id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19234v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19234v1
|
Multi-hop Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T03:31:03 | 2024-04-30T03:31:03 |
Abir Chakraborty
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Knowledge graphs (KGs) are large datasets with specific structures
representing large knowledge bases (KB) where each node represents a key entity
and relations amongst them are typed edges. Natural language queries formed to
extract information from a KB entail starting from specific nodes and reasoning
over multiple edges of the corresponding KG to arrive at the correct set of
answer nodes. Traditional approaches of question answering on KG are based on
(a) semantic parsing (SP), where a logical form (e.g., S-expression, SPARQL
query, etc.) is generated using node and edge embeddings and then reasoning
over these representations or tuning language models to generate the final
answer directly, or (b) information-retrieval based that works by extracting
entities and relations sequentially. In this work, we evaluate the capability
of (LLMs) to answer questions over KG that involve multiple hops. We show that
depending upon the size and nature of the KG we need different approaches to
extract and feed the relevant information to an LLM since every LLM comes with
a fixed context window. We evaluate our approach on six KGs with and without
the availability of example-specific sub-graphs and show that both the IR and
SP-based methods can be adopted by LLMs resulting in an extremely competitive
performance.
|
[
-0.5155302882,
-1.290500164,
0.9089898467,
0.1887799501,
-0.0169612784,
0.2298189998,
0.0596362725,
-0.4202667475,
0.1530965567,
0.5037052035,
-0.5454466343,
-0.4018441737,
-0.5470481515,
0.3601024449,
-0.056642279,
0.5542760491,
-0.1708790809,
-0.0608415864,
-0.4854198396,
-0.2697727382,
-0.51706779,
-0.4474931955,
-0.7347701192,
-0.2933185101,
0.808051765,
0.3637887836,
0.6828688979,
0.5987735987,
0.3718794286,
0.2737723291,
-0.3850262165,
0.3459048569,
-0.3665770292,
0.3975680172,
-0.0082679801,
-0.2946429253,
-0.3246566653,
-0.2804334164,
0.5766324401,
1.045117259,
0.2296643108,
0.2726583779,
-0.2433412224,
0.7330941558,
-0.5619242191,
0.1921967864,
-0.5750734806,
-0.0126104672,
-0.0106537752,
-0.2261253446,
-0.5894824862,
-0.4986608922,
0.1290879995,
-0.6209363937,
-0.5194488764,
0.0718400851,
0.6388292313,
0.096182555,
-0.7719329596,
-0.5941005349,
-0.5877212882,
0.4113311172,
-0.5655546784,
0.6830359697,
0.3327242434,
0.678823173,
-0.3273159862,
-0.7845156789,
-0.4119692147,
-0.0384281054,
-0.2161912024,
-0.0049727224,
0.0542217083,
-0.0195976794,
0.3975538611,
0.0105976667,
-0.5508888364,
-0.1382708251,
-0.0402772091,
-0.1312288642,
0.4591355622,
0.1330425292,
0.2549975812,
-0.2256279886,
-0.3796700835,
-0.0281982627,
-0.5332111716,
0.2265017927,
0.2656189799,
0.3639046848,
0.4023212492,
0.7983765602,
-0.5673707724,
1.1645596027,
-0.1922965795,
-0.4953271449,
0.1225147098,
-0.2117980868,
-0.0952582136,
-0.3100863099,
0.6437269449,
0.3581113517,
0.6267616749,
-0.6156044006,
0.0983609259,
-0.3590605259,
-0.0973018259,
-0.655121088,
0.1213537157,
0.3194489181,
-0.3150680959,
-0.0370967798,
-0.3304254711,
-0.9058287144,
-0.2988367677,
-0.1265104264,
0.6433026195,
-0.5912302732,
-0.2669488788,
0.0535443686,
-0.3699863255,
0.6089310646,
0.298383683,
-0.3983380795,
0.3270597458,
0.3844055533,
0.7572324276,
0.1248285845,
-0.3120664656,
-0.6003770232,
0.4333984256,
-0.2054783106,
0.7012530565,
-0.6351526976,
-0.2344489098,
-0.1321299076,
-0.1190245301,
-0.4541631937,
-0.3178914785,
0.281783998,
-1.3334777355,
-0.0067450241,
-0.5896288753,
-0.8738037348,
-0.2301770449,
0.7844910026,
-0.4854614139,
0.9446688294,
0.0443639606,
-1.09465909,
-0.0333991088,
-0.739520371,
-0.5804581642,
-0.0594724678,
-0.0814395249,
0.121800527,
-0.3403820693,
0.5330857038,
0.4467569292,
-0.2329539806,
0.1596144587,
-0.3536380231,
0.0640532449,
0.3132497072,
-0.1715021133,
0.6654115319,
0.3545016646,
0.1976795644,
-0.2257625461,
-0.735104382,
0.4138549864,
0.3078608513,
-0.5556872487,
-0.4424825013,
0.0934159905,
-0.6569946408,
0.3706357479,
0.0435255915,
-0.6659519076,
0.4324603975,
-0.2194406539,
0.3868710101,
0.4860987067,
0.2777834535,
0.1980194449,
-0.1643027216,
0.5629948974,
-0.0477582365,
-0.0131972628,
-0.255333364,
-0.7069742084,
-0.4157088399,
-0.1281356215,
0.2818095088,
0.6604939699,
-1.0830322504,
0.0544061176,
-0.5243715048,
-0.4676173925,
-0.2971897423,
-0.0314985588,
0.1218493283,
0.8951397538,
0.4521155357,
0.1810370982,
-0.1293346137,
-0.7256619334,
-0.4194639623,
-0.1259007156,
0.1212652773,
0.6523908377,
0.4999037981,
-0.0604651161,
1.3751612902,
-0.8880565166,
0.1707832068,
-0.3966474533,
-0.0718511641,
0.2987353802,
-0.0280265808,
0.3885494471,
-0.9270054102,
-0.6633994579,
-0.0200170353,
-0.8841577172,
0.0349266082,
0.0951803252,
-0.302010864,
-0.116421856,
0.6011884212,
-0.7905106544,
0.1781239659,
0.3817424774,
-0.3249923587,
0.5496897697,
0.2393042147,
0.2229526043,
-1.1200248003,
0.1548451781,
-0.4015448391,
-0.3713086843,
-0.7917325497,
0.1892565191,
-0.1096925661,
-0.1524801254,
-0.2813049257,
0.6162737608,
-0.3790440261,
-0.3149330616,
-0.0128171127,
0.2622900307,
0.163873747,
0.5444378853,
0.0967903584,
0.5590977073,
0.5248099566,
-0.6881738305,
0.5646715164,
0.3293609619,
-0.1040124521,
0.2709611952,
-0.7047933936,
0.391457051,
-0.3580122292,
0.406398803,
-1.1553446054,
-0.2513858378,
0.1097076908,
-0.6171703935,
0.0559945069,
-0.6555239558,
-0.5175260305,
-0.5860820413,
-0.1245032772,
0.4163624644,
0.1631064713,
-0.4601771533,
0.8975462317,
0.2211723328,
-0.2084251344,
-0.7512596846,
-0.3580113351,
-0.0111020068,
-0.189614296,
-1.1580024958,
-0.1451351941,
-0.0273840372,
-0.2176341861,
0.3132331371,
-0.1148277968,
-0.1762858927,
0.1617256254,
-0.219109118,
-0.0337323025,
-0.286740154,
0.2667881548,
-0.1660109907,
-0.1469699442,
-0.0776151344,
-0.4176972508,
0.7397005558,
-0.0917774588,
-0.5340148211,
-0.0049452242,
0.5150440335,
0.7867153287,
-0.3362258077,
1.0246034861,
0.3948403597,
-0.2943752706,
0.0007705604,
-0.531850338,
0.0859951898,
-0.4183664024,
0.2862382531,
-0.7246765494,
-0.949292779,
0.7266948819,
-0.352861017,
-0.0178462267,
0.3593890071,
0.4744763672,
-0.1129906327,
0.9437413812,
0.3055807054,
-0.0839902833,
-0.0025992,
-0.1443003118,
0.4520436227,
-0.6888241172,
-0.4306690395,
-0.6160244942,
-0.1226628199,
-0.3922394216,
-0.351680249,
0.7327364683,
0.4246608317,
-0.2811240554,
0.1783564091,
0.0435797721,
0.5588690042,
0.5810650587,
-0.1236870959,
0.475899756,
-0.1620500684,
-0.4787199497,
0.4067523479,
-0.9609811306,
-0.326664418,
0.9455826283,
0.2455119342,
0.8651610613,
0.2483398467,
0.4241173565,
-0.1664563566,
0.0268736407,
-0.9483167529,
0.5194274187,
0.2175050527,
-0.6687984467,
-0.5559902191,
-0.8310558796,
-0.8163772225,
0.4373802841,
-0.0611998849,
-0.8592599034,
-0.2109312713,
-0.0100196274,
-0.2345937341,
0.5138387084,
-0.8042945862,
0.9228978753,
-0.2340842932,
-0.0388139412,
0.3505286872,
-0.9478753209,
0.2639469802,
0.1105015427,
0.3932614625,
0.0512338988,
0.2757790089,
0.7720433474,
-0.2806916535,
0.5374068618,
-0.2967947125,
0.0918582901,
0.6024904847,
0.2118890584,
0.7254312634,
-0.0573184788,
-0.0935424492,
-0.2134549022,
0.2574829161,
-0.2744461,
-0.8651462793,
0.4014849961,
-0.7857139111,
-0.5093385577,
-0.1447888464,
-0.7245305777,
-0.7962543964,
0.3542532623,
-0.0082532046,
0.6534004211,
0.2738113999,
0.2280691713,
0.5049385428,
-0.3800976276,
0.3728103638,
0.3893376291,
-0.3770228624,
-0.4238469005,
0.6010447741,
0.31488204,
0.5275171995,
0.6390854716,
0.4276323617,
-0.610812366,
-0.4083919525,
-0.6675397754,
0.2980616987,
-0.964507401,
-0.3463156819,
-1.0799205303,
-0.2821277976,
-0.6909384131,
-0.0127097629,
-0.2242298871,
-0.4124908149,
0.3633130193,
-0.0246696286,
0.5134111047,
0.6186901927,
0.2287192047,
0.1869672239,
-1.0993857384,
0.5682164431,
0.6298645139,
0.5364736319,
0.1358094364,
-0.2252825946,
-0.0621914566,
-0.156288892,
-0.0671714395,
-1.3027746677,
0.0570769869,
-0.0445697308,
0.6871769428,
0.1491109282,
0.0857930332,
0.8443946838,
-0.65850389,
0.5670353174,
-0.0461528301,
-0.6016658545,
0.4976543784,
-0.3777559102,
0.1087095216,
0.5609583259,
0.818826437,
-0.8900858164,
-0.1900046617,
-0.3594482243,
-0.9664503336,
0.6912325621,
0.1930985749,
-0.1868270785,
-0.1383510679,
0.4799995124,
-0.1365617812,
0.2686751485,
-0.7486554384,
-0.3215304017,
0.0526491851,
-0.1026887819,
0.2263378799,
-0.2124633193,
-0.0829683244,
-0.0672273636,
0.5938712955,
-0.2969582677,
0.2686077952,
0.2335669398,
-0.2309159636,
0.0738273636,
0.389716506,
-0.088586323,
0.8016834855,
-0.1669968367,
0.3253990114,
0.1336936802,
-0.1325060725,
0.101813525,
0.028824769,
-0.2318985313,
-0.2519966662,
0.5428814888,
0.496188283,
-0.3856799603,
-0.6491276026,
0.515992105,
0.0075959256,
0.0022085744,
0.0870753601,
-0.2089332342,
0.5387707353,
0.3196307421,
0.2852192223,
-0.3641906381,
-0.0203894582,
-0.5373532176,
0.1484703273,
0.5055297613,
-0.0745441616,
0.0823230222,
0.3712469339,
0.0467289761,
-0.1666032672,
0.7920265794,
-0.24992311,
-0.6278500557,
0.6715538502,
0.7076004744,
0.4007333517,
0.0814769492,
0.1707118154,
0.3068318069,
0.3182793558,
0.2308067232,
0.2102050483,
0.0661310405,
-1.0491540432,
-0.824064672,
-0.8191940784,
-0.3897627592,
0.0216979235,
-0.5356861353,
-0.0602153353,
-0.039478384,
0.0767416209,
-0.041621428,
-0.1278287023,
-0.5267210603,
0.0878345296,
0.0989156365,
1.3101971149,
-0.9855824113,
0.5046592355,
0.9579192996,
-0.2856752574,
-1.0869005919,
-0.0472991988,
-0.2964167297,
-0.8592402339,
0.7051690221,
0.0539990403,
-0.200709641,
0.1644502729,
-0.3932205737,
-1.1353839636,
1.1305695772,
0.2631067038,
-0.091620788,
-0.0882198662,
0.2736042738,
0.2518934906,
-0.1537319571,
0.2356996685,
0.564894557,
0.5452173352,
0.5260570049,
-0.7177465558,
-0.1102749854,
0.0786496773,
-0.2730461359,
0.2244485617,
-0.5647336245,
0.6256476045,
-0.1171129122,
0.0567823313,
-0.1697455347,
0.4171673059,
0.287694037,
0.2636054754,
0.6634129286,
0.7385142446,
0.8230065107,
0.0597023778,
1.1841470003,
-0.265524298,
0.4086134732,
0.9469937682,
-0.2792779505,
0.5509525537,
0.500533402,
-0.3153711259,
0.3140467405,
0.5889135003,
0.5541223884,
0.4189081192,
0.2000951767,
-0.1163948402,
-0.4461372793,
-0.0406483896,
-0.3015080392,
0.558034122,
0.2371652424,
0.0323643871,
-0.6195127964,
-0.1101976484,
0.1583376825,
-0.2235793322,
-0.3289816976,
0.8558579087,
-0.1041796952,
-0.6924309134,
0.0889546722,
0.2094008625,
0.0947026908,
-0.9140865207,
0.0570995845,
-0.3232261837,
-0.2557196617,
-0.061280448,
-0.9372221231,
0.2252525985,
0.1850408465,
-0.0506818928,
-0.1510072052,
0.928824544,
-0.2231495976,
-0.5504678488,
0.4453079402,
1.0106078386,
0.1369554996,
0.0022511499,
-0.4834115207,
-0.2904158831,
-0.2743408382,
-0.5738742352,
0.2077910602,
0.8113914132,
-0.0752543882,
0.9875457883,
0.5476688147,
-0.1152352914,
0.3858308196,
0.0552321039,
1.1185742617,
-0.5210466981,
-0.5805394053,
-0.835334003,
0.2569778264,
0.0034686218,
0.0385001823,
0.8462358713,
0.5073968172,
0.587069273,
0.1772868633,
0.6795638204,
-0.4238507748,
0.5500600338,
-0.6623579264,
0.1778201461,
-0.4227927327,
-0.02301489,
-0.4118848741,
-0.7349749804,
-0.2907200158,
0.4704454541,
-0.4004163742,
0.1223697811,
0.5968766212,
0.6164565682,
0.0042934045,
-0.0246967599,
0.2916276157,
0.3962364793,
0.3772305846,
0.5206994414,
1.0817550421,
-0.1307396889,
0.8060287833,
-0.0482097976,
-0.1505025029,
0.1332670152,
-0.8546957374,
-0.613111794,
-0.1693734527,
0.0163608827,
-0.4084350765,
-0.1035576016,
0.8291249275,
0.4142919779,
-0.5800079107,
-0.0171284769,
0.2106632292,
0.4692988396,
-0.1041562483,
-0.2352467477,
0.6206336021,
-0.5013898611,
-0.3384456635,
0.434117943,
0.2324466556,
-0.2898851633,
0.114955835,
0.1057755724,
-0.5470348001,
-0.0355808772,
0.8521972299,
0.1072608903,
-0.2180811018,
-0.6291241646,
0.4178979695,
0.225789994,
0.0452831276,
0.7656776905,
-0.7245913744,
0.4362334907,
0.6671743393,
1.2409673929,
0.5516101718,
0.2536570728,
0.1926131546,
-0.9369251728,
-0.249991715,
0.1554353386,
0.3015176356,
0.1393771768,
-0.2429239303,
0.4952121079,
0.4054742754,
-0.4986292124,
-0.4354805052,
0.5176380873,
-0.8883544803,
-0.5068206787,
1.4709244967,
-0.1919590235,
-0.0873206332,
-0.424346298,
0.0307216775,
0.1193133444,
-0.0033886905,
0.1288202405,
0.8325057626,
-0.6426401734,
0.2273882926,
-0.6538675427,
0.079863064,
0.0195888188,
-0.7585693598,
0.0600593314,
0.5395922661,
0.4897253215,
0.1661271006,
1.0588117838,
-0.1770416498,
-0.1614042222,
-0.1074547693,
-0.3205988109,
-0.1638611853,
-0.5736173987,
0.1781784296,
0.6349030137,
0.1783095896,
-0.1662099659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19232v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19232v4
|
GRAMMAR: Grounded and Modular Methodology for Assessment of Domain-Specific Retrieval-Augmented Language Model
| 2024-04-30T03:29:30 | 2024-05-29T11:12:21 |
Xinzhe Li, Ming Liu, Shang Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented Generation (RAG) systems have been actively studied and
deployed across various industries to query on domain-specific knowledge base.
However, evaluating these systems presents unique challenges due to the
scarcity of domain-specific queries and corresponding ground truths, as well as
a lack of systematic approaches to diagnosing the cause of failure cases --
whether they stem from knowledge deficits or issues related to system
robustness. To address these challenges, we introduce GRAMMAR (GRounded And
Modular Methodology for Assessment of RAG), an evaluation framework comprising
two key elements: 1) a data generation process that leverages relational
databases and LLMs to efficiently produce scalable query-answer pairs. This
method facilitates the separation of query logic from linguistic variations for
enhanced debugging capabilities; and 2) an evaluation framework that
differentiates knowledge gaps from robustness and enables the identification of
defective modules. Our empirical results underscore the limitations of current
reference-free evaluation approaches and the reliability of GRAMMAR to
accurately identify model vulnerabilities.
|
[
-0.260581404,
-1.1664335728,
0.5439919233,
0.1530034244,
0.0767988116,
0.2243527472,
0.0315541402,
-0.1146774143,
-0.0779819116,
0.3654460609,
-0.5099852681,
-0.373152405,
-0.2638309598,
-0.0737222061,
-0.4861018956,
0.6631678343,
0.1767584532,
-0.0362448096,
-0.9426501989,
-0.0420118906,
-0.9640336633,
-0.692679286,
-0.3547495306,
-0.0729972199,
-0.0840603262,
0.3957282901,
0.6085281968,
0.4787931144,
0.6317439675,
0.2646239698,
-0.2415924817,
0.1717386693,
-0.4127379954,
0.3927650154,
-0.3808093071,
-0.2001920938,
-0.6730874181,
-0.3054893315,
0.4235466421,
0.9005678892,
-0.1470393389,
0.4477549195,
-0.1503082514,
0.6831181645,
-0.7678678632,
0.0560472235,
-0.8027739525,
-0.0691016391,
-0.1286378056,
-0.0873007104,
-0.4705293477,
-0.2056811303,
-0.107366018,
-0.3084723949,
0.1257109344,
-0.0154428771,
0.7910957932,
0.1532394141,
-0.5144591928,
-0.3177776337,
-0.4194185734,
0.7626091838,
-0.6486512423,
0.288462162,
0.5615471601,
0.5032796264,
-0.2970234454,
-0.6451080441,
-0.3427188098,
-0.3750407994,
-0.1078691706,
-0.0795393586,
0.0813068971,
-0.2095163614,
0.1239764318,
0.531676352,
-0.6702669859,
-0.2780501842,
-0.1135344431,
-0.1892511845,
0.4565875232,
0.30262205,
0.6300820112,
-0.5901568532,
-0.3010647893,
0.2328600883,
-0.7234213948,
-0.1629970372,
0.3804245889,
0.4797520041,
0.2640300095,
0.5839886069,
-0.246418789,
0.9454724193,
0.1562720835,
-0.285860002,
0.177367568,
-0.3676063716,
-0.3491117656,
-0.49458763,
0.4128648639,
0.1209388375,
-0.1779912859,
-0.4005165696,
-0.3627817929,
0.1046285853,
0.5689656138,
-0.3530492485,
0.1853455156,
0.3802616,
-0.2819331884,
-0.585251689,
-0.0860244036,
-0.7817497253,
-0.3786227703,
-0.136839062,
0.5005021095,
-0.4223901331,
-0.5869127512,
-0.0502541624,
-0.0579889603,
0.2223639041,
-0.177116394,
-0.7364177704,
0.489590317,
0.8718852997,
0.4020159841,
-0.249505043,
0.0227836762,
-0.4123807549,
0.0005982044,
-0.2994532287,
0.8655335307,
-0.5580973029,
-0.3948705792,
0.0237752255,
-0.1401387304,
-0.3031307757,
-0.7944378257,
0.7273479104,
-0.7223347425,
0.0635997877,
-0.0993899778,
-0.6078902483,
-0.0494669862,
0.6304340363,
-0.5106016994,
1.2857664824,
0.5642957091,
-0.7997750044,
0.2961900234,
-0.2625023425,
-0.3610940278,
0.130600363,
-0.2019721121,
-0.4187218547,
0.1399301887,
0.0324211605,
0.3194441795,
-0.5591332316,
0.6497340798,
-0.2068050951,
-0.1021204144,
0.1354174912,
-0.0874127373,
0.7410196662,
0.1247855648,
-0.3281483948,
-0.0342559554,
-1.2495743036,
0.3868768215,
0.1777919978,
-0.3163740933,
-0.4648058712,
0.2289846241,
-0.0795472637,
0.0699093193,
0.1926911622,
-0.1580076069,
0.0692108348,
-0.4342983067,
0.0265277419,
0.5284241438,
0.1830673963,
0.3646698594,
-0.3954152465,
0.6873713136,
0.0584441423,
0.1673606187,
-0.3734223843,
-0.2653838098,
-0.9070832133,
-0.1719467938,
0.3237383962,
0.6436164975,
-0.6073701978,
0.5116251707,
-0.214436844,
-0.5406442285,
-0.1120233908,
-0.0097223092,
0.6892427802,
0.8096666932,
0.2633358538,
-0.2429715842,
-0.6950560212,
-0.7688337564,
-0.3897415698,
-0.4602257311,
0.1346907914,
0.4772895873,
0.3059946597,
-0.5465821028,
0.9947015047,
-0.2034116685,
0.0350906663,
-0.1482654661,
-0.0563174784,
0.2085621059,
0.4797541797,
0.5092366338,
-0.8204712868,
-0.2383846939,
0.094664149,
-0.8739853501,
-0.3002710938,
0.2124137878,
-0.1055457965,
0.3101943433,
0.2892754376,
-0.4719253182,
0.3549633324,
0.3501155078,
-0.6423918009,
0.7595488429,
0.3251367509,
0.2712427676,
-0.9361224771,
0.2530941963,
-0.5076307654,
-0.4239981771,
-0.5993297696,
0.5762929916,
0.0655979887,
-0.2528600395,
-0.1917065233,
0.3805125654,
-0.4310326874,
-0.3197958767,
-0.0365031026,
0.0461846255,
0.1529245824,
0.1669780761,
-0.5460294485,
0.8392903209,
0.5428028703,
-0.6652630568,
0.4586104751,
0.1823784411,
-0.3435773551,
0.6144033074,
-0.4968329966,
0.284657836,
0.0746500939,
-0.4481094778,
-0.8780713081,
-0.3908459842,
-0.0447480194,
-0.5785452724,
0.4565161169,
-0.2780962884,
-0.2901565135,
-0.1203178689,
-0.0340904929,
0.392860353,
0.3596807122,
-0.3718693256,
0.639878273,
0.522449255,
-0.2676127851,
-0.7399476171,
-0.4183389246,
0.0796816424,
-0.2259245813,
-0.9930315614,
-0.1055020466,
0.0638463646,
-0.659515202,
0.1975400746,
-0.413736552,
-0.3811329305,
0.5448004603,
0.1824265718,
0.1578631699,
-0.4468229115,
0.1015102491,
0.0815917775,
-0.1105147675,
0.164512068,
-0.1357094646,
0.3287486136,
-0.2543798983,
-0.7210407853,
0.1621384919,
0.3910741806,
0.5707585812,
-0.1567913294,
0.432433337,
0.0231398344,
-0.3738684058,
-0.3782387376,
-0.5760275722,
0.1691842377,
-0.4178231657,
0.3156766295,
-0.540502727,
-0.7184271812,
0.4590398967,
-0.3582495153,
-0.4479117692,
0.6237931848,
0.5566378236,
0.3779394925,
0.6290537715,
0.7842916846,
0.2104458362,
-0.0652834699,
0.0286165159,
0.2564223409,
-0.5515139699,
-0.3922324181,
-0.5810975432,
0.3002881408,
-0.0600852147,
-0.5589078069,
0.3362548649,
0.447498709,
-0.1407995075,
0.1442820728,
-0.2219516337,
0.5050133467,
0.199574545,
-0.2011186033,
0.4808062911,
0.0698975101,
-0.6593571901,
-0.0311793052,
-0.5230036378,
-0.8296966553,
1.0232578516,
0.1619463712,
0.4720217288,
0.3289880157,
0.469550997,
0.5072771311,
0.2261583805,
-0.9185088873,
0.6141129732,
0.1747714579,
-0.8194720149,
-0.0870109722,
-0.4814581871,
-0.5314285755,
0.1842283159,
-0.0969326422,
-0.5174388289,
0.0934142023,
-0.0443330184,
-0.1489810944,
-0.0226309206,
-0.7151273489,
0.8970623612,
-0.1614448726,
-0.366758585,
0.1537041366,
-0.5012943745,
0.6232652068,
-0.4362452924,
0.3926333785,
-0.1278973669,
0.1272199452,
0.3800497353,
-0.480861932,
0.593622148,
-0.1725987196,
0.0205063559,
0.4050653279,
0.425058037,
0.1840909868,
0.2459149063,
-0.3163183033,
-0.1366017908,
0.0711178035,
-0.3121193349,
-0.7358821034,
0.6497452855,
-0.5435394645,
-0.6834900975,
-0.4395677149,
-0.4038876891,
-0.7968841195,
0.4080732167,
-0.071269013,
0.4607595503,
-0.5330831409,
-0.0281730611,
0.5919712186,
-0.3604475558,
0.1506396681,
0.6653447151,
-0.4581196606,
-0.4843553901,
0.7346404195,
-0.0459895357,
0.35737589,
0.0596528538,
-0.0424453914,
0.1589656621,
-0.4382719994,
-0.4729412198,
-0.05926257,
-0.7630793452,
-0.6667147875,
-0.4323196411,
-0.1803642511,
-0.5519548059,
0.068736501,
-0.3668510616,
-0.7091107368,
-0.1014519408,
-0.2999334335,
0.1886820495,
0.754242599,
0.1030427217,
-0.0008837429,
-0.7816212773,
0.4125542641,
0.3637390733,
0.4016800225,
-0.173334673,
-0.3696870804,
-0.2208493799,
-0.1396809965,
-0.361946851,
-0.9655644298,
0.3053115904,
0.1689551771,
0.6716647744,
0.1070317551,
-0.0707481727,
0.7792958021,
-0.6804839373,
0.9337789416,
-0.1680479199,
-1.1018036604,
0.7201894522,
-0.5905804038,
-0.2067388743,
0.6074277163,
0.1210407093,
-0.2008636445,
-0.276671499,
-0.7405076623,
-1.2380313873,
0.5101727843,
-0.0012487961,
0.0958071798,
-0.3717215359,
0.5795487165,
0.0364395566,
0.133683458,
-0.3400141299,
-0.3288680613,
-0.0203972012,
-0.0605541058,
0.3357984126,
-0.706920743,
-0.1755928993,
-0.0985100642,
0.752913475,
-0.0253596045,
0.2324397713,
0.0885213166,
-0.432061404,
-0.2349753529,
0.4057847857,
0.4323166013,
1.0810111761,
-0.2645349205,
-0.0179542396,
-0.0337927118,
-0.3449757993,
0.3858160377,
-0.0900793225,
-0.2097617537,
0.1648924798,
0.3415811956,
0.4929445684,
0.1239566654,
-0.8992648721,
0.7078726888,
-0.0335560702,
0.0551959202,
-0.4035389721,
-0.069377549,
-0.0189691596,
0.0942311734,
0.5045394897,
0.0689288005,
0.248299107,
-0.4140636325,
0.5309274793,
0.4068350196,
-0.2435295135,
-0.2406425625,
0.3851416111,
0.0358222909,
-0.1734795719,
0.3018641472,
-0.1757387221,
-0.3558944166,
0.6736088991,
0.8007025719,
0.9078617096,
-0.2747133076,
0.1759056747,
0.2105643749,
0.4302749634,
0.001566723,
0.4712746739,
0.22293064,
-0.5734516382,
-0.4544715285,
-0.8128210306,
-0.3814249635,
0.0800095722,
-0.9425958395,
0.2120366096,
-0.4131671488,
-0.2914335728,
-0.4235772491,
-0.1073867455,
-0.2100360394,
0.2407411337,
-0.2415078729,
0.9122838974,
-0.8414379954,
0.415691644,
0.9168334603,
-0.4695115685,
-0.7851887345,
0.0033688843,
0.0034838724,
-0.7372691035,
0.9765669703,
-0.1539527029,
-0.0495833233,
-0.2719093561,
-0.3330670893,
-0.9580131173,
0.9690106511,
0.5367503166,
-0.1181554645,
0.2180933952,
0.1807821542,
0.4530196786,
-0.2758078277,
0.0679928586,
0.706453979,
0.4181777537,
-0.0694685355,
-1.0713071823,
0.0457748584,
-0.4134894907,
0.151347965,
0.1634443551,
-0.3837257326,
0.8241897821,
0.1803392172,
-0.3683651388,
0.1873419136,
0.5067682266,
0.210679695,
0.4063127339,
0.3024047017,
0.9396384358,
0.8319485784,
-0.0768605843,
1.0687587261,
-0.2251008004,
0.5471259952,
0.9547511339,
-0.3254187405,
0.9752913117,
0.3796102107,
-0.1246791482,
0.5030989051,
0.2081888914,
0.3077578247,
0.3895194232,
0.3154700398,
-0.3179327548,
-0.2402597219,
-0.016499117,
-0.3689672649,
0.3624338508,
0.5026769042,
-0.1532719433,
-0.3171514869,
-0.0357445776,
-0.0359335914,
0.2705562413,
-0.2677010894,
0.8607138991,
-0.0968542621,
-0.563316226,
0.8587952852,
0.1713847667,
0.1898559481,
-0.3929935992,
-0.0072118682,
-0.5596473813,
0.1919475347,
-0.2738576531,
-0.1699149311,
0.7267068028,
0.2941819727,
-0.4732568562,
-0.0197428968,
1.1847264767,
0.0138273519,
-0.6277745366,
0.2234366238,
0.7863326669,
-0.046669744,
0.1720235795,
-0.5052260756,
0.2391588539,
-0.2426146418,
-0.2685748041,
0.375838697,
0.6735706329,
-0.1192471609,
0.5869269371,
0.3921391964,
0.0163478702,
0.2668025792,
-0.0609612688,
1.1567783356,
-0.6713536978,
-0.0333033577,
-0.6254073381,
0.7047255635,
-0.0074185221,
0.0352435298,
0.9687399268,
0.5262635946,
0.5699252486,
-0.0846605524,
0.8997660875,
-0.3025317192,
0.8899905086,
-0.474270314,
0.636587441,
-0.4368477464,
0.6235926747,
-0.3426423371,
-0.8698874712,
-0.5493776798,
0.4902580678,
-0.0547990017,
0.0426002741,
0.8041411638,
0.8057976365,
-0.1678359807,
-0.3692317307,
0.503485024,
0.2105428874,
0.0622813962,
0.1289129257,
1.0045764446,
-0.5854672194,
0.3692324162,
0.0616685189,
-0.2987703681,
-0.170104295,
-0.9064188004,
-0.774685204,
-0.2733438015,
-0.2313650846,
-0.5081961751,
0.2855642736,
0.5090513229,
0.3654200733,
-0.7991936803,
-0.2764929533,
-0.0690281168,
0.2385381013,
-0.0863257796,
-0.2824674547,
0.2778638005,
-1.0131293535,
-0.2980243266,
0.7499642968,
0.3396372497,
-0.3590453267,
-0.2190728039,
0.2588007748,
-0.2275539637,
0.1048040166,
0.6569652557,
0.2420721054,
-0.560233891,
-0.1880746335,
0.1781949997,
-0.0622936375,
-0.2645411193,
0.8985649347,
-0.8768673539,
0.4572468102,
0.5449014306,
1.0783426762,
-0.081663236,
0.2589984536,
0.6328844428,
-1.0185704231,
0.1748063415,
0.3478811383,
0.2370708138,
0.3876859844,
-0.3757208288,
0.6282084584,
0.4976029098,
-0.6647797823,
-1.0974814892,
0.3571995199,
-0.8314551711,
-0.246895045,
1.4075136185,
-0.1993714124,
-0.2367732972,
-0.3051394522,
0.0218937527,
-0.080126062,
0.2249751091,
0.5725607276,
0.6977677941,
0.1658108085,
0.3119627535,
-0.5953479409,
0.3838440478,
0.4596579373,
-0.7468791604,
-0.006418773,
0.8776200414,
0.4147076011,
0.286865145,
0.6076810956,
-0.4286214709,
0.134170264,
0.1394081414,
-0.0776422843,
-0.0462482832,
-0.2453060448,
-0.336756736,
0.3674674928,
0.3359205425,
0.1585021019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19221v1
|
Transcrib3D: 3D Referring Expression Resolution through Large Language Models
| 2024-04-30T02:48:20 | 2024-04-30T02:48:20 |
Jiading Fang, Xiangshan Tan, Shengjie Lin, Igor Vasiljevic, Vitor Guizilini, Hongyuan Mei, Rares Ambrus, Gregory Shakhnarovich, Matthew R Walter
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
If robots are to work effectively alongside people, they must be able to
interpret natural language references to objects in their 3D environment.
Understanding 3D referring expressions is challenging -- it requires the
ability to both parse the 3D structure of the scene and correctly ground
free-form language in the presence of distraction and clutter. We introduce
Transcrib3D, an approach that brings together 3D detection methods and the
emergent reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs). Transcrib3D
uses text as the unifying medium, which allows us to sidestep the need to learn
shared representations connecting multi-modal inputs, which would require
massive amounts of annotated 3D data. As a demonstration of its effectiveness,
Transcrib3D achieves state-of-the-art results on 3D reference resolution
benchmarks, with a great leap in performance from previous multi-modality
baselines. To improve upon zero-shot performance and facilitate local
deployment on edge computers and robots, we propose self-correction for
fine-tuning that trains smaller models, resulting in performance close to that
of large models. We show that our method enables a real robot to perform
pick-and-place tasks given queries that contain challenging referring
expressions. Project site is at https://ripl.github.io/Transcrib3D.
|
[
-0.1523049027,
-0.554895401,
0.7442893386,
-0.0321689323,
-0.1655780822,
0.002397866,
0.1517326087,
-0.8682592511,
-0.0465086401,
0.766531229,
-0.5099082589,
-0.3749833107,
-0.5159447193,
0.4255703986,
-0.3904024363,
0.3132513762,
-0.0396513864,
-0.1080376655,
-0.2641640306,
-0.2907918394,
-0.1756404936,
-0.4459795952,
-0.4218719602,
-0.1080137566,
0.3311235905,
0.3754689693,
1.1434417963,
1.1447974443,
0.6652915478,
0.3565158844,
0.0242105592,
0.236139819,
-0.1853405684,
-0.0681855008,
-0.3238776624,
-0.3394134939,
-0.3184448779,
-0.3398436904,
0.6958664656,
0.8806505203,
0.1595639288,
-0.0247737169,
-0.039745979,
0.7664008737,
-0.556643784,
-0.0168331489,
-0.3607033193,
0.1697497964,
-0.1532273442,
-0.0296790171,
-0.2015807778,
-0.0577775985,
0.1381412297,
-0.7636009455,
0.5701224804,
-0.1411513537,
0.5487583876,
0.5292637944,
-0.3585443795,
-0.1324404478,
-0.8485099673,
0.6077041626,
-0.6119211912,
0.5511038899,
0.2540540695,
0.4711825252,
-0.106265001,
-0.6304350495,
-0.6715906858,
-0.1718235165,
0.0035741257,
0.0137328831,
-0.2311856449,
0.0349123701,
0.3872593939,
0.3552882969,
-0.6297895908,
-0.0694448501,
-0.5764526725,
-0.4158862233,
0.4050914049,
0.0816509277,
0.2626489997,
0.006012491,
-0.3234060705,
-0.3146691024,
-0.7001926899,
-0.5198312402,
0.1935838461,
0.6548948884,
-0.1234412044,
0.6362653375,
-0.2644999325,
1.0905106068,
-0.0035711958,
0.125122875,
0.3332118988,
-0.1896334738,
-0.0962306932,
0.0381430052,
0.8090232015,
0.329982549,
0.24189201,
0.0459441729,
0.0120580839,
-0.2277691811,
0.3516494036,
-0.5325514674,
-0.1026290953,
0.0623585284,
-0.3543573618,
0.2434082627,
-0.2133491933,
-0.7183933258,
-0.7266454101,
-0.259185195,
0.4409949183,
-0.2990342081,
-0.369210124,
0.5360313058,
-0.0128156599,
-0.0736844838,
0.6198664904,
-0.5976637602,
-0.0073392149,
0.3398668766,
0.922373116,
0.055986423,
-0.2471662611,
-0.6018288136,
0.6811375618,
-0.3500646353,
1.0565774441,
-0.5404626727,
-0.6258094907,
0.0825924277,
-0.1535155624,
0.0812590048,
-0.883936286,
0.2059542239,
-0.0815883577,
0.4670726061,
0.4012155235,
-0.2227446288,
-0.2669037282,
0.3378931284,
-1.0582262278,
0.8237498403,
0.3968520761,
-0.1766409427,
-0.2228031456,
-0.6842175722,
-0.4113685787,
0.1539998651,
-0.0605133399,
-0.0454242453,
0.103522867,
0.2064785659,
0.4500370622,
-0.3739266396,
-0.2454546541,
-0.2525263727,
-0.1062250286,
-0.212228477,
-0.0886911154,
0.4347074926,
0.1172149107,
-0.0118318368,
0.2208564728,
-0.6781613827,
-0.1344973296,
0.0833860561,
-0.1016713381,
-0.1180078089,
-0.2286757082,
-0.3866612613,
0.4249054492,
0.3259937465,
-0.4907906651,
0.0450898036,
-0.4446887076,
0.16220285,
0.3406638801,
-0.3606767654,
0.3590295315,
-0.19831343,
0.5084318519,
0.1106293276,
0.1727086455,
-0.2098898888,
-0.4078242779,
-0.4586804807,
-0.1361509413,
-0.0114755537,
0.406183809,
-1.052459836,
0.2613158822,
-0.4219898283,
-0.4523940384,
-0.448490411,
0.2627375424,
0.2008399367,
0.7178065181,
0.6594426036,
0.0596473143,
-0.4490666687,
-1.1179202795,
-0.2015734017,
-0.346516341,
-0.7315384746,
0.0317369103,
0.0603543334,
-0.1397140175,
0.7513719201,
-0.3424078822,
-0.6620694399,
-0.4447545707,
0.207170397,
0.2162521929,
0.3697877228,
0.3975639939,
-0.8589930534,
-0.2314718664,
0.1319810897,
-0.5350542068,
-0.1492680758,
-0.2141358405,
0.0155923245,
0.1860690564,
0.9409680963,
-0.4295519888,
0.2618002295,
0.7977331281,
-0.303093791,
0.0522477403,
-0.1307370663,
-0.0763357878,
-0.9654307365,
0.0717098787,
0.2546401322,
-0.4765819907,
-0.4711267352,
-0.0217304062,
-0.050582733,
-0.1123705432,
-0.8160982132,
0.4882788956,
-0.5318107605,
-0.1982541233,
-0.3616778851,
0.4939008355,
0.1631893069,
0.3843334019,
0.614289999,
0.6790878177,
0.2432248592,
-0.7255378366,
0.5217334032,
0.2580359876,
-0.2912293077,
0.375300318,
-0.6163185239,
0.2053412348,
0.1257869303,
0.2355357856,
-0.7658587694,
-0.1152202263,
0.3186749518,
-0.3734053373,
0.0438315086,
-0.0865115672,
-0.6112928391,
-0.2911284566,
-0.1146273687,
0.7183698416,
0.0633914992,
-0.5359573364,
1.1731666327,
0.4437292516,
0.2226876169,
-0.2418534905,
-0.4752341211,
0.1438494772,
0.1319366246,
-0.4070723653,
0.4420874417,
-0.1228852123,
0.1044396684,
-0.0260719098,
-0.2493818551,
-0.0686279982,
-0.0715769008,
-0.0516846515,
0.2786235213,
-0.0879582688,
-0.1783918589,
-0.3836396635,
-0.3116572797,
0.0548356213,
0.0138336802,
0.5749483705,
-0.2325673401,
-0.3545313179,
-0.3091582358,
0.2138943523,
0.6340463758,
0.153319627,
0.2414757907,
0.4600630999,
-0.5412546396,
0.0241954736,
-0.3987103999,
0.019140821,
-0.5052998066,
0.5978776217,
-0.5487232804,
-0.867857039,
0.3448977172,
-0.4459587336,
-0.0378193185,
0.5479964018,
0.441501826,
0.0140232081,
1.1227674484,
0.6257667542,
0.445002377,
0.3721162975,
-0.0641626418,
0.266448319,
-1.0830672979,
-0.3102956712,
-0.7389519811,
-0.2351861447,
-0.3188296258,
-0.9035920501,
0.2867569327,
0.0014948109,
-0.2292845547,
0.6608310342,
-0.5486471653,
0.602178514,
0.4621461034,
0.0788895339,
0.3752755821,
-0.2157003433,
-0.0453111008,
0.1143017411,
-0.4789772034,
-0.5356662869,
0.4443547428,
0.3315329254,
0.6004090905,
0.1890141815,
0.150371626,
0.2513790727,
0.0650189146,
-0.8725957274,
0.9173848629,
-0.2488879263,
-0.5280213356,
-0.2226987481,
-0.5051810145,
-0.7559857368,
0.3052829206,
-0.1427826136,
-0.665484786,
0.1017713919,
0.0780342892,
-0.4741612375,
0.5842363238,
-0.4374749959,
0.9318609834,
-0.1541863978,
-0.523562789,
-0.2748051286,
-0.702783525,
0.0904070958,
0.0617177673,
0.0517543852,
-0.3840989769,
-0.0998741388,
0.4664027095,
-0.1255046874,
0.8832637072,
0.041477859,
-0.5534538627,
0.2007776052,
0.7112386227,
0.1174767464,
-0.2073391229,
-0.1882981956,
0.6900743842,
0.0878614709,
-0.1222569123,
-0.8655047417,
0.4620510042,
-0.6107594371,
-0.7123727798,
-0.3429011703,
-0.7077454329,
-0.5217099786,
0.3933497667,
-0.1096771806,
0.2489790022,
-0.0661558732,
0.2578280866,
0.440582037,
-0.3235143423,
0.2596455812,
0.63129884,
-0.3263756037,
-0.2262598425,
0.6751692891,
-0.3142516911,
0.3446897268,
0.8251896501,
0.1393651068,
-0.5125145912,
-0.4310209453,
-0.6040703654,
0.3383141458,
-0.5349892378,
-0.5833969116,
-0.47656551,
-0.1441920996,
-0.3332990706,
-0.2115837634,
-0.6836538911,
-0.6349374652,
-0.3257160783,
0.0069802608,
0.0469919965,
0.7861587405,
-0.4877689779,
0.2990825772,
-1.1843146086,
0.8604112864,
0.242345199,
0.4754509032,
-0.3023971319,
-0.4562404752,
-0.3018713295,
0.2565172017,
-0.168656379,
-0.2960313559,
0.2788867652,
-0.0082951812,
0.3441473842,
0.1775757968,
0.0543218292,
0.8827080131,
-0.3895539343,
0.739413023,
0.2905957103,
-1.0962631702,
0.7406517267,
-0.2454818934,
0.6900758147,
0.4440001845,
0.340552628,
-0.7121394873,
-0.3567880988,
-0.2548725307,
-0.6862837076,
0.7873228788,
-0.1170929223,
0.1248354167,
-0.0744436681,
0.3031640053,
-0.0527101979,
-0.185693115,
-0.6362296343,
0.1718152612,
-0.2867738605,
-0.3916147649,
0.1475368589,
-0.1671678573,
-0.0825692713,
-0.14438501,
0.3613969684,
-0.4202857316,
0.41654405,
0.2620191574,
-0.2090627551,
-0.3720160127,
-0.3104141057,
0.6334680915,
0.6875549555,
-0.2708905041,
0.1943819076,
-0.0047303499,
-0.419608295,
-0.2314174175,
-0.1376999766,
0.3066846728,
0.0988579988,
0.5793830156,
0.3561043441,
0.0830142498,
-0.7257856131,
0.3299423456,
-0.1519614458,
-0.2216979116,
-0.1012918055,
0.0893862247,
-0.1059726402,
0.09562774,
0.4473833144,
0.1727033854,
0.1684645563,
-0.4618192315,
0.1315642595,
0.2870320976,
-0.5921450853,
-0.2826472819,
0.5446648002,
0.4361998141,
-0.304544121,
0.8667845726,
0.353793025,
-0.4480057657,
0.6246429682,
0.7331699133,
0.950856626,
-0.3975428641,
0.2296112925,
0.5984915495,
0.2799089551,
-0.1361166388,
-0.063307032,
-0.0322404876,
-1.1280890703,
-0.5884533525,
-0.2906731665,
-0.6917364597,
0.168585822,
-0.4652743638,
0.1913966984,
-0.5884007812,
0.1572255939,
-0.1671092212,
-0.2725788355,
-0.5551831722,
0.090013288,
0.5114353299,
0.9257098436,
-0.4268426597,
0.6448619366,
0.7987964749,
-0.1040513813,
-0.4084897637,
0.1495817304,
0.0240708161,
-0.9851018786,
0.6499000788,
0.4302899539,
-0.7590138912,
-0.0496068262,
-0.4209115207,
-0.9087163806,
0.7001419663,
0.5285252333,
-0.5606918931,
0.0421889909,
0.5305234194,
0.5381401181,
-0.2617218494,
0.2875190377,
0.2968370914,
0.4497977197,
0.4798712432,
-1.0515310764,
0.1676024348,
-0.1759410501,
0.0964614078,
0.223562628,
-0.5372738242,
0.3756553531,
-0.2043812871,
-0.4880474508,
-0.0123578878,
0.8953688145,
0.084317632,
-0.0795637667,
0.7143113613,
0.4731930494,
0.2996812463,
0.0848791227,
0.9157847762,
-0.3025661707,
-0.0273863971,
1.1640924215,
-0.6558340788,
0.664740622,
0.3121850789,
0.0085774744,
0.6019126773,
0.3126266301,
0.1273735762,
0.4560417831,
-0.0072347107,
-0.1997686028,
-0.576076746,
-0.3262050748,
-0.0578251742,
0.5406578779,
0.5578957796,
0.1308307201,
-0.6128737926,
0.0593056269,
-0.3350538313,
0.4120018482,
-0.3992304206,
0.7563163042,
-0.1109964475,
-0.3562755287,
0.3128833175,
-0.2352369577,
0.3765439689,
-0.627905786,
-0.5072945356,
-0.1587523371,
0.4676721394,
-0.1408913136,
-1.0491344929,
0.7080338597,
-0.3169518113,
0.037983153,
-0.4125701487,
0.3330937028,
-0.2612229586,
-0.575191319,
0.5081470013,
0.4541885555,
0.0084073171,
-0.17732732,
-0.7135759592,
0.0713110939,
0.0828607902,
0.0130370669,
0.1845225841,
0.7146955729,
0.0145470807,
0.8725021482,
0.4922706485,
-0.0811206773,
-0.3029057086,
0.1219701245,
0.7080250978,
-0.7220401168,
-0.1117012277,
-0.6934509277,
0.3301892281,
-0.0056366688,
-0.298747927,
0.5173186064,
0.8140425086,
1.0839076042,
-0.1348090023,
0.3896354437,
0.0500765368,
0.86996907,
-0.472327292,
-0.0110769561,
-0.5345840454,
0.1148877218,
-0.1485651433,
-0.8897180557,
-1.0460546017,
1.0046014786,
-0.1524794549,
0.00975064,
0.6492731571,
0.7966691256,
-0.1304491758,
-0.2436210215,
0.5304579139,
0.1421812773,
0.4311008751,
0.6903709173,
0.9548627734,
-0.4310557544,
0.8708236814,
-0.3092703819,
0.0772676766,
-0.1281428784,
-1.0870848894,
-0.7552519441,
-0.7341650128,
-0.5937208533,
-0.3623915613,
-0.2127234787,
0.7835572958,
0.5235167146,
-0.6169772744,
-0.3261932731,
0.0736734569,
0.1996981651,
-0.2790512741,
-0.2148834169,
0.246845901,
0.0558112822,
-0.9751343727,
0.6154049635,
0.4745493531,
0.2546738982,
-0.2343529165,
0.1359168291,
-0.2484451532,
-0.1285293102,
0.6755195856,
0.5300971866,
-0.3747936487,
-0.5148020983,
-0.1271849573,
-0.1547140777,
0.238400802,
0.9263082147,
-1.1807184219,
0.4395651221,
0.4488431215,
0.4627015889,
0.4839927256,
0.0899661034,
0.834954679,
-0.5622156262,
0.2090844959,
0.5558758378,
0.3592500985,
0.6538524032,
-0.3690533638,
0.8930433989,
-0.0524445362,
-0.2206024379,
-0.5571359992,
0.4300492406,
-1.0795193911,
-0.4664526582,
0.9152013659,
0.1997265071,
-0.3901102841,
-0.2521422803,
-0.1980193555,
0.1561344266,
-0.087140508,
0.8617431521,
0.4467480183,
-0.3132267594,
-0.4147634804,
-0.3763220012,
0.4101320505,
0.1634896249,
-0.5953515172,
0.4419367313,
0.8179616928,
-0.102590993,
0.5949111581,
0.3456246257,
-0.3636594415,
0.253485024,
-0.2528060377,
0.2705089748,
-0.2541497648,
-0.4329383671,
-0.2188945264,
0.1473179609,
-0.2729631662,
-0.2021766901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19192v1
|
Mix of Experts Language Model for Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-04-30T01:41:03 | 2024-04-30T01:41:03 |
Xinwei Chen, Kun Li, Tianyou Song, Jiangjian Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is an essential steppingstone in the field of
natural language processing. Although promising performance has been achieved
by various distantly supervised models, we argue that distant supervision
inevitably introduces incomplete and noisy annotations, which may mislead the
model training process. To address this issue, we propose a robust NER model
named BOND-MoE based on Mixture of Experts (MoE). Instead of relying on a
single model for NER prediction, multiple models are trained and ensembled
under the Expectation-Maximization (EM) framework, so that noisy supervision
can be dramatically alleviated. In addition, we introduce a fair assignment
module to balance the document-model assignment process. Extensive experiments
on real-world datasets show that the proposed method achieves state-of-the-art
performance compared with other distantly supervised NER.
|
[
-0.4998594522,
-0.7589523196,
0.5782651305,
0.052840922,
-0.1329748929,
0.0740808472,
-0.3903250992,
-0.7842580676,
0.4210436344,
0.546713233,
-0.0579629429,
-0.3082375526,
-0.8429262042,
0.3252792656,
-0.4102419615,
1.0862568617,
0.1016446277,
0.0749811605,
-0.1659629792,
-0.0091423932,
-0.331389904,
-0.2845942974,
-0.905389905,
-0.2205145806,
0.370177716,
0.3732759356,
0.5176302791,
0.7227367759,
0.6920419931,
0.3263200819,
-0.2267382592,
0.2458333969,
-0.2030167431,
0.2118950039,
-0.2904209495,
-0.3581280708,
-0.9161830544,
-0.2456505448,
0.6136667728,
0.6791856885,
-0.4667685032,
-0.2171869278,
-0.1267711967,
0.2945024669,
-0.6055043936,
0.1336493939,
-0.9468697906,
-0.2073729783,
-0.1863711178,
0.0457012542,
-0.5099027157,
-0.1448408663,
0.3649742305,
-0.735776186,
0.3859388232,
0.2785149515,
1.1696099043,
0.2095249146,
-0.4266653657,
-0.1712791622,
-0.7748436332,
0.8285358548,
-0.7988354564,
0.4248050153,
0.4879774749,
0.2009919584,
-0.3063312173,
-0.3264220059,
-0.597525835,
0.0201521777,
0.1120457351,
-0.0155175179,
-0.0118450504,
0.1692973226,
-0.0634411648,
0.4505333602,
-0.0921144262,
0.2618199587,
-0.4023091793,
-0.1702436954,
0.6822367907,
-0.1164829135,
0.3574028313,
0.0651948676,
-0.5791153908,
0.1996447146,
-0.2976510823,
-0.2150523812,
0.4641444981,
0.464882195,
0.0015435811,
0.483648181,
-0.3943350017,
0.6852192879,
0.4664463699,
-0.3513631523,
0.2383106947,
0.1830204278,
-0.0847934484,
0.3790102601,
0.8282917738,
0.3949062526,
0.3991129398,
-0.5783382058,
-0.4934680462,
-0.0664013401,
0.1205961257,
-0.6729950905,
-0.5171592832,
-0.0019749915,
-0.0065311533,
-0.3372936845,
0.0775552541,
-0.8920660615,
-0.2253063321,
-0.403884232,
0.3718241155,
-0.5134326816,
-0.7286615968,
-0.194399029,
-0.0648059547,
-0.158432439,
0.399299413,
-1.0929269791,
0.6658972502,
0.6811597943,
0.5066732764,
-0.174542591,
-0.1916862279,
-0.6760808825,
0.5300811529,
-0.0672665238,
0.9467912912,
-0.7628029585,
-0.1118052751,
-0.4049933255,
-0.2057126015,
-0.2647826672,
-0.6330912113,
0.2833912969,
-0.6108056307,
0.1335279047,
0.1119610518,
-0.8794585466,
-0.088883087,
0.1897667199,
-0.8154851794,
1.0305701494,
0.1328304708,
-0.9713557959,
0.7426531911,
-0.3904013634,
-0.3829205036,
0.194808051,
-0.2425299585,
-0.4208396971,
-0.0257510953,
0.4361610115,
0.6274741292,
0.0745066479,
0.816770494,
-0.4502302706,
-0.0272167306,
0.2955039442,
-0.1823957264,
0.3179747164,
0.109749727,
-0.1270483881,
-0.1684706211,
-1.1000580788,
-0.3000384271,
-0.0871752426,
-0.468803525,
-0.8780543208,
0.0143136531,
0.1043482423,
0.0502111167,
0.1154072955,
-0.6058456302,
0.1019922644,
-0.4958786368,
0.3305608034,
0.56930691,
0.2056619227,
0.9071515799,
-0.1128569916,
0.3916589618,
0.2590337396,
-0.297208339,
0.0810582116,
-0.4979490638,
-0.9969995618,
-0.6123681068,
0.5687060952,
0.6504856348,
-0.5408174396,
0.3575945795,
-0.4358631968,
-0.3029531837,
-0.5915253758,
0.3050125539,
0.2793156505,
0.6089707017,
0.497767061,
-0.2456406951,
-0.5034443736,
-1.0858002901,
-0.2823930979,
-0.2332236171,
0.1739795953,
0.2259668708,
0.3355214596,
-0.1560252458,
1.1023055315,
-0.1363061368,
-0.4700964093,
-0.1852842122,
0.1700677276,
0.1799688786,
0.5746859312,
0.2477816045,
-0.8497729301,
-0.422190845,
0.1045930013,
-0.5909150839,
0.0203620233,
-0.0379357375,
-0.1005517691,
0.0219951905,
0.5081991553,
-0.5520754457,
0.0000461488,
0.230866164,
0.0446395166,
0.161593467,
-0.1356867254,
-0.2474920601,
-1.4610444307,
-0.1831218004,
0.2544073462,
-0.4964798391,
-0.5424999595,
0.0926306471,
-0.1281290203,
0.2337926477,
-0.1252611876,
0.6187703013,
-0.8955731988,
0.3155860603,
-0.2602870166,
0.238976106,
-0.1549965739,
0.3126865625,
0.3466760516,
0.4857951403,
0.6847516894,
-0.658366859,
0.2051481307,
0.123296842,
-0.2159598917,
0.8111675978,
-0.5249246955,
0.1016468182,
-0.202278614,
-0.1035218909,
-0.5274168253,
-0.6039757133,
0.1757650077,
-0.3578837514,
0.7878561616,
-0.3322171867,
-0.2442473471,
-0.0045926669,
0.3506132364,
0.334856838,
0.2662601769,
-0.3303751349,
0.8225497603,
0.7867919803,
-0.5001463294,
-0.5686886907,
-0.7870412469,
0.2768210471,
-0.3788485229,
-0.4661934078,
0.5297564268,
0.3321835399,
-0.396438092,
0.194526732,
-0.175104171,
-0.8076000214,
0.0253634006,
0.3393609226,
0.2708146274,
-0.3110880256,
0.0741845369,
0.1817878783,
-0.1789298356,
-0.0037514635,
0.2123167366,
-0.0345914364,
-0.1657439619,
-0.0433555767,
-0.2910857797,
0.4655930698,
0.2789869308,
-0.2181940824,
0.7408928871,
0.5103171468,
-0.6580811143,
-0.3838928342,
-0.8654548526,
-0.0536324941,
-0.4264487624,
0.3651026487,
-0.4621180296,
-0.8504974246,
0.5072315931,
-0.0717956945,
-0.0709880441,
0.3501580358,
0.2700996697,
0.1136590093,
0.5291728377,
0.8351683021,
-0.2182848155,
0.4147524834,
0.1144143939,
0.4660409987,
-0.7712202072,
-0.2748568654,
-0.2610852122,
-0.0405561589,
-0.4241202772,
-0.0937618762,
-0.1656877249,
0.4732430577,
0.1885820478,
0.6607800722,
-0.5479130745,
0.5152482986,
0.543320179,
0.1685974747,
0.3496376574,
0.1092356071,
-0.2432340533,
-0.0150644304,
-0.584669292,
-0.7201282978,
0.7882176638,
0.2617628276,
0.7633643746,
0.0177893918,
1.3019032478,
0.0916552395,
0.3908711076,
-0.4831748903,
0.6233079433,
0.1496395171,
-0.9313283563,
-0.2087872028,
-0.5202051401,
-0.8257299662,
0.1697885841,
-0.237681374,
-0.9788449407,
0.496243,
0.0599461831,
-0.4707255065,
0.4463194013,
-0.6339778304,
0.541973114,
0.0607422851,
-0.1031581908,
0.0191428922,
-0.7068378925,
0.3814734519,
-0.212271288,
0.4651909769,
-0.2678109109,
0.0435350947,
0.7982575297,
-0.3556082547,
0.4719339013,
-0.0275471974,
-0.015223287,
0.3130008578,
0.0515621528,
0.6059476137,
0.2115660012,
-0.1819733977,
0.0508553796,
-0.2730261683,
-0.2000333667,
-0.2492747754,
0.6992952824,
-0.6414911747,
-0.3345232606,
-0.3822181821,
-0.6029022336,
0.0372573584,
0.3790901899,
0.3030395508,
0.2960762382,
-0.1897128522,
-0.0181567296,
0.6892545223,
0.1690080166,
0.5643305779,
0.4354356229,
-0.2708291411,
-0.5844662786,
1.1585288048,
0.2803636193,
0.128071934,
0.5645312071,
-0.3727277219,
0.139550969,
-0.5312631726,
-0.4079016745,
-0.006969145,
-0.5140311122,
-0.1710376292,
-1.1153291464,
-0.1757361591,
-0.2872551084,
-0.1273898929,
-0.674541533,
-0.3474800289,
-0.5718982816,
-0.2748293877,
0.3370278776,
0.5955216885,
0.0890164524,
0.3708759248,
-0.7027232647,
0.4126464725,
0.3731635511,
0.3403641284,
-0.1205930337,
-0.3579231799,
-0.1886713803,
-0.0856982842,
0.0507526137,
-1.0518460274,
0.4368478656,
0.517291069,
0.7830530405,
0.6158415675,
0.2317040116,
0.6369993687,
-0.4604921043,
0.3618220091,
0.0348167792,
-0.7566500306,
0.3626123667,
-0.5344663262,
-0.3626441061,
0.814066112,
0.0796397626,
0.0451722853,
-0.8229408264,
-0.7627872825,
-1.2333030701,
0.6066765189,
0.1758290529,
-0.0455903485,
-0.2582766712,
0.1301036477,
0.2572287917,
0.1817985773,
-0.8942589164,
-0.2102429122,
0.2784318328,
-0.2513967454,
0.3385599554,
-0.2105307132,
0.2422646135,
-0.0704700872,
0.8938222528,
0.2050034553,
0.2717049718,
0.2007561326,
-0.3561219573,
-0.2410153002,
0.6939432621,
0.1803222299,
0.3949971795,
-0.5023981929,
0.139863342,
0.3160462677,
-0.2583438754,
0.1081147343,
0.4795073569,
-0.2781160772,
0.3230326772,
0.2174792588,
0.757815659,
0.3789776862,
-0.2937736213,
0.5120054483,
0.1397867501,
-0.1024542302,
-0.3419281542,
0.2944111228,
0.1713852584,
0.2654433548,
0.5186338425,
0.5114433765,
0.2112385482,
-0.1040311679,
0.3269555867,
0.2241388261,
-0.3111747801,
-0.2710029483,
0.9171065688,
0.2029418945,
-0.3352540433,
0.6738268733,
-0.4923042357,
-0.4723937511,
0.7198290229,
0.4699083865,
0.7351501584,
-0.2980585992,
-0.0310212579,
0.2575107813,
0.392860204,
-0.3636098504,
0.2311672717,
0.0306033548,
-0.8609341383,
-0.3913682699,
-0.7161194086,
-0.4594671726,
-0.117412217,
-1.0179086924,
0.394282937,
-0.3231590986,
-0.5024808645,
0.3025069237,
-0.3660972118,
-0.6625221372,
0.3575716913,
0.3535894752,
0.5176389813,
-0.7877477407,
0.8938757181,
0.9901331663,
-0.3968455493,
-0.9882538915,
-0.2194543034,
-0.2509245872,
-0.3446167409,
0.6106589437,
0.4371190965,
0.1504382193,
0.2027987242,
-0.2835016251,
-0.8944199085,
0.8523657918,
0.4650202692,
-0.8548315167,
-0.1575234085,
-0.2626374662,
0.4840734601,
-0.4591185749,
0.3899854422,
0.0533477776,
0.4043026865,
-0.1767008752,
-1.045553565,
-0.1408877969,
-0.4075182974,
-0.1421978027,
0.3753029406,
-0.5636594296,
0.9448350072,
-0.3426660597,
-0.2890199125,
0.0888067111,
1.0448608398,
0.2605702877,
0.5647239685,
0.5736573339,
0.8625047803,
0.9120070934,
0.0800753906,
0.8307669163,
-0.2506169379,
0.3970189393,
1.5419363976,
-0.486119777,
1.0169979334,
0.6021553874,
-0.3280754387,
0.5388890505,
0.5852338076,
-0.2216286808,
0.5036092401,
-0.0873859227,
-0.3666551709,
-0.4748855531,
-0.2434746474,
-0.3960873187,
0.1956727356,
0.3018950224,
-0.5255842209,
-0.2425999045,
-0.1250627786,
-0.0945703238,
0.0007815168,
-0.2037836462,
0.9113761187,
0.3343627453,
-0.4730282426,
-0.0080962209,
0.1005536392,
0.8913546205,
-0.0827529579,
-0.0784637555,
0.0416408293,
0.2080575526,
-0.2291226089,
-0.4775355458,
-0.0122968536,
-0.0415801555,
-0.5371850729,
0.1025575995,
0.8724324107,
-0.8986334801,
-0.7553110719,
0.3491218686,
0.4962116182,
0.4752493799,
-0.0537227206,
-0.3030789495,
-0.7297673225,
-0.2846625149,
-0.3265361488,
0.3641492128,
0.5517129898,
-0.0404786095,
0.7027847171,
0.5134571195,
0.2023703456,
0.496044606,
-0.0490168072,
0.7498585582,
-0.4044780433,
-0.4514386952,
-0.913120985,
0.2861271501,
-0.1211091205,
-0.3410356343,
0.7367847562,
0.5475434065,
0.92757833,
0.1145983487,
0.5634968281,
-0.0253722183,
0.5910242796,
-0.2145240605,
0.6536657214,
-0.407625854,
0.1680344045,
-0.6437595487,
-1.1603447199,
-0.3401029706,
0.5245707631,
-0.2249113321,
0.1408123076,
0.2898329198,
0.796102345,
-0.366630584,
-0.0397180095,
0.1599305868,
0.0648052469,
-0.0143798813,
0.4750025272,
0.7453761101,
-0.3296546042,
0.3504545987,
-0.4617063701,
0.2284320742,
-0.2634469867,
-0.850271523,
-0.9398695827,
-0.155805245,
-0.7161383629,
-0.0445021093,
0.073338531,
1.0982282162,
0.7865383625,
-1.0314902067,
0.270277828,
-0.2887366712,
0.0478088595,
-0.0442367457,
-0.268462956,
0.1962747276,
-0.182065919,
-0.8777140975,
0.5194965005,
0.2494586408,
-0.0030322531,
0.2046029121,
-0.1269304007,
-0.411634624,
-0.158325091,
0.0535501018,
0.0647520348,
-0.8364636302,
0.0624497645,
-0.2841081321,
-0.3872869909,
0.1085520163,
0.2148321569,
-0.5138728619,
0.6318624616,
0.3820770383,
0.7491265535,
0.1557543576,
0.1293454915,
0.5942649841,
-0.6869986653,
-0.0672983527,
0.1589269936,
0.5894626379,
0.5151955485,
-0.630897522,
0.4498264492,
0.1550066322,
-0.6418400407,
-0.9391187429,
-0.3056708574,
-1.2187594175,
0.0753557459,
1.1610082388,
-0.3104635179,
-0.0497617498,
-0.287594676,
-0.0236592144,
0.4986844361,
-1.0306646824,
0.527169168,
0.8761957288,
0.1649302542,
-0.322882086,
-0.6339033246,
-0.0702192336,
0.5521543026,
-0.5241561532,
-0.4432484508,
0.3949509859,
0.5350660086,
0.1618480533,
0.5058709383,
0.2034343034,
-0.0574964434,
0.016613761,
0.307964772,
-0.2121947408,
-0.4035540521,
-0.2260346562,
0.1969121546,
0.1999873668,
-0.055076737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00740v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00740v3
|
Modeling Caption Diversity in Contrastive Vision-Language Pretraining
| 2024-04-30T01:19:18 | 2024-05-14T12:48:45 |
Samuel Lavoie, Polina Kirichenko, Mark Ibrahim, Mahmoud Assran, Andrew Gordon Wilson, Aaron Courville, Nicolas Ballas
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
There are a thousand ways to caption an image. Contrastive Language
Pretraining (CLIP) on the other hand, works by mapping an image and its caption
to a single vector -- limiting how well CLIP-like models can represent the
diverse ways to describe an image. In this work, we introduce Llip, Latent
Language Image Pretraining, which models the diversity of captions that could
match an image. Llip's vision encoder outputs a set of visual features that are
mixed into a final representation by conditioning on information derived from
the text. We show that Llip outperforms non-contextualized baselines like CLIP
and SigLIP on a variety of tasks even with large-scale encoders. Llip improves
zero-shot classification by an average of 2.9% zero-shot classification
benchmarks with a ViT-G/14 encoder. Specifically, Llip attains a zero-shot
top-1 accuracy of 83.5% on ImageNet outperforming a similarly sized CLIP by
1.4%. We also demonstrate improvement on zero-shot retrieval on MS-COCO by
6.0%. We provide a comprehensive analysis of the components introduced by the
method and demonstrate that Llip leads to richer visual representations.
|
[
-0.428979218,
-0.1459578872,
0.2452875525,
0.294184655,
-0.7247131467,
0.4262877405,
-0.0411811285,
-0.5175767541,
0.3931078911,
0.5068156123,
-0.432049185,
-0.5255155563,
-0.7586835027,
0.2060634941,
-0.2559997141,
0.7771715522,
-0.1207185686,
0.4075307846,
-0.2346372455,
-0.2973634899,
-0.5574322343,
-0.4993765652,
-0.0442521274,
-0.1348854601,
0.3390528262,
0.6179184914,
0.4297554195,
0.3938514292,
0.762624383,
0.2683691978,
-0.0172693226,
-0.0917124376,
-0.6626225114,
-0.0951841325,
0.0271662418,
-0.8545311689,
0.0053678569,
0.0693874657,
0.6523942351,
0.6345795393,
0.1083054841,
-0.2683691084,
0.0966451615,
0.5045162439,
-0.7975773215,
-0.0574910417,
-0.7477093339,
0.3888816237,
-0.1707991958,
-0.3116748929,
-0.22214894,
0.0400699079,
0.0821873248,
-0.5372076035,
0.3188659251,
0.0883584246,
1.0345627069,
0.3338123262,
-0.0838259757,
0.1651280969,
-0.4141713381,
1.0431748629,
-0.5644286275,
0.3333565891,
0.1107475236,
0.332510829,
0.1737504154,
-0.5919073224,
-0.5866948366,
-0.0907984748,
0.0969988778,
0.4299198687,
0.003728773,
0.0907571912,
0.109355405,
0.5439500213,
-0.1825899482,
0.3693751991,
-0.4812740088,
-0.1171367988,
0.4508024156,
0.0801688656,
0.4289629459,
0.0357958972,
-0.5690936446,
-0.3048937917,
-0.8437286615,
-0.1175520569,
0.2283363491,
0.0446157344,
-0.4548411071,
0.5746340752,
-0.1138356403,
0.5980241299,
0.0192125384,
-0.2445202917,
0.4226116836,
-0.3243485391,
-0.1603947729,
-0.2842103243,
0.7936108112,
0.86499089,
0.4441599548,
-0.1676605493,
-0.126549229,
-0.0149747105,
-0.0965672433,
-0.9138737321,
-0.3114382327,
-0.0622225106,
-0.2967442274,
-0.3485023081,
0.133543849,
-0.8962438703,
-0.3420217633,
-0.1091162413,
0.2623299658,
-0.4269846678,
0.2542304099,
0.0171457361,
-0.2645614147,
0.6304535866,
0.5208294392,
-0.858446002,
0.4660485983,
0.1678011566,
1.0189843178,
-0.7564616799,
-0.4828911126,
-0.6580575109,
-0.0077662519,
-0.2916661799,
1.0354909897,
-0.5915042758,
-0.246078521,
0.0358325578,
-0.147115469,
0.0723285228,
-0.7286188006,
0.070392333,
-0.4896454513,
0.083147414,
-0.2185570598,
-0.3685182631,
0.0342435017,
0.2840422392,
-0.7751869559,
0.5208749175,
0.0660047531,
-0.9873429537,
0.5556281805,
-0.4526106715,
-0.3348012865,
0.2106141299,
-0.6335306764,
-0.4660027623,
0.1152018458,
0.6086386442,
0.243405968,
-0.0690650642,
0.0560698584,
-0.3292441964,
-0.6169496775,
0.2892997563,
-0.3552687466,
0.4740481377,
-0.035079632,
-0.0823992267,
0.1865243465,
-0.3290400207,
-0.2737460434,
0.2034386396,
-0.0779470652,
-0.0247982573,
-0.1511431932,
-0.016626684,
0.0211122092,
0.0782716945,
-0.6237457991,
0.1387991458,
-0.2910745442,
0.4286800325,
0.5453261137,
0.0814622566,
0.4604766667,
-0.3308508098,
0.7384898663,
0.3079048097,
0.2247617394,
-0.5659210086,
-0.5081299543,
-0.7706633806,
-0.3957473934,
0.2475686818,
0.7523502111,
-0.8889375925,
0.2438382953,
-0.2818106413,
-0.1411372125,
-0.3783826828,
0.1816699952,
0.2373661101,
0.4086076915,
0.3988622725,
-0.923622489,
-0.4215093851,
-0.9725121856,
0.1822656244,
0.0806035623,
-0.111616537,
0.5339252353,
0.5287079811,
-0.0619044416,
0.8341787457,
-0.7089139223,
-0.5581384897,
-0.5529844165,
0.1331999451,
0.2115165293,
0.4105625451,
0.7294371724,
-0.8295574784,
-0.6208288074,
-0.1916745305,
-0.5562158823,
-0.2041019052,
-0.1972182095,
0.0635228604,
-0.2025074959,
0.6224393845,
-0.1652329415,
0.4054760039,
0.6006122231,
0.2377116978,
0.6434686184,
0.0001058288,
0.201750055,
-0.7622904778,
-0.0818210542,
-0.2420547307,
-0.1755379885,
-0.432589829,
0.134393245,
-0.219609946,
-0.3591163754,
-0.8474895954,
0.2289102972,
-0.4968504608,
-0.3404184282,
-0.2758356035,
0.1663395762,
0.179690972,
0.5237494707,
0.405484587,
1.052777648,
0.8871367574,
-0.2369369715,
0.2657212317,
0.314876765,
-0.4918909669,
0.4803052843,
-0.8288888931,
-0.0163874123,
-0.2364000976,
0.1885683388,
-1.1417269707,
-0.3029114008,
0.2735242546,
-0.2888307869,
0.3792241216,
-0.2962567508,
-0.2915044725,
-0.1812327206,
-0.588603735,
0.6944928765,
0.4642424881,
-0.6180900931,
0.4095052779,
0.1942421794,
-0.2821272016,
-0.8718464971,
-0.853063643,
0.1561245918,
-0.0535302013,
-0.2057853043,
0.704143703,
-0.1775506586,
0.1745453924,
-0.0778627098,
-0.0958191007,
-0.4069993496,
-0.0777356327,
0.2500080764,
0.4101980329,
-0.08556851,
-0.102237083,
-0.1262714267,
0.1408714205,
-0.4123975337,
0.0341728069,
0.6930845976,
-0.2345991582,
-0.6180267334,
-0.3025249541,
0.527813971,
0.3322835863,
-0.369530648,
0.4578026831,
0.3761199117,
-0.0307260938,
-0.0882106796,
-0.496704638,
-0.1130282655,
-0.4440989196,
0.5117328763,
-0.2819000483,
-1.032712698,
0.6549344063,
-0.0775971413,
-0.0802575499,
0.1625754535,
0.1581012607,
-0.2937693298,
0.3330125213,
0.9697816968,
-0.1513256282,
0.9436459541,
-0.3946270347,
-0.0900283977,
-0.8305110335,
-0.1100816801,
-0.0717406049,
-0.343261987,
-0.525978744,
-0.7538371682,
0.1177627668,
0.4230228961,
0.0707430393,
0.220717743,
-0.3643206656,
1.046174407,
0.6246440411,
0.2471524924,
0.1610758007,
0.3545917869,
-0.1511718333,
-0.5081431866,
-0.6900826097,
-0.2050912827,
1.1689170599,
0.2871503532,
0.9363307357,
-0.2262385339,
1.0717794895,
0.2300591618,
0.4289103448,
-0.7586010098,
0.6249352098,
-0.6706711054,
-0.1222095266,
-0.1166278869,
-0.1920992881,
-0.6619212627,
0.3424983621,
-0.4836319685,
-0.5639308095,
0.3952772319,
0.2622525394,
-0.1476756334,
0.3363872766,
-0.4300178289,
0.8300687075,
-0.6796922088,
-0.460860014,
0.0801965594,
-0.7061328888,
0.2984675467,
-0.0039102021,
-0.1020239443,
-0.0372848399,
-0.1440255195,
0.5987789035,
-0.1075907946,
1.2087358236,
-0.0486328639,
0.2183693796,
0.3362600207,
-0.1234940141,
0.0523970015,
-0.3329511881,
0.3516716957,
0.4814670682,
-0.2734631002,
-0.4147938788,
-0.5147880912,
0.3147648573,
-0.875169158,
-0.5002577901,
-0.3745986223,
-0.2691792548,
0.0220734216,
0.2203302383,
0.6603963375,
0.1749889851,
-0.2333860248,
0.2630759478,
0.5130735636,
-0.6249630451,
0.3388202488,
0.2997481227,
-0.2174311578,
-0.7492584586,
0.8220340014,
-0.0425278321,
0.363807857,
0.6914621592,
0.0053518,
-0.1725900471,
-0.8635877371,
-0.1183787212,
0.3430115283,
-1.0220121145,
-0.2969112098,
-0.2439475656,
-0.203294158,
-0.2446024418,
-0.4794047773,
-0.3293251693,
-0.2687974572,
-0.3700698614,
-0.0502402745,
-0.1023101211,
0.443397373,
-0.0414183401,
0.768915236,
-0.5532800555,
0.4624471962,
0.5150856376,
0.5443876386,
-0.2952375412,
-0.7324324846,
0.0221509282,
-0.418423444,
-0.4549401999,
-1.0269547701,
0.5805784464,
0.5029243231,
0.7558419704,
0.5476536751,
0.0420583859,
0.6633342505,
-0.695753634,
0.946326673,
0.6823375225,
-0.9091235399,
0.6649514437,
0.0788781717,
0.2553662062,
0.6654291153,
0.3822540343,
-0.3081617951,
-0.4334893525,
-0.302215308,
-1.0419927835,
0.3947378099,
-0.0067315493,
0.2923495471,
-0.0169250928,
0.1342825145,
0.1457085162,
0.2664379776,
-1.2787365913,
0.0552451499,
-0.6451368928,
-0.1616360247,
0.0300180987,
-0.2723895609,
-0.2531007528,
-0.0880071819,
-0.0021894097,
-0.2574607134,
0.3348472714,
0.2690675855,
-0.3949284852,
0.1598296016,
0.35404706,
0.6413305402,
0.4222931564,
-0.307860285,
0.2522013187,
0.2387980223,
-0.4849400818,
0.0305018332,
0.0066158371,
-0.297357142,
-0.0022322277,
0.8420357704,
1.0197819471,
0.2242729664,
-0.8359727859,
0.9897001386,
0.1356593519,
-0.2619334757,
-0.1907724291,
0.0662236884,
-0.2889777124,
0.0146015985,
0.2736101747,
0.0448169708,
0.1378507465,
-0.4094684124,
0.3256363273,
0.3440691829,
-0.3744119406,
-0.2457806915,
0.6066887975,
0.4667690992,
0.0976982117,
0.6377449632,
0.0048782886,
-0.853545785,
0.6358401775,
0.6243408918,
0.7946913242,
0.0597373806,
0.1544936597,
0.3144703507,
0.3077661097,
0.0832225829,
0.2163543999,
-0.2496355921,
-1.0244153738,
-0.5572500825,
-0.5195791721,
-0.8197849989,
0.1059674397,
-0.555985868,
0.1315522641,
-0.5369914174,
0.0241506305,
-0.1933526546,
-0.3074444532,
-0.8102115989,
0.1518685818,
0.4063423872,
0.7142065167,
-1.278901577,
0.6415303349,
0.7425390482,
-0.7095301151,
-0.3201256394,
0.1499264538,
-0.4620695412,
-1.0027672052,
1.070625186,
0.5777387619,
-0.1845154762,
-0.3105014861,
-1.0627813339,
-0.6517703533,
0.9383531809,
0.4910267293,
-0.8372883201,
0.3654726744,
0.3484382629,
0.4405319691,
-0.8065615296,
0.1544765383,
0.1171169207,
0.0055092704,
0.4275571108,
-0.637973249,
-0.2606408596,
-0.1539090127,
0.0785931423,
-0.3943123817,
-0.5218684077,
0.8401582837,
-0.5798210502,
-0.3396898806,
-0.0607337467,
0.6568581462,
0.3335029781,
0.1378676444,
0.4943550825,
0.4146930873,
0.3518825173,
-0.0043290406,
0.9606443644,
-0.2166788727,
0.0240789391,
1.4100289345,
-0.364562273,
1.130171299,
0.7497586012,
-0.178694129,
0.5435091257,
0.5664658546,
-0.5084245205,
0.8217940927,
0.2279141098,
-0.1366394758,
-0.4082722664,
-0.2756356299,
-0.0826434717,
0.4176489115,
0.0873408318,
-0.3992607892,
-0.0339958519,
0.0642811432,
-0.4350695312,
0.0979863033,
-0.2737239599,
0.6997205019,
0.1094602495,
-0.4475605786,
0.5173714757,
-0.2846623361,
0.976328969,
-0.4413158596,
-0.2593634725,
-0.5005127788,
-0.0469115935,
-0.1718364358,
-1.1643158197,
0.1138820723,
0.0324667208,
-0.0747983158,
-0.0054623554,
0.6117477417,
-0.5240873098,
-0.2902392447,
0.3068390489,
0.2421223074,
0.3636956513,
0.035062626,
-0.5761625767,
0.2921177447,
0.1126784235,
0.3038258851,
0.2099434286,
0.1440034807,
-0.0336744711,
0.6219389439,
0.3972893357,
0.2869467139,
0.0907558352,
0.441113323,
1.0660973787,
-0.5965692997,
-0.4785097241,
-0.6931906939,
0.4500152171,
-0.2773618102,
-0.1618036181,
0.2413138598,
0.474581033,
0.8801764846,
-0.4797200859,
0.6825578213,
0.2318060249,
-0.0143401101,
-0.5475447178,
0.3206649125,
-0.4871277213,
0.3390348256,
-0.2244656384,
-0.9535370469,
-0.7679405212,
0.6880304217,
-0.3285345137,
-0.1685665846,
0.5464931726,
0.5534191728,
-0.1941504478,
-0.5818030834,
0.4417653978,
-0.1711135656,
0.2042582482,
0.6110728383,
0.9373257756,
-0.3428553343,
0.8820893764,
-0.2225210369,
-0.3302288055,
-0.258711338,
-1.0847915411,
-1.013354063,
-0.0953696892,
-0.4197490513,
0.3375925124,
-0.0338606276,
0.4951288998,
0.8637667298,
-0.9435441494,
-0.2599813044,
-0.0455624945,
-0.0539325736,
0.0173343159,
-0.1418700069,
0.2284872681,
-0.2754317522,
-0.5158056021,
0.2102625072,
0.536249876,
0.5293772817,
-0.0683290362,
-0.1275452375,
0.1756033897,
-0.0950348154,
0.5682079196,
0.4062291682,
-0.7552226782,
-0.2370602489,
0.0559044294,
0.1266972125,
0.5765410662,
0.6225884557,
-0.6212824583,
0.5279995203,
0.4331820607,
0.5546626449,
0.7112751603,
0.1607614756,
0.5211243629,
-0.9993824363,
0.4238613248,
0.1773101836,
0.5319293737,
0.680595994,
0.1267943531,
0.4033943713,
0.4928184152,
-0.1446496248,
-0.5696401596,
0.5469099283,
-1.2733211517,
-0.187686339,
0.8020160794,
-0.4623272121,
-0.0763453096,
0.2000932246,
-0.3016729355,
-0.0683217645,
-0.2719428837,
0.5664137006,
0.4338702559,
-0.1469654441,
-0.8706591129,
-0.1401643306,
0.1835696548,
0.3960038722,
-0.8297145367,
-0.1662558764,
0.5154148936,
0.4434764385,
0.2449401766,
0.7370020747,
-0.2427756488,
0.207596451,
0.1846296191,
0.2481234223,
-0.0550639182,
-0.4031338096,
-0.2522864044,
0.1584886014,
0.2798021734,
-0.6007547975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19178v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19178v1
|
Revenge of the Fallen? Recurrent Models Match Transformers at Predicting Human Language Comprehension Metrics
| 2024-04-30T01:02:15 | 2024-04-30T01:02:15 |
James A. Michaelov, Catherine Arnett, Benjamin K. Bergen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transformers have supplanted Recurrent Neural Networks as the dominant
architecture for both natural language processing tasks and, despite criticisms
of cognitive implausibility, for modelling the effect of predictability on
online human language comprehension. However, two recently developed recurrent
neural network architectures, RWKV and Mamba, appear to perform natural
language tasks comparably to or better than transformers of equivalent scale.
In this paper, we show that contemporary recurrent models are now also able to
match - and in some cases, exceed - performance of comparably sized
transformers at modeling online human language comprehension. This suggests
that transformer language models are not uniquely suited to this task, and
opens up new directions for debates about the extent to which architectural
features of language models make them better or worse models of human language
comprehension.
|
[
-0.6300971508,
-0.6467101574,
0.525552392,
0.1023643315,
-0.0239626709,
0.5233260393,
0.2533574104,
-0.3834865689,
0.0870771855,
0.7694277763,
-0.8393979669,
0.0981764495,
-0.471314311,
0.2709023654,
-0.8317648172,
0.8377184868,
0.1522663981,
-0.1075694934,
-0.4064836502,
-0.1600874662,
-0.3565621078,
-0.7190452814,
-0.7001821399,
-0.9794891477,
0.7159852982,
-0.1695006192,
0.8777632117,
0.733767271,
0.5616486669,
0.34971416,
-0.0651919395,
-0.2912281454,
-0.6107516289,
0.3154559135,
-0.0115257008,
-0.5095271468,
0.0169915743,
-0.0386000648,
0.4979768693,
0.6727122664,
-0.5628563166,
-0.0512908474,
-0.2129665166,
0.8454921246,
-0.3107955456,
-0.2108490914,
-0.6173937321,
0.2679868937,
0.1162985489,
-0.278891772,
-0.8065009713,
-0.3316142857,
0.3192426264,
-0.5538157225,
0.4272343516,
0.0254156571,
0.7948765755,
0.6555045247,
-0.2113708407,
-0.0096110068,
-0.9681681395,
1.0719712973,
-0.7347220182,
0.1852566451,
0.1380271167,
0.4969593585,
-0.1654735357,
-1.0917568207,
-0.5832306147,
-0.2845104039,
-0.2700532377,
0.327711463,
-0.7288935781,
-0.0865489021,
0.2766506374,
0.458781451,
-0.4399233758,
0.1159656197,
-0.3112346828,
-0.0811197758,
0.1675905883,
0.6461524963,
0.3843538165,
-0.4617674649,
-0.5740361214,
-0.1964824349,
-0.4887700379,
0.1772970706,
0.4403997958,
0.1966708302,
0.0813639536,
0.2583748996,
-0.089713335,
0.8224415183,
0.1268155724,
-0.2298351526,
-0.1444718242,
0.0021043792,
-0.3381971121,
0.1094687358,
0.66547364,
0.3352269232,
0.3966411948,
-0.3942672312,
0.1039665118,
0.2788417339,
1.0801458359,
-0.5051752329,
-0.1527024955,
-0.0063361428,
-0.5685904622,
-0.69543612,
-0.0213238243,
-0.7472556829,
-0.4188245833,
-0.3631462157,
0.3432838619,
-0.4728305042,
-0.4235201478,
0.1942663789,
-0.3823224902,
0.3472580016,
0.1633018404,
-0.7654377222,
0.3593161404,
0.9535229206,
0.8904825449,
-0.295861125,
-0.4317685664,
-0.1588305086,
-0.1961285472,
-0.1881424785,
0.63338691,
-0.5640320182,
-0.3000732958,
0.1112774238,
-0.0668376386,
-0.0737559274,
-0.3739570379,
0.5484194756,
-0.7652488351,
0.2841723561,
0.0771187246,
-0.3541466296,
-0.5567575097,
0.3090874553,
-0.8525588512,
0.6875598431,
0.3054407835,
-0.9921322465,
0.0508051962,
-0.2805022597,
-0.6645938158,
-0.1733555198,
-0.0808912739,
-0.5222623944,
0.0084843384,
0.1209374517,
0.3545001149,
-0.3305767179,
0.0223902836,
-0.1594623476,
-0.6458540559,
0.2858030498,
-0.6043542027,
0.8154954314,
0.2247377187,
-0.3589529097,
-0.2318050265,
-0.6147902608,
-0.1411745697,
0.4077873528,
-0.4569295049,
-0.2781328559,
0.439075768,
-0.2110563368,
0.0254209228,
-0.109160535,
-0.4297901094,
0.024033457,
-0.8533554077,
0.762753427,
0.7145307064,
0.0094189234,
0.6348105669,
-0.5326706767,
0.9240127206,
-0.0763488933,
0.2741034925,
-0.3387698531,
-0.4013045728,
-0.7541946769,
0.0001444293,
-0.0465482883,
0.3846005797,
-0.6644163728,
0.0464191847,
-0.4368416369,
-0.9186338782,
-0.5710048079,
-0.6655880213,
0.4041258991,
0.6361339092,
0.4704740345,
-0.2806459367,
-0.8195044398,
-1.0560076237,
-0.4157750607,
-0.3669392467,
-0.0182449128,
0.2346360832,
0.1324348897,
-0.1354509145,
1.1365374327,
-0.2238020003,
-0.2011682689,
-0.4381938577,
0.1694710553,
0.3897447586,
0.1510150582,
0.6293632388,
-0.8369563222,
-0.1582759321,
0.1718813032,
-0.5320028663,
0.22649993,
-0.225608319,
0.416471839,
0.2011880726,
0.3620069623,
-0.5296237469,
0.2192337513,
0.630839169,
0.0005500441,
0.5715034604,
0.1699155271,
0.3181531429,
-1.2447808981,
0.1100422964,
-0.4418881238,
-0.3688479364,
-0.8156079054,
0.209226355,
-0.1791544259,
-0.0089837834,
-0.6768039465,
0.2769343853,
-0.1065809727,
-0.213124305,
-0.238101095,
0.1865503341,
0.1091651469,
0.3925068676,
-0.1561027765,
0.5147225261,
0.5312106609,
-0.7418688536,
0.6851041317,
0.3434778452,
-0.4294596314,
0.2513728142,
-0.7613263726,
0.1375359893,
-0.2058812082,
0.4099803567,
-1.0180205107,
-0.1106428728,
0.0918730423,
-1.0653915405,
0.0641519427,
-0.284001857,
-0.1044448465,
-0.5242090821,
-0.192235291,
0.4018342495,
0.7360677123,
-0.4941031933,
1.1302976608,
0.0957139432,
0.1019399688,
-1.0642020702,
-1.0187727213,
0.058862824,
-0.3113658726,
-0.4505660832,
0.4710974693,
0.2858447433,
-0.4098492265,
-0.1993751973,
0.1082732454,
0.0538996086,
0.1994581521,
0.4808078408,
0.0906371623,
-0.590167284,
-0.1035912409,
-0.2473191917,
-0.3906679749,
0.1527485549,
0.0889864936,
0.771455884,
0.1382738054,
-0.4165744185,
-0.3700563312,
0.1832045913,
1.0783261061,
-0.1352042556,
0.749430716,
0.2191189378,
-0.1717508733,
-0.1137532592,
-0.6752949953,
-0.2549589276,
-0.49812904,
0.4106167257,
-0.2662311196,
-0.7112470269,
0.6226807237,
0.2232122719,
0.3558127582,
0.4494991601,
0.4652658105,
-0.0099282563,
1.1607345343,
0.5367411375,
-0.4875957668,
0.4784801602,
-0.0330697484,
0.227029115,
-0.5647117496,
-0.0168359689,
-0.6723020077,
-0.4204976559,
-0.4764824212,
0.1796797663,
-0.0562690496,
-0.3001945019,
-0.1989647597,
0.5638449788,
-0.5624082088,
0.3386192024,
0.523083806,
-0.1888531744,
0.3677528203,
0.2983133793,
-0.0051549557,
-0.1769728959,
-0.58924371,
-0.5573321581,
0.6350618601,
0.3986407816,
0.6802668571,
0.0410234258,
0.2928003073,
0.4466539323,
0.2176057845,
-0.6813085079,
0.3991448879,
-0.1953694969,
-0.5834403634,
-0.0732478574,
-0.5145346522,
-1.2720569372,
0.1884115487,
0.2045256644,
-0.37775895,
-0.0870919824,
-0.0458289646,
-0.6003380418,
0.5572154522,
-0.4525368214,
0.7743501067,
0.1873750836,
0.3345537186,
-0.4541808665,
-0.6568877101,
0.3299320936,
0.0789550096,
0.0806362629,
0.1364486367,
-0.0045058019,
0.6595388055,
-0.1384260803,
0.6937140226,
0.0735552013,
0.1678913385,
0.2532494068,
0.4447871149,
0.4413235486,
-0.2008721977,
-0.2951948047,
0.0248998646,
0.0817792416,
-0.4463813305,
-0.7001703978,
0.6949226856,
-0.7539627552,
-0.5425329208,
-0.5762003064,
-0.1637274325,
-0.0321632326,
-0.0159889665,
0.4998025596,
0.5378684402,
-0.3928131163,
0.3239443302,
0.4424003661,
-0.2515559494,
0.7379484177,
0.7528398037,
-0.3067402542,
-0.5774998069,
0.5416148901,
-0.2580043972,
0.542273283,
0.4439159334,
0.01207479,
-0.3766589463,
-0.3991375268,
-0.4811937213,
0.130622521,
-0.8164454699,
-0.2502237558,
-0.743018508,
-0.4678187966,
-0.208799988,
-0.2505857944,
-0.3842969537,
-0.1227734089,
-0.3116109669,
-0.3237609267,
0.5100734234,
1.1579630375,
0.2309403121,
0.3424635231,
-0.803068459,
0.2374709845,
0.2171526253,
0.2530875802,
0.4526346922,
-1.1187742949,
-0.0977854878,
0.0682666972,
-0.3457690179,
-0.7834604979,
0.3184296191,
-0.2251698375,
0.4323212206,
0.3218492568,
0.1351508498,
0.5997187495,
-0.713142395,
0.7949359417,
0.3534705341,
-0.5281587243,
0.1795220226,
-0.3106422722,
0.1534636319,
0.3247786462,
0.2665540576,
-0.833384335,
-0.5699574947,
-0.7411121726,
-0.6363963485,
1.0451649427,
0.2154338509,
0.5789681077,
-0.0210965611,
0.4188303649,
0.2492672652,
-0.1091026291,
-0.9207602143,
-0.5431610942,
-0.3186554611,
-0.0211562496,
-0.0980999842,
-0.08420977,
0.4396068752,
-0.0967986956,
0.4945042431,
0.2502930462,
0.3230491579,
0.2404772937,
0.1291577518,
-0.3807615042,
-0.0492930263,
0.6815939546,
0.5898510814,
0.0243880991,
0.1413258016,
0.2485292256,
-0.4974492192,
0.3776634634,
-0.147210151,
-0.3120786548,
0.1340243816,
0.5837587714,
0.9153998494,
0.4654975235,
-0.5846552253,
0.28125453,
-0.2397182137,
-0.1557748169,
-0.6702535748,
0.1105053052,
0.2028601915,
0.2066459507,
0.6442169547,
0.4608102739,
-0.1377858371,
-0.4807542264,
0.4395677447,
0.1790625602,
-0.5241860151,
-0.1599337459,
0.4441895485,
0.0130635509,
-0.9006166458,
0.7480006218,
0.3866547048,
-0.7114371657,
0.7136933208,
0.5779634118,
0.6967537403,
-0.4900494218,
0.2815914452,
0.5013915896,
0.3659312427,
-0.1422128081,
-0.4173632264,
0.244758904,
-0.6783422828,
-0.6076444387,
-0.7738099694,
-0.3821828663,
0.1906853914,
-0.8841683269,
0.092626363,
-0.4591201246,
-0.1099794433,
0.0417438298,
-0.3908813,
-0.2130194455,
0.2297501564,
-0.0876117945,
0.7554294467,
-0.3892496228,
0.6541335583,
0.4104251266,
-0.6153975129,
-0.6249979734,
0.0959598124,
-0.4584312737,
-0.6307038665,
0.3217406273,
0.2489195168,
-0.2486436069,
0.4428970516,
0.0484980792,
-0.893758595,
0.8330290318,
0.4355913401,
-0.459605366,
-0.2759775519,
0.3064434826,
0.7479516268,
-0.0117838215,
0.2625981569,
0.7288048863,
0.464902699,
-0.2650597095,
-0.7627412677,
-0.1510956287,
0.2744186521,
-0.3191966712,
0.4891729653,
-0.4055436552,
0.6568953991,
-0.0971551239,
-0.4929319918,
0.3318163157,
0.5587992668,
-0.1390125155,
0.1704440862,
0.5518822074,
0.7372376919,
0.0984484777,
-0.2812976539,
1.5884110928,
0.1678383648,
0.3794596791,
0.8016771674,
-0.0351506956,
1.0927932262,
0.354685843,
-0.7196420431,
0.7498574853,
0.6168282628,
-0.0330329351,
0.4470746517,
0.0893230736,
-0.1057717577,
-0.419015497,
0.1740105003,
-0.288297534,
0.3991120756,
-0.0711536109,
-0.3863978684,
-0.2096918076,
0.0965969414,
-0.2451424301,
0.5269662738,
-0.2194701433,
0.9988583326,
0.1550347209,
-0.9345843792,
0.7150633931,
0.0065551787,
0.5920191407,
-0.5014626384,
0.2005143166,
-0.4236308634,
0.4411581159,
-0.0239483602,
-0.7521083355,
0.6443528533,
-0.1933175772,
-0.4181136191,
-0.1325049549,
0.4957303107,
0.0696662888,
-0.4009110034,
0.7891361117,
0.1892559975,
-0.0606344156,
-0.2559423745,
-0.7798038721,
-0.1154441908,
0.1295437515,
-0.2922686338,
0.2347695976,
-0.0301756281,
0.463080436,
1.0624167919,
0.5379658937,
-0.3499000967,
0.3676107228,
0.2564657032,
0.6615666747,
-0.8059381247,
-0.3046367466,
-1.2395554781,
0.3998909295,
0.0970028043,
-0.1310687512,
0.5056506395,
0.3940824568,
0.587556839,
-0.3305182457,
0.6449825764,
0.0801747516,
0.9955763221,
-0.1845495403,
0.9961588383,
-0.7486507893,
-0.2145036608,
-0.2376645654,
-0.9199517369,
-0.2124674171,
0.4856975675,
0.0064698681,
0.0603347234,
0.5983504653,
0.6060177088,
-0.0901449397,
0.0527177751,
0.5356696248,
0.3202670515,
0.2806518674,
0.5434007049,
1.2755668163,
-0.6012119651,
0.9909986854,
-0.0841325372,
0.306117177,
-0.2906202674,
-0.659563601,
-0.864249289,
-0.6459850669,
0.0932027474,
-0.2357152402,
-0.1200986877,
0.3805469871,
0.4067299068,
-0.8083853126,
0.0948062539,
-0.4508544505,
0.2068188787,
-0.3485570252,
-0.2905168831,
-0.0286661759,
-0.1948619485,
-0.6452327967,
0.6200796962,
0.2437156439,
-0.0109386723,
-0.6099704504,
-0.2627955973,
-0.1011855751,
0.2998170853,
0.4913799465,
0.2337366045,
-1.3801618814,
-0.2517113686,
0.1622189879,
-0.2826949358,
0.1937383115,
0.9500640035,
-1.1808503866,
0.2224954814,
0.6501826644,
0.8973671794,
0.1589687467,
0.1723608673,
0.8458265662,
-0.7718510628,
0.0287601184,
0.4489408135,
0.3680471182,
0.4448886812,
-0.1043565571,
0.4260565937,
0.0896042809,
-0.5838592052,
-1.0399332047,
0.3303166926,
-0.7821059823,
-0.3489568233,
0.7130595446,
-0.0805198625,
-0.0558875576,
-0.4245574474,
-0.338229388,
0.3839165866,
-0.1220479086,
0.9268147349,
0.8179220557,
0.2315586805,
-0.3270718753,
-0.4007017612,
0.4358049333,
0.6956914663,
-0.3436971903,
0.3410428166,
0.2109752446,
0.1518811584,
0.572335422,
0.1522188336,
0.0036861834,
0.5389906764,
-0.048907645,
-0.0677605569,
-0.0614304245,
-0.0876718834,
-0.3315722644,
0.2830408812,
0.0671142787,
0.0242986213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19175v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19175v1
|
Game-MUG: Multimodal Oriented Game Situation Understanding and Commentary Generation Dataset
| 2024-04-30T00:39:26 | 2024-04-30T00:39:26 |
Zhihao Zhang, Feiqi Cao, Yingbin Mo, Yiran Zhang, Josiah Poon, Caren Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The dynamic nature of esports makes the situation relatively complicated for
average viewers. Esports broadcasting involves game expert casters, but the
caster-dependent game commentary is not enough to fully understand the game
situation. It will be richer by including diverse multimodal esports
information, including audiences' talks/emotions, game audio, and game match
event information. This paper introduces GAME-MUG, a new multimodal game
situation understanding and audience-engaged commentary generation dataset and
its strong baseline. Our dataset is collected from 2020-2022 LOL game live
streams from YouTube and Twitch, and includes multimodal esports game
information, including text, audio, and time-series event logs, for detecting
the game situation. In addition, we also propose a new audience conversation
augmented commentary dataset by covering the game situation and audience
conversation understanding, and introducing a robust joint multimodal dual
learning model as a baseline. We examine the model's game situation/event
understanding ability and commentary generation capability to show the
effectiveness of the multimodal aspects coverage and the joint integration
learning approach.
|
[
-0.6744558215,
-0.786318779,
0.0155328726,
0.4418332279,
-0.2853865325,
0.2676875889,
0.0297153015,
-0.2873754501,
0.3536761999,
0.3469223976,
-0.9034157991,
-0.2959424853,
-0.4597484469,
-0.1262135506,
0.3216998279,
1.2963184118,
0.1844033599,
0.0745566189,
-0.2067584097,
-0.3107759655,
-0.6229146123,
-0.4823842049,
-0.5958862305,
-0.0484944358,
0.1365341544,
0.4225133657,
0.2984268069,
0.0547824576,
0.4949934781,
0.4236454368,
0.0774335861,
0.6341345906,
-0.802482903,
0.4472785294,
-0.1138737202,
-0.1699715108,
-0.6666215062,
-0.092642352,
0.4187394977,
0.2937716544,
-0.0748395622,
0.2863132358,
0.1620449424,
0.0774561465,
-0.6216599941,
0.4850120544,
-0.4401243627,
0.4892992079,
0.0369670056,
-0.5193268657,
-0.5999472141,
0.5670079589,
-0.3258778751,
-0.9458820224,
0.4390612543,
0.0464563444,
0.6458466649,
0.2345545739,
-0.6905616522,
-0.157420218,
-1.0142604113,
0.8024304509,
-0.275423795,
0.2232283801,
0.1017203331,
0.4646368623,
-0.2989194095,
-0.2918748856,
-0.4912209511,
0.4196364284,
0.2008430511,
0.5708163977,
0.0464476384,
0.0621854551,
0.2194021046,
-0.1405526996,
-0.1224238053,
-0.2454129755,
-0.3563705981,
-0.0044454113,
0.911472559,
0.4285574853,
0.5644424558,
-0.0617882945,
-0.692404151,
0.2146908343,
-0.4066151977,
0.1391303092,
0.4241207242,
0.129624024,
-0.3158866167,
0.352900058,
-0.1515317261,
0.4087736905,
0.1472169906,
-0.5794549584,
0.3805600703,
-0.588514924,
0.0414400809,
0.1312434971,
0.4521625638,
0.9202415943,
-0.1292791814,
-0.1064351127,
0.1157112271,
-0.010084738,
0.0848221332,
-0.8803207874,
-0.2699480951,
0.6273660064,
-0.3404345214,
-0.3942316175,
0.194096148,
-1.0993777514,
-0.7043541074,
-0.2271649688,
0.066877462,
-0.0283102114,
-0.6359527707,
-0.0831999853,
-0.4857126176,
0.3796645403,
0.6772025824,
-0.6432979703,
-0.1130469963,
0.5914079547,
0.5895089507,
-0.1279904693,
-0.1806263328,
-0.8674722314,
0.5637877584,
-0.0618665963,
0.9420762658,
-0.3441507518,
-0.3730997741,
0.1200564802,
-0.0527779572,
0.2301080674,
-0.0602245107,
0.2341602594,
-0.3368139267,
0.0091344761,
-0.2011857927,
-0.4364825785,
0.0389108211,
0.5181850195,
-0.7749675512,
0.5778074861,
-0.4191051424,
-0.8983622193,
0.7560760975,
-0.668094337,
-0.345826149,
0.3896566927,
-0.183461383,
-0.4342058301,
-0.0600047596,
0.4353367984,
0.3401900232,
0.1706712246,
0.311257869,
-0.8044620752,
-0.1947611123,
0.2131575644,
-0.5780473948,
0.659103632,
0.1759601533,
-0.0418011807,
-0.1065497324,
-0.6014811993,
-0.1437050253,
-0.0819741488,
-0.2403857559,
-0.0100056231,
0.56085217,
-0.1132939607,
0.4043782651,
0.0076364358,
-0.727434516,
0.0283629,
0.2074186951,
0.3487635851,
0.3998149335,
0.375897795,
0.3858243227,
0.0599342436,
0.400966078,
0.215723604,
0.4470932782,
-0.4003112614,
-0.4691176713,
-0.1965990365,
-0.3423155248,
-0.0117466319,
0.5647441745,
-1.1857017279,
-0.0734019727,
-0.2346576601,
-0.1590662152,
-0.3159249723,
0.1652230322,
0.323985368,
0.333473146,
0.032602787,
0.0319467597,
-0.7075500488,
-0.3543042541,
-0.013459566,
-0.2626865804,
0.3577538729,
0.4089109302,
0.301833272,
0.1880058795,
0.8057619929,
-0.4646698534,
-0.4594950974,
-0.7469444275,
0.3883137107,
-0.2592130303,
0.2339523584,
0.7017726898,
-1.2057337761,
-0.5643791556,
-0.2205570042,
-0.9982325435,
-0.1052581593,
-0.042771142,
0.0411944166,
-0.0671186373,
0.7428379655,
-0.2323532999,
0.5257236958,
0.6355766058,
-0.8258216381,
0.4013120234,
-0.1011859104,
0.5831142664,
-0.9462648034,
-0.2681483328,
-0.0607237928,
-0.3430157304,
-0.8798071742,
0.0523491465,
-0.380888164,
-0.345438689,
-0.7731077075,
0.6341251731,
-0.6270501614,
0.1009763926,
-0.4604768753,
0.414781034,
0.4495987594,
0.5651484132,
0.3430875242,
0.6783317327,
0.2141345292,
-0.4637053907,
0.6880931854,
0.4521076977,
-0.5391969085,
0.7867718935,
-0.2165378928,
-0.1136355773,
-0.2600056827,
0.4362982512,
-1.1429835558,
-0.2169743031,
0.2478360981,
-0.5781421661,
0.1878201216,
-0.3484994173,
-0.1251772493,
-0.2992312312,
-0.3492608368,
0.5211288333,
-0.0628968775,
-0.3416430652,
0.7183252573,
1.0167740583,
-0.2255818397,
-0.7581948638,
-0.5339735746,
0.0363648497,
-0.3166947067,
-0.643373251,
0.1667837948,
-0.1719079018,
-0.2695618272,
-0.0854466185,
0.0522975847,
-0.3569843471,
-0.1394088715,
0.1854592264,
0.1948605925,
-0.3446815312,
0.1650316566,
-0.1550738961,
0.0350271799,
-0.0783898383,
0.5616003275,
0.2091497332,
0.0524768196,
-0.2559715211,
-0.283016324,
0.7313187122,
0.113939777,
-0.115528442,
0.6954511404,
0.8449522853,
-0.0495268032,
-0.1439521462,
-0.4400933683,
-0.0823865384,
-0.4222318232,
0.7503384352,
-0.5007953644,
-0.4312417209,
0.6072467566,
-0.0077736657,
0.2418124527,
0.1261416972,
0.4956103265,
-0.4117193222,
1.5534080267,
0.1208257824,
0.1796000749,
0.4274750948,
0.0166501757,
0.090168491,
-0.7444425225,
-0.4272602797,
-0.1862549931,
-0.4960238039,
-0.1552066207,
-0.374979496,
0.2241805345,
0.0059255213,
-0.2314661592,
-0.0275956281,
0.0989695787,
0.75718081,
0.0178353116,
0.2840641141,
0.2859750092,
-0.3932813108,
0.4209526479,
-0.1760190129,
-0.7150186896,
0.108967416,
0.8125218749,
0.1893806458,
0.6043077707,
0.6137325168,
0.4478448927,
0.5613498092,
0.230452314,
-0.570096314,
0.2793869972,
0.082991451,
-0.8850210905,
-0.4076032639,
-0.2734493911,
-0.6249950528,
0.3882790804,
-0.5587186813,
-0.5695363283,
0.2080615014,
0.2388309836,
-0.5595597029,
0.413685441,
-0.8588989973,
0.6664634943,
-0.1115993336,
-0.6585239172,
0.3357144594,
-0.4147522748,
0.5552259088,
0.3614952862,
0.658341229,
-0.3349539936,
-0.1133456901,
0.5218769908,
-0.3680072129,
0.9907478094,
-0.4749665856,
0.0933012217,
0.6500415802,
0.1798414439,
0.2496404797,
0.5734249949,
0.3401674926,
-0.1604463905,
-0.1267849803,
-0.4223381877,
-0.6843191981,
0.3678958714,
-0.7080649137,
-0.6660377383,
-0.2996193171,
-0.5952228308,
-0.4917336702,
0.01777911,
0.4197071791,
0.6947290897,
-0.4065343142,
0.3898583055,
0.5856167078,
-0.2726458609,
0.4229618013,
0.4845711291,
-0.1857305467,
-0.289529413,
0.8314673305,
-0.1959563345,
0.0273439586,
0.2736116946,
-0.0488614701,
-0.1965169609,
-0.2756391466,
-0.5890526175,
-0.16652219,
-0.6345422864,
-0.4162589908,
-0.3380768597,
-0.168513611,
-0.2640301287,
0.1018417776,
-0.3808164001,
-0.0018549125,
0.0150009189,
-0.177347675,
0.1214242876,
0.7072428465,
-0.1029754952,
0.4471260011,
-0.7249720097,
0.2539224625,
0.207622841,
0.1680212915,
-0.2695367038,
-0.2768518627,
-0.1117940396,
0.1407401115,
-0.3840999603,
-0.9278390408,
0.3510695696,
0.3970284462,
0.5280047655,
0.7200023532,
0.0623076782,
0.7809513211,
-0.5388079286,
1.0388092995,
0.3574098349,
-0.5338490605,
0.3578985333,
-0.5055598617,
0.0557221398,
0.4720912278,
-0.0838723183,
-0.3806433976,
-0.1313231289,
-0.5004646182,
-0.6124311686,
0.954803288,
-0.0070321006,
0.1755393595,
-0.0830861405,
-0.1231015399,
0.160751164,
0.425200671,
-0.6722905636,
-0.1652571559,
-0.333098352,
0.0407851078,
-0.3320954442,
-0.2249940038,
-0.2314893901,
-0.251462847,
0.4700769484,
-0.0843859836,
0.4488314986,
-0.2391619384,
-0.0433151238,
0.172845602,
-0.0239859391,
0.8710647821,
0.5659303069,
-0.282981813,
0.0164656248,
0.4087272882,
-0.5153101087,
-0.1121965721,
-0.2962568998,
0.136304304,
-0.0177395176,
0.4292836487,
1.0564237833,
0.5676389337,
-0.6644411683,
0.9253882766,
-0.0826409608,
-0.3738360107,
-0.2578131855,
-0.0905777439,
-0.0254723094,
0.3436471522,
0.0957799405,
0.017096119,
0.2902304828,
-0.6383376718,
0.4108306468,
0.3003303409,
-0.4965066612,
-0.3738647997,
0.767043829,
0.7462701201,
-0.1066154167,
0.2842125595,
-0.4100042582,
-0.5198042989,
0.6589056253,
0.6400226951,
0.3886153996,
-0.2930428386,
0.646400094,
0.2521967292,
-0.2670703828,
0.2359608561,
0.3923059404,
-0.0607098974,
-0.9795674682,
-0.655629456,
-0.1601285487,
-0.2823579609,
0.2223401666,
-0.6420484185,
0.5548689365,
-0.0807429478,
-0.3696955144,
0.0330282263,
0.0021910111,
-0.8180323243,
-0.0160901435,
0.3519739807,
0.5759679079,
-0.9983230829,
0.3485124707,
0.5441381931,
-0.5844272971,
-0.35765329,
-0.353770256,
0.265083313,
-0.7101576328,
0.6573072076,
-0.2423147708,
-0.0936146453,
-0.2757119536,
-0.5357263088,
-0.4151327908,
0.9746690392,
0.1941051781,
-0.1567822844,
-0.2088339925,
0.0243117847,
0.3170717061,
-0.5037205219,
0.4870272577,
0.1932727695,
0.3208041191,
0.4855925143,
-0.3651314974,
-0.667252779,
-0.5188568234,
-0.141547963,
0.2798706889,
-1.0182510614,
0.6761661768,
-0.196875006,
-0.0704575554,
-0.3940332532,
0.8579992652,
0.2197862267,
0.5407550931,
0.2888407111,
0.0996244252,
0.3378005326,
-0.2801038921,
0.7039803267,
-0.179792583,
0.3496790826,
1.2482485771,
-0.3747630119,
0.7700126767,
0.4234129488,
0.1268839687,
0.1915642768,
0.3846224546,
-0.0716698915,
0.5100696087,
-0.1743791699,
-0.3259271979,
-0.7125825286,
-0.0807833374,
-0.2976042926,
0.8480163217,
0.5795645118,
-0.1064199507,
-0.4092593491,
0.4732697904,
0.1463821977,
-0.1057897285,
-0.3447672427,
1.0693379641,
-0.3116922677,
-0.5336164832,
-0.3201489747,
-0.2410361171,
0.5985078216,
-0.4381422698,
-0.2172901481,
-0.2772484124,
0.1685758233,
-0.0913637504,
-1.0318969488,
0.0937167257,
-0.0538825952,
-0.0340724587,
0.0909663439,
0.6813260317,
-0.4505562782,
-0.3582287431,
0.1380518526,
0.5688563585,
0.2201240808,
0.0788643733,
-0.5435542464,
0.3324084282,
-0.0761713088,
-0.2541019619,
0.4613517523,
0.7753168941,
0.2943455279,
0.3884602785,
-0.0057895225,
0.1543690115,
0.2292872071,
0.0447267778,
0.2925230265,
-0.1435477585,
-0.7135519385,
-0.5641363859,
0.4208460748,
-0.573910594,
-0.4714758694,
0.6634171009,
0.6156323552,
0.5457481146,
-0.2673059106,
0.997097671,
-0.013730051,
0.2643761933,
-0.3546768427,
0.5901774168,
-0.5286936164,
-0.0459848605,
-0.1811278611,
-0.5435390472,
-0.2665720582,
0.3473117948,
0.0677453727,
-0.047932528,
0.0982642472,
0.3595949411,
-0.3873587847,
0.2676160038,
0.3399123251,
-0.2700852156,
0.3481546938,
0.5315208435,
0.7926530242,
-0.2665963173,
0.8536475897,
-0.1025841236,
-0.3834205568,
-0.5090408325,
-0.9551438689,
-1.144719243,
-0.8449620605,
-0.5577390194,
-0.5565572381,
0.1104815453,
0.8383999467,
0.5389255285,
-0.8586193919,
-0.0414455794,
0.4867872894,
-0.1593147218,
-0.5026159286,
-0.3338050246,
0.2058310509,
-0.4020220339,
-0.9700405002,
0.2213041931,
0.2588253915,
-0.3811555803,
-0.1192437634,
-0.0524384417,
-0.1359781921,
0.206091091,
0.983506918,
0.6072707772,
-0.3942266107,
-0.6039184332,
-0.1185951158,
0.2195558548,
0.2374680191,
0.8593921661,
-0.4069125354,
0.753652513,
0.5509855747,
0.4720528424,
0.3354338408,
0.1722050458,
0.7240062356,
-0.90563941,
0.4195640683,
-0.0552515648,
0.2817634344,
0.0572637282,
-0.2824078202,
0.4449465871,
0.4044733644,
-0.3442484438,
-0.9524437189,
0.2855149508,
-0.8472385406,
-0.2864765227,
1.4674371481,
-0.1195372269,
-0.0944890976,
-0.5806372166,
-0.3975271881,
0.4635706544,
-0.4433532059,
0.6763241887,
0.9794661403,
-0.4384332001,
-0.0649220869,
-0.7608494163,
0.6992112994,
-0.1866383851,
-0.5228282809,
0.0670120865,
0.4681404233,
0.0874875262,
0.0745570585,
0.629130125,
0.0263374913,
0.342912674,
0.5695143342,
0.0117928563,
-0.4072988331,
-0.6327705383,
0.2619468868,
0.3728149533,
-0.5692435503,
-0.4533552825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19159v1
|
What Drives Performance in Multilingual Language Models?
| 2024-04-29T23:49:19 | 2024-04-29T23:49:19 |
Sina Bagheri Nezhad, Ameeta Agrawal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
This study investigates the factors influencing the performance of
multilingual large language models (MLLMs) across diverse languages. We study 6
MLLMs, including masked language models, autoregressive models, and
instruction-tuned LLMs, on the SIB-200 dataset, a topic classification dataset
encompassing 204 languages. Our analysis considers three scenarios: ALL
languages, SEEN languages (present in the model's pretraining data), and UNSEEN
languages (not present or documented in the model's pretraining data in any
meaningful way). We examine the impact of factors such as pretraining data
size, general resource availability, language family, and script type on model
performance. Decision tree analysis reveals that pretraining data size is the
most influential factor for SEEN languages. However, interestingly, script type
and language family are crucial for UNSEEN languages, highlighting the
importance of cross-lingual transfer learning. Notably, model size and
architecture do not significantly alter the most important features identified.
