id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00942v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00942v2
|
LLaVA Finds Free Lunch: Teaching Human Behavior Improves Content Understanding Abilities Of LLMs
| 2024-05-02T02:04:01 | 2024-05-16T21:52:02 |
Somesh Singh, Harini S I, Yaman K Singla, Veeky Baths, Rajiv Ratn Shah, Changyou Chen, Balaji Krishnamurthy
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Communication is defined as "Who says what to whom with what effect." A
message from a communicator generates downstream receiver effects, also known
as behavior. Receiver behavior, being a downstream effect of the message,
carries rich signals about it. Even after carrying signals about the message,
the behavior data is often ignored while training large language models. We
show that training LLMs on receiver behavior can actually help improve their
content-understanding abilities. Specifically, we show that training LLMs to
predict the receiver behavior of likes and comments improves the LLM's
performance on a wide variety of downstream content understanding tasks. We
show this performance increase over 40 video and image understanding tasks over
23 benchmark datasets across both 0-shot and fine-tuning settings,
outperforming many supervised baselines. Moreover, since receiver behavior,
such as likes and comments, is collected by default on the internet and does
not need any human annotations to be useful, the performance improvement we get
after training on this data is essentially free-lunch. We release the receiver
behavior cleaned comments and likes of 750k images and videos collected from
multiple platforms along with our instruction-tuning data.
|
[
-0.3945932984,
-0.5488936901,
0.4529958367,
0.278131485,
-0.6731805801,
-0.0352321565,
-0.4275873005,
-0.6370165944,
0.3363035321,
0.3489234447,
-0.5643501282,
-0.3110569417,
-0.9157882929,
-0.1431515962,
-0.5586033463,
1.2125188112,
0.3101359904,
0.2384675443,
-0.3772261739,
0.0289771166,
-0.4949389696,
-0.1688751578,
-1.0114260912,
-0.6407094002,
0.8892015219,
0.5574309826,
0.2574949265,
0.6510710716,
0.4206689,
0.3213456869,
-0.1506916881,
0.1596510708,
-0.9525816441,
0.1572371423,
-0.1081110463,
-0.7231463194,
-0.2724076211,
0.0012416039,
0.5894371271,
0.4427770376,
-0.2435614467,
0.1729111075,
0.2333897799,
1.0304638147,
-0.5556833744,
0.3103550076,
-0.6894265413,
0.0183341652,
0.0044452827,
-0.5096170306,
-0.4737244248,
-0.1321346909,
-0.0299872644,
-0.7681455612,
0.0768193007,
-0.1662183106,
0.8365331888,
0.4299289882,
-0.6068063974,
-0.3655894399,
-0.6695349216,
0.7854610085,
-0.2187076807,
0.5967358351,
0.5008273125,
0.1209044605,
-0.4227566421,
-0.2929268777,
-0.5609734654,
0.2634481788,
0.0023357393,
0.1603124142,
-0.1777465791,
0.2170218229,
0.1349704117,
0.3724561036,
-0.2850096822,
0.0175930895,
-0.2902274132,
-0.0999980122,
0.6026856899,
0.0994776785,
0.193081677,
-0.0800129175,
-0.1596051455,
-0.128569603,
-0.7390373945,
0.4707291722,
0.2291988432,
0.0114533622,
-0.1580792069,
0.3719316125,
-0.3649488389,
0.4651275277,
0.1494683474,
-0.2320016176,
0.2479799688,
-0.0360668898,
-0.3190356493,
-0.1460497081,
0.4775892794,
0.5479353666,
0.6242439747,
-0.3224434555,
-0.1307113767,
-0.0311188716,
0.322787106,
-0.774056077,
-0.1651331186,
-0.0721455812,
-0.628587842,
-0.283293277,
0.1255732775,
-0.5016323328,
-0.6231964827,
-0.4090664387,
0.2457436323,
-0.3005416989,
-0.3073408902,
0.2156917751,
-0.2387535572,
0.743453145,
0.6011059284,
-1.2525821924,
0.4277075529,
0.7655466795,
0.6673231125,
-0.1316480637,
-0.1340613216,
-1.1231911182,
0.3778064549,
-0.3037017584,
1.1913983822,
-0.4622402787,
-0.355283618,
-0.1572293788,
0.1676478088,
-0.157425791,
-0.5756749511,
0.2368677855,
-0.8304291964,
-0.3022634685,
-0.4816136062,
-0.5221735239,
-0.120717302,
0.421997726,
-0.4888460338,
0.6671669483,
-0.1983529329,
-0.6848919392,
0.4005116224,
-0.5149724483,
-0.5483279824,
0.0049687661,
-0.1231693029,
-0.1166846529,
0.2207828462,
0.1962593049,
0.3953985274,
0.3147214055,
0.0122688143,
-0.0119757131,
-0.6991180778,
0.5219472647,
-0.0703743696,
0.4145353138,
0.0631463602,
-0.2196886539,
0.0843638405,
-0.4224946797,
-0.1831428856,
0.0997294039,
-0.8555013537,
-0.2970965803,
0.2591761351,
-0.5054380298,
-0.0046632434,
-0.2365610898,
-0.6876131296,
0.2315626144,
-0.188528806,
0.0616371408,
0.9275696278,
0.1427358091,
0.6293833256,
-0.4406933486,
0.3880390227,
0.0640524328,
0.2485761493,
-0.3320079446,
-0.5562556982,
-0.9646205902,
-0.2084351331,
-0.3511680961,
0.4234164953,
-0.6933318377,
-0.3544671535,
-0.3585276008,
-0.1672495157,
-0.6233494878,
0.7165198326,
0.5171040297,
0.4253097177,
0.1639191061,
-0.5362284184,
-0.6507946253,
-0.5643693209,
-0.4984770715,
-0.0788776353,
-0.121291548,
0.4065564275,
0.2005855292,
-0.1060742885,
0.5498195887,
-0.4123029411,
-0.1696824133,
-0.4061221182,
0.0112334043,
0.003401693,
0.0698532909,
0.3040065765,
-0.4795637429,
-0.4844574332,
-0.419676125,
-0.7091599107,
0.2138017118,
0.0902721733,
-0.2806648612,
0.2084092349,
0.3556839824,
-0.7076853514,
0.4021973014,
0.4744924307,
-0.3309147954,
0.3040704727,
-0.0274674743,
0.1857936233,
-0.6836057901,
-0.4787667394,
0.2124842703,
-0.4214511514,
-0.4954891801,
-0.259822309,
-0.1459289342,
0.0457902811,
-0.8001111746,
0.3951743245,
-0.3652175069,
-0.5138571262,
-0.3896350861,
0.1846349984,
-0.0960647985,
0.4917936623,
0.283228159,
0.9632641077,
0.4254645705,
-0.9230392575,
0.2789540887,
0.3551156521,
-0.6021180749,
0.6930882931,
-0.4924904704,
0.3545698524,
-0.4419640005,
0.2992167473,
-1.015583396,
-0.1466602087,
0.4026507139,
-0.6949295998,
0.3340905905,
-0.281621933,
-0.4766483307,
-0.0370724797,
-0.5529990196,
-0.1857751012,
0.488651216,
-0.6645668745,
0.2753506303,
0.3094745874,
0.12628901,
-0.6595911384,
-0.8908125162,
0.0744193196,
-0.0536551476,
-0.5533431172,
0.0584368408,
-0.2966932952,
-0.1778762192,
-0.0794150457,
-0.0348893069,
0.0469100252,
0.3281615078,
0.3620589972,
0.0971539468,
0.0239240304,
0.4053066373,
-0.1487969309,
-0.0868530869,
0.3438586593,
-0.1915792227,
0.4399597943,
-0.1659386903,
-0.0996244848,
-0.596716702,
0.0091376482,
0.0549574941,
0.090024814,
0.8201975226,
0.6493529081,
0.256288439,
-0.1407413781,
-0.2834076583,
-0.6061636209,
-0.5596005917,
0.1901499033,
-0.1306349039,
-0.8754667044,
0.0905628651,
0.1233376861,
0.0136754811,
-0.2116482854,
0.1569552124,
-0.8063752055,
0.9688662887,
0.8524594903,
0.0955733657,
0.9934902191,
-0.3924846351,
0.0936255306,
-1.0685944557,
-0.5308480859,
-0.061990805,
-0.5513776541,
-0.6659319997,
-0.3767006397,
0.0727167875,
-0.2026419789,
-0.2323043644,
-0.0691534877,
-0.2444607317,
0.6831719875,
0.5639514923,
0.4232909083,
0.6415144801,
0.3943231702,
0.1290175468,
-0.2624754012,
-0.3649806976,
-0.4633117616,
1.0775257349,
0.2770410776,
1.1191942692,
0.1807608306,
0.8487929106,
0.5112069845,
0.6422673464,
-1.1575138569,
0.7977315187,
-0.1877272725,
-0.2612552643,
0.0283720791,
-0.3738176823,
-1.041200161,
0.1323946416,
-0.1981467754,
-0.910874486,
-0.0958378986,
0.4495423436,
0.1376375854,
0.4334830046,
-0.6750953197,
0.3416299522,
-0.2672052383,
-0.5089203119,
-0.5841491222,
-0.472992897,
0.3849841952,
0.3756343722,
0.3048554659,
-0.1529955864,
-0.1565981358,
0.8993925452,
-0.0189849027,
1.070237875,
-0.3606428802,
-0.1830472052,
0.3396470547,
0.16990453,
0.3909354806,
0.0917696431,
0.0054810834,
-0.0802914426,
-0.3316566348,
-0.4200962782,
-0.7443460822,
0.6260639429,
-0.9836150408,
-0.7568005323,
-0.1894590855,
-0.5488656759,
-0.2218630314,
-0.0203041807,
-0.0029514665,
0.1532223672,
0.1044730395,
0.4419202209,
1.0738744736,
-0.1406131089,
0.4288663566,
0.8640330434,
-0.0132406708,
-0.3054439425,
0.9738082886,
-0.2347120792,
0.2302460968,
0.4747200608,
-0.0277531818,
-0.2175839245,
-0.2773678899,
-0.2390745431,
0.4862410426,
-1.0466125011,
-0.1144497767,
-0.6797146201,
0.0670357198,
-0.2070494294,
-0.1013917774,
-0.1675965339,
-0.2404231727,
-0.3774992824,
-0.2788719535,
0.418961525,
1.0237803459,
-0.1147237122,
0.7497805953,
-0.7531201839,
0.1853096187,
0.5297298431,
0.6853768229,
0.3076500893,
-0.6886865497,
-0.4079301953,
0.1597549766,
-0.6688627601,
-0.7200689316,
0.1426421255,
0.3848952055,
0.6222891808,
0.4944291115,
-0.3098311424,
0.5647165775,
-0.0248611085,
0.5780991912,
-0.000299626,
-0.8798465729,
0.7310339212,
-0.3127759099,
0.1918742955,
0.2475548983,
0.4067400992,
-0.7943334579,
-0.3013716936,
-0.3004644811,
-0.4145419896,
0.7292197943,
0.0145127643,
0.5349981189,
-0.2781272531,
0.5246472955,
-0.0211947896,
0.3977533579,
-0.8672140837,
-0.1861153394,
-0.3740909696,
0.0409835875,
-0.0555423275,
-0.4993917346,
0.0355179049,
-0.4012707174,
0.7504839897,
-0.0898346007,
0.6213644147,
0.0682121441,
-0.4358137846,
-0.3535056114,
0.3145963252,
0.4492017925,
0.342466712,
-0.3396112323,
0.2187206298,
0.0575825237,
-0.658995688,
0.2818770409,
-0.4819923639,
0.0000373966,
-0.308700949,
0.3878645897,
0.6833884716,
0.478883028,
-0.70532763,
0.5681582093,
-0.4817298055,
-0.3055401444,
-0.1115135774,
0.5426504016,
0.3954647779,
0.3133470714,
0.2663048506,
-0.2211358845,
0.0593917817,
-0.4978041947,
0.2136033028,
0.4551615119,
-0.3755126297,
-0.462897867,
0.3442441821,
0.3897827864,
-0.1646142453,
0.9220753312,
-0.1233132556,
-0.2685207129,
0.7107722759,
0.6383620501,
0.6771594286,
0.0098288078,
0.5571825504,
0.1416734904,
0.2184836268,
0.1170074046,
0.4720849693,
-0.5244184136,
-0.8992008567,
-0.6790211797,
-0.5094764233,
-0.5027849674,
0.0632830709,
-0.6767816544,
0.2286138833,
-0.3583066761,
0.0009634327,
-0.0639162809,
0.1867419183,
-0.9204339981,
0.1181597486,
0.3244350851,
0.9324530363,
-0.8503001332,
0.9474755526,
1.0080962181,
-0.3515524864,
-0.7811273932,
0.0135647263,
-0.0818470567,
-1.1213550568,
0.9753917456,
0.3657524586,
-0.3705066144,
0.0590789616,
-0.7175476551,
-0.9330365062,
1.1340485811,
0.4026077986,
-0.6057738066,
0.2314643264,
0.048992753,
0.5290654898,
-0.3510988951,
0.3100381792,
0.3608503342,
0.2089990079,
0.3836794198,
-0.4528061748,
-0.1175904498,
-0.2145972848,
-0.109280929,
0.1557778269,
-0.6988304853,
0.4392646551,
-0.6195591092,
-0.1910483837,
-0.220802933,
0.5582719445,
0.1362867653,
0.5808364153,
0.6251173019,
0.4604616463,
0.6536061764,
0.1336405128,
1.1013950109,
0.0320734419,
0.1912310719,
1.0641590357,
0.0570316464,
0.8551249504,
0.7572501898,
0.0759603381,
0.9624788761,
0.742104888,
0.2136640549,
0.6896893382,
0.0792001337,
-0.3287223577,
-0.3213095665,
-0.4044995606,
0.050420247,
0.4716384709,
0.5577465296,
-0.2889230847,
-0.1982436478,
0.1227796674,
0.0466331467,
0.0495539866,
-0.3762141466,
1.1590297222,
0.2113797814,
-0.5963370204,
0.6196928024,
-0.3960235119,
0.8130949736,
-0.3424008489,
0.056330096,
-0.5623537302,
0.1499528289,
-0.4957558513,
-1.0760893822,
0.4119769931,
0.1057868898,
-0.1090123281,
-0.2389838398,
0.8740956187,
-0.267813921,
0.1801237762,
0.5107986331,
0.3672806025,
0.3955877125,
-0.0209007245,
-0.3850055933,
0.2609556317,
-0.1518519223,
-0.4708093107,
0.5352166891,
0.0929364115,
0.0441301689,
0.9297037125,
0.7088724375,
0.0942735821,
-0.0999461859,
0.0641288012,
1.1039177179,
-0.7010957599,
-0.2886379361,
-0.7118387222,
0.3941714466,
-0.1057958007,
0.2467091978,
0.6574604511,
0.2799510956,
1.1422117949,
-0.1659808159,
0.6740672588,
0.2010583133,
0.2356580794,
-0.3220205903,
0.3030385077,
-0.522796452,
0.3594863415,
-0.0112665975,
-0.7490086555,
-0.0319703259,
0.4575716853,
-0.6890681386,
-0.1627219319,
0.4537070096,
0.722170949,
-0.1134581119,
-0.0316075832,
0.2651229501,
0.0221865401,
0.5197274685,
0.4130347967,
0.9468114376,
-0.1229363382,
0.9573577046,
-0.4359027147,
-0.1060293168,
-0.3814215064,
-0.7952660918,
-1.1314871311,
-0.1192246303,
-0.0467367992,
-0.30879125,
0.3699852228,
0.7706580162,
0.8654907346,
-0.395308286,
-0.3604312539,
-0.1565676928,
0.4931420982,
-0.1701230705,
-0.2562214732,
-0.0151354689,
-0.486823082,
-0.4909722209,
0.1966429949,
0.3090966344,
0.0518995821,
0.0468724668,
-0.4188280106,
-0.160886988,
0.1918264329,
0.8475564718,
0.346645087,
-0.4443324208,
-0.3253075778,
0.2334414423,
-0.0452505089,
0.2113185823,
0.9156424999,
-0.8252287507,
0.5004597902,
0.29476583,
0.620208919,
0.7696242332,
0.067522943,
0.2856761217,
-0.8803682327,
0.3109114468,
-0.2588205636,
0.1783685982,
0.6774998903,
-0.5718480349,
0.3254795074,
0.3421368897,
-0.5927612185,
-0.464261651,
0.3688109517,
-0.765291214,
-0.0276176464,
1.1352570057,
-0.0798354745,
-0.5284343362,
0.1437794715,
-0.1649322212,
0.396356076,
-0.7176741362,
1.0580211878,
0.4660506845,
-0.3680889308,
-0.6587411165,
-0.7405921221,
0.4813256562,
0.50555861,
-0.9464998245,
-0.3028062582,
0.1630324423,
0.7460555434,
-0.5094401836,
0.8924289942,
0.1826682985,
0.4062357247,
-0.4909802675,
0.0649319142,
-0.0750541538,
-0.2647259831,
-0.2121525556,
-0.5537107587,
0.3764970899,
-0.5560413599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00903v1
|
A Named Entity Recognition and Topic Modeling-based Solution for Locating and Better Assessment of Natural Disasters in Social Media
| 2024-05-01T23:19:49 | 2024-05-01T23:19:49 |
Ayaz Mehmood, Muhammad Tayyab Zamir, Muhammad Asif Ayub, Nasir Ahmad, Kashif Ahmad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Over the last decade, similar to other application domains, social media
content has been proven very effective in disaster informatics. However, due to
the unstructured nature of the data, several challenges are associated with
disaster analysis in social media content. To fully explore the potential of
social media content in disaster informatics, access to relevant content and
the correct geo-location information is very critical. In this paper, we
propose a three-step solution to tackling these challenges. Firstly, the
proposed solution aims to classify social media posts into relevant and
irrelevant posts followed by the automatic extraction of location information
from the posts' text through Named Entity Recognition (NER) analysis. Finally,
to quickly analyze the topics covered in large volumes of social media posts,
we perform topic modeling resulting in a list of top keywords, that highlight
the issues discussed in the tweet. For the Relevant Classification of Twitter
Posts (RCTP), we proposed a merit-based fusion framework combining the
capabilities of four different models namely BERT, RoBERTa, Distil BERT, and
ALBERT obtaining the highest F1-score of 0.933 on a benchmark dataset. For the
Location Extraction from Twitter Text (LETT), we evaluated four models namely
BERT, RoBERTa, Distil BERTA, and Electra in an NER framework obtaining the
highest F1-score of 0.960. For topic modeling, we used the BERTopic library to
discover the hidden topic patterns in the relevant tweets. The experimental
results of all the components of the proposed end-to-end solution are very
encouraging and hint at the potential of social media content and NLP in
disaster management.
|
[
-0.494110018,
-0.8725449443,
0.6949889064,
0.5445370078,
-0.4531260133,
0.408326894,
-0.1749628037,
-0.3110327721,
0.6018322706,
0.4322298169,
-0.3399755955,
-0.4508871436,
-0.8010066748,
0.1571799666,
-0.8190281987,
0.7581498027,
-0.1623010784,
-0.2516399324,
0.2372905314,
0.0554488078,
-0.4211241007,
-0.0391045958,
-0.8905565143,
0.2206926495,
0.4197134376,
0.3279802799,
0.3443861306,
0.1966218352,
1.025562644,
0.332785964,
-0.1675258279,
0.0160702765,
-0.4860676229,
-0.030272929,
-0.6320031285,
0.2612829804,
-0.0107478146,
-0.2660422921,
0.6450728774,
0.2881093919,
-0.1673969626,
0.0852962881,
0.1570064574,
0.3376140594,
-0.4145364165,
-0.1987183392,
-0.6807708144,
-0.2747661471,
-0.0038198356,
-0.6639520526,
0.0251609962,
-0.7039326429,
0.5581300259,
-0.1882813722,
0.6051466465,
-0.0079543749,
1.0358593464,
0.3149839938,
-0.4143739343,
-0.1700348109,
-0.898293376,
0.7667405009,
-0.4070560336,
0.4060022533,
0.1979357004,
0.4259035885,
-0.2671894431,
-0.2381634116,
-0.5023177266,
0.3876541257,
0.1874857396,
-0.2116113305,
-0.0280942656,
-0.2594679594,
0.0595739149,
0.1964219213,
-0.5682369471,
-0.0338461436,
-0.2348919958,
-0.2845300138,
0.7878232598,
0.030537568,
0.5150004625,
-0.9562339187,
-0.3580009341,
0.0990367755,
-0.5386118293,
-0.2605424225,
0.0961306468,
0.6325898767,
-0.482483238,
0.4895299673,
-0.3215387464,
0.5172841549,
-0.1857168823,
-0.3696563244,
-0.027977258,
-0.1894778758,
-0.0050713792,
0.2785960734,
0.7638477087,
0.4683207273,
-0.0975805297,
-0.1948638558,
-0.2276469618,
-0.2433444113,
0.4050059021,
-0.6214200854,
-0.1011565775,
0.2653988302,
-0.5606315732,
-0.4221437275,
0.1642739773,
-0.8609709144,
-0.8473894596,
-0.2397467941,
0.4368026853,
-0.4629794657,
-0.5183187127,
-0.0930433199,
-0.1000571251,
0.0380715989,
0.6188830733,
-0.591245234,
0.0073030354,
0.6909902692,
1.2315282822,
-0.0515435748,
0.1749654412,
-0.1971351206,
0.1106604859,
-0.0103853084,
1.2900575399,
-0.2451172322,
-0.0933924764,
0.0244537424,
0.0854321346,
0.0872638524,
-0.1648008674,
0.7857366204,
-0.5940050483,
-0.0706583411,
-0.6034392715,
-0.3217440248,
-0.4654597938,
0.3916775286,
-0.8590561748,
0.8725680709,
0.170015201,
-1.274061203,
0.340321362,
-0.6283369064,
-0.3622178435,
0.2238743305,
0.0399487019,
-0.3705922961,
0.1388479769,
0.4080162942,
0.5809999108,
-0.7048370242,
0.5894764662,
-0.5421460271,
-0.3681233823,
-0.1226387024,
-0.2596332431,
0.5456603169,
0.0282367524,
-0.35530743,
0.0456680618,
-0.5700798631,
-0.0660054311,
0.2880260944,
-0.2622285187,
-0.5041313171,
0.2336068451,
0.3577569425,
0.2161765397,
0.0010788712,
-0.4017006755,
-0.1279599667,
-0.1599203944,
0.3211598694,
0.5814453363,
0.6405440569,
0.5526330471,
-0.1862323582,
0.1373263747,
-0.154196173,
-0.0142048663,
0.2968534231,
-0.3935923278,
-0.5538037419,
0.0069429595,
0.5516176224,
0.6745707989,
-0.8986400366,
0.3267359734,
-0.5394701362,
-0.6439919472,
-0.3475575447,
-0.3367175758,
-0.312110126,
0.6352011561,
0.4926678538,
0.1435294151,
-0.8323239088,
-0.6048284769,
0.0522083901,
-0.2703477442,
-0.0392720029,
0.0278689191,
0.47986871,
-0.145245105,
1.0316319466,
-0.3244458139,
-0.1047956049,
-0.5214006901,
0.3481441736,
0.1517953277,
0.0750852972,
0.6110414863,
-1.3685158491,
-0.3604823649,
-0.0653994679,
-0.7853171229,
-0.1718045026,
-0.0179941393,
-0.1498811543,
0.1271071285,
-0.1891662776,
-0.3889613152,
0.54862535,
0.1262964308,
-0.0419134088,
0.1756282002,
0.362631768,
0.5887861252,
-1.3892548084,
0.0725119039,
0.2680341899,
-0.0432963371,
-0.6249830723,
-0.2247229517,
0.0421835631,
-0.3589491248,
-0.4610870481,
0.606003046,
-0.1661860943,
-0.2442575842,
-0.4245438576,
0.1555447727,
-0.399864614,
-0.1615285277,
0.3937089741,
0.2381407022,
0.6531652808,
-0.5715243816,
0.3595710695,
0.0597734973,
-0.278772831,
0.4710481763,
-0.5051473975,
-0.1765335351,
-0.3746627867,
0.1419556886,
-0.7478447556,
-0.5028256774,
0.3924832642,
-0.5024473667,
0.0410740785,
-0.2524019778,
-0.5874685645,
-0.5712665319,
-0.2259048522,
-0.0722453669,
0.1647930145,
-0.3033373654,
0.7656632066,
0.585072279,
-0.4795584381,
-0.3850287497,
-0.0977439955,
0.1881967336,
-0.6138094068,
-0.5371211767,
0.606153965,
0.0980211794,
-0.1764593422,
0.3205834031,
-0.2762658298,
-0.3070125878,
0.3522412479,
0.3637306988,
0.0552654043,
-0.020729702,
0.0873806849,
-0.0729484856,
-0.2027608901,
-0.2559911013,
0.0974018201,
0.6698775291,
-0.0040049525,
0.036716748,
-0.3693335652,
0.5028678775,
0.2673342228,
-0.2040482908,
0.8695716858,
0.5044462085,
-1.0858359337,
0.0724678934,
-0.68484658,
-0.0938991457,
-0.4097207785,
-0.0081762383,
0.1702144593,
-0.7629178166,
0.6598621011,
-0.2265334725,
0.0384127758,
0.5402287245,
0.233863771,
-0.2307597548,
0.4345039427,
0.8822895288,
-0.3279888928,
0.4241625071,
-0.2520471215,
0.6649294496,
-0.303008914,
-0.1623983979,
-0.4978730977,
-0.1787979305,
-0.4306412935,
-0.2609807551,
0.1503112316,
0.1062553227,
0.0120911244,
0.687535882,
-0.4981727898,
0.2508051693,
0.2071469128,
0.1227930039,
0.0080577154,
0.3338733017,
0.3810304403,
-0.1673083454,
-0.4560599029,
-0.7216037512,
0.5278499126,
0.3563589454,
0.4759861827,
0.1883784831,
1.2468374968,
0.3860125542,
0.6565515399,
-0.3751568198,
0.5842450857,
0.166905269,
-0.5360419154,
-0.4535427392,
-0.5966380835,
-0.3926742971,
-0.0884522274,
-0.3500634432,
-0.7382894158,
0.1743817329,
-0.2571509182,
-0.7059136033,
0.4962229431,
-0.4201229513,
0.4656358361,
-0.1357564032,
-0.0371452607,
-0.0732653439,
-0.4960671663,
0.1736599356,
-0.2587746084,
0.4017703235,
-0.2596178353,
0.2067149431,
0.6266530156,
-0.1978598237,
0.4078803957,
-0.202452451,
-0.1074708551,
0.5760675073,
-0.0588541776,
0.3046553731,
0.4242090881,
-0.2288409919,
0.1252939403,
-0.5179443955,
-0.1235290095,
-0.5199753046,
0.922092855,
-0.5028952956,
-0.3141767383,
-0.4491244853,
-0.2197522968,
0.1666200161,
0.3243667483,
0.3415262401,
0.4473074079,
-0.1839648932,
0.0657455772,
0.6289895773,
-0.3605490029,
0.8189626932,
0.6598415971,
0.2282723337,
-0.4923044443,
1.2289104462,
0.3578616977,
-0.4650340974,
0.7591708899,
-0.1459678262,
-0.2927503288,
-0.7040694952,
-0.0261187069,
0.2681942284,
-0.4833684564,
-0.6459203959,
-1.0511907339,
-0.4873268902,
-0.4088028669,
-0.4230911136,
-0.3494479656,
-0.1099237129,
-0.386441499,
-0.2950962484,
0.3508961499,
0.4348042905,
-0.3211467862,
0.2467712462,
-0.7725048661,
0.5388659239,
-0.1910544783,
0.4978283346,
-0.0386438705,
-0.2123202831,
-0.0152649814,
0.0676210001,
-0.3563718498,
-1.1474429369,
0.4647097588,
-0.1048859581,
0.2770340741,
0.479563266,
0.3272635639,
0.6391296387,
-0.4282175601,
0.4121923149,
-0.0003145337,
-0.5819962621,
0.9313499331,
-0.5737733841,
-0.2549006343,
0.6147946119,
0.7398801446,
-0.5352179408,
-0.3016400635,
-0.6547922492,
-0.8504114151,
0.4777223766,
0.454272449,
-0.071829088,
-0.2893741429,
0.1831014454,
-0.2145561576,
-0.0680746585,
-0.8075252771,
0.0097892368,
-0.0957260802,
0.0492989123,
0.3260988593,
-0.3847959638,
0.1705177277,
0.0599838048,
0.6910081506,
0.2722774148,
0.3306441903,
0.1526487172,
-0.0167861693,
-0.2120753378,
0.120877035,
0.2425378412,
0.4958000481,
-0.6316352487,
0.0132832183,
0.1085264012,
-0.1848076135,
0.0869307593,
0.6234221458,
-0.2861169279,
0.2599681318,
0.4931617379,
0.2650041878,
0.5096924901,
-0.382941395,
0.3345118761,
-0.236737445,
0.14026317,
-0.4570169747,
-0.1326060593,
0.1837138534,
0.4265480042,
0.7094771266,
-0.0750791878,
0.4087076783,
-0.2307390869,
0.3885362446,
0.0403037593,
-0.3199259639,
-0.1176650152,
0.3850280643,
0.275152564,
-0.500541091,
0.7140786648,
-0.3997659385,
-0.6176406145,
0.6206992865,
0.2470681071,
0.8611835241,
-0.6661457419,
0.7397438884,
0.6346151233,
0.4275632203,
-0.2617691755,
0.7466020584,
0.1564412713,
-0.6412473321,
-0.1608956307,
-0.8629136682,
-0.0552615225,
0.2107953131,
-0.3612870872,
0.6965162754,
-0.4682714641,
-0.2952983975,
0.2304949462,
0.0378431454,
-0.5558803678,
0.3292578757,
0.1077618524,
0.7773965001,
-0.9356248379,
0.145975098,
0.7201989293,
-0.2645737231,
-0.7613338232,
0.3251712024,
-0.0926396772,
-0.0872047469,
0.3118827343,
0.4161154032,
0.4312787354,
0.078910999,
-0.4843569994,
-1.2623806,
1.0911084414,
0.2646830082,
-0.254276365,
-0.1704561263,
0.2018616498,
0.4254679084,
-0.1612063795,
0.126698032,
0.0976983607,
0.3112201393,
0.1388244033,
-0.7742821574,
0.1219302192,
-0.1219634935,
0.1132602692,
0.5768604875,
-0.4470546842,
0.2742745876,
-0.3328966796,
-0.5763891339,
-0.2613266408,
0.7085784078,
0.2660880089,
0.5738728642,
0.4265072644,
0.5851687789,
0.5287418365,
-0.2133114636,
0.9857218266,
0.0654180124,
0.8606088161,
0.8098582625,
-0.1346439123,
0.8026896119,
0.2190305442,
0.1233721823,
0.2570379972,
1.109690547,
0.0805091187,
1.0363175869,
-0.0388456658,
-0.3007730842,
-0.1755326092,
-0.5096508265,
-0.3307205737,
0.2131583691,
0.5090840459,
-0.4389082193,
-0.7978681922,
-0.023455726,
-0.1202267259,
-0.2587508857,
-0.2720286548,
0.5395231247,
0.0958796293,
-0.1504496038,
0.1829369664,
0.31975016,
0.3075582683,
-0.2920701206,
-0.302207619,
-0.0501814745,
-0.49099648,
-0.2411038131,
-0.7410758734,
0.7856146097,
0.0374125056,
-0.2526156604,
-0.0568302087,
1.0819606781,
-0.1030238569,
-0.7008744478,
0.3347395062,
0.2350498587,
0.0060908012,
-0.3424462974,
-0.4976765215,
0.1984872371,
-0.2031199336,
-0.0285588577,
-0.0294350255,
0.5208162069,
-0.2311094701,
0.6882193089,
0.4764784873,
-0.1766041666,
-0.397711426,
0.0921177119,
0.8885443807,
-0.8174445033,
-0.6702005863,
-0.8799683452,
0.4959531128,
-0.4052474499,
-0.0381178483,
0.4470647275,
0.3640293181,
0.2654244006,
0.209722355,
0.8262481689,
-0.7156540155,
0.8545675278,
-0.0574378222,
0.7370468974,
-0.552411139,
0.2904902697,
-0.9031787515,
-1.1682664156,
-0.3832304776,
0.5550143123,
-0.449593097,
-0.2281340659,
0.4252782464,
0.5175146461,
-0.1978650838,
0.1994159222,
-0.2151914388,
-0.0914792493,
0.2795190215,
0.3418566287,
0.8282876015,
-0.4067138731,
0.2769200504,
-0.3710724711,
-0.1810404956,
-0.4476880431,
-0.9678148627,
-0.834584713,
-0.7960502505,
-0.4465928674,
-0.1283901036,
0.0054524592,
0.7328077555,
0.4359878004,
-0.8172273636,
0.4426973164,
-0.0681714416,
0.6685652137,
0.1500249803,
-0.329012692,
0.5715736151,
0.3413724601,
-0.2083580792,
0.1332428604,
0.5831735134,
0.2174547762,
0.0283005536,
0.2997477353,
-0.2715081871,
-0.0898240656,
0.4316854775,
0.1937168092,
-0.7024450302,
-0.534982264,
-0.0083444612,
0.0029414471,
-0.3188185692,
0.5442574024,
-0.5257688165,
0.0252031535,
0.532786727,
0.8138265014,
-0.0487608016,
0.2817783654,
0.2539011836,
-0.5291103125,
-0.212849468,
0.2239391506,
0.3264361918,
0.7564131021,
-0.64016819,
0.723692894,
0.2669234872,
-0.2427376211,
-0.9796825051,
-0.1252185404,
-0.8498020768,
0.0688617006,
1.121771574,
0.1866290867,
-0.0168248583,
-0.2284458429,
-0.0896117985,
0.4372537434,
-0.5158191919,
1.3174325228,
0.6545580029,
0.1337154657,
-0.5896504521,
-0.633959949,
0.259432286,
-0.2166900784,
-0.7631129622,
-0.3168028593,
0.2139365673,
0.5022665858,
0.4368855655,
0.7329449058,
0.0226529315,
0.1993997395,
-0.5516679287,
-0.0951145813,
0.5897094607,
-0.6725476384,
-0.0200527962,
0.2963230908,
-0.4875289798,
0.0756646916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00899v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00899v2
|
Characterising the Creative Process in Humans and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-01T23:06:46 | 2024-06-05T19:15:43 |
Surabhi S. Nath, Peter Dayan, Claire Stevenson
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Large language models appear quite creative, often performing on par with the
average human on creative tasks. However, research on LLM creativity has
focused solely on \textit{products}, with little attention on the creative
\textit{process}. Process analyses of human creativity often require hand-coded
categories or exploit response times, which do not apply to LLMs. We provide an
automated method to characterise how humans and LLMs explore semantic spaces on
the Alternate Uses Task, and contrast with behaviour in a Verbal Fluency Task.
We use sentence embeddings to identify response categories and compute semantic
similarities, which we use to generate jump profiles. Our results corroborate
earlier work in humans reporting both persistent (deep search in few semantic
spaces) and flexible (broad search across multiple semantic spaces) pathways to
creativity, where both pathways lead to similar creativity scores. LLMs were
found to be biased towards either persistent or flexible paths, that varied
across tasks. Though LLMs as a population match human profiles, their
relationship with creativity is different, where the more flexible models score
higher on creativity. Our dataset and scripts are available on
\href{https://github.com/surabhisnath/Creative_Process}{GitHub}.
|
[
-0.3683811128,
-1.0185098648,
0.72400105,
0.2836951613,
0.0550370291,
0.4526054263,
-0.3788076043,
-0.4662457705,
0.4372241497,
0.4646264911,
-0.9342350364,
-0.513228178,
-0.3761904538,
0.1524244547,
-0.2559912205,
0.4366141558,
-0.087125361,
-0.213802442,
-0.305730015,
-0.0551445447,
-0.4083409011,
-0.2662924826,
-0.5181078315,
-0.4362998903,
0.9800964594,
0.4421919882,
0.7770631909,
0.3792048097,
0.2461280525,
0.3764442801,
-0.3735235929,
0.0878347009,
-0.6142085791,
0.2276750356,
-0.4641917944,
-0.3094067276,
-0.1937636882,
0.2786501646,
0.3430345654,
0.7171606421,
-0.0839178562,
0.0692512318,
-0.0056959582,
0.6015341282,
-0.2114914805,
-0.1066415012,
-0.6015095711,
0.073027581,
-0.5379751921,
-0.3155080676,
-0.1803958863,
-0.2473128289,
-0.0082765464,
-0.552303791,
0.4323497117,
0.0048651625,
0.4692078829,
0.1417867243,
-0.3387658894,
-0.6344780922,
-0.7979934812,
0.5975056887,
-0.558062613,
0.118008092,
0.0662980527,
0.2206837684,
-0.4756345749,
-0.6696828604,
-0.7518372536,
-0.4648012221,
0.2417955995,
-0.0988867879,
0.0135310292,
-0.1121319607,
0.4405014217,
0.3955364823,
-0.7505052686,
0.3397191167,
-0.181779325,
-0.1577247679,
0.8586885929,
0.4921514988,
0.5915161967,
0.1018161699,
-0.3034289181,
-0.2515216172,
-0.4865589738,
0.3299002647,
0.6485763788,
-0.0247896388,
0.2177736163,
1.0545188189,
-0.375176698,
0.5213245749,
-0.2095298469,
-0.1281971335,
0.4059914052,
-0.3053978086,
0.0522344448,
-0.5657448769,
0.7540863156,
0.2649792433,
0.4786673784,
-0.4212191403,
-0.427588135,
0.1439361423,
0.372644484,
-0.4292641878,
-0.0607671738,
-0.0711207166,
-0.245790422,
0.014447974,
0.0243000444,
-0.3100144863,
-0.5127751827,
-0.290656358,
0.3584957719,
-0.3593840003,
-0.2312145382,
0.4006681442,
-0.4872753024,
0.0805839226,
0.0709809214,
-0.7111179233,
0.2866464257,
0.7540892959,
0.7872780561,
-0.5035902858,
-0.5796580315,
-0.1254523993,
-0.2292003334,
-0.3207260668,
0.9452546239,
-0.5576815009,
-0.251357317,
-0.2184647024,
-0.0205119736,
-0.038364917,
-0.7182548642,
0.5545372367,
-0.6433457136,
0.0877508894,
-0.2456204444,
-0.6716926098,
-0.1696542948,
-0.0007949541,
-0.9031444192,
0.8775791526,
0.1323879957,
-0.6557879448,
0.6203777194,
-0.8393207192,
-0.3282272816,
0.305129081,
-0.2387627363,
-0.0658428669,
0.3414229155,
-0.0972468853,
0.5259333253,
-0.2007273436,
0.2608308196,
-0.5052121878,
-0.4917155504,
0.864561975,
-0.1903738678,
0.7630907893,
0.2559173703,
-0.1417804807,
0.303134203,
-0.93486619,
-0.0014623046,
0.2284372896,
-0.5149896741,
-0.1412239373,
-0.0062990058,
0.1678511649,
0.6202244759,
0.3078499734,
-0.5405910611,
0.3768537343,
-0.5466490388,
0.4941548109,
0.5195153952,
0.278852582,
0.3551512957,
-0.5810317397,
0.7043612003,
-0.1357040107,
-0.176843822,
0.100219436,
-0.8243616223,
-0.5275391936,
-0.3058390617,
-0.200341478,
0.4852992892,
-0.3878857791,
0.6265527606,
-0.2487419099,
-0.6195101738,
-0.4392887056,
0.6089811921,
-0.034733329,
0.2129050642,
-0.0216694083,
-0.6563321352,
-0.385543108,
-0.8555941582,
-0.6044248939,
0.0198863316,
-0.4435375333,
0.259215802,
0.5475510955,
-0.4004079401,
1.1047890186,
-0.3280133009,
-0.0623506382,
-0.3512527943,
0.4931742251,
0.4278691113,
0.1277078539,
0.2819901109,
-0.7150873542,
-0.3013151884,
-0.3411133587,
-0.4451509416,
-0.5243116021,
-0.3695133626,
-0.2860451341,
0.1564795524,
0.4165635407,
-0.8646782637,
0.4510624111,
0.1063554585,
-0.6954732537,
0.4436000884,
0.0854538158,
-0.0971735641,
-0.6168542504,
0.2370045632,
-0.0645481944,
0.1082344428,
-0.2801916599,
-0.0627582073,
-0.2669181228,
0.1488856226,
-0.5590308905,
0.5503313541,
-0.4811360538,
-0.2549107671,
-0.1865504235,
0.0797049105,
-0.0100839343,
0.4685488939,
0.186400339,
0.5050158501,
0.3384974897,
-0.2877715826,
0.4309789538,
-0.0723453388,
-0.6200330257,
0.2308924496,
-0.6826127172,
0.449436605,
-0.0437314846,
0.0738440529,
-1.5332773924,
-0.3810389936,
-0.017365329,
-0.3776931763,
-0.0887724906,
0.3574686348,
-1.0048495531,
-0.5123810768,
-0.2594637573,
0.1255355477,
0.6486228108,
-0.017892899,
0.4946879148,
0.2270984352,
-0.2439898252,
-0.0061659236,
-0.8050633669,
0.2037487626,
-0.6803119779,
-1.2105828524,
0.4756346941,
-0.5133371353,
-0.4719922543,
-0.1497775763,
0.0447294079,
0.0189841948,
0.3979232907,
0.2816857696,
0.0935565159,
-0.1205800995,
-0.1497228295,
-0.4517506957,
0.188765645,
0.1872814447,
0.0740424991,
0.5759301782,
0.0254422817,
-0.2944107056,
-0.3355819285,
0.2509106994,
0.646134913,
0.2828088999,
0.7243145108,
0.7811927795,
-0.0735543594,
-0.2222346067,
-0.5788930058,
0.0990480781,
-0.5084678531,
0.1879271865,
-0.2522936463,
-0.9314348698,
0.7639550567,
0.158149749,
0.0394792184,
0.5119475126,
0.9155942202,
-0.1750396192,
0.8282669187,
0.7447860837,
0.3244126141,
0.3887874782,
-0.2400091439,
0.1146926582,
-0.6556247473,
-0.3065639138,
-0.0804683566,
-0.6783208251,
-0.3603659868,
-0.5347750187,
0.0962419957,
0.1957812011,
-0.0767033771,
0.2254196107,
-0.3757288754,
0.6647123694,
0.3660083711,
-0.2409519851,
0.2055194676,
-0.199461937,
-0.345716238,
-0.173587963,
-0.5183885098,
-0.6388431787,
0.932970047,
0.3575698137,
0.9408739805,
0.1000704095,
0.7735335231,
0.3169007897,
0.2778851688,
-0.949652195,
0.857732594,
0.1591709703,
-0.5099229217,
-0.456584096,
-0.2611325085,
-1.0995014906,
-0.0098732347,
-0.0229989439,
-0.8900470734,
-0.1546953171,
-0.1440112442,
-0.3563720882,
0.1482462883,
-0.6558279395,
0.7383984923,
-0.2846372724,
-0.4999879897,
-0.1437922269,
-0.5691899657,
0.336527437,
-0.1974948645,
0.1105149761,
-0.3000443876,
-0.1080269516,
0.8363688588,
-0.0821753144,
0.9500249028,
0.0570119955,
-0.2434162796,
0.4208631217,
0.2393325418,
0.18435736,
-0.0985830501,
-0.0108219767,
-0.1356791407,
-0.4412172437,
-0.1271981001,
-0.6507841945,
0.73888731,
-0.4795249403,
-0.6461817622,
-0.1715592146,
-0.8032642007,
-0.261202991,
0.0954208896,
0.2867998183,
-0.0708155632,
-0.374905467,
0.1347373128,
0.2911708355,
-0.2477854788,
0.4396975338,
0.476570189,
-0.1423759907,
-0.1720818281,
0.4334752262,
0.2629103363,
0.1806485504,
0.2162010968,
0.269127667,
-0.6357985735,
-0.3550137877,
-0.0768672302,
0.2161676139,
-0.770239234,
0.3945502043,
-0.4803987443,
-0.1209413409,
-0.4283350706,
-0.2020094097,
-0.0917046741,
-0.6131845713,
-0.5148254037,
0.0217264593,
0.2888566852,
0.9187693,
0.0068875365,
-0.1228982434,
-0.4771699309,
0.4191784561,
0.4562734365,
0.237476632,
0.2194904834,
-0.5491949916,
-0.0046761492,
-0.0463311262,
-0.5656508207,
-0.7494184971,
0.5320801735,
0.3486597538,
0.8086653948,
0.3587800562,
-0.4210519791,
0.5867589116,
-0.3985849619,
1.0897529125,
-0.0137877688,
-0.621098876,
0.4304096997,
-0.2627057433,
0.4498577416,
0.3392556608,
0.4230896235,
-0.6707825661,
-0.3729279041,
-0.6324365139,
-1.0800007582,
0.3803088665,
0.2717294097,
0.0768392682,
-0.1492279768,
0.2040578127,
0.2277388424,
-0.028416317,
-0.6864581108,
0.141177997,
0.1506863981,
-0.0008052118,
-0.2965371311,
-0.0267088432,
-0.1775643826,
-0.2133418322,
0.2479492575,
0.0454804935,
0.0328923352,
-0.0151097775,
-0.0442774072,
-0.285957396,
0.237542063,
0.4526153505,
0.6697098613,
0.045858603,
0.1695251465,
0.0533980653,
-0.2679625154,
0.2462332696,
-0.25866431,
0.2824309766,
-0.1396751106,
0.5741268992,
0.5792316198,
0.1485293955,
-1.0687352419,
0.3192301393,
-0.0969831944,
-0.1971953958,
-0.5047084689,
0.6727564335,
0.513265729,
0.4683870375,
0.2109728754,
0.1809333414,
0.2937098742,
-0.7396760583,
0.1256730109,
0.3422953188,
0.0945989192,
-0.5290334225,
0.5737006068,
-0.0889733434,
-0.8557505608,
0.6187559366,
-0.3743550777,
-0.0637747422,
0.6778769493,
0.4677658081,
1.2224146128,
0.3639364541,
0.0769442841,
-0.0705085397,
-0.146870926,
-0.1673677713,
0.5455455184,
-0.1079234406,
-0.7971020937,
-0.5079299808,
-0.7481319308,
-0.0932356119,
0.3309829235,
-0.3967399597,
0.3161628842,
-0.2029531747,
-0.2233913392,
0.2391203195,
-0.1144737229,
-0.9617163539,
-0.0516828075,
0.5530806184,
1.1548141241,
-0.9476578832,
0.7076497078,
0.8661940098,
-0.3083536029,
-0.5263434649,
0.0225083027,
0.247481823,
-0.5802939534,
0.7935923934,
0.3657544255,
-0.3799271286,
-0.1591299325,
-0.6198967695,
-0.8767507672,
1.0808444023,
0.0763474777,
-0.3921450377,
-0.2033344656,
0.2342367321,
0.9798654914,
-0.5371598601,
-0.1505935639,
0.6715254784,
0.1958703399,
0.3986813426,
-0.6760559678,
-0.1302381754,
-0.599717021,
0.3197816312,
-0.1831742376,
-0.3105132282,
0.6415579319,
-0.2913789153,
-0.5442396998,
0.4333622456,
0.3701298237,
0.5537742972,
0.3239512444,
0.5624215603,
0.7319211364,
0.6917256713,
0.2796823978,
0.7620129585,
-0.087361075,
0.1742665321,
0.7593966126,
-0.4552537501,
0.9018785357,
0.5649907589,
-0.0574352257,
0.5851814747,
0.6480552554,
-0.0688950866,
0.4530572891,
0.7000461817,
-0.091642186,
-0.2078762054,
0.1260304749,
0.2729080617,
0.4240502715,
0.5432892442,
-0.2831879258,
0.1102074608,
-0.0430873744,
-0.2447560281,
0.1352203488,
-0.0780539513,
0.6885287762,
0.0324858576,
-0.9345234036,
0.6544238925,
-0.1850102395,
0.9221853018,
-0.4220589101,
0.0924681723,
-0.0129779084,
-0.1152046323,
-0.0833209828,
-1.5188916922,
0.501540482,
-0.0656835884,
-0.0016535029,
-0.484223485,
0.6980323195,
-0.2737471759,
-0.3021668792,
0.2988032699,
0.6062378287,
0.3114926517,
0.113289915,
-0.619266808,
-0.0601284206,
-0.2197455168,
-0.6539033651,
0.0735933483,
0.7020452023,
-0.0992289931,
0.669813633,
0.6768119931,
0.1387360394,
0.1181188226,
0.4248202741,
0.6130281091,
-1.0522516966,
-0.5661371946,
-0.9223718047,
0.6038622856,
-0.1297281981,
-0.772716403,
0.731382966,
0.496478647,
0.9170513749,
-0.3033060133,
0.4197830558,
-0.1053631529,
0.4399098754,
-0.6282585859,
0.5650438666,
-0.5754283667,
0.3778715432,
-0.307670027,
-0.9266374111,
-0.2996277511,
0.5669013858,
-0.2399428636,
0.0258727055,
0.5165758729,
1.0625234842,
-0.1340822726,
-0.1903004646,
0.2660381496,
0.1769245118,
0.1627292186,
0.6337341666,
1.504685998,
0.522971034,
0.0482884571,
-0.1210607663,
-0.2279265225,
-0.1944568008,
-0.8822680712,
-0.9349690676,
-0.744370997,
-0.2488988936,
-0.1246493831,
-0.5447111726,
0.8427613378,
0.5292992592,
-0.1922394186,
-0.3053961694,
-0.313133955,
-0.1804202646,
-0.2267665267,
-0.2961944938,
-0.1820473373,
-0.1869917363,
-0.3981220722,
0.5381401181,
0.3649120927,
0.0885646343,
-0.6557831168,
-0.0075886277,
0.0352720618,
0.3803138733,
0.509057045,
0.2093510926,
-1.0613418818,
0.0142115448,
0.3678139448,
-0.2039806694,
0.0739432275,
0.9949880242,
-0.6714920998,
0.3070285022,
0.8539181352,
0.3501014411,
0.3139257133,
-0.1719595194,
0.2334188819,
-0.6849989295,
0.0166091081,
0.5291402936,
0.3307464719,
0.4735126495,
-0.4541995525,
0.4858159423,
0.4525264502,
-0.6981230378,
-0.444634527,
0.3562967777,
-1.1421306133,
-0.2636886835,
1.2754321098,
-0.0270703044,
-0.2848095894,
-0.0763329118,
-0.3631414473,
0.0773224831,
-0.1805377603,
0.9905198216,
1.0165362358,
-0.7027500272,
0.3151338398,
-0.5022919774,
0.3055301309,
0.1086726263,
-0.4286833704,
-0.0757352188,
0.3864513636,
0.5951504707,
0.3169207275,
0.7643423676,
-0.0363698155,
0.1903237104,
-0.2333378196,
-0.0165835265,
0.2044149041,
-0.2886864245,
-0.307818979,
0.2299757004,
0.292865634,
0.22732611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00888v1
|
DynaMo: Accelerating Language Model Inference with Dynamic Multi-Token Sampling
| 2024-05-01T22:17:57 | 2024-05-01T22:17:57 |
Shikhar Tuli, Chi-Heng Lin, Yen-Chang Hsu, Niraj K. Jha, Yilin Shen, Hongxia Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Traditional language models operate autoregressively, i.e., they predict one
token at a time. Rapid explosion in model sizes has resulted in high inference
times. In this work, we propose DynaMo, a suite of multi-token prediction
language models that reduce net inference times. Our models
$\textit{dynamically}$ predict multiple tokens based on their confidence in the
predicted joint probability distribution. We propose a lightweight technique to
train these models, leveraging the weights of traditional autoregressive
counterparts. Moreover, we propose novel ways to enhance the estimated joint
probability to improve text generation quality, namely co-occurrence weighted
masking and adaptive thresholding. We also propose systematic qualitative and
quantitative methods to rigorously test the quality of generated text for
non-autoregressive generation. One of the models in our suite, DynaMo-7.3B-T3,
achieves same-quality generated text as the baseline (Pythia-6.9B) while
achieving 2.57$\times$ speed-up with only 5.87% and 2.67% parameter and
training time overheads, respectively.
|
[
-0.2183920145,
-0.7863486409,
0.247488752,
0.2962411046,
-0.3733213842,
0.463824898,
-0.1250390112,
-0.5883098841,
0.4256145656,
0.2861660421,
-0.5938037038,
-0.4890762269,
-0.4878858626,
-0.1626843363,
-0.7193692923,
0.6983109713,
0.0997226834,
0.0543000735,
0.1036340296,
-0.0321557485,
-0.1841052771,
-0.2502694428,
-0.4511752427,
-0.0980015621,
0.4163660109,
0.473046124,
0.7250627875,
0.6495681405,
0.2982060313,
0.2726766765,
-0.0480599701,
0.1144557223,
-0.1949016899,
0.6827847958,
0.1878354996,
-0.344371587,
-0.4956516027,
0.0235650502,
0.583773613,
0.7502968311,
-0.2083063573,
0.5029869676,
-0.2453392297,
0.4008592963,
-0.8217327595,
0.0313936174,
-0.8469165564,
-0.0977751985,
-0.2742686272,
0.1887642592,
-0.4568715096,
-0.1356134564,
-0.0995965227,
-0.4301029444,
0.6309933662,
0.3207392991,
0.7228845358,
0.1432210654,
-0.3496756554,
0.0631341338,
-0.6748139262,
0.8440244198,
-0.6824620366,
0.4676617384,
0.3748270571,
0.5364833474,
-0.1253239363,
-1.1451516151,
-0.9549679756,
-0.1501811594,
0.2607911825,
0.1726331562,
0.2072657347,
-0.0067215767,
-0.0564831533,
0.3013212979,
-0.2566021383,
0.2897227705,
0.1035691053,
-0.2612533569,
0.5782288909,
0.2660277784,
0.0544504151,
-0.422742337,
-0.0910392851,
-0.4003999233,
-0.5898798108,
-0.0459139496,
0.8086954951,
0.4657902718,
-0.1021766961,
0.48914361,
-0.3792987168,
0.7153937817,
0.2023875713,
-0.1083857715,
0.2360954732,
-0.6975262165,
-0.1557478309,
-0.3562973738,
0.9692197442,
0.1406590641,
-0.3201601505,
-0.2628445029,
-0.2772657275,
-0.2153220326,
0.134446457,
-0.8799021244,
-0.5208806396,
0.4878425002,
-0.7386437654,
-0.4496807456,
0.007012303,
-1.0377873182,
-0.3357996047,
-0.1474513412,
0.1863453537,
-0.4772650599,
-0.3716867864,
0.1171108484,
-0.2781467736,
-0.3084050715,
0.410972625,
-1.0217444897,
0.1981147826,
0.3352976739,
0.7468358874,
-0.1272873282,
-0.4237944782,
-0.7926849127,
0.1515795439,
-0.2476714253,
0.7501556277,
-0.3771516681,
-0.1673223078,
-0.0007769749,
-0.2501115203,
0.0148740271,
-0.2326085418,
0.5537828803,
-0.500146687,
0.3069698811,
0.0888391435,
-0.4061677158,
0.042737253,
-0.226367712,
-0.8370267153,
1.3249980211,
0.1592615098,
-0.7619922161,
0.9132903814,
-0.3859153092,
-0.6348440647,
-0.0763012394,
0.2616776526,
-0.5609827042,
0.236002937,
0.4552506506,
0.4596337974,
-0.5818011165,
0.4951973557,
-0.5279605985,
-0.119397752,
0.0236330759,
-0.6794613004,
0.7133968472,
0.1981950849,
-0.4293515086,
0.4281768799,
-1.0367921591,
0.1333297491,
-0.1532924175,
-0.1412120908,
0.0290726405,
0.0881558806,
0.3886129856,
0.3193838596,
0.1313620061,
-0.4883785546,
0.073577486,
-0.3789188564,
0.067047514,
0.5861723423,
-0.2368372083,
0.5419283509,
-0.0790507197,
0.610707581,
-0.1094879285,
0.2426023036,
-0.2316612303,
-0.3079721928,
-1.0019462109,
-0.671256125,
0.7155486941,
0.0929913223,
-1.0266628265,
0.7313426733,
-0.3813234568,
-0.800375998,
-0.7355154157,
-0.1592563987,
0.1303049177,
0.266002357,
0.4561621547,
-0.1223818585,
-0.5194897056,
-0.7071558833,
-0.394310832,
-0.4130799472,
-0.1802242994,
0.1809740216,
0.4719307423,
0.3077499866,
0.9413041472,
-0.3216623068,
0.0629717559,
-0.4444364607,
0.6655805111,
0.1593817174,
0.3800331652,
0.7017800212,
-0.5315228105,
-0.7077341676,
-0.4914326668,
-0.314691484,
-0.2643789947,
-0.1311249882,
0.0210658927,
0.3581182063,
0.3338578343,
-0.7687613964,
0.2565599382,
0.8667687178,
-0.3942992389,
0.6729360223,
-0.2184751779,
0.1160001606,
-1.3563504219,
0.1942884028,
-0.3672894835,
-0.2567081153,
-0.5470919013,
0.0560726114,
0.1594032198,
-0.0373371802,
-0.3162644804,
0.891683042,
-0.7402801514,
-0.1105887145,
-0.4268276393,
0.04939273,
0.0585302301,
0.0509038754,
-0.1603362113,
0.9922453165,
0.7557725906,
-0.6793447733,
0.261716634,
-0.0862499848,
-0.7016426921,
0.1004281268,
-0.3868864179,
0.0049544275,
-0.1586000472,
0.41862306,
-1.1568329334,
-0.268956542,
-0.0904148519,
-0.482535094,
0.2957245409,
0.0028507572,
-1.1630039215,
-0.5772309303,
-0.1744655371,
0.2474928349,
0.5029312372,
-0.6465774775,
0.8422071934,
0.5258825421,
-0.0861403346,
-0.7624559402,
-0.3528555632,
0.2127007693,
-0.0367112383,
-0.4357583821,
0.4248895049,
0.3680901825,
-0.066112332,
-0.0399141535,
-0.0976543352,
-0.0465901755,
0.399625212,
0.0755422637,
0.0738799348,
0.0793794468,
0.4753731489,
0.3499834538,
-0.0737170801,
-0.2382951677,
-0.5347930193,
1.0164903402,
0.3762978315,
-0.4061879814,
-0.6598710418,
0.104800649,
0.7175033689,
-0.3322422206,
1.1537795067,
0.7944241166,
-0.1273711026,
-0.250158757,
-0.3983547091,
-0.4663505554,
-0.4149716496,
0.4127241373,
-0.494197458,
-0.3880708814,
0.8594872355,
0.1350757629,
-0.0072453483,
0.6076738238,
0.6700823903,
0.1066056937,
1.0079840422,
0.3107942045,
-0.1468729377,
0.744658649,
-0.223398447,
0.2135062069,
-0.5413895845,
-0.0675352886,
-0.759819746,
-0.2850964367,
-0.4168243706,
-0.6223820448,
0.0825203434,
0.1792781204,
-0.0116757229,
0.387937814,
-0.0497339852,
0.2026728988,
0.7805956006,
-0.1834649295,
0.2551324069,
-0.0485734344,
-0.3081567585,
0.1263293624,
-0.899738729,
-0.2514880598,
1.274242878,
0.1387522519,
0.7457500696,
0.2659737766,
0.4226649404,
0.0591075383,
0.534886539,
-0.407799989,
0.4623196423,
-0.0994530916,
-0.8784145713,
-0.344265759,
-0.5192989707,
-0.943162322,
0.3016290963,
-0.5602966547,
-0.697148025,
-0.1173734963,
0.3243250847,
-0.1703929603,
0.3811251223,
-0.5365093946,
0.4960207939,
-0.0255633742,
-0.5074082017,
-0.3892277777,
-0.5740254521,
0.4191375673,
-0.2610019445,
0.1128994897,
-0.2971047759,
0.0399220102,
0.466874212,
-0.5279412866,
0.9793904424,
-0.3982462287,
0.0459720902,
0.3652699888,
0.0506647639,
0.7579291463,
0.0225082505,
-0.4687775075,
0.0483350903,
-0.3600122631,
-0.434253931,
-0.5999079943,
0.4165094197,
-0.585850358,
-0.3574032784,
-0.1707028598,
-0.6425738931,
-0.1305603385,
0.320248872,
0.2974351048,
0.4507161081,
-0.0980378836,
0.21232149,
-0.0700411275,
-0.268137306,
0.7367209196,
0.4146707356,
-0.3340927064,
-0.7088665366,
0.650282979,
0.0407377556,
0.5176746249,
0.2445169836,
0.0517647751,
-0.7918919325,
-0.8912513852,
-0.7392857671,
0.0028314083,
-0.4846713245,
-0.4091433585,
-1.0567569733,
0.215714708,
-0.6785762906,
0.2079820484,
-0.4946697652,
-0.9000738263,
-0.2963961661,
0.0393313579,
0.3964388967,
0.2466774881,
0.1846251786,
0.8265851736,
-0.8828526139,
0.2908881605,
-0.0761580095,
0.3635742962,
0.2725308239,
-0.593362391,
-0.3474721313,
-0.110456191,
-0.2714415789,
-0.6925210953,
0.6019920707,
0.2462614775,
0.4871763885,
0.1298520863,
0.304680109,
0.7611667514,
-0.6040600538,
0.9079605937,
0.3416046798,
-1.1241080761,
0.1803485006,
-0.3543126583,
0.2841678858,
0.6225190163,
-0.0708072856,
-0.4701846242,
-0.9352536201,
-0.9538775086,
-1.0204960108,
0.5700780749,
0.303514719,
0.2400339544,
-0.1741448194,
0.2506577671,
0.3807893693,
0.5166156292,
-0.4161292315,
-0.3706769347,
-0.3279839754,
-0.5027307868,
-0.07279443,
-0.0109004909,
0.2550730109,
-0.1221791804,
0.6022898555,
-0.3094406426,
0.1532372087,
-0.2513476908,
-0.0698122159,
-0.1689847261,
-0.1066881716,
0.3762049377,
0.4623485804,
-0.0705811381,
0.083066307,
0.0636526272,
-0.4981430769,
0.1616585106,
0.3396475911,
-0.3228566945,
0.266774565,
0.4420899451,
0.9668682218,
-0.1516991258,
-0.5692593455,
0.3534731865,
-0.1970977932,
0.0355512537,
-0.1514844,
0.0956492648,
0.0477266982,
-0.0063802497,
0.4666026831,
0.1584195346,
0.0259744879,
-0.4599017203,
0.2912206352,
0.5448439121,
-0.074229084,
-0.5188364983,
0.9100192785,
0.4301177859,
-0.2399397045,
0.4118902683,
-0.3485941887,
-0.3267640471,
0.5859339237,
0.6100171804,
0.8260406256,
-0.1613369584,
0.2719297111,
0.4893214107,
-0.0217033532,
-0.2021743208,
0.3977796137,
0.1276183575,
-0.7850357294,
-0.6218439341,
-0.7114894986,
-0.3989528716,
0.1470070928,
-0.3720955551,
0.3736854494,
-0.2738699615,
-0.4627261758,
-0.0150962882,
0.1180970892,
-0.4124979079,
0.1660236716,
-0.4570400417,
0.9511859417,
-0.870228827,
1.0102682114,
0.3029409647,
-0.3128651679,
-0.6493775845,
0.3954924047,
-0.1752110869,
-0.5107632875,
0.7759968638,
0.072941795,
-0.1927711219,
0.288086772,
-0.2601569593,
-1.1292536259,
0.9113157988,
0.3302073777,
-0.1936236322,
0.1913869381,
-0.2636562586,
0.565740943,
-0.1926282495,
0.2885478437,
0.1851466745,
0.3619114161,
-0.0062793549,
-0.8708944321,
-0.0879959092,
-0.018945856,
-0.2169206738,
0.5997894406,
-0.6567473412,
1.1166461706,
-0.2486501336,
-0.4156504869,
0.5132177472,
0.9980213046,
0.3427729607,
0.0156988576,
0.5833603144,
0.3905764222,
1.1612383127,
0.0769238696,
1.2033252716,
-0.7842402458,
0.4060418904,
1.2223876715,
-0.4530412555,
0.7301134467,
0.523704052,
-0.0079555251,
0.5227614045,
0.6166397333,
0.0622911826,
0.5351812243,
0.1288380772,
-0.4977826774,
-0.2251244783,
-0.149262026,
-0.0837338269,
0.5734399557,
0.1267752498,
-0.4137997627,
-0.0473792814,
-0.1775585711,
-0.1288796961,
-0.0665257797,
0.1748173088,
0.4559877217,
-0.3849861026,
-0.8122406006,
0.3458374143,
0.2765565515,
0.5241599083,
-0.208917737,
0.2715839744,
-0.1266958714,
0.1067597419,
0.3027694821,
-0.4950695038,
0.0206752215,
-0.1257034242,
-0.1604172587,
-0.3218173087,
0.6414954662,
-0.4867858887,
-0.7060976624,
0.1993843615,
0.7523863912,
-0.0714370459,
0.1063375622,
-0.4214862287,
-0.254221797,
-0.3376662135,
-0.2976453304,
0.2068401724,
0.6567215919,
0.0856421739,
0.8631362319,
0.9799787402,
0.4717386663,
0.1834850162,
0.2767868638,
0.6594647765,
-0.5734868646,
-0.4140360057,
-0.7152918577,
0.4326249957,
-0.3870609105,
-0.3999753296,
0.7160959244,
0.5958881974,
0.4123362601,
-0.1679589301,
0.6449988484,
-0.1305390298,
0.6769556999,
-0.7387988567,
0.9304587841,
-0.5561814904,
0.0726006255,
-0.0774443597,
-0.7910523415,
-0.4439098835,
0.4172556698,
0.0338833779,
0.099358879,
0.761531353,
0.4897244573,
-0.0631232336,
-0.1240184829,
0.0765414611,
0.0136422589,
0.5861222744,
-0.0854914933,
0.5996400118,
-0.5155814886,
0.4113945663,
-0.1971386522,
0.1017476618,
-0.3169908822,
-1.0384742022,
-0.8053165674,
-0.5254888535,
0.0199033227,
-0.4383144379,
-0.1759222746,
0.9035885334,
0.86769557,
-0.6358126402,
-0.1051644385,
-0.3684717417,
0.0580061302,
-0.2888937593,
-0.1819154322,
0.5856234431,
-0.7047700286,
-1.0971916914,
0.3256232142,
-0.0173223969,
0.3100087345,
-0.3089456856,
0.1945144981,
-0.0535381064,
-0.0949739218,
0.3848881423,
-0.2359890789,
-0.6188046336,
-0.4487530589,
0.1701573581,
-0.05844751,
-0.1181114316,
0.8141678572,
-0.8732295036,
0.3587963879,
0.719212234,
0.5438233018,
0.547616601,
0.0739247426,
0.8588448763,
-0.9139510989,
0.5378085971,
0.3254405558,
0.3687460721,
0.2298298478,
0.0609329492,
0.1859622896,
0.3516200781,
-0.3217143714,
-0.9855096936,
0.4406581521,
-0.4572680593,
-0.3955082893,
0.9646903872,
0.0147194508,
-0.1304561794,
-0.3560123742,
0.0998366624,
0.5605783463,
-0.4957912862,
1.1173797846,
0.7481703758,
0.1159531251,
-0.1820551306,
-0.3824601173,
0.5414185524,
0.6026830077,
-0.8817304373,
0.5358194709,
0.4542901814,
-0.0776042864,
0.1678922474,
0.5591567159,
0.1485123187,
0.1911353469,
0.4126514792,
0.3861919343,
0.0537233241,
-0.6292862892,
-0.0637932122,
0.3278104067,
0.1790443659,
-0.1811255515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00864v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00864v1
|
Math Multiple Choice Question Generation via Human-Large Language Model Collaboration
| 2024-05-01T20:53:13 | 2024-05-01T20:53:13 |
Jaewook Lee, Digory Smith, Simon Woodhead, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multiple choice questions (MCQs) are a popular method for evaluating
students' knowledge due to their efficiency in administration and grading.
Crafting high-quality math MCQs is a labor-intensive process that requires
educators to formulate precise stems and plausible distractors. Recent advances
in large language models (LLMs) have sparked interest in automating MCQ
creation, but challenges persist in ensuring mathematical accuracy and
addressing student errors. This paper introduces a prototype tool designed to
facilitate collaboration between LLMs and educators for streamlining the math
MCQ generation process. We conduct a pilot study involving math educators to
investigate how the tool can help them simplify the process of crafting
high-quality math MCQs. We found that while LLMs can generate well-formulated
question stems, their ability to generate distractors that capture common
student errors and misconceptions is limited. Nevertheless, a human-AI
collaboration has the potential to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of
MCQ generation.
|
[
-0.7121165395,
-0.9518105388,
0.6877294779,
-0.0229778588,
-0.0239247754,
0.3730966747,
-0.0128654335,
-0.1576144397,
0.1726822108,
0.5760786533,
-0.7447370887,
-0.2189200968,
-0.2051140368,
0.0984174088,
-0.1334944367,
0.7168931961,
-0.1865297854,
0.174210459,
-0.6894675493,
0.0050297333,
-0.4972655177,
-0.6581574678,
-0.761084199,
-0.2935315371,
0.5346287489,
0.7285524607,
0.9198723435,
0.2670494914,
0.6051424146,
0.334697336,
0.3134040236,
0.4390342534,
-0.1774414778,
0.2694478929,
-0.0262408778,
-0.3863497972,
-0.4391322732,
0.0876752585,
0.4666051269,
0.9283306003,
-0.2847678661,
0.528465271,
0.0154324537,
0.4349366724,
-0.6086785793,
-0.2533918321,
-0.6065512896,
0.0306873955,
-0.1203921214,
0.0164595302,
-0.2308151275,
-0.4842195213,
-0.0358929001,
-0.3109481335,
0.17864196,
-0.0916428491,
0.5805152059,
0.3696638048,
-0.321778506,
-0.4774784148,
-0.6140606999,
0.7136042714,
-0.4651872814,
0.2203782797,
0.2881784737,
0.6218768358,
-0.2545233667,
-0.5071543455,
-0.6705933213,
-0.1646179408,
0.1841992736,
0.2700467706,
0.3014920354,
-0.3157528341,
0.3703255057,
0.1293118894,
-0.3610187173,
-0.0896820873,
-0.3153380156,
-0.2304019034,
0.8891320229,
0.6434372663,
0.4881800413,
-0.2662684917,
-0.11635077,
-0.0465799607,
-0.6282150149,
0.0346888863,
0.4491121471,
0.1180127487,
0.3123348057,
0.8989915848,
0.1325109601,
0.6823613048,
-0.1622057855,
-0.2526089549,
0.0547871217,
-0.373478353,
-0.006535959,
-0.2078016698,
0.98405689,
0.2147320658,
0.1969161779,
0.2749709487,
-0.1073960736,
0.114282161,
0.0644056723,
-0.634550333,
-0.234723404,
0.1777623743,
0.1195078194,
-0.3449262977,
0.0688640848,
-0.5490981936,
-0.0292997658,
-0.6079887748,
0.4141807258,
-0.2235626131,
-0.1542205215,
0.0148656657,
-0.0773921832,
-0.1039323881,
0.4749482274,
-0.6341087818,
0.1902039945,
0.392342031,
0.474948138,
-0.3375364244,
-0.5934323668,
-0.7229355574,
0.2424434125,
-0.2207220048,
0.614669323,
-0.4037875533,
-0.682366848,
-0.2750906944,
-0.5530167222,
-0.0645690933,
-0.5744953752,
0.3271405697,
-0.3577448428,
0.4669069946,
-0.1243212,
-0.5473014712,
0.230411455,
0.4444644749,
-0.5613022447,
1.2293747663,
0.2327509224,
-0.4827305377,
0.1349653006,
-0.7352995872,
-0.1828397065,
0.3508821428,
-0.5926549435,
-0.5466766357,
-0.1686326712,
0.4781676829,
0.4157910943,
-0.4950511158,
0.5011103749,
-0.1707016081,
-0.1738441586,
0.6475700736,
-0.5586937666,
0.8898977637,
0.1243749261,
-0.0350217298,
0.0473094694,
-0.5035945773,
0.183690086,
0.2406181991,
-0.444773972,
-0.0254951604,
-0.2383117378,
-0.0944831222,
0.5390728712,
0.175039649,
-0.3296569884,
-0.0113702966,
0.1317016333,
0.2716098726,
0.6592134237,
0.2447339594,
0.0705427527,
-0.6989812255,
0.8796103597,
-0.1159486398,
0.1666189283,
-0.0231231693,
-0.6408962011,
-0.7855614424,
-0.2761798203,
0.1580688208,
0.482644707,
-0.8288828731,
0.4002738595,
0.057118997,
-0.5542911291,
-0.5447893143,
0.3785374463,
0.2090894878,
0.6010963917,
0.0746790245,
-0.0307750665,
-0.4281536043,
-0.5843139291,
-0.0983847827,
0.1433991641,
-0.229122445,
0.6778620481,
0.5328528881,
-0.0543010011,
1.3024735451,
-0.8077353239,
-0.0094546191,
-0.1882463247,
0.3631100059,
-0.0216532312,
0.4912517369,
0.4191029668,
-0.6923369765,
-0.5686321259,
-0.5478174686,
-0.5895166993,
-0.0739768371,
-0.0465115272,
-0.6531397104,
-0.1160304844,
0.4711493254,
-0.5832012892,
0.0877620801,
0.3599900901,
-0.1050341055,
0.983269155,
0.0763241276,
0.0321605392,
-1.4413429499,
0.1202076003,
-0.4353575706,
-0.0841689184,
-0.2531615198,
0.0746929571,
-0.0966331884,
-0.4969247878,
-0.6687728763,
0.5444023013,
-0.2855291069,
-0.064438574,
0.2424215674,
0.4426068068,
0.0111121265,
0.209683761,
-0.1083713025,
0.8291473389,
0.3250301182,
-0.6392251253,
0.3715419471,
0.3621992469,
-0.1734188497,
0.8180168271,
-0.5843703747,
0.1862320751,
0.0551368706,
0.128411293,
-0.9371518493,
-0.562910974,
0.0859205648,
-0.6844348311,
-0.2160332203,
-0.0108044548,
-0.645892024,
-0.7255898714,
-0.1681090295,
0.4920328259,
0.4393034279,
-0.4455038905,
0.4697510302,
0.3936383128,
-0.3897327781,
-0.5534763336,
-0.5658658147,
0.0784807503,
0.1627352685,
-0.7699343562,
-0.0871350095,
-0.6403571367,
-0.2701406777,
-0.1545963436,
0.1581954211,
-0.1241121367,
0.1923987865,
0.0911904573,
0.6982088685,
-0.1650369763,
0.2296680659,
0.2884497643,
0.0278758649,
0.4435224235,
-0.0298279598,
0.5982132554,
0.1225493774,
-0.7644545436,
-0.1277787387,
0.5095182657,
0.7560167313,
-0.4270323217,
0.4027035534,
0.4047927856,
-0.3877550662,
-0.2912956774,
-0.672950685,
-0.1810580939,
-0.5137857795,
0.0795309693,
-0.3475874364,
-0.9471755028,
0.3271699548,
-0.1842653453,
0.2583100498,
0.3106191456,
0.8269021511,
-0.0355641209,
1.3844374418,
0.0620118491,
0.2266044468,
0.3018346131,
-0.1325055957,
-0.2236815095,
-0.7481259108,
-0.1373472661,
-0.4642647207,
-0.1173465475,
0.1333821863,
-0.6355320215,
0.5459792614,
0.0623309687,
-0.2851043344,
-0.043688383,
-0.4903719425,
0.7026461363,
0.8357905746,
-0.0115606552,
0.2785415947,
0.0527246408,
-0.6549156904,
-0.1611626893,
-0.5558851957,
-0.560791254,
1.2176513672,
-0.1498440951,
0.4826067686,
0.2599627674,
1.0767886639,
-0.1024936661,
0.6153690219,
-0.6754124761,
0.7128091455,
0.3205260634,
-0.8703383803,
-0.5917866826,
-0.6796836853,
-0.8044127822,
0.2149200439,
-0.4380018711,
-0.4246018231,
-0.5008660555,
0.080533497,
-0.4894383252,
0.108130075,
-0.6214193106,
0.6901619434,
-0.335735321,
-0.5199493766,
0.1036876813,
-0.4641006887,
0.5620161891,
-0.3180037439,
0.2121593505,
-0.1057605743,
0.1875710785,
0.7178982496,
-0.6089516282,
0.6072996855,
0.1412850916,
-0.2404203564,
0.7331268191,
0.4650115371,
0.162100777,
0.4695571959,
-0.186996907,
-0.3025037944,
-0.3672580123,
-0.2781723738,
-0.5539395809,
0.6496017575,
-0.8513429165,
-0.5825633407,
-0.088302739,
-0.9432120919,
-0.3178528845,
0.2820954323,
0.0124941841,
0.4145998657,
-0.095754914,
-0.2147102058,
0.400701493,
0.0130382236,
0.5177535415,
0.3444968164,
-0.2843009531,
-0.6944447756,
0.8974852562,
0.108876586,
0.4318426549,
0.0807323083,
0.3531627357,
-0.2494950145,
-0.1321462393,
-0.6130753756,
0.3133561611,
-0.6522049308,
-0.2745127082,
-0.4472145438,
-0.4364798963,
-0.3983801305,
-0.5004532337,
-0.2108570784,
-0.3892679811,
-0.4407520592,
0.1035010293,
-0.029970102,
0.5912246108,
0.0915545076,
0.0660283044,
-1.1056381464,
0.2466218024,
0.9105460048,
0.0266572125,
-0.0448540077,
-0.078393802,
0.0335291773,
0.2782132924,
-0.593174696,
-0.5099224448,
0.2449680865,
-0.2074623853,
0.3905653656,
0.205031842,
0.0672874972,
0.7513967752,
-0.521841526,
0.833420217,
0.5214307308,
-1.1585173607,
0.441955179,
-0.3466068506,
0.3897725344,
0.5322070718,
0.292441994,
-0.3838472962,
-0.603264451,
-0.6392980814,
-0.382627815,
0.6028795242,
0.3558829725,
0.0757250339,
-0.1557771713,
0.1955118328,
0.1815718859,
0.335219264,
-0.4456456304,
-0.1641113013,
-0.0161677264,
-0.4110737145,
-0.0936178565,
-0.0582541786,
-0.3092730641,
-0.2432616949,
0.3207743764,
-0.1666675955,
-0.0145502053,
0.0410078391,
-0.0748009682,
-0.5130863786,
0.3922268748,
0.6593479514,
0.8693198562,
-0.0025310898,
0.0876899734,
0.2482458502,
-0.5433581471,
0.1242747605,
-0.0577045195,
-0.2531492114,
-0.0506688617,
0.0511819087,
0.2697708607,
-0.0983360559,
-0.9085379839,
0.4187403917,
-0.1221733019,
-0.6979612112,
-0.5035465956,
0.3005820811,
0.3593220115,
-0.0463810265,
0.3069787621,
0.2847108841,
-0.0954280347,
-0.3495802283,
0.3943237364,
0.5231913328,
-0.0255245864,
-0.0245705601,
0.7057299614,
0.45573771,
-0.7572529912,
0.818171978,
-0.2120683938,
-0.5781579018,
0.7023816109,
0.4855727851,
0.4337495863,
-0.2387126386,
0.4941560924,
0.3994503617,
-0.0060488852,
-0.0615767799,
0.5596325994,
0.0576763563,
-0.7251132727,
-0.5079914927,
-0.2887358069,
-0.8529553413,
0.0002000028,
-0.592240572,
0.3964797556,
-0.3448246419,
-0.2524561584,
-0.0947128534,
-0.065868035,
-0.7095264792,
0.1744620055,
0.1730998904,
0.456084311,
-0.5321245193,
0.3771545887,
0.9251573682,
-0.508153975,
-1.0717685223,
-0.1942682117,
-0.0875886306,
-0.7239720225,
0.6604107618,
0.0863865614,
-0.1541457623,
0.2364484668,
-0.68208009,
-0.8697640896,
1.2397733927,
0.3265419602,
-0.4575226903,
0.0023895518,
0.6074693203,
0.3761511147,
-0.3457365632,
0.4624851048,
0.0879868418,
0.2667261064,
0.5665868521,
-0.7501983643,
0.0889064744,
-0.1354790777,
-0.252858609,
0.4622800648,
-0.4883381128,
1.1309782267,
-0.3954779506,
0.0402982458,
-0.0602481402,
0.3837732673,
0.6585189104,
0.3004727662,
0.4657891691,
0.5186879635,
0.8629008532,
0.1518837214,
0.494780302,
-0.18526721,
0.348839432,
1.1958097219,
-0.419300288,
0.9249303341,
0.6212352514,
-0.1966866702,
0.3527751863,
0.2826967537,
-0.1194549203,
-0.3491381407,
0.6328073144,
-0.2631387115,
-0.790702939,
0.0733540803,
-0.2489240021,
0.3249806762,
0.497315824,
-0.0844179392,
-0.178063482,
0.0013386337,
-0.033837609,
0.0296905767,
-0.202839449,
0.426574558,
-0.1160754785,
-1.1026916504,
0.2957212627,
-0.2032089978,
0.3759680092,
-0.3091121912,
-0.0842057019,
-0.1647407413,
0.0321141146,
0.0400269628,
-0.9250689745,
0.0070896125,
-0.0589815676,
0.0033262789,
-0.0045719021,
0.3315092623,
-0.549898088,
-0.8660183549,
-0.2912650704,
1.062603116,
0.1144086123,
0.0720281973,
-0.895221591,
-0.174873203,
-0.2290531695,
0.0735445619,
0.1481467783,
0.2389794886,
0.0073771202,
0.8443694115,
1.0130960941,
-0.1608536392,
0.1495681256,
0.2500768602,
0.7043987513,
-0.4431478679,
-0.2878387272,
-0.7193318605,
0.6295441389,
-0.2242521942,
-0.5085224509,
0.7670394182,
0.6282865405,
0.7714439034,
-0.1266775131,
0.9042359591,
0.2265701443,
0.6400434375,
-0.2039668113,
0.6311411858,
-0.5196765065,
0.2473975122,
-0.4893644154,
-0.9024265409,
-0.4360355139,
0.1993932128,
0.0772849917,
0.0259136651,
0.7610680461,
0.5558379292,
0.0360036194,
-0.1880723834,
0.3690477014,
-0.3954002857,
0.5094872117,
0.6694257259,
1.0985951424,
-0.3159638047,
1.0173659325,
-0.2445336878,
-0.0932875052,
-0.1184248105,
-0.5375515223,
-1.3837412596,
-0.3623345494,
-0.3647006154,
-0.14495489,
-0.4042252898,
1.1629258394,
0.3923800588,
-0.4452208281,
-0.4938994944,
-0.2552033961,
0.289298445,
0.0300376955,
-0.3086824715,
0.3110406995,
-0.2509546876,
-0.775036335,
-0.0379543751,
-0.0406128354,
0.4390995502,
-0.5021649003,
-0.0933417007,
-0.1535870284,
0.3107692003,
0.4293557703,
-0.1557395905,
-0.4636078179,
-0.1013399884,
0.3185098469,
-0.2654100955,
-0.1289538741,
0.9167048335,
-0.5812628269,
0.3661422133,
0.4067253172,
0.751087904,
0.139340952,
0.0236351583,
0.5376337171,
-0.7852761745,
-0.4436144233,
0.4135351479,
0.2070740759,
0.2145039886,
-0.1841533184,
0.3877752423,
0.2367127091,
-0.6131747365,
-0.8341987133,
0.3292463422,
-0.6624974012,
-0.1339322329,
1.0166586637,
0.1882412732,
-0.1430889964,
-0.0771945342,
-0.6910282373,
0.1319678575,
-0.344623059,
0.7253702879,
0.9224251509,
-0.2524760962,
-0.081333369,
-0.3892390132,
0.2004625201,
0.5012090206,
-1.0986344814,
-0.2203157544,
0.5208822489,
0.1860403866,
0.4154078066,
0.3656736314,
0.1639014781,
0.5402776003,
0.0751824751,
0.138587445,
-0.2753472328,
-0.0868647322,
0.3125249743,
0.3214627504,
0.0277148057,
-0.076507628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00828v1
|
WIBA: What Is Being Argued? A Comprehensive Approach to Argument Mining
| 2024-05-01T19:31:13 | 2024-05-01T19:31:13 |
Arman Irani, Ju Yeon Park, Kevin Esterling, Michalis Faloutsos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose WIBA, a novel framework and suite of methods that enable the
comprehensive understanding of "What Is Being Argued" across contexts. Our
approach develops a comprehensive framework that detects: (a) the existence,
(b) the topic, and (c) the stance of an argument, correctly accounting for the
logical dependence among the three tasks. Our algorithm leverages the
fine-tuning and prompt-engineering of Large Language Models. We evaluate our
approach and show that it performs well in all the three capabilities. First,
we develop and release an Argument Detection model that can classify a piece of
text as an argument with an F1 score between 79% and 86% on three different
benchmark datasets. Second, we release a language model that can identify the
topic being argued in a sentence, be it implicit or explicit, with an average
similarity score of 71%, outperforming current naive methods by nearly 40%.
Finally, we develop a method for Argument Stance Classification, and evaluate
the capability of our approach, showing it achieves a classification F1 score
between 71% and 78% across three diverse benchmark datasets. Our evaluation
demonstrates that WIBA allows the comprehensive understanding of What Is Being
Argued in large corpora across diverse contexts, which is of core interest to
many applications in linguistics, communication, and social and computer
science. To facilitate accessibility to the advancements outlined in this work,
we release WIBA as a free open access platform (wiba.dev).
|
[
-0.5937229395,
-1.1734721661,
0.513222754,
0.2099875361,
-0.3408832848,
-0.2117051631,
-0.1091765165,
-0.3372032642,
0.2995187342,
0.354111284,
-0.4732615352,
-0.4345931411,
-0.6618252397,
0.1126772165,
-0.4757835865,
1.0236668587,
0.1837881505,
-0.0433056243,
-0.5938464403,
-0.3558424115,
-0.5423460007,
-0.3327103257,
-0.5214407444,
-0.1900102943,
0.7619040608,
0.5441672206,
0.4292377234,
0.2243507206,
-0.108256802,
0.4269673824,
-0.2449320108,
0.1370557249,
0.056918785,
0.3806815743,
-0.5415507555,
-0.4735697508,
-0.1977785081,
-0.2155506909,
0.3576876819,
0.6438855529,
0.0574518517,
0.1828643382,
-0.3414413631,
0.5437902212,
-0.9087745547,
-0.1913609356,
-0.9204546213,
0.0345242769,
-0.5552568436,
-0.1616054177,
-0.5277506113,
0.0188679658,
0.2626054585,
-0.2015983462,
0.068228595,
-0.0200551134,
1.2497406006,
-0.1377480626,
-0.7790570855,
-0.5087445378,
-0.1236553639,
0.7050740123,
-0.9931423068,
-0.1382489651,
0.1582883149,
0.0323895887,
-0.2910600305,
-0.8714114428,
-0.7740462422,
-0.0591699257,
0.0300069991,
0.1768508703,
-0.6977213621,
0.0696714967,
0.3539503813,
0.1935469657,
-0.3027042449,
0.1946082115,
-0.2668020427,
-0.3244963586,
0.543589294,
-0.049534943,
0.2547543347,
-0.6368160844,
-0.2960303426,
0.2039096206,
-0.3399868608,
0.2295347452,
0.6262978315,
0.0364931524,
0.0262777656,
0.5953173637,
-0.2934372127,
0.7310253978,
0.0486261621,
0.2723527551,
-0.0567541569,
0.1648479402,
-0.3421583772,
0.0924848169,
1.0797138214,
0.2178217173,
-0.1689303368,
0.1862845123,
0.0892947018,
0.1242324859,
0.3339464068,
-0.7102237344,
-0.0661707893,
0.4637785852,
-0.6758954525,
-0.4452669024,
-0.0275050569,
-0.9364826083,
-0.6136626005,
-0.0330651142,
0.3956828415,
-0.0893566906,
-0.5715125799,
0.0523344986,
-0.3969554603,
0.255561024,
0.1368204057,
-0.915374577,
0.186407268,
1.0546330214,
0.8974094391,
0.0093123512,
0.0420444869,
-0.6091717482,
0.0353596695,
-0.7501214743,
1.4608099461,
-0.7112874389,
-0.3746251166,
0.1370744705,
-0.0770167932,
0.1734400541,
-0.5792262554,
1.2446660995,
-0.4015895128,
0.3267154992,
-0.3560169935,
-1.0056878328,
-0.2026471943,
0.5601785183,
-0.9523587823,
0.9885396361,
-0.3415344059,
-0.9390363693,
0.5474306941,
-0.9655413032,
-0.5876028538,
0.2087519616,
-0.2134851813,
-0.3883585632,
0.444930315,
0.0272838548,
0.4075985551,
-0.5129700303,
0.3430240154,
-0.4676982462,
0.0221085139,
0.2768437564,
-0.3038414419,
1.0192323923,
0.4535237551,
-0.5855414271,
0.3146483302,
-0.618771255,
0.0473254398,
-0.0089738658,
0.1706656814,
-0.4913806021,
0.6326176524,
-0.1792887449,
0.1637526006,
0.3100419939,
-0.7398730516,
0.0716379955,
-0.5298090577,
0.4969076514,
0.8525753617,
0.152975902,
-0.0541853569,
0.2019301206,
0.3536725342,
0.1348202676,
0.0350277126,
-0.1448108852,
-0.7483538389,
-0.8705548048,
-0.1729406863,
0.393856287,
0.3447974622,
0.1144959331,
0.6122089028,
0.0210499261,
-0.3499318957,
-0.478856504,
-0.1327192634,
-0.135861516,
0.6058601737,
0.3021155894,
0.0475089997,
-0.6195647717,
-1.1272354126,
-0.253028065,
-0.4758665562,
0.0637241453,
-0.0663182139,
0.3384944797,
-0.2264830768,
1.2889789343,
-0.3973133266,
0.0267192982,
-0.3353688419,
0.6577531099,
0.2731741965,
0.1173265055,
0.4454466999,
-0.9349274039,
-0.4553315938,
0.4290085137,
-0.6787227988,
-0.3800124824,
-0.0660965219,
-0.3576748371,
0.3560448289,
0.4817116857,
-0.598705411,
0.4445624948,
0.2671065927,
-0.6103641987,
0.4716833532,
0.1385231018,
0.0723319277,
-1.4603908062,
0.1652584374,
0.0523231626,
-0.0785996318,
-0.4755169153,
-0.0834810659,
-0.0386732556,
-0.0966980606,
-0.1251334995,
0.4499991238,
0.0161480475,
0.5301472545,
-0.7478308082,
0.101397939,
0.1821474135,
-0.0032580576,
0.0844659284,
0.1675251126,
0.5331059098,
-0.3703730106,
0.4508785307,
0.1210196242,
-0.5083266497,
0.8729892969,
-0.6599369645,
0.0667843744,
0.0424540751,
0.1242976412,
-0.7304158211,
0.0102167027,
-0.0171919223,
-0.5429374576,
-0.0817463845,
-0.4376081228,
-0.2362399846,
-0.1443367302,
-0.2385441661,
-0.0879920572,
0.0740310028,
-0.5151049495,
0.8625199199,
0.6640377641,
-0.355879277,
-0.9306022525,
-0.2877795994,
0.3410182595,
-0.3892038763,
-0.5668257475,
0.4104998708,
0.1257909834,
-0.4679875374,
0.26070261,
-0.1396568418,
-0.1254301816,
0.2477207631,
0.1336277425,
0.1998557895,
-0.1647271663,
0.1924293786,
0.2986383736,
-0.0487092957,
0.4812600315,
-0.182078585,
0.3349456787,
0.0235564597,
-0.2620004416,
-0.1173745021,
0.9465218186,
0.3722178638,
-0.2016664892,
0.5155278444,
0.4576592147,
-0.6619690061,
-0.4899707735,
-0.5074679255,
0.4477954507,
-0.4989353418,
0.4973016083,
-0.4642911553,
-0.5232927203,
0.3173944652,
-0.4069758356,
0.6942046881,
0.5626094341,
0.7609531879,
-0.3134865165,
1.1147669554,
0.50371629,
-0.2561502755,
0.2949213088,
0.0494468883,
0.6464125514,
-0.4145641029,
-0.362351954,
-0.9036241174,
-0.3123230934,
-0.5244265795,
-0.2370990515,
-0.1854432076,
0.2845535874,
-0.0168162547,
0.0852604732,
-0.2428591251,
0.3997660875,
0.1797566265,
-0.3640290797,
0.0056885667,
-0.1190145686,
-0.31481269,
0.0077263089,
-0.330629468,
-0.8694223166,
0.7154781818,
0.248657316,
0.2189494967,
0.2181384265,
0.5433750153,
0.7355898619,
0.4943732619,
-1.0794392824,
0.7230374813,
-0.0695320666,
-0.9613986611,
0.018342549,
-0.3661549389,
-1.0918426514,
0.5216713548,
-0.3722110689,
-0.8653223515,
-0.0059561855,
0.0565609187,
0.1195988953,
0.7019299269,
-0.7613200545,
1.2927023172,
-0.1611589491,
-0.4373549223,
-0.5461673141,
-0.2858870327,
0.1276866943,
0.2981841564,
0.2918212712,
-0.2722745836,
0.1241614297,
1.0290920734,
-0.6402204037,
0.6072803736,
-0.4463922679,
-0.3775467277,
0.6621690392,
-0.2799264193,
0.1339139193,
0.1721955389,
-0.2423824221,
-0.1485952735,
0.2000450194,
-0.5634893775,
-0.7145258784,
0.744376123,
-0.3636076152,
-0.845131278,
-0.5171672702,
-0.2189068645,
-0.4192207456,
0.238435626,
0.1109614447,
0.3224781454,
-0.4837993681,
0.3237580955,
0.5080484748,
-0.1349765807,
0.3823142648,
0.1967777908,
0.0497176237,
-0.4311522841,
1.033929944,
-0.0950102732,
-0.2205420882,
0.378501147,
0.6099612117,
-0.4002184868,
-0.4879009724,
-0.3807109892,
-0.0939531624,
-0.9828716516,
-0.341111362,
-0.7608913183,
0.2586864531,
-0.3939565122,
-0.0883869305,
-0.2107671052,
-0.3730543852,
0.2053881586,
-0.3733205795,
0.2509278059,
0.7090111971,
0.1064471155,
-0.0907105282,
-0.4390861094,
0.1881095767,
0.1126598418,
0.2077061683,
0.0245951861,
-0.0672807172,
-0.1454049945,
-0.2032986283,
-0.6875719428,
-1.0860332251,
-0.067996271,
0.0082090069,
0.716155231,
0.7367791533,
0.3533172607,
0.7281486988,
-0.4142674506,
0.973549664,
0.2549834251,
-1.2076147795,
0.6992243528,
0.1925117373,
-0.1809657663,
0.5244854689,
0.4395975173,
-0.5049669147,
-0.1837915778,
-0.6510531306,
-0.9887244701,
0.3069202304,
-0.2792049944,
0.250505805,
-0.4199815691,
0.0993184969,
0.0876556784,
0.0417903922,
-0.9289568067,
0.033622086,
-0.2295919955,
-0.5030661821,
0.542332828,
-0.1620905101,
-0.3057444096,
-0.2006401569,
0.5786006451,
-0.3669234812,
0.1448945552,
0.0580671169,
-0.1009588167,
0.2235229611,
0.584481895,
0.193028152,
0.4987593591,
0.2581597567,
-0.0747763216,
0.2574665844,
-0.2373600602,
-0.0169319734,
0.1464399248,
-0.3508332968,
0.334395349,
0.5537119508,
0.9033799171,
0.117524974,
-0.7185235023,
0.5198864341,
0.0323082246,
-0.6080230474,
-0.2763754427,
-0.128456831,
0.4108345807,
0.2708543241,
0.3536338508,
-0.0239011757,
0.320648998,
-0.6763084531,
-0.0055504227,
0.7196252942,
-0.3781258464,
-0.1787105352,
0.3424449563,
0.2520570159,
-0.1638379842,
0.3376405537,
0.1301833242,
-0.6044449806,
0.567928493,
0.4331766069,
0.8700734973,
0.2483692169,
0.4637202919,
0.3782252371,
-0.0917120725,
0.3432641029,
0.1450126022,
-0.4105181694,
-0.6318131089,
-0.3423038125,
-0.4863637984,
-0.6405453682,
0.1754848808,
-0.86001724,
0.4798205197,
-0.5095874071,
-0.4045977294,
0.2762425244,
0.4336636364,
-0.1528136134,
0.0833190978,
0.26508075,
1.0850974321,
-0.7962470055,
0.6708694696,
0.8330628872,
-0.1615805477,
-0.3264977634,
0.3019313514,
-0.0612160601,
0.2673543394,
0.1826329231,
0.3896805048,
-0.3871329427,
-0.4612595737,
-0.7300191522,
-0.1320030391,
0.6993271112,
0.5068656802,
-0.2248951048,
0.2464761287,
-0.2110916227,
0.3469417095,
-0.1877670437,
0.2367237508,
0.3120041788,
0.5519104004,
-0.1499717981,
-0.205601275,
-0.0195141975,
-0.5709630847,
-0.4153007865,
0.1702087075,
-0.5783182383,
0.442309171,
-0.2175542861,
-0.3734198213,
0.1097155064,
1.1392050982,
0.2367702425,
0.4133400917,
0.7692388892,
0.5191640854,
1.1343176365,
-0.1664733887,
0.6917002797,
0.1436688453,
0.0983802378,
0.8103999496,
-0.6342176795,
1.1249912977,
0.5286821723,
0.0268635005,
1.057407856,
0.679302156,
0.0983874723,
0.2261514813,
0.3271746933,
-0.638777554,
-0.4128075242,
-0.1126498878,
0.0283695515,
0.3165773153,
0.5632761121,
0.1242111176,
-0.0947627574,
-0.1544409245,
0.2361859828,
0.4772605598,
-0.1269450337,
0.8358088732,
-0.1339313537,
-0.9303739071,
0.1552623212,
0.2586760521,
0.7652148604,
-0.8998329043,
0.0456967987,
-0.0905573368,
0.0150598874,
-0.464926064,
-0.7340353131,
0.1469947398,
0.5054063201,
-0.1852253675,
0.2385238558,
0.5365949273,
-0.024582427,
-0.3915978968,
0.5328242183,
0.1125590354,
-0.1609030068,
0.4101708829,
-0.7837964296,
0.1045558676,
-0.0588199608,
-0.3830288053,
0.2446730435,
0.8915486336,
-0.3495775163,
0.3466130197,
0.641915977,
0.0754231215,
0.0171780549,
0.2113224417,
0.8599162102,
-0.6631428599,
-0.4168589413,
-0.9231035709,
0.6013607383,
-0.8426772356,
-0.5642266273,
0.4875223637,
0.6519167423,
0.519939363,
0.3161301315,
0.8425987959,
-0.5363057256,
0.3143748641,
-0.3332944214,
0.5625439882,
-0.5208364725,
-0.1355618984,
-0.5373199582,
-0.6122568846,
-0.12021254,
1.0016252995,
-0.1422348469,
-0.4344564676,
0.760139823,
0.4592195749,
-0.0995352939,
0.4573392272,
0.142278865,
-0.029552117,
0.7880417705,
0.318105191,
0.9223136306,
-0.3977743089,
0.5358577371,
0.0225243717,
-0.3654984534,
0.1059628949,
-1.2005611658,
-0.8251586556,
-0.7020571828,
-0.4859559834,
-0.3205536306,
-0.3015642464,
0.9876907468,
0.6462788582,
-1.0061153173,
-0.3020217121,
0.0454938523,
0.2483651638,
-0.3183864653,
-0.2167632729,
0.2085266411,
-0.6916632056,
-0.8293697834,
0.6007852554,
0.157673806,
-0.6901133657,
-0.1678274572,
0.0131275011,
-0.6930557489,
0.5754798651,
0.7887285352,
0.4836822748,
-0.6922416091,
-0.1768656075,
-0.4003595114,
0.194321543,
-0.0510607101,
1.032055378,
-0.561702311,
0.518432498,
0.4644254446,
0.9208772779,
0.4776483178,
-0.1399893165,
0.5918415785,
-0.4831972718,
0.2215094864,
0.1496428996,
0.7775544524,
0.2218958139,
-0.0151176034,
0.2112990469,
0.0329967476,
-0.3224198222,
-1.0039122105,
0.2364057004,
-1.0040501356,
-0.4883534908,
0.7245346904,
-0.4135094285,
-0.3042856455,
-0.2959282696,
-0.3893942833,
0.0218986776,
-0.1347611696,
0.6636414528,
1.0849509239,
0.006327366,
0.081955798,
-0.4352783859,
0.2681808174,
0.7529321909,
-0.8519053459,
0.2809059918,
0.5905742645,
0.3271636665,
0.3548857272,
0.5210236311,
-0.4188205004,
0.1577156335,
-0.1571294218,
-0.2019579709,
0.3538276255,
-0.0320989862,
-0.0922679827,
0.706608355,
0.1724263728,
-0.1205332875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00823v1
|
WorkBench: a Benchmark Dataset for Agents in a Realistic Workplace Setting
| 2024-05-01T19:07:03 | 2024-05-01T19:07:03 |
Olly Styles, Sam Miller, Patricio Cerda-Mardini, Tanaya Guha, Victor Sanchez, Bertie Vidgen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA
|
We introduce WorkBench: a benchmark dataset for evaluating agents' ability to
execute tasks in a workplace setting. WorkBench contains a sandbox environment
with five databases, 26 tools, and 690 tasks. These tasks represent common
business activities, such as sending emails and scheduling meetings. The tasks
in WorkBench are challenging as they require planning, tool selection, and
often multiple actions. If a task has been successfully executed, one (or more)
of the database values may change. The correct outcome for each task is unique
and unambiguous, which allows for robust, automated evaluation. We call this
key contribution outcome-centric evaluation. We evaluate five existing ReAct
agents on WorkBench, finding they successfully complete as few as 3% of tasks
(Llama2-70B), and just 43% for the best-performing (GPT-4). We further find
that agents' errors can result in the wrong action being taken, such as an
email being sent to the wrong person. WorkBench reveals weaknesses in agents'
ability to undertake common business activities, raising questions about their
use in high-stakes workplace settings. WorkBench is publicly available as a
free resource at https://github.com/olly-styles/WorkBench.
|
[
-0.3143851757,
-0.3848539889,
0.41231969,
0.179348886,
-0.0595637374,
0.1331944764,
-0.0030369991,
-0.6378030777,
0.0279421527,
0.2173234522,
-0.735316813,
-0.3442414105,
-0.2892078459,
0.1999824196,
-0.3163335621,
0.7873754501,
-0.1034519225,
-0.2270050794,
-0.4467165172,
-0.3204960823,
-0.7145593762,
-0.2332700342,
-0.4598607421,
-0.6657662988,
0.494228065,
0.5116022825,
0.8589461446,
0.5140403509,
0.6903331876,
0.3128136098,
0.2004172206,
-0.1660541594,
-0.8317281008,
0.3617558181,
-0.6399127245,
-0.4194143414,
-0.6015658379,
0.1416799575,
0.0369219854,
0.7382262349,
-0.4855450988,
0.3008206785,
-0.3330789804,
0.7410768867,
-0.7608485222,
0.3898784518,
-0.1774493307,
0.2020861357,
-0.2626529038,
0.4309874177,
-0.278311044,
-0.3820853531,
-0.3741795123,
-0.2931717634,
0.0935214162,
0.2400428355,
0.5168858767,
0.2538400292,
-0.4558733106,
0.3008753657,
-0.6950981021,
0.2746712267,
-0.3465866446,
0.1232726723,
0.1958679408,
0.8376469016,
-0.3763685822,
-0.8930718303,
-0.4433865249,
-0.0769715905,
0.0186118986,
0.2664644718,
-0.2372858524,
0.179178521,
0.4837938249,
0.4178814888,
-0.7357435226,
0.0240717288,
-0.1368035376,
-0.054783985,
0.6231563687,
0.6546189189,
-0.0507464409,
0.0864094421,
-0.2988194227,
-0.6668812037,
-0.39043051,
0.2810711861,
0.2209842354,
0.208229959,
0.0869382471,
0.5397814512,
-0.562455833,
0.6365765333,
0.0413744561,
0.3181409836,
0.4284662902,
-0.2641471028,
-0.1418614835,
-0.1791965067,
0.5387396812,
0.3652391434,
-0.0054630218,
-0.5518065095,
-0.369458884,
0.4567319155,
0.7762829065,
-0.7149256468,
0.0061903251,
0.355882585,
-0.329451263,
-0.4812092781,
0.1041618884,
-0.5436601043,
-0.854028821,
-0.4085609317,
0.4012881815,
-0.1122056544,
-0.1983886063,
-0.3297035694,
-0.4604583085,
0.1551551819,
0.3123206496,
-0.2404777855,
0.6713495851,
0.6812958121,
0.4383410811,
-0.3910051882,
-0.6508637071,
-0.7031275034,
-0.0862960592,
-0.5787220597,
0.7732509375,
-0.5398597717,
-0.4274988472,
-0.0967306048,
0.2114723623,
0.0349060819,
-0.7337534428,
0.2760680616,
-0.3678524494,
-0.5455331206,
-0.6067137122,
-0.2996813059,
0.0234797467,
0.3674939871,
-0.9489402771,
1.1090188026,
0.6941760778,
-0.30929178,
0.5002126694,
-0.8998585939,
-0.5180690289,
-0.0449318029,
-0.1081118435,
-0.09023875,
0.3111530542,
-0.4541992843,
0.4266904891,
-0.4171728492,
-0.0920932814,
-0.4823012054,
-0.4195162058,
0.4029680789,
0.0667858049,
0.4406248927,
0.0694142878,
-0.6931332946,
0.2246709168,
-0.6763015389,
0.1400623471,
0.0281268861,
0.0307758488,
0.2371300757,
-0.0773472339,
0.197362408,
0.5286890864,
0.097606428,
-0.7069557309,
-0.1897286922,
-0.0894679353,
-0.1743933558,
0.931444943,
-0.081006892,
0.1528149545,
-0.6286561489,
0.6082982421,
-0.1411532462,
0.4507327676,
0.436072439,
-0.0989903361,
-0.1416858137,
-0.1891009957,
0.1004588455,
0.4493310153,
-0.6250494719,
0.3178779781,
-0.3840627372,
-1.0277004242,
0.0558465458,
0.1221123561,
0.5865288377,
0.6219851375,
-0.1047301367,
-0.8814350963,
-0.1685287207,
-0.8804922104,
-0.4312513769,
0.0693459064,
0.1392145753,
0.1661696136,
0.6985809207,
-0.1405738443,
1.0811910629,
-0.3439997733,
-0.2887142003,
-0.1202470213,
0.2960706651,
0.348808676,
0.2269291729,
0.4025064111,
-0.7175721526,
-0.6370335817,
-0.0510588586,
-0.8218789697,
0.0246470813,
0.1923522204,
-0.4796821177,
0.1498285085,
0.363781333,
-0.7755294442,
0.7644931674,
0.2571313083,
-0.4625567794,
0.5908919573,
-0.0436303914,
0.0597389042,
-0.7607773542,
0.5984482169,
-0.3326735198,
-0.6174486279,
-0.5084890127,
-0.0714106634,
0.0907566175,
-0.4948215485,
-0.4804662466,
0.438808918,
-0.2372177392,
-0.5416073799,
-0.325901866,
0.1350711733,
-0.0285053868,
0.5989791155,
-0.2037088871,
0.6658938527,
0.2235288173,
-0.3150257766,
0.8487735987,
0.4331676364,
-0.2731210291,
1.2313531637,
-0.5229753852,
0.3902072906,
-0.0568127744,
0.5264211893,
-0.7520819902,
-0.4604546428,
0.105880335,
-0.1209222227,
0.0439973064,
0.2477116734,
-0.7378124595,
-0.5446974635,
-0.3622481525,
0.011284709,
0.5730304122,
-0.4974878132,
0.6140870452,
0.3010886014,
-0.0433156788,
-0.6439599395,
-0.5356713533,
0.0703485608,
0.1844622344,
-0.3772673607,
0.3200376332,
0.0559174903,
-0.2202443779,
0.3338883519,
-0.6879554987,
-0.2717541158,
0.0541085377,
0.7563311458,
-0.0474602729,
0.3075440228,
-0.1365216374,
-0.535703361,
-0.3393278718,
0.0813197419,
0.1647304296,
0.2153720111,
-0.3186717927,
-0.6039736271,
-0.1296358556,
0.35294047,
0.6905044913,
-0.1594583541,
0.6233317852,
0.6588038802,
-0.4638151228,
-0.1738701612,
-0.5147619843,
-0.2690215409,
-0.4484896362,
0.207839936,
-0.3552724719,
-0.0579263009,
0.7296361327,
-0.403139323,
0.3151133955,
0.2804256678,
0.5676777959,
-0.0534835421,
0.7689017057,
0.5059486628,
-0.1476052999,
0.5936450362,
-0.0526545048,
0.1854537725,
-0.4799908698,
-0.1323662549,
-0.3995704055,
-0.5634339452,
-0.2041250616,
-0.3533780873,
0.3593988419,
-0.4368814528,
-0.1547860503,
0.6356735826,
-0.3827042282,
0.4891196191,
0.5137647986,
0.2738494277,
-0.0915816724,
-0.2639660239,
0.0571254231,
0.2778920531,
-0.3913239539,
-0.3366509676,
1.0444699526,
-0.110210143,
0.8052530289,
0.2033433914,
0.6052752733,
0.7789291739,
0.4685409665,
-0.317002207,
0.5486877561,
0.1333928555,
-0.963822186,
-0.4559371173,
-0.2515540719,
-1.2952945232,
0.4188885391,
0.1627600044,
-0.8827963471,
0.3661626875,
0.0353708081,
-0.0658333823,
-0.1591162384,
-0.7077994943,
1.4147846699,
-0.1173724756,
-0.8262755275,
-0.5267787576,
-0.8098360896,
-0.1413754374,
-0.0552498065,
0.3439993858,
-0.5093126297,
-0.0086681983,
0.5829694867,
-0.7662326097,
0.9847195745,
-0.5739857554,
0.3749787211,
0.2146694064,
0.2344937623,
0.945648849,
-0.2604492903,
-0.4818311036,
-0.3079069555,
0.2140624821,
-0.4931218624,
-0.6892772913,
0.4608184695,
-0.4568462074,
-0.0483573154,
-0.7001758218,
-0.3803797364,
-0.6031715274,
0.4096966684,
-0.0037111505,
0.4989086092,
-0.6948713064,
0.2465623617,
0.0239595454,
0.3933682144,
0.4352650642,
0.7732948065,
0.1737262309,
-0.1630600095,
0.8312891722,
0.0347464345,
0.0778483525,
-0.0993500724,
-0.093471922,
-0.3775004148,
-0.1416243464,
-0.1391588151,
-0.1236609444,
-1.1315829754,
-0.4219717979,
0.0759594217,
0.3158878982,
0.0970553309,
-0.2959322631,
-0.651725471,
-0.1771231592,
0.2022552788,
-0.1772449911,
0.06063357,
0.7638106942,
-0.2108300328,
0.0902097076,
-0.3908964396,
0.4167537689,
0.4235884845,
0.7523162365,
-0.3059744835,
0.2467424124,
-0.4356684089,
-0.1967677772,
-0.5424218774,
-0.9532923102,
0.1189567745,
0.0774191022,
0.8405139446,
0.0278078504,
0.4725696743,
0.2615863979,
-0.2218112797,
0.5476418138,
-0.0196293443,
-0.8847573996,
0.2220550478,
-0.3794187307,
0.2140270323,
1.075602293,
0.1161740348,
-0.4350346923,
-0.1476453692,
-1.0437290668,
-0.7550824881,
1.0875906944,
0.5412240624,
-0.2022855282,
0.2947743237,
0.0611919165,
0.0892968699,
0.6931633949,
-0.360001862,
-0.0765966177,
-0.1296021193,
-0.3256724179,
-0.3195620477,
0.2534506023,
-0.6452553868,
0.066919215,
0.3697001338,
-0.2124734819,
0.3557362258,
-0.0584598221,
-0.3127698302,
-0.2528423965,
0.1889713854,
0.1156505942,
1.027670145,
-0.2778678834,
-0.0175419841,
0.3376166523,
-0.2792858779,
0.2179083079,
0.332770437,
0.6896231174,
-0.0167628042,
0.1174847111,
0.5810921192,
0.1736961454,
-1.0011796951,
0.7042104602,
-0.0779610723,
-0.1177136004,
-0.3492364287,
0.2243189365,
-0.1005827636,
0.3687996268,
0.151127398,
0.1894250214,
0.2980264425,
-0.7708070874,
0.0542715266,
0.085965395,
-0.5683652163,
-0.1551503241,
0.4194073379,
0.2499288172,
-0.3404061496,
0.4442788064,
-0.5373570919,
-0.2513996959,
1.0408941507,
0.2499553859,
0.8128753901,
-0.1272261441,
0.1453777105,
-0.1289296299,
0.218192935,
-0.2467032969,
0.6333767772,
0.071727246,
-0.261122793,
-0.0376335829,
-0.1944552809,
-1.1105110645,
-0.334798336,
-0.676507175,
-0.1592207551,
-0.4744053781,
-0.4428778589,
0.0772953406,
0.0534278303,
-1.070920229,
0.3031921089,
-0.215126127,
0.8477416635,
-0.7853934765,
0.270730406,
0.8950859904,
-0.1425849646,
-0.5680799484,
-0.3790508509,
0.2362665236,
-0.4475702643,
0.3334009647,
0.2099206001,
-0.1310386658,
-0.3390876949,
-0.2008991092,
-0.6642781496,
1.1853946447,
0.3868600726,
-0.3118573427,
0.4561893046,
0.2888913453,
0.7516847849,
-0.1965929121,
0.3708785176,
0.6947276592,
0.7188802958,
-0.2588807344,
-1.0522869825,
0.4634779692,
-0.4971772432,
-0.0282894913,
0.0797812566,
-0.7611507773,
0.8501009941,
0.1821765751,
0.0660084486,
-0.3291260302,
0.0559614189,
0.0361058339,
0.4569439292,
0.7088019252,
0.4034976661,
0.9077913165,
-0.1858880073,
1.2630239725,
-0.2007594407,
0.1241288036,
0.9368276596,
-0.7011015415,
0.8579502702,
0.2342532873,
-0.2475633621,
0.659401238,
0.5674479604,
-0.0183278322,
0.3889580071,
0.2708593905,
0.0024907258,
-0.2166698873,
-0.1661821157,
-0.223016426,
0.470484525,
0.0575516969,
0.2149269283,
-0.2751360238,
0.0657582432,
-0.1880371422,
-0.1764039099,
0.0708278194,
0.7574255466,
-0.0470635891,
-0.7618806958,
0.4641422331,
-0.2241983861,
-0.1842149943,
-0.5237852335,
0.05062747,
-0.1047513932,
0.4721935093,
-0.3746263385,
-0.6092504859,
0.2599307299,
-0.0904011652,
-0.006569121,
-0.2080286443,
0.7175056934,
0.2780192792,
0.0244667344,
0.2269026786,
0.4683240652,
0.0738541111,
-0.5403924584,
-0.6192375422,
0.1394652277,
-0.5751055479,
-0.4666767418,
0.3336865008,
0.2564558685,
-0.1353346407,
0.5692901611,
0.432988584,
-0.2285254151,
-0.2902318537,
0.0398478583,
0.927898407,
-0.6550796032,
-0.6443652511,
-0.3685304523,
0.5866639018,
-0.6843286157,
-0.1767728329,
0.4819566309,
0.6549397707,
0.5044654012,
-0.249543637,
0.8215313554,
-0.4586215317,
0.4734168649,
0.0953275934,
0.3799240887,
-0.5399704576,
-0.3972937763,
-0.3773951828,
-0.9686619043,
0.2253832519,
0.430157274,
-0.2532946765,
0.1426142901,
1.0137974024,
0.6937763095,
-0.0423834249,
0.0871208161,
0.2554287612,
0.0181898549,
0.3189756274,
0.5463439226,
0.698443532,
-0.2995071709,
0.8324463367,
-0.4824672043,
-0.2848912776,
-0.610556066,
-0.7916058898,
-0.8917807341,
-0.3227165639,
-0.2860815823,
-0.275141418,
0.213703081,
0.7733345032,
0.909773469,
-0.5893734694,
-0.4619850516,
-0.2580131292,
0.0610667616,
-0.8931989074,
-0.1618842036,
-0.0085628051,
-0.4653329551,
-0.3224070966,
0.4949172139,
0.0433102362,
-0.2096084505,
0.1549960524,
-0.0894747376,
0.3993209004,
0.0707280561,
0.3364870548,
0.6264711618,
-0.1851419061,
-0.1286652684,
-0.2147091925,
-0.4126922488,
-0.0436395667,
0.5911019444,
-0.6320309639,
0.5069627762,
0.5585890412,
0.6974354386,
0.8272013664,
0.1207582429,
0.7008426785,
-0.8374707699,
0.1330167949,
0.2675364017,
0.193847388,
0.1292297095,
-0.1679163426,
1.0380145311,
0.1865004152,
-0.5186447501,
-0.8767722249,
-0.0534067713,
-0.9819850922,
-0.2195513248,
0.6020145416,
0.003318202,
-0.3605768681,
-0.2219692767,
-0.2236686498,
0.1722477376,
-0.4250868559,
0.7492543459,
0.6667792201,
-0.4105812013,
0.1118315309,
-0.6833117008,
0.457215935,
0.5335303545,
-1.1900231838,
0.2649944723,
0.633954525,
0.2228287756,
0.0413555391,
0.7139862776,
0.1841839254,
0.8555532098,
0.5127195716,
0.1970986426,
-0.2954734564,
-0.2241067141,
0.1419058144,
0.2731290162,
0.2187971175,
-0.3287849724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00821v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00821v1
|
Uncovering Agendas: A Novel French & English Dataset for Agenda Detection on Social Media
| 2024-05-01T19:02:35 | 2024-05-01T19:02:35 |
Gregorios Katsios, Ning Sa, Ankita Bhaumik, Tomek Strzalkowski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The behavior and decision making of groups or communities can be dramatically
influenced by individuals pushing particular agendas, e.g., to promote or
disparage a person or an activity, to call for action, etc.. In the examination
of online influence campaigns, particularly those related to important
political and social events, scholars often concentrate on identifying the
sources responsible for setting and controlling the agenda (e.g., public
media). In this article we present a methodology for detecting specific
instances of agenda control through social media where annotated data is
limited or non-existent. By using a modest corpus of Twitter messages centered
on the 2022 French Presidential Elections, we carry out a comprehensive
evaluation of various approaches and techniques that can be applied to this
problem. Our findings demonstrate that by treating the task as a textual
entailment problem, it is possible to overcome the requirement for a large
annotated training dataset.
|
[
-0.5810834765,
-0.9714539051,
0.6736897826,
0.4548088014,
-0.2353869677,
-0.0617104582,
-0.168081373,
-0.148697257,
0.7741766572,
0.7404128909,
-0.7156003714,
-0.6958013177,
-1.0262693167,
-0.1162336096,
-0.570659101,
0.7697120309,
-0.1431709826,
-0.1891991645,
-0.0132274264,
-0.1283570677,
-0.2810297906,
-0.1483368129,
-0.6595876217,
-0.2707678974,
0.6387087703,
0.2800484002,
0.2815360725,
0.8669155836,
0.4228249788,
0.1413649768,
-0.0006679499,
0.6855893135,
-0.9876549244,
-0.2061545104,
-0.1812284887,
-0.1254215389,
-0.0637990087,
0.0905186608,
0.5149102211,
0.1791188866,
0.317623347,
0.2318797261,
0.2580236793,
0.7317652106,
-0.6998077035,
0.2841959894,
-0.7358811498,
-0.4193675816,
-0.3972320855,
-0.7349467874,
-0.1631553024,
-0.3520584106,
-0.1986038387,
-0.5244829655,
0.0452134125,
-0.1994140744,
0.6623913646,
0.1472983658,
-0.5522606373,
-0.6294982433,
-0.833070457,
0.7067360282,
-0.0635020509,
0.2782266438,
0.8445177078,
0.0300790276,
-0.2171742767,
-0.4500326514,
-0.2720680237,
0.4913137853,
0.0845195279,
0.1186859012,
-0.0944396183,
-0.2057483047,
0.0825527534,
-0.3679195046,
-0.1043280661,
-0.0219252426,
-0.3021570444,
-0.0150870932,
0.6893004179,
-0.2228425443,
0.2833935916,
-0.2818087935,
-0.2216926813,
0.2517405748,
-0.7518335581,
-0.1373945177,
0.5814360976,
0.2850148976,
-0.2758342922,
0.6498715281,
-0.3811065555,
0.4190487862,
0.0903834552,
0.3968574107,
-0.0273284223,
-0.304843694,
0.1329659224,
0.1922945529,
0.6418930292,
0.5488684773,
0.4633303285,
0.1982717067,
-0.1562967449,
0.1852600574,
0.0142013058,
-0.596200943,
-0.2243859768,
0.5406245589,
-0.4825614691,
-0.1465062648,
0.2426932603,
-0.7799667716,
-0.7026198506,
-0.4004584849,
0.4127336442,
-0.0721294731,
-0.0541497767,
-0.1785717905,
-0.3409793377,
0.243930608,
0.5438640714,
-0.5457369685,
-0.1061713398,
0.9353502989,
0.9402874708,
-0.0145223858,
0.2552762032,
-0.4981731772,
0.077927351,
-0.5013747215,
0.8858698606,
-0.911963284,
-0.3793691993,
0.4705354273,
0.1906404346,
0.2012348473,
-0.2183694243,
0.6212477088,
-0.4925384223,
-0.1322896034,
-0.4184422195,
-0.6242257357,
-0.0719297528,
0.0673788339,
-0.7863559723,
0.9043069482,
-0.2680019736,
-0.4878578484,
0.4825782776,
-0.7221108079,
-0.4712684453,
0.0151243052,
-0.6037641168,
-0.2759327888,
0.0046243239,
0.8633660078,
0.6948077083,
-0.0793500915,
0.2943620682,
-0.2025121599,
-0.1597076654,
0.0527106598,
-0.2285614759,
0.972722888,
-0.4064099491,
-0.4656055868,
0.274431318,
-0.493599087,
-0.480944097,
0.1776753068,
0.0086936606,
-0.476982981,
0.5957832336,
0.1786660552,
0.0822833702,
0.3566645384,
-0.4564358592,
0.1145313308,
0.0968824029,
0.5252134204,
0.8183779716,
0.8669774532,
0.6342825294,
-0.5706400275,
-0.0665484518,
-0.3303416669,
0.1027053073,
-0.1952305883,
-0.8348898888,
-0.5865057707,
-0.0506852269,
0.0043357252,
0.5487407446,
-0.811049521,
0.4594434202,
-0.23358877,
-0.4196438789,
-0.3914456367,
0.2868835032,
-0.1877172589,
-0.0861423984,
0.2649475336,
0.3095371425,
-0.5454826355,
-0.9175406098,
-0.5654068589,
0.1845284551,
-0.1905458868,
0.3043323755,
0.8542736769,
0.0469000563,
0.6463205218,
-0.1657179743,
-0.5826680064,
-0.2289024442,
0.4547618032,
0.1114538088,
0.354979068,
0.3805401921,
-1.1417902708,
-0.4062026739,
-0.0258062016,
-0.5543590784,
-0.1960646957,
-0.4283308089,
-0.2151770741,
-0.1709887683,
0.6335805058,
-0.0912821665,
0.663021028,
0.2773510516,
-0.1081144214,
-0.1740980744,
0.0895827487,
0.4513399303,
-0.8419983983,
-0.3633368313,
0.5123912692,
-0.2899692357,
-0.7044991851,
-0.3695112765,
0.2220949382,
0.213833034,
-0.513551116,
0.4614042342,
-0.2647539973,
0.4843003452,
-0.3092286587,
0.3337648213,
-0.1384735703,
0.2303191125,
0.1597217619,
0.2720080018,
0.3319704235,
-0.5243113041,
-0.0491747707,
0.4283200502,
-0.587642014,
0.5035077929,
-0.4509138763,
0.4671626687,
-0.7181643844,
0.1657947302,
-1.1840516329,
-0.4285362661,
0.2505931258,
-0.5046423078,
-0.0899317935,
-0.2860308588,
-0.4904443026,
-0.0227983259,
-0.2849330306,
-0.2958784103,
0.2631004155,
-0.491074115,
0.5357045531,
0.9139804244,
0.2060638666,
-0.3998911083,
-0.4883709252,
0.0388102308,
-0.2636189461,
-0.1164713278,
0.1862768829,
0.5473915935,
-0.3829341233,
0.1853237301,
-0.0384537615,
0.036211513,
-0.2169004679,
0.3516384959,
-0.2020432502,
0.2559965551,
0.2181148231,
0.2245971113,
0.118509151,
-0.0560668893,
-0.3665987849,
0.5317075253,
0.414205879,
-0.1940786541,
-0.6261072755,
0.5438778996,
0.4359701276,
-0.4840154052,
0.6703113914,
0.5573844314,
-0.8528823853,
-0.4205568433,
-0.6412430406,
-0.4334150255,
-0.4340882599,
0.2816312611,
0.2421208024,
-0.7309666872,
0.7132970095,
-0.2947563529,
0.1973750144,
0.5329125524,
0.6313281655,
0.0581906438,
1.106110692,
0.4209423661,
-0.2652140856,
0.5472031236,
-0.3886810839,
-0.0563695319,
-0.4977955222,
-0.1979470849,
-0.6800647378,
-0.5104855299,
-0.8171523213,
-0.6188428402,
0.1541119516,
-0.2570984364,
-0.1060748398,
0.2094608098,
-0.8233658075,
0.5551115274,
0.4258933067,
0.3801308274,
-0.0180667918,
-0.0166349262,
0.7771877646,
0.0601092577,
-0.4883038402,
-0.7394244075,
0.9983308911,
-0.0674587488,
0.4589618146,
-0.077143088,
0.7172632813,
0.5956991315,
0.550481379,
-0.6050986648,
0.4780569077,
-0.0653483868,
-0.8645641804,
-0.4001936316,
-0.2797191441,
-0.9775258303,
0.0420552641,
-0.5539724231,
-1.1970667839,
0.5858793259,
-0.093473956,
0.0604811162,
0.4343436062,
-0.2367136478,
0.7182568908,
-0.4166177213,
-0.5717201233,
-0.1106216386,
-0.3017575741,
-0.1062457338,
-0.2242827415,
0.404419899,
-0.5664397478,
-0.403298378,
1.1447662115,
0.2762326002,
0.8262776732,
-0.2143015116,
0.2483841181,
0.312689662,
-0.2608188987,
1.0066490173,
0.2000943571,
0.1671582907,
0.1839341521,
-0.2351438254,
-0.2982993126,
-0.354456991,
0.7142271996,
-0.4678660929,
-0.4582977891,
0.0267285053,
-0.4317764044,
0.074094519,
0.2931386828,
0.4593193233,
0.4405856133,
-0.4612798989,
0.463838011,
0.5035974383,
0.0872818902,
0.4056978226,
0.2191649526,
-0.0725691989,
-0.0844777673,
0.9938219786,
0.7027831078,
-0.2997442782,
0.629537046,
0.1996501386,
-0.317524761,
-0.4366608262,
-0.1310655922,
0.0878047198,
-0.6153734326,
0.1411038041,
-0.6269336939,
0.2603164613,
-0.1991306394,
-0.3482281268,
-0.292307049,
-0.2644008398,
-0.6419975758,
-0.0558954068,
0.4417050779,
1.0536921024,
0.0570702702,
0.5274270773,
-0.1856263578,
0.2029178441,
-0.056441132,
0.079685241,
-0.3040303588,
0.0486248136,
-0.0816754252,
0.0165733173,
-0.3296369612,
-1.5202562809,
0.3517753482,
0.2077414691,
0.3125109673,
0.8186226487,
0.2949641049,
0.1991092712,
-0.4471699893,
0.4574986398,
-0.3626265228,
-0.6581391096,
0.8279489875,
-0.910372436,
0.1784035712,
0.5460527539,
0.9706708193,
-0.2818830013,
-0.4665094316,
-0.7201625705,
-1.0098249912,
0.4531407058,
0.4063242972,
0.1978212893,
-0.196699053,
0.3942603469,
-0.287281841,
0.410849005,
-0.2700282335,
-0.3821482956,
0.0923688635,
-0.0615624227,
-0.0830761343,
-0.1999175102,
-0.3207590878,
-0.0952926129,
0.7061065435,
0.1328906119,
0.1803662181,
0.3629527688,
0.2588842809,
-0.1580999494,
-0.0579237528,
0.4714770913,
0.819981277,
-0.3514330983,
-0.0427639075,
-0.169041574,
-0.1325376928,
-0.0551651567,
0.0232205614,
-0.4457470179,
0.260954529,
0.284642756,
0.5927727818,
-0.0009597286,
-0.267894417,
0.3714538813,
0.1943349242,
-0.4336749017,
-0.5156407952,
-0.3645467758,
0.3361372948,
0.1205257475,
0.7190813422,
-0.3655899167,
0.1427263767,
-0.5132283568,
0.4795188606,
0.5854299664,
-0.9987725019,
-0.2134117186,
0.8131687045,
0.2812483013,
-0.5924526453,
0.170470953,
-0.3421612978,
-0.5220944285,
0.9568204284,
0.1312534809,
0.6809568405,
-0.2919970751,
0.2389570922,
0.1192915738,
0.9170584679,
-0.0314670056,
0.3437740803,
0.1610245258,
-0.8940062523,
-0.5074651241,
0.0496765375,
-0.3064130545,
0.7102405429,
-0.613992691,
0.4219013751,
-0.4205746055,
-0.3303410411,
0.6248502731,
-0.1535626054,
-0.6927200556,
-0.1087563559,
-0.2196180969,
0.7583521605,
-1.0190290213,
0.439666003,
0.6833292842,
0.1585631073,
-0.3278886974,
0.1300760061,
0.4546127319,
-0.6297387481,
0.3554515541,
0.2687721848,
0.2205910683,
0.0250874516,
-0.7265459895,
-0.5153594017,
0.450488776,
0.0156354159,
-0.405174464,
0.2852843702,
0.0417067148,
0.115215309,
-0.4655569494,
-0.2197205275,
0.5571070313,
0.8154994845,
-0.3569658995,
-0.3041065633,
-0.0131640434,
-0.112271525,
-0.5182090402,
0.7625856996,
-0.5884607434,
0.6950204372,
0.2490724772,
-0.4541096985,
-0.4923591316,
0.472992003,
-0.4480500519,
0.5210195184,
0.3558817804,
0.0002071047,
0.6634476781,
-0.4051351547,
0.9136630893,
-0.4916791022,
0.2980956435,
0.8076970577,
-0.2149087638,
0.6990606785,
0.4566296935,
0.2539665699,
-0.0444340371,
0.6517727971,
0.1223498434,
0.4728355706,
0.0031095373,
-0.245272845,
-0.5509644747,
-0.5120232105,
0.0731023923,
0.5282170773,
1.0386494398,
-0.3311883211,
-0.3618675172,
0.1322306842,
0.0166795272,
0.3654665053,
-0.5869019628,
0.7179724574,
-0.1292696297,
-0.4137614667,
0.0250275899,
-0.2189227194,
0.2256561071,
-0.4735605121,
-0.3252577186,
0.3001516163,
0.0063406019,
-0.1864845157,
-0.6575725675,
0.1830752641,
-0.2652206719,
0.2088291198,
-0.2028846443,
0.9063515067,
-0.3522748053,
-0.4511495829,
0.3442290127,
0.7598777413,
-0.1101023108,
-0.2400700301,
-0.4346145988,
0.0665563494,
0.0843901783,
-0.2884970605,
-0.0570159368,
0.3055119812,
-0.373825103,
0.4015017152,
0.5534764528,
0.114974685,
-0.5102992654,
-0.249380663,
0.699095726,
-0.0669327155,
-0.4092182517,
-0.8209835291,
0.1420878768,
-0.534678638,
-0.2686855495,
1.0059161186,
0.5395285487,
0.8102289438,
0.1385815144,
1.0986055136,
0.0440460183,
0.5113379955,
-0.2525023818,
0.7456341386,
-0.6039574742,
0.0616300181,
-0.0153463874,
-0.6784673929,
-0.3420062661,
0.6609127522,
-0.7166198492,
-0.2821081281,
0.2169970572,
0.7655308843,
-0.013496994,
0.2099044621,
-0.0353164226,
-0.0004550276,
0.3033584952,
0.1229045466,
0.7199990749,
0.0683548599,
0.2858244479,
-0.3401728272,
-0.4207960069,
-0.3465634286,
-0.8409189582,
-1.2878332138,
-0.9671798348,
-0.2525730729,
-0.4340164661,
0.3974913061,
1.1477417946,
0.5492019057,
-0.866384089,
-0.0699283257,
-0.1429864466,
0.6108306646,
-0.2619802356,
-0.1363634765,
0.8835567832,
0.1005249321,
-0.9965021014,
0.1801392287,
0.4001427293,
-0.2053817064,
-0.1429721266,
0.587287724,
-0.6820389628,
0.6283372045,
0.3340248466,
0.2453226298,
-0.435143441,
-0.5228204131,
0.013330549,
0.2425870746,
-0.0376348197,
0.9998336434,
-0.2712926865,
0.4835037589,
0.6078953743,
0.5525712967,
0.5843030214,
0.0550667904,
0.1589840949,
-0.9298583269,
0.286960721,
0.2856685519,
0.2907621264,
0.197720468,
-0.3933906257,
0.4634641707,
0.0430594385,
-0.6240487695,
-0.5000053644,
0.1580206901,
-0.8515977859,
-0.2332822233,
1.2436710596,
0.4729609787,
-0.3716699183,
-0.5141723156,
-0.2595054507,
0.1963758767,
-0.7718093991,
0.7182808518,
0.6497118473,
-0.1117210835,
-0.0310186744,
-1.0441404581,
0.5753147602,
-0.0827109963,
-0.5731319785,
0.0072636693,
0.1969731599,
-0.3541292846,
0.381220907,
0.7435659766,
0.2224307358,
-0.0259912498,
-0.2742215097,
-0.3605411053,
0.146612227,
-0.3759265244,
0.1433281004,
0.2338722348,
-0.6762439013,
-0.2607365847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00801v2
|
"Ask Me Anything": How Comcast Uses LLMs to Assist Agents in Real Time
| 2024-05-01T18:31:36 | 2024-05-06T16:15:32 |
Scott Rome, Tianwen Chen, Raphael Tang, Luwei Zhou, Ferhan Ture
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Customer service is how companies interface with their customers. It can
contribute heavily towards the overall customer satisfaction. However,
high-quality service can become expensive, creating an incentive to make it as
cost efficient as possible and prompting most companies to utilize AI-powered
assistants, or "chat bots". On the other hand, human-to-human interaction is
still desired by customers, especially when it comes to complex scenarios such
as disputes and sensitive topics like bill payment.
This raises the bar for customer service agents. They need to accurately
understand the customer's question or concern, identify a solution that is
acceptable yet feasible (and within the company's policy), all while handling
multiple conversations at once.
In this work, we introduce "Ask Me Anything" (AMA) as an add-on feature to an
agent-facing customer service interface. AMA allows agents to ask questions to
a large language model (LLM) on demand, as they are handling customer
conversations -- the LLM provides accurate responses in real-time, reducing the
amount of context switching the agent needs. In our internal experiments, we
find that agents using AMA versus a traditional search experience spend
approximately 10% fewer seconds per conversation containing a search,
translating to millions of dollars of savings annually. Agents that used the
AMA feature provided positive feedback nearly 80% of the time, demonstrating
its usefulness as an AI-assisted feature for customer care.
|
[
-0.578838706,
-1.0429567099,
0.4753336012,
0.2430872619,
-0.0404125154,
0.1763972491,
0.2666933537,
-0.7620102167,
0.5387402177,
0.6613001227,
-0.7821314931,
0.1508530974,
-0.1750192791,
0.0173795391,
-0.3346125782,
0.5760475397,
0.0055824481,
0.0953805819,
0.0065267305,
0.1167886332,
-0.5274428129,
-0.5680733323,
-1.2612051964,
0.0437466837,
0.6794310808,
0.7626197338,
1.226156354,
0.7111742496,
0.3929795623,
0.368134737,
0.1134427562,
0.5823241472,
-0.1361824721,
0.6351029277,
0.1076570377,
-0.5393735766,
-0.7063617706,
0.3267400265,
0.3238896132,
0.7592102289,
-0.2800501883,
0.2014002651,
-0.213163361,
0.5697020292,
-0.5079078674,
-0.1408634335,
-0.6216945052,
0.2536999583,
0.4119804502,
-0.5125206709,
0.0917640775,
-0.416472137,
0.4573788643,
-0.8250290155,
0.0875709355,
0.2286828756,
0.9778187275,
0.4543631673,
-0.4717037082,
-0.5486704707,
-0.8569359183,
0.3697489798,
-0.0493563004,
0.4140706658,
0.540397048,
0.518830955,
0.0114252856,
-0.5857955813,
-0.6719723344,
-0.3556274474,
-0.0743794963,
0.1326510757,
-0.5431050062,
-0.0078140078,
0.1582044214,
0.0048669656,
-0.6169658899,
-0.1338638812,
0.0675923303,
0.0004143756,
0.4326165318,
0.5574896932,
0.2005349547,
0.151859194,
-0.007607263,
0.016789047,
-0.5233060718,
0.4026221633,
0.1712362915,
-0.1222906411,
0.0514973924,
0.579092443,
-0.1954545379,
0.5646967888,
0.0575546511,
0.3973950446,
-0.6195375919,
-0.0956012309,
-0.3495872021,
0.0744065866,
0.1890868396,
0.3168021739,
0.3228791356,
-0.0529672764,
0.2971941829,
-0.1109437272,
0.4770173728,
-0.5682873726,
0.0890210867,
0.6043783426,
-0.4316588342,
-0.1788739413,
0.0503873676,
-0.3698779643,
-0.5056141615,
-0.40705809,
0.0730127916,
-0.0117265573,
-0.0995922089,
-0.1010645032,
-0.1921865493,
0.5702057481,
0.6321932673,
-0.413932234,
0.2193262577,
0.7518385649,
0.5690994859,
0.15953511,
-0.3629946709,
-1.0615972281,
0.0824475363,
-0.3612836599,
1.1170768738,
-0.6359027624,
-0.3857702911,
0.1936090887,
0.2051502764,
-0.2387930751,
-0.6567877531,
-0.0492392667,
-0.7593570948,
0.0462113433,
-0.1424626559,
-0.303838253,
0.1377193034,
0.8164767623,
-0.3469446301,
0.5683557391,
0.1228697449,
-0.083934091,
0.1224913299,
-0.8475947976,
-0.2676236331,
0.1610554159,
-0.0175347682,
-0.2755727768,
0.0627509207,
0.0147556262,
0.4903098047,
-0.3604803383,
-0.2659590542,
-0.2843563259,
-0.3051375151,
1.1090109348,
-0.6968135238,
0.4620605409,
0.6296210885,
-0.344832629,
-0.3135652244,
-0.6136991978,
0.0089710401,
0.0849838033,
-0.3705380857,
0.0385312736,
0.072193712,
-0.2332963794,
0.0131332055,
0.4956068099,
-0.5248716474,
0.2087991238,
-0.3269161582,
0.1448674649,
0.6816652417,
0.2229908854,
0.4428813457,
-0.6694204211,
0.9281069636,
-0.0308691375,
0.6048561931,
-0.2444703877,
-0.4621546865,
-1.1226038933,
-0.0736799389,
-0.136635676,
0.6447211504,
-0.8621973395,
0.119118847,
-0.3319728673,
-0.3803789914,
-0.8235217929,
0.1204550937,
0.2522371113,
0.2171511799,
-0.0265721735,
-0.0015278528,
-0.274384886,
-0.6449947953,
-0.1789843291,
0.0065394598,
-0.0036168811,
0.7674415708,
-0.2555837333,
0.0416604206,
1.1990561485,
-0.8040641546,
-0.1911415756,
-0.2026424408,
-0.0295471884,
-0.0219965056,
0.1310113817,
0.1725771874,
-0.888730526,
-0.9606359005,
0.1329384744,
-0.7643710375,
-0.2063958049,
-0.1963844746,
-0.0331513956,
0.3003046811,
0.377430886,
-0.6670844555,
0.5394142866,
0.4592149556,
-0.7524386644,
0.2765948474,
-0.719350338,
0.4089576602,
-0.7694690228,
-0.0313999318,
-0.3489064574,
-0.4842123985,
-0.8443859816,
-0.1776929647,
-0.2387785167,
-0.6556293964,
-0.8428930044,
0.6812191606,
-0.473372519,
-0.2961025536,
-0.3987270594,
0.1332754046,
0.2851085365,
0.4323438406,
-0.2000799477,
1.1064213514,
0.2618881762,
-1.1407473087,
0.4536477923,
0.4405958951,
0.0229319278,
1.1877981424,
-0.5577274561,
0.2879831791,
-0.0901204273,
0.0587256141,
-1.0888003111,
-0.0472910926,
0.4295806885,
-0.6877505183,
-0.285994947,
0.0381981954,
-0.4371263981,
-0.0853443518,
-0.1621519178,
0.1124439314,
0.2508587241,
-0.569318831,
0.9521402121,
0.5760247707,
-0.3480974436,
-0.2632770538,
-0.6338909268,
0.4066601098,
-0.004264852,
-0.7867828012,
-0.1818432361,
-0.2763841748,
-0.3387420774,
-0.0154918311,
0.0597222261,
-0.5439158678,
0.5200482607,
0.2435065657,
0.1812305897,
0.0586368367,
0.0773475245,
0.0883804187,
-0.3706283867,
-0.1260200441,
-0.2066512108,
0.934446156,
0.0760477632,
-0.5323702693,
-0.6247347593,
0.8424175382,
0.6431753635,
-0.2366959155,
0.4047785997,
0.1456759572,
0.0237891693,
-0.0129133193,
-0.9003095627,
-0.0496443585,
-0.5188395977,
-0.0684863254,
-0.3794884384,
-0.8826370835,
0.5984574556,
-0.0204759333,
0.2122798711,
-0.260461539,
0.3906171322,
-0.704613328,
1.5438082218,
0.4858741164,
0.0752810165,
0.7688091993,
-0.1953499317,
0.2657726407,
-0.5060793757,
-0.3446891904,
-0.7793242931,
-0.36141482,
-0.3602972329,
-0.246406734,
0.7623295784,
-0.5721442699,
-0.1833698601,
0.3119469285,
-0.3188382089,
0.133013159,
0.6110267639,
0.0543481112,
0.4272310734,
-0.0454179905,
0.308973968,
0.2125018984,
-0.7230560184,
-0.3711699545,
0.5186671615,
0.4131317735,
0.8750270009,
0.2791076601,
0.1280611902,
0.7474676371,
0.3002824783,
-0.7914845347,
0.5377206206,
-0.0138749909,
-0.7027323842,
-0.2323777527,
-0.3720281124,
-1.5988286734,
0.126638487,
-0.0795236453,
-0.2922642231,
0.5298917294,
0.4907205999,
-0.529810071,
0.1157492101,
-0.7192349434,
0.4116350114,
-0.4626902044,
-0.1137777343,
-0.2319963276,
-0.4199262857,
-0.401946485,
0.2197380513,
0.2170172781,
-0.2563748062,
-0.4083049893,
0.3681156337,
-0.5917776227,
0.6647312641,
-0.0891674981,
-0.1824077219,
0.3931223154,
0.3238041997,
0.7598618269,
-0.1647415161,
0.0159830544,
-0.1538677514,
0.1215545684,
-0.5639135242,
-0.829013586,
0.5835867524,
-0.6610510945,
-0.3455766439,
-0.4969220161,
-0.6610649824,
-0.3302785456,
-0.0668108687,
-0.2118543237,
0.2184517831,
-0.21405527,
0.0202944297,
0.5744211078,
-0.1360835582,
0.5473530889,
1.116977334,
-0.0648802072,
-0.3637019396,
1.0149296522,
0.2937253714,
0.2129170895,
0.4119990468,
-0.0342848152,
-0.2381166518,
0.1627585292,
-0.364752233,
0.2147212774,
-0.6529380083,
-0.1126623899,
-0.8733380437,
0.035840515,
-0.4136114419,
-0.3636462986,
-0.3361001909,
-0.3312683105,
-0.2881312668,
0.0813717917,
0.1743166596,
0.3494749367,
0.226148054,
0.8875765204,
-0.9730885029,
0.2652131021,
0.7119671702,
0.1798907816,
-0.1445049047,
-0.1742549986,
-0.3721015453,
0.0915353671,
-0.3500517607,
-0.5642054081,
0.5056722164,
0.2066517472,
0.5616255999,
0.5457341671,
0.1136011183,
0.6301363111,
-0.2194055319,
0.8302947879,
-0.1369516999,
-0.8030001521,
0.0113510564,
-0.1489305198,
0.226406306,
0.4797534943,
0.2732088268,
-0.8405445814,
-0.4525382221,
-0.765286386,
-0.5364512205,
0.571500659,
0.1683133245,
0.5517202616,
-0.1130278781,
0.3468858004,
-0.2844259441,
0.6732373238,
-0.0785161257,
-0.6996806264,
0.1336917877,
0.1682133228,
0.1287124455,
-0.3071453273,
-0.0140076345,
-0.0400789715,
0.352866739,
-0.1209271029,
0.6447659731,
0.3264422417,
-0.0839574561,
-0.2719221711,
0.3854802251,
0.5455556512,
0.7449722886,
-0.3303088546,
0.1479234397,
0.1735336483,
-0.2141091824,
0.1768352538,
0.1197443455,
0.0036961674,
0.0688425377,
-0.2212498635,
0.587044239,
-0.0690555722,
-1.0012531281,
0.4691692293,
-0.3572824299,
-0.2251106203,
-0.598308742,
0.1383229792,
-0.1366148591,
0.3401231766,
0.4816110134,
-0.227969408,
0.0492984839,
-0.7504349351,
0.0336955488,
0.6749689579,
-0.8217861056,
0.1239601523,
0.268520236,
0.3375924528,
-0.8059928417,
0.3358427584,
-0.0162781067,
-0.5497451425,
0.7974095345,
0.2573101223,
0.946180582,
-0.2230117023,
0.4301411211,
-0.6180872917,
0.068987079,
0.4598059356,
0.5216065645,
-0.1016162187,
-0.6353546977,
-0.2366087437,
-0.1238591895,
-1.1758375168,
-0.0101958998,
-0.3732585907,
0.1685998142,
-0.7316662669,
0.0706722662,
-0.0501741581,
-0.0131009826,
-0.8112530112,
0.505187571,
0.0314508267,
0.9911342859,
-0.3908689022,
0.444131732,
0.8474622369,
-0.2351680547,
-0.8648777604,
-0.1597432047,
-0.346839726,
-1.2711372375,
0.3601411283,
-0.1425454468,
-0.318043083,
0.2446068972,
-0.7087957859,
-0.5127875805,
1.095952034,
0.4081282318,
-0.2621269226,
-0.0628336892,
0.4420903325,
0.4558437765,
-0.6080787778,
0.5473861694,
0.7009499669,
0.4457617998,
0.1638960093,
-0.6776260138,
-0.1074767783,
-0.2056177109,
-0.2195146382,
0.0780652389,
-0.9328848124,
0.8278981447,
0.418969512,
-0.0733832195,
0.009516241,
0.1981839985,
0.0475712642,
0.628270328,
0.7559912801,
0.1097794101,
0.713978827,
0.1511253715,
1.342664957,
-0.4575657547,
0.041396454,
0.6770407557,
-0.2298466414,
0.5585147142,
0.5917700529,
-0.0539124161,
-0.0201535858,
0.5642809868,
0.1824200302,
0.0819397867,
-0.0809453651,
-0.474309206,
-0.5515138507,
-0.719718039,
-0.2248483151,
0.3753877878,
0.1180582792,
0.0463602506,
-0.394208014,
0.3183297515,
0.3916525543,
-0.1559742838,
-0.1461214125,
1.160692215,
0.0798936039,
-1.1050966978,
0.6422619224,
-0.1846596152,
0.33578372,
-0.8123659492,
-0.1085724011,
-0.618906498,
0.2195409834,
-0.0425190218,
-0.4400736392,
0.4074516594,
0.1142935231,
-0.0306053218,
-0.2714681923,
0.4278100729,
-0.3119098246,
-0.2712589502,
0.1697145253,
0.7363817692,
0.501535356,
-0.4656531215,
-1.0451229811,
0.1379356533,
-0.2245481908,
-0.1307177246,
0.3999070823,
0.202278614,
0.2231930047,
1.2382854223,
0.9468832016,
0.504144609,
0.2106243223,
-0.2058359832,
1.0315395594,
-0.5122190118,
-0.6469752789,
-0.4282867014,
0.5714383721,
-0.1459735036,
-0.2496777624,
0.6737626791,
0.4413504303,
0.3767413497,
0.0824664012,
0.8268495798,
-0.0127621042,
0.8120011091,
-0.3257943094,
0.5210656524,
-0.9795432091,
0.4971255362,
0.1625467539,
-0.8720906973,
-0.0262769163,
0.4439454675,
-0.208803013,
-0.3598809838,
0.6071066856,
0.7877818942,
0.0053696656,
-0.1810135394,
0.6650862098,
0.0230331179,
0.9371625781,
0.0163468681,
1.2214845419,
-0.0060413308,
0.9959076643,
-0.0088476753,
-0.1670006365,
-0.419339776,
-0.6195599437,
-0.5344356894,
-0.0745729655,
-0.1578394175,
-0.368214339,
0.1855667531,
1.3033076525,
0.5371565819,
-0.6773568988,
-0.5202243328,
0.0973169431,
0.2621231973,
-0.3119901419,
-0.195219934,
0.1088980138,
-0.6762546897,
-0.8412332535,
0.4534518421,
0.3309555948,
0.0134751918,
-0.1873265952,
-0.0539822802,
-0.301846683,
0.4316999614,
0.3819110096,
0.5170309544,
-0.1606513709,
-0.3352619112,
0.3385215998,
-0.2310037613,
0.2004087418,
0.9103471637,
-0.3078329563,
0.4889118075,
0.3523433506,
1.0627326965,
0.4359052777,
0.2906443477,
0.5955713391,
-0.4673923254,
0.1022090763,
0.1296057552,
0.0164204277,
0.044617705,
-0.6859791279,
0.2225888669,
-0.0110656219,
-0.7256289124,
-0.5657100081,
0.1863000542,
-0.8862730861,
-0.3422117531,
0.7608739734,
-0.3233196437,
-0.1093633696,
-0.7965363264,
-0.5731491446,
0.1668836176,
-0.6150009036,
0.773824811,
0.3019573987,
-0.4511889219,
-0.4506177604,
-0.5319917202,
0.2641343772,
0.8715510368,
-0.9777312875,
-0.0230338275,
0.2739004791,
0.1695100367,
0.176539585,
0.8288838267,
0.4587030113,
0.4088364542,
-0.3918060958,
-0.3514961004,
-0.432757169,
-0.4877003133,
-0.3200564086,
0.3615444899,
0.1215070114,
-0.5171163678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00675v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00675v4
|
Self-Play Preference Optimization for Language Model Alignment
| 2024-05-01T17:59:20 | 2024-06-14T05:57:01 |
Yue Wu, Zhiqing Sun, Huizhuo Yuan, Kaixuan Ji, Yiming Yang, Quanquan Gu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Traditional reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) approaches
relying on parametric models like the Bradley-Terry model fall short in
capturing the intransitivity and irrationality in human preferences. Recent
advancements suggest that directly working with preference probabilities can
yield a more accurate reflection of human preferences, enabling more flexible
and accurate language model alignment. In this paper, we propose a
self-play-based method for language model alignment, which treats the problem
as a constant-sum two-player game aimed at identifying the Nash equilibrium
policy. Our approach, dubbed Self-Play Preference Optimization (SPPO),
approximates the Nash equilibrium through iterative policy updates and enjoys a
theoretical convergence guarantee. Our method can effectively increase the
log-likelihood of the chosen response and decrease that of the rejected
response, which cannot be trivially achieved by symmetric pairwise loss such as
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) and Identity Preference Optimization
(IPO). In our experiments, using only 60k prompts (without responses) from the
UltraFeedback dataset and without any prompt augmentation, by leveraging a
pre-trained preference model PairRM with only 0.4B parameters, SPPO can obtain
a model from fine-tuning Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2 that achieves the
state-of-the-art length-controlled win-rate of 28.53% against GPT-4-Turbo on
AlpacaEval 2.0. It also outperforms the (iterative) DPO and IPO on MT-Bench and
the Open LLM Leaderboard. Starting from a stronger base model
Llama-3-8B-Instruct, we are able to achieve a length-controlled win rate of
38.77%. Notably, the strong performance of SPPO is achieved without additional
external supervision (e.g., responses, preferences, etc.) from GPT-4 or other
stronger language models. Codes are available at
https://github.com/uclaml/SPPO.
|
[
-0.1664184332,
-0.2810372114,
0.2915773988,
0.2821342647,
-0.1904169023,
0.0883998722,
-0.3594356179,
-0.2533526421,
0.1105092913,
0.6824832559,
-0.7441860437,
-0.1988387257,
-0.2855991721,
-0.1026913673,
0.1923733801,
1.0977945328,
-0.1506772935,
-0.0968623459,
-0.0307845958,
-0.1259099096,
-0.4533908069,
-0.300442487,
-0.4713999331,
-0.5512506366,
0.3544159234,
0.5692919493,
0.7867283225,
0.8703995943,
0.3251103163,
0.3176300824,
0.1730839163,
0.0852126926,
-0.5697613955,
0.0356851146,
-0.0562865809,
-0.2289200425,
-0.4626938105,
0.0946642905,
0.7058367133,
0.0046609198,
-0.6082064509,
-0.0842768028,
0.1017379388,
0.6515491605,
-0.3741661608,
0.0925163329,
-0.5227249265,
0.2492512316,
-0.1587827355,
-0.3700737357,
-0.4865153134,
-0.3276094496,
0.1702373624,
-0.7440941334,
-0.0620738715,
0.09113013,
0.947404623,
0.2774298489,
-0.2595948875,
-0.0640359074,
-0.6558513045,
0.821749568,
-1.0850987434,
0.2941631079,
0.2872368395,
0.2439667434,
-0.4109503031,
-0.0372337811,
-0.4871180058,
-0.5164382458,
0.0433292836,
0.3259163499,
0.042868346,
0.278137058,
-0.0455609038,
0.1083162501,
-0.808594048,
0.4926039279,
-0.0471303239,
-0.2257474661,
0.8014953136,
0.0714656115,
0.1744527221,
-0.0255375952,
-0.6519019604,
-0.2295061499,
-0.6358924508,
0.4058231711,
0.6520674825,
0.3110353649,
-0.0548388697,
0.4972073138,
-0.1867156923,
0.624327898,
0.4427102804,
-0.3718669415,
0.0860472098,
0.028933553,
0.0026459605,
0.1407115608,
0.936365068,
0.4783522785,
0.089612484,
-0.2085866332,
-0.2874851525,
-0.0417547561,
0.1865557879,
-0.4733326137,
-0.0176751949,
0.1899772584,
-0.3243039548,
-0.3871385157,
-0.1949335486,
-0.6909726262,
-0.1106837243,
-0.3056316972,
0.5378298163,
-0.2880288661,
-0.232906878,
0.0642958954,
0.3305662274,
0.4149163961,
0.1369289309,
-1.1968358755,
0.4441237152,
0.7443099618,
0.6176440716,
-0.5043942928,
-0.6245650649,
-0.4589099884,
0.2043287009,
-0.3449801803,
0.6747124791,
-0.2743058205,
-0.4226781428,
-0.2536278367,
-0.2596420646,
-0.1138665751,
-0.262778461,
0.4265241325,
-0.5351555943,
0.4115753174,
-0.065398328,
-0.7752915621,
0.2073799074,
0.1174107492,
-0.419685632,
1.065810442,
-0.1825958192,
-0.5977722406,
0.1620442122,
-0.5083122253,
-0.2010706216,
-0.0961927399,
-0.282645911,
-0.6300986409,
-0.0251298826,
0.1226176247,
0.0911604762,
-0.2143781781,
0.4104669988,
-0.4998861849,
-0.3848802745,
0.2081065327,
-0.1681146026,
0.4584882557,
0.1792477518,
-0.633826077,
0.4039733112,
-0.4278972745,
0.0159383379,
0.2955264747,
-0.212641716,
-0.0517889559,
0.2153877616,
-0.3585166931,
0.3746596575,
0.3235376775,
-0.4462588131,
0.4534509778,
-0.6739997268,
0.1645527631,
1.1208331585,
-0.3139859438,
0.5995156765,
-0.1959039122,
0.7750225663,
-0.3468897045,
0.5085836053,
0.2959955037,
-0.3014327288,
-0.4632742703,
-0.2018480599,
0.4015449286,
0.4066293836,
-0.3002286553,
0.5742578506,
-0.153579101,
-0.2735409141,
-0.6337329745,
0.1260601878,
0.5900762081,
0.8166695833,
0.3226592839,
-0.3106866479,
-0.3666401505,
-1.0138047934,
-0.0455899313,
-0.3126215041,
0.4423505962,
0.5862913728,
-0.0715624765,
0.0482525304,
1.1211106777,
-0.6217944622,
-0.2794636488,
-0.226359725,
0.1518457383,
0.2044973373,
0.4494965971,
0.5460885167,
-0.4164801836,
-0.610224545,
0.0583748184,
-0.3811964691,
-0.21943295,
0.0068401364,
-0.1416825354,
0.4135198593,
0.0115056466,
-0.3768394291,
0.1295646429,
0.8382213712,
-0.0786337331,
0.5110710859,
-0.3885265589,
0.1526006609,
-0.8317580223,
0.0850945339,
-0.1254626364,
-0.2096677423,
-0.4346682727,
0.0930505842,
0.0788329467,
0.1154603511,
-0.2634154558,
0.6115298271,
-0.3398052156,
-0.1650650948,
-0.5288781524,
0.0612181127,
-0.1511759907,
0.6679372191,
0.2906504273,
1.0055067539,
0.3289699554,
-0.3754812181,
0.2608664334,
0.0677673146,
0.0448739268,
0.0574161299,
-0.5525650382,
0.2388716489,
-0.0339638852,
0.3213564456,
-1.0509381294,
0.0077892239,
0.2601951659,
-0.4098688066,
0.4762769639,
-0.1468013674,
0.0041272263,
-0.4195487499,
-0.3505855799,
0.3428572416,
0.4292698503,
-0.5858425498,
0.4074532688,
0.5711109638,
-0.0862729028,
-1.0445313454,
-0.1821670532,
-0.1319347024,
-0.2470203191,
-0.3180505633,
0.4487692416,
-0.3765024245,
0.1720609367,
-0.3570555151,
-0.28174299,
0.0770976171,
0.1201991364,
0.0179352034,
0.4213216007,
-0.1219023392,
0.027556587,
0.0290528219,
-0.321895808,
-0.14988783,
-0.2959828973,
0.5235922933,
-0.1304447353,
-0.1274714321,
-0.4655337036,
0.1256963462,
0.1777038574,
-0.3126416504,
0.3216561973,
0.1337414235,
0.0505777188,
-0.1765636802,
-0.5928269625,
-0.3062083721,
-0.5044099092,
0.1394895464,
-0.4264838994,
-0.9670048356,
0.4066046178,
0.109729819,
0.0258000977,
0.4839783013,
0.4849572778,
-0.1754679829,
1.1797629595,
0.4830979109,
-0.4411846697,
0.4085964561,
-0.0723962262,
-0.0397795029,
-0.6123897433,
0.0020910648,
-0.3321662545,
-0.1309166253,
-0.6748688221,
-0.0697969124,
0.1258886158,
-0.0493814237,
-0.1383322328,
0.5933650136,
-0.5181075931,
0.5007609725,
0.5298851728,
0.1429536641,
0.0989336073,
-0.2442793697,
-0.3599484265,
-0.3087764382,
-0.7424223423,
-0.3180244565,
1.0862001181,
0.54034096,
0.8638221622,
0.3078858554,
1.0759890079,
0.350317508,
0.3001664579,
-0.6643763781,
0.3683714569,
0.030218713,
-0.4606436193,
-0.6134906411,
-0.4974069595,
-0.7582708001,
0.2076731473,
-0.2769381106,
-0.6311375499,
0.0775587857,
0.5238503814,
-0.6003109813,
-0.0443008579,
-0.4022152424,
0.9884487987,
-0.5575689673,
-0.5040380955,
-0.1684404016,
-0.7696131468,
0.4142232239,
0.0949393362,
0.101174213,
-0.2548668087,
0.0547439046,
0.5935240984,
-0.3730176985,
0.6561777592,
-0.0373198241,
-0.2647751272,
0.1447916627,
0.1819919795,
0.6460790038,
-0.0707958043,
-0.0513160937,
-0.055341199,
-0.0430644937,
-0.2798737288,
-0.5533359647,
0.9045393467,
-1.1272097826,
-0.745475769,
-0.6871501803,
-0.4106581211,
-0.2618454695,
0.1416781992,
0.1527568698,
0.2356318384,
-0.2906509936,
-0.2050514072,
0.5358032584,
0.0073720515,
0.5145226121,
0.7323672175,
-0.3073276877,
-0.5454423428,
0.9128136635,
-0.1055231094,
0.2743546963,
0.4618524611,
0.6526966691,
-0.7325484157,
-0.4610222578,
-0.570299983,
0.3653406799,
-0.2759559453,
-0.2913177609,
-0.4350686371,
-0.0615410507,
-0.5283709764,
0.0396400876,
-0.6132162809,
-0.3493309617,
-0.2524857223,
0.0419479795,
0.0375352353,
0.5825023651,
-0.1772743911,
0.4582104087,
-0.5402855277,
-0.0000449342,
0.4676215649,
0.4968318939,
-0.1636270881,
-0.7452378273,
-0.0759946182,
-0.0534230061,
-0.3490890563,
-1.0703345537,
0.3749467432,
0.1404214352,
0.5967707634,
0.4966920912,
0.0139519088,
0.6864134669,
-0.619120419,
0.4368748069,
0.1881830245,
-0.9077805877,
0.5820532441,
-0.5835810304,
-0.0150689194,
0.6739051342,
0.2373182476,
-0.2964453399,
-0.0053196964,
-0.6384302974,
-0.5086621046,
1.0618572235,
0.0275701564,
-0.0412108675,
0.0952756554,
0.4794977307,
-0.0047826669,
0.100613296,
-0.8858713508,
-0.2292527109,
-0.1895089447,
-0.2040122002,
-0.1715416312,
-0.26761657,
-0.2260742933,
0.0248157624,
0.9825667143,
-0.4310110211,
0.0036088026,
0.0263138339,
0.0538865477,
-0.3610469401,
0.1166740134,
0.8070777655,
0.4547378421,
-0.4879854321,
-0.1641784906,
0.0352300815,
-0.0125669325,
0.3352846205,
0.295928061,
-0.1367731988,
-0.402939409,
-0.0220836625,
0.7149443626,
0.372942239,
-0.5904204249,
0.6386805177,
-0.0263136905,
0.0179491453,
-0.0539758727,
0.0627699271,
-0.0714132339,
0.1021462381,
0.0363247208,
-0.3364582062,
0.2964113355,
-0.3881498575,
0.2561966777,
0.6249223351,
-0.4478551149,
-0.2572321594,
0.5156213045,
0.1886131912,
-0.2261289358,
0.1657387167,
-0.1807771921,
-0.5622664094,
0.563849926,
0.9657910466,
0.7051314712,
-0.6225457788,
0.4488662779,
0.3475198448,
0.1314025819,
-0.3326903582,
0.0303251576,
-0.155013904,
-0.8710888028,
-0.4063201547,
-0.4078922272,
-0.5433138013,
-0.0658917949,
-0.5015391707,
0.1478510946,
-0.5739030242,
-0.1938668638,
-0.1749412268,
0.2085172534,
-0.1623756289,
0.1191939786,
0.248455748,
0.5105170608,
-0.7505345941,
0.9958367944,
0.3989101052,
-0.287484318,
-0.8655531406,
-0.0110044349,
0.2189238518,
-0.9368329048,
0.4382566512,
-0.0673233122,
-0.2915996909,
0.1708280891,
-0.3507619798,
-1.2060217857,
1.0374560356,
0.3229777515,
-0.6997038722,
0.0566279255,
-0.0091197398,
0.4720095098,
-0.5050182343,
0.5168135166,
0.4794602692,
0.1840895563,
0.1540655792,
-1.0226721764,
-0.0775172859,
0.2548686266,
0.192644611,
0.3053048849,
-1.0407193899,
0.4289138317,
-0.1410271078,
0.0233161971,
0.0491484441,
0.9299997687,
0.5397959948,
-0.0397135317,
0.6138504148,
0.6646922231,
0.405910641,
0.1234080866,
0.7289206386,
-0.4835011661,
0.6704148054,
1.3799500465,
-0.5296248198,
0.8563273549,
0.4103821516,
-0.2252758592,
0.3551333845,
0.6498562694,
0.2751970589,
0.6423906684,
0.1879310906,
-0.0779727474,
-0.3540544808,
-0.0354793854,
-0.3188180923,
0.6881135106,
-0.0897104293,
-0.0612386465,
-0.1079538539,
-0.4093225896,
0.039843455,
0.3080513477,
0.0674607381,
0.8706971407,
-0.2213994861,
-1.1284765005,
0.363989383,
0.0611720867,
0.6734195352,
-0.8401125669,
0.0172389168,
-0.3494040072,
0.1819625795,
0.0941852629,
-0.7069528103,
-0.0205254816,
-0.2465243936,
-0.0115052145,
-0.1225487217,
0.5226314664,
-0.552690208,
-0.1041350365,
0.4816842973,
0.0616142228,
-0.1983080953,
0.2618418038,
-1.0982785225,
0.1041337997,
0.1570533812,
-0.1875222176,
0.5094304681,
-0.1652586311,
0.0631012768,
0.5243911147,
0.5469372272,
0.0165060386,
-0.1629635841,
-0.0398348309,
0.6939632893,
-0.4341491759,
-0.6216266751,
-0.7708156109,
0.0860786289,
0.0100548109,
-0.4647295475,
0.5395695567,
0.6700528264,
0.6357393861,
0.0575751029,
0.4129680693,
0.2427169979,
0.35990116,
-0.4134592712,
0.4523378015,
-0.548291266,
0.1536224484,
-0.3305378258,
-0.8113858104,
-0.0538602211,
0.5566709042,
-0.3206953108,
-0.0691141337,
0.216945529,
0.8306040168,
-0.0125961946,
-0.1163276806,
0.2874878943,
0.1019875556,
0.1469986886,
0.5144168139,
0.6685020328,
-0.238332659,
0.3742248416,
-0.3754239976,
-0.642542243,
-0.247637257,
-1.0462973118,
-0.5943781734,
-0.3386177421,
-0.2241516858,
-0.4950790703,
0.2831893563,
1.3499552011,
0.6768541932,
-0.7498812079,
-0.7186916471,
0.0434843078,
0.0078652436,
-0.3148599565,
-0.2354673743,
0.3068694472,
-0.4604720473,
-0.5037257671,
0.5603206158,
0.3322764933,
0.0527679212,
-0.2417769432,
-0.4570706785,
-0.3891345561,
0.2009894997,
0.2425048798,
0.7645587325,
-0.9449583888,
-0.2392369062,
0.1991001219,
-0.1880593449,
0.1962973326,
0.6436027884,
-0.5419287682,
0.6888320446,
0.2624832392,
0.6130428314,
0.5543499589,
0.2269975096,
0.756814599,
-0.5897409916,
0.0554304123,
0.2063065767,
0.2417088896,
0.1226824746,
-0.4765536785,
0.3250733018,
0.1581754386,
-0.7995399237,
-0.5347394347,
0.2644426823,
-0.8909106255,
-0.088493146,
1.0569740534,
-0.0953149796,
-0.2162670493,
0.3825644851,
-0.3363421261,
0.1749163568,
-0.6822018027,
0.9477988482,
0.5028390288,
-0.4049811065,
-0.2739627063,
-0.0872570127,
0.8078435063,
0.8105434179,
-0.5459771156,
0.069362402,
0.4248553813,
0.3221740723,
-0.1394785494,
1.0127955675,
0.0313448384,
0.2196441889,
-0.5149937272,
0.360561341,
0.1468571424,
-0.3529631197,
-0.5585517287,
-0.1569088101,
0.2879064083,
-0.0867228508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00664v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00664v1
|
Is Bigger Edit Batch Size Always Better? -- An Empirical Study on Model Editing with Llama-3
| 2024-05-01T17:50:37 | 2024-05-01T17:50:37 |
Junsang Yoon, Akshat Gupta, Gopala Anumanchipalli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This study presents a targeted model editing analysis focused on the latest
large language model, Llama-3. We explore the efficacy of popular model editing
techniques - ROME, MEMIT, and EMMET, which are designed for precise layer
interventions. We identify the most effective layers for targeted edits through
an evaluation that encompasses up to 4096 edits across three distinct
strategies: sequential editing, batch editing, and a hybrid approach we call as
sequential-batch editing. Our findings indicate that increasing edit
batch-sizes may degrade model performance more significantly than using smaller
edit batches sequentially for equal number of edits. With this, we argue that
sequential model editing is an important component for scaling model editing
methods and future research should focus on methods that combine both batched
and sequential editing. This observation suggests a potential limitation in
current model editing methods which push towards bigger edit batch sizes, and
we hope it paves way for future investigations into optimizing batch sizes and
model editing performance.
|
[
-0.2025709897,
-0.9592329264,
0.7982549071,
0.4803164303,
-0.0673759505,
0.1481845677,
-0.2005354762,
-0.6671586633,
0.1700520515,
0.6216796041,
-0.2798630595,
-0.2055704743,
-0.6209007502,
0.2986979187,
-0.4404144883,
0.6309395432,
-0.2487987429,
0.1226115301,
0.0685217157,
0.0263912138,
-0.6806372404,
-0.513853848,
-1.114693284,
-0.227031067,
0.898373425,
0.6423971057,
0.8611909747,
1.2280255556,
0.692178905,
0.3365898132,
-0.5948516726,
0.0890502036,
-0.400529474,
-0.0806771442,
-0.0040328428,
-0.6637263894,
-1.2728408575,
0.1233946159,
0.8727920055,
0.4707170427,
-0.1533156037,
0.4449619949,
-0.2564044297,
0.5740303397,
-0.6429012418,
-0.573245883,
-0.6237304807,
0.0617211945,
-0.356169343,
0.1893794388,
-0.4637600183,
0.072281912,
-0.2978110313,
-0.5498841405,
0.0145116458,
0.1819395125,
0.4412195981,
0.4864778221,
-0.2511729598,
0.1300840825,
-0.6993043423,
0.7488465309,
-1.1080836058,
0.1522641182,
0.2723258734,
0.1513500363,
-0.114265576,
-0.8520991802,
-0.5585781336,
0.0686390251,
0.2480007708,
-0.3409446776,
-0.3643333912,
0.2765648365,
0.6426410079,
0.287263304,
-0.3039084971,
0.9061151743,
-0.5110951662,
-0.1496759355,
0.6951757073,
0.2982761264,
0.4694274068,
-0.0058009019,
0.0659272149,
-0.1057161763,
-0.9248141646,
-0.2936857343,
0.4686637819,
0.0091744149,
0.2116961926,
0.8830143809,
-0.165193975,
0.9492414594,
0.2349623293,
-0.3821284771,
-0.1176579446,
-0.1143297106,
-0.6361240745,
0.1112420559,
0.589222908,
0.7032174468,
-0.0139443027,
0.1132852659,
-0.2897273302,
-0.3408841789,
0.3227199316,
-0.9796929359,
0.063609004,
0.3684480786,
-0.5975528955,
-0.5235848427,
-0.3312525749,
-0.3614465594,
-0.562394917,
-0.2275642604,
0.2916041613,
-0.1021654084,
0.0668515116,
0.3639469445,
-0.1636990458,
-0.0428809449,
0.6615932584,
-0.8657034636,
0.334506005,
0.7768365145,
1.0043411255,
0.1477320492,
-0.535461545,
-0.5332932472,
0.2641562521,
-0.6711301804,
0.7277374268,
-0.6615899801,
-0.4709699452,
-0.6034327745,
-0.2043019086,
0.0588498153,
-0.6181389093,
0.3593224287,
-0.6377518177,
-0.0209533423,
-0.364975661,
-0.5771169662,
-0.1557355523,
-0.0844693631,
-0.9829413891,
0.9455327392,
-0.0647929013,
-0.4977613688,
0.3694300056,
-0.8046130538,
-0.3853777647,
-0.4364334643,
0.4055544436,
-0.5288513899,
0.3039453328,
0.5349660516,
0.5793638229,
-0.389772743,
0.2716144621,
-0.36606583,
-0.4245469272,
0.2005759627,
-0.1146893203,
0.470528394,
0.251006633,
-0.1548763663,
0.3717090786,
-0.8925811648,
-0.1912463605,
0.1466662437,
-0.3201341927,
-0.1198888496,
-0.1195823997,
-0.0755337477,
0.2296694517,
0.3559797704,
-0.6873044968,
0.5485907793,
0.1256952584,
0.6079497933,
1.084671855,
0.2884081602,
0.6125782728,
-0.4119727612,
0.6377182603,
-0.3140610158,
0.4087589681,
-0.0779387653,
-0.4722619057,
-0.8334487081,
-0.3961152136,
0.5531045794,
0.409026742,
-0.1995730549,
0.0270066094,
-0.1319741458,
-0.7584456801,
-0.4298586547,
0.4744672477,
0.301392138,
0.2630039155,
0.2967453599,
-0.3740978539,
-0.6129854918,
-1.260206461,
-0.5448257923,
0.0704969168,
0.0756982192,
0.0653129965,
0.5625869632,
-0.2024880797,
0.6334320903,
-0.4676243663,
-0.0886210054,
-0.4558260739,
-0.1082549393,
-0.011771718,
0.5886195898,
0.6462381482,
-0.3406240046,
-0.4588587582,
0.0552921258,
-0.4534473717,
-0.1969933361,
-0.2980667055,
-0.2514701486,
0.014116047,
0.5733873844,
-0.3925892711,
0.1858292967,
0.6878410578,
-0.0477870516,
0.2763633728,
-0.3042901456,
0.1130895838,
-0.7299803495,
-0.2965047359,
-0.0166668799,
-0.2001982331,
-0.8658092618,
0.0945506394,
0.5090846419,
0.1197881773,
-0.4611164927,
0.4646083713,
-0.5276508927,
-0.2279813439,
-0.2737390697,
-0.1051461324,
0.1170952618,
0.2956314087,
-0.2992939055,
0.8348120451,
-0.0424000472,
-0.232983768,
0.1173629239,
0.0562813468,
-0.7422361374,
0.1525671631,
-0.9139614701,
0.7656223774,
0.1423874944,
0.5219663978,
-0.738948524,
-0.322088629,
-0.0824889764,
0.0317134112,
0.2394163311,
0.1623759419,
-0.696747005,
-0.3661634326,
-0.5645179152,
0.3826581538,
0.0949219167,
-0.6178125739,
0.4492008388,
0.2830149233,
-0.1980704963,
-0.5958656073,
-0.9334834814,
0.3282233477,
-0.4229578674,
-0.86199826,
0.4067578614,
-0.1062727422,
-0.4611259103,
-0.2010926306,
-0.003515759,
-0.0886175111,
0.1848854274,
-0.0108283013,
0.3760216832,
-0.2004819065,
-0.3391039371,
0.35104388,
0.2002969533,
-0.246446237,
0.1775667667,
0.3485411108,
0.1051075533,
-0.1013380513,
-0.8104485273,
0.2053896636,
0.7275003195,
-0.3263328075,
0.767893672,
0.2004047483,
-0.2970006168,
-0.1118296683,
-0.9196311831,
0.0867499113,
-0.4861406982,
0.5280348063,
-0.5275093913,
-0.9914291501,
0.5780013204,
-0.0281023998,
0.1142119691,
0.5083454847,
0.4025088847,
0.0013513039,
1.1266502142,
0.686008513,
-0.1568913907,
0.5736525059,
-0.3215757608,
0.0451852232,
-1.3638443947,
0.1098749712,
-0.3586503565,
-0.7057383657,
-0.2640250623,
-0.741933167,
0.1789014637,
0.1242911294,
-0.3986569345,
0.3380733728,
-0.2110027969,
0.7254545689,
0.2645232975,
0.2039396465,
0.4249463677,
-0.2604855001,
0.2540344596,
0.0743444487,
-0.7324160933,
-0.6194521189,
1.3194895983,
0.5737547278,
0.4227000475,
0.297205478,
0.4491181374,
0.2867448926,
0.3010885417,
-0.6477181911,
0.5510452986,
0.0525547937,
-0.7847795486,
-0.5016765594,
0.051307857,
-0.482018888,
0.4239319563,
-0.0859550238,
-0.5704749227,
0.2321424335,
0.2433602661,
-0.538155973,
0.8100536466,
-0.7691973448,
0.7510194778,
-0.1647779793,
-0.263012737,
-0.3997130394,
-0.4657209814,
0.4096711874,
-0.4302214086,
0.3676282167,
-0.0412919782,
-0.4319568276,
0.8340132236,
-0.6810501814,
0.7574458718,
0.0617746748,
-0.3070243001,
0.1096613854,
0.2585507631,
0.895709753,
-0.1461750716,
-0.3322489262,
0.1635366976,
-0.283254236,
-0.3643220663,
-0.9950499535,
0.5929819942,
-0.8224935532,
-0.8630968928,
0.0446507223,
-0.607126832,
-0.079261601,
0.022576727,
-0.0139019368,
0.5524892807,
-0.0611495897,
0.2491501868,
0.2225596756,
-0.2258018851,
0.5684122443,
0.3041600287,
-0.4064290524,
-0.3252206147,
0.6929376721,
0.4741422534,
0.602547884,
0.2952952385,
0.2903439403,
0.4005132914,
-0.9101390243,
-0.5977596045,
0.3078467846,
-0.5991973877,
0.0228724517,
-0.6449740529,
0.1149280667,
-0.2664626539,
-0.5740725398,
-0.6249694824,
-0.8563328385,
-0.1458466351,
-0.1553143412,
0.4081774056,
1.1578623056,
-0.2889943719,
0.8176004887,
-0.3751794696,
0.2562916875,
0.2604582012,
0.3191748261,
0.1854971051,
-0.6736191511,
-0.2522241771,
-0.2211530805,
-0.2116215676,
-0.7441994548,
0.3004962802,
0.0530530699,
0.2732413411,
0.229959026,
-0.538538456,
0.9648620486,
-0.7285193205,
0.8581153154,
-0.123514086,
-1.0651203394,
0.5402826667,
-0.4836932123,
0.4278900623,
0.2926420271,
0.0445421934,
-0.6146057248,
-0.2363384813,
-0.6966251731,
-0.5710185766,
0.7757908106,
-0.0773398355,
-0.0473938435,
0.256056428,
0.5995550752,
-0.0124372886,
0.1511613131,
-0.4459221661,
-0.2197191119,
0.3890507221,
0.2648386955,
-0.1079792157,
-0.7381517291,
0.1467016041,
-0.4455976784,
0.776106596,
0.3438218236,
-0.0323145874,
-0.0404561944,
-0.1081300452,
-0.4049711525,
0.2527885735,
0.7576339841,
1.0098264217,
-0.4282645285,
-0.3087894917,
0.670299232,
-0.6314035654,
0.0876904428,
-0.5703747272,
-0.1536812931,
-0.3820107579,
0.5410425067,
1.1300489902,
0.2879573703,
-0.4386192858,
0.0971649289,
0.0149314571,
-0.2909219563,
0.0972347707,
0.1711094528,
-0.1913694441,
0.3369750381,
-0.025778234,
0.3411180973,
0.2378690243,
-0.3360877633,
-0.3861674964,
0.0182783883,
0.1413525939,
-0.0144565599,
0.7706733346,
-0.0802641362,
-0.4416444898,
0.6208337545,
0.4700295031,
-0.3309743404,
0.7514284849,
0.5215594172,
0.5822689533,
-0.4692178965,
0.0442670472,
0.469573766,
0.5981915593,
-0.4328288138,
-0.2419265211,
0.1706468016,
-0.7115276456,
-0.8249305487,
-0.2759751379,
-0.7394545078,
0.3524512351,
-0.6922881603,
0.4079098701,
-0.8919032812,
-0.2039065957,
0.1670546681,
-0.1721010655,
-0.4065214694,
0.3603249192,
-0.1609288752,
0.920271039,
-0.5880478621,
0.875901103,
0.65497154,
-0.1556775272,
-1.0807859898,
-0.4038934708,
0.3886606693,
-0.7154645324,
0.4047838449,
0.0355635583,
0.0675643235,
0.084196046,
-0.7047211528,
-1.1694278717,
1.1407500505,
0.3527292609,
-0.7453358769,
-0.1495163739,
-0.0474840663,
0.362729311,
-0.4072422981,
0.0607303195,
0.9795114994,
0.5449939966,
0.0695478618,
-0.9948453903,
-0.013738567,
-0.2494582236,
0.3853035867,
0.1319013834,
-0.9057993889,
0.9973279834,
-0.3737927973,
0.243613407,
0.3536053598,
0.5764765143,
0.115311496,
-0.2354784161,
0.5809686184,
0.7595720887,
0.8705243468,
0.3830247521,
1.476372242,
-0.0466518961,
-0.0466738865,
1.4323875904,
-0.1772567779,
1.0417481661,
0.4170664847,
-0.1833139658,
0.4371628761,
0.9001471996,
-0.0811933205,
0.1902300119,
0.1759237796,
-0.0233456548,
-0.029536048,
0.245989874,
-0.2476476133,
0.4295493066,
0.2224594355,
-0.4424129128,
0.4337091148,
0.1434734762,
0.7255001664,
-0.1909799725,
-0.3381686211,
0.501698494,
-0.1225230843,
-0.4356912971,
0.4044373035,
0.4774397016,
0.4311674535,
-0.1770350784,
0.1751211733,
-0.3086434901,
0.046990905,
-0.1431424767,
-0.5694813728,
0.0181129165,
0.3988931477,
-0.1651640981,
-0.2857536376,
0.4466442168,
-0.011499742,
-0.6328967214,
0.147436142,
0.2174033374,
0.0552119128,
-0.2996495664,
-0.5407273769,
0.5874521732,
0.0506815687,
-0.6237131357,
0.3172469139,
0.243063435,
-0.1986473352,
0.4874424338,
0.7178652883,
0.3555650413,
0.2108632922,
0.2349290997,
0.7216048837,
-0.6921355128,
-0.1153196543,
-0.9805490375,
0.6310670376,
-0.2360045016,
-0.3194871545,
0.8702183366,
0.559609592,
0.8019887805,
0.0524786748,
0.6852138042,
0.1490469128,
0.233931154,
-0.6052419543,
0.3820678294,
-0.6811090708,
0.3698633015,
-0.5718693137,
-1.3017251492,
-0.524237752,
0.4730223119,
-0.5291424394,
-0.1629876047,
0.7202113867,
0.8877552748,
0.1471193284,
0.2275556028,
0.3652562201,
0.6777351499,
0.3804590404,
0.3023697138,
0.9005161524,
-0.4578334391,
-0.1868542582,
-0.7160744667,
-0.161306873,
-0.031152511,
-0.9061037898,
-0.9300783277,
-0.2791986167,
-0.1746158302,
0.1242018193,
-0.0623447448,
0.8764885068,
0.3994360268,
-0.3889112175,
-0.3228627145,
0.2253146917,
-0.0509815887,
-0.1416743398,
-0.0685338974,
0.2435155064,
0.0854581892,
-0.9035870433,
0.5987577438,
0.3611174226,
-0.0105981166,
-0.0088665877,
0.1775442064,
-0.3180212975,
0.2115620971,
0.7675306797,
0.1027285308,
-0.7780227065,
-0.3746901155,
-0.1483501047,
0.0467071012,
-0.0604529865,
0.8978430033,
-0.196366936,
0.5136995316,
0.1416099072,
0.655436337,
0.6683830023,
-0.0048221853,
0.7384103537,
-0.3345096707,
0.3085294068,
-0.2345249951,
0.4410069585,
0.4712561667,
-0.5422952771,
0.7200395465,
-0.2086870223,
-0.6862316132,
-0.9691836834,
-0.4186472297,
-0.9116273522,
-0.3447989523,
1.3390575647,
0.2840152383,
-0.2768116593,
0.45998016,
-0.6050032973,
0.1677129418,
-0.0887820795,
0.35989663,
0.9574462771,
-0.4003569186,
-0.1302557439,
-1.017802,
0.1715250611,
0.4987647235,
-0.6774083972,
-0.0539485738,
0.7409076691,
0.0498983599,
-0.2228989452,
0.5124465227,
-0.0392949358,
0.3216646612,
-0.0704656467,
-0.041145727,
-0.2803043127,
-0.5673287511,
-0.4520492554,
-0.0034153482,
0.3496011496,
0.3483115435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00659v1
|
NLU-STR at SemEval-2024 Task 1: Generative-based Augmentation and Encoder-based Scoring for Semantic Textual Relatedness
| 2024-05-01T17:44:05 | 2024-05-01T17:44:05 |
Sanad Malaysha, Mustafa Jarrar, Mohammed Khalilia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semantic textual relatedness is a broader concept of semantic similarity. It
measures the extent to which two chunks of text convey similar meaning or
topics, or share related concepts or contexts. This notion of relatedness can
be applied in various applications, such as document clustering and
summarizing. SemRel-2024, a shared task in SemEval-2024, aims at reducing the
gap in the semantic relatedness task by providing datasets for fourteen
languages and dialects including Arabic. This paper reports on our
participation in Track A (Algerian and Moroccan dialects) and Track B (Modern
Standard Arabic). A BERT-based model is augmented and fine-tuned for regression
scoring in supervised track (A), while BERT-based cosine similarity is employed
for unsupervised track (B). Our system ranked 1st in SemRel-2024 for MSA with a
Spearman correlation score of 0.49. We ranked 5th for Moroccan and 12th for
Algerian with scores of 0.83 and 0.53, respectively.
|
[
-0.611739397,
-0.6362772584,
0.4551454782,
0.3958677649,
-0.3389396071,
-0.2371365279,
-0.2389062494,
-0.7580247521,
0.3987544179,
0.6237494349,
-0.6234847307,
-0.8492054343,
-0.3544745147,
0.2866208553,
-0.3677243292,
1.0387845039,
-0.0283072516,
-0.0253976956,
-0.5558311939,
-0.6362796426,
-0.4714485407,
-0.8373143673,
-0.3346929252,
-0.2854942083,
0.6685149074,
0.2167789638,
0.6089960933,
0.306368053,
0.8267511725,
0.2924422324,
0.0429240763,
0.1283853352,
-0.1585244536,
0.4963358343,
-0.402020812,
-0.2375530452,
-0.5862361193,
-0.3113352954,
0.2164879292,
0.5622836947,
0.1832771152,
0.1604132652,
0.1428803355,
0.6879674196,
-0.3106156588,
-0.100791879,
-0.4299735427,
-0.2158827931,
-0.266390264,
-0.3184860945,
-0.189280957,
-0.3377442062,
0.1189925224,
-0.3511095047,
0.5615959764,
-0.0424641855,
1.1439234018,
0.350230515,
-0.4054379165,
-0.5781370401,
-0.4761937261,
0.8755201697,
-0.6865205169,
0.2548212707,
0.6686872244,
-0.0077748536,
0.0884918272,
-0.4771791101,
-0.3884781599,
-0.1136086062,
-0.1035012454,
0.3116802871,
0.1258388609,
-0.1402486712,
0.080893375,
0.1552128643,
-0.6979868412,
-0.0965707153,
-0.1774827093,
-0.3506124616,
0.7375164628,
-0.014093711,
0.2230502665,
-0.0365609005,
-0.4966949821,
-0.01580403,
-0.7409256101,
-0.2301469743,
0.476914674,
0.2417308092,
-0.1951090246,
0.5868198872,
-0.1967720985,
0.6684678197,
-0.2881158292,
0.3489346802,
0.6313937902,
-0.6489001513,
0.117422685,
0.1442810297,
0.7807745934,
0.3311576545,
0.0872038528,
-0.0543504655,
-0.1881861687,
0.2069421709,
0.1358516067,
-0.4980689287,
-0.1329859942,
-0.1143206581,
-0.4618902206,
0.022194827,
0.041871395,
-0.5478300452,
0.0508159436,
-0.4454146624,
0.7617619038,
-0.6358780861,
0.0291455518,
-0.3037490249,
0.045702707,
0.4024234712,
0.5294423103,
-0.5364894867,
0.2010043561,
0.7084149718,
0.7641817927,
-0.3522510827,
-0.3567310274,
-0.0680782124,
0.0874267668,
-0.0312038939,
0.8032806516,
-0.6797267795,
-0.3674885035,
-0.013695566,
-0.0071490454,
-0.1904056668,
-0.6406873465,
0.9718764424,
-0.6549021602,
0.191125527,
-0.3289265931,
-0.6373512745,
-0.5407316089,
0.2723686993,
-0.7770246267,
1.4832695723,
0.1224394217,
-0.6427493691,
0.2597548664,
-0.3668732047,
-0.4954428971,
-0.0379231088,
-0.1538655311,
-0.4802187979,
0.0348125398,
0.2649736404,
0.3308441639,
-0.2244055569,
0.2006114423,
-0.101443924,
-0.5600278378,
0.1496504098,
-0.4379335046,
0.3317926228,
0.2246662378,
-0.2279370278,
0.2313604057,
-0.7537221909,
-0.0118558435,
-0.3282806873,
-0.1957521886,
-0.6338313222,
-0.1862312704,
0.3260495663,
0.4440509975,
0.5648729801,
-0.4259576499,
-0.1590897143,
-0.5959191918,
-0.0825266391,
0.3840940595,
0.2086087912,
0.2596198916,
-0.5826499462,
0.309889704,
0.0523056537,
-0.2893375158,
-0.2974036038,
-0.5934337974,
-1.0297051668,
-0.1784852445,
0.5691834688,
0.5543627143,
-0.5890998244,
0.6738933325,
-0.4502160847,
-0.5643641353,
-0.4403192997,
-0.071315825,
0.3960601985,
0.2054677457,
0.5839264989,
-0.3951351941,
-0.5799534917,
-0.9544206262,
-0.1684984565,
-0.0437989049,
-0.0665723979,
0.098301217,
0.6439661384,
-0.2429827899,
0.573556602,
-0.0825654641,
-0.5630196333,
0.0271777678,
0.1574899703,
0.4696533978,
0.5677666664,
0.6109147668,
-0.6276668906,
-0.5846325159,
0.2625055313,
-0.7973111868,
-0.2279214263,
0.3008688986,
-0.038627401,
0.4400851727,
0.7204419374,
-0.110060744,
0.4820073247,
0.5039044023,
-0.4780288041,
0.164435938,
-0.2842841148,
0.4822739363,
-1.2796341181,
-0.1463445276,
-0.1772179753,
-0.0964835137,
-0.5434971452,
0.0237571392,
-0.2109749168,
0.0850591362,
-0.2326686829,
0.3655372858,
-0.0953223109,
0.023001004,
-0.1753849238,
0.0114358822,
-0.0479009151,
0.4264134765,
0.0762894601,
0.9144417048,
0.2666757703,
-0.5244708657,
0.1224648505,
0.2734253705,
-0.2883731723,
0.4706395566,
-0.7793294787,
0.2682985365,
-0.0649186373,
-0.1281342953,
-0.7575361133,
0.0673051327,
-0.2083352953,
-0.660325706,
0.19490017,
0.1848869026,
-0.3702214658,
0.1212222278,
-0.3183919787,
0.6826479435,
0.2901333869,
-0.2430389822,
0.6765856147,
0.1296262294,
-0.5016441941,
-0.5480630994,
-0.5919610858,
0.0812137872,
-0.3093713522,
-0.7747932673,
0.5610258579,
0.1372079998,
-0.1296121776,
0.2978960276,
0.0146631561,
0.1319801956,
-0.1160551757,
0.4767771661,
0.2497958094,
-0.2983240783,
0.2360889465,
0.0413888358,
0.0290399212,
0.0409929305,
0.0228089504,
0.6449542046,
-0.1999504864,
-0.4625072479,
0.0286462847,
0.6421758533,
0.2302837819,
-0.223083809,
0.8958792686,
0.862962842,
-0.3154776096,
0.0504499488,
-0.6507146955,
-0.0853837878,
-0.4197882712,
0.4490278065,
-0.7070816159,
-1.2276653051,
0.6540331244,
0.0628500506,
-0.2445653528,
0.7518302202,
0.7252204418,
-0.2864886224,
0.6930516958,
0.4592172503,
-0.0827498958,
0.2045934647,
-0.0768554732,
0.128381893,
-0.7025897503,
-0.419519335,
-0.8569703698,
-0.0619466528,
-0.9506288171,
-0.6942626834,
0.2526429296,
0.073202163,
-0.2447649837,
0.6447663307,
-0.1063062549,
0.2127606869,
0.5908917785,
-0.0299210753,
0.1169453412,
0.1891478598,
-0.3834650218,
-0.264295578,
-0.533624351,
-0.5584626794,
0.9436238408,
0.1595686674,
0.5184341669,
0.4500452876,
1.0561259985,
0.6832592487,
0.0860711038,
-0.5250849724,
0.5936127901,
-0.0718883052,
-0.274079293,
-0.3366366029,
-0.2223646641,
-0.8780210614,
0.1766916364,
-0.2315826714,
-0.6150158644,
0.146243304,
-0.2391415983,
0.2678400576,
-0.3404758573,
-0.3297361732,
0.5335165262,
0.0898340344,
-0.5699636936,
-0.3245999217,
-0.8090273738,
-0.1452560425,
-0.2379487008,
0.3505076468,
-0.3859818578,
-0.1167803705,
0.8961209655,
-0.5455576181,
0.4647576511,
0.1354644299,
-0.192046687,
0.2711392641,
-0.0743159577,
0.2470197827,
-0.1794772744,
-0.51301229,
0.4290767908,
0.1806320995,
-0.4398426712,
-0.4654320776,
1.0324760675,
-0.8199756742,
-0.3800236583,
-0.7681035995,
-0.5084999204,
-0.2290759683,
0.0053302106,
0.2070043683,
0.5236803889,
-0.4235133231,
0.1669366658,
0.4240952432,
-0.2312578857,
0.47564888,
0.4203936756,
-0.0845581591,
-0.4580186009,
1.101333499,
-0.2422736287,
0.0116015561,
0.5902056694,
-0.2254345119,
-0.5991116762,
-0.4059409499,
-0.3758988082,
0.2718841136,
-0.7648967505,
-0.3184399605,
-0.571164906,
-0.4954309165,
-0.3067393005,
-0.2565035522,
0.0952421278,
-0.5099864006,
-0.2554723322,
-0.0029053157,
0.4415054023,
0.7488237619,
0.0726151392,
0.0162848104,
-0.9671052098,
-0.0757981166,
0.0459215865,
-0.0647002235,
-0.2662933171,
-0.8896195889,
-0.301707983,
-0.2489905655,
-0.127746135,
-0.6557285786,
0.4476793408,
0.5773026347,
0.4128780067,
0.1223542541,
0.106582135,
0.6320095062,
-0.6146989465,
0.8236878514,
0.0335251391,
-0.9058398008,
0.7448298931,
-0.3868463337,
0.3369885087,
0.8784161806,
0.4640850127,
-0.2383304238,
-0.5718179941,
-0.421315521,
-1.004498601,
0.4610271454,
0.5939940214,
0.2692056596,
-0.1010246575,
-0.0154582784,
0.162075296,
-0.0333006606,
-0.4529482722,
-0.3964436352,
-0.079963237,
-0.6584305763,
-0.1331802756,
-0.3782126904,
0.1817426234,
-0.172929883,
0.8440187573,
0.025381973,
0.3425071836,
0.3002458215,
-0.1660969257,
0.2079990804,
0.6092303991,
0.6101461649,
0.5746786594,
-0.3052650988,
0.2058275193,
0.5157324076,
-0.5948656797,
0.188698411,
0.3145881593,
-0.2895891964,
0.2962341309,
0.7108112574,
0.7147148252,
0.085661158,
-0.5908031464,
0.4967823625,
0.0786067024,
-0.2765752375,
-0.4504228532,
-0.1690466106,
0.1238308921,
0.0501294024,
0.3290018141,
0.1872503757,
0.3469783962,
-0.4769462943,
0.3659028709,
0.1969013512,
-1.0659996271,
-0.3540454507,
0.3316573203,
0.2324531376,
-0.1316623986,
0.1483375877,
-0.2195838839,
-0.6590941548,
0.644133389,
0.6631822586,
0.4314008057,
-0.4051025212,
-0.0332478136,
0.6834173799,
0.2124774754,
0.2538143098,
0.6483133435,
-0.0703041106,
-0.8090761304,
-0.5397690535,
-1.0020586252,
-0.1752704531,
-0.1027850434,
-0.9698510766,
0.3853299618,
0.2639220953,
-0.1954624504,
-0.056323532,
-0.119283855,
-0.7646414638,
0.4106391072,
-0.1373843849,
0.7146354914,
-0.8603655696,
0.9069907665,
1.063785553,
-0.3222837448,
-0.6368693113,
-0.0943743661,
-0.0742826685,
-0.4818740785,
0.6308225393,
0.283567071,
-0.14633362,
-0.0665474087,
0.1053392515,
-0.8233167529,
1.1207984686,
-0.0490137339,
-0.5893200636,
0.1469180882,
0.2756458521,
0.6439419389,
-0.1923474967,
0.4639424682,
0.5554828048,
0.1594161391,
0.1174143106,
-0.8973833323,
-0.0494507104,
-0.4416666627,
0.0280213151,
0.5720996857,
-0.4075061977,
0.534973681,
0.0859585628,
-0.0874588713,
0.3897290528,
0.8572098613,
0.1163919419,
0.5854583383,
0.2472474128,
0.9247929454,
0.3540786505,
-0.2402143329,
0.6263825893,
-0.4054000676,
0.3299666643,
1.3025636673,
-0.4720667005,
0.9801519513,
0.4451650381,
-0.345849514,
0.6928435564,
0.3607819378,
0.1281009167,
0.5710036159,
0.0187211595,
-0.6667832732,
-0.0299087279,
-0.6837850809,
-0.6387012005,
0.628993988,
0.585318327,
-0.511787653,
-0.1319758743,
-0.0312872715,
-0.1157490909,
0.5120400786,
-0.2653808296,
1.1046842337,
0.1824362874,
-0.5793715715,
0.2794887424,
0.0218001828,
0.6071606278,
-0.6096436977,
-0.3496683538,
-0.0196806733,
0.0588019863,
-0.0931203663,
-0.7141079903,
0.5435948968,
-0.0558374561,
-0.2871381044,
0.1669138819,
0.8967117071,
-0.6695237756,
-0.6370066404,
0.5344141722,
0.7449653149,
0.1429415643,
0.1759639829,
-0.4374096692,
0.1885842979,
0.0080153989,
0.2602925599,
0.2971509695,
0.4988023341,
-0.3002898395,
0.1987827122,
0.5169878602,
-0.0097423997,
-0.0596431121,
0.5363730788,
0.7456831932,
-0.8553709388,
-0.2428364754,
-0.754599452,
-0.142441839,
-0.0198131073,
-0.2698858976,
1.0530314445,
0.7679991126,
0.9941807985,
-0.197883606,
0.6686596274,
-0.0633950904,
0.6995831132,
-0.6263449788,
0.5500242114,
-0.3559353352,
0.312035352,
-0.3379616141,
-1.2508425713,
-0.173636511,
0.6244512796,
-0.2513569295,
-0.0288514215,
0.7929289937,
1.0553644896,
0.0607127994,
0.1547327042,
0.514010787,
-0.3072426319,
-0.1832503676,
0.5850200653,
1.0650074482,
-0.6752587557,
0.2237375379,
-0.1525793374,
0.0954188779,
-0.0940751955,
-0.6843375564,
-0.9479822516,
-0.8868195415,
-0.2629190683,
-0.4512111545,
0.2155446708,
0.981535852,
0.2724682093,
-1.2743910551,
-0.223135516,
0.0245476868,
-0.0892413706,
-0.0561376624,
-0.2410161942,
0.6985115409,
-0.1283495873,
-0.5224889517,
0.2664156854,
0.4280930459,
-0.0409982838,
0.2033330202,
-0.1875326037,
-0.5335114598,
0.0586602017,
0.6469119787,
-0.1157368869,
-0.782089591,
-0.4532305002,
-0.079379037,
-0.1480529606,
-0.1010705605,
0.5990270972,
-0.7511989474,
0.3381670713,
0.5849884748,
0.6191961765,
0.5379219651,
0.2071065903,
0.3871440291,
-0.7612683177,
0.3274530172,
0.3928926885,
0.323269397,
0.5404304266,
-0.0262981318,
0.8186459541,
-0.0204003956,
-0.7544535398,
-0.2866186202,
0.2608889043,
-1.0670737028,
0.1953929067,
0.969940424,
-0.3587062657,
-0.070456095,
-0.6078214049,
-0.2409127355,
0.1515922099,
-0.2784394026,
0.383459121,
0.6798505187,
-0.0167721584,
0.0403951295,
-0.3808859587,
0.4253515601,
0.7291059494,
-0.7755433917,
-0.6558073163,
0.3881751001,
0.1124917939,
0.2755439281,
0.4598200023,
-0.1175208017,
0.2827683091,
-0.0965542048,
-0.0124938376,
0.1939637661,
-0.1092530489,
-0.3434285223,
0.0168205015,
0.0689907447,
-0.0247915313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00657v1
|
RST-LoRA: A Discourse-Aware Low-Rank Adaptation for Long Document Abstractive Summarization
| 2024-05-01T17:37:50 | 2024-05-01T17:37:50 |
Dongqi Pu, Vera Demberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
For long document summarization, discourse structure is important to discern
the key content of the text and the differences in importance level between
sentences. Unfortunately, the integration of rhetorical structure theory (RST)
into parameter-efficient fine-tuning strategies for long document summarization
remains unexplored. Therefore, this paper introduces RST-LoRA and proposes four
RST-aware variants to explicitly incorporate RST into the LoRA model. Our
empirical evaluation demonstrates that incorporating the type and uncertainty
of rhetorical relations can complementarily enhance the performance of LoRA in
summarization tasks. Furthermore, the best-performing variant we introduced
outperforms the vanilla LoRA and full-parameter fine-tuning models, as
confirmed by multiple automatic and human evaluations, and even surpasses
previous state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.1465409845,
-0.7157458067,
0.5798107982,
0.4135147333,
-0.5812023878,
0.2305847108,
-0.0944529101,
-0.4750092626,
0.4939029515,
0.3322329521,
-0.101441741,
-0.3821485937,
-0.9104917645,
0.1562646329,
-0.3951757848,
1.2981700897,
0.1136012748,
-0.3120680749,
0.1833948046,
-0.3276364207,
-0.162213549,
-0.384577781,
-0.5886961222,
-0.2552283108,
0.9531687498,
0.2770071626,
0.6416829824,
0.4970455468,
0.5518748164,
0.2411219776,
-0.4815179408,
0.0865389183,
-0.6175657511,
0.3346225321,
-0.6043999195,
-0.4844496548,
-1.0773096085,
-0.4388080835,
0.8690204024,
0.6911033392,
-0.0613138378,
0.1984785944,
0.3657405674,
1.0097339153,
-0.7320705056,
0.1095960587,
-0.5062823892,
-0.0746954679,
-0.1459320784,
-0.5717810392,
-0.4826383293,
-0.4353429079,
0.1322324574,
-0.7108358145,
-0.2449513227,
0.1026378945,
0.6054248214,
0.3850639462,
-0.5184531808,
-0.1398851424,
-0.6959525943,
0.5713628531,
-0.7597519159,
-0.0876298621,
0.2735364735,
0.1886391938,
-0.0826598406,
-0.5475694537,
0.0527587198,
0.1176895574,
-0.0350404717,
0.4416328371,
-0.1896940023,
0.2974140644,
0.1194481775,
0.3957863748,
-0.345109731,
0.1594205648,
-0.4885368645,
0.2700445056,
0.2501772642,
0.0072287545,
-0.1589171141,
-0.5526870489,
-0.191659227,
0.3299899995,
-0.7905163169,
-0.1460294276,
0.2033298314,
0.763019979,
-0.3441595733,
0.5828015804,
-0.3227794766,
0.6010207534,
0.1296591014,
-0.2132511735,
-0.2485197484,
-0.2256967127,
-0.1979151517,
0.09949404,
0.5227440596,
0.0979040712,
0.0308149643,
0.2578771114,
-0.115580298,
-0.0624634586,
-0.1463422179,
-1.0008227825,
-0.0129732303,
0.0820205584,
-0.5525925159,
-0.4243377447,
-0.218707189,
-0.7276313901,
-0.4738487005,
-0.1524566561,
0.3669598699,
-0.5118044019,
-0.0091577442,
0.1951925904,
-0.1252693236,
0.330881387,
0.6909009814,
-0.9201019406,
0.6434751153,
0.8154752851,
1.0342521667,
-0.4193101227,
-0.2521827519,
-0.7211720943,
0.5024490952,
-0.1879903376,
1.3361217976,
-0.3936069012,
-0.4472919405,
-0.2793060243,
-0.3305963874,
-0.1680761427,
0.002949984,
0.7675845623,
-0.4169917107,
0.496917814,
-0.3509254456,
-0.2924847007,
-0.077527009,
0.1781371385,
-0.4896094799,
0.9552674294,
0.4810741246,
-0.9567309022,
-0.0802860931,
-1.017052412,
-0.8257721066,
-0.1971135288,
-0.0095069893,
-0.5036259294,
0.3170821667,
0.2126738876,
0.2580341101,
-0.1895846725,
-0.1836535633,
-0.0764673799,
-0.5583019853,
0.1178746969,
-0.1600215435,
0.5584571958,
0.1384626776,
0.0920133963,
0.3382626474,
-0.7381314635,
-0.0474982858,
-0.0857112855,
-0.370082736,
-0.5044999123,
0.1231526136,
-0.0384527296,
-0.0471978933,
0.2280628383,
0.0309921056,
0.121937111,
-0.8026974797,
0.7555126548,
0.8214129806,
0.4148899019,
0.4623580575,
-0.4678720832,
0.6692718267,
-0.1509533376,
-0.1497443318,
-0.3072627485,
-0.3668743074,
-0.7277188897,
-0.3123645782,
0.6751782894,
0.542796433,
-0.4675368369,
0.4078745246,
-0.5470736027,
-0.3443416655,
-0.172332257,
-0.151570335,
0.5475668311,
0.3626171947,
0.196631223,
-0.1628468782,
-0.558373332,
-0.6526929736,
-0.4189283848,
-0.1463754624,
0.159879759,
-0.1957274824,
0.6466070414,
0.4330375791,
0.9860748649,
-0.7157478929,
-0.2845134735,
-0.5355687737,
0.4339365959,
0.2417914271,
0.2460370809,
0.7156344056,
-0.4055432379,
-0.6776082516,
0.0059420648,
-0.4456198812,
0.2297318578,
0.1255001873,
0.0138161154,
0.230579704,
0.4100059271,
-0.593357265,
0.5570953488,
0.3769327998,
-0.2166171372,
0.1436441541,
-0.4775992036,
0.1510505527,
-1.6485987902,
0.0545649529,
-0.0873700455,
-0.447685957,
-0.3038109243,
0.1239318252,
0.0688785315,
-0.4021217227,
-0.2900144756,
0.337816596,
-0.5323616862,
-0.5277252793,
-0.3229090273,
0.5318170786,
0.1880401373,
0.6040003896,
-0.1241301745,
0.7108135819,
0.1811400801,
-0.6010690331,
-0.3551998436,
0.3076565266,
-0.3478465974,
0.9594881535,
-0.8651328683,
0.0191129092,
-0.3090139627,
0.5386815667,
-1.0473773479,
-0.3576155603,
0.2141184956,
-0.337928772,
0.1004074439,
-0.5753993392,
-0.2532596588,
0.2325408459,
-0.6002312303,
0.4637752473,
0.443484962,
-0.0431846976,
0.7921008468,
0.1569991261,
-0.6507558227,
-0.7598185539,
-0.6646975875,
0.1544973105,
-0.4159292579,
-0.2983547151,
0.501126945,
-0.0276431087,
-0.2816158533,
-0.2390211821,
-0.0946188346,
0.1493059695,
0.1776417941,
0.3057258725,
0.0224064272,
-0.6284415722,
-0.1414150745,
0.5169786811,
-0.2603079379,
-0.2793059051,
0.155449748,
0.2021937519,
-0.021720415,
-0.3259793818,
-0.3670059443,
0.4717682302,
0.6467623711,
-0.3033799827,
0.5020253062,
0.1019359306,
-0.2853113115,
-0.2559578121,
0.0220169555,
-0.0080704363,
-0.4327525795,
0.6084029675,
-0.4247712791,
-0.6796178818,
0.6709437966,
-0.0926737562,
0.0819694474,
0.5088541508,
0.1518404186,
-0.2308621854,
0.6485025287,
0.7426612973,
-0.1855248064,
0.5251227617,
0.012591688,
0.2889168859,
-0.9126752019,
0.4597957432,
-0.7985343933,
-0.3492685556,
-0.4378650486,
-0.2808584571,
0.5892366171,
-0.1070917249,
-0.1508214325,
0.1528808177,
-0.5054729581,
0.6433190107,
0.025992021,
-0.07048098,
0.7423607707,
0.0270425789,
0.6609700918,
-0.0856130719,
-0.4802453518,
-0.2743381262,
0.7370374799,
0.4054139555,
0.793664813,
0.4605807364,
0.7119455338,
0.4417088628,
0.0920976549,
-1.0275902748,
0.6033993959,
-0.3726810515,
-0.1804045439,
-0.5836114883,
-0.0458706357,
-1.0906426907,
0.4725349247,
-0.0590531565,
-0.5908288956,
0.1614099592,
0.1351601779,
-0.8652064204,
-0.0542309918,
-0.6039239168,
0.3829919398,
0.0203784965,
-0.1487912536,
-0.3365648091,
-0.6349725127,
0.2803362012,
0.0472286977,
0.2697066963,
-0.2081999481,
-0.3018612266,
0.8499832153,
-0.0407446697,
0.9672256112,
-0.0099623427,
-0.3038829565,
-0.071979098,
0.0952245593,
0.9111088514,
0.0587545596,
-0.2579740882,
-0.4596224725,
0.1084148437,
-0.3833620846,
-0.8383926749,
0.716630578,
-0.6887875199,
-0.5498367548,
-0.7184944749,
-0.5016903281,
-0.2796242833,
0.4134478569,
0.2591992319,
0.3587969542,
-0.5808700919,
0.2378699183,
0.893238008,
0.1832604557,
0.3602977693,
0.379645139,
-0.2975291908,
-0.4411781132,
0.7652552724,
0.2806801796,
0.2366966009,
0.74427104,
0.3124389946,
0.0985244066,
-0.948161602,
-0.2616735995,
0.2394094616,
-0.8398828506,
-0.2940298319,
-0.5568928123,
-0.4248011112,
-0.3354891539,
-0.4348762035,
-0.4437044859,
-1.1105407476,
-0.3750609457,
-0.1343867034,
0.6029770374,
0.8972292542,
0.3007742167,
0.5408651233,
-0.13580437,
0.6804664731,
0.1816609502,
0.3739029765,
-0.2819461823,
-0.9963974953,
-0.1564906389,
-0.2429509461,
-0.214703247,
-0.7431447506,
0.1241662353,
0.3683602214,
0.0730206594,
0.2385385931,
0.2257006913,
0.655629456,
-0.2252508998,
0.6479969025,
0.0666470379,
-0.8610969186,
0.5715637803,
-1.0168853998,
0.4913662374,
0.7056564093,
-0.0877399668,
-0.3345862925,
-0.1756336391,
-0.1877663285,
-0.8228882551,
0.5115285516,
0.1131921709,
0.0005373866,
0.3741678894,
0.3011532426,
0.1076414138,
-0.0632711947,
-0.7954263687,
0.035078384,
-0.2808065116,
-0.1871608049,
0.0351892225,
-0.5091725588,
-0.346316278,
-0.1890350878,
0.7145135999,
-0.2708180845,
0.1120456755,
0.0633049607,
-0.2024278045,
0.0257014297,
0.8664386272,
1.1809508801,
1.0019577742,
-0.4979255795,
0.09013322,
0.2930349708,
-0.2558400035,
-0.0636936203,
0.1176696047,
-0.2079039216,
-0.0679067969,
0.1906200945,
0.6366773248,
0.9053052068,
-0.1122877821,
0.4692387879,
-0.0145364711,
-0.3033057749,
-0.3449838459,
-0.0918702558,
0.2462965846,
-0.0180301778,
0.3505505025,
0.2099022418,
0.1369201839,
-0.5465971231,
-0.2669329643,
0.1955831498,
-0.2528119087,
-0.3823242486,
0.3750040233,
0.423542738,
-0.4593472481,
-0.2434435487,
-0.1420368999,
-0.1458161175,
0.1949196607,
0.6759112477,
0.755492568,
-0.1951362789,
0.3328740597,
0.1562612355,
0.1488767117,
-0.1980193853,
0.3734569848,
0.024189027,
-0.0619126372,
-0.5879430771,
-0.3726423979,
-0.6928184628,
-0.1073032469,
-0.6958572865,
0.3451001346,
-0.6133828759,
-0.0453830734,
0.1372395009,
-0.1759874821,
0.1292163283,
-0.282387048,
-0.3962719142,
0.7502118945,
-0.4641501009,
0.7260354757,
0.4146035314,
-0.1996939182,
-0.2405300289,
-0.0322978869,
-0.2543876767,
-0.5119011402,
0.3111101985,
-0.4667027593,
-0.7737450004,
-0.0480915867,
-0.2269911021,
-1.2316502333,
1.140591979,
0.6223535538,
-0.1505582929,
-0.4780839384,
0.0925126374,
0.6817725301,
-0.2925663292,
0.0558697656,
0.3381845057,
0.4343719184,
0.0771492422,
-0.7546966076,
0.0291482788,
0.0255635921,
0.0360470563,
0.311314106,
-0.8247675896,
0.8551207781,
-0.1853038222,
-0.122309491,
0.4527046382,
1.0041766167,
0.2713243663,
0.2302663028,
0.1232118979,
0.1768530309,
0.727378428,
0.1528404653,
0.583014667,
-0.377399236,
-0.0177896693,
1.7011311054,
-0.3554868102,
1.150818944,
0.5035033226,
-0.1623488665,
0.7543990612,
0.2592271268,
0.3891522288,
0.4577699006,
0.0822671875,
-0.0555269979,
0.1625389159,
0.0889525935,
-0.6877425909,
0.5943270922,
0.6286904216,
-0.4854314327,
-0.3944592476,
-0.2031117231,
0.1230070442,
0.3310830891,
-0.3914252818,
0.8045458794,
0.2862245739,
-0.7846727371,
0.6992357373,
0.230470717,
0.6819252372,
-0.7606036663,
0.1336072683,
-0.1936789602,
0.0172550101,
-0.3232272863,
-0.5853309631,
0.2278681993,
-0.1016547456,
-0.3103650808,
-0.15683496,
0.7931143045,
-0.0543794632,
-0.4522036314,
-0.07082434,
0.6161967516,
-0.0279645622,
-0.0269719921,
-0.4448617101,
0.0459224544,
-0.2527385056,
-0.3983644843,
0.7546791434,
0.4579951763,
-0.1037111059,
0.4636078775,
0.2072062343,
0.046569135,
-0.4982803464,
-0.0143610751,
0.8503541946,
-0.8301525712,
-0.9993214607,
-0.7407801151,
0.3170346916,
-0.1744690388,
-0.4194516242,
0.572165966,
0.683693707,
-0.0971562713,
0.1062109917,
0.8646942973,
0.169377327,
0.843881309,
-0.6070618629,
0.9571790695,
-0.1448774487,
0.2215879858,
-0.4315431416,
-0.9042162299,
-0.079016462,
0.4570628107,
-0.3743619025,
-0.1513054967,
0.9727653265,
0.4329083562,
-0.3245838284,
0.1140117645,
0.2416849136,
0.295624584,
0.0063665072,
0.5224952102,
0.600844264,
-0.5815241933,
0.5435988903,
0.1189050898,
-0.0654818863,
-0.2444973439,
-1.2300081253,
-0.978107214,
-0.686532259,
-0.391795516,
-0.3155156374,
0.4553097188,
0.7568071485,
0.5987768173,
-0.5582674742,
-0.2149667889,
0.2588055134,
0.3654845357,
-0.1640009433,
-0.1051644683,
0.6797139645,
0.1054849029,
-0.4563032985,
0.5457645059,
0.6093936563,
0.2526515722,
-0.063694708,
0.0395679213,
-0.0500915162,
0.5052443147,
0.9960382581,
0.6744639874,
-0.5075258613,
-0.417396158,
-0.4165304601,
-0.0973880738,
0.4064510167,
0.8344214559,
-0.481862992,
-0.2606927156,
0.4072545171,
0.3541585505,
0.5346623063,
0.3126178086,
0.4596943855,
-0.8054628968,
0.1329752654,
0.2463304102,
0.3509797156,
0.22972624,
-0.2647401989,
0.5511414409,
-0.2316536754,
-0.4085271358,
-1.0755589008,
0.3307963014,
-1.578492403,
-0.2834286094,
1.09319067,
0.047848396,
-0.3715188503,
-0.2490360737,
-0.4196267426,
0.0603743047,
-0.6126302481,
0.9168629646,
0.5085150003,
-0.1928771287,
-0.2357047945,
-0.2800768614,
0.7028103471,
0.4272271097,
-1.2455239296,
0.3600566685,
0.1691483408,
0.2226661742,
0.1449380964,
0.9436422586,
-0.066761151,
0.3023353219,
-0.3588632047,
-0.5861590505,
-0.0175822452,
0.018763978,
-0.3654236197,
0.565797627,
0.4439526498,
0.2583318353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00632v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00632v1
|
When Quantization Affects Confidence of Large Language Models?
| 2024-05-01T16:58:28 | 2024-05-01T16:58:28 |
Irina Proskurina, Luc Brun, Guillaume Metzler, Julien Velcin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent studies introduced effective compression techniques for Large Language
Models (LLMs) via post-training quantization or low-bit weight representation.