Our findings provide valuable insights into the strengths and limitations of
current MLLMs and hope to guide the development of more effective and equitable
multilingual NLP systems.
|
[
-0.493377924,
-0.3595744073,
0.2488116473,
0.5825460553,
-0.0006815068,
0.3648483753,
-0.3953846395,
-0.5622673035,
-0.1149843633,
0.5406614542,
-0.4408444464,
-0.2423149943,
-0.7185652256,
0.1787890196,
-0.2346919775,
1.0468863249,
0.0139232036,
0.2143718004,
-0.063682273,
-0.3008356988,
-0.3108908534,
-0.9943335652,
-0.3707155585,
-0.3900099099,
0.859777391,
0.1248955801,
0.5954540372,
0.5902293324,
0.4590486288,
0.2406366467,
-0.002546492,
0.0219671447,
-0.4887099266,
0.1165655404,
-0.1921691447,
-0.4871161282,
-0.3165724576,
-0.0715969428,
1.0262209177,
0.8720942736,
0.0568198413,
0.378046751,
0.163558796,
0.4482035637,
-0.5682414174,
0.2046377361,
-0.6212911606,
0.0562067851,
-0.5112100244,
-0.0755745247,
-0.4551512599,
-0.1065437347,
0.1833597422,
-0.1993142217,
0.0126408869,
0.1458471119,
0.6215170026,
0.0445259996,
-0.7711254954,
-0.3640925288,
-0.8103230596,
0.8956753016,
-0.5765992403,
0.7171292305,
0.2499257028,
-0.069551222,
0.0470884256,
-0.4551811218,
-0.1578870863,
-0.140711993,
-0.3845209479,
-0.2472418547,
0.10750328,
-0.0357402787,
0.5409818292,
0.2011162639,
-0.7380806804,
0.4758149981,
-0.4625290334,
-0.1526931971,
0.584115088,
0.1835147738,
0.2446103543,
0.062064711,
0.066377908,
-0.0084758978,
-0.8808475137,
0.1452579498,
0.577278614,
0.4157719612,
-0.1562049538,
0.4702184796,
-0.0183961578,
0.7509624958,
-0.4527784288,
-0.4046760798,
0.3034493029,
-0.4506514966,
0.0732609928,
0.0641431957,
0.499019891,
-0.0357254967,
0.4482343793,
-0.2063524723,
-0.2238208801,
-0.3202335536,
-0.1052859798,
-0.9586972594,
-0.0854953602,
-0.1844005585,
-0.4499340951,
0.1367384344,
-0.0549996868,
-0.5373734832,
-0.3349376321,
-0.4692925811,
0.1870967001,
-0.1736902744,
-0.5822222233,
-0.1999231428,
0.134499833,
0.2727139294,
0.1736517102,
-0.9947177768,
0.3182879388,
0.5742394328,
0.6847300529,
-0.4661513269,
-0.5916693807,
-0.377455771,
0.0526454411,
-0.5211708546,
0.4727037251,
-0.7077726722,
-0.1681072861,
0.0019964338,
0.2477685213,
-0.5774912834,
-0.4601814151,
-0.0105299307,
-0.4161658585,
0.3286139667,
-0.3535878658,
-0.44484815,
-0.2155895531,
-0.0414514057,
-0.774812758,
0.957438767,
-0.1513773501,
-0.7694625854,
0.5994134545,
-0.666354835,
-0.6462520957,
-0.0234257299,
-0.2957213223,
-0.2433747351,
0.2160733491,
-0.1305971891,
0.6591956615,
-0.1472059339,
0.3874718845,
-0.2073196471,
-0.3623640835,
0.228225112,
-0.6947823167,
0.662564218,
0.2803500891,
-0.3557976484,
0.1938619018,
-0.8710053563,
-0.0085652759,
0.120653607,
-0.4225786626,
-0.1043058932,
-0.0500452034,
0.2153121382,
0.5643057227,
0.1712392569,
-0.3092964888,
-0.0175317284,
-0.0866736025,
0.1821739227,
0.5954970121,
-0.1648775786,
0.2247738242,
0.0396323279,
0.9490666389,
0.0152585004,
0.0078938166,
-0.4701995254,
-0.6047777534,
-0.6735595465,
-0.221495226,
0.5951999426,
0.4699596167,
-0.3234034479,
-0.2902794182,
-0.0877514109,
-0.4074729979,
-0.6726228595,
0.3109270036,
0.3919970095,
-0.0345352627,
-0.0624229796,
-0.0632216111,
-0.3669293821,
-1.1266559362,
-0.0326841027,
-0.016163772,
0.3396021426,
0.392208457,
0.3646941483,
-0.1884871721,
0.483782202,
-0.211597681,
0.1902601272,
-0.5349213481,
0.0988169461,
0.1702271402,
0.351149112,
0.8211861253,
-0.8320731521,
-0.6757365465,
0.1875347197,
-0.5498794913,
-0.2576993108,
-0.0552074835,
0.144574061,
0.6962409616,
0.6305802464,
-0.3917069435,
0.3386202455,
0.9537382126,
-0.2951484621,
0.5879670382,
-0.3809885383,
0.0539037548,
-0.7089787126,
0.1837750375,
-0.1774506271,
0.0257969256,
-0.6304875016,
0.0312419683,
0.1897711158,
-0.2366527617,
-0.609426558,
0.6089365482,
-0.5738870502,
-0.536431253,
0.0023477683,
-0.1830618382,
-0.0019022567,
0.5207768083,
0.1171065867,
0.9354240894,
0.663213551,
-0.6549987793,
0.0080503803,
-0.2946876585,
-0.4448600113,
0.034402173,
-0.484354645,
-0.0869913995,
-0.1345364898,
-0.1026835367,
-0.6958536506,
-0.0400024503,
-0.200243786,
-0.1260634065,
0.5889941454,
-0.0673192665,
-0.5736410022,
-0.1488028914,
0.1331885457,
0.2900837958,
0.0172658227,
-0.2111712545,
0.6333473325,
0.2810196877,
-0.315662235,
-0.6645864844,
-0.4767886102,
0.0288195889,
-0.4572380185,
-0.3882655799,
0.1253859401,
-0.1749638468,
-0.353728652,
-0.3148444593,
0.156053111,
-0.028852772,
0.5165584683,
0.2863186598,
0.1345050484,
-0.4363267124,
0.3926066458,
-0.1403711587,
0.0387227051,
-0.0417840667,
-0.0810370222,
0.8358504176,
-0.3979899585,
-0.4160147309,
-0.0627803579,
0.4309104383,
0.7918329835,
-0.5787954926,
1.2353680134,
0.8378586769,
-0.1591466814,
-0.1106767207,
-0.436708957,
0.0185142551,
-0.3923092186,
0.8116173744,
-0.5888262987,
-0.9322187304,
0.7927448153,
0.1536619067,
0.0472114421,
0.4346697628,
0.7734547257,
0.1273276061,
1.1298499107,
0.7542737722,
-0.1703941226,
0.6727327108,
0.0389232039,
0.1602410823,
-0.5781624913,
-0.3355998099,
-0.5807395577,
-0.1028656662,
-0.9548718333,
-0.2927225232,
0.1491602063,
0.1216779277,
-0.1704320163,
0.1217752919,
0.1677818298,
0.3890579939,
0.5308534503,
-0.4736420214,
0.2788848281,
0.0000608147,
-0.3074022233,
-0.0036069003,
-0.906730175,
-0.4585074186,
1.1919111013,
0.5410863757,
0.7410939932,
0.2665381134,
0.4539176226,
-0.0477214009,
0.119848676,
-0.3742370307,
0.3580774665,
-0.2898450792,
-0.8646479845,
-0.388361603,
-0.3528353572,
-0.9648708701,
0.6244240403,
-0.2167179137,
-0.6832517385,
-0.0173954125,
-0.1484268606,
-0.0655239075,
0.1914252937,
-0.8466261625,
0.9824650288,
-0.8004510999,
-0.3262243867,
-0.2914076447,
-0.4578997791,
0.1766851395,
-0.6223396063,
0.2141788751,
-0.2174434066,
0.1147217527,
0.7492609024,
0.2537910938,
0.7025819421,
-0.0090931728,
-0.2242459804,
-0.1434336752,
-0.0727208629,
0.2824703455,
-0.1483141929,
-0.1435344964,
0.4825275838,
0.0688011348,
-0.3405231833,
-0.3399251997,
0.661895752,
-0.784396708,
-0.5708671808,
-0.1470661908,
-0.5280589461,
-0.4153666496,
0.3096389174,
0.1591226161,
0.641683042,
-0.039258942,
0.6487551332,
0.6380864382,
-0.5906168818,
0.6458209753,
0.7497480512,
-0.7350857854,
0.1924941838,
0.9692317247,
0.553152442,
0.57120049,
0.3065154552,
0.0621024221,
-0.251093775,
-0.7246090174,
-0.5005181432,
0.3208357692,
-0.7004301548,
0.24412857,
-0.8707465529,
-0.3638850152,
-0.4649964571,
0.1792357713,
-0.4032698274,
-0.3971822858,
-0.278021723,
-0.1086617485,
0.0862965062,
0.896040976,
0.0689277053,
0.3947522044,
-0.6520817876,
0.0726107955,
0.0901080444,
0.523540318,
0.0842097327,
-0.511323452,
-0.4660470784,
-0.1856585741,
0.0053431117,
-0.4850344658,
0.4078027606,
0.3941603303,
1.0613735914,
0.2453969568,
-0.2857808769,
0.57613796,
-0.4751676023,
0.5981142521,
-0.0944148824,
-0.6808543205,
0.3071087897,
-0.3370475769,
0.3485918343,
0.2817262709,
0.5885847807,
-0.5113059282,
-0.3484047055,
-0.3949702382,
-0.6748253107,
0.8891088963,
0.0758649111,
0.0931358188,
0.2827635407,
-0.0026371228,
0.2252029628,
0.4388723969,
-0.9239534736,
-0.3543810248,
0.0143802399,
0.1111426875,
-0.3926595747,
-0.2004466951,
0.3296186924,
-0.1893085688,
0.5237552524,
-0.2027043849,
-0.0756915137,
-0.4744625986,
-0.3972353935,
0.0288440697,
0.2611633837,
0.8259904385,
1.0625519753,
-0.1510244161,
-0.0553230904,
0.1655021757,
-0.2856869698,
-0.1160954237,
-0.0176678393,
-0.0088960398,
0.0019826733,
0.6738735437,
1.1812355518,
0.262057215,
-0.6477366686,
0.1836873293,
-0.1069086641,
0.1971960366,
-0.135107398,
0.11766316,
0.0792439282,
0.1926220804,
0.3092734218,
-0.0865511745,
-0.1202687621,
-0.7245441079,
0.0275892019,
0.3994209468,
-0.205903545,
-0.3854313493,
0.3644904494,
-0.0941420943,
-0.2361259609,
0.5274885297,
0.1517917812,
-0.7574628592,
0.6653602123,
0.5160074234,
0.4615038931,
-0.4387907684,
0.1991429478,
0.1267910153,
0.566360414,
0.1089521274,
-0.018814858,
0.0760041103,
-0.7225461602,
-0.5912793875,
-0.8668418527,
-0.2357181907,
0.3273434639,
-0.6123716831,
0.2681427598,
-0.2657055557,
-0.1103827432,
0.0580266975,
0.1091593802,
-0.9754990339,
0.2375641316,
0.5435761213,
0.6747430563,
-0.9147475958,
1.0711431503,
0.5435707569,
-0.0957506374,
-0.7358168364,
-0.1456524134,
-0.1024659276,
-0.811468184,
0.9889224768,
0.1095930263,
-0.1142984703,
-0.005215378,
-0.0556249954,
-1.2342820168,
0.6178508997,
0.415032506,
-0.4221490026,
0.0121765761,
0.3609002829,
0.5809304714,
-0.6090574861,
0.2873307467,
0.553129077,
0.3801623285,
-0.0109100509,
-1.32134974,
-0.4071242809,
-0.0972268358,
-0.0259917546,
0.1535187513,
-0.6099752784,
0.8667946458,
-0.1754579395,
-0.0091800801,
-0.2715525627,
0.2872814238,
0.3051121831,
0.1284791529,
0.2345182449,
0.051281821,
0.8110373616,
-0.013215798,
1.0683934689,
-0.4623174369,
0.059432853,
1.0358489752,
-0.5883228183,
0.8429768682,
0.3286725581,
-0.2025556713,
0.4092371166,
0.763332665,
0.0136041492,
0.36909464,
0.1150451079,
0.0565707795,
-0.2840672135,
-0.2904237807,
-0.5583725572,
0.847961545,
0.4400638938,
-0.5304997563,
-0.0084932316,
0.3305725455,
-0.0635163486,
-0.3125391304,
-0.4129947424,
0.6515649557,
-0.100621447,
-0.6836773753,
0.4309320748,
0.11477568,
0.638410449,
-0.91777426,
0.1739519835,
-0.1643606573,
0.1523364484,
-0.1361274123,
-0.6667514443,
0.2737108171,
-0.068508558,
-0.3044638038,
-0.4505003095,
0.7078191638,
-0.4761840999,
-0.655163765,
0.5720223188,
0.7234700322,
0.234758094,
-0.0019944678,
-0.6090747714,
0.3363515139,
0.110742718,
-0.4465359747,
0.6801276207,
0.6271297336,
-0.3950521648,
0.8946082592,
0.5888952613,
0.2469066083,
0.4276256263,
0.1904371381,
0.5759755373,
-0.6991262436,
-0.3667420447,
-0.7232094407,
0.293412596,
0.0835518688,
-0.3180427551,
1.0978758335,
0.6244964004,
0.8286315203,
-0.0675060377,
0.4529772997,
0.3018510044,
0.4897617996,
-0.510540545,
0.8200765848,
-0.5430408716,
0.1860323697,
-0.2438331544,
-1.0744001865,
-0.0587675683,
0.422488749,
-0.296669662,
0.2733862698,
0.5522918701,
0.6248327494,
0.2199954689,
-0.0589232482,
0.6112732291,
0.0599239133,
0.2525133789,
0.2239326835,
0.8148036003,
-0.0080083059,
0.3837729096,
-0.1927157044,
0.0219217055,
-0.1222851127,
-0.8991934657,
-0.9271982312,
-0.5446752906,
-0.3277789652,
0.0629511625,
-0.1676294208,
0.6892101765,
0.8158028126,
-1.0064564943,
-0.4759156406,
0.3892788887,
0.2623625994,
0.2295214534,
-0.2336518466,
0.3218268156,
-0.2493781447,
-0.5289216638,
0.2723723054,
0.2979438007,
0.0268213507,
-0.5269424319,
-0.1062257662,
-0.346475333,
-0.1186854169,
0.7515909672,
0.1325453073,
-0.7938970327,
0.175921008,
0.0999992788,
-0.1548336297,
-0.2768596113,
0.8473521471,
-0.5734456778,
0.2048104554,
0.1506522894,
0.5255778432,
0.5376173854,
-0.3360692859,
0.6283249855,
-0.7979124784,
0.3211955726,
-0.0339731462,
0.4932843745,
0.3943607509,
-0.3057770729,
0.4442532659,
0.2144689262,
-0.4379252493,
-0.8775546551,
0.0090769604,
-0.3234582543,
-0.4533575475,
1.3064931631,
-0.138730824,
0.0520483889,
-0.2540921271,
0.0339581557,
-0.1433525681,
0.0318267755,
0.1333801597,
1.0785855055,
-0.1724995077,
-0.503305316,
-0.8150117397,
0.4357125759,
0.3137759268,
-0.5111021996,
0.241410464,
0.4543821514,
0.2497317642,
0.1845076829,
0.3662657738,
-0.0116593139,
-0.118774727,
-0.1535239071,
-0.1645343006,
0.0545547865,
-0.7479697466,
-0.4469066262,
0.2302289605,
0.1801071465,
0.2335080206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19154v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19154v2
|
RTF: Region-based Table Filling Method for Relational Triple Extraction
| 2024-04-29T23:36:38 | 2024-06-13T16:26:15 |
Ning An, Lei Hei, Yong Jiang, Weiping Meng, Jingjing Hu, Boran Huang, Feiliang Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Relational triple extraction is crucial work for the automatic construction
of knowledge graphs. Existing methods only construct shallow representations
from a token or token pair-level. However, previous works ignore local spatial
dependencies of relational triples, resulting in a weakness of entity pair
boundary detection. To tackle this problem, we propose a novel Region-based
Table Filling method (RTF). We devise a novel region-based tagging scheme and
bi-directional decoding strategy, which regard each relational triple as a
region on the relation-specific table, and identifies triples by determining
two endpoints of each region. We also introduce convolution to construct
region-level table representations from a spatial perspective which makes
triples easier to be captured. In addition, we share partial tagging scores
among different relations to improve learning efficiency of relation
classifier. Experimental results show that our method achieves state-of-the-art
with better generalization capability on three variants of two widely used
benchmark datasets.
|
[
-0.5803887248,
-0.8871718645,
0.4926971495,
0.1631711572,
-0.1642713696,
0.0554716811,
0.0020860285,
-0.6592838764,
0.1041955203,
0.5314627886,
-0.1971854419,
-0.7329006791,
-0.3276077509,
0.1463369131,
0.0218554959,
0.7184442878,
-0.3115874827,
-0.135167405,
-0.2811881006,
-0.1336888224,
-0.7133053541,
-0.3194672465,
-0.4024806619,
-0.4740264118,
0.3679252565,
0.9097357392,
0.6031158566,
0.8648267984,
0.4868046343,
0.211619094,
0.3961466551,
0.4057169855,
-0.0798267573,
0.2090672851,
0.0670148209,
-0.4007852077,
-0.7181779742,
-0.1636029035,
0.7533721328,
0.7721999288,
-0.1912150532,
0.0394172929,
-0.180769369,
0.9871983528,
-0.3839211762,
0.7025901675,
-0.6548962593,
0.3174839914,
-0.618850708,
-0.4235573411,
-0.3069427907,
-0.4189362824,
0.1636828631,
-0.683999598,
0.4307961166,
0.2939795852,
0.8279078603,
-0.0039407033,
-0.739712894,
-0.0215339661,
-1.0199862719,
0.3742204607,
-0.1835887879,
0.5715543628,
0.5406995416,
0.4005536139,
-0.2418388277,
-0.574326098,
-0.6709189415,
0.2003028095,
-0.504930377,
-0.2312669903,
-0.1474061757,
-0.1469069719,
0.2587029338,
0.4005299211,
-0.6493005753,
-0.4188912809,
-0.1229332462,
0.0574770272,
0.3256431222,
-0.0386143178,
0.6316605806,
-0.2863339484,
-0.4327294827,
-0.0429081097,
-0.7869638801,
-0.3278560042,
0.0189822409,
0.5506749153,
-0.0939693078,
0.5393826962,
-0.1268436015,
1.0751076937,
-0.0723471567,
-0.1798780113,
0.310197562,
-0.4155242443,
-0.1147574857,
-0.1045365408,
0.803129375,
0.4344566464,
0.1000137255,
-0.2917470038,
0.0548565164,
-0.3900467157,
-0.2814746499,
-0.3410142362,
-0.5705063939,
0.084422119,
-0.134125337,
-0.0363123231,
0.1322440356,
-0.9811611176,
-0.3743088245,
-0.2031516135,
0.0868612528,
-0.5209195018,
-0.5631391406,
-0.0152291702,
-0.1625642776,
0.2905954421,
-0.0203176308,
-0.8206422925,
0.3454290926,
0.4937491417,
0.8413351774,
-0.0808918178,
-0.1834404916,
-0.5201921463,
0.8932441473,
0.0467276052,
1.0797650814,
-0.4600515068,
-0.3120163679,
-0.0077697118,
-0.3904978931,
0.2595410049,
-0.6090493202,
0.1923575997,
-0.721503675,
0.2938472629,
-0.5611338615,
-0.2636489272,
-0.1297196001,
0.3785521984,
-1.0705813169,
1.2707759142,
0.2314198166,
-0.9185886383,
0.5764078498,
-0.5897357464,
-0.5804380774,
0.2623421848,
-0.3875160515,
-0.5890889764,
-0.5379773974,
0.6773297191,
0.5276317596,
-0.2718774378,
0.3338383138,
-0.4323323965,
-0.1687713861,
-0.0228215754,
0.2196606547,
0.4762002826,
-0.1811169237,
-0.1216058508,
-0.2381094694,
-0.5589414239,
-0.0601766631,
0.075139448,
-0.2378899604,
-0.4599972069,
-0.168910563,
-0.2995705307,
0.1340713352,
0.1209546775,
-0.4361751676,
0.2867688239,
-0.2520036101,
0.1543044299,
0.0718193576,
0.4478844106,
0.8235540986,
-0.1472329646,
0.2621423006,
0.3258902431,
-0.372531414,
0.36751315,
-0.5081129074,
-0.566637814,
-0.3426162899,
0.5742339492,
0.5727493763,
-1.4409059286,
0.6133110523,
-0.4886250198,
-0.4600548148,
-0.041244328,
-0.0179430936,
0.2932182252,
0.7098863721,
0.6038293839,
0.1380511671,
-0.6863148212,
-0.9166651964,
-0.1223610565,
-0.026991073,
0.1262138784,
0.3342263103,
0.4325960577,
0.3124348223,
1.1262987852,
-0.7147092223,
-0.7804806828,
-0.4690047503,
-0.006795221,
0.0861614347,
0.5831915736,
0.5666236877,
-0.9936041832,
-0.8627370596,
0.1516997516,
-0.933812201,
0.1495267302,
0.1642301679,
-0.4862512946,
0.2608693838,
0.3652807772,
-0.4795913994,
0.3889379501,
-0.1410417408,
-0.364256084,
0.0176517814,
-0.0309031419,
0.0188689884,
-0.9164458513,
0.0416033268,
0.1927972585,
-0.3852454424,
-0.8238869309,
-0.0978721753,
0.2552639544,
-0.1344530433,
-0.1571771801,
0.4925579429,
-0.8608217239,
-0.3336206675,
0.2707919776,
0.3244231045,
0.1890820861,
0.7126722336,
0.2786359191,
0.4312701821,
0.3240196109,
-0.3974730968,
0.3431052566,
0.4529475272,
0.0176471602,
0.6435058713,
-0.2591900229,
0.1883512586,
-0.0967469215,
0.4933054745,
-0.5833922625,
-0.2401228994,
0.7077308893,
-0.3572573662,
0.6406911016,
-0.4922697246,
-0.4697293639,
-0.274353981,
-0.3086921871,
0.4715376496,
-0.0376930572,
-0.6700336337,
0.9018880725,
0.7589182258,
-0.0170544311,
-0.8162500858,
-0.8884237409,
-0.0007784175,
-0.307551533,
-0.6628547311,
0.7342177033,
0.5111432672,
0.0459404327,
0.4540015161,
-0.3071212173,
-0.1362491399,
-0.1289535761,
0.1110580713,
0.3012955487,
-0.0770758241,
-0.0045597064,
-0.1022835448,
-0.2586635947,
0.0489899591,
-0.4007415175,
0.6100978851,
-0.2975631356,
-0.056473121,
-0.4658070803,
0.6366380453,
0.1572115272,
-0.4604278505,
0.6940011382,
0.5599808693,
-0.9146680832,
-0.2035072297,
-0.4760255516,
0.1932060868,
-0.414147377,
0.3394958079,
-0.5627601147,
-0.6733381748,
0.5544689298,
0.2464917749,
-0.2436960638,
0.3035989702,
0.0703691319,
0.0093668653,
0.5563858747,
0.6328954697,
0.1053840518,
0.2615287304,
-0.5359220505,
0.4988544285,
-0.6684347391,
-0.6782766581,
-0.8323205113,
-0.1573802382,
-0.3608531356,
-0.4491822422,
0.5163794756,
0.2247047275,
-0.2616640329,
0.2473123372,
-0.4925979376,
0.7487283945,
0.4559630752,
0.2008334398,
0.5566654205,
0.4509496093,
0.0008049143,
-0.1340687275,
-0.6504932642,
-0.1777735204,
0.8464292288,
0.1375155747,
0.2986055017,
0.5539221168,
0.9318882823,
0.2652342618,
0.3143677711,
-0.7153073549,
0.5419934392,
0.1258153617,
-0.4400012493,
-0.295609355,
-0.803466022,
-0.7058122158,
0.2295734435,
-0.470379293,
-0.6062366962,
0.2908911705,
0.165283069,
-0.1568073332,
0.6537710428,
-0.6961094141,
0.8250043392,
0.0794795007,
-0.2493058294,
0.4796243012,
-0.4977117777,
0.557374239,
0.1207223162,
0.0687627941,
-0.078616865,
-0.0258488338,
0.8041856885,
-0.4091551602,
0.3390507996,
-0.6556386352,
0.2178452015,
0.2250319421,
0.2133988291,
0.369178921,
0.5352214575,
0.0266811624,
0.0811593905,
-0.0658618361,
-0.4794591963,
-0.8858082294,
0.6005357504,
-0.7422277927,
-0.4967287481,
-0.6791689396,
-0.6110448837,
-0.6647087336,
0.4379100204,
-0.1987870038,
0.6264942884,
0.0756520107,
0.0194526557,
0.5857379436,
0.0223246552,
0.4179797769,
0.3243865371,
-0.2735323608,
-0.7156820893,
0.9198758602,
-0.047682181,
-0.4136901796,
0.6285576224,
-0.0644942597,
-0.4330104291,
-0.4274311662,
-0.5143408775,
0.4788136184,
-0.5122871995,
-0.8616829515,
-0.7682756782,
-0.0286091752,
-0.2792729735,
-0.0046645245,
0.0063849352,
-0.3552465141,
-0.0373572856,
-0.1007787958,
0.2497255504,
0.8437640071,
-0.1644892842,
0.060522601,
-0.9102389216,
0.408387661,
0.3757463396,
0.4297594428,
0.1143176705,
0.2236297876,
-0.071812816,
-0.2392905504,
-0.0201210491,
-1.2581092119,
0.2661580741,
0.0091825947,
0.429331094,
-0.1072114184,
0.0259865839,
0.7082543969,
-0.2839374542,
0.425001055,
0.1238813996,
-0.8671929836,
0.4164532721,
-0.4266707003,
-0.0534601882,
0.4883700907,
0.4481763244,
-0.3853451014,
0.1323017031,
-0.4294077158,
-0.8701652288,
0.9851532578,
0.1515387148,
-0.4710507393,
0.0439652689,
0.5293869972,
-0.1567459702,
-0.1299273372,
-0.9604444504,
-0.4183856547,
0.0377254151,
-0.2541793883,
0.5754631162,
-0.373587817,
-0.2006551176,
-0.16017133,
0.7070990205,
0.0893833488,
0.5224330425,
0.358002305,
-0.0411696658,
-0.1627823859,
0.1116875485,
0.1424138993,
0.5432062745,
-0.4488663077,
0.3377565444,
0.0236370154,
-0.432898134,
-0.0024862334,
0.4673919678,
-0.1395259351,
0.0147795212,
0.4269271791,
0.2601883709,
-0.2162319869,
0.2319955826,
0.6254950166,
-0.4040132761,
-0.111652635,
-0.3862098753,
-0.2322662622,
0.1926792711,
0.169813022,
0.3690579236,
0.0842692927,
0.1881201416,
-0.3845389485,
0.3208018243,
0.3267368078,
-0.4653126895,
0.0885391235,
0.3504543602,
0.3676271141,
-0.212060526,
0.630926311,
-0.5772823691,
-0.5062878132,
0.4723477066,
0.6072057486,
0.3953438997,
0.1901836842,
0.1332188547,
0.5412896276,
0.1739149541,
0.0560209528,
0.5779498219,
-0.308270365,
-0.8925712109,
-0.255503118,
-0.3531928658,
-0.1530070752,
0.1323142052,
-0.7917918563,
0.2480155677,
-0.1042837352,
-0.0201820247,
-0.0491303243,
0.3577800989,
-0.6390299201,
-0.112224862,
0.2564234436,
0.9181608558,
-0.7550774217,
0.9853774309,
0.7968553305,
-0.361392349,
-1.0247268677,
0.0179468822,
-0.1650185585,
-0.4131554663,
0.5079869628,
0.1319931298,
-0.027056193,
-0.1103838235,
-0.0998137891,
-0.9943863153,
1.2564421892,
-0.0155725013,
-0.124066636,
-0.2585079372,
0.4297918379,
0.1478619874,
-0.4596451521,
0.0995951742,
0.8430634141,
0.5892570019,
0.0492806062,
-0.4388310313,
0.3769070208,
-0.2203580439,
0.265740186,
0.6368858218,
-0.1856323779,
0.3463581204,
0.0000097147,
-0.4406915605,
-0.3883613646,
1.0258131027,
0.4086473584,
0.357047677,
0.5931751132,
0.6614619493,
0.8750901222,
-0.4359788895,
0.5881783366,
-0.1522862613,
0.3281415701,
1.3114278316,
-0.525333643,
0.6882160902,
0.2941862345,
-0.133310467,
0.5725947618,
0.3787867129,
0.0381388292,
0.5270999074,
-0.0040593371,
-0.2899486423,
-0.1469954997,
0.0213942379,
-0.5477839708,
0.3510739505,
0.6659843922,
0.2086831033,
-0.4625032544,
-0.2787051797,
0.3299280703,
0.2094595879,
-0.1298823357,
0.5667642951,
-0.1291699857,
-0.6109810472,
0.2162288427,
-0.003428176,
0.3037635386,
-0.1198903471,
-0.4742928445,
-0.3777724504,
-0.239980042,
-0.4676916003,
-0.9638468623,
0.3505728245,
-0.2464539856,
-0.213910684,
-0.0432337523,
0.8328157663,
-0.829931736,
-0.1126479954,
0.2261130363,
0.7692816257,
-0.2455712259,
0.125770852,
-0.5477760434,
-0.1372947395,
0.1494316906,
-0.0698013753,
-0.0850102529,
0.7558215261,
-0.1446111798,
0.2928132117,
0.4430111051,
0.0200489685,
-0.3044290841,
-0.0936389714,
0.7495010495,
-0.8165945411,
-0.3846664429,
-0.738086164,
0.3585969508,
-0.4524624646,
0.0638989359,
0.4288714826,
0.6431660652,
0.7619162798,
0.0287997015,
0.6800479293,
-0.4182963669,
0.4460038245,
-0.6217213273,
0.7022511959,
-0.2935601771,
0.4008803964,
-0.1337540746,
-1.1466211081,
-0.9815839529,
0.2790894806,
-0.4058238566,
0.1875300109,
0.8511014581,
0.7531254292,
-0.1550671607,
0.1121838838,
-0.0346379951,
-0.0207957681,
0.4262002707,
0.5894421935,
0.6612403989,
-0.4199007452,
0.779453814,
-0.6587241292,
-0.2890717685,
0.027156312,
-0.9503875375,
-0.9005112648,
-0.7529690862,
-0.26869753,
-0.4898204207,
-0.2388516814,
0.6334316134,
0.682266891,
-0.4025216997,
-0.0268758833,
0.1682264954,
0.4396359622,
0.016436683,
-0.2821169496,
0.7651546001,
0.0856805071,
-0.3497827649,
0.1984484941,
0.3006586134,
0.0041257106,
0.0470861457,
0.2947832942,
-0.5565320849,
-0.5804186463,
0.2887642086,
0.3475257158,
-0.2991267741,
-0.3567187786,
-0.2347741574,
-0.060513597,
0.3365589678,
0.8023074269,
-0.6999512911,
0.1591129899,
0.497035861,
0.3311564326,
0.7331798673,
0.0222152323,
0.5962709785,
-1.0320481062,
-0.0241121426,
0.1256552339,
0.5559495091,
0.7353637218,
-0.528341949,
0.7113164663,
0.3630692661,
-0.4668485224,
-0.7782505751,
0.2560195923,
-1.1927554607,
0.0720267296,
0.9173569679,
0.0426373817,
-0.4471577704,
-0.4702090919,
0.0412651487,
0.4876815081,
-0.4733339548,
0.3892123401,
0.3754507303,
-0.3922036886,
0.1089133695,
-0.3008092344,
0.7502875924,
-0.0380815864,
-0.8391317129,
0.080682002,
0.4788860083,
0.3960303962,
0.2401014119,
0.7446444631,
-0.3270581365,
0.155298084,
-0.1495660245,
0.3262405097,
-0.3294252753,
-0.4797376692,
-0.1365618408,
0.4502027631,
-0.0541046783,
0.1192668229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19128v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19128v1
|
Q-GroundCAM: Quantifying Grounding in Vision Language Models via GradCAM
| 2024-04-29T22:06:17 | 2024-04-29T22:06:17 |
Navid Rajabi, Jana Kosecka
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Vision and Language Models (VLMs) continue to demonstrate remarkable
zero-shot (ZS) performance across various tasks. However, many probing studies
have revealed that even the best-performing VLMs struggle to capture aspects of
compositional scene understanding, lacking the ability to properly ground and
localize linguistic phrases in images. Recent VLM advancements include scaling
up both model and dataset sizes, additional training objectives and levels of
supervision, and variations in the model architectures. To characterize the
grounding ability of VLMs, such as phrase grounding, referring expressions
comprehension, and relationship understanding, Pointing Game has been used as
an evaluation metric for datasets with bounding box annotations. In this paper,
we introduce a novel suite of quantitative metrics that utilize GradCAM
activations to rigorously evaluate the grounding capabilities of pre-trained
VLMs like CLIP, BLIP, and ALBEF. These metrics offer an explainable and
quantifiable approach for a more detailed comparison of the zero-shot
capabilities of VLMs and enable measuring models' grounding uncertainty. This
characterization reveals interesting tradeoffs between the size of the model,
the dataset size, and their performance.
|
[
-0.4023717046,
-0.6417746544,
0.6075689793,
0.1494563669,
-0.4534881413,
-0.1573353261,
0.0802366212,
-0.005562779,
-0.2586320341,
0.2483825088,
-0.3982764184,
-0.8604010344,
-0.6699154377,
-0.4491163194,
-0.2441045791,
0.7126808167,
0.1095365956,
0.1615196466,
-0.7589825988,
-0.430257678,
-0.8039162755,
-0.5392140746,
-0.0240163617,
-0.1210549921,
0.0093515459,
0.1662132591,
0.9852893949,
0.6230270863,
0.8642121553,
0.1353495419,
-0.1385696381,
-0.241033271,
-0.4926634729,
-0.1811439842,
-0.0973963067,
-0.5053534508,
-0.2424182594,
0.1907810271,
0.8522771001,
0.71113801,
0.1885721982,
0.4160613418,
-0.2751819491,
0.6502745748,
-0.9730855227,
0.1261364073,
-0.650847137,
0.2451461107,
0.1163240895,
-0.3758561909,
-0.1502856314,
-0.0556722395,
0.0083356155,
-0.5463768244,
0.338344574,
-0.2143928558,
1.2683329582,
0.5652731061,
-0.0995574743,
0.1199948639,
-0.4283588529,
0.7604351044,
-0.6953956485,
0.5468286276,
0.4200582504,
0.6134560704,
0.0032360759,
-0.244539991,
-0.3605793715,
-0.3942660093,
0.0068301624,
0.2159118652,
-0.0541779548,
0.3179311752,
0.4848952293,
0.4249505699,
-0.4979109168,
-0.3075802028,
-0.2753369808,
0.001322452,
0.1816416234,
0.1952854693,
0.3774353266,
0.0143969115,
-0.2564162314,
-0.1848068535,
-0.4172263145,
0.276362896,
0.0306541231,
0.0028794135,
-0.1053076908,
0.8343507051,
-0.609383285,
1.1403053999,
0.0088536981,
-0.3948188722,
0.0965684131,
-0.1321993321,
-0.4254495203,
-0.3381724358,
0.4537492692,
1.0106527805,
0.2138045132,
-0.3170004487,
-0.0715720132,
0.4230695665,
0.0653474852,
-0.6847710013,
-0.089201197,
0.2870832682,
-0.2154141814,
-0.3901799917,
0.1377608329,
-0.520758152,
-0.2460023463,
-0.4032039046,
0.6489935517,
-0.4381546676,
-0.2076271474,
0.4966651201,
-0.3848351836,
0.7424325943,
0.3027101159,
-0.360373199,
0.1428479999,
0.7344642282,
1.1000939608,
0.1438910812,
-0.4410916865,
-0.7486607432,
0.0029512972,
-0.6483793855,
0.6738007069,
-0.4159011245,
-0.3403003216,
0.0504398644,
-0.1620818228,
-0.0648387223,
-0.4513066113,
0.4008349478,
-0.2804409862,
0.0055426476,
-0.220351249,
-0.4301996231,
-0.1634660959,
0.6034933329,
-0.3348979354,
1.0889908075,
0.150799185,
-0.7845231891,
0.6092804074,
-0.0420590676,
-0.0560233407,
0.3611095548,
-0.5874484181,
-0.3352368474,
0.6569327712,
0.1690095216,
0.6092210412,
-0.2414241582,
0.6066867709,
-0.2993113697,
-0.459436357,
-0.0599931069,
-0.0255066175,
0.6756452322,
-0.253366679,
-0.3146239519,
0.0746253729,
-0.8875480294,
0.2681403756,
-0.0454441272,
0.2101300359,
-0.3953434825,
-0.0462805256,
-0.4961439371,
0.3589046597,
-0.0799869671,
-0.3237866163,
-0.1320888698,
0.0466250256,
0.1385667473,
0.0652392507,
0.0027173248,
0.4046367705,
-0.1541308165,
0.6558784842,
-0.1114589125,
0.1556674093,
-0.5541524887,
-0.4971750379,
-0.6448383331,
-0.4259352982,
0.0035532992,
0.5723119378,
-0.6909572482,
0.3599478006,
-0.5986464024,
-0.6297140121,
-0.5044653416,
-0.3183346391,
0.6924254298,
0.7112597823,
0.2460916787,
-0.283538878,
-0.1221562624,
-0.7224814892,
-0.0270144939,
-0.2967107892,
-0.2201565951,
0.4212232828,
0.4131596684,
0.1390281618,
1.3934454918,
-0.4348663092,
-0.3883704543,
0.0755780041,
0.1720103323,
0.0561712198,
0.4841645956,
0.8901387453,
-0.6608324051,
-0.1976404637,
-0.004867923,
-1.1044715643,
-0.317918241,
-0.1066323146,
-0.2251358926,
-0.2951290011,
0.5415611863,
-0.8589612246,
0.9441885352,
0.5242413878,
-0.6175326109,
0.8022323847,
-0.0966947377,
0.2832988203,
-0.1340205073,
0.0538477302,
0.0741512775,
-0.2567865252,
-0.6602607965,
0.5904924273,
0.1052231193,
-0.3099094629,
-0.7544080019,
0.3842310607,
-0.689491272,
-0.6625480652,
-0.1596458405,
0.3310652375,
0.2004940957,
0.4342838228,
0.3708617985,
0.9202510715,
0.9379783869,
-0.7001246214,
0.2622742653,
0.2743228376,
-0.4494025111,
0.7390047312,
-1.0108160973,
-0.1111764014,
-0.3111120164,
0.0007288332,
-1.146504879,
0.0274940226,
0.0870938748,
-0.780564189,
-0.275577575,
-0.5868314505,
-0.2252324969,
-0.1989772767,
-0.2411526293,
0.5569610596,
0.726070106,
-0.2825942338,
0.4804961979,
0.25623703,
0.2682413459,
-0.3667854667,
-0.4628498256,
0.227715075,
-0.4139888287,
-0.6976320744,
0.150229916,
0.0801585466,
-0.4129931033,
-0.0223579407,
-0.1205907241,
-0.0011216868,
0.0642749518,
0.5065942407,
0.1218929067,
-0.3750393689,
-0.0324450657,
-0.2731941044,
-0.3101037741,
0.1371693462,
-0.3291304708,
0.3510403931,
-0.290813446,
-0.3722525239,
-0.2863782048,
0.0169656947,
0.7411080599,
-0.5012979507,
0.7621212602,
0.4537830949,
-0.4181077182,
0.2556388378,
-0.475345552,
0.178456381,
-0.382432878,
0.2886379361,
-0.7500299215,
-0.602646172,
0.4865314662,
0.0359569751,
-0.1504580379,
0.3505580425,
0.3754135668,
0.0747853667,
0.8335347772,
0.7118005753,
0.1451320946,
0.3227937818,
-0.3521901071,
-0.0325211883,
-0.7419868112,
-0.1894782484,
-0.3128483891,
0.0950952843,
-0.0957481191,
-0.8582781553,
0.1113578379,
0.4775626659,
-0.0756585076,
0.0433874466,
-0.2008804977,
0.7958638072,
0.5012404323,
-0.0501932129,
0.0786412284,
0.1041999981,
-0.0030949444,
-0.2231155783,
-0.5695071816,
-0.5676450133,
0.7783535123,
0.5020803809,
0.4676736295,
-0.2083830386,
0.1306285858,
0.1486606002,
-0.0586127974,
-0.9453721046,
0.6384341717,
-0.1127863452,
-0.2961652875,
-0.4993627667,
-0.1235212609,
-0.1289741099,
0.6135001779,
-0.1125328317,
-0.6369811893,
0.237206161,
0.1725869477,
-0.4692454934,
0.1880222857,
-0.3792374432,
0.9796303511,
-0.212739259,
-0.3893760443,
0.2140702903,
-0.7123490572,
0.2874688506,
0.3764016628,
0.1113551334,
-0.3859104216,
0.0757898986,
0.565341413,
-0.2162180394,
0.6927977204,
-0.4713905752,
-0.208696112,
0.3862951696,
0.1976936609,
0.0249262918,
0.1157244444,
0.2100486457,
0.6114209294,
0.021155322,
-0.6472422481,
-0.6695235968,
0.3057413399,
-0.5965895653,
-0.5321063399,
-0.2798092067,
-0.453450799,
-0.4734289944,
0.1147750691,
0.4584334791,
0.5714424849,
-0.1793666184,
0.3779620528,
0.6418069005,
-0.237638101,
0.1723450422,
0.3536344767,
-0.4813100696,
-0.425540328,
0.948439002,
-0.098398,
0.433891505,
0.4078849852,
0.0449232422,
-0.0065622772,
-0.6568519473,
-0.5026551485,
0.2274320573,
-0.7375962734,
-0.1916433871,
-0.6492191553,
-0.0711096898,
-0.3935930431,
-0.317492187,
-0.2252793312,
-0.3546921015,
-0.1001223102,
-0.5060517192,
0.1426139474,
0.1673284471,
0.0365516581,
0.8549314737,
-0.6311865449,
0.563960433,
0.3319309652,
0.3629904985,
-0.3475291133,
-0.6362671256,
-0.22997953,
0.1992931366,
0.1465601921,
-0.8917328119,
0.357281357,
0.3994558454,
0.4801756442,
0.4110462666,
-0.1320931911,
1.0526661873,
-0.630546689,
1.0246218443,
0.2085328698,
-1.1102727652,
0.7378780246,
-0.426512748,
0.2961713374,
0.6558902264,
0.079517588,
-0.311434269,
-0.3779250085,
-0.4838224947,
-0.6226587892,
0.4158995152,
0.2232121527,
0.0200743601,
0.1639173478,
0.4402157068,
-0.2470326424,
0.3969528079,
-0.4554145932,
-0.1284322888,
-0.3382048011,
-0.0413051993,
-0.3518680036,
-0.5715609789,
-0.2482955605,
-0.2712346315,
0.244361788,
-0.1246394888,
0.1523082703,
0.1694417596,
-0.4263927042,
-0.0057601803,
-0.2000547498,
0.7292382717,
0.7329561114,
-0.5167040229,
0.2910918891,
-0.1150521636,
-0.561137557,
0.2251564711,
-0.3494665921,
-0.3851991594,
0.5958377719,
0.5618199706,
1.0711683035,
0.1151075885,
-0.8615716696,
0.8390375376,
0.057851173,
-0.2564866543,
-0.1002040356,
-0.0492279567,
-0.5632891655,
-0.0229267236,
0.2653281689,
-0.3231678307,
0.1427637339,
-0.2793957889,
0.4063565731,
0.4603399038,
-0.6903809905,
-0.397800535,
0.4564543068,
0.0554766171,
-0.1554366946,
0.3388262391,
-0.208628431,
-0.6500672698,
0.882673502,
0.3609887958,
0.8541932702,
0.0346800648,
0.5670212507,
0.4137309492,
0.4645572603,
-0.0189826544,
0.0877550468,
-0.0299460758,
-0.7314719558,
-0.3918631673,
-0.3622738421,
-0.3032262027,
0.1128559336,
-0.9858232737,
0.340010196,
-0.5502552986,
-0.1785921007,
-0.4172700047,
-0.1647458375,
-0.74680233,
0.6881023049,
0.1427706778,
0.8367494941,
-1.2192811966,
0.4307065904,
0.9789796472,
-0.2457579374,
-0.3907004595,
0.0007195552,
-0.2393823564,
-0.7692972422,
0.9010370374,
0.4145689607,
-0.3366725743,
0.0860885009,
-0.5545161963,
-0.6624364853,
1.0788933039,
0.416864574,
-0.3254290223,
0.0527187474,
0.1501503438,
0.4798207283,
-0.449637115,
0.3885453045,
0.6030347347,
0.0515200645,
0.256467104,
-0.6372373104,
-0.3640710711,
-0.1635579765,
0.1258306652,
0.0494920723,
-0.3338854015,
0.7863664031,
-0.2060600519,
-0.2946999073,
-0.1540955454,
0.6875473857,
0.4761269689,
0.6009526849,
0.4592271745,
0.8264323473,
0.3959728777,
-0.1305044889,
0.7659620643,
-0.4688417912,
0.5163639188,
1.187300086,
-0.2319995761,
0.7140149474,
0.4736341834,
-0.0981166661,
-0.0454913303,
0.2685545087,
0.006397733,
0.7237713337,
0.2718465924,
-0.1114355028,
-0.4861911833,
-0.2801587582,
-0.4602954984,
0.3232952058,
0.3320914805,
0.0991974995,
-0.3599966466,
0.3050338626,
-0.251136601,
0.0844920874,
-0.3993837833,
0.6099752784,
-0.1825733185,
-0.3428922892,
0.6318924427,
-0.1453887224,
0.3362250924,
-0.3741256595,
-0.1804035902,
-0.5107915998,
-0.1627915651,
-0.0177630279,
-0.7218344808,
0.1181870103,
0.1566541493,
0.0234141648,
0.0366451256,
0.6128014922,
-0.2287614644,
-0.4321692288,
0.1657595187,
0.5158701539,
0.391250968,
-0.2880140543,
-0.450004369,
0.2720790803,
-0.243282184,
0.1197236478,
0.1262203306,
0.8536688685,
-0.0303799938,
0.8272352219,
0.4799910188,
0.2208460271,
0.4098494947,
0.1314903498,
0.6757292747,
-0.7579542994,
-0.5371630192,
-0.8215004206,
0.6972322464,
0.0621401407,
-0.4831363857,
0.7909075618,
0.3745192587,
0.8133069277,
-0.335955143,
0.5970820785,
0.0656420663,
0.1157843247,
-0.7330349684,
0.1987346709,
-0.3668752313,
-0.0086188037,
-0.3660621941,
-1.0058255196,
-0.5952631235,
0.9122079611,
-0.46826002,
-0.3157433867,
0.4697353542,
0.4454525709,
-0.061102841,
-0.6667556763,
1.1182779074,
-0.0766502768,
0.3167246878,
0.343834579,
0.9310202003,
-0.5070785284,
0.2064895332,
-0.3100327849,
-0.4918879867,
-0.1936500221,
-1.0568920374,
-1.0848685503,
-0.333509922,
-0.6800495982,
-0.0142596252,
0.230289951,
0.2087030262,
0.8248571157,
-0.5642288327,
-0.1107333452,
-0.3258648217,
-0.1763154566,
-0.1687737256,
-0.187033385,
0.2277982384,
-0.2925584614,
-0.3232973814,
0.0669411272,
0.355986923,
0.2707199752,
-0.3059479594,
0.0337259658,
0.0931111872,
-0.0459284224,
0.6895431876,
0.2446342409,
-0.765873313,
-0.3049489558,
0.0792255774,
-0.0252736341,
-0.096762076,
0.7769224048,
-1.0800379515,
0.3825692832,
0.3855129182,
0.6633039117,
-0.0804344341,
0.4428496659,
0.5648369789,
-0.7076527476,
0.6762397885,
0.0374072306,
0.2204213589,
0.3430407345,
-0.1592584252,
0.7429024577,
0.2851703763,
-0.2990508974,
-1.0285815001,
0.0156813953,
-0.7968766093,
0.1524449587,
1.1732202768,
-0.5603231788,
-0.1458889395,
0.275606215,
-0.3936332464,
-0.043407917,
0.1046906337,
0.5288434625,
0.7712565064,
0.3785643876,
-0.4111162722,
-0.8122765422,
0.3728109002,
0.5083957314,
-0.5421420336,
-0.0157228839,
0.8604832888,
-0.0127590364,
0.2182401568,
0.5945483446,
-0.0195190273,
0.3646313548,
0.1020230204,
0.0902589709,
-0.1429959536,
-0.6801242828,
-0.6570643187,
0.2036395967,
0.0871985033,
-0.7340821624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19124v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19124v2
|
Accelerating Production LLMs with Combined Token/Embedding Speculators
| 2024-04-29T21:59:07 | 2024-06-06T18:38:34 |
Davis Wertheimer, Joshua Rosenkranz, Thomas Parnell, Sahil Suneja, Pavithra Ranganathan, Raghu Ganti, Mudhakar Srivatsa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This technical report describes the design and training of novel speculative
decoding draft models, for accelerating the inference speeds of large language
models in a production environment. By conditioning draft predictions on both
context vectors and sampled tokens, we can train our speculators to efficiently
predict high-quality n-grams, which the base model then accepts or rejects.
This allows us to effectively predict multiple tokens per inference forward
pass, accelerating wall-clock inference speeds of highly optimized base model
implementations by a factor of 2-3x. We explore these initial results and
describe next steps for further improvements.
|
[
-0.3507378697,
-0.6542218328,
0.5164077282,
0.3884157836,
-0.25507617,
0.384649992,
-0.1050347835,
-0.7297087908,
0.4946625233,
0.614584744,
-0.4674139619,
-0.3461987972,
-0.7657123804,
0.0847536251,
-0.6006483436,
0.6775527596,
-0.1884236932,
0.1528071612,
-0.0104481373,
0.3161700368,
-0.1118024811,
-0.7094873786,
-0.6858283877,
-0.2039584368,
0.3184497356,
0.3829600811,
0.5409335494,
0.9222868085,
0.3320211172,
0.2857420146,
-0.3384421766,
0.3576124907,
-0.4963133335,
0.2753140926,
0.2857664526,
-0.4458583295,
-0.797421515,
0.0025086701,
0.5780323148,
0.5611698627,
0.0681421161,
0.162712723,
-0.2960366011,
0.2216614187,
-0.7538045049,
-0.0373147875,
-0.5753896832,
0.2624717057,
-0.0704619288,
-0.5096750855,
-0.9679718018,
-0.1961789727,
-0.1110946313,
-0.812489748,
0.4819715023,
0.3801860511,
0.5267025232,
0.0005100212,
-0.3706751466,
-0.1101247966,
-0.6218430996,
0.8418226838,
-0.7137799859,
0.4533621073,
0.2775894701,
0.2350944281,
-0.2662392259,
-1.1073410511,
-0.1029789075,
-0.1808553338,
0.1118608788,
0.2261131704,
0.1022329554,
0.3229836226,
0.4338922501,
0.5918236971,
-0.1365804374,
0.3074824512,
-0.4271860123,
-0.5058113337,
0.5168553591,
0.3800915182,
-0.0314876363,
0.1213208213,
-0.5009231567,
0.0549971759,
-0.5940558314,
-0.3295245767,
0.5237329006,
0.0977218151,
-0.1014842838,
0.5088198185,
-0.4247032702,
0.7025461197,
0.1021020859,
0.0963740051,
0.297252208,
-0.5247767568,
-0.3586402237,
0.0052477149,
0.3214801848,
0.4603588879,
-0.1370907724,
-0.4001448154,
-0.4655543268,
0.4397138655,
0.067736119,
-1.1520968676,
-0.0304481182,
0.2943471968,
-0.4136884212,
-0.3369033337,
-0.0786597356,
-0.758575201,
-0.3531568646,
-0.0883170962,
0.1896674782,
-0.3207653463,
-0.4934029281,
0.332798779,
-0.794886291,
0.2940218747,
0.1629940271,
-1.2118626833,
0.2789816558,
0.809520483,
0.8495573401,
-0.1277424842,
-0.1789370179,
-0.8041653633,
0.1941350549,
-0.6483876109,
1.0532861948,
-0.4689958096,
-0.6768212318,
-0.0048294277,
-0.2257265002,
0.0441594869,
-0.3559711277,
0.9169896245,
-0.7346976995,
-0.2244902849,
-0.2852476239,
-0.9055836797,
-0.0049689161,
0.3021548688,
-0.5987057686,
0.9119580984,
0.0948007703,
-0.7133125663,
0.7282970548,
-0.4764506519,
-0.3009724915,
0.0573057942,
-0.0352749377,
-0.0183359701,
0.4289748371,
0.2617612183,
0.5921600461,
-0.2272045016,
-0.0499356575,
-0.3278354108,
-0.8222203255,
0.225953266,
-0.3165706098,
0.2103090584,
0.4097365737,
0.081120275,
0.2758183181,
-0.8433161378,
0.0600674301,
-0.0995816737,
-0.6842702031,
0.0983183831,
-0.0589201152,
0.0813297182,
-0.0863081738,
0.0775250569,
-0.6102728844,
0.0390332527,
-0.3709564805,
0.5954499841,
0.7440209389,
0.0882863775,
0.5611717105,
-0.280977577,
0.7022640109,
0.0492512882,
0.1289968044,
-0.4507989883,
-0.4656915665,
-0.9602769017,
-0.294939667,
0.3254923522,
0.1994698644,
-0.5403594971,
0.0473379456,
-0.2047714889,
-0.3239880204,
-0.4458074272,
0.1063334495,
0.3700589538,
0.1755486131,
-0.0216508955,
-0.2857557833,
-1.0944566727,
-0.8150013089,
-0.3641195297,
0.092054747,
0.090796724,
-0.2741458118,
0.2646166682,
-0.2493498176,
0.5649481416,
-0.3935571015,
0.3807801604,
-0.3320005536,
0.4057292938,
0.4035635293,
0.3707981706,
0.4275788665,
-0.4150002003,
-0.309127748,
-0.1486767828,
-0.6593769193,
0.0452701747,
0.2177270651,
-0.3515665233,
0.2860917449,
0.9591093659,
-0.5648930073,
0.1410112679,
0.707152307,
-0.5362074375,
0.694634974,
-0.1305968463,
-0.0137966499,
-1.1444321871,
-0.3584187925,
0.0764884949,
-0.3236445189,
-0.8297572136,
0.1463071108,
0.1285189241,
0.1041980609,
-0.6400334835,
0.4253520966,
-0.8510458469,
-0.3188356459,
-0.4746108353,
0.0871539712,
0.1414560676,
0.2556484044,
-0.0278565958,
1.1698367596,
0.5576567054,
-0.7215826511,
-0.0179534089,
0.0672214851,
-0.5266724825,
0.0654144213,
-0.4314596951,
0.3496394455,
-0.0176296066,
0.3639468849,
-0.8225550056,
-0.2111752182,
-0.0573298298,
-0.522121489,
0.2344146818,
-0.1844298691,
-0.6752638817,
-0.5510184169,
-0.2586682141,
0.1593111753,
0.5854448676,
-0.4984022081,
0.7943600416,
0.2860037982,
0.3983944654,
-0.6105999351,
-1.1037191153,
0.0593287721,
-0.088948518,
-0.6330602169,
0.4922354221,
-0.1350756586,
-0.32959795,
0.0153128961,
-0.0458636992,
0.1499161571,
0.1979531497,
0.2612701356,
0.2023406029,
-0.3563177884,
-0.0453670323,
-0.0155154867,
-0.3265210688,
0.1739572436,
-0.5447996259,
0.521512866,
0.034269467,
-0.1284378767,
-0.3089552522,
0.334421277,
0.5813257098,
0.1832207292,
0.8465301991,
0.7350697517,
-0.2669217885,
-0.3113898635,
-0.7488100529,
-0.1931300163,
-0.5605140924,
0.5307301879,
-0.5519004464,
-0.7697399259,
0.7602933049,
-0.1354463845,
0.1655860841,
0.4755719006,
0.6770406365,
0.3637195528,
1.2879008055,
0.6919590235,
0.0525043793,
0.5647649169,
-0.5751051307,
0.0646044984,
-0.9554113746,
-0.1276509613,
-0.2200631797,
-0.2212216109,
-0.4524197876,
-0.8461139202,
0.0653181896,
0.1684964448,
-0.1901079416,
0.1136412397,
-0.2832074463,
0.5838177204,
0.6254586577,
0.090057753,
0.2725657821,
0.0394984409,
-0.4526947141,
0.2909700274,
-0.6911847591,
-0.4285613,
1.3179016113,
0.4565127194,
0.6351703405,
-0.1381185949,
0.5735440254,
0.2494136542,
0.5789880157,
-0.8196218014,
0.5788496733,
-0.202914834,
-0.8265632987,
0.1529801488,
-0.1129717231,
-0.2796765864,
0.2476434112,
-0.1794813424,
-0.6347784996,
0.1312879622,
0.1639314294,
-0.3288629651,
0.5258084536,
-1.0192240477,
0.4102925062,
-0.013368817,
-0.3920710981,
-0.4172047973,
-0.1373526305,
0.6173497438,
0.1028049812,
0.0773248672,
-0.367079109,
-0.1544878632,
0.8916074038,
-0.231035322,
0.938221693,
-0.3022394776,
-0.0094936267,
0.3889157474,
0.0026783361,
0.5571419597,
-0.0614040196,
-0.6845462322,
-0.0360496119,
-0.2369387597,
-0.5503544807,
-0.2739048004,
0.6205380559,
-0.8190232515,
-0.743903935,
-0.0988141149,
-0.7160003781,
-0.2758425474,
-0.0489511341,
0.440630585,
0.4116230607,
-0.2076196969,
0.1361646056,
0.2658398449,
0.135401085,
0.5256121159,
0.3672086,
-0.2392281145,
-0.5673545599,
0.4746239483,
0.1007286087,
0.5594285131,
0.2774290144,
-0.0626233444,
-0.2652963102,
-1.0084201097,
-0.4178248942,
0.0060607898,
-0.9632309079,
-0.2355296761,
-0.7570014,
-0.4714482725,
-0.3561318517,
-0.176541999,
-0.3311999142,
-0.554312408,
-0.3586596549,
-0.6713625789,
0.5595504642,
0.8471827507,
-0.0683056936,
0.6900735497,
-0.673371911,
0.1315463632,
-0.0319521129,
0.4637850523,
0.1746830642,
-0.847682178,
-0.6804719567,
-0.0754097328,
-0.3514975309,
-0.61326617,
0.3776857853,
-0.0290053319,
0.7522678971,
0.683855772,
-0.2140210569,
0.704841435,
-0.3281988502,
0.7089988589,
0.2362746894,
-1.0173501968,
0.3309071362,
-0.3559753597,
0.0576123297,
0.2376057059,
0.0893634483,
-0.3787733614,
-0.4100274444,
-0.3475734591,
-0.8510093689,
0.5932383537,
-0.0518983379,
0.2709973156,
-0.316881001,
0.5709430575,
0.2998371422,
0.0262843408,
-0.2012111694,
-0.184263736,
0.0473220907,
0.1803491414,
-0.2183691114,
-0.8337221742,
0.0147800986,
-0.2720499039,
0.6802193522,
-0.2556618452,
0.5730746984,
0.1526114792,
0.0174521003,
-0.3428857028,
0.0485353544,
0.5147479773,
0.7277733088,
-0.5220890641,
0.0869578719,
0.4820751846,
-0.3573894501,
0.163097769,
-0.095169194,
0.0552202128,
-0.1244386956,
0.3633191586,
1.2085684538,
0.3664043546,
-0.4615601599,
0.0941040963,
-0.2025838792,
-0.6623538733,
-0.4045250714,
0.1831222177,
0.3057863712,
0.445417732,
0.5246912837,
0.1559838653,
0.1031649858,
-0.4890770614,
0.2634684145,
0.2947354019,
-0.1514498442,
-0.5030747652,
0.8254164457,
0.2993605137,
-0.1652732342,
0.4827766418,
-0.3754956722,
-0.4738875031,
0.8357338905,
0.914283514,
1.0409579277,
0.1151326373,
0.0326558985,
0.2620761395,
0.0838793963,
-0.3701459765,
0.550360024,
0.1317820102,
-1.094384551,
-0.7430661321,
-0.7726600766,
-0.7441704273,
-0.1537293196,
-0.6014184356,
0.2249891609,
-0.6575391889,
-0.5729667544,
-0.0349428318,
0.1806055754,
-0.8361232877,
0.0425424017,
0.5674619675,
1.4576830864,
-0.8492519259,
0.9348145723,
0.5524913669,
-0.1854637414,
-0.697825551,
-0.0587846003,
-0.2296979427,
-0.9874826074,
0.8116564155,
0.2976606786,
-0.2304095328,
0.1892938912,
-0.3438477814,
-0.94114995,
1.3138264418,
0.4066334963,
-0.5662490726,
0.0230410136,
-0.217238903,
0.4728581607,
-0.6863310337,
0.4659707546,
0.8544737697,
0.4102859795,
0.1785672307,
-0.4172893465,
0.0765373632,
-0.3275119662,
0.0213216431,
0.2029938847,
-0.8117834926,
0.9497734308,
-0.1858687401,
-0.2924845517,
0.3810641766,
0.9955792427,
0.5114865899,
0.2980585694,
0.4391003847,
0.7112415433,
0.656476438,
-0.0284003131,
1.1933101416,
-0.7540453672,
-0.0144461477,
0.7870184779,
-0.2861977816,
0.9448523521,
0.6734030247,
-0.0880927369,
0.5839852095,
0.774348557,
0.0503761768,
0.3465315402,
0.2642790079,
-0.3520352542,
-0.2632405162,
-0.4842560291,
-0.362187475,
0.2594826221,
0.657346487,
-0.6156556606,
0.1690953225,
-0.3437494338,
-0.1667964607,
-0.0977308452,
-0.4110518694,
0.4109361172,
0.2124894112,
-0.6087521315,
0.5923476219,
0.2959302366,
0.9547564387,
-0.4739469588,
0.3990830779,
-0.2931261063,
0.3632563353,
0.0292720329,
-0.5335873961,
0.2916662097,
-0.1138994768,
-0.182788536,
-0.3859326839,
0.6078643799,
-0.0376071483,
-0.7389597893,
0.7738992572,
0.4685115218,
0.0045846291,
0.1091097966,
-0.2554359734,
0.3452958763,
-0.3400328755,
-0.4754267931,
0.1665005386,
0.4240904152,
0.1154077649,
0.5116750598,
0.775991559,
0.1792276949,
0.3990426064,
0.3105909824,
1.0706214905,
-0.8483196497,
-0.6471607685,
-0.8366162181,
0.3271715045,
-0.0616140701,
-0.1848545521,
0.7950966954,
0.6258541346,
0.5676275492,
-0.120146513,
0.7755405307,
0.3895202279,
0.2981408536,
-0.8180328012,
0.2411686927,
-0.1838329285,
0.1658309847,
0.1494701654,
-0.7219368219,
-0.0910265744,
-0.0975994468,
-0.2047451735,
0.0137983505,
0.7672032714,
0.8878561854,
0.0403488949,
0.236636132,
0.4144903719,
0.3577066958,
0.2943135202,
0.6611580849,
1.081058979,
-0.5656668544,
0.4868353605,
-0.3205286562,
0.0939432904,
-0.3686696291,
-1.092545867,
-0.9462019801,
-0.1384963542,
-0.1138016209,
-0.3605065644,
0.120459795,
0.8008915186,
1.1029791832,
-0.6803868413,
-0.3370284736,
-0.2999436855,
-0.1295004338,
-0.2169816941,
-0.1912576407,
0.1019471809,
-0.4119701385,
-0.847828567,
0.7729026675,
0.2552497089,
0.1894886345,
-0.4872704744,
-0.2181190401,
-0.0283245854,
0.3369232416,
0.5196758509,
-0.1664609313,
-0.6657605767,
-0.0737935528,
0.0842368975,
0.0557942688,
-0.0011053436,
1.0858722925,
-0.7708440423,
0.2173632979,
0.8001815677,
0.5100033283,
0.8374397159,
0.0457205474,
0.9705541134,
-0.8058264852,
0.7292239666,
-0.007515158,
0.4804063141,
0.2559996843,
-0.6461205482,
0.3798964322,
0.1723329872,
-0.2867736816,
-0.9535117149,
0.1572951376,
-0.6347944736,
-0.1352370828,
1.0794215202,
-0.1094226316,
-0.5054208636,
0.1914070994,
0.1726187766,
0.4268703461,
-0.5456699133,
0.4531593323,
0.5915537477,
0.0818413869,
-0.0823082626,
-0.8719754219,
0.4033551812,
0.4747717381,
-0.4553534985,
0.1168759987,
0.2488077432,
0.1179879159,
0.061689727,
0.711078763,
-0.0031966513,
0.1799956709,
0.7071012855,
0.0052610892,
-0.2797311246,
-0.2359168679,
-0.1261494607,
0.1465701014,
0.3331989646,
-0.3600342572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19119v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19119v1
|
Effects of Added Emphasis and Pause in Audio Delivery of Health Information
| 2024-04-29T21:36:16 | 2024-04-29T21:36:16 |
Arif Ahmed, Gondy Leroy, Stephen A. Rains, Philip Harber, David Kauchak, Prosanta Barai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Health literacy is crucial to supporting good health and is a major national
goal. Audio delivery of information is becoming more popular for informing
oneself. In this study, we evaluate the effect of audio enhancements in the
form of information emphasis and pauses with health texts of varying difficulty
and we measure health information comprehension and retention. We produced
audio snippets from difficult and easy text and conducted the study on Amazon
Mechanical Turk (AMT). Our findings suggest that emphasis matters for both
information comprehension and retention. When there is no added pause,
emphasizing significant information can lower the perceived difficulty for
difficult and easy texts. Comprehension is higher (54%) with correctly placed
emphasis for the difficult texts compared to not adding emphasis (50%). Adding
a pause lowers perceived difficulty and can improve retention but adversely
affects information comprehension.
|
[
-0.1139999554,
-0.805228591,
0.7437978983,
0.4145275056,
-0.4024597406,
-0.30436638,
-0.3331764042,
-0.7424669862,
0.5865760446,
0.2444211096,
-0.2221866101,
-0.2687254846,
-0.9785993695,
0.2240301222,
-0.314915657,
1.2281467915,
0.2541615963,
0.1172725037,
-0.0040081432,
-0.2226352543,
-0.8686042428,
-0.3454623222,
-0.504391551,
-0.1780018061,
0.5215699077,
0.540746212,
0.9514845014,
0.904379189,
0.6144071221,
0.2412839383,
-0.6158519387,
-0.3190448284,
-0.2326935083,
0.4283362031,
0.0053198701,
-0.3404069841,
-0.3070446849,
-0.1456477493,
0.7605457902,
0.7773804665,
-0.014051782,
0.1910006851,
0.2939170599,
0.8141874075,
-0.7378283143,
-0.2004373074,
0.0088798506,
0.1192044243,
-0.1708351672,
-0.7716737986,
-0.2340485901,
0.0056037307,
0.6738007069,
-0.8154797554,
-0.2066692114,
-0.1220999658,
0.7696628571,
0.8434256315,
-0.5479593277,
-0.6238840222,
-1.0929682255,
0.6239907146,
-0.4779668152,
0.6281664371,
0.6475501657,
-0.2142537832,
-0.0550033487,
-0.4812994003,
-0.343531549,
0.2099579424,
0.0624176301,
0.3829813302,
-0.113463603,
0.2917275727,
0.3934611082,
0.4458323717,
0.0102060148,
-0.0804913938,
-0.6232250333,
0.1042361334,
0.4336694777,
-0.0553955585,
0.5078825355,
-0.4796764553,
-0.0838383585,
0.0241329316,
-0.4383183122,
0.3967983723,
0.2875991166,
0.0824532956,
0.0586539283,
0.7085161805,
-0.3035089374,
0.1734045148,
0.2245062292,
-0.8189172745,
0.3893707395,
-0.5195667148,
-0.1209530979,
0.4314168096,
0.3567927182,
0.428129822,
-0.0869998261,
0.227783069,
0.1712216437,
-0.3584464788,
0.382420063,
-0.6103914976,
-0.0442294069,
0.5934843421,
-0.9075492024,
0.0749023706,
-0.1856914759,
-0.5554787517,
-0.4657361209,
-0.3163734674,
0.5420665145,
-0.6298113465,
-0.0230987146,
0.27219221,
-0.4675233066,
-0.2031318843,
0.3809155524,
-0.851008296,
0.3699424863,
0.271121949,
0.7948199511,
-0.31474334,
0.1068321615,
-0.3537277579,
0.2713371217,
0.0084089777,
0.7959356308,
-0.2987988591,
-0.5326735377,
0.0002658622,
0.1543809325,
-0.2055296302,
-0.5026782751,
1.1085323095,
-0.0545360707,
0.0694626048,
-0.3659934103,
-0.6877439022,
-0.269993037,
-0.0408504941,
-0.8488405347,
0.9172300696,
-0.1142787486,
-1.1148875952,
0.4678147137,
-0.4623096883,
-0.9840717912,
-0.2044275254,
-0.1155977175,
-0.4836783707,
-0.1076511666,
0.3492263258,
-0.0108081615,
0.1431042403,
-0.2175559103,
0.1459069848,
-0.7885575891,
0.7331848145,
-0.5642902255,
0.4053730071,
-0.1156584993,
-0.8373484015,
-0.0921791196,
-0.5121931434,
-0.0744255185,
-0.2066439241,
-0.8062957525,
-0.5725333691,
0.1245279387,
0.0975703299,
-0.0531017333,
-0.1533768028,
-0.314889729,
-0.1186113432,
-0.2878040671,
0.2241178602,
0.2865302861,
0.531570375,
0.0891699716,
-0.7301143408,
0.5422848463,
-0.044974193,
0.393445015,
-0.4912851751,
-0.7899922729,
-0.501408875,
-0.3684782386,
0.2986194193,
0.8637563586,
-0.2687532306,
0.1174399555,
-0.0603112541,
0.0216585416,
-1.0545344353,
0.0800601318,
0.3696631491,
0.5468871593,
0.6782163978,
-0.3079763353,
-0.2329655737,
-0.7062837481,
-0.2866076529,
0.0029107607,
-0.201838702,
0.6741663218,
-0.0350181423,
-0.1930081397,
0.362446934,
-0.2883500755,
-0.3967622519,
0.0013668193,
0.1267209798,
0.0739894658,
0.4509934485,
0.1810877025,
-0.826895237,
-0.1770496666,
-0.4399305284,
-0.1905077398,
-0.1495307684,
-0.2072682828,
0.1157783344,
-0.2502075434,
0.1861975193,
-0.5314034224,
0.7711791992,
0.1561119258,
-0.2765437663,
0.6443062425,
-0.224164784,
0.8876265883,
-0.5786919594,
-0.0140924947,
-0.1955125779,
0.0579812303,
-0.7729330063,
-0.5049405694,
-0.1537282467,
0.002897152,
-0.468973726,
0.2187738717,
-0.4288975596,
-0.038334012,
-0.5352857709,
0.1511263102,
0.4844838679,
-0.0234571192,
0.0843726844,
0.749653399,
0.1096042246,
-0.8121657372,
-0.2191837132,
0.3252896965,
-0.3348688781,
0.8913149834,
-0.8268281817,
0.0982682481,
-0.1143130735,
0.2308161408,
-0.9466713667,
-0.5789743662,
0.1084995717,
-0.435803026,
0.3834784925,
0.1191322654,
-0.1859048605,
-0.3505186141,
-0.3489896059,
0.5844804049,
0.4381643534,
-0.0563964956,
-0.0585865267,
0.5931341052,
-0.4749068916,
-0.6136338115,
-0.8521149158,
-0.1102635637,
-0.484146148,
-0.4283415079,
0.4502820075,
-0.2339921445,
-0.2803372443,
0.1421995014,
-0.2975986898,
-0.4084795117,
0.258262217,
0.4709459841,
-0.1163827777,
-0.0369977504,
0.7230275273,
0.3048982322,
0.0240749959,
-0.0529994965,
-0.0967063457,
0.0056598173,
0.1427373886,
-0.2929987609,
-1.0937956572,
0.7613059282,
0.4855187237,
-0.0082507525,
0.6803025603,
0.4476771355,
-0.348120451,
0.6730207205,
-0.6441203356,
-0.5229855776,
-0.4149764776,
0.0860995203,
0.1054590866,
-0.8087105751,
0.091675289,
0.0844178051,
-0.1952570081,
0.2077277601,
0.3384877443,
-0.6274107099,
1.1128259897,
0.4110307992,
0.2125110477,
0.6004082561,
0.1253390014,
-0.1696257591,
-0.9068291187,
-0.0584515333,
-0.601633966,
-0.3962475955,
-0.3379640579,
-0.3006664515,
0.4946815073,
0.1383410245,
0.116886504,
-0.1841270328,
-0.8804035187,
0.0924553052,
0.6085223556,
0.5616382957,
0.5036185384,
-0.2391000986,
0.2419306338,
-0.4487657845,
-0.2993032038,
-0.284419477,
0.8817960024,
0.4626464844,
0.6313078403,
0.1248793751,
0.3227833211,
0.3850547671,
-0.1173232868,
-1.0768947601,
-0.1215105727,
0.1301940233,
-0.6250095367,
-0.6421535015,
-0.0623061843,
-1.3519865274,
-0.1709150076,
-0.3860274851,
-0.6440720558,
0.2620352805,
0.2843952477,
-0.7149943709,
-0.3345985711,
-0.5915541053,
0.4732388258,
-0.1420758218,
-0.1776473671,
-0.2742675543,
-0.7950255275,
-0.0757190734,
0.2133596241,
0.7516735792,
-0.3321599066,
-0.1619051397,
1.0157665014,
-0.3400957882,
0.4118162394,
-0.0030484253,
0.21496737,
0.4105120003,
-0.4302355647,
0.3774821162,
0.1063797548,
-0.1079073697,
-0.4392206371,
0.0154143581,
-0.4240536094,
-0.5736005306,
0.235911727,
-0.5948622823,
-0.8446564674,
-0.1145949066,
-0.6378130913,
-0.0051583047,
0.228597194,
0.5087890029,
0.5605819225,
0.0648358241,
0.4646219909,
0.9880353808,
-0.2268809229,
0.1030297652,
0.3225117922,
0.4274683297,
-0.5115450025,
0.3772982359,
0.6077951789,
0.2580149174,
0.1674475074,
0.5527302027,
-0.2313112766,
-0.5607787371,
-0.2678707838,
0.2827997506,
-0.7354163527,
0.1653404832,
-0.9144501686,
-0.0525801964,
-0.6528269053,
-0.089194797,
-0.2400672138,
-0.6583402157,
-0.4594819248,
-0.2417227477,
0.7964968085,
0.6275871396,
-0.0141949104,
0.5385366082,
-0.814954102,
0.1048510894,
0.3208509386,
0.1401134431,
-0.1976359934,
-0.6168608665,
-0.6951373816,
-0.2751309276,
-0.3684504628,
-1.42489779,
-0.1988325715,
0.0688805357,
0.3527137637,
0.6094775796,
0.3694644868,
0.6359760761,
-0.4167313278,
0.8592746854,
0.0662838593,
-0.8562101126,
0.555033505,
-0.3811379373,
0.8750322461,
0.8918503523,
0.2522888482,
-0.8837792277,
-0.7355600595,
-0.6492816806,
-1.0805382729,
0.4078076482,
0.4606591463,
-0.0110257426,
-0.2394714355,
0.2033058405,
0.09157224,
0.3359608352,
-0.4909669757,
-0.5607675314,
-0.3072225451,
0.0365671217,
0.4137861133,
-0.740203023,
-0.23682262,
-0.3732184172,
0.478172034,
0.4360055029,
0.3713440299,
0.8554183245,
-0.1993029714,
-0.1612071246,
0.7576739788,
0.6267467141,
0.4055759609,
-0.2931940258,
0.3212224841,
0.1255695522,
-0.902887404,
0.3957050741,
0.1507817209,
-0.3781663775,
0.4099574983,
0.5215592384,
0.9025933743,
0.6711421013,
-0.6195397377,
0.4798866808,
0.0877858847,
-0.1194478795,
-0.2206314653,
-0.0058410331,
0.227094546,
0.0305588972,
0.3908504546,
-0.1897742003,
0.9270026684,
-0.3435899615,
0.4298057854,
-0.0765350237,
-0.6905559301,
0.0597024001,
0.7949641943,
0.1954213679,
-0.1350539774,
0.3494900763,
0.3917676806,
-0.3905559778,
0.5643504262,
0.6335695386,
0.439745456,
-0.5398267508,
0.1389216781,
0.2344847322,
0.3751973808,
-0.0091804517,
0.5136283636,
-0.2691281438,
-0.0616135933,
-0.5771721005,
-0.0340258367,
-0.7895667553,
-0.0673024282,
-0.9274142981,
0.0165226292,
-0.2305857986,
-0.7571219802,
0.0413390622,
0.1027793139,
-0.6765375733,
0.5095363855,
-0.0853666887,
0.6065558791,
-0.6531880498,
0.3319886029,
0.7799502015,
-0.2676971257,
-1.0580052137,
0.3843306303,
0.1467896849,
-0.1341975033,
0.0553908385,
0.5167866349,
-0.0140338494,
-0.3230487406,
-0.1332835406,
-1.1717323065,
0.6978097558,
0.2135491818,
-0.2996112108,
0.3070390224,
-0.0435688198,
0.5542227626,
-0.0133954315,
0.6167603135,
0.65125525,
0.8462183475,
-0.1148587689,
-1.0944750309,
0.0850551352,
-0.3140537143,
-0.4184786677,
0.0594964735,
-0.600505054,
0.6581630707,
-0.209473148,
-0.4655858278,
-0.3551624119,
0.4586090744,
0.0406656973,
0.701531291,
0.7177867889,
0.228860721,
1.1243071556,
0.0868540034,
1.2717438936,
-0.0323402062,
-0.1047181785,
1.067640543,
0.2039647549,
0.7406573296,
0.4879828095,
-0.0564753823,
0.5481049418,
0.6592847109,
0.6559501886,
0.3433906436,
-0.0729634166,
-0.3501086533,
0.245906502,
-0.7139175534,
-0.7380496264,
0.2478713542,
0.6841621995,
-0.518877089,
0.4851434231,
0.5316519737,
0.4403895736,
-0.0086662546,
-0.0212694034,
0.7099475861,
0.0930552781,
-0.7331726551,
0.5573206544,
-0.4561156034,
0.3115102649,
0.0176615342,
0.1105631515,
0.1005345806,
-0.284971267,
-0.4808781147,
-0.7065908313,
0.3298571408,
-0.145882979,
-0.6579653621,
-0.1613496244,
0.6891739368,
-0.6357094646,
-0.0122817978,
0.4320139885,
0.2240950316,
0.542557478,
0.0302705169,
-0.5287302136,
0.2982129753,
-0.1803797334,
-0.5758323073,
-0.094206661,
0.4661113024,
0.283054173,
0.1532230973,
0.5217652321,
0.3194550276,
-0.0535120852,
-0.0027053303,
0.5289990902,
-0.7973279357,
-0.7698534131,
-0.5361148119,
0.4166494608,
-0.2283979207,
-0.2203228623,
0.7763361335,
0.2642937303,
0.1672649235,
0.1854788065,
0.6989579797,
0.1816963702,
0.9188033342,
-0.6017028093,
0.6638911963,
-0.6749284863,
0.0424211845,
-0.4325805902,
-0.6015204787,
-0.1589488834,
0.2228271812,
-0.2605295181,
-0.336356014,
1.0498919487,
0.0103675406,
0.2903205454,
0.1273176372,
0.0613062307,
0.1231937855,
-0.0285202377,
0.152109772,
0.6077716947,
-0.0752097145,
0.6857036352,
-0.4469068348,
-0.3443787992,
-0.6740746498,
-0.5896368027,
-0.5822659731,
-0.1095941961,
-0.3197217286,
-0.6185984015,
0.2879989743,
0.9361225367,
0.6229905486,
-0.463383615,
0.1645510346,
0.4830132723,
0.5221925378,
-0.5442998409,
-0.2428707629,
0.6617560983,
0.0168460682,
-0.8058685064,
0.6056841016,
0.5618876815,
0.247535646,
0.2399867624,
-0.0267318953,
-0.1850454509,
0.3980054557,
0.1820494384,
0.6141225696,
-0.4728913903,
-0.4751961827,
0.1136118248,
-0.3295624852,
0.6441121697,
0.9316704273,
-0.4843298793,
0.8368737102,
0.5299509764,
0.487477839,
0.4351244271,
0.3572309315,
0.430111587,
-0.5533065796,
0.5740552545,
0.2902769148,
0.2927887738,
0.4492729306,
-0.8033676744,
0.1653591245,
0.1264580488,
-0.7410991788,
-0.6768665314,
-0.2441146523,
-0.8390094638,
-0.1280156374,
1.1967301369,
-0.0023307947,
-0.1538830251,
-0.7475391626,
-0.4265969396,
0.756745398,
-0.6756545901,
0.8108844757,
0.8834481239,
-0.333645463,
-0.1349554807,
-1.0271453857,
0.844389081,
1.0147993565,
-0.6515865326,
-0.2408232689,
0.2848879695,
-0.0095111094,
0.2091310918,
1.0669603348,
0.0044106408,
0.7371765971,
-0.0835845172,
-0.2571684718,
0.4295052588,
-0.3601537049,
-0.2676304281,
0.0211114082,
0.1306981891,
-0.209823519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01592v1
|
Text and Audio Simplification: Human vs. ChatGPT
| 2024-04-29T21:00:33 | 2024-04-29T21:00:33 |
Gondy Leroy, David Kauchak, Philip Harber, Ankit Pal, Akash Shukla
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, H.4
|
Text and audio simplification to increase information comprehension are
important in healthcare. With the introduction of ChatGPT, an evaluation of its
simplification performance is needed. We provide a systematic comparison of
human and ChatGPT simplified texts using fourteen metrics indicative of text
difficulty. We briefly introduce our online editor where these simplification
tools, including ChatGPT, are available. We scored twelve corpora using our
metrics: six text, one audio, and five ChatGPT simplified corpora. We then
compare these corpora with texts simplified and verified in a prior user study.
Finally, a medical domain expert evaluated these texts and five, new ChatGPT
simplified versions. We found that simple corpora show higher similarity with
the human simplified texts. ChatGPT simplification moves metrics in the right
direction. The medical domain expert evaluation showed a preference for the
ChatGPT style, but the text itself was rated lower for content retention.
|
[
-0.2124149948,
-0.7039891481,
0.8369089365,
0.360044986,
-0.5108599663,
0.1170216575,
-0.31381616,
-0.6939065456,
-0.006990192,
0.0553196445,
-0.6534081697,
-0.4180919528,
-0.6630567908,
0.3744711876,
-0.059716098,
1.2932046652,
-0.0358811393,
0.5216242075,
-0.3290551007,
0.0410153531,
-0.4498334527,
-0.5554240346,
-0.9772503972,
-0.5459484458,
0.4344729781,
0.4061069489,
0.9906526208,
0.6653526425,
1.0510239601,
0.2832451761,
-0.4023224413,
-0.033892367,
-0.2178480029,
-0.1804685146,
0.2756667733,
-0.1846752614,
-0.7534075975,
-0.1907160878,
-0.0036880439,
1.2085007429,
-0.2179053128,
0.087918438,
-0.0502739325,
0.9974242449,
-0.3579283655,
0.3154198229,
0.0312325638,
0.206116423,
0.2514435053,
-0.5503643751,
-0.0730522648,
-0.5518414974,
0.4072363377,
-0.9531190395,
0.4003995955,
0.2100708932,
0.7230024338,
0.6090498567,
-0.5649082065,
-0.7102898955,
-0.8598126173,
0.437892288,
-0.4460013807,
0.5180312395,
0.179232657,
0.3297027946,
-0.0042947005,
-0.9717923403,
-0.4133555293,
-0.2023626268,
-0.1755303741,
0.4113716185,
-0.4172632694,
0.5388174057,
0.5290828943,
0.5092760921,
-0.7687397003,
-0.315207243,
-0.9151058197,
-0.2553557158,
0.4804371297,
-0.0787962228,
0.7505672574,
-0.4239989519,
-0.5197683573,
-0.1035880744,
-0.7304717898,
-0.4286316037,
0.0695038736,
-0.1912658215,
0.1014364958,
0.511952579,
-0.3556358218,
-0.0428091697,
-0.2117761821,
-0.5052596927,
0.4554595649,
-0.463727951,
-0.372366786,
0.415732801,
0.8961963058,
0.712310493,
0.3969725072,
-0.2247428298,
-0.0449318811,
0.243029654,
0.3080813885,
-0.6722023487,
-0.3915365934,
0.2264634073,
-0.7100972533,
0.0398866795,
-0.1037743315,
-0.3309501112,
-0.3989132941,
-0.5233720541,
0.4606638551,
-0.7365665436,
0.0400448404,
0.5357967019,
-0.3625063002,
0.0823305026,
0.8516580462,
-0.6748387218,
0.7568089366,
0.7767187953,
0.8313693404,
-0.3687274754,
0.0581457056,
-0.0062243929,
-0.2093853354,
-0.213267386,
0.8846309781,
-0.0248476285,
-0.5451458097,
-0.3095358014,
-0.3558244407,
-0.0147400778,
-0.8871179819,
1.2430810928,
-0.0437397733,
0.5445765257,
-0.2356701344,
-0.7654049397,
-0.242582202,
-0.0704025552,
-0.6612786651,
0.8420578241,
0.0547705069,
-0.9541128278,
0.5544184446,
-0.8365684152,
-0.3648728728,
0.1273966581,
-0.1824850589,
-0.4474835694,
-0.1911904067,
0.2682690024,
0.1779117137,
-0.32840994,
0.1107782647,
0.0476075038,
-0.6621213555,
0.1170745566,
-0.5633320212,
0.593611002,
0.4416457415,
-0.3411351144,
-0.1511894315,
-0.7466806769,
0.0243616384,
-0.2598257065,
-0.5709857941,
-0.084034279,
-0.0138535956,
0.3700449467,
0.045430515,
-0.006248727,
-0.459253639,
0.0134073421,
-0.0982236117,
0.4493280947,
0.0989420936,
0.3488206565,
0.2446704656,
-0.6076418757,
0.679033339,
-0.0932331905,
0.4426230788,
-0.1553684622,
-0.8499029875,
-0.5531201959,
-0.495018363,
0.5247597098,
0.9169328213,
-0.2753787935,
0.2233941853,
-0.4359765649,
-0.4964031577,
-0.9154613614,
-0.066749461,
0.3295390904,
0.5322666168,
0.5826452374,
-0.5019544959,
-0.4267039597,
-1.102969408,
-0.407622844,
-0.4299179018,
-0.6870442033,
0.3027094901,
0.121682927,
-0.3574037552,
0.6566097736,
-0.4032298625,
-0.3822068572,
-0.1523235142,
0.3742664754,
-0.066461198,
0.4108122289,
0.2046082765,
-1.0415999889,
-0.4297319651,
0.0864341483,
-0.4924574196,
-0.270837158,
-0.1036658511,
0.3936826587,
-0.1818481088,
0.6476433277,
-0.7029661536,
0.5601960421,
0.3199342191,
-0.1407473683,
0.4610826373,
-0.5006529689,
0.5899113417,
-0.7753506303,
-0.0054504662,
-0.2061772645,
-0.551012516,
-0.8186817765,
-0.1727886349,
0.1344810724,
-0.2947832644,
-0.5248631835,
0.167871058,
-0.4144948423,
-0.0261655524,
-0.0369638056,
0.3317116797,
-0.0052510523,
0.3918282688,
-0.047870066,
0.845122993,
0.2087186277,
-0.386734277,
0.4377502799,
0.3810922801,
-0.3815048039,
0.4473694563,
-1.1077357531,
0.0600050054,
-0.1964696199,
0.4215219319,
-1.0212914944,
-0.4598811269,
0.2611455619,
-0.4035435617,
0.1543022394,
0.0379565246,
-0.4574947953,
0.0866392031,
-0.3781723976,
0.5092978477,
0.7549114823,
-0.0319147818,
0.259185493,
0.1621272415,
-0.49729532,
-0.1723762006,
-0.786237061,
0.1381733119,
-0.1730672717,
-0.6325918436,
0.4327582419,
-0.4300737083,
-0.3989261687,
-0.0778828859,
-0.3340801895,
-0.3625157773,
-0.0152244866,
0.275200963,
0.0921292976,
-0.3173021078,
0.4407833815,
-0.0080780722,
-0.1527692527,
-0.040743567,
0.3209767342,
0.2913259268,
-0.2945192754,
-0.5969647169,
-0.6763057709,
0.7352969646,
0.3791454136,
0.3507399559,
0.1925595999,
0.6319388747,
-0.0785696208,
0.5309306383,
-0.6094359756,
-0.2517548203,
-0.4027071893,
0.1858670861,
-0.1842444688,
-0.7204592824,
0.2288823128,
-0.3538782597,
-0.1505270153,
0.6426930428,
0.4326087236,
-0.4053257406,
1.0281454325,
0.428142935,
0.3917020261,
0.1663706601,
0.3036853075,
0.1788467318,
-0.4917373359,
-0.3502162993,
-0.5154639482,
-0.0359368175,
-1.0232026577,
-0.244268164,
0.5200270414,
0.1487586498,
-0.0514480099,
0.2120085359,
-0.5779350996,
0.3242126107,
0.3376682997,
0.4117706418,
0.6617897153,
0.02366025,
0.139971301,
-0.132303834,
-0.7095910907,
-0.7133002877,
0.8880952597,
0.5449114442,
0.8113796711,
0.3082224429,
0.792555809,
0.3138638437,
0.2885304987,
-1.0862134695,
0.3209685683,
-0.1076305062,
-0.4357123971,
-0.1515933573,
-0.6254038811,
-1.001019001,
0.0818729848,
-0.2503851056,
-0.3149534464,
-0.1296699047,
0.1595697403,
-0.4213409424,
-0.1533394009,
-1.4890525341,
0.7541208863,
0.1777067482,
0.2475723177,
-0.0363817476,
-0.6686040163,
-0.0340827554,
-0.0053331042,
0.4062613845,
-0.1994434297,
-0.4362468421,
0.6665399075,
-0.6167794466,
0.5409059525,
0.3791227639,
0.3232831359,
-0.0409333482,
-0.153421104,
-0.0407526493,
0.0602104254,
0.2442291975,
-0.0627575368,
0.2296653241,
-0.3681023717,
-0.7532361746,
0.2493263483,
-0.709253788,
-0.6700401306,
-0.362659663,
-0.1431210488,
-0.1323922873,
0.185265854,
0.4757729173,
0.5251411796,
-0.5439754128,
0.2455928326,
0.727247417,
-0.2898459136,
0.0761992112,
-0.0426694416,
0.158932969,
-0.2324573249,
0.5459454656,
-0.1450537294,
0.4764053226,
0.4747244418,
0.4514692724,
-0.2552225888,
-0.3678629696,
-0.431627214,
0.2491953373,
-0.9375158548,
0.1343729496,
-0.6586981416,
-0.2101031095,
-0.4421500266,
0.0851185843,
0.034304779,
-0.7772470713,
-0.1978072077,
0.111567311,
0.364875406,
0.8284074068,
0.1210597008,
0.428073138,
-0.6650545597,
0.4820096791,
0.4768664241,
0.1888537854,
-0.7163492441,
-0.3146587312,
0.2815114856,
-0.1912309229,
-0.3046632111,
-1.0917236805,
0.1122909188,
0.3753337562,
0.3184945881,
0.3073516786,
-0.0564628579,
0.7623003125,
-0.7399812341,
0.7340601683,
0.4679873288,
-0.9392074347,
0.2330008149,
-0.2353481799,
0.5200361013,
0.6753969193,
0.5566052198,
-0.9912629724,
-0.3107890785,
-0.9379220009,
-0.8743451834,
0.2991658151,
0.5065053701,
-0.1108070388,
0.1818162501,
0.2759893239,
0.0343355313,
0.2582193315,
-0.4853306711,
-0.5132386684,
-0.2597844303,
-0.2964254022,
0.0267282948,
-0.2947656512,
-0.1019735113,
-0.1752792746,
0.2955432236,
0.0427882262,
0.5567311645,
0.7051287293,
-0.035980992,
0.1804399192,
0.7149160504,
0.7171575427,
0.7628356218,
-0.2798795104,
0.1290952712,
0.4124348164,
-0.8399339914,
-0.1318021417,
-0.0397026837,
-0.1347697079,
0.5674358606,
0.718531847,
0.9844602942,
0.463730067,
-0.7500035763,
0.7766745687,
-0.4182271659,
-0.5822809935,
-0.2412989438,
0.0238901675,
0.2957711816,
-0.1519929767,
0.2303581983,
0.4098587632,
0.8107221127,
-0.5816018581,
0.1663213521,
-0.2796193957,
-0.6228865385,
0.0490542687,
0.5306395292,
0.055683244,
-0.4461840093,
0.2667790055,
0.0418960527,
-0.3972324133,
0.3723527789,
0.1742117554,
0.7286790013,
-0.0548209734,
0.1088231653,
0.2915146947,
0.2628374696,
-0.2308761775,
0.322293371,
-0.2009456605,
-0.1134959832,
-0.5185473561,
-0.2141269445,
-0.9286440015,
-0.159970656,
-0.6656965613,
0.3261903524,
-0.3263914585,
-0.2118867338,
0.4240843058,
0.1164162159,
-0.7701789737,
0.5208115578,
-0.1166126728,
1.000664711,
-0.6044160128,
0.4668778181,
0.8790748715,
-0.4112463295,
-1.1143020391,
0.1427347213,
0.2270877957,
-0.3710901439,
0.5053985119,
-0.0566067211,
0.0198658109,
-0.2852036059,
-0.2215243131,
-0.3064835072,
1.0459984541,
0.4335342348,
-0.4708078504,
-0.1598722339,
0.2467124909,
0.9055416584,
0.0009297446,
0.7882592082,
0.5715801716,
0.4458017647,
0.0418244042,
-1.4348325729,
-0.0540854521,
-0.0142957009,
-0.3286723495,
0.0637125894,
-0.3330142498,
0.789855659,
-0.1480071098,
-0.6099255681,
-0.3106733859,
0.3474710882,
-0.066867426,
0.4267816246,
0.6535694003,
0.0430288762,
0.8849275708,
-0.3199149668,
1.3473135233,
0.1418585777,
0.3654719889,
0.8260977268,
0.2307413518,
0.8089786768,
0.5552130938,
-0.435680002,
0.4271705151,
0.7853448987,
0.4282484949,
0.2619869411,
0.2732869983,
-0.5533465147,
-0.1633056998,
-0.0634082779,
-0.4729897678,
0.329066813,
0.1528245956,
-0.1403567344,
-0.232013613,
-0.0930371433,
0.2632334828,
0.138248384,
-0.0550926886,
1.2248010635,
0.2827685773,
-0.6221715212,
0.4789014757,
-0.0210094042,
0.4187411666,
-0.5222904086,
0.1026093885,
-0.1590432376,
0.0102417665,
-0.4270287156,
-0.5197820067,
0.2818656564,
-0.0023926497,
-0.0738476664,
-0.282820791,
0.6577298641,
-0.5816895962,
-0.144442454,
0.1550099999,
0.5420224667,
0.5221464634,
-0.2359496057,
-0.7065306306,
-0.0625426099,
-0.02641383,
-0.2844042182,
-0.0640526935,
0.6132920384,
-0.0987546444,
0.7874680758,
0.6310382485,
0.3264116347,
0.0366077498,
0.1581429243,
0.8148717284,
-0.5695845485,
-0.4764450788,
-0.7666736245,
-0.1080878675,
-0.2049977779,
-0.4260560572,
0.4499239624,
0.5956138372,
0.6394451857,
-0.280754894,
0.6265973449,
0.0988987982,
0.8238353133,
-0.6298263073,
0.7675407529,
-0.6330769658,
0.0984926447,
-0.4591391087,
-0.6564714909,
-0.5598907471,
0.4036503732,
-0.1116655618,
0.0006900655,
1.1187763214,
0.5906258821,
-0.3421986401,
0.180252403,
0.3542856574,
-0.1653535068,
0.1176306084,
0.5407871604,
0.6355870366,
-0.6127657294,
0.9057198167,
-0.1680570692,
-0.2268081754,
-0.3608910143,
-0.8964401484,
-0.6000593901,
-0.3536843359,
-0.5254163742,
-0.0136264861,
0.077060774,
1.2270460129,
0.7154346108,
-0.5336543918,
0.1062040105,
0.0915011689,
-0.0666617826,
-0.3864616752,
-0.1735372841,
0.5613577366,
-0.2150345147,
-0.6870975494,
0.3125097454,
0.3769796193,
0.0980125666,
0.146571964,
-0.2743644416,
0.3210463524,
0.1358770728,
0.5602395535,
0.1079690009,
-0.6575143337,
-0.2494357526,
-0.0150965797,
-0.6960368156,
0.5048214197,
0.9985281229,
-0.4624664485,
0.4553774595,
0.6705884337,
0.4392054379,
0.5160577297,
0.2975623906,
0.4746696055,
-0.6601541042,
0.1104777232,
0.2615154684,
0.3123808205,
0.6740248799,
-0.265781194,
0.5505312681,
0.3003606498,
-0.6835220456,
-0.557195127,
-0.0304030292,
-1.4210362434,
-0.132490918,
1.1598135233,
-0.1344704181,
-0.1537029147,
-0.6422048211,
-0.8584364057,
0.2477679849,
-0.4713490903,
0.4901247025,
0.5687144399,
-0.3061317801,
-0.0970684066,
-1.0824451447,
1.1195963621,
0.5412228703,
-1.0305627584,
-0.2447922975,
0.2727496922,
0.3808147609,
0.3083658814,
1.0121608973,
-0.1752915382,
0.7619099617,
0.0638587698,
0.1966911554,
0.1297532022,
0.1160807908,
-0.2946846485,
0.1485699862,
0.1133890674,
-0.0273881294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19094v1
|
In-Context Symbolic Regression: Leveraging Language Models for Function Discovery
| 2024-04-29T20:19:25 | 2024-04-29T20:19:25 |
Matteo Merler, Nicola Dainese, Katsiaryna Haitsiukevich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Symbolic Regression (SR) is a task which aims to extract the mathematical
expression underlying a set of empirical observations. Transformer-based
methods trained on SR datasets detain the current state-of-the-art in this
task, while the application of Large Language Models (LLMs) to SR remains
unexplored. This work investigates the integration of pre-trained LLMs into the
SR pipeline, utilizing an approach that iteratively refines a functional form
based on the prediction error it achieves on the observation set, until it
reaches convergence. Our method leverages LLMs to propose an initial set of
possible functions based on the observations, exploiting their strong
pre-training prior. These functions are then iteratively refined by the model
itself and by an external optimizer for their coefficients. The process is
repeated until the results are satisfactory. We then analyze Vision-Language
Models in this context, exploring the inclusion of plots as visual inputs to
aid the optimization process. Our findings reveal that LLMs are able to
successfully recover good symbolic equations that fit the given data,
outperforming SR baselines based on Genetic Programming, with the addition of
images in the input showing promising results for the most complex benchmarks.
|
[
-0.0927582532,
-0.459348917,
0.785641849,
0.1173800901,
-0.294375658,
0.1144689992,
-0.2747880518,
-0.2582729757,
0.2250296474,
0.5999849439,
-0.7078749537,
-0.4318574667,
-0.9358450174,
0.2497116923,
-0.4293644428,
0.4457852244,
-0.266133666,
0.4462167323,
-0.2730534375,
0.076276727,
-0.3760970533,
-0.3441031277,
-0.4770370424,
-0.2952960432,
0.4589752853,
-0.0453883074,
0.2877704501,
0.5115250349,
0.6853044629,
0.3454991281,
0.3321289718,
0.1590201408,
-0.7105644941,
0.1061294749,
0.1649644375,
-0.6643915772,
0.1283527613,
-0.1758235991,
0.7504934669,
0.5983056426,
-0.0641124696,
0.4130536914,
0.1355098635,
0.4388666749,
-0.7374157906,
0.7761273384,
-0.5247216821,
0.1465687901,
-0.0077138003,
-0.3212037086,
-0.5137786269,
-0.5604137778,
0.1433519721,
-0.4343298674,
0.0804365724,
-0.2395868152,
0.8458132148,
0.7107565999,
-0.1715794653,
0.0659963191,
-0.841733098,
1.0296059847,
-0.7277702093,
0.5641490221,
0.1579681635,
0.5577482581,
-0.3883809149,
-1.008764863,
-0.3630389571,
-0.5414279699,
-0.4570999742,
-0.0188960079,
-0.4394613206,
-0.1909652501,
0.3247248828,
-0.2720927298,
-0.3383221924,
-0.1644341648,
-0.4785909951,
-0.0804286525,
0.6687211394,
0.0502747819,
0.2060175985,
-0.0566632189,
-0.0725906044,
-0.2969717085,
-0.7441840768,
-0.0037540256,
-0.1405175328,
0.6674764752,
-0.0917591006,
0.7386274338,
0.1194363311,
0.6597758532,
-0.4182572961,
-0.2086087614,
0.1709326059,
-0.1930462122,
-0.33102566,
-0.2006319761,
0.6270295978,
-0.1555103511,
0.7048183084,
0.0115935495,
-0.425483495,
0.2629263103,
0.3557235897,
-0.7788878083,
-0.027567029,
-0.2454625815,
-0.407849431,
-0.113661699,
0.0645844564,
-0.3998410106,
-0.2492094189,
-0.7690705061,
0.5895507932,
-0.4540641904,
0.0312985778,
-0.03162314,
-0.2094852924,
0.0551794805,
0.3571268916,
-0.4151344299,
0.1202029958,
0.5380116701,
0.7481780648,
0.2230003178,
-0.1322236508,
-0.7805720568,
0.0962000415,
-0.3709633946,
0.5484278798,
-0.6581813693,
-0.3986620605,
-0.0067432118,
-0.0082612745,
-0.2488114238,
-0.4609951377,
0.2301221788,
-0.3646552861,
-0.0582049303,
-0.1621351242,
-0.1352841556,
-0.1425088197,
-0.0016881684,
-0.5580103993,
1.1471071243,
0.4266158342,
-0.5172002912,
0.3886453211,
-0.6289764047,
-0.3773037791,
0.0599057414,
-0.4487805963,
-0.4960892498,
0.4316700399,
0.2615682483,
0.5226829648,
-0.6073798537,
0.5236485004,
-0.383760035,
-0.4609256387,
0.1216029897,
-0.0412771553,
0.5264548063,
0.1074268743,
-0.3392395973,
0.3877376914,
-0.5304487348,
-0.077968277,
0.3431125581,
0.202661559,
-0.4459071755,
0.2388866842,
-0.2131263167,
0.0798863545,
0.0636547729,
-0.5084869266,
0.0972608179,
-0.2109390646,
0.4548497796,
0.7698079348,
-0.5346947908,
0.0865811184,
0.03187076,
0.7091506124,
-0.1770402193,
0.21952039,
-0.1690451801,
-0.2448429912,
-0.7354133725,
-0.5471444726,
0.1359012574,
0.2902444601,
-0.7099058032,
0.2553679943,
-0.4436893165,
-0.4268467426,
-0.4439368546,
0.0543373972,
0.2087980956,
0.6724793911,
0.3470574617,
-0.0988673344,
-0.6135962605,
-1.0078974962,
-0.1238233149,
-0.1002037749,
-0.1694244146,
0.2279886752,
0.5762513876,
-0.3631136417,
1.0791978836,
-0.7781556249,
-0.3925621808,
-0.3800046444,
0.0303673837,
0.2453705966,
0.1454381049,
0.6444190145,
-0.6823171377,
-0.3682434857,
0.0254209768,
-1.0668139458,
-0.2261991054,
0.1360692978,
0.1998183727,
-0.0549596176,
0.5893929005,
-0.3191622794,
0.5217099786,
0.5372553468,
0.0306016747,
0.57675457,
-0.1264374405,
-0.0070894957,
-0.9139867425,
0.09622702,
0.5328920484,
-0.0944682881,
-0.5372964144,
0.1126511022,
0.0628308132,
-0.0914197192,
-0.2673232853,
0.6596328616,
-0.4529971182,
-0.2537070215,
-0.075763382,
-0.0444525592,
-0.5132277012,
0.3017101288,
0.1304303706,
0.6429060102,
0.8405447602,
-0.2162148058,
-0.0208639838,
0.1212907434,
-0.0640045032,
0.0362078883,
-0.6376680136,
-0.2393302619,
-0.5465371609,
0.2441363633,
-1.0091700554,
-0.1317319423,
0.2545029819,
-0.2261731327,
0.2155574262,
-0.3197693825,
-0.5077268481,
-0.4905525744,
-0.2939912081,
0.2958751619,
0.6001578569,
-0.5461264849,
1.259640336,
0.3230648637,
-0.100478217,
-0.5999724269,
-0.3644702435,
-0.0526215471,
-0.3026006818,
-0.7400437593,
0.157751888,
0.328692615,
-0.1961854845,
-0.1541286111,
-0.1972239912,
0.1830794662,
-0.0404759757,
0.2421170473,
0.4799484015,
-0.2555094659,
-0.0567676276,
-0.1262169182,
-0.211659804,
0.1835442632,
-0.2529868782,
0.6227594018,
-0.0812813267,
-0.302952081,
-0.4736659229,
0.1282608062,
0.4340141416,
-0.4271041453,
0.4489537179,
0.4110504091,
-0.522325635,
-0.5222553015,
-0.4649308622,
-0.42345649,
-0.4977923632,
0.443097502,
-0.3932057917,
-0.8652614355,
0.2908007801,
-0.3101716936,
-0.010770346,
0.2024889439,
0.33117944,
-0.0326999575,
1.160441637,
1.0427100658,
0.3238820732,
0.6166880727,
-0.3894069493,
0.504288137,
-0.5521739125,
-0.4518244863,
-0.5730690956,
-0.4615039527,
-0.4018750787,
-0.5920538306,
0.5469244123,
-0.0221759584,
-0.337808758,
0.4245800674,
-0.3610778749,
0.2365938276,
0.5505412221,
0.1391120702,
0.097577773,
0.0941701978,
0.007751938,
-0.1614827067,
-0.6235665679,
-0.4278161824,
1.082039237,
0.2628199756,
1.0228210688,
-0.2921447754,
0.8544999361,
-0.0332081281,
0.8668726683,
-0.8332557678,
0.7413204908,
-0.6441693902,
0.2354161292,
-0.1954072714,
-0.5730894208,
-0.799588263,
0.2430905551,
-0.110487029,
-0.9939151406,
0.0305365082,
0.3824682832,
-0.0838826969,
-0.0028520741,
-0.7678313255,
0.7870284319,
-0.5341963768,
-0.2270081788,
-0.1688063145,
-0.6523545384,
0.3497977853,
-0.3470581472,
0.2233299315,
0.0948917493,
0.4290576875,
0.6413582563,
-0.3162345886,
0.9797766209,
-0.2661193013,
-0.1268309057,
0.0385164097,
0.1097052991,
0.5177809596,
-0.2378953248,
0.1654408872,
0.2240065038,
0.0421367995,
-0.0477370806,
-0.7619213462,
0.5705655217,
-0.5721053481,
-0.7034714222,
-0.3983429372,
-0.5067186952,
-0.349835366,
0.2407962084,
-0.2288126349,
0.2939994633,
0.1251128912,
0.2581478655,
0.3131582439,
-0.2136358619,
0.3902062774,
0.2505693436,
-0.4065616429,
-0.0427221619,
0.6751447916,
-0.1011311337,
0.0923477039,
0.3751718104,
0.5402297974,
-0.4325483739,
-0.3608419895,
-0.1506145298,
0.6327774525,
-0.6598739028,
-0.2781934142,
-0.4391576052,
-0.1748621613,
-0.3372185528,
-0.2641671896,
-0.2579267323,
-0.1411709189,
-0.1802999824,
0.130712375,
0.2886221707,
0.627050221,
0.0858143494,
0.5510472655,
-0.7852905989,
0.3690308034,
-0.1704559922,
0.2660893202,
-0.0512918048,
-0.155292362,
-0.1280254126,
0.1509581655,
-0.0433941036,
-0.6812532544,
0.7594498396,
0.0477767214,
0.6333764195,
0.1289033145,
-0.3071627021,
0.8392444849,
-0.4158875048,
0.393707633,
0.2965227962,
-0.8648883104,
0.6263881326,
-0.0880718604,
0.2353880852,
0.1545399129,
0.5188459158,
-0.1692638397,
-0.3997886479,
-0.2874804139,
-0.6941978335,
0.6446566582,
0.0935443714,
0.0619624592,
0.2150440663,
0.4082243741,
-0.0775489062,
0.2256364673,
-0.7565383911,
-0.1020139605,
-0.1678337008,
-0.4323265851,
-0.2203987837,
0.1541326046,
-0.3678794801,
-0.4170130491,
0.3555888236,
-0.4672042429,
0.1271996349,
-0.0429434702,
-0.1816222817,
-0.1630063653,
-0.230809629,
0.3480328321,
0.7168607712,
-0.0299251545,
0.0643896908,
-0.0995434746,
-0.3752794266,
-0.1511410624,
0.2620480955,
-0.0945677087,
-0.0184723958,
0.3889095485,
0.8485745788,
0.3586396277,
-1.0738527775,
0.2577075958,
0.0242672432,
-0.0859772414,
-0.5028200746,
0.0226114672,
-0.0246195383,
0.4624224007,
0.5512068868,
0.0601294748,
-0.0207724087,
-0.4175530374,
0.3995941579,
0.8915702105,
-0.1914264262,
-0.2917852998,
0.8059797883,
-0.2090738565,
-0.2132707387,
0.5893545151,
0.4548727274,
-0.671466291,
0.727006197,
0.7237918377,
0.9821215272,
-0.0139073785,
0.2440295517,
0.4408889413,
0.2818550467,
-0.1701316237,
0.3315836787,
0.1565334946,
-0.7225157619,
-0.6238265038,
-0.9516358376,
0.0372994207,
-0.1182545722,
-0.3594332933,
0.6708969474,
-0.2641568184,
-0.2200915962,
0.038788747,
-0.475797385,
-0.7999745607,
0.316324383,
0.2606643438,
0.7037295699,
-0.878218174,
0.7655894756,
0.5129219294,
-0.4205133319,
-0.9978568554,
-0.0509973057,
0.0126398038,
-1.2653232813,
1.2646830082,
0.1623347402,
-0.5848238468,
0.1819089204,
-0.5198597908,
-1.090842247,
1.142423749,
0.794919908,
-0.5346383452,
-0.2252188921,
0.3242384791,
0.6584042907,
-0.5750806332,
0.1377845109,
0.6055788398,
0.5635741353,
0.3957063258,
-0.7799782753,
0.1625608653,
-0.0723720938,
0.1947088391,
0.6543451548,
-0.2726264298,
0.6439361572,
-0.5006511211,
-0.2079993039,
-0.0508059375,
0.474185437,
0.4257729948,
0.0591992326,
0.4081974626,
0.3947103024,
0.2785403132,
-0.306060642,
1.1420122385,
-0.2633874416,
0.3918916583,
0.7469281554,
-0.1763810366,
0.8332327008,
0.8260706067,
-0.1273670048,
0.369374156,
0.3732473552,
-0.2763493359,
0.5170986056,
0.6073477864,
0.0324179009,
-0.2171929926,
-0.1126728654,
0.0084757367,
0.3352546692,
0.2955600321,
-0.5734905005,
-0.3906398118,
-0.0249888767,
-0.1865319908,
-0.0622206219,
-0.1985899806,
0.4667175412,
0.2061432451,
-0.5585008264,
0.5604618788,
-0.2239430249,
0.4392777383,
-1.0003508329,
-0.271209836,
-0.1722854674,
0.3133239448,
-0.0259446334,
-0.5129904151,
0.3059202433,
-0.2187352031,
0.3124456406,
-0.3731267154,
0.6801202893,
-0.3236702979,
-0.8228783011,
0.5129829645,
0.5921605229,
-0.2506492138,
0.1079762727,
-0.2744603455,
0.2982287109,
0.0766390562,
-0.0383269601,
0.1643622965,
0.039270781,
-0.3719601631,
0.9969394803,
0.6892715096,
0.0916130915,
-0.026471762,
0.25525105,
0.8836398721,
-0.539513588,
-0.2276628762,
-0.8412182331,
0.7017741203,
0.1300128996,
-0.0232135728,
0.4930298924,
0.4548839033,
0.8301206231,
-0.4297044575,
0.8266058564,
0.1079268903,
0.0575977862,
-0.5308270454,
0.4441412687,
-0.9167844057,
0.2596596181,
-0.3125090897,
-1.0688999891,
-0.7398959398,
0.7083637714,
-0.3531864882,
0.0479480512,
0.7058157325,
0.8460713029,
-0.1520264894,
-0.0003370267,
0.1297834665,
0.1333444566,
0.4997310936,
0.1840998083,
0.7569835782,
-0.1062845439,
0.2050465345,
-0.2640118599,
-0.4544874132,
0.0044821166,
-1.0170880556,
-0.6475581527,
-0.6314374804,
-0.2454546094,
-0.1505283862,
0.158124581,
0.9156594276,
0.5907470584,
-0.6144728065,
-0.6180545688,
0.032977052,
-0.2955803573,
-0.2065384835,
-0.2027083337,
0.3664205372,
-0.3017268777,
-0.829136312,
0.3826029897,
0.3470717669,
0.029303031,
-0.378664881,
0.057465259,
0.1581302732,
0.0300953612,
0.7890386581,
0.1924788505,
-0.7759869099,
-0.3454380929,
0.2869502306,
0.2781221271,
-0.0328818262,
1.1561014652,
-1.1073030233,
0.3274862468,
0.303216964,
0.6828195453,
0.7201468945,
-0.1248287261,
1.0163134336,
-0.6911736131,
-0.0318047851,
0.2889853418,
0.707433939,
0.2601553798,
-0.1240449175,
0.7547643185,
0.1388821602,
-0.0989201739,
-1.0864593983,
0.2538152933,
-0.9416025877,
-0.2900188565,
0.9660925269,
0.1315347105,
-0.1821376532,
0.3978752792,
-0.1503822505,
0.2146534324,
-0.0975037143,
0.9940931797,
0.3812382817,
-0.4129237533,
-0.3155514002,
-0.3429372013,
0.4320239425,
0.2623792291,
-0.852634728,
0.1046553254,
0.5271064639,
0.2394361347,
0.1923801899,
0.2187108994,
-0.1550643891,
-0.0843583196,
-0.3255704939,
-0.1663842201,
-0.0109973997,
-0.4728762209,
-0.0962872356,
0.1709167212,
-0.0678838864,
0.192828238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19071v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19071v1
|
Blind Spots and Biases: Exploring the Role of Annotator Cognitive Biases in NLP
| 2024-04-29T19:28:35 | 2024-04-29T19:28:35 |
Sanjana Gautam, Mukund Srinath
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
With the rapid proliferation of artificial intelligence, there is growing
concern over its potential to exacerbate existing biases and societal
disparities and introduce novel ones. This issue has prompted widespread
attention from academia, policymakers, industry, and civil society. While
evidence suggests that integrating human perspectives can mitigate bias-related
issues in AI systems, it also introduces challenges associated with cognitive
biases inherent in human decision-making. Our research focuses on reviewing
existing methodologies and ongoing investigations aimed at understanding
annotation attributes that contribute to bias.
|
[
-0.9247813225,
-0.8132014275,
0.5422827005,
0.4482310116,
0.2969123125,
-0.0410512835,
-0.0691481978,
-1.0134906769,
0.215351209,
0.4778696001,
-0.4034847021,
-0.1118478179,
-0.8561915159,
0.132217586,
-0.185569033,
1.0378994942,
0.2525415421,
0.0813053101,
-0.3549297154,
-0.4113999009,
-0.8440435529,
-0.8457790613,
-0.7823057175,
-0.4680156708,
0.4197793901,
0.1657233536,
0.9602077603,
0.3482781649,
0.6151945591,
0.2591296136,
-0.0111953756,
-0.1493094265,
0.2744940519,
0.0946226865,
-0.2855513394,
-0.4830028117,
-0.2957229614,
0.2917837203,
0.4422675967,
1.0440477133,
0.3357338607,
0.1802247912,
0.0975148603,
0.6943591833,
-0.7932090163,
0.1758087575,
-0.6457317472,
0.4367155135,
-0.4055511355,
0.0224719867,
-0.2998922467,
-0.2084581107,
0.7236474752,
-0.7975426316,
0.5111923218,
0.1462448984,
0.4590684175,
1.0031424761,
-0.2743245959,
-0.2183558494,
-0.7577241659,
1.0119204521,
-0.5325737596,
-0.0729545578,
0.630859375,
0.1359125078,
0.0782978609,
-0.320548892,
-0.6832464337,
0.0321923681,
-0.1391876787,
-0.1136191711,
-0.0498754419,
-0.0018458348,
0.6561147571,
-0.1244361848,
-0.2256191522,
0.1836479157,
-0.1349158734,
-0.1626949161,
0.9833642244,
-0.0749018714,
0.3985660374,
-0.1916132271,
-0.1509213001,
0.077302359,
-0.3365568221,
-0.1589978188,
0.3514121473,
0.1014828458,
0.2755895257,
0.5850378275,
-0.2382932156,
0.7814691067,
-0.192809701,
0.46452564,
0.3583264947,
-0.1903329939,
-0.1343879253,
0.1970275491,
0.5681898594,
0.4611924887,
0.5628340244,
0.2654209733,
0.0989861786,
0.3663760126,
0.492808938,
-0.0731302649,
-0.2397600412,
0.1543023586,
-0.2690959871,
-0.4073469043,
0.0464880951,
-0.9940265417,
-0.9211694002,
-0.2444864064,
0.1877309084,
-0.1519598961,
-0.1452080458,
-0.1777347624,
-0.5557280779,
0.2011025697,
0.6805871725,
-0.8281925917,
0.1318872124,
0.6777344942,
0.6641392708,
-0.1027410179,
-0.3067287803,
0.0244570374,
-0.0815005898,
-0.2868017256,
0.8816531897,
-0.4767163992,
-0.1021518558,
0.2383556813,
-0.3762185276,
-0.1535728723,
-0.5803866982,
0.7581679225,
-0.2521749735,
0.2482281625,
-0.560162127,
-0.2533031702,
-0.4487551153,
0.278508395,
-0.767973125,
1.1196007729,
-0.0667427778,
-0.9624263644,
0.764711678,
-1.1510112286,
-0.4704390168,
0.1482824087,
-0.549156189,
-0.3710317016,
-0.0472057462,
0.5044584274,
0.2829637527,
-0.144804731,
0.1516717523,
-0.1373239607,
-0.201499328,
0.5925221443,
-0.43040362,
1.0593255758,
-0.1592232436,
-0.8149966598,
0.1370505691,
-0.5382446647,
-0.2613725364,
0.0631681904,
-0.1199238151,
-0.7643560767,
0.4333622754,
0.3158852458,
0.3032675385,
-0.0688193142,
-0.3460130095,
0.0727701485,
-0.2056370676,
0.7150910497,
0.7989749908,
0.1366338879,
0.4687418044,
-0.3471883237,
0.2261001915,
0.0957041606,
0.3873558939,
0.0009218958,
-0.9396777749,
-0.8646848798,
0.0316522308,
0.3382595778,
0.8351724148,
-0.6967412233,
0.3881708384,
0.3219096959,
-0.0974428654,
-0.8225666285,
-0.0458309166,
0.2546162307,
0.5368257761,
0.5101537704,
-0.506703794,
-0.4102002084,
-1.0507838726,
-0.442890197,
-0.1309520751,
-0.2420062423,
0.5286784172,
0.6707064509,
-0.0448259264,
1.0443894863,
-0.2315586358,
-0.7161874175,
0.0962484553,
0.1610356718,
-0.2853016853,
0.8048434258,
0.6069474816,
-1.0163913965,
-0.1640520543,
-0.3690003455,
-1.0481693745,
-0.1787685305,
-0.5014441013,
-0.047399383,
0.3451228738,
0.5920113325,
-0.7754057646,
0.7961422801,
-0.0123969531,
-0.5539740324,
0.3047681451,
0.2295328826,
0.0951276347,
-0.3887931108,
0.0939541608,
0.3065238893,
0.1010739282,
-0.5602371097,
-0.3082822263,
-0.3932888806,
0.102000773,
-0.2318299264,
0.3863423169,
-0.3440061212,
-0.2507175803,
-0.1151060387,
0.4625130892,
-0.0024889617,
0.2927913964,
-0.0400882512,
0.6678622961,
0.2979694605,
-0.4074403644,
-0.2194176614,
0.4838279188,
-0.139614284,
0.7151201963,
-0.6164810061,
0.0196652543,
-0.3067852855,
0.1055881232,
-0.7038862705,
-0.2067617923,
0.3784913123,
-0.6133799553,
0.0717908666,
0.1676088721,
-0.3903024495,
-0.3770721555,
-0.5490044951,
0.5878495574,
0.1356547773,
-0.1180257499,
0.5904735327,
0.7933090329,
-0.3598989248,
-0.9085843563,
-0.9786084294,
0.2524432242,
-0.2340226173,
-0.4040445089,
0.3321723938,
0.1748801321,
-0.7434926033,
-0.0628099293,
0.0983590931,
0.1491584778,
0.3708114028,
0.3199223578,
0.1714977324,
0.0195581429,
0.0014620534,
-0.0146004511,
-0.2781045437,
0.4041208923,
-0.2214113921,
0.280084461,
0.0916651785,
-0.4134116471,
-0.5400620699,
0.6104698777,
0.50465554,
-0.2325611711,
0.5652279258,
0.4108855724,
-0.5309379697,
-0.1596896201,
-0.8377920389,
-0.0519897155,
-0.3562956452,
0.5304293633,
0.3420902491,
-0.728083849,
0.5745554566,
0.0397853255,
0.1843398511,
0.51447469,
0.3989829421,
-0.198723495,
1.2728987932,
0.8704074621,
-0.3033599257,
0.7266545296,
-0.0993974283,
0.2282714695,
-1.0602220297,
-0.1764064431,
-0.7384883165,
-0.4193146229,
-0.8131834269,
-0.3477735221,
0.1610392481,
-0.0141502339,
-0.1846015006,
-0.2688249946,
-0.995739758,
0.490619421,
0.981682539,
-0.1528553367,
0.1065732539,
-0.4494297802,
0.2489091158,
-0.3142342269,
-0.6846315265,
-0.6451537609,
1.0136221647,
0.3875440657,
0.0857646167,
-0.2395944744,
0.348516345,
0.8211612701,
0.4685333073,
-0.5251954794,
0.350818336,
0.2941943407,
-1.0853116512,
-0.4386410713,
0.1451189816,
-0.6188095212,
0.2765960693,
-0.5715084076,
-0.9131541252,
0.5992307663,
0.1893365532,
-0.3692484796,
0.0515671149,
-0.7913089991,
0.903444171,
-0.1642644703,
-0.4816354513,
-0.0104505531,
-0.887912631,
0.3267098665,
0.0104421591,
0.1910823286,
-0.2949213982,
0.0404435173,
1.1178447008,
-0.0175195727,
0.9247369766,
-0.5236076117,
0.4148869514,
0.1546559334,
-0.2554216981,
0.1826319695,
0.2770380378,
-0.1249229163,
0.7136561275,
-0.3205705881,
-0.5464040041,
-0.2844105661,
0.3291215301,
-0.8646248579,
-0.6809179783,
-0.8796147108,
-0.8450674415,
-0.2352206856,
0.269701153,
0.0238510631,
-0.2740880847,
-0.0831018016,
-0.3298940361,
0.6501793265,
-0.5239744782,
0.6560978889,
0.0951632187,
0.0951669812,
-0.2835392952,
0.5664505363,
0.3476546109,
-0.0316793807,
-0.0767330602,
-0.2949402928,
0.1527159214,
-0.8564401865,
-0.3444657326,
0.0094129387,
-0.7252168655,
-0.0669924393,
-0.5533754826,
-0.2299126536,
-0.2143941224,
-0.5646694303,
-0.123552762,
-0.6516025066,
-0.1626109481,
-0.1373378783,
0.2654796839,
0.896353662,
-0.0016329151,
0.3232444227,
-0.211880669,
0.0541436858,
0.1537926346,
0.1714150608,
0.1978086531,
0.1800196022,
-0.1804277599,
-0.141949147,
-0.4601460993,
-0.6738368273,
0.2684617043,
-0.2378020883,
0.7561424971,
0.2445195615,
0.0725058094,
0.3393754959,
-0.4514110088,
1.1244443655,
-0.180392608,
-0.9041320682,
0.7912502289,
-0.2650466561,
0.1683144718,
0.7992014885,
0.4817300141,
-0.3585010767,
-0.5857186317,
-0.6552018523,
-1.2149094343,
0.7677868009,
0.4107878506,
-0.1883134097,
0.0410285257,
0.3205772042,
-0.0217476655,
0.3645071685,
-0.7578083873,
-0.5205140114,
-0.222955808,
-0.0510942228,
-0.0190045368,
-0.1844872236,
-0.2039366663,
-0.3258236945,
0.5046378374,
-0.0056846389,
0.2604204714,
0.5220654011,
-0.2272453457,
0.0342066698,
0.083317697,
0.7363055944,
0.7230449915,
-0.0877935886,
0.0814243183,
0.172847718,
-0.7341221571,
-0.3115048409,
0.4783970714,
-0.8752580881,
-0.0164324492,
0.4740714431,
0.5583891869,
-0.1331211776,
-0.475186348,
0.4321713746,
0.0429596566,
-0.131274879,
-0.8359282017,
-0.0355927013,
-0.2228182703,
0.4546037614,
0.8017072082,
0.6475247741,
0.2693439424,
-0.362593472,
0.0915421247,
0.5975920558,
-0.5486698747,
-0.0795072094,
0.8555262685,
0.401569128,
-0.5249916911,
0.6958640814,
0.2541127503,
-0.7100363374,
0.7141276598,
0.0054207123,
0.8334500194,
-0.1363182366,
-0.0761239976,
-0.0119374329,
0.7951425314,
0.1762137711,
-0.0117525598,
-0.339779377,
-0.7803338766,
-0.3615393341,
-0.338270396,
-0.4347934723,
-0.167287305,
-0.5971215963,
0.0656806082,
-0.595133841,
-0.6988365054,
0.5433111787,
0.0369391665,
-0.8304769397,
0.084865436,
0.3604608476,
0.8161000013,
-1.0777232647,
0.4951555729,
0.551808238,
-0.7952534556,
-0.1831510365,
0.2151829749,
0.2648431063,
-0.6382045746,
0.548253715,
0.3582342863,
0.364027679,
-0.205366835,
-0.5926301479,
-0.7334603667,
1.0115659237,
0.0586900115,
-0.3304824829,
-0.0635460317,
0.257096976,
0.5053821206,
-0.3415744305,
0.3881853819,
0.9277012944,
0.8038725257,
-0.6506587267,
-0.9394450188,
0.0617271587,
-0.2605581582,
0.1488691121,
0.1235005185,
-0.5682858229,
0.7569005489,
-0.0779527724,
0.107446745,
-0.4684713185,
0.3010973632,
0.2464060783,
0.7193627954,
0.3552994132,
0.4957309961,
0.704344511,
-0.1419185549,
0.9290459156,
0.0444722585,
-0.0929261222,
0.9267984033,
-0.5992938876,
0.4952422976,
0.8931706548,
-0.1073334888,
0.4701103866,
0.3895204663,
-0.1617853045,
0.2935209274,
0.0983178392,
-0.1697706878,
0.1207669601,
-0.4024840295,
-0.3103449047,
0.3033208847,
0.7251897454,
-0.4516369104,
0.2208600491,
0.0898906142,
0.0257913973,
0.2355515063,
-0.2616417408,
0.8670504689,
0.0205268674,
-0.7433140278,
-0.1798179001,
-0.1304936558,
1.0854356289,
-0.2541222274,
-0.3164770901,
0.0033519177,
0.1267552376,
-0.3255898058,
-0.8181400299,
0.6186951995,
-0.1926816851,
-0.4695265889,
-0.2716676593,
0.7317852378,
0.0580580793,
-0.298166424,
0.3259085417,
0.5300287008,
-0.0955604687,
-0.2181038558,
-0.9179752469,
0.2326632738,
-0.0352320299,
-0.3953258097,
0.3158806264,
0.3779141605,
-0.4990189075,
0.5679463744,
0.5384331346,
0.0713457763,
0.1278497875,
0.0950172767,
0.5207511783,
-0.9103623629,
-0.3513286412,
-0.8457966447,
0.651661694,
-0.4945881665,
-0.4959378839,
0.9407161474,
0.1899056882,
1.0490865707,
0.0096064676,
1.2340644598,
-0.2586118281,
0.3550188243,
-0.0641833842,
1.0254814625,
-0.0789672211,
0.3001968265,
-0.5990316272,
-0.7881313562,
-0.7363718152,
0.958511889,
-0.5559013486,
0.2179598361,
0.4880765975,
0.4141272008,
0.4636405408,
0.130592674,
-0.0902985558,
-0.0194003638,
0.2760443985,
0.4297391474,
0.9341981411,
-0.4926761985,
0.0931066647,
-0.3038437366,
-0.3087586761,
-0.2602028549,
-0.7781382799,
-0.8150233626,
-0.550139904,
-0.5227221251,
-0.0883382633,
0.0079735285,
0.6275310516,
0.5801867843,
-0.8325648904,
0.1016890183,
-0.1810851246,
0.5456140637,
-0.417329222,
-0.3755244315,
0.2879091501,
-0.2937362492,
-0.6167456508,
-0.3122836947,
0.3727474511,
-0.039290715,
-0.5493739843,
0.2822971642,
-0.6106826067,
0.159634009,
0.6200026274,
0.2965618074,
-0.8002786636,
-0.4613330066,
-0.3513802886,
0.0917752683,
-0.0731647685,
0.8470969796,
-1.0169215202,
0.1725398302,
0.2819731534,
0.6775736213,
0.1457543075,
-0.1288423389,
0.5989180207,
-0.8114524484,
0.474781692,
0.7334769368,
0.2164780647,
0.624820292,
-0.426828593,
0.5754773021,
0.3325257897,
-0.8037250638,
-1.0228972435,
-0.008141499,
-0.9281541705,
-0.2233305722,
0.632538259,
0.2794567943,
-0.1518033743,
-0.6814994812,
-0.2417674363,
0.1371486187,
-0.3360174596,
1.2452065945,
0.7770420909,
-0.5627322793,
0.0268321037,
-1.1862945557,
0.8268316388,
0.7945250869,
-0.7057209611,
0.175690636,
0.6529009342,
-0.1346953213,
0.7137313485,
0.7536988258,
-0.0881489068,
0.2321522236,
0.2193891108,
0.3121339083,
0.1168359965,
-0.3351889849,
-0.3821596205,
0.072904177,
0.3596863449,
-0.1218816116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19065v1
|
HELPER-X: A Unified Instructable Embodied Agent to Tackle Four Interactive Vision-Language Domains with Memory-Augmented Language Models
| 2024-04-29T19:12:42 | 2024-04-29T19:12:42 |
Gabriel Sarch, Sahil Somani, Raghav Kapoor, Michael J. Tarr, Katerina Fragkiadaki
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent research on instructable agents has used memory-augmented Large
Language Models (LLMs) as task planners, a technique that retrieves
language-program examples relevant to the input instruction and uses them as
in-context examples in the LLM prompt to improve the performance of the LLM in
inferring the correct action and task plans. In this technical report, we
extend the capabilities of HELPER, by expanding its memory with a wider array
of examples and prompts, and by integrating additional APIs for asking
questions. This simple expansion of HELPER into a shared memory enables the
agent to work across the domains of executing plans from dialogue, natural
language instruction following, active question asking, and commonsense room
reorganization. We evaluate the agent on four diverse interactive
visual-language embodied agent benchmarks: ALFRED, TEACh, DialFRED, and the
Tidy Task. HELPER-X achieves few-shot, state-of-the-art performance across
these benchmarks using a single agent, without requiring in-domain training,
and remains competitive with agents that have undergone in-domain training.
|
[
-0.327983439,
-0.400365293,
0.6332542896,
-0.191651091,
0.0098110391,
0.1122479066,
-0.1547358632,
-0.4476221502,
0.2365788817,
0.6350213289,
-0.311552465,
-0.204755649,
-0.4821407795,
-0.0592846461,
-0.2593605816,
0.6583395004,
-0.1939041764,
0.0086482298,
-0.4191029072,
-0.1964913011,
-0.6952281594,
-0.5304986835,
-0.5757197142,
-0.3213451803,
0.5130413771,
0.5764073133,
0.9989321232,
0.3159100413,
0.1681704372,
0.4316897094,
0.364492774,
0.2079285532,
-0.319265008,
0.1612570733,
-0.2145306915,
-0.6170415282,
-0.665394783,
-0.2320726663,
0.728610456,
0.4422096312,
-0.0032310935,
-0.1497114897,
-0.0877332017,
0.1961169988,
-0.7379847169,
0.538505435,
-0.2548268437,
-0.1417529583,
0.1409227252,
-0.1273930818,
-0.3999705315,
0.091100812,
0.1366084814,
-0.7617518306,
0.0079491399,
0.0935375392,
0.3830847144,
0.5271380544,
-0.1984907091,
-0.1184190139,
-0.4336290956,
0.9115229249,
-0.2799418271,
0.4849703908,
0.3145738542,
0.5072532296,
-0.3196411729,
-0.8969120383,
-0.6939254403,
-0.3497121036,
-0.1425446719,
0.0617868714,
-0.4552647173,
0.2421786934,
0.1914558411,
0.1370869875,
-0.4921563864,
-0.2603310347,
0.0354404971,
0.0408548415,
0.4870282114,
0.3597797453,
0.6733159423,
0.1588075608,
-0.3075433969,
-0.3813868165,
-0.4543294907,
-0.2150634527,
-0.150205642,
0.1254660338,
0.0289526153,
0.4116282463,
-0.1387445331,
0.6930763125,
-0.00901567,
0.1636286527,
-0.1556687057,
-0.0006397123,
-0.2148730904,
-0.0767266825,
0.3838666379,
0.4567801356,
0.1463561356,
-0.5027802587,
-0.2573238015,
0.0192673989,
0.570027411,
-0.6977000833,
-0.2657507658,
0.043711625,
-0.0682937056,
0.3631049097,
-0.1805362701,
-0.4260495603,
-0.4007821083,
-0.285989821,
0.7283143401,
-0.5382922292,
-0.2779961824,
0.2418642789,
-0.2631461322,
0.330219835,
0.4493024349,
-0.7514864206,
0.7300171256,
0.6019619107,
0.3841979802,
-0.3255277574,
-0.4740977287,
-0.6234763861,
0.2764366567,
-0.2429255396,
0.8627162576,
-0.8423278928,
-0.3019272983,
0.0824997723,
0.1070936322,
-0.1202592626,
-0.5905408263,
0.1713058501,
-0.5490925312,
0.1576006711,
-0.3155083656,
-0.6173725128,
-0.2813144028,
0.2883674204,
-0.6843041182,
0.8769501448,
0.4270811081,
-0.3056873977,
0.4368437529,
-0.6905409098,
0.0294420198,
0.6475995779,
-0.5581616163,
0.0106671043,
0.0574579686,
0.1099627987,
0.6673499942,
-0.2519406676,
-0.1224976778,
0.1267098784,
-0.6158448458,
0.167280823,
-0.271741569,
0.3977963328,
-0.3679180443,
-0.43217206,
0.3866754174,
-0.7623348236,
0.1035257131,
0.1981309354,
0.0431323014,
-0.5595012307,
-0.1702170372,
0.1393142045,
0.1018924564,
0.1657240242,
-0.5430296063,
0.4909051061,
-0.1703216285,
-0.116658181,
0.4491909146,
-0.1945453435,
0.6794103384,
-0.5079423785,
0.758713305,
-0.3666252494,
0.0835358053,
-0.3954972029,
-0.5141841769,
-0.9563970566,
-0.529024899,
-0.4250139296,
0.3707394898,
-1.1075177193,
-0.1047023535,
-0.2265225202,
-0.2816955149,
-0.253313899,
0.0463300087,
0.690669775,
0.1361434907,
0.4123852551,
-0.1760631651,
-0.291680038,
-0.5946521163,
0.0304256547,
-0.1379192173,
0.2141521573,
0.220990628,
0.4911569357,
-0.209109351,
0.8907056451,
-0.4664838314,
-0.1123057306,
-0.4640002549,
-0.1780436337,
-0.1280048937,
0.3648985028,
0.5542148948,
-0.8063308001,
-0.5055459738,
0.0118072694,
-0.6595767736,
0.1396936029,
-0.0800901428,
-0.1571552157,
0.1577982455,
0.2608269751,
-0.7306653857,
0.5401136279,
0.4766821265,
-0.4894074798,
0.4639705122,
-0.5280148983,
0.1501821131,
-1.1117507219,
-0.3670565784,
-0.2703389823,
-0.296759665,
-0.6774308085,
0.3842721581,
0.0932874605,
-0.0389087386,
-0.4007436633,
1.1571390629,
-0.824200213,
-0.0469208844,
-0.7714203,
-0.0153618092,
-0.2500700653,
0.7499528527,
0.2036141902,
0.9941446781,
0.8024585247,
-0.6125866771,
0.3391830623,
0.4286631048,
-0.2665502429,
0.5645185709,
-0.5512502193,
0.4272522628,
-0.0340019092,
0.0166387055,
-0.8799904585,
-0.3215467632,
0.3973944783,
-0.0262133945,
0.4377819002,
-0.0727342218,
-0.6008462906,
-0.1470920444,
-0.1050715819,
0.4990372658,
0.487911135,
-0.9073652625,
0.8184332252,
0.2969472408,
-0.0279212501,
-0.6200748086,
-0.4076288342,
0.1509818435,
0.0979041755,
-0.496532768,
0.42466259,
-0.2575810552,
-0.3987502456,
0.2653876543,
-0.2053463459,
-0.1904776394,
-0.3018997312,
0.5353136063,
0.2127638906,
-0.0968347043,
0.1214011386,
0.0241529997,
-0.3273194432,
-0.0338599309,
-0.1911399215,
0.4243663251,
-0.1352781206,
-0.5630155206,
-0.2262349278,
0.51806885,
0.6173114181,
-0.1294106096,
0.6400258541,
0.0190013871,
-0.3441547751,
-0.4391832948,
-0.5223124623,
-0.1353821456,
-0.4619359672,
0.4407584369,
-0.4285945296,
-0.9280596972,
0.3477466404,
0.0756019354,
0.1386845112,
-0.240701139,
0.3482006192,
0.1470963955,
0.8934925795,
0.9361829758,
0.0708090439,
0.780634284,
-0.4803720713,
-0.2458744645,
-0.6489199996,
-0.2194170803,
0.038098406,
-0.090716809,
-0.1410111934,
-1.0319430828,
0.293408215,
-0.3786991537,
-0.1709240377,
0.6165298223,
-0.4103652537,
0.5372898579,
0.5405289531,
0.1190890372,
0.1517181396,
-0.0937148184,
0.080380708,
0.2488262355,
-0.8412131071,
-0.7247388959,
0.8085137606,
-0.0198585521,
0.7239401937,
-0.0233910959,
0.7312272191,
0.0839366466,
0.3028434217,
-0.8155645132,
0.8999692202,
0.022564549,
-0.6108455658,
-0.2189631015,
0.1857184321,
-0.9171281457,
0.4277001619,
0.0482639149,
-0.8811119199,
0.1387657523,
0.2588677108,
-0.2620276511,
0.353371799,
-0.7523983717,
0.8137708902,
-0.2896950543,
-0.5332354307,
-0.5414652228,
-0.3410172164,
-0.0633863956,
0.0491411202,
-0.3852899075,
0.091419585,
-0.4288109839,
0.4181580842,
-0.3989297748,
1.0618954897,
-0.2299431115,
-0.0847702026,
0.3999019265,
-0.0316066705,
0.5018525124,
-0.23043935,
-0.0166068021,
-0.0342332348,
0.0051817289,
-0.5272290707,
-1.0113787651,
0.6039381623,
-0.5536251068,
-0.7337006927,
-0.318728894,
-0.9882493615,
-0.2964110672,
0.0882050022,
-0.2487459034,
0.7847366929,
-0.3387138546,
-0.0609248579,
0.4707606137,
-0.2335500419,
0.5179963112,
0.6849847436,
0.0253096297,
-0.2884077728,
0.84719944,
0.090576984,
0.2530469,
0.7829002738,
-0.0234584305,
-0.1316091865,
-0.4217509627,
-0.4649626911,
0.116895996,
-0.7223212123,
-0.0763918608,
-0.6965430379,
0.0169008039,
-0.0004792829,
-0.3492656946,
-0.306204468,
-0.2679053247,
0.0198715776,
0.0225477107,
0.428907603,
0.8891935945,
0.1327242702,
0.6008859873,
-0.735709846,
0.3829830289,
0.5733986497,
0.3096580803,
0.0122561669,
-0.2696921229,
-0.3956246376,
-0.2254042923,
-0.1139639467,
-0.8136376739,
0.3170902133,
-0.054544054,
0.9723329544,
0.3648882508,
0.004103899,
0.7571176291,
-0.5756403804,
0.59332335,
0.153317824,
-0.6559366584,
0.1869455874,
-0.1515298039,
0.3980715871,
0.2892628908,
0.2542100251,
-0.3145068884,
-0.509600997,
-0.5706301332,
-0.5444568992,
0.8025488257,
0.2778310478,
0.420458734,
-0.1177982241,
0.4116088748,
0.2848654687,
0.0780470967,
-0.2589948177,
-0.318703115,
-0.0287899617,
-0.0920159668,
-0.135289371,
-0.339863658,
0.1032159925,
-0.2643264234,
0.4502722025,
-0.3282011449,
0.4467864335,
0.0363934711,
-0.2950346172,
0.040547803,
0.2952374816,
0.3655425906,
0.6121938229,
-0.0191661436,
0.1567352861,
0.3733368814,
-0.5171180367,
0.1453931481,
0.2315762043,
0.0686638355,
-0.206209287,
0.4738798141,
0.7931523323,
0.6959140897,
-0.8984072804,
0.3391981721,
-0.2282111198,
0.0864962637,
-0.349175781,
0.5265450478,
-0.1888392419,
0.6355503201,
0.3540143669,
-0.093182005,
0.0730336159,
-0.6176992655,
0.3798771501,
0.3960968852,
-0.5960086584,
-0.5265730619,
0.5450018644,
0.0782190412,
-0.4037238359,
0.276227057,
-0.312163949,
-0.4244610071,
0.4213789701,
0.6722524762,
0.9939424992,
-0.1443517804,
0.1215678006,
0.0760147572,
0.0881799906,
0.0234016757,
0.6507644057,
-0.5257384181,
-0.8654660583,
-0.4197246432,
-0.063548848,
-0.6211163402,
-0.2192664444,
-0.501681447,
-0.08904057,
-0.1911130995,
-0.0086617842,
-0.2051858157,
0.0677792206,
-0.6995093226,
0.1545756906,
0.1828436106,
0.9397255778,
-0.3935261965,
1.0372909307,
1.246152997,
-0.709987998,
-0.7669249177,
0.0435423441,
-0.1033558697,
-0.9186971784,
0.5468050241,
0.0591807105,
-0.5732010007,
-0.0434059203,
-0.7115110159,
-0.6951092482,
1.2111860514,
0.6970610619,
-0.3952150643,
-0.1257109344,
-0.0208916813,
0.4652963281,
-0.356148988,
0.5165245533,
0.3618251383,
0.3174815178,
0.0708885491,
-0.8636933565,
0.2623137236,
-0.4152128696,
-0.2156152129,
0.3192600906,
-0.7147536874,
0.4494079053,
-0.4322769046,
-0.1622475088,
0.5070989132,
0.7550880313,
0.258304745,
0.4847911894,
0.6046366096,
0.2487610877,
0.6061913967,
0.2456227094,
1.2667273283,
-0.4099424183,
-0.2201693356,
1.3318676949,
-0.316654712,
0.7949998379,
0.4997242391,
0.2097835392,
0.5456755161,
-0.1871766448,
0.3481947184,
0.4037777483,
-0.0879633054,
-0.5135172606,
-0.3591069877,
-0.2351032346,
-0.0185148083,
0.5291291475,
0.2981687784,
0.0414417274,
-0.1259984821,
0.3096649945,
-0.0451742858,
0.0429170169,
-0.3569864929,
0.6727130413,
0.0330252275,
-0.710493505,
0.302562654,
-0.435603261,
0.4780710936,
-0.6572020054,
-0.5581214428,
-0.1931420565,
0.4855664074,
0.1159100085,
-0.8895103931,
0.0172463432,
-0.1201903448,
-0.0238866583,
-0.4924423695,
0.9425183535,
-0.4221244454,
-0.0907171145,
0.5092476606,
0.5451372266,
0.383179754,
-0.282017678,
-0.3958933949,
-0.0188663937,
-0.3243268132,
0.0655832067,
0.3637813926,
0.3311233521,
-0.3702664375,
1.0224846601,
0.1151618809,
-0.2557550073,
0.1841896027,
0.1001317054,
1.1549768448,
-0.6866062284,
-0.2248207033,
-0.3969798386,
0.7179471254,
-0.0697811618,
-0.1317914426,
0.8711177111,
0.4554950595,
0.9040573239,
-0.2101290822,
0.5744922161,
-0.0416787416,
0.009258775,
-0.2458688617,
0.6304495931,
-0.7331717014,
-0.1469398439,
-0.3822580874,
-0.7181113362,
-0.1785000861,
0.5357040763,
-0.1862728745,
0.1341276318,
0.6586587429,
0.9470383525,
-0.1475431621,
-0.1210441142,
0.9056195617,
-0.1928558499,
0.1942482591,
0.616230607,
1.1883128881,
-0.3876803517,
0.5931375027,
-0.2842639983,
-0.2738418579,
-0.0256835055,
-0.4832546413,
-1.079503417,
-0.8350756764,
-0.554420948,
0.0976969227,
0.1994179338,
1.1372352839,
1.0831667185,
-0.5834404826,
-0.3168962896,
0.0711509883,
0.0803686082,
-0.5056508183,
-0.0885176733,
0.246241793,
-0.2501610518,
-1.0280237198,
0.7925946116,
0.4936344028,
-0.0323689803,
-0.2892750502,
-0.3654832244,
0.1880690604,
0.1490212232,
0.792403698,
0.4847123623,
-0.6950905919,
-0.4006920457,
0.0991319865,
-0.0131488033,
-0.1301140338,
0.8744493723,
-0.8870177269,
0.7674228549,
0.256744206,
0.6682438254,
0.3658552766,
-0.2791215777,
0.7702057958,
-0.64732939,
0.3451322019,
0.1167635024,
0.5707235932,
0.1059205309,
-0.2637531161,
0.3531981707,
-0.2473175973,
-0.4545255899,
-0.3864235282,
0.046783112,
-1.2220151424,
-0.1894336492,
1.1272956133,
-0.1397326142,
-0.3383687139,
-0.2654845715,
-0.6811669469,
0.1827262938,
-0.4815399945,
0.4407040477,
0.3538529277,
-0.3447371125,
-0.5658557415,
-0.4913087785,
0.3191491961,
0.3172170818,
-0.8779875636,
0.015569929,
0.6811635494,
0.1043694764,
0.1304026842,
0.8776731491,
0.1544785947,
0.5599168539,
0.1908361763,
0.4364259243,
-0.2729360163,
-0.526404798,
-0.1974234879,
0.1532478482,
0.1380602419,
-0.6265457273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19063v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19063v1
|
SuperCLUE-Fin: Graded Fine-Grained Analysis of Chinese LLMs on Diverse Financial Tasks and Applications
| 2024-04-29T19:04:35 | 2024-04-29T19:04:35 |
Liang Xu, Lei Zhu, Yaotong Wu, Hang Xue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The SuperCLUE-Fin (SC-Fin) benchmark is a pioneering evaluation framework
tailored for Chinese-native financial large language models (FLMs). It assesses
FLMs across six financial application domains and twenty-five specialized
tasks, encompassing theoretical knowledge and practical applications such as
compliance, risk management, and investment analysis. Using multi-turn,
open-ended conversations that mimic real-life scenarios, SC-Fin measures models
on a range of criteria, including accurate financial understanding, logical
reasoning, clarity, computational efficiency, business acumen, risk perception,
and compliance with Chinese regulations.
In a rigorous evaluation involving over a thousand questions, SC-Fin
identifies a performance hierarchy where domestic models like GLM-4 and
MoonShot-v1-128k outperform others with an A-grade, highlighting the potential
for further development in transforming theoretical knowledge into pragmatic
financial solutions. This benchmark serves as a critical tool for refining FLMs
in the Chinese context, directing improvements in financial knowledge
databases, standardizing financial interpretations, and promoting models that
prioritize compliance, risk management, and secure practices.
We create a contextually relevant and comprehensive benchmark that drives the
development of AI in the Chinese financial sector. SC-Fin facilitates the
advancement and responsible deployment of FLMs, offering valuable insights for
enhancing model performance and usability for both individual and institutional
users in the Chinese market..~\footnote{Our benchmark can be found at
\url{https://www.CLUEbenchmarks.com}}.
|
[
-0.2274343669,
-0.8417300582,
0.0881052539,
0.1123999655,
-0.2308406532,
0.2411597818,
-0.2089704871,
-0.7095896006,
-0.0607211925,
0.5563080311,
-0.4367927611,
-0.5785394311,
-0.041519355,
-0.3540952206,
-0.471531719,
1.246671319,
0.1738409996,
0.2505778372,
-0.0088348547,
0.111694254,
0.1461970955,
-0.6547737122,
-0.8200422525,
-0.295363456,
0.1300175786,
0.207489714,
0.7187549472,
0.6773637533,
0.8913016319,
0.2077479661,
0.0105565963,
0.218040064,
-0.5737342834,
-0.2374311388,
-0.3138001561,
-0.2935933769,
-0.7713947892,
0.0442376733,
0.426527679,
0.5262686014,
-0.3605959415,
0.5336714387,
0.0531600751,
0.824813962,
-0.6177295446,
0.4449747801,
-0.2905556858,
-0.1522679627,
-0.5759769678,
-0.098104395,
-0.1730701029,
-0.5071339011,
0.4206113219,
-0.7310943604,
0.1165281236,
0.2285524905,
1.0389469862,
-0.1442082226,
-0.5269703865,
-0.1024694592,
-0.5859847069,
0.7313238978,
-0.6613506079,
0.3732119799,
0.1176275909,
0.6639735699,
-0.1941188425,
-0.9808004498,
-0.1823320836,
-0.1924950927,
-0.0466598608,
0.098687686,
0.0334418565,
0.2200194597,
0.0635472238,
0.8213043213,
-0.4843423963,
-0.2250082642,
-0.4992409945,
-0.5816944838,
0.9260082245,
0.3138170838,
0.155549705,
0.255554527,
-0.9219731688,
-0.2883884311,
-0.6679569483,
0.2801301777,
0.3447155356,
0.5544297695,
-0.2329490483,
0.0624661297,
-0.2151559889,
0.5001906157,
-0.0621407367,
-0.3732334673,
0.2308099568,
-0.4813214839,
-0.4088205695,
0.2360071987,
0.4747394919,
0.5122060776,
0.30738464,
0.186079517,
-0.4985512197,
-0.0306050815,
-0.1684815437,
-0.6598461866,
-0.2018743604,
0.138709709,
-0.5115528107,
-0.2367129326,
0.4411149025,
-0.6067042351,
-0.311162293,
-0.319604367,
0.1901891083,
-0.1965062767,
-0.3665041625,
0.2398880124,
-0.1501128525,
0.410274893,
0.0793217793,
-0.8714859486,
0.6041792631,
1.1159360409,
0.5382950902,
-0.1770220399,
-0.1914491802,
-0.4924105108,
0.3318123817,
-0.5766087174,
1.0223186016,
-0.4365944862,
-0.2397664487,
-0.0303123854,
-0.093406342,
-0.1534296721,
-0.6286513805,
0.5380966663,
-0.4027347863,
-0.2256373316,
-0.3939840198,
-0.5929178596,
-0.4871647358,
0.3503947556,
-0.3769386709,
1.3035421371,
0.3830792606,
-0.7137135863,
0.5142709613,
-0.5832377076,
-0.1661705673,
0.4177995622,
-0.1413623393,
0.0310374238,
-0.0323929191,
-0.1107124016,
0.5165333748,
-0.7982423306,
0.5099616647,
-0.4746882319,
-0.8165279627,
0.2071202248,
-0.434371084,
0.3971279562,
0.2338871509,
-0.399800241,
0.4612746835,
-0.9873131514,
-0.0074341255,
-0.0386860035,
0.119682923,
-0.8027520776,
-0.177259177,
0.3321907818,
0.3147928715,
0.7435482144,
-0.4363211989,
-0.1334719211,
-0.6143937111,
0.6948788166,
0.8991187215,
-0.0517657027,
-0.1558420807,
-0.4164944291,
0.3565330803,
-0.288933605,
0.4540103376,
-0.174638018,
0.1619022489,
-0.6723306775,
-0.2431739718,
0.5191869736,
0.6212065816,
-0.4531406164,
0.008058602,
0.045026511,
-0.7950983047,
-0.2956851721,
0.2402426153,
0.5184876919,
0.3542346656,
0.3184943199,
-0.2525155246,
-0.3304272592,
-1.1016905308,
-0.3011471629,
-0.1521631777,
0.164637059,
0.1863790005,
0.4022395611,
-0.0019544018,
0.567037642,
-0.4588822722,
-0.2737027109,
-0.2779002488,
-0.0115935467,
0.2341135889,
0.4986876547,
0.6042974591,
-0.9568728805,
-0.3801958859,
0.3542796671,
-0.6156145334,
0.0986693799,
-0.2738997638,
-0.481826365,
0.2843449712,
0.6599538326,
-0.0787302926,
0.3033925295,
0.4138679802,
-0.3613470495,
1.0277062654,
-0.4078174233,
0.1196591854,
-0.3874005973,
0.3244496286,
0.2152082622,
0.0920618251,
-0.6870650053,
0.6148511171,
0.0613044463,
0.2546301484,
-0.6505984068,
0.6171762347,
-0.0583863333,
-0.4114378095,
-0.066127643,
0.4067559242,
-0.1605451256,
0.5548804402,
-0.1854932159,
0.9890549183,
0.4296823442,
-0.5941504836,
0.3689700365,
-0.4682960212,
-0.2646439075,
0.8611047268,
-0.7429403067,
-0.1031724587,
0.5988422632,
0.0628191978,
-1.0391540527,
-0.076987721,
0.0842369497,
0.2157704234,
0.0087559223,
0.4745066166,
-0.4844688177,
-0.5394034982,
-0.564906776,
0.4720195234,
-0.1043138653,
-0.3385350108,
0.5573219657,
0.2421192825,
-0.0994199738,
-0.5278860331,
-0.6901932359,
-0.1946792156,
-0.3177725971,
-0.6983276606,
0.4320765436,
-0.1991668046,
-0.3154246211,
-0.1613313556,
-0.5995153189,
-0.0687747672,
0.2775277495,
0.0141364681,
0.8549628854,
-0.5374571085,
-0.2570560277,
0.0565374494,
-0.5416591763,
0.0437768102,
-0.4096873701,
0.4290351272,
-0.7438291907,
-0.2691160738,
-0.4444529414,
-0.1317393035,
0.7483685613,
-0.2462492287,
0.3778608739,
0.6250343919,
-0.5158981085,
0.0204771645,
-0.6554009914,
0.2236847281,
-0.5969119668,
0.1087635234,
-0.4515993893,
-1.1668126583,
0.7993636131,
-0.0918711498,
0.3288442791,
0.7392633557,
0.4121184349,
0.2472301722,
0.7608612776,
0.7818524837,
-0.1045099944,
0.3187470734,
-0.2660450339,
0.0896808952,
-0.594586432,
-0.1408305615,
-0.2278224379,
-0.1801865101,
-0.487441659,
-0.1817852557,
0.2213625312,
0.2585709393,
-0.6230567694,
0.4512732625,
-0.4204739034,
0.3224426508,
0.4573100209,
-0.1484812945,
0.4500491023,
-0.2198109627,
-0.4318403304,
-0.0565449074,
-0.5257171988,
-0.6565386653,
1.0872536898,
0.4904280305,
0.510442853,
-0.3752075136,
0.4823555946,
0.5960361362,
0.3642213941,
-0.3893146515,
0.6641077995,
-0.4822336137,
-0.6546787024,
-0.1422784626,
-0.2945249081,
-0.3937865496,
0.2461102754,
-0.0819844604,
-0.6790456176,
0.1433337927,
0.1309282929,
-0.8379739523,
0.2528978288,
-0.3265485168,
1.1467692852,
-0.3525298536,
-0.4160577953,
-0.3442738354,
-0.4080718458,
0.8860048652,
-0.2682009339,
0.5191608667,
-0.25839293,
-0.0118304184,
0.6605599523,
-0.4158787429,
0.4818026721,
-0.1057236716,
-0.5111958981,
0.6056419611,
0.0327478945,
0.2461305708,
0.074070178,
-0.2757477164,
0.3932305574,
0.5118519068,
-0.4427651763,
-0.4099858701,
0.7438563704,
-0.5182250142,
-0.3616453707,
-0.4496620595,
-0.54616189,
0.0055584386,
0.213308394,
-0.1125819609,
0.5248773098,
-0.3086106479,
0.0932757482,
0.3556980491,
-0.1020362452,
0.2871951461,
0.7133748531,
-0.4229195416,
-0.4158517122,
1.4191160202,
0.2546378672,
0.2968089581,
0.1945816129,
0.2787662148,
-0.3878490627,
-0.3870030642,
-0.4222547412,
0.145936504,
-0.6161436439,
-0.0423324592,
0.0109239276,
-0.4550248981,
-0.3359996676,
-0.4164380729,
-0.5666903257,
-0.3197981119,
0.0603029504,
-0.3407130241,
0.1409161091,
0.5854120851,
-0.256278336,
0.1011930183,
-0.8067674041,
0.2239525467,
0.2424817234,
0.5029388666,
0.1142885312,
-0.3521068394,
-0.5406639576,
0.0083827563,
0.0524742715,
-0.0855938643,
0.0096156634,
0.1703245789,
0.8863202333,
1.0589809418,
0.2551699281,
0.9395907521,
0.1246761605,
0.9284828901,
0.0085608987,
-1.0979151726,
0.3919180334,
-0.3810551763,
-0.1681205183,
0.7707301974,
0.1099237204,
-0.6202090979,
-0.4561395049,
-0.5985005498,
-1.1518930197,
0.6808390617,
-0.2658453584,
-0.075050272,
0.0723259151,
0.501765728,
0.2988925874,
0.3686414063,
-0.5195715427,
-0.6165061593,
-0.0822688341,
0.1133062169,
-0.0150976842,
-0.4430123866,
-0.0716686398,
-0.1738755852,
0.8551020026,
-0.1494020224,
-0.2378736436,
0.0874014348,
0.03281096,
-0.0517322607,
0.131771341,
0.9694054127,
0.6513608098,
-0.3567284942,
0.0983597115,
0.2922271788,
-0.633641839,
-0.0092167649,
0.1983440071,
-0.0231618248,
-0.4274381399,
0.3164448738,
0.2955991626,
0.6329638958,
-1.0767468214,
0.2835354507,
0.0237438586,
-0.3235157728,
-0.301207155,
0.4950989485,
-0.1811328679,
0.4626615047,
0.8345836997,
0.0556837469,
0.2975072563,
-0.6092820764,
0.4247199893,
0.1337330788,
-0.7278738618,
-0.155177325,
0.6311390996,
0.1638321579,
0.052534841,
0.2298567891,
-0.2433213741,
-0.6184453964,
0.6594783664,
0.4945272505,
0.8645559549,
-0.1564647704,
0.0613438524,
0.1305191219,
0.3371653855,
-0.38994205,
0.4471123219,
-0.093750678,
-0.3812967241,
-0.1676440984,
-0.7141048312,
-0.5533963442,
-0.0567719899,
-1.0200474262,
0.1821589023,
-0.9383410215,
-0.1152886599,
-0.2426210195,
0.4368032515,
-0.3206454813,
0.2289921194,
0.4035216868,
1.4560410976,
-0.6840832233,
0.6888885498,
0.6394429207,
-0.151372835,
-0.723125875,
-0.2420766503,
0.1659538448,
-0.7531696558,
0.4701603949,
0.315128237,
-0.444802016,
-0.1811488122,
-0.3911436498,
-1.065446496,
1.2211793661,
0.5424864292,
-0.6718776226,
0.1079468131,
0.1679545343,
0.6903343201,
-0.5782022476,
0.274369359,
1.2264975309,
0.7209979296,
-0.125728637,
-0.9706061482,
0.0337776206,
-0.5439510345,
0.0684153214,
0.070014596,
-1.1876914501,
1.0001932383,
0.0362668149,
-0.2046294957,
-0.0287072584,
1.0066306591,
0.6656612158,
0.747159183,
0.4707201123,
0.1130701751,
0.8232627511,
-0.2599954307,
0.7805808783,
-0.9476305842,
0.4292474389,
0.9119670987,
-0.401303947,
0.9132511616,
0.1035587415,
-0.3245320618,
0.822214067,
0.9945135117,
-0.1546191573,
0.2354287654,
0.3448863328,
0.020093739,
-0.5230827332,
-0.3189643621,
-0.6725701094,
0.4430141151,
0.5593354702,
0.1134163663,
-0.0793908909,
-0.2247574925,
-0.1759866923,
0.2776410878,
-0.6791282892,
0.1975955367,
0.2425624728,
-0.2183775753,
0.2890971303,
0.2068308592,
0.8830208778,
-0.9640587568,
0.1253387928,
-0.2640806735,
0.2973965704,
-0.253883034,
-0.3846936524,
0.3119475543,
-0.2004830241,
0.0198799111,
-0.0135242743,
0.8167278767,
-0.2078536898,
-0.5313032866,
0.4890716374,
0.1707875729,
0.270126611,
0.0657851323,
-1.0418044329,
-0.0129405856,
-0.2693225741,
-0.3816643953,
0.3806072772,
0.4291833341,
-0.4018357992,
0.8355042934,
0.9640883803,
-0.0958219692,
-0.407479018,
0.14035061,
0.7555629611,
-0.9564760923,
-0.8882499337,
-0.9215017557,
0.1235888302,
0.0978098735,
-0.5560210347,
0.8121021986,
0.9174280763,
1.0681554079,
0.36659953,
0.5909672976,
0.382496208,
0.2946222126,
-0.3143397272,
0.7436321378,
-0.5999578834,
0.5404703021,
-0.7775147557,
-0.7651152015,
-0.2692009211,
0.5408779383,
-0.3963039815,
-0.0579529367,
0.4591504931,
0.5341976881,
0.1889416724,
0.497921735,
0.3605133593,
-0.1153757423,
0.04569019,
0.6431248188,
0.638070941,
-0.5793529153,
0.7242850661,
-0.4084196687,
-0.0026858663,
-0.477497071,
-0.8142496347,
-0.8046097755,
-0.0818551555,
-0.4134379625,
-0.0447032526,
-0.0284860544,
1.0974141359,
0.5404349566,
-1.1511029005,
-0.7234372497,
0.2012827992,
0.1150768697,
-0.9429237247,
-0.2696682215,
0.7100747228,
-0.1850632876,
-0.418495357,
0.3606589437,
0.7876265645,
0.1374094635,
-0.6867732406,
-0.05140616,
0.1497095525,
0.2341737449,
0.46732831,
0.1779162437,
-0.6243730783,
-0.2947004437,
0.1728503853,
-0.4138937593,
-0.3068519831,
0.9211050868,
-0.352306515,
0.1142136827,
0.1571197063,
0.4362980425,
0.2905691564,
0.193797484,
0.6922158003,
-0.1959616691,
0.0663803592,
-0.3687927127,
0.2407088876,
-0.0748266354,
-0.5276851058,
0.6340219378,
0.4361273348,
-0.3595919013,
-0.9314737916,
-0.4126215875,
-0.9332802892,
-0.3470530808,
0.6923186779,
-0.5340662599,
-0.3494994938,
-0.2683958709,
-0.144476667,
0.0275589954,
-0.4897703826,
0.4704897702,
0.7782648802,
-0.0776167288,
0.292874068,
-0.8486506939,
0.5518851876,
0.3884343207,
-0.4244334102,
0.5472205281,
0.1685931236,
0.0754123256,
0.0407919399,
0.6909467578,
-0.0065875328,
0.6995050311,
0.1421868801,
-0.0283652227,
-0.2890458107,
-0.4387195408,
-0.1743341088,
0.4504644573,
-0.2503802478,
0.2410850823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19055v1
|
Plan of Thoughts: Heuristic-Guided Problem Solving with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T18:51:17 | 2024-04-29T18:51:17 |
Houjun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While language models (LMs) offer significant capability in zero-shot
reasoning tasks across a wide range of domains, they do not perform
satisfactorily in problems which requires multi-step reasoning. Previous
approaches to mitigate this involves breaking a larger, multi-step task into
sub-tasks and asking the language model to generate proposals ("thoughts") for
each sub-task and using exhaustive planning approaches such as DFS to compose a
solution. In this work, we leverage this idea to introduce two new
contributions: first, we formalize a planning-based approach to perform
multi-step problem solving with LMs via Partially Observable Markov Decision
Processes (POMDPs), with the LM's own reflections about the value of a state
used as a search heuristic; second, leveraging the online POMDP solver POMCP,
we demonstrate a superior success rate of 89.4% on the Game of 24 task as
compared to existing approaches while also offering better anytime performance
characteristics than fixed tree-search which is used previously. Taken
together, these contributions allow modern LMs to decompose and solve
larger-scale reasoning tasks more effectively.
|
[
-0.4545439482,
-0.897469759,
1.2686581612,
0.1259648055,
0.0229938384,
0.2382898629,
-0.1548168808,
-0.0275711231,
0.1879583001,
0.6130921245,
-0.8610855341,
-0.3119015694,
-0.3067362309,
-0.0739781782,
-0.0102459854,
0.4236354828,
-0.4346843958,
-0.1249891296,
0.201043278,
0.3275237083,
-0.352948457,
-0.3356586993,
-0.6759032011,
-0.3599418104,
0.5702310205,
0.5312794447,
0.6779878736,
0.3568050563,
0.5190964341,
0.1709060967,
-0.250005722,
0.2265550494,
-0.3499568403,
0.3093900979,
-0.3961675763,
-0.3465985656,
-0.4491527081,
-0.0956048891,
0.3987251818,
0.8644069433,
-0.6380306482,
0.0932770222,
-0.343510896,
0.7228884697,
-0.8488659859,
0.4917032719,
-0.6201680303,
0.3881022334,
0.1074785441,
-0.3676084876,
-0.4552160501,
0.1365697682,
0.2981393039,
-0.520257771,
-0.2700080574,
-0.1182912812,
0.3291954696,
0.3993315697,
-0.0944815353,
-0.2273064405,
-1.0251799822,
0.9184203744,
-0.832554698,
0.13144207,
0.3500890434,
0.346429199,
-0.5855535865,
-0.1618021131,
-0.6261923313,
0.1520309299,
0.3818814754,
-0.0505015552,
-0.1277380735,
0.0759812444,
0.5329191685,
0.1168264523,
-0.4103324413,
-0.2104313374,
-0.0586403199,
0.0713066757,
0.7227067947,
0.2841097414,
-0.0449067988,
0.1070286781,
-0.2487319857,
0.0933066905,
-0.4594265521,
0.0706213638,
0.1639552265,
0.320781976,
0.2975185513,
0.6406998634,
-0.5421572924,
0.8103089929,
-0.2006680667,
-0.4469625652,
-0.078012161,
-0.4722864926,
-0.273562789,
-0.0185610205,
0.5954302549,
0.1556835175,
0.3333092034,
-0.0100970604,
-0.2433997095,
0.224696517,
0.1798936725,
-0.6102246642,
-0.3158126175,
0.5152899027,
-0.3277971447,
0.0713207796,
-0.5042510033,
-0.3868787885,
-0.37413463,
-0.4153525531,
0.6002508402,
-0.5166125894,
-0.5543442369,
0.7848280072,
0.0221965145,
-0.1484101713,
0.4052256644,
-0.4373191893,
0.3181958497,
0.5387126803,
0.5130972266,
0.0858275518,
-0.2716890872,
-0.4159697294,
0.2500452995,
-0.703725338,
0.8008223772,
-0.7030516863,
-0.4341267645,
0.1641757786,
-0.436047107,
0.035212364,
-0.4724304974,
0.5661227107,
-0.2370173931,
0.1200709715,
-0.6015158296,
-0.5730767846,
-0.1597966999,
0.3907595575,
-0.5233739018,
0.9147225618,
-0.0946772918,
-0.7233758569,
0.2303880453,
-0.9229136705,
-0.3995146751,
0.0241079982,
-0.2137680799,
-0.2088344097,
0.1875166148,
0.280004859,
0.7252489328,
-0.2954573631,
0.0823742524,
-0.1594304591,
-0.1148112193,
0.0313041881,
0.0637908205,
0.5976919532,
0.2950201333,
-0.4804891348,
0.3949961066,
-0.7288120985,
0.3243235648,
0.6490482688,
-0.5155477524,
-0.1505979151,
0.6334270239,
-0.5613318682,
0.4571903348,
0.1384145319,
-0.5624704957,
0.3868119419,
-0.3167629838,
0.4492135048,
0.3406528533,
0.1921003461,
0.5602008104,
-0.2230598032,
0.4681583345,
0.1349705309,
0.3731084764,
-0.5543254018,
-0.7689279318,
-0.8153336644,
-0.0823910087,
-0.3232841492,
0.4429767728,
-1.0966160297,
0.1292077154,
0.1657149792,
-0.4029328227,
-0.3162739873,
-0.3462711871,
0.4064595699,
0.2515661418,
0.4902325869,
-0.2618850172,
-0.5247738957,
-0.8057324886,
-0.2898609638,
-0.057184197,
0.2677505612,
0.1411131471,
0.4794458747,
0.0383128338,
0.8791994452,
-1.0003193617,
-0.3121940494,
-0.4089169204,
0.2094256133,
0.1818945855,
0.1062194183,
0.01053927,
-0.5623474717,
-0.4383943081,
-0.404640764,
-0.4046433568,
0.2064464986,
-0.0533514582,
-0.1842825264,
0.1194363013,
0.2585962415,
-0.6948741674,
0.3769243062,
0.2108822465,
-0.3524214625,
0.3876826763,
-0.336453855,
0.0592030734,
-0.9618859887,
-0.2794057429,
0.1087940335,
-0.0848655254,
-0.5926249027,
0.3084977865,
-0.1171193346,
-0.1187272295,
-0.4278080165,
0.2046027184,
-0.7449940443,
-0.0330528319,
-0.4252865016,
-0.0344176553,
-0.3039038479,
0.6900407076,
0.3247462511,
0.3921367228,
0.7187390924,
-0.5497539043,
0.3257574737,
0.0602142252,
-0.5250733495,
0.4711174965,
-0.1742385328,
0.3882609904,
-0.3526492119,
0.2927491665,
-0.8008297086,
0.1506585032,
0.2155426443,
-0.2012683749,
0.1479792297,
-0.1557679921,
-0.5935489535,
-0.4403471649,
-0.3711247444,
0.2405214608,
0.3584079444,
-0.0384857729,
0.4466582239,
0.5868151188,
-0.1916253865,
-0.4793453515,
-0.4723756313,
0.1784040183,
0.2107983679,
-0.3015173972,
0.3970761597,
-0.2248507291,
-0.541154325,
0.2176066935,
-0.2421193272,
-0.0427156128,
0.0369841829,
-0.0162252318,
0.1288325787,
-0.165475592,
-0.4362596273,
-0.2223296016,
-0.271245122,
0.1439255476,
-0.5784487128,
0.7839395404,
0.1816648692,
-0.5341411233,
-0.2716674805,
0.7832944393,
0.4914974868,
-0.626150012,
0.6448075175,
0.013307875,
-0.6074301004,
-0.6119651198,
-0.4363099933,
-0.0777609572,
-0.3556463718,
0.2266495824,
-0.7034257054,
-0.6386652589,
0.1945654899,
-0.2114376873,
0.3300016224,
0.1550406665,
0.7280429006,
-0.1851620376,
1.310556531,
0.7566104531,
0.1284782141,
0.4167562425,
-0.4169751108,
0.599767983,
-0.7320993543,
-0.3213355541,
-0.5088315606,
-0.3704535961,
-0.2145478874,
-1.0629057884,
0.2902231216,
0.0900875628,
-0.0672284141,
0.4353434741,
-0.6002381444,
0.5826660991,
0.4825378656,
-0.1151188165,
0.3246264756,
-0.1454073042,
-0.468357861,
0.081606701,
-0.9186112881,
-0.4002193511,
1.0526016951,
0.1926517338,
0.6079185009,
0.0434277393,
0.7199202776,
-0.1727498174,
-0.1986752898,
-0.8815125227,
0.9061145186,
0.2689528763,
-0.7806733251,
-0.6114646792,
-0.4234425426,
-0.7637417912,
0.2484217435,
-0.0672523901,
-0.88868469,
-0.031306874,
-0.132097587,
-0.4669446945,
0.5444862843,
-0.4723238051,
0.5382141471,
-0.0967494994,
-0.3056986034,
-0.5992517471,
-0.3126204312,
0.1369379461,
0.1921393722,
0.3988990784,
-0.3194118142,
-0.0478666164,
0.6586694121,
-0.3196921349,
0.3443481028,
-0.3361260295,
-0.3205204606,
0.4418061972,
0.4059616625,
0.791275084,
-0.5118908286,
0.1118818298,
-0.1738696247,
0.1413909346,
-0.3655056655,
-0.3221320212,
0.6781485677,
-0.2200887352,
-0.6868011951,
-0.4031435251,
-0.756272614,
-0.3963733912,
0.1853329241,
-0.2092506438,
0.2611994743,
0.1277994514,
-0.3452254236,
0.948420465,
-0.2123650163,
0.7555223703,
0.7506095171,
-0.5500581264,
-0.112961866,
0.7287381291,
0.2403915226,
0.33980003,
0.5751034021,
0.2444100231,
-0.1720273793,
-0.7953689694,
-0.2962278426,
0.2907600701,
-0.7723439336,
0.1761292517,
-0.548089087,
-0.0504996926,
-0.0219678693,
0.0575470328,
-0.5267382264,
-0.3951978087,
0.2042686641,
0.1994585693,
-0.0233748592,
0.7197558284,
0.2053467184,
-0.166880846,
-0.439922601,
0.454120189,
0.0193255395,
0.3518064618,
0.0198266357,
0.001993218,
-0.2038477808,
-0.1206731945,
-0.2123580575,
-1.0037808418,
0.3115766346,
-0.2804892659,
0.662176013,
0.0989153683,
0.1118601635,
0.7529155612,
-0.8889949322,
0.536046803,
0.2049911618,
-0.5581153631,
0.766921103,
-0.4538257122,
0.4842979908,
0.3172057867,
0.7572066784,
-0.4102008343,
-0.2101590931,
-0.4161258638,
-0.6623861194,
0.8600033522,
0.2919950187,
-0.4228800535,
0.1249043196,
0.3414699137,
-0.109327592,
0.2798861861,
-0.118506901,
-0.3253186643,
0.326477617,
0.0358218998,
-0.12893565,
-0.3307219744,
-0.0553467721,
-0.2750462294,
0.6389707327,
-0.2544524968,
0.3893842101,
0.3140214384,
0.2379537225,
-0.4466403723,
0.4713072777,
0.5851930976,
0.8672275543,
-0.0185093544,
0.2201219797,
-0.1081881672,
-0.0891683251,
0.128782481,
-0.0572771989,
-0.1987069398,
-0.0922783092,
-0.0217269752,
0.562512517,
0.2085901201,
-0.6694193482,
0.1874530464,
-0.0254567228,
-0.3244714737,
-0.1892434061,
0.073299095,
0.5690024495,
0.4821993709,
0.3032299578,
-0.0141474837,
0.0902413055,
-0.912769556,
-0.1344843209,
0.4535948932,
-0.3714830577,
-0.267454356,
0.4123654962,
0.0639268532,
-0.6428111792,
0.1585386097,
-0.5921092629,
-0.6783672571,
0.2803623974,
0.5411819816,
0.8901668787,
-0.1540597975,
0.382119894,
0.2622695565,
0.321985662,
-0.5334991813,
1.0378592014,
-0.2007527649,
-0.7152223587,
-0.9483010173,
-0.6327207088,
-0.4696374834,
0.2840719819,
-0.1883826256,
0.1194183156,
-0.65066576,
-0.1110497788,
0.1106306762,
0.0469268374,
-0.3899884224,
0.1499243677,
0.43977198,
0.869590044,
-0.3294756114,
0.7283750176,
0.8805171847,
-0.4094880223,
-0.9601587653,
0.1954123229,
0.1611974984,
-0.4325141311,
0.3008265793,
-0.287725538,
-0.3817431927,
0.0871902183,
-0.1418706179,
-1.0159790516,
0.7428805828,
0.3294825852,
-0.7759225368,
-0.2314563394,
0.1172181144,
0.0772636086,
-0.1439118683,
0.0023935514,
0.5089206696,
0.4220182896,
0.3047941625,
-1.2150441408,
-0.0241067074,
0.0733898133,
-0.183594197,
0.7137405872,
-0.2282220274,
1.0069582462,
-0.4894444644,
-0.2374264002,
-0.1617830545,
0.2309754789,
0.2425237298,
0.141330719,
0.4114881754,
0.7477320433,
0.6519143581,
-0.0053909947,
1.0009119511,
-0.1488316208,
0.2576717436,
1.0237933397,
-0.6105523705,
1.1766340733,
0.3994791508,
-0.4330455959,
0.2298221141,
0.4773942828,
0.572072506,
0.6980121732,
0.4505253434,
-0.2863773704,
-0.5075213909,
-0.0510000922,
0.0223207623,
0.269003123,
0.2039134651,
0.0557056032,
-0.4067330062,
-0.0907864943,
0.2349221408,
0.3581442833,
-0.4567708075,
0.608366847,
0.0036645462,
-1.0080114603,
0.3760351837,
0.3075880706,
0.5230850577,
-0.5096664429,
-0.0584346503,
0.1315200329,
0.5700611472,
-0.1384426653,
-0.9713197351,
0.3167748153,
0.015402399,
-0.2125251442,
-0.6207504272,
0.7317977548,
-0.2566247284,
-0.4864156544,
0.2664949894,
0.7488432527,
0.0770333484,
-0.5445561409,
-0.6812407374,
-0.0380752943,
-0.0995013416,
-0.2619208992,
0.3545909524,
0.4330397248,
-0.1993157566,
0.822850585,
0.6420652866,
0.1840319037,
0.0312393811,
0.0465528928,
0.7037971616,
-0.8637971282,
-0.4513998032,
-0.8779463172,
0.3533045948,
0.0615487099,
-0.1119738519,
0.5179768801,
0.6244866848,
1.0690191984,
0.1306010485,
0.6583236456,
0.051881671,
0.5681778193,
-0.5590789318,
0.4165657759,
-0.3553118706,
0.210927695,
-0.4251663983,
-0.9619989991,
-0.1756311357,
0.7449772954,
-0.455742985,
-0.1771172881,
0.9832316041,
0.5321567059,
0.3271517456,
0.0247317385,
0.4840417802,
0.0608646236,
0.3676540554,
1.0345414877,
1.1030453444,
0.0123798102,
0.2445110232,
-0.444276005,
-0.2693765461,
-0.0495836399,
-0.8652324677,
-0.8331217766,
-0.7935556173,
-0.4551951885,
0.1251746118,
-0.21576114,
0.977276206,
0.6472674608,
-0.5243606567,
-0.3677265048,
-0.2523587048,
-0.0183315594,
-0.3224008977,
-0.1173750311,
-0.0643173382,
-0.3615798652,
-0.4071003497,
0.7394579649,
0.6672804952,
-0.3956767321,
-0.7619931102,
-0.1270597577,
-0.6730915308,
0.5212391615,
0.8131728172,
0.0001681762,
-0.849706769,
-0.0306320377,
0.2677375972,
0.0692847222,
0.0308820736,
1.1274343729,
-0.8455858827,
0.4620796144,
0.4857815802,
0.415353775,
0.8524944186,
-0.4774173498,
0.3824061751,
-0.2475460768,
0.0682379529,
0.5506913662,
0.584349215,
0.0898217037,
0.0867931694,
0.4510959089,
0.028826179,
-0.3088701367,
-0.6837717891,
0.5766172409,
-0.7758245468,
-0.7959039211,
1.1858016253,
-0.0183252655,
-0.3401347697,
-0.1132116169,
-0.5426005125,
0.0846115202,
-0.323125124,
0.5686488748,
0.7647701502,
-0.516146481,
-0.1454562098,
-0.6414273977,
0.5224721432,
0.4993464649,
-0.7920553088,
0.1280840039,
0.5190122128,
0.0827654824,
0.450796634,
0.9087723494,
0.0196149666,
-0.0689514354,
0.0732672289,
-0.0696904659,
-0.1379228383,
-0.6819614768,
0.1185254604,
0.4164540768,
0.2624056637,
-0.2163238078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19048v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19048v2
|
A Framework for Real-time Safeguarding the Text Generation of Large Language Model
| 2024-04-29T18:40:01 | 2024-05-01T19:53:12 |
Ximing Dong, Dayi Lin, Shaowei Wang, Ahmed E. Hassan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced natural language
processing (NLP) tasks but also pose ethical and societal risks due to their
propensity to generate harmful content. To address this, various approaches
have been developed to safeguard LLMs from producing unsafe content. However,
existing methods have limitations, including the need for training specific
control models and proactive intervention during text generation, that lead to
quality degradation and increased computational overhead. To mitigate those
limitations, we propose LLMSafeGuard, a lightweight framework to safeguard LLM
text generation in real-time. LLMSafeGuard integrates an external validator
into the beam search algorithm during decoding, rejecting candidates that
violate safety constraints while allowing valid ones to proceed. We introduce a
similarity based validation approach, simplifying constraint introduction and
eliminating the need for control model training. Additionally, LLMSafeGuard
employs a context-wise timing selection strategy, intervening LLMs only when
necessary. We evaluate LLMSafeGuard on two tasks, detoxification and copyright
safeguarding, and demonstrate its superior performance over SOTA baselines. For
instance, LLMSafeGuard reduces the average toxic score of. LLM output by 29.7%
compared to the best baseline meanwhile preserving similar linguistic quality
as natural output in detoxification task. Similarly, in the copyright task,
LLMSafeGuard decreases the Longest Common Subsequence (LCS) by 56.2% compared
to baselines. Moreover, our context-wise timing selection strategy reduces
inference time by at least 24% meanwhile maintaining comparable effectiveness
as validating each time step. LLMSafeGuard also offers tunable parameters to
balance its effectiveness and efficiency.
|
[
-0.0860248655,
-0.8346645236,
0.5412849784,
0.2928743064,
-0.4368969202,
0.1565277874,
-0.1157274544,
-0.5082831979,
-0.123350665,
0.6004526615,
-0.656008184,
-0.4755302072,
-0.5378208756,
0.1884547025,
-0.4733541012,
0.8990336061,
-0.0882606432,
-0.0980217755,
-0.1221851259,
0.0192245804,
-0.1891925335,
-0.5561788678,
-0.8687548041,
-0.4065051079,
0.3875462115,
0.1557201445,
0.5748265386,
0.8166808486,
0.4463792145,
0.220756799,
-0.3560892045,
0.3065678775,
-0.5615990758,
0.6310036778,
-0.3269855678,
-0.1079560146,
-0.3252934515,
-0.3907972574,
0.5319446325,
-0.0839388892,
-0.1566505581,
0.1879358441,
-0.0122032035,
0.4344938099,
-0.7220190763,
-0.2280178368,
-0.763251245,
0.3347608447,
-0.2118284702,
-0.4635234773,
-0.497939527,
-0.5019512177,
-0.3078443408,
-0.2656701803,
-0.1556833386,
0.1145545319,
1.2576980591,
0.3609257638,
-0.3419572711,
0.0256098229,
-0.6644275188,
0.8584879041,
-1.0674706697,
0.2521670461,
0.3074526489,
0.2392661721,
-0.2804802656,
-0.7157343626,
-0.618363142,
-0.2563182116,
0.0921268687,
0.0060550994,
-0.0205683652,
0.1942125857,
0.3420367241,
-0.0264188405,
-0.6298162937,
0.3134371042,
-0.046966102,
-0.5621943474,
0.6530954242,
0.1659343243,
0.3999216855,
-0.3483963311,
-0.4521043897,
0.0494981334,
-1.2094464302,
-0.2857132852,
0.4114262462,
0.0025995579,
0.0182955638,
0.5158367753,
-0.1928516924,
0.2094675303,
-0.0798306018,
-0.5137667656,
0.1476564705,
-0.2398623377,
-0.2178483903,
0.3057516515,
1.0799570084,
0.258494854,
0.3044179082,
0.0117523661,
-0.295342356,
0.0870712101,
0.3321377039,
-1.2288845778,
0.2903448045,
0.3025216162,
-0.3678486347,
-0.6035574675,
-0.1921087056,
-0.4817766249,
-0.1279200763,
-0.2264948934,
0.3016042411,
-0.4062893689,
-0.0386724435,
0.0407786742,
0.3991913795,
0.0379617102,
0.0199822485,
-0.519708097,
-0.017705489,
0.7033125758,
0.7894092202,
-0.2382085174,
-0.200223431,
-0.9352744222,
0.5773363113,
-0.1872747093,
0.6001646519,
-0.3179338276,
-0.3196871877,
0.0295681916,
0.0797782838,
0.2031046152,
-0.3961556256,
0.6713183522,
-0.7949442267,
-0.0089132115,
0.0493638888,
-0.4247645736,
0.1289655119,
0.3486663997,
-0.5049325228,
1.1324317455,
-0.22081469,
-0.9769502282,
0.3187660575,
-0.4136409163,
-0.7720298767,
0.0123813059,
-0.2720459104,
-0.8634008169,
-0.1921619475,
0.213651076,
0.5742147565,
-0.2011379004,
0.755576849,
-0.2195160389,
-0.3191615641,
0.149016127,
-0.7685611248,
0.5773056746,
0.5383511782,
-0.4985249937,
0.1171589792,
-0.801907599,
0.1056082994,
0.1773998141,
-0.7316760421,
-0.1187072918,
0.2030807287,
0.3490739167,
0.3087278903,
0.1755404174,
-0.7203868628,
-0.1656534523,
-0.3542975783,
0.4886758327,
0.831353724,
0.3820048869,
0.0934997052,
-0.4628565013,
0.6434984207,
-0.1368600428,
0.1508641988,
-0.1155810878,
-0.1596554965,
-0.5222074389,
-0.3059122264,
0.2582684159,
0.8254089952,
-0.9088637829,
0.7949001789,
-0.5926902294,
-0.4790375531,
-0.1952183396,
0.1620589495,
0.8983858824,
0.3139801025,
0.0963815078,
-0.0362935625,
-0.5198489428,
-0.8030416965,
-0.0895250961,
-0.0711091235,
-0.2601717114,
0.1004913971,
0.384265095,
-0.3776195347,
0.7406859398,
-0.3589090109,
-0.1677377224,
-0.1985642761,
0.0573794879,
0.0204785112,
0.6742176414,
0.5234867334,
-0.6646214128,
-0.1688667685,
-0.1798106879,
-0.951587975,
-0.4927883446,
-0.3737634718,
-0.3310067952,
0.2812003493,
0.9355202317,
-0.463799715,
0.2134188265,
0.6154375076,
-0.3243096471,
0.4912342727,
-0.1401003748,
0.0788728818,
-1.2316300869,
0.2252657562,
-0.4109485149,
-0.5930342078,
-0.435007602,
0.3537183702,
0.0335961618,
-0.037139561,
-0.9442002177,
0.6003349423,
-0.2002662718,
0.1213344932,
-0.1032544449,
0.1936265826,
0.1955821514,
0.1531629115,
0.0918010324,
0.7119817734,
0.1760744601,
-0.6511663198,
0.0987669751,
0.2213619053,
-0.5195895433,
0.5698266029,
-0.646905005,
0.0204150341,
-0.1946932375,
0.3943209052,
-0.481764257,
-0.2514304519,
0.0101918112,
-0.1476563513,
0.3808259666,
-0.0425960571,
-0.7572940588,
-0.14790079,
-0.2345314324,
0.2734721601,
0.339756161,
-0.4931734502,
0.5630380511,
0.2031587064,
-0.3769013584,
-0.7151073813,
-0.9545450211,
0.2977429628,
-0.205366239,
-0.6896547079,
0.3771389723,
-0.190610826,
-0.2036880851,
-0.1506006718,
-0.0900234133,
0.2065035254,
0.3725972474,
0.2877750099,
0.2279895544,
-0.0502868854,
0.0883179158,
0.5899956226,
-0.3148345053,
-0.1075757071,
-0.1069017127,
0.6206371188,
0.3839758933,
-0.6169681549,
-0.316793561,
0.4158727229,
0.5565552115,
-0.282933712,
0.7395668626,
0.7166524529,
-0.3115263283,
-0.3818918765,
-0.5273060799,
-0.3475174606,
-0.5409964323,
0.3256804645,
-0.085532546,
-1.1827442646,
0.266602546,
0.0831882283,
0.425211668,
0.153401345,
0.7066192031,
0.1356232166,
0.7943145633,
0.246574387,
0.0621550605,
0.5113060474,
0.0003852508,
0.4794001281,
-0.6662294269,
-0.1556536257,
-0.368865788,
-0.2877774835,
-0.343585223,
-0.3038207591,
0.4178641438,
-0.0313498043,
-0.3377074897,
0.3547612131,
-0.5080817938,
0.6819900274,
0.267803818,
-0.0242020674,
0.361253351,
-0.0292722397,
-0.3296262324,
-0.0837815702,
-0.5398638844,
-0.8411332369,
0.880549252,
0.4077691734,
0.8216878772,
0.1030787304,
0.9865430593,
0.450650692,
0.4580619037,
-0.4710215628,
0.8458971381,
0.0637134388,
-0.8552785516,
-0.1053989306,
-0.6504330635,
-0.7247694731,
0.2552720606,
-0.4102131426,
-0.6417353153,
-0.1976898164,
0.133483842,
-0.4181439281,
0.3740130961,
-0.3403272033,
0.4357239902,
-0.3306983411,
-0.7527273893,
-0.1324587762,
-0.6377411485,
0.4854575098,
-0.3569661677,
0.5209698677,
-0.4341200888,
0.011609274,
0.7042025328,
-0.2741528451,
0.6894173026,
-0.0767027885,
-0.4988544285,
0.2856440246,
0.5977448821,
0.6837624907,
0.2187658548,
-0.2502091527,
0.0539123826,
0.106874086,
-0.1225345582,
0.0000141575,
0.9816529155,
-0.2803502977,
-0.4183892012,
-0.3107157648,
-0.4589354694,
-0.0197513197,
0.4531741142,
0.5677549839,
0.4119234085,
-0.1792173684,
0.4028271437,
0.8624454737,
-0.4215433896,
0.6631984711,
0.3205616176,
-0.1686969101,
-0.3821307719,
0.9463310838,
-0.0887077227,
0.4946224689,
0.5615751743,
0.1944226176,
-0.2182490677,
-0.6055135727,
-0.3176909685,
0.1586759239,
-0.7834760547,
-0.6086047888,
-0.7842308879,
-0.4453752041,
-0.2722488344,
-0.3788484037,
-0.2203113735,
-0.2964827418,
-0.2822663784,
-0.3604584038,
0.2994561195,
0.3628256321,
0.0659109727,
0.3701865077,
-1.2538801432,
0.3769256771,
0.108449176,
0.401534915,
-0.1752669215,
-0.3878982663,
-0.1254854351,
-0.10028366,
-0.3403855264,
-0.4946758747,
0.4737721682,
0.2264680713,
0.4767596722,
0.4643712342,
0.3115997016,
0.135289669,
-0.5978575349,
0.8209753036,
0.0170933716,
-0.9230588078,
0.3213284612,
-0.4266123474,
0.3021962345,
0.548774302,
0.0103821736,
-0.3992578685,
-0.6783890128,
-0.4807171226,
-1.0912681818,
0.4838780463,
0.5492863655,
0.1613683552,
-0.0865479261,
0.0313214287,
-0.195541501,
0.2593922913,
-0.8128144145,
0.197111547,
-0.01045366,
-0.3648145795,
0.2538153529,
-0.3161829114,
-0.2090471238,
0.2751176953,
0.84962672,
-0.1575725675,
0.0035330416,
0.1868048608,
-0.1787677407,
-0.1754289269,
0.5822094679,
0.5306351781,
0.2846696973,
-0.1573285311,
0.2257226855,
0.3091900945,
-0.6627901793,
0.4455933571,
-0.1058792099,
-0.4897566736,
-0.1387978047,
0.5540919304,
0.4731470048,
0.3606115878,
-1.1310249567,
0.455581218,
-0.0280546024,
-0.3791131377,
-0.1387799978,
0.1480473876,
0.1720881462,
0.1032031924,
0.0829760805,
-0.2046713531,
-0.1635998189,
-0.2171900272,
0.3890728354,
0.3411172926,
-0.0663320944,
0.0559820458,
0.9124312401,
0.1588052213,
-0.0993780121,
0.1442966014,
-0.2020320147,
-0.4962287247,
0.4547535181,
0.5726495385,
0.9898009896,
-0.3137039542,
-0.1091619357,
0.2586492002,
0.370355159,
-0.1349446177,
0.3391103446,
0.0626181513,
-0.5977115631,
-0.4816024899,
-1.089456439,
-0.1063027307,
0.2176610082,
-0.3184466958,
0.1438866407,
-0.8228211403,
-0.3121750653,
-0.3791072071,
-0.3125905395,
-0.1603809148,
0.2826201618,
0.1752496362,
0.8263665438,
-0.817067802,
0.8006558418,
0.1891022325,
0.0003975808,
-0.6648423672,
0.0438883156,
0.2843709886,
-0.4744651318,
0.4426139295,
0.1784183979,
-0.3870906532,
-0.099329643,
-0.5110793114,
-0.7581506968,
1.1672362089,
0.4707880616,
-0.8336215615,
-0.2190343291,
-0.0946128666,
0.4700711071,
-0.1497650892,
-0.2171372622,
0.4419680536,
0.4250609875,
0.2927485108,
-0.7726734877,
0.3377563059,
-0.2412585318,
0.0997715741,
0.2509960532,
-0.3951191008,
0.3914447129,
-0.0504807271,
-0.4403383136,
0.0543493666,
0.4168939888,
0.7556575537,
0.072599791,
0.3996084034,
0.3923225701,
0.4521288276,
-0.0428259894,
1.0298364162,
-0.3169788122,
0.1088820696,
0.991458416,
-0.5337682962,
0.8616513014,
0.5857716203,
0.1114233136,
0.2281560898,
0.2722334266,
0.001981535,
0.469217509,
0.3439115882,
-0.3506125212,
-0.4680784345,
-0.303016156,
-0.2391820997,
0.1116162464,
0.2886313796,
-0.3954430521,
-0.2145740092,
0.1018335894,
0.6342741847,
0.3711391985,
0.0310296807,
0.6187024117,
0.1757299751,
-0.5912258029,
0.6429904103,
0.0909683704,
0.8850913048,
-0.8387060761,
0.1621174961,
-0.0336412415,
0.3572666347,
-0.241121307,
-0.7014707923,
0.3682329655,
0.2420800626,
0.1119814292,
-0.434296906,
0.7162462473,
-0.3350477815,
-0.4538781941,
0.4588164985,
0.1038926318,
-0.2061119378,
0.2429744899,
-0.4427624345,
0.3858368695,
0.0534320511,
-0.5288115144,
0.4428004324,
0.2854371667,
-0.2746167183,
0.8164658546,
0.9286780357,
0.3881483078,
0.0652014017,
0.0889643505,
0.8039839268,
-0.3023117483,
-0.6021082997,
-0.8353408575,
0.2578199208,
-0.0383984745,
-0.0120158754,
0.5430828929,
0.5123816729,
0.6035985947,
0.0534776114,
0.7606128454,
-0.0452660471,
0.4678718448,
-0.9841996431,
1.1236110926,
-0.4630779624,
0.4501307905,
-0.3420003355,
-0.9760887623,
-0.5013508201,
0.4377135932,
-0.0457065329,
-0.2794447839,
0.5897823572,
1.0117022991,
-0.0951852351,
-0.2558474243,
0.3015335202,
0.0825315267,
0.8985128999,
0.4254817367,
0.6645435095,
-0.1531837136,
0.7538169026,
-0.0268512331,
0.0041730627,
-0.1689527184,
-1.4096500874,
-0.8453661799,
-0.1891790032,
-0.1948334426,
-0.4721782207,
0.150054723,
1.1045788527,
0.6686363816,
-0.678088665,
-0.0431468785,
0.015608862,
-0.0969295725,
-0.0845556185,
-0.2293883264,
0.3424529731,
-0.1202721447,
-0.4685614407,
0.486390233,
0.3306431174,
0.2002494037,
-0.2280030549,
-0.1946414262,
-0.2994738817,
0.5207682252,
0.6028284431,
0.174003616,
-0.6004644632,
-0.353919208,
-0.219879061,
-0.3869183064,
-0.2108854949,
0.6310954094,
-0.4467953444,
0.0673560798,
0.689394474,
0.6629747748,
0.4508008957,
-0.0650506318,
0.549693048,
-0.9311733246,
0.267547518,
0.3926345706,
0.4862748981,
0.4526743591,
-0.5461063385,
0.4016067684,
0.0986985639,
-0.6147256494,
-0.9997573495,
0.4821907878,
-0.7950806618,
-0.2202386856,
1.3215594292,
-0.1731457412,
-0.2808427215,
-0.104173407,
-0.361521244,
0.2675452828,
-0.5113306046,
0.6605198979,
0.3798540235,
0.3082470894,
-0.0295574479,
-0.5184887052,
0.5086513162,
0.2475236952,
-1.0392967463,
0.3509961367,
0.56681633,
0.4364693463,
0.1853558272,
0.5264414549,
-0.4185496569,
0.0715398788,
-0.2133055478,
0.0239890981,
-0.232970655,
-0.3594298363,
-0.0382011831,
0.1597053111,
-0.0917694792,
0.2017190754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.19007v1
|
How Did We Get Here? Summarizing Conversation Dynamics
| 2024-04-29T18:00:03 | 2024-04-29T18:00:03 |
Yilun Hua, Nicholas Chernogor, Yuzhe Gu, Seoyeon Julie Jeong, Miranda Luo, Cristian Danescu-Niculescu-Mizil
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Throughout a conversation, the way participants interact with each other is
in constant flux: their tones may change, they may resort to different
strategies to convey their points, or they might alter their interaction
patterns. An understanding of these dynamics can complement that of the actual
facts and opinions discussed, offering a more holistic view of the trajectory
of the conversation: how it arrived at its current state and where it is likely
heading.
In this work, we introduce the task of summarizing the dynamics of
conversations, by constructing a dataset of human-written summaries, and
exploring several automated baselines. We evaluate whether such summaries can
capture the trajectory of conversations via an established downstream task:
forecasting whether an ongoing conversation will eventually derail into toxic
behavior. We show that they help both humans and automated systems with this
forecasting task. Humans make predictions three times faster, and with greater
confidence, when reading the summaries than when reading the transcripts.