Although quantized weights offer storage efficiency and allow for faster
inference, existing works have indicated that quantization might compromise
performance and exacerbate biases in LLMs. This study investigates the
confidence and calibration of quantized models, considering factors such as
language model type and scale as contributors to quantization loss. Firstly, we
reveal that quantization with GPTQ to 4-bit results in a decrease in confidence
regarding true labels, with varying impacts observed among different language
models. Secondly, we observe fluctuations in the impact on confidence across
different scales. Finally, we propose an explanation for quantization loss
based on confidence levels, indicating that quantization disproportionately
affects samples where the full model exhibited low confidence levels in the
first place.
|
[
-0.2140731066,
-0.4418694675,
0.6755619645,
0.1869179606,
-0.080859296,
-0.1252799332,
-0.1373521388,
-0.3848278522,
-0.1971933246,
0.1899891347,
0.1081308722,
-0.3639721274,
-0.863512218,
0.0648484975,
-0.2966673672,
0.9675699472,
0.0188642815,
0.3981970251,
-0.3535650671,
-0.0103464825,
-0.2237941027,
-1.1692430973,
-0.5958054662,
-0.404274106,
0.4504879117,
-0.0898494795,
1.0801000595,
0.4780302048,
0.3911342025,
0.2457051277,
-0.3118799925,
-0.5167914033,
-0.483520478,
0.1137260571,
0.2155440301,
-1.1765400171,
-0.4161767364,
0.156032145,
0.9080577493,
0.7856372595,
-0.3840502203,
0.18921794,
0.1119949669,
0.4810987711,
-0.9606726766,
0.0892677978,
-0.3093942702,
-0.0903081447,
-0.036874298,
-0.2174710631,
-0.4242601991,
-0.349524647,
0.0055775112,
-0.4448484778,
0.0086634159,
-0.0765360147,
0.7541568875,
0.5229129195,
-0.6937488914,
-0.0272499975,
-0.961509645,
0.9358035922,
-0.8957122564,
0.2524518073,
0.6244131327,
-0.0530698672,
0.2484260499,
-0.4092366695,
-0.33537063,
-0.006579462,
0.0600788444,
-0.2654619515,
-0.0317751206,
0.4021477699,
0.4734578431,
0.6972019076,
-0.302650243,
0.0599691011,
-0.0587625653,
-0.2777677774,
0.4140715599,
-0.098388128,
0.0054310784,
0.0375724882,
-0.0093655596,
-0.4998836517,
-0.9282727242,
0.042648159,
0.602694273,
0.0622237399,
0.1648483127,
0.5155720711,
-0.0418114401,
0.7354573607,
-0.0175779685,
-0.2683171332,
0.0418386906,
-0.2885075808,
-0.4457758665,
0.0618560649,
0.7865927219,
0.2767089307,
0.4912795126,
0.0941083208,
-0.3242120147,
0.0513701662,
-0.0786270723,
-1.1064991951,
-0.3218363225,
0.0286590178,
-0.2924123108,
-0.3045132458,
0.0716500729,
0.1229066327,
-0.4092477858,
-0.0634267107,
0.8156348467,
-0.3237127662,
-0.1430345923,
0.3244556487,
-0.0675974265,
0.1390975565,
0.3361286521,
-0.911539495,
0.3100489974,
0.5690792799,
0.7087217569,
0.4441556036,
0.2789435387,
-0.3813634813,
0.047317706,
-0.6426096559,
0.1861429662,
-0.40404737,
-0.5230950117,
-0.0255045872,
-0.0800280422,
0.1131567061,
-0.4460147619,
0.238394469,
-0.5680288672,
0.0493152738,
-0.1173560396,
-0.6048389077,
-0.1407131553,
0.0647159144,
-0.880672574,
0.7543613911,
0.09790501,
-0.7890692949,
0.3093797565,
0.2970626056,
-0.2306457162,
-0.0090021491,
-0.1355075389,
-0.4129773974,
0.653431654,
-0.0897840187,
0.4095504284,
-0.3468088806,
0.2151335329,
-0.4223663509,
-0.8033437133,
0.7819548845,
-0.5642091632,
0.6205051541,
-0.0436731279,
-0.109245792,
-0.3920955956,
-0.5762947202,
0.3631827831,
-0.1215135306,
-0.4735355973,
-0.6484079957,
-0.0188768823,
-0.1341156065,
0.1019179374,
0.1627227366,
-0.3759331703,
0.252930969,
-0.251178652,
0.6099856496,
0.5891112685,
0.1363713592,
0.4273949265,
-0.1761378795,
0.7236482501,
-0.1134081483,
-0.0266992934,
-0.0035589689,
-0.4506826103,
-0.6523452997,
0.0278535448,
0.9406203628,
0.3883157074,
-0.7308593988,
0.1473085284,
-0.6387668252,
-0.1394170225,
-0.6733746529,
-0.2102960944,
0.5241078734,
-0.0904079527,
-0.1098157763,
-0.2049240619,
-0.217969507,
-1.0381965637,
-0.356071651,
-0.191925168,
-0.5206397176,
-0.1408446431,
0.4894777238,
0.0590583347,
0.8855502009,
-0.4153750241,
-0.0575554855,
0.1314924657,
0.5076193213,
-0.0477679744,
0.5299615264,
0.3420972228,
-0.7138345838,
-0.3734481335,
-0.2994884253,
-0.1364667416,
0.0426951312,
0.0557304285,
0.2679469585,
0.3409553766,
0.39144665,
-0.6332244277,
0.6314297915,
1.0388045311,
-0.0493488498,
0.4964157939,
-0.2057760209,
0.3528102636,
-0.9257085323,
-0.2450033277,
0.2412799895,
-0.3849179745,
-0.5403353572,
-0.017045863,
0.2707616389,
0.0974856988,
-0.2511156797,
0.1826657653,
-0.2967780828,
-0.1750982404,
-0.1063550636,
-0.0424873792,
0.4376276433,
0.2178790569,
0.1410971284,
1.029510498,
0.3619893193,
-0.4886083901,
-0.0920555294,
-0.0978323892,
-0.4912633002,
0.3935874403,
-0.8502112627,
0.0839605704,
0.0079909936,
0.3873824775,
-0.9466730356,
-0.1542396098,
-0.2251046747,
-0.5579953194,
0.6317787766,
-0.38587901,
-0.8724330068,
-0.15125902,
-0.5835829973,
0.5530086756,
0.5059577227,
-0.0964868367,
0.0689548105,
0.191029802,
0.0594722405,
-0.2626574039,
-1.3060468435,
0.0196849406,
-0.1941471994,
-0.4752045572,
0.34292081,
-0.2381636202,
-0.4218322039,
-0.2277063578,
-0.3860729635,
-0.2650595903,
0.0997612923,
0.2490067184,
-0.004746594,
-0.0568672791,
0.5454150438,
-0.1146330535,
0.1177973375,
0.2342597544,
-0.3411966562,
0.4490877986,
-0.3509259224,
-0.0339742228,
-0.4907838404,
0.054005485,
0.3109499216,
-0.0941425115,
1.2442322969,
0.4448880553,
-0.281159699,
0.0862975642,
-0.5153592825,
-0.3297330737,
-0.4544155598,
0.2937279642,
-0.476772666,
-1.1987478733,
0.3553646505,
0.0605033413,
-0.6337550879,
0.310836941,
0.5880801082,
-0.1702534258,
1.273360014,
0.8145813942,
0.0084026493,
0.3759638369,
-0.1314396262,
0.3185686171,
-0.8977489471,
0.1587569118,
-0.7159426808,
-0.2551893592,
-1.0172502995,
-0.6506962776,
0.3132975399,
0.3260211945,
-0.3732384145,
-0.0233493969,
-0.4232888818,
0.4907147586,
0.5496717095,
0.0727546513,
0.3700959384,
-0.0897972807,
0.4762575924,
-0.1604578495,
-0.7356308103,
-0.5360800624,
1.2163197994,
0.5009638071,
1.142952323,
0.2808713019,
0.5949538946,
0.1678784937,
0.2805667222,
-0.9704870582,
0.1715988666,
-0.0053965147,
-0.6479947567,
-0.4730462432,
-0.810340941,
-0.7687520385,
0.1129049435,
-0.1247512996,
-0.6587232351,
0.3537694216,
0.2567826509,
-0.7317541838,
0.0290565342,
-0.7515577674,
0.6996613145,
0.0929710343,
-0.0465890765,
-0.0286871195,
-0.632599175,
0.6220689416,
-0.3020944893,
0.4113701582,
0.0106689632,
-0.255981952,
0.8025177121,
-0.6427769661,
0.9303337336,
0.1388504207,
-0.5527274609,
0.2519575953,
0.2652766407,
0.5329112411,
0.1774582267,
-0.0694310963,
0.3996047974,
0.396930635,
-0.4787772596,
-0.6987091303,
0.5319315791,
-0.7108299732,
-0.5954123735,
-0.3944763243,
-0.610348165,
-0.3279581368,
-0.3130325377,
0.5424948335,
0.3913374841,
0.3274769187,
0.4776142836,
1.0806481838,
-0.3718149066,
0.2862227857,
0.2511777878,
0.0127353501,
-0.3926286101,
0.5892972946,
0.3894788921,
0.8336514235,
0.4939103723,
0.1673824787,
-0.1166384518,
-0.356544137,
0.1002282724,
0.2761025727,
-0.7170645595,
-0.4071100056,
-0.0691663101,
-0.1563590765,
-0.7373052239,
0.1953191161,
-0.4000213444,
-0.7798201442,
-0.2707630396,
-0.0749624893,
0.3315385282,
0.6555634141,
0.163462162,
0.8827046156,
-0.762922883,
-0.1529346406,
0.4231577814,
0.4509317279,
-0.2178417593,
-0.7785134912,
-0.6398146749,
0.1938525587,
0.0296324436,
-0.8768391013,
0.1721076816,
0.2718216777,
-0.0518533699,
0.4441198111,
-0.1351637542,
0.5489447713,
-0.3309005201,
0.8396523595,
0.1221020967,
-1.1828118563,
0.1850378215,
-0.1891146749,
0.6252990961,
0.4233010411,
0.5386765003,
-0.6258149147,
-0.2196841985,
-0.5612640977,
-0.6572271585,
0.4970457852,
0.0335739926,
0.2123345584,
0.0052153626,
0.4737186134,
-0.3072508276,
0.6193218231,
-1.060111165,
-0.2430942506,
-0.059361998,
-0.0465280935,
-0.2516206205,
-0.7480068207,
-0.0020592178,
-0.0792487562,
0.5254845023,
0.0216821358,
0.1354892701,
0.0123032136,
-0.1128664389,
-0.1784267277,
0.3421901464,
0.4952621758,
0.2645345628,
-0.2150053233,
0.2114209682,
-0.1452811211,
-0.3816250861,
0.3067443371,
-0.17284742,
-0.218879208,
-0.0963414833,
0.565859139,
0.9468104839,
0.5395901799,
-0.3766033947,
0.6697425842,
-0.0773599967,
-0.3403106332,
-0.1481813341,
-0.1350653023,
-0.0388824716,
-0.0062307687,
0.2793291509,
-0.1706366539,
0.1771718562,
-0.5998988152,
-0.1787807941,
0.613951385,
-0.1099157259,
-0.2561487257,
0.6699033976,
-0.1622736901,
-0.076524958,
0.5413557291,
-0.1096307561,
-0.4625331461,
0.4923992157,
0.2447670251,
0.5729824305,
-0.6169041991,
0.1464472264,
0.2943773568,
0.4940921962,
-0.487449497,
-0.1149338111,
-0.010315707,
-0.6252114177,
-1.0436159372,
-0.7326502204,
-0.4060316086,
0.1217320487,
-0.8070904613,
-0.1130742282,
-0.3158289194,
-0.7405539751,
-0.4739118516,
0.0828595534,
-0.4566783011,
0.4207975268,
0.5139189959,
0.648665905,
-0.8170273304,
0.8987721205,
0.439321965,
-0.3991838098,
-1.2034972906,
0.0477796793,
-0.1766887456,
-0.4824685752,
0.8239460588,
0.0580401309,
-0.0583067834,
0.4028403163,
-0.6325080395,
-1.2558435202,
0.9386631846,
0.4572627246,
-0.5574040413,
-0.1325787604,
0.4607990086,
0.7151090503,
0.1319610029,
0.2476527989,
0.6949926019,
0.444090575,
0.1370936781,
-1.0760160685,
-0.0358057581,
0.2368092388,
0.4830854833,
0.4877863824,
-0.4871890545,
1.1256914139,
0.0758293346,
-0.3170296252,
0.1576933563,
0.2999097109,
0.0483313799,
-0.2167372555,
0.1915363967,
0.7420114279,
0.5990470648,
-0.256390214,
1.450406909,
-0.3740317822,
0.5464752913,
0.8436959386,
0.0205636676,
0.8286975026,
0.5374756455,
-0.5537235737,
0.3298819959,
0.7635211349,
0.2246038914,
0.3008995652,
0.7071534991,
-0.3103613853,
-0.2654345632,
-0.0659686849,
-0.2483917624,
0.2178023458,
0.4544356763,
-0.1640859991,
0.1781490445,
0.1650495082,
0.1810556203,
-0.1905186772,
-0.6036964059,
0.338629365,
0.3233858943,
-0.3742405772,
0.9482801557,
0.0805928335,
0.6460595727,
-0.518353045,
0.2348625213,
-0.2035719752,
-0.0695942417,
-0.173146382,
-0.5955337286,
-0.0118590835,
-0.362937957,
-0.1022046134,
-0.3934458196,
0.2492062747,
-0.579616785,
-0.4098438919,
-0.0900684148,
0.3839785755,
0.2167201787,
-0.6936249733,
-0.2065683156,
0.3745493293,
-0.1128265932,
-0.725109458,
0.5753239393,
0.7047401071,
-0.1309546232,
0.7202089429,
0.3435714543,
0.2320214659,
-0.0368563607,
0.1049809307,
0.5304667354,
-0.422847271,
-0.1544204056,
-0.9000017047,
0.1597971916,
0.2296080142,
0.1254286319,
0.8680999875,
0.3623303473,
0.7973527908,
-0.0627689585,
0.5381180048,
0.2330571413,
0.1077052727,
-0.5687039495,
0.691336453,
-0.5131431222,
0.3416257203,
-0.1391747147,
-1.0252766609,
-0.5454559922,
0.6096485853,
-0.5018708706,
0.3751729727,
0.7867798209,
0.436236769,
0.657417655,
-0.5332756639,
0.7471321225,
0.3712506294,
0.1218727529,
0.5683140755,
0.4675935507,
-0.5106330514,
0.6400200725,
-0.3493539691,
-0.1666251719,
-0.1690619439,
-0.8924474716,
-0.6831183434,
-0.5997076631,
-0.5134330988,
-0.3007396758,
-0.0980931222,
0.2923484445,
0.9043263793,
-0.4727247953,
-0.1068401635,
-0.029136857,
-0.0519893877,
0.2211849689,
-0.2664951086,
0.2996510267,
-0.1467171162,
-0.8681818247,
-0.1438801885,
0.136872828,
0.554053843,
-0.4191207886,
0.1108097583,
0.2351948023,
0.2254544795,
0.5667207837,
-0.0129792988,
-0.5405825377,
-0.3212493956,
-0.2325828522,
-0.3753379881,
-0.0114400247,
0.7953649163,
-0.9522340298,
0.1485825628,
0.1497056037,
0.3696709275,
0.4890668094,
0.2448675632,
0.6657262444,
-1.0931913853,
0.2600662112,
0.2076257616,
0.1906069666,
0.4579657912,
-0.4514240623,
0.4509380162,
0.1893976033,
-0.8132523298,
-0.8857394457,
0.1737744063,
-0.5064287186,
-0.3391241431,
1.1828355789,
-0.0584322773,
-0.2289504558,
0.4294656813,
0.0713136792,
0.1758173704,
-0.2395843416,
0.5726120472,
1.2930865288,
0.1177476794,
-0.4318674803,
-0.7936843634,
0.7231741548,
0.4578214586,
-0.3871364892,
0.1241343543,
0.5180979371,
0.169850558,
0.1051119119,
0.4941785038,
0.1107221022,
0.0387041569,
0.0421503969,
0.3650268018,
0.463100642,
0.1347246319,
-0.8174288273,
0.0220502522,
0.5369647741,
0.0967198461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00622v1
|
Causal Evaluation of Language Models
| 2024-05-01T16:43:21 | 2024-05-01T16:43:21 |
Sirui Chen, Bo Peng, Meiqi Chen, Ruiqi Wang, Mengying Xu, Xingyu Zeng, Rui Zhao, Shengjie Zhao, Yu Qiao, Chaochao Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Causal reasoning is viewed as crucial for achieving human-level machine
intelligence. Recent advances in language models have expanded the horizons of
artificial intelligence across various domains, sparking inquiries into their
potential for causal reasoning. In this work, we introduce Causal evaluation of
Language Models (CaLM), which, to the best of our knowledge, is the first
comprehensive benchmark for evaluating the causal reasoning capabilities of
language models. First, we propose the CaLM framework, which establishes a
foundational taxonomy consisting of four modules: causal target (i.e., what to
evaluate), adaptation (i.e., how to obtain the results), metric (i.e., how to
measure the results), and error (i.e., how to analyze the bad results). This
taxonomy defines a broad evaluation design space while systematically selecting
criteria and priorities. Second, we compose the CaLM dataset, comprising
126,334 data samples, to provide curated sets of causal targets, adaptations,
metrics, and errors, offering extensive coverage for diverse research pursuits.
Third, we conduct an extensive evaluation of 28 leading language models on a
core set of 92 causal targets, 9 adaptations, 7 metrics, and 12 error types.
Fourth, we perform detailed analyses of the evaluation results across various
dimensions (e.g., adaptation, scale). Fifth, we present 50 high-level empirical
findings across 9 dimensions (e.g., model), providing valuable guidance for
future language model development. Finally, we develop a multifaceted platform,
including a website, leaderboards, datasets, and toolkits, to support scalable
and adaptable assessments. We envision CaLM as an ever-evolving benchmark for
the community, systematically updated with new causal targets, adaptations,
models, metrics, and error types to reflect ongoing research advancements.
Project website is at https://opencausalab.github.io/CaLM.
|
[
-0.1604996175,
-0.852270782,
0.4901842475,
0.6302430034,
0.1218328327,
-0.2261251956,
-0.5531291366,
-0.322685957,
-0.3716267347,
0.0580978505,
-0.3801415265,
-0.4634643197,
-0.4449374974,
-0.010513314,
-0.48715958,
0.7451678514,
0.0056799804,
0.0023508179,
0.00747194,
-0.1052895188,
-0.6229372621,
-0.2860942483,
-0.9610029459,
-0.4452264905,
0.6959497333,
0.3189153075,
0.7535033226,
0.6014738679,
0.6353750825,
0.3419980109,
0.1572777927,
-0.3800986409,
-0.6533302069,
0.0239698235,
-0.5358898044,
-0.1945753396,
-0.3670054972,
0.1280492842,
0.7045916915,
0.836990118,
-0.1390868574,
0.2165878266,
-0.1692939848,
0.4304275215,
-0.932631135,
0.3394361734,
-0.5199826956,
-0.2329304069,
-0.1081922576,
-0.0722478852,
-0.6669963002,
-0.445622623,
0.0784718543,
-0.4426912665,
-0.171789825,
0.1745654494,
0.7211977243,
0.4029386044,
-0.6310144067,
-0.0643894672,
-0.9134999514,
0.9528012872,
-0.8468703032,
0.4693244696,
0.3597133458,
0.2608795166,
-0.4295991063,
-0.7510229945,
-0.46031636,
-0.3984620869,
0.2199387848,
0.3335797489,
-0.5359886289,
-0.1632570177,
0.2578616142,
0.1048258096,
-0.609727025,
0.3607103825,
-0.1068671867,
-0.1805521399,
0.7854278684,
0.4412361383,
0.446954459,
0.1776690185,
-0.3438347876,
-0.0017907951,
-0.3744663894,
0.0869688913,
0.1324287355,
0.5002954006,
-0.2325618565,
0.2050071657,
-0.4046031237,
0.648393929,
-0.040622469,
-0.2070290893,
-0.1343888938,
-0.2823590338,
-0.2738054693,
-0.1161262169,
0.920563519,
0.353764534,
0.0643122122,
-0.2934775352,
-0.1562481076,
0.2311531305,
0.2735697329,
-0.6184982657,
-0.1224348694,
0.250446707,
-0.2664576173,
-0.1870041043,
-0.2337129563,
-0.7265306115,
-0.4171274602,
-0.550319314,
0.4131257832,
-0.2193502933,
-0.3810156882,
0.3898634613,
0.1051008627,
0.1858318001,
0.3355282545,
-0.5853193402,
0.6017563939,
0.7478385568,
0.417796284,
-0.0768702701,
-0.5749025345,
-0.170789957,
-0.0608406626,
-0.5295863152,
1.0292114019,
-0.5256866217,
-0.2162479013,
0.1883225292,
-0.1683505177,
-0.328953594,
-0.1844232827,
1.1794805527,
-0.4183694124,
0.1714603603,
-0.3410610259,
-0.5473546982,
-0.3222632706,
-0.0438950956,
-0.6026613712,
1.0236138105,
0.0096516097,
-0.735640049,
0.4688514173,
-0.3135387599,
-0.5638023615,
-0.0871783122,
0.1379590631,
-0.2271863669,
0.15373604,
-0.1079816222,
0.2108813226,
-1.1895323992,
0.9990522861,
-0.6543463469,
-0.3121962249,
0.3910304606,
-0.4609113038,
1.0509032011,
0.2710696757,
-0.5832337141,
0.3406015337,
-0.8333560228,
-0.0039394824,
-0.0197972246,
-0.3143112361,
-0.2987494469,
0.3337763548,
0.005480045,
0.5076110959,
0.0489835776,
-0.1928523928,
-0.1058919281,
0.0045368425,
0.1877927631,
0.7162703276,
0.1391198933,
0.221153602,
-0.1907408535,
0.384359628,
-0.0297947116,
0.5076519251,
0.051107198,
-0.4455486238,
-0.9463623762,
-0.3241033554,
-0.064006485,
0.6612568498,
-0.3182842135,
0.5033246875,
-0.2171743959,
-0.7897593975,
-0.4079792798,
0.0177536458,
0.5848991871,
0.7630009651,
0.191641286,
-0.2917977571,
-0.3020150363,
-0.8459747434,
-0.5962551832,
-0.5998131633,
0.1704549491,
0.123606883,
0.4389458001,
-0.2665322125,
0.8012465239,
-0.3151828647,
0.2412537187,
0.0717377365,
0.5529565215,
0.1649032831,
0.4917038381,
0.4467157125,
-0.4044791758,
-0.0502964184,
-0.1411532313,
-0.8484000564,
-0.4759230316,
-0.1773169935,
-0.3888257146,
-0.11485935,
0.6365833282,
-0.4737693965,
0.2860772312,
0.2303600758,
-0.5861423016,
0.8141018152,
0.1162693352,
0.3450647295,
-0.6919619441,
0.5394046307,
0.1064582393,
0.3073203862,
-0.8408755064,
0.1254067868,
-0.1089552566,
-0.2655419111,
-0.3102076054,
0.898483932,
-0.0468101688,
0.2846596539,
-0.0494782068,
0.1843585074,
-0.1664791256,
0.581605196,
-0.2500575483,
0.3262884915,
0.699537456,
-0.5224793553,
0.1739515662,
-0.2192481756,
-0.4322555661,
0.5333049893,
-0.7033780813,
0.1584737599,
0.0599403791,
-0.0457911119,
-0.8223307133,
-0.2390494347,
0.1442350149,
-0.2278236896,
0.2230751067,
0.259570539,
-0.5685783625,
-0.4255638421,
-0.0570003353,
0.3468254507,
0.3167140186,
-0.3066791892,
0.3807148635,
0.5128447413,
-0.1738120168,
-0.4804622233,
-0.4515000582,
0.0145469066,
-0.3402251303,
-0.4703807235,
-0.0809980482,
-0.2038214505,
-0.7564979792,
0.113425374,
-0.0175949894,
-0.3407749832,
0.5187308192,
0.2317697853,
0.1122037247,
-0.3653547764,
0.2839266658,
-0.0510202758,
-0.2536339164,
0.3404038548,
-0.2447788119,
0.0925365686,
-0.4268845916,
-0.3708269,
-0.477676481,
0.2341554761,
0.6633198857,
-0.2941074371,
0.7607604861,
0.6269451976,
-0.6110009551,
-0.0976139084,
-0.5344557762,
-0.1351706535,
-0.344581008,
0.2206306309,
-0.2611370683,
-0.8975658417,
0.6089260578,
-0.3511672914,
-0.0809395611,
0.6031182408,
0.831646204,
0.3263635933,
1.1302233934,
0.6184626222,
-0.4249952734,
0.2570730448,
0.4734752774,
0.5486861467,
-0.4776470065,
-0.1871753335,
-1.0690108538,
0.0639415458,
-0.515098393,
-0.4605410695,
0.0683522075,
0.5563957095,
-0.6528708339,
0.1787546277,
0.0361470655,
0.1536690295,
0.3103519082,
-0.1061417535,
0.1891844273,
-0.3852344453,
-0.2398054451,
0.050395444,
-0.7368175387,
-0.5880876184,
0.8108595014,
0.3620412648,
0.8138630986,
0.3049325049,
0.1761024594,
0.1716273278,
0.7152371407,
-0.6877638102,
0.603525281,
0.1229762211,
-0.8968211412,
-0.3063515425,
-0.5131972432,
-0.8876562715,
0.1299976259,
-0.0996925235,
-0.951577127,
0.3814848959,
0.0124054123,
-0.0653365403,
-0.0867197961,
-0.8077089787,
1.1139739752,
-0.2036582977,
-0.6831276417,
-0.432144016,
-0.5833537579,
0.8414241076,
-0.3595798314,
0.4029197097,
-0.4468425512,
0.2098092586,
0.7029466629,
-0.2010572404,
0.9331965446,
0.0231338311,
-0.0173061192,
0.3977610171,
0.1553979516,
0.0087696323,
-0.1165451854,
-0.5312510729,
0.2447942346,
-0.2281993032,
-0.4430127442,
-0.7125568986,
0.8903966546,
-0.8031727672,
-0.6043684483,
-0.3400949538,
-0.6618622541,
-0.3015444577,
0.3774616718,
-0.355329901,
0.5978304148,
-0.4906631708,
-0.0895873308,
0.2697121799,
-0.4528800249,
0.3069705963,
1.0637338161,
-0.3562562764,
-0.2338982075,
0.8856591582,
-0.280377239,
0.2197857052,
0.3789038062,
0.5186131597,
-0.261821419,
-0.2615028024,
0.0336248092,
0.0747629255,
-1.0163861513,
-0.1363485157,
-0.3759763837,
0.1086471081,
-0.5504978895,
-0.1834952831,
-0.2292053849,
-0.2910995483,
-0.0448651873,
0.056109909,
0.2166391313,
0.565007627,
-0.2181730717,
0.0500107855,
-0.3619631529,
0.0726968572,
0.2720930874,
0.3838863969,
0.1972163618,
-0.4732099771,
-0.3419913054,
-0.3788208961,
-0.0544177629,
-0.8678253293,
0.1735375375,
0.1501264721,
0.8693185449,
0.6665099859,
0.2038768679,
0.8454645276,
-0.529835999,
0.5504817963,
0.0640927628,
-1.1061251163,
0.6663677692,
-0.4688745737,
0.5475292206,
0.7686769366,
0.4494436979,
-0.3958119154,
-0.6355108619,
-0.5615203381,
-0.7392923832,
0.4907597005,
-0.0045719435,
-0.2586521804,
-0.2984327376,
0.4086273015,
-0.1661000848,
-0.0564150885,
-0.5244549513,
-0.1428037733,
0.1374404728,
-0.1121447012,
-0.3206276298,
-0.12773256,
-0.1536864042,
-0.3590756059,
0.7596700191,
-0.0683660731,
0.1621744186,
-0.058894515,
-0.1517313421,
-0.3729007542,
0.4043720961,
0.6134153008,
0.7479248047,
-0.1708515584,
0.3570509553,
0.088222146,
-0.1971924007,
0.1126800925,
0.3036155999,
-0.1933833957,
-0.244738698,
0.7847773433,
0.8417569995,
0.8425411582,
-0.7710016966,
0.2098365128,
-0.2257745862,
0.4138081074,
0.1120053381,
-0.0727986172,
-0.0863050669,
0.1300652772,
0.0013164845,
0.1249261647,
0.2547200918,
-0.5892209411,
0.2706384063,
-0.0010542946,
-0.6357390881,
-0.5551772714,
0.6874462366,
0.1276618838,
-0.1728297025,
0.6136696935,
-0.1858320236,
-0.4178607166,
0.4716015458,
0.6684881449,
1.1889199018,
-0.7145229578,
0.2147295177,
0.7282057405,
0.7532439828,
-0.0545930713,
0.5105077624,
0.1667927057,
-0.6979004145,
-0.3836042583,
-0.7486233115,
-0.3805759847,
-0.0864858329,
-0.8413374424,
0.3448932767,
-0.4152469635,
-0.2299690992,
-0.0457709767,
-0.0284866076,
-0.7489791512,
0.3175774515,
0.0096778506,
1.0515956879,
-1.1351131201,
0.837051928,
0.56485641,
-0.4971586466,
-0.9795571566,
-0.0496649109,
0.4036984444,
-0.5949119925,
0.7424117327,
-0.0244053379,
-0.3256629407,
-0.1460799426,
-0.5196171403,
-0.8510142565,
0.8100376129,
0.5526157022,
-0.3854644895,
0.5948782563,
0.0216633044,
0.7778491974,
-0.2441791892,
0.3305840492,
0.7209818363,
0.6696441174,
-0.1557691544,
-0.7836695313,
0.3297185898,
-0.5359077454,
-0.1495487243,
-0.0598532744,
-0.510638535,
0.8234039545,
-0.2338015437,
-0.2983927429,
-0.0733865276,
0.6039770246,
0.2902569473,
0.2959683239,
0.3110583723,
0.6736072302,
0.8403990865,
-0.2057504207,
1.4455821514,
-0.4988065064,
0.3346995711,
1.3364555836,
-0.6473529935,
0.9863955975,
0.2450954914,
-0.0848379061,
0.46210289,
0.5593851209,
0.3510484099,
0.3571481407,
0.3368634284,
-0.3506180942,
-0.2579069138,
-0.6111367345,
-0.0423099212,
0.3544562161,
0.4778428674,
0.0298217572,
-0.2842952609,
-0.2717297971,
0.3354452848,
0.0701357722,
-0.2429347634,
0.4900914431,
0.1219547689,
-0.8915707469,
0.3709399998,
0.2236906588,
-0.1462636888,
-0.5902158618,
0.2573464215,
-0.3943171799,
0.3726236224,
0.0208120719,
-0.5014466643,
0.1966917813,
0.0913522765,
-0.0254843887,
-0.1028389707,
0.9097778201,
-0.2481294274,
-0.5879849792,
0.5828924775,
0.4387758076,
0.1631586403,
0.2876501381,
-0.8755614758,
0.5358028412,
-0.4222052991,
-0.2024309188,
0.1217349768,
0.5768125057,
-0.4046919644,
0.8185346127,
0.5503115654,
-0.1179081202,
0.109457612,
0.633906424,
0.8242759109,
-0.755056262,
-0.259614259,
-0.753700316,
0.6392284632,
0.2039256245,
-0.6576321125,
0.8318267465,
0.3806390762,
0.4808908999,
0.1180286855,
0.5281028152,
-0.0108528398,
0.2127935141,
-0.3573458195,
0.5782782435,
-0.3942572773,
0.0629345551,
-0.56695503,
-0.6593069434,
-0.6362061501,
0.4122031629,
-0.6154459715,
-0.0094717676,
0.8766091466,
0.7245369554,
0.3003523052,
0.0704999343,
0.3197270632,
0.5503296852,
0.3079063296,
0.4439471066,
0.9996201396,
-0.3054241836,
0.0211782083,
-0.2272947282,
-0.5421941876,
-0.1925489902,
-1.0988628864,
-0.8853214979,
-0.6324004531,
-0.6850128174,
-0.1034269556,
0.0992397293,
0.5730575919,
0.5901377797,
-0.9304041862,
-0.5714476705,
-0.0292079225,
0.3211224377,
-0.4015575945,
-0.2583284676,
0.3023508191,
-0.5807810426,
-0.3653920591,
0.5214993358,
0.6677693725,
-0.488383919,
-0.2805819213,
-0.1426575184,
-0.4588606656,
0.3550450802,
0.6703014374,
0.5146005154,
-0.8544824123,
-0.3982822597,
-0.1854422241,
-0.3088979125,
-0.4951912761,
0.9719759822,
-0.4110991955,
0.6469596028,
0.3772295415,
0.6200179458,
0.0371196717,
-0.3870481551,
0.70305866,
-0.1393126696,
0.3787721395,
0.1283261776,
0.4884877503,
0.1949488074,
-0.0316426083,
0.480078727,
0.1133741811,
-0.6659376621,
-0.9199129343,
0.1970385909,
-0.9577794075,
-0.2115522027,
0.8803513646,
-0.3587316275,
-0.1293490976,
-0.2447040975,
0.1006280854,
0.3588356972,
-0.150803715,
0.9345206022,
0.7107405663,
-0.1220866144,
-0.0836048871,
-0.6259535551,
0.3529774547,
0.428159833,
-1.1189504862,
0.1089087129,
0.6208477616,
-0.0388961732,
0.0469688773,
0.5333173275,
-0.2489322275,
0.2994420826,
0.2608914971,
0.2072796375,
0.6099526882,
-0.3802570403,
-0.6368408799,
-0.0083764074,
0.3091188669,
0.5568153262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00611v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00611v1
|
Addressing Topic Granularity and Hallucination in Large Language Models for Topic Modelling
| 2024-05-01T16:32:07 | 2024-05-01T16:32:07 |
Yida Mu, Peizhen Bai, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) with their strong zero-shot topic extraction
capabilities offer an alternative to probabilistic topic modelling and
closed-set topic classification approaches. As zero-shot topic extractors, LLMs
are expected to understand human instructions to generate relevant and
non-hallucinated topics based on the given documents. However, LLM-based topic
modelling approaches often face difficulties in generating topics with
adherence to granularity as specified in human instructions, often resulting in
many near-duplicate topics. Furthermore, methods for addressing hallucinated
topics generated by LLMs have not yet been investigated. In this paper, we
focus on addressing the issues of topic granularity and hallucinations for
better LLM-based topic modelling. To this end, we introduce a novel approach
that leverages Direct Preference Optimisation (DPO) to fine-tune open-source
LLMs, such as Mistral-7B. Our approach does not rely on traditional human
annotation to rank preferred answers but employs a reconstruction pipeline to
modify raw topics generated by LLMs, thus enabling a fast and efficient
training and inference framework. Comparative experiments show that our
fine-tuning approach not only significantly improves the LLM's capability to
produce more coherent, relevant, and precise topics, but also reduces the
number of hallucinated topics.
|
[
-0.7027754784,
-1.0570861101,
0.6511019468,
-0.0262906197,
-0.4443335533,
-0.3593502343,
-0.4278244376,
-0.1599851102,
0.3333079517,
0.9326555729,
-0.4505001605,
-0.6082184315,
-0.6199009418,
-0.0098321848,
-0.2729128897,
0.766207993,
0.1670540273,
-0.0703797415,
-0.2045660317,
0.246833086,
-0.5010198951,
-0.6584840417,
-0.4938656986,
-0.3736861944,
0.4980766475,
0.364413023,
0.6978858113,
0.644405067,
0.460039258,
0.1845988929,
-0.5394209027,
0.3470770121,
-0.7939705253,
0.2457927018,
-0.3229727745,
-0.170165062,
-0.6254048944,
-0.2616177201,
0.3538902104,
0.8785956502,
-0.0136351045,
-0.0796046108,
0.0617047362,
0.5164911151,
-0.5191168189,
0.0310558081,
-1.1098634005,
-0.0724726915,
-0.0790542215,
-0.5036914349,
-0.3049323857,
-0.1016648188,
-0.0305739418,
-0.3396477699,
0.517565012,
-0.2006925792,
0.7944462895,
0.4477961957,
-0.2214834094,
-0.441812098,
-0.6967077255,
0.6838696599,
-0.6616725326,
0.2556571364,
0.4895473719,
0.0030114618,
-0.4012790918,
-0.484413147,
-0.4119134843,
-0.1534042954,
0.0889864713,
-0.3010946512,
0.028089663,
0.1725996137,
0.2341615856,
0.5117481947,
-0.4791733325,
0.2466235161,
-0.2053800374,
-0.2722296715,
0.5430454612,
0.2781685591,
-0.1257244051,
-0.4361371696,
0.0215954315,
0.2397138476,
-0.5655218959,
-0.3652112782,
0.3419823647,
0.5199102163,
0.2524334192,
0.4796384275,
-0.4294739664,
0.8370209932,
0.5429365635,
-0.305365622,
0.1522552222,
0.0931807607,
-0.0689432472,
0.1640644073,
0.5139821172,
-0.0045592021,
0.040337462,
-0.4949033558,
-0.1377695948,
-0.0223211385,
0.4643508494,
-0.9494649172,
-0.1224479526,
0.6990149021,
-0.3699059486,
-0.4590364993,
0.0703703538,
-0.7704792619,
-0.4846454263,
-0.6316139698,
0.412135005,
-0.3135939837,
-0.325173974,
0.5319740772,
0.2212377191,
0.1650271416,
0.6708996296,
-1.0045053959,
0.1917553991,
1.1017518044,
0.8211219907,
-0.4784862697,
-0.2982782125,
-0.5819890499,
0.2218579799,
-0.4578563273,
0.8755620122,
-0.5948939323,
-0.4174362123,
-0.1224993989,
-0.0963149592,
0.3870172501,
-0.7930852175,
0.4948491454,
-0.380990386,
0.1738421172,
-0.3641473353,
-0.4004881084,
0.0254459307,
0.2993661165,
-0.435867399,
0.8567180634,
-0.1332575381,
-0.8075440526,
0.3588220179,
-0.5212352276,
-0.2634027302,
-0.0663130581,
-0.3633843064,
-0.1247771084,
0.4260958433,
0.1472970098,
0.6462333798,
-0.2857148349,
1.0150324106,
-0.2938334942,
-0.3959162235,
0.0645578802,
-0.4873896837,
0.2732017934,
0.1644183546,
-0.4160239398,
0.4080018997,
-0.6913588047,
-0.3295151889,
-0.1791258007,
0.0273439251,
-0.3706265688,
-0.0962789208,
-0.0483087525,
0.263928026,
0.4030179977,
-0.1319366544,
0.4241198003,
-0.4266583025,
0.2742484808,
1.040273428,
0.1243609339,
0.472925514,
-0.3575761318,
0.2619441748,
0.2353331745,
-0.0622297712,
-0.0373440273,
-0.2818315327,
-0.7009640932,
-0.4884822667,
0.2171065658,
0.2031209022,
-0.4903087616,
0.8302352428,
-0.2676078975,
-0.3674038649,
-0.3687089682,
0.006122468,
-0.0584526807,
0.3424286842,
0.1676664948,
-0.2196534276,
-0.2404187471,
-0.8677785993,
0.0724381506,
-0.0149263674,
0.1429657638,
0.5784778595,
0.3569456339,
-0.398538202,
0.972130239,
-0.7750858665,
-0.3201741278,
-0.1531413347,
0.2101482153,
0.2380706519,
0.1849176735,
0.1849395633,
-0.9623318911,
-0.2733869553,
0.083261475,
-0.6911507845,
-0.335142076,
-0.20355694,
-0.3174974024,
0.1172380447,
0.4006530941,
-0.7824747562,
0.301628828,
0.0290142689,
-0.159604609,
0.5457108617,
-0.1783117205,
0.0759300813,
-1.3113161325,
-0.0363696963,
-0.2196800411,
-0.1105620861,
-0.6043381095,
0.0542639047,
-0.1686135679,
-0.3594705164,
-0.5434210896,
0.9153711796,
-0.3961094022,
0.0241999011,
-0.719289124,
0.1373182684,
-0.1500958502,
0.3017444611,
0.3361808658,
0.6899939179,
0.8719177246,
-0.6752800345,
0.0270223655,
0.2216461301,
0.0315446407,
0.1349048018,
-0.4343319535,
0.2590176463,
-0.3320160508,
0.086510703,
-0.6221898794,
-0.4395408034,
0.2153732032,
-0.1095997393,
0.3839305341,
-0.1839153171,
-0.3263756633,
0.0202633496,
-0.380826205,
0.1368231475,
0.34773314,
-0.487644881,
0.4200490415,
0.4173240066,
-0.211308524,
-0.5977876782,
-0.1306969374,
0.1937927157,
-0.456714958,
-0.5410666466,
0.5803999901,
-0.0907894596,
-0.46509552,
-0.1611596942,
-0.2892825902,
-0.0707402229,
0.0780802593,
0.4949888587,
-0.1591884196,
-0.0392448828,
0.1326993108,
0.1863229275,
-0.2226174623,
-0.2348939329,
-0.2037673593,
1.0671267509,
0.1358110905,
-0.304082036,
-0.2385488898,
0.4196406603,
0.6061328053,
-0.0119383382,
0.5732848048,
0.5530162454,
-0.4586384594,
-0.4326997995,
-0.6661228538,
-0.3994689882,
-0.4577962458,
0.4160619974,
-0.5768600702,
-1.1010922194,
0.5324882865,
-0.212792024,
-0.1181188002,
0.4457374215,
0.9889418483,
0.4566229582,
0.4368442297,
0.6472028494,
-0.2257905304,
0.4361275434,
-0.2209486365,
0.1277856529,
-0.5974194407,
-0.1015649736,
-0.528803587,
0.0292665884,
-0.3401625156,
-0.6055609584,
0.1507027596,
0.249610737,
-0.00034512,
-0.0191487148,
-0.5790124536,
0.4561628103,
0.2448986322,
0.1828424633,
0.3293671608,
0.3646830916,
0.2260128707,
0.0808071643,
-0.4250406921,
-0.881432116,
0.8394116163,
0.2699147463,
1.0042079687,
-0.1519900858,
0.985396266,
0.3694613874,
-0.1379047483,
-0.8246644139,
0.664139092,
-0.2405789196,
-0.5008060932,
-0.4615167379,
-0.4985383451,
-0.8393028975,
0.5270581841,
0.0110348994,
-0.8604667187,
0.3754394054,
-0.0718815476,
-0.2339597344,
0.3987368941,
-0.2173941135,
0.643075943,
-0.0426462367,
-0.491844058,
-0.1442896575,
-0.1404911131,
0.3314100504,
-0.3131323457,
-0.0277351364,
-0.2360982895,
-0.0263519064,
0.4442871511,
-0.0976681337,
0.9458366036,
0.0213300511,
-0.5640769601,
0.1871913821,
0.1471024156,
0.2829933465,
0.4415766001,
-0.3979234993,
0.398761034,
-0.2798233926,
-0.335832864,
-0.4196004868,
0.9422149658,
-0.8821092248,
-1.0734678507,
-0.4127793312,
-0.7181962729,
-0.1468593031,
-0.0096845645,
0.2996884882,
0.5945423841,
-0.2865519822,
0.0482781641,
0.9421166182,
-0.3307484388,
0.3477803469,
0.3829149604,
-0.4017485678,
-0.4197144508,
0.9751201272,
0.1216457933,
0.1653290093,
0.3536019921,
0.1496920884,
0.0164276287,
-0.9110851288,
-0.2793515623,
0.2746324241,
-0.6379195452,
-0.0322963446,
-1.0652858019,
-0.3438350856,
-0.6452468634,
-0.2210816294,
-0.3680379093,
-0.2541047335,
-0.7536728382,
0.0134062152,
0.2811088562,
0.5028522015,
-0.1926860213,
0.1785036623,
-0.5364979506,
0.8186116815,
0.2093219161,
0.2280162126,
0.03486,
-0.835324645,
0.0205378216,
-0.0326489434,
-0.4616223574,
-0.6099565029,
0.4773362577,
-0.0679422095,
0.5532932281,
0.6197576523,
0.2162911296,
0.7761016488,
-0.3995615542,
0.808157742,
-0.1725317389,
-0.8560280204,
0.721427381,
-0.4642442167,
0.122580424,
0.6494660974,
0.5423606038,
-0.3313138187,
-0.2119620442,
-0.5200613737,
-0.8832120299,
0.6158624291,
0.1734137237,
0.2955163121,
-0.2266383767,
0.643528223,
0.764680028,
0.3196046054,
-0.5592594147,
-0.1416922957,
0.0908209607,
0.1326597333,
-0.1565718204,
-0.5152272582,
-0.077604264,
-0.1858337969,
0.6701024175,
-0.2181101888,
0.1162876561,
0.0970925242,
-0.1055315286,
-0.2340504378,
0.2878424823,
0.6871358156,
0.8759386539,
-0.4471958876,
0.1155828387,
-0.0359089598,
-0.435477078,
0.1720328629,
0.0033316826,
-0.3586684763,
0.1745237261,
0.2399841398,
0.9100476503,
-0.2309149057,
-0.4301480353,
0.2509978116,
0.0391016416,
-0.2800758183,
-0.0361087434,
0.1811369061,
-0.0810210481,
0.0975953341,
0.3357984126,
-0.2148441672,
0.1637206674,
-0.6035844088,
0.2683590651,
0.4958776832,
-0.516985774,
-0.2488026619,
0.3827058375,
0.1166166887,
-0.435100317,
0.132344991,
-0.189621523,
-0.3037290275,
0.4538127184,
0.4724413157,
0.980997324,
0.1076832116,
0.382748872,
0.0709819272,
0.0465860665,
-0.3342657089,
0.3320159912,
-0.0566051155,
-0.587594986,
-0.3562589884,
-0.8889914751,
-0.5315366387,
0.5249444842,
-0.6805030704,
0.5132318139,
-0.1873953193,
-0.0466855243,
0.0396239161,
0.0031969531,
-0.1209232286,
0.1074832082,
0.1254581064,
0.5914058685,
-0.7961142063,
0.8966883421,
0.6164088249,
-0.1448582113,
-0.2578862906,
0.4886562526,
-0.3591927886,
-0.3096827269,
0.4833642244,
0.1228570268,
0.0324763693,
-0.0987101197,
-0.5431854129,
-0.626873374,
0.8952715397,
0.4911083579,
-0.5703738332,
-0.1334739476,
0.3334590197,
0.4091312885,
-0.2656431496,
0.0281524137,
0.305228442,
0.2805497646,
0.3426675498,
-0.8815632463,
-0.0472550578,
0.1189482734,
-0.0810794607,
0.4094520807,
-0.6628057361,
0.8962420225,
-0.0109077804,
0.1850928217,
-0.1251285821,
0.5564467907,
0.3112987876,
0.3346570432,
0.2580435872,
0.5798358917,
0.9234586358,
0.0722656623,
0.7790723443,
-0.3613867164,
0.3356996179,
1.1110806465,
-0.5288048387,
0.6267515421,
0.5929151177,
0.1220624596,
-0.1607298106,
0.9046971798,
0.2927428186,
0.7002435327,
0.3649378121,
-0.1104472876,
-0.4091074765,
-0.1320708394,
-0.6836354136,
0.3962046504,
0.2810155153,
-0.2310720086,
-0.2919392884,
0.1064240783,
-0.1579875201,
-0.118545413,
-0.4649171233,
1.0739605427,
0.150799349,
-0.4754951298,
0.7761528492,
0.0073370934,
0.8553907275,
-0.4318628907,
0.0707136095,
-0.4878916144,
0.0423776135,
-0.1108924448,
-0.4310348928,
0.3195233345,
0.0041143275,
-0.5156266689,
-0.1164644584,
0.948143661,
-0.3548510969,
-0.5085633993,
0.1449319273,
0.6274549961,
0.3228622675,
-0.5251767635,
-0.4336512387,
0.1716677994,
0.0994367972,
-0.2193547487,
0.7026754022,
0.9824644923,
-0.160564065,
0.5941753387,
0.4814188182,
0.3391893208,
-0.1970017552,
0.1062244847,
1.0363606215,
-0.838807106,
-0.3747641146,
-0.9557711482,
0.2184820473,
0.0440306067,
-0.368485719,
0.5054374337,
0.622187376,
0.6526040435,
-0.160890311,
0.6510424018,
0.1670944989,
0.2022966594,
-0.5684649944,
0.60729146,
-0.6050332189,
0.4604094923,
-0.4054210484,
-1.1210950613,
-0.2227171063,
0.4996325672,
-0.4858796895,
-0.0975301564,
0.4530256987,
1.0738102198,
-0.2256768048,
-0.1224377826,
0.6469349265,
0.2407312393,
0.2427010536,
0.2688808739,
0.9201927185,
0.0266574398,
0.2346321195,
-0.4614143372,
-0.0643795878,
-0.3440110385,
-0.7750848532,
-1.1839795113,
-0.601187706,
-0.4461086988,
-0.2134646922,
0.1182545051,
0.8720425367,
0.6622475386,
-0.7816368937,
-0.2576082051,
-0.0447192155,
0.1791076809,
0.1708320975,
-0.239745751,
0.5258912444,
-0.4095138013,
-0.5651840568,
0.1186680645,
0.4839501977,
-0.0390276387,
-0.5074982643,
0.0655563176,
0.1456030011,
0.104144454,
0.7103591561,
-0.2808459103,
-1.1309847832,
-0.1837639958,
0.0178129934,
-0.1707790196,
0.2107976526,
0.8675254583,
-0.6414600015,
0.1532477736,
0.3708252907,
0.5166942477,
0.5946836472,
0.1759096831,
0.2770467401,
-0.3303786516,
0.3654716611,
0.2431922704,
0.1269849241,
0.2170556635,
-0.5952289104,
0.3899637461,
0.0592338257,
-0.4919091761,
-1.0455745459,
0.2241021842,
-1.1604350805,
-0.6973284483,
1.5936236382,
0.2624513507,
-0.133038938,
-0.1560108364,
-0.6645717621,
-0.0061817192,
-0.4485778809,
1.222974062,
0.6109540462,
-0.0331889242,
0.076320529,
-0.3958056271,
0.4175781608,
0.1277124137,
-0.8588218689,
0.5099844933,
0.6094009876,
0.0840175152,
0.1039888486,
0.670501411,
0.0576807186,
-0.0247183349,
-0.0327087305,
0.0975477621,
-0.1027405038,
-0.6088443995,
-0.4781242013,
0.5857006311,
0.2038996667,
0.1473320276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00602v1
|
Investigating Automatic Scoring and Feedback using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-01T16:13:54 | 2024-05-01T16:13:54 |
Gloria Ashiya Katuka, Alexander Gain, Yen-Yun Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Automatic grading and feedback have been long studied using traditional
machine learning and deep learning techniques using language models. With the
recent accessibility to high performing large language models (LLMs) like
LLaMA-2, there is an opportunity to investigate the use of these LLMs for
automatic grading and feedback generation. Despite the increase in performance,
LLMs require significant computational resources for fine-tuning and additional
specific adjustments to enhance their performance for such tasks. To address
these issues, Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning (PEFT) methods, such as LoRA and
QLoRA, have been adopted to decrease memory and computational requirements in
model fine-tuning. This paper explores the efficacy of PEFT-based quantized
models, employing classification or regression head, to fine-tune LLMs for
automatically assigning continuous numerical grades to short answers and
essays, as well as generating corresponding feedback. We conducted experiments
on both proprietary and open-source datasets for our tasks. The results show
that prediction of grade scores via finetuned LLMs are highly accurate,
achieving less than 3% error in grade percentage on average. For providing
graded feedback fine-tuned 4-bit quantized LLaMA-2 13B models outperform
competitive base models and achieve high similarity with subject matter expert
feedback in terms of high BLEU and ROUGE scores and qualitatively in terms of
feedback. The findings from this study provide important insights into the
impacts of the emerging capabilities of using quantization approaches to
fine-tune LLMs for various downstream tasks, such as automatic short answer
scoring and feedback generation at comparatively lower costs and latency.
|
[
-0.3026194572,
-1.1701651812,
0.6126372218,
0.176188007,
-0.1251259595,
0.1802105755,
-0.4091874361,
-0.4082128704,
-0.2106595635,
0.5515268445,
-0.165347591,
-0.5948115587,
-0.4024786055,
0.0360674262,
-0.2788236737,
1.2513896227,
-0.1275855452,
0.0882052258,
-0.0193003789,
0.0054648188,
-0.4940496981,
-0.7545924187,
-0.9320218563,
-0.3720450699,
0.6725366116,
0.4257420003,
0.5784166455,
0.5940991044,
0.6127787232,
0.2990050614,
-0.0494220331,
0.1933267564,
-0.3676832914,
-0.0817243904,
-0.1750341803,
-0.609477818,
-0.948058188,
0.1577810049,
0.8451622128,
0.6260986328,
-0.2324647754,
0.5105668902,
0.3406414092,
0.7297801971,
-0.6373677254,
0.246027112,
-0.480607003,
-0.1075281948,
-0.0340564623,
-0.1833807379,
-0.5049879551,
-0.6007704139,
-0.011015771,
-0.4709951878,
-0.1252885908,
-0.1307428926,
0.7369017005,
0.5160143971,
-0.383841902,
-0.3108356893,
-0.737067759,
0.9181753397,
-0.7493758798,
-0.1043006778,
0.6304289699,
0.2693424523,
0.1528766453,
-0.4346399605,
-0.1742366105,
-0.3081021309,
0.0110674519,
-0.1266677827,
-0.0927060395,
0.2569578588,
0.1925988495,
0.5104430914,
-0.2065148652,
0.4527299702,
-0.2461523265,
-0.1450086981,
0.7686482668,
0.3841960728,
-0.2410750687,
-0.0840823203,
0.1016541123,
-0.1222076565,
-0.699984014,
0.3359038532,
0.4251441956,
0.3403003812,
0.0170311574,
0.5062927008,
-0.3825891316,
0.8001456857,
0.3828661442,
-0.2314973772,
-0.0118295979,
-0.1919733733,
-0.3192380965,
-0.2176035941,
0.7485189438,
0.4233064055,
0.3903902471,
0.0215458069,
-0.5355214477,
0.1163058132,
0.0506722629,
-0.8720318675,
-0.414000839,
-0.0719906688,
-0.4968603849,
-0.5884621739,
-0.2839065194,
-0.6804240346,
-0.26720649,
-0.6018117666,
0.7629988194,
-0.187528044,
0.1513657868,
0.0078694364,
0.4604009688,
0.0205603763,
0.8264466524,
-0.7074786425,
0.347178638,
0.5331551433,
0.7892922759,
-0.2396834195,
-0.1586506218,
-0.8561884165,
-0.0543774888,
-0.3843629658,
0.9531938434,
-0.5945477486,
-0.1077983603,
-0.1120527089,
-0.0953963399,
0.0088139307,
-0.7005519271,
0.4313595891,
-0.5556537509,
0.0346712321,
0.0676566511,
-0.4871770144,
-0.1703964919,
0.4867621958,
-0.5471785069,
0.9524950385,
0.2245284766,
-0.3474309444,
0.0525610894,
-0.472836107,
-0.1155503318,
-0.0285496674,
0.2326872796,
-0.5202434659,
0.2002625912,
0.137697041,
0.5418814421,
-0.4416806698,
0.3614916503,
-0.3239473104,
-0.6446594596,
0.2981798649,
-0.536452949,
0.1425271779,
0.1342767477,
-0.4485335946,
0.1606106609,
-0.862521708,
0.3481704295,
-0.1311195195,
-0.8062443733,
-0.3164851069,
-0.1420324296,
-0.0779332891,
0.0266833231,
0.271933943,
-0.3553894162,
0.276925683,
-0.3254228234,
0.5565648079,
0.9136636853,
-0.0061360402,
0.406927675,
-0.3712878227,
0.6553816795,
-0.2318736762,
0.1347801387,
-0.11161419,
-0.1750960946,
-0.7870998383,
-0.1776200533,
0.8099173307,
0.4573537409,
-0.3348783255,
0.2014183402,
-0.1157738864,
-0.4414554834,
-0.5571610928,
0.3109868765,
0.4861102998,
0.2533207536,
0.2144221067,
-0.1672864556,
-0.2483323663,
-0.7495347857,
-0.1218691319,
-0.2619296908,
-0.0156628434,
0.2444758117,
0.2628180981,
-0.0875987336,
0.7681168914,
-0.4517040253,
-0.3919748366,
0.2041095495,
0.2417956889,
0.0902150422,
0.3925445676,
0.4141045809,
-0.3532842398,
-0.5787542462,
-0.1001257151,
-0.3055811524,
-0.3383144438,
0.1605096608,
-0.0551576652,
0.4101341069,
0.4408383369,
-0.2224585712,
0.194111377,
0.6775383353,
-0.3455000222,
0.5120454431,
-0.1143347919,
0.2094941735,
-0.5484259129,
0.021094162,
0.1264028847,
-0.4221636951,
-0.2253764421,
0.0107658766,
0.1121602878,
0.1614716202,
-0.2290296406,
0.4165888131,
-0.108417958,
0.1917221993,
-0.5319252014,
-0.1500006765,
0.0295769013,
0.7401821613,
-0.0118247299,
0.6923841238,
0.1598496437,
-0.5520246625,
0.0843287185,
-0.1875434071,
-0.246534735,
0.5922076702,
-0.765841186,
0.2516451776,
0.140266791,
0.2291288525,
-0.9074723721,
-0.1767484546,
0.0103393551,
-0.2746017575,
0.2064966857,
-0.3113904297,
-0.7830522656,
-0.1476131678,
-0.3622760475,
0.4687647521,
0.6044096351,
-0.3496901691,
0.3693191707,
0.4500298798,
-0.3160147071,
-0.1357747316,
-0.4494107962,
-0.2041701525,
-0.3467383981,
-0.2411792874,
0.2265572101,
-0.2262906134,
-0.3770864606,
-0.2238024622,
0.1810346395,
-0.0762237012,
0.2641608417,
0.3547605276,
0.1668786407,
-0.2523257434,
0.273814857,
0.3557115793,
0.0609121397,
0.1911826134,
-0.1890570819,
0.4658121169,
-0.5262796283,
-0.1041621342,
-0.3864887357,
0.1616294533,
0.6891801357,
-0.2933624685,
0.5311183929,
0.4948700368,
-0.3039400876,
-0.3171759248,
-0.6657781005,
-0.2352142781,
-0.4746762812,
0.3257728815,
-0.2026532143,
-1.1980905533,
0.3584346175,
-0.2143437564,
-0.0161328185,
0.4621676803,
0.9274155498,
-0.1718948185,
1.4015586376,
0.6596910357,
0.0025784115,
0.4013001323,
-0.3208148181,
0.0035811546,
-0.6861408353,
-0.1288764775,
-0.4738466144,
-0.3824610412,
-0.6469824314,
-0.3469165266,
0.3348116875,
0.4823734164,
-0.4139504135,
-0.0686670393,
-0.5296761394,
0.6148092151,
0.5301136971,
0.1141893566,
0.4799049497,
-0.0117857577,
0.0210211053,
0.1491165757,
-0.4383224249,
-0.8175414205,
1.1619763374,
0.6538530588,
0.8336052299,
-0.1066801175,
0.480748415,
0.4487037659,
0.4666677117,
-0.9002992511,
0.4128407538,
-0.3165429533,
-0.1373840272,
-0.3900255859,
-0.3746523559,
-0.5871521235,
0.0963697284,
-0.007288429,
-0.4909059405,
-0.0702666119,
0.3403927386,
-0.7563966513,
0.1048295647,
-0.7279154062,
0.5481398702,
-0.180580616,
-0.6414685845,
-0.3844708204,
-0.377913028,
0.2316254079,
-0.504678309,
0.2047729492,
-0.3001250923,
0.1010617986,
0.964225769,
-0.5184448957,
1.0299947262,
-0.214105323,
-0.6933245659,
0.4248334765,
0.2193411291,
0.4937288761,
0.3416289687,
-0.2669449747,
0.1163445115,
0.3576458693,
-0.1754259765,
-0.5961682796,
0.9231572747,
-0.9872483611,
-0.5492609143,
-0.2022905201,
-0.6024767756,
-0.363353163,
-0.0604444481,
0.0163828414,
0.2093866616,
0.3830337822,
0.0221884921,
0.5859525204,
-0.1171593294,
0.3960321248,
0.8625026345,
-0.2563179731,
-0.6768162251,
0.9777842164,
0.2607889175,
-0.0226871315,
0.3321848512,
0.2453530431,
-0.1179919541,
-0.5347331762,
-0.4711860716,
0.3120610416,
-0.5909842253,
-0.6154024005,
-0.3850194216,
-0.104232125,
-0.158397913,
0.0116156451,
-0.3601838946,
-0.614291966,
-0.4098714888,
-0.038315855,
0.3897254467,
0.9009426832,
0.0011305489,
0.5157903433,
-0.8634277582,
-0.0151779903,
0.3644734025,
0.6617485881,
0.2457635254,
-0.7462376356,
-0.549164474,
0.0346386693,
-0.5380336046,
-0.5257475376,
0.2443095446,
0.2555834055,
0.0819140375,
0.0562612154,
-0.0525967255,
0.7120760679,
-0.3865794539,
0.7088614106,
-0.1726587862,
-1.1919089556,
0.6487265229,
-0.4031811059,
0.265017122,
0.6151375175,
0.1150095612,
-0.1226599365,
-0.37835747,
-0.0310910065,
-0.7151405811,
0.7970046997,
-0.1082220376,
0.0601509735,
0.0555083603,
0.6446843743,
0.2277325094,
0.2514722347,
-0.6814510226,
0.1239961982,
0.100061886,
-0.2455814183,
-0.1088797301,
-0.3264034986,
0.0947342068,
-0.4452337325,
0.6186236739,
-0.3610378504,
0.0303506311,
-0.055507455,
-0.0671023577,
-0.4316366315,
0.2663549185,
0.5136554837,
0.4846962094,
-0.1709451675,
-0.0053456263,
0.3122879863,
-0.3207077682,
0.3943040073,
-0.1035718173,
-0.1166414618,
-0.18580769,
0.1551986933,
0.7112151384,
0.0292074624,
-0.8439424038,
0.2977547944,
-0.0308116749,
-0.2426934093,
-0.3353400528,
0.1016919464,
-0.2305380255,
0.3333040476,
0.3208886981,
-0.1378528476,
0.1602639705,
-0.3564227521,
-0.0005055186,
0.3561886847,
-0.3058407605,
-0.4741137028,
0.5408357978,
0.1664228588,
-0.2782298326,
0.5492013693,
0.0414465256,
-0.3715134263,
0.5621157289,
0.3746610284,
0.5209845901,
-0.1999346316,
0.2405365407,
0.3667742908,
-0.0553301349,
-0.1865487397,
0.0906808674,
-0.2691093683,
-0.1579093635,
-0.8127948046,
-1.1512134075,
-0.5024941564,
0.2346287072,
-0.797491014,
0.2709346712,
-0.6135033369,
-0.5608377457,
-0.244285658,
0.3049864471,
-0.4614313245,
0.3586413562,
0.4049448967,
0.5310617685,
-0.7157897949,
0.976457119,
0.8493360877,
-0.2263726592,
-1.1589657068,
-0.0815400779,
-0.3572535813,
-0.4292562604,
0.8407660127,
0.0785516351,
-0.1662130952,
0.1532347649,
-0.3696906567,
-0.9395411015,
0.7898224592,
0.5187539458,
-0.8488405347,
-0.3518056571,
0.3351562917,
0.9246423244,
0.0126250712,
0.4758967161,
0.8329403996,
0.4252514243,
-0.2964240611,
-1.2189216614,
-0.1156164929,
-0.3874180019,
0.0820727199,
0.4053945839,
-0.987940371,
0.9370785952,
0.0141180931,
0.2557539642,
0.2342031896,
0.507175982,
0.460537672,
0.3395868242,
0.4228367209,
0.6520287991,
0.693325758,
-0.0625139996,
0.8673812747,
-0.3714509606,
0.5286390781,
0.89078933,
-0.2325532883,
1.0087291002,
0.3933940828,
-0.3184872866,
0.628593564,
0.7519395351,
-0.1956530958,
0.5329122543,
0.5988001227,
0.0604886413,
-0.2813437283,
-0.1717869788,
-0.013807388,
0.493488729,
0.3088715672,
-0.3826187253,
-0.0145706972,
0.2645254135,
-0.1807736009,
0.1808507293,
-0.8090986013,
0.7943664789,
0.1207501516,
-0.9075838327,
0.8535993695,
0.3722342849,
0.8930897117,
-0.2402102798,
-0.1753793806,
-0.4055922925,
0.3852259517,
-0.302228868,
-0.5824873447,
0.2298547328,
0.4478514791,
-0.3663024008,
-0.1855544895,
0.3008578718,
-0.3394739032,
-0.6047354341,
0.1620184779,
0.2807798386,
-0.1184055284,
-0.1816387624,
-0.4993746281,
0.1430399716,
-0.2221202999,
-0.3253134191,
0.5488237143,
0.3391757905,
-0.4023472965,
0.538066864,
0.4155284762,
0.0974928215,
-0.0139822252,
0.0852984041,
0.6207844019,
-0.4544965923,
-0.4452757537,
-0.9666234255,
0.0832719579,
0.4684098065,
-0.230366841,
0.7185956836,
0.501381278,
0.9470443726,
0.0007708322,
0.5949034691,
0.3501441479,
0.6327784061,
-0.6376353502,
0.7463746667,
-0.5526951551,
0.3820061088,
-0.3532595336,
-0.8737614155,
-0.2857154906,
0.4570635855,
-0.4951258302,
0.1395905167,
0.5406916142,
0.5224276185,
0.2856845558,
-0.2860442102,
0.2177305818,
0.0679764971,
0.2562609911,
0.7597945333,
1.049880743,
-0.4101833105,
0.5586761236,
-0.5598984957,
-0.0733651295,
-0.3282194138,
-0.5046518445,
-0.9839076996,
-0.3964921236,
-0.6784403324,
-0.3025940359,
0.123804532,
0.7915745974,
0.6874549389,
-0.9644332528,
-0.2573066056,
-0.062925525,
-0.1942031384,
0.076175198,
-0.3226443231,
0.6338983178,
-0.2512115538,
-0.9811066389,
0.0717562288,
0.2208117545,
0.1048426032,
-0.2692121863,
-0.0946741328,
0.3285117745,
0.1468254328,
0.7669665813,
-0.0909921378,
-0.8278104663,
-0.1583158821,
0.0881717801,
-0.2311646938,
0.0539558344,
0.650318265,
-1.1566464901,
-0.2152405679,
0.3686105311,
0.4634312391,
0.2480987757,
0.256988734,
0.5154377818,
-0.4375902712,
-0.2589694262,
0.3552190065,
0.064372994,
0.3082997799,
-0.451494813,
0.44502303,
-0.1151611805,
-0.8647338152,
-1.1096487045,
-0.1577839702,
-0.7306415439,
-0.2237092853,
1.0814237595,
-0.1782218516,
-0.1924571246,
0.3146289885,
-0.3980987966,
0.2281101346,
-0.415204674,
1.0135263205,
0.5773800015,
-0.1897467524,
-0.228763178,
-0.2811446786,
0.4629075825,
0.7597180605,
-0.8358245492,
0.084454909,
0.4857802093,
0.3109647036,
-0.0081650596,
0.4222117066,
-0.1005506143,
0.410233587,
-0.5142108798,
-0.1997947097,
-0.0617724247,
-0.3170827329,
-0.7796091437,
0.4722579718,
0.4479382932,
0.1453230828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00588v1
|
Are Models Biased on Text without Gender-related Language?
| 2024-05-01T15:51:15 | 2024-05-01T15:51:15 |
Catarina G Belém, Preethi Seshadri, Yasaman Razeghi, Sameer Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Gender bias research has been pivotal in revealing undesirable behaviors in
large language models, exposing serious gender stereotypes associated with
occupations, and emotions. A key observation in prior work is that models
reinforce stereotypes as a consequence of the gendered correlations that are
present in the training data. In this paper, we focus on bias where the effect
from training data is unclear, and instead address the question: Do language
models still exhibit gender bias in non-stereotypical settings? To do so, we
introduce UnStereoEval (USE), a novel framework tailored for investigating
gender bias in stereotype-free scenarios. USE defines a sentence-level score
based on pretraining data statistics to determine if the sentence contain
minimal word-gender associations. To systematically benchmark the fairness of
popular language models in stereotype-free scenarios, we utilize USE to
automatically generate benchmarks without any gender-related language. By
leveraging USE's sentence-level score, we also repurpose prior gender bias
benchmarks (Winobias and Winogender) for non-stereotypical evaluation.
Surprisingly, we find low fairness across all 28 tested models. Concretely,
models demonstrate fair behavior in only 9%-41% of stereotype-free sentences,
suggesting that bias does not solely stem from the presence of gender-related
words. These results raise important questions about where underlying model
biases come from and highlight the need for more systematic and comprehensive
bias evaluation. We release the full dataset and code at
https://ucinlp.github.io/unstereo-eval.
|
[
-0.0572300367,
-0.3239990175,
0.3443068862,
0.2264997512,
0.0113381585,
-0.1961575001,
-0.3221096098,
-0.4154234827,
-0.2132315189,
0.5760074258,
-0.5936259031,
-0.4906052053,
-0.4001478851,
0.1393943131,
-0.5215587616,
1.1167856455,
0.1655941904,
0.6564528346,
-0.4138213992,
-0.2758516371,
-0.441988796,
-0.6392301321,
0.1576638222,
-0.5458744168,
-0.1602840126,
0.2820135951,
0.5165473819,
0.4842475057,
0.1787079275,
0.2016921192,
-0.1950703263,
-0.2906242013,
-0.4749923348,
0.1434365809,
-0.1275144368,
-0.4908772409,
-0.2917135358,
0.4863348305,
0.3131145239,
1.0266909599,
-0.1281947643,
0.1919152737,
0.1998894066,
0.8217229247,
-0.7830079794,
0.1406697333,
-0.7446978092,
0.0482681133,
-0.1368736625,
0.0307653714,
-0.327136308,
-0.3251214325,
0.3298775256,
-0.3385629952,
0.5828832984,
0.1113433167,
0.579443574,
0.1259443909,
-0.6381169558,
-0.386184454,
-0.3849577904,
0.949993372,
-0.5222941041,
0.4770707488,
0.5128289461,
-0.1136390418,
-0.1944824606,
-0.1606963277,
-0.2677868903,
-0.4669472873,
-0.0737174153,
0.0472088195,
-0.3879852295,
0.1109952182,
0.4215297997,
0.2689898908,
-0.2785475552,
-0.0507984161,
-0.4409587085,
0.0786023289,
0.5061798692,
-0.1628948897,
0.3834248483,
-0.4494685531,
-0.3790927827,
-0.1358200908,
-0.6299222112,
0.0191512518,
0.753662765,
0.4728139937,
-0.2742576599,
0.7911965847,
0.079983823,
0.310661763,
-0.0377005488,
0.4940616488,
0.4471123219,
-0.0571372248,
-0.3600544035,
0.2411860377,
0.8814864159,
0.4268478155,
0.7691097856,
-0.2509220243,
-0.1862036884,
0.2181434482,
0.4285320044,
-0.5867210627,
-0.119054392,
-0.0742915943,
-0.4782138467,
-0.5836606622,
-0.0366464481,
-1.1148270369,
-0.5440584421,
0.0980581418,
0.0551236421,
-0.144463405,
-0.2418016791,
-0.0965751186,
-0.413949132,
-0.1603230387,
-0.0909938663,
-0.9778807163,
0.2175739706,
0.3801377416,
0.5475511551,
0.0429379195,
-0.2027789801,
-0.2954436243,
-0.1290403455,
-0.6538171768,
0.5552152395,
-0.8128346801,
-0.5447731614,
0.2097891122,
-0.0681353062,
-0.0994837731,
-0.528721571,
0.6896058321,
-0.0280359425,
0.6436570287,
-0.3447492123,
-0.5278992057,
-0.0114097549,
-0.0530644357,
-0.6559554338,
1.1184227467,
-0.0228096433,
-1.2107044458,
0.5518850684,
-0.7562625408,
-0.1401453912,
-0.4318106771,
-0.3116950095,
-0.1124092564,
0.4205003381,
0.1738629639,
-0.0780671537,
-0.4154029191,
0.6239435673,
-0.4759292305,
-0.2897775471,
0.2943247557,
-0.5607024431,
0.8229373097,
-0.1589433253,
-0.563788712,
0.0286443923,
-0.5248301625,
0.0539708585,
-0.1200269386,
0.0133441184,
-0.8556479812,
-0.1320960224,
0.3052354455,
0.2671127915,
0.0693838447,
-0.7471431494,
-0.0253088064,
-0.391094774,
0.2427060753,
0.8788176775,
-0.5802091956,
0.923900485,
-0.2097092867,
0.4181179106,
-0.2407922,
-0.0097562987,
0.3212242126,
-0.266995877,
-0.6260010004,
-0.3434518874,
0.3479775786,
0.3574444354,
-0.613212347,
0.04734971,
-0.0008954011,
-0.2248217314,
-0.68457973,
0.114118062,
0.7645549774,
0.5019032955,
0.2829176784,
-0.1316589415,
-0.6091445088,
-1.2784730196,
-0.9105992317,
-0.3329476714,
-0.1765593737,
0.2236306667,
0.6824973822,
0.0078074019,
0.9174007773,
-0.1700240225,
-0.3838997781,
-0.2973937392,
0.4282141328,
0.0905903876,
0.3141363859,
0.7010609508,
-0.4948910773,
0.1033269614,
-0.4257044196,
-1.013543129,
-0.5970959067,
0.2757243514,
-0.1702786833,
0.3956401944,
0.2800897956,
-0.5025221109,
0.4119851291,
0.7748804092,
-0.5845839381,
0.3420238495,
-0.1645157635,
0.0732381344,
-0.5635770559,
0.196470812,
0.1468268931,
-0.1817452759,
-0.6695116758,
-0.1961484253,
-0.0124286152,
0.1897339821,
-0.408388257,
0.8090034127,
-0.5536106229,
-0.233039245,
-0.4004671872,
-0.1969056129,
-0.070481725,
0.3280640543,
0.3145148754,
0.7090588212,
0.4073623419,
-0.4017971456,
-0.4595051706,
0.2059116513,
-0.1651642174,
0.4700058699,
-0.6480336189,
0.1712634861,
-0.4507099986,
0.0563168526,
-0.516982615,
0.0436925627,
0.1320186555,
-0.3824876249,
-0.056924317,
-0.2697297335,
-0.2199997008,
-0.1824686676,
-0.6016117334,
0.3454867899,
0.4619448483,
-0.3815986216,
0.1839240342,
0.4452819824,
0.2536450326,
-0.814522326,
-0.7177032828,
-0.4003764987,
-0.1345180869,
-0.2538909018,
0.0762358233,
-0.1325442195,
-0.5684638023,
-0.183513388,
-0.3971348107,
-0.3388625979,
-0.1127857789,
0.4766784906,
0.40419963,
0.1466420293,
0.2036501318,
0.0931050479,
0.3258800209,
0.0679125339,
-0.176979214,
0.3632411063,
-0.1623289585,
-0.0004426294,
-0.3224199712,
0.3104413748,
0.5872092843,
0.1940301657,
0.6170545816,
0.2113319188,
-0.4501323402,
-0.2508482933,
-0.3447467685,
-0.3267278969,
-0.388723433,
0.4810991287,
-0.0258964114,
-1.0724467039,
0.1966509074,
0.5367406011,
0.159253031,
0.3511815369,
0.3400253057,
-0.1641025394,
0.9582938552,
0.7954471707,
-0.0278962534,
0.3505917788,
0.1847103089,
-0.0815302357,
-0.7739357352,
-0.2515754104,
-0.7012465,
-0.124487333,
-0.9774572253,
-0.2565107644,
-0.0570523739,
-0.0007629599,
-0.3798269331,
0.0605050996,
-0.3306327462,
0.333478421,
0.4946137071,
-0.3381807804,
0.3722863495,
0.0351218171,
-0.1331875175,
-0.4847796559,
-0.6174087524,
-0.5775921941,
1.3535957336,
0.1962939054,
0.6977105141,
-0.2544932663,
0.3468484879,
0.6665370464,
0.4923370481,
-0.3394622803,
0.3636504114,
-0.4052729905,
-1.0602287054,
-0.0038117662,
-0.6903511882,
-0.8265507817,
0.4652690887,
-0.3378755152,
-0.7656006217,
0.3684731722,
0.2737333179,
0.30032143,
0.2257675678,
-0.4771824181,
0.8781279922,
-0.3440417647,
-0.3039720953,
0.2112635076,
-0.3427731991,
0.6562052369,
0.0034008918,
0.5409359932,
-0.3363254964,
0.2433125228,
0.9880115986,
-0.3673825562,
0.7149599195,
-0.2222490609,
-0.0845934898,
-0.1321140081,
0.2172350734,
0.014226404,
0.0875682682,
-0.1520216018,
0.5978010893,
0.0326217897,
-0.2208064049,
-0.3283407986,
0.6238769889,
-0.7798501849,
-0.248312816,
-0.7139016986,
-0.5625003576,
-0.3159264326,
0.3429053724,
0.3593337536,
0.2565206587,
-0.5617179275,
-0.0605923794,
0.4446430206,
-0.2743707001,
0.2934007645,
0.505230546,
-0.2910109758,
-0.1319335252,
0.3779310584,
-0.2136519104,
0.1070284769,
0.2885185182,
0.1507019401,
-0.3906962276,
-0.1279963851,
-0.4662571549,
0.2632847726,
-0.2897261083,
0.0025121288,
-0.6470894217,
0.0099645145,
-0.4629707634,
0.0716239586,
-0.7985312939,
-0.4273121953,
-0.1075455099,
-0.0788624063,
0.1850319654,
0.776012361,
0.0427963734,
0.1893156767,
-0.3918860555,
0.3371885419,
0.1934086829,
0.1714709252,
-0.1674102992,
-0.4580442607,
0.3668488562,
0.2688039541,
0.0836363062,
-0.911042273,
0.5503875017,
0.0732340366,
0.4636893868,
0.1960211098,
0.0850465894,
0.2078856677,
-0.4836093485,
0.5594004393,
0.2299438417,
-1.204854846,
0.4117749631,
-0.5190889835,
0.046006579,
0.7622131109,
0.2341221422,
-0.5866319537,
-0.5892164707,
-0.5896435976,
-0.730056107,
0.8206305504,
0.5581114888,
0.3194032311,
-0.2086452246,
0.2515693605,
0.1237965673,
0.8389787674,
-0.9604542255,
-0.3071469665,
-0.3718992174,
-0.2539294064,
0.1265914142,
-0.3560610712,
-0.0119018555,
-0.0588904545,
0.4811554551,
-0.0766900256,
0.2705998123,
0.0696994066,
-0.3701735139,
0.0917923301,
0.6441993713,
0.3346190453,
0.5082170367,
-0.5023352504,
0.0222580768,
-0.0708526149,
-0.4847726226,
-0.00170292,
-0.0436029844,
-0.5016075373,
0.236451596,
0.3969302773,
0.6300132275,
0.3372451663,
-0.8403435946,
0.8628054857,
-0.2610425651,
-0.2545510828,
-0.2449089587,
-0.0996439457,
-0.2007602453,
0.2286977768,
0.2294182479,
0.139683485,
0.1557054222,
-0.6923786402,
-0.0083693489,
0.7023475766,
-1.0628722906,
-0.3395369351,
0.9315277934,
0.2014233768,
0.1660829633,
0.7950283885,
0.0804920197,
-0.4121289253,
0.5640411377,
0.3718323708,
0.9206340313,
-0.1832342148,
0.5223369002,
0.2137024403,
0.6882933378,
-0.2572876215,
0.222437188,
0.2618492842,
-0.8067073822,
0.1254611313,
-0.6430446506,
-0.0114934593,
0.0903128311,
-0.7345981598,
0.1858637482,
-0.3999684453,
-0.1350233704,
-0.225948751,
-0.3792966306,
-0.6093741059,
0.152610153,
0.127230227,
0.7660011649,
-1.0897969007,
0.5272467732,
0.6730268598,
-0.3096947372,
-0.361489445,
-0.0510284081,
0.2374959439,
-0.646459043,
0.6810451746,
0.2512182891,
-0.1434824318,
-0.5751854181,
-0.4302152991,
-0.3611198366,
0.6312923431,
0.7235155702,
-0.3862754703,
-0.2494175881,
0.189300552,
0.6153107882,
-0.5963820219,
0.6355298758,
0.3689624965,
0.3749395907,
-0.1316466033,
-0.9475085139,
-0.0473817959,
-0.3524034023,
0.1971382499,
-0.0480782613,
-0.2784611285,
1.002853632,
-0.0926773846,
0.03674604,
0.0190560594,
0.5562571287,
0.1574929506,
0.2451056838,
0.412299484,
0.3395021558,
0.9812870026,
0.075795114,
1.0179576874,
-0.0346888788,
0.3059630394,
1.155241251,
-0.3946638107,
0.569544673,
0.4699691534,
0.2001699358,
0.502066195,
0.2784900665,
0.1689539701,
0.4560071528,
0.2884705961,
-0.1088240519,
-0.2313470542,
-0.4939205348,
-0.3754175305,
0.78038764,
-0.1727388948,
-0.6970792413,
-0.256398797,
-0.0573269986,
0.4901887476,
0.1489411145,
-0.2929316461,
0.3271276653,
0.0662166551,
-0.4405863881,
0.2712111771,
0.0866009891,
0.9878601432,
-0.594497025,
0.0455258489,
-0.4662326276,
0.1674330086,
-0.1633053124,
-0.3822133839,
0.0671024844,
0.4863782823,
-0.5032063127,
-0.2683481872,
0.5703774095,
-0.6574074626,
-0.691473186,
0.4125375152,
0.8494020104,
0.126019761,
-0.1014943346,
-0.4277491271,
-0.3569315672,
0.1465209872,
-0.0273262784,
0.4380431473,
0.1737994552,
-0.413120985,
0.5480796099,
0.6121039391,
0.1503551155,
0.0357776955,
0.444878906,
0.5344038606,
-0.5774016976,
-0.2510478199,
-0.8354141116,
0.2155047059,
-0.1487593204,
-0.3986143172,
0.8198688626,
0.6357346177,
0.8390298486,
0.0278600529,
0.8611882925,
0.1301457435,
0.3130882084,
-0.4334253073,
1.1335690022,
-0.6290593147,
0.1887633502,
-0.6940048933,
-0.9904285073,
-0.1645083278,
0.6285702586,
-0.3292279243,
0.3973509669,
0.7718129754,
0.6073259115,
0.029243784,
0.345492065,
0.1628053188,
0.1789665222,
-0.1010840312,
0.3785172105,
0.90103966,
-0.2902192771,
0.4047006071,
-0.0045621288,
-0.2924034894,
0.2682841122,
-0.9181429744,
-1.3220505714,
-0.283714503,
-0.2062481195,
-0.2014597058,
0.4701479077,
0.7814360857,
0.409634918,
-0.5517392159,
-0.5547853112,
-0.1078977063,
0.300878793,
0.0949626416,
-0.1849567443,
0.188350141,
-0.1959528774,
-0.8118379116,
0.165628016,
-0.0368721187,
-0.1726151258,
0.0036246781,
0.0127473967,
-0.0709611923,
0.0389715657,
0.2408753186,
0.0374275856,
-0.2913243473,
-0.168956697,
0.1689214706,
0.0161495283,
-0.0163087361,
1.0602637529,
-0.7196414471,
0.4548077285,
0.4029809535,
-0.0079455357,
0.2012376636,
-0.0941888988,
0.8162365556,
-0.8174539208,
0.2442639619,
0.0804789141,
0.3287792206,
0.5437766314,
-0.0955683663,
0.3539655805,
0.3355492949,
-0.1299333274,
-0.9116894603,
0.0495313033,
-0.4289765954,
-0.3896858394,
1.1780709028,
0.2007240951,
-0.3397426307,
-0.0142213767,
0.1438198239,
0.2707204819,
-0.6650454402,
0.9033871293,
0.7499827743,
-0.0421749242,
-0.0877011195,
-1.0081660748,
0.7562181354,
0.5343304873,
-0.6511380672,
0.3575653434,
0.72913903,
0.4375231862,
-0.2504401505,
0.7540809512,
-0.2614009976,
0.0509224162,
-0.1872780919,
0.3607996702,
0.0570663325,
-0.3106961846,
-0.301636368,
-0.0468885005,
-0.1177607477,
-0.0559879169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00578v1
|
The Real, the Better: Aligning Large Language Models with Online Human Behaviors
| 2024-05-01T15:30:41 | 2024-05-01T15:30:41 |
Guanying Jiang, Lingyong Yan, Haibo Shi, Dawei Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language model alignment is widely used and studied to avoid LLM
producing unhelpful and harmful responses. However, the lengthy training
process and predefined preference bias hinder adaptation to online diverse
human preferences. To this end, this paper proposes an alignment framework,
called Reinforcement Learning with Human Behavior (RLHB), to align LLMs by
directly leveraging real online human behaviors. By taking the generative
adversarial framework, the generator is trained to respond following expected
human behavior; while the discriminator tries to verify whether the triplets of
query, response, and human behavior come from real online environments.
Behavior modeling in natural-language form and the multi-model joint training
mechanism enable an active and sustainable online alignment. Experimental
results confirm the effectiveness of our proposed methods by both human and
automatic evaluations.
|
[
-0.3233690858,
-0.9299092889,
0.4143610299,
0.1159319133,
0.099339962,
0.4662338793,
-0.320519954,
-0.5606612563,
0.3081981242,
0.3329137564,
-0.7788538933,
0.0303215142,
-0.0924424231,
-0.098914735,
0.0040270649,
0.9620814919,
0.0854666308,
0.173879087,
-0.3067936599,
-0.116656214,
-0.435941726,
-0.5191973448,
-0.7412855029,
-0.5709662437,
0.5490643382,
0.0160637926,
0.9288780689,
0.7509453893,
0.3968498111,
0.3922469616,
0.2006529272,
0.4099021554,
-0.6074015498,
0.0990958214,
-0.2513049543,
-0.2794234753,
-0.59737432,
-0.0042317957,
0.4753428698,
0.2415174395,
-0.745029211,
-0.0554561913,
-0.0909355357,
0.611528039,
-0.4128719866,
-0.1525777727,
-0.3320021629,
0.2082071602,
0.1749788225,
0.0003157746,
-0.3339129686,
-0.7538837194,
0.0060504726,
-0.9635049105,
-0.0165588725,
0.3748197854,
1.0753952265,
0.3392915726,
-0.5047127604,
-0.0373546369,
-0.6835606098,
0.6502329707,
-0.7606615424,
0.5472401381,
0.2143993229,
0.4568798542,
-0.4651942253,
-0.2407541126,
-0.8971832395,
-0.2341489196,
-0.0951476097,
0.1118389443,
0.1250929683,
0.1606733948,
0.1133146659,
-0.0135965757,
-0.8004614115,
0.4381326735,
-0.0625253469,
-0.2716314495,
0.7774167061,
0.2454859912,
0.4177283943,
0.1647026837,
-0.4923631847,
-0.356331557,
-0.6775659919,
0.1308429092,
0.8137370944,
0.4195124209,
-0.2283786684,
0.4808051884,
0.1090285182,
0.8663445115,
0.5505819917,
-0.3315820694,
0.1091165096,
-0.1223930493,
-0.1310150623,
0.3353969157,
0.8027394414,
0.3835256994,
0.355894357,
-0.2292688787,
-0.1486779898,
0.0896474645,
0.8189920187,
-0.5076957345,
0.0032144117,
0.0793748572,
-0.340524286,
-0.3737312257,
0.1662781686,
-0.7903513908,
-0.6461489797,
-0.6664975882,
0.3863770962,
-0.2271836996,
-0.5121285319,
0.0182031393,
0.2751443386,
0.4042577147,
0.231607452,
-1.1319864988,
0.3972584009,
0.9676002264,
0.6162917018,
-0.4089201391,
-0.3455419838,
-0.7875593305,
0.249223724,
-0.3835292459,
0.5194234848,
-0.2879494429,
0.0019670844,
0.1514309049,
-0.0719016343,
-0.1157377958,
-0.5609604716,
0.3854552209,
-0.8312709332,
0.4611529112,
-0.0555171669,
-0.7347626686,
-0.0757703483,
0.559630096,
-0.7449482679,
0.9935632348,
-0.0593596175,
-0.5526525974,
0.2198110223,
-0.7052199244,
-0.3416037858,
-0.1658081859,
-0.1567628235,
-0.8379622102,
-0.1619498283,
0.2211554199,
0.3000993133,
0.1830185205,
0.6203775406,
-0.5507612824,
-0.4034533203,
0.6662992835,
-0.195841983,
0.707252562,
0.2493889183,
-0.2449605167,
0.5877146125,
-0.5126280189,
0.0460940264,
0.2240081578,
-0.7665401101,
-0.0801350549,
0.2229503542,
-0.11835327,
0.4692330956,
0.2316096872,
-0.5132983923,
0.4532451034,
-0.5652377009,
0.2289035767,
1.0228353739,
-0.2387224436,
0.563896656,
-0.4721682072,
0.7465055585,
-0.3221575022,
0.0705771595,
0.5437713265,
-0.077428177,
-0.6727274656,
-0.2791188955,
0.0682384446,
0.5550031066,
-0.3908887208,
0.7573344707,
-0.5321152806,
-0.1376719922,
-0.7303789854,
0.070526816,
0.6757304668,
0.3127219379,
0.2269885689,
-0.0009848666,
-0.7426797152,
-0.7271798849,
-0.4228966534,
-0.2259477675,
-0.0024687746,
0.0911627188,
0.1110362932,
-0.1824445277,
1.1388998032,
-0.4654284716,
-0.1393832266,
-0.3531936109,
0.2229128331,
-0.2007593215,
0.2805110812,
0.2435962409,
-0.7964922786,
-0.3684783876,
-0.030735299,
-0.6992891431,
0.0779459104,
-0.1752220988,
-0.3207898438,
0.296970576,
0.4258502126,
-0.5069074631,
-0.0478401072,
0.7556667328,
-0.2284563482,
0.2570155263,
-0.3459064662,
0.083433263,
-1.1453795433,
-0.0909870788,
0.2088415176,
-0.6687528491,
-0.5833268762,
0.0668896437,
0.1294852346,
-0.0513923727,
-0.5196982622,
0.6809235811,
-0.3259699643,
-0.4174166322,
-0.2586083114,
0.2063444257,
-0.0335622132,
0.6330416799,
0.2588802874,
0.8120234609,
-0.016955778,
-0.7701811194,
0.7293356657,
0.3822346926,
-0.4386124909,
0.7502611279,
-0.2657727301,
0.1171448454,
-0.2696372867,
0.4815036952,
-0.745257318,
-0.4090152383,
0.3109439015,
-0.3533811867,
0.348110497,
0.1130272374,
-0.2822297513,
-0.2365034372,
-0.3602063954,
0.0974506065,
0.3700940609,
-0.7177075148,
0.7106326222,
0.3940616548,
0.0531273298,
-0.4693569243,
-0.4874172211,
-0.0312430002,
-0.4681161344,
-0.5519123673,
0.5255405307,
-0.195992738,
-0.3154546022,
-0.1698718518,
0.1757237464,
0.0512859821,
0.2464294881,
0.0480332896,
0.5573711991,
-0.1262338609,
0.0678244457,
-0.5568015575,
0.0491032638,
-0.1145102754,
-0.0581528246,
0.5180889964,
0.0194736645,
-0.494348377,
-0.6103819013,
0.0543878488,
0.2756523788,
-0.0778998807,
0.7532963753,
0.6966760755,
-0.2065628022,
-0.0369321257,
-0.398475498,
-0.2473437041,
-0.4950232804,
0.4959250391,
0.0254637878,
-0.8716464043,
0.1244051829,
0.1787120998,
0.0300260484,
-0.1271788329,
0.5274233222,
-0.3255574405,
1.449723959,
0.688459754,
-0.0934288651,
0.6327339411,
0.3485806584,
0.5321401358,
-0.8177446723,
-0.2706152797,
-0.1974138916,
-0.4615839124,
-0.6568106413,
-0.1205334142,
0.1779979765,
0.0973040164,
-0.6989964247,
0.3763216436,
-0.3749614954,
0.318571955,
0.3471541107,
0.3158176839,
0.0401921794,
-0.0088689299,
-0.0787062868,
-0.2882535756,
-0.4457686245,
-0.470133096,
0.7384648323,
0.3743643463,
0.8557025194,
0.6265997291,
0.4613655508,
0.2941301763,
0.4765945375,
-0.803624928,
0.4491398036,
0.21963422,
-0.6638812423,
-0.3875114024,
-0.4138822556,
-0.9311952591,
0.4151763022,
-0.5114591718,
-0.726637423,
-0.3251610696,
0.4732497931,
-0.5669999719,
0.2429994345,
-0.3652166724,
0.9115569592,
-0.9743717909,
-0.4507823586,
-0.2561156452,
-0.6732849479,
0.5288662314,
0.0374396816,
0.4382953048,
-0.1803950518,
0.0429522768,
0.711420238,
-0.2530570328,
0.9660403132,
-0.1431838423,
-0.2424387038,
-0.1791992188,
0.1376562417,
0.9731417298,
-0.436429888,
0.0888209641,
-0.3614059389,
-0.3603705466,
-0.2276830375,
-0.570314765,
0.7522912621,
-0.9708285928,
-0.5124368072,
-0.5572084785,
-0.3038820028,
-0.5516222715,
-0.0870667398,
-0.1513711512,
0.0110081621,
-0.5424868464,
-0.1445589066,
0.805395782,
-0.2782257497,
0.3420497775,
0.6756916046,
-0.5327888727,
-0.4770278931,
1.204449296,
-0.4282439649,
0.3146150112,
0.6140747666,
0.3831565082,
-0.6444679499,
-0.0995956436,
-0.5259905457,
0.2915984094,
-0.5174787641,
-0.062326584,
-0.4891993999,
0.0504239574,
-0.6132010221,
-0.3907323778,
-0.1862816215,
0.0003315395,
-0.3224751353,
-0.3108106852,
0.2360295206,
0.6640417576,
0.0697159395,
0.4295959473,
-0.7731188536,
0.4770764112,
0.6629565954,
0.2757907808,
0.0360478275,
-0.4845276773,
-0.1317751706,
0.1897133738,
-0.4665876627,
-0.6034713984,
0.4435170293,
0.2783976495,
0.7615999579,
0.5939229727,
0.0185851026,
0.9563397765,
-0.330486685,
0.5766361356,
0.3778206408,
-0.6834709048,
0.2250528634,
-0.3436501324,
-0.0221673436,
0.3892928362,
0.5054037571,
-0.7708500624,
-0.014627059,
-0.4173411131,
-0.5876371861,
0.8035638928,
-0.0967705026,
-0.0094257323,
0.0715631172,
0.1003287807,
-0.1436816603,
0.1999397427,
-1.0242437124,
0.0383833498,
-0.2618004382,
-0.5178350806,
0.1399570256,
0.1774006784,
-0.2247722,
-0.0857322887,
0.9219283462,
-0.3285789192,
0.1120402217,
-0.4588946998,
-0.3149906397,
-0.3558904529,
0.195034489,
0.683899343,
0.609053731,
-0.1943016201,
-0.0877572447,
0.0286128148,
-0.043388322,
0.4192816317,
-0.1596741676,
0.0072759422,
-0.675501287,
0.2653738856,
0.8604280353,
0.5542550087,
-0.9001438618,
0.6615427732,
-0.2327112556,
-0.0086022625,
-0.3386976123,
0.2232934535,
0.3948611617,
0.1766440272,
-0.1005622521,
-0.2658228874,
-0.4145841002,
-0.5764964819,
0.1302277446,
0.6418772936,
-0.4714453518,
-0.2240536064,
0.6886683106,
0.3963683546,
-0.5249006152,
0.6986685991,
-0.2341022193,
-0.6564460993,
0.498565197,
0.7794958353,
0.6210882068,
-0.2201090753,
0.2994471192,
0.4760827422,
-0.1421257108,
-0.4121526182,
0.0037285658,
0.1190932989,
-1.0252578259,
-0.4577541351,
-0.8775359988,
-0.3123139441,
0.0756013244,
-0.6186848879,
0.2986235917,
-0.472199887,
0.0263999589,
-0.142498523,
-0.142976284,
-0.3045390844,
0.1581326276,
0.3105776012,
0.2103132308,
-0.8406528831,
0.8858304024,
0.7502844334,
-0.4324124157,
-0.8257191777,
0.1187124401,
0.3688150942,
-1.0575532913,
0.6773750782,
0.1816411167,
-0.2935240269,
0.1800412238,
-0.459040761,
-0.9291649461,
0.9938918352,
0.3922831118,
-0.6707618237,
-0.0684488341,
-0.1031855792,
0.4952906668,
-0.35781461,
0.0345141143,
0.3532942533,
0.599432528,
-0.029471606,
-0.742765069,
0.1054103971,
0.195154056,
0.0754783228,
0.5110878944,
-0.6035106182,
0.5131730437,
-0.0679370537,
-0.4214972854,
0.0119685298,
0.7090005875,
0.385926187,
-0.2137434036,
0.5937239528,
0.7902613282,
0.8014355302,
0.1127273664,
0.8045329452,
-0.0039938516,
0.2848659754,
1.1924960613,
-0.5894348621,
0.871135354,
0.3920349777,
-0.469365418,
0.5400141478,
0.7976103425,
0.1324638724,
0.5317856669,
0.4301398396,
-0.3928260207,
-0.6241859198,
-0.105784595,
-0.0852735564,
0.318613559,
0.1680225879,
0.17737028,
-0.0666385964,
-0.0474822372,
0.0814712122,
0.5378814936,
-0.165611282,
1.2182087898,
-0.2384585142,
-1.1537339687,
0.4398710728,
0.1872815639,
1.090839386,
-0.6110650301,
0.0251270942,
-0.069634676,
0.3128279448,
-0.304215461,
-0.6320019364,
0.1355015188,
-0.0975110456,
-0.0832123086,
-0.3393321335,
0.4187087715,
-0.5664809346,
-0.2934220135,
0.3620445132,
0.1476992667,
-0.0866477713,
0.1970940381,
-0.8688294291,
-0.1421652734,
-0.034643583,
-0.1285568625,
0.8848154545,
-0.0976677164,
-0.2298362851,
0.7373268008,
0.847882092,
0.1297234148,
0.0982199311,
0.0454411581,
0.4414799213,
-0.7100334167,
-0.6191383004,
-0.778285861,
0.3206112385,
-0.2299340367,
-0.0573337153,
0.4774121642,
0.4070813954,
0.9021805525,
0.1371017843,
0.7866805196,
0.0030615125,
0.4854092598,
-0.6389155388,
0.432144165,
-0.3977682292,
0.027290877,
0.2269684076,
-0.9287261963,
-0.0780385286,
0.8537259698,
-0.0128238034,
-0.029306883,
0.3625318706,
1.0147386789,
-0.2287104428,
-0.3400433362,
0.3278661966,
-0.1548605561,
0.5291134119,
0.2546674311,
0.8697571754,
0.0455797203,
0.5029972196,
-0.0519089028,
-0.017656561,
-0.5147968531,
-1.1960792542,
-0.6582984328,
-0.1721867174,
-0.2250221819,
-0.4097536504,
0.1359951347,
1.556982398,
0.6673207283,
-0.7279942036,
-0.295016408,
-0.1398084909,
0.0415756442,
-0.4074184299,
-0.2758995891,
0.1450902373,
-0.2804583907,
-0.5151406527,
0.551946044,
0.0611435547,
0.1481638998,
-0.5647354126,
-0.7787261605,
-0.5789884329,
0.0062826201,
0.2682226896,
0.5610675812,
-0.9767810106,
-0.4577400088,
-0.1588804126,
-0.4405907094,
0.1834859997,
0.7850512862,
-0.6647971272,
0.4403983653,
0.4216535389,
0.7887982726,
0.2391668707,
0.5413393378,
0.8962869048,
-0.7993694544,
-0.1098985299,
0.1834396124,
0.2389230132,
0.633399725,
-0.361058861,
0.1462104917,
-0.0405453555,
-0.6507074833,
-0.4810074568,
0.4144336879,
-0.7438934445,
-0.3080215454,
1.1155264378,
-0.1295171231,
-0.2220440805,
-0.1781082004,
-0.087340571,
0.5162883401,
-0.501203537,
0.999950707,
0.6148146391,
-0.4203536808,
-0.0098064039,
-0.4391361177,
0.6012088656,
0.316042304,
-1.0760182142,
0.1670122296,
0.6319979429,
0.2106004953,
-0.0722707435,
0.4324841499,
0.271712184,
0.0468807109,
-0.6219177246,
0.3509643376,
-0.0255936962,
-0.0439832471,
-0.5130628943,
-0.1245541573,
0.2936892509,
-0.0261181965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00566v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00566v1
|
NumLLM: Numeric-Sensitive Large Language Model for Chinese Finance
| 2024-05-01T15:17:27 | 2024-05-01T15:17:27 |
Huan-Yi Su, Ke Wu, Yu-Hao Huang, Wu-Jun Li
|
cs.CE
|
cs.CE, cs.CL, q-fin.GN
|
Recently, many works have proposed various financial large language models
(FinLLMs) by pre-training from scratch or fine-tuning open-sourced LLMs on
financial corpora. However, existing FinLLMs exhibit unsatisfactory performance
in understanding financial text when numeric variables are involved in
questions. In this paper, we propose a novel LLM, called numeric-sensitive
large language model (NumLLM), for Chinese finance. We first construct a
financial corpus from financial textbooks which is essential for improving
numeric capability of LLMs during fine-tuning. After that, we train two
individual low-rank adaptation (LoRA) modules by fine-tuning on our constructed
financial corpus. One module is for adapting general-purpose LLMs to financial
domain, and the other module is for enhancing the ability of NumLLM to
understand financial text with numeric variables. Lastly, we merge the two LoRA
modules into the foundation model to obtain NumLLM for inference. Experiments
on financial question-answering benchmark show that NumLLM can boost the
performance of the foundation model and can achieve the best overall
performance compared to all baselines, on both numeric and non-numeric
questions.
|
[
-0.0708096251,
-1.029224515,
0.0491648726,
0.3952726126,
-0.4758216143,
0.1761088818,
-0.3599871695,
-0.3806317151,
-0.2568074167,
0.8676674366,
-0.0503535233,
-0.7350324392,
-0.3303992152,
-0.0475155152,
-0.2993356287,
1.1945683956,
0.2928983867,
0.1215224564,
-0.0078060874,
-0.0707400963,
-0.3475921154,
-0.5956389308,
-0.7481100559,
-0.2372666299,
0.3104434311,
0.2306383103,
0.7130531669,
0.346871376,
0.670519948,
0.2971140146,
-0.2002054155,
-0.049376063,
-0.5321118832,
-0.1576374322,
0.1151993424,
-0.4865077436,
-0.8964412808,
-0.2433762848,
0.7823591828,
0.7164021134,
-0.0554919802,
0.3334900439,
0.1373410374,
0.6759520173,
-0.6265155673,
0.3946786821,
-0.6310353279,
-0.0904628634,
0.0993745178,
-0.2196200341,
-0.7004973292,
-0.4605675936,
0.1402886659,
-0.6837957501,
-0.0181616358,
-0.0572073646,
0.3997011185,
0.3783536851,
-0.634411633,
0.0165837817,
-0.4204277098,
0.7248768806,
-1.057117939,
-0.0165748894,
0.4384649992,
0.2723602355,
0.0845148638,
-0.5332300663,
0.0128366649,
-0.3828336895,
-0.0881699994,
-0.1245579049,
0.0171764772,
-0.152839452,
0.2994989157,
0.2209960967,
-0.5649906397,
0.3174170256,
-0.2506027818,
-0.0304939821,
0.7902820706,
0.2053512037,
0.0109663112,
0.0533259884,
-0.7583509684,
-0.1472166777,
-0.8287332654,
-0.0099946726,
-0.0331090502,
0.6322184801,
-0.4169430733,
0.2703707218,
-0.0454579629,
0.8543564081,
-0.0561664775,
-0.2966699898,
0.1581460238,
-0.0416431911,
-0.5996897817,
0.3687537014,
0.2924688458,
0.196788311,
0.4258960783,
0.125075683,
-0.4459925592,
-0.3238776028,
-0.0768401623,
-0.8216286302,
-0.2139437795,
0.2368831336,
-0.4373568594,
-0.5562184453,
0.0870885104,
-0.6007688046,
-0.5437471271,
-0.2532213628,
0.5114268661,
-0.3021049201,
-0.2836027145,
0.2360129952,
0.0197162014,
0.6686745286,
0.4010351896,
-0.9706639051,
0.2535691261,
1.049374938,
0.7246174812,
0.0239250995,
-0.0695044771,
-0.9360784292,
0.3228954375,
-0.2774218321,
0.7503678799,
-0.3604846001,
-0.4014393091,
-0.141577974,
-0.3051431477,
-0.0610527247,
-0.5166199803,
0.0603261963,
-0.7006491423,
-0.0171961915,
-0.0045053978,
-0.4818453193,
-0.1088523567,
0.318764776,
-0.7684490681,
0.7845333219,
0.2482741475,
-0.7634983063,
0.2896484137,
-0.9880298376,
-0.4032872617,
0.4315333068,
-0.0386215895,
-0.4849809408,
-0.1722155362,
-0.0465132333,
0.3802321255,
-0.5300542116,
0.591457665,
-0.471414417,
-0.6288046241,
0.8204883933,
-0.6046230197,
0.7470118403,
0.0582170226,
-0.2864545584,
0.2731567919,
-0.9406614304,
0.0066236188,
0.0392962769,
-0.2487218082,
-0.6758310795,
-0.3493906856,
0.2834599912,
-0.1429786384,
0.6247479916,
-0.0631042495,
0.1343388557,
-0.6074293852,
0.4646975696,
0.9841282368,
-0.1124814376,
0.487157315,
-0.3133535385,
0.3517925441,
-0.0953915715,
0.1151229739,
-0.0198279023,
-0.226375252,
-0.5053706169,
-0.1529714167,
0.4888048172,
0.3875344992,
-0.531897366,
0.2220030874,
-0.0134756491,
-0.3565012515,
-0.2213027924,
0.2808354497,
0.2721666098,
0.3495548666,
0.1456130445,
0.0598947369,
-0.2871358395,
-0.6950372458,
-0.1897396743,
-0.3187640607,
-0.0912069455,
0.2089044154,
0.4468696713,
0.3331702352,
0.7322454453,
-0.7819005847,
-0.1306854784,
-0.2425686866,
0.2272487581,
0.6536425948,
0.3703038394,
0.8626841903,
-1.2119832039,
-0.6019932032,
0.2197381556,
-0.4419851005,
-0.1902050227,
-0.2107630819,
-0.0322391689,
0.321098268,
0.5747120976,
-0.3421816826,
0.4318235219,
0.5305296183,
-0.7742345929,
0.2165820748,
-0.4556621611,
-0.3946668804,
-0.9380817413,
0.3568358123,
-0.0314758532,
-0.0721649826,
-0.7435792685,
0.0927111283,
0.3541043699,
0.1555843353,
-0.5003717542,
0.872181356,
-0.3748397231,
-0.3072525263,
-0.4857313335,
0.3135405481,
0.0855426267,
0.4824388921,
-0.0890720189,
0.7119749188,
0.3189720213,
-0.6094810963,
0.2291402668,
0.2013750076,
-0.4774702787,
0.4322038591,
-0.6937068105,
-0.10823448,
0.0596817769,
0.047869347,
-1.0426419973,
0.1016846597,
0.1285376549,
-0.1303554773,
0.2600975633,
-0.0081350701,
-0.10904181,
-0.0577491708,
-0.1815882623,
0.5562838912,
0.3933381736,
-0.3267251551,
0.5960590243,
0.1184811667,
-0.4748321176,
-0.6161573529,
-0.4895265102,
0.0050587449,
-0.4191871583,
-0.5778149962,
0.0988472253,
-0.2895960808,
-0.5991176963,
-0.1584182978,
0.0698926598,
-0.1496016085,
0.7745088339,
0.1494139135,
0.8844782114,
-0.7744138241,
0.3278875351,
-0.3561227024,
-0.379814744,
0.0076365918,
-0.2117107362,
0.4517954886,
-0.2711759806,
-0.1374079436,
0.2400821447,
-0.0402822644,
0.49961254,
-0.3795058727,
0.8544900417,
0.4463048577,
-0.2089288235,
-0.3779992759,
-0.3114688098,
0.0160916448,
-0.4843930304,
0.4204897881,
-0.2908725441,
-1.0481671095,
0.3450876772,
0.0303102415,
0.075441815,
0.7301580906,
0.902316153,
0.3684857488,
0.5067328811,
0.7474304438,
-0.363047272,
0.2277218103,
-0.1604475379,
0.1310185939,
-0.3782826364,
-0.0432925299,
-0.6200663447,
-0.2936329544,
-0.279772222,
-0.3619533777,
0.1967562437,
-0.0172468871,
-0.632537961,
0.1805426925,
-0.0188546348,
0.5785474181,
0.2422196269,
-0.2555777431,
0.6289741397,
-0.1919088662,
0.0024934879,
0.1845040917,
-0.5036305189,
-0.4025113285,
1.0538024902,
0.3943985999,
0.9082334042,
0.2046534866,
0.0750543475,
0.3140540421,
0.6801256537,
-0.4488380551,
0.2797983587,
-0.6071639061,
-0.4451884925,
-0.6430852413,
-0.676287055,
-0.5141006112,
0.2383627892,
-0.1378032416,
-0.4531893134,
0.0278987847,
-0.1905899942,
-0.8744782209,
0.1834886968,
-0.297003895,
0.8459143639,
-0.6781042814,
-0.2597074211,
0.157139346,
-0.5403419733,
0.6092525125,
-0.7358906865,
0.3661086559,
-0.3958286643,
-0.1907426119,
0.5013513565,
-0.2303416878,
1.1040375233,
-0.0828613117,
-0.6791902184,
-0.0219142735,
-0.1235828698,
0.4476216137,
0.2680930495,
-0.4144890904,
0.2270096987,
-0.0244938191,
-0.3595769107,
-0.546541512,
0.6527702212,
-0.7950382233,
-0.5241296887,
-0.3388041556,
-0.8821473718,
-0.1524233818,
0.209207207,
-0.0991401076,
0.2086272091,
-0.4245978296,
0.5683943033,
0.3965219259,
-0.3965745866,
0.4255177677,
0.9417876601,
-0.4833277762,
-0.4213096201,
0.6709286571,
-0.0762295946,
0.4272793829,
0.7377622128,
0.3156591058,
-0.3243508637,
-0.3392358124,
-0.1724695116,
0.2213306427,
-0.5926996469,
-0.2757507563,
-0.3985073864,
-0.5051000714,
-0.5773171186,
-0.2332288325,
-0.0983608663,
-0.3150670528,
-0.5399298668,
-0.1138766184,
0.7994046807,
0.6322427392,
-0.1555327773,
0.1374127716,
-0.8726065159,
0.6459702849,
0.3242862225,
0.5018452406,
0.1701516658,
-1.0298309326,
-0.4637568593,
0.0890626013,
0.2061889917,
-0.2728341222,
0.5984151363,
0.2016464174,
0.3524540365,
0.779088974,
0.4059806764,
0.5675379634,
0.1525688469,
0.274361372,
-0.031950891,
-0.8035240769,
0.0942016169,
-0.204287976,
0.4346707463,
0.4885239303,
0.0868834332,
-0.6464296579,
-0.2510254085,
-0.1803181916,
-0.9424594641,
0.616466701,
0.0244286899,
0.2015482932,
0.1911037266,
0.4698590636,
0.2673301697,
0.306622833,
-0.784439981,
-0.1672821045,
0.0063065118,
-0.0186027866,
-0.3468385935,
-0.3931631148,
0.0436096415,
-0.1339762211,
0.6475178599,
-0.4255303442,
-0.3446675241,
-0.2167049646,
0.0193763189,
-0.1182402968,
0.1642939001,
0.6314772367,
0.6649688482,
-0.4452142119,
0.0611561537,
0.4355533421,
-0.4215195179,
0.0261977632,
-0.0361234583,
-0.20931831,
-0.139401108,
0.3416222632,
0.781124711,
0.8815751672,
-0.7738673091,
0.5437178612,
-0.1383748353,
-0.4245191216,
-0.5571217537,
0.1585132927,
0.233044669,
0.3458150029,
0.5477164388,
-0.2569139004,
-0.180102855,
-0.3399187624,
0.2783443928,
0.3565295041,
-0.3190242052,
0.0218392201,
0.8071338534,
0.2496211082,
-0.1122758389,
0.550699234,
0.2972602844,
-0.3937543035,
1.0182111263,
0.7444939017,
0.974401772,
-0.1561576277,
0.380362004,
0.10374704,
0.1454594284,
-0.1216982007,
0.3762644827,
0.1006498411,
-0.6425599456,
-0.5922294259,
-0.8493047953,
-0.5748659372,
0.1296992302,
-0.706936121,
0.5699604154,
-0.8321880698,
-0.0121199805,
0.0836379677,
-0.0640457496,
-0.2645455599,
0.1347340643,
0.3871362507,
1.2172504663,
-0.6436080933,
0.8223616481,
0.4492241442,
-0.1463638544,
-0.5390647054,
-0.3938747644,
-0.2624377608,
-0.9283713698,
0.7587348819,
0.0357191153,
0.2058485299,
0.0562543534,
-0.5271226168,
-0.9347471595,
1.2524757385,
0.4654788077,
-0.607714951,
-0.0366857685,
0.5758690238,
0.4275510311,
-0.5059790611,
-0.0526889078,
0.4996242821,
0.7615983486,
0.297173202,
-0.5625516176,
-0.1503272206,
-0.3978126049,
-0.1465603411,
0.3946445882,
-0.979634285,
1.2543996572,
-0.2615501285,
0.1657830179,
0.4172486663,
0.5665335655,
0.4312714934,
0.6927021742,
0.437946111,
0.1464317292,
0.8410800695,
0.0237332378,
0.8184320331,
-0.6222246885,
0.467646569,
1.1707093716,
-0.5913832784,
1.0525115728,
0.1350262314,
-0.124715656,
0.2292845547,
0.3838528693,
-0.4110073447,
0.1944248229,
0.4013267457,
-0.3218515217,
-0.5237611532,
0.0264405832,
-0.6259453297,
0.6170610785,
0.1293786764,
-0.3210785985,
0.0129878018,
-0.1468090415,
-0.2414373606,
-0.0319632888,
-0.4375050068,
0.7938156724,
0.5683276057,
-0.2383214235,
0.3939229548,
0.2576338053,
0.4300555289,
-0.7703879476,
0.0003610359,
-0.4827332795,
0.18348445,
0.0334522799,
-0.4056708515,
0.0568825044,
0.1745109111,
-0.0097750537,
-0.000918949,
0.9947066307,
-0.4262074828,
-0.8530625701,
0.3025844395,
0.3514973223,
0.0571137965,
-0.2999124825,
-0.4077314436,
-0.3571405709,
-0.0745352656,
-0.2432688624,
0.4912704825,
0.78093189,
-0.1707463264,
0.6423858404,
1.1388041973,
-0.1117885113,
-0.4377285838,
0.2828814089,
0.724260509,
-1.3478628397,
-0.7488885522,
-1.0638154745,
0.1967603564,
0.0805217475,
-0.3256064653,
0.5647760034,
0.5165886879,
0.3969635367,
-0.1439467818,
0.7094669938,
0.6778848767,
0.1132548377,
-0.6913656592,
1.0524600744,
-0.4016893804,
0.5873492956,
-0.3741809428,
-0.9778041244,
-0.6607416868,
0.4204408526,
-0.4342573285,
-0.0710297003,
0.276824832,
0.4225744307,
0.1681758612,
0.3003435135,
0.8320671916,
0.6041429043,
-0.1274950653,
0.7388350964,
0.7131819725,
-0.2426133007,
0.4888731837,
0.0298572257,
0.0294688717,
-0.7221230268,
-1.0343153477,
-0.8883537054,
-0.0152300047,
-0.2883105874,
0.0010954563,
-0.3243370652,
0.7860251665,
-0.0130023845,
-0.8147234321,
-0.5548692942,
0.4623908401,
0.2199813277,
0.1213379651,
-0.2111707926,
0.4713277221,
-0.0290380679,
-0.3722195029,
0.111065872,
0.7724245191,
0.3510753214,
-0.4790452719,
-0.2089537531,
0.1412472874,
0.0570287704,
0.6815261245,
0.1197742894,
-0.254925102,
-0.0717776492,
0.2627047002,
-0.2850734591,
0.0463103056,
0.8266949058,
-0.5153279901,
-0.091186747,
0.1536214203,
0.7382453084,
0.2544244528,
0.2213936746,
0.5812507272,
-0.2499065697,
0.2299980372,
0.0423195735,
0.2793900371,
0.0973735377,
-0.4754980803,
0.493052721,
-0.0969457328,
-0.3887243271,
-0.6380162239,
-0.3372775018,
-0.9891932607,
-0.618426621,
1.2519192696,
-0.0085609471,
-0.6364842057,
-0.2585985065,
-0.2902493179,
-0.0154851507,
-0.2595837414,
0.7602917552,
0.4804005325,
0.6222913265,
-0.0511857979,
-0.4831022322,
0.1847928613,
0.2968008518,
-0.6598927975,
0.382165879,
0.1924021989,
0.1607539505,
-0.1687310189,
0.6496816874,
0.0141634829,
0.5529722571,
-0.0216102228,
-0.1212955266,
-0.0918333381,
-0.0434610285,
-0.4196378887,
0.4801940322,
0.3665775061,
0.2901227474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00557v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00557v2
|
Mixture of insighTful Experts (MoTE): The Synergy of Thought Chains and Expert Mixtures in Self-Alignment
| 2024-05-01T15:06:05 | 2024-07-03T15:04:25 |
Zhili Liu, Yunhao Gou, Kai Chen, Lanqing Hong, Jiahui Gao, Fei Mi, Yu Zhang, Zhenguo Li, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, James T. Kwok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have expanded
dramatically, aligning these models with human values presents a significant
challenge. Traditional alignment strategies rely heavily on human intervention,
such as Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF), or on the self-alignment capacities of LLMs, which usually
require a strong LLM's emergent ability to improve its original bad answer. To
address these challenges, we propose a novel self-alignment method that
utilizes a Chain of Thought (CoT) approach, termed AlignCoT. This method
encompasses stages of Question Analysis, Answer Guidance, and Safe Answer
production. It is designed to enable LLMs to generate high-quality, safe
responses throughout various stages of their development. Furthermore, we
introduce the Mixture of insighTful Experts (MoTE) architecture, which applies
mixture of experts to enhance each component of the AlignCoT process, markedly
increasing alignment efficiency. The MoTE approach not only outperforms
existing methods in aligning LLMs with human values but also highlights the
benefits of using self-generated data, revealing the dual benefits of improved
alignment and training efficiency.
|
[
-0.4119221866,
-0.5910055041,
0.4354656935,
-0.1361141652,
-0.1346855313,
0.6853618026,
-0.2450268418,
-0.3728876114,
0.4052633941,
0.5433000922,
-0.6932861209,
-0.3034394681,
-0.3214361668,
-0.0240660012,
-0.2550337017,
0.8947196603,
-0.0664171576,
-0.0496724956,
-0.1824897975,
-0.2508925796,
-0.4334295392,
-0.2923784256,
-0.3256495595,
-0.089282386,
0.3013389707,
0.582767427,
0.7469857335,
0.8859819174,
0.5114648342,
0.3375589252,
0.2512808442,
0.6103336215,
-0.4537787437,
0.2559629679,
-0.7508431673,
-0.1508892924,
-0.5738124847,
0.0452311449,
0.0506565943,
0.4722765684,
-0.5051086545,
0.045258943,
0.2031330764,
0.4586733878,
-0.585024178,
-0.5151459575,
-0.8849996924,
-0.1347001344,
-0.0525665507,
-0.2177786529,
-0.1946535558,
-0.1985495389,
0.0813974813,
-0.4825554192,
0.1751646847,
0.2787439823,
0.5476580262,
0.4830727279,
-0.3773725629,
-0.2071803659,
-0.4199019074,
0.8046635389,
-0.9620385766,
0.153620705,
-0.040567819,
0.2247249484,
-0.456627667,
-0.1556231827,
-0.7719505429,
0.4305002689,
0.0698209107,
0.2781274021,
0.3301216662,
-0.1014767885,
-0.3564647138,
0.2084337771,
-0.5801429152,
0.3720700741,
-0.0691415593,
-0.2688482404,
0.8467668295,
0.2582545578,
0.363555938,
-0.035994716,
-0.7124181986,
-0.1053514183,
-0.4117621183,
-0.2836138308,
0.3167966902,
0.2302739471,
0.1724442393,
0.5436183214,
-0.0487111993,
0.6990809441,
0.4854892492,
-0.440512836,
0.0646446496,
-0.3677510619,
-0.0591311008,
0.3145121634,
1.1203768253,
0.3501905501,
0.1572432965,
-0.1926276982,
-0.3294772208,
-0.1375888586,
0.3203175366,
-0.4266387224,
-0.1867491901,
0.3482568264,
-0.0474045686,
-0.538885951,
0.0448380485,
-0.8055715561,
-0.530298233,
-0.462723285,
0.3087103665,
-0.4100361466,
-0.4316426516,
0.0902993307,
0.1630144417,
0.3445540071,
0.4179298282,
-1.1374577284,
0.3858941793,
0.7869552374,
0.426536262,
-0.5201631784,
-0.2705799043,
-0.3162667155,
0.4130773544,
-0.4250054955,
0.9025568366,
-0.3270600438,
-0.2183102518,
-0.3295390308,
-0.3917011917,
-0.0836740062,
-0.4708227813,
0.2094780654,
-0.4378875494,
0.4714979827,
-0.2352034003,
-0.6335140467,
0.212792933,
0.3924576342,
-0.1926996112,
1.1458284855,
0.1772283465,
-0.8618929386,
0.2152363658,
-0.2865629196,
-0.244756341,
0.1418884844,
-0.6839285493,
-0.0420964397,
0.0348711908,
0.486358285,
0.2595905066,
-0.2349151373,
0.4807994068,
-0.2145088315,
0.202450335,
0.406365484,
-0.2986414433,
0.6120301485,
0.3312208951,
-0.4367466271,
0.1845938712,
-0.5582144856,
0.3940715194,
-0.1346373409,
-0.0726205409,
-0.3010726869,
-0.1100635976,
-0.4586463273,
0.5821481943,
0.4581024051,
-0.5287658572,
0.2531958222,
-0.356493026,
0.3084062636,
1.0654945374,
-0.0254677031,
0.4145619273,
-0.1818055362,
0.6366069913,
0.3114834428,
-0.0988369584,
0.1142235994,
-0.2095977664,
-0.738635838,
-0.0046468936,
0.3649286032,
0.4319010079,
-0.6400720477,
0.8659155965,
-0.3183400035,
-0.4077085257,
-1.1001565456,
0.6086995006,
0.4384877086,
0.9045783281,
0.4223524928,
-0.37297979,
-0.4848331213,
-0.9335430264,
-0.2210635692,
-0.136299476,
0.276848793,
0.0324683636,
0.2540228367,
-0.0718743578,
1.2518935204,
-0.523440063,
0.0487400554,
-0.0228217486,
0.2007432133,
0.0189474113,
0.6801301241,
0.1358056217,
-0.3961588442,
-0.5842382908,
0.3622899055,
-0.5998035669,
-0.0976250097,
0.0400869437,
-0.4744210839,
0.1337403059,
0.3795188367,
-0.3286217749,
-0.1096042767,
0.5000930429,
-0.175317347,
0.3855289221,
-0.0950980484,
0.2047905624,
-1.4735308886,
-0.1638634503,
-0.0971998498,
-0.4178455472,
-0.3888724446,
0.02281853,
0.1454839408,
0.1185076311,
-0.3243407607,
0.4696210921,
-0.5508711338,
0.2039058208,
-0.2884770036,
0.4936754107,
-0.0404018536,
0.4811336398,
-0.0681845173,
1.1573425531,
0.300077498,
-0.3265677691,
0.2450169474,
0.4195123613,
-0.2655629218,
0.6630382538,
-0.3294799328,
0.5363223553,
-0.0844935626,
-0.0489951,
-0.939042449,
-0.2954629958,
0.0258930959,
-0.3111030459,
0.2522003055,
0.1440788507,
-0.2271692753,
-0.3046807051,
-0.1480086893,
0.4642848074,
0.5168921947,
-0.4770413935,
0.6604190469,
0.6305875778,
-0.2331959307,
-0.8444952369,
-0.5130472183,
0.0707716867,
-0.2043653578,
-0.7382087708,
0.404714942,
-0.0459510572,
-0.1572988331,
-0.0620534159,
-0.4257687628,
0.1748006344,
0.0541534424,
-0.2688049674,
0.2246045619,
-0.3311662674,
0.1753695011,
0.06362167,
-0.0809593871,
-0.0423660316,
-0.5596961975,
0.5323420167,
-0.1172131449,
-0.3422560096,
-0.2850048244,
0.4148371816,
0.5028042793,
-0.5034404993,
0.6386381984,
0.2807864845,
-0.1254790425,
-0.2787253261,
-0.8946661353,
-0.1226373911,
-0.4960541427,
0.1776802391,
-0.1685568243,
-0.8354340792,
0.3987866044,
0.0279435478,
0.0485199206,
0.4676935971,
0.5039896369,
-0.4071069062,
1.1535768509,
0.5234479308,
-0.1400469542,
0.1731166542,
-0.0010210588,
0.4689741135,
-0.9895142913,
-0.3155983984,
-0.3323405385,
-0.4549423754,
-0.3902280927,
-0.3927915096,
0.2749067545,
0.0895025805,
-0.2855403125,
0.4398076832,
-0.708724618,
0.5705614686,
0.3405174315,
0.2400230765,
0.1995821744,
-0.2650537193,
-0.333232522,
0.0203689057,
-0.8524261117,
-0.6163310409,
0.8495886922,
0.1651314497,
1.1303838491,
0.2020173073,
0.9031600952,
0.064445734,
0.2100671083,
-0.5987751484,
0.6270132065,
0.0616084598,
-0.4615858197,
-0.3835892677,
-0.3289274573,
-0.6290901899,
0.2549302876,
-0.2978104651,
-0.7595230341,
0.1521484107,
0.2732160091,
-0.566357851,
0.1986174881,
-0.6450762153,
0.7510375977,
-0.8024770021,
-0.4452798963,
-0.1035949439,
-0.9241682291,
0.3159677088,
-0.1957702935,
0.1710949838,
-0.1585448086,
-0.1349867582,
0.8038216233,
-0.5076526999,
0.7693783641,
0.2074583173,
-0.4449685812,
0.4891619682,
0.1138014272,
0.4858471155,
-0.3118225336,
0.0073018456,
-0.3225341141,
-0.1162329614,
-0.3624329865,
-0.8700252771,
0.7535693049,
-0.9641416073,
-1.0267986059,
-0.2158698887,
-0.7065165639,
-0.5883390307,
0.2664424479,
0.0779612586,
0.2347894758,
-0.0403257459,
-0.0438434966,
0.8733664155,
0.1974202543,
0.2907299697,
0.4540075958,
-0.1383595467,
-0.9130883813,
0.8180226684,
-0.0287479106,
0.5238026977,
0.433470726,
0.3140573502,
-0.3576043844,
-0.3556028008,
-0.310957849,
0.1218690351,
-0.7015752792,
-0.4906844199,
-0.7787475586,
-0.2937729955,
-0.742441833,
-0.2282473892,
-0.456964463,
-0.4309364259,
-0.1200932711,
-0.2373165488,
0.1293366104,
0.4930175841,
0.155007869,
0.3893553019,
-0.7491908073,
-0.0127259307,
0.4902073443,
0.1612982601,
0.0535398126,
-0.3185758293,
-0.2518498898,
0.2687774003,
-0.5966578722,
-0.7916445136,
0.2508478463,
-0.1037666425,
0.6285207272,
0.4255271554,
0.1272837669,
1.0146803856,
-0.2300237864,
0.6092226505,
0.511896193,
-0.9732809067,
0.5638904572,
-0.3450241685,
0.1362409443,
0.9112585187,
0.1255997866,
-0.3796187043,
-0.5448239446,
-0.7059066296,
-0.706040144,
0.3617280722,
-0.0002653259,
-0.1458545178,
-0.1660020053,
0.0964934155,
0.2762092948,
0.3095897138,
-0.4251451194,
0.2908652723,
-0.0349851362,
-0.9583635926,
0.137260288,
0.0788353384,
-0.4076395631,
-0.2310917825,
0.7690272331,
-0.4315848351,
-0.0757576376,
0.2223713249,
-0.1911631972,
-0.3959743083,
0.3717518747,
0.5432923436,
0.7238621116,
0.0521977134,
0.3607415557,
0.2196960896,
-0.0248035882,
0.3232933581,
-0.3477565944,
0.1759607345,
-0.6043928266,
0.3009108305,
0.4267224371,
0.1746109128,
-0.5888161063,
0.5500247478,
0.1702961624,
-0.1143011153,
0.03524822,
0.4943259656,
0.1493810862,
0.0782164708,
0.1772170216,
0.2301302254,
-0.2031587213,
-0.5188426971,
0.2099208236,
0.572121799,
-0.3882593811,
-0.1487434208,
0.601580143,
0.518951118,
-0.3785326183,
0.6206346154,
0.1012917608,
-0.6908849478,
0.529106915,
0.6564614177,
0.9114011526,
-0.3893906474,
0.0828863755,
0.0668166354,
0.1289428174,
-0.0645497516,
0.193896994,
-0.0641941875,
-1.091884613,
-0.5294377208,
-0.3837656975,
-0.3166354001,
-0.2897998393,
-0.5779012442,
0.181848675,
-0.3392475545,
-0.0162521526,
-0.1411875784,
-0.0538129471,
-0.4816183746,
0.2936903834,
-0.0155138569,
0.8912832141,
-0.7651839256,
0.8356482387,
0.6181061864,
-0.3088331819,
-1.1659269333,
0.1152139679,
-0.0393376611,
-0.9659734964,
0.2220389694,
0.0463588722,
-0.4282401204,
0.2178959697,
-0.7225852609,
-0.910089016,
1.0960423946,
0.2630997896,
-0.7021689415,
0.0755356699,
-0.0381596014,
0.5838941336,
-0.6809028983,
0.2173471153,
0.5888831615,
0.1845474839,
0.2271291316,
-0.6769595146,
0.0535958037,
-0.1571857184,
-0.1028449833,
0.5452643633,
-0.7709344625,
0.3888279498,
-0.2394773364,
-0.1610466242,
-0.1234363541,
0.9517248273,
0.1910423636,
-0.1635031402,
0.5752295256,
0.8135219812,
1.0068403482,
0.16658777,
0.5007320642,
-0.5978062749,
0.2100069225,
1.4282873869,
-0.4019474387,
0.7494494319,
0.7423732877,
-0.026034236,
0.6672938466,
0.5097228885,
0.2340245992,
0.6116883755,
0.0039188191,
-0.1711729169,
-0.5585340261,
-0.0180645343,
-0.1830284446,
0.3390892148,
0.1627449095,
-0.0698266849,
-0.1027715653,
-0.330843091,
-0.1348967701,
0.4021029472,
-0.1110666692,
1.0446027517,
-0.0704879761,
-1.1497608423,
0.3135228753,
-0.2708047032,
0.4865721166,
-0.3817970753,
0.1089163944,
-0.1211604029,
0.14252536,
-0.3321186006,
-1.0837273598,
-0.0084012859,
-0.1367216706,
-0.0143670319,
-0.2964200974,
0.443097651,
-0.8073106408,
-0.4401069582,
0.0456022918,
0.5725650191,
-0.1323079616,
0.4414481521,
-0.6007885337,
-0.3875126839,
0.0602997206,
0.148372829,
0.3358131349,
0.6949135065,
0.022367375,
0.6757119894,
0.3670390546,
-0.0620395355,
0.0378338844,
-0.1714764088,
0.9158896804,
-0.7145135999,
-0.431139946,
-0.8699181676,
0.7117779255,
-0.3505081236,
-0.5633667707,
0.5959921479,
0.5650524497,
0.6965498328,
0.2044578195,
0.8093289733,
-0.0263769198,
0.3954826593,
-0.5694710612,
0.3423401713,
-0.361373961,
0.2427217513,
-0.2748686969,
-0.7096951604,
0.1086792499,
0.4034023583,
-0.2183203697,
-0.041463837,
0.8325486183,
0.9053544402,
-0.1550839692,
0.1161552295,
0.1773058921,
0.1440664828,
0.4449049234,
0.4398384392,
0.8377018571,
-0.1589350253,
0.3380771875,
-0.3156468868,
-0.283500731,
0.0551230125,
-0.9345049262,
-0.7277095914,
-0.4018237293,
-0.3844615817,
-0.2516282797,
-0.0714625865,
1.4746659994,
0.6054522991,
-1.0049777031,
-0.290386796,
-0.2317025512,
0.0861853361,
-0.2751863301,
-0.1865594089,
0.3560524881,
-0.6101807952,
-0.4159521759,
0.3304378688,
0.4682991505,
0.0900980234,
-0.4126958847,
-0.0582769476,
-0.236057803,
0.1300964653,
0.1083950624,
-0.0189551171,
-0.7777826786,
-0.4112528861,
0.1686781049,
-0.4080376625,
0.3493581414,
0.7719384432,
-0.6960920095,
0.6229568124,
0.4496465027,
0.8795161247,
-0.0378904939,
0.6079618931,
0.9453440905,
-0.5147199035,
-0.2739313543,
0.4732663333,
0.4242379069,
0.3537808359,
-0.5576559305,
0.4529714584,
-0.0548865981,
-0.6743419766,
-0.4321456254,
0.2483637929,
-1.0943329334,
-0.1184446514,
0.9484066367,
0.1328690201,
-0.385799408,
0.0072482852,
-0.4447813332,
0.1027539,
-0.317222625,
0.9519858956,
0.7704921365,
-0.2773391008,
-0.1710496396,
0.1123403087,
0.179831624,
0.5740624666,
-0.9242392778,
0.0981445983,
0.1958572119,
0.3605389595,
0.1380748749,
0.5003710389,
-0.1293278635,
-0.1661295444,
-0.3508569598,
0.2140934318,
0.2601103485,
-0.2481145412,
0.0436659381,
-0.0025383064,
0.1940098405,
-0.0250818077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00543v1
|
New Benchmark Dataset and Fine-Grained Cross-Modal Fusion Framework for Vietnamese Multimodal Aspect-Category Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-05-01T14:29:03 | 2024-05-01T14:29:03 |
Quy Hoang Nguyen, Minh-Van Truong Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The emergence of multimodal data on social media platforms presents new
opportunities to better understand user sentiments toward a given aspect.
However, existing multimodal datasets for Aspect-Category Sentiment Analysis
(ACSA) often focus on textual annotations, neglecting fine-grained information
in images. Consequently, these datasets fail to fully exploit the richness
inherent in multimodal. To address this, we introduce a new Vietnamese
multimodal dataset, named ViMACSA, which consists of 4,876 text-image pairs
with 14,618 fine-grained annotations for both text and image in the hotel
domain. Additionally, we propose a Fine-Grained Cross-Modal Fusion Framework
(FCMF) that effectively learns both intra- and inter-modality interactions and
then fuses these information to produce a unified multimodal representation.
Experimental results show that our framework outperforms SOTA models on the
ViMACSA dataset, achieving the highest F1 score of 79.73%. We also explore
characteristics and challenges in Vietnamese multimodal sentiment analysis,
including misspellings, abbreviations, and the complexities of the Vietnamese
language. This work contributes both a benchmark dataset and a new framework
that leverages fine-grained multimodal information to improve multimodal
aspect-category sentiment analysis. Our dataset is available for research
purposes:
https://github.com/hoangquy18/Multimodal-Aspect-Category-Sentiment-Analysis.
|
[
-0.6325420141,
-0.7660086751,
0.4382017255,
0.3041469455,
-0.4801005721,
-0.0234012306,
-0.2161715776,
-0.2345480025,
0.3266606331,
0.3975242972,
-0.4534818828,
-0.7190871835,
-0.4085147977,
-0.0301117934,
0.0254096091,
0.764221549,
-0.1991113126,
0.1401071995,
-0.4819667339,
-0.7707974315,
-0.2931112051,
-0.6337301135,
-0.0312475972,
-0.0625564605,
0.5388587117,
0.507660687,
0.6224676967,
0.1576572806,
0.665153265,
0.1318203509,
0.3760150373,
0.5988830328,
-0.1455901861,
-0.0095316367,
-0.101628229,
-0.0298061948,
-0.4656001031,
-0.1379770935,
0.4924053848,
0.3324629366,
0.1659529805,
0.1746536195,
-0.0093291868,
0.6242857575,
-0.748842895,
0.3910768926,
-0.3730149865,
-0.1387979984,
-0.1243492961,
-0.2259269208,
-0.0135260019,
-0.096844241,
0.1328120977,
-0.3519012332,
-0.1165897623,
-0.2418804169,
0.9050733447,
0.129099369,
-0.9049902558,
0.058924105,
-0.4284061491,
0.8185950518,
-0.2928871512,
0.52756387,
0.3566529453,
0.4400621355,
0.3300051093,
-0.3661490679,
-0.6877142191,
-0.118353352,
-0.0813000798,
0.1315915287,
-0.1920959204,
-0.0302766431,
-0.1360648125,
0.4328783154,
-0.621848166,
-0.1999385357,
-0.1349419951,
-0.2036020458,
0.5349823236,
0.1971565038,
0.0603225864,
-0.7995576859,
-0.7371972203,
-0.2824377418,
-0.4785491228,
0.2098618895,
-0.0467759185,
0.3236322999,
-0.3370855153,
0.6667904854,
-0.4380981624,
0.5130565166,
-0.4663650095,
-0.1095979288,
0.7339164019,
-0.6778104901,
-0.3637439311,
-0.0451656058,
1.0082297325,
0.9464308619,
-0.0338860489,
0.3569881022,
-0.3711769879,
0.5144750476,
0.0550364964,
-0.5351923704,
-0.1891377121,
0.3582329154,
-0.6365761161,
-0.2208594084,
0.4591229856,
-1.032544136,
-0.3407119811,
-0.3031380177,
0.559818089,
-0.2862094641,
-0.4178065956,
-0.0555651262,
-0.1087093055,
0.3633261323,
0.3825100064,
-0.2120178491,
-0.0852165148,
0.5620837212,
0.8637428284,
-0.1500186473,
-0.3144211173,
-0.5660277009,
-0.1587115973,
0.0349920057,
0.845769763,
-0.84129107,
-0.633092165,
0.2378350943,
0.1696176827,
0.0638957918,
-0.5973804593,
0.4858271182,
0.0010503012,
-0.031620089,
-0.2892955244,
-0.0054363343,
-0.426235944,
0.5437511802,
-0.819884479,
1.0964974165,
0.3157819211,
-0.3974095881,
0.2896119952,
-0.3949362934,
-0.4290669262,
-0.3544496894,
-0.2003053874,
-0.4412606061,
0.3048069477,
0.5461053848,
0.718682766,
-0.3836856782,
0.2811363935,
-0.572845459,
0.1428673714,
0.4950562716,
-0.5228381157,
0.2634204924,
0.3721387684,
-0.1206166446,
0.1766573638,
-0.8625739217,
-0.1516811103,
-0.0879688486,
-0.2169040591,
-0.610806644,
-0.2761836946,
0.6604239941,
0.639710784,
0.3413143456,
-0.4385870099,
0.113958016,
0.2929287255,
0.2240106761,
0.5775806904,
0.1308224201,
0.3378006816,
-0.3821643293,
0.4838420451,
0.6042214632,
0.3685160577,
-0.630227983,
-0.3469836414,
-0.7250494957,
-0.4461629987,
-0.0065828105,
0.2063599527,
-1.1774455309,
0.1944867522,
-0.2378933281,
-0.5617428422,
-0.8535309434,
0.1292133182,
0.3893078566,
0.2717862129,
0.4383773506,
-0.5467346311,
-0.7013460994,
-0.9509111643,
-0.1597369611,
-0.1624842584,
0.1513266861,
0.3310608566,
0.2933468819,
-0.7403643131,
0.8257639408,
-0.3904647529,
-0.725699842,
-0.0316077583,
0.3577342033,
-0.2967736721,
0.424274236,
0.6593544483,
-1.0244381428,
-0.1398646533,
0.1163814738,
-0.725707233,
-0.0627630576,
0.0179218892,
0.0102396738,
0.3309193552,
0.271681577,
-0.38747859,
0.1608140618,
0.798576057,
-0.3373596668,
0.3421467245,
0.1553989053,
0.4316777289,
-1.320638299,
-0.0772301704,
0.5527544618,
-0.279135555,
-0.4204375744,
0.0199306253,
0.0529191606,
0.0180948544,
-0.6241846681,
0.6265271902,
-0.1329310834,
0.2429862469,
-0.4486193359,
0.0110868188,
0.1985320896,
0.6121956706,
0.1322573721,
0.3502916098,
0.4738334417,
-0.1941801012,
0.3315732181,
-0.118624337,
-0.2600324452,
0.7352414727,
-0.3031626344,
-0.2092731297,
-0.1158600524,
0.3089004755,
-1.1035438776,
-0.2953922153,
0.0974211544,
-0.2270189524,
-0.0586257763,
0.0530467629,
-0.4232121706,
-0.0012669918,
-0.6818611026,
0.6198479533,
0.0838703141,
-0.288366586,
0.9027300477,
0.6323040128,
-0.0872472599,
-0.3171541989,
-0.4206642509,
-0.0449501835,
-0.0920577198,
-0.2080857009,
0.1490773857,
0.2008031756,
-0.1518426538,
0.0556460582,
-0.0024999641,
-0.1478292644,
-0.278627187,
0.5206771493,
0.3668987453,
-0.3188095391,
0.1751840413,
0.1712496132,
-0.1396467388,
-0.0433971025,
-0.0294855684,
0.605605185,
-0.4873652756,
-0.1977937818,
-0.4538685381,
0.4009294808,
0.8209506273,
-0.3834707141,
0.4382936358,
1.078088522,
-0.3971481025,
0.3370709121,
-0.6647660136,
0.0364975445,
-0.3357660174,
0.4668479562,
-0.4871112704,
-0.9869405031,
0.2413081378,
0.0459174402,
-0.1044952273,
0.5968537927,
0.7431053519,
-0.0212685857,
0.9689024091,
0.6419907212,
-0.3705047369,
0.570674777,
-0.2506568432,
-0.0853280127,
-0.7224792242,
-0.3841826022,
-0.3294567764,
-0.3097587228,
-0.8973016739,
-0.9177986979,
0.3319991529,
-0.2633256316,
0.0351817682,
0.0567578338,
-0.1255025864,
0.0476506501,
0.4764685333,
0.088914156,
0.4532398283,
0.0887405425,
0.0816043988,
0.0243067443,
-0.2781539857,
-0.4560801387,
0.8751733303,
0.2512480319,
0.8963459134,
-0.1212430224,
0.3959210813,
0.3353232443,
0.0388971455,
-0.719442904,
0.3920731246,
-0.2494772375,
-0.2577437162,
0.1880933344,
-0.507209599,
-0.5022322536,
0.437219739,
-0.3656369746,
-0.3249677122,
0.6745054722,
-0.0738993287,
-0.1668419391,
0.0268550608,
-0.6529635191,
0.8414657116,
-0.1939465553,
-0.1188547537,
-0.1996041387,
-0.6578573585,
0.3800927997,
-0.2276084423,
0.3003337085,
-0.501429975,
-0.1099987552,
0.5554118156,
-0.2685455382,
0.7532086372,
-0.1867413819,
-0.2008966357,
0.2749708593,
-0.1007478461,
-0.0374588184,
0.5251677632,
0.1153648719,
0.633643508,
0.0524643324,
-0.3298524022,
-0.4310986102,
1.0289804935,
-0.8944944143,
-0.0762965605,
-0.3687101305,
-0.39502424,
-0.2714350522,
-0.0073827445,
0.1488206089,
0.5780670047,
-0.2961278558,
0.2599999011,
0.2668838203,
-0.0821893066,
0.3464609385,
0.3738342822,
-0.3735660315,
-0.8464298248,
1.3291406631,
0.0633114278,
0.0316262506,
0.6625086069,
-0.0121550141,
-0.222361505,
0.1887362003,
-0.2959932983,
0.0149120744,
-0.5704555511,
-0.3924721181,
-0.8633110523,
-0.0639696121,
-0.3810116947,
-0.141392231,
-0.4978589714,
-0.5050967336,
-0.0586681105,
0.0522355735,
0.3566863537,
0.4599965811,
0.0517788418,
0.3318855464,
-1.0357285738,
0.5868154764,
0.3145195842,
0.1549459249,
-0.1623413265,
0.0361253098,
-0.2160096616,
0.1838625968,
-0.3628377914,
-0.5202351213,
0.3032336533,
0.1649194658,
0.208103016,
0.5841119289,
0.0658262819,
0.6365295649,
-0.0080025941,
0.8384258151,
0.2723674178,
-0.834282279,
0.5359196067,
-0.3172125518,
0.5637339354,
0.6433492303,
0.2817738652,
-0.6774368286,
-0.3135554492,
-0.3974721432,
-0.873146534,
0.4771945179,
0.0588562526,
0.0609641187,
0.1301036477,
-0.163198486,
0.3808153272,
0.5445592999,
-0.7109866738,
-0.1592029482,
-0.5647043586,
-0.5014102459,
-0.4187290072,
-0.2296831906,
-0.0615260862,
-0.3821436465,
0.4791184068,
-0.3316489458,
0.2402374595,
0.059777461,
-0.2052064687,
-0.0948351994,
0.1972009689,
0.5826383233,
0.4299843013,
-0.2877916396,
0.3992538154,
-0.185571,
-0.4108003974,
0.1385779381,
0.2877339125,
0.2692739666,
0.1564052999,
0.3359021246,
0.6980291009,
0.0734176338,
-0.8230549693,
0.5126803517,
-0.2194222361,
0.1075883284,
0.053936027,
-0.1801413,
-0.3620738089,
0.3255356252,
0.3272795081,
0.2331456244,
0.0958051085,
-0.7306399941,
0.197195515,
0.3722872138,
-0.8986081481,
-0.5241428018,
0.252676636,
0.2602196932,
0.1978931278,
0.1708439291,
0.1294428855,
-0.4742149711,
0.2210568786,
-0.0220593009,
1.0387701988,
-0.2382931262,
0.445420593,
0.0441960692,
0.2966124117,
0.1256864071,
0.5728296041,
-0.0920476019,
-0.4049906731,
-0.0789194554,
-0.8920778036,
-0.3195685148,
-0.1051469594,
-0.6319715381,
0.2546078861,
-0.2686903179,
-0.1883627623,
-0.1733480841,
-0.0735186338,
-0.7369476557,
0.4075031281,
0.1191374585,
0.4699586034,
-0.8587776423,
0.8843377829,
1.1365637779,
-0.4932370782,
-0.4172914922,
0.0513286702,
0.2381624281,
-0.6465530992,
0.1353156716,
0.4888947606,
-0.0890395567,
-0.5533739328,
-0.3066674471,
-0.4802176654,
0.8304938674,
0.0325352922,
-0.3776648939,
0.2696020603,
0.4124573469,
0.36241436,
-0.7118518353,
0.0352463685,
0.5821537375,
0.3587932587,
-0.1222870722,
-0.8036878705,
-0.0003291295,
-0.4446534812,
0.1422998011,
0.2786235809,
-0.8679667115,
0.8587260246,
0.2250816822,
0.3081614673,
-0.153743282,
0.7581846118,
0.1051310673,
0.675237,
0.5745417476,
0.5059278607,
0.3368720412,
-0.2311462313,
0.7307372093,
-0.0143294819,
0.4822943807,
0.9748218656,
-0.3524465263,
1.0758426189,
0.6330604553,
0.2260298878,
0.5312014222,
0.5533439517,
0.1562719941,
0.7512427568,
-0.4647002816,
-0.1397434175,
-0.3709970415,
-0.5920177102,
-0.4657102525,
0.8600687981,
0.3310449421,
-0.3030137122,
-0.3423496485,
0.7342088819,
-0.0930546299,
-0.1716471165,
-0.3045501709,
0.8373105526,
0.3179319203,
-0.4161683023,
0.2930243611,
0.0515409745,
0.6626240015,
-0.5422596335,
0.0080988863,
-0.2035743147,
0.2439038754,
-0.186690554,
-0.8276363015,
-0.0640104339,
-0.1090610847,
-0.2381320447,
0.0719408095,
0.6848512888,
-0.5934846997,
-0.6417668462,
0.1751207858,
0.5249720812,
-0.3904349208,
-0.3120257854,
-0.5382758975,
0.452462256,
-0.2166935503,
-0.0551388562,
0.2824425399,
0.6300253272,
-0.1847343594,
0.2904858887,
0.4041340947,
-0.3217741549,
-0.2052190751,
0.1645465195,
1.0868191719,
-0.7445662618,
-0.4670737684,
-0.8628438711,
0.4493507445,
0.0017816214,
-0.6646157503,
0.847016871,
0.6209495068,
0.9868280888,
-0.0337594636,
0.8510895967,
0.0236271191,
0.0242756233,
-0.6392504573,
0.4277468324,
-1.0821762085,
-0.0060836617,
-0.716024518,
-1.0665929317,
-0.2233800441,
0.3810934722,
0.0366787687,
0.1252533644,
0.5271015763,
0.8525116444,
-0.1193978786,
0.0592541806,
0.320245862,
0.1058500186,
0.4447602034,
0.4303516746,
1.0434216261,
-0.5496205688,
0.370742023,
-0.5263556838,
-0.1904557049,
-0.6872035265,
-0.5640640259,
-0.7539039254,
-1.0357260704,
-0.3333173394,
-0.3868738413,
-0.1519028246,
1.2588385344,
0.4757807851,
-0.792147994,
-0.2633004189,
0.5891158581,
0.0306909364,
-0.4293198287,
-0.2782967389,
0.4355372787,
-0.1321019679,
-0.6863011718,
0.0006268282,
0.7341942191,
0.003294037,
-0.5276256204,
-0.0172980726,
-0.3275794089,
0.0622349158,
0.9874926805,
-0.0872817338,
-0.6548229456,
-0.1692127138,
-0.0260080528,
-0.3114149868,
0.1779852062,
1.026014328,
-0.7822751403,
0.8034726977,
0.443502754,
0.497385174,
0.1317116022,
-0.1391917765,
0.4276452661,
-0.7590878606,
0.2879069149,
0.0146253919,
0.625475049,
0.3671460748,
0.0094129918,
0.2201571465,
0.2764629722,
-0.2438740581,
-0.7372034192,
0.012894365,
-1.4958720207,
-0.2668109834,
1.1982090473,
0.2404667884,
-0.4605713785,
-0.200034678,
-0.5492819548,
0.0817541257,
-0.6208719611,
0.7377250195,
0.5208668113,
0.2766252756,
-0.0956912339,
-0.2299041748,
0.3970851302,
0.3782631159,
-0.8114492297,
0.1109466776,
0.8266612887,
-0.1999700367,
0.1303712428,
0.6296758056,
-0.0040075183,
0.4831346869,
-0.2988326252,
-0.1105554402,
-0.0021384144,
-0.6777829528,
-0.4247492552,
0.4734894335,
-0.2394999117,
-0.3597367108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00536v1
|
A Legal Framework for Natural Language Processing Model Training in Portugal
| 2024-05-01T14:18:50 | 2024-05-01T14:18:50 |
Rúben Almeida, Evelin Amorim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.ET, 68T50, K.5.0
|
Recent advances in deep learning have promoted the advent of many
computational systems capable of performing intelligent actions that, until
then, were restricted to the human intellect. In the particular case of human
languages, these advances allowed the introduction of applications like ChatGPT
that are capable of generating coherent text without being explicitly
programmed to do so. Instead, these models use large volumes of textual data to
learn meaningful representations of human languages. Associated with these
advances, concerns about copyright and data privacy infringements caused by
these applications have emerged. Despite these concerns, the pace at which new
natural language processing applications continued to be developed largely
outperformed the introduction of new regulations. Today, communication barriers
between legal experts and computer scientists motivate many unintentional legal
infringements during the development of such applications. In this paper, a
multidisciplinary team intends to bridge this communication gap and promote
more compliant Portuguese NLP research by presenting a series of everyday NLP
use cases, while highlighting the Portuguese legislation that may arise during
its development.
|
[
-0.3631456494,
-0.6724952459,
0.269431293,
0.1554388106,
-0.2581624687,
0.1233219355,
-0.3650617301,
-0.837459743,
-0.1301016808,
0.9317998886,
-0.3634340465,
-0.4388947785,
-0.7680230737,
0.0542028099,
-0.4719414413,
1.069226265,
0.1522421837,
0.1927241385,
0.0136816287,
-0.1834357977,
-0.5569728613,
-0.795787394,
-0.7822781801,
-0.1306526959,
0.2382692695,
0.1859476566,
0.4732327461,
0.4622746706,
0.355468899,
0.3066024482,
-0.2271847129,
-0.1139707267,
-0.2245036066,
0.2519470751,
-0.2767577171,
-0.5866745114,
-0.0400426723,
-0.1021616161,
0.4227431715,
0.6372705102,
-0.3569190204,
-0.301835984,
0.2341958284,
0.7215040922,
-0.538725853,
0.2185257375,
-0.5488520265,
0.3027504086,
-0.2385374755,
-0.0607610084,
-0.2642688155,
-0.4434078634,
0.3208364546,
-0.3865620196,
0.3894227743,
-0.3506048322,
0.9430999756,
0.3838230073,
-0.3997111619,
-0.7349640131,
-0.5338286161,
0.5759102702,
-0.781953454,
0.4138559401,
0.3377789259,
0.5039060116,
-0.3710501194,
-0.5513836741,
-0.3507808745,
-0.4428141713,
0.1241978183,
-0.148047328,
-0.4307411909,
0.1598698646,
0.337767601,
0.0785341859,
-0.4655673802,
0.307687968,
-0.6583404541,
-0.2021258622,
0.5399537683,
-0.1814830899,
0.3087372184,
0.021120511,
-0.1458058804,
0.1385331452,
-0.7688321471,
-0.0008016003,
0.6490144134,
0.4294484556,
-0.0875549167,
0.4569923282,
-0.1186675727,
0.8565946221,
-0.4929902256,
0.1926935762,
0.160972625,
0.0460312665,
-0.2511996627,
0.1591123194,
0.7408602834,
-0.0266244076,
0.5500847697,
-0.1194133312,
-0.1672348678,
0.1085049286,
0.4023984373,
-0.598067522,
-0.0159352459,
0.1359073818,
-0.2566029727,
-0.2572674751,
0.022600539,
-0.6464010477,
-0.5906755924,
-0.5785444379,
-0.0863011852,
-0.3936951756,
-0.313239783,
0.4433375597,
-0.024016818,
0.2822814286,
0.0885031745,
-1.0026643276,
0.4663397372,
0.8857707381,
0.4995833039,
0.1253180653,
-0.0746802762,
-0.2700068653,
0.0628700182,
-0.0636856109,
0.6872855425,
-0.4342090487,
-0.3018344939,
0.1396600604,
-0.0407481678,
-0.0796908885,
-0.4111555815,
0.9954136014,
-0.5287731886,
0.4743492901,
-0.0295768194,
-0.4918695092,
-0.259247303,
0.4235390425,
-0.4951036274,
0.6911402941,
-0.2311034948,
-0.8232884407,
0.5075320601,
-0.8016235232,
-0.5042228103,
0.1863083839,
-0.4489167035,
-0.273186326,
-0.0878667235,
0.0682082847,
0.5189038515,
-0.2575160563,
0.6648294926,
-0.0503258854,
-0.0571110174,
0.0437627286,
-0.6279468536,
1.2048050165,
0.4631478786,
-0.2574737966,
0.0478088185,
-0.8435896635,
-0.2757542431,
-0.0528644435,
-0.644833982,
-0.4093310237,
-0.0173717793,
0.0598722063,
0.4430742264,
0.0616009422,
-0.6090455651,
0.062763229,
-0.6584957838,
0.9196870923,
0.4252477586,
-0.1273195893,
0.3224445581,
-0.0700289384,
0.6381112933,
-0.1526995152,
0.0758760124,
-0.1122407168,
-0.7955730557,
-0.6708331108,
-0.0998896733,
0.4461106956,
0.5361866951,
-0.7242850661,
0.2360752374,
-0.3959492743,
-0.3511511683,
-0.7806490064,
0.0997181907,
0.2791553736,
0.4871894419,
0.1585238576,
-0.382722199,
-0.6417849064,
-0.8997379541,
-0.3931061924,
0.0450647399,
-0.1441648453,
0.3027922809,
0.5738976002,
-0.2287125885,
1.0482860804,
-0.0221739206,
-0.4774537086,
-0.275680691,
0.2043268234,
0.3409937322,
0.5900643468,
0.5692921281,
-0.9153530598,
-0.3843883276,
0.0431877449,
-0.7332997322,
-0.155505836,
0.0568182766,
0.1387785524,
0.4093694091,
0.5910170674,
-0.5435298681,
0.334495306,
0.3844034672,
-0.4196465313,
0.3491851985,
-0.4339691699,
-0.0897769108,
-0.8482637405,
0.0645585284,
-0.05574812,
-0.3542015851,
-0.6900337934,
0.179461807,
-0.2132893354,
-0.3399635851,
-0.7471939921,
0.3277004361,
-0.2369119823,
0.0907655284,
-0.2946058214,
-0.1768367141,
-0.1643101573,
0.3188110888,
0.2414326072,
0.4549413621,
0.677709043,
-0.702771306,
0.2138998359,
0.145597294,
-0.198643744,
0.7342454195,
-0.5348325968,
0.0011478571,
-0.1947939396,
-0.0310759954,
-0.4096109867,
-0.3081173003,
0.3802809417,
-0.4592078924,
0.3082030714,
-0.5857420564,
-0.3620761931,
-0.3103172481,
-0.0310592167,
0.1109340787,
0.2109216452,
-0.3247021437,
0.5419914126,
0.7541283965,
-0.0908199102,
-0.7306129932,
-1.0610080957,
0.5724748373,
-0.3507148325,
-0.8307883739,
0.2419892251,
0.2054181695,
-0.177689597,
0.0280619785,
0.2964027524,
-0.5920827389,
0.3745322526,
0.2437325418,
-0.309556514,
-0.1128718928,
0.0083095795,
0.044853203,
-0.197118178,
0.3290106654,
-0.1810576618,
0.6309895515,
-0.071090661,
-0.2886252701,
-0.4451751113,
0.4580074847,
0.1792957485,
-0.0991132036,
0.4073419571,
0.328817904,
-0.4211132824,
-0.1811451912,
-0.5635258555,
0.0496693701,
-0.4794876575,
0.1679424495,
-0.1340590566,
-1.080545783,
0.2725069523,
0.1861880273,
0.3455187082,
0.3408417404,
0.6335340738,
0.1010419279,
0.60646981,
0.9602446556,
-0.0606222302,
0.571926415,
0.0074096164,
0.2768984735,
-0.2815932333,
-0.2003721446,
-0.7794910073,
0.049408555,
-0.9169394374,
-0.2742504776,
0.0187229719,
-0.1462212205,
-0.0848154947,
0.7682800293,
-0.6750730276,
0.7373487949,
0.7545794249,
-0.1311471313,
0.4928913116,
0.0029906812,
-0.3191320598,
-0.0744075179,
-0.8493391275,
-0.7750376463,
0.9402123094,
0.4247528613,
0.4875923097,
-0.0175625198,
0.8870159984,
0.3590656519,
0.1160135418,
-0.7421656251,
0.4809055626,
-0.1564085335,
-0.756862998,
-0.0529567525,
-0.490259707,
-1.4435949326,
0.1628452241,
-0.2123659551,
-0.6729492545,
0.333332628,
0.0083204731,
-0.2759336531,
0.1152224466,
-0.726226151,
0.953140974,
-0.1960796416,
-0.524104178,
-0.2217735797,
-0.7743392587,
0.1985839754,
0.1833977997,
0.4623122215,
-0.2297808826,
0.303684473,
0.7868528366,
-0.259862572,
1.0216027498,
-0.2366637588,
-0.3157513142,
0.4859695435,
0.1039779335,
0.1179092601,
-0.0035484713,
0.0154949902,
0.0714986995,
0.0302288067,
-0.2146709561,
0.0420935638,
0.4644488394,
-0.3933956921,
-0.3796077073,
-0.5136215687,
-0.3384850323,
-0.0487224162,
0.4210017025,
0.2306301743,
-0.1847671121,
-0.4682614803,
0.075899899,
0.6044026017,
-0.2850170135,
0.3559290469,
0.7714262605,
0.1413554847,
-0.0655318946,
0.9607169032,
0.0569154732,
-0.0806806386,
0.1912656873,
0.103213273,
-0.2017813623,
-0.6533138752,
-0.2241717428,
-0.0336028114,
-0.7653446198,
0.064225778,
-0.6448842287,
-0.131282568,
-0.5534806848,
-0.0192109924,
-0.2644970119,
-0.4723317027,
-0.1010215431,
0.0664922446,
0.1273042262,
0.6723359823,
-0.0828517824,
0.2726152241,
-0.89475137,
0.1374937147,
0.3451339602,
0.3943771422,
-0.3477392197,
-0.2901600599,
-0.1113551334,
0.1643735617,
-0.5014993548,
-0.5665360689,
0.626116693,
0.064466536,
0.561665535,
0.084998548,
-0.4002453983,
0.2625757754,
-0.5539987683,
0.442245692,
-0.0424816236,
-0.8118272424,
0.6273406148,
-0.5928082466,
-0.0771618709,
0.539488852,
0.2601123154,
-0.7521118522,
-0.4380696714,
-0.6754017472,
-1.0074088573,
0.5967043638,
0.4756242633,
0.2973029912,
0.1752354801,
0.2812629938,
0.0566059165,
0.4269995987,
-1.0016573668,
0.466766417,
0.0216288939,
-0.0560621396,
0.3838151991,
0.0558037683,
-0.2242110372,
-0.1395074278,
0.6500084996,
-0.0342066623,
0.2041379958,
-0.0457759127,
-0.2473687232,
0.2909352481,
0.4983647168,
0.4966326952,
0.5682204962,
0.141240567,
-0.0264227837,
-0.0060988255,
-0.4988424182,
-0.0235981476,
0.336751312,
-0.2174821496,
0.0117620546,
0.2453765571,
0.6213421822,
0.2280040085,
-0.9345133901,
0.5103235841,
-0.1857459992,
-0.3051741123,
-0.3441339731,
0.3022939563,
0.0995875522,
0.2646966577,
-0.0284705497,
0.169077903,
0.4051412046,
-0.4452392757,
0.2525292635,
0.2321718186,
-0.5383786559,
0.0029817161,
0.771528542,
0.2251593173,
-0.3256447017,
0.3437164724,
-0.1983304322,
-0.5467220545,
0.6287949085,
0.0768584684,
0.8038918972,
-0.0119002778,
0.1215028837,
0.0044533783,
0.3014427423,
-0.4927744865,
0.384514004,
-0.186329022,
-0.7833458185,
-0.4189496934,
-0.3794140518,
-0.6329612136,
-0.2024703175,
-0.4253734648,
0.4591836929,
-0.356849134,
-0.0684450418,
-0.0381463133,
-0.1531341076,
-0.6962985396,
0.0646404177,
0.3954863548,
0.6368352175,
-0.7093954682,
1.0600063801,
0.4360167682,
-0.2875953615,
-0.1344000697,
-0.4319220483,
0.0342497528,
-0.6712092161,
0.4909853339,
0.2831714153,
0.0001232395,
-0.135216862,
-0.6972703338,
-0.2452269644,
0.5611742735,
0.7351020575,
-0.6295571327,
-0.0802019536,
0.608969748,
0.9240813255,
-0.1090745255,
-0.1047693267,
0.8480068445,
0.2701078653,
0.0570815094,
-0.6442705393,
-0.2792701125,
-0.2504558861,
-0.273624748,
0.1540178657,
-0.204349041,
0.6465073824,
0.1076064631,
-0.2784139812,
-0.2379774898,
0.430649966,
0.2364340872,
0.04935316,
0.1497659236,
0.6644089222,
0.8527870774,
-0.1978701204,
1.0367244482,
-0.2883299589,
0.247863546,
1.2686594725,
-0.2227849364,
0.5379988551,
0.4392396808,
0.0245041698,
0.1442105919,
0.4316712022,
-0.3272208273,
0.1542571187,
0.4011852443,
-0.3091903627,
0.0423833542,
-0.4251814783,
-0.2030072212,
0.4556373656,
0.6706845164,
-0.3896165192,
-0.4598748088,
0.1005733907,
0.2816738784,
0.346921891,
-0.1244693026,
0.7108701468,
0.1872950494,
-0.5276740789,
0.2800756991,
0.2811912596,
0.884567678,
-0.4602045119,
0.0821162015,
0.0935129151,
0.1075287834,
-0.1899075955,
-0.9455798864,
0.6720281243,
0.4401335716,
0.2154000998,
-0.5549001694,
0.7339600325,
-0.2435481846,
-0.3381364346,
0.4268495739,
0.3621528745,
0.3072393835,
-0.129083842,
-1.0768004656,
-0.0813845247,
-0.1569576859,
-0.1985431761,
0.2179466188,
0.6171656251,
-0.1842723191,
0.7862940431,
0.6230896115,
0.1651553512,
0.3145877421,
0.2573640943,
0.9597828388,
-0.6344172359,
-0.7047668099,
-0.906835556,
0.2923595011,
-0.1440226287,
-0.5097261071,
0.5306501985,
0.5329415202,
0.8117876649,
0.2923766077,
0.8011721373,
-0.2263167351,
0.4552502632,
-0.6440545321,
0.8257780671,
-0.0255668201,
0.4235165417,
0.0049936324,
-0.7673829794,
-0.5892485976,
0.6494809389,
-0.3595778346,
-0.1249455586,
0.206658572,
0.4931401312,
-0.1725470275,
0.2682988048,
0.2698958814,
0.2885900438,
0.7057056427,
0.7155716419,
0.6316393614,
-0.2926875353,
0.5231169462,
-0.3071614504,
0.2164176553,
0.1347765326,
-1.0313117504,
-0.8571776152,
-0.2320443094,
-0.2050766945,
-0.3390806019,
0.1518303454,
0.9788131118,
0.609335959,
-1.0456972122,
-0.4653928578,
-0.6766585708,
0.0782004818,
0.114065893,
-0.2235690653,
0.1371643096,
-0.352067709,
-0.7652802467,
0.3513832688,
0.158785969,
0.1685466617,
-0.2010324895,
0.0559133403,
-0.2706778944,
-0.2577902675,
0.4720254242,
0.6484435201,
-0.2673745751,
0.0321321562,
-0.5123628378,
-0.1582168788,
0.3953142464,
0.9182728529,
-0.8611730337,
0.5881871581,
0.5838547349,
0.8390752077,
0.4166561365,
-0.4757883847,
0.7777459025,
-0.8143811226,
0.5342149734,
0.764960289,
0.4904626906,
0.4409172833,
-0.1508555263,
0.7104656696,
0.1468903124,
-0.4735350013,
-0.7007017732,
0.1634805053,
-0.7416809797,
-0.3301341236,
0.8181748986,
-0.1285903603,
-0.1639759243,
-0.600686729,
-0.468154788,
0.2214163542,
-0.5427666903,
0.9382959008,
0.795155406,
0.0884913728,
0.0047906889,
-1.3187959194,
0.6694037318,
0.1607766151,
-0.9409405589,
0.0852629766,
0.2277142406,
0.1929822713,
0.0391277038,
0.4482450187,
-0.2812093198,
0.1301141977,
-0.3723488748,
0.2147888839,
0.1232118979,
-0.2209309936,
-0.5155830383,
0.1482374072,
-0.0948500782,
0.1763532609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00523v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00523v1
|
CookingSense: A Culinary Knowledgebase with Multidisciplinary Assertions
| 2024-05-01T13:58:09 | 2024-05-01T13:58:09 |
Donghee Choi, Mogan Gim, Donghyeon Park, Mujeen Sung, Hyunjae Kim, Jaewoo Kang, Jihun Choi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces CookingSense, a descriptive collection of knowledge
assertions in the culinary domain extracted from various sources, including web
data, scientific papers, and recipes, from which knowledge covering a broad
range of aspects is acquired. CookingSense is constructed through a series of
dictionary-based filtering and language model-based semantic filtering
techniques, which results in a rich knowledgebase of multidisciplinary
food-related assertions. Additionally, we present FoodBench, a novel benchmark
to evaluate culinary decision support systems. From evaluations with FoodBench,
we empirically prove that CookingSense improves the performance of retrieval
augmented language models. We also validate the quality and variety of
assertions in CookingSense through qualitative analysis.
|
[
-0.4524232745,
-0.558605969,
0.539047122,
0.3416824043,
0.6454179883,
0.0202458762,
-0.0936668366,
-0.2709669173,
0.5450906157,
0.4393322766,
-0.5521748066,
-0.7131237984,
-0.6703281403,
0.1217905581,
-0.284966737,
0.6025980115,
-0.2607456744,
0.2275807261,
-0.6884860396,
-0.0090867439,
-0.6273451447,
0.0409273431,
-0.16924721,
-0.2554861307,
0.8002076149,
0.6935498118,
0.3203335404,
0.2707103193,
0.7679604292,
0.2175694406,
0.3049598336,
0.5510590076,
0.1468586028,
0.6504278183,
-0.6052926183,
-0.3603348136,
-0.145585224,
0.0571557097,
-0.2091075629,
0.5951408148,
-0.1567718685,
0.2808284461,
-0.1276899427,
0.8925128579,
-1.1621289253,
0.1316232383,
-0.2548429966,
-0.0131379943,
-0.0591597147,
0.3411075473,
-0.2946005464,
-0.7375416756,
-0.0544173084,
-0.6217541695,
0.0257792417,
-0.3188793361,
0.6000668406,
0.1527008712,
-0.6189219356,
-0.338298738,
-0.8811549544,
0.7102102041,
-0.3950919509,
0.715978086,
0.7487819195,
0.9751195312,
-0.0634711087,
-1.0955842733,
-0.6456420422,
-0.1285887957,
0.0566182658,
0.2566508949,
0.2724566758,
-0.2836768329,
-0.0315123573,
0.3549720347,
-0.5032058954,
-0.1984173506,
0.0649634004,
0.0884558707,
0.724516809,
0.1835976839,
0.3477412462,
-0.4027647972,
-0.4372246265,
-0.1058591977,
-0.3062456548,
-0.0094612138,
-0.2799522579,
-0.2449769825,
0.1936333179,
0.6850736737,
-0.504807353,
0.7615844607,
-0.3581950068,
-0.341884315,
-0.0022916724,
-0.5221298933,
-0.0193011314,
-0.1280169487,
0.6056412458,
0.797650516,
-0.2268034965,
-0.2302156091,
0.0521503277,
0.5677338839,
0.054488495,
-0.4313920438,
-0.6492654085,
0.2220210135,
-0.2404742241,
-0.1743376404,
0.5574115515,
-0.977479279,
-0.8590735793,
0.0393807292,
-0.0183359683,
-0.2577240169,
-0.5885450244,
0.0831439793,
-0.9824257493,
0.2071907967,
0.0099054137,
-0.8893703818,
0.491006732,
0.9216889143,
0.846570015,
-0.1685664058,
-0.1519391388,
-0.0799572915,
0.37390396,
-0.2910941243,
1.0168840885,
-0.7341284752,
-0.6789728403,
-0.3266125917,
0.091427654,
-0.1223348081,
-0.7732576132,
0.9015163779,
-0.2865251899,
-0.2600679696,
-1.2022446394,
-0.9532698393,
-0.3384725749,
0.4514887333,
-0.6878030896,
0.9573825002,
0.2091931701,
-0.5812467933,
0.8692784905,
-0.8128654957,
-0.5079606771,
0.1643792838,
-0.4090270102,
-0.0610825978,
0.061291229,
0.2321434468,
0.4905290902,
-0.7910637259,
0.2871923149,
-0.5505110025,
0.1968985796,
0.2392169237,
-0.1812010556,
0.5375534296,
0.5527608395,
-0.0513351224,
0.0042927181,
-0.6367733479,
0.0644184574,
0.239835903,
-0.2553550899,
-0.8443884254,
0.3791674376,
-0.2580939829,
0.005474709,
0.1980293095,
-0.9442104697,
0.2853589356,
-0.0698558912,
0.2389532626,
0.3351741433,
0.3853614926,
0.097946316,
-0.7179321647,
0.3693815768,
-0.0175065957,
0.1777538061,
-0.039846275,
-0.561568439,
-0.4529986978,
-0.3507332206,
0.2197957933,
0.8630351424,
-1.1083371639,
0.4271764457,
-0.1301078498,
-0.6954266429,
-0.3597009182,
-0.050291568,
0.0022018668,
0.6655804515,
0.3934195936,
-0.0113666328,
-0.5877059102,
-0.8210411668,
-0.674839437,
0.3517681658,
-0.0997377262,
0.0974215344,
0.2249259204,
-0.106632784,
0.8307545185,
-0.9499329329,
0.0365665704,
-0.1602261066,
-0.0653671846,
0.1307569146,
0.4163913429,
0.7724289894,
-0.7778081298,
-1.0572708845,
0.4402906597,
-1.1178478003,
0.0975544304,
0.35252738,
-0.1731951535,
-0.4254525602,
0.3135334551,
-0.7580580711,
0.374697566,
0.2680555284,
-0.8375570774,
0.7427152395,
0.4601866901,
0.5870752931,
-1.2610164881,
-0.3657918572,
0.3718349338,
0.0319254771,
-0.3126912713,
0.105135493,
0.1823605895,
0.1653786898,
-0.1392931938,
0.7046282887,
-0.2446892262,
0.1349429339,
-0.0986499414,
-0.3073060215,
0.6721633673,
0.116956912,
-0.0745769069,
0.523622632,
0.7142883539,
-0.3091238439,
0.9799183607,
0.2338045239,
-0.8162820339,
0.9272538424,
-0.2708019912,
-0.2634794414,
0.1629999429,
0.0268545039,
-1.3344119787,
-0.2135330886,
0.3510020375,
-0.1318342835,
-0.0311535504,
-0.2185308188,
-0.4166026413,
-0.7501291633,
0.0277026854,
-0.1542470753,
-0.1442988962,
-0.6512550116,
0.9060046077,
0.2626622021,
-0.3499583006,
-0.2698304355,
-0.563324213,
0.1761421561,
-0.2409487069,
-0.5494616628,
-0.0282233097,
0.095432438,
-0.5170210004,
0.100244537,
-0.183821246,
-0.2288931012,
0.3052988946,
0.2418648154,
0.1893284917,
-0.3688536584,
0.0333755016,
0.0980831385,
0.2870113552,
0.4401102364,
-0.4416981339,
0.1484619528,
-0.0424700081,
-0.5033310056,
-0.3700046241,
0.6159872413,
0.8468301296,
-0.2913052142,
0.7067399621,
0.5098774433,
-0.1634346843,
0.0442201793,
-0.8078050613,
-0.1302574426,
-0.4770853817,
0.1287461221,
-0.5042880177,
-0.2615349889,
0.6516164541,
-0.3521268368,
0.3501583338,
0.5708505511,
-0.1086784676,
-0.1833316982,
0.7585885525,
0.0126432981,
0.1959500313,
0.128073588,
-0.0460439473,
-0.1714367867,
-0.6696868539,
-0.5342607498,
-0.7812134027,
-0.2321115583,
-0.3275104165,
-0.5925202966,
0.4398069382,
-0.4756356776,
-0.2862800658,
0.1888224632,
-0.6060497761,
1.0058268309,
0.3420414329,
0.2985292673,
0.3803837001,
-0.1871483028,
-0.5686059594,
-0.1750669628,
-0.5793118477,
-0.3911473453,
0.9230648279,
0.1137764305,
0.7823732495,
0.5544781685,
0.4999375343,
0.6115937233,
0.2486428022,
-0.9478516579,
0.3913003802,
-0.4221343994,
-0.7376326323,
-0.2213424295,
-0.7196385264,
-0.4021914303,
0.4155828655,
-0.1390796304,
-0.3428209126,
0.3466432989,
-0.1782813519,
-0.1904339939,
0.4073955715,
-1.2805503607,
1.0479547977,
-0.665364325,
-0.6641919017,
0.1752269864,
-0.2005323023,
0.5277836323,
0.3000948429,
0.1651992202,
-0.1890427768,
0.4096909463,
0.7831765413,
-0.4509769976,
0.7845236659,
-0.7700640559,
-0.1406244785,
0.1927203387,
0.6444377303,
0.3099729121,
0.1931881607,
-0.3549868762,
-0.0387300029,
0.6533216834,
-0.2863054276,
-0.9839396477,
1.0075439215,
-0.4493927062,
-0.5781030059,
-0.4441868067,
-0.1523658186,
-0.6601695418,
0.5262293816,
-0.0440464579,
-0.0094039049,
-0.3528097272,
0.0048773359,
0.663303256,
-0.0225100387,
0.1309216172,
0.2792848945,
-0.4425112605,
-0.3274095953,
1.161427021,
0.1097171754,
0.0434241109,
0.4667651355,
0.5944834352,
-0.2036085725,
-0.0264272075,
-0.1294451505,
-0.2091330588,
-0.8073647022,
-0.3757857978,
-0.53649652,
-0.0197411217,
-0.5389207006,
-0.1664873809,
-0.6755655408,
-0.7513326406,
0.1154584736,
-0.361684233,
0.5445514321,
0.8170985579,
-0.0048617874,
-0.0846265703,
-0.7877651453,
0.5424522161,
0.3105194569,
0.5397821665,
0.1958628893,
0.069193244,
-0.4648239911,
-0.0075096833,
-0.4953430295,
-0.903214395,
0.1509975493,
0.3476698399,
0.7328546047,
0.5946842432,
0.2259510756,
0.329492718,
-0.1772499681,
0.8830451369,
0.5021553636,
-0.4792542458,
0.658377409,
-0.244078353,
0.4387529194,
0.8239023685,
0.7843127847,
-0.627260983,
-0.1203631461,
-0.1807359606,
-0.6185779572,
-0.1521473825,
-0.5214441419,
-0.230473727,
-0.4315740168,
0.3005679548,
0.5330534577,
-0.0274617635,
-0.3724332154,
-0.1429757029,
-0.696767509,
-0.1285236627,
0.2493681908,
-0.1166302636,
-0.4223109186,
-0.7827620506,
0.4939286709,
0.1875583827,
-0.0686824545,
0.0835221261,
0.327314049,
0.0996077135,
0.1760175377,
0.4599197507,
0.7740786672,
-0.0781779811,
0.314748317,
-0.1329060793,
-0.3640414178,
0.3228753805,
-0.1837521791,
0.3384759724,
0.0166298188,
0.4464296103,
0.5554431677,
-0.018635489,
-0.233379811,
0.5266788602,
-0.380402416,
-0.3340943158,
-0.1186885387,
0.2323935628,
0.3359151185,
0.1330398619,
0.2568074763,
0.2859908044,
0.5107361078,
-0.2629375458,
0.5356599689,
0.1957990378,
-0.1355402172,
-0.044553522,
0.3506313562,
0.4060062766,
0.4197195172,
0.590339005,
0.0282560494,
-0.1708200276,
0.5249657035,
0.0304298904,
0.6634674072,
-0.5717033148,
0.6072953343,
0.3551380038,
-0.044748053,
0.0205163751,
0.5241643786,
-0.4080087245,
-0.7755932808,
-0.2029003799,
-0.6182494164,
-0.3375974,
-0.440428704,
-0.8948031068,
-0.0315600187,
-0.5178002119,
-0.4024309814,
0.4553500116,
-0.2429439723,
-0.6653692126,
0.0161235984,
-0.3364934027,
1.3279055357,
-1.0018583536,
0.5259363651,
0.8376897573,
-0.199610725,
-0.6038566232,
-0.1025535166,
0.2363169491,
-0.6554528475,
0.7627384663,
-0.3492892683,
-0.2082394361,
-0.4067205191,
-0.4031040967,
-0.6461943388,
0.5837599635,
0.0308619328,
-0.5271151662,
-0.0239837375,
-0.1066697836,
0.1002945602,
-0.162709862,
-0.0572818592,
0.6514824629,
0.9854422212,
0.5054459572,
-0.7956029773,
-0.0243829787,
-0.2305290848,
-0.2218619436,
0.2186644226,
-0.4732463956,
0.6751496196,
-0.0497691669,
-0.0385981053,
-0.0339327045,
0.5235772133,
-0.1027569696,
0.4073898196,
0.0411863625,
0.6948308349,
0.799055934,
-0.4185231924,
1.0833296776,
0.1717472076,
0.1647276431,
1.3234037161,
-0.8205564618,
0.4769786596,
0.4414638281,
-0.1827816516,
0.8120359778,
0.9038234949,
-0.2012363374,
1.1058540344,
0.03138813,
-0.3946703672,
-0.1509298235,
-0.3052178919,
-0.3651275635,
0.741224587,
0.6505013704,
-0.3795360327,
-0.4006891251,
0.2476984411,
-0.193223834,
0.2128985524,
0.0455090366,
1.1963723898,
0.013424607,
-0.7199392915,
0.4983311892,
0.082820721,
0.0628451556,
-0.5295500159,
-0.3991024196,
-0.1571108401,
-0.0556769781,
-0.3583678305,
-1.0578106642,
0.3202646077,
-0.4003365934,
-0.475686729,
-0.088724196,
0.6588932872,
-0.120862402,
-0.6287739277,
0.2217853516,
0.681761682,
-0.347661376,
-0.0464821719,
-0.4628152251,
0.1537482142,
-0.182415992,
-0.028542934,
0.0328857265,
0.5880143642,
0.2178784609,
0.398247838,
0.3093770742,
0.2036943585,
0.1632151902,
0.0923931375,
0.8345478773,
-0.5234052539,
-0.6670220494,
-0.7407522798,
0.3897275925,
-0.1970105767,
0.1029861197,
1.1022729874,
0.5215021968,
0.9084261656,
-0.3100875318,
1.2054100037,
-0.3446517587,
0.8407908678,
-0.5350402594,
0.6109919548,
-0.5267596841,
0.3702686429,
-0.2910054326,
-0.6793404818,
-0.191324845,
0.6435493827,
-0.6057597399,
0.1450588852,
0.5124290586,
0.6379640698,
-0.2157625109,
0.4023039937,
0.3256444633,
-0.1402196735,
0.2743926644,
0.1841500551,
1.089856267,
-0.1886977702,
-0.424749881,
-0.3520888686,
-0.3782443404,
-0.1062490121,
-0.6212751269,
-0.5060600042,
-0.7142062187,
-0.3026789129,
-0.1357119232,
0.0112304809,
0.6982905865,
0.9142819643,
-0.9222946167,
-0.3093437552,
0.1238563061,
0.4944240451,
-0.9694881439,
-0.319527626,
0.1118105352,
-0.0376503207,
0.0049335943,
0.7767718434,
0.2040939778,
-0.406508863,
-0.2125999629,
0.0668864399,
-0.6607138515,
-0.009003981,
0.8162302375,
0.5314797163,
-0.4689759314,
0.0512985773,
-0.1321534067,
0.2031918317,
-0.069934465,
0.9515736103,
-0.2725504339,
0.654499352,
0.2710660696,
0.9180064201,
0.34811607,
-0.1684411615,
0.4189313054,
-0.8492801189,
-0.3196977377,
0.0538693257,
0.4521591663,
0.3675030768,
-0.608324945,
0.4178960323,
0.2821277678,
-0.5160854459,
-0.4076158404,
0.322725445,
-0.5895941257,
-0.7068961859,
0.7713910341,
-0.2507306635,
-0.1689447016,
-0.2326361686,
0.1993129998,
0.0611146353,
-0.216202721,
0.8785900474,
0.9019340873,
-0.4324814677,
-0.1399895102,
-0.672363162,
0.3804920316,
0.1633418649,
-0.9686464071,
0.2281310111,
0.714802146,
0.6570290923,
0.3578574955,
0.0173244365,
0.0883295685,
0.2533434629,
-0.0165812615,
0.0640667006,
-0.0408825204,
-0.8005306721,
0.7533620596,
0.302533716,
0.2704441845,
-0.2560161352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00522v1
|
DAM: A Universal Dual Attention Mechanism for Multimodal Timeseries Cryptocurrency Trend Forecasting
| 2024-05-01T13:58:01 | 2024-05-01T13:58:01 |
Yihang Fu, Mingyu Zhou, Luyao Zhang
|
econ.GN
|
econ.GN, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.CR, q-fin.CP, q-fin.EC
|
In the distributed systems landscape, Blockchain has catalyzed the rise of
cryptocurrencies, merging enhanced security and decentralization with
significant investment opportunities. Despite their potential, current research
on cryptocurrency trend forecasting often falls short by simplistically merging
sentiment data without fully considering the nuanced interplay between
financial market dynamics and external sentiment influences. This paper
presents a novel Dual Attention Mechanism (DAM) for forecasting cryptocurrency
trends using multimodal time-series data. Our approach, which integrates
critical cryptocurrency metrics with sentiment data from news and social media
analyzed through CryptoBERT, addresses the inherent volatility and prediction
challenges in cryptocurrency markets. By combining elements of distributed
systems, natural language processing, and financial forecasting, our method
outperforms conventional models like LSTM and Transformer by up to 20\% in
prediction accuracy. This advancement deepens the understanding of distributed
systems and has practical implications in financial markets, benefiting
stakeholders in cryptocurrency and blockchain technologies. Moreover, our
enhanced forecasting approach can significantly support decentralized science
(DeSci) by facilitating strategic planning and the efficient adoption of
blockchain technologies, improving operational efficiency and financial risk
management in the rapidly evolving digital asset domain, thus ensuring optimal
resource allocation.
|
[
-0.4356935322,
-0.6245701909,
0.0538369939,
0.5333724618,
-0.8698066473,
0.4881500006,
-0.0757651627,
-0.3987568617,
0.5097514391,
0.38574031,
-0.8277631998,
-0.50088346,
-0.4407583475,
-0.2866539359,
-0.4099549949,
1.2313050032,
0.1051141694,
0.1353207976,
-0.0556886047,
0.1370211244,
-0.1578111053,
-0.2820318341,
-0.587331295,
-0.185629338,
0.6010489464,
0.2791292667,
0.5593825579,
0.5114686489,
0.9801447988,
0.2390564084,
0.4660601914,
0.3234548569,
-0.1542789489,
0.4453965425,
0.1531490684,
0.1671183407,
-0.4265522063,
-0.1111202538,
0.3981975615,
0.2839682698,
-0.2842280865,
0.2353273332,
0.0076528457,
0.5013646483,
-0.71765697,
0.3895941675,
-0.3834790587,
0.2260316908,
-0.2920131385,
-0.6014595032,
-0.1282485723,
0.0263784248,
0.2427188158,
-0.4507177472,
0.2145134807,
0.2460657656,
0.3426223695,
0.2930497527,
-0.4917950332,
-0.0159858894,
-0.5756788254,
0.7918309569,
-0.333907485,
0.2696436048,
-0.0712687597,
0.3175566494,
0.2187719047,
-0.7478656769,
-0.364173919,
0.0328562744,
0.1190265268,
0.2548973262,
-0.212925151,
-0.1951136589,
0.0746737123,
0.3500693142,
-0.1864796877,
-0.2954726219,
-0.5144505501,
-0.3512901366,
0.4343383014,
0.396301806,
0.0393914878,
-0.2022039294,
-0.9383205175,
-0.1939832568,
-0.1137580127,
0.0477465093,
0.3931082189,
0.62588346,
-0.5552327633,
0.2999740839,
-0.0813157335,
0.2581750453,
0.2087795287,
-0.2234306484,
0.1967297345,
-0.5895752907,
-0.0129474457,
0.5522136688,
0.8554014564,
0.7353417277,
-0.0353418365,
-0.1582352519,
-0.1196637824,
0.1689907908,
0.4014644325,
-0.8071576953,
0.0847527906,
0.344920218,
-0.1470815986,
-0.6164202094,
0.2485194355,
-1.4728223085,
-0.5955144763,
-0.4556652606,
0.1153158545,
0.0380776674,
-0.5732960701,
-0.043793194,
-0.573805809,
-0.1500230432,
0.0724976212,
-0.9128493071,
0.5284047127,
0.775811553,
1.0723676682,
-0.1429134756,
0.0079290764,
-0.6391968727,
0.2761812508,
-0.1655039042,
0.6244005561,
-0.2013260275,
-0.3691434562,
0.012632614,
-0.2447352409,
0.1970315874,
0.0230120681,
0.1513199955,
-0.7150120735,
-0.039010264,
0.0786691681,
0.2193149775,
-0.0542386472,
0.3667843342,
-0.7006739974,
0.6689338684,
-0.1275719404,
-1.52483356,
0.2779170871,
-0.8777074218,
-0.5216001272,
-0.1449303627,
0.279904902,
-0.5341140032,
-0.4355240762,
0.4531318843,
0.3614807725,
-0.4535462558,
0.5091666579,
-0.9055294394,
-0.0747377425,
0.5677545071,
-0.6512714028,
0.472464025,
0.0015988302,
-0.7109912634,
0.4891705811,
-0.8559561372,
-0.0485767275,
-0.0070437402,
0.4520268738,
-0.4015576541,
-0.0450094156,
0.5393331647,
0.3618648052,
0.6056272984,
-0.3285486996,
0.2253011912,
-0.3786545098,
0.9315468669,
1.1191542149,
0.3224042952,
0.3368043005,
-0.0205371454,
0.3218671083,
0.3100951314,
0.5868626833,
0.0448870547,
-0.018895112,
-0.3970859647,
-0.4487775564,
0.0426366851,
0.5623743534,
-0.1115932241,
0.0083718766,
-0.3105246425,
-0.3583438098,
-0.4843582213,
-0.0039623911,
-0.1618201286,
0.1541430652,
0.3074026406,
-0.248490423,
-0.8881223798,
-0.7934013009,
0.0882044062,
0.1067158282,
0.2247299254,
0.0815917775,
0.2736884356,
-0.4271162152,
0.6283798814,
-0.2567783594,
-0.1603924185,
0.0419295952,
0.367223531,
0.2013604641,
-0.0335543193,
0.1040263772,
-1.1098046303,
-0.2642225921,
0.2155742496,
-0.4398199916,
0.3835479915,
-0.0235508177,
-0.0837535337,
0.0497655049,
0.1468947381,
-0.4672887027,
0.2626515031,
0.6287615895,
-0.3277723193,
0.4309600592,
-0.2613936663,
0.2802107036,
-1.2788724899,
-0.0342710689,
0.0412636064,
-0.1415299326,
-0.2798780799,
-0.1330383718,
0.2200492322,
-0.2316351086,
-0.100159876,
0.4723395109,
-0.3213855326,
0.0009107186,
-0.3485078216,
0.4628593922,
-0.1895555705,
0.3580953777,
-0.2211470455,
0.5540611148,
1.106595397,
-0.6339420676,
1.0083851814,
-0.3294246495,
-0.2112537771,
0.4363729656,
-0.6595538259,
0.1594687104,
0.0257124919,
-0.2014086545,
-1.1232001781,
-0.1008661464,
0.574706614,
-0.304744035,
0.424982816,
0.4053935707,
-0.3928018808,
-0.7925750613,
-0.7193579078,
0.245872885,
-0.0234090537,
-0.3304559588,
0.5570361614,
0.3329322338,
-0.1664684713,
-1.1881184578,
-0.4965174496,
0.0681845471,
-0.4336698949,
-0.5672969818,
0.2817746699,
-0.3479470909,
-0.5595846176,
-0.039237354,
-0.3239423931,
0.2957408428,
0.0555241741,
0.6965097189,
0.9052789211,
0.1017392278,
-0.0214692391,
-0.0251986124,
-0.4082793891,
0.0862219855,
-0.7441262007,
0.5417215228,
0.0493744239,
-0.0689717904,
-0.7730259895,
0.3195461333,
1.0798674822,
-0.2914287746,
0.765694797,
0.5360177159,
-0.0524355471,
-0.0498898402,
-0.4663773477,
-0.335313201,
-0.4555003941,
0.0970908701,
-0.1745779067,
-0.7865480185,
0.5726982355,
0.2327063233,
0.0732263103,
0.4297237992,
0.80859828,
0.3172152638,
1.3717359304,
0.7520893216,
-0.3757940233,
0.5969051123,
-0.2916309834,
0.4170659482,
-0.7768079638,
-0.2632459402,
-0.1352721602,
-0.5101821423,
-0.7970355749,
-0.2908580899,
0.2680798769,
-0.18335931,
-0.2806373239,
0.1903213561,
-0.5326330662,
-0.3402170539,
0.5889178514,
0.1435554028,
0.4314751625,
0.3256311417,
-0.1680305451,
-0.0994419307,
-0.2207878828,
0.0467449799,
1.4473081827,
0.1313788891,
0.8113526106,
-0.4614749551,
0.4169011414,
0.7702692747,
0.5387914181,
-0.6221058965,
0.0002942054,
0.0430569053,
-0.5087916851,
-0.3150125146,
-0.3150707185,
-0.464535594,
0.2456896156,
0.1366875917,
-0.253262192,
0.3583515584,
-0.1737442166,
-0.4261378944,
0.2769289613,
-0.1432459205,
0.9508325458,
-0.0852849334,
-0.5126358271,
-0.7626846433,
-0.4901789129,
0.1879604757,
-0.0434635803,
0.6590362191,
-0.2382493168,
-0.5516178012,
0.4545072615,
-0.1782856882,
0.7701342106,
-0.0207720269,
0.0124738524,
0.1281881034,
-0.509949863,
0.6976546645,
0.5511245728,
0.2091661394,
0.1964497417,
-0.3275073469,
-0.3817383647,
-0.2759875059,
1.0999381542,
-0.8937144876,
-0.4392632842,
-0.5144693851,
-0.6530004144,
-0.0531594418,
0.0868805498,
0.1508406997,
0.5571121573,
-0.2208723426,
-0.0771905407,
0.174222365,
0.8287937641,
0.6730981469,
0.5827142,
0.1478397399,
-1.1108253002,
0.6919438243,
-0.1451038718,
0.0312650278,
0.7163242102,
0.1531261057,
-0.4484014809,
-0.2273609936,
-0.2794944644,
0.2520903647,
-0.523707211,
-0.2283881754,
-0.8267156482,
0.1891192794,
-0.9061781168,
0.1359822154,
-0.3097679019,
-0.2617813945,
-0.0759989321,
-0.2374467254,
0.396328032,
0.1550560147,
-0.3438683748,
-0.0947799832,
-0.6096491218,
0.6971647739,
0.6302160621,
0.210387975,
0.0888312683,
-0.2498652041,
-0.2220518291,
0.2992753983,
-0.4504233897,
-0.8110016584,
0.4970888197,
-0.1972049326,
0.1652609408,
1.0370447636,
0.202333048,
0.7963896394,
-0.2202815264,
0.2591643929,
0.6736938357,
-0.8333308697,
0.6113857627,
-0.2278378308,
-0.0802372545,
0.0554317348,
0.2971442342,
-0.9080759883,
-0.6604421735,
-0.5078716874,
-0.8207514882,
0.826764524,
-0.1750500798,
0.1283245236,
-0.0737116709,
-0.1835337132,
0.2341865003,
0.707445085,
-0.6818190813,
-0.5693794489,
-0.7543390989,
-0.1498218477,
-0.0411453322,
-0.2182871103,
-0.2438094169,
-0.1157143936,
0.6864637136,
-0.1127169654,
0.0006929553,
0.1081980988,
0.4033675194,
-0.5850622058,
0.3806142509,
0.370719403,
0.6918190718,
-0.2778453529,
0.0886344686,
-0.1903981268,
-0.3932494223,
-0.0084699569,
0.5275873542,
-0.3217799067,
-0.1413038522,
0.1143983006,
0.9068582058,
0.6002485156,
-0.6638689041,
0.439222157,
-0.1547306031,
-0.1109720767,
-0.4810503125,
-0.3097605407,
0.0165099408,
0.5740715265,
0.6341581941,
0.6311117411,
0.3592921793,
-0.6280373335,
0.1105447337,
0.5196400285,
-0.7273368835,
-0.5434067845,
0.9597228765,
-0.0129689984,
0.0521950722,
0.4796627164,
0.1501822323,
-0.2823044658,
0.7123768926,
0.4060927927,
1.0272125006,
-0.3569296002,
0.2140257806,
0.5034408569,
0.148456499,
-0.1965112984,
0.1735085398,
-0.3543664813,
-0.5107558966,
-0.4668726027,
-0.5845515728,
0.0092583783,
-0.1574354023,
-0.6304605007,
0.5599691868,
-0.6215591431,
-0.5715353489,
0.3507764935,
0.2464176863,
-0.4824355245,
0.0925743356,
0.4218071699,
0.4788022339,
-0.4424197078,
0.5195063949,
0.6780457497,
-0.1329669654,
-0.1266006827,
-0.1109902486,
0.0034282373,
-0.7392778397,
0.5638509393,
0.3699780703,
-0.1409652978,
-0.0487181544,
-0.4844144285,
-0.7826567292,
0.9846419692,
0.0766804144,
-0.7539567351,
-0.1294039041,
-0.0891928449,
0.3050045967,
-0.500837028,
0.1151824668,
0.0738446787,
0.8865289688,
0.0508972295,
-0.5406534672,
-0.1026242748,
-0.4612240791,
-0.200087443,
0.7984306812,
-0.8173663616,
0.5879086852,
-0.7512527704,
-0.476932317,
-0.177795127,
0.7432436943,
-0.0134606566,
0.8252385259,
0.6122009754,
0.4387030602,
0.5208877921,
-0.088979207,
0.8814589977,
-0.6998153925,
0.6166223884,
0.5041869283,
-0.0220309701,
0.6175432801,
0.797516048,
-0.3830053806,
0.770149827,
0.6142756343,
0.0186207071,
1.054489255,
-0.1340068728,
-0.2342224568,
-0.6305041313,
-0.3084458709,
-0.5810163021,
0.1394171417,
0.2056003809,
-0.0412555933,
0.0320679024,
0.3471569121,
-0.3729479611,
-0.1601762027,
-0.5488708615,
0.4855998456,
0.1651707888,
-0.4219519794,
0.0414363183,
0.0603608415,
0.8739554882,
-0.7292101383,
0.34777987,
0.0014593672,
0.4268749654,
0.0969640017,
-0.2782177627,
-0.0037884379,
-0.3137894571,
-0.533705771,
-0.3461276293,
0.4115751088,
-0.3243627846,
-0.6195008755,
0.5713312626,
-0.1127287671,
-0.5594658256,
-0.3542128503,
-0.6795818806,
-0.282356292,
-0.1993181109,
-0.0764125362,
0.2778141797,
0.5694895983,
0.0662843585,
0.8058304191,
0.7263284922,
-0.0794200152,
-0.1436735094,
0.2631947398,
0.8225976825,
-0.7890006304,
-1.0009592772,
-0.8375605941,
0.4217579067,
-0.2670009136,
-0.0019773797,
0.6464282274,
0.4320057333,
0.4765577316,
0.0547206029,
0.7212427855,
0.2105083168,
0.3664563,
0.0647581741,
0.2108935416,
-0.586623013,
-0.0561267994,
-0.0162150506,
-0.5688476562,
0.0697455332,
-0.1029705256,
-0.3943953812,
-0.2478065938,
0.666529417,
0.4733483195,
-0.0762757063,
0.1485529542,
-0.0127359442,
-0.0239358954,
-0.1325419247,
0.3275917172,
0.5536872149,
-0.3512527943,
0.8086273074,
-0.8316478133,
-0.0143663399,
-0.5512208939,
-0.6241848469,
-0.8748132586,
-0.3873645365,
-0.3475880325,
-0.0638577566,
0.04743734,
0.7500440478,
0.5686616898,
-1.1268019676,
-0.1539817154,
0.0777501911,
0.2167582512,
-0.7737968564,
-0.3759199381,
0.4588650465,
-0.3073775172,
-0.7573376298,
-0.0199652575,
0.8607996702,
-0.0850956291,
-0.5913428068,
0.0753095374,
0.2732907534,
-0.1759682596,
0.2451578677,
-0.3112249672,
-0.571914494,
0.106873937,
0.3361540735,
-0.323312968,
0.0574631095,
1.2351080179,
-0.4328369498,
0.5386924148,
0.4917454422,
0.0288397744,
0.5466425419,
0.029870322,
0.3351919949,
-0.4101809859,
0.4434162676,
-0.012824147,
0.1880078912,
0.3880873919,
-0.5192835331,
-0.0910785198,
0.6382715702,
-0.2708745003,
-0.6535295248,
-0.2765751183,
-1.0753650665,
-0.1173478961,
0.4543997943,
0.3117837906,
-0.3335694373,
-0.0709704384,
-0.0231074858,
0.4987743795,
-0.7825161219,
1.1200150251,
0.6489986181,
0.3852728605,
-0.2909831703,
-0.7521507144,
0.1157235578,
-0.0861741155,
-0.3687423766,
0.2892361879,
0.2283933014,
0.0832872763,
0.4632376134,
0.3841083944,
-0.1340148747,
0.5839804411,
0.0694260523,
0.0080459816,
-0.3380760252,
-0.4333760738,
0.1470798403,
0.5039840937,
-0.4334780574,
-0.3242004514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00516v1
|
Navigating WebAI: Training Agents to Complete Web Tasks with Large Language Models and Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-05-01T13:51:45 | 2024-05-01T13:51:45 |
Lucas-Andreï Thil, Mirela Popa, Gerasimos Spanakis
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, 68T07, I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.1
|
Recent advancements in language models have demonstrated remarkable
improvements in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks such as web
navigation. Supervised learning (SL) approaches have achieved impressive
performance while utilizing significantly less training data compared to
previous methods. However, these SL-based models fall short when compared to
reinforcement learning (RL) approaches, which have shown superior results. In
this paper, we propose a novel approach that combines SL and RL techniques over
the MiniWoB benchmark to leverage the strengths of both methods. We also
address a critical limitation in previous models' understanding of HTML
content, revealing a tendency to memorize target elements rather than
comprehend the underlying structure. To rectify this, we propose methods to
enhance true understanding and present a new baseline of results. Our
experiments demonstrate that our approach outperforms previous SL methods on
certain tasks using less data and narrows the performance gap with RL models,
achieving 43.58\% average accuracy in SL and 36.69\% when combined with a
multimodal RL approach. This study sets a new direction for future web
navigation and offers insights into the limitations and potential of language
modeling for computer tasks.
|
[
-0.4428010881,
-0.8007635474,
0.3780885041,
0.021104373,
-0.0580264889,
0.2779276669,
-0.2482065558,
-0.4143667817,
-0.0762753785,
0.1809163541,
-0.8941763043,
-0.5725589395,
-0.420363009,
-0.070863314,
-0.2202486247,
0.9149094224,
0.1771028787,
0.0112911826,
-0.4745222926,
-0.1169750243,
-0.274509877,
-0.3196602464,
-0.9407019615,
-0.5864312649,
0.8112425804,
0.291138351,
0.763712585,
0.6835597754,
0.3655750453,
0.3173075318,
0.1062371656,
0.4595431685,
-0.3865684271,
-0.0288240686,
-0.3913770318,
-0.5358219147,
-0.4117279649,
0.0127878292,
0.3226607442,
0.8034462929,
-0.25369066,
-0.0205902513,
-0.1125364751,
0.7992714643,
-0.789568007,
0.3116606474,
-0.3611832559,
0.113959305,
0.0787392259,
-0.2641809881,
-0.719483912,
0.0009464601,
0.2983709276,
-1.0999034643,
0.2469713986,
0.2249836326,
0.8080139756,
0.4148766994,
-0.7834106088,
-0.4033917487,
-0.5630404949,
0.9852392077,
-0.612944603,
0.7304720283,
0.5887129307,
0.4494722784,
-0.0886615291,
-0.7401130199,
-0.3861523867,
-0.3678043783,
-0.0515101254,
0.0358324833,
-0.329169482,
0.02303515,
0.1999686956,
-0.2773140669,
-0.8552973866,
0.2968717217,
-0.1130203232,
-0.2021884024,
0.7480250001,
0.1749035716,
0.3780064881,
0.0113810739,
-0.4293180108,
-0.6699156761,
-0.3693993986,
0.2888936996,
0.1132479087,
0.6174374819,
-0.1528939903,
0.138270244,
-0.4064365029,
0.6967983246,
0.0526139699,
-0.6307875514,
0.3636304736,
-0.2179711759,
-0.0623333864,
-0.2559847236,
0.6000159383,
0.3863111734,
0.2596435547,
-0.2895586491,
-0.3018583059,
0.0525502786,
0.55180794,
-0.3826393783,
-0.4034901261,
0.0084803747,
-0.5696178675,
-0.0200965237,
-0.0053035044,
-0.6863064766,
-0.3841473758,
-0.3076322079,
0.2848642468,
-0.4490866363,
-0.2930231392,
-0.2224958539,
-0.2304181159,
0.3369092345,
0.5630714297,
-0.9051840901,
0.5129543543,
0.6356296539,
0.6662374139,
-0.5059148073,
-0.4504878521,
-0.6725947261,
0.2542354167,
-0.3242822289,
0.6578810811,
-0.4666475654,
-0.265052706,
0.2164534628,
-0.2954155803,
-0.1475772709,
-0.3806402981,
0.172559008,
-0.741145432,
-0.1345287114,
0.1568481326,
-0.3898952007,
-0.5545679331,
0.4649740756,
-0.8662636876,
0.683621645,
-0.18657583,
-0.4052916169,
0.2420647442,
-0.5491794944,
-0.7170728445,
-0.1176542267,
0.0403245129,
-0.3231666684,
-0.1070959195,
0.5149611235,
0.3731816411,
-0.0716818273,
-0.0795913413,
-0.1014743149,
-0.1798376888,
0.2841376364,
-0.4257558584,
0.5435571074,
0.1362264901,
-0.2074404657,
0.1773924828,
-0.8354019523,
0.2372698933,
0.2056782991,
-0.5340855122,
-0.5887988806,
0.0673434287,
0.2151441723,
0.2298305631,
0.3005257547,
-0.156838879,
0.2883395851,
-0.2345579565,
0.0281124506,
0.7292714119,
-0.0737364739,
0.6766124964,
-0.2925939262,
0.6978988051,
-0.0713075995,
0.3672341704,
0.0279555377,
-0.4367881715,
-1.0295470953,
0.2571443915,
0.3267539442,
0.5244851708,
-1.30262959,
-0.2602023184,
-0.4081876874,
-0.5726298094,
-0.4915482104,
0.2691108584,
0.848572731,
0.1717456877,
0.7474873066,
-0.3005029261,
-0.5190497637,
-0.648660779,
-0.2374519259,
-0.3373613656,
0.1102066338,
0.2811697721,
0.4898884594,
-0.5292675495,
0.8422489166,
-0.4488831758,
-0.3764156401,
-0.6822118163,
0.4380513132,
-0.1469198912,
0.5354366302,
0.0920887515,
-1.257864356,
-0.6326266527,
0.1731945574,
-0.7053488493,
0.200584203,
-0.2565138042,
0.2608350515,
0.1470989138,
0.5368563533,
-0.4399824739,
0.5029070377,
0.445928514,
-0.0671467632,
0.3262788355,
-0.3236727118,
-0.0541775376,
-0.4889618456,
-0.2890115678,
0.5157229304,
-0.5631901026,
-0.886154592,
0.5418986082,
0.1962517202,
0.0819721296,
-0.5988870263,
0.6414510012,
-0.6968938112,
-0.1062331274,
-0.5378290415,
0.322432667,
-0.117204003,
0.9902150631,
-0.0807781145,
0.7846155763,
0.2825942338,
-0.9424874187,
0.5048260093,
0.278546989,
0.1402389854,
0.3838235438,
-0.3153703213,
0.0898591429,
-0.1406901181,
0.285295099,
-0.6894812584,
-0.0949365869,
-0.0662689731,
-0.6823931336,
0.3118716776,
-0.1827742159,
-0.3731404543,
-0.2002422959,
-0.1755750775,
0.2566855848,
0.5318049192,
-0.4610358775,
0.8939182162,
0.336220324,
0.0491405353,
-0.4983903766,
-0.624694109,
-0.0076742847,
-0.1001860723,
-0.4078436196,
0.3954896331,
0.0557787269,
-0.3292609751,
-0.2297999263,
-0.074118562,
-0.3180487454,
0.2828589976,
0.2995815277,
0.09201096,
-0.1246783212,
0.1357946098,
-0.1676337272,
-0.3677574098,
-0.1729604751,
-0.2571521103,
0.6040992737,
-0.1122925952,
-0.4368619919,
-0.8284966946,
0.1903166026,
0.1674285829,
-0.2921724916,
0.6245970726,
0.6275722384,
-0.1741552502,
-0.2827442884,
-0.487180233,
-0.131997034,
-0.4831790626,
0.2546471655,
-0.425216496,
-0.5853248835,
0.1330090165,
-0.3039371669,
0.0848029107,
0.2491214871,
0.1778806448,
-0.5161159039,
1.2927423716,
1.1438374519,
-0.1496368051,
0.5956261158,
-0.3473336399,
-0.0436871275,
-0.5941252112,
-0.4115042686,
-0.3586314321,
-0.2862767279,
-0.7420174479,
-0.4747660458,
0.3795642555,
-0.0646770373,
0.0333101265,
0.3674127162,
0.0730416849,
0.18392694,
0.8613117337,
0.2397869676,
0.446016252,
-0.0875846297,
-0.3814305365,
0.223967433,
-0.937949717,
-0.2596028149,
1.1432670355,
0.2418267876,
1.0596581697,
0.2651215196,
0.6074202061,
0.6407280564,
-0.0786224306,
-0.4975615442,
0.6962003708,
0.0672628358,
-0.2640469968,
-0.5392641425,
-0.3226179481,
-1.1056580544,
0.5084403753,
-0.235384658,
-0.6074470282,
-0.0516379774,
0.1581375003,
-0.2834812999,
0.0451179743,
-0.6660001874,
0.7855547667,
-0.3547841907,
-0.5162017941,
-0.4964257479,
-0.8383018374,
0.0321905091,
0.3961187601,
0.4988466799,
0.2203037292,
-0.2367998064,
0.5707494617,
-0.2849195004,
0.8677045107,
-0.1986400783,
0.088383317,
-0.0597721264,
-0.0124458009,
0.7141053677,
-0.3072499037,
0.2639176548,
-0.2954317629,
-0.2648105621,
-0.5707381964,
-0.7510524988,
0.5001602769,
-0.7640048862,
-0.5113409162,
-0.6269154549,
-0.5186827183,
-0.4847437143,
-0.0291011743,
-0.201084584,
0.3813571632,
-0.1079387292,
0.0371336564,
0.853562355,
-0.237265721,
0.6457394958,
0.7510699034,
-0.3452743888,
-0.149949789,
1.0738116503,
-0.2385771275,
0.227368921,
0.7072333694,
-0.0318786204,
-0.4846799076,
-0.7516612411,
-0.5193740129,
0.1359314471,
-0.7831317782,
0.0063397507,
-0.5960996747,
-0.0874031186,
-0.5122938156,
-0.0170126092,
-0.2803310454,
-0.1046676263,
-0.2463539541,
-0.0106247673,
0.0258106645,
0.7286849618,
-0.1197000965,
0.443374157,
-0.7695158124,
0.4188278913,
0.5390942097,
-0.1550938785,
0.487118721,
-0.1069361046,
-0.5262136459,
0.0655891448,
-0.3095601201,
-0.8212919235,
0.4938234091,
0.0455510169,
0.8778963685,
0.4646696746,
0.010913942,
0.9281057119,
-0.4540738463,
0.6789902449,
0.3105885684,
-0.7248746753,
0.7280791402,
-0.2737115622,
0.4606553018,
0.5677015185,
0.588463068,
-0.4999610484,
-0.1674376279,
-0.5527142882,
-0.7296379805,
0.5382526517,
0.1220260933,
-0.2557837069,
0.2340863347,
0.0123574529,
-0.1120907813,
0.1203154027,
-0.9366779923,
-0.2736489177,
0.004859623,
-0.1214455813,
-0.2402834296,
0.0643479824,
0.1570177823,
-0.1700133532,
1.001794219,
-0.4517230988,
0.0260045938,
-0.0134205529,
-0.873752594,
0.1390006542,
0.1063516065,
0.4165197611,
0.8514614105,
0.0499970242,
0.0805429816,
0.2624286115,
-0.2039569467,
0.2136757076,
0.002563484,
-0.2657108307,
-0.2123113275,
0.6811290383,
0.864908874,
0.3338669837,
-1.0071729422,
0.5988691449,
-0.1382903904,
0.1452496499,
-0.3196302652,
0.2687261701,
0.059660513,
0.4866322577,
0.5564066172,
-0.1334813684,
0.2194710374,
-0.7517390251,
0.2404982746,
0.4406650364,
-0.5769649148,
0.0159079954,
0.5141586661,
0.2926906943,
-0.4205425978,
0.6018946171,
-0.3413367867,
-0.4286275804,
0.5951544046,
0.4682317674,
0.5860549808,
-0.0588761121,
0.3753070235,
0.227605328,
0.2754224539,
-0.0629752055,
-0.0581475124,
-0.2766409516,
-0.5014861226,
-0.3902807534,
-0.4997630417,
-0.5022472739,
-0.2127178162,
-0.9317052364,
-0.2694513202,
-0.4822833538,
-0.1349820048,
-0.1573472321,
0.2328492552,
-0.7456910014,
0.5836655498,
0.1778766066,
0.8308748007,
-0.7556478977,
1.098585248,
0.7709944248,
-0.7735625505,
-0.6486024857,
0.2244084924,
0.173136279,
-0.5726217628,
0.669120729,
0.1856004894,
-0.2883710563,
0.0496535227,
-0.3537318707,
-0.6654495597,
1.1634354591,
-0.3432442844,
-0.5292206407,
-0.3779346049,
-0.0109090628,
0.5569730997,
-0.2218506187,
0.2713213861,
0.5249941945,
0.3991729915,
-0.0662961453,
-0.9530389905,
-0.0614826865,
-0.3173246384,
0.2461208254,
-0.0609236844,
-0.7283449769,
0.8846365213,
-0.2345814705,
-0.2494171262,
0.1544127762,
0.9390622973,
0.1116556898,
0.5723411441,
0.7164801955,
0.5150141716,
0.7422138453,
0.0683540106,
0.9924772978,
0.1802319735,
0.2686312795,
1.139103651,
-0.138141647,
0.9777433276,
0.51165241,
-0.2403985262,
0.8068674207,
0.4940873981,
0.1878074557,
0.7892302871,
0.0790313706,
-0.1260019541,
-0.5931531787,
-0.2050418258,
-0.0240469333,
0.5554693341,
0.3335138857,
0.0248970054,
-0.3288477957,
0.5901049972,
-0.1273269653,
0.5729609728,
-0.4872555137,
1.1645661592,
0.0011836295,
-0.782984972,
0.3546615839,
0.3060271144,
0.8113928437,
-0.8780679107,
-0.1795432866,
-0.2774807513,
0.1729004979,
0.0244303457,
-0.3118360937,
-0.151552707,
0.0792411268,
-0.1288540959,
-0.5328937173,
0.6650366783,
-0.1478260905,
-0.2712354064,
0.5256819129,
0.7138400674,
0.0399443805,
0.0963491872,
-0.7557244301,
0.0323943496,
0.1661837399,
0.0365523547,
0.6077575088,
0.0694313422,
-0.0964668095,
1.4114049673,
0.806327641,
-0.1955628842,
0.3398337066,
0.0201272294,
0.7548104525,
-0.762534678,
-0.8056185842,
-0.7190357447,
0.2777527273,
-0.196287632,
-0.1044713706,
0.7924398184,
0.5886817575,
1.0591546297,
0.0125873843,
0.8525176048,
0.2165880948,
0.5049405098,
-0.8318294287,
0.5991225243,
-0.849601984,
-0.1053818986,
-0.2050803304,
-0.489606142,
-0.0116551928,
0.736911118,
-0.0506490394,
0.0550711751,
0.804349184,
0.6709221005,
-0.0726666451,
-0.0882743374,
0.4459911287,
-0.0008006498,
0.4048189521,
0.8902024627,
0.7901819348,
-0.3668302596,
0.746657908,
-0.4347460568,
-0.1260297298,
-0.3855983615,
-0.6497502327,
-1.0032691956,
-0.6768860221,
-0.1911254227,
-0.15451473,
0.4610716999,
1.0249329805,
0.9944236875,
-0.6383735538,
-0.3754028082,
-0.0206106119,
0.328707397,
-0.701588273,
-0.1460845172,
0.1218494251,
-0.464815557,
-0.8746775389,
0.7492324114,
0.1103984192,
0.1707442254,
-0.5900406241,
-0.4048552513,
-0.7085858583,
-0.1110325679,
0.4122384489,
0.4647566378,
-0.9311176538,
0.0125887627,
-0.2484097034,
-0.2980778217,
-0.0012882934,
0.7281826735,
-1.1784198284,
0.2918277979,
0.3065476716,
0.8388351202,
0.9347353578,
0.1150405779,
0.4703633487,
-0.7319139838,
0.2443867922,
0.2298884988,
0.1279191375,
0.354385972,
-0.0385642946,
0.5427408814,
0.0999526083,
-0.1136384234,
-0.5323600173,
0.3005313873,
-1.0514981747,
-0.5674469471,
1.1167712212,
-0.1913087517,
-0.2693325579,
-0.2013194114,
0.1194146425,
0.3958825767,
-0.4383275509,
0.5284696817,
0.4023157358,
-0.219631955,
-0.3636080921,
-0.8288817406,
0.4138610661,
0.2124455124,
-0.8708810806,
-0.3814637065,
0.4937319458,
0.0437797979,
0.2793776095,
0.6235796809,
0.6582983136,
0.4780263305,
0.1396271586,
0.0243507642,
-0.1173245758,
-0.7953144312,
-0.1297582239,
0.2564920485,
0.0074075465,
-0.3132233024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00494v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00494v1
|
GOLD: Geometry Problem Solver with Natural Language Description
| 2024-05-01T13:00:51 | 2024-05-01T13:00:51 |
Jiaxin Zhang, Yashar Moshfeghi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Addressing the challenge of automated geometry math problem-solving in
artificial intelligence (AI) involves understanding multi-modal information and
mathematics. Current methods struggle with accurately interpreting geometry
diagrams, which hinders effective problem-solving. To tackle this issue, we
present the Geometry problem sOlver with natural Language Description (GOLD)
model. GOLD enhances the extraction of geometric relations by separately
processing symbols and geometric primitives within the diagram. Subsequently,
it converts the extracted relations into natural language descriptions,
efficiently utilizing large language models to solve geometry math problems.