Furthermore, automated forecasting systems are more accurate when constructing,
and then predicting based on, summaries of conversation dynamics, compared to
directly predicting on the transcripts.
|
[
-0.4250946939,
-1.0283237696,
0.8893941045,
-0.2320812792,
-0.1755214781,
0.5545859337,
0.1348616928,
-0.5943415761,
0.4358659983,
0.5533146858,
-0.7698717713,
-0.2646026909,
-0.5840896964,
0.0243211426,
-0.4401157498,
1.2339588404,
0.5568912029,
-0.1432773471,
-0.1905734092,
0.2467279732,
-0.4895909727,
-0.4993216097,
-0.4899682403,
-0.4724915028,
0.742302537,
0.5911307931,
0.7443711758,
0.5709653497,
0.5149403214,
0.4507850409,
-0.3066781461,
-0.037210118,
-0.7006511688,
0.4602730572,
0.0646246448,
-0.5555115938,
-0.2155929953,
0.2439277321,
0.1603110731,
1.0738399029,
-0.3298062384,
0.2406861931,
0.1473639905,
0.4688639343,
-0.314322114,
0.1267819107,
-0.4918461144,
0.1195116341,
0.1617213786,
-0.5380215049,
-0.1657907516,
-0.2671856284,
0.5033216476,
-0.4210882783,
-0.072954163,
-0.0544810854,
0.6496528983,
0.2336775362,
-0.9842290878,
-0.5265544653,
-1.0226231813,
0.7740782499,
-0.421623826,
0.0358673595,
0.4892931283,
0.379262954,
-0.5377849936,
-0.9485196471,
-0.1929909587,
-0.2470173538,
-0.2759336233,
0.3869638145,
-0.301952213,
-0.0506361015,
0.0090198917,
-0.0162883997,
-0.2058038116,
-0.3244867027,
-0.7383162379,
-0.3456279039,
0.7789104581,
0.623249352,
0.4871584177,
-0.0082959728,
0.0430831537,
0.14207986,
-0.2764774263,
0.1969171762,
0.2544485927,
0.3280905485,
-0.0738391429,
0.2823801637,
-0.1126522496,
0.5393067002,
0.0786779746,
-0.1540451199,
-0.0984199941,
-0.5070025325,
0.0516062081,
-0.0962686464,
0.693287909,
0.9496008754,
0.1746528298,
-0.2776277959,
0.3692942858,
-0.0825273171,
0.4749752879,
-0.5838468075,
-0.2167131454,
0.3369180262,
-0.5593473315,
-0.5417147279,
-0.1302892268,
-0.9806473851,
-0.2551316917,
-0.6267852783,
0.1648478359,
-0.069986254,
-0.3432540298,
-0.1905211806,
-0.4413437545,
-0.0911826268,
0.4735904932,
-0.883942306,
0.4718661606,
0.7310664654,
1.0614686012,
-0.2565720379,
-0.0534711666,
-0.4313527048,
-0.0935477763,
-0.2855481207,
1.080999732,
-0.2501491308,
-0.7389256358,
-0.1105393618,
-0.1293037236,
0.2111271918,
-0.2968100011,
0.221506983,
-0.4297461808,
0.4844903648,
-0.4567417204,
-0.2779884636,
-0.2980283201,
0.3033771813,
-0.1599803269,
0.5456505418,
-0.3798238337,
-0.9337525368,
0.2639189065,
-0.5037273169,
-0.5840761662,
-0.0665798485,
0.2353038043,
0.0521249846,
-0.0492061749,
-0.0895183161,
0.3207096756,
-0.0190388802,
0.2083718181,
-0.0536831208,
-0.2901017368,
0.2980247736,
-0.1065296456,
0.9004681706,
0.3921951354,
-0.1057805642,
0.1663402468,
-0.3466452956,
-0.0746943951,
-0.276847899,
-0.2267484814,
-0.2997759283,
0.3462591171,
-0.2390882522,
0.2627032399,
0.0193177052,
-0.2804281712,
-0.0356653854,
-0.2735637724,
0.5030082464,
0.5977103114,
0.5682377815,
0.5922045708,
-0.534047544,
0.7327328324,
0.1049240679,
0.1484840512,
-0.5743640065,
-0.6450788975,
-0.5721718073,
0.4199548662,
-0.1772506088,
0.8063186407,
-0.1708706319,
0.2966760099,
-0.4000041783,
-0.7529841661,
0.1548457593,
-0.1635372788,
0.3446978927,
0.5946685672,
0.1518253833,
-0.2844875455,
-0.3763722777,
-0.4805356562,
-0.4259592593,
-0.7441168427,
-0.3324806392,
0.1223129854,
0.4930512607,
-0.0442424677,
1.1173399687,
-0.8001749516,
0.151885137,
-0.4030046761,
0.7284181118,
-0.0199620388,
0.2391886562,
0.3635354936,
-0.403287828,
-0.5339564085,
-0.1026068032,
-0.5821311474,
-0.1452593803,
-0.2766433656,
-0.4265677929,
-0.2871988714,
0.6970365047,
-0.3480247557,
0.298740536,
0.155812934,
-0.4552053213,
0.4222091734,
0.080141224,
0.2247285098,
-1.2274918556,
-0.1851057559,
-0.0858175829,
-0.3636695743,
-0.6857375503,
-0.7483850718,
-0.3831283748,
0.0659931004,
-0.3421717286,
0.0524229482,
-0.3487647772,
-0.0522758141,
-0.1038317606,
0.1765080392,
-0.2113265395,
0.7330552936,
-0.1476626247,
0.6021620035,
0.5268361568,
-0.7199732065,
0.5418710113,
0.4168508351,
-0.0949393287,
0.5986726284,
-0.5017220378,
0.1915960908,
-0.5160919428,
0.4277220964,
-1.0855185986,
-0.3128051758,
0.1961017996,
-0.5750963092,
0.0355935618,
-0.2145907134,
0.0758209378,
-0.4176095426,
-0.1471062601,
-0.065176852,
0.6455884576,
0.0071022036,
0.8430823088,
1.0894876719,
-0.5707393885,
-0.2369967997,
-0.6260424256,
0.408067584,
-0.3732108176,
-0.4810881317,
0.0971057713,
-0.1554577798,
-0.8684129119,
-0.4219121337,
-0.0480664782,
-0.1905565858,
0.1796098799,
0.5020142198,
0.1432204694,
-0.0046892343,
0.0426865183,
0.0400458053,
-0.0504277088,
0.6349795461,
-0.0380828157,
0.3171384335,
-0.0676432997,
0.0606492795,
-0.6707047224,
0.4436814487,
0.8571276665,
0.2591267526,
0.6673685908,
0.110782139,
-0.040359322,
0.2866381407,
-0.1724246442,
-0.2919356227,
-0.4820040166,
0.3325642347,
0.1411277503,
-0.4419325888,
0.7057295442,
-0.3238664865,
0.3974037468,
0.2036367059,
0.5136417747,
-0.4465711713,
1.2523685694,
0.5501697659,
-0.057676509,
0.6560944319,
-0.0063644038,
0.0844511688,
-0.3180498779,
-0.4273907244,
-0.5267079473,
-0.380651325,
-0.4714577496,
0.1335402876,
0.4637907445,
-0.0899780393,
0.0177041329,
0.3431216478,
-0.2289412022,
0.6006164551,
0.6017453671,
0.0003329358,
0.3594639599,
-0.3576186001,
0.0831482261,
-0.1174743026,
-0.3777883649,
-0.6267958879,
0.8309878707,
0.3051281273,
0.4775723815,
0.0372973904,
0.3595045805,
0.5280723572,
0.6845622659,
-0.7509325743,
0.5775597692,
0.4524681866,
-0.3796277344,
-0.2718279362,
-0.2760630548,
-1.0779272318,
0.194473505,
-0.2302285135,
-0.7824268937,
-0.1343412846,
0.1792940348,
-0.4084311724,
-0.0445319712,
-0.7970696092,
0.7928218246,
-0.3450303376,
-0.1268403828,
-0.3242138326,
-1.1502138376,
0.3050076962,
0.1978192776,
0.5551916361,
-0.3949204683,
0.2183918357,
1.0108212233,
-0.5756700039,
1.0018492937,
0.1212281063,
-0.3147391975,
0.5444369316,
0.0711924285,
0.0955988839,
-0.0943700224,
0.0777207017,
0.2359242439,
0.0843130201,
-0.1509978622,
-0.7007598877,
0.2859359682,
-0.4747629166,
-0.4355202019,
-0.3106686473,
-0.4159038365,
-0.1416546404,
-0.0076764757,
0.3514834344,
0.5915052891,
-0.3967269957,
-0.2845900953,
0.0863300785,
0.095400475,
0.6824368834,
0.6604246497,
-0.2942900956,
-0.2658846378,
0.71348387,
-0.0745439082,
0.2881290913,
0.2383967638,
0.3821760118,
-0.2867062092,
-0.3849647343,
-0.1527769715,
0.1608498096,
-0.6447433829,
-0.2575818002,
-0.8827511072,
0.0617814846,
-0.5613309741,
-0.0676292405,
-0.0643490776,
-0.2702790797,
-0.4647117257,
-0.3056672513,
0.304487884,
1.0989313126,
-0.0168577209,
0.5006124973,
-1.0803825855,
-0.0330956765,
0.5510604382,
-0.0950052068,
0.0556770451,
-0.6277025938,
-0.3924601674,
0.3475430012,
-0.9468964934,
-1.4096677303,
0.7046980262,
0.2210744768,
0.1983170658,
0.3154174089,
0.2225274742,
0.9039981365,
-0.3914283514,
1.1145173311,
0.0129304072,
-0.8996436,
0.835314393,
-0.5912591815,
0.2332316637,
0.4934090972,
0.3809003532,
-0.8415094614,
-0.8533980846,
-0.413248539,
-0.6837917566,
0.4398045242,
0.2547903061,
0.5136812925,
-0.0539965555,
0.3017425537,
-0.1445805132,
0.0648420528,
-0.3338122964,
-0.4063519537,
-0.1692378521,
-0.0482507981,
-0.0944246948,
-0.1706305742,
-0.1287617832,
-0.2671946883,
0.3160841763,
0.0546946302,
0.0540323146,
-0.0365810469,
0.0200428683,
-0.4743672013,
0.1539672315,
0.6930217743,
0.6064680219,
-0.2158279419,
-0.0536165275,
0.3349046111,
-0.6243145466,
-0.0968892574,
-0.3761693537,
0.0832254067,
0.1182393134,
0.6100694537,
0.7346470356,
0.4740393162,
-0.8715240955,
0.4086883068,
-0.38541013,
-0.1158993766,
-0.4053635001,
0.1910557151,
0.1530655771,
0.2850489914,
0.4914687276,
0.1673631072,
0.420823276,
-0.9059206247,
0.2694576383,
0.4512270391,
-0.3723042011,
-0.5418633223,
0.8556967378,
0.631786406,
-0.6281812787,
0.5390976667,
0.2319739461,
-0.6873413324,
0.5549806952,
0.3784786761,
0.7283297181,
-0.1935423613,
0.3311104774,
0.5772072673,
-0.1632732004,
-0.062178921,
-0.0872847512,
-0.5079321861,
-0.6574507952,
-0.4052943885,
-0.4807826579,
-0.7105225325,
-0.3507454097,
-0.8460925817,
0.0794366747,
-0.1763832569,
-0.5370262861,
-0.0033698541,
-0.1143738478,
-0.0968078598,
0.0132311657,
-0.0395803899,
0.6010152698,
-1.1234022379,
0.1016994789,
0.4729174972,
-0.4015359879,
-0.615968883,
0.3001099229,
0.2426742613,
-0.462826997,
0.5596616268,
0.1818929017,
-0.3065396249,
0.0146237705,
-0.7166050673,
-1.0621042252,
0.9357055426,
0.2630749345,
-0.3946570158,
-0.1025870293,
-0.191375792,
0.881542325,
0.0408292972,
0.4505719841,
0.8828848004,
0.3455809355,
0.4122411609,
-0.9487705827,
-0.2850896716,
-0.5680744052,
-0.4113236964,
0.2797369659,
-0.3609238267,
0.524490118,
-0.4407503307,
-0.479136914,
-0.0374127626,
0.8701341748,
-0.5594182014,
0.3320881128,
0.4511642456,
0.0287015885,
0.7122625113,
-0.1154656857,
1.1196545362,
-0.2012551725,
0.2020930201,
0.9812152982,
-0.0489783697,
0.8205444217,
0.3498623967,
-0.4036329389,
0.8257191777,
0.6059854627,
0.4936701357,
0.4727674127,
0.167430222,
-0.3515595496,
-0.3846008182,
-0.2070415616,
-0.0651417747,
0.5573911071,
0.5593263507,
-0.0600858666,
-0.2613750696,
0.0883485302,
0.04875632,
-0.0057940902,
-0.1079553291,
1.33910501,
-0.0857642367,
-1.2746441364,
0.0769074559,
-0.4913801849,
0.5721091032,
-0.3385823667,
-0.0669412389,
-0.265370518,
-0.2945914865,
-0.0965713784,
-1.0064474344,
0.7279464006,
-0.0639511123,
0.1451975852,
-0.6251874566,
0.3236319423,
-0.553932488,
-0.3492449224,
0.1433479339,
0.5337301493,
0.4533452988,
0.0981491581,
-0.3937112987,
-0.0939319581,
-0.0747299194,
-0.154926613,
0.2288759053,
0.2434687912,
0.0616591014,
0.8064746857,
0.7533734441,
-0.0295082834,
-0.0591344833,
-0.1320016682,
0.6692391634,
-0.7541972995,
-0.7288702726,
-0.9717487693,
0.7262017727,
-0.0977860764,
-0.3241676688,
0.4025404751,
0.2476854026,
0.2587640285,
0.2830280364,
0.6881961823,
0.0812491998,
0.9043877125,
-0.3238260448,
0.8325018287,
-0.447556138,
0.2269271463,
-0.2957980335,
-0.4710919857,
-0.2925122976,
0.5791534185,
-0.1299068779,
-0.2462916225,
0.6099781394,
0.5512307882,
0.3173163533,
0.2076662183,
0.0639642775,
0.4450612068,
0.3359726965,
0.2955828607,
1.0123617649,
-0.0420199372,
0.7980929017,
-0.184206292,
-0.1988393664,
-0.0358795598,
-0.9458364248,
-0.8437325954,
-0.8455905318,
-0.3503228128,
-0.3827833831,
-0.0609558448,
0.8057389855,
0.6464906931,
-0.7197660208,
-0.3200309277,
-0.37932989,
0.1909187883,
-0.0282340813,
-0.2913269103,
-0.0584801547,
-0.3572206795,
-0.8050088286,
0.2446779311,
0.2873140872,
0.3050423563,
0.0112116532,
0.0033386333,
0.0823033676,
0.0873194635,
0.3707977235,
0.5635388494,
-0.6146712899,
-0.2057951689,
-0.0844776332,
-0.2495601922,
0.0057568755,
1.0037584305,
-0.8874823451,
0.1456145048,
0.6093550324,
0.1883439869,
0.3124025762,
0.3265970349,
1.259757638,
-0.4717860818,
-0.0625424832,
0.1501506418,
0.1358044595,
0.1593137085,
-0.5031927824,
0.2543843687,
0.0704718977,
-0.751316905,
-0.7178371549,
0.1645660549,
-0.9910139441,
-0.1403537691,
0.6465914249,
-0.0690536499,
-0.1690240949,
-0.7440395951,
-0.5218800902,
0.4437811971,
-0.4099723101,
1.215867281,
0.6006009579,
-0.5122410655,
-0.0546504259,
-0.24110654,
0.5588004589,
0.2216839492,
-1.107232213,
0.1166449338,
0.8133766055,
0.2998771966,
0.4121953249,
0.8359916806,
0.2684330046,
0.1813147962,
-0.1740984023,
-0.5673289299,
0.4068964124,
-0.086002633,
0.2353570014,
0.1651077121,
-0.4491091073,
-0.18098858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18928v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18928v1
|
Stylus: Automatic Adapter Selection for Diffusion Models
| 2024-04-29T17:59:16 | 2024-04-29T17:59:16 |
Michael Luo, Justin Wong, Brandon Trabucco, Yanping Huang, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Zhifeng Chen, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Ion Stoica
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG
|
Beyond scaling base models with more data or parameters, fine-tuned adapters
provide an alternative way to generate high fidelity, custom images at reduced
costs. As such, adapters have been widely adopted by open-source communities,
accumulating a database of over 100K adapters-most of which are highly
customized with insufficient descriptions. This paper explores the problem of
matching the prompt to a set of relevant adapters, built on recent work that
highlight the performance gains of composing adapters. We introduce Stylus,
which efficiently selects and automatically composes task-specific adapters
based on a prompt's keywords. Stylus outlines a three-stage approach that first
summarizes adapters with improved descriptions and embeddings, retrieves
relevant adapters, and then further assembles adapters based on prompts'
keywords by checking how well they fit the prompt. To evaluate Stylus, we
developed StylusDocs, a curated dataset featuring 75K adapters with
pre-computed adapter embeddings. In our evaluation on popular Stable Diffusion
checkpoints, Stylus achieves greater CLIP-FID Pareto efficiency and is twice as
preferred, with humans and multimodal models as evaluators, over the base
model. See stylus-diffusion.github.io for more.
|
[
-0.5959795117,
-0.5188921094,
0.9170187116,
0.1968218237,
-0.3309269845,
-0.3701167107,
-0.1479305178,
-0.3136731386,
0.3408456147,
0.2551974356,
-0.4513814747,
-0.2846779823,
-0.679977119,
0.0639559031,
-0.0115524959,
0.8340969682,
-0.3579575121,
-0.2656449974,
-0.4667384028,
-0.3995372951,
-0.6254765391,
0.5596250296,
-1.022030592,
-0.1336823255,
0.6512413621,
0.4127258062,
0.5890073776,
0.7467147708,
0.3711155653,
0.245402053,
-0.2066509575,
0.0785676539,
-0.3153816462,
0.3080939949,
-0.3057922125,
-0.1294994205,
-0.2353318483,
0.0039536436,
0.3736013174,
0.3008466065,
-0.0471496843,
0.3591378927,
0.1126828864,
0.7399893999,
-0.7623203993,
-0.4181374013,
-0.3022024333,
0.2282541096,
0.0195410438,
0.1250162572,
-0.2825024128,
-0.4414381385,
0.3120069504,
-0.9236854315,
0.4212361276,
-0.1816084981,
0.565813601,
0.3369989693,
-0.3108706474,
-0.3517955542,
-0.6871157885,
0.373231113,
-0.3405297697,
0.2436757237,
0.0449342355,
0.6780585051,
-0.2589487433,
-1.0158905983,
-0.360858053,
-0.096185796,
0.1656726003,
0.2974578142,
-0.0972939953,
0.0028947771,
0.2324423939,
0.2990519404,
-0.4755342305,
-0.0999611616,
-0.2875312269,
-0.1656270921,
0.4721749127,
0.3317266107,
0.2004381865,
0.219827354,
-0.1409147233,
0.0176615659,
-0.5122020245,
0.2093079835,
0.4216934443,
-0.0743401423,
-0.0913874432,
0.3483249247,
-0.0807952806,
0.9816393852,
0.5476359725,
0.0435455441,
-0.0600509495,
-0.5829983354,
-0.0284543131,
-0.4155646265,
0.9028901458,
0.488255024,
-0.0205967929,
0.200158909,
-0.079293929,
-0.2743614912,
0.3817661703,
-0.9611023664,
-0.7144607902,
0.3000059426,
-0.7382224798,
-0.2955912948,
-0.4090530872,
-1.0947747231,
-0.7056402564,
-0.0697634891,
0.6014266014,
-0.1448577046,
-0.2533593178,
0.0261319894,
-0.7906453013,
-0.4255140424,
0.8275746107,
-0.7328734398,
0.0536514372,
0.1845902503,
1.2999017239,
-0.4254598022,
-0.2513217032,
-0.5703599453,
-0.0103228223,
-0.426882565,
1.2244807482,
-0.976110518,
-0.7680082917,
-0.1207494661,
0.2253710777,
-0.243662551,
-0.5621455312,
0.5608664155,
-0.3254250884,
0.192634508,
-0.3876802027,
-0.6727343798,
-0.0554810762,
-0.1021792144,
-0.8705215454,
0.8800928593,
0.2994358838,
-0.6444242597,
0.6882520318,
-0.9871378541,
-0.2693841457,
-0.0201096851,
0.1775943637,
-0.3837513626,
0.2278240323,
0.006600834,
0.2943381965,
-0.1777999401,
-0.0876477435,
-0.5400206447,
-0.2280940562,
-0.1672697663,
0.0312210433,
0.641055882,
0.3907513916,
-0.0318307728,
0.7153263688,
-0.4271782637,
-0.5173330903,
-0.0580006391,
-0.3581752479,
-0.1854451299,
0.0591742508,
0.2022622228,
0.1851289123,
-0.0093870331,
-0.5660541654,
0.2373020053,
0.0137955518,
0.6763065457,
0.7818034291,
0.1354638636,
0.901781857,
-0.5806574225,
0.6037995219,
0.2503642738,
0.385692209,
-0.4955119193,
-0.8106327653,
-0.4471484423,
-0.6490418315,
0.2077207714,
0.3190936148,
-0.5944672227,
0.2178987116,
-0.0696140453,
-0.9957224131,
-0.4462229013,
0.1455095559,
-0.1999687403,
0.9048239589,
0.2744336128,
-0.3874174058,
-0.0913613662,
-0.906743288,
-0.2373036295,
0.0766572878,
-0.2851886153,
0.6838991642,
0.3412324488,
-0.2999894023,
1.0327775478,
-0.7549656034,
-0.3199739158,
-0.1269128919,
-0.0680493712,
0.3192970157,
0.4417270124,
0.7504325509,
-0.5004370213,
-0.6286380291,
-0.1473185271,
-0.3152516782,
-0.1904554218,
-0.2547077239,
-0.33698228,
-0.2286881953,
0.2700110674,
-0.7528911233,
0.3158165812,
0.2804032266,
-0.5826796889,
0.6478329301,
-0.5795629025,
0.2342610806,
-1.0472663641,
0.2858329713,
0.4422201812,
-0.1782431453,
-0.6910892725,
-0.2195675075,
0.3523972332,
-0.1197331622,
-0.5772769451,
0.8948343992,
-0.1198204532,
0.2156506926,
-0.2724123895,
0.0089626554,
0.2713737488,
0.0579204001,
0.2112974077,
0.742220521,
0.6097621918,
-0.7346892953,
0.2819521725,
0.2384677976,
-0.2652101815,
0.8572642803,
-0.7073134184,
0.074822247,
-0.2490317971,
0.4886879623,
-1.2717181444,
-0.0752605423,
0.3717320859,
0.0902566835,
-0.1350866258,
-0.4943887293,
-0.181669727,
-0.4415593147,
-0.5268622637,
0.555627048,
0.654694438,
-0.3596266806,
0.9295132756,
0.4300167859,
-0.2453595847,
-0.0203524567,
-0.1950927675,
-0.0914107636,
-0.5402780771,
-0.6198049784,
0.1367015988,
-0.5276739001,
0.2165616155,
-0.1266415119,
0.1534824818,
-0.0465431139,
0.2460032552,
0.3763878942,
0.2295016348,
-0.0421956219,
-0.1451877654,
0.290833056,
-0.1132206768,
-0.2574017644,
-0.591965735,
0.1011990532,
0.4844705164,
-0.2213808,
-0.469171226,
0.0937572867,
0.6387890577,
0.256392926,
0.1078410223,
0.8424717188,
-0.2036202848,
-0.0324570499,
-0.4551174939,
0.033920031,
-0.5566012859,
0.0455791242,
-0.4903458059,
-0.5149510503,
0.6923504472,
-0.1062130481,
0.4840458632,
0.3168823123,
0.4863999188,
-0.1233609319,
0.9462125897,
0.5510209203,
0.0349908955,
0.9899157286,
0.0463566184,
-0.2084201276,
-0.9458450675,
0.1600153893,
-0.2961626053,
-0.7182157636,
-0.1270912737,
-0.4778773189,
0.3649677634,
-0.220147267,
-0.0712363049,
0.3561096787,
-0.836403966,
0.5317821503,
0.6281301975,
0.1246821731,
0.0818480775,
-0.0766953602,
-0.0998030156,
0.1321730763,
-0.5026724339,
-0.3298397362,
1.0462167263,
0.3875075579,
0.5792844296,
0.0191397984,
0.2730783224,
0.427100122,
0.2811819613,
-0.7964188457,
0.449349016,
-0.2270185649,
-0.3671082258,
-0.2016330659,
-0.0318671875,
-1.0715749264,
0.290174067,
-0.2286644727,
-0.4711176753,
0.768642664,
0.5014602542,
-0.828199923,
0.1599398106,
-0.7011525631,
1.1461588144,
0.2108045518,
-0.4407170415,
-0.2528085411,
-0.3079413176,
-0.0196813289,
-0.1274329126,
0.0563990325,
-0.3107208312,
-0.3607521355,
0.9693728685,
-0.1585395187,
0.5348581672,
-0.6267134547,
0.0379650146,
0.2499219477,
0.3140449524,
0.4546738863,
-0.0185856968,
-0.1502247155,
-0.0139808757,
0.2570229471,
-0.3196961284,
-0.3237720728,
0.6776559353,
-0.3304286301,
-0.4615060389,
0.0699390769,
-0.5770236254,
0.0543216355,
0.3812004924,
0.6111733913,
0.3443938792,
-0.1893201023,
-0.4285838008,
0.6683771014,
-0.1491649002,
0.5902353525,
0.3646102548,
-0.0996051356,
-0.6375380158,
0.9929479361,
0.1555703431,
0.1633693129,
-0.2309659868,
0.4152317941,
-0.1119826585,
-0.8232515454,
-1.2711533308,
0.1477823257,
-0.660472393,
-0.1470801532,
-0.7178806067,
0.2603490353,
-0.2932329178,
-0.5155544877,
-0.0902089402,
-0.4194886982,
-0.6819303632,
0.0523512848,
0.5233204365,
0.8727133274,
-0.0564977452,
0.3759245276,
-0.7685565352,
0.4119451344,
0.37757954,
0.3341683447,
-0.0452519283,
-0.6357769966,
-0.3763453662,
-0.2307920605,
-0.4002777934,
-0.903696537,
0.2087429166,
0.5053372979,
0.5897724032,
0.6849489212,
0.059200231,
0.8506045341,
-0.6613962054,
0.9320424795,
0.1571571529,
-0.6236877441,
0.7722210288,
-0.5351017714,
0.2917103469,
0.7705886364,
0.2587738037,
-0.4490301013,
-0.3778465092,
-0.4790751934,
-0.953551054,
0.6420065165,
-0.198098436,
0.0726712123,
0.2060062289,
0.5623169541,
0.4789486229,
0.097405225,
-0.1149843261,
-0.0162328687,
-0.2513803244,
-0.7039791942,
-0.1510666609,
-0.3138122559,
-0.3770305514,
-0.1618108898,
0.1865413338,
-0.1739552021,
0.2615825534,
0.2301621586,
-0.219439134,
-0.3575944304,
-0.2603096068,
0.6676031351,
0.442604959,
0.1102903485,
0.0597983114,
0.1647276431,
-0.7834277153,
0.2496747375,
0.0240318123,
-0.3788351715,
0.1484607458,
0.1546715945,
0.7772999406,
0.0849288329,
-0.5166553259,
0.6713459492,
-0.3460414112,
-0.260260433,
-0.2534724474,
0.4553155005,
0.0691008344,
0.2985919118,
0.1605138332,
0.5248194337,
0.6482974887,
-0.034939386,
0.2118253559,
0.4820783734,
-0.5937514901,
-0.5182953477,
0.7413868308,
0.4627870321,
-0.3649368584,
0.2264146209,
-0.0447833911,
-0.0208923332,
0.6609128714,
0.3174795806,
0.9861191511,
-0.313439548,
0.2448930293,
0.4385616481,
0.0760512576,
-0.3937188983,
0.031143263,
-0.4554228187,
-0.3752738833,
0.0904998928,
-0.4003863335,
-0.4006427228,
-0.4402982593,
-0.4963395596,
0.4488421082,
-0.6406427622,
-0.5234645605,
0.0334256329,
-0.3517740667,
-0.7056724429,
-0.1789801121,
-0.031340383,
1.5579839945,
-1.2477121353,
0.6156939864,
0.8834164739,
-0.155420348,
-0.1015712023,
-0.0985766128,
-0.0641137287,
-0.3505014777,
0.2172105312,
0.0189322568,
0.1941172779,
0.1806006879,
-0.0819704756,
-0.6832089424,
1.1439100504,
0.3364835978,
-0.2824462056,
0.0782133192,
-0.4838521779,
0.3485386968,
-0.5139695406,
0.7543258667,
0.638243854,
0.5392541885,
0.3044982553,
-0.8879774213,
0.2092011571,
-0.3163520694,
0.0667701662,
0.0988922268,
-0.4153422415,
0.6921256781,
-0.1080226749,
-0.1732453555,
0.1419870406,
0.3561030924,
0.2081728429,
0.5744920373,
0.8957676291,
0.6406322718,
0.6573780179,
0.102027148,
0.6985884309,
-0.1744619012,
-0.0855261534,
0.8699972034,
-0.2586922944,
0.7623345256,
0.3118322492,
-0.0780866891,
0.6076780558,
1.1522650719,
-0.1720533818,
0.7212336063,
-0.1447699666,
-0.3297044337,
-0.2693524957,
0.0959444791,
-0.0470811576,
-0.3430464566,
0.3688987494,
-0.3421028554,
-0.1796170473,
0.4361344278,
-0.3546343744,
-0.4451272786,
-0.2427846491,
1.1951891184,
-0.1165633276,
-0.8139569163,
0.0705898777,
-0.43594414,
0.677521944,
-0.4357556105,
0.0057227942,
-0.1886470318,
-0.0170537923,
-0.3221651614,
-1.0703248978,
0.3537037373,
-0.2761762738,
-0.2070446461,
-0.1852147728,
0.8481642008,
-0.3459675312,
-0.367086947,
0.1176761985,
0.1080822349,
0.0909646749,
-0.0566537902,
-0.6534327269,
0.0188082457,
-0.1504806876,
-0.34719643,
0.300069958,
0.3019489348,
0.2316026837,
0.6405280232,
0.6182720661,
0.2607076466,
-0.1841782331,
-0.3269647956,
0.8461536169,
-0.5555506945,
-0.6705406904,
-0.7458438277,
0.8658795357,
-0.2430147082,
-0.3480515182,
0.5971370339,
0.4946371615,
0.2715736032,
-0.2887083292,
0.8687782288,
0.0825523958,
0.3019866049,
-0.2715925574,
0.7026954293,
-0.5611512661,
0.0421069525,
-0.1682383269,
-0.868573308,
-0.1524662971,
0.6950152516,
-0.3827543855,
-0.0782914609,
0.4116415679,
0.7770555019,
-0.390740782,
-0.0991635472,
0.134600684,
-0.3014004529,
0.3485250473,
0.4690851569,
0.7207134366,
-0.2553759217,
0.4340414405,
-0.0303427204,
-0.2941753268,
-0.6214222312,
-0.9337966442,
-0.7930639982,
-0.7382753491,
-0.5782690048,
-0.4200090766,
-0.2666729987,
0.7213308811,
0.8897361755,
-0.6950917244,
-0.2153333873,
-0.1089596003,
0.2777993679,
-0.0612625331,
-0.1483941078,
0.2187926322,
-0.2225638777,
-0.709993422,
0.3081544936,
0.434168756,
0.2196025103,
0.048047781,
-0.084109351,
0.3545678556,
0.2084156871,
0.3947615027,
0.1881323755,
-0.3389714956,
-0.2044142783,
-0.1109948382,
0.0441542529,
0.0806326568,
0.9044018984,
-0.8284080029,
0.6237286329,
0.9396033287,
0.4069224894,
0.4416991472,
-0.1789332926,
0.63606745,
-0.0939508379,
0.0010511943,
0.007727433,
0.514161706,
0.0916652903,
-0.2593418956,
0.2838139236,
0.3053945601,
-0.7842886448,
-0.7666598558,
0.4792245924,
-0.8796547055,
-0.2535945475,
1.1339042187,
-0.2181251496,
-0.3518832028,
-0.4812598825,
-0.5584627986,
-0.0631658062,
-0.6042375565,
0.6904159188,
0.4448859692,
-0.3204136491,
-0.2758739889,
-0.2901284099,
0.6616011262,
0.017448375,
-0.4246066809,
0.0536136962,
0.7566900253,
0.6751681566,
0.2575960457,
0.9071977735,
0.3393951058,
0.4360340238,
-0.064632386,
-0.214899987,
-0.1446671337,
-0.0895304009,
-0.5932609439,
0.2939998209,
0.3861550391,
-0.2405086011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18923v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18923v2
|
Holmes: Benchmark the Linguistic Competence of Language Models
| 2024-04-29T17:58:36 | 2024-05-22T08:36:49 |
Andreas Waldis, Yotam Perlitz, Leshem Choshen, Yufang Hou, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Holmes, a benchmark to assess the linguistic competence of
language models (LMs) - their ability to grasp linguistic phenomena. Unlike
prior prompting-based evaluations, Holmes assesses the linguistic competence of
LMs via their internal representations using classifier-based probing. In doing
so, we disentangle specific phenomena (e.g., part-of-speech of words) from
other cognitive abilities, like following textual instructions, and meet recent
calls to assess LMs' linguistic competence in isolation. Composing Holmes, we
review over 250 probing studies and feature more than 200 datasets to assess
syntax, morphology, semantics, reasoning, and discourse phenomena. Analyzing
over 50 LMs reveals that, aligned with known trends, their linguistic
competence correlates with model size. However, surprisingly, model
architecture and instruction tuning also significantly influence performance,
particularly in morphology and syntax. Finally, we propose FlashHolmes, a
streamlined version of Holmes designed to lower the high computation load while
maintaining high-ranking precision.
|
[
-0.232238695,
-0.9136072397,
0.5326213837,
0.1694044173,
0.0284850895,
0.1222430542,
-0.3067058325,
-0.323984921,
0.1292826533,
0.5248352289,
-0.233896926,
-0.194692865,
-0.6484467983,
0.1274072379,
-0.5943832994,
0.5190820694,
0.3536384404,
0.0317738205,
-0.4022336304,
-0.0735300556,
-0.235659048,
-0.2457210124,
-0.6149408817,
-0.1086657122,
0.49538517,
0.0888327658,
0.7500856519,
0.6918171644,
0.6391524673,
0.3278139532,
-0.2059446573,
-0.1106036678,
-0.2766469717,
0.3264888227,
-0.334058851,
-0.6026232839,
-0.507584095,
-0.1835253835,
0.7723438144,
1.0717622042,
-0.0929973423,
0.4769473374,
0.1405156851,
0.6081545949,
-0.8130797148,
0.2802491486,
-0.8159663677,
-0.2325047106,
-0.5923269391,
-0.3786359131,
-0.5695662498,
-0.2551538944,
0.1683687121,
-0.2511771321,
0.335907042,
-0.0129387258,
0.6247990131,
0.286455065,
-0.5659019351,
-0.0961894542,
-0.3810119629,
0.8144078255,
-0.6624971032,
0.5557982922,
0.5838312507,
0.3720509112,
0.0562272668,
-0.6984824538,
-0.4228514135,
-0.4186883867,
-0.0302902441,
-0.009593226,
-0.0577572398,
-0.0635822117,
0.3227382302,
0.3385839164,
-0.7177507877,
0.0224916544,
-0.3623016775,
-0.006892472,
0.7432969809,
0.2957380414,
0.1591138691,
-0.0383410305,
0.1429628432,
-0.1935830712,
-0.6051129699,
0.180176571,
0.2884225249,
0.3752776086,
0.3281956613,
0.5326012969,
-0.2551689446,
0.5855900645,
-0.1493888497,
0.0626668707,
0.1643614024,
0.0701952651,
-0.2367229015,
-0.1672936082,
0.6679424047,
0.0466214456,
0.3656589985,
-0.0830656141,
-0.1185713932,
-0.0834911689,
0.5280796289,
-0.5023799539,
-0.2373409718,
0.3464049697,
-0.3929813206,
-0.2707763314,
-0.2918713689,
-0.8817830086,
-0.4133762121,
0.0320191942,
0.2397092879,
-0.2589053214,
-0.4953183532,
0.1278583556,
0.0498968028,
0.2159517705,
0.0558894649,
-1.2380381823,
0.5984321237,
0.8683820367,
0.5199174881,
-0.1230014041,
-0.4351118803,
-0.4501547515,
-0.0944747999,
-0.7167050242,
0.5093522072,
-0.6292862296,
-0.3919836879,
0.3125555515,
0.0397780985,
-0.0520103388,
-0.561042726,
0.4935775697,
-0.4810677767,
0.0021214986,
-0.0958734676,
-0.9133528471,
-0.2562155724,
0.2220168859,
-0.7404096127,
1.1252474785,
-0.0497137271,
-0.6422906518,
0.312980324,
-0.4428245425,
-0.5035303831,
0.4510120451,
-0.2177185565,
-0.1356625855,
0.4973179698,
0.1861959994,
0.6325075626,
-0.2963209152,
0.3950591087,
-0.4316435754,
-0.1810759455,
0.2262693346,
-0.3357513845,
1.0248887539,
-0.0719668865,
-0.1591063142,
0.1849303842,
-0.8158482313,
0.2865696847,
0.1991289258,
-0.124880977,
-0.2999069989,
0.3185044527,
-0.0170951858,
-0.2727698088,
0.1437014788,
-0.2655938864,
-0.1575184464,
-0.3655275404,
0.4238203764,
0.334949553,
-0.2092466503,
0.2407438904,
-0.4079750478,
0.5579935312,
-0.2092909068,
0.0387638323,
-0.4561342299,
-0.6713847518,
-0.7897523046,
-0.2109528631,
0.306991607,
0.5642781258,
-0.3267826736,
0.5702347159,
-0.3780297339,
-0.6444260478,
-0.6819139719,
0.0058239242,
0.3669222593,
0.4984545708,
0.4209627211,
-0.3731286526,
-0.2458549142,
-0.872921586,
-0.6318802238,
-0.281172961,
0.000827914,
0.0219993331,
0.4661419392,
0.14491041,
0.7670383453,
0.0422547385,
0.0177942608,
-0.1833487302,
0.1141609624,
0.1947791278,
0.4480146766,
0.2113543451,
-0.3660133183,
-0.3647236228,
-0.1548785418,
-0.8101556301,
0.0477219857,
0.0674580708,
0.2556570768,
0.27642712,
0.7979915142,
-0.5143967271,
0.2645403743,
0.5394016504,
-0.066562213,
0.5301396251,
-0.1722950339,
0.1048127115,
-0.6885036826,
0.2403785586,
0.061542511,
-0.2480731755,
-0.6197748184,
0.6043151021,
0.4371193945,
-0.0184636991,
-0.4288493991,
0.70396626,
-0.5434114337,
-0.1697882712,
0.122618489,
0.2116627544,
-0.2838903368,
0.350463599,
0.1850258261,
0.6348667145,
0.7392445803,
-0.5607197285,
0.2038525045,
-0.1778990924,
-0.7961754799,
0.5225614905,
-0.7607166767,
0.1689501256,
0.0449534021,
-0.1841309667,
-0.9953597188,
-0.0590558499,
-0.5275632739,
-0.4240534604,
0.3252330124,
-0.2635544837,
-0.6011065841,
-0.1858081371,
-0.1614465564,
0.3857084215,
0.785363853,
-0.2929528356,
0.5888320208,
0.417583555,
-0.1830373704,
-0.4245156944,
-0.7655008435,
0.0401452631,
-0.2543947697,
-0.5408241153,
0.0809761435,
0.1140395924,
-0.5730971098,
-0.184795633,
0.1168754324,
-0.2117389888,
0.3498039842,
0.0635587797,
0.0433300883,
-0.5330091715,
0.120391652,
0.0517015047,
-0.0538488552,
0.256309092,
-0.0665568113,
0.3910209537,
-0.1597793996,
-0.4894666672,
-0.3903231025,
0.0953187197,
0.4101568758,
-0.3531138003,
0.5358835459,
0.3406076133,
-0.361948669,
-0.1955813169,
-0.6481623054,
-0.3993804753,
-0.4420030713,
0.4961433709,
-0.6376235485,
-0.883830905,
0.4900234938,
0.0379789956,
0.1089620739,
0.4962849319,
0.5446559787,
-0.1011322811,
1.1416621208,
0.4944253266,
0.0017318198,
0.1521368027,
-0.0028421471,
0.2907439172,
-0.8335689902,
0.0468643717,
-0.771856606,
-0.1122723073,
-0.6648466587,
-0.3718676567,
0.1321605295,
0.3040412962,
-0.0369194634,
0.3831214011,
-0.2798679769,
0.5428711772,
0.453284204,
-0.1665180326,
0.3319685757,
-0.3862296641,
-0.1048079878,
-0.2541694045,
-0.503103137,
-0.6936548352,
1.2455888987,
0.5280700326,
0.5123437643,
0.2958091497,
0.5773556232,
0.1919521838,
0.0306191724,
-0.7538802624,
0.8049864769,
0.0016864456,
-0.8087295294,
-0.3496721685,
-0.470457226,
-0.9524481893,
0.4121368825,
-0.0862671286,
-0.8149749637,
-0.1186512336,
0.1425235868,
-0.2526198328,
0.0806746706,
-0.5741320848,
0.8463369608,
-0.1585560441,
-0.4569128454,
-0.5291181803,
-0.3152134717,
0.3633369505,
0.121136263,
0.2978417575,
-0.3934719265,
-0.339515537,
0.569819212,
-0.1274109632,
0.8103253245,
0.0869703665,
-0.0928337276,
-0.0268606152,
0.6309089661,
0.0933443755,
0.1146664247,
-0.0915401801,
0.207570076,
0.4245248139,
-0.5637103319,
-0.5335034728,
0.456196934,
-0.1803797781,
-0.5847190022,
-0.4648574293,
-0.2617302537,
-0.6483081579,
0.2642439604,
0.0998078957,
0.6802279353,
-0.4794683456,
0.1779417694,
0.8370584846,
0.0793734789,
0.583378315,
0.5384300947,
-0.5496678352,
0.0656725764,
0.7502371669,
-0.095888786,
0.2062731981,
0.5145915747,
0.2038629204,
-0.3098288774,
-0.9118449688,
-0.3578076959,
0.1389039755,
-0.7058411241,
0.0717398375,
-0.4409402609,
-0.1567133963,
-0.4178255796,
-0.0202312246,
-0.4537122548,
-0.4381083846,
-0.0083995992,
0.1672905385,
0.1592980027,
0.68902421,
0.3711799383,
0.0352564864,
-0.791595161,
-0.1226636395,
0.4661737978,
0.3821594715,
-0.0380354114,
-0.6602869034,
-0.0290313121,
-0.1328360885,
-0.1281415373,
-0.7586024404,
0.3029793203,
0.3236400485,
0.7669690847,
0.2073343843,
-0.2358836234,
0.4280973971,
-0.5359528065,
1.0241159201,
-0.2575261295,
-1.2134242058,
0.5444890261,
-0.4823217392,
0.5231005549,
0.6316820979,
0.5463457704,
-0.4902435243,
-0.7375352383,
-0.6930091977,
-0.4577286541,
0.3111357093,
-0.0241195802,
0.2039823681,
-0.3428145051,
0.1011992097,
-0.0984668359,
0.1368407607,
-0.1881910414,
0.0794305727,
0.1854912788,
-0.2698881924,
-0.2271223813,
-0.2866238058,
-0.110680379,
-0.2062152922,
0.5716764927,
-0.3894490302,
-0.0337895378,
-0.0366942361,
-0.5866384506,
0.1585695893,
0.1486381143,
0.5935246348,
0.9523416758,
-0.1703964621,
0.3189955354,
0.2152977139,
-0.4505538344,
-0.3640748262,
-0.1591082513,
0.0339893401,
-0.0351514146,
0.8688260317,
0.360147506,
0.4924901426,
-0.9490785599,
0.4586158991,
-0.14181678,
-0.0807604641,
-0.088401638,
0.1023230478,
0.121365346,
0.0429370143,
0.1301828325,
-0.0924116448,
0.3091474175,
-0.7430738211,
0.1976382583,
0.3920695484,
-0.423039794,
-0.3682013452,
0.4656301141,
0.2533159256,
-0.4723914266,
0.6069280505,
-0.151424408,
-0.3722266853,
0.4812048376,
0.2366725951,
0.8240463138,
-0.4575463831,
-0.0768888369,
0.5055704713,
0.438087821,
-0.2984016538,
0.4417828321,
-0.0223104674,
-0.6675059795,
-0.3811759353,
-0.3268038034,
-0.4126683176,
-0.00733541,
-0.9667633772,
0.2141096741,
-0.6373894215,
-0.1631156504,
0.1457028389,
0.164640367,
-0.5819022655,
0.0520995222,
-0.1454322338,
1.2499186993,
-0.5673140883,
1.0353221893,
0.5172450542,
-0.3429393172,
-0.3844652176,
-0.1245585755,
0.2956265509,
-0.9077730775,
0.2857973874,
0.0794906691,
-0.1220369935,
0.0292932149,
-0.1208932698,
-0.5771772265,
0.7238183022,
0.2855183184,
-0.7291689515,
0.2283746898,
-0.0993194729,
0.7107266784,
-0.2229564041,
0.6529517174,
0.932452023,
0.0070831687,
-0.4003337324,
-1.3073103428,
-0.1707607061,
-0.3916062415,
0.1669015437,
0.2454615533,
-0.3185817897,
0.7487692833,
0.005376352,
-0.1712662727,
0.1865973473,
0.6000961065,
0.1243769899,
-0.0096302656,
0.3715242445,
0.4735724032,
1.0012491941,
-0.1713273078,
1.0619558096,
-0.4769726694,
0.3101477623,
1.1966192722,
-0.4444856644,
1.4860600233,
0.3655222952,
-0.3390736282,
0.4711791575,
0.3818968236,
0.3316406608,
0.3365694284,
0.2903761566,
-0.0623794757,
-0.142134428,
0.2250622809,
-0.3027775586,
0.5362983346,
0.5855420828,
-0.2140440494,
0.0416999161,
-0.2109037787,
0.0079300273,
0.3919736445,
-0.1435412467,
0.8120123744,
-0.1327502131,
-0.7369998097,
0.5916670561,
-0.2567845881,
0.5533409119,
-0.65752244,
0.2424248159,
-0.31462273,
0.2684139907,
0.0108585805,
-1.0130804777,
0.5531805158,
-0.1591872126,
0.0920066684,
-0.2533079386,
0.3994937241,
-0.4303178787,
-0.4534427524,
0.2910633385,
0.5108878016,
0.3564278483,
0.043652188,
-0.6491667628,
0.3755884171,
-0.4432424307,
-0.0984601602,
0.3051887751,
0.2437323332,
0.0990160555,
0.7134979963,
0.2250870019,
0.2691083252,
0.3527323008,
0.2819370031,
0.0576181263,
-0.6832587719,
-0.2844130099,
-0.6881456971,
0.5019879937,
-0.1732085049,
-0.613779068,
0.8592107296,
0.5642066002,
0.9277021885,
0.0675121844,
0.6082763672,
0.055141028,
0.7048024535,
-0.6351997852,
0.6414915919,
-0.5370207429,
0.1567447335,
0.0137144001,
-0.8481990695,
-0.379473418,
0.7424902916,
-0.2837778926,
0.1506585032,
0.9297272563,
0.8721717,
-0.131791234,
0.3729103804,
0.5353702903,
0.0384541973,
0.2823549211,
0.3478260934,
0.8799586296,
-0.3343258798,
0.0420116112,
-0.2853868604,
-0.3526264727,
-0.2782723308,
-1.0107750893,
-1.1495113373,
-0.9613602161,
-0.4465987384,
-0.1644414663,
0.0077457721,
0.6189382076,
1.0249768496,
-0.7914671898,
-0.6347150207,
-0.1193981692,
-0.1179973856,
-0.5016500354,
-0.1931636781,
0.2090601772,
-0.8044526577,
-0.5365691185,
0.7125426531,
0.3230811656,
-0.279106468,
-0.6651185155,
0.2394989282,
-0.0706447661,
0.2918364108,
0.5342904329,
0.2659629583,
-0.949378252,
-0.0876988024,
-0.0145592252,
-0.2361458689,
-0.131010741,
1.1301345825,
-0.6717941165,
0.6029036045,
0.6765801907,
0.7392808795,
0.3953872323,
-0.6165872216,
0.4331046939,
-0.5991396308,
0.1009820774,
0.4929619133,
0.484025985,
0.2875311673,
0.0688475445,
0.4398221374,
-0.0235469807,
-0.5680347681,
-1.047575593,
0.1844581068,
-0.7976990938,
-0.2369922101,
0.6544978619,
-0.0831361935,
-0.2664104104,
-0.1886570901,
0.2897067368,
-0.2479919344,
-0.0465564653,
0.8115445375,
0.779754281,
0.0645470321,
-0.5033492446,
-0.9213041663,
0.6676285267,
0.8479379416,
-0.8578107357,
0.2622447908,
0.0694034621,
0.227671504,
0.2345190495,
0.7331843972,
-0.1924795806,
0.2457958311,
0.2570782602,
-0.1949275881,
0.2747955024,
-0.4257006049,
-0.7046729326,
0.0818045139,
0.3459632397,
0.0134511665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18922v1
|
DPO Meets PPO: Reinforced Token Optimization for RLHF
| 2024-04-29T17:58:30 | 2024-04-29T17:58:30 |
Han Zhong, Guhao Feng, Wei Xiong, Li Zhao, Di He, Jiang Bian, Liwei Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
In the classical Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) framework,
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) is employed to learn from sparse,
sentence-level rewards -- a challenging scenario in traditional deep
reinforcement learning. Despite the great successes of PPO in the alignment of
state-of-the-art closed-source large language models (LLMs), its open-source
implementation is still largely sub-optimal, as widely reported by numerous
research studies. To address these issues, we introduce a framework that models
RLHF problems as a Markov decision process (MDP), enabling the capture of
fine-grained token-wise information. Furthermore, we provide theoretical
insights that demonstrate the superiority of our MDP framework over the
previous sentence-level bandit formulation. Under this framework, we introduce
an algorithm, dubbed as Reinforced Token Optimization (\texttt{RTO}), which
learns the token-wise reward function from preference data and performs policy
optimization based on this learned token-wise reward signal. Theoretically,
\texttt{RTO} is proven to have the capability of finding the near-optimal
policy sample-efficiently. For its practical implementation, \texttt{RTO}
innovatively integrates Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) and PPO. DPO,
originally derived from sparse sentence rewards, surprisingly provides us with
a token-wise characterization of response quality, which is seamlessly
incorporated into our subsequent PPO training stage. Extensive real-world
alignment experiments verify the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
|
[
-0.2700778842,
-0.7437641621,
0.4341488779,
0.1012114882,
-0.2165678293,
0.1349232942,
-0.1784258634,
-0.1909119338,
0.1769593805,
0.6124760509,
-0.8649887443,
-0.3611455858,
-0.3268755078,
0.0370021462,
0.3062152565,
1.1172068119,
-0.0888992175,
-0.0033361262,
-0.1547846645,
0.0588273033,
-0.4847362041,
-0.5659412742,
-0.6438545585,
-0.5954676867,
0.6614383459,
0.6637172699,
0.5568578839,
0.7478141189,
0.3474188149,
0.2855612934,
-0.1379019022,
0.3483904898,
-0.5734139085,
0.0424705558,
-0.1002499908,
-0.1995487213,
-0.4298701882,
0.0381660052,
0.7200021744,
0.3736062944,
-0.531034708,
-0.2370438576,
0.0761372522,
0.7304244041,
-0.8632202148,
0.1902390569,
-0.4922558963,
0.4454001486,
0.2469071448,
-0.3239928186,
-0.3566636145,
-0.2805380225,
0.1598457843,
-0.8300759792,
-0.2261642367,
0.1355811507,
0.6674787998,
0.1644998342,
-0.3377927542,
-0.1791485399,
-0.5475710034,
0.9099588394,
-0.4953686595,
-0.0001674412,
0.3336641192,
0.1260557622,
-0.7258565426,
-0.6029528975,
-0.7858814597,
-0.5269464254,
0.0809796005,
0.216259107,
0.0045908294,
0.568330884,
-0.1559825987,
0.4028831422,
-0.4032536149,
0.4439457059,
0.0889726356,
-0.3095287979,
0.4566602111,
0.1230223626,
-0.1237501949,
-0.2295401394,
-0.6683136821,
-0.2801440358,
-0.5322186947,
0.2734684944,
0.6265152097,
0.3633848429,
0.1902736723,
0.5285426378,
-0.1686632782,
0.5740154982,
0.1596564054,
-0.2439745814,
0.0743859559,
-0.0374441855,
-0.1034795195,
0.1180496663,
0.8317601085,
0.272514075,
0.2104898989,
-0.1711511165,
-0.6579499841,
-0.2847232521,
0.3270643055,
-0.5164475441,
0.0678196996,
0.2814498842,
-0.4564800858,
-0.6652256846,
0.0369092673,
-0.7075405121,
-0.2983513474,
-0.2352212667,
0.3773404062,
-0.0121171409,
-0.4203049541,
0.1242161095,
-0.0995260924,
0.0644494221,
-0.1173346415,
-1.1262433529,
0.3057237864,
1.2302085161,
0.6846044064,
-0.281530112,
-0.4037789106,
-1.0796678066,
-0.0204062499,
-0.3253512979,
0.5312506557,
-0.5071795583,
-0.4537451267,
0.3390500247,
-0.3301369846,
-0.1479871422,
-0.5891489387,
0.8238885403,
-0.5715308189,
0.40888834,
-0.0701298341,
-0.4666504562,
0.1713661551,
0.5891699195,
-0.4445641339,
0.9576017261,
0.1509041637,
-0.8078112602,
0.4939215183,
-0.5582063794,
-0.2139860988,
-0.1633300781,
-0.0404167511,
-0.6356754899,
0.1956100762,
0.1785717607,
0.2856179178,
-0.0156113757,
0.5084167123,
-0.508477211,
-0.584122479,
0.4396192431,
-0.3305344582,
0.3389934301,
0.3172259927,
-0.1688509136,
0.7833812237,
-0.6522276402,
-0.2447049469,
0.0986703113,
-0.6119811535,
-0.1472307593,
0.1775486022,
-0.0419248864,
0.1275306791,
0.1081795171,
-0.5484477878,
0.3741379976,
-0.5348240733,
0.7656041384,
1.1694449186,
0.0835366249,
0.5521520376,
-0.3264913261,
0.6474182606,
-0.0888682753,
0.5098403692,
0.1400236934,
-0.0611344613,
-0.3815574646,
-0.5874328613,
0.3577673435,
0.5685858727,
-0.6644420028,
0.802023828,
-0.0494805872,
0.0978285819,
-0.3295232654,
-0.1770721525,
0.4293005168,
0.9415566921,
0.1882840991,
-0.3818121552,
-0.4341540039,
-0.9549373388,
-0.1028253287,
-0.4678504169,
0.1908832788,
0.336823076,
0.3613223135,
-0.1304637343,
0.9426437616,
-0.4204289913,
-0.391928345,
-0.483669579,
0.1130976379,
0.1887003481,
0.6636533141,
0.1163870841,
-0.6274292469,
-0.1061904803,
-0.1907262355,
-0.305362165,
0.0903257206,
-0.2016191036,
-0.1506005377,
0.3989929855,
0.2511632442,
-0.6086668968,
-0.1160710603,
0.4563346803,
-0.1528484076,
0.5817090869,
-0.5532941818,
0.0393624641,
-0.8948536515,
0.0932679474,
-0.2173327655,
-0.2740134895,
-0.249787882,
0.0304124597,
-0.2032410353,
-0.2533396482,
-0.274680078,
0.4601366818,
-0.0734680668,
-0.1946735829,
-0.3902220428,
0.077620171,
-0.2250553071,
0.9347326159,
0.2388653457,
0.8309116364,
0.23321338,
-0.5476056337,
0.2416591495,
0.0509629771,
-0.213173151,
0.4876392782,
-0.6520050168,
0.1340711713,
-0.1135606393,
0.3787931204,
-0.891040206,
-0.1066471562,
0.5497609973,
-0.2593127191,
0.4113906026,
-0.2331586629,
-0.491581589,
-0.2767488956,
-0.5130152106,
0.2885510921,
0.4482572079,
-0.4966380596,
0.4046662748,
0.6297755837,
0.1090479568,
-1.2158045769,
-0.1255782843,
0.0476671346,
-0.4385539293,
-0.1891542375,
0.4390133023,
0.3344185352,
-0.0019473146,
-0.0517730378,
-0.3394556642,
-0.0067119952,
0.2632841766,
0.0274780039,
0.307693243,
0.2035531551,
0.1697795838,
-0.0473785736,
-0.4423844218,
0.0441723056,
-0.7105599046,
0.4933962226,
-0.0371838659,
-0.123605676,
-0.5318613052,
0.1557850689,
0.2608603239,
-0.1184216291,
0.6279556751,
0.5491982102,
-0.0426191241,
-0.2335078716,
-0.2838209569,
-0.3317072093,
-0.4446230233,
0.4625236392,
-0.4956142902,
-1.0221056938,
0.2239599526,
-0.1806239933,
0.0848535001,
0.2538692951,
0.3004108667,
-0.1018979475,
1.0003564358,
0.6580552459,
-0.1964186728,
0.9760535359,
-0.0864418373,
-0.104200542,
-0.693670094,
-0.3803365529,
-0.3304009438,
-0.4262413383,
-0.6767976284,
-0.1864074916,
0.248395443,
0.2712467909,
-0.4282053113,
0.1979432255,
-0.4482328296,
0.307895571,
0.800753057,
0.2415654808,
0.274648428,
0.0674450696,
-0.3109152019,
0.0468678586,
-1.0891082287,
-0.3555988371,
1.0009185076,
0.5847452879,
0.6101260185,
-0.3071315587,
0.9993397593,
0.5897197127,
0.1207836121,
-0.9219308496,
0.6064478159,
0.1465929747,
-0.2321407944,
-0.3067426682,
-0.7187414169,
-1.103546381,
0.2387405932,
-0.5167185068,
-0.4526237845,
0.195276767,
0.4591104686,
-0.2361886203,
0.075146243,
-0.4984703064,
1.1250942945,
-0.225558579,
-0.5271847844,
-0.5905965567,
-0.61513412,
0.3143366575,
0.3660009801,
-0.0014042202,
-0.0849485546,
-0.2197640389,
0.6861003041,
-0.5862683654,
0.7206118703,
-0.4358435571,
-0.0856973156,
0.3594944179,
-0.0946807116,
0.7805227041,
0.1689743996,
0.2133093625,
-0.1694859862,
-0.0610888973,
-0.5208975673,
-0.5158700943,
0.6916190386,
-0.8998960257,
-0.3850143552,
-0.6183235645,
-0.4489996433,
-0.2922868431,
-0.0183255039,
-0.2031306177,
0.2355872095,
-0.3166604638,
-0.0813051462,
0.7070604563,
-0.202043429,
0.4027332962,
0.3085767627,
-0.0551065728,
-0.8963866234,
0.8523774743,
-0.3313009143,
0.0932701901,
0.8671719432,
0.5198964477,
-0.5886792541,
-0.6605338454,
-0.3024677038,
0.2510126829,
-0.4827147126,
-0.030146217,
-0.3056996763,
0.2464346886,
-0.2239224464,
0.0349374004,
-0.2933374047,
-0.5205479264,
-0.1954867244,
-0.1277329177,
0.0066961627,
0.3999525607,
-0.3112201989,
0.159863174,
-0.7078380585,
0.1947748512,
0.3916352391,
0.3735044897,
-0.0909255967,
-0.3816084564,
-0.1307790279,
-0.0191134103,
-0.2408323139,
-0.6538639665,
0.1924762279,
-0.0582264662,
0.692495048,
0.3139251471,
0.337125659,
0.6341319084,
-0.2787416577,
0.3632948399,
0.3126429319,
-0.7281904817,
0.4420815706,
-0.3390966356,
-0.1265539825,
0.6390357018,
0.1476033181,
-0.5095444918,
0.1374084204,
-0.4647554457,
-0.9009301066,
0.6898608208,
-0.0116517292,
0.1172488481,
-0.2152174264,
0.6014319062,
0.0211735871,
0.3889128566,
-0.6887193322,
0.2024822533,
-0.1805066466,
-0.3040504754,
-0.0059997723,
-0.4023263156,
-0.4674702585,
0.2066582739,
0.6337820888,
-0.2968896925,
0.1880061179,
0.3499849439,
-0.1426477879,
-0.0710387081,
0.3203305304,
0.7346730828,
0.3860758543,
-0.3738963902,
-0.0687144324,
-0.1525157988,
-0.3587988317,
0.1078076139,
0.0637237579,
-0.0934769958,
-0.5378893614,
0.3954433501,
0.831463933,
0.2513621449,
-1.0449898243,
0.4721750617,
-0.0353505947,
-0.3019885123,
-0.3735905886,
0.1160617247,
-0.470231086,
0.4128415287,
0.3716383874,
-0.2621084154,
-0.0005065915,
-0.6585534811,
0.3190783262,
0.562232852,
-0.6103247404,
-0.0500661619,
0.457123965,
0.5228068829,
-0.484611243,
0.7261320353,
-0.1352194548,
-0.560593605,
0.4706590176,
0.3745623529,
0.9873882532,
0.4023149014,
0.3370578587,
0.3058288991,
0.0542049222,
-0.191976279,
0.1610773951,
-0.5467117429,
-0.667892158,
-0.7142682076,
-0.5472652316,
-0.5421164036,
-0.0913551301,
-0.605286777,
0.0361042991,
-0.6081327796,
-0.1909078062,
-0.6325876713,
0.3284161091,
-0.1375501454,
-0.1336174607,
0.01846884,
0.7079607844,
-0.6256954074,
0.7741874456,
0.5420398116,
-0.340662986,
-0.4776114523,
0.1183516681,
-0.2528698742,
-1.0945876837,
0.6352661252,
0.013312309,
-0.0647153333,
0.0846557915,
-0.2149120271,
-0.376722753,
1.0299007893,
0.2524939775,
-0.6097129583,
-0.02374354,
-0.0704675168,
0.4013669193,
-0.4117913842,
-0.0377075374,
0.5392209291,
0.3673715889,
0.2815637589,
-0.8423042893,
-0.0470193326,
0.2447016686,
0.075332053,
0.2803638875,
-0.5805633664,
0.3970212638,
-0.1906375587,
0.0472844467,
0.1094594821,
0.8422033191,
0.6059567332,
0.2150340378,
0.6845958233,
0.7857637405,
0.5807386041,
-0.0488214754,
1.0476881266,
-0.2019351125,
0.4341968596,
0.9058179259,
-0.2038486153,
0.9462914467,
0.7838408351,
-0.197459206,
0.4646238089,
0.9186783433,
0.2865299284,
0.8722894788,
0.5673546195,
-0.3592950106,
-0.245587796,
-0.2941471338,
-0.0050586574,
0.3367247283,
-0.0634154677,
-0.0808441788,
0.0271911919,
-0.0433375947,
-0.009007629,
0.3350330889,
-0.3924776614,
1.0439081192,
-0.1747614443,
-1.0591970682,
0.4550838768,
0.0047970586,
0.7661930919,
-0.6759738922,
-0.0905515999,
-0.3757782876,
0.5640987158,
0.0346809551,
-0.7195209861,
0.271401763,
-0.2270454913,
-0.0493598767,
-0.4996869862,
0.5310745239,
-0.326210171,
-0.0155460685,
0.1577467471,
0.1519798636,
-0.1116623357,
-0.0345735289,
-0.9087433219,
-0.0216718055,
-0.2623694241,
-0.3187122047,
0.6709833741,
0.3348433971,
0.1771466732,
0.6648191214,
0.647311151,
0.1338982731,
-0.3358355463,
-0.0546993166,
0.6985698342,
-0.4539960921,
-0.6333386898,
-0.7355058193,
0.4494983256,
-0.054054074,
-0.438536346,
0.2753913105,
0.4472969174,
0.9102944732,
0.0294037331,
0.4043885171,
0.1849499643,
0.2686397731,
-0.7825905681,
0.2430550754,
-0.5619185567,
0.2150218636,
-0.09146557,
-0.8722224236,
-0.11221724,
0.7069650292,
-0.1696824878,
-0.1740422696,
0.4580314755,
0.8035193086,
0.0776892081,
-0.4094590843,
0.1208631992,
-0.2404209375,
0.2757108808,
0.7809519768,
0.8979108334,
-0.0870446265,
0.8066772819,
-0.1364036649,
-0.2805624604,
-0.3122869134,
-1.064958334,
-0.7897925973,
-0.4581533372,
-0.1613104939,
-0.4144624174,
0.391682446,
1.2592642307,
0.718242228,
-0.6145192981,
-0.3327803016,
-0.6314792633,
0.5355811119,
-0.5641674995,
-0.2401861399,
0.2638036311,
-0.5558401942,
-0.7594704032,
0.4398215115,
0.3816096187,
0.0201495346,
-0.3269366324,
-0.5193077326,
-0.1928699166,
-0.057252761,
0.4344551563,
0.5016343594,
-0.6320513487,
-0.310270071,
0.0302025527,
-0.082584098,
-0.0259850807,
1.3042675257,
-0.8209968805,
0.4205232859,
0.6561029553,
0.8675008416,
0.4893158674,
0.094761543,
0.7926473618,
-0.7338867188,
0.2535632849,
0.4535250664,
0.2375377864,
0.0271232165,
-0.190329507,
0.3097048998,
0.5161461234,
-0.6142655015,
-1.054669857,
0.5072373152,
-0.9369958639,
-0.4611388743,
0.9659934044,
-0.2665680349,
-0.0723602399,
0.0028700775,
-0.2791258097,
0.1393087357,
-0.6684268117,
1.065379858,
0.5500264764,
-0.1353619695,
-0.3526760042,
-0.1737531573,
0.5513346791,
0.582818985,
-0.4698310196,
0.0233493671,
0.5266396999,
0.0167810712,
-0.3071096241,
0.8109789491,
0.0884443521,
0.1371153295,
-0.0501173772,
-0.0674084052,
-0.5603108406,
-0.4185207486,
-0.4846943617,
0.3656644523,
0.3001898825,
-0.5338457823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18911v1
|
Kangaroo: Lossless Self-Speculative Decoding via Double Early Exiting
| 2024-04-29T17:53:54 | 2024-04-29T17:53:54 |
Fangcheng Liu, Yehui Tang, Zhenhua Liu, Yunsheng Ni, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Speculative decoding has demonstrated its effectiveness in accelerating the
inference of large language models while maintaining a consistent sampling
distribution. However, the conventional approach of training a separate draft
model to achieve a satisfactory token acceptance rate can be costly. Drawing
inspiration from early exiting, we propose a novel self-speculative decoding
framework \emph{Kangaroo}, which uses a fixed shallow sub-network as a
self-draft model, with the remaining layers serving as the larger target model.
We train a lightweight and efficient adapter module on top of the sub-network
to bridge the gap between the sub-network and the full model's representation
ability. It is noteworthy that the inference latency of the self-draft model
may no longer be negligible compared to the large model, necessitating
strategies to increase the token acceptance rate while minimizing the drafting
steps of the small model. To address this challenge, we introduce an additional
early exiting mechanism for generating draft tokens. Specifically, we halt the
small model's subsequent prediction during the drafting phase once the
confidence level for the current token falls below a certain threshold.
Extensive experiments on the Spec-Bench demonstrate the effectiveness of
Kangaroo. Under single-sequence verification, Kangaroo achieves speedups up to
$1.68\times$ on Spec-Bench, outperforming Medusa-1 with 88.7\% fewer additional
parameters (67M compared to 591M). The code for Kangaroo is available at
https://github.com/Equationliu/Kangaroo.
|
[
-0.2692404091,
-0.4784899652,
0.2305550128,
0.4822867513,
-0.5176882744,
0.3303178549,
-0.0189165641,
-0.2713935077,
0.3392491639,
0.750546813,
-0.8152062893,
-0.1215050742,
-0.6652063727,
0.3068855107,
-0.2764312625,
0.6157326102,
0.0230291225,
-0.4398132563,
0.1070186123,
-0.1377709806,
-0.4537919462,
-0.886960268,
-0.7287800908,
-0.2351267934,
0.3075219989,
0.5439288616,
0.5855759382,
0.7155037522,
0.0498668887,
0.1831267774,
-0.2695574462,
0.1570317745,
-0.659966588,
-0.1199784726,
-0.0616072342,
-0.7125455737,
-0.1356347352,
0.1421310604,
0.4848438799,
0.361640662,
-0.3008093834,
0.297955066,
-0.1852802634,
0.9180455804,
-0.6627299786,
0.3970330954,
-0.7485670447,
0.2783709764,
-0.453614831,
-0.2331926078,
-0.8793074489,
0.1883681118,
-0.6536155939,
-0.7966674566,
0.1063790843,
0.3214998841,
0.5068882108,
0.3035077751,
-0.2591006756,
0.0135138361,
-0.5278044343,
0.479667604,
-0.5149324536,
0.1648073792,
0.3818801641,
0.2823274136,
-0.237237066,
-0.8151727319,
-0.8054367304,
0.101120472,
-0.1097582057,
0.2394890934,
-0.2206113786,
-0.068515189,
0.189650014,
0.3049008548,
-0.335136354,
0.0399667509,
-0.4482576847,
-0.597446382,
0.4957803488,
0.3637996316,
0.1263392717,
-0.6311542988,
-0.4445172846,
0.1241045594,
-0.4512193203,
0.3339822888,
0.6426854134,
0.4301739037,
-0.3269966543,
0.7339590788,
-0.5041615963,
0.3716810942,
0.3169672191,
0.217657268,
0.3342090547,
-0.366524756,
-0.0564853996,
0.0764471069,
0.8868536949,
0.2808893323,
-0.2093492746,
0.0696933046,
-0.2511636019,
0.1162890494,
0.1668466777,
-0.7839540243,
-0.520463407,
0.5054622889,
-0.8067495227,
-0.456902653,
-0.3044817746,
-0.5103773475,
-0.0656465217,
0.1755620241,
0.3134072125,
-0.6958283186,
-0.6450893283,
0.4100175798,
-0.3941194117,
0.0090384427,
-0.0118608102,
-1.1651574373,
0.4499534965,
0.630361855,
0.8917555213,
0.0338148773,
-0.3682407439,
-0.8531273603,
-0.1130509824,
-0.6557155848,
0.7207324505,
-0.3577255309,
-0.4759412408,
-0.4084717035,
0.0038492163,
-0.16276972,
-0.2916514575,
0.6358068585,
-0.6654474735,
-0.08571814,
0.1258332729,
-0.2117926031,
-0.1502285153,
0.1647017747,
-0.6581454277,
1.1439421177,
0.2474247217,
-0.9266251922,
0.511680603,
-0.7443629503,
-0.5281591415,
-0.072286047,
0.0130519746,
-0.3368890882,
0.2005474716,
0.3477237225,
0.3469789922,
-0.1413839757,
-0.1406563818,
-0.3867302239,
-0.7164842486,
0.0439078696,
-0.4564656913,
0.9067920446,
0.5019361377,
-0.2940489948,
-0.1213355139,
-0.8887002468,
0.3209252357,
0.3381122053,
-0.2439526916,
-0.4013040662,
-0.3357034326,
-0.1822210848,
0.2318863273,
-0.0205547698,
-0.6899209023,
0.4393643737,
-0.3925773203,
0.6277077794,
0.5142204165,
-0.0298253801,
0.5514755845,
0.0491453297,
0.4913560152,
0.0875381231,
0.555020988,
-0.4672926366,
-0.5343000889,
-0.550396204,
-0.4787359536,
0.5255560279,
0.2283438146,
-0.6319220662,
0.3950129151,
0.069514975,
-0.4539851248,
-0.5285723805,
0.0505566597,
0.3266918063,
0.1673184484,
0.3440178037,
-0.3634444475,
-0.6142573357,
-0.6125121117,
-0.3059126437,
-0.6066516638,
0.3626824617,
0.2328944802,
0.1872972101,
-0.3120630383,
0.8623729348,
-0.3307177722,
-0.0365726091,
-0.5418223143,
0.4868436456,
0.486602366,
0.6485760212,
0.4387277365,
-0.7098223567,
-0.2664131522,
-0.206881389,
-0.892095089,
0.1900470555,
-0.3323669136,
-0.4300347567,
0.2158541381,
0.4710837901,
-0.9942290783,
0.6256483197,
0.4707894623,
-0.3670624793,
0.710378468,
-0.4251921773,
-0.1040798947,
-0.7921815515,
0.0824367553,
-0.7855079174,
-0.0585911535,
-0.3113539219,
0.2999055386,
0.5148270726,
-0.3158623576,
-0.3824340105,
0.5842243433,
-0.6802659631,
0.124178417,
-0.3747602105,
-0.1641110033,
0.3420929313,
0.1946875006,
0.0989423841,
0.9364138842,
0.4889908135,
-0.4648789465,
-0.0265329219,
0.3398083448,
0.1169348285,
-0.3444402814,
-0.2581232488,
0.2031259388,
-0.1479962319,
0.5852849483,
-0.8863030672,
-0.0472514145,
0.7746011019,
-0.4844796062,
0.2760133147,
-0.7488817573,
-0.2747995555,
-0.9548239112,
-0.1847181469,
0.7721287608,
0.8125933409,
-0.6738602519,
0.8853940964,
0.0235616975,
-0.0470686182,
-0.9805213213,
-0.7752714753,
0.5582404137,
0.0402664319,
-0.5208069682,
-0.116480276,
-0.1199614406,
0.2211710215,
0.1168033704,
0.0495484024,
0.1706835479,
-0.0776444897,
0.347964704,
0.1438096017,
-0.3551462889,
-0.1306226254,
0.3188165426,
-0.6697546244,
0.1408044845,
-0.9440867305,
0.5625832677,
0.1012614071,
-0.1856551468,
-0.5589955449,
0.4452445507,
0.727722168,
-0.4015461802,
0.9294394255,
0.5590676069,
0.0141397091,
-0.3593506515,
-0.63816607,
0.1451194882,
-0.4699940383,
-0.063004598,
-0.8983162045,
-0.3608668745,
0.8236024976,
-0.2405510694,
-0.3478733301,
0.72902143,
0.3240776062,
0.3114715517,
0.6331567764,
1.0215507746,
-0.0162900221,
0.206804052,
-0.6994571686,
0.2326787114,
-0.8553224206,
-0.4025843441,
-0.1766759902,
0.1756103635,
-0.0881642774,
-0.6916640401,
-0.1519042552,
0.4054950774,
0.088135235,
0.2705064714,
-0.5070698857,
0.4665196836,
0.4942224324,
0.0031153222,
0.3203745484,
-0.1573408544,
-0.5893015265,
0.2150259763,
-1.3028193712,
-0.1266733706,
1.3645591736,
0.1967394501,
1.0888506174,
-0.2421212345,
1.0994490385,
0.5141811967,
0.2718076706,
-0.6391325593,
0.312373817,
-0.1205849349,
-0.7096135616,
-0.3699264228,
-0.5666285753,
-0.503883183,
0.1682887226,
-0.2509133816,
-0.3326196671,
0.3269577026,
0.2811623812,
-0.6062040329,
0.517557323,
-0.7649462223,
0.9114351869,
-0.0285813008,
-0.3493996263,
-0.2077258527,
-0.637529254,
0.7461304665,
-0.364199996,
0.3612061739,
-0.2206017524,
-0.0031853188,
0.5846415162,
-0.8292239308,
0.922516346,
-0.3323698342,
0.262467593,
0.8398708105,
0.3424996138,
0.55971843,
0.4208542109,
-0.512622118,
0.3842974305,
0.0812431946,
-0.6297540069,
-0.4968925714,
0.172519654,
-0.9150631428,
-0.249187991,
-0.3327311575,
-0.1520627439,
0.2202809602,
0.4635702372,
0.7062499523,
0.7278254032,
0.0156546216,
-0.3406402469,
0.1425524205,
-0.0810182169,
0.4018216729,
0.3368384242,
-0.2971564233,
-0.3696782291,
0.8771119714,
-0.1509500146,
0.246108979,
0.2015662193,
0.3311010599,
-0.5554582477,
-0.730873704,
-0.9757551551,
0.1805866063,
-0.7676354051,
-0.2537489533,
-1.0195275545,
-0.3442085683,
-0.3049592078,
0.1400924027,
-0.7526471615,
-0.7271084785,
-0.0123365093,
0.0174915045,
0.193083182,
0.854596734,
-0.6316856146,
0.3006623983,
-0.9472139478,
0.366981864,
-0.1223545969,
0.3963623047,
0.1276409328,
-0.6280511618,
-0.2389753163,
-0.3207268417,
0.2567641139,
-0.2925795019,
0.1713329703,
0.0448467135,
0.6086211801,
0.6610503793,
0.6445323825,
0.6757413149,
-0.5617648363,
0.7837790251,
0.5709894896,
-0.8329662085,
0.3662401438,
-0.1933444589,
0.1125883609,
0.5820661783,
-0.0117374184,
-0.5340770483,
-0.3771258593,
-0.5083292127,
-0.7778832912,
0.8964681625,
0.3150238097,
0.3027482331,
-0.3514062762,
0.6685029268,
0.6517741084,
-0.032758899,
-0.4687898457,
-0.2495604306,
-0.6492943764,
0.0391028896,
-0.2545726597,
-0.5258624554,
-0.1426717937,
-0.0541326664,
0.3827122748,
-0.4800933003,
0.5177694559,
0.1798588634,
0.0501980111,
-0.3189980388,
0.0501003079,
0.0977180749,
0.1731641442,
-0.1589868963,
0.1223505735,
0.1051596776,
-0.3579615057,
0.5096397996,
0.053687688,
-0.1625726521,
-0.0098885652,
0.3414511979,
0.513638556,
0.2865398824,
-0.3672093749,
0.7363725305,
-0.7098784447,
-0.3292184472,
-0.3101237714,
0.0196300261,
-0.2023771852,
0.0356356278,
0.5008294582,
0.6926887631,
0.1630964875,
-0.5044000149,
0.2803359628,
0.1677511781,
-0.0739147663,
-0.344471097,
1.0385752916,
0.2669138908,
-0.3236567378,
0.5991845727,
-0.4149264097,
-0.458415091,
0.5167740583,
0.8270331621,
0.8614940643,
0.3800601661,
0.2720910013,
0.4390513897,
0.2781143785,
-0.2039761394,
0.3268091977,
-0.3117691875,
-0.5219163299,
-0.6156213284,
-0.6412655711,
-0.4215351939,
-0.2904583216,
-0.7092453837,
0.0119499695,
-0.5183483362,
-0.2986596227,
-0.5890860558,
-0.2499065548,
-0.714617312,
0.1975066364,
0.3607131541,
1.4069638252,
-0.6916614771,
0.5433911681,
0.3573427796,
-0.2842591703,
-1.0708072186,
0.2387154996,
-0.08927764,
-0.8848156333,
0.7142209411,
0.3671196401,
-0.4228808284,
-0.1789303273,
-0.3278136551,
-1.0344488621,
0.7679535747,
0.1559394598,
-0.3370326757,
-0.1859672219,
-0.1107160226,
0.0865891278,
-0.420888871,
0.5267685056,
0.3605843782,
0.2577637136,
0.2280305177,
-0.4227076173,
0.3392386734,
-0.4408442378,
-0.3284302652,
0.0186878815,
-1.2765284777,
0.8449735045,
-0.5856763721,
-0.3574278355,
0.5574399233,
0.7380378842,
-0.1304715723,
0.4073814452,
0.6308324337,
0.3362394571,
0.7689099312,
0.270034343,
1.138024807,
-0.677280426,
0.2895130515,
0.6786951423,
0.0109710386,
0.9824659228,
0.2525923252,
-0.043807745,
0.5573151708,
0.7523428798,
0.5828822851,
0.5657712817,
-0.1156503484,
-0.0490881205,
-0.722802043,
0.5301648974,
-0.5458942056,
0.5052694678,
0.2441204637,
0.0629737899,
0.0232795868,
0.0122521678,
-0.5132380128,
-0.1558499634,
-0.1690752655,
0.4539931118,
0.1816542745,
-0.5475453734,
0.8954312205,
-0.009108006,
0.5312212706,
-0.7531782389,
0.2722322941,
-0.4309762716,
0.1278990507,
-0.0756744146,
-0.5652556419,
0.1499180198,
-0.3014150858,
-0.1484057456,
0.0727104545,
0.7847610116,
0.0461902767,
-0.6601467133,
0.6620686054,
0.5909443498,
0.2620067596,
-0.0437080301,
-0.638733089,
0.4083218277,
-0.2420960367,
-0.3106428981,
0.0795942545,
0.8076289296,
0.2581709325,
0.8416934013,
0.9478382468,
0.0279391687,
0.1602936238,
0.1422085613,
1.2415319681,
-1.0078251362,
-1.1114697456,
-0.7631322742,
0.4284212589,
-0.0083796708,
-0.3656675816,
0.5398846269,
0.7147656083,
0.4019318223,
-0.0747488514,
0.9263993502,
0.0427574031,
0.2748205662,
-0.7264351845,
0.6646789312,
-0.6783643365,
0.1483466923,
-0.0957140103,
-0.5259779692,
-0.0832737908,
0.1118536219,
-0.1150800958,
-0.3402112126,
0.7706986666,
0.5141886473,
-0.2818924189,
0.2062562704,
0.3208361566,
0.1988735795,
0.0847412124,
0.2910247147,
1.1503415108,
-0.5059404969,
1.051905036,
-0.2209548503,
-0.4782112539,
-0.5410453081,
-0.7083121538,
-1.1217274666,
-0.0417603776,
0.1328095347,
-0.4266913533,
0.2390856296,
0.6422670484,
1.1239910126,
-0.3595479429,
0.1960270703,
-0.0662881136,
-0.0783178136,
-0.5162612796,
-0.1330226511,
0.1932617277,
-0.6109845638,
-0.0833562091,
0.6715972424,
0.4980746806,
-0.1444942653,
-0.0328479074,
-0.2874419391,
0.3711527288,
0.347958684,
0.5012773275,
0.6884074807,
-0.6998944283,
-0.1480113417,
-0.1081409529,
0.0271355547,
0.2127099931,
1.0789095163,
-1.0303424597,
0.5498720407,
0.0272316188,
0.5926749706,
0.8964569569,
0.3181200325,
0.520640254,
-0.2296300232,
0.664921999,
-0.0004826813,
0.254847765,
0.1177947149,
-0.8021762967,
0.488293469,
0.4824025929,
-0.280369103,
-0.6638881564,
0.0972856209,
-0.8738411665,
-0.175828293,
0.7485307455,
-0.1681868136,
-0.6930167079,
-0.2936686277,
-0.3614887297,
0.0627871081,
-0.4913522899,
0.5864437222,
0.3667015135,
-0.3641472459,
0.071780391,
-0.1187583059,
0.3111106157,
0.4082865119,
-0.1678428054,
0.6509746313,
-0.0373712964,
0.4660835862,
0.1320834905,
1.3738718033,
-0.1363926679,
0.346467942,
1.0075690746,
-0.0139166322,
-0.4843136966,
-0.4719565511,
-0.1995991468,
0.2200899273,
0.2081242353,
-0.2521102726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18988v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18988v2
|
Markovian Agents for Informative Language Modeling
| 2024-04-29T17:36:58 | 2024-05-23T00:00:23 |
Scott Viteri, Max Lamparth, Peter Chatain, Clark Barrett
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning could in principle enable a deeper
understanding of a language model's (LM) internal reasoning. However, prior
work suggests that LMs can answer questions similarly despite changes in their
CoT, suggesting that those models are not truly using the CoT. We propose an
reinforcement learning technique to produce CoTs that are sufficient alone for
predicting future text, independent of other context. This methodology ensures
that if the LM can predict future tokens, then it must have used the CoT to
understand its context. We formalize the informativeness of a sender to a
receiver LM as the degree to which the sender helps the receiver predict their
future observations, and we define a "Markovian" LM as one which predicts
future text given only a CoT as context. We derive a "Markovian training"
procedure by applying our definition of informativeness to a Markovian LM and
optimizing via policy gradient and Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO). We
demonstrate our training algorithm's effectiveness on fifteen-term arithmetic
problems, show the model utilizes the CoT, and externally validate that the
generated CoT is meaningful and usable by another model.
|
[
-0.4872001708,
-0.9006240964,
0.928945601,
0.0839353576,
-0.2967895567,
0.0220249705,
-0.4692917466,
-0.2061650455,
0.046680551,
0.6257950068,
-0.7682622075,
-0.4429000616,
-0.3905980289,
0.0572767816,
-0.2742043734,
1.2734405994,
-0.1657993495,
-0.055984769,
-0.1507391632,
0.2016180456,
-0.4281897843,
-0.5760724545,
-0.668746233,
-0.237606585,
0.6079174876,
0.3362514973,
0.7088839412,
0.4087588191,
0.2211347818,
0.3063691854,
-0.0279966164,
0.2927725613,
-0.2896794677,
0.3253581524,
-0.5531064868,
-0.55465132,
-0.0966402963,
-0.0830775723,
0.7761781812,
0.5178086758,
-0.254247725,
0.0022576966,
-0.2686286569,
0.6793084145,
-0.9000828862,
0.3129003942,
-0.8332337737,
0.0729403198,
0.2448515147,
-0.4691500664,
-0.8617312908,
-0.3357424736,
0.1034109667,
-0.5700246096,
-0.4039350152,
0.1851543784,
0.4502879381,
0.1608259231,
-0.5074784756,
-0.4748708606,
-0.9030722976,
0.5895419717,
-0.5371435881,
0.2214737833,
0.5053592324,
0.3405308723,
-0.5093464255,
-0.362480402,
-0.9215411544,
-0.4279059172,
0.1470712274,
0.0459137335,
-0.0104962448,
0.1881105304,
-0.0054544713,
0.0659687892,
-0.4080256522,
-0.1114695519,
-0.2973684967,
0.0719155595,
0.4504681826,
0.288484633,
0.1404328346,
0.1817471385,
-0.7423706651,
-0.1251279414,
-0.53190732,
0.0861243159,
0.4397471249,
0.1999180168,
-0.0147514325,
0.5298765898,
-0.0781480521,
0.6580892205,
-0.0093505234,
-0.0443368927,
-0.0783963874,
-0.0977015272,
-0.23340635,
0.2382068932,
0.7694869637,
-0.1503032148,
0.301428318,
-0.1709405929,
-0.5907967091,
0.2307646424,
0.4434196353,
-0.48777619,
-0.3275282383,
0.3420797586,
-0.2641804814,
-0.504077971,
0.0133673074,
-0.3288863897,
-0.2489006072,
-0.3956690431,
0.5713068247,
-0.5508659482,
-0.5092302561,
0.005808407,
-0.0694447905,
-0.145954743,
0.206028074,
-0.8366932273,
0.6100401282,
0.4540419579,
0.6839330792,
-0.1155531108,
-0.4036012292,
-0.588478744,
0.2753280997,
-0.8392741084,
0.8106325269,
-0.7346413136,
-0.2250812799,
-0.0133228377,
-0.1225594133,
-0.2153391838,
-0.2839424014,
0.0882399678,
-0.6920918822,
0.2814306021,
-0.0371715948,
-0.5467709303,
-0.1041993275,
0.3136105835,
-0.7197458148,
0.5968809724,
0.2440868616,
-0.761251986,
0.4532402158,
-0.6206111908,
-0.1109913662,
-0.0848917589,
-0.2647154331,
-0.3440293968,
0.063526094,
0.1012665108,
0.3763288558,
-0.0989405289,
0.6477511525,
-0.2889494896,
-0.2722212374,
0.8455750346,
-0.4459114671,
0.3743312061,
0.4357567728,
-0.2349776626,
0.452979207,
-0.7425491214,
0.0145225422,
-0.0380234793,
-0.4956483543,
-0.1197589189,
0.1964320391,
-0.1789245307,
0.5319088101,
0.1790843904,
-0.3513016105,
0.2116051316,
-0.3381335139,
0.1362307668,
1.0917286873,
0.2547596395,
0.5473829508,
-0.5006145835,
0.7263740897,
0.3976263106,
0.1618484706,
-0.1646770239,
-0.2551689446,
-0.8111881018,
-0.1125560552,
-0.0356207974,
0.3654451072,
-1.2416965961,
0.2790085077,
-0.0414143577,
-0.244955197,
-0.186661914,
-0.1723807901,
0.5808573365,
0.330419004,
0.1549691856,
-0.2351779789,
-0.6243742108,
-0.6605497003,
-0.3715147376,
-0.3778917193,
0.5281109214,
0.0642886013,
0.5162494183,
-0.1098518297,
0.6614593863,
-0.2291997373,
0.0796561763,
-0.4730610251,
0.0527873635,
0.3796257675,
0.4340260923,
-0.0953096971,
-0.702712059,
-0.1436596662,
0.1042525694,
-0.6144733429,
0.3793481588,
-0.2677122653,
-0.0812877417,
0.4061914682,
0.3862619996,
-0.6094959378,
0.3431555033,
0.4322936833,
-0.4338452816,
0.6007583737,
-0.6559292674,
-0.0639469177,
-0.8907224536,
-0.095042035,
-0.0370365977,
-0.3748283386,
-0.6432788968,
-0.2091361731,
-0.1213998049,
-0.0472205803,
-0.3567128181,
0.6329932213,
-0.4072527587,
-0.1266085058,
-0.4220109582,
0.1380034983,
-0.3921024203,
0.7595443726,
0.2566188276,
0.8740171194,
0.3422282636,
-1.0631594658,
0.1470878422,
-0.088584207,
-0.6179044843,
0.3254082799,
-0.2129116207,
0.0954294726,
-0.3566436172,
0.439244926,
-0.7837133408,
0.0386929139,
0.3465777934,
-0.4727400839,
0.1189814284,
-0.1020447388,
-0.4912525415,
-0.1040580571,
0.0968712941,
0.4105556905,
0.3703037798,
-0.5555074811,
0.383910507,
0.5254487991,
-0.0569644608,
-0.6659275293,
-0.2663935721,
-0.196622178,
-0.2256185263,
-0.0424717478,
-0.0205241404,
0.0556349382,
-0.3069666922,
0.0576385595,
-0.0474437661,
-0.0852397233,
0.1070642993,
0.2061164081,
0.4563846886,
0.0602039024,
0.7070998549,
0.0176818538,
-0.2845874727,
0.2840052843,
-1.0568928719,
0.6796417832,
-0.2465118319,
0.0346378163,
-0.309527576,
0.1194241419,
0.1656193733,
-0.2322636545,
1.0315088034,
0.513478756,
-0.2455785871,
-0.5343680978,
-0.2056325078,
-0.0934192389,
-0.4409688115,
0.3243736029,
-0.6508805156,
-0.5499336123,
0.107813254,
-0.204051137,
-0.2347298563,
0.4114147425,
0.7098740339,
-0.0579902977,
1.1498720646,
0.825604558,
0.0445513688,
0.7810018659,
-0.428537339,
0.1584958583,
-0.8909996152,
-0.5526934266,
-0.1742309183,
0.0174447522,
-0.8594136238,
-0.4175606072,
0.4292749465,
0.0162459537,
-0.5529188514,
0.3736530542,
-0.4004463255,
0.6019134521,
0.4782342613,
0.1747995168,
0.184164241,
-0.2678743899,
-0.4697466791,
0.550439775,
-0.7972103357,
-0.8078192472,
1.0757186413,
0.2243721932,
0.9864843488,
0.0992418304,
0.6833319664,
0.3083176017,
0.2283106893,
-0.4454179704,
0.568233192,
0.3421603441,
-0.5707239509,
-0.3899239004,
-0.6339650154,
-0.9884470105,
0.2570156157,
-0.2569055259,
-1.1745136976,
0.277820617,
0.2175527364,
0.156028837,
0.3983592689,
-0.3692855835,
0.6353590488,
-0.1771509498,
-0.3081793785,
-0.5527203083,
-0.698122859,
0.3002882898,
0.1195460632,
0.3761769533,
-0.2309303582,
-0.2891377807,
0.6963704228,
-0.5034942031,
0.6262025237,
-0.0866073221,
-0.1979248971,
0.4430355132,
0.3633059859,
0.6254323721,
0.0883441567,
-0.0148512283,
-0.4651337266,
0.2905656099,
-0.4118374288,
-0.754586339,
0.6250990033,
-0.8653543591,
-0.5225432515,
-0.5293574333,
-0.6062018871,
-0.3039565682,
0.097159259,
0.1238236055,
0.5519923568,
-0.2028403431,
-0.3058847487,
0.715446651,
-0.0120030362,
0.4356915951,
0.3136021495,
-0.5469803214,
-0.4299088717,
1.1496238708,
-0.3152561784,
0.4956554174,
0.8592869043,
0.2223168314,
-0.3922911584,
-0.2984158695,
-0.2442623675,
0.0355924256,
-1.0497062206,
0.0048476895,
-0.5346126556,
-0.0753423274,
0.0902204588,
0.0921134949,
-0.181024,
-0.5810147524,
-0.1363003105,
-0.096727252,
0.1646028906,
1.1475340128,
0.1160769239,
0.2822600305,
-0.3918543756,
0.0010793087,
-0.0126073044,
0.2145656645,
-0.0193360671,
-0.276432395,
-0.4911001027,
0.1215592325,
-0.4338552356,
-0.8995215297,
0.491415143,
-0.0733386204,
0.5145172477,
0.3663502932,
0.1111709923,
0.3806117177,
-0.3665987253,
0.4598337412,
0.2839138806,
-1.0746364594,
0.8706539869,
-0.1937969774,
0.2505723536,
0.3914378583,
0.6422922015,
-0.3774966598,
-0.6195762157,
-0.8007421494,
-0.5167577267,
0.6368154883,
0.1066248044,
-0.0551706217,
-0.4191130996,
0.1261857748,
0.2314258963,
0.4639151394,
-0.7705777287,
0.081120871,
0.1458436102,
-0.3364334404,
-0.3036109209,
-0.0272474475,
0.1410326362,
0.0561976917,
0.9180148244,
-0.2778295875,
0.4730460942,
0.2776691914,
-0.2860038877,
-0.1558973789,
0.4169193804,
0.5860204697,
0.9964832664,
-0.1794734448,
0.3307900131,
0.1736170202,
-0.1078101024,
0.3797829151,
-0.3909199536,
0.2389743179,
-0.0683626458,
0.3329969347,
1.0141935349,
0.1738029122,
-0.8199263215,
0.4978067279,
-0.0876482427,
0.0807530582,
-0.6550084949,
0.2962359786,
-0.1526289582,
0.4307194054,
-0.081176959,
0.1793114394,
0.0912380815,
-1.0412420034,
-0.0098301861,
0.3754144609,
-0.6553607583,
-0.1799543202,
0.4423747659,
-0.1387290061,
-0.4438066781,
0.4741879404,
-0.181270659,
-0.5708522797,
0.6364277005,
0.8123145103,
0.704210639,
-0.234902516,
0.2245119959,
0.1163231507,
0.1514731199,
0.0215210319,
0.5448154807,
-0.522290349,
-0.7417277098,
-0.1925396323,
-0.3347111046,
-0.5652233362,
-0.1646514088,
-0.5859537721,
0.2151831537,
-0.7294237018,
-0.2857586145,
-0.1740197688,
0.0692822337,
-0.6646772623,
0.5652003884,
0.1451210827,
0.7909013629,
-0.5316032767,
1.0687253475,
0.5141221285,
-0.6315940619,
-0.7180107236,
0.0267052427,
-0.3006950617,
-0.7411424518,
0.7580546141,
0.0690441057,
-0.4185525179,
-0.141485706,
-0.4633311331,
-0.8807911277,
1.026250124,
0.2265226394,
-0.5497501493,
-0.1296064705,
-0.294623971,
0.4403768778,
-0.7564693093,
0.5577852726,
0.3499316871,
0.1382345259,
0.0393630117,
-0.7138808966,
0.0697135776,
-0.1917777359,
0.2792750597,
0.4880694151,
-0.4033563137,
0.9619367123,
-0.5794229507,
-0.2365793139,
0.1905314028,
0.6877736449,
0.2303128839,
0.1650529951,
0.4650746584,
0.1914485991,
1.0402442217,
0.1851385534,
1.4473185539,
-0.237988323,
0.268941015,
1.2099916935,
0.0561610758,
0.9902075529,
0.498031199,
-0.0675515756,
0.9631844163,
0.5772473216,
0.4691352248,
0.8826650977,
0.5841731429,
-0.4880103469,
-0.2782099545,
-0.0595751852,
-0.151048556,
0.1973877251,
0.4761061668,
-0.4983089864,
0.2846862376,
0.0740334094,
-0.0080171917,
0.1788404286,
-0.3175811172,
1.1843155622,
0.1089541614,
-0.9200763702,
0.615252018,
0.006898067,
0.103702344,
-0.5176907182,
-0.0168945324,
0.1106225625,
0.5523899198,
0.0655687898,
-0.7616232038,
0.0444751792,
-0.231998086,
-0.1353609711,
-0.0096113989,
0.5501157641,
-0.6169977784,
-0.4050498605,
0.1917477548,
0.434907198,
0.2860846817,
0.1765466034,
-0.3561795354,
-0.0052710632,
-0.3492174745,
-0.086257562,
0.3246602416,
0.7049103975,
-0.1498696953,
1.1691051722,
0.6950557232,
0.4017881751,
-0.182766974,
-0.0893411636,
1.0301978588,
-0.7845064402,
-0.8099115491,
-0.9467899799,
0.2780093253,
0.0372372121,
-0.3315480649,
0.2959899306,
0.3583578765,
0.9740724564,
-0.0650516376,
0.771150589,
0.4112546444,
0.0864240676,
-0.9194388986,
0.4307489097,
-0.1374948174,
0.4355892241,
-0.1454463154,
-0.8939658403,
0.2613044083,
0.749546349,
-0.5488944054,
0.1455424279,
1.0787776709,
0.4924746752,
0.2800875604,
0.1953514665,
0.4434683025,
0.0458564609,
0.2721137702,
0.9936921,
1.3034676313,
-0.1405910999,
0.3441289365,
-0.2754301131,
-0.1406061053,
0.0033251226,
-0.6386883259,
-1.103007555,
-1.0267124176,
-0.0693119317,
-0.3679029644,
0.4734759629,
1.3305512667,
0.6707292795,
-0.5450932384,
-0.5123120546,
-0.5646418929,
0.45147416,
-0.1576439142,
-0.1896488219,
0.1091708243,
-0.7819850445,
-0.321500957,
0.232217297,
0.4159004092,
-0.0264004432,
-0.4414167702,
-0.2438626438,
-0.2817312479,
0.414717257,
0.4871460497,
-0.0028335257,
-0.709382534,
-0.0842839777,
-0.4395902455,
-0.0520696491,
0.0692184567,
1.0760709047,
-1.2381418943,
0.6522638798,
0.1571419239,
0.4048958719,
0.6326290369,
-0.2327002883,
0.8513506651,
-0.4082517922,
0.1734148562,
0.4417672455,
0.2991427779,
0.1020878404,
-0.5112059116,
0.1936944425,
-0.201786831,
-0.5484142303,
-0.4876271784,
0.3902333081,
-0.5427046418,
-0.5167524815,
1.059756279,
-0.2211127877,
-0.5800986886,
-0.0645940155,
-0.2611725628,
0.2546898127,
-0.4513266683,
0.6339678168,
0.5011036396,
0.0307395309,
-0.4020217359,
-0.2384482771,
0.6142380834,
0.1679277718,
-1.0888444185,
-0.1119153798,
0.2116615772,
0.0926403403,
-0.1442727447,
0.8418856859,
0.0642785504,
0.370462805,
0.1315311491,
-0.1641523391,
0.0190615002,
-0.8185201287,
-0.2677053213,
-0.3548285067,
0.3035140038,
-0.1933916807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18880v1
|
Spivavtor: An Instruction Tuned Ukrainian Text Editing Model
| 2024-04-29T17:16:22 | 2024-04-29T17:16:22 |
Aman Saini, Artem Chernodub, Vipul Raheja, Vivek Kulkarni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Spivavtor, a dataset, and instruction-tuned models for text
editing focused on the Ukrainian language. Spivavtor is the Ukrainian-focused
adaptation of the English-only CoEdIT model. Similar to CoEdIT, Spivavtor
performs text editing tasks by following instructions in Ukrainian. This paper
describes the details of the Spivavtor-Instruct dataset and Spivavtor models.