Experiments show that the GOLD model outperforms the Geoformer model, the
previous best method on the UniGeo dataset, by achieving accuracy improvements
of 12.7% and 42.1% in calculation and proving subsets. Additionally, it
surpasses the former best model on the PGPS9K and Geometry3K datasets, PGPSNet,
by obtaining accuracy enhancements of 1.8% and 3.2%, respectively.
|
[
-0.1189492568,
-1.0228840113,
0.4025928676,
0.2250714451,
-0.0508525483,
-0.1098426953,
-0.1196311861,
-0.4806183875,
-0.0313584283,
0.59172225,
-0.6952602863,
-0.4942363501,
-0.6728193164,
0.3550405204,
-0.3615522683,
1.0446041822,
-0.2506507039,
0.009796924,
-0.3150306642,
0.0943765193,
-0.3071512878,
-0.5565946102,
-0.6391165257,
-0.4457532465,
0.2089650631,
0.0681221411,
1.1382570267,
0.8102871776,
0.9972244501,
0.5119544268,
-0.2026840448,
0.3009485006,
-0.2276272476,
-0.5003715158,
0.1533558965,
-0.4199745357,
-0.6413763165,
-0.1514968574,
0.4538051486,
0.9564248323,
-0.0446784198,
0.1608432233,
-0.0409182683,
0.9855930805,
-0.4007197917,
0.8043075204,
-0.2630261183,
0.0529682115,
-0.0963058323,
-0.1842850596,
0.1057520658,
-0.6064376235,
0.3536566198,
-1.2988004684,
0.1969199777,
0.1085767224,
0.9495827556,
0.4807608724,
-0.1722991765,
-0.4650113881,
-1.0643402338,
0.738042593,
-0.5565447211,
0.1303990036,
0.5153409839,
0.6847108006,
-0.2018564939,
-0.5857436061,
-0.3806551695,
-0.1398565024,
-0.4393741488,
-0.0799516961,
-0.29094401,
0.2604955137,
0.1707334667,
0.9039019942,
-0.7419992685,
-0.4282307625,
-0.925160706,
-0.2622716129,
0.7497476339,
0.1538271159,
0.5593523383,
-0.407002151,
0.0895198211,
0.050370995,
-0.3046077192,
0.0599749461,
0.3854157031,
0.4388208091,
-0.0928691849,
0.7758834958,
-0.399713397,
0.9412195683,
-0.3042811453,
-0.1353612542,
0.2312986106,
-0.1161824018,
-0.3921281397,
-0.0077058249,
0.707362175,
0.0480470136,
0.5385731459,
-0.2845882475,
0.0321095958,
0.247616142,
-0.0059173997,
-0.5330010653,
-0.7128781676,
0.0786795244,
-0.4855413735,
-0.0222074427,
0.2150557041,
-0.5996129513,
-0.2204496413,
-0.714046061,
0.2764427662,
-0.4282829463,
-0.1838315278,
0.5800933242,
0.0361479297,
-0.1691555828,
0.1792178005,
-0.5368673801,
0.4625425935,
0.9225543141,
0.9396559,
0.2609733641,
-0.2267610431,
-0.6916408539,
0.2040276378,
-0.2107793093,
0.8845642805,
-0.4925502539,
-0.2878309786,
-0.2847076058,
0.0666621625,
-0.0259852279,
-0.582680583,
0.7878189683,
-0.1078111678,
0.5124509335,
-0.2817315757,
-0.5448792577,
-0.5344605446,
0.3964656293,
-1.1405981779,
1.0412101746,
0.2208635062,
-0.5734863281,
-0.0679821894,
-1.1419786215,
0.0198877789,
0.4090572894,
-0.0180195086,
-0.4146054685,
0.2156961709,
0.5434908867,
-0.0846512169,
0.0427338071,
0.2264718413,
-0.198583141,
-0.276843816,
0.0634536818,
-0.2236725986,
0.6822390556,
0.043503087,
0.0000661889,
0.2071730644,
-0.620229423,
-0.0291189253,
0.4399065375,
-0.1539011151,
-0.2181347609,
0.0223657899,
0.0111177685,
0.1930584908,
0.3679589629,
-0.5588697791,
0.1079609767,
-0.819879353,
0.318020463,
0.5235418677,
-0.2142063677,
0.5526682734,
-0.2574431896,
0.479488492,
-0.4589846134,
0.3061626852,
0.1530677825,
-0.5922653079,
-0.6191987991,
-0.2484644949,
0.151758641,
0.8152725101,
-0.5488533378,
0.4019175768,
-0.4274590611,
-0.3290305436,
-0.4043150544,
0.3049414754,
0.4195646346,
0.6134876609,
0.4185160697,
0.0517320558,
-0.5042676926,
-0.7855301499,
-0.58484447,
-0.1800248325,
-0.0909260437,
0.3325042725,
0.3698708415,
-0.0668100193,
1.1604347229,
-0.6899442673,
-0.6256236434,
-0.4389658272,
0.526630342,
0.215668723,
0.1133261025,
0.4070624113,
-0.8466765285,
-0.3673274815,
0.1839991361,
-0.9988662004,
-0.1868372411,
0.0978344902,
-0.3741261959,
0.196686998,
0.1185308471,
-0.580678165,
0.8108554482,
0.5534520149,
-0.4818655252,
0.4749445617,
-0.3514235914,
-0.0542171076,
-0.7815601826,
0.2539418042,
0.2505356669,
0.0559278131,
-0.3603561223,
-0.0365706421,
-0.1722092032,
-0.4340288341,
-0.2736808658,
0.5646039844,
-0.3888626099,
-0.2755750716,
-0.2521018684,
0.020053057,
0.2112208754,
0.3841285408,
0.0420452021,
0.6691204309,
0.5335816741,
-0.5178920627,
0.8877962828,
0.5602755547,
-0.0712791309,
0.41517362,
-0.9078815579,
-0.0942569971,
-0.3405750394,
0.2161057442,
-0.7212103009,
-0.2830824852,
0.2827267051,
-0.4140949845,
-0.2027340084,
-0.4323014021,
-0.7028760314,
-0.6365895271,
-0.0546526611,
0.4666061401,
0.0547261611,
-0.3567815721,
0.8127402067,
0.1380207539,
-0.4786945879,
-0.3014064729,
-0.4910512269,
0.1991245896,
-0.2628278136,
-0.8178335428,
0.3137662411,
-0.211637944,
-0.4051699042,
0.3113984466,
0.0555507801,
-0.1779057533,
-0.0651821271,
0.0561200082,
0.5321184397,
-0.0851139724,
0.0766539499,
-0.3250644803,
-0.7411874533,
0.3293185234,
-0.2515393496,
0.5534977913,
-0.5507777929,
-0.3510737419,
-0.7978682518,
0.4786242843,
0.3617958128,
-0.6858382225,
0.6513536572,
0.3723210096,
-0.7384436727,
0.4233764708,
-0.0654396713,
0.0366936401,
-0.4989594519,
0.5584962368,
-0.2924099267,
-0.4003884196,
0.4713032842,
-0.0282443333,
0.2980245352,
0.5968817472,
0.0705183074,
0.1786151975,
1.4319258928,
0.79072088,
-0.3148140609,
0.3223171532,
-0.4164401889,
0.6293488741,
-0.5610282421,
-0.4718783498,
-0.5382297039,
-0.3767840564,
-0.1749114245,
-0.0100379037,
0.6215479374,
0.3265304863,
-0.2398633808,
0.1538185775,
-0.8095443845,
0.668664515,
0.2941271663,
-0.1376616955,
0.5636049509,
0.4544774294,
0.369140476,
-0.3275731802,
-0.4925271869,
-0.6494980454,
0.9212676287,
0.1572630852,
0.8035373688,
0.2238018066,
0.3430365026,
-0.0392255932,
0.0844072253,
-0.7928066254,
0.2727968395,
-0.400674969,
-0.4650961757,
-0.1720055491,
-0.8207698464,
-0.8886227012,
-0.0274817962,
-0.1698133647,
-0.6444016099,
-0.5231013894,
0.229725942,
-0.6575414538,
0.5666204095,
-0.5885119438,
1.0135729313,
-0.6471222639,
0.0897064582,
0.1124400347,
-0.2781222165,
0.2028452605,
0.4498095512,
0.4358369112,
-0.0687627867,
0.2663398087,
0.7059791088,
-0.3504360318,
0.4020963311,
-0.0476547666,
-0.0697711855,
0.2803598642,
0.3537034988,
0.3217119575,
0.1025617197,
-0.0007589933,
0.1039663553,
-0.037577983,
-0.3762439489,
-0.8567515016,
0.4155923724,
-0.8907496333,
-0.041334901,
-0.2917057574,
-0.97734797,
0.202129975,
0.1060067564,
0.2430788875,
0.8449952602,
-0.0541196726,
-0.2070191056,
0.4336754382,
-0.3180157542,
0.3629238009,
0.0344760679,
-0.4471167028,
-0.495616734,
0.8911489248,
0.0580037497,
-0.100334622,
0.073706679,
0.2828216851,
-0.5247734785,
-0.1704927981,
-0.6331014037,
0.6190673709,
-0.5677392483,
-0.3410327137,
-0.5510542393,
-0.4767207205,
-0.1771441251,
-0.1632540524,
-0.4929812551,
-0.6049542427,
-0.1482913047,
0.0447531231,
0.6378616095,
0.9314626455,
0.1135579199,
0.5492271185,
-0.8727917671,
0.4512088597,
0.2087505162,
0.4813879728,
-0.5105652213,
-0.2276797593,
-0.0923486948,
0.2366511375,
-0.2276856303,
-0.5467042923,
0.7446123362,
0.3585942388,
0.4456416667,
0.3025098741,
-0.1463827342,
1.030621767,
-0.2775513828,
0.4716682136,
-0.075717777,
-0.7685489655,
0.69863379,
-0.2133231461,
0.3461254239,
0.3384986222,
0.0861543119,
-0.4026231766,
-0.174046725,
-0.6038033366,
-0.7664754987,
0.6179205179,
0.4152899683,
-0.1705617756,
0.3845866621,
0.5449009538,
-0.0321044698,
-0.0070462604,
-0.7451639771,
-0.2341165841,
-0.1849061847,
-0.5224952102,
-0.0042423857,
-0.0320287459,
-0.3731193244,
-0.3225564957,
0.6166142821,
-0.2128417939,
0.4595124125,
0.0166964978,
-0.3347042501,
-0.4434919953,
0.1767262965,
0.3810587823,
1.0464190245,
-0.2397295088,
0.0547577478,
-0.0355207324,
-0.3838577271,
-0.5601535439,
0.7876002192,
-0.0054148301,
0.120262824,
0.3943966925,
0.5176252723,
-0.1319415867,
-0.5171815157,
0.1553833038,
-0.3653306365,
-0.1772147864,
-0.530246675,
-0.0635386035,
-0.1409743428,
-0.0980940163,
0.5320470929,
0.2446844131,
0.4310778975,
-0.1907559186,
0.0288712978,
0.4313760102,
-0.2096098363,
-0.3694145679,
0.4450351298,
0.0231932104,
-0.5035570264,
0.9720652103,
-0.2555255294,
-0.9793049693,
0.724771142,
0.5167692304,
0.384082824,
0.07260672,
0.2627096176,
0.5090423226,
0.2463325411,
-0.0067003448,
0.3561605215,
0.3311124444,
-0.3225166202,
-0.7060765028,
-0.5780501962,
-0.1631189734,
0.1257312298,
-0.7448630929,
0.0610542782,
-0.4555917084,
0.1212624758,
-0.2916722596,
0.5381015539,
-0.471753031,
0.0335249044,
0.3999522924,
0.6813982129,
-0.9389774203,
0.2431628108,
0.9742118716,
-0.1688524783,
-0.9066877961,
-0.4472955763,
0.3154284656,
-0.4149778783,
0.3840209246,
0.3844988346,
-0.2104693949,
-0.0448567979,
-0.5264915824,
-1.0114398003,
1.0210268497,
0.6499781609,
-0.1226814687,
-0.0827221945,
0.448233217,
0.3653635681,
-0.1173066124,
0.1960771829,
0.5174613595,
0.5065130591,
0.2155658007,
-1.1990914345,
-0.4458815455,
-0.5685616732,
-0.0871701837,
0.4974589348,
-0.0963378251,
0.9528306127,
0.0831392854,
-0.1986141354,
0.3171796501,
0.850602746,
0.5014643669,
0.3011836708,
0.3842699528,
0.7193084359,
0.9162347913,
-0.3084014356,
1.1189001799,
-0.2145318389,
0.6030477285,
0.7462354302,
0.1758776903,
0.4079581201,
0.1063872725,
-0.2157125622,
0.7559452057,
0.5633116961,
0.3110311627,
0.2002683729,
-0.0678288043,
-0.1331469119,
-0.351315707,
-0.0043250411,
-0.5439619422,
0.5825497508,
0.3308811784,
0.0009268049,
-0.707711935,
-0.3002695441,
0.0582152642,
0.3251940608,
-0.5779039264,
0.6032513976,
-0.1688628793,
-0.2722811401,
0.3015880287,
0.1693233252,
0.4099016488,
-0.629329145,
-0.3559175432,
-0.1709541976,
0.5139462948,
-0.389934659,
-0.6097721457,
0.7875939608,
0.0221895333,
-0.1590049267,
-0.0329520516,
0.4907350838,
-0.4172883928,
-1.3409793377,
0.0185895693,
0.3850961924,
0.0973466784,
-0.4015626311,
-1.056104064,
-0.0458304062,
-0.4115696847,
0.247922793,
-0.2084059715,
0.6643713713,
-0.1631403118,
0.8801749349,
0.7616036534,
0.1239820793,
0.2579457164,
-0.2187460065,
0.8975337148,
-0.4562919438,
-0.9142009616,
-0.777071774,
0.5467532873,
-0.3017950356,
-0.2070066184,
0.6620208025,
0.8443661928,
0.6776998639,
0.1071927249,
0.6083610654,
-0.0180519521,
0.5167216659,
-0.4359408915,
0.5948420167,
-0.294968158,
0.2631260753,
-0.3086600006,
-1.0637811422,
-0.6901753545,
1.0496935844,
-0.6282564402,
-0.0027487266,
0.6657957435,
0.6765314341,
-0.4181129932,
0.2552293837,
-0.1904254854,
-0.2097775936,
0.4074527323,
0.757632792,
0.8267282248,
-0.5128606558,
0.9040500522,
-0.4605836272,
-0.2598209679,
0.1441364139,
-0.7039592266,
-0.814761281,
-0.2188352793,
-0.2251519412,
-0.1788528115,
-0.1822160333,
0.8082926869,
0.7009907365,
-0.735547483,
-0.3683412373,
-0.2395896167,
0.0122434068,
-0.2319909334,
-0.2855627835,
0.6224238276,
-0.2734288871,
-0.7585926652,
0.126455605,
0.3158299923,
-0.0992985368,
-0.1787610799,
-0.3993991017,
0.088876009,
-0.2144698352,
0.3883566558,
0.3761584461,
-0.7089227438,
-0.0897609517,
0.0254738946,
0.0963104367,
0.1137854531,
0.8723502755,
-0.8961043358,
0.4101661742,
0.1865984052,
0.6057444215,
0.1274178922,
0.3748288751,
0.5823286772,
-0.4774536788,
0.1977644116,
0.0406224579,
0.3703359365,
0.6288840175,
-0.634478271,
0.4543414116,
0.3453351259,
-0.3533886373,
-0.3968817592,
0.358505547,
-0.8038497567,
-0.1116078272,
0.8811311722,
-0.0309036784,
-0.5636669397,
-0.1851801723,
-0.4144918919,
0.3380557299,
-0.1613100022,
0.9709931612,
0.4253616333,
-0.3729389012,
-0.156085819,
-0.6385251284,
0.4225946665,
0.3792633414,
-0.9820541143,
-0.026854042,
0.6685822606,
0.0756707266,
0.216494903,
0.2654084265,
-0.4065171778,
0.1978244781,
-0.4971229434,
-0.091165863,
-0.6327939034,
-0.528273046,
-0.3521440327,
0.0491870195,
-0.2436796129,
-0.1059352458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00492v1
|
Is Temperature the Creativity Parameter of Large Language Models?
| 2024-05-01T12:59:37 | 2024-05-01T12:59:37 |
Max Peeperkorn, Tom Kouwenhoven, Dan Brown, Anna Jordanous
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are applied to all sorts of creative tasks, and
their outputs vary from beautiful, to peculiar, to pastiche, into plain
plagiarism. The temperature parameter of an LLM regulates the amount of
randomness, leading to more diverse outputs; therefore, it is often claimed to
be the creativity parameter. Here, we investigate this claim using a narrative
generation task with a predetermined fixed context, model and prompt.
Specifically, we present an empirical analysis of the LLM output for different
temperature values using four necessary conditions for creativity in narrative
generation: novelty, typicality, cohesion, and coherence. We find that
temperature is weakly correlated with novelty, and unsurprisingly, moderately
correlated with incoherence, but there is no relationship with either cohesion
or typicality. However, the influence of temperature on creativity is far more
nuanced and weak than suggested by the "creativity parameter" claim; overall
results suggest that the LLM generates slightly more novel outputs as
temperatures get higher. Finally, we discuss ideas to allow more controlled LLM
creativity, rather than relying on chance via changing the temperature
parameter.
|
[
-0.431076616,
-0.9486582875,
0.9640399814,
0.2644240856,
-0.5337650776,
0.0142675769,
-0.5290724635,
-0.1010431647,
0.4264520109,
0.4221231937,
-0.5225942731,
-0.4932065904,
-0.4912143946,
-0.0093012676,
-0.4133355618,
0.8618907928,
-0.0805424303,
-0.5728532672,
-0.4699277282,
0.1977805942,
-0.0550383739,
-0.6154536605,
-0.3344886899,
-0.3606499732,
1.1226291656,
0.4769656658,
0.7080990076,
0.7519980073,
0.1571298242,
0.3600544035,
0.0763297603,
-0.1691400856,
-0.5159736872,
0.7955334783,
-0.0842224211,
-0.4531220496,
-0.0952580795,
0.2660309672,
0.4417220354,
0.4919658601,
-0.105172798,
0.1696375161,
-0.0492389463,
0.5648431182,
-0.3869539499,
-0.1197817773,
-0.790667057,
-0.2199569792,
-0.3488720655,
-0.2996735871,
-0.2636514008,
-0.5190754533,
0.1626524627,
-0.183764562,
0.4744600058,
0.1094474792,
0.6728628874,
0.1696500331,
-0.3542594612,
-0.6314804554,
-0.8726604581,
0.9537252188,
-0.8745328188,
0.0573211573,
-0.0084580807,
-0.1637439877,
0.0881926268,
-0.5559875369,
-0.8454723358,
-0.2564307153,
0.5337907076,
0.1643662006,
-0.0193275288,
-0.6004670262,
0.3428861797,
0.4384169579,
-0.4924353063,
0.3723319769,
-0.0720469952,
0.0485465787,
0.7155905366,
0.5968330503,
0.5270001292,
0.0953307077,
-0.1112097651,
-0.1735759526,
-0.5343158245,
0.3964482248,
0.6666114926,
0.1493788809,
-0.1489459872,
0.4842588603,
-0.1568160951,
0.4035942852,
-0.0730316341,
-0.2645764053,
0.0566541739,
-0.0964374393,
0.021864878,
-0.0359534174,
0.786552012,
0.5901745558,
0.2031146884,
-0.3496874571,
-0.2116646916,
-0.2269705683,
0.1541786343,
-0.7932803035,
-0.4873827696,
0.0703200772,
0.0556787401,
-0.3703278005,
0.20482409,
-0.5512681603,
-0.2308186591,
-0.290340811,
-0.0881367251,
-0.0511085428,
-0.4478528798,
-0.191533044,
-0.4794141948,
0.0476213247,
0.1614180207,
-1.0008909702,
-0.1069966182,
0.5136080384,
0.6792832017,
-0.5591407418,
-0.553927362,
0.0731840432,
0.3736920953,
-0.7328862548,
0.7641535401,
-0.6551789641,
-0.1438719034,
-0.2767897248,
-0.2227791846,
-0.0176701918,
-0.1592766196,
0.2181020677,
-0.6771969795,
0.384119451,
-0.6077852845,
-0.3464455307,
-0.0087070661,
-0.128572911,
-0.8235433102,
0.6840897799,
-0.0111096976,
-0.5746873021,
0.7824267149,
-0.1356776953,
-0.3017171323,
0.1725658178,
-0.0729439035,
-0.3850885034,
0.3848814368,
-0.2044078857,
0.4316005409,
-0.7012901306,
0.495644778,
-0.4369102418,
-0.1589275151,
0.8254237771,
-0.5561813712,
0.3770662546,
0.3212184012,
-0.3653522134,
0.0875250027,
-0.6342116594,
0.374085933,
0.3648486733,
-0.6542292237,
-0.2366550714,
-0.3320329487,
-0.2780837715,
0.0682604164,
0.4848932326,
-0.5196357965,
0.1689589471,
-0.451408416,
0.3998400271,
0.5876953006,
0.3666430116,
0.6545602083,
-0.6941051483,
0.7077456117,
-0.0826857612,
-0.5454830527,
0.0654526278,
-0.7449449897,
-0.5587618947,
-0.4112558961,
-0.1498646587,
0.4717138112,
-0.5648741126,
0.0820739493,
0.2278707176,
-1.0223432779,
-0.2120114118,
0.611004591,
0.1392407119,
0.4018491209,
-0.2133654803,
0.1344690025,
-0.3797603548,
-0.70229882,
-0.4592733979,
0.1913623065,
-0.2118674964,
0.3023013175,
0.1544722319,
0.2783854902,
0.9120291471,
-0.3917620778,
0.3500005901,
-0.6278877854,
0.4629055262,
0.8852466941,
0.4416200519,
0.8414257765,
-0.5801455975,
-0.5623058677,
-0.3099625111,
-0.8168008924,
-0.4280135632,
-0.006174373,
0.0816855058,
0.5911152363,
0.4901319742,
-0.8596278429,
0.2624080181,
0.5806906819,
-0.2908514142,
0.5522706509,
-0.2427411675,
0.2582917809,
-0.9587362409,
-0.0802021399,
-0.0194857679,
0.368449837,
-0.7778248191,
0.1406367272,
-0.3060671687,
-0.1046825051,
-0.5937914252,
0.6064932346,
-0.3634764254,
0.5062366724,
-0.4870012999,
-0.2005159855,
0.127645418,
0.3678222001,
0.1080315188,
0.2501786947,
0.8356743455,
-0.577452004,
0.952673018,
-0.3891566098,
-0.3830965161,
-0.0662091598,
-0.7444192171,
0.5440395474,
-0.1152688637,
-0.0166052002,
-1.0880442858,
-0.5304523706,
-0.2681626678,
-0.0972895697,
0.0734841973,
0.4019245803,
-0.8507815599,
-0.4115960896,
-0.0560500994,
0.1849640012,
0.5732405186,
-0.1473809928,
0.3782936931,
-0.1738269031,
-0.5744185448,
0.1862253547,
-0.716981411,
-0.0181323551,
-0.7557290792,
-0.6880527735,
0.1979682148,
-0.6386038661,
-0.6706685424,
-0.2447556406,
0.0687716976,
0.0592233278,
0.0961494744,
0.472769022,
-0.0019035282,
-0.4898094833,
-0.2105478793,
0.0438595749,
0.2091885209,
0.3373475671,
0.1356273144,
0.8310412169,
-0.1104012951,
-0.0937534347,
-0.2794203162,
0.5799081922,
0.5478592515,
0.290612489,
0.7782135606,
0.592051506,
-0.0137989223,
-0.3043107986,
-0.6649191976,
-0.1051192656,
-0.5572398305,
0.007359039,
-0.4668935537,
-0.8350249529,
0.8537511826,
0.5016831756,
-0.0907405093,
0.5717187524,
1.0230443478,
-0.1039263234,
0.8115818501,
0.4350986183,
0.384224683,
0.257543236,
0.199882105,
0.2898453474,
-0.3852474093,
-0.3036060333,
-0.439114213,
-0.5128943324,
-0.770139873,
-0.1104773283,
0.1913848966,
0.090429157,
-0.3551286161,
-0.1716093868,
-0.2199153155,
0.7824019194,
1.0497144461,
-0.0503871925,
-0.0501575395,
-0.2174181044,
-0.1692177057,
-0.1854501665,
-0.6755728126,
-0.5306168199,
0.8739366531,
0.2261244208,
0.7412864566,
0.3921024203,
0.9909602404,
-0.1689240187,
0.1449079961,
-0.3243615627,
0.5661851764,
-0.0657233,
-0.5931415558,
-0.7122460604,
-0.3719230592,
-0.683019042,
-0.2650825977,
-0.165216431,
-0.8581017852,
-0.1402551085,
0.001514543,
-0.4216983914,
0.4887083173,
-0.7707034349,
0.5702283382,
-0.1921634525,
-0.6263217926,
0.1466894448,
-0.2427126914,
0.3599901795,
-0.4369071126,
0.0839640051,
-0.3496647477,
0.1269787252,
0.7512975931,
-0.0801858976,
0.8391306996,
-0.0284503326,
-0.2954467833,
0.4812033176,
0.5354881287,
0.3470882773,
0.1711145043,
-0.5274117589,
-0.0831886679,
-0.0019640357,
-0.396274358,
-0.5182790756,
1.096570611,
-0.7486569881,
-1.2464733124,
-0.229842186,
-1.2403757572,
-0.1498906463,
0.1936537027,
0.8339184523,
0.2830075324,
-0.0378711484,
0.5216628909,
0.4075717032,
-0.5641264915,
0.8238934875,
0.4307532609,
-0.0119879115,
0.056445457,
0.9226441383,
0.213337779,
0.4845085442,
-0.0612850673,
0.6224622726,
0.0694859028,
-0.6341314912,
-0.112859875,
0.0344318487,
-0.7626760602,
0.0052309274,
-0.4317082763,
-0.4067790806,
-0.6407195926,
-0.6269314289,
-0.0650044903,
-0.2345562428,
-0.8496066928,
-0.080793269,
0.5240758657,
0.78218472,
-0.0484494977,
0.1197958961,
-0.4937195778,
0.1683049947,
0.4861677587,
0.0188405104,
0.1830567569,
-0.6958033442,
-0.0752971843,
-0.0956800953,
-0.2520870864,
-0.6489690542,
0.7017736435,
0.2460992932,
0.6197099686,
0.552922368,
0.1362499595,
0.088583827,
-0.2145450413,
1.222774148,
0.3032574058,
-0.735768497,
0.3574424088,
-0.6371522546,
1.1090853214,
0.1372330487,
0.2936911285,
-0.091684252,
-1.209145546,
-0.7892618179,
-0.9390233159,
0.3367564082,
-0.221342057,
0.7862249613,
-0.0968086496,
0.2318212837,
0.5473957658,
0.2310269475,
-0.7752566934,
0.0018187043,
-0.1567976475,
0.0845893174,
-0.2148383111,
-0.4518493414,
-0.1368000954,
-0.2248827666,
0.2736339569,
0.1394905001,
-0.0366496667,
-0.1305085123,
0.4060527384,
-0.5336303711,
0.3796001077,
0.8212890029,
0.9458265305,
-0.1953146756,
0.4433712661,
0.2414536476,
-0.1130829453,
-0.2132224441,
-0.536265552,
-0.1421301365,
-0.1380820572,
0.5216948986,
0.784383893,
-0.1504893452,
-0.3849509358,
0.1414335966,
0.0323746689,
-0.3784071207,
-0.3453741968,
0.7986397743,
0.3703711331,
0.5273823738,
0.4305811524,
0.0943156779,
-0.3218908906,
-0.8620120287,
-0.0242778901,
0.3761271536,
0.0706318989,
-0.580655396,
0.832223177,
-0.2114755362,
-0.3717036843,
0.5966892242,
-0.310100019,
-0.3346333802,
0.8296800256,
0.8179769516,
0.614061892,
-0.1157236546,
0.2215479016,
0.1749740988,
0.1651827097,
0.1112658083,
0.6567193866,
0.1545718163,
-0.9205433726,
-0.0505523682,
-0.814242661,
-0.37284711,
0.2135474235,
-0.4888458252,
0.0407519899,
-0.5159437656,
-0.0033623527,
-0.0085127074,
-0.3482099771,
-0.9896045327,
0.3683133423,
0.4112227857,
0.4382553101,
-0.7891596556,
1.0020414591,
0.2503578961,
-0.279191047,
-0.9260305762,
-0.0363619924,
0.1929377913,
-0.6169735193,
0.702531755,
-0.1329448819,
-0.0544295497,
-0.025853537,
-0.7688841224,
-0.9897219539,
0.9630920887,
0.5635596514,
-0.5281036496,
-0.2049553543,
0.3606070578,
0.9401268363,
-0.8101369143,
-0.3964737654,
0.5995023251,
0.4644643664,
0.54792732,
-0.6552190781,
0.214698121,
-0.3201654851,
-0.052978944,
-0.2000451088,
-0.4723535776,
1.0176055431,
-0.7750384808,
-0.0357735492,
0.3285744786,
0.6347382665,
0.4394977093,
0.7050183415,
0.1035624146,
0.5399240851,
0.6123306155,
-0.1786621511,
1.1753901243,
-0.2954255939,
-0.1629639119,
0.901419282,
-0.3239952922,
0.6910371184,
0.5851261616,
0.304770112,
0.5087562799,
0.5919526219,
-0.1311005503,
0.5880227089,
0.3762792051,
-0.2326809168,
-0.2349568903,
-0.1143081412,
-0.1344294101,
0.3242796957,
0.2697716355,
-0.5829831958,
0.1438694149,
0.1563164592,
0.1976128966,
0.0924568027,
-0.2170656174,
0.8215771914,
0.2252736837,
-0.9150196314,
0.510909915,
-0.2650666535,
0.3452300429,
-0.3020702899,
0.4540497065,
-0.1653657109,
-0.1880760938,
-0.1489574313,
-1.2870877981,
0.3504715264,
0.0766176283,
-0.4571203291,
-0.6605681777,
0.4443449378,
-0.3911153376,
-0.503110528,
-0.2122566253,
0.524733305,
0.1753548682,
-0.0857244506,
-0.2414990216,
0.2265383899,
-0.0917769447,
-0.7426546812,
0.216897577,
1.0996772051,
0.4416097105,
0.2583503425,
0.6690736413,
0.3455894589,
-0.0412268154,
0.1719917655,
0.7580334544,
-0.8710470796,
-0.4579785764,
-1.0649107695,
0.3025569916,
0.2571496367,
-0.6895340085,
0.8589178324,
0.295245856,
0.2584319115,
-0.2527472675,
0.6160670519,
-0.0155226029,
0.3947028816,
-0.7895950079,
0.6414663792,
-0.5074461699,
0.3482941985,
-0.420496881,
-1.3729995489,
-0.1254790127,
-0.0947404355,
-0.652061224,
0.1093111411,
0.8668939471,
0.7222656608,
0.2904887795,
0.0213127993,
0.531119585,
0.2108617276,
0.2117891163,
0.3774933815,
0.9642526507,
0.5263080001,
0.1101502329,
-0.3111034334,
-0.1694085896,
0.1899391711,
-1.1113847494,
-1.0345761776,
-0.9178987741,
-0.3937480152,
-0.3520790935,
-0.3028587103,
0.7490641475,
0.2432656735,
-0.556532681,
-0.1798146814,
0.0354118496,
-0.1036143154,
0.0727379248,
-0.2674686909,
0.0882275254,
0.0492373854,
-0.6407335997,
0.2301136553,
0.3941172361,
0.1988922507,
-0.3580667973,
0.2000303417,
0.284639746,
0.6671743989,
0.430804044,
0.0736769885,
-0.8487248421,
-0.0797867849,
0.0757118836,
-0.2631696165,
-0.057621371,
0.7234125733,
-0.2254439443,
0.1853464842,
0.7362296581,
-0.0213966742,
0.3867909908,
-0.1902676672,
0.65993613,
-0.9258633256,
0.1363455653,
0.3246239722,
0.243847549,
0.2926559746,
-0.4651502073,
-0.2622957826,
0.2058767229,
-0.6436989903,
-0.6800176501,
0.4209665358,
-0.9638925195,
-0.4302655756,
1.5172296762,
0.1205217168,
-0.3827903271,
0.3531639576,
0.0080098966,
0.1225399747,
-0.5247948766,
1.1187388897,
1.0749716759,
-0.2170015275,
-0.4519197345,
-0.5307347775,
0.2512016892,
0.0421491712,
-0.4799104333,
0.0952370912,
0.2526762187,
0.3643706441,
0.1663857251,
0.3892819881,
0.404586792,
0.1935865283,
-0.0625896007,
-0.1080260724,
-0.0340307243,
-0.1531716585,
0.2744520009,
0.6585281491,
0.3462347686,
0.6842848659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00489v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00489v1
|
Explainable Automatic Grading with Neural Additive Models
| 2024-05-01T12:56:14 | 2024-05-01T12:56:14 |
Aubrey Condor, Zachary Pardos
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.AP
|
The use of automatic short answer grading (ASAG) models may help alleviate
the time burden of grading while encouraging educators to frequently
incorporate open-ended items in their curriculum. However, current
state-of-the-art ASAG models are large neural networks (NN) often described as
"black box", providing no explanation for which characteristics of an input are
important for the produced output. This inexplicable nature can be frustrating
to teachers and students when trying to interpret, or learn from an
automatically-generated grade. To create a powerful yet intelligible ASAG
model, we experiment with a type of model called a Neural Additive Model that
combines the performance of a NN with the explainability of an additive model.
We use a Knowledge Integration (KI) framework from the learning sciences to
guide feature engineering to create inputs that reflect whether a student
includes certain ideas in their response. We hypothesize that indicating the
inclusion (or exclusion) of predefined ideas as features will be sufficient for
the NAM to have good predictive power and interpretability, as this may guide a
human scorer using a KI rubric. We compare the performance of the NAM with
another explainable model, logistic regression, using the same features, and to
a non-explainable neural model, DeBERTa, that does not require feature
engineering.
|
[
-0.5054219365,
-0.840822041,
0.5384220481,
0.0321600474,
-0.1930669546,
-0.0019972215,
0.0898674279,
-0.6970425248,
0.1735588014,
0.1988102794,
-0.2555333078,
-0.3126087785,
-0.6699235439,
-0.1926925331,
-0.54732728,
1.1378929615,
-0.058123827,
0.1351030469,
-0.4120974839,
-0.2058915496,
-0.5895901322,
-0.4742197096,
-0.7983561158,
-0.7302423716,
0.4676381946,
0.3535912633,
0.8250680566,
0.9346074462,
0.6441938281,
0.3163614273,
-0.3395037055,
-0.1410266161,
0.2524570823,
-0.310135752,
-0.2330952436,
-0.5255687237,
-0.9332091212,
0.2727513313,
0.3610525131,
0.9303745031,
0.2885797918,
0.3941486478,
0.1296670139,
0.5374664068,
-0.6053689122,
0.373535037,
-0.1206928417,
0.1271169335,
0.306972146,
0.1230812222,
-0.3032031655,
-0.7379165292,
0.3820335567,
-0.4722642899,
0.2565508783,
-0.4924396574,
0.8788456917,
0.3063437343,
-0.3810558915,
-0.6586104631,
-0.621106267,
0.4793318808,
-0.5691467524,
-0.103680104,
0.4362125397,
0.5499960184,
0.2259142399,
-0.5312618017,
-0.5384545326,
-0.3284891248,
-0.1798092872,
0.2442332953,
0.128822878,
0.3973303437,
0.1008083522,
0.5226963162,
-0.3548618555,
0.3211075068,
-0.3141669631,
-0.1285829842,
0.7207416892,
0.165111959,
0.2350372076,
-0.3229077756,
-0.361020416,
0.0820809156,
-0.3270001411,
0.5319594145,
0.5138370395,
0.1325625032,
0.2149958014,
0.6891402602,
-0.0320262499,
0.7925693989,
0.0166835152,
0.2151497751,
-0.0601922572,
-0.0797660053,
-0.0724804252,
0.3197600245,
0.4687268734,
0.3357697725,
0.107793577,
-0.0841641575,
-0.2836408019,
0.4818764031,
0.2314295769,
-0.7590857148,
-0.5314313173,
-0.0042482363,
-0.4380621314,
-0.7047760487,
-0.4758257866,
-0.5541723967,
-0.2964497209,
-0.5665663481,
1.0161738396,
-0.2949905694,
-0.0131946625,
-0.06121023,
-0.1404478699,
-0.0928392112,
0.6522477269,
-0.6097193956,
0.103088364,
0.3771767318,
0.720385015,
-0.1144987568,
-0.2367929071,
-0.1275258362,
-0.280588299,
-0.3518126309,
0.8744379282,
-0.4944098294,
-0.0710126236,
-0.4503099918,
-0.1834051907,
0.0429314375,
-0.395808816,
0.1617390066,
-0.6541748643,
0.3411487639,
-0.0538502634,
-0.7334628105,
-0.7579785585,
0.3415359557,
-0.4749460816,
0.6834648252,
0.2895157635,
-0.2980418503,
0.3669558764,
-1.1724975109,
-0.2684950233,
0.1939269453,
0.1157980114,
-0.3777905107,
0.1205880418,
0.0267592669,
0.3243610263,
-0.1716786176,
0.5098112226,
-0.3243694305,
-0.4831307828,
0.3757966161,
-0.3865021765,
0.7148906589,
0.1853181124,
-0.2786603868,
0.2037407607,
-0.9753023982,
0.0433042124,
-0.0703217238,
-0.3362547755,
-0.3296145797,
-0.1388607025,
-0.3318240047,
0.2820807099,
0.3679336309,
-0.3575985432,
-0.0061417632,
-0.2195729017,
0.3543152511,
1.0064057112,
-0.0515092611,
0.5856205225,
-0.3773853481,
0.8090983033,
0.2374638021,
0.0932468548,
-0.1831118912,
-0.5410372615,
-0.8677222133,
-0.0704269931,
0.7553873658,
0.4226792157,
-0.6014353633,
0.3561298549,
0.1391767412,
-0.2963089049,
-0.655448854,
0.1921318471,
0.368663013,
0.8675975204,
0.3534772694,
-0.4200125635,
-0.1743778139,
-0.980317235,
-0.2380143851,
-0.2262514383,
-0.1189570278,
0.2610887587,
0.4239812195,
0.1631891876,
0.8475341797,
-0.6164396405,
-0.1245878488,
-0.0733269975,
0.451901257,
0.1451668292,
0.4667677581,
0.4391499162,
-0.5858251452,
-0.1722706258,
-0.2047085017,
-0.9379436374,
-0.0937204137,
0.0159880929,
-0.2154249251,
-0.2003649473,
0.278475672,
-0.214108035,
0.9111377597,
0.0604977645,
-0.6185356379,
0.5522076488,
-0.1762610972,
0.0953546762,
-0.6402317882,
-0.0920404941,
0.2991608679,
-0.0143695995,
-0.5617876053,
0.1043101773,
0.3114502132,
-0.3481172025,
-0.3072887659,
0.6671931148,
-0.0381643213,
-0.060842406,
-0.6280291677,
-0.0590514727,
0.3784193695,
0.7306610346,
-0.0989177004,
0.5697233677,
0.3980283141,
-0.8913286328,
0.2880195975,
0.1316836476,
-0.4198076427,
0.506397903,
-0.7724913359,
-0.2005942315,
-0.3638448119,
0.1303070337,
-0.8668942451,
-0.1709945202,
-0.0546494722,
-0.6197890639,
0.0822545588,
-0.4387032092,
-0.1699555814,
-0.298299998,
0.049473241,
0.5893529058,
0.6521939635,
-0.7140364647,
0.548627913,
0.1194868088,
-0.1432255208,
-0.5128391385,
-0.5651822686,
-0.0843698904,
-0.447786957,
-0.4470720887,
0.2859764099,
-0.0682692528,
-0.1190357506,
0.3012648523,
0.0077599008,
-0.3124232888,
0.511999011,
0.2047076076,
0.4718824923,
-0.5467783809,
0.4214518368,
0.0452860333,
-0.1125951409,
0.4383823276,
-0.1662097573,
0.0090899635,
-0.1554451138,
-0.292013377,
-0.4136237204,
0.1138881594,
0.8275387287,
-0.2990293801,
0.7344664335,
0.4275566936,
-0.5355021358,
-0.2732637525,
-0.239659816,
-0.2660100162,
-0.4394386113,
0.306666106,
-0.1494067609,
-0.4763914347,
0.8117758036,
0.1259898245,
0.1129442975,
0.3193000853,
0.1641035974,
-0.257348299,
1.3344712257,
0.6298130751,
0.4621045589,
0.5241162777,
-0.3916317821,
0.41973719,
-0.9403631091,
-0.397813648,
-0.3393824399,
-0.7777881026,
-0.4100474119,
-0.0301876161,
0.2159323841,
0.4589185119,
-0.0924467891,
0.0795338973,
-0.690705359,
0.6117166281,
0.5693331361,
0.3474336565,
0.130005151,
-0.3185645938,
-0.0662342384,
0.2923412919,
-0.6772781014,
-0.4599190652,
1.1416246891,
0.3839711547,
0.5505400896,
-0.0348917022,
0.4974558949,
0.435926646,
0.6836176515,
-1.1665108204,
0.5320977569,
-0.3017320931,
-0.597181499,
-0.2799659371,
-0.3848686814,
-0.6304858923,
0.2600654364,
-0.2398646623,
-0.4391226172,
0.2447461039,
0.4519909918,
-0.5618574023,
0.3072774708,
-1.1897671223,
0.7936635613,
-0.3769973516,
-0.3106682301,
-0.0207891632,
-0.2044873089,
0.5411345959,
-0.0955488756,
0.2458857,
-0.1994044483,
0.3528688252,
0.9298758507,
-0.613984108,
0.5669397116,
-0.3595662713,
0.1267372221,
0.6129654646,
0.1886126995,
0.1929190904,
-0.0481230989,
-0.2636187673,
-0.0837070942,
-0.3991072774,
-0.4851464033,
-1.0139365196,
0.7997868061,
-0.8235201836,
-0.5940547585,
-0.2613254488,
-0.8417247534,
0.0534600988,
-0.039168112,
0.0676236078,
0.5445945263,
0.3290466964,
-0.1343254596,
0.7224729061,
-0.2082580179,
0.5454689264,
0.3119906783,
-0.1298249811,
-0.229691118,
1.1580278873,
0.5824486613,
0.2114061415,
-0.1141122505,
0.5190131068,
-0.4503136277,
-0.6328180432,
-0.5702385902,
-0.1652299613,
-1.0469231606,
-0.2237642854,
-0.6757103801,
-0.4386305511,
-0.1982108206,
-0.4334413409,
0.0658989549,
-1.0229871273,
-0.4765116274,
-0.2819349766,
0.4600947201,
0.9764391184,
-0.0082424488,
0.5228047371,
-0.436193496,
0.3836201131,
0.5949357748,
0.6294152141,
0.4478328824,
-0.8800073266,
-0.3310695887,
0.1188218743,
-0.4912565649,
-0.6394661069,
0.1587783098,
0.1095338091,
0.4106852114,
0.3276876807,
-0.0534141324,
0.7016694546,
-0.1429789513,
0.7706942558,
0.2138219476,
-0.9624554515,
0.6210669875,
-0.0648952872,
0.4567738175,
0.2760977149,
0.3292092979,
0.0075649288,
-0.4550259113,
-0.7234363556,
-0.9229261875,
0.8073454499,
0.0062358086,
-0.1490739137,
-0.0114125591,
0.5151401162,
0.2223461717,
0.1580299288,
-0.9321954846,
-0.2238889784,
-0.5158432722,
-0.4274229407,
-0.1376882941,
-0.1752234697,
0.0593530089,
-0.4066158235,
0.6485987902,
-0.0709433109,
-0.0069088801,
-0.0399161316,
-0.3251880407,
0.1457123905,
0.3284463584,
0.6046915054,
0.6565472484,
-0.3549147248,
0.2146690488,
0.1368694156,
-0.2630396783,
0.3679167926,
0.1604785323,
-0.3228341043,
-0.10650336,
0.25981462,
0.687700212,
-0.1079237685,
-0.2940098941,
0.2598888278,
-0.1940419227,
-0.394579798,
-0.2778062224,
0.4003173113,
-0.046563305,
0.1462300271,
0.2493937761,
0.4684294164,
0.2155600786,
-0.4215453565,
0.0789644048,
0.2115309536,
-0.6338428259,
-0.2935825288,
0.6895515919,
0.2767370343,
-0.5964365005,
0.4592027068,
-0.0763850063,
-0.5378114581,
1.2526074648,
0.3822060525,
0.8822419643,
-0.0468105711,
0.3656204641,
0.3778101802,
0.207300052,
0.0497331135,
0.0114814704,
-0.2676569819,
-0.3713202775,
-0.4571062624,
-0.8267092109,
-0.3322831392,
0.3059229851,
-0.754820466,
0.2195031196,
-0.847251296,
-0.2224365175,
0.4892081916,
-0.2752124369,
-0.742297709,
0.6669176817,
-0.0234379098,
0.6328787208,
-1.1728363037,
0.4591594636,
1.0552927256,
-0.4723429382,
-0.8827345371,
-0.3210859001,
-0.2808825672,
-0.7694911361,
0.7153426409,
0.296125859,
0.1820918918,
-0.0893226117,
-0.1503499746,
-0.7238349319,
0.9123312235,
0.070737876,
0.1368969083,
-0.3602577746,
0.0083821844,
0.7782228589,
-0.3491059542,
0.7360949516,
0.3418604434,
0.3452637792,
0.1535308957,
-0.4930371642,
-0.0568389148,
-0.3766438663,
-0.180064857,
0.357652247,
-0.3792865276,
0.7133918405,
-0.1922611892,
0.1980203688,
-0.3304395974,
0.5209618211,
-0.0567882955,
0.6427996755,
0.3977920115,
0.7579728961,
0.5453557372,
-0.1132279634,
0.7682324052,
-0.0832868591,
-0.0149271749,
1.0357403755,
0.2216591388,
0.2995336652,
0.1513942182,
0.0504025929,
0.7047639489,
0.6243128777,
-0.0160370637,
0.2658677995,
0.3753815293,
-0.36328879,
-0.3665978611,
-0.2199298739,
-0.2261003405,
0.7140185833,
0.4710685313,
-0.6509925127,
-0.3635292053,
0.3276312351,
-0.6001784205,
0.1655855477,
-0.8386334777,
0.7791916132,
-0.0362156071,
-0.9815744758,
0.5468994379,
-0.0115908319,
0.5455409288,
-0.4039582312,
-0.3395322561,
-0.2819851935,
0.2536012828,
-0.3655383289,
-0.9192183614,
0.3123464584,
0.1075927168,
-0.4277534187,
-0.2077390999,
0.3798792362,
-0.4421232641,
-0.6728733182,
-0.0090940949,
0.1164080203,
0.0807619169,
0.2676539421,
-0.5933626294,
-0.5967057347,
-0.0780960545,
-0.0365848802,
0.4146973789,
0.4734052122,
-0.2870036364,
0.8933178782,
0.5689663291,
-0.0094112651,
0.0297238193,
-0.219353959,
0.5302754045,
-0.5801021457,
-0.5867558122,
-0.7103596926,
0.7139571905,
0.2000953257,
-0.2493178546,
0.4724937081,
0.3202148378,
0.5522602797,
0.1046360657,
0.6507430077,
0.2508916557,
0.3131510317,
-0.3860827684,
0.9174838662,
-0.5750700235,
0.4015896022,
-0.1326946467,
-0.7136839032,
-0.1543922573,
0.5412151217,
-0.2837485373,
0.1205719411,
0.6931341887,
0.2798799872,
-0.1107904539,
0.2241749763,
0.2293272316,
-0.1897771508,
0.3411020935,
0.5715436935,
0.9322749376,
-0.4548103213,
0.5886058211,
-0.5750479698,
-0.4145306051,
-0.2230246514,
-0.7556711435,
-1.1177779436,
-0.2839050293,
-0.6772331595,
-0.5667060614,
-0.1311794221,
0.6364763379,
0.4942467809,
-0.7411613464,
0.0195760261,
-0.1179261208,
0.4825828671,
-0.1328023523,
-0.3022132218,
0.5004312992,
-0.1440793276,
-0.4291462898,
0.2099643201,
-0.0480265431,
0.5723707676,
-0.0207490195,
0.2478121072,
-0.0811123103,
0.2895317674,
0.526368618,
0.1522170305,
-0.5650749207,
-0.3692645133,
-0.0528962053,
0.1686709225,
0.0424862839,
0.5353921652,
-0.8886615038,
0.6085941792,
0.4076851308,
0.58817029,
0.2218026966,
0.1402886659,
0.5760504603,
-0.4172435999,
-0.0208894368,
0.497436136,
0.1680722237,
0.1177955344,
-0.6070154905,
0.263753444,
-0.0016344639,
-0.6044895053,
-0.9590696096,
0.2050584555,
-0.5068132281,
-0.3902951479,
0.3988679647,
-0.3864671588,
-0.17851156,
-0.1440176517,
0.2173832208,
0.331672281,
-0.0986559168,
1.2740210295,
0.9410569668,
-0.4271131158,
-0.1538861245,
-0.3525999188,
0.5005251169,
0.6151737571,
-0.7353810072,
-0.1673832983,
0.4787933826,
0.2595523298,
0.3027920425,
0.0590105839,
-0.1955351382,
0.6971127987,
-0.1685547829,
0.150000751,
-0.524128139,
-0.5645924211,
-0.6105279326,
0.3698140979,
0.2116639316,
-0.2946969569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00467v1
|
Harnessing the Power of Multiple Minds: Lessons Learned from LLM Routing
| 2024-05-01T12:04:28 | 2024-05-01T12:04:28 |
KV Aditya Srivatsa, Kaushal Kumar Maurya, Ekaterina Kochmar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rapid development of LLMs, it is natural to ask how to harness their
capabilities efficiently. In this paper, we explore whether it is feasible to
direct each input query to a single most suitable LLM. To this end, we propose
LLM routing for challenging reasoning tasks. Our extensive experiments suggest
that such routing shows promise but is not feasible in all scenarios, so more
robust approaches should be investigated to fill this gap.
|
[
-0.6633076072,
-0.5876365304,
1.2696983814,
0.1045917198,
-0.3427573144,
0.1093347967,
-0.0035905803,
-0.1649303734,
-0.0049115601,
0.8112997413,
-1.0700267553,
-0.1444735527,
-0.587338686,
0.222047016,
-0.252168417,
0.4763305187,
0.0178427231,
0.2164100707,
-0.4587500095,
-0.3883882463,
-0.7452602983,
-0.8411767483,
-0.8333673477,
-0.7562662959,
0.8990957141,
0.5824264884,
0.3608218729,
0.1818214208,
0.6271731257,
0.309296906,
-0.0292683709,
0.6898661256,
-0.1305037588,
0.5875638127,
-0.5517911911,
-0.7407040596,
-0.1732778847,
-0.1754302233,
0.6871225238,
0.7532578707,
-0.1569694281,
-0.1962621361,
-0.2162546068,
0.9987293482,
-0.4536297917,
-0.4919268787,
-0.9096907973,
0.0941274986,
-0.4553825855,
-0.4916949868,
-0.3162841797,
-0.3274038434,
0.0064854356,
-0.3904610872,
0.0315255709,
0.5519423485,
0.3001794219,
0.6485425234,
-0.7124778032,
-0.3992468119,
-0.7597420812,
0.6530071497,
-0.2115814835,
0.19979617,
0.1942195296,
0.6756666899,
-0.0775293037,
-0.7491255999,
-0.4461488426,
0.1546024531,
0.2355280817,
0.1737123877,
0.005930746,
0.0622707121,
0.3492915332,
0.0462725237,
-0.2677395642,
0.1388905793,
-0.2872312665,
0.0933900699,
0.8021133542,
0.5078237653,
0.1379574388,
0.002040348,
-0.4370720387,
0.1549398601,
-0.7896056771,
-0.0785167664,
0.5232831836,
0.2584641576,
0.4138798118,
0.6096510291,
-0.2066547424,
0.9965595007,
-0.0262036901,
-0.2129623294,
-0.4002897143,
-0.446382463,
0.0389282927,
0.0009095507,
0.4206501245,
0.2114632279,
0.2189138532,
-0.3899609447,
-0.0152510675,
-0.071875222,
0.7757073641,
-0.3442958593,
-0.1879705936,
0.223775804,
-0.2583143413,
0.0488941818,
-0.1050161049,
-0.9694126248,
-0.7713984251,
-0.238372907,
0.5034584999,
-0.3247948885,
-0.3094946146,
0.3168118596,
-0.2459270954,
0.4506679773,
0.4638098478,
-1.0530650616,
0.613083005,
0.763630867,
0.7926233411,
-0.4293962419,
-0.2564770281,
-0.1417534798,
0.0810194463,
0.019718172,
1.0617240667,
-0.5141876936,
-0.5111121535,
-0.2914220691,
-0.3291380703,
-0.2644068003,
-0.5782524347,
0.6657807231,
-0.6862019897,
-0.1044612452,
-0.8324586153,
-0.5904124975,
-0.2507627606,
0.3918836415,
-0.5150498152,
0.3928904831,
-0.1457497627,
-0.6577804685,
-0.0461001918,
-0.5218119621,
-0.7190007567,
-0.1653540879,
-0.3164720237,
-0.0153425038,
-0.0007401085,
0.391296953,
0.3597232401,
-0.4884975255,
-0.0503819585,
-0.3430805504,
-0.1771260649,
0.2890951931,
-0.4176272452,
1.0816473961,
0.1086638123,
-0.1280819029,
0.0717379302,
-0.6523783207,
0.1008759663,
0.2685791552,
-0.3703772426,
-0.1879317313,
0.2185808867,
-0.4417618811,
0.3082421422,
-0.1998758465,
-0.3854456842,
0.4864501357,
-0.2402584702,
0.6208640337,
1.152320385,
-0.0096902456,
0.7299611568,
-0.777203083,
0.75023067,
-0.0468933731,
-0.1519084126,
0.1372935325,
-0.6707193255,
-1.0149406195,
0.0833844393,
-0.1646515131,
0.7247655988,
-0.8606737256,
-0.1781031042,
0.1369304061,
-0.4455868602,
-0.5539687872,
0.2731108367,
0.1257054806,
0.635941267,
0.4464240968,
0.0171514917,
-0.5307160616,
-0.6889587641,
-0.5688624978,
-0.0787601843,
0.0531252436,
0.6501784325,
0.2906448841,
0.110395208,
0.5577640533,
-0.5789141059,
-0.3661553562,
-0.3522813916,
-0.253216207,
0.1582217962,
0.458414048,
0.1230747923,
-0.8817491531,
-0.1250288486,
-0.3184045553,
-0.94143641,
-0.0571593046,
-0.2944163978,
-0.5264846087,
-0.2513809502,
0.4905861318,
-0.875035584,
0.0921427384,
0.1476667672,
-0.1063501686,
0.5400810242,
0.2029958218,
0.0620079003,
-0.8390521407,
-0.5234439969,
-0.0325863399,
-0.030750677,
-0.518832922,
0.273584187,
-0.1992607862,
0.0786709711,
-0.430742085,
0.608671546,
-0.5143945217,
-0.0984453708,
-0.0393790267,
0.214017123,
0.0994867459,
0.5854833126,
-0.2796056867,
0.8092952371,
0.8805337548,
-0.752823174,
0.9951973557,
0.1298434734,
-0.0498108119,
1.0431878567,
-0.4090187252,
0.5624352098,
-0.170263201,
0.1818158478,
-1.0320417881,
-0.1654852778,
0.1677326411,
-0.2954741716,
0.1245486736,
0.1794636548,
-0.4537562728,
-0.3366183043,
-0.077061668,
0.3683773279,
0.4204738438,
-0.7657114863,
0.9321820736,
0.3082855046,
0.0188565534,
-0.2696920335,
-0.8408872485,
0.0634659827,
-0.6219477057,
-0.8748158813,
0.4024290144,
-0.1928990781,
-0.3788279891,
-0.3255696595,
-0.2255999297,
0.056249924,
0.1296707988,
0.2915611565,
-0.0639227927,
0.0039762291,
0.2255723774,
0.0466288328,
-0.0521700792,
0.3920050263,
-0.6422185898,
0.2969596684,
-0.0615706854,
-0.9959221482,
-0.2216112763,
0.8240662813,
0.6471573114,
-0.2333835065,
0.3254649937,
0.2433368564,
-0.4341880381,
-0.4758477509,
-0.8707642555,
-0.2330251187,
-0.5177947283,
0.0370824747,
-0.6331295967,
-1.1346051693,
0.3943954706,
-0.7105222344,
0.0144952573,
-0.0784762502,
0.554225564,
-0.3282558024,
1.1149827242,
0.563387692,
0.1134690717,
0.0500557907,
-0.0534077436,
0.3509648442,
-1.030864954,
-0.4562932253,
-0.5446283817,
-0.3265527189,
-0.4866198897,
-0.4572891593,
0.7584733963,
0.1279051304,
-0.015981447,
-0.166022256,
-0.4912035763,
0.357640177,
0.9451387525,
0.4298241735,
0.5083590746,
0.1076059416,
-0.6378123164,
0.2163358033,
-1.2604902983,
-0.4573901296,
0.8262954354,
-0.2213545442,
0.8233428001,
0.3550644517,
0.5291287899,
-0.2677692175,
0.1417482942,
-0.9306461215,
0.8965790272,
-0.0005100271,
-0.7368277907,
-0.3810681105,
-0.3189169765,
-0.9281546474,
0.4594859183,
-0.0874915794,
-0.8278629184,
-0.1083956212,
-0.0224946942,
-0.472417295,
0.9136133194,
-0.5356500149,
0.2346205413,
-0.5016179681,
-0.6275995374,
-0.2648906708,
-0.7676125169,
0.5986831188,
0.0295603108,
0.1784040183,
-0.113871865,
-0.0650664791,
0.6054490209,
-0.2776839435,
0.4740974903,
0.208210364,
0.2363112718,
0.4420193434,
-0.1058768332,
0.070051983,
0.0095956866,
-0.364792943,
-0.1610066295,
-0.5273829699,
-0.4066278636,
-0.6378443241,
0.7722153068,
-0.6049361825,
-1.1481577158,
-0.3216751218,
-0.6873822212,
-0.7498595715,
0.2803904414,
0.2720367908,
0.3766315877,
0.1811489165,
-0.1233024225,
0.8071952462,
0.1141055226,
0.6153280139,
0.1487811655,
0.0377727002,
-0.2748800218,
0.7061520219,
0.3216087818,
0.223040998,
0.2820402086,
0.0753324255,
-0.4729319513,
-0.7655889988,
-0.5892375708,
0.0917795971,
-0.8367330432,
-0.3154168725,
-0.672550559,
-0.0697707236,
-0.1526045352,
-0.3307082653,
-0.2764599025,
-0.4050064087,
-0.2917068899,
-0.1300468147,
0.3329376578,
0.5932059884,
-0.1741898358,
0.2684729099,
-0.5151228905,
0.604932487,
1.0409531593,
0.3658238053,
0.4558466077,
-0.1271359473,
0.1768841743,
-0.2670514882,
-0.7724325657,
-1.1609065533,
0.1591482759,
-0.1606149524,
0.8759535551,
0.2077671885,
0.2149457633,
0.6217270494,
-0.7320080996,
0.6593614817,
0.3907554746,
-0.6666666865,
0.9052872062,
-0.1914566904,
0.3790729344,
0.501275599,
0.6544088125,
-0.1142393202,
-0.2545299232,
-0.4983471632,
-0.7577208877,
0.5084326267,
0.0465974249,
-0.155110389,
0.0989253297,
0.4078796804,
0.0685813054,
0.0703601912,
-0.3354408443,
-0.413387239,
0.0433623381,
0.2633414268,
0.4021682143,
-0.0136239128,
-0.453637749,
-0.4209859967,
0.3943797052,
-0.1626660675,
0.4883520901,
0.3768493831,
0.2260352075,
-0.0871625543,
0.2263828516,
0.4219508469,
1.0224226713,
0.1108539328,
0.6567060351,
0.4582066238,
0.0482143946,
0.3700661063,
-0.1279810965,
-0.0460125618,
-0.237523824,
0.2032009065,
0.653370738,
-0.3048572242,
-0.459094733,
0.1504519731,
-0.2586397827,
-0.5960912108,
-0.0195108857,
0.4323886335,
0.4231715798,
0.6446859241,
0.584913969,
0.2724520266,
0.0553963147,
-0.2421643883,
0.0654438958,
0.6476737261,
-0.186403662,
0.0171780102,
0.7266759276,
0.2522512674,
-0.921235919,
0.7808514833,
-0.0645642728,
-0.6770830154,
0.6290929317,
0.509164989,
0.7988710999,
0.065121077,
-0.2446528077,
0.0742869675,
0.5442601442,
-0.2418533564,
0.2527795136,
-0.147547394,
-0.8577098846,
-0.4384648502,
-0.3595301509,
-0.9191424251,
-0.2355155945,
-0.6372960806,
-0.0405716971,
-0.6069289446,
-0.2785708308,
-0.1832694709,
-0.0801615119,
-0.8283612132,
0.1307325512,
0.1927490532,
0.6910590529,
-0.4146338105,
0.8158763647,
1.1279592514,
-0.1687839478,
-0.8421347737,
-0.3361063004,
0.27022475,
-0.9688107371,
0.2360803783,
0.0545824021,
-0.5183922648,
0.0219067968,
-0.7505633235,
-0.542955637,
1.246108532,
0.2324170619,
-0.3281461,
-0.1213311851,
-0.0108938785,
-0.0177747142,
-0.3131023943,
0.0701278746,
0.4696209431,
0.4816784263,
0.2623410523,
-0.6895346045,
0.2342896014,
0.0425974205,
-0.0340419114,
-0.1239906773,
-1.1259843111,
0.7752813101,
-0.4689321518,
-0.1369172186,
-0.1200697049,
0.5817591548,
0.7609875798,
0.5362171531,
0.628682673,
0.6622629762,
1.2628303766,
-0.0264324415,
0.938803196,
0.1935050786,
-0.0514447056,
0.8941149712,
-0.3883495033,
0.3578825295,
0.7501758933,
-0.3861376643,
0.2350440919,
0.4960001111,
0.4776378274,
0.5792627335,
0.5242913961,
-0.5494030714,
-0.6403070092,
-0.0904794335,
-0.1736480147,
0.2910559475,
0.4845098853,
0.2743721008,
-0.33871454,
0.2682075799,
-0.0031033929,
0.0776629299,
-0.5948043466,
0.4858508706,
0.4564310908,
-0.8425648808,
0.2133337706,
-0.1577954739,
0.8595395684,
-0.4693352878,
-0.1005303264,
-0.301235348,
-0.043916259,
-0.1716576666,
-0.6477481127,
0.3650230765,
-0.1862690002,
-0.1349069625,
-0.7274002433,
1.3191316128,
0.1195481569,
-0.5571249723,
0.1932414174,
1.080473423,
0.1852640659,
-0.0570742823,
-0.5947784781,
0.0418731123,
-0.0913920552,
-0.2102802992,
0.5507693887,
0.7822367549,
0.2295131832,
1.373295784,
0.5830727816,
0.2626128793,
0.4340294003,
0.0939990729,
1.0457265377,
-0.9258025289,
-0.199489668,
-1.1379448175,
0.2537038922,
-0.0718477666,
-0.3204582632,
0.8534173965,
-0.0219222959,
0.7933589816,
0.2912779748,
0.8814789653,
0.1431856751,
0.3650323451,
-0.686979413,
0.2630301118,
-0.6336527467,
0.4619548321,
0.0862410069,
-0.5492361784,
-0.2438010126,
0.7403644323,
0.054579217,
-0.0226521678,
0.9915012121,
0.7892547846,
0.1194739267,
0.3359323442,
0.2176479846,
-0.0976799875,
0.2562036514,
1.1191204786,
1.1026302576,
0.0636233836,
0.5213259459,
-0.348995626,
-0.1318635345,
-0.0419070013,
-0.9680114985,
-0.982968688,
-0.2005703002,
-0.2108446509,
-0.2029353976,
0.1386083364,
0.4911472499,
0.9635052681,
-0.3409388959,
-0.301877588,
-0.3853534162,
1.0621217489,
-0.3650480807,
-0.1479601115,
-0.0037752939,
-0.3002938926,
-0.4855331779,
0.4933436513,
0.3162303567,
-0.3213739395,
-0.6911916733,
0.2130731344,
-0.5837510228,
0.1068443954,
0.6743840575,
0.0734440312,
-0.891502142,
-0.2832295895,
0.2677473128,
-0.0073947995,
0.1132518426,
1.1283055544,
-0.9534694552,
0.3195798695,
0.4405218363,
1.1054978371,
0.644300878,
-0.054058928,
0.4565224648,
-0.3880779743,
-0.3584917784,
0.5538160205,
0.2806990147,
0.3463955522,
-0.4156904519,
0.5913466811,
0.3938701451,
-0.8025372028,
-0.5118234158,
0.5273969769,
-1.1993938684,
-0.3716923892,
1.2482666969,
0.0317794681,
0.0158481523,
-0.3927523494,
-0.2207722664,
0.1031070054,
0.0504830517,
0.372551769,
1.0683320761,
-1.017901063,
-0.4227091372,
-0.9253900647,
0.0511922427,
0.7642410398,
-0.6716664433,
-0.2949422598,
0.2863569558,
0.1130959988,
0.0653870925,
1.079462409,
0.162622273,
-0.1734710634,
0.0771876425,
-0.6551134586,
-0.1902809441,
-0.5109151006,
-0.1298642159,
0.6173086762,
0.1888232529,
-0.0749403313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00465v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00465v3
|
BiomedRAG: A Retrieval Augmented Large Language Model for Biomedicine
| 2024-05-01T12:01:39 | 2024-05-03T01:12:08 |
Mingchen Li, Halil Kilicoglu, Hua Xu, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have swiftly emerged as vital resources for
different applications in the biomedical and healthcare domains; however, these
models encounter issues such as generating inaccurate information or
hallucinations. Retrieval-augmented generation provided a solution for these
models to update knowledge and enhance their performance. In contrast to
previous retrieval-augmented LMs, which utilize specialized cross-attention
mechanisms to help LLM encode retrieved text, BiomedRAG adopts a simpler
approach by directly inputting the retrieved chunk-based documents into the
LLM. This straightforward design is easily applicable to existing retrieval and
language models, effectively bypassing noise information in retrieved
documents, particularly in noise-intensive tasks. Moreover, we demonstrate the
potential for utilizing the LLM to supervise the retrieval model in the
biomedical domain, enabling it to retrieve the document that assists the LM in
improving its predictions. Our experiments reveal that with the tuned
scorer,\textsc{ BiomedRAG} attains superior performance across 5 biomedical NLP
tasks, encompassing information extraction (triple extraction, relation
extraction), text classification, link prediction, and question-answering,
leveraging over 9 datasets. For instance, in the triple extraction task,
\textsc{BiomedRAG} outperforms other triple extraction systems with micro-F1
scores of 81.42 and 88.83 on GIT and ChemProt corpora, respectively.
|
[
0.076295346,
-0.6830001473,
0.6753002405,
0.0547673143,
-0.3410140574,
0.31619066,
-0.1999537647,
-0.7979362607,
0.6447402835,
0.3918716609,
-0.1742605418,
-0.4509271085,
-0.7507134676,
0.4315040112,
-0.3481968641,
1.0915635824,
0.1785960644,
0.3441648781,
-0.1143562645,
-0.1021948755,
-0.2667702436,
-0.551115036,
-0.5776644349,
-0.6217560768,
1.0039627552,
-0.1288888901,
0.4825998545,
0.6946669817,
0.8640621901,
0.2554255128,
-0.3807812035,
0.189491719,
-0.3019364476,
0.4970107079,
-0.2718854547,
-0.3350067139,
-0.6570539474,
-0.2286131382,
0.7134014368,
0.6415151358,
-0.1881349832,
0.2378250211,
0.1159408242,
0.5940907598,
-0.57303828,
0.106956929,
-0.5127675533,
0.0666392297,
-0.3706611693,
-0.5258237123,
-0.3413080871,
-0.2363906056,
-0.2192827165,
-0.3192168772,
0.0172944926,
0.1013203114,
0.4505344927,
0.5227868557,
-0.1190730408,
-0.1480276734,
-0.5661255717,
0.4561932981,
-0.4089758396,
0.5948144794,
0.4343094826,
0.1930170506,
-0.2137598097,
-1.0029864311,
-0.1266192496,
-0.0256589707,
0.0554243289,
0.1665521711,
-0.2054921985,
0.2481124252,
0.2512366176,
0.4507469833,
-0.5113183856,
0.1942400187,
-0.7721369863,
-0.1394734532,
0.5073750019,
0.1652950197,
0.3044878542,
-0.3944760859,
-0.1193944663,
0.1454584599,
-0.7719381452,
-0.3843974769,
-0.1751610339,
0.1924726367,
0.2038329244,
0.8525452018,
-0.2037528157,
0.7327342629,
0.1280102134,
-0.2835027575,
0.4658455253,
-0.2676080763,
-0.2183133513,
0.3429827392,
0.7942367196,
-0.0269584209,
-0.2280198187,
-0.2840918005,
-0.1291569471,
-0.0568249971,
0.6607012153,
-0.9439758658,
-0.2082008272,
0.5727668405,
-0.5499957204,
-0.3821469247,
-0.3603251278,
-0.8100335002,
-0.4643412828,
-0.0466676801,
0.4766896665,
-0.5463018417,
0.1988390684,
0.3732723892,
-0.146821633,
-0.0418002456,
0.2302913517,
-0.7292511463,
0.0698388964,
0.8054202795,
1.048045516,
-0.3225726485,
-0.0187382717,
-0.9180615544,
0.2957255542,
-0.1806794703,
0.966527164,
-0.6826527119,
-0.395943433,
-0.1042505577,
-0.0609888211,
-0.0892629027,
-0.7634795308,
0.6629292369,
-0.6392710209,
0.0099040894,
0.0115184756,
-0.6000916958,
-0.0919809788,
0.0515349172,
-0.6979866624,
0.9431729913,
0.0603881218,
-0.7952477932,
0.2285184562,
-0.6599237919,
-0.3955257833,
0.5197796822,
-0.2753870785,
-0.3581216037,
0.0876448601,
0.0653395057,
0.531837225,
-0.2181496471,
0.2855991125,
-0.2718010843,
-0.5105143785,
0.0919838101,
-0.1188930422,
0.6148254275,
0.1213892177,
-0.0361439176,
0.1076126471,
-0.7002342939,
-0.0376927443,
-0.195383057,
-1.0000590086,
-0.2413783967,
-0.0295581073,
-0.0191548076,
0.067438066,
0.2389297485,
-0.7149032354,
0.2565177381,
-0.618731916,
0.350237757,
0.3315058351,
0.021710759,
0.2401696891,
-0.5567420721,
0.6647893786,
-0.3369995654,
-0.2444162816,
-0.01486036,
-0.4777510464,
-0.1211081892,
-0.7986208797,
0.570382297,
0.534840405,
-0.7309807539,
0.3813632429,
-0.2679131925,
-0.4029648304,
-0.9580638409,
0.222574234,
0.3447317779,
0.5619445443,
0.6295669675,
-0.1313880384,
-0.5806968212,
-0.6281985044,
-0.3381176889,
-0.1006164774,
-0.2364932448,
0.2792670429,
0.4585565627,
-0.6291483045,
0.3500622511,
-0.4051413834,
-0.263499856,
-0.4388177097,
0.0073318346,
0.3985573053,
0.2421403378,
0.2302745283,
-0.6402917504,
-0.2670879066,
0.2050186545,
-0.6867936254,
-0.4801550508,
0.3894898593,
-0.0596042387,
0.0760137662,
0.3978074193,
-0.886197567,
0.3308027387,
0.4490912259,
-0.0393109061,
0.7548674345,
-0.3293709457,
0.1535221338,
-1.1390763521,
0.4846502841,
-0.1196561381,
-0.4161607027,
-0.4585424364,
0.2451721132,
0.155783534,
0.0690070391,
-0.2652918398,
0.8157463074,
-0.2628146112,
-0.064478904,
-0.3543297052,
0.0042179693,
0.176262334,
0.1554139256,
0.067492798,
0.7527753711,
0.217150569,
-0.4365531206,
0.3401122689,
0.5477676988,
-0.3874647319,
0.407356739,
-0.9219915271,
0.0185614321,
-0.3541570008,
0.513946414,
-0.4592584074,
-0.6250813007,
0.1866679788,
-0.2886599004,
0.5389122367,
-0.0217844173,
-0.6239889264,
-0.4583565593,
-0.3494535387,
0.3204091191,
0.4908273518,
-0.5057426095,
0.3929926753,
0.4649238884,
-0.4887722433,
-0.6066706777,
-0.4709332883,
-0.0303520877,
-0.0562227182,
-0.1388246119,
0.5889663696,
-0.0351756252,
-0.2100282609,
-0.2778304815,
-0.0824674219,
0.0038973449,
-0.1087574586,
0.2268707603,
0.3335893154,
-0.0228007399,
0.6295075417,
0.2773205936,
-0.027970992,
-0.0476302765,
-0.1473747939,
0.5819989443,
0.3465075791,
-0.1835295111,
-0.1357372552,
0.3271782994,
0.5554402471,
-0.2951975167,
0.7164695859,
0.6991259456,
-0.4410315156,
0.086035125,
-0.5494542122,
-0.2903884351,
-0.3957791626,
0.6631932259,
-0.10732802,
-0.9594253898,
0.2321083248,
-0.1480662227,
-0.0934169814,
0.4568569362,
0.8128071427,
-0.2950945795,
0.8835714459,
0.2870661914,
-0.1547673345,
0.2659364045,
0.0335161239,
-0.0700373352,
-1.2214289904,
-0.5223679543,
-0.7892287374,
-0.4456091523,
-0.3748309612,
-0.6517335773,
0.8553184271,
0.156817317,
-0.1286337972,
0.1019768789,
-0.6081215143,
0.1677251011,
0.3338119388,
0.5930312276,
0.4554068446,
0.1550035328,
-0.2503988743,
0.0932474583,
-0.9333791733,
-0.3084951639,
1.0242831707,
0.2906343639,
0.7364144921,
0.0980235636,
0.8206225634,
0.213739261,
0.4406897426,
-0.8352863789,
0.2989458144,
-0.2139974833,
-0.7339212298,
-0.0223128647,
-0.5857356191,
-1.1898754835,
0.2162598819,
-0.452085048,
-0.8348335028,
0.0880414471,
0.0661216229,
-0.6601191163,
0.2154646367,
-0.0990736485,
0.4837395251,
-0.1164104566,
-0.661996305,
-0.3429569006,
-0.7037521601,
0.2647715807,
-0.474643141,
0.2038718015,
0.1001995355,
-0.1832856387,
0.6578685641,
-0.4204778671,
0.6239742637,
0.2509221733,
-0.0706242546,
-0.038131848,
0.057397861,
0.3779782355,
-0.0746236965,
-0.4312277734,
0.1344310045,
0.2632430792,
-0.2217619866,
-0.4043827653,
0.5685942769,
-0.3576672077,
-0.4810231626,
-0.3167856336,
-0.6366023421,
-0.138630718,
0.2305699885,
0.317746073,
0.61897403,
-0.0192904007,
0.4306209981,
0.7425807714,
-0.6606040597,
0.1748638749,
0.5246643424,
-0.4822842777,
-0.4257986546,
0.6486074328,
0.0550586954,
-0.0245970916,
0.5325062275,
0.1057270095,
-0.4182395041,
-0.3915186226,
-0.3524987698,
0.3761619627,
-0.2837875187,
-0.5365825891,
-1.1334781647,
-0.3731296957,
-0.2760672867,
0.079305023,
-0.0670377985,
-0.3071219325,
-0.321274817,
-0.1443513334,
0.634341538,
0.7082108259,
-0.2051711977,
0.0901759416,
-1.1911101341,
0.4608443081,
-0.0683274418,
0.4562090337,
-0.2559699118,
-0.6910713315,
-0.3153849244,
-0.1557188183,
-0.2224791795,
-1.0387721062,
0.6140905023,
0.2658565044,
0.3495080471,
0.0407254621,
-0.3228460252,
0.3680786788,
-0.8501576185,
0.4036988616,
-0.0269484855,
-0.3636489809,
0.5423222184,
-0.4839182496,
0.4346079826,
0.544593811,
0.4499848783,
-0.2649764121,
-0.3292212188,
-0.5038544536,
-0.6487819552,
0.2933013439,
-0.2227131277,
-0.0349999033,
-0.2218608856,
0.621941328,
0.0909460634,
0.4069253504,
-0.3211364448,
0.1090971306,
0.4635672569,
-0.5461585522,
-0.0168202687,
-0.4200007021,
-0.0756559819,
-0.4313317537,
0.5676920414,
-0.0384872556,
0.4053405821,
0.37616992,
-0.0470669307,
-0.1558484435,
0.3172595501,
0.5142227411,
0.3164863884,
-0.3239959478,
0.0542648658,
0.02758817,
-0.7112302184,
-0.0219823159,
0.3724890947,
-0.0210314058,
0.1754686236,
0.4287286997,
0.3688979149,
0.4900894463,
-0.8097552061,
0.141890347,
0.3689318001,
-0.0373811536,
0.1196293309,
0.0795596465,
0.0631312206,
0.5352560878,
0.303358227,
0.056528978,
0.5120219588,
-0.4411814213,
0.4041377604,
0.459189266,
-0.3715401888,
-0.2201999128,
0.921214819,
-0.0026019288,
-0.4368783534,
0.2301804721,
0.2556741238,
-0.4609982669,
0.1559653431,
0.6592541933,
0.5947679877,
-0.2815445364,
0.1778567731,
0.2761497498,
-0.0327576846,
-0.3227019012,
0.3957469761,
0.0419883914,
-0.457960248,
-0.7839579582,
-1.1680470705,
-0.259539336,
-0.0185042527,
-0.5189023018,
0.0118949823,
-0.2137237936,
-0.3362873793,
0.1458517164,
0.0838196874,
-0.3240976632,
0.0959547684,
-0.1450169832,
0.9008862972,
-0.1971956342,
0.8676548004,
0.6940709352,
-0.304523766,
-0.5972334146,
-0.3815253675,
-0.0813729092,
-0.6625536084,
0.6932330132,
-0.1133837327,
0.0243988875,
-0.0235534459,
-0.411673367,
-0.6595676541,
0.9504674077,
0.3037860096,
-0.7264795899,
-0.1529062837,
-0.187624976,
0.8163593411,
-0.123653464,
0.1892064661,
0.461586386,
0.3417466283,
-0.0259338059,
-0.9967958331,
-0.0611651689,
-0.3460309803,
-0.396618247,
0.2334807962,
-0.5838354826,
0.6835867763,
-0.1827133,
0.1600391567,
0.2432804257,
0.2569234371,
0.6381534338,
0.2322468311,
-0.2239773422,
0.4568789601,
1.0062206984,
0.1138970479,
1.5141459703,
-0.4323812723,
0.0660209507,
0.984765172,
-0.4386191964,
1.1070376635,
0.3471702635,
-0.1638098359,
0.4788707495,
0.3139457405,
0.2540056407,
0.2390553951,
0.1610548198,
-0.5008881688,
-0.0894696414,
-0.2925294936,
-0.5155599117,
0.4977684021,
0.4697640538,
-0.7747380137,
0.0642287284,
0.0046374453,
0.0372022912,
-0.0715719163,
-0.4678213298,
0.8487351537,
0.2741468549,
-0.3645450175,
0.5034287572,
0.0374754034,
0.557787478,
-0.4262703359,
-0.183750689,
-0.1035722271,
0.1076155454,
-0.259519726,
-0.4985627532,
0.2994811833,
0.1407847852,
-0.3512865603,
-0.0477561057,
1.0947619677,
-0.5899752975,
-0.7045853138,
0.2629818022,
0.5317208171,
0.3408736885,
-0.0037195936,
-0.5017855167,
0.4535434544,
-0.2853944004,
-0.0739839822,
0.38187626,
0.1561409086,
0.2997612357,
0.697588861,
0.4414710402,
0.5753927231,
-0.1799699217,
-0.145144999,
0.7236189246,
-0.5289332271,
-0.0342986621,
-0.7993212938,
0.1243731454,
-0.0530869812,
0.0050944537,
0.4358202517,
0.5610727072,
0.2957560718,
-0.0785347372,
0.6476020217,
0.1894547045,
1.0673891306,
-0.6505057216,
1.0085384846,
-0.606020391,
0.2972889841,
-0.22051467,
-0.8131890893,
-0.4987451732,
0.6088154912,
-0.2217572182,
0.205324173,
0.7394736409,
0.6584072709,
0.0663854182,
-0.1645601541,
0.348862052,
0.4326975942,
-0.051199045,
0.4815595746,
0.4986623526,
-0.3902373016,
0.1115464494,
0.2092926353,
-0.0576296188,
-0.3536190987,
-0.4862160087,
-0.6183443666,
-0.156267643,
-0.1635436863,
-0.5370387435,
0.418907553,
1.1350243092,
0.490565151,
-0.4935582876,
0.0866200849,
0.4410802126,
0.0093800286,
0.0263543297,
-0.1634847224,
0.2866624892,
-0.3414238989,
-0.6461859941,
0.7321351767,
0.6602967978,
-0.2477318794,
-0.0760562122,
0.0847009644,
-0.3292329907,
0.0336519666,
0.7629135847,
0.2809614241,
-0.4200588167,
-0.172803551,
0.0150656169,
-0.341047585,
0.1539315432,
0.5660408735,
-1.0589128733,
0.2586866617,
0.3980921507,
0.9471750259,
0.4808475077,
0.0051862537,
0.6052821875,
-0.5872716308,
0.024242444,
0.2659222186,
0.3830528855,
0.27707991,
-0.5276613832,
0.6856759191,
0.1504543126,
-0.7247012258,
-0.8519958258,
-0.1174476594,
-0.8708811402,
-0.2144500464,
1.2204937935,
0.2204972655,
-0.2525702417,
-0.17003043,
-0.3032890856,
0.3248358965,
-0.2172655612,
0.9413419366,
0.2669705451,
-0.0276428759,
-0.0616650581,
-0.813528955,
0.6638775468,
0.5079941154,
-0.8136031628,
-0.2824725807,
0.6465147138,
0.1598766893,
0.1020705327,
0.8252333403,
-0.4338139594,
0.3358619213,
-0.3694814444,
0.0440247431,
0.2123264074,
-0.4140026569,
-0.4156645834,
0.322686702,
-0.0754949749,
0.151794672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00461v1
|
Enhancing Surgical Robots with Embodied Intelligence for Autonomous Ultrasound Scanning
| 2024-05-01T11:39:38 | 2024-05-01T11:39:38 |
Huan Xu, Jinlin Wu, Guanglin Cao, Zhen Lei, Zhen Chen, Hongbin Liu
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Ultrasound robots are increasingly used in medical diagnostics and early
disease screening. However, current ultrasound robots lack the intelligence to
understand human intentions and instructions, hindering autonomous ultrasound
scanning. To solve this problem, we propose a novel Ultrasound Embodied
Intelligence system that equips ultrasound robots with the large language model
(LLM) and domain knowledge, thereby improving the efficiency of ultrasound
robots. Specifically, we first design an ultrasound operation knowledge
database to add expertise in ultrasound scanning to the LLM, enabling the LLM
to perform precise motion planning. Furthermore, we devise a dynamic ultrasound
scanning strategy based on a \textit{think-observe-execute} prompt engineering,
allowing LLMs to dynamically adjust motion planning strategies during the
scanning procedures. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our system
significantly improves ultrasound scan efficiency and quality from verbal
commands. This advancement in autonomous medical scanning technology
contributes to non-invasive diagnostics and streamlined medical workflows.
|
[
-0.3148956001,
-0.3983683586,
1.0335900784,
-0.2543256581,
-0.612416327,
0.130193755,
0.2306252271,
-0.8121700883,
0.8161965609,
0.6681368351,
-0.7078405619,
-0.4248886108,
-0.7290174961,
0.1376071125,
-0.3629889786,
0.4922468662,
0.1786322147,
0.1296579689,
-0.0198707767,
-0.3296162486,
-0.2519105375,
-0.135077551,
-0.4092597067,
-0.2145135105,
0.4840093255,
0.0992591903,
1.1002898216,
0.9166672826,
0.5498899817,
0.3574724197,
0.2593406141,
0.7644516826,
-0.0032745455,
0.0671436787,
-0.1990765631,
-0.2316144705,
-0.8185762167,
-0.2811034918,
0.3855746984,
0.9341492057,
-0.2129805237,
-0.2594521344,
-0.2910793126,
0.6310673952,
-0.3905833066,
0.0949496999,
-0.0864026621,
0.1273741126,
0.3825935721,
-0.4565056562,
-0.0014131684,
-0.2892048657,
-0.0564847775,
-0.8933838606,
-0.1923328787,
-0.2874470055,
0.3929308057,
0.8871856928,
-0.4525018036,
-0.4134193659,
-0.9903413653,
0.236356914,
-0.2830021083,
0.7896184325,
0.0444969088,
0.1640403122,
-0.0851363763,
-0.7331418395,
-0.2554310262,
-0.3333446085,
-0.016169183,
0.257155031,
-0.1322243214,
0.355137974,
0.1060385257,
0.0874353871,
-0.4917263389,
0.0930003077,
-0.224930197,
-0.0266270954,
0.7594255209,
0.2945950031,
0.4101918638,
0.2806560695,
-0.4090506136,
-0.2016071677,
-0.4258348048,
-0.1572690159,
0.0079954369,
0.0100053921,
0.0857025906,
0.5865869522,
-0.2575117648,
0.6522141099,
0.1186882928,
-0.2071374059,
0.2877744734,
-0.1126480475,
-0.1449380219,
0.2443894595,
0.630648613,
0.1660867929,
-0.1207163259,
-0.0344807059,
-0.517793119,
-0.0973016098,
0.7669870257,
-0.6324172616,
0.0039826236,
0.1535813808,
-0.568549931,
0.0233560242,
-0.1299614906,
-0.3335622251,
-0.8998135924,
-0.4566485584,
0.5015789866,
-0.4220931828,
-0.2843246758,
0.7350542545,
-0.0396695957,
0.1846094579,
0.581105113,
-0.7830334306,
0.2558479011,
0.7128474712,
0.5463371873,
0.4731731117,
0.0979706571,
-0.4236031771,
0.3448403776,
-0.7742961645,
0.8052557707,
-0.53504318,
-0.8810697794,
-0.1728693098,
-0.0523122214,
0.0295089856,
-0.7893431783,
0.4331831932,
-0.2625837326,
-0.2691697776,
0.0421439968,
-0.4498054087,
-0.5321797729,
0.0064018373,
-0.7680380344,
0.4758764207,
0.2843928039,
0.0419895947,
0.3296927214,
-0.8572320938,
-0.7476448417,
0.4820238054,
-0.6053000689,
-0.218641296,
0.1163911149,
0.4851928949,
0.6775804758,
-0.2162267864,
0.3188910186,
-0.1620399803,
-0.6956894398,
0.0039306595,
-0.0482845344,
0.5487481356,
-0.1540749222,
-0.3821495771,
0.2218755931,
-0.3887275159,
-0.4031876922,
0.1307021081,
-0.0402408093,
-0.0591030791,
0.0940021574,
-0.6634951234,
-0.1680733263,
0.4076488912,
-0.3627189398,
0.6131736636,
-0.7667104006,
-0.0775037631,
0.468881011,
0.0534351133,
0.5984213948,
-0.6819767952,
0.6354644299,
-0.404505372,
0.2798938155,
0.1709492058,
-0.6639472842,
-0.7668159008,
-0.5015694499,
-0.4621253014,
0.6148981452,
-0.7840536237,
0.3674187064,
-0.1089876741,
-0.7286500335,
-0.6402297616,
-0.0572558269,
0.2505342364,
0.6036555171,
0.2935501337,
-0.1583521813,
-0.5214503407,
-0.7936019897,
-0.040534649,
-0.3258878887,
-0.2416836172,
0.7906033993,
0.2201864272,
-0.4094081819,
0.3013420999,
-0.488612324,
-0.5114116669,
-0.257643491,
0.1393028647,
0.7533217072,
0.5163585544,
0.5001942515,
-0.7322379351,
0.2736017704,
0.2800878286,
-1.0295677185,
0.052275598,
-0.2265783399,
-0.2535991371,
0.3419893086,
0.6061583757,
-0.9839673042,
0.4933252931,
0.2325477153,
-0.1623324454,
0.3029115498,
-0.5736585855,
0.2863969505,
-0.8550173044,
0.0771635547,
-0.020634545,
0.0223054476,
-0.3431762159,
0.2245395929,
0.0085045733,
-0.0397291817,
-0.1502908468,
0.5620678663,
-0.4862665236,
-0.204047516,
-0.4078597128,
-0.0089319227,
0.0471619703,
0.2762279212,
0.3534556031,
0.6585467458,
0.4119236767,
-0.8265758753,
0.5621584654,
0.2854976952,
-0.1681068242,
0.3798279464,
-0.6000134945,
0.4009471834,
0.2125527561,
0.2585552037,
-0.5137942433,
-0.2116908431,
0.2684963942,
-0.6369683743,
0.4626217484,
-0.0794618204,
-0.3377099931,
-0.5952342153,
-0.1560126245,
0.1212865263,
0.7302375436,
-0.5148252845,
1.331664443,
0.5849962831,
-0.2560981512,
-0.5771558881,
-0.2651644945,
0.1597620398,
0.0142401541,
-0.5541835427,
0.1766973138,
0.0575679094,
-0.247427389,
-0.1068553925,
-0.2490504533,
-0.1832773983,
0.3423483372,
0.0641861036,
0.4786075652,
-0.1969424933,
0.2617638707,
0.5167315006,
-0.2515600622,
0.4076940417,
-0.6619346142,
0.5623117089,
0.168400526,
-0.5764294863,
-0.7845512033,
0.1831778288,
0.7297400832,
-0.1744024903,
0.2621253133,
0.5527147055,
-0.4283138514,
-0.1752084345,
-0.5094400048,
-0.7201863527,
-0.5296801329,
0.5001170039,
-0.2211562097,
-0.5926251411,
0.4039897621,
-0.1279191673,
0.0367303118,
0.0915933922,
0.5915509462,
-0.5197380185,
1.4041842222,
0.6586443186,
0.0660956576,
0.1503463835,
-0.307706207,
0.1775985807,
-0.7701587081,
-0.5097026825,
-0.4589143097,
-0.3561548591,
-0.5037717819,
-0.6177082658,
0.8844125271,
-0.4196685553,
-0.3415497243,
0.0257474314,
-0.7677986026,
0.1550649256,
0.6751376987,
0.4507781267,
0.0915747955,
-0.4141001105,
-0.0208276697,
0.4833973646,
-0.6185570955,
-0.6216370463,
0.803403914,
0.0490652733,
0.8634514213,
-0.1309917122,
0.6468915343,
0.1746940613,
-0.2542207241,
-0.9280908108,
0.821064353,
-0.3300657868,
-0.2568614185,
-0.2929934859,
-0.0611158088,
-1.0719952583,
-0.0204038918,
-0.0648806617,
-0.410256058,
0.1776363701,
0.3033468723,
-0.6445319653,
0.4850722849,
-0.1309375912,
0.1052594632,
-0.404946059,
-0.2869105935,
-0.5204146504,
-0.7088165879,
0.0301535241,
-0.0154843982,
0.0967676267,
-0.1048780084,
-0.5765404105,
0.6072189808,
-0.3209032714,
0.8571563363,
-0.4965634644,
-0.3471356928,
0.0906132087,
0.4029189944,
0.3400487304,
0.1258193851,
-0.0722473636,
0.1497815102,
-0.5437427759,
0.0008964701,
-0.7261205912,
0.2586760819,
-0.4961440861,
-0.7144572139,
-0.0844197646,
-0.8047522306,
-0.2766364515,
0.1201196536,
-0.2340450883,
0.4423830509,
-0.0009653388,
-0.0128722163,
0.7521672845,
-0.2511644661,
0.2228629142,
0.4315279126,
0.0833044723,
-0.077435717,
0.7476819158,
0.0608503744,
-0.1958877891,
0.5453874469,
0.3216481209,
-0.5429335833,
-0.5996385217,
-0.8852763176,
0.4077524841,
-0.4943796396,
-0.2027935386,
-0.8419913054,
-0.0888847187,
-0.4132362604,
-0.5892944932,
-0.4755017459,
-0.1509721577,
-0.463738054,
0.0036361718,
0.4907199442,
1.0005282164,
-0.1207198501,
-0.0578252897,
-1.086187005,
0.6372573376,
0.4192231596,
0.1933205575,
-0.1733955443,
-0.3778072298,
-0.1122599691,
0.0365307704,
0.1133538485,
-0.5534052849,
0.3791104853,
-0.0671592504,
0.6813755035,
0.655225575,
0.0368394889,
0.6091818213,
-0.2232099622,
0.4738863409,
-0.0541673191,
-0.7531938553,
0.5140980482,
-0.5776957273,
0.3667700291,
0.2949477732,
0.3884965777,
-0.2097309381,
-0.5676438808,
-0.3197001517,
-0.7403045297,
0.5391776562,
-0.3215880394,
0.1213873401,
0.2417664975,
0.5522623062,
0.1682764739,
0.357801348,
-0.0820141137,
0.2262700796,
0.0594658889,
-0.2669312954,
0.228605032,
0.1301622242,
-0.2178237438,
-0.4414719939,
0.7310451865,
-0.4853433967,
0.5991241932,
0.2051785141,
0.111251004,
-0.0062581473,
-0.4182314575,
0.7082391381,
0.3529435396,
0.0386105739,
-0.2007819712,
0.1651396006,
-0.828538835,
-0.0116080325,
0.0929738507,
0.1816366762,
-0.218919307,
0.4423343241,
0.5045726895,
0.0786302164,
-0.8362594843,
0.3125969768,
-0.0665265098,
-0.3349560797,
-0.2737747133,
0.4362609088,
0.326410532,
0.5749425888,
0.3684221506,
0.1517894119,
0.5037403107,
-0.155704543,
0.0832851455,
0.4345731735,
-0.4256308079,
-0.0373458341,
0.5597547293,
0.3407880962,
-0.3086999953,
0.7851127982,
-0.1195002869,
-0.3885784745,
0.9810070992,
0.175111562,
0.737570405,
-0.5298649669,
-0.0540262125,
0.1743722707,
0.6117997766,
0.2546199262,
0.716853261,
-0.3606268466,
-0.7851204872,
-0.4747573137,
-0.2456200272,
-0.6914498806,
-0.2078932226,
-0.5919412374,
0.2854365408,
-0.6343343854,
0.2067606896,
-0.2103241682,
-0.1383375823,
-0.4122341573,
0.4605336785,
0.3989514709,
0.6070269942,
-0.1817459315,
0.6908980012,
0.9872980714,
-0.104830578,
-0.9574308991,
-0.1904296875,
-0.0154328318,
-1.465888381,
0.3313591182,
0.215647608,
-0.9807321429,
-0.1577703357,
-0.4964762628,
-0.8203529716,
0.9245708585,
0.4218814671,
-0.6351178288,
-0.073756583,
-0.1347167641,
0.5093413591,
-0.3069028258,
0.1534915119,
0.4857140481,
0.5791156888,
0.1130780131,
-1.0850465298,
0.0125017697,
-0.3651563227,
-0.5320264697,
0.498465687,
-0.297984302,
0.5084850192,
-0.7459480762,
-0.014206171,
0.3029307425,
0.4795404375,
0.2800388336,
0.450506717,
0.6243088841,
0.5985845327,
0.930426836,
0.027566392,
1.1617003679,
-0.620711565,
-0.3285928667,
0.6675911546,
-0.5162634254,
0.3061932027,
0.0596291013,
0.2950896323,
0.4202572703,
0.3864530325,
0.0732554793,
0.1244595349,
-0.1891032457,
-0.482698679,
-0.5285952687,
-0.294564724,
-0.2328744978,
1.0719019175,
0.7341868281,
-0.2135318071,
0.2568227351,
0.4933710992,
0.0110484157,
0.0448528863,
-0.6074904203,
1.1580512524,
-0.1071944609,
-0.4808946848,
0.5306427479,
-0.43214643,
0.4264923632,
-0.5785737634,
-0.3727434576,
-0.0038540054,
0.108904317,
-0.1090361103,
-0.9255021214,
0.2646316886,
-0.4194191694,
0.2051906139,
-0.2514529228,
0.8017058969,
0.1512152404,
-0.3661268651,
0.5198287368,
0.68609339,
0.2266448885,
-0.1089702025,
-0.4764778316,
-0.1375793815,
-0.0944989547,
-0.0408937633,
0.054210797,
0.2711831033,
0.0680932254,
0.9548957944,
0.49349612,
0.0051954249,
-0.5060142279,
0.0633286014,
1.1214746237,
-0.6839796901,
-0.43852368,
-0.5086724162,
0.3057521284,
0.0678795353,
-0.0844672099,
0.1465838403,
0.3493593633,
0.5831251144,
0.0594222099,
0.4815159142,
0.2265201211,
0.6390487552,
-0.4531954825,
1.1097860336,
-0.9533065557,
0.0111593213,
-0.0993922278,
-0.4052026868,
-0.368601352,
0.9587426186,
-0.0230890382,
0.4311008155,
0.4506570697,
0.8424275517,
0.0588805079,
0.1542978138,
0.4443871975,
0.2466883659,
0.1149175614,
0.3841502368,
0.7658675313,
0.1110630408,
0.0677801743,
-0.3689909577,
-0.3015052378,
-0.3918903172,
-0.5577095747,
-0.473780781,
-0.4770123363,
-0.1491022557,
-0.0755848438,
0.1373760104,
0.9465139508,
1.0459986925,
-0.0334573388,
-0.3124736249,
0.1317182481,
0.0715386569,
-0.3120521903,
-0.0770211145,
0.2766030729,
0.1071034446,
-0.8111162186,
1.1501386166,
0.7070872188,
-0.0202038772,
-0.0998087004,
-0.1196820885,
0.084869653,
0.2278883606,
0.399300456,
0.2038134784,
-0.3696959615,
-0.2231876552,
0.2708569765,
-0.1280818582,
0.1613186896,
0.6418682933,
-1.1227374077,
0.5832794309,
0.1116642132,
0.713631928,
0.1377702057,
-0.2000915706,
0.4332588911,
-0.0135507053,
0.2398463488,
1.0999598503,
0.5121181011,
0.0061302488,
-0.8963072896,
0.5444629788,
0.1343470514,
-0.546649158,
-0.3744585812,
0.1128128543,
-1.1738060713,
-0.3935472965,
0.6162765622,
0.0999930426,
-0.4571369588,
-0.2534234524,
-0.3167209327,
0.4648680389,
-0.3594507575,
0.7123994231,
-0.2411599904,
-0.7746776938,
-0.0168218594,
-0.2026143372,
0.1565443724,
0.4040862918,
-0.8760175109,
-0.4348596632,
0.4523736835,
-0.1333031952,
0.2423982769,
0.6999275684,
-0.251145035,
0.8590577841,
0.0659046844,
0.4172636867,
-0.3354716003,
-0.5267104506,
-0.2236731499,
0.1030730605,
-0.1631691158,
-0.3034252822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00449v1
|
RAG-based Explainable Prediction of Road Users Behaviors for Automated Driving using Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-01T11:06:31 | 2024-05-01T11:06:31 |
Mohamed Manzour Hussien, Angie Nataly Melo, Augusto Luis Ballardini, Carlota Salinas Maldonado, Rubén Izquierdo, Miguel Ángel Sotelo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.NE
|
Prediction of road users' behaviors in the context of autonomous driving has
gained considerable attention by the scientific community in the last years.
Most works focus on predicting behaviors based on kinematic information alone,
a simplification of the reality since road users are humans, and as such they
are highly influenced by their surrounding context. In addition, a large
plethora of research works rely on powerful Deep Learning techniques, which
exhibit high performance metrics in prediction tasks but may lack the ability
to fully understand and exploit the contextual semantic information contained
in the road scene, not to mention their inability to provide explainable
predictions that can be understood by humans. In this work, we propose an
explainable road users' behavior prediction system that integrates the
reasoning abilities of Knowledge Graphs (KG) and the expressiveness
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLM) by using Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) techniques. For that purpose, Knowledge Graph Embeddings (KGE)
and Bayesian inference are combined to allow the deployment of a fully
inductive reasoning system that enables the issuing of predictions that rely on
legacy information contained in the graph as well as on current evidence
gathered in real time by onboard sensors. Two use cases have been implemented
following the proposed approach: 1) Prediction of pedestrians' crossing
actions; 2) Prediction of lane change maneuvers. In both cases, the performance
attained surpasses the current state of the art in terms of anticipation and
F1-score, showing a promising avenue for future research in this field.
|
[
-0.5207234025,
-0.8433580399,
1.0719283819,
0.0657076612,
-0.1451126486,
-0.0117178923,
-0.0244531799,
-0.6595778465,
0.2540757656,
0.5057122707,
-0.6860853434,
-0.2423324883,
-0.4067594707,
-0.2210030705,
-0.4855203032,
0.6351534128,
-0.1222236603,
-0.089706026,
-0.3991787434,
-0.0133456057,
-0.5040906668,
-0.1739410907,
-0.3501213193,
-0.4505824149,
0.7062027454,
0.1654984653,
0.7412228584,
0.4596218765,
0.2006340325,
0.3479171991,
0.1032330915,
0.269367069,
-0.0237293337,
0.1431541443,
-0.315476805,
0.2347898781,
-0.3811785877,
-0.208003521,
0.553438127,
0.8487876654,
-0.0822310001,
-0.2993883491,
-0.0496392623,
0.5350493193,
-0.6888743043,
0.2453024387,
-0.4411867559,
-0.2787437737,
-0.0781759247,
-0.2729877234,
-0.2634869218,
-0.2635427117,
0.1455233097,
-0.6812290549,
-0.148282975,
0.0731217191,
0.4312289655,
0.307531327,
-0.6072050929,
-0.4199947715,
-0.8141955733,
0.515237391,
-0.6157788634,
0.5252613425,
0.4634267688,
0.6522766352,
-0.4010350406,
-0.2988002002,
-0.8939403296,
-0.2251638472,
-0.3393498957,
0.3064832985,
0.038225431,
0.0612449758,
0.1530483216,
-0.2519270182,
-0.7185369134,
0.2113961428,
-0.0836781561,
0.0463009477,
0.8773139119,
0.465944618,
-0.0182759836,
-0.060365729,
-0.5689501762,
0.0414578021,
-0.4766088724,
0.4245234132,
0.1033334732,
0.1608816087,
-0.1370595247,
0.4509932399,
-0.5562886,
0.8658463955,
0.0345523544,
-0.1585830152,
0.4494104385,
0.0381452665,
-0.2011840492,
-0.1557674259,
0.9186475277,
0.4815798998,
0.4612900019,
-0.5560882092,
-0.1979836971,
-0.0176390316,
0.0926958993,
-0.6038977504,
-0.1146019027,
0.0802504867,
-0.2067223638,
-0.329924047,
0.2517398894,
-1.0350791216,
-0.7640189528,
-0.5841954947,
0.3127343357,
-0.4906919599,
-0.4842627645,
0.0864681751,
0.0584385544,
0.3823372424,
0.7266189456,
-0.6972301602,
0.2281206399,
0.5006304383,
0.5313697457,
-0.3500056863,
-0.3823514283,
-0.3689219654,
0.473951906,
-0.0542333424,
0.9732396007,
-0.4746495187,
-0.2956671417,
-0.1024353877,
0.0253589414,
-0.0966408849,
-0.2331170589,
0.4429464042,
-0.6201848388,
-0.1407116354,
0.0754056424,
-0.5288117528,
-0.5999292135,
0.080181554,
-0.5654309392,
0.6357753277,
0.1645605117,
-0.627001822,
0.2645706832,
-0.715022862,
-0.908973515,
0.1270939112,
0.0148321092,
-0.4966848791,
-0.0394369289,
0.3316572905,
0.5652133226,
-0.1535688192,
0.6216006875,
-0.4270740151,
-0.1292234808,
0.613088727,
-0.3079416752,
0.7741581798,
0.1232030541,
-0.268967241,
0.2370362878,
-0.5159693956,
-0.0912019461,
0.0240312144,
-0.1011049226,
-0.2831751704,
0.1163817793,
-0.1153216586,
0.3370242417,
0.1394510716,
-0.4962336123,
-0.175550878,
-0.3688376546,
-0.061646603,
1.0848852396,
0.0143033369,
0.486071378,
-0.2626137137,
0.7055686712,
0.1425521523,
0.0203518141,
0.0220010895,
-0.7449114919,
-0.4256327748,
0.2870110869,
0.0782758817,
0.5844864845,
-0.684081912,
0.2263205498,
-0.3769166768,
-0.4928429723,
-0.258620888,
0.0595719852,
0.2860213816,
0.7399677634,
0.2356375903,
0.005638083,
-0.3192312121,
-0.3338705897,
-0.3327406645,
-0.322871834,
-0.0156111903,
0.6426823139,
0.3987269104,
-0.4128708243,
1.1119879484,
-0.4887291193,
0.0188240558,
-0.4265788198,
0.2157940716,
-0.0968681797,
0.4293293953,
0.2902363241,
-1.0723457336,
-0.3523302376,
0.1257401407,
-0.5910692811,
-0.0921935439,
-0.1592911482,
-0.0969078019,
0.2694332004,
0.522900939,
-0.4967992902,
0.7334463596,
0.5773722529,
-0.8060461283,
0.5667549968,
-0.2582373917,
-0.0618534163,
-0.7193071842,
-0.0676738545,
0.1491904259,
-0.5343019962,
-0.612332046,
-0.2896800935,
-0.1543688923,
0.1056364104,
0.0177727379,
0.7280240655,
-0.0470201001,
-0.5251581669,
-0.3433555961,
0.1963024139,
-0.2935938835,
0.4171469808,
0.1516666263,
0.47862342,
0.5157877803,
-0.8324962258,
0.2115621567,
0.0135041056,
-0.5406907201,
0.2699848115,
-0.3986521959,
-0.2573840916,
-0.3631154895,
0.2379526049,
-1.0137358904,
-0.504378438,
0.0771526918,
-0.9075653553,
0.0799251646,
-0.1401767582,
-0.4741464853,
-0.2284676135,
0.4146208763,
0.2157622129,
0.7183717489,
-0.4584304988,
0.9812752604,
0.8468037248,
-0.0339530371,
-0.1153189763,
-0.3756444752,
-0.0471379571,
-0.4821794033,
-0.7800874114,
0.2357413322,
-0.115087457,
-0.309785068,
0.029485492,
0.2064534277,
-0.2391534299,
0.4597420394,
0.640206635,
0.4065456092,
0.138049081,
0.2510709763,
-0.0587939508,
-0.4606515169,
0.3226702213,
-0.0878166705,
0.4007269144,
0.0526241101,
-0.0597474687,
-0.4902365208,
0.0769009218,
0.6267524958,
-0.3530392349,
0.4603178203,
0.8562037945,
-0.1516177356,
-0.0378723666,
-0.1987149268,
-0.2076651901,
-0.4937376082,
0.1652864069,
-0.3611073792,
-0.7800418735,
0.3531194925,
-0.4805102944,
-0.2700516284,
0.3682049513,
0.5386551619,
-0.7048577666,
1.4049904346,
0.4687825739,
0.1350808293,
0.4074315131,
0.0022786381,
0.1436833888,
-0.6010738611,
-0.4600474536,
-0.1345603615,
-0.266228199,
-1.0365517139,
-0.4258463383,
0.6032868624,
-0.2233726829,
-0.330653429,
0.0762894452,
-0.045970697,
0.2246106416,
0.3816044331,
0.0985251591,
0.1688556671,
-0.1345973313,
-0.0097738942,
0.3572510779,
-0.532833159,
-0.1106855199,
0.8439628482,
0.2025646418,
0.8810583353,
0.1567407846,
0.3872927129,
0.2555957437,
0.3026868701,
-0.808295846,
0.6978504658,
-0.1428852528,
-0.3103948832,
-0.4146380424,
-0.8277671933,
-1.1220611334,
-0.0523808785,
-0.4059960544,
-0.7587782145,
-0.0973024368,
0.2137824893,
-0.2982369959,
0.2295602709,
-0.2429694086,
0.94996351,
-0.5492344499,
-0.2625416219,
-0.355699718,
-0.8249501586,
0.2399327457,
0.2023817003,
0.6757081151,
-0.3111423254,
0.2064524591,
0.6508508325,
-0.1859115511,
0.7874560952,
-0.6626224518,
0.1891951561,
0.1508903801,
0.1315367967,
0.6582821012,
-0.2552249134,
-0.0110555533,
-0.0716620609,
-0.4536982179,
0.0787428617,
-0.9405209422,
0.5907582641,
-0.4651248157,
-0.358992815,
-0.1197915301,
-0.7697389722,
-0.3976908326,
0.1059859246,
-0.0047847298,
0.5258384347,
0.206632182,
-0.2910269797,
0.5357248187,
-0.1878515631,
0.2296287268,
0.5990813375,
-0.5449265242,
-0.2011035085,
1.0641605854,
-0.0339919962,
0.0945068523,
0.3689603209,
0.6198951006,
-0.526912272,
-0.5346176624,
-0.5416890383,
0.2613647282,
-0.4274226725,
0.0124117099,
-0.6016031504,
0.0827462077,
-0.5174773335,
-0.2864129543,
-0.0629859567,
-0.599747777,
0.0380061083,
-0.0830328986,
0.4004656672,
1.0840029716,
-0.157626912,
0.5332550406,
-0.282258898,
0.4445638359,
0.4507049322,
0.4494612217,
0.0756242648,
-0.3893321455,
-0.3756992221,
-0.0777990595,
-0.1256408244,
-0.7682433724,
0.4006567895,
-0.3335554004,
0.6212473512,
0.4554004371,
0.2376273125,
0.5767601728,
-0.2102221996,
0.1788772494,
0.2185207009,
-0.5234429836,
0.5567644835,
-0.432431668,
0.1027496606,
0.3102501035,
0.3537364006,
-0.3391558826,
-0.4409829676,
-0.4474856853,
-0.7966148257,
0.4586343467,
0.1637479365,
-0.2729388475,
0.2867981791,
0.177320689,
0.1646349132,
-0.0781546012,
-0.6329353452,
-0.0458787121,
-0.1026552543,
-0.4047980309,
-0.2605519295,
-0.0767875314,
0.3696643114,
-0.511051476,
0.5778683424,
-0.2199392319,
0.1803857386,
-0.020608427,
-0.0211500451,
-0.1057484746,
0.0569279976,
0.4898114204,
0.7954197526,
-0.3465588689,
0.1724182516,
0.026116835,
-0.1808847785,
0.0568276979,
0.1582258791,
-0.4614874721,
-0.0533998832,
0.1021029055,
0.6131609082,
0.0546319,
-0.9024339318,
0.4749055505,
0.0967376307,
0.0555660352,
-0.9478352666,
0.2094773948,
0.0239855908,
0.2807791531,
0.1084470451,
0.1185676306,
0.3234192431,
-0.3009608984,
0.0512324572,
0.4518350959,
-0.7644700408,
-0.3237104416,
0.6959218979,
0.1523694396,
-0.0163842048,
0.2969864309,
-0.4751369059,
-0.6551351547,
0.5857546926,
0.2619155645,
0.8567364812,
-0.3205107152,
0.17254363,
0.5614724755,
-0.000021415,
0.1437688619,
0.050121896,
-0.1007826701,
-0.9504802227,
-0.5427677035,
-0.7148855329,
-0.3124887943,
-0.0677610636,
-0.4698721468,
0.0072852396,
-0.2903527915,
-0.0691724047,
0.1462930441,
-0.2202059031,
-0.499464184,
0.3932144344,
0.1662075669,
0.7926279902,
-0.8427986503,
0.8020903468,
0.7678158283,
-0.2373021245,
-0.5527771115,
0.2268954217,
0.0113236066,
-0.654999733,
0.6874348521,
0.3652217388,
-0.3583208919,
-0.1309317946,
-0.2879690826,
-0.6654253006,
1.1528429985,
0.0769972205,
-0.2046687007,
-0.1451696008,
0.1531609148,
0.140311569,
-0.468336463,
-0.0718546137,
0.5993392467,
0.7550843954,
0.3459765017,
-0.6211961508,
0.137028411,
0.0819954053,
-0.012826141,
0.2229448557,
-0.162249878,
0.7824278474,
-0.3397932649,
-0.0856519043,
0.1956332326,
0.6382879615,
0.3710156381,
0.7518709302,
0.9776775837,
0.6572617292,
0.6784440279,
0.070042938,
1.2336969376,
-0.0904366896,
0.0760681778,
1.1357573271,
-0.0914242044,
0.6448466182,
0.3436685801,
-0.1043430045,
0.9761743546,
0.2540569007,
0.3197467625,
0.7466672659,
-0.0430139042,
-0.2732487917,
-0.7174107432,
-0.019962946,
0.2221938968,
0.9192517996,
0.516708076,
-0.2533771992,
-0.1856872886,
0.0206830371,
-0.1291701496,
0.0517670214,
-0.5239664912,
1.1089986563,
-0.3387415111,
-0.8522055149,
0.0416447446,
-0.0052809734,
0.3256756067,
-0.3986959159,
-0.2185122222,
0.1794284284,
0.2449883074,
-0.1637500674,
-1.3453444242,
0.2659273148,
-0.1537133455,
-0.1484305263,
-0.4211921692,
0.8871182799,
-0.3192483187,
-0.5933598876,
0.4265982211,
0.4609582126,
0.2517473996,
0.0182094127,
-0.40904814,
-0.2829769254,
0.0868665501,
-0.09821482,
0.3245905638,
0.5915890336,
-0.1272762716,
0.9973317981,
0.5936213136,
-0.0017392129,
-0.1478204578,
-0.251290828,
1.0034502745,
-0.759942472,
-0.5756663084,
-0.8067908883,
0.7779241204,
0.0431206599,
-0.0420850627,
0.6458966136,
0.3708562553,
0.4462966323,
0.2326618582,
1.0286290646,
-0.1106144115,
0.9083286524,
-0.6607823968,
0.5233139992,
-0.5660406351,
0.1210751683,
-0.2329379916,
-0.3280419409,
0.1205917001,
0.8274988532,
-0.4691491127,
0.295109123,
0.026241472,
0.5953785777,
-0.2927190661,
-0.0875345245,
0.2778070569,
0.3276981413,
0.2667727172,
0.5901842713,
0.7991394401,
0.2305674404,
0.4093231261,
-0.4731912911,
-0.3429822922,
-0.5508894324,
-0.7690207362,
-0.5932689309,
-0.7323641181,
0.0192361306,
-0.251879245,
-0.1135292873,
0.3428576887,
0.633346498,
-0.6010987759,
-0.2883205712,
-0.4714729786,
0.4091433287,
-0.0431408472,
-0.3160109222,
0.2382699549,
-0.3058260381,
-0.2556859851,
0.4198762774,
0.2215080857,
0.2241866589,
-0.4192236066,
-0.596039474,
-0.028501166,
-0.2104010433,
0.5392562151,
0.2401992679,
-0.6106536984,
-0.1427321434,
-0.1692364365,
0.0951592103,
-0.2675404847,
0.7363449931,
-1.3425863981,
0.484569639,
0.4023135006,
0.3619068861,
0.6774749756,
0.2536965013,
0.7355468273,
-0.2340897918,
-0.057020355,
0.3184576333,
0.3360566497,
0.2864335179,
-0.1928114444,
0.5959932208,
0.1453280151,
-0.6734858155,
-0.3629338443,
0.4684460461,
-1.0781545639,
-0.4845575392,
1.1207789183,
-0.1806828231,
-0.3411989212,
-0.4247675836,
0.1436470598,
0.2068275362,
-0.4093941152,
0.7947009802,
-0.0141916303,
-0.490065068,
-0.3839097917,
-0.7287490368,
0.4882981479,
0.0964670405,
-0.9203215241,
0.4162077904,
0.681441009,
0.0549924485,
-0.09664049,
0.3993277252,
0.2922803462,
0.54682827,
-0.4395755827,
-0.292463392,
-0.2580216229,
-0.4445191324,
0.0719562024,
-0.079787381,
-0.069697842,
0.2635598779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00438v1
|
MetaRM: Shifted Distributions Alignment via Meta-Learning
| 2024-05-01T10:43:55 | 2024-05-01T10:43:55 |
Shihan Dou, Yan Liu, Enyu Zhou, Tianlong Li, Haoxiang Jia, Limao Xiong, Xin Zhao, Junjie Ye, Rui Zheng, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The success of Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) in language
model alignment is critically dependent on the capability of the reward model
(RM). However, as the training process progresses, the output distribution of
the policy model shifts, leading to the RM's reduced ability to distinguish
between responses. This issue is further compounded when the RM, trained on a
specific data distribution, struggles to generalize to examples outside of that
distribution. These two issues can be united as a challenge posed by the
shifted distribution of the environment. To surmount this challenge, we
introduce MetaRM, a method leveraging meta-learning to align the RM with the
shifted environment distribution. MetaRM is designed to train the RM by
minimizing data loss, particularly for data that can improve the
differentiation ability to examples of the shifted target distribution.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that MetaRM significantly improves the RM's
distinguishing ability in iterative RLHF optimization, and also provides the
capacity to identify subtle differences in out-of-distribution samples.
|
[
-0.2660901546,
-0.3051654994,
0.2493333817,
-0.0955843925,
-0.1353249401,
-0.030398773,
-0.2884299755,
0.0131600136,
0.0948527679,
0.432405293,
-1.0302033424,
-0.3631050289,
-0.6372352242,
-0.058590319,
0.0607879981,
1.2001212835,
-0.0676798522,
-0.0348062925,
-0.3007871211,
-0.3114543259,
-0.3965758979,
-0.3656265438,
-0.334990859,
-0.7512111068,
0.7306829095,
0.4628534913,
0.7508631945,
1.0246845484,
0.7707265019,
0.217035085,
0.2058810741,
0.0154293114,
-0.5675909519,
0.2062613666,
-0.4516937137,
-0.1896157861,
-0.072094433,
0.0699554086,
0.6875432134,
0.5092686415,
-0.6275066733,
0.333568275,
0.1763384193,
0.8448426723,
-1.1526451111,
0.1359079182,
-0.3181611598,
0.1548896134,
-0.194163844,
-0.2946710289,
-0.5135241151,
-0.3601797223,
0.0749267265,
-0.5478944182,
0.1102715507,
-0.071211189,
0.7133536339,
0.6908115745,
-0.5116513371,
-0.1533535421,
-1.0507200956,
0.8852921128,
-0.3263610601,
0.600579977,
0.2770311236,
0.6237167716,
0.0550899245,
-0.3592187464,
-0.3071643114,
0.0788339823,
-0.0235551484,
0.0813308805,
0.1533389241,
-0.1500881016,
0.0543625951,
0.0077224057,
-0.4595796466,
-0.0466736034,
-0.3192070723,
-0.2757539749,
0.6440083981,
0.4380575418,
0.1746949703,
-0.0490602292,
-0.2860258222,
-1.0014410019,
-0.6425645947,
0.0833015442,
0.462621063,
0.4454907775,
0.1500014216,
0.3767372668,
0.085201934,
0.6574716568,
-0.0210588947,
-0.3523994684,
0.4358280599,
0.066565603,
-0.2554931641,
0.1002136022,
0.7279218435,
0.2752120793,
-0.3281532824,
0.1097448021,
-0.3493516445,
-0.1296823919,
0.4266971946,
-0.5642613769,
-0.2897521555,
-0.1880690604,
-0.5916718841,
-0.3567356467,
0.3798822463,
-0.8799385428,
-0.4456041753,
-0.2208898962,
0.4078436196,
-0.1329674721,
-0.5942147374,
0.0526687726,
-0.3009622693,
0.259688288,
-0.0092451004,
-1.2758646011,
0.2519576252,
0.7546389699,
0.4868547916,
-0.3052086532,
-0.3299800158,
-0.7121515274,
0.4369293451,
-0.176541239,
0.628845036,
-0.8013586402,
-0.3007383049,
0.0332684182,
0.0314639471,
-0.4473516941,
-0.8251740932,
0.5628675818,
-0.4810936749,
0.3250129521,
-0.460739404,
-0.2580811083,
-0.1666325331,
0.3961866498,
-0.7287521958,
1.0905439854,
0.3933515549,
-0.9152976871,
0.4178762436,
-0.7778552175,
-0.2600954175,
-0.2047285736,
0.0116720852,
-0.6449642777,
-0.0222364701,
0.0124725709,
0.0561658591,
0.0133151338,
0.1042817309,
-0.4628225863,
-0.1469281614,
0.3389024734,
-0.3050566018,
0.4744380116,
0.3544856608,
-0.393673867,
0.1976831257,
-0.5663920045,
0.085472852,
-0.0214530565,
-0.5710616112,
-0.4852871001,
0.2534280419,
-0.0117733125,
0.3464328051,
-0.1346168518,
-0.2012092322,
0.4002412558,
-0.1873183399,
0.38950634,
0.8206802011,
-0.1754757464,
0.8888300061,
-0.2694245279,
0.8617994189,
0.0388764292,
0.2448669672,
0.2961874008,
0.0568816774,
-0.3096170127,
-0.3270772099,
0.5348268151,
0.8120017648,
-0.5696973205,
0.3661851287,
-0.2779320776,
-0.22733289,
-0.7269063592,
0.1557769775,
0.3510441184,
0.6305705905,
0.4328242838,
-0.1038665622,
-0.4968159497,
-0.8491894603,
-0.3665677011,
-0.0454319604,
0.098549597,
0.2288800478,
0.2957791984,
-0.7890056372,
0.9529497027,
-0.7021967173,
-0.1480845213,
-0.2771502137,
0.3803919554,
-0.0928239971,
0.4800962806,
0.2373444587,
-0.7612282634,
-0.341493398,
-0.0897313803,
-0.4569017291,
-0.3544673324,
-0.0364849195,
-0.4495956004,
0.0124936849,
0.5409644842,
-0.372597754,
0.2646099329,
0.6607230902,
-0.1843594015,
0.3821724653,
-0.1770309806,
-0.096400179,
-0.8970326781,
0.1512736529,
-0.3705227673,
-0.3807830811,
-0.3134841025,
-0.0012659056,
0.2473074794,
-0.0342863053,
-0.2997860014,
0.6828773022,
-0.2913940847,
-0.2417186946,
-0.3320177794,
-0.2578009665,
-0.2972091734,
0.4000123441,
0.3610477149,
0.5398644805,
0.2758044302,
-0.9357526898,
0.2984021604,
0.4060615301,
-0.1214616373,
0.6873084903,
-0.3287270069,
0.0472880416,
-0.1318935305,
0.345744729,
-0.7994096279,
-0.2458363324,
0.6828417778,
-0.143733561,
0.2578290701,
0.048429843,
-0.1289388835,
-0.286513418,
-0.2567367256,
0.6318908334,
0.5430672169,
-0.664765358,
0.6142746806,
0.2015271634,
0.0406440832,
-1.0176713467,
-0.5178348422,
-0.4629384279,
-0.5187593102,
-0.1976647526,
0.3727167845,
-0.0449454412,
-0.1967434734,
0.1474883854,
-0.147229746,
0.2399369329,
0.1955643147,
0.2472479641,
-0.0827950686,
0.09937343,
0.5457326174,
0.0444708616,
-0.3945715129,
0.1839326024,
-0.2346495688,
0.4881009758,
0.1935796291,
-0.4608685374,
-0.1828281879,
0.1308084577,
0.3100378215,
-0.2201237977,
0.8593561649,
0.7414873838,
-0.0999838039,
-0.2399712056,
-0.0487305,
-0.3905786276,
-0.4972784221,
0.3227770925,
-0.1060899273,
-0.45969522,
0.2497479171,
-0.2060568333,
0.147660628,
0.521553874,
0.4459644258,
-0.1095508933,
1.1759148836,
0.8559004068,
-0.0834446698,
0.9202457666,
-0.0460054725,
-0.0857519582,
-0.9839049578,
-0.366309315,
-0.3031489551,
-0.7581140995,
-0.4074454308,
-0.2675253749,
0.4061008096,
-0.1389311701,
-0.4758474529,
0.2188359946,
-0.5078849792,
0.4671143889,
0.7213068604,
0.2636103928,
-0.0139690535,
-0.1776940227,
-0.1966378242,
-0.1871726215,
-0.7423571348,
-0.3169365823,
1.009537816,
0.2524844408,
0.9508705735,
0.2043029815,
0.922313273,
0.457739979,
0.5885475874,
-0.4327968359,
0.3509144485,
0.2526134551,
-0.4149309099,
-0.5044305325,
-0.7881967425,
-1.0638318062,
0.2386001945,
-0.3962469995,
-0.1557251364,
0.1229876354,
0.3160985112,
-0.2439785898,
0.2643432617,
-0.5026319623,
1.0661766529,
-0.2903431356,
-0.0684215799,
-0.2257841676,
-0.9075546861,
0.3619581461,
0.2101499438,
0.3080042601,
-0.1028187796,
-0.0015425606,
0.8033427,
-0.4965977073,
0.6248835325,
-0.2737141252,
-0.1365358531,
0.0971790478,
0.2663962841,
0.6145054698,
-0.0761315376,
0.0687147751,
-0.4972236454,
-0.0506256856,
-0.3841135502,
-0.7342290878,
0.215428561,
-0.9055630565,
-0.3929637671,
-0.4026425183,
-0.7448369265,
-0.07052885,
0.0181560628,
0.3709777594,
0.115484409,
-0.4275312424,
0.0365266204,
0.7571939826,
-0.2647592425,
0.4385942817,
0.4549068213,
-0.237689957,
-0.641620338,
0.8754460812,
-0.2333286554,
0.4723326266,
0.6676695347,
0.4620230198,
-0.6648976803,
0.0603723302,
-0.3275651932,
0.2449801415,
-0.9163243771,
-0.307451725,
-0.4644748569,
-0.0878200606,
-0.3672040701,
-0.0702815205,
-0.3037962615,
-0.2422256321,
-0.3583197296,
-0.2395765483,
0.0158232283,
0.7188367248,
-0.4579315782,
0.4130690992,
-0.8075700998,
-0.0054185432,
0.6626618505,
0.1759859473,
-0.2568177879,
-0.6390203238,
-0.1903262734,
0.3373758197,
-0.5161438584,
-1.0156664848,
0.4656280279,
0.231154561,
0.5428210497,
0.6277153492,
0.1668373495,
0.6311175227,
-0.3652083576,
0.3342538774,
0.2180639803,
-0.9217135906,
0.3253422976,
-0.2839705944,
0.2531007826,
0.6021417975,
0.2564882636,
-0.8316632509,
-0.1160675362,
-0.8146799803,
-0.446652025,
0.6879829168,
-0.2492687702,
0.0682203025,
0.0446994454,
0.2495251149,
0.1624581218,
0.2808176875,
-0.9750215411,
-0.036412809,
-0.290243566,
-0.4543263018,
-0.2541511357,
-0.0859253854,
-0.4150748849,
-0.3055852354,
0.5764940977,
-0.2030722797,
0.3363324404,
-0.1351203024,
-0.376109004,
-0.3349018693,
0.3329238892,
1.0832971334,
0.6596370935,
-0.2572140992,
0.5333724022,
0.0867886245,
-0.3440824449,
0.424910605,
-0.179115802,
0.0502039976,
-0.1800921857,
0.3014048636,
0.8799634576,
0.326654911,
-0.6881872416,
0.5305986404,
0.155031234,
-0.4632498026,
0.1422011405,
0.2721783519,
0.1469527781,
0.398652792,
0.2418379933,
0.0911668092,
-0.0629221052,
-0.5654194951,
0.3264892995,
0.5848249197,
-0.4266924858,
-0.2775297165,
0.6476552486,
0.1675717086,
-0.4624226391,
1.0268435478,
-0.3105736077,
-0.7599073052,
0.5181077123,
0.7525663972,
0.893268168,
-0.5234239697,
0.6117042303,
0.4334750175,
0.2371360064,
-0.4977896214,
0.037962798,
-0.1510826945,
-0.8323981762,
-0.0004333479,
-0.2180820704,
-0.5250605345,
-0.2465962917,
-1.0620433092,
0.2526547313,
-0.4342361987,
-0.0906109735,
-0.4943005741,
-0.3825689256,
-0.5756437182,
-0.0205447897,
0.3038316071,
0.5519984365,
-1.3089256287,
0.5802766681,
0.5914800763,
-0.0581857935,
-0.6745436192,
-0.0052591707,
-0.0247883815,
-0.925129354,
0.8452649117,
-0.0160452966,
-0.0830799118,
-0.0945291296,
-0.6021963954,
-0.9693484902,
1.3025825024,
0.4974934161,
-0.442640692,
0.2685714364,
0.1413082927,
0.3619673848,
-0.4279625118,
0.3596706688,
0.459181428,
0.5781309605,
0.1395239234,
-0.6580630541,
-0.0536269099,
0.2098447084,
-0.1653541625,
0.79421556,
-0.48504439,
0.8324838877,
-0.2719229758,
-0.3764008284,
-0.6239131689,
0.5654782057,
0.4727460742,
0.3021176159,
0.6512470245,
0.8568273187,
0.9498888254,
-0.0080129104,
0.8639028668,
0.1240314469,
0.6671131253,
0.9783483148,
-0.365364939,
1.0024467707,
0.439931035,
-0.088777706,
0.9634792805,
0.9805006385,
0.2356538326,
1.1139099598,
0.221292004,
-0.1360130459,
-0.3673527241,
0.2743106484,
-0.4974997342,
0.0087386519,
0.2090165019,
-0.4091994762,
-0.4543140829,
0.2299095243,
-0.2443150133,
-0.0141644543,
-0.3158475757,
0.8711829782,
-0.1548575163,
-0.7375278473,
0.5618509054,
0.0735373497,
0.4023027122,
-0.4912759662,
-0.0143325059,
-0.2356497645,
0.4483132958,
-0.2676576674,
-0.462631613,
0.5325613618,
-0.5458918214,
-0.3893363774,
-0.6018856168,
0.5142037868,
-0.7508231401,
-0.2418495268,
0.1543372422,
0.3504532278,
-0.0751424581,
0.1266869307,
-0.9018815756,
-0.0141276298,
-0.0768716186,
-0.1125834212,
0.4165057838,
0.4148130417,
-0.0043432196,
0.7480368018,
0.418348074,
-0.2114420831,
0.0998412445,
-0.2704981565,
0.5300549269,
-0.7485731244,
-0.6853607297,
-1.1623436213,
0.2141684443,
0.1199789792,
-0.2408916354,
0.4003084302,
0.3225217164,
0.657851696,
-0.3935072422,
0.6894344091,
0.0119420458,
0.5815014243,
-0.5140193701,
0.1757825166,
-0.436648339,
0.096032165,
-0.2218336165,
-1.1695479155,
-0.1804367751,
0.7002668977,
-0.5236829519,
-0.0178206488,
0.9232667685,
0.6544868946,
-0.3044517934,
-0.4831883013,
0.032656841,
-0.461937964,
0.2720680535,
0.8063903451,
0.9911617637,
-0.1963378489,
0.6708966494,
0.0835208371,
0.0690462142,
-0.5183551908,
-1.0987602472,
-0.7189849615,
-0.539031446,
-0.3923697174,
-0.4099312425,
-0.0713785961,
1.2252441645,
0.870513618,
-0.6610879898,
-0.2676828504,
-0.1883767992,
0.5884760618,
-0.85459131,
-0.2330578864,
0.1870744079,
-0.3707591891,
-0.3949555159,
0.092439346,
0.1871317476,
0.082551308,
-0.224076286,
-0.5597352982,
-0.0332088508,
-0.0394159481,
0.0924714878,
0.6548936963,
-0.3681217134,
-0.3021920323,
0.0275765881,
-0.3607008457,
0.0768641531,
1.0876557827,
-0.6481848955,
0.1578785479,
0.6757419109,
0.96858567,
0.2988983095,
0.3886234164,
0.7231603265,
-0.8748525977,
0.0555230826,
0.1338602006,
0.0006411928,
0.3010033071,
-0.3099181652,
0.5516628027,
0.2991536558,
-0.7350491285,
-0.9547294378,
0.3837827146,
-0.611045897,
-0.2429586202,
1.3489917517,
0.3413597345,
-0.3219142556,
0.2194886506,
-0.0701811239,
0.2021118402,
-0.1926748455,
0.9066976905,
0.8647300005,
-0.0251986049,
-0.564160943,
-0.2964351177,
0.9248723388,
0.685651958,
-0.9324615598,
0.2716987133,
0.2767875195,
0.5770484209,
0.0212502442,
0.5247333646,
0.1788619906,
0.1860999614,
-0.4706280828,
0.2568980157,
0.1239340454,
-0.4261851609,
-0.5549818873,
-0.0543702245,
-0.023483688,
-0.5688360333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00402v1
|
Self-Refine Instruction-Tuning for Aligning Reasoning in Language Models
| 2024-05-01T09:10:27 | 2024-05-01T09:10:27 |
Leonardo Ranaldi, Andrè Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The alignments of reasoning abilities between smaller and larger Language
Models are largely conducted via Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) using
demonstrations generated from robust Large Language Models (LLMs). Although
these approaches deliver more performant models, they do not show sufficiently
strong generalization ability as the training only relies on the provided
demonstrations.
In this paper, we propose the Self-refine Instruction-tuning method that
elicits Smaller Language Models to self-refine their abilities. Our approach is
based on a two-stage process, where reasoning abilities are first transferred
between LLMs and Small Language Models (SLMs) via Instruction-tuning on
demonstrations provided by LLMs, and then the instructed models Self-refine
their abilities through preference optimization strategies. In particular, the
second phase operates refinement heuristics based on the Direct Preference
Optimization algorithm, where the SLMs are elicited to deliver a series of
reasoning paths by automatically sampling the generated responses and providing
rewards using ground truths from the LLMs. Results obtained on commonsense and
math reasoning tasks show that this approach significantly outperforms
Instruction-tuning in both in-domain and out-domain scenarios, aligning the
reasoning abilities of Smaller and Larger Language Models.
|
[
-0.2578141093,
-0.6419100761,
0.6143277287,
-0.1770166457,
-0.2316796929,
-0.2308071107,
-0.5410689116,
0.1003671139,
-0.1519402564,
0.6890161037,
-0.8821165562,
-0.2299497724,
-0.2890928984,
-0.0400365144,
0.1253069639,
0.8130948544,
0.0591579974,
0.0550069176,
-0.3459158242,
0.0521722473,
-0.6816624403,
-0.0850206316,
-0.6215459704,
-0.5584305525,
0.2624237835,
0.7779684067,
0.5283085704,
0.9789287448,
0.2408379465,
0.3363755047,
0.3532006741,
0.4776692688,
-0.5012432337,
0.1097556949,
-0.7442916036,
-0.3611087799,
-0.3059633076,
-0.000196528,
0.4890992045,
0.3526336253,
-0.2057913393,
0.4471918046,
0.1664915234,
0.8261047602,
-0.5139442682,
0.0618150458,
-0.8634846807,
-0.1780660003,
0.0725216269,
-0.3463011384,
-0.5192105174,
-0.2764969766,
-0.0606014729,
-0.517208457,
0.3518958092,
0.155454427,
0.7398824692,
0.6773118973,
-0.148431316,
0.032487683,
-0.4268875122,
1.0443280935,
-0.9770498276,
0.2699063718,
0.209262535,
0.3034453988,
-0.0890546143,
-0.3525593281,
-0.2449228913,
-0.2057987303,
-0.2680840194,
-0.1355734318,
0.0486751907,
-0.0146667203,
0.382496953,
0.0702229068,
-0.5985258818,
0.3933822811,
-0.2503044009,
-0.170779869,
0.7755352259,
0.1294866502,
-0.1137533933,
-0.011349665,
-0.228504926,
-0.0459914431,
-0.7488125563,
-0.0843326077,
0.3902567029,
0.5502501726,
0.1476257741,
0.5470273495,
-0.4856342077,
0.907542944,
0.716344893,
-0.2974195182,
0.0181556493,
-0.3593949378,
-0.2399516404,
-0.0179876182,
0.6935667396,
0.2573693097,
0.3768424392,
0.113951616,
-0.2862954736,
-0.0875097513,
0.368555367,
-0.7746543884,
-0.3438646197,
-0.0887130275,
-0.3798636794,
-0.2136478722,
-0.3567746282,
-0.7337929606,
-0.0596266538,
-0.8911641836,
0.6743043661,
-0.2559892535,
-0.15764606,
0.2465959638,
0.2488833964,
0.088634938,
0.3525971472,
-1.3586221933,
0.1810662299,
0.7878442407,
0.3157261312,
-0.0413969085,
-0.2210689187,
-0.5871973038,
0.1831072569,
-0.3111430407,
0.8135816455,
-0.6155177951,
-0.0264959596,
-0.1062216759,
-0.0670233667,
-0.334536016,
-0.6062372327,
0.3550879657,
-0.3462295234,
0.2377822399,
-0.2453164756,
-0.6712052822,
0.1068359986,
0.1199891046,
-0.1716184467,
1.1088032722,
-0.0126830665,
-0.4073720276,
0.0831775814,
-0.4675205648,
-0.4152754247,
-0.1823554039,
-0.3651121855,
-0.4455418587,
0.1212800071,
0.4965586364,
0.449390918,
-0.2547430694,
0.1693988144,
-0.3189779222,
-0.3540777564,
-0.1565659344,
-0.2250918746,
0.3330535889,
0.2270773798,
-0.5890302658,
0.2970924675,
-0.4728202522,
0.5349547863,
0.1134495288,
0.094139412,
-0.1464625895,
0.0176904127,
-0.8837616444,
0.2850960195,
0.5542336106,
-0.2656034529,
0.510892868,
-0.672080636,
0.4535115063,
0.905287087,
-0.1675878018,
0.6893354654,
-0.2428383082,
0.4177157581,
-0.0790489092,
0.1192405447,
-0.1722100973,
-0.3390288353,
-1.0397875309,
0.0323119909,
0.3125092387,
0.4266740084,
-0.5297242403,
0.6165465713,
-0.209653452,
-0.2456698865,
-0.8562544584,
0.3871218562,
0.5704997778,
0.7607035637,
0.5255651474,
0.1722851694,
-0.2339568883,
-1.2135176659,
-0.3150629103,
0.0307157766,
0.1411118656,
0.310061276,
0.4248921871,
0.0751725957,
0.8876173496,
-0.5152565837,
-0.2262436897,
0.0321006402,
0.1923824102,
-0.0055513573,
0.6417841911,
0.2159003019,
-0.2265988886,
-0.5116926432,
0.0886566266,
-0.4292155504,
-0.3657242656,
-0.1106064618,
-0.3059782982,
0.2896172404,
0.595828414,
-0.1574866474,
0.2514039576,
0.3068667352,
-0.1255129576,
0.6110715866,
-0.3731543422,
0.1177509278,
-0.6589959264,
-0.3775001168,
-0.0338051468,
-0.2293648422,
-0.2183900476,
0.1112854406,
0.1405600309,
0.0297872331,
0.0420689434,
0.6814226508,
-0.6311283708,
0.0590402707,
-0.5294604301,
0.3242399693,
0.1759346426,
0.6069787741,
0.2319273353,
0.875234127,
0.5611556172,
-0.4574628174,
0.254157573,
-0.1486760974,
-0.1732650846,
0.5189564824,
-0.4404430985,
0.3142172396,
0.1238920316,
-0.0525229797,
-0.8334518671,
0.0280586574,
0.0737353414,
-0.0904401392,
0.3743056059,
-0.4512123466,
-0.3324247897,
-0.4100446403,
0.0119400006,
0.2522119582,
0.6006547213,
-0.7890689969,
0.6188440919,
-0.0374856181,
-0.1870283335,
-0.5110875368,
-0.3671941459,
-0.4856229722,
-0.1514096707,
-0.715708077,
0.2198545933,
-0.1157208607,
-0.0125393467,
-0.1381951571,
-0.3600941896,
0.2201453,
-0.105483599,
-0.0210162513,
0.1805595011,
-0.4407795668,
0.310401082,
0.6041722298,
-0.3534745872,
-0.0629269406,
-0.5979738235,
0.3420047164,
-0.3045981526,
-0.6522477269,
-0.4463283122,
0.1638835818,
0.1184923425,
-0.3558442891,
0.4988892376,
0.4598050117,
-0.079294309,
-0.4787399471,
-0.8311659694,
-0.6123057008,
-0.5273698568,
0.0821513385,
-0.5914403796,
-1.0777810812,
0.0361499712,
-0.3616561294,
0.097769849,
0.5790861845,
0.7187085152,
-0.0958500206,
1.4428701401,
0.3991929889,
0.0773248747,
0.3124924302,
-0.1978816241,
0.2720061243,
-0.8273374438,
-0.0348537453,
-0.5857902169,
-0.2599644959,
-0.375954181,
-0.4446751475,
0.0615995228,
0.1604222208,
-0.5399554968,
0.2688345611,
-0.8163094521,
0.7913399935,
0.5782450438,
0.0286113322,
0.2145376503,
0.1110300794,
-0.4092737734,
-0.2467135787,
-0.7288480997,
-0.7171824574,
0.85919559,
0.2208941728,
0.9608765244,
-0.0103676766,
0.849270761,
0.0000279031,
0.2141690105,
-0.5647787452,
0.5285944939,
-0.3606625795,
-0.5057417154,
-0.5080358386,
-0.5067335367,
-0.5886049271,
0.3335136175,
-0.0941669047,
-0.7581768036,
0.1065009758,
0.5353055,
-0.4881359935,
-0.0309178252,
-1.0384254456,
1.1135482788,
-0.4224526882,
-0.5333767533,
-0.6119737625,
-0.5184746981,
0.3557858765,
0.1827638447,
0.1471818984,
-0.3286817968,
0.1666343212,
0.3327251971,
-0.3853670657,
0.87746948,
-0.1394006908,
-0.3157638013,
0.1591402888,
0.2621669769,
0.5435832739,
0.1344217509,
-0.1928984225,
-0.2468530536,
0.0859554335,
-0.27983886,
-1.0271840096,
0.9770556092,
-0.7379007339,
-1.1276800632,
-0.0662619397,
-0.3282165527,
-0.4626866281,
0.2269370854,
0.0934263542,
0.3373309076,
0.1264312416,
-0.1738155186,
0.7492411733,
0.240016818,
0.1050572544,
0.7040640712,
-0.2363656014,
-0.3257621229,
1.1403135061,
-0.1109834909,
0.6143825054,
0.3433847129,
0.4652268887,
-0.4415069818,
-0.3485310376,
-0.6792243719,
0.4125374556,
-0.6320741773,
-0.3752302527,
-0.1838052869,
-0.1840446889,
-0.5747249722,
-0.2189485729,
-0.5743433237,
-0.4807462394,
-0.3890377283,
0.1265809834,
0.1938005388,
0.3619112074,
-0.1584654301,
0.3004366457,
-0.3883728981,
0.4579379857,
0.7003341913,
0.3774468303,
-0.0464450307,
-1.0190545321,
-0.2667473853,
0.2625917494,
-0.3314930201,
-0.4680794477,
0.1472591013,
0.2553016543,
0.4076013863,
0.4516783655,
-0.0723362565,
0.9281575084,
-0.6021293998,
0.4392277896,
0.0303068999,
-0.8537722826,
0.871516943,
-0.2766788304,
0.3262581229,
0.7599777579,
-0.0595890395,
-0.0417999625,
-0.1698018014,
-0.5631586313,
-0.2749635875,
0.8525684476,
-0.0342333503,
0.0592429675,
0.0342778526,
0.5765723586,
0.0956693292,
0.0755998641,
-0.4827857614,
-0.1166029423,
-0.3673346639,
-0.3545466959,
0.1182988286,
-0.1043679118,
-0.3906215429,
-0.5655568242,
1.0686846972,
-0.7082284689,
0.0219692141,
-0.1116241664,
0.0878850594,
-0.4009990096,
0.3993054926,
0.6164119244,
0.5827103853,
0.0428723767,
0.0596994348,
0.1609868258,
0.1872134805,
0.224108994,
0.1151107401,
-0.2631290555,
-0.4964259863,
0.0155136837,
0.9428324103,
0.296854198,
-0.4577465951,
0.4683270752,
0.0140484897,
-0.1923618913,
0.0132291429,
0.5378702283,
0.1585709602,
0.4093278944,
-0.0446468778,
0.0071865241,
-0.0184846316,
-0.2255702019,
0.0047695315,
0.651432097,
-0.1310272962,
-0.0447004884,
0.4106114507,
0.1673419923,
-0.2906488776,
0.6377630234,
-0.2613428235,
-0.3325794339,
0.4495847225,
0.9078826904,
0.7791119218,
-0.1902382076,
0.2271237969,
0.6123625636,
0.3059570491,
-0.3093809783,
0.0252898689,
-0.1256559193,
-0.9255923033,
-0.6358398795,
-0.5836898685,
-0.2878965437,
0.0708783865,
-0.6839419007,
0.2645071745,
-0.3613740802,
0.0059092725,
0.0098549323,
0.0383058041,
-0.4697022736,
0.2953693569,
0.0683556572,
0.714464128,
-0.744692564,
0.9745039344,
0.488360852,
-0.1646020561,
-1.0730968714,
-0.0899113566,
-0.0380968936,
-0.9431881905,
0.61106354,
0.0739630908,
-0.4649996758,
0.3153140843,
-0.5610799193,
-0.9554662704,
0.9152787328,
0.6300451159,
-0.995403409,
-0.0386760049,
-0.030023355,
0.6532099247,
-0.671095252,
0.1935185492,
0.777952075,
0.4286335409,
0.1625564992,
-0.8570219874,
-0.0213534068,
-0.0358447768,
0.0146927312,
0.2082431316,
-0.870518744,
0.4209584892,
-0.374579519,
-0.0480238087,
0.1598839313,
0.8955235481,
0.4267807007,
-0.0740208849,
0.5932735205,
0.772433877,
0.6690667868,
-0.1450603306,
0.5758380294,
-0.3723986149,
0.4205020666,
1.4795725346,
-0.2622129917,
0.7399354577,
0.3358677626,
0.0084336111,
0.7288030982,
0.4028959572,
-0.0546384081,
0.5106915832,
0.1907988191,
-0.0548264496,
-0.7928329706,
0.2323508114,
-0.3342681527,
0.3306982517,
0.3537086844,
-0.2231160998,
-0.1435473412,
-0.1621486843,
-0.1925783157,
0.3699784279,
-0.3731137514,
0.7773557901,
-0.0216948837,
-1.1646386385,
0.6801254749,
0.1303379387,
0.3780651093,
-0.4739244282,
-0.1034387425,
-0.1388353854,
0.2690035999,
-0.098217316,
-0.6403710842,
0.1375881582,
-0.1325724274,
-0.2614969313,
-0.391120851,
0.8232984543,
-0.61343503,
-0.3997358978,
0.134881258,
0.3885652125,
-0.0303152911,
0.1095051169,
-0.98459059,
-0.230666101,
0.1157314107,
-0.0903336331,
0.5092762113,
0.5348028541,
-0.1008241475,
0.7263200283,
0.4711762965,
-0.0677674934,
0.04708701,
0.5005726218,
0.7506914139,
-0.489769727,
-0.3417097032,
-0.8376216292,
0.3036512434,
-0.0689503253,
-0.2452164292,
0.6865685582,
0.5108540058,
0.8050775528,
-0.1373954564,
0.5401135087,
0.2409452498,
0.7185686827,
-0.7420940995,
0.2744948566,
-0.5810277462,
0.2906998694,
0.0589530617,
-0.6438688636,
0.139048323,
0.9136365652,
-0.6018784046,
0.2858950198,
0.584359169,
1.0571130514,
-0.1466821134,
-0.0401663072,
0.2823558748,
0.1265619695,
-0.0131857274,
0.4038589895,
0.5870495439,
-0.134584859,
0.248767972,
-0.5016292334,
-0.3015648127,
-0.1241465062,
-0.8672302961,
-0.9977291226,
-0.256839633,
-0.458080858,
-0.134063378,
0.0603165776,
0.8867418766,
0.8842871785,
-0.8498443961,
-0.1718225032,
-0.0086236428,
0.1682359278,
-0.4211283028,
-0.268346101,
0.3540090919,
-0.799053967,
-0.6139430404,
0.5954926014,
0.303290695,
-0.2738978267,
-0.5155794621,
-0.0762384161,
-0.0359400213,
0.2283698618,
0.357961297,
0.3071809113,
-0.975718081,
-0.562004745,
0.0337833539,
-0.1283272803,
0.0629619882,
0.7793669105,
-0.8510180712,
0.5672313571,
0.2080565989,
0.4347478449,
0.5667918921,
0.263916105,
0.5067321062,
-0.8749827743,
-0.1933900416,
0.0314362645,
0.276072681,
0.2298975736,
-0.3873660862,
0.3756659031,
-0.0167662911,
-0.8695710897,
-0.5922307372,
0.3826599419,
-0.7087709904,
-0.1996215731,
1.0659451485,
0.0305863842,
-0.0165806767,
0.2131616771,
-0.3400125206,
0.1184726357,
-0.373937428,
0.8637675643,
0.5384011865,
-0.3857781589,
-0.2813699543,
-0.1737128198,
0.5838779211,
0.754135251,
-0.743453145,
0.3482960761,
0.5041287541,
0.4792791307,
0.0603617392,
0.5121171474,
0.0435868315,
0.2705560625,
-0.3196395338,
-0.0571286827,
-0.0893665254,
-0.4553179443,
-0.3742845058,
-0.0567491241,
0.1926172227,
0.1556796134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01601v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01601v1
|
Efficient Sample-Specific Encoder Perturbations
| 2024-05-01T08:55:16 | 2024-05-01T08:55:16 |
Yassir Fathullah, Mark J. F. Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Encoder-decoder foundation models have displayed state-of-the-art performance
on a range of autoregressive sequence tasks. This paper proposes a simple and
lightweight modification to such systems to control the behaviour according to
a specific attribute of interest. This paper proposes a novel
inference-efficient approach to modifying the behaviour of an encoder-decoder
system according to a specific attribute of interest. Specifically, we show
that a small proxy network can be used to find a sample-by-sample perturbation
of the encoder output of a frozen foundation model to trigger the decoder to
generate improved decodings. This work explores a specific realization of this
framework focused on improving the COMET performance of Flan-T5 on Machine
Translation and the WER of Whisper foundation models on Speech Recognition.
Results display consistent improvements in performance evaluated through COMET
and WER respectively. Furthermore, experiments also show that the proxies are
robust to the exact nature of the data used to train them and can extend to
other domains.
|
[
-0.0979832634,
-0.5155875087,
-0.0316290744,
0.0946559981,
-0.131844461,
-0.1904056668,
-0.0035570979,
-0.2869439125,
0.3844000995,
0.4562722743,
-0.3429547548,
-0.2082058489,
-0.6109827757,
0.1734316051,
-0.7877955437,
0.4806444049,
0.22419855,
0.0821288675,
0.2230665982,
0.0282622408,
-0.0021901741,
-0.519841969,
-0.4731001854,
-0.335649699,
0.1812360436,
0.2337890416,
0.7775374651,
0.8127655387,
0.485247016,
0.3327331543,
-0.2192146331,
-0.2065451294,
-0.5584976077,
0.141451031,
-0.3239004314,
-0.5491375327,
-0.2796215713,
-0.5232118964,
0.5927324295,
0.8427143097,
-0.2680442333,
0.1617721915,
0.088852562,
0.5167207718,
-0.9887081981,
-0.0462002493,
-0.684040606,
0.0291357879,
-0.1105467081,
-0.2732921243,
-0.4618784189,
-0.0038309621,
-0.0494541191,
-0.3166278005,
0.6924712062,
-0.2382084429,
0.730243504,
0.58466959,
-0.0109650092,
-0.1377864331,
-0.7576456666,
0.5919499993,
-0.6688563824,
0.7447162867,
0.2381553352,
0.3133126199,
-0.4705206156,
-0.8246617913,
-0.4911501706,
0.1631460786,
-0.0841362774,
0.0823139995,
-0.1106384322,
0.0142151313,
0.1180277392,
0.4172136486,
-0.1685453951,
0.0693182573,
0.063788496,
-0.4596803486,
0.2901274562,
0.1493983567,
-0.0444551706,
0.0135494601,
0.1652346104,
-0.5356765389,
-0.6828685403,
0.2052446306,
0.4322260022,
0.361176759,
0.1063810587,
0.4914052188,
-0.5922815204,
0.8055633903,
0.5298033357,
-0.0044966508,
0.2507352233,
0.0353230461,
-0.3381017148,
0.2229857147,
0.5211268067,
-0.0967305973,
-0.2006105185,
-0.3644257188,
-0.5766316652,
0.3367147148,
-0.003208563,
-1.0450927019,
-0.4072808325,
0.2067733258,
-0.4235825539,
-0.2607674003,
0.1571425349,
-0.6840430498,
-0.2112940997,
0.0986150876,
0.6172060966,
-0.3501110673,
-0.1293795854,
0.5331496596,
-0.3077958226,
0.0407581069,
0.226227805,
-0.8715427518,
0.6040506959,
0.2459839582,
0.6642551422,
0.1409729719,
-0.0024724028,
-1.021884203,
0.1715822071,
-0.3009657264,
0.5919424295,
-0.8020274639,
-0.3442908525,
-0.1665296406,
-0.0795977637,
-0.0185627323,
-0.5960167646,
0.1051527709,
-0.7148062587,
-0.344045192,
-0.2506850362,
-0.5082131028,
0.1483470947,
-0.1806005985,
-0.9512208104,
0.5652318597,
0.0049085892,
-0.6937174201,
0.1151557714,
-0.6541197896,
-0.5756701827,
-0.272395581,
0.0356751531,
-0.2294320762,
0.0785498247,
0.5406458974,
0.4860556126,
-0.2253456265,
-0.0802655444,
-0.0994599685,
-0.6374437809,
0.3627032042,
-0.3123512566,
0.5420147181,
0.3488742113,
-0.5392323732,
-0.1221332178,
-0.9615160823,
-0.0388786085,
-0.1104243323,
-0.4785878956,
-0.2281241715,
0.206496194,
-0.1388342083,
-0.2313411981,
-0.0268953796,
-0.426661253,
-0.083377257,
-0.4982984066,
0.5204043388,
0.357725203,
0.1134523749,
0.6184410453,
-0.1732669324,
0.447221905,
0.0558620207,
0.0123108095,
-0.3623754382,
-0.1414120346,
-0.8427129388,
-0.5080299973,
0.7380584478,
0.4265854061,
-0.9195051789,
0.3138837814,
-0.2370328903,
-0.1740407348,
-0.8752216101,
0.1117274761,
0.4541015923,
0.5899094343,
0.58597368,
-0.4619349241,
-0.2778181136,
-0.7052257061,
-0.5188187957,
0.0564368516,
-0.2588731647,
0.016605353,
0.3496026695,
0.0087766415,
0.9523774981,
-0.2656336129,
0.0094969869,
-0.0001052035,
-0.0543701239,
0.4577983022,
0.8930417299,
0.3633780777,
-1.0152961016,
-0.2548662126,
-0.3130827844,
-0.3735636175,
-0.3438228071,
-0.0534635112,
-0.1644510031,
-0.2098061889,
0.4518072605,
-0.4144354165,
0.7249180675,
0.3575106859,
-0.3741743565,
0.3750451505,
0.0752526373,
0.2896789312,
-0.6327203512,
-0.0312128812,
-0.1342450827,
-0.28701666,
-0.8469136953,
0.2839655876,
0.1831317842,
0.2192282975,
-0.5413175225,
0.2848103642,
-0.5212939978,
-0.1874693185,
-0.1083346158,
-0.3204702139,
-0.0548480339,
0.2290879339,
0.3015922308,
0.6138931513,
0.5954212546,
-0.9770333767,
0.0729063228,
0.3403207958,
-0.194287017,
0.3004705012,
-0.6937164068,
0.3354949355,
-0.2747329473,
0.4053417146,
-0.6103628278,
-0.2958979607,
0.1731589586,
-0.4627998471,
0.3229954243,
-0.4235559404,
-0.4872623384,
-0.1039847061,
0.0227379408,
0.112951763,
0.650639236,
-0.8068190217,
0.9260352254,
0.0534445383,
0.4509200454,
-0.6468914151,
-0.9842068553,
0.0361274481,
-0.0687017962,
-0.4322694242,
0.6022429466,
-0.2005727142,
-0.1003433987,
0.0608719401,
-0.3231828511,
0.0011442906,
0.0537924953,
0.1932819486,
-0.3850024045,
-0.2121827751,
-0.1126889884,
0.3396048844,
-0.011314624,
-0.2097350955,
-0.4517120123,
0.5006247759,
-0.0389701873,
-0.3153865039,
-0.4801009297,
0.2406000346,
0.398336947,
-0.2998394072,
0.748690784,
0.3678830266,
-0.4083417058,
-0.5444587469,
-0.6415269971,
-0.7121462822,
-0.5994784236,
0.2182247639,
-1.0383774042,
-0.7241083384,
0.6845782995,
-0.1423178315,
-0.2257998288,
0.153896302,
0.3202162385,
0.1931529641,
0.8449408412,
0.588771522,
-0.1154288054,
0.4694094062,
-0.5210573673,
-0.1101188585,
-0.683539629,
-0.0029457428,
-0.5938458443,
-0.3582543731,
-0.2451968342,
-0.3748889565,
0.2080136985,
0.2946824431,
-0.3325663209,
0.5162344575,
-0.371434778,
0.347235918,
0.3012649715,
0.3449904323,
0.1273909211,
0.0441575423,
-0.4068686664,
0.2555461526,
-1.1414405107,
-0.4165202677,
0.7670070529,
0.1810227633,
0.9817185998,
0.368370086,
0.7202319503,
0.3033231795,
0.1677678525,
-0.3757572174,
0.4924361706,
-0.5178195238,
-0.3286983967,
-0.2938145995,
-0.4489684999,
-0.7448518276,
0.4332564771,
-0.1559851468,
-0.8080890179,
0.8019863367,
0.5655195117,
-0.2908321917,
0.3315930665,
-0.5492563844,
0.4710302055,
0.2072172165,
-0.5273168683,
-0.1316560507,
-0.4543205798,
-0.0881573483,
-0.0749899596,
0.0143281119,
0.1650374532,
-0.079464592,
0.4553775489,
-0.6331240535,
1.0371425152,
-0.4241416454,
0.2054411173,
0.3248762786,
0.3403954506,
0.567114234,
0.0248633195,
-0.6891927123,
0.0226225741,
-0.029775342,
-0.4589681625,
-0.8594332933,
0.4731375575,
-0.5559684038,
-0.5466370583,
0.0763698369,
-0.203551352,
-0.2675893605,
0.0836672708,
0.4069062769,
0.7706002593,
-0.1433669329,
0.4028675556,
0.6916148067,
-0.0476942956,
0.500218749,
0.8656746149,
0.1899318546,
-0.343785584,
0.5032231808,
-0.0149320774,
0.3853555322,
0.8963712454,
0.2854825258,
-0.1468082964,
-0.6897532344,
-0.4611841738,
-0.1497529745,
-0.9515134692,
-0.3284709454,
-0.6462727189,
0.0504408441,
-0.515167594,
-0.170418486,
-0.558818996,
-0.4513200223,
-0.444347918,
0.0708961412,
0.3958002031,
0.4437384605,
-0.1553705633,
0.6878566146,
-0.7328236699,
0.3084631562,
0.254820317,
0.3405678272,
-0.0271342844,
-0.7858709693,
-0.14665398,
0.1686583906,
0.2762198448,
-1.0635085106,
0.3836689889,
0.5704230666,
0.5284335613,
0.3802646995,
0.443384409,
0.7706382871,
-0.5217954516,
0.6615179181,
0.0408922732,
-1.3827131987,
0.5762920976,
-0.0436256565,
0.4044118524,
0.32065171,
0.1188636422,
-0.0047178911,
-0.4287382066,
-0.416732043,
-0.6799476743,
0.5049586296,
0.4314965904,
0.0425849035,
0.1108256504,
0.7139787078,
-0.0294607971,
0.207516551,
0.0455251969,
-0.118364431,
-0.67606318,
-0.2864458859,
0.064128004,
-0.0378145203,
0.1010176167,
-0.1092996448,
0.5877273083,
-0.343880564,
0.2371779978,
0.5496244431,
-0.4167730808,
-0.138831526,
0.1643622071,
0.157249406,
0.3777535558,
-0.2509152591,
0.2603802383,
0.2434979826,
-0.5823433399,
0.1761207879,
-0.0180048272,
-0.4096131623,
0.0320506319,
0.1964044124,
0.8920499682,
0.2744591534,
-0.4627750516,
0.3435745239,
-0.0195892453,
-0.1498378813,
-0.1061963663,
0.5224719644,
-0.1177188009,
0.4001227319,
0.5416361094,
0.2496000081,
0.4603525996,
-0.3727320135,
0.3077653944,
0.0356271043,
-0.2198820412,
-0.492775023,
0.8304673433,
0.0711381361,
-0.3884156346,
0.4460218847,
-0.0310329553,
-0.5766434669,
0.6537709832,
0.8374279141,
0.6997334361,
-0.5303162932,
-0.0889280066,
0.2669157088,
0.2680375278,
-0.3291481733,
0.3075017631,
-0.1544314176,
-1.178155303,
-0.39466241,
-0.7068179846,
-0.3112027943,
0.02509569,
-0.8741357923,
0.1002998352,
-0.3411046863,
-0.3416243196,
0.0234668422,
-0.4538064003,
-1.0218536854,
0.5290042162,
-0.2444283515,
1.1511381865,
-0.6160898209,
1.062633872,
0.6892910004,
-0.1989443451,
-0.7395131588,
0.053465195,
-0.0952814445,
-0.3124256134,
0.6173522472,
-0.1817975193,
-0.649936676,
0.2012576163,
-0.5084306598,
-1.0744774342,
0.9198601842,
0.5795452595,
-0.8952313066,
0.3228755295,
-0.1007933691,
0.4762460887,
-0.5061123967,
0.2420452684,
0.7712473273,
0.3135472536,
0.1157895923,
-0.9701296091,
0.1251358986,
-0.4829238057,
0.2112046331,
0.0016344476,
-0.6347042322,
0.4780142009,
-0.1190164089,
-0.1089525074,
0.2327174693,
0.8603135347,
-0.0075549767,
-0.1240236461,
0.7917087078,
0.3295943737,
0.6403115988,
-0.0004864242,
1.0130255222,
-0.4848049581,
0.0104630468,
1.0816694498,
-0.1441947222,
1.0363340378,
0.5376952291,
-0.0844817236,
0.3394391239,
0.3184753954,
-0.0026004699,
0.9419565201,
0.3615635633,
-0.2969891727,
-0.3119236529,
0.2670028508,
-0.0761151835,
0.5576415658,
0.6724233031,
-0.2424557656,
0.1862345487,
0.0991208404,
-0.1582580209,
0.0825510547,
-0.3173613846,
0.5203140974,
-0.0496598966,
-0.3344577849,
0.6784985662,
0.3242041171,
0.8440680504,
-0.638102591,
-0.0493019633,
-0.1707554311,
0.3390204012,
-0.3109883666,
-0.0700231045,
0.1514862478,
0.0652221218,
-0.2936378717,
-0.0166289825,
0.7385064363,
-0.428883791,
-0.3162317872,
0.2687928379,
0.1153103113,
0.2709053159,
0.0257555321,
-0.3906152248,
0.3486804366,
-0.1010037735,
-0.3784469068,
0.1987528056,
0.152970612,
0.2184807062,
0.5566788912,
0.7167013288,
0.2266460508,
0.3058817983,
0.2533804178,
0.8668660522,
-0.5053601861,
-0.8102376461,
-0.5200188756,
0.493843317,
0.0164130256,
-0.0470743813,
0.4696671367,
0.3021602333,
0.7383319139,
-0.214650631,
0.7683050632,
-0.1616943628,
0.4588710368,
-0.8020316362,
0.7325115204,
-0.2954450548,
0.6523978114,
-0.1955124438,
-0.683734417,
-0.2989684939,
0.7487350702,
-0.0418916419,
-0.0857703984,
0.5405510068,
1.1359190941,
-0.0739099458,
0.1400030851,
0.3644925654,
0.3604565561,
0.401524961,
0.2045725286,
0.4617321491,
-0.5647183657,
0.3172724545,
-0.5043385029,
-0.2309219986,
-0.1091165468,
-1.0113884211,
-0.7501797676,
-0.4798709452,
-0.5229386687,
-0.5373986959,
0.6644811034,
0.8138903379,
0.9475103617,
-1.1644223928,
-0.1455860585,
0.0251209904,
-0.1391493976,
-0.5195007324,
-0.1765969098,
0.4444950223,
-0.1969700605,
-0.684802413,
0.9318180084,
-0.1833491325,
0.0178255364,
-0.0380890407,
-0.2835643888,
0.357757628,
0.2646445632,
0.3276256919,
0.2761145532,
-0.667442739,
-0.3322247565,
-0.0302748121,
0.3186363578,
-0.0668010935,
0.9528582692,
-1.0576968193,
0.5165224671,
0.4870072305,
0.6798050404,
0.8266276717,
-0.0138745969,
0.6692941189,
-0.6341238618,
0.2241601944,
0.2455846518,
0.4507018924,
0.4910719097,
-0.5741580725,
0.4363240004,
0.2132695168,
-0.1080359742,
-0.7583376169,
0.1377629042,
-0.45674178,
-0.2701528668,
1.0040830374,
-0.2461144179,
-0.4116507173,
0.042943202,
0.346614033,
0.2598241568,
-0.6332517862,
0.6059108973,
0.2503331602,
-0.0115023153,
-0.2286006808,
-0.221974358,
0.4231527746,
0.3632743657,
-0.3068292141,
-0.3772785068,
0.4874598086,
0.6274495721,
-0.0158710778,
0.653281033,
-0.1396178454,
0.2565097511,
0.2066653818,
0.0290899798,
-0.095239982,
-0.4045920968,
-0.4972202182,
0.4185999632,
-0.1571208388,
-0.3243385553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00390v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00390v2
|
CofiPara: A Coarse-to-fine Paradigm for Multimodal Sarcasm Target Identification with Large Multimodal Models
| 2024-05-01T08:44:44 | 2024-05-20T07:25:27 |
Hongzhan Lin, Zixin Chen, Ziyang Luo, Mingfei Cheng, Jing Ma, Guang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media abounds with multimodal sarcasm, and identifying sarcasm targets
is particularly challenging due to the implicit incongruity not directly
evident in the text and image modalities. Current methods for Multimodal
Sarcasm Target Identification (MSTI) predominantly focus on superficial
indicators in an end-to-end manner, overlooking the nuanced understanding of
multimodal sarcasm conveyed through both the text and image. This paper
proposes a versatile MSTI framework with a coarse-to-fine paradigm, by
augmenting sarcasm explainability with reasoning and pre-training knowledge.
Inspired by the powerful capacity of Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) on
multimodal reasoning, we first engage LMMs to generate competing rationales for
coarser-grained pre-training of a small language model on multimodal sarcasm
detection. We then propose fine-tuning the model for finer-grained sarcasm
target identification. Our framework is thus empowered to adeptly unveil the
intricate targets within multimodal sarcasm and mitigate the negative impact
posed by potential noise inherently in LMMs. Experimental results demonstrate
that our model far outperforms state-of-the-art MSTI methods, and markedly
exhibits explainability in deciphering sarcasm as well.
|
[
-0.3793790042,
-0.9254732728,
0.4919393659,
0.3790191114,
-0.2498332262,
-0.1453184634,
-0.4465260506,
-0.3155511022,
0.1681434214,
-0.14183864,
-0.9389023781,
-0.0126069207,
-0.5606947541,
-0.0232585538,
-0.1236332059,
1.2282443047,
0.2422955036,
-0.0730165169,
0.041896265,
0.070408076,
-0.2725769579,
-0.2457965314,
-0.9732257128,
-0.0157681406,
1.0223041773,
0.466604054,
0.6390319467,
0.0754438713,
0.7045507431,
0.317418009,
0.140660882,
0.1998914033,
-0.5865569115,
-0.1572925895,
-0.2652978301,
-0.4058044851,
-0.2608210742,
-0.0277951341,
0.2359969616,
0.1936209053,
0.3339472115,
0.3363111019,
-0.1510007679,
0.0580257364,
-0.9048532844,
0.073661834,
-0.4713080823,
0.16521734,
-0.4057356417,
-0.5760207176,
-0.6097287536,
0.012550557,
-0.3024216592,
-0.4957224727,
0.1521013677,
-0.1054965481,
1.0299813747,
0.4966383874,
-0.5234528184,
-0.1690863818,
-0.5474934578,
0.7641221881,
-0.3905140162,
0.3720526099,
0.0401295312,
0.8204663396,
0.0813820213,
-0.5856821537,
-0.3896116018,
-0.3352715075,
-0.2755945921,
0.0474749617,
-0.1759356707,
-0.0313868597,
0.3716997206,
0.2511772513,
-0.57148242,
-0.3175891042,
-0.074872762,
-0.4126444459,
0.2712225616,
-0.0257253684,
0.2147172689,
-0.2486861199,
-0.8447666764,
0.4235746861,
0.0467588678,
0.3490523994,
0.2453044504,
0.3000920713,
-0.427909106,
0.3491196334,
-0.3049884439,
0.2011032999,
0.3786817789,
-0.4175579548,
0.2420190126,
-0.421603471,
-0.201055035,
-0.3274584413,
0.7590786219,
0.1343896687,
0.4618819356,
-0.1436817795,
-0.2480760515,
0.201922521,
0.2622892261,
-0.6138939857,
-0.0753359422,
-0.1387331486,
-0.3633873165,
-0.4155443311,
-0.2063988894,
-0.9347687364,
-0.2963005602,
-0.1614068747,
0.5941137075,
-0.6085447073,
-0.4408925176,
-0.234074086,
-0.5495035052,
0.1938337684,
0.379044205,
-0.632733047,
-0.0327779092,
0.5670163631,
0.7933686972,
0.3865792751,
-0.3799284399,
-0.553635478,
0.2518314421,
0.0436373949,
0.7760599852,
-0.673907578,
0.2548798025,
-0.3453530073,
-0.2086794972,
-0.2629035413,
0.0499614738,
0.8049826622,
-0.3082170188,
-0.2249963433,
-0.1939361393,
0.1854749173,
-0.241678521,
0.6623522639,
-0.5929373503,
0.9640058875,
0.3144484758,
-0.9851071835,
0.2093935013,
-0.6549471021,
-0.441759944,
-0.1122275665,
-0.1071046814,
-0.0818478391,
0.3666574657,
0.2941583693,
0.6393256187,
-0.5144956112,
0.7066895962,
-0.5924963951,
-0.465444833,
0.349701643,
-1.2436996698,
0.7919257879,
0.5921192765,
-0.4449847639,
-0.0975060835,
-0.5478184819,
-0.0469643697,
0.1402335614,
0.0208167695,
-0.364564538,
-0.4890093505,
0.1156029701,
0.5495000482,
0.3665232658,
-0.1626095176,
-0.3410283029,
0.0331763141,
0.4808887243,
0.6956272721,
-0.278775394,
0.4442539215,
-0.2725077271,
0.4563411474,
0.2875215113,
0.7340666652,
-0.4664130807,
-0.1856929362,
-0.7066975236,
-1.1664707661,
0.0939812586,
0.3168155849,
-1.0003832579,
-0.1273988932,
-0.4585358799,
-0.4971508682,
-0.4547045231,
-0.0849048868,
0.6624066234,
0.6009225845,
0.4465075731,
-0.1580309421,
-0.3294481337,
-1.1748988628,
-0.7455571294,
0.1030160859,
0.3296313882,
0.3664566278,
0.4921503067,
-0.2396506369,
0.7543359399,
-0.3073731363,
-0.2362014204,
-0.1830561906,
0.3331567645,
-0.0913928673,
0.3966322839,
0.5996753573,
-1.0491745472,
-0.4670122862,
-0.1109453067,
-0.6812240481,
-0.1162510812,
-0.3623567224,
-0.2686344087,
-0.2624165118,
0.469979912,
-0.7108952403,
0.5031483173,
0.1144070327,
-0.3732827008,
0.6654511094,
0.3148009777,
0.5906270146,
-1.037717104,
0.1359039396,
0.3666950464,
-0.3560738862,
-0.6949898601,
0.4997853637,
-0.0576312728,
-0.1477954239,
-0.5852799416,
0.7105255127,
-0.1150480509,
0.1806408167,
0.2496242672,
-0.307128638,
0.195549652,
0.8416118622,
-0.345195055,
0.6319236159,
0.3324941695,
-0.3503381908,
0.25450629,
-0.3080863953,
0.0813581645,
1.207909584,
-0.5015321374,
-0.1314511299,
-0.1919047683,
0.5367150307,
-1.1569383144,
-0.6855799556,
0.5525054932,
-0.6210516095,
0.2613511682,
-0.3249179125,
-0.3242065609,
-0.4198776484,
-0.4328922033,
0.9342781901,
0.0428466611,
-0.5732021928,
1.004953742,
-0.1248181984,
-0.1355544776,
-0.8685381413,
-0.7267506719,
0.0395336151,
-0.4074164331,
-0.8542952538,
0.170071125,
-0.2107276171,
-0.1319667399,
-0.3897607625,
0.1472820342,
-0.5249890685,
0.0569960102,
0.211186409,
0.1003850251,
-0.2342951,
0.1803711206,
0.197949037,
-0.236953035,
-0.108805865,
0.2303419411,
0.5606137514,
-0.2718389928,
-0.329080373,
-0.9437746406,
0.4929653108,
0.7504383326,
-0.2397708446,
0.3387251794,
1.3897987604,
-0.4089250267,
0.1471554935,
-0.6720870137,
-0.0576487109,
-0.4929543734,
0.3209956884,
-0.9043949246,
-0.5963920951,
0.2957338393,
-0.3624641597,
-0.4535225332,
0.4176100791,
0.4577477574,
-0.0160831884,
1.1175373793,
0.685572207,
-0.0084506748,
0.4620227218,
0.0027868401,
0.1978684664,
-0.4972533584,
-0.2556304634,
-0.5220228434,
-0.4289448261,
-0.1293589175,
-0.5775130391,
0.2637523711,
-0.0661638081,
-0.5059509277,
0.1342659444,
-0.06034033,
0.5173273087,
0.4950130582,
0.4177014828,
0.1795611233,
0.0454992354,
0.0475520939,
-0.0245112535,
-0.4762328863,
-0.1846304238,
0.5236697197,
0.5555173159,
0.823495388,
0.1552298963,
0.4883540869,
0.3900243044,
0.3151279688,
-0.902063489,
0.402741313,
-0.2296251506,
-0.8458252549,
0.0618074909,
-0.6300283074,
-0.1215985939,
0.0118322484,
-0.1576777399,
-0.3943454623,
0.1671243608,
0.3597103059,
-0.4768725336,
0.0458530262,
-1.1333059072,
1.0169066191,
-0.2668550313,
-0.4222503304,
-0.2024271637,
-0.8384054899,
0.5666869879,
0.0994025469,
0.6207873821,
-0.2385505736,
0.0112800784,
0.2286965698,
-0.1064666659,
1.2294774055,
-0.3804302514,
-0.0066130674,
0.1696729064,
0.0170354936,
0.3880075812,
0.346115917,
-0.1349952072,
0.3241405487,
-0.1140586138,
-0.6013435721,
-0.5009377599,
0.7305905819,
-0.5489398241,
-0.2754333317,
-0.132576555,
-0.8139144778,
-0.1096003503,
0.2707608938,
0.4292278886,
0.6998383999,
-0.2693358958,
-0.0848512799,
0.4317454994,
0.0848872662,
0.4607701898,
0.0091986395,
0.5393747687,
-0.4055034518,
1.1642823219,
-0.2481379658,
0.1005485207,
0.4551047683,
0.1167765483,
-0.1371085197,
0.0714598373,
-0.3513062298,
0.2287534028,
-0.9054831862,
-0.3016034365,
-0.6471990347,
-0.1616601497,
-0.5430596471,
-0.6121630669,
-0.4300813079,
-0.3060700595,
-0.3754710853,
0.4371046126,
0.1463097632,
0.1863761842,
-0.1116118729,
0.531925261,
-0.3602933288,
0.5054786205,
0.3080686033,
0.1997897774,
-0.0657463223,
-0.7406311631,
-0.0661745518,
0.326736182,
-0.0727545023,
-0.6531525254,
0.226026535,
0.5098634362,
0.2281935662,
0.7022038698,
-0.0150865922,
1.0096712112,
-0.424472928,
0.478811264,
0.5938432217,
-0.8551975489,
0.4395748079,
-0.4757278562,
0.2860300541,
0.8027490377,
0.5893249512,
-0.2272468209,
-0.322465837,
-0.4628409743,
-0.5521489382,
0.5073770881,
-0.1590053141,
0.5249021053,
-0.1412854195,
0.3658607304,
0.2950566709,
0.2456228882,
-1.1051846743,
0.1485843658,
-0.2704342902,
-0.6962522864,
-0.08028166,
-0.2008701563,
-0.3957354128,
-0.2580033839,
0.4359787703,
-0.5582580566,
0.4476504326,
-0.0730561763,
-0.534809351,
-0.0150771895,
0.4742738903,
0.6496094465,
0.2598744035,
0.0314500257,
0.5355662107,
-0.1030208766,
-0.3035696149,
0.0034882778,
0.1813045293,
-0.040371716,
-0.0954937786,
0.3710356951,
0.700670898,
0.44333601,
-0.5213910937,
0.9979918599,
-0.137759611,
-0.0593409576,
-0.2477289438,
-0.0625948533,
-0.3242834806,
0.6935112476,
0.2863105237,
0.7818267345,
0.3816046119,
-0.6591104865,
0.1020205095,
0.5759994984,
-0.7460772395,
-0.6011587381,
0.3496138752,
0.2172432244,
-0.0926542059,
0.1280599535,
-0.2400437146,
-0.5697214007,
0.6372023225,
0.4710582197,
0.8204872012,
-0.1452694684,
0.6053011417,
0.1847252399,
0.5054488182,
0.0635231137,
0.2564938962,
-0.2860778868,
-0.3524156511,
-0.1539557874,
-0.5065541863,
0.2090811282,
-0.1256980598,
-0.6443083882,
0.6875007749,
-0.5941377878,
-0.290985167,
0.4716769457,
-0.530593276,
-0.8430725932,
0.5749641061,
0.253695637,
0.9033758044,
-1.0003045797,
0.3530903757,
0.3992346525,
-0.6803433299,
-0.6996713281,
0.238142848,
0.1943244189,
-0.8055278659,
0.6459717155,
0.4598514736,
-0.3179625869,
0.1232285649,
-0.7585126758,
-0.536527276,
0.9447245002,
0.8016209602,
-0.189182207,
-0.1737467945,
0.0611304566,
0.514762938,
-0.3646745384,
0.8483115435,
0.3853708506,
0.6078751683,
0.3719666898,
-0.8645901084,
0.1999445707,
-0.2790555954,
-0.2867391109,
0.1317759603,
-1.0183670521,
1.0825754404,
-0.4169831574,
-0.0234339982,
-0.0676349029,
0.3305667341,
-0.1280304641,
0.7350519896,
0.5516797304,
0.7051851153,
0.4337962568,
-0.1598699689,
0.9533095956,
0.1437043101,
0.3171970248,
1.1150228977,
0.156257838,
0.6743457317,
0.6923822165,
0.3015552461,
0.5741003752,
0.6388891935,
0.1481751055,
0.607427001,
-0.2700389326,
-0.3028988242,
-0.4749367535,
-0.3989391923,
-0.2955691218,
0.6125969887,
0.4254077077,
-0.474909544,
-0.4653893411,
0.2626779377,
0.1547157317,
-0.2310156375,
-0.5275927782,
0.6006885171,
-0.0477933884,
-0.4665198326,
0.7197368741,
0.0304478109,
0.9782323241,
-0.4956164658,
0.1869919151,
-0.1285854131,
0.2251219749,
-0.2263108641,
-0.289514184,
0.2750518322,
-0.0203400794,
-0.291229248,
0.1442462951,
0.9531311393,
-0.4426989853,
-0.4568340182,
0.1719446331,
0.2671965063,
-0.0868664011,
-0.2182388753,
-1.0703940392,
-0.0079064295,
-0.2740405202,
-0.0763574019,
0.0344915204,
0.9143258333,
-0.1916405708,
0.6149081588,
0.3925596476,
-0.4958316088,
-0.0975375623,
0.307733655,
1.0743148327,
-0.4400883019,
-0.5781681538,
-0.8925180435,
0.6907595396,
-0.1891159564,
-0.486183852,
0.4517701864,
0.1348428577,
0.5076329112,
-0.2715733349,
0.6139931083,
-0.2515370846,
0.1529456228,
-0.2857444286,
0.4436500967,
-1.0203436613,
-0.147408694,
-0.4609660208,
-0.5859186053,
-0.2671368718,
0.4102027714,
-0.2524038851,
0.43831411,
0.7916561961,
0.928324759,
-0.5842871666,
0.0557376184,
0.3556695879,
0.2307782322,
-0.0596056879,
0.7082893252,
0.987211287,
-0.3354616761,
0.8501765728,
-0.2080405951,
-0.612621069,
-0.4570170045,
-0.7251873612,
-1.1344521046,
-0.3161782324,
-0.1239431649,
-0.1698800027,
0.1015883833,
0.9661391973,
0.7226620913,
-0.4929667711,
0.3465326428,
0.1827918291,
-0.0474275909,
-0.2516940832,
-0.2935038209,
-0.0247889087,
-0.5347680449,
-0.6240087748,
0.0675159916,
0.5468941927,
-0.3436294496,
-0.1639276892,
-0.0212004092,
-0.4597037435,
0.5259069204,
0.6909170151,
0.1569796503,
-0.721580565,
-0.4357283711,
0.0171007514,
-0.2871156037,
-0.1569803804,
0.8100064397,
-0.3317196667,
0.2884191573,
0.3768358529,
0.5212322474,
0.0224612299,
-0.1808802485,
0.1562483013,
-1.1228672266,
0.5532644987,
0.1038248613,
0.2968494892,
0.2934359312,
-0.6519985795,
0.3702548444,
0.4581722021,
-0.0972499475,
-0.9190502167,
0.3831606507,
-1.1374179125,
-0.3061268032,
1.1429954767,
-0.2367468178,
-0.4002849758,
-0.2879045904,
-0.4485979378,
0.3190105557,
-0.3749806583,
0.8316710591,
0.4741474092,
0.2512941957,
-0.3165491223,
-0.339753747,
0.5037037134,
0.4824681878,
-0.7759104371,
-0.2380444407,
0.5401963592,
0.1659082323,
0.3587405086,
0.8531926274,
-0.1144568473,
0.6949885488,
0.1449883729,
-0.0905548483,
0.0420453995,
-0.8790081739,
-0.0669127628,
0.3911813498,
-0.280377686,
0.3030350804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.15787v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15787v1
|
Extracting chemical food safety hazards from the scientific literature automatically using large language models
| 2024-05-01T08:02:10 | 2024-05-01T08:02:10 |
Neris Özen, Wenjuan Mu, Esther D. van Asselt, Leonieke M. van den Bulk
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The number of scientific articles published in the domain of food safety has
consistently been increasing over the last few decades. It has therefore become
unfeasible for food safety experts to read all relevant literature related to
food safety and the occurrence of hazards in the food chain. However, it is
important that food safety experts are aware of the newest findings and can
access this information in an easy and concise way. In this study, an approach
is presented to automate the extraction of chemical hazards from the scientific
literature through large language models. The large language model was used
out-of-the-box and applied on scientific abstracts; no extra training of the
models or a large computing cluster was required. Three different styles of
prompting the model were tested to assess which was the most optimal for the
task at hand. The prompts were optimized with two validation foods (leafy
greens and shellfish) and the final performance of the best prompt was
evaluated using three test foods (dairy, maize and salmon). The specific
wording of the prompt was found to have a considerable effect on the results. A
prompt breaking the task down into smaller steps performed best overall. This
prompt reached an average accuracy of 93% and contained many chemical
contaminants already included in food monitoring programs, validating the
successful retrieval of relevant hazards for the food safety domain. The
results showcase how valuable large language models can be for the task of
automatic information extraction from the scientific literature.
|
[
0.054206565,
-0.6940936446,
0.6994458437,
0.0504719913,
0.0526079573,
-0.3407005072,
-0.1218349561,
-0.7585517168,
-0.0704031065,
0.4451321363,
-0.1725992411,
-0.5314534903,
-0.6959904432,
0.5829666853,
-0.6903787851,
0.8688533306,
-0.3139299452,
-0.0377343521,
0.034552861,
0.5581678152,
-0.3408258259,
-0.2805182636,
-0.5565212965,
0.2119136006,
0.6412584782,
0.369505316,
0.3908654153,
0.4584261179,
0.4144857228,
0.3685362935,
-0.0495638512,
-0.0270877015,
0.2008310109,
0.3997575045,
-0.6150973439,
-0.1705805063,
-0.1836222708,
0.1508495957,
0.1514364481,
0.4271880984,
0.1256174445,
0.2788016498,
0.1474335641,
0.6105951071,
-0.5743440986,
0.5296045542,
-0.4423273802,
0.1495495588,
0.3791321516,
-0.3138868809,
-0.5468425155,
-0.6327218413,
0.2380842119,
-0.7336544394,
-0.3516060114,
0.2103904933,
0.7994446754,
-0.0411103256,
-0.4949879646,
-0.5893658996,
-0.7019101381,
0.7257614732,
-0.6258590221,
0.1906827837,
0.4720965326,
0.486638099,
-0.4313418865,
-0.6139574647,
-0.4509717822,
-0.6825742126,
0.0907896385,
-0.1130645573,
0.0054029594,
-0.1904121488,
0.4444657564,
-0.0858511105,
-0.4546378255,
0.0661593601,
-0.3571839333,
-0.1533739865,
0.6063120365,
0.1842733324,
0.6274437308,
-0.2284104377,
-0.4017753601,
-0.3867068589,
-0.4836490452,
-0.044928994,
-0.103569977,
0.3922890425,
0.206244424,
0.7334051132,
-0.3408148289,
0.3253023326,
-0.2573033571,
-0.3098801374,
0.1049773321,
-0.474809885,
0.1976692826,
0.1846106946,
0.8919807076,
0.5197229385,
0.3305895627,
0.0553161204,
-0.1886714399,
-0.1773099452,
-0.0136159994,
-0.7075558901,
-0.3775740266,
0.2549287081,
-0.258230716,
-0.3589189649,
-0.0715774819,
-0.9973625541,
-0.6343407035,
-0.2093910575,
0.5155437589,
-0.2314102352,
-0.0786110088,
0.0295639336,
-0.2344251424,
-0.1283602268,
0.2925820053,
-0.7649065852,
0.1001229584,
0.4405344427,
0.819363296,
-0.220541507,
0.2267797589,
-0.6533107162,
0.4002973735,
0.0430843718,
0.807615459,
-0.5168361068,
-0.2352551073,
-0.1136320084,
0.3477697372,
0.043902006,
-0.3980172575,
0.5693563223,
-0.5149353743,
-0.096813865,
-0.388412118,
-0.281034261,
-0.3036414981,
0.1112896129,
-0.6711629629,
0.8777672052,
-0.0388783999,
-0.6436361074,
0.3024688363,
-0.556666255,
-0.708018899,
0.0496820807,
-0.0987783,
-0.1400431693,
-0.3533600569,
0.4144407809,
0.4340256155,
-0.6912568808,
0.4363084435,
-0.2974586487,
0.1803856939,
0.3283770382,
-0.4065030217,
0.4723703563,
0.2824238837,
-0.2916570008,
0.1765883267,
-0.4360464513,
0.0690178201,
0.168288812,
-0.5825222135,
-0.3220429718,
0.0829252154,
0.26124686,
0.4787171781,
0.1787800342,
-0.5217827559,
-0.0679003075,
-0.2031735629,
0.3626826704,
0.6799109578,
0.3881978095,
0.2684370279,
-0.295084089,
0.3942943811,
-0.0846774355,
0.208828941,
-0.3204508126,
-0.3686930537,
-0.1872191727,
-0.3061031401,
0.4888411164,
0.9352972507,
-0.7396935821,
0.9615692496,
-0.0426756665,
-0.5310667157,
0.109871611,
-0.0920560509,
0.0514135733,
0.7284066081,
0.3648610711,
0.0340346321,
-0.414960891,
-0.4600006342,
-0.2703547776,
-0.1296734512,
-0.1168901473,
0.0428080894,
0.6118932366,
-0.1147233546,
0.9335333109,
-0.9254413247,
0.2758819163,
-0.1078857258,
0.1246012822,
0.3218050301,
0.5284766555,
0.3532856107,
-0.6565995216,
-0.865236342,
0.470187664,
-0.8531250954,
-0.1850602478,
0.2121469229,
-0.2067419291,
0.2171228081,
0.6145210862,
-0.6110815406,
0.3126168549,
0.2365910858,
-0.0301419403,
0.8878778219,
-0.1145832166,
0.209472999,
-0.9186499715,
0.5780821443,
0.5140345693,
0.0579201616,
-0.510009408,
-0.167724818,
0.1320218891,
-0.2530229688,
-0.4389736652,
0.7519940734,
-0.5236783028,
0.217934534,
-0.1736941338,
0.0291160699,
0.1998044848,
0.0344795957,
0.1959692091,
0.4613859057,
0.5640423894,
-0.7967396975,
0.5149471164,
0.0055364398,
-0.3845725954,
0.0001835539,
-0.6007564068,
-0.5001339316,
-0.207486704,
0.5350120068,
-1.0536352396,
-0.3928037286,
0.656416297,
0.0471040122,
0.1677882671,
-0.0061142542,
-0.7253152728,
-0.6160337925,
-0.0579919964,
-0.1545503885,
0.3465776443,
-0.3399271667,
0.5294876099,
0.6777575612,
-0.9290773273,
-0.3334793448,
-0.1452798098,
-0.088388145,
-0.2327958941,
-0.2652147412,
-0.4527551532,
-0.2947819829,
-0.1489573568,
-0.3569684327,
-0.4355556071,
-0.0846009478,
0.2281299829,
0.3474913239,
0.3373709917,
0.2121306807,
0.2137480676,
0.1374571621,
-0.2433763593,
0.3457679749,
-0.0566267334,
0.4093337953,
0.1130032912,
0.0798017383,
-0.6160467863,
0.5210732222,
0.6127452254,
-0.2949281931,
0.4537606239,
0.2690339983,
-0.5029110312,
0.1145773157,
-0.1056473553,
-0.3686328232,
-0.4992021322,
0.4051376283,
0.0295916926,
-0.1314382702,
0.1424906552,
-0.2832069993,
0.1552033573,
0.5751581192,
-0.0213645827,
-0.1497826576,
1.0662894249,
0.2836104929,
-0.1930284351,
0.451117754,
0.1196595728,
0.129927665,
-0.2420749962,
-0.4988990128,
-1.0345460176,
0.3628611565,
-0.0780209005,
-0.3840215504,
0.7357478142,
-0.6105890274,
-0.4270409644,
0.32617414,
-0.4766437411,
0.7805175781,
0.1182352901,
0.1770405769,
0.4234464467,
0.367313534,
-0.3933012784,
0.187624082,
-0.4754033089,
-0.6996189356,
0.5843166113,
0.6755694747,
0.9971577525,
-0.1071318239,
0.2962312996,
0.1677032113,
0.4359888434,
-0.8533546925,
0.6154730916,
-0.1278481632,
-0.774828136,
-0.4831421375,
-0.5097180605,
-0.6564085484,
0.1121862605,
-0.4143511057,
-0.7090244889,
0.0285901837,
-0.0321378931,
-0.4869712591,
-0.0105448514,
-0.8645070791,
0.6460467577,
-0.5536156297,
-0.1229050532,
0.3806112111,
-0.9191654325,
0.32845065,
-0.4382898211,
0.5530489683,
-0.2894407213,
0.0194686633,
0.7447608113,
-0.2278904617,
1.039441824,
-0.1137009785,
-0.5977562666,
0.2061152309,
0.2227848768,
0.9141411781,
-0.2307763845,
-0.2839281261,
-0.1492639333,
0.1236903965,
0.0336077213,
-0.2509818077,
0.6086685658,
-0.2761443853,
-0.3686668575,
-0.8043110371,
-0.5164200664,
-0.1175570711,
0.5402525067,
0.0976880863,
-0.0226826966,
-0.0092633637,
-0.1864267886,
0.5771154165,
-0.5746908188,
0.6321066022,
0.7356715798,
-0.2399033457,
-0.1850343794,
0.8191887736,
0.2274229228,
0.0669642389,
0.3304355741,
0.4577758312,
-0.5524472594,
-0.2360634208,
-0.1774924695,
0.0037295842,
-0.9168763757,
-0.4100307822,
-1.0297697783,
-0.2695310414,
-0.4544805884,
-0.0050927973,
0.0594684072,
-0.1954171211,
-0.4726131856,
-0.1692215204,
0.4394055903,
0.6206809878,
0.0686826184,
0.0424874537,
-1.31112957,
0.2740590274,
0.1223879755,
0.0909155458,
0.303352654,
-0.2495515645,
-0.0745277777,
-0.0926882923,
-0.1790950149,
-1.2217520475,
0.7105275989,
0.0899543986,
0.6104450822,
0.4391471744,
0.3850259483,
0.3229482472,
-0.5404475927,
0.6214878559,
0.5551931262,
-0.7617252469,
0.6211246848,
-0.5204960704,
0.2435787916,
0.5871905684,
1.1013072729,
-0.6561757326,
-0.3721437156,
-0.0675280318,
-1.2630681992,
0.3961231411,
-0.1470210552,
-0.4123190641,
-0.3717754185,
-0.0093106246,
0.4242857397,
-0.1371901482,
-0.7033731937,
0.1114822701,
0.2585394084,
-0.3174741268,
0.0325676948,
-0.2027764469,
-0.2575245202,
-0.4162353873,
0.85463202,
0.0182522219,
-0.0346525013,
0.1776801497,
-0.2396619916,
-0.4997049868,
0.4092927873,
0.3186325729,
0.4510809183,
-0.0438125469,
0.3391862214,
0.0872994363,
-0.6197713017,
0.2308775485,
0.0788686499,
-0.0166741852,
-0.2095345706,
0.1707181484,
0.128389433,
0.1049570441,
-0.9836585522,
0.3362564147,
-0.0789994821,
0.1446314305,
-0.3771103323,
0.202003926,
-0.0989884287,
0.1130404472,
0.6303619742,
0.0250233617,
0.4553467631,
-0.5098785162,
0.4926899076,
0.0907403901,
0.1880633682,
0.0065531838,
0.3962464035,
0.4728747904,
0.2194815427,
0.432005167,
-0.0554237366,
-0.38342309,
0.7921090722,
0.776093483,
0.5484394431,
-0.4403454959,
0.3711889684,
0.7411116362,
0.3047323227,
-0.1885198802,
0.330126375,
0.4102188051,
-0.2422114611,
-0.3918251395,
-0.7557975054,
-0.0054227253,
0.2193769664,
-0.3646201491,
0.0715152845,
-0.5562744737,
-0.0582812503,
0.5487872958,
-0.2715887725,
-0.265078932,
0.1043891758,
-0.0117845684,
1.0009701252,
-1.3838788271,
0.3934597969,
0.6351200938,
-0.359305352,
-0.7906439304,
0.1439979821,
0.0416829623,
-0.3518230617,
0.6877192855,
0.2349056453,
0.105623275,
-0.2861054242,
-0.6180464029,
-1.1531100273,
0.7668843865,
0.1932180226,
-0.8619796038,
-0.2399537265,
0.0783522427,
0.3973661065,
-0.2282985896,
0.4174463153,
0.4093474448,
0.8868352175,
0.2535918355,
-0.87141186,
0.4987562299,
-0.3320653439,
-0.155919686,
0.0410196893,
-0.1176485866,
0.4455879927,
-0.1627929807,
-0.3338611126,
-0.0415624157,
0.5709239244,
0.1842631847,
0.4640304744,
0.5162231922,
-0.1529709548,
0.7868123055,
0.1631435603,
0.8337859511,
-0.0317143686,
0.096412465,
1.0178097486,
-0.5216905475,
0.8176909089,
0.3268905282,
-0.0335746333,
0.184763968,
1.0073766708,
-0.1260623187,
0.7232043743,
0.1266923696,
-0.4303130507,
-0.0445336401,
-0.2342406213,
-0.3345483243,
0.1419395506,
0.6803307533,
-0.8695168495,
-0.4190158248,
0.1981155276,
0.2147740871,
-0.2574306428,
-0.313988775,
0.6495595574,
0.1134855002,
-0.7547863126,
0.4187652469,
0.0232024323,
0.050648246,
-0.3711183965,
-0.3784370422,
0.2002790719,
-0.1926888525,
-0.199156478,
-0.789313972,
-0.021434078,
0.0707278028,
-0.0912434161,
0.1947933137,
0.743442595,
-0.6075324416,
-0.4949715734,
0.179139331,
0.1190046296,
0.3415706456,
-0.1156827435,
-0.6399371624,
0.0533485413,
-0.2312512696,
-0.0249127168,
0.0840710551,
0.1504506469,
-0.2046524733,
0.519833684,
0.7258613706,
-0.0282684453,
-0.0590459742,
-0.352433145,
1.0104613304,
-0.609847486,
-0.6550480723,
-0.4600185454,
0.5551692247,
-0.1764625162,
0.2241623551,
0.5333350301,
0.3053441346,
0.2598960698,
-0.4400684834,
0.9056844115,
-0.2192310393,
0.2147641182,
-0.5070021749,
0.8357549906,
-0.2747491598,
0.3492847085,
-0.4675036967,
-0.7383541465,
-0.2411222011,
0.5627788305,
-0.5460733771,
0.1149597317,
1.0194710493,
0.7778918743,
0.1012317464,
0.0343294293,
-0.1240314096,
0.4615472555,
0.2187539786,
0.2972899973,
0.5380959511,
-0.0397107638,
0.2071034759,
0.0342196375,
-0.4450909197,
-0.4278135598,
-1.1282397509,
-0.5570379496,
-0.5498840809,
-0.535107851,
-0.3604649603,
0.2716173828,
1.1221101284,
0.4342384338,
-0.7458459735,
0.045557119,
0.1736174822,
0.0042798021,
-0.1999194771,
-0.2043260932,
0.4437286854,
-0.2130299658,
-0.352720499,
0.4811420143,
0.0918553472,
0.2121608704,
0.2389132828,
0.1918589324,
-0.4416606426,
0.1162375063,
0.7899207473,
0.7501556277,
-0.3341521621,
-0.3358505666,
-0.3721316159,
-0.2949866354,
-0.3600971103,
0.1838098168,
-0.1150257066,
0.4904249907,
0.5184097886,
0.4332600534,
0.238819778,
-0.1232218146,
0.6100130677,
-0.5982168317,
-0.3557942808,
0.0693722144,
0.1589309126,
0.0439307615,
-0.8020941019,
0.37498945,
0.0104432581,
-0.5079439878,
-0.7335093021,
0.1042148396,
-1.0340986252,
-0.4730027914,
1.4922156334,
-0.2475875467,
-0.6822872162,
-0.2744382918,
-0.292904377,
0.4754398167,
-0.4305823743,
0.9042274952,
0.4888906181,
0.114826262,
0.0408559777,
-0.7170500159,
0.5767778158,
-0.0478894934,
-1.2748744488,
0.1656028181,
0.5951100588,
0.7087569237,
0.2489135861,
0.0909015387,
-0.3408631384,
0.3164257407,
-0.1841217875,
0.2796155512,
0.2325112224,
-0.8113169074,
-0.1996102482,
0.1716384888,
-0.0415128544,
0.0783317387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00361v1
|
AdaMoLE: Fine-Tuning Large Language Models with Adaptive Mixture of Low-Rank Adaptation Experts
| 2024-05-01T07:33:43 | 2024-05-01T07:33:43 |
Zefang Liu, Jiahua Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce AdaMoLE, a novel method for fine-tuning large language models
(LLMs) through an Adaptive Mixture of Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) Experts.