We evaluate Spivavtor on a variety of text editing tasks in Ukrainian, such as
Grammatical Error Correction (GEC), Text Simplification, Coherence, and
Paraphrasing, and demonstrate its superior performance on all of them. We
publicly release our best-performing models and data as resources to the
community to advance further research in this space.
|
[
0.2960762978,
-1.0381631851,
0.5233383775,
0.3864480257,
-0.1706718057,
0.0207792446,
-0.3112864196,
0.0307766013,
0.0764503106,
0.5688410997,
-0.6932406425,
-0.8015854955,
-0.684024334,
0.1694109887,
-0.5400121808,
1.204610467,
-0.1943481714,
0.4099924266,
-0.3277118802,
0.0346672162,
-0.636090517,
-0.4762642682,
-0.3099493086,
0.0010689204,
0.2316852957,
0.642041266,
0.4719551802,
0.7847706676,
0.4803542793,
0.4382176995,
0.0815370828,
-0.0516972952,
-0.548345089,
0.089878805,
-0.356816262,
-0.6317303181,
-0.4504938722,
-0.2560522556,
0.4963671863,
0.3617773354,
-0.3182360828,
0.1653273702,
-0.1309641004,
0.4239423573,
-0.4817441106,
-0.1617407501,
-0.5763446689,
0.0361134633,
-0.123219803,
-0.1252820939,
-0.7469971776,
-0.7247732282,
-0.1141505316,
-0.8359333277,
0.4088332653,
-0.2233200073,
0.8660185933,
0.4369620085,
-0.2853266597,
-0.5463952422,
-0.8097624183,
0.6333254576,
-0.0671523809,
0.4790737331,
0.0729938373,
0.1436393708,
-0.0300529487,
-0.9394760728,
-0.1598299891,
0.0895488486,
0.0703007728,
0.4864140153,
-0.4269215465,
0.2329724133,
0.0289196689,
0.3044353724,
-0.1928503215,
-0.0612745546,
-0.6963530183,
-0.3230926096,
0.5504027605,
0.1150601059,
0.4911105037,
0.00539352,
-0.3014703393,
0.3841300309,
-0.3047354519,
0.2663220763,
0.6540378332,
-0.0238326993,
0.1900045574,
0.6369614005,
-0.0100789638,
0.7625411749,
0.6295087337,
0.0480558164,
-0.0581953414,
-0.1799104512,
-0.4904590845,
0.0859533772,
0.4816318154,
0.4929810464,
-0.0775266737,
-0.3059112132,
-0.2270686924,
0.2514208853,
0.5376975536,
-0.7675679326,
-0.2353112102,
0.0995066389,
-0.4709283412,
-0.4295441508,
0.1955435574,
-0.7746624947,
-0.0452524014,
-0.2086065859,
0.6667020321,
-0.6235906482,
0.0107583646,
0.5728223324,
0.0393692926,
-0.14368774,
0.376713872,
-0.7265899777,
0.8013058305,
0.7935501337,
0.7724372149,
-0.2678425908,
-0.6522087455,
-0.8764435649,
-0.399987787,
-0.3604129851,
0.8815028667,
-0.9126669765,
-0.6422165036,
0.0200648271,
0.4828465879,
-0.23477,
-0.1078692004,
0.8570771217,
-0.3671942055,
0.1293572932,
0.1203877181,
-1.0515195131,
-0.0980123132,
-0.3384234607,
-0.7592080832,
1.5231497288,
0.0535101742,
-0.7234147191,
0.3941554427,
-0.7527392507,
-0.4787311554,
0.2202788442,
0.1986027062,
-0.4883708954,
0.2563585043,
-0.1065099016,
0.487423718,
0.2195594162,
0.4264020622,
0.2449799478,
-0.4166350365,
0.3702163994,
-0.0827514604,
0.7804023027,
-0.1033032909,
-0.1276440173,
0.6919823289,
-1.2010890245,
-0.2710761726,
-0.341340363,
-0.6462385058,
-0.1317159832,
0.0377615094,
0.3794926107,
0.1485642642,
0.4056718349,
-0.8482444286,
0.4021341503,
-0.1817855686,
0.2623194158,
0.7466978431,
0.1454004198,
0.7148696184,
-0.2285339832,
0.9904251695,
-0.1928595901,
0.3674796522,
0.0381516628,
-0.2313714325,
-1.0579295158,
-0.3526774347,
0.3876013756,
0.7259020805,
-0.7146858573,
0.4318014383,
-0.1127835289,
-1.0186804533,
-1.0308337212,
0.0549164042,
0.2155336887,
0.414950639,
0.247988537,
0.346619904,
-0.6098772883,
-0.854377687,
-0.5319487453,
0.4193980694,
0.2466269135,
-0.0776357353,
0.6973744631,
0.0541328862,
0.5235778689,
-0.3446971774,
0.200845167,
-0.5272704363,
0.0203420501,
0.0028072796,
0.3664782643,
0.5225912929,
-0.6629618406,
-0.8600183129,
0.1694838554,
-0.190570116,
-0.3467836678,
-0.1527161896,
-0.2934264541,
0.1025155187,
0.6835685372,
-0.3909876347,
0.5619558096,
0.6189166903,
-0.6362050772,
0.7288928032,
-0.5466205478,
0.3076345026,
-1.346015811,
0.0068709087,
-0.0236362517,
-0.4681206346,
-0.9803493023,
0.257491529,
0.5685910583,
-0.2311087102,
-0.3581787646,
0.0446528643,
-0.2431229055,
0.1534882188,
-0.0856522471,
-0.0666939691,
0.02249364,
0.1332402527,
-0.056255538,
1.136695385,
0.9124116898,
-0.4534027874,
0.4764910042,
0.4435196817,
-0.5024741292,
0.5322615504,
-0.7002361417,
0.2668388486,
-0.3272073865,
-0.1012381092,
-0.7066958547,
-0.2649047077,
0.1069571003,
-0.4409457743,
0.0614610091,
-0.2368806899,
-0.3761986494,
0.1698339581,
-0.185619697,
-0.4067013562,
0.1521254331,
-0.418361336,
0.9057375789,
0.0863659754,
-0.4039028883,
-0.6138449311,
-0.5533969998,
-0.0763092786,
-0.097491391,
-0.473097086,
0.3624254167,
-0.3333972096,
-0.0891700536,
0.0522116758,
0.1800001264,
-0.199181512,
0.1121745482,
0.4159723818,
0.6830883622,
-0.1094989032,
0.3155152202,
0.0914886892,
-0.1240270883,
-0.2465257198,
0.0132413115,
0.2543753982,
0.0731537193,
0.171025604,
-0.7514339685,
0.5425258279,
0.6600373983,
-0.6011199355,
0.7577442527,
0.3306567967,
-0.1633971035,
-0.3103161752,
-0.239597261,
0.116556637,
-0.4424878657,
0.6928114295,
-0.7026252747,
-0.6269466877,
0.5019340515,
-0.1826502681,
0.0149593819,
0.3152239621,
0.4814013541,
0.3016375601,
0.7966372967,
0.98301965,
0.132886678,
0.6800019741,
0.0445730984,
-0.0257294159,
-0.4891585112,
-0.0970533416,
-0.7120290995,
-0.1595727801,
-0.6264546514,
-0.2897785306,
-0.0518285818,
-0.2766937315,
0.2720193565,
0.3242292702,
-0.6737251282,
0.677606225,
0.3039805889,
0.1293814033,
0.0549985431,
-0.3245562613,
-0.1740873754,
-0.3573761284,
-0.8258056641,
-0.6155974269,
0.9141346812,
0.0928451121,
0.675447464,
-0.173235327,
0.46551314,
0.1012931839,
0.1087958515,
-0.9378826022,
0.4828681648,
-0.4289765656,
-0.6598540545,
0.027284598,
-0.0084727695,
-0.5590795875,
-0.0133217582,
-0.4332789779,
-0.795560658,
0.2132475972,
0.0354447663,
-0.3534050584,
0.2175504416,
-0.844927609,
1.0842648745,
0.0215773601,
-0.5475853682,
-0.1322130114,
-0.2976653278,
0.0423143618,
0.1156287268,
0.0728215054,
0.2447142452,
-0.1907723397,
0.633008182,
-0.4766157866,
0.5225970745,
-0.4750314653,
0.179499507,
-0.0572645664,
0.1604756117,
0.7129395604,
-0.1387957036,
-0.361797452,
-0.4333637655,
0.1390236616,
-0.2832829356,
-0.7537553906,
0.5064344406,
-0.8579701185,
-0.2854931951,
-0.2210369408,
-0.2841630876,
0.2122085392,
0.122966066,
0.5220384598,
0.5771895051,
-0.595071733,
0.5649772286,
0.5382701159,
-0.296689868,
0.079684414,
0.6945616603,
-0.4097024202,
-0.2492760122,
0.7071173191,
0.298271209,
0.2204305232,
0.229841575,
0.0223160479,
0.1743203551,
-0.5647757053,
-0.6341376901,
-0.1298386455,
-0.92523247,
-0.0739226863,
-0.8031522632,
-0.2260280699,
0.1122119799,
-0.510371685,
-0.57426548,
-0.3745213151,
-0.3603180945,
-0.5053856373,
0.6305880547,
0.9592843056,
0.1055836454,
0.5980096459,
-0.371014446,
0.2448697835,
0.0683670938,
0.374977231,
-0.5992707014,
-0.3739506304,
-0.5211897492,
-0.3865255415,
-0.0121928649,
-1.0486718416,
0.1930331439,
0.2312316746,
0.2124266773,
-0.0595510192,
-0.3286829591,
0.679776907,
-0.8244681358,
0.6330512166,
-0.2317836434,
-1.2615511417,
0.6105276346,
-0.1229842156,
0.3528614938,
0.6802361012,
0.3730233014,
-0.6748381853,
-0.4106560349,
-0.5507548451,
-0.4109757841,
1.0154434443,
0.2733411491,
0.162980929,
0.373187691,
0.5748782158,
0.6697654128,
-0.073110044,
-0.5568940043,
-0.2446833551,
-0.4812403619,
-0.5616025925,
0.1377197802,
-0.1907643825,
0.2706942558,
-0.3676187694,
0.9820241928,
0.1786239743,
0.0955555737,
0.2279292494,
-0.444989115,
-0.2758744657,
0.5827809572,
0.567923367,
0.6705821157,
-0.0843808204,
-0.2128804475,
0.2069175094,
-0.8027202487,
0.2212626934,
0.3019906282,
-0.6104806066,
0.3476774693,
-0.0789405853,
1.0285100937,
0.4552758336,
-0.3346652985,
0.6139341593,
-0.5840643048,
-0.2994404733,
0.0312251449,
0.2934850156,
0.207880646,
-0.0744806454,
0.263060987,
0.4219801426,
0.3552390933,
-0.2634202838,
0.1549874693,
-0.2481830269,
-0.5406330824,
-0.5741893053,
0.5045214891,
0.4148381352,
-0.8534241319,
-0.0517856255,
0.0619818643,
-0.584731698,
0.4488795996,
0.6124768853,
0.5966184735,
-0.5736582279,
0.4045732319,
0.4177191257,
0.2387461811,
0.0435240269,
0.6080027819,
0.0298357718,
-0.6785206199,
-0.411280781,
-0.5917326212,
-0.2335596532,
0.1390116364,
-1.1765362024,
0.5271162391,
-0.4681574404,
0.0137065575,
0.5032891631,
0.0689745694,
-0.6870747805,
0.3047451973,
-0.6752227545,
1.0959211588,
-0.8399618268,
0.9356354475,
0.9315119386,
-0.0456373878,
-0.6801083088,
-0.2345073521,
-0.1263494939,
-0.4129102528,
0.2816284299,
-0.0130224815,
-0.468036592,
0.3393845856,
-0.6854327321,
-0.3908030987,
0.7837205529,
0.3686719239,
-0.7740482092,
0.1444891393,
-0.2461103648,
0.3704395294,
-0.3315851688,
-0.3354402483,
0.7972263694,
0.3046677411,
-0.3990747631,
-0.529805541,
-0.2862323821,
-0.6221865416,
-0.169587791,
0.346886456,
-0.7068257332,
0.4910393059,
0.3751131892,
-0.1686378419,
0.4580408037,
0.3653101921,
-0.2009676844,
-0.1510270536,
0.1613608897,
0.2599662542,
0.838201642,
-0.0204472449,
0.9173519611,
-0.547247231,
0.3144743145,
1.302021265,
-0.1421222389,
0.8531674743,
0.3552075624,
-0.0506672226,
0.5869011879,
0.4299143851,
-0.1940465719,
0.3040703535,
-0.3362803161,
-0.3040882945,
-0.0444842763,
0.0564570241,
0.2305193394,
0.7810177207,
0.2192269415,
-0.3718100488,
0.1562564522,
0.3068538606,
0.3829541802,
0.5177876353,
-0.3471095562,
0.9869950414,
-0.6955826879,
-0.7308261991,
-0.066131033,
0.4620846212,
0.5653122663,
-0.7946578264,
0.1567294896,
-0.0394394435,
0.1479403526,
-0.2169427276,
-0.629991293,
0.3239144087,
0.6688746214,
-0.2955484092,
-0.2937238514,
1.1225527525,
-0.5536670685,
-1.1149166822,
0.2094148099,
0.1907844096,
-0.0274529122,
0.2632842064,
-0.6297124624,
0.1845526099,
0.100223653,
-0.1317327023,
-0.3523524404,
0.7786371112,
0.5489293337,
0.3267158866,
0.3862009645,
0.4364520609,
0.3029240966,
0.0972264335,
0.5844092965,
-0.6117802858,
-0.6618745923,
-0.8612405062,
0.8767468333,
-0.1089394018,
-0.4966098964,
0.8939913511,
0.7929180264,
0.6549255252,
-0.3494678736,
0.9988316894,
0.0784193575,
0.5454369187,
-0.4928219616,
0.8990539312,
-0.288910538,
-0.5364537239,
-0.0628730282,
-0.6712048054,
-0.2617880106,
0.5662882924,
-0.4145540595,
-0.3250313401,
0.6415365338,
0.9284943342,
-0.3056199253,
-0.0090907775,
0.5371710062,
0.3691724539,
-0.2093289196,
0.0299678631,
0.8296989799,
-0.6224409938,
0.4499371648,
-0.2934083045,
-0.1006773785,
-0.3224894106,
-0.4236708283,
-0.9424006939,
-0.7008517981,
-0.160116747,
-0.0390361585,
0.3539076447,
1.0388147831,
0.5347035527,
-0.559482336,
-0.1209190339,
-0.3541781306,
-0.2627806664,
-0.1077431068,
-0.2025196254,
0.2574600577,
-0.2603773177,
-0.8800338507,
0.4288749993,
0.590297997,
-0.1215123609,
-0.0527119897,
-0.0587234497,
-0.4124839604,
0.5197507739,
0.3200509548,
-0.3817831874,
-0.4986427426,
-0.260369122,
0.3270635605,
0.0396990106,
0.5617541075,
0.8079292774,
-0.2847490609,
0.9119641185,
0.1697886139,
0.4989522994,
0.5637968779,
0.0377398357,
0.7086042762,
-0.7936371565,
0.2803826928,
-0.0292487331,
0.3441970944,
0.6718375683,
-0.5748013258,
0.0939608738,
-0.1175222322,
-0.6903907061,
-0.4423441887,
-0.0235966519,
-0.559623301,
-0.1900870204,
0.8770987391,
-0.3004565537,
-0.6850460172,
-0.0473313853,
-0.8517224193,
0.6188766956,
-0.4703884423,
0.7564261556,
1.2408306599,
0.2163726985,
-0.3284040987,
-0.7655847073,
0.6458351016,
0.201349318,
-0.9772645831,
0.183630988,
0.5389108062,
0.6297901273,
-0.2183966935,
0.3320145607,
0.1296319366,
0.9110249281,
0.2340175509,
0.2455201,
0.0941100195,
-0.4488968253,
-0.7086976767,
0.0173943024,
0.0250263494,
-0.1640010178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18870v1
|
More RLHF, More Trust? On The Impact of Human Preference Alignment On Language Model Trustworthiness
| 2024-04-29T17:00:53 | 2024-04-29T17:00:53 |
Aaron J. Li, Satyapriya Krishna, Himabindu Lakkaraju
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The surge in Large Language Models (LLMs) development has led to improved
performance on cognitive tasks as well as an urgent need to align these models
with human values in order to safely exploit their power. Despite the
effectiveness of preference learning algorithms like Reinforcement Learning
From Human Feedback (RLHF) in aligning human preferences, their assumed
improvements on model trustworthiness haven't been thoroughly testified. Toward
this end, this study investigates how models that have been aligned with
general-purpose preference data on helpfulness and harmlessness perform across
five trustworthiness verticals: toxicity, stereotypical bias, machine ethics,
truthfulness, and privacy. For model alignment, we focus on three widely used
RLHF variants: Supervised Finetuning (SFT), Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO),
and Direct Preference Optimization (DPO). Through extensive empirical
investigations, we discover that the improvement in trustworthiness by RLHF is
far from guaranteed, and there exists a complex interplay between preference
data, alignment algorithms, and specific trustworthiness aspects. Together, our
results underscore the need for more nuanced approaches for model alignment. By
shedding light on the intricate dynamics of these components within model
alignment, we hope this research will guide the community towards developing
language models that are both capable and trustworthy.
|
[
-0.1922608465,
-0.4698751569,
0.7249082923,
-0.0903362855,
0.0024091261,
-0.0374113992,
-0.1770602465,
-0.8099749684,
-0.3020240963,
0.5961899757,
-0.5580151081,
-0.2387055457,
-0.5079083443,
-0.079534255,
-0.0545764677,
1.2125456333,
0.1565719247,
0.1084359139,
-0.3403428495,
-0.0938656852,
-0.2942858338,
-0.7385493517,
-0.4249602854,
-0.852848053,
0.5799854398,
0.4231359363,
1.2946639061,
0.941753149,
0.7019011378,
0.1874419898,
0.0918119252,
0.0802413598,
-0.4871614873,
0.1516959667,
-0.2002957463,
-0.4124906361,
-0.7166595459,
0.2654112279,
0.331220597,
0.4418580532,
-0.3219350576,
-0.0559556559,
0.2518231869,
0.7718482018,
-0.4332211614,
0.1423650384,
-0.4332517982,
-0.1572893709,
0.1135583594,
-0.056145329,
-0.4584304392,
-0.676997304,
0.5658954382,
-0.6515185237,
-0.20010975,
0.3401630521,
0.9989206791,
0.3972550333,
-0.356048286,
-0.2212518305,
-0.5284342766,
1.0971050262,
-0.7777770758,
0.4085595608,
0.4695802331,
-0.0428945832,
-0.2938174307,
-0.2962631583,
-0.3347764015,
-0.5990857482,
-0.0526024662,
-0.1082553938,
-0.0024279794,
0.2291941494,
0.0757701471,
0.0906857476,
-0.3033874631,
0.3918398023,
0.1275368333,
-0.4860097468,
0.6748653054,
0.1032361984,
0.2209838182,
-0.1872037053,
-0.4228284955,
-0.4142224491,
-0.6749439836,
0.2606807351,
0.7327061892,
0.3575178981,
-0.1386194229,
0.4555235505,
-0.0903415754,
0.6393166184,
0.1144333407,
-0.4382468462,
0.0231541116,
-0.3139160573,
-0.0748402402,
0.0613794886,
0.8466022015,
0.7154729962,
0.7098507285,
-0.1258425713,
-0.1550271064,
0.0617813393,
0.4652987421,
-0.5222319961,
-0.2169362009,
0.2436449975,
-0.4634849429,
-0.8267284632,
0.1144558564,
-0.393483758,
-0.5937507153,
-0.5322803855,
0.0906412899,
-0.4909667075,
-0.2555938065,
0.0194104221,
0.1903907359,
0.2382989675,
0.3175034821,
-0.85182482,
0.2051229477,
1.0439531803,
0.4455497563,
-0.4917458594,
-0.4358786643,
-0.5135169625,
0.0515511073,
-0.3822569549,
0.4319648147,
-0.6631635427,
-0.3100588024,
-0.0332804844,
-0.144465521,
0.0481028445,
-0.4078858197,
0.7364497185,
-0.5270910859,
0.3183752894,
-0.4807164967,
-0.5857345462,
-0.2142348289,
0.2954883873,
-0.5481084585,
0.9332590103,
-0.099338755,
-0.7530803084,
0.4105604291,
-0.4416999221,
-0.1971272677,
-0.3794199824,
-0.1264771223,
-0.5269189477,
0.0132465186,
0.0092651118,
0.5396910906,
-0.3067198992,
0.5909321904,
-0.7022699118,
-0.2973867059,
0.7206405401,
-0.5424776673,
0.6929528117,
0.2204697281,
-0.2746978998,
0.4270118177,
-0.5422375798,
-0.0280085672,
0.0249122307,
-0.2712677121,
-0.3378193378,
-0.096630834,
0.0809124634,
0.3037644327,
0.3975265324,
-0.2787030041,
-0.1103240997,
-0.3448801339,
0.3964057565,
1.0455456972,
-0.178074494,
0.6367254853,
-0.6350255013,
0.5159465075,
0.041905582,
0.4685209692,
0.3665460348,
-0.5012764335,
-0.3814820647,
-0.0290743262,
0.2802762389,
0.3479804099,
-0.0490446575,
0.3901731074,
-0.3057096899,
-0.2428247184,
-0.694103539,
0.1486502737,
0.7584878206,
0.8143135309,
0.2295889854,
-0.3071455657,
-0.2703749537,
-1.2781758308,
-0.3557993472,
-0.3480101526,
0.2477102876,
0.496209234,
0.1276514083,
-0.1859373152,
1.033626914,
-0.3545573652,
-0.0115242125,
0.0852154419,
-0.1009356603,
-0.1996559948,
0.4405582249,
0.4486224651,
-0.6691108346,
-0.4399780929,
0.0758086815,
-0.3599893153,
0.0147277918,
0.3195631802,
-0.0474614799,
0.5422442555,
0.2468499392,
-0.2990326583,
-0.1517485827,
0.7897622585,
-0.1667945683,
0.5093009472,
-0.2082715034,
0.1111317798,
-0.9470271468,
0.0007913986,
0.0247182511,
-0.4580086768,
-0.6202476025,
0.1856539845,
0.1505987048,
0.2872574031,
-0.4536166191,
0.3990808725,
-0.2669852674,
-0.066547662,
-0.2138651609,
0.1554322392,
-0.1107172817,
0.3895827234,
0.1121102124,
0.8471186757,
0.4243296087,
-0.4691208303,
0.1276386082,
0.0245836657,
-0.0705881789,
0.5315623879,
-0.6081680059,
0.3363412023,
0.1024062857,
0.0925819725,
-0.8008381128,
-0.3636239171,
0.3104632497,
-0.3483935893,
0.2875392735,
-0.0644715875,
-0.3222881854,
0.1614717394,
-0.4617386758,
0.2122818977,
0.5480817556,
-0.4171740115,
0.3714017272,
0.5613825917,
0.0451400839,
-0.9755688906,
-0.46599105,
-0.1088801175,
-0.4078097939,
-0.5297245979,
0.2044842243,
0.02277885,
-0.450291425,
-0.0625221282,
-0.240648061,
0.029413294,
0.3282428682,
0.3414312303,
0.5786425471,
0.0943123624,
-0.1139311492,
-0.271276921,
-0.3102819324,
0.0770488679,
-0.1363110989,
0.3531867266,
-0.4246709347,
-0.2020591944,
-0.4702378511,
0.0134938797,
0.4681658447,
-0.1242897958,
0.6815838814,
0.3900296092,
-0.1323021799,
0.0587307066,
-0.5944314599,
-0.4594664276,
-0.4374729693,
0.2715478837,
-0.1302855462,
-1.266502142,
0.2448878735,
0.2475492656,
0.1116876081,
0.2072551996,
0.3177609444,
-0.1746156812,
1.079133153,
0.7229318619,
-0.4139535725,
0.440339148,
0.427875936,
0.2137992084,
-0.6604851484,
-0.0686553642,
-0.4550471902,
-0.0789123848,
-0.9062594771,
-0.1654815227,
0.040678896,
-0.082286112,
-0.2508226037,
0.2865306139,
-0.3813938498,
0.2958912253,
0.4185388088,
0.1355973035,
0.5184968114,
-0.0781886801,
-0.1038046405,
-0.2017344236,
-0.5087277293,
-0.734095335,
1.1576992273,
0.7017332911,
0.8529990911,
0.1257161796,
0.762976706,
0.0370996445,
0.3241145015,
-0.7694140077,
0.401530534,
-0.1324308664,
-0.5417368412,
-0.4207952321,
-0.274223268,
-0.6230835319,
-0.0545490161,
-0.3287068307,
-0.6796406507,
0.0895919129,
0.5583018661,
-0.4170185924,
-0.1600450426,
-0.7863391638,
0.6927483082,
-0.3102025092,
-0.5109039545,
-0.3125856817,
-0.8771224618,
0.4960076511,
0.0086966176,
0.2581149042,
-0.2057508677,
-0.0485578068,
0.5970408916,
-0.0577075705,
0.8690666556,
0.0346528254,
-0.4615436792,
-0.1301733404,
0.1030926257,
0.7412638664,
-0.0726663992,
-0.0959516615,
0.215736419,
0.1671276391,
-0.1987665892,
-0.3952096105,
0.9532347322,
-0.8796719909,
-0.8108823895,
-0.4737633169,
-0.7390874624,
-0.5263674855,
0.295566678,
-0.1037637591,
0.0912819132,
-0.2532880008,
0.2327370644,
1.0751513243,
-0.0135353021,
0.2763859332,
0.3030875921,
-0.2732786238,
-0.2396683395,
0.7623367906,
-0.154704541,
0.5395174026,
0.3649599552,
0.2858813405,
-0.4381013215,
-0.3048297167,
-0.143091768,
0.2890314758,
-0.5838769078,
-0.0624845214,
-0.3894720972,
-0.0235853903,
-0.5499492884,
-0.1353422999,
-0.4877291024,
-0.4378478825,
-0.2500475347,
-0.2307417691,
0.4139540493,
0.6414842606,
0.1401628703,
0.0758108869,
-0.6477802992,
0.0606322065,
0.2348615378,
0.566575706,
-0.1046700701,
-0.4612656832,
-0.1228895634,
0.0600195602,
-0.1860540658,
-0.6182844043,
-0.0643023252,
-0.1845578551,
0.4603477418,
0.4168483019,
0.102506645,
0.6006079316,
-0.2160526067,
0.5530467033,
0.1505002528,
-0.7838969231,
0.074261941,
-0.4535982907,
-0.2112028599,
0.6218621135,
0.2747941315,
-0.3347281516,
-0.1622910053,
-0.595529139,
-0.4422856569,
0.7145733237,
-0.0186175499,
0.0821684748,
0.3649365902,
0.4546940327,
0.1606710702,
0.1506162286,
-0.7204710841,
-0.2262610197,
-0.1348480284,
-0.2634640038,
-0.1583271474,
-0.3952313066,
-0.4545327127,
0.1035455242,
0.7483298779,
-0.1653171182,
-0.0667426884,
0.0216521323,
0.0781362653,
-0.2630313337,
0.5740044117,
0.7216379046,
0.5878391862,
-0.2644338012,
0.0693020746,
-0.2038101852,
-0.3813690543,
0.1298082471,
0.0163350087,
-0.1673553735,
-0.7174773812,
0.2180728912,
0.6134223342,
0.2828761041,
-0.5244139433,
0.474989444,
-0.1114021093,
-0.2269710898,
-0.1360095441,
0.5006309152,
0.3368382454,
0.0470695198,
-0.0461555421,
0.0538510159,
-0.0461627953,
-0.5032442808,
0.1459875405,
0.7125746608,
-0.6445913315,
-0.1644448936,
0.5955622792,
0.0684463829,
-0.3210679889,
0.4579063952,
0.222815305,
-0.4155194461,
0.2427321225,
0.3344167471,
0.787031889,
-0.1199348792,
0.2474544346,
0.016859211,
0.2869222462,
-0.3165299594,
0.0028148319,
-0.0211730972,
-1.0608873367,
-0.2872532308,
-0.4757728875,
-0.6830185652,
-0.0323724262,
-0.8567868471,
-0.0363047682,
-0.3716286719,
-0.3241520822,
-0.2560087144,
0.2465232611,
-0.4351896942,
0.159337461,
-0.1164613739,
0.5026871562,
-0.6959547997,
1.1158938408,
0.7461768389,
-0.2623238564,
-1.0386481285,
0.3005329967,
0.1409371644,
-0.9766428471,
0.2774116099,
-0.055066824,
-0.3968469799,
-0.0168726221,
-0.5685732961,
-0.8713853359,
1.1100257635,
0.5534411073,
-0.6920667887,
0.0189273115,
0.1055812538,
0.5904077888,
-0.4390923977,
-0.0384693965,
0.6796969771,
0.6363289952,
-0.2479419112,
-0.9976673126,
0.243079707,
0.1901661009,
0.1466018856,
0.03123671,
-0.8120788932,
0.318316102,
-0.280765295,
0.0811933056,
-0.0865122229,
0.5489913821,
0.5197629929,
0.0427996255,
0.5435163975,
0.5735141635,
0.8307842612,
0.0466871858,
1.1234369278,
-0.4011085331,
0.1603788733,
1.2250680923,
-0.413579464,
0.7714655399,
0.7473607659,
-0.1033392996,
0.398775816,
0.6203977466,
0.2214094698,
0.5399702787,
-0.132912606,
0.1545647234,
-0.3914130032,
-0.2985562384,
-0.2142504603,
0.3017054498,
-0.0444952212,
-0.317691952,
0.1334398985,
-0.4092596173,
0.305631876,
0.2144387066,
0.0465191007,
0.731861949,
0.1358591765,
-1.1039646864,
0.286128968,
0.0000426376,
0.744638741,
-0.4471590817,
0.1529533714,
-0.0111151515,
0.2135280967,
-0.383382827,
-0.8790678978,
0.1386731416,
-0.1587108523,
-0.3109755218,
-0.3176914454,
0.6785627604,
-0.2564769387,
0.0224772114,
0.4652802348,
0.3090915382,
-0.1598565131,
0.198138535,
-0.8509243131,
0.1413949728,
0.1442137212,
-0.2831113338,
0.7479369044,
0.0220532194,
-0.1510310024,
0.7079210281,
0.7455958128,
0.0131440749,
-0.1455670297,
0.0686364993,
0.5151206255,
-0.46311602,
-0.2842071652,
-0.8735380173,
0.3678198457,
0.0297164209,
-0.2604268193,
0.8728034496,
0.2259143889,
0.8281757236,
0.1229923666,
0.7305210233,
0.4019433558,
0.3719094992,
-0.5017850399,
0.7011010647,
-0.2963107824,
0.254204452,
-0.3309818804,
-0.8361167908,
-0.2442353815,
0.5257344246,
-0.3450649083,
0.1793858111,
0.6148810387,
0.9860313535,
0.0782197192,
0.0784837082,
0.3704861104,
0.1371343583,
0.3328847289,
0.2673367858,
0.6781491637,
-0.1025317833,
0.4211101532,
-0.5630133748,
-0.1988887936,
-0.2337308973,
-1.2958946228,
-0.6020158529,
-0.4790700376,
-0.2950617075,
-0.3619944155,
0.1111160666,
1.0645550489,
0.6804731488,
-0.8617143631,
-0.2581484914,
-0.2132287025,
0.1787847877,
-0.2652916312,
-0.2521820664,
0.2570227385,
-0.2102782279,
-0.6026032567,
0.2295093983,
0.1439965516,
0.160533905,
-0.3039581478,
-0.5100955963,
0.0578564592,
0.1154676229,
0.2477665693,
0.2089725733,
-0.975682497,
-0.6121333241,
0.2918414176,
-0.4070664644,
0.0573274493,
0.6827126145,
-0.3515655398,
0.2552928627,
0.2660894394,
0.6008878946,
-0.0567658544,
0.3075518906,
0.830348134,
-0.3631251156,
-0.2381622046,
0.0248965193,
0.3145693839,
0.4817478061,
-0.6400725245,
0.3496803641,
-0.1353158206,
-0.8984136581,
-0.8690596819,
0.4254406691,
-0.8843220472,
-0.0781987756,
1.184825182,
-0.1145176739,
-0.1793876439,
-0.0968566611,
-0.1739588529,
0.1245917231,
-0.7378590107,
0.9249479175,
0.9365211725,
-0.4570129514,
-0.1659173667,
-0.2792309225,
0.8293596506,
0.6028301716,
-0.5432753563,
0.4067482948,
0.6855332851,
0.49376297,
0.1065682024,
0.5285035372,
-0.2566468418,
0.2385292947,
-0.5473499298,
-0.1726190895,
-0.1733932197,
-0.3341989219,
-0.6226674914,
0.0925714672,
0.6619190574,
0.1542011648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18865v1
|
Truth-value judgment in language models: belief directions are context sensitive
| 2024-04-29T16:52:57 | 2024-04-29T16:52:57 |
Stefan F. Schouten, Peter Bloem, Ilia Markov, Piek Vossen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has demonstrated that the latent spaces of large language models
(LLMs) contain directions predictive of the truth of sentences. Multiple
methods recover such directions and build probes that are described as getting
at a model's "knowledge" or "beliefs". We investigate this phenomenon, looking
closely at the impact of context on the probes. Our experiments establish where
in the LLM the probe's predictions can be described as being conditional on the
preceding (related) sentences. Specifically, we quantify the responsiveness of
the probes to the presence of (negated) supporting and contradicting sentences,
and score the probes on their consistency. We also perform a causal
intervention experiment, investigating whether moving the representation of a
premise along these belief directions influences the position of the hypothesis
along that same direction. We find that the probes we test are generally
context sensitive, but that contexts which should not affect the truth often
still impact the probe outputs. Our experiments show that the type of errors
depend on the layer, the (type of) model, and the kind of data. Finally, our
results suggest that belief directions are (one of the) causal mediators in the
inference process that incorporates in-context information.
|
[
-0.0137181981,
-0.9401216507,
1.1035211086,
0.1182621196,
0.0800331607,
-0.4742734432,
-0.1594562083,
-0.2126429379,
0.0182707366,
0.6288259029,
-0.2990384698,
-0.4664101601,
-0.6578178406,
-0.1440801919,
-0.2837063372,
0.7682073116,
0.1009383202,
0.0953534842,
-0.4582885504,
-0.1670315415,
-0.5493321419,
-0.5777103305,
-0.4405188262,
-0.1945950091,
0.6777825952,
0.4379186332,
0.6454476714,
0.4877663255,
0.3486390114,
0.3029737175,
-0.1463695914,
-0.2799156606,
-0.268833667,
0.5160890222,
-0.3368071914,
-0.9423186183,
-0.3057337999,
0.5088422298,
0.7435259223,
0.8480017781,
0.1014279127,
-0.1336306632,
-0.1623473912,
0.3126250207,
-0.7049190402,
0.1049102619,
-0.5793289542,
-0.2014627606,
0.0978820249,
-0.3680787981,
-0.6417547464,
-0.4329260588,
0.4448624253,
-0.1659262627,
0.211685732,
0.1086056009,
0.8384008408,
0.2398039848,
-1.0533014536,
-0.3277080953,
-0.7164648175,
1.0159029961,
-0.9401765466,
0.4873571098,
0.5960006714,
0.3681989014,
-0.3697814345,
-0.5735559464,
-0.5985819697,
-0.3120080531,
-0.1634381264,
0.1915236712,
0.0459857993,
0.0312302988,
0.5501379967,
0.1485187411,
-0.1799883246,
-0.0629402399,
0.0104171168,
-0.0381794535,
0.4484660923,
-0.0048006945,
-0.0289179962,
-0.2682575583,
-0.3019550741,
-0.1434502453,
-1.0545649529,
0.2345874012,
0.1562502831,
0.2482974082,
0.0095842145,
0.6968862414,
-0.2627962232,
0.8261449337,
0.2062961459,
-0.4466454387,
0.037135765,
-0.4545719326,
-0.2645736933,
0.1763884127,
0.4871889651,
0.478679657,
0.0570858754,
-0.0088156592,
-0.2490079999,
0.2449618578,
0.2399965823,
-0.661175251,
-0.0169147216,
0.0233238265,
-0.2847960591,
-0.2633526027,
-0.0211323798,
-0.3425908089,
-0.4145427346,
-0.2566741705,
0.3986827135,
-0.2504447699,
-0.1860105246,
0.0924087688,
-0.0410921946,
0.4110682607,
0.4516578019,
-0.7390004396,
0.2093905807,
0.6148726344,
0.5091071725,
0.0460341349,
-0.3134149909,
-0.6518413424,
0.1840709001,
-0.4882774353,
0.8533521891,
-0.727278769,
-0.4278869033,
-0.0023327128,
0.1110711247,
-0.0624707378,
-0.3422262073,
0.8031064272,
-0.6888501644,
0.5567789674,
-0.9108108282,
-0.9398578405,
-0.473885566,
0.2965477109,
-0.4527360797,
0.6027665734,
-0.059187755,
-0.8848030567,
0.6069325209,
-0.3907223046,
-0.6006116867,
-0.3245024383,
-0.5815169811,
-0.0393477827,
0.2482683063,
-0.1348999739,
0.5528454185,
-0.2671123743,
0.3949509859,
-0.3425849378,
-0.2802135646,
0.5911694765,
-0.5928934216,
0.553471446,
-0.160667628,
-0.7481931448,
0.1794199795,
-0.6559685469,
-0.1794620007,
0.1108239889,
-0.3237221837,
-0.6363437772,
0.5296373963,
-0.3243578076,
0.2041000873,
-0.1850972176,
-0.6100840569,
0.1710163504,
-0.338149339,
0.0954453424,
0.7627540231,
0.1012058184,
0.4711197913,
-0.1374399662,
0.3076893985,
0.1080729067,
-0.114850916,
-0.1252245158,
-0.5997954011,
-0.7614389658,
0.2385527939,
0.1088201776,
0.2554468811,
-0.3587751091,
0.2975554466,
-0.112551108,
-0.2038419098,
-0.1375445426,
-0.4606601298,
0.4154982269,
1.1284356117,
0.2708306313,
0.1343834847,
-0.3158601224,
-0.9712311625,
-0.2718501091,
-0.5071969628,
0.1735652238,
0.506763339,
0.5693325996,
-0.1250257194,
1.1152899265,
-0.795271337,
-0.0223183483,
-0.0281193331,
0.1589478701,
0.3647053838,
0.3049077392,
0.5845299959,
-1.1947481632,
-0.1277697533,
-0.3305219412,
-0.6843460798,
-0.3177940547,
-0.0440810584,
0.1916704774,
0.2870243788,
0.5311182141,
-0.3745336831,
0.5300998688,
0.8630807996,
-0.701343894,
0.7051643133,
0.1185001731,
0.3249374032,
-0.9562662244,
-0.1080688387,
0.0411836766,
-0.1493697613,
-0.6029632092,
-0.1748791188,
0.0617549196,
0.7643694878,
-0.2124753445,
0.5048600435,
-0.0517059565,
-0.0817390382,
-0.4662135243,
0.1960768551,
0.2267774493,
0.2374978811,
0.4034766555,
0.8622872233,
0.3541853428,
-0.7549409866,
0.269407779,
0.0657110214,
-0.267675817,
0.6905976534,
-0.7306946516,
-0.0261952002,
-0.0873883739,
0.1665904224,
-1.1655139923,
-0.0830445513,
0.2001065314,
-0.5218746662,
0.1027731076,
-0.2945874333,
-0.3570977449,
0.0716813505,
0.1238109991,
0.4005034566,
0.2438348383,
-0.4799727201,
0.5201070309,
0.3953653276,
-0.0072332737,
-0.7075383663,
-0.8327085376,
-0.0956858918,
-0.3699114919,
-0.4064838886,
0.2595044374,
-0.1252153814,
-0.7679837346,
0.0433112197,
-0.1953465044,
0.0434339941,
0.2563843727,
0.4574622214,
0.287689209,
-0.2910014093,
0.3275815845,
0.0285761543,
-0.0533747859,
0.5008637309,
-0.4498317242,
0.2353404015,
-0.2579170167,
-0.6591123939,
0.2240032405,
0.1549999267,
0.425998807,
-0.0380848311,
0.8434372544,
0.0101611344,
-0.3468906581,
0.0427190289,
-0.8024563789,
-0.2367774695,
-0.4591130316,
0.1315383315,
-0.5243706107,
-0.9876604676,
0.526540339,
-0.0114219896,
-0.2584063113,
0.4042716622,
0.5162675977,
-0.1322612315,
1.015835166,
0.5039870143,
0.0220244359,
0.1441039145,
-0.0769484043,
0.315230459,
-0.8877259493,
-0.1305148602,
-0.6141105294,
0.1111320257,
-0.6934521198,
-0.2646668255,
0.5013046861,
0.0665388554,
-0.0422747023,
0.0267375074,
0.1243142635,
0.427857399,
0.4309291542,
-0.124017112,
0.2757614553,
-0.4676594734,
-0.4557985961,
-0.1933814734,
-0.6854655743,
-0.6288043857,
0.9662455916,
0.2947476208,
0.6529229879,
0.3646404445,
0.2682141066,
-0.1163886562,
0.3163957894,
-1.0732212067,
0.4334854782,
0.3104777038,
-0.8476833105,
-0.2766820192,
-0.3129535615,
-0.7156808972,
0.3806418777,
-0.101683937,
-0.6442851424,
0.3256294429,
0.049815286,
-0.2990261912,
0.1641175449,
-0.5884271264,
0.8128671646,
-0.2389781773,
-0.6312775016,
-0.1099462956,
-0.7113547921,
0.137052685,
-0.0061660833,
0.0977977663,
0.0626564324,
0.2425279617,
0.7127066851,
-0.0886224732,
0.993332386,
-0.2424562275,
-0.3854475319,
0.1515543461,
0.2692060769,
0.4048724771,
0.0701480135,
-0.1011805236,
-0.0777929053,
0.0743318796,
-0.2583105862,
-0.76000911,
0.6285588741,
-0.3712827265,
-1.0104970932,
-0.5372880697,
-0.5634472966,
-0.4696720541,
0.363180846,
0.2541625798,
0.4929986,
-0.3515443802,
0.3109518588,
0.9110880494,
-0.3205367029,
0.2178862095,
0.80109936,
-0.3225063086,
0.1941892207,
0.2731085122,
0.1502931416,
0.5196504593,
0.5455342531,
0.4991896152,
-0.5630365014,
-0.5100565553,
0.0810159221,
0.3195662498,
-0.9298844934,
0.014944667,
-0.3318896294,
0.0380172655,
-0.4706477523,
-0.068211928,
-0.4475620091,
-0.1156801507,
-0.0309163686,
-0.4445878267,
0.2280068845,
0.7438221574,
0.0207504332,
0.1995754093,
-0.5552853942,
-0.1254339516,
0.4306305945,
0.2456572056,
-0.292144388,
-0.5355947018,
-0.2291687727,
0.2351350337,
0.0783120617,
-1.0460908413,
0.2528285384,
-0.2042564303,
0.5039350986,
0.5102692842,
0.0899192095,
0.3917610347,
-0.4938723743,
0.7365888953,
-0.1454173177,
-1.0574886799,
0.749694407,
-0.5004674792,
0.2301998287,
0.3481370509,
0.3523016572,
-0.7941169143,
-0.4464305341,
-0.5493872762,
-0.3709689081,
0.4149796367,
0.0169590712,
-0.0360829793,
-0.1842309535,
0.463121593,
0.1026512608,
0.321158886,
-0.6608213186,
-0.2253070176,
-0.1280658245,
0.1861517578,
-0.2907929718,
-0.5185632706,
-0.3151746988,
-0.1490116715,
0.2605893016,
-0.3854643404,
0.271917522,
0.4339727759,
0.0321270749,
-0.173036471,
0.3577741683,
0.7419061661,
0.8657951355,
-0.372117579,
0.5938399434,
0.0996848717,
-0.1422864944,
0.1133186445,
-0.1883422583,
-0.3874032199,
-0.0393100865,
0.7261305451,
0.8198644519,
0.2701174915,
-0.2976329327,
0.86531955,
-0.1089547798,
-0.0033281464,
-0.3587326407,
0.0448140465,
-0.0147027066,
0.3865576684,
0.2213480473,
0.0659071133,
0.2941524684,
-0.6205210686,
0.2239845395,
0.4260736108,
-0.2685126662,
-0.5591370463,
0.5881121159,
-0.180173263,
0.1063036099,
0.4897005558,
-0.1272623092,
-0.8829630017,
0.5782230496,
0.7660545707,
0.7636476755,
-0.4313673079,
0.1414528489,
0.1705118865,
0.1351653934,
0.0240376629,
0.2562866211,
0.1605487168,
-1.2624636889,
-0.6595081091,
-0.2734703124,
-0.3398656547,
0.0420647711,
-0.6000877619,
-0.0187537447,
-0.2405101508,
-0.1910120398,
-0.1761834621,
-0.0534773394,
-0.398766309,
0.5361997485,
0.1198583394,
0.8126267791,
-0.9719212651,
1.0927319527,
0.5827556849,
-0.3343490958,
-1.0155974627,
0.4049950242,
0.1683750153,
-0.6305064559,
1.05677104,
0.0758848637,
-0.5961883068,
-0.353666693,
-0.656280756,
-1.0866910219,
0.8923151493,
0.2811336219,
-0.3432311714,
0.0930450335,
-0.0562666915,
0.6134442687,
-0.4327974916,
0.2804739177,
0.3999067247,
0.564710319,
0.2679177225,
-0.8032379746,
0.2214362174,
-0.0056987708,
-0.1863169521,
-0.0832811967,
-0.4835568368,
0.9960184693,
-0.3317927122,
-0.1282602251,
-0.204114452,
0.6388397217,
0.2886246145,
0.2455263436,
0.5987775326,
0.3801964223,
0.7455451488,
-0.1396757513,
1.2818278074,
-0.1597715914,
0.2780870497,
1.0808331966,
-0.3206154406,
0.8224995732,
0.6411644816,
-0.0303166062,
0.658313632,
0.5285514593,
0.2258443832,
0.7014628649,
-0.0667332038,
-0.0163235031,
-0.0917831659,
-0.4396541119,
-0.275582999,
0.5305188894,
0.4963286519,
-0.2798159122,
0.1502342373,
-0.2842409909,
0.2778496742,
0.0977199376,
0.0645736977,
0.393081218,
0.0873704702,
-0.837777853,
0.402543515,
0.075256452,
0.3289207518,
-0.5442586541,
-0.2073484808,
-0.2796526849,
0.1496584564,
-0.1760301739,
-0.9786098599,
0.2847445011,
-0.3382834792,
-0.2196422964,
-0.2290879041,
0.7962906361,
-0.2997409999,
-0.1312587559,
0.5718092322,
0.5515398979,
-0.1335700601,
-0.1160091758,
-0.277462095,
0.0097371303,
-0.0698596463,
-0.5282819271,
0.0929879323,
0.4415988922,
-0.0265731551,
0.5615119934,
0.4687905014,
0.3041798472,
-0.0731266364,
0.1412475705,
0.8154157996,
-0.7389981747,
-0.3944833279,
-0.8240144849,
0.260995239,
0.1617760509,
-0.1155114323,
1.0815454721,
0.190671578,
0.8605983257,
0.2792723775,
0.7062627673,
0.1583512872,
0.5730130672,
-0.8756138086,
0.4462450743,
-0.5205286145,
0.3574682176,
-0.3140074909,
-0.8390886784,
-0.3368311822,
0.8268256783,
-0.9334385395,
0.1474772692,
1.0085799694,
0.6766545773,
0.0880445689,
0.1469917595,
0.3240474164,
0.5314196944,
0.3819725215,
0.3181072474,
1.1274987459,
-0.2854207456,
-0.1430506557,
-0.1597054005,
-0.3431707323,
-0.1719419658,
-0.9640344977,
-0.6992999315,
-0.7570314407,
-0.1933977306,
-0.5056553483,
-0.1517410576,
0.5416800976,
0.6526497602,
-0.8263258934,
-0.3518453538,
-0.1700612307,
0.3414075971,
-0.0182512794,
-0.2658378184,
0.3875763416,
-0.1634626091,
-0.5988928676,
0.6176418066,
0.2425029278,
-0.0372297131,
-0.2305087149,
-0.1970099509,
-0.3608388305,
0.1031999514,
0.6456366181,
-0.0735350549,
-0.8904029131,
-0.7388241887,
0.2164080143,
-0.320543915,
0.0552126914,
0.6670899391,
-0.8374844193,
0.3894120157,
0.5041929483,
0.4596496224,
0.2508202493,
-0.1055579558,
0.9031255245,
-0.6411575675,
0.0360579491,
0.2452506423,
0.5750000477,
0.2282842696,
-0.464946866,
0.3932013512,
0.4725012481,
-0.6368879676,
-0.6876454353,
0.6558995843,
-0.7523326874,
-0.4513338208,
1.3696842194,
-0.3120464683,
-0.1882236153,
0.1637067646,
-0.0641399175,
0.1867030263,
-0.1637613475,
0.598164618,
0.8482494354,
-0.1536006182,
-0.0732682645,
-0.6245832443,
0.4383176267,
0.6882651448,
-0.4543257356,
-0.0298738517,
0.8359693289,
0.2206754386,
0.2820645273,
0.4749067128,
0.0626549572,
-0.0201457981,
-0.0326141752,
-0.3261513114,
0.3906553388,
-0.4676318169,
-0.3675211072,
-0.014006136,
0.3736147285,
-0.0233447812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18851v1
|
A Comprehensive Rubric for Annotating Pathological Speech
| 2024-04-29T16:44:27 | 2024-04-29T16:44:27 |
Mario Corrales-Astorgano, David Escudero-Mancebo, Lourdes Aguilar, Valle Flores-Lucas, Valentín Cardeñoso-Payo, Carlos Vivaracho-Pascual, César González-Ferreras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rubrics are a commonly used tool for labeling voice corpora in speech quality
assessment, although their application in the context of pathological speech
remains relatively limited. In this study, we introduce a comprehensive rubric
based on various dimensions of speech quality, including phonetics, fluency,
and prosody. The objective is to establish standardized criteria for
identifying errors within the speech of individuals with Down syndrome, thereby
enabling the development of automated assessment systems. To achieve this
objective, we utilized the Prautocal corpus. To assess the quality of
annotations using our rubric, two experiments were conducted, focusing on
phonetics and fluency. For phonetic evaluation, we employed the Goodness of
Pronunciation (GoP) metric, utilizing automatic segmentation systems and
correlating the results with evaluations conducted by a specialized speech
therapist. While the obtained correlation values were not notably high, a
positive trend was observed. In terms of fluency assessment, deep learning
models like wav2vec were used to extract audio features, and we employed an SVM
classifier trained on a corpus focused on identifying fluency issues to
categorize Prautocal corpus samples. The outcomes highlight the complexities of
evaluating such phenomena, with variability depending on the specific type of
disfluency detected.
|
[
-0.1465364844,
-0.8811807036,
0.2598868906,
0.5418843627,
0.0452488549,
0.5257311463,
-0.3312270641,
-0.0992696136,
0.5835789442,
0.5019385219,
-0.2014206648,
-0.6937625408,
-0.5714503527,
-0.0401823334,
-0.320707947,
1.1603393555,
0.2069845498,
0.5149650574,
-0.030764455,
0.0319649093,
-0.7654734254,
-0.3844750524,
-0.388181746,
-0.0098308381,
0.2879517376,
0.628002286,
0.8567755222,
0.3257908523,
0.7639474273,
0.380848527,
-0.2529089749,
-0.0432453156,
-0.1279329211,
0.4922508597,
-0.1347748488,
-0.0066894563,
-0.8725865483,
0.2848009169,
0.6886051297,
0.8889916539,
-0.3362399042,
0.1786288619,
-0.0406842344,
0.3593989015,
-0.1052221358,
0.0136819221,
-0.2853308916,
-0.0134035237,
-0.5984051824,
-0.2362489402,
-0.0200871993,
-0.4961494505,
0.1057929099,
-0.7232718468,
0.2132834792,
-0.4657143652,
0.7198126316,
0.2874342203,
0.0832270458,
-0.4793696702,
-0.3941473365,
0.7429125905,
-0.705962956,
0.3474082649,
0.7367699146,
0.4194667935,
-0.2557626963,
-0.5940946937,
-0.3303386271,
-0.8975899816,
-0.0993009657,
0.22620444,
0.1312991381,
0.2002931833,
-0.0005084964,
0.4915829301,
-1.0269151926,
0.0918387175,
-0.4254377186,
-0.7437772751,
0.6325261593,
0.135605529,
0.5684250593,
-0.2078850865,
-0.1035339832,
0.0357047841,
0.0121915163,
0.0664308369,
0.547226727,
0.6325846314,
-0.0612189025,
0.2835702002,
0.1402859539,
0.5029232502,
-0.0886567384,
-0.8401039243,
0.6032041311,
-0.3668307066,
-0.0532775708,
-0.0498101003,
0.5377658606,
-0.0469937362,
0.2187985629,
-0.3698887825,
-0.0804924071,
0.0871333107,
0.4188725352,
-0.2585584521,
-0.4801164567,
0.279207319,
-0.128948763,
-0.2908192575,
-0.2517638505,
-0.765530467,
-0.5453387499,
-0.6594855785,
0.4753508866,
-0.6547569036,
-0.350243628,
-0.3084354699,
-0.1982797235,
-0.2816723883,
0.3072762787,
-0.7031103969,
0.4805917144,
0.5711753368,
0.806532383,
-0.1443061978,
-0.23460567,
-0.6841107607,
-0.2548435926,
-0.2706369162,
0.6758273244,
-0.8249623775,
-0.2538675368,
-0.2267863154,
-0.2260402441,
-0.3194151223,
-0.7341442108,
0.8957426548,
0.0030177997,
-0.1237403974,
0.0799554959,
-0.5521191955,
-0.0894095153,
-0.1195402667,
-0.6146508455,
0.8709212542,
0.5815874934,
-0.5509978533,
0.417345047,
-0.5777062178,
-0.688493073,
0.5091680288,
-0.2686183751,
-0.3103420138,
-0.0674887449,
-0.2351661175,
0.4427855611,
-0.0242115129,
0.5982350707,
-0.0085763289,
-0.2736187577,
0.6665999889,
-0.0027351989,
0.6311110258,
0.1768164933,
-0.2049306929,
0.2023376077,
-1.0723954439,
0.0995720923,
-0.6077894568,
-0.2793803513,
-0.0819668993,
-0.3520806134,
0.1144225001,
0.0149070881,
0.0135146137,
-0.4130811095,
-0.1783927679,
-0.2788246572,
0.5338492393,
0.2545604706,
0.1365718991,
0.0765473172,
-0.3706900477,
0.6383956671,
0.1883586198,
0.2511064708,
0.1257344335,
-0.5805844665,
-0.514092803,
-0.8156278133,
0.6030319929,
0.5822988153,
-0.1424351484,
0.5452356935,
-0.0139745409,
-0.7234472036,
-0.6507070661,
0.1469863951,
0.6382661462,
0.835025847,
0.6378525496,
-0.602001667,
-0.5146811604,
-0.7342115045,
0.0023724523,
-0.1169455424,
-0.0616055354,
0.1211546436,
0.4762926996,
0.0144621646,
0.5891379118,
0.082171835,
-0.9783371091,
-0.0573078953,
0.4230027795,
0.196995303,
0.6702862978,
0.1147192642,
-0.5989031792,
-0.2831786275,
0.0355742797,
-0.1934652328,
-0.3751561046,
0.0883994773,
0.0031161057,
0.1212122813,
0.0308159497,
-0.3733549714,
0.4373128414,
0.5631039143,
-0.2368158549,
0.8080370426,
-0.0864679664,
0.4515566826,
-0.5687425137,
0.237279132,
0.1510665566,
-0.0821766183,
-0.8452773094,
-0.2635130584,
-0.2256609797,
0.0225763898,
-0.0996675864,
0.0319990218,
0.0978121832,
-0.0855543464,
0.1725822687,
0.5637217164,
0.1821179241,
0.1346597075,
0.0662116557,
0.7918595076,
0.6839861274,
-0.532394588,
0.329167366,
0.1750570238,
-0.1006675363,
0.8445082903,
-0.4729581475,
-0.0421151072,
0.2369323522,
0.1659787297,
-1.1837030649,
-0.456281215,
0.1500555128,
-0.9103216529,
0.6582568884,
0.0072854855,
-0.2314046621,
-0.1496621221,
-0.1684885323,
0.1063827425,
0.3634694219,
0.1203873381,
0.2247030884,
0.9458070397,
-0.2795232534,
-0.447781235,
-0.7142736316,
0.0465849228,
-0.3898611367,
-0.7351074219,
0.3956859708,
0.1776578724,
-0.3332034051,
-0.4046226144,
-0.0301764831,
-0.4493654072,
0.1826792508,
0.2508489788,
-0.0305556376,
-0.148113817,
0.3297655582,
-0.2259085923,
-0.2525602281,
-0.2010980099,
0.1540609151,
0.284989357,
-0.1103628278,
0.0171888024,
-0.6682014465,
0.0139343608,
0.3773716688,
-0.1491780877,
-0.0724176019,
0.70306319,
-0.2875562906,
-0.0296260603,
-0.531802237,
-0.0835134536,
-0.3222187757,
0.3439757526,
-0.4122240543,
-0.5000747442,
0.8487992287,
0.1563803703,
-0.3583463132,
0.170267418,
0.5358722806,
-0.3242874146,
0.7185822725,
0.2052405775,
0.352024585,
0.217134878,
-0.1193040833,
0.001854424,
-0.9190924168,
-0.2149254531,
-0.7677868605,
-0.1990760714,
-0.5561573505,
-0.7164501548,
0.1179228351,
0.0483783856,
-0.1066614613,
0.3988995552,
-0.9200925827,
-0.0034471995,
0.2208157033,
0.0623667501,
0.2629099488,
-0.2106754482,
-0.2226535976,
-0.5366668701,
-0.2317399979,
-0.8384733796,
0.9796747565,
0.7062371373,
0.4924956262,
0.1842542142,
0.630392909,
0.5424435735,
0.4678254426,
-0.7422885299,
0.5097802877,
-0.3015762269,
-0.9318701029,
-0.6351775527,
-0.4718731642,
-0.8323628306,
0.2345633954,
-0.0170288756,
-1.2156666517,
0.2967206538,
0.0754444897,
-0.5246111155,
-0.1667553186,
-0.4786203802,
0.8995779157,
-0.3859844208,
-0.1828046441,
-0.1193286479,
-0.7636470795,
0.4029848278,
-0.1681000441,
0.2804503739,
-0.4502694309,
-0.0440681353,
0.9982444644,
-0.1978381127,
0.5957767367,
-0.2628293335,
0.0031588539,
0.1628406793,
0.2509746253,
-0.1833355427,
0.1035984904,
-0.2149172574,
0.3145436049,
0.3244161606,
-0.0650636554,
-0.3869778812,
0.4161216617,
-0.7114930749,
-0.3639490604,
-0.4772355556,
-0.4276137054,
-0.4999230802,
-0.0503694899,
-0.087086007,
0.4930457771,
-0.4104427099,
0.0303473715,
0.5310638547,
-0.203150481,
-0.0268423166,
0.4720680714,
-0.1032770574,
-0.5885811448,
1.3293031454,
0.481449157,
0.082323879,
0.2280951589,
0.3470031023,
-0.4348498881,
-0.8500674963,
-0.3350031078,
0.1857251972,
-0.7715284824,
-0.2744455338,
-0.3411596715,
-0.1713819355,
-0.6000367403,
0.2825539112,
-0.1587084234,
-0.5077115893,
-0.4114551842,
-0.0294209607,
0.2247664183,
0.4347396493,
-0.3903768361,
0.1251014322,
-0.451908946,
0.4468500316,
-0.0836540312,
0.2005794048,
-0.341763556,
-1.052388072,
-0.0461609177,
0.0018751856,
-0.5004906058,
-0.9235903025,
0.6061588526,
0.3486770689,
0.6507176161,
0.1611641198,
0.0205055419,
0.874248445,
-0.0630514175,
0.819473803,
0.2134521306,
-1.099014163,
0.6997769475,
-0.0872480869,
-0.2716817856,
0.8382887244,
0.3125933111,
-0.3735373914,
-0.945356369,
-0.8015387058,
-0.781591177,
0.5655372143,
0.2724764049,
-0.2651980221,
-0.0245383363,
-0.0066232714,
0.306889981,
-0.0243221875,
-0.2700633109,
-0.084972769,
-0.3648394942,
-0.1613245457,
-0.1324436963,
0.0562416986,
-0.6677681208,
-0.4525149763,
0.640050292,
-0.0512585267,
-0.0671378747,
0.4228054881,
-0.3656990528,
-0.0434327312,
0.4804883599,
0.7705981731,
1.087192297,
-0.3854876757,
-0.0292590056,
0.1274354607,
-0.9592690468,
0.2034884244,
0.3934076726,
0.0642458051,
0.3016925454,
0.4034283459,
0.3820130527,
0.1112323925,
-0.6922314763,
0.705821991,
-0.0468339212,
-0.2495728135,
-0.4264109731,
0.0316859595,
-0.0589841492,
0.0529873557,
0.4363110065,
-0.0598664246,
0.4353528023,
-0.3313843012,
0.2850715816,
0.3146136403,
-0.5056397915,
-0.220248431,
0.2225062251,
0.3709587753,
-0.5126726031,
0.2823856175,
-0.2159824073,
-0.2846471369,
0.5177265406,
0.2086875588,
0.705088079,
-0.3679091334,
0.6370684505,
0.1665966064,
0.2011335343,
0.4291324317,
0.3649002016,
-0.1313791722,
-0.2405632436,
-0.5276318789,
-0.9411222339,
-0.5971200466,
0.3955957592,
-0.604778707,
0.1598482579,
-0.4430603385,
-0.4926322401,
0.5880213976,
0.3639643192,
-0.4276374578,
0.6572309732,
0.2722250819,
0.5570986271,
-0.6826471686,
0.8636894226,
0.7957804799,
-0.7472513914,
-1.0544937849,
-0.112725839,
0.0555568002,
-0.7671091557,
0.9893535972,
0.0584945939,
-0.0654632673,
-0.244368732,
0.0959693342,
-0.7830988765,
0.8974550366,
0.297062546,
-0.4821163714,
0.4627223909,
0.2530203462,
0.9631832242,
-0.26755476,
0.699950099,
1.0588563681,
0.8099539876,
-0.0382686071,
-1.4568326473,
0.1032481045,
0.076854676,
-0.0334442034,
-0.2504526377,
-0.1047597975,
0.6260228753,
-0.2336005867,
-0.5081948638,
0.298656702,
0.1757263541,
0.3418146968,
0.4828184247,
0.1880925596,
0.6082325578,
1.1223458052,
-0.2945774794,
0.446072489,
-0.1366671324,
0.1402314454,
0.7686467767,
-0.1268759221,
0.6730177402,
0.3741934597,
-0.3786714673,
0.3776653409,
0.5868854523,
0.1842702478,
0.1566690356,
0.6800635457,
0.0950179026,
-0.1634724438,
-0.2092678398,
-0.4890822768,
0.4515593648,
0.75793612,
-0.2822519541,
-0.0261182562,
-0.0224095173,
0.0739337727,
0.3590704501,
-0.1752377599,
0.6742966771,
-0.0573523641,
-0.6295596361,
0.6406775713,
-0.363522768,
0.3804453909,
-0.3240400851,
-0.0910906941,
-0.2921259403,
0.1545101702,
-0.6658021212,
-0.9893910289,
0.374541074,
-0.1938211471,
0.0900947526,
0.0256311744,
0.4098232985,
-0.4171746373,
-0.3673196137,
0.0953341722,
0.3115379214,
0.700619638,
0.3068833351,
-0.7648330927,
0.2819091082,
-0.2756314278,
-0.1645411402,
0.2350869328,
0.3135502934,
0.0447603427,
0.6128441691,
0.5150028467,
0.2963643074,
-0.2159596533,
0.572401762,
0.708409965,
-0.5326495767,
-0.2892580032,
-0.4316636622,
0.7632208467,
-0.0837583169,
-0.7048999071,
0.5628288984,
0.1173148602,
0.3953463435,
0.3275960386,
0.4890424013,
-0.02362841,
1.0505242348,
-0.205570668,
0.522336185,
-0.2786941528,
0.24121508,
-0.6089574099,
-0.5717113018,
-0.7070948482,
1.0426814556,
-0.466350764,
-0.0026810186,
0.7564091682,
0.9497061372,
0.1782101542,
0.1825980544,
0.5698195696,
0.1823266894,
0.1876059771,
0.3601639569,
1.0087808371,
-0.1208572388,
0.5812026858,
-0.2983079553,
-0.6377518773,
-0.3814768493,
-0.6079660654,
-0.611176908,
-0.6836063266,
-0.6232813001,
-0.6019624472,
0.4066076279,
0.5177108049,
0.7409150004,
-0.8406086564,
-0.2361431867,
-0.0309670679,
0.1434207261,
-0.4399574399,
-0.3223751783,
0.4048146605,
-0.6744267941,
-0.2961145043,
0.4327647984,
0.362102896,
-0.0807959065,
-0.4428992271,
-0.0884731933,
0.0165659003,
-0.1101330668,
0.1558813155,
0.3380469084,
-0.792386353,
-0.1419178545,
-0.2940370142,
-0.2880172729,
0.1555420309,
0.6534478664,
-0.6238005757,
0.4040295184,
0.4293329716,
0.1243484914,
0.0106806578,
0.2082267702,
0.2630651295,
-0.6472854018,
-0.0811195374,
1.1669442654,
0.0603457838,
0.6100980639,
-0.08909408,
0.3939300179,
0.069833979,
-0.7953926921,
-1.0763610601,
-0.0596421026,
-1.1536191702,
-0.0655101016,
1.0648021698,
-0.4396961927,
0.0032799658,
-0.6639339924,
-0.360622555,
0.2782810628,
-0.4852155745,
0.7115461826,
0.5639513731,
-0.5694518685,
0.1482577026,
-0.5884115696,
0.7766418457,
0.4038301408,
-0.4418281317,
0.0226042662,
0.5325002074,
0.2922588885,
0.682695508,
0.5726278424,
-0.362893492,
0.4331983626,
0.0445984751,
-0.0443576202,
0.1720848083,
-0.3643175066,
-0.3712501228,
0.0948145688,
-0.0042069689,
-0.163599968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18848v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18848v3
|
FeDeRA:Efficient Fine-tuning of Language Models in Federated Learning Leveraging Weight Decomposition
| 2024-04-29T16:42:26 | 2024-05-25T06:55:19 |
Yuxuan Yan, Qianqian Yang, Shunpu Tang, Zhiguo Shi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite their exceptional performance on various tasks after fine-tuning,
pre-trained language models (PLMs) face significant challenges due to growing
privacy concerns with data in centralized training methods. We consider
federated learning (FL) to fine-tune PLMs in this paper. However, the
substantial number of parameters in PLMs poses significant difficulties for
client devices with limited communication and computational resources. One
promising solution is to exploit parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) into
FL, which trains a much smaller set of parameters than full parameter
fine-tuning (FFT). Although remarkably improving training efficiency, PEFT
methods may lead to degraded performance especially when data across different
clients are non i.i.d, as revealed by experimental results. To overcome this,
we propose FeDeRA, which extends and improves a widely used PEFT method, i.e.,
low-rank adaption (LoRA). FeDeRA follows LoRA by decomposing the weight
matrices of the PLMs into low-rank matrices, which allows for more efficient
computation and parameter updates during fine-tuning. Different from LoRA which
simply initializes these low-rank matrices by random sampling or zeros, the
proposed FeDeRA initializes these matrices by the results of performing
singular value decomposition (SVD) on the pre-trained weight matrices.
Extensive experiments across various tasks and datasets show that FeDeRA
outperforms the considered PEFT baselines and is comparable to or even
surpasses FFT method within the FL setting in terms of task performance.
Moreover, FeDeRA requires only 1% trainable paramentes compared to FFT,
significantly reducing training time costs by more than 90% to achieve the same
task performance level. The experimental results also highlight the robustness
of FeDeRA against data heterogeneity, as it maintains stable task performance
even as data heterogeneity increases.
|
[
-0.5043466687,
-0.709518373,
0.2341273427,
0.2513311803,
-0.1764068156,
0.0834989622,
-0.3543990254,
-0.2064235359,
-0.14282839,
0.4112114608,
-0.618373692,
-0.3528804183,
-0.4712943733,
0.0642779768,
-0.2709294558,
1.1037234068,
-0.0529832281,
-0.0346785672,
-0.3243516982,
-0.4164606929,
-0.1245771945,
-0.2570069432,
-0.5285407901,
-0.4373633862,
0.5292352438,
0.5851249099,
0.3475834727,
0.5276449323,
0.6882671714,
0.3561686873,
0.1405164897,
0.1773377955,
-0.8709805012,
0.2116155773,
-0.2353458554,
-0.6240612864,
-0.6023139358,
0.2500027716,
0.8768414855,
0.9685190916,
-0.1461878866,
0.4543034136,
0.1432774961,
0.7665391564,
-0.7682006359,
0.3847171366,
-0.4850610495,
0.1290631294,
-0.411672771,
-0.3364708126,
-0.4632482231,
-0.1193462014,
0.0508026369,
-0.579723537,
0.2508020699,
0.1504159421,
0.8315141201,
0.540928483,
0.0556809492,
0.3030299246,
-0.9962155223,
0.7547345161,
-0.4076966345,
0.4740262628,
0.1794213802,
0.3213650882,
-0.149752304,
-0.6957428455,
-0.2678945363,
0.1834978163,
-0.1468018591,
-0.1812815964,
-0.4293287694,
0.1679554582,
0.347322762,
0.7279657125,
-0.3834822178,
0.3372037411,
-0.0407550596,
-0.0111750094,
0.4721667469,
-0.0264294688,
-0.0531323217,
0.3855031431,
-0.2547828257,
-0.316948086,
-0.7442038655,
0.2409318089,
0.5137389302,
0.748321712,
0.0444036983,
0.3197490275,
-0.5197601914,
0.6714377999,
0.5607293248,
-0.380332917,
0.3142486215,
-0.0930468962,
-0.5892785788,
-0.2846632004,
0.585460484,
-0.121996589,
-0.021196777,
-0.3997536898,
-0.4110395908,
-0.0763180479,
0.0481526628,
-0.9316368699,
-0.2005850524,
-0.0032085795,
-0.5155369043,
-0.2720020413,
0.0431699753,
-0.4680386484,
-0.1065742746,
-0.2601139247,
0.5251148939,
-0.3441797793,
-0.1601537764,
-0.0015604658,
0.3045168221,
0.2767386138,
0.4417117238,
-1.0313597918,
0.6133992076,
0.9832116365,
0.6364790201,
-0.0930801257,
-0.3803074956,
-1.3121166229,
-0.2805965245,
0.0807104856,
0.7434307337,
-0.3766135871,
0.0155378403,
-0.2867731452,
0.1410604864,
-0.4374246597,
-0.4052170813,
0.3780209422,
-0.4106446207,
0.5005860925,
-0.2884888649,
-0.5345431566,
-0.0903524458,
0.1609523743,
-0.5267400146,
0.6980751157,
0.417899549,
-0.7799307704,
0.3798146248,
-0.7950095534,
-0.5750652552,
0.1091273949,
0.0467242785,
-0.7512331009,
0.2132702023,
0.2941090763,
0.6809841394,
-0.3937841058,
0.1409772635,
-0.3775117695,
-0.6336898804,
-0.3924600482,
-0.1137559935,
0.635702908,
0.3326093554,
-0.4686622918,
0.1575405747,
-0.761567235,
0.0112209115,
0.1303340495,
-0.3127494752,
-0.5076209903,
0.1322790235,
-0.0341057964,
0.0654768124,
0.1322989762,
-0.600769639,
0.1129054427,
-0.8366257548,
0.2111240178,
0.7916045189,
-0.2267045081,
0.7318270206,
-0.4572916627,
0.6055987477,
-0.1155256107,
0.2114489675,
0.0657172576,
-0.0033415803,
-0.8003506064,
-0.2848027647,
0.3644925952,
0.2228187472,
-0.7083113194,
0.2782808542,
-0.3849692643,
-0.5178061724,
-0.6080251932,
0.2819977999,
0.4736766219,
0.6483961344,
0.260245502,
-0.06918744,
-0.3490893245,
-0.7481760383,
-0.2434096783,
-0.0578815639,
-0.1009764448,
0.2481126934,
0.2999565601,
-0.1071745455,
0.9070709348,
-0.3277173042,
-0.5392980576,
-0.0585795641,
0.2281743735,
0.0985795036,
0.6212158799,
0.8745911717,
-0.5931811333,
-0.6047357917,
0.1151455194,
-0.2594744861,
-0.1704356074,
0.0820540264,
0.1454803199,
0.3500068486,
0.0531741716,
-0.0291767456,
-0.0426738299,
0.7914487123,
-0.4166422784,
0.2300481498,
-0.2528501749,
-0.0232061166,
-0.8275094628,
0.3176122308,
-0.0931728259,
-0.3999818861,
-0.4421657026,
0.2341013551,
-0.2276044339,
-0.181524992,
-0.2640955746,
0.2497653514,
-0.3436423242,
-0.2127508372,
-0.2921179533,
-0.2861735225,
-0.1005666852,
0.6471853852,
-0.1747230738,
0.9198278785,
0.5901721716,
-0.1825955659,
0.0527101755,
0.2147723734,
-0.1383656412,
0.8213812113,
-0.5807982087,
-0.0096499091,
-0.1084668413,
0.1032381877,
-0.6980394125,
-0.140492171,
0.1963653713,
0.0060078567,
0.1744252145,
-0.1666386724,
-0.6913443208,
-0.0886790231,
-0.2390150279,
0.1070619524,
0.4845219851,
-0.7157312036,
0.5965825319,
0.4202888906,
-0.0140306996,
-0.5727271438,
-0.3785575032,
-0.5300406814,
-0.2544178963,
-0.6798158884,
0.3026447892,
-0.1397794932,
-0.2515582144,
-0.2586483955,
-0.2826008797,
-0.0153649589,
0.4282352626,
0.4583453238,
-0.1110825837,
-0.41833812,
0.0965690613,
0.3666720986,
-0.1373721808,
-0.0704544261,
-0.1650492847,
0.5486282706,
-0.7001654506,
-0.3038396537,
-0.313318938,
0.2763317227,
0.6708853841,
-0.4998738766,
0.9847872853,
0.8908137679,
-0.2639379501,
-0.4546993375,
-0.4787965417,
-0.2304117978,
-0.4867489636,
-0.1425430775,
-0.3937537968,
-1.2281267643,
0.6595016122,
-0.2849705517,
0.3087505102,
0.3215687871,
0.4105448127,
-0.2598881125,
0.9313026667,
1.0884418488,
-0.2523822486,
0.7580782175,
-0.3053140938,
0.0252322722,
-0.4441938102,
0.0216981191,
-0.5562823415,
-0.5749887824,
-0.6137093902,
-0.3177560568,
0.2905950546,
-0.170817852,
-0.2942380309,
0.2563944161,
-0.4083461165,
0.4729966223,
0.5192738771,
0.0715033486,
0.3860283196,
0.1736023426,
-0.0676523149,
0.1817523539,
-0.7980885506,
0.0433326475,
0.957315743,
0.4412887096,
0.8119614124,
-0.2266983539,
0.9114432931,
0.116205506,
0.3880958259,
-0.6206570268,
0.3206632137,
-0.3800245225,
-0.2092849314,
-0.267637223,
-0.6626574993,
-0.7428350449,
0.3693048954,
-0.3323491812,
-0.5929825902,
0.4184467494,
0.1937801987,
-0.5796818733,
0.2789066136,
-0.7289478779,
0.7016346455,
0.0216038693,
-0.4668045044,
-0.2168998718,
-0.5930382609,
0.2721294463,
-0.1495711952,
-0.1309809536,
-0.1825307906,
0.2382973433,
0.9370371103,
-0.7671739459,
0.6638902426,
-0.5188084245,
-0.1425701678,
-0.2353798896,
-0.2679560781,
0.6495411396,
0.1151627675,
-0.1311225295,
0.0252706986,
0.0573561043,
-0.4908013642,
-0.4783238769,
0.9409318566,
-0.878108263,
-0.3575125933,
-0.3084124327,
-0.7381780148,
-0.4488438666,
0.3650443554,
0.0473635271,
0.3237638474,
-0.1206177175,
0.5430544615,
0.7427641153,
0.1078602076,
0.398886323,
0.8414852619,
0.0550252311,
-0.2083933651,
0.7595874071,
0.0372287482,
0.1313617975,
0.5372315049,
0.0983757898,
0.061702352,
-0.73126477,
0.1387639642,
0.3515385687,
-0.3575283885,
-0.4292282164,
-0.3927054107,
0.0458595455,
-0.2026137114,
-0.3151041567,
-0.8326246738,
-0.2112765759,
-0.3285546303,
0.0833370313,
0.3552030027,
0.1164010689,
0.0187235959,
0.7738698721,
-0.3877382278,
0.0961971283,
0.2391947359,
0.8358200192,
-0.3385978937,
-0.1826621741,
-0.2876412868,
0.1200320348,
0.0708458275,
-0.1841601431,
0.2789801359,
0.4752812386,
0.5398464799,
0.5558595061,
0.3453096151,
0.8791801333,
-0.1935854554,
0.1849979013,
-0.1839890927,
-0.8715189099,
0.4427525401,
-0.5243631005,
0.2914696634,
0.9764294028,
0.120063439,
-0.0731863379,
-0.4215068519,
-0.6745185256,
-0.5253772736,
1.0937387943,
0.2718915939,
-0.2015283406,
0.5181195736,
0.191522643,
0.2997190356,
0.1273222566,
-0.4962610006,
-0.3526368141,
0.0091692125,
0.068037264,
-0.2067439258,
0.0754196495,
-0.2168847471,
-0.5943324566,
0.5960043669,
-0.4398387372,
0.257718116,
-0.1828897297,
-0.2383088619,
-0.6035480499,
0.1530623287,
0.5138834715,
0.5667184591,
-0.3812511265,
-0.0767199323,
0.0137693454,
-0.3227594197,
-0.0183224455,
0.6659815311,
-0.2073530406,
-0.1473411024,
0.1738946438,
0.9365065098,
0.5202909708,
-0.5799433589,
0.3790694475,
-0.2806927562,
-0.2937937379,
-0.009234746,
0.3558385372,
-0.2320521921,
0.3383120298,
0.3685847223,
0.3706455827,
-0.2423663139,
-0.3435507417,
0.3064403832,
0.4919026494,
-0.1034775525,
-0.5048604012,
0.6523740888,
0.3485593498,
-0.0808721781,
0.4168336689,
-0.0586544685,
-0.1569379121,
0.1795615256,
0.3432183564,
0.7178941369,
-0.402050823,
0.3472473323,
0.0451470092,
0.2485785484,
-0.2617489398,
0.300484091,
-0.3718983829,
-0.5263344049,
-0.4758342206,
-0.9475408196,
-0.3331525326,
0.19684726,
-0.7680892348,
0.0757369176,
-0.683210969,
0.084058933,
-0.0772417784,
0.5304076076,
-0.7920509577,
-0.1247917116,
0.1330938786,
0.8560736775,
-1.0938760042,
1.0728526115,
0.6413522959,
-0.2057899088,
-0.8569456339,
-0.1322440505,
-0.2799538374,
-0.5511086583,
0.2721867263,
-0.0471977256,
0.0091094999,
0.3299387693,
-0.3760116994,
-0.8193204403,
1.2464650869,
0.821757853,
-0.5061607361,
-0.1569887549,
0.2735416591,
0.6706678271,
-0.430562675,
-0.1270153373,
0.6805052161,
0.5239278674,
0.0133822085,
-1.0931328535,
-0.0316437557,
-0.1704545766,
-0.1367790252,
0.2874263227,
-0.7039825916,
1.1153697968,
0.1082886606,
-0.2642573118,
-0.1292580366,
0.6890807152,
-0.0835103169,
0.2839033008,
0.6727414131,
0.5287789702,
0.8652848601,
-0.2208956778,
0.7808400989,
-0.1811244488,
0.6755216718,
1.0981873274,
-0.3341217041,
0.6976590157,
0.5873519182,
-0.1067663506,
0.4569706917,
0.2796678543,
-0.055208087,
0.5680558681,
-0.2263195068,
-0.0769773796,
-0.2402932793,
0.1196036562,
-0.2365007997,
0.8839735389,
0.206689477,
-0.5137680173,
-0.7445805669,
0.4350487292,
-0.0134562682,
0.164858833,
-0.4423689246,
0.7463130951,
-0.137828216,
-0.5318464637,
0.8287210464,
0.1390812695,
0.7066576481,
-0.5825198293,
0.2668250203,
-0.4107305706,
0.5488684773,
-0.1818817407,
-0.100541845,
0.3981476724,
-0.0099953758,
-0.2709271014,
-0.7554857731,
0.7336511612,
-0.4170684516,
-0.3341974616,
0.0525031239,
0.6332841516,
-0.2908284068,
-0.2504367232,
-0.5965561271,
0.1320939064,
-0.2355506569,
-0.3167218864,
0.7172513008,
-0.0442408845,
0.0780958682,
0.6441259384,
0.6277139783,
-0.0813968107,
-0.2367527038,
-0.2293158472,
1.0403937101,
-0.0776026547,
-0.6513185501,
-0.5764179826,
0.1872196794,
0.14805004,
-0.1052804142,
0.8240522742,
0.4253267348,
0.9663510323,
-0.124541223,
0.3557425737,
-0.1313205957,
0.5067769885,
-0.1840761155,
1.1609436274,
-0.5267273784,
0.2034099996,
-0.3851687014,
-0.7536934018,
-0.3349858522,
0.5893540978,
-0.4794823527,
-0.3097499013,
0.4500659108,
0.5169397593,
-0.3459239006,
0.0553814098,
0.1826395094,
0.0653457716,
0.2713578343,
0.5800441504,
0.0948559418,
-0.4521135092,
0.3293265998,
-0.7168192863,
-0.1239749789,
-0.4464254975,
-0.6179232001,
-0.8887367845,
-0.7366401553,
-0.335852176,
0.2149315476,
0.0835987702,
0.8159022331,
0.8955028057,
-0.9082695246,
-0.0364978276,
-0.1246725768,
0.21390751,
-0.6575906873,
-0.2317694426,
0.2306779325,
-0.3277230561,
-0.842279017,
0.5131699443,
0.1362979561,
-0.1398466527,
-0.4331952035,
-0.1642909497,
-0.109731108,
-0.2715540826,
0.5629190803,
0.4210364521,
-0.4259684682,
-0.3747668266,
-0.0950533152,
0.0935394913,
0.0155563233,
0.7044893503,
-1.0881931782,
0.3212237358,
0.6174402833,
0.6932581663,
0.372024864,
0.2321078479,
0.7030857801,
-1.0919938087,
0.3411774635,
0.3477176726,
0.3809667826,
0.1189443469,
-0.3206305802,
0.4369429052,
0.2096030563,
-0.4767127335,
-1.169914484,
-0.1621000022,
-1.0972175598,
0.0148652447,
0.6811292171,
-0.4186983109,
-0.371309787,
0.2613824904,
0.2063101977,
0.1634573191,
-0.2444654852,
0.7050619125,
0.3713717461,
-0.1067540795,
-0.3067170382,
0.0017323807,
0.6245296001,
0.3863153756,
-0.8153087497,
0.1145833284,
0.4148165584,
0.4623748362,
-0.0238864832,
0.581564486,
0.1326547116,
0.2561052144,
-0.2707220018,
-0.3114457726,
-0.5628608465,
-0.3584644198,
-0.4546164572,
0.610619843,
-0.0553488433,
-0.1663394719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18832v1
|
It's Difficult to be Neutral -- Human and LLM-based Sentiment Annotation of Patient Comments
| 2024-04-29T16:19:47 | 2024-04-29T16:19:47 |
Petter Mæhlum, David Samuel, Rebecka Maria Norman, Elma Jelin, Øyvind Andresen Bjertnæs, Lilja Øvrelid, Erik Velldal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentiment analysis is an important tool for aggregating patient voices, in
order to provide targeted improvements in healthcare services. A prerequisite
for this is the availability of in-domain data annotated for sentiment. This
article documents an effort to add sentiment annotations to free-text comments
in patient surveys collected by the Norwegian Institute of Public Health
(NIPH). However, annotation can be a time-consuming and resource-intensive
process, particularly when it requires domain expertise. We therefore also
evaluate a possible alternative to human annotation, using large language
models (LLMs) as annotators. We perform an extensive evaluation of the approach
for two openly available pretrained LLMs for Norwegian, experimenting with
different configurations of prompts and in-context learning, comparing their
performance to human annotators. We find that even for zero-shot runs, models
perform well above the baseline for binary sentiment, but still cannot compete
with human annotators on the full dataset.
|
[
-0.394554317,
-0.2171225548,
0.6666148305,
0.0911386237,
-0.575062573,
0.0975279585,
-0.3707895577,
-0.7015613317,
0.3853052557,
0.5330227613,
-0.4887144864,
-0.4532524049,
-0.7017862201,
0.4424726069,
0.1202831864,
1.2429639101,
0.01521926,
0.61484164,
-0.2922900617,
-0.5264123082,
-0.096269384,
-0.9811319113,
-0.4632011354,
-0.6057799459,
0.7516971827,
0.3614451587,
0.6821497679,
0.00483735,
0.6187113523,
0.1712528914,
-0.170580402,
-0.1073560491,
-0.3274461925,
0.1705417037,
-0.1367094815,
-0.2533305585,
-0.5562187433,
0.2320405394,
0.282474339,
1.149481535,
0.2712376118,
-0.0823033899,
-0.0531653799,
0.6612484455,
-0.3215667903,
0.0847513378,
-0.3201654851,
0.3727756441,
0.0012573976,
0.0172329284,
-0.34415856,
-0.4218653142,
0.4321468174,
-0.4626635015,
0.1431318074,
-0.2352570742,
0.8255126476,
0.2457320541,
-0.3256572783,
-0.2948765457,
-0.626522243,
1.0580381155,
-0.8295986056,
0.1925039142,
0.2576068044,
0.1004323065,
0.0956247151,
-0.2221755236,
-0.4147940278,
-0.4384079874,
-0.1314523965,
0.0799935311,
0.0477124304,
0.2220299244,
0.2805286348,
0.1755417436,
-0.0627685115,
0.1786444932,
-0.0699049234,
-0.2471755445,
0.7628696561,
0.1135668457,
0.2702692151,
-0.5018971562,
-0.4965161681,
0.3899523318,
-0.6690470576,
-0.08926709,
0.096866712,
0.486946553,
-0.2128248066,
0.6531127095,
-0.2665904164,
0.5423537493,
-0.1865602732,
-0.1501045078,
0.4620550871,
0.2681072354,
-0.1232535243,
-0.084967643,
0.7851839662,
0.6966432929,
0.3830114007,
-0.3511834443,
-0.2969753146,
0.3740498424,
0.2510409951,
-0.9190163016,
-0.3563925922,
0.3199232221,
-0.508828938,
-0.5460931063,
-0.0747642517,
-0.7973735929,
-0.6960409284,
-0.365531683,
0.1900770068,
0.003397553,
-0.2359801978,
-0.0163304489,
-0.0531079546,
0.1172600985,
0.5517283082,
-0.5588068366,
0.3490792215,
0.5719337463,
0.8044533134,
-0.1041113809,
0.1130207479,
-0.3571566343,
-0.3279336393,
-0.3616443276,
0.7854946256,
-0.4799040258,
-0.6620740294,
-0.0822671428,
0.0334447883,
0.3133336306,
-0.6091376543,
0.5431191325,
-0.3933552802,
0.4615773559,
-0.6388178468,
-0.6575132012,
-0.2127507031,
0.3715991378,
-0.4937944412,
0.561377883,
0.6221938729,
-0.9437234402,
0.2886449993,
-0.7352910638,
-0.3748093545,
0.3093630672,
-0.3324543834,
-0.2462503314,
0.3373057544,
0.1829554737,
0.6765083075,
-0.412602365,
0.3266597092,
-0.5755995512,
-0.2775695622,
0.5561649203,
-0.0287028439,
0.925717473,
0.1163573042,
-0.3208821714,
-0.0912094116,
-0.5097021461,
-0.2940465212,
-0.1225593239,
-0.3852211833,
-0.3520724177,
0.0549466684,
0.1566168964,
0.4399887323,
0.0750855133,
-0.817779541,
0.2617471814,
-0.5546884537,
0.2400141209,
0.7465523481,
0.1930883527,
0.4428749681,
-0.285046339,
0.7092020512,
0.0491178893,
0.2849084139,
0.243715927,
-0.7222790122,
-0.6227475405,
-0.4725200236,
0.4169187844,
0.5825362802,
-0.8461835384,
0.0872929916,
-0.2657006681,
-0.2879709303,
-0.7493149638,
0.2748963833,
0.4110437334,
0.8895700574,
0.3397229314,
-0.5757141709,
-0.4741218984,
-0.9084652066,
-0.3563144505,
-0.3025051951,
-0.0538119674,
0.3640859425,
0.4039077163,
-0.4926484227,
0.8059279919,
-0.4281303287,
-0.1281113029,
-0.144753173,
0.2216603011,
0.1504336298,
0.1918134987,
0.296893388,
-0.4420665503,
-0.5803969502,
-0.0624491572,
-0.951336503,
-0.3695687652,
0.1141206324,
0.1181526035,
0.2593714595,
0.3482619524,
-0.456684947,
0.144737497,
0.423266232,
-0.140617609,
0.2533490956,
0.118379876,
-0.0010472436,
-0.8217398524,
0.2187836766,
0.1713836193,
-0.1726983488,
-0.9286628366,
-0.058102563,
-0.1660134643,
-0.1798221022,
-0.5049389005,
0.7306293249,
-0.39556247,
0.3066759706,
-0.3636897802,
0.0528712571,
0.0353195071,
0.3251578808,
0.1486669481,
0.4509707689,
0.4606620967,
-0.2151970416,
0.1747899503,
0.2023064643,
-0.220693782,
0.7904187441,
-0.6018876433,
0.1277530789,
-0.3600785732,
0.2275677919,
-0.7329494953,
-0.5857081413,
0.5176561475,
-0.4708112776,
0.2166185528,
-0.3238651454,
-0.2336432785,
-0.1233777627,
-0.5433270931,
0.281080991,
0.5325347781,
-0.3004265428,
0.3880042434,
0.6692895889,
-0.3823326826,
-0.5578627586,
-0.8175989389,
0.4070198536,
-0.2155237794,
-0.2758462429,
-0.0236123055,
0.1129669845,
-0.5415728688,
-0.0092515061,
0.3693317175,
-0.0462399386,
0.1752084345,
0.4439271092,
0.3533746302,
-0.0199684873,
0.3783387244,
-0.1880304217,
-0.3388575613,
0.201318115,
0.0392873734,
0.1660336554,
-0.0375307761,
-0.2604806721,
-0.6287336349,
0.6443920135,
0.596193552,
0.0964463502,
0.5577337742,
0.1636242568,
-0.5529218912,
-0.08360219,
-0.5744318366,
-0.2122736126,
-0.3676913381,
0.1409205049,
0.205572322,
-1.0509128571,
0.3268362582,
-0.0119758034,
0.0290945452,
0.4111525714,
0.5156138539,
-0.3011221886,
1.1286386251,
0.3962771297,
-0.2540187836,
0.1348901242,
0.011156274,
0.1778005213,
-0.8503732681,
-0.0819780454,
-0.4309231043,
-0.2989220917,
-0.7165687084,
-0.5156139135,
0.5272299051,
-0.0950542167,
-0.1428170055,
-0.395865798,
-0.6059161425,
0.0881627351,
0.2364723831,
0.2092222273,
0.0665111095,
0.0186542012,
0.1790521741,
-0.3179148138,
-0.4677330256,
-0.612408042,
0.9192745686,
0.5953786969,
0.5848827362,
-0.1489711404,
0.7748706341,
0.0473350845,
0.9558998942,
-0.9872608185,
0.5937904716,
-0.38721174,
-0.584600389,
-0.0341886841,
-0.4604797363,
-0.5858720541,
0.0929130539,
-0.381344825,
-0.4389977753,
0.2801099122,
0.1490968913,
-0.6460549831,
0.3977155983,
-0.6530610919,
0.5199762583,
-0.081733115,
-0.2086274028,
0.4207548201,
-0.7800601125,
0.0922051966,
0.0651236996,
0.3253162503,
-0.3337624371,
-0.221727252,
0.7099792361,
-0.6475540996,
1.1907309294,
-0.8001329303,
-0.0536441617,
0.2737364173,
-0.0552970096,
0.2420582026,
0.0196460094,
-0.2130903006,
0.3068055212,
-0.4591971934,
-0.4666593969,
-0.4073412418,
0.6249163747,
-0.92947191,
-0.4121522009,
-0.5758725405,
-0.2760714293,
-0.5833677649,
-0.0475195646,
0.1822966784,
0.3173917532,
-0.1449943632,
0.0136628151,
0.5085502863,
-0.3800058961,
0.1673182547,
0.2950981259,
-0.1413052529,
-0.6280807853,
0.8077045083,
0.3109638095,
0.0619731061,
0.2173695862,
0.458101809,
-0.3142102063,
-0.4855699539,
-0.4406990111,
0.3811668456,
-0.7921219468,
-0.2256327868,
-0.7973333001,
-0.0198652335,
-0.1299386919,
-0.3670645356,
-0.0803881958,
-0.6244363189,
-0.6052730083,
-0.1738212109,
0.5491966605,
0.8766796589,
0.0414771028,
0.3609447181,
-0.7244520783,
0.3228977621,
0.4364786446,
0.5030869246,
-0.0680876151,
-0.2125942558,
-0.1573209316,
-0.1054169014,
0.0642857179,
-1.0997730494,
0.2377990186,
-0.0411044396,
0.0860213563,
0.4848760664,
0.0631973073,
0.4376774728,
-0.2858760357,
1.0725685358,
0.3493944705,
-0.8737427592,
0.3163387179,
-0.4580017924,
0.1716329306,
0.867803216,
0.6036217809,
-0.6572166681,
-0.3106437922,
-0.4495123923,
-0.9411126971,
0.5299779177,
-0.3819400966,
0.2763288915,
-0.2366006672,
0.5688914061,
0.2907214165,
0.2849752307,
-0.7824624777,
0.0307935625,
-0.2946583629,
-0.21128048,
-0.3158811331,
-0.6156383157,
-0.1466117203,
-0.2367588282,
0.6342969537,
-0.1896783113,
0.224957943,
0.4897684157,
-0.0438413247,
-0.3257597089,
0.3919962347,
0.3212519586,
0.3608359396,
-0.3156320751,
0.2586727142,
0.3658716083,
-0.2652871907,
0.1369933933,
-0.1190802455,
-0.421379447,
0.3286163509,
0.4358409345,
0.655782938,
0.2048888803,
-0.4898989201,
0.8742337227,
0.0582904927,
-0.3455290794,
-0.2924052477,
-0.2616367638,
0.2065059692,
-0.0569676086,
-0.0133778388,
-0.075624913,
0.0400908105,
-0.4022984505,
-0.0614860393,
0.5447437167,
-1.0511108637,
-0.4688509703,
0.4518385828,
0.4750657976,
-0.2649792135,
0.6125699878,
-0.2344148606,
-0.4701123238,
0.1008481681,
0.1089619026,
1.0308287144,
-0.1846631616,
0.3886322081,
0.1406535059,
0.137305215,
-0.1419160217,
0.7220636606,
0.3888720572,
-0.4653028548,
-0.7426576614,
-0.4220681489,
-0.8659451604,
-0.1203977019,
-0.7090505362,
0.1562466174,
-0.6977565885,
-0.5622500777,
0.0926576704,
0.0348928422,
-0.7292978168,
0.4856539071,
0.2558857799,
0.7378662825,
-0.8968484402,
0.5784208775,
0.9409546852,
-0.2769532502,
-0.5063464642,
-0.102887243,
-0.0188257825,
-0.4871941507,
0.521720469,
0.2397810817,
-0.0799253508,
-0.6121931076,
-0.688739419,
0.0190268606,
0.5816970468,
0.4497539401,
-0.5033144355,
-0.0323982351,
0.2562767267,
0.9305542707,
-0.3053239584,
0.2501609623,
0.1246856302,
0.323856473,
-0.3685802817,
-0.5644888878,
0.1189369857,
-0.2515757382,
-0.1591337025,
0.0836875364,
-0.6233628988,
1.191311717,
0.0101166926,
0.0006555424,
-0.2398392558,
0.426016897,
-0.2172658592,
0.3044707179,
0.6891183853,
0.5474574566,
0.6549347043,
0.0479517952,
1.0167276859,
-0.2182789147,
0.3357975483,
0.9552547932,
-0.6719358563,
0.7977731824,
0.6889153123,
0.0385011248,
0.7010641694,
0.1413193196,
0.1763995737,
0.3270990849,
0.3721783459,
-0.8472342491,
-0.344714731,
-0.4335306883,
-0.1835183948,
0.3095018268,
0.241986528,
-0.2532580495,
-0.2150564641,
-0.0821886435,
0.3739129007,
-0.0319440849,
-0.2876446545,
0.9783241749,
0.4551234245,
-0.5603380799,
0.417714417,
0.0521592088,
0.7812567353,
-0.4327996671,
-0.0113810645,
-0.1354129165,
-0.0474194176,
-0.3970224857,
-0.5916773677,
0.2944001853,
0.4090366662,
-0.238238737,
-0.2502703667,
0.6748051047,
-0.0367474779,
-0.4981434643,
0.3897690177,
0.649787128,
0.2657020092,
-0.1111748517,
-0.6052052379,
-0.090576604,
0.0889870077,
-0.3731175959,
0.3970562816,
0.3723841608,
-0.2224770635,
0.3887864649,
0.5646538138,
0.4309116304,
-0.402500838,
0.2674755454,
1.0432320833,
-0.8137158751,
-0.1589571238,
-0.8859821558,
0.5752951503,
-0.0839314908,
-0.4084605873,
0.5331737995,
0.1877708286,
0.7333132029,
-0.223340556,
1.1478881836,
0.156462878,
1.106541872,
-0.1480894685,
0.6384210587,
-0.5476871729,
0.1356086433,
-0.3667638898,
-0.5402866602,
-0.7786833644,
0.6748068333,
-0.3650154471,
-0.0087535568,
0.2798832357,
0.7392427325,
0.1487149149,
0.1457867175,
0.1918193847,
0.2457392812,
0.4037670493,
0.5436157584,
1.1795860529,
-0.0096521229,
-0.1369384378,
-0.4969065785,
-0.3465126157,
-0.3211848736,
-1.2028284073,
-1.0622347593,
0.0091960365,
-0.4696047008,
-0.4038171172,
-0.0286060572,
1.3868451118,
0.487609446,
-0.9899864793,
-0.077689819,
0.3053182065,
-0.1544858217,
0.2265385091,
-0.1554273963,
0.2613081932,
-0.2251043171,
-0.3704178929,
0.1002121642,
0.2474766821,
-0.0028645867,
-0.4129576683,
-0.0853156671,
0.1716176718,
0.1499883235,
0.5743809342,
0.3019807935,
-0.5822005272,
-0.4867411256,
0.0042938786,
-0.0988400429,
0.2071568519,
0.7969485521,
-0.7220399976,
0.6120279431,
0.3198468089,
0.6000561714,
-0.0504914634,
0.10766159,
0.1913480908,
-0.70606637,
0.1278684288,
0.7484203577,
0.3240300119,
0.8473880291,
-0.2359342426,
0.2297288626,
0.1681130826,
-0.579628706,
-1.002710104,
0.1858795583,
-0.9614903927,
-0.2031846046,
1.178537488,
-0.2248399407,
-0.0580765754,
-0.3201648891,
-0.3319787979,
0.1206822768,
-0.4256570935,
0.8933208585,
0.6118642688,
-0.348143816,
0.1227075011,
-0.7111000419,
0.6675114632,
0.4738840759,
-0.7676638365,
0.0391496085,
0.4697531164,
0.3058478832,
0.1552138478,
1.1777416468,
-0.2724210322,
0.055169262,
-0.3314455748,
0.4167976677,
0.1766518801,
-0.2688391507,
-0.7602411509,
0.3588592112,
0.4908831716,
0.1163050607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18824v1
|
Benchmarking Benchmark Leakage in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T16:05:36 | 2024-04-29T16:05:36 |
Ruijie Xu, Zengzhi Wang, Run-Ze Fan, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Amid the expanding use of pre-training data, the phenomenon of benchmark
dataset leakage has become increasingly prominent, exacerbated by opaque
training processes and the often undisclosed inclusion of supervised data in
contemporary Large Language Models (LLMs). This issue skews benchmark
effectiveness and fosters potentially unfair comparisons, impeding the field's
healthy development. To address this, we introduce a detection pipeline
utilizing Perplexity and N-gram accuracy, two simple and scalable metrics that
gauge a model's prediction precision on benchmark, to identify potential data
leakages. By analyzing 31 LLMs under the context of mathematical reasoning, we
reveal substantial instances of training even test set misuse, resulting in
potentially unfair comparisons. These findings prompt us to offer several
recommendations regarding model documentation, benchmark setup, and future
evaluations. Notably, we propose the "Benchmark Transparency Card" to encourage
clear documentation of benchmark utilization, promoting transparency and
healthy developments of LLMs. we have made our leaderboard, pipeline
implementation, and model predictions publicly available, fostering future
research.
|
[
-0.2830004096,
-0.2891469598,
0.7477252483,
0.055143211,
-0.0640995428,
-0.0380365811,
-0.177305162,
-0.4833737612,
-0.3743165731,
0.7003186345,
-0.4865674675,
-0.7041237354,
-1.0420823097,
-0.1423622221,
-0.7339655161,
0.7660466433,
-0.3049829006,
0.1416504085,
-0.3822537959,
-0.2867490351,
-0.3623859882,
-0.5559968948,
-0.2092754096,
-0.414372474,
0.4034531415,
0.3639057577,
0.4908082783,
0.9608424902,
0.5471124053,
0.2626441121,
-0.0823654756,
-0.1355275363,
-0.5580534935,
0.2197392732,
-0.1047265008,
-0.8738536835,
-0.4697333574,
-0.0029141805,
0.9410201907,
0.6389480233,
-0.1088299975,
0.4960773885,
0.1081706285,
0.6114850044,
-1.0050195456,
0.3702683449,
-0.8145008683,
0.1028245017,
-0.7655742764,
0.1502445936,
-0.2552669942,
-0.4352934062,
-0.2311840504,
-0.3736930788,
0.1713595986,
-0.1236531213,
0.7025299072,
0.4446947873,
0.0133623388,
-0.1533449441,
-0.2999798059,
0.6627234817,
-0.8399503231,
0.5344824195,
0.4570034742,
0.6771920323,
-0.0630026981,
-0.7649883628,
-0.5157927275,
-0.1113586351,
0.2019606233,
-0.0885537937,
-0.2721175253,
-0.3432066441,
0.4954687655,
0.3584033549,
-0.412102282,
0.3090794086,
0.0603162572,
-0.2307237089,
0.6242083907,
0.1058061868,
0.0231790021,
0.2715732753,
-0.3135658205,
-0.3279197216,
-1.0149968863,
-0.2217473537,
0.6616640687,
0.1768345684,
-0.1816005558,
0.3925476074,
-0.3349610567,
0.3725813925,
-0.3785972595,
0.07581494,
0.5951764584,
-0.1521529555,
-0.1639006138,
-0.0369950645,
0.7596965432,
0.0999112651,
0.4293715656,
-0.2775950432,
-0.3284045458,
0.1468272805,
0.0082760481,
-0.7887435555,
-0.2217783183,
0.125488922,
-0.1076190993,
-0.3869378865,
0.1234421507,
-0.7602214813,
-0.5409677029,
-0.1788286418,
0.2734240592,
-0.0694252998,
-0.3787889481,
0.1505923122,
-0.1140524074,
-0.1568350643,
0.0163064208,
-0.7682653069,
0.3358027041,
1.0490151644,
0.5600022674,
-0.1429535151,
-0.3560495675,
-0.5354005694,
0.1414221376,
-0.2237929851,
0.7984175086,
-0.6336137652,
-0.2227550745,
0.24926503,
0.0389557369,
0.2140875012,
-0.9611908197,
0.7591351271,
-0.1312103122,
-0.0222237017,
-0.3110431433,
-0.6894200444,
0.2815483212,
0.2449129075,
-0.5774312019,
0.9961456656,
-0.1430986971,
-0.7819766998,
0.5578759909,
-0.3991152644,
0.0838465169,
0.2341119051,
-0.3789385855,
-0.6055831909,
0.2093204409,
0.2452469915,
0.4838480353,
-0.252341032,
0.4516945183,
-0.5969561934,
-0.5262137055,
0.3036710024,
-0.6411759853,
0.6201081872,
0.1274522841,
-0.2530576289,
-0.1091890931,
-0.5961619616,
0.1676371396,
0.1804031581,
-0.1134571359,
-0.0441842191,
-0.2696201205,
-0.280035764,
0.03089712,
0.2425468266,
-0.3544970751,
-0.0384813137,
-0.0386895165,
0.2293629795,
0.8840565085,
-0.43158108,
0.1533020884,
-0.3880441189,
0.5735618472,
0.0737538487,
0.1782462746,
-0.2635736465,
-0.3536013663,
-0.5389239192,
-0.1973827779,
0.6102784872,
0.2837592959,
-0.2749991119,
0.437620759,
-0.3706808686,
-0.6101452708,
-0.6077054143,
0.3264186978,
0.5329515934,
0.507427454,
0.2332827896,
-0.3879471123,
-0.1003595144,
-0.9613416791,
-0.8146107793,
0.0552286543,
-0.2933600545,
0.2417831868,
0.521559,
-0.0333370753,
0.557482183,
-0.4518764019,
-0.2929594517,
-0.0132581815,
0.2782403529,
0.1751671582,
0.5012586117,
0.2606711984,
-0.4865742326,
-0.3340579271,
-0.4010030627,
-0.9377429485,
-0.3630692363,
0.3571027517,
-0.0253183674,
-0.0899214298,
0.7964362502,
-0.3146191835,
0.3162904382,
0.9131677747,
-0.040215183,
0.7232559323,
-0.0276991278,
-0.3362365365,
-0.6257358789,
0.1289531738,
-0.0624909922,
-0.1443550587,
-0.3905999362,
0.1168356016,
0.4355877936,
0.0280343164,
-0.4140585661,
0.4203740954,
-0.4598696828,
-0.1621976942,
-0.1059482917,
0.1273216903,
-0.0532980524,
-0.0208587982,
-0.254865706,
0.7200013995,
0.6935172081,
-0.2061891407,
0.0869317502,
0.1125176698,
-0.6997994184,
0.3955727816,
-0.5306488872,
0.1834440678,
-0.0151468394,
0.3921794295,
-0.6848368645,
-0.0396106578,
0.1451026052,
-0.3946518898,
0.5046847463,
-0.3190480471,
-0.8722199798,
-0.028258238,
-0.2370952964,
0.4730302989,
0.4904485941,
-0.5154820085,
0.0288154483,
0.4623874724,
-0.0435593687,
-0.832508862,
-0.8985438943,
0.0478230193,
-0.2230272442,
-0.5645231605,
0.3189810216,
-0.033392258,
-0.2030983567,
0.0118150814,
-0.4666714668,
-0.1508629322,
0.2078760117,
0.2994413674,
-0.0427324586,
-0.3047344685,
0.3113321066,
-0.2048461735,
-0.2879194021,
0.4335694909,
-0.094095096,
0.5729587078,
-0.1564746052,
-0.5732964277,
-0.3733575046,
0.05904698,
0.5445362926,
-0.3626494408,
0.6608784795,
0.4150424302,
-0.3951990604,
-0.3602047861,
-0.7303216457,
-0.2124224305,
-0.475668937,
0.3847988248,
-0.3699846268,
-0.5662704706,
0.5253212452,
-0.4448994398,
-0.1831568033,
0.260535121,
0.3522275686,
0.1714298874,
0.9287673831,
0.5951353312,
-0.1495977044,
0.3845338225,
-0.2341176122,
0.1812747419,
-0.7577069998,
-0.2356469035,
-0.6956213117,
-0.1675816029,
-0.6562210917,
-0.5670176744,
0.1408365518,
0.3279123902,
-0.2552215159,
0.1368982494,
-0.2099809349,
0.8419940472,
0.3372179568,
-0.1671535969,
0.4575873613,
-0.1142224073,
-0.4111112952,
-0.1286771595,
-0.6062346101,
-0.6315006614,
1.4723541737,
0.6185114384,
0.6546084285,
0.0600982867,
0.8655202985,
-0.0605758466,
0.4984098375,
-0.3945988119,
0.4408281744,
-0.2678764462,
-0.5632590055,
-0.2254693806,
-0.412982583,
-0.8030552268,
0.2082515955,
-0.2891469896,
-0.8627737164,
0.2817368507,
-0.0202177316,
0.1214924157,
0.3317056298,
-0.61119771,
1.0570116043,
-0.1761332452,
-0.562551558,
0.0542016216,
-0.38288939,
0.5468215346,
-0.2726870775,
0.1694404632,
-0.5418211222,
0.0279024448,
0.4875994623,
-0.4565136135,
0.5493545532,
-0.0812262967,
-0.2487948388,
-0.2463512719,
0.100671947,
0.6537976265,
0.1310638785,
-0.2293527275,
0.7477211952,
-0.1550832689,
-0.5152693391,
-0.3885134161,
0.7246290445,
-0.5661580563,
-0.5069159269,
-0.5091716647,
-0.6248600483,
-0.6526811123,
0.2887865603,
0.393343091,
0.2404994667,
0.0758188516,
0.2123385072,
0.8151534796,
-0.0633235797,
0.1314266771,
0.5680434108,
-0.2098568678,
0.0860739648,
0.8052333593,
0.0701642781,
0.394023627,
0.0848656222,
0.3344061077,
-0.4122693241,
-0.9953663945,
-0.2147492319,
0.4153424799,
-0.6786202788,
-0.2239103764,
-0.3107915521,
-0.2755810916,
-0.4162841141,
0.2113887966,
-0.609023869,
-0.1726655364,
0.1138558015,
-0.0518126041,
-0.0635999069,
0.7141552567,
0.0001587032,
0.1748401821,
-0.6048516035,
0.128276512,
0.1026978418,
0.7824733257,
-0.0514873192,
-0.4454751909,
-0.0238242429,
0.0344496928,
-0.2535932362,
-0.5318114161,
0.1913893968,
-0.1049795896,
0.900567472,
0.5547198653,
-0.0275404733,
0.3813712001,
-0.5331910849,
0.3498694301,
0.2598659992,
-1.0961374044,
0.428666532,
-0.2924874723,
0.5055925846,
0.7072924972,
0.3838308752,
-0.4482273757,
-0.7559678555,
-0.5906005502,
-0.8248049617,
0.6046211123,
0.02846287,
0.0312238876,
0.3598943353,
0.0159288179,
0.2768969536,
0.4660646915,
-0.6046486497,
-0.2669720352,
-0.1351160407,
-0.0772547573,
-0.186206609,
-0.3226144314,
-0.3047918975,
-0.0949218571,
0.3715933263,
-0.0731347874,
-0.0793990716,
-0.2519708872,
-0.2762471735,
0.1408049613,
0.3030733168,
0.3477210402,
0.9189715385,
-0.2132210732,
0.3095904589,
0.1929467469,
-0.5745127797,
-0.0674177706,
0.1683498025,
0.0364487283,
-0.0664097369,
0.5174710155,
0.4242560863,
0.1953179985,
-0.8294724822,
0.6701331735,
-0.0564186946,
-0.3126310706,
-0.3380284011,
0.1089553311,
0.333999157,
0.1180743799,
0.1252660006,
-0.0916370228,
0.0305642653,
-0.5904842019,
0.3299018741,
0.3221397102,
-0.4881389141,
-0.0817673057,
0.6606950164,
-0.0615323707,
-0.0934970006,
0.570443809,
-0.066361323,
-0.5006132722,
0.4615041018,
0.3084665239,
0.7345758677,
-0.2136054039,
0.1102258414,
0.0927683339,
0.3580923676,
-0.3953469396,
0.0912403017,
0.0252167247,
-0.7437580824,
-0.3559737802,
-0.4370756149,
-0.4250505269,
0.3501522243,
-0.8618052602,
0.2744475007,
-0.5628826022,
0.0918011591,
0.2465042919,
-0.02035187,
-0.732378602,
-0.031286668,
0.5072799325,
1.061331749,
-0.88803792,
1.0411697626,
0.1036875546,
-0.2555756569,
-0.6713389754,
0.3176186383,
0.2409668714,
-1.0960072279,
0.7341088057,
0.3665264249,
-0.0390397012,
-0.4684434533,
-0.5697779059,
-0.6905731559,
1.0200384855,
0.814474225,
-0.8985882998,
0.3328138888,
0.5423043966,
0.4695993662,
-0.2863464653,
0.2667632997,
0.7966281176,
0.6925332546,
-0.0815526694,
-0.8517330885,
0.3106841147,
-0.1726900339,
-0.2077958584,
0.3118719161,
-0.5971481204,
1.0514938831,
0.1579865217,
-0.3123782575,
-0.0791542158,
0.023299586,
0.402546227,
0.4272024333,
0.4399564564,
0.8266552687,
0.9559696317,
-0.2979810536,
1.0859245062,
-0.1354576498,
0.1337547749,
1.3493660688,
-0.5298240185,
0.9668185711,
0.2398623079,
-0.191061303,
0.3399392664,
0.1466378719,
-0.2464435995,
0.4119728208,
0.7558631301,
-0.2942828238,
-0.1980276406,
-0.2157858759,
-0.6348341703,
0.4319720268,
0.3361169398,
-0.3677445948,
-0.478798449,
-0.6156836748,
0.2500520945,
0.1755753905,
-0.146218136,
0.4968661666,
0.0856128186,
-0.4767959416,
0.6201331019,
-0.1949244142,
0.5472649336,
-0.5418549776,
-0.0085098045,
-0.3219449222,
0.3778837025,
-0.2664843798,
-0.7808715105,
0.1507795006,
0.0987984538,
0.0950010195,
-0.387649864,
0.4722785652,
-0.4257989228,
-0.489982605,
0.4529075325,
0.6317324638,
0.3110789359,
-0.4305027425,
-0.7465503812,
0.3964884281,
-0.3289416432,
0.2310706228,
0.5881003737,
0.452546984,
-0.1474805772,
0.7948642969,
0.6103239059,
0.4204767346,
0.1210032925,
0.3191686869,
0.7885337472,
-0.455393821,
-0.259776026,
-0.7442120314,
0.180237636,
-0.3276118636,
-0.3930822611,
0.892570734,
0.6212577224,
0.9773471951,
0.3148107231,
0.7891631722,
0.6868775487,
0.4880834818,
-0.5430767536,
0.9529721737,
-0.3953962922,
0.6614617109,
-0.1201517954,
-0.9203905463,
-0.3087868094,
0.1758144349,
-0.4610571861,
-0.0693437979,
0.8813089728,
0.7005397677,
-0.1934684068,
0.1221788675,
0.3494662941,
0.3802316785,
0.3102249503,
0.6922875643,
0.8065006733,
-0.3925110996,
0.6300888062,
-0.2263321877,
-0.1465303153,
-0.2731245756,
-1.1572520733,
-0.6903638244,
-0.1801074147,
-0.4380781949,
-0.152534619,
0.3040034771,
0.0740738064,
0.7550818324,
-0.8811815977,
-0.3100757301,
-0.3421099186,
0.1844196767,
-0.142810002,
-0.1342476606,
0.2201163024,
-0.2796595693,
-0.6343895793,
0.344633311,
0.0165092368,
0.0023071552,
-0.5405671,
0.1707237214,
0.173089534,
-0.12772955,
0.0510788448,
0.2699099183,
-0.5433974862,
-0.1285264492,
-0.3749674559,
0.1027165428,
-0.0551089346,
0.7657002211,
-0.701687634,
0.4527325332,
0.3579315841,
0.649238646,
0.7150347829,
-0.2065574378,
0.7008635402,
-0.7363535762,
0.1693044752,
0.2420790642,
0.2477120906,
0.3270457089,
-0.0958162472,
0.5588471293,
-0.05037928,
-0.3476771414,
-1.3284323215,
0.2481994033,
-0.4073216319,
-0.3339234293,
0.8353571296,
-0.4482209086,
-0.1564798951,
-0.0165704563,
0.5695146322,
0.0130290296,
-0.3155128956,
0.6625877619,
1.0115545988,
0.2374449223,
0.0164001193,
-0.9695775509,
0.5187952518,
0.4669555128,
-0.8787376285,
0.3812729418,
0.2190216482,
0.4240493476,
-0.0361058228,
0.1985609084,
-0.5002322197,
0.0136668803,
0.2595046759,
-0.1194313616,
-0.2376519293,
-0.2958259881,
-0.5206440091,
0.1681041867,
0.1057673693,
-0.1460101604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18810v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18810v2
|
Unknown Script: Impact of Script on Cross-Lingual Transfer
| 2024-04-29T15:48:01 | 2024-05-07T12:23:39 |
Wondimagegnhue Tsegaye Tufa, Ilia Markov, Piek Vossen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual transfer has become an effective way of transferring knowledge
between languages. In this paper, we explore an often overlooked aspect in this
domain: the influence of the source language of a language model on language
transfer performance. We consider a case where the target language and its
script are not part of the pre-trained model. We conduct a series of
experiments on monolingual and multilingual models that are pre-trained on
different tokenization methods to determine factors that affect cross-lingual
transfer to a new language with a unique script. Our findings reveal the
importance of the tokenizer as a stronger factor than the shared script,
language similarity, and model size.
|
[
-0.262273699,
-0.3064374328,
0.3216005564,
0.3924897909,
0.0696256161,
0.339730382,
-0.0870689228,
-0.8908714056,
0.3680905998,
0.3671188354,
-0.3866482973,
-0.0347322412,
-0.8370255828,
-0.0099043334,
-0.6736980081,
0.8959405422,
-0.1564226449,
0.2673792839,
0.0317527838,
-0.1560753435,
-0.175851807,
-0.726439476,
-0.3095846474,
-0.2783902287,
0.5104660988,
0.0720306039,
0.5456373096,
0.4078043997,
0.6392040849,
0.2771405578,
0.3410859704,
-0.5394119024,
-0.5212517977,
-0.3706719577,
-0.4518881142,
-0.8757154346,
-0.2276451439,
-0.1033907533,
0.8796467185,
1.1428294182,
0.2401465327,
0.19188793,
-0.2965770364,
0.3038172722,
-0.5805889368,
0.12276797,
-0.4383836985,
0.0442051068,
-0.3718703091,
-0.2135235369,
-0.4636881649,
-0.1586800218,
0.4513233006,
-0.6881039143,
0.1926357895,
0.0621116497,
0.7025841475,
0.0051331301,
-0.5295481682,
-0.2632515132,
-1.0281939507,
0.8585811257,
-0.5143299103,
0.2604148686,
0.2860481441,
0.1302422583,
0.1727989465,
-0.832103312,
-0.6917105317,
-0.0440095589,
-0.4713343382,
-0.1596913338,
-0.2877848446,
-0.0348730348,
0.1799913198,
0.0452169254,
-0.2392102033,
0.1858318001,
-0.6642389894,
-0.4256675243,
0.2252334058,
-0.1402398795,
1.0310630798,
-0.2480904162,
-0.4915953577,
-0.0123350108,
-0.6849359274,
0.2534175813,
0.4906962514,
0.4387815297,
-0.1062929407,
0.5615294576,
0.1917217821,
0.6258166432,
-0.1709146947,
-0.0039870152,
0.0681078956,
-0.8805333376,
0.08822947,
0.4255955219,
0.3903880119,
0.1178791076,
0.5419878364,
-0.3658391833,
-0.070018433,
0.0031158749,
0.0238208864,
-0.7136241794,
-0.0968130752,
-0.3674530089,
-0.3733571172,
-0.1096230075,
0.2982030213,
-0.5307369828,
-0.117807515,
-0.1303877831,
0.4324151576,
-0.2849980295,
-0.6014962196,
-0.2657520771,
-0.3655528724,
0.5193832517,
0.2328065783,
-1.1552345753,
0.4397203624,
0.5701587796,
0.7007998824,
-0.6504192352,
-0.7671191096,
-0.678525269,
0.1594259441,
-0.551615119,
0.9024791718,
-0.6843920946,
-0.3623328507,
0.1106480137,
0.3264828026,
-0.6089999676,
-0.1638093144,
-0.0307078771,
-0.3300961554,
0.4367213547,
-0.3114163578,
-0.3040855527,
-0.2747491896,
-0.4350650907,
-0.7993172407,
0.6445216537,
0.4119062424,
-0.5478010774,
0.5630300045,
-0.6195626855,
-0.8114105463,
-0.0598072931,
0.0422519185,
0.1959772557,
0.1523429304,
0.0518160462,
0.046536468,
0.0761503726,
0.1024119854,
-0.2272267938,
-0.6788091063,
0.3861095607,
-0.3144064546,
0.7556153536,
-0.0351664089,
-0.3334821165,
-0.0904295594,
-0.9116181731,
0.1072395593,
-0.0586844124,
-0.3165383637,
-0.5954236388,
-0.6862847805,
0.4567057788,
0.2873996496,
0.2384351045,
-0.5202012658,
0.0123838224,
-0.3121422231,
-0.0386220962,
0.5257611275,
-0.0205550268,
0.8555918336,
-0.2658580542,
0.9431657195,
-0.0926474035,
-0.1570133865,
-0.2942479551,
-0.1861174405,
-0.8736913204,
-0.1220246106,
0.6864768267,
0.3761462271,
-0.7454252839,
-0.4231670201,
-0.156247139,
-0.3354501426,
-0.7153439522,
0.1461786628,
0.4762105346,
0.0358644798,
0.057301864,
-0.363589406,
-0.712394774,
-0.8340715766,
-0.6248607039,
-0.2266982049,
0.3713674545,
-0.0414449312,
0.1469803154,
-0.0403255373,
0.8674296141,
-0.1916439384,
-0.2810046971,
-0.8236327767,
0.3583091199,
-0.06728971,
0.6620051265,
1.0233927965,
-0.3720589578,
-0.751868248,
0.3313128352,
-0.299358815,
-0.5774382353,
-0.2404739857,
-0.139862746,
0.4200459421,
0.7412833571,
-0.5574737787,
0.4277037084,
0.9984562993,
-0.2641463578,
0.5226740241,
-0.3208489418,
0.2165518254,
-1.000590682,
0.5508529544,
-0.435523212,
-0.0941449478,
-0.92585814,
-0.1913432628,
0.143090114,
-0.1376898885,
-0.9475718141,
0.9766690135,
-0.6077666283,
-0.3346197307,
-0.2393518835,
-0.0183064118,
-0.0581471883,
0.6196613312,
0.0875238925,
0.9351850152,
0.7215014696,
-0.4526074827,
0.0280699152,
-0.0217975657,
-0.390521735,
0.6045162678,
-0.5523943305,
0.0630888194,
0.1990937293,
-0.1625833809,
-0.8963194489,
-0.013213452,
0.0764877424,
-0.4019786119,
0.6290344,
-0.5320045352,
-0.1674108058,
0.1083141342,
0.1112274677,
0.5232670307,
0.3232205808,
-0.3398156464,
0.5242251158,
0.3560814559,
-0.0447409041,
-0.7421543002,
-0.8009162545,
0.0672921389,
-0.1976999789,
-0.4852366745,
0.1576473713,
-0.0332190581,
-0.2914670706,
0.1152106449,
-0.290452987,
-0.2914275825,
-0.0441429019,
0.1957072765,
0.2644219995,
-0.3781957924,
0.0467518121,
0.106282562,
-0.0781587735,
0.1884331554,
-0.1964490563,
0.4834864438,
0.1189929992,
-0.5118511319,
-0.3115283251,
0.3138101101,
0.7406032085,
-0.2334351838,
0.839086771,
0.8337404132,
-0.0907688066,
-0.3056696653,
-0.2257054895,
0.1058961973,
-0.4096125662,
0.5110155344,
-0.4899094701,
-0.4923642576,
0.710973382,
-0.18617706,
-0.5676472187,
0.4239539206,
0.3041185141,
0.3945209086,
0.8920665383,
1.1218224764,
0.0270937979,
0.8986384869,
-0.0052454406,
0.2109564543,
-0.515222609,
-0.0508264527,
-0.4859323502,
-0.096479781,
-0.6335053444,
-0.3496410847,
-0.0960112512,
-0.0697799847,
0.3636257946,
0.6526514292,
0.3289475441,
0.40273422,
0.5556332469,
-0.5791409016,
0.4023356736,
-0.1044850796,
-0.3582021594,
0.1600072533,
-0.9291772246,
-0.0650338382,
1.1134105921,
0.1909840554,
0.8718860149,
0.1454304904,
0.3884672523,
0.2396080345,
0.0104020564,
-0.450935632,
0.4624929726,
-0.0190708507,
-0.5590955019,
-0.2918176353,
-0.308570683,
-1.2434889078,
0.4003976583,
-0.1180298105,
-0.7182353139,
0.3003604114,
-0.4717382789,
-0.1256486773,
0.166297704,
-1.1237963438,
0.9964900613,
-0.2584598362,
-0.1686021388,
-0.1388968229,
-0.5562818646,
0.1952395886,
-0.6237800717,
0.273242861,
0.0821955502,
0.1272698492,
0.9460923076,
-0.4142893851,
0.7286073565,
0.0231040064,
0.0280342381,
0.2096057832,
0.410592258,
0.3744612634,
-0.3048020005,
0.2314859033,
0.5651602149,
0.3612444103,
-0.4619653821,
-0.7180266976,
0.7683963776,
-0.8726161718,
-0.7725228667,
-0.3687641025,
-0.5813571215,
-0.1059966609,
0.7248167992,
0.0854374021,
0.4845261574,
-0.3526844084,
0.0350553356,
0.1440983713,
-0.3085156381,
0.6840912104,
0.8341340423,
-0.653689146,
0.1102262884,
0.8745144606,
0.3546443284,
0.8709037304,
0.4191001356,
0.0547410958,
-0.1280322075,
-0.4408367872,
-0.5716158152,
0.3696468472,
-0.96810323,
0.4014053345,
-0.7501749396,
-0.3428793252,
-0.6792270541,
-0.1722739935,
-0.5626010299,
-0.8143274784,
-0.1462753564,
-0.2094827145,
0.0213274602,
0.8406711817,
-0.2728853226,
0.3571642041,
-0.7928541303,
-0.024009537,
0.2354755104,
0.3459618986,
-0.1747031659,
-0.519569695,
-0.4024976492,
-0.166057989,
0.5509845018,
-0.623314321,
0.4251338542,
0.0694807693,
0.9202288985,
0.2811359465,
0.1482831091,
0.6696327329,
-0.1479910165,
0.6256625652,
0.2194880694,
-1.1922892332,
0.1745766252,
-0.1811700165,
0.4740622044,
0.358900249,
0.338095367,
-0.7212265134,
-0.4701740444,
-0.5393484235,
-0.5070241094,
1.1507686377,
0.148952812,
0.199564293,
0.2537990212,
-0.412715584,
0.3719173074,
0.1933488399,
-0.826854527,
-0.073399812,
0.033340659,
0.3704593182,
-0.1248999909,
0.0376382396,
0.2167009413,
-0.1737549305,
0.1023014188,
0.0603600964,
-0.0238172188,
0.0079010604,
-0.5309642553,
-0.5637559891,
0.0396241881,
0.6256958246,
0.9242305756,
-0.1557031423,
0.2955594957,
0.2070295364,
-0.6368665695,
-0.109919101,
-0.0910456777,
-0.0147909513,
0.2548807561,
0.753492415,
0.9640348554,
0.5764824152,
-0.5738221407,
0.5900226831,
0.0284166206,
0.1369522363,
-0.2141821831,
0.0391578563,
-0.1737348735,
-0.0597901158,
0.2686710358,
0.5074148774,
-0.1395237893,
-0.8881450295,
0.2187973261,
0.2634566128,
-0.6109378338,
-0.579708755,
0.3160707355,
0.1705251038,
-0.343470037,
0.3370706737,
0.1740496606,
-0.8307844996,
0.70766294,
0.7808059454,
0.4850239456,
-0.4225561917,
0.2470788509,
0.2052553296,
0.5299907327,
0.1323731393,
-0.2952302098,
-0.0197324585,
-0.5522629023,
-0.495606184,
-0.3326501846,
-0.3126427531,
-0.3063946962,
-0.5095245242,
0.541395545,
-0.1043090299,
0.0940412283,
-0.1360385567,
-0.2148637176,
-0.890812695,
-0.2043707073,
0.038052436,
0.7086415887,
-0.9207428098,
1.1367601156,
0.4333788455,
-0.6173483133,
-0.9523663521,
0.0183570441,
-0.3359942734,
-1.116538763,
0.9301851392,
-0.0831302404,
-0.1706143022,
0.1006231233,
0.1482173651,
-1.3469775915,
0.6851655841,
0.2819271386,
-0.0629955456,
-0.0954903364,
0.5278049707,
0.8834062815,
-0.4891244471,
0.388533771,
0.4872525036,
0.5276791453,
0.2312983721,
-1.5186480284,
0.1469988972,
-0.2405733466,
-0.0490944982,
0.2180797309,
-0.4426950216,
0.9556733966,
-0.5250419378,
-0.5308861136,
-0.1382455379,
0.2086601555,
-0.495736897,
0.2620508671,
0.1264874786,
0.0378446244,
0.4271297157,
0.3413991332,
1.2943798304,
-0.4659276307,
0.0523839332,
0.8519827724,
-0.3432586491,
0.738450408,
0.7833974361,
-0.1861940473,
0.6153575778,
0.1258838177,
0.1775140762,
0.523847878,
0.1937448978,
0.0610926449,
0.0620581172,
-0.2122944593,
-0.5151954889,
0.8322255611,
0.069465138,
-0.5257237554,
-0.243855387,
0.2514880002,
0.0482317619,
-0.184546411,
-0.2567796409,
0.6764442325,
0.0222248901,
-1.0141357183,
0.483887285,
-0.0967827067,
0.4808489978,
-0.9249249101,
0.0066865506,
-0.3647428751,
0.2466366887,
-0.1729699522,
-0.4925709069,
0.5213748217,
-0.2563229799,
0.0705114901,
-0.3930372,
0.9831083417,
-0.5801885724,
-0.5218479633,
0.6357843876,
1.0687606335,
0.2031572163,
0.1038985774,
-0.1768516451,
-0.0651244968,
-0.0278803818,
-0.1187938154,
0.8337418437,
0.5880246162,
-0.1032456458,
0.5332738161,
1.0467658043,
0.4136835337,
0.4217835069,
0.1479247063,
0.6017773151,
-0.5636457801,
-0.4909950793,
-0.5157527924,
0.1114366651,
0.1658540666,
-0.2007256448,
1.1812851429,
0.3346685469,
1.0878852606,
-0.3503449261,
0.7287794352,
-0.0463069491,
0.3227363825,
-0.3657444417,
0.9755168557,
-0.3414166272,
0.2266327441,
-0.5646839142,
-0.9601843357,
-0.1468785405,
0.3266634047,
-0.3226881027,
0.0478258654,
1.1746906042,
0.7704408765,
0.0954385102,
-0.2860605419,
0.6680420041,
-0.065815866,
0.027397763,
0.4739908874,
1.0473673344,
-0.2859332263,
0.8260295391,
-0.1444512904,
-0.1011258662,
-0.031620834,
-0.8942796588,
-0.9901947975,
-0.6155910492,
-0.2700511217,
-0.1902204454,
-0.0709487125,
0.6601495147,
0.7042964101,
-0.7309342623,
-0.5600202084,
0.1102857739,
0.4243654907,
-0.2790418863,
-0.233934015,
0.3277834952,
-0.3651130795,
-0.9413252473,
0.3196263611,
0.1584655195,
0.1398979872,
-0.5482706428,
0.0296001062,
-0.3152150512,
0.2061446607,
0.4203341603,
0.3404865563,
-0.4769542515,
-0.24077411,
0.2859202027,
-0.1986349821,
-0.1181082949,
1.2953101397,
-0.6795933247,
0.5621603131,
0.5563446283,
0.4477727711,
0.502517283,
-0.2492933869,
1.0004220009,
-0.6445040703,
0.2715881765,
-0.2316877246,
0.399312079,
0.1854412109,
-0.4479981363,
0.391377598,
0.6240084171,
-0.0964575708,
-0.8345291018,
-0.0600112043,
-0.8814888597,
-0.4470678568,
1.4739153385,
-0.2035032362,
-0.3521977067,
-0.3403147459,
-0.3426016271,
0.2106399536,
-0.1200493649,
0.4350194931,
1.0547738075,
-0.019745633,
-0.2893776894,
-0.3965778947,
0.4794079661,
0.4420401454,
-0.5162177682,
-0.0862179548,
0.0628352612,
0.4880708754,
0.2238752693,
0.6216711402,
-0.0945450813,
0.2130432874,
0.4776057005,
0.0481040739,
-0.0180045795,
-0.3012025058,
-0.1778834313,
0.2037500292,
0.0731652081,
-0.0742012113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18796v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18796v2
|
Replacing Judges with Juries: Evaluating LLM Generations with a Panel of Diverse Models
| 2024-04-29T15:33:23 | 2024-05-01T15:37:11 |
Pat Verga, Sebastian Hofstatter, Sophia Althammer, Yixuan Su, Aleksandra Piktus, Arkady Arkhangorodsky, Minjie Xu, Naomi White, Patrick Lewis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) have become more advanced, they have outpaced
our abilities to accurately evaluate their quality. Not only is finding data to
adequately probe particular model properties difficult, but evaluating the
correctness of a model's freeform generation alone is a challenge. To address
this, many evaluations now rely on using LLMs themselves as judges to score the
quality of outputs from other LLMs. Evaluations most commonly use a single
large model like GPT4. While this method has grown in popularity, it is costly,
has been shown to introduce intramodel bias, and in this work, we find that
very large models are often unnecessary. We propose instead to evaluate models
using a Panel of LLm evaluators (PoLL). Across three distinct judge settings
and spanning six different datasets, we find that using a PoLL composed of a
larger number of smaller models outperforms a single large judge, exhibits less
intra-model bias due to its composition of disjoint model families, and does so
while being over seven times less expensive.
|
[
-0.5491573215,
-0.082813777,
1.0138580799,
0.0404646136,
-0.455270052,
0.1856999397,
-0.2520394623,
-0.2449474782,
-0.104381822,
0.6175777912,
-0.3356892169,
-0.1992252469,
-0.5930941701,
0.0243220795,
-0.3100264072,
0.9516841769,
0.0108513637,
0.4629741311,
-0.3714955151,
-0.0823444501,
-0.085871011,
-0.2414476722,
-0.3651585877,
-0.596890986,
0.4360218942,
0.1990054697,
0.7663740516,
0.1627511382,
0.3179596066,
0.3183799684,
-0.3886623979,
0.3081661761,
-0.5987164974,
-0.0451925099,
-0.3587017357,
-0.5654821992,
-0.1920768619,
0.4305956364,
0.6048600674,
0.9063854814,
0.0449960791,
0.0467491336,
0.2120963484,
0.6676239967,
-0.4811902344,
0.1903843284,
-0.8026939631,
0.0905148461,
-0.1476285607,
-0.1842579395,
-0.6001263857,
-0.7484799623,
-0.0692402124,
-0.2556618154,
0.2614780664,
-0.0798308477,
0.5728910565,
0.1023828536,
-0.7089576125,
0.1306294054,
-0.6945329309,
0.7386627793,
-1.0252135992,
0.227070123,
0.3368220031,
0.4418346286,
-0.3442515433,
-0.5172069669,
-0.3699890077,
-0.5585076213,
0.1599146724,
0.2353859097,
-0.3199920654,
0.1039088145,
0.143988207,
0.5221883059,
-0.3356851637,
0.4623363614,
-0.3962479532,
-0.097949855,
0.6366992593,
0.2751953006,
0.1320862621,
-0.1104501337,
-0.2154381871,
0.0701552257,
-0.9310407639,
-0.0564595275,
0.8442802429,
0.4364788234,
0.2019132674,
0.5261956453,
-0.3198724985,
0.5807809234,
0.3398531079,
-0.1192994565,
0.1155740619,
-0.4109970331,
-0.1389626861,
-0.3967992067,
0.8330621719,
0.4028787613,
0.146774739,
-0.0875038058,
-0.3829813898,
-0.0141084027,
0.1955108941,
-0.7886596918,
-0.1408618242,
-0.0083011612,
-0.7034038901,
-0.4573015869,
-0.0280555822,
-0.872328043,
-0.6082507372,
-0.4312247038,
0.407027632,
-0.0022152294,
-0.0901845321,
-0.1823587418,
-0.2530186772,
0.041186627,
0.7073246241,
-0.6954054832,
0.2187462449,
0.5908530354,
0.5627032518,
-0.1035235599,
-0.0838080794,
-0.799864769,
-0.4387763739,
-0.4935407341,
0.8538084626,
-0.8452983499,
-0.6852958202,
-0.204838261,
-0.2124271244,
0.0834083557,
-0.8411463499,
0.3478149474,
-0.6035533547,
0.6399424076,
-0.3654631972,
-0.7420001626,
-0.0357432924,
0.1124442369,
-0.7723578215,
0.7552658319,
0.5220608711,
-0.5117044449,
0.6565314531,
-0.3734720051,
-0.056757763,
0.005321871,
-0.3314464986,
-0.3675228059,
0.4837839007,
0.5719908476,
0.2761937976,
-0.519957304,
0.5263699293,
-0.7476552725,
-0.5538009405,
0.1629718244,
-0.8697315454,
0.7153829932,
0.2786495686,
-0.3611699641,
0.2637676895,
-0.7966057658,
-0.053752657,
-0.2343687266,
-0.5691918731,
-0.2931901217,
0.0605409667,
-0.0804907307,
0.3029792309,
-0.228827849,
-0.6442562342,
0.1854614019,
-0.51880759,
0.3549960554,
1.1222709417,
0.0814816058,
0.4283113182,
-0.4497226775,
0.8146682978,
0.0044259261,
0.2578991652,
0.2618477941,
-0.6329729557,
-0.6547796726,
-0.3200089931,
0.3744063973,
-0.0680285394,
-0.8195781708,
0.2214800268,
-0.3272157907,
-0.7629159093,
-0.5102089643,
0.2148449719,
0.1592821181,
0.1203968301,
0.0987363905,
-0.3536521792,
-0.1323474199,
-0.9788325429,
-0.3562789857,
-0.3099405468,
-0.1097800657,
0.2003495097,
0.4921876192,
-0.0455184691,
0.9785203934,
-0.0335216969,
0.3610036969,
-0.4478417933,
-0.089707762,
0.3542012274,
0.2555457354,
0.6384246945,
-0.3168367147,
-0.2805120647,
0.0150776766,
-0.2262105793,
-0.4948645532,
0.0369602814,
0.082854405,
-0.0369042903,
0.1902076602,
-0.5848974586,
0.3231437802,
0.8417945504,
-0.3498077989,
0.7274066806,
0.1276014,
0.2137715518,
-0.6731971502,
-0.1640158296,
-0.0700280741,
-0.3401811123,
-0.41607216,
0.1409450769,
-0.0336519517,
-0.1059916317,
-0.4727940857,
0.8257178068,
-0.664169848,
-0.1803729534,
-0.3882450163,
0.2268787622,
0.3246668577,
0.2098918855,
-0.5101126432,
0.971026063,
-0.0288605634,
-0.3872404397,
0.4531267285,
0.2016499639,
-0.9217786789,
0.3992744982,
-0.1925207973,
0.0934863761,
-0.2714313865,
0.6291486025,
-1.1013530493,
-0.0657707378,
-0.0052541806,
-0.0238267202,
0.3017170727,
-0.144691512,
-0.2633707523,
-0.5576515794,
-0.5331488848,
0.261245966,
0.3687153757,
-1.0515224934,
0.5854874253,
0.1459135115,
-0.2642942071,
-0.3822407126,
-0.4719886482,
0.1571353674,
-0.3988622427,
-0.6190786958,
0.1385151595,
-0.0099087842,
-0.5388845801,
0.0207578521,
-0.3370997012,
0.1650453061,
0.0981455147,
0.0222132988,
0.2196224481,
-0.2119223624,
0.1369774938,
0.0837360024,
-0.0143279685,
-0.1379824281,
-0.0813513324,
0.5769643784,
0.1072833464,
-0.8445245028,
-0.3519947827,
0.2463545948,
0.7291579843,
-0.3547224104,
0.2847933173,
0.2060427815,
0.0697288066,
-0.4628922045,
-0.925001204,
-0.1304483563,
-0.4755791128,
0.3624849617,
-0.4580259025,
-1.2498675585,
0.3516713381,
0.0021318323,
0.1035016403,
0.5033568144,
0.7394083142,
0.2099391818,
0.9750241041,
0.3134871125,
-0.2683680654,
0.4938268363,
0.1967821568,
0.3910115063,
-0.9755263329,
0.0757423267,
-0.6114608049,
-0.3449130654,
-0.7252912521,
-0.5482660532,
0.4927676022,
-0.0754613057,
-0.2500273883,
-0.0186793525,
-0.1843143851,
0.4347260594,
0.7876133919,
0.2791373432,
0.4154484868,
-0.1153657362,
-0.2776388526,
0.1861259937,
-0.6272428632,
-0.7349187732,
1.433947444,
0.3262758851,
0.8921068907,
0.0985712335,
0.834463954,
-0.0112127764,
0.8823900223,
-0.6708086133,
0.6127069592,
-0.4352644384,
-0.6105382442,
-0.1249422505,
-0.7763373256,
-0.7668223381,
0.8856583834,
0.0693735033,
-0.7769904137,
0.4925332069,
-0.1400073767,
-0.712906599,
0.5860046148,
-0.4461622834,
0.6607362032,
-0.2380600572,
-0.3950028121,
-0.2314159572,
-0.2460501343,
0.8902565241,
-0.2914691269,
0.2004876137,
-0.3281790316,
0.3174421489,
0.5072336793,
-0.6968913674,
0.8145592213,
-0.2561292052,
-0.1846146733,
0.4169617295,
0.1209861264,
0.4159486592,
-0.0516922884,
-0.391979754,
-0.2087222338,
-0.0181056242,
-0.0638962835,
-0.5923971534,
0.7401419282,
-0.8376392722,
-0.8391030431,
-0.2779526711,
-0.4283155501,
-0.6347408891,
-0.3014112413,
0.0933348909,
0.448663801,
-0.2065822035,
0.2975857854,
0.0778412446,
-0.3998727202,
0.4337567091,
0.3323921561,
-0.5212870836,
-0.5534926653,
0.6247374415,
-0.0171423722,
0.4967551529,
0.1247904673,
0.5156033635,
-0.4173858464,
-0.4451178014,
-0.3989329338,
0.0453094915,
-0.6620548964,
-0.1936943978,
-0.4135415852,
0.0546241477,
-0.2475751191,
0.2382447869,
-0.3077429235,
-0.5974610448,
-0.1870651394,
-0.3804770708,
-0.0605127513,
0.6822147369,
0.0064560641,
0.4293277264,
-0.761362195,
0.1985684484,
0.7697659731,
0.3577658832,
-0.0221169759,
-0.6822565794,
0.2533414066,
-0.1870001107,
-0.3262482285,
-0.8937702179,
0.2124524862,
-0.0170792118,
0.8071154356,
0.5174362063,
-0.3050471544,
0.7479009628,
-0.4901939034,
0.9956886768,
0.2619180083,
-0.9372231364,
0.253598243,
-0.3126649857,
0.1985558271,
0.6900241971,
-0.125585407,
-0.3270443976,
-0.6276404262,
-0.5483680964,
-0.7186771035,
0.7036545873,
-0.0849198774,
0.2821907699,
0.0778747052,
0.1235269904,
0.4935105145,
0.3937265873,
-0.9131143689,
0.3056674004,
-0.0928270221,
-0.0824280828,
-0.0952397808,
-0.3776494265,
-0.1986094564,
-0.3068399727,
0.7927998304,
-0.1589640677,
-0.0529535748,
-0.0891406685,
0.1516436189,
-0.1291964948,
0.6409608126,
0.3067112565,
0.7815222144,
-0.0351084769,
0.1260219812,
0.0066379835,
0.1512182355,
0.3603060842,
0.1524548531,
-0.3256978989,
0.1527195871,
0.3396012783,
1.0983222723,
0.1356425732,
-0.5713994503,
0.684089005,
0.1756373346,
-0.2972709537,
0.0873637646,
0.1630673856,
0.1639859974,
0.4584856033,
0.0164493714,
0.0258769672,
0.0343373306,
-0.7347126007,
0.1529513597,
0.5767002702,
-0.3700975478,
-0.0464690551,
0.7760266662,
0.3531545103,
0.1052598283,
0.546754837,
-0.231609717,
-0.4904670119,
0.5789759755,
0.2624965906,
0.9959093332,
-0.321973443,
0.3052064478,
0.0737003535,
0.4609584808,
-0.3076500297,
0.1112735271,
0.2366508991,
-0.8283964992,
-0.6229093671,
-0.8206453323,
-0.6476255059,
0.4227569103,
-0.3052996397,
0.0445987396,
-0.4157304168,
-0.3948432803,
-0.1451551318,
-0.1135870367,
-0.7521770597,
0.1301576793,
0.3557998836,
0.9065912366,
-0.9909530878,
0.5770005584,
0.4247278869,
-0.3978164494,
-0.7785047889,
-0.0474673994,
0.1555410773,
-0.6548000574,
0.6409397125,
0.1742580086,
0.0551994331,
-0.4344240427,
-0.5231221914,
-0.7517205477,
0.6310626268,
0.3182802498,
-0.897868216,
0.0175282042,
-0.1250904948,
0.4941639006,
-0.3453641236,
0.6740261316,
0.704128623,
0.7464283705,
-0.2167941034,
-1.0631427765,
-0.045374237,
-0.1393478811,
0.2359242886,
0.0546856634,
-0.7953734994,
1.0606199503,
0.0197648183,
-0.0738508999,
0.1546058208,
0.407197237,
0.4792273045,
0.1418712735,
0.8007804751,
0.3804803491,
0.7162111998,
-0.2015723735,
1.0432684422,
-0.1685594767,
0.3595001698,
1.3243758678,
-0.7336972952,
0.6076440215,
0.5581117868,
-0.5515711904,
0.2404282391,
0.5447154641,
-0.2224690616,
0.3515115678,
0.6081196666,
-0.4499026239,
-0.5495899916,
0.2693614662,
-0.1376738697,
0.6947003603,
-0.0577229448,
-0.4252825379,
-0.6768421531,
0.0235775355,
0.0113159679,
0.2686612308,
-0.2179181725,
0.4603652656,
0.2319072038,
-0.7253113985,
0.0168988407,
0.0841845796,
0.5370495319,
-0.5611121655,
0.1881358176,
-0.5217953324,
0.1230269596,
-0.0665081292,
-0.6464185119,
-0.0513935313,
0.153699249,
0.0525090471,
-0.2766611576,
0.4606949091,
-0.3176057339,
-0.7708323002,
0.3721592128,
0.9633845687,
0.1948703527,
-0.2363751382,
-0.400098592,
0.0104948357,
0.2025995404,
-0.7256404161,
0.3378172219,
0.1862695068,
-0.3063331544,
0.6157597899,
0.7402625084,
0.3074541092,
0.1027279645,
0.7067987919,
1.1242518425,
-0.5714582801,
-0.3017780185,
-0.8368394971,
0.336274296,
-0.1373155862,
-0.3645537794,
0.6176327467,
0.5450226068,
0.7607616186,
-0.0103124995,
1.0101429224,
0.3121727109,
0.5860771537,
-0.5568780899,
0.6415183544,
-0.5704266429,
0.3691453934,
-0.2573903799,
-1.2531512976,
-0.0945873633,
0.4408767521,
-0.4794328511,
0.4456879497,
0.5305400491,
0.7023836374,
-0.1202812418,
0.3113758862,
0.5143100619,
0.283075273,
0.83273983,
0.4966169596,
1.2864005566,
-0.0182781145,
0.3629907072,
-0.0897904262,
-0.3819110096,
-0.1591929048,
-0.7400690317,
-0.8675981164,
0.0159283467,
-0.1229605153,
-0.0626706779,
-0.0637632012,
1.0035389662,
0.4016594589,
-0.7653752565,
-0.2387555242,
0.4258737266,
0.0421764031,
-0.0700082704,
-0.204585433,
0.2426149994,
-0.4450811744,
-0.9920681715,
0.9546838403,
0.2922767401,
-0.3231895864,
-0.4495380521,
0.2734580338,
0.1836407781,
0.130459398,
0.6856715083,
-0.2429907918,
-0.9261283875,
-0.6424157619,
-0.5534726381,
-0.1049819738,
0.1330821365,
0.6371600032,
-0.7722418308,
0.6206812859,
0.5923182368,
0.5722155571,
0.645690918,
0.2597207427,
0.7030347586,
-0.2586463988,
-0.2110718489,
0.2812571526,
0.6822859645,
0.3623655438,
0.1588422209,
0.5841616392,
0.1628115028,
-0.6316055655,
-0.7917333245,
0.2603819072,
-0.8550239801,
-0.3505878747,
1.1710937023,
0.0390745178,
0.0855503902,
0.0930475965,
-0.2452807873,
-0.1103067026,
-0.1980664581,
0.67636621,
0.9192634821,
-0.2155621946,
-0.1095651463,
-0.6570664048,
0.0632833317,
0.4238437116,
-0.7045474052,
-0.1094438881,
0.7348726392,
0.5631355047,
-0.1192453206,
0.7739508152,
-0.4655448794,
-0.0667997524,
-0.013951702,
0.0604532696,
0.0844379216,
-0.1418056935,
-0.4980297089,
0.3604167104,
0.2857714295,
0.1361684352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18784v1
|
Where on Earth Do Users Say They Are?: Geo-Entity Linking for Noisy Multilingual User Input
| 2024-04-29T15:18:33 | 2024-04-29T15:18:33 |
Tessa Masis, Brendan O'Connor
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Geo-entity linking is the task of linking a location mention to the
real-world geographic location. In this paper we explore the challenging task
of geo-entity linking for noisy, multilingual social media data. There are few
open-source multilingual geo-entity linking tools available and existing ones
are often rule-based, which break easily in social media settings, or
LLM-based, which are too expensive for large-scale datasets. We present a
method which represents real-world locations as averaged embeddings from
labeled user-input location names and allows for selective prediction via an
interpretable confidence score. We show that our approach improves geo-entity
linking on a global and multilingual social media dataset, and discuss progress
and problems with evaluating at different geographic granularities.
|
[
-0.631885767,
-1.0181409121,
0.8039977551,
0.3311716616,
-0.3642344475,
0.1390099376,
-0.5070694685,
-1.0027056932,
0.6816849113,
0.0187374167,
-0.5398629904,
-0.9129544497,
-0.4209605157,
0.0983505249,
-0.2300757915,
0.6689426303,
-0.2016000897,
-0.1968303621,
-0.1327455789,
-0.0538868941,
0.0286950804,
-0.519494772,
-0.5699111223,
0.0609761998,
0.7976850271,
0.452898562,
1.0578588247,
0.4305187464,
0.2525757849,
0.1663499326,
0.0288108867,
0.4188341498,
-0.5156689286,
0.4303247631,
-0.3494493067,
-0.024597289,
-0.0592910796,
-0.1877091974,
0.5989485383,
0.7200555205,
0.0104708485,
0.3958095014,
-0.0655622706,
0.0322809331,
-0.5345995426,
0.3111334741,
-0.6624205709,
-0.1327038258,
-0.2206441611,
-0.0150718242,
0.0871006697,
-0.6907562613,
0.0288945846,
-0.6033420563,
0.3522767425,
0.4881449342,
1.0378315449,
0.1155987009,
-0.4511890709,
-0.2063301504,
-0.8189178109,
0.5089150667,
0.1052869856,
0.7470183969,
0.7682060003,
0.089142181,
-0.1023267508,
-0.1591256857,
-0.3942130506,
-0.0102121169,
-0.0810104609,
-0.1989912242,
-0.072583504,
-0.2694110572,
0.124191612,
-0.1279246211,
-0.2257353812,
-0.1060086638,
-0.4289420843,
-0.1045916304,
0.6561740637,
-0.4623492658,
0.2868893743,
-0.2143827379,
-0.152210474,
0.3524267673,
-0.8751990199,
-0.2157545239,
0.7382018566,
0.6146121621,
-0.155186832,
0.5538514256,
-0.2351026684,
0.1778206974,
0.0911748931,
-0.0732864216,
0.3003383875,
-0.2667157948,
0.242635712,
0.3942433596,
0.8703642488,
0.5979976058,
0.5159992576,
-0.5726726651,
-0.1002639905,
-0.2954743803,
0.1028109491,
-0.5936030746,
-0.2694272697,
0.1707355976,
-0.1292202771,
0.0279661268,
0.2676798701,
-0.6017366648,
-0.3485915065,
-0.0572471321,
0.0117608868,
-0.1815602332,
-0.1958994418,
-0.2238242328,
0.3538408577,
-0.4100365043,
0.22696051,
-0.8764764667,
0.0697081834,
0.4947040379,
0.7931949496,
0.3667520583,
-0.6005190611,
-0.2048651576,
0.3009997904,
-0.2214635462,
1.0663710833,
-0.6041307449,
-0.4704089761,
0.2793522477,
0.3016913831,
0.1730706692,
-0.4791596234,
0.6093663573,
-0.6240733266,
-0.1370586902,
-0.885838449,
0.0305515658,
-0.1883290112,
0.04123969,
-0.7227615714,
1.5542041063,
-0.1702149212,
-0.5410395861,
0.671497345,
-0.3336782753,
-0.7307320237,
0.1088247821,
0.1295496523,
-0.200480029,
0.0178129617,
0.5346128345,
0.472060591,
0.0097214077,
0.5868879557,
-0.7093434334,
-0.464019537,
0.2456626743,
-0.312004447,
0.48936674,
0.2794142365,
-0.1633112878,
-0.4121226072,
-0.5936461687,
-0.1230693981,
0.0504901372,
-0.4414480031,
-0.5194467306,
0.3782099187,
-0.179624483,
0.2042192519,
0.4137155712,
-0.5082467794,
-0.0412127562,
0.0286317933,
0.1376193911,
0.4089297056,
0.1794671267,
0.5535188913,
0.0150364917,
0.2987481654,
-0.0867434666,
-0.1887936741,
0.1547653526,
-0.6409381032,
-0.2234731168,
-0.0532207377,
0.3373503983,
0.4655397236,
-0.7031089067,
0.2085214108,
-0.6485829353,
-0.4735296667,
-0.7245647311,
0.4910325408,
0.0401029326,
0.5048587322,
0.5851927996,
0.2043729872,
-0.5840060711,
-0.5955694318,
-0.4183747172,
-0.6486235261,
-0.1650169492,
0.5646885633,
0.2709632218,
-0.0591842309,
0.4172505736,
-0.5369575024,
-0.2209204435,
-0.0316939801,
-0.0323094316,
-0.2662174404,
-0.1179767996,
0.4907332063,
-0.8519567847,
-0.8666262627,
-0.099699758,
-0.6426010728,
-0.2663004994,
0.0651963204,
-0.3707205653,
-0.0693676099,
0.4803426564,
-0.6147270799,
0.0713263527,
0.5572296381,
-0.2297248393,
0.2435780019,
0.0452991053,
0.4197915196,
-1.0439198017,
-0.2279473841,
0.5306337476,
-0.2867932916,
-0.1839565933,
-0.0536633246,
-0.176113531,
-0.1347067058,
-0.3457536995,
0.4825534523,
-0.6627116799,
-0.2035842389,
0.3156123459,
0.5116087198,
-0.1509227306,
0.239612624,
0.0811200961,
0.6665543914,
0.4968081117,
-0.3641287982,
0.392997086,
0.0216028262,
-0.3895078897,
0.6127884388,
-0.31632635,
0.0311112106,
-0.1301023215,
0.164116323,
-1.0097814798,
-0.5797086358,
0.2198654115,
-0.3869434893,
-0.0009659783,
-0.4887621999,
-0.7686197758,
-0.1748904735,
-0.1672118753,
0.3864002526,
0.0005451682,
-0.6505052447,
0.3553507328,
0.7712131143,
-0.4030644894,
-0.4022992849,
-0.7017886639,
0.3396407068,
-0.4345118403,
-0.6029620767,
0.4373095036,
0.1661213636,
-0.3692244589,
0.4696126878,
0.1307531297,
-0.2806189954,
0.1528281569,
0.4706670344,
-0.0293556545,
-0.0943515673,
0.4046020508,
-0.005030843,
0.0787244588,
0.2989419103,
-0.3314660192,
0.0985381156,
0.0284141451,
-0.3124772608,
-0.1976630837,
0.5162639022,
0.1919513047,
-0.0294754505,
0.8434141278,
0.7408023477,
-0.7692848444,
-0.0724603683,
-0.5663721561,
0.2167202085,
-0.4136427343,
0.3604376912,
-0.3433153331,
-0.7131560445,
0.7030246854,
-0.4103116095,
-0.1819566339,
0.1368070692,
0.450060308,
-0.3627687097,
0.6829869747,
0.6326423287,
-0.1661823094,
0.3214142025,
0.3465442657,
0.7274410725,
-0.2727502882,
-0.3260928094,
-0.5856430531,
-0.6628385186,
-0.7858240604,
-0.4929676056,
0.2822083533,
0.2257720679,
-0.0713997409,
0.4302528203,
-0.0454085842,
0.7384773493,
0.5177304745,
0.115670003,
0.1328843832,
0.489402324,
-0.2217284739,
-0.2812172174,
-0.5551258922,
-0.3827448785,
0.7036061287,
0.1249220818,
0.9463318586,
0.4368086457,
0.6574466825,
0.0611941442,
0.2557478249,
-0.6680129766,
0.2923550308,
-0.0120491814,
-0.6736108661,
-0.3864612877,
-0.2269715667,
-0.878770411,
0.1243746132,
-0.6097952127,
-0.9643832445,
-0.0076336632,
0.1440155804,
-0.430909574,
0.5553398728,
-0.6812520027,
0.5142751932,
-0.1497760862,
-0.4996940196,
0.2582637966,
-0.5197912455,
0.0677992105,
-0.062776126,
0.6043021083,
-0.3448022008,
0.0780952126,
0.2340404391,
-0.0489284955,
0.85643363,
-0.2333473414,
-0.2543648779,
0.5755314827,
-0.036137905,
0.4308125973,
0.4042286873,
-0.0913501978,
0.6530213356,
-0.4311501086,
-0.0719700381,
-0.2850618362,
1.2853792906,
-0.7824067473,
-0.1204516813,
0.0574156567,
-0.3499833047,
-0.245406419,
0.0711421072,
0.3365702033,
0.317920357,
-0.2106595784,
0.0836112574,
0.7544533014,
0.0630182698,
0.1496428996,
0.2186652273,
-0.1329447925,
-0.2655377388,
0.8406443596,
0.6130517721,
-0.3278106451,
0.2831546664,
-0.2256605625,
-0.853084147,
0.0134885004,
-0.4048919678,
0.3073835075,
-0.7660663128,
-0.0848411396,
-0.6776174307,
0.1496492177,
-0.4006586671,
-0.5615745187,
-0.2975387573,
-0.2387646884,
-0.1391687989,
-0.4640408456,
0.0587644577,
0.5810039043,
-0.1961844414,
0.2651156485,
-0.4643320143,
0.4513453245,
-0.0980864763,
0.6641226411,
-0.2675826848,
0.0440864153,
-0.5564345717,
0.0205293167,
-0.0055040186,
-1.019205451,
0.1713820696,
0.3512537181,
0.4597994983,
0.2317793816,
0.0484154522,
0.9838187099,
-0.6876783371,
0.7015456557,
-0.1357714981,
-0.4627614021,
0.5840905309,
0.0224217158,
0.0728408694,
0.5039085746,
0.8549748063,
-0.5507180095,
-0.606238246,
-0.3902599216,
-1.0313335657,
0.0709536374,
-0.2549071312,
0.3522704244,
-0.3894914687,
0.5232674479,
-0.1703185439,
0.0181758106,
-0.7704683542,
-0.4481746852,
0.0680736154,
-0.1968589574,
-0.1178704351,
-0.4542991221,
-0.1638483256,
0.0292959008,
0.7406362891,
-0.1558157504,
0.0780507475,
0.1977068037,
-0.3857892752,
-0.5807923079,
0.2908640504,
0.10155572,
0.7189851999,
-0.2362661511,
0.3823987246,
0.3384845853,
-0.334017396,
0.0739336014,
0.3553370237,
-0.5351717472,
0.3123696148,
0.0423340425,
0.4660722315,
0.7481960654,
-0.134525314,
0.2321512401,
-0.1259904057,
-0.0414066426,
-0.4433785379,
-0.199147895,
0.4790733755,
0.3229180276,
0.3176745474,
-0.0591794066,
0.045350384,
-0.3699626923,
0.0491752736,
0.2145330608,
-0.6043319106,
-0.5744377971,
1.0450081825,
0.2236746103,
-0.1438386589,
0.4929507375,
-0.4982500374,
-0.3640989661,
0.0646892637,
0.4719360173,
0.8935035467,
-0.1937177777,
0.184936285,
0.8555549383,
0.5223767757,
-0.0223122202,
0.5685492754,
0.0157684255,
-0.7895563245,
-0.4188743234,
-0.6374457479,
-0.1899903119,
-0.1574239582,
-0.6473234296,
0.5604705215,
-0.3864449859,
-0.430170089,
-0.0252885614,
0.0102845561,
-0.7878265381,
0.1587455422,
0.4740433693,
0.5798398852,
-1.0083581209,
0.5256645679,
1.2004493475,
0.0388083197,
-0.5599333644,
0.1325698346,
0.4245418906,
-0.516512394,
0.2966485918,
0.1481238008,
-0.4464164078,
-0.1334201992,
-0.8534033895,
-1.0179579258,
0.9636849761,
0.3821929395,
-0.2598650753,
0.0526110753,
0.0545031279,
0.4166461825,
-0.2391075045,
-0.0973981619,
0.1131848469,
0.3295439482,
-0.1058942229,
-0.6967847943,
0.2306625843,
-0.0051987614,
-0.1532631665,
0.2699058056,
-0.7871495485,
0.3901548088,
-0.5894662738,
-0.4451098442,
-0.3638173342,
0.9079138637,
0.1783128679,
0.2593623698,
0.5504458547,
0.5469098091,
1.166580677,
-0.3446729183,
0.8087630868,
-0.7196090221,
0.6227796078,
1.2336063385,
-0.3755480051,
0.9306901693,
0.2352032512,
-0.148536846,
0.6442970634,
0.7944498062,
-0.1497301608,
0.5766065717,
-0.1293946058,
-0.413993746,
-0.3500762284,
-0.4000098407,
-0.0491180941,
0.292601794,
0.5545171499,
-0.1298465729,
-0.5143322349,
-0.5948826075,
0.2648471594,
0.0245485306,
-0.2021799833,
0.4603584111,
0.0619869642,
-0.4657608271,
0.0835065618,
0.061544843,
0.4219372571,
-0.5371239781,
0.0257441234,
0.0858339146,
-0.3797045052,
-0.3606945574,
-0.9103286266,
0.4326331019,
0.1129159927,
-0.23046574,
-0.1524307579,
0.8720276356,
-0.8226279616,
-0.6114639044,
0.5333938003,
0.5555534959,
0.4155339599,
-0.191413939,
-0.6622799635,
-0.1170139685,
-0.1470161974,
-0.1928540915,
0.1828075945,
0.794793129,
-0.3198174834,
0.7833331227,
0.8091984391,
0.1271561384,
0.134781763,
0.2768402398,
0.553286314,
-0.6851817966,
-0.5304629803,
-0.6945935488,
0.2048131227,
0.1477920264,
-0.3423485756,
0.7217894197,
0.498531431,
1.1546792984,
0.4375672042,
0.9727010727,
-0.0610378496,
0.3350523412,
-0.2853096426,
0.5531827211,
-0.5253377557,
0.2329312861,
-0.1477940679,
-1.2533836365,
-0.406940937,
0.4964790642,
-0.1882452518,
0.0136597082,
0.4380681515,
0.741989851,
-0.308298856,
-0.3314547241,
0.3498410583,
0.1661966741,
-0.064141728,
0.3303907514,
0.7092112303,
-0.1143351346,
0.5293731093,
-0.6162365675,
0.1308510751,
-0.223258689,
-0.868435204,
-0.5881587267,
-0.3843230009,
-0.5811647177,
-0.541672349,
-0.1087903976,
0.9219142795,
0.5867205858,
-0.8262802958,
0.1921040416,
0.7916887999,
0.4339732826,
-0.0169590954,
-0.1811955273,
0.3153063953,
-0.0821039304,
-0.9078669548,
0.2819614112,
0.3089496195,
0.1084197462,
-0.2829732597,
0.1603975445,
-0.3190315068,
-0.1637448668,
0.3910321593,
0.1543635428,
-0.8181723952,
-0.5731823444,
-0.0138342967,
-0.2325831652,
-0.1082423627,
0.2382154465,
-0.3601863086,
0.4349796176,
0.1746610254,
0.2529965341,
0.1531085223,
0.5486347675,
0.1858270913,
-1.1400709152,
-0.04399148,
-0.3463232517,
0.6786358356,
0.6857184768,
-0.7781527638,
0.5557131767,
0.1948440224,
-0.5652612448,
-0.383990109,
-0.1420315206,
-0.4974092543,
0.0348729268,
1.5372267962,
-0.3802386224,
-0.2253432572,
-0.3436023593,
0.0723735467,
0.1373473406,
-0.4913674295,
0.8664391637,
0.9506394267,
0.3043835759,
0.1041256413,
-0.946003139,
0.3182091713,
-0.1751788557,
-0.3463958502,
-0.1054546088,
0.6827735901,
0.5461224318,
0.4207293391,
0.663951695,
0.0104138786,
-0.0915726572,
0.1864193678,
0.0767992064,
0.1726220697,
-0.4901699424,
-0.0644530877,
0.143480435,
0.0373239443,
0.0917613953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18759v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18759v2
|
Towards A Structured Overview of Use Cases for Natural Language Processing in the Legal Domain: A German Perspective
| 2024-04-29T14:56:47 | 2024-05-02T09:56:51 |
Juraj Vladika, Stephen Meisenbacher, Martina Preis, Alexandra Klymenko, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
In recent years, the field of Legal Tech has risen in prevalence, as the
Natural Language Processing (NLP) and legal disciplines have combined forces to
digitalize legal processes. Amidst the steady flow of research solutions
stemming from the NLP domain, the study of use cases has fallen behind, leading
to a number of innovative technical methods without a place in practice. In
this work, we aim to build a structured overview of Legal Tech use cases,
grounded in NLP literature, but also supplemented by voices from legal practice
in Germany. Based upon a Systematic Literature Review, we identify seven
categories of NLP technologies for the legal domain, which are then studied in
juxtaposition to 22 legal use cases. In the investigation of these use cases,
we identify 15 ethical, legal, and social aspects (ELSA), shedding light on the
potential concerns of digitally transforming the legal domain.
|
[
-0.5269300342,
-0.8331149817,
0.6841739416,
-0.0498540662,
-0.4676021039,
0.109426789,
-0.1153971255,
-0.5635036826,
0.1835947782,
0.8329628706,
-0.2802090347,
-0.7621589303,
-0.3833566904,
0.119480364,
-0.8241145611,
1.0223385096,
0.0579684563,
0.192612499,
0.0309385657,
-0.2753984928,
-0.6238383651,
-0.7686465979,
-0.5909370184,
-0.3296925128,
0.19996126,
0.1586294323,
0.68466115,
0.2746476531,
0.439588964,
0.3134550452,
-0.2056382149,
-0.480971992,
0.037212234,
0.0688705891,
-0.2158320248,
-0.3091436923,
-0.5409603715,
-0.0776070505,
0.4611946046,
0.5762609839,
-0.5640298128,
0.0792453066,
-0.2507301867,
0.6190345287,
-0.4499012232,
-0.0499249734,
-0.4122277796,
0.5240498185,
-0.2409536242,
-0.3410495818,
-0.2230863273,
-0.1323455125,
0.0947203934,
-0.5952067375,
0.4388171732,
0.0578076988,
0.7750316262,
0.1998056769,
-0.6211940646,
-0.4699839056,
-1.0033028126,
0.4380469918,
-0.8683504462,
0.2452919334,
0.2721809447,
0.5881652832,
-0.3053779006,
-1.0703129768,
-0.5739623308,
-0.0295889098,
-0.1715117246,
0.0688225925,
-0.5379269719,
0.1981565058,
0.4550857246,
0.1403478086,
-0.5919460654,
0.1439213008,
-0.5032376051,
-0.2812149823,
0.707333982,
-0.1081581712,
0.5134875178,
0.0643451959,
0.2065264881,
0.123230949,
-0.5546984673,
0.2382486463,
0.5463402271,
0.1890089661,
0.0422449932,
0.7019524574,
-0.0138543434,
0.8804209232,
-0.034532737,
-0.0661377832,
0.4976246953,
-0.4054977298,
-0.2762225866,
0.2268597335,
0.6523097157,
0.3117505908,
0.5262590051,
-0.1041957811,
-0.3187705576,
-0.4518022537,
0.8160159588,
-0.5141960979,
0.4275321066,
0.6024389863,
-0.5453247428,
-0.0750483349,
0.2238372713,
-0.4045054317,
-0.3984535336,
-0.4723869264,
-0.3189554811,
-0.3617424071,
-0.2511271238,
0.4746247828,
-0.4497296512,
0.5288522243,
0.0603415817,
-0.6939959526,
0.6351797581,
0.9738438129,
0.5495592952,
0.308200866,
0.1652556211,
-0.4342879057,
0.1065966338,
-0.2500614822,
0.8870436549,
-0.4277115166,
-0.5595504642,
0.6582484245,
0.0208868291,
0.2541005015,
-0.6639272571,
1.1303955317,
-0.7532913089,
0.2833776176,
0.1010216549,
-0.5227505565,
-0.436991483,
0.1238538548,
-0.8843101859,
0.8833661079,
-0.2480181009,
-0.8736628294,
0.9590041637,
-1.041851759,
-0.9563698173,
0.6085695624,
-0.2592445016,
-0.3239664733,
0.311989218,
-0.1228896454,
0.3655925989,
0.0561302416,
0.8298741579,
-0.0144408988,
-0.3935111463,
-0.1348086149,
0.3685599864,
1.0915837288,
0.222081393,
-0.3648551404,
0.2848622799,
-0.8734428287,
-0.2125280052,
-0.0446037464,
-0.1555059105,
-0.6654638648,
0.1433221102,
0.3390909433,
0.5590114594,
-0.1759677678,
-0.5765795112,
-0.2154257894,
-0.4074365497,
0.661749959,
0.1325735599,
0.0682958737,
0.5552318096,
-0.1632202417,
0.788382113,
-0.1995095164,
0.1061654761,
0.0992858186,
-0.6232586503,
-0.4203414917,
-0.1036206856,
0.4938907325,
0.6648679376,
-0.7562608719,
0.5312168598,
-0.3353060484,
-0.3021078408,
-0.8196542859,
-0.1694114208,
0.0325171277,
0.4676735997,
0.1120116189,
-0.0745740458,
-0.5406306386,
-1.3238899708,
-0.486174643,
-0.270406574,
-0.2172915637,
0.4675967395,
0.7220463753,
-0.1886851192,
1.2043972015,
0.1181020588,
-0.4771657884,
-0.3209997714,
0.1753786206,
0.4649729431,
0.0360490829,
0.5563815832,
-1.2598190308,
-0.3681783378,
0.0601051748,
-0.8746754527,
-0.2035889775,
-0.1718969643,
0.1358954608,
0.3318594992,
0.6274223924,
-0.400903374,
0.3641791344,
-0.0676423609,
-0.8225092888,
0.2722838819,
-0.2598280907,
0.1854291409,
-0.7340206504,
0.1420653909,
0.190743044,
-0.5073838234,
-0.9505021572,
0.2391685545,
0.0341548286,
-0.0577939339,
-0.8812806606,
0.4343977869,
-0.172023192,
-0.2930458188,
-0.2900072932,
0.083248429,
-0.0042566592,
0.1281392723,
0.1222267523,
0.667201221,
0.3179925084,
-0.4219298959,
0.2084554136,
0.2116497159,
-0.3494510353,
0.9585126638,
-0.6730409265,
-0.0011006927,
-0.0925265625,
-0.002437128,
-0.1426472515,
0.0676384568,
0.2563106418,
-0.0665739179,
0.3018037379,
-0.5123848319,
-1.0553848743,
-0.2653672397,
-0.2820848227,
0.0531412438,
0.4486541748,
0.255936712,
0.9373894334,
0.8225526214,
-0.4242162704,
-0.3140702844,
-0.8189672828,
0.6508516073,
-0.6821960807,
-0.8845319152,
0.7310606837,
0.3347422183,
-0.6749696732,
0.3514195383,
0.0781105831,
-0.4538826048,
0.3543143868,
0.125566572,
-0.2213415653,
-0.0680585057,
0.0129919928,
0.1316884607,
0.0539551899,
0.2402475625,
-0.2959177792,
0.4476903081,
-0.2268712074,
-0.2220502347,
-0.3766283691,
0.7040210366,
0.0662100539,
0.1817413419,
0.4118738472,
0.3910050094,
-0.4523341954,
-0.1361309439,
-0.4777061343,
0.1189106107,
-0.4256592095,
0.0737381205,
-0.352609247,
-1.0828375816,
0.5753557086,
0.1401771903,
0.5004552007,
0.7694375515,
0.5005511045,
-0.4042393565,
0.3883400559,
1.2257959843,
0.3238404095,
0.6871935725,
0.081145905,
0.5115994215,
-0.1797479242,
-0.2184625566,
-0.7481164932,
0.0405018963,
-0.7154203653,
0.1465367228,
0.3330845237,
-0.0194039103,
0.0480515547,
0.7379834056,
-0.1197170243,
0.1703011543,
0.7764965892,
-0.3146099448,
0.6417950988,
0.1433353722,
-0.2361658365,
0.0147429425,
-0.8528847098,
-1.0585010052,
0.7408093214,
0.2816244662,
-0.0673017129,
-0.1458172798,
0.9818695188,
0.8295052052,
-0.0597922541,
-0.989038825,
0.6296573877,
-0.1685333103,
-0.7862058282,
-0.2209287882,
-0.0937943161,
-1.2431188822,
-0.0395621061,
-0.0418061689,
-0.5077716112,
0.0409604423,
-0.1561498195,
-0.4974740148,
0.0298080668,
-0.6206640005,
0.8151651621,
-0.0293501299,
-0.2844866216,
-0.463098526,
-0.6776058078,
0.1461425871,
-0.2143239975,
0.7031222582,
0.0772041976,
0.1213317961,
0.8880037069,
-0.6346372366,
0.6890985966,
-0.0786175877,
-0.3213106394,
0.6501405239,
-0.1199264824,
0.0875963941,
-0.1050546765,
0.0286532436,
0.276445657,
0.4423539042,
-0.1741348952,
-0.5219822526,
0.2604369819,
-0.0593839288,
-0.5636616349,
-0.630423069,
-0.1869773269,
-0.0771971568,
0.5650622249,
-0.0701184124,
0.0327804238,
-0.2758112252,
-0.0495224521,
0.2034373432,
-0.0515776984,
0.6317208409,
0.801422894,
0.0261007268,
-0.0549656004,
0.3584281504,
0.2734137774,
-0.4106807709,
-0.0520676002,
0.0564008392,
-0.3564213812,
-0.8655019999,
-0.3319081068,
0.2084545493,
-0.8763912916,
0.1776285172,
-0.5942872167,
-0.1962884068,
-0.3574065268,
-0.3304361403,
0.0533367582,
-0.500241816,
0.002303214,
-0.1524380296,
0.2115586996,
0.7717051506,
0.230279237,
0.234511137,
-0.877613008,
0.5040621161,
-0.1230547354,
0.5810233355,
-0.5833009481,
-0.4483852386,
-0.0680956915,
-0.2114966363,
0.0216876362,
-0.4320909381,
0.4403692782,
0.0021041685,
0.6444755793,
0.0667872429,
-0.0040503065,
0.4769279957,
-0.864280045,
0.6671224833,
-0.0957284644,
-0.7847931981,
0.6166568995,
-0.4023475349,
-0.0142411478,
0.8234369755,
0.2394137979,
-0.8599267602,
-0.345317781,
-0.9839419127,
-1.156316638,
0.6251550913,
0.4688085318,
0.28404513,
0.4189130366,
0.3693670928,
0.038812574,
0.5096089244,
-0.6932421923,
-0.0888960734,
0.0789669827,
0.0701695159,
0.258255899,
-0.1273287535,
-0.3778418601,
-0.0546109155,
0.6885924935,
0.1517080814,
0.0272947848,
0.0978828147,
-0.3993490338,
0.3354106843,
0.5066460967,
0.4608507752,
0.6754701138,
-0.0305369012,
0.0204109866,
-0.1940755397,
-0.4614442885,
-0.0437101945,
0.1996047795,
-0.7275636196,
0.3800752759,
0.4232036769,
0.4584459066,
0.1554541737,
-0.8307330012,
0.3706860244,
-0.2000509351,
-0.4995809495,
-0.8175694942,
-0.1843759716,
0.0116587924,
0.3590947688,
0.2583405375,
-0.1446734071,
0.761388123,
-0.594745338,
0.4020749927,
0.2980225682,
-0.3864020705,
-0.1819427758,
0.3611441851,
0.2775279284,
-0.7386752367,
0.1403305531,
-0.3349300623,
-0.2184499949,
0.4794146717,
0.1755529046,
1.2169232368,
0.5265604854,
0.3221623302,
-0.0511168763,
0.1385065466,
-0.2472541332,
0.5682137609,
-0.2253081352,
-0.5219070911,
-0.4815034866,
-0.3777592778,
-0.1669261754,
-0.0344809368,
-0.5262978077,
0.5347047448,
-0.358871609,
-0.5190708637,
0.2168519348,
0.0111123836,
-0.6085649729,
-0.3621974587,
0.0398935378,
0.9533619285,
-0.6325745583,
0.8223875165,
0.8819256425,
-0.2673487663,
0.0163048636,
0.035626363,
0.1554638147,
-0.3278340101,
0.4779373705,
-0.039087493,
-0.3875070214,
-0.1751284003,
-0.4477795064,
-0.1905087382,
0.7850872874,
0.1511325091,
-0.5060911179,
0.0298863985,
0.366589874,
1.0515851974,
-0.1044248715,
-0.1448223293,
0.903491199,
0.4126259983,
-0.0182690602,
-0.8425086141,
-0.0335319713,
-0.5435793996,
-0.1484388709,
0.067624703,
0.1309098154,
-0.003476342,
0.1432431638,
-0.8107278943,
-0.4203184545,
0.3356866241,
0.0213326719,
0.4936874509,
0.4655555785,
0.3477857709,
0.6149758101,
0.1143228933,
1.1826785803,
-0.4298192263,
0.0124389343,
0.9099185467,
-0.4773934484,
0.5377004743,
0.7088930011,
-0.2049695551,
0.4383151531,
0.4767033458,
-0.2116278261,
0.2178002596,
0.2831335366,
-0.2031148821,
-0.0750413164,
-0.4241378903,
0.0815310925,
0.3471964598,
0.3036406636,
-0.1371555775,
-0.4190560281,
-0.1577446163,
0.1966923028,
0.3745817244,
-0.2077630609,
1.0713280439,
0.1296201348,
-0.7132316828,
0.1222348511,
0.4711817503,
0.6238945723,
-0.4237734675,
-0.2007745504,
-0.0408900939,
-0.3917877674,
-0.3195969462,
-1.0829490423,
0.7914616466,
0.4379514754,
0.0886741132,
-0.779764235,
0.832290709,
0.1397583187,
-0.5162225366,
0.4347962141,
0.6224057674,
0.3158253431,
-0.0435543694,
-0.6597819328,
-0.5422731042,
-0.4673928618,
-0.2989372611,
0.2348571122,
0.4670959115,
-0.5268485546,
0.5518289804,
0.5196760893,
0.0440620445,
0.2439345568,
0.4658696055,
0.7159618735,
-1.0554995537,
-0.5642120838,
-0.8956587911,
0.6091546416,
-0.2563635409,
-0.2540181875,
0.6086788177,
0.5223723054,
0.8537741303,
0.209361285,
0.7751604319,
-0.3808735311,
0.2764931321,
-0.6557646394,
0.5494408607,
-0.2341546714,
0.2016171068,
-0.1147861108,
-0.6391331553,
-0.6927208304,
0.4701381922,
-0.1037958339,
-0.1463315338,
0.469380945,
0.180039525,
-0.1458238959,
0.1128688976,
0.4687130153,
-0.1276070774,
0.3215416372,
-0.0551694855,
0.3676412702,
-0.245205,
0.3800588548,
-0.3811920881,
0.1553000361,
-0.1914268732,
-1.0604857206,
-0.7110265493,
-0.5553305745,
-0.2804622948,
-0.3262797892,
-0.1752325892,
0.6935055256,
0.557674408,
-1.0068025589,
-0.4042077065,
-0.1573719382,
0.1792356074,
-0.125599727,
-0.2207898051,
0.0602332726,
-0.5788029432,
-0.5896995068,
0.384570092,
0.383595109,
0.0240864698,
0.0668281168,
0.2078397572,
-0.284694612,
-0.1662188321,
0.7076109052,
0.5013611317,
-0.6665118337,
0.051886104,
-0.1483201981,
-0.049622599,
0.2750694752,
1.4749937057,
-0.7015437484,
0.4327783287,
0.4325163662,
0.5742995143,
0.6251674294,
-0.1770113409,
0.9004128575,
-0.655867219,
0.2612746656,
0.6937144399,
0.7696466446,
0.0087119956,
-0.1202665195,
0.7254853249,
0.2015412748,
-0.1049083024,
-0.7176751494,
0.2067498118,
-0.918012917,
-0.4606845081,
1.163746953,
-0.0850999802,
-0.0690321028,
-0.8493171334,
-0.0048070326,
0.1948071569,
-0.5921297669,
0.8338193893,
1.0252268314,
0.0333493277,
0.0907547697,
-1.4736241102,
0.5303190351,
-0.0153688546,
-0.7499356866,
-0.2247621864,
0.5455496907,
0.0963983387,
0.2642787397,
0.6642822623,
-0.435136795,
0.05974482,
-0.2187256515,
0.2922824621,
0.0163735729,
-0.2671773732,
-0.8317816854,
0.3900727034,
-0.0505606458,
0.3479591906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18977v1
|
Computational Job Market Analysis with Natural Language Processing
| 2024-04-29T14:52:38 | 2024-04-29T14:52:38 |
Mike Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
[Abridged Abstract]
Recent technological advances underscore labor market dynamics, yielding
significant consequences for employment prospects and increasing job vacancy
data across platforms and languages. Aggregating such data holds potential for
valuable insights into labor market demands, new skills emergence, and
facilitating job matching for various stakeholders. However, despite prevalent
insights in the private sector, transparent language technology systems and
data for this domain are lacking. This thesis investigates Natural Language
Processing (NLP) technology for extracting relevant information from job
descriptions, identifying challenges including scarcity of training data, lack
of standardized annotation guidelines, and shortage of effective extraction
methods from job ads. We frame the problem, obtaining annotated data, and
introducing extraction methodologies. Our contributions include job description
datasets, a de-identification dataset, and a novel active learning algorithm
for efficient model training. We propose skill extraction using weak
supervision, a taxonomy-aware pre-training methodology adapting multilingual
language models to the job market domain, and a retrieval-augmented model
leveraging multiple skill extraction datasets to enhance overall performance.
Finally, we ground extracted information within a designated taxonomy.
|
[
-0.116955772,
-0.8501508236,
0.2345931232,
0.1499628723,
0.015110922,
0.0849881992,
-0.3834093511,
-0.8615365028,
0.0948236659,
0.6278035641,
-0.4111109972,
-0.4380726218,
-0.5308167934,
0.0704990402,
-0.302600652,
0.8154034615,
0.2274018824,
-0.3006753922,
-0.1425419152,
0.2195847481,
-0.2731580436,
-0.5099115372,
-0.7748209238,
-0.0334101729,
0.148072049,
0.4383843243,
0.6226876378,
1.0157381296,
0.3697486222,
0.2905499339,
0.1102653891,
-0.0288649779,
-0.0940178856,
0.2881073952,
-0.0143996496,
-0.1319490373,
-0.4635099173,
0.3037827015,
0.6099689007,
1.0196987391,
-0.2066773921,
0.31772542,
-0.0429439358,
0.3791599572,
-0.6386429667,
0.6910468936,
-0.8958779573,
-0.06584768,
-0.4193754494,
-0.1347209811,
-0.1825933456,
-0.197514832,
0.5341305733,
-0.4320818782,
0.3580317795,
-0.169744119,
1.0641405582,
0.102113843,
-0.2681652904,
-0.5620207191,
-0.8135309219,
0.8459723592,
-0.548620522,
0.2307327837,
0.6885256767,
0.4493032098,
0.0851446912,
-0.7411968708,
-0.1028572097,
0.1090078726,
-0.2361555248,
-0.0481091961,
-0.0720831752,
0.0859947801,
0.0957482383,
0.6020449996,
-0.3405273259,
0.4690080583,
-0.8021084666,
0.0548431352,
0.6109926701,
-0.0213143528,
0.1557074636,
-0.0402396359,
-0.1017864719,
-0.0945553854,
-0.2148738205,
0.1510345936,
0.7181789875,
0.5557904243,
0.0247134287,
0.628954649,
-0.3056752086,
0.9770687819,
-0.552280426,
-0.1029507965,
0.0755727142,
-0.1862865686,
-0.2880207896,
-0.0495833792,
0.8869897127,
-0.2354489714,
0.0481416211,
-0.2677000165,
-0.331674248,
0.0149491187,
0.6804248691,
-0.2409720421,
-0.0923553407,
0.1479787529,
-0.393401593,
-0.3158476055,
0.1330083311,
-1.0481956005,
-0.3684181571,
-0.3992712498,
0.0458472706,
-0.0026335579,
-0.3831380904,
0.0786752254,
-0.3134619594,
0.3687749505,
-0.0605932511,
-1.0182899237,
0.6066846251,
0.9379063249,
0.808275938,
-0.2213173211,
0.1634246409,
-0.2046812773,
0.0000959643,
-0.0297566522,
0.4783578813,
-0.7388061285,
0.0666488111,
0.155523777,
0.1513189822,
-0.3961646259,
-0.6044932008,
0.4909414649,
-0.8158558607,
0.2301324606,
0.235983476,
-0.2219745964,
-0.3534178734,
0.4985404611,
-1.0099271536,
1.0956588984,
0.309802413,
-0.656725347,
0.2072076946,
-1.0196985006,
-0.3356460035,
0.1288789064,
-0.2475556433,
-0.4239889085,
-0.0026038673,
0.0769261643,
0.593973875,
-0.2676411271,
0.235755235,
-0.0298401285,
-0.3584906757,
0.2482415438,
-0.3938990533,
0.8621308804,
0.3315522373,
-0.161302492,
-0.2121197432,
-0.7093496919,
-0.2929416001,
0.1864742041,
-0.2554905415,
-0.2197499871,
-0.0412593447,
-0.0365866609,
0.2952295244,
0.3105075657,
-0.3466603756,
0.0806083456,
-0.6683830619,
0.2944453061,
0.4753191173,
-0.1381707788,
0.5025141239,
0.062896125,
0.7903037071,
-0.3862265944,
0.1010276005,
0.106185399,
-0.4480171502,
-0.1077018008,
-0.2735186517,
0.4002915323,
0.8267481923,
-0.8390840888,
0.2305523306,
-0.1044574827,
-0.5093223453,
-0.7623616457,
0.0677939206,
0.0950430185,
0.4765886366,
0.2527832687,
-0.4320307672,
-0.9001977444,
-1.0628606081,
-0.5304888487,
0.1315857172,
0.1418143958,
-0.2126835436,
0.0298352782,
-0.1755789965,
1.1665251255,
-0.6898387074,
-0.4648037851,
-0.3012650907,
0.191717729,
0.7130083442,
0.3280722499,
0.1014854535,
-1.0510652065,
-0.2083653808,
0.3533555567,
-0.7734704018,
-0.0185833499,
-0.1671561599,
0.1404561698,
0.0159870423,
0.3462504148,
-0.6001487374,
0.4494880438,
0.4948753119,
-0.0189332999,
0.685721755,
-0.1799702495,
-0.1767857075,
-0.8119274974,
0.5224010944,
0.3754042685,
-0.0849871635,
-0.7510590553,
-0.0564551018,
-0.4237294197,
-0.3370917141,
-0.3072278798,
0.6192320585,
-0.7639698386,
-0.3883975744,
-0.5799785256,
0.1034128442,
-0.2199963182,
0.494739145,
0.2438396811,
0.6020035148,
0.5826576948,
-0.5174726248,
0.42706424,
0.3573337793,
-0.2684125602,
-0.0499176718,
-0.3278212547,
0.0570811518,
-0.1394872516,
-0.1410314441,
-0.5652316213,
-0.3658004701,
0.2967995703,
-0.11175102,
0.145056352,
-0.3504761457,
-0.4934846163,
-0.4358588159,
-0.1644292176,
0.1767426729,
0.338722378,
-0.0118471421,
0.2574473619,
0.7918778658,
-0.7299497724,
-1.008351922,
-0.7126036882,
0.1036005765,
-0.1740473509,
-0.155141905,
0.3646838665,
0.6006461978,
-0.3388966322,
-0.1021369994,
-0.2058399469,
-0.8888722658,
0.5028353333,
0.0646824986,
0.5919190645,
0.0527989864,
-0.0848996267,
-0.0544412322,
-0.4215328991,
0.3494694531,
-0.282669574,
0.163415432,
0.06976787,
-0.0052440888,
-0.2989139557,
-0.0405295119,
0.3783209622,
-0.0951778218,
0.8544938564,
0.9622856975,
-0.6093223691,
0.0497607403,
-0.4364551306,
0.0351921506,
-0.4637833834,
0.1770654619,
0.1036990061,
-0.72879076,
0.2793786824,
-0.1362335831,
0.2717694938,
0.5293156505,
0.3717260957,
0.2082439512,
0.7365637422,
0.8765275478,
0.0598886125,
0.5963501334,
-0.3219017982,
0.3430868089,
-0.3426202238,
-0.3529959619,
-0.5877429843,
-0.2381474972,
-0.5496706963,
-0.207661882,
0.1829262823,
-0.014793762,
0.390725553,
0.5632462502,
-0.7268796563,
0.3931106031,
0.6250656843,
-0.2238118649,
0.2770761251,
0.1942193955,
0.2244732529,
-0.1625294685,
-0.3225851357,
-0.8022395372,
1.0086513758,
0.3829011917,
0.2577647269,
-0.2041171342,
0.1874468774,
0.3267130852,
0.1667821705,
-0.5261297822,
0.3174249828,
-0.3827814758,
-0.5520949364,
-0.4041858315,
-0.4661456347,
-1.0186568499,
0.2622848153,
-0.5188025236,
-0.6469083428,
0.240388602,
-0.1104399711,
-0.3453410566,
0.1823938787,
-0.6678768396,
1.0353053808,
-0.1579678804,
-0.2596634924,
0.0089914352,
-0.6772705317,
0.2690851092,
-0.5281569958,
0.6371198297,
-0.1944913417,
0.0412785374,
0.8464465737,
-0.1369912326,
0.8604845405,
-0.3241470754,
-0.0841841176,
0.1860751957,
-0.2563249469,
0.3326171339,
-0.0716853291,
-0.8368992805,
0.2353999764,
0.2446958572,
-0.4123718739,
-0.1930274814,
0.2571710646,
-0.4782690406,
0.0141878743,
-0.2127434611,
-0.4066595137,
-0.3039237261,
0.3831819594,
0.1318222582,
0.1015033573,
-0.2421122491,
0.0388098769,
0.1629418582,
-0.1824030876,
0.2594489753,
0.1737457216,
0.0909795314,
-0.1636835933,
1.0027198792,
0.2204530388,
-0.2222302705,
0.1557967067,
-0.1535412818,
-0.3336417675,
-0.4239600003,
0.010873802,
0.1990375668,
-0.4322353601,
-0.0800061449,
-0.6543029547,
-0.303260386,
-0.5127626061,
-0.0596880428,
-0.2609064579,
-0.3564542532,
-0.2733909786,
-0.0195737742,
0.0767556801,
0.8114686012,
-0.0092628039,
0.4514283538,
-0.7498974204,
0.449588716,
0.2232426107,
0.6587543488,
-0.1401328295,
0.2561541796,
-0.7793105245,
0.2596926987,
-0.2263209373,
-0.7441597581,
0.7383775115,
0.1683516949,
0.7726796269,
0.1546494514,
-0.1548909545,
0.5146997571,
0.0748379156,
0.7046597004,
-0.0459503233,
-0.5622329116,
0.4605941772,
-0.3771766424,
0.042419441,
0.6688236594,
0.5054770708,
-0.6668137908,
-0.1925401241,
-0.7707777023,
-1.1213839054,
1.1221097708,
0.4769423306,
-0.0270496905,
-0.1249322519,
0.4668180048,
0.5247689486,
0.4817276299,
-0.5613618493,
0.0499006361,
0.2020091116,
-0.511154592,
0.108992897,
-0.1433397979,
0.1988522559,
-0.1771718264,
0.5493002534,
0.0371286608,
0.2306329906,
-0.213832885,
-0.2930711508,
0.1121230125,
0.2445923388,
0.2905902565,
0.6761949658,
-0.187580198,
0.0661262423,
-0.0304212011,
-0.5409562588,
-0.3144868016,
0.3951994777,
0.2209351212,
0.0658890828,
0.2065659165,
0.4873338938,
0.0682768449,
-0.9769031405,
0.6777203679,
-0.015293913,
-0.2210995704,
-0.6294247508,
-0.0032475726,
-0.2094104439,
0.1717479825,
0.7305992842,
0.0577780418,
0.2206647396,
-0.3288404047,
0.2270416021,
0.3429615498,
-0.5852516294,
-0.4700644314,
0.5492452979,
-0.0765853599,
-0.2041155398,
0.813498795,
-0.1403812766,
-0.1875564158,
0.6622626185,
0.3521627784,
0.7317895889,
-0.0170748029,
0.127033025,
0.0950558111,
0.2123183012,
-0.4060658514,
0.1457271725,
-0.0421022139,
-0.5135794282,
-0.7562546134,
-0.5378844738,
-0.5383236408,
0.0820531696,
-0.7665786147,
0.2937839925,
-0.4208815098,
-0.1847144067,
0.0318327136,
-0.0836516917,
-0.9649584889,
0.2768277228,
0.2278194726,
0.4228220582,
-0.8901481628,
0.6322249174,
0.8601199985,
-0.1892169565,
-0.3442738652,
-0.439535588,
-0.0527408719,
-0.6231278777,
0.5155301094,
0.43629089,
0.1156845912,
-0.0143049881,
-0.5025718212,
-0.5312798619,
0.8174988627,
0.5665175319,
-0.0695073754,
-0.3983159959,
0.2849707305,
0.5343188643,
-0.2560782731,
0.1432743222,
0.8419289589,
0.4066869915,
-0.2730036378,
-0.9067805409,
-0.2960848212,
-0.3138495684,
-0.1690707952,
0.2059265971,
0.14774248,
0.6352094412,
0.4618751109,
-0.494086802,
-0.3570849299,
0.3350273669,
-0.0605344661,
0.3669203818,
0.4928938448,
0.1408336163,
0.693808794,
-0.023721708,
0.6191406846,
-0.265440762,
0.4401735365,
0.8000568151,
-0.2273673266,
0.6713674664,
0.2325470746,
-0.1002825946,
0.7229519486,
0.5792145729,
-0.1056511924,
0.1774683893,
0.0260479208,
-0.0263591744,
-0.0310073737,
-0.1600386053,
-0.0776126087,
0.7527406216,
0.493589282,
-0.3186539114,
-0.3836828768,
0.0701193437,
-0.3567568958,
0.1530334651,
-0.1709297746,
0.8925281167,
0.087786831,
-0.4008234441,
0.1849403083,
0.2127639949,
0.6525322795,
-0.5788633227,
-0.4402228892,
0.3013551235,
-0.1460838467,
-0.3495211005,
-0.6397724748,
0.946651876,
0.0980821326,
-0.0558904037,
-0.7480469942,
0.9685848951,
-0.3950654268,
-0.2564658523,
0.2067708373,
0.6301054358,
0.3282454312,
-0.179542914,
-0.8465758562,
-0.1250455827,
-0.2433392256,
-0.064607285,
0.2032623589,
0.3784353137,
-0.0261434987,
0.5215244293,
0.6982937455,
0.3810955286,
0.0662470907,
-0.3422690034,
0.4834683537,
-0.8649426699,
-0.7623583078,
-0.7205724716,
0.4409775734,
-0.4193478525,
-0.1636044085,
0.465516597,
0.512591958,
0.6403008699,
-0.0071963444,
0.6570516825,
-0.0582061075,
0.6651426554,
-0.4124743938,
0.4632834792,
-0.2405981123,
0.5068286657,
-0.2310974896,
-0.9431232214,
-0.2428681999,
0.3608432114,
-0.6122520566,
-0.1191342846,
0.3220884502,
0.6326962113,
-0.1957172006,
0.0984025821,
0.0185897835,
-0.0235329419,
0.0086964611,
-0.0576123297,
0.5776411295,
-0.3571529984,
0.5549587607,
-0.2999118865,
0.0839814767,
-0.3963620663,
-0.6573301554,
-0.2379018813,
-0.4598039687,
-0.430778563,
-0.1284960657,
-0.2132342905,
0.7040904164,
0.5828290582,
-0.5936917067,
-0.6935896873,
0.0581373014,
0.1950804144,
-0.80367589,
-0.3694344461,
0.3096861541,
-0.4431625605,
-0.5152903795,
0.7486149669,
0.3285590708,
-0.0812202916,
-0.1600293219,
0.328504473,
-0.3900124431,
-0.3293811679,
0.4141434729,
0.5715802908,
-0.3430433571,
0.1996327341,
-0.274494797,
-0.2142715901,
-0.0916130766,
0.8451753855,
-0.6573224068,
0.5390595794,
0.0831147358,
0.9374756217,
0.3579846025,
0.1168190837,
0.7816396952,
-1.2619605064,
0.2975054979,
0.2663063407,
-0.0511268191,
0.3964157403,
-0.5039929152,
0.8492526412,
0.214919582,
-0.3099390566,
-0.8234363198,
-0.0331357308,
-0.8241564631,
-0.5508575439,
0.8621900082,
0.3290362358,
-0.4448727071,
-0.7952347994,
0.0567081645,
0.5359474421,
-0.1310776919,
0.602517128,
0.484400779,
0.0444423594,
-0.1154962108,
-1.0728212595,
0.3967137635,
-0.0572489798,
-0.6581104398,
0.2580572069,
0.4343088865,
-0.0078106234,
0.1470663399,
0.8632822633,
-0.0665173456,
0.1765084863,
-0.1551012248,
0.282810837,
-0.0858321413,
0.0075483569,
-0.6600900292,
0.6098436713,
0.1999035031,
-0.1996632665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18976v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18976v1
|
Foundations of Multisensory Artificial Intelligence
| 2024-04-29T14:45:28 | 2024-04-29T14:45:28 |
Paul Pu Liang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
Building multisensory AI systems that learn from multiple sensory inputs such
as text, speech, video, real-world sensors, wearable devices, and medical data
holds great promise for impact in many scientific areas with practical
benefits, such as in supporting human health and well-being, enabling
multimedia content processing, and enhancing real-world autonomous agents. By
synthesizing a range of theoretical frameworks and application domains, this
thesis aims to advance the machine learning foundations of multisensory AI. In
the first part, we present a theoretical framework formalizing how modalities
interact with each other to give rise to new information for a task. These
interactions are the basic building blocks in all multimodal problems, and
their quantification enables users to understand their multimodal datasets,
design principled approaches to learn these interactions, and analyze whether
their model has succeeded in learning. In the second part, we study the design
of practical multimodal foundation models that generalize over many modalities
and tasks, which presents a step toward grounding large language models to
real-world sensory modalities. We introduce MultiBench, a unified large-scale
benchmark across a wide range of modalities, tasks, and research areas,
followed by the cross-modal attention and multimodal transformer architectures
that now underpin many of today's multimodal foundation models. Scaling these
architectures on MultiBench enables the creation of general-purpose
multisensory AI systems, and we discuss our collaborative efforts in applying
these models for real-world impact in affective computing, mental health,
cancer prognosis, and robotics. Finally, we conclude this thesis by discussing
how future work can leverage these ideas toward more general, interactive, and
safe multisensory AI.
|
[
-0.3715364635,
-0.6891592741,
0.6447220445,
0.2622356415,
0.3606122136,
-0.0500348955,
-0.2136088759,
-0.6456810832,
0.0915719122,
-0.0235034321,
-0.42924878,
-0.1366543025,
-0.4949662685,
-0.3085954785,
-0.3143458664,
0.5671443343,
0.0626882911,
0.2533588707,
-0.1067223996,
-0.4242708683,
-0.3199602962,
-0.4150332212,
-0.4547623694,
-0.2104733586,
0.6381218433,
0.4097318351,
0.5358125567,
0.3442381322,
0.3394659162,
0.3470233679,
0.3941763043,
0.029120829,
0.0758962408,
0.214959085,
0.0353488252,
-0.396486789,
-0.0766128674,
0.1289094836,
0.3975907862,
0.7605347037,
0.040883895,
0.051787816,
-0.088877432,
0.3881927133,
-0.6244023442,
0.6389224529,
0.0046568522,
0.1887758225,
0.137128517,
0.1308015436,
-0.4241964817,
0.1962215751,
-0.1191955432,
-0.4889411628,
0.0504758991,
-0.0402340069,
0.3995150626,
0.5567996502,
-0.7984525561,
-0.0383235067,
-0.7243212461,
0.9414798617,
-0.1700308323,
1.0424090624,
0.4628522694,
0.3157711625,
0.0335207805,
-0.77919209,
-0.5628687143,
-0.5635662675,
-0.0953453705,
0.1903434247,
-0.1170305833,
0.0911595374,
0.0635396242,
0.0452585071,
-0.5587138534,
0.002456292,
-0.2068378478,
-0.0732947588,
0.5471305847,
0.0853087902,
0.1935678571,
-0.0376989432,
-0.3538280725,
-0.4209675491,
-0.1694327593,
0.2263180315,
-0.1131944433,
0.0882004648,
-0.2544115484,
0.3467803597,
-0.190145418,
0.6418586373,
0.110887818,
-0.3103901744,
0.4265743792,
-0.7068215013,
-0.0759267434,
-0.2327617258,
0.6886065602,
0.1071938425,
0.0251794122,
-0.200834766,
0.0157218147,
0.5260951519,
0.4744821787,
-0.4946357608,
-0.2632390857,
0.3218108416,
-0.7106690407,
-0.2199135423,
0.0887382329,
-0.6932140589,
-0.4370636344,
-0.7554239631,
0.5198546052,
-0.4546694458,
-0.4246654212,
0.0746253952,
-0.0849137455,
0.0750463456,
0.2183976769,
-0.9901086092,
0.1352000535,
0.4089834988,
0.4373570085,
-0.0007109352,
-0.6342408657,
-0.3908135593,
0.3461563587,
-0.1741294265,
0.5180597305,
-0.6780124307,
-0.1966896802,
-0.3333824873,
0.0192304775,
-0.2396839857,
-0.2663221061,
0.4428423047,
-0.3506802022,
0.0664022639,
0.1319563389,
-0.0972529203,
-0.415230155,
0.3806516826,
-0.8581964374,
0.5555301905,
0.0986613631,
-0.4344289005,
0.2123610526,
-1.0722898245,
-0.90579319,
-0.4279625416,
-0.2687421441,
-0.2901300788,
0.4134742022,
0.0026728616,
0.5654910207,
-0.2019319087,
0.4578655064,
-0.2973046601,
-0.0275774579,
0.1915433705,
-0.738263011,
0.7147974968,
0.2495145202,
-0.5430527329,
0.3877111077,
-0.9964654446,
0.0322008133,
-0.103119418,
-0.4320180714,
-0.0142100705,
0.2312516719,
0.4780413508,
0.3432399631,
-0.0318472162,
-0.3732187152,
-0.1187650561,
0.0355986543,
0.7331686616,
0.5490294695,
-0.1987503022,
0.3338530958,
-0.3570278883,
0.2319818288,
0.1686699837,
0.2997068763,
-0.5840407014,
-0.3255096972,
-0.5619598627,
-0.4406106472,
0.1699617803,
0.5854491591,
-0.5324105024,
0.3068866432,
0.0358548276,
-0.4114633501,
-0.3065381646,
0.0124679683,
0.2656929195,
0.4998688102,
0.4716678858,
-0.2884350717,
-0.4172666073,
-0.7611962557,
-0.0654323623,
-0.1993316114,
0.0479840413,
0.4573248327,
0.2781312466,
-0.5968333483,
0.7938956022,
-0.3368023634,
-0.037093915,
0.1007088572,
0.2899832428,
-0.0435715877,
0.7549663186,
0.6521984935,
-1.3810027838,
-0.1259575635,
0.1058647633,
-0.9196355939,
0.2843886614,
-0.1205473617,
0.1255993992,
-0.2071018368,
0.4346831739,
-0.8003470898,
0.4709324241,
0.4566686749,
-0.2701078057,
0.5646018386,
-0.0700464398,
0.3897598386,
-1.0874682665,
0.1843096018,
0.1572857648,
0.0464046486,
-0.8242946267,
0.2847502232,
0.0680652186,
-0.3065168858,
-0.4514925778,
0.6891155839,
-0.2480278611,
-0.0825129226,
-0.1677983254,
-0.4150544107,
0.0918145627,
0.6356893778,
-0.1213958561,
0.3751491904,
0.5926755667,
-0.8459566236,
0.6462937593,
0.0837669447,
-0.0492352396,
0.7953466773,
-0.5977540016,
-0.2033234835,
-0.2228205502,
0.100726828,
-1.0207402706,
-0.5362134576,
0.2763887942,
-0.6418193579,
0.2656485736,
0.2394810468,
-0.5197694302,
-0.3508917987,
-0.1422424316,
0.6746000051,
0.0222842228,
-0.5737944245,
1.1555900574,
0.5063861012,
0.1195583418,
-0.4908792078,
-0.7554495931,
-0.0092777442,
-0.1306220144,
-0.6112770438,
0.3291217387,
-0.3552337289,
-0.3458046019,
0.0689720511,
0.0258731637,
-0.2503821254,
0.4144922197,
0.517947793,
-0.0283118151,
-0.249135986,
0.4520596266,
-0.0781408548,
-0.3980282843,
0.0489763618,
-0.3072740138,
0.4726497829,
-0.4484962523,
-0.8878330588,
-0.5658388734,
0.525144279,
0.8952005506,
-0.5524989367,
0.4753627479,
1.0167663097,
-0.5049917698,
0.2849633694,
-0.3630023003,
-0.4423705339,
-0.3870305419,
0.5176457763,
-0.5986934304,
-0.6861082911,
0.307855159,
-0.212644428,
-0.0022510714,
0.3627175093,
0.7407533526,
-0.1850922555,
1.3252979517,
0.8419581652,
-0.2895304263,
0.6724770069,
-0.1541263461,
0.2703754902,
-0.5728946328,
-0.3698326051,
-0.3923808038,
-0.6968625784,
-0.4561759233,
-0.3846218288,
0.6488198042,
-0.050775297,
-0.3406737447,
0.0440437943,
-0.3653434813,
0.2492096871,
0.9513093829,
0.1821616888,
0.1062936708,
-0.001616888,
-0.2016560733,
0.2991735041,
-0.5654019713,
-0.1004453599,
0.9743595123,
0.265288651,
0.8253412843,
0.1899106055,
0.16744183,
0.3184580207,
0.0850707963,
-0.7277412415,
0.1489855945,
0.0053284951,
-0.7056316137,
-0.2037177384,
-0.0819519609,
-0.9067765474,
0.4410542548,
-0.3011135161,
-0.46316576,
0.3591257632,
0.2072695345,
-0.242973119,
0.1535934508,
-0.9906384349,
0.8925983906,
-0.8224634528,
-0.4229842126,
-0.6385219097,
-1.1017529964,
0.3556962609,
-0.0053475425,
0.3657815158,
0.0570777804,
0.0423541702,
0.3361840844,
0.4165437818,
1.0974675417,
-0.3150205314,
0.2201960683,
0.0161191449,
-0.0560371652,
-0.1887693405,
0.2597595751,
-0.0374485515,
0.2290835679,
-0.0145529564,
-0.3131061196,
-0.4889475405,
0.4895253778,
-0.8535054326,
-0.2033931166,
-0.1441004276,
-0.6080275774,
-0.4668752551,
0.4883920848,
-0.2082849741,
0.5630158782,
-0.2725914717,
0.4088799357,
0.6816533804,
0.1090297177,
0.5404313207,
0.2320557088,
0.1339554191,
-0.3276770711,
1.1124111414,
-0.3792529106,
-0.177570805,
0.5506740212,
0.1481471807,
-0.130260244,
-0.0712893829,
-0.5870149732,
-0.0571135655,
-0.6482188106,
-0.0504958257,
-0.6422139406,
-0.0623591729,
-0.4251664579,
-0.0636406541,
-0.107684657,
-0.3746894896,
-0.3786052763,
-0.0946589038,
0.1344995946,
0.7409676909,
-0.4773636162,
0.2238405198,
-0.7356581092,
0.7821882963,
0.5580022335,
0.3588929772,
0.1463167667,
0.0996298119,
-0.3446514904,
0.1891007125,
-0.408115536,
-0.6744235158,
0.0205225945,
0.216680333,
1.0238823891,
0.6382490396,
-0.1491654068,
0.3128640652,
-0.4601492882,
0.6600539088,
0.4087616503,
-0.7671121359,
0.5348198414,
-0.0885147229,
0.0473059304,
0.5391414762,
0.5779107213,
-0.6017704606,
0.2543956637,
-0.5054649711,
-0.5259587169,
0.5341594219,
-0.1920004487,
0.0852004066,
0.1259281933,
0.1627155989,
0.1334077418,
0.4040656984,
-0.7155632377,
-0.1575725526,
-0.6242980361,
-0.841997683,
-0.2691361904,
0.0555929951,
-0.3974504471,
-0.228490591,
0.2326734066,
-0.4174073339,
0.3548551798,
-0.152072072,
-0.3553648591,
0.2145453393,
0.041093871,
0.8294878006,
0.537977159,
0.268155396,
0.5261983871,
-0.2623063326,
-0.2360585183,
0.4040330052,
0.3471806049,
0.1271989793,
-0.5137541294,
0.3571974337,
0.9127939939,
0.3572502434,
-0.8448500633,
0.3092919588,
-0.0584127195,
-0.0170717482,
-0.1012712941,
0.0621144027,
0.0967194661,
0.6263644099,
0.3642234206,
0.3997350335,
0.1442016214,
-0.5940986872,
0.407987237,
0.5843525529,
-0.4413520694,
-0.5899947286,
0.7861457467,
0.1460153461,
-0.1696908325,
0.4082150459,
0.2395882159,
-0.4853178859,
0.6943676472,
0.3551437855,
0.6298007965,
-0.4160394371,
0.0316715166,
-0.0338627994,
0.2593033016,
0.206323579,
0.1289726049,
-0.5007913113,
-0.8235624433,
-0.1629885435,
-0.4874745905,
-0.3486851156,
-0.1826302111,
-0.3968305588,
-0.1040794849,
-0.5016939044,
-0.1967393607,
0.1117440388,
-0.1679304689,
-0.7250288725,
0.4603566229,
0.2547467053,
0.396736294,
-0.9877590537,
0.4490786493,
0.7620008588,
-0.5789496303,
-0.4171182811,
-0.1645757109,
0.0948390439,
-0.9996037483,
0.6064133644,
0.2524416149,
-0.2039424926,
-0.0119441301,
-0.6249995828,
-0.8943650126,
0.8553104997,
0.0761378929,
-0.0567662381,
0.0595499761,
-0.0368434526,
0.3554022908,
-0.2526532114,
0.1225141808,
0.3251703382,
0.8173409104,
-0.1667177379,
-0.7684544325,
-0.207898736,
-0.3682530224,
-0.3016864061,
0.0286231767,
-0.8700114489,
1.0002965927,
-0.3015054762,
0.1438341141,
-0.0615828745,
0.4537622333,
0.2123165578,
0.510740757,
0.4743421972,
0.8105916977,
0.6443704367,
-0.0295306891,
0.8070148826,
-0.4994261265,
-0.0151394932,
0.7663690448,
-0.2848416865,
0.5796145201,
0.3694154322,
-0.1277810931,
0.4278439283,
0.5369461179,
0.0207258575,
0.5100679994,
0.0304234922,
-0.3084976077,
-0.0932851434,
-0.19193995,
-0.3101127148,
0.6919187307,
0.5598992109,
-0.2234135568,
0.004932614,
0.7362356186,
-0.4770791531,
-0.1510294229,
-0.1173921749,
0.7578294277,
-0.0688117296,
-0.3583608866,
0.031736251,
0.2811961174,
0.5263081789,
-0.5201155543,
-0.1576648951,
0.0531404279,
0.3429214358,
-0.1272640079,
-0.464643538,
0.1146215424,
-0.530236125,
-0.7565217018,
-0.1777891368,
0.7352879643,
-0.3360127211,
-0.5126472116,
0.2957831919,
0.6715984941,
-0.1206607297,
-0.0081745982,
-0.7093387842,
0.2688304484,
-0.2889816463,
-0.203914851,
0.270901978,
0.3329942822,
-0.1976547688,
0.6963862777,
0.7627442479,
-0.3176974356,
0.1984387338,
-0.041005794,
0.77584517,
-0.8748117089,
-0.4071040154,
-0.5925595164,
0.4572996199,
0.3099342287,
-0.0983735919,
0.4076465368,
0.2990477979,
0.7079572082,
0.0319246911,
0.8137120605,
-0.2276860327,
0.2568175197,
-0.3506789505,
0.6418756843,
-0.7540276051,
-0.5084639192,
-0.0471974127,
-0.6202925444,
-0.5996249318,
0.8539729118,
0.1772889644,
0.3841259778,
0.5648257732,
0.4985158145,
-0.2262150347,
0.0946206152,
0.3917541504,
0.1881951243,
0.4590834379,
0.5451008081,
0.7619886398,
-0.2800419033,
0.2574268878,
-0.2969810963,
-0.341098845,
-0.3142797947,
-0.5773870945,
-0.5017896295,
-0.8857663274,
0.0566186868,
-0.0106776003,
-0.2643992901,
0.6814486384,
1.1941069365,
-0.8138104677,
-0.2298785001,
0.002736581,
0.1878412068,
-0.3246287107,
-0.2076284587,
0.2167493403,
-0.2462209314,
-0.6728570461,
0.8377372026,
0.2349133641,
0.0782619491,
-0.409992367,
-0.3062221706,
-0.3391442597,
-0.3135575652,
0.9157657623,
0.5548246503,
-0.8427914977,
-0.2238456756,
0.0757443607,
-0.0180432424,
0.070506379,
0.677036345,
-1.0702923536,
0.458581686,
0.275757134,
1.0701502562,
0.3556286097,
-0.0226582251,
0.2196433097,
-0.6663103104,
0.4369779229,
0.2716901898,
0.411950171,
0.2096155733,
-0.1325232536,
0.5517308712,
0.4712624848,
-0.321949482,
-0.6037532687,
0.3394140899,
-0.9801492691,
-0.4586679041,
0.645957768,
0.1959283054,
-0.2624042332,
-0.0457533784,
-0.1127076298,
0.2293152213,
-0.0932020694,
0.5631808043,
0.5648010969,
-0.5994246006,
-0.4406265914,
-0.3283526897,
0.0512448475,
0.5443320274,
-0.9278327227,
-0.2102707922,
0.8190410733,
0.0061523719,
0.629188478,
0.40316239,
0.1236297637,
0.4630809128,
0.166503042,
0.2000327557,
-0.1894228309,
-0.868838191,
-0.4723239541,
0.5624288321,
-0.1404721141,
-0.4106131792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18739v1
|
Towards Dog Bark Decoding: Leveraging Human Speech Processing for Automated Bark Classification
| 2024-04-29T14:41:59 | 2024-04-29T14:41:59 |
Artem Abzaliev, Humberto Pérez Espinosa, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Similar to humans, animals make extensive use of verbal and non-verbal forms
of communication, including a large range of audio signals. In this paper, we
address dog vocalizations and explore the use of self-supervised speech
representation models pre-trained on human speech to address dog bark
classification tasks that find parallels in human-centered tasks in speech
recognition. We specifically address four tasks: dog recognition, breed
identification, gender classification, and context grounding. We show that
using speech embedding representations significantly improves over simpler
classification baselines. Further, we also find that models pre-trained on
large human speech acoustics can provide additional performance boosts on
several tasks.