Moving beyond conventional methods that employ a static top-k strategy for
activating experts, AdaMoLE dynamically adjusts the activation threshold using
a dedicated threshold network, adaptively responding to the varying
complexities of different tasks. By replacing a single LoRA in a layer with
multiple LoRA experts and integrating a gating function with the threshold
mechanism, AdaMoLE effectively selects and activates the most appropriate
experts based on the input context. Our extensive evaluations across a variety
of commonsense reasoning and natural language processing tasks show that
AdaMoLE exceeds baseline performance. This enhancement highlights the
advantages of AdaMoLE's adaptive selection of LoRA experts, improving model
effectiveness without a corresponding increase in the expert count. The
experimental validation not only confirms AdaMoLE as a robust approach for
enhancing LLMs but also suggests valuable directions for future research in
adaptive expert selection mechanisms, potentially broadening the scope for
optimizing model performance across diverse language processing tasks.
|
[
-0.474543035,
-0.740293026,
0.3241626024,
-0.0494410284,
-0.1409010887,
0.4369552433,
-0.5775820613,
-0.6797497869,
0.0569981039,
0.4156787992,
-0.0916059241,
-0.3799048364,
-0.6919207573,
0.1771563739,
-0.1907199472,
0.7636414766,
0.3098160923,
-0.2846567631,
-0.2203036994,
-0.2497627586,
-0.2554813027,
0.1113680229,
-1.1525059938,
-0.2757503092,
0.3861387968,
0.6433228254,
0.4712463021,
0.4586730003,
0.0989025682,
0.4371012449,
-0.4140997529,
0.4385279417,
-0.5895598531,
0.3932037354,
-0.4929682314,
-0.3666865826,
-0.9344142079,
-0.2223279029,
0.4031077027,
0.8178834915,
-0.1624708027,
0.14444682,
0.4010453522,
0.508733511,
-0.7809758186,
-0.3168186843,
-1.1636359692,
-0.1477711648,
0.1287366748,
-0.4337551892,
-0.4440079033,
-0.1336694658,
-0.1116750911,
-0.6137231588,
-0.1232854351,
0.3420543671,
0.2141925693,
0.561475575,
-0.1461623162,
-0.1093033776,
-0.8518638611,
0.945757091,
-0.995688498,
0.2592784166,
0.2520371974,
0.0524609759,
-0.1115154251,
-0.2268713415,
-0.3105535805,
-0.3980224729,
0.4934515059,
-0.1851050705,
-0.158604607,
-0.0707406029,
-0.0823957101,
0.2131118774,
-0.092730239,
0.5958244801,
-0.3209939599,
0.0684051365,
0.6135713458,
-0.2882685363,
0.1831817329,
0.3857396543,
-0.1870156378,
0.1979334652,
-0.491460979,
0.0974961668,
0.4446237087,
0.5241864324,
0.0652778298,
0.1878044158,
-0.2910598218,
0.822945118,
0.4398990571,
-0.2692377865,
0.0776652545,
-0.0564095676,
-0.2175548375,
0.3507046402,
0.6512494087,
0.2257193327,
0.3628063798,
-0.2871712744,
-0.2618952692,
-0.467235893,
0.2919567823,
-0.7095758319,
-0.3018213809,
0.2609630525,
-0.0083694533,
-0.7095385194,
-0.5203174353,
-0.9273158908,
-0.6145030856,
-0.1498975456,
0.2112392634,
-0.3732016981,
-0.2357898504,
0.0066128699,
0.2802245021,
-0.214170441,
0.4209023118,
-1.2142010927,
0.5745828748,
0.5848062634,
0.4787983298,
-0.1297105253,
-0.4936524034,
-0.8732066751,
0.1431375742,
-0.5624582171,
0.994032979,
-0.950866282,
0.0022408145,
-0.1735715121,
-0.3389950097,
-0.2344294637,
-0.7020972967,
0.7120825052,
-0.504088521,
-0.0267032124,
-0.0977852345,
-0.462325871,
-0.1567931771,
0.2837965488,
-0.3727986813,
1.2015804052,
0.1124107391,
-0.3934713006,
0.5415729284,
-0.8570291996,
-0.4410230815,
0.2262159735,
0.0119899679,
-0.0785845146,
0.2320720404,
0.5401307344,
0.432274431,
-0.2324016839,
-0.1852134317,
-0.3117374182,
-0.2013595104,
0.2032692581,
-0.08327391,
0.5167863369,
0.0970757231,
-0.1076812223,
0.5656582713,
-1.1010802984,
-0.1332615912,
0.0207310338,
-0.5405914783,
-0.7067149282,
0.3798814118,
-0.1822620928,
-0.0093086306,
0.3136957884,
-0.4645826519,
0.197800532,
-0.5152727365,
0.7077383399,
0.9927354455,
0.1402177364,
0.7216099501,
-0.1588097662,
0.4118208289,
0.0294925384,
-0.02026188,
0.2562574446,
-0.314897269,
-0.8773415089,
-0.130170688,
0.4323854446,
0.5158776641,
-0.7692925334,
0.6427512765,
-0.3244973719,
-0.3305686414,
-0.6194047928,
0.7507070303,
0.0707974583,
0.5046781898,
0.3097471595,
-0.0805983394,
-0.2329368293,
-0.6612693667,
-0.1579249948,
-0.0130633386,
0.2655293047,
0.3661105335,
0.3160989881,
0.1339470148,
0.6302252412,
0.0107197501,
-0.1982459575,
-0.52859056,
0.0778630301,
0.3713675141,
0.4914293587,
0.7178730369,
-0.4102774262,
-0.4203777313,
0.383682698,
-0.3843865395,
-0.0966656506,
-0.1872688681,
-0.1058136821,
0.1020785943,
0.727402091,
-0.0561187938,
-0.3262117803,
0.7363624573,
-0.2304532677,
0.2464822233,
-0.3983159065,
0.1278408468,
-1.1718326807,
-0.0462997928,
0.0910731256,
-0.5161212087,
-0.7126431465,
0.2780388892,
-0.1525215507,
-0.0239399057,
-0.6314608455,
0.6650574207,
-0.3666433096,
-0.0273743663,
-0.3294260502,
0.3386158943,
-0.2208791673,
0.4367498755,
-0.5697230697,
1.0108305216,
0.9418683052,
-0.8287168145,
0.2631124854,
0.3227786124,
-0.3485982418,
0.7370710969,
-0.5021328926,
0.4465482831,
0.0415898077,
-0.2660051286,
-0.860535562,
-0.2437370867,
0.2253633291,
-0.2491446882,
0.240244776,
-0.5973397493,
-0.1883755475,
-0.1490279883,
-0.2975328565,
0.466663003,
0.4705246985,
-0.2381605357,
0.6905590892,
0.3204451203,
-0.5375141501,
-0.4527359605,
-0.440002352,
0.3853873909,
-0.1497144699,
-0.3371010721,
0.1157800853,
-0.1134965345,
-0.337149024,
-0.0088321567,
-0.0448132269,
0.0066146054,
0.5936146379,
-0.0158828255,
-0.0467626601,
-0.2568492293,
-0.0844296217,
0.3873163164,
-0.1380941123,
-0.2133744806,
-0.3991045058,
0.6253008842,
-0.0820212215,
-0.1546544731,
-0.2296222001,
0.105225876,
0.586212635,
-0.3650070727,
0.8611565232,
0.6872956753,
-0.3678816855,
-0.6049660444,
-0.3380206227,
-0.0394684486,
-0.5034396648,
0.5699605942,
-0.4049056172,
-0.9324714541,
0.6009590626,
-0.2755232453,
0.1182956398,
0.3748867214,
0.6001697183,
0.1236100122,
0.8408353925,
0.5975872278,
-0.3057240844,
0.4318659604,
0.012582846,
0.3030492365,
-1.1312229633,
0.1955701262,
-0.4841473699,
-0.6201984882,
-0.4180851877,
-0.2902105749,
0.3866731226,
0.3507127762,
-0.1091553792,
0.0535202026,
-0.6238343716,
0.76392138,
0.615596354,
0.216814369,
0.3051543832,
0.0044231298,
0.1224807054,
0.3334051967,
-0.6929833293,
-0.4196727276,
1.0723352432,
0.2875657976,
0.8003035784,
0.145268932,
0.7032134533,
0.6701713204,
-0.0346052684,
-0.7110020518,
0.8009633422,
-0.3274943829,
-0.4534856677,
-0.5338022113,
-0.2163367569,
-0.7609308362,
0.0829696655,
-0.5513424873,
-1.0322453976,
0.4149210453,
0.3637534678,
-0.9155097604,
0.5185310245,
-0.4300153852,
0.4709326327,
-0.1820749342,
-0.5084290504,
-0.4896272719,
-0.198990792,
0.0446334481,
-0.1700119823,
0.2112969011,
-0.4047150016,
-0.1792157739,
0.7670784593,
0.0079299463,
0.8610443473,
-0.2101031691,
-0.2232059389,
0.0668405667,
0.3381228745,
0.7349324822,
-0.1021684334,
-0.4947617352,
-0.0512933694,
-0.1542708874,
-0.617784977,
-0.3068484962,
0.9324964881,
-0.9252800345,
-0.5281581879,
-0.1042446867,
-0.742031157,
-0.4283054173,
0.3839300573,
-0.1062242016,
0.4877009094,
-0.0944736972,
0.3019151986,
0.573738873,
-0.203106761,
0.4964728057,
0.1835972518,
-0.1222743541,
-0.5779981017,
0.999735117,
-0.2258941084,
0.3874140382,
0.27170977,
0.1040282845,
0.1454725713,
-1.3381745815,
-0.6103339791,
-0.0549888909,
-0.7647855282,
-0.0826684311,
-0.487598151,
-0.1114041656,
-0.4834437668,
-0.3636642098,
-0.5271618962,
-0.335383743,
-0.3996838629,
-0.0675925314,
0.3635982871,
0.5969195366,
0.1470379084,
0.2637677789,
-0.4725381732,
0.1804577857,
0.5538227558,
0.3130097389,
0.0130261453,
-0.8095452189,
-0.2786861658,
-0.077961348,
0.0053020841,
-0.4866822362,
0.1868277341,
0.6849262714,
0.7091078758,
0.4523598552,
0.1174348518,
0.4108451009,
-0.6071483493,
0.504283011,
-0.1702198386,
-0.9679728746,
0.3724480867,
-0.6018580794,
0.0420563444,
0.8890478611,
-0.040203549,
-0.3027845919,
-0.4433631599,
-0.2297026217,
-0.891151011,
0.6637926698,
0.0734394267,
0.3497506678,
0.3156694472,
0.3592619896,
0.3212472796,
0.1028499752,
-0.5869144201,
0.0966729149,
0.1919326484,
-0.3489297628,
0.1425709724,
-0.4342146814,
-0.443022877,
-0.2854971886,
0.8809476495,
-0.4931870401,
0.273063153,
0.0214207526,
-0.4054525495,
-0.5788587332,
0.5940240026,
0.8600088358,
1.1080362797,
-0.3912155628,
0.149748832,
0.7423347235,
-0.1116303056,
-0.0640847534,
0.3010705411,
-0.2151072323,
-0.6111909151,
0.513718009,
1.0696188211,
0.4549466074,
-0.4859342575,
0.0590180084,
0.2165684104,
-0.461034596,
-0.1468818188,
0.6647182107,
-0.0743483752,
0.5411149263,
0.6546220183,
0.5862680674,
-0.0189418383,
-0.4507404566,
0.0320319682,
0.1775076836,
-0.2761196196,
-0.2935575843,
0.8890624642,
0.6628943682,
-0.4132463038,
0.126104787,
-0.3849591315,
-0.3229072392,
0.3610204756,
0.5070205331,
0.7629535794,
-0.3552289009,
0.0567012914,
0.1282710582,
0.340385139,
0.1842781007,
0.0637899935,
0.101091966,
-1.0882841349,
-0.691154778,
-0.7338157892,
-0.5293793082,
0.1245168447,
-0.4813202024,
-0.0205192957,
-0.8109160662,
0.0938519463,
0.1514572501,
-0.127906993,
-0.4206074476,
0.0321852937,
0.5183083415,
1.0624477863,
-0.9843375683,
0.77976197,
0.9275978804,
0.040801201,
-0.3028468192,
0.0131332967,
-0.2442584038,
-0.9123595357,
0.1753792316,
-0.3040547371,
-0.1311100423,
0.504571557,
-0.52341187,
-0.7587028146,
0.889420867,
0.3273740411,
-0.692407012,
0.159315303,
0.0090067042,
0.5774906278,
-0.485476017,
0.213242963,
0.5771983266,
0.4050294757,
0.1159733981,
-0.7729703784,
0.0512565263,
-0.2747571766,
-0.1770136207,
0.1596748084,
-0.4581932724,
0.6143715382,
-0.1892324388,
0.4096553028,
0.1278887093,
0.701598227,
0.2631337643,
0.0515573658,
0.982550025,
0.4894064069,
0.960067451,
0.1875450462,
0.978520453,
-0.7151793242,
0.1578359753,
1.0499778986,
-0.4475940466,
0.9394928813,
0.3055761158,
-0.1486159414,
0.4277984202,
0.5561836362,
0.1177141815,
0.4358783364,
-0.258268863,
-0.3260805011,
-0.6706621051,
-0.0128170606,
-0.0802076831,
0.4345905185,
0.3013280332,
-0.2499786615,
-0.0721012354,
0.1246667281,
0.0267916992,
0.1339311451,
-0.5959863663,
0.7992473245,
-0.1212570518,
-0.5704253912,
0.7495818734,
-0.0401741117,
0.432510227,
-0.1970844567,
0.2061053067,
-0.196999386,
0.3177767992,
-0.0605827682,
-0.5220053196,
-0.2645363808,
-0.0750631392,
-0.0031517041,
-0.0159322005,
0.9556342959,
-0.5645419359,
-0.8968584538,
0.2072242498,
0.5364993215,
-0.1482636034,
-0.0828526095,
-0.9366756678,
0.0280801896,
0.0141176963,
-0.1552924812,
0.2349055707,
0.3702853918,
0.0717849582,
0.6924747229,
0.6976864934,
0.3530947566,
0.006796354,
0.2683508694,
0.9956535697,
-0.4764818251,
-0.387637198,
-0.6798084378,
0.4229181111,
-0.2149770856,
-0.3111536801,
0.5539214015,
0.207623288,
0.6390052438,
0.0798625723,
0.7450833917,
-0.0420565717,
0.567006588,
-0.6426196694,
0.6984041333,
-0.5575767756,
0.2858120799,
-0.1572124362,
-1.1826658249,
-0.3068811595,
0.4332183599,
-0.4891213775,
0.314651072,
0.4921808243,
0.6339810491,
-0.3342634141,
-0.2112242728,
0.4018263519,
0.7882717252,
0.3737067878,
0.5112794042,
0.6867928505,
-0.1482814997,
0.404103756,
-0.2471192181,
-0.2527294159,
-0.3958311677,
-0.8986909389,
-1.1883831024,
-0.255651623,
-0.4174132347,
0.0383095406,
0.3884804845,
1.3450089693,
0.9676449299,
-1.2556638718,
0.0678109154,
0.0078322403,
0.1382560879,
-0.3660246134,
-0.0965850353,
0.1755090356,
-0.5251749754,
-1.0744367838,
0.8658611774,
0.4705676436,
-0.3534666002,
-0.1303375512,
-0.133078903,
-0.1948546916,
0.0973668247,
0.5671831369,
0.2453427166,
-0.5697561502,
-0.502816081,
-0.3705745041,
0.1914010197,
0.1960999668,
0.4925360382,
-0.5854004622,
0.1702669263,
0.4544906616,
0.7603132129,
-0.0273269769,
0.1081348285,
0.2991734147,
-0.7652651072,
0.3832433224,
0.2162996531,
0.3679202497,
0.3002795577,
-0.2999479771,
0.3863404393,
0.0558106601,
-0.7433216572,
-0.9099076986,
-0.0776330754,
-1.2023839951,
-0.3245057464,
1.2182326317,
0.2718067765,
-0.2668107748,
-0.094153665,
-0.2482381165,
-0.0833992511,
-0.7000166774,
0.9050590396,
0.4414081573,
0.0223504491,
-0.5648082495,
-0.6880378723,
0.2979544997,
0.4435214102,
-0.8963466287,
-0.0816751793,
0.124164708,
0.3468464017,
0.1332105249,
0.265745014,
0.482162565,
0.0411851145,
-0.2482080162,
0.1186446398,
-0.4493236542,
-0.4296667874,
-0.1128620207,
0.1597014666,
0.6532970667,
-0.0401997939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00332v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00332v3
|
A Careful Examination of Large Language Model Performance on Grade School Arithmetic
| 2024-05-01T05:52:05 | 2024-05-03T17:53:26 |
Hugh Zhang, Jeff Da, Dean Lee, Vaughn Robinson, Catherine Wu, Will Song, Tiffany Zhao, Pranav Raja, Dylan Slack, Qin Lyu, Sean Hendryx, Russell Kaplan, Michele Lunati, Summer Yue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive success on many
benchmarks for mathematical reasoning. However, there is growing concern that
some of this performance actually reflects dataset contamination, where data
closely resembling benchmark questions leaks into the training data, instead of
true reasoning ability. To investigate this claim rigorously, we commission
Grade School Math 1000 (GSM1k). GSM1k is designed to mirror the style and
complexity of the established GSM8k benchmark, the gold standard for measuring
elementary mathematical reasoning. We ensure that the two benchmarks are
comparable across important metrics such as human solve rates, number of steps
in solution, answer magnitude, and more. When evaluating leading open- and
closed-source LLMs on GSM1k, we observe accuracy drops of up to 13%, with
several families of models (e.g., Phi and Mistral) showing evidence of
systematic overfitting across almost all model sizes. At the same time, many
models, especially those on the frontier, (e.g., Gemini/GPT/Claude) show
minimal signs of overfitting. Further analysis suggests a positive relationship
(Spearman's r^2=0.32) between a model's probability of generating an example
from GSM8k and its performance gap between GSM8k and GSM1k, suggesting that
many models may have partially memorized GSM8k.
|
[
-0.4372021556,
-0.5267674923,
0.8102168441,
0.0236401036,
-0.1070936769,
-0.0279836692,
0.0766832903,
-0.3529562056,
-0.3223666847,
0.6405971646,
-0.5125176907,
-0.4560140371,
-0.8516203165,
-0.1323785186,
-0.3928712904,
0.6930164099,
-0.1073587686,
0.2195427567,
-0.5771631002,
-0.1268790066,
-0.0897183195,
-0.8617095947,
-0.6611460447,
-0.7206802964,
0.3131498694,
0.2604720294,
0.774453342,
0.9710515738,
0.5727261901,
0.295804441,
-0.2558341324,
0.0376417451,
-0.5445186496,
-0.1027816087,
-0.3732082844,
-0.5945006609,
-0.5982748866,
0.2638324499,
0.6934458613,
0.9659256339,
-0.3744443655,
0.1835305393,
-0.1017653942,
1.0941021442,
-0.705532074,
0.2000344396,
-0.6286578774,
-0.180296585,
-0.4507638812,
0.1329885721,
-0.6232730746,
-0.4263689518,
-0.1426045895,
-0.7325338721,
-0.0164594706,
-0.0846206099,
0.6505573988,
0.3666431308,
-0.4257316291,
-0.3969028592,
-0.6190912127,
0.9165632725,
-0.8483384252,
0.387175858,
0.830183208,
0.4880209565,
-0.2705746889,
-0.5688410997,
-0.3487789035,
-0.1372467875,
0.1986366212,
0.1101341769,
-0.1065578312,
-0.0059116422,
0.7438842654,
0.4011886716,
-0.5801305771,
-0.1605460793,
-0.5991080403,
-0.1506581753,
0.6659103632,
0.4074732363,
0.1902992278,
-0.0098512387,
-0.2533347905,
-0.0897054225,
-1.1938390732,
0.1826547831,
0.5865949392,
0.0813818201,
0.2401824147,
0.5811983943,
-0.3187720478,
0.760502398,
-0.3875900805,
-0.2778363526,
-0.0209211819,
-0.1755411923,
-0.2083285153,
0.1818986982,
0.5135038495,
0.0998088568,
0.643102169,
-0.0829270333,
-0.3397818208,
0.3669159412,
0.2056965232,
-1.0190187693,
-0.3671929538,
-0.0595008247,
-0.0485732444,
-0.0088519305,
0.1236657873,
-0.1131588295,
-0.2549712658,
-0.5213872194,
0.3751572669,
-0.3253602087,
-0.0750404298,
0.5424504876,
0.2287842929,
-0.285391897,
0.3337206244,
-0.8435240388,
0.4153928161,
1.2817003727,
0.571660459,
0.0320209824,
-0.2813771963,
-0.3695396483,
-0.0799459666,
-0.6447482705,
0.6974529028,
-0.6103585362,
-0.3795136511,
-0.0226156451,
-0.1764603108,
-0.2104460597,
-0.9144362807,
0.8428258896,
-0.623190701,
0.0311818272,
-0.4223385453,
-0.9131958485,
-0.1579321027,
0.2198577821,
-0.6392808557,
0.9895578027,
0.0897616744,
-0.5178726315,
0.2967320681,
-0.0664436147,
-0.2397890985,
-0.095102407,
-0.072212778,
-0.3894882798,
0.0627498403,
0.089391768,
0.1732480228,
-0.267685771,
0.2669586837,
-0.692636013,
-0.5325735211,
0.4149914682,
-0.5046836734,
0.8186501861,
0.218594119,
0.0880259201,
-0.3735271692,
-0.8340480924,
0.3345009387,
-0.0033845874,
-0.2838559151,
-0.5574348569,
-0.1545101106,
-0.4704329967,
0.548186481,
-0.004619807,
-0.4965925515,
0.3154578805,
-0.1848605722,
0.5667432547,
0.7132177353,
-0.0856951401,
0.3562325239,
-0.6311796904,
0.4648944736,
-0.0817973167,
0.0992911682,
-0.5197319984,
-0.569845438,
-0.6631774902,
-0.1953707635,
0.4451369643,
0.4317422509,
-0.5323036313,
0.1329673827,
-0.5185027122,
-0.4880377054,
-0.3722496033,
0.2120429575,
0.4324426651,
0.4857747257,
0.1311494857,
-0.148746863,
-0.1069015041,
-0.8520210385,
-0.478966713,
-0.1780200303,
-0.1735969782,
0.2861154079,
0.4345286787,
0.099150598,
0.8286086917,
-0.4596177042,
-0.0367809385,
0.1329465061,
0.0510769337,
0.2507246435,
0.4483623207,
0.316672951,
-0.3728270233,
-0.2774167061,
-0.1960617006,
-0.8724999428,
-0.187406078,
0.1463702023,
-0.3167340159,
0.0359363146,
0.3264096379,
-0.6132763028,
0.4424535334,
0.569106102,
-0.5231934786,
0.4834596217,
-0.1275323182,
0.1406016946,
-0.7155602574,
-0.0790658742,
0.2253293842,
-0.1504932046,
-0.538764596,
0.0317678303,
0.3477575779,
-0.024708489,
-0.3033327758,
0.4366783202,
-0.1207405776,
-0.1310361475,
-0.0916988403,
0.0967604592,
0.1922299266,
0.1257044673,
-0.3954388201,
0.9627328515,
0.3228102922,
-0.3223368824,
0.2011694014,
0.0439759679,
-0.7471958995,
0.4481229484,
-0.6467790008,
0.2443165481,
0.1208420545,
0.3216997087,
-0.9771158099,
-0.1875746548,
-0.08090543,
-0.4993268251,
0.2009007633,
-0.5499020815,
-0.6986522079,
-0.2367704511,
-0.1763581634,
0.4632167816,
0.4867345691,
-0.7020519972,
0.2956555784,
0.2958354652,
-0.403333962,
-0.4751238823,
-0.5910845995,
0.0491061099,
-0.1356263161,
-1.1407908201,
-0.1169047877,
0.0829045475,
-0.5730205774,
-0.0278736725,
-0.4444870353,
-0.190715909,
0.2118373215,
0.4299409688,
0.6013227701,
-0.4073014259,
0.0728010163,
0.0508274771,
-0.2477461398,
0.5086610317,
-0.0817511827,
0.3692779541,
-0.1353709102,
-0.6653254032,
-0.1788632274,
-0.0095348004,
0.7554953694,
-0.1083668992,
0.6744042635,
-0.1692980975,
-0.4698954523,
-0.2504649162,
-0.4771019518,
-0.1047670096,
-0.4903746545,
0.1657461971,
-0.6143779159,
-0.7126978636,
0.6863726377,
-0.1390527189,
-0.1213240996,
0.4198243022,
0.0917559341,
0.1004209742,
1.2593472004,
0.1246323436,
-0.0589989126,
0.2006812692,
-0.2869935036,
-0.000651773,
-0.7288006544,
-0.1449276805,
-0.500433147,
0.0118686864,
-0.3719401956,
-0.4089712799,
0.1140585616,
0.482616961,
-0.5506267548,
0.0318967402,
-0.1512663066,
0.8652847409,
0.3749659061,
0.0258845165,
0.5405524373,
0.1826095581,
-0.0441793874,
-0.2719588876,
-0.7088932395,
-0.7806719542,
1.2866133451,
0.5362935066,
0.9397078156,
0.0595878586,
0.6158728004,
0.0192495584,
0.5703245401,
-0.5550838709,
0.4472719133,
-0.383646369,
-0.8246937394,
-0.2733842432,
-0.888597846,
-0.6598749161,
0.223990798,
0.0908494219,
-0.5330638289,
-0.0326798223,
0.0906525254,
-0.1515850872,
0.2063184083,
-0.6803479195,
0.8447678685,
0.0608857274,
-0.4659307599,
-0.1287472546,
-0.2969679534,
0.8081247211,
-0.1341917068,
0.3643881381,
-0.3332487941,
0.1759488881,
0.616130054,
-0.5541440248,
0.3744977117,
0.0032447225,
-0.4033479691,
0.3537052274,
0.3892849386,
0.7088124156,
0.0121663446,
-0.2068347484,
0.4289357364,
-0.0679617673,
-0.6226421595,
-0.7388542295,
0.8608651757,
-0.7089597583,
-0.4932753742,
-0.357667774,
-0.3352183104,
-0.3908484876,
0.048562374,
0.1863110811,
0.7966044545,
0.1915893108,
0.2343065292,
0.8253437877,
0.0841125324,
0.1069122478,
0.4347561598,
-0.3672894239,
-0.5235444903,
0.9824168086,
0.4790717363,
0.6984598637,
-0.1217510104,
0.2847219706,
-0.3687226176,
-0.4941608608,
-0.7785767317,
0.3035977185,
-0.9721199274,
-0.1067471579,
-0.3422451615,
-0.4066593945,
-0.2044586539,
0.0389863104,
-0.5725613832,
-0.7085617185,
0.1232501045,
-0.0301612839,
0.0329306498,
0.9344578385,
0.3410060704,
0.1641647369,
-0.8075372577,
0.0964951515,
0.3156443536,
0.5368965268,
-0.0146166952,
-1.0077030659,
-0.2187497318,
0.1345793605,
-0.2053704709,
-0.4090259671,
0.0409460962,
-0.0473176613,
0.5412908196,
0.6282734871,
-0.1235267892,
0.6221572757,
-0.5428081751,
0.5954164267,
0.1170587465,
-0.9056001306,
0.1442141384,
-0.4706288278,
0.3751464188,
0.4172157347,
0.3688698709,
-0.4596494734,
-0.5250554681,
-0.7426027656,
-0.5534977913,
0.7436788082,
0.2488945574,
-0.0404093675,
0.2592434585,
0.4074466825,
0.0374465697,
0.0048798285,
-0.373645395,
-0.4091739953,
-0.2258195281,
-0.1610517353,
-0.1942390054,
-0.3113427758,
-0.241906628,
-0.2364301533,
0.617836535,
0.1367134154,
-0.2457467616,
-0.2458512336,
-0.0498296283,
-0.2431887984,
0.2730523646,
0.9573435783,
1.1569828987,
-0.0194571633,
0.468911618,
0.026947476,
-0.781098187,
0.1424754113,
0.1541164666,
-0.1297251135,
-0.1585299671,
0.6006256342,
0.5172510147,
0.1629140824,
-0.6304864883,
0.3617924154,
-0.0135865901,
-0.4035508037,
-0.1189568937,
0.2316474915,
0.2899005711,
0.0360374562,
0.6031243205,
0.081938073,
0.0718332455,
-0.6056613326,
0.2756356597,
0.1995848268,
-0.0287432764,
-0.2557697594,
0.5354397893,
-0.1345217824,
-0.1704473346,
0.6203144789,
-0.2669284344,
-0.7788743377,
0.8645175099,
0.4745506346,
0.4119441509,
-0.2543203235,
-0.0453079827,
0.5288051963,
0.5097019672,
-0.5669967532,
0.0102537442,
0.1636844277,
-0.4919194281,
-0.7288580537,
-0.3173476458,
-0.501611948,
0.204524681,
-0.6786307693,
0.0034779257,
-0.5072542429,
-0.0223690514,
0.1970018595,
0.2398011386,
-0.2920595407,
0.2646251023,
0.2974184155,
0.9933868647,
-0.9671584964,
0.8917953372,
0.554194212,
-0.0206130743,
-1.0451614857,
-0.2579887211,
0.0009260185,
-0.8391250968,
0.8246101141,
0.1686476767,
0.0467549823,
-0.2163278162,
-0.4462729692,
-0.9395504594,
0.874899745,
0.5676897168,
-0.7538551688,
0.3034738898,
0.4873420298,
0.4451774657,
-0.1506045759,
0.2745887041,
0.6456531286,
0.3309125602,
0.458352983,
-0.9268773794,
0.0243768506,
-0.1388602108,
-0.1259325892,
0.527998805,
-0.544121325,
1.106176734,
-0.0791838393,
-0.2789337933,
-0.0914312676,
0.2080358118,
0.5465855002,
0.7324348688,
0.2967271209,
1.0601273775,
0.6792193651,
-0.3146777749,
1.0358223915,
-0.1771798134,
0.5222724676,
1.0941212177,
-0.3330680728,
0.8525836468,
0.1580367535,
-0.6505405307,
0.0837611184,
0.5962957144,
0.2578174174,
0.3858083487,
0.4100707173,
-0.4002666473,
-0.6553148031,
0.3594495952,
-0.487190783,
0.1068583578,
0.3902009428,
-0.2161803842,
-0.3980917335,
-0.2779603004,
0.204197824,
0.1905125529,
-0.5308074951,
0.5194347501,
0.3516073227,
-0.7489552498,
0.7823873758,
-0.1162577346,
0.1916016489,
-0.3227293491,
-0.0584024675,
-0.537116766,
0.3564598858,
-0.2368853688,
-0.9278985262,
0.2745814621,
-0.0827007666,
-0.2139001489,
-0.1325616986,
0.6340897679,
-0.4790912569,
-0.6211894155,
-0.0613046959,
0.4163573384,
0.277123183,
-0.2776926756,
-0.5102096796,
0.252614975,
-0.189500466,
-0.2476297766,
0.5113088489,
0.6239222884,
-0.0414612964,
1.0121054649,
0.7505458593,
0.0757279322,
0.4144456685,
0.0943612084,
0.9149054289,
-0.4936273694,
-0.3074940741,
-1.0593510866,
0.1112417057,
-0.0508408695,
-0.3322922289,
0.9173702598,
0.961730361,
0.9707503915,
0.1873027384,
0.5098657608,
0.6554658413,
0.4853501618,
-0.7172473669,
0.6329194903,
-0.2829361856,
0.4345411956,
-0.1151814461,
-0.8897896409,
-0.04581853,
0.610260129,
-0.6120396256,
0.0151894204,
0.6954707503,
0.6142252088,
-0.1736967862,
0.2115982175,
0.5878227949,
-0.087512888,
0.2310819626,
0.7383739948,
1.1295469999,
-0.471062839,
0.6275671721,
-0.3713488579,
-0.1342389435,
-0.1259794831,
-0.6455097198,
-0.8947901726,
-0.1641300619,
-0.3411020935,
-0.3913838863,
0.0960677937,
0.5795278549,
0.6341988444,
-0.5887312293,
-0.05204954,
-0.0687366202,
0.1442404389,
0.1127742678,
-0.1853794605,
0.1481838673,
-0.2164275199,
-0.5662673116,
0.237886712,
0.1109478772,
0.0624069944,
-0.2687741518,
-0.0934554413,
0.3533780873,
0.2992638946,
0.5720287561,
0.1460078657,
-0.5935395956,
-0.1370904744,
0.0770381987,
-0.4886711836,
0.0248881169,
0.9015516639,
-0.5375662446,
0.3263558149,
0.388753891,
0.6723492146,
0.5610664487,
0.2866249084,
0.210317269,
-0.3436577022,
-0.1247010082,
0.125188753,
0.3193420172,
0.302393049,
-0.1102563217,
0.5495301485,
0.328119278,
-0.759971559,
-1.0438729525,
0.0957233906,
-0.7533656359,
-0.1515680254,
1.2260326147,
-0.4425450861,
-0.1700658947,
0.0104981782,
0.097301878,
-0.1847666502,
-0.4017881155,
0.8823367953,
1.3065103292,
0.0599044338,
-0.0434130393,
-1.0644801855,
0.39869681,
0.4551520348,
-0.8549491763,
0.3949552178,
0.4826205969,
0.3700796962,
0.1450573355,
0.3046784997,
-0.186791271,
0.317037642,
0.2974261045,
-0.2509042621,
-0.3537776768,
-0.1943062991,
-0.3529780507,
0.1244171262,
0.0843441784,
0.0750497058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00321v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00321v1
|
DFKI-NLP at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Towards Robust LLMs Using Data Perturbations and MinMax Training
| 2024-05-01T05:03:08 | 2024-05-01T05:03:08 |
Bhuvanesh Verma, Lisa Raithel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The NLI4CT task at SemEval-2024 emphasizes the development of robust models
for Natural Language Inference on Clinical Trial Reports (CTRs) using large
language models (LLMs). This edition introduces interventions specifically
targeting the numerical, vocabulary, and semantic aspects of CTRs. Our proposed
system harnesses the capabilities of the state-of-the-art Mistral model,
complemented by an auxiliary model, to focus on the intricate input space of
the NLI4CT dataset. Through the incorporation of numerical and acronym-based
perturbations to the data, we train a robust system capable of handling both
semantic-altering and numerical contradiction interventions. Our analysis on
the dataset sheds light on the challenging sections of the CTRs for reasoning.
|
[
0.0077459794,
-0.8790471554,
0.5325487256,
0.2663580477,
-0.1066718251,
-0.2215408832,
0.0882416815,
-0.2014353573,
-0.0433128774,
0.8127251267,
-0.5407497883,
-0.5968937278,
-0.8214409351,
0.4853853583,
-0.268543601,
1.0032331944,
-0.1001489237,
0.4932515323,
-0.1540296078,
-0.1113488078,
-0.4992504418,
-0.8401546478,
-0.687834084,
-0.3217976987,
0.6994264722,
0.446995616,
0.5705011487,
0.3010373712,
0.7631695867,
0.2696013451,
-0.2702895105,
-0.0557171628,
-0.6408926249,
0.2397934645,
0.1334919035,
-0.5431797504,
-0.4634685814,
-0.231306836,
0.522474587,
0.6304140687,
-0.2607806027,
-0.3998951614,
0.0832545832,
0.4142134488,
-0.4875844419,
-0.0432180911,
-0.6933282614,
0.1512819529,
-0.0445850044,
-0.2076843828,
-0.3232061863,
-0.1929800659,
0.1725068688,
-0.6010963917,
0.1242582723,
-0.3467590809,
0.6615421772,
0.6889474392,
-0.8302642703,
-0.4957302809,
-0.5067233443,
0.9027410746,
-1.0971413851,
0.3942814469,
0.5421103239,
0.2059906721,
-0.618282795,
-1.0042021275,
-0.4846546352,
-0.2487172782,
-0.0242505278,
0.1009699032,
-0.1582360119,
0.3894600272,
0.5070055127,
-0.0170163624,
-0.3503878117,
0.3142147064,
-0.1778676212,
-0.3770881593,
0.5146619678,
0.5688051581,
0.033176925,
-0.059296418,
-0.4580757916,
0.1515081823,
-0.7181863189,
-0.1742821336,
0.1622715443,
0.2963621914,
-0.1640419513,
0.7016811371,
-0.1433940083,
0.8249971867,
-0.0574855283,
-0.2876387537,
0.2495287508,
-0.7004611492,
-0.3147713244,
-0.0292911828,
0.7428025603,
0.3228515387,
-0.2255957723,
-0.088986747,
-0.3875399232,
0.0409266986,
0.1630350649,
-0.7368622422,
0.0155331222,
0.2778989077,
-0.172352016,
-0.7579960227,
-0.314607352,
-0.9464634657,
-0.3801710904,
-0.3121566474,
0.645806849,
-0.4539057016,
0.0233547185,
0.3562234342,
-0.1917581856,
0.1771167964,
0.4015916288,
-0.5915930867,
0.5223905444,
0.6858420968,
0.6360967755,
-0.1194644049,
-0.1256581545,
-0.6652131677,
0.1046218872,
-0.1598135233,
0.7390121222,
-0.5345565081,
-0.6014736295,
0.1929648072,
-0.0569852144,
-0.1404137313,
-0.4690490663,
1.0959504843,
-0.406227082,
0.2456251681,
-0.4892266393,
-0.7861482501,
0.1236055642,
0.4280353189,
-0.6328089833,
0.8929483891,
0.0259491187,
-1.100463748,
0.2033149153,
-0.6757564545,
-0.4441088438,
-0.1107064933,
-0.3233167231,
-0.4167458415,
0.1113109067,
0.2003647536,
0.209529534,
-0.1274321079,
0.3737608492,
-0.3990932703,
-0.2101834118,
0.4000160992,
-0.5057979226,
0.699323535,
0.352722019,
-0.3316272497,
0.0469823182,
-0.8398765326,
-0.2126503587,
0.005661299,
-0.3821959794,
-0.3269814849,
-0.1911644787,
0.0391347185,
0.1360393912,
0.2773816884,
-0.5877264738,
0.1907859892,
-0.6318480968,
0.6574277282,
0.5397197008,
0.3039713204,
0.1695277393,
-0.2303348333,
0.6615602374,
0.1581724733,
0.3248943686,
0.0263941549,
-0.3484788835,
-0.6681250334,
-0.3514323533,
0.4754811525,
0.4762085676,
-1.0808714628,
0.1877922416,
-0.2207412273,
-0.2360133678,
-0.1121073663,
-0.0607590899,
0.2701609731,
0.7621837854,
0.2739460766,
0.0720172226,
-0.6559634805,
-1.01197052,
-0.0660833567,
0.0220853649,
0.0785625875,
0.0626241937,
0.693356216,
-0.4358974993,
0.7079280019,
-0.2457024753,
-0.429649502,
-0.2219991833,
0.1963232905,
0.4074358344,
0.4180483222,
0.2807302773,
-0.7840512395,
-0.1441846639,
-0.3354079723,
-0.6437074542,
-0.4452513754,
-0.213706255,
-0.040509671,
-0.0836770386,
0.7762581706,
-0.394141227,
0.654031992,
0.5137132406,
-0.4319958985,
0.3892020285,
-0.1959587187,
0.1301659495,
-0.968781352,
-0.0366824754,
-0.0681459755,
-0.1738012731,
-1.0573275089,
-0.2709853351,
-0.3342233896,
0.2226424664,
-0.3394698501,
0.4684472382,
-0.1076494083,
0.1675584316,
-0.3159472346,
-0.2274304777,
0.0146851102,
0.134249106,
-0.0983724147,
0.684659481,
0.1998273879,
-0.5539603829,
0.0489080101,
0.5992444158,
0.0236319248,
0.1969539672,
-1.0222854614,
0.0875756294,
-0.0494308174,
0.3605085611,
-0.8712925315,
-0.3468182683,
0.0903936401,
-0.5226982832,
0.265311271,
-0.120247297,
-0.4786684513,
-0.1887235194,
-0.2493491322,
0.369774431,
0.1061398685,
-0.3089740872,
0.646402359,
0.4695587456,
-0.1637866348,
-0.7350273728,
-0.9521588087,
0.3278834224,
-0.2502807677,
-0.4373602271,
0.4158383608,
-0.0892410278,
-0.3242814243,
-0.1652428061,
0.0679365322,
-0.3560027182,
0.1498598158,
0.2681944668,
0.2018728852,
-0.1294142902,
0.046485737,
0.3032909036,
-0.059404593,
0.1784665585,
0.1036545634,
0.2123642415,
-0.0344650596,
-0.4324044585,
-0.574841857,
0.3709259033,
0.5719545484,
0.2031019479,
0.4740390778,
0.376021564,
-0.522554636,
0.1358246654,
-0.548063159,
-0.1993641108,
-0.46604985,
0.4339439571,
-0.5409266949,
-1.3696824312,
0.2103450596,
-0.1293176562,
0.0868347064,
0.4316081405,
0.8965142965,
0.0209444594,
1.209538579,
0.5096937418,
0.0290477425,
0.2063996792,
-0.1142044589,
0.1026082188,
-0.7477315664,
-0.1312730759,
-0.6461005211,
-0.1236445904,
-0.3778158724,
-0.5051545501,
0.6674101353,
0.054301247,
-0.3420321941,
-0.1523247957,
-0.4030812383,
0.1377697289,
0.2818543017,
0.1743306816,
0.1933803111,
0.1569583565,
-0.4544309676,
-0.3422724009,
-0.9430055618,
-0.4757226408,
1.1113444567,
0.5352959633,
0.7603127956,
0.1608715057,
0.6150105596,
0.301060468,
0.1490322053,
-0.6855946183,
0.330016464,
-0.1303113103,
-0.5522500277,
-0.187964797,
-0.355817169,
-1.0070766211,
0.1231517047,
-0.2038339972,
-0.4693453312,
0.329495281,
0.0455680005,
-0.3950626254,
-0.0393456072,
-0.5186636448,
0.7153460383,
-0.343932122,
-0.2826825976,
-0.0557481609,
-0.7784520388,
0.2857264876,
-0.1430493742,
0.2437283993,
-0.0521304905,
-0.4552212358,
0.5143826008,
-0.6271916628,
1.064927578,
-0.3592739105,
-0.1018208563,
0.1890289932,
-0.1122408807,
0.607694149,
0.2512972355,
-0.3215829134,
0.155492574,
0.3878523409,
-0.4598664939,
-0.5385189652,
0.5641458035,
-0.7073805928,
-0.4984025955,
-0.5883873105,
-0.4002781808,
-0.4533237815,
0.1238219738,
0.4617787004,
0.6838402748,
-0.2983068228,
0.1378048956,
0.6137273312,
-0.4077889323,
-0.0083522107,
0.4251537323,
0.1154865324,
-0.6981544495,
0.4100556374,
-0.146597296,
0.1998154968,
0.4528854191,
0.2594516873,
-0.5192543864,
-1.0444779396,
0.058297541,
0.3185189068,
-0.8129871488,
-0.2451913804,
-0.7135659456,
-0.2629401386,
-0.5257664323,
-0.0192992296,
-0.1688130498,
-0.4907970726,
-0.3886058331,
-0.1128266081,
0.3133397698,
0.7998484373,
-0.1433122158,
0.3086682558,
-0.8728721142,
-0.051202599,
0.1104761213,
0.1182767376,
-0.4141213298,
-0.8536868095,
-0.1417703331,
0.0816947669,
-0.0236854088,
-0.7219573855,
0.4140675068,
0.3430009186,
0.6050118208,
0.2513384521,
0.1276824325,
0.7132613063,
-0.4973117709,
0.7701219916,
0.3140418828,
-0.7473578453,
0.7710239887,
-0.5533599854,
0.3071830273,
0.841379106,
0.4103832245,
-0.3001500368,
-0.3642083704,
-0.4015695453,
-0.6950089335,
0.4045728445,
0.3604272306,
0.1099035367,
-0.0171083901,
0.8064314127,
0.0679565296,
0.0417360254,
-0.5570490956,
0.1327658892,
-0.1018947363,
-0.6386665702,
0.0825739801,
-0.6965882778,
-0.4816356301,
-0.2909419537,
0.6206686497,
-0.3599593341,
0.3995990455,
0.6499875784,
0.0885503963,
0.1897213012,
0.2031231225,
0.8580302596,
0.5152063966,
-0.0004640875,
0.1624282449,
0.5845835805,
-0.6418766975,
0.1265530884,
0.1710166782,
-0.1401884854,
-0.026607452,
0.6605452299,
0.8204378486,
0.3011304438,
-0.8949658275,
0.7512802482,
-0.5504314303,
-0.5805935264,
-0.663053453,
-0.0713307932,
-0.2520010769,
0.2678806782,
0.0038971875,
-0.0869866982,
0.3967488408,
0.1379257739,
0.3999332786,
0.2572742105,
-0.8022243977,
-0.5235456824,
0.7569947839,
0.1166706979,
0.1464039981,
0.4141432941,
0.1249484718,
-0.5548989177,
0.4977071285,
0.4421840906,
0.5292093158,
-0.0457619503,
-0.0849836841,
0.5076164603,
0.2976568341,
0.0753588155,
0.4527969062,
0.3747617304,
-0.8754569292,
-0.5692808628,
-0.4811090529,
-0.3424076438,
0.394321382,
-0.5869975686,
0.59284693,
-0.5298648477,
-0.3471339345,
0.0547480658,
-0.2080762386,
-0.5205988884,
0.2162188292,
0.0911688954,
1.0563684702,
-0.6390373707,
1.0090773106,
0.7007569671,
-0.1504009366,
-0.7709533572,
-0.1943708658,
0.4046328068,
-0.5300648212,
0.8161206841,
-0.1815163046,
-0.0896181762,
-0.035820473,
-0.7019069195,
-0.852189362,
0.9706171155,
0.2028414309,
-0.4888553321,
-0.0859619156,
0.4158037007,
0.611923933,
-0.2044292539,
0.169052884,
0.7282683253,
0.3675763607,
0.3672561347,
-0.7066508532,
-0.0837441906,
-0.1493002623,
-0.0143626127,
-0.0624400117,
-0.3417291939,
0.4575103819,
-0.1168851182,
0.1385788023,
0.3457477689,
0.649948597,
0.2496412545,
0.3360845149,
0.7414533496,
0.7655067444,
0.6421345472,
-0.110371381,
0.9872688651,
-0.2050594389,
0.2586321235,
1.1303262711,
-0.5384677052,
0.7662872672,
0.6292985082,
-0.1707381755,
0.1260816157,
0.5261924267,
-0.0184697546,
0.6109042168,
0.1125573739,
-0.5243066549,
-0.1020121649,
-0.1914985925,
-0.2069910169,
0.5862756968,
0.7199769616,
-0.0777838826,
-0.0466767028,
0.1036283523,
0.1051065996,
-0.1251006871,
0.1498907804,
0.9207436442,
0.2194963098,
-0.6072950959,
0.6755974293,
0.0412477851,
0.5698286891,
-0.7847218513,
-0.1392514706,
-0.1590028107,
0.283911854,
-0.1456631124,
-0.3746067882,
0.4394983649,
0.0969181061,
0.1180634648,
0.1746165603,
0.931430757,
-0.2359542102,
-0.6276991963,
0.276999861,
0.2439305037,
-0.1312284619,
0.3872471452,
-0.9028910995,
0.211890161,
0.260076344,
-0.2392987311,
0.3158717453,
0.6294233203,
0.1601192206,
0.5304703116,
0.4856730998,
0.1775307506,
0.1071112528,
0.3831669092,
0.9809108377,
-0.6271670461,
-0.245929867,
-0.6201892495,
0.3269625902,
-0.0157173127,
-0.4466994107,
0.5888155103,
0.4571109712,
0.2534811795,
0.3093516529,
0.7947028875,
0.0886039957,
0.677030623,
-0.7761644125,
0.2433455735,
-0.5884047747,
0.350851953,
-0.0939005911,
-0.2801830769,
-0.5575372577,
0.3391262889,
-0.2544414401,
-0.1324749738,
0.6056237221,
0.7980675697,
0.340239346,
0.2251916528,
0.3363989294,
0.7039549947,
0.5944016576,
0.4375959635,
1.0151672363,
-0.4567183256,
0.4277810454,
-0.2857884765,
-0.2878552675,
-0.0774659514,
-0.8471772671,
-0.733027637,
-0.4046610594,
-0.3532888293,
-0.4954513311,
0.0882555693,
0.8781475425,
0.3600464761,
-0.9618486166,
-0.0471872129,
-0.3863452375,
-0.1081827357,
0.1270595938,
-0.1675338298,
0.2608788908,
-0.619584322,
-0.651163578,
0.6045824885,
0.3424674571,
0.1523227245,
-0.054680407,
-0.1608162969,
-0.2010962069,
-0.0465049595,
0.5720912814,
-0.1455582231,
-0.6949816942,
-0.1524099708,
0.0534052327,
-0.1756563634,
-0.058704704,
0.9540243745,
-0.6064968705,
0.4524577856,
0.4701749384,
0.9103662968,
0.4618049264,
-0.1896525472,
0.6834539175,
-0.5100024343,
0.291461736,
0.6905729771,
0.37770316,
0.1374251097,
-0.4154663384,
0.661323905,
0.2797297239,
-0.7920722961,
-0.9000844955,
0.1074283496,
-0.8984640837,
-0.2478449643,
1.2723910809,
-0.0180654675,
-0.0816546679,
-0.5130364895,
-0.1288587749,
0.1210004017,
-0.1007646173,
0.4638366997,
0.8266177177,
-0.2264633775,
-0.021355344,
-0.9372235537,
0.6784057021,
0.6069649458,
-0.7014039159,
-0.3231235147,
0.5848181248,
0.2366940528,
-0.3019491136,
0.8296560049,
-0.4638392925,
0.0577199496,
0.0147865796,
-0.2281953096,
0.1600942612,
0.013920269,
-0.7818505764,
-0.0355838425,
0.2244499177,
0.2406266332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00302v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00302v3
|
Generating Feedback-Ladders for Logical Errors in Programming using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-01T03:52:39 | 2024-05-08T20:38:58 |
Hasnain Heickal, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In feedback generation for logical errors in programming assignments, large
language model (LLM)-based methods have shown great promise. These methods ask
the LLM to generate feedback given the problem statement and a student's
(buggy) submission. There are several issues with these types of methods.
First, the generated feedback messages are often too direct in revealing the
error in the submission and thus diminish valuable opportunities for the
student to learn. Second, they do not consider the student's learning context,
i.e., their previous submissions, current knowledge, etc. Third, they are not
layered since existing methods use a single, shared prompt for all student
submissions. In this paper, we explore using LLMs to generate a
"feedback-ladder", i.e., multiple levels of feedback for the same
problem-submission pair. We evaluate the quality of the generated
feedback-ladder via a user study with students, educators, and researchers. We
have observed diminishing effectiveness for higher-level feedback and
higher-scoring submissions overall in the study. In practice, our method
enables teachers to select an appropriate level of feedback to show to a
student based on their personal learning context, or in a progressive manner to
go more detailed if a higher-level feedback fails to correct the student's
error.
|
[
-0.0689457953,
-0.7522985935,
0.4870497286,
0.4489401281,
0.1516969353,
0.1926119328,
-0.097733818,
-0.0453958027,
0.0842516348,
0.2344414443,
-0.5150202513,
-0.6289078593,
-0.3811514676,
0.2612663805,
-0.5588669181,
1.17770648,
-0.1021059752,
0.1389742196,
-0.5005789399,
0.1904865801,
-0.8174389005,
-0.5241933465,
-0.6141913533,
-0.1746441126,
0.576957345,
0.7645348907,
0.359741658,
0.404227674,
0.7094962597,
0.233447969,
0.1688989103,
0.0945679173,
-0.4961999655,
0.2748902142,
-0.2629161775,
-0.7006775737,
-0.4064408243,
-0.1522221118,
0.8171212077,
0.7025979161,
-0.2070786953,
0.4745164216,
0.3578798175,
0.6063375473,
-0.5799200535,
0.2492577285,
-0.3769638538,
0.2484056503,
-0.1978342533,
-0.4025996923,
-0.7023819089,
-0.5686935186,
-0.3898675144,
-0.2097166032,
-0.054192543,
-0.0275552869,
0.3754705787,
0.2668296993,
-0.461896956,
-0.5322777629,
-0.9666700363,
0.7098403573,
-0.9063072205,
0.1446034312,
0.1335150003,
0.334202677,
-0.3952337801,
-0.3897979558,
-0.3966009915,
-0.4246578813,
0.1107240766,
0.2948037386,
0.1103510335,
-0.0882406011,
0.462787658,
0.0874369591,
-0.427425921,
0.2665135562,
-0.4591333866,
-0.2149436474,
0.6504490376,
0.4080618322,
0.2803120911,
-0.3858705759,
-0.2990274131,
-0.1010556221,
-1.030741334,
0.3801332414,
0.5857930183,
0.3687410951,
0.2356719971,
0.8314472437,
-0.0288142338,
0.8659587502,
-0.102066204,
-0.4905383587,
0.2192448378,
-0.3641848266,
0.0986828431,
-0.1999125779,
0.6130421162,
0.4545069337,
-0.0207708627,
-0.0128530851,
-0.6179535985,
0.3153344989,
0.1397447735,
-0.6273559928,
-0.2804197371,
0.1887244582,
-0.2925066948,
-0.4843499959,
0.0751755387,
-0.8637497425,
-0.5599806905,
-0.3239185512,
0.4177107513,
-0.0555046275,
-0.1694660038,
-0.1954507977,
0.1348651797,
-0.0439927205,
0.4425387979,
-0.476827085,
0.2977885604,
0.4296353459,
0.4821987152,
0.020584926,
-0.4704201221,
-1.0830556154,
0.0293045826,
-0.4240912497,
0.596322,
-0.6685992479,
-0.3576386571,
0.0579638034,
-0.5164051652,
0.1214141995,
-0.6184444427,
0.3082129061,
-0.3425278664,
0.2172166258,
-0.337434411,
-0.6185998321,
0.2615593374,
0.3002875745,
-0.3131840527,
0.976557076,
0.0466303527,
-0.811891377,
0.0192020759,
-0.602809906,
-0.1448284239,
0.0806789473,
-0.4317507744,
-0.121012859,
0.0216269568,
0.1141801402,
0.3173120916,
-0.1580457538,
0.3005832732,
-0.0654172003,
-0.3372080922,
0.3783155382,
-0.1436333656,
0.6326880455,
0.1709712744,
-0.3706715405,
0.3270944953,
-0.8976992369,
0.0701785088,
0.0221473817,
-0.7267472744,
-0.0857200325,
0.2638180852,
-0.2347359359,
0.4009608626,
0.2303032875,
-0.4981208444,
0.3284342289,
-0.1352203786,
0.353112042,
1.0545276403,
-0.0094218301,
0.0994632095,
-0.412032783,
0.8443543911,
0.302786082,
-0.1174356341,
-0.2423755527,
-0.2562640309,
-0.7187099457,
0.1577987224,
0.2725173831,
0.6777769923,
-0.704719007,
0.2018580735,
-0.0790930092,
-0.3076305389,
-0.2228183299,
0.6340739727,
0.5354311466,
0.6460575461,
0.0748275891,
-0.2950908244,
-0.4654515982,
-0.5621754527,
-0.3343443871,
-0.4579219818,
-0.1167966798,
0.2817725837,
0.43452847,
-0.3756061196,
0.9535968304,
-0.6097127199,
-0.1664893776,
-0.2112590969,
0.0467359796,
0.2165729254,
0.5730921626,
0.274223417,
-0.3376681805,
-0.3655496836,
-0.3644961119,
-0.6004831791,
-0.2615885139,
-0.2990058064,
-0.0396728814,
0.2342876345,
0.4672168791,
-0.2740350962,
0.138259083,
0.5888800621,
-0.2280016392,
0.7637881637,
-0.1429716796,
-0.0755355582,
-1.0117424726,
-0.0852276683,
0.1356878132,
-0.1512615234,
-0.2642421424,
0.2760785222,
0.0018042453,
-0.1227762774,
-0.065176025,
0.2114185095,
-0.4069174826,
-0.0513154007,
0.0368768945,
0.4191922545,
-0.4120681882,
0.5273311138,
-0.335784018,
0.3586551845,
0.5897697806,
-0.3204269409,
0.6662232876,
-0.0683988333,
-0.0967113078,
0.7042740583,
-0.569747448,
0.2959458232,
-0.2153764665,
0.4109978974,
-1.3289400339,
-0.4013995528,
0.300016731,
-0.6877177358,
0.2004050463,
0.0483738594,
-0.7196024656,
-0.6836078167,
-0.5475724339,
0.1989796162,
0.4253352284,
-0.5406858921,
0.2044880837,
0.1495839804,
-0.2420258224,
-0.6720576286,
-0.5996128321,
0.0556590557,
0.0591515824,
-0.7972106338,
-0.2536375523,
-0.27052176,
-0.1687669456,
0.0199982282,
-0.3779243827,
0.1315443218,
0.1641118973,
0.4013653994,
0.3530014753,
-0.0988204256,
0.1472815722,
-0.0723701641,
0.0315648392,
0.493658185,
-0.1579034925,
0.3051371872,
-0.4356348515,
-0.6598647237,
-0.2379084378,
0.2763602138,
0.4379743338,
-0.3588526845,
0.61740309,
0.2417284697,
-0.3358235359,
-0.6659196615,
-0.4848665297,
-0.237462312,
-0.4132720828,
0.4128575027,
-0.2101892829,
-0.8038153648,
0.4934070706,
-0.1241272017,
0.3374010324,
-0.0160947628,
0.6078300476,
-0.2525489628,
1.1100893021,
0.5896012783,
0.0497628599,
0.2077618092,
-0.1854465902,
0.4811541438,
-0.6849847436,
-0.4664727747,
-0.8146600127,
-0.3106275201,
-0.3937480748,
-0.2540178895,
0.3939365745,
0.3597187996,
-0.3586145937,
0.1225133017,
-0.4558388889,
0.4919980168,
0.7443429232,
0.1142822951,
0.4307780564,
0.042637419,
-0.2434832454,
-0.1093711331,
-0.7632642984,
-0.5262088776,
1.1128726006,
0.328545481,
1.0677000284,
0.3250808716,
1.1608774662,
0.0888507217,
0.5133554339,
-0.743778944,
0.6235063672,
0.2990776896,
-0.4778170884,
-0.3719385564,
-0.9285761118,
-0.690698266,
0.1925956309,
-0.072620593,
-0.7661712766,
-0.3453718126,
0.445514679,
-0.3382094502,
0.3287955523,
-0.5969750881,
0.753798306,
-0.0438140519,
-0.3722698092,
-0.0928293988,
-0.7503188252,
0.4806919396,
-0.1731388718,
0.4834736586,
0.4190378785,
0.2966751158,
0.756077528,
-0.6351524591,
1.044426918,
-0.333101213,
-0.3705450892,
0.4689085484,
0.4632486105,
0.6903698444,
0.2272596955,
0.1058667898,
-0.4570195675,
-0.044839114,
-0.2712082565,
-0.6101288199,
0.751830399,
-0.8472332358,
-0.8926212788,
-0.4687589705,
-0.6937176585,
-0.3407613337,
0.1150775403,
0.1065322757,
0.7438541055,
0.4926686287,
0.065682888,
0.2753055692,
-0.3882392049,
0.2066459954,
0.3509544432,
-0.6235201955,
-0.0937114507,
1.0151207447,
0.2212631404,
0.227299571,
0.0497509986,
0.1762068421,
-0.0797870681,
-0.5396683216,
-0.3227805793,
0.2271674424,
-0.9641292691,
-0.3247884512,
-0.1650202274,
-0.2872225046,
-0.3202280402,
-0.1220681742,
-0.168862164,
-0.3736050725,
-0.0358459726,
-0.1912560463,
-0.1286576688,
1.0172101259,
-0.2332286388,
-0.0011407433,
-0.966724813,
0.0786747783,
0.2072582394,
0.2108725756,
0.3361628652,
-0.3835379779,
-0.0851751864,
0.1275984645,
-0.5434595346,
-1.0163319111,
0.1823621094,
-0.1700794995,
0.4358736575,
0.0263459086,
0.1013135463,
0.473677516,
-0.3733903468,
0.8939196467,
0.4503514767,
-1.0027781725,
0.8370722532,
-0.2893352807,
0.2828730643,
0.2983352542,
0.2832930684,
-0.6589149833,
-0.8616485596,
-0.1986100376,
-0.8528299332,
0.7308415174,
0.1137773767,
0.1596580744,
0.0155235706,
0.2825775743,
-0.0663520768,
0.0983264223,
-1.2054531574,
-0.1884308457,
-0.1103904769,
-0.1752205193,
0.1839900464,
-0.214633137,
-0.2327804565,
-0.1448125839,
0.5046051145,
-0.2295448333,
-0.0921057686,
0.1566182524,
-0.0640884861,
-0.568323195,
0.5113613009,
0.4303140044,
1.1435140371,
-0.0767036751,
0.3883465827,
-0.0039594425,
-0.2577908933,
0.2370567322,
-0.4181024432,
-0.1589771807,
-0.1213693246,
0.4739539027,
0.2376410067,
-0.103242524,
-0.7609152198,
0.5940104723,
0.0929913521,
0.0220523253,
-0.180918023,
0.137693882,
0.2417414486,
0.1071096882,
0.2872625887,
0.2898589075,
-0.0168136433,
-0.660543859,
0.015886711,
0.2585034072,
-0.1049894542,
-0.279284656,
0.4766803384,
0.5325129032,
-0.4849174917,
0.8223932385,
-0.174883604,
-0.5205091238,
0.7296438813,
0.8685516715,
0.4397864044,
-0.1578316987,
0.4547044933,
0.5819067955,
0.2515729964,
-0.0209292471,
0.2173238993,
-0.0899104625,
-0.506952405,
-0.6626686454,
-0.5364252329,
-0.5681422949,
-0.0551034845,
-0.7045798898,
0.2162284851,
-0.5846093893,
-0.0155327134,
-0.330861032,
-0.0327631012,
-0.3477365077,
0.005420357,
0.2221877724,
0.7242649198,
-0.8450590968,
0.671818614,
0.9767007828,
-0.5549954772,
-1.3253452778,
-0.032172773,
0.1916625649,
-0.4187138081,
1.085039854,
0.0687458366,
-0.1755468547,
-0.2016057521,
-0.6098759174,
-0.6667734981,
0.7998409271,
0.2811478376,
-0.8283851743,
-0.1963683665,
0.2980315983,
0.6844750643,
-0.2477931231,
0.1697526872,
0.064951323,
0.2815944254,
0.1714760214,
-0.7908667326,
0.2397643328,
-0.2450928092,
0.2107624561,
0.146429345,
-0.6040831804,
0.9158922434,
-0.4270254374,
-0.1136901155,
-0.1023844704,
0.5325644016,
0.5962194204,
0.1513581723,
0.5721060038,
0.5208684206,
0.9810714126,
0.1190042421,
0.9583761692,
-0.2136056572,
0.5701970458,
1.2313001156,
-0.3375612497,
0.8452398181,
0.5142406821,
-0.1824972332,
0.5858601332,
0.517691493,
-0.1159532964,
0.1173369512,
0.8287670612,
-0.014561234,
-0.2845947146,
0.2290724665,
-0.4418592453,
-0.0340360105,
0.1441400945,
-0.0282837767,
-0.413425386,
-0.1835611016,
0.0364118405,
0.1479736269,
-0.4330309033,
0.301116854,
0.1810734272,
-0.9400589466,
0.5894615054,
0.0522708781,
0.5762712359,
-0.2744829655,
-0.1858678013,
-0.4768236876,
0.3122547865,
-0.8128462434,
-0.8052567244,
0.2235189676,
0.4447678626,
-0.1447161436,
-0.1718140244,
0.4208676517,
-0.3415032923,
-0.5371864438,
0.2675035596,
0.5013519526,
0.1288183182,
0.4325349033,
-0.3643238842,
0.0763945356,
0.095616214,
-0.2030089647,
0.2485782802,
0.3491583169,
-0.0043917624,
0.7939385772,
0.591671288,
0.1515189856,
0.3156756461,
0.0915546045,
0.8668143749,
-0.5102242827,
-0.2038438171,
-0.8508771658,
0.4792001545,
0.1916176826,
-0.237652719,
1.1253088713,
0.480627507,
1.1071988344,
-0.0685884431,
0.7191253304,
-0.0641424358,
0.4145227075,
-0.4052054882,
0.2962331176,
-0.4796210825,
0.7869981527,
-0.5837481618,
-1.2109180689,
-0.4278731048,
0.5318148732,
-0.1117196381,
0.0862063989,
0.8562361002,
0.7943529487,
0.2657874823,
-0.125938043,
0.0164006408,
0.5363894701,
0.4872210324,
0.8986166716,
1.3151122332,
-0.0411059633,
0.6728590131,
-0.1396370232,
-0.4183664024,
-0.2376117557,
-0.6702225804,
-0.8859414458,
-0.270401448,
-0.5725082755,
-0.7697349191,
-0.0781454518,
0.9891102314,
0.3658210933,
-0.7444288731,
-0.4950197935,
-0.201194495,
0.383012116,
-0.0142911477,
-0.2435861975,
0.1755276471,
-0.7287287116,
-0.4568386674,
0.1965800375,
-0.0015532336,
-0.4511899054,
-0.4536004663,
-0.1444952339,
0.1974704862,
-0.0256000459,
0.5353611112,
0.0547265112,
-0.5455981493,
-0.4835005999,
0.0917320177,
-0.2968619168,
0.1368585229,
0.6997231841,
-0.6127110124,
0.2597576976,
0.7680664659,
0.6856966019,
0.2916205823,
-0.1045521051,
0.4339660406,
-0.769107163,
-0.4409873784,
0.3267409503,
0.251883626,
0.1918073297,
-0.3447243571,
0.4297341406,
0.2466249615,
-0.7994525433,
-1.1320519447,
0.2110459805,
-0.8616415858,
-0.1898763329,
1.1308416128,
-0.3149863183,
-0.0590283833,
0.3730972409,
-0.3522956669,
-0.0435695648,
-0.3042958975,
0.8473376632,
0.9399734139,
-0.2947134674,
0.1330901384,
-0.4498645365,
0.1776599139,
0.5025103688,
-0.9313871861,
-0.0166595876,
0.865691483,
0.5305061936,
0.3808286786,
0.4748305678,
-0.215018034,
0.3930752873,
0.0673962012,
-0.060571894,
0.0518113412,
-0.6851643324,
-0.3399677873,
0.4275344014,
0.4461082816,
0.126959458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00301v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00301v3
|
Enhanced Language Model Truthfulness with Learnable Intervention and Uncertainty Expression
| 2024-05-01T03:50:09 | 2024-06-07T01:41:15 |
Farima Fatahi Bayat, Xin Liu, H. V. Jagadish, Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) can generate long-form and coherent text, yet
they often hallucinate facts, which undermines their reliability. To mitigate
this issue, inference-time methods steer LLM representations toward the
"truthful directions" previously learned for truth elicitation. However,
applying these truthful directions with the same intensity fails to generalize
across different query contexts. We propose LITO, a Learnable Intervention
method for Truthfulness Optimization that automatically identifies the optimal
intervention intensity tailored to each specific context. LITO explores a
sequence of model generations based on increasing levels of intervention
intensities. It selects the most accurate response or refuses to answer when
the predictions are highly uncertain. Experiments on multiple LLMs and
question-answering datasets demonstrate that LITO improves truthfulness while
preserving task accuracy. The adaptive nature of LITO counters the limitations
of one-size-fits-all intervention methods, maximizing truthfulness by
reflecting the model's internal knowledge only when it is confident. Our code
is available at https://github.com/launchnlp/LITO.
|
[
0.2704606354,
-0.9463333488,
0.8265351057,
0.2731396258,
-0.1840996444,
0.1868367791,
-0.4954673946,
-0.277091831,
-0.0861047581,
0.5942198634,
-0.3614327312,
-0.3656895459,
-0.4362381697,
-0.0636016428,
-0.103158474,
0.8744633794,
0.1245075166,
-0.0353163704,
0.1202976704,
-0.116933316,
-0.3065964878,
-0.0592965335,
-0.7408143282,
-0.3746457994,
0.4096509218,
0.4438970387,
0.7897711396,
0.568482995,
0.3641231954,
0.3134898543,
-0.1032247096,
0.3757370114,
-0.6140665412,
0.1798081994,
-0.0156989153,
-0.6857163906,
-0.3879998028,
-0.0433588587,
0.7302194834,
0.8140442967,
-0.2965870798,
-0.1346317679,
0.0743505955,
0.6005837321,
-0.7678149939,
0.0775789395,
-0.8678437471,
-0.0588008799,
0.3868506253,
-0.2263004929,
-0.5709234476,
-0.6115198731,
0.1301333755,
-0.7042892575,
-0.118767783,
0.0194714349,
0.5077100396,
0.5020930767,
-0.4508671761,
-0.4854882061,
-0.9244371653,
1.1151540279,
-0.9364097714,
0.4255032837,
0.235468775,
0.2695392966,
-0.2248581201,
-0.583756566,
-0.4843577743,
-0.1616433114,
0.1180354282,
0.3785821795,
0.1744425148,
0.3595624864,
0.2055910379,
0.0679664239,
-0.4369169474,
0.0401227474,
0.0546867996,
-0.3166304231,
0.5174928308,
-0.0306296404,
0.0009648313,
-0.0620525889,
-0.365770936,
0.0675677583,
-0.5657802224,
0.1478176117,
0.3568768799,
0.133186534,
-0.1033669934,
0.4942353368,
-0.2522946298,
0.6716829538,
-0.0905148983,
-0.6587352157,
0.2794007361,
-0.1749499589,
-0.1347885132,
0.1653473824,
0.5532267094,
0.5712242126,
-0.027905954,
-0.2099458575,
-0.5970323086,
-0.1317015588,
0.0611073375,
-0.9927204251,
0.2376973629,
0.5051645041,
-0.1619754732,
-0.4792824388,
-0.1645557135,
-0.7463840246,
-0.4399103522,
-0.0401977077,
0.611119926,
-0.4179393053,
-0.3406883776,
0.3932858706,
0.1115940064,
0.2447278351,
0.4008823335,
-0.5854568481,
0.0142202377,
0.483076781,
0.7541192174,
0.0204349663,
0.0673773959,
-0.7789762616,
0.2452166528,
-0.6722514033,
0.3636032641,
-0.8151964545,
-0.2766726911,
0.1279567331,
-0.300634712,
-0.1389529407,
-0.36692065,
0.7971701026,
-0.697011888,
0.3516191244,
-0.10045553,
-0.8283483982,
-0.2183802128,
0.2343428433,
-0.5069066286,
0.7854652405,
0.2012030184,
-0.7010520697,
0.2458762527,
-0.7250550985,
-0.2560061216,
-0.0469404794,
-0.2359347343,
-0.423065871,
0.4005638063,
0.1844694763,
0.3995325863,
-0.105181478,
0.6331498623,
-0.2664109468,
-0.2940825224,
0.4346852899,
-0.6038293242,
0.5559478998,
0.2759592831,
-0.2239216119,
0.2967321277,
-0.8961324096,
0.0602177046,
0.307233423,
-0.3850064278,
-0.2945135534,
0.1163449585,
-0.1982568055,
-0.108820565,
0.4486228824,
-0.6559951305,
0.0130800176,
-0.6264683008,
0.2487602681,
0.8594754338,
0.1784329414,
0.2881856859,
-0.3854915202,
0.4064821601,
-0.2460125238,
0.4301649034,
0.066057004,
-0.2643432915,
-0.7512129545,
-0.2832372785,
0.0870093256,
0.5254797339,
-1.1093202829,
0.4082323015,
-0.4457670748,
-0.0542263053,
-0.4668107331,
0.1912809759,
0.4494153261,
0.8573712111,
0.2366494536,
0.2104910165,
-0.3494929075,
-0.7901907563,
-0.3862749636,
-0.2442697883,
0.0927968845,
0.3416148424,
0.3082892001,
-0.1824100763,
0.8808899522,
-0.540723443,
0.2105387747,
-0.4439215064,
0.352737546,
0.297952652,
0.2901532352,
0.4732156098,
-0.9892439246,
-0.4578900039,
-0.0497953258,
-0.7611892223,
-0.2387513369,
-0.4961399734,
0.1490920037,
0.0775337741,
0.2563946843,
-0.0995813087,
0.1871202737,
0.691070497,
-0.0389171131,
0.2308610529,
-0.259811759,
0.107512325,
-1.1328641176,
-0.0995702744,
-0.4400835335,
-0.364402324,
-0.7836974859,
-0.0562082678,
0.1762362421,
0.1821757406,
-0.349683255,
0.6113493443,
-0.2588327825,
0.1034433842,
-0.4866353869,
0.0672242865,
0.0621573143,
0.4986338317,
0.2241664678,
0.9168929458,
0.4827384651,
-0.5222126245,
0.253320694,
-0.1651350856,
-0.3202738762,
0.3163808286,
-0.69872576,
0.3524888754,
-0.1645866781,
-0.2712619007,
-0.675612092,
-0.4696253836,
-0.0343208387,
-0.3986727893,
0.3027582169,
-0.0053113657,
-0.3082280159,
0.0280149747,
-0.5940988064,
0.2578675449,
0.3842470944,
-0.580514133,
0.8946552277,
0.1717504859,
-0.0895235538,
-0.7668373585,
-0.4791133702,
-0.0216113217,
-0.276250273,
-0.4739552736,
0.0594573729,
-0.551687777,
-0.3258388638,
-0.3290551603,
-0.1975299269,
-0.0253638234,
0.3134121597,
0.0987511203,
0.2866474986,
0.0622285455,
0.3864096999,
0.3003991842,
0.0311161447,
0.0265313499,
-0.0635617301,
0.4423072934,
-0.2537653446,
-0.3121731579,
-0.2497702092,
0.1331421435,
0.3387442231,
-0.0704950243,
0.840076983,
0.6067091227,
-0.3329697251,
-0.3250075281,
-0.740296185,
-0.2960306108,
-0.5428469777,
0.400729984,
-0.3428468108,
-0.9158617258,
0.3878310621,
-0.2475145608,
0.2466682643,
-0.0204049218,
0.2462649643,
0.1808187813,
1.1157569885,
0.8291944861,
-0.0288113747,
0.6075227857,
-0.1029982567,
0.1711870879,
-0.8552742004,
-0.0861347616,
-0.2548007071,
0.1120494679,
-0.4741960466,
-0.4107614458,
0.5810667872,
0.1218785495,
-0.0252901409,
-0.1718675345,
-0.3504576683,
0.3181095123,
0.3041115999,
0.4198875129,
0.4876390398,
-0.083123289,
0.1144810617,
-0.1120966673,
-0.7281885743,
-0.4199364781,
1.2121852636,
0.308167249,
0.8862240911,
0.1681162268,
0.7756395936,
0.0519061312,
0.4745976031,
-0.9947673082,
0.4744618237,
0.3569121361,
-0.5593553782,
-0.4705585539,
-0.7978102565,
-0.7191227078,
0.026093822,
-0.3032174408,
-0.5014488101,
0.1740008742,
0.1127945408,
-0.520486176,
0.1073879004,
-0.6633853912,
0.4640472531,
-0.4196717441,
-0.5166550875,
-0.2264129519,
-0.6128079891,
0.2743323147,
-0.423976481,
0.5436446667,
-0.0831452981,
-0.5578212738,
0.6007310152,
-0.1506289095,
0.8539861441,
-0.0676578507,
-0.1166837662,
0.2874735892,
0.1288756281,
0.8484374881,
0.1758653373,
-0.4073286355,
-0.324265033,
-0.380592972,
-0.458917737,
-0.7777770758,
0.478236258,
-0.6200689673,
-0.5582556129,
-0.1314702779,
-0.8684068322,
-0.4635768831,
0.2756735384,
0.2580795586,
0.4125086367,
-0.1739221066,
0.4411492348,
1.0338900089,
-0.2675336897,
0.6851537824,
0.797958672,
-0.5081961155,
-0.5423946381,
0.7609550357,
-0.0312630124,
0.646916151,
0.4890791476,
0.621013999,
-0.2411988527,
-0.8541733027,
-0.0403671153,
0.2357716709,
-0.6998882294,
-0.141550526,
-0.4326736331,
-0.1175177768,
-0.3924858868,
-0.2126012295,
-0.5933475494,
-0.2817325592,
-0.0091480175,
-0.1936267912,
0.3534907401,
0.5323306918,
-0.0673209205,
0.4150384963,
-0.5668747425,
0.2837562561,
0.5437093377,
0.2457681,
-0.3929811716,
-0.8054434657,
-0.149845466,
0.2012272477,
0.1453912854,
-0.8130950332,
0.417280525,
0.4550918043,
0.534711957,
0.4880714715,
0.4024716616,
0.3097526729,
-0.1899456382,
0.459302634,
0.2420081496,
-0.887486279,
0.8471328616,
-0.2464413643,
0.2682318985,
0.5317966938,
0.3261668086,
-0.2257645279,
-0.2677184641,
-0.3700898886,
-0.6868104935,
0.4008467793,
0.2361906022,
0.2687418759,
0.1854474396,
0.5468555689,
0.1840677857,
0.3796662688,
-0.9274203181,
0.0105181532,
-0.1577495933,
-0.4996207058,
0.2185499817,
-0.4470742643,
-0.438343823,
0.1415050626,
0.7688753605,
-0.6557881236,
-0.089619346,
0.3467888534,
-0.2955995202,
-0.2625742257,
0.3557314277,
0.4978556335,
0.7430038452,
-0.3258188367,
0.1897695363,
0.2360788286,
-0.5658162236,
-0.1645867527,
0.0051619736,
-0.5039699674,
-0.1735651195,
0.7587364316,
0.840221405,
0.1537629813,
-0.8201009631,
0.6793499589,
-0.0828323215,
0.0877452567,
-0.1511300057,
0.3896160722,
-0.0871834084,
0.4179518521,
0.2817497253,
-0.2979273498,
0.2307489812,
-0.59062922,
-0.1753207296,
0.5127758384,
-0.4509007335,
-0.180022046,
0.4424017966,
0.2227250487,
-0.2429148257,
0.3510674238,
-0.1886531264,
-0.5140833259,
0.3535209596,
0.457534343,
0.7999714017,
-0.5174441934,
0.2450754941,
0.2739391327,
0.4434219897,
-0.0661222413,
0.5597259402,
0.170647338,
-1.0834304094,
-0.5029230714,
-0.5302394629,
-0.410816133,
0.2363302708,
-0.580768466,
-0.0822574124,
-0.5996790528,
-0.1290343106,
-0.4247975051,
0.1075111702,
-0.3073991537,
0.2636038661,
-0.0704466179,
0.5895036459,
-0.8113487363,
0.8523615599,
0.3593688905,
-0.3834444284,
-0.8656917214,
0.0496779941,
-0.1614051908,
-0.9751465917,
0.1649059355,
0.1165401936,
-0.4132521749,
0.0246903617,
-0.9650508761,
-0.7456680536,
1.1159319878,
0.6371458173,
-0.6025090814,
0.1740894914,
0.2026928216,
0.4110621512,
-0.4744126499,
0.2219523489,
0.4163909256,
0.4380713701,
0.1818741411,
-0.7338722348,
0.0752699077,
0.1619195044,
0.0603579506,
-0.1648980826,
-0.7182671428,
0.367105782,
-0.4033179581,
-0.020850759,
0.0504238047,
0.748586297,
0.1098998636,
0.2083053589,
0.7075330019,
0.2493654191,
0.9905269742,
-0.0274883416,
1.0025941133,
-0.5319057107,
0.2887444794,
1.3148630857,
-0.2212082446,
0.5886021852,
0.4788528979,
0.0790632293,
0.3016656637,
0.4069574773,
0.4443841875,
0.5483477116,
-0.3319717348,
-0.5747842193,
-0.4336067736,
-0.4513698518,
-0.1873287112,
0.22133331,
0.5180808306,
-0.2703408897,
0.1480332315,
0.0417147875,
0.102079019,
0.2431719452,
-0.1863058656,
0.7548516989,
-0.0196791608,
-0.5138394237,
0.5380703807,
-0.2969914675,
0.4646981359,
-0.7419288754,
-0.1618294716,
-0.3350357413,
0.0192747395,
-0.1354273707,
-0.7333975434,
0.0156290438,
-0.2000663728,
0.0109601822,
-0.1340399086,
0.7262509465,
-0.5408855677,
-0.5622488856,
0.4343602061,
0.4901732504,
-0.0895168781,
-0.1050003096,
-0.7245355248,
0.2864364088,
0.131903246,
-0.6267060637,
-0.0516803972,
0.4660983086,
0.1962766498,
0.9386317134,
0.4674879313,
0.2318453789,
0.0286434125,
0.2715640366,
0.803178668,
-0.3231381476,
-0.1012962312,
-0.5241884589,
0.3514384031,
-0.3190912306,
-0.1106645092,
0.5764366388,
0.5776122212,
0.5295934081,
0.215239048,
0.6505495906,
0.301220119,
0.5677492619,
-0.8257225156,
0.2863447964,
-0.6773548126,
0.488550514,
-0.001360026,
-0.891952157,
-0.2443534583,
0.5837791562,
-0.3841113746,
0.0579228885,
0.6550459266,
0.9837600589,
0.1502602845,
-0.0218120944,
0.6224267483,
0.4804630876,
0.2881526947,
0.4942972064,
0.6942987442,
-0.1451891512,
0.533415556,
-0.4302036166,
-0.5002596974,
-0.2745705843,
-1.0519435406,
-0.8082441688,
-0.2411462218,
-0.20596762,
-0.2136078477,
0.2185633928,
1.0166012049,
0.6750209928,
-0.6146888733,
-0.0587086454,
-0.1791270822,
0.3819371462,
-0.0141443368,
-0.2459793836,
0.3227130771,
-0.5220850706,
-0.8334733248,
0.5285033584,
0.3733720183,
0.0301839504,
-0.0352196768,
-0.2515127361,
-0.0098302914,
0.4845068753,
0.5259982944,
0.0015124276,
-0.498582989,
-0.6579410434,
0.0528510213,
-0.0961341411,
0.1320910901,
0.6446661353,
-0.4776089787,
0.7851806283,
0.4146079421,
0.688836813,
0.3166089952,
-0.2061722428,
0.5067507625,
-0.7303106785,
0.1470270306,
0.594512701,
0.4128789902,
0.5027578473,
-0.557225287,
0.7291145921,
0.2215003073,
-0.3935869932,
-0.8535488248,
0.4327518344,
-0.8719146848,
-0.4509941638,
1.1907494068,
-0.2456270903,
-0.2063857466,
-0.0965223387,
-0.0918468609,
0.3875154555,
-0.4223924577,
0.7730407715,
0.5412709713,
-0.1554712504,
-0.2096434236,
-0.7308129668,
0.4597290158,
0.5660691857,
-0.8373057246,
0.0563192293,
0.4600555599,
0.2930563092,
0.1190441772,
0.4292908907,
0.1566150635,
0.0398225784,
-0.0484089628,
0.104764238,
-0.0017734369,
-0.4994364977,
-0.3737642169,
-0.028760815,
0.3299628496,
0.2284762412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00291v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00291v1
|
How Can I Improve? Using GPT to Highlight the Desired and Undesired Parts of Open-ended Responses
| 2024-05-01T02:59:10 | 2024-05-01T02:59:10 |
Jionghao Lin, Eason Chen, Zeifei Han, Ashish Gurung, Danielle R. Thomas, Wei Tan, Ngoc Dang Nguyen, Kenneth R. Koedinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Automated explanatory feedback systems play a crucial role in facilitating
learning for a large cohort of learners by offering feedback that incorporates
explanations, significantly enhancing the learning process. However, delivering
such explanatory feedback in real-time poses challenges, particularly when high
classification accuracy for domain-specific, nuanced responses is essential.
Our study leverages the capabilities of large language models, specifically
Generative Pre-Trained Transformers (GPT), to explore a sequence labeling
approach focused on identifying components of desired and less desired praise
for providing explanatory feedback within a tutor training dataset. Our aim is
to equip tutors with actionable, explanatory feedback during online training
lessons. To investigate the potential of GPT models for providing the
explanatory feedback, we employed two commonly-used approaches: prompting and
fine-tuning. To quantify the quality of highlighted praise components
identified by GPT models, we introduced a Modified Intersection over Union
(M-IoU) score. Our findings demonstrate that: (1) the M-IoU score effectively
correlates with human judgment in evaluating sequence quality; (2) using
two-shot prompting on GPT-3.5 resulted in decent performance in recognizing
effort-based (M-IoU of 0.46) and outcome-based praise (M-IoU of 0.68); and (3)
our optimally fine-tuned GPT-3.5 model achieved M-IoU scores of 0.64 for
effort-based praise and 0.84 for outcome-based praise, aligning with the
satisfaction levels evaluated by human coders. Our results show promise for
using GPT models to provide feedback that focuses on specific elements in their
open-ended responses that are desirable or could use improvement.
|
[
-0.5696073174,
-0.7007083297,
0.331258148,
0.0639390275,
-0.4236108363,
0.1125589237,
-0.4346859157,
-0.3768959343,
0.116061911,
0.0688653588,
-0.4109225571,
-0.466855377,
-0.5383455753,
0.232285127,
-0.4455263317,
1.3979746103,
-0.0722602978,
0.198177129,
0.1076637059,
0.1343075335,
-0.8263012767,
-0.4888966382,
-0.5886368155,
-0.0479967557,
0.6158815622,
0.625298202,
0.5635057688,
0.4312846661,
0.5081967115,
0.2408229709,
0.0181981958,
0.1620353162,
-0.4296161234,
0.0302486159,
-0.1435017735,
-0.544320941,
-0.5704286098,
0.184560284,
0.2597818673,
0.6531504393,
0.008970187,
0.2712152302,
0.6357995868,
0.4437111914,
-0.3871922493,
0.466186285,
-0.2140254825,
0.2514097989,
0.0112729529,
-0.3302338719,
-0.6358044147,
-0.6357942224,
0.3323974907,
-0.6504389644,
0.5027663112,
-0.2765341997,
0.7599567175,
0.4682965279,
0.0525485985,
-0.3777833581,
-0.8550993204,
0.6896237135,
-0.7049142718,
0.0315119214,
0.4067969322,
0.5266207457,
0.242690295,
-0.5766459703,
-0.3293514252,
-0.2589999139,
-0.2678605616,
0.5379187465,
0.108904615,
0.0053227129,
0.4188693464,
0.5490594506,
-0.4631035328,
0.212754041,
-0.2017938048,
-0.1220271662,
0.4994532168,
-0.0238771457,
0.0169056933,
-0.0102890348,
-0.0470810682,
-0.3077685535,
-0.6283432841,
0.4086622894,
0.4499911964,
0.5228669643,
0.0426562689,
0.6775432825,
-0.1975285113,
0.7677304149,
0.1450376064,
0.0636435524,
0.0563987233,
-0.2494147718,
0.0676752478,
-0.2631354034,
0.5266113877,
0.4518892765,
0.2443353087,
-0.1883249134,
-0.3010396063,
0.0763368979,
0.291023463,
-0.7298613787,
-0.3785605133,
0.1318991035,
-0.3228171468,
-0.073193498,
0.4939672947,
-0.9558298588,
-0.1279675961,
-0.6528945565,
0.6472415924,
-0.4022070765,
-0.0957192555,
-0.0935565457,
-0.0756126195,
0.121289745,
0.5960665345,
-0.9287412763,
-0.0506238602,
0.5116581917,
0.8335707188,
-0.0367128924,
-0.1551703662,
-0.6817089319,
-0.1451583803,
0.0099571394,
0.9063873887,
-0.5236237645,
-0.4540265203,
0.0886967033,
-0.0408302806,
-0.1336841136,
-0.5380131602,
0.3969715238,
-0.4167720675,
0.6031523943,
-0.152549535,
-0.6691286564,
-0.1828943938,
0.0825662166,
-0.5908452868,
0.7129192352,
0.414198041,
-0.5053352714,
0.4237923622,
-0.807084322,
-0.3184041083,
0.1695853919,
-0.1777867675,
-0.48127985,
0.2163993567,
0.3706038594,
0.3576315045,
0.0860995203,
0.1729480028,
0.005521677,
-0.5081755519,
0.2761766911,
-0.3068726659,
0.0905244276,
-0.0207080282,
-0.7492848039,
0.6057392955,
-0.6097882986,
0.3610645831,
-0.1412205994,
-0.3938363194,
0.0351211242,
-0.2378581464,
-0.090183042,
0.0698470175,
-0.1190326586,
-0.2998559475,
0.452141434,
-0.2984684408,
0.4068623483,
0.8692807555,
-0.1118311733,
0.1296572089,
-0.2510596514,
0.8369162679,
-0.1801210493,
0.1533203721,
-0.3196936846,
-0.5747423172,
-0.7467841506,
-0.2520147264,
0.5762979388,
0.2030079365,
-0.8499145508,
0.4529401064,
-0.3208031952,
-0.2642485499,
-0.7130823135,
0.0541649535,
0.550031364,
0.5557395816,
0.6380082369,
-0.650613308,
-0.4271389544,
-0.5500776172,
-0.3609730303,
-0.1289398521,
-0.3515532017,
0.2118670344,
0.3107968867,
0.1136877015,
1.042422533,
-0.6220561266,
-0.2725830972,
-0.333914727,
0.3881630003,
0.2300274968,
0.2356158942,
0.082760796,
-0.7501540184,
-0.7180648446,
-0.1846716851,
-0.3921015859,
-0.1477825642,
0.0319582485,
0.0110434229,
-0.1238567382,
0.2548177838,
-0.2847358882,
0.4867165089,
0.0967515111,
-0.3356269002,
0.8353925943,
-0.002549415,
0.1917718798,
-0.6669914126,
0.0705748424,
-0.1822681129,
-0.1947447211,
-0.4382511377,
0.0932352394,
0.0197226815,
-0.0140614463,
-0.3647438288,
0.174015224,
-0.2579494715,
0.0793468282,
-0.3328952193,
-0.0891725421,
-0.0697839856,
0.7670577765,
-0.0141270775,
0.893887639,
0.2070592195,
-0.5477455854,
0.2960066497,
0.3849972486,
-0.3561349809,
0.4706612527,
-0.7409139276,
0.1763355285,
0.0019480513,
0.1760035604,
-1.0297256708,
-0.595656395,
0.2136276215,
-0.536831975,
0.5055461526,
-0.1748432666,
-0.52455616,
-0.5824773908,
-0.2027247101,
0.2731763124,
0.6141312718,
-0.7076073885,
0.20620583,
-0.1626746804,
-0.3917446733,
-0.2556502223,
-0.3214903176,
-0.2109811306,
-0.1737121642,
-0.2430059165,
0.2489476353,
-0.094769232,
0.2006661892,
-0.1306074858,
0.0160084069,
0.0118178278,
0.0053346879,
0.303334713,
0.2403843552,
-0.1440636814,
0.1047776416,
-0.1618807912,
-0.375587821,
-0.0361657888,
-0.3180464804,
0.460483253,
-0.2869546413,
-0.5802249908,
-0.4726761281,
0.2902327478,
0.4297762215,
-0.3570935428,
0.311889112,
0.8312042952,
0.0183025002,
-0.1566676795,
-0.2091832459,
-0.4391091466,
-0.4156183004,
0.3865751326,
-0.0726813078,
-1.1034485102,
0.2795604467,
0.1695916653,
0.1454033256,
0.2180044949,
0.4415805042,
-0.0845540464,
1.3420203924,
0.5931420922,
0.1468854845,
0.5937033892,
-0.4939299822,
0.276838243,
-0.883433044,
-0.1279100627,
-0.2527221143,
-0.2720702291,
-0.2749603987,
-0.1477844864,
0.407895565,
0.4417931139,
-0.0368221179,
0.3710826635,
-0.7618051171,
0.4985292852,
0.8125017881,
0.3753388226,
0.2432214618,
-0.0262872223,
-0.0713014901,
-0.0685936436,
-0.5000042915,
-0.4694661796,
0.9288403392,
0.4024096429,
0.7285544276,
0.2983960807,
0.4019694924,
0.1310292333,
0.6977239251,
-0.9243673682,
0.3933179379,
0.0009597479,
-0.2094623297,
-0.3855309486,
-0.3846766651,
-0.7939031124,
0.1217632815,
0.1931745857,
-0.5821451545,
-0.3114936352,
0.3811437786,
-0.7769882083,
0.1409610957,
-0.8778648973,
0.9096789956,
-0.2124471068,
-0.5006116629,
0.0700113252,
-0.6990256906,
0.091117464,
-0.0252089519,
0.0452360287,
0.0558770001,
0.3346458972,
0.5764219761,
-0.7351230979,
1.0640846491,
-0.3512357175,
-0.1765145957,
0.3708649874,
-0.3527759612,
0.3354316056,
-0.1381825954,
0.1287407279,
-0.3634679914,
-0.285490185,
-0.4045667648,
-0.9042266011,
0.2414695472,
-0.6828053594,
-0.6679489613,
0.0645896718,
-0.4235135615,
-0.3103094697,
-0.0177068766,
0.6051681638,
0.6093608141,
0.1751859635,
-0.2154024988,
0.5396761894,
-0.1963098347,
0.3862557709,
0.5516257882,
-0.2824333906,
-0.4219725728,
1.1581941843,
0.1946869642,
0.3382407129,
0.3104603887,
0.1696790904,
-0.526332438,
-0.470725894,
-0.717130065,
0.0069106948,
-0.7543955445,
-0.326778084,
-0.3704594076,
0.0233215448,
-0.4487310052,
0.058609087,
-0.0491699204,
-0.4763815999,
-0.356875062,
-0.1899953783,
0.2893531322,
1.027192831,
0.0156326294,
0.5713084936,
-0.7632287145,
0.0510650054,
0.5218079686,
0.7365509272,
0.2621715963,
-0.6634187102,
-0.4737480283,
0.0789425895,
-0.6470400095,
-0.8718720078,
0.4269120395,
0.2900011539,
0.2435049564,
0.3439334333,
-0.1031522602,
0.7288028002,
-0.4176654518,
0.9048084617,
0.0872476622,
-0.8362879157,
0.7932709455,
-0.2611167431,
0.3360171616,
0.4068421721,
0.3606710434,
-0.3012619019,
-0.5128175616,
-0.3886039257,
-1.0408269167,
0.6567104459,
0.059220992,
-0.217146337,
-0.0392402112,
0.3628841937,
0.4386242628,
0.3732647896,
-0.5978116393,
-0.1862074584,
-0.4930597544,
-0.1722928435,
-0.0821143687,
-0.0113821262,
-0.0726200491,
-0.2810491621,
0.7148046494,
-0.4482941329,
0.5103642941,
0.2172925472,
-0.1432828009,
-0.0629666671,
0.5770128965,
0.6135057211,
0.5754641891,
-0.1543155313,
0.0451940484,
-0.2026564181,
-0.3557033539,
0.1951415092,
0.2742781043,
-0.1139964685,
0.2584536076,
0.3719985485,
0.7658810616,
0.1229373962,
-0.3585718274,
0.6540111303,
-0.2351353616,
0.1089627743,
-0.0349979065,
0.2078344524,
-0.3039084971,
-0.0346054211,
0.2960614264,
-0.0642548054,
0.1007796824,
-0.3262866437,
0.2437057495,
0.2006228566,
-0.6222559214,
-0.5031681061,
0.6762029529,
0.2896472514,
-0.2098298669,
0.5345733762,
-0.3568181396,
-0.7638167739,
0.5747793913,
0.4305225015,
0.9319531322,
-0.1802824736,
0.3721572161,
0.482337296,
-0.214888528,
-0.085958004,
0.206307441,
-0.2644877434,
-0.1874825507,
-0.7887111306,
-0.5273046494,
-0.6862950921,
0.0401326902,
-1.1831948757,
0.2733077109,
-0.3298921585,
-0.2601796091,
0.0588901229,
-0.3142625988,
-0.7862463593,
0.0852191597,
-0.1226314679,
0.6899778843,
-0.6735113859,
0.5903332233,
0.8148410916,
-0.9943965673,
-1.2598650455,
0.0046803714,
-0.0752636716,
-0.657483995,
0.5637311935,
0.584127605,
0.2693988383,
0.253341198,
-0.5324061513,
-0.6130430698,
0.7727577686,
0.1617749482,
-0.5301221609,
-0.1501077265,
0.3340314329,
0.7788460255,
-0.2013796866,
0.8099889755,
0.417136997,
0.3492490351,
-0.0099382261,
-1.0587009192,
-0.0222933851,
-0.3705706,
-0.0778064057,
0.1954570711,
-0.5756483078,
0.5700787902,
-0.4355705082,
-0.3289611936,
0.4266037643,
0.625241816,
-0.1066727862,
0.1445541233,
0.3576817811,
0.5740410686,
0.6678782701,
-0.3880414069,
1.1221461296,
-0.0455958359,
0.4705042243,
1.2803370953,
0.2340992391,
0.7614551783,
0.3363692462,
-0.3876268566,
0.4451529086,
0.758641541,
-0.196101889,
0.6402942538,
0.4657029808,
-0.2920046151,
-0.0174304247,
-0.2016483992,
-0.596431613,
-0.0444790907,
0.1975142211,
-0.3727198541,
-0.0971613154,
0.3629615307,
-0.4381683767,
-0.1099113822,
-0.3361152112,
0.9050363898,
-0.0679682642,
-1.0885970592,
0.635402441,
-0.3558851182,
0.6790100932,
-0.4141614735,
-0.3545936644,
-0.153015554,
0.2835148275,
-0.4837797582,
-0.7939400673,
0.1055845395,
0.1552651972,
-0.4573792219,
-0.2371943593,
-0.0138199534,
-0.7394761443,
-0.1442738324,
0.0661475286,
0.3515862823,
0.1639580727,
-0.1428182423,
-0.3953232169,
-0.2294343412,
0.2754768431,
-0.0761767253,
0.220301196,
0.1661072373,
0.1021313965,
0.3530207574,
0.620457828,
-0.0894184485,
0.0285261162,
0.5550516844,
0.8384207487,
-0.6507133245,
-0.4404548109,
-0.6389324665,
0.7007470727,
0.1611041129,
-0.4309709966,
0.8144563437,
0.4361903369,
1.1167486906,
-0.3655810356,
0.9642224312,
0.0092702452,
0.9131157398,
-0.434163332,
0.2391493767,
-0.2210302949,
0.440885216,
-0.3705081344,
-0.8635511994,
-0.3742305934,
0.5523164272,
-0.3830901384,
0.0720752552,
0.6241037846,
0.554025054,
0.1015100032,
0.4518351257,
0.0984514654,
0.0899170935,
0.6110645533,
0.6001873016,
1.2882664204,
-0.261146158,
0.5579244494,
-0.2753429711,
-0.3979322016,
-0.2640072405,
-0.6308327913,
-0.7375355363,
-0.2573974729,
-0.5283296108,
-0.4284646809,
0.1218579412,
0.8583669662,
0.5894461274,
-1.0822588205,
0.0465395823,
-0.2003942281,
-0.0705760941,
-0.3367170393,
-0.3002397716,
0.5649690032,
-0.611064136,
-0.6710530519,
0.1819889992,
0.0363117792,
0.2868553996,
-0.080860503,
-0.0614128448,
0.4272789955,
-0.5875989795,
0.6558581591,
0.2946307361,
-0.8906581998,
-0.4386590123,
0.1445557773,
0.0369854495,
0.1577321738,
0.8519855738,
-0.6780183315,
0.524549067,
0.2247725725,
0.5883204341,
0.1728556901,
0.2587500215,
0.7673333287,
-0.8566403389,
-0.33298859,
0.3048738241,
0.3076097071,
0.4661960602,
-0.2442141026,
0.6933203936,
0.1063839868,
-0.6239690781,
-0.4871399701,
0.0724837035,
-0.6640918255,
-0.0928484201,
1.0009291172,
-0.5831868052,
0.2184500992,
-0.0909840018,
-0.5231801867,
0.4089500606,
-0.4018666446,
0.9691519141,
0.7509045601,
-0.5212382674,
0.0406756513,
-0.4405592382,
0.5479902029,
0.8322040439,
-0.7912489772,
0.0008041192,
0.4475406706,
-0.1127053797,
0.3742705882,
0.299944371,
-0.157677114,
0.5020058155,
-0.412093848,
-0.1735491306,
-0.105172351,
-0.3802024722,
-0.568102181,
0.2362138629,
0.1592961401,
-0.2790988386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00289v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00289v2
|
Adversarial Attacks and Defense for Conversation Entailment Task
| 2024-05-01T02:49:18 | 2024-05-02T03:37:08 |
Zhenning Yang, Ryan Krawec, Liang-Yuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As the deployment of NLP systems in critical applications grows, ensuring the
robustness of large language models (LLMs) against adversarial attacks becomes
increasingly important. Large language models excel in various NLP tasks but
remain vulnerable to low-cost adversarial attacks. Focusing on the domain of
conversation entailment, where multi-turn dialogues serve as premises to verify
hypotheses, we fine-tune a transformer model to accurately discern the
truthfulness of these hypotheses. Adversaries manipulate hypotheses through
synonym swapping, aiming to deceive the model into making incorrect
predictions. To counteract these attacks, we implemented innovative fine-tuning
techniques and introduced an embedding perturbation loss method to
significantly bolster the model's robustness. Our findings not only emphasize
the importance of defending against adversarial attacks in NLP but also
highlight the real-world implications, suggesting that enhancing model
robustness is critical for reliable NLP applications.
|
[
-0.361605525,
-1.356536746,
0.2789473534,
0.0303724371,
0.0253320895,
0.0846174955,
-0.0900959596,
-0.2900568247,
-0.0214529522,
0.9806095362,
-0.5199250579,
-0.1765059978,
-0.9268726707,
-0.1105115563,
-0.8056992888,
0.8156158924,
0.1441110224,
-0.0768351629,
-0.2146753073,
-0.132159248,
-0.3322464824,
-0.6277555823,
-0.7559571862,
-0.4626958668,
0.3419252336,
0.0416934714,
1.18230474,
0.3912062347,
0.6668950915,
0.304053396,
-0.2900208533,
0.1930254996,
-0.5912209153,
0.6371909976,
0.009667919,
-0.9606084228,
-0.3919496834,
-0.0613977797,
0.3046518564,
0.5428129435,
-0.2636546493,
-0.1760585755,
0.1134031489,
0.5017129779,
-0.5848028064,
-0.1524730027,
-1.2956582308,
0.0854345635,
-0.254109025,
-0.2196631283,
-0.701130271,
0.0186826903,
0.1779196262,
-0.3743537664,
0.2583275139,
0.103248544,
1.0716431141,
0.5896692872,
-0.1434710473,
-0.2350527048,
-0.6617343426,
0.6581096053,
-0.932738781,
0.2549956441,
0.2744669616,
0.2828281522,
-0.5322323442,
-0.5789333582,
-0.6542798281,
-0.275034517,
-0.1122219786,
0.037234582,
-0.7146953344,
0.2427332997,
0.3799310029,
0.3292614222,
-0.3306933343,
0.2069905251,
0.1732694507,
-0.1865422726,
0.4370073378,
0.2840460241,
0.4053417146,
0.135583207,
-0.2063381821,
-0.2372439355,
-0.9845302105,
-0.1286965758,
0.7157282233,
0.273801744,
0.0107180746,
0.7228280902,
0.0085760904,
0.5277931094,
0.2223887295,
0.0291018132,
-0.4169580042,
-0.243234247,
-0.4151157439,
0.0274783522,
0.7246903777,
0.19485116,
0.0976691023,
-0.4317733049,
-0.0347375758,
0.3112108409,
0.6651538014,
-0.7718420029,
-0.279366225,
0.2779137492,
-0.1734211296,
-0.5315430164,
-0.1214980707,
-0.6849828959,
-0.5801074505,
0.0232078638,
0.3838089108,
-0.4291489124,
0.030782802,
0.3249855936,
-0.0874077305,
0.2089220881,
0.2830412686,
-0.859906435,
0.3879443109,
0.931850493,
0.6464287043,
-0.1619642675,
-0.2544948757,
-0.4831723869,
0.0952966884,
-0.4197869599,
0.5790388584,
-0.5634558797,
-0.4522770941,
0.1451257467,
0.0146253081,
-0.2412055582,
-0.5017433763,
0.6987826824,
-0.6103976965,
0.2386978567,
0.164972201,
-0.5119161606,
-0.1882649958,
0.739233613,
-0.569271028,
0.5828102827,
-0.2940921783,
-0.9038482904,
-0.0810355544,
-0.4658546448,
-0.5246693492,
-0.2256631553,
-0.0074266349,
-0.7178208828,
0.1105858311,
0.4085560739,
0.4134996533,
-0.2945454717,
0.0966448709,
-0.2975397706,
-0.0629290789,
0.4924283922,
-0.8030775189,
0.7302461267,
-0.0489862002,
-0.2646677792,
0.2484685779,
-0.3689120114,
-0.1807816029,
0.3715783656,
-0.131053105,
-0.2349528372,
0.2149897516,
-0.4187437594,
-0.1355761439,
0.0935768932,
-0.5174741745,
0.1946690083,
-0.9647673368,
0.5357530117,
0.4495944977,
0.0535811931,
0.4822268486,
-0.380946815,
0.6063290238,
0.0649539977,
0.4328560531,
-0.264443785,
-0.5932764411,
-0.9514085054,
-0.0287754536,
0.3321146965,
0.6249279976,
-0.8370374441,
0.3816848397,
-0.122821562,
-0.6925697327,
-0.7657741308,
0.0219154228,
0.3253352344,
0.20534724,
0.3394238651,
0.1502300203,
-0.423812449,
-0.9187167883,
-0.6014002562,
-0.0242111795,
-0.0636033267,
0.0748282447,
0.4298523068,
-0.5136629343,
0.6433368921,
-0.562787056,
-0.2283229977,
-0.2278836966,
-0.0116636287,
0.0714230165,
0.3388107419,
0.5061490536,
-0.8926967978,
-0.4404805899,
-0.2512463331,
-0.4603779316,
0.1821810454,
-0.3241197765,
-0.185182184,
0.1224045977,
0.6286852956,
-0.7934128642,
0.4442123473,
0.7008384466,
-0.2557945549,
0.3334094584,
-0.0964129791,
-0.0634086356,
-0.977709949,
-0.4187387526,
-0.2176059783,
-0.2292170227,
-0.8582916856,
0.4713887274,
-0.2203147262,
-0.0980319455,
-0.3933889866,
0.1554257423,
0.0285656713,
0.5423021317,
-0.326767385,
0.0466370881,
0.2321416885,
0.2377511114,
-0.3096400201,
0.5590329766,
0.7205218077,
-0.6021362543,
0.4217886031,
0.4629458487,
-0.0851545855,
0.532566011,
-0.9523785114,
0.2294722497,
0.0487819873,
0.3068713248,
-0.7119851112,
0.0207280423,
0.2326999307,
-0.646736443,
0.572140038,
-0.1792179793,
-0.5196210146,
0.0388548188,
-0.3924253881,
-0.1064900756,
0.222250551,
-0.6019040942,
0.8387853503,
0.5234563351,
0.0969296545,
-0.6518038511,
-0.8644628525,
0.5624461174,
-0.3750391603,
-0.7895485759,
0.5803623796,
0.1257764101,
-0.3903669119,
-0.2369273752,
0.0659765452,
0.1182478592,
0.4442061782,
0.2712029219,
0.0422450863,
-0.1544885188,
-0.1604472548,
-0.2242915034,
-0.0669799671,
0.3012500703,
0.0580306053,
0.734834969,
-0.108281672,
-0.6695042253,
-0.2885197103,
0.2635336816,
0.6751898527,
-0.0532594845,
0.960180521,
0.5116806626,
-0.4415388703,
-0.2773807943,
-0.5160900354,
-0.3353333175,
-0.5157399774,
0.5854191184,
-0.39119187,
-0.8196516037,
0.6122862101,
0.010290538,
0.1382942349,
0.5431317687,
0.3902619183,
0.0526451543,
1.2537101507,
0.5510230064,
-0.1881196052,
0.2201603949,
-0.2354249507,
0.4654629827,
-0.8473643661,
-0.1426567584,
-0.5525811911,
-0.0515513867,
-0.7884941101,
-0.2599414885,
0.2490662187,
-0.0656990036,
-0.1831412613,
0.4834589064,
-0.3913970888,
0.3260319829,
0.417460084,
0.0805569664,
0.1456043273,
-0.1821382046,
0.2503408492,
-0.1661889851,
-0.6650267243,
-0.5485895872,
0.9300435185,
0.6748325825,
1.0661649704,
0.4559760988,
0.3516234756,
0.1434208304,
0.0193901695,
-0.9533302784,
0.5675439835,
-0.3244650364,
-0.4330013692,
-0.3684127927,
-0.3259147704,
-1.0619963408,
0.3828120232,
-0.4466063678,
-0.5007279515,
-0.0778265893,
0.0668675154,
-0.1568383127,
0.5823892355,
-0.3581508696,
0.8310781717,
-0.1888775527,
-0.1030153334,
-0.2651931345,
-0.3508537412,
0.3055454493,
-0.0535550974,
-0.1001494825,
0.040304821,
0.1269768178,
0.4971627593,
-0.2591714263,
1.0188218355,
0.077706039,
-0.3480065167,
0.064071618,
0.4280384779,
0.7315608859,
0.0509217903,
0.0748493448,
0.1978860199,
-0.0932868645,
-0.1486575752,
-0.6886264682,
0.6728935838,
-0.5570291877,
-1.1012867689,
-0.1934745163,
-0.4145488143,
-0.230581671,
-0.0983610675,
0.4325533211,
0.3012734056,
-0.3201274872,
0.5622636676,
1.0331822634,
-0.3709853292,
0.2195504606,
0.383122474,
0.1502147317,
-0.1278985441,
0.7256250978,
-0.17143327,
0.5697184205,
0.5085232854,
0.2810986042,
-0.1460382044,
-0.6645554304,
-0.4216932058,
-0.0633609518,
-0.6322352886,
-0.4283540845,
-0.6848721504,
-0.2456112206,
-0.5157427192,
-0.0406214297,
-0.5843128562,
-0.2874278426,
-0.0848131701,
0.1150402278,
0.2035997808,
0.5599283576,
0.5820754766,
0.4679267108,
-0.570533216,
0.2818286121,
0.4000731707,
-0.0193448681,
-0.1160495579,
-0.9483587146,
-0.0996516347,
0.4101277292,
-0.7699534893,
-0.8390211463,
0.5107361674,
0.3597371876,
0.5189968348,
0.3837408721,
0.1817756891,
0.4702877104,
-0.5905624628,
0.8767818213,
0.1362482905,
-0.8823368549,
0.6361376047,
-0.2845452726,
0.3363267481,
0.2381837964,
0.1842010915,
-0.4796095788,
-0.7502871156,
-0.8813033104,
-0.8777668476,
0.4457074106,
0.2810572982,
0.4272343814,
0.0843545422,
0.1220480651,
-0.1522650421,
0.1313333213,
-0.6592059135,
-0.4295588732,
-0.3125413358,
-0.052389957,
0.0714166984,
-0.2273195088,
-0.5362944007,
-0.0267631449,
0.8051002622,
-0.1542533934,
0.2224378288,
0.0363227315,
-0.0710100904,
0.0680387095,
0.4136475027,
0.546898663,
0.1612176001,
0.1714748889,
0.2625158429,
0.417817682,
-0.3352233768,
-0.0442815088,
0.070715785,
-0.333118856,
-0.0621013939,
0.471472621,
0.9219008088,
0.1691911668,
-0.4695691168,
0.6331146359,
-0.2283254117,
-0.1944404542,
-0.31618312,
0.1658052951,
0.0837186798,
0.10326837,
0.163456589,
0.3068383932,
0.1090338081,
-0.5290596485,
-0.0711368248,
0.8536477089,
-0.3925243616,
-0.1596733779,
0.6382500529,
-0.0928945914,
-0.461912781,
0.3542653918,
0.0598388426,
-0.919505477,
0.6730142832,
0.5990621448,
0.8767332435,
-0.3272378445,
-0.0299264714,
0.0150321927,
0.6640548706,
-0.2419524938,
-0.3406451046,
0.4013181627,
-0.994574368,
-0.3325310051,
-0.4106768668,
-0.8169006109,
0.2775459886,
-0.6129671931,
0.150930956,
-0.3091416359,
-0.2142007351,
0.2012376636,
-0.3919427991,
-0.3932488561,
0.086247392,
0.1151442677,
0.6296809316,
-0.4670657814,
0.6861560941,
0.4104440212,
-0.0607158318,
-0.3022109866,
0.2008900791,
-0.1169914976,
-0.5605570674,
0.5276943445,
0.0172579829,
-0.3730511069,
-0.4354173839,
-0.685931623,
-0.60614568,
0.6115375757,
0.6422826648,
-0.3870662451,
0.0546031445,
0.3205010295,
0.4767635763,
-0.2330262959,
0.0973750725,
0.572894454,
0.2889488637,
-0.022092158,
-0.8647261262,
0.088497065,
0.0147963846,
-0.1222325787,
0.2678646147,
-0.4980168343,
0.7175995111,
-0.1393115669,
-0.3270207345,
-0.1703480184,
0.6481204033,
-0.180838272,
0.0246488359,
0.5328599215,
0.6227679253,
0.5210688114,
-0.3540206254,
1.0197920799,
-0.2649269402,
0.0517214127,
1.0388464928,
-0.0807819963,
0.9062997699,
0.3401104212,
-0.2799411416,
0.2131385505,
0.1760567427,
-0.0851443559,
0.3124510348,
0.3249439001,
-0.0704448298,
-0.1844117939,
0.1251924336,
-0.1813293099,
0.8037091494,
0.7066870928,
-0.1017524227,
-0.0037414068,
0.024594184,
0.2756902277,
0.3964080811,
-0.0733977407,
0.9180076122,
0.0312242787,
-0.7340360284,
0.7198672891,
0.2074985653,
1.073469162,
-0.6917105913,
0.1553554237,
0.0913440585,
0.5014804602,
-0.1604655981,
-0.5315352082,
0.5918387175,
-0.2487930954,
-0.0067066802,
-0.1365321428,
0.6513846517,
-0.5120022297,
-0.2538734376,
0.3111901581,
0.1885529757,
-0.3569015265,
-0.2977505624,
-0.8205824494,
-0.0245797671,
-0.006580241,
-0.2462548316,
0.4276285768,
0.1481566727,
0.306717515,
0.9915021062,
0.5355566144,
0.2472252548,
-0.0751550347,
0.2393990606,
0.8595579267,
-0.3132658601,
-0.2539391816,
-1.2550764084,
0.0393517129,
-0.2273163199,
-0.1027909741,
1.093924284,
0.4128870964,
0.6530957222,
0.0959101394,
0.6144484878,
0.3553053439,
0.4830244184,
-0.5481743813,
0.7873072028,
-0.2154784501,
0.4151118398,
-0.0578065105,
-0.5439064503,
-0.3434817791,
0.4118014276,
-0.1813666672,
-0.3534545004,
0.6009901762,
0.958791554,
0.1110610068,
0.2807568014,
0.4484709799,
0.303617239,
0.7346524596,
0.3499574959,
0.8484995961,
-0.7567665577,
0.7214990854,
-0.1371079832,
0.1161783561,
-0.0786059201,
-0.8597839475,
-1.1396052837,
-0.3301953971,
-0.5460415483,
-0.6577607393,
0.1176285297,
0.4619749188,
0.5103085041,
-0.9460347891,
-0.0244359914,
-0.0273232944,
0.0727986097,
-0.1301879138,
-0.2421226203,
0.2444557995,
-0.3597660959,
-0.7148139477,
0.6882492304,
0.0998362303,
0.1611229479,
-0.5441747308,
0.0548381731,
-0.115815945,
0.4408217669,
0.444754988,
0.0125881499,
-0.9737222195,
-0.2540321052,
-0.0389998257,
-0.1350945085,
-0.0954681188,
0.716055572,
-0.3728124797,
0.4735175371,
0.2625368237,
0.97207582,
0.1841278076,
-0.1464594454,
0.7669615149,
-0.776312232,
0.1970002204,
0.3337843716,
0.4948474467,
0.5400770307,
-0.5548046231,
0.347458154,
-0.060850855,
-0.5171374083,
-0.9542979002,
0.4926106632,
-0.6488823891,
-0.3454898894,
1.1332563162,
-0.2698142529,
-0.1494060159,
-0.1464616954,
-0.233830303,
0.1322851926,
-0.1074815691,
0.8615272045,
0.7482529879,
0.1734261215,
0.0311407782,
-0.4864218235,
0.7753504515,
0.4616011977,
-0.7439626455,
0.2645329535,
-0.0114334347,
-0.0994769186,
0.391048938,
-0.0948983431,
-0.0795796663,
-0.1027425453,
0.1103182584,
-0.3284662366,
-0.0935926363,
-0.0669344068,
-0.2837789953,
0.2399621755,
0.0149102258,
-0.2801862061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00273v1
|
Social Life Simulation for Non-Cognitive Skills Learning
| 2024-05-01T01:45:50 | 2024-05-01T01:45:50 |
Zihan Yan, Yaohong Xiang, Yun Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Non-cognitive skills are crucial for personal and social life well-being, and
such skill development can be supported by narrative-based (e.g., storytelling)
technologies. While generative AI enables interactive and role-playing
storytelling, little is known about how users engage with and perceive the use
of AI in social life simulation for non-cognitive skills learning. To this end,
we introduced SimuLife++, an interactive platform enabled by a large language
model (LLM). The system allows users to act as protagonists, creating stories
with one or multiple AI-based characters in diverse social scenarios. In
particular, we expanded the Human-AI interaction to a Human-AI-AI collaboration
by including a sage agent, who acts as a bystander to provide users with more
insightful perspectives on their choices and conversations. Through a
within-subject user study, we found that the inclusion of the sage agent
significantly enhanced narrative immersion, according to the narrative
transportation scale, leading to more messages, particularly in group chats.
Participants' interactions with the sage agent were also associated with
significantly higher scores in their perceived motivation, self-perceptions,
and resilience and coping, indicating positive impacts on non-cognitive skills
reflection. Participants' interview results further explained the sage agent's
aid in decision-making, solving ethical dilemmas, and problem-solving; on the
other hand, they suggested improvements in user control and balanced responses
from multiple characters. We provide design implications on the application of
generative AI in narrative solutions for non-cognitive skill development in
broader social contexts.
|
[
-0.2738298178,
-0.8862509131,
0.5905119181,
0.3455609083,
-0.0522374064,
0.4126348197,
-0.1266667396,
-0.6333293319,
0.7063344717,
0.0814417079,
-0.6377535462,
-0.3588935733,
-0.3032404184,
-0.1516388357,
-0.0159047842,
0.9837619662,
0.2872412801,
0.267539829,
-0.5002685785,
-0.0573173016,
-0.6678692698,
-0.4818281829,
-1.077675581,
-0.7063233256,
0.7858877182,
0.5128931403,
0.9225264192,
0.1337723285,
-0.0837004781,
0.2780537009,
0.2010073513,
0.2589083016,
-0.6313546896,
0.0557422414,
-0.1435383558,
-0.6152179241,
-0.4788030386,
-0.0039983671,
0.4570988417,
0.5855464339,
-0.2237833142,
0.2047741115,
0.1843224615,
0.3575735986,
-0.391844511,
0.4339669049,
0.0474361256,
0.1488927603,
0.0328823961,
-0.0861615017,
-0.2747892737,
-0.2770408392,
-0.0503328033,
-1.2792087793,
0.057205338,
0.0762387738,
0.5589692593,
0.3117155433,
-0.3563674092,
-0.1870857775,
-0.7773842812,
0.789657414,
-0.3413440883,
0.0374193005,
0.4197173119,
0.3716351688,
-0.3108541667,
-0.2177365422,
-0.5980825424,
-0.4339969456,
0.0207105558,
0.4350067675,
0.2681461573,
0.1217503995,
0.3031876981,
-0.1000055969,
-0.4815631211,
0.1069572419,
-0.3193188608,
-0.2596656978,
1.0316140652,
0.5253215432,
0.4389326274,
-0.0685647354,
-0.1560648531,
-0.3682784736,
-0.4336983562,
0.3991779685,
0.3725282252,
0.1461471617,
-0.3743874133,
0.5975334644,
-0.0874195099,
0.1092393026,
-0.2715986669,
-0.5160315037,
0.3414127827,
0.1363492459,
0.0902515426,
0.2744480968,
0.5334622264,
0.5884370804,
0.7303432822,
-0.2359218746,
0.0934260935,
0.2879818976,
0.4075123966,
-0.6373500228,
0.1640143692,
-0.0426371135,
-0.4851838052,
-0.3101828694,
-0.1283826828,
-1.0171489716,
-0.8301565647,
-0.2598237097,
0.2326341569,
-0.6734481454,
-0.3507527709,
0.0216763727,
-0.4237215519,
0.5264122486,
0.5983377099,
-0.6307607293,
0.3472415209,
0.5020372868,
0.7962141633,
-0.0158050116,
-0.6639435291,
-0.5875780582,
0.297227174,
-0.2855684757,
0.8080649376,
-0.8182258606,
-0.8379167318,
-0.086245805,
-0.2445019335,
-0.1116057113,
-0.2929777801,
0.445121944,
-0.3045308888,
-0.2037564814,
-0.4082967937,
-0.3993408084,
-0.1282901019,
0.2903159261,
-0.5421509147,
0.8082210422,
0.1293748021,
-0.3661194444,
0.2899431586,
-1.0792779922,
-0.7759314179,
0.5347625017,
-0.336800456,
-0.1698747277,
0.0600446761,
-0.0141213732,
0.1736016572,
-0.3003016412,
0.3165603578,
-0.3939934075,
-0.6909764409,
0.4124583304,
-0.564669311,
0.6406177282,
0.0563697182,
-0.3197138906,
0.025409935,
-0.3958732486,
0.0167418905,
0.3515803814,
-0.1285504401,
-0.0798460096,
-0.0246280488,
0.0903543383,
0.0191500802,
-0.0055620736,
-0.5198110938,
-0.0149978753,
0.012267556,
0.1876181662,
0.4534113705,
0.3168528676,
0.3129350245,
-1.0374745131,
0.9073415995,
-0.1643665731,
0.2564265728,
-0.1629977822,
-0.8136644959,
-0.7276675105,
-0.1672137231,
-0.0269925576,
0.7559565902,
-1.3041472435,
-0.0367820673,
-0.1669266969,
-0.6472165585,
-0.5260047317,
0.0153206363,
0.4867470562,
0.3375405073,
0.32493788,
-0.209277764,
-0.0947968289,
-0.3795457184,
-0.4217325747,
-0.6117379665,
0.0668582916,
0.5355885029,
0.3936500847,
-0.3139077723,
0.9319041967,
-0.4149004817,
-0.4069874287,
-0.5444514155,
0.49632743,
-0.4713352025,
0.3897582889,
0.5188654065,
-0.775590539,
-0.4397984445,
-0.0741845667,
-1.1157369614,
0.0253006853,
-0.5649347305,
-0.0177406054,
0.1163997799,
0.1989746094,
-0.7540311813,
0.8132508993,
0.0882605612,
-0.2053702623,
0.4350507855,
-0.5269559026,
0.3046891391,
-0.828549087,
-0.0351814404,
0.140084371,
-0.1930264831,
-0.6926517487,
-0.1870690733,
-0.1764269471,
-0.3656426668,
-0.5959096551,
0.800734818,
-0.3050507903,
-0.2673096955,
-0.1630547345,
0.1693280339,
-0.0458952263,
0.5776153207,
0.1713195592,
1.1666653156,
0.4544757307,
-0.4653343856,
0.2368171513,
0.307612896,
-0.2439853996,
0.7048766017,
-0.593016386,
0.1345685273,
-0.4739986956,
0.272816509,
-0.6004974246,
-0.2567339242,
0.1588995904,
-0.6170500517,
-0.0945016891,
0.3240512609,
-0.7724872231,
0.0874037221,
-0.405100137,
0.133735165,
0.618703723,
-0.0897237584,
0.9434531331,
0.570641458,
-0.1753904372,
-0.1050516292,
-0.8286434412,
0.2629876435,
-0.2900923193,
-0.6844162941,
0.2272819579,
-0.2440380603,
-0.4252684712,
-0.0889740363,
0.4729169011,
0.1151892245,
0.3000503778,
0.4520920217,
0.3522433341,
-0.0331324786,
0.166306451,
0.4190900326,
-0.4465247095,
-0.0379795916,
0.2208773941,
0.3333308101,
-0.1816657186,
-0.4617371559,
-0.4118990302,
0.3846300244,
0.5957514644,
-0.1798143536,
1.0392664671,
0.3368547559,
-0.2312976271,
0.0982038081,
-0.4823938012,
-0.1089540869,
-0.4149119854,
-0.0746095255,
0.0446776897,
-0.9824072719,
0.6318734884,
-0.2241617888,
-0.0999665931,
-0.0064322716,
0.3333301544,
-0.3946583569,
0.6225585938,
0.519400239,
-0.0348114483,
0.6260174513,
-0.0256030224,
0.1062425673,
-0.7395305037,
-0.3757826388,
0.2052633762,
-0.5219629407,
-0.2397188097,
-0.6304238439,
0.5640518665,
-0.2479006499,
-0.1555843055,
-0.1148701161,
-0.1305987239,
0.5111734271,
0.4456217587,
0.0431804582,
0.4462001026,
-0.2319216579,
-0.0046691131,
-0.0513166711,
-0.5416929126,
-0.6771438122,
0.7494386435,
0.1929783374,
0.8077040911,
-0.0119802095,
0.8607605696,
0.6865648031,
0.6731607318,
-0.6090983152,
0.7911819816,
0.2617030144,
-0.7187300324,
-0.4758788645,
-0.379076004,
-0.7986354232,
0.0298880786,
-0.4727443457,
-0.6699712873,
0.1454520524,
-0.1397825927,
-0.8001914024,
0.0232447386,
-1.0355119705,
0.6617975235,
-0.4726511538,
-0.5140695572,
-0.3591175377,
-0.8275401592,
-0.1360109448,
-0.0717994422,
0.3690458238,
-0.1104897708,
0.0050755609,
0.2204370648,
-0.0157347471,
1.3328142166,
-0.2701583803,
0.2330574095,
0.6152027249,
0.1692306101,
0.2974811792,
0.3487543762,
-0.301923871,
0.256824255,
-0.0832366124,
-0.2908636332,
-0.6101731062,
0.6334895492,
-1.1639535427,
-0.6765321493,
-0.4857890606,
-0.526421845,
-0.1312102973,
-0.0098965922,
-0.0913134515,
-0.0099773519,
-0.7133527398,
0.1170848012,
0.5703511834,
-0.4485090673,
0.4580578506,
0.6416879296,
-0.165686518,
-0.4113619626,
1.0607067347,
0.4586664736,
0.253076762,
0.0847257003,
0.0552518889,
0.0253033433,
0.0306633264,
-0.4270839691,
0.3007682562,
-0.5365302563,
-0.0840800852,
-0.7130692005,
-0.4042020738,
-0.2120884061,
-0.4884440601,
-0.011644097,
-0.2158321887,
-0.4663051367,
-0.3876931965,
0.444326967,
0.6132021546,
-0.2126708478,
0.4633317292,
-0.754984796,
0.2871003151,
0.3452123106,
0.0829569399,
0.3244531453,
0.00886722,
-0.2320494205,
0.2240772992,
-0.472163707,
-0.7348464727,
0.2487095445,
0.1610282958,
0.6184206009,
0.3854727149,
0.2382492125,
0.8722543716,
-0.3892119527,
0.9240910411,
-0.0526656508,
-0.7323459387,
0.2478908151,
-0.4672127366,
0.1205578744,
0.7895826101,
0.1602997482,
-0.816845715,
-0.3606012464,
-0.5929806828,
-0.414655745,
0.8009960055,
0.5369474292,
0.5071999431,
-0.1006062627,
0.656332314,
0.0998199433,
0.2367327362,
-0.7282239795,
-0.3591549098,
-0.4398943782,
0.0475365892,
-0.2481095493,
-0.2618222237,
0.0633152723,
-0.2085757107,
0.6790065169,
-0.219933942,
0.4196530282,
0.0741720945,
0.1161211729,
-0.2640306056,
0.0543253049,
0.4967004359,
0.3155469298,
0.2584123015,
-0.1877744943,
0.5788243413,
-0.3754278421,
0.1058242768,
0.0489651784,
0.0350359604,
-0.5105063915,
0.4472816586,
0.5507724285,
0.2893050015,
-0.9583106637,
0.492261976,
-0.3953553736,
-0.2557835281,
-0.6318237185,
0.588459909,
0.3965452611,
0.6646459103,
0.255648613,
-0.1385003924,
0.1237413138,
-0.5825092793,
0.074455142,
0.3242810667,
-0.339648962,
-0.1623096317,
0.5829722881,
0.3102707863,
-0.8439900875,
0.6211031079,
-0.492795527,
-0.207335338,
0.8381658196,
0.4582038522,
0.7951455116,
-0.1021045074,
0.8629076481,
-0.1663200855,
0.3232521415,
-0.0324829519,
0.3339504302,
-0.2251521945,
-0.8350504637,
-0.2523376346,
-0.2554941177,
-0.6565358639,
-0.1641035527,
-0.5005751252,
0.2660194933,
-0.4750722349,
-0.1576748937,
-0.1766601503,
0.0026488781,
-0.4364593625,
0.0798145905,
0.2482222766,
0.6113142371,
-0.9795156121,
0.933758378,
0.904746294,
-0.6850780845,
-0.6311388612,
0.5197210312,
-0.0861890092,
-0.6514869332,
0.310973078,
0.285998404,
-0.3436254859,
0.0787458718,
-0.4857149124,
-0.6360086799,
1.6196825504,
0.7944011092,
-0.0299657788,
-0.1104336232,
0.4360997379,
0.9859173298,
-0.4675600529,
0.3434405923,
0.1054079011,
0.4157827795,
0.4510737956,
-0.6331316233,
-0.1743590385,
-0.3431532979,
0.2083768249,
-0.1807400882,
-1.2824428082,
0.5728788376,
-0.1969132423,
-0.2570053041,
0.1853333861,
0.8124683499,
0.4702073634,
0.7451252937,
0.384190321,
0.2190498561,
0.8929881454,
0.3769626617,
1.0834033489,
-0.2613395751,
0.1542888135,
0.9368038177,
-0.7459604144,
0.3710088432,
0.3386204243,
0.3208061457,
0.7950119376,
0.4304591417,
0.3849864006,
0.3901047707,
0.0028088677,
-0.5454584956,
-0.5696921349,
-0.5108633041,
-0.1873333603,
0.2017620206,
0.3619662523,
0.0088699833,
-0.2747813165,
0.3319138587,
0.0730004907,
0.1551781595,
-0.1218972653,
0.8456285,
0.279404521,
-0.6865097284,
-0.1221756712,
0.0120076397,
0.1856528968,
-0.5969548821,
-0.3078651726,
-0.1236344278,
0.0774049684,
0.0067297313,
-0.8006477356,
0.3490543664,
0.0455255322,
0.029807331,
-0.4454459548,
0.8518591523,
-0.1336409003,
-0.6078981161,
0.682141006,
0.7119215727,
0.1262941211,
0.1407515854,
-0.6272234321,
-0.1194838062,
-0.3352117836,
-0.0811465085,
0.5148997903,
0.7546882629,
-0.42238006,
0.8531318307,
0.7899778485,
-0.3261095583,
-0.2904955447,
0.0817800313,
1.1326118708,
-0.7234426737,
-0.7163057923,
-0.7299176455,
0.5646013021,
-0.1634730995,
-0.3436969221,
0.5820723772,
0.4744095206,
0.4682736397,
0.2052900791,
0.8563817143,
0.0593113564,
0.053812813,
-0.2009251416,
0.8306059837,
-0.5258319974,
0.1536336243,
-0.2298041433,
-0.7069593072,
-0.196530655,
0.7054654956,
-0.5144042373,
0.2986274064,
0.5132467747,
0.6490945816,
0.3533524871,
0.4362646043,
0.6693726778,
-0.3638081849,
0.4780164361,
0.4494604468,
1.1671841145,
0.0334899314,
0.1273217499,
0.1697737724,
-0.387858361,
-0.067528069,
-0.7228190303,
-1.4390772581,
-0.3312155604,
-0.0434364937,
-0.0611624755,
0.3106141686,
1.1648881435,
0.3326818645,
-0.196990788,
-0.44988662,
-0.0448911749,
0.1320894361,
-0.2294135094,
-0.239451319,
-0.2929981053,
-0.2549919486,
-0.3068739772,
0.4354931414,
0.3902093172,
0.0850573704,
-0.4135701358,
-0.4488902688,
-0.1341944039,
0.464733094,
0.4969861507,
0.3114296794,
-0.2335243523,
-0.3166674078,
0.0018957159,
0.0057848459,
0.0601236634,
0.7534998059,
-0.9823482633,
0.2499548644,
-0.0296160839,
0.7501626611,
0.6804614663,
0.0992011577,
0.4247064888,
-0.4531166852,
0.2453301102,
0.0344629623,
0.0715811849,
0.2005436718,
-0.9884086847,
0.4303857386,
0.25994277,
-0.3246086836,
-0.3607247472,
0.1368497908,
-0.5688718557,
-0.0896202922,
1.2863893509,
-0.2227557153,
-0.3375385106,
-0.2847352922,
-0.5235205293,
0.1499358863,
-0.8716801405,
0.7832764387,
0.8497584462,
-0.4415250421,
-0.2926406264,
-0.6781333685,
0.2022897899,
0.3968820274,
-1.0950175524,
-0.1172273383,
0.4019145668,
-0.0120987166,
0.2930530906,
0.850220263,
0.1142507941,
0.31553936,
-0.0674303249,
0.0831980929,
-0.3020609915,
-0.4715679288,
-0.1265857518,
0.0002305652,
0.0039862129,
0.1164098829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00263v1
|
Clover: Regressive Lightweight Speculative Decoding with Sequential Knowledge
| 2024-05-01T00:46:22 | 2024-05-01T00:46:22 |
Bin Xiao, Chunan Shi, Xiaonan Nie, Fan Yang, Xiangwei Deng, Lei Su, Weipeng Chen, Bin Cui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) suffer from low efficiency as the mismatch
between the requirement of auto-regressive decoding and the design of most
contemporary GPUs. Specifically, billions to trillions of parameters must be
loaded to the GPU cache through its limited memory bandwidth for computation,
but only a small batch of tokens is actually computed. Consequently, the GPU
spends most of its time on memory transfer instead of computation. Recently,
parallel decoding, a type of speculative decoding algorithms, is becoming more
popular and has demonstrated impressive efficiency improvement in generation.
It introduces extra decoding heads to large models, enabling them to predict
multiple subsequent tokens simultaneously and verify these candidate
continuations in a single decoding step. However, this approach deviates from
the training objective of next token prediction used during pre-training,
resulting in a low hit rate for candidate tokens. In this paper, we propose a
new speculative decoding algorithm, Clover, which integrates sequential
knowledge into the parallel decoding process. This enhancement improves the hit
rate of speculators and thus boosts the overall efficiency. Clover transmits
the sequential knowledge from pre-speculated tokens via the Regressive
Connection, then employs an Attention Decoder to integrate these speculated
tokens. Additionally, Clover incorporates an Augmenting Block that modifies the
hidden states to better align with the purpose of speculative generation rather
than next token prediction. The experiment results demonstrate that Clover
outperforms the baseline by up to 91% on Baichuan-Small and 146% on
Baichuan-Large, respectively, and exceeds the performance of the previously
top-performing method, Medusa, by up to 37% on Baichuan-Small and 57% on
Baichuan-Large, respectively.
|
[
0.0617798157,
-0.5544610023,
0.7690761089,
0.5953236818,
-0.3528905511,
0.5310459733,
-0.1235651225,
-0.407497704,
0.608504653,
0.3357672393,
-0.7873800993,
-0.7176009417,
-0.7077271938,
0.2556605935,
-0.2644813061,
0.7459921241,
-0.0710953921,
-0.0551378243,
0.1296963096,
0.238891989,
-0.4196327329,
-0.5040704012,
-0.6066914201,
0.0258345902,
0.7820923924,
0.5178465843,
0.5651622415,
1.0336295366,
0.5592657328,
0.2924927473,
-0.0977474675,
0.3199909627,
-0.8768327832,
-0.2262273133,
0.0125578223,
-0.8926645517,
-0.2635984123,
-0.4175851941,
0.8385019302,
0.5876727104,
0.0438687876,
0.3661914766,
-0.1606643051,
0.414518714,
-0.8229438663,
0.2399137616,
-0.8614609241,
0.065662168,
-0.6222720742,
-0.5219064951,
-0.7761304379,
-0.2828078568,
-0.3722412288,
-0.8427837491,
0.3154854774,
0.5679591894,
0.6741880178,
0.2237645239,
0.0168973338,
0.1313089877,
-0.5631232858,
0.9263984561,
-0.7774628997,
0.2842233777,
0.2868424952,
-0.0339161009,
-0.3057816029,
-0.7825657725,
-0.6277171373,
0.1693192571,
0.0048355376,
0.0790004358,
0.0456028022,
-0.0034368713,
0.3590355814,
0.4427160919,
-0.5377127528,
0.2659361362,
-0.2316114753,
-0.4004434049,
0.2172272056,
0.6501647234,
0.0030640347,
-0.0845967233,
-0.5133806467,
-0.0977826342,
-0.560762763,
0.0904655084,
0.4768725932,
0.2136929631,
0.0295966696,
0.2046500444,
-0.343054682,
0.565125525,
0.2661506236,
-0.2601524889,
0.3071938157,
-0.3433077037,
-0.0275083426,
-0.100001879,
0.7859193683,
0.2190608978,
-0.3560209572,
-0.3169203103,
-0.0694357827,
0.5654942989,
-0.1800639033,
-0.7475939393,
-0.4531759024,
0.2763017416,
-0.5742449164,
-0.089183718,
-0.0721717477,
-0.8177656531,
-0.1265007406,
-0.0757468715,
0.0953684747,
-0.5773448944,
-0.2942612171,
0.6050068736,
-0.3827327788,
0.1794586778,
0.2130445242,
-1.2685960531,
0.5617964864,
0.8630307913,
0.8710050583,
-0.1756518334,
-0.3538806438,
-0.8691011071,
0.2561730146,
-0.4451879859,
0.8062999249,
-0.6175581813,
-0.2387748361,
-0.2603749633,
-0.0042815735,
-0.1417113543,
-0.2420375943,
0.4969341755,
-0.7939462662,
-0.5856280923,
-0.6542167068,
-0.3816415071,
-0.1601428092,
-0.1973372549,
-0.6313233376,
0.4818845987,
-0.1705771089,
-1.1639106274,
0.6252750158,
-0.2364941984,
-0.4894719124,
0.1454633921,
-0.1846268475,
-0.1090629399,
0.0268141292,
0.2727068067,
0.3880130947,
-0.1879166961,
-0.0245434716,
-0.7456206679,
-0.6735252142,
0.0907222927,
-0.3386902511,
0.4985232651,
0.2769909501,
-0.2634466887,
0.2089556307,
-0.7804871202,
0.0142722037,
0.0392072536,
0.1978299916,
-0.4445664287,
-0.090652138,
0.0014896457,
-0.2761187851,
0.3769242764,
-0.6792176962,
0.0129199326,
-0.2472768575,
0.3716349602,
0.9639745951,
-0.0942921862,
0.2175264359,
-0.2907861769,
0.2620499134,
0.1356887668,
0.2231600732,
-0.582662642,
-0.4597696066,
-0.8846328259,
-0.5053710341,
0.3445757329,
0.650609076,
-0.7235346437,
0.2147164047,
-0.2141196281,
-0.2632811069,
-0.708453238,
0.4539147019,
0.3776233792,
0.2857633829,
0.1788573116,
-0.2296719402,
-0.6452999711,
-0.6050719619,
-0.3932694793,
-0.1549766213,
0.4533682466,
-0.0393702239,
0.1390675902,
-0.5577049851,
0.7086725831,
-0.8778118491,
0.0287187975,
-0.0288164504,
0.4332362413,
0.5137614012,
0.6679840684,
0.2993587255,
-0.5934053063,
-0.3419860005,
0.0808385983,
-0.8209068775,
0.3445902169,
-0.0609775782,
-0.3762761652,
-0.0139475865,
0.1717083752,
-0.7368301749,
0.3492481112,
0.431093812,
-0.2120182365,
0.6108145714,
-0.3372967541,
0.1736111939,
-0.8035206199,
0.0464319773,
-0.258887887,
-0.2396661192,
-0.2788797021,
0.2006057501,
0.2389561534,
0.1808642745,
-0.0376711115,
0.2234369814,
-0.5207063556,
-0.0184589904,
-0.2718381584,
-0.2677457929,
-0.1180221513,
0.3732449412,
0.2640656233,
0.9496193528,
0.465428412,
-0.4732795358,
0.3692195714,
-0.0212728493,
-0.257741034,
-0.2172320187,
-0.3944888413,
0.2955527306,
-0.1628728211,
0.2152429372,
-1.0006899834,
-0.2292884588,
0.0853670761,
-0.4085615575,
0.1395809799,
0.1832535565,
-0.945962429,
-0.5863237977,
-0.1942381263,
0.836194098,
0.8173379898,
-0.712556541,
0.3073838949,
0.1025289968,
-0.1444844007,
-0.7007667422,
-0.7145611644,
0.0648586601,
-0.2441074848,
-0.6977390051,
0.002482909,
-0.2590609491,
-0.1497595757,
0.0728453994,
0.0854063854,
0.1191547811,
-0.2201881856,
0.0637836382,
0.3517262638,
-0.2938627899,
-0.2092792839,
0.0972704738,
-0.5011762977,
0.0070907981,
-0.9082564712,
0.5060762167,
0.0220895056,
-0.2367169559,
-0.6854468584,
0.4372400641,
0.4416030943,
-0.2056528926,
0.7933995724,
0.8581492305,
-0.2189001143,
-0.4106098413,
-0.7078588009,
-0.2166076303,
-0.5129945278,
0.1408126354,
-0.5724179149,
-0.8534111381,
0.9459704757,
-0.25711748,
0.1049762964,
0.384269774,
0.3285090327,
0.29771173,
0.8768603206,
0.915492177,
-0.3148872554,
0.2473690659,
-0.3822538257,
0.0788112655,
-0.5544558167,
-0.1715886593,
-0.0882076621,
-0.133738488,
-0.1417694241,
-0.6452114582,
-0.1852134466,
0.0215259194,
-0.0624670275,
0.4200534225,
-0.1942477524,
0.1942853779,
0.5123471618,
0.338273555,
0.5846945643,
0.0080704028,
-0.286907196,
-0.1836314201,
-0.8573531508,
0.0255549233,
1.2295534611,
0.5008828044,
1.1664303541,
-0.1892823279,
0.8713396192,
0.3058961034,
0.1653909683,
-0.4844406247,
0.4318928123,
-0.3001300693,
-0.2224639803,
-0.1230122074,
-0.6727541685,
-0.5028817654,
0.0755450055,
-0.0059480048,
-0.6661757231,
0.4159276187,
0.1772775948,
-0.8791396022,
0.5213978887,
-0.8063732386,
0.4800652266,
-0.0404749289,
-0.6054133773,
-0.3176768422,
-0.4530335665,
0.8921390772,
-0.3292705119,
0.2905918658,
0.1008693203,
-0.0422606543,
0.7541053295,
-0.5167269111,
0.9096795321,
0.0213187467,
-0.2097488642,
-0.0153152831,
-0.1349039078,
0.7830830216,
0.3681862354,
-0.0508235916,
0.180828467,
0.0720798522,
-0.5355160236,
-0.5272882581,
0.7678878903,
-0.7788677216,
-0.6223398447,
-0.388310492,
-0.6853542328,
-0.1945658475,
0.3255036473,
0.5829498172,
0.4503156543,
0.3551307619,
-0.1736798584,
1.0719003677,
0.0175796691,
0.0441826656,
0.3951582015,
-0.3206160665,
-0.6434713006,
1.2085716724,
-0.0277001075,
0.3037027717,
0.6565151811,
-0.2113443315,
-0.0816967115,
-0.582015872,
-0.1900685281,
0.385582,
-0.6275841594,
-0.2845258117,
-0.7931715846,
-0.0900071189,
-0.4866576791,
-0.0307648052,
-0.2977510691,
-0.0656374842,
-0.4231851399,
-0.138286531,
0.5450788736,
0.6096526384,
-0.199938938,
0.5730655193,
-0.7473888397,
0.5821767449,
0.0757411197,
0.4446965754,
0.140004307,
-0.2802226841,
-0.3692283034,
-0.1133852676,
0.2378482372,
-0.5260719657,
0.3338178396,
-0.3977633417,
0.3474300802,
0.8910412788,
0.3400428891,
1.1928168535,
-0.7113686204,
0.2985306978,
0.5091179013,
-0.7388905287,
0.1811228096,
-0.3328098059,
0.1964865476,
0.5351293087,
0.164468959,
-0.0884387121,
-0.4897808731,
-0.4004454315,
-0.6828143001,
0.7781673074,
0.0023554098,
-0.279620707,
-0.0116733601,
0.3162742555,
0.5483490229,
0.014934591,
-0.2476673722,
-0.2247141749,
0.1179336756,
-0.2927528322,
-0.4228903353,
-0.5458117723,
-0.0622274652,
-0.1832610071,
0.2710806429,
0.0296685565,
0.3966028392,
0.0394237004,
0.1690576524,
-0.3174998462,
-0.1131270453,
0.260102421,
0.5264830589,
-0.4324284494,
0.025052825,
0.1324758083,
-0.6643771529,
0.0020518082,
0.2669818401,
-0.2489329129,
0.1434244514,
0.29952842,
0.96095258,
0.5320855379,
-0.4503788948,
0.1041672975,
-0.2746804953,
-0.1405702382,
-0.3932646215,
-0.0569021627,
-0.285823673,
0.3492073417,
0.513127923,
0.3711484969,
0.4077073932,
-0.4195125997,
0.2820211053,
0.3301151693,
0.2095754147,
-0.3891979456,
0.7829862833,
0.0870437026,
0.1330468655,
0.2686081827,
-0.1591325849,
-0.3813287616,
0.4460666478,
0.8391563296,
0.9295508862,
0.145540148,
-0.0412456021,
0.2978988886,
0.2584072351,
-0.3842435479,
0.4906515181,
-0.2568404675,
-0.458165884,
-0.6884953976,
-0.8044220209,
-0.2197514623,
-0.1223988906,
-0.6438618898,
0.1224559173,
-0.8182774186,
-0.4154222608,
-0.309506923,
0.1466567218,
-0.6977574229,
-0.1062620357,
0.0269304998,
1.2939083576,
-0.6593523622,
0.8474640846,
0.3222151101,
-0.2196073532,
-0.8657146096,
0.2780322433,
-0.173458606,
-0.7793466449,
0.8411516547,
0.2399398535,
-0.3346137702,
0.3166451454,
-0.335011363,
-1.080245018,
1.1238538027,
0.4133198559,
-0.7497651577,
-0.2608126998,
-0.1841919571,
-0.0005525149,
-0.2528770566,
0.2417916656,
0.3667280674,
0.3141375184,
0.4018186629,
-0.6952460408,
0.166782409,
-0.2394106388,
0.1405508369,
0.0370311625,
-1.0079464912,
1.2130393982,
-0.5503274798,
-0.466850698,
0.6652683616,
1.1837172508,
0.4005282521,
0.3532272279,
0.3323030174,
0.6692789793,
0.933986485,
0.1053526998,
0.8951144218,
-0.5626404881,
0.0940856189,
0.5817914605,
-0.2837986946,
1.1011601686,
0.3736720681,
-0.3084070981,
0.76553756,
0.7178806067,
0.3238388002,
0.6627146006,
0.0339586288,
-0.3043573797,
-0.5922464728,
0.3475367129,
-0.5010628104,
-0.095538713,
0.6043605208,
-0.0854377225,
0.0886768922,
0.1004269868,
-0.1137485355,
0.0474253558,
-0.4327264428,
0.5613132715,
0.2235259414,
-0.4773835242,
0.6140514016,
0.094648242,
1.0129696131,
-1.0052269697,
0.0119468737,
-0.1958913505,
0.6783768535,
-0.2984084785,
-0.4735255539,
-0.0534136631,
-0.1700284481,
-0.5354266167,
0.171201244,
0.6179023385,
-0.302238524,
-0.602581501,
0.4263796508,
-0.1515707225,
0.0085041365,
0.2928897142,
-0.1360350549,
0.7346188426,
-0.2108085752,
0.4703202546,
0.2139642686,
0.6696872115,
0.2542182505,
0.6514605284,
1.0669295788,
0.3372233212,
0.3005198538,
-0.2640461028,
1.0948395729,
-0.8556697965,
-1.0859789848,
-0.640145123,
0.2388754785,
-0.0052251592,
0.1311272979,
1.2195945978,
0.5713431835,
0.5905434489,
-0.1618743986,
0.8153876066,
0.3661881387,
0.5452235937,
-0.8510519862,
0.4044572711,
-0.1718271822,
0.4100219011,
-0.4214389324,
-0.5545684099,
-0.0819082856,
0.207364127,
-0.4535278976,
-0.2550582588,
0.719972074,
0.5754739046,
0.0900819376,
0.3393318355,
0.2645870149,
0.2644341886,
-0.0552143827,
0.9249992371,
0.749920249,
-0.3009620309,
0.355948776,
-0.053371951,
-0.7136566043,
-0.1820675433,
-0.5300154686,
-0.8893482685,
-0.273035109,
0.0074297828,
-0.1587358117,
0.3637955487,
0.4920217693,
0.7163652778,
-0.7058805823,
-0.3682917655,
-0.2254063338,
0.0326932706,
-0.4023942351,
-0.2178499997,
0.2632984221,
-0.8219339252,
-0.5235226154,
0.1916323453,
0.3162097335,
-0.4265591502,
-0.3212991953,
-0.2629217207,
0.030617578,
-0.0205383096,
0.545375526,
0.5352069139,
-0.723970294,
0.1086146683,
0.1436724663,
0.1175448373,
-0.3282757401,
0.915350616,
-1.1049206257,
0.2828226686,
0.4627828598,
0.8767459393,
0.4815917909,
0.0741697028,
0.6506806016,
-0.1248593181,
0.454651624,
-0.1132587269,
0.3248716593,
0.1333318949,
-0.7642997503,
-0.2149101049,
0.8056477904,
-0.3053575456,
-0.7665060163,
0.0437050164,
-0.8859683871,
-0.1303121895,
1.2935317755,
-0.3161179125,
-0.6948453188,
-0.0283797625,
-0.0631922111,
0.0098183174,
-0.5577914715,
0.4278999865,
0.3855701387,
0.1420573443,
-0.21178931,
-0.327370435,
0.4518424571,
0.3311060369,
-0.3509560823,
0.231398806,
0.3115840256,
0.2659705877,
0.2989236116,
0.87950629,
-0.0451485887,
0.288769424,
0.6221503615,
-0.315536797,
0.0798766389,
-0.5073953271,
0.0033903352,
0.0956484303,
0.1174555942,
-0.4383698702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00253v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00253v2
|
CodeHalu: Code Hallucinations in LLMs Driven by Execution-based Verification
| 2024-04-30T23:56:38 | 2024-06-26T20:28:36 |
Yuchen Tian, Weixiang Yan, Qian Yang, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Ziyang Luo, Lei Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant progress in code
generation, providing developers with unprecedented automated programming
support. However, LLMs often generate code that is syntactically correct and
even semantically plausible but may not execute as expected or meet specified
requirements. This phenomenon of hallucinations in the code domain has not been
systematically explored. To enhance the community's understanding and research
on this issue, we introduce the concept of code hallucinations and propose a
classification method for code hallucination based on execution verification.
We classify code hallucinations into four main types: mapping, naming,
resource, and logic hallucinations, with each category further divided into
different subcategories to understand and address the unique challenges faced
by LLMs in code generation with finer granularity. Additionally, we develop a
dynamic detection algorithm named CodeHalu to quantify code hallucinations and
establish the CodeHaluEval benchmark, which includes 8,883 samples from 699
tasks to systematically and quantitatively evaluate code hallucinations. By
evaluating 17 popular LLMs on this benchmark, we reveal significant differences
in their accuracy and reliability in code generation and provide detailed
insights for further improving the code generation capabilities of LLMs. The
CodeHalu benchmark and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/yuchen814/CodeHalu.
|
[
-0.1489176154,
-0.9802486897,
0.4474545419,
0.4229379892,
-0.1012016684,
0.2922756076,
-0.3865844011,
-0.6200705171,
0.2893744707,
0.7489353418,
-0.2997417748,
-0.736168623,
-0.4488352537,
0.3522101343,
-0.7625304461,
0.6989614964,
-0.1659729183,
-0.0672057942,
-0.318944037,
0.0925496519,
-0.8284772038,
-0.7027608752,
-0.0863467306,
-0.2432213873,
0.1671817601,
0.2321889251,
0.6075336337,
0.5132450461,
0.5208232403,
0.2913013697,
0.1569182128,
0.2899970114,
-0.6150850654,
0.2503050268,
0.4828794897,
-0.6094525456,
-0.3452873826,
-0.3609157205,
0.2446688861,
0.415981859,
-0.432392627,
0.0270759575,
-0.1376384795,
0.3614812195,
-0.6328146458,
0.1802129298,
-0.7826352119,
0.3617942929,
-0.1067741513,
-0.5669643283,
-0.5697805882,
-0.7024541497,
-0.3602894545,
-0.2074528933,
-0.0176102389,
0.0418873392,
0.5639448762,
0.5447592139,
-0.1860491931,
-0.7872402072,
-0.6819635034,
0.5885135531,
-0.4715042114,
0.3262729347,
0.2747779191,
0.3546327055,
-0.1759395599,
-0.6332149506,
-0.5390350223,
-0.4187822342,
-0.0503833517,
-0.2086914778,
-0.052360516,
-0.052627556,
0.576200366,
0.5342690945,
-0.8587828279,
0.1212070584,
-0.3023242056,
-0.3447314203,
0.5138791203,
0.2566539645,
0.3565451801,
-0.1858800203,
-0.2644330263,
0.2448087037,
-0.6896865368,
-0.3489575982,
0.4531317651,
-0.3037575483,
-0.0131501798,
0.3831891119,
-0.2252278179,
0.5428934693,
-0.2457347661,
-0.1056874618,
0.4263089001,
0.0554400384,
-0.1870700121,
0.3802678287,
0.3879582584,
0.2730560005,
0.3831394017,
-0.3272230327,
-0.4708971083,
0.622731328,
0.6625329852,
-0.7801693082,
-0.4126770198,
0.4286891222,
-0.5572515726,
-0.7820939422,
0.1469304413,
-0.6902025342,
-0.5898150802,
-0.1550972611,
0.2454345673,
-0.3504122794,
-0.4274652004,
0.2541759312,
0.2551141977,
0.4940121472,
0.1752441376,
-0.5316250324,
0.1601585448,
0.8075945973,
0.47343418,
-0.6132810712,
-0.4453880787,
-0.520825088,
0.0151180746,
-0.5448294878,
0.8182960153,
-0.4520744383,
-0.2688866556,
0.3849266171,
-0.0861244947,
0.1724502295,
-0.9750187397,
0.1598584801,
-0.6255417466,
-0.2325447053,
0.0616070442,
-0.4742957652,
-0.221024245,
0.2557432055,
-0.4693061411,
0.8428393602,
0.1263349652,
-0.4815357924,
0.3295502663,
-0.3215699792,
-0.5877392292,
0.4661643505,
-0.7190858722,
-0.3316742182,
0.3245907724,
-0.2043111473,
0.3941674232,
-0.0112583144,
0.5191290975,
0.0604858398,
-0.8440659642,
0.6174254417,
-0.1392926574,
0.5254201293,
0.2986779511,
-0.7547857761,
0.2847873569,
-0.9063356519,
0.0615558177,
0.2154885828,
-0.1596302986,
0.1119750366,
-0.0095888488,
-0.0273856521,
-0.2277082354,
0.130760774,
-0.0460501984,
0.253277719,
-0.1257857978,
0.2697004676,
0.7029080987,
0.0613003522,
0.0013098812,
-0.3264911771,
0.7420017123,
-0.0333444737,
0.1960481703,
-0.1245168969,
-0.386071384,
-0.8075454831,
-0.0593575872,
0.024149986,
0.6213734746,
-0.8762027025,
0.5725926161,
-0.0280378349,
-0.257879585,
-0.1353903562,
0.160421297,
0.4007279277,
0.1386267692,
0.2117736638,
-0.1481888592,
-0.6912350059,
-0.6814354658,
-0.0710255951,
-0.3074949384,
0.2628649473,
0.106278643,
0.5145429373,
-0.8874934912,
0.3738540113,
-0.5574434996,
-0.2319518775,
-0.16072537,
0.1791675091,
0.0266269147,
0.3595811427,
0.243854478,
-0.7538009286,
0.0359113961,
-0.0498448052,
-1.1829919815,
-0.4247821271,
-0.3109565079,
0.0520812981,
0.7351603508,
0.6716012359,
-0.169301331,
0.4897663295,
0.6119315028,
-0.180655539,
0.7790617943,
-0.0944008306,
0.2519296408,
-0.573513031,
0.0141763389,
-0.5824152231,
-0.0753931329,
-0.3974711001,
0.5852321386,
0.0106215151,
-0.0272944383,
-0.1112015769,
-0.1076710373,
-0.4352645874,
-0.3398937583,
-0.4428578317,
-0.0732706711,
-0.3188067377,
0.4601756334,
0.024417853,
0.5974435806,
0.6871936917,
-0.5222955346,
0.7022923827,
-0.0201118421,
-0.7486837506,
0.1473296583,
-0.3299644291,
0.3694661856,
0.2835129797,
0.1729407459,
-0.6738167405,
-0.4485183656,
0.1811684966,
-0.2419600487,
0.0801170841,
0.1333197504,
-0.9919956326,
-0.1927737892,
-0.121441856,
0.5640547872,
0.8416002393,
-0.5846310258,
0.3678739667,
0.3523769379,
0.3334313333,
-0.4565077126,
-0.8034209013,
0.1947568357,
-0.190669179,
-0.4058785141,
0.1904801726,
-0.1686039865,
-0.4168308079,
-0.1967162341,
-0.1753524989,
-0.0347625576,
0.230566889,
0.637259841,
0.1481122524,
-0.1635395885,
-0.0685485974,
0.0248946231,
-0.1493040621,
0.4772057235,
0.0346320197,
0.7348210216,
-0.2389606237,
-0.5582128167,
-0.2525168359,
0.1467895061,
0.4593485594,
0.0240519531,
0.25671646,
0.6205561757,
-0.5101732016,
-0.6663641334,
-0.7673873901,
-0.1941130161,
-0.4545410573,
0.2909494638,
-0.5022749305,
-0.749178946,
0.7107091546,
-0.0794747248,
-0.2500070035,
0.0313093774,
0.7551575899,
0.3058831394,
0.7802292109,
0.4731389284,
0.2467464954,
0.0074627004,
-0.2580190301,
0.2246686518,
-0.1916898191,
-0.4532775879,
-0.2662866116,
-0.1266748309,
-0.5938037634,
-0.533601284,
0.151848644,
0.1379377991,
0.1961918175,
0.3192545474,
-0.8925995827,
0.6116834283,
0.1333597302,
-0.0192677341,
0.382766217,
0.056753885,
-0.0253121331,
0.1632312834,
-0.4664760232,
-0.5089757442,
0.7064371705,
0.2620267272,
0.9285687208,
0.0876498893,
1.0392651558,
0.7576236129,
0.1915918291,
-0.6701219678,
0.8193904161,
0.389082402,
-0.1532955617,
0.1068315729,
-0.6427860856,
-0.736522615,
-0.0997548774,
-0.0287915748,
-0.5466099977,
0.0823192745,
-0.0425373539,
-0.2434988469,
0.0880797952,
-0.5254237056,
0.7021258473,
-0.3302304745,
0.0363978818,
-0.4370315671,
-0.2880757749,
0.6470882297,
-0.4372662902,
0.3662470877,
0.0463262014,
0.1050284952,
0.5138515234,
-0.3776164353,
0.6963767409,
-0.0892959088,
-0.6458265185,
0.3433334827,
0.5668230057,
0.4239869118,
0.1422461122,
0.1105900332,
0.4960702658,
0.0269565713,
-0.1583854407,
-0.4566897154,
1.001321435,
-0.4956757724,
-0.4328663051,
-0.4773965478,
-0.4875124097,
0.141006425,
0.1377214342,
0.4113081992,
0.4293466806,
0.1034582853,
-0.0566818044,
0.7447095513,
-0.6206207275,
0.199813351,
0.1870298386,
-0.8475583196,
-0.2471278906,
1.1039446592,
-0.0123153245,
-0.1903535277,
0.0981943011,
-0.1527560204,
0.0733398795,
-0.8704243898,
-0.1963179559,
0.0504441522,
-0.9135759473,
-0.3340952694,
-0.596691072,
-0.4393920004,
-0.1961390376,
-0.3111227751,
-0.0718876421,
-0.0528677702,
-0.0813632086,
0.0626136288,
0.2639870644,
1.0332307816,
0.1487191468,
-0.1050429046,
-0.6389949918,
0.5986093879,
0.1089818031,
0.5249847174,
-0.0495890416,
-0.3726300597,
-0.3208596706,
-0.3441244364,
-0.1154959127,
-0.8248531818,
0.1934170276,
-0.3250138462,
0.4699963331,
0.4505223036,
0.2255983502,
0.5502405167,
-0.3996177614,
0.7956044674,
0.03839745,
-1.1480534077,
0.6765369177,
-0.0081675882,
0.0768219605,
0.3341809213,
0.0128992191,
-0.2474793941,
-0.6698952913,
-0.4074393809,
-0.4701270163,
0.3034143448,
0.3954296112,
0.1445263922,
-0.1956068426,
0.4597442746,
0.3927527368,
0.0797953159,
-0.8486694694,
-0.2128428668,
-0.0083621815,
0.0252442509,
0.3560881615,
-0.3827661574,
-0.0196356457,
-0.0623914897,
0.335311383,
-0.136902526,
0.4184072614,
-0.0075458717,
-0.5597091913,
-0.240399912,
-0.0363866948,
0.9738340974,
1.0353873968,
-0.1843452901,
0.3239405155,
0.1683846861,
-0.4664613903,
0.0593852364,
-0.329284668,
0.0902937427,
0.1568275541,
0.5626190305,
0.6408942938,
0.2381017059,
-0.9893772602,
0.5856009722,
-0.1095601246,
-0.2626818717,
-0.6762889028,
0.4545869529,
-0.3622817099,
0.3179869056,
0.4163247645,
-0.0011544815,
0.2248756438,
-0.433698833,
0.3299224675,
0.1981377602,
-0.0310351793,
-0.2791438699,
0.5584125519,
0.1380589455,
-0.5291044116,
0.5825597048,
-0.4469436705,
-0.5906848907,
0.654612422,
0.4150594473,
1.1482377052,
0.0102179907,
0.0431525558,
0.0207315404,
0.2999216616,
0.0100788325,
0.5536577702,
-0.149900794,
-0.6197292209,
-0.4434838891,
-0.7687460184,
-0.4127451479,
0.1064883173,
-0.6625268459,
0.37499699,
-0.3493805826,
0.0296544656,
-0.3554757833,
-0.1243339032,
-0.1556096971,
-0.1979980022,
0.4886907339,
0.6832495332,
-0.5318841338,
0.9829186201,
0.4673566222,
-0.1385456324,
-0.3719593883,
0.3673528433,
-0.1807263643,
-0.8952246308,
0.6179942489,
0.5310689211,
-0.1857986897,
-0.0580970943,
-0.5284774899,
-0.2621041834,
0.9403922558,
0.2088453472,
-0.3829101622,
-0.04919976,
0.2773303688,
0.447522074,
-0.4175853729,
-0.1281234324,
0.5214867592,
0.3473064303,
-0.0477809384,
-0.5588197112,
0.3488047421,
-0.1295678318,
0.1602576673,
0.0612560324,
-0.3012990057,
0.3494671583,
-0.3751732707,
-0.2042742074,
0.1415205598,
0.5154998302,
0.6658626199,
0.3647146523,
0.3675871193,
0.3826019764,
0.6816410422,
-0.2055544853,
0.8820927143,
-0.733196795,
0.193810761,
0.6701008081,
-0.5861756802,
0.5920934081,
0.2917467356,
-0.0630474612,
0.8142703772,
0.5308587551,
-0.431809634,
0.274879545,
0.6353020668,
0.0590518564,
-0.1279248595,
0.0944059789,
-0.6128272414,
0.4303955138,
0.1979533136,
-0.2143934816,
0.2087813765,
0.2122449279,
-0.2163677961,
0.0131051401,
0.0859392136,
0.8127170205,
-0.0011391258,
-0.6811535358,
1.1620125771,
-0.1357937604,
0.7220477462,
-0.3381187022,
-0.3248053491,
-0.4435940683,
0.2054241598,
-0.4481945932,
-0.4603540003,
0.4323951304,
0.1328537762,
-0.0284968335,
-0.2988355756,
0.6081624627,
-0.1809106916,
-0.2636622488,
0.5415655971,
0.2139546275,
0.559257865,
-0.1191746742,
-0.3624490798,
0.9457504153,
0.0809696093,
-0.0085548908,
0.1003926471,
0.5688748956,
0.1405492127,
0.5249448419,
0.4259563982,
0.0952770188,
0.2208559662,
0.1559122652,
0.6172831655,
-0.6393325925,
-0.3757683635,
-0.9190620184,
0.077695623,
0.1447762698,
-0.1115370169,
0.6519867182,
0.7767150998,
0.8979408741,
-0.3449373841,
0.4681400657,
0.0195369814,
-0.1287927181,
-0.6701341867,
0.8513847589,
-0.3830701709,
0.6183332205,
-0.2927524745,
-1.1262279749,
-0.5158822536,
0.7236881256,
-0.0328657776,
0.029387258,
0.9147186279,
0.9846999049,
0.2254467458,
0.0869338512,
0.5909340382,
0.3285284042,
0.1250263453,
0.6316689253,
1.2685192823,
-0.4006946981,
0.5782281756,
-0.2598187327,
-0.1746384948,
-0.4760398865,
-0.6474926472,
-0.8264734745,
-0.5198999047,
-0.7790849805,
-0.6879856586,
-0.1068818942,
0.6938028932,
0.5191782713,
-0.944853723,
-0.599729538,
-0.4231813252,
0.2669023871,
-0.2319304347,
-0.3152589798,
0.1458940953,
-0.6032266021,
-0.4672432542,
0.2149515748,
0.3606428206,
-0.1175318658,
-0.5809088945,
-0.4159777462,
0.3821720481,
0.0326433666,
0.6704405546,
-0.1248722821,
-1.0899883509,
-0.0491594113,
-0.0278757829,
-0.3519368768,
0.041418802,
0.9702221751,
-0.8510501981,
0.2180383056,
0.3087007105,
0.7367836237,
0.1747674793,
-0.3672686219,
0.1598906964,
-0.5718740821,
-0.0377679765,
0.1547210068,
0.3092859089,
-0.034929987,
-0.561504066,
0.7057372332,
0.362972796,
-0.6592467427,
-1.3895769119,
0.2127684206,
-1.0116640329,
-0.4639925659,
1.3624457121,
0.1702676415,
-0.0222845059,
-0.0331139751,
-0.1707113236,
0.0822212026,
-0.049170915,
1.1680294275,
0.5166090131,
-0.1731393933,
-0.2197452486,
-0.4949209988,
0.7032479644,
0.2258753926,
-1.0274066925,
0.2495372444,
0.6441277862,
-0.0906273499,
0.3641479313,
0.3531162143,
-0.0548569039,
0.4059648216,
0.0432295911,
0.3235752285,
0.0330192447,
-0.4016432166,
-0.4772826135,
0.4505907297,
0.1218826547,
0.0616492853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00216v1
|
Graphical Reasoning: LLM-based Semi-Open Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-30T21:41:53 | 2024-04-30T21:41:53 |
Yicheng Tao, Yiqun Wang, Longju Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a comprehensive exploration of relation extraction
utilizing advanced language models, specifically Chain of Thought (CoT) and
Graphical Reasoning (GRE) techniques. We demonstrate how leveraging in-context
learning with GPT-3.5 can significantly enhance the extraction process,
particularly through detailed example-based reasoning. Additionally, we
introduce a novel graphical reasoning approach that dissects relation
extraction into sequential sub-tasks, improving precision and adaptability in
processing complex relational data. Our experiments, conducted on multiple
datasets, including manually annotated data, show considerable improvements in
performance metrics, underscoring the effectiveness of our methodologies.
|
[
-0.571377337,
-1.2782497406,
0.9587699175,
-0.2008424699,
-0.2935346365,
-0.0701033399,
-0.0826692134,
-0.7469705939,
-0.5928369164,
0.4712068737,
-0.4957115352,
-0.8172940612,
-0.4059273899,
-0.0295410492,
-0.0367788374,
1.032299757,
-0.3942653835,
-0.1059172899,
-0.2545668185,
-0.1710162461,
-0.3005013168,
-0.4445219636,
-0.8852528334,
-0.3151661754,
0.3835212588,
0.2652560174,
0.7199927568,
0.5123073459,
0.4654357433,
0.2037938684,
-0.0106486091,
0.3800455332,
-0.5864593983,
0.2043143362,
-0.5505460501,
-0.237142548,
-0.5265139341,
-0.028264612,
0.3961419463,
0.6120422482,
0.0271828827,
0.3159724474,
-0.2612929344,
0.5428942442,
-0.5895295143,
0.7583136559,
-0.5432069302,
-0.0061806147,
-0.1091709211,
0.0072752493,
-0.5675218105,
-0.2541613281,
0.2323708981,
-0.53747648,
0.0619767532,
-0.043078959,
1.1109111309,
-0.1120865196,
-0.5334302783,
-0.2621420026,
-0.8065931201,
0.5121589303,
-0.539853096,
0.4425271451,
0.1272948682,
0.5367565155,
-0.3288100064,
-1.2486021519,
-0.296946615,
-0.0708415881,
-0.1879208982,
0.1042474359,
-0.1412960291,
0.2187592834,
0.7738379836,
0.6021329165,
-0.351071924,
-0.3917205334,
-0.1336800307,
0.2216547728,
0.6668145061,
-0.1120158508,
0.8140800595,
-0.1988915056,
-0.512711823,
0.1646931469,
-0.9145879149,
-0.2053665966,
0.0317594707,
0.1576223224,
-0.1133661345,
0.6483482718,
0.0114470432,
0.7436718345,
-0.5514212847,
-0.1470976025,
-0.2605938017,
-0.2819795907,
-0.4601727426,
-0.2935680151,
0.956414938,
0.0964561254,
0.7415962815,
-0.3512018919,
-0.2357452512,
0.0438184738,
-0.3445903063,
-0.356454581,
-0.4971884787,
0.1047240421,
-0.5322505832,
0.0347254835,
0.1495630145,
-0.819840312,
-0.0581818409,
-0.4821509421,
0.1445720643,
-0.6101988554,
-0.2903427184,
-0.2665100694,
-0.4055210948,
0.245648846,
0.5733690262,
-0.767388761,
0.6027493477,
0.5129044652,
0.9844620824,
-0.1383624524,
0.1809089035,
-0.5307789445,
0.7223587036,
-0.1030303687,
0.731556952,
-0.6416714191,
-0.2203182131,
-0.249946624,
0.0224027596,
-0.0922671705,
-0.5121971369,
0.1924553663,
-0.6755439639,
0.3890551031,
-0.1671453416,
-0.61098665,
-0.2053427398,
0.13761805,
-0.8043111563,
1.2063183784,
0.541819334,
-0.8675895929,
0.2758494616,
-0.7226355672,
-0.2746648788,
0.1177278534,
-0.7199060321,
-0.0858679414,
-0.1696578562,
0.6729738712,
0.4712073505,
-0.439886272,
0.2756444216,
-0.5849133134,
-0.1277298182,
-0.2101524472,
-0.0583944842,
0.8863568902,
0.3851869702,
-0.3069710433,
0.1982821524,
-0.6928761005,
-0.0433411039,
0.1794998348,
0.1139201075,
-0.351332128,
-0.0125576332,
-0.2387240231,
0.5417671204,
0.1014487073,
-0.5141042471,
0.5420010686,
-0.2575137019,
0.3262498081,
0.69583565,
0.433211416,
0.3974529505,
0.3318888545,
0.457683742,
0.111469619,
-0.0223029274,
0.0716379359,
-0.4986847639,
-0.3367492259,
-0.4594099224,
0.2360220402,
0.5961349607,
-1.134984374,
-0.0014321029,
-0.1518971473,
-0.1209593788,
0.0763668641,
0.095209524,
0.3157523274,
0.6264097691,
0.4315868914,
-0.2049429417,
-0.3387477398,
-0.752592802,
-0.2872926891,
-0.2463145703,
-0.0336419046,
0.4907893538,
0.3706326187,
-0.0730461851,
1.1163657904,
-1.0384289026,
-0.0884696394,
-0.4959675074,
0.1912651956,
0.2552132905,
0.1710796654,
0.3699217439,
-0.7181780338,
-0.4687422514,
0.4015013576,
-1.4862509966,
0.0543587953,
-0.0845279992,
-0.3859207034,
-0.0935304686,
0.6833688021,
-0.6537483335,
0.7611621022,
-0.0307251047,
-0.1484654248,
0.4920212626,
-0.0794039592,
-0.2495835572,
-0.9181584716,
-0.1426424384,
0.4774204493,
-0.4950253069,
-0.5223665833,
0.0432497375,
-0.0522591472,
-0.1524469703,
-0.245827809,
0.6612709165,
-1.0852258205,
-0.4329105318,
0.028384069,
0.4542368054,
-0.4024598002,
0.5424175858,
0.2554679513,
0.8229637146,
0.6135874987,
-0.4797909558,
0.5794535875,
0.3937191963,
-0.2166607678,
0.0871725529,
-0.3451697826,
0.2196474671,
-0.180909723,
0.1874472946,
-0.9703528285,
-0.0885269418,
0.4263513684,
-0.0506452397,
0.3844934702,
-0.6022102237,
-0.665432632,
-0.1802684516,
-0.0006956012,
0.3209584653,
0.3809562922,
-0.6967740655,
0.4580300152,
0.4781122804,
-0.337156564,
-0.4762386382,
-0.2062757462,
-0.055253163,
-0.1855992973,
-0.5454047918,
0.0940102264,
0.5375686288,
-0.5749844909,
0.1975133121,
-0.3015329242,
-0.1085216776,
-0.1761075556,
-0.0999618247,
0.5112520456,
-0.0954291224,
0.0786863789,
0.0087060016,
-0.1468081027,
0.2457066476,
-0.2071042955,
0.2430206835,
-0.1861059219,
-0.25642851,
-0.175705269,
0.1867203861,
0.2623889744,
-0.169253543,
0.5109040737,
0.5631871819,
-0.6871173382,
-0.2338070869,
-0.1775892824,
0.0494085401,
-0.3703227341,
0.2999490201,
-0.7394268513,
-0.6381447315,
0.535702467,
-0.6866308451,
-0.0798288062,
0.2994782329,
0.4304086268,
0.1119410396,
1.0975141525,
0.7017660737,
-0.0426649451,
0.5813704133,
-0.4297032356,
0.5107492805,
-0.9051693082,
-0.3883383572,
-0.0802791566,
0.1590830684,
-0.7045398951,
-0.1305732727,
0.3997682333,
0.3630382121,
-0.2374769151,
0.2674330771,
-0.2367883176,
0.4304065704,
0.2062090784,
0.4061056376,
0.4705216289,
0.0721929595,
-0.2005703002,
0.2442983836,
-0.5037524104,
-0.8684598207,
0.8327922821,
0.2667300403,
0.8611385822,
0.2532716095,
0.5396903157,
0.1180436164,
0.6220207214,
-0.6604499817,
0.7558249831,
0.0268955957,
-0.4968849123,
-0.5394471884,
-0.700335443,
-0.7452172637,
0.2433174998,
0.0393012427,
-1.5544458628,
-0.0348931141,
-0.1117998436,
0.2481174618,
0.6847804785,
-0.7516817451,
0.89925915,
-0.1272305101,
-0.7315061092,
0.2332140803,
-0.8785979152,
0.6972592473,
0.3837268353,
0.1493945867,
-0.296713382,
0.041263774,
0.4889970124,
-0.3655285537,
0.4723595083,
-0.2520506978,
-0.2459093034,
0.4860958159,
0.0437795222,
0.5826841593,
0.3663140237,
0.0216752924,
0.050764285,
0.1996650398,
-0.3550056517,
-1.0118882656,
0.4948252439,
-0.568970263,
-0.5027753711,
-0.4579039216,
-0.8141123056,
-0.5826149583,
0.3549571037,
-0.0223612823,
0.4831006229,
-0.2409069091,
-0.3527564108,
0.5159077048,
-0.1173759252,
0.3583351076,
-0.2102702111,
-0.4952041507,
-0.6742216349,
0.5748940706,
-0.04113397,
0.4452418089,
0.4752570093,
-0.0597697496,
-0.5493617058,
-0.2526474893,
-0.5081299543,
0.5458753705,
-1.0067225695,
-0.0404102392,
-0.5316469669,
-0.213612631,
-0.2219394445,
0.2736102641,
0.1194797829,
-0.4332876801,
-0.0951389894,
-0.1906698942,
0.3107707798,
1.0643998384,
0.254925102,
0.1250612885,
-0.789493382,
0.5977197289,
0.1693102121,
0.2405334711,
0.0853871331,
0.1999293864,
-0.0496740155,
-0.071761176,
-0.4835021496,
-1.1885567904,
0.2732920051,
-0.1330293715,
0.7422930598,
0.4771569669,
-0.2545904815,
0.8592423797,
-0.3350614607,
0.7524671555,
0.1783820242,
-0.8481532931,
0.7673726082,
-0.570556581,
-0.0520825684,
0.2710261345,
0.6291140914,
-0.0900737047,
-0.1760671139,
-1.0447796583,
-0.7841602564,
0.6380035877,
0.4787622094,
-0.5201625228,
-0.1670309454,
0.6969099641,
-0.0261417199,
0.0946096405,
-0.6724347472,
-0.3689534664,
0.3908789456,
-0.2942183316,
0.0862285271,
-0.2526206374,
-0.1073033959,
-0.5027653575,
0.5379304886,
-0.2348993421,
0.5117352009,
0.238988921,
-0.2038018703,
-0.0481725223,
0.2784552276,
0.0804935172,
1.2792025805,
-0.4697069228,
0.3160203993,
0.3629543185,
-0.2035096437,
0.1307986379,
0.1238938347,
0.0337079838,
-0.0845545754,
0.5984908938,
0.6084198952,
0.0014339343,
-0.3351749778,
0.5177218914,
-0.0889060795,
0.0577456318,
0.0308093224,
-0.0923208371,
0.1451554298,
0.1176460758,
0.0453024693,
-0.4239442348,
0.1778645217,
-0.9066464901,
0.4892793596,
0.5478981137,
-0.4928974211,
-0.1638999432,
0.6999953389,
-0.1479794681,
0.1170446202,
0.9090077877,
-0.0162521247,
-0.1810475886,
0.505255878,
0.8721981645,
0.8306409717,
0.2219578475,
0.1328168213,
0.4559162259,
0.0297659524,
-0.0235614534,
0.3578046858,
-0.3454530537,
-0.6362522244,
-0.5292707086,
-0.1478118151,
-0.5342150331,
0.1754694432,
-0.8456947803,
0.4543989599,
-0.3986632824,
-0.1119731814,
-0.2259512693,
-0.0615298674,
-0.5077039599,
0.3277695179,
0.120804593,
0.9440615773,
-0.905218184,
0.867258966,
0.9272038341,
-0.7633805275,
-0.9154288769,
-0.053960152,
-0.206481427,
-0.6834337711,
0.6443762183,
-0.0022107738,
-0.1177857518,
0.1042450294,
-0.6349921823,
-0.5875700712,
1.2184773684,
0.5962875485,
-0.408246994,
-0.1752103418,
-0.0637669042,
0.4675629139,
-0.4660761952,
0.7631770968,
0.7439083457,
0.170159772,
0.2101314515,
-0.572414279,
0.3349053562,
-0.2007738054,
0.1476824284,
0.6415966749,
-0.4587470591,
0.5799458027,
-0.2445144057,
-0.5339403749,
-0.1786715537,
0.8830598593,
0.4043554068,
0.547553122,
0.3906505108,
0.5411811471,
0.8714578152,
-0.1296195835,
1.0745939016,
0.0436930358,
0.5433328152,
1.334411025,
-0.3574504852,
0.5912402272,
0.568844974,
-0.3088524044,
0.8293682933,
0.9161622524,
0.2405533493,
0.4639291763,
0.0439744815,
-0.3840732574,
-0.2529371679,
0.1335325986,
-0.2603846788,
0.0456154682,
0.3531207144,
-0.5597046614,
-0.631377995,
-0.3610676825,
0.1965866387,
-0.1049844697,
-0.2465210557,
1.0771141052,
0.4472967386,
-0.5138251781,
0.2179482728,
-0.307728827,
-0.204594478,
-0.4639585316,
-0.5391438603,
0.0107284319,
0.0616028644,
-0.3343437612,
-0.983971417,
0.0418478884,
0.0734589547,
0.0452338606,
-0.0264771692,
1.1828614473,
-0.3323393166,
-0.2618733943,
0.4675878882,
1.0690459013,
0.2938191891,
0.0299631935,
-0.6835047007,
-0.3636192977,
0.1030672118,
-0.3134766817,
0.380449295,
0.9038869143,
-0.5663733482,
0.6976037621,
0.7116302252,
0.2736158073,
-0.2356836051,
0.3251262903,
1.1277754307,
-0.9054051042,
-0.1786064357,
-1.0759141445,
0.2636139989,
-0.5179903507,
0.0152933644,
0.7265672088,
0.6978769302,
0.8303344846,
-0.0722367987,
1.0837550163,
-0.1104009971,
0.0850693733,
-0.692602098,
0.1607580185,
-0.1274981052,
0.4093494117,
-0.7505105734,
-1.1261461973,
-0.4250882566,
0.4470483065,
-0.85352844,
0.1555750966,
1.0965639353,
0.5452944636,
-0.3597735465,
0.2406639755,
0.0519669876,
-0.0770819336,
0.762401104,
0.7225778103,
1.0056595802,
-0.4105561376,
0.4060745835,
-0.2541863918,
-0.4740659297,
0.6138929725,
-0.9739542007,
-1.0185267925,
-0.2571620941,
-0.3490570188,
-0.2667085826,
0.0624550506,
0.701862514,
0.3902715445,
-0.5053748488,
-0.3777656853,
-0.4611887336,
0.3837080896,
-0.4018906653,
-0.3172294497,
0.6644563079,
-0.4247182906,
-0.5388104916,
0.0652623922,
0.377306819,
0.0326861069,
0.1559008956,
0.0598928817,
-0.6354032159,
-0.3274678588,
0.8366917968,
0.2661151588,
-0.4764525294,
-0.3948703706,
-0.5311077237,
0.1081338525,
0.2397510558,
0.8312426209,
-0.7152104974,
0.4581905007,
0.5888438225,
0.2324731499,
1.0417764187,
0.563152194,
0.8391662836,
-0.6207140684,
0.0305787064,
-0.0884623602,
0.4703073502,
0.1286475956,
-0.6448631883,
1.089138031,
0.4298965931,
-0.3704434633,
-0.7302253842,
0.4411826432,
-1.0361112356,
-0.1629845202,
1.2299211025,
-0.3624035418,
-0.3370582461,
-0.2893957794,
-0.3773117065,
0.6367841363,
-0.1678253412,
0.264806211,
0.6416338682,
-0.9936932325,
-0.3850374222,
-0.6533975601,
0.4750419557,
-0.3041286767,
-1.3072744608,
0.0525961332,
0.4059442878,
0.3424755037,
-0.2155276388,
0.7600148916,
-0.4980913699,
0.0301273819,
-0.0761441588,
-0.1141810641,
-0.0924230367,
-0.2879017591,
0.1278737336,
0.2794642448,
0.0710084736,
-0.1133323386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00208v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00208v2
|
A Primer on the Inner Workings of Transformer-based Language Models
| 2024-04-30T21:20:17 | 2024-05-02T01:29:17 |
Javier Ferrando, Gabriele Sarti, Arianna Bisazza, Marta R. Costa-jussà
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid progress of research aimed at interpreting the inner workings of
advanced language models has highlighted a need for contextualizing the
insights gained from years of work in this area. This primer provides a concise
technical introduction to the current techniques used to interpret the inner
workings of Transformer-based language models, focusing on the generative
decoder-only architecture. We conclude by presenting a comprehensive overview
of the known internal mechanisms implemented by these models, uncovering
connections across popular approaches and active research directions in this
area.
|
[
-0.0717809126,
-0.6812683344,
0.3796469569,
-0.0881107152,
-0.0977298468,
0.0994040594,
-0.0503716841,
-0.0867025703,
-0.3031903505,
0.9715005755,
-0.5395498276,
0.0436993986,
-0.4830858111,
-0.0107916091,
-0.7756476998,
1.0424188375,
0.0788948089,
0.0847283453,
-0.0293560494,
0.3497481644,
-0.419500351,
-0.4374671876,
-0.5051528215,
-0.5562688112,
-0.1132199764,
0.2869368494,
0.8022951484,
0.4961713254,
0.5119696856,
0.2715300322,
-0.3956591487,
-0.3649533391,
-0.4482160211,
0.2746408582,
-0.1349934638,
-0.7974418402,
-0.1519072503,
-0.4932101667,
0.7462135553,
0.7106384635,
0.0097995894,
-0.0848983899,
0.1653680801,
0.3917705417,
-0.4163591266,
0.3707631826,
-0.4979080856,
0.0468717329,
-0.5868831873,
-0.3362982571,
-0.8310881257,
-0.1227380037,
-0.0036007811,
0.0696641281,
0.617716074,
-0.3297515213,
0.5667303801,
0.0871078297,
-0.5834199786,
-0.4386967719,
-1.1447793245,
0.6876348257,
-0.4030662179,
0.5844690204,
0.133677423,
0.4103316367,
0.1626343429,
-0.8832887411,
-0.4929339588,
-0.2813598514,
-0.488751471,
-0.1781079322,
-0.4243387282,
0.3192283809,
0.0024891018,
1.0216114521,
-0.3887777328,
0.0453952886,
-0.5555895567,
0.189941898,
0.1419315636,
0.3225397468,
0.5028781295,
-0.1072168872,
-0.0179268904,
-0.1539986581,
-0.7788581252,
0.062054012,
0.2437327951,
0.0886355713,
-0.2425526232,
0.6540778279,
0.209966138,
0.5725198984,
0.2074988931,
0.1342492849,
-0.1487174928,
-0.4598679841,
-0.4316964149,
-0.2773112059,
0.6207386255,
0.0226916317,
0.2182858735,
-0.7544788122,
-0.5079855323,
0.2644332349,
0.5235159993,
-0.6125758886,
-0.46897614,
0.1909534782,
-0.6117046475,
-0.4834188521,
0.1021438166,
-0.832705915,
-0.1949384362,
-0.1808417886,
0.1188881248,
-0.3641882539,
-0.7463279366,
0.0935203135,
-0.1149357185,
0.6822004914,
-0.2236372977,
-1.0389053822,
0.6108022928,
0.8544296026,
0.769744873,
-0.0282478705,
-0.1163730547,
-0.1536829621,
0.0726834014,
-0.2290748656,
0.9867476225,
-0.721208334,
-0.5471869707,
0.1985955834,
0.3316581845,
-0.1532114595,
-0.5728496313,
0.7415120602,
-0.9569606185,
-0.0744806603,
0.0187634621,
-0.6915416718,
-0.1570989341,
-0.1667541862,
-0.9048479795,
0.60509938,
0.205236882,
-0.6049218774,
-0.0501516387,
-1.1257921457,
-0.3342060745,
0.1504543424,
-0.0378917083,
0.000870355,
0.6364559531,
0.1045495048,
0.0576696619,
-0.5160714984,
0.364377141,
0.3282307386,
-0.2571080327,
0.3808928728,
-0.5973933935,
0.9849207401,
0.2181526572,
-0.3307824433,
0.4780060351,
-0.7898787856,
-0.2284121215,
0.2944303453,
0.2251865417,
0.0466920175,
0.0444407575,
0.0739824474,
0.0068797371,
-0.0240409337,
-0.3533129394,
0.3437673151,
-0.4553976357,
0.481305629,
0.4367708266,
-0.1518842876,
0.9656706452,
-0.063080743,
0.8382451534,
-0.1893560737,
0.191572234,
-0.9512087107,
-0.4229260087,
-1.0134674311,
0.0597048998,
0.0284314975,
0.558955133,
-0.4234478772,
0.3546776175,
-0.3225756884,
-0.3859043121,
-0.704093039,
-0.1678161621,
0.3838087618,
0.2556570172,
0.1869076043,
-0.2363417,
-0.4327425063,
-0.8657271266,
0.003815939,
0.0800070912,
0.0122945094,
-0.2516159713,
0.4675603211,
-0.2931005359,
1.1037379503,
-0.3886047602,
0.0116557991,
-0.5282142162,
0.1888844818,
0.2871527076,
0.4933231175,
0.4496853054,
-0.9085065722,
-0.384023726,
0.075483717,
-0.6970526576,
-0.1699153781,
0.0180966333,
-0.0722234026,
-0.3418348432,
0.7981472015,
-0.7031832933,
0.4154315293,
0.5790166259,
-0.387236625,
0.5923830867,
0.0714819506,
-0.1259345114,
-0.6437366605,
0.2317628562,
-0.1533583999,
0.252391696,
-1.2223083973,
0.5636893511,
0.2652309239,
-0.3199958801,
-0.1105139107,
0.5138497949,
-0.5935961604,
-0.1513179392,
-0.6851556301,
-0.4618619382,
-0.0010333051,
0.0305771846,
0.0936164558,
0.9905161262,
0.7455083132,
-0.3844082654,
0.3524698317,
0.3617074788,
-0.423188895,
0.3062636256,
-0.8434270024,
0.2483009249,
-0.4435356855,
0.2684821486,
-0.8070106506,
0.0300225709,
0.264146924,
-0.1842057556,
0.5395864844,
-0.5783433318,
-0.6687862277,
-0.3491544425,
0.3390394747,
0.371044606,
0.5547268987,
-0.60026896,
0.8522998691,
0.2950251997,
-0.0650220811,
-0.1759123057,
-0.5936853886,
0.3014602661,
-0.0704767257,
-0.7613734603,
0.5480357409,
-0.0051585715,
-0.7647362947,
0.0679289475,
0.1174597293,
-0.3515478671,
0.0672716796,
0.199240014,
-0.0171159729,
-0.6790930033,
-0.0224957485,
-0.1096584052,
-0.6373166442,
0.2742041945,
-0.2776069641,
0.5473596454,
-0.2796349227,
-0.290831238,
-0.4858317375,
0.657856226,
0.8706675172,
-0.5710197687,
0.9838157892,
0.2157631814,
-0.0089668054,
-0.1372239888,
-0.4129357636,
-0.4256263077,
-0.5234228969,
0.2893153131,
-0.8153603673,
-0.5208905339,
0.6791211367,
-0.0601769835,
-0.0061058169,
0.4996905923,
0.536845088,
0.3389460146,
0.8332790732,
1.3994802237,
0.138540253,
0.5160633326,
-0.3637718856,
0.5600979924,
-0.7255849242,
-0.3097037077,
-0.5039997697,
0.3909215331,
-0.2613358498,
-0.4090620279,
0.2061403543,
0.3654307127,
-0.1156750917,
0.3608095944,
-0.4845034778,
0.5884745121,
0.3791316152,
-0.4022429287,
0.445538044,
-0.2396751046,
-0.0838152915,
0.1166572645,
-0.7496777773,
-0.6311560273,
0.8408380151,
0.5801485777,
0.8897840977,
0.0304489173,
-0.0201644413,
0.0546599068,
0.5457807183,
-0.662602067,
0.2047712654,
-0.0423926376,
-0.6824792624,
0.1431493014,
-0.0814547837,
-0.7754656076,
0.5368902087,
0.1450179964,
-0.4268205762,
0.1250838786,
-0.0033711593,
0.006577733,
0.8213425279,
-0.6785277128,
1.1192144156,
-0.3679534495,
0.3051838279,
-0.0601166338,
-0.5628194213,
0.5046367645,
0.034708295,
0.3641740382,
0.2965756059,
0.2418704182,
0.0797939524,
-0.087299265,
0.9239754081,
0.004145347,
-0.5812609196,
0.1758559197,
0.2408425212,
0.4755859375,
-0.5326881409,
-0.0447190143,
0.1402803808,
-0.1802898794,
-0.1385066211,
-0.6021041274,
0.3075820208,
-0.5476047397,
-0.3743185103,
-0.1447763145,
-0.4963638484,
0.025946822,
0.0369301885,
0.4063177705,
0.6982793212,
-0.3206399083,
0.2181483805,
0.6676704288,
-0.0134429792,
0.4478827715,
0.5143461227,
-0.17297481,
-0.2018770874,
0.4332408309,
-0.3950618207,
0.2980862856,
0.9021399021,
0.044219397,
-0.257258445,
-0.6185133457,
-0.5591617823,
0.2000904977,
-1.0548455715,
0.0579261295,
-0.9080545902,
-0.3277856708,
-0.383348763,
-0.1912295222,
-0.397292316,
0.0195936486,
-0.2050704956,
-0.1751174033,
0.0914980471,
1.1354039907,
0.1277102381,
0.8141101599,
-0.8451765776,
0.3543568552,
0.3155017197,
0.4562031627,
0.2780889869,
-0.4984280169,
-0.3736254275,
-0.0774202347,
-0.2919636965,
-1.000028491,
0.2907184064,
0.0909922794,
0.5897310972,
0.4751262665,
-0.1632165313,
0.471140027,
-0.6998392344,
0.7587252855,
-0.0328566656,
-1.048989892,
0.6018807292,
-0.1747638434,
0.1438686997,
0.0477565676,
0.0858619064,
-0.4774828553,
-0.2694363892,
-0.413590461,
-0.7142363191,
0.6029244661,
0.1560138017,
0.3611041009,
0.0093383472,
0.3104606569,
0.1675328612,
0.0105632544,
-0.9623093009,
-0.5221264362,
-0.2777322531,
-0.0992831364,
-0.098392643,
-0.4857268631,
-0.0849854872,
0.0429424308,
0.3916187286,
-0.3035351336,
0.3825701475,
-0.2573133707,
-0.5222132802,
-0.3094617128,
0.476226151,
0.3790746033,
0.7060670853,
-0.0245321989,
0.054348886,
-0.1841262728,
-0.1570644975,
0.0701701194,
0.0462466553,
-0.2958265841,
-0.0347180367,
0.3552445173,
1.1529749632,
0.4858611524,
-0.5457842946,
0.6041958928,
-0.0687736496,
0.3348958194,
-0.3799417913,
-0.1301843673,
-0.2567067444,
0.4676395357,
0.6954363585,
0.067133382,
0.060972672,
-0.6050717831,
0.3994183838,
0.3794104755,
-0.5265261531,
-0.8320457339,
0.6377170086,
0.208593905,
-0.2224939913,
0.6329077482,
0.0594151206,
-0.5064731836,
0.5013319254,
0.94713974,
1.2805755138,
-0.3062821031,
0.02209628,
0.0989850387,
0.4946421981,
-0.0227079038,
-0.0449968018,
-0.189683497,
-0.744170785,
-0.8620896935,
-0.6614946723,
-0.4264658093,
0.1417464316,
-0.803855598,
0.0194046758,
0.1728938669,
0.1259044856,
-0.0698510781,
-0.5103006959,
-0.4634033442,
0.0491348356,
0.2283813059,
0.9002951384,
-0.9116316438,
0.99871701,
0.6108621955,
-0.5049580336,
0.0256844517,
0.3058133721,
-0.1008110195,
-0.8079851866,
0.8781865239,
-0.1138585135,
-0.331132859,
0.0710974857,
-0.3655206263,
-0.9444950223,
0.5897340775,
0.2641789317,
-0.2972002923,
-0.4169630706,
0.0318224765,
0.3886088729,
-0.3558555841,
0.4233379364,
0.6695016026,
0.3997833133,
-0.2413953692,
-0.9247810245,
-0.1040598154,
-0.5494627357,
0.1322107017,
0.3945591748,
-0.3061552048,
0.9476023316,
-0.1191824451,
-0.603135705,
0.3145168424,
0.9364039898,
-0.3569661677,
-0.2466285378,
0.2924773991,
0.3342802823,
0.1239768937,
-0.0740533099,
1.1865822077,
-0.8830951452,
0.3091244996,
0.774310708,
0.0968739316,
0.4242881835,
0.1548049301,
-0.1808811128,
0.6645017266,
-0.1803969294,
-0.1588339806,
0.6529482603,
-0.0027294138,
-0.3569032252,
0.0145367961,
-0.0329700075,
-0.1733492166,
0.4179798663,
0.6002492905,
-0.4089578092,
-0.4252983928,
0.1113033593,
-0.1609794945,
-0.1315872967,
-0.1779385954,
0.8255213499,
0.1162472218,
-0.6160048246,
0.2305552065,
0.2081137002,
0.874324441,
-0.6712651849,
-0.0003062849,
-0.0106594022,
0.2388695031,
0.0717347413,
-0.9965084195,
0.7447737455,
0.1957726926,
-0.4872017205,
-0.611046195,
0.7841445804,
-0.3182794452,
-0.1952326,
0.3237344325,
0.5465468168,
-0.2109098732,
-0.2411260158,
-0.45654881,
0.3288361132,
-0.1586892754,
0.1585010886,
-0.051103346,
0.4937594235,
0.2557801008,
0.5434715152,
0.5521370769,
-0.2103591263,
0.1601935327,
0.1784398705,
0.7194251418,
-1.0115301609,
-0.5266339183,
-0.7331724167,
0.7423824668,
0.3824848831,
-0.144070968,
0.6638196111,
0.3792827725,
0.6512073278,
-0.1116319969,
0.882696569,
-0.0570674948,
0.1578992903,
-0.4919865727,
0.5914685726,
-0.1109496206,
0.0308696758,
0.0857260078,
-0.6680979133,
-0.2500691116,
0.5786613822,
-0.0650436655,
-0.2626707256,
0.5856510401,
0.8218843937,
-0.3046380579,
0.3446299732,
0.136932224,
0.3825272322,
0.4396661222,
0.1109264717,
1.1140158176,
-0.4850755632,
0.5002036691,
-0.3900076449,
-0.2263218611,
-0.2479902655,
-0.7156667113,
-0.7205203176,
-0.7328079939,
-0.1479148418,
-0.1519884765,
-0.1331516653,
0.3282316029,
0.7323387265,
-1.0235743523,
-0.4381022751,
-0.5795913935,
-0.0269842371,
-0.2528907955,
-0.3087406754,
0.2770847976,
-0.5556610227,
-0.5039465427,
0.7345151305,
0.2038518786,
0.0276534036,
-0.4239282608,
0.2009070963,
0.5444880128,
0.1093781665,
0.7043356299,
0.2839680016,
-0.9823574424,
0.2752484679,
0.1835371554,
0.0719741881,
0.2569544613,
1.5272886753,
-0.6292642951,
0.4577355385,
0.5010200143,
0.3985306919,
0.3877477944,
-0.4138107598,
0.9085823298,
-0.4317711294,
-0.1014628485,
0.2649044394,
0.3972049356,
0.484177202,
-0.104769811,
0.3127970397,
0.0915361717,
-0.4446907341,
-0.8729288578,
0.4572257996,
-0.4686311185,
-0.2444299161,
0.9698848724,
0.1025136486,
-0.1722932905,
-0.2893272638,
-0.0822811127,
0.2611667514,
0.0808150545,
0.3159422576,
0.3947825134,
0.0012548983,
-0.6993477941,
-0.5267793536,
0.4041189849,
0.041428566,
-0.6103563309,
0.3597138226,
0.2685312927,
0.1672855318,
0.1881151795,
0.5781143904,
-0.3223213553,
-0.0669273883,
0.3273867965,
0.1182921752,
0.195346579,
-0.4787546098,
-0.7264381051,
0.382794708,
-0.0997231454,
0.2768021226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00204v1
|
General Purpose Verification for Chain of Thought Prompting
| 2024-04-30T21:15:17 | 2024-04-30T21:15:17 |
Robert Vacareanu, Anurag Pratik, Evangelia Spiliopoulou, Zheng Qi, Giovanni Paolini, Neha Anna John, Jie Ma, Yassine Benajiba, Miguel Ballesteros
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many of the recent capabilities demonstrated by Large Language Models (LLMs)
arise primarily from their ability to exploit contextual information. In this
paper, we explore ways to improve reasoning capabilities of LLMs through (1)
exploration of different chains of thought and (2) validation of the individual
steps of the reasoning process. We propose three general principles that a
model should adhere to while reasoning: (i) Relevance, (ii) Mathematical
Accuracy, and (iii) Logical Consistency. We apply these constraints to the
reasoning steps generated by the LLM to improve the accuracy of the final
generation. The constraints are applied in the form of verifiers: the model
itself is asked to verify if the generated steps satisfy each constraint. To
further steer the generations towards high-quality solutions, we use the
perplexity of the reasoning steps as an additional verifier. We evaluate our
method on 4 distinct types of reasoning tasks, spanning a total of 9 different
datasets. Experiments show that our method is always better than vanilla
generation, and, in 6 out of the 9 datasets, it is better than best-of N
sampling which samples N reasoning chains and picks the lowest perplexity
generation.