|
[
-0.418184638,
-0.1598214358,
0.2188109905,
0.4003064632,
-0.0510600656,
0.2392030954,
-0.1325029582,
-0.9058781266,
-0.064371489,
0.3470262885,
-0.2897292078,
-0.6597858667,
-0.2836382985,
0.0200959779,
-0.3539559245,
0.6525954604,
0.4473742545,
0.4045834541,
-0.0969568938,
0.0293136686,
-0.4453917146,
-1.1509090662,
-0.8527409434,
-0.8130853772,
0.4190267324,
0.0282786675,
0.3098089397,
0.8207282424,
-0.0763199776,
0.2870762944,
0.2760136724,
-0.2211227864,
0.1892612725,
-0.1126089767,
0.0224675126,
-0.6086111665,
-0.5119373202,
0.7465010285,
0.211571604,
0.5344487429,
-0.5423266888,
0.0307630487,
-0.0994778797,
0.1889830828,
-0.4497272968,
0.524004221,
-0.5027237535,
0.1230650619,
-0.0934895873,
-0.3455968201,
-0.5777664781,
-0.0537674688,
0.0940035209,
-0.5458400846,
0.4849219918,
-0.0613806397,
0.5750641227,
0.3162283301,
-0.3741771877,
-0.600995183,
-0.6864548922,
0.743910253,
-0.6847572923,
0.4839513898,
1.2672128677,
0.1948058158,
-0.1573786139,
-0.9108424187,
-0.0269775614,
-0.5274732113,
-0.261313349,
0.0642298162,
-0.5135217309,
0.3741297424,
0.284671098,
0.2615667582,
-0.0694349781,
0.2982343435,
-0.1425731629,
-0.4412239492,
0.9070860147,
0.0588425025,
0.3293767869,
0.044447206,
0.35731709,
-0.5167917013,
-0.1584949046,
0.7265053391,
0.0329332165,
0.2759499252,
0.1852948964,
0.3047190011,
0.1040665582,
0.8138628602,
0.3670834303,
-0.1966277063,
0.2397502661,
0.0513475053,
-0.1495708376,
0.5847089887,
0.3067522943,
0.0984404236,
0.0870540813,
-0.2693972588,
-0.0581359342,
0.2577075958,
0.569648087,
-0.3218023181,
-0.3111371696,
0.0135914413,
-0.5160844922,
-0.3613168597,
-0.2431328148,
-0.0231349729,
-0.2483021766,
-0.5093819499,
0.2679124177,
-0.4360377192,
-0.1095370874,
0.385986656,
-0.531131506,
0.7050053477,
0.2374375165,
-1.0509352684,
0.5597645044,
0.4724999666,
0.4215990901,
0.6446349621,
-0.4599512219,
-0.6513371468,
0.5492724776,
-0.5154598951,
0.4866625071,
-0.5761037469,
-0.3059111834,
-0.4173650742,
0.2179654837,
0.1544745415,
-0.65645051,
0.6479461193,
-0.2385310531,
0.0772792473,
-0.0826954246,
-0.5112489462,
-0.5504059196,
0.0981135815,
-0.5315467119,
0.8462688923,
-0.0772994086,
-0.7226813436,
0.2091685534,
-0.6512409449,
-0.725631237,
-0.0725298524,
-0.2008040696,
-0.2444298863,
0.2155693322,
0.3950019479,
0.8921706676,
0.0188172609,
-0.0354265496,
-0.0804129988,
-0.1985084563,
0.0593382716,
0.0807757452,
0.6162713766,
0.0362828597,
-0.5137178302,
0.1147966161,
-0.7937802672,
0.2761946619,
0.2286157608,
-0.177005291,
-0.69183743,
0.206744045,
-0.1797255725,
0.0501225814,
0.0484155305,
-0.4986433685,
0.0060312427,
-0.3578953445,
0.7095380425,
0.2780707777,
-0.3429906666,
0.4596517086,
-0.3359204233,
0.261749506,
-0.3544535935,
-0.328371793,
-0.1907392889,
-0.3070170879,
-0.3432836831,
-0.4922218025,
0.3722189069,
0.6056878567,
0.1295122802,
0.8823568821,
0.2918059528,
-0.6202681661,
-0.7777392864,
-0.2023396492,
0.1772169471,
0.1877735108,
0.3583971262,
-0.3345702589,
-0.6404314637,
-0.8504998684,
-0.017371485,
-0.2608749866,
-0.2979388833,
0.2471686155,
0.2047067732,
-0.3259336948,
1.2301921844,
-0.2539488971,
-0.673933804,
-0.2427412122,
0.7877014279,
-0.0648342073,
0.5081478953,
0.5641179681,
-0.57686764,
-0.1928014159,
-0.0423738323,
-0.7752745152,
-0.1247572005,
-0.0041976245,
0.2782804072,
-0.0368970335,
0.7861684561,
-0.3932291269,
0.533183217,
0.3142013252,
-0.0518706888,
0.2191791683,
-0.4487967491,
0.0502262823,
-0.5344770551,
-0.2773909569,
-0.0300353914,
-0.6315171719,
-0.7229880095,
-0.5791051388,
-0.1058549061,
-0.2005774528,
-0.0509150214,
0.1649715304,
-0.7669818997,
-0.4957070351,
-0.5843700171,
-0.1568927318,
-0.0213046614,
0.2316378653,
0.6720951796,
0.6078139544,
0.8932507038,
-0.4495419562,
0.4793936014,
0.1186595932,
0.1692973524,
0.3556236625,
-0.6554643512,
0.4072591364,
-0.0581892021,
0.6708510518,
-0.7012990117,
-0.2263602018,
-0.0590254366,
-0.7269518375,
0.4907403886,
-0.2633572519,
-0.486984551,
-0.4257703424,
-0.2078624666,
0.1840788424,
0.7142732143,
-0.7713500261,
0.638780117,
0.6220628619,
0.1241078153,
-0.1849016249,
-0.5758517385,
0.118285805,
-0.3933412731,
-0.5893608332,
0.5525782704,
0.362411201,
0.0060439743,
0.0347960293,
-0.0268571768,
-0.0976992697,
0.1205829829,
0.4718861282,
-0.4102501869,
-0.0281015858,
0.427378267,
-0.2983085215,
-0.0940266773,
0.3008137047,
-0.2955800593,
0.6546336412,
-0.4376004338,
-0.1791157871,
-0.9138973951,
0.5402171016,
0.439899534,
-0.4948095977,
0.2962806523,
1.00141716,
-0.4952458143,
-0.1002671197,
-0.6325224042,
-0.4754883647,
-0.4623877406,
0.2785739601,
-0.5383098125,
-0.6442261338,
0.3233639002,
-0.3258123696,
-0.3429571688,
0.0652035624,
0.2214284241,
-0.8323431611,
1.4359233379,
0.9543303251,
-0.4049333036,
0.4900382757,
-0.0824425519,
-0.0574141629,
-0.7831732035,
-0.1854271889,
-0.6510952711,
0.0623151623,
-0.4446527362,
-0.3408273458,
-0.0305409282,
0.3406384289,
-0.1151941568,
0.203970477,
-0.7515157461,
0.3799738884,
0.8340734243,
0.0053467262,
0.0915342271,
0.2386494279,
0.2504444718,
-0.1898255795,
-0.7614514828,
-0.5958350897,
0.7680776119,
0.74501127,
0.9016934037,
-0.4828357697,
0.9309337735,
0.6051887274,
0.1021722853,
-1.1280997992,
0.3075328469,
-0.3153358996,
-0.6355420351,
-0.3891899586,
0.0446994342,
-1.1968551874,
0.2647559345,
-0.0735987872,
-0.8595380187,
-0.1177488938,
0.0704097673,
0.0621262118,
0.169568643,
-0.6013858318,
0.6058453918,
-0.4338288903,
0.1807690114,
-0.5714145899,
-0.6667807102,
0.0124827493,
0.216545254,
0.2238096595,
-0.1455071419,
0.2674756646,
1.079975605,
-0.1283718646,
1.1498018503,
-0.4138026237,
-0.0302656405,
0.4898859859,
-0.3832856119,
0.4749949872,
-0.2765095234,
0.0711042136,
0.1149088144,
0.2549065053,
-0.3727830946,
-0.5255971551,
0.0164746176,
-0.7922578454,
-0.6804668903,
-0.7054954767,
-0.1857986748,
-0.4040341675,
-0.0719424337,
0.2364739478,
0.493785888,
-0.1800972968,
0.1283320189,
0.1978314072,
-0.0847415552,
0.4661585391,
0.745790422,
-0.1285504997,
-0.3911984265,
0.7207586169,
-0.121001035,
-0.1560744047,
-0.0129025057,
0.2096617222,
-0.6970983744,
-0.4292793572,
-0.3011089265,
0.457691431,
-0.8543814421,
-0.0045003109,
-0.5718598962,
-0.3725797236,
-0.4827447236,
-0.219440937,
-0.5002753735,
0.0944292471,
-0.560318768,
-0.193395853,
0.2784720659,
1.1893694401,
-0.5211613178,
0.6871353388,
-1.03810215,
0.3966756761,
0.696257472,
0.0709284171,
0.1429717243,
-0.3988721371,
-0.2742651999,
0.0358736776,
-0.1777012795,
-1.1328217983,
0.5186690688,
0.3512443602,
1.0546958447,
-0.0324411578,
0.189877972,
0.7759240866,
-0.4762476087,
0.4584307075,
0.2509391904,
-1.3227585554,
0.8748731017,
-0.2289871126,
-0.1047439426,
0.4076825082,
0.5317088962,
-0.4206518829,
-0.369299978,
-0.5078465939,
-0.4488862455,
1.0690485239,
0.1469567418,
0.0879854113,
0.2353207469,
0.3342642486,
-0.1108845249,
-0.016637221,
-0.6925470233,
-0.1296839416,
-0.5468424559,
0.013972248,
-0.3870437443,
-0.1010546684,
-0.1082605496,
-0.7476542592,
0.4047625661,
-0.1728954911,
0.3434502184,
0.4629309475,
-0.0883993655,
0.0157845691,
0.3648743927,
0.2510893643,
0.0188377518,
-0.6476482749,
0.2125156224,
0.2845394909,
-0.3726573288,
0.7175644636,
-0.0201339908,
0.5586227775,
-0.0191313196,
0.6025221944,
0.6672816873,
-0.0515420064,
-0.4215164781,
0.361379087,
-0.3644608259,
-0.1819162518,
-0.5419331789,
-0.1099679694,
0.3161672652,
0.365005821,
0.4604969025,
-0.1701825559,
0.5084654093,
-0.8064520359,
0.4172176421,
0.444920361,
-0.4094256163,
-0.347738713,
0.384023577,
0.127976954,
-0.3202761114,
0.6763003469,
-0.272219032,
-0.7518908381,
0.6038956046,
0.9460056424,
0.9734538794,
-0.3840476871,
0.2047992498,
0.2610574067,
0.0692981407,
-0.1943178475,
-0.0468151979,
-0.6411036849,
-0.4673475623,
-0.2930257916,
-0.5155804753,
-0.2893633842,
0.0649552047,
-1.0810158253,
0.1933149248,
-0.3248721361,
-0.5246240497,
0.3095867336,
-0.0866675749,
-0.186018005,
0.4758127928,
0.6566070914,
0.5884050727,
-0.8008683324,
1.3427813053,
1.0077995062,
-0.054659497,
-1.0983908176,
0.1020530835,
-0.3511084914,
-0.3275333941,
1.032117486,
0.5317301154,
-0.8696478009,
0.3005213439,
-0.7598244548,
-0.5212868452,
0.9823752642,
0.0810981393,
-0.310397923,
-0.092188634,
-0.0045970473,
0.7646346092,
-0.4755429924,
0.009228061,
0.6903868318,
0.2717325091,
0.1312663257,
-1.1735419035,
-0.0891128927,
-0.2600126565,
-0.3385008276,
-0.5260362625,
-0.3433759511,
0.7045525312,
-0.030497279,
-0.3787514269,
-0.2270378768,
0.6232237816,
0.2505432665,
0.6548653245,
0.7196837664,
0.4463229179,
1.0001299381,
0.0995522588,
0.8129376173,
0.0557808839,
0.1398724914,
1.2313331366,
-0.1970809847,
0.9347450137,
-0.1495800465,
-0.5045831203,
0.186855033,
0.7277317643,
0.0667709708,
0.6942768097,
0.4069960713,
-0.2815196216,
-0.613042891,
-0.2265094966,
-0.6775469184,
1.0051096678,
0.6232542396,
-0.1833778471,
-0.2273449451,
0.3627493083,
-0.632037282,
-0.112746343,
-0.4368751943,
1.1110105515,
0.2161738873,
-0.4051192105,
0.9413959384,
0.1628240645,
0.810277164,
-0.3807719052,
-0.1758988202,
0.2298714817,
0.0957743004,
-0.361602664,
-0.6676038504,
0.537789166,
-0.1403352916,
-0.3520057797,
-0.3396846056,
0.9831892848,
-0.2712275982,
-0.0055472692,
0.9059590697,
0.1102609336,
0.3834753335,
-0.5918348432,
-0.5077893138,
-0.2557041049,
0.0355223715,
0.1149645895,
0.2507331669,
0.1539809108,
-0.2976462245,
0.7814385891,
0.4251607955,
-0.0009419129,
0.4695097506,
0.0904521719,
0.6672025919,
-1.2376149893,
-0.7216257453,
-0.5821114779,
0.1056012064,
0.1251894981,
0.409332037,
0.5274825692,
0.2642141283,
0.5802366734,
-0.2074318975,
0.8624113202,
0.1307416707,
0.6585563421,
-0.3498474658,
0.6277242303,
-0.5250023007,
-0.0754785985,
-0.0033618542,
-0.6128165126,
-0.232118234,
0.9954403639,
-0.4185734689,
-0.0412932038,
0.3487787843,
0.5063354969,
-0.0786150768,
0.3194520772,
0.5578700304,
-0.2460931391,
0.3603403866,
0.2847222984,
1.5172657967,
-0.0492625721,
0.4947356284,
-0.4021272063,
-0.0672099814,
0.0236212853,
-0.4901655614,
-1.1532709599,
-0.7546523213,
-0.2325813323,
-0.115248397,
-0.1774989218,
0.953117907,
1.6204063892,
-0.6496981978,
-0.4723878503,
0.0000581883,
-0.2996481955,
0.0094123436,
-0.1777124703,
0.2777422667,
-0.6879149079,
-0.5626844168,
0.6157608628,
0.1362929195,
0.3846894801,
-0.0298917182,
-0.1959053129,
0.0642480925,
-0.0717892721,
0.5908129215,
0.5301632285,
-0.894305408,
-0.0061130067,
-0.2095646858,
-0.3340821862,
0.3909582496,
0.9928821325,
-0.9570637941,
0.1722759008,
0.224025324,
0.5060707927,
0.9973884225,
0.4179984033,
0.5360045433,
-0.8107446432,
0.3358002305,
0.346795857,
0.0585934781,
0.4733596742,
-0.2809739709,
0.4188074172,
-0.085384801,
-0.3918966055,
-0.6301957965,
0.0556786284,
-1.2630810738,
-0.3361045122,
0.542526722,
-0.4223499,
-0.3349211514,
-0.3986420929,
-0.5782951713,
0.4551209211,
-0.5199525356,
0.3932693303,
0.6728573442,
-0.747699976,
-0.410312891,
-0.3854650557,
0.7066614032,
0.2793059945,
-0.8885453343,
0.0521527566,
0.261070013,
0.4516694546,
0.327283293,
0.8931058049,
-0.0474821627,
0.1637224704,
0.1998791695,
0.3131925762,
-0.0101473508,
-0.2785097957,
-0.5499549508,
0.1624645442,
0.4804387391,
-0.6143326759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18726v1
|
The Constant in HATE: Analyzing Toxicity in Reddit across Topics and Languages
| 2024-04-29T14:14:33 | 2024-04-29T14:14:33 |
Wondimagegnhue Tsegaye Tufa, Ilia Markov, Piek Vossen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Toxic language remains an ongoing challenge on social media platforms,
presenting significant issues for users and communities. This paper provides a
cross-topic and cross-lingual analysis of toxicity in Reddit conversations. We
collect 1.5 million comment threads from 481 communities in six languages:
English, German, Spanish, Turkish,Arabic, and Dutch, covering 80 topics such as
Culture, Politics, and News. We thoroughly analyze how toxicity spikes within
different communities in relation to specific topics. We observe consistent
patterns of increased toxicity across languages for certain topics, while also
noting significant variations within specific language communities.
|
[
-0.3902367949,
-1.0712593794,
0.3595106304,
0.6486644745,
-0.0929368809,
0.2816992998,
-0.0789645761,
-0.7889518738,
0.5236797929,
0.4342651963,
-0.6193092465,
-0.3325042129,
-0.8311586976,
0.34324646,
-0.2419320494,
1.1680113077,
-0.0273505244,
0.2457602024,
0.064844355,
-0.4664861858,
-0.4473774731,
-0.5493143797,
-0.7931554914,
-0.1391827762,
1.2771371603,
0.7198574543,
0.5409976244,
0.0214438625,
0.6736562252,
0.2955108583,
-0.1383668631,
-0.3027065098,
-0.7188256979,
0.3777840137,
-0.628751874,
-0.2251837105,
0.1783346832,
-0.1610493958,
0.2022840083,
0.4537547827,
0.1558588892,
0.1824446768,
-0.1198700666,
0.6018851399,
-0.5586158037,
-0.3142333925,
-0.7723661065,
0.049893517,
-0.4347522855,
-0.0421875603,
-0.217678681,
-0.5613670349,
0.0356721133,
-0.4430421591,
-0.2551495731,
-0.4279195666,
0.8623517156,
0.0396947563,
-0.6691032052,
-0.737814784,
-0.6310112476,
1.1329964399,
-0.3025236428,
0.2477691621,
0.030595487,
0.1628794074,
-0.1109243482,
-0.3586799204,
-0.4728023112,
-0.0684091672,
-0.2817445099,
-0.166638121,
-0.551415205,
-0.3388643563,
-0.1498679519,
0.1034134179,
-0.5273335576,
-0.0973463804,
-0.5688286424,
-0.0112246117,
0.8211906552,
0.2032410204,
1.01517272,
-0.191056028,
-0.0223064441,
0.4806994498,
-0.5050503016,
-0.5319908857,
0.622653842,
0.0905946493,
-0.1042926759,
0.3343296945,
0.3142167926,
0.5262387991,
-0.1501518786,
-0.080884181,
0.1457536817,
-0.3608971536,
0.2132246494,
-0.2062709332,
0.8592665792,
0.8955388069,
0.5009285212,
-0.135004133,
0.4523986876,
0.5220380425,
0.4680292904,
-0.6581409574,
-0.2427600473,
0.1613170654,
-0.2377798259,
-0.4533284605,
-0.4269057214,
-1.2539627552,
-0.7552586794,
0.3172321916,
-0.1205228344,
-0.021274602,
-0.489556998,
-0.1954488009,
-0.3058658242,
-0.2118869871,
0.1536865532,
-0.4321023524,
0.1927190721,
0.4862498045,
0.7858754396,
-0.468352139,
-0.3987897933,
-0.3218840957,
-0.0932323709,
-0.3791788816,
0.9485824108,
-0.7324123383,
-0.2667299807,
0.2850227058,
0.1404468715,
0.2065868527,
-0.729516387,
0.4766611755,
-0.5394929051,
0.0739396363,
-0.3283797503,
-0.0250850283,
-0.272810936,
0.381164521,
-0.4756713808,
0.7755972147,
0.0990858525,
-0.954098165,
0.3883582056,
-0.609724462,
-0.5936239958,
0.0856776461,
0.0920173079,
-0.2032844871,
-0.071222052,
-0.5167859197,
0.0491789579,
-0.199254483,
-0.0164349694,
-0.3363144398,
-0.1355931014,
0.2300516218,
0.0507474542,
0.9728187919,
0.4966617823,
-0.447833091,
0.3170691133,
-0.6375135183,
-0.3745705187,
0.0967072099,
-0.4013641775,
-0.7752333879,
0.1674372554,
0.3531650603,
0.7199282646,
-0.0263166018,
-0.9055307508,
-0.3379791379,
-0.2277135104,
0.6524543762,
0.4586734176,
0.5925654173,
0.1560697258,
-0.4233472049,
0.5617462993,
0.2315329164,
0.2978453338,
0.3120062947,
-0.6878530979,
-0.6577137113,
0.3817329109,
-0.5275487304,
0.5762499571,
-0.4172655344,
-0.0687933043,
-0.0675893649,
-0.7536969185,
-0.2979502976,
0.2312513888,
0.5143170357,
0.1010030136,
0.2765492797,
-0.3192177713,
-0.7756656408,
-0.8451111913,
-0.6290338635,
-0.2255734801,
0.3484750688,
0.4768416286,
0.3900567889,
-0.5611166358,
0.4658691287,
-0.254219681,
-0.2797601819,
-0.2731919885,
0.4818263352,
-0.0084543759,
0.1293946207,
0.7976773977,
-0.6302338839,
-1.5059821606,
0.4156959951,
-0.6045265198,
-0.5708190203,
-0.1645343453,
-0.4253841341,
0.3450614512,
0.7009707093,
-0.0513956137,
0.0895829573,
0.776638031,
-0.5368156433,
0.3944525719,
0.4171308875,
0.3436440229,
-0.8370583057,
-0.02377549,
0.3495325148,
0.1739750355,
-0.8123651147,
0.132051155,
-0.3829261363,
0.0110313175,
-0.8641377687,
0.7750211358,
-0.1649742723,
0.6016221642,
-0.1106120497,
0.0345569476,
-0.3525005579,
0.1783819944,
-0.0645802468,
0.5936304927,
0.1037212685,
-0.3437564969,
0.5837877989,
-0.0301412586,
-0.1803767681,
0.5576456189,
-0.3793796599,
-0.0233088452,
-0.1755580306,
0.0672964305,
-0.9095795155,
-0.2216063291,
0.5115258098,
-0.3412279189,
-0.2968880534,
-0.2421559393,
-0.4681677222,
-0.456145227,
-0.1521140486,
0.453438729,
0.1541023999,
0.1393971145,
0.3853688836,
0.8662779927,
-0.435408622,
-0.5757389069,
-0.8257047534,
0.0920903534,
-0.4841468036,
-0.5036916137,
-0.1284925044,
-0.4855647385,
-0.9851123691,
0.0726389885,
0.0158066116,
-0.3517207205,
-0.0017946431,
0.293674171,
-0.3600016832,
0.0743364543,
0.0099745141,
-0.0740648434,
0.1181178316,
0.3544729948,
0.3088476658,
0.7505900264,
-0.0635172278,
0.0404759124,
-0.1348020136,
0.9047309756,
1.0471147299,
0.3116039932,
0.8195085526,
0.1080705449,
-0.0861228257,
-0.2752971649,
-0.4660863578,
0.1296439469,
-0.4837034941,
0.5455422997,
-0.0193546116,
-0.9273507595,
0.882158637,
0.4269585013,
0.2229280323,
0.456695497,
0.8498855233,
-0.024432065,
0.7520139813,
0.6285657883,
-0.4829093218,
0.5937581658,
0.443459183,
0.2996589541,
0.1966914684,
-0.0917831883,
-0.6081681848,
-0.3231957853,
-0.577783823,
-0.2514525354,
0.3722789586,
-0.4541974962,
-0.6767632365,
0.2606827319,
-0.4681528807,
0.7915897965,
0.1190510094,
-0.0521687642,
0.3387898207,
0.2004842609,
0.0530804545,
-0.7290480733,
-0.7253288627,
-0.1286522597,
0.5661061406,
0.5641347766,
0.6946991086,
0.2527620494,
0.2764977217,
0.3247797787,
0.8969935775,
-0.6589123607,
0.3576757312,
-0.2184381038,
-0.9589271545,
-0.0948719457,
-0.4408535361,
-0.7400862575,
0.103648223,
0.1626644582,
-0.3833309412,
0.0068611903,
-0.1334185451,
-0.0700998977,
0.4970254302,
-0.6931015849,
0.9660733938,
-0.1770656854,
-0.3732284009,
-0.4747703373,
-0.6313200593,
0.4724230766,
-0.2317171097,
0.6277893186,
-0.0911049768,
0.0711072683,
0.7238742709,
-0.1250608414,
0.9399532676,
0.2623516023,
-0.4059925079,
0.3104269803,
0.2218791246,
0.1229582056,
-0.0337636247,
-0.141336143,
0.433288306,
-0.2807523906,
-0.5678116679,
-0.1302228719,
0.9939163923,
-0.7266944647,
-0.3604640663,
-0.6107451916,
-0.4467326701,
-0.1303293258,
0.1547431648,
0.4186066389,
-0.1937188953,
-0.2371117175,
-0.1515247524,
0.585137248,
-0.753765285,
0.1111002341,
0.7711561322,
-0.33538118,
-0.1682778895,
1.1511769295,
0.0378017984,
0.4504688382,
0.0087228417,
0.1390610635,
0.2285286188,
-0.2525751293,
-0.3958119154,
0.5560182333,
-0.8583472967,
-0.1369005293,
-0.8973451853,
-0.3118720651,
-0.0362338945,
-0.5175169706,
-0.5103766918,
0.2984329462,
0.0212725196,
0.0684099644,
0.4409586489,
1.0453459024,
-0.2288224399,
0.1157248318,
-0.8685044646,
-0.048335705,
0.452275455,
0.6130130291,
-0.0969384238,
-0.3663592041,
-0.168642953,
-0.1949739754,
-0.1546656191,
-1.4507262707,
0.3469676077,
-0.1442686021,
0.3291399777,
0.4391990304,
0.0575977378,
0.533945024,
-0.3831504881,
0.9357226491,
0.2034425586,
-0.5937872529,
0.5366005301,
-0.7080963254,
0.0859364793,
0.6392804384,
1.0201408863,
-1.4507741928,
-1.1304402351,
-0.4741329551,
-0.8579358459,
0.4726189077,
-0.0902453437,
0.8269684911,
-0.5262835622,
-0.0866204873,
0.0601825863,
-0.0218098406,
-1.149715662,
-0.7593818307,
-0.0372992717,
0.1745598167,
0.1855345368,
-0.6955784559,
-0.3848673999,
-0.5146914721,
0.7852790952,
0.4361841977,
0.0247953963,
-0.3896635771,
-0.1667411774,
-0.8638107777,
0.2842484713,
0.7096190453,
0.9133242965,
-0.1353988796,
0.1301714927,
0.2206972688,
-0.7271968126,
0.1449457705,
-0.5021551847,
-0.1303364187,
0.4176205695,
0.1850351989,
0.2530527711,
0.5427706242,
-0.8962943554,
0.3853525221,
0.0136957355,
-0.180392772,
-0.3013418615,
-0.2533730268,
0.2175672799,
0.1379079074,
0.1517474949,
-0.0091289729,
-0.2715064287,
-0.8198572397,
0.5748220086,
0.1521008313,
-0.7055172324,
-0.233698532,
0.4929154515,
0.507938385,
-0.0307968147,
0.2327825725,
-0.1861009896,
-0.7679069042,
0.3827878535,
0.4028376937,
0.7459754944,
-0.2146978378,
0.5642397404,
0.7699546814,
0.3956383467,
0.5764800906,
0.2467721701,
0.4289312661,
-0.7347595096,
-0.3068219125,
-0.8785196543,
-0.2753244936,
0.4243244231,
-0.1550248563,
0.0245228559,
-0.4267035127,
0.1696208715,
0.2876403332,
0.0101141594,
-0.0452042557,
-0.1357810944,
-0.0122009097,
0.8261731267,
-1.2947437763,
0.5465887785,
0.9725678563,
-0.6087566018,
-0.2698689699,
0.1677578241,
0.3648559153,
-0.475412488,
0.9009974599,
-0.3030867875,
-0.1447094232,
-0.2757654786,
-0.6495063901,
-0.6654763222,
0.1999532133,
-0.0013916086,
-0.3254893124,
0.3343762457,
0.2724660933,
0.8874340057,
-0.1259977371,
0.1102340296,
0.4942992032,
0.5841401219,
-0.0352921598,
-0.8798285723,
-0.221232146,
-0.6784023643,
-0.2399719208,
0.2886597216,
-0.7687559724,
0.8216940761,
0.3375317156,
-0.4243210852,
-0.3495521843,
0.2972052097,
-0.0446524136,
0.0947601348,
0.4867563844,
0.369378835,
0.1555309147,
0.2111751288,
0.7017683983,
-0.3871150613,
0.375744462,
0.8268820047,
-0.0870285481,
0.6012764573,
0.5559770465,
-0.117300272,
0.8417328596,
0.4195742011,
0.1891555488,
0.3703765273,
0.4170717001,
-0.5296618342,
-0.1049382687,
-0.514988184,
-0.3037710488,
0.0807158127,
0.4123108387,
-0.3124681413,
-0.7644802928,
0.2818614244,
0.6635667086,
0.4159306884,
-0.2557272315,
0.7115469575,
-0.0155789638,
-0.6926417351,
0.5662382841,
0.0291329324,
1.0406526327,
-0.5043718815,
0.045031406,
-0.4891943932,
0.1239976659,
-0.2122557461,
-0.9656257033,
1.0600063801,
0.3852980435,
-0.1173856333,
-0.2043921053,
0.6143177748,
-0.5039275885,
-0.3207859993,
0.8257723451,
0.4101835489,
0.2838425636,
-0.2313254923,
-0.8975718021,
0.4304562509,
-0.0317192003,
-0.1077539995,
0.5426216125,
0.5036991835,
-0.1838171631,
0.6806064248,
0.3780964613,
0.0955673084,
0.4173921645,
-0.1208038777,
0.9410105348,
-0.4757554829,
-0.2075124532,
-0.7660851479,
0.4171546698,
-0.0249501187,
-0.608394146,
0.8700436354,
0.3705465198,
1.0972708464,
-0.0210098941,
0.946883738,
-0.5026078224,
0.8531728983,
0.2894165516,
1.1013883352,
-0.8913670182,
-0.1468775123,
-0.5522162318,
-0.6378372908,
-0.6107804179,
0.5896232128,
-0.3101162612,
-0.193511799,
0.8554045558,
0.8926863074,
0.181833595,
-0.2701658607,
0.2420021594,
0.6649085283,
0.0730121359,
0.5398623943,
0.9940590262,
-0.2267269343,
0.7706326842,
-0.4216037989,
0.0649314821,
-0.231149286,
-0.5533370376,
-0.7675322294,
-0.5433229208,
-0.4120438099,
-0.7731181383,
0.1418525428,
0.6266152859,
0.0986756086,
-1.1346268654,
-0.4450081885,
-0.1548252255,
0.7030642033,
-0.0262608472,
-0.3443411589,
-0.2964410186,
-0.3202686012,
-0.8917495012,
-0.1110152826,
0.3856047988,
-0.4833303988,
-0.250403434,
-0.0907567739,
-0.6246823072,
0.0921552554,
0.8036664724,
0.6426035762,
-0.6106060743,
-0.4995650053,
-0.1192930266,
-0.5719587207,
-0.048460111,
0.9004219174,
-0.0892959684,
0.4333707988,
0.7911531925,
0.3004542291,
-0.0923135802,
-0.2252813131,
0.4688779414,
-0.6489827633,
0.2897241116,
0.3789097667,
-0.2588537037,
0.0566646792,
-0.2709864676,
0.4062948525,
0.5720158219,
-0.6464311481,
-0.8194901347,
0.4504424632,
-0.7594314218,
-0.6518033743,
1.555606842,
-0.010558865,
-0.0096262358,
-0.8014729619,
-0.0097452775,
0.0374125391,
-0.4688921571,
0.9744468331,
1.0296068192,
0.0732016414,
-0.4180592895,
-0.9199481606,
0.7519171834,
0.3836318552,
-0.7109981775,
-0.027921265,
0.6454423666,
0.6572209001,
0.4125640988,
0.8597545624,
-0.2369091809,
0.4781338274,
0.0019261854,
-0.0616726764,
0.8822463155,
-0.4029597342,
-0.0022369844,
0.2564759851,
-0.1756109893,
0.3306175172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18722v1
|
Improving Automatic Text Recognition with Language Models in the PyLaia Open-Source Library
| 2024-04-29T14:11:16 | 2024-04-29T14:11:16 |
Solène Tarride, Yoann Schneider, Marie Generali-Lince, Mélodie Boillet, Bastien Abadie, Christopher Kermorvant
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
PyLaia is one of the most popular open-source software for Automatic Text
Recognition (ATR), delivering strong performance in terms of speed and
accuracy. In this paper, we outline our recent contributions to the PyLaia
library, focusing on the incorporation of reliable confidence scores and the
integration of statistical language modeling during decoding. Our
implementation provides an easy way to combine PyLaia with n-grams language
models at different levels. One of the highlights of this work is that language
models are completely auto-tuned: they can be built and used easily without any
expert knowledge, and without requiring any additional data. To demonstrate the
significance of our contribution, we evaluate PyLaia's performance on twelve
datasets, both with and without language modelling. The results show that
decoding with small language models improves the Word Error Rate by 13% and the
Character Error Rate by 12% in average. Additionally, we conduct an analysis of
confidence scores and highlight the importance of calibration techniques. Our
implementation is publicly available in the official PyLaia repository at
https://gitlab.teklia.com/atr/pylaia, and twelve open-source models are
released on Hugging Face.
|
[
0.1083079055,
-0.3652866483,
0.4860320687,
0.3696919978,
-0.2782618403,
-0.0177458562,
-0.1090900674,
-0.7498853207,
0.162711069,
0.2504227757,
0.249848932,
-0.5260458589,
-0.6478921175,
0.3257412016,
-0.5201137066,
0.616214633,
-0.415495038,
-0.0112586562,
0.0271793697,
-0.1656353325,
-0.0324950665,
-0.5603283048,
-0.3369165063,
-0.2587318718,
0.4249148965,
0.2885409296,
0.6959736943,
1.0329555273,
0.6158115864,
0.2437706292,
-0.1419748366,
0.0832261816,
-0.1650714129,
-0.0672753528,
0.067264311,
-0.4655648172,
-0.5687754154,
0.0481569245,
1.0381134748,
0.5505066514,
-0.0860121474,
0.1647554785,
0.2533277273,
0.4955498278,
-0.6486810446,
0.4464499056,
-0.4751717448,
-0.3975497186,
-0.3322341442,
-0.0861462876,
-0.5713813901,
-0.4831511378,
0.1346644312,
-0.5943418741,
0.0759182349,
0.0552069135,
0.8948997259,
0.2642637193,
-0.3207355142,
-0.6528342962,
-0.6407206655,
0.7927162051,
-0.4868088365,
0.4501858652,
0.4439839423,
0.1282290667,
-0.2863487899,
-0.5491439104,
-0.5269210935,
-0.0993478075,
-0.1253992468,
-0.2271627486,
-0.4952501655,
-0.1418957561,
-0.0448599681,
0.6054434776,
-0.4609523118,
-0.1345809996,
-0.1519987583,
-0.5118060708,
0.5630325675,
-0.0024131648,
0.3807808459,
0.0660194457,
0.2723197043,
-0.500289917,
-0.5610991716,
0.0305424947,
0.542997539,
0.2808358967,
-0.0963977277,
0.609038651,
-0.0184252318,
0.7440873981,
-0.2058440447,
0.1352187991,
0.5354414582,
-0.1692311317,
-0.1482340842,
-0.0800415277,
0.7876470089,
0.0420581326,
0.4118159115,
-0.0974530429,
-0.3987207711,
0.380614996,
0.1184540689,
-0.792006731,
-0.822963357,
0.0969771966,
-0.7681627274,
-0.4724211395,
0.1293485761,
-0.7203823924,
-0.5079987049,
-0.052703727,
0.5193595886,
-0.3144248426,
-0.4649693668,
0.2959770858,
0.1200728342,
-0.1193539649,
0.4577633739,
-0.6386748552,
0.4575507939,
0.3715788126,
0.9955217242,
0.0270335078,
-0.274391979,
-0.6261863708,
-0.1945254803,
-0.4417668581,
0.895529449,
-0.3202309608,
-0.2464158535,
-0.0943296328,
0.1233995631,
-0.201062575,
-0.5667799115,
0.5835281014,
-0.3022321463,
0.212701872,
0.0309751872,
-0.564900279,
-0.1370825022,
-0.1292037815,
-0.9153246284,
0.8075538874,
-0.0975021869,
-0.7056255937,
0.1227241457,
-0.6292102337,
-0.2883977592,
0.0402680375,
0.2443584949,
-0.6429756284,
0.3113528788,
0.2645011842,
0.152925998,
-0.1137835011,
-0.042995654,
-0.3356204331,
-0.4428828359,
0.3035853207,
-0.4721850753,
0.7283406258,
0.3272854686,
-0.0513194278,
0.148873508,
-0.8183857799,
0.1285037249,
0.0489904918,
-0.5646929145,
-0.2320494652,
0.0394063033,
0.6359337568,
-0.0613395944,
0.3066679835,
-0.5644468069,
0.0449144728,
-0.6323137283,
0.3034198284,
0.3447709084,
-0.2003636509,
0.7508673668,
-0.2530193329,
0.2248766571,
-0.0706944466,
0.0189442243,
-0.2058394849,
-0.8881267309,
-0.6053211093,
-0.3741231263,
0.7080045342,
0.5882766843,
-0.7147077322,
0.4648081958,
-0.0467135683,
-0.5980713964,
-0.462282896,
0.159586817,
0.4427072108,
0.2400844991,
0.2999812961,
-0.5883338451,
-0.4946091771,
-0.5840963721,
-0.3375610411,
-0.766947329,
-0.3308094144,
0.1130248979,
0.5216422677,
-0.1046418622,
0.8651242852,
-0.4339066744,
-0.2891505063,
-0.153693974,
0.3916094899,
0.1768378317,
0.5449680686,
0.4987848103,
-0.6852405667,
-0.6097361445,
-0.1426336765,
-0.5364356637,
-0.2835123539,
0.2547889948,
-0.0006462318,
0.4982949197,
0.1381467134,
-0.3948152661,
0.5361654162,
0.6255571246,
-0.4648593962,
0.4200717807,
-0.4347080886,
0.1409137398,
-1.0158172846,
0.4249570072,
0.3851248622,
-0.3069822192,
-0.6749889851,
0.0682001486,
0.4837266207,
0.0144552412,
-0.2293682545,
0.6499476433,
-0.4610379934,
-0.1878847927,
-0.5194986463,
-0.2334953696,
-0.0753865838,
0.1349846572,
0.3067824244,
0.7551852465,
0.564920783,
-0.5869945288,
0.2673920989,
0.3060471416,
-0.6201918125,
0.0809400082,
-0.5458350182,
0.1187630147,
0.0721725971,
0.3784921169,
-0.9506431818,
-0.510586381,
0.65417099,
-0.6322027445,
0.1502953172,
-0.1196419299,
-0.6519645452,
-0.139274627,
-0.1475035548,
0.3692449927,
0.4652083516,
-0.5440475345,
0.9073065519,
0.7602198124,
0.0022053916,
-0.3177572489,
-0.633771956,
0.2539178729,
-0.0188131686,
-0.3856108487,
0.4865629673,
-0.1575569957,
-0.295553565,
-0.0297448318,
0.0178651959,
-0.3216513693,
-0.0439704619,
0.2542920411,
0.1980605721,
-0.2281515449,
0.0189485792,
-0.3044078946,
-0.2242063582,
-0.1850811541,
-0.2777782381,
0.2966745198,
-0.3695196807,
0.1313170195,
-0.7889494896,
0.0648397878,
0.5858182311,
-0.4092666209,
0.6823866963,
0.4477189779,
-0.6657462716,
0.0194992442,
-0.3447091877,
0.0409772433,
-0.4023746848,
0.1009397507,
-0.4295332134,
-0.5260064006,
0.4771951139,
0.3662776947,
-0.1127085239,
0.3446579576,
0.4068694115,
-0.0928389356,
1.063210845,
1.023332119,
-0.4174900055,
0.7170172334,
0.1772659719,
-0.016388528,
-0.5012465119,
0.0436224304,
-0.7742185593,
0.114755623,
-0.5578967333,
-0.4530481398,
0.1540885419,
-0.1002266034,
0.0758183822,
0.4109590054,
-0.3989442587,
0.5697540045,
0.4666254818,
0.2337739766,
0.3499162197,
0.1975623965,
0.1905863732,
0.1477076262,
-0.5773165226,
-0.7441444993,
1.2003133297,
0.862149179,
0.74964571,
-0.0142806657,
0.5996243954,
0.1248780712,
0.400555402,
-0.9099136591,
0.3841687441,
-0.4160621464,
-0.2569093108,
-0.136367932,
-0.6405237317,
-0.756244421,
-0.0260114856,
-0.2568551302,
-0.7136149406,
0.3779043853,
0.4350757003,
-0.391373992,
0.1380446702,
-0.8207077384,
0.8651117682,
0.0958177298,
-0.1854616106,
-0.1734628379,
-0.5013824105,
0.04273469,
-0.0598346889,
0.0568386391,
0.076940693,
-0.033740364,
0.7531214356,
-0.1381327361,
0.6777541041,
-0.2445266247,
-0.4644092619,
0.3913549781,
0.0917596743,
0.5636351109,
-0.1585273296,
-0.1862877756,
0.3243967891,
0.1063998491,
-0.2739087343,
-0.4105468988,
0.6263847351,
-0.6423863173,
0.0864377394,
-0.6307654381,
-0.6255078912,
0.0304194354,
0.1588470489,
0.0409212187,
0.5878562927,
-0.1979360282,
0.1638621688,
0.7628212571,
-0.3114769757,
0.3332758844,
0.4423698485,
-0.3382503688,
-0.4053083062,
1.0263476372,
0.0136969509,
-0.1196056604,
0.3472724855,
0.0451684669,
-0.4405317903,
-0.6436498761,
-0.7298519611,
0.2669508159,
-0.7564820051,
-0.0821882263,
-0.7027272582,
0.0047258702,
-0.4525911212,
0.2172253579,
-0.4095732272,
-0.4457630217,
-0.4031817913,
0.3618210554,
0.2018601,
0.8202819824,
0.1065431461,
0.4213268161,
-0.7435001135,
0.295517236,
-0.1575144529,
0.5863505602,
-0.2678817213,
-0.4720736742,
-0.4470135868,
-0.1918131858,
0.0836713985,
-0.9296489358,
0.5864620209,
0.2458282113,
0.3402638435,
-0.0794776231,
-0.2041222304,
0.213991791,
-0.3465795219,
0.2854605019,
-0.1362586319,
-1.0613843203,
0.3030361235,
-0.3022663891,
0.4473656416,
0.4583027661,
0.1754872948,
-0.2414452136,
-0.3839191496,
-0.263130188,
-0.5115209818,
0.7325357795,
0.4518024027,
-0.0968147218,
0.3051511049,
0.3025901616,
-0.3229048848,
0.0246145707,
-0.6968170404,
-0.0499689765,
-0.1945720464,
-0.8347827792,
-0.1628666967,
-0.3277775943,
0.2172157168,
-0.1654253155,
0.9390950799,
-0.3132185638,
0.2317686081,
0.0140527049,
-0.4568857253,
-0.3230907023,
-0.1993425041,
0.1248974502,
0.3629047573,
-0.456974566,
-0.0049234452,
-0.1167600155,
-0.841788888,
0.0501537845,
0.2909016311,
-0.1031262428,
0.1500524879,
0.1591165811,
0.4866610765,
0.1703449339,
-0.4693289399,
0.3839752078,
-0.5295887589,
0.0597848892,
-0.0651566088,
-0.1030478776,
-0.21638529,
0.2410287559,
0.3670345545,
0.1651459038,
0.1930605471,
-0.4416139126,
0.2864782512,
0.2661458552,
-0.0265382249,
-0.1406597942,
0.4441705644,
0.1430957019,
-0.2920122743,
0.5429257154,
-0.0718961284,
-0.4578516185,
0.4929441214,
0.5867145658,
0.7871299982,
-0.4670620859,
0.2865467072,
0.5615268946,
0.3471210897,
-0.5188999176,
0.2058311999,
-0.0757511258,
-0.8417736888,
-0.1621153206,
-1.0249534845,
-0.656193912,
-0.0072050733,
-0.4146237373,
0.3836039007,
-0.2617248893,
-0.0567825586,
0.0155077698,
0.2065228671,
-0.1943870783,
0.4271917641,
0.2934482098,
1.0563268661,
-0.9605981112,
1.2304140329,
0.755243957,
-0.2983801663,
-0.6900845766,
0.4001850188,
0.0749890357,
-0.1995408982,
0.2705890834,
0.3119708896,
-0.3243618608,
0.1814601421,
-0.3252475858,
-0.9358828068,
0.6871284246,
0.2993005812,
-0.4282160103,
-0.200067848,
0.0573715866,
0.6594001055,
-0.4433950186,
0.3557767272,
0.567173183,
0.2923514247,
-0.0477854088,
-1.227237463,
-0.1090912744,
-0.5900328159,
0.0286393855,
0.0874483436,
-0.0566128604,
0.7493522167,
0.0953169093,
-0.4047127068,
0.6908409595,
0.7222126126,
0.0804674402,
0.2785722017,
0.5214091539,
0.2704047263,
0.7280099392,
-0.0013385509,
0.9733639956,
-0.5165176392,
0.2050827742,
0.8792063594,
-0.0857335478,
1.1569445133,
0.2127263248,
0.0099966871,
0.493722856,
0.4506371021,
-0.017291477,
0.3866524994,
0.021188451,
-0.3823154271,
-0.1473583579,
0.1120818704,
-0.1344762594,
0.5321006179,
0.4406915605,
-0.618699491,
-0.1436017603,
0.0011831226,
-0.1233419552,
0.1987120956,
-0.3652583063,
0.5448165536,
0.0252987184,
-0.3705152571,
0.5156583786,
0.399320215,
0.8188749552,
-0.4743128121,
0.073467426,
0.0382600799,
0.5703719258,
-0.2045754045,
-0.6616026163,
0.4381751418,
0.2648827434,
-0.2182510197,
-0.2888203561,
1.0828498602,
-0.5661075115,
-0.6582432985,
0.1977202594,
0.356523782,
0.4015432894,
-0.3150383532,
-0.5393974781,
0.3763267696,
-0.2522198856,
-0.1653018147,
0.3147901297,
0.1248945072,
-0.0719458237,
0.4809724391,
0.5521953702,
0.131899491,
-0.1471900344,
-0.1124024764,
0.682320416,
-0.3109833002,
-0.4911884367,
-0.5441235304,
0.2107533067,
0.0500667393,
-0.264726162,
0.8763347268,
0.5530813336,
0.7411218882,
-0.0946259722,
0.5650902987,
-0.0024929894,
0.4748465717,
-0.432474643,
1.2466210127,
-0.3981973827,
-0.0337605961,
-0.5431982279,
-0.927441597,
-0.8379622102,
0.937070787,
-0.365473628,
-0.2295858711,
0.5453714728,
1.0130400658,
-0.0763325915,
-0.0019005644,
0.0154682426,
0.1685365289,
0.2860589921,
0.5793104172,
0.5649950504,
-0.7089806199,
0.591948092,
-0.2489973307,
-0.4871157408,
-0.1867128462,
-0.9273971319,
-0.6261749268,
-0.712158978,
-0.5159464478,
-0.5656831264,
0.23916623,
0.8364432454,
0.5794252753,
-0.996491611,
-0.4158465862,
-0.2063218802,
-0.0313607715,
-0.0207945798,
-0.1354848891,
0.2973253131,
-0.2047731876,
-0.9535377026,
0.5852895975,
0.1421693563,
0.0832244009,
-0.0623341687,
-0.1096419692,
-0.1207710057,
0.117530793,
0.3354665041,
0.5101348162,
-0.2071996927,
0.0661520734,
-0.1907137632,
-0.1653857827,
0.1290479153,
0.6093378663,
-0.8557086587,
0.402664423,
0.7167707682,
0.4930873215,
0.207584694,
-0.0724098384,
0.7962788939,
-0.3089038432,
0.1033187285,
0.0760373697,
0.4393183887,
0.6254482865,
-0.2328121513,
0.3661777675,
0.207646504,
-0.5901932716,
-1.0993769169,
0.0600272082,
-0.4356404543,
-0.0109805567,
1.0188711882,
-0.3825107515,
-0.598574996,
-0.1398866624,
-0.246619001,
0.4179677665,
-0.2770973146,
0.8513450623,
0.7393750548,
0.1967358291,
-0.1136442423,
-0.2477228791,
0.6858373284,
0.4830272794,
-0.7548431158,
0.2073755711,
0.7428482175,
0.3521078229,
0.2418700755,
0.745662272,
-0.3182416558,
0.4001508951,
0.0920923874,
0.0867204145,
0.0439636782,
-0.9322627783,
-0.855188787,
0.1389807463,
0.1928528845,
-0.0630639941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18708v1
|
Iconic Gesture Semantics
| 2024-04-29T13:58:03 | 2024-04-29T13:58:03 |
Andy Lücking, Alexander Henlein, Alexander Mehler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The "meaning" of an iconic gesture is conditioned on its informational
evaluation. Only informational evaluation lifts a gesture to a quasi-linguistic
level that can interact with verbal content. Interaction is either vacuous or
regimented by usual lexicon-driven inferences. Informational evaluation is
spelled out as extended exemplification (extemplification) in terms of
perceptual classification of a gesture's visual iconic model. The iconic model
is derived from Frege/Montague-like truth-functional evaluation of a gesture's
form within spatially extended domains. We further argue that the perceptual
classification of instances of visual communication requires a notion of
meaning different from Frege/Montague frameworks. Therefore, a heuristic for
gesture interpretation is provided that can guide the working semanticist. In
sum, an iconic gesture semantics is introduced which covers the full range from
kinematic gesture representations over model-theoretic evaluation to
inferential interpretation in dynamic semantic frameworks.
|
[
-0.1662902236,
-0.643312037,
0.3913165033,
-0.1089617312,
-0.3529771864,
-0.1241559759,
0.0529922359,
-0.8794644475,
0.4422047734,
0.1568194926,
-0.4574783742,
-0.40254125,
-0.996514678,
-0.3371688426,
-0.6215033531,
0.840364933,
-0.2674333453,
-0.1865504086,
0.1389214098,
-0.4828561246,
-0.2293406427,
-0.3600336015,
-0.297393769,
-0.2220287025,
0.379869312,
0.3837563097,
1.2215502262,
0.5258847475,
0.5714442134,
0.2893445194,
-0.1213083863,
-0.3894547522,
-0.4980483353,
-0.1147469059,
-0.3797233403,
-0.4359828234,
-0.190511331,
0.3001529276,
0.659003377,
1.1733576059,
0.110037744,
0.1851538569,
-0.0428849384,
0.4985503852,
-0.5709599257,
0.531096518,
-0.257142663,
0.076851137,
-0.1187162027,
-0.2114248425,
-0.0696674436,
-0.5016451478,
0.4291570485,
-0.5273475647,
-0.2728873789,
-0.155319795,
1.0999029875,
-0.145185411,
-0.3268974125,
-0.2630990744,
-0.6027724743,
0.4643847644,
-0.30467242,
0.5528584123,
-0.0185497273,
0.6388133168,
-0.0676733479,
-0.7479686737,
-0.8201314211,
-0.4969227612,
0.1318580359,
0.0752132833,
-0.3381388485,
0.2146095484,
0.5293526053,
0.247829631,
-0.1614951342,
0.039799422,
-0.2180346847,
0.1719872653,
0.4025188684,
-0.0063071791,
0.4117948711,
-0.3010735214,
-0.8158758283,
-0.0012887538,
-0.6368367076,
0.2845954597,
0.2613537014,
0.0414171405,
-0.2970666885,
0.4906820357,
-0.206762895,
0.6164489388,
-0.0061463937,
0.1694499403,
0.3771018684,
-0.2500789464,
-0.3754686415,
-0.1071961895,
0.5541027188,
0.442494601,
0.4105032384,
-0.2949679494,
0.197254166,
0.0470577702,
-0.0075859884,
-0.4402277768,
-0.1700204462,
-0.0113844639,
-0.5648086071,
-0.3106612861,
0.4933071136,
-0.3278105259,
-0.3562463224,
-0.2878808379,
0.4962318242,
-0.5683788061,
-0.4722917676,
0.2114458829,
-0.5579122305,
0.4273769557,
0.547308147,
-0.8733209372,
-0.0187656712,
0.758505702,
0.3809476793,
-0.0327210054,
-0.4401454031,
-0.0206376743,
0.5432681441,
-0.3977466226,
0.749371469,
-0.9300499558,
-0.2960294187,
-0.0687399209,
-0.0067778234,
-0.2121232152,
-0.4203371406,
0.693082273,
-0.4222931564,
-0.0090549951,
-0.2107175887,
-0.6202314496,
-0.6608855128,
-0.1612200439,
-0.593770206,
0.6270029545,
0.1666487902,
-0.3942885101,
1.1674120426,
-0.7872518301,
-0.3274136186,
0.4723413885,
-0.4735905826,
0.1835236996,
0.3795216978,
-0.4062276185,
0.5474820137,
-0.0532417856,
-0.0072489581,
-0.3593589962,
-0.0939409509,
0.4098419845,
-0.2136924416,
0.4706924856,
0.195991993,
-0.5568936467,
0.2303645462,
-0.5521885157,
0.1017177477,
-0.1136149541,
-0.2150741071,
-0.4955095649,
-0.0506274179,
-0.0970480517,
0.118571654,
0.2002917677,
-0.4165825248,
0.1946199387,
-0.2838842869,
0.2670960426,
0.6111760139,
-0.0612576827,
0.5887486935,
-0.05754162,
0.3449033499,
-0.2182705998,
0.3954794705,
-0.0672595724,
-0.4840075374,
-0.4328526556,
-0.4803135693,
0.004738919,
0.2958829701,
-0.5722720027,
0.40058887,
-0.7021459937,
-0.3144935966,
0.0174111705,
-0.1192265004,
0.3961995542,
0.1605550051,
-0.2452731133,
-0.3594413996,
-0.1477254033,
-0.9746448398,
-0.4000435174,
-0.4912973642,
0.217106387,
0.0719899982,
0.4099788964,
0.2956969142,
0.5412899852,
-0.0990915895,
-0.2499109805,
-0.1404266059,
0.5233216286,
0.3211778998,
0.2339721918,
0.6984277964,
-1.1706126928,
-0.0590338409,
0.0899034142,
-0.8418707252,
0.1449172944,
-0.2257874459,
-0.3257730603,
-0.0428187288,
0.618581593,
-0.5550262332,
0.6260261536,
0.2587770224,
-0.6185072064,
0.2937176526,
0.168393895,
0.5968976617,
-0.4800507724,
-0.0469341725,
-0.4193586409,
-0.0346760266,
-0.5911584496,
0.4919874072,
-0.0533024408,
0.0910464004,
-0.4660275578,
0.6421906352,
-0.5616673231,
-0.163916707,
-0.1234754771,
0.2454807013,
-0.1847017407,
0.1927091777,
0.4452236295,
-0.0278717428,
0.5774490833,
-0.5082722902,
0.2916703522,
0.07168708,
-0.680719614,
0.9937259555,
-0.2118394673,
-0.374048233,
-0.0968268886,
-0.2037771493,
-1.4707562923,
-0.331740886,
0.2795142233,
-0.6734741926,
0.4093022943,
0.0521645285,
-0.424680084,
-0.4044157863,
-0.2848849893,
0.4246090353,
0.2332898974,
-0.7536815405,
0.7249881029,
0.3027664721,
0.0535484292,
-0.5279172063,
-0.5528420806,
0.3047802746,
-0.2967295647,
-0.790250659,
0.0077953595,
0.2861375213,
-0.250312686,
-0.0457930826,
-0.0583499335,
0.0387300514,
0.0382125452,
0.5108324885,
0.1866473854,
0.047849711,
0.1109907851,
0.1024601012,
-0.1473207176,
-0.0969418362,
-0.0013275254,
0.1313079596,
-0.1569159627,
-0.6633833051,
-0.6237949133,
0.4742574096,
0.885529995,
0.2509680092,
0.396838665,
0.2060622424,
-0.4413192868,
0.4751398861,
-0.2997514307,
-0.184541136,
-0.3506163955,
0.4087918401,
-0.7957748771,
-0.5000990629,
0.4065755308,
-0.1856213063,
0.1399428397,
0.2761860788,
0.2445480227,
-0.1651207954,
0.7854356766,
0.5453616977,
0.3702672124,
0.712883234,
-0.2842966318,
0.2725144029,
-0.6167094707,
-0.353348285,
-0.3230283856,
-0.5739222765,
-0.1708593816,
-0.3115127981,
0.351000309,
0.440235585,
-0.1767258197,
0.5213996172,
-0.1498074681,
0.1732877791,
0.3586039841,
-0.0687123686,
0.3888908029,
0.0711488575,
-0.1605322808,
-0.0928886011,
-0.5409372449,
-0.7786230445,
0.50777632,
0.4137239754,
0.8477981091,
0.5764021277,
0.3765856028,
0.180050239,
0.3876047432,
-1.0109990835,
0.7662832141,
0.0498269051,
-0.4382695556,
-0.1491209418,
0.0326560736,
-0.9390004277,
0.1271796227,
-0.4676847756,
-1.2135591507,
0.4451115429,
0.1538235396,
-0.1720531583,
0.1726307422,
-0.7527603507,
0.9713081121,
-0.1395338327,
-0.2051462084,
-0.4111171961,
-0.6234825253,
0.3522215188,
0.1866893619,
0.2085738331,
-0.2223970294,
-0.1857461035,
0.7130740285,
-0.3803124428,
0.9916467071,
-0.3430929184,
0.0928905904,
0.2858254015,
0.5104891062,
0.347685039,
-0.5640221238,
0.0959550962,
0.5138952136,
0.2048919499,
-0.2654855251,
-1.0684890747,
0.352167964,
-0.3350768685,
-0.4181591272,
-0.1503265053,
-0.3613836765,
-0.1594837904,
-0.0305743981,
0.3671950698,
0.5550349951,
-0.3781295121,
0.0123082697,
0.2008488029,
0.1316362917,
0.1997646689,
0.5437517166,
-0.2312911004,
0.1847256124,
0.5519678593,
0.1245134175,
0.5919858217,
0.6903743148,
0.1979409903,
-0.4566014707,
-0.5801269412,
-0.4652675986,
0.0059817214,
-1.0630723238,
0.2844572663,
-0.4183836281,
0.3187439442,
-0.0818633661,
-0.4763495624,
0.0468457937,
-0.9303412437,
0.1534082443,
-0.5525292754,
0.3362182379,
0.5227651,
-0.3669611216,
0.3524815738,
-0.6055383086,
0.3538404107,
0.0359000228,
0.1771707386,
-0.0390468799,
-0.527279675,
0.164233163,
-0.1781376451,
0.0760828629,
-0.9092183113,
-0.2538411021,
0.3278098702,
1.0831352472,
1.0310827494,
-0.2299350947,
0.5432699919,
-0.157355383,
0.8670040965,
0.7038532495,
-0.8443064094,
0.388845861,
-0.4024618566,
0.1920999438,
0.3106298149,
0.4428147674,
-0.6460978985,
-0.4379957914,
-0.8749698997,
-0.9938969016,
0.2806338668,
-0.034390334,
0.3960156441,
-0.3921926022,
0.4240906239,
0.3424890935,
0.2604686916,
-0.4715786576,
-0.0958282351,
-0.0584900156,
-0.1832749397,
0.2645471692,
-0.2659287751,
-0.3398818672,
-0.3125854135,
0.3525652289,
-0.09950611,
0.5408244729,
-0.2430136502,
-0.2564661205,
0.0341855958,
0.1518059522,
0.3768398464,
0.6710673571,
0.0907671452,
0.3118867278,
-0.095233649,
-0.370921433,
-0.0688630491,
-0.1702278703,
0.0734308958,
-0.0645852685,
0.5433145761,
0.8047282696,
0.6041941643,
-0.5906200409,
0.8759563565,
0.2314111739,
0.1112220511,
-0.2562888861,
0.0556752719,
-0.184434399,
0.3029101193,
0.4864358306,
0.1880455166,
0.4153163135,
-0.8795669079,
0.3069680035,
0.684014082,
-0.6269286275,
-0.3700055182,
0.6102948785,
-0.0046860129,
0.3324102461,
0.1588827223,
0.0027496126,
-0.3808482289,
0.5357054472,
0.0605937168,
0.9511909485,
-0.1348167956,
0.2805383801,
0.2978461683,
0.1307741106,
0.1939070672,
0.5181784034,
-0.4632597566,
-0.8056892157,
-0.0824952722,
-0.4032034576,
-0.3412693143,
-0.4482571483,
-0.806461215,
0.361338824,
-0.3174625039,
-0.0635984689,
0.4846434891,
-0.8180510402,
-0.5545434356,
0.3380322158,
0.260478884,
0.9960591793,
-0.8449296951,
0.4318436682,
0.8364995718,
-0.4180407822,
-0.8334391713,
-0.1786238253,
0.1098673865,
-1.1648930311,
1.2608757019,
-0.011807044,
-0.5265901685,
-0.2420048863,
-0.5317195058,
-0.9139308929,
0.6659058928,
0.4859100282,
-0.1048123166,
-0.0257893335,
-0.0439742133,
0.4094907939,
-0.446900636,
0.4670491219,
0.4636196494,
0.5519495606,
0.7422923446,
-1.1416082382,
0.2062072754,
-0.1746591181,
0.1250243187,
0.2625597119,
-0.3006742001,
0.3445889354,
-0.5896844268,
-0.5749895573,
0.3696470261,
0.8024665117,
-0.3283204138,
-0.1218227223,
0.4122653604,
0.3456047773,
0.6655287743,
-0.3692761064,
1.2282810211,
-0.2563815117,
0.0886552706,
0.8454008698,
0.073495388,
0.9281871915,
0.4496357143,
-0.0215700809,
0.5876203775,
0.4629131258,
0.3380289972,
0.4857893288,
0.0836616457,
-0.4150915146,
-0.109448649,
-0.0843969062,
-0.0784230903,
0.9340375066,
0.6922747493,
-0.762953043,
-0.6388283968,
0.3335848153,
0.0544353686,
0.0785061046,
-0.525641799,
0.5977293849,
-0.0578617603,
-0.4871722162,
0.6123874187,
-0.3261693716,
0.2217809111,
-0.6297430396,
-0.1895327121,
0.4703665674,
0.0197756048,
-0.4174150229,
-1.2236810923,
0.341232121,
-0.5329636335,
0.0250231642,
-0.1061764583,
0.6101979613,
-0.0935002118,
-0.0652773008,
0.3899386823,
0.3110802174,
0.7685959935,
0.0434981957,
-0.6606025696,
0.0892873555,
-0.3217070401,
-0.2172963768,
-0.1017089859,
0.3207577765,
-0.505282402,
0.4640559256,
0.178000465,
-0.0986832902,
0.2496751845,
0.2058556378,
0.4849490225,
-0.7036464214,
-0.5196504593,
-0.5797455311,
0.3915506303,
-0.0879304931,
-0.1688536853,
0.5276420116,
0.2742345333,
0.6584427953,
-0.103404738,
0.8601810336,
-0.3319790363,
0.3363576233,
-0.6044992805,
0.4057018161,
-0.2735941708,
-0.2514377534,
-0.6630566716,
-0.7847405672,
-0.2557646334,
0.9271127582,
-0.7191545367,
0.2870292962,
0.6041032672,
0.3209818006,
-0.0083567556,
0.4425121844,
0.7941400409,
0.2724879384,
-0.0021848136,
0.6208437085,
1.02569139,
-0.1550420374,
0.1278570294,
0.1921165437,
-0.9632282853,
-0.2299734503,
-1.1276245117,
-0.5150765777,
-0.9072363973,
-0.6478258967,
-0.220775038,
-0.0408153161,
0.8567379117,
0.7574850321,
-0.4719134271,
-0.1257172525,
0.1526693851,
-0.0044678175,
-0.6156914234,
-0.2821849883,
0.4121419787,
0.1407866776,
-0.9132184386,
0.1102036536,
0.6332320571,
0.1730168015,
0.0248244684,
0.2721520066,
0.0626173168,
-0.0515392721,
0.9115051031,
0.6341199279,
-0.6155803204,
-0.9287720919,
-0.4329330623,
0.0987546816,
0.0742619112,
0.6414523125,
-0.5685593486,
0.5656834245,
0.507959187,
-0.0366958529,
0.2627525628,
-0.0015239082,
0.4355588555,
-0.2478146702,
0.2056125104,
-0.0009109268,
0.4967449605,
0.1775560975,
-0.3128700554,
0.3703595996,
0.4293327034,
0.153431043,
-0.3514863849,
0.8778887391,
-1.2676692009,
-0.1544969529,
1.1943758726,
-0.2327539921,
-0.3081083,
-0.2862736583,
-0.2049139738,
-0.1082924306,
-0.2348822802,
0.4558046758,
0.6087548733,
-0.6946445704,
-0.2473393232,
-0.4029537439,
0.2845308483,
0.1012359485,
-0.375712961,
-0.0180732049,
0.7174041271,
0.2617337406,
0.3887026012,
0.5771620274,
-0.5504315495,
0.5258947611,
-0.0058613475,
0.2005694807,
0.0182027854,
-0.3049616218,
-0.0760800838,
0.3844474554,
0.2769700885,
-0.4061319828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18971v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18971v1
|
Credible, Unreliable or Leaked?: Evidence Verification for Enhanced Automated Fact-checking
| 2024-04-29T13:47:04 | 2024-04-29T13:47:04 |
Zacharias Chrysidis, Stefanos-Iordanis Papadopoulos, Symeon Papadopoulos, Panagiotis C. Petrantonakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.SI
|
Automated fact-checking (AFC) is garnering increasing attention by
researchers aiming to help fact-checkers combat the increasing spread of
misinformation online. While many existing AFC methods incorporate external
information from the Web to help examine the veracity of claims, they often
overlook the importance of verifying the source and quality of collected
"evidence". One overlooked challenge involves the reliance on "leaked
evidence", information gathered directly from fact-checking websites and used
to train AFC systems, resulting in an unrealistic setting for early
misinformation detection. Similarly, the inclusion of information from
unreliable sources can undermine the effectiveness of AFC systems. To address
these challenges, we present a comprehensive approach to evidence verification
and filtering. We create the "CREDible, Unreliable or LEaked" (CREDULE)
dataset, which consists of 91,632 articles classified as Credible, Unreliable
and Fact checked (Leaked). Additionally, we introduce the EVidence VERification
Network (EVVER-Net), trained on CREDULE to detect leaked and unreliable
evidence in both short and long texts. EVVER-Net can be used to filter evidence
collected from the Web, thus enhancing the robustness of end-to-end AFC
systems. We experiment with various language models and show that EVVER-Net can
demonstrate impressive performance of up to 91.5% and 94.4% accuracy, while
leveraging domain credibility scores along with short or long texts,
respectively. Finally, we assess the evidence provided by widely-used
fact-checking datasets including LIAR-PLUS, MOCHEG, FACTIFY, NewsCLIPpings+ and
VERITE, some of which exhibit concerning rates of leaked and unreliable
evidence.
|
[
-0.2972204089,
-0.8467723131,
0.6886154413,
-0.0551339462,
-0.4084371328,
0.2607758939,
0.0805297419,
-0.8578993082,
-0.0065945471,
0.4604885578,
-0.3080949187,
-0.387057364,
-0.9001063704,
0.3678450286,
-0.7447150946,
0.8980307579,
-0.1990693808,
-0.0684921071,
-0.1258431971,
-0.2437845021,
-0.0200765338,
-0.2944114804,
-0.5073645711,
-0.6138295531,
-0.0168004669,
0.4606217742,
0.7183053493,
0.8934912682,
0.4081414044,
0.300529778,
0.165639028,
0.6470755339,
-0.3802512288,
0.0920120031,
-0.323086381,
-0.2607935965,
-0.4144075215,
0.2726222277,
0.0517401062,
0.1255417317,
-0.1636603624,
0.233668983,
-0.1169013977,
0.5069779158,
-0.7666437626,
0.2170239538,
-0.7754895687,
-0.1584180743,
-0.3176529408,
-0.1788417846,
-0.4517122507,
-0.6672458053,
0.0900960937,
-0.6703859568,
0.3581107259,
0.163112089,
1.3469189405,
0.32296893,
-0.5549485683,
-0.7134531736,
-0.7056688666,
0.3609268963,
-0.5194686055,
0.4838485718,
0.6507415771,
0.3073210418,
-0.0635956079,
-0.9674916863,
-0.7486156821,
-0.2569130659,
-0.2554625571,
0.1638251841,
-0.0724990517,
-0.1525849849,
0.1161305085,
0.3661971688,
-0.5810358524,
-0.1151679009,
0.1519305408,
-0.7789819241,
0.5148423314,
-0.292748183,
0.3103981912,
0.2047929615,
-0.4775179625,
-0.3586428463,
-1.0286806822,
-0.1579987407,
0.5147082806,
0.0504040457,
0.057022769,
0.5440291762,
-0.5791371465,
0.46108374,
0.3973037302,
-0.132207185,
-0.0714407265,
-0.5776638389,
-0.0471493788,
0.2767618001,
0.6046834588,
0.0879539549,
-0.22574085,
0.0044896188,
-0.3583356142,
0.1803911775,
0.0308660939,
-0.8505525589,
-0.4403349161,
0.4264648855,
-0.3590477705,
-0.4316376448,
0.4270834923,
-0.8479025364,
-0.4753485322,
-0.1017132998,
0.5809194446,
-0.3627902269,
-0.221292451,
0.1179216355,
-0.4080281556,
-0.2552144229,
0.6489519477,
-0.2020213306,
0.2210114002,
0.6617358923,
0.6781744361,
0.0370849669,
-0.0993004888,
-0.8146933913,
0.0275682844,
-0.3424302042,
1.4461275339,
-0.5013099909,
0.4986976683,
0.4708159566,
0.1655119509,
0.3862544894,
-0.3887883127,
1.3276957273,
-0.7745286822,
0.4127956331,
-0.3930617571,
-0.8101374507,
-0.2284992188,
0.4041594565,
-0.991440773,
0.9228612185,
-0.222577244,
-0.7511551976,
0.7189216614,
-0.4868948162,
-0.5269855261,
0.1001557857,
-0.0622725226,
-0.5167468786,
-0.2125896066,
0.5454665422,
0.1138200536,
-0.1991574019,
0.1345483512,
-0.1393851638,
-0.1293144524,
0.2571142912,
-0.5974123478,
0.7039955854,
0.1100665405,
-0.6181912422,
-0.2478807718,
-0.8692569137,
-0.0174324438,
0.1159719229,
-0.5160256028,
-0.3788075745,
0.1151959747,
-0.055276718,
-0.0126474779,
0.2444283813,
-0.8356295824,
-0.2181081176,
0.0049279109,
0.1265237778,
0.4998445213,
0.017936619,
0.2263605148,
-0.4743838906,
0.1378221214,
0.1893838644,
0.1588779539,
-0.3456208706,
-0.2863149047,
-0.7052409053,
-0.0331044383,
0.5980549455,
0.4805953205,
-1.1513127089,
0.573318541,
-0.3334770501,
-0.4385093749,
-0.1464622915,
-0.2141010761,
0.2033595145,
0.5607412457,
0.5239482522,
-0.1786359549,
-0.2803011537,
-0.6805485487,
-0.5380269885,
-0.5688195825,
0.0004271117,
0.1047484949,
0.4404731691,
0.1832477152,
0.8945490718,
-0.1634838879,
-0.3360609412,
-0.0165720731,
0.352519691,
-0.0076690195,
0.197256729,
0.3146383464,
-0.5991654396,
-0.4095540047,
-0.0790633857,
-0.6842273474,
-0.2260929793,
-0.3999073505,
0.1701470613,
0.200624004,
0.0734313279,
-0.7258917689,
0.4197042286,
0.667320013,
-0.707917273,
0.7831770182,
-0.0508355051,
0.605620265,
-0.2692466974,
-0.0715320483,
-0.1002587602,
-0.87455374,
-0.5370482802,
0.1140689179,
0.2880469859,
0.3591823876,
-0.3401207328,
0.2585539818,
-0.6303902268,
0.2077292353,
-0.6078714728,
0.3061597049,
0.3691981733,
-0.0607754178,
-0.000021602,
0.7050497532,
0.3619671166,
-0.6166706681,
0.4591843784,
0.3426423073,
-0.5722149611,
0.5717746019,
-0.59480685,
0.1714947522,
0.242773056,
0.7554409504,
-0.4799565971,
-0.4933923483,
0.3428976238,
-0.3667984903,
0.3120267987,
-0.4484663308,
-0.4931479692,
-0.138603583,
-0.1176799983,
0.0328972116,
0.0408833511,
-0.9795153141,
0.436288625,
0.457644403,
-0.0988267288,
-0.9861888289,
-0.4067318738,
0.5629856586,
0.1542202383,
-0.7214146256,
0.4199125171,
0.326353997,
-0.3827568889,
0.2228619009,
-0.3789407909,
-0.5619051456,
-0.0555120483,
-0.0397664309,
0.0106591061,
-0.1965687275,
0.0249857586,
0.2928200066,
0.0214493982,
0.1121580675,
-0.2162499279,
0.2911593616,
-0.0538821332,
-0.8033508062,
-0.7319666743,
0.2676857114,
0.6689600945,
-0.0341958217,
0.6902790666,
0.6658808589,
-0.493619144,
-0.3144375682,
-0.8403591514,
-0.6382683516,
-0.4819211662,
0.1669180542,
0.0869616419,
-0.6054742336,
0.5121048093,
-0.4055898488,
0.3165055215,
0.5159048438,
0.1208732054,
0.0736688077,
0.6621960402,
0.3954015374,
0.0996229798,
0.1426588893,
0.0117893498,
0.1079538539,
-0.0980219617,
-0.0741030127,
-0.6710719466,
0.0711274445,
-0.0154440831,
-0.1909691691,
0.1211896166,
-0.1832929403,
-0.0706730038,
0.3473083973,
-0.3093249202,
0.6231225133,
0.3397438824,
0.3510946631,
0.6607963443,
0.0374518782,
0.1283258498,
0.2636251748,
-0.5638065934,
-0.5685088038,
0.9743457437,
0.4690844715,
0.7244938612,
0.114111647,
0.2258515209,
0.8845606446,
0.3443014026,
-0.2960535288,
0.3564424813,
0.105801098,
-0.8492558599,
-0.3361587524,
-0.3199004531,
-0.5124797225,
-0.0050325803,
-0.4624918997,
-0.0607839786,
0.5691806078,
0.3152862191,
-0.1363140494,
0.3253464997,
-0.370893091,
0.1853555441,
-0.3150729239,
-0.4276264906,
-0.5845060349,
-0.2787001133,
0.4291471839,
-0.0094075035,
0.1295456737,
-0.1364671141,
-0.0015880578,
0.3993607759,
-0.6695851684,
0.6559964418,
-0.2132681459,
0.0229586046,
0.4155289531,
0.2978710234,
1.2490723133,
0.4887574911,
-0.0104572736,
0.561080277,
-0.2294197679,
-0.1548234969,
-0.3175091147,
0.4324046969,
-0.6550340652,
-0.4660153389,
-0.8744577765,
-0.0042889342,
0.0603455268,
0.3003515899,
0.4372901917,
0.7308959961,
-0.2761099637,
0.1842869371,
0.7717590332,
-0.0354637876,
0.4139033854,
0.7461539507,
0.2469715178,
-0.4441231489,
0.5656713843,
-0.0292390399,
0.1073058695,
0.3598369956,
0.1702245921,
-0.5090221763,
-0.8573186398,
-0.8488548994,
-0.0029593508,
-0.6892931461,
-0.615537703,
-0.5157584548,
-0.3057480454,
-0.201668933,
0.3785967529,
-0.8811748028,
-0.6572602391,
0.0065223342,
-0.2096143514,
0.3579799533,
0.941026628,
-0.2190752923,
0.008721862,
-0.7846275568,
0.4360160828,
0.2191560715,
0.4381617308,
-0.4801010191,
-0.6342061162,
-0.3682190776,
0.3265676796,
-0.1908908784,
-1.0857651234,
0.1666794419,
0.5300243497,
0.5706789494,
0.724748075,
0.5487036705,
0.4090820253,
-0.5593202114,
0.9187265038,
-0.1229024902,
-0.9032957554,
0.3079867959,
-0.1165888458,
-0.3444712758,
0.7588917017,
0.2237050533,
-0.0821516812,
-0.4684437215,
-0.5578597188,
-0.7023423314,
0.6464807987,
0.4961928427,
-0.4076613486,
0.1251080036,
0.3103910387,
0.4871267676,
0.1129076928,
-0.6289650202,
-0.474827826,
-0.6241799593,
-0.085733667,
0.6267502904,
-0.3991364241,
-0.5580921769,
0.1987615973,
0.9391481876,
-0.2958664596,
0.3334719837,
0.6891599298,
-0.5569279194,
-0.2989651263,
0.167378664,
0.6747974753,
0.8226732016,
-0.0579883307,
0.4455243051,
-0.0740066767,
-0.8431121707,
0.3207835853,
0.186075896,
-0.3720193207,
0.4360491335,
0.4026513696,
0.2893299758,
-0.2780587375,
-0.5338293314,
0.6987795234,
-0.2349408865,
-0.049535159,
-0.6301468611,
-0.0859844983,
-0.3683530092,
-0.1510742605,
0.6690869927,
0.410643816,
0.3017638326,
-0.4696013033,
0.5283638239,
0.2455724031,
-0.2892570198,
-0.4672217965,
0.3697927594,
0.3987943828,
0.0146887498,
0.5233617425,
-0.2375847697,
-0.8522752523,
0.6377369761,
0.2845558524,
0.7268289328,
-0.2176833004,
0.4992932081,
0.4098509848,
0.682810843,
-0.4886954427,
-0.0361697003,
0.1916140914,
-0.8861784339,
-0.6020089984,
-0.1999247372,
-0.5548482537,
0.3344940543,
-0.3069749177,
0.0084797032,
-0.2760483623,
-0.1973497421,
-0.2534378469,
0.006440307,
-0.6683897376,
0.1814951599,
-0.1096064374,
1.0829679966,
-1.0177532434,
0.508705914,
0.5639614463,
-0.0329189673,
-0.531976819,
0.1752995849,
0.2969577909,
-0.5607699752,
0.2992818654,
-0.0082742283,
-0.166223079,
-0.4517234266,
-0.6150721908,
-0.9616590142,
0.9518295527,
0.4381183088,
-0.3447733521,
0.4455596805,
0.279553771,
0.3311310112,
-0.1909919679,
0.7285887599,
0.4964932799,
0.7501790524,
-0.0126921479,
-0.8560149074,
0.334672153,
-0.0431139283,
-0.9996247888,
-0.1514511704,
-0.7447732687,
0.550678432,
0.0636907592,
-0.4531327188,
-0.1767358184,
0.7917679548,
0.0026952126,
0.5294337869,
0.9072860479,
0.5447329879,
0.899271965,
-0.3264313042,
0.7127636671,
-0.5252505541,
0.1188034713,
1.1061040163,
-0.4264198244,
0.6723541021,
-0.0165627804,
0.0538943596,
0.8209511638,
0.5890927911,
-0.038895309,
0.3905382752,
-0.6466056705,
-0.2835062742,
-0.4249995053,
-0.2381174713,
-0.2095891386,
0.3790461719,
0.4838367105,
-0.2898023427,
-0.3185773492,
-0.4319084287,
0.0624445975,
0.0296616815,
0.0909534469,
0.7856904864,
-0.1847753078,
-0.7195637822,
0.1982666701,
-0.2364312857,
0.2699839771,
-0.4902395606,
-0.2834016979,
-0.1933403909,
0.1170458049,
-0.3625920117,
-0.7934783697,
0.1342989355,
0.177665323,
0.1249103323,
-0.166358456,
1.2232508659,
-0.3885446191,
-0.0618809611,
-0.0328656659,
0.7315619588,
-0.0618898012,
-0.3500357568,
-0.629914999,
0.0451520458,
-0.1063805073,
-0.2785364389,
0.032702148,
0.3488720953,
0.2233891785,
0.8694321513,
0.9173011184,
0.3687439263,
-0.1552397013,
0.0107674887,
0.7740963697,
-0.1300148368,
-0.5526031256,
-0.6570724249,
0.2108283341,
-0.6441358924,
0.0825744867,
0.8240563273,
0.600879252,
0.467232585,
0.0968498662,
0.8596211076,
-0.2461408377,
0.5546949506,
-0.3786183298,
1.1050270796,
-0.0615564287,
0.3284455538,
0.0906615332,
-0.7994842529,
-0.0230648834,
0.4133280814,
0.2913550138,
-0.1929807812,
1.0057303905,
0.5100999475,
-0.2505681813,
0.4048785865,
-0.0179784093,
0.3955682516,
0.5967645645,
0.0156267826,
0.9315112829,
-0.5121865869,
0.794175446,
-0.3848864734,
-0.3081790805,
-0.2616683245,
-1.2080914974,
-0.7133538723,
-0.2990089059,
-0.6956748366,
-0.5291942358,
0.2489091009,
0.7100663781,
0.969464004,
-1.0113697052,
0.4052322805,
-0.2726664245,
0.3315281868,
-0.5042725205,
-0.195609957,
0.5541539788,
-0.0230900981,
-0.4361320436,
0.683334887,
0.0953607783,
-0.0443791151,
-0.1919105798,
0.2360788137,
0.0492293946,
0.3245200813,
0.2564741969,
0.4299432635,
-0.4496538937,
-0.7578618526,
-0.167832315,
-0.0370076671,
-0.0378741436,
0.8278149366,
-0.9033622146,
0.1962643117,
0.641943872,
0.6005972028,
0.2260398418,
0.3393254876,
0.5219421387,
-0.5314154625,
0.0011623184,
0.2981039286,
0.5006516576,
0.3724788725,
-0.6322157383,
0.4748826623,
0.2073799074,
-0.9161227942,
-0.9006823897,
0.2052230239,
-0.8569856286,
-0.017542759,
1.0490938425,
-0.4370402992,
-0.0509158894,
-0.8515213132,
0.2405587584,
0.2730077505,
-0.7066791058,
1.2510521412,
0.6375507116,
0.0456756949,
-0.0653476268,
-0.2581031024,
0.9245961308,
0.0382666998,
-0.8855038285,
0.2253312171,
0.6202837825,
0.343627274,
0.2922563553,
0.1737380028,
-0.0342098549,
0.4661578834,
0.2282548249,
-0.1418572515,
-0.3484458327,
-0.4622885883,
0.0905627385,
0.2986172736,
-0.2302757949,
0.0156301372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18684v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18684v2
|
Work Smarter...Not Harder: Efficient Minimization of Dependency Length in SOV Languages
| 2024-04-29T13:30:27 | 2024-05-11T03:51:38 |
Sidharth Ranjan, Titus von der Malsburg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, econ.TH, math.OC
|
Dependency length minimization is a universally observed quantitative
property of natural languages. However, the extent of dependency length
minimization, and the cognitive mechanisms through which the language processor
achieves this minimization remain unclear. This research offers mechanistic
insights by postulating that moving a short preverbal constituent next to the
main verb explains preverbal constituent ordering decisions better than global
minimization of dependency length in SOV languages. This approach constitutes a
least-effort strategy because it's just one operation but simultaneously
reduces the length of all preverbal dependencies linked to the main verb. We
corroborate this strategy using large-scale corpus evidence across all seven
SOV languages that are prominently represented in the Universal Dependency
Treebank. These findings align with the concept of bounded rationality, where
decision-making is influenced by 'quick-yet-economical' heuristics rather than
exhaustive searches for optimal solutions. Overall, this work sheds light on
the role of bounded rationality in linguistic decision-making and language
evolution.
|
[
-0.4295845628,
-0.7576060891,
0.7792570591,
0.2760773897,
-0.0620581321,
-0.1682067066,
-0.4543159604,
-0.3774298728,
0.282330662,
0.2622372806,
-0.6449202299,
-0.1383216828,
-0.5532748699,
0.1302919686,
0.2001752257,
0.7606115341,
0.224660188,
-0.0826113895,
-0.3110968471,
-0.3842064142,
-0.3472245038,
-0.4840768278,
-0.3827888072,
-0.137992233,
0.5881122947,
0.6512506008,
1.166652441,
1.0184209347,
0.3435599208,
0.3283815086,
-0.1928937435,
-0.2800006568,
-0.4904274642,
0.0194835216,
-0.1514743865,
-0.7285445929,
-0.0959731862,
-0.0409025848,
0.4293140173,
0.8732682467,
-0.07539168,
0.2152341902,
-0.189188391,
1.2772586346,
-0.8037055731,
0.1146158352,
-0.1194818765,
-0.1539448798,
-0.5662814379,
-0.0507486872,
-0.4176276326,
-0.1847430617,
0.4030167162,
-0.4485805631,
-0.0312271416,
-0.0433324873,
0.7064371109,
0.496098727,
-0.4125976264,
-0.1895720363,
-0.7483384013,
1.0025434494,
-0.2642795444,
0.6972902417,
0.3067713082,
0.1671926081,
-0.1276837736,
-0.4608587027,
-0.4573058486,
-0.3200944364,
-0.1548262537,
-0.1725045443,
-0.1765577495,
0.3805480897,
0.5490454435,
-0.0575863495,
-0.5541997552,
0.2125869989,
-0.4925137758,
-0.2561870813,
0.3877910674,
-0.0272910297,
0.3792903125,
-0.2890045345,
-0.1487763077,
0.069033049,
-0.6574422121,
0.4605374932,
0.1759951413,
0.2360700369,
0.3680500984,
0.6531071067,
-0.4949641526,
0.6420240402,
-0.268674016,
-0.2530239224,
-0.0472507402,
-0.6142812371,
-0.0753857046,
0.1682477891,
0.5960327983,
0.1565964371,
0.2991982102,
-0.021721255,
-0.2134102881,
0.3159185648,
-0.0202745348,
-0.8643242717,
-0.0453560948,
-0.0119419144,
-0.5885491967,
0.0617773458,
-0.1777870208,
-0.3882917166,
-0.0101730321,
-0.4140542746,
-0.0021571254,
-0.4900705218,
-0.0042556059,
0.2063628733,
-0.0203371048,
0.2542169392,
0.1965841651,
-1.0841696262,
0.5084515214,
0.9262980819,
0.7813753486,
0.0506947115,
-0.1878378838,
-0.7393658757,
-0.0150865661,
-0.417078197,
0.7547951937,
-0.5804887414,
-0.1546049267,
-0.2967312634,
-0.232862547,
0.0906889886,
-0.4544425011,
0.385997206,
-0.483979702,
0.2263287902,
-0.514939189,
-0.4353348315,
-0.4130173028,
-0.2077003121,
-0.4561718702,
0.6283299327,
0.0765817314,
-0.4607597888,
0.5928872824,
-0.4406066239,
-0.7597412467,
0.0327551812,
-0.3460733593,
-0.124385722,
0.3470071852,
-0.3731423914,
0.3082090914,
-0.482496649,
0.0815251693,
-0.107927002,
-0.075939998,
0.1545645595,
-0.1945427805,
0.8905820847,
0.219260022,
-0.3805536032,
0.2538454235,
-0.5561804771,
-0.1593954712,
0.0335728936,
-0.3894228041,
-0.6486769319,
0.117242299,
-0.1928137094,
0.1501542777,
0.2035902441,
-0.442071259,
0.3132455945,
-0.5172603726,
0.3405155241,
0.8262933493,
-0.1565236449,
0.9598860145,
-0.1817017198,
0.5592032671,
-0.571084857,
0.6591538191,
0.2478234023,
-0.2949180305,
-0.7796963453,
-0.624581337,
0.3199014962,
0.6562231779,
-0.5454682112,
0.0989620909,
-0.3240525126,
-0.2052331567,
-0.2753573358,
0.1923841834,
0.5626244545,
0.2756539285,
0.2522679567,
-0.349209249,
-0.4998164773,
-1.0185235739,
-0.3045061231,
-0.2131519914,
0.1074611843,
-0.0170856379,
0.2884790301,
-0.2479094118,
1.1148136854,
-0.6609081626,
-0.198384285,
-0.308090657,
-0.0537775755,
0.2357590944,
0.4474890828,
0.6948272586,
-0.6958698034,
-0.4765961468,
-0.1423135549,
-0.3186243773,
-0.1447750628,
-0.1391069889,
-0.2882152498,
0.3898228407,
0.5092812181,
-1.0182387829,
0.6147024035,
0.0586748086,
-0.4625948668,
0.5616025329,
-0.3878540695,
-0.2545392215,
-0.3553972244,
-0.278623879,
-0.2827786207,
-0.3005527854,
-0.8610935211,
-0.0174440145,
-0.0999705195,
0.4032814503,
-0.5308829546,
0.2782851458,
-0.6318138838,
-0.1295506507,
-0.1379425079,
0.0715386719,
-0.1443425119,
0.5441474319,
-0.2324658781,
0.6086445451,
0.4770130515,
-0.8715010285,
0.0835291594,
0.233069092,
-0.404962033,
0.4040871263,
-0.3734173179,
-0.0384357646,
-0.3888067901,
-0.0174472984,
-0.605333209,
0.1208691597,
0.0629215911,
-0.4165644646,
0.2506339252,
-0.1958655119,
-0.4979282022,
0.0769046918,
-0.2511182725,
0.4501890242,
0.8068966866,
-0.2639542222,
0.4500678182,
0.4240655303,
-0.3251987398,
-0.3413066268,
-0.6346503496,
-0.2119863629,
-0.1403916478,
-0.9250513315,
0.17894274,
-0.1025719196,
-0.7501580715,
-0.1565794051,
-0.4504593611,
0.0381280147,
0.1829686612,
0.0136749828,
0.1506500542,
-0.2576072514,
0.2879139185,
-0.1224241853,
-0.3438266516,
-0.0133069577,
-0.3591507971,
0.4266313016,
-0.3220316768,
0.0435301252,
-0.24801144,
0.3480799496,
0.6570653915,
-0.1796085685,
0.7237311602,
0.0672485009,
-0.1167601645,
0.0047146077,
-0.616781354,
-0.1192607358,
-0.5022893548,
0.2804281116,
-0.4902504385,
-0.9830069542,
0.3458392322,
-0.0408998318,
0.00329826,
0.3285134137,
0.3158626258,
0.0988065526,
1.1939296722,
0.5725272894,
0.0665750355,
0.6586478949,
-0.1482406855,
0.2321871966,
-0.3931601942,
-0.0380158462,
-0.5730291009,
-0.0881886855,
-0.8119763732,
-0.5798884034,
0.0870033205,
0.1903280765,
-0.1355398744,
0.2543231547,
-0.2914946675,
0.6196502447,
0.4342612624,
-0.2015686333,
0.1291143894,
-0.3866480887,
-0.0480072573,
-0.0741579011,
-0.8553161621,
-0.3671002686,
0.4542798102,
0.0694710985,
0.4118840992,
0.4170058072,
0.7040715218,
0.1834302545,
0.0736745447,
-1.117385149,
0.7831548452,
-0.210628286,
-0.2920962572,
-0.6024572253,
-0.5441291928,
-1.3132607937,
0.1966952831,
-0.2094092369,
-0.5282542109,
0.1753863543,
0.0186870154,
-0.4443751872,
-0.1373380721,
-0.6986072063,
0.9301888347,
-0.4128596485,
-0.4163269699,
-0.564845264,
-0.7554041743,
0.045863051,
0.1587572545,
0.5998827815,
-0.2791506052,
-0.3076833189,
0.8161762357,
-1.0587185621,
0.2342322022,
-0.3138926029,
0.303591311,
0.3982794881,
0.2091463655,
0.5800451636,
-0.2186512798,
0.2370515168,
-0.1893143207,
-0.015755862,
-0.8721961379,
-0.6232827902,
0.6179165244,
-0.4597426653,
-0.7939698696,
-0.4916418493,
-0.0355110504,
-0.0962747261,
0.4807935655,
0.2753816545,
0.3126064539,
-0.2992917895,
0.1389613599,
0.5572216511,
-0.1141951531,
0.6440262198,
0.5430134535,
-0.1940376908,
-0.1473207772,
0.941262126,
0.660577476,
0.3458216488,
0.3979494274,
0.5141184926,
-0.2276510149,
-0.4089042544,
-0.304212898,
0.3074460924,
-0.6568366289,
0.1600326598,
-0.5830498934,
0.3211737275,
-0.5081369281,
-0.4539925754,
-0.6107645035,
-0.6714459658,
-0.0832816362,
-0.335486114,
0.3731809258,
0.7643191814,
-0.1676817536,
0.1364349574,
-0.8810851574,
0.2229148,
0.6110915542,
0.2261955291,
-0.0614381954,
-0.0970312804,
-0.1726373881,
-0.1523486525,
0.1869623363,
-0.7327326536,
0.1939276904,
0.1717101187,
0.4785835445,
0.3165341616,
0.1209177449,
0.6784568429,
-0.4949809909,
0.4836046696,
0.5044721961,
-1.0957351923,
0.3777217567,
-0.2469659597,
0.5269005299,
0.7972928286,
0.2008145452,
-0.5164029598,
0.0205733608,
-0.6925580502,
-0.9388508797,
0.5798446536,
0.3532266915,
-0.1283817291,
-0.035207428,
0.2134000361,
0.1660815328,
0.0438372418,
-0.2343679219,
-0.3124684989,
0.2417541444,
0.0045497776,
0.1780159026,
-0.294885695,
0.2666456401,
-0.3468256891,
0.5050233006,
-0.1133571342,
0.1215104535,
0.1888153851,
-0.5155599117,
0.2910782397,
0.3794569671,
0.8531271219,
0.5488103032,
-0.0058920947,
0.20928891,
0.1619922668,
-0.3404860497,
0.205171302,
-0.1775593013,
-0.3212437034,
-0.0475412868,
0.2636255026,
0.7115820646,
-0.0650544539,
-0.6862950325,
0.6687826514,
-0.1657124907,
-0.0405111834,
-0.4160442054,
-0.0265170895,
-0.0216436982,
0.3378623128,
0.0061837854,
0.5588552952,
0.2950733602,
-0.5706355572,
0.1593708247,
0.2884813547,
-0.5195304751,
-0.4910236597,
0.3110359311,
0.0369681977,
-0.3364192843,
0.582021594,
-0.3634466827,
-0.5731493235,
0.578699708,
-0.0429022312,
0.8166589141,
-0.1115761697,
0.1999156922,
0.0602996238,
0.391212225,
-0.3785991371,
0.3795399666,
-0.3084826171,
-0.5378316641,
-0.742561698,
-0.4075396359,
-0.1460647881,
-0.4520018101,
-0.5838677287,
0.3225051761,
-0.7195180655,
-0.2039240599,
0.018333029,
-0.3039294183,
-0.7543581128,
0.1495944411,
0.1257359982,
0.6526197195,
-0.5641958117,
0.7705783844,
0.4160601497,
-0.4657960534,
-0.7435954809,
-0.0814807564,
0.0081775822,
-0.7144729495,
0.7269921303,
0.4186478853,
-0.3664058447,
-0.174841851,
-0.5378702879,
-1.0361329317,
0.6794787645,
0.4621426761,
-0.3419968188,
0.2542883754,
0.0841145962,
0.5636828542,
-0.0340040289,
0.1558725238,
0.8563601971,
0.5950082541,
-0.0603178442,
-0.7768341899,
0.3204594553,
-0.1192199886,
0.1682597101,
0.6109538674,
-0.9929181933,
0.4808018208,
-0.4467462897,
-0.5035140514,
-0.1379445642,
0.8677989244,
-0.0690625608,
0.1588178575,
0.8238716125,
0.4023468196,
0.7717263103,
0.0284790341,
0.9716935158,
-0.1427195072,
0.0634795427,
0.7990264893,
-0.046370741,
0.5559775829,
0.6744332314,
-0.1858365983,
0.5821970105,
0.5336444378,
0.4133933485,
0.6663236618,
0.5872790217,
-0.1599253416,
-0.2483870536,
-0.4607920647,
0.0995666906,
0.5944974422,
0.2425734401,
0.1448616683,
0.3744408488,
0.1802333742,
0.4344270825,
-0.0631689355,
-0.2388400733,
0.8224957585,
0.0428689383,
-1.0655506849,
0.7583166957,
-0.1976633966,
0.6081058383,
-0.550227344,
0.2630490661,
-0.1736098677,
0.0458443761,
-0.3093661964,
-0.4573752284,
0.4859588444,
-0.1463983357,
-0.4102636576,
-0.7256888151,
0.6382219195,
-0.0685709342,
0.1351783425,
0.4713365138,
0.5267749429,
0.0082005356,
-0.0373461097,
-0.3319787085,
-0.1947307438,
0.1650619507,
-0.5198853612,
0.4051298797,
0.5746501684,
-0.2628335357,
0.6469128132,
0.7957313061,
0.1066036597,
0.0559900105,
0.0412353799,
0.6756578684,
-0.7851130366,
-0.5743714571,
-0.9961355925,
0.4199991524,
0.062529169,
-0.1892445832,
0.6000115275,
0.5158784389,
0.9703646898,
-0.0125087649,
0.722224772,
-0.253973484,
0.08861278,
-0.4574032128,
0.2764998078,
-0.5750752091,
0.2867440879,
-0.1345966756,
-0.9399858713,
-0.4541799128,
0.6680864096,
-0.5170432329,
-0.2801599801,
0.9217225313,
0.7580240369,
0.2931557298,
-0.0588844381,
0.3024898469,
0.2858688831,
0.078554213,
0.3057172298,
0.8210622072,
0.094104439,
0.6324390173,
-0.4334053397,
-0.491918534,
-0.237169221,
-0.5423557758,
-0.6046054959,
-0.3412080705,
-0.4206225872,
-0.2127185166,
-0.1872560233,
1.2067551613,
0.6387342811,
-0.6696656346,
-0.3373804092,
-0.410479933,
0.3693580329,
-0.3071956038,
-0.2130528092,
0.2258435339,
-0.3223538995,
-0.348400265,
0.5051575303,
0.6884878874,
-0.0635153055,
0.0696074441,
-0.3041432798,
-0.4888771176,
0.270609647,
0.6573325396,
0.5811184645,
-0.6033592224,
-0.4232770503,
0.4189707637,
-0.3569287658,
0.1319591105,
0.8563715219,
-0.5409172773,
0.6062330604,
1.2132638693,
0.4878260493,
0.3353984058,
-0.3544795513,
0.6172504425,
-0.6049742103,
0.2599437535,
0.1324832141,
0.359103471,
0.0879736841,
-0.2045329064,
0.6170135736,
0.4365512133,
-0.6227537394,
-0.5157390237,
0.5547474623,
-0.7169120312,
-0.379965961,
1.1406797171,
0.0738424882,
-0.4656091034,
-0.3539170623,
-0.4012954533,
0.323721081,
-0.370097667,
0.3840408027,
0.4806489646,
-0.5507065058,
0.0076179504,
-0.4689200819,
0.684735775,
0.9671571255,
-0.4627430439,
-0.031143602,
0.5180610418,
-0.0017173633,
0.3940296471,
0.8756042123,
0.4339083135,
0.2166814804,
-0.1202820614,
-0.0463393107,
0.3057744801,
-0.2967926562,
-0.0917482898,
-0.0777605847,
0.3071001172,
-0.0959541947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01591v1
|
Simplifying Multimodality: Unimodal Approach to Multimodal Challenges in Radiology with General-Domain Large Language Model
| 2024-04-29T13:23:33 | 2024-04-29T13:23:33 |
Seonhee Cho, Choonghan Kim, Jiho Lee, Chetan Chilkunda, Sujin Choi, Joo Heung Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.IV
|
Recent advancements in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have attracted interest
in their generalization capability with only a few samples in the prompt. This
progress is particularly relevant to the medical domain, where the quality and
sensitivity of data pose unique challenges for model training and application.
However, the dependency on high-quality data for effective in-context learning
raises questions about the feasibility of these models when encountering with
the inevitable variations and errors inherent in real-world medical data. In
this paper, we introduce MID-M, a novel framework that leverages the in-context
learning capabilities of a general-domain Large Language Model (LLM) to process
multimodal data via image descriptions. MID-M achieves a comparable or superior
performance to task-specific fine-tuned LMMs and other general-domain ones,
without the extensive domain-specific training or pre-training on multimodal
data, with significantly fewer parameters. This highlights the potential of
leveraging general-domain LLMs for domain-specific tasks and offers a
sustainable and cost-effective alternative to traditional LMM developments.