|
[
-0.2892192304,
-0.8948953152,
1.1641869545,
-0.0931361914,
-0.1242144331,
-0.021710448,
-0.3498807251,
-0.2229704559,
-0.2003525794,
0.8230899572,
-0.649859786,
-0.4887382388,
-0.298397541,
0.2567947805,
-0.3910655081,
0.7888511419,
-0.4208956063,
-0.2946895361,
-0.4521866441,
0.1350562423,
-0.3768966496,
-0.6339125633,
-0.419750005,
-0.578425765,
0.4495473504,
0.3424002528,
0.636131525,
0.5927173495,
0.3233987987,
0.2872364223,
-0.3050141633,
0.8111281395,
-0.4118414521,
0.3800444305,
-0.6145341396,
-0.4674438834,
-0.3868299127,
-0.3662393689,
0.4093819261,
0.5401018858,
-0.1533771455,
0.1297308654,
0.0005887132,
0.515917778,
-0.7372487783,
-0.2593948543,
-0.7945593596,
-0.1972996742,
-0.0140138119,
-0.3279498219,
-0.547808826,
-0.5959615707,
0.1664037555,
-0.4704414904,
0.0973228961,
0.2257479578,
0.9961224198,
0.2276482731,
-0.6306889057,
-0.4970778525,
-0.9637041688,
0.6987833381,
-0.7031711936,
0.335664928,
0.3844669461,
0.2103109956,
-0.4786559045,
-0.7926149368,
-0.6849294305,
-0.1807810664,
0.0780762061,
-0.2589255571,
-0.0630778,
0.1365349889,
0.7276575565,
0.5456048846,
-0.2972352207,
-0.0811015591,
-0.1587349772,
-0.287629813,
0.5022960305,
0.1176481023,
0.2597844303,
-0.0028052893,
-0.2640331089,
-0.1245099753,
-1.1965708733,
0.1132502407,
0.4355304241,
0.0032291177,
0.304535687,
0.6140412092,
-0.4791363478,
0.8171619773,
0.0992662832,
-0.1973166317,
0.0056752106,
-0.5463359952,
-0.315218538,
-0.2506556511,
0.4229302406,
0.2634099126,
0.4815974832,
0.0474804342,
-0.3278535903,
-0.0498098917,
0.4483534396,
-0.3825382888,
-0.1262882501,
0.3528815508,
0.0168547444,
-0.004594414,
-0.1509507149,
-0.214692995,
-0.2753235102,
-0.5555552244,
0.3103710115,
-0.3847858012,
-0.0568000637,
0.3659805059,
0.0091997916,
0.220663622,
0.6232267618,
-0.8736474514,
0.1851462871,
0.8935223818,
0.4238415956,
0.0743025169,
-0.1962367743,
-0.4650251567,
0.3527661264,
-0.4569736719,
0.8440615535,
-0.4446772635,
-0.0656293854,
0.0938940942,
-0.1306019127,
0.0404606313,
-0.496869117,
0.772672534,
-0.4488843083,
0.0833584443,
-0.7807401419,
-0.6810548306,
-0.3177713752,
0.668692112,
-0.3441990018,
0.8677021265,
-0.0280789882,
-0.6946448088,
0.4478388131,
-0.3795547485,
-0.4459594786,
-0.016868826,
-0.3916230202,
-0.0572558232,
0.3798642457,
0.4819487929,
0.3828863204,
-0.5939263105,
0.3971326947,
-0.2666171491,
-0.1695515811,
0.2760154605,
-0.2528966963,
0.6709824204,
0.2461746931,
-0.2675799429,
0.1340863407,
-0.7958438993,
0.4519348741,
-0.0282794852,
-0.3897123933,
-0.3017986417,
0.2312331796,
-0.6464982629,
0.1877402365,
-0.0415823013,
-0.2941735089,
0.4214567244,
-0.2922712266,
0.6454578042,
0.762534976,
0.3548849523,
0.0554580837,
-0.3803563118,
0.4570501447,
0.0839779004,
0.180187732,
-0.2434678227,
-0.5125416517,
-1.008505106,
0.0803403854,
0.239123106,
0.536283195,
-0.892143786,
0.6480950713,
-0.1267358363,
-0.1498535275,
-0.112519905,
0.2668533623,
0.3502290249,
0.5221815109,
0.3233002424,
-0.0690921992,
-0.666185081,
-0.6985113621,
-0.0514995605,
-0.4383251667,
-0.1821051389,
0.2532289624,
0.6705170274,
-0.3635546267,
0.9079307318,
-0.1682186276,
0.6262671947,
-0.2341166735,
-0.0762390271,
0.4632103443,
0.4547852874,
-0.0669308007,
-0.4779133201,
0.0564631224,
0.1546341926,
-0.9471030235,
-0.1560979187,
-0.2413297147,
-0.2608176172,
-0.0000044206,
0.3781896234,
-0.4691496789,
0.4231968522,
0.3565282822,
-0.1502076387,
0.5964186192,
-0.4109402299,
0.188323617,
-0.7137690187,
-0.0830846503,
-0.0025625399,
-0.2936904132,
-0.7313843966,
0.3062942326,
0.026982883,
0.2185916901,
-0.1934937835,
0.1391129643,
-0.4547047615,
0.2824961841,
-0.140909031,
0.1942651868,
0.2248331755,
0.1654169559,
-0.08749789,
0.5954453349,
0.6209096909,
-1.0274906158,
0.5667213798,
-0.0088377278,
-0.5701400638,
0.5631758571,
-0.8379663229,
0.4978768229,
-0.1371588856,
0.4122052193,
-1.0074731112,
-0.2198498398,
0.1227023602,
0.0137509853,
-0.1118004099,
0.1239308938,
-0.761136353,
-0.7624152303,
0.0266320836,
0.2692953944,
0.5312472582,
-0.7992627025,
0.7924926877,
0.0267036036,
0.2946849763,
-0.6098818183,
-0.4429448545,
0.0543916002,
-0.2268335968,
-0.9425394535,
0.1460018307,
-0.118161343,
-0.4493209422,
-0.3946644962,
-0.3547682464,
0.197137922,
0.1162014306,
0.0779257864,
0.1845747977,
-0.1124285758,
0.1618978977,
0.0752614066,
0.0109140696,
0.2108610421,
-0.564858377,
0.4378542602,
-0.0880238414,
-0.6428525448,
-0.1583411843,
0.0824071541,
0.4232352972,
-0.0633441955,
0.189939782,
0.1294842809,
-0.4032617509,
-0.5420265794,
-1.0713583231,
-0.137581557,
-0.4949698746,
-0.1006637588,
-0.6702353358,
-1.0342904329,
0.6345974803,
-0.4130914211,
-0.0353111848,
0.2262448519,
0.5157803297,
0.0952629298,
0.9883952141,
0.4811548591,
0.1573196203,
-0.2422362715,
-0.1031751558,
0.4254011512,
-0.9933573604,
-0.3187639117,
-0.4128213823,
-0.0936509892,
-0.4186473489,
-0.5604887009,
0.3079530597,
0.4628475606,
-0.2938840091,
0.2587969899,
-0.4460935295,
0.767193675,
0.4666216373,
0.1601154506,
0.4277156293,
0.1055104956,
-0.7064248323,
0.3011706769,
-0.6017486453,
-0.948099494,
0.8679566979,
0.4456021786,
0.7740584016,
0.0688604489,
0.7088215947,
0.0093558887,
0.0362639651,
-0.4421465099,
0.7850800753,
0.1519320607,
-0.7586574554,
-0.3095635772,
-0.4789271355,
-0.6206127405,
0.1604823619,
-0.0153409969,
-1.1716235876,
0.2678711116,
0.4364148974,
-0.3781656623,
0.3668622673,
-0.3040332198,
0.4425917268,
-0.2776060402,
-0.5087988973,
-0.2692842782,
-0.4456982315,
0.6462991238,
0.1101061478,
0.0670848936,
0.1208801046,
0.1807780862,
0.1640079468,
-0.7979528308,
0.7637428641,
0.0759566277,
-0.645100534,
0.6783564687,
0.0755219832,
0.9539836049,
-0.0814540982,
-0.0802586898,
-0.1819590181,
-0.2630114555,
-0.0310904104,
-0.7948173285,
0.5597673059,
-0.3844746947,
-1.2256938219,
-0.067135185,
-0.5156258345,
-0.3762592077,
0.0267250855,
0.3157256246,
0.3114302456,
0.0940717012,
0.2483923286,
0.9241378903,
-0.0967750996,
0.0088236555,
0.0431546569,
-0.4593022168,
-0.5136731863,
0.5201260448,
-0.0556875579,
0.5321543813,
0.3540743589,
0.3675972223,
-0.3964166641,
-0.677365303,
-0.4130551219,
0.1362386346,
-1.1836885214,
-0.0099511445,
-0.524189055,
-0.1008841619,
-0.3381103873,
-0.0206500441,
-0.0505027249,
-0.3224373162,
0.0077333753,
-0.1710848063,
0.2537689507,
0.9503983855,
0.0031634241,
0.0191073753,
-0.417981118,
0.1870698631,
0.6432872415,
0.1104052961,
0.1077641025,
-0.5074443221,
0.0893780366,
0.0721324533,
-0.3545103371,
-0.6196454763,
-0.2212473005,
-0.1814064831,
0.769436121,
0.5455338955,
-0.1175650582,
0.7792751193,
-0.4851427674,
0.8322585821,
0.1612830609,
-1.3007183075,
0.9567534328,
-0.3296231925,
0.2789036334,
0.4125451148,
0.3559759557,
-0.3336499631,
-0.4947625995,
-0.6815508604,
-0.7269957066,
0.1114400998,
0.3159779906,
-0.0360878408,
-0.0611291341,
0.8260200024,
-0.1515677124,
0.0746802986,
-0.6781375408,
-0.0376440324,
-0.0514219701,
0.087917313,
0.2332845181,
-0.3805058897,
-0.1532688886,
-0.2763591409,
0.6777263284,
-0.2316584736,
-0.2981641591,
0.3772729039,
0.0592152365,
-0.1837299615,
0.4464679062,
0.7640936971,
1.1909101009,
0.0072760084,
0.499225378,
0.5069721937,
-0.1074313894,
0.5324200988,
-0.5518766642,
-0.4218945801,
-0.122826457,
0.4597051442,
0.8137235641,
-0.0387671478,
-0.4827046096,
0.1881281286,
0.1095222309,
-0.3074238896,
-0.0686474517,
0.5213081837,
0.0502307378,
0.2933036089,
0.1604866534,
-0.1099418998,
0.035844475,
-0.5729439855,
0.0500328168,
0.2996090949,
0.0811816081,
-0.2135615796,
0.4346734881,
-0.0242624544,
-0.2271703035,
0.6944483519,
-0.2594218552,
-0.5867567658,
0.4501411021,
0.6276404858,
0.7765101194,
-0.1598078161,
0.1024164036,
0.5210374594,
0.5202699304,
-0.5611854792,
0.4606634378,
-0.228033796,
-0.9400246143,
-0.7532250285,
-0.2867793739,
-0.7913424969,
0.2196166068,
-0.4573634863,
0.2839908898,
-0.6229013801,
-0.3725657463,
-0.2380731553,
-0.1945796311,
-0.556131959,
0.3191614747,
0.2691095471,
0.7913483977,
-0.7005669475,
0.8279214501,
0.6490296125,
-0.2513674796,
-0.9973614216,
-0.010285276,
0.0321119465,
-0.7513347268,
0.8224445581,
0.089501597,
-0.3474064767,
-0.2251450568,
-0.7637530565,
-0.9166459441,
0.971178174,
0.2569602728,
-0.9544491768,
-0.0569393821,
0.0842478201,
0.4757301211,
-0.5079036355,
0.1791204959,
0.575517416,
0.6003471017,
0.4565119743,
-0.7140327692,
0.312893182,
-0.1223409623,
0.3008546531,
-0.024766773,
-0.0591398589,
0.8481432199,
-0.4861654341,
-0.3465600908,
0.0580897518,
0.7358829975,
0.9213026762,
0.1267921776,
0.736836791,
0.6209110618,
1.3230967522,
-0.2102158517,
1.1808048487,
-0.116311051,
0.1349341273,
1.139436245,
-0.5524530411,
0.704133153,
0.5839028955,
-0.1575446278,
0.864500761,
0.3808941543,
-0.0309092607,
0.1718245447,
0.830059886,
-0.1821901649,
-0.6108157039,
-0.142859906,
-0.2173579037,
0.1504129469,
0.478700757,
-0.3207482696,
-0.0657458454,
-0.1445488185,
0.0763506815,
0.1625114083,
-0.3249437511,
0.4899742305,
-0.0593515486,
-1.1062245369,
0.8330508471,
-0.2032954246,
0.3410889506,
-0.4403519034,
0.0020006252,
0.0278272331,
0.3608590066,
-0.1410828233,
-0.7399662137,
-0.0268499758,
0.1000405252,
-0.1859827489,
-0.2357701808,
0.8730257154,
-0.1946855336,
-0.4933368862,
0.0536006354,
0.5020936728,
0.1546886712,
0.0404194407,
-0.3727616072,
0.2855871916,
0.1957291365,
-0.2032755166,
-0.2635914683,
0.9360076785,
-0.1752967834,
0.8101332188,
0.6268925071,
0.2753613591,
-0.1098135263,
0.3533646762,
0.8856067657,
-0.6699334383,
-0.2257633656,
-1.0769532919,
0.5144845843,
-0.2484180778,
-0.4387664199,
0.9123720527,
0.2290549725,
0.9081916213,
0.0731535777,
0.7525471449,
0.1710386872,
0.2388274372,
-0.8877318501,
0.0416165739,
-0.1839679182,
0.5721468329,
-0.1842883378,
-0.8772376776,
-0.3759131134,
0.8396461606,
-0.5191403627,
0.1293991208,
1.006751895,
0.7037150264,
0.0496743172,
0.3916448653,
0.2375177443,
0.0953288823,
0.5469725132,
0.8184873462,
1.419657588,
-0.2875255048,
0.1618261933,
-0.1865208745,
-0.0982228592,
0.1085419059,
-1.2638962269,
-1.1309527159,
-0.3058284819,
-0.5474941134,
-0.5570421815,
0.0300736707,
0.8670806885,
0.6971381903,
-0.7846811414,
-0.3182760477,
-0.4498405159,
0.3793278337,
-0.2913915515,
-0.1064204425,
0.0125196939,
-0.5751516223,
-0.3333935142,
0.4052335918,
0.3888449967,
-0.0484701581,
-0.4942972064,
-0.0738954842,
-0.2600257993,
0.3111826479,
0.6148864031,
0.1321862042,
-1.2130308151,
-0.701574862,
-0.1715510786,
0.0978198349,
-0.0449357927,
1.1736544371,
-0.6147399545,
0.3063150942,
0.6941776872,
0.5123170614,
0.3502679169,
0.0402613729,
0.7064762712,
-0.5708185434,
-0.4784995317,
0.0822056308,
0.6167439222,
0.2845487893,
-0.3904528022,
0.6626737118,
0.0169648379,
-0.7138001323,
-0.8749659061,
0.4947672188,
-0.7345078588,
-0.1193897054,
1.2715818882,
-0.3295941055,
-0.333142072,
-0.1530476958,
-0.0427305102,
-0.0242718644,
-0.0069435593,
0.5925056934,
1.0040047169,
-0.1512661427,
-0.0730372071,
-0.3299348354,
0.2938736379,
0.3110656738,
-0.9541173577,
0.3372543752,
0.4961624444,
0.2324258983,
0.4638037384,
0.4918383658,
0.0258700047,
0.1044178605,
-0.2794039249,
-0.1727482229,
0.0842545107,
-0.4818923771,
-0.1248821616,
0.2581261992,
0.1280025244,
0.2733986676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00201v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00201v1
|
SPAFIT: Stratified Progressive Adaptation Fine-tuning for Pre-trained Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T21:07:32 | 2024-04-30T21:07:32 |
Samir Arora, Liangliang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Full fine-tuning is a popular approach to adapt Transformer-based pre-trained
large language models to a specific downstream task. However, the substantial
requirements for computational power and storage have discouraged its
widespread use. Moreover, increasing evidence of catastrophic forgetting and
overparameterization in the Transformer architecture has motivated researchers
to seek more efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods. Commonly known
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods like LoRA and BitFit are typically
applied across all layers of the model. We propose a PEFT method, called
Stratified Progressive Adaptation Fine-tuning (SPAFIT), based on the
localization of different types of linguistic knowledge to specific layers of
the model. Our experiments, conducted on nine tasks from the GLUE benchmark,
show that our proposed SPAFIT method outperforms other PEFT methods while
fine-tuning only a fraction of the parameters adjusted by other methods.
|
[
-0.5237697959,
-1.102375865,
0.292581439,
0.3693082035,
-0.1587771326,
-0.1342419833,
-0.6290820837,
-0.1301188171,
-0.141343236,
0.6343606114,
-0.6074302197,
-0.3335149884,
-0.4914791882,
-0.0953650773,
-0.2130705118,
1.233058691,
-0.1989278644,
-0.1876971424,
0.1311992854,
-0.0135818012,
-0.5798608065,
-0.2573913932,
-0.9394503236,
-0.4714593291,
0.29593274,
0.4647095203,
0.6180285811,
0.3709823787,
0.4470547438,
0.3351507187,
-0.1836467832,
0.2748068571,
-0.7585292459,
-0.0953318775,
-0.517546773,
-0.3693011403,
-0.4977280796,
-0.3294948041,
0.8366948962,
0.8227431178,
-0.3076466024,
0.3790100217,
0.1532602012,
0.9138887525,
-0.643439889,
-0.0473329537,
-0.7031210661,
0.0410903729,
-0.0410318449,
-0.2085329443,
-0.4504054487,
-0.1582822949,
0.096597217,
-0.6137419939,
0.4528980851,
-0.0739372149,
0.7571194768,
0.5704344511,
-0.2908412814,
0.1469160318,
-1.0161956549,
0.5977071524,
-0.6339687109,
0.4571232796,
0.4065150321,
0.2573478222,
-0.4119610488,
-0.6283704042,
-0.3381278813,
-0.3497002125,
-0.0100018345,
0.0509009026,
-0.1408004463,
0.1627643704,
0.2502617538,
0.3619723916,
-0.5544726253,
0.1584350616,
-0.1127800047,
-0.0790231004,
0.3420658708,
-0.2152631432,
-0.0585858971,
0.4159826338,
-0.3387333453,
-0.0061522797,
-0.6408343315,
0.045444157,
0.0979728848,
0.4743240476,
-0.0837363452,
0.3264070451,
-0.2937810719,
0.8569617271,
0.6242536306,
-0.0862148404,
0.2026560754,
-0.2216426134,
-0.3758555949,
-0.0529907085,
0.4256317317,
-0.1177382171,
0.4237267077,
-0.2776840031,
-0.2958301008,
-0.3086186945,
0.3764928281,
-0.6487167478,
-0.3393091857,
-0.1708643436,
-0.1610249877,
0.0440084413,
-0.1992113739,
-0.469847858,
-0.2424486727,
-0.4063757658,
0.8431158662,
-0.419483602,
-0.3350057602,
0.4077542424,
0.1242884398,
0.2550886273,
0.3146876395,
-0.8312470317,
0.4308897555,
0.755535841,
0.8046576977,
-0.178125158,
-0.5818719864,
-0.7939699292,
0.0607860796,
-0.2919974923,
1.1271266937,
-0.6523324847,
-0.0455175005,
-0.1815093011,
0.3578873873,
-0.4856886864,
-0.6006256342,
0.5457198024,
-0.3888362646,
0.1261299998,
-0.047021918,
-0.3444831669,
-0.096068427,
-0.014031047,
-0.4756490588,
1.2971205711,
0.4762856066,
-0.4921678305,
0.2477352619,
-0.6420401931,
-0.7331265807,
-0.1434614062,
0.409858197,
-0.6798114777,
0.4773257077,
0.1996415555,
0.3560605347,
-0.1534863412,
0.3751452267,
-0.1196716949,
-0.6260693669,
-0.0576122925,
-0.2801189125,
0.3263226151,
0.0119212912,
-0.6306000948,
0.2544612288,
-0.6036456823,
-0.3548021913,
-0.0457134508,
-0.2909701765,
-0.226612404,
-0.1372040659,
-0.1026812121,
-0.0200831313,
0.176832065,
-0.2903514206,
0.2771453857,
-0.6668444276,
0.4332371652,
0.8642536402,
0.0022850465,
0.7706356645,
-0.2423271686,
0.3609744608,
0.0301263016,
0.1602910012,
-0.0341127776,
-0.1561549306,
-1.1413323879,
-0.2247132361,
0.5948242545,
0.4962341785,
-0.6946123242,
0.5745398402,
-0.2550645769,
-0.812002182,
-0.3853610754,
0.0998017043,
0.2898115814,
0.5651432872,
0.4199625552,
-0.2309370637,
-0.1197920665,
-1.000300169,
-0.3384991884,
0.261669904,
-0.214846015,
0.2041548342,
0.4579940438,
-0.1345512122,
0.6813763976,
-0.4832617044,
-0.4540242255,
-0.0362180173,
0.1107790321,
0.4428683221,
0.5208321214,
0.6500833631,
-0.7030082345,
-0.5523974895,
0.1812605262,
0.0500785597,
-0.1580666155,
-0.2556674778,
-0.3069621325,
-0.0382751338,
0.3577809334,
-0.5904404521,
-0.0577713922,
0.7123795748,
-0.5718303323,
0.4136326313,
-0.4838983417,
0.2392032743,
-0.8583478332,
0.0661718026,
0.1080688909,
-0.38523525,
-0.8555839062,
0.0271907263,
0.1964569837,
-0.1842700243,
-0.3991386294,
0.3637547195,
-0.2981280386,
0.1503715813,
-0.2270723432,
-0.0857587084,
-0.1104068011,
0.6719145775,
0.2515746057,
0.9335330129,
0.5466977358,
-0.5349189043,
0.0408097878,
-0.0395692699,
-0.1826274395,
0.3310306966,
-0.6007355452,
0.219632715,
-0.248100251,
0.2783684433,
-0.9604213834,
-0.0665320903,
0.0751963854,
0.0759049729,
0.3527749777,
-0.280280143,
-0.2889276147,
-0.0347900242,
-0.2179501057,
0.367831409,
0.4684791267,
-0.4061916173,
0.9401051998,
0.3837422132,
-0.2989553213,
-0.2667041421,
-0.321357578,
-0.2867796719,
-0.3589758277,
-0.4147815108,
0.4191749394,
-0.1078452393,
0.4048113823,
-0.3779070079,
-0.4313158095,
-0.1425679922,
0.2889816165,
0.1312976629,
0.0073229712,
-0.4897551239,
0.0323638022,
0.2104119658,
-0.3117547929,
-0.5002330542,
-0.2619547546,
0.698353529,
-0.2781797945,
-0.2456176281,
-0.1242226139,
0.2411582321,
0.4455138147,
-0.3418502808,
0.8310614824,
0.9353979826,
-0.4431675971,
-0.4987768531,
-0.7823732495,
-0.1100746989,
-0.537582159,
0.4632721543,
-0.5157064199,
-1.2711945772,
0.4583215714,
-0.6129465699,
0.0028933762,
0.4749621749,
0.6181587577,
0.0262112711,
0.7647169828,
1.0149974823,
-0.0826426968,
0.7902182937,
0.0082673952,
0.300542444,
-0.5228824019,
0.1432247907,
-0.8104363084,
-0.3774331808,
-0.4629701674,
-0.4536352754,
0.252458632,
0.4066922367,
-0.6241174936,
0.6845172048,
-0.6314035654,
0.6899037957,
0.4022883475,
0.1797789782,
0.23210904,
0.131348595,
0.3925513923,
0.147610262,
-0.6761954427,
-0.080431357,
0.5110986829,
0.45051983,
0.6404802799,
-0.0833123699,
0.4377154708,
0.1902495027,
0.317063719,
-0.5989164114,
0.2944622338,
-0.6068071127,
-0.4303026795,
-0.4757717848,
-0.4154635072,
-0.6649430394,
0.1022920087,
-0.2107551694,
-0.6485286951,
0.2907666266,
0.3354074657,
-0.4712340236,
0.0986907184,
-0.9347664714,
0.9973756075,
-0.0271330196,
-0.0890909061,
-0.2632399201,
-0.3044208884,
-0.0732119754,
-0.5496576428,
0.2935048044,
-0.293865025,
-0.010046538,
0.7566668987,
0.0068358644,
0.8695895672,
-0.4060179293,
-0.2031600028,
-0.1025943831,
0.1692035645,
0.821570456,
-0.0903471634,
-0.1738616377,
0.3379124701,
0.1065252349,
-0.5144966841,
-0.4464029968,
0.6815206409,
-0.7365908623,
-0.5829803348,
-0.0229528937,
-0.3343550265,
-0.4969103932,
0.3857660294,
0.2469866127,
0.1770062447,
-0.1142940149,
0.2903587818,
0.819796145,
-0.1988178343,
0.1386346966,
0.6466858387,
0.2323514521,
-0.2213307023,
0.9723526835,
0.1794351339,
0.0975657776,
0.5296669602,
0.2468558252,
-0.0109803854,
-0.7171221972,
-0.2958230972,
0.3667793572,
-0.3747753799,
-0.4076204896,
-0.2757041752,
-0.2135628462,
-0.326421231,
-0.4406508803,
-0.8099661469,
-0.3216580749,
-0.1702507138,
0.1666718423,
0.3552641571,
0.4553087056,
0.237977013,
0.5448420644,
-0.6204326749,
0.5161215663,
0.2081428766,
0.7316608429,
-0.3113816977,
-0.8854626417,
-0.3819238544,
-0.007924946,
-0.1619735211,
-0.4182214439,
0.0749852285,
0.8919624686,
0.5306481719,
0.0483047739,
0.0843935311,
1.0435373783,
-0.783424139,
0.6614772677,
-0.0227735229,
-0.9776981473,
0.6551369429,
-0.3280670047,
0.4207103252,
0.6334717274,
0.2562520802,
-0.2275911123,
-0.2914904356,
-0.3555998504,
-0.8693386912,
0.5230869651,
0.007758372,
0.3673577905,
0.3079965711,
0.6163442135,
0.4756689072,
-0.0331330895,
-0.5367819667,
-0.0009434015,
-0.148760289,
-0.1591840237,
-0.3922230303,
-0.1776789576,
-0.053312514,
-0.3215857446,
0.7037642598,
-0.3506344855,
0.1191568375,
0.0626306236,
-0.3557857871,
-0.4050574899,
0.3416182995,
0.5537435412,
0.600071907,
-0.0505521819,
0.0887674764,
0.7127569914,
-0.5060825944,
0.1576918066,
0.133495003,
-0.1510867327,
-0.202553615,
0.3675802946,
0.9703612328,
0.533608377,
-0.4754360914,
0.4395677149,
-0.0263000671,
-0.3262389898,
-0.2556137145,
0.4305049181,
0.0825944543,
0.5400002003,
0.2602995634,
0.2697502077,
-0.0135371834,
-0.2085463107,
0.266569674,
0.2504725158,
-0.4283391237,
-0.396839112,
0.3739810586,
0.0703274161,
-0.4066509008,
0.2201351076,
0.1965621263,
-0.188381061,
0.2049881667,
0.6826122403,
0.8405836821,
-0.391435653,
0.1772325188,
0.2172591686,
0.2760665715,
-0.4516191185,
-0.1523562521,
-0.2030782551,
-0.5938293338,
-0.8234314919,
-1.1139423847,
-0.1839825958,
0.1156721562,
-0.4559943974,
0.2913503647,
-0.3828957677,
-0.321634084,
0.081591107,
-0.0277214795,
-0.7195391059,
0.056228891,
0.1380002499,
1.3351317644,
-1.1491143703,
0.9125860333,
0.8460317254,
0.0890530124,
-0.703733027,
-0.0030921826,
-0.5901100636,
-0.6372268796,
0.1346284449,
-0.1805475801,
-0.1850440949,
0.3389895558,
-0.2689217925,
-0.8621050119,
0.9017354846,
0.8722787499,
-0.695299685,
-0.133135885,
0.0579001196,
0.6392803788,
-0.2155472785,
-0.0000823701,
0.9733963609,
0.5227596164,
-0.0493044145,
-1.3822102547,
-0.0021111665,
-0.1111358181,
0.1274507195,
0.3764724731,
-0.7593297362,
0.6068191528,
0.188268885,
-0.0152044995,
-0.1349306554,
0.5417961478,
-0.0291806478,
-0.0533516929,
0.7695992589,
0.4450523257,
0.5522373319,
-0.1905753314,
0.5420024395,
-0.1033064127,
0.7029474378,
1.0357636213,
0.0165226776,
0.9118785858,
0.3969199061,
-0.2500518262,
0.3478755057,
0.6710445881,
-0.0686712861,
0.7155271173,
-0.0161908809,
-0.0758929551,
-0.585237205,
0.0810611844,
-0.3495419919,
0.3384350538,
0.2830856144,
-0.0673398376,
-0.3381332159,
0.2487481385,
-0.1114993989,
-0.1117355749,
-0.4736923575,
1.0608922243,
0.0409571007,
-0.7869939804,
0.9464459419,
-0.010135523,
0.6446762681,
-0.6030113697,
0.0724312738,
-0.195110783,
0.4191247821,
-0.1981141567,
-0.6099811792,
0.2215705812,
-0.1365869939,
-0.099802576,
-0.234355852,
0.960688591,
-0.474072367,
-0.4289676249,
0.2130740583,
0.264492929,
-0.1623647064,
-0.3455589414,
-0.7112457752,
-0.0103311101,
0.0190851763,
-0.8074766994,
0.5007776618,
0.4430218041,
-0.0900618881,
0.5742913485,
0.6009787917,
0.2494521141,
-0.1121838391,
0.1200940236,
1.084751606,
-0.5478820801,
-0.4505122602,
-0.6822217703,
0.7124419212,
0.2185473442,
-0.2861922979,
0.4498818815,
0.2950592339,
0.8165398836,
-0.2866283059,
0.4968605638,
0.1034260169,
0.3993132412,
-0.5331990123,
0.6341172457,
-0.516387403,
0.0223083217,
-0.3080417812,
-1.319909215,
-0.4325849712,
0.7349693775,
-0.4670034349,
-0.048623275,
0.4912558198,
0.8895909786,
-0.5254337192,
0.0004999337,
0.3061231077,
0.3719407618,
0.1199177131,
0.4966218472,
0.4815955758,
-0.38376531,
0.3507122993,
-0.334949553,
-0.5963338614,
-0.1975955069,
-0.950922668,
-0.9392752051,
-0.6732507944,
-0.3205236793,
-0.0655865148,
0.2568125725,
0.6938303709,
0.8327944875,
-1.1068439484,
0.0173853599,
0.005741125,
-0.2221122831,
-0.380943805,
-0.1495619863,
0.5339577794,
-0.3500576317,
-0.4821956158,
0.4528001547,
0.3919787109,
-0.2452008277,
0.0137468595,
0.0152941551,
0.083748661,
0.0364233367,
0.7235056758,
0.137563467,
-0.3517450094,
-0.6899241209,
-0.0388044789,
0.2660602331,
0.0831418335,
0.900936842,
-0.6537222862,
0.0924979076,
0.4938514233,
0.5964218378,
0.8185831308,
0.1292468011,
0.5332252383,
-0.803165853,
0.2594583631,
0.1145898402,
0.2834604383,
0.0953187048,
-0.2543142438,
0.4005967975,
-0.0113580804,
-0.7245847583,
-0.8604778051,
0.1729834527,
-0.963163197,
-0.3005429208,
1.0217735767,
-0.1162714735,
-0.3142418861,
-0.1756641269,
-0.4279806614,
0.3122744858,
-0.2539895773,
0.8189783692,
0.4348788559,
-0.1105511487,
-0.2630892694,
-0.3861274421,
0.527585566,
0.2937028706,
-0.5178099871,
0.3695628345,
0.102218315,
0.5513827801,
0.138117522,
0.6596938372,
0.1838215888,
0.1808996797,
-0.183218509,
-0.3273904324,
-0.0545008294,
-0.4419359267,
-0.3436629772,
0.3487882018,
0.2979459763,
0.2953475714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00200v1
|
In-Context Learning with Long-Context Models: An In-Depth Exploration
| 2024-04-30T21:06:52 | 2024-04-30T21:06:52 |
Amanda Bertsch, Maor Ivgi, Uri Alon, Jonathan Berant, Matthew R. Gormley, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As model context lengths continue to increase, the number of demonstrations
that can be provided in-context approaches the size of entire training
datasets. We study the behavior of in-context learning (ICL) at this extreme
scale on multiple datasets and models. We show that, for many datasets with
large label spaces, performance continues to increase with hundreds or
thousands of demonstrations. We contrast this with example retrieval and
finetuning: example retrieval shows excellent performance at low context
lengths but has diminished gains with more demonstrations; finetuning is more
data hungry than ICL but can sometimes exceed long-context ICL performance with
additional data. We use this ICL setting as a testbed to study several
properties of both in-context learning and long-context models. We show that
long-context ICL is less sensitive to random input shuffling than short-context
ICL, that grouping of same-label examples can negatively impact performance,
and that the performance boosts we see do not arise from cumulative gain from
encoding many examples together. We conclude that although long-context ICL can
be surprisingly effective, most of this gain comes from attending back to
similar examples rather than task learning.
|
[
-0.485080421,
-0.7945920825,
0.4678210914,
0.1706828177,
-0.2650969028,
-0.1856935173,
-0.3791052401,
-0.7325076461,
-0.429831475,
0.210302189,
-0.2696618736,
-0.2643755376,
-0.4255189598,
-0.0821813345,
-0.6137180328,
1.1722887754,
-0.0242525619,
0.0723147914,
-0.7055077553,
-0.4773956537,
-0.3574303091,
-0.814827621,
-0.6995562911,
-0.5727324486,
0.5649525523,
0.5986489654,
0.2726550698,
0.5541333556,
0.2191011459,
0.1184064969,
-0.1259395629,
0.0153777078,
-0.875326395,
0.1189933196,
-0.1148969308,
-0.149309054,
0.0024769024,
-0.0087125078,
1.0485142469,
0.9054251909,
0.1857154816,
0.1451039612,
0.3885000944,
0.6272284985,
-0.5305322409,
0.0068875207,
-0.192275092,
0.0630754903,
-0.2127353549,
0.1177916676,
-0.5942141414,
0.0175298564,
0.4844496548,
-0.4558338225,
-0.0247134604,
0.0993100107,
0.3081835806,
0.0792256817,
-0.8196100593,
-0.4333176613,
-0.7835851312,
0.9088289142,
-0.5594245791,
0.4798889756,
0.335596472,
0.3832886219,
-0.0639027506,
-0.8566274643,
-0.272251457,
-0.4416890442,
0.0010576672,
-0.0664171502,
0.1529262066,
0.0433008783,
0.7576722503,
0.1291362494,
-0.3124265373,
0.4988000393,
-0.3917768598,
0.2854638994,
0.5545859337,
0.099834092,
-0.1901128143,
0.30235672,
-0.6131873727,
-0.3758474588,
-0.9757241607,
0.5328002572,
-0.0209997036,
0.2496621311,
-0.0825096369,
0.2966394722,
-0.2007304281,
0.8462710977,
-0.0628013313,
-0.1909026504,
0.1050653756,
-0.1366903484,
-0.326796025,
0.0962056816,
0.3426799476,
0.3382302523,
-0.1109068021,
-0.2824486196,
-0.3531607091,
-0.3969093561,
-0.0909202173,
-1.0772864819,
0.0262685362,
0.0285621807,
-0.4833854735,
-0.0795789659,
0.0607470348,
-0.6071763635,
-0.3938195407,
-0.689262569,
0.7895715833,
-0.4852129817,
0.1376535445,
0.2275068313,
-0.2442694604,
0.3050061166,
0.2433780283,
-0.6523428559,
0.695092082,
0.7231459618,
0.7600944638,
-0.4707871377,
-0.49727121,
-0.6991303563,
0.1038631126,
-0.3196268082,
0.3968115151,
-0.6009445786,
-0.4729819894,
0.0044562439,
-0.0989038646,
0.112926878,
-0.8349789977,
0.0903543532,
-0.67342031,
0.0526766106,
-0.3567436934,
-0.9674658775,
-0.1403000057,
0.2145648748,
-0.5863742828,
1.0692461729,
0.0833187476,
-0.3901077807,
0.8955059052,
-1.0050388575,
-0.6524222493,
-0.1246633604,
-0.2310450673,
-0.3699479401,
0.0731427744,
-0.0824396759,
0.8105629086,
-0.1366490275,
0.2681255937,
-0.5154761672,
-0.7953647971,
0.4550823569,
-0.4227396548,
0.5765926838,
0.0298465751,
-0.4059284329,
-0.0425899215,
-0.7051109076,
-0.1023563519,
-0.1179187894,
-0.5125622749,
-0.5916569829,
0.1137364134,
0.0592177659,
0.3842859268,
-0.0887314752,
-0.5473122597,
0.3450015783,
-0.0759164989,
0.5082201958,
0.5758469105,
0.0392041579,
0.4897081554,
-0.2935802937,
0.1463603079,
0.338453263,
0.143138051,
-0.1761160493,
-0.0009531943,
-0.5107928514,
-0.2113845646,
0.328638792,
-0.0873633474,
-0.5804615617,
0.0275266282,
-0.2876580656,
-0.0949121565,
0.0013344702,
0.0945840031,
0.4406379759,
0.7360851169,
0.5802205801,
-0.2744435072,
-0.0798447207,
-0.9609856009,
-0.1264999211,
0.3480873704,
-0.1246403903,
0.624984324,
0.8099717498,
-0.0983194485,
0.9960574508,
-0.2666480541,
0.0507865809,
-0.1147040874,
0.0951692089,
0.1356268674,
0.5004429221,
0.6094488502,
-0.911852777,
-0.561438024,
-0.0347251892,
-0.6318271756,
0.4037869275,
-0.2173969895,
0.1134062707,
0.0802661777,
0.7055186629,
-0.1785857677,
0.4823556542,
0.1707476079,
-0.1358554512,
0.3741260767,
-0.2315933406,
-0.2413981855,
-0.8330149055,
-0.1493503451,
0.1421062499,
-0.243300736,
-0.6864467859,
0.1865221858,
0.4093647301,
-0.0665693134,
-0.7010178566,
0.6943194866,
-0.2507175505,
-0.4159304798,
-0.1751639843,
-0.0836773962,
0.0108854799,
0.5185306668,
0.0679265782,
0.8556320667,
0.7784652114,
-0.8937098384,
0.1636631787,
-0.1205100715,
-0.8406985998,
0.3981122971,
-0.4835793674,
0.148994714,
-0.2009731531,
0.7617703676,
-0.8130269051,
-0.4582965672,
-0.2458310574,
0.1997341514,
0.5967839956,
0.0028073178,
-0.5951288342,
-0.3548118174,
-0.2303365469,
0.7638098598,
0.4245684743,
-1.1744164228,
0.0504756197,
0.0675908849,
0.4271973073,
-0.5961124897,
-0.603800416,
-0.0889926627,
-0.7589232922,
-0.2144260257,
0.3561736643,
-0.2972274423,
-0.2308826298,
-0.4956683815,
-0.0720427632,
-0.0723907426,
0.2025876343,
0.2532311678,
-0.2552564442,
-0.1898892671,
0.6360114217,
-0.0045780637,
0.3655371964,
0.1098363698,
-0.4838018715,
0.2974398136,
-0.3009569645,
-0.3120050728,
-0.3324376643,
0.7154844999,
0.575492084,
0.0705999658,
0.7314853072,
0.277651459,
-0.4057364464,
-0.4456392527,
-0.2612458169,
-0.3209312558,
-0.4248113036,
0.5610906482,
-0.5476580262,
-0.7362445593,
0.44709903,
-0.2900959849,
0.1008481532,
0.129342556,
0.1882604808,
-0.4245975316,
1.1376934052,
0.7816547155,
-0.1734369993,
0.6793627739,
-0.6786010265,
-0.0980715528,
-0.9719358087,
-0.218188718,
-0.1678843498,
-0.6880654693,
-0.2760337591,
-0.2452180237,
0.4953148365,
0.1488804817,
-0.5766002536,
0.0832997784,
-0.1589229107,
0.8604987264,
0.5655178428,
0.5140161514,
0.0430682339,
-0.0031107971,
0.0784131065,
0.0701550469,
-0.8972380161,
-0.108772926,
1.0150862932,
0.3460362852,
0.7921686172,
0.047843121,
0.6010285616,
0.0228362028,
0.3859021962,
-0.8190952539,
0.288566798,
-0.2004729211,
-0.4973255396,
-0.5456198454,
-0.1748716086,
-0.8052746654,
0.1142139509,
0.0549343899,
-0.5519459844,
0.3766634762,
0.1698003411,
-0.3850246072,
0.3725727201,
-0.5975699425,
0.7908995748,
-0.3873006403,
-0.60533005,
-0.2093634754,
-0.9186171889,
0.2077966034,
-0.0579646342,
0.0398437306,
0.388576597,
0.0013385528,
0.7249482274,
-0.0545291863,
0.9600899816,
-0.1452529132,
0.0603547134,
0.139209941,
-0.0897348076,
0.4544668198,
0.1244136244,
-0.0591955036,
-0.1622301489,
-0.1709396243,
-0.5155732632,
-0.7221027613,
0.8145019412,
-0.7827340961,
-0.240802452,
-0.0844408497,
-0.5619616508,
-0.3600029051,
-0.0069153165,
0.4513985515,
1.0458441973,
-0.1231706738,
0.8981927633,
1.0168139935,
-0.0349804349,
0.5901814699,
0.1258202642,
-0.1135625243,
0.0849699974,
0.8223292232,
0.3479694128,
0.6003465652,
0.5056804419,
0.2295566648,
-0.3789742291,
-0.4412167966,
-0.4442441761,
-0.100518167,
-0.9107462168,
-0.0647123456,
-0.5263147354,
-0.0358939096,
-0.0538286567,
-0.3030856848,
-0.1464368999,
-0.3250285983,
-0.3919761181,
-0.1083325595,
0.1271952093,
0.8307961822,
0.0934531018,
0.3998026848,
-0.252589792,
0.0495682992,
0.607876122,
0.5057458878,
0.4102189243,
-0.5392611027,
-0.6830022335,
0.131955862,
-0.4131711721,
-0.5032058954,
0.0663004965,
0.4317037165,
0.3563765287,
0.6375964284,
-0.0610262528,
0.9935382605,
-0.3800937235,
0.7635112405,
-0.069139801,
-0.6836069226,
0.0844549388,
-0.2443794012,
0.5331192613,
0.5077416301,
0.6562376022,
-0.51784724,
-0.0356262811,
-0.5867195725,
-0.8036620021,
0.7170130014,
-0.2566981316,
0.2396018505,
0.09119571,
0.5820960999,
0.4250187278,
0.0636439547,
-0.7766546011,
-0.069385156,
-0.1494300514,
0.1388376653,
-0.3572306931,
-0.310978204,
-0.333586365,
-0.5131328106,
0.4247208536,
-0.3273328841,
0.1753991544,
0.0834458247,
-0.3325573802,
0.3215102851,
0.1345686466,
0.8216680884,
0.8118938208,
-0.1647786945,
0.116441451,
0.457868427,
-0.0077007608,
-0.0243620444,
-0.1581330895,
0.1841060072,
-0.4222606122,
0.3604212403,
1.02684021,
0.6815078259,
-0.6308715343,
0.5786864758,
0.0269356612,
-0.2742470503,
-0.3921031654,
-0.0165648106,
-0.0562725998,
0.3534135818,
0.4086221457,
-0.2038727403,
0.4433374107,
-0.7780328989,
0.2518938482,
0.3642208874,
-0.5618265867,
-0.0968818665,
0.5226736069,
-0.2227092385,
-0.120797269,
0.984495461,
0.0494185202,
-0.2758420408,
1.001842618,
0.877959609,
0.500897944,
0.3531822264,
-0.1749262512,
0.1889541,
-0.352358073,
-0.2075404823,
-0.228300631,
-0.7065358758,
-0.3125265241,
-0.3754843473,
-0.2318983078,
-0.4409291148,
0.3383225799,
-0.9477279186,
0.2538820207,
-0.1537948996,
0.0605037771,
-0.072215043,
0.0283923913,
-0.795132041,
0.207920298,
0.1452686191,
1.0270383358,
-0.7431544065,
1.0765846968,
0.6114711761,
0.022670893,
-0.5702475905,
-0.0516208224,
-0.2718089819,
-0.30241099,
0.8879842162,
0.5715410709,
0.0863749087,
-0.1818399727,
-0.9183921218,
-0.8329477906,
1.304240942,
-0.0434907638,
-0.4967823327,
-0.0862757564,
0.0913990512,
0.6372510791,
-0.6724386215,
0.0814754888,
0.5277252197,
0.0828218013,
-0.0384694189,
-0.6306263208,
-0.2516100705,
0.2375525981,
-0.0634093583,
0.1139858142,
-0.8459671736,
0.8200505376,
-0.1114042699,
0.0212555621,
-0.0065524331,
0.7278138399,
0.3102691174,
0.6769662499,
0.5449021459,
0.2708231211,
0.5873912573,
0.1861282438,
1.2595020533,
-0.0060736388,
0.3583524823,
1.2960436344,
-0.320374161,
0.7400236726,
0.5096543431,
0.0892618373,
0.3352632821,
0.8459675312,
0.205458045,
0.6691127419,
0.2155372947,
-0.2677167356,
-0.2760928869,
0.0217236355,
-0.3569221497,
0.3570080996,
0.592084229,
-0.376460135,
-0.2443584949,
0.7711906433,
-0.2801613212,
-0.1484161615,
-0.3497136235,
0.6876783371,
0.1509575695,
-0.4917308092,
0.5025319457,
-0.3880162537,
0.5572573543,
-0.409850359,
-0.1640972048,
-0.219661653,
0.205620721,
0.1804733574,
-0.7407799363,
-0.164605394,
-0.3339689672,
-0.4302678108,
-0.4306047857,
0.3012151718,
-0.470700711,
-0.1317069381,
0.3599445224,
0.1170604825,
0.3560495079,
0.1480118483,
-0.3668674231,
-0.2474428564,
-0.305113852,
-0.3932279348,
0.9434586763,
0.4034767151,
-0.4305848181,
0.7235869765,
0.3677031398,
-0.4287562966,
0.1873809397,
-0.1081614122,
1.0011835098,
-0.546985805,
-0.3845597804,
-0.833774209,
0.2578973472,
-0.2698979974,
-0.4299041331,
0.5698833466,
0.8399323225,
1.3230686188,
-0.0853327587,
0.4742730856,
0.097168006,
0.2996222973,
-0.5714123249,
0.4496854842,
-0.7887842655,
-0.0218140054,
0.0529965423,
-0.7073021531,
-0.2950401306,
0.3206063509,
-0.2913539112,
0.0099603897,
0.5510901213,
0.383109659,
-0.4741708934,
0.0606519319,
0.5567491055,
0.1917401403,
0.3934035003,
0.6820133328,
0.9761299491,
-0.2556558251,
0.1652831435,
-0.563710928,
-0.1903448403,
-0.3328601122,
-0.8157804608,
-0.9090510011,
-0.7812324166,
-0.0425850488,
-0.0200277027,
0.0096341008,
0.9179082513,
1.0008219481,
-0.5126237869,
-0.5919877887,
0.2535839379,
-0.045028545,
-0.4719748795,
-0.2314030975,
0.5019408464,
-0.2227054983,
-0.7061352134,
0.6576627493,
-0.0111034485,
0.1280061007,
-0.0929253474,
0.0231911857,
-0.0718601644,
-0.2280288488,
1.0998610258,
0.4643929899,
-0.4741639197,
-0.3828043044,
-0.1578868181,
-0.0654725805,
0.1223484352,
0.9343295693,
-1.0193574429,
0.4751812816,
0.243029356,
0.6195598841,
0.9382475019,
0.0307258517,
0.2989349961,
-0.8837285638,
0.1875256598,
0.2427739352,
0.2674908936,
0.0454490259,
-0.2906042039,
0.3591991365,
-0.2923308015,
-0.8761891723,
-1.0233547688,
0.1827618182,
-0.7302005291,
-0.4825879335,
1.1205788851,
-0.0117822578,
-0.0557916723,
0.0361962318,
-0.0218703039,
0.0615020134,
-0.3328775465,
0.7521005273,
0.8335471153,
-0.6235914826,
0.280662179,
-0.8489698172,
0.6084702015,
0.333024323,
-0.3856540024,
0.1077712327,
0.5009403825,
0.2724184096,
-0.134961307,
0.2409137487,
0.0697328746,
0.2857199013,
-0.3555166721,
-0.4437299669,
-0.0941365585,
-0.8089718819,
-0.7444391251,
0.2088917196,
-0.0290008914,
-0.0483776145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00175v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00175v1
|
Towards a Search Engine for Machines: Unified Ranking for Multiple Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T19:51:37 | 2024-04-30T19:51:37 |
Alireza Salemi, Hamed Zamani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper introduces uRAG--a framework with a unified retrieval engine that
serves multiple downstream retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems. Each
RAG system consumes the retrieval results for a unique purpose, such as
open-domain question answering, fact verification, entity linking, and relation
extraction. We introduce a generic training guideline that standardizes the
communication between the search engine and the downstream RAG systems that
engage in optimizing the retrieval model. This lays the groundwork for us to
build a large-scale experimentation ecosystem consisting of 18 RAG systems that
engage in training and 18 unknown RAG systems that use the uRAG as the new
users of the search engine. Using this experimentation ecosystem, we answer a
number of fundamental research questions that improve our understanding of
promises and challenges in developing search engines for machines.
|
[
-0.6971805096,
-0.4708793163,
0.7257997394,
0.0177903101,
0.1151233017,
0.1460406184,
-0.06840837,
-0.2513555586,
0.0069252187,
0.621581018,
-0.4629769325,
-0.2622604072,
-0.3431370556,
0.1097055823,
-0.5289022923,
1.0005928278,
0.1495250165,
-0.0311926939,
-0.1680255085,
-0.1968445182,
-0.3979048133,
-0.7449647784,
-0.6181265116,
-0.2828392684,
0.928184092,
0.3846897483,
0.6629253626,
0.4146976173,
0.6378920674,
0.2673998177,
0.0211181231,
0.3264386952,
-0.6602886915,
0.6059080958,
-0.4994234443,
-0.3660469055,
-0.1458799988,
0.0771251246,
0.8378216028,
0.7564722896,
-0.2011570036,
0.4434705973,
0.1232697815,
0.6206394434,
-1.0259283781,
-0.3243401945,
-0.7965907454,
-0.2734443247,
-0.2616523802,
-0.1805348545,
-0.7027651668,
-0.0812740698,
-0.2110159993,
-0.6350431442,
0.1884581745,
0.4075825214,
0.8269348145,
0.1686830223,
-0.4665791392,
-0.1636010855,
-0.7173762918,
0.7948858738,
-0.2944741845,
0.5995290279,
0.1857856512,
0.4259653389,
-0.4855127037,
-0.9902384281,
-0.2542497814,
0.0618189611,
-0.1012304127,
-0.1837553233,
0.0582677983,
0.0263053291,
0.0265556388,
0.1803746819,
-0.7175486088,
0.0453275107,
-0.220243752,
0.0249374304,
0.7470401525,
0.084945783,
0.3271152079,
0.1590713859,
-0.2844472826,
-0.0156340282,
-0.6700373292,
-0.1876797527,
0.3879197836,
0.4667925239,
0.4889245033,
0.6224914789,
-0.1633789241,
0.5890173912,
-0.1977622509,
0.0161746722,
0.1661863774,
-0.0065885354,
-0.3617595732,
-0.098285228,
0.5126674175,
-0.0906735137,
0.0087846136,
-0.5437973738,
-0.5401358008,
-0.1138774231,
0.8672001958,
-0.6770427823,
0.1019993499,
0.0633169711,
-0.3907435834,
-0.4180953503,
0.1995670795,
-0.8981521726,
-0.3318409622,
-0.3293085098,
0.7884001136,
-0.0117233675,
-0.2088748068,
-0.0180919059,
-0.5145244002,
0.2595898509,
0.1538185775,
-0.7288146019,
0.3639144599,
0.7199639082,
0.4227696657,
-0.0310303587,
-0.5651738048,
-0.6971763372,
0.3617331684,
-0.3832512796,
1.0076365471,
-0.8395499587,
-0.6363967657,
0.057906203,
0.0438819006,
-0.1858688742,
-0.4461035728,
0.6924817562,
-0.9522403479,
0.393943876,
-0.0841999128,
-0.5153326988,
-0.3110599816,
0.0383001417,
-0.6066406369,
1.0818347931,
-0.1549044251,
-0.6683602333,
0.0835738406,
-1.0025492907,
-0.3206543326,
0.2031741738,
-0.1115919873,
-0.1837723255,
0.3013979495,
0.1105574295,
0.1755609661,
-0.5805394053,
0.2956531048,
-0.4513566792,
-0.5614750981,
-0.1014449894,
-0.2330453694,
0.7887757421,
0.331004113,
-0.2899020314,
0.0366333164,
-0.512212038,
0.4522701204,
0.1752191037,
-0.6296824813,
-0.4704243839,
0.0018982596,
0.2730485201,
-0.2024178356,
0.5182333589,
-0.3354772925,
0.5844059587,
0.0558637194,
0.1596051306,
0.8417721391,
-0.1328234673,
0.4227484763,
-0.0279134307,
0.4210748971,
-0.5130771995,
0.0378747657,
-0.3350738883,
-0.5752837062,
-0.7859712243,
-0.125795424,
0.7880052328,
0.2508532703,
-0.3451310098,
0.2827110291,
-0.1564454883,
-0.3539123237,
-0.8352569342,
0.1658380032,
0.3886585534,
0.180035606,
0.2477579117,
-0.1314237565,
-0.8670924902,
-0.8843060732,
-0.2392345071,
-0.0385505371,
-0.31582582,
0.4801806211,
0.562715292,
-0.726631701,
0.8376415968,
-0.3577294648,
-0.1794293225,
-0.0180654265,
0.435144037,
-0.014927485,
0.3263230324,
0.1167068481,
-1.2873883247,
-0.2644880414,
0.1378901154,
-1.0161914825,
0.0489810891,
0.6300689578,
-0.2671658695,
0.4103646874,
0.5386225581,
-0.3099470735,
0.382035315,
0.5929484963,
0.0074722422,
0.5134724379,
-0.1926826239,
0.3278949857,
-0.8548611999,
0.6777451634,
-0.3979125917,
-0.1400745213,
-0.3302431703,
0.6762689352,
-0.133680582,
-0.3673149943,
-0.2517291903,
0.8101522923,
-0.2940088511,
-0.3722208142,
-0.3773011863,
0.1515006423,
0.011003565,
0.3744380474,
-0.3284676969,
1.1867916584,
0.4053220153,
-0.8124457598,
0.1436190456,
0.0268021263,
0.1758949906,
0.566103518,
-0.6553193331,
0.4419545829,
-0.1313707978,
0.1569935381,
-0.9833647609,
-0.4909099042,
-0.3613583446,
-0.6886256933,
0.1773191392,
-0.2480551153,
-0.6572317481,
-0.5390261412,
-0.0561887547,
0.3187823296,
0.5793653131,
-0.7844014764,
0.6326721907,
0.8402003646,
0.1161724329,
-0.690523386,
-0.049865745,
0.1092553884,
-0.2549809217,
-0.649698019,
0.2577224672,
-0.0643341467,
-0.0311871022,
0.2463250458,
-0.0188466646,
-0.4927597046,
0.3624872863,
0.2443848997,
0.1480856389,
-0.2000852525,
0.5455776453,
-0.1905614585,
-0.1514743865,
-0.1282611787,
-0.4761889279,
0.6429567933,
-0.2299818695,
-0.3654605448,
-0.0827913508,
0.5182715654,
0.450871706,
-0.463572681,
0.4687051475,
0.729775548,
-0.4528381228,
0.0093767196,
-0.6288540959,
-0.1091684774,
-0.4853385091,
0.1181501821,
-0.6322152615,
-1.1447833776,
0.3596596718,
-0.3339524567,
0.2436913401,
0.7702636719,
0.4819458425,
-0.3153885901,
1.6812787056,
1.0121005774,
-0.1122612432,
-0.0799246505,
-0.1099686921,
0.1321610957,
-1.2087743282,
-0.2797035575,
-1.1523996592,
-0.4407818317,
-0.8698449731,
-0.1499931961,
0.4270341992,
0.3276160657,
-0.641149044,
0.2887341976,
-0.7632542253,
0.4557959139,
0.8904391527,
-0.2772831917,
0.3465464115,
0.0849709436,
-0.5078505874,
0.1167961434,
-0.6284086704,
-0.5690815449,
1.2149119377,
-0.0765298232,
0.8440183997,
0.1130540669,
0.859215796,
0.4563013613,
0.3292399049,
-0.4492589831,
0.3878673911,
-0.1394271702,
-1.3290787935,
-0.4741599262,
-0.3328999281,
-1.4832702875,
0.5416588783,
0.0429270789,
-0.8054066896,
-0.0968797877,
-0.2526234388,
0.1377127916,
0.4209047854,
-0.5160335302,
0.7134168148,
-0.2936652005,
-0.1516750902,
-0.3682717085,
-0.4444296956,
0.3222224414,
0.029627353,
0.260163933,
0.177158311,
-0.1107054576,
0.6472435594,
0.0915542617,
0.4029763639,
0.0071271835,
0.125443846,
0.2999191582,
-0.0828931034,
0.2244685739,
0.0647103861,
-0.0314511582,
-0.1219284683,
-0.2320308685,
-0.5362002254,
-0.5446622372,
0.8240555525,
-0.7604064941,
-0.5728006959,
-0.4167971015,
-0.3948712945,
-0.1379690915,
0.6323972344,
0.0256151147,
0.2067483664,
-0.3875232637,
0.4456802905,
0.9310560226,
-0.046194803,
0.2082126141,
0.4967221618,
-0.7076530457,
-0.2548490763,
0.9561549425,
-0.206277743,
-0.2106996775,
0.3893956542,
0.0292679463,
-0.3558648527,
-0.0374649465,
-0.4329392314,
0.1553625166,
-0.4985587299,
-0.1224099398,
-0.6540127993,
-0.3293757439,
-0.510692358,
-0.0976630077,
-0.3988445997,
-0.0566272959,
-0.0923246145,
0.408765763,
0.1349764317,
1.1827909946,
-0.1194692478,
0.1100693196,
-0.751486361,
0.2739426196,
0.5831890702,
0.567085743,
-0.0987356603,
-0.472923547,
-0.3205081224,
0.1428298801,
-0.6280393004,
-0.5375952125,
0.0813380554,
-0.0416422971,
0.9558216333,
0.1283960938,
-0.2324481905,
0.6497662663,
-0.8239999413,
0.5600847006,
-0.0286725145,
-0.6858995557,
0.5138956904,
-0.3715907633,
0.0226036701,
0.6034775376,
0.6907619834,
-0.6192703843,
-0.0499727875,
-0.8514907956,
-0.690250814,
0.4699645638,
0.0518266894,
0.0677368045,
0.3650871217,
0.2561583221,
-0.0684482828,
0.4892693758,
-0.2724758089,
-0.3398784399,
0.3063653409,
0.1570869535,
-0.0080948854,
-0.087848708,
-0.2889886498,
-0.0747993439,
0.835635066,
-0.1097019762,
0.4099709094,
-0.0254748985,
-0.1114006266,
-0.1834259182,
0.3313619494,
0.2573949397,
0.6099716425,
-0.2941996455,
0.0775225759,
-0.1494443864,
-0.2298225462,
0.4056440592,
0.1438939869,
-0.1665742397,
0.0835597441,
-0.1043079272,
0.5213359594,
0.3629037738,
-0.718393445,
0.0677993819,
-0.1822620779,
-0.095998019,
-0.1073145419,
0.1413466781,
0.1933516413,
0.0288370978,
0.6590277553,
-0.1041260287,
0.53992486,
-0.5253727436,
0.4338144064,
0.5604770184,
-0.4458947182,
-0.1182191223,
0.7213429809,
0.3638450503,
-0.617247045,
0.7358081341,
-0.3568001986,
-0.57388556,
0.2492627054,
0.3153829873,
1.0402591228,
-0.3159096241,
0.173105076,
0.1953525543,
0.2824067473,
-0.1996415406,
-0.0327180438,
0.1758015901,
-0.3580569923,
-0.4964162707,
-0.8036804199,
-0.5659543276,
0.3485651314,
-0.6339145899,
0.3009175956,
-0.0725781098,
-0.0611108951,
0.2807358205,
0.0569495112,
-0.6883069873,
0.1659270972,
0.099035345,
0.7724470496,
-0.2384184897,
0.7009869218,
1.1875914335,
-0.7149299383,
-0.6246404648,
-0.1660308391,
-0.084617883,
-0.8202257752,
0.7250663042,
0.2597725689,
-0.2065436691,
0.1672071517,
-0.814442277,
-0.9718635678,
0.9338347316,
0.3186791241,
-0.2049645782,
-0.3553593457,
-0.2877549529,
0.3356493115,
-0.5615087748,
0.2545131445,
0.2807664573,
0.6191678643,
-0.1826533377,
-0.9623884559,
-0.3704530895,
-0.2988896966,
0.1631881148,
0.4079416096,
-0.474131763,
0.7066841722,
-0.2071681172,
-0.2515476942,
0.3429463208,
0.3584554791,
0.3465393782,
0.3786258996,
0.4238855243,
0.8543695807,
0.7378848791,
0.0627058744,
1.1961585283,
-0.0855352208,
0.6015540361,
0.9770261049,
-0.3910008669,
1.0934957266,
0.3602741659,
-0.2762465179,
0.5890454054,
0.5031318069,
0.1810794622,
0.2488180399,
0.2773930132,
-0.1955661327,
-0.3693188131,
-0.3254562616,
-0.4330474734,
0.5005159378,
0.1101127192,
-0.3023598194,
-0.4778556526,
-0.0471494049,
-0.1781008393,
0.1055836156,
-0.2398585379,
0.761257112,
-0.1829610467,
-0.6527153254,
0.7138503194,
0.0653804913,
0.564386189,
-0.3297660947,
-0.0627534986,
-0.0819426253,
0.1345934719,
-0.0160272699,
-0.5841601491,
-0.0661754161,
-0.0069361203,
-0.449298054,
0.0467084683,
0.8169761896,
-0.1294250339,
-0.5337843299,
0.3753855526,
0.4786939323,
0.3702109754,
-0.253918618,
-0.7841915488,
0.2236844152,
-0.0820524469,
-0.3213181496,
0.7168554664,
0.5446541905,
0.0675492212,
0.6831738949,
0.6524047256,
-0.3224422932,
0.0949663669,
0.0027054483,
0.8620816469,
-0.6484962106,
-0.2222100943,
-0.3338969052,
0.474786967,
-0.0429017693,
-0.0893384069,
0.697350502,
0.6370529532,
0.9873229861,
0.2724358141,
1.0131214857,
-0.2034457475,
0.6904759407,
-0.0511097312,
0.7505691648,
-1.0429145098,
-0.2017273009,
0.0907419026,
-1.1513205767,
0.0000261121,
0.4208424091,
0.3213275671,
0.2467490733,
0.651804924,
0.5955986977,
-0.1894185841,
-0.0582240373,
0.4712460339,
-0.1137017012,
0.371974647,
0.1590375751,
0.5848286152,
-0.5761261582,
0.7501007915,
0.0503304973,
-0.0434452072,
-0.3871497214,
-0.5083027482,
-0.5941400528,
-0.7432386875,
0.2650944293,
-0.2208418101,
0.4733872414,
0.4415570498,
0.6992062926,
-0.5795958042,
-0.5573300719,
0.0010360691,
0.2862318754,
0.0694758818,
-0.2607399523,
0.0424221642,
-1.1208667755,
-0.8547734618,
0.4097165465,
0.2528068125,
-0.3910994232,
-0.6616284847,
-0.17624259,
-0.7058089375,
-0.0659998506,
0.4645732343,
0.4323568642,
-0.5819712877,
-0.1292059124,
0.1482907087,
-0.2117204666,
-0.0931065902,
0.999489665,
-0.9374255538,
0.5734925866,
0.3324202299,
1.0984765291,
0.2738567889,
-0.03479065,
0.5314242244,
-0.6624296904,
-0.0355013832,
0.0625784397,
0.0729526281,
0.2577981949,
-0.1407981515,
0.8343704939,
0.1047529653,
-1.1238951683,
-1.0991746187,
0.1998486221,
-0.3854341209,
-0.3118524253,
1.1475939751,
0.1008596122,
-0.2090138942,
0.0224905629,
-0.1174295396,
0.1166998744,
-0.5366494656,
0.6713055968,
0.4620146751,
0.0830923095,
0.3183733523,
-0.8729300499,
0.3016107678,
0.3040374815,
-0.7407736182,
-0.1166933924,
0.3291970491,
0.1348819882,
0.5392668843,
0.3407321572,
-0.1264493167,
0.364387095,
-0.129471615,
0.4027720094,
0.3116328418,
-0.652174294,
-0.2641023397,
0.2677969933,
0.1514356136,
-0.1898888499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00155v1
|
HistNERo: Historical Named Entity Recognition for the Romanian Language
| 2024-04-30T19:05:22 | 2024-04-30T19:05:22 |
Andrei-Marius Avram, Andreea Iuga, George-Vlad Manolache, Vlad-Cristian Matei, Răzvan-Gabriel Micliuş, Vlad-Andrei Muntean, Manuel-Petru Sorlescu, Dragoş-Andrei Şerban, Adrian-Dinu Urse, Vasile Păiş, Dumitru-Clementin Cercel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work introduces HistNERo, the first Romanian corpus for Named Entity
Recognition (NER) in historical newspapers. The dataset contains 323k tokens of
text, covering more than half of the 19th century (i.e., 1817) until the late
part of the 20th century (i.e., 1990). Eight native Romanian speakers annotated
the dataset with five named entities. The samples belong to one of the
following four historical regions of Romania, namely Bessarabia, Moldavia,
Transylvania, and Wallachia. We employed this proposed dataset to perform
several experiments for NER using Romanian pre-trained language models. Our
results show that the best model achieved a strict F1-score of 55.69%. Also, by
reducing the discrepancies between regions through a novel domain adaption
technique, we improved the performance on this corpus to a strict F1-score of
66.80%, representing an absolute gain of more than 10%.
|
[
-0.3287922144,
-0.4364713728,
0.4661601782,
0.0552772172,
-0.1280472726,
-0.0883259475,
-0.4808044732,
-0.5263850093,
0.6621342301,
0.5365777612,
-0.2450625449,
-0.4209779501,
-0.7035884261,
0.5554907322,
-0.4634499848,
1.0241892338,
0.0589915439,
0.353269428,
0.3619784713,
-0.2175886035,
-0.2026568949,
-0.7079430819,
-0.6348822713,
0.0107961325,
0.4823273718,
0.3693352044,
0.1907680482,
0.6815788746,
0.7511970401,
0.4552178681,
-0.3162123859,
-0.1052729338,
-0.3935253024,
0.0177444704,
-0.2838709354,
-0.5352782607,
-0.2792441845,
-0.2480866909,
1.021802783,
0.2593980432,
0.0045745862,
0.0631198063,
-0.4034905136,
0.6862011552,
-0.473698318,
0.0806600377,
-0.8927202225,
-0.0340908654,
-0.5098150969,
-0.5680145621,
-0.6203849912,
-0.1897216737,
0.220321402,
-0.5118017197,
0.2220952809,
0.2231458277,
1.5286551714,
0.1964618862,
-0.3624123931,
-0.2769764364,
-0.8197209835,
0.8133541346,
-0.4047346115,
0.5466385484,
0.3858554661,
0.5505547523,
-0.610591054,
-0.688182354,
-0.4977131188,
-0.1593357325,
-0.0988868624,
0.0337803327,
-0.7175903916,
-0.5410407782,
0.1400288045,
0.3789527416,
-0.5543752909,
0.2703438401,
-0.7691393495,
-0.4317899942,
0.2700321376,
0.0493886098,
-0.085229747,
-0.4700293839,
-0.6244796515,
0.2412365377,
-0.8092750907,
-0.1576225907,
0.602540493,
0.414573282,
0.2407547385,
0.5561696887,
-0.3266169727,
0.75066185,
0.0633521751,
-0.3049780726,
0.2754100859,
-0.2509158254,
-0.2707745433,
0.3009996414,
0.654294908,
-0.1610383242,
0.3947800696,
-0.3997311592,
-0.0487068444,
-0.1792179048,
0.2405337244,
-0.7066380382,
-0.1185386851,
-0.0770643726,
-0.281432122,
-0.1932673007,
0.0899941251,
-0.7338415384,
0.0716178343,
-0.2978217602,
0.0073749772,
-0.6056464911,
-0.1576675028,
-0.1630432606,
-0.1124967262,
0.3178212643,
0.5225758553,
-0.6977844238,
0.3623271585,
0.7034682035,
0.5638813376,
-0.0842323676,
-0.4529464543,
-0.7278096676,
0.0738549605,
-0.1686894447,
1.0813981295,
-0.6826627254,
-0.1188750938,
-0.2306287587,
0.4589624405,
0.1976408213,
-0.3230242431,
0.7098867893,
-0.8027809858,
0.5292130709,
0.1124258488,
-0.8999488354,
-0.276101619,
0.2194053084,
-0.8641891479,
0.9724880457,
0.1314763874,
-0.9147775173,
0.5361353755,
-0.0876581073,
-0.2856850922,
0.354562521,
-0.2344210595,
-0.2891531885,
-0.0245654657,
-0.0927780196,
0.4177546501,
-0.2167054266,
0.4125109017,
0.1993296295,
0.1245811284,
0.2360936254,
-0.200304836,
0.803538084,
0.0572112612,
-0.3578189611,
-0.0133358566,
-0.9247583151,
-0.2484296262,
-0.1700692624,
-0.5155447125,
-0.5767193437,
-0.2303868234,
0.2819743752,
0.0498785153,
0.1505743563,
-0.5229167342,
-0.0523653664,
-0.296965301,
0.3111336231,
0.5441692472,
-0.1862173229,
0.5352117419,
-0.1202956587,
0.4145731628,
0.1136528179,
-0.3607263267,
-0.2232588679,
-0.6196758151,
-0.847661376,
-0.3573886454,
1.0391700268,
0.6908714771,
-0.534899354,
0.744413197,
-0.5168343782,
-0.5435783863,
-0.3108566105,
-0.157047838,
0.1992591769,
0.8832607269,
0.348954916,
-0.2130514085,
-1.0032451153,
-0.9520079494,
0.1867011786,
-0.2896568179,
0.1168240085,
0.449953109,
0.9657357335,
-0.1639361829,
0.8503086567,
-0.3341042399,
-0.7235867381,
-0.0802924186,
-0.0480069295,
0.1311586797,
0.5311431885,
0.5005178452,
-0.7585939765,
-0.0725883767,
0.1248023435,
-0.5526838303,
0.5134156346,
0.1015189365,
-0.4135619402,
0.6729394794,
0.4904506803,
-0.0954573825,
0.3564586937,
0.6870269179,
-0.4173495471,
0.5603752136,
-0.4101507664,
0.2796487212,
-1.5243763924,
0.2776684463,
0.18995139,
-0.5073816776,
-0.5876731277,
-0.1475787163,
0.0461581126,
0.0029089262,
-0.6403313279,
0.6164274812,
-0.6412879825,
0.1614401042,
-0.1622760445,
0.3587277234,
-0.3315072358,
0.2547449172,
0.5425240993,
0.4964325726,
0.5987766385,
-0.5625404716,
0.2849031687,
0.437364459,
-0.3890818655,
0.8117289543,
-0.4495455325,
0.0622335523,
-0.3495160341,
0.062555097,
-0.5361688733,
-0.1590214521,
0.1505399495,
-0.7399666309,
0.3673975468,
-0.6639789343,
-0.2199154496,
-0.0056000068,
0.2647388577,
0.06672097,
0.1091980562,
-0.5184210539,
0.6554152369,
0.6953622699,
-0.1144399941,
-0.633756578,
-0.6584384441,
0.6215205193,
-0.5615429282,
-0.6251085997,
0.5683518648,
0.103370972,
-0.0314691849,
0.1182169542,
0.142852664,
-0.7010267973,
-0.1755558103,
0.017216865,
0.4259026647,
-0.6677253246,
0.2797510326,
-0.3366506696,
-0.5410138965,
-0.6162108779,
-0.1369620264,
0.5115984678,
-0.3568372428,
0.5775182843,
-0.7830832005,
0.1342258751,
0.0482766517,
-0.3820435405,
0.648866117,
0.330604136,
-0.8008372784,
0.1622189432,
-0.6427339911,
-0.1130995899,
-0.375303179,
0.0625605732,
-0.7945381403,
-0.9489367604,
0.3947411776,
-0.0830240175,
-0.3151285648,
0.5588222742,
0.4902153611,
0.0875482112,
0.0700490624,
0.7198429108,
-0.5193273425,
0.6128844023,
-0.2142624855,
-0.0080391504,
-0.7492465973,
0.0390763246,
-1.0354489088,
-0.1728962809,
-1.0997610092,
-0.2565559745,
-0.1860703826,
-0.1815269291,
0.2106053382,
1.0440130234,
-0.2376341075,
0.3440597355,
0.5634063482,
-0.2072926313,
0.5519670248,
0.0137323495,
0.4440331757,
-0.4553354681,
-0.3574817777,
-1.0074347258,
0.7927163243,
0.1802826226,
0.5950116515,
0.3575559556,
1.1578172445,
0.0308817569,
0.1277004629,
-0.8190075159,
0.2865692675,
-0.3026950061,
-0.8912596107,
-0.5258154273,
-0.5727334619,
-1.3901172876,
0.0909337029,
-0.3436976969,
-0.8306959867,
0.4340468645,
0.0565374047,
-0.260500282,
0.0373106189,
-0.3116445243,
0.8161532879,
-0.1914438158,
-0.050366614,
-0.1038697064,
-0.3382497728,
0.0844956487,
0.2134863436,
0.037168134,
-0.1871606112,
-0.050602939,
0.8554037213,
-0.0787781626,
0.3202216029,
0.2104980499,
0.3280913532,
0.1014197171,
0.1420935839,
0.4602477252,
0.2681985795,
-0.2870042622,
0.1687202454,
0.1880536079,
-0.3162695765,
-0.3420010209,
0.9227206707,
-0.3787657022,
-0.2429791391,
-0.7369679809,
-0.0550468452,
0.5038825274,
0.6635846496,
0.3964487612,
0.684843421,
-0.6707735062,
0.3290075064,
0.5070151687,
0.2056646198,
0.4432597756,
0.7970976233,
0.0822581872,
-0.4288170934,
0.9961539507,
0.2184275985,
-0.4889933467,
0.6172623634,
0.0879913867,
0.0198841281,
-0.5453208685,
-0.8561897874,
0.26919958,
-0.5498888493,
-0.3232806921,
-0.6123592854,
0.0775637031,
-0.2479329109,
0.083091177,
-0.4774455726,
-0.5764388442,
-0.6929260492,
-0.0743149668,
0.3326380253,
0.5694010258,
0.370859772,
0.4119846523,
-0.5807647109,
0.0404021703,
-0.2685339451,
0.2495048195,
-0.5221772194,
-0.6154907942,
0.0480003878,
-0.3494316936,
0.1453579217,
-1.1436305046,
0.6902419925,
0.2970310152,
0.7516867518,
0.4158304036,
-0.2014779299,
0.5794571042,
-0.8358127475,
0.2314866334,
-0.1249225289,
-0.7508029342,
0.6273853779,
-0.0241731144,
-0.0699040666,
0.8035293818,
0.8231803179,
-0.4621906579,
-0.1715147495,
-0.9259417057,
-0.7203504443,
0.6383177638,
0.3331288993,
0.0124932313,
0.0013959548,
0.3126137853,
0.1792086661,
0.1239746064,
-0.7011185884,
-0.2805478275,
0.1568275839,
-0.1090447456,
-0.070363842,
-0.111260049,
0.0178244263,
-0.0323060192,
0.8522980809,
-0.0497281961,
0.2734119296,
0.2100996971,
-0.7067112923,
0.2123602331,
0.4658273757,
0.7958617806,
0.7625572681,
-0.0659255236,
0.2433474958,
0.1770463586,
-0.2348766476,
-0.0579575785,
0.1257184297,
-0.1698839217,
0.5209538937,
0.2801007926,
1.0317976475,
0.3563518822,
-0.4093073606,
0.4315142632,
-0.3624438643,
0.1272028387,
-1.0801044703,
-0.1356475353,
-0.1409387738,
0.2041699886,
0.4474145472,
-0.0199963469,
0.2369924337,
-0.5238662958,
0.4300276041,
0.1426295787,
-0.7445940971,
-0.3851788342,
0.31800735,
0.1243721917,
-0.6036166549,
0.6735312343,
-0.3717028201,
-0.5494781137,
0.6388667226,
0.4410112202,
0.6422939301,
-0.3391694427,
0.2316414714,
0.8568671346,
0.3911536634,
-0.0262147021,
0.1089907214,
0.0484761037,
-0.8985420465,
0.0148346238,
-0.7189858556,
-0.1918485761,
-0.0041868342,
-0.5684353709,
0.7805249691,
-0.3177493215,
-0.4263002574,
0.5207307339,
-0.0125913564,
-0.7676519752,
0.3220362663,
-0.0003461481,
0.9579365253,
-0.5486745238,
0.9748407006,
0.6513728499,
-0.4961906374,
-0.2719808221,
-0.2309688032,
-0.0211503357,
-0.6236463785,
1.0237988234,
0.0037375565,
-0.0633655563,
0.3099328876,
0.0061489535,
-1.2069967985,
0.8700281978,
0.0417915247,
-0.7489024997,
-0.0125049567,
-0.3281246424,
0.7628028989,
-0.6909486055,
0.378995508,
0.6443721652,
0.6382525563,
0.0414599143,
-0.9141352177,
-0.1252881736,
-0.1691654176,
-0.0217365455,
0.4898725152,
-0.4010726213,
0.3748105466,
-0.2703666091,
-0.4417524636,
0.3723138869,
1.0435119867,
-0.0576084405,
0.0762163848,
0.3498311937,
0.5894696116,
1.0495305061,
-0.5044436455,
0.8479382396,
-0.4379805923,
0.1396659762,
1.1595740318,
-0.0962509438,
1.1582514048,
0.6554291844,
-0.1572929919,
0.6386401653,
0.5862257481,
-0.2307801247,
0.3759468198,
0.3232218027,
-0.1535537541,
0.0900494233,
-0.0207210872,
-0.2199031413,
0.9751962423,
0.1612176299,
-0.4440403283,
-0.1313485503,
-0.0994771495,
0.4062381387,
-0.0321217291,
-0.0365284458,
0.8811450005,
-0.1192817241,
-0.5229019523,
0.3421829045,
0.1158356443,
0.7478920221,
-0.5071545839,
0.12005312,
-0.1772308946,
0.1888254434,
-0.1996191442,
-0.4943780899,
0.3566077054,
0.049488768,
-0.2737229466,
0.1689866334,
0.3535574675,
-0.4559754133,
-0.764431119,
0.3269878626,
0.3648825586,
0.5659429431,
0.1730272919,
-0.1745864898,
-0.2560025752,
-0.1755526364,
-0.2227038592,
-0.0453053489,
0.4886193275,
-0.2932192981,
0.4017702043,
0.4680875838,
0.2441532463,
0.2596945465,
-0.0430346988,
0.5145307779,
-1.1127712727,
-0.543397963,
-0.6613999009,
0.2649458051,
-0.1074503064,
-0.8703021407,
0.5866663456,
0.8373773694,
1.0401395559,
0.0912156403,
0.5350176692,
-0.1966274232,
0.5141533017,
-0.4082683921,
0.581633687,
-0.3970566094,
-0.3012804389,
-0.3728956282,
-0.7556761503,
-0.3971627951,
0.5691921711,
-0.3094069362,
-0.3164585233,
0.8042937517,
0.8468437791,
0.192503944,
0.0030369202,
0.3514208794,
0.1162900478,
0.0871406794,
0.3203246891,
0.7460712194,
-0.6228367686,
0.6821561456,
-0.4024402499,
-0.2265920341,
-0.3011241853,
-1.0528533459,
-0.7294047475,
-0.9837589264,
-0.3228130043,
-0.3001975715,
0.3057513237,
0.7859205008,
0.6222646832,
-1.1936680079,
-0.3090312779,
0.1481863558,
0.052051276,
0.1216815338,
-0.1108176634,
0.383920759,
-0.1565046161,
-1.0863637924,
0.5890178084,
0.1716918945,
0.1711383909,
-0.0842867196,
-0.1881840378,
-0.4201118946,
-0.4372643828,
0.4611314535,
0.3650511503,
-0.6179098487,
-0.2908078432,
0.2429420203,
-0.199400425,
0.5278701186,
0.9962128401,
-0.8495098352,
0.3646551073,
0.8047921658,
0.503205061,
0.7032063007,
-0.0563280396,
0.424136728,
-0.4087482691,
0.4809748828,
0.3226351142,
0.7973491549,
0.5955847502,
-0.4926340282,
0.4821430743,
0.220024392,
-0.488050878,
-0.6333862543,
-0.0440509208,
-0.97212255,
-0.0420752652,
0.8215228915,
-0.1201401725,
-0.569042325,
-0.2276664376,
-0.1722263843,
0.2270212471,
-0.7246252298,
0.8061566353,
0.7293762565,
-0.0672756657,
-0.2081235796,
-0.659809649,
0.3912673593,
0.1776397228,
-0.8483706117,
-0.5158587098,
0.5634298325,
0.4052745402,
0.3636296988,
0.6725308299,
-0.117147781,
0.2920077145,
-0.1315792501,
0.1582977772,
0.2028919756,
-0.7038109303,
-0.475640744,
-0.0389312133,
-0.0318633541,
-0.0273783226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00134v1
|
Transforming Dutch: Debiasing Dutch Coreference Resolution Systems for Non-binary Pronouns
| 2024-04-30T18:31:19 | 2024-04-30T18:31:19 |
Goya van Boven, Yupei Du, Dong Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Gender-neutral pronouns are increasingly being introduced across Western
languages. Recent evaluations have however demonstrated that English NLP
systems are unable to correctly process gender-neutral pronouns, with the risk
of erasing and misgendering non-binary individuals. This paper examines a Dutch
coreference resolution system's performance on gender-neutral pronouns,
specifically hen and die. In Dutch, these pronouns were only introduced in
2016, compared to the longstanding existence of singular they in English. We
additionally compare two debiasing techniques for coreference resolution
systems in non-binary contexts: Counterfactual Data Augmentation (CDA) and
delexicalisation. Moreover, because pronoun performance can be hard to
interpret from a general evaluation metric like LEA, we introduce an innovative
evaluation metric, the pronoun score, which directly represents the portion of
correctly processed pronouns. Our results reveal diminished performance on
gender-neutral pronouns compared to gendered counterparts. Nevertheless,
although delexicalisation fails to yield improvements, CDA substantially
reduces the performance gap between gendered and gender-neutral pronouns. We
further show that CDA remains effective in low-resource settings, in which a
limited set of debiasing documents is used. This efficacy extends to previously
unseen neopronouns, which are currently infrequently used but may gain
popularity in the future, underscoring the viability of effective debiasing
with minimal resources and low computational costs.
|
[
-0.5154423118,
-0.6414344907,
0.2529094815,
0.234391138,
-0.3839524686,
-0.0676268116,
-0.3795751631,
-0.8822512031,
0.2089327276,
0.3647124767,
-0.2480492443,
-0.492285192,
-0.7928462625,
0.5664502978,
-0.211691618,
0.6778408289,
0.2873520553,
0.1425174326,
-0.2914382815,
-0.1919470727,
-0.7426971793,
-0.5152787566,
-0.059639208,
-0.5318658352,
0.2709550261,
0.7123827934,
1.2072256804,
0.2980154753,
0.6094051003,
0.3019378483,
-0.1750098914,
0.2485923916,
-0.3079935312,
0.2660103142,
-0.3492343724,
-0.2490426153,
-0.3364621997,
0.2730999589,
0.2961930931,
1.0720704794,
0.3339710832,
0.1103490889,
0.074140057,
0.7736049891,
-1.0281015635,
0.0684021637,
-0.4749755859,
0.1877174079,
0.1001582965,
0.0284215901,
-0.3610741496,
-0.457111001,
0.2854015529,
-0.5611997843,
0.2638059258,
-0.1531698406,
0.6146417856,
0.0933113843,
-0.2435053587,
-0.2946137488,
-1.104798317,
1.1525915861,
-0.4972504079,
0.1800260395,
0.5155094862,
0.2236465067,
-0.0762268007,
-0.0561246946,
-0.4234707952,
-0.2623384297,
-0.0704976171,
0.0974277705,
-0.6430539489,
-0.071145989,
0.0813859031,
0.2212191671,
-0.3672885597,
0.2413556725,
-0.2988224924,
-0.1508948654,
0.5743838549,
-0.2254414856,
0.0402042754,
-0.4016410112,
-0.1243542805,
-0.0055953506,
-0.5045531392,
-0.1897270977,
0.7066342831,
0.6995936632,
0.1953924596,
0.7639629245,
0.1091671661,
0.3585836291,
0.557405293,
-0.0124309715,
0.3946909606,
-0.1410335749,
-0.1507371217,
0.2809413671,
0.5260189772,
0.800194025,
0.3777369261,
-0.2526134253,
-0.1443510503,
0.4540475607,
0.1782761812,
-0.5462636948,
-0.111236766,
0.1729239821,
-0.4116791189,
-0.1006297395,
0.0339075141,
-0.4337507188,
-0.4344525933,
-0.4754556417,
0.3398513198,
-0.6476141214,
-0.4507193863,
0.2247252613,
-0.2557917237,
0.1137172431,
0.4509624541,
-0.5847885609,
0.125510633,
0.5641949773,
0.6321378946,
-0.0534084737,
0.125399068,
-0.3625606596,
-0.1889782548,
-0.6699320078,
0.5855769515,
-0.8192129135,
-0.7406321168,
0.0553704165,
0.0092258044,
0.2133465409,
-0.9242163897,
0.3366732001,
-0.2564487755,
0.2452764064,
-0.4966142178,
-0.2512962222,
-0.2035981715,
0.2851632237,
-0.7219483852,
1.0446271896,
-0.0656123757,
-0.7847882509,
0.5767623782,
-0.3505801857,
-0.2780497372,
-0.1540924609,
0.071797505,
-0.0476209335,
0.1813174933,
0.1980153024,
0.5021014214,
-0.4388559461,
0.2376597375,
-0.2842460871,
-0.4628965855,
-0.0110525489,
-0.2227528542,
0.8556066155,
-0.2628795505,
-0.2796596587,
-0.0209293738,
-0.8795180917,
-0.1967108548,
-0.2536409497,
0.0931944549,
-0.8368442655,
-0.2404370606,
0.0119363703,
0.3087494969,
0.2600632012,
-0.7637828588,
0.0222321246,
-0.5010221004,
0.0951984972,
0.5383586287,
-0.2504546344,
0.6934082508,
-0.1154171899,
0.4381555021,
0.3463251293,
0.3245352507,
0.2491003722,
-0.461191088,
-0.7730075121,
-0.0785886496,
0.5096535683,
0.6547628045,
-0.8331961036,
0.8133479357,
-0.0765176266,
-0.7097607255,
-0.4266414046,
0.0320351236,
0.3912731707,
0.5240897536,
0.7364402413,
-0.3057028055,
-1.0013971329,
-1.384295702,
-0.2056471556,
-0.5903384686,
-0.0039592488,
0.0305615384,
0.6721484661,
-0.2892900109,
0.9542196393,
0.0240056254,
-0.3319330215,
-0.1383463293,
0.3784327507,
0.5242263675,
0.6625606418,
0.8558942676,
-0.6610274911,
-0.2422467619,
-0.193212375,
-0.5750464201,
-0.1804579645,
-0.0316021182,
0.0645190626,
0.265732199,
0.143693924,
-0.238458693,
0.5128499269,
0.5066755414,
-0.5357523561,
0.9753597379,
-0.1469280571,
0.0720858946,
-0.5507207513,
0.2019925565,
-0.0666218847,
-0.4481889606,
-0.2919037044,
-0.3228590488,
-0.160637483,
0.2699047923,
-0.5415549278,
0.2851134539,
-0.4683964252,
-0.1311194301,
-0.295625329,
0.142401278,
0.0334991664,
0.045575019,
0.0984202698,
0.684245646,
0.3791962862,
-0.7901847363,
0.2632887959,
0.3467703164,
-0.2904098928,
0.9676691294,
-0.6009346843,
0.1374050528,
-0.3303443491,
-0.075902991,
-0.9620710611,
0.516913116,
0.1831883639,
-0.1873927414,
0.0926040486,
-0.0380602628,
-0.4556154609,
-0.338375181,
-0.4467113912,
0.280116111,
0.322974503,
-0.3592951298,
0.4589240253,
0.3221756816,
0.1236070618,
-1.1877501011,
-0.9253928065,
0.4723514616,
0.1393365413,
-0.3275533915,
0.4925403595,
0.0657636672,
-0.6222419143,
0.2655277848,
-0.2001796216,
0.0841494277,
-0.0660776645,
0.3469464183,
0.0967929885,
0.0150241824,
0.1960856318,
0.1379573643,
-0.4900692701,
0.034164276,
-0.1225579977,
0.2042996287,
-0.1169844046,
-0.1208691821,
-0.2779787779,
0.712230742,
0.3736815155,
0.1632389277,
0.7044556141,
0.4311490357,
-0.3497629762,
-0.1058866829,
-0.7828953266,
-0.2340691686,
-0.3477158248,
0.0665771663,
-0.4566299021,
-0.5943539143,
0.7061603069,
0.0533845536,
0.2339306474,
0.7114229798,
0.3795919716,
-0.2038483918,
0.6200844049,
0.6789070964,
0.4475032687,
0.2731975913,
-0.2356828004,
0.1717063636,
-0.6027849317,
0.0003175202,
-0.6065369844,
-0.7073864341,
-0.7748064995,
-0.5952082872,
0.1292969733,
0.3219748437,
-0.1147668958,
0.6080114841,
-0.471894145,
0.4405234754,
0.6150746942,
0.1187706366,
0.4810920656,
-0.4352784455,
-0.1536117196,
-0.5617697239,
-0.4422931671,
-0.7870574594,
0.8333441615,
0.0180179402,
0.4452417195,
0.0819123387,
0.5311967134,
0.7038753629,
0.2060116827,
-0.6334633231,
0.6612657309,
-0.7019664049,
-0.6158434749,
-0.1694853604,
-0.1781922132,
-0.8220248222,
0.279812783,
-0.3049299121,
-0.3772760034,
1.1070976257,
-0.0461393707,
-0.1585693061,
0.3885861337,
-0.436573267,
0.5055301189,
0.1695593745,
-0.2990401387,
-0.2191917449,
-0.6361873746,
0.2443324625,
-0.0055865585,
0.0110064633,
-0.4665499628,
-0.1639911532,
0.8486507535,
-0.4564175904,
1.2581986189,
-0.4513269067,
-0.3975120783,
0.2989489138,
0.4006679654,
0.2503591478,
-0.0122933816,
-0.5055475235,
0.6343457103,
0.136105597,
-0.2614552379,
-0.5693161488,
0.6048948765,
-0.8173469305,
-0.5083305836,
-0.4187704921,
-0.2674586475,
-0.2274967432,
0.0904288739,
0.0459241793,
-0.0267753303,
-0.476998806,
0.3699044287,
0.3232071698,
-0.342344135,
0.4309539199,
0.6555572748,
-0.0488811545,
-0.4867777824,
0.2711774111,
0.5649123192,
-0.067499809,
0.3199293613,
0.2705854774,
-0.4275419116,
-0.1625164449,
-0.2021567971,
0.0602758862,
-0.941753149,
-0.3973354399,
-0.6499260068,
0.2522930801,
-0.3873024285,
-0.2376360893,
-0.7128337622,
-0.7614609599,
-0.3164690435,
-0.186310187,
0.1916614622,
0.3923248053,
-0.7480436563,
0.0246379264,
-0.5531484485,
0.4497550428,
0.380222708,
0.0180716403,
-0.399538219,
-0.471961081,
-0.0073079597,
-0.1449480206,
-0.0119766369,
-1.0902520418,
0.1627251357,
0.1677443832,
0.1975840628,
0.3247693777,
0.5528841615,
0.7588187456,
-0.300005585,
0.8059856296,
0.2922544479,
-1.1675214767,
0.5041563511,
-0.1101360843,
0.1555561721,
0.8190008998,
0.2654154599,
-0.6078940034,
-0.323273629,
-0.4925288856,
-1.0100913048,
0.3711157441,
0.0946753845,
0.2343261838,
-0.2750329375,
0.5631011724,
0.8448990583,
0.2467579246,
-0.3748930097,
-0.3990112245,
-0.1560181379,
0.3032221198,
-0.0136778299,
-0.6153481007,
0.0350608565,
-0.3325436711,
0.8124274611,
-0.1815276891,
0.2556587458,
0.3467314243,
-0.2212256789,
-0.1995180994,
0.4093430936,
0.2104766667,
0.7550576329,
-0.2733779848,
0.2843973339,
0.0341015197,
-0.3313180208,
0.4580868781,
-0.1764309406,
-0.4086532295,
0.5732699037,
0.5409527421,
0.463034153,
0.4428475499,
-0.2750630081,
0.5376060009,
0.094380632,
-0.4278509319,
-0.3904493451,
-0.1507970542,
-0.3012128174,
0.1671864092,
0.3233420849,
0.2522121966,
0.0626288801,
-0.3903579116,
0.0614455119,
0.3308687508,
-0.5218115449,
-0.4824520648,
0.3736120462,
0.4115023315,
0.0487434082,
0.4145385027,
-0.2123971581,
-0.2281869799,
0.4189271629,
0.5430192351,
1.1876022816,
-0.3685961962,
0.5534585118,
0.5572907329,
0.5686510205,
-0.0433277711,
0.6088611484,
-0.044224523,
-1.0157117844,
-0.7759357691,
-0.3439907134,
-0.5959416032,
0.0020092574,
-0.770150125,
0.2272081971,
-0.3425309956,
-0.5459270477,
-0.1473823041,
0.1811718494,
-0.9174186587,
0.1747239381,
0.0979198813,
0.7331309915,
-1.0434525013,
0.3681616783,
0.8821418881,
-0.1701159924,
0.1200741753,
-0.4151099324,
-0.2168369889,
-0.423748076,
1.0383988619,
0.3169974983,
-0.4012008607,
-0.4458260238,
-0.2053364962,
-0.5387861133,
0.5208835006,
0.7636187077,
-0.9103754163,
-0.0131678795,
0.3833105266,
0.6641049981,
-0.1343680918,
0.519754529,
0.499951154,
1.0274909735,
-0.3478448987,
-1.1846530437,
0.0234656557,
-0.2126114815,
0.0538477674,
-0.1534035057,
-0.3519459069,
0.6691665649,
-0.1215028837,
-0.3717719018,
-0.2047935724,
0.7292383909,
-0.2509083748,
0.0112496139,
0.8764349818,
0.3715553284,
0.7468741536,
-0.0687076077,
0.6732305884,
-0.1242865324,
0.042947609,
1.060572505,
-0.4520214796,
0.6415349841,
0.7211150527,
-0.1896907389,
0.6258176565,
0.314535439,
0.2513056397,
0.2507818937,
0.1106182858,
0.0493707098,
-0.7111582756,
-0.4079483449,
-0.2047167867,
0.8230654001,
0.304102242,
-0.2356538326,
-0.4200796783,
0.3948144913,
-0.1983882487,
0.4400771856,
-0.1110565141,
0.7259762287,
-0.0403582901,
-0.3088965714,
0.6885992885,
-0.0008043504,
0.8233084083,
-0.2600183785,
-0.1225219369,
-0.0442360751,
0.2378539294,
-0.1959564835,
-0.6219178438,
0.6894985437,
-0.0124817854,
-0.6809716821,
-0.2958212197,
0.6570019126,
-0.1705483347,
-0.6059913635,
0.7437067032,
0.8502457738,
0.106136322,
-0.2090519965,
-0.7987318635,
-0.1362959594,
-0.2610794008,
-0.1538006514,
-0.1111033857,
0.4648686647,
-0.1894490272,
0.3274514675,
0.4517171383,
0.2275416404,
-0.3408212364,
0.1217125505,
0.6323475242,
-0.8495298028,
-0.3865923285,
-0.760094583,
0.1611711234,
0.056481503,
-0.4748269022,
0.8027690649,
0.4634349644,
0.7594273686,
-0.126934126,
0.5973570943,
-0.063510187,
0.5960489511,
-0.0509793386,
0.2405693382,
-0.1982131451,
0.1795824617,
-0.3720580339,
-1.2378972769,
-0.7154218554,
0.5828456879,
-0.6310179234,
-0.0577427298,
0.3420468271,
0.5121139884,
0.1084769964,
0.0278795268,
0.6264202595,
0.2294366807,
0.2696790695,
0.3751192689,
0.7859989405,
-0.6141517758,
0.3571074009,
-0.6404516697,
-0.0746057555,
-0.3789956868,
-1.1312556267,
-0.821792841,
-0.5052093267,
-0.6534676552,
-0.2746277452,
0.3124680817,
1.0110890865,
0.613363862,
-1.0329833031,
0.1166372672,
0.1732829809,
0.1312952489,
-0.7058832645,
-0.2195831835,
0.3573484719,
-0.2248017937,
-1.032245636,
0.5761112571,
0.2419801652,
-0.2931629717,
-0.5665789247,
0.147366479,
-0.2241193354,
-0.0325845815,
0.6662119031,
0.096119307,
-0.6556816697,
-0.4562844038,
-0.2363037914,
0.0511362962,
0.1733276248,
0.7854401469,
-1.0070793629,
0.6112505198,
0.7441982031,
0.38181144,
-0.0731614009,
-0.0173633099,
0.6425142884,
-0.9071255326,
0.3217929304,
0.5768313408,
0.2524116337,
0.5332949758,
-0.3557798266,
0.4834147096,
0.3654486239,
-0.2073929012,
-0.7738053203,
0.084419623,
-0.6522603035,
-0.4038811624,
1.0872327089,
0.0410100743,
-0.2268399894,
-0.6561303735,
-0.1451191008,
0.1569861919,
-0.4343182147,
0.6877008677,
0.5939007401,
-0.0275002196,
0.1786921322,
-0.3407207131,
0.2117146701,
0.6306765676,
-0.107837826,
0.2460376173,
0.5128769875,
-0.022782987,
0.6880564094,
0.2479049116,
-0.2443355769,
0.3677554429,
-0.0587387271,
0.4161925912,
-0.2346611619,
-0.3119747043,
-0.1306316406,
0.2423371822,
-0.254337281,
-0.3082899153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00123v1
|
Graph Neural Network Approach to Semantic Type Detection in Tables
| 2024-04-30T18:17:44 | 2024-04-30T18:17:44 |
Ehsan Hoseinzade, Ke Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This study addresses the challenge of detecting semantic column types in
relational tables, a key task in many real-world applications. While language
models like BERT have improved prediction accuracy, their token input
constraints limit the simultaneous processing of intra-table and inter-table
information. We propose a novel approach using Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) to
model intra-table dependencies, allowing language models to focus on
inter-table information. Our proposed method not only outperforms existing
state-of-the-art algorithms but also offers novel insights into the utility and
functionality of various GNN types for semantic type detection. The code is
available at https://github.com/hoseinzadeehsan/GAIT
|
[
-0.1233939156,
-0.7168341875,
0.5995400548,
-0.1168099269,
-0.3875209987,
-0.0353231244,
0.2929507196,
-0.6385111213,
0.5101976991,
0.4497831762,
-0.463253051,
-0.8003794551,
-0.7089225054,
-0.0492531955,
-0.7372450233,
0.7551006675,
-0.0929588825,
0.3032093346,
-0.640183866,
-0.2869210541,
-0.3339070678,
-0.4740374982,
-0.4174056053,
-0.4283742011,
0.6192162633,
0.3916559219,
0.824193418,
0.5927894711,
0.6277726889,
0.2997051179,
-0.0412331298,
0.1810585111,
-0.1310830563,
0.0324124582,
0.2736062109,
-0.2672426403,
-0.2678608298,
-0.4090172648,
0.6946524382,
0.5913461447,
0.1729852855,
0.0124991061,
-0.0863999203,
0.5743895173,
-0.3509304225,
0.7937918901,
-0.8537656069,
0.4819045067,
-0.4461604059,
0.1090312302,
-0.5209792852,
-0.3938604295,
0.1389390677,
-0.3741715848,
0.1856606454,
0.2684469521,
0.9138048291,
-0.1707024425,
-0.4811602831,
-0.2815072834,
-0.4830836654,
-0.1123958528,
-0.8106365204,
0.6640089154,
0.228274405,
0.0956560075,
-0.4458893239,
-1.0624181032,
-0.8736000061,
-0.6997885108,
-0.6266227365,
-0.2223397791,
-0.0746959597,
0.3190522492,
0.0471929982,
0.12871629,
-0.8410729766,
0.1148646101,
-0.0270273127,
-0.3249333799,
0.0274867825,
0.2114716321,
0.8868610859,
-0.1404576302,
-0.1581625193,
0.2971487939,
-0.5792730451,
0.0704299659,
0.3171138763,
0.6118311286,
0.1158000529,
0.5260926485,
-0.3741566539,
1.0947868824,
-0.4395281672,
0.2585383356,
0.0531763472,
-0.4003990591,
-0.0199551471,
0.0035047396,
0.6886311769,
0.062505126,
0.4160826206,
-0.774929285,
0.0652015284,
0.3277333379,
0.0656664595,
-0.5535050631,
-0.5356298685,
-0.0609640218,
-0.3300528824,
-0.4559983909,
-0.2101380974,
-0.6731618643,
-0.5633118749,
-0.3987525105,
0.585424602,
-0.5081606507,
-0.2083576322,
-0.1070342511,
-0.125900358,
0.1998507231,
0.2278981656,
-1.1369200945,
0.4326745272,
0.66018641,
1.1456713676,
-0.0219822917,
-0.1546569318,
-0.7568150759,
0.3671903312,
-0.1897126734,
0.8010939956,
-0.6105282307,
-0.2505362034,
0.1534209996,
-0.280071497,
-0.1533060372,
-0.3974749446,
0.2842859328,
-0.6486171484,
-0.1019262373,
-0.1893503964,
-0.6362762451,
-0.28883183,
0.3351235986,
-0.9563477635,
0.9269860387,
0.475530237,
-1.0293362141,
0.7740705609,
-0.6179394126,
-0.6019655466,
0.2789711356,
-0.4944951236,
-0.6900832653,
0.0374003164,
0.1624631733,
0.3309670687,
-0.0082855821,
0.2910760939,
-0.8123340011,
-0.358027041,
0.0984118581,
0.2716868222,
0.5581097007,
-0.3087955117,
0.0472964793,
0.6312520504,
-0.9610982537,
0.2379657328,
0.1212320849,
-0.2263520509,
-0.1963932812,
0.1711668968,
-0.1948677748,
0.6002776623,
-0.1643394083,
-0.639465332,
0.2656395435,
-0.1792378873,
0.7171714306,
0.5202908516,
-0.2594254315,
0.2330102324,
0.0842037797,
0.1729908139,
0.2235299796,
0.1469170302,
0.7230932713,
-0.6909562945,
-0.707498014,
-0.0402601734,
0.4799088836,
0.6869607568,
-0.8818234801,
0.3173443377,
-0.3470396996,
-0.357224375,
-0.1245403662,
-0.0568521246,
0.300283134,
1.0699650049,
0.5145979524,
-0.5052063465,
-0.5082474947,
-0.7584694624,
-0.4199736416,
-0.3660018444,
0.1664061099,
0.4041276872,
0.6707996726,
0.0163062364,
1.28132689,
-0.1083059609,
-0.3819345832,
-0.2556861341,
0.1012601405,
0.1093523428,
0.5817409754,
0.6003024578,
-0.8478969336,
-0.7199593186,
0.1410512328,
-0.8171144724,
0.2506996393,
0.4467926025,
-0.0062540476,
0.139754653,
0.672636807,
-0.6978859305,
0.7624978423,
0.2385395914,
-0.4903612435,
0.4822401106,
-0.1342250854,
-0.4301448762,
-0.5172179341,
-0.0124147972,
-0.0293701757,
-0.2524551749,
-0.9643084407,
-0.3212089837,
0.1446236968,
-0.1922146976,
-0.278301686,
0.3120176494,
-0.4529326856,
-0.5788949728,
0.3039830923,
0.1631619483,
0.1448442936,
0.5414832234,
0.1009479463,
0.5438456535,
0.3176073432,
-0.4945755601,
0.5111109614,
0.5245073438,
-0.5593821406,
0.1030998081,
-0.5569187999,
0.2430163473,
-0.319478631,
0.4186768532,
-1.527697444,
-0.1079575419,
0.7663354874,
-0.5657910705,
0.5932469964,
-0.5582436323,
-0.6407302618,
-0.713488996,
0.1379221082,
0.0429063849,
-0.1028840169,
-0.4970562458,
1.014195323,
0.194080621,
0.2316552699,
-0.6916378736,
-0.8204866052,
0.1547601521,
-0.1224181354,
-1.0772966146,
0.338183105,
0.3598237336,
-0.0218859129,
0.3384925723,
-0.2860793173,
-0.269402951,
0.2377812415,
-0.0095966505,
0.4341663718,
-0.2511434555,
0.3602362573,
-0.2251795679,
-0.1391673833,
0.1377549171,
-0.7879716158,
0.8213543296,
-0.2044809908,
-0.1975254565,
-0.6228889823,
0.1760551631,
0.3396020532,
-0.3275720179,
0.8275829554,
0.6963558793,
-0.3024314642,
0.0286705997,
-0.1108021066,
-0.1129462272,
-0.4495263398,
0.847858429,
-0.3670430779,
-0.7877010703,
0.8094860315,
0.2248459607,
-0.5788939595,
0.3706193268,
0.3409252465,
0.0783475861,
0.8886668086,
0.3609140515,
-0.3346726298,
0.5554453731,
-0.158911556,
0.493095547,
-0.653844893,
-0.1947747171,
-0.7775155902,
-0.4580343068,
-0.4566011131,
-0.0856461674,
0.2517601848,
-0.1463600546,
-0.3199672103,
0.224426344,
-0.6663727164,
0.3897718787,
0.6262437105,
0.2845056057,
0.2935112119,
-0.1527555585,
-0.514361918,
0.3618215024,
-0.6564738154,
0.0268268101,
0.9646216035,
0.1563168168,
0.3160120845,
0.0027591658,
0.6264393926,
0.4573914111,
0.3855155706,
-0.7942912579,
0.6926860809,
-0.4630337059,
-0.4300531447,
-0.7120451927,
-0.5086615086,
-0.5414693356,
0.3608236611,
-0.2028580606,
-1.1807903051,
0.0844696239,
0.2414315194,
-0.0877895951,
0.5886428356,
-0.6645538807,
1.2957361937,
-0.2218066454,
-0.1644418538,
0.2562123537,
-0.9233714342,
0.2557781339,
0.4599727392,
-0.076355271,
-0.1700924039,
0.2867159545,
0.6327448487,
-0.7211275101,
0.6841665506,
-0.5801649094,
0.3041701913,
0.3738179207,
0.2024284452,
0.9657453895,
0.0820321962,
-0.0042759143,
0.1359928548,
-0.2725457251,
-0.1479241252,
-0.6181615591,
0.3569368124,
-0.5580446124,
-0.1395927221,
-0.2971827984,
-0.7844677567,
-0.7059527636,
0.2650795579,
0.3854045272,
0.5997295976,
0.083817035,
-0.0581193976,
0.2429282218,
0.271448046,
0.5127016306,
0.1550294161,
-0.3998913169,
-0.5965046883,
0.9350870848,
0.5681905746,
0.0354439579,
0.4707775116,
0.2852138877,
-0.5037477612,
-1.075561285,
-0.7435562611,
-0.0262447372,
-0.78381145,
-0.1169792265,
-0.6007424593,
-0.1255320609,
-0.4029909968,
0.2279503793,
0.2818084955,
-0.5736182928,
-0.2955759764,
-0.2878249586,
0.6488718987,
0.766646266,
0.3180683255,
0.4141071141,
-0.7180888057,
0.0146520426,
0.5543174744,
0.7265906334,
0.223385796,
-0.2602953315,
-0.0802322701,
-0.2736592889,
0.2780825198,
-0.8303042054,
0.346939981,
0.2532782853,
0.5495446324,
0.0957056135,
-0.2788538635,
0.3491102159,
-0.4329048097,
0.4787099659,
0.1559884995,
-0.9541144371,
0.1219321415,
-0.4024705887,
-0.0922556892,
0.6867238879,
0.3343698382,
-0.7477270961,
0.0947163254,
-0.2454037517,
-0.868052721,
0.7699973583,
-0.0271315668,
-0.2171215564,
0.088802889,
0.4259218276,
-0.1244767606,
0.2491614074,
-0.9195995331,
0.0575168841,
-0.202984795,
-0.2483815402,
0.3041137457,
-0.1855764985,
0.1136687398,
-0.4218901098,
0.4769272804,
-0.4037190676,
0.4094902277,
0.1201336458,
-0.3167252243,
0.1229086444,
-0.05446098,
0.7796051502,
0.5399050117,
-0.2787938118,
-0.1043791026,
0.0882921889,
-0.659722209,
-0.1192636043,
0.1808282882,
-0.3962038159,
0.2702204585,
0.1997284144,
0.9875050783,
-0.022037806,
0.1207462773,
0.342309922,
-0.1826655418,
-0.1080765426,
-0.2852306664,
-0.1290396452,
0.3093116879,
-0.1156463251,
-0.2563435435,
-0.1591277868,
0.284676671,
-0.3736909628,
0.4685072899,
0.6402510405,
-0.9483615756,
-0.0890770108,
0.5461134911,
-0.0529951006,
-0.4508139193,
1.0042494535,
-0.1968755126,
-0.6808353066,
0.9370445609,
0.6941738725,
0.8464925289,
0.0486968234,
0.2943827212,
-0.0076011983,
0.0929577649,
0.3709746599,
0.4977725148,
0.0959698185,
-1.0605059862,
-0.129579246,
-0.4291594923,
-0.5183944702,
0.0618263707,
-0.2553978562,
0.2925274968,
-0.596092701,
-0.0656187832,
0.2758836448,
-0.2961679697,
-0.4092871845,
0.0895602033,
0.219389528,
0.8362756968,
-0.6613823771,
1.1286659241,
0.4401911199,
-0.7600861788,
-0.8684979081,
-0.3096820116,
-0.0851423293,
-0.9993199706,
0.8222955465,
0.1787814945,
0.15069969,
-0.075245589,
-0.3294047117,
-1.0394638777,
0.8561547995,
0.3246018589,
-0.2006869912,
-0.5710573196,
0.741111815,
0.4279441535,
-0.3410867453,
0.380692035,
0.6576182246,
0.731842041,
-0.0704228953,
-0.6451428533,
-0.0564521737,
-0.2076296955,
0.2669197321,
0.6513360143,
-0.4945614338,
1.1135954857,
0.3089427948,
0.1816324443,
-0.0923737511,
0.7523263693,
-0.18868047,
0.2442941517,
0.6767182946,
0.8027930856,
0.7751121521,
-0.315048039,
0.7037733793,
-0.4072090089,
0.3753029704,
1.2610337734,
-0.6132805943,
0.4476105273,
0.2247116715,
-0.3207215965,
0.8729257584,
0.5000050664,
-0.0308547523,
0.3463455737,
0.7914631367,
-0.3529609442,
-0.0680852309,
-0.1089418605,
-0.409426719,
0.6012288928,
0.7192592621,
-0.3386012018,
-0.4815374315,
-0.2010586411,
0.0606083348,
-0.2076346129,
-0.3746722341,
0.6555693746,
-0.2417358011,
-0.2184882909,
0.1524436027,
-0.4078886807,
0.1521048844,
-0.7602981329,
-0.1212251559,
0.0162845161,
0.0401055068,
-0.3760929704,
-0.750992775,
0.2558936477,
-0.762781322,
-0.0316326395,
0.3265661895,
1.2703057528,
-0.425837487,
-0.2689212859,
0.5320084095,
0.4003256559,
-0.3431019187,
-0.2093188167,
-0.3648491502,
-0.2453324646,
-0.4407247305,
0.0044453307,
0.5621436834,
0.6810062528,
-0.2214493901,
0.5772567987,
0.4967852533,
-0.2682486773,
0.2986680865,
0.1397178769,
0.9323827624,
-0.3320969045,
-0.8164690137,
-0.8018264174,
0.2869012058,
-0.2370108813,
-0.3092944622,
0.3913095891,
0.4576412141,
0.626111567,
-0.32076931,
0.6216992736,
-0.0645405799,
0.3291021287,
-0.5842937231,
0.9761821032,
-0.1232979745,
-0.2196428329,
-0.4729031622,
-0.5287610292,
-0.8787592053,
0.3819720745,
-0.4272708893,
-0.0492189378,
0.713360548,
0.6474793553,
0.100960128,
0.4154353142,
0.077378422,
0.0018657652,
0.382303834,
0.4774349332,
0.7832381725,
-0.0712818354,
0.781642437,
-0.3035265505,
0.0987020284,
-0.3539749384,
-0.930796504,
-0.5843576193,
-0.5595177412,
-0.0970649123,
-0.7691036463,
0.1114291102,
0.6093790531,
0.6164754033,
-1.0367437601,
-0.1095349044,
-0.6424431205,
0.330909133,
-0.0945232511,
-0.1971255541,
0.6660724282,
-0.4836058319,
0.0832114816,
0.143152535,
0.3594252169,
0.0271735992,
-0.0581214465,
0.2235914469,
-0.7009934783,
-0.1731936187,
0.5695350766,
0.4381798208,
-0.4981866181,
-1.0540158749,
-0.1593167037,
-0.051727552,
0.5312018991,
0.8579235673,
-0.9537067413,
0.2955730855,
0.8946399689,
0.6879975796,
0.6078816652,
-0.2906454802,
0.1615936905,
-0.7028480172,
0.1904387325,
0.4965623915,
0.7797225714,
0.0899949446,
-0.4669760466,
0.862187624,
0.6833311915,
-0.531558454,
-0.5296865106,
0.3903717697,
-1.0143460035,
0.0846059769,
0.6746703982,
-0.0828795582,
-0.3213702142,
-0.5139850974,
-0.0756271407,
0.3154332638,
-0.3054690361,
0.6757501364,
0.7285994291,
-0.5580098629,
0.1682623625,
-0.2519403994,
0.5574365854,
0.1095438153,
-0.7344129682,
-0.1153085008,
0.4138374031,
0.0963740051,
0.2597329617,
0.6309328079,
-0.0882339701,
0.2432079613,
0.0005352152,
0.0566150919,
-0.2775642276,
-0.4220427573,
-0.0314398222,
0.3588695526,
-0.08471255,
-0.3245235384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00099v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00099v2
|
Creative Beam Search: LLM-as-a-Judge For Improving Response Generation
| 2024-04-30T18:00:02 | 2024-05-09T15:14:19 |
Giorgio Franceschelli, Mirco Musolesi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Large language models are revolutionizing several areas, including artificial
creativity. However, the process of generation in machines profoundly diverges
from that observed in humans. In particular, machine generation is
characterized by a lack of intentionality and an underlying creative process.
We propose a method called Creative Beam Search that uses Diverse Beam Search
and LLM-as-a-Judge to perform response generation and response validation. The
results of a qualitative experiment show how our approach can provide better
output than standard sampling techniques. We also show that the response
validation step is a necessary complement to the response generation step.
|
[
-0.5671131015,
-0.794093132,
0.853426218,
0.2931627929,
-0.2056613415,
0.4531638026,
0.0438660607,
-0.39170748,
0.2131712437,
0.4188671708,
-0.8480758071,
-0.138069436,
-0.5144475698,
0.3100035787,
-0.4529145062,
0.5237982273,
-0.118298538,
0.31889534,
-0.1669348776,
0.0908372551,
-0.7548043728,
-0.1013261974,
-0.6999507546,
-0.6155694127,
0.5908771157,
0.3895683587,
0.4950970411,
0.3310603797,
0.7183606029,
0.4003848732,
-0.1972489208,
0.5507115126,
-0.4062029421,
0.4284141064,
-0.522601068,
-0.619926393,
-0.1416080296,
0.0518362857,
0.4257444441,
0.4812264442,
-0.0846283957,
0.1042253003,
-0.2697465122,
0.8491023779,
-0.5573538542,
-0.0784482062,
-0.7466899753,
0.492823571,
-0.1265179068,
-0.5202970505,
-0.5783526301,
-0.770070076,
-0.1876673698,
-0.4621012807,
0.5120259523,
0.3745458424,
0.5112458467,
0.3493623137,
-0.5416981578,
-0.5514082909,
-1.0637042522,
0.6725777388,
-0.795394361,
0.2798504829,
0.1318967789,
0.5360153913,
-0.5289936066,
-0.838452518,
-0.7460015416,
-0.4371916652,
0.1102656126,
0.3700796068,
0.0088510877,
0.1440920234,
0.5798312426,
0.4191863537,
-0.7543528676,
0.0713032335,
-0.047823377,
-0.0365603156,
0.87280339,
0.4334001839,
0.1797741205,
-0.1981930435,
-0.1688038558,
-0.198796913,
-0.6122521162,
0.2754833698,
0.5318353176,
0.0752666965,
0.4091995656,
0.8732424378,
-0.6845238805,
0.6520450711,
0.2426451594,
-0.0453296825,
0.1414944977,
-0.3580929637,
-0.0563196354,
-0.0395896249,
0.6028751731,
0.3704681993,
-0.0407834202,
-0.080978252,
-0.6201825738,
0.2169245631,
0.4927005172,
-0.8718963861,
0.1047842279,
0.1871200055,
-0.567511797,
-0.3335137367,
0.1787042022,
-0.5395969748,
-0.6165245175,
-0.3397155404,
0.3277566433,
-0.1466395855,
-0.006370991,
0.2670889199,
-0.4941948652,
0.0705073029,
0.3467698097,
-0.7002949715,
0.0738405138,
0.3883599639,
0.4956246912,
0.0641207248,
-0.0198305361,
-1.0369488001,
-0.2522432804,
-0.5885155797,
1.098867774,
-0.3942128718,
-0.5385860205,
-0.1208112985,
-0.4428924322,
0.1041788682,
-0.8793990612,
0.3826927543,
-0.9420691729,
0.4251730144,
-0.1739067584,
-0.577730298,
-0.1414798498,
0.1953436434,
-0.5148511529,
0.8586451411,
0.2086455524,
-0.6888719797,
0.6359718442,
-0.7199165821,
-0.4802424312,
0.3693095744,
-0.45648399,
-0.5158474445,
0.709446013,
0.2651020885,
0.1825810373,
-0.4021498263,
0.3915909231,
-0.6274742484,
-0.5177460909,
0.661655426,
-0.1443089098,
0.4956647158,
0.632522583,
-0.4419433773,
0.258851707,
-1.0854908228,
0.2840191424,
0.4331803024,
-0.876672864,
0.2498623431,
0.3695540726,
0.1061513722,
0.3026769161,
0.1455339342,
-0.8063879609,
0.0253647231,
-0.8996089697,
0.3027820885,
0.7427718043,
0.097151421,
0.2222047448,
-0.5341724753,
0.7021802068,
-0.1717367172,
-0.1957102567,
-0.1422454715,
-0.4991104901,
-0.5791890621,
0.0936945453,
-0.0043218737,
0.411596328,
-1.1291429996,
0.4322034717,
0.2152287066,
-0.4475529492,
-0.864059031,
0.2839133739,
0.1927149743,
0.464166522,
0.0927223563,
-0.5204640627,
-1.0049053431,
-0.8204663396,
-0.3917205036,
-0.149016276,
-0.3991915584,
0.4451403916,
0.1727749109,
-0.2865730524,
1.2295489311,
-0.3533658087,
0.1464628279,
-0.4248380959,
0.3000716567,
0.479914993,
0.1228418425,
0.4902860522,
-0.9451779723,
-0.3100987971,
-0.0319806561,
-0.8618693948,
-0.501527667,
-0.1460872442,
0.1569441855,
0.0193766821,
0.3295327723,
-0.6452750564,
0.4774336517,
0.3695576787,
-0.3107250631,
0.4622134566,
0.022033859,
0.1357123107,
-1.02267313,
0.1729593277,
-0.4451813698,
-0.2459091991,
-0.5673561096,
0.4639373422,
-0.0043541323,
-0.0309308525,
-0.5952598453,
0.5273419619,
-0.2714798152,
-0.1057332903,
-0.987608552,
0.3973861039,
0.062994644,
0.1079580039,
-0.1691746861,
0.5008806586,
0.2599853873,
-0.5763543248,
0.9620057344,
0.2514976561,
-0.5144226551,
0.4507705271,
-0.7273126245,
0.5213150978,
-0.5805079341,
0.3087533414,
-1.2767893076,
-0.4345972836,
-0.1143750995,
-0.4610725343,
0.2078680843,
0.3831568062,
-0.6722160578,
-1.0645473003,
-0.4914370477,
0.2888332307,
0.3455523849,
-0.5847046375,
0.6571102142,
-0.0387287252,
-0.1315495819,
-0.2261762917,
-0.5789163709,
0.0552506074,
-0.2576919794,
-0.7858070731,
0.3259318173,
-0.6953911185,
-0.34077847,
-0.3894726634,
-0.0057801558,
0.5166005492,
0.437220037,
0.1042731181,
0.0643454567,
-0.290388912,
0.0238988586,
-0.2327016592,
0.010788871,
0.1396356523,
0.0833180323,
0.9008766413,
0.1420997232,
-0.6960788965,
-0.3285402656,
0.4498772323,
0.3098594546,
-0.3146263957,
0.1754263937,
0.5181732178,
-0.2161725461,
-0.3193700612,
-0.6917732954,
-0.4302326143,
-0.6335772872,
0.3613855541,
-0.2950687408,
-0.9238544106,
0.3427255452,
0.0546981134,
0.0404770896,
0.2528969347,
1.0845156908,
-0.296990335,
1.4965610504,
0.4660767019,
0.3999415636,
0.6111570597,
0.1824423224,
0.5031511188,
-0.7855941057,
-0.2016456574,
-0.6740735769,
-0.6381531358,
-0.7005577683,
0.0485261157,
0.247895062,
-0.0605192892,
-0.1936629564,
0.0656921491,
-0.4902316034,
0.3038651049,
0.8660548329,
0.1356619895,
0.2368210852,
-0.2585729063,
-0.4196573496,
-0.0876750425,
-0.6075159311,
-0.4756087661,
0.889962554,
0.2596964538,
0.8479495645,
0.0677585155,
1.0186293125,
-0.0668713748,
0.4985027909,
-1.0315420628,
0.703135252,
0.1908430457,
-0.6481337547,
-0.1356395185,
-0.612408936,
-0.923078537,
0.1758688539,
-0.183037594,
-0.5260751843,
-0.1719196141,
0.0283306818,
-0.526896894,
0.1127497926,
-0.5564593077,
0.2917836308,
-0.4423121512,
-0.1356021017,
-0.1723883897,
-0.4703516662,
0.2608415484,
-0.3705592155,
0.2301573604,
-0.2192649543,
0.4272078276,
0.5187202692,
-0.1884049177,
0.6036953926,
-0.2842719555,
0.0800963342,
0.4384010434,
0.4082185924,
0.6867644191,
0.0531241409,
-0.0659998283,
-0.8178675175,
-0.7284492254,
-0.1423172057,
-0.6719093323,
0.5090702772,
-0.5427132249,
-1.0393645763,
0.1128845289,
-0.8050364256,
-0.3734841049,
0.3323836029,
0.3923171759,
-0.1524364948,
-0.0535740033,
0.43677333,
0.4002325833,
-0.2991881967,
0.6157875657,
0.6018609405,
-0.4534074962,
-0.3972319961,
0.5285487771,
-0.1078865975,
-0.0131030083,
0.3849775195,
0.4106399119,
-0.3815557063,
-0.8128387928,
-0.321636498,
0.0130209001,
-0.4657483697,
-0.3290944993,
-0.3839470446,
-0.1872371435,
-0.5469994545,
-0.1416628212,
-0.2591204047,
-0.4975308478,
-0.2156399339,
-0.3249938786,
-0.0623349994,
0.9768570065,
0.1163783371,
0.2022077739,
-0.687959075,
0.4133051038,
0.5941916108,
0.2471248358,
-0.0267312787,
-0.612770915,
-0.07839863,
0.0620603487,
-1.0452122688,
-0.7986738086,
0.48836568,
0.0851005688,
0.8479784727,
0.3243965209,
0.0025375916,
0.4689109921,
-0.5424191952,
0.8215299249,
0.3025088906,
-0.6907325983,
1.1417437792,
-0.1836933196,
0.4792154133,
0.0728075653,
0.057717137,
-0.4333644509,
-0.6914453506,
-0.5660865307,
-0.9222676158,
0.6256898046,
0.2527902424,
0.2067418694,
-0.0234395023,
0.1812082678,
-0.1179279163,
0.4836067557,
-0.6956377029,
0.2217624635,
-0.1580491364,
-0.0586465225,
0.0405833796,
0.0505444184,
-0.2713843584,
0.2818188369,
0.5440814495,
-0.3924318254,
0.1776188463,
0.2106764317,
0.2243691534,
-0.6280473471,
0.1533002853,
0.5032731295,
0.3769658208,
0.0160624385,
0.2732077241,
0.2273015529,
0.0544285998,
0.2771718502,
0.0635709241,
-0.2420861721,
-0.1866725981,
0.3946713209,
0.6319013834,
-0.0456951968,
-1.0316609144,
0.2937788367,
-0.1325991303,
-0.3150729537,
-0.0237251129,
0.5200078487,
0.1960070133,
0.688367188,
0.4458711445,
0.1350140274,
0.4154722095,
-0.4999783337,
0.3176384568,
0.5731612444,
0.0678004399,
-0.1309587806,
0.9803723097,
-0.1966884881,
-0.8474224806,
0.5984024405,
-0.3745656312,
-0.2654680908,
0.6811615825,
0.7312386036,
1.1155560017,
-0.2243712991,
0.164610073,
0.1711348891,
-0.0269028489,
-0.0896454826,
0.5368874669,
-0.0137128206,
-0.8831626177,
-0.3524723053,
-0.7467983365,
-0.4847402573,
0.059979517,
-0.5556299686,
0.2165756822,
-0.6007508039,
-0.5204005837,
-0.0232697893,
0.0743590295,
-0.8666912317,
0.335150212,
0.3856972456,
0.7351639867,
-0.4019753635,
0.4896557629,
0.9330755472,
-0.2590861917,
-0.7038102746,
-0.2526870966,
0.0921372771,
-1.0154579878,
0.8322728276,
0.3047244847,
-0.2124681622,
-0.2887034714,
-0.6969246268,
-0.7916765213,
1.1372936964,
0.3764861822,
-0.4774781466,
-0.1542255282,
0.2113111764,
0.7874791026,
-0.479029119,
0.2337234914,
0.3929193914,
0.4126620889,
0.5000813603,
-0.8886696696,
-0.1140433252,
-0.416534245,
0.6436864138,
-0.1440414339,
-0.6242198348,
0.7023422122,
-0.2415771484,
-0.2656417489,
0.2445388585,
0.6618865132,
0.8732005358,
0.7715005875,
0.2265615612,
0.4630930126,
0.7074732184,
-0.0290801674,
0.9277533293,
-0.0782560185,
0.3649753034,
0.856177032,
-0.5631582737,
0.7909429073,
0.6549203992,
-0.0398552269,
0.2391546518,
0.7292665243,
-0.0912887901,
0.5687750578,
0.5435679555,
-0.1856427193,
-0.24006024,
-0.1546197087,
0.0621194616,
0.4229976833,
0.1413657814,
-0.4371547699,
-0.2406767756,
0.1017560959,
-0.3547818959,
0.5178111196,
-0.1802715063,
0.6578582525,
0.1522646546,
-0.8008409142,
0.4265636802,
0.2681984305,
0.5771494508,
-0.2709781826,
0.1566292942,
-0.4554772377,
0.2884882092,
-0.3043227494,
-0.7617432475,
0.3159686327,
-0.0592186302,
-0.1790656745,
-0.3486148119,
0.6863244176,
-0.0220630728,
-0.4045767188,
0.3845722079,
0.6373318434,
-0.2744252682,
0.0028461358,
-0.4902777076,
0.0046936716,
0.1049844623,
-0.7818800807,
0.0883976743,
0.4806783497,
0.1337551922,
0.7947670221,
0.6578814387,
0.127174601,
0.1516210437,
0.1525055617,
0.9584978819,
-0.7596866488,
-0.4006972909,
-0.6450366378,
0.4092082083,
-0.0194621123,
-0.1270148307,
0.5910313129,
0.5901924372,
0.9647217989,
-0.2582064867,
0.7950725555,
0.0338693298,
0.7426445484,
-0.7031105757,
0.3168027401,
-0.611423552,
0.3179822564,
-0.1260534078,
-1.0582385063,
-0.4377520978,
0.7332423925,
-0.2342623174,
0.3065327406,
0.5096955895,
1.0270750523,
0.057971511,
0.1519865841,
0.4951981604,
0.3163917661,
0.8909218311,
0.707232058,
1.3039668798,
-0.2129101157,
0.3726056516,
0.1196109876,
-0.2536427379,
-0.3322422206,
-0.7088124156,
-0.9074454308,
-0.184427917,
0.0035816326,
-0.289187938,
-0.3470632136,
1.1415058374,
0.5329220295,
-0.7331674099,
-0.2970967889,
-0.2112214267,
-0.1433381736,
-0.09445142,
-0.2521194816,
-0.2401833683,
-0.6738432646,
-0.7667229772,
0.8851432204,
0.2649042308,
0.1754990965,
-0.3474787772,
-0.0564237349,
0.2203536183,
0.328799963,
0.6818230748,
-0.0681039616,
-0.5946372151,
-0.2131865323,
0.2343322337,
-0.1664813012,
0.1120136455,
0.9232826233,
-0.9250102639,
0.6809282899,
0.6292771697,
0.6724316478,
0.6009934545,
-0.1711781323,
0.5521872044,
-0.7011178732,
-0.0430452116,
0.6212849021,
0.411490947,
0.3516932726,
-0.3366861045,
0.4254781306,
0.4713177085,
-0.5835860372,
-0.633825779,
0.6877750158,
-0.8454396129,
-0.1793689728,
0.9245496392,
0.0981234759,
-0.0845025182,
0.1752587706,
-0.6255106926,
0.0568099134,
-0.2661258578,
1.2638829947,
0.7862596512,
-0.4848771989,
0.0029199868,
-0.4159741998,
0.1836184412,
0.4958276749,
-0.6602922082,
-0.2000070214,
0.4328674674,
0.0718668997,
0.3689665496,
0.6419440508,
0.0168921165,
0.5281983018,
-0.0731517971,
-0.0642874762,
0.1316290945,
-0.2425802797,
-0.1414251775,
0.4679875672,
0.5426566601,
0.0118588097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19753v1
|
DOCCI: Descriptions of Connected and Contrasting Images
| 2024-04-30T17:56:24 | 2024-04-30T17:56:24 |
Yasumasa Onoe, Sunayana Rane, Zachary Berger, Yonatan Bitton, Jaemin Cho, Roopal Garg, Alexander Ku, Zarana Parekh, Jordi Pont-Tuset, Garrett Tanzer, Su Wang, Jason Baldridge
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Vision-language datasets are vital for both text-to-image (T2I) and
image-to-text (I2T) research. However, current datasets lack descriptions with
fine-grained detail that would allow for richer associations to be learned by
models. To fill the gap, we introduce Descriptions of Connected and Contrasting
Images (DOCCI), a dataset with long, human-annotated English descriptions for
15k images that were taken, curated and donated by a single researcher intent
on capturing key challenges such as spatial relations, counting, text
rendering, world knowledge, and more. We instruct human annotators to create
comprehensive descriptions for each image; these average 136 words in length
and are crafted to clearly distinguish each image from those that are related
or similar. Each description is highly compositional and typically encompasses
multiple challenges. Through both quantitative and qualitative analyses, we
demonstrate that DOCCI serves as an effective training resource for
image-to-text generation -- a PaLI 5B model finetuned on DOCCI shows equal or
superior results compared to highly-performant larger models like LLaVA-1.5 7B
and InstructBLIP 7B. Furthermore, we show that DOCCI is a useful testbed for
text-to-image generation, highlighting the limitations of current text-to-image
models in capturing long descriptions and fine details.
|
[
-0.5725315213,
-0.2873568237,
0.6383813024,
-0.025800623,
-0.6157533526,
-0.0746710002,
-0.1558233202,
-0.9226154685,
-0.0642470568,
0.3578987718,
-0.4397198856,
-0.3759555817,
-0.543263793,
0.3516624272,
-0.4816580713,
1.024498105,
-0.3569347858,
0.0439126045,
-0.5522167087,
-0.048893407,
-0.6428254247,
0.1192984208,
-0.8495880961,
-0.1735390574,
0.7297341228,
0.3520936072,
0.5352279544,
0.7103483677,
0.8979708552,
0.2002139837,
-0.0096385926,
0.3403929472,
-0.5395178795,
0.0893703699,
-0.2718618512,
-0.4097627103,
-0.0156613849,
0.2175713032,
0.6668691635,
0.7907478809,
0.3618759215,
-0.0870753303,
-0.1324695647,
0.6725988984,
-0.4327976108,
0.3131054938,
-0.535544157,
0.1471336484,
-0.3093428314,
-0.0896643028,
-0.2485564202,
-0.0298978798,
0.2728505731,
-0.9080253839,
0.5292931199,
0.0943495855,
1.2281737328,
0.2543198764,
-0.5033944845,
-0.417368561,
-0.650793314,
0.4188596904,
-0.3016409576,
-0.0797263756,
0.4503145516,
0.4808234572,
0.2093369961,
-0.9134531617,
-0.8542113304,
0.0164577514,
-0.3347227871,
0.4718329906,
0.1868691891,
-0.2570628524,
0.0972815976,
0.4289821386,
-0.2746041417,
0.3715058565,
-0.8493401408,
-0.017764248,
0.7388215065,
0.4871200323,
0.178216055,
-0.0773308873,
-0.5067973733,
-0.2229397446,
-0.9297037125,
-0.1034491286,
0.4083114266,
-0.1387613118,
-0.5382325649,
0.568775475,
-0.0290388893,
0.6424554586,
-0.0570000894,
-0.0551883467,
0.0574876182,
-0.4241375923,
0.2789212167,
-0.1546257585,
0.9107027054,
0.8984053135,
0.2402891666,
-0.3337090015,
-0.2808843851,
0.2278513014,
0.1071070954,
-0.9646400213,
-0.149927184,
-0.1677138954,
-0.6089509726,
-0.310696125,
0.1136918738,
-0.8126508594,
-0.4824200571,
-0.3214857876,
0.0187958777,
-0.3270641565,
-0.1291818917,
-0.267013818,
-0.3528504372,
0.4262202382,
0.3217355907,
-0.7737497091,
0.4498228133,
0.6537341475,
0.828376174,
-0.2379087508,
-0.5043125153,
-0.1930598766,
0.2877292037,
-0.6529889703,
1.0328999758,
-0.6377856135,
-0.7519905567,
0.0887228698,
0.0585677959,
0.2881359756,
-0.3580262363,
0.3335105181,
-0.1140188798,
0.4782921076,
-0.2254979908,
-0.5184899569,
0.0715892911,
0.2462411374,
-0.7791823149,
0.7016251087,
0.0752871782,
-1.2462533712,
0.3397387862,
-0.6069893241,
-0.5280553699,
0.1030788198,
-0.814180851,
-0.3612751663,
0.2290868461,
-0.0624314249,
0.5331201553,
-0.668595612,
0.0626844093,
-0.2014203072,
-0.4930494726,
0.4406734705,
-0.1365465671,
0.3419982493,
0.3276446164,
-0.2080875486,
-0.1404910982,
-0.8315340281,
-0.4464058876,
0.5514189601,
0.0193869844,
-0.3872843981,
0.050738588,
0.3178608716,
-0.0124146715,
0.2710433602,
-0.6130758524,
-0.01977567,
-0.1704716533,
0.6285352111,
0.6406522989,
-0.0895947739,
0.1491487473,
-0.2547180355,
0.2172287852,
0.3684794903,
0.1456919312,
-0.5250515342,
-0.4912889898,
-0.5828781128,
-0.1699759513,
0.1827752888,
0.3621784449,
-0.9161183238,
-0.0780624077,
-0.6177079678,
-0.4629904628,
-0.5710033774,
-0.1483011991,
0.6119972467,
1.0406090021,
0.2115350962,
-0.8072316647,
-0.0750351772,
-1.3094154596,
0.453892678,
-0.1785397381,
-0.1772214025,
0.6872380972,
0.5082011819,
-0.1016732007,
0.6522345543,
-0.5714218616,
-0.4145742357,
0.4679391086,
0.2027694434,
-0.1233052984,
0.1216244176,
0.5480867624,
-1.0721844435,
-0.650033772,
0.1370037943,
-0.7548923492,
0.2330937982,
-0.2863134444,
0.1544795483,
-0.0691410154,
0.5834573507,
-0.5583297014,
0.3959058821,
0.2508089244,
-0.4042817056,
0.5904371142,
-0.4214847684,
0.2992650568,
-1.5178542137,
0.2901623845,
0.1346705258,
0.0010266248,
-0.2287248075,
0.2781500816,
-0.0920559168,
-0.2103550434,
-0.5088467002,
0.5639573336,
-0.6836256981,
-0.1913881749,
-0.2105564922,
0.2740629017,
0.1341226399,
0.114569895,
0.4569528401,
1.1068898439,
0.9567328691,
-0.2115497738,
0.5619602203,
0.68436414,
-0.3158318698,
0.9294320345,
-0.7669211626,
0.3754603267,
-0.0250950512,
0.3508880734,
-0.9437260032,
-0.3882790506,
0.0240890197,
-0.2282266915,
0.5416257977,
0.1158868447,
-0.4741143882,
-0.2711111009,
-0.3267279267,
0.707057178,
0.4544768333,
-0.6623994708,
0.3841988146,
0.1493509263,
-0.2244948,
-0.359008193,
-0.803289175,
0.6382600069,
-0.3152405322,
-0.5079212785,
0.527058363,
0.1366277039,
-0.1090328097,
0.1219200939,
0.3715609014,
-0.1366312504,
-0.1032960564,
0.610393405,
0.5268004537,
-0.0298637059,
0.2268332392,
-0.1854774356,
-0.1436926425,
0.0590992868,
-0.0124478145,
0.0438584238,
-0.0238736942,
-0.01999701,
-0.3109249175,
0.8064107299,
0.1699285209,
-0.2652052343,
0.4322345257,
0.76874125,
-0.1928408146,
0.3457477093,
-0.3508596718,
0.0274284724,
-0.3797516227,
0.3249867558,
-0.7776439786,
-0.5442613363,
0.4558626115,
-0.1576761156,
0.0200725477,
0.4922396541,
0.2170811743,
-0.569247365,
0.5635355115,
0.5850732327,
0.13732557,
0.2861378789,
-0.2513639331,
0.0363865979,
-0.902728498,
-0.4699954391,
-0.4706304371,
-0.2429140955,
-0.6145834923,
-0.3929513097,
0.199709177,
-0.3300860226,
0.0008796467,
0.0546156317,
-0.626960218,
0.5909553766,
0.5717469454,
0.1992492229,
-0.0291614346,
0.2769980133,
0.0679615438,
-0.1052439138,
-0.247067973,
-0.5286763906,
1.2541949749,
0.1406442076,
0.8144633174,
-0.2156943679,
0.7045852542,
0.2052388638,
0.0250501409,
-0.5225002766,
0.6149643064,
-0.7104366422,
-0.1884265989,
0.1889506727,
-0.2295598239,
-0.9130902886,
-0.5089967847,
-0.4054952562,
-0.3324558735,
0.295796454,
-0.0014525003,
-0.1100943014,
0.198559612,
-0.7922315598,
0.512830019,
-0.1997106373,
-0.5283819437,
-0.3395026028,
-1.1662925482,
0.0958906636,
0.0127009768,
-0.0675590858,
0.211243242,
-0.1709800661,
0.5239978433,
-0.1781587154,
0.9517011046,
0.2409194708,
-0.064613007,
0.2460713238,
-0.137128368,
0.2212139368,
-0.1713959277,
0.3049764931,
0.3142636716,
0.0829474032,
-0.5078080893,
-0.2355937511,
0.7450467944,
-0.7894004583,
-0.4550620317,
0.0139375664,
-0.5885571241,
-0.0939218104,
0.0274017472,
0.5572533607,
0.6859453321,
-0.3216645122,
0.0127203139,
0.5980402827,
-0.2613741755,
0.3511441648,
-0.116466023,
0.0604187474,
-0.4808452725,
0.8774175048,
-0.247425437,
0.1117791981,
0.5056958795,
-0.0688362494,
-0.2368977219,
-0.6157342792,
-0.3620195687,
0.3177244067,
-0.7638822794,
-0.1177917942,
-0.1891801208,
-0.1251279116,
-0.2688289881,
-0.2680999935,
-0.1467408538,
-0.3699109852,
-0.4640397727,
-0.0707403496,
0.230068624,
0.8727883101,
0.1392573267,
0.2455141693,
-0.4016776681,
0.4789117873,
0.491997242,
0.4577465653,
-0.342346102,
-0.1089630127,
-0.2958400249,
-0.1071126312,
-0.3210266829,
-0.7311992049,
-0.0578122512,
0.5128542185,
0.0359867923,
0.6968263388,
-0.0467131957,
0.7271549702,
-0.5942476988,
0.9298663735,
0.7491217852,
-0.44691962,
0.554944098,
-0.2802280188,
-0.0162071884,
0.3635582924,
0.2251990587,
-0.3334255517,
-0.3723662794,
-0.5112740993,
-0.7970168591,
0.341230303,
0.149571985,
0.333011955,
-0.0591503754,
0.5471010208,
0.4685793817,
0.0879799128,
-0.5698240995,
-0.0151651017,
-0.4356461465,
-0.5743948221,
-0.2582247853,
-0.3652791977,
-0.6276530623,
0.2489540726,
0.3480639458,
-0.2666010857,
0.2941631079,
0.4662313759,
0.075392656,
0.0490467995,
0.0881585851,
0.4189185202,
0.5015053153,
0.0307957996,
0.4049193263,
-0.2153461277,
-0.5249661803,
-0.2303845882,
0.4321762025,
-0.2942314744,
-0.0713479519,
0.7799047232,
1.1483668089,
-0.3297163248,
-0.6728330851,
0.5086411238,
-0.2821444869,
-0.3909966052,
-0.1958962232,
-0.084194541,
0.1862447113,
0.2534707487,
0.0996780545,
-0.1575024426,
0.3064180613,
-0.5443898439,
-0.10580156,
0.294295311,
-0.6320348978,
-0.3772910237,
0.6451809406,
0.4489462674,
-0.0511939041,
0.7702264786,
-0.0348441005,
-0.0919920579,
0.8772916794,
0.4202892184,
0.7040352225,
0.4510181546,
0.2024508417,
0.1807859242,
0.1196265891,
0.2292423695,
-0.0614982545,
-0.2344994992,
-0.4546296895,
0.05045636,
-0.1763046086,
-0.2992596626,
-0.0598290414,
-0.6235455871,
0.1909821182,
-0.3257748783,
-0.1365620643,
0.2824368477,
0.1554421335,
-0.9345465899,
0.4587512612,
0.5103315711,
0.8675547242,
-1.0445799828,
0.7158616781,
0.978322804,
-0.7536114454,
-0.9067358971,
-0.115387246,
-0.38570714,
-0.5664216876,
0.6944058537,
0.3934503198,
0.1654800177,
-0.2510556281,
-0.7914748788,
0.0846098065,
1.3428946733,
0.2670430839,
-0.6507515907,
-0.1445346475,
0.3203080595,
0.7494860291,
-0.8115696907,
0.3026910126,
0.1793522686,
0.2700301111,
0.2091559619,
-0.6674778461,
0.0616783909,
-0.3555941284,
0.2217746377,
-0.1218303218,
-0.7711946368,
0.7284086347,
-0.5171961188,
-0.3250311911,
0.4328671992,
0.4183639288,
-0.0943864435,
0.5930181742,
0.5142531395,
0.5869058371,
0.2803121507,
-0.1622940451,
1.0850425959,
-0.0982813239,
0.0757163167,
1.3574490547,
-0.274622947,
0.7390906215,
0.8601666093,
-0.0769670233,
0.4113379717,
1.084880352,
-0.4338084161,
0.7196026444,
-0.1340922266,
-0.2824275196,
-0.1670026332,
-0.4748078287,
-0.4870795608,
0.1739099324,
0.1993055791,
-0.5160176158,
-0.2078578919,
-0.0159865282,
-0.4571778476,
0.4031707644,
-0.1341731846,
1.0633698702,
0.1816434413,
-0.5994814038,
0.265763849,
-0.3943244815,
0.3136385679,
-0.3485369682,
-0.2736771703,
-0.4659838378,
-0.0948123485,
-0.0903847665,
-1.1995632648,
0.1728719473,
0.019215703,
-0.2232738137,
-0.0198810436,
0.7138493657,
-0.5693991184,
-0.4270176888,
0.2144117504,
-0.0019291607,
0.3706780076,
0.3874065876,
-0.595428586,
-0.3118799925,
-0.1325021237,
0.1863051206,
0.0248151012,
0.497418493,
-0.1465820074,
0.5312438011,
0.2596971095,
0.2897267342,
-0.1195297018,
0.00512452,
0.8767982721,
-0.4444589317,
-0.4946213663,
-0.4173288941,
0.3210374713,
-0.294390142,
-0.3408137262,
0.0881020054,
0.6322929859,
0.87160182,
-0.3500700891,
0.758230269,
-0.1894620657,
0.2142040133,
-0.5371373892,
0.5204837322,
-0.7138217092,
0.0357658938,
0.1353919506,
-0.8593621254,
0.052406691,
0.2502744794,
-0.0435141996,
-0.3638866842,
0.8425089121,
0.6504942775,
-0.297256887,
-0.3180416226,
0.1303575337,
0.2362927943,
0.2572887838,
0.6981580853,
0.8907694221,
-0.4493443668,
0.6816250086,
-0.3330487013,
-0.0074855485,
0.2331326008,
-0.8656422496,
-0.9283043146,
-1.0051195621,
-0.5395089984,
-0.2550316751,
0.0688224435,
0.2756145,
0.6649638414,
-0.4845189154,
-0.1483491957,
-0.0337684788,
-0.2742364705,
0.0227488857,
-0.0869831443,
0.5551837087,
-0.2032984644,
-0.7572404146,
-0.2297395468,
0.3347641826,
0.2674881816,
-0.3023332059,
-0.2276144326,
0.1006216779,
0.0056477487,
0.2302489877,
0.1243573278,
-0.5798342824,
-0.1574938446,
-0.4744025469,
-0.2953425348,
0.1979397833,
0.7833799124,
-0.527156651,
0.6729037166,
0.1618730426,
0.5610904098,
0.642370224,
-0.194872424,
0.3753733337,
-0.7150551081,
0.4413057268,
-0.0882512778,
0.4770869613,
0.8450652957,
-0.265866518,
0.8252353072,
0.2646913826,
-0.1960592419,
-0.5593709946,
0.4645207524,
-1.3133888245,
-0.2694087625,
1.0474025011,
-0.5563886166,
-0.2367436886,
0.3287159801,
-0.3907537758,
0.3753056824,
0.0233799163,
1.0161163807,
0.7238174677,
0.4747453034,
-0.1405785382,
-0.2203462422,
0.2627307177,
0.095583193,
-0.997682333,
-0.1812526286,
0.79983145,
0.3384551108,
0.2714747488,
0.4181691706,
-0.2189271301,
0.1974496543,
0.274543643,
0.1335786581,
-0.2743545175,
-0.2101359814,
0.0633048937,
-0.0570409819,
0.1095495746,
-0.4758863747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19737v1
|
Better & Faster Large Language Models via Multi-token Prediction
| 2024-04-30T17:33:57 | 2024-04-30T17:33:57 |
Fabian Gloeckle, Badr Youbi Idrissi, Baptiste Rozière, David Lopez-Paz, Gabriel Synnaeve
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models such as GPT and Llama are trained with a next-token
prediction loss. In this work, we suggest that training language models to
predict multiple future tokens at once results in higher sample efficiency.
More specifically, at each position in the training corpus, we ask the model to
predict the following n tokens using n independent output heads, operating on
top of a shared model trunk. Considering multi-token prediction as an auxiliary
training task, we measure improved downstream capabilities with no overhead in
training time for both code and natural language models. The method is
increasingly useful for larger model sizes, and keeps its appeal when training
for multiple epochs. Gains are especially pronounced on generative benchmarks
like coding, where our models consistently outperform strong baselines by
several percentage points. Our 13B parameter models solves 12 % more problems
on HumanEval and 17 % more on MBPP than comparable next-token models.
Experiments on small algorithmic tasks demonstrate that multi-token prediction
is favorable for the development of induction heads and algorithmic reasoning
capabilities. As an additional benefit, models trained with 4-token prediction
are up to 3 times faster at inference, even with large batch sizes.
|
[
-0.4734135568,
-0.3700945675,
0.542978406,
0.2368830293,
-0.3636192679,
0.2695510387,
-0.4789313078,
-0.6841012836,
0.0572651401,
0.3784637153,
-0.2850741744,
-0.244909361,
-0.9077374339,
0.1916383654,
-0.2727651596,
0.8210693002,
0.2874381542,
0.4267172515,
0.0339885578,
-0.0679073408,
-0.7431319952,
-0.9550011754,
-1.0638729334,
-0.288456589,
0.749139607,
0.2653162181,
0.5313339233,
0.7402909398,
0.5658339858,
0.2965660095,
-0.1350409985,
0.0392526686,
-0.1822548062,
0.0219229106,
0.2519639134,
-0.5036312938,
-0.3290087879,
-0.1883051991,
0.6350237727,
0.6679803133,
-0.0351466164,
0.1211156398,
-0.1182624176,
0.4317080379,
-0.3482241333,
0.3458122611,
-1.0129877329,
-0.0359907374,
-0.3013333976,
-0.1336408406,
-0.5796900392,
-0.0650707334,
-0.0742972866,
-0.4215904176,
0.1310125589,
0.2751262486,
0.4505085945,
0.0365431085,
-0.442299664,
0.1027885973,
-0.3594754338,
0.8293249011,
-0.8771317601,
0.6660773754,
0.3984131515,
0.4528642297,
-0.1306809485,
-0.8989915252,
-0.7034264803,
-0.4127563238,
0.0840865001,
-0.2137864828,
0.1112376675,
0.1694113016,
0.2757900655,
0.1872680187,
-0.3019470572,
0.4299493432,
-0.362688899,
-0.5476850867,
0.4414412081,
0.0905736759,
0.0168453977,
0.0059033493,
-0.1932471544,
-0.082750015,
-0.8109560013,
-0.205812335,
0.4582918286,
0.593948245,
0.0451220162,
0.5429130793,
-0.1461814195,
0.63739568,
-0.0871879458,
-0.3447768986,
0.3369282186,
-0.5623643398,
0.0530004799,
-0.055317685,
0.4992128313,
0.2369090021,
0.2607882619,
-0.2255142629,
-0.2095147669,
0.0266441405,
0.0059708003,
-1.0596517324,
-0.1492357701,
0.1314341128,
-0.5921880603,
-0.0657268167,
-0.2279420048,
-0.5051619411,
-0.4142080843,
-0.6625088453,
0.1001462713,
-0.5050650239,
-0.3144418299,
0.109481208,
-0.3460269272,
0.1239188761,
0.3639521599,
-1.0295330286,
0.0988531336,
0.9248656034,
1.0550624132,
-0.1918179095,
-0.5294498205,
-1.0927575827,
-0.0183182303,
-0.4653613865,
0.9791295528,
-0.7327542305,
-0.1417406052,
-0.0593071356,
-0.1724638194,
-0.0641079247,
-0.3411882818,
0.458188355,
-0.5395472646,
-0.098296389,
-0.3941519856,
-0.4549004734,
-0.1409824044,
0.161078617,
-0.8433435559,
0.9537036419,
-0.0941986144,
-0.763055861,
0.674972415,
-0.7069549561,
-0.466301918,
-0.022901684,
0.0081217363,
-0.266924113,
0.2504404187,
0.4501846135,
0.8894363642,
-0.2218634933,
0.3560896814,
-0.5898171067,
-0.3533075154,
0.0244151857,
-0.4994393885,
0.5156940222,
0.1272860318,
-0.2458400875,
0.375428021,
-0.6521269083,
0.0108381091,
-0.0601751618,
-0.6462180018,
-0.1759699881,
-0.2001129985,
0.1743005216,
0.301936537,
-0.0452742502,
-0.4558267593,
0.2673326731,
-0.3074199259,
0.5866137743,
1.1116193533,
-0.2799031734,
0.3456090987,
-0.1080019623,
0.5310905576,
-0.0900672749,
0.0516089797,
-0.3105454147,
-0.8568046689,
-0.5937180519,
-0.4544565976,
0.5017375946,
0.0951540843,
-0.62254107,
0.2097679526,
-0.3644101024,
-0.4960222542,
-0.3034151793,
0.1222605184,
0.4213193655,
0.213057965,
0.2351093143,
-0.5074214935,
-0.8503392935,
-0.605394423,
-0.2086056769,
-0.3079077601,
0.1441743523,
0.0315398723,
0.5962313414,
-0.1877414584,
0.5819038749,
-0.2566527128,
-0.0534130596,
-0.5662156343,
0.2188241631,
0.2327013314,
0.4142987132,
0.483332634,
-0.7282990217,
-0.5045482516,
0.0662390441,
-0.2918042839,
0.2956332564,
0.0218405016,
-0.2397616208,
0.3329445422,
0.5497808456,
-0.6403254867,
0.0481144749,
0.7067328691,
-0.2998957932,
0.7477650046,
-0.1403942853,
-0.1093961522,
-1.1902439594,
0.0204858854,
-0.2288221568,
-0.1629689038,
-0.6541664004,
-0.0447398946,
0.0887821689,
-0.0777895451,
-0.454213351,
0.695682168,
-0.5272054672,
-0.3746089041,
-0.1933864355,
-0.3071289659,
-0.1286105067,
0.6025521755,
0.1329912245,
1.2008118629,
0.6662147045,
-0.6355925798,
0.1777045131,
0.1538294554,
-0.4830552936,
0.0553314649,
-0.5779901743,
0.415877223,
-0.1506128013,
0.4741072953,
-0.9847210646,
-0.1997652203,
-0.2912049592,
-0.5326229334,
0.354803592,
0.010011985,
-0.7122833133,
-0.5437930822,
-0.3540332913,
0.3938722908,
0.2416893244,
-0.7768986821,
0.6229011416,
0.3361102045,
-0.2118716836,
-0.968411386,
-0.8201874495,
0.2089447528,
-0.3358244896,
-0.2981943488,
0.3459521234,
-0.0481963418,
0.1187257841,
-0.162668705,
0.0715215057,
-0.1070700511,
0.1247286126,
0.0986430272,
0.1743559688,
-0.1948949248,
0.4732748568,
-0.1266465187,
-0.2848307788,
-0.2132653892,
-0.6638207436,
1.0612779856,
-0.1948235333,
-0.3697127104,
-0.35204193,
0.3126682043,
0.5849083066,
-0.5986779332,
1.0516012907,
0.8623170853,
-0.3819712102,
0.2827389538,
-0.7760311365,
-0.1945645958,
-0.4058966637,
0.6541502476,
-0.5241526365,
-0.8910141587,
0.6760766506,
0.2068355381,
0.1511635035,
0.5064041615,
0.7971248031,
0.5260593891,
1.2631874084,
0.9089260697,
-0.476647526,
0.6850281954,
-0.3544704914,
0.2973824441,
-0.7877744436,
-0.3142126203,
-0.6393156052,
0.0220194478,
-0.4425382614,
-0.6749830246,
0.1459536701,
0.0867930949,
-0.3496673405,
0.4289133847,
-0.280205071,
0.4738602638,
0.8380764723,
-0.2049137354,
0.3734099567,
0.0454434231,
-0.3447616994,
0.2641594708,
-0.7258601189,
-0.3225024641,
1.6670560837,
0.3795329332,
0.3971936107,
-0.0574524514,
0.6785216928,
0.0198614877,
0.6706203818,
-0.7589184046,
0.3294331133,
-0.1071366742,
-0.7775986791,
-0.2754094303,
-0.3786236346,
-0.7800470591,
0.3788132071,
-0.1972490549,
-0.650747478,
-0.1052894667,
0.2042556405,
-0.4510357082,
0.534399569,
-0.8438272476,
0.7407554984,
-0.1870739311,
-0.0664215684,
-0.4055739343,
-0.6296749711,
0.3524984717,
-0.3076808155,
0.1248712465,
-0.3514110744,
-0.1080434024,
0.7372870445,
-0.2842333317,
0.7282763124,
-0.2467648983,
0.0958247334,
0.2655003667,
-0.3535055816,
0.5194175839,
-0.061744459,
-0.4346605241,
0.4340096414,
-0.2083984464,
-0.3663677275,
-0.2858695686,
0.4929514527,
-0.6209881306,
-0.3528481424,
-0.0958248973,
-0.4439678788,
-0.2506538332,
0.2669877112,
0.2210927904,
0.6656471491,
0.2430746853,
0.3059402108,
0.0916472897,
-0.1834480166,
0.7058712244,
0.0684753507,
-0.0774427652,
-0.4782826602,
0.6473276019,
0.0397215672,
0.3566263318,
0.4397777617,
0.3405809104,
-0.7733519673,
-0.8361856937,
-0.5609784722,
0.1698844135,
-0.8476724029,
-0.5748718977,
-0.8648108244,
0.0910586268,
-0.6573460102,
0.1774781644,
-0.3532576859,
-0.5432481766,
0.1093224362,
-0.3050450087,
0.4563371837,
0.5316125154,
-0.0853976011,
0.5776875615,
-0.8173745871,
0.1747819036,
0.2160836458,
0.5545598269,
0.3171965778,
-0.5367369652,
-0.3462741375,
-0.2351996601,
-0.1998484433,
-0.6614794135,
0.3807118237,
0.3705168664,
0.6104196906,
0.3744906783,
-0.3645622134,
0.9463498592,
-0.772972405,
0.6988571286,
0.5343182087,
-0.9367165565,
0.0399443023,
-0.1939815581,
0.1212152764,
0.4203356504,
0.1970297396,
-0.6847249269,
-0.3459648788,
-0.4047715366,
-0.7266820669,
0.548740685,
-0.1504819393,
0.3057921231,
-0.2056483924,
0.2141640037,
0.5310536623,
0.4150246978,
-0.7255418301,
-0.0169656239,
-0.0504884832,
-0.0731404349,
-0.3729004264,
-0.2706173658,
0.3862334788,
-0.3959115744,
0.6277413964,
-0.4973634183,
0.6790953875,
-0.2672759593,
0.1781495959,
0.0169050414,
0.0646145195,
0.4456092119,
0.7599487305,
0.1171002612,
0.1194392815,
0.4557133615,
-0.3176289499,
0.0410151444,
0.1234112829,
0.4767279327,
-0.0071530137,
0.5823948383,
0.970821619,
-0.0106308684,
-0.726352632,
0.4508225918,
-0.143889308,
-0.0292379484,
-0.410430491,
-0.2890651524,
0.215699479,
0.2793631256,
0.37192294,
0.2210825533,
0.1528649181,
-0.6506103277,
0.2428288609,
0.5394403934,
0.0713598058,
-0.2026328444,
0.8087599277,
0.0293836519,
-0.1011181176,
0.5696468949,
-0.2303917855,
-0.724745214,
0.7369329333,
0.6521320343,
0.7375934124,
-0.2018104494,
-0.0091364132,
0.4212290645,
0.0162401404,
-0.4198632836,
0.0037447468,
0.0418561101,
-0.7492924333,
-1.1569815874,
-0.8018141389,
-0.3892191947,
0.2438184172,
-0.2695117891,
0.3148661256,
-0.4094631672,
-0.3260666728,
0.1124386489,
0.1210751235,
-0.8856666088,
-0.021981122,
0.2591219544,
0.9657670259,
-0.6995234489,
1.0643726587,
0.5176064372,
-0.310757339,
-1.1208747625,
-0.1583861411,
-0.2660764456,
-1.0023572445,
0.8343359828,
0.8363810778,
0.0539245866,
-0.1203419194,
-0.3328877389,
-1.1946583986,
0.9009098411,
0.6034132242,
-0.5691672564,
-0.1064963415,
-0.1098007783,
0.3636926711,
-0.4532568753,
0.3516951501,
0.6216318607,
0.4677218795,
0.0323930942,
-1.0566439629,
-0.0705679506,
-0.0812096223,
0.2099579871,
0.3451314867,
-0.431024313,
1.0827031136,
-0.4902039766,
-0.0060006524,
0.2445052862,
0.8544131517,
0.2427138388,
0.1826143414,
0.6129387021,
0.3623195291,
0.9382990003,
-0.0386457443,
1.3558046818,
-0.3960838616,
0.0933136791,
0.858572185,
-0.0357996523,
1.0665853024,
0.4684114158,
-0.1185689047,
0.4209884703,
0.7377300858,
0.2065730244,
0.5126895308,
0.2729107738,
-0.1722004861,
-0.3346678913,
-0.1039638892,
-0.4735539854,
0.5651616454,
0.0638021305,
-0.1368643641,
0.1320731342,
0.2256279141,
0.0303221568,
-0.2279436588,
-0.3997457922,
0.5522639751,
-0.0834221542,
-0.8373275995,
0.5417084098,
0.2902697921,
0.9437884092,
-0.4302583337,
0.018472312,
-0.2230979353,
0.3353476524,
0.0665529668,
-0.3398292959,
0.2361876369,
-0.0003392677,
0.1083261222,
-0.1644540578,
0.6988610625,
-0.3102624416,
-0.6196926832,
0.3049601614,
0.4795244634,
0.187277481,
-0.3953639269,
-0.5677310824,
-0.0200694222,
-0.2058816403,
-0.206873849,
0.3205660582,
0.295498997,
-0.1924078912,
0.8449434042,
1.0156655312,
0.2630626559,
0.5062795877,
0.2917523086,
0.9215265512,
-0.5786765814,
-0.5396950841,
-0.9320417047,
0.2765180469,
-0.1314276606,
-0.3344352841,
0.4116168916,
0.6107726097,
0.9295604825,
-0.0976773053,
0.7503071427,
0.0867991075,
0.5143765807,
-0.6419645548,
0.3248433471,
-0.4525955319,
0.024021117,
-0.0649170578,
-0.9619964957,
-0.4348337948,
0.4827223122,
-0.1980932504,
0.1850407571,
0.8081511259,
0.5838856697,
0.0664350241,
-0.1031542942,
0.236548081,
-0.1901442707,
0.5497173667,
0.5728213191,
0.8005631566,
-0.1878695637,
0.6553957462,
-0.3000673354,
0.1074407846,
-0.2444842607,
-0.9433906078,
-1.0582112074,
-0.5269525647,
0.0617128499,
-0.028002454,
0.0152348988,
1.0205081701,
1.064281106,
-0.7953732014,
-0.0455135368,
-0.285045445,
-0.0500968993,
-0.419439137,
-0.1259921938,
0.3893669844,
-0.6795477867,
-0.870242238,
0.2539615035,
0.1083627865,
-0.0480845608,
-0.1886656731,
-0.1988100111,
0.0184249915,
-0.0836849511,
0.7881721854,
-0.1141136885,
-0.7147531509,
-0.4081311524,
-0.0336904414,
0.1039251313,
0.0336725414,
1.0141301155,
-0.7538052797,
0.1807061732,
0.3540335596,
1.0117233992,
0.5542186499,
-0.1265576929,
0.7404315472,
-0.7487094998,
0.4376422465,
0.1541984081,
0.5847937465,
0.5231196284,
-0.2762078941,
0.5017513633,
0.0951820165,
-0.3324213326,
-0.829346478,
0.1194944158,
-0.6486395001,
-0.1104030609,
1.2279102802,
-0.1430886537,
0.033238586,
-0.0324486569,
-0.2703786194,
0.4310516119,
-0.5500572324,
0.5595226288,
0.7158952951,
-0.0820040405,
-0.0603935122,
-0.8095555305,
0.4029767811,
0.597456336,
-0.8280216455,
0.2082536668,
0.4014459848,
0.0750559494,
0.1103099212,
0.8525534868,
-0.0993382111,
0.137780562,
0.1268398315,
0.0399606563,
-0.3259119391,
-0.6754544377,
-0.2478873432,
0.1546785831,
0.4737587869,
-0.2355477363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19733v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19733v3
|
Iterative Reasoning Preference Optimization
| 2024-04-30T17:28:05 | 2024-06-26T01:28:35 |
Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Weizhe Yuan, Kyunghyun Cho, He He, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar, Jason Weston
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Iterative preference optimization methods have recently been shown to perform
well for general instruction tuning tasks, but typically make little
improvement on reasoning tasks (Yuan et al., 2024, Chen et al., 2024). In this
work we develop an iterative approach that optimizes the preference between
competing generated Chain-of-Thought (CoT) candidates by optimizing for winning
vs. losing reasoning steps that lead to the correct answer. We train using a
modified DPO loss (Rafailov et al., 2023) with an additional negative
log-likelihood term, which we find to be crucial. We show reasoning improves
across repeated iterations of this scheme. While only relying on examples in
the training set, our approach results in increasing accuracy on GSM8K, MATH,
and ARC-Challenge for Llama-2-70B-Chat, outperforming other Llama-2-based
models not relying on additionally sourced datasets. For example, we see a
large improvement from 55.6% to 81.6% on GSM8K and an accuracy of 88.7% with
majority voting out of 32 samples.
|
[
-0.4337764978,
-0.5418183804,
0.8600983024,
0.1202127934,
-0.5737894177,
0.2876020968,
-0.4312234521,
-0.0712842345,
-0.0004688565,
0.393866986,
-0.6480264664,
-0.5508552194,
-0.8582362533,
0.0133230714,
-0.0369344912,
0.8021800518,
-0.3691094816,
0.0079290457,
-0.1777708828,
0.0284182597,
-0.6450542212,
-0.5787409544,
-0.7216663957,
-0.5879039764,
0.4165058732,
0.8069640994,
0.4544300735,
0.5368989706,
0.197637096,
0.2621282041,
-0.2715153992,
0.6069353223,
-0.7881827354,
0.0537249967,
-0.4362316132,
-0.6563591361,
-0.2056498528,
0.1151529625,
0.1415549219,
0.3464754522,
-0.4487056732,
0.2807359099,
-0.287007004,
1.1160355806,
-0.7785056829,
-0.1756554246,
-1.1657524109,
0.0409633629,
-0.1842675805,
-0.8029592037,
-0.7848557234,
-0.5533983707,
0.0865955427,
-0.6212848425,
0.1228530928,
0.3639059067,
0.6958825588,
0.4615390897,
-0.3763717115,
-0.5106151104,
-0.5546401739,
1.0404759645,
-0.4917817414,
0.1997193694,
0.4909736514,
0.1233078837,
-0.348808527,
-0.2270309627,
-0.5019891858,
-0.2987923324,
0.3525930047,
0.2692056,
0.026036812,
0.2605077326,
0.0938098282,
0.4370147884,
-0.2396928817,
0.1053175926,
-0.3834388554,
-0.0340909511,
0.7819393277,
0.1191727743,
-0.2189023942,
0.2388977408,
-0.3224744797,
-0.2505763173,
-0.7148736119,
0.2039937824,
0.5745527148,
0.0182051808,
0.3244426847,
0.6648598313,
-0.2641300261,
0.9608576298,
0.5477839112,
-0.3266711533,
0.1310486197,
-0.0433859639,
-0.0584877878,
0.2950100899,
0.3711094558,
0.5571355224,
0.3232701421,
-0.0108161578,
0.1036975831,
0.2297695279,
0.3388011158,
-0.4085478485,
-0.2375359833,
0.329000771,
-0.3132742345,
-0.3637026548,
-0.2491689622,
-0.3124892116,
-0.2220445126,
-0.5832126737,
0.3268022239,
-0.2873379886,
-0.1818916053,
0.5181947351,
-0.2208693922,
0.292976439,
0.5299264193,
-0.9842637181,
0.1324086785,
0.638201654,
0.611263454,
-0.3982101381,
-0.0023012583,
-0.6423201561,
-0.0083193034,
-0.7491158843,
0.9479475617,
-0.6518121362,
-0.535356164,
-0.4558488429,
-0.4801287949,
-0.4923004508,
-0.6322398186,
0.6191520691,
-0.6214312911,
0.1234208122,
-0.5363785625,
-0.7601177692,
-0.0414404832,
0.5397547483,
-0.4498900175,
1.03541255,
-0.1766158789,
-0.6006880403,
0.4363362491,
-0.4414769113,
-0.1508551389,
-0.504871726,
-0.1871895194,
-0.4327682555,
0.2098823488,
0.2981381118,
0.050637193,
-0.448089093,
0.0848939717,
-0.2938517928,
-0.728602767,
0.0238939505,
-0.0561342388,
0.7088644505,
0.0412585028,
-0.7186967731,
0.1059979647,
-0.5260474682,
0.4744228721,
0.2170178145,
-0.351546824,
-0.1878850907,
0.2160806507,
-0.8733193278,
0.0915608853,
-0.0610614754,
-0.5855002403,
0.5094564557,
-0.2641143799,
0.1574015319,
1.2718579769,
-0.0331623405,
0.4049040377,
-0.2743007243,
0.3524065614,
0.1659962833,
0.331078887,
0.502732873,
-0.6836695075,
-1.0059325695,
0.0250855312,
0.1694695204,
0.4488408566,
-0.8767287731,
0.3190507293,
0.1396630555,
-0.3735523522,
-0.5718353391,
0.1441998929,
0.2829985619,
0.5866345167,
0.3545466363,
-0.0874365494,
-0.4734143019,
-0.6118416786,
-0.072834298,
-0.3394046426,
0.3466700912,
0.513017714,
0.1521352082,
-0.1387985796,
0.5148047209,
-0.5739527345,
-0.0202111863,
-0.2321460694,
-0.1190866381,
0.2790917158,
0.1722790599,
0.4520488083,
-0.6114577055,
-0.430736661,
0.1503320485,
-0.4498518407,
0.0938931406,
-0.0563604087,
-0.5095117688,
0.3080753386,
-0.0851020664,
-0.2078771144,
0.579495132,
0.4715816677,
-0.1754930168,
0.4224268496,
-0.0834325925,
0.3720427752,
-0.6792125106,
-0.2133961767,
-0.2474019825,
0.0257562231,
-0.2151682675,
-0.2462573647,
-0.1867351681,
0.2019626647,
-0.0673576146,
0.3494516015,
-0.2261206508,
-0.1412943006,
-0.3087602854,
0.3734214306,
0.0461173207,
0.651180625,
0.309271425,
0.9827764034,
0.4531635344,
-0.7468639016,
0.2955337465,
0.3863960505,
-0.2921507955,
0.2882290781,
-0.5443997979,
0.8075194955,
-0.0768555552,
0.2320314199,
-0.8605592847,
0.2646066844,
0.2901718915,
-0.4140306413,
-0.0115881106,
0.1177368984,
-0.111618273,
-0.5503867865,
-0.495669961,
0.3113739491,
0.3280302882,
-1.0291050673,
0.3142037094,
0.0513230413,
0.2784126997,
-0.9774775505,
-0.0727985501,
-0.0682787448,
-0.1068764254,
-0.4238182902,
0.4381422997,
-0.2050969005,
-0.2497826666,
-0.2420037389,
-0.5109646916,
0.1951754838,
-0.0503665172,
-0.1195504516,
0.2943348885,
0.009935068,
0.2761588991,
0.261315912,
-0.4748390019,
-0.2277609408,
-0.4039889574,
0.630366385,
-0.3031872213,
-0.3617373109,
-0.3252915144,
0.4983157516,
0.130003944,
-0.118924208,
0.5493953824,
0.2021785825,
0.187438488,
-0.4145070314,
-0.6855348945,
-0.0684623644,
-0.4936696887,
-0.0449204929,
-0.657817781,
-0.7948510051,
0.2467287481,
-0.2141787708,
0.0688080341,
0.2959722877,
0.6324211955,
-0.1156127676,
1.2050589323,
0.5812305212,
-0.0837383196,
0.3665725291,
-0.4235961735,
0.4037002623,
-0.8487176299,
-0.2697392404,
-0.3420709074,
-0.2102774233,
-0.6129738688,
-0.4280059636,
0.3562732041,
0.071248509,
-0.4451197684,
0.2532202303,
-0.9522794485,
0.6778666377,
0.9121583104,
0.5900056958,
0.4222631752,
0.0280151032,
-0.2166299969,
0.1760211587,
-0.7948055863,
-0.5752213001,
1.2455658913,
-0.0333389305,
0.8447219729,
-0.0134956241,
1.0814716816,
0.2794443071,
0.1402027756,
-0.8420175314,
0.4673387408,
-0.1513278633,
-0.3562519848,
-0.0379066952,
-0.373634994,
-0.6405454874,
-0.0473362245,
0.100575611,
-0.9136176705,
0.2259137779,
0.5244917274,
-0.1711753309,
0.4706056714,
-0.5463632345,
0.3605129421,
-0.4270467758,
-0.4097540081,
-0.578096807,
-0.6144941449,
0.2585691214,
0.2642623186,
-0.4976011217,
-0.2079689503,
0.0120535577,
0.6210304499,
-0.4265376031,
0.3391104639,
-0.0294050351,
-0.1626467854,
0.6623156071,
-0.1304983348,
0.5818212628,
0.0568201505,
-0.5719103217,
0.1693475097,
-0.1823886931,
-0.5040987134,
-0.6284223199,
0.6108905077,
-0.9515382051,
-1.0775256157,
-0.4282673597,
-0.2383431792,
-0.3144033849,
-0.2334195673,
0.5416290164,
0.3441874683,
0.2665638924,
0.0797358826,
0.838588357,
-0.0137587376,
0.2083774805,
-0.0179634504,
0.1848561764,
-0.5529842973,
0.7133695483,
-0.2007167786,
0.6183407903,
0.3809194565,
0.4032741487,
-0.4144176841,
-0.5424385667,
-0.8599288464,
0.0888385326,
-0.9564657211,
-0.2557767034,
-0.3356165886,
-0.0021899124,
0.2245376706,
-0.3938983679,
-0.5378608108,
-0.4937988222,
-0.2108753026,
-0.2029345483,
0.3134890497,
0.4837487936,
0.1383572221,
0.2115299255,
-0.1128722802,
0.2490877658,
0.456043452,
0.417141974,
0.0336630568,
-0.4255836308,
0.0678058863,
0.0853723437,
-0.588974297,
-0.789537847,
-0.0875944123,
0.0723310262,
0.7177948952,
0.2982053459,
0.1872916818,
0.9828260541,
-0.1186707094,
0.6906847954,
0.1553409547,
-0.9832063317,
0.8563607931,
-0.011519338,
0.0561520718,
0.8471930623,
0.2755955756,
-0.0031072712,
-0.0470050015,
-0.6842990518,
-0.5793522596,
0.6165903211,
0.3084126413,
-0.1333043277,
-0.2098763734,
0.5276328325,
0.1325797439,
0.3625842929,
-0.3698139787,
-0.3487373292,
-0.2268977165,
0.0029055288,
0.2772799432,
-0.2318744063,
-0.2628709078,
-0.435525775,
1.0030516386,
-0.4004378319,
0.4798078239,
0.2620994747,
0.1508724988,
-0.18421112,
0.1372849047,
0.6623088717,
0.6943044066,
-0.2564986348,
0.072089605,
0.2682032585,
-0.2527074814,
0.4429208338,
-0.393345654,
-0.0172500256,
-0.0729354545,
0.0123062087,
1.0617142916,
-0.0810956508,
-0.5492635369,
0.3383961022,
-0.1682516932,
-0.3368934691,
-0.0376781598,
0.3380478024,
-0.0691350698,
0.1883434653,
0.25712502,
0.3004313409,
0.2143338025,
-0.4472807646,
-0.0554424264,
0.2947657108,
-0.0634812415,
0.0860397667,
0.3800643086,
0.3020090759,
-0.2575781345,
0.5272797346,
-0.2346574813,
-0.7186014056,
0.7574945092,
0.6975131631,
0.8703120947,
-0.0247342885,
0.369217664,
0.6793032289,
0.1323948652,
-0.3337988853,
0.3280495703,
-0.5589332581,
-0.918071866,
-0.3511234522,
-0.2097581923,
-0.9018260837,
-0.2044245899,
-0.7044030428,
0.3265836239,
-0.6104646921,
-0.2433415949,
-0.248813048,
0.2575396299,
-0.614826858,
0.2878018022,
0.0585364699,
0.7220988274,
-0.3293852508,
0.7361085415,
0.4914365709,
0.0622557811,
-0.9456287622,
0.0027828137,
-0.068517454,
-1.0699095726,
0.4646869004,
0.2123413086,
-0.609492898,
0.0029343446,
-0.4646423161,
-0.9781517982,
1.1087017059,
0.4196400344,
-0.8964551687,
0.1415497959,
-0.0787662789,
0.22225824,
-0.5222756863,
0.366830796,
0.8190467954,
0.2096241713,
0.5641561151,
-0.9140487313,
-0.2608971,
-0.2649647593,
0.0553499795,
0.2045540512,
-0.9390208125,
0.6417130828,
-0.7067185044,
0.0706896558,
-0.0464420542,
0.2745944858,
0.7893651724,
0.5655654073,
0.6642451286,
0.5192309022,
1.0154367685,
-0.1530906856,
0.917863667,
-0.1149164438,
0.3455686867,
1.2256090641,
-0.333168298,
0.6464181542,
0.5849384069,
-0.1959736198,
0.8032239079,
1.0189089775,
0.4091127217,
0.6689493656,
0.3380359411,
-0.3377880454,
-0.6255046129,
0.0816497728,
-0.2778119445,
0.6114069819,
0.1961920112,
-0.2419680059,
0.0116921607,
-0.1938587427,
-0.0382595696,
0.244486168,
-0.3686223924,
0.9042375088,
-0.0290777497,
-0.9447081685,
1.0025268793,
-0.224620536,
0.4237728417,
-0.3867868483,
-0.0215768293,
-0.2450023443,
0.3877667189,
-0.0350028612,
-0.6108938456,
0.0997716635,
-0.0123632569,
-0.1657480896,
-0.0080555752,
0.6557310224,
-0.2281842083,
-0.3176250756,
0.3153845966,
0.2357629091,
-0.1774913818,
0.1443314105,
-0.7390993834,
0.3332442939,
0.3307514489,
-0.3844404221,
0.0415465981,
0.094739981,
-0.2112590969,
0.8489853144,
0.4355491996,
-0.0611779392,
-0.0779916123,
0.0918356329,
1.179805398,
-0.6760549545,
-0.4130472839,
-0.8555706143,
0.346213907,
-0.5677605867,
-0.6362715364,
0.4584749639,
0.4753013551,
0.8970580697,
0.0248136632,
0.6977051497,
0.0621394366,
0.2002845109,
-0.6190189123,
-0.1336077303,
-0.3499417901,
0.4271134138,
-0.2234134376,
-0.8520258069,
0.1210063621,
0.8197489977,
-0.6206759214,
-0.0907653272,
0.7488209009,
0.5862334967,
0.2837592959,
0.2638628185,
0.1521419138,
-0.4057352841,
0.3083189726,
1.012010932,
0.7828270793,
-0.5250585675,
0.3785640597,
-0.4787186384,
-0.3967754841,
-0.1982699484,
-0.913554728,
-1.0664373636,
-0.3800109327,
-0.3368752003,
-0.2159368545,
0.3339132071,
1.112580061,
0.6377677321,
-0.6844655871,
-0.2267059833,
-0.2399550974,
0.433223784,
-0.4115235507,
-0.1040913686,
0.2862287462,
-0.4739882946,
-0.542752564,
0.262789309,
0.3367491663,
-0.2128563821,
0.1499590725,
-0.2164697498,
-0.2249795347,
0.3314069211,
0.7132048607,
0.1081069112,
-0.8955824971,
-0.6034196019,
0.3840772212,
0.2391117513,
0.1944523305,
0.8055568337,
-0.7534660101,
0.7586116195,
0.3148112595,
0.5771202445,
0.9353169799,
0.2645803094,
0.6657605767,
-0.478715539,
0.1415439844,
0.2819372118,
0.1096664667,
0.2907278538,
-0.4957901239,
0.8456585407,
0.1860675365,
-0.730948329,
-0.6439546347,
0.1466420442,
-1.1844291687,
-0.085048832,
1.1711051464,
0.0770830512,
-0.1200107262,
0.1371475905,
-0.7196136713,
0.0831492096,
-0.5254511237,
1.2715491056,
0.5521740913,
-0.5672733188,
-0.2126616091,
-0.0318611339,
0.5839523673,
0.6025814414,
-0.8009366989,
-0.125825882,
0.1110312492,
0.1313452125,
-0.0041749147,
0.9395486712,
0.1118400767,
0.493253231,
-0.0128111038,
-0.2494687736,
0.025110241,
-0.4039676487,
0.2123489082,
-0.1360763311,
0.3029530346,
-0.47173962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19721v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19721v2
|
PANGeA: Procedural Artificial Narrative using Generative AI for Turn-Based Video Games
| 2024-04-30T17:11:54 | 2024-06-30T20:54:57 |
Steph Buongiorno, Lawrence Jake Klinkert, Tanishq Chawla, Zixin Zhuang, Corey Clark
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This research introduces Procedural Artificial Narrative using Generative AI
(PANGeA), a structured approach for leveraging large language models (LLMs),
guided by a game designer's high-level criteria, to generate narrative content
for turn-based role-playing video games (RPGs). Distinct from prior
applications of LLMs used for video game design, PANGeA innovates by not only
generating game level data (which includes, but is not limited to, setting, key
items, and non-playable characters (NPCs)), but by also fostering dynamic,
free-form interactions between the player and the environment that align with
the procedural game narrative. The NPCs generated by PANGeA are
personality-biased and express traits from the Big 5 Personality Model in their
generated responses. PANGeA addresses challenges behind ingesting free-form
text input, which can prompt LLM responses beyond the scope of the game
narrative. A novel validation system that uses the LLM's intelligence evaluates
text input and aligns generated responses with the unfolding narrative. Making
these interactions possible, PANGeA is supported by a server that hosts a
custom memory system that supplies context for augmenting generated responses
thus aligning them with the procedural narrative. For its broad application,
the server has a REST interface enabling any game engine to integrate directly
with PANGeA, as well as an LLM interface adaptable with local or private LLMs.
PANGeA's ability to foster dynamic narrative generation by aligning responses
with the procedural narrative is demonstrated through an empirical study and
ablation test of two versions of a demo game. These are, a custom,
browser-based GPT and a Unity demo. As the results show, PANGeA holds potential
to assist game designers in using LLMs to generate narrative-consistent content
even when provided varied and unpredictable, free-form text input.
|
[
-0.4287615716,
-0.8868707418,
0.8815033436,
0.4595990479,
-0.491463542,
0.374447912,
-0.1849315017,
-0.5312321782,
0.481182456,
0.6863238215,
-0.8288274407,
-0.7800366879,
-0.2858048379,
0.3583012521,
-0.4002197385,
0.7388258576,
-0.0761661902,
-0.2679737508,
-0.1996429116,
-0.0083484491,
-0.3976733387,
-0.396238625,
-0.6903669834,
-0.3072480559,
0.2804616988,
0.0419571325,
0.5901488662,
1.0526169538,
0.4305766821,
0.4221144319,
0.1133443862,
0.4643170834,
-0.6487016678,
0.2477344126,
-0.079731524,
-0.6060524583,
-0.2071782947,
-0.1448110193,
0.2013900429,
0.0119414711,
-0.0911870077,
0.2604268491,
-0.2602907121,
0.2596870363,
-0.2145322114,
0.2340890914,
-0.3739331961,
0.2686057985,
-0.1408455372,
-0.2943589389,
-0.364107728,
-0.6200296283,
0.2317305058,
-1.1125539541,
0.2891211808,
-0.0135546373,
0.5668614507,
0.5115681887,
-0.0851127654,
-0.8276166916,
-0.9899073243,
0.4304408133,
-1.0211730003,
-0.1437367648,
0.0443919487,
0.1596994996,
-0.2132181823,
-0.5480717421,
-0.7295355201,
-0.4343175888,
0.3570222557,
0.4055852294,
0.1252323538,
0.2637868822,
0.0416635424,
0.4810461998,
-0.58790797,
0.5155524015,
-0.2110423148,
-0.0828016996,
0.8943558335,
0.5226979852,
0.5973575115,
-0.211812377,
-0.4004022479,
-0.1082932428,
-0.9181100726,
0.2384249717,
0.6380777359,
0.2832708061,
-0.2486805171,
0.6927937269,
0.1730974019,
0.4687912166,
0.1882687211,
-0.3223803639,
-0.1578143388,
-0.2476246208,
-0.0321372598,
0.362067908,
0.9286087751,
0.6297178864,
0.0338975601,
-0.2274425328,
-0.0704683885,
0.6018927097,
0.4767890573,
-0.8387697935,
-0.1220104396,
0.433701396,
-0.5207290053,
-0.5682192445,
0.0668796077,
-1.2380912304,
-0.9575096965,
-0.0883855596,
-0.2860223949,
-0.4516845047,
-0.1437127292,
-0.2939732373,
-0.2512609363,
0.2250193357,
0.1793399006,
-1.0381797552,
0.1699359417,
0.7557063103,
0.9889654517,
-0.5426766872,
-0.2332639545,
-0.335759908,
0.3866437972,
-0.4745108187,
0.8700917363,
-0.5864741802,
-0.8677241802,
0.3086348772,
-0.183617875,
0.4365547895,
-0.7675433159,
0.2010173649,
-0.2320612371,
-0.0636969507,
-0.1035425365,
-0.4332328439,
-0.1408263743,
0.3694561422,
-0.6656885743,
0.672278285,
-0.0233649239,
-0.0377456434,
0.5290285349,
-0.6514106393,
-0.4007903337,
0.4181234539,
-0.2741148472,
-0.1069371998,
0.3726893663,
0.1300929636,
-0.2215201706,
-0.471272856,
0.2475978732,
-0.1772029698,
-0.4067554176,
0.2138633281,
-0.2682914436,
0.2959814072,
-0.0598662794,
-0.4710553885,
0.4544267058,
-0.7595968246,
-0.0666797236,
0.1846692115,
-0.3729855418,
-0.0121043436,
0.4392901957,
-0.3737468123,
0.2444097102,
0.2243401706,
-0.5233409405,
0.5209462047,
-0.4658719599,
0.5256711245,
0.7828524113,
0.1914828122,
0.3431828916,
-0.2834578156,
0.6532635093,
-0.1702110916,
0.0722816661,
-0.3109952807,
-0.4582304657,
-0.6061879992,
-0.209679231,
-0.0093738688,
0.8175806999,
-1.0797255039,
0.2147726268,
0.0469870344,
-0.5562310219,
-0.6207956076,
0.1547091305,
0.2349606007,
0.4104753733,
0.2337519377,
-0.3207057416,
-0.7858300805,
-0.4740429223,
0.2222550064,
-0.4902178049,
-0.194499597,
0.539327085,
0.1495646983,
-0.1588713825,
0.8053575158,
-0.4628343582,
-0.2929627299,
-0.3880308568,
0.4601436555,
0.0034369989,
0.1687037796,
0.5239248276,
-0.4775068462,
-0.2048493326,
-0.0389653556,
-0.9646239877,
-0.2991212904,
-0.3843818903,
0.1702207774,
0.2412442714,
0.2011687607,
-0.8006685972,
0.5144516826,
0.6202523112,
-0.2611504793,
0.8034719825,
-0.3435868621,
0.225168407,
-0.9862632155,
-0.0577071905,
-0.1011909321,
0.1427825838,
-0.3961596191,
0.2830837071,
-0.6179435849,
-0.2273808867,
-0.3702549338,
0.5375127792,
-0.2345535606,
-0.1093825698,
-0.375366509,
0.5629972219,
-0.1678181291,
0.5140911341,
0.2602224648,
0.9145363569,
0.2200919688,
-0.5681011081,
0.8273183107,
0.3468809128,
-0.208548367,
0.6196815968,
-0.7404661179,
0.282697171,
0.0475577451,
0.2133066952,
-0.8008035421,
-0.0627623349,
0.0853846371,
-0.3045821786,
-0.4065009356,
-0.0865367278,
-0.5281097889,
-0.5795269608,
-0.2408727556,
0.180546537,
0.6090405583,
-0.4139248729,
0.8254886866,
0.3007198572,
-0.3151515722,
-0.0521744639,
-0.7231655121,
0.2712576091,
-0.4457115829,
-0.4539093673,
0.4045547247,
-0.2126876116,
-0.2453154922,
-0.0175226144,
0.1864501536,
0.0260768775,
-0.1726184189,
0.4709492624,
0.3897424638,
-0.4556749165,
-0.235590294,
0.0337767228,
-0.064747788,
0.2182542086,
-0.3080663085,
0.9392818213,
0.0329699144,
-0.2271323502,
-0.4540149271,
0.4107106626,
0.5950180888,
-0.2041626871,
0.3715860248,
0.2716259956,
-0.0125187961,
-0.1771290004,
-0.2808736563,
-0.0129486313,
-0.5043126345,
0.2157922834,
-0.2063527703,
-0.6688703895,
1.0539468527,
-0.2948645055,
0.1337281168,
0.3240468204,
0.674089849,
0.0862441212,
1.2800548077,
0.6463836432,
-0.0212745592,
0.2122201174,
-0.2282450944,
0.0910149962,
-0.7369702458,
-0.3206360638,
-0.2225309014,
-0.4912584722,
-0.6608889103,
-0.2511557639,
0.1296654493,
-0.2408370823,
-0.2625459731,
0.0750691518,
-0.6762062907,
0.5056275725,
0.5545104146,
-0.0056874715,
0.4129146338,
-0.4050815403,
-0.0612912476,
-0.0275237709,
-0.4478226006,
-0.6503546238,
0.7516313195,
0.0395445302,
0.5475115776,
0.2101378739,
0.7744801641,
0.4866148531,
0.3596588969,
-0.6647612453,
0.777469337,
-0.2413717359,
-0.2397566587,
-0.3629868627,
-0.2841191888,
-0.8826879859,
-0.083311215,
-0.2479544878,
-0.7806115746,
-0.153226316,
0.0481428169,
-0.7699923515,
0.3554897904,
-0.4713479877,
0.5176906586,
-0.4442142844,
-0.1921046823,
-0.1444363594,
-0.4280111492,
0.316740185,
0.2160192579,
-0.2251753509,
0.0555846281,
-0.0971429422,
0.3732410073,
-0.4707484245,
1.0579427481,
-0.2156203687,
-0.1861913502,
0.6425974965,
0.6790158749,
0.3897867203,
0.3009872437,
0.1777494997,
0.0088983821,
-0.1033931375,
-0.0452923439,
-0.6992077827,
0.7950436473,
-0.9606404901,
-0.6726521254,
-0.4968350828,
-0.7688671947,
-0.1230299175,
0.4271621704,
0.1642007381,
0.3259425163,
-0.5704442263,
-0.1130675301,
0.5760171413,
-0.4183316529,
0.4515376985,
0.2984994352,
-0.3437278867,
-0.5859528184,
1.0644968748,
-0.1686202586,
0.1084821299,
0.0069182953,
0.0548069552,
-0.286840409,
-0.8422957659,
-0.8459367752,
0.0924378037,
-0.2199809402,
-0.1025063396,
-0.0307321437,
-0.1585871726,
-0.173959285,
-0.4939276278,
-0.1605312675,
0.0369213857,
-0.4269759059,
-0.4009746313,
0.2480791062,
1.0372370481,
0.2062759846,
0.5580410361,
-0.6159065366,
0.3959017396,
-0.0573088527,
0.3156476319,
-0.0515211374,
0.0088149505,
0.4309438765,
0.1644681096,
-0.2458955199,
-0.9107042551,
0.5788226724,
-0.0821926743,
0.3332412839,
0.5721896291,
-0.3254100084,
0.8175693154,
-0.6240413189,
1.2421199083,
0.1095202938,
-0.7264806628,
0.4924001992,
-0.4717379212,
0.461845696,
0.5586800575,
0.0415544622,
-0.7171751857,
-0.5098829269,
-0.5358721614,
-0.7545977235,
0.6085034013,
-0.0313195735,
0.1054122224,
-0.2347533852,
0.4582519233,
0.3312049508,
0.4555382133,
-0.3370715678,
0.06026664,
-0.3515446186,
-0.4967750907,
-0.0146861114,
-0.1483773738,
-0.1424505711,
0.2981759906,
0.4207186103,
-0.2248854041,
0.150522083,
0.1665341854,
-0.0327232815,
-0.0290748905,
-0.351148963,
0.8577095866,
0.5957859755,
0.1402765661,
-0.0556846,
0.0411118791,
-0.5664595962,
0.0282232929,
-0.023137683,
-0.6183601618,
-0.2293577492,
0.29332757,
0.8771247268,
-0.0743497163,
-0.9242603183,
-0.0047550392,
0.0042805132,
-0.2348720282,
-0.3999529779,
0.0145439329,
-0.0719755813,
0.2957150638,
0.2680000961,
-0.1983081549,
-0.0744148791,
-0.7375147939,
0.0856463611,
0.1730151325,
-0.3395116031,
-0.4473913312,
0.7113801837,
0.4971576929,
-0.634629786,
0.9671549201,
-0.2223592848,
-0.2486768067,
0.7865747809,
0.9641389251,
0.8283305168,
-0.2464165688,
0.7519628406,
0.1412204802,
0.3132246435,
0.311430335,
0.2729269266,
0.2489670664,
-0.5141623616,
-0.51173985,
-0.4732080996,
-0.4325361848,
0.2023142427,
-0.1486040503,
-0.0418351442,
-0.8877152205,
-0.0714811683,
-0.4930916131,
-0.0100930547,
-0.2672870457,
-0.0715722293,
0.4512650371,
0.8764030337,
-0.6702623963,
0.0546387993,
0.4138281345,
-0.8683340549,
-0.6190703511,
-0.1519994587,
0.296623379,
-0.8334713578,
0.1713631749,
-0.0192174893,
-0.0378849097,
-0.054211162,
-0.4734211266,
-0.5566424727,
1.1464021206,
0.1723258644,
-0.1716829538,
-0.4059867561,
0.7125635743,
0.8762190342,
-0.6528480649,
0.0483415388,
0.5823406577,
0.4546251297,
0.3141540289,
-0.4913703203,
0.0527208894,
-0.1629374772,
0.1990169585,
0.1816450506,
-0.8354910016,
0.4041923881,
-0.1013059691,
-0.1386702061,
0.5798308849,
0.90531075,
0.6662135124,
0.3166101575,
0.2295464426,
0.6644892693,
0.8359404206,
-0.457731545,
1.0718274117,
-0.3637712896,
-0.2291359156,
0.8084430099,
-0.5429028869,
0.452393353,
0.3510006964,
0.1155789867,
0.9804114699,
0.6532822251,
-0.2578897476,
0.4732897878,
0.3837934434,
-0.3056798875,
0.1713430583,
-0.3051923215,
0.0582458042,
0.5005452037,
0.3506013453,
-0.0889716074,
-0.2139514238,
0.0819713622,
-0.0392339602,
0.2033230364,
-0.4844252169,
1.0029585361,
-0.1464720964,
-0.8957914114,
-0.1225059032,
-0.1500828415,
0.5191130042,
-0.839109242,
-0.2632237375,
-0.417555064,
0.1679659635,
-0.0172685944,
-0.6093601584,
0.0764583424,
0.1443917453,
-0.1106023788,
0.0631183386,
0.4507091939,
-0.397461772,
-0.4974405169,
-0.1757517159,
0.3967064023,
0.0753357038,
0.0602608696,
-0.5605809093,
0.4622695744,
-0.1542173028,
0.1310457885,
0.1372991949,
0.5881300569,
-0.2731699646,
0.6487044692,
0.7511821985,
0.3415057361,
0.1255007237,
0.1564724594,
0.6131263375,
-0.5961917043,
-0.7951188684,
-0.8950111866,
0.3069691658,
-0.2638399601,
-0.5401116014,
0.6088783145,
0.6815572381,
0.4076837897,
-0.0932205915,
0.94307971,
-0.1813758761,
-0.0326963365,
-0.5523886085,
0.3941287398,
0.1254709363,
-0.1319926977,
0.0205676872,
-0.9829546809,
-0.1913476586,
0.2566928566,
-0.2249087691,
-0.0707621649,
0.6070796847,
0.4644616544,
0.2482908964,
0.0470009036,
0.0273212381,
0.2317421585,
0.7859062552,
0.6810860634,
0.8427618742,
0.1408545822,
0.4393297434,
-0.0324754082,
-0.3713100851,
-0.0240426641,
-0.8554033041,
-0.9079334736,
-0.4636120796,
-0.0108391326,
-0.280551523,
0.1050219312,
0.7197983861,
0.3255693316,
-0.7083938122,
-0.3869310319,
-0.3122256398,
-0.1863003671,
-0.3493901789,
-0.2988445163,
0.1961716115,
-0.0568978526,
-0.795141995,
0.6096201539,
0.5100637674,
0.0681924075,
-0.8338855505,
-0.0125399567,
0.0331341177,
0.3702966273,
0.6332607269,
0.6974909902,
-0.8600937128,
-0.3649418056,
0.2315962017,
0.2110584974,
0.1270052344,
1.206043005,
-0.8679485917,
0.3943289518,
0.3773703575,
0.7761856318,
0.5095923543,
0.3997441828,
0.9884040952,
-0.5150706172,
0.3203063607,
0.4449435771,
0.0817942843,
0.2644197047,
-0.5047162175,
0.3712399006,
0.1151792929,
-0.4485526085,
-0.6191723943,
0.3862960041,
-0.9138444066,
0.0229218658,
1.0952267647,
0.0408634022,
-0.4516761005,
0.1104282439,
-0.5662856698,
0.1538502127,
-0.4232545197,
1.2168443203,
0.9932941198,
-0.279779762,
-0.1035469323,
-0.3369228542,
0.6685496569,
-0.0076532327,
-0.9877689481,
0.063386187,
0.8335760832,
-0.2626520395,
0.4937496781,
0.3338200748,
-0.2006537765,
0.3214283884,
0.0581497699,
0.1171637848,
-0.4185088575,
-0.2681648433,
0.0840424895,
0.2297742069,
-0.2326852083,
0.0965921432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19714v1
|
ThangDLU at #SMM4H 2024: Encoder-decoder models for classifying text data on social disorders in children and adolescents
| 2024-04-30T17:06:20 | 2024-04-30T17:06:20 |
Hoang-Thang Ta, Abu Bakar Siddiqur Rahman, Lotfollah Najjar, Alexander Gelbukh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes our participation in Task 3 and Task 5 of the #SMM4H
(Social Media Mining for Health) 2024 Workshop, explicitly targeting the
classification challenges within tweet data. Task 3 is a multi-class
classification task centered on tweets discussing the impact of outdoor
environments on symptoms of social anxiety. Task 5 involves a binary
classification task focusing on tweets reporting medical disorders in children.
We applied transfer learning from pre-trained encoder-decoder models such as
BART-base and T5-small to identify the labels of a set of given tweets. We also
presented some data augmentation methods to see their impact on the model
performance. Finally, the systems obtained the best F1 score of 0.627 in Task 3
and the best F1 score of 0.841 in Task 5.
|
[
0.0251634866,
-0.3614309728,
0.5832445621,
0.0702285916,
-0.0569588281,
0.204486385,
0.1651651561,
-0.7956991792,
0.127415508,
0.2501713037,
-0.5410831571,
-0.6991741657,
-0.9825515151,
0.1475450248,
-0.5367684364,
0.8324108124,
-0.2228181362,
0.0310320985,
-0.1435925961,
0.2193972766,
-0.0971383005,
-0.7341922522,
-0.6970540285,
-0.1257129908,
0.3956416547,
0.5383163691,
0.0943079144,
0.2854152322,
0.7367824912,
0.2056156099,
0.0266799349,
0.1171775535,
-0.6274830103,
-0.0023590163,
-0.2732492387,
-0.2494962364,
-0.5168511868,
0.0315984078,
0.3445151746,
0.5323085189,
-0.0341356583,
0.2859222889,
0.2755079567,
0.2578837276,
-0.2580089867,
0.2984962761,
-0.3328187764,
0.0696504563,
-0.2494282275,
-0.403842777,
-0.2007563561,
-0.2119384259,
-0.1374507248,
-0.2372705787,
0.356338799,
0.0286157597,
0.7235779166,
0.286442697,
-0.741266489,
-0.2564254403,
-0.4847227335,
0.5728592873,
-0.5433633327,
0.3235605955,
0.6816254854,
0.089909181,
-0.0056751342,
-0.7688382268,
-0.3334605992,
0.4812190235,
0.0296667702,
-0.1272357702,
-0.1987744123,
0.1150211394,
0.1725500524,
-0.0126167778,
-0.4865267575,
-0.0549909547,
-0.9192121029,
-0.1044493914,
0.7338501215,
0.325671494,
0.2730222046,
-0.2379269302,
0.1154002026,
0.3109731674,
-0.2110999376,
0.0442197099,
-0.1382635236,
0.2031428069,
-0.2501655817,
0.357925266,
0.0430136733,
0.3663981557,
0.2586007714,
-0.1909648627,
0.6215225458,
-0.3716811538,
-0.0076185162,
-0.0539005995,
0.7020488381,
0.7241039276,
-0.09455093,
-0.10884431,
-0.3172684312,
0.2014971226,
0.4613092542,
-0.9580612779,
-0.2865493298,
0.0195476543,
-0.8336766362,
-0.5736837387,
-0.0156337991,
-0.8547075987,
-0.4377774596,
-0.183893919,
0.4856161475,
-0.5106810927,
-0.2311735749,
0.0363045186,
-0.0530056804,
-0.0916978195,
0.2690028548,
-0.9436974525,
0.7038513422,
0.463940829,
0.7485889792,
-0.3117370009,
-0.0257517155,
-0.1010479107,
0.2448311597,
-0.2246162295,
0.6029961109,
-0.724847436,
-0.3448240757,
-0.1215210333,
0.5077813268,
-0.4845113754,
-0.3421703577,
0.7072144747,
-0.2532057762,
0.0277127326,
-0.3970596194,
-0.4751166105,
-0.2634230852,
0.3292745948,
-0.5232875943,
0.9376431108,
0.4659425914,
-0.9464694858,
0.2248375565,
-0.8116691113,
-0.5204716325,
0.1425716132,
0.1092835739,
-0.23499915,
-0.0448509157,
0.2912239134,
0.8257534504,
-0.0757107213,
0.1595603377,
-0.4893782437,
-0.531396389,
0.114730075,
-0.0648448691,
0.5777126551,
0.0922740027,
-0.2390051186,
0.065598838,
-0.6114755869,
-0.0827771053,
0.0743371993,
-0.204801172,
-0.0466885157,
-0.0607238375,
0.2680582404,
0.2386611402,
0.2636885047,
-0.6537051797,
-0.0596819185,
0.0176267233,
0.5818596482,
0.6836157441,
0.4026340842,
0.3502743244,
-0.5854331851,
0.5888201594,
0.185459435,
0.4104687572,
0.1054567844,
-0.6877352595,
-0.3061408103,
0.0156627335,
0.1654688567,
0.333997637,
-1.0867743492,
0.2985523641,
-0.3698808849,
-0.5165933371,
-0.5190463662,
-0.2117089182,
-0.0077397232,
0.133550331,
0.4885440469,
0.0510334969,
-0.7982653975,
-0.4103656411,
-0.053688284,
0.0643717498,
0.2421972007,
0.1525941342,
0.760025084,
-0.8916454315,
0.383980453,
-0.2012926787,
-0.33229509,
-0.3117956519,
0.0628232136,
-0.186534062,
0.6079922915,
0.6559982896,
-0.775799334,
-0.6029058695,
0.0491902344,
-0.7355872393,
-0.2112166882,
0.5403368473,
0.1106509268,
0.1674479842,
0.5411118269,
-0.4648513496,
0.4854874909,
0.6618981361,
-0.3173495531,
0.1846812367,
0.2015858293,
0.4731811881,
-1.1422493458,
-0.1217281744,
0.099096559,
-0.4428155422,
-0.8784757257,
-0.130711183,
0.0689656362,
-0.0929526389,
-0.180903092,
0.1214734241,
-0.2553975284,
0.1894333512,
-0.2426457256,
-0.4315093756,
-0.1591172814,
0.1510980576,
-0.3383993804,
0.0943536758,
0.7690374255,
-0.5392697453,
0.3056208491,
-0.2334911823,
-0.0061381357,
0.2441510558,
-0.3267571926,
0.2761427164,
-0.3117439747,
0.2551080883,
-0.8017636538,
-0.509843111,
0.5593600869,
-0.8158792853,
0.3856510818,
0.0835639089,
-0.6117224097,
-0.7157047391,
-0.4127643108,
0.4987870753,
0.3899392486,
-0.4200676382,
0.5347607732,
0.7818136811,
0.1576833278,
-0.1328188181,
-0.6651108861,
-0.2403822988,
-0.4380328059,
-0.4300334752,
0.8005049825,
0.0289316177,
0.1379753947,
0.4639056921,
-0.1032941863,
-0.1778403521,
-0.027711885,
0.443476975,
-0.0373771191,
0.066188097,
0.0088205906,
0.0562803783,
0.0272473544,
0.1916587651,
0.1057835147,
0.4745230675,
0.0207948405,
-0.078185834,
-0.3400447667,
0.3513914645,
0.2816562057,
0.1078495085,
0.6975909472,
0.7631674409,
-0.9958680272,
-0.1491350085,
-0.1623432338,
-0.2352211177,
-0.4990521669,
0.1760323942,
-0.3480509818,
-1.0890043974,
0.3573884368,
0.0170771498,
-0.1310381293,
0.3172526062,
0.2437047064,
-0.2915446758,
1.2041343451,
0.7295724154,
-0.0884955525,
0.3079918027,
-0.3529580832,
0.2881025374,
-0.5028499365,
-0.4266244173,
-0.4548840523,
-0.3344879746,
-0.6481926441,
-0.5438611507,
0.1826588362,
-0.4801611602,
-0.1574808806,
0.1597616673,
-0.5684595108,
0.1940155774,
0.1377975047,
0.462819159,
-0.2371650487,
-0.1954560876,
0.3926903307,
-0.358356297,
-0.7088592052,
-0.409124136,
1.1848591566,
0.550737679,
0.5911573172,
0.0673054606,
0.9986035824,
0.366219908,
0.7116159797,
-0.5931907892,
0.541911304,
-0.3497848809,
-0.6297040582,
-0.0225277264,
-0.50287956,
-1.0634447336,
-0.0103798676,
-0.2253563851,
-0.9127165675,
0.2822780907,
-0.1992063224,
-0.2912863493,
0.2423982024,
-0.5448572636,
0.8925362229,
-0.1247931719,
0.0006410757,
-0.1183253527,
-0.6846562624,
0.4213052392,
-0.3326927125,
0.6850750446,
-0.1977397799,
-0.052862145,
1.115044713,
-0.059138149,
0.8497422338,
-0.3625898659,
0.392293185,
0.09727256,
-0.3439227343,
0.054380767,
-0.3530678749,
-0.0067038201,
-0.0089894421,
0.4074116647,
-0.3456633091,
-0.4405573905,
0.7433636189,
-0.9138427973,
-0.1616883576,
-0.6777268052,
-0.1109770089,
-0.1691348553,
0.1989253014,
0.3545931876,
0.336896956,
-0.0397660807,
0.3461318016,
0.4400677383,
0.0782576427,
0.3266654015,
0.3434536457,
-0.2258194536,
-0.2569257021,
0.9797502756,
0.3999748826,
-0.1177138239,
0.189143464,
-0.0189043917,
-0.048231028,
-0.6996021271,
0.1821914613,
0.1833721399,
-0.8073709607,
-0.3814384937,
-0.7427169681,
-0.5327284932,
-0.7792734504,
-0.0539039113,
-0.1234009787,
-0.1313683242,
-0.7911037207,
-0.5128240585,
0.1144351214,
1.1160542965,
-0.2254828364,
0.4922860861,
-0.9463686943,
0.4478439391,
-0.1271531731,
0.3399354815,
0.023352515,
-0.4660475254,
-0.4863241017,
-0.0681177899,
-0.5971878767,
-1.0949573517,
0.6210138202,
0.1316415966,
0.5764042139,
0.5382497907,
0.2120111734,
0.6959490776,
-0.2684407532,
0.7421389222,
0.0670066401,
-0.7462313771,
0.4455371499,
-0.2985413373,
-0.1005712897,
0.5647546649,
0.8938946724,
-0.3546514809,
-0.1115937456,
-0.8857380152,
-0.6566809416,
0.9827849865,
0.2801092863,
-0.0378198661,
-0.0527222641,
0.4317362607,
-0.0167123731,
-0.0885944888,
-0.7561481595,
-0.0781462789,
-0.2364265174,
-0.641765058,
-0.0590621606,
-0.5492914915,
0.2293264121,
-0.5944693089,
0.5195875168,
0.1446502954,
0.3829751611,
0.029916618,
-0.0424157009,
-0.4113201499,
-0.1194918677,
0.1317223459,
0.4996863902,
-0.4885890186,
0.4279205799,
0.1789100617,
-0.4612006545,
0.1587396264,
0.2761958539,
0.0863314122,
0.0846801698,
0.4920412004,
0.7075158358,
0.4260104895,
-0.208693698,
0.5414372683,
-0.2908481956,
-0.5579820871,
-0.2598474026,
0.0999561027,
0.0899757817,
0.0647922829,
0.4435601234,
0.0880310163,
0.6504265666,
-0.6996108294,
0.2846671641,
-0.0881285816,
-0.4883169532,
-0.7486385703,
0.5717278719,
0.1908401251,
-0.2132277191,
0.2088236064,
-0.332644403,
-0.8114418983,
0.514122963,
0.5382857919,
0.6053351164,
-0.6406830549,
0.0580852702,
0.4807502925,
0.5016934276,
-0.2397950739,
0.7036499381,
0.2780069113,
-0.8916264772,
-0.1634880602,
-0.4229665995,
-0.102344051,
0.1564668864,
-0.6921877861,
0.3112999499,
-0.2053186595,
-0.5956633091,
0.1340678185,
-0.0274740495,
-0.6390182376,
0.4808641374,
0.1707931757,
0.4465129077,
-0.9633862972,
0.8795757294,
0.8154065609,
0.057609234,
-0.6829518676,
0.2589722872,
0.0616349988,
-0.270375073,
0.3318870962,
0.6013976336,
-0.0012452949,
0.1144482717,
-0.9016165137,
-0.978871882,
0.9240686893,
-0.0493100099,
-0.2511657774,
-0.1515067965,
0.1167028919,
0.530107379,
-0.5156134963,
-0.014604615,
0.7549025416,
0.3968653381,
0.207862854,
-0.8873279095,
0.1820512116,
-0.6384354234,
-0.0284358468,
-0.0331432112,
-0.2449672967,
0.6449170113,
-0.1959783733,
-0.4064374268,
-0.208089456,
0.3872857094,
0.1517741382,
0.7365366817,
0.2952983081,
0.4137876332,
0.7025696039,
-0.1590085477,
0.9927277565,
-0.3149658442,
0.3123097122,
0.6457723975,
-0.0190342702,
0.6803200841,
0.1174774244,
-0.2646543086,
0.1192713827,
1.0589720011,
0.3373257518,
0.7209454775,
-0.0822083205,
-0.1458042711,
0.0642727911,
-0.0905981809,
-0.3387016058,
0.1004350707,
0.94787848,
-0.2933302522,
0.1173556447,
0.3141399026,
-0.0937070549,
-0.2535627782,
-0.4172073901,
0.7312407494,
0.398260206,
-0.1706518829,
0.474093467,
0.3673716486,
0.820114255,
-0.1985265613,
0.0016419552,
0.1622667611,
0.2961714268,
-0.5406631827,
-0.8044141531,
0.7456078529,
-0.1787305623,
-0.0819991156,
-0.2716367841,
1.1139374971,
-0.5027127266,
-0.6764609218,
0.5663720369,
0.0548692346,
0.3851167858,
-0.1364814639,
-0.6462960243,
0.2332364768,
0.0275046695,
-0.0323761776,
0.17871508,
0.7991713285,
-0.2206133008,
0.5903040767,
0.5073628426,
-0.0951267928,
0.1466793716,
0.1895026118,
0.8718073368,
-0.7976877093,
-0.3284730017,
-0.808098793,
0.3197221756,
-0.0040335758,
0.1682757437,
0.7019992471,
0.4574458599,
0.5476158261,
-0.0084723439,
0.8838495016,
-0.177733466,
0.9104681015,
-0.0059362338,
0.6258271337,
-0.5445438623,
0.0012827828,
-0.2475375533,
-0.4992002547,
-0.3615083396,
0.5687302351,
-0.4001030922,
0.1119185537,
0.898686111,
0.5786362886,
0.0009442753,
0.2405787408,
0.1007421911,
0.0462025851,
0.3691342771,
0.7349211574,
0.7458141446,
-0.5459290147,
0.2452369034,
-0.4372969568,
-0.251767844,
-0.3291772008,
-0.3132946491,
-0.9674549103,
-0.6797848344,
-0.2428560704,
-0.4446344972,
0.3641490638,
0.9327463508,
0.6738328934,
-0.8048965931,
-0.0500269309,
0.1456348151,
0.0331024565,
-0.0132914288,
-0.2543702126,
0.2397780865,
-0.0772384331,
-0.4310748577,
0.0947620273,
-0.0555834807,
0.2572499216,
0.2824388146,
-0.0805971846,
-0.1226272136,
-0.179736048,
0.6382508278,
-0.2859768867,
-0.2120984346,
-0.207246542,
-0.0506718382,
-0.1540430784,
0.014214756,
0.4114980698,
-0.3704124093,
0.0990147516,
0.4305247068,
0.5077781081,
0.738298595,
0.2208013088,
0.3631356359,
-0.5127480626,
-0.2479021996,
0.40373227,
0.2140891403,
0.6572657228,
-0.4437563121,
0.6479572058,
0.3640469313,
-0.5560927987,
-0.9364016652,
-0.4176560044,
-1.0050017834,
-0.2504891753,
1.1772292852,
0.0265450981,
-0.4634456336,
-0.494897753,
-0.1825810373,
0.3410590589,
-0.4058071673,
0.6638864279,
0.583000958,
-0.1201981679,
-0.6575796604,
-0.6072263122,
0.7448841333,
-0.407623142,
-0.921253264,
-0.4970369041,
0.1504285187,
0.4102637172,
-0.1858207732,
1.0459945202,
-0.159030661,
0.2509462535,
-0.0378935859,
0.0705679059,
0.1454458833,
-0.2361704409,
-0.1586294323,
0.1816547513,
-0.1573320627,
-0.3173492849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19713v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19713v2
|
Automated Generation of High-Quality Medical Simulation Scenarios Through Integration of Semi-Structured Data and Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T17:06:11 | 2024-05-06T17:58:48 |
Scott Sumpter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study introduces a transformative framework for medical education by
integrating semi-structured data with Large Language Models (LLMs), primarily
OpenAIs ChatGPT3.5, to automate the creation of medical simulation scenarios.
Traditionally, developing these scenarios was a time-intensive process with
limited flexibility to meet diverse educational needs. The proposed approach
utilizes AI to efficiently generate detailed, clinically relevant scenarios
that are tailored to specific educational objectives. This innovation has
significantly reduced the time and resources required for scenario development,
allowing for a broader variety of simulations. Preliminary feedback from
educators and learners has shown enhanced engagement and improved knowledge
acquisition, confirming the effectiveness of this AI-enhanced methodology in
simulation-based learning. The integration of structured data with LLMs not
only streamlines the creation process but also offers a scalable, dynamic
solution that could revolutionize medical training, highlighting the critical
role of AI in advancing educational outcomes and patient care standards.
|
[
-0.0898026526,
-1.0691463947,
0.8200522065,
-0.0040634368,
-0.1037334874,
0.279196769,
-0.1481637806,
-0.248316437,
0.1052390635,
0.3111561239,
-0.4255985916,
-0.6283842921,
-0.3053165078,
-0.0814260319,
-0.3010701537,
0.7021201849,
-0.3794054985,
0.371671468,
-0.289247334,
0.2871834934,
-0.2606518865,
-0.7722961903,
-0.7108469605,
-0.3271242976,
0.1550497711,
0.3420722783,
0.7055796385,
0.7859299183,
0.4755919278,
0.2570322156,
0.2691273987,
0.2617529631,
-0.3821010888,
0.0354003459,
-0.0712351277,
-0.0898533314,
-0.5759343505,
0.0353101641,
0.9048271179,
1.0062804222,
-0.6301367879,
0.0558581427,
-0.0116379345,
0.220783934,
-0.2204274386,
0.3702306151,
-0.1261403859,
0.5010852814,
0.1146905795,
-0.4497346282,
-0.2297580391,
-0.2893473208,
0.1712505221,
-0.6129055023,
0.0384163074,
-0.0378932543,
0.6038442254,
0.1884225756,
-0.3337950706,
-0.2030966431,
-0.9326810241,
0.5371533632,
-0.6934356689,
0.2557728887,
-0.0976492241,
0.6794335246,
-0.4787411392,
-1.0128991604,
-0.5789259672,
0.0444925837,
0.1246725619,
0.4946077764,
0.2286367118,
0.4202707112,
0.1944616586,
0.2961902916,
-0.5078539848,
0.3897349536,
-0.6733009815,
-0.0077192378,
0.668261528,
0.7797036767,
0.5198773146,
0.0797046795,
-0.3327633142,
0.0205814671,
-0.7134883404,
-0.0365124121,
0.0518008843,
0.3590467274,
-0.3648902774,
0.8182130456,
-0.0427880026,
0.5307913423,
-0.48207587,
-0.4794327915,
0.2588815093,
-0.2425420433,
-0.5337557197,
0.2258060575,
0.8740562797,
0.4386294484,
0.166318655,
0.0746852607,
-0.1107505485,
0.1662477404,
0.3423671722,
-0.8954073191,
-0.091792509,
0.5128179193,
-0.5399981141,
-0.5426881313,
-0.1360083222,
-0.8769860864,
-0.1640812755,
-0.5539183617,
0.2533893585,
-0.4371045828,
0.0301827826,
0.4470567107,
0.1875034422,
0.0640828609,
0.5276387334,
-0.5127622485,
0.2684212029,
0.2949175835,
0.6938284636,
-0.3360049129,
-0.1440382898,
-0.2412797511,
0.5192943811,
-0.389832139,
0.4974975586,
-0.7014812231,
-0.8219676614,
0.3109076321,
-0.1068719923,
-0.0516704544,
-0.682099402,
0.2674813569,
-0.1242482141,
0.3688165247,
0.6502169967,
-0.7697331905,
0.0506176576,
0.3367477059,
-0.4068751633,
0.8867922425,
0.2758470178,
-0.2280444354,
0.1872193962,
-0.8866557479,
-0.5931364298,
0.3850934803,
-0.7269350886,
-0.5471619368,
-0.1562410444,
0.1828022152,
0.6078150272,
-0.5107599497,
0.7998071313,
-0.1126294285,
-0.3261511028,
0.143479839,
-0.2237752825,
0.4684715867,
0.0514671393,
-0.1315861642,
0.0339241885,
-0.676310122,
0.0577699728,
0.359960705,
-0.5562525392,
0.0165095795,
0.1096123904,
0.0999227017,
0.4804339707,
-0.0781776011,
-0.4699361622,
0.419906944,
-0.5284483433,
0.3141544163,
0.3381168544,
0.4648455977,
0.3468923569,
-0.4854495823,
0.7795194387,
0.3855645955,
0.4353329241,
-0.252456367,
-0.4266202748,
-0.3557950854,
-0.2787034214,
0.2253755778,
0.6374787688,
-0.8016665578,
0.0974967331,
-0.2119805217,
-0.4336994588,
-0.6501435637,
-0.14739272,
0.1956253052,
0.7983742952,
0.4582063854,
-0.1896910667,
-0.7304108739,
-0.7355141044,
0.2493917346,
-0.114186272,
-0.0459255539,
0.3955003023,
0.6569703221,
-0.3951218724,
0.6423028708,
-0.4134826064,
-0.358815372,
-0.3620474041,
-0.0621532872,
-0.0059607956,
0.7292086482,
0.585729301,
-0.6347977519,
-0.2726688683,
-0.0137974815,
-1.064353466,
0.2923385203,
-0.33885324,
-0.0886802375,
-0.019946469,
0.4750517607,
-0.2021585554,
0.6855741143,
0.4571814835,
-0.1021506265,
0.5015469193,
-0.5051301718,
0.4103156924,
-1.4402785301,
0.0095221149,
-0.1520036608,
0.0379267372,
-0.6337372661,
-0.1861571521,
-0.0295767467,
-0.5075691938,
-0.5929136872,
0.7830728292,
-0.2555561662,
0.0969613269,
0.0448688455,
0.1026335284,
-0.18028377,
0.2382644862,
0.2732852697,
0.8112578988,
0.7636870742,
-0.5184673071,
0.2311085612,
0.4177431464,
-0.3379459381,
0.420473069,
-0.7706961036,
-0.4003293812,
0.0941531509,
0.4453048706,
-0.3431842923,
-0.7394353151,
0.1478457153,
-0.2948314846,
0.216928035,
-0.2315241545,
-0.7596108317,
-0.3213594258,
-0.0009432011,
0.4353426397,
0.8919459581,
-0.3348833323,
0.6409285665,
0.6053127646,
-0.2636726499,
-0.2146951556,
-0.4765930772,
0.1537400931,
-0.0487331077,
-0.3475451767,
0.3408433497,
-0.0928600729,
-0.1803144366,
-0.1716789156,
0.1717659533,
-0.0174499433,
0.0976265967,
0.4455425441,
0.8251170516,
-0.1922959983,
0.031297721,
0.6574115753,
0.1527806967,
0.1961214393,
-0.5492467284,
0.4202124476,
0.3924676478,
-0.649864614,
-0.6575513482,
0.6112585664,
0.7159653306,
-0.1360267997,
0.9210966825,
0.0757022649,
-0.6725883484,
-0.288446635,
-0.2322575897,
-0.2205533981,
-0.4157390296,
0.416405648,
0.1212250069,
-0.832239747,
0.3924668729,
-0.4417191148,
0.3432847261,
0.1544422805,
0.9729500413,
-0.5150604248,
1.2739652395,
0.3471719623,
0.4137520194,
0.1486797929,
-0.1891617626,
0.1560680717,
-0.6820989251,
-0.7376576662,
-0.225064069,
-0.2541364133,
-0.3360487819,
-0.8684090972,
0.906753242,
-0.3593500555,
-0.3523462415,
-0.567889452,
-0.3752638996,
0.2996638417,
0.2806282938,
0.1984566301,
0.116173692,
0.0657305792,
-0.2950750291,
0.1356690675,
-0.8904923797,
-0.6185780764,
1.2733712196,
0.311386466,
0.7725480199,
-0.1586002409,
0.7864202261,
0.2294445038,
0.3849363625,
-0.6209420562,
0.5443369746,
0.0535986461,
-0.5376643538,
-0.0731957629,
-0.3230777979,
-0.8996816278,
-0.2752546966,
-0.5024514794,
-0.4028542638,
-0.2366904616,
0.1079075187,
-0.5515153408,
0.4318309426,
-0.4739042521,
0.6873648763,
-0.0681111068,
-0.3314217925,
-0.0093862843,
-0.8702794313,
0.1555899531,
-0.35367167,
0.3267862499,
0.0129570626,
-0.1763235927,
0.7044093013,
-0.4307255149,
0.9975828528,
-0.1623907983,
-0.0089720609,
0.3205735385,
0.0560268424,
0.1577355266,
0.3289428055,
0.0262094624,
0.13868469,
-0.0935337543,
-0.4579668343,
-0.5385407805,
0.4835527539,
-0.7622600794,
-0.1721292883,
-0.2865508795,
-0.8638898134,
-0.47103104,
0.0590804294,
-0.0217210278,
0.5831944942,
-0.3893163502,
-0.185596779,
0.7284155488,
-0.6109021306,
0.0594026782,
0.5221050978,
-0.2591780126,
-0.3307495117,
0.7514629364,
0.0680351928,
0.2681953013,
0.0772248581,
0.0944908559,
-0.0919115543,
-0.7423317432,
-0.7531676888,
0.1975684911,
-0.5171835423,
-0.1790234149,
-0.5545940399,
-0.7196718454,
-0.3794372976,
-0.4846587181,
-0.234840259,
-0.1231189519,
-0.1804221272,
-0.016832618,
-0.0162566453,
0.8137577772,
0.2908521295,
0.3441895843,
-1.0515291691,
0.1759498417,
-0.119144164,
0.2953972518,
-0.3742740452,
-0.5191143751,
-0.2542065382,
-0.0546997562,
-0.0529557727,
-0.7307757139,
0.2887974679,
0.1088984013,
0.5810732841,
0.2881035805,
-0.1337155402,
0.6075992584,
-0.7827132344,
0.83673805,
0.2976558805,
-0.4125030935,
0.8722705841,
-0.3614849746,
0.0780583918,
0.3555806279,
0.4231875241,
-0.1883300245,
-0.5154041052,
-0.7202577591,
-0.8503673077,
0.6061137915,
0.1216241643,
0.1397975534,
-0.1109571308,
0.4597414732,
0.2617217898,
0.1369208395,
-0.1512939185,
-0.2383364886,
0.255012095,
-0.7086918354,
-0.0841964632,
-0.0909146965,
-0.4348034263,
-0.369546473,
0.7752377391,
-0.0848494396,
0.2388993353,
0.0197524615,
0.1718355268,
-0.0010135733,
0.159489736,
0.5201472044,
0.3216040432,
0.100207381,
-0.2952518761,
0.1917819679,
-0.8447220325,
0.1978823394,
0.2190776616,
0.0351228639,
-0.09468247,
0.2750315964,
0.6717535853,
0.2056152672,
-1.2122465372,
0.4080762863,
-0.1669955254,
-0.4071798325,
-0.4485040009,
0.2586726546,
-0.00647423,
0.3926712275,
0.0217398684,
-0.1664038301,
0.1611596644,
-0.4113734365,
0.2552962005,
0.0911275446,
0.0069616577,
-0.1297788322,
0.7632691264,
0.1418216676,
-0.107901454,
0.6959813237,
0.2540481091,
-0.069115147,
0.7433868647,
0.7839789987,
0.2094266117,
-0.3982601166,
0.1512245387,
0.6290993094,
-0.016718857,
-0.2498022616,
0.5996280313,
0.2418606877,
-0.3565149009,
-0.4007915854,
-0.8135709763,
-0.649079442,
-0.0052855955,
-0.5854572058,
0.5770595074,
-0.5346003771,
0.024462603,
-0.0901608616,
-0.3667493165,
-0.5753311515,
0.5682500601,
0.2436324656,
1.0354061127,
-0.9077199101,
0.9453541636,
1.1287171841,
-0.4209340811,
-1.1662284136,
-0.0870277807,
0.0085218335,
-0.889436841,
0.2504612803,
-0.1531715393,
0.131341517,
0.0575745665,
-0.3882883489,
-0.263279736,
1.1163650751,
0.2511799037,
-0.5691392422,
-0.5201432109,
0.4256300628,
0.6644834876,
-0.543631196,
0.184849903,
0.5662025809,
0.1020857021,
0.255651623,
-0.8113426566,
-0.2455666065,
-0.2996810675,
-0.1363633573,
0.2931339145,
-0.1251564026,
0.5040928125,
-0.4483062625,
-0.117816478,
-0.1354780495,
0.5058765411,
0.2943620384,
0.4393784404,
0.0634139031,
0.4902899861,
0.6077136993,
-0.1792236865,
1.0080202818,
-0.4690796733,
0.3024249673,
0.9756860137,
-0.3832535446,
0.5066870451,
0.5198485255,
-0.1483435333,
0.3561258912,
0.6691370606,
-0.033190947,
0.0891323984,
0.1103255674,
-0.4860968888,
-0.3037736416,
-0.1058737338,
-0.5170910358,
0.4722714722,
0.6689830422,
-0.5413749218,
-0.2175622731,
0.4091289937,
0.0257444978,
0.1294473261,
-0.269890964,
0.7978537083,
-0.0334668718,
-0.583892107,
0.192038998,
-0.1117765754,
0.0166265145,
-0.6465287805,
-0.3084409535,
-0.1824165881,
0.0102572599,
-0.217843473,
-1.0190571547,
0.1684568077,
0.1074560583,
0.1443067491,
-0.1621441692,
0.3122664988,
-0.6042728424,
-0.6343533397,
-0.0442025214,
0.7804936767,
0.298656702,
0.5996977687,
-0.5808230042,
0.1191163808,
-0.2066899836,
-0.0867220461,
0.5192398429,
0.4787575006,
-0.1595855504,
0.54897964,
0.6416823268,
0.3143934608,
-0.1646771282,
0.14783445,
0.9703323841,
-0.2651892006,
-0.5259065628,
-0.6932047606,
0.6033121347,
-0.0721763819,
-0.0942310542,
0.1925471127,
0.9066533446,
0.6435444355,
-0.0545752607,
0.9846409559,
-0.0423628949,
0.3845409155,
-0.5514389277,
0.848289907,
-0.6826680899,
0.2782963812,
-0.0680653974,
-0.3999806941,
-0.5224756002,
0.2732251883,
-0.1126484051,
0.1081254557,
0.5795747638,
0.4239820838,
-0.2522365153,
-0.0724796057,
0.4422200918,
0.0059192749,
0.4809193313,
0.6221545339,
0.7322542667,
-0.1880227178,
0.1344058812,
-0.1662667543,
-0.4380593896,
-0.148026675,
-0.4941736758,
-1.1197659969,
-0.5789262056,
-0.35048756,
-0.273739934,
0.1807898432,
1.2424309254,
0.5725310445,
-0.6082969308,
-0.1498722732,
0.2077130377,
-0.5135246515,
0.1018346995,
-0.1865437031,
0.4150900841,
-0.2330241203,
-0.9136968851,
0.5375922918,
0.5874695182,
0.4995172918,
-0.2212727666,
-0.1623321325,
0.0550614409,
0.3371802866,
0.5236364007,
0.1855302602,
-0.333142817,
-0.1112861782,
-0.0631622225,
-0.3688236773,
0.1145643145,
0.8361225724,
-0.9909843802,
0.5282202959,
-0.0597395897,
0.8255567551,
0.1403663009,
-0.0162899829,
0.6688162088,
-0.4174316525,
0.1459931433,
0.5204296708,
0.3238485456,
-0.067001231,
-0.3548033834,
0.4568176866,
0.2024835944,
-0.3814573884,
-1.0670148134,
0.0705927238,
-0.9581219554,
-0.1436141878,
0.9604155421,
-0.1007745415,
0.004148901,
-0.1139661148,
-0.2818025649,
0.5250636339,
-0.00601904,
0.9020698071,
0.3127837777,
-0.4644944072,
0.3303856552,
-1.1241831779,
0.3816705048,
0.1540117562,
-1.4722787142,
-0.3668497205,
0.62758255,
0.2971753478,
-0.4026897252,
0.4555178285,
-0.5200182199,
0.415294826,
-0.1366114765,
0.1670884043,
-0.232477352,
-0.5773621202,
-0.0904125422,
0.272787869,
-0.2772389352,
-0.0322630517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19708v1
|
Harmonic LLMs are Trustworthy
| 2024-04-30T17:00:32 | 2024-04-30T17:00:32 |
Nicholas S. Kersting, Mohammad Rahman, Suchismitha Vedala, Yang Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
We introduce an intuitive method to test the robustness (stability and
explainability) of any black-box LLM in real-time, based upon the local
deviation from harmoniticity, denoted as $\gamma$. To the best of our knowledge
this is the first completely model-agnostic and unsupervised method of
measuring the robustness of any given response from an LLM, based upon the
model itself conforming to a purely mathematical standard. We conduct human
annotation experiments to show the positive correlation of $\gamma$ with false
or misleading answers, and demonstrate that following the gradient of $\gamma$
in stochastic gradient ascent efficiently exposes adversarial prompts.
Measuring $\gamma$ across thousands of queries in popular LLMs (GPT-4, ChatGPT,
Claude-2.1, Mixtral-8x7B, Smaug-72B, Llama2-7B, and MPT-7B) allows us to
estimate the liklihood of wrong or hallucinatory answers automatically and
quantitatively rank the reliability of these models in various objective
domains (Web QA, TruthfulQA, and Programming QA). Across all models and domains
tested, human ratings confirm that $\gamma \to 0$ indicates trustworthiness,
and the low-$\gamma$ leaders among these models are GPT-4, ChatGPT, and
Smaug-72B.
|
[
-0.6996312141,
-1.1598106623,
0.4150005281,
0.0292606633,
-0.2735278308,
0.1309276521,
-0.0679771528,
-0.612718761,
-0.0208343547,
0.0072042858,
-0.6539685726,
-0.3924794495,
-0.4417906106,
0.1125713065,
-0.3640572727,
1.0098949671,
0.2432798743,
0.4216096997,
-0.1820118278,
-0.2809616029,
-0.3081237674,
-0.5193728209,
-0.6682148576,
-0.4938659668,
0.3647820354,
-0.1943330765,
1.1675733328,
0.4441618025,
0.6786991358,
0.1489966661,
-0.1232777536,
0.0814266428,
-0.5440542698,
0.2249426842,
-0.1612801552,
-0.8970525861,
-0.7963505983,
0.3035420775,
0.1336986423,
0.3981555104,
-0.4415388405,
0.5322211981,
0.302543968,
0.3658966124,
-0.2973925769,
0.0659345388,
-0.7639036179,
0.1545953751,
-0.3632761836,
-0.3518176973,
-0.3473535776,
-0.5763628483,
0.0220351219,
-0.7057419419,
0.0005666025,
0.2924102247,
0.9842911959,
0.5010269284,
-0.3883966804,
-0.174165532,
-0.8779720068,
0.9668962955,
-0.737793088,
0.3722645342,
0.6922661066,
0.7398119569,
-0.2396064699,
-0.7327458858,
-0.5065774322,
-0.5054730773,
0.2502758503,
0.4356659949,
-0.1296483874,
0.0621775351,
0.3079019785,
0.6058496237,
-0.3749821186,
0.0137003902,
-0.0280269682,
-0.4880288839,
0.5519081354,
0.3387614489,
0.3544912636,
-0.1656860858,
-0.4906796813,
0.1381317079,
-0.645501852,
0.228154242,
0.3580287099,
-0.0708681643,
-0.0936292037,
0.6055175662,
0.446026206,
0.4346918762,
0.4091350734,
-0.2364616394,
-0.3654399812,
-0.6849454641,
-0.356638521,
-0.4113172591,
0.6851283908,
0.2693668604,
0.4322707653,
-0.2482861429,
-0.2626322508,
0.3611913919,
0.5187350512,
-0.6194646955,
-0.1711518466,
0.1849335283,
-0.5167681575,
-0.7106030583,
0.0829300657,
-0.6008635759,
-0.3852871358,
-0.1693406105,
0.490133971,
-0.5288383961,
-0.0287466943,
-0.1081075594,
0.2991000414,
0.5862193704,
0.4415314198,
-0.7867249846,
0.4292237461,
0.9583492279,
0.5980914831,
-0.1507808268,
-0.1190045252,
-0.4153047502,
-0.3876944482,
-0.5511713624,
0.5336197019,
-0.0709711686,
-0.3944093883,
-0.1895914823,
-0.05558642,
0.2999124229,
-0.4050037563,
0.8303853869,
-0.7809667587,
0.3459722698,
-0.2191557884,
-0.6541424394,
-0.3628364503,
0.50159657,
-0.3358885646,
1.1545431614,
0.0990646034,
-0.8714613318,
0.3123391867,
-0.2118956,
0.1093014777,
-0.1203556582,
-0.069524914,
-0.4538660347,
0.0901664123,
0.1069685146,
0.1966716796,
-0.5355297923,
0.2690486312,
-0.821236372,
-0.4738815725,
0.6726915836,
-0.9823784828,
1.2110340595,
0.1855905354,
-0.4152220786,
0.025719231,
-0.6270342469,
0.1355307251,
0.0353274979,
-0.2044623047,
-0.1105190143,
-0.1953696162,
-0.2494703233,
0.1098257974,
0.2497700304,
-0.3556753695,
-0.1584824026,
-0.2890270948,
0.1253641695,
1.1106652021,
0.152793318,
0.1399730742,
-0.8775214553,
0.8678506017,
-0.0516164042,
0.3894610405,
0.1113570407,
-0.7170407176,
-0.5001843572,
-0.3111786544,
0.3269590437,
0.6710652709,
-0.3942566514,
0.6958108544,
-0.1672438383,
-0.6286492348,
-0.5342524052,
0.1717543304,
0.289632678,
0.7904308438,
0.1787585914,
-0.4995933175,
-0.0280157849,
-0.8242695928,
-0.2827013433,
-0.160793215,
-0.2704670429,
0.525105238,
0.2969949543,
-0.390247494,
0.6638796329,
-0.2097087204,
-0.0149955153,
0.2884283364,
0.0783331394,
0.2330845445,
0.031454917,
0.6243578792,
-0.4144717753,
-0.41157794,
-0.1867024601,
-1.1506409645,
-0.0445345007,
0.136844039,
-0.2016955763,
0.1065590158,
0.0126447659,
-0.6090682745,
0.3875663579,
0.5012866259,
-0.2785314322,
0.6629676223,
-0.1681247056,
0.2932837903,
-1.1378369331,
0.0041944352,
0.1854469776,
-0.6137743592,
-0.3814249635,
0.2337175608,
0.0409997515,
0.1456633359,
-0.3699024916,
0.4656294286,
-0.2083970606,
-0.2806543112,
0.0045042899,
0.2745499611,
-0.2638008296,
0.438923806,
-0.8508991599,
0.9071540236,
0.7684087157,
-0.6088361144,
0.8185018897,
0.232515201,
-0.1292037815,
1.0634049177,
-0.7695945501,
0.1782593131,
0.0040508793,
0.1249698251,
-1.1023432016,
-0.170027867,
0.2252608687,
-0.7671830654,
0.1631293595,
0.0023532824,
-0.4114527404,
-0.2897604704,
-0.661513865,
0.428591758,
0.8520376682,
-0.5618676543,
0.6328140497,
0.3680514693,
0.1078021154,
-0.6495467424,
-0.6450068355,
-0.0692494512,
-0.2971686721,
-0.918397069,
-0.2243722677,
-0.3297861516,
-0.7001453042,
-0.2078542858,
-0.4549447298,
-0.2981061935,
0.6536789536,
0.4358195662,
0.6789916158,
-0.2740193903,
-0.3296074569,
-0.4078511298,
-0.2645937204,
0.3670544624,
-0.209372595,
0.2182157636,
-0.4071384072,
-0.6576457024,
-0.7332673073,
-0.3591992259,
0.7574285865,
-0.0377381593,
0.294911772,
0.6560675502,
-0.5794748068,
-0.3062199354,
-0.2889306247,
-0.4590893686,
-0.5142560601,
-0.0251834989,
-0.1710258424,
-0.6082934141,
0.9609100223,
0.2082647085,
0.1173720211,
0.2173516303,
0.6577780247,
-0.1526455134,
0.9594365358,
0.2458235472,
-0.0565245599,
0.1476836056,
0.0981874615,
0.2454872429,
-0.6604735851,
-0.0467795245,
-0.4736779928,
-0.1723951697,
-0.7349497676,
-0.3857024014,
0.5056139827,
0.1259298176,
-0.1669766009,
0.0279729404,
-0.3819480836,
0.1826088428,
0.5305681825,
0.2390163094,
0.3834587336,
-0.1560107917,
-0.0858670846,
-0.3342218697,
-0.2541513741,
-0.632221818,
1.3883951902,
0.5953652859,
1.1447073221,
0.2167310864,
0.3600891531,
0.3716471493,
0.5903037786,
-0.8552535772,
0.5790435076,
0.3727154732,
-0.7464696765,
-0.4581685662,
-0.3723795116,
-0.8289997578,
0.1882579774,
-0.2673169076,
-0.4830646515,
-0.2794038951,
0.1166291162,
-0.5105388165,
0.2539665401,
0.0547765791,
0.344116956,
-0.4449909925,
-0.4423707128,
-0.1511859596,
-0.6769554615,
0.6597877145,
-0.4088017046,
0.2866792381,
-0.184610188,
0.0319090113,
0.498926729,
-0.3609354794,
0.6864642501,
0.0498064607,
-0.4554026425,
0.2715310454,
0.6319351196,
0.5929340124,
0.3453920782,
-0.0886989236,
0.424053669,
-0.0716446638,
-0.3522036076,
-0.8212105036,
0.6071769595,
-0.7930464745,
-0.6481658816,
-0.5422897935,
-0.3717021942,
-0.3812402487,
0.37396577,
0.2819051445,
0.4648507535,
-0.2489913404,
0.2806884348,
0.8762681484,
0.0864282921,
0.1192347854,
0.3413298428,
-0.3366285861,
-0.5740628839,
0.4988118708,
-0.0113739548,
0.3636953533,
0.094760932,
0.1865562499,
-0.300750196,
-0.6263908744,
-0.2553159595,
0.1180195212,
-0.6448473334,
-0.1152708977,
-0.0344701819,
-0.2948976457,
0.086454019,
-0.194634527,
-0.3882290423,
-0.4679635465,
-0.2557153106,
-0.4127002954,
0.0647849217,
0.779387176,
0.0500678234,
-0.2489831299,
-0.6432205439,
0.5033637881,
0.6122344136,
0.2587041557,
-0.1075468212,
-0.8485147953,
0.0170822814,
0.3916938007,
-0.4823931158,
-0.8452726007,
0.1400901973,
-0.0207265709,
0.7522972822,
0.5829432607,
0.1204712391,
0.5578121543,
-0.1668043882,
1.0795906782,
-0.0438957363,
-1.0083807707,
0.2716533542,
-0.7128751874,
-0.3950859308,
0.4306460917,
0.2694271803,
-0.1390559822,
-0.7458894849,
-0.6940936446,
-0.4643199444,
0.3764431775,
0.2481664121,
0.038886819,
0.2043251842,
0.7082803845,
0.1059009284,
0.1739781499,
-0.8858248591,
-0.6631402373,
-0.3456425965,
-0.1991273463,
0.0753461942,
-0.3097604513,
-0.5979508162,
0.015540543,
0.520834744,
-0.2024109066,
0.1594960093,
0.0297074467,
0.0769742057,
-0.5010851622,
0.11497996,
0.6229910254,
0.8743213415,
-0.4559094906,
0.431784302,
0.4380474985,
-0.4024246335,
0.3891617954,
-0.1760285646,
-0.2606269717,
-0.240029484,
0.4291295707,
0.2700244784,
0.330124259,
-0.2208507359,
0.7178963423,
-0.3775098622,
-0.1633387655,
-0.4051413238,
0.1327882409,
-0.0266205687,
0.071561709,
0.2620855868,
0.2934192717,
-0.0814318657,
-0.5531015396,
0.4683895111,
0.9565032125,
-0.5265146494,
-0.6835370064,
1.2643254995,
0.0074496656,
-0.400116086,
0.3553980589,
-0.0639774799,
-0.308958739,
0.4235092103,
0.3901761472,
0.9060841203,
-0.1791394353,
0.1698875725,
0.1768486649,
0.386711508,
-0.1666561067,
0.2113952935,
0.0637993813,
-0.6435908079,
0.1701805741,
-0.4914394319,
-0.6936641932,
-0.2373373657,
-1.1523532867,
0.0680556819,
-0.7482448816,
-0.6108974218,
-0.1569658518,
0.1965953708,
-0.4118297696,
0.0856816396,
-0.0583790801,
0.9576531053,
-0.4923959076,
0.6450468898,
0.4816921651,
-0.2241420597,
-0.7637706399,
0.2497261316,
0.3236475587,
-1.2899641991,
0.3758537769,
-0.2931650281,
-0.339725554,
-0.1361398995,
-0.6965337396,
-0.7056791186,
1.5956118107,
0.5603442192,
-0.2569741309,
0.1661919504,
-0.2230219245,
0.7573305368,
0.19605349,
0.27937904,
0.2478397489,
0.51651752,
0.034306176,
-1.1562503576,
0.2027014643,
0.0808740556,
0.0779245868,
-0.1272133142,
-0.7711566687,
0.8015222549,
-0.1910095662,
-0.4694579542,
0.2730508149,
0.50750947,
0.5096986294,
0.2669523954,
0.2930271626,
0.5550541282,
1.2955123186,
-0.15810965,
1.2366847992,
-0.8878754377,
0.6433225274,
0.7210606337,
-0.1712280065,
0.5141425133,
0.2463106215,
-0.3592703044,
0.0863034055,
0.803817153,
-0.1326388419,
0.4045043588,
0.2209826112,
-0.1675928384,
-0.4549995661,
0.1451330483,
-0.28836748,
0.105951272,
0.067002669,
0.0113686882,
-0.2001559436,
-0.400452435,
0.3596889973,
-0.0528220646,
-0.207790345,
0.4745297432,
0.5569984913,
-0.6006813049,
0.8003427386,
-0.0276277605,
0.7631018162,
-0.6311452985,
0.3294250965,
-0.4525034726,
0.273665756,
-0.248317793,
-0.6831709146,
0.0847579315,
-0.1957952529,
0.1837384701,
0.0506878383,
0.6739387512,
-0.0267411023,
-0.3344573081,
0.3834638894,
0.6280278563,
-0.1541621983,
0.4278298616,
-0.6967152953,
-0.3118393719,
-0.0771626756,
-0.3490495384,
0.2927381992,
0.4336280227,
0.1293686032,
1.2559152842,
0.7930575609,
0.2615243196,
0.2328415364,
-0.3786689937,
0.4919556081,
-0.5721174479,
-0.3823968172,
-0.9772191048,
0.2105720341,
0.2932365835,
-0.1461571902,
1.4507997036,
0.2363530546,
0.4701735973,
0.2411773652,
0.7520544529,
0.6939569116,
0.2091233283,
-0.4712669551,
0.7173040509,
-0.3846823871,
0.5301651359,
-0.0335361063,
-0.9704763889,
-0.4601848125,
0.671130836,
0.1342524886,
0.1161150783,
0.6251649261,
0.8185915947,
-0.1288931072,
0.1054398343,
0.4746347666,
0.4126964808,
0.5755717754,
0.322025001,
0.9600124955,
-0.311916858,
0.4133264422,
-0.0742563009,
-0.3782236874,
-0.1811528206,
-0.7222778797,
-0.9926434755,
0.0322273932,
-0.2415941358,
-0.889020741,
-0.1437400132,
0.726038754,
0.6868629456,
-0.762842536,
-0.0215980615,
-0.0951158181,
0.2740019858,
-0.2973282933,
-0.2279807031,
0.0752367154,
-0.1841497421,
-0.4047044218,
0.1932380795,
0.3246103525,
0.4223304391,
-0.6404718757,
-0.1412743926,
0.527662456,
0.6611932516,
0.158507511,
0.1335792243,
-0.8644911051,
-0.5553629994,
0.2519160509,
-0.4311968386,
0.1078240052,
0.4590469897,
-0.2661519647,
0.2922557592,
0.3865956068,
0.555126369,
0.1023449227,
0.4216260314,
0.6638009548,
-0.335550338,
-0.0870556682,
0.3516397178,
0.4717654288,
0.1974889189,
-0.3137583137,
0.5030661225,
0.3397497237,
-0.9958356023,
-0.9584540725,
0.3103787899,
-1.0982904434,
0.2279831469,
1.0253719091,
-0.3175013363,
-0.2417533845,
-0.2064157724,
-0.0417061932,
-0.1164634973,
-0.1610050499,
1.216019392,
0.8445091844,
-0.2895069122,
0.1367607862,
-0.6414526105,
0.7248772383,
0.3450125456,
-0.7437039018,
0.0338248312,
0.464158386,
0.5387523174,
0.3069384098,
0.7054962516,
-0.375298351,
0.4388355017,
0.0667534992,
-0.4495412409,
-0.281647414,
-0.0401435718,
-0.5556709766,
0.2666320801,
0.4462744892,
-0.1975524724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19705v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19705v2
|
When to Retrieve: Teaching LLMs to Utilize Information Retrieval Effectively
| 2024-04-30T16:52:55 | 2024-05-06T19:08:10 |
Tiziano Labruna, Jon Ander Campos, Gorka Azkune
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In this paper, we demonstrate how Large Language Models (LLMs) can
effectively learn to use an off-the-shelf information retrieval (IR) system
specifically when additional context is required to answer a given question.
Given the performance of IR systems, the optimal strategy for question
answering does not always entail external information retrieval; rather, it
often involves leveraging the parametric memory of the LLM itself. Prior
research has identified this phenomenon in the PopQA dataset, wherein the most
popular questions are effectively addressed using the LLM's parametric memory,
while less popular ones require IR system usage. Following this, we propose a
tailored training approach for LLMs, leveraging existing open-domain question
answering datasets. Here, LLMs are trained to generate a special token, <RET>,
when they do not know the answer to a question. Our evaluation of the Adaptive
Retrieval LLM (Adapt-LLM) on the PopQA dataset showcases improvements over the
same LLM under three configurations: (i) retrieving information for all the
questions, (ii) using always the parametric memory of the LLM, and (iii) using
a popularity threshold to decide when to use a retriever. Through our analysis,
we demonstrate that Adapt-LLM is able to generate the <RET> token when it
determines that it does not know how to answer a question, indicating the need
for IR, while it achieves notably high accuracy levels when it chooses to rely
only on its parametric memory.
|
[
-0.4769795537,
-0.5235415697,
0.5377283096,
-0.0916571617,
-0.1744844317,
-0.0146820582,
-0.2551709116,
-0.1200869903,
-0.0145069137,
0.4846027195,
-0.3059295118,
-0.250066191,
-0.3986964822,
0.0368845984,
-0.3014708161,
0.794264853,
0.0085281413,
0.139429912,
-0.2290128767,
-0.2711052001,
-0.6415961385,
-0.6347423196,
-0.7195227146,
-0.0972282141,
0.5546482205,
0.7039888501,
0.434545517,
0.6262466908,
0.4001349211,
0.1878341436,
0.0099051986,
0.2251283675,
-0.8154112697,
0.0944865271,
-0.2652239501,
-0.7656180263,
0.0282873977,
-0.328094691,
0.5986022353,
0.6187744737,
-0.3989926875,
0.3189907074,
-0.0357868075,
0.5919035673,
-0.8630093336,
-0.0753909722,
-1.1705602407,
-0.0684210286,
-0.0636952892,
-0.6426888108,
-0.5956568122,
-0.3390253484,
0.3498462141,
-0.6212136745,
-0.0046850429,
0.2649647593,
0.6049576402,
0.1362703741,
-0.6147004366,
-0.4876583219,
-0.6365824938,
0.795353651,
-0.3911848366,
0.461163044,
0.5385255814,
0.4778439701,
-0.2281379551,
-0.6563848257,
-0.2056611478,
-0.1143660992,
0.1417807192,
0.0421926305,
-0.0562596954,
-0.2183312476,
0.217170313,
0.1543986201,
-0.4500108957,
-0.1300673336,
-0.4312684536,
-0.0056148069,
0.1173869297,
0.1821326762,
0.1282745749,
-0.0234391578,
-0.6167907715,
0.1683112532,
-0.9211448431,
0.0029775582,
0.0317887403,
0.3814533055,
0.4406369328,
0.632856071,
0.1315419823,
0.7905592918,
0.1420386136,
-0.001741819,
0.0244286489,
-0.1221341416,
0.093720153,
-0.0313700251,
0.3030740023,
0.1415208578,
0.446631372,
-0.23169595,
-0.5164496899,
-0.749710083,
0.4377101362,
-0.7602091432,
-0.042189654,
-0.0090219965,
-0.4980477691,
0.1821909696,
-0.0050945026,
-0.6063196659,
-0.2133603543,
-0.2738211751,
0.9086933136,
-0.4965539873,
-0.1325906515,
0.2685737312,
-0.1804895103,
0.4024054408,
0.2474454939,
-0.9447740912,
0.3644464016,
0.3139710426,
0.6472966075,
-0.3512411118,
-0.1197083667,
-1.005992651,
0.3434922397,
-0.325605154,
0.8710808158,
-0.4799839556,
-0.2955912948,
0.0884558558,
0.0744385943,
-0.2529572248,
-0.8881912827,
0.2884614468,
-0.9606148601,
0.1747303605,
-0.4195414782,
-0.636538744,
-0.0172390435,
0.3478087485,
-0.6173927784,
0.9242988229,
0.1151770279,
-0.7586359382,
0.1585682482,
-0.5918832421,
-0.1791980863,
-0.106791757,
0.0295506287,
-0.0521706678,
0.1946410835,
0.2996616662,
0.2708035409,
-0.2191078514,
0.1054065749,
-0.1000498235,
-0.4925614595,
0.318500042,
-0.1724260598,
0.4573999345,
0.3109205961,
0.1512878239,
-0.1527386457,
-0.7049360275,
0.0767978802,
0.2292670161,
-0.9299331307,
-0.437965095,
0.1857553124,
-0.291490972,
-0.0666941851,
0.4052915573,
-0.5652429461,
-0.0182410013,
-0.3095546365,
0.3274555802,
0.6695851684,
0.0786074847,
0.4761933684,
-0.5677655339,
0.5143919587,
-0.1023201942,
-0.0978870168,
-0.2518971264,
-0.0969944298,
-0.8201465011,
-0.0116417399,
0.0921981558,
0.5446451306,
-1.0406839848,
0.0154300248,
-0.1152421683,
-0.2209656984,
-0.3542679548,
0.3573974669,
0.1527996659,
0.6747322083,
0.4900029004,
-0.0812782198,
-0.6914681792,
-0.5701622367,
-0.4277776778,
-0.3119971454,
-0.0558336005,
0.7046028376,
0.2752788365,
0.2282482982,
1.0185053349,
-0.5766609907,
-0.0072836531,
-0.40930444,
-0.0695725456,
0.1103983745,
0.0625013933,
0.3696837425,
-0.8870204687,
-0.2641756833,
-0.2774096727,
-0.6719017625,
-0.0534485579,
-0.0618727468,
-0.2009429187,
0.075112313,
0.5522945523,
-0.4770304859,
0.2466683239,
0.0884672105,
-0.1674854755,
0.2732117176,
-0.3647279739,
0.0546736866,
-1.0847939253,
0.1941409111,
-0.1441192627,
-0.2542565465,
-0.4381264448,
0.022880422,
0.2373978645,
-0.1371282041,
-0.6283474565,
0.8118772507,
-0.7202539444,
-0.2649516463,
-0.5210981965,
0.2089897245,
0.0400085039,
0.2911042571,
0.1577716023,
1.1682475805,
0.1990269125,
-0.9169732928,
0.1821647584,
0.342856586,
-0.4441427886,
0.4930464923,
-0.3722379804,
0.3433583975,
-0.4616524577,
0.1001661792,
-1.0006330013,
-0.0607693009,
-0.0626946911,
-0.4854415059,
0.330483824,
-0.1399639845,
-0.3804647028,
-0.3539664745,
-0.1818639934,
0.3272635937,
0.5086187124,
-0.9946750998,
0.698622942,
0.3803543448,
-0.0986540318,
-0.7776857615,
-0.4617493749,
-0.0420834087,
-0.4966594875,
-0.3400344551,
0.1585399806,
-0.3157649636,
0.0002097233,
-0.0951396301,
-0.1764035076,
-0.2672666013,
0.3267773688,
-0.229773134,
0.1036906093,
-0.5230023265,
0.5186769366,
-0.2159425467,
0.0087262839,
0.0231093876,
-0.2607671618,
0.6012833118,
-0.0324761383,
-0.3401399553,
0.048248671,
0.2612576485,
0.3246547878,
-0.154886663,
0.9499620795,
0.2477287352,
-0.3040156364,
-0.1226307079,
-0.7081968188,
-0.4036450684,
-0.4559406042,
0.5050952435,
-0.4048055708,
-0.7519788742,
0.4926360548,
-0.1096862331,
0.1065810695,
0.0794225484,
0.5252436996,
-0.1745187789,
0.7836745977,
0.4567639232,
-0.078923665,
0.7050696611,
0.0326384045,
-0.0234212633,
-1.0379471779,
-0.407145232,
-0.5610747933,
-0.2210014015,
-0.0836785585,
-0.3759276867,
0.217862919,
0.2475676537,
-0.4758525193,
0.2389127761,
-0.1994543225,
0.4919940531,
0.5872570872,
0.266392231,
0.2620483339,
0.1934883296,
-0.1271472424,
0.0692711025,
-0.8139600754,
-0.371645987,
1.5013107061,
0.2001535296,
1.0666227341,
0.1311348379,
0.6264418364,
-0.0017251612,
0.3675825,
-0.8104758859,
0.564114809,
-0.0045597833,
-0.6663571596,
-0.1144881696,
-0.5182749033,
-1.1859123707,
0.2397522032,
0.0371747166,
-0.4889257848,
0.099523291,
0.0840143338,
-0.3007528186,
0.3515720963,
-0.7174233794,
0.3946112096,
-0.459087491,
-0.186584264,
-0.0401574075,
-0.4921543002,
-0.1068174616,
-0.218192637,
-0.0004328009,
0.0857283473,
-0.4592559338,
0.7470685244,
-0.0303441789,
0.5679792762,
-0.3979460597,
0.1493621171,
0.506506145,
0.0322268233,
0.3663470447,
-0.1379279792,
-0.5034364462,
-0.4716564417,
0.1170227528,
-0.4584096968,
-0.7497805953,
0.599656105,
-0.6710617542,
-0.9754447341,
-0.2131176293,
-0.6297290325,
-0.377625972,
0.1001842543,
0.0928132534,
0.3285971284,
-0.2184043229,
0.5275258422,
0.993242085,
-0.3793998957,
0.3060069382,
0.9487062693,
-0.2503644824,
-0.4287239015,
0.886372447,
0.2298808396,
0.4123756289,
0.602096498,
0.3615487814,
-0.3819563985,
-0.5535929203,
-0.4336048365,
0.1989646852,
-0.9597460032,
-0.3699373305,
-0.569165051,
-0.3147397041,
-0.1595599353,
0.2207212001,
-0.0482204594,
-0.2445863187,
-0.5873582959,
-0.0010566565,
0.5648987889,
0.3547424078,
0.0228486154,
0.3312074244,
-0.8437872529,
0.2296940088,
0.2692997754,
0.169777751,
0.0312857479,
-0.9998716116,
-0.1479585171,
-0.0508118682,
-0.3612686694,
-0.6392474174,
0.2823155224,
0.4933221936,
0.883505106,
0.1419363171,
0.1716497093,
0.5463450551,
-0.4667119086,
0.4517772496,
-0.2272881567,
-0.4915860593,
0.7027913928,
-0.3232177198,
0.413246125,
0.6340149641,
0.730576098,
-0.3756935596,
-0.0359907374,
-0.2780269086,
-0.8336996436,
0.7387683988,
-0.2621711791,
0.4849449694,
-0.4313711226,
0.8127636909,
0.2658624351,
0.366594851,
-0.6957028508,
-0.127869457,
0.040258579,
-0.4236812592,
0.1712634712,
-0.4779112339,
0.0172170177,
-0.0164319389,
0.5622584224,
-0.3033168912,
0.4867860675,
-0.0045511187,
-0.2475280017,
-0.0991574302,
0.2108675241,
0.1714393944,
0.9039882421,
-0.4103911519,
0.1978090703,
0.2793515623,
-0.3271308839,
0.1187019125,
-0.1252371967,
0.0159444548,
-0.2391758412,
0.0183936916,
0.6568897963,
0.2823469043,
-1.0218397379,
0.4398269355,
-0.1668168306,
-0.0533083826,
-0.2698105574,
0.2281147242,
0.3469317555,
0.2429169416,
0.6279521585,
-0.3082381785,
0.0145802312,
-0.6464758515,
0.3325072229,
0.5903736353,
-0.2185026258,
-0.0439799838,
0.4198533893,
-0.0872175395,
-0.5504356027,
0.6813126206,
0.2975743711,
-0.2860777378,
0.4768918455,
0.9854032993,
0.4759766459,
-0.4497122765,
0.0425040126,
0.2219256163,
0.0487217493,
-0.2217623442,
0.5153289437,
-0.0531539097,
-0.6972528696,
-0.110103853,
-0.4739347994,
-0.3395026326,
0.2784568965,
-0.8408133388,
0.2174227238,
-0.5584629178,
-0.0052905385,
-0.4870097041,
-0.194287464,
-0.5576153398,
0.1951696277,
-0.2096153796,
1.1484825611,
-0.4928106368,
0.7101686597,
0.7251225114,
-0.3067165315,
-0.7180445194,
0.1946560442,
-0.2573920488,
-1.241915226,
0.7054508924,
0.0398321524,
-0.0170474406,
0.1437946707,
-0.5078232884,
-1.2148789167,
1.142485261,
0.5610521436,
-0.3380057514,
-0.0417458005,
-0.0653298274,
0.4035289586,
-0.4839893579,
0.2600438595,
0.4612430632,
0.0948928371,
0.5600532293,
-0.6137347221,
-0.0872651413,
0.0119796284,
-0.0607207306,
0.2059951574,
-0.6115530729,
0.7316806912,
-0.2953302562,
-0.1242515221,
0.3364759684,
0.6104514599,
0.3923842311,
0.3093840182,
0.4676806629,
0.2610044479,
0.8280786276,
0.1792350858,
0.8684512377,
-0.172693491,
0.1051883623,
1.1939172745,
-0.204937458,
1.2879859209,
0.6405698657,
0.1188510358,
0.2105542421,
0.7292428017,
0.2456400245,
0.7643887997,
0.3670336306,
-0.2933061719,
-0.308942318,
-0.0661657676,
-0.2066302001,
0.3113236725,
0.5175252557,
-0.4723189175,
-0.4375863969,
0.4012580812,
-0.2069339454,
0.1201634333,
-0.3736064434,
0.9529719353,
0.2219166905,
-0.7763736844,
0.7460445166,
-0.1497327387,
0.3151648641,
-0.5619474649,
0.2103787512,
-0.5086418986,
0.2751505077,
-0.0196077153,
-0.7573723197,
0.1322071552,
-0.0088814944,
-0.2857725918,
-0.0409094878,
0.6425711513,
-0.4603372514,
-0.335549444,
0.4131103456,
0.5558224916,
0.2674177289,
0.1346282661,
-0.6284483075,
-0.1214866042,
-0.0000202678,
-0.4464345276,
0.6169469357,
0.6224569678,
0.0508308634,
1.0641930103,
0.3613551557,
0.138776809,
0.2027224749,
0.01033937,
1.038192749,
-0.5833913684,
-0.1913943589,
-0.6223976612,
0.1570744663,
0.2497178763,
-0.0675504133,
0.6639140844,
0.6511620879,
0.6843621135,
0.0525479056,
0.6861932874,
0.259152025,
0.8482649326,
-0.7670629621,
0.3403470218,
-0.7881599069,
0.5887063146,
0.2026602477,
-1.0164071321,
-0.039950639,
0.6062755585,
-0.5862431526,
0.1903796494,
0.6310508251,
0.7460592985,
-0.0853938758,
0.0563831218,
0.2624889612,
-0.0566931032,
0.3182237744,
0.8017960191,
1.1035373211,
-0.2354644537,
0.945377171,
0.3314606249,
-0.0466327369,
-0.2555607855,
-0.6650314331,
-0.8569268584,
-0.3996161819,
0.0314204544,
-0.4399532378,
0.2810707092,
0.863184154,
0.4156804979,
-0.5847535133,
-0.3925822675,
0.142383486,
0.0735358149,
0.3100354075,
-0.1656283736,
0.2948609889,
-0.5886503458,
-0.4640288949,
0.4106517732,
0.1424229741,
-0.0425080582,
0.0188236702,
0.0121677136,
-0.4317410886,
0.2256058902,
0.3099691868,
0.4646653533,
-0.4609955251,
-0.3830677569,
0.4276869893,
-0.0496999025,
0.4927940965,
0.8994073272,
-0.8286389112,
0.5249031186,
0.3912720084,
1.1349582672,
0.4811359048,
0.1877004355,
0.6621549129,
-0.5639097095,
-0.0971780419,
0.2865615189,
0.2205276191,
0.4021341503,
-0.4313967228,
0.1999311,
-0.1103571728,
-0.6387063265,
-0.7274136543,
0.0604383983,
-0.4821795225,
-0.4086971879,
1.2919331789,
-0.2446655035,
-0.1802080423,
-0.3776624799,
-0.3237442374,
-0.0764124915,
-0.293499738,
0.7481963634,
0.6902199984,
-0.0725005195,
-0.3442183137,
-0.5858644247,
0.2895854115,
0.5108490586,
-0.6133595705,
-0.0002100182,
0.1984142661,
0.7804028392,
-0.1863771677,
0.765112102,
-0.0595792681,
0.2118482888,
-0.4060008824,
-0.3642343283,
0.0189828575,
-0.3467495441,
-0.1940395236,
0.2426841408,
0.4969631732,
-0.354960084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19696v1
|
Naturally Supervised 3D Visual Grounding with Language-Regularized Concept Learners
| 2024-04-30T16:44:18 | 2024-04-30T16:44:18 |
Chun Feng, Joy Hsu, Weiyu Liu, Jiajun Wu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
3D visual grounding is a challenging task that often requires direct and
dense supervision, notably the semantic label for each object in the scene. In
this paper, we instead study the naturally supervised setting that learns from
only 3D scene and QA pairs, where prior works underperform. We propose the
Language-Regularized Concept Learner (LARC), which uses constraints from
language as regularization to significantly improve the accuracy of
neuro-symbolic concept learners in the naturally supervised setting. Our
approach is based on two core insights: the first is that language constraints
(e.g., a word's relation to another) can serve as effective regularization for
structured representations in neuro-symbolic models; the second is that we can
query large language models to distill such constraints from language
properties. We show that LARC improves performance of prior works in naturally
supervised 3D visual grounding, and demonstrates a wide range of 3D visual
reasoning capabilities-from zero-shot composition, to data efficiency and
transferability. Our method represents a promising step towards regularizing
structured visual reasoning frameworks with language-based priors, for learning
in settings without dense supervision.
|
[
-0.3176323473,
-0.8705661297,
0.5298425555,
0.0333063826,
-0.3687046468,
-0.0713272318,
-0.1570024788,
-0.3317902386,
0.0419561937,
0.5187668204,
-0.1856982708,
-0.721364975,
-0.2975248694,
0.1881893128,
0.132898435,
0.7054451704,
-0.2467663884,
0.0122270491,
-0.3556153178,
-0.0875281245,
-0.5820681453,
-0.545802474,
-0.5796305537,
-0.0966706201,
0.551748693,
0.3393903375,
0.7598274946,
0.7970140576,
0.6373663545,
0.270601064,
-0.1269058585,
0.3016785979,
-0.6265301704,
-0.1403698176,
-0.061651729,
-0.5827032328,
-0.1123622507,
0.013909596,
0.6732918024,
1.0334466696,
0.0154654896,
-0.3892564774,
-0.0679430291,
0.8681208491,
-0.7192029953,
0.3911703229,
-0.4003018737,
0.277803272,
0.2234388143,
-0.0664439052,
-0.0835209712,
-0.3663533032,
0.0227535628,
-0.9528547525,
0.6056283116,
0.032071922,
1.0951322317,
0.7881213427,
-0.2702464163,
0.2556631267,
-0.5872564912,
0.526368618,
-0.3033922911,
0.6765587926,
0.6124673486,
0.4732568562,
-0.0756623298,
-0.5426398516,
-0.5059912205,
-0.4470192194,
-0.1953622401,
0.2006459683,
0.3028948605,
0.3223534524,
0.6584058404,
0.538346529,
-0.4428141713,
-0.0542672649,
-0.5852072835,
-0.1364576668,
0.4725507796,
-0.2284741998,
0.3629562259,
-0.1225619167,
-0.2114700824,
-0.4682534337,
-0.7379468083,
0.1159416139,
-0.0647635758,
0.4507043064,
-0.3523571789,
0.6537439227,
-0.3906963468,
1.0318260193,
-0.1097380891,
-0.0296414122,
0.1206532344,
-0.1372800171,
-0.2829844058,
0.0670598969,
0.4368566871,
0.4414004385,
0.4757584929,
-0.2769317031,
-0.1193170324,
0.4020920992,
0.2471159399,
-0.6665235758,
-0.4777580798,
-0.1452485919,
0.0573519617,
0.1006266773,
0.4005803168,
-0.352891624,
-0.5215275288,
-0.6115188003,
0.1107313186,
-0.3525610268,
-0.1713389307,
0.4532307684,
-0.1562321782,
0.3072591722,
0.4659892023,
-0.5367515087,
0.3310310245,
0.4517042637,
0.8897762895,
-0.0803296044,
-0.0885258839,
-0.7656891346,
0.4146232903,
-0.6384605765,
0.6238495111,
-0.3239986897,
-0.3411694467,
-0.1464381665,
0.0037929255,
0.0549197756,
-0.479803443,
0.349658072,
-0.4663363397,
0.1795751303,
-0.2435043305,
-0.2864605486,
-0.2304709852,
0.4024201632,
-0.7373287082,
0.8082103729,
0.1731395274,
-0.7780486941,
0.4145762622,
-0.2120338231,
-0.4740721881,
0.1279155761,
-0.589695096,
0.0077637862,
0.194627583,
0.4397550821,
0.4815202653,
0.0070000575,
0.3697595,
-0.2173464,
-0.4997393787,
-0.4109458327,
0.0901682824,
0.4032542408,
-0.0663485527,
-0.132135585,
0.0830762312,
-0.8835258484,
-0.1164303496,
0.1448823512,
-0.0218704585,
-0.4891008139,
-0.084611252,
-0.1847638637,
0.3415108919,
-0.0458339527,
-0.3331405222,
-0.0136033269,
-0.717972219,
0.0875823572,
0.3232451677,
0.0134030348,
0.7405948639,
-0.0264319871,
0.3394060731,
-0.0534836687,
-0.2316720635,
-0.0003035289,
-0.2720602751,
-0.8156850934,
-0.5030523539,
0.1273822933,
0.5684444308,
-0.93495363,
0.5742697716,
-0.2956100702,
-0.0889830366,
-0.2162946016,
0.2952573001,
0.3985044956,
0.7905519605,
0.5909793973,
-0.0826559514,
-0.4377263188,
-1.1102598906,
0.2135192454,
-0.0248490535,
-0.3683519065,
0.104340896,
0.3670631647,
-0.124900423,
1.0702427626,
-0.6364063621,
-0.7351174951,
-0.1610217988,
-0.0277472213,
0.2349931449,
0.6994128823,
0.4218742549,
-1.0309940577,
-0.4400433898,
0.1942585409,
-0.9789961576,
0.0163209829,
-0.1323979348,
-0.1657285392,
0.0767528564,
0.8905438781,
-0.3812853396,
0.5521653295,
0.208482638,
-0.2107349932,
-0.0999864563,
-0.3197027743,
-0.1873906851,
-0.631228745,
-0.0599635392,
0.2696544528,
-0.182584092,
-0.5307103992,
0.2176597267,
-0.0293079223,
-0.0841812268,
-0.5110977888,
0.580568254,
-0.4334415197,
0.1232914627,
-0.196679309,
0.2559707165,
0.1997780204,
0.7589730024,
0.95683676,
0.3483584225,
0.7981320024,
-0.7258588672,
0.0690554455,
0.3447059095,
-0.3037201166,
0.6482806206,
-0.9388861656,
0.2028483152,
-0.2888348103,
0.3349219859,
-0.6287376881,
-0.2080633938,
0.2196760029,
-0.1387182176,
0.113475956,
-0.2579671144,
-0.6301301122,
-0.151908949,
-0.0747937933,
0.2418252379,
0.3585880399,
-0.573971808,
0.5043418407,
0.1736110896,
0.3698368967,
-0.273434937,
-0.6373156309,
0.0587748364,
-0.062576957,
-0.6039447784,
0.4035152495,
0.1093936414,
-0.3681324422,
0.033664871,
-0.6585223079,
-0.2333446294,
0.0018558732,
0.3753852248,
0.1724282354,
-0.2208628207,
-0.1713587642,
-0.1547415257,
-0.1921132952,
0.0277581699,
0.0190848038,
0.1230158955,
-0.3923537731,
-0.2572785616,
-0.6176276803,
0.2203034908,
0.1791215241,
-0.1791582406,
0.6708492041,
0.5421119332,
-0.7029262185,
-0.0821971446,
-0.5469776392,
-0.2942038774,
-0.4598614573,
0.3451187313,
-0.6409344673,
-1.0665454865,
0.2268749923,
0.1767327785,
-0.1896971464,
0.1514961869,
0.0767928436,
-0.2218474746,
1.1991426945,
0.9501491189,
0.1927952915,
0.3255593777,
-0.5980780125,
0.1280902475,
-0.7866758108,
-0.3593020141,
-0.1890482008,
-0.1384031773,
-0.2169634104,
-0.7475687861,
0.2588611245,
0.7057030797,
-0.321015507,
0.0467630327,
-0.4077357352,
0.6888788342,
0.4923184514,
0.2805215716,
0.1044438183,
0.0963600725,
-0.209048748,
-0.0659798086,
-0.6885964274,
-0.4266903102,
0.474619478,
0.2056940198,
0.4901751876,
-0.1364346594,
0.51390028,
-0.2407772243,
0.2007138729,
-0.6950355172,
0.3586159647,
-0.0173412673,
-0.2362534851,
-0.2526491582,
-0.5432416797,
-0.6689965725,
0.5916470885,
-0.3204649389,
-0.626095295,
0.3332468569,
0.1876524985,
-0.4779897928,
0.2606876791,
-0.6117793322,
0.9787775278,
-0.2125723362,
-0.6499399543,
-0.0226979814,
-0.8563797474,
0.3805897534,
0.043938756,
0.2873185575,
-0.018488517,
0.0983398855,
0.4011758566,
-0.3622495234,
0.9941115975,
-0.3341526985,
-0.2917832732,
0.216467768,
0.1636460871,
0.4141136706,
0.5890821218,
0.3205121458,
0.0699804276,
-0.0968715698,
-0.4545412958,
-0.9065561295,
0.5403552651,
-0.7315209508,
-0.8301267624,
-0.4352338612,
-0.5808442235,
-0.5529460311,
0.3519548178,
0.0650432557,
0.1340696365,
-0.192866683,
0.4180792272,
0.8272119164,
-0.1735567749,
-0.031252943,
0.2810251117,
-0.2149407864,
-0.2927256823,
0.8883157372,
-0.2787643969,
0.1084363982,
0.6625429988,
0.2022944093,
-0.2696831524,
-0.5443102717,
-0.1094282642,
0.2425825149,
-0.7376534939,
-0.0960117802,
-0.574732542,
-0.2160087228,
-0.1521843225,
-0.7166368365,
-0.3704907596,
-0.3300737441,
-0.2943433821,
-0.311240375,
0.0792893171,
0.3665691316,
-0.1507869065,
0.3808655441,
-0.6135941148,
1.0965750217,
0.5237159729,
0.5188601017,
-0.5540213585,
-0.3534204066,
-0.1020010859,
0.3602094054,
0.3301003873,
-0.3656315804,
0.2346292138,
0.2069565803,
0.6077321768,
0.4897303879,
-0.0116946222,
0.8761485815,
-0.3611673117,
0.4910196364,
0.2625706494,
-0.6409693956,
0.7518516779,
-0.3217232227,
0.4517555833,
0.7354003191,
0.2216115147,
-0.3768944442,
-0.4321258068,
-0.4369883239,
-0.697537601,
0.6498910189,
0.2736674249,
0.0736532733,
-0.1553172469,
0.471159786,
-0.2856291234,
-0.0629271567,
-0.7782968879,
0.0124793239,
-0.5880779028,
0.110692054,
-0.3617050648,
0.0291000158,
-0.2970024645,
-0.6211494803,
0.2000206709,
-0.3338889182,
-0.2563247681,
0.3362253308,
-0.4647855163,
0.0193084944,
-0.3475589454,
0.4884415269,
0.5025914311,
-0.5090877414,
0.3927747011,
0.1283848882,
-0.2647105455,
-0.1272391677,
-0.0869382247,
-0.2350702137,
-0.0675655827,
0.451985687,
0.9151242375,
0.226181969,
-0.6483940482,
0.4165557921,
-0.0932402387,
-0.422731638,
-0.0335130617,
0.1310911626,
-0.1769647747,
-0.0251144283,
0.0768113509,
0.0742382035,
-0.1426098049,
-0.0711222962,
0.2162452638,
0.3130187988,
-0.5878345966,
-0.3200637698,
0.7754227519,
0.1035337523,
0.1846694946,
0.7125171423,
-0.1098811328,
-0.3180639744,
0.7986200452,
0.558929801,
0.6237664223,
0.090697661,
0.2316998094,
0.6510154605,
0.4383493364,
-0.5083609819,
0.1783033311,
-0.2266727388,
-1.0586074591,
-0.5552982092,
-0.4015877247,
-0.2483077198,
0.0228346456,
-0.675516367,
0.4325093329,
-0.7319339514,
0.2273508459,
-0.3707620203,
-0.1991512626,
-0.7664531469,
0.4095955491,
0.5783119202,
0.6742165089,
-0.8149360418,
0.8914160132,
0.9966088533,
-0.5110247731,
-0.5618101358,
-0.2997753918,
-0.1697617173,
-0.4600029588,
0.9074030519,
0.4618912339,
-0.5459414124,
0.1088828892,
-0.501680553,
-0.9136067033,
0.6522122622,
0.5054285526,
-0.3666289747,
0.039507553,
0.1471483111,
0.759820044,
-0.1619011313,
-0.2752518654,
0.3897303641,
0.4673220813,
0.4543603957,
-0.4679612517,
-0.0511217266,
-0.4063975811,
0.146285668,
0.0147702033,
-0.2800780535,
0.2894191742,
-0.2692005336,
-0.5578808188,
-0.3535083234,
1.0190986395,
0.4580353796,
0.0689851418,
0.687974453,
0.7900887728,
0.5573685169,
-0.0126340585,
0.9537844658,
-0.1540403068,
-0.0546532907,
1.2500087023,
-0.3980636001,
0.579010129,
0.6835476756,
0.0968038067,
0.3660964072,
0.557515204,
0.0689404309,
0.6896938682,
0.4298771024,
0.2503542304,
-0.5768854022,
-0.2382327169,
-0.394399941,
0.3629699349,
0.5046007633,
0.2955831587,
-0.288293004,
-0.0314758383,
-0.3157358766,
0.5116825104,
-0.3794570267,
0.6155878305,
0.2821727395,
-0.371920228,
0.9365375638,
-0.1680873334,
0.5608923435,
-0.400444001,
-0.3200804889,
-0.3463102579,
-0.1220826581,
-0.2887706161,
-0.3298662901,
0.4482636452,
-0.2282097191,
0.0389552377,
-0.4388698041,
0.3533295691,
-0.4386338592,
-0.6221520901,
0.0296584517,
0.5250705481,
-0.0543785095,
-0.2622881234,
-0.374373585,
-0.177875042,
-0.3125394583,
-0.1043841168,
0.1588933319,
0.4667513072,
-0.4122451246,
0.6248092055,
0.6031460166,
0.0660153851,
-0.0810710341,
0.2590142787,
0.8860824108,
-0.5730766654,
-0.5766731501,
-0.5728939772,
0.3396243155,
-0.083558701,
-0.1193406433,
0.6411760449,
0.7522444129,
1.0473947525,
-0.0796677768,
0.4241924584,
0.030655982,
0.0930680931,
-0.8061326146,
0.3501512408,
-0.5400765538,
0.2475329489,
-0.138806507,
-1.1353205442,
-1.1509987116,
1.1933231354,
-0.2588554621,
-0.1992844045,
0.9697547555,
0.7555322051,
-0.1407618076,
-0.2753734589,
0.4584738016,
-0.1132370681,
0.1308763027,
0.5599093437,
0.9984485507,
0.0156298131,
0.1361721605,
-0.849558115,
-0.0782422274,
0.2510023117,
-0.8627396226,
-1.3681724072,
-0.4544197917,
-0.6996279955,
-0.050397031,
0.0221588183,
0.7742877007,
0.6602478623,
-0.8442349434,
-0.0773102343,
-0.5207643509,
0.2756082714,
-0.3481224477,
-0.1962939948,
0.7039573193,
-0.3039290309,
-0.7522522807,
0.6753535867,
0.2018910348,
0.193370983,
-0.0026659372,
-0.0727952495,
-0.1075532809,
-0.4146205187,
0.5226992965,
0.4407744408,
-0.7230958939,
-0.4254251122,
-0.0164845362,
-0.2146862298,
0.2024632543,
0.8551138639,
-1.0954021215,
0.4114253521,
0.4390361607,
0.5153980255,
0.4510402381,
0.0969147161,
0.7694411874,
-0.9806956053,
0.6849574447,
0.3225009143,
0.3990918994,
0.4318164587,
-0.3025997281,
0.8150827289,
0.2776578069,
0.1479346007,
-0.9117212296,
0.1480719894,
-0.9712023139,
-0.2049975544,
1.2322330475,
0.0346507467,
-0.1330968291,
-0.1355403662,
-0.3357480466,
0.2663806975,
0.0139533477,
0.7075076699,
0.2181732357,
0.1219761521,
-0.4441100657,
-0.693253696,
0.7085415125,
0.2585617602,
-0.6806018353,
-0.2278287858,
0.81848526,
-0.1282690465,
0.1419684738,
0.3267764747,
0.1031184196,
0.2379691154,
-0.2907644212,
0.2745495141,
-0.330422163,
-0.5863407254,
-0.3336660862,
0.2114699036,
-0.1951090842,
-0.0722850487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01597v1
|
Improving Disease Detection from Social Media Text via Self-Augmentation and Contrastive Learning
| 2024-04-30T15:24:54 | 2024-04-30T15:24:54 |
Pervaiz Iqbal Khan, Andreas Dengel, Sheraz Ahmed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting diseases from social media has diverse applications, such as public
health monitoring and disease spread detection. While language models (LMs)
have shown promising performance in this domain, there remains ongoing research
aimed at refining their discriminating representations. In this paper, we
propose a novel method that integrates Contrastive Learning (CL) with language
modeling to address this challenge. Our approach introduces a self-augmentation
method, wherein hidden representations of the model are augmented with their
own representations. This method comprises two branches: the first branch, a
traditional LM, learns features specific to the given data, while the second
branch incorporates augmented representations from the first branch to
encourage generalization. CL further refines these representations by pulling
pairs of original and augmented versions closer while pushing other samples
away. We evaluate our method on three NLP datasets encompassing binary,
multi-label, and multi-class classification tasks involving social media posts
related to various diseases. Our approach demonstrates notable improvements
over traditional fine-tuning methods, achieving up to a 2.48% increase in
F1-score compared to baseline approaches and a 2.1% enhancement over
state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.008993567,
-0.601015389,
0.3658078909,
0.0752281398,
-0.4989193082,
0.2239650935,
-0.053310968,
-0.8164525628,
0.7787082195,
0.4359745979,
-0.3264822066,
-0.7203362584,
-0.7143294215,
0.1806315333,
-0.2348214537,
1.0279132128,
0.2696500123,
0.071845606,
-0.0404385924,
-0.2912278771,
-0.0677146018,
-0.2941943407,
-0.7772768736,
-0.367149353,
0.5972905159,
0.4155366123,
0.4832196534,
0.757773757,
0.5979394317,
0.2947542667,
-0.0303124934,
0.5243844986,
-0.4532012343,
0.1632208228,
-0.453683883,
-0.1737556309,
-0.0800182968,
-0.12379843,
0.3056201339,
0.6736680269,
0.2216461301,
-0.0195242427,
0.4442002177,
0.8158968091,
-0.5031987429,
0.0962645635,
-0.4248580039,
-0.0640413836,
0.0398633368,
-0.4382700622,
-0.0787356943,
-0.0877675787,
0.0812050924,
-0.4589028955,
0.3193122745,
-0.388248682,
0.680624187,
0.3246747255,
-0.5614151955,
-0.418027699,
-0.4569277167,
0.604614377,
-0.6550438404,
0.283420682,
0.5091553926,
0.2824661136,
0.1810760498,
-0.7523533702,
-0.2225709558,
-0.0878562331,
-0.3327797949,
0.2029176354,
-0.3586788177,
-0.0451384485,
-0.1079623997,
0.4747652113,
-0.5433555841,
0.1393343657,
-0.4986977875,
-0.2622849345,
0.7281527519,
-0.2318992615,
0.5397135019,
-0.3431079984,
-0.1951230913,
-0.0263003688,
-0.3692060113,
-0.3244205713,
-0.0095304856,
0.5212816,
-0.5577491522,
0.1573476791,
-0.2622794509,
0.3829768896,
0.2144506276,
-0.0152235106,
0.7348091602,
-0.3592253625,
-0.1142281294,
-0.1685734391,
0.7389290333,
0.5563539267,
-0.1073037609,
0.1205380559,
-0.095380038,
0.0513150394,
0.0647061467,
-0.9397285581,
-0.8980635405,
0.148668319,
-0.7814749479,
-0.4610373974,
-0.3503969312,
-0.8128783703,
-0.7070486546,
-0.1907953173,
0.4026439786,
-0.7012430429,
-0.4430660009,
0.0980733931,
0.0104914755,
-0.2995473146,
0.373785764,
-0.99295187,
0.09658169,
0.3572719097,
0.8656760454,
-0.3311018944,
0.2355909348,
-0.6043999195,
0.1254002452,
-0.3151622713,
1.0102007389,
-0.5980713367,
-0.3373386264,
0.1528739929,
-0.0578332953,
0.1500553191,
-0.7046038508,
0.4441047907,
-0.2814454436,
0.0572732538,
-0.2226867974,
-0.4633690417,
0.0201397762,
0.1655057222,
-0.7612713575,
0.9509167671,
0.1254321784,
-0.9964865446,
0.1359646916,
-0.431922853,
-0.5799816847,
0.2613204718,
-0.4060949683,
-0.6863949895,
0.0372776166,
0.6844089031,
0.6934082508,
0.2821648717,
-0.0346668363,
-0.5713484287,
-0.2861412466,
-0.0738626793,
-0.1974933296,
0.5800644755,
0.3002287745,
-0.186178118,
0.2384989858,
-0.6116759777,
-0.238057375,
0.218896091,
-0.1579713225,
-0.7102637291,
0.0846905261,
-0.1230411157,
0.080732286,
0.199304834,
-0.4449002147,
0.024335321,
-0.7559847832,
0.1561026275,
0.6068804264,
0.2144132107,
0.3280171752,
-0.510263741,
0.2593151927,
0.2946943641,
0.0124279484,
-0.4699515402,
-0.3986776173,
-0.5270091891,
-0.3684340715,
0.2852756977,
0.2870416641,
-1.233479619,
0.5139096975,
-0.0931816548,
-0.3365524411,
-0.9474437833,
0.3854009211,
0.3256706297,
0.3844607174,
0.8531035185,
0.0227372218,
-0.466643095,
-0.6605704427,
-0.3678836226,
0.0266283154,
-0.1138117313,
0.2783863246,
0.302128911,
-0.6170510054,
0.284127295,
-0.5527232885,
-0.4569804072,
-0.3338009417,
0.2606285214,
-0.0272601843,
0.7509225607,
0.6227142811,
-0.8945877552,
-0.7400141954,
0.3125221133,
-0.734777689,
-0.2831911445,
0.0371374339,
0.3411074877,
-0.0983433276,
0.6573911309,
0.2153988928,
0.454931438,
0.8408844471,
-0.2372432351,
0.2646411061,
-0.3399194777,
0.2584689856,
-1.168843627,
-0.2195663005,
0.5582244992,
-0.585957706,
-0.6952621937,
0.0841389745,
0.2125882655,
-0.1068180501,
-0.2052191496,
0.6642193198,
-0.3986246884,
0.405880332,
-0.546241641,
0.0394228809,
0.004439421,
0.0026526451,
-0.155400008,
0.5626065731,
0.6199659109,
-0.5326303244,
0.082441166,
-0.2626293004,
-0.1147981584,
0.293408066,
-0.5574417114,
-0.0505351014,
-0.457590133,
0.0803037882,
-1.1846687794,
-0.192614153,
0.498523891,
-0.6595816016,
0.2635678053,
0.2003161609,
-0.3929696679,
-0.36331442,
-0.5151721239,
0.3982389569,
0.3031613827,
-0.9462624788,
0.6759241819,
0.4955226183,
-0.0131588168,
-0.3662335575,
-0.8468870521,
-0.1970356107,
-0.140278548,
-0.4317724109,
0.6840399504,
-0.0802594721,
-0.0233514756,
0.1816520393,
-0.3225693107,
-0.0929175317,
0.0269987863,
0.0077136811,
-0.0746386647,
-0.0092719598,
0.6604691744,
0.290515691,
0.0757602453,
-0.2421165109,
0.1835559607,
0.5150418282,
0.0724515915,
-0.3398998976,
-0.5840758681,
0.451204747,
0.0330931582,
-0.3257735372,
0.4547566175,
0.7593149543,
-0.5825420618,
-0.3579036593,
-0.5622885823,
-0.4518113732,
-0.564699173,
0.2544849515,
-0.2903823853,
-1.0283157825,
0.393989414,
-0.2561501265,
-0.2936045825,
0.4901179075,
0.2189714164,
-0.3221085072,
1.0594875813,
0.8221764565,
-0.2780578136,
0.6424107552,
-0.1619946957,
-0.0005013742,
-0.6911865473,
-0.0274062306,
-0.3516208529,
-0.0165862273,
-0.8520480394,
-0.6888243556,
0.4040059745,
0.05424257,
0.2483082265,
0.0138708493,
-0.7989819646,
0.497520715,
0.3176946044,
0.9561805725,
0.2539354563,
0.1134405062,
-0.2181260586,
-0.2484016567,
-0.6334928274,
-0.1633848995,
1.1725358963,
0.413636148,
0.6429320574,
0.0222166628,
1.1796395779,
0.6751158237,
0.6791397333,
-0.3277269602,
0.1672211587,
-0.7527190447,
-0.3268142343,
-0.1355642974,
-0.5713217854,
-1.0852856636,
0.3682207465,
-0.4830200076,
-0.6036550999,
0.251478672,
0.4532682896,
-0.4303637147,
0.127530992,
-0.7056902051,
0.7627363205,
-0.2974373698,
-0.3512108922,
-0.3444713354,
-0.6435644031,
0.2890859544,
0.0627363324,
0.3496673703,
-0.1940376163,
0.0668823719,
0.5573210716,
-0.0994734168,
1.1604559422,
0.1341313124,
-0.0321617983,
-0.096882388,
-0.2083334327,
0.2510628402,
0.037383154,
-0.2392778397,
-0.0155296717,
-0.1233112141,
-0.6077676415,
-0.5303538442,
0.9621803761,
-0.636105299,
-0.5456523895,
-0.4752570391,
-0.246540606,
-0.0202431586,
0.258792907,
-0.0784217045,
0.2179495394,
-0.1881113201,
0.1023517177,
0.6703233719,
-0.3934159279,
0.2774986029,
0.5330453515,
-0.3848414421,
-0.5130007267,
1.1938811541,
-0.0781524852,
0.2489212155,
0.3485485315,
0.6069797277,
-0.3334674537,
-0.544734776,
0.0774421021,
0.5561336279,
-0.9783201814,
-0.235843122,
-0.7476586699,
-0.2060488164,
-0.8458510637,
0.0038274438,
-0.0547411218,
0.0639408976,
-0.7942137718,
-0.0960698128,
0.299882561,
0.7398590446,
-0.5770751238,
0.3618127108,
-0.6982274652,
0.7815157175,
0.3839666843,
0.2855623364,
-0.0677298307,
-0.4679574966,
-0.1408315152,
0.1328821182,
-0.3440393507,
-1.2255306244,
0.5326974988,
0.2320015281,
0.5992295742,
0.6608729959,
0.2259986848,
0.5756626725,
-0.0671552569,
0.3586509228,
0.3429088295,
-0.7019978166,
0.7575105429,
-0.2793429494,
0.3738857806,
0.7087370157,
0.7930625081,
-0.4500611424,
-0.3383015096,
-0.4847721457,
-0.5239367485,
0.1960060447,
0.0544348732,
0.2809051573,
-0.3247389793,
0.2574743032,
-0.123245351,
-0.2037003487,
-0.9817368984,
-0.4702713788,
-0.2925887108,
-0.4345276654,
-0.1545232236,
-0.3183128834,
0.1007223949,
-0.4975823164,
0.587924242,
-0.3003181219,
-0.1288629025,
0.5292325616,
-0.0089875907,
-0.056010887,
0.0104087656,
0.1775590181,
0.4387430549,
-0.1196808666,
0.4637794495,
0.0883756131,
-0.1460242569,
-0.2899544239,
0.5394446254,
-0.0272047706,
0.2777352929,
0.3928869069,
0.3867331147,
0.2216080427,
-0.487785995,
0.6819770336,
0.21575813,
0.1072312519,
0.1941606402,
0.0015139568,
0.2791780829,
0.300845474,
0.3762097061,
-0.1046427637,
0.5825510025,
-0.5762265921,
0.5105777979,
0.4079191685,
-0.698297143,
-0.1968957931,
0.4489321709,
0.515478909,
-0.1754630059,
0.0354276821,
-0.3019478619,
-0.4480543733,
0.489990294,
0.7058348656,
0.4310504794,
-0.8941571116,
0.4639753699,
0.448348999,
0.3225831389,
0.1300713867,
0.2895733118,
-0.0206912719,
-0.8252878785,
-0.4229217768,
-0.494132489,
-0.083665967,
0.4725593328,
-0.4071422815,
0.3348935246,
-0.1438551545,
-0.0332587734,
0.5892517567,
0.0427854322,
-0.4010104537,
0.5546876192,
0.2421033829,
0.6420773268,
-1.1552270651,
0.8899528384,
0.5536295772,
-0.4637555182,
-0.4550585747,
0.4148132205,
-0.0861077234,
-0.7674945593,
0.4963272214,
0.6843723059,
-0.1679397374,
-0.1045150757,
-0.4238351285,
-0.7163527012,
0.6357690096,
0.2416346967,
-0.6581465602,
0.0139419166,
0.0034275055,
0.7237668037,
-0.4550459981,
0.1327399909,
0.2990927696,
0.084965989,
0.0180886444,
-0.645180285,
0.0758670419,
-0.2800891995,
-0.031334877,
0.0104274768,
-0.3783963323,
0.522403717,
-0.3177401721,
-0.5588877797,
-0.1927028596,
0.8458702564,
0.2197977901,
0.4273024499,
0.3892005682,
0.4268942773,
0.8109068871,
0.2598817945,
0.8642045259,
-0.4017962813,
0.3675795197,
1.2014899254,
-0.0134983752,
0.7074827552,
0.159402594,
0.0672318786,
0.6318793297,
0.6987485886,
0.0318933651,
0.6198399067,
0.2452052832,
-0.4441150427,
-0.4043931663,
-0.2550987005,
-0.484860003,
0.2093618512,
0.673943162,
-0.8919274807,
-0.5188217759,
0.2258349955,
-0.023750389,
0.673617959,
-0.4410408139,
0.8282567263,
0.0979745239,
-0.1689045429,
0.6057806015,
-0.100457184,
0.9111696482,
-0.2826582789,
-0.4069902301,
-0.1259345412,
0.1756100655,
-0.2837928534,
-0.6387653947,
0.4917798638,
-0.431081593,
-0.001092758,
0.0719264522,
1.1921464205,
-0.7801727653,
-0.7518351078,
0.7316312194,
0.5085909367,
0.08206442,
-0.1789513081,
-0.9457982779,
0.1261513531,
0.0949463248,
0.2971006334,
0.1604626924,
0.3260760307,
0.125225842,
0.734924674,
0.6182251573,
0.2006894946,
-0.3858439326,
0.1742305607,
1.1387913227,
-0.4193485677,
-0.491488874,
-0.9550197124,
0.1656175554,
-0.4921827614,
-0.0381868519,
0.7027531862,
0.5781708956,
0.7485222816,
0.0792005658,
0.8695223331,
0.4162538648,
0.9875152111,
-0.3553395569,
0.8037303686,
-0.8405593634,
0.1771875918,
-0.2333537042,
-0.0117803933,
-0.6283214092,
0.5774751902,
-0.3366035819,
-0.030307984,
0.7325537205,
0.7284021378,
-0.0622111447,
-0.2650849819,
0.4195490479,
0.134344846,
0.1662185788,
0.2421773523,
0.44542557,
-0.3043790162,
0.3533522487,
-0.5819718838,
-0.4066711068,
-0.4245527387,
-0.630484283,
-1.2579696178,
-0.4975193441,
-0.553022027,
-0.4909806848,
0.5248926282,
0.9584689736,
0.7768292427,
-0.8660507202,
0.1870342791,
0.1727926433,
0.1701774895,
-0.2855813205,
-0.1789474189,
0.6859130263,
-0.446470201,
-0.5335083008,
0.4536584616,
0.1996649504,
0.1566720158,
-0.1412885785,
0.167068094,
-0.3930383027,
-0.0514124408,
0.6542282104,
0.3014847934,
-0.5591958761,
-0.1423237324,
-0.263189137,
-0.2661502361,
0.3539779186,
0.4362576008,
-0.8135179281,
0.7219128609,
0.3915733993,
0.7001563907,
0.5323003531,
0.4001927376,
0.2081589252,
-0.7826548815,
-0.1383805573,
0.3835465312,
0.2374224812,
0.7799274921,
-0.5229542255,
0.286111474,
0.2749946713,
-0.2773050368,
-0.5440564156,
0.2331137955,
-0.8739359379,
-0.7074519396,
1.1673736572,
-0.0325569063,
-0.1768913567,
-0.3571390212,
-0.143766433,
0.4221576452,
-0.4983952045,
1.1596485376,
0.043456994,
-0.2188307047,
-0.3462508917,
-0.123543337,
0.6600986719,
0.3213275969,
-1.0108225346,
-0.1318508536,
0.2432975769,
0.4307177067,
0.1986226737,
0.9102346897,
-0.0139521845,
0.3176910281,
-0.3786706924,
0.1041688621,
0.2077799886,
-0.1457322091,
-0.5277913809,
-0.027373435,
-0.3579933941,
-0.3110882044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19597v1
|
Transferring Troubles: Cross-Lingual Transferability of Backdoor Attacks in LLMs with Instruction Tuning
| 2024-04-30T14:43:57 | 2024-04-30T14:43:57 |
Xuanli He, Jun Wang, Qiongkai Xu, Pasquale Minervini, Pontus Stenetorp, Benjamin I. P. Rubinstein, Trevor Cohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The implications of backdoor attacks on English-centric large language models
(LLMs) have been widely examined - such attacks can be achieved by embedding
malicious behaviors during training and activated under specific conditions
that trigger malicious outputs. However, the impact of backdoor attacks on
multilingual models remains under-explored. Our research focuses on
cross-lingual backdoor attacks against multilingual LLMs, particularly
investigating how poisoning the instruction-tuning data in one or two languages
can affect the outputs in languages whose instruction-tuning data was not
poisoned. Despite its simplicity, our empirical analysis reveals that our
method exhibits remarkable efficacy in models like mT5, BLOOM, and
GPT-3.5-turbo, with high attack success rates, surpassing 95% in several
languages across various scenarios. Alarmingly, our findings also indicate that
larger models show increased susceptibility to transferable cross-lingual
backdoor attacks, which also applies to LLMs predominantly pre-trained on
English data, such as Llama2, Llama3, and Gemma. Moreover, our experiments show
that triggers can still work even after paraphrasing, and the backdoor
mechanism proves highly effective in cross-lingual response settings across 25
languages, achieving an average attack success rate of 50%. Our study aims to
highlight the vulnerabilities and significant security risks present in current
multilingual LLMs, underscoring the emergent need for targeted security
measures.
|
[
-0.0533030443,
-0.6914513707,
0.2934677005,
0.3179009259,
0.1191576719,
0.1729395241,
-0.2299142182,
-0.6630764008,
-0.0988149047,
0.577098906,
-0.6083799601,
-0.649245739,
-0.7591475844,
0.0577190481,
-0.4630567431,
1.0460063219,
-0.0019362033,
0.1982828081,
0.1273953915,
0.0813932717,
-0.6545738578,
-0.8276157379,
-0.6134791374,
-0.1346790045,
0.6714507937,
0.381911695,
0.6613531113,
0.1531465948,
0.5206894875,
0.2572222352,
0.2331698686,
-0.3737913072,
-0.7353743911,
0.1452096403,
-0.3927874267,
-0.7577435374,
-0.3285895288,
-0.1159609407,
0.4704371691,
0.3338426948,
-0.1201329529,
0.0378420129,
0.0233365186,
0.4897997975,
-0.6041250825,
-0.1439132839,
-1.0512199402,
0.260844171,
-0.377586931,
-0.3725572228,
-0.7090615034,
-0.1400149614,
-0.2606423199,
-0.3771274984,
0.0153484521,
0.1294526458,
0.6333404779,
-0.0087953471,
-0.2923765182,
-0.423509419,
-0.3420983255,
0.7529298067,
-0.633823514,
0.6685305238,
0.3279202878,
0.1716889292,
-0.1410002857,
-0.5349286795,
-0.1765052527,
-0.2706068158,
-0.1696864218,
-0.0056937947,
-0.5038946867,
-0.2601107955,
0.2520608902,
0.2133047581,
-0.7573263645,
0.496651262,
-0.4985374212,
-0.5142166018,
0.5409108996,
0.2644984424,
0.7031786442,
0.1441202462,
-0.3713857532,
-0.1392930895,
-1.2930210829,
0.0102098016,
0.7236604095,
0.3811139464,
-0.2857791483,
0.3175338507,
0.3022092879,
0.4409368634,
-0.0323434547,
-0.1699692458,
-0.0342192091,
-0.4870404601,
0.0949621052,
0.1677918434,
0.6614792347,
0.3519832492,
0.3169875443,
-0.5568265915,
-0.2423335165,
-0.2406794876,
0.290800035,
-0.8505734801,
-0.1467757374,
0.1592657864,
-0.1880220175,
-0.3078053594,
0.0177026168,
-0.9885196686,
-0.2083694339,
0.382717371,
0.5035330653,
-0.5262368321,
-0.202080369,
0.0498110428,
0.0462279245,
0.5362676978,
0.0561199896,
-0.9699627757,
0.1162300855,
0.8717365265,
0.7899357677,
-0.4350611567,
-0.7874960899,
-0.6530044079,
0.4316840768,
-0.4985764921,
0.3850758672,
-0.6461976767,
-0.612377584,
0.222852245,
0.4163015783,
-0.3869616091,
-0.3709922433,
0.0479121543,
-0.7964644432,
0.272752583,
-0.2374714762,
-0.1691892296,
-0.0679542944,
0.4019544721,
-0.570074141,
0.6339467764,
-0.3799568713,
-0.7622337341,
-0.1168580949,
-0.1895243675,
-0.9114317894,
-0.2766247392,
0.0497634187,
-0.2505666912,
0.0774814859,
0.0884988233,
0.4411180615,
-0.1565386206,
-0.2115637362,
-0.2354928553,
-0.3190553784,
0.3686367571,
-0.6592619419,
0.9831345677,
0.0238567945,
-0.3837905228,
-0.1519999206,
-0.5993694067,
-0.138170138,
0.1772674769,
-0.1942979246,
-0.4987321794,
-0.3992582262,
-0.2806108594,
0.3253795505,
0.3446025252,
-0.5595163107,
0.1503568292,
-0.4024907053,
0.2081392556,
0.7034262419,
0.0936489552,
0.1935484856,
-0.2376692742,
0.9525462985,
0.0841583535,
0.1908198297,
-0.4047721326,
-0.608273983,
-0.274747014,
-0.049201645,
0.200941205,
1.0180629492,
-0.8338958025,
-0.1367294192,
-0.1834706068,
-0.520205915,
-0.4247709811,
0.1438778937,
0.8180060983,
0.2730287611,
0.1499170065,
-0.1027457193,
-0.1178363115,
-0.7255559564,
-0.6382989287,
-0.0522546992,
0.2454361469,
0.2124682367,
0.5996282101,
-0.2506787181,
0.172868222,
-0.3812894523,
-0.1677838564,
-0.0878138393,
0.0423561186,
0.0120546333,
0.5143312812,
0.7362242341,
-0.5133270025,
-0.7230833173,
0.30463323,
-0.5671841502,
-0.1838188618,
-0.1625769734,
-0.1963098347,
0.3430468142,
0.6683899164,
-0.501411736,
0.3884700835,
0.9294366241,
-0.2236523628,
0.6867671609,
-0.0094747562,
0.2698585689,
-1.2887357473,
-0.1465335935,
-0.2569243908,
0.0462414511,
-0.7448400259,
0.4190755785,
0.3279884458,
-0.2887893021,
-0.7896878123,
0.5764728189,
-0.5621052384,
-0.1853453964,
0.1191148162,
-0.0931606293,
0.0068473928,
0.5999397635,
-0.2593968213,
1.054366827,
0.7479804158,
-0.3644377887,
0.546528101,
-0.0410387106,
-0.0854019225,
0.6596684456,
-0.5315608978,
0.3034365177,
0.374070704,
-0.0136784632,
-1.0769279003,
-0.0687915012,
0.5380735993,
-0.5763424039,
0.9173821807,
-0.3938950002,
-0.3237114847,
0.0795211568,
-0.4903714657,
0.3290567994,
0.2475285083,
-0.6341915131,
0.5763162374,
0.0708872601,
-0.4042082727,
-0.8023828864,
-0.9804815054,
0.4238924384,
-0.3872992098,
-0.7666999698,
0.3039592206,
0.0521486998,
-0.1488856524,
-0.1453727782,
0.032322038,
0.026513001,
0.1897772104,
0.1187504604,
0.1387386024,
-0.259778887,
-0.171225518,
0.1425614953,
-0.0073275226,
0.4023518264,
-0.1585693657,
0.4195555747,
0.0160341468,
-0.7101014256,
-0.2607464492,
0.7035086155,
0.7774476409,
-0.2941671312,
0.8991888762,
0.5357684493,
-0.1661138833,
-0.144404918,
-0.3165270984,
-0.2970840633,
-0.4770874679,
0.6196867228,
-0.7165784836,
-0.6115205288,
0.7965459824,
0.2445098013,
0.2975378036,
0.0803690404,
0.6175925136,
0.2194869667,
1.0508285761,
0.721804142,
-0.2103760689,
0.3294731379,
0.1018797234,
0.1844812036,
-0.6488432288,
-0.2118840963,
-0.5828207731,
-0.1065347493,
-0.8437345624,
-0.040558774,
0.1912006289,
-0.286791563,
0.0238004494,
0.2407190353,
0.0388635546,
0.4654622972,
0.2924140394,
-0.1370595545,
0.3915348649,
0.1166878194,
-0.2346949577,
-0.1499816626,
-0.7386415005,
-0.0946483165,
1.1825555563,
0.485306561,
1.2400039434,
0.4972734153,
0.6778419614,
-0.0327710807,
0.2617838681,
-0.5725790262,
0.4232936203,
-0.2352845371,
-0.7236309052,
-0.0587806925,
-0.4489181042,
-1.2416607141,
0.234249115,
0.1839324385,
-0.903008759,
0.0723081082,
0.0161977373,
-0.2038634121,
0.6001473665,
-0.7815130949,
0.9203628302,
-0.5674188137,
-0.5158988833,
-0.242899403,
-0.6975696087,
0.6694310904,
-0.5326619744,
0.3820464015,
0.1769358516,
-0.0167567544,
0.7311654687,
-0.1031735465,
1.108977437,
0.0442213528,
-0.8279042244,
-0.4798949957,
0.3989551067,
0.6986359358,
0.0555863678,
0.2034021467,
0.721449554,
0.2164312005,
-0.3909995854,
-0.6526114345,
0.9306675196,
-0.6649893522,
-1.2018560171,
-0.4334308207,
-0.5535335541,
-0.3319596946,
0.0714068487,
0.5526923537,
0.2918151319,
0.1716272682,
0.1251846552,
0.7610778213,
-0.5809794068,
0.4215515852,
0.8538047671,
-0.3703090549,
-0.2777600288,
1.1406081915,
0.1648037136,
0.6072723866,
0.3944791555,
0.0957082659,
0.0425448902,
-0.5013743639,
-0.6147420406,
0.3647610247,
-0.6581562757,
-0.2303672433,
-0.3722486496,
-0.3384819925,
-0.5473666787,
-0.0725940242,
-0.5291939974,
-0.1986258179,
-0.1508534998,
0.0319968052,
0.4131672084,
0.5924759507,
-0.1136415005,
0.2932904959,
-1.1432185173,
0.0888248608,
0.3212568462,
0.2247454524,
0.0221580211,
-0.825042367,
-0.5241239667,
-0.0303434804,
-0.2144328207,
-1.3940380812,
0.3957018256,
0.0976992771,
0.5447129011,
0.1933502704,
-0.0846036896,
0.4833271801,
-0.5930585265,
0.7882781029,
0.0721616894,
-0.7390047312,
0.3124964535,
-0.1985500902,
0.0365875289,
0.2343781888,
0.6167850494,
-0.7097378373,
-0.5621930361,
-0.321536541,
-0.7706847191,
0.7901986837,
-0.060503114,
0.3722214997,
0.3468215168,
0.1132717133,
0.3324054182,
0.0790236592,
-0.7335770726,
-0.3116951287,
-0.1044689342,
0.0507052802,
-0.0157782473,
-0.2055885643,
-0.1791131049,
0.0528830774,
0.712300241,
0.1337614954,
-0.0324251987,
-0.1939056963,
-0.3836184442,
-0.0787298977,
0.3879617155,
0.667123735,
0.4464309812,
0.2184851021,
0.1384710371,
0.3954967856,
-0.8340357542,
0.2839942873,
0.1058623269,
-0.0718049556,
-0.1621003896,
0.6274063587,
0.5895091295,
0.5368741155,
-0.4020791352,
0.432313472,
-0.2266106009,
0.1148657277,
-0.0622112304,
-0.0096585089,
-0.0231878925,
0.2694824934,
0.2443323731,
-0.2772090733,
-0.165919587,
-0.7940753698,
0.1077589169,
0.5998150706,
-0.2082148939,
-0.6523680687,
0.2507531941,
0.1187081635,
-0.4447119534,
0.471758306,
0.183918342,
-0.9119832516,
0.448905021,
0.9422518611,
0.9196631312,
-0.6877615452,
-0.2615270615,
-0.1089524478,
0.7557551861,
0.2807868123,
0.0127962409,
0.0906554982,
-0.7230182886,
-0.2966473699,
-0.3047214448,
-0.5143522024,
0.1236234605,
-0.7259340882,
0.0104849404,
-0.2311487794,
0.1083088666,
-0.4290377498,
-0.1250644177,
-0.3310672939,
-0.1646898985,
0.2957828343,
0.8176433444,
-1.024435997,
0.9494037032,
0.5997905731,
-0.0961496085,
-0.7333008647,
0.3080639839,
-0.0339188352,
-1.1339057684,
0.7127448916,
0.0646831468,
-0.3791552782,
0.0303816032,
-0.3245681226,
-0.8943423629,
0.7742984891,
0.5013558865,
-0.722197175,
-0.1142417118,
0.2647050321,
0.2357780784,
-0.028167434,
-0.2710249424,
0.7422122359,
0.5465669036,
0.015488972,
-0.909537375,
0.1112435982,
-0.2204310447,
-0.254855901,
0.2364835888,
-0.6863176227,
0.9423857331,
-0.1311771572,
-0.2686169446,
-0.1838775575,
0.3708407879,
0.24980627,
0.3617455661,
0.1408256292,
0.6460133791,
0.4910075366,
0.0390834659,
1.0390359163,
-0.7175293565,
-0.1558866799,
0.9981756806,
-0.4921222627,
0.8036636114,
0.5648272634,
-0.0778086707,
0.419439584,
0.4828261435,
-0.0107254004,
0.571760416,
-0.0343876742,
0.0779646561,
0.2024755627,
0.2225545347,
-0.7386585474,
0.3781972826,
0.5207601786,
-0.139365688,
-0.1873323768,
0.3204848766,
0.4870644212,
-0.227072373,
-0.3514080346,
0.6451951265,
0.2170930952,
-0.6969468594,
0.6139593124,
0.1537556201,
0.8010399938,
-0.7666442394,
0.1360934824,
-0.5337792635,
0.0441533327,
-0.3263896108,
-0.7752717733,
0.3549424708,
0.1315485984,
0.0998562127,
-0.1775664985,
0.5971871614,
-0.5457730889,
-0.3277587593,
0.6003972292,
0.3967340291,
0.2491097301,
0.0498647504,
-0.6558471322,
0.244556427,
0.1125538051,
-0.4317517877,
0.7153552771,
0.5982328057,
-0.1142883673,
0.616699338,
0.7133663297,
0.4406592548,
0.4567195177,
-0.0355029851,
0.7304159999,
-0.7095041275,
-0.5069611669,
-1.1374844313,
0.179107815,
0.2515996993,
-0.0623962022,
1.343970418,
0.4360977411,
1.0359638929,
0.0521769449,
0.6722709537,
0.4454962909,
0.1319107413,
-0.8745690584,
0.8766040802,
-0.6038005352,
0.6158615351,
-0.2352954,
-0.6102687716,
-0.1039217934,
0.0922208279,
-0.4897499979,
0.0935693532,
0.7753863931,
1.1029901505,
-0.0431702062,
-0.1197168827,
0.5876353979,
0.4297733605,
0.3448553681,
0.841330409,
0.9901758432,
-0.3137606978,
0.8482486606,
-0.2267863303,
-0.0148871746,
-0.2101680934,
-0.726865232,
-0.9977519512,
-0.1902198344,
-0.204480812,
-0.428999275,
0.4680792987,
0.3310259581,
0.4337730408,
-0.8341989517,
-0.3261406422,
0.3910042346,
0.3950016201,
-0.0472416952,
-0.1925185919,
0.2418583184,
-0.348980844,
-0.5398507118,
0.4846384525,
0.2686057687,
0.0628627017,
-0.5970010161,
-0.0588943549,
-0.0298793353,
0.0772728845,
0.3791383207,
0.399469465,
-0.6264473796,
-0.2301727533,
0.0671270639,
-0.3753963411,
-0.0607628152,
0.7155556083,
-0.2784153223,
0.1061816886,
0.3215797544,
0.8528207541,
0.190029338,
-0.3771685362,
0.7841889858,
-1.0147739649,
0.3262414932,
0.0088502653,
0.3516544998,
0.377066642,
-0.5953107476,
0.1618442535,
0.2832798064,
-0.3012496531,
-1.0269702673,
0.3955760598,
-0.3445056975,
-0.5438979268,
1.2975803614,
-0.4842227101,
-0.4563080966,
-0.0805587992,
-0.0340607986,
0.006342215,
-0.1573345512,
0.7288658023,
0.8848466277,
0.3284288943,
-0.1245489866,
-0.5951095819,
0.3856422603,
0.5151023269,
-0.7520474792,
0.2233296633,
0.1983406544,
0.3907562494,
0.1481168419,
-0.0966477841,
-0.2898033857,
0.43554914,
0.0394905806,
-0.2050362527,
-0.1069300175,
-0.5788616538,
-0.6514130235,
0.2785544991,
-0.0550268404,
-0.1520174295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19563v1
|
RepEval: Effective Text Evaluation with LLM Representation
| 2024-04-30T13:50:55 | 2024-04-30T13:50:55 |
Shuqian Sheng, Yi Xu, Tianhang Zhang, Zanwei Shen, Luoyi Fu, Jiaxin Ding, Lei Zhou, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic evaluation metrics for generated texts play an important role in
the NLG field, especially with the rapid growth of LLMs. However, existing
metrics are often limited to specific scenarios, making it challenging to meet
the evaluation requirements of expanding LLM applications. Therefore, there is
a demand for new, flexible, and effective metrics. In this study, we introduce
RepEval, the first metric leveraging the projection of LLM representations for
evaluation. RepEval requires minimal sample pairs for training, and through
simple prompt modifications, it can easily transition to various tasks. Results
on ten datasets from three tasks demonstrate the high effectiveness of our
method, which exhibits stronger correlations with human judgments compared to
previous metrics, even outperforming GPT-4. Our work underscores the richness
of information regarding text quality embedded within LLM representations,
offering insights for the development of new metrics.
|
[
-0.1352407187,
-0.2410817295,
0.4563983977,
0.3491829336,
-0.4742346704,
0.313466996,
-0.3278093636,
-0.2843283415,
0.2575191557,
0.1610652506,
-0.2891690731,
-1.0653823614,
-0.7391360402,
0.2969377637,
-0.5389984846,
0.944319129,
-0.2169912755,
0.000185709,
-0.3601683676,
-0.3507490456,
-0.429561466,
-0.5695230365,
-0.3431773484,
-0.4445507824,
0.5979546309,
0.1619179547,
0.507353425,
0.5801458955,
0.8151632547,
0.2221948206,
0.2477683425,
0.3764590323,
-0.6166417003,
0.271417439,
-0.0907330438,
-0.3275061846,
-0.2639221847,
0.4251876771,
0.9715820551,
0.4543303549,
-0.3034870327,
0.3797516525,
0.4618732333,
0.8761003017,
-0.5072250962,
-0.0578855164,
-0.5118376017,
0.2227905244,
-0.1328839362,
-0.4859841168,
-0.5630974174,
-0.5904851556,
0.1850349456,
-0.705797255,
0.1240545288,
0.2415792048,
0.8469564915,
0.2838357091,
-0.2411064208,
-0.2836925089,
-0.3245269656,
1.0002832413,
-0.5948911309,
0.6756827831,
0.1870673746,
0.3475477695,
-0.0376539975,
-1.1317400932,
-0.2158018947,
-0.4637619853,
-0.1510367244,
0.4317140281,
-0.1783246249,
-0.1319736391,
-0.1122882068,
0.4010661244,
-0.3181627691,
0.0363349207,
0.1303475052,
-0.3362688422,
0.5603474975,
0.2229439616,
0.1412553638,
-0.3420636654,
-0.626101315,
-0.1829605699,
-0.8595640659,
-0.4092229605,
0.137039721,
0.1039610505,
0.1269535124,
0.6339457035,
0.1972466856,
0.534699738,
-0.0927815139,
-0.0196425002,
0.3059950471,
-0.567866087,
-0.3382244408,
-0.1682867408,
0.9392263889,
0.5368026495,
-0.188863799,
-0.1320144683,
-0.3519484401,
-0.1441220492,
0.6129806042,
-0.7011351585,
-0.0734127164,
-0.3181222081,
-0.7603780627,
-0.363363564,
0.1975269318,
-0.8110608459,
-0.7930324078,
-0.1641585976,
0.2787204683,
-0.4450306296,
-0.0536127575,
-0.1699498296,
0.0608694926,
0.2390367836,
0.457329154,
-0.6902800202,
0.216913715,
0.7159276009,
0.9347471595,
-0.5470898151,
-0.2056014836,
-0.6523792744,
-0.2384488285,
-0.5702877641,
0.8097169399,
-0.3822634816,
-0.4777827859,
0.2802485526,
-0.2006954551,
0.089402087,
-0.4943180382,
0.9920967817,
-0.496639967,
0.2833609879,
-0.011811696,
-0.7765376568,
-0.061290957,
0.5206153393,
-0.6785539985,
1.2706854343,
0.4345185161,
-0.7154639959,
0.6766853929,
-0.4158832431,
-0.1859410405,
0.1857580543,
-0.3000464737,
-0.494612813,
0.2940983474,
0.3381022513,
0.3843950629,
-0.4227599204,
-0.1758993566,
0.1566382796,
-0.3613536954,
0.0976847857,
-0.6529729962,
0.1679067612,
-0.0463982485,
-0.0197945405,
0.1779529899,
-0.5410180092,
0.2165211886,
-0.1554854065,
-0.6404577494,
-0.4227885008,
-0.0561091155,
0.0308376402,
-0.3293966949,
0.4395367503,
-0.4393550158,
0.1976882964,
-0.6042821407,
0.0040646936,
0.5067068934,
0.0239505526,
0.5537263751,
-0.227712363,
0.6502344012,
-0.6262956858,
-0.1478543878,
-0.2043015659,
-0.4015106857,
-0.5504242778,
-0.0767338499,
0.5926704407,
0.4020508826,
-0.6776992083,
0.3886769116,
-0.3112558722,
-0.7392137051,
-0.8431901336,
0.246629104,
0.5208188891,
0.4276467264,
0.373024106,
-0.15562962,
-0.5721423626,
-0.8684397936,
-0.6485375166,
-0.3554809093,
-0.275023073,
0.2119179517,
0.2570036352,
-0.1100949496,
0.7909235954,
-0.3181355298,
-0.5360418558,
-0.3463258743,
0.5334877968,
0.2732716501,
0.2122436464,
0.5288900733,
-0.5739425421,
-0.5211623907,
-0.0539734848,
-0.7482516766,
-0.3245157599,
-0.3528478742,
-0.1869643331,
0.1701897681,
0.35011971,
-0.0567685142,
0.4233761728,
0.7640590072,
-0.3782940805,
0.8307039142,
-0.3622799814,
0.5037967563,
-0.8065477014,
-0.1757453531,
0.1912206858,
-0.4517630637,
-0.3572233617,
-0.0020406246,
0.2561542988,
0.2823134363,
-0.2832180262,
0.526255846,
-0.5383938551,
-0.1854847372,
-0.1085516065,
0.6927434802,
0.3130892217,
0.032613799,
-0.0794661939,
0.9957145452,
-0.0593677573,
-0.2038827538,
0.3373479545,
0.2568269074,
-0.7671123743,
0.7453465462,
-0.6373478174,
0.2269441187,
0.1432459652,
0.143560186,
-1.0559709072,
0.0187441558,
0.1386580318,
-0.6594016552,
0.2857434452,
0.0263808444,
-0.5728171468,
-0.2063752711,
-0.2860030234,
0.2978897989,
0.5771872997,
-0.8814694285,
0.3921113908,
0.378372699,
0.1806622446,
-0.578029871,
-0.8282148242,
0.3286700547,
-0.2329126298,
-0.3988265991,
0.7509661913,
0.2724827528,
-0.0990236104,
-0.0991449952,
-0.2434898317,
0.1369389147,
-0.1915456057,
0.0572353043,
0.2827844322,
-0.1874642968,
0.2875970006,
-0.0118906721,
-0.331215471,
0.0137577411,
-0.2248469591,
0.2581431568,
-0.3027493656,
-0.4893501997,
-0.4746681154,
0.0310916323,
0.168598026,
-0.081097275,
0.5475115776,
0.5726136565,
-0.2987538576,
-0.1194432676,
-0.517536521,
0.1301531643,
-0.4434818327,
0.5283564329,
-0.0201799963,
-0.8082206845,
0.1412205547,
-0.2398954779,
0.2081565112,
0.5019145012,
0.4220944643,
-0.2283122838,
0.8732239604,
0.5898430347,
0.1393268257,
0.5299884677,
-0.184696883,
-0.1687529534,
-1.1543550491,
-0.3718650043,
-0.2712695599,
-0.4224454165,
-0.4870890379,
-0.7574171424,
0.2212088704,
0.3169057965,
-0.0608499572,
0.4426732957,
-0.84247756,
0.4993163347,
0.2333095968,
0.0261914022,
0.5263828039,
0.0953119472,
-0.1134885401,
-0.5764609575,
-0.533616364,
-0.9532216787,
1.0289274454,
0.5525804162,
0.6207395792,
-0.1546310037,
1.1483970881,
0.610598743,
1.1428610086,
-0.8420186043,
0.5014301538,
-0.3499358892,
-0.0999679789,
-0.3006228507,
-0.5471698046,
-0.9324177504,
0.4434600472,
-0.3945013285,
-0.4822874367,
0.0126720928,
0.0260165986,
-0.2671068311,
0.1794056147,
-0.5887588263,
0.6880212426,
-0.3200312555,
-0.244599387,
-0.2548470795,
-0.1752024889,
0.0073382081,
0.0287331697,
0.0614339262,
-0.1815212965,
-0.5842115879,
1.0949527025,
-0.2028075457,
0.4881086648,
-0.2592137754,
-0.1279603243,
0.4020800889,
0.1729347557,
0.5049043298,
0.2083621919,
-0.4289203286,
0.2527453303,
-0.0717984885,
-0.0443806536,
-0.9350128174,
0.7520188689,
-0.5678092837,
-0.4254695475,
-0.4737615287,
-0.268274188,
-0.2595433593,
0.1964861751,
0.2386561632,
0.2732465863,
-0.5834972262,
0.3599972427,
0.163826406,
-0.5439174771,
0.1850455105,
0.3442460597,
-0.4893696308,
-0.8825752735,
0.8053242564,
-0.117202431,
0.1091948599,
0.3651397824,
0.2653812468,
-0.7180236578,
-0.7445138693,
-0.286105454,
0.050766401,
-0.6789270043,
-0.6221266985,
-0.2163390219,
-0.2791216373,
0.0740044042,
-0.1520507485,
-0.4655661285,
-0.4163697958,
-0.3434161246,
-0.3584246933,
0.1944312602,
0.7791492939,
-0.0736075565,
0.3357850909,
-0.8300895691,
0.2504298091,
0.0404904746,
0.5572996736,
-0.1852695048,
-0.6565424204,
-0.3471543193,
-0.1388616413,
-0.1805157512,
-0.7909703851,
0.6806771755,
0.3446795642,
0.6405715942,
0.1992879063,
0.0340886675,
0.4777325392,
-0.5392284989,
0.8627439737,
0.4763233066,
-0.7818507552,
0.4453880191,
-0.1397453547,
0.0655916408,
0.8723537326,
0.1582435966,
-0.6315653324,
-0.3515444994,
-0.3960673511,
-0.8249445558,
0.2228690535,
0.4155255556,
0.2483517826,
-0.1900631785,
0.4606200755,
0.363822788,
0.1344545335,
-0.5845649242,
-0.1654535234,
-0.3179988563,
-0.3343865871,
0.0921140611,
-0.3509236276,
-0.0166884884,
-0.2676369846,
0.2551730871,
0.1062043384,
0.3018866479,
0.4188082218,
-0.2274399996,
0.350358516,
0.1322313845,
0.330183208,
0.5354137421,
-0.1419193149,
0.1489134282,
0.4058309197,
-0.5645955801,
0.1770601124,
-0.1179870591,
0.0998039469,
0.1496962756,
0.6920762658,
0.549978137,
0.4235393405,
-0.3657038808,
0.5017691851,
-0.1518816352,
-0.1561070681,
-0.2829110622,
-0.1516871005,
-0.2224372923,
0.154056251,
0.566780746,
-0.1401890367,
-0.0059612473,
-0.1195573062,
0.5652372241,
0.2158516645,
-0.755066216,
0.0435685925,
0.5304267406,
0.4497881234,
-0.5806619525,
0.62019068,
-0.3453890085,
-0.3956719935,
0.4259658158,
0.5784252882,
0.9923074841,
-0.0074474001,
0.4243817925,
0.6034240127,
0.4509933591,
-0.0026491331,
-0.0636472329,
0.186260432,
-0.7317077518,
-0.5153421164,
-0.7990190983,
-0.507363677,
-0.1888575405,
-0.5673162937,
0.0976979062,
-0.4327719808,
-0.3670854867,
-0.47895509,
0.1852101833,
-0.6925703287,
0.1118701175,
0.0321155488,
1.1494451761,
-0.3722273111,
0.6015838385,
0.5578074455,
-0.3170221448,
-0.4579628408,
0.0329420418,
-0.0475322641,
-0.9375854731,
0.7108718753,
0.320782572,
-0.2506856024,
0.1139502153,
-0.24878712,
-0.5530594587,
1.2858392,
0.3959390223,
-0.6452564001,
0.2132870555,
0.134915024,
0.8171585798,
-0.6882908344,
0.2605085373,
0.7331447005,
0.5805490017,
-0.1582609564,
-0.5205971003,
0.0400689133,
-0.135872826,
0.0801922828,
0.1592645198,
-0.3104729056,
0.1251730174,
-0.1733573377,
-0.6516619325,
0.3129555583,
0.9981266856,
0.4692319632,
0.3030617833,
0.4860090315,
0.4115834832,
1.045209527,
-0.3924322426,
1.225923419,
-0.30790326,
0.4774742424,
1.1508107185,
-0.0157660898,
1.0219900608,
0.3476547301,
-0.3498533666,
0.6359828711,
0.5935251117,
-0.2169294953,
0.4723023176,
0.3531547487,
-0.2949268818,
-0.2201419622,
-0.1486090273,
-0.3047850728,
0.2602115273,
0.417835772,
-0.5252107382,
-0.2867916822,
-0.1213827059,
-0.2688887119,
0.6189465523,
-0.1076301411,
0.6638644934,
0.2444928288,
-0.4614157379,
0.5561708212,
-0.0165933482,
0.8068348765,
-0.4676204026,
-0.3197660446,
-0.3006315529,
-0.0546648949,
-0.3214961886,
-1.1333978176,
0.496920079,
0.1178584322,
0.0747503117,
-0.569311142,
0.8405174017,
-0.3798976541,
-0.516215682,
0.4221918881,
0.3959476352,
0.2097123712,
-0.07043311,
-0.6019320488,
-0.0165174343,
-0.1263175458,
-0.3123751581,
0.1414921582,
0.4953511357,
0.2417432368,
0.5435690284,
0.4948756397,
0.2377771437,
-0.1311926395,
0.308508873,
0.5752180219,
-0.7927302718,
0.0039852406,
-0.9448487759,
0.4542066157,
-0.3511554003,
-0.345615536,
0.9420177937,
0.6041985154,
0.3384580612,
0.2356814593,
0.8260846138,
0.1876119971,
0.4956663251,
-0.39974159,
1.0630122423,
-0.4796370566,
0.4543895423,
-0.297260195,
-1.1296161413,
-0.5648031831,
0.842721343,
-0.311653316,
-0.1884873211,
0.7762348652,
0.4577528238,
0.2750137448,
-0.1804253012,
0.3340909481,
-0.1013288796,
0.4079683721,
0.4658602774,
1.0055247545,
-0.5248929858,
0.8103030324,
0.0671713427,
-0.4154887497,
-0.0597758777,
-1.1763615608,
-0.7218912244,
-0.4102434516,
-0.2999917567,
-0.418258518,
-0.0108112423,
0.8111471534,
0.4815634787,
-0.5891484618,
-0.0406615622,
-0.0420223475,
0.3018169105,
-0.2222521752,
-0.1863749623,
0.65414083,
-0.4110572934,
-0.5088236928,
0.5348880291,
0.4193468094,
-0.2185062468,
-0.4160937965,
-0.3055122495,
0.1459473968,
-0.0072650574,
0.7771434188,
0.0381273292,
-0.5401232243,
-0.5042799115,
-0.065348655,
-0.2809765339,
0.3092833459,
0.7067032456,
-0.9563024044,
0.4993363619,
0.5518667698,
0.8561888337,
0.3778263032,
0.2559750676,
0.7592384815,
-0.9744625092,
-0.2746577859,
0.4002877176,
0.2464694828,
0.6053289175,
-0.1137418747,
0.821926415,
0.0403574742,
-0.6390602589,
-0.8396469355,
0.118302539,
-0.6893530488,
0.2813512385,
1.1837427616,
-0.2847545743,
0.0529791676,
0.1198773161,
-0.4326790273,
0.2518685758,
-0.40390113,
0.9229052663,
0.8168073893,
-0.296233356,
-0.2803948522,
-0.4075127542,
0.470875293,
0.2889619172,
-0.9848874807,
0.1412870288,
0.3473020196,
-0.052365303,
0.1736473888,
0.5989949107,
-0.3869686127,
-0.0472954698,
0.0165917855,
-0.0700902939,
-0.035434857,
-0.1000031978,
-0.1603884548,
0.1539038122,
0.0962957218,
-0.1725251377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19553v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19553v1
|
Extending Llama-3's Context Ten-Fold Overnight
| 2024-04-30T13:25:20 | 2024-04-30T13:25:20 |
Peitian Zhang, Ninglu Shao, Zheng Liu, Shitao Xiao, Hongjin Qian, Qiwei Ye, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We extend the context length of Llama-3-8B-Instruct from 8K to 80K via QLoRA
fine-tuning. The entire training cycle is super efficient, which takes 8 hours
on one 8xA800 (80G) GPU machine. The resulted model exhibits superior
performances across a broad range of evaluation tasks, such as NIHS, topic
retrieval, and long-context language understanding; meanwhile, it also well
preserves the original capability over short contexts. The dramatic context
extension is mainly attributed to merely 3.5K synthetic training samples
generated by GPT-4 , which indicates the LLMs' inherent (yet largely
underestimated) potential to extend its original context length. In fact, the
context length could be extended far beyond 80K with more computation
resources. Therefore, the team will publicly release the entire resources
(including data, model, data generation pipeline, training code) so as to
facilitate the future research from the community:
\url{https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding}.
|
[
-0.5441545248,
-0.5967711806,
0.786760211,
0.3448165953,
-0.646545589,
0.1583620906,
-0.3184505403,
-0.8980139494,
-0.1231075823,
0.4612712264,
-0.5083866119,
-0.3228453994,
-0.4605029225,
0.1370268017,
-0.2786391973,
1.1805435419,
-0.186485827,
-0.3357466459,
0.220381096,
-0.3167422414,
-0.4263453782,
-0.3272551894,
-0.7138932347,
-0.1872357428,
0.4958273172,
0.5394077301,
0.381881237,
0.7819833159,
0.2818247974,
0.2311173826,
-0.1394280642,
0.132838726,
-0.7793574929,
-0.0701096654,
0.2354799509,
-0.5940980911,
-0.776144743,
0.1014500037,
0.7649891973,
0.471028626,
-0.1085172668,
0.4879851043,
0.2340761721,
0.8195070624,
-0.653668046,
0.4103164673,
-0.515709877,
-0.0794507712,
-0.2905465066,
-0.0365018733,
-0.2144446671,
-0.1214700267,
0.017120447,
-0.7093490958,
-0.0876613557,
0.0642511994,
0.701153338,
0.2412453443,
-0.5167223811,
0.1044571996,
-0.5535318851,
0.64057374,
-0.5772929192,
0.1127640828,
0.3152402937,
0.5521092415,
-0.1606155187,
-0.6744312644,
-0.7239173055,
-0.1354090869,
0.2572152913,
-0.0724782348,
-0.0075573921,
0.1962590963,
0.4636873007,
0.511435926,
-0.2145484537,
0.091102168,
-0.519235611,
0.1265080124,
0.5541550517,
0.1802839488,
0.1130445525,
0.0970516577,
-0.4753573239,
-0.053775344,
-1.0609242916,
0.0128881037,
0.3926660419,
-0.0823831856,
-0.4160011113,
0.3600302637,
-0.5151879787,
0.5448105335,
-0.0276160669,
-0.0266367253,
0.3583028018,
-0.3553978205,
-0.3016811609,
-0.0301961023,
0.3550900817,
0.5671677589,
-0.3789768815,
-0.0579173639,
-0.2844348252,
0.1591091901,
0.1605095267,
-0.9735968709,
-0.0139392996,
0.1541381478,
-0.2551124394,
-0.1539500207,
-0.1819562465,
-0.3670793772,
-0.1180488393,
-0.3901886642,
0.4484331608,
-0.4206816852,
-0.1479239613,
0.2875877023,
0.0718361884,
0.5525596738,
0.5074786544,
-0.6740012169,
0.2603289187,
0.8304498792,
0.833243072,
-0.3705760539,
-0.2641911507,
-0.4925188422,
0.2649741769,
-0.4311954975,
0.6735828519,
-0.3665362895,
-0.1939855367,
-0.2162530869,
0.2328160703,
0.1810110509,
-0.3275322914,
0.4901649058,
-0.8045465946,
0.1823747158,
-0.3934974372,
-0.3818919361,
-0.5254385471,
0.1773163974,
-0.7165608406,
1.0681772232,
0.3887265027,
-0.1994211674,
0.3612210751,
-0.9862883091,
-0.1836525947,
0.3698855042,
0.0281868372,
-0.4239617586,
0.1575091779,
0.3912472725,
0.4882266223,
-0.3192723989,
0.2314209789,
-0.1317842603,
-0.7305224538,
-0.0175902303,
-0.1831562817,
0.7107990384,
0.2000067383,
-0.7509043813,
0.1376787126,
-0.75026232,
-0.0617082939,
-0.0838791654,
-0.5183714032,
-0.0263085794,
-0.3898468614,
-0.0171346385,
0.1033984497,
0.3153131902,
-0.6151100993,
0.2822508216,
-0.2515503168,
0.558365345,
0.8493422866,
-0.0123956995,
0.4597319365,
-0.263371259,
0.6960407495,
-0.3222497702,
0.4553824067,
-0.1586102843,
-0.5204854608,
-0.931411922,
-0.3606010675,
-0.0543670915,
0.0842602178,
-0.7018195987,
0.2734366357,
-0.4368795753,
-0.4125991762,
-0.3661355972,
0.234730199,
0.4691852927,
0.3381956518,
0.5638924241,
-0.2392753512,
-0.6773146987,
-0.8971315026,
0.0973732099,
-0.0424615107,
-0.229809016,
0.1369883865,
0.7091649771,
-0.4828700125,
0.7211914062,
-0.4424670637,
-0.1951659024,
-0.3103859723,
-0.3906544149,
0.4895489812,
0.4500498176,
0.5724966526,
-0.4929852784,
-0.3908346593,
-0.0192221235,
-0.6913410425,
-0.0035930991,
0.0134439114,
-0.4118083119,
0.1502542794,
0.4249229133,
-0.5099340081,
0.2428934276,
0.7373661995,
-0.2801418602,
0.6992334127,
0.0375003666,
0.053519886,
-1.0116146803,
-0.2071772665,
-0.5285920501,
-0.2393425554,
-0.5135039091,
0.4082096815,
0.1640775949,
-0.0572946817,
-0.4905101657,
0.600260973,
-0.7062631845,
-0.2303389907,
-0.5114532709,
0.1436269581,
-0.0058649383,
0.5762475133,
-0.3058799505,
1.0665745735,
0.4834541678,
-0.6569977403,
0.0295373853,
0.0491083302,
-0.5099401474,
0.3280881345,
-0.6246173382,
0.2791282237,
0.1704268903,
0.6679301262,
-0.6641400456,
-0.281648308,
0.1719791889,
-0.1309125125,
0.014993377,
-0.0221451148,
-0.2784174979,
-0.18753694,
-0.6838486195,
0.7435289621,
0.5761694908,
-0.9349893332,
0.5359786749,
0.4525836408,
0.1342322081,
-0.3939070106,
-0.3699945509,
0.463214457,
-0.5194552541,
-0.2204955965,
0.5555904508,
-0.0892347172,
-0.0942579135,
-0.1447491944,
-0.1785950363,
0.3632462323,
0.131550625,
0.4207647145,
0.2628840804,
-0.2951757312,
0.0008825524,
0.1431932449,
0.0231230091,
0.0448356271,
-0.244799301,
0.5588901639,
-0.6742106676,
-0.103613317,
-0.4897753,
0.1136683375,
0.2214334458,
0.0799738541,
0.7998942733,
0.6234096885,
-0.3562616706,
-0.0767654926,
-0.6857776642,
-0.1625194699,
-0.5456508994,
0.3439059854,
-0.4374400675,
-1.277884841,
0.4575392008,
0.0752921999,
0.0296526719,
0.5499059558,
0.4252100885,
0.0060087177,
0.7136343122,
0.9369328618,
-0.1517523378,
0.6315014958,
-0.5944041014,
0.0089348406,
-1.5576080084,
-0.2278224677,
-0.0237437487,
-0.3260725737,
-0.6454519629,
-0.8476904631,
0.4363260269,
0.3357466161,
-0.4333392084,
0.4913920164,
-0.39578408,
0.5959903598,
0.1908275038,
0.4495604336,
0.1282159686,
-0.0523890071,
0.2748273015,
0.3443989754,
-0.6163310409,
-0.5831914544,
1.3012701273,
0.4444080293,
0.1647988111,
0.159304142,
0.645106256,
0.1006533056,
0.7161195874,
-0.4831283689,
0.7088406682,
0.3051813245,
-0.3319920003,
-0.2652507126,
-0.0477321446,
-0.7941753268,
0.2159917504,
0.121943824,
-0.7027273178,
0.0942069516,
0.0041577523,
-0.3946778178,
0.206372261,
-0.5276513696,
0.4532918036,
-0.1281382293,
-0.4558185935,
-0.4478734136,
-0.5202320814,
0.5812499523,
-0.1597530842,
0.0955094099,
-0.5561032295,
-0.4671720564,
1.0824427605,
-0.4504561722,
0.8969394565,
-0.1328721792,
-0.2764631212,
0.358420521,
-0.2657118142,
0.3338444829,
0.3217839003,
0.0029910437,
0.5155569315,
-0.3705038428,
-0.6249408126,
-0.5066196322,
0.6950438619,
-0.7431358099,
-0.7900639772,
-0.2840111852,
-0.4995494485,
-0.3243300617,
0.0360840373,
-0.1196211949,
0.2176371515,
0.0658606067,
0.4490098953,
0.3145675957,
-0.015458825,
0.6398329735,
0.5143122673,
-0.1446460634,
-0.4719776213,
0.5967586637,
-0.3014962375,
0.1318914592,
0.2045017481,
0.2260095477,
-0.2644632757,
-0.6733257174,
-0.4516106248,
0.241679877,
-0.7112683058,
-0.2824186385,
-0.5285305381,
-0.0530706868,
-0.0916202143,
-0.2560147643,
-0.3147939146,
-0.655439496,
-0.202676177,
-0.3958819211,
0.5459102988,
0.7755074501,
0.0138888359,
0.8630011678,
-0.5701972842,
0.1569799632,
0.2997111976,
0.2886892259,
0.050413616,
-0.7485419512,
-0.4693383873,
-0.0499549098,
-0.28197366,
-0.5940626264,
0.2262218595,
0.2892141342,
0.4812897444,
0.5655796528,
-0.2077528685,
1.0318257809,
-0.5862965584,
0.968714416,
0.1097134277,
-0.8679464459,
0.4391471744,
-0.4193921387,
0.449565649,
0.3382268846,
0.2500823438,
-0.0620326102,
-0.3000766039,
-0.4951268733,
-0.9466876388,
0.4380378425,
0.4115591943,
0.207140848,
0.0488642529,
0.7918844223,
0.3266752064,
0.1046972871,
-0.5902302265,
-0.0983705223,
-0.1892359704,
0.2367258668,
-0.416647464,
-0.4397354424,
-0.3820987344,
-0.5091812611,
0.6515788436,
-0.5165801644,
0.4006971419,
-0.0598278493,
-0.267688483,
0.2328005284,
0.166396305,
0.8425895572,
0.8767538071,
-0.1298444867,
0.1614368111,
0.6054189205,
-0.6537411213,
0.204009369,
0.0504134558,
0.1360982507,
-0.5134076476,
0.5584478378,
1.0640062094,
0.3998138905,
-0.5415099263,
0.1241771653,
0.016714802,
0.0311674271,
-0.2141385525,
0.3080696464,
0.1164117083,
0.4906606674,
0.7129198313,
-0.2621793449,
0.2123373002,
-0.5050013661,
0.1860148609,
0.1523428261,
-0.1016309112,
-0.5628796816,
0.7629554272,
0.2321543247,
0.1113519818,
0.3567554653,
-0.1835456342,
-0.7278698683,
0.6444143057,
0.6324647665,
0.8648590446,
-0.0548752621,
0.0028099902,
0.4271140099,
0.172898829,
-0.1473409534,
0.337474972,
-0.4938510656,
-0.5720638037,
-0.5039044619,
-0.8263240457,
-0.3795136213,
0.1652166545,
-0.6625706553,
0.044371523,
-0.3522919714,
-0.0597411543,
-0.5973422527,
0.346714139,
-0.7118676901,
0.2176176012,
0.0283658728,
0.8972936869,
-0.4996334612,
0.9571687579,
0.4660160542,
-0.0651136711,
-0.7087900043,
-0.0582290441,
-0.2092499286,
-1.1302267313,
0.6461703181,
0.6613630652,
-0.312165767,
-0.0556206964,
-0.6531434059,
-0.824451983,
1.6023244858,
0.3417080343,
-0.8202053905,
0.128176868,
-0.0114809657,
0.6061646342,
-0.7022404075,
0.0957566276,
0.808437109,
0.1833215058,
-0.2923089266,
-0.7332634926,
0.4501948655,
-0.1644124091,
0.2962239087,
-0.2101229876,
-0.7576400042,
0.5957968831,
-0.4332663715,
-0.1675750166,
-0.049810376,
0.9031559229,
0.3958525956,
-0.0149402963,
0.6606856585,
0.5182920098,
0.6668557525,
0.0633054078,
1.190587163,
-0.6491580009,
0.2536181808,
1.0259896517,
-0.1300694346,
1.0397269726,
0.5317189693,
-0.2453287691,
0.6306788921,
0.8469437957,
0.2388947308,
0.5157486796,
-0.0035944988,
-0.615640521,
-0.122358419,
-0.1322439015,
-0.559813261,
0.3731834292,
0.5100101829,
0.0341780186,
-0.0285668951,
0.0657611564,
0.0659251064,
-0.4083483517,
-0.4075520337,
0.4974123538,
0.2352274656,
-0.6007835269,
0.8020006418,
-0.1519528627,
0.6161504984,
-0.3072482049,
-0.0606706068,
-0.3836874962,
0.1027542427,
-0.0463752039,
-0.7190126181,
0.0177553166,
-0.1853251308,
0.1594838351,
-0.1851790696,
0.446320504,
-0.2256886214,
-0.168691352,
0.2319240719,
0.2611800134,
0.0807321593,
-0.2043281198,
-0.4169586003,
0.4513587654,
-0.0435385182,
-0.4953927994,
0.4462538958,
0.0744526684,
-0.2982828617,
0.7813616991,
0.785644412,
-0.0574608259,
0.1219902188,
0.022509791,
1.3163433075,
-0.5739197731,
-0.4491765797,
-0.8413909674,
0.1611415297,
-0.0902087837,
-0.3264795542,
0.7720983028,
0.7541090846,
0.940523386,
-0.0477009304,
0.5293042064,
0.1112326905,
-0.0936487541,
-0.6780680418,
0.5317268372,
-0.4812139273,
0.4115109146,
-0.0300518293,
-1.0202133656,
-0.0263692308,
0.4472346604,
-0.2549733222,
-0.1298060417,
0.8272313476,
0.521187067,
0.0935331881,
0.031830553,
0.2234621197,
0.1495564282,
0.5483168364,
0.8062244654,
0.8029593825,
-0.5745559931,
0.4681254327,
-0.4243214428,
-0.4880424142,
-0.3418406248,
-1.0716074705,
-0.870414257,
-0.4999672174,
-0.172576353,
0.0215834044,
0.2277699411,
0.5957889557,
0.6873238087,
-0.6052599549,
-0.3022504747,
0.0052757002,
-0.0480281934,
-0.2804540396,
-0.2143113017,
0.5101588964,
-0.2616990507,
-0.6829369068,
0.6950147748,
0.5225769281,
-0.1559761018,
-0.3065655231,
-0.2005809546,
-0.0415345058,
-0.2324951887,
0.9877089262,
0.1475626379,
-0.6451621056,
-0.4806314707,
-0.1408572644,
0.0922512189,
0.1068873778,
0.5584815741,
-0.8230993152,
0.1273460984,
0.149733901,
0.6464878917,
0.6994630098,
0.0385806449,
0.7278888226,
-0.4976462424,
0.223739624,
0.001282806,
0.3913788497,
0.2554838955,
-0.3594085872,
0.7519783974,
0.0438899249,
-0.5769213438,
-0.9144335389,
0.0967804715,
-0.9937586784,
-0.0059058,
1.1703344584,
-0.1427580267,
-0.4213594794,
0.1491758227,
-0.2120919973,
0.2726925611,
-0.3588437438,
0.9603688121,
0.4256584942,
-0.4340684414,
-0.2254649848,
-0.9872186184,
0.763995707,
0.1814320982,
-0.930368185,
-0.2431617975,
0.3193042278,
0.4875388741,
-0.0994908884,
0.7880015969,
-0.0268261563,
0.5333826542,
-0.1634518355,
-0.0558366403,
-0.1619186401,
-0.32361269,
-0.2933160365,
0.1244139746,
-0.0552007668,
-0.3987832069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19543v1
|
RAG and RAU: A Survey on Retrieval-Augmented Language Model in Natural Language Processing
| 2024-04-30T13:14:51 | 2024-04-30T13:14:51 |
Yucheng Hu, Yuxing Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have catalyzed significant advancements in
Natural Language Processing (NLP), yet they encounter challenges such as
hallucination and the need for domain-specific knowledge. To mitigate these,
recent methodologies have integrated information retrieved from external
resources with LLMs, substantially enhancing their performance across NLP
tasks. This survey paper addresses the absence of a comprehensive overview on
Retrieval-Augmented Language Models (RALMs), both Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) and Retrieval-Augmented Understanding (RAU), providing an
in-depth examination of their paradigm, evolution, taxonomy, and applications.
The paper discusses the essential components of RALMs, including Retrievers,
Language Models, and Augmentations, and how their interactions lead to diverse
model structures and applications. RALMs demonstrate utility in a spectrum of
tasks, from translation and dialogue systems to knowledge-intensive
applications. The survey includes several evaluation methods of RALMs,
emphasizing the importance of robustness, accuracy, and relevance in their
assessment. It also acknowledges the limitations of RALMs, particularly in
retrieval quality and computational efficiency, offering directions for future
research. In conclusion, this survey aims to offer a structured insight into
RALMs, their potential, and the avenues for their future development in NLP.
The paper is supplemented with a Github Repository containing the surveyed
works and resources for further study:
https://github.com/2471023025/RALM_Survey.
|
[
-0.4586467445,
-0.9711887836,
0.3931898773,
-0.0524072871,
0.0509534925,
0.403409332,
-0.3232637048,
-0.7934506536,
0.302403003,
0.7865809798,
-0.266820848,
-0.1705223769,
-0.6313025355,
0.2772753537,
-0.4269891381,
0.8303990364,
0.1746973246,
-0.1401882768,
-0.3372690082,
-0.3677460253,
-0.5655635595,
-0.5975542665,
-0.3809235096,
-0.5581228733,
0.5041838288,
0.0174231622,
0.5841745734,
0.2504489422,
0.5728049278,
0.2194892913,
-0.3603828847,
0.442928642,
-0.3302989304,
0.7250382304,
-0.2010507882,
-0.2677901387,
-0.4086606205,
0.009565074,
0.810026288,
0.796764493,
-0.2299359143,
0.2428259701,
0.181241855,
0.8628494143,
-0.912566483,
-0.0742488056,
-0.6278335452,
-0.1260940135,
-0.2803506851,
-0.2111544013,
-0.6704593301,
-0.3394362032,
0.0302444678,
-0.2821566164,
0.1584089845,
0.301101774,
0.6442206502,
0.1514407098,
-0.3482348621,
-0.4832405746,
-0.88847363,
1.0499736071,
-0.6804324389,
0.6344235539,
0.6201114655,
0.2281148732,
-0.3633752167,
-0.6905908585,
-0.2288734764,
-0.42824471,
-0.2922465801,
-0.0016107603,
-0.2491374016,
-0.0028478489,
0.0786352307,
0.6401034594,
-0.6080691218,
0.0816603079,
-0.0798007846,
0.0584679767,
0.5753532052,
0.2542034984,
0.3163516521,
-0.4228819013,
-0.3372493386,
0.1597591341,
-0.5175019503,
-0.1956737787,
0.0797112808,
0.2771418095,
0.0795961395,
0.7703778148,
-0.0983912349,
1.0718590021,
-0.4049007297,
-0.1575766504,
0.1120373532,
-0.4580359161,
-0.1915067881,
-0.412327379,
0.7228803039,
-0.1316706985,
-0.1200143471,
-0.3511462808,
-0.5271171331,
-0.1791868955,
0.3411229849,
-0.3904981911,
0.0793144405,
0.0513341576,
-0.3849360049,
-0.1754383892,
-0.0986771509,
-0.7798406482,
-0.4563332498,
-0.5140986443,
0.2028957009,
-0.3125899136,
-0.4616821706,
0.0336940214,
0.0993930101,
0.2852225602,
0.2457720041,
-0.5964031219,
0.5031501651,
0.8987609744,
0.6425138712,
-0.3714866638,
0.0894266069,
-0.6485287547,
-0.0480224341,
-0.169324711,
0.9169697762,
-0.8283857107,
-0.4063916504,
0.154598102,
-0.3329384327,
-0.1386879385,
-0.7192974091,
0.8549917936,
-0.9959670901,
0.1762191057,
-0.1241177693,
-0.4671491086,
-0.4064168036,
0.4614269137,
-0.7443885207,
1.3642883301,
-0.1066235825,
-0.9448363781,
-0.0891715363,
-0.5341905355,
-0.3919118643,
0.2467892915,
-0.0543502569,
-0.1663572043,
0.3556153178,
0.1225842461,
0.3675716519,
-0.7009137869,
0.3641903102,
-0.0925125331,
-0.2352385819,
0.3698189259,
-0.402790457,
0.6797641516,
0.3941769004,
0.2231697738,
0.1388289779,
-0.7549957633,
-0.0135607598,
0.1187272966,
-0.3299476206,
-0.7046378851,
-0.0287959371,
0.1900594532,
-0.0298073851,
0.334987849,
-0.3379348516,
0.2518354952,
-0.4102473259,
0.0754250214,
0.4240050018,
-0.0171082877,
0.6135313511,
-0.2305101007,
0.7609229088,
-0.4637748897,
0.0487291478,
-0.0981942415,
-0.4416959882,
-0.6786829829,
-0.2319464087,
0.2686953843,
0.424044013,
-0.7372011542,
0.2094994932,
-0.1685759574,
-0.3962680101,
-0.6649332643,
0.1702769995,
0.4072080553,
0.4514134228,
0.3653184474,
-0.010370818,
-0.7402690053,
-0.728942275,
-0.4645165205,
0.0299151242,
0.1985522211,
0.4788600206,
0.3702875078,
-0.4019765854,
1.0815942287,
-0.3628158867,
-0.2475769818,
-0.5468432307,
0.244381234,
0.2626355886,
0.10922499,
0.2714022994,
-0.8968449235,
-0.3244659007,
-0.0280306898,
-0.6895292997,
-0.1554700881,
0.3639729321,
0.100415051,
0.3670066297,
0.1863668859,
-0.6723908782,
0.4405155778,
0.6257994771,
-0.0326796696,
0.6388799548,
-0.2845471799,
0.0682384074,
-0.8558336496,
0.3967701495,
-0.1480547041,
-0.3209771514,
-0.8156764507,
0.5215914845,
-0.0681479201,
0.1322938949,
-0.0691371784,
0.8910298944,
-0.7454057336,
-0.4305142164,
-0.5312060118,
0.4653354287,
0.1327478588,
0.0076675946,
0.0355574526,
0.7824772,
0.1288691908,
-0.6269313097,
0.2168631405,
0.2259688228,
-0.3811638057,
0.2092626393,
-0.4079259634,
0.3974722028,
-0.1763051748,
0.1550901979,
-0.6705749035,
-0.1088005453,
0.2727765739,
-0.5562657714,
0.418472141,
-0.2564640045,
-0.6559749842,
-0.1356413513,
-0.1933217943,
0.4845635593,
0.5335603952,
-0.3074420393,
0.8360370398,
0.5979606509,
-0.1560589075,
-0.9381875992,
-0.5289607048,
0.198354125,
-0.0499596782,
-0.3942093849,
0.1802218705,
0.0982212946,
-0.62321347,
0.1279668957,
0.0761291683,
-0.0194183476,
0.0387840346,
0.0679046065,
0.4568688273,
-0.131988287,
0.1783438027,
-0.3758436143,
-0.0411968306,
-0.054756131,
0.1833669841,
0.6332592964,
-0.091486223,
-0.3244590759,
-0.0165733136,
0.2818627656,
0.1656292677,
-0.6615114808,
0.7577818632,
0.6272930503,
-0.4010150135,
-0.0443668291,
-0.9074100256,
-0.0979408473,
-0.3521953523,
0.1772723794,
-0.1744427979,
-0.9582670331,
0.552121222,
0.0949719772,
0.1618206352,
0.4401223361,
0.4727143645,
0.0314754955,
0.7210229039,
0.6414510608,
-0.0977187231,
0.4013400078,
-0.2570205629,
0.2418856919,
-1.2804464102,
-0.2392662466,
-0.8207018971,
-0.0151744289,
-0.3620562851,
-0.5749411583,
0.1695881635,
0.2340695858,
0.1225253716,
0.0646612346,
-0.4226798415,
0.1723594218,
0.3199469149,
-0.3586581945,
0.7185729742,
-0.0043513924,
-0.0062698317,
-0.1986347735,
-0.6117072105,
-0.5908282399,
0.8140573502,
0.2542226911,
0.8332931995,
0.0643962026,
0.5921717882,
0.3641974926,
0.4109098613,
-0.830838263,
0.5122078657,
-0.0150808906,
-0.6895455122,
-0.0537818037,
-0.4697303176,
-1.2266454697,
0.4471770823,
-0.3253976405,
-0.5629983544,
-0.0031249435,
-0.0730962083,
-0.0969545916,
0.3701209426,
-0.3131113946,
0.3693816066,
-0.133807689,
-0.2683573961,
-0.4223524034,
-0.548972249,
0.6660141945,
-0.0189725198,
0.5758091211,
-0.1294558942,
-0.0921270028,
0.6374219656,
-0.0718849823,
0.3765521944,
-0.0002942755,
-0.141253233,
0.4453315139,
0.1885733753,
0.5366470814,
-0.058001671,
-0.2273592055,
-0.0423079021,
-0.1088469699,
-0.0214243345,
-0.6502640843,
0.7422847748,
-0.3586835861,
-0.4741082788,
-0.6926897168,
-0.7296102047,
-0.1701430976,
0.1518140286,
-0.104885675,
0.5432319641,
-0.016110979,
0.2364233583,
0.7336061001,
-0.3628602028,
0.282931596,
0.5667797327,
-0.8118668795,
-0.3923860192,
0.7319591641,
0.0630451143,
0.2533531785,
0.5087418556,
0.0165102389,
-0.3540641069,
-0.6583396792,
-0.0938285664,
0.4556117058,
-0.5779235363,
-0.485419184,
-0.7468571663,
-0.347946316,
-0.4064486325,
0.1805443764,
-0.3541362882,
-0.2797330618,
-0.4053904116,
0.1243713424,
0.5761479735,
1.0957303047,
0.0550122671,
-0.150962308,
-0.8923673034,
0.6212336421,
-0.0381918289,
0.3783867657,
0.233439222,
-0.6588127017,
-0.2332944721,
0.0211771838,
0.0380172879,
-0.6925956607,
0.6157394648,
-0.0197243411,
0.5882571936,
-0.0437660664,
0.2615595758,
0.5094389319,
-0.4198437333,
0.6078041792,
-0.2013447434,
-0.4455921948,
0.4134603441,
-0.170460254,
0.0458369367,
0.4483834803,
0.2217095196,
-0.6049950719,
-0.2698279917,
-0.4617716372,
-0.8985031247,
0.6414396167,
0.1325142384,
0.0788744688,
-0.0756649822,
0.3808279932,
0.0388042592,
0.0237458553,
-0.5314334631,
-0.4641236663,
0.4788366258,
0.0119043607,
0.1005245969,
-0.550565064,
0.1182796583,
0.0193152595,
0.7307704687,
0.2803284228,
0.1353460103,
0.1036339477,
-0.4470693469,
0.0147359446,
0.544242084,
0.4186455607,
0.6151996851,
-0.4005544186,
0.0491801277,
0.064636983,
-0.6186257601,
-0.0283837784,
0.0811471492,
-0.2402149737,
0.1554184407,
0.3191125989,
0.5763928294,
0.2933484912,
-0.7396445274,
0.2209204286,
-0.1041283756,
0.217697069,
-0.4075467288,
-0.1632146686,
-0.0250307955,
0.1478098631,
0.6162467003,
0.0835950971,
0.3306503296,
-0.4311741889,
-0.0300850403,
0.7520388365,
-0.2305561155,
-0.2640288472,
0.4706952274,
-0.0921062231,
-0.5817385912,
0.6204125881,
-0.2648770511,
-0.3239228427,
0.0011041517,
0.5499796271,
0.945976913,
-0.1115762666,
-0.0668909252,
0.2539934814,
0.2635549307,
-0.0482957214,
0.1062796563,
-0.0647750199,
-0.6796372533,
-0.818757534,
-0.8909130096,
-0.4297870696,
0.1910781562,
-0.957636714,
0.1259188205,
-0.1232269406,
-0.2882382572,
-0.3783974946,
0.1315945834,
-0.4750521481,
-0.103028886,
-0.0326910838,
0.8968337178,
-0.4575799108,
0.822142601,
0.8287582397,
-0.4509785175,
-0.3126058578,
-0.2692874968,
-0.3236091435,
-0.5534415245,
0.7667995095,
-0.1640945524,
-0.3404012024,
-0.071128428,
-0.2189090401,
-0.8334538937,
0.79516536,
0.1835446954,
-0.2480983287,
-0.19044514,
0.0657373592,
0.5809262395,
-0.0860602707,
0.2720019519,
0.6216027141,
0.4247540236,
0.047158204,
-0.7980002165,
-0.2248262465,
-0.1793341339,
0.2079963684,
0.2828415036,
-0.2012978941,
0.4756651521,
-0.0868713409,
-0.2938863635,
0.2959457338,
0.7508214116,
0.4933880866,
0.1907039881,
0.2250632793,
0.6997321844,
0.5038924813,
-0.037156377,
1.2815397978,
-0.1199478582,
0.3502551913,
1.2323803902,
-0.254332304,
1.2058913708,
0.4377533793,
-0.3781222999,
0.3341459334,
0.1253635436,
0.4146296978,
0.13152951,
-0.0707710385,
-0.3847527206,
-0.1738911122,
-0.3281692266,
-0.4031543136,
0.2917256057,
0.5548343062,
-0.2352952361,
-0.2483812571,
0.1891931295,
-0.2178895921,
0.3234052658,
-0.1997927874,
0.8984674811,
0.2440307289,
-0.5514143109,
0.566912353,
0.1463257819,
0.811850071,
-0.5625939965,
-0.1972759366,
-0.3407760262,
-0.0050843828,
-0.1567991227,
-0.8209337592,
0.5024659038,
0.2673852146,
-0.2415159792,
-0.3235480785,
1.023709774,
-0.207828328,
-0.3833884895,
0.4356748462,
0.5580515265,
0.1113444641,
0.0600184798,
-0.6355533004,
0.3462128937,
-0.192903325,
-0.4386715889,
0.4381093085,
0.1916577667,
0.0715360418,
0.9001336098,
0.520494163,
0.1847154647,
0.2534098327,
0.2183737308,
0.6277447939,
-0.6860856414,
0.1568442136,
-0.6872881651,
0.3885596693,
0.1704580337,
0.093176879,
0.9490804076,
0.7127258778,
0.5280978084,
0.0932658613,
0.5877107382,
-0.0415598191,
1.1395224333,
-0.4826011062,
0.6625647545,
-0.5050742626,
0.3737002611,
-0.2645494044,
-1.0898946524,
-0.466552496,
0.5321097374,
-0.3440646231,
0.0567882285,
0.3697334528,
0.5993981957,
-0.015900895,
-0.0095879119,
0.2432202995,
0.1500840187,
0.2792746127,
-0.0571232326,
1.0635014772,
-0.5076175332,
0.361032784,
-0.1206220835,
0.1277362257,
-0.3725230694,
-0.7979636192,
-0.4757601321,
-0.6221995354,
-0.12235865,
-0.2420910895,
0.0217249747,
0.8353295922,
0.1299298257,
-0.5717629194,
-0.3493363559,
0.1271864623,
0.3024013937,
0.1199462339,
-0.2445079684,
0.3477816284,
-0.6697999239,
-0.6988512874,
0.535433948,
0.3017478883,
-0.228565827,
-0.3700487912,
-0.125674814,
-0.6528733373,
-0.1308647394,
0.8632710576,
0.476983428,
-1.0525746346,
0.1016070768,
0.2147792727,
-0.1247047037,
0.0634826869,
0.6646296978,
-1.0154833794,
0.5389671922,
0.6516769528,
0.9110701084,
0.3893973231,
0.0306501947,
0.3738276064,
-0.6219449639,
0.0081705824,
0.5196285248,
0.3977135122,
0.5407539606,
0.0137553345,
0.5850740075,
-0.0188859217,
-0.7406439781,
-1.1581147909,
0.1592742652,
-0.8584865928,
-0.0785459504,
1.2407541275,
0.0799881741,
0.0614074171,
-0.2326111495,
-0.2338067293,
0.180624485,
-0.0324562788,
0.2946546674,
0.5648448467,
-0.1015284508,
-0.2596329749,
-0.9280008674,
0.3682928979,
0.3116113544,
-0.6917933822,
0.3024338186,
0.6385903955,
0.0561073571,
0.1565690041,
0.5008288622,
-0.2821013331,
-0.1048018038,
-0.5172140598,
0.1905890107,
0.0670454502,
-0.1574638337,
-0.58713907,
0.0791156068,
0.4776290059,
0.2424789071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19509v1
|
Do Large Language Models Understand Conversational Implicature -- A case study with a chinese sitcom
| 2024-04-30T12:43:53 | 2024-04-30T12:43:53 |
Shisen Yue, Siyuan Song, Xinyuan Cheng, Hai Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, J.5
|
Understanding the non-literal meaning of an utterance is critical for large
language models (LLMs) to become human-like social communicators. In this work,
we introduce SwordsmanImp, the first Chinese multi-turn-dialogue-based dataset
aimed at conversational implicature, sourced from dialogues in the Chinese
sitcom $\textit{My Own Swordsman}$. It includes 200 carefully handcrafted
questions, all annotated on which Gricean maxims have been violated. We test
eight close-source and open-source LLMs under two tasks: a multiple-choice
question task and an implicature explanation task. Our results show that GPT-4
attains human-level accuracy (94%) on multiple-choice questions. CausalLM
demonstrates a 78.5% accuracy following GPT-4. Other models, including GPT-3.5
and several open-source models, demonstrate a lower accuracy ranging from 20%
to 60% on multiple-choice questions. Human raters were asked to rate the
explanation of the implicatures generated by LLMs on their reasonability, logic
and fluency. While all models generate largely fluent and self-consistent text,
their explanations score low on reasonability except for GPT-4, suggesting that
most LLMs cannot produce satisfactory explanations of the implicatures in the
conversation. Moreover, we find LLMs' performance does not vary significantly
by Gricean maxims, suggesting that LLMs do not seem to process implicatures
derived from different maxims differently. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/sjtu-compling/llm-pragmatics.
|
[
-0.1320530027,
-0.8033644557,
0.6543355584,
0.1111444235,
-0.2197269946,
-0.0816040784,
-0.1967646778,
-0.0943738818,
0.072613731,
0.6956104636,
-0.4599075615,
-0.2744868398,
-0.4675247669,
-0.0538083501,
-0.2652062774,
0.9327091575,
-0.0741248205,
0.2034388483,
0.0030363423,
-0.1334406883,
-0.3075096011,
-0.5973619223,
-0.5241780877,
-0.5309634805,
0.5862582922,
0.5480939746,
0.9741126895,
0.6836454272,
0.6289904118,
0.2960141301,
-0.0020081988,
0.3775598705,
-0.6832213402,
0.1524003148,
-0.369568646,
-0.5403555632,
-0.1216966137,
0.2046600282,
0.6738690734,
0.6820037961,
-0.1734512895,
0.1051929891,
0.2756240666,
0.3708226979,
-0.1309379041,
0.1764059961,
-0.821878016,
0.0476794243,
-0.2999947369,
-0.4504092634,
-0.6126503944,
-0.3763436675,
0.1509804428,
-0.6038612723,
0.2769243121,
0.1033669561,
1.0633276701,
-0.0497293994,
-0.4030257761,
-0.4455558062,
-0.5833550096,
0.5791909099,
-1.0529478788,
-0.0287744422,
0.2775232792,
0.3317801058,
-0.6170015931,
-0.709512949,
-0.7988718748,
-0.5096803308,
-0.2179270089,
0.0423922166,
0.0465505235,
0.3401852846,
0.4745125473,
0.435977906,
-0.8551668525,
-0.0501377694,
-0.1599035263,
0.0121029187,
0.755455792,
0.4033042192,
0.3812632263,
-0.2448690534,
-0.4379729927,
-0.0957841277,
-0.736504972,
0.0947574303,
0.4507772028,
0.241829142,
-0.2729845941,
0.48101601,
0.2871479988,
0.493868351,
0.2155889571,
-0.2852129042,
0.0217202026,
-0.3504360914,
-0.3571783006,
-0.0935563669,
0.9608866572,
0.3616016209,
0.5111361146,
-0.00834902,
0.1407215744,
-0.2428887486,
0.1508956403,
-0.7895271182,
-0.3717643917,
0.2314491123,
-0.3649797142,
-0.1135848016,
-0.0825137347,
-0.3344937265,
-0.7276611924,
-0.3769897819,
0.3862878084,
-0.5525832176,
-0.2894112468,
0.1051378101,
-0.2312019467,
0.3950722218,
0.3862349093,
-0.7687271237,
0.0590629354,
0.7260993719,
1.1068993807,
0.0346589386,
-0.5181090236,
-0.3537417948,
0.2131881565,
-0.5764222741,
0.6219833493,
-0.5422921777,
-0.1814023703,
-0.144422546,
0.1935094297,
-0.4767356217,
-0.5374974012,
0.6353123784,
-0.0639736727,
0.0888939649,
-0.2427048236,
-0.5617379546,
-0.5058022738,
0.2786186337,
-0.3742408752,
0.4419643581,
-0.0918241441,
-0.7056956291,
0.0208748467,
-0.6185991168,
-0.3628996611,
0.2266864777,
-0.2644269168,
-0.2287711203,
0.0151139181,
-0.0952152535,
0.6441136003,
-0.556217432,
0.9364137053,
-0.5302686691,
-0.5155674815,
0.5870075822,
-0.9276555777,
0.856046021,
0.1260287017,
-0.1927755475,
0.0494982786,
-0.1782471687,
-0.1412361264,
0.4318298101,
0.2765558064,
-0.1861799955,
0.0587329045,
-0.4531475306,
0.4033332169,
0.1449802071,
-0.5102627873,
0.0214190595,
-0.5521221161,
0.4356152415,
0.7870490551,
0.0731830969,
-0.0195892639,
-0.761044383,
0.5648388863,
0.1513026208,
0.0296345018,
-0.5330579281,
-0.466175884,
-0.7560839653,
-0.1666233093,
-0.2746052146,
0.5165349245,
-0.8953353763,
-0.0567031093,
-0.3539207876,
-0.7864804268,
-0.2207369059,
-0.0248758346,
0.50649333,
0.5106124878,
0.0265780836,
-0.0145823341,
-0.1881838441,
-1.1213729382,
-0.6263910532,
-0.4215836525,
0.0391838141,
0.468772471,
0.4662261605,
0.2613096535,
0.8170737624,
-0.3953680992,
-0.0549359061,
-0.4396751523,
0.2697351575,
0.5619846582,
0.2092179656,
0.3837237954,
-0.8192196488,
-0.6278182268,
0.0621192493,
-0.8773658276,
-0.0621073544,
-0.2861142755,
-0.0051303655,
-0.3657743037,
0.191672951,
-0.5411900282,
0.143696636,
0.509193182,
-0.1463326067,
0.7604376674,
-0.2508282065,
0.2195803523,
-1.2247810364,
-0.0042330581,
0.3393214941,
-0.0807945356,
-0.9455730915,
0.2685023844,
-0.0758793652,
-0.19745408,
-0.4758083224,
0.5239742994,
-0.1434189379,
0.2238607109,
-0.1390969455,
0.3681126535,
0.0814062282,
0.7653681636,
-0.1166360825,
0.8258699775,
0.2322328538,
-0.5537111759,
0.639328301,
0.166843012,
-0.0532544181,
0.6779970527,
-0.7510102987,
0.2042765617,
-0.2384537011,
0.2836401165,
-1.3127286434,
-0.6710777879,
0.5408676267,
-0.4214554131,
0.1002667025,
-0.4308442771,
-0.6029387712,
-0.2111614943,
-0.3547965288,
0.1242256388,
0.0006907703,
-0.5934360623,
0.3969403207,
0.5554344654,
-0.3744058609,
-0.3340537548,
-0.5747601986,
0.2840367556,
-0.5082278848,
-0.8786175251,
0.0499098748,
-0.2823305428,
-0.3838170171,
-0.5587032437,
0.3073649108,
-0.1337604374,
0.0862617716,
0.3906843066,
0.2236843258,
-0.2589913607,
0.1196721718,
0.0589150675,
0.1941981167,
0.0561928153,
0.0825049952,
0.6098533273,
-0.0617931001,
-0.5678317547,
-0.4308945835,
0.1944754422,
0.6219453216,
0.029317867,
0.6219360828,
0.109497495,
-0.1698148847,
-0.078351289,
-0.4164707065,
-0.0930334628,
-0.4731591046,
0.3154775798,
-0.5301988721,
-0.7190045118,
0.592058301,
0.046530094,
0.3310610354,
0.1400917619,
0.6078594923,
0.1597245783,
1.2430593967,
0.013049393,
-0.021299284,
0.3398852944,
0.0120394621,
0.4392193556,
-0.7101567388,
0.0813622624,
-0.2711279392,
-0.2091320008,
-0.6896420121,
-0.3527109921,
0.5534287691,
-0.3343481719,
-0.3114162087,
0.4305233955,
-0.2628312707,
0.3922934234,
0.2912707329,
-0.0496477187,
0.341302067,
-0.1122079715,
0.0937962681,
-0.2199062407,
-0.6808594465,
-0.5897755027,
0.8294129968,
0.6605759859,
0.7565723658,
0.1959711164,
0.3061521053,
0.1424086541,
0.2032506466,
-0.6807222366,
0.6228302717,
-0.2959648669,
-0.5937767625,
-0.2302814871,
-0.4731989801,
-0.8885740042,
0.7302474976,
0.3472473621,
-0.7100570798,
0.1170096248,
0.1505468637,
-0.2340122908,
0.2540785372,
-0.8408075571,
0.8660338521,
-0.2333377749,
-0.4048348367,
-0.066052109,
-0.601524353,
0.7849008441,
-0.0297346972,
0.2522629797,
-0.3947399259,
0.4639466107,
0.555881381,
-0.3687617183,
0.8518309593,
-0.194806993,
-0.3303067684,
0.1599261314,
0.2643477023,
0.7101145387,
0.00571068,
-0.1925811917,
0.249234885,
0.1884058416,
-0.0982300714,
-0.7624564171,
0.6302981973,
-0.443908453,
-0.8164991736,
-0.5532907844,
-0.8295711875,
-0.1444173306,
-0.1013867557,
0.170103088,
0.6889897585,
0.0286207199,
0.2335798144,
0.6316171885,
-0.2323891371,
0.1860171854,
0.7709370255,
-0.2294775844,
-0.1364511997,
1.0870345831,
0.3933520019,
0.5371620655,
0.0570684299,
0.3760660589,
-0.0436988622,
-0.4363902509,
-0.7233179212,
0.4645533264,
-0.620164752,
0.0364462435,
-0.5005114675,
-0.4763760269,
-0.2401140332,
0.0075745941,
-0.1264984906,
-0.0452119671,
-0.0306662079,
0.0514603592,
0.1150356829,
0.5498875976,
0.1358003467,
0.4349189103,
-0.6102257371,
0.4192622006,
-0.027773425,
0.0577898137,
0.004315299,
-1.0927497149,
-0.249583751,
0.564786613,
-0.3021051586,
-0.8954822421,
0.5289125443,
0.1960737258,
0.4619756043,
0.6068953872,
0.162603125,
0.9443109035,
-0.437286377,
0.8619778156,
-0.0987017155,
-0.7195444703,
0.2420334667,
-0.5893752575,
0.2392480224,
0.2925990224,
0.2998424172,
-0.9791080356,
-0.8509346843,
-0.5898675919,
-0.5758274794,
0.9438093305,
0.0140391961,
0.4422977567,
-0.0841814131,
0.2271598727,
0.1753249317,
0.1014071554,
-0.7320090532,
-0.259898752,
0.0883143172,
-0.2328502089,
-0.042340707,
-0.3077255487,
-0.2243655771,
-0.0133765368,
0.7026062608,
-0.3222432435,
0.125000149,
0.066982694,
-0.1329825222,
-0.1347179562,
0.125539884,
0.7624619603,
0.8728116155,
0.0383538529,
0.1237724721,
0.0427716933,
-0.4765095115,
0.1355095357,
0.1714184433,
0.0489724241,
0.1689431369,
0.458571434,
0.8736667633,
0.1589129716,
-0.7317496538,
0.8100939393,
-0.0660339147,
-0.0905769095,
-0.5838168859,
0.029190626,
-0.0982373506,
0.3066544235,
0.3135575354,
-0.4195539355,
0.196908921,
-0.5657569766,
0.0476935208,
0.6293312907,
-0.176070407,
-0.3143959641,
0.4615296423,
-0.0943419635,
-0.152994588,
0.2249360979,
-0.2967642844,
-0.5476984382,
0.497367084,
0.5768948793,
0.752369523,
-0.2879528403,
0.5729517937,
0.2280617654,
0.2160593122,
-0.0739392191,
0.0070198653,
0.1147422194,
-0.8968522549,
-0.482411027,
-0.2880581021,
-0.7154666185,
0.3220794201,
-0.3579970598,
0.3377267718,
-0.4971790016,
0.1791528612,
0.0549512804,
-0.177086696,
-0.1778564453,
-0.050812047,
0.0376830362,
0.5724493265,
-0.7801868916,
0.6838490963,
0.2975614369,
-0.415128231,
-1.1041269302,
0.2449031472,
0.1086308658,
-0.9076786637,
0.4557203948,
0.1488849372,
-0.2071725726,
-0.0924294591,
-0.8003576994,
-0.6737433076,
0.8417381644,
0.8246271014,
-0.5226364136,
-0.1903499812,
0.384647131,
0.4257000685,
-0.1346230656,
0.5690288544,
0.5767586827,
0.401037842,
0.2363389283,
-1.2047513723,
-0.0280301329,
-0.2345772088,
-0.1254863441,
0.2131682634,
-0.7730503678,
0.9774673581,
-0.0000238345,
-0.2952727973,
0.0928609595,
0.3233802617,
0.3707350194,
0.3591346145,
0.1161046401,
0.1824765205,
0.741459012,
0.0484088771,
1.1262233257,
-0.43066594,
0.1869416982,
1.1050773859,
-0.4723495543,
0.4216121733,
0.2951586246,
-0.1723793149,
0.4116454422,
0.4792809486,
0.2131684124,
0.0497218147,
0.2445615381,
-0.2419371307,
-0.1650047749,
-0.4020954967,
-0.1402160078,
0.4805961549,
0.5135153532,
-0.5371653438,
-0.2209403962,
0.1339857876,
0.5983148813,
-0.0449593961,
-0.1747275144,
0.827899456,
0.2970322073,
-0.7411990166,
0.6880902648,
0.0782991573,
0.3835914731,
-0.7755744457,
-0.2234689295,
-0.2509873807,
0.2335182279,
-0.0909679681,
-0.9795950055,
0.0492209271,
-0.1119687259,
0.1260700524,
-0.075580366,
0.6293622851,
-0.7340356112,
-0.3075553775,
0.0022156774,
0.2422735244,
0.5224147439,
-0.1456575692,
-0.6355281472,
-0.2030470669,
0.0579435341,
-0.074059099,
0.3091731369,
0.641926229,
-0.1614097953,
0.8275108933,
0.6281222701,
0.158267796,
-0.1084189638,
-0.0522228666,
0.7107537389,
-0.4630793333,
-0.3338356316,
-1.166503191,
0.2857410908,
-0.1955433339,
-0.2724609673,
1.0045469999,
0.506357193,
0.5757622719,
0.081598103,
0.8169295788,
0.2567894757,
0.7500450611,
-0.5079298019,
0.5790665746,
-0.3846364021,
0.1700938642,
-0.2970509827,
-0.5147588253,
-0.0517164581,
0.5220236778,
-0.615573585,
-0.2175340056,
0.4727512896,
0.9474478364,
-0.0213424377,
0.2892568409,
0.5238359571,
0.2631999552,
0.5508702397,
0.6934345365,
0.9586375952,
-0.1118245795,
0.3717365861,
-0.1510606706,
-0.0265165679,
-0.2720785141,
-0.5521402359,
-0.8984565735,
-0.6388133764,
0.0165288113,
-0.1948321164,
0.1224312186,
1.1740540266,
0.3754121065,
-0.615101099,
-0.5714737177,
0.0280642081,
0.1707440913,
-0.0272935778,
-0.2781089842,
0.1190491021,
-0.300403446,
-0.7747146487,
0.4627227485,
0.3662503064,
-0.2382618785,
-0.3847410977,
-0.0544023328,
-0.190216437,
0.3311288357,
0.516343832,
0.1221972555,
-0.7676707506,
-0.5259743333,
-0.158406198,
-0.0145849213,
0.1860902458,
0.9655493498,
-0.3249020278,
0.5916496515,
0.4271809459,
0.4104322195,
0.1527728736,
0.1217305586,
0.7626510859,
-0.5610004663,
0.0683925673,
0.2155284435,
0.3780945241,
0.4364768863,
-0.3478945792,
0.3093225062,
0.3266143799,
-0.6168039441,
-0.9081447124,
0.4056189954,
-0.4896935225,
-0.1001454964,
1.1837232113,
-0.4278324246,
-0.0123638036,
-0.3446853459,
-0.5522918105,
0.1870255023,
-0.2753428817,
0.4225583076,
0.9916635156,
-0.1956740171,
-0.2956239581,
-0.7738217115,
0.3077428639,
0.3066267967,
-0.5611764193,
0.5172147155,
0.3383712173,
0.0653990954,
0.0860085562,
0.4306030273,
0.0860811546,
0.2254019529,
-0.1469202936,
-0.3532938659,
-0.0536219031,
-0.1192831695,
-0.2563503981,
0.1169906557,
0.2033912838,
-0.0765219629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19505v1
|
Context-Aware Machine Translation with Source Coreference Explanation
| 2024-04-30T12:41:00 | 2024-04-30T12:41:00 |
Huy Hien Vu, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite significant improvements in enhancing the quality of translation,
context-aware machine translation (MT) models underperform in many cases. One
of the main reasons is that they fail to utilize the correct features from
context when the context is too long or their models are overly complex. This
can lead to the explain-away effect, wherein the models only consider features
easier to explain predictions, resulting in inaccurate translations. To address
this issue, we propose a model that explains the decisions made for translation
by predicting coreference features in the input. We construct a model for input
coreference by exploiting contextual features from both the input and
translation output representations on top of an existing MT model. We evaluate
and analyze our method in the WMT document-level translation task of
English-German dataset, the English-Russian dataset, and the multilingual TED
talk dataset, demonstrating an improvement of over 1.0 BLEU score when compared
with other context-aware models.
|
[
-0.4941842258,
-0.7343697548,
0.7745663524,
-0.0748203844,
-0.662453711,
-0.2954829335,
-0.5227846503,
-0.6324663758,
-0.1630896628,
0.5083725452,
-0.4908024073,
-0.4348119795,
-0.9549424052,
0.1928780675,
-0.2900838852,
1.0420837402,
-0.1987389773,
0.0904098228,
-0.3866055906,
-0.3159321249,
-1.009458065,
-0.569329381,
-0.185945034,
-0.7033055425,
0.3085579276,
0.6375310421,
0.8417354822,
0.6689403653,
0.5050299764,
0.192139551,
-0.1989202797,
0.1751746982,
0.0075844177,
0.0248193778,
-0.5032164454,
-0.3176195025,
-0.4159774482,
0.022185782,
0.4531076252,
0.8429936767,
0.2618229389,
0.1653538644,
0.1376231313,
0.3209044635,
-0.3315921724,
0.1447796375,
-0.6217874885,
-0.1710228026,
-0.0540392101,
-0.3611212075,
-0.5515694022,
0.0135753145,
0.2389942706,
-0.3523131609,
0.3111304343,
0.1088702008,
0.6010181308,
0.3383927345,
-0.6765132546,
-0.4502204359,
-0.7457181811,
0.8327769637,
-0.6037423611,
0.3242993653,
0.5198049545,
0.2587673962,
0.0546973646,
-0.4637154639,
-0.6745690107,
-0.0581191666,
-0.4237274826,
0.1490126997,
-0.2456918508,
-0.2358981818,
0.1654843986,
0.1991742551,
-0.5298939347,
0.0060671237,
-0.2116017491,
-0.0400475077,
0.1642609984,
-0.0825215131,
0.0504312329,
-0.4820971191,
-0.340698719,
0.1450084448,
-0.5788629055,
0.0990219861,
-0.4459805191,
0.4624143839,
0.0540752336,
0.5779201388,
-0.048386123,
0.7978373766,
0.3226157725,
-0.1777853966,
0.2419431359,
-0.4234399498,
-0.2772996128,
0.3200571835,
0.4002348483,
0.4880479872,
-0.092729412,
-0.2734193802,
-0.0269025639,
-0.2488133758,
0.0362212248,
-0.825879097,
0.3367722034,
0.439189136,
-0.4375438392,
-0.0727779418,
-0.0802575797,
-0.1669128239,
-0.1464906186,
-0.5258460641,
0.1976189166,
-0.5921670198,
-0.0907848999,
-0.1602711976,
-0.1038506404,
-0.0843598843,
0.4166389108,
-0.4583640993,
-0.1498233825,
0.4950875938,
0.9060884118,
-0.3758012652,
-0.34630391,
-0.5383676887,
0.4206727743,
-0.2021505535,
0.7372741699,
-0.5370154381,
-0.7166843414,
-0.2362070829,
0.2178681493,
-0.1353147924,
-0.5887157917,
0.8853296638,
-0.2136847228,
0.4843265116,
-0.3955814838,
-0.5732164383,
-0.4859928787,
0.2353112996,
-0.3415950835,
0.8776880503,
0.1193781123,
-0.7238513827,
0.2932700515,
-0.8855612874,
-0.7084429264,
0.0966519564,
0.3172595799,
-0.1869813651,
0.3898239732,
0.4497072995,
0.6850946546,
-0.4089787602,
0.7207632661,
-0.1345285624,
-0.194403559,
0.4696001709,
-0.1156952605,
0.6634047031,
0.3105392456,
-0.3013086319,
0.4367540479,
-0.4530082941,
-0.2041452229,
0.0220124088,
-0.0481528342,
-0.596719563,
-0.0177994203,
-0.0005030166,
0.591915071,
0.2616509199,
-0.4636242092,
0.0580673963,
-0.0544267073,
0.6892522573,
0.4283398986,
-0.045558773,
0.8227230906,
-0.1460382491,
0.3625860214,
0.3154126704,
0.0543130524,
-0.34199965,
-0.3916191161,
-0.4193939865,
-0.1046836674,
0.3313144147,
0.6041007638,
-0.8317303061,
0.5612506866,
-0.490245223,
-0.3658388257,
-0.3595075905,
0.1084620431,
0.4303408861,
1.0153982639,
0.6175112128,
-0.1219296828,
-0.4043286443,
-1.0640765429,
-0.2134843171,
0.0293728355,
-0.0908100158,
0.2369836569,
0.7333214879,
-0.4099243879,
0.9931034446,
-0.3122161925,
-0.2676436305,
-0.4716843665,
0.1013797969,
0.1940192282,
0.7879089713,
0.4160981178,
-0.8393183947,
-0.2349349409,
0.2361367941,
-0.6290532947,
-0.1509413719,
-0.0930426568,
-0.2401916981,
0.0066843419,
0.2644289136,
-0.7683388591,
0.1838205904,
0.6682345271,
-0.29090482,
0.4894059598,
-0.0706836134,
0.1537661701,
-1.5419754982,
0.4273963869,
-0.2034248859,
-0.5536361933,
-0.5194357634,
-0.0019008358,
0.3052144051,
-0.3411040902,
-0.4824047089,
0.5970012546,
-0.2333331555,
0.0525364503,
-0.4390571713,
0.3970539868,
0.3339832723,
0.2960655987,
0.1568139344,
0.8621739745,
0.2166830003,
-0.6287305951,
-0.0071294568,
0.487362206,
-0.1228880435,
0.9316807985,
-0.6048631668,
0.0423847735,
-0.0144479675,
0.4560168386,
-0.7956021428,
-0.1696350724,
0.1074393168,
-0.7242897153,
0.4277252555,
-0.194454819,
-0.4426521361,
-0.1403420866,
0.2951014936,
0.2173479199,
0.2851044834,
-0.5246142745,
0.6130237579,
0.2328902185,
-0.0706240162,
-0.5544962287,
-0.7168751955,
0.187346682,
-0.3483992517,
-0.6129858494,
0.6805855036,
-0.1446403116,
-0.0313452147,
0.1430054009,
-0.1289951801,
-0.2230173349,
0.2228289545,
0.4757353365,
0.0747504383,
-0.041355066,
0.2472938895,
0.3600179255,
-0.2617185414,
0.0371981934,
-0.4927696288,
0.3254839778,
-0.2012764215,
-0.0599323846,
-0.3077888191,
0.6741604805,
0.7594624758,
-0.3544786572,
0.7322880626,
0.8198294044,
-0.3873665631,
0.0199695155,
-0.2649508119,
-0.2695806623,
-0.3514916003,
0.417922765,
-0.6833484173,
-0.8844527006,
0.608970046,
-0.2753372788,
-0.0441273898,
0.6465319991,
0.5565676093,
-0.2927434444,
0.9874404073,
0.5500838161,
0.3052368164,
0.4677022398,
-0.0155015467,
0.183285147,
-1.0967441797,
-0.1138249636,
-0.5409491062,
-0.261015594,
-0.3068341017,
-0.4070715606,
0.1868412048,
0.4378655553,
0.1988817751,
0.7705554366,
-0.4258426428,
0.2801617384,
0.6764315963,
-0.0004133596,
0.361278981,
-0.194323495,
-0.2635551095,
-0.1244973168,
-0.7724329233,
-0.5699998736,
0.6435437202,
0.1308947355,
0.0950958133,
0.0474754497,
0.3017320633,
0.2982881069,
0.4822729826,
-0.7310298681,
0.3434450328,
-0.0560790338,
-0.8453154564,
-0.0453438275,
-0.5234639049,
-0.8105484843,
0.2974202335,
-0.2153257281,
-0.4108543992,
0.1071178615,
0.2604453564,
-0.0224651359,
-0.0331707969,
-0.6848839521,
1.1609176397,
-0.2662917972,
-0.1701487452,
-0.2665436864,
-0.6525505781,
0.3150320351,
-0.0954816565,
0.4259905219,
-0.2055682689,
0.2440036833,
0.5995480418,
-0.1492248029,
0.7228503823,
-0.0664700568,
0.1722780764,
0.2495972812,
0.3957566917,
0.3526376188,
0.0100240456,
-0.1603536904,
0.4651297927,
-0.0314015672,
-0.3886168599,
-0.6025365591,
0.6507388949,
-0.5847162604,
-0.5354782939,
-0.0783459768,
-0.7218927145,
-0.1566673666,
0.3718087971,
0.6197757125,
0.3963070512,
-0.1884807795,
0.3489049971,
0.3670566678,
-0.0585793257,
0.5638160706,
0.5029696226,
-0.07478863,
-0.4175503254,
0.6108696461,
0.212765336,
0.1833898723,
0.4071077704,
0.4154740572,
-0.3467954695,
-0.4463252723,
-0.8464827538,
0.0933140665,
-1.0276244879,
-0.1726971865,
-0.580632627,
0.2453075945,
-0.4483571351,
-0.3549838364,
-0.2881404757,
-0.6077888012,
-0.2023607045,
-0.170994103,
-0.0560565665,
0.4328831434,
0.246578604,
0.6697049737,
-0.9513572454,
-0.1078102142,
0.0387396142,
0.086281769,
-0.179248482,
-0.9549417496,
-0.5786700249,
-0.0571356788,
-0.4554206431,
-1.0001357794,
0.3963699639,
0.1058284119,
0.577536881,
0.3531534374,
0.0801585168,
0.6714977026,
-0.5814584494,
0.830616653,
0.1643531621,
-1.400744915,
0.7647127509,
-0.1515677869,
0.7518243194,
0.4233255088,
0.2985955775,
-0.6995645761,
-0.2373431623,
-0.6492831111,
-0.5681927204,
0.5260117054,
0.3736867607,
-0.0420636386,
0.0643488541,
0.3284215927,
0.3997097909,
0.2916490734,
-0.6224666238,
-0.0749277547,
-0.2969507873,
-0.1191145331,
-0.3021103144,
-0.2945030332,
-0.1561414897,
-0.1764965504,
0.6680344343,
-0.1859961748,
0.2004373968,
0.3568716943,
-0.5837441683,
-0.163366437,
0.5289505124,
1.0923266411,
0.9900866151,
-0.266307652,
0.4550992846,
0.2668866515,
-0.1260513365,
-0.2609705925,
0.0758602619,
-0.3358873725,
0.4892678857,
0.5073302388,
0.7745935321,
0.0835825875,
-0.4824955761,
0.38498348,
0.1064118892,
0.0917424113,
-0.1871396601,
-0.2665452957,
0.1449354738,
0.0169015955,
0.4582170844,
0.4802590609,
0.1936365813,
-0.409529984,
0.1855523884,
0.2456708848,
-0.6933169365,
-0.5409895778,
0.5387893915,
0.4397560358,
-0.2687987387,
0.2217891961,
0.0054029995,
-0.7870797515,
0.3268396854,
0.6831367016,
0.8378095627,
-0.2073865831,
-0.1021515727,
0.5513116121,
0.3898228407,
0.0972272903,
-0.146166712,
-0.2116696984,
-0.7049298882,
-0.6786949039,
-0.341327399,
-0.5632226467,
-0.0844085291,
-0.8345947862,
0.1087118015,
0.0366995782,
-0.4168306291,
-0.1494447738,
-0.2796301842,
-0.742110908,
0.2665119469,
0.0260369908,
0.6346137524,
-0.8403887749,
1.024879694,
0.8021621108,
-0.2830294073,
-0.2916488349,
-0.166768387,
-0.2423541397,
-0.5521822572,
0.6063584685,
0.4190205336,
-0.1058149412,
-0.0435557403,
-0.4383352995,
-0.8186620474,
0.9195511341,
0.4622063935,
-0.3161461949,
0.1575737894,
-0.0028160508,
0.2318569869,
-0.6708734632,
0.020581631,
0.4140717685,
0.5583834052,
-0.0809526145,
-1.1415214539,
0.2776742876,
-0.0923412517,
0.037101604,
0.0155398883,
-0.0901789293,
0.5897847414,
-0.1256143898,
-0.1951358169,
-0.4069926739,
0.5642542243,
-0.0919810385,
0.4672429264,
0.3950072229,
0.3624264598,
0.5472133756,
-0.1323588341,
1.1887112856,
-0.5865733027,
0.3565885127,
1.5159749985,
0.0375473164,
0.9071865678,
0.6115835309,
0.3643065393,
0.3614579737,
0.7523277998,
0.3821149766,
0.3615471423,
-0.5025379062,
0.0799602345,
-0.412909925,
-0.4006642699,
-0.3452284932,
0.4854752421,
0.5051500201,
-0.7580732107,
-0.2265478671,
0.3906926811,
0.1745280176,
0.0698990151,
-0.1880824119,
0.6721881628,
0.1624818444,
-0.9256628156,
0.6785300374,
0.3224898279,
0.3524778187,
-0.3260706067,
0.063489683,
-0.1906054616,
0.1276239455,
-0.0992562473,
-0.8041235805,
0.6582385302,
-0.1077161804,
-0.6383344531,
-0.4870701432,
0.4914288819,
-0.4787369967,
-0.3418115079,
0.2509149313,
0.6777193546,
0.1617819518,
-0.4123841822,
-0.775564611,
-0.0163091179,
-0.1888041198,
0.0359322838,
0.0653890893,
0.5817634463,
-0.2144637704,
0.4862354398,
0.7030573487,
-0.2672062814,
-0.1890485138,
-0.2898206413,
0.5250841379,
-0.6955442429,
-0.5014979839,
-0.9452059865,
0.5310950875,
-0.1356984377,
-0.5962027311,
0.7269177437,
0.3954692781,
0.7544749379,
-0.1450151354,
0.7446966767,
-0.133172527,
0.4561014175,
-0.2682706118,
0.4452383816,
-0.382207185,
0.056593895,
-0.1225181594,
-1.0418900251,
-0.2856821418,
0.3739799857,
-0.4140841961,
-0.3500895798,
0.9946779013,
0.282802552,
-0.1563790739,
-0.1659843475,
0.5272625685,
0.1950494796,
0.2952279747,
0.4105540812,
0.440634191,
-0.3242194355,
0.5750390291,
-0.4315242767,
-0.1090345606,
-0.4738914073,
-1.0965330601,
-0.8860472441,
-0.7522196174,
-0.3265777528,
-0.4967112243,
-0.3234131634,
0.8895198107,
1.0145772696,
-0.9155390263,
-0.0234413221,
0.1933132708,
0.3824344277,
-0.6103246808,
-0.154263258,
0.3583372235,
-0.2137367874,
-0.7580509186,
0.4504563212,
0.2041238993,
-0.0251844674,
0.0521850027,
-0.043768622,
0.0682478324,
-0.014008929,
0.8827372789,
-0.1702657342,
-1.0185782909,
-0.4432503879,
0.1038146019,
-0.2902541757,
0.2417487502,
0.9882436991,
-0.475841552,
0.6045854092,
0.339556098,
0.571013391,
0.3778703213,
0.252971679,
0.7063028216,
-0.7313959002,
0.1995777935,
0.0771209374,
0.4998378754,
0.6071981192,
-0.4892216027,
0.4185804129,
0.3630559146,
-0.3484905958,
-0.58825773,
0.4212657809,
-1.3013447523,
-0.6235084534,
0.9624717236,
-0.2852125168,
-0.3042387962,
-0.1888628006,
-0.305472374,
0.3873367608,
-0.3683399856,
0.6062699556,
0.7856408954,
-0.034731973,
-0.3124477863,
-0.5807626843,
0.1975920051,
0.4849076271,
-0.421228081,
0.2051200569,
0.4621295929,
0.3085734248,
0.4187011719,
0.1021698341,
-0.0424769782,
0.29353863,
-0.2748646736,
0.3347254097,
-0.4042879045,
-0.1127905324,
-0.2893387675,
0.2012212127,
0.0543696471,
-0.19397223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19486v1
|
Safe Training with Sensitive In-domain Data: Leveraging Data Fragmentation To Mitigate Linkage Attacks
| 2024-04-30T12:09:55 | 2024-04-30T12:09:55 |
Mariia Ignashina, Julia Ive
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Current text generation models are trained using real data which can
potentially contain sensitive information, such as confidential patient
information and the like. Under certain conditions output of the training data
which they have memorised can be triggered, exposing sensitive data. To
mitigate against this risk we propose a safer alternative which sees fragmented
data in the form of domain-specific short phrases randomly grouped together
shared instead of full texts. Thus, text fragments that could re-identify an
individual cannot be reproduced by the model in one sequence, giving
significant protection against linkage attacks. We fine-tune several
state-of-the-art LLMs using meaningful syntactic chunks to explore their
utility. In particular, we fine-tune BERT-based models to predict two
cardiovascular diagnoses. Our results demonstrate the capacity of LLMs to
benefit from the pre-trained knowledge and deliver classification results when
fine-tuned with fragmented data comparable to fine-tuning with full training
data.
|
[
-0.2968524992,
-0.9091133475,
0.3210434914,
-0.2681200504,
-0.6088613272,
0.0836184546,
-0.0460594483,
-0.8669763207,
-0.010454542,
0.6466590762,
-0.6794746518,
-0.4693227112,
-0.6574308872,
0.0350279473,
-0.5877800584,
1.1618767977,
0.0838109329,
0.4767991304,
-0.4483248293,
-0.137845099,
-0.2556615472,
-0.8894438148,
-0.589525044,
-0.3215049207,
0.6066508889,
0.2468441874,
0.4582535028,
0.6680912375,
0.8992015719,
0.1658445001,
-0.0655432045,
0.1666227579,
-0.6427927613,
0.3800877929,
-0.0186534002,
-0.4479848444,
-0.5406524539,
-0.2868931293,
0.425665915,
0.8432843089,
-0.0025809498,
-0.0274102502,
0.1271359324,
0.7207166553,
-0.4035415351,
-0.1961824596,
-0.7947235703,
0.140554145,
-0.3475526869,
-0.3614716828,
-0.3924370408,
-0.4408787489,
0.3724928498,
-0.2959890366,
0.4840832055,
0.2751353085,
0.8355214596,
0.4045023322,
-0.3586528599,
-0.1571371555,
-0.4482346177,
0.6499439478,
-0.3840609789,
0.4809322357,
0.522601068,
0.1163398996,
-0.2845902443,
-0.6659924388,
-0.2013580501,
0.2724989057,
0.128406927,
-0.0628779233,
-0.1229320541,
0.3303851783,
0.0832402632,
0.3357632458,
-0.6907694936,
0.2983465493,
-0.3472569585,
-0.401311636,
0.6484160423,
0.2387993783,
0.4917306602,
0.004817504,
-0.7864399552,
0.0377131589,
-1.0808949471,
-0.3579271436,
0.2927059531,
0.4809077978,
-0.1725053191,
0.3990502954,
0.1547283679,
0.5889368653,
0.0498770773,
-0.2824097872,
0.1736701876,
-0.2043899447,
-0.3592024148,
0.2784013152,
0.72536093,
0.2827158272,
0.388805896,
-0.4309071004,
-0.0383140668,
0.0363081954,
0.4644257426,
-0.9508607984,
-0.4063805044,
0.4267988503,
-0.5065113902,
-0.5256974101,
-0.1705989838,
-0.516449213,
-0.1532989293,
-0.0768136457,
0.208823368,
-0.7769398093,
0.1362548023,
0.1931935996,
-0.0321913213,
-0.2534567416,
0.2958698869,
-0.8442859054,
0.2461643964,
0.7704565525,
0.5618991256,
-0.4405061901,
-0.1324270964,
-0.3122602999,
0.3578866124,
-0.0810476914,
0.87162745,
-0.0659428611,
-0.6541596651,
0.2265680134,
-0.0965997055,
-0.0773804337,
-0.6788364649,
0.4887963533,
-0.5842544436,
0.0413851663,
-0.0668668672,
-0.9801303744,
0.0874595791,
0.2820912004,
-0.8281683326,
0.8421470523,
0.0606506877,
-1.0887445211,
0.6896792054,
-0.1110596806,
-0.6207226515,
0.0988813341,
-0.1810639799,
-0.928340137,
0.0142672062,
0.2176537365,
0.5606841445,
-0.0876604319,
0.2151405066,
-0.540574491,
0.0067319712,
0.4963388741,
-0.4090663493,
0.3327866197,
0.1397008598,
0.1959009767,
0.0504736416,
-0.761811614,
0.217937544,
-0.1407160163,
-0.4143559337,
-0.4541760683,
0.1006152853,
0.0712165982,
-0.0301552992,
0.1965669543,
-0.5867032409,
0.0513702556,
-0.3393336833,
0.2451716363,
0.6920353174,
0.5804567337,
0.284747839,
-0.8291738033,
0.371937871,
0.3438699245,
0.5669555664,
0.0935080722,
-0.5082047582,
-0.417619586,
-0.4729291797,
0.2649704218,
0.3071085811,
-0.6896399856,
0.5660116673,
-0.3891628981,
-0.3079678416,
-0.4474626184,
0.1681208313,
0.3137678802,
0.7411907911,
0.5338571072,
-0.4352073371,
-0.3697051406,
-0.7183386683,
-0.2085634619,
-0.1250400245,
-0.0876722261,
0.3317967653,
0.3154700398,
-0.3992023766,
0.6407667398,
-0.5602707267,
-0.2099732608,
-0.3273163438,
-0.0477877371,
-0.3146574199,
0.7392055392,
0.2998094857,
-0.7795943618,
-0.39992401,
-0.304364264,
-0.6147388816,
0.2839889526,
-0.1918336004,
-0.3369094431,
-0.3430711031,
0.4984858632,
-0.3169110119,
0.4108006954,
0.3374812305,
-0.1772549897,
0.1364097893,
-0.3075329363,
-0.2593604326,
-1.1558631659,
-0.1316777468,
-0.1763247699,
-0.4282458425,
-0.8919520974,
0.0098855812,
0.077267848,
-0.0028940146,
-0.4183697104,
0.3090759814,
-0.20742926,
0.3588288426,
-0.1812208593,
-0.2410896271,
-0.132521525,
0.101140812,
0.0657277927,
0.4511063397,
0.5358855724,
-0.5012657642,
-0.2232084572,
0.5786665678,
-0.4939621985,
0.4724982679,
-0.633287549,
0.2793466449,
-0.1583292931,
0.0839695856,
-0.6088097692,
-0.4785784483,
0.0055106361,
-0.3264104128,
0.6534301639,
-0.0673148856,
-0.5644236803,
-0.1168816015,
-0.4033453465,
0.6776348352,
0.4561042488,
-0.665363729,
0.0909489021,
0.6382483244,
-0.0923960134,
-0.446077168,
-0.7778303027,
-0.2977272272,
-0.4846155047,
-0.7559015751,
0.2746212184,
-0.2948603332,
0.2453886718,
-0.1498227268,
-0.2419300675,
-0.5427033305,
0.4485263526,
0.5839859843,
0.4856380224,
0.1845207959,
0.2478391826,
0.2503536642,
0.1496056318,
0.1065573841,
-0.1556426287,
0.4231671691,
0.3080743253,
-0.4161669314,
-0.4059887528,
0.5705863833,
0.3295584321,
0.0006404314,
0.6994280815,
0.6073626876,
-0.5228053927,
-0.5569689274,
-0.2314824164,
-0.4227080345,
-0.4871656299,
0.2217373699,
0.0315088332,
-1.1887044907,
0.2747792006,
-0.341838479,
-0.1433376968,
0.1787854284,
0.4076170921,
-0.5525430441,
0.6314416528,
0.9164121151,
-0.1381647289,
0.4989750981,
-0.0762660354,
0.1649952978,
-0.7097139359,
-0.5160422921,
-0.4032235444,
-0.3723360598,
-0.503480196,
-0.4932217002,
0.6151340604,
0.1867255867,
-0.1003623828,
-0.114618592,
-0.5646559,
0.5439217687,
0.3099505901,
0.6499488354,
-0.0004831069,
0.2576090991,
-0.1430336982,
0.0036573447,
-0.822393477,
-0.3054934144,
1.5207853317,
0.3434454501,
1.1553932428,
-0.1645614654,
1.125869751,
0.3639325798,
0.2875580788,
-0.6260245442,
0.3538880348,
-0.2010559589,
-0.7698326707,
-0.1097248346,
-0.479490757,
-1.2146416903,
-0.2078220397,
-0.4164990187,
-0.7150053978,
0.1354008466,
0.0563067608,
-0.4406763613,
0.4746106267,
-0.4222410023,
0.5818924308,
-0.2875870764,
-0.1680686921,
-0.0090857921,
-0.9499858022,
0.3035378456,
-0.600260675,
0.1011641696,
-0.3043974042,
-0.0659025535,
0.7543786764,
-0.7505997419,
1.0725665092,
0.2643583715,
0.039226301,
0.2280661762,
-0.0789187104,
0.2659952641,
-0.0670934692,
0.2467205822,
0.3567410707,
-0.137219578,
-0.5262780786,
-0.3568773568,
0.678486228,
-0.9424713254,
-0.1707027853,
-0.338850677,
-0.5396571159,
-0.4796943069,
0.052612491,
0.5801009536,
0.4898753762,
-0.1792884171,
0.0741815418,
0.9815992117,
0.1128553525,
0.3412412703,
0.3529603481,
0.5042374134,
-0.610199213,
0.8892941475,
-0.1933118105,
0.4054912031,
0.482622683,
0.0527057163,
-0.291641444,
-0.9462608695,
-0.237103343,
0.1846565604,
-0.7569022775,
-0.5167824626,
-0.3864053786,
-0.2616792321,
-0.0762218833,
-0.3228372633,
-0.139785856,
-0.3634151816,
-0.476690948,
-0.3459597826,
0.3579109907,
0.7235211134,
0.0766347647,
0.4643687904,
-1.2913608551,
0.0799360797,
-0.0133951539,
0.2321350574,
-0.3316292763,
-0.1742478609,
-0.591088295,
-0.2957127988,
-0.1052035093,
-0.7825198174,
0.413398087,
0.3350285292,
0.4775619805,
0.3475908935,
0.1824594289,
0.5416343212,
-0.5933350325,
0.8102740645,
0.3994485438,
-0.664257288,
0.6513102055,
-0.1795473248,
-0.0257315319,
0.9159069657,
0.6159136295,
-0.0985105261,
-0.4441059828,
-0.8128691912,
-0.9749672413,
0.3278850317,
-0.0073331329,
-0.141526863,
-0.2284552008,
0.5626568794,
0.3216757774,
0.2414947152,
-0.5013328195,
-0.287630558,
0.2358489186,
-0.59267205,
0.1203688756,
-0.405657202,
-0.5438271165,
-0.0803141147,
0.4209223092,
-0.1078190506,
0.2501908839,
0.3824256957,
-0.2208996117,
-0.3129621446,
0.102620922,
0.197628364,
0.3291107416,
-0.2006080151,
0.1767678857,
0.1069117337,
-0.9032204151,
0.2582427561,
-0.008751506,
-0.2195720375,
0.1253561378,
0.6247848868,
0.4720919728,
0.4643055201,
-0.7285259962,
0.5858056545,
-0.1735932678,
-0.2562813461,
-0.0605103448,
0.2763227522,
-0.1717933118,
0.1069136634,
-0.1081113815,
0.3436582983,
-0.110619545,
-0.2102564722,
0.6389735937,
0.3086659312,
-0.4465427995,
-0.3390751481,
0.779551208,
0.2728980482,
0.0376711041,
0.4674448669,
0.2774508893,
-0.414274931,
0.3942560852,
0.4714702964,
0.8793436289,
-0.3044673502,
-0.0200740248,
0.1298822016,
0.2310596704,
-0.0358885266,
0.5486667752,
-0.0187740587,
-0.7402519584,
-0.1275092363,
-0.6043822169,
-0.4356658459,
-0.0605173744,
-1.0352958441,
0.0159378387,
-0.6821528077,
-0.347199738,
-0.1127697006,
-0.0811250284,
-0.6455517411,
0.5296440721,
0.3127483726,
0.9661267996,
-0.7787124515,
1.3917640448,
0.5938225985,
-0.3039485216,
-0.8089600205,
0.1463420093,
-0.0564637221,
-0.7915296555,
0.5653969646,
-0.0192968659,
0.3344987035,
-0.5581868291,
-0.4233725667,
-0.7525932193,
0.9670716524,
0.2293805927,
-0.6135833859,
-0.1803298146,
0.5593820214,
0.47827214,
-0.1807685047,
-0.1979334652,
0.4932567775,
-0.005161508,
-0.0830693841,
-0.783620894,
0.1707020402,
0.1119586676,
-0.3081244826,
0.4113097191,
-0.5692371726,
0.8884945512,
-0.1805081069,
-0.1031884849,
0.0515266769,
0.4107943177,
0.0499350801,
0.3171826899,
0.4135394692,
0.7663895488,
1.2672948837,
-0.2018885016,
1.1344116926,
-0.5728897452,
0.164100185,
1.1731475592,
-0.1063095704,
1.0259248018,
0.2973309159,
-0.1002188176,
0.303804934,
0.7637539506,
0.1179388762,
0.7705734372,
0.2071414292,
-0.7338196635,
-0.3407298028,
-0.0202918313,
-0.4294270873,
0.2271803916,
0.4512485564,
-0.3775589168,
-0.1800632775,
0.0011061768,
0.0829222351,
-0.1933749914,
-0.2717240453,
0.9416184425,
0.2334230542,
-0.1320218295,
0.5406133533,
-0.3210586905,
0.5661127567,
-0.8139415383,
0.3514099121,
-0.2024566829,
0.168062672,
-0.4324045777,
-0.4866266847,
0.2421681583,
0.05937621,
-0.2502345145,
-0.1842943281,
0.9249814749,
-0.6540332437,
-0.2601102293,
0.083824262,
0.5422146916,
0.1926350296,
0.048144035,
-0.7217216492,
0.1465709507,
0.2001497895,
0.0907440558,
0.7335003614,
0.514406383,
0.1095452756,
0.694642961,
0.6728311181,
0.3785682917,
-0.0058615771,
0.1148025766,
1.101960063,
-0.6468709111,
-0.4040503502,
-0.7218765616,
0.3506110311,
-0.0979719907,
-0.2310634851,
0.6092720628,
0.687045753,
0.8221831322,
0.2243453264,
0.903137207,
0.6874868274,
0.6009385586,
-0.5209525228,
0.9178059697,
-0.5006657839,
0.3753272593,
-0.0148650296,
-0.3489422798,
-0.4764230549,
0.1780122221,
-0.0548841804,
-0.31344226,
0.759195447,
0.4800000489,
0.0918667093,
0.2004748881,
0.3230696619,
-0.0373012945,
0.5812981129,
0.5817345381,
0.6853922606,
-0.32045573,
0.4539916813,
-0.3948360682,
0.0084495908,
-0.2450906932,
-0.7262927294,
-1.2164007425,
-0.2068066746,
-0.4398708045,
-0.2886222601,
0.1268848032,
0.7814728618,
0.9832020998,
-0.6057513952,
0.1008107886,
-0.026409911,
0.0833629295,
0.1287238151,
-0.0661816299,
0.5645242333,
-0.4336639643,
-0.3968701661,
0.596534133,
0.3168094456,
0.6354897022,
0.01481253,
0.1214022934,
0.2844190598,
0.1204584017,
0.3401538134,
0.0783280805,
-0.3416371942,
-0.3168263733,
-0.322013557,
-0.2217910588,
0.0842721686,
0.9075999856,
-0.6945042014,
0.4486595094,
0.2288227826,
0.8396808505,
0.2611177862,
0.2252796441,
0.5232596993,
-0.9602290988,
0.1968837231,
0.595430851,
0.4579873681,
0.378696233,
-0.7072727084,
0.4273904264,
0.2342640162,
-0.6858216524,
-0.883800745,
0.0349435806,
-1.2042520046,
-0.3957720399,
0.9011334777,
-0.3360244334,
-0.4030153453,
-0.2263098508,
0.1685236841,
0.0796388984,
-0.2314337492,
0.7463653684,
0.2849451005,
-0.2960148156,
0.4766404629,
-0.3151800036,
0.9382246733,
0.511138916,
-1.0410401821,
-0.137199074,
0.3284671605,
0.5174691677,
-0.327075243,
0.4966938198,
-0.1562810987,
0.1042542458,
-0.0481523573,
-0.2050666511,
0.104834877,
-0.4103327394,
-0.2763105035,
0.4101802111,
0.0567040816,
-0.40927881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19484v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19484v2
|
More Compute Is What You Need
| 2024-04-30T12:05:48 | 2024-05-02T01:58:15 |
Zhen Guo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language model pre-training has become increasingly expensive, with
most practitioners relying on scaling laws to allocate compute budgets for
model size and training tokens, commonly referred to as Compute-Optimal or
Chinchilla Optimal. In this paper, we hypothesize a new scaling law that
suggests model performance depends mostly on the amount of compute spent for
transformer-based models, independent of the specific allocation to model size
and dataset size. Using this unified scaling law, we predict that (a) for
inference efficiency, training should prioritize smaller model sizes and larger
training datasets, and (b) assuming the exhaustion of available web datasets,
scaling the model size might be the only way to further improve model
performance.
|
[
-0.3341572285,
-0.3420550525,
0.5287616849,
0.318698138,
-0.0094486866,
-0.3215970695,
-0.4511972964,
-0.3594295979,
0.1154932231,
0.6578422785,
-0.3695210814,
0.4670887887,
-0.6444416046,
-0.1952520162,
-0.4859080315,
0.7290212512,
0.4665932655,
0.2043134719,
-0.4120215476,
0.1796606481,
-0.2114106119,
-0.4747478366,
-0.570820868,
-0.6461002827,
0.3195572495,
0.3136304915,
1.0633866787,
1.0175453424,
0.6905614138,
0.3519657254,
0.0191035382,
-0.3840106428,
-0.5058620572,
-0.2033943236,
-0.0437060744,
-0.944460094,
-0.4071486592,
-0.0023036816,
0.5395867825,
0.757153213,
-0.4405011237,
0.2575697005,
-0.345930934,
0.5530200601,
-0.8903537989,
0.1242381334,
-0.5424951315,
-0.2234973609,
-0.270932436,
0.0949801654,
-0.5987693667,
-0.2144934237,
0.0407440662,
-0.8067926168,
0.2544980645,
0.0054489346,
0.9497561455,
0.5072082281,
-0.3564196527,
-0.1024741679,
-0.6224975586,
0.8912153244,
-0.7981985211,
0.5726677775,
0.3647146523,
0.2987290919,
0.2641814649,
-1.148594141,
-0.5566114187,
-0.3492864966,
-0.21170941,
-0.0499193482,
-0.4509912431,
0.1277095526,
0.5876120329,
0.3315401971,
-0.254214108,
0.5261231661,
-0.3599028289,
-0.1103601456,
0.5646125674,
0.1874981225,
0.4632197022,
0.0099482127,
0.1634740829,
-0.3074809611,
-0.605668664,
-0.0302903503,
0.3042459488,
0.5494149923,
-0.1577026099,
0.369184792,
-0.0157720502,
0.7410296202,
0.1762625426,
-0.1918167323,
0.1451108754,
-0.1694705486,
-0.302893877,
0.0000953481,
0.6989578605,
0.1848073304,
0.5709017515,
-0.1082218662,
-0.0168271884,
-0.0879669562,
0.7544524074,
-1.1987512112,
-0.3577173352,
-0.0123819327,
-0.361105144,
-0.0958453864,
-0.2213835269,
-0.6681286693,
-0.4559208751,
-0.5838452578,
0.4084277153,
0.0200365372,
-0.501077354,
0.0195629578,
-0.1899288893,
0.0991083607,
0.2496658266,
-1.2370769978,
0.3805670142,
0.6360043287,
0.8326064944,
0.2855469286,
-0.304050833,
-0.2900607884,
-0.2745358944,
-0.6153864264,
0.524268806,
-0.5049061775,
-0.1528366059,
-0.0271849222,
0.0705238432,
-0.3010806143,
-0.480902046,
0.53985852,
-0.5630229115,
-0.1525862664,
-0.3614359498,
-0.5783648491,
0.0798779577,
-0.385607779,
-1.0698572397,
0.7460881472,
0.4004917741,
-0.7194798589,
0.4234321713,
-0.7340251207,
-0.8584116697,
0.138790682,
0.0977701992,
-0.4424919486,
0.3965224028,
0.0757636204,
0.5488038063,
-0.9741613269,
0.4419041276,
-0.1727361679,
-0.3276320994,
-0.072752893,
-0.1413134336,
1.0451842546,
0.4354485571,
-0.6020855904,
0.0284201708,
-0.6749991775,
0.1238808855,
0.2197832167,
-0.2839000821,
-0.16945526,
0.2193215787,
0.0143700484,
-0.2121393979,
0.1832728982,
-0.4786663949,
0.0248621199,
-0.292018652,
0.7017490864,
0.6401849985,
-0.5330284238,
0.9232384562,
-0.0690030828,
0.688185513,
-0.336260438,
0.2038264275,
-0.1317083687,
-0.1623336524,
-0.8423730731,
-0.383397311,
0.2781147957,
0.234438017,
-0.1963521093,
0.1234494671,
-0.4224003851,
-0.5849898458,
-0.5012186766,
-0.1833757758,
0.2689133584,
0.3497552872,
0.340919733,
-0.047260724,
-0.7497448921,
-1.0226467848,
-0.1408207119,
0.1607679427,
-0.0031925768,
0.3234194815,
0.4508072734,
-0.0785094649,
0.981428802,
-0.5700989962,
-0.0187012404,
-0.4952511787,
-0.1286561638,
0.3750796616,
0.4501512945,
0.7234821916,
-0.9540647268,
-0.6252559423,
0.1162502319,
-0.4235331416,
-0.0749332756,
-0.1834766418,
0.066681698,
-0.1314368695,
0.7400830388,
-0.6045120955,
0.0451948419,
0.5734635592,
0.2221945226,
0.5293574929,
-0.3585674763,
-0.1837893277,
-0.7439954877,
0.0197557397,
-0.042888537,
-0.1695139408,
-0.6997655034,
0.431230545,
0.4162516594,
-0.0759124309,
-0.1745200753,
0.440309912,
-0.5272126198,
0.0445260927,
-0.307416141,
-0.1307336539,
-0.1481938064,
0.4053634703,
0.1108150631,
1.0918092728,
0.6525714993,
-0.6139527559,
0.2323134392,
-0.1805547327,
-0.4707018733,
0.4487885833,
-0.8893068433,
-0.1690267771,
0.0573312528,
0.2060090005,
-0.5806533694,
-0.4890949726,
-0.6887997389,
-0.2995037735,
0.4730163515,
-0.0711250976,
-0.2721332312,
-0.650360465,
-0.1494834572,
0.1907621771,
0.7126760483,
-0.8147274256,
0.9306157231,
0.759580791,
0.3027217984,
-0.6768254638,
-0.8167331815,
-0.2052158862,
-0.0986237004,
-0.5024966598,
0.2206769437,
0.0771572515,
-0.1828567684,
-0.1006390601,
0.276293695,
-0.405421257,
0.1813508272,
0.3080254495,
-0.0329137594,
-0.6296700239,
0.0796031207,
-0.207332015,
0.0926144868,
0.3101509511,
-0.3549686968,
0.8536035419,
-0.2182162255,
-0.1718300283,
-0.3874481916,
0.001645162,
0.7908725739,
-0.2765351832,
0.8471701741,
0.3787616193,
-0.2704995871,
-0.0141717819,
-0.645255208,
-0.0058346987,
-0.5183659196,
0.7573933005,
-0.4561502934,
-0.5696937442,
0.4838083386,
-0.1297211349,
0.0804807395,
0.816945672,
0.769284904,
0.1571109891,
0.9948376417,
0.8552672267,
-0.4954151213,
0.6203802228,
-0.2837084234,
0.2621495128,
-0.759359777,
0.0352266431,
-0.8544427752,
-0.0242922921,
-0.8040376902,
-0.4289121628,
-0.04602338,
-0.2065862119,
-0.7270174026,
0.6463788152,
-0.5178186297,
0.7832333446,
0.8053731918,
0.073834613,
0.0240139998,
-0.1261300743,
0.0569284447,
-0.0010710642,
-0.9077084661,
0.0153042395,
1.2436088324,
0.0709070191,
0.8417623639,
-0.0335547887,
0.3903502822,
-0.0767609924,
0.358296454,
-0.8767974973,
0.2811314166,
-0.2165070474,
-0.9158668518,
-0.5578551292,
-0.7172452211,
-1.2560577393,
0.2816488147,
0.0192444697,
-0.5957867503,
0.0414664075,
0.1796923578,
-0.2930586636,
0.488735348,
-0.8022867441,
0.8371184468,
-0.1424730122,
-0.1834220439,
-0.5126563311,
-0.5779901743,
0.2184774876,
-0.2182869017,
0.4340033531,
0.1802113503,
0.1081121191,
0.8474737406,
-0.6707904339,
0.73170048,
-0.2243361473,
0.1846751422,
0.4484937787,
-0.2095988244,
0.4537986815,
-0.4475385547,
-0.0409319922,
0.0146711078,
-0.0914892182,
-0.5573936701,
-0.3908639848,
0.3791882098,
-1.0559651852,
-0.4644066393,
-0.1495465785,
-0.4317996502,
-0.1310641766,
0.3297609687,
0.7795369625,
0.4606564641,
-0.0999287292,
0.55581671,
0.6276661754,
-0.0062094498,
0.4896547198,
0.3734946847,
-0.0526282974,
-0.1096680388,
0.8440917134,
0.3773562014,
0.3826184273,
0.4650995731,
0.5242651701,
-0.2205466777,
-0.4270682335,
-0.2506309152,
0.2707402706,
-0.5747023821,
-0.2370810211,
-0.7282787561,
-0.3555645049,
-0.5225874186,
-0.4855101705,
-0.9526615143,
-0.3964321017,
-0.2418216169,
0.0504755452,
0.3116745353,
0.5256887674,
-0.229102999,
0.8675373197,
-0.2167322636,
0.2084711492,
0.2687284052,
0.3911654651,
0.3921456635,
-0.913171649,
-0.5070524216,
0.0217356645,
-0.1365904808,
-0.2887185514,
0.2371816188,
0.2636675239,
0.7147663236,
0.4183801115,
-0.1377043575,
0.7441840768,
-0.7752323151,
0.4688894153,
0.6122336388,
-0.9799930453,
0.2009282559,
-0.1836273223,
0.3878529668,
0.3855029643,
0.4443349242,
-0.3644853234,
-0.2386070192,
-0.8481267691,
-0.7967990041,
0.7813643217,
-0.1825554669,
0.8385586739,
0.2027022541,
0.419097811,
-0.2728982568,
0.1527526826,
-0.7696207166,
-0.132781148,
-0.1615336984,
-0.0561961643,
-0.1181242466,
-0.1358289421,
0.1629984975,
-0.4548994601,
0.5908319354,
-0.2371281087,
0.2735547125,
-0.3629259467,
-0.2301522791,
-0.0757898241,
-0.0025640607,
0.3606734276,
0.8591664433,
0.1647254229,
-0.0782621577,
0.1206983104,
-0.7919441462,
0.1590359658,
-0.1772140563,
-0.1978787631,
-0.3315103054,
0.5041731,
1.0151326656,
0.2798640728,
-0.6905776262,
0.684330821,
0.0495935343,
-0.3204772472,
-0.2061254084,
0.3819420934,
0.4350678027,
0.1876554191,
0.2324726284,
0.0542887449,
-0.0593311489,
-0.3844299614,
0.2034432888,
0.3131407797,
-0.1215601116,
-0.1663639843,
0.7670139074,
0.0127292927,
-0.3548930287,
0.8344418406,
0.1326269507,
-0.5897504091,
0.8316400647,
0.6465243101,
0.5280381441,
-0.5355989337,
0.1322315037,
0.712051034,
0.5008667707,
-0.6134339571,
-0.1792812198,
-0.0201999675,
-0.6623046994,
-0.604945004,
-0.6455670595,
-0.4376380444,
0.0247810148,
-0.8211263418,
0.269559294,
-0.5489879847,
-0.3352404535,
0.2941349447,
-0.0395727158,
-0.7445343137,
0.5353831649,
-0.0865443498,
0.5948001146,
-0.5828939676,
0.7393335104,
0.2290559709,
-0.3563928008,
-1.0411350727,
-0.4550310969,
-0.0845893845,
-1.0189198256,
0.5657770038,
0.0229549389,
-0.1797179878,
-0.0584366135,
-0.4346800745,
-1.2021328211,
0.8420904875,
0.9037887454,
-0.7954825163,
-0.1875294596,
-0.063532196,
0.6273439527,
-0.3332708478,
0.5679842234,
0.6894522905,
0.2345902622,
0.132756114,
-1.0350356102,
-0.0654051453,
-0.0766582862,
-0.0123345163,
0.5590008497,
-0.773911953,
1.2283748388,
-0.5090315342,
-0.098458603,
-0.2411100417,
0.5729925632,
-0.4546586871,
-0.1504963338,
0.5328315496,
0.5928015113,
1.091080904,
0.0887842476,
1.4729542732,
-0.2595042884,
0.5275965929,
1.3859021664,
-0.1366705894,
0.8340757489,
0.0610029474,
-0.7068173289,
0.4417216778,
0.6326419711,
-0.2486929893,
0.2425534278,
0.3901830614,
0.256786108,
-0.2564530373,
-0.0957166776,
-0.308855623,
0.5248932242,
-0.0519099124,
-0.3780168891,
0.0067223324,
-0.0784290805,
0.4154224992,
-0.0913918018,
-0.3084560931,
0.5457469821,
-0.193059355,
-0.7272045016,
0.6637574434,
-0.1262159199,
0.5179809928,
-0.6693580151,
0.6384989619,
-0.1208257675,
0.3144520223,
-0.120109044,
-0.2628368735,
0.0787508041,
-0.0041539459,
-0.2685729265,
-0.019266203,
0.3869633079,
0.0261161625,
-0.7167951465,
0.403124243,
0.2426163256,
0.1293344051,
-0.3008473217,
-0.3997458816,
-0.2630746067,
-0.03121447,
-0.5789307952,
0.5828280449,
0.1328303516,
-0.0468305424,
0.7220950127,
0.7016441226,
0.3264744282,
0.2836768031,
0.3762223721,
0.8418260813,
-0.3530564904,
-0.690566361,
-0.911174953,
0.3206279874,
-0.3414542675,
-0.1827249229,
0.5383667946,
0.58209759,
0.6277961731,
0.2330944538,
0.7224316597,
-0.1847317219,
0.2830713391,
-0.2589372098,
0.6634623408,
-0.8799421191,
-0.1661476493,
-0.1355871409,
-0.7515150309,
-0.0866487995,
0.7774723768,
-0.2177663296,
0.0920468196,
0.6585028768,
0.6588061452,
-0.2337369472,
0.3359103799,
0.3412496746,
0.1283074766,
0.222776562,
0.3559182286,
0.3071163595,
-0.1974126548,
0.3039985001,
-0.3487449288,
-0.4138483405,
-0.1500378698,
-0.7450358272,
-0.739097774,
-0.6354872584,
-0.2175455093,
-0.150347203,
-0.4211435318,
0.5986584425,
1.1226587296,
-0.6707186103,
-0.5955892205,
-0.2556135058,
-0.13962695,
-0.244941324,
-0.1564790308,
0.3410324454,
-0.7587835789,
-0.7499133945,
-0.0447449014,
-0.0176730417,
-0.2122036964,
-0.0729153678,
0.0677297935,
-0.1098475233,
0.4207796156,
0.6122117043,
0.2339691818,
-0.4447596669,
0.1075152308,
0.1050934047,
-0.2781723142,
0.2789276242,
1.3412437439,
-0.3731100559,
0.5412980318,
0.2149906605,
0.9742170572,
0.9885292053,
-0.4140104353,
0.6552881598,
-0.2954944968,
0.2957346439,
0.0854635611,
0.4123682976,
0.1663273275,
-0.4923356175,
0.6442617774,
-0.0976346508,
-0.6602104902,
-0.8381336331,
0.0619847886,
-0.4917694032,
-0.4326386452,
0.8346509933,
-0.2046566755,
-0.3420320451,
0.3082374036,
0.0843013376,
0.1932928264,
-0.1441390067,
0.350540936,
0.7184358835,
-0.1916729063,
-0.1822160035,
-0.7833856344,
0.4435659349,
0.5578780174,
-0.8318373561,
0.355389148,
0.3282292485,
0.1525210887,
0.339967072,
0.6956850886,
0.163763687,
0.1421236247,
0.4624112248,
-0.0516996384,
0.1948388815,
-0.2526322305,
-0.0791829824,
0.3010851741,
0.0171662904,
0.300060153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19482v1
|
FactCheck Editor: Multilingual Text Editor with End-to-End fact-checking
| 2024-04-30T11:55:20 | 2024-04-30T11:55:20 |
Vinay Setty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce 'FactCheck Editor', an advanced text editor designed to automate
fact-checking and correct factual inaccuracies. Given the widespread issue of
misinformation, often a result of unintentional mistakes by content creators,
our tool aims to address this challenge. It supports over 90 languages and
utilizes transformer models to assist humans in the labor-intensive process of
fact verification. This demonstration showcases a complete workflow that
detects text claims in need of verification, generates relevant search engine
queries, and retrieves appropriate documents from the web. It employs Natural
Language Inference (NLI) to predict the veracity of claims and uses LLMs to
summarize the evidence and suggest textual revisions to correct any errors in
the text. Additionally, the effectiveness of models used in claim detection and
veracity assessment is evaluated across multiple languages.
|
[
-0.1135649458,
-0.8332226872,
0.7184116244,
0.1357664466,
-0.0416106768,
0.3315834701,
0.0074672448,
-0.5522254705,
0.2134260088,
0.6246255636,
-0.5239223242,
-0.5549313426,
-0.6152080297,
0.5300015807,
-0.5154408216,
1.1600840092,
-0.3510877192,
-0.1753839999,
-0.437179327,
-0.0555056743,
-0.2011901289,
-0.2645602524,
-0.5816152692,
-0.3271631598,
0.4321862161,
0.6105787158,
0.7315759659,
0.3205299675,
0.2828231752,
0.4152691066,
0.0228324551,
0.5069245696,
-0.2051962763,
-0.0801451951,
-0.3329297304,
-0.7994054556,
-0.4707918167,
0.0651505888,
0.1677994132,
0.0947706923,
-0.0754328147,
0.2324219942,
-0.3958837688,
0.4324638546,
-0.772290647,
0.0960874334,
-0.4521449804,
0.0004644513,
0.0533130169,
-0.0240859613,
-0.5459596515,
-0.9024270177,
-0.0707984418,
-0.464158833,
0.4583925605,
0.0849386007,
1.0034565926,
0.4254470468,
-0.8837978244,
-0.3933280706,
-0.514419198,
0.4589397311,
-0.6760898829,
0.5933991075,
0.4015964866,
0.246789515,
0.0770341456,
-0.6614798307,
-0.9158769846,
-0.0545590967,
-0.4606193006,
0.3167474568,
-0.2345786095,
0.0326589383,
0.3929896057,
0.2270508409,
-0.6185180545,
-0.0316082053,
-0.3242366612,
-0.7396615148,
0.7957823277,
-0.1032711938,
0.5254318714,
-0.2338931412,
-0.1198250204,
0.0302471556,
-0.693132937,
-0.0349466875,
0.4855717719,
-0.2158991098,
-0.252464503,
0.7266865969,
-0.4493691325,
0.612463057,
-0.1206113547,
-0.4634813368,
0.173851639,
-0.6233857274,
-0.3750362396,
0.4396221042,
0.7745696306,
0.4587682188,
-0.2988173962,
-0.242085889,
-0.1659367532,
0.1367332786,
0.1032108143,
-0.6063269973,
-0.0991033688,
0.447052151,
-0.1401506811,
-0.4753628373,
0.1550601721,
-0.7583320141,
-0.5654725432,
-0.2106923014,
0.4478583634,
-0.1342361867,
-0.0675955787,
0.3236461878,
-0.3344954252,
-0.1581618041,
0.6206744313,
-0.3667759001,
-0.0971628502,
0.3166740835,
0.7253600955,
0.01391018,
-0.2963163257,
-0.4627584219,
-0.028456999,
-0.4687891304,
1.0891284943,
-0.2276101559,
-0.1131410748,
0.1567489505,
0.2477401495,
0.1513802558,
-0.1980187893,
1.2613836527,
-0.7058750391,
0.4509999454,
-0.2539652586,
-0.4997845888,
-0.5354241133,
0.5584651828,
-1.1029208899,
1.1125682592,
-0.0899514258,
-0.8756645918,
0.3023096919,
-0.771056056,
-0.325299412,
-0.0345881917,
0.0961228982,
-0.6573668718,
-0.0246634483,
0.2525309622,
0.2324835807,
-0.2739076316,
0.595862031,
0.0484764427,
0.1633484513,
0.4088758528,
-0.5039920807,
0.9526656866,
0.0586690158,
-0.3106393516,
0.2668310702,
-0.9996227026,
-0.2934719324,
0.0378685109,
-0.6169935465,
-0.105951719,
0.1171960682,
0.0758846402,
0.2396748215,
0.3658513129,
-1.0454484224,
0.1198380068,
-0.1561865062,
0.1229353845,
0.2888030708,
0.2115256339,
-0.1488387138,
-0.3368306458,
0.3304130733,
0.0482693687,
0.191106081,
-0.2635298967,
-0.3527719378,
-1.0615708828,
-0.1754825264,
0.5526117086,
0.9957708716,
-0.8922994137,
0.6024209261,
-0.2877938747,
-0.5359657407,
-0.4699399471,
0.1590573788,
0.1525397003,
0.630861938,
0.2418820113,
0.2084487677,
-0.7584489584,
-0.9785192013,
-0.595728457,
-0.1227268726,
0.0931216925,
-0.3465538621,
0.8494542837,
-0.5548030734,
1.2250132561,
-0.5950422883,
-0.0068056374,
-0.2332539111,
0.3624604046,
0.1619870514,
-0.0340117589,
0.4184740484,
-0.8609939814,
-0.4962418079,
0.1517116874,
-0.7853470445,
-0.3055733442,
-0.4520556331,
0.0089120977,
0.4749471843,
0.3520338833,
-0.7732630968,
0.4769058228,
0.6729233265,
-0.5185759664,
0.7138698697,
-0.1820150465,
0.431876868,
-0.8828095198,
0.1102665365,
0.078374438,
-0.6326281428,
-0.4975609481,
0.0393855721,
0.5074527264,
0.1036017016,
-0.4506964982,
0.2755251229,
-0.3369910717,
0.2941981852,
-0.22476013,
-0.0038555232,
0.3913230002,
0.314078927,
-0.0510891043,
0.973988831,
0.3151489794,
-0.5749374628,
0.6722897887,
0.3146383166,
-0.4074008763,
0.4974398017,
-0.5884125829,
-0.1466333568,
-0.104000926,
0.3219037652,
-0.9594678879,
-0.413279444,
-0.0910658017,
-0.3465958834,
0.0463602208,
0.0402999669,
-0.8417313099,
-0.3058780134,
-0.3933226764,
-0.2838406265,
-0.0946882218,
-0.7256442904,
0.820961535,
0.4141591489,
-0.102757521,
-0.6397200227,
-0.6545516849,
0.4513975382,
0.2579633594,
-0.5648970604,
0.121161066,
-0.1308486611,
-0.3970756233,
0.0532049276,
-0.1843401343,
-0.3666298091,
0.1024815515,
-0.0555198267,
0.4650444686,
0.0036266418,
0.0995176136,
0.2991814911,
-0.1294019967,
0.2508257329,
0.085592553,
-0.1300369054,
-0.0082561942,
-0.604724288,
-0.3498370945,
0.3706174493,
0.7848464847,
-0.4003159404,
0.581543386,
0.4699490964,
-0.4706153274,
0.1293519735,
-1.0048230886,
0.1526605487,
-0.4054045081,
0.4230570495,
-0.1711508781,
-0.880666852,
0.4532271922,
-0.2056589425,
0.4547601938,
0.8972474933,
0.4793613255,
0.1619459242,
0.7421811819,
0.691100359,
0.1221767887,
-0.1396383494,
-0.0552095324,
0.4366677403,
-0.2828090489,
-0.3013694286,
-0.602914989,
0.1418108791,
-0.536628902,
-0.3631104231,
0.613373518,
-0.3216607571,
0.1029082239,
0.2444619238,
-0.2174453288,
0.8598492742,
0.3405089676,
0.0803534016,
0.7024345398,
-0.2556606829,
0.1060645878,
-0.0110028731,
-0.4879164398,
-0.5520324707,
0.8531133533,
0.2691910267,
0.6786461473,
0.5085572004,
0.4173688889,
0.5306869745,
0.4781309366,
-0.641119957,
0.1894862205,
0.1378852129,
-0.8084774613,
-0.1899596453,
-0.0490184985,
-0.3884451985,
0.1664254665,
-0.4956339598,
-0.2992884219,
0.2268717438,
0.2623135149,
-0.3938584626,
0.5600121617,
-0.8319174647,
0.7801178098,
-0.3850958347,
-0.384173274,
-0.3454388082,
-0.5036059022,
0.597571969,
-0.2751150131,
0.4646397233,
0.1692334563,
0.0178043339,
0.3857941329,
-0.3067265749,
1.0267692804,
0.1712625772,
-0.3457250595,
0.3353962302,
0.268425107,
0.7468469739,
0.3504332304,
0.013155573,
0.2321130633,
-0.118217878,
-0.0234742537,
-0.5249950886,
0.3933438957,
-0.7104303837,
-0.4360053539,
-0.6322537065,
-0.2609389126,
-0.0697414428,
0.3940314651,
0.2460414916,
0.4005505741,
-0.5617135167,
-0.0265917536,
0.9533780813,
-0.3159106672,
0.4279922843,
0.9640125632,
-0.2566714585,
-0.2924179137,
0.7171984315,
-0.0048220647,
-0.0435262397,
0.7709411383,
0.2039107531,
-0.4753614068,
-0.2604809403,
-0.7096149921,
0.1995526701,
-0.8660211563,
-0.4454233944,
-0.9469629526,
-0.1933065355,
-0.2156502753,
-0.0915546343,
-0.43098104,
-0.5666418672,
0.110149391,
-0.4132214785,
0.4785405099,
0.9756729603,
-0.115373455,
0.2888865173,
-0.7988251448,
0.6831965446,
0.5848727226,
0.4972912967,
-0.7329451442,
-0.310804069,
-0.5194271207,
-0.0594147034,
-0.4834226072,
-1.2783619165,
0.086642459,
0.1659070551,
0.4450636506,
0.2198602855,
-0.1058808938,
0.1802923679,
-0.5661300421,
0.9328426123,
0.1186291203,
-1.0656137466,
0.5602429509,
0.0936196148,
0.1798779815,
0.4781920612,
0.5122147202,
-0.6936607957,
-0.4718176723,
-0.6069310904,
-0.3583731949,
0.6126055717,
0.0208283886,
-0.3248685896,
0.1109747291,
0.127848655,
0.2700470686,
0.1294792593,
-0.6889796257,
-0.3625670671,
-0.4830195904,
-0.2361910492,
0.1211000681,
-0.718677938,
-0.5189151168,
-0.084584184,
1.1067237854,
-0.4023265839,
0.0451704375,
0.5528113842,
-0.4942380786,
-0.1645247638,
0.8066802025,
0.8378762007,
0.9313691258,
-0.1673874855,
0.389757365,
0.5049290657,
-0.4728379846,
0.1918714345,
0.0745040551,
-0.3802675009,
0.4752779305,
0.3830063343,
0.7419953346,
0.2154752314,
-0.6483072639,
0.5803579688,
-0.3110966086,
-0.2595181167,
-0.2413680106,
-0.0705552623,
0.1932707131,
-0.0251261313,
0.2112221718,
0.3309077322,
0.3859707415,
-0.3036795259,
0.2103715092,
0.1116239503,
0.0326893814,
-0.3168934286,
0.6593189836,
0.3628668487,
-0.1996317953,
0.2318849266,
-0.3149955869,
-0.8728109002,
0.5288507938,
0.3970802128,
1.0073555708,
-0.1646921635,
0.4026987255,
0.4928568602,
0.7899514437,
-0.0930381268,
0.1331732422,
0.3213947713,
-0.7902797461,
-0.9398619533,
-0.323969394,
-0.6319069266,
0.1650632024,
-0.2401864082,
0.3583279252,
-0.0858699977,
-0.0273201335,
0.2785081863,
-0.0670393258,
-0.6532887816,
0.3410870731,
-0.087774463,
1.0741615295,
-1.080440402,
0.6181537509,
0.6853897572,
-0.3570939302,
-0.4785577357,
-0.1799073368,
0.4845268726,
-0.5407719016,
0.5320160985,
-0.0534805283,
-0.4506391585,
-0.3064790964,
-0.8814777136,
-0.7900968194,
0.8489663005,
0.6027921438,
-0.5903468728,
0.2994490862,
0.1198167726,
0.3532319665,
0.0576146692,
0.5384963751,
0.6970230341,
0.6415358186,
-0.2224150449,
-0.9474412203,
-0.0278495718,
-0.1041090712,
-0.4628764689,
0.0693159252,
-0.5484701991,
0.6608652472,
-0.228418991,
-0.2207892835,
-0.5250003934,
0.6500014067,
-0.1734706163,
0.1450920105,
0.6459459066,
0.6557940245,
0.8608376384,
0.0107695637,
0.9699051976,
-0.506513834,
0.5029957294,
1.0758556128,
-0.1841032952,
0.3253070116,
0.1977346241,
-0.1865156889,
0.7603689432,
0.437951237,
0.0223993082,
-0.0539806858,
-0.5738734603,
-0.2975923717,
-0.2888838053,
-0.2383864969,
0.0651937276,
0.5061123371,
0.2920773625,
0.1021456197,
-0.3954840302,
-0.3233225644,
0.2971379161,
0.1388686299,
0.0196495894,
0.7488698959,
-0.5182299614,
-0.7497038841,
0.1769644767,
0.3126784563,
0.6080302,
-0.7243237495,
-0.2303079814,
-0.1079448536,
-0.1543454826,
-0.5195049047,
-1.0318176746,
0.4685732424,
0.320843637,
-0.4864209294,
-0.0441884473,
0.8444337249,
-0.6713167429,
-0.5819469094,
-0.0838411301,
0.5016244054,
-0.1916543096,
-0.1317484379,
-0.7028331757,
0.1304131299,
0.1910251379,
-0.0480457656,
-0.2228489965,
0.5170173049,
-0.0557901524,
0.6349415183,
0.6887652874,
0.0736332834,
-0.1136344448,
0.0697122365,
0.5093390942,
-0.3925863504,
-0.6540215611,
-0.9127569795,
0.6835374832,
-0.3947995603,
-0.1555958092,
0.8177492023,
1.0069247484,
0.7246743441,
-0.2235557884,
1.1561139822,
-0.1281712651,
0.6573857069,
-0.5208098292,
0.7765221,
-0.4094706178,
-0.2154696733,
0.110176146,
-0.4128018618,
-0.3612318039,
0.2837272882,
0.0946130827,
-0.5124674439,
0.9813185334,
0.8136401772,
-0.1054777503,
0.252181083,
0.267909199,
0.3780034781,
0.3622986674,
0.1037024781,
0.5445996523,
-0.6015316248,
0.3983355463,
-0.2283031791,
-0.1842562109,
-0.1732255667,
-1.0818454027,
-0.8222181797,
-0.3548503518,
-0.6582849622,
-0.3133451939,
-0.2923963368,
0.9666455984,
0.3720010519,
-1.0538779497,
0.0056428639,
0.177659139,
0.6573756933,
-0.0288112927,
-0.1993045658,
0.4179547429,
-0.2076043487,
-0.5945934653,
0.2885872424,
0.3417485058,
-0.0773331672,
-0.310462445,
0.139040336,
-0.4680324197,
0.2699034214,
0.6937408447,
0.2322889268,
-0.7111808658,
-0.2963992655,
-0.2033233494,
-0.1493477523,
0.0897086635,
0.9729042053,
-0.4529588223,
0.7941914201,
0.5114632845,
0.8117865324,
0.2072957605,
-0.2440680861,
0.3128855526,
-0.7954408526,
0.0975737572,
-0.2730077505,
0.5405493379,
0.575789094,
-0.7366035581,
0.5057052374,
0.3517195582,
-0.5350661278,
-0.6871268153,
0.2070216238,
-0.7710803151,
-0.1344492882,
0.7538281679,
0.0362827294,
-0.3650097251,
-0.4182952046,
-0.3863612711,
0.451762557,
-0.2270660996,
0.8846065998,
1.0025062561,
0.0513792522,
-0.1091181263,
-0.8366401792,
0.6742588282,
0.0912029073,
-1.1779695749,
0.1310256869,
0.557354033,
0.3915404379,
0.3867860436,
0.3965744376,
0.0905614793,
0.4802218974,
-0.1212815344,
0.5977522731,
0.0136519112,
-0.2174214423,
-0.2033957392,
-0.1230558902,
-0.1517952234,
0.0444469638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19442v1
|
Which Nigerian-Pidgin does Generative AI speak?: Issues about Representativeness and Bias for Multilingual and Low Resource Languages
| 2024-04-30T10:45:40 | 2024-04-30T10:45:40 |
David Ifeoluwa Adelani, A. Seza Doğruöz, Iyanuoluwa Shode, Anuoluwapo Aremu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Naija is the Nigerian-Pidgin spoken by approx. 120M speakers in Nigeria and
it is a mixed language (e.g., English, Portuguese and Indigenous languages).
Although it has mainly been a spoken language until recently, there are
currently two written genres (BBC and Wikipedia) in Naija. Through statistical
analyses and Machine Translation experiments, we prove that these two genres do
not represent each other (i.e., there are linguistic differences in word order
and vocabulary) and Generative AI operates only based on Naija written in the
BBC genre. In other words, Naija written in Wikipedia genre is not represented
in Generative AI.
|
[
-0.8324673176,
-0.7917695642,
0.143612951,
0.6751561761,
-0.0719219521,
0.277050823,
-0.5271561742,
-0.6134208441,
0.7885844111,
0.5772024393,
-0.7553893328,
-0.3211168051,
-0.6190875769,
0.6814310551,
-0.29996714,
1.0109932423,
0.1800357252,
0.2005662918,
-0.1355869174,
-0.3294033706,
-0.3454293907,
-0.4649266005,
-0.5457559824,
-0.1484681964,
0.1818662733,
0.3339115381,
0.95302248,
0.1900399774,
0.3152890503,
0.3626995087,
-0.1669781506,
0.0630790666,
-0.3856016099,
0.3066000938,
-0.1635401249,
-0.5715575218,
-0.2107987702,
-0.0467460528,
0.450684011,
0.706343174,
-0.2307443917,
-0.0742392391,
-0.1090524569,
0.4677234888,
-0.5433030725,
0.1055320054,
-0.5808125734,
0.0743011087,
-0.4508537948,
0.1626975387,
-0.1382969618,
-0.1075698286,
-0.0903483108,
-0.8079392314,
0.4359423816,
-0.2533119023,
0.6673879623,
0.4822353125,
-0.3932655156,
-0.8286585808,
-0.4521244764,
0.7644156218,
-0.3822387159,
0.079811424,
0.6358994842,
0.2856296599,
-0.36044994,
-0.3823383749,
-0.7964221835,
-0.3050111532,
-0.0586169548,
0.1634472609,
-0.0916328579,
-0.1203912273,
0.226281777,
0.610050559,
-0.4219536483,
0.2073626816,
-0.5882023573,
-0.3831857741,
0.8839378357,
-0.1615950167,
0.3325657845,
-0.4001215696,
-0.2131703794,
0.1582856625,
-0.6261065006,
-0.2509355843,
0.8979034424,
0.2943280339,
-0.2662020922,
0.4775615335,
-0.2109833211,
0.9674156308,
0.1722639054,
-0.5533635616,
0.4529087543,
-0.0952544585,
0.160084784,
0.3655659258,
1.3361246586,
0.1974999905,
0.1503943801,
-0.1931652129,
-0.1737772673,
0.2333399504,
0.2641128302,
-0.4924143255,
-0.1853220612,
0.1150762439,
-0.3317673504,
-0.0082468912,
-0.1848397255,
-0.7344407439,
-0.4789907932,
0.2036595494,
0.1342917085,
-0.2138752192,
-0.4746299684,
-0.3363804221,
0.0741478652,
0.0346212313,
0.1310174018,
-1.1153440475,
-0.0434135273,
0.4145561159,
0.7903180122,
-0.1958933175,
-0.0776907504,
-0.0129150068,
-0.2429087758,
-0.3649676144,
0.7768493295,
-0.4294236004,
-0.5778340697,
-0.0902283117,
-0.0157317799,
-0.0034892077,
-0.6433581114,
0.5719840527,
-0.3705928624,
0.4197824001,
-0.0273235757,
0.0614692122,
-0.2052934766,
-0.1478411853,
-0.850559175,
0.8993835449,
0.3598952293,
-0.6168378592,
0.4919399023,
-0.6058908701,
-0.4431762695,
0.1338284761,
-0.5192290545,
-0.2299452275,
-0.0236290693,
0.191362232,
0.2941018641,
-0.0649855733,
0.4663929045,
-0.1994539946,
-0.2923275232,
0.3057707846,
-0.6053361893,
1.0526070595,
0.3477104008,
-0.3369185627,
-0.0427287184,
-0.8540357351,
-0.2081269175,
-0.1343312413,
-0.4809621871,
-0.1713460386,
-0.1332381964,
0.3115864694,
0.4071014524,
0.2208985686,
-0.9253619313,
0.4323166013,
-0.5317990184,
0.6587274671,
0.3477470577,
-0.0785688385,
0.571157515,
-0.3064992726,
0.9374166727,
0.0748024732,
-0.2895618677,
0.0637069196,
-1.005797267,
-0.4926488101,
-0.35997504,
0.6514274478,
0.5364194512,
-1.2975814342,
-0.0107304901,
0.0033923059,
-0.203957051,
-1.0146074295,
0.1956064403,
0.2166005224,
0.2478487939,
0.2334678918,
-0.1579430401,
-0.470741421,
-1.2581951618,
-0.0642546788,
-0.175956592,
0.0375828892,
0.0112699587,
0.418862462,
-0.2692402005,
0.5696725845,
0.2010876536,
-0.4427674711,
-0.353644073,
0.2219201475,
0.5298563838,
0.1665479541,
1.0575066805,
-0.9886346459,
-0.8384103775,
0.02551491,
-0.7136112452,
-0.2205341011,
-0.2458637506,
0.059326984,
0.3815132976,
0.3534276485,
-0.2151177078,
0.476531148,
1.1296682358,
-0.1507758498,
0.1836120337,
0.0366391838,
-0.0130511643,
-1.0976041555,
-0.3579975367,
-0.101765193,
-0.0955801606,
-0.4927938879,
-0.0549534522,
-0.2348717302,
-0.0773127601,
-0.2789929807,
0.6646121144,
-0.6691603661,
-0.0952407643,
-0.3650230765,
0.2346525192,
-0.4319299459,
0.3723326921,
0.4706402719,
1.3859344721,
0.7146576643,
-0.6295024157,
0.4484411478,
0.4474871159,
-0.6194284558,
0.7951596379,
-0.5266205668,
-0.1107041165,
-0.1512715667,
0.1157868728,
-0.7246530652,
-0.4541479349,
0.7699024677,
-0.4321275353,
0.4863525629,
-0.2072120905,
-0.2252120972,
-0.2035842389,
0.3525191545,
0.3707888424,
-0.0254773926,
-0.251128763,
0.4571280479,
0.7805017829,
-0.55727005,
-1.0488249063,
-0.8965955973,
0.2560767531,
-0.0850170255,
-0.570853889,
0.3740547895,
0.1651715934,
-0.3927996159,
0.1014018953,
0.1812464595,
-0.2901184857,
0.1725304723,
0.6192697287,
-0.1488389522,
-0.4466352761,
0.0467194766,
0.3290265203,
0.0683683231,
-0.0380819179,
0.1151543632,
0.6317355037,
-0.1467725337,
-0.1137856245,
-0.2774869204,
0.6397407651,
0.411111325,
-0.110656105,
1.0981408358,
0.6144965291,
-0.0350307412,
-0.1506278515,
-0.1537638754,
0.0137199685,
-0.355646044,
0.3266179264,
-0.6597309709,
-0.6740489006,
0.5943491459,
0.2396946102,
-0.0537082292,
0.8489449024,
0.8359674811,
-0.2367150187,
0.5213109255,
0.378167659,
-0.0355652459,
0.3350199163,
-0.4565691948,
-0.007920173,
-0.9613749385,
-0.2400470078,
-0.674510181,
-0.5425009131,
-1.3758454323,
0.0330849923,
0.541651547,
0.076091893,
-0.0030020354,
0.3799200356,
-0.3568334877,
0.262784481,
0.7239670753,
0.0515405163,
0.2439282835,
0.3720397353,
-0.0370953716,
-0.0738675371,
-1.1476565599,
-0.5608243346,
1.3461816311,
-0.0015561741,
0.5381116271,
0.3720608056,
0.7640491128,
0.3930771649,
0.6386643052,
-0.8116833568,
0.0024558224,
-0.0371205136,
-1.1305221319,
-0.4163729548,
-0.4630838335,
-1.0097588301,
0.4645214379,
-0.4909307659,
-0.5149397254,
0.779976368,
-0.0872295275,
-0.086841248,
0.3513862193,
-0.308269769,
0.7130147815,
-0.1093305573,
-0.1532315314,
0.1061105356,
-0.5302693248,
0.5660826564,
-0.0161146466,
0.4849460423,
0.0440999903,
0.2309588641,
0.8236293793,
-0.3138712645,
0.5263911486,
0.0585592054,
-0.3086747229,
0.5350301266,
-0.0349116884,
-0.1624619365,
0.2615275383,
-0.4203541875,
0.6674464345,
0.0635090843,
-0.7215092182,
-0.1057301611,
0.6755981445,
-1.0435202122,
-0.5140981674,
-0.8446540833,
-0.4555900991,
-0.2433613092,
0.118842572,
0.7754432559,
0.2545129061,
-0.4225252271,
0.4719974995,
0.4493015409,
-0.4331635535,
0.4549163282,
0.0720405206,
-0.1420476288,
-0.5368086696,
0.8392657042,
0.1072145477,
0.1742948592,
0.2532389462,
-0.2701697648,
-0.4404464364,
-0.2641585767,
-1.0309836864,
0.3812634945,
-0.4707314372,
0.019263301,
-0.6257876754,
-0.1261859536,
-0.1900169402,
0.0197549183,
-0.2604464591,
-0.6651902199,
-0.2024942338,
0.1697189957,
0.0854232907,
0.9383108616,
-0.2341923118,
0.7726700306,
-0.202754572,
0.6719808578,
0.0150734782,
0.1015325785,
-0.4005883336,
-0.5836899877,
-0.0724351928,
0.5087599754,
-0.3098214269,
-1.1994843483,
0.3897190094,
0.4463199675,
0.7142974138,
0.5344629288,
0.0197537988,
0.1128116101,
-0.0586779676,
0.6384032965,
0.1956127435,
-0.5607658625,
0.2153187394,
-0.2220343351,
0.1182206497,
0.4741986096,
0.6676983237,
-0.6280041933,
-0.5570660233,
-0.4560615122,
-0.4769556224,
0.8066476583,
0.2193998992,
0.3028567135,
-0.2793062031,
-0.0109086577,
0.4824576378,
0.6143583655,
-0.7717944384,
-0.6191079617,
-0.6570290327,
0.0106701776,
-0.1879931539,
-0.3306693733,
-0.0781371593,
0.0151270507,
0.6453578472,
-0.1311101317,
0.3937828243,
-0.0224726815,
-0.1247508079,
0.0019300708,
0.3506029844,
0.6124584079,
0.8525613546,
-0.0051502422,
-0.3627645075,
-0.4592095912,
-0.868635118,
0.2953931093,
-0.0327875726,
-0.7673997283,
0.5418548584,
0.3844571114,
0.951202929,
-0.0606138445,
-0.3347677588,
0.3692581654,
-0.0832344219,
-0.3508344889,
-0.5004271269,
0.0774117932,
0.0618935376,
-0.1541625112,
0.3608674109,
0.0709853098,
0.0342471041,
-0.8637434244,
-0.2832606733,
0.3906823099,
-0.1570651233,
0.0318719968,
0.7188902497,
0.5553846359,
-0.0825947672,
0.9621970654,
-0.4271682203,
-0.4710974991,
0.7799316049,
0.459130317,
0.4717701972,
-0.1446887702,
0.7444916368,
0.2653837502,
0.4208391905,
0.3108952641,
0.5709831119,
-0.210582003,
-0.9706765413,
-0.2970269024,
-0.8321430087,
-0.3074476123,
0.0805432051,
-0.9628335238,
-0.1729229242,
-0.2797960937,
-0.6383269429,
0.3579665124,
-0.0505079888,
-0.7172676325,
0.1540264189,
-0.1145557091,
0.4806244373,
-0.8302394152,
0.6260555387,
1.0554176569,
-0.374055326,
-0.2461604923,
-0.1112493947,
-0.265098542,
-0.5591641068,
0.8622649312,
-0.1721018255,
0.1598762274,
-0.1278738976,
-0.4140720367,
-0.7950671315,
0.6319586635,
0.2175076455,
-0.5384904146,
0.3063079417,
0.0972122699,
0.5479080081,
-0.3959758282,
0.3374505639,
0.0888132453,
0.5368204117,
-0.1853496432,
-1.3319197893,
-0.7525367141,
-0.276058495,
0.0578237996,
0.2000212669,
-0.7634670734,
1.0943090916,
-0.0523999706,
-0.3563292027,
0.1096836403,
0.8647741675,
-0.038167607,
0.3782742321,
0.0647440329,
0.3415590823,
0.7633781433,
-0.5113807321,
1.1362864971,
-0.4400497973,
0.0510117225,
1.1596335173,
-0.0705139413,
0.42863819,
0.4462276399,
-0.4417827725,
0.7652196884,
0.7042139769,
0.0987504497,
0.5396916866,
0.008184188,
-0.4358161092,
-0.0448018126,
-0.1445330232,
-0.4984237254,
0.9453779459,
0.6163023114,
-0.4665560126,
-0.0165189002,
0.2406722903,
-0.092426762,
0.402526468,
-0.4684853554,
0.857088685,
0.0492107868,
-0.5153315067,
0.7681726217,
0.3146728277,
0.7478611469,
-0.2897682786,
-0.0593683571,
-0.3676025569,
-0.2657528818,
-0.1935988516,
-0.9018413424,
0.5144560933,
-0.0532052927,
-0.5029702783,
0.038030114,
0.1708476692,
-0.6063991785,
-0.5208894014,
-0.0869795606,
0.4719667435,
0.4252224863,
-0.2150836289,
-0.5717865825,
0.0184219256,
-0.1238352209,
0.1168079972,
0.2247919589,
0.4541635215,
-0.410641849,
0.7971313,
0.3706280291,
0.4856454432,
0.3419934213,
-0.2790688872,
0.4335387647,
-0.1786339134,
-0.6577159762,
-0.2360729575,
0.0547176674,
0.0611827821,
-0.7018968463,
0.6736494303,
0.4113518596,
1.1431236267,
-0.4450247884,
0.9762387872,
-0.4133019447,
0.2943324447,
-0.5694146752,
0.7657057643,
-0.1593806893,
-0.2175502628,
-0.0909804478,
-1.2132049799,
0.2395225465,
1.0148748159,
-0.3372846246,
0.0220949519,
0.3321484923,
0.6833791137,
-0.0285511464,
-0.0775973722,
0.3567059338,
0.4611549973,
-0.2714193165,
0.3100016415,
0.8045729399,
-0.5283423066,
0.2133276463,
-0.4488955438,
-0.1002786681,
-0.0398385264,
-0.6174030304,
-0.7682517767,
-0.6097961068,
-0.2658067048,
-0.3982250094,
-0.0018407677,
0.6374558806,
0.451076299,
-1.2607704401,
-0.2546624839,
0.277007848,
0.3539093733,
-0.0461603031,
-0.2503791153,
0.0997898802,
0.294162333,
-1.0112860203,
0.4026156962,
0.1946038157,
-0.1973845661,
-0.7343117595,
-0.1400783658,
-0.1818410456,
-0.3758555353,
0.3339013755,
0.6376071572,
-0.9707010388,
0.3143294156,
-0.2263456881,
-0.209197104,
0.080573976,
0.3657303452,
-0.7756149173,
0.7432447076,
0.3487541974,
0.3136764467,
0.2961368263,
0.1979928315,
0.4978448451,
-0.4453882873,
0.7084415555,
0.2255659103,
0.2511142492,
0.4825205505,
-0.3797187805,
0.3731883764,
0.4166362882,
-0.409309715,
-0.4951893985,
0.3710184395,
-0.7813732624,
-0.1145881936,
1.0079123974,
-0.0215963032,
-0.1788780987,
-0.3164475262,
-0.2771704197,
-0.0625843182,
-0.5474052429,
0.7357942462,
0.8916537762,
-0.0190720763,
-0.1181732267,
-0.7851899266,
0.5422205329,
-0.1181186587,
-0.2365566343,
-0.8185985684,
0.5510441661,
0.2573442459,
0.4486748278,
0.5998945832,
0.1222777069,
0.3659946024,
0.2425816357,
0.0897729397,
0.0338954106,
-0.5177072883,
-0.1526192576,
0.0444436073,
-0.3342639804,
-0.1067087576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19432v1
|
Can Large Language Models put 2 and 2 together? Probing for Entailed Arithmetical Relationships
| 2024-04-30T10:28:04 | 2024-04-30T10:28:04 |
D. Panas, S. Seth, V. Belle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Two major areas of interest in the era of Large Language Models regard
questions of what do LLMs know, and if and how they may be able to reason (or
rather, approximately reason). Since to date these lines of work progressed
largely in parallel (with notable exceptions), we are interested in
investigating the intersection: probing for reasoning about the implicitly-held
knowledge. Suspecting the performance to be lacking in this area, we use a very
simple set-up of comparisons between cardinalities associated with elements of
various subjects (e.g. the number of legs a bird has versus the number of
wheels on a tricycle). We empirically demonstrate that although LLMs make
steady progress in knowledge acquisition and (pseudo)reasoning with each new
GPT release, their capabilities are limited to statistical inference only. It
is difficult to argue that pure statistical learning can cope with the
combinatorial explosion inherent in many commonsense reasoning tasks,
especially once arithmetical notions are involved. Further, we argue that
bigger is not always better and chasing purely statistical improvements is
flawed at the core, since it only exacerbates the dangerous conflation of the
production of correct answers with genuine reasoning ability.
|
[
-0.4210873842,
-0.9855954647,
1.0869191885,
0.1670868844,
-0.0957159624,
-0.2532788813,
-0.2519937456,
-0.6733435988,
-0.1029628292,
0.4619363844,
-0.3332664073,
0.0867224336,
-0.7939171791,
0.1202078909,
-0.3352612555,
0.7199203372,
0.2431835979,
0.2115683109,
-0.5014615655,
-0.1443122178,
-0.2304068357,
-0.594845295,
-0.8323293924,
-0.3602994084,
0.5867929459,
0.1779109985,
0.7842078209,
0.6184520125,
0.7073948979,
0.3207748234,
-0.130852744,
0.3821535707,
-0.5695248842,
0.1353506893,
-0.2059116215,
-0.654206872,
-0.3947210312,
0.0332789719,
0.6998478174,
1.1377265453,
0.134618476,
-0.025491504,
-0.0009610242,
0.9268401265,
-0.4447246194,
0.1642599106,
-0.6921238303,
-0.3530619144,
-0.1931099147,
-0.1275012195,
-0.3782843649,
-0.458345741,
0.0889820382,
-0.5107476711,
0.0262556691,
0.1606760472,
0.4621891975,
0.3230633736,
-0.8337542415,
-0.5320187807,
-0.6161453724,
0.762353003,
-0.586212337,
0.3312313259,
0.598177731,
0.237478286,
-0.2519137263,
-0.5895527005,
-0.6107696891,
-0.3417441845,
-0.155769363,
-0.0446725003,
-0.1416796744,
0.0251491778,
0.580945611,
0.3790512979,
-0.7454410195,
-0.0080396701,
-0.6107114553,
0.071891658,
0.7562175989,
0.1292349249,
0.3071816266,
0.2103385478,
-0.2356326878,
-0.0148162311,
-1.2181385756,
-0.0773163587,
0.489272058,
-0.0176570732,
-0.0520679951,
0.8624189496,
-0.0215750579,
0.636993885,
-0.1083125547,
0.1439865083,
-0.1610660702,
-0.2524592578,
-0.0917312875,
-0.0101999119,
0.6946387291,
0.0677608028,
0.8350149989,
-0.141885668,
-0.1417918652,
0.1709875613,
-0.0597698987,
-0.7349920273,
-0.3808027804,
0.277502656,
-0.032315176,
-0.0284891389,
0.1170996726,
-0.4886281192,
-0.197501272,
-0.743755579,
0.4782849252,
-0.3237540424,
-0.4263045192,
0.2168331742,
-0.0924191773,
0.2496771663,
0.3284022212,
-1.0510450602,
0.3893055022,
1.3464742899,
0.7026528716,
0.0471332036,
-0.3673250079,
-0.369151324,
0.1147112176,
-0.8032131791,
0.8603920341,
-0.6386212707,
-0.3145460784,
-0.0121849636,
-0.1706217527,
-0.1185994074,
-0.5596313477,
0.1324578971,
-0.6126500964,
0.1631193012,
-0.7385321856,
-0.7068867683,
-0.2191027999,
0.2784585953,
-0.5554509759,
0.9448501468,
-0.1079183519,
-0.6488059759,
0.2974132895,
-0.3218935728,
-0.5013142228,
-0.111548461,
-0.5299645662,
-0.0995088592,
0.2536682189,
-0.0347336456,
0.2769913971,
-0.6375722885,
0.2355636805,
-0.7246829271,
-0.4404380918,
0.5034803152,
-0.5077040792,
0.895134449,
0.1510811001,
-0.1241131797,
-0.2114262134,
-0.6080924273,
-0.0193963144,
0.1278115064,
-0.1201389879,
-0.3957241774,
0.1925285906,
-0.6862507463,
-0.0120343557,
0.3089081943,
-0.2570360005,
0.2027719766,
-0.357472837,
0.3982639015,
0.6914042234,
-0.073652491,
0.5224719048,
-0.456546396,
0.1833837777,
-0.1622942239,
-0.1283574253,
0.0455956608,
-0.5531361699,
-1.0015387535,
-0.0224890448,
0.1780599356,
0.5354319215,
-0.6051004529,
0.1964336932,
-0.2637996376,
-0.3389442861,
-0.0769410208,
0.0746508017,
0.4213689864,
0.2107807547,
0.1528168917,
-0.0905067921,
-0.2919360101,
-0.7088159919,
-0.3731045127,
-0.4440982938,
-0.0639092997,
0.3807864785,
0.5258687139,
0.1964863539,
0.6922746897,
-0.4223546982,
0.1727252901,
-0.2314157337,
0.0979991183,
0.2358332723,
0.2862838209,
0.4937794507,
-0.6990217566,
-0.3007371724,
0.0020749711,
-0.9589398503,
-0.1215960681,
0.3187666237,
-0.131821543,
0.0607218035,
0.375795275,
-0.9215135574,
0.13067168,
0.3709830046,
-0.3366440833,
0.5637438893,
-0.3760299683,
-0.0000391153,
-0.5659877062,
-0.3344852924,
0.0844933912,
0.0673415363,
-0.7294759154,
-0.0449412577,
0.0362600312,
0.099296689,
-0.1166550368,
0.4786971807,
-0.5549510717,
-0.4357726574,
-0.3047156334,
0.1196134686,
-0.1300997585,
0.3050974309,
-0.0658708513,
0.8499883413,
0.709776938,
-0.7157098055,
0.2828790843,
-0.0886385813,
-0.3088591695,
0.4836497009,
-0.7549635768,
0.1444222331,
-0.1699149907,
0.333792299,
-1.1168067455,
-0.4305759668,
0.0522063933,
-0.6978352666,
0.2346989959,
-0.210470736,
-0.6295012832,
-0.0664912686,
-0.0184282232,
0.6346760392,
0.7564054132,
-0.4890272915,
0.3431282341,
0.3573954999,
-0.4218947291,
-0.3048302531,
-0.5912322402,
-0.1301171631,
-0.3752464652,
-0.9379706383,
-0.4482147098,
0.1596561372,
-1.0224351883,
-0.0588810071,
-0.1391569376,
-0.1220079437,
-0.1046945155,
-0.1268637478,
0.4028678834,
-0.5183244348,
0.4858947396,
-0.1888845861,
-0.2971635163,
0.4500274062,
-0.2876419723,
0.3745342791,
-0.0972794592,
-0.5983671546,
0.13381733,
0.2520129681,
0.5845128894,
-0.3258523643,
0.6319822073,
0.2307092398,
-0.3585075736,
-0.1007487699,
-0.7772198915,
-0.3931754529,
-0.4613144696,
0.2869043946,
-0.6088897586,
-1.1058341265,
0.3154013157,
0.0230071191,
-0.0654757321,
0.5734454989,
0.5442503095,
-0.0658319816,
1.1586699486,
0.2251261324,
0.2159923464,
-0.1037570834,
-0.1932306588,
0.391836524,
-0.7123728991,
-0.1087222919,
-0.5289075375,
-0.0372323468,
-0.7585945129,
-0.498573333,
0.5207110047,
0.1906640828,
-0.5622103214,
0.0103008887,
-0.1571093947,
0.6694527864,
0.4428856373,
0.0870557204,
0.4375945032,
-0.1860402375,
0.3285468519,
0.0266921185,
-0.6035057902,
-0.370745182,
1.2180947065,
0.2965953648,
0.4986630678,
0.5766830444,
0.3351377249,
-0.1138352007,
0.2667819262,
-0.7449946404,
0.659922123,
-0.2909852862,
-0.6210290194,
-0.5301887989,
-0.8334351182,
-0.8344045281,
0.6791879535,
0.0110945152,
-0.6918320656,
0.1344267875,
0.1730914414,
0.0362902768,
0.3474962413,
-0.6289474368,
0.6384583712,
-0.5713838935,
-0.5762529373,
-0.4271208644,
-0.4907330573,
0.8044872284,
-0.0924062729,
0.4147675037,
-0.3214534223,
-0.0440658256,
0.6142526269,
-0.4490174055,
0.683552742,
0.0800279826,
-0.1554086059,
0.3653609157,
0.338792026,
0.690511167,
0.0240735058,
0.1647279114,
0.0358120129,
0.1997221857,
-0.5661728382,
-0.764788568,
0.6320247054,
-0.5736078024,
-0.7310389876,
-0.5566756725,
-0.607675612,
-0.4532621503,
-0.0645301193,
0.0303066205,
0.6955118775,
0.1266937703,
0.1877457201,
0.9939131141,
0.1128097475,
0.1599415988,
0.5654777288,
-0.2403033376,
-0.2287371159,
0.9312505722,
0.2273302078,
0.5580095053,
0.4020083547,
0.367454201,
-0.6413410306,
-0.497089386,
-0.3966299295,
0.6382436156,
-0.5644896626,
0.2282153219,
-0.5763338208,
0.0265098438,
-0.4235959351,
0.0766299441,
-0.1317172796,
-0.4970980883,
0.0239180401,
-0.1185258776,
0.4665727317,
1.0297306776,
-0.3111482859,
-0.0634050742,
-0.4387216866,
0.1237831712,
0.6793453097,
-0.0352888778,
0.2651356161,
-0.5398884416,
0.0721805319,
0.1274176687,
-0.0737847313,
-0.8949021101,
0.0543970503,
0.0221828781,
0.3185890615,
0.5069739223,
-0.0956256017,
0.7191010118,
-0.4666951597,
0.531960547,
0.2191918939,
-0.5124872923,
0.1345683485,
-0.6418279409,
-0.0873530358,
0.1704852581,
0.5801047087,
-0.3010477722,
-0.3348218799,
-0.6499226093,
-0.5584328175,
0.4272915125,
0.136879921,
0.0609557778,
-0.1845167279,
0.1159160212,
-0.0776073709,
0.0393307619,
-0.5258501768,
-0.0455898084,
0.3825325668,
-0.1539814472,
-0.1723076552,
-0.4982288182,
-0.2506997287,
-0.3313723505,
0.5579024553,
-0.0652176663,
0.1617144346,
-0.0350077339,
-0.0091061965,
-0.06187452,
0.2303131223,
0.4979105294,
1.2359054089,
-0.1226749197,
0.4872614741,
0.1699760705,
-0.2987457216,
0.0709068179,
0.0954282358,
0.1622135341,
-0.4082946181,
0.592254281,
0.6269013882,
0.388874054,
-0.6511161327,
0.5029949546,
0.3374254107,
-0.4707928002,
-0.5132784247,
0.0869110525,
0.2106519639,
0.3184795678,
0.3687285185,
-0.3046486974,
0.0848948509,
-1.0079920292,
0.2013712376,
0.5542584062,
-0.2029427737,
-0.2746162415,
0.5014180541,
0.0646492615,
-0.2285753042,
0.6114681959,
-0.2882273495,
-0.7704622149,
0.8976913095,
0.4791162908,
0.5131912827,
0.0308877639,
-0.0679447874,
0.3937370181,
0.4920713305,
-0.4198895991,
0.1553823203,
-0.1147637218,
-0.8437393308,
-0.7418042421,
-0.3695341349,
-0.4772335589,
0.0733418614,
-0.4970903099,
-0.0482772142,
-0.1560636163,
0.2087037265,
-0.0350771658,
0.0586430691,
-0.4618456662,
0.2022941858,
-0.0777153224,
0.6763405204,
-0.8827776909,
0.5778741241,
0.5382527113,
-0.5486137867,
-0.8534436226,
0.0016493783,
0.0499680266,
-1.0379058123,
0.6168784499,
0.1766994596,
0.0987698436,
-0.0138227222,
-0.4564270377,
-0.9327372909,
0.7789540291,
0.1765059978,
-0.6283370256,
0.1574615836,
0.4400191009,
0.5604348183,
-0.1473778039,
0.4874798656,
0.7608911395,
0.5972467661,
0.4172080457,
-0.9341681004,
0.0083901249,
-0.0027902578,
-0.4052388966,
0.6674079895,
-0.7071737051,
1.090747118,
-0.38234815,
-0.1634174287,
0.0592466369,
0.5615269542,
0.423618257,
0.6502223611,
0.4078440368,
0.9300174713,
0.6861258149,
-0.3667577505,
1.1875652075,
-0.1290249825,
0.2825484574,
0.9231324792,
-0.2402775884,
0.7311535478,
0.3637799621,
-0.8355314136,
-0.1055627614,
0.757912755,
0.2586601377,
0.2236062139,
0.2528485358,
-0.4113220274,
-0.6141524911,
0.3410357237,
-0.4532066286,
0.1366542727,
0.5831567049,
-0.1122526154,
-0.1608237773,
-0.6201544404,
0.1672210395,
-0.0638533831,
-0.268479079,
0.8800078034,
0.4782206714,
-0.8897197247,
0.3288259804,
-0.3003207445,
0.2632456422,
-0.6318657398,
-0.1041784286,
-0.3041213751,
0.108081609,
-0.0825328156,
-1.0093050003,
0.3324653804,
-0.0316606462,
-0.0135521768,
0.2520559728,
0.70363307,
-0.5554578304,
-0.6572389007,
0.1745035201,
0.7792505026,
0.5990096927,
-0.09756051,
-0.2834402919,
-0.0454955921,
-0.0495301969,
-0.0841827765,
0.5067449808,
0.9106448889,
-0.0655529425,
0.6906446218,
0.8679742813,
0.3174255192,
0.2696761489,
0.0327739231,
0.6029986143,
-0.4874205291,
-0.2076832503,
-1.0356794596,
0.2958709002,
-0.0236344691,
-0.2487570494,
0.6928756833,
0.6201989651,
0.7305232286,
0.3084409535,
0.8224474192,
0.0358260609,
0.4669242203,
-0.7820599079,
0.2610515654,
-0.5870496035,
0.3474128246,
0.1826782376,
-1.0382964611,
-0.068086423,
0.6608278751,
-0.6936667562,
0.1725975126,
0.9038038254,
0.8212745786,
-0.2157136947,
0.2792854309,
0.4708921909,
0.3384830654,
0.2521863282,
0.7755727768,
1.0113933086,
-0.1390163898,
0.4353031516,
0.0014823324,
-0.3994346261,
-0.0333373062,
-0.522113502,
-0.9356814623,
-0.4468480945,
0.0400947668,
-0.168115586,
0.2275678366,
0.5500819683,
0.2929622829,
-0.5038855672,
-0.3402920365,
-0.3195255995,
0.1485695094,
0.1024117097,
-0.1925095916,
0.3711862266,
-0.3866252899,
-0.6800833344,
0.2352291793,
0.2759841084,
-0.001224658,
-0.411524266,
-0.1719850451,
0.1554178447,
0.3135041595,
0.6618802547,
0.3077894449,
-0.6894618273,
-0.2651538551,
-0.0861787274,
0.1009454578,
-0.2399854064,
0.9792480469,
-0.2934137881,
0.2012847066,
0.6578888297,
0.6496876478,
0.5138215423,
0.0544914901,
0.5084736943,
-0.1938614845,
0.1150358915,
0.0369518586,
0.4748425782,
0.245581463,
-0.0575199835,
0.8130570054,
0.3458653092,
-0.883087635,
-0.8326383233,
0.4769433737,
-0.8319836259,
-0.2730873227,
1.4087394476,
0.0778706893,
-0.0103978748,
-0.1109393761,
0.1034099981,
-0.0534594655,
-0.1227049828,
0.6427758336,
0.786237359,
-0.3632914424,
-0.0906509161,
-0.8870546818,
0.2705279291,
0.4746824503,
-0.6701633334,
-0.0483631827,
0.6922140718,
0.2393748164,
-0.0017273946,
0.7036588788,
-0.135102123,
0.3778209984,
0.2043404728,
-0.6392155886,
0.1250211596,
-0.4208270311,
0.0238318536,
-0.0138614047,
0.219762519,
0.0587181449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19430v1
|
Sõnajaht: Definition Embeddings and Semantic Search for Reverse Dictionary Creation
| 2024-04-30T10:21:14 | 2024-04-30T10:21:14 |
Aleksei Dorkin, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present an information retrieval based reverse dictionary system using
modern pre-trained language models and approximate nearest neighbors search
algorithms. The proposed approach is applied to an existing Estonian language
lexicon resource, S\~onaveeb (word web), with the purpose of enhancing and
enriching it by introducing cross-lingual reverse dictionary functionality
powered by semantic search.
The performance of the system is evaluated using both an existing labeled
English dataset of words and definitions that is extended to contain also
Estonian and Russian translations, and a novel unlabeled evaluation approach
that extracts the evaluation data from the lexicon resource itself using
synonymy relations.
Evaluation results indicate that the information retrieval based semantic
search approach without any model training is feasible, producing median rank
of 1 in the monolingual setting and median rank of 2 in the cross-lingual
setting using the unlabeled evaluation approach, with models trained for
cross-lingual retrieval and including Estonian in their training data showing
superior performance in our particular task.
|
[
-0.6337942481,
-0.7586343884,
0.2755942047,
0.0444559567,
-0.5462746024,
-0.2013870031,
-0.1356615573,
-0.4938125312,
0.8365702629,
0.5709036589,
-0.3486666381,
-0.6461328864,
-0.7307043076,
0.3240869641,
-0.6956842542,
0.5963941216,
-0.1190879643,
0.3419775963,
-0.1558275223,
-0.1786200404,
-0.4300422072,
-0.2817690372,
-0.0894265249,
-0.1664270759,
0.197388947,
0.7482733727,
0.8547937274,
0.543888092,
0.4682286382,
0.2910931706,
0.0551201254,
-0.2080378979,
-0.5340488553,
0.3968681693,
-0.6662126184,
-0.3969372213,
-0.0220606197,
-0.1850979179,
0.6490911245,
0.4027121067,
-0.222949177,
0.3294831812,
-0.2299002558,
0.3769866228,
-0.8011807799,
-0.1932883561,
-0.7595613003,
0.0194744281,
-0.3127150834,
-0.2916310728,
0.0354294628,
-0.4825010002,
0.2306870222,
-0.4775594175,
0.2348394245,
0.1947124302,
0.9201852679,
-0.2204338014,
-0.2588460147,
-0.3633058667,
-0.2148092836,
0.8878872395,
-0.4460814595,
1.0673519373,
0.4315778315,
0.469904989,
-0.1335535198,
-0.549972415,
-0.9007131457,
-0.0809273496,
0.014890248,
0.0575782694,
-0.0052161417,
-0.1466746926,
-0.3661952615,
0.380684793,
-0.5931357741,
-0.1371655762,
-0.3110830784,
0.004703321,
0.4497189522,
0.2445557714,
0.385491401,
-0.5970026255,
-0.5093836188,
-0.174312979,
-0.7644453645,
-0.6942687035,
0.473438412,
0.6016604304,
0.1118807569,
1.0100455284,
-0.2931137681,
0.4255458415,
-0.1074910313,
-0.2314614505,
0.2799321413,
-0.3076069355,
-0.1271110028,
0.1837535799,
0.2526450455,
0.2132210433,
0.0567653663,
-0.3732020259,
-0.535700202,
-0.0007418221,
0.385078907,
-0.6126776338,
0.1702030897,
-0.0690192208,
-0.8121777177,
-0.5196233988,
0.2036465704,
-0.5928027034,
-0.1668374091,
-0.3112668693,
1.0039678812,
-0.5338508487,
-0.5349835753,
-0.0370548144,
-0.4111753702,
0.5051632524,
0.0201378502,
-0.5691924095,
0.5749176741,
0.6505715847,
0.644397676,
-0.2467924803,
-0.3945603371,
0.0567733459,
0.1613373905,
-0.4608215988,
0.7437383533,
-0.7398574948,
-0.6914011836,
-0.0110586006,
0.1675930023,
0.3136229217,
-0.6646602154,
0.3094699085,
-0.8854993582,
0.2635042667,
0.0776496157,
-0.6442214251,
-0.3695742488,
0.3465678692,
-0.5490999818,
1.1545538902,
0.069094643,
-0.9833801389,
0.3016984165,
-0.5169551969,
-0.547563076,
0.148969993,
-0.024072485,
0.0311111566,
0.1752874851,
0.1295046955,
0.5638648272,
-0.8496128917,
0.1639163047,
0.0403971337,
-0.4426729977,
-0.4730760753,
-0.0133031663,
0.6477435231,
0.2376086861,
-0.2586722672,
-0.2017875016,
-0.7976765633,
0.1029428467,
0.3474560082,
-0.3467581868,
-0.8899399042,
-0.3342800438,
0.3735105693,
-0.0801771954,
0.3970088959,
-0.9572889209,
-0.0238315761,
-0.6939386725,
-0.2982465625,
0.6375041008,
0.0373791791,
0.0191999823,
-0.0607172325,
0.6649520993,
0.0007329572,
0.1206700131,
0.3420163095,
-0.413023293,
-0.647785008,
0.0505468212,
0.5925398469,
0.7843293548,
-0.9770550728,
0.4985280037,
-0.6196082234,
-0.7985773087,
-0.6984423399,
0.1116532236,
0.6020283103,
0.5101903677,
0.6274161339,
-0.3548172116,
-0.7179065943,
-1.2186973095,
-0.2134489268,
-0.0654800013,
0.0594911762,
0.2340905517,
0.6179977655,
-0.5042831302,
0.6731635928,
-0.3240074217,
-0.4078605771,
-0.3467276096,
0.0268850364,
0.2618052661,
0.4482887387,
0.1964339167,
-1.0752094984,
-0.282984525,
-0.0797670335,
-0.5039407015,
-0.126384899,
0.6519342661,
-0.2088755518,
0.2780018151,
0.3659812212,
-0.1367957741,
0.6389445662,
0.540542841,
-0.2770156264,
0.3913057745,
-0.0241059195,
0.3211615086,
-1.5015505552,
0.2640234828,
-0.4854005575,
-0.2737146318,
-0.1779500097,
0.4694040716,
-0.0873154625,
-0.0416098759,
-0.5047917962,
0.6558114886,
-0.3486344814,
-0.2015597224,
-0.1459275633,
0.5065239668,
-0.3033697307,
0.0489802174,
0.1800961643,
0.824029386,
0.4118056595,
-0.7112923861,
0.8239988089,
0.4992262423,
-0.3487747908,
0.8554347157,
-0.5159928799,
-0.0562188402,
-0.2685766518,
-0.1189308837,
-0.86302495,
0.1086186692,
-0.1028041691,
-0.5212401152,
0.303276062,
-0.1542446613,
-0.5942178965,
-0.1342283189,
-0.3396293521,
0.5033037066,
0.3634891212,
-0.755007267,
0.7164952159,
0.8270400167,
-0.1321527809,
-0.6987106204,
-0.8935649395,
0.2471725494,
-0.1394006312,
-0.6925929189,
0.3857062459,
0.6440461874,
-0.1552273482,
0.2434939295,
0.0777514875,
-0.0840169936,
-0.1657979786,
0.0714222267,
0.1272533983,
-0.2199048102,
0.6324629784,
0.0051296763,
-0.1404711455,
-0.3507991135,
-0.4322699904,
0.6255913377,
-0.2085402757,
-0.2165144384,
-0.0877113938,
0.5112996697,
-0.1059785262,
-0.0400562398,
0.8147332072,
0.4082873464,
-0.4000324011,
-0.0001411382,
-0.8514934182,
-0.2386665493,
-0.3811746836,
0.2210861593,
-0.8914069533,
-0.5132767558,
0.5552400947,
-0.13604711,
-0.3482895195,
0.6397789717,
0.4539450705,
0.1040261164,
0.6042628884,
0.7226939797,
0.2850615978,
0.2583393753,
-0.2643590868,
-0.0024985152,
-0.766413033,
-0.3301999271,
-0.5875321627,
-0.32334131,
-0.9591758251,
-0.2982493639,
0.3703143597,
-0.2064893246,
0.0222243369,
0.801114738,
-0.2593915462,
0.3259992301,
0.672314167,
0.1466253102,
0.3566741645,
-0.0852394626,
-0.6021831036,
-0.1598360986,
-0.6903650165,
-0.2596089244,
1.1769253016,
0.0072159548,
1.1101416349,
0.392877996,
1.0796371698,
0.2902209759,
0.0058002081,
-0.7000904679,
0.5977871418,
-0.1014560983,
-0.6895926595,
-0.5447793603,
-0.3021539152,
-1.1495517492,
0.1865130961,
-0.3571734428,
-0.4074372053,
0.1124705225,
-0.2697359622,
0.353371352,
0.2421787083,
-0.5033890009,
0.646155715,
0.0096522551,
-0.2625643313,
-0.7833468914,
-0.7676592469,
0.0591661707,
-0.0114217047,
0.0825455859,
0.2301400304,
-0.2841767669,
1.1348814964,
-0.5814359784,
0.3188869953,
-0.2049232274,
-0.1680087298,
0.1585631818,
0.5129846931,
0.3433773816,
-0.0290263947,
0.0086565269,
0.1063432172,
0.5067907572,
-0.5310476422,
-0.6533207297,
0.9303127527,
-0.5156388879,
-0.6441693306,
-0.2358748019,
0.0529199876,
-0.2815138698,
0.5587713122,
0.1938095391,
0.463299036,
-0.2967367768,
0.2358765751,
0.5362430215,
-0.3011504412,
-0.1921198368,
0.4590087831,
-0.6368857622,
-0.4231982827,
0.9277330041,
0.2081053108,
-0.0863378495,
0.7068781853,
0.4030348957,
-0.5746449232,
-0.1905386895,
-0.2812668979,
0.2621931434,
-0.8974648118,
-0.3677503467,
-0.4278769493,
0.1162555292,
-0.7085271478,
0.0424053967,
-0.6257539392,
-0.7763808966,
0.2058622986,
-0.0079661161,
0.4040934741,
0.9622845054,
-0.1741129607,
-0.023793811,
-0.7656205893,
0.6858859062,
0.2035975754,
0.7903057933,
0.0398727059,
-0.5483781099,
-0.2539867163,
-0.1516571045,
0.1004610062,
-0.9022572637,
0.139168784,
0.0795090869,
0.4729425013,
-0.0409399755,
0.0001014222,
0.7431919575,
-0.3411610126,
0.6047456861,
-0.1594165862,
-0.9637451172,
0.6329401135,
0.003806293,
0.1884557903,
0.6697339416,
0.5317898989,
-0.6496242881,
-0.1627031118,
-0.7601781487,
-0.8041673303,
0.42040205,
-0.0447583124,
0.26899001,
-0.15555951,
0.0667371154,
0.4743666649,
0.1532230228,
-0.0118411193,
-0.0211728122,
-0.2469288856,
-0.213119477,
0.2359938323,
-0.3621525764,
0.1350785345,
-0.2920953333,
1.1597677469,
0.127055943,
0.2827120125,
0.3789265156,
-0.3083091676,
-0.0278302412,
0.176556617,
0.1532292217,
0.4881199896,
-0.1832875162,
0.2504080534,
0.4517080188,
-0.6548714638,
0.0791525394,
-0.0550069548,
-0.0209797472,
0.2368261218,
0.2567826211,
0.3745230138,
0.3958800435,
-0.7892591357,
0.8030256629,
-0.0848322958,
0.0878642723,
-0.5548766255,
-0.4049017429,
-0.0628587976,
0.1188749894,
0.2980710864,
-0.4774080813,
0.3883492947,
-0.5035386682,
0.4251359999,
0.5636402965,
-0.118922554,
-0.0420667082,
0.2587924004,
0.0618623197,
-0.060228195,
0.5033320189,
0.1872464418,
-0.5940794349,
0.0802219361,
0.5993770361,
0.7911585569,
-0.3356850147,
0.0176834315,
0.2240360379,
0.1969312131,
0.1266615987,
0.8130555749,
-0.1946094483,
-0.7533969283,
0.0715676472,
-0.8236218691,
-0.1861763,
-0.2098699063,
-0.5225782394,
0.879766345,
-0.2831298709,
-0.0321081802,
-0.4316522777,
-0.0954166651,
-0.8150619268,
0.4554597437,
-0.2443821877,
1.2911845446,
-0.4890610874,
0.6254329085,
0.822871387,
-0.4622056484,
-0.6305773854,
-0.0700959116,
-0.3348014951,
-1.046628356,
1.0066308975,
-0.2156201601,
-0.6569876671,
0.2018983513,
-0.3219733536,
-1.1204892397,
0.8709567189,
0.1328175366,
0.0043306225,
-0.0739245787,
-0.0917668566,
0.6765422225,
-0.161623612,
0.3870470524,
0.3264372051,
0.4851198494,
0.0315104276,
-1.1151430607,
0.1133314297,
-0.2578955591,
0.4665285349,
0.2827524841,
-0.2507894039,
0.3886655867,
0.1282469481,
-0.5748112798,
0.2178084254,
0.60133183,
-0.2259282172,
-0.2219327539,
0.3426400721,
0.9057561755,
0.0444749109,
0.2828657925,
1.0456222296,
-0.3124626577,
0.3315837979,
0.8749662638,
0.0914914906,
1.1227604151,
0.8458433747,
-0.1098007262,
0.3931404948,
0.1884069294,
0.2658414245,
0.647816658,
0.2037384063,
0.1639261991,
-0.1803037673,
-0.372864455,
-0.4946574867,
0.8723109365,
0.2193629146,
-0.4939441383,
-0.5639060736,
0.18361862,
-0.2172703594,
0.3268405497,
-0.0780709013,
0.9710792303,
-0.1962963492,
-0.3321438432,
0.9716952443,
0.3263993561,
0.8163242936,
-0.3908200562,
-0.2237095237,
-0.0884780884,
-0.1183800474,
-0.1547470987,
-0.8316579461,
0.458917588,
-0.2471353412,
0.3803087175,
0.1481714696,
0.7429469228,
-0.4067877233,
-0.412735194,
0.5377889276,
0.6082397699,
0.3654675484,
0.3039203882,
-0.2832524478,
-0.0706375316,
-0.4609059989,
-0.3529133201,
-0.0270350669,
0.354363203,
-0.1393909454,
0.5341520309,
0.3048528433,
0.3848001659,
0.1154624447,
-0.0955837891,
0.719576776,
-0.8575744629,
-0.6725316644,
-0.4023455679,
-0.1844868064,
0.3006136417,
-0.3540351093,
0.5508599281,
0.6754498482,
1.192782402,
-0.2202723771,
0.8364660144,
-0.3139474392,
0.9915164113,
-0.6087952852,
0.5890111327,
-0.850982368,
-0.0210196804,
-0.3622875512,
-1.2194033861,
-0.2465589494,
0.5384925008,
-0.2078525722,
-0.0856465027,
0.4222148657,
1.0164481401,
-0.3785641789,
0.1856323481,
0.4746147096,
0.1513413936,
-0.1237808764,
0.190198198,
0.6593242884,
-0.7722594738,
0.3575417399,
-0.3125271499,
-0.0557931103,
-0.3713054359,
-0.584618926,
-0.5248353481,
-1.0303180218,
0.3917727172,
-0.295478344,
0.3158989847,
1.1487340927,
0.3544432223,
-0.8891546726,
-0.206032306,
-0.0595926009,
0.1362848133,
0.1066881493,
-0.2613178492,
0.3172863424,
-0.0454052612,
-0.6514587402,
0.2416351289,
0.0153038092,
0.0599176511,
-0.4801883996,
0.018186029,
-0.6381801367,
0.0977334902,
0.3396994174,
-0.0251236223,
-0.7429847121,
-0.3855078816,
-0.2449042648,
-0.1502627283,
-0.1390381306,
0.5961293578,
-1.059825778,
0.6725866199,
0.9893855453,
0.863292098,
0.3998892605,
0.1688582897,
0.5583705306,
-0.6248899698,
0.3695333898,
0.303086102,
0.0457302481,
0.5170460939,
-0.2362711132,
0.4749162793,
0.2882833481,
0.0154484166,
-0.5432918072,
0.2270789891,
-0.2407485396,
-0.2688542008,
0.9438762069,
0.2318438739,
-0.4182343781,
-0.1715870202,
-0.1375417411,
0.40555197,
-0.1610776782,
0.8838735819,
0.6243070364,
0.0413286053,
0.1302610934,
-0.1756335348,
0.2926642001,
0.4729292095,
-0.209936738,
-0.3124440908,
0.0948186517,
0.3064827025,
0.3850750923,
0.1514944881,
-0.5423694253,
0.2817337513,
0.0908683017,
0.198642239,
-0.0095736412,
-0.3423665762,
-0.1405676901,
0.0089811198,
-0.0581263639,
-0.1691107005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19409v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19409v1
|
Countering Reward Over-optimization in LLM with Demonstration-Guided Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-04-30T09:57:21 | 2024-04-30T09:57:21 |
Mathieu Rita, Florian Strub, Rahma Chaabouni, Paul Michel, Emmanuel Dupoux, Olivier Pietquin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Reinforcement Learning (RL) has been proven essential for tuning large
language models (LLMs), it can lead to reward over-optimization (ROO). Existing
approaches address ROO by adding KL regularization, requiring computationally
expensive hyperparameter tuning. Additionally, KL regularization focuses solely
on regularizing the language policy, neglecting a potential source of
regularization: the reward function itself. Inspired by demonstration-guided
RL, we here introduce the Reward Calibration from Demonstration (RCfD), which
leverages human demonstrations and a reward model to recalibrate the reward
objective. Formally, given a prompt, the RCfD objective minimizes the distance
between the demonstrations' and LLM's rewards rather than directly maximizing
the reward function. This objective shift avoids incentivizing the LLM to
exploit the reward model and promotes more natural and diverse language
generation. We show the effectiveness of RCfD on three language tasks, which
achieves comparable performance to carefully tuned baselines while mitigating
ROO.
|
[
-0.3005372286,
-0.5858188272,
0.3795002103,
0.2603572309,
-0.3467836082,
0.1118548214,
-0.5827291012,
0.0648743287,
-0.1209503189,
0.6191952825,
-0.8134068251,
-0.324454546,
-0.4898733497,
-0.0748032182,
0.2812430263,
1.3755280972,
-0.1008707136,
-0.1791763902,
-0.4099955857,
-0.0439124107,
-0.398725301,
-0.3842402697,
-0.8345672488,
-0.7410268188,
0.6917464137,
0.5938623548,
0.4315055907,
0.7631504536,
-0.102662988,
0.2093105018,
0.1950938851,
0.3617845178,
-0.9123416543,
0.0891495571,
-0.1977442652,
-0.5758907795,
0.2927338779,
0.0942856669,
0.663859129,
0.4050409794,
-0.2962186038,
-0.1550404131,
-0.0663162544,
0.9044328928,
-1.1313147545,
0.1965808868,
-0.363278687,
0.1020557284,
0.1855915934,
-0.4600203335,
-0.5953413844,
-0.6667188406,
-0.0957136303,
-0.6279508471,
-0.045779027,
0.0612222739,
0.8223156333,
0.6522209644,
-0.2696367204,
-0.167288214,
-0.8917969465,
1.1933617592,
-0.5082662702,
0.4466587305,
0.4169522226,
0.3946082294,
-0.2914150059,
-0.3232380748,
-0.4138095975,
-0.6000756025,
0.0132177891,
0.2557570338,
-0.1728730649,
0.096479699,
0.4437209964,
0.1732489765,
-0.558591485,
0.2663933933,
-0.2260570824,
-0.182884559,
0.599195838,
0.020116901,
-0.0124814333,
0.0636328161,
-0.5112677217,
-0.7989926934,
-0.9341517091,
0.489059478,
0.5576430559,
0.235488072,
0.0797545686,
0.400924623,
-0.338568598,
0.5394867659,
0.0692762583,
-0.1724498719,
0.0394506454,
-0.1703158021,
-0.201723367,
0.1485389024,
0.6908624768,
0.3447695673,
0.5184062719,
-0.1262170523,
-0.5066729188,
0.2423325777,
0.3254703283,
-0.9057182074,
-0.1261817217,
-0.0433899201,
-0.1602462679,
-0.5453732014,
-0.1605962664,
-0.5501102209,
-0.2391126603,
-0.2395780534,
0.4960002899,
-0.176097542,
-0.1501967311,
0.2998729646,
-0.2234666646,
0.0808888152,
-0.0394893065,
-1.1367577314,
0.4528773129,
0.7266477346,
0.4670663476,
-0.2226952463,
-0.3516001105,
-1.1276110411,
0.2081367821,
-0.5695198178,
0.5932613611,
-0.3762517571,
-0.4982777536,
0.0262331925,
-0.1568009257,
-0.100774534,
-0.7492520809,
0.621493876,
-0.5251510143,
0.2865795791,
-0.2697160542,
-0.4693747461,
-0.0457935892,
0.4146881104,
-0.4536272287,
0.8604544401,
0.1869796515,
-0.2909713984,
0.7111397386,
-0.6242442727,
-0.6265012622,
-0.1027271822,
-0.396374464,
-0.5293339491,
0.0037841869,
0.3038726747,
0.2095773518,
-0.1992069334,
0.3401227593,
0.1235159859,
-0.4973135293,
0.1333572417,
-0.3479285538,
0.216256246,
0.2536862493,
-0.4462085664,
0.4623924792,
-0.5819372535,
0.1208834648,
0.0725829154,
-0.5892822742,
-0.304330647,
0.1616989076,
-0.1103588566,
0.2174576074,
0.0285485201,
-0.6022766232,
0.1467937976,
-0.9096777439,
0.3039948046,
0.8587123752,
0.1166830584,
0.2954904735,
-0.6027680635,
0.9429662228,
-0.3159856498,
0.1463063061,
-0.0011451378,
-0.0859334171,
-0.5632072687,
-0.3730110824,
0.2958298028,
0.3769550323,
-0.7126837373,
0.3290404379,
-0.1849275827,
-0.3463525474,
-0.4700254202,
0.1603970379,
0.7230562568,
0.3939787149,
0.3900908828,
-0.1896209717,
-0.2899754345,
-0.9138244987,
-0.2063545287,
-0.0665510595,
-0.0741985142,
0.3807895184,
0.2851091027,
0.1050370783,
0.8333777785,
-0.541072607,
-0.3502598405,
-0.4324004948,
0.3799498081,
0.1411849111,
0.6047247648,
0.406180352,
-0.7795456052,
-0.5542911887,
0.1043025628,
-0.039302282,
-0.1604335755,
-0.4454774559,
0.0772837922,
0.396732986,
0.5143448114,
-0.2826182842,
0.3096207678,
0.3733294606,
0.0428748988,
0.5858305693,
-0.5427956581,
0.1713161469,
-0.5844606161,
-0.077476047,
-0.1285146624,
-0.4039531648,
-0.233824566,
0.1450662017,
0.0887291357,
-0.0205554646,
-0.2436145246,
0.5482068062,
-0.0586770475,
-0.0175460167,
-0.6538335085,
0.1233174577,
-0.0052796812,
0.8024170995,
0.3960033357,
0.7767573595,
0.3201941848,
-0.6543684602,
0.3930076063,
-0.0913245901,
-0.2548022866,
0.3762486279,
-0.8471087813,
-0.1855197847,
-0.0817040056,
0.3126628995,
-0.8667019606,
-0.0835755467,
0.1689195037,
-0.4349529445,
0.2464961559,
-0.0378954671,
-0.2862325311,
-0.0801301077,
-0.668895483,
0.4694572985,
0.8707537055,
-0.7511600852,
0.2338906378,
-0.2014944255,
0.116401203,
-0.628903091,
-0.4229264855,
-0.3199742436,
-0.2738307118,
-0.2813818753,
0.5364708304,
-0.0551441349,
0.0913765132,
-0.2836233974,
-0.1551167369,
0.4938423038,
0.1873891801,
0.2556645572,
-0.0684407055,
-0.1211477965,
0.1479611844,
0.1307897866,
-0.2173098326,
0.1464568228,
-0.1184472442,
0.7584804893,
0.2430415601,
-0.4122287631,
-0.431520462,
0.1581965536,
0.2686301172,
-0.1807270944,
0.6133215427,
0.5012937188,
-0.1979593039,
-0.4313227534,
-0.3552276492,
-0.4259748161,
-0.4869493842,
0.4896908998,
-0.284550041,
-0.7378825545,
-0.0134915281,
-0.3422936499,
0.0629208535,
0.0373385511,
0.5244832039,
0.2462738901,
1.3511452675,
0.6449509859,
-0.1773592234,
0.6792011261,
-0.170518145,
-0.0348093286,
-0.6711964011,
-0.1525676101,
-0.5105832815,
-0.2636751831,
-0.5587435365,
-0.1592358947,
0.2248091102,
0.2733126283,
-0.3997920156,
0.1548044384,
-0.3074923456,
0.6803264618,
0.8813850284,
0.1179132611,
0.1837566942,
-0.0792257786,
-0.1995304525,
-0.3057253063,
-0.7291144729,
-0.3812169731,
1.0560121536,
0.1817851514,
0.903215766,
-0.0363808088,
0.9548446536,
0.295152545,
0.3261877596,
-0.7122496367,
0.3104029596,
-0.0464917496,
0.0400212519,
-0.4505039752,
-0.6288574934,
-1.0208662748,
0.0956652686,
-0.1508159488,
-0.596239984,
0.1073391959,
0.4334745705,
-0.358418256,
-0.1512069106,
-0.6493791938,
1.0683012009,
-0.2754961252,
-0.3791609704,
-0.6598578691,
-0.4821417034,
0.3000659645,
0.1844290644,
0.1884111464,
0.2340698242,
0.0636659265,
0.6209786534,
-0.3254195154,
0.6589167118,
-0.2862856984,
-0.1112561151,
-0.2725489438,
0.0872008502,
0.9356070161,
0.0244300738,
0.2434078753,
-0.9449230433,
-0.2232604921,
-0.4797127247,
-0.996360898,
0.9340834618,
-0.7704887986,
-0.465062052,
-0.24576886,
-0.5517193079,
-0.3528223932,
-0.0972449481,
0.0311187673,
0.3348713517,
-0.1661248356,
0.1377286762,
0.7421109676,
-0.4399567842,
0.187755689,
0.3804677725,
-0.1165506169,
-0.506732285,
1.374088645,
-0.4145312607,
0.8497307897,
0.578212142,
0.5411843061,
-0.6084039807,
-0.3584209383,
-0.4921310246,
0.1870149076,
-0.5900017023,
0.0301118474,
-0.3138663769,
0.0856416225,
-0.3568647206,
-0.4034276307,
-0.425514102,
-0.2869488001,
-0.1584083289,
-0.0465041399,
0.1985986382,
0.5045180321,
-0.221485272,
0.3599347174,
-0.3310029805,
0.2827599049,
0.4820106328,
0.1275134385,
-0.0967452452,
-0.462913692,
-0.0931153595,
0.2234119475,
-0.4531980157,
-0.3455995619,
0.3926562667,
0.1470428705,
0.6925525069,
0.568503201,
0.4060665965,
0.5850144625,
-0.3219344318,
0.6244636774,
0.3218984306,
-0.6516987085,
0.6089933515,
0.0364548005,
0.2428508103,
0.3502039313,
0.4686964154,
-0.6749800444,
-0.4493667483,
-0.5301567316,
-0.8493465781,
0.7941206098,
-0.113457948,
0.1890287995,
-0.0714984685,
0.1353209466,
-0.0246677753,
0.2277646661,
-0.9482754469,
-0.1123830527,
-0.352157712,
-0.1585205942,
-0.2988309562,
-0.0986132473,
-0.381406486,
-0.0087023787,
1.000212431,
-0.3258175552,
-0.1678430289,
0.0939701051,
-0.1959225535,
-0.4130785167,
0.3490850627,
1.172896266,
0.3911194503,
-0.2889218926,
-0.0503881127,
-0.103973642,
-0.0150948651,
0.0685356334,
0.004314607,
-0.2127682865,
-0.4052667022,
0.1518639177,
1.130471468,
0.2904826403,
-1.0740487576,
0.6109478474,
0.1489459723,
-0.3643989265,
-0.0114059718,
0.4726700485,
-0.0254986528,
0.4107688367,
0.2879864573,
-0.2344953865,
-0.1396970898,
-0.4212103784,
0.2069885582,
0.5861566663,
-0.4257521927,
0.1359582543,
0.6890779734,
-0.1571853906,
-0.4931040704,
0.3882753849,
-0.2330568433,
-0.6886098385,
0.6403993368,
0.7892051935,
0.6559861302,
0.1271562427,
0.3947032988,
0.3737442791,
0.2620618343,
-0.2196368873,
0.1154743358,
-0.4270341098,
-0.7239364982,
-0.8252663612,
-0.3770240545,
-0.5548765063,
0.2359774858,
-0.8099815249,
0.2433573008,
-0.5555643439,
0.2672120035,
-0.1307067722,
0.1140379235,
-0.1512893587,
0.2516711354,
-0.0541599318,
0.590105474,
-0.9737859368,
0.760292232,
0.5023270845,
-0.4415301085,
-0.6369025111,
-0.0928720459,
-0.5165143609,
-0.850810349,
1.0068001747,
-0.0594052561,
-0.3103834391,
0.2051739842,
-0.6019706726,
-0.2932320833,
0.9136807919,
0.3384742737,
-0.4296126962,
0.334621042,
0.1086764187,
0.5485619307,
-0.3906705976,
0.1618957222,
0.3956277072,
0.5378451943,
0.2273924202,
-0.6905388832,
0.0901990235,
0.2050026059,
0.0446942113,
0.3792886436,
-0.4876994789,
0.5417695045,
-0.3101757765,
-0.1891263723,
0.0660301149,
0.5081940293,
0.8084944487,
0.0223747417,
0.7398931384,
0.4600920081,
0.3454335928,
0.0247272979,
1.1349797249,
0.0221816078,
0.3122555315,
0.9726185203,
-0.2842321694,
0.7155093551,
0.7709929347,
-0.1635559797,
0.3991836607,
0.510433495,
0.084253408,
0.920042932,
0.7362588644,
-0.2528733015,
-0.6125309467,
-0.2896898091,
-0.1634897292,
0.0076373718,
0.1971082389,
-0.169481799,
-0.4320555329,
0.1736323982,
-0.3213294446,
0.7841140032,
-0.1873706281,
0.7032213807,
-0.2910583019,
-0.8584493399,
0.973553896,
0.1357854456,
0.8171361685,
-0.735325098,
-0.2893888652,
-0.2619097531,
0.2369435728,
0.122016333,
-0.3081991374,
-0.0088520078,
-0.2632185817,
-0.1825211793,
-0.6097431183,
0.4064853191,
-0.7010296583,
-0.1021227166,
0.1110700443,
0.1219605058,
0.1381778121,
-0.0413852856,
-0.490566045,
-0.1397978812,
0.162853986,
-0.3174345195,
0.6296069622,
0.231074065,
-0.2529805303,
0.9577670693,
0.7529082894,
0.2381884307,
-0.157465443,
0.2426034957,
0.8668374419,
-0.6190539598,
-0.6948318481,
-0.8376583457,
0.1511349529,
-0.0333778709,
-0.3253142238,
0.2833441496,
0.6492930055,
1.2006732225,
-0.2360116392,
0.550260663,
0.2240097672,
0.4788457155,
-0.7481282949,
0.4544287026,
-0.8223457932,
0.0687757879,
-0.0946248174,
-0.5538668036,
-0.1736623943,
0.7736439705,
-0.2524343133,
-0.0365256816,
0.5077449679,
1.038944006,
0.0184078701,
-0.1487924755,
0.5773200989,
-0.2726406157,
0.3350830674,
0.7598103881,
1.0357604027,
-0.0551715158,
0.7250441909,
-0.4087311924,
-0.1974609047,
-0.1914084554,
-1.0515748262,
-0.7794659138,
-0.2075536698,
-0.4075037539,
-0.0674518123,
0.2665242553,
1.2063851357,
0.6224040389,
-0.8594164848,
-0.3509540558,
-0.3292510509,
0.3585201502,
-0.5783663988,
-0.3003979325,
0.2411015332,
-0.6001120806,
-0.8321297169,
0.5994374752,
0.1593049467,
-0.0060267448,
-0.3902369142,
-0.5730526447,
-0.1843977571,
-0.0915311053,
0.3414039314,
0.6832509041,
-0.6812695265,
-0.4017483592,
-0.1400702447,
-0.1868350059,
0.0159252901,
0.9691452384,
-1.082002759,
0.2209407538,
0.3478800058,
0.9689667821,
0.719723165,
0.1599594355,
0.8781917691,
-1.1425881386,
0.0606974363,
0.2436735928,
-0.0364994332,
0.1274226159,
-0.193779096,
0.2598437965,
0.1893964112,
-0.6513029337,
-1.0655585527,
0.4690295458,
-0.7078980803,
-0.2578345537,
1.1535036564,
-0.1422459483,
-0.1154759824,
0.0960673466,
-0.3764989376,
0.1727699041,
-0.5581057072,
0.7959042192,
0.5800753236,
-0.071618177,
-0.2933508456,
-0.4940713346,
0.8940330744,
0.8559539914,
-0.6788834929,
0.2158412486,
0.4868376553,
0.2189122885,
-0.0554290898,
0.5158832669,
0.2058529407,
0.6111389399,
-0.3905063868,
0.3068328798,
-0.296602875,
-0.3160485327,
-0.4005341232,
-0.0940457806,
0.4782314003,
-0.4276153445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19369v1
|
Evaluating Telugu Proficiency in Large Language Models_ A Comparative Analysis of ChatGPT and Gemini
| 2024-04-30T08:55:01 | 2024-04-30T08:55:01 |
Katikela Sreeharsha Kishore, Rahimanuddin Shaik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
The growing prominence of large language models (LLMs) necessitates the
exploration of their capabilities beyond English. This research investigates
the Telugu language proficiency of ChatGPT and Gemini, two leading LLMs.
Through a designed set of 20 questions encompassing greetings, grammar,
vocabulary, common phrases, task completion, and situational reasoning, the
study delves into their strengths and weaknesses in handling Telugu. The
analysis aims to identify the LLM that demonstrates a deeper understanding of
Telugu grammatical structures, possesses a broader vocabulary, and exhibits
superior performance in tasks like writing and reasoning. By comparing their
ability to comprehend and use everyday Telugu expressions, the research sheds
light on their suitability for real-world language interaction. Furthermore,
the evaluation of adaptability and reasoning capabilities provides insights
into how each LLM leverages Telugu to respond to dynamic situations. This
comparative analysis contributes to the ongoing discussion on multilingual
capabilities in AI and paves the way for future research in developing LLMs
that can seamlessly integrate with Telugu-speaking communities.
|
[
-0.259436816,
-0.8456853032,
0.4428287148,
0.4069444537,
-0.1693504602,
0.4616169333,
-0.3646568954,
-0.5954765677,
0.20070602,
0.1593091637,
-0.301889807,
-0.206020385,
-0.745767355,
0.09929391,
-0.4867841005,
0.7247901559,
0.036117617,
0.1822091341,
-0.1960973144,
0.0359491743,
-0.5850185752,
-0.4163731337,
-1.0831292868,
-0.3248525858,
0.3651134968,
0.2319628894,
0.8466471434,
0.1770272255,
0.5874817371,
0.4707750976,
-0.2517412007,
-0.0067483028,
-0.5237378478,
0.2956801653,
-0.0912164822,
-0.3864958882,
-0.4097138345,
-0.218621701,
1.134922266,
0.5052699447,
0.00938424,
0.0589652583,
0.1127676889,
0.2637640238,
-0.2202923596,
0.584679544,
-0.6417121291,
0.0104002552,
-0.2047485411,
0.1761459708,
-0.2842567563,
-0.4754492939,
0.0262493286,
-0.3014857173,
-0.3494687974,
-0.1184748113,
0.8357143402,
0.1640684456,
-0.3954897523,
-0.1540938914,
-0.7099819779,
0.6955730319,
-0.5832223892,
0.3726578355,
0.0426719077,
0.3708223104,
-0.0203473791,
-0.604747951,
-0.5294581652,
-0.687082231,
-0.0152580021,
0.3320925534,
-0.1929196119,
-0.0923976079,
0.1260553598,
0.4731877148,
-0.6813417077,
0.429805994,
-0.4165329635,
-0.3115973473,
0.5794203877,
0.2386492193,
0.415917635,
-0.2285145521,
-0.0365938917,
-0.0261314735,
-0.6955444813,
-0.0038718437,
0.229057014,
0.1655528992,
-0.2927215695,
0.8822800517,
0.1881490499,
0.642809391,
-0.3068856299,
-0.3414583504,
-0.0449936837,
-0.2368408442,
-0.1179526374,
-0.1752805859,
0.7230495811,
0.1286171377,
0.475046128,
-0.1046605855,
-0.1914346367,
-0.0195254199,
0.1455669552,
-0.6309065223,
0.3442465961,
0.2021720558,
-0.3201617301,
0.1374219358,
-0.0726655573,
-0.4730177224,
-0.5123158693,
-0.2338851839,
0.4497395158,
-0.6312061548,
-0.5621285439,
-0.3008382916,
-0.1209396794,
0.7084783912,
0.2324835211,
-0.8382239342,
0.3251356184,
1.34565413,
0.9144820571,
-0.579683423,
-0.7236156464,
-0.3128503561,
-0.1945623904,
-0.3164293468,
0.8240451217,
-0.5402150154,
-0.4821314216,
0.0013261127,
-0.3903401494,
-0.386498332,
-0.6831285357,
0.5064270496,
-0.6040759087,
-0.1228828058,
-0.0264485329,
-0.5115199089,
0.0869312361,
0.5057831407,
-0.446285069,
0.8873141408,
0.3949612677,
-0.7130394578,
0.1837464124,
-0.4964478612,
-0.4758786857,
0.3403734267,
-0.2234836668,
-0.1334038079,
-0.0037880265,
-0.1527115405,
0.5294625163,
-0.227379635,
0.2735428214,
-0.1120306104,
-0.4807783961,
0.603138864,
-0.3762031496,
0.4572011232,
0.3014281988,
0.0659400001,
0.3777249753,
-0.5748927593,
0.1492737234,
0.0256811716,
-0.4912096262,
-0.0300652198,
-0.1813196987,
0.0646257252,
0.1470089257,
0.3890902102,
-0.3181444108,
0.0433253385,
-0.5891766548,
0.5265046358,
0.6473097205,
-0.2578106821,
0.3803393543,
-0.3078600764,
0.7629873157,
-0.084444806,
0.1353696883,
-0.1133534387,
-0.8133463264,
-0.8251932859,
-0.2250717878,
0.4026289284,
0.6651038527,
-0.6791533232,
0.0926692858,
-0.4239169061,
-0.6803801656,
-0.5113121867,
0.1021281183,
0.5601863265,
0.3204127252,
0.1242802367,
-0.4461581409,
-0.4765480459,
-0.9164272547,
-0.296302706,
-0.283551991,
0.1916872263,
0.2722373903,
0.5732895136,
-0.0694168285,
0.6510539651,
-0.3443662226,
0.0959226489,
-0.8372224569,
-0.2257783264,
0.2555792034,
0.1762955785,
0.3729174435,
-0.9493058324,
-0.7601410747,
0.1147234961,
-0.6349659562,
0.0747601986,
0.18643938,
0.1011274904,
0.3861992061,
0.5007776022,
-0.8180110455,
0.258608669,
0.6648851633,
-0.4570986331,
0.8016744852,
-0.3129038811,
0.0816781446,
-1.0848687887,
0.0158933345,
-0.01043991,
-0.0006663515,
-0.813015759,
0.2910900414,
-0.0473671667,
-0.1729004681,
-0.4385066628,
0.7957038283,
-0.4205454588,
-0.5417605042,
-0.1936877072,
0.3137235343,
-0.4831476808,
-0.003758003,
0.2765134573,
0.8538982868,
0.7674914598,
-0.4303472638,
0.5134943128,
0.0902549624,
-0.4124136865,
0.76733464,
-0.786295712,
-0.0833775029,
-0.1032125428,
-0.0582959391,
-1.1980313063,
-0.320163697,
0.0499487892,
-0.7769834995,
0.3056581914,
-0.2867287695,
-0.385206461,
-0.2229475528,
-0.0761384964,
-0.0123176556,
0.5669657588,
-0.0040313136,
0.7285965085,
0.4121258855,
-0.508494556,
-0.5421831012,
-0.5948514938,
0.3133832216,
-0.3943039477,
-0.7230606675,
0.2462611198,
-0.0559464842,
-0.8305963278,
-0.3511750698,
0.1429170221,
-0.1868133247,
0.0882417262,
0.3518204689,
0.4276059568,
-0.5305749178,
0.0977128297,
-0.0421482921,
-0.2984550297,
0.0147982305,
0.0021738219,
0.9138836861,
-0.5126715899,
-0.3385331035,
-0.1415127069,
0.1594699472,
0.5502997637,
-0.37114802,
1.0241292715,
0.6425665617,
-0.2280864567,
0.2528941035,
-0.5746244192,
0.1150588468,
-0.4400357902,
0.522531569,
-0.4732244611,
-0.8523111343,
0.6908300519,
0.3021939695,
0.0984624773,
0.4761784673,
0.8180155754,
0.1436199546,
0.4816189706,
0.4734943211,
-0.2300150692,
0.357247144,
-0.2016201168,
0.0672650933,
-0.7857041955,
-0.3707116246,
-0.5809169412,
-0.1313836128,
-0.6998382807,
-0.4835329354,
0.3279913962,
-0.4514327049,
-0.3664227724,
0.3137617409,
-0.1157332361,
0.4180063009,
0.416215688,
-0.3048113883,
0.4661297202,
-0.2089113891,
-0.1611937433,
-0.0652431101,
-0.481161356,
-0.4870868921,
0.8899994493,
0.31219396,
0.5858203173,
0.4215242565,
0.4322202206,
0.0071395622,
0.334620744,
-0.9658590555,
0.7540931106,
-0.0896226242,
-0.5218865871,
-0.3394538164,
-0.4444893897,
-1.0813800097,
0.5051075816,
-0.2827059031,
-0.750911355,
-0.4767601192,
-0.2504518628,
-0.1153352857,
0.0349549353,
-0.9734538794,
0.7570866942,
-0.2631074786,
-0.1994367987,
-0.4057106376,
-0.498585552,
0.2411892414,
-0.0707631856,
0.2004621327,
-0.087120831,
-0.3507750928,
0.4537856877,
-0.0068943426,
0.7084089518,
0.1694097966,
-0.1001130417,
0.2678111792,
0.0532951169,
-0.0659662709,
0.1730060428,
-0.3242254257,
0.0331124552,
-0.0257322192,
-0.2654610872,
-0.2752386332,
1.0349724293,
-0.9845992923,
-0.5005859733,
-0.6239744425,
-0.6178756356,
-0.4360287786,
0.2284748256,
0.0044204202,
0.1662616879,
-0.4638861716,
-0.0264132433,
0.4850169718,
-0.2501562238,
0.6327111125,
0.7120782733,
-0.4712688625,
-0.2275911868,
0.7737538815,
0.1946175098,
0.4267880619,
0.5566809177,
0.2185607851,
-0.4988958836,
-0.705309689,
-0.4396639168,
0.4089193344,
-0.7106103301,
0.2093931586,
-0.4034229517,
-0.5418106318,
-0.5263314843,
0.1907175779,
-0.3941776752,
-0.4237892628,
0.0317084454,
0.1968014538,
0.1771080941,
0.8679124117,
0.2665852606,
0.3479282856,
-0.749899447,
0.2446556836,
0.30005005,
0.3668096662,
0.0297261383,
-0.8151654005,
-0.0092457402,
-0.1405122578,
-0.4277344346,
-0.8557829261,
0.322448194,
0.2013992667,
0.7670735121,
0.2796824872,
-0.5055930018,
0.6801064014,
-0.1849193424,
0.709215641,
-0.1022173092,
-1.0072529316,
0.4080255032,
-0.3722602427,
0.3905621171,
0.1649802327,
0.6256451011,
-0.7718521953,
-0.3262599409,
-0.6497914791,
-0.5874980092,
0.4384020269,
0.4326657355,
0.218588531,
0.2034537345,
0.5877651572,
-0.082390599,
0.0529592298,
-0.7555487752,
-0.2130696177,
0.1022192389,
-0.0200229622,
-0.3414128125,
-0.1066387892,
0.3345505297,
-0.4079022706,
0.5164170861,
-0.1124307215,
0.159550935,
-0.2612941265,
-0.1253102273,
0.3353210092,
0.4288011491,
0.4728655517,
0.8550767899,
0.2905792594,
0.0476192273,
0.5961780548,
-0.7468771935,
-0.0443526916,
0.1552628428,
-0.0572079644,
-0.2230747044,
0.5836825371,
0.4855086803,
0.1586700976,
-0.9161405563,
0.2297734618,
-0.2334114015,
0.3995755017,
-0.5730550289,
0.3098821342,
0.5389695764,
0.3105821609,
0.1669062674,
-0.1935158819,
-0.1478952318,
-0.8859961033,
-0.2249267846,
0.6216175556,
-0.2556973398,
-0.2506411374,
0.1379844248,
0.0196872819,
-0.5424610376,
0.8834982514,
-0.0522702448,
-0.4708641768,
0.8532667756,
0.6930996776,
0.4868960679,
-0.5419104695,
0.1028298736,
0.3304311931,
0.3203678727,
0.0173077732,
0.3815930188,
0.2761278152,
-0.8882459402,
-0.6545314789,
-0.6747012734,
-0.7643299103,
0.152500391,
-0.3622669578,
0.3937906027,
-0.3447287977,
-0.224763751,
0.1811038852,
0.1403714418,
-0.1936165094,
0.1733037233,
0.2483236641,
0.8181927204,
-0.5316992998,
0.8848135471,
0.8448177576,
-0.319439739,
-0.7599348426,
-0.1334160119,
-0.0751742646,
-1.0818375349,
0.5352891684,
0.1657786071,
0.0143896956,
-0.1284218878,
-0.0707124844,
-0.6639199257,
0.8988964558,
0.5065168142,
-0.2927586436,
0.0653045252,
0.5921375751,
0.9852566123,
-0.3044803441,
0.7086294889,
0.8671323657,
0.5814479589,
0.292544961,
-1.3953328133,
-0.3462607861,
-0.3025825322,
0.0008614034,
0.1802664846,
-0.9130117893,
0.8013449907,
-0.2944477797,
0.0354452021,
0.2752934098,
0.7107789516,
0.3204039931,
0.1807967871,
0.2197416574,
0.2998865545,
0.5345582962,
-0.4238309562,
0.9772359133,
-0.2519856393,
0.0161859635,
0.9560438991,
-0.2539530694,
1.1845602989,
0.371497035,
-0.3899441361,
0.2640900314,
0.4343964159,
-0.0224607736,
-0.1135466695,
0.3625502884,
-0.2187470943,
-0.1917894036,
0.0151454257,
-0.2915326059,
0.944952786,
0.5291572213,
-0.1319829673,
-0.1265420318,
-0.0738113225,
0.2714443207,
0.0569299087,
-0.4643147588,
0.760504365,
0.3106667399,
-1.3054368496,
0.4303646386,
0.2383587211,
0.6481876969,
-0.7846123576,
0.1077832729,
-0.3805675805,
0.4470173717,
-0.1535836905,
-1.3159791231,
0.739448905,
0.1675461978,
0.3962220848,
-0.1298623234,
0.8911916018,
-0.1446720511,
-0.3827642202,
0.1371132582,
0.7038163543,
0.3896952868,
-0.1414225399,
-0.6974133253,
0.2904585302,
-0.2196568847,
0.0831057206,
0.5541659594,
0.1563226879,
-0.0605534688,
1.112754941,
0.2851065695,
0.2087706178,
0.0665704533,
0.1074622348,
0.7271731496,
-0.6661624908,
-0.3013256788,
-1.0192008018,
0.2087443471,
-0.0735763982,
-0.5078367591,
1.0236233473,
0.8389731646,
0.5043768287,
-0.1077130064,
0.6430353522,
-0.18559663,
0.3825340271,
-0.3851502538,
0.8033903837,
-0.1994082183,
0.3432579041,
-0.1359124035,
-0.9431068897,
-0.149930492,
0.6288753748,
-0.3814907968,
0.31330055,
0.5218441486,
0.7026363015,
0.1022906378,
0.0398754328,
0.4198067784,
0.4808677733,
0.2779332995,
0.7080349326,
1.3705921173,
-0.1177392825,
0.6439856887,
-0.0144650619,
-0.2091370821,
0.0566405244,
-0.8930146694,
-1.0951411724,
-0.6597168446,
-0.128085494,
-0.3440748155,
-0.0121856295,
0.6586539745,
0.3741335571,
-0.6115465164,
-0.5109732747,
0.3154897094,
0.3389486074,
-0.068668887,
-0.1699259281,
0.2899801135,
-0.0821825787,
-0.8807524443,
0.2320896685,
0.3193602562,
0.1231929958,
-0.6340405345,
-0.1890756786,
0.1051120237,
0.2240065634,
0.7727807164,
0.1871581525,
-0.5755486488,
0.0201799255,
0.0970401168,
-0.0555838607,
0.1255642027,
0.5576116443,
-0.6463611126,
-0.0671411976,
0.5997437239,
0.1981966197,
0.4600088,
-0.2452466339,
0.1977553517,
-0.3547131121,
0.1440195441,
0.2671441734,
0.4482412636,
0.49007833,
-0.0835544989,
0.3231735826,
-0.0155846523,
-0.5456715822,
-0.47307235,
0.1795786023,
-1.0681540966,
-0.0508169718,
1.3793115616,
-0.3092150986,
0.0373154357,
-0.3289813697,
-0.4355839491,
0.0348333456,
-0.2554325461,
0.7905498743,
0.878867507,
-0.2217987925,
-0.224655062,
-0.5030452013,
0.2401986271,
0.2217181325,
-1.1051242352,
-0.2081933469,
0.232248202,
0.3797086775,
0.1393925548,
0.6301960349,
-0.2248429954,
0.3066157699,
-0.0498395003,
-0.5003826618,
0.110052973,
-0.1642732471,
-0.3008801043,
0.1505964547,
0.578576684,
0.4659332633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19364v1
|
Navigating Brain Language Representations: A Comparative Analysis of Neural Language Models and Psychologically Plausible Models
| 2024-04-30T08:48:07 | 2024-04-30T08:48:07 |
Yunhao Zhang, Shaonan Wang, Xinyi Dong, Jiajun Yu, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural language models, particularly large-scale ones, have been consistently
proven to be most effective in predicting brain neural activity across a range
of studies. However, previous research overlooked the comparison of these
models with psychologically plausible ones. Moreover, evaluations were reliant
on limited, single-modality, and English cognitive datasets. To address these
questions, we conducted an analysis comparing encoding performance of various
neural language models and psychologically plausible models. Our study utilized
extensive multi-modal cognitive datasets, examining bilingual word and
discourse levels. Surprisingly, our findings revealed that psychologically
plausible models outperformed neural language models across diverse contexts,
encompassing different modalities such as fMRI and eye-tracking, and spanning
languages from English to Chinese. Among psychologically plausible models, the
one incorporating embodied information emerged as particularly exceptional.
This model demonstrated superior performance at both word and discourse levels,
exhibiting robust prediction of brain activation across numerous regions in
both English and Chinese.
|
[
-0.1914558113,
-0.6998744011,
0.695268333,
0.6530754566,
0.1044661477,
-0.0887288228,
-0.7384640574,
-0.4474672079,
0.0445672572,
0.0121832108,
-0.3242289126,
-0.2159845829,
-0.6840482354,
0.0169898234,
-0.3260556161,
0.4280633926,
0.2737352252,
0.5039162636,
-0.380631119,
-0.0798061118,
-0.698906064,
-0.8238828182,
-0.8269760609,
-0.8280303478,
0.6336296201,
-0.6249755025,
0.8360136747,
0.4099053144,
0.1758446991,
0.3217165768,
-0.1155606732,
0.0154879028,
-0.1740219742,
-0.0918042138,
-0.1028652564,
-0.6452394128,
-0.379088968,
-0.0701636449,
0.5446936488,
0.9788546562,
-0.3265292645,
-0.265183419,
0.2274480313,
0.304623276,
-0.5523118973,
0.3355032206,
-0.6291424036,
0.1048158407,
0.0408474542,
-0.0385755152,
-0.8968082666,
-0.0018937085,
0.3318955898,
-0.4939838946,
-0.218967557,
-0.2528859973,
0.7338606715,
-0.1637880206,
-0.7460352182,
-0.2588287592,
-0.7675549388,
0.7269131541,
-0.758122921,
0.785353303,
0.6907353401,
0.1050035581,
-0.0041431258,
-0.6221109033,
-0.5453699231,
-0.5057659149,
-0.251493156,
0.0889214352,
-0.3305172622,
0.242356509,
0.3101320267,
0.0153413033,
-0.677418828,
0.2372102588,
-0.0082564875,
-0.3849015534,
0.4430736303,
0.2198750675,
0.5034790635,
-0.2797022164,
-0.0992150232,
-0.2677748203,
-0.5429831147,
0.0497869626,
0.0890282765,
0.4723079801,
-0.2583027184,
0.5433282256,
0.1944736093,
0.6164217591,
0.0263412632,
-0.1354157627,
0.0678517818,
-0.2251327932,
-0.1664963812,
-0.049555935,
0.8068239689,
0.3835530281,
0.2859822214,
-0.5623826981,
-0.326210767,
0.2887313664,
0.354332298,
-0.5228590369,
-0.1901190132,
0.143509537,
-0.7572416067,
0.2771485448,
0.0177931786,
-0.4274681211,
-0.5213585496,
-0.2598593533,
0.2525161207,
-0.8298307657,
-0.6253317595,
0.2292537391,
0.0056083528,
0.2425752282,
0.1762856692,
-1.0875200033,
0.1858796924,
0.8000298142,
0.8916140795,
-0.1578629911,
-0.4167169631,
0.1945295036,
0.0098894266,
-0.5062195063,
0.612683177,
-0.6031413078,
-0.1670644879,
0.260084033,
-0.2078244984,
-0.3133069277,
-0.3170687556,
0.2404489666,
-0.7730985284,
0.2610872984,
-0.6458336115,
-0.4447667897,
-0.3680974245,
0.224927932,
-0.8649649024,
0.7189568281,
-0.0689662769,
-0.6760605574,
0.3941594362,
-0.3374143541,
-0.4959281385,
-0.2484516948,
-0.3405565619,
0.2311252505,
0.3992697597,
0.0511362962,
0.6222313643,
-0.3904738128,
0.407671243,
-0.1555335373,
-0.3312117457,
0.6658751965,
-0.7148595452,
0.9846054316,
0.0250434373,
-0.2188173383,
-0.2108766288,
-0.4675647914,
-0.0218552835,
0.115960829,
-0.3713005483,
-0.482280761,
0.2053507119,
0.1379932314,
0.2696986794,
0.2797316015,
-0.5714704394,
-0.0723113343,
-0.3710973859,
0.4328490794,
0.5323185325,
-0.405336827,
0.7333787084,
-0.0284709018,
0.4852726161,
0.0906493366,
-0.3038050234,
-0.3593094051,
-0.5728840232,
-0.4708201587,
-0.1266334355,
0.4869366884,
0.4438118637,
-0.6719766855,
0.1416198909,
-0.4500248432,
-0.3523929715,
-0.4602637887,
-0.3995272517,
0.3908669055,
0.263644278,
0.2921953797,
-0.0683170632,
-0.4960817099,
-0.9868253469,
-0.375726521,
-0.4831167161,
-0.155377239,
0.1502787918,
0.2616182864,
-0.2104254365,
0.5138213634,
-0.2063530385,
0.0780146345,
-0.2156265378,
0.4243541956,
0.1995482296,
0.3805895746,
0.7426080704,
-0.5069873333,
-0.3047731519,
0.3609904349,
-0.9307422042,
0.2392321229,
-0.4748941362,
0.0970049426,
0.2752899826,
0.3788381219,
-0.6583537459,
0.4695746005,
0.6083933115,
-0.321387887,
0.4288547337,
-0.4325875938,
0.2827489674,
-0.7357744575,
0.1205993071,
0.0078657856,
0.017103374,
-0.7984078526,
-0.1352510154,
0.4479365349,
0.1460478604,
0.0578797907,
0.3981737494,
-0.6898621917,
0.0956439078,
-0.3808512092,
-0.0794718564,
-0.3608531654,
0.7037280798,
0.2671752274,
0.68066293,
0.9097616076,
-0.4581348896,
0.0609461851,
-0.0900041237,
-0.3687759638,
0.1672201902,
-0.6085041165,
0.0991730839,
-0.4108857214,
0.2085124552,
-1.156357646,
-0.2096947432,
-0.1947757453,
-0.4827948511,
0.4272556901,
0.1990869492,
-0.5926988125,
-0.0685860068,
0.0425909534,
0.6046985388,
0.5087038875,
-0.2508116066,
0.8015956283,
0.4095071256,
0.0888108313,
-0.4380125403,
-1.2133643627,
0.3119249046,
-0.0639658123,
-0.4984286129,
0.6379712224,
0.0931745619,
-0.0826853514,
-0.2238853574,
0.0205933154,
-0.1737552285,
-0.0910967886,
0.220541507,
0.1553652734,
-0.5049073696,
0.0008971609,
-0.0842595473,
-0.0184029788,
0.5913469791,
-0.0923427418,
0.6034122705,
-0.1232216656,
-0.4068297744,
-0.2503175437,
0.4799680114,
0.650455296,
-0.1781652272,
0.9641779661,
0.4422013462,
-0.8515170813,
-0.0522980541,
-0.4633367658,
-0.3405402899,
-0.4246318042,
0.5106574893,
-0.5269445181,
-0.5686563849,
0.7721806765,
0.1114063114,
-0.1572967321,
0.0298999343,
0.3860846758,
-0.0230322592,
1.5825304985,
0.6973339915,
0.0787876472,
0.5637318492,
-0.1736767292,
0.3099319041,
-0.774710834,
-0.3927907646,
-0.2711849809,
-0.196239084,
-0.6916383505,
-0.4677091539,
0.2539694011,
-0.2650451064,
-0.0936621577,
0.4303283393,
-0.2134292722,
0.3541327417,
0.276480943,
0.0521020815,
-0.0066079614,
0.2217209488,
-0.5425414443,
-0.431079179,
-1.0254193544,
-0.4860757291,
1.0786352158,
0.3697631657,
0.513828218,
0.0060591577,
0.124371998,
-0.0990519151,
0.2811906636,
-0.6319262385,
0.665719986,
-0.1774588823,
-0.6874762177,
0.0760199875,
-0.1764333844,
-1.031430006,
0.4422824979,
-0.3680721223,
-0.9528378844,
0.2451548725,
-0.2001452595,
-0.3724156618,
0.3047268987,
-0.6667283773,
0.7092052698,
-0.3758404255,
-0.2642713487,
-0.5023607612,
-0.4246098101,
0.3250797391,
-0.0580265746,
0.1786850542,
0.3345743716,
-0.2912470698,
0.5964841247,
0.1051058844,
0.7900716662,
-0.112974517,
-0.2716361284,
-0.0775634199,
0.2151447237,
-0.1206643134,
-0.1100787967,
-0.4246425033,
0.4601620436,
0.0541211665,
-0.3315594792,
-0.8572599292,
0.7404930592,
-0.7424116135,
-0.3947367668,
-0.4475980401,
-0.4760532081,
-0.300845027,
0.2009161562,
0.3440716267,
0.4994368255,
-0.3357365131,
0.1462468207,
0.5859149098,
-0.3215548396,
0.6407437325,
0.1458890587,
-0.2691560388,
-0.460128665,
0.7502657175,
0.31321612,
-0.0013072069,
0.6095660925,
-0.0897154734,
-0.422516197,
-0.5915567875,
-0.2098235339,
0.3968138993,
-0.6106321216,
0.0806328431,
-0.5168682337,
-0.091423735,
-0.3133716285,
0.0145896068,
-0.4448937476,
-0.1627742946,
0.0534631498,
-0.1067614257,
-0.0747888312,
0.7042855024,
-0.1826983094,
0.297617197,
-0.3727445602,
0.1139443964,
0.1073208675,
0.4395310283,
0.5991659164,
-0.2549775243,
-0.6150148511,
0.445761025,
-0.0552420914,
-1.3584071398,
0.2543621361,
0.0194855239,
0.8036035895,
0.5271294713,
-0.4030293524,
0.8334369659,
-0.6129673719,
1.0018645525,
0.3724921048,
-0.7774578333,
0.2321283519,
-0.3847289383,
0.4794847667,
0.310103327,
0.6134120822,
-0.520901382,
-0.2564471066,
-0.4433997571,
-0.7583324313,
0.5949565768,
0.1394968778,
0.2476101816,
-0.2574844062,
0.2944973111,
0.1457162499,
0.058274053,
-0.9750908613,
-0.3485521078,
-0.1403645873,
0.0135993129,
-0.063738957,
0.0023198249,
0.1867905706,
-0.3646275103,
0.1843187511,
-0.0913854986,
0.8662026525,
0.1004515886,
-0.0982916653,
0.2748031318,
-0.1150398403,
0.4535498321,
0.6323181987,
0.0113191726,
0.3113405108,
0.2390092909,
-0.4132005572,
-0.0571041554,
-0.2000318766,
-0.0106764734,
0.1680551022,
0.6602060795,
0.8872093558,
0.3302928805,
-0.6557098031,
0.3207554221,
-0.2423683703,
0.0973062813,
-0.3267939389,
-0.2222305834,
0.5037664771,
0.2356939018,
0.2200032175,
0.1610657275,
0.0708314702,
-0.6688815951,
-0.1117208079,
0.6035683751,
-0.2282156646,
-0.6700277328,
0.6840299368,
-0.1183621436,
-0.3414764702,
0.7632278204,
-0.0216349717,
-0.5376684666,
0.5139532089,
0.7576507926,
0.9569842219,
-0.1762393862,
0.0154902199,
0.7118076682,
0.4431498945,
-0.1943181306,
0.2676633894,
-0.1402208805,
-0.9415826797,
-0.5392223001,
-0.2035546452,
0.0805749074,
0.2748008966,
-0.7232970595,
-0.1017660946,
-0.33754161,
-0.6675867438,
-0.0167057216,
-0.3286318183,
-0.8017935157,
0.2229156792,
0.6496758461,
1.0382964611,
-0.944247365,
1.0086519718,
1.0647572279,
-0.3657766581,
-0.8573427796,
0.1056548133,
-0.2707392871,
-0.5730758309,
0.4506446123,
0.1654881239,
-0.2126657367,
-0.305267483,
-0.2046083212,
-0.7884566188,
1.0123304129,
0.7049785852,
-0.0746754259,
-0.3508124352,
0.3510822356,
0.859333396,
-0.4886209965,
0.6453050971,
0.4541350901,
0.5405219793,
-0.3425180316,
-0.8683001995,
0.2168222964,
-0.4235892594,
0.3033950627,
-0.2135786414,
-0.39722386,
0.8099788427,
-0.0023164595,
-0.4246949852,
0.101311475,
1.0981874466,
0.2385736853,
0.2159689069,
0.39816311,
0.1141867787,
0.8353940845,
-0.0861602575,
1.0779500008,
-0.5316928029,
-0.0384319276,
0.7179247737,
-0.0862955749,
0.9586413503,
0.6084626317,
-0.1209062263,
0.697668314,
0.5684447885,
0.349250108,
0.6185365319,
-0.0043263119,
-0.0759296939,
-0.3821881413,
0.0152962562,
-0.2730295956,
0.5750780702,
0.4861857593,
-0.3059933782,
-0.1092567369,
0.132300213,
-0.0066326191,
0.2398065925,
-0.0760336891,
0.561322093,
0.1675492525,
-1.0906312466,
0.8092648387,
0.2622102499,
0.9168131351,
-0.7851603031,
0.0722340196,
-0.3458008468,
-0.104341872,
0.0285117738,
-0.694837451,
0.2443541437,
0.0060928464,
-0.1607560515,
-0.6775935292,
0.7790990472,
-0.4927720129,
-0.1444197893,
0.693770647,
0.5792545676,
-0.0285642426,
-0.1325309426,
-0.6322809458,
0.1399546266,
-0.0390759371,
-0.2900392115,
0.401899159,
0.5245019197,
-0.0766487718,
0.6869940162,
0.3818586171,
0.3218507767,
0.3199731112,
-0.0948651433,
0.4916577041,
-0.9045082331,
-0.53418082,
-0.8803422451,
0.6199983358,
-0.0304324962,
-0.3011823297,
0.7793064117,
0.4515042007,
0.7448292971,
-0.224383533,
0.5986465216,
-0.0720343292,
-0.1687764972,
-0.4488695264,
0.834821105,
-0.4952436686,
0.1284757257,
-0.272023648,
-0.7493425608,
-0.1632666588,
0.9495898485,
-0.2260754406,
0.2586335242,
0.9433446527,
0.9185797572,
-0.2783212662,
0.3053180873,
0.3949239254,
0.3920181394,
0.0315603167,
0.797347784,
1.0428199768,
-0.4341698885,
0.0755501315,
-0.2390060723,
-0.2833167315,
0.1872590482,
-1.0337955952,
-0.8046510816,
-0.941173017,
-0.2641445994,
-0.2557174563,
-0.2580491304,
0.8450016379,
0.9490455985,
-0.6242893934,
-0.6197633147,
0.044335857,
-0.1268646419,
-0.4607541561,
-0.1681943238,
0.1889896542,
-0.0396801755,
-0.7454491258,
0.6534007192,
0.1187920198,
-0.1093951985,
-0.5471883416,
-0.1097374335,
-0.1956357658,
0.2874493301,
0.7989450693,
0.08504536,
-0.8532876968,
-0.1312383413,
0.3907077312,
-0.4779635072,
-0.1249727905,
0.8690152168,
-0.942902565,
0.2408595979,
0.6793385148,
0.6920318007,
0.3469890654,
-0.5886867642,
0.9638101459,
-0.3919686973,
0.1189653575,
0.119581677,
0.5512714386,
0.3676034212,
-0.2595591247,
0.2755862176,
-0.138094753,
-0.2314496189,
-0.8758830428,
0.134958759,
-1.1870719194,
-0.4129281044,
1.193854928,
-0.1435455084,
-0.3884203732,
0.1687748879,
-0.162671715,
0.2799959183,
-0.1069904491,
0.8401644826,
1.0709139109,
-0.2066736519,
0.1112085953,
-0.6224336624,
0.2147317976,
0.7731266022,
-0.2203281224,
0.1486436874,
0.4526563287,
-0.0292787813,
0.3344877958,
0.5320786238,
-0.0894155875,
0.3131360114,
0.1944941878,
-0.2079602927,
0.2292061001,
-0.3154428005,
-0.5026623607,
0.2949873805,
-0.0274798367,
0.0553191639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19363v1
|
Expressivity and Speech Synthesis
| 2024-04-30T08:47:24 | 2024-04-30T08:47:24 |
Andreas Triantafyllopoulos, Björn W. Schuller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Imbuing machines with the ability to talk has been a longtime pursuit of
artificial intelligence (AI) research. From the very beginning, the community
has not only aimed to synthesise high-fidelity speech that accurately conveys
the semantic meaning of an utterance, but also to colour it with inflections
that cover the same range of affective expressions that humans are capable of.
After many years of research, it appears that we are on the cusp of achieving
this when it comes to single, isolated utterances. This unveils an abundance of
potential avenues to explore when it comes to combining these single utterances
with the aim of synthesising more complex, longer-term behaviours. In the
present chapter, we outline the methodological advances that brought us so far
and sketch out the ongoing efforts to reach that coveted next level of
artificial expressivity. We also discuss the societal implications coupled with
rapidly advancing expressive speech synthesis (ESS) technology and highlight
ways to mitigate those risks and ensure the alignment of ESS capabilities with
ethical norms.
|
[
-0.4074653089,
-0.7137480974,
0.3398412168,
0.2809097469,
0.3352856338,
0.5990089178,
-0.3601297736,
-0.7610343695,
0.5267184973,
0.5007661581,
-0.4852631986,
-0.0558376014,
-0.5112267137,
0.1454662383,
-0.6045333147,
0.5967314243,
0.2439745665,
-0.2070993334,
-0.2561233342,
-0.4522852302,
-0.0371050015,
-0.9624722004,
-0.6144729853,
-0.0691683069,
0.3542437851,
0.4192609489,
0.7524276376,
0.4228338599,
0.2292091995,
0.3988358974,
-0.1947814524,
0.2178130299,
-0.1816848814,
0.5840975046,
-0.080764316,
-0.4153160751,
-0.2953469455,
0.0948835984,
0.6069792509,
0.755269587,
0.1647301465,
0.133660689,
0.0099063497,
0.6768380404,
-0.2795152664,
0.0180963725,
-0.5230587721,
0.0865931883,
-0.0600216016,
0.0406601503,
-0.3531194329,
-0.1745755374,
0.0269888528,
-0.4478820264,
-0.1166847795,
-0.0253752731,
0.3586182296,
0.3245690167,
-0.1886145622,
-0.5543886423,
-0.9056851864,
0.8200014234,
-0.7476962805,
0.3102302551,
0.1881120652,
0.2147718966,
-0.0815794766,
-1.1835143566,
-0.7080373764,
-0.445517242,
-0.0171609446,
-0.0021704994,
-0.524359405,
0.2199367434,
0.3476220369,
0.0854617655,
-0.0399856493,
0.0831568018,
-0.7776935697,
-0.2275351584,
0.8211324811,
0.0838022307,
0.6675434709,
0.088876918,
0.0104124211,
0.0602007173,
-0.8541773558,
0.1114051417,
0.6553586125,
0.5339533687,
0.1665805429,
0.5878485441,
-0.2995617986,
0.442115128,
-0.1523075253,
0.333234936,
0.2027595341,
-0.3576577306,
0.0506563969,
0.1880076677,
0.601791501,
0.0804923102,
-0.0368607119,
-0.1209078357,
-0.1508071721,
0.389682889,
0.3800438643,
-0.6922647953,
0.2263129652,
0.4774552882,
-0.359108597,
-0.2899518013,
-0.1237962767,
-0.7534650564,
-0.361685127,
-0.8048560619,
0.4336492419,
-0.1971004009,
-0.4713908434,
-0.003944668,
-0.3563569784,
0.170828864,
0.0818659812,
-1.0586826801,
0.720172286,
0.7948543429,
0.5631539822,
-0.1632315665,
-0.2625041604,
-0.5130816698,
0.2719715238,
-0.36187163,
0.4813625216,
-0.7707301378,
-0.4814556837,
-0.0193873066,
-0.1447398663,
0.2526870966,
-0.736344099,
0.6970870495,
0.0980309397,
0.3029541373,
-0.2554263473,
-0.4015586078,
-0.1056052893,
-0.2311366349,
-0.4375783801,
0.7947158813,
-0.0248398241,
-0.1519544572,
-0.2263544053,
-1.1597025394,
-0.8087340593,
-0.0575195551,
-0.2881962359,
-0.1171126068,
0.5167334676,
-0.0565123968,
0.1799840331,
0.0180042163,
-0.0874899775,
0.0190950837,
-0.1809311658,
0.4976533651,
-0.2801301181,
0.5320030451,
0.292637825,
-0.4602719247,
0.4094290733,
-0.5654707551,
0.1219583824,
-0.3671450615,
0.2116331011,
-0.0560311563,
0.3644625545,
0.1186278686,
0.2982618809,
0.2337562889,
-0.5483411551,
-0.3433057368,
-0.7896807194,
1.389981389,
0.7310156226,
-0.1531140059,
0.5271478295,
-0.4670860469,
0.6006854773,
-0.2184171081,
0.3134986758,
-0.3358950019,
-0.4667158127,
-0.6476542354,
-0.221068114,
-0.1785757393,
0.4512644112,
-0.1363243014,
0.2805542946,
0.0739128888,
-0.5553756952,
-0.9592334032,
-0.3497537673,
0.1514227837,
0.3512816727,
0.1863693148,
-0.1868320554,
-0.6169010997,
-1.197909832,
-0.4400458336,
-0.2744399011,
0.0519618131,
0.2154008001,
0.1756805629,
0.0552701131,
0.748953104,
-0.1429440528,
-0.0955391452,
-0.0811932608,
0.1337486058,
0.1567045599,
0.7804151177,
0.270424217,
-1.0714486837,
-0.2266658098,
0.1306242943,
-0.7214148045,
0.1375531703,
-0.1322018206,
0.0033307578,
0.0471451432,
0.8393607736,
-0.7385320663,
0.3514093161,
0.2890031934,
0.0190164279,
0.230152905,
-0.0410772525,
0.4609804451,
-0.6983487606,
-0.0320554823,
-0.420599848,
-0.1051741615,
-0.9119777679,
0.0040338803,
-0.4802908599,
-0.497281611,
-0.7538102269,
0.5691252351,
-0.5358593464,
-0.1427976787,
-0.2758403122,
0.3217863142,
-0.1667361259,
0.3356729448,
-0.3090035617,
0.7744711637,
0.7137792706,
-0.5683316588,
0.4832407832,
0.3336721361,
-0.0268993974,
0.6788718104,
-0.8589922786,
0.3974556923,
-0.1927198917,
-0.1880894303,
-0.8774559498,
-0.3749228716,
0.0339998901,
-0.856672883,
0.0959095359,
0.2522653937,
-0.1054297015,
-0.2698124349,
-0.1107280552,
0.2773633599,
0.8075518012,
-0.1246599481,
0.9434509873,
0.9071505666,
-0.7943297029,
-0.2190196663,
-0.9955540895,
0.5269039869,
-0.4883500636,
-0.690363884,
0.2850610018,
-0.1478312761,
-0.5714190602,
-0.1663563401,
0.0196966995,
0.0948367491,
0.2013151497,
0.4755423665,
-0.2856282294,
0.1625029594,
0.0669067726,
0.4684538543,
-0.1492215991,
0.2471442819,
0.0109944325,
0.2501571774,
-0.2535946369,
-0.4591870904,
-0.7001793385,
1.1468163729,
0.8817793131,
-0.2437468767,
0.3037897944,
0.1919004172,
-0.5316144824,
-0.1549926549,
-0.1241715252,
-0.4063504338,
-0.5012272596,
0.4468688965,
-0.3403208256,
-0.8185675144,
0.4997936487,
-0.3807891607,
0.0387374796,
0.0978771895,
0.4661361873,
-0.128598392,
1.3335946798,
0.4389056861,
0.3001237214,
0.6849594712,
0.1144776717,
0.4442022741,
-0.9061443806,
-0.1258012652,
-0.7128831148,
-0.3915505111,
-0.9564458728,
-0.0627068505,
0.5850718021,
-0.2873419523,
-0.3538756669,
0.0446146503,
-0.860468924,
0.3136036992,
0.7637943625,
0.1242406443,
-0.0291577391,
-0.0894322768,
0.5060876012,
-0.1062977836,
-0.3550564945,
-0.74421525,
0.8530458212,
0.1549634337,
0.3316604197,
0.2557204664,
0.7211782336,
0.477083832,
0.364107877,
-0.673568368,
0.6930153966,
-0.177392453,
-0.5536106229,
-0.265294075,
0.1522199959,
-0.9272441268,
0.1793623567,
-0.2038577646,
-0.6465424299,
-0.0705616996,
0.2536700666,
0.0488230735,
-0.0390091203,
-0.7430950403,
0.6079106927,
-0.2224006802,
-0.5009959936,
-0.383672297,
-1.0540548563,
-0.0223290846,
0.4300296307,
0.288862586,
-0.1347998679,
-0.2153769732,
0.5822435617,
0.0303983819,
0.8488417268,
-0.0355002247,
0.0982182026,
0.3171334267,
-0.1902570873,
0.3182841241,
-0.5127300024,
-0.3141948581,
-0.0584660172,
-0.0024597661,
-0.2912471592,
-0.4802479446,
0.5293080211,
-0.6138087511,
-0.8721734881,
-0.0783217177,
-0.263407588,
-0.321167469,
0.1873784363,
0.0755209178,
0.5478879213,
-0.6672163606,
-0.0552490987,
0.6610930562,
-0.1246784404,
0.3947016895,
-0.0340876542,
-0.2138668448,
-0.6027473211,
0.9320247769,
-0.0096793259,
0.5154588223,
0.2055516094,
0.2367796302,
-0.3348200321,
-0.3729339838,
-0.3917843103,
0.1728614718,
-0.8049268126,
0.114483431,
-0.5690441132,
-0.0565072149,
-0.6985924244,
-0.35752967,
-0.3381328881,
-0.8974460363,
-0.4001557231,
-0.3733204007,
0.1872549802,
1.0349490643,
-0.3254981637,
-0.0296403766,
-0.5298008919,
0.3252047896,
0.3362465203,
-0.2600366473,
-0.1674124897,
-0.185858801,
0.1489642709,
0.3034783006,
-0.2856155932,
-0.9783214331,
0.4407773018,
0.3408758044,
0.7487474084,
0.0022862996,
0.0265021827,
0.3868945837,
-0.5204526782,
1.1763147116,
0.1760814488,
-1.3604803085,
0.8062512875,
-0.250444293,
-0.0456429496,
0.3915688694,
0.162034601,
-0.7780345082,
-0.7745240927,
-0.84221071,
-1.1470757723,
0.3087379336,
0.3021639287,
0.5864569545,
-0.0109784659,
0.0226879641,
0.2350074351,
0.4923347831,
-0.334089309,
-0.2374536395,
-0.1465890408,
-0.4066337347,
0.1406855434,
0.1643140465,
-0.6352311373,
-0.2138951868,
0.5694522262,
-0.1427718848,
0.4906668365,
0.2052440792,
0.1644556373,
0.1213398129,
0.4307652414,
0.7182299495,
0.7262365222,
0.3639969826,
0.1488260329,
-0.2570223212,
-0.0086332345,
0.2386513054,
0.0957975462,
-0.1539125592,
-0.0293215234,
-0.018893728,
0.8341020346,
-0.3188373744,
-0.8409103155,
0.3397582769,
0.2030514181,
0.0768545493,
-0.5151571035,
0.1091395766,
0.1782565862,
0.2491119504,
0.1901879907,
0.3470098078,
0.3080548644,
-0.9132422209,
0.1429993659,
0.5214960575,
-0.4056811631,
-0.4188747704,
0.8747225404,
0.5045341849,
-0.7491060495,
0.4791114032,
0.0776616782,
-0.463725239,
0.6782668233,
0.3496461511,
1.1449906826,
-0.2590069473,
-0.0265333634,
0.1073042154,
0.3353648782,
0.1634053886,
0.4707989395,
-0.3825055659,
-0.4876583219,
-0.2331157774,
-0.3039132357,
-0.7226541638,
-0.4480455816,
-0.7007058263,
0.0339615531,
-0.2750260234,
-0.1602122486,
0.2057496905,
-0.5080466866,
-0.3670415878,
-0.0041183895,
0.3009440601,
0.5112735629,
-0.8676491976,
0.2636779547,
0.7244716883,
-0.3631204665,
-0.5270856619,
-0.3679195344,
-0.0648991093,
-0.5696768165,
0.5813961029,
0.3045107722,
-0.5124292374,
0.1637155712,
-0.8531246185,
-0.7263525128,
0.6226924658,
0.4201800525,
-0.138644293,
0.2968037426,
0.244488284,
0.6196659207,
-0.3998306692,
0.1024689302,
0.6307352185,
0.5836179256,
-0.1000221446,
-0.8455846906,
0.0397315249,
-0.3943921626,
-0.0694051087,
0.180014953,
-0.725558877,
0.6314596534,
-0.2999833226,
-0.4672383368,
0.3594278097,
1.0572146177,
-0.1704253107,
0.4185145795,
0.1418890804,
0.2066360861,
0.7919547558,
-0.1913860589,
0.7045938373,
-0.1304370612,
-0.278078109,
0.7365050912,
-0.4334537685,
0.7302740812,
0.6090019941,
-0.2237430215,
0.2056402266,
0.2248697579,
0.572879374,
0.3262623847,
0.5600059032,
-0.8030897975,
-0.0521921404,
-0.4557909071,
-0.1864367872,
0.6216995716,
0.7806087136,
-0.3115943074,
0.4801025391,
0.420874387,
-0.0571440421,
0.4459130466,
-0.2052439004,
0.9396611452,
-0.0255463719,
-0.894715488,
0.1309715062,
-0.4535322189,
0.5543251038,
-0.6115182042,
-0.3158774972,
0.0468002297,
-0.2083383203,
-0.1849924475,
-0.7508219481,
0.5855579972,
-0.3240982294,
-0.0260803625,
-0.7334005237,
0.6411272883,
-0.4468810856,
-0.1336732805,
0.0718350038,
0.5688505173,
0.2953953445,
0.1004725918,
-0.5049338937,
0.3658622503,
0.0689352378,
-0.0917147473,
0.0449237823,
0.3370430768,
0.1221174374,
0.7656732798,
0.5997297168,
0.4335537553,
0.136858806,
-0.1537986398,
0.9028222561,
-0.8365451097,
-0.547421217,
-0.5448781848,
0.6253830791,
-0.2112834603,
-0.4038872719,
0.3677414656,
0.3665930629,
0.620423317,
0.1406054348,
1.3071330786,
-0.4438816607,
0.4717639685,
-0.4037007689,
0.4677646458,
-0.3400626779,
-0.1138613299,
-0.0953643173,
-0.3382632136,
-0.0275403336,
0.6024414897,
0.1997670233,
-0.1454081535,
0.3980009556,
0.8983112574,
0.3859738111,
0.4751866758,
0.5329197049,
0.2957445979,
0.4421850145,
0.2963799536,
1.2035363913,
-0.2554252446,
0.0750326663,
-0.1035810784,
-0.356143117,
0.2659773231,
-0.7587475777,
-0.1771858335,
-0.8278217912,
-0.3298288882,
-0.2647378147,
0.1446674168,
0.9420996308,
0.8272134066,
-0.5153723359,
-0.4246177375,
-0.1297776252,
0.1699418426,
-0.5953954458,
-0.1995329857,
0.0970140398,
-0.3711262345,
-1.3126904964,
0.704703927,
0.5852995515,
0.0775516778,
-0.3039869368,
0.2036263496,
0.1484266967,
0.2974230349,
0.6940489411,
0.767275095,
-0.7490149736,
-0.4061620831,
-0.049151998,
0.199407056,
0.1147745028,
0.8958044052,
-0.7591816783,
0.5343259573,
0.4008434117,
0.7596082091,
0.2339630723,
-0.1493397951,
0.762136817,
-0.4410050511,
0.2931728065,
0.84255898,
0.1753778756,
0.5006044507,
-0.1899880469,
0.3728767037,
-0.045303572,
-0.719808042,
-0.9178422093,
0.8195884824,
-0.9663154483,
-0.2125755996,
0.8588683605,
0.2183007747,
-0.2498697788,
0.1086984351,
-0.4470258951,
0.3052197397,
-0.3631207645,
0.5461863279,
0.5561093688,
-0.9718948007,
0.1251165271,
-0.4161732197,
0.664526701,
0.5782793164,
-1.2313994169,
0.2614615858,
0.6094549298,
-0.1532133222,
0.3601489365,
0.6335077286,
-0.3109736741,
-0.005576977,
0.1575223953,
-0.1193446517,
0.1309550107,
-0.2023296505,
-0.2148307413,
0.2074958235,
0.0433580428,
-0.2622437477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19360v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19360v1
|
Large Language Model Informed Patent Image Retrieval
| 2024-04-30T08:45:16 | 2024-04-30T08:45:16 |
Hao-Cheng Lo, Jung-Mei Chu, Jieh Hsiang, Chun-Chieh Cho
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In patent prosecution, image-based retrieval systems for identifying
similarities between current patent images and prior art are pivotal to ensure
the novelty and non-obviousness of patent applications. Despite their growing
popularity in recent years, existing attempts, while effective at recognizing
images within the same patent, fail to deliver practical value due to their
limited generalizability in retrieving relevant prior art. Moreover, this task
inherently involves the challenges posed by the abstract visual features of
patent images, the skewed distribution of image classifications, and the
semantic information of image descriptions. Therefore, we propose a
language-informed, distribution-aware multimodal approach to patent image
feature learning, which enriches the semantic understanding of patent image by
integrating Large Language Models and improves the performance of
underrepresented classes with our proposed distribution-aware contrastive
losses. Extensive experiments on DeepPatent2 dataset show that our proposed
method achieves state-of-the-art or comparable performance in image-based
patent retrieval with mAP +53.3%, Recall@10 +41.8%, and MRR@10 +51.9%.
Furthermore, through an in-depth user analysis, we explore our model in aiding
patent professionals in their image retrieval efforts, highlighting the model's
real-world applicability and effectiveness.
|
[
-0.0478525348,
-0.354480803,
0.5976693034,
0.2216531783,
-0.4894526899,
-0.073769629,
-0.1559523344,
-0.7647556663,
0.206821844,
0.7232444882,
0.0312260613,
-0.5975816846,
-0.8510445356,
-0.4184811115,
-0.2085024714,
0.3715589046,
0.1958221644,
0.0987177491,
0.0075965803,
-0.2629340887,
-0.4527920187,
-0.3934684694,
-0.2181680799,
-0.3876521587,
0.5439733863,
0.2123200148,
0.595672071,
0.4127556384,
0.6965644956,
0.3414947391,
-0.3693713248,
-0.1248780116,
-0.1790270954,
0.0268081557,
-0.3251792192,
-0.609136641,
-0.0949522704,
-0.0527689494,
0.3315630853,
0.5062746406,
-0.0939498767,
-0.0682175681,
-0.1817862242,
0.3489233255,
-0.8037664294,
0.3859923184,
-0.9483860135,
0.2321949452,
-0.1476107985,
-0.2278220356,
-0.6963937283,
0.181363076,
0.3672249019,
-0.7391807437,
0.5137615204,
0.1864165068,
0.7815881371,
-0.0931145251,
-0.5264234543,
-0.3037684858,
-0.3658933938,
0.7362656593,
-0.4612362385,
0.3854762912,
0.1670109183,
0.3769644499,
-0.1534322053,
-1.0775370598,
-0.8065128922,
-0.2817057669,
-0.058918789,
-0.0534487292,
-0.1512290984,
0.0251595061,
0.2432741523,
0.237576738,
-0.6171221137,
0.2534542978,
-0.4137357175,
-0.3300451934,
0.300316453,
-0.3445443511,
0.3128923476,
-0.2459567487,
-0.5680942535,
-0.4363944232,
-0.8950702548,
-0.1350749582,
0.151759088,
0.2465976179,
0.1298564672,
0.604282856,
-0.1230126098,
0.3116558194,
-0.2119337618,
-0.0328446291,
0.478785336,
-0.0884344652,
-0.1014263183,
-0.0049653607,
0.7230901718,
0.2566941679,
-0.0093781855,
0.0769546479,
-0.4755343795,
-0.2084985524,
-0.2149003297,
-1.1113551855,
-0.4154927731,
-0.0276453868,
-0.8127267361,
0.118120864,
0.2722788453,
-0.7991445065,
-1.0510240793,
-0.1272385418,
0.7152962685,
-0.4509316087,
-0.4502146244,
0.256128639,
-0.5333734751,
0.1545896977,
0.3154515028,
-0.8429024816,
-0.2738164663,
0.8839609027,
0.7449020147,
0.47198385,
-0.1317675859,
-0.5119642019,
0.2134705484,
-0.3135664761,
0.9192739129,
-0.6784471273,
-0.4889095128,
-0.1193047017,
0.1295555532,
-0.0809188411,
-0.8891314268,
0.3446100354,
-0.9002285004,
-0.0122585194,
-0.1463130862,
-0.3122061789,
-0.2023628652,
0.0527630895,
-0.7955400944,
0.2896831334,
-0.4553930163,
-0.7864959836,
0.8572493196,
-0.6276839972,
-0.5688502789,
0.2194469124,
-0.376283586,
-0.4988841712,
0.2860024273,
0.3733892739,
0.5409283042,
-0.1738342494,
0.3340623379,
-0.6213688254,
-0.1088700816,
0.0830271617,
-0.2010972798,
0.6536564231,
0.3856970072,
-0.2110771388,
0.0758332014,
-0.6436357498,
-0.2069096863,
0.3032637835,
0.0063045276,
-0.6861310601,
-0.0424979031,
-0.0426906534,
0.3764670193,
0.401445806,
-0.8452574015,
0.0369086601,
-0.3652539849,
0.4251846373,
0.6756454706,
0.0027709038,
0.4245429039,
0.1744914651,
0.3673006892,
0.2154793739,
0.3603545129,
-0.5170584321,
-0.6928974986,
-0.4599226415,
-0.7297939062,
0.4393584132,
0.4221963286,
-0.7976564765,
0.2986536026,
-0.450740844,
-0.3317505121,
-0.6900861859,
0.2578652501,
0.4249801934,
0.5331590772,
0.2132007331,
-0.6192265153,
-0.2030079663,
-1.1718680859,
0.0353304967,
-0.0321177132,
-0.0885535628,
0.7197518349,
0.6964018941,
-0.2630196214,
0.7276546955,
-0.7719256282,
-0.4599124491,
-0.2104775161,
0.5878098607,
0.5105961561,
0.3801214397,
0.4570458829,
-1.1996549368,
-0.4492474496,
0.4656201303,
-0.4935756624,
0.1169150323,
0.1480012536,
0.0455325879,
-0.0326574296,
0.3738545775,
-0.9197508097,
0.5144510269,
0.1352720708,
-0.2294694036,
0.2401927561,
-0.5956539512,
0.2870815098,
-1.1511858702,
0.3970589936,
0.2447979748,
0.0975962877,
-0.1412018389,
0.1083591953,
0.6107802987,
-0.4856949747,
-0.5327537656,
0.7515583038,
-0.5608207583,
-0.1402087212,
-0.1957981139,
-0.0773656964,
0.4169084132,
-0.0141245881,
0.1500502676,
0.8625102043,
0.7236498594,
-0.2475895584,
0.3018428087,
0.106888108,
-0.7172061205,
0.6485192776,
-0.7327741385,
0.02136188,
-0.4057237804,
0.2171580642,
-0.8840731382,
-0.1912873685,
-0.0573028363,
-0.1118235067,
0.6921188235,
-0.4087000489,
-0.8907271028,
-0.4032478929,
-0.2124048769,
0.1254313737,
0.350453645,
-0.9246831536,
0.6638875008,
0.4333894551,
-0.4288932085,
-0.9097540975,
-0.5943156481,
0.2589819431,
-0.183057636,
-0.7680031657,
0.5398762226,
0.1743143499,
-0.0216949657,
0.1218448579,
0.2430742532,
-0.4054487646,
-0.1018041447,
0.2205354571,
0.2151189446,
-0.1890251786,
0.4744063914,
-0.0996638387,
-0.0810971037,
-0.2531320453,
-0.1969626695,
0.3314562142,
0.3432613909,
-0.5053046346,
-0.4043386579,
0.4258645773,
0.5923508406,
-0.4410169423,
0.4983107746,
0.5233214498,
-0.1589523405,
-0.3589448631,
-0.5659346581,
-0.0875762403,
-0.5434244871,
0.5857614875,
-0.5682162046,
-0.7203001976,
0.6025214195,
-0.2357438505,
-0.3744125068,
0.4486857057,
0.2791772783,
0.0265563559,
0.9312160611,
0.9499928951,
-0.051764451,
0.6019687057,
-0.455142498,
0.6880910397,
-0.6483873129,
-0.5704707503,
-0.4618080854,
-0.275182724,
-0.1711090952,
-0.448358953,
0.171373114,
0.020869242,
0.0288111158,
0.336848259,
-0.553753078,
0.6408559084,
0.8397032619,
0.3070095479,
0.1939276606,
0.2093504071,
-0.4348551929,
-0.0362013616,
-0.361046195,
-0.1916678697,
1.0957375765,
0.4209841192,
1.1051107645,
0.0370343849,
0.5250835419,
0.1460286826,
0.1970574409,
-0.7655806541,
0.5079470873,
-0.4793546796,
-0.63505584,
0.0985656455,
-0.2399098873,
-1.0071928501,
0.3218434155,
-0.1738507003,
-0.5850673914,
0.7715466619,
0.2193357497,
-0.210485056,
0.0374706239,
-1.1761705875,
0.8685956001,
-0.4249358475,
-0.2562386692,
-0.6814598441,
-0.6630501747,
0.2565543652,
-0.2610144019,
0.0472688079,
-0.0109736612,
0.1431578845,
0.3926981688,
-0.2665159404,
0.909662962,
-0.4082609117,
0.0416912921,
-0.0273618773,
-0.1380425543,
0.2712415159,
-0.2344844788,
-0.1751694381,
-0.100405477,
-0.1775263101,
-0.1615705192,
-0.7786809802,
0.8013868928,
-0.3337613046,
-0.6148770452,
-0.1120358035,
-0.4417937398,
0.1741447002,
0.3582612574,
0.1938973963,
0.3261359632,
0.1336184889,
0.4775381684,
0.6975052357,
-0.6374973655,
0.2279486358,
0.5318431258,
0.0150142759,
-0.5104775429,
1.0053675175,
0.2008556873,
-0.1471073776,
0.5932813883,
0.2237260789,
-0.8498625159,
-0.6634100676,
-0.208082661,
0.376377821,
-1.2511409521,
-0.1911155134,
-0.6335392594,
0.0864418298,
-0.591162324,
0.1359181702,
-0.2116328031,
-0.3630583882,
-0.2915448546,
0.1075243875,
0.3096412718,
0.6696410775,
0.2089558095,
0.166520074,
-0.4730359912,
0.2266956121,
0.5261692405,
0.7360475659,
0.0058929017,
-0.5071037412,
-0.020086864,
-0.1791898459,
-0.3939565718,
-0.4339720011,
0.3451786041,
0.4399867058,
0.8210477829,
0.5933995843,
-0.0663425177,
0.5928981304,
-0.5963676572,
0.6377228498,
0.4040610492,
-0.6579666734,
0.7341997027,
0.1341405213,
-0.0556347296,
0.102967374,
0.238428399,
-0.1072909832,
0.0285093542,
-0.4711200595,
-1.1236423254,
0.278657198,
-0.3096663654,
0.5359056592,
0.0321264938,
0.025916703,
0.0753575265,
0.1697466522,
-0.7695780993,
0.3792875707,
-0.2291160971,
-0.2839405239,
0.1340682358,
-0.3193420172,
-0.2223085016,
-0.1464177817,
0.4920057952,
-0.0861232281,
0.1621999741,
0.1915169805,
-0.3724890947,
0.324151814,
0.4227882028,
0.6235654354,
0.5825453997,
-0.2304929644,
0.3548975587,
-0.4603386521,
-0.4458112121,
-0.0974223837,
0.5111788511,
0.2083433717,
0.0263629537,
0.2480137199,
0.8290080428,
-0.0939606354,
-0.8564352393,
0.9301450253,
0.0435784832,
-0.2972513735,
0.0890443325,
-0.1408300996,
-0.055190403,
0.6529312134,
0.6901296377,
-0.0376642682,
0.4981949031,
-0.2962059081,
0.4547761083,
0.8030989766,
-0.1868159026,
-0.2153732181,
0.5106166005,
0.1121729538,
0.0687226802,
0.3182333708,
-0.0856024325,
-0.3868776858,
0.7894775271,
0.6270676255,
0.8121708035,
0.0697912872,
0.2226080894,
0.000659699,
0.3155383468,
-0.3189257681,
0.1006147191,
-0.027898619,
-0.5987724066,
-0.301469624,
-0.272269547,
-0.2667960227,
0.083024919,
0.070815146,
0.3653501868,
-0.5151693821,
-0.3958317935,
0.2989178896,
-0.3677771688,
-0.636116147,
0.0328881778,
0.1538385004,
0.8520152569,
-0.8103132248,
0.8062399626,
0.5868537426,
-0.5602187514,
-0.6266431212,
-0.1904260814,
-0.285109818,
-0.800815165,
1.3294959068,
0.3313708901,
-0.0623905323,
-0.2411529273,
-0.5691890121,
-0.6475711465,
1.2512351274,
0.4885688424,
-0.3969916999,
0.5043637156,
-0.057309676,
0.5591890216,
-0.4506369233,
0.2086407095,
-0.1797408015,
0.1148255393,
0.6537142396,
-0.9611712098,
-0.0171015169,
-0.4827205539,
0.3547248244,
0.081693612,
-0.1856389046,
0.7884269953,
-0.4548055232,
-0.2967691422,
0.0782076716,
0.3151083291,
0.1819707453,
0.520791471,
0.4040883482,
0.7326043248,
0.6064712405,
0.1767010242,
1.0812491179,
-0.2955863774,
0.372300595,
0.9408147931,
-0.6187645197,
1.1439324617,
0.5108292699,
0.2274035513,
0.2138027996,
0.2991148829,
-0.308251828,
0.8819509745,
0.0462196656,
-0.4462321699,
-0.1063101664,
-0.497802943,
-0.3698688745,
0.1619215757,
0.3556355536,
-0.9872570634,
-0.1907152981,
0.1726268083,
-0.3557614386,
-0.0732623935,
0.03630054,
0.6233710051,
0.1154308096,
-0.1357362568,
0.4617809355,
-0.1666888148,
0.7868278623,
-0.3487064242,
-0.1726655215,
-0.0174833219,
0.423038125,
0.0073544816,
-1.0361453295,
-0.1441485137,
-0.2460197359,
-0.2168557048,
-0.0205309093,
0.8068966269,
-0.4240996838,
-0.3651105762,
0.4549108446,
0.0717026368,
-0.0853663757,
-0.1054232195,
-0.7347912192,
-0.1150661036,
-0.2769642174,
-0.1354281008,
0.2030668557,
0.6394261122,
-0.1649494618,
0.9365763664,
0.6187759042,
0.1525693238,
0.0746440068,
0.2926273346,
0.9253758192,
-0.2318265885,
-0.4540961087,
-0.4340560138,
0.5776283145,
-0.5069643259,
-0.0304558259,
0.1424720287,
0.5320040584,
0.578600049,
-0.4504694641,
0.6836748719,
0.0822691098,
0.3192158043,
-0.4667344987,
0.8776490092,
-0.5656954646,
0.3521772325,
-0.3380327225,
-0.6347723603,
-0.783398211,
0.5893930793,
-0.4652274251,
-0.172969982,
0.4034455419,
1.3609768152,
-0.5651518106,
-0.4272789955,
0.379661411,
0.0578619577,
0.6002053022,
0.1309249848,
0.6826014519,
-0.3331566751,
0.5576747656,
-0.2952879667,
-0.2244997621,
-0.1815694571,
-0.9073845744,
-0.5997080207,
-0.565382123,
-0.2428575009,
-0.009615628,
-0.0549671575,
0.8214466572,
0.9897754788,
-0.7222120166,
0.1439021677,
0.1774776131,
-0.006356563,
0.358533591,
-0.2011617124,
0.4534080327,
-0.2075692713,
-0.4060176909,
0.1196580231,
0.5746942759,
0.1433535516,
0.0485771596,
0.0509128459,
-0.0776474178,
-0.2456165105,
0.8497232199,
0.2756446898,
-0.8375144005,
-0.1528548747,
0.0554549769,
-0.2092815191,
0.086597763,
0.8504313231,
-0.4563876987,
0.8837113976,
0.723328948,
0.7479189634,
0.3408007324,
-0.2145212144,
0.3543352187,
-0.7924765944,
0.7989513278,
0.2655844092,
0.7672308683,
0.4196914136,
-0.375510186,
0.0535174087,
0.470515132,
-0.3786401451,
-0.4370493293,
0.2265459299,
-0.9246806502,
-0.5876897573,
0.8096197248,
-0.3479600251,
-0.1708728522,
-0.0408204421,
-0.3491892815,
-0.2020839006,
-0.5609073043,
0.8961557746,
0.4583798945,
0.3084346354,
-0.6919993162,
-0.4088833332,
0.0036736676,
0.2359030992,
-0.394243896,
-0.0480598435,
0.6331578493,
0.2698449194,
0.4085679948,
0.5290372968,
-0.4509688914,
0.0945550427,
-0.1423061788,
0.5238034725,
0.1752181947,
-0.3710673749,
-0.2468157411,
0.35320732,
0.5227437019,
-0.3420628905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19359v1
|
Evaluating Lexicon Incorporation for Depression Symptom Estimation
| 2024-04-30T08:41:06 | 2024-04-30T08:41:06 |
Kirill Milintsevich, Gaël Dias, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the impact of incorporating sentiment, emotion, and
domain-specific lexicons into a transformer-based model for depression symptom
estimation. Lexicon information is added by marking the words in the input
transcripts of patient-therapist conversations as well as in social media
posts. Overall results show that the introduction of external knowledge within
pre-trained language models can be beneficial for prediction performance, while
different lexicons show distinct behaviours depending on the targeted task.
Additionally, new state-of-the-art results are obtained for the estimation of
depression level over patient-therapist interviews.
|
[
-0.4977307618,
-0.4176466167,
0.8633927107,
0.2833008766,
-0.1920871884,
-0.2890779376,
-0.2504866123,
-0.5022804737,
0.6309665442,
0.0950322226,
-0.4328158498,
-0.5526454449,
-1.1090373993,
0.403396219,
-0.3336809576,
0.9715200663,
0.0411868021,
0.3559656143,
-0.3702441156,
0.3945141137,
-0.5969147086,
-0.7191702127,
-0.566757679,
-0.1259347051,
0.3280797601,
0.082165271,
0.9037075043,
-0.2492071092,
0.5145891905,
0.3336696327,
-0.5684661865,
-0.1433392763,
-0.2630118132,
-0.0571919642,
-0.399622798,
-0.6906028986,
-0.4457030892,
0.0847029015,
0.2361197323,
0.72785604,
-0.093968235,
-0.1134008691,
0.3690261841,
0.1084846035,
-0.8757554889,
0.1308668852,
-0.1427122355,
0.29316172,
0.2964892685,
0.1423005313,
-0.0963792354,
-0.395247221,
0.3650471568,
-0.1054415256,
0.1794090867,
-0.7008191943,
0.8103289008,
0.3166365623,
-0.3282827139,
-0.7238691449,
-0.7521659732,
0.6041085124,
-0.7725231051,
0.3655026555,
0.4645741582,
0.1442690343,
0.1293607503,
-0.8125872612,
-0.3039336801,
-0.0327157564,
-0.5907149315,
0.4417138696,
-0.3622877896,
0.1334849298,
0.1143993512,
0.6729409099,
-0.04722986,
-0.2005218118,
-0.2219183892,
0.0126266368,
0.4528645575,
0.25802055,
0.5010514855,
-0.73898983,
0.0486664772,
0.2503987253,
0.0552972183,
0.0544650592,
-0.0352285504,
0.2484734356,
-0.2959745824,
0.6238308549,
0.0734795704,
0.3735491633,
0.0800950527,
-0.2151189446,
0.1317146569,
-0.3215361834,
-0.1286373734,
0.0309524462,
0.760514915,
0.4742901027,
0.0165333115,
-0.1513631344,
-0.2248940766,
0.5390122533,
0.6428699493,
-0.6695362926,
-0.6032318473,
0.2726810873,
-0.368657589,
-0.1540455818,
0.0075496738,
-1.3162784576,
-0.8242227435,
-0.3035551012,
0.3881818354,
-0.4789646864,
-0.5586178899,
0.0229824483,
-0.4743559062,
-0.1626746356,
0.2290608287,
-0.5155109763,
0.417596221,
0.7369201779,
0.9967238307,
-0.0057809744,
0.2259041667,
-0.3127762675,
-0.2389945388,
-0.2868098319,
1.0006700754,
-0.4759995043,
-0.7803656459,
0.3278913796,
0.215596959,
-0.2190201581,
-0.4305554926,
0.6277328134,
0.0592025034,
0.4704294801,
0.0397844277,
-0.834487915,
0.1308182329,
0.0417116024,
-0.7437660694,
0.8892768621,
0.6204705834,
-1.0622141361,
0.0516892262,
-0.4386643171,
-0.3712652922,
0.0439831913,
0.0881094113,
-0.0407227725,
0.7019673586,
0.1562911719,
0.5973058343,
-0.1751164049,
0.0567437522,
-0.1089719385,
-0.0175128486,
0.610750854,
0.1741335243,
0.4663216174,
0.121688284,
0.0060039228,
-0.2478927821,
-0.4745849967,
-0.39594993,
-0.1528315842,
-0.056883648,
-0.7603901029,
0.0769520104,
-0.1377370656,
0.2302758396,
0.2605599463,
-0.4464597106,
-0.2268812954,
-0.6631901264,
0.1060011983,
0.4083332717,
0.3401943743,
0.289185524,
0.0903492495,
0.9267876744,
0.2284694165,
0.3978635371,
0.1118375957,
-0.6135001183,
-0.4228919446,
-0.3872968853,
0.2617447674,
0.3767361939,
-0.4036039114,
0.5292508602,
-0.1808661968,
-0.6922125816,
-0.4262669086,
-0.0208416414,
0.1725046188,
0.2243942022,
0.4055771232,
-0.3679457605,
-0.6074516177,
-0.4371678829,
-0.3674694598,
0.0299859252,
-0.0561360829,
0.2423979938,
0.2609992027,
-0.5334505439,
0.7584178448,
-0.9306632876,
-0.1930904686,
-0.6468899846,
0.0980374068,
0.3468365073,
0.1741307229,
0.4688754976,
-0.3627774119,
-0.5357833505,
-0.1610107571,
-0.427763164,
-0.0315592587,
0.0271877535,
-0.2285641283,
-0.0209322125,
0.2376815826,
-0.702334404,
0.7587330937,
0.8163005114,
-0.6848964691,
0.5687836409,
0.0431322977,
0.0642218143,
-1.4832689762,
-0.3355825543,
0.4657785296,
-0.1008861065,
-0.6220967174,
-0.4530918002,
0.0202195626,
-0.1855798662,
-0.3313609958,
0.2988648713,
-0.1887210459,
0.1371513307,
-0.3156336546,
0.3445566595,
0.1386431009,
0.0080161933,
0.0656383187,
0.4408486784,
0.7977176905,
-0.5790128708,
0.3220959306,
0.4133502543,
-0.5400027633,
0.6011419296,
-0.3672734797,
-0.242840156,
-0.3201157749,
-0.0073832222,
-0.9843719006,
-0.1291014552,
0.2453998774,
-0.4202337265,
0.1927257031,
0.0684756637,
-0.109135747,
-0.4419265389,
0.0247886889,
0.1936541945,
0.4863643348,
-0.1912379116,
0.6398473978,
0.4160457551,
-0.2154189497,
-0.0295924544,
-0.6899566054,
0.2176098824,
-0.4536677599,
-0.140947938,
0.5856469274,
0.105066821,
-0.3967673779,
0.1118240654,
-0.0239613559,
-0.1576216221,
-0.0262134373,
0.400084585,
0.1301735491,
0.0431965739,
0.4448561072,
0.0699068904,
-0.075281933,
0.44112885,
0.4160767198,
0.6431204081,
0.098593235,
0.1159666851,
-0.7337344885,
0.4307427406,
0.3384431601,
0.1663366705,
0.9945043325,
0.2844454646,
-0.454544127,
-0.2026762962,
-0.3068117797,
-0.3137072623,
-0.3754611015,
0.1851973981,
-0.3679031134,
-0.4381251633,
0.3684411943,
-0.5192334652,
-0.6451659799,
0.3645625412,
0.3514740467,
-0.0180610809,
1.2811499834,
0.7091935277,
0.0808914155,
0.7003778815,
-0.3032741547,
0.5152387619,
-0.7913265824,
0.0524778925,
-0.5255486965,
-0.2011365294,
-0.6236022115,
-0.316373229,
0.2877923846,
0.289652288,
0.1597051173,
0.5665333271,
-0.4427229464,
-0.2295157313,
0.0937099382,
0.446092397,
0.1218293905,
-0.4305132329,
-0.0105157346,
-0.3556799293,
-0.5918426514,
-0.1898497492,
0.8983486295,
0.4814592004,
0.6781690121,
0.0560923107,
0.7475063205,
0.2667952776,
0.6213240027,
-1.2239317894,
0.3205362856,
-0.227574423,
-0.1437599063,
0.0518441647,
-0.2504156828,
-0.7473917603,
-0.1034873724,
-0.1090203449,
-0.7910193801,
0.4760324955,
-0.2066736966,
-0.5676249266,
-0.1473148316,
-0.8189144135,
0.9474366307,
-0.1466191411,
0.5318983197,
-0.4994082749,
-0.2199729383,
0.2730100453,
-0.1506538093,
0.4445125759,
-0.1958478391,
-0.0430327803,
0.7455070019,
-0.6539142728,
0.8728610873,
-0.1752531081,
-0.351534605,
0.2312771529,
0.0467937812,
0.3015966117,
0.1931160241,
-0.0739841759,
0.2220303118,
0.4814979136,
0.0086252121,
-0.9299694896,
0.4922380447,
-0.887850523,
-0.6737600565,
-0.3150675595,
-0.3512004316,
-0.5523584485,
-0.2644822299,
0.1692493558,
0.4413793087,
-0.3527901769,
-0.1262775511,
0.1987347603,
-0.5221907496,
0.1318003237,
0.2942249179,
-0.2720742822,
-0.7761378288,
0.4659304917,
0.0688403249,
0.2682680488,
0.1425722539,
0.6294663548,
0.0092724878,
0.1374827176,
0.3150786459,
0.5888928175,
-0.9149677157,
-0.3131879866,
-0.6823286414,
-0.2713920176,
-0.6971653104,
-0.0675400421,
-0.4644734859,
-0.3673296571,
-0.5638984442,
-0.3237745464,
0.4972768724,
0.7540711164,
-0.2483367324,
0.5758161545,
-0.9702820182,
0.238522768,
0.038541764,
0.4762515128,
-0.0999038294,
-0.644239068,
-0.5791369081,
0.0375026241,
-0.1628583968,
-1.3223265409,
0.740399003,
0.1492539644,
0.3631396592,
0.564221859,
0.1010897085,
0.6673540473,
-0.2404688299,
0.9948666692,
0.6246246696,
-1.308059454,
0.9414785504,
0.3082299232,
0.2768559754,
0.347299099,
0.9666012526,
-0.9060983062,
-0.5466279984,
-0.6994746327,
-0.5067462921,
0.6278010011,
-0.1282068938,
0.3889862299,
-0.4788863957,
0.4055759609,
0.0099079767,
-0.2487304956,
-0.4362021983,
-0.189452529,
-0.4096624553,
-0.4250067472,
-0.3155839145,
-0.6451240182,
-0.1159556657,
-0.5353150964,
0.4726478159,
0.1467723995,
0.684207201,
0.3437174559,
-0.1182422116,
-0.0040585645,
0.050246913,
0.1007703394,
0.5750780702,
-0.1044644564,
0.2975184619,
0.2282771319,
-0.3445717692,
-0.2842505872,
0.0536912158,
0.2881989479,
0.7116021514,
0.207547158,
0.7885172963,
0.4057427943,
-0.5952857733,
0.7211385965,
-0.1386735886,
-0.1377322972,
-0.472474277,
-0.0156555846,
0.1744744927,
0.3893824816,
-0.1753627956,
-0.1432920694,
0.3001007736,
-0.5304481387,
0.0172756445,
0.3512911201,
-0.9223155975,
-0.689750433,
0.2225389183,
0.0517288968,
-0.3860670328,
0.3313510418,
0.2651590407,
-0.6297257543,
0.3602819145,
0.4935675561,
0.9395115376,
-0.6881876588,
0.4436983764,
0.537165761,
-0.1320261061,
-0.2253354043,
0.4195451736,
0.1217989549,
-0.9308308363,
-0.2600580454,
-0.7849732637,
-0.2184847742,
-0.1250606775,
-0.7512677312,
0.5737136006,
-0.2010391802,
-0.7946637869,
-0.0347941369,
-0.2915193439,
-0.8406018615,
0.453561455,
0.5179678798,
0.8708167076,
-0.9032095671,
0.4978846014,
0.9250553846,
-0.5926936865,
-0.6880373955,
0.1792231947,
-0.1214047596,
-0.4391565919,
0.4863855243,
0.3197280467,
0.2571980953,
-0.0813810304,
-0.0779179782,
-1.2850106955,
0.8664966226,
0.1733862013,
0.0049962173,
-0.1797857136,
0.4181390405,
0.7625827789,
-0.2397479415,
0.4794330299,
0.5746628642,
0.2910207212,
-0.1851637661,
-0.9184814095,
0.07892216,
-0.2645451427,
0.3104794621,
0.2200664431,
-0.0902193487,
0.6729972363,
0.2788651884,
-0.7271683216,
-0.1827292442,
0.526956737,
-0.4926570952,
-0.2702053487,
0.6713048816,
0.6576678157,
0.6249896288,
0.1350340694,
1.3338955641,
-0.8975613713,
0.4551101327,
0.7905270457,
0.11448735,
0.6506686807,
0.401091367,
-0.3734078705,
1.0253081322,
0.4918483794,
0.1889309883,
0.6469146013,
0.0502769612,
-0.5829835534,
-0.0822474882,
-0.515299201,
-0.2375749052,
0.3354468346,
0.837469697,
-0.8219329715,
-0.2414074838,
0.2280278355,
0.1132077351,
-0.0942932367,
-0.4005496204,
1.1055675745,
0.5343920588,
-0.6429820657,
0.4994108975,
-0.0570146516,
0.5079765916,
-0.2216567993,
0.2718595862,
-0.2957032919,
0.3171242476,
-0.3694279492,
-0.7205247283,
0.808457911,
0.1708488017,
0.0008809104,
-0.0027299921,
0.6797824502,
-0.2509321272,
-0.6757398248,
0.5913986564,
0.7864832878,
0.2507340312,
-0.3926352561,
-0.35436517,
-0.2598913908,
-0.3529389799,
-0.3319652677,
0.4012328386,
0.7573786378,
0.3398139179,
0.2752816379,
0.0350412689,
0.2769811451,
-0.2626891434,
0.347085923,
0.8797874451,
-0.7366672158,
-0.478471905,
-0.7529110312,
0.6759728789,
-0.077480644,
-0.4070875049,
0.7042800188,
0.0425005592,
0.4770052731,
-0.2175852805,
0.8588590622,
-0.2037148476,
0.595852375,
0.0017286779,
0.3415539861,
-0.5252000093,
-0.2337804288,
-0.5923839808,
-0.6743586659,
-0.1873486936,
0.4886146784,
-0.6482568383,
-0.3223495781,
0.9590224028,
0.610089004,
0.1925293058,
0.2474989593,
0.2591438293,
0.1003784612,
0.1228577644,
0.3719704747,
0.9658079147,
-0.362402916,
0.3040550053,
-0.8123002648,
-0.280125469,
-0.0353570916,
-0.5904055238,
-0.7231596708,
-0.4670463204,
-0.5583797693,
-0.5394732356,
-0.2428545058,
0.8453197479,
0.0632947981,
-0.9318534732,
-0.303240329,
-0.0355746225,
0.1380185485,
-0.4208054543,
-0.3234393597,
0.2495286912,
-0.6420988441,
-0.7889052629,
0.0058218203,
-0.1399973184,
-0.0902684927,
-0.1644143611,
0.2103743553,
-0.0988724828,
0.1370108575,
0.7641789317,
-0.4298866689,
-0.494222492,
-0.2014912367,
-0.2959552109,
-0.1383535117,
0.1296156496,
0.7920885086,
-0.8052715659,
0.3489587605,
0.4290925264,
0.4326686561,
0.1301115006,
0.2606398761,
0.8609946966,
-0.4038657844,
-0.1063435748,
0.2060575634,
0.6102067232,
0.3986758292,
-0.6612194777,
0.4192952514,
0.3560580611,
-0.189320609,
-0.6025267839,
0.0833538547,
-0.5020048618,
-0.6753078699,
1.1844412088,
-0.2314316481,
-0.1326438785,
-0.0087233493,
-0.1243115067,
0.5288655162,
-0.2431818247,
1.0293613672,
0.6685060263,
-0.4655304551,
-0.3228625357,
-0.341081351,
0.800219655,
0.2417639494,
-0.66873312,
-0.1148337498,
0.4822736084,
0.052024845,
0.3415314853,
0.1895216852,
-0.1037101671,
-0.0691319034,
0.0328192264,
0.4441851676,
0.6799563766,
0.1508207768,
-0.4334484637,
0.205873996,
-0.1912677139,
0.1859639883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19335v1
|
StablePT: Towards Stable Prompting for Few-shot Learning via Input Separation
| 2024-04-30T08:01:49 | 2024-04-30T08:01:49 |
Xiaoming Liu, Chen Liu, Zhaohan Zhang, Chengzhengxu Li, Longtian Wang, Yu Lan, Chao Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have shown their ability to become effective few-shot
learners with prompting, revoluting the paradigm of learning with data
scarcity. However, this approach largely depends on the quality of prompt
initialization, and always exhibits large variability among different runs.
Such property makes prompt tuning highly unreliable and vulnerable to poorly
constructed prompts, which limits its extension to more real-world
applications. To tackle this issue, we propose to treat the hard prompt and
soft prompt as separate inputs to mitigate noise brought by the prompt
initialization. Furthermore, we optimize soft prompts with contrastive learning
for utilizing class-aware information in the training process to maintain model
performance. Experimental results demonstrate that \sysname outperforms
state-of-the-art methods by 7.20% in accuracy and reduces the standard
deviation by 2.02 on average. Furthermore, extensive experiments underscore its
robustness and stability across 7 datasets covering various tasks.
|
[
-0.2534151375,
-0.9743125439,
0.3591189384,
-0.148729533,
-0.3668190837,
-0.1406946629,
-0.5637577176,
-0.0652517676,
-0.513623178,
-0.1391825378,
-0.677508235,
-0.2283008695,
-0.517126739,
0.2679759264,
0.1180960163,
1.0087888241,
0.2182949185,
0.3023845255,
0.0578383766,
-0.1698888242,
-0.656545341,
-0.0500025637,
-1.0401164293,
-0.1802832484,
0.8262175918,
0.6732863188,
0.6460191011,
0.6390289068,
0.2261873335,
0.3247763216,
-0.2359795719,
0.131281659,
-0.5815588236,
0.9244042635,
-0.1356865913,
-0.4025160074,
0.0491874143,
-0.0230709352,
0.9398943782,
0.8131141067,
-0.0319271684,
-0.121439822,
0.5911138654,
0.3827077746,
-0.9542452097,
0.1955602169,
-0.5747927427,
-0.0730658695,
-0.2640070915,
0.3607106805,
-0.6634253263,
-0.2975416183,
0.1153823286,
-0.5598480105,
0.1462939531,
-0.4351885915,
0.8821458817,
0.2294831872,
-0.0288331043,
0.2104666978,
-0.619479239,
0.9033195972,
-0.4329302311,
0.4440518916,
0.4782847464,
0.3801238537,
-0.3384100795,
-0.4919579327,
-0.3031614423,
-0.1067142636,
0.1862103045,
0.055986736,
-0.0826511458,
0.2439851016,
0.3106045127,
-0.1479893029,
-0.3731006384,
0.4714214504,
-0.4007469714,
-0.3606479764,
0.114411287,
0.2221952677,
0.1264900267,
0.0150694689,
-0.2809394002,
-0.0969987661,
-0.7368699312,
0.4163004458,
0.377225399,
1.1256957054,
-0.3216648102,
0.3383823335,
-0.1688301414,
0.943933785,
0.3713617623,
-0.4788999557,
0.1186569929,
-0.1316935718,
-0.053564027,
-0.10224282,
0.7486803532,
0.0689368472,
0.1209416017,
0.0371968895,
-0.2716518641,
0.2873238325,
-0.0830814838,
-0.9331343174,
-0.2301925123,
0.3736126721,
-0.2953287959,
-0.3274336755,
-0.1118271276,
-0.9542891979,
-0.5315176249,
-0.2222667485,
0.4502789974,
-0.5687644482,
-0.2084531784,
-0.2713783383,
-0.0179932658,
0.1057695448,
0.5734727979,
-1.1369301081,
0.315402925,
0.5690001249,
0.8596951962,
-0.4083915353,
-0.3286060989,
-1.1515200138,
-0.2949306071,
-0.2925578058,
0.7876511216,
-0.6433084607,
-0.3092953563,
0.0645879135,
-0.070162341,
-0.0599165522,
-0.4245760143,
0.2891487479,
-0.2164869756,
0.4805872142,
-0.2775448561,
-0.4070459902,
0.2890911996,
0.3064001501,
-0.5988761187,
0.862267673,
0.2175336033,
-0.6416630745,
0.6127198339,
-0.2409763038,
-0.4405312836,
0.2666398585,
-0.3454722166,
-0.6031723619,
0.0403285623,
0.1788650006,
0.3396650255,
0.1895023882,
0.1611701995,
-0.5596988201,
-0.4156560004,
0.0740507469,
-0.5158737898,
0.7195551991,
0.2588593364,
-0.2797015309,
0.1935678571,
-0.7852862477,
-0.0861106887,
0.0195880719,
-0.351108849,
-0.1919537634,
-0.1150768995,
-0.1551421881,
0.2153166682,
-0.0587098822,
-0.4205708504,
0.4470227063,
-0.551204443,
0.2773219049,
0.968151629,
-0.0962667763,
0.6666443348,
-0.3760243058,
0.8000248075,
0.3172480166,
0.1429022551,
-0.6067200899,
-0.3887563348,
-0.5747076869,
-0.5041637421,
0.5411132574,
0.5676168799,
-0.8644198179,
0.1716858596,
0.2212274671,
-0.3113447428,
-0.3827944696,
0.3499933779,
0.3291268647,
0.9466719031,
0.2811932564,
-0.048497729,
-0.4879925251,
-0.5112509727,
-0.0927035362,
-0.2650793493,
-0.0516653992,
0.0322557613,
0.0215182435,
0.0875778347,
0.8513872623,
-0.1681897789,
-0.0922302231,
-0.7145877481,
0.0171537399,
0.4052015245,
0.7357794642,
0.3095062077,
-0.3350910842,
-0.3973485231,
-0.5308074355,
-0.4416203797,
-0.1810994148,
-0.1745240986,
-0.0865880474,
0.1709991395,
0.2867017388,
-0.8154931664,
0.1686994433,
0.244719848,
-0.2175088376,
0.498713851,
0.2361167371,
-0.159600094,
-1.0933256149,
-0.0894309655,
0.1493574381,
-0.2609829009,
-0.4676169455,
-0.101270631,
-0.0750214756,
-0.2508927882,
-0.9137631059,
0.6990603805,
-0.4179851711,
0.3764580786,
-0.2251193076,
0.2581982613,
0.0294422228,
0.2528814375,
0.1292938888,
0.6945139766,
0.9381194711,
-0.6843705177,
0.0327163339,
0.2204389125,
-0.0199957173,
0.6300361753,
-0.7874265313,
0.0583523028,
-0.1902109683,
0.2557190359,
-1.1928533316,
-0.2982102931,
0.4922937453,
-0.3618869185,
0.6197129488,
-0.5385252833,
-0.3402513266,
0.0940069258,
-0.3404722214,
0.4593373835,
0.6235288382,
-0.5188031197,
0.1944252849,
0.1838477999,
-0.4536128044,
-0.6403745413,
-0.4338752031,
-0.3768190742,
-0.188653484,
-0.3547390699,
-0.1308075786,
-0.0503730588,
-0.281263262,
-0.3091386557,
-0.2091546655,
-0.2419546843,
0.1755734235,
0.3846236765,
0.5074917674,
-0.4609415233,
0.4052304924,
0.3109246492,
-0.3638308644,
-0.3455452621,
-0.2696143687,
0.4754388034,
-0.1208189279,
0.0217401329,
-0.738915205,
0.2167683095,
0.4632824361,
0.1775635928,
0.8023341894,
0.4647269547,
-0.4348013699,
-0.3404424191,
-0.1599991471,
-0.6408308744,
-0.5442478657,
0.039136745,
-0.4689632356,
-0.917581439,
0.490292877,
-0.1159226,
0.2700722814,
0.2824913263,
0.4569564164,
-0.2846605778,
1.0567704439,
0.5069913268,
0.0627055168,
0.7608055472,
0.1637305617,
-0.2084635198,
-0.2569178641,
-0.0710109994,
-0.6567456722,
-0.4793097973,
-0.4120681584,
0.1609445661,
0.1848950088,
0.1997622848,
-0.3406913579,
0.0541199148,
-0.5098926425,
0.7552775145,
0.5404670835,
0.3015334606,
0.0068982369,
-0.0112957433,
-0.3107979,
-0.3347185552,
-0.9244370461,
-0.3357912004,
0.706017673,
0.3026190996,
1.0100226402,
-0.0874151438,
0.7942946553,
-0.0106073329,
-0.1984832138,
-0.9142686725,
0.4496141076,
-0.0347867683,
-0.5446100235,
-0.44031021,
-0.4110500515,
-1.3896380663,
0.2944638133,
-0.4905011058,
-0.7343118191,
0.3178992271,
0.3640598953,
-0.8632361293,
0.0845531151,
-0.7466483712,
0.8232837915,
0.0495141596,
-0.9904151559,
0.2594102025,
-0.9581303596,
0.3358843029,
0.3266327381,
-0.0150808506,
-0.1374741495,
-0.1210239157,
0.7165924311,
-0.6127691269,
1.0951260328,
-0.3186502755,
0.1366750747,
0.2938381433,
0.2904815674,
0.552734971,
0.2005159706,
-0.1063427106,
-0.084320575,
-0.0062060673,
-0.5404225588,
-0.4884614348,
0.4438253939,
-0.7549780607,
-0.2623700202,
-0.4916396439,
-0.2630091906,
-0.3054191172,
0.4245225191,
0.6069040895,
0.6123332977,
0.1880210787,
0.047120817,
0.8199339509,
0.0532932654,
0.581844151,
0.3153004646,
0.0003990731,
-0.5076117516,
0.698394835,
0.059842892,
0.2779909074,
-0.0421673506,
0.5012788177,
-0.2897962332,
-0.4955121875,
-0.583594203,
0.0844937712,
-0.6812580228,
-0.5119501352,
-0.2694491744,
0.0097924592,
-0.3274680674,
-0.2443506718,
-0.5611624122,
-0.5614826679,
-0.6187646985,
-0.0754981786,
0.218265444,
0.4858500361,
-0.0377491489,
0.6573476791,
-0.9266591668,
0.3918124437,
0.3133616447,
0.4721325636,
-0.5194236636,
-0.5153207183,
0.0331573933,
-0.1407871395,
-0.1562224627,
-0.9532794952,
0.0300891995,
0.4569238722,
0.5295087099,
0.7723208666,
0.372145921,
0.5238627195,
-0.4408369362,
0.9786204696,
0.4028202295,
-0.9291133285,
0.8753584027,
-0.457736522,
0.7846241593,
1.3511368036,
0.2465027571,
-0.2180956006,
-0.4565183222,
-0.6229043603,
-0.7525160313,
0.950468719,
-0.1495133489,
0.1241563261,
-0.0409547016,
0.3213806748,
0.6691249609,
0.0890362933,
-0.6985072494,
-0.1023328453,
-0.0408553444,
-0.3908261955,
0.3284418285,
-0.2337476909,
-0.0536641218,
-0.1896569133,
0.5406438112,
-0.1833594441,
-0.1866082251,
-0.2995596528,
-0.0494058579,
-0.3155565262,
0.4293239415,
0.5339144468,
0.5980727673,
0.1256814152,
0.4774470627,
0.0579153486,
-0.5925472975,
0.3771132231,
-0.0035792962,
-0.4535989165,
0.1407568753,
0.3019095063,
0.6842932105,
0.2938895524,
-0.4608032703,
0.6256702542,
-0.178449735,
-0.1332468688,
0.2202976793,
0.3770599663,
-0.5411915779,
0.2128087133,
0.0955585837,
0.3232064545,
-0.1645146012,
-0.1653331965,
0.3236728311,
0.233547613,
-0.5053491592,
-0.4409802556,
0.5181484222,
0.5332256556,
-0.2668052316,
0.8523867726,
-0.2595826685,
-0.2901816368,
0.1906726956,
0.5409690738,
0.9610337019,
-0.4568994939,
0.260926038,
0.5626043677,
0.1971906722,
-0.3994600475,
0.2989608943,
-0.3366597295,
-0.5528819561,
-0.2922242284,
-0.361661315,
-0.6545573473,
0.2460026145,
-0.4799654186,
0.8327444196,
-0.8484603167,
-0.2754281163,
-0.4125888348,
-0.1416995823,
-0.4403315783,
0.006808708,
0.2386149615,
0.711932838,
-1.0241439342,
0.7488616109,
0.6042201519,
-0.4203662872,
-0.8123724461,
-0.1357339323,
0.2024076581,
-0.369432956,
0.3988794982,
0.3864082992,
-0.1254389435,
-0.2427536249,
-0.955968678,
-0.6972913742,
0.550116539,
0.712887466,
-0.8135724068,
0.1650706679,
-0.3110686243,
0.2034467757,
0.0680133924,
0.239935562,
0.4174602628,
0.4110516608,
0.3688371181,
-0.6422807574,
-0.0207567867,
-0.2261924595,
-0.3927984834,
0.0671753883,
-0.56942451,
0.857493639,
-0.3484174907,
-0.4579840302,
0.0510548055,
0.6849307418,
0.7728539109,
0.4534412324,
0.7444531918,
0.1715885401,
0.8999826312,
-0.2254954875,
0.5037161708,
-0.0805193111,
0.1515811831,
1.4040575027,
-0.218924731,
0.8136139512,
0.5876743793,
-0.2261499763,
0.4321504235,
0.9690870047,
0.0325273685,
0.6475738883,
0.0733014196,
-0.3427378237,
-0.4786277115,
0.0149886347,
-0.3447102308,
0.3758751154,
0.3047663867,
-0.1141178012,
-0.4102769494,
0.1091446728,
0.1810389161,
-0.1493243277,
-0.1608781815,
0.816011548,
0.0912028402,
-0.7971411347,
0.6619235277,
-0.3658387959,
0.6579563618,
-0.8744049072,
-0.1615283787,
-0.2917348444,
0.0929366648,
-0.2555948496,
-0.5247966647,
-0.0597374029,
-0.0696401075,
-0.1021149457,
-0.2238567024,
0.9266266227,
-0.5280825496,
-0.310093075,
-0.3003728986,
0.6289356351,
0.0774134398,
0.2884482443,
-0.6216193438,
0.239866659,
-0.4032884836,
-0.2603908479,
0.4044915438,
0.3703839779,
0.1736392826,
0.4748115242,
0.411404103,
0.1724816561,
-0.0254442506,
0.1385062337,
0.8200486898,
-0.2571636736,
-0.7105525136,
-1.0662714243,
0.8136892915,
0.1712280214,
-0.5395895839,
0.6439061165,
0.2956212163,
0.5646999478,
0.0759914443,
0.7671616077,
0.1495044827,
0.2841915488,
-0.5431832671,
0.6209804416,
-0.1837861687,
0.3394007683,
-0.4034433961,
-0.8623449802,
-0.5856441259,
0.6259815097,
-0.0198449995,
0.1747981757,
0.5312179923,
0.5575828552,
-0.0660632104,
-0.030773446,
0.3695662022,
0.0265082549,
0.1021516621,
0.3700392246,
1.0672867298,
-0.129755944,
0.532230556,
-0.2630479336,
-0.2694891691,
-0.2387806326,
-0.768137753,
-0.8605235219,
-0.3626401424,
-0.5614961982,
-0.6224145293,
0.1980193555,
1.2141084671,
1.0350692272,
-0.9655744433,
0.0600897744,
-0.2750571966,
0.4963482022,
-0.3651388884,
-0.2288169116,
0.226100862,
-0.9691453576,
-0.7735946178,
0.5683831573,
0.1473422498,
0.3096446097,
-0.1590138674,
-0.0214949306,
0.2648156285,
-0.0873455778,
0.3994781673,
0.5512525439,
-0.4748935401,
-0.1970473081,
-0.047778856,
-0.1906757951,
0.1518622488,
0.6312054992,
-1.1172419786,
0.6664618254,
0.7185300589,
0.6647500992,
0.0896608233,
0.0971041843,
0.531183064,
-0.9459037781,
0.3805615902,
0.3520500362,
0.2609763145,
0.2951886654,
-0.3962555528,
0.2208558619,
0.4379949272,
-0.4855750203,
-1.0302647352,
0.2121792436,
-1.0873042345,
-0.2683722675,
1.2652654648,
-0.1842345297,
-0.1923690289,
-0.2263032496,
-0.2866309583,
0.2493328452,
-0.8983410001,
0.6173613667,
0.6943870187,
-0.2544798255,
-0.562484026,
-0.0060899793,
0.5748544931,
0.477111429,
-0.6073639989,
0.0483354144,
0.7129259109,
0.2535126209,
-0.1742731184,
0.4266691506,
0.1135177761,
0.597119689,
0.289185524,
-0.2817671597,
-0.0811685324,
-0.6722221971,
-0.916246593,
0.5485101938,
0.2418631613,
-0.583031714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19328v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19328v2
|
Computational Approaches for Integrating out Subjectivity in Cognate Synonym Selection
| 2024-04-30T07:52:26 | 2024-06-05T15:56:26 |
Luise Häuser, Gerhard Jäger, Alexandros Stamatakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.PE
|
Working with cognate data involves handling synonyms, that is, multiple words
that describe the same concept in a language. In the early days of language
phylogenetics it was recommended to select one synonym only. However, as we
show here, binary character matrices, which are used as input for computational
methods, do allow for representing the entire dataset including all synonyms.
Here we address the question how one can and if one should include all synonyms
or whether it is preferable to select synonyms a priori. To this end, we
perform maximum likelihood tree inferences with the widely used RAxML-NG tool
and show that it yields plausible trees when all synonyms are used as input.
Furthermore, we show that a priori synonym selection can yield topologically
substantially different trees and we therefore advise against doing so. To
represent cognate data including all synonyms, we introduce two types of
character matrices beyond the standard binary ones: probabilistic binary and
probabilistic multi-valued character matrices. We further show that it is
dataset-dependent for which character matrix type the inferred RAxML-NG tree is
topologically closest to the gold standard. We also make available a Python
interface for generating all of the above character matrix types for cognate
data provided in CLDF format.
|
[
-0.5824713111,
-0.7597740889,
0.6719976068,
0.1229818091,
-0.3280144334,
-0.0705186799,
-0.3516436815,
-0.440500468,
0.4544758201,
0.3493919969,
-0.6335021257,
-0.4478700161,
-0.5756513476,
0.3783769608,
-0.3751333654,
0.8671666384,
-0.0595792457,
-0.0329173952,
-0.3829743862,
-0.4631010294,
-0.3066509366,
-1.0546334982,
-0.224350214,
-0.3486418128,
0.8392814398,
0.5316529274,
0.935319066,
0.534337759,
0.6498738527,
0.2547497451,
0.0681507289,
-0.1989842057,
-0.32226336,
0.6257027984,
-0.3371717036,
-0.5022943616,
-0.2962889969,
0.2370510846,
0.7490649223,
0.8475931287,
-0.1028060392,
0.0511907153,
-0.103672266,
0.4538399577,
-0.7409137487,
-0.0113301883,
-0.8042290807,
0.4182368517,
-0.4904478788,
-0.1914370656,
-0.1939110756,
-0.2766291201,
0.2635408938,
-0.669475913,
0.1930230707,
0.1168225408,
0.8813539147,
0.1644715816,
-0.2430081367,
-0.4269495308,
-0.4941580296,
0.9686976671,
-0.4708098173,
0.5282863379,
0.4043711126,
0.3201655149,
-0.2994533181,
-0.5516486764,
-0.7005758286,
-0.4184413254,
-0.3367573023,
0.1295041144,
-0.3305940628,
0.3209866285,
0.2803040445,
0.5062021017,
-0.6253684759,
0.1328939646,
-0.0371098183,
-0.2290803045,
0.4831422567,
0.1844538748,
0.1507766545,
-0.1513164937,
-0.230754748,
-0.4507873356,
-0.9917396307,
-0.2970285416,
0.3497175872,
0.3603526354,
0.1098408923,
0.9425259233,
0.0459666774,
0.7829846144,
0.0157187898,
-0.0183914546,
0.0205671471,
-0.3522610366,
-0.2360317558,
-0.0085909907,
0.9683900476,
-0.10782177,
0.0432807729,
-0.3950131238,
0.2031249553,
0.4092791378,
-0.0459089093,
-0.6859371662,
-0.2995202839,
0.3898566663,
-0.3460490704,
-0.0191358048,
-0.0513962656,
-0.7729117274,
-0.1643079519,
-0.3268583417,
0.3153349161,
-0.4222353101,
-0.3341150284,
-0.0740988627,
-0.4909133315,
0.0260366574,
0.2586553991,
-0.6668038964,
0.3682314157,
0.8818899989,
0.6775317192,
-0.2979425192,
-0.3234342635,
-0.5097140074,
0.0738291517,
-0.4237093925,
0.5781499147,
-1.0424690247,
-0.6078265309,
-0.4057985842,
-0.1568466276,
-0.1065115556,
-0.5256639123,
0.8112570643,
-0.3173789084,
0.483997941,
-0.4727888107,
-0.611620605,
-0.5610944629,
0.1232162789,
-0.6842916012,
0.968757093,
0.3292530775,
-1.054795146,
0.3902623355,
-0.3401546776,
-0.5543392301,
0.1217902303,
-0.4546108544,
-0.2889757156,
0.0442795567,
-0.3622574508,
0.7208878398,
-0.2327526808,
0.3763339221,
-0.619423151,
-0.0776174515,
0.4123710394,
0.0626352876,
0.637802422,
0.2942916155,
-0.2366428077,
-0.0635625571,
-0.5404740572,
0.1394435763,
-0.1244473532,
-0.0575105436,
-0.5146748424,
0.299975872,
0.1377425194,
0.2349643409,
0.0557918772,
-0.6866180301,
0.1142163351,
-0.3655185401,
0.3918263316,
0.3397318423,
-0.3068510294,
0.3253417611,
-0.3096567988,
0.7006396651,
0.0579848439,
-0.4647489786,
0.1911667287,
-0.6417480111,
-0.6423429847,
-0.4576295614,
0.3178284168,
0.4235485196,
-0.688328743,
0.6865323782,
-0.3711111844,
-0.5554153919,
-0.359770447,
-0.223479569,
0.3844433129,
0.4317441881,
0.2862765193,
-0.6118901372,
-0.7150884867,
-0.8267226815,
-0.0865426734,
-0.2494958937,
0.1636530012,
0.6488102078,
0.4512777627,
-0.0300476719,
1.2775799036,
-0.6158239841,
-0.2088810802,
-0.2412717044,
0.0484803021,
0.4110816121,
0.4747417569,
0.4927373528,
-0.7845570445,
-0.4782982469,
0.2264777422,
-0.6190032363,
0.1011805162,
0.1364227682,
-0.2115403265,
0.0494606271,
0.0850970149,
-0.567942977,
0.3623548746,
0.6031371951,
-0.2457416952,
0.6270693541,
-0.1661145091,
0.0092004072,
-1.3040610552,
0.446590811,
-0.0426833928,
-0.223819375,
-0.7181494236,
0.6221152544,
-0.2901335955,
-0.0113987047,
-0.2066658139,
0.5284928679,
-0.2758321166,
-0.3552159071,
0.0726827532,
0.1548245996,
-0.0606438257,
0.4158885181,
0.6466944218,
0.777007699,
0.5935497284,
-0.5274455547,
0.4967944622,
0.3929941952,
-0.1442170143,
0.5890393257,
-0.6428520679,
0.0930809155,
-0.0663506314,
0.2700600922,
-0.819578886,
-0.0695542395,
0.504529953,
-0.3834129572,
0.2760969698,
-0.0617946833,
-0.3953635991,
-0.0925596058,
-0.3048471212,
0.4393510818,
0.1750867516,
-0.3594853282,
0.3360284567,
0.546777308,
-0.2530201674,
-0.6252262592,
-0.800352633,
0.4453835785,
-0.4278216362,
-0.4252782464,
0.4482916594,
-0.1519126892,
-0.2035177499,
-0.0574311726,
0.327080816,
-0.2740388215,
0.199369207,
0.2169266343,
0.1854425818,
-0.276950717,
-0.0909607708,
0.1978088319,
-0.0852873176,
-0.3021583557,
-0.2093817592,
0.5358791351,
-0.1403093189,
-0.2133302689,
-0.1841315925,
0.8278087378,
0.3206524849,
-0.3564908206,
0.4404650927,
0.4324522018,
-0.2292317599,
0.0256560054,
-0.2983439863,
-0.2022200376,
-0.3896294236,
0.4341495335,
-0.5580527782,
-1.2144876719,
0.3745316565,
0.1997523606,
-0.0724490434,
0.3078977466,
0.6654530764,
0.0094410079,
0.7226529121,
0.4491020143,
0.0753663853,
0.2316532433,
-0.2054424733,
0.3182989359,
-0.9803086519,
0.011929593,
-0.8856653571,
-0.2984649241,
-0.9540560246,
-0.5139212608,
0.3293258846,
-0.088950105,
0.0177617669,
0.59985286,
-0.6028361917,
-0.0197725464,
0.5133684874,
-0.1339588463,
0.196688652,
0.3849126697,
-0.4151481986,
-0.2360137552,
-0.7287704945,
-0.2436438054,
0.9350964427,
0.0844550654,
0.6531745791,
0.18635948,
0.8330272436,
-0.0277121104,
0.3082271218,
-1.0500116348,
0.7587378025,
-0.4787817895,
-0.6804831028,
-0.113157995,
-0.4285934865,
-1.2712807655,
0.4657847583,
-0.4226078093,
-0.8973368406,
0.6924769282,
0.178182736,
-0.2355218232,
0.1027638465,
-0.4175238311,
0.8487271667,
0.1582153738,
-0.2652085423,
-0.4715874493,
-0.7656535506,
0.3946988583,
-0.0834636837,
0.0154857673,
0.0808019787,
-0.2103225887,
0.6236141324,
-0.4350030422,
0.4648014605,
0.2114104331,
-0.096116893,
0.293838352,
0.411570102,
0.1794770807,
-0.2965618968,
-0.227931276,
0.4382128417,
0.5749812126,
-0.0439922549,
-0.3040925264,
0.5821121931,
-0.6970859766,
-0.440364778,
-0.7660343647,
-0.5780706406,
-0.182003662,
0.0587568693,
0.2514036,
0.5313495994,
-0.4102239609,
0.2898233533,
0.2708724141,
-0.0571026206,
0.3330513835,
0.2629970908,
-0.2559075654,
-0.4714445174,
1.2226672173,
0.15056777,
0.1735599339,
0.6375538111,
0.4986619055,
-0.3423020244,
-0.3614949584,
-0.2644642293,
0.0737418085,
-0.6237242818,
-0.0334282592,
-0.7375901341,
0.0078764511,
-0.0661814138,
0.0175216291,
0.203100279,
-0.8324024081,
-0.1531191766,
0.2378808707,
0.4125512242,
0.6801268458,
-0.0729162097,
0.2539767325,
-0.7054321766,
0.2143974304,
0.1705937237,
0.1287937462,
-0.0116304727,
-0.0157607608,
0.0076111699,
0.1377203614,
-0.1908509135,
-1.1450442076,
0.3538170457,
0.7244564891,
0.4481804669,
0.3555721939,
-0.186842829,
0.5913086534,
-0.5160688162,
0.7568629384,
0.2158994675,
-0.7332255244,
0.207939893,
-0.3496671319,
-0.1126729921,
0.6972569823,
0.6010459065,
-1.0344024897,
-0.4595820606,
-0.5489444733,
-0.4681270719,
0.614295125,
0.3159254491,
-0.1578952968,
-0.166245684,
0.4005045295,
0.4059756696,
0.3988047242,
-0.4661403596,
-0.218254298,
-0.128404215,
-0.4675294161,
-0.3210240901,
-0.0308025647,
-0.0234485976,
-0.4626995027,
0.4554217756,
-0.238122642,
0.3783235252,
0.2655878365,
-0.184392184,
0.0173993409,
0.4424521625,
0.3833249807,
0.575696528,
-0.126941219,
0.3081359863,
-0.0822940916,
-0.7521221638,
0.164222151,
0.0588034913,
-0.1904473156,
0.3557925224,
0.288595885,
0.4909026325,
0.157919392,
-0.5579603314,
0.3935714364,
-0.0186766479,
-0.0632786527,
-0.0382295847,
0.0191925317,
0.1428623199,
-0.2174130678,
-0.04758773,
0.0832277611,
0.3077976406,
-0.7576237917,
0.1831617653,
0.9486238956,
-0.2093991339,
-0.4193169475,
0.3073121607,
-0.1220215037,
-0.1997946948,
0.4980444014,
-0.2101318538,
-0.6719855666,
0.4674207568,
0.3729986846,
1.0559555292,
-0.2908765972,
0.1206517145,
0.4374501407,
-0.080849804,
0.1912708431,
0.4545172155,
-0.3578696847,
-0.848141253,
-0.4401038289,
-0.812161088,
-0.5247471929,
-0.190756768,
-0.6214110851,
0.2217722088,
-0.4619903564,
-0.2669740617,
0.0794568658,
0.0203715581,
-0.5005084872,
0.2100118846,
0.1231330559,
0.6022834182,
-0.7326547503,
0.9684227109,
0.7567028999,
-0.2446298152,
-0.7560684681,
-0.1127569973,
-0.143280223,
-0.6946855783,
0.7372046113,
0.0539657623,
-0.1128344983,
-0.0113320556,
-0.3530575931,
-1.0267753601,
0.85490942,
0.3116802573,
-0.4400371611,
-0.0076911771,
0.2994369566,
0.5012886524,
-0.3142769337,
0.501968503,
0.5608128309,
0.543667078,
0.4387974739,
-0.8099498749,
0.0442298241,
-0.0312081967,
0.0283684861,
0.3167414069,
-0.1045330316,
1.0935615301,
0.1339756697,
-0.6030102372,
0.3571121395,
0.565525651,
0.1855829209,
-0.0353124775,
0.468182832,
0.9233662486,
0.686101377,
-0.1394105256,
0.9874479175,
-0.4845220149,
0.4788359404,
1.1893482208,
-0.4010257423,
1.0873479843,
0.5073820353,
-0.620726347,
0.6282798052,
0.8834736943,
0.0012680606,
0.2997179627,
0.1060232371,
-0.3540280163,
-0.367688328,
-0.2927373052,
-0.5113630295,
0.5911377668,
0.5701155663,
-0.1406939626,
-0.5319306254,
-0.4012895823,
0.1474278122,
-0.0391477272,
-0.014496414,
0.7269381285,
0.2377759367,
-1.0597332716,
0.6071855426,
0.1289891452,
0.6711123586,
-0.8604477644,
-0.1414562315,
0.0841104984,
0.0885108039,
-0.3429177105,
-0.9376907349,
0.3552716672,
-0.2560247481,
0.1111007109,
-0.1231411248,
0.5834406614,
-0.754786849,
-0.5629882812,
0.1418318897,
0.5688257217,
0.3939885199,
0.0272741579,
-0.6027968526,
-0.2287241966,
-0.4858956039,
0.1915558875,
0.2588637173,
0.1563247591,
-0.1462747008,
0.5251184106,
0.625503242,
0.3076731563,
-0.0815654844,
-0.3010925055,
0.8050826788,
-0.410264641,
-0.650801301,
-0.9825855494,
0.0438568592,
0.1557419896,
-0.2117764354,
0.836522162,
0.5607241988,
0.6457211375,
0.1424771994,
0.666154027,
-0.3394003212,
0.4459442496,
-0.3101918995,
0.5249276161,
-0.5690200329,
-0.3838129044,
-0.6052641273,
-1.0070675611,
-0.1740149111,
0.7266179919,
-0.113234289,
-0.1240755841,
0.9737529755,
0.8325535059,
-0.0786029622,
0.1976736635,
0.3310619295,
0.0592921227,
0.1638751775,
0.7274412513,
0.8244945407,
-0.121234946,
-0.1169646904,
-0.1048027351,
-0.2210865617,
-0.13645567,
-1.1033090353,
-0.7478402257,
-0.9616576433,
-0.1179351285,
-0.5121414661,
-0.06644696,
1.1591989994,
0.6633163095,
-0.864526093,
-0.5730136037,
-0.0760996118,
0.3556317091,
-0.254178524,
-0.1657092869,
0.3902223706,
-0.1220870763,
-0.5537677407,
0.2531858087,
0.3728837669,
-0.1880282313,
-0.4791786969,
-0.0990295783,
-0.4043940008,
-0.0915115997,
0.6150797606,
0.364276588,
-0.8106197715,
-0.3843702972,
-0.0670341402,
0.0361627452,
0.3729874492,
1.1064043045,
-0.9461645484,
0.5747343302,
0.6627439857,
0.4534091651,
0.2556608021,
-0.2131851614,
0.8405646682,
-0.6848580837,
0.2708705366,
0.4691863656,
0.5870373845,
0.4271890521,
-0.2379157841,
0.3084166646,
0.4706050158,
-0.2164090723,
-0.6876920462,
0.6176692843,
-1.1096489429,
-0.2641158402,
1.1551891565,
-0.2071338296,
-0.3102130592,
-0.2190872729,
-0.2178183347,
-0.0140952021,
-0.0071889143,
0.2399238795,
0.8130431175,
-0.0128895622,
0.1206730083,
-0.1646436006,
0.5733379126,
0.5112420917,
-0.7284933925,
-0.0127031822,
0.4588825107,
0.2521031201,
0.3132069707,
0.4505881965,
-0.0401891731,
0.30505234,
-0.3309836686,
-0.0074792462,
0.2450199723,
-0.1718870103,
-0.4578387439,
0.1047274545,
0.1533577144,
0.1732749939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19319v1
|
Knowledge Distillation vs. Pretraining from Scratch under a Fixed (Computation) Budget
| 2024-04-30T07:40:35 | 2024-04-30T07:40:35 |
Minh Duc Bui, Fabian David Schmidt, Goran Glavaš, Katharina von der Wense
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compared to standard language model (LM) pretraining (i.e., from scratch),
Knowledge Distillation (KD) entails an additional forward pass through a
teacher model that is typically substantially larger than the target student
model. As such, KD in LM pretraining materially slows down throughput of
pretraining instances vis-a-vis pretraining from scratch. Scaling laws of LM
pretraining suggest that smaller models can close the gap to larger
counterparts if trained on more data (i.e., processing more tokens)-and under a
fixed computation budget, smaller models are able be process more data than
larger models. We thus hypothesize that KD might, in fact, be suboptimal to
pretraining from scratch for obtaining smaller LMs, when appropriately
accounting for the compute budget. To test this, we compare pretraining from
scratch against several KD strategies for masked language modeling (MLM) in a
fair experimental setup, with respect to amount of computation as well as
pretraining data. Downstream results on GLUE, however, do not confirm our
hypothesis: while pretraining from scratch performs comparably to ordinary KD
under a fixed computation budget, more sophisticated KD strategies, namely
TinyBERT (Jiao et al., 2020) and MiniLM (Wang et al., 2023), outperform it by a
notable margin. We further find that KD yields larger gains over pretraining
from scratch when the data must be repeated under the fixed computation budget.
|
[
-0.4176216424,
-0.6224808693,
0.6304839849,
-0.071473226,
-0.3242118061,
0.3262172937,
-0.5145974159,
-0.2624240518,
0.1193477884,
0.3970825076,
-0.5967843533,
0.0479585342,
-0.8074851036,
-0.1151648462,
-0.2355028391,
0.9277149439,
-0.0206290279,
0.1772311628,
-0.7824252248,
0.197884649,
-0.4685016274,
-0.7549338341,
-0.492372632,
-0.7528095841,
0.5047925711,
0.4635123014,
0.4486141801,
0.645778656,
0.2739897668,
0.3215405047,
0.1119123921,
-0.2987138927,
-0.5737788677,
-0.1426337212,
0.0479427762,
-0.6681531072,
-0.1095327288,
0.4001356065,
0.1768738031,
0.9832189679,
-0.3050936162,
0.0748922601,
0.1995031387,
1.1045664549,
-0.9347918034,
-0.0397033729,
-0.6049616933,
0.074184671,
-0.1262280494,
0.1432877034,
-0.4276168048,
-0.460654974,
0.3839627504,
-0.5852726698,
0.3051659167,
-0.3339009881,
0.966617763,
0.5132479668,
-0.1476092935,
-0.4060119689,
-0.9454681873,
0.6569190621,
-0.6974337697,
0.6200885177,
0.5425052643,
0.337128073,
0.1308787614,
-1.1496292353,
-0.5551487207,
-0.359133631,
-0.0572803207,
-0.0763185024,
-0.0491466485,
0.1187265292,
0.4651061893,
0.4992176294,
-0.1892677695,
0.1336605549,
-0.7228488326,
-0.1109740511,
0.3980149925,
-0.2815003395,
0.008398748,
0.2369200587,
-0.4883449972,
-0.3021164238,
-0.786924839,
-0.0933431759,
0.2368567586,
0.257299006,
0.120040141,
0.3094522357,
-0.3084170818,
0.4751466215,
0.298648864,
-0.4448496103,
0.0785418674,
-0.2796341181,
-0.3421009183,
0.2698817849,
0.5408941507,
0.1874829978,
0.7789306641,
-0.274096638,
-0.1557540894,
0.011460688,
0.202652663,
-1.1208627224,
-0.8057044148,
-0.0572877973,
-0.1904802173,
-0.2052312493,
-0.22018902,
-0.3544341028,
-0.3801833093,
-0.6835026741,
0.6014384627,
-0.2471636832,
-0.2288939506,
0.0614250302,
-0.1481863111,
-0.2235228121,
0.3482653201,
-0.8967870474,
0.329413563,
0.3553368747,
0.8018937707,
-0.1014836654,
-0.3122039437,
-0.0915599242,
-0.379027307,
-0.4630837142,
0.4336141944,
-0.2339015752,
-0.2872152925,
-0.3202886283,
-0.3222843707,
-0.3156266212,
-0.8499535322,
-0.0361373164,
-0.6847751141,
0.1409350038,
-0.4424367845,
-0.7677042484,
0.1371543854,
-0.0289614201,
-0.6683743,
1.0064914227,
0.2271180898,
-0.7931194901,
1.0199599266,
-0.3975583315,
-0.3600699306,
-0.1402888596,
-0.1173473448,
-0.2586641312,
0.057783708,
-0.0359973237,
0.4123058915,
-0.2527486086,
0.2372941226,
-0.4279377759,
-0.3637887537,
0.2276389897,
-0.2751087546,
0.6258472204,
0.4393720925,
-0.3630744517,
-0.3351231217,
-0.8294249773,
0.0569515824,
-0.0078963554,
-0.5647131205,
-0.5323063731,
0.0298416242,
-0.4364605844,
0.4221112132,
0.259226799,
-0.5287674069,
0.1969605833,
-0.3840607703,
0.3082433343,
0.8948562145,
-0.1811260283,
0.6791300178,
-0.1728978455,
0.5079022646,
0.1592281163,
-0.1807942986,
-0.1056559235,
-0.1499619484,
-0.9145896435,
-0.3858234882,
0.7623801231,
0.3125848174,
-0.895209372,
-0.144544363,
-0.1655730456,
-0.6251273155,
-0.6378120184,
0.1628699452,
0.5581865311,
0.5056086183,
0.3359384835,
-0.2982780337,
-0.6245546341,
-0.7442188263,
-0.2212513834,
0.0209674947,
-0.1457293183,
0.1530940682,
0.4602892995,
0.2229787409,
1.114633441,
-0.73974365,
-0.2500764132,
-0.2632243335,
-0.0073046782,
0.0758977011,
0.6657298803,
0.6199297905,
-0.4326713085,
-0.919678092,
-0.0988962501,
-0.4309363663,
-0.0305249039,
0.0855066627,
0.1686629057,
0.4077417254,
0.8337253928,
-0.678976655,
0.5866086483,
0.3718889654,
-0.1759567112,
0.7056797743,
-0.335554868,
0.0550584532,
-0.8837676644,
-0.0405932441,
-0.4903999567,
-0.1596867889,
-0.7884777784,
-0.0806508958,
-0.0537565574,
-0.03923738,
-0.3793524206,
0.229400903,
-0.4798974991,
0.0597820953,
-0.464812398,
-0.0397262238,
-0.0014669871,
0.5356817245,
0.1657191366,
0.7453094125,
0.3724840581,
-0.7076993585,
0.182974264,
-0.4631979167,
-0.7722008824,
0.0437997691,
-0.7758001685,
0.323094964,
0.0388323404,
0.1200186014,
-0.7682893276,
-0.0134011908,
-0.0354079232,
-0.2576389909,
0.502877295,
-0.121260725,
-0.3281071782,
-0.2974454463,
-0.1028340012,
0.4644378126,
0.8491410017,
-0.4526449144,
0.1881994903,
0.0937556624,
-0.0742276907,
-0.5963300467,
-0.7278712392,
-0.3128773868,
-0.3466766775,
-0.4504266679,
0.1812378615,
-0.0754193366,
-0.3210131526,
0.0510384254,
-0.3475352228,
-0.2832323313,
0.3667773902,
0.1437829435,
0.0462694541,
-0.4203938246,
0.0177609753,
-0.3080437183,
-0.1028801501,
0.1728601158,
-0.4890769124,
0.7118429542,
0.1749004126,
-0.4242085814,
-0.1758945584,
-0.0904784724,
0.4942491651,
0.1490818262,
1.1167007685,
0.3194237053,
-0.2658471167,
-0.2695044577,
-0.6395950913,
-0.4133434296,
-0.5033964515,
0.1939444244,
-0.4356082082,
-0.8764440417,
0.3134154379,
-0.1715470403,
-0.0206471551,
0.3862017691,
0.5151052475,
-0.2524353564,
0.6083856225,
0.8879410625,
-0.054273203,
0.3435024321,
-0.2211539,
0.2776980996,
-0.3327548206,
-0.1342447549,
-0.5950030088,
-0.4989970028,
-0.4313493371,
-0.5198779702,
0.0330057964,
0.5802341104,
-0.2835290432,
0.1659208834,
-0.2624717057,
0.8408797383,
0.9603556395,
-0.0208688304,
0.3068394363,
0.0613171831,
-0.2680802047,
-0.2343642563,
-1.0924550295,
-0.2343924046,
1.4338053465,
0.1886757165,
0.8448135257,
-0.3346990645,
0.9337637424,
0.0713847056,
0.3470240533,
-0.5455729365,
0.3398068547,
-0.1071061268,
-0.5912154913,
-0.3871928751,
-0.4937042296,
-0.8267326951,
0.2740231752,
-0.080180496,
-0.7487286925,
0.3269323409,
0.4918832183,
-0.2605730593,
0.5311709046,
-1.1133513451,
0.886210382,
0.0724304765,
-0.0580974296,
-0.1474532783,
-0.5776087046,
0.4590232074,
-0.5531029701,
0.2458114028,
0.0742729753,
0.4127618372,
0.9467059374,
-0.984911859,
0.7190874815,
-0.5164405107,
-0.0148202954,
0.3298735321,
-0.0734906867,
0.2699610889,
-0.3780092597,
0.2679208815,
-0.0070896675,
0.3113599718,
-0.47659868,
-0.693525672,
0.3913879395,
-0.9653049707,
-0.750331521,
-0.2610470653,
-0.3965638876,
-0.1707726717,
0.1745241433,
0.5155121088,
0.303280443,
-0.0278726667,
0.4083666801,
0.7189370394,
-0.0366944298,
0.5189979672,
0.4421057105,
-0.3293789923,
-0.1312776655,
0.8694027066,
0.6031160355,
0.8761867285,
0.1540683359,
0.3131279647,
-0.1761095077,
-0.5023334622,
-0.1965024024,
-0.0500465557,
-0.7463525534,
0.0051664948,
-0.3947797716,
-0.2871512771,
-0.423232764,
-0.1946921945,
-0.8451621532,
-0.6980621815,
-0.0607631058,
-0.1102101654,
0.2288478613,
0.586740911,
-0.2157293856,
0.2972602844,
-0.4432731271,
0.1451410055,
0.4743134081,
0.2869436145,
0.256467551,
-0.513736546,
-0.6662690043,
0.3708430231,
-0.1580784917,
-0.538634479,
0.0713436976,
0.263233602,
0.3675722778,
0.6592922211,
0.3317747116,
0.9407624602,
-0.6975401044,
0.8087262511,
0.3264346421,
-0.6210306883,
0.2961365879,
0.1562696993,
0.4719229937,
0.8210042119,
0.6321185231,
-0.3064136505,
-0.4305239916,
-0.6995031238,
-0.7063571215,
0.8710169792,
0.0417807773,
0.018119406,
0.3388582766,
0.2365754694,
0.1292615086,
0.4427905977,
-0.6566445827,
-0.4297049344,
-0.1245425493,
0.1742296368,
-0.419205904,
-0.2866170108,
0.0766223222,
-0.4943161607,
0.6804092526,
0.1992491335,
0.0899172574,
0.0826141164,
-0.3500927985,
0.1016583443,
0.1017719433,
0.4972850978,
0.8781173229,
-0.2462657094,
0.322126925,
0.194417268,
-0.8981449008,
0.2522861362,
-0.0867460594,
-0.2062884718,
-0.0112381326,
0.51870507,
1.0027801991,
0.1506555378,
-0.5136395693,
0.3782738745,
0.1459620297,
-0.5701889992,
0.0552901886,
0.1692593843,
0.3648184836,
0.1228964552,
0.2903912067,
0.124674879,
-0.3169598579,
-0.500117898,
0.1538411677,
0.1474756151,
-0.2242987603,
-0.1985612512,
0.5866247416,
-0.066423811,
-0.1233625785,
0.7540564537,
-0.0272453688,
-0.4616716802,
0.5557973385,
0.3563285768,
0.7217522264,
-0.287691474,
0.1105679423,
0.1832193136,
0.4293542802,
-0.107972078,
-0.1083381101,
-0.369020462,
-0.831879437,
-0.572722137,
-0.8586970568,
-0.1392147094,
0.3442738354,
-0.7159366012,
-0.0260855351,
-0.5407619476,
-0.0231057703,
-0.0281785689,
0.2119550556,
-0.7041684985,
0.3400855064,
-0.0812244713,
0.8646575212,
-0.8198000789,
1.1041257381,
0.6142915487,
-0.2561800182,
-1.1329200268,
-0.2202198207,
-0.1991334409,
-0.6768830419,
0.9736834168,
0.0511732586,
0.1451401412,
0.0050204676,
-0.2607759237,
-0.8416908383,
1.1880135536,
0.5508727431,
-0.7397224903,
-0.1302217394,
0.4595543146,
0.4348022044,
-0.250498265,
-0.0730925426,
0.8711414933,
0.1148920804,
0.4296764433,
-1.1848521233,
-0.1302461773,
0.1105708033,
-0.1769772619,
0.2740013599,
-0.2127305865,
1.1917027235,
-0.2982046902,
-0.3499879837,
-0.3949398398,
0.4407790899,
0.2213308513,
0.5052045584,
0.5324835181,
0.9383879304,
0.7410042882,
-0.1575659513,
0.8750356436,
-0.2949905992,
0.2845461369,
1.2507731915,
-0.1127353758,
0.6617438197,
0.6906760335,
-0.6941592097,
0.4809967577,
0.7065545321,
0.3633326888,
0.7807995081,
0.2852410674,
-0.1221294478,
-0.2176593244,
0.3140798211,
-0.6315097213,
0.1631691605,
-0.1359923482,
-0.0990594178,
-0.2410676628,
0.2570119798,
0.2534219623,
0.0767956376,
-0.4327789247,
0.9228528142,
0.3618410528,
-0.755841136,
0.850748539,
-0.1310124993,
0.5797307491,
-0.5688270926,
0.3394456506,
-0.3771418929,
0.3810311556,
-0.0091587882,
-0.1245051101,
0.2896238565,
0.0246682521,
-0.3047039211,
-0.465955168,
0.968917191,
-0.5575531721,
-0.2706879973,
-0.0449304208,
0.5782519579,
0.2661653161,
-0.2064251453,
-0.3930893242,
-0.1173971444,
-0.0213526841,
-0.4544224739,
0.8679813147,
0.4253363013,
0.0835932195,
0.675891459,
0.7812935114,
0.1934807748,
0.3672069311,
-0.0222718921,
1.0446984768,
-0.1276383996,
-0.5378927588,
-1.1759637594,
0.4356327653,
0.1302477866,
0.0492959544,
0.9271330237,
0.4378747046,
1.1964673996,
-0.3534994423,
0.5480191708,
0.0072731497,
0.2963294983,
-0.7212458849,
0.9947014451,
-0.4541370273,
0.2115041167,
-0.2709315717,
-1.0090281963,
0.2977015078,
0.5486405492,
-0.3507595956,
0.2876848876,
0.738625586,
0.5377914906,
-0.0927699432,
-0.1667196304,
0.2591028214,
0.0936028212,
-0.0250465274,
0.4456113577,
0.8652083874,
-0.1293905675,
0.2884958088,
-0.5706063509,
-0.0440337136,
0.0296650231,
-0.8375288248,
-1.0198712349,
-0.6402485967,
-0.3888120651,
-0.2733802199,
-0.1256006062,
0.6797532439,
0.7559472919,
-0.6497203112,
-0.2640728951,
-0.2882384956,
0.157550469,
-0.0847677067,
-0.2072772235,
0.2801011801,
-0.5588744283,
-0.4781285524,
0.2231609374,
-0.1394325644,
0.0194591861,
-0.2662551105,
-0.1787163168,
-0.3024533093,
0.2509687841,
0.5570595264,
0.2389722914,
-0.4065882564,
-0.0776215568,
-0.049867928,
-0.0085942475,
-0.1105984375,
1.0270898342,
-1.1148993969,
0.4796305299,
0.310841918,
0.6948788166,
0.9807277322,
-0.1747441292,
0.5897107124,
-0.9095658064,
0.329936713,
0.0035993652,
-0.067202419,
0.0357463732,
-0.0377166569,
0.2681328058,
0.4512610734,
-0.5324636102,
-1.1589772701,
0.1278250068,
-0.2280747592,
-0.6789435148,
0.7833688855,
-0.3606125116,
0.0958174318,
0.0088421227,
0.0464791656,
0.203320384,
0.068860352,
0.6677253842,
1.0687894821,
0.1025920361,
0.0295189284,
-0.5882400274,
1.0252861977,
0.3818367422,
-0.3884742558,
-0.0407678373,
0.3131833673,
0.4434894025,
0.2120313942,
1.0683135986,
0.2560112178,
0.1389750391,
0.260078311,
-0.0019632694,
-0.2694273889,
-0.6457846165,
0.0230310597,
0.1582936645,
0.2024548501,
-0.2967138886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19318v1
|
Enhancing Trust in LLM-Generated Code Summaries with Calibrated Confidence Scores
| 2024-04-30T07:38:08 | 2024-04-30T07:38:08 |
Yuvraj Virk, Premkumar Devanbu, Toufique Ahmed
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
A good summary can often be very useful during program comprehension. While a
brief, fluent, and relevant summary can be helpful, it does require significant
human effort to produce. Often, good summaries are unavailable in software
projects, thus making maintenance more difficult. There has been a considerable
body of research into automated AI-based methods, using Large Language models
(LLMs), to generate summaries of code; there also has been quite a bit work on
ways to measure the performance of such summarization methods, with special
attention paid to how closely these AI-generated summaries resemble a summary a
human might have produced. Measures such as BERTScore and BLEU have been
suggested and evaluated with human-subject studies.
However, LLMs often err and generate something quite unlike what a human
might say. Given an LLM-produced code summary, is there a way to gauge whether
it's likely to be sufficiently similar to a human produced summary, or not? In
this paper, we study this question, as a calibration problem: given a summary
from an LLM, can we compute a confidence measure, which is a good indication of
whether the summary is sufficiently similar to what a human would have produced
in this situation? We examine this question using several LLMs, for several
languages, and in several different settings. We suggest an approach which
provides well-calibrated predictions of likelihood of similarity to human
summaries.
|
[
-0.2267210186,
-0.1297460496,
0.646561563,
0.1560211182,
-0.2403255403,
0.1848519742,
-0.289521873,
-0.6008428931,
0.2976928353,
0.4948467314,
-0.1919719279,
-0.5664671063,
-0.5714673996,
0.3344617188,
-0.4587249756,
1.0413295031,
-0.1425855905,
0.0852811113,
-0.5437424183,
0.0213729702,
-0.2069834173,
-0.496094346,
-0.373459816,
-0.834577024,
0.2236678153,
0.2783600688,
0.7489999533,
0.5384736061,
0.5589538217,
0.2130965441,
0.1038897336,
0.3321862817,
-0.6201013923,
0.1165960655,
0.1157641485,
-0.8502084017,
-0.515756309,
0.0942271501,
0.4531539083,
0.5208662152,
0.0767614245,
0.3587089181,
0.4682873785,
0.6978652477,
-0.4921451509,
0.4011088908,
-0.569401741,
-0.0819333866,
0.2241072953,
-0.6036680937,
-0.3878620565,
-0.7869428992,
-0.0372736119,
-0.4348482788,
0.1746404469,
0.0062906384,
0.8094240427,
0.3299755156,
-0.1882105321,
-0.4064511359,
-0.6378267407,
0.9621731043,
-0.9914796948,
-0.1433781981,
0.6800478697,
0.1439842135,
-0.2656005025,
-0.3882783055,
-0.4894279242,
-0.6178833246,
-0.1722698361,
0.3000876307,
0.2471029609,
-0.025059361,
0.3063483834,
0.3169386089,
-0.475726366,
-0.1279219091,
-0.2261985838,
-0.5566775203,
0.9762158394,
0.1201707721,
0.0830179155,
-0.2560105026,
-0.2611511052,
-0.2880265117,
-0.9520637393,
0.1269059479,
0.5803134441,
-0.0792502239,
-0.0664928108,
0.7368659973,
-0.1116997153,
0.4162730277,
-0.050472375,
-0.3547619581,
0.1909094453,
-0.3829797506,
-0.1257349402,
0.1163566262,
0.5301684141,
0.9226319194,
0.9713023305,
-0.1492194533,
-0.3680298924,
0.2110321075,
0.294898659,
-0.7522441745,
-0.4038576782,
0.3118496239,
-0.5024971962,
-0.4237735868,
0.504329145,
-0.2463287562,
-0.3802361786,
-0.4177393913,
0.276479125,
-0.3545953035,
0.0818435326,
-0.3072774112,
-0.0313673764,
0.4523602128,
0.4032996297,
-0.5557063818,
0.1275624931,
0.7799967527,
0.5835280418,
-0.2993835807,
-0.4244957268,
-0.5774071813,
0.1154753938,
-0.6279407144,
0.5807171464,
-0.2200820148,
-0.6716015339,
-0.125760287,
-0.3767784834,
0.1222318485,
-0.5108433962,
0.1009435952,
-0.466639787,
0.0938853323,
-0.2092639953,
-0.8054016232,
-0.1619330645,
0.5711765885,
-0.555524528,
0.9089252949,
0.02662622,
-0.9056751132,
0.2396903634,
-0.1922522187,
-0.514420867,
-0.2124477327,
-0.5953217745,
-0.4424043298,
0.236325115,
0.1318815947,
0.5782854557,
-0.0989740938,
0.1424101293,
-0.326130271,
-0.6490784883,
0.7881215811,
-0.4492729604,
0.5490490794,
0.1987351477,
-0.2072687745,
-0.1461279392,
-0.4727811217,
0.3904050291,
-0.2862748802,
-0.3660674691,
-0.2933028042,
-0.0378998891,
-0.2197510302,
-0.1881477237,
0.6015142798,
-0.3133907318,
-0.1850827485,
-0.528636992,
-0.0515864193,
0.736299634,
0.2739843428,
0.314612627,
-0.9087538719,
0.6249216199,
-0.2174324691,
-0.0295172017,
-0.4726111591,
-0.4423603714,
-0.6250036955,
-0.0259226393,
0.3931282759,
0.6333470941,
-0.6486139894,
0.544410944,
-0.440331161,
-0.4818800092,
-0.3156996667,
0.3459478617,
0.6437145472,
0.4650633931,
-0.0032944118,
-0.6268926263,
-0.2837958038,
-0.9013692141,
-0.4015111923,
-0.5932203531,
-0.3965311348,
0.3383462429,
0.377646476,
0.0008714744,
1.0461771488,
-0.6406863928,
-0.1170017794,
-0.0529024564,
0.3723733425,
0.1949010044,
0.3843567967,
0.6029649377,
-0.6661294699,
-0.6551190019,
-0.0549958497,
-0.7090664506,
-0.1587827057,
-0.1842557043,
0.0855721161,
0.2272515744,
0.5640345812,
-0.2850113511,
0.4743282199,
0.5979992151,
0.0728661567,
0.6770471931,
-0.5116725564,
0.4786431789,
-1.5155482292,
0.3003755212,
-0.0880546421,
-0.5713061094,
-0.2041188627,
0.2877229452,
0.0728675872,
0.3036072254,
-0.2244405597,
0.2663952708,
-0.3837493956,
-0.3065414727,
-0.3633748293,
0.1154549718,
0.0660552159,
0.2004105896,
-0.0986531302,
0.9694671035,
0.3970044553,
-0.4957599342,
0.2208507508,
0.0753143281,
-0.4346027672,
0.5546235442,
-0.8458765149,
0.1505566686,
0.004612979,
0.2639666498,
-1.0766905546,
-0.3550163209,
-0.1736579835,
-0.9176633954,
0.2482344806,
-0.064923279,
-0.5708102584,
0.0057445844,
-0.7733968496,
0.2546705902,
0.6451905966,
-0.1598128229,
0.5717058778,
0.1872455627,
-0.4089037776,
-0.6824156046,
-0.9982586503,
0.0703336596,
-0.1539827138,
-0.5296593308,
0.2088316828,
-0.2715496421,
-0.4206347167,
-0.176329881,
-0.1471140683,
-0.1297871917,
0.1929435581,
0.6584771872,
0.4143483043,
-0.1006175652,
-0.0667343065,
0.0073621599,
-0.0963939577,
0.3075158596,
0.1688197404,
0.2322783768,
-0.1441897601,
-0.5505910516,
-0.2564929426,
0.2808309793,
0.7677323818,
-0.1015687808,
0.4001157284,
0.4685917795,
-0.302441597,
-0.1902447492,
-0.627335012,
-0.3961397409,
-0.4107320011,
0.1278883219,
-0.1562115252,
-0.7245287895,
0.6970329881,
-0.048088938,
0.0803937912,
0.1876539737,
0.6807464361,
-0.3632669747,
0.8790656328,
0.7506196499,
-0.481318295,
0.2647692561,
-0.1290826648,
-0.0230825935,
-0.6314573288,
-0.0851707682,
-0.6022609472,
-0.2335299551,
-0.6682426929,
-0.4738470316,
0.493093133,
-0.0307865329,
0.1329721361,
0.3399882019,
-0.1152562201,
0.7342311144,
0.7005007267,
0.0571951717,
0.5187539458,
-0.0290247574,
-0.0781494379,
0.1862771213,
-0.3158058822,
-0.9469381571,
1.265786171,
0.2371266931,
0.9971803427,
0.0384239554,
1.1349992752,
0.5437530875,
0.5516450405,
-0.5264222026,
0.4553427696,
0.0607822612,
-0.3118741512,
-0.2178294361,
-0.6491372585,
-0.8000769019,
-0.1982330978,
-0.2013360113,
-0.7732852101,
-0.2769952118,
0.4183795154,
-0.4519381225,
-0.2016848326,
-0.7009836435,
0.2759384811,
-0.0873643532,
-0.0247984473,
-0.40306741,
-0.6779056787,
0.3399065733,
-0.2913038433,
0.1952006817,
-0.1360162199,
0.0226639248,
0.5593397617,
-0.281719625,
0.8995714188,
0.1833562255,
-0.1444522738,
0.4564400315,
0.4280723035,
0.4693328738,
0.3121219575,
-0.3653769493,
0.0138439843,
0.1873681247,
-0.3083473444,
-0.5899224281,
0.7863968015,
-0.6985384822,
-0.4334171414,
-0.2958327532,
-0.6394934058,
-0.1040858105,
0.1255295724,
0.3814724386,
0.3011189401,
-0.2487786114,
0.0911319032,
0.5317515135,
-0.1547117829,
0.4327824712,
0.2345729768,
-0.1676466316,
-0.3678866029,
0.6733334661,
-0.1565357447,
0.4362039268,
0.4161907732,
0.0645002201,
-0.2793854177,
-0.4533168375,
-0.3025065064,
0.1548557878,
-0.5769713521,
-0.4908803701,
0.0650740787,
-0.2814354897,
-0.3790829182,
-0.2660742402,
-0.1928493381,
-0.4232262969,
-0.3212682307,
-0.0181552153,
0.282494694,
0.7190971375,
0.1083211973,
0.0214937124,
-0.9939299226,
0.2660601437,
0.1558258832,
0.3010419011,
0.0178243816,
-0.5507948995,
-0.3099515438,
0.3143359423,
-0.2365339994,
-0.8119053245,
0.3742657006,
0.1674628407,
0.5656855702,
0.3167778552,
0.3624747694,
0.5909937024,
-0.2289559543,
0.8974522352,
0.1202330813,
-0.9247797132,
0.4648174345,
-0.1025072336,
0.1782323122,
0.8116334677,
0.2744494975,
-0.139833644,
-0.8642461896,
-0.5210675001,
-0.5254883766,
0.2411271781,
0.5423069596,
0.3084968626,
0.1378159225,
0.4312405884,
0.0395110585,
0.2855531871,
-0.625246644,
-0.2134345919,
0.0643417686,
-0.3440528214,
-0.3933762908,
-0.0792900696,
-0.1785640121,
0.2886829674,
0.5440645814,
-0.3465163112,
0.0716387033,
0.339424789,
-0.2685084641,
-0.1903648674,
0.2245183736,
0.6896213889,
0.9315984845,
-0.3422413766,
0.2807321846,
0.215680629,
-0.5322076082,
-0.0837959498,
-0.1069217846,
-0.2564437091,
-0.0861022472,
0.6884848475,
0.2224349678,
0.0107869105,
-0.834879458,
0.7036821246,
-0.0593909062,
-0.1606186032,
-0.4888476729,
0.259234041,
0.0414482988,
0.2459162921,
0.3433417082,
0.1994880289,
0.0907166377,
-0.480075717,
0.4594223797,
0.3137297034,
-0.2044536322,
-0.1309905499,
0.3840870559,
0.1806001514,
-0.3268640339,
0.5475214124,
-0.1570371538,
-0.5728872418,
0.8055534363,
0.3182688057,
0.787999928,
-0.0280992482,
0.0934778377,
0.2945569754,
0.3249402046,
-0.2553066313,
0.3556694984,
-0.0781348348,
-0.7221640944,
-0.699780345,
-0.4804228246,
-0.7413827777,
-0.3376248181,
-0.8231517076,
-0.0209923312,
-0.2779565752,
-0.2590323389,
-0.5172119141,
0.1897758394,
-0.4880143404,
0.121268101,
0.2496235967,
0.8760653734,
-0.9671006799,
0.8726179004,
0.5662456155,
-0.3053052127,
-1.0820448399,
0.3181940019,
-0.1934764087,
-0.7551465631,
0.2068852484,
0.2056220472,
-0.3282443881,
-0.2430315763,
-0.4719150066,
-0.5673162341,
1.4177616835,
0.4998855889,
-0.4349499941,
0.1254549026,
0.1710729003,
0.7267596722,
-0.362929821,
0.2409496009,
0.3596362472,
0.3776308,
0.0320729986,
-1.117685914,
0.0392311625,
-0.1229448691,
0.0636377707,
-0.0981452316,
-0.3933219016,
0.673114121,
-0.3981720805,
0.0046075182,
0.4007607698,
0.6304696798,
0.4947311282,
0.4620589912,
0.4695755243,
0.1673460901,
0.8669646978,
0.2203766406,
1.2832716703,
-0.6422286034,
0.4064089954,
1.343626976,
-0.3454033434,
0.9875212908,
0.52628088,
-0.1177506223,
0.4435277581,
0.3884426951,
-0.0047455244,
0.2237586677,
0.3662951589,
-0.0450078808,
-0.2995247841,
0.098146081,
-0.3566896617,
0.4280122221,
0.1806719601,
-0.6808937788,
-0.1058714092,
-0.5699968338,
-0.0643545464,
0.4069834352,
-0.2687743306,
0.7871468663,
0.4920882881,
-1.0006825924,
0.3479943573,
0.0157954283,
0.5459779501,
-0.5577495098,
-0.0906928554,
-0.3076862693,
0.1335943788,
-0.2707256079,
-0.8652012348,
0.3122133315,
0.2230570912,
-0.1963719428,
-0.1014554352,
0.6241611242,
-0.3833972216,
-0.5739119649,
0.0517712422,
0.6800521016,
0.450743258,
-0.1064545736,
-0.3996632695,
-0.022044912,
0.2493012398,
-0.1436217874,
0.3272288144,
0.1369876713,
0.0213242099,
0.7199395895,
0.5268563032,
0.339592725,
-0.0901721567,
0.0568376705,
0.5189926624,
-0.4029332101,
-0.452439338,
-0.9536129832,
0.1942510307,
-0.1970586181,
-0.0967832059,
0.9064817429,
0.6423429847,
0.8183532953,
-0.1048971117,
0.8002218008,
0.2815560699,
0.3776782453,
-0.604096055,
0.9384790659,
-0.2444786727,
0.4437790513,
-0.4560382068,
-1.1853836775,
-0.3388943672,
0.7794456482,
-0.1143728122,
0.1239932626,
0.5292233229,
1.1116937399,
0.1202286109,
-0.1921620071,
0.385777086,
0.0316055305,
0.2401527017,
0.6881219149,
0.7369818091,
-0.3183868527,
0.556884706,
-0.2106560618,
-0.2957167029,
-0.3014178574,
-1.2777980566,
-0.9073745012,
-0.3361633718,
-0.3502014279,
-0.4207791686,
-0.1956045479,
0.9763320088,
0.6923917532,
-0.825537324,
-0.3812261522,
0.128547892,
0.1839401424,
-0.1266876906,
-0.1420976967,
0.3424418271,
0.0191070829,
-0.6273812056,
0.0654537231,
0.1233129576,
0.3018554151,
-0.3866945207,
-0.4225344658,
0.5159950852,
0.3643439412,
0.3850221932,
0.0489978977,
-0.6600990295,
-0.5204014182,
-0.055098556,
-0.3316264153,
-0.0550973266,
0.732283175,
-0.7680107951,
0.2903374135,
0.5938347578,
0.610455811,
0.2890223563,
0.3597734869,
0.9040250182,
-1.0084768534,
-0.3315000832,
0.2398372591,
0.4328232408,
0.4022658467,
-0.4246551096,
0.4149962366,
-0.368175149,
-0.6952295899,
-0.6552107334,
0.2350112647,
-1.1038281918,
0.0612044446,
1.1396791935,
-0.6174585819,
-0.0791359395,
0.0907148719,
-0.2057136148,
0.1577004641,
-0.3880243599,
1.0597858429,
0.7021116614,
-0.168057099,
0.2264045626,
-0.1865229756,
0.3333501816,
0.300504595,
-0.8750354648,
0.0973170847,
0.515322566,
0.4209439754,
0.3900200129,
0.5267144442,
-0.1597308815,
0.5976996422,
-0.084405981,
-0.0487799644,
-0.1136321872,
-0.1928103566,
-0.1757517159,
0.1788544953,
0.5579020381,
-0.0988888368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19317v1
|
Revisiting N-Gram Models: Their Impact in Modern Neural Networks for Handwritten Text Recognition
| 2024-04-30T07:37:48 | 2024-04-30T07:37:48 |
Solène Tarride, Christopher Kermorvant
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In recent advances in automatic text recognition (ATR), deep neural networks
have demonstrated the ability to implicitly capture language statistics,
potentially reducing the need for traditional language models. This study
directly addresses whether explicit language models, specifically n-gram
models, still contribute to the performance of state-of-the-art deep learning
architectures in the field of handwriting recognition. We evaluate two
prominent neural network architectures, PyLaia and DAN, with and without the
integration of explicit n-gram language models. Our experiments on three
datasets - IAM, RIMES, and NorHand v2 - at both line and page level,
investigate optimal parameters for n-gram models, including their order,
weight, smoothing methods and tokenization level. The results show that
incorporating character or subword n-gram models significantly improves the
performance of ATR models on all datasets, challenging the notion that deep
learning models alone are sufficient for optimal performance. In particular,
the combination of DAN with a character language model outperforms current
benchmarks, confirming the value of hybrid approaches in modern document
analysis systems.
|
[
0.0704145133,
-0.4835349619,
0.6223542094,
-0.3654469252,
-0.1584993601,
-0.0406268165,
-0.0555334128,
-0.7743112445,
0.0361235552,
0.5165323019,
-0.0458842777,
-0.6153602004,
-0.7811248302,
0.1709168106,
-0.5301517844,
0.7067688107,
-0.1269645095,
0.1131560355,
-0.1845771968,
-0.0854285583,
0.2726086974,
-0.6220706701,
-0.6586836576,
-0.3502086699,
0.6539352536,
0.2343236208,
0.5873349905,
0.7331029773,
0.7761873603,
0.3471670449,
-0.2052018195,
0.1987644881,
0.1045684814,
-0.0349640921,
0.5805614591,
-0.4760801494,
-0.889303267,
0.229695186,
0.8338635564,
0.8197687864,
0.2656561136,
-0.1616190076,
0.026148418,
0.3752978444,
-0.6589131951,
0.0647754297,
-0.1346376687,
-0.0475360826,
-0.3669628203,
0.1654756218,
-0.4850713015,
-0.5707823634,
0.390375942,
-0.6064404249,
0.3655675948,
-0.3042644858,
0.7385278344,
-0.106665723,
-0.370097965,
-0.6922399402,
-0.5855671763,
0.5227836967,
-1.0533447266,
0.3780044019,
0.3076233566,
0.2669455409,
-0.1214126572,
-0.8698642254,
-0.6076480746,
-0.441825211,
-0.195160225,
-0.0074291453,
-0.1471446753,
0.2279461175,
0.2239743918,
0.6628574729,
-0.2154180706,
0.4502762854,
-0.2392079681,
-0.188105613,
0.6376933455,
0.2612424791,
0.4801817536,
0.0832546204,
0.0118968012,
-0.1882145107,
-0.5076714158,
0.2341475487,
0.7225615978,
0.5001772642,
-0.1238527074,
0.3583438694,
0.0655312613,
0.861948669,
-0.0195880178,
-0.1743661463,
0.1246646419,
-0.2247670889,
-0.3428778052,
-0.2254939824,
0.8787031174,
0.0702541173,
0.392611891,
-0.3340843916,
-0.2050134987,
0.0501596667,
0.06573046,
-0.9275304675,
-0.4218243659,
-0.3397268355,
-0.7960699797,
-0.4853901863,
0.2999900281,
-0.9099704027,
-0.8249271512,
-0.5021567941,
0.0996485353,
-0.1605706513,
-0.4833999574,
0.1824287325,
-0.2566170096,
0.2002945393,
0.4588290751,
-0.9977632761,
0.6167565584,
0.5741127729,
0.7251167297,
0.0458443761,
-0.1143778935,
-0.3354477286,
-0.445651114,
-0.4723541141,
0.5367336273,
-0.5101271868,
-0.4658938646,
0.0616406463,
-0.1704057753,
-0.2317907512,
-0.579567194,
0.6464636326,
-0.3789284229,
0.0428274609,
-0.1844103783,
-0.5596863627,
-0.087188147,
0.0047372263,
-0.9156875014,
0.7966881394,
-0.2090520412,
-0.5423716903,
0.6238015294,
-0.3566588163,
-0.7379238605,
-0.0323555991,
-0.0333535857,
-0.7277718186,
0.5452501178,
0.1673065126,
0.914686203,
-0.3695785403,
-0.078279458,
-0.4530668855,
-0.5169153214,
0.2484567612,
-0.8710497618,
0.8419958949,
-0.0419201776,
-0.0784603804,
-0.1328721642,
-1.3421748877,
-0.0925280973,
0.0057153921,
-0.7755662203,
-0.2724229097,
-0.213467747,
0.3402541578,
-0.0263820104,
0.1677800715,
-0.8800053596,
0.1923193783,
-0.3033169508,
0.4809280634,
0.3210068047,
-0.3432385623,
0.6383745074,
-0.0551949106,
0.3557647467,
-0.3297146857,
-0.1207734644,
-0.1915902346,
-0.4411182702,
-0.8330253959,
-0.3213541508,
0.6126658916,
0.3555497825,
-0.4155061245,
0.2470744252,
-0.2424971014,
-0.5088748932,
-0.4125410914,
0.0349138379,
0.674649775,
0.2963647842,
0.0929143876,
-0.443004936,
-0.409306109,
-0.7789651752,
-0.3235411346,
-0.2871639431,
-0.0422037132,
0.4642165899,
0.255204767,
0.1950433999,
0.543795228,
-0.1834513396,
-0.2221989036,
-0.3246410787,
0.4692588449,
0.2775215209,
0.1894685477,
0.4599119723,
-0.6077496409,
-0.6877730489,
0.1202544719,
-0.7696796656,
-0.1429900527,
-0.0497094765,
0.3690308928,
0.5512439013,
0.7664300203,
-0.2502452731,
0.7341697216,
0.3719201684,
-0.2183429748,
0.3871126175,
-0.4509594738,
-0.1519244462,
-0.7147129774,
0.3586567342,
0.212890029,
-0.0165505335,
-0.8843233585,
-0.0813825876,
0.5256527066,
-0.0312056467,
-0.1945589185,
0.5844463706,
-0.981772542,
-0.4182976782,
-0.5755878091,
-0.3446978927,
0.0310901497,
0.4084881246,
0.3018225729,
0.8296230435,
0.3929162025,
-0.454590708,
0.01992267,
-0.0091636246,
-0.5194385648,
0.4833500981,
-0.494430095,
0.3313518465,
-0.1866306365,
0.1863734275,
-1.1392389536,
-0.1167437956,
0.1507845819,
-0.4904831648,
0.780854404,
-0.110731706,
-0.4768191576,
-0.3887488544,
-0.1280359924,
0.2509159148,
0.3652467132,
-0.5783672333,
1.1550953388,
0.2524454594,
0.2203755528,
-0.4133855104,
-0.6487095356,
0.3954328895,
-0.0487300195,
-0.4569015205,
0.3850932419,
0.4102881253,
-0.1875572056,
-0.2826155722,
-0.1305546314,
-0.187529251,
0.2824566364,
0.3391475677,
0.3133916259,
-0.303953141,
-0.1983409971,
-0.3480068147,
-0.3559054434,
0.055107832,
-0.2824920118,
0.3198617697,
-0.0128196701,
0.0090089422,
-0.9116100073,
0.1520883292,
0.8819690943,
-0.4287125766,
0.5626698732,
0.2971262932,
-0.3066214323,
-0.1091313884,
-0.394344151,
0.1150010899,
-0.4135534167,
0.1797096431,
-0.5420057774,
-0.4611775875,
0.45050928,
0.1331820488,
0.0689885989,
0.3828459978,
0.3002367318,
-0.18977727,
0.36786744,
0.5029695034,
-0.3392293751,
0.6646780968,
-0.2173113227,
0.3667526841,
-0.9199593663,
-0.0207416993,
-0.5278971195,
-0.4273714125,
-0.3400242329,
-0.1830787659,
0.0674222112,
-0.3452012241,
0.2070363313,
0.4315018654,
-0.1698428988,
0.6472387314,
0.6148758531,
0.0932669565,
0.1144934893,
-0.1051289588,
-0.1829626858,
0.320260942,
-0.4856767356,
-0.7822903991,
1.6499325037,
0.4763661325,
0.5984463692,
-0.177424714,
0.8448937535,
-0.0281723533,
0.3416753411,
-0.7475344539,
0.652972281,
-0.9308533072,
-0.3068271577,
-0.209862873,
-0.1590932012,
-0.8382496238,
0.242724359,
-0.2365839481,
-0.3342892826,
0.6046631336,
-0.0592101589,
-0.7187516093,
0.4723560214,
-0.5711145401,
0.5276979804,
-0.2774215937,
-0.3157815337,
0.4141855538,
-0.4943217337,
0.1510224342,
0.2020534575,
-0.1394027919,
0.1093357801,
-0.0524623282,
0.602009654,
-0.325561285,
1.1028561592,
-0.1679323167,
-0.4637902081,
0.301168561,
-0.0814900771,
0.5021606684,
-0.4089311361,
-0.292173326,
0.3429551125,
-0.4187827706,
0.0364230163,
-0.489167124,
0.5282382369,
-0.6666266322,
-0.0849007294,
-0.2571535408,
-0.3808117807,
0.117192328,
0.2555973232,
0.2476820648,
0.9921072721,
-0.209890604,
0.1828979701,
0.5016623735,
-0.0186236762,
0.8171921372,
0.2396262288,
0.0742703155,
-0.540658772,
0.8060759902,
0.5487674475,
0.2531866431,
0.2937162817,
0.0509718508,
-0.237258628,
-0.9852406979,
-0.6704891324,
0.0437929444,
-0.7269884944,
0.1621914953,
-0.8778290749,
-0.2041501701,
-0.2751021683,
-0.1091906205,
0.0547069684,
-0.4223389924,
-0.7330607772,
-0.055153504,
-0.043002151,
0.8057003021,
0.1824201792,
0.4185146689,
-0.6468904614,
0.2866867483,
0.1799147725,
0.4599627852,
0.3538309038,
-0.2220094204,
-0.0610806085,
-0.3643610775,
0.095373489,
-0.8251922131,
0.0801124945,
0.1962738931,
0.5427704453,
0.3858091831,
-0.4127911031,
0.2999784946,
-0.4819826782,
0.304600358,
-0.0290937107,
-0.7388989329,
-0.2037758082,
-0.6793596745,
0.1584665477,
0.6910087466,
0.0467575006,
-0.3680099547,
-0.0642812923,
-0.4031170011,
-0.6307811141,
0.5974671841,
0.122125417,
0.1688142866,
0.1918427944,
0.5497226119,
0.1567195803,
0.1321066767,
-0.6665565968,
0.014102377,
0.1136711985,
-0.6418012381,
-0.0693227574,
-0.3942521811,
0.5954214931,
-0.2317775041,
0.4130007923,
-0.045135811,
0.2152250558,
0.0196840372,
-0.0911777094,
0.1897078902,
-0.1154227257,
0.4895329773,
0.1669983417,
-0.1018042117,
-0.0886922032,
-0.0802057832,
-0.7743071914,
0.2924121022,
0.1363830864,
-0.3502475619,
-0.0388485044,
0.7765504122,
0.9549933672,
0.278025806,
-0.1376854926,
0.4207957387,
-0.0695919096,
-0.6460452676,
-0.2996626794,
0.1651370227,
-0.0154445143,
0.2068641931,
0.0815187171,
-0.0156812388,
0.2910284996,
-0.5011305213,
0.0661357343,
0.6431720257,
-0.008471841,
-0.1257824451,
0.4747037292,
0.2244199663,
-0.6358819604,
0.6388814449,
0.1333278567,
-0.4838045537,
0.9275605083,
0.4358483851,
1.1530108452,
-0.089530088,
0.1389399618,
0.3417437673,
0.1315457672,
-0.0935039893,
0.2709393501,
-0.2891713679,
-0.5853103399,
0.0625170246,
-0.6290622354,
-0.3765842319,
-0.029575659,
-0.4494255185,
0.255939275,
-0.9620984197,
-0.2852323353,
0.3046597242,
0.0873905644,
-0.4772690237,
0.4423657656,
0.4961017072,
0.649217248,
-0.8594464064,
0.8010631204,
0.3583184779,
-0.3864752948,
-0.5692821741,
0.2691645622,
0.0631528273,
-0.5941969156,
0.6286809444,
0.500251472,
-0.2658635378,
0.0638640374,
-0.0332572944,
-0.9910848141,
0.9233297706,
-0.0308335684,
-0.6316432357,
-0.1865509897,
0.2153736204,
0.8306999803,
-0.2767660916,
0.3995037973,
0.5975921154,
0.4122613668,
0.1072449759,
-0.8727568984,
-0.2196548581,
-0.4955573976,
0.0595675223,
0.635591507,
-0.4060933292,
1.144788146,
0.0521305129,
-0.4017104506,
0.532125175,
0.6628101468,
-0.1742779166,
0.3235827386,
0.2574285567,
0.7618023157,
0.8575516939,
-0.0241474845,
1.1813951731,
0.0207695588,
-0.3698079586,
0.8594093323,
-0.4526131153,
0.9474929571,
0.2536675632,
-0.2322082222,
0.5663099289,
0.2103656381,
-0.1599274278,
0.238766849,
0.5255836844,
-0.2908822894,
-0.0286428519,
0.2646862864,
0.0471342057,
0.5317510962,
0.0026487662,
-0.7462588549,
-0.3082741201,
0.100095585,
0.211457327,
0.2025393397,
-0.4220521152,
0.9545506239,
-0.056775596,
-0.5448777676,
0.3479438722,
0.3120462596,
0.9112533927,
-0.318973124,
0.0864326581,
-0.2779824436,
0.524110496,
-0.2004823089,
-0.3452439904,
0.2498476356,
0.0755798072,
-0.2354758978,
-0.2608349621,
0.9980604053,
-0.3627420068,
-1.0497255325,
0.2376846969,
0.0487165265,
0.1015186533,
0.028722845,
-0.2044526339,
-0.1066732109,
-0.3699380755,
-0.0187494271,
0.3301066458,
0.2934233248,
-0.073454909,
0.1520811468,
0.9082631469,
-0.0175116025,
0.3607375026,
-0.0349238254,
0.6158630252,
-0.3470609188,
-0.5269728899,
-0.993942678,
0.3566671014,
-0.1644733101,
-0.4152987003,
0.7873032093,
0.417114079,
0.4846579432,
0.0634408891,
0.7917423248,
0.3177836537,
0.425214678,
-0.768304944,
1.0443278551,
-0.5391971469,
-0.0971550569,
-0.4982590675,
-0.7991743684,
-0.7100622654,
0.7609269023,
-0.5271770358,
0.2533255816,
0.4814407527,
0.5014302135,
-0.0518288687,
0.2640228868,
0.1678203791,
-0.2968161702,
0.3447743356,
0.6850307584,
0.5496785641,
-0.7167354226,
0.1401196122,
0.0320279486,
-0.1467134804,
-0.1965192109,
-0.9527806044,
-1.135776639,
-0.4881365299,
-0.1824226826,
-0.1057233661,
-0.1048580781,
0.4901092052,
0.3550966084,
-0.4576722682,
-0.3318828344,
-0.3582800329,
-0.3716134131,
0.0384662859,
-0.0179114472,
0.5187575817,
-0.0569179244,
-0.7865411043,
0.4364100695,
0.1911595613,
0.4568176568,
-0.1359977126,
0.0289995689,
-0.0630769357,
0.175720945,
0.2362958938,
0.3530703783,
-0.6424960494,
0.406688869,
0.1882441342,
-0.2804561555,
0.0850050449,
1.0631000996,
-0.6260174513,
0.2287656814,
0.6195837855,
0.9539556503,
0.312864095,
-0.1507894695,
0.5757609606,
-0.2793958485,
-0.0136273503,
0.1287557781,
0.4634511471,
0.4138340652,
-0.3620716631,
0.2859833241,
0.14107728,
-0.2085251212,
-0.8344712257,
0.0400337279,
-0.341286391,
-0.2005853057,
1.0096136332,
-0.3180696964,
-0.3297255933,
-0.1565136015,
-0.2531836033,
0.1981326342,
-0.0451323651,
0.427852422,
1.0086940527,
0.2063928694,
-0.3250101507,
-0.3055238724,
0.4831452072,
0.3876270652,
-0.7058402896,
0.3543849885,
0.7228273749,
0.0403316729,
0.1121409535,
0.9214426279,
-0.1978883892,
0.2002082914,
0.0874302238,
0.0590003245,
-0.6055923104,
-0.9122712016,
-0.7515580058,
0.3484207392,
-0.0974542871,
-0.2990995944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19316v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19316v1
|
QLSC: A Query Latent Semantic Calibrator for Robust Extractive Question Answering
| 2024-04-30T07:34:42 | 2024-04-30T07:34:42 |
Sheng Ouyang, Jianzong Wang, Yong Zhang, Zhitao Li, Ziqi Liang, Xulong Zhang, Ning Cheng, Jing Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extractive Question Answering (EQA) in Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC)
often faces the challenge of dealing with semantically identical but
format-variant inputs. Our work introduces a novel approach, called the ``Query
Latent Semantic Calibrator (QLSC)'', designed as an auxiliary module for
existing MRC models. We propose a unique scaling strategy to capture latent
semantic center features of queries. These features are then seamlessly
integrated into traditional query and passage embeddings using an attention
mechanism. By deepening the comprehension of the semantic queries-passage
relationship, our approach diminishes sensitivity to variations in text format
and boosts the model's capability in pinpointing accurate answers. Experimental
results on robust Question-Answer datasets confirm that our approach
effectively handles format-variant but semantically identical queries,
highlighting the effectiveness and adaptability of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.1590867788,
-0.6796228886,
0.523205936,
-0.2102689594,
-0.3344351649,
-0.0381034985,
0.173563242,
-0.0883004665,
0.1462073475,
0.6731554866,
-0.8941760659,
-0.3824810386,
-0.4903665185,
0.0892095491,
-0.1576219946,
0.9320124388,
0.0859474167,
0.0154512748,
-0.5026730299,
-0.494897157,
-0.2359559089,
-0.3023641706,
-0.4864933193,
0.1326359361,
0.7562714815,
0.3117878437,
0.8283782005,
0.4171779454,
0.6070647836,
0.1812693775,
-0.1752935201,
0.4621250629,
-0.3482449055,
0.4310586751,
-0.1697523594,
-0.8689911962,
-0.4871525168,
-0.017517766,
0.7691012025,
0.6717835665,
-0.2539175153,
0.2152075917,
0.0689533129,
0.7057794333,
-0.847904563,
-0.1721813977,
-0.7744432688,
0.0449547358,
0.2854142785,
-0.4768078327,
-0.6189889312,
-0.2904694676,
0.1031873301,
-0.6935824752,
0.1599354744,
0.0358038731,
0.6748763919,
0.7844327092,
-0.6053160429,
-0.2842349708,
-0.4248175621,
0.9621329904,
-0.6250921488,
0.4740541279,
0.6945516467,
0.6817141175,
0.2446762323,
-0.9454009533,
-0.4596155286,
-0.027876541,
-0.1928317249,
0.3391527832,
0.1721445769,
-0.2736335695,
0.2245962024,
0.2467202991,
-0.9566556215,
-0.3307377398,
-0.1989114285,
-0.2953563929,
0.2091064304,
0.4571709037,
0.2562718093,
-0.0427412018,
-0.1369061321,
-0.1674473286,
-0.6179921627,
0.2056289613,
0.1404044181,
0.3370422423,
0.1933303028,
0.6570929885,
-0.3188852966,
0.9461446404,
0.0363829024,
0.1198384538,
-0.0631827936,
-0.4933640063,
-0.0270462316,
-0.1265604794,
0.3054611385,
0.1699206084,
-0.0898123607,
-0.2288435847,
-0.3106060028,
-0.4267766178,
0.5870665312,
-0.9429558516,
-0.413490802,
0.3003081679,
-0.2947683632,
-0.2776747346,
0.2191714644,
-0.5466117263,
0.0525851957,
-0.1805913299,
0.5098747611,
-0.0845065936,
0.139781341,
-0.1073506922,
-0.0211980566,
0.7730116844,
0.3588931561,
-0.7733181119,
0.2525587082,
0.540897429,
0.5915363431,
-0.1325668544,
0.1912840307,
-1.0186371803,
0.1099998355,
-0.2916113436,
0.8795263767,
-0.6285898089,
-0.1815231144,
-0.162371695,
0.3282519579,
-0.1188542023,
-0.3421744108,
0.5837432146,
-1.3721722364,
0.5455265045,
-0.1840812564,
-0.4067870975,
0.1518113762,
0.6712848544,
-0.838078618,
1.0990381241,
0.2995885611,
-1.0205430984,
0.0463546924,
-0.2112766206,
-0.1262740493,
0.0402356498,
-0.0304064192,
-0.4393305779,
-0.255371958,
0.5548323989,
-0.0433593579,
-0.1626782417,
-0.2796218991,
-0.1366449744,
-0.2242472321,
0.6467763782,
-0.4594079852,
0.7289046049,
0.3424123228,
0.0184466112,
0.25956586,
-0.6864153147,
0.7008123398,
0.0666319728,
-0.2261746228,
-0.2686299384,
0.0317062214,
-0.2213679999,
0.1081933901,
0.4283494651,
-0.4666292369,
-0.2483812422,
-0.5863338113,
0.5122163892,
0.3848143518,
0.1841659397,
0.6398468614,
-0.3289332688,
0.6373842359,
-0.1192833632,
0.1144881025,
-0.3245551586,
-0.2345362753,
-0.4794204533,
-0.2390063703,
0.3354031146,
0.6201338768,
-0.8059018254,
0.4324021637,
-0.0547636598,
-0.5319386721,
-0.6445736289,
-0.1632699817,
0.2365724146,
0.7207514048,
0.5021348,
-0.0246432126,
-0.0184186306,
-0.649818182,
-0.4964565635,
-0.1183142811,
-0.2807787359,
0.4892395437,
0.0866792277,
0.3851441443,
1.086864233,
-0.7390581369,
-0.0311617535,
-0.0322700813,
-0.1659400016,
-0.0219918638,
0.4094115198,
0.3020204306,
-1.2506566048,
-0.4820508063,
-0.2328645289,
-0.4946684241,
-0.1218106002,
0.0190375596,
-0.5315365195,
0.006446925,
0.7917474508,
-0.2510657907,
0.3471176028,
0.3613696396,
-0.4984937608,
0.4102708399,
-0.1710866243,
0.2701753676,
-1.074647069,
0.2301533967,
-0.4422391951,
-0.390168488,
-0.4171029627,
0.4365386963,
0.6130663157,
0.0167679768,
-0.5538521409,
0.3427840173,
-0.2391450703,
-0.0657811761,
-0.0341950469,
0.5651381612,
0.7337921858,
0.2553864717,
-0.2735575438,
0.8612970114,
0.0138855996,
-0.4490374923,
0.3144975603,
0.291426748,
0.1127344221,
0.6270151138,
-0.923202455,
0.504126668,
-0.1338232309,
0.2849128842,
-1.3790466785,
0.0243682954,
0.0739092082,
-0.7745850086,
0.2406910211,
-0.1313462406,
-0.3735078275,
-0.1789456308,
-0.3432362378,
0.463976413,
0.2326993495,
-0.4550470114,
0.8524683118,
0.0381986238,
-0.2426232249,
-0.5896803737,
-0.9581810832,
-0.3423779309,
-0.0177127402,
-0.6471973658,
0.2179128379,
-0.2577497959,
0.2060593963,
-0.0181790274,
-0.2702482343,
-0.3348416388,
0.1694813371,
-0.1316972822,
0.4087933898,
-0.6041327119,
0.1572921574,
0.4696907103,
-0.0500590391,
0.0004760119,
-0.4294073582,
0.386287123,
-0.0083975783,
-0.3527354896,
-0.3853812218,
0.5604878068,
0.5471116304,
-0.909055531,
0.8742223978,
0.4465309381,
-0.2626109421,
0.0157848299,
-0.2356726229,
-0.5050096512,
-0.448577404,
0.4959981143,
-0.7206820846,
-0.9756314158,
0.5673031807,
0.3138029873,
0.1294763833,
0.5209906697,
0.4178555906,
-0.1270290613,
1.1684303284,
0.4213599861,
0.6418268085,
0.3210392892,
0.1169628277,
0.1451644599,
-1.0265843868,
-0.3146862984,
-0.8377325535,
-0.0690588653,
-0.336722672,
-0.5691877007,
0.251301676,
0.1320694983,
-0.2352482378,
0.1001018211,
-0.5775833726,
0.4069326818,
0.1026604325,
0.2196071446,
0.423258096,
-0.0445954576,
-0.2286527753,
-0.4222830534,
-0.4343999326,
-0.680188477,
1.1375533342,
0.1471094489,
0.7507587671,
0.5067173243,
0.4692722857,
0.078137137,
0.1096991003,
-0.7155175209,
0.1774926037,
-0.1105892509,
-0.6694352031,
-0.5880708694,
-0.5156331658,
-0.6878461838,
0.538223505,
-0.073274605,
-0.5916348696,
0.0797988474,
-0.1190042943,
-0.5747628212,
0.0674880743,
-0.7490673065,
1.094466567,
-0.0184931327,
-0.5108988881,
0.0219523497,
-0.8912613988,
-0.2406803668,
-0.1358501911,
-0.1215350404,
0.0364934504,
-0.5192394853,
0.5947563052,
-0.2022873908,
0.5718790889,
-0.086128071,
0.047562886,
0.5012872815,
0.2653667629,
0.5542362332,
0.1579493433,
-0.3010347486,
-0.6977205873,
0.6796486974,
-0.8298052549,
-1.0540467501,
0.4684012234,
-0.7783201933,
-0.5124690533,
-0.1657107025,
-0.6323436499,
-0.4790179431,
0.1375192106,
-0.1002366543,
0.475058347,
-0.3363184929,
0.328569144,
0.745508194,
0.0363535322,
0.1483359635,
0.644769907,
0.0851375088,
-0.4455631077,
0.6346178651,
-0.0615522414,
0.6374891996,
0.6791067719,
0.1370498389,
-0.6456369758,
-0.3139591515,
-0.5863114595,
0.1634860039,
-0.8377406001,
-0.2194505185,
-0.990660131,
-0.2914263904,
-0.6150158048,
0.091916427,
-0.1511289328,
-0.5163556933,
-0.4853540063,
0.0623618141,
0.2125646323,
0.2497467846,
0.3508947492,
0.4034717083,
-0.915589571,
0.1552093327,
0.5690252185,
-0.0406160578,
-0.2064595222,
-1.0818101168,
-0.0893806145,
-0.0610874593,
-0.3467918336,
-0.857984364,
0.3921827972,
0.3389252126,
0.5110598803,
0.150968492,
0.5855044723,
0.3507162035,
-0.1466586143,
0.8805986643,
-0.1013882011,
-0.4688960612,
0.6252945065,
-0.0134043787,
0.6385172009,
0.8826562166,
0.4512908757,
-0.4020574987,
-0.2990298569,
-0.3928309381,
-0.6957227588,
0.4965516329,
0.0074918764,
0.1725950539,
0.2310000807,
0.5764003396,
0.078656733,
-0.0119308867,
-0.2605175376,
-0.0204626191,
-0.2540604174,
-0.5607351065,
0.0971008986,
-0.2736041844,
-0.1559803486,
0.1056720838,
0.3871307969,
-0.5915521979,
-0.0477177016,
0.6265574098,
-0.2967331409,
0.0717123672,
0.3084847629,
0.2116512209,
0.4948423803,
-0.302036792,
0.370578438,
0.0468489043,
-0.7384521961,
-0.2089305818,
0.2410234213,
-0.2790493965,
-0.3823579848,
0.2380657345,
0.3233845532,
-0.0440858342,
-0.6950103045,
0.4704736471,
-0.5146262646,
-0.0526580997,
-0.0316723622,
-0.0231401529,
0.1291315258,
0.2508643568,
0.4222724438,
-0.1807524711,
0.2069340348,
-0.2744133472,
0.5393106937,
0.190496996,
-0.9249868989,
-0.0071341246,
0.5579300523,
0.0351082347,
-0.153273657,
0.7773752809,
-0.1868976057,
-0.5910173059,
0.7383239865,
0.4666619897,
0.5008419156,
-0.1772675514,
0.1791316718,
0.4330335557,
0.350935638,
0.5264785886,
0.3692882359,
-0.4776902795,
-0.5462254882,
-0.386166364,
-0.5915501714,
-0.3853463531,
-0.5351892114,
-0.9604139328,
-0.0389703251,
-0.3154109418,
0.057027299,
-0.0871519223,
0.2527951598,
-0.4098505676,
0.3428983986,
-0.1696515679,
0.7986270189,
-0.6163991094,
0.853397429,
0.7800273895,
-0.5161613226,
-1.0910747051,
0.1671113819,
-0.1940657943,
-0.4797201753,
0.2786284089,
0.0565416515,
-0.1497655958,
0.2718446553,
-0.4434011579,
-0.9064942002,
1.1501642466,
0.0351836607,
-0.2135391533,
0.0350215435,
0.1628695428,
0.4558978379,
-0.6303324103,
0.6085939407,
0.6540552974,
0.2621258199,
0.553260982,
-0.4919261038,
0.2010616809,
-0.0712061301,
-0.22723867,
-0.01875728,
-0.3814315796,
0.6607705355,
-0.3410746753,
-0.1228405684,
0.3288573623,
0.8277317286,
0.2492576092,
0.3223655522,
0.4989931881,
0.3752508759,
0.9179714322,
-0.0456537977,
0.9047930837,
-0.1899613142,
0.3638164103,
1.4024285078,
-0.1713437587,
1.1575000286,
0.6838678718,
-0.2641820908,
0.4494004548,
0.8240618706,
0.3132363558,
0.6793618202,
0.1301719397,
-0.1913938373,
-0.4836524427,
-0.0631796792,
-0.1526387781,
0.2517736852,
0.4649158716,
-0.1925252527,
-0.1618506759,
-0.369279325,
-0.3056572974,
0.3028510809,
-0.0861921012,
0.8213809729,
0.0178819019,
-0.7155545354,
0.440331161,
-0.0996267721,
0.1746371388,
-0.5302727222,
0.0500257649,
-0.3838412464,
0.1598715335,
-0.3429032862,
-0.8949220777,
0.6250574589,
-0.2062842399,
-0.300870657,
0.2743093371,
0.4938353002,
-0.4747535586,
-0.2886034846,
-0.0221694671,
0.6805441976,
0.2123400718,
-0.4062500596,
-0.7492346764,
-0.1521222591,
0.1510571092,
-0.1544114947,
0.2441694885,
0.7372791171,
0.0419283137,
0.3460159898,
0.5730303526,
-0.2965620458,
0.3666839004,
0.215909481,
0.97138834,
-0.6779500842,
-0.6467458606,
-0.2663381994,
0.5238726735,
-0.1442192346,
-0.3358938694,
0.3024570644,
0.4456402063,
0.3028295636,
0.258933723,
0.1516052037,
0.1538107097,
0.5546441674,
-0.3953674138,
0.8367417455,
-0.8517624736,
0.1675866693,
0.1868405193,
-1.0707322359,
-0.3863714933,
0.4551226199,
-0.3211500943,
-0.0296605304,
0.9784706831,
1.1251547337,
0.1401126385,
0.143363446,
0.4975287318,
-0.0396847576,
0.3788742125,
0.4761847854,
0.7605542541,
-0.6468600631,
1.0314769745,
0.0944890827,
-0.3416064978,
-0.0840564817,
-0.4993905425,
-0.7213568091,
-0.5585857034,
-0.3262302876,
-0.5714232922,
0.0357971862,
0.3329464793,
0.5647336245,
-0.7891094685,
0.39364779,
0.2612572908,
0.1414011121,
-0.016478803,
-0.2776458561,
0.6259481311,
-0.4950557947,
-0.6197028756,
0.0612216182,
0.2032935619,
-0.1110435352,
-0.4096709192,
0.0199494679,
-0.2048056871,
0.1952237189,
0.4588892758,
0.0606825612,
-0.5891640782,
-0.1783332527,
0.5476531386,
-0.5980548263,
0.0615427196,
0.7637729049,
-0.7675284147,
0.6396353841,
0.6222288013,
0.963385582,
0.5642797947,
0.0835110545,
0.1991791278,
-0.6500171423,
0.0909402221,
0.609320581,
-0.1805515885,
0.374240458,
-0.358186096,
0.2729783356,
0.0111456197,
-0.5349698067,
-0.5383730531,
0.2864245772,
-1.2114634514,
-0.246912241,
0.8013619184,
-0.3787309825,
-0.6340911984,
-0.1304446161,
-0.252476275,
0.1511668116,
-0.2988841832,
0.3162141144,
0.4942616224,
0.1476458311,
-0.3701106012,
-0.5580928922,
0.0953253508,
0.771392405,
-0.5800509453,
0.0647692382,
0.2718416452,
0.1458700746,
0.0323444493,
0.3012119532,
-0.6357728243,
0.2634442151,
0.1347010285,
-0.3129947186,
0.1945891827,
-0.0270078853,
-0.3209403455,
0.3734416664,
0.2002552003,
-0.1691324562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19315v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19315v1
|
Modeling Orthographic Variation in Occitan's Dialects
| 2024-04-30T07:33:51 | 2024-04-30T07:33:51 |
Zachary William Hopton, Noëmi Aepli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Effectively normalizing textual data poses a considerable challenge,
especially for low-resource languages lacking standardized writing systems. In
this study, we fine-tuned a multilingual model with data from several Occitan
dialects and conducted a series of experiments to assess the model's
representations of these dialects. For evaluation purposes, we compiled a
parallel lexicon encompassing four Occitan dialects. Intrinsic evaluations of
the model's embeddings revealed that surface similarity between the dialects
strengthened representations. When the model was further fine-tuned for
part-of-speech tagging and Universal Dependency parsing, its performance was
robust to dialectical variation, even when trained solely on part-of-speech
data from a single dialect. Our findings suggest that large multilingual models
minimize the need for spelling normalization during pre-processing.
|
[
-0.3264982998,
-0.4330156446,
0.407630384,
-0.131954819,
-0.1538370699,
-0.3966822028,
-0.62625283,
-0.7019887567,
0.3525790274,
0.5754268169,
-0.2263240516,
-0.7249821424,
-0.3522172868,
0.1579883695,
0.2212087661,
0.723931253,
0.0197807867,
0.281273514,
0.4669307768,
-0.5189087391,
-0.2866356373,
-0.6771397591,
-0.2811843753,
-0.2799606323,
0.7111624479,
0.7106950283,
0.7246225476,
0.9481109977,
0.3305219412,
0.2923600078,
-0.3291881382,
0.1819560379,
-0.540027678,
0.2991532087,
-0.2931776643,
-0.7579719424,
-0.4691804349,
-0.1546285152,
0.6834397912,
1.102314353,
-0.3483049572,
0.0029899357,
-0.112486653,
0.3526730537,
-0.6820114255,
0.1672129035,
-0.4612785578,
-0.2106491476,
-0.5932403803,
0.3243836164,
-0.1610001028,
-0.2409477681,
0.0524307489,
-0.5029963851,
0.3345540166,
-0.0578997545,
0.828789413,
-0.2872397304,
-0.4004175961,
-0.0942981988,
-0.6657449007,
0.7359039783,
-0.9000545144,
0.4535444081,
0.3838229477,
0.2596143782,
0.0928924605,
-0.3934324384,
-0.3134326339,
-0.5384817123,
-0.1453683376,
-0.0019509575,
0.3660930097,
0.2105746567,
0.2332651913,
0.3872145712,
-0.4245370328,
0.2806076705,
-0.3002435565,
0.2100012749,
0.4649814963,
0.2548568845,
0.2864335775,
-0.4206916988,
0.0895687789,
-0.1685608923,
-0.5987114906,
0.0984661803,
0.8117061853,
0.9342651963,
-0.0208958741,
0.8100173473,
-0.4141128361,
0.744925499,
-0.1464522183,
-0.2360189408,
0.0580048785,
-0.3579746485,
-0.3582194746,
-0.2458177209,
0.6520326138,
0.0059413621,
0.2270890772,
0.0753531456,
-0.203519538,
0.0224814173,
0.001784139,
-0.6589992046,
-0.3751242161,
-0.2478478849,
-0.2307416797,
0.0447567105,
0.370100826,
-0.7571551204,
-0.6801003218,
-0.3336144388,
-0.0194669925,
-0.7837593555,
-0.3330973387,
0.4734588563,
-0.1758052707,
-0.2087022066,
0.2593612969,
-1.1469355822,
0.35488832,
0.4430333376,
0.7776861191,
0.0038770917,
-0.4507776797,
-0.1497426331,
0.0089234896,
-0.3772116005,
0.6787533164,
-0.7232503891,
-0.3887627125,
0.042689696,
-0.0161498748,
-0.3583211005,
-0.5683428645,
0.4220730364,
-0.0780620053,
-0.0785496309,
-0.2753692269,
-0.3805784881,
-0.2515973747,
0.0828505233,
-0.9684696794,
0.8382370472,
0.1745751649,
-0.6918642521,
0.3918052316,
-0.3306539655,
-0.4087046981,
-0.279589504,
-0.3216060102,
-0.2423035204,
0.6238510609,
0.2148694843,
0.2994166911,
-0.3442704082,
0.0452414826,
-0.3963849843,
-0.0949828401,
0.0664522573,
-0.2484484017,
0.8886902332,
-0.0491443165,
-0.2269175351,
-0.1330929101,
-0.8782094121,
-0.1815543026,
-0.0701071694,
-0.3486031294,
-0.6028752327,
0.0185272936,
0.3617176116,
-0.2546139061,
-0.0138420323,
-0.8336147666,
0.4602774978,
-0.6728138924,
0.617762804,
0.3226938844,
-0.3558740318,
0.4227519929,
-0.5919247866,
0.5123046041,
0.0262180064,
-0.1149751469,
-0.279461354,
-0.3825726509,
-1.0376497507,
-0.5455031991,
0.5136621594,
0.2574725449,
-0.3018033504,
0.1134165153,
-0.4499470294,
-0.6796745062,
-0.4707711637,
-0.0724543929,
0.2501551509,
0.1332738698,
0.2325918674,
-0.5595206022,
-0.303273946,
-0.7592136264,
-0.303650409,
-0.0521468483,
0.0580725186,
0.1500485092,
0.0997396633,
0.0512833148,
0.7963891029,
-0.3421969116,
-0.3839946687,
-0.3522870541,
0.4086943865,
0.2677603066,
0.4603562355,
0.8384518027,
-0.5232529044,
-0.7042118311,
0.5132246614,
-0.1924310178,
-0.0383384824,
0.1285892278,
0.0983825102,
0.267604351,
0.5641806722,
-0.4473616481,
0.7202736735,
0.3489412367,
-0.108062394,
0.6297898889,
-0.3682654798,
0.1975355148,
-0.8559991121,
0.1776669174,
-0.2784109712,
-0.2467033267,
-0.8457760215,
0.4048830867,
0.2233441621,
-0.2778466642,
-0.2328982055,
0.3002019227,
-0.5399600267,
0.3415605426,
0.1677881777,
-0.0963275135,
0.1259292215,
0.3106902838,
0.2361550033,
0.4819707572,
0.4556785226,
-0.1819662005,
0.3484579623,
-0.2060428858,
-0.5053698421,
0.7435046434,
-0.6421889663,
-0.0091690691,
-0.3730184734,
-0.1884150654,
-1.2243970633,
-0.732293427,
-0.1130994409,
-0.1338602155,
0.2441247702,
-0.2565005422,
-0.5944005251,
0.1715780199,
-0.2653540075,
0.6677153111,
0.0287431218,
-0.3599169254,
0.6804323792,
0.1450576335,
-0.4576096535,
0.015375169,
-0.7083288431,
-0.2866529822,
-0.3609870374,
-0.547066927,
0.3778497577,
0.3010932207,
-0.2338939011,
-0.2252161801,
0.1430106163,
-0.3581300676,
-0.2007318586,
0.2700975537,
-0.0249247793,
-0.44866997,
0.362041533,
-0.041753877,
0.2723053694,
-0.4417639375,
-0.3913195729,
0.664822042,
0.063443765,
-0.4841759503,
-0.3681156337,
0.6161355376,
0.5671142936,
-0.3128821254,
0.6759101748,
0.1634438485,
-0.3201662004,
-0.0844618902,
-0.5581616759,
0.1392680705,
-0.3968183696,
0.4640962481,
-0.5653474927,
-0.6652120352,
0.6480434537,
0.2016260326,
-0.1255124658,
0.4605347812,
0.4126575887,
-0.0727987885,
0.7892855406,
0.8682345152,
-0.2658475041,
0.6036555767,
0.0471984223,
0.0339960568,
-0.3044822812,
-0.2517446876,
-0.9108291268,
-0.1443286985,
-0.8017812371,
-0.3685946763,
0.5142425895,
0.1916062981,
-0.1535331607,
0.4522571862,
-0.0215514563,
0.4562132657,
0.6648567915,
0.1912458241,
0.3993283212,
0.2360844463,
-0.3538413644,
-0.1251980811,
-0.7761722803,
-0.3518571258,
1.0266661644,
0.1050210595,
1.1526600122,
0.3091293871,
0.6833834052,
-0.3316701949,
0.0321618058,
-0.6241494417,
-0.0375982262,
-0.5829862356,
-0.5144933462,
-0.5449835062,
-0.3779864311,
-0.9295522571,
0.3189886808,
-0.0481697321,
-0.9180406332,
0.6071959734,
0.1189867184,
-0.6627433896,
0.2752326131,
-0.8108520508,
0.8141566515,
0.1135217473,
0.051202897,
-0.2595705092,
-0.5248915553,
-0.0020601274,
0.1167107597,
0.269569546,
-0.1346001327,
0.0679128096,
0.1945491135,
-0.5017861128,
1.1108916998,
0.3064138293,
-0.1123443395,
0.0763597339,
0.1220426261,
-0.0316206403,
0.2500889301,
-0.4607726932,
0.1563765407,
0.229570806,
-0.5664625764,
-0.434992075,
0.5534071922,
-0.8939327002,
-0.3769980669,
-0.2140358984,
-0.4277943969,
-0.2296807766,
0.2373880595,
0.5331051946,
0.6171070933,
-0.6394862533,
0.0412851311,
0.341573,
-0.0526201651,
0.2881575227,
0.2261658907,
-0.3227497637,
-0.3781972229,
0.6914925575,
0.4886327982,
0.4778213799,
0.2992553711,
0.2091213614,
-0.0716325641,
-0.1573925614,
-0.5607203841,
0.4708014727,
-0.5931951404,
-0.1149036735,
-0.3308384418,
-0.031077886,
-0.7738543153,
0.0782216638,
-0.4808188975,
-0.6501236558,
-0.3892737031,
0.0460148901,
0.1199621558,
1.1366783381,
-0.1099225059,
0.4614554644,
-0.5541461706,
0.2730593681,
0.37906003,
0.2698040605,
-0.1479473859,
-0.6454335451,
-0.3615795076,
0.2338232398,
-0.1736300737,
-0.9627817869,
0.218721047,
0.5804845691,
0.226382643,
0.4315603971,
-0.0879994035,
0.8602234125,
-0.4952098727,
0.6172116399,
0.1463201046,
-1.0999746323,
0.3806756735,
-0.6031355262,
0.4970038831,
0.5525513291,
0.3331128657,
-0.69447577,
-0.5047188997,
-0.4311462045,
-0.806024611,
0.7676196098,
-0.0406809114,
0.2041942924,
0.2055631578,
0.3435353935,
0.3788436055,
0.1731701195,
-0.7350527644,
0.1992460489,
-0.3130607903,
-0.0356818587,
-0.4136073589,
-0.3497298956,
0.0019085058,
-0.2748371065,
0.1229101568,
0.1745891422,
0.0144140078,
0.0995520204,
-0.2329880893,
0.1488908976,
0.2835644186,
0.6570951939,
0.5439753532,
-0.1173814908,
0.5036447048,
-0.013163982,
-0.437541604,
0.0755105913,
0.2752001882,
-0.0806834474,
0.3614906669,
0.6454032063,
0.8545426726,
-0.1375160962,
-0.5372192264,
0.2436356694,
0.1910540313,
0.0869082883,
0.1377301961,
0.0803946108,
0.0599996969,
0.1005275175,
-0.1441771686,
0.1826224178,
0.0893996656,
-0.7510439157,
-0.310282886,
-0.0065145688,
-0.3059011698,
-0.5389751792,
0.2858009934,
-0.2172252983,
-0.0890801176,
0.4209430218,
-0.0098550254,
-0.4091358185,
0.6905588508,
0.1976276189,
0.406109184,
-0.6710295081,
0.0948102549,
0.3880898356,
0.4133682251,
-0.1850940883,
0.4011600614,
0.2053317428,
-0.5530396104,
-0.0895369649,
-0.3523228467,
-0.2457337081,
-0.0853598863,
-1.0784410238,
0.5466401577,
-0.4377827048,
-0.4672109783,
0.2228509188,
-0.4526465535,
-0.83806777,
0.2653300166,
-0.0214340128,
0.6901879311,
-0.8602318764,
1.0376433134,
0.8596677184,
-0.2799762189,
-0.8985711932,
0.054558184,
-0.1712070405,
-0.5241345763,
0.5269730091,
0.3018265665,
-0.2035180181,
-0.2590048909,
-0.1456201822,
-0.7982270718,
0.4358781874,
0.794719696,
-0.5486561656,
0.0466064103,
0.6530860066,
0.7104628682,
-0.300470084,
0.4362086654,
0.7480157018,
0.3227160871,
-0.303630352,
-1.201787591,
-0.2941741943,
-0.1187431589,
0.4781647623,
0.1091914922,
-0.5728953481,
1.445761323,
-0.0181318261,
-0.3308260441,
0.4281091988,
0.458634913,
-0.3883474767,
-0.4118579924,
0.26433146,
0.5117368698,
0.6836732626,
-0.0125401905,
0.9068595171,
-0.0576334931,
0.4028152227,
1.3721735477,
-0.1760800481,
0.9198530912,
0.4652492404,
0.0403747074,
0.4666241705,
0.5628730655,
0.3283011913,
0.4411626458,
0.3833038211,
-0.2453464121,
-0.2131353617,
-0.3758436739,
-0.4615623653,
0.8408947587,
0.3200084269,
-0.2778779864,
-0.3047327101,
0.0766203329,
0.1158559993,
0.354593426,
-0.2500759065,
0.6461734772,
-0.1906496286,
-0.5775921941,
0.9392316341,
0.4472527206,
0.4166318774,
-0.449695766,
0.1987942904,
-0.664580524,
0.1098275185,
-0.0854600221,
-0.1183431819,
0.2331398427,
-0.0910951197,
-0.1678151786,
-0.0312886424,
0.0907874554,
-0.8579067588,
-0.6233731508,
0.2951828837,
0.2475351542,
-0.1207133159,
-0.1116633564,
0.0503340997,
0.1395972669,
-0.1046462059,
-0.136403054,
0.0786815137,
0.794085443,
-0.0641928911,
0.1434723288,
0.0849066675,
0.4356872439,
0.3457379341,
0.255076915,
0.9351764321,
-0.5519928336,
-0.5319176912,
-0.8206024766,
0.3809231222,
0.0271786563,
-0.5952126384,
0.6990315914,
0.4779831767,
1.1178371906,
-0.2464971393,
0.7132472396,
-0.0253798179,
0.6327192783,
-0.6080960631,
0.6550065279,
-0.725538373,
-0.1380935311,
-0.0857396647,
-0.8734303713,
-0.5132220387,
0.7796822786,
-0.197962299,
-0.0731201321,
0.7423480153,
0.9572545886,
-0.4409488142,
0.0202247109,
0.4871839583,
0.193345651,
-0.0860310048,
0.4429004192,
0.7772763371,
-0.0525150336,
0.1779924631,
-0.3884630203,
-0.2930434048,
-0.181754753,
-0.787427187,
-1.1552692652,
-0.4581041634,
0.1696176231,
-0.1061593965,
0.2163628042,
0.8645812869,
0.8991833329,
-1.0213798285,
-0.9833052754,
0.0048472844,
-0.1474606991,
-0.1398597062,
-0.0653576925,
0.117074281,
-0.4159185886,
-0.8892560005,
0.2940944731,
0.2249977142,
0.0394385383,
-0.1934209168,
0.4504193068,
0.0278987642,
0.0722330511,
0.2116089314,
0.1334065646,
-0.7794421315,
-0.2963937521,
-0.01155187,
-0.4743775725,
0.2573679686,
1.1161240339,
-0.0995471776,
0.8595557213,
0.547108829,
0.2523319423,
0.5411285758,
-0.085819684,
0.7413621545,
-0.7923310995,
0.6843320727,
0.0775959045,
0.3749506474,
0.3590447009,
-0.1781912893,
0.2055193186,
0.2614968717,
-0.0725426227,
-0.43890962,
0.5456218123,
-0.5353147388,
-0.2275343388,
1.0343483686,
-0.6041840911,
0.1840101033,
-0.1914816201,
-0.3719902635,
0.1893367022,
-0.2610559165,
0.776198566,
0.8574225307,
0.0466655493,
0.1297212094,
-0.2866086662,
0.4362349212,
0.6141203046,
-0.6256474257,
0.0987449363,
0.5366021395,
0.2255189568,
0.294757098,
0.4417954683,
0.1687687635,
0.0319013298,
0.0708984733,
0.0600577295,
0.1112118736,
-0.5650342107,
-0.5059967637,
0.2802163363,
0.3503385484,
0.096159853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19310v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19310v2
|
Does Whisper understand Swiss German? An automatic, qualitative, and human evaluation
| 2024-04-30T07:29:40 | 2024-05-09T11:54:04 |
Eyal Liron Dolev, Clemens Fidel Lutz, Noëmi Aepli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Whisper is a state-of-the-art automatic speech recognition (ASR) model
(Radford et al., 2022). Although Swiss German dialects are allegedly not part
of Whisper's training data, preliminary experiments showed that Whisper can
transcribe Swiss German quite well, with the output being a speech translation
into Standard German. To gain a better understanding of Whisper's performance
on Swiss German, we systematically evaluate it using automatic, qualitative,
and human evaluation. We test its performance on three existing test sets:
SwissDial (Dogan-Sch\"onberger et al., 2021), STT4SG-350 (Pl\"uss et al.,
2023), and Swiss Parliaments Corpus (Pl\"uss et al., 2021). In addition, we
create a new test set for this work, based on short mock clinical interviews.
For automatic evaluation, we used word error rate (WER) and BLEU. In the
qualitative analysis, we discuss Whisper's strengths and weaknesses and anylyze
some output examples. For the human evaluation, we conducted a survey with 28
participants who were asked to evaluate Whisper's performance.
All of our evaluations suggest that Whisper is a viable ASR system for Swiss
German, so long as the Standard German output is desired.
|
[
-0.1070917323,
-0.6254758239,
0.4892296195,
0.4574033916,
-0.3895421028,
0.2793282866,
-0.231545344,
-0.7567364573,
-0.0811563209,
0.1793940514,
-0.7025187612,
-0.5110660791,
-0.7961500287,
0.2275261432,
-0.648886323,
0.7140527964,
-0.033626359,
0.5799043775,
0.330194056,
-0.1714086831,
-0.2116533965,
-0.550767839,
-0.6680725217,
-0.6139650941,
0.0689459667,
0.3045319319,
0.4284675717,
0.3263737559,
0.1430231929,
0.3822192252,
-0.2768232524,
-0.2706391811,
-0.537610352,
-0.2630113661,
0.2053050399,
-0.0673238933,
-0.2237217128,
0.0352716371,
0.7187277675,
0.737860024,
-0.5745250583,
0.235809952,
0.079017438,
0.7164117694,
-0.1839255393,
0.1976757348,
-0.5744624138,
-0.0790499747,
-0.3073980212,
0.2418531626,
-0.3911041319,
-0.4485145211,
0.8128854036,
-0.496214062,
0.6630094647,
0.1147999018,
1.0345950127,
-0.0110934442,
-0.5094108582,
-0.4211340249,
-0.8408518434,
0.5671569705,
-0.5325753093,
0.6377658844,
0.5882052183,
0.5921784639,
0.1491516232,
-0.6175789237,
-0.4347338676,
-0.0875951797,
0.0858424529,
0.4198923409,
-0.6551375389,
-0.010011212,
0.1194051206,
0.3859563172,
-0.5102164149,
0.1008568108,
-0.6228108406,
-0.6698149443,
0.834438026,
-0.0494197793,
0.1397548616,
-0.0378112905,
-0.2638105154,
-0.0690632612,
-0.2634798288,
0.3827579916,
0.5052402616,
0.1833278388,
-0.1574401557,
0.1627339423,
-0.3140606582,
0.802963078,
0.2931686044,
-0.0525198877,
0.2627511024,
-0.0492008664,
-0.0833802745,
0.5505902171,
0.8283475041,
0.2790805399,
0.433960408,
-0.3978634179,
-0.2757922709,
0.1278052777,
0.3235032558,
-0.7098885775,
-0.3428780138,
0.0626069903,
-0.5381187201,
-0.0513978116,
0.0439585336,
-0.12271218,
-0.0703945383,
-0.1432005614,
0.6991571188,
-0.807965219,
-0.2661087513,
0.5580925941,
-0.5743891001,
0.3285477161,
0.4075210392,
-0.6032223105,
0.625469625,
0.3569163978,
0.6522567868,
-0.252976656,
-0.4702190459,
-0.5815681219,
-0.0658854172,
-0.2711514533,
1.1028048992,
-0.1289610267,
-0.9799561501,
0.1580443233,
0.0195120014,
-0.3975846767,
-0.8627867103,
0.6323480606,
-0.5502915382,
0.1920292079,
-0.1743003875,
-0.5471033454,
-0.420788914,
-0.3546009064,
-0.4360864758,
0.666652739,
0.084245488,
-0.5692871213,
0.3383022547,
-0.385520637,
-0.9795747995,
0.0788179785,
0.3135172129,
-0.0794248804,
0.3392451704,
0.0790634677,
0.2189016789,
-0.1360699087,
0.0935100988,
0.0145438304,
-0.6912096739,
0.6906914711,
-0.3706880212,
0.7999929786,
-0.0936743021,
-0.2323436141,
0.046058245,
-0.8074790835,
0.4780232906,
-0.1889943182,
-0.2535168231,
0.0667287037,
-0.0018108719,
0.2023866028,
-0.1328680217,
-0.0216124989,
-0.8917649388,
-0.4794602096,
-0.5461440682,
0.6428466439,
0.5499618053,
0.0765563324,
0.3323321044,
-0.2347553223,
0.4710688591,
-0.3277316988,
0.3082075715,
0.0368949138,
-0.2886542082,
-0.8690869212,
-0.3209958375,
0.6538207531,
0.8354378939,
-0.3095210493,
0.5699145198,
-0.1616354734,
-0.6303477287,
-1.0707867146,
-0.0624328479,
0.7145087719,
0.68540591,
0.2685679197,
-0.2211844027,
-0.2803397775,
-1.1761564016,
-0.135238722,
-0.4037117362,
-0.13529405,
0.0554161146,
0.3656810224,
-0.1520889401,
0.7484793663,
-0.6037175059,
-0.3862767518,
-0.2103831917,
0.4950760901,
0.099751398,
0.1137357801,
0.1460639983,
-0.661973834,
-0.5391985774,
-0.0291429702,
-0.583994925,
-0.1324212849,
0.4446339905,
0.1460491121,
0.267318815,
0.1172365323,
-0.2555255592,
0.3991023898,
0.5400386453,
-0.3063149154,
0.7457409501,
-0.3425883055,
0.1000710875,
-0.651291728,
-0.0586406104,
-0.0481850505,
-0.213184908,
-0.7178459167,
-0.3803081214,
0.1896205246,
-0.2356614918,
-0.4452131689,
0.5768812299,
-0.2859997749,
-0.1563277543,
-0.2167813778,
-0.0739147514,
0.0250152797,
0.0449222699,
0.4332731068,
0.8061696887,
0.7260796428,
-0.5293024778,
0.1301197708,
0.4189510942,
-0.5493176579,
0.849493444,
-0.9647145271,
0.3726190627,
0.2726220489,
0.0859448165,
-0.8026503921,
-0.3071897328,
-0.1602667421,
-0.8158808351,
0.3826633394,
-0.1510581225,
-0.5347813964,
-0.3044036925,
0.0743502825,
-0.2765371501,
0.9061564803,
-0.3218588531,
0.582600832,
0.4026115537,
-0.2063426673,
-0.1061536074,
-0.3229892552,
0.105350256,
-0.1318346113,
-0.818503499,
0.1933252662,
-0.0882326737,
-0.4312646091,
-0.1595970541,
-0.3821433485,
-0.5077897906,
0.0169615205,
0.2594075501,
0.3164651096,
-0.0516256094,
-0.0731054321,
0.134053573,
-0.4187520742,
0.1133571789,
-0.0500134155,
0.2483722866,
-0.5775910616,
-0.4563964903,
-0.9944270253,
0.5014505386,
0.355124265,
-0.105656825,
-0.0520194545,
0.6674416661,
-0.2206668705,
-0.1836858541,
-0.8703827262,
-0.2645973265,
-0.4749671817,
0.2087969482,
-0.566488266,
-0.9573920369,
0.7549670339,
-0.0473176017,
-0.3625973165,
0.4983882904,
0.1118523329,
-0.6462453008,
1.2514369488,
0.6606808305,
-0.1375401765,
-0.1243543029,
-0.1896570474,
-0.0783833638,
-0.6366485953,
-0.1593956649,
-0.781914115,
-0.022610236,
-0.1885015517,
0.0843033269,
0.5052337646,
0.252250284,
-0.0511519536,
0.1729370356,
-0.3705638945,
-0.0008122471,
0.4315648973,
0.0631534085,
0.4094516337,
0.0515420772,
0.0657477826,
-0.393577069,
-0.5951266885,
-0.5845762491,
0.4839042723,
0.365650773,
0.7779019475,
-0.1098631099,
0.7812590599,
0.3780763149,
0.1833772808,
-1.0022208691,
0.5235465169,
-0.1976150274,
-0.3579112887,
-0.3661209345,
-0.1015276164,
-0.9226571321,
0.1860972047,
-0.0348549187,
-0.5449406505,
-0.0204785336,
0.1278737932,
-0.3966807723,
-0.2496245205,
-1.1352468729,
0.6474242806,
-0.286298722,
0.3926251531,
-0.434930861,
-0.5681598186,
0.066383265,
-0.3114266396,
0.1909341514,
-0.1210747287,
0.0714770481,
1.0081818104,
-0.4109012783,
0.9404317737,
-0.3235928714,
0.0157815591,
0.3783710301,
0.1276748627,
0.1737650037,
-0.1643944234,
-0.2952575088,
0.6316192746,
0.2515437305,
-0.1939059943,
-0.6781350374,
0.2275823951,
-0.8149670959,
-0.4368367195,
-0.5563120246,
-0.1196788475,
-0.3878047764,
0.2579517961,
0.5852749944,
0.6613535881,
-0.7103558779,
-0.2578547895,
0.7011134624,
0.0327378996,
0.0798126534,
1.5823564529,
-0.0672355592,
-0.5290160179,
0.8510488868,
0.2984843254,
0.2893257439,
-0.1167635992,
0.49850142,
-0.554902494,
-0.9232248068,
-0.959423542,
0.3860065043,
-0.5607590079,
0.1437433213,
-0.7417207956,
-0.4357155561,
-0.1917681992,
-0.1989849061,
-0.0212111305,
-0.1937425584,
-0.2421800792,
-0.2309931219,
0.562379539,
0.9795319438,
-0.0362825245,
0.599321723,
-1.0298931599,
0.1579732895,
0.4449142218,
0.1351525635,
-0.1251252294,
-0.8919330835,
-0.1138660163,
-0.0903548375,
0.0746156052,
-0.868139565,
0.1793000549,
0.3865938187,
0.6535474062,
0.4693245292,
0.2299341261,
0.9490404129,
-1.0774309635,
0.7391425371,
0.2235372066,
-1.3639538288,
0.6243412495,
-0.2625775635,
0.2255507708,
0.8439581394,
0.1567013413,
-0.5187615752,
-0.4984686077,
-0.9044195414,
-0.3793445826,
0.7336177826,
0.0437973738,
0.2060561925,
0.140637666,
0.2582237124,
0.3823272884,
0.2381059825,
-0.0820709243,
-0.1443995833,
-0.1418899298,
0.0639362857,
-0.1606388539,
-0.2765516937,
-0.2931180596,
-0.2917951643,
0.5077815056,
-0.0603280626,
0.2004845887,
0.2132049352,
-0.1601827145,
-0.1462976038,
0.2732709646,
0.2828123868,
0.6980651617,
-0.3292598128,
-0.088770844,
0.446685791,
-0.6070585847,
0.2595850229,
0.5426347256,
-0.421344161,
0.3316572905,
0.8393223286,
0.8715984225,
0.4064260423,
-0.7908806205,
0.5930382609,
-0.1272008121,
-0.5283672214,
-0.5219185352,
0.0798756182,
0.2310588062,
0.153595522,
0.5885618329,
0.1536094546,
0.4981782436,
-0.4681414068,
0.2438336313,
0.4508184791,
-0.9681565762,
-0.7169701457,
0.3435103893,
0.3774651289,
-0.6116301417,
0.6776772738,
-0.2929973602,
-0.9317334294,
0.1760478169,
0.7954438329,
1.0318781137,
-0.3856332898,
0.5014092922,
0.1819795817,
0.2564817071,
-0.2212579995,
0.7236779928,
-0.2813598514,
-0.7688358426,
-0.4237800539,
-0.6827386022,
-0.5507169366,
-0.2802301943,
-1.2943117619,
-0.073002398,
-0.0243834257,
-0.2773742378,
0.1884457469,
-0.0507694297,
-0.5938548446,
0.1456638575,
-0.2609382868,
1.2193005085,
-0.9361489415,
0.911780715,
0.6938699484,
0.0780565292,
-0.7849214673,
0.161481604,
0.1072011739,
-1.2781395912,
0.9077652097,
0.1330229193,
-0.6887003183,
0.18632406,
-0.2350620031,
-0.5865804553,
0.789477706,
0.2597686052,
-0.3605337441,
0.2851323187,
-0.3944020271,
0.7399377227,
-0.0467623733,
-0.1731129736,
0.5664789081,
0.6753610373,
0.0995854586,
-1.5626561642,
-0.3803699613,
-0.2091372758,
-0.073056899,
-0.0106055848,
-0.547924459,
0.1751020998,
-0.4115403295,
-0.6675707698,
0.119948253,
0.526409328,
-0.0840766281,
0.4917981327,
0.7886952162,
0.3688054085,
0.895024538,
-0.183247447,
1.1915922165,
0.0361542739,
-0.1849023402,
1.0281050205,
-0.8566611409,
1.2080820799,
0.081424363,
-0.500932157,
0.5628487468,
0.5726951361,
0.1780090183,
0.6319389939,
0.0892745852,
-0.3832451105,
-0.3442124128,
-0.0336614475,
-0.2061705291,
0.654471755,
0.2595841289,
0.0389998518,
-0.1577259004,
0.3299348652,
0.0117713623,
0.1744105667,
-0.0547230765,
1.2308626175,
0.1342197359,
-0.4600743353,
0.6767668724,
0.0254837871,
0.4569934011,
-1.1284372807,
0.2240608931,
0.3000746667,
0.1662368774,
-0.0009884392,
-0.6119554639,
0.3394330144,
0.1139994636,
-0.3079583943,
-0.2556765378,
0.7794659734,
-0.2398445159,
-0.626147151,
0.4008679986,
0.7132258415,
0.4975343943,
-0.2418771386,
-0.7143084407,
0.1490850598,
0.1643337607,
0.238239944,
0.3621434867,
0.2403734922,
0.1416810602,
0.61210531,
0.5650987625,
0.5057252645,
-0.1713721901,
0.3337393403,
0.6027339697,
-0.611779809,
-0.6762719154,
-0.6665753126,
0.2733769715,
-0.2699474692,
-0.3800130188,
0.9653851986,
0.6518473029,
0.5230437517,
0.0235531535,
0.9557204247,
0.3010510206,
1.0284376144,
-0.4971707463,
0.7698588371,
-0.0082687372,
-0.3147049844,
-0.031170249,
-0.4414789081,
0.0757173821,
0.8546660542,
-0.258038491,
-0.4229107797,
0.6585658193,
0.4449152648,
0.1729092598,
0.5705962181,
0.1748714745,
0.1149532571,
-0.0723904744,
0.0316158943,
1.0131752491,
-0.2825742364,
0.6846030951,
-0.144291237,
-0.4439744949,
0.0730195567,
-0.6534962654,
-0.8264663815,
-0.5976675749,
-0.3925881386,
-0.4252828956,
0.3499799669,
0.4245705605,
0.95779109,
-0.7467266917,
-0.6316412091,
0.5566716194,
-0.3127300441,
-0.621011436,
-0.1799440384,
0.6850984693,
-0.0403396934,
-0.5374000669,
0.7632838488,
0.2471058667,
0.2743442059,
-0.2258659601,
-0.2280592322,
0.5101622343,
-0.2215444148,
0.6388171911,
0.1218284667,
-0.9323368073,
-0.3805271983,
0.4356196523,
0.1127139255,
-0.1228327081,
0.7856678963,
-0.8097981811,
0.7180321217,
0.1833871305,
0.3432949483,
0.6941944957,
0.0684001967,
0.7511315346,
-0.2703811228,
-0.08260829,
0.2370264679,
0.2713195384,
0.4602916539,
-0.1576048732,
0.264015317,
0.1937484592,
-0.3967425525,
-0.8115232587,
0.1174912602,
-1.0353555679,
-0.0142403496,
1.0820404291,
-0.1118991598,
-0.1163332164,
-0.5857424736,
-0.4723971486,
-0.0286451615,
-0.6829301715,
0.6358474493,
0.9822499752,
-0.4159905612,
0.1888946295,
-0.6771183014,
0.4540994465,
0.0414125733,
-0.2906420529,
-0.0044461717,
0.5202681422,
0.5563752055,
0.1171509102,
1.0236780643,
-0.1144769266,
0.4156279862,
-0.0880068988,
-0.0748606548,
-0.0582508557,
0.1482225209,
-0.7580609322,
-0.1446642727,
0.2476463318,
-0.3309467733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19296v1
|
Octopus v4: Graph of language models
| 2024-04-30T06:55:45 | 2024-04-30T06:55:45 |
Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models have been effective in a wide range of applications, yet the
most sophisticated models are often proprietary. For example, GPT-4 by OpenAI
and various models by Anthropic are expensive and consume substantial energy.
In contrast, the open-source community has produced competitive models, like
Llama3. Furthermore, niche-specific smaller language models, such as those
tailored for legal, medical or financial tasks, have outperformed their
proprietary counterparts. This paper introduces a novel approach that employs
\textit{functional tokens} to integrate \textbf{multiple open-source models},
each optimized for particular tasks. Our newly developed Octopus v4 model
leverages \textit{functional tokens} to intelligently direct user queries to
the most appropriate vertical model and reformat the query to achieve the best
performance. Octopus v4, an evolution of the Octopus v1, v2, and v3 models,
excels in selection and parameter understanding and reformatting. Additionally,
we explore the use of graph as a versatile data structure that effectively
coordinates multiple open-source models by harnessing the capabilities of the
Octopus model and \textit{functional tokens}. Use our open-sourced GitHub
(\url{https://www.nexa4ai.com/}) to try Octopus v4 models
(\url{https://huggingface.co/NexaAIDev/Octopus-v4}), and contrite to a larger
graph of language models. By activating models less than 10B parameters, we
achieved SOTA MMLU score of 74.8 among the same level models.
|
[
-0.2138969451,
-0.5822456479,
0.6181890368,
0.021540761,
-0.1713690311,
-0.1380515248,
-0.0036623708,
-0.6903120279,
0.4229125082,
0.9182857871,
-0.2440591604,
-0.7079799175,
-0.1710662991,
0.2198897451,
-0.2513211668,
0.8305491805,
0.1179613099,
0.0594983511,
0.0400305912,
-0.6704961061,
-0.179020822,
-0.4013954103,
-0.4873266518,
-0.2253064364,
0.594481051,
0.5031961799,
0.7040426731,
0.6843044758,
0.4619886279,
0.3512169123,
-0.1039170995,
-0.3013556004,
-0.581338346,
-0.0395669416,
-0.1953428835,
-0.569660306,
-0.6985980272,
-0.0875246376,
0.6329432726,
0.6491490602,
-0.1530295908,
0.1624515057,
-0.3488189876,
0.3554544151,
-0.2839520276,
0.5922775269,
-0.7841300368,
-0.1215673983,
-0.3819819689,
0.2454922795,
-0.374468267,
-0.3957051933,
0.0697786361,
-0.8843414187,
-0.4178355336,
0.1854681224,
0.8192813993,
0.0987116098,
-0.4678079188,
-0.221628502,
-0.4330032766,
0.6612753868,
-0.9950302243,
0.6103070974,
0.1811236441,
0.4515188634,
-0.1370967031,
-1.1390525103,
-0.6008265615,
-0.3180022538,
0.1695292145,
-0.1101595536,
-0.3987394869,
0.1478122622,
0.0476707704,
0.215693742,
-0.3699492216,
0.4349869192,
-0.7693372369,
-0.1888811141,
0.4742231965,
0.1420450956,
0.4612430334,
-0.1232305393,
-0.3457793891,
0.264080137,
-0.9556245208,
0.0289915148,
0.7613008618,
0.5162047744,
-0.0761681721,
0.8537450433,
-0.2931595147,
0.676619947,
-0.3132987618,
-0.226612702,
0.5158157945,
-0.5392435193,
0.2161408514,
-0.220092088,
0.9617783427,
0.2295672894,
0.1772059798,
0.0642044321,
-0.2401332706,
-0.1117149964,
0.2481076568,
-0.697280407,
-0.2234551162,
0.2402435839,
-0.43369627,
-0.443075031,
-0.2896172106,
-0.6319876909,
-0.1553604752,
-0.3110645115,
0.3583592772,
-0.4494795799,
-0.4708177745,
0.150353387,
-0.0866730213,
-0.1720823497,
0.1422987729,
-0.9345183372,
0.6813749671,
0.8136329651,
0.9531394243,
-0.075974375,
-0.0947314501,
-0.4630333483,
0.1122683138,
-0.2403574139,
0.5678179264,
-1.0202207565,
-0.1652113646,
-0.1202716455,
-0.2284308821,
0.0479065627,
-0.3198398352,
0.392257899,
-0.5871219635,
0.2903975248,
-0.0702840537,
-0.6091341972,
-0.5163142085,
0.1391971111,
-1.1260056496,
1.0110673904,
0.2773243487,
-0.927638948,
0.2447152734,
-1.2667502165,
0.0162379555,
0.3951008022,
-0.2919650972,
-0.4131987095,
-0.1834211498,
0.085089311,
0.1809023172,
-0.2984421551,
-0.0687793791,
-0.8499913216,
-0.1455935538,
-0.1501835138,
0.3781393468,
0.7721492052,
0.3562845886,
-0.0845884681,
0.4258661866,
-0.6609410048,
-0.1458240747,
0.1505797356,
-0.3235301673,
-0.6052256227,
0.1507544518,
-0.0982039645,
-0.000413588,
0.3324012756,
-0.6346995831,
0.4958494306,
-0.5749432445,
1.1041851044,
0.5992524028,
-0.0895646662,
0.3866808414,
0.0476313382,
0.5225727558,
0.0490178242,
0.1700008959,
-0.3169438541,
-0.9774081707,
-0.2380899489,
-0.4426444471,
0.3088641167,
0.3638437986,
-0.7710780501,
0.0097304042,
-0.2545560896,
-0.7378854752,
-0.4698290825,
-0.0527789779,
0.0840599239,
0.5394239426,
0.323939532,
-0.3266069591,
-0.2655492127,
-0.7751082778,
-0.3698569536,
-0.4680892527,
0.0749941692,
0.5297967196,
0.5953561068,
-0.4211326838,
0.9842044115,
-0.4988209307,
-0.0650068745,
-0.4061027765,
0.0291152615,
0.5898559093,
0.2739183903,
0.8884692192,
-0.8927986026,
-0.2739653587,
0.3570945263,
-0.3218437731,
-0.2712771893,
0.3730753064,
0.1170509905,
0.092094548,
0.3033938408,
-0.6126574278,
0.0745149851,
0.6309992671,
-0.3646390736,
0.6091329455,
-0.1460116059,
-0.2145186514,
-1.046407342,
0.3502006233,
0.0448945016,
-0.3844504356,
-0.6802580953,
0.3604326248,
0.0010578824,
-0.354280889,
-0.4994093478,
0.6820144653,
-0.2589641809,
-0.3027893901,
0.1283142418,
0.0900187269,
-0.207904011,
0.4158344269,
-0.0873372704,
0.51320678,
0.5882825851,
-0.2649837732,
0.2736141682,
0.0626780689,
-0.0748300627,
0.1792463362,
-0.9027849436,
0.0734719038,
0.0786698312,
0.137075454,
-0.9569337368,
-0.1934838593,
0.4879998863,
-0.0931309164,
-0.1997744143,
-0.2507764399,
-0.4761706889,
-0.3162892461,
-0.3240201175,
0.5357129574,
0.3224886358,
-0.3428846896,
0.7301203609,
0.7013040781,
-0.4693966508,
-0.3688055277,
-0.2155788541,
-0.0479090959,
-0.4408391714,
-0.7220879793,
0.3108179569,
-0.0597691536,
-0.0840385482,
0.3286649287,
-0.0196834244,
-0.2259160131,
-0.0810357332,
0.0201669782,
0.1348082423,
-0.6153139472,
-0.0992683247,
0.0891072527,
-0.3413853347,
-0.2729516923,
-0.7908957005,
0.4113978744,
-0.3096921742,
-0.4507153332,
-0.4628515542,
0.2301216274,
0.9211878777,
-0.6102715731,
0.4475777149,
0.1695317328,
-0.45583722,
0.0091835288,
-0.5237606764,
-0.1514938772,
-0.4906839132,
0.1927979141,
-0.5427627563,
-1.0646265745,
0.6617895961,
-0.0872350484,
0.2920537293,
0.3787644804,
0.7064252496,
0.3377438188,
0.9785010815,
0.747849524,
-0.0594209246,
0.6039429307,
-0.1764469445,
0.4385890365,
-0.3615794778,
-0.1421713978,
-0.6500871778,
-0.0665608346,
-0.700330615,
-0.3406202197,
0.4914592206,
-0.1052269191,
-0.2430591285,
0.6135818362,
-0.3339283466,
0.4525988102,
0.4948019087,
-0.347523272,
0.3808898926,
0.0156854223,
-0.5748342276,
-0.0239759237,
-0.6624819636,
-0.6625523567,
1.3122916222,
0.6543133259,
0.6339305639,
0.1231403723,
0.7423945665,
-0.0899408758,
0.3001166284,
-0.4978544414,
0.464938581,
-0.1185320765,
-0.6053803563,
-0.4961448014,
-0.5946397781,
-1.0685125589,
0.6083940268,
-0.001752252,
-1.1126712561,
0.1495046467,
0.1243457124,
-0.2492667586,
0.2126870751,
-0.7699849606,
1.2344502211,
-0.1410987377,
-0.2292553037,
-0.1808979213,
-0.4697476625,
0.3457840085,
-0.2221798301,
0.5077420473,
-0.3622059524,
-0.3616686463,
0.3617470562,
-0.6223028898,
0.6815881729,
-0.1817760766,
0.0566788763,
0.3400229812,
-0.0338199139,
0.3603467941,
0.1309834868,
-0.5441803932,
0.5121526718,
0.2213020176,
-0.2309755385,
-0.4067786634,
0.6960184574,
-0.7553862333,
-0.2466641665,
-0.0591949224,
-0.3061812222,
0.1901599765,
0.8442580104,
-0.0969976187,
0.3582814336,
-0.0205016993,
0.1741136163,
0.081314154,
-0.1273078173,
0.2852773368,
0.6441739202,
-0.4481282532,
-0.5711595416,
0.9998494983,
0.3667325377,
0.165514037,
0.1289217919,
0.3946332335,
-0.518591404,
-0.6177726984,
-0.3452381492,
0.5791987777,
-0.5755935311,
-0.0514410473,
-0.7038808465,
0.2332946807,
-0.4509071112,
0.127079621,
-0.4348598719,
-0.6778315902,
-0.2043838501,
-0.2947875857,
0.3283403516,
0.9478846192,
0.0280627664,
0.1686366946,
-0.6220492125,
0.3748518229,
0.0146144889,
0.6735779047,
-0.3487975597,
0.2158762962,
0.0520310514,
-0.077963613,
-0.3823031187,
-1.2227879763,
0.322268784,
0.1908924431,
0.7029462457,
0.5167486668,
-0.0466712862,
0.4425721765,
-0.7310739756,
0.8187271357,
0.3343838453,
-1.1226494312,
0.2976447344,
-0.5894752741,
-0.0313292071,
0.3353003561,
0.4955615401,
-0.3914081156,
-0.5874938965,
-0.5856322646,
-1.088363409,
0.8154097795,
0.3781296909,
0.039911937,
0.2111829817,
0.4770144224,
0.2639518082,
0.3456224501,
-1.0430147648,
0.1681278646,
-0.43355304,
-0.4164718688,
0.1754752696,
-0.0008205516,
-0.0010660103,
-0.3670946062,
0.4477599561,
-0.4313111007,
-0.0053780233,
-0.1944991648,
0.1963983625,
0.1394986063,
-0.102021277,
0.5181176662,
0.7228312492,
0.1384993345,
-0.041409459,
0.1573255062,
-0.2579375207,
-0.18030563,
0.1563814431,
0.0393929072,
0.0587094426,
0.2614409626,
0.7846106291,
0.446577996,
-0.5921034813,
0.5287116766,
-0.0753624216,
-0.0427035056,
-0.3085997701,
0.1429163665,
0.4757703841,
0.3568688333,
-0.0011250672,
-0.2202565521,
0.3416704535,
-0.4914937317,
0.1720775366,
0.1839873046,
-0.3015094399,
-0.6172409654,
0.9762381315,
0.3531522751,
-0.3981813788,
0.5132106543,
-0.0464335382,
-0.3482345641,
0.3611251414,
0.5022565722,
0.513240993,
-0.2945809066,
0.1253037006,
0.231900692,
0.2400791496,
0.0147343408,
0.7448616624,
0.0101847462,
-0.5091850758,
-0.3746976256,
-0.4785609245,
-0.5446335673,
0.0986335725,
-0.2102467865,
0.6880788803,
-0.2925625443,
-0.2418649197,
0.2571648955,
-0.2000244558,
-0.4979434311,
-0.1843196899,
-0.0085183084,
1.0252733231,
-0.7027772665,
0.8602541089,
0.9427737594,
-0.7922873497,
-0.8684498668,
-0.3756509721,
0.033755444,
-0.6906096339,
0.5094769001,
0.2271036953,
-0.0184367429,
0.1078218371,
-0.5302988291,
-1.0072789192,
0.8998975158,
0.7072860003,
-0.4277247787,
-0.1759734601,
0.3717912138,
0.6716330051,
-0.7205916643,
0.5193575025,
0.4323890507,
0.5476979613,
0.1257151812,
-1.0404243469,
0.0259635691,
-0.3176429272,
0.067900911,
0.2584808469,
-0.4557995796,
1.1407592297,
-0.1839175373,
-0.0516414046,
0.083325386,
0.4984006286,
0.2586699426,
0.2551947236,
0.638546586,
0.5771458745,
0.7692548037,
-0.0210626964,
0.9028872848,
-0.6645311117,
0.4051114619,
0.6440072656,
-0.4069723487,
0.987590611,
0.348511219,
0.0991197079,
0.5878568888,
0.4510275722,
0.120731689,
0.3103289604,
0.2294377387,
0.0898703635,
0.026150804,
0.2756876647,
-0.2591566145,
0.4284428358,
0.5491701365,
-0.162419647,
-0.223141253,
-0.1235303879,
0.1924915314,
-0.2059841007,
0.0137465401,
0.8339534402,
0.0919752941,
-0.6001042128,
0.3829777241,
0.2773773372,
0.1360480189,
-0.664991796,
-0.1500269175,
-0.1988372207,
0.1094792187,
-0.2537312806,
-0.5838655829,
0.3297828436,
-0.0196828432,
0.2941808105,
-0.1536437124,
0.549821198,
-0.3560370207,
-0.3758055568,
0.4455898702,
0.1035282388,
0.3668364286,
0.1160847694,
-0.7306779623,
0.3375255167,
-0.1944313347,
-0.202063933,
-0.152556926,
0.5883395672,
-0.2622894347,
0.7651643753,
0.8154502511,
0.1162013412,
0.1040659547,
-0.1745827049,
1.0801749229,
-0.4928580225,
-1.0427379608,
-0.6914601326,
0.6836056113,
-0.2167286873,
-0.3708880842,
0.5241813064,
0.6565486789,
0.7217559218,
0.0836238042,
0.6344756484,
0.1866297722,
0.4759868681,
-0.3960670233,
0.698094964,
-0.8161076307,
0.3044904768,
-0.525806725,
-1.0385630131,
-0.4648801982,
0.4243300557,
-0.4059310853,
-0.1850454956,
0.5028765798,
0.7216982841,
-0.385265708,
0.2353746295,
0.0788002685,
0.3559751213,
0.6997207999,
0.1774886101,
0.6145358086,
0.019877946,
0.5169329047,
0.1884940267,
-0.3571950197,
-0.5878118873,
-0.9052074552,
-0.6269446015,
-0.5692252517,
-0.3243762255,
0.13181068,
-0.0357416235,
0.6328166127,
0.9585968852,
-0.6526151299,
-0.4806644022,
-0.1021206155,
0.4130888879,
-0.1338797063,
-0.1610856354,
0.0003813792,
-0.3567672968,
-0.6598754525,
0.4931196272,
0.4939349592,
-0.2300346792,
-0.4431706965,
-0.1490086615,
0.0113164205,
0.3477640748,
0.5199397206,
0.4713221192,
-0.8610990047,
-0.3682941794,
-0.0972980782,
0.1049257219,
0.1441295743,
0.85266608,
-0.5716122985,
0.566947937,
0.7372140884,
0.3978096843,
0.5701516867,
-0.2396739125,
0.7458031178,
-0.3322659731,
0.130713895,
0.3625541329,
0.6348962188,
0.0900382474,
-0.0522748232,
0.6360038519,
0.3313975632,
-0.4260674119,
-1.0378345251,
0.4497052133,
-0.7905522585,
-0.2672587931,
0.9425027966,
-0.2236405909,
-0.2575986087,
-0.1534643024,
-0.376924932,
-0.175145641,
-0.5060924292,
0.3431582451,
0.516053617,
-0.3565960824,
-0.0583610423,
-0.6674240828,
0.1997253597,
0.0280702412,
-0.7178763151,
-0.3452092111,
0.4919048548,
0.6138954759,
0.3600057662,
0.8153726459,
-0.3648849428,
-0.049301438,
-0.0584378131,
-0.0034229888,
-0.1619032472,
-0.3119426668,
-0.1014447734,
0.584831655,
0.153261736,
-0.0654603392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01593v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01593v1
|
Large Language Model Agent for Fake News Detection
| 2024-04-30T06:55:27 | 2024-04-30T06:55:27 |
Xinyi Li, Yongfeng Zhang, Edward C. Malthouse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In the current digital era, the rapid spread of misinformation on online
platforms presents significant challenges to societal well-being, public trust,
and democratic processes, influencing critical decision making and public
opinion. To address these challenges, there is a growing need for automated
fake news detection mechanisms. Pre-trained large language models (LLMs) have
demonstrated exceptional capabilities across various natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, prompting exploration into their potential for
verifying news claims. Instead of employing LLMs in a non-agentic way, where
LLMs generate responses based on direct prompts in a single shot, our work
introduces FactAgent, an agentic approach of utilizing LLMs for fake news
detection. FactAgent enables LLMs to emulate human expert behavior in verifying
news claims without any model training, following a structured workflow. This
workflow breaks down the complex task of news veracity checking into multiple
sub-steps, where LLMs complete simple tasks using their internal knowledge or
external tools. At the final step of the workflow, LLMs integrate all findings
throughout the workflow to determine the news claim's veracity. Compared to
manual human verification, FactAgent offers enhanced efficiency. Experimental
studies demonstrate the effectiveness of FactAgent in verifying claims without
the need for any training process. Moreover, FactAgent provides transparent
explanations at each step of the workflow and during final decision-making,
offering insights into the reasoning process of fake news detection for end
users. FactAgent is highly adaptable, allowing for straightforward updates to
its tools that LLMs can leverage within the workflow, as well as updates to the
workflow itself using domain knowledge. This adaptability enables FactAgent's
application to news verification across various domains.
|
[
-0.1489878595,
-1.0520102978,
0.7849677205,
0.2183127403,
-0.2425516695,
0.322609961,
-0.0781565905,
-0.5284072161,
0.371501565,
0.4782197773,
-0.3210138083,
-0.4399977028,
-0.5558676124,
0.0209413879,
-0.5729846358,
0.8545823097,
0.0844383836,
-0.0151159689,
-0.1692684889,
0.1248540133,
-0.1321215034,
-0.438041985,
-0.8149299026,
-0.4178184867,
0.4702388346,
0.2849523425,
0.7332536578,
0.371009022,
0.0545430109,
0.4688059688,
0.2896449566,
0.495847404,
-0.2920060456,
-0.1621643156,
-0.3239998221,
-0.533562243,
-0.4694608152,
0.2136431485,
0.3329610527,
-0.0586246662,
-0.1788262725,
0.1609105468,
-0.480489552,
0.3004940748,
-0.3431014121,
0.1854194999,
-0.7145040035,
-0.1037714779,
0.0305387825,
-0.2913910747,
-0.5027797818,
-0.4762010276,
-0.0266265254,
-0.4531906843,
0.4296189845,
0.1635472625,
0.9918500781,
0.2573272884,
-0.6834244728,
-0.2183015645,
-0.7222527862,
0.3986592591,
-0.8411206603,
0.4698373973,
0.2374568135,
0.4983641505,
-0.3109517097,
-0.6584970951,
-1.0837682486,
-0.6072824001,
-0.0673094168,
-0.0229846537,
-0.2427208573,
-0.181252107,
0.223249808,
0.0663265735,
-0.7583955526,
0.0672412068,
-0.0539830662,
-0.6316300631,
0.7070379257,
-0.2153944522,
0.3983931243,
-0.0882195607,
-0.308065623,
0.0464346632,
-0.5288556814,
-0.4278362095,
0.4599063993,
0.1321528405,
-0.1545578092,
0.4587776661,
-0.3757117093,
0.5693002939,
0.0491559282,
-0.606541276,
0.2929968238,
-0.0479758978,
-0.1577111781,
0.3109987676,
0.7158161402,
0.0002772275,
0.105741851,
0.0383861847,
-0.4832689762,
0.2587095201,
0.2463565767,
-0.73067379,
0.0801107436,
0.2350881249,
-0.2788855433,
-0.4644660652,
0.1250342578,
-0.5223997235,
-0.6286568642,
-0.5406079888,
0.6480200887,
-0.2666135132,
-0.3469707668,
0.1330003738,
-0.0537223518,
0.1421414465,
0.7752088308,
-0.0041227285,
0.0269902833,
0.586037755,
0.7748724222,
0.055494979,
-0.2625620067,
-0.9059103131,
-0.049471397,
-0.5096037984,
0.961143136,
-0.3070029318,
0.3107068241,
0.0527302474,
0.1117819622,
0.1092878431,
-0.3618800044,
0.6618968248,
-1.057728529,
0.0436462648,
-0.110430114,
-0.6101366282,
-0.2915733755,
0.6802587509,
-0.8847082257,
0.8278029561,
-0.0238499325,
-0.7011361122,
0.2840286493,
-0.7435409427,
-0.5297426581,
0.1227328405,
0.1046908498,
-0.5030415058,
-0.1242608353,
0.274641335,
0.3300116658,
0.0456187986,
0.2305281609,
-0.1794043034,
-0.0913353413,
0.3564885259,
-0.6927831769,
0.5286180973,
0.1913609356,
-0.4534687698,
0.1830005646,
-0.7589297891,
-0.3299581409,
0.1959961951,
-0.345312953,
-0.2095952183,
0.0084245736,
-0.0318852216,
0.3376685977,
0.1485440135,
-0.7946192026,
0.1569570452,
-0.2718316019,
0.0976682454,
0.5434866548,
0.1615204215,
0.1116510257,
-0.4027187824,
0.2265286148,
0.1595804989,
0.0893944874,
-0.0916615278,
-0.1687686145,
-0.8381122947,
-0.356525898,
0.4682563245,
0.7038229704,
-1.2991435528,
0.3664178252,
-0.1983344406,
-0.5602301359,
-0.290622592,
0.0019018579,
0.1836374104,
0.3958107531,
0.2024858743,
0.1576092541,
-0.5470440388,
-0.7546315193,
-0.534753561,
-0.1519517154,
0.0393190719,
-0.3316983581,
0.8008707166,
-0.1665643901,
1.0272779465,
-0.2811416984,
-0.1796394438,
-0.2811382413,
0.362827152,
0.1579033732,
-0.0026572694,
0.4758743942,
-1.1736477613,
-0.476408571,
-0.0422440507,
-0.6847845912,
-0.087266542,
-0.3115117252,
0.1858459413,
0.7526641488,
0.3952729106,
-1.1414364576,
0.6441576481,
0.5289574265,
-0.4686597884,
0.811732471,
-0.184988454,
0.4451352954,
-0.9222995639,
-0.1462953389,
0.2293182462,
-0.9060407281,
-0.7887453437,
0.0166341104,
0.0279699527,
-0.0380916744,
-0.652038753,
0.7033689618,
-0.4855649471,
-0.1962990463,
-0.7301763892,
0.0970742777,
0.0896992907,
0.266646713,
0.1308041364,
0.6655502319,
0.3968304694,
-0.637095511,
0.7115212679,
-0.067335017,
-0.2683032155,
0.5148291588,
-0.5988539457,
0.0370350666,
-0.2594567537,
0.6888483167,
-0.7040610909,
-0.3956120014,
0.3495230675,
-0.7227903008,
-0.0072691422,
-0.1460530758,
-1.1470463276,
-0.4384586811,
-0.1271978319,
-0.2494517267,
0.2693647444,
-0.7279375196,
0.8168131113,
0.0753739774,
0.1537975818,
-0.4478710592,
-0.453288734,
0.4171757996,
0.1626759171,
-0.6838243008,
0.0585927851,
0.0090797683,
-0.4852950275,
0.0788380504,
-0.3609043658,
-0.183763504,
-0.1349170059,
0.0211448632,
0.3339399993,
-0.2892397046,
0.2185249478,
-0.1525974721,
0.0389363654,
0.0109314527,
-0.2319196165,
0.3271838129,
-0.1156235859,
-0.5252680779,
-0.5705214739,
0.171997577,
0.9568421841,
-0.2661413848,
1.0731307268,
0.7398854494,
-0.4506880045,
-0.4610093534,
-0.911696434,
-0.3317784071,
-0.4579277635,
0.3150465488,
-0.109661229,
-0.664909482,
0.3002218008,
-0.0288529489,
-0.0005796592,
0.2996751964,
0.7320381999,
0.3638863564,
1.0084877014,
0.4631173015,
-0.2019919455,
0.2251115441,
0.0467393249,
0.2878807485,
0.1636623889,
-0.0307175163,
-0.2379388064,
0.1075271666,
-0.2717703283,
-0.6932600141,
0.3742240369,
-0.5084824562,
-0.0014335222,
0.0270347204,
-0.138195917,
0.6042546034,
0.4216173589,
0.1842088252,
0.6454344988,
0.0671333075,
0.3436282277,
0.3603498042,
-0.4547915757,
-0.6331307888,
0.7652762532,
0.5142643452,
0.7425770164,
0.2228495777,
0.3252599537,
0.8663979769,
0.5874456763,
-0.8524712324,
0.6226120591,
0.2252382338,
-0.7911869287,
-0.324730128,
-0.3482849002,
-0.5594385266,
0.4422426224,
-0.2863439023,
-0.2333398908,
-0.2022617757,
0.1988752782,
-0.1504543126,
0.5411469936,
-0.5774970651,
0.4624947309,
-0.2328914106,
-0.2015190274,
-0.3862293959,
-0.3664576113,
0.5026343465,
-0.3053652942,
0.2679253519,
-0.0810722783,
-0.0479620323,
0.235010609,
-0.5257381201,
1.1703170538,
-0.2550685704,
-0.1633159667,
0.3777341843,
0.1748804599,
1.0228295326,
0.1267131865,
0.086143896,
0.0517413989,
-0.2649251819,
-0.3359675705,
-0.4944539368,
0.6293763518,
-0.7317127585,
-0.6509413719,
-0.722574234,
-0.5982167125,
-0.0837184042,
0.2542371154,
-0.019114567,
0.2707935572,
-0.2359514982,
-0.0630177259,
0.757078886,
-0.1715019941,
0.3539125919,
1.1730852127,
-0.2584715486,
0.0079420852,
0.9451836348,
0.1389724761,
0.0146984039,
0.4363198876,
0.2519060373,
-0.3488437831,
-0.4271225333,
-0.4289126396,
0.3259408176,
-0.6240302324,
-0.2305659503,
-0.7209668756,
-0.4214720428,
-0.5049412847,
0.1129685268,
-0.5033918023,
-0.2267857641,
-0.0748131797,
-0.1880049556,
0.3918220997,
0.6969980001,
-0.0785839185,
0.3222388625,
-0.7588025928,
0.8482093811,
0.5786036849,
0.1245425045,
-0.2644791603,
-0.5921217799,
-0.2683565021,
0.127150923,
-0.2846719325,
-1.0600620508,
0.5387451649,
-0.0338108167,
0.705829978,
0.4515317976,
0.2260087132,
0.1211079583,
-0.3290840983,
0.5888565183,
-0.1292874962,
-0.8978134394,
0.4104343951,
-0.5115764141,
-0.1298718005,
0.1299691349,
0.5369638801,
-0.3177986741,
-0.4887493253,
-0.568477273,
-0.3530572355,
0.6332548857,
0.1724889725,
0.0253335014,
0.18037121,
0.1586930454,
0.1197157502,
0.3477973938,
-0.9811377525,
-0.2163019031,
-0.4245296419,
-0.117406629,
0.0638072789,
-0.1486973315,
-0.2327788621,
-0.0381257571,
0.9684919119,
-0.3341384232,
0.1485127509,
0.4127443135,
-0.5516579747,
-0.0549758077,
0.3563451171,
0.9373289347,
0.9721013904,
0.0545878708,
0.2882374227,
0.1464218348,
-0.3336549997,
0.2823688388,
0.1515236199,
-0.2094106674,
0.4445265234,
0.5163444281,
0.6879609823,
-0.1722544879,
-0.5632300973,
0.8725594282,
0.0484477356,
-0.3625811338,
-0.5746529698,
-0.0941558629,
0.0708389729,
0.4749029577,
0.6612794995,
0.0686671063,
0.0854388624,
-0.6608502269,
0.2371969223,
0.3269716203,
-0.1328747422,
-0.4227725267,
0.3303206563,
0.2676237226,
-0.3990713358,
0.2335131466,
-0.498190701,
-0.9030627012,
0.7829533219,
0.6777022481,
0.5648041964,
-0.3721769154,
0.7319538593,
-0.0174580496,
0.696798861,
-0.4603981078,
-0.0196786746,
0.4710986614,
-0.981105566,
-0.6983939409,
-0.4615696669,
-0.3300904334,
0.4962146282,
0.0908359885,
0.2856720984,
-0.3331156969,
0.0799142271,
0.0102251116,
0.0457692146,
-0.4664615691,
0.2897806764,
0.3538601696,
1.2247749567,
-1.1294476986,
0.8241191506,
0.7158890963,
-0.3066536784,
-0.7789080739,
0.2736370862,
0.5172755122,
-0.6668311954,
0.6432407498,
0.1474906057,
-0.135335207,
-0.1189236566,
-0.7830427289,
-0.5845303535,
0.8526024818,
0.7229677439,
-0.5173521042,
0.06387043,
0.1920196712,
0.5895194411,
-0.449439019,
0.1803371161,
0.293482691,
0.8216647506,
0.2943479717,
-0.7403048873,
0.2193205804,
0.0068886778,
-0.3972217739,
0.0801095888,
-0.759265542,
0.9032940269,
-0.1532226354,
-0.0608345866,
-0.2361214459,
0.839928329,
0.3508976698,
0.6949629784,
0.6815930009,
0.4874339998,
0.6745641828,
0.2505938113,
1.0527158976,
-0.132873103,
0.2685625553,
0.943574965,
-0.3775582314,
0.4823406339,
0.1565323025,
0.0716041774,
0.7167140245,
0.4191638529,
-0.1463000923,
0.0142457457,
0.0329293124,
-0.4789040089,
-0.5300884247,
-0.164309755,
-0.0102226352,
0.5984756351,
0.1205760762,
-0.1698543429,
-0.4222632051,
0.1647403091,
0.3537924886,
0.2129285038,
-0.4384673238,
0.3570962548,
-0.1883134544,
-0.6057425141,
0.2535101175,
0.2305883914,
0.557192564,
-0.7646227479,
-0.3004137874,
-0.1383552402,
0.0666724294,
-0.2666338682,
-0.4777481854,
0.0642345101,
-0.0354387388,
-0.2897278666,
-0.004541365,
1.2484747171,
-0.5096165538,
-0.4747696817,
0.0692888573,
0.7163002491,
0.0967933387,
-0.5891686082,
-0.623917222,
0.0988616198,
-0.214029029,
-0.5958551764,
0.0729490966,
0.4744652808,
-0.2398987263,
0.8616884947,
0.9498960972,
0.2824250162,
-0.0521251634,
0.1449785829,
0.7770541906,
-0.4014462531,
-0.6099082828,
-0.824629128,
0.1912509948,
-0.4019441009,
0.3558762372,
0.8919215202,
0.5362138748,
0.4115062654,
-0.2764782906,
0.9631369114,
-0.0134079317,
0.7157184482,
-0.5469095111,
0.9403333664,
-0.4222946763,
0.1864218712,
0.1251819432,
-0.8576928973,
-0.1236701533,
0.3159708083,
-0.2423133999,
0.0885891318,
0.7364999056,
1.0031905174,
-0.1979042292,
-0.146745041,
0.4729518592,
0.4876230061,
0.4146207273,
0.0362452455,
0.8545145392,
-0.2469623536,
0.5983424187,
0.2157811522,
-0.1549308151,
-0.522171855,
-1.0499459505,
-1.1440340281,
-0.2327868044,
-0.4695494473,
-0.4017108083,
0.1353131682,
1.0388188362,
1.0131716728,
-0.5430983305,
0.2257507294,
0.1279029399,
0.4922032058,
-0.0037954699,
-0.3244902492,
0.1743762195,
-0.100453116,
-0.5869570374,
0.56674546,
-0.0047375043,
0.0888143852,
-0.3915858865,
-0.1442185342,
-0.4666689932,
0.6425945759,
0.767582953,
0.4369868636,
-0.7144531012,
-0.5014224648,
-0.273825109,
-0.1937193274,
-0.1632234901,
0.7500406504,
-0.9329600334,
0.0841322839,
0.4046280682,
0.5991974473,
0.4686013162,
0.0438407622,
0.2112249434,
-0.8465760946,
0.220303461,
0.0999155194,
0.0816351324,
0.4033380151,
-0.6731770635,
0.2831092477,
0.4884908795,
-0.474034667,
-0.8544974327,
0.201589644,
-0.9176445603,
-0.4376085997,
1.2300517559,
0.1464322805,
-0.5355448127,
-0.4114297926,
-0.2563402653,
0.3432005346,
-0.6422653794,
0.7687988281,
0.5840482116,
0.1174611822,
-0.2692900896,
-0.8222576976,
0.4130678177,
-0.1551619917,
-1.1554080248,
-0.2146184891,
0.5344398618,
0.6366449594,
0.2273921669,
0.6341293454,
0.1628026068,
0.4320989847,
0.0943565071,
0.3357698619,
-0.3683858216,
-0.4480980337,
0.0583899654,
0.0941346586,
-0.2005247623,
-0.0914969146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19260v1
|
Aspect and Opinion Term Extraction Using Graph Attention Network
| 2024-04-30T04:53:59 | 2024-04-30T04:53:59 |
Abir Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work we investigate the capability of Graph Attention Network for
extracting aspect and opinion terms. Aspect and opinion term extraction is
posed as a token-level classification task akin to named entity recognition. We
use the dependency tree of the input query as additional feature in a Graph
Attention Network along with the token and part-of-speech features. We show
that the dependency structure is a powerful feature that in the presence of a
CRF layer substantially improves the performance and generates the best result
on the commonly used datasets from SemEval 2014, 2015 and 2016. We experiment
with additional layers like BiLSTM and Transformer in addition to the CRF
layer. We also show that our approach works well in the presence of multiple
aspects or sentiments in the same query and it is not necessary to modify the
dependency tree based on a single aspect as was the original application for
sentiment classification.
|
[
-0.7822737098,
-0.9881204367,
0.4319613874,
0.2579562664,
-0.3452848494,
0.1849183589,
0.0515791476,
-0.5520003438,
0.7148700953,
0.7781555057,
-0.3246991634,
-0.5796759129,
-0.7159602046,
-0.0299794376,
-0.2939483821,
1.0799907446,
-0.0104927616,
0.1108380258,
-0.2407684922,
-0.4492003322,
-0.2696511149,
-0.8344507217,
-0.9688463807,
-0.3881537616,
0.8300319314,
0.1842364222,
0.2960095406,
0.4572532773,
0.5770655274,
0.2945006788,
-0.346108526,
0.10280779,
-0.1875908226,
0.2873580456,
-0.3740496039,
-0.1303445995,
-0.6435545087,
0.0660966709,
0.5685147643,
0.6486509442,
0.2450314015,
0.1367272735,
0.3146737516,
0.8713199496,
-0.2931854129,
0.6505920291,
-0.5121350288,
0.2095902264,
-0.1405579299,
-0.2466965318,
-0.2910069525,
-0.1744446903,
0.3650917113,
-0.038828142,
0.4046384692,
0.2345803231,
1.0312819481,
-0.1105163693,
-0.4975673854,
-0.0207378995,
-0.6701757908,
0.393822819,
-0.5614796877,
0.5952120423,
0.0580600053,
-0.0187707171,
-0.0091734715,
-0.9120228291,
-0.5064048171,
0.1990014911,
-0.1816786528,
0.2705119848,
-0.114133805,
0.4416912794,
0.0144151961,
0.8190582395,
-0.1483293772,
-0.1352698654,
-0.152372092,
-0.4327737391,
0.2721376419,
0.116469793,
-0.041034501,
-1.0455391407,
-0.2709653676,
0.0292714406,
-0.5497161746,
0.4552609026,
0.3160360157,
0.5763453245,
0.2803224027,
0.5990712047,
-0.3441239595,
0.5115755796,
0.1154366955,
0.0168582257,
0.5081595182,
-0.3465406597,
-0.3310929835,
0.0521545224,
0.9441920519,
0.1115416065,
-0.3220308423,
-0.1729305983,
-0.1830004156,
-0.15790537,
0.3002551496,
-0.7512224913,
-0.2700843513,
0.3938454092,
-0.4824030995,
-0.4374860823,
0.2798867524,
-0.8675730824,
-0.4552328587,
-0.4197879434,
0.0360306539,
-0.2805112898,
-0.4837859571,
-0.372423768,
-0.1149385944,
0.1111340225,
0.179178372,
-0.4067044556,
0.2713478208,
1.0201274157,
0.8228602409,
-0.3217457235,
0.1260095835,
-0.5962908864,
-0.2275000215,
-0.0325880051,
0.9624744654,
-0.7080478668,
-0.2426761091,
-0.1767176837,
0.4737053812,
-0.0959970206,
-0.4214681685,
0.368834734,
-0.7896922231,
0.3613321483,
-0.1502764523,
-0.5297141671,
-0.7005781531,
0.5947355032,
-0.8710423112,
1.1405063868,
0.3070539534,
-1.0309904814,
0.2818769813,
-0.8875548244,
-0.650339365,
0.1573203206,
-0.246352464,
-0.4340598285,
-0.0777724162,
0.3702230155,
0.3725299239,
0.0193465166,
-0.1039205045,
-0.4807272553,
0.3120092154,
0.237309128,
-0.1354324818,
0.7021217942,
-0.0010937382,
-0.3463678956,
0.3400268555,
-0.5042792559,
0.116856046,
-0.0997840017,
-0.3446296751,
-0.3644186258,
-0.0015551306,
0.1792871803,
0.32454741,
0.1999869943,
-0.7432428002,
-0.1074792743,
-0.7013247013,
0.7397302985,
0.6232931614,
0.7228732705,
0.4166791737,
0.4576932788,
0.6256961226,
0.5507432818,
0.1895593256,
0.1300214529,
-0.3476178944,
-1.0087981224,
0.0347605236,
0.6927404404,
0.4468235672,
-0.9027340412,
0.4721800089,
-0.246424824,
-0.158446908,
-0.4400343001,
0.1313564777,
0.3665015399,
0.7220215797,
0.1161762252,
-0.7367091775,
-0.482956022,
-0.998501718,
-0.0633339062,
-0.5341951251,
0.3928174078,
0.8008516431,
0.1476576328,
0.2585318089,
1.1202170849,
-0.5783221722,
-0.3253719211,
-0.4593317807,
0.1250091493,
0.1941180974,
0.0785576254,
0.4364565611,
-1.0177483559,
-0.1327683926,
0.1891839504,
-0.5693007112,
0.1401625276,
0.362977922,
-0.3071168363,
0.1270152032,
0.1578341424,
-0.4770737588,
0.2452559471,
0.2191516161,
-0.291551888,
0.1282785386,
0.3220267594,
0.1769723445,
-1.2645173073,
-0.0774021819,
0.237945348,
-0.7624526024,
-0.4022519588,
0.0495039932,
-0.1018401682,
-0.177813381,
-0.6272509694,
0.1879178882,
-0.3210326433,
-0.2655466199,
-0.4040601254,
0.428560704,
0.546805799,
0.733956933,
0.0837559476,
0.3862878978,
0.4167539775,
-0.4332633317,
0.4824062884,
0.1717919856,
-0.0700050667,
0.4329276085,
-0.5321139097,
0.6325190067,
-0.1426902413,
0.0919824019,
-0.8348340988,
-0.099440068,
0.6605366468,
-0.327164501,
0.4574570954,
-0.2837161422,
-0.3166066706,
-0.5300858021,
-0.2385480106,
-0.0102279186,
-0.0678147748,
-0.2787653506,
0.7880145907,
0.7959576249,
-0.2444196641,
-0.4928736985,
-0.2898448706,
0.21802935,
-0.2957760394,
-0.2752967179,
0.2359628081,
0.5512708426,
0.0961565524,
0.4387415349,
-0.1132381782,
-0.0448432155,
0.000223758,
0.5638760924,
0.1763378978,
-0.3821285963,
0.1090431437,
-0.0147035932,
-0.0568523668,
0.0504251271,
-0.2763983905,
0.715634644,
-0.2891533077,
-0.0185749866,
-0.3139944971,
0.4735535383,
0.4647347331,
-0.5413590074,
0.4521022439,
0.3874280751,
-0.3364628851,
-0.0254335813,
-0.358926028,
-0.0051452718,
-0.3810688853,
0.8155223131,
-0.3043017685,
-1.1036863327,
0.5624002218,
-0.1261341721,
-0.0233657416,
0.6870318055,
0.2557158172,
0.0457100384,
1.0998772383,
0.6250388622,
-0.4549177885,
0.8766809702,
-0.3015929759,
0.3859523833,
-1.2316513062,
-0.2151716352,
-0.4870647192,
-0.4279531538,
-0.3875392079,
0.0284633767,
0.2679384947,
0.3520003557,
-0.0289973263,
0.4652323127,
-0.7483329773,
0.0705468953,
0.2833619416,
0.5283476114,
0.0901730359,
0.1732653081,
0.2088869214,
0.150008291,
-0.3035606444,
-0.4104648829,
0.672262013,
0.4858764112,
0.1083688661,
-0.1876881123,
0.6352921128,
0.274194777,
0.3667165339,
-1.2537705898,
0.5936390162,
-0.1435682327,
-0.4436808527,
-0.3911291063,
-0.572939992,
-0.7935380936,
0.2754482627,
0.0709932894,
-0.8741396666,
0.3664965034,
-0.0089872815,
-0.1957767457,
0.1419923007,
-0.6133821607,
0.7641995549,
0.1101405546,
0.0316777155,
-0.1082250997,
-0.6408120394,
0.0389968976,
0.2166877985,
-0.0471541993,
-0.1430090517,
0.225308612,
1.1609231234,
-0.386785686,
0.7830334306,
-0.3263530433,
0.3257905245,
0.5415455103,
-0.1331439316,
0.3925438523,
0.2857217491,
-0.1516242474,
0.4983884692,
-0.2553521097,
0.0451987423,
-0.7738426328,
0.654294312,
-0.6915792823,
-0.8741864562,
-0.1304243952,
-0.2308907658,
-0.3739521503,
0.4702323079,
0.0782734454,
0.8363448977,
-0.1161164194,
0.0701722577,
0.2278901935,
0.2915766537,
0.6875757575,
0.0438785404,
-0.4944167435,
-0.8233054876,
0.9485754371,
0.3065514266,
0.0826790407,
0.3936474621,
0.1352324933,
-0.2946700454,
-0.5364170074,
-0.5897355676,
0.0123001998,
-0.8262110949,
-0.5462617278,
-1.0876287222,
-0.6999880075,
-0.601249218,
0.6644715667,
-0.3177110255,
-0.6875696182,
-0.1569204181,
-0.3928989172,
0.5821325779,
0.8439663053,
0.5458623171,
0.2711215019,
-0.797211647,
-0.0547542907,
0.1815567464,
0.2420448065,
0.1350265592,
-0.2314239144,
-0.2723250091,
-0.2338565439,
-0.7222531438,
-0.9616426229,
0.1547999978,
0.1681208163,
0.4155809879,
0.5445890427,
-0.0135713229,
0.4670628011,
-0.1552612484,
0.9353595972,
0.1914135963,
-0.9917149544,
0.556111455,
0.109753035,
0.0017572597,
0.5637002587,
0.0499936454,
-0.449231863,
-0.6104385257,
-0.7843894362,
-0.9638360143,
0.959865272,
0.2089278251,
-0.0042991447,
-0.1303198189,
0.6621958017,
-0.0419734158,
0.4623554349,
-0.4068595469,
-0.4787750244,
-0.4323557019,
-0.2145273685,
0.2989889383,
-0.2195865661,
-0.0027771457,
-0.2426607609,
0.5737892389,
-0.0415283367,
0.3096292913,
0.406373769,
0.1934688091,
0.0696556345,
0.2950398326,
-0.0965160802,
0.4836675227,
0.0464384295,
0.4978027046,
0.0577408634,
-0.6417254806,
-0.1755658984,
0.0825138465,
-0.1511165947,
0.0299291629,
0.3519426882,
1.053309679,
-0.0938447341,
0.3135275543,
0.5212047696,
-0.0206407029,
-0.0103057753,
-0.0944103673,
0.03834581,
0.1808909327,
0.3756346107,
0.0203709695,
0.2562808692,
0.519271791,
-0.4333933592,
0.113864705,
0.3796312511,
-1.1770573854,
-0.3994556069,
0.2723153532,
0.1396291256,
-0.6017048359,
0.3994442523,
-0.2485389858,
-1.0894789696,
0.7749749422,
0.3318760693,
1.1004257202,
-0.0329186246,
0.3957860172,
0.1190922856,
-0.1600538939,
0.3379119933,
0.322694242,
0.0358122364,
-0.7451773882,
-0.3376275897,
-0.6978115439,
-0.2105749249,
0.194537729,
-0.7164148688,
0.1559198201,
-0.6301627755,
-0.6015494466,
0.465541929,
-0.0436941646,
-0.6785526276,
0.2704142034,
-0.1176279932,
0.3502272069,
-0.4872855842,
0.6542031169,
1.0812140703,
-0.5303395391,
-1.1686397791,
-0.0753339604,
-0.2506707609,
-0.500688076,
0.5944732428,
0.3368211389,
-0.2247005105,
-0.0239385199,
-0.2826367319,
-0.6388165951,
0.8573253155,
-0.0062694978,
-0.2521715164,
-0.0346945152,
0.109516792,
0.5013579726,
-0.8003460765,
0.0994717106,
0.5037459731,
0.2446591407,
0.0951069742,
-0.6053911448,
0.1586627215,
-0.2946959734,
0.0381194279,
0.5262747407,
-0.7112593055,
0.6774476171,
0.3353549242,
-0.3744962215,
-0.6320569515,
1.005521059,
-0.3135617375,
0.3993345797,
1.0560731888,
0.3617148697,
0.6340733171,
-0.0641605109,
0.7899736762,
-0.5110815763,
0.7293550372,
1.0324200392,
-0.1833410114,
0.8409950137,
0.4515454471,
-0.1867080778,
0.568492353,
1.0064370632,
0.2763599753,
0.6351743937,
-0.1219217032,
-0.1552622616,
-0.2834945619,
-0.4730575383,
-0.217045784,
0.3532913327,
0.3529124856,
-0.6702359915,
-0.0769457817,
0.2942653894,
0.1263557374,
-0.5515632629,
-0.4597984254,
1.1140390635,
0.3878861964,
-0.5393716097,
-0.2818047702,
-0.2510008216,
0.0422266088,
-0.026350826,
-0.1591877192,
-0.0649346858,
0.0702608004,
-0.4751509726,
-0.9555129409,
0.2456362247,
-0.3099424839,
-0.4249803126,
0.1251490563,
0.7636205554,
-0.2605604529,
-0.5892525315,
0.355376482,
0.4302845299,
0.116239436,
-0.2079614699,
-0.7089295387,
-0.3503694832,
0.0406885445,
-0.7520442009,
0.0380997024,
0.7224872708,
0.0225865617,
0.1021530926,
0.3622497916,
0.3098136485,
-0.3184400797,
0.3270714581,
1.1466636658,
-0.6571714878,
-0.7160022855,
-0.8385429382,
0.0403954946,
-0.6000659466,
-0.3739952147,
0.6405450106,
0.5818428397,
0.477658838,
0.4891898334,
0.759486258,
-0.2639445066,
0.5090189576,
-0.355764389,
0.5593607426,
-0.4179623723,
0.1465461999,
-0.4451541901,
-1.2245320082,
-0.1806861609,
0.0747827888,
-0.4985338748,
0.0341920517,
1.1534249783,
0.6392039657,
0.0266490504,
0.5566248894,
-0.1543933451,
0.1401015371,
0.592199266,
0.1885341704,
0.5131385326,
-0.2842260003,
0.3729435205,
-0.4421567619,
-0.2004531324,
0.0098702908,
-0.6971703768,
-0.8161942363,
-0.594376266,
-0.6485130787,
-0.8191825151,
-0.3650580645,
0.7954827547,
0.6808523536,
-1.0474549532,
0.4355802238,
-0.1063519046,
0.3507326245,
-0.1877422035,
-0.3610569239,
0.9454120994,
-0.3711051345,
-0.6548166275,
0.068496041,
0.5732886195,
-0.2570216358,
-0.4772795141,
0.3898853958,
0.0953580067,
-0.1664034873,
0.6777282357,
-0.0194815472,
-0.5849019885,
-1.015380621,
-0.0016713325,
-0.1134695262,
0.467050463,
1.1293329,
-0.5685192347,
0.3490339816,
0.6885168552,
0.6114765406,
0.6153934598,
0.274082005,
0.2402845919,
-0.6672925949,
-0.0532508381,
0.2581197619,
0.5752036572,
0.4706680775,
-0.7607506514,
0.3646802902,
0.4097452462,
-0.503719151,
-0.3515529633,
0.2383110076,
-1.269382,
0.0702379793,
1.13507092,
-0.3618193269,
-0.6670038104,
-0.4957637489,
-0.3409242034,
0.4229298234,
-0.6299146414,
0.6280453205,
0.8321073651,
-0.6370752454,
-0.3175742328,
-0.2365475148,
0.103956528,
0.1962649673,
-0.7707403302,
0.0562452376,
0.2089635432,
0.2245325893,
0.4871551394,
0.5006293058,
-0.4877477586,
-0.3575540483,
-0.2051984668,
0.075031586,
-0.2208263725,
-0.3287973106,
-0.1523723006,
0.7228947282,
0.0549127795,
-0.3963199854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19254v1
|
Suvach -- Generated Hindi QA benchmark
| 2024-04-30T04:19:17 | 2024-04-30T04:19:17 |
Vaishak Narayanan, Prabin Raj KP, Saifudheen Nouphal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Current evaluation benchmarks for question answering (QA) in Indic languages
often rely on machine translation of existing English datasets. This approach
suffers from bias and inaccuracies inherent in machine translation, leading to
datasets that may not reflect the true capabilities of EQA models for Indic
languages. This paper proposes a new benchmark specifically designed for
evaluating Hindi EQA models and discusses the methodology to do the same for
any task. This method leverages large language models (LLMs) to generate a
high-quality dataset in an extractive setting, ensuring its relevance for the
target language. We believe this new resource will foster advancements in Hindi
NLP research by providing a more accurate and reliable evaluation tool.
|
[
-0.3570135236,
-0.5034534931,
0.3226219714,
0.3115541637,
-0.3471556306,
0.3511461616,
0.1576206386,
-0.4170428216,
-0.0560714975,
0.1943365335,
-0.4546518326,
-0.4324764609,
-0.3969805837,
0.4971196055,
-0.7542074323,
0.453222841,
-0.1131429821,
0.2676886916,
-0.3270029128,
-0.3921518922,
-0.5923322439,
-0.2539310455,
-0.6311219335,
-0.2452954352,
0.1367797852,
0.405097574,
0.543882668,
0.3354288638,
0.5002006292,
0.2093193084,
-0.0186648946,
0.2783245742,
-0.258705616,
0.2603432238,
0.0386984162,
-0.5400387049,
-0.0757493973,
0.0134614836,
0.7353817821,
0.4068786204,
-0.6182800531,
0.6095286012,
-0.3529847562,
0.5160390735,
-0.6577202678,
0.085135363,
-0.641931057,
0.0145031186,
-0.0260435753,
-0.0343760997,
-0.287032783,
-0.9649947882,
-0.2468709499,
-0.4197624326,
-0.1526683569,
0.2768315375,
1.1211684942,
0.4309825003,
-0.3141331673,
-0.1564936638,
-0.7166157961,
0.7520615458,
-0.8704921603,
0.6411370039,
0.0781582147,
0.9012956619,
0.0786374584,
-0.6346219778,
-0.8064545393,
-0.1310344934,
0.2240634412,
0.0908338279,
-0.2053763866,
-0.3885825574,
0.0250673536,
0.5733631849,
-0.5135477781,
0.0530879088,
-0.3475128114,
0.1820780933,
0.5752763748,
0.2583110332,
0.572201848,
-0.3140029013,
-0.3618910909,
-0.3245202005,
-1.0097587109,
0.0498053171,
0.2932246923,
0.0487556346,
0.0729429573,
0.9596450925,
-0.4239871502,
0.5821731687,
0.0935601816,
-0.1600770354,
0.3164387941,
-0.3569908738,
-0.3919587433,
0.0535992384,
0.5199257135,
0.3243077397,
0.2070356309,
-0.3651407361,
-0.1841070652,
-0.2309305668,
0.188668102,
-0.7058796287,
0.0894084871,
0.2290875018,
-0.136352092,
-0.0489500239,
-0.1479094326,
-1.0192186832,
-0.2794762254,
-0.2530614734,
0.1935930997,
-0.2622348368,
-0.2358673513,
-0.1052648202,
0.2074327171,
1.2849997282,
0.1301415712,
-0.5035843849,
0.4778220654,
0.4575763643,
0.5177232027,
-0.4105064273,
-0.1761395037,
-0.7720271349,
-0.0471242368,
-0.6499438286,
1.1308701038,
-0.754578948,
-0.3310415149,
0.0351292603,
-0.2661371529,
0.0503252819,
-0.9078277349,
0.744030118,
-0.824238658,
-0.0067464896,
-0.4328621924,
-0.4491430819,
-0.1351091564,
0.2553032041,
-0.5115041733,
1.3590180874,
0.3330955803,
-0.3414657712,
0.5584863424,
-0.2977740169,
-0.1887056082,
0.2296723872,
-0.3898519874,
-0.3245290816,
-0.1333493441,
0.7338186502,
0.0818867683,
-1.0625549555,
0.3816029131,
0.0248081069,
-0.2262240946,
0.2328526527,
-0.204476878,
0.5484326482,
0.4915546477,
-0.0415523164,
0.0447535701,
-0.8556415439,
0.6024158597,
0.1904555261,
-0.2845193744,
-0.0102097904,
-0.3387774527,
-0.136318475,
0.4126633704,
0.0565865226,
-0.7194013596,
-0.1710678786,
-0.6393769383,
-0.0037796213,
0.7410761714,
0.1472734064,
0.0901827663,
-0.2531536222,
1.0438020229,
-0.1332606375,
-0.0523066446,
0.3433144093,
-0.4847150743,
-0.6332112551,
-0.1263465583,
0.5546743274,
0.5689283609,
-0.6399117708,
0.0118573662,
-0.2819684148,
-0.7637833953,
-0.8917791247,
0.3106792867,
0.6249305606,
0.2628210485,
0.3011487126,
-0.3328539431,
-0.4089612067,
-0.9609335065,
-0.4362584949,
-0.2151240557,
-0.1099178791,
0.2834693789,
0.2205965221,
0.1321870089,
0.7572025061,
-0.518102169,
0.072931841,
-0.4010328352,
0.1552940309,
-0.0567270517,
0.2177410573,
0.3867658973,
-0.8310858011,
-0.5397133231,
-0.2528343797,
-0.7826324701,
-0.4549176693,
0.1484680027,
-0.2894451022,
-0.185021162,
0.5275166631,
-0.6719304323,
0.3057284057,
0.4350423813,
-0.1046846509,
0.667937398,
0.1487507075,
0.4805827141,
-1.3423793316,
0.1310308874,
0.0805447474,
-0.0451025143,
-0.3273550868,
0.4039540291,
-0.0272579677,
-0.2611923218,
-0.5636249781,
0.7151754498,
-0.4198996425,
-0.445951134,
-0.0419961959,
0.2949434221,
-0.0113848774,
0.2597746551,
-0.3721316457,
1.3557057381,
0.2899359167,
-0.3531976342,
0.3433404565,
0.6685798764,
-0.4575853348,
0.6999784112,
-1.0650103092,
0.216882661,
-0.0167691763,
-0.182072252,
-1.0233441591,
-0.1962023675,
0.1202461347,
-0.5252529979,
0.2706308663,
0.1354445964,
-0.8430575132,
-0.1671641171,
-0.0188823026,
0.6403918266,
0.7722665668,
-0.6055642962,
0.7133593559,
0.6298998594,
-0.3326393664,
-0.4777755737,
-0.485943377,
0.1201599687,
-0.2681774199,
-0.3085257411,
0.0347823128,
-0.0021977923,
-0.3579546809,
-0.2889942527,
-0.1996290535,
-0.3408293724,
-0.2334571332,
0.1469864398,
0.0234210026,
-0.2448481619,
0.0941801295,
0.1687780023,
0.0979740173,
0.2346119434,
0.3090751171,
0.6103976965,
-0.2268538922,
-0.5107748508,
-0.3533299863,
0.4148040712,
0.5259785652,
-0.6267960072,
0.4963382781,
0.4466580749,
-0.3596580625,
-0.062632516,
-0.7327378988,
0.1772292852,
-0.4424686432,
0.3087377548,
-0.5374177098,
-0.2663922906,
0.5409802198,
-0.2528309822,
-0.0782301202,
0.7360557318,
0.6462972164,
0.3510197401,
1.0999554396,
0.5057355762,
-0.0515419617,
-0.1520930529,
0.0828251094,
0.4436240792,
-1.0751216412,
-0.3731819093,
-0.8560708165,
0.2055209577,
-0.5261746049,
-0.4220537245,
0.3839590251,
0.0093600629,
-0.2126703262,
0.3284959495,
-0.6562140584,
0.333178997,
0.4007411003,
-0.2254062593,
0.371265173,
-0.2167065442,
-0.2196815014,
0.0751546249,
-0.5427494049,
-0.5569730997,
1.193770647,
-0.0245736819,
0.7747935057,
0.3418622613,
0.4432313442,
0.2567277849,
0.4611735344,
-0.2321606576,
0.6927657127,
0.2465726882,
-0.5180559158,
-0.2514646649,
-0.2588207722,
-0.7665031552,
0.2010244429,
-0.044390358,
-0.7096956968,
0.0862989873,
-0.3484804034,
-0.1855543405,
0.1310278773,
-0.7634031177,
0.6303838491,
-0.1021808162,
-0.1707286388,
-0.005617396,
-0.3466846645,
0.4547552168,
-0.0481956154,
-0.2016501725,
-0.4672857225,
-0.0915486366,
0.8466790318,
-0.2272846252,
0.3314890563,
-0.0383573771,
-0.0191970151,
0.5181339979,
-0.0036346074,
0.3755988479,
0.2985298634,
-0.3538679779,
-0.1982379258,
0.3320860863,
-0.6228452325,
-0.458971113,
0.695538044,
-0.9165776372,
-0.5507916212,
-0.4827125967,
-0.6015869975,
-0.6007539034,
-0.0111398716,
-0.1899529696,
0.3148869574,
-0.1399998069,
0.0041727754,
0.4469517767,
-0.4350040853,
-0.0147726443,
0.5319864154,
-0.2654304206,
-0.1888352334,
0.653049767,
-0.1460284442,
0.1920362562,
0.312469244,
-0.1119304672,
-0.6774970293,
-0.6851342916,
-0.8473529816,
0.0928307474,
-1.0953919888,
-0.3764026165,
-0.5251972079,
-0.4834601879,
-0.3482865691,
0.1806949675,
-0.4279845655,
-0.1871553212,
0.2298697531,
-0.1459131837,
0.3730964065,
0.8153053522,
0.3823977411,
-0.1242037266,
-0.7342044115,
0.5321754217,
0.5743371248,
0.3995718658,
0.0570151918,
-0.630456388,
0.0667858794,
-0.1485318393,
-0.3102709949,
-0.8375095129,
0.4912725389,
0.2348591387,
0.7679060698,
-0.2241549939,
-0.0218024533,
0.6223789454,
-0.3404560685,
0.914440155,
-0.0188832171,
-0.7706514597,
0.473500073,
-0.09647955,
0.704952836,
0.8224070668,
0.4217237532,
-0.2910567224,
-0.4573565423,
-0.2750245035,
-0.857708931,
0.0225966536,
0.3912349343,
-0.0001345657,
-0.2357819527,
0.6136612892,
0.3527765274,
0.4304554462,
-0.4637002051,
-0.1769120991,
0.0448317528,
-0.2640721202,
0.039729584,
-0.2266560048,
0.1037477702,
-0.3924755752,
0.5760324597,
-0.0905107856,
0.3122474253,
0.2272482365,
-0.1739404202,
-0.2221946269,
0.4690042436,
0.2396705598,
1.1068456173,
-0.0757072344,
-0.2114800513,
0.5654062629,
-0.3442753851,
0.4349151254,
0.351293385,
-0.3027939796,
-0.1295160949,
-0.1331727505,
0.2424775362,
0.0209299438,
-1.1510225534,
0.2736421227,
-0.2956722379,
0.1525633633,
-0.4271290898,
-0.0587107465,
0.0419253893,
0.0836648196,
0.6802450418,
-0.2743825614,
0.1807799488,
-0.3993974328,
0.289422214,
0.2979575992,
-0.3462238908,
-0.1534763873,
0.900949955,
0.0593224168,
-0.2040736228,
0.7059977651,
-0.2932066321,
-0.376442045,
0.6543853283,
0.3469609618,
0.9977253079,
-0.2733685374,
0.2949087918,
0.6334921122,
0.2896182537,
0.245721817,
0.5272842646,
0.2276453525,
-0.3485347629,
-0.6262860298,
-0.9957597852,
-0.6068428159,
0.0458565131,
-0.6618385315,
0.0725848898,
-0.1915431917,
0.2500178814,
-0.0369783118,
0.0494613573,
-0.8977757692,
0.5760761499,
-0.0996610373,
0.8942313194,
-0.7504867315,
0.7090426087,
0.6126288176,
-0.6491102576,
-1.1193364859,
0.0727581009,
-0.2833380401,
-0.926727891,
0.7093702555,
-0.0796228573,
-0.2710025311,
0.0518367887,
-0.4883275926,
-1.1191989183,
1.1050595045,
0.3222948909,
-0.143302992,
0.0680281296,
0.370845139,
0.7214223742,
-0.4863983095,
0.2804550529,
0.5555496216,
0.3676463962,
0.0860874504,
-0.7719573975,
0.3145956993,
-0.5682496428,
0.0799342394,
0.159545511,
-0.6030424833,
0.6301503778,
-0.1217755526,
-0.4260976315,
0.4399103522,
0.7913479805,
0.2714762092,
0.1281289607,
0.2708705366,
0.744243741,
0.4925671518,
-0.1630384624,
1.2814134359,
-0.3396374583,
-0.0869399086,
1.1941789389,
-0.6482451558,
1.0031754971,
0.6014527678,
-0.5641111135,
0.3042343259,
0.6152381897,
-0.1333368719,
0.4433756471,
0.4399402142,
0.0338742211,
-0.2065663785,
-0.3756402433,
-0.4112547338,
0.6739867926,
-0.0875337049,
0.0154059622,
-0.417044878,
-0.2676127553,
-0.3717258573,
0.3652775288,
-0.1696101874,
0.8299298286,
0.0037410278,
-0.9719803929,
0.6842509508,
0.0452685654,
0.1357178092,
-0.435498327,
-0.3314335644,
-0.2673299313,
-0.2114441097,
0.0898748785,
-0.726545155,
0.4250100553,
0.1467456371,
0.2878054678,
0.2234803438,
0.46170789,
-0.2702904344,
-0.6444737315,
0.0892530829,
0.9246580005,
0.2431033552,
0.1356339753,
-0.7121118307,
-0.1143271923,
-0.2571280897,
-0.1361333877,
0.3778115213,
0.0951900035,
0.0539524928,
0.9815568924,
0.4747853279,
0.0303641055,
0.3929724097,
0.1788365841,
0.845733285,
-0.5607581139,
-0.1608097255,
-0.3480082154,
0.1511384696,
-0.1934273839,
-0.6644608378,
0.9308042526,
0.719448626,
0.792470336,
0.0935381651,
0.5981501937,
-0.1233567223,
0.7202487588,
-0.4805472493,
0.5467049479,
-0.5959608555,
0.4112738669,
-0.0916546136,
-1.0149683952,
-0.0070311455,
0.0709596425,
-0.3008963466,
0.3002702594,
0.6540030241,
0.8267022967,
0.1152169704,
0.0316471159,
0.3256760538,
0.0321376733,
0.2405201495,
0.4963375032,
0.8841020465,
-0.7496487498,
0.7103865743,
-0.148916766,
0.2273794115,
0.1200437918,
-0.6436077952,
-0.7055390477,
-0.7577881813,
-0.2658110559,
-0.2092097998,
0.1453566849,
0.7677417994,
0.53262043,
-0.9750522375,
-0.1274073869,
0.0160886161,
0.0935005024,
-0.3921224177,
-0.2301847041,
0.6117938757,
-0.1889040023,
-0.7673594356,
0.2466315329,
0.1728385538,
-0.1129188761,
-0.3881751895,
-0.0009209454,
-0.6948167682,
0.349321425,
0.3142399788,
0.4343147278,
-0.7395402789,
-0.2755314112,
0.199822396,
-0.0969462246,
0.4363391995,
0.4155932963,
-0.7291572094,
0.4816285074,
0.2922776341,
0.9952081442,
0.3441973329,
0.2234899253,
0.8553979993,
-0.6039897203,
-0.1986480802,
0.3659867644,
0.0828065425,
0.6177333593,
-0.1787240505,
0.6339244843,
-0.3645171225,
-0.5320388675,
-0.9914140701,
0.0609021075,
-0.795745194,
0.0740494505,
1.184553504,
-0.0604607463,
-0.3815143704,
-0.0529213138,
-0.1465561092,
0.3173816502,
-0.2222406119,
0.9470983744,
0.5216614604,
0.0682625771,
-0.3630978465,
-0.7072587609,
0.488501966,
0.579402566,
-1.2465445995,
-0.1211413369,
0.1159000173,
0.2047208846,
-0.1436630785,
0.3950919509,
-0.4138541222,
0.5292788744,
0.0655938536,
0.1235464811,
0.2482642829,
-0.1099174023,
-0.1215895414,
0.2810531557,
0.5247378349,
-0.0086759049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19252v1
|
Exploiting Hatred by Targets for Hate Speech Detection on Vietnamese Social Media Texts
| 2024-04-30T04:16:55 | 2024-04-30T04:16:55 |
Cuong Nhat Vo, Khanh Bao Huynh, Son T. Luu, Trong-Hop Do
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growth of social networks makes toxic content spread rapidly. Hate speech
detection is a task to help decrease the number of harmful comments. With the
diversity in the hate speech created by users, it is necessary to interpret the
hate speech besides detecting it. Hence, we propose a methodology to construct
a system for targeted hate speech detection from online streaming texts from
social media. We first introduce the ViTHSD - a targeted hate speech detection
dataset for Vietnamese Social Media Texts. The dataset contains 10K comments,
each comment is labeled to specific targets with three levels: clean,
offensive, and hate. There are 5 targets in the dataset, and each target is
labeled with the corresponding level manually by humans with strict annotation
guidelines. The inter-annotator agreement obtained from the dataset is 0.45 by
Cohen's Kappa index, which is indicated as a moderate level. Then, we construct
a baseline for this task by combining the Bi-GRU-LSTM-CNN with the pre-trained
language model to leverage the power of text representation of BERTology.
Finally, we suggest a methodology to integrate the baseline model for targeted
hate speech detection into the online streaming system for practical
application in preventing hateful and offensive content on social media.
|
[
-0.337138921,
-0.9281916022,
0.212387532,
0.0304321777,
-0.62934798,
-0.003199996,
-0.3061957955,
-0.441765219,
0.4099134505,
0.7991011143,
-0.4260644019,
-0.57830441,
-0.9304290414,
-0.0340664983,
-0.5123394728,
1.237236619,
0.3491477072,
-0.1522857845,
0.4384701848,
-0.2250918001,
-0.1972659081,
-0.4813275337,
-0.4944823086,
0.0582546927,
0.9645450115,
0.4279842973,
0.3080772758,
0.5093764067,
0.567697227,
0.2626050711,
-0.1479376704,
0.1639371812,
-0.8842343688,
0.3276380301,
-0.226159811,
-0.20437783,
-0.0160912164,
-0.0917596072,
0.5070573688,
-0.3281321526,
0.3548870981,
0.2615027428,
0.1317893565,
0.2090033591,
-0.4848791063,
-0.1778092831,
-0.9175221324,
-0.0285826158,
-0.3860265613,
-0.2214575261,
-0.2188935131,
-0.4971479177,
0.0938680023,
-0.2178322971,
0.1311385185,
-0.4821485281,
0.6166331172,
0.2601914108,
-0.303088963,
-0.2574655116,
-0.8830194473,
0.7245991826,
-0.6409538984,
0.2435483932,
0.2682715058,
0.4638518691,
0.3212732971,
-0.1970499605,
-0.6080790162,
-0.2699724436,
0.1048910767,
-0.0350977555,
-0.4524645209,
0.0075980751,
0.1741055995,
0.0957069546,
-0.6332730651,
0.2751325965,
-0.6090028882,
-0.2644263506,
0.9126654863,
-0.271833688,
0.3334190249,
-0.4906976819,
-0.537257731,
0.2588371933,
-0.1815894246,
-0.5621644258,
0.5780154467,
0.8211539984,
-0.055129353,
0.7189747691,
-0.1476731449,
0.3865475655,
-0.167411834,
-0.2150692195,
0.3489335179,
0.0522026122,
-0.0452871546,
0.2518422008,
0.6842936277,
0.7418482304,
0.7684978843,
0.0814751536,
-0.0773876235,
0.6353848577,
0.5054638982,
-0.5741890073,
0.0185859911,
-0.0453168042,
-0.3941862583,
-0.6399966478,
-0.2339388281,
-0.8737356663,
-0.8989596367,
-0.1500327736,
0.4777853489,
-0.4759886563,
-0.5447815657,
-0.4814553857,
-0.4242008626,
0.0326854512,
0.0781262144,
-0.382915467,
0.1494474858,
0.5689759851,
0.9277681708,
-0.420927912,
-0.0523347035,
-0.884726882,
0.2198642194,
0.2227840275,
0.7347922921,
-0.5538442135,
-0.2062149495,
0.4730613232,
-0.3366512656,
0.4397480786,
-0.6395887136,
0.9388436079,
-0.5652769804,
-0.1728862077,
0.0606542528,
-0.6826028824,
-0.1525726318,
0.2360978276,
-0.4753018916,
0.9481117725,
0.1714502424,
-0.9499287009,
0.3079075217,
-0.5307203531,
-0.4096812308,
0.362963587,
0.1400431544,
-0.5594830513,
-0.0923646539,
-0.03139228,
0.623524785,
0.0882341489,
0.011974521,
-0.5015439987,
-0.2600482106,
-0.0195503328,
-0.2376292199,
0.9017876983,
0.6195096374,
-0.54881078,
0.4003223181,
-0.5562670827,
-0.3042830229,
0.265883714,
-0.2094462216,
-0.6896029711,
0.0349610522,
0.6331955791,
0.3291448653,
-0.0541843474,
-0.8060277104,
-0.3063382208,
-0.0434743948,
0.272813797,
1.010997653,
0.0820017755,
0.0690668002,
-0.3051659465,
0.4862518311,
0.1744976789,
0.2698447108,
0.347438544,
-0.4778679609,
-0.5893793106,
-0.2368362546,
-0.4981322587,
0.5294340849,
-0.7410109043,
0.2460680604,
-0.0905254483,
-0.7651966214,
-0.5167182684,
0.1654204726,
0.3756027222,
0.3710286915,
0.6103281975,
0.0761031806,
-1.0201097727,
-0.8579635024,
-0.6332235336,
-0.5167409182,
-0.0055784341,
0.1363881677,
0.1129679158,
-0.3596819937,
0.7355021238,
-0.399469763,
-0.6273003817,
-0.276564151,
0.1906709224,
-0.3527706563,
0.0711489916,
0.5241891146,
-1.1772079468,
-0.892627418,
-0.0763754398,
-0.4624926448,
-0.5777807236,
0.2519308925,
-0.1993585825,
-0.1717046201,
0.5401371717,
0.0961240157,
0.2644572258,
0.453956604,
-0.2501610816,
0.4997513294,
0.5609225035,
0.2366655618,
-0.9908322692,
-0.5318918824,
0.5696595311,
-0.3445121348,
-0.9935011268,
-0.0058712461,
-0.5580997467,
0.0442253016,
-0.8320845962,
0.3321916163,
0.1580388099,
0.3786457479,
-0.4335734546,
0.3064676225,
-0.4929973483,
0.2274491489,
0.0507652648,
0.0537350997,
0.0747444853,
-0.4450090528,
0.5389006734,
-0.1630752087,
-0.1379458457,
0.8619855046,
-0.277203083,
-0.0237394366,
-0.2360916138,
0.007674492,
-0.7800257802,
0.056683071,
0.6848194003,
-0.6245405674,
-0.3488723338,
-0.3235718012,
-0.2862658501,
-0.2880995274,
-0.3529221117,
0.3585616648,
0.1424357444,
-0.2852549255,
0.4073671997,
0.8030524254,
-0.0707042962,
-0.1814161837,
-0.7145377994,
0.0335400626,
-0.8398402333,
-0.4038834274,
0.3138840795,
-0.0232813489,
-0.4394267499,
0.0387630016,
0.3999351561,
-0.2339461446,
-0.2030481696,
0.3635378778,
0.0173428878,
-0.226713866,
-0.0132123083,
-0.1562246233,
0.2435299009,
0.0875152797,
-0.424261719,
0.5357954502,
0.1484137923,
0.0607525706,
-0.5151945949,
0.4862013161,
0.6302839518,
0.0048657046,
0.4891247749,
0.9791177511,
-0.6055856347,
-0.2365172356,
-0.7874463201,
-0.0129696606,
-0.3997706175,
0.3776180148,
0.0962083861,
-1.2395609617,
0.1303755194,
0.4584910572,
-0.0087096458,
0.4832382798,
0.8036882877,
0.0803386122,
0.7570038438,
0.4683897495,
-0.3299773037,
0.8286843896,
0.0928621665,
0.0729945451,
-0.2298279107,
0.035117466,
-0.5699746609,
-0.1180186272,
-0.7625812888,
-0.7125174999,
0.1732853651,
-0.3881571889,
-0.3298439085,
0.5259913206,
-0.6725948453,
0.3504500687,
0.4079995453,
0.151672706,
0.2491591275,
0.4860883355,
0.1469452828,
-0.3971693218,
-0.2741064429,
-0.3809153438,
0.8902572393,
0.4539168477,
0.3099752367,
-0.0019155043,
0.7741808891,
0.853456974,
0.6047798395,
-0.7300295234,
0.4538887441,
-0.398366183,
-0.6584255695,
-0.3602173924,
-0.4390657544,
-0.4631272554,
0.1272234023,
-0.0364957191,
-0.7836529613,
-0.0957720876,
-0.0176614653,
-0.0532693192,
0.6080486178,
-0.6298770308,
0.6420010328,
-0.0636363477,
-0.1333411336,
-0.3687628806,
-0.2798486948,
0.3933976889,
-0.0222300757,
0.4373200834,
-0.2646211088,
0.1396063566,
0.9269275665,
-0.3295259774,
0.8856793642,
-0.4071790874,
-0.1657176614,
0.5425639153,
-0.1285862327,
0.1599713266,
-0.3990292549,
-0.1887203902,
0.2749353945,
-0.4735478163,
-0.3354189396,
-0.2746511996,
0.5815553069,
-0.6922107339,
-0.2588104308,
-0.2101905793,
-0.2409920841,
0.0855848491,
0.19159545,
0.2376976311,
-0.1073944122,
-0.4331137836,
-0.12713103,
0.3645991385,
-0.1200695038,
-0.0857026055,
0.3219400048,
-0.3331339955,
-0.3829278946,
1.3759300709,
0.24880597,
0.2422696203,
0.3664948344,
0.2312383056,
-0.1927011013,
-0.3954004347,
-0.1341827512,
0.1926099807,
-0.5539802909,
-0.1542418599,
-0.8101747632,
-0.4405519664,
-0.5469891429,
-0.2776354253,
-0.1055039912,
0.0269485172,
-0.2164856344,
-0.1390426457,
0.4692017436,
0.9401581883,
-0.4627015889,
0.5607361794,
-0.5785732865,
0.652797699,
0.3930237889,
0.1882340014,
-0.0935860276,
-0.8599053025,
-0.318410635,
0.2573975027,
-0.2076778561,
-1.2705312967,
0.504191637,
-0.1424371749,
0.0911856443,
0.7238490582,
0.2206418663,
0.5153250098,
-0.3664805591,
0.4813437462,
0.0964872241,
-0.5156570077,
0.8240029812,
-0.5414993763,
-0.1209666505,
0.309610337,
0.7565689683,
-0.853367269,
-0.9126281738,
-0.5497351885,
-0.4751127958,
0.551992476,
0.3720064759,
0.1367884874,
-0.1882635355,
-0.0765435547,
-0.1064336598,
-0.0795268267,
-0.8847097754,
-0.4212399721,
-0.2842012942,
0.0310768727,
-0.1341048032,
-0.5305987597,
-0.0082566617,
-0.2482668906,
0.7543798089,
0.2039069086,
0.0550805219,
-0.1144724116,
-0.3313598633,
-0.1428567767,
0.0441270396,
0.3672493696,
0.2110391855,
-0.2494134158,
0.0934723169,
-0.1040665656,
-0.5847141743,
0.1199634299,
0.1333065778,
-0.2639079094,
0.4802441001,
0.1671126485,
0.5802668929,
-0.0823979303,
-0.5608987212,
0.4910163581,
-0.0315873362,
-0.0041772383,
-0.3452512622,
-0.1006947532,
0.0687664226,
0.3352016211,
0.3617066443,
-0.333188206,
0.1174607873,
-0.2129248232,
0.4819821417,
0.1606957912,
-0.8805718422,
-0.098586753,
0.6645841002,
0.1660629809,
-0.6238893867,
0.2571533322,
-0.1740580052,
-0.9424706697,
0.4693267345,
0.3542057276,
0.9623550773,
-0.6233611107,
0.8640587926,
0.4328735769,
0.4404166937,
0.6602296233,
0.0973968953,
0.1177303419,
-0.8212710619,
-0.2107319087,
-0.8241977096,
-0.0079465229,
0.4640584886,
-0.5181668997,
0.5504148602,
-0.5269138217,
0.0044267038,
0.3940622509,
-0.1714923084,
-0.448669225,
0.2316102684,
0.6863924861,
0.4318039119,
-1.0819041729,
0.4691056311,
0.4115488231,
-0.3949958682,
-0.4100839794,
0.0239914898,
0.5246724486,
-0.8452292085,
0.6389491558,
0.3366995454,
-0.110509403,
0.007197042,
-0.6280212402,
-0.3741750419,
0.1174535602,
0.3327197134,
-0.3409178555,
0.2939513326,
0.5308096409,
0.740929842,
-0.4510554671,
0.0320726149,
0.4982060194,
0.284525454,
-0.10601639,
-0.5765963793,
0.0127610788,
-0.2441020608,
-0.1170066297,
0.0096965991,
-0.6083892584,
0.6819346547,
0.2723171711,
-0.2055954486,
-0.4275043011,
0.7196849585,
0.1114215255,
0.2692006528,
0.9033536315,
0.3911102116,
0.427639693,
0.3832244873,
0.5780394673,
0.3403819799,
0.179000169,
0.9350085258,
-0.0131937675,
0.6927942038,
0.2648342252,
0.0352271982,
0.3674830794,
0.4285678566,
-0.1210748777,
0.2288264632,
0.6633737683,
-0.6031780839,
-0.0959069654,
-0.8444094658,
-0.2861451805,
0.508713901,
0.5105879307,
-0.3763473928,
-0.356112659,
0.3808929026,
0.0743047148,
0.4883601367,
-0.4609279037,
0.7662730217,
0.0362714641,
-0.2047192007,
0.4927895367,
0.1857450753,
0.9440211058,
-0.3631097078,
-0.0054328698,
0.1209446937,
0.0353606232,
-0.2495667636,
-0.5286830068,
0.4734463096,
0.6233740449,
-0.1154813021,
-0.2323819995,
0.8392345309,
-0.6138681769,
-0.3625913262,
0.6841619611,
0.1125192866,
0.2595982254,
-0.6573354602,
-0.8056052327,
0.3740491569,
0.1328750849,
0.2494125366,
0.167013526,
0.3817682862,
-0.0152025204,
0.3778780997,
0.5230129957,
0.3481363654,
0.2753287852,
0.2828340828,
1.1148661375,
-0.500311017,
-0.5408027172,
-0.9562869668,
0.2800560296,
-0.2855164707,
-0.3353797793,
0.7852321863,
0.5873503685,
1.2600193024,
0.1469958276,
1.1542526484,
-0.0484114923,
0.9844174981,
0.019401893,
0.8052024841,
-0.5906649232,
-0.1559443176,
-0.801343739,
-1.0413813591,
-0.4464675486,
0.5478073955,
-0.3516830206,
-0.2577060461,
0.3295421898,
0.821373105,
0.0573685765,
-0.0351536088,
0.4527817965,
0.6316589117,
0.5965759158,
0.1960854977,
0.7804960012,
-0.2721084058,
0.9335833192,
-0.3914677203,
-0.2345648557,
-0.5565353036,
-0.4305431247,
-0.8821154833,
-0.5836144686,
-0.3791438043,
-0.6528200507,
0.3230534792,
0.8011715412,
0.3404974341,
-0.8960539103,
-0.388546139,
0.3771420419,
0.3349247575,
-0.0157687478,
-0.3281446695,
0.1044533178,
-0.0305272732,
-0.8596134186,
0.1063358411,
0.3056292236,
-0.2129344195,
-0.2630200982,
-0.0607806593,
-0.7401604056,
-0.1085126251,
0.7681671977,
0.2807286084,
-0.5964443684,
-0.4179278314,
-0.2974264324,
-0.1545397043,
-0.0650529116,
0.8118391037,
-0.4351091087,
0.4596584439,
0.3211679161,
0.7153041363,
0.4104395509,
0.0753617287,
0.1599019915,
-0.5758916736,
0.261089474,
0.5389002562,
-0.0848288387,
0.3691178262,
-0.2754367292,
0.1891205907,
0.4659546018,
-0.2406242937,
-0.9266660213,
0.2510118783,
-0.8256679177,
-0.1585920304,
1.3095027208,
0.0192760639,
-0.0803667977,
-0.4184045792,
-0.3722300231,
0.729731679,
-0.5458751321,
0.8641237617,
0.6087883711,
0.3325227499,
0.0800399631,
-0.3950102031,
0.6055058837,
0.293625623,
-0.589345634,
0.0489167795,
0.5942785144,
-0.0290738959,
0.064527303,
0.7026466727,
0.1792949736,
0.1241500154,
-0.0933554247,
-0.152132988,
0.4418486357,
-0.2504748404,
-0.2516762912,
0.3243103623,
-0.4930057228,
-0.1209558249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19245v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19245v2
|
HydraLoRA: An Asymmetric LoRA Architecture for Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-04-30T04:01:09 | 2024-05-23T15:06:02 |
Chunlin Tian, Zhan Shi, Zhijiang Guo, Li Li, Chengzhong Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) to new tasks through fine-tuning has
been made more efficient by the introduction of Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
(PEFT) techniques, such as LoRA. However, these methods often underperform
compared to full fine-tuning, particularly in scenarios involving complex
datasets. This issue becomes even more pronounced in complex domains,
highlighting the need for improved PEFT approaches that can achieve better
performance. Through a series of experiments, we have uncovered two critical
insights that shed light on the training and parameter inefficiency of LoRA.
Building on these insights, we have developed HydraLoRA, a LoRA framework with
an asymmetric structure that eliminates the need for domain expertise. Our
experiments demonstrate that HydraLoRA outperforms other PEFT approaches, even
those that rely on domain knowledge during the training and inference phases.
|
[
-0.3916036189,
-0.7798022628,
0.4486782253,
0.2270351648,
-0.3115178645,
0.2429541945,
-0.4324018955,
-0.614099443,
-0.027894808,
0.4288415611,
-0.3631499112,
-0.484412998,
-0.4692158699,
-0.145890668,
-0.3854256868,
0.9520587325,
-0.212172389,
-0.0652945414,
0.2191133052,
-0.3341926634,
-0.2517909408,
-0.2538156509,
-0.987549603,
-0.7542719841,
0.7807119489,
0.4967219234,
0.5926754475,
0.6313562393,
0.1864906549,
0.2251888216,
-0.0895837694,
0.4695866704,
-0.5754609108,
0.0564395152,
-0.4602658749,
-0.5949329734,
-0.5799481869,
-0.1786898524,
0.4768927395,
0.8883757591,
0.010783609,
0.399597019,
0.2472878695,
1.0415762663,
-0.8256787658,
0.113744013,
-0.9352164865,
-0.2666294575,
-0.4627678394,
-0.3851978183,
-0.0376493745,
-0.1613390446,
0.1913233846,
-0.5843409896,
0.0731730089,
0.173492685,
1.0364940166,
0.6406064034,
-0.1790181696,
-0.240733251,
-0.8286027908,
0.6683624387,
-0.574187398,
0.3766460121,
0.1151542738,
0.3424024284,
-0.1904300153,
-0.4905515313,
-0.358346194,
0.1800428629,
0.4664645791,
-0.173682645,
-0.3788071871,
0.0224058498,
0.1199971586,
0.0633681193,
-0.3600978851,
0.4058129489,
-0.276304692,
0.1974303126,
0.5339817405,
-0.1608696729,
0.1426756084,
0.3034698665,
-0.2460189015,
0.1227165908,
-1.1731179953,
0.0435980186,
0.4832071662,
0.6555298567,
-0.0210956633,
0.5528820753,
-0.3631173074,
0.6621124744,
0.1259595156,
0.0693742111,
-0.0651064739,
0.1438181102,
-0.4646096528,
0.3084917963,
0.3277980387,
-0.066598393,
0.5008821487,
-0.2776448429,
-0.1584733874,
0.2258435488,
0.0854805559,
-0.7364891171,
-0.3762569129,
0.3470531106,
-0.1699593812,
-0.0802476779,
-0.0539570823,
-0.6614314318,
-0.2353076488,
-0.4466061592,
0.3924218118,
-0.3490020633,
0.1779131144,
0.4884297848,
-0.0202532038,
0.2437002361,
0.6261677742,
-0.6906285286,
0.5699454546,
0.8565582037,
0.6307760477,
-0.5191497207,
-0.443459183,
-0.7085541487,
0.301556617,
-0.2059293538,
1.2021538019,
-0.592208147,
0.0989317223,
-0.0718053579,
-0.201282829,
-0.1538623273,
-0.8345748782,
0.5060663819,
-0.8825902939,
-0.0588837638,
-0.3208092749,
-0.4447094798,
-0.1982918978,
-0.0158486143,
-0.5388627648,
0.7677160501,
0.2763851583,
-0.6023847461,
0.1460709423,
-0.7807215452,
-0.3429040611,
-0.1456804425,
-0.0349899642,
-0.4858476222,
0.2408191115,
0.0360193439,
0.1694354564,
-0.8307423592,
0.0097325286,
-0.409458667,
-0.4629773498,
0.029700147,
-0.1526643932,
0.7138577104,
0.3585360646,
-0.5875686407,
0.2987780571,
-0.7814021707,
0.3189396858,
0.0630810857,
-0.7023805976,
-0.437825948,
-0.091710493,
0.2838106453,
-0.1096297577,
0.2694658637,
-0.3344334066,
0.1773949713,
-0.535669744,
0.6101341248,
0.6669143438,
-0.1729403734,
0.4672205448,
-0.1809443384,
0.4761366844,
-0.1757666171,
0.0338657871,
0.4423396885,
-0.38876459,
-1.0457612276,
-0.2238904387,
0.4223027825,
0.3649656475,
-0.7135700583,
0.2606390119,
-0.0437118225,
-0.5220183134,
-0.4171905518,
0.7210066915,
0.5742705464,
0.3684850335,
0.3760178685,
-0.1629685163,
-0.4705337882,
-0.8811650276,
-0.7154576182,
0.0283569712,
0.202140227,
0.1465991139,
0.3574576378,
-0.4035704434,
0.8548024893,
-0.4415073097,
-0.2472304702,
-0.2341717333,
-0.1909660399,
0.3899032176,
0.4326440096,
0.6611360908,
-0.6959434152,
-0.8286681771,
0.2528263927,
-0.4812674224,
-0.3901851177,
0.2752273083,
-0.1816674769,
0.2638637424,
0.5075950027,
-0.6908571124,
0.06653703,
0.7365288734,
-0.5436319113,
0.3388294578,
-0.2173827887,
-0.2355912626,
-0.7779123187,
0.2710568607,
-0.1153449416,
-0.239597261,
-0.7420918941,
0.2151072323,
0.1239809096,
0.0420179814,
-0.2809684575,
0.6195219159,
-0.4707769156,
-0.113044776,
-0.4963248968,
0.1930779815,
0.1160002723,
0.5909520388,
-0.1217430681,
0.7913258076,
0.4003430605,
-0.6500962973,
0.2051934451,
0.0592837781,
-0.4768301249,
0.5369977951,
-0.8590065837,
0.1514124721,
0.0698078796,
-0.0676580071,
-0.5483462214,
-0.2688460946,
0.1597302854,
0.158384338,
0.1756916046,
-0.1272435039,
-0.5254710317,
-0.0650400594,
-0.2705045342,
0.4863522053,
0.4215097725,
-0.7082410455,
0.6769897342,
0.3933663368,
-0.0757249445,
-0.4547227025,
-0.3630436361,
-0.1776503026,
-0.5770810246,
-0.3006408811,
0.5257316232,
-0.1468236595,
-0.514728725,
-0.220802635,
-0.2080286443,
-0.2706677318,
0.2939633429,
0.2730385065,
-0.1294165403,
-0.5036123395,
0.0684469417,
0.3002021313,
-0.0918470994,
-0.1081434041,
-0.2509694099,
0.8279892802,
-0.1808253676,
-0.4808280468,
-0.6633095741,
0.1278697401,
0.6867892742,
-0.1713028401,
0.5156903267,
0.2916174233,
-0.3069542944,
-0.7620036602,
-0.4750420749,
0.1062425897,
-0.5574103594,
0.2779119015,
-0.5294505358,
-0.7518743277,
0.5673860312,
-0.4192709327,
0.0226840191,
0.3807606995,
0.419271946,
-0.1335554421,
0.5464242697,
0.7673831582,
-0.2252613753,
0.6638182998,
-0.1821359545,
0.1468196064,
-0.7861936688,
-0.1250258684,
-0.7286534905,
-0.3337046504,
-0.287591666,
-0.5666084886,
0.2856967449,
0.4041629732,
-0.6963739991,
0.3617905676,
-0.1532320678,
0.4998115301,
0.4748151302,
0.1428574473,
0.6381287575,
0.2677462399,
0.4618114829,
0.289612174,
-1.058811307,
-0.4553216398,
0.9915089607,
0.5125409365,
0.9567168355,
0.1689100116,
0.5326119065,
0.0195599701,
0.2044570297,
-0.7135281563,
0.2265639007,
-0.311062336,
-0.2567893863,
-0.4119417667,
-0.2147180438,
-0.9867739081,
0.1056215167,
-0.0161575899,
-0.4985877573,
0.416094631,
0.3096215129,
-0.6225063205,
0.2986526787,
-0.6146375537,
0.6356890798,
-0.2099204212,
-0.4450471401,
-0.3060551584,
-0.1486685574,
-0.005210293,
-0.438821435,
-0.0146162985,
-0.2679132223,
-0.2265177816,
0.6083993912,
-0.3522316217,
0.8821720481,
-0.2158534825,
-0.6064689159,
0.2439862639,
0.0388280414,
0.62087816,
0.1010986269,
-0.3076246679,
0.0386117771,
-0.0544646531,
-0.5579549074,
-0.7890995741,
1.0272769928,
-1.0062013865,
-0.571805954,
-0.0226517301,
-0.7600741386,
-0.6989380121,
0.1854443103,
0.1359592676,
0.126381129,
-0.0657026991,
0.1495173573,
0.9983269572,
-0.1656472385,
0.1324867457,
0.5371565819,
-0.1062082872,
-0.0230381005,
0.7694114447,
0.1067280248,
0.3035986125,
0.3353068829,
0.0541313812,
0.0535514094,
-0.7595357895,
-0.304978013,
0.415215075,
-0.6479588151,
-0.3046499789,
-0.4068493843,
-0.1144681573,
-0.0913935378,
-0.2528710961,
-0.779424727,
-0.3844135702,
-0.4313089848,
0.3890041113,
0.4438295662,
0.7320438027,
0.5354033709,
0.4324180484,
-0.375410825,
0.3489859402,
0.4704810977,
0.5020986199,
-0.0099997157,
-0.6879155636,
-0.1638624221,
-0.037590038,
-0.019150639,
-0.4801177979,
0.2794808745,
0.6146511436,
0.4061091542,
0.481417805,
-0.0690552667,
1.102058053,
-0.6417422295,
0.2841326296,
-0.2082013637,
-1.1249438524,
0.5212218761,
-0.4909675717,
0.416718632,
0.5972711444,
0.2096646726,
-0.0117776906,
0.0055157845,
-0.4133745432,
-0.7357321978,
0.4070632458,
0.1194700301,
0.0925598145,
0.6889576912,
0.7374194264,
0.2148799151,
0.3787115514,
-0.3631841838,
-0.2644334435,
0.1224390119,
-0.2015731633,
-0.246253565,
-0.2231139392,
-0.348492384,
-0.3378577232,
0.6062577367,
-0.5506273508,
0.0272897705,
-0.0646793991,
-0.017496977,
-0.2978496253,
0.106503807,
0.4186672568,
0.7518073916,
-0.0327052176,
0.2902356386,
0.4131944478,
-0.1147242114,
-0.1783269793,
-0.0911071151,
-0.0009822614,
-0.2066294402,
0.4665609002,
0.7584732771,
0.4291089177,
-0.9544416666,
-0.0153263118,
0.2365086824,
-0.0545259491,
-0.1629655659,
0.5903593898,
0.1968955547,
0.7741115093,
0.2576303184,
0.0989026055,
-0.0289133471,
-0.8595920205,
-0.0154814357,
0.498524636,
-0.3540915549,
-0.4517120123,
0.4914129674,
-0.0083297808,
-0.3894908428,
0.1521686763,
0.2921680808,
-0.3807363212,
0.4668451548,
0.683775425,
0.6795926094,
-0.1533631682,
0.042889569,
-0.224159807,
-0.0094435262,
-0.1501549333,
0.6447334886,
-0.0497785583,
-0.7398097515,
0.0095758,
-0.907545507,
-0.3299143314,
-0.0226239935,
-0.6793637276,
0.0461989045,
-0.7198632956,
-0.0749128088,
0.0523572452,
0.1838885695,
-0.6875124574,
-0.0563273318,
-0.1445121914,
1.2393091917,
-0.790704608,
1.2616232634,
0.7050035596,
0.0415632762,
-0.7088773847,
0.0264975093,
-0.2508041859,
-0.8686534166,
0.7926895618,
-0.2798888981,
-0.5649030209,
0.046293851,
-0.537774086,
-1.0802688599,
1.1474915743,
1.0065095425,
-0.6475993395,
-0.2036047429,
0.1920951158,
0.8122164011,
-0.6116338372,
-0.6321094036,
0.8269795179,
0.4393341243,
-0.2253834456,
-1.0545307398,
-0.0143724671,
-0.2144633383,
0.0828912631,
-0.0830983818,
-0.8985207081,
0.929328084,
-0.1053458154,
-0.1483806521,
0.2047377676,
0.6295304298,
0.3973522484,
0.2742110491,
0.4540064931,
0.269313246,
0.8656288981,
-0.0457817987,
0.9319716692,
-0.4817035198,
0.2349675298,
1.4329942465,
-0.3684599698,
1.1278063059,
0.8419183493,
-0.1216680408,
0.6088901162,
0.5830972195,
0.1753000468,
0.4946607351,
0.1426640451,
-0.0278422609,
-0.4842060208,
-0.1643619537,
-0.1471315473,
0.5810982585,
0.3975920379,
-0.2346727252,
-0.2988160253,
-0.0962855741,
-0.0235971604,
0.247138992,
-0.4715726078,
0.4986130893,
0.3305571079,
-0.507805407,
0.8548815846,
0.0930146948,
0.5500974655,
-0.5488653183,
0.0943485945,
-0.1272136122,
0.4135057926,
-0.2969457209,
-0.4201488197,
0.1238390282,
0.0916577056,
-0.1989191175,
-0.0320812911,
0.5836148858,
-0.3946028352,
-0.0839194953,
0.5615649223,
0.7017983198,
-0.0408338606,
-0.5173498392,
-0.8315482736,
0.3790445924,
-0.0894808024,
-0.3226236999,
0.4153189361,
0.4649951756,
-0.1681033522,
0.9317418933,
0.600227952,
0.3261535466,
-0.0914123878,
0.1765406877,
1.2270487547,
-0.4529904723,
-0.2502453029,
-0.7453018427,
0.0201440044,
0.102929838,
-0.3734277189,
0.8658305407,
0.5111552477,
0.7249699831,
-0.0003760147,
0.5793694258,
0.3179236054,
0.340819031,
-0.7531499863,
0.8503993154,
-0.6541848183,
0.5689382553,
-0.1692356765,
-1.1659654379,
-0.3052661419,
0.3834570944,
-0.3031449616,
-0.0414210036,
0.5921740532,
0.6866969466,
-0.3423149586,
-0.0924320221,
0.2255446613,
0.377744019,
0.3100323081,
0.647506237,
0.4818376005,
-0.5602766275,
0.1307162941,
-0.0601766855,
-0.0483761206,
-0.2945894003,
-0.5519522429,
-1.1981549263,
-0.4801840484,
-0.3087937236,
-0.1954204738,
0.414081037,
0.9968462586,
0.7078461647,
-1.1842913628,
-0.4065547884,
-0.0677409843,
0.0848174989,
-0.1669276655,
-0.1098253131,
0.6129905581,
-0.3706158698,
-0.9882405996,
0.6339532733,
0.4302805662,
-0.0457085297,
-0.305824846,
-0.1223756447,
0.0234338585,
0.306139648,
0.7171455026,
0.5208501816,
-0.6423286796,
-0.2519115806,
-0.3066059053,
-0.0505750924,
0.048751194,
0.7622916698,
-0.6354944706,
0.0253339261,
0.2908573151,
0.7491274476,
0.3711022437,
0.0329218693,
0.7095064521,
-0.2629786134,
0.0875969157,
-0.0576500148,
0.3750198483,
0.0506086014,
-0.2181751132,
0.4519041479,
-0.0210483335,
-0.3401194215,
-1.0217882395,
0.2711433768,
-1.070453763,
-0.5126112103,
1.2844057083,
-0.1493547708,
-0.5862627029,
-0.430149734,
-0.2343611866,
0.1002178192,
-0.3356752992,
1.1005296707,
0.1079012603,
-0.3692719638,
0.132375285,
-0.4982773662,
0.8848563433,
0.5083727241,
-1.0833457708,
0.2306978703,
0.0535014123,
0.6163684726,
0.1681235582,
0.3736564517,
0.2231684327,
0.2229502201,
-0.2679904699,
-0.389747411,
-0.0573797226,
-0.6761924624,
-0.4475113153,
0.6509510875,
0.5293905139,
0.3783046901
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.