Moreover, the robustness of MID-M against data quality issues demonstrates its
practical utility in real-world medical domain applications.
|
[
-0.2688469589,
-0.7189241648,
0.8292263746,
-0.0868093446,
-0.5847152472,
-0.1732915789,
-0.3425580561,
-0.3539700806,
0.0434243046,
0.269012481,
-0.6418867707,
-0.5109003782,
-0.8242026567,
0.0898052976,
-0.0229125246,
0.8361136317,
-0.141956985,
0.535887599,
-0.4009365141,
-0.3840733171,
-0.2740603983,
-0.5436021686,
-0.353805542,
-0.2938759327,
0.7188630104,
0.5058658123,
0.9874631166,
0.4857306182,
0.4920349717,
0.263635844,
0.3973079622,
0.3094528615,
-0.1370760351,
0.0745749548,
-0.1569204777,
-0.0429198332,
-0.56110847,
-0.0195181519,
0.6154839993,
1.0699870586,
0.0753442645,
-0.0040179021,
-0.1455296278,
0.5931244493,
-0.6982707977,
0.217911914,
-0.3217537701,
-0.143359527,
-0.2476204485,
-0.554094851,
-0.3089012206,
0.2116007954,
0.3146821856,
-0.6463682055,
-0.0182950702,
-0.0012917019,
0.8848060966,
0.116976738,
-0.7698309422,
-0.5041970015,
-0.8146852851,
0.8836512566,
-0.4510670602,
0.560272634,
0.3173185885,
0.6456622481,
0.0577010438,
-0.9084050059,
-0.5123749375,
-0.16174303,
-0.0828520879,
0.144650504,
-0.3236661255,
0.3168511391,
-0.0101166284,
0.2093111128,
-0.662358582,
-0.0386704728,
-0.2032358348,
-0.2005108446,
0.1461660564,
0.2852395475,
0.4133414328,
-0.0979615375,
-0.689338088,
0.0273168366,
-0.9356885552,
-0.1387630254,
-0.2108206302,
0.1934892088,
-0.2635856271,
0.6092879772,
-0.305873841,
0.5475648046,
-0.3102954626,
-0.4663989246,
0.3437801898,
-0.3753443956,
-0.3915586472,
-0.4444414973,
0.5348582864,
0.408572793,
0.0136426706,
-0.1340365857,
-0.3498634398,
-0.0075607095,
-0.1255904138,
-0.9248403907,
-0.0101818303,
0.2507311404,
-0.798055768,
-0.0031579977,
-0.2729305029,
-0.5651204586,
-0.0289606005,
-0.6094437838,
0.6906676292,
-0.4270634949,
-0.0572998822,
0.361875236,
0.3822081685,
-0.0590232909,
0.4318894446,
-0.5577734113,
0.0889309198,
0.0790430456,
0.7941464782,
0.251550734,
-0.1590418071,
-0.5132578611,
0.4318163395,
-0.0908696949,
0.588675499,
-0.7264852524,
-0.2619366646,
-0.1760231256,
0.1362283826,
-0.236666128,
-0.577121675,
0.4426809847,
-0.3233198524,
0.3658383787,
0.0814443305,
-0.2508350015,
-0.1050954461,
0.3742652237,
-0.5387753844,
0.3394182324,
0.2284430116,
-0.4997360706,
0.1347721666,
-0.5371666551,
-0.3947978318,
-0.0123527721,
-0.4986263812,
-0.4734963179,
0.0952952951,
0.4287036061,
0.8648333549,
-0.5832818151,
0.4504254758,
-0.3768817484,
-0.1588219106,
0.4257491529,
-0.5452112556,
0.346765846,
0.4670503736,
0.1155242622,
0.0823119655,
-0.7047159076,
-0.1466061175,
0.1738192439,
-0.3895986974,
-0.3375275433,
-0.2203379571,
0.2354805768,
0.5301894546,
0.1317306906,
-0.5898872614,
0.1074160263,
0.0300945938,
0.2111940831,
0.4843868911,
-0.0492422394,
0.4553379118,
-0.6454514265,
0.5317329168,
0.3674171567,
0.6106671095,
-0.3335238993,
-0.3688949943,
-0.4703406692,
-0.8318673968,
0.3707176745,
0.3233414888,
-1.1916047335,
-0.2465256304,
-0.4330912828,
-0.2357634455,
-0.6221041083,
0.131792143,
0.6257517338,
0.5406101346,
0.5347191691,
-0.4078432024,
-0.6163265109,
-1.0083961487,
0.2600673735,
0.2849817276,
-0.1891463101,
0.590834856,
0.1503359079,
-0.8333227038,
0.5472402573,
-0.4963962734,
-0.666071713,
-0.1663313508,
0.2033745646,
0.1619787663,
0.4066550434,
0.4112685323,
-0.9539620876,
-0.3361760676,
-0.0132517498,
-0.9388621449,
-0.079816699,
-0.2569363415,
0.1109018177,
0.0980025679,
0.4709948003,
-0.6633784175,
0.2436798364,
0.75460428,
-0.0979576558,
0.550768137,
-0.6532705426,
0.2978619039,
-1.2170225382,
0.1395108402,
0.0630621836,
-0.1169138029,
-0.6559960246,
-0.0128841465,
0.1809985191,
-0.1936599612,
-0.511417985,
0.5145145655,
-0.8405507207,
0.048364412,
-0.2946406603,
-0.266577065,
0.0266177766,
0.3663266897,
-0.0623802282,
0.4580826759,
0.8692415357,
-0.5047844052,
0.0982335135,
-0.0286218822,
-0.129895106,
0.6700949669,
-0.4668872058,
0.0104617719,
-0.5134766698,
0.2765040696,
-0.8665761352,
-0.4618116021,
-0.0835485235,
-0.440385282,
0.720607996,
-0.3816502988,
-0.5139360428,
-0.1295387894,
-0.0606068708,
0.8080220819,
0.3511333764,
-0.4172101617,
0.734200418,
0.3261705935,
-0.1946303099,
-0.7891893983,
-0.4611034691,
0.2439084947,
-0.023266824,
-0.7577248812,
0.3938304186,
-0.3129924238,
0.0855211765,
-0.1020947844,
0.0252043083,
-0.1774009913,
-0.0533092469,
0.2964333296,
0.3135742247,
-0.2177828103,
0.2739390135,
0.0630851611,
-0.3001539409,
-0.1633811444,
-0.006725424,
0.4730689526,
0.0006840504,
-0.4526321888,
-0.2965346873,
0.4400284886,
0.8104940057,
0.0050366251,
0.3561227024,
0.6131204963,
-0.5380495191,
0.0320589654,
-0.4103114307,
-0.1131283417,
-0.4512295425,
0.5228021741,
-0.5800328255,
-0.9323421717,
0.2382964045,
-0.4558618963,
-0.2711215913,
0.0679687262,
0.7383104563,
-0.47262308,
1.2666100264,
0.5788622499,
0.1189936996,
0.1647112966,
-0.0698270574,
0.0448177382,
-0.8876776695,
-0.453348726,
-0.1935890317,
-0.2792172432,
-0.2620140016,
-0.6862733364,
0.7700075507,
-0.2602482736,
0.0843334198,
-0.2825289369,
-0.2663680613,
0.465800643,
0.2004009187,
0.335895896,
0.3295637965,
0.0037390196,
-0.2479868084,
-0.1395672113,
-0.5587607622,
-0.5420157313,
1.4287497997,
0.3238819838,
1.1203943491,
0.1819471121,
0.2213772684,
0.2375458479,
0.1555404365,
-0.5785334706,
0.4542030394,
-0.4530632496,
-0.4978688359,
-0.0579678081,
-0.3277046978,
-1.1445450783,
0.3933072984,
-0.4389592707,
-0.0589332432,
0.1198724955,
0.1203713939,
-0.3966554403,
0.4037412107,
-0.5662260056,
0.6258345842,
-0.2973112762,
-0.231727019,
-0.1661123335,
-0.98641783,
0.2564339638,
-0.1796252877,
0.6801841855,
-0.3528890312,
-0.2911100984,
0.2899632752,
-0.1149445251,
0.9267079234,
-0.3250183761,
0.2168521881,
-0.1515376717,
0.146352753,
0.0724885762,
0.1254518628,
0.537052989,
0.0649409145,
0.0451369435,
-0.5562432408,
-0.4156046808,
0.6438149214,
-0.9149852395,
-0.2305673957,
-0.283225596,
-0.8429391384,
-0.5264365673,
0.2060627937,
0.2752906382,
0.8454736471,
-0.1806651056,
0.2925659716,
0.7371922135,
-0.3652300537,
0.2740027905,
0.4317728281,
-0.0293020867,
-0.4609417319,
0.7665940523,
0.0379841439,
0.2503004074,
0.6639327407,
0.2169731408,
-0.2436905801,
-0.7843225002,
-0.6324241161,
0.2229779512,
-0.8166555762,
-0.2864628434,
-0.6942208409,
0.0346046872,
-0.1197112724,
-0.1622383595,
-0.3545225263,
-0.2773119211,
-0.0929859206,
0.3081052601,
-0.1994611919,
0.4827522337,
-0.0272646993,
0.4215472341,
-0.9729885459,
0.2293968201,
0.3605023026,
0.2996304631,
-0.1742729992,
-0.4925973415,
-0.5865926743,
0.1314271837,
-0.1810228676,
-0.478965342,
0.4420773983,
0.3327201605,
0.525511682,
0.4695107341,
-0.1603931785,
0.6066514254,
-0.3413767219,
0.4293692708,
0.4754042625,
-0.6928916574,
0.2851784825,
-0.3985906839,
0.3992705643,
0.2249596864,
0.6224717498,
-0.4915102124,
-0.0638490692,
-0.4064028561,
-0.8344737291,
0.28440696,
-0.0197930802,
0.1492631584,
0.124571763,
0.1979734302,
0.2264178842,
0.1327985674,
-0.6655256152,
-0.0680635497,
-0.0083489781,
-0.3410390615,
-0.1858588159,
-0.4397028387,
-0.3836991191,
-0.2619800866,
0.3539213538,
-0.4866618216,
0.4360649884,
0.2677775919,
-0.6515077949,
-0.1584751606,
0.5542802811,
0.8396622539,
0.669265151,
-0.2568944693,
0.5501608849,
0.0184109565,
-0.4576372504,
0.13277556,
-0.1166200191,
0.2018229067,
0.0869326219,
0.3572241366,
0.5637306571,
0.4805455506,
-0.7424141169,
0.950704217,
-0.1338742524,
-0.2432042211,
-0.1543537527,
-0.4943679571,
0.0669117197,
0.3631808162,
0.5239631534,
0.2342067361,
0.2682039142,
-0.5027750134,
0.3991421461,
0.482839644,
-0.3383794427,
-0.5841034651,
0.6356424689,
-0.0146550033,
0.5292415023,
0.5458832979,
0.2536457479,
0.047090888,
0.3751606643,
0.5848114491,
0.5157750249,
-0.1010818481,
-0.0270662643,
0.1325495541,
0.1422497183,
0.1294959784,
0.3424270451,
0.2071284205,
-0.7139620185,
-0.5793586969,
-0.3332363069,
-0.4103677869,
0.093834646,
-0.5744962096,
0.2098478973,
-0.5954575539,
-0.3844285607,
0.1198399141,
-0.3819412589,
-0.6946526766,
0.6405778527,
0.5145412683,
0.569573164,
-0.6880730987,
1.2601023912,
0.82827878,
-0.4415380061,
-0.4805677831,
-0.2200946212,
0.0290323421,
-0.8650029302,
0.586994946,
0.1336727738,
-0.0512387417,
-0.3361361921,
-0.6491161585,
-0.7861623168,
1.3473058939,
0.4189901948,
-0.3503495157,
-0.2465466708,
0.3087824285,
0.3622663617,
-0.6881724596,
0.2894950509,
0.1173162386,
0.2009738386,
0.3053570688,
-0.9852218628,
0.1829954684,
-0.1159481779,
0.0448492989,
0.0933577418,
-0.4688740075,
1.0813133717,
-0.4762756228,
-0.2503466308,
-0.0670025051,
0.3782631755,
0.1860901713,
0.5010200143,
0.4483068287,
0.427454561,
0.5322394371,
-0.1138116121,
0.9466614723,
-0.2937458456,
0.3674155474,
0.7745867968,
-0.2397749573,
0.5306661725,
0.670825243,
0.0953448489,
0.3335820138,
0.4700618088,
0.2525833547,
0.7163726091,
-0.2177320421,
-0.4352811277,
-0.4450986981,
-0.0921305791,
-0.2758576274,
0.509360075,
0.5907974243,
-0.3157188594,
-0.5400915742,
0.4557745755,
0.028098898,
-0.1064689457,
-0.4107145965,
0.6395816803,
0.2888811529,
-0.1389985383,
0.6658524275,
0.029158093,
0.9216375947,
-0.7629209161,
-0.0035322302,
-0.2120547891,
0.2610731423,
-0.2520301044,
-0.5584959388,
0.3648693264,
-0.3670870662,
-0.3575688601,
-0.1503771693,
0.6543828249,
-0.6405703425,
-0.1224975288,
0.3220690191,
0.6522738934,
0.0580081455,
0.0023821907,
-0.5790784359,
0.0477196053,
-0.140926972,
-0.065508686,
0.7466347814,
0.4132819474,
-0.1466680616,
0.8589395881,
0.6794945598,
-0.02609111,
-0.227132827,
0.0792972967,
0.9352231622,
-0.5390843153,
-0.1006590649,
-0.7043373585,
0.4912624955,
0.2615081072,
-0.2053936273,
0.3766824901,
0.6151686311,
0.930796504,
-0.1751271635,
0.6441137195,
0.1136907712,
0.4622876644,
-0.7590180039,
0.6522535682,
-0.8882485032,
0.181479305,
0.0105568478,
-0.4564135969,
-0.6845211983,
0.209466964,
-0.1313916296,
0.1494536549,
0.7820253968,
0.842944622,
-0.364877522,
-0.411935091,
0.8780210614,
0.0705313906,
0.1981779486,
0.8282103539,
0.7690057158,
-0.255233556,
0.5687586665,
-0.2454768419,
-0.3302481771,
-0.2461563051,
-0.5778977275,
-0.6852892637,
-0.7377115488,
-0.1721902639,
-0.3151100278,
-0.0963638574,
1.0729886293,
0.9235189557,
-0.5001209378,
-0.125972867,
0.8747228384,
-0.3440338969,
0.0284131858,
-0.0601904951,
0.4807236195,
-0.2758923769,
-0.7028624415,
0.4488641024,
0.5626499057,
0.3100126386,
0.015717281,
-0.2277593911,
-0.1601897627,
0.1420947015,
0.8266450763,
0.1512716711,
-0.5116161704,
-0.0941831023,
-0.0248207487,
-0.4305169284,
0.2286230028,
0.8484427929,
-0.4628683031,
0.8332674503,
0.0809686482,
0.5457209945,
0.4857795835,
-0.2099244148,
0.4303500056,
-0.9113460779,
0.3068468571,
0.2381469011,
0.6813474894,
0.5094140172,
-0.2482403964,
0.3370327353,
0.2673657835,
-0.5934850574,
-0.6506346464,
0.3187864125,
-1.2010502815,
-0.5625314713,
1.0946676731,
-0.1127883121,
-0.1396255046,
-0.2931725085,
-0.0768344775,
0.1902534068,
-0.0013240855,
0.5613123178,
0.3173803985,
-0.1561391354,
-0.2988198996,
-0.5737075806,
0.3301857114,
0.344894737,
-0.6054545641,
-0.3118723035,
0.7361957431,
0.651902616,
-0.1653468758,
0.8646582961,
-0.5044721365,
0.5202896595,
-0.4467778206,
0.3721624613,
-0.2842473388,
-0.5162513256,
-0.3770300746,
0.2993972003,
0.1586941332,
-0.2659211159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01590v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01590v1
|
101 Billion Arabic Words Dataset
| 2024-04-29T13:15:03 | 2024-04-29T13:15:03 |
Manel Aloui, Hasna Chouikhi, Ghaith Chaabane, Haithem Kchaou, Chehir Dhaouadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models have revolutionized the field of
natural language processing, showcasing an impressive rise predominantly in
English-centric domains. These advancements have set a global benchmark,
inspiring significant efforts toward developing Arabic LLMs capable of
understanding and generating the Arabic language with remarkable accuracy.
Despite these advancements, a critical challenge persists: the potential bias
in Arabic LLMs, primarily attributed to their reliance on datasets comprising
English data that has been translated into Arabic. This reliance not only
compromises the authenticity of the generated content but also reflects a
broader issue -the scarcity of original quality Arabic linguistic data. This
study aims to address the data scarcity in the Arab world and to encourage the
development of Arabic Language Models that are true to both the linguistic and
nuances of the region. We undertook a large-scale data mining project,
extracting a substantial volume of text from the Common Crawl WET files,
specifically targeting Arabic content. The extracted data underwent a rigorous
cleaning and deduplication process, using innovative techniques to ensure the
integrity and uniqueness of the dataset. The result is the 101 Billion Arabic
Words Dataset, the largest Arabic dataset available to date, which can
significantly contribute to the development of authentic Arabic LLMs. This
study not only highlights the potential for creating linguistically and
culturally accurate Arabic LLMs but also sets a precedent for future research
in enhancing the authenticity of Arabic language models.
|
[
-0.2949616909,
-0.6028983593,
0.3439984322,
-0.0312649533,
-0.2110354453,
0.1946198344,
-0.2386586815,
-0.4296934009,
0.0140931113,
0.7099627852,
-0.285045743,
-0.9284520149,
-0.8920921087,
0.3104161322,
-0.5720950365,
1.0142408609,
-0.1676620245,
0.0420032293,
0.0228973422,
-0.61567384,
-0.4175050259,
-0.4666258693,
-0.4343576133,
-0.1669197679,
0.2321898341,
0.543559432,
0.9996167421,
0.8368941545,
0.2101160288,
0.2394980788,
-0.083557561,
0.4761795402,
-0.4455688894,
0.1004651636,
-0.2066314667,
-0.2026603818,
-0.2444876134,
-0.0613368526,
0.5722329021,
0.6631822586,
-0.1878533661,
0.3067015707,
0.0529426336,
1.0069313049,
-0.5072056651,
0.1383642405,
-0.7131433487,
-0.2315278649,
-0.392021656,
0.0679074079,
-0.0912078694,
-0.408347398,
0.0937846601,
-0.1514762938,
0.1372662038,
-0.0708803236,
0.7401847839,
0.1602339894,
-0.4441580176,
-0.5179363489,
-0.6163634658,
0.8278700709,
-0.6618020535,
0.2426314205,
0.5717079043,
0.0779090524,
-0.3114002347,
-0.5759176016,
-0.6273843646,
-0.0983448476,
0.1404892206,
-0.3129546344,
-0.0316875838,
-0.2281221002,
-0.0437348559,
0.3878783286,
-0.5757192969,
-0.0578211509,
0.0845675096,
-0.2603032887,
0.6973439455,
0.1997060627,
0.5260105133,
-0.0513744764,
-0.030459404,
0.018005209,
-1.0154144764,
-0.1393044591,
0.3286368549,
0.2652770877,
0.00486279,
0.4972663522,
-0.6065069437,
0.4430269003,
-0.4933821261,
-0.3831654191,
0.1613462865,
-0.3686802387,
0.0073845461,
0.2721824348,
0.5180006027,
0.2330759913,
0.6027128696,
-0.1514369696,
-0.2000343204,
-0.1888639331,
0.0568174273,
-0.7786576748,
0.1029184535,
0.3933963478,
-0.3629040718,
-0.1994060725,
0.0730210394,
-0.6381536126,
-0.4519658387,
-0.383356899,
0.2552223802,
-0.4526799619,
-0.1006190479,
0.1404477954,
0.1744788438,
0.0824269801,
0.2727119625,
-0.4826257825,
0.1704021692,
0.5712345243,
0.9108768702,
-0.1007583067,
-0.1411811113,
0.0142683322,
0.3953762054,
-0.4745630324,
0.4287911057,
-0.6057750583,
-0.3026273847,
0.3162635267,
-0.0889673233,
0.5314929485,
-0.8101564646,
0.8838703632,
-0.8852035403,
-0.186747402,
-0.2106587887,
-0.5057268739,
-0.4371804893,
0.2259574533,
-0.8318727612,
0.9530293345,
0.0277171675,
-0.6909189224,
0.3403658271,
-0.3740935624,
-0.4009216428,
0.3072013557,
-0.1348745972,
-0.3301644325,
0.2188115567,
0.4179800451,
0.1918273419,
-0.4010262489,
0.4271588326,
0.1051995531,
-0.503043592,
0.4711709321,
-0.5842272043,
0.4475126565,
0.3032414317,
-0.3572030663,
-0.4087291062,
-0.8102566004,
-0.0412962399,
0.2368349731,
-0.3954841793,
-0.3560692966,
-0.0206926204,
0.1669116318,
0.147762239,
0.5111625195,
-0.5366375446,
0.208439365,
-0.342476815,
0.157515645,
0.7702833414,
-0.0073344368,
0.1242426187,
-0.5931953192,
0.4955501854,
0.0711865649,
-0.420609355,
-0.3259372413,
-0.2973989248,
-0.8085581064,
-0.511254549,
0.5712378621,
0.4347397685,
-0.5860851407,
0.4957726896,
-0.6600536704,
-0.5593091249,
-0.8491488099,
0.3104905486,
0.050134372,
0.2360223085,
0.2753256559,
-0.1984261274,
-0.4633230865,
-0.9954800606,
-0.3147644103,
0.1989106834,
0.0140406014,
0.3407871425,
0.401904285,
-0.4864044189,
1.179299593,
-0.3614636362,
-0.3703015447,
-0.3307480514,
0.1831152886,
0.4017272294,
0.4286735058,
0.2041302472,
-0.6800638437,
-0.5895553231,
-0.0294403657,
-0.6594458818,
-0.3741420507,
0.0394658893,
-0.2006817907,
0.5175806284,
0.3130280077,
-0.5799337626,
0.6540228128,
0.5768944621,
-0.1931340545,
0.3545863926,
-0.007945749,
0.232825309,
-0.8584111333,
0.2411203086,
-0.2347242385,
-0.1605592519,
-0.4265999198,
-0.0911418796,
-0.0913796276,
-0.0005429672,
-0.2483623922,
0.7476708889,
-0.4160871208,
0.3508149385,
-0.5830580592,
-0.2263813913,
-0.1534586698,
0.1385923922,
-0.0447824299,
0.9453340173,
0.405272454,
-0.4658601284,
0.2772063315,
0.3710695505,
-0.6724825501,
0.0754835606,
-0.5808051825,
0.2874667346,
-0.3223733008,
0.1891022921,
-0.9908685088,
-0.1845312417,
0.0534149371,
-0.3501167893,
0.2409351468,
-0.087128669,
-0.7001900077,
0.0460776575,
-0.2580191493,
0.4539353251,
0.5471954942,
-0.4329868257,
0.4087385833,
0.4481690526,
-0.5958263278,
-0.7860834599,
-0.3862043023,
0.3995339572,
-0.2199103683,
-0.4941649437,
0.2147706598,
0.1923290938,
-0.4375383258,
-0.0187185425,
-0.2536992431,
0.1289186627,
0.1021663696,
0.5048231483,
0.119838886,
0.0702911541,
0.253126502,
0.0036827151,
-0.111546725,
-0.0070450329,
-0.4480964243,
0.7735952735,
0.1475766897,
-0.2247675508,
-0.3935880363,
0.3937705457,
0.7411222458,
-0.0848905891,
1.1886327267,
0.4017232358,
-0.5432695746,
-0.3597458005,
-0.6985638142,
0.162827909,
-0.457195729,
0.4974430799,
-0.3014396429,
-0.7229573727,
0.3504567146,
-0.2638969719,
-0.0591044426,
0.4352106154,
0.5388643742,
0.0578182153,
0.9202266335,
0.6037682295,
-0.8681306243,
-0.059532471,
-0.141792506,
0.2177523822,
-0.3836432099,
-0.1419828236,
-0.6406568289,
-0.4708555043,
-0.7311016321,
-0.3717550635,
0.2961864471,
-0.1099886373,
-0.2621011436,
-0.0368049368,
-0.0656853989,
0.4617232084,
0.4708583057,
0.0777332708,
0.5518369079,
0.542845726,
-0.0730337277,
-0.2354838252,
-0.4489260316,
-1.2429037094,
1.3126269579,
0.2606470287,
0.5296147466,
0.3569453359,
0.5426977873,
0.7306720018,
0.4513215125,
-0.5611050129,
0.524241209,
-0.0571471378,
-0.5633186102,
-0.2522317767,
-0.3002058566,
-1.0069249868,
-0.1002348289,
0.0208219178,
-0.3890421093,
-0.3764256239,
-0.2197588831,
0.1115147248,
0.1464769542,
-0.1777820438,
0.4235393405,
-0.1362525821,
-0.537176311,
-0.3380502462,
-0.3784094751,
0.0932500586,
-0.4867212474,
0.4825490117,
-0.3202342391,
-0.4401109219,
0.7889786363,
-0.6028982997,
0.4962337315,
-0.0255745314,
-0.4303663969,
0.5304051638,
0.3436843753,
0.650800705,
0.1088933498,
-0.3394347131,
0.6176509261,
-0.2304829508,
-0.7082702518,
-0.1431612819,
0.8210213184,
-0.9003215432,
-0.4946665764,
-0.6517342329,
-0.6959434748,
-0.314493686,
0.0281316526,
0.0698448718,
0.3322211802,
-0.3815830052,
-0.0007998777,
0.3994270861,
-0.5233850479,
0.4834291041,
0.8111667633,
-0.0975657552,
-0.4683278203,
0.9255005121,
0.3245360255,
-0.1525886208,
0.2317256033,
-0.1920379102,
-0.3157492876,
-0.9719577432,
-0.5035837293,
0.2841232121,
-0.5294103622,
-0.3234185874,
-0.6283376813,
-0.2148243338,
-0.1720244288,
-0.0094705923,
-0.107224375,
-0.1320720017,
-0.0715531334,
-0.0293684229,
0.5702144504,
0.7638696432,
-0.0363677368,
0.2354253232,
-1.1870663166,
0.3013750613,
0.0881804004,
0.1988355964,
0.1212082803,
-0.6916297674,
-0.3716599643,
0.3152340651,
-0.1809456497,
-0.6264749765,
0.7800513506,
0.2966746092,
0.2913042009,
0.4061435461,
-0.0323746689,
0.5085203648,
-0.5726159215,
0.7543519139,
-0.4533798099,
-0.947568953,
0.5059796572,
-0.379162848,
0.408618927,
0.8317793608,
0.8307207823,
-0.8146790266,
-0.2592271566,
-0.6290327907,
-1.0708566904,
0.6354000568,
0.3266716897,
0.3396479189,
0.0943440348,
0.410425216,
0.5302485824,
0.4676252902,
-0.3587733507,
-0.3957243562,
0.3295064569,
-0.6707638502,
0.016844077,
-0.4500292838,
0.1023631096,
-0.0304787941,
0.9209991693,
-0.0839498192,
-0.1257614195,
0.0298679415,
-0.4161192775,
0.0254753865,
0.2615054548,
0.1790223271,
0.7515876293,
-0.1480213255,
0.2522903681,
0.3099246919,
-0.943572402,
0.4001079798,
-0.0546304882,
-0.4187818766,
0.2003474981,
0.4897266328,
0.1802923381,
-0.4568558931,
-1.2883235216,
0.3043196797,
0.108117722,
0.2103929222,
-0.3782448471,
-0.1712706685,
0.0717639625,
-0.1291658729,
0.8121620417,
-0.2262087762,
0.0404721536,
-0.4448792636,
0.3917083144,
0.488419354,
-0.1376717985,
-0.054965198,
0.1841555685,
0.1115046889,
-0.0613825321,
0.8102027178,
-0.1101385579,
-0.6178321242,
0.4836405218,
0.236953631,
0.5280442238,
0.0035521362,
0.156800732,
0.3994037509,
0.2474580705,
-0.028923681,
0.3585505188,
0.0711800754,
-0.8704285622,
-0.4290298223,
-0.9463828802,
-0.3401933014,
0.4514761269,
-0.2992381155,
0.1721245944,
-0.3830068409,
0.0703502744,
-0.5154338479,
0.2935911715,
-0.6406875849,
0.3292929232,
0.373718828,
0.8885953426,
-0.7342864871,
0.8072362542,
0.4758313298,
-0.1186982989,
-0.5036557913,
-0.0242844727,
-0.0812734589,
-1.1337891817,
0.7463417649,
0.3124867976,
-0.0190349687,
0.0396859087,
-0.8988167644,
-1.0333982706,
0.7935273051,
0.1659535766,
-0.5811120868,
0.4712652564,
0.7110689282,
0.4763845801,
-0.2282546163,
0.0674344078,
0.7763239741,
0.4481810629,
0.0365575999,
-0.5503345728,
0.1282852739,
-0.2030256689,
-0.0204450376,
0.1998118907,
-0.5280569792,
0.5624567866,
-0.0316924453,
-0.285169661,
0.3075502217,
0.6913021803,
0.3108405471,
0.1077139601,
0.1606649309,
0.8139565587,
0.737295866,
-0.0761155859,
0.7169746161,
-0.5172499418,
0.0376847871,
0.9446287155,
-0.4752682447,
0.6961385608,
0.230095759,
-0.2803050876,
0.43477422,
0.361464113,
0.1599925458,
0.4377262294,
0.4367635548,
-0.7148711681,
-0.0651566237,
-0.789114356,
-0.3720144331,
0.7234082222,
0.3327144384,
-0.3634513021,
-0.0769269317,
-0.2270923108,
0.4285226762,
0.1355571449,
-0.3538745642,
0.6446518898,
-0.1290519387,
-0.4131247401,
0.474501282,
0.2507011294,
0.7170110345,
-0.5975168943,
-0.1787270755,
-0.532282114,
0.0610765927,
-0.1855468452,
-0.4468097687,
0.1831096262,
0.356471628,
-0.0838468149,
-0.1856868118,
0.5728988647,
-0.4921714664,
-0.7088373899,
-0.1141204834,
0.6741220951,
0.263201803,
-0.264210999,
-0.2973844111,
0.3598320782,
0.1654856056,
-0.1143266037,
0.2763895988,
0.6543545723,
0.082568571,
0.7797432542,
0.6699231267,
0.5942137837,
-0.2086250633,
-0.1854408979,
0.5575628877,
-0.985822022,
-0.2177778929,
-1.0555903912,
0.3527794182,
-0.0185514744,
-0.0941413119,
0.9145306349,
0.6429974437,
0.6884949803,
0.054060705,
1.1265830994,
0.1270094067,
0.6191053987,
-0.4645530581,
0.8890043497,
-0.364302814,
0.241301164,
-0.2126478553,
-0.8728667498,
0.0055782809,
0.4627326429,
0.0385206155,
0.0723253414,
0.4381786287,
0.8875318766,
0.354039222,
0.0930006728,
0.1107252613,
0.2462075949,
0.1750130355,
0.5882815719,
0.8543139696,
-0.6000598073,
0.3381972015,
0.0510901064,
-0.1156467795,
-0.0992670059,
-0.8887196779,
-0.4923419356,
-0.49673751,
-0.3724425137,
-0.3494940698,
-0.0646073669,
1.005969882,
0.3271678388,
-1.1117402315,
-0.2487781346,
-0.0709886849,
0.1436166465,
0.0675673783,
-0.1782895774,
0.5071839094,
0.0463810228,
-0.8981871605,
0.2627794147,
0.119343631,
0.2975411713,
-0.0991025567,
-0.1187622696,
-0.1567481905,
0.1803808957,
0.5185912251,
0.0317649171,
-0.3781191111,
-0.1150721908,
-0.1751861572,
-0.3139965236,
-0.1055669114,
0.4219854474,
-1.0457564592,
0.1563615799,
0.1594110727,
0.8975397944,
0.2379909754,
0.0419403017,
0.5727753043,
-0.5467194319,
0.1782240868,
0.2083545178,
0.2918097079,
0.6047855616,
-0.1368292421,
0.6553977728,
0.1531574875,
-0.4707818925,
-0.6274543405,
0.0871596411,
-0.6232296824,
-0.2213941664,
1.296218276,
0.0202770066,
0.1344681233,
-0.421535939,
-0.5488051772,
0.2871622145,
-0.4826090634,
0.9464659691,
1.1065839529,
0.3526053131,
0.2138898969,
-0.457713753,
0.5573321581,
0.5625143051,
-0.6020304561,
0.1556479484,
0.5705717206,
0.0668163523,
-0.0200438071,
0.283192426,
0.0128887659,
-0.137340501,
-0.2392042726,
0.097325474,
0.034261547,
-0.2564550638,
-0.4792311192,
0.4684389234,
0.3772025406,
-0.0864260122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18655v1
|
Revealing the Parametric Knowledge of Language Models: A Unified Framework for Attribution Methods
| 2024-04-29T12:38:26 | 2024-04-29T12:38:26 |
Haeun Yu, Pepa Atanasova, Isabelle Augenstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Language Models (LMs) acquire parametric knowledge from their training
process, embedding it within their weights. The increasing scalability of LMs,
however, poses significant challenges for understanding a model's inner
workings and further for updating or correcting this embedded knowledge without
the significant cost of retraining. This underscores the importance of
unveiling exactly what knowledge is stored and its association with specific
model components. Instance Attribution (IA) and Neuron Attribution (NA) offer
insights into this training-acquired knowledge, though they have not been
compared systematically. Our study introduces a novel evaluation framework to
quantify and compare the knowledge revealed by IA and NA. To align the results
of the methods we introduce the attribution method NA-Instances to apply NA for
retrieving influential training instances, and IA-Neurons to discover important
neurons of influential instances discovered by IA. We further propose a
comprehensive list of faithfulness tests to evaluate the comprehensiveness and
sufficiency of the explanations provided by both methods. Through extensive
experiments and analysis, we demonstrate that NA generally reveals more diverse
and comprehensive information regarding the LM's parametric knowledge compared
to IA. Nevertheless, IA provides unique and valuable insights into the LM's
parametric knowledge, which are not revealed by NA. Our findings further
suggest the potential of a synergistic approach of combining the diverse
findings of IA and NA for a more holistic understanding of an LM's parametric
knowledge.
|
[
-0.0795944482,
-0.4269950688,
0.7000637054,
0.0271304101,
0.0145387063,
-0.0594562218,
-0.3955187798,
-0.144254446,
-0.0055277711,
0.3708564937,
-0.2230833471,
-0.4792264104,
-0.3485698104,
-0.3302576244,
-0.6190147996,
0.8314571977,
0.0106591536,
0.1798855513,
-0.7053102255,
-0.4221985042,
-0.0195444208,
-0.6025640368,
-0.6078569293,
-0.8917157054,
0.6777098775,
0.2255739868,
0.5859606862,
0.5712925792,
0.2477013767,
0.3018454313,
-0.1011169925,
-0.2132955194,
-0.0460815355,
-0.1492877007,
-0.3259730041,
-0.6725761294,
-0.3178203702,
-0.0711744428,
0.7172711492,
0.8136076927,
-0.4529800713,
0.4927803278,
0.3012602627,
0.5226804018,
-0.8940512538,
0.119804427,
-0.7503909469,
-0.1999728531,
-0.134556368,
-0.3018297255,
-0.403328687,
-0.387667805,
0.0286936369,
-0.4839217663,
0.2311784476,
-0.1158949882,
0.9423317909,
0.0891744345,
-0.4660279751,
-0.2754372954,
-0.5318453908,
1.0146608353,
-0.812609911,
0.2244184911,
0.4995251298,
0.3717262149,
0.2063516378,
-0.6107749343,
-0.3511193693,
-0.3144950271,
-0.0745263994,
-0.2622625828,
-0.1680143774,
-0.1089437976,
-0.0497607775,
0.3569898009,
-0.3851307631,
0.0449671373,
-0.2271778286,
-0.310978353,
0.4839458764,
0.1067485958,
0.4482253194,
-0.1240044087,
-0.2964685559,
-0.1775413305,
-0.7745239735,
0.0896949172,
0.5581244826,
0.1067562401,
-0.1471658796,
0.328458339,
-0.0852160752,
0.6550709605,
-0.2378386557,
0.0691854134,
0.2822841704,
-0.3352528512,
0.2300423086,
-0.0987418368,
1.0432304144,
0.230482161,
0.5417003632,
-0.4844391644,
-0.3658972085,
-0.0660519674,
0.3170217872,
-0.308788538,
-0.1206658185,
-0.3452533782,
-0.6427767277,
-0.506370306,
-0.1024012715,
-0.735049963,
-0.2315995246,
-0.2933588028,
0.4618307352,
-0.3874506652,
-0.4461629391,
0.0243527684,
-0.0835824162,
0.3066673577,
0.1305864155,
-1.0243473053,
0.5069039464,
0.6195427179,
0.8358227015,
-0.1855378598,
-0.4997054935,
-0.0514000766,
0.1009768322,
-0.3661818206,
0.8591518402,
-0.4152974188,
0.2306715995,
0.1092154309,
-0.3628370166,
-0.0349677131,
-0.5974071622,
0.332757473,
-0.4991233051,
-0.0964860842,
-0.4998275638,
-0.3914806843,
-0.2432766855,
0.0392712578,
-0.5446989536,
0.8224292397,
0.0902579576,
-0.6602894068,
0.5353610516,
-0.4187555015,
-0.0705945268,
-0.1310628355,
-0.4998160899,
-0.2039113641,
0.3824475706,
0.2545335591,
0.4147410095,
-0.7328227758,
0.4653146565,
-0.3389263451,
0.0845976621,
0.3572135866,
-0.640245676,
1.0483570099,
-0.0155888014,
-0.2647742033,
0.0344018675,
-0.9056711793,
0.1233074889,
0.1395449638,
-0.1923683286,
-0.6268828511,
0.1291065961,
-0.0964060426,
0.1052457988,
0.1744226515,
-0.5255874395,
-0.0968507752,
-0.2659204006,
0.4292982221,
0.6548447013,
0.0051944437,
0.6917956471,
-0.2143988162,
0.5794532895,
-0.1010143384,
0.0720314533,
0.0799378753,
-0.2582553327,
-0.706849575,
0.3302473724,
0.3238357306,
0.1162838265,
-0.5730761886,
0.2733195722,
-0.29507038,
-0.6074012518,
-0.4302485287,
0.2282335907,
0.696792841,
0.5528638959,
0.3207322061,
-0.3628024161,
-0.2154416293,
-1.19335711,
-0.5913977623,
-0.4530057311,
-0.0941166952,
0.19186306,
0.5318777561,
0.3328053653,
0.909014225,
-0.219578132,
0.0651540756,
-0.2567625642,
0.4817025363,
0.0236694664,
0.5531719923,
0.6180065274,
-0.4074369669,
-0.3799894452,
0.1004649177,
-1.0296266079,
-0.1349966973,
-0.1091884449,
0.1980398595,
-0.2523566186,
0.6094067097,
-0.1624799669,
0.3346196413,
0.4795035124,
-0.2134892792,
0.5370238423,
-0.3396759629,
0.0020556259,
-0.8300822973,
-0.0159877501,
0.003822895,
-0.0612997748,
-0.6165215969,
-0.0179990642,
0.3852145672,
0.0901461244,
-0.3026951253,
0.5996922255,
-0.7308622599,
-0.1352259815,
-0.0677208528,
-0.071936287,
-0.0599195771,
0.6298902035,
-0.1001691222,
0.7036700249,
0.7520993948,
-0.5388320088,
0.3150590062,
0.0890305564,
-0.7176306844,
0.1819814444,
-0.8323320746,
0.1536660343,
-0.0039883344,
-0.1517904252,
-0.8375480175,
0.033023864,
0.0396971107,
-0.5980462432,
0.0668917671,
0.000048923,
-0.6074318886,
0.0081759477,
0.0315342955,
0.7130090594,
0.4385182261,
-0.4491540194,
0.7616152167,
0.3039975464,
-0.0740082115,
-0.5979244113,
-0.7442407012,
-0.0371336043,
-0.522074759,
-0.4573630691,
0.345400691,
0.4256014526,
-0.452496171,
0.0369744785,
-0.2000725269,
-0.3685035706,
0.0044597532,
0.0542068705,
-0.1564445794,
-0.5382627845,
0.2330827713,
-0.1209247485,
-0.276994884,
0.5606514812,
0.0802455842,
0.4937649667,
-0.4080552161,
-0.7890204787,
-0.4898184538,
0.1986973584,
0.4962781668,
-0.3197224736,
0.8870675564,
0.4401599467,
-0.4072658718,
-0.1971892565,
-0.6590325832,
-0.4140013158,
-0.4240413606,
0.3857279718,
-0.2731289566,
-0.2915664613,
0.9669662118,
0.0706747025,
-0.2644177675,
0.4870140553,
0.5180499554,
0.3270570338,
0.9679586887,
0.7760050297,
-0.2571408451,
0.4745795131,
-0.1948212534,
0.0798481181,
-0.8776453733,
-0.4135985076,
-0.671615839,
-0.2396570891,
-0.0208984092,
-0.0701717436,
0.1056631729,
0.2010840774,
-0.1564814001,
0.4824136198,
-0.143782109,
0.6156045794,
0.5160170794,
0.235530138,
0.3555010557,
0.0589183122,
-0.1337977648,
-0.0380395949,
-0.8888988495,
-0.594799161,
1.56764853,
0.4296430051,
0.818556726,
0.1762898862,
0.5590187311,
-0.0207349695,
0.2565373182,
-0.6353511214,
0.4974784851,
0.178139329,
-0.7221922278,
-0.2826351821,
-0.3963545561,
-0.644572258,
0.1018897817,
0.0440764725,
-1.1041498184,
0.4481294751,
0.1292334348,
-0.4876372516,
0.333910346,
-0.6488180757,
0.9021782279,
-0.3402956128,
-0.3673397005,
-0.2831118703,
-0.5369511843,
0.2534409165,
-0.1666728705,
0.0542351231,
-0.0150446342,
-0.2568244338,
1.0599189997,
-0.2678203285,
0.7905892134,
-0.0657029003,
-0.2529634237,
0.2491110861,
-0.0722942427,
0.2784287632,
0.1842583269,
-0.2687862515,
0.22808972,
-0.1286637783,
-0.3003246188,
-1.0881245136,
0.6193348169,
-0.6688665152,
-0.4088996351,
-0.3651552796,
-0.7585136294,
-0.3005820811,
0.004336969,
0.3619452119,
0.7197854519,
-0.1063026935,
0.5354533195,
0.5856173635,
-0.1733164191,
0.2656744719,
0.5245727301,
-0.2683321834,
-0.0990029126,
0.9383531809,
-0.0661881417,
0.5408904552,
0.2175956964,
0.2895976901,
-0.2902424335,
-0.7223818898,
-0.2169270962,
0.3053893745,
-0.9293963313,
-0.0879996493,
-0.4199913144,
-0.0440656096,
-0.2219966948,
-0.1205835044,
-0.6534283757,
-0.2055240721,
-0.1603077054,
0.1471149325,
0.2500689626,
0.7182629704,
-0.1745401919,
0.5628201962,
-0.5205973983,
0.0577305667,
0.2257338911,
0.2132054865,
0.3825996816,
-0.6412243247,
-0.3320142329,
0.1799553633,
-0.3061966002,
-1.2044013739,
0.3419204056,
0.3733679354,
0.974345386,
0.6387239099,
-0.2476688027,
0.6224249005,
-0.3081999421,
0.675892055,
0.2596850991,
-0.9491615891,
0.3643606603,
-0.3952417374,
-0.0091033326,
0.7742062807,
0.4656240344,
-0.2620876431,
-0.2417506129,
-0.9057181478,
-0.8995079994,
0.8843897581,
0.2046412379,
0.2116887271,
0.1770541966,
0.5266737938,
-0.0329228528,
0.1911965758,
-0.8997334242,
-0.4445085227,
0.1337128878,
-0.1759894043,
-0.3212319613,
-0.1813716888,
-0.231452778,
-0.6134002209,
0.4892539978,
-0.0452857465,
0.3452865481,
-0.2149398327,
-0.3377904892,
0.0589415208,
0.1032216474,
0.3236985207,
1.074570179,
-0.1410882622,
0.2417568713,
0.3232703507,
-0.0055337064,
0.2316237837,
-0.3472031057,
0.0217320714,
0.2003401816,
0.703078866,
0.784319222,
0.3717734218,
-0.4404993057,
0.8054463863,
0.125823766,
-0.3097864985,
-0.2773593068,
-0.0745660439,
0.3032951355,
0.1885508299,
0.2182158977,
0.0549477786,
0.2487765551,
-0.7110806108,
0.3321079612,
0.4336535931,
-0.5539747477,
-0.4498269856,
0.3861830235,
-0.1675329953,
-0.243485257,
0.4868782461,
0.0442605875,
-0.5041828156,
0.7616820931,
0.6291771531,
0.8798758388,
-0.3315317631,
0.4072652161,
0.2789264023,
0.1280623674,
-0.2260655016,
-0.0928398445,
-0.2278586477,
-0.9206523895,
-0.2283628434,
-0.6230407357,
-0.0780455917,
0.3836565614,
-1.2501927614,
-0.0095849643,
-0.2119738758,
-0.0357160904,
0.1521626711,
-0.4509027302,
-0.4324231744,
-0.0887122974,
-0.1110727862,
0.6463435292,
-1.2108595371,
0.8106949329,
0.7787790298,
-0.6631602049,
-0.9173225164,
0.1842951328,
0.0579139665,
-1.1179703474,
0.8870307207,
-0.1466862559,
-0.0183763094,
0.0046233181,
-0.3396061063,
-0.9412794709,
0.965644002,
0.5769552588,
-0.243118763,
-0.2117324173,
0.1245647594,
0.5357190967,
-0.5152997971,
0.4915503263,
0.5331697464,
0.186917901,
-0.1977350861,
-0.7858731747,
0.0511738323,
-0.2999713719,
0.1742612273,
0.24670434,
-0.1778547168,
0.8977742195,
-0.0240123533,
-0.0653446764,
-0.1003485024,
0.8250015974,
0.0935850739,
0.0782016143,
0.4828235209,
0.3422917128,
0.3965503573,
0.0802265108,
0.8949144483,
-0.3201233447,
0.423609674,
1.122223258,
0.2220998406,
0.8254953027,
0.9237148166,
-0.2886405587,
0.6276111603,
0.4366162717,
0.1419264227,
0.6849591732,
0.4377793968,
-0.2905336916,
-0.3787811697,
-0.0156628396,
-0.2864908576,
0.3508951664,
0.2921561897,
-0.6231650114,
-0.6346917152,
0.1293151975,
-0.0855494142,
0.2696579397,
-0.2439436316,
0.8507071733,
0.2685916722,
-0.5896034837,
0.7858700752,
-0.1469099373,
0.4820738137,
-0.7118861675,
0.0914464667,
-0.0646647513,
0.3676383793,
-0.1044042036,
-0.6937233806,
0.5482480526,
-0.0528855324,
-0.183290273,
-0.3190283477,
0.6729575396,
-0.4048788846,
-0.3236135542,
0.4701794088,
0.5829949975,
0.2535003126,
-0.4257829487,
-0.839009285,
-0.1985672116,
0.1236902326,
-0.3994152844,
0.3905538023,
0.4956018925,
-0.1164191514,
0.9325587749,
0.3265655935,
0.3070453107,
0.0866852775,
0.1170997992,
0.8547125459,
-0.3418875039,
-0.0646060929,
-0.9619202018,
0.5576965809,
-0.0806835517,
-0.5292103291,
0.7682623863,
0.3692037165,
0.6420475841,
0.0096412189,
0.7022585869,
0.0255644303,
0.1681203991,
-0.5474170446,
0.8857375383,
-0.9137076139,
0.3881473243,
-0.1639910787,
-0.9373981357,
-0.0995019004,
0.7587481737,
-0.6336718798,
0.0273976512,
0.9488355517,
0.8425913453,
-0.2711240053,
-0.1021980643,
0.2460521311,
-0.1356737167,
-0.0149407694,
0.5150592923,
0.8331497312,
-0.5466042161,
0.5576669574,
-0.413713485,
-0.3329412937,
0.1311030388,
-0.7972529531,
-0.8308473229,
-0.8840687275,
-0.2667296827,
-0.0358000435,
0.2229331583,
0.5480898619,
0.4776995778,
-0.8396443129,
-0.5220101476,
-0.5194514394,
-0.1434767842,
-0.3038062155,
-0.1877504885,
0.4578857422,
-0.5767864585,
-0.3286916018,
0.3017463684,
-0.0460896976,
-0.2012623847,
-0.41844064,
-0.1859739721,
-0.2951404452,
-0.1430259496,
0.1540375948,
0.2472020239,
-0.8157203197,
-0.1016265079,
-0.1732803136,
0.0106769046,
-0.0052582221,
0.9941892028,
-0.5301655531,
0.1641516834,
0.6377180815,
0.6081738472,
0.1860382557,
-0.1272291988,
1.1098706722,
-0.6465875506,
0.1382961273,
0.241136387,
0.4859259725,
0.2038808465,
-0.1303993315,
0.1941047758,
-0.0221629795,
-0.6534098387,
-0.842228651,
0.3529806733,
-0.6497077346,
-0.2200045586,
1.30303967,
-0.4283746779,
-0.2780231535,
-0.2174810916,
0.3192996681,
0.3606778383,
-0.3389421999,
0.5776211023,
0.8997302055,
0.1171305999,
-0.1907672435,
-0.7047771811,
0.6916832924,
0.8710505962,
-0.5345239043,
0.2316519916,
0.0810158849,
0.377803266,
0.3051650524,
0.3788749278,
-0.2660420537,
0.0189153645,
0.192342639,
0.28712973,
-0.0257545263,
-0.4738299549,
-0.5253253579,
0.0799892023,
0.186378628,
-0.0637147501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02563v1
|
A cost minimization approach to fix the vocabulary size in a tokenizer for an End-to-End ASR system
| 2024-04-29T12:16:21 | 2024-04-29T12:16:21 |
Sunil Kumar Kopparapu, Ashish Panda
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Unlike hybrid speech recognition systems where the use of tokens was
restricted to phones, biphones or triphones the choice of tokens in the
end-to-end ASR systems is derived from the text corpus of the training data.
The use of tokenization algorithms like Byte Pair Encoding (BPE) and WordPiece
is popular in identifying the tokens that are used in the overall training
process of the speech recognition system. Popular toolkits, like ESPNet use a
pre-defined vocabulary size (number of tokens) for these tokenization
algorithms, but there is no discussion on how vocabulary size was derived. In
this paper, we build a cost function, assuming the tokenization process to be a
black-box to enable choosing the number of tokens which might most benefit
building an end-to-end ASR. We show through experiments on LibriSpeech 100 hour
set that the performance of an end-to-end ASR system improves when the number
of tokens are chosen carefully.
|
[
-0.5939708352,
-0.1014939472,
-0.2683747411,
0.0020317899,
-0.6754126549,
0.2758194506,
-0.2677696347,
-0.6309712529,
0.5027287006,
0.1413230151,
-0.1607336998,
0.2505246997,
-0.5195493102,
0.1282637566,
-0.267698437,
0.9809101224,
-0.0568249002,
0.1341171712,
0.0230665337,
-0.2250713557,
-0.3477269113,
-0.6737549901,
-1.1084741354,
-0.2424822599,
0.3352989852,
0.4504740238,
0.4544385374,
0.8585329652,
0.5136611462,
0.2589738965,
-0.4350809157,
0.1793963611,
-0.2005760223,
-0.3901364505,
-0.168737635,
-0.3176955879,
-0.172504276,
-0.1591609567,
0.4009310603,
0.7793041468,
0.0485063978,
0.5558282137,
-0.1275781095,
0.454310447,
-0.588994503,
-0.3508516252,
-0.6055812836,
0.0234976262,
-0.2594562769,
-0.3841914833,
-0.3326419294,
0.2727417946,
0.1069203168,
-0.4561976194,
0.0681690276,
0.4086369574,
0.790260911,
0.3722365797,
-0.2271357328,
-0.3898815215,
-0.8257396221,
0.6852032542,
-0.46396029,
0.5377608538,
0.2161533833,
0.0843039602,
-0.0419948176,
-0.4682383537,
-0.6599516869,
0.096912317,
-0.0718672276,
0.0907720849,
-0.1982301027,
0.3559637964,
0.3091346323,
0.352447629,
-0.5473369956,
0.2096412033,
-0.8676707149,
-0.4775899351,
0.4300207496,
-0.2583325803,
0.25846982,
-0.0241126958,
-0.506426692,
0.0866454616,
-0.4876919389,
0.201473847,
0.2666373253,
0.2518742085,
0.1258745939,
0.804014802,
-0.0980557352,
0.6277642846,
0.1927363873,
-0.2617772818,
0.1744728088,
-0.4578205943,
-0.3715879023,
0.5709040165,
0.463005811,
0.2204899043,
0.3579982817,
-0.5113228559,
-0.4625018239,
0.403940022,
0.159989208,
-0.7008513212,
0.4738874435,
0.484266609,
-0.4700563252,
-0.0711200908,
-0.1213764325,
-0.3047317266,
0.0587056279,
-0.3399008811,
0.8372412324,
-0.4173767269,
0.0024602935,
0.3031951189,
-0.5432701707,
0.4579126537,
-0.0973768458,
-0.6963105202,
0.7444850206,
0.4406142533,
1.3466079235,
-0.156321913,
0.0637152717,
-0.7742940784,
0.2611947358,
-0.577057302,
0.7433100939,
-0.1186318099,
-0.8427366614,
-0.1769871265,
-0.3465221226,
0.1202725098,
-0.5968423486,
0.3188070655,
-0.4914059043,
0.1180292144,
-0.1770562232,
-0.7952943444,
0.2184872925,
-0.296700567,
-0.4495902061,
0.868108809,
-0.2149741352,
-0.761225462,
0.6647453308,
-0.9514759779,
-0.5756874084,
0.3527542949,
0.0665304437,
-0.3061547875,
0.2984820008,
-0.0054759835,
0.0337306783,
-0.1112585589,
-0.0148364604,
0.3949790597,
-0.7294674516,
0.1803097725,
-0.2774886489,
0.7000342011,
0.3987713158,
-0.3626097739,
0.2098007947,
-0.9134753942,
-0.2129805088,
-0.1933905482,
-0.7648237944,
-0.2764083743,
0.058294557,
0.1874847412,
0.0247709192,
0.4427421391,
-1.1306240559,
-0.407602787,
-0.8711764216,
0.3419058621,
0.6731301546,
-0.1121495143,
0.4554125071,
-0.4188996851,
0.2389226258,
0.0354795754,
0.1482520401,
0.0416328721,
-0.2854627371,
-1.1523822546,
-0.4308729768,
0.6909125447,
0.5227395296,
-0.586974442,
0.5958332419,
-0.4165741205,
-0.1341119558,
-0.4702622592,
-0.0539242737,
0.4635100067,
0.1916089952,
0.2698585689,
-0.5255063176,
-0.6987525821,
-0.8148447275,
-0.0700466856,
-0.1037116647,
-0.1406853646,
0.1573307514,
0.3773219585,
0.3165028393,
1.1958639622,
-0.0851251185,
-0.4987326562,
-0.174711585,
-0.1959236115,
0.1711342931,
0.5041433573,
0.3961775601,
-0.524985373,
-0.497153908,
0.256207794,
-0.0731606632,
-0.1071104631,
-0.1658105552,
-0.0269561931,
0.3106273413,
0.6814716458,
-0.4254977405,
0.5937498808,
0.3437482417,
-0.4629365206,
0.4269448817,
-0.4873590469,
-0.4411998987,
-0.9853749275,
0.3522338867,
-0.1427532583,
-0.2068811208,
-0.6993241906,
-0.1488773227,
-0.2167712301,
-0.1825471818,
-0.2817161977,
0.7201234102,
-0.565376997,
-0.4581364393,
-0.3505889475,
0.0523496717,
-0.219006747,
0.5992190242,
0.0162496362,
1.115131259,
0.2613119483,
-0.5781979561,
0.2402153462,
0.2176870853,
0.0190814678,
0.4579298198,
-0.828181982,
0.1300971955,
-0.2915961146,
0.1227425486,
-0.923093617,
0.1632903218,
0.0168344714,
-0.7374978662,
0.3433683217,
-0.2521924078,
-0.466073066,
-0.2590613663,
-0.3370189071,
0.2582548857,
0.4904466569,
-0.6040921807,
0.5690587759,
0.5682787299,
0.023041008,
-0.5680807233,
-0.4870156348,
0.1419359148,
-0.2198664099,
-0.3395243585,
0.4798027277,
-0.2578436136,
0.0397764742,
-0.1249328181,
-0.4408606589,
0.1415278763,
-0.2111705989,
0.1328385025,
0.2206701487,
-0.1063301042,
0.4262648225,
0.0654598773,
-0.389015168,
-0.1683419347,
-0.7315930724,
0.7371369004,
0.096352376,
-0.2731892467,
-0.2330378443,
0.3386513889,
0.4518547952,
-0.634308517,
0.6532412767,
0.4341972172,
-0.6319773197,
-0.1569868475,
-0.6870315671,
-0.0153081166,
-0.5394086242,
0.3621804416,
-0.4318951666,
-0.7191934586,
0.6108137965,
0.0405283757,
0.2297203094,
0.1138079613,
0.4127790034,
0.1956348568,
0.3470605612,
0.3015231788,
-0.197708562,
0.5371199846,
-0.1254786253,
0.2504067123,
-0.9027962089,
-0.2965948284,
-0.4552742541,
-0.5841175914,
-0.3278572857,
-0.5380284786,
0.4822415113,
-0.0609085187,
-0.2530180514,
0.3672440946,
-0.725828588,
0.52622509,
0.9754287004,
0.064148128,
0.1685046256,
0.2463870496,
-0.1716958582,
0.3968110681,
-0.6306087971,
-0.1564425975,
1.1385110617,
0.1818971485,
0.1436695009,
0.3204479218,
0.8659632206,
0.220587343,
-0.2084647864,
-1.0056277514,
0.5640419126,
-0.3853183389,
-0.4922128022,
-0.792312026,
-0.2612838447,
-1.0117890835,
0.1977415085,
-0.0744864643,
-0.8627934456,
0.4303570986,
0.1628296524,
-0.4459858537,
0.3872314394,
-0.5564584136,
0.4169187844,
-0.0909638479,
0.0046062325,
-0.2049644738,
-0.512135148,
-0.4323366284,
-0.1808891594,
0.1723914593,
0.2699959874,
-0.3385077119,
1.199545145,
-0.8259904981,
0.6432199478,
-0.2995940149,
0.4376271665,
0.410713315,
-0.0359788053,
0.3985929787,
-0.303254813,
0.1352882385,
0.1403293163,
0.1746799499,
-0.4282820523,
-0.2208290696,
0.3091236055,
-0.8408973217,
-0.4105517566,
-0.2339972407,
-0.2426642179,
-0.324542582,
0.1492532939,
0.5166640878,
0.8918094039,
0.1353432089,
0.2550621629,
0.5597279072,
-0.3201352358,
0.7406033874,
0.282941103,
0.1068489477,
-0.5057444572,
1.0961087942,
0.5421782136,
0.2281074375,
0.3679306805,
0.3664131761,
-0.3013968468,
-0.7793154716,
-0.628047049,
0.2868571281,
-0.4971880615,
-0.3950096369,
-0.4108864367,
-0.4057139754,
-0.0484055765,
-0.439121753,
-0.3757658303,
-0.5254996419,
-0.3128764629,
-0.355748266,
0.6022934914,
0.1592022777,
-0.3930742741,
0.6649469733,
-0.3588449657,
-0.09418571,
0.1047689319,
0.5329563022,
0.0701697171,
-0.8874760866,
-0.4401500225,
-0.1984440833,
0.2009173781,
-0.5879814029,
0.2523705363,
0.4549218714,
0.3045713902,
0.2752971649,
-0.0492636673,
0.7392876744,
-0.6300661564,
0.5723385811,
0.5445981622,
-1.1934868097,
0.3343095183,
-0.0042721648,
0.0084337266,
0.2586073279,
0.0004153293,
-0.8483790159,
0.103103146,
-0.4796261191,
-1.013112545,
0.5660729408,
0.058363419,
0.2114691138,
0.0422095172,
0.4585233331,
-0.1578534544,
0.1635770351,
-0.3005367815,
-0.2571567595,
-0.1830310673,
-0.3508459926,
0.0047954693,
-0.4021333754,
0.1396992207,
-0.1736415774,
0.674513936,
-0.2092856318,
0.4136741459,
0.140032202,
-0.0548400469,
-0.219702825,
0.2229627371,
0.4392406046,
0.2703637779,
-0.1206895784,
-0.1210557371,
0.4417968988,
-0.410382241,
0.1448276788,
-0.0726421177,
-0.0990551487,
0.1538278461,
0.0829906389,
0.9479912519,
0.1258040816,
-0.8625036478,
0.7484802604,
0.4843613207,
-0.2636750042,
-0.5398538113,
-0.2595762014,
-0.0401049033,
0.0637987107,
0.2572437227,
0.0773041993,
0.4028471708,
-0.17675291,
0.3807883263,
0.6639733315,
-0.4494099617,
-0.0825172439,
0.5626802444,
0.223369807,
-0.564645946,
0.2682100534,
-0.216756314,
-0.4009485841,
0.429587692,
0.6010594368,
0.6050850153,
-0.1520998925,
0.188737765,
0.2333810776,
0.3414205909,
0.1135955974,
0.2855590582,
-0.0315816216,
-0.8959494829,
-0.562543869,
-0.9160379767,
-0.2455497831,
-0.0814032182,
-0.6456580162,
0.4906738997,
-0.7486613989,
-0.2804188132,
0.1387588233,
0.0360707231,
-0.4677142501,
0.3768016398,
0.1505368352,
1.0357706547,
-0.3822159767,
0.4843861759,
0.6062520146,
-0.415179342,
-0.8767181635,
-0.5154290199,
-0.133356899,
-0.7837304473,
0.6138734818,
-0.2204901129,
-0.1839873046,
0.1059261337,
-0.101353541,
-1.113137722,
0.8865292668,
-0.0861211568,
-0.4981563091,
-0.2367413193,
0.1782444268,
0.4991400838,
-0.0967750847,
0.0176948067,
0.3787542284,
0.0828225464,
0.4901034236,
-1.3239769936,
-0.1630005836,
-0.1985880584,
0.2572636306,
0.3642202616,
-0.6429110765,
0.5071675777,
-0.1749963164,
-0.2467609197,
-0.149773404,
0.4038297832,
0.0302966665,
0.0083100377,
0.6062996387,
0.2916053832,
0.467487216,
0.2581644952,
0.6140019894,
-0.4305181503,
0.1206553727,
0.8263762593,
-0.0521481186,
1.0247081518,
0.7772945762,
-0.2956930697,
0.0186449718,
0.5933638215,
-0.052651789,
0.4876444936,
0.6744309664,
-0.2918044329,
0.1275207847,
-0.1277879924,
0.0081056748,
0.5832853317,
0.3771461248,
-0.0690652728,
-0.0070214416,
0.0895008072,
-0.0060155811,
-0.3364736438,
-0.4159286618,
1.0772000551,
0.0230785366,
-0.1265564263,
0.5327416062,
0.1127446368,
0.9580713511,
-0.6034479141,
0.5146784186,
-0.2346047312,
-0.0008538936,
-0.1770079732,
-0.0572379641,
0.4477079213,
0.0073872167,
-0.0072504575,
0.1822794378,
0.5649300218,
-0.3418895304,
-0.5806016326,
0.1299132854,
0.5124233961,
0.2171537876,
0.0788872018,
-0.1523285061,
0.0199645348,
0.0391045585,
0.0016886543,
0.4065093398,
0.3042767048,
0.0157297552,
0.6455022097,
0.897642076,
0.6618022919,
0.2639042139,
-0.035508167,
0.7224905491,
-0.4094980359,
-0.8093765974,
-0.6058188677,
0.5027779937,
-0.1582333446,
-0.3463874757,
0.1295827776,
0.8196828365,
0.8827483654,
0.1196010634,
0.822707653,
-0.0202170778,
0.6415372491,
-0.2802813947,
0.4201750457,
-0.6483432055,
0.2735775411,
-0.0213167556,
-0.6475178003,
-0.3196995854,
0.7732038498,
-0.0348995551,
-0.3149193823,
0.4847216904,
0.8052979708,
0.1170049906,
0.0925950333,
0.5655022264,
-0.2311118394,
0.2196332365,
0.0807134211,
0.2462311834,
-0.3101106584,
0.826461494,
-0.0534430407,
-0.5844433904,
-0.1166915596,
-0.3309520781,
-0.783012569,
-0.5887153745,
-0.3528319597,
-0.2351354808,
0.2001909316,
1.3516894579,
0.4854031205,
-0.8923486471,
-0.495349735,
0.0995523706,
-0.5207080245,
-0.2021562308,
-0.1463221014,
0.5784538984,
-0.3764354289,
-0.5596882701,
0.1068656296,
0.5347063541,
0.1047986895,
0.007072181,
-0.0957647711,
0.170713678,
0.5335109234,
0.6312246323,
0.2542508245,
-0.6751872897,
-0.6919234395,
0.0917263925,
0.4008690417,
0.2267272472,
0.7913174033,
-0.6243886948,
0.4643379748,
0.061743021,
0.9090543389,
0.5675611496,
-0.2792650163,
0.4855512381,
-1.0134032965,
0.2801560462,
-0.0210447107,
0.546066761,
0.2414989024,
-0.2975004911,
0.4491919577,
0.3130851686,
-0.3188420832,
-0.8378861547,
0.085768193,
-1.0033519268,
-0.2021220475,
1.078410387,
0.1685504615,
-0.0223292466,
-0.3729620576,
-0.4637549818,
0.2975436747,
-0.4325627685,
0.4676125646,
0.5143114924,
-0.2024169564,
0.0064760572,
0.0326920636,
0.4731021523,
0.1515370905,
-0.3726567626,
-0.1487264633,
0.2775141299,
0.338375181,
0.42422387,
0.6690654159,
0.0372117534,
0.0807944685,
0.2812376022,
0.1265064776,
-0.0737405866,
0.0489670485,
0.0363776833,
-0.0928943455,
0.0614504851,
-0.7923438549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18638v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18638v1
|
Reinforcement Learning Problem Solving with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T12:16:08 | 2024-04-29T12:16:08 |
Sina Gholamian, Domingo Huh
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) encapsulate an extensive amount of world
knowledge, and this has enabled their application in various domains to improve
the performance of a variety of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. This
has also facilitated a more accessible paradigm of conversation-based
interactions between humans and AI systems to solve intended problems. However,
one interesting avenue that shows untapped potential is the use of LLMs as
Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents to enable conversational RL problem solving.
Therefore, in this study, we explore the concept of formulating Markov Decision
Process-based RL problems as LLM prompting tasks. We demonstrate how LLMs can
be iteratively prompted to learn and optimize policies for specific RL tasks.
In addition, we leverage the introduced prompting technique for episode
simulation and Q-Learning, facilitated by LLMs. We then show the practicality
of our approach through two detailed case studies for "Research Scientist" and
"Legal Matter Intake" workflows.
|
[
-0.2272515893,
-1.0585862398,
0.9293986559,
0.1880614012,
0.0323848166,
0.2006030083,
-0.4767027795,
-0.0971954018,
0.0160622802,
0.6023522615,
-1.0217289925,
-0.3174910545,
-0.3526492119,
0.1406380832,
0.1006803811,
0.887252748,
-0.0627943873,
0.2170648575,
-0.1165276319,
0.2634164989,
-0.6805398464,
-0.2663268447,
-1.269721508,
-0.7268133759,
1.018029213,
0.5444769859,
0.48173666,
0.3723940849,
0.0891800448,
0.3393902183,
-0.1327286512,
0.384367764,
-0.3572585583,
0.6414361,
-0.3560757041,
-0.5136643052,
0.1419127285,
-0.0901845247,
0.6721607447,
0.5938768387,
-0.531260848,
-0.1139256135,
-0.1841801107,
0.698366642,
-0.3056306243,
0.4870504737,
-0.5599666834,
0.3408323824,
0.4085259736,
-0.5301762223,
-0.5843462348,
-0.1358305216,
0.2157548666,
-0.7127109766,
-0.2565094233,
0.4017278552,
0.4971942902,
0.3464868963,
-0.1649643481,
-0.4073858261,
-0.8380061388,
0.8892503381,
-0.6942461133,
0.1070959195,
0.3673469722,
0.2421295941,
-0.7104219794,
-0.4151327312,
-0.6995392442,
-0.6094478965,
0.1871437281,
-0.1515883654,
-0.1410578042,
0.1110085696,
0.4582212865,
-0.1577243656,
-0.3988943398,
0.5771815777,
-0.3881024122,
-0.0419611186,
0.5571880341,
0.5372541547,
0.0620659776,
-0.0663962588,
-0.2078138888,
-0.2243123949,
-0.7364605665,
0.1656477153,
0.1162925437,
0.4517658353,
0.0859838426,
0.4895918071,
-0.1416282654,
0.5393207073,
-0.0789113119,
-0.1336579025,
-0.0801195726,
0.1657426059,
-0.2218273729,
-0.0958328247,
0.7030699253,
-0.0007317942,
0.5197305083,
0.1473568529,
-0.2993752658,
-0.2958472371,
0.3340109289,
-0.4996066093,
-0.1043171287,
0.3837669194,
-0.1457742006,
-0.1579897702,
-0.4921444058,
-0.4609000683,
-0.5148797035,
-0.5065678954,
0.7138950825,
-0.3438609242,
-0.2224435508,
0.1029290855,
-0.0866894573,
0.2306082845,
0.4549804032,
-0.7964240909,
-0.0072941249,
0.6341410279,
0.5506801009,
-0.2713101506,
-0.2895838618,
-0.821511507,
0.0517774522,
-0.562687993,
0.6316142082,
-0.5734100938,
-0.6431151628,
0.3018927276,
-0.073997587,
-0.135022223,
-0.8528603315,
0.1711384058,
-0.6913489103,
0.0173761193,
-0.2171335965,
-0.5092154741,
-0.1325178146,
0.5913206339,
-0.5882614255,
0.8295984864,
-0.1860833466,
-0.3118686378,
0.1895948946,
-0.8683068752,
-0.2719993293,
0.201651901,
-0.2970415354,
-0.3257118464,
-0.2493597269,
0.3063605726,
0.7822463512,
-0.0949867591,
0.4195441008,
-0.0233384948,
-0.0432448275,
0.5599249601,
-0.3248583674,
0.4172872007,
0.3026727736,
0.0098178266,
0.6031782031,
-0.3789865077,
0.092481859,
0.4111624062,
-0.7244924307,
0.0384448282,
0.2412681729,
-0.4067201018,
0.230902493,
-0.0160324927,
-0.1782190949,
0.3898922205,
-0.2383302599,
0.5922179818,
0.7815361023,
0.4994404614,
0.1962076128,
-0.583424747,
0.7393865585,
0.1433543563,
-0.0729162768,
-0.195033282,
-0.420915395,
-0.8571727872,
-0.2183559686,
-0.0842175782,
0.5602730513,
-1.1809886694,
0.0010974108,
0.1608037055,
-0.1637316644,
-0.3365288973,
0.0411660671,
0.2912264466,
0.2915183008,
0.2209794223,
0.0758377239,
-0.4437070191,
-0.644385457,
-0.1798281521,
-0.2918228507,
0.1715969294,
0.4610165656,
0.5985770226,
-0.1576285958,
0.754260838,
-0.2560421526,
-0.1346181184,
-0.6272758842,
0.3596551716,
0.2935155332,
0.379368633,
-0.2950145602,
-0.5663657784,
-0.3022890389,
-0.1459054053,
-0.5067458153,
0.0567543879,
-0.2002919465,
0.1826502085,
0.4502775669,
0.7821598649,
-0.6154159904,
0.0784811601,
0.3572103679,
-0.0559163913,
0.7931039333,
-0.6676210165,
0.0195697136,
-0.73148036,
-0.107659325,
0.1757777035,
-0.4330941737,
-0.6966654658,
-0.0279115457,
-0.2679173946,
-0.3057090342,
-0.7385802269,
0.5456596017,
-0.3905117512,
-0.193791762,
-0.3534352183,
0.1770356297,
-0.3258153796,
0.8212679625,
0.4282201827,
0.8879784942,
0.4455809891,
-1.0158034563,
0.4748041332,
0.0631681308,
-0.2836097181,
0.3716273904,
-0.4748437703,
-0.0214957818,
-0.2867229581,
0.3144695163,
-0.6021584868,
-0.0279097054,
0.3999723196,
-0.1989200711,
0.1857929379,
-0.0596219338,
-0.5060742497,
-0.2788523436,
-0.014506869,
0.0760404617,
0.5947465301,
-0.4430372417,
0.3434167206,
0.2313268483,
-0.3300549984,
-0.4802182913,
-0.1437570155,
0.1097043604,
-0.3009300828,
-0.1991865486,
0.1030825749,
-0.1768232286,
-0.3784628212,
-0.1164138019,
0.2768847346,
0.0541084744,
0.0631110147,
0.2341028452,
0.3247919083,
0.0242495425,
0.311763227,
-0.3026045561,
-0.1795895994,
0.3473285735,
-0.350225836,
0.5796127915,
-0.0097294683,
-0.4152597189,
-0.5012498498,
0.3695477843,
0.3240777254,
-0.1272875667,
0.6480254531,
0.3007006049,
-0.1286172718,
-0.6345636249,
-0.4386222661,
-0.4085600376,
-0.4742193222,
0.4639365971,
-0.2688279152,
-1.0869497061,
0.2853904068,
-0.3523632288,
0.1921877116,
0.0352217332,
0.9310878515,
-0.2493002564,
1.1292321682,
0.3710956573,
-0.0926850811,
0.6844040155,
-0.2967271507,
0.2589740455,
-0.6743274927,
-0.52344203,
-0.4482989013,
-0.1268383265,
-0.3604008555,
-0.7530793548,
0.553391993,
-0.1944402456,
-0.3368587494,
-0.0356204398,
-0.1347400397,
0.6479184031,
0.6618694067,
0.0988350287,
0.374029249,
-0.0213693921,
-0.3101759553,
0.0028055746,
-0.9888513684,
-0.367477715,
0.7594290972,
0.4865369201,
0.7646582127,
-0.0730041787,
0.7239967585,
0.4852339625,
0.0265669487,
-1.0909289122,
0.7798076272,
0.4820764363,
-0.2791828215,
-0.6431218982,
-0.4105274975,
-1.2983529568,
0.2869235873,
-0.4420104623,
-0.8131881952,
-0.1746810228,
0.1311064959,
-0.3091474771,
0.2219281644,
-0.2744278014,
0.7073696256,
-0.0915961191,
-0.2764767706,
-0.8055967689,
-0.3316363692,
0.127436623,
0.2857438326,
0.3341492116,
-0.2074091285,
0.087872155,
0.7282319665,
-0.2365785837,
0.8609057665,
-0.3152270615,
-0.3367027044,
0.3343842924,
0.2467281967,
0.8642152548,
0.0219050348,
0.1361526102,
-0.4855652153,
0.0357631408,
-0.1608896405,
-0.7321156859,
0.4242489934,
-0.6476512551,
-0.9445021749,
-0.4079470336,
-0.841660738,
-0.3827804923,
-0.1673205495,
-0.387855351,
0.1377112269,
-0.1095921546,
-0.1912463158,
1.0395461321,
-0.4374293983,
0.4693705142,
0.9824126363,
-0.49584499,
-0.0193287153,
1.0202019215,
-0.1907471418,
0.3551374972,
0.2613492906,
0.3349842429,
-0.3235937059,
-0.5923669338,
-0.2943490148,
0.392037034,
-0.7504733801,
0.0030257436,
-0.5012426972,
-0.2714366019,
0.0008442879,
-0.0561227016,
-0.0176842175,
0.013981469,
-0.2977659702,
0.0383194983,
0.4341572523,
0.7471228838,
-0.1437563896,
0.0750370845,
-0.7325680852,
0.1694198549,
0.5332776904,
-0.0828596577,
0.1945033967,
-0.5711632967,
-0.2314262092,
-0.119217582,
-0.2443613559,
-0.7484372258,
0.6867222786,
-0.0069282269,
0.6946570277,
0.2525943816,
0.069897525,
0.3671688437,
-0.6386170983,
0.603503108,
0.0016133841,
-0.6179968119,
0.6222436428,
-0.5181230903,
0.1178044528,
0.2060863823,
0.5962699056,
-0.880834043,
-0.4893856049,
-0.4808978736,
-0.7244545221,
0.7234406471,
-0.0970694795,
0.005219968,
-0.1549714804,
0.3497140706,
-0.0827567875,
0.2599794269,
-0.6235523224,
0.039161697,
0.5076258183,
0.0648221001,
-0.0618122183,
-0.12559475,
-0.1817292571,
-0.0828446671,
1.0823614597,
-0.1860728115,
0.1989129931,
0.2487888038,
-0.1829715818,
-0.0601672158,
0.6119667292,
0.5911802053,
0.4210059643,
0.1443614513,
-0.1900384575,
0.3209914863,
0.198758319,
0.2947402298,
-0.3591039181,
0.163532272,
-0.3870032132,
-0.0770569667,
0.9177529812,
0.1734894216,
-1.2747117281,
0.1464059055,
0.0548893772,
-0.348043412,
-0.4714963734,
0.3407687843,
0.2963635921,
0.8962007761,
0.3742413223,
-0.5926681757,
-0.1299383044,
-0.772975564,
0.0345842689,
0.6071400046,
-0.358800143,
0.3289776146,
0.1439783722,
0.1676626652,
-0.7975338697,
0.8029414415,
-0.2851538956,
-0.7027097344,
0.6730161905,
0.7224894762,
0.4236272871,
0.1174883991,
0.5259244442,
0.1808965355,
-0.0041746674,
-0.3079068959,
0.2950184047,
-0.1307417601,
-0.748129487,
-0.850532949,
-0.3542215526,
-0.9436901808,
0.3068066537,
-0.540848434,
0.0013634699,
-0.6351676583,
0.1312959045,
-0.1780106276,
0.1234653369,
-0.4281488359,
-0.0520547405,
0.2326464206,
0.6433874369,
-0.6935884953,
0.7546205521,
0.6231645346,
-0.2220650911,
-1.1662244797,
-0.2334216088,
-0.0157962069,
-0.9585752487,
1.0154615641,
-0.0964053199,
0.0459631979,
0.1904719174,
-0.6257253289,
-0.4585385919,
0.9016890526,
0.1376800239,
-0.595110178,
-0.0071557974,
-0.0090474803,
0.3709549308,
-0.4271312356,
0.1302505434,
0.6125083566,
0.5002684593,
0.1843153834,
-0.8734969497,
0.0770937204,
-0.0206667278,
-0.0436625518,
0.1647243649,
-0.356013298,
0.7318177819,
-0.5123330951,
0.0195883885,
-0.0533117615,
0.7279137969,
0.7913854122,
0.0673034936,
0.5697658658,
0.2478057444,
0.902995646,
0.1664910018,
0.7903316021,
0.089708671,
0.2115041763,
0.7241188288,
-0.4095189869,
0.9728366733,
0.6186367273,
-0.2563367486,
0.5962050557,
0.7128751278,
-0.0211393759,
0.264719367,
0.7397530675,
-0.4688682258,
-0.5015044212,
-0.3097179234,
0.1760786921,
0.0577131137,
0.6839346886,
-0.1010356918,
-0.2617937624,
0.2292510569,
0.105930239,
0.083701767,
-0.6502928734,
0.9005105495,
0.2037668228,
-1.0926280022,
0.3528963923,
0.1270464212,
0.4635165632,
-0.7049027085,
-0.2430235445,
0.1003062427,
-0.0883125663,
0.049646616,
-0.8419538736,
-0.0502656549,
-0.0645613596,
-0.1732386351,
-0.4233303666,
0.5059930086,
-0.6260476708,
-0.0352699794,
0.1378296763,
0.6249676347,
0.3857970536,
0.1173137948,
-0.8349433541,
-0.1050725356,
-0.1371648163,
-0.2849538028,
0.5720651746,
0.3118729293,
-0.1642570645,
1.2570996284,
0.7306898832,
0.332121253,
-0.0380890854,
0.1348576695,
0.6790639758,
-0.750679493,
-0.6531451344,
-0.734496057,
0.3694118857,
0.1673572958,
0.1192517281,
0.3675094545,
-0.006498666,
0.6068487167,
-0.0965782702,
0.772749722,
0.2091105282,
0.4397946,
-1.0889905691,
0.2361712307,
-0.2424733788,
0.4129401743,
0.2334966958,
-0.730307579,
-0.0539687313,
0.7096847892,
-0.4100125432,
0.0388286375,
0.8022714853,
0.9662881494,
0.5038762093,
-0.0917825326,
0.5240114927,
-0.0334152728,
0.4825573862,
0.8402027488,
1.1711639166,
0.3490776122,
0.4130074382,
0.1843977123,
0.1502395123,
-0.3877477646,
-0.8713434935,
-1.1008815765,
-0.5726904869,
-0.321265012,
-0.4040380418,
0.3841944635,
1.4372198582,
0.4469147325,
-0.528740406,
-0.3418582082,
-0.1477143317,
0.3004654348,
-0.209128812,
-0.2092316747,
0.0262371004,
-0.8260375261,
-0.694205761,
0.791813314,
0.1336458623,
-0.0120590832,
-0.6705738902,
-0.5025538802,
-0.2355390489,
0.2026365548,
0.4034208357,
0.7370139956,
-0.7364888191,
-0.1185149699,
-0.3114017248,
0.0499478281,
0.1153883636,
1.2683030367,
-1.0102182627,
0.1634495705,
0.2864013314,
0.800704658,
0.6554064155,
-0.2299121022,
0.6674199104,
-0.6394995451,
0.0256238021,
0.4750835896,
0.1915156543,
0.133598417,
-0.1004674882,
0.0763879642,
-0.0949932933,
-0.7573534846,
-0.6594545841,
0.4669559002,
-0.660503149,
-0.4619897306,
1.3708747625,
-0.0947929919,
-0.2568003237,
-0.3071670532,
-0.4058417082,
0.0709833652,
-0.7398391366,
0.5975601077,
0.5227473974,
-0.281709075,
-0.4839713871,
-0.843452692,
0.6084575057,
0.6837400198,
-0.8436725736,
0.1930510402,
0.5079102516,
0.2399903834,
-0.1361373365,
0.7566428185,
0.2433031648,
0.0812167823,
-0.3698779345,
-0.0147306267,
-0.2079828978,
-0.5053250194,
-0.5721767545,
-0.0446757711,
0.5153383017,
0.0635980144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18624v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18624v2
|
Do Vision & Language Decoders use Images and Text equally? How Self-consistent are their Explanations?
| 2024-04-29T11:52:20 | 2024-06-10T10:43:20 |
Letitia Parcalabescu, Anette Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, 68Txx, I.2.7; I.2.10
|
Vision and language model (VLM) decoders are currently the best-performing
architectures on multimodal tasks. Next to predictions, they can also produce
explanations, either in post-hoc or CoT settings. However, it is not clear how
much they use the vision and text modalities when generating predictions or
explanations. In this work, we investigate if VLMs rely on modalities
differently when they produce explanations as opposed to providing answers. We
also evaluate the self-consistency of VLM decoders in both post-hoc and CoT
explanation settings, by extending existing unimodal tests and measures to VLM
decoders. We find that VLMs are less self-consistent than LLMs. Text
contributions in VL decoders are more important than image contributions in all
examined tasks. Moreover, the contributions of images are significantly
stronger for explanation generation compared to answer generation. This
difference is even larger in CoT compared to post-hoc explanations. Lastly, we
provide an up-to-date benchmarking of state-of-the-art VL decoders on the VALSE
benchmark, which before only covered VL encoders. We find that VL decoders
still struggle with most phenomena tested by VALSE.
|
[
-0.254991889,
-0.4937637746,
0.7297100425,
0.1953395605,
-0.4752696753,
-0.4949651659,
-0.0442881472,
-0.5141720176,
-0.2605283856,
0.4342797697,
-0.500423789,
-0.2413099259,
-0.5073878169,
0.3156377375,
-0.4247097969,
0.8139148355,
-0.4239096045,
0.2591061294,
-0.5873751044,
-0.1847858727,
-0.6406012177,
-0.7248454094,
-0.182409659,
-0.2609867752,
0.5048646331,
-0.1744558364,
0.5457985401,
0.8435732126,
0.3923731446,
0.3161984384,
0.1353258491,
0.3101742566,
-0.2425076067,
0.2488833368,
-0.1975162625,
-0.1603969336,
-0.0511351563,
-0.4048675895,
0.3332633674,
0.3844097257,
0.1731083244,
0.0109746447,
0.1108327657,
0.4930588007,
-0.9344442487,
0.1576693207,
-0.4750932157,
0.1524233669,
0.0391101092,
-0.4439825416,
-0.6151200533,
0.252561599,
-0.0945891663,
-0.3993080854,
0.1771039069,
0.0925162137,
0.8763489723,
0.426623255,
-0.5927735567,
-0.3173575997,
-0.8663409948,
0.7141582966,
-0.4176519513,
0.616334796,
0.3908585012,
0.3001738489,
0.0800034702,
-0.7114726901,
-0.5033749938,
0.0468305349,
-0.3223707974,
0.3239747882,
-0.3044865727,
0.2195953429,
0.1470396519,
0.4138914049,
-0.5844584703,
-0.0486483052,
-0.4054187238,
-0.5159953237,
0.3821405172,
0.411709547,
0.0790024325,
-0.2945245504,
-0.7606076002,
-0.1144813374,
-0.5429659486,
0.2383629829,
-0.2156522125,
-0.4992240667,
-0.1517141163,
0.6742358208,
0.0544113889,
0.9554312229,
-0.0869980901,
0.0139144687,
0.0823547468,
-0.8442898393,
-0.4442451298,
-0.183685258,
0.8593337536,
0.5370235443,
0.1726130396,
-0.180484727,
-0.5084111094,
0.3450970948,
0.2731239498,
-0.4391076267,
-0.1856999993,
0.1042131037,
-0.7549986839,
-0.1609189659,
-0.2236059159,
-0.7517905235,
-0.2928655148,
-0.3943019807,
0.5497889519,
-0.3681809902,
-0.1572917253,
0.2076057643,
-0.1341306865,
0.5738286972,
0.5427556038,
-1.0392107964,
0.1947701424,
0.2727221251,
0.5465645194,
-0.1879622638,
-0.4339888096,
-0.4276710153,
-0.0283641387,
-0.5513675213,
1.0146216154,
-0.1913997531,
-0.2669393122,
0.1510406733,
0.0626828149,
-0.1211033463,
-0.3936124146,
0.2895604372,
-0.2943812609,
0.2848412097,
-0.6846141219,
-0.4579848051,
-0.1454254687,
0.0544660091,
-0.5030648112,
0.7933552861,
-0.0371032432,
-0.597440362,
0.4194034934,
-0.378285408,
-0.238933444,
-0.0856530666,
-0.4666318595,
-0.1372735649,
0.4418717623,
0.2893213928,
0.3303086758,
-0.1604945809,
-0.0259024743,
-0.0911299512,
-0.4957271516,
0.5473662615,
-0.9666286111,
0.6028032899,
0.3537003398,
-0.4685934186,
0.0775351822,
-0.6667861938,
0.0925604552,
0.2659602165,
-0.3259903789,
0.0023720586,
0.3293589354,
-0.0591580272,
0.1451164931,
0.3583990335,
-0.4618816078,
-0.2056644708,
0.0821617842,
0.3161226511,
0.927054882,
-0.3139484227,
0.2304863334,
-0.1213931292,
0.3261963725,
0.2285163254,
0.2993853688,
-0.7053830624,
-0.3221370578,
-0.6896570921,
-0.1707447469,
-0.0306995604,
0.2660823166,
-0.9507536292,
-0.3811852932,
-0.1294244379,
0.0720615536,
-0.6520822048,
0.0010783386,
0.768340826,
0.5580282211,
0.3970530927,
-0.1570049822,
-0.6603119969,
-0.8039939404,
-0.286965996,
-0.2532440126,
0.1305502504,
0.1293551326,
0.2979361713,
-0.1643338054,
0.6561129689,
0.16959171,
0.1176785529,
-0.0497482717,
0.0110827321,
-0.134096697,
0.0667247176,
0.7539719343,
-1.0177340508,
-0.2929969132,
-0.106645003,
-1.1489703655,
-0.1320251524,
-0.1842092276,
0.3119635582,
0.7506709099,
0.5383371711,
-0.2940288782,
0.6692008376,
0.8817776442,
-0.7084291577,
0.7121595144,
-0.5427919626,
0.3351713419,
-0.5813224316,
-0.2911196947,
-0.0786379054,
-0.5128868222,
-0.6078132987,
0.021244755,
0.1549294144,
0.3106393218,
-0.4501248598,
0.4258720279,
-0.7639129162,
-0.3596073687,
-0.3787519932,
0.1620562971,
0.3196296096,
0.4468137026,
0.1129798144,
0.8910743594,
0.7821459174,
-0.5335204005,
0.4420200884,
-0.019525677,
-0.1599775255,
0.3632641435,
-0.9499612451,
0.0547277145,
-0.4518665373,
-0.0851788446,
-1.2568541765,
0.0379951261,
0.2609457672,
-0.361023128,
0.0717440844,
-0.0524060614,
-0.4268306196,
-0.3365066051,
-0.2855809927,
0.3858816922,
0.6728668809,
-0.720354259,
0.7448413372,
-0.1046272591,
0.5220187306,
-0.5876432657,
-0.9500412941,
0.0347074531,
0.0442136675,
-0.423281014,
0.0698455796,
-0.313833952,
-0.4082053304,
0.2433855385,
-0.2856318951,
-0.1362809688,
-0.0869721919,
0.4920283556,
0.3033212423,
-0.6021317244,
0.2198603898,
-0.2938534319,
-0.1396625936,
0.1070542186,
-0.0563767515,
0.3521991372,
-0.5263372064,
-0.5162500739,
-0.4973552823,
0.3976492584,
0.7182145715,
-0.3314794004,
0.8567038774,
0.5782134533,
0.0681389272,
0.266813904,
-0.5445056558,
0.0386253484,
-0.4674752653,
0.0809710547,
-0.8066681623,
-0.792101264,
0.5319817662,
0.2055373341,
0.0166937187,
0.6588081717,
0.6715405583,
-0.435896337,
1.205360651,
0.5909374356,
0.404450506,
0.4027412236,
-0.0026639504,
0.0876897871,
-0.8561477661,
-0.2812398672,
-0.2287893295,
0.1156759486,
-0.4168644547,
-0.3653390706,
0.1534187645,
0.0889826566,
0.236165002,
0.1156964377,
-0.5451435447,
0.5162017345,
0.4672971368,
-0.1842985004,
0.2773573101,
0.1744282842,
0.0973362178,
-0.1099469662,
-0.7858480811,
-0.5508562922,
0.9991362095,
0.2483962774,
0.9115652442,
-0.0714249387,
0.4967035353,
0.2746539414,
0.0543400347,
-0.5035458803,
0.3406088352,
-0.3316741884,
-0.4615113437,
-0.159912467,
-0.1466250569,
-1.0269047022,
0.7538049817,
-0.1802771837,
-0.580198288,
0.248714909,
0.4224545062,
0.068631433,
0.0920834616,
-0.6527309418,
0.963871181,
-0.3199820817,
-0.2134892941,
0.018220447,
-0.5307673216,
0.2671490014,
0.1911734939,
0.3231579065,
0.1947298348,
0.0455243252,
0.4647766054,
-0.3130088747,
0.769076407,
0.0608249046,
-0.197173804,
0.3684627712,
0.1037384197,
0.1357190013,
-0.2319174707,
-0.0086613754,
0.3549546003,
0.362178117,
-0.4599895477,
-0.6820869446,
0.4104560316,
-0.7642095685,
-0.6496512294,
-0.3051788807,
-0.3049076796,
0.2184904963,
0.1169120371,
0.6878985167,
1.0977108479,
0.141496256,
0.2734975219,
0.9303908348,
-0.0263017733,
0.6989345551,
0.4889004827,
-0.2848038077,
-0.2413278222,
0.7501913309,
-0.1307788342,
0.4224392474,
0.3105044365,
0.1524738967,
-0.4484443665,
-0.6648494601,
-0.7945172191,
0.0801917017,
-1.1934595108,
-0.0265502408,
-0.4458648562,
-0.2112100869,
-0.4075978696,
-0.2783094049,
-0.426520288,
0.0329291038,
-0.1488283724,
0.02688393,
0.1278691888,
0.9223149419,
-0.2138326466,
0.0520618297,
-0.7041370869,
0.7063271999,
0.3849372566,
0.199362129,
-0.2097447515,
-0.3888276219,
-0.2339112163,
0.3463565409,
0.1263688207,
-1.0720293522,
0.0067290417,
0.0474551618,
0.6337124705,
0.2811640203,
-0.0853657648,
0.6844739914,
-0.4732489586,
1.0918836594,
0.2466482818,
-1.0354701281,
0.4315441251,
-0.0269895997,
0.492926687,
0.2360825092,
-0.0168219861,
-0.4765509665,
-0.3863736391,
-0.3816813529,
-0.4157929718,
0.5986753106,
0.1984395236,
0.2193875611,
0.0212932006,
0.2920542657,
0.2096602321,
-0.1055569351,
-1.0098917484,
-0.3110323846,
-0.6003801227,
-0.4402596653,
-0.0525198244,
-0.7050927281,
-0.2394066304,
0.0312305894,
0.0462031364,
-0.0918117538,
0.4880839288,
0.6815346479,
-0.3671531975,
-0.1819276661,
0.0854559615,
0.999725461,
0.962092936,
0.3534396589,
0.7816352844,
0.0302935857,
-0.1972061694,
-0.062048465,
-0.441288501,
0.0250148457,
0.4292609692,
0.9024405479,
1.2567316294,
0.0950076282,
-0.7724793553,
0.7540587187,
-0.4667454362,
-0.3584779501,
-0.2008967996,
0.0225942936,
-0.1461640596,
0.2391165942,
0.124352254,
0.047916986,
0.0456824638,
-0.6890403628,
-0.0753900856,
0.4226283133,
-0.4000689387,
-0.4211368561,
0.7489554286,
-0.1398301572,
-0.3236548901,
0.3098548353,
0.100350745,
-0.4133080542,
0.5387951732,
0.6253492832,
0.635181427,
-0.1090184748,
0.2516162694,
-0.1503021568,
0.333883822,
0.0872803256,
0.3830016255,
-0.5214807391,
-0.7509164214,
-0.5557777286,
-0.5179454088,
-0.1997093409,
-0.0184300896,
-0.6114196777,
-0.145318076,
-0.114795059,
0.2332823277,
0.0692908764,
-0.5744772553,
-0.6618813276,
0.3988959193,
0.3289859891,
0.4953802526,
-0.6280978322,
0.6020823717,
0.7658725977,
-0.4038901627,
-0.7908106446,
-0.164611727,
-0.0230868645,
-1.1277449131,
0.7049736977,
-0.0902677476,
-0.544226706,
-0.2196438015,
-0.492634058,
-0.7873831391,
0.8482754827,
0.3520612717,
-0.2807716429,
0.2361008525,
0.0872180015,
0.777907908,
-0.291115284,
0.2933482826,
-0.0049519176,
0.4948972464,
0.0862884521,
-1.0641182661,
-0.0066746068,
-0.2034863532,
0.2459972352,
0.0266399365,
-0.3400588632,
0.7609490752,
-0.1929691285,
-0.2729871273,
-0.0288769454,
0.6111301184,
-0.0326042436,
0.4290118515,
0.3876716793,
0.1678927541,
0.1259095669,
-0.1438673586,
1.4405962229,
-0.1701151133,
0.3581364155,
0.8495180607,
0.1720140427,
0.6752070785,
0.6677125096,
0.060182523,
0.6173701286,
0.5901318192,
-0.002712229,
0.66065377,
-0.2517095208,
-0.0347786509,
-0.4527194202,
0.001689474,
-0.3182184994,
0.6747068167,
-0.0315745436,
-0.4652441144,
-0.3164448738,
0.4069338739,
-0.3757568002,
0.0534945577,
-0.3924718499,
0.9384992123,
0.0408615582,
-0.6699109674,
1.0563143492,
-0.1846530735,
0.2983426452,
-0.475638032,
0.0542928874,
-0.2486882508,
0.3005668521,
-0.0246589184,
-1.0470247269,
0.3771028221,
-0.0581623837,
-0.3095344603,
-0.6688795686,
0.8644894361,
-0.4685794413,
-0.1434320956,
0.2293152064,
0.4563528597,
0.4150897861,
0.0953263268,
-0.4560103714,
0.6329992414,
0.030649431,
-0.2817911506,
0.1396784484,
0.7010909915,
0.0428158343,
0.5848643184,
0.1554208398,
-0.1738545299,
0.4584522545,
-0.0379412025,
0.6107823849,
-0.5041908622,
-0.0710951388,
-1.0766721964,
0.7131607533,
0.0889121294,
-0.3232122958,
0.9059454203,
0.3359812498,
0.8248972893,
-0.2713749111,
0.5464817286,
0.1077608168,
-0.1124164686,
-0.9652403593,
0.2143474668,
-0.9282101393,
-0.0341634005,
0.0074373772,
-0.7592445612,
0.0803853124,
0.6226457953,
-0.0086554475,
-0.0880716071,
1.0930851698,
0.4345691502,
0.0321319848,
0.0374174379,
0.6236277223,
0.2089973688,
0.2651498318,
0.321051091,
0.8681336641,
-0.5489117503,
0.5904207826,
-0.0889708474,
-0.0051327329,
-0.2770674229,
-0.7100622058,
-0.8194630146,
-0.8383826017,
-0.2733583152,
-0.1276502609,
0.199761793,
0.152433306,
0.6012504697,
-0.5029515624,
-0.0822251439,
-0.1605038792,
0.2203379124,
-0.2091996819,
-0.1771765202,
0.1887592524,
-0.4237544239,
-0.393334955,
0.3500037193,
0.6387354732,
0.2429544926,
-0.424854666,
-0.1403474063,
0.4718085825,
0.1720265895,
0.926858902,
0.2060455382,
-1.2702894211,
-0.5076078773,
0.2706601918,
-0.2803948522,
0.2550247014,
0.8436596394,
-0.869743824,
0.8447506428,
0.4672374427,
0.3651820719,
0.4992305636,
-0.1788333356,
0.585832715,
-0.2055633217,
-0.0484102368,
0.0110976193,
0.5426728725,
0.2622186244,
-0.2459280938,
0.2107419074,
0.2171240896,
-0.3944412768,
-0.6957357526,
0.2779011726,
-1.05565238,
-0.4368834198,
1.2164844275,
-0.2037874162,
-0.6620659828,
-0.1029614136,
-0.3123377264,
0.0181652904,
0.2035621852,
0.5882990956,
0.7525871992,
-0.2234883457,
-0.7799042463,
-0.4756398797,
0.3770656288,
0.4695186019,
-0.5391504169,
0.1995116174,
0.6157775521,
0.2979212999,
0.0884390399,
0.9546746016,
-0.1797991395,
0.6333756447,
0.2468533814,
-0.0721134394,
-0.1089029312,
-0.3756088018,
-0.4885249436,
0.0051961718,
-0.0665153116,
-0.4480681419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18615v1
|
The SAMER Arabic Text Simplification Corpus
| 2024-04-29T11:34:06 | 2024-04-29T11:34:06 |
Bashar Alhafni, Reem Hazim, Juan Piñeros Liberato, Muhamed Al Khalil, Nizar Habash
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the SAMER Corpus, the first manually annotated Arabic parallel
corpus for text simplification targeting school-aged learners. Our corpus
comprises texts of 159K words selected from 15 publicly available Arabic
fiction novels most of which were published between 1865 and 1955. Our corpus
includes readability level annotations at both the document and word levels, as
well as two simplified parallel versions for each text targeting learners at
two different readability levels. We describe the corpus selection process, and
outline the guidelines we followed to create the annotations and ensure their
quality. Our corpus is publicly available to support and encourage research on
Arabic text simplification, Arabic automatic readability assessment, and the
development of Arabic pedagogical language technologies.
|
[
-0.4556187689,
-0.2590115666,
0.3462111056,
0.253673315,
-0.3771269321,
0.0962168872,
-0.009606597,
-0.4101161063,
0.0765096992,
0.3289133012,
-0.4735500216,
-0.6468362808,
-0.6602206826,
0.7307318449,
-0.4977857471,
1.0254164934,
-0.2627325356,
-0.077870585,
-0.1599065661,
-0.305177182,
0.0152070401,
-0.5543142557,
-0.4176732004,
-0.0811780393,
0.878429234,
0.6225898266,
0.8862708807,
0.902179718,
0.6739143133,
0.3336369991,
-0.34855479,
-0.125174135,
-0.3125956655,
-0.151666671,
-0.0999718457,
-0.0530901477,
-0.2092789859,
-0.3777674437,
0.8288021088,
0.7237179875,
0.2646211386,
0.3418343067,
0.1014758348,
1.0304539204,
-0.8038959503,
0.0028783949,
0.0900081024,
-0.165593192,
-0.5759230256,
0.248085171,
-0.1924656183,
-0.6813070178,
-0.1971840411,
-0.5919049382,
0.0937170982,
-0.0499231145,
0.6679297686,
0.2568123937,
-0.3971657455,
-0.3460658193,
-0.6565214396,
0.8765827417,
-0.3572239876,
0.1089765579,
0.5808143616,
0.4693236947,
0.1966047287,
-1.0865235329,
-0.8849083185,
-0.0737340897,
-0.2915334105,
-0.0694633052,
-0.0228448715,
0.0822041258,
0.3586552143,
0.2587404251,
-0.7468014359,
-0.3712422848,
-0.8864366412,
-0.2723633349,
0.5703760386,
-0.0680137947,
0.4045463502,
-0.1469883025,
-0.4353141785,
-0.1245288625,
-0.6879312992,
-0.1248795018,
0.4373333454,
0.0291010439,
0.0318722576,
0.5718625784,
-0.4905033708,
0.2978742421,
-0.5193904638,
-0.0920046121,
0.3053120077,
-0.3625139296,
-0.2651700675,
0.5091716051,
0.6490212679,
0.164327234,
0.4583423734,
0.1506966352,
-0.1948260963,
0.0678059384,
0.2054207772,
-1.0236730576,
0.0872815177,
0.2129669935,
-0.6053768396,
-0.0703914016,
0.1935929954,
-0.522130847,
-0.0888124481,
-0.0268168934,
0.1785992831,
-0.5590683222,
0.0393851884,
0.2856450677,
-0.1640091836,
-0.0695086345,
0.3342031837,
-0.6004331708,
0.4523843825,
0.6104236245,
0.582926631,
-0.0023460588,
-0.4896096289,
0.2025594711,
0.4046960473,
-0.1801875681,
0.5691498518,
-0.55921489,
-0.3262172639,
0.3545036912,
-0.3034197688,
0.1102251634,
-0.4033799767,
1.3605846167,
-0.6788551211,
-0.1119807959,
-0.0682069734,
-0.3695603311,
-0.497903198,
-0.0583889373,
-0.9178048372,
0.9818390012,
-0.0150070461,
-1.039503336,
0.1771738529,
-0.5281746387,
-0.4719487131,
0.2714032531,
-0.1170179993,
-0.3735123277,
-0.2361743003,
0.282954216,
0.0975516886,
-0.1839542687,
0.0270799957,
0.3724667132,
-0.625890255,
0.1147603989,
-0.325221628,
0.7479842901,
0.7227908373,
-0.0584738776,
0.1452994347,
-0.7839251757,
0.093537733,
-0.1642957032,
-0.2699573934,
-0.2788464129,
-0.3297581077,
0.937734127,
0.0026889876,
0.8492725492,
-0.9069423676,
0.1073393226,
-0.1089102775,
0.0186807569,
0.1288847029,
-0.1663447917,
-0.2624649405,
-0.9354298711,
0.7513667941,
0.0569421053,
-0.0227028783,
-0.4057471156,
-0.3252987266,
-0.4719583988,
-0.6063121557,
0.5956247449,
0.5287642479,
-0.3753984571,
0.3204054534,
-0.2043509036,
-0.6886831522,
-0.684060216,
0.134398967,
0.6878751516,
-0.0201237407,
0.4537065029,
-0.0128933517,
-0.6910670996,
-1.0095207691,
-0.5190606117,
-0.1513885707,
0.1792834103,
-0.2088331282,
0.4242704809,
-0.4591575563,
0.6733444333,
-0.5093386173,
-0.4835444391,
-0.3671039343,
0.3888352811,
-0.0016873002,
0.5397719741,
0.56399858,
-1.0093249083,
-0.8616268039,
0.0424693041,
-0.5806967616,
-0.2451105416,
0.0970994458,
0.0741054565,
0.2950299382,
0.9211872816,
-0.1566877663,
0.8189327121,
0.3311422169,
-0.1712332219,
0.2788078785,
-0.3255827725,
0.4127033353,
-0.7957159281,
0.1134402007,
-0.2266390622,
-0.4069603086,
-0.4450450838,
0.1981026232,
0.2390315086,
0.151244998,
-0.2499659956,
0.5257325768,
-0.4210384488,
0.5651215911,
-0.3680849075,
0.1012862772,
-0.2271565944,
0.1345047355,
-0.107122086,
0.9211438298,
0.316480875,
-0.1892318279,
-0.088225469,
0.3690026104,
-0.4632616937,
0.0633686781,
-0.7590051293,
0.1047433987,
-0.5982695818,
0.0330638364,
-1.1875021458,
-0.2482005656,
0.0298883561,
-0.088993527,
-0.0650785193,
0.2464336455,
-0.6051908731,
-0.034597151,
-0.3197139204,
0.9126528502,
0.4757371843,
-0.358494252,
0.6237546802,
0.1162455305,
-0.8010672331,
-0.7396286726,
-0.7090881467,
-0.2348413169,
0.1514141113,
-0.4807897508,
0.1912199557,
-0.2940527797,
-0.2393449992,
-0.0570894107,
-0.2005551755,
-0.4544674456,
-0.2289283276,
0.6646448374,
0.2209071368,
-0.2622694373,
0.0421130881,
0.4730237126,
-0.0908023864,
-0.2493167222,
0.4018200934,
0.4798723161,
-0.1814554632,
-0.2223865986,
-0.5499395132,
0.744286418,
0.2890924811,
-0.1402842849,
0.9780481458,
0.4394988418,
-0.3676221371,
0.0368425436,
-0.5410815477,
0.233089298,
-0.4939371943,
0.1725362539,
-0.7896465063,
-0.8757348061,
0.3156314492,
-0.1661661267,
0.1293117255,
0.8074413538,
0.3560970426,
0.1604418159,
0.4958677888,
0.6429284811,
-0.0945817679,
0.244464919,
0.2133410424,
-0.0362053439,
-0.1263117045,
-0.3093583882,
-0.6888106465,
-0.3835175335,
-0.5959388018,
-0.2488437593,
0.2064820975,
0.390240252,
-0.4372654557,
0.138763383,
-0.3575844169,
0.7378909588,
0.5911568999,
0.0143637154,
0.8274052739,
0.061617244,
-0.4284917414,
-0.2394867241,
-0.1753725111,
-1.0569384098,
1.2160768509,
0.132565856,
0.4487934113,
0.5481979847,
1.1950331926,
0.4979124963,
0.5971663594,
-0.3447200656,
0.5623725653,
-0.0627184957,
-0.6412194967,
-0.2939823568,
-0.2692035735,
-1.0788865089,
-0.1145649329,
0.0212271623,
-0.3789528906,
-0.2085134685,
-0.3064578176,
-0.2990041375,
-0.2148301154,
-0.579289794,
0.7813361287,
0.4578370452,
-0.0329285599,
-0.3392319679,
-0.8601815104,
0.0357355997,
-0.4445169568,
0.224774003,
0.047900416,
-0.2973513007,
0.8177338839,
-0.4003191888,
0.571377039,
0.2992505729,
0.3429039121,
0.4713048935,
0.0849120319,
0.0597529188,
-0.1540373713,
-0.3089345098,
0.2621135116,
0.4610745311,
-0.624414444,
-0.1715050191,
0.6107905507,
-1.0252325535,
-0.6113705039,
-0.8327134848,
-0.6399723887,
0.220944643,
0.7063704133,
-0.0802836418,
0.4027575552,
-0.4417178631,
0.1693812162,
0.1271322221,
0.1892557889,
0.5653651357,
0.3532362878,
-0.6722586751,
-0.4126462042,
0.7770918012,
0.111731194,
-0.0928195715,
0.42811957,
0.1827451736,
-0.2331349403,
-0.672103405,
-0.4096486568,
0.276709646,
-0.5692620277,
0.0909465998,
-0.6389832497,
-0.5151594877,
-0.5044964552,
-0.2536138892,
0.0515660159,
-0.6454364061,
-0.1610490829,
-0.1616100818,
0.4468508661,
1.2157590389,
-0.0929873884,
0.5912848711,
-0.8283728361,
0.4598145485,
0.0924827009,
0.0101723522,
-0.6626748443,
-0.5285164714,
-0.1341336071,
-0.1779430509,
-0.310738802,
-0.6666773558,
0.3622564971,
0.2365022451,
0.1364375651,
0.4994519353,
0.3459936976,
0.2531738877,
-0.61211133,
0.5138468742,
0.1454469264,
-0.8474239111,
0.2654701173,
-0.3146694303,
0.6170181036,
0.9429842234,
0.9954557419,
-0.4517860413,
-0.2298292667,
-0.5185944438,
-0.7237841487,
0.4878404737,
0.336422056,
0.034646906,
0.1457136571,
0.1961462647,
0.4386749268,
0.3889862001,
-0.5176128745,
-0.8888210058,
-0.0481980816,
-0.9826151133,
-0.13518098,
-0.7309657931,
-0.1905810088,
-0.1118793264,
0.4807554781,
0.1137417108,
-0.2655626833,
0.3411210477,
-0.088765502,
-0.0659688711,
0.5635193586,
0.5626077652,
0.9737140536,
-0.3697194159,
0.1330104172,
-0.2084379196,
-1.1144841909,
0.1147396117,
0.561721921,
-0.6808369756,
0.2906375527,
0.2446309626,
0.2425628901,
-0.0681795999,
-1.1773734093,
0.5485677719,
0.0248472337,
-0.1753044426,
-0.6395083666,
-0.0435933843,
0.0935807899,
0.3581797183,
0.6157002449,
-0.0395742059,
0.2960752845,
-0.3860888183,
0.3118426204,
-0.0155427661,
-0.4078149796,
0.163374275,
0.4906495512,
-0.0915319324,
-0.3936594725,
0.0423453376,
-0.3605226874,
-0.3793265522,
0.4722948074,
0.5808278918,
0.6107410789,
-0.2712274492,
0.31502226,
0.4334079623,
0.3904827833,
-0.087556459,
0.745197773,
0.0315511115,
-0.5309209228,
-0.0704445392,
-0.8311165571,
-0.559161365,
-0.2310883701,
-0.6455706358,
0.2151786983,
-0.6872214079,
0.0229209922,
0.2188162357,
0.1413204819,
-0.557608068,
0.4147747159,
0.0092070252,
0.8880845308,
-0.567199111,
0.9045656323,
1.0565650463,
-0.7679416537,
-0.4969367981,
0.0545820594,
-0.0161986109,
-0.5852654576,
0.9356401563,
0.2485182285,
-0.3246504366,
0.3575266898,
-0.4212350845,
-0.7073704004,
0.7680393457,
0.1196716577,
-0.6448052526,
0.0517271087,
0.4765664935,
0.5500286222,
-0.2770205438,
0.5462332964,
0.3563164771,
0.5024251342,
0.2176875621,
-0.8213578463,
0.133079499,
-0.2877148986,
-0.0569813028,
0.2663522661,
-0.5467320085,
0.8292154074,
-0.1726607084,
-0.4280868471,
0.4799683094,
1.1531631947,
0.1428465098,
0.6078648567,
0.2449770421,
0.7050964236,
0.5607406497,
0.1866946667,
0.8470805883,
-0.3241145015,
0.0420711637,
0.9797231555,
0.1282080859,
1.1887817383,
0.6243406534,
-0.3546312451,
0.6445714235,
0.2468269616,
0.3913668394,
0.5221346617,
0.3825562596,
-0.6888512373,
0.0494248942,
-0.4202871323,
-0.405161947,
0.0668212622,
0.0423503108,
-0.3307285011,
-0.2973822951,
0.0471282192,
0.2111738026,
0.6508854628,
-0.5029749274,
0.5379701853,
0.1193626374,
-0.4306368828,
0.4160733223,
0.2158277929,
0.4777608812,
-0.4590578079,
0.0576819666,
-0.0027272596,
0.3012189269,
-0.2269142121,
-0.7335098386,
0.3596890569,
0.1007568091,
-0.3084639013,
-0.0933460966,
0.5995268822,
-0.7420755029,
-0.8342676163,
0.1285519898,
0.5336470604,
0.4822007716,
-0.1597648561,
-0.2292237282,
0.2822218537,
0.0620782264,
-0.1356974989,
0.1523844898,
0.6095572114,
0.1141839996,
0.5742343664,
0.4662169516,
0.1060975045,
0.2811408937,
-0.0522003062,
0.8137366176,
-1.0595194101,
-0.3322426379,
-0.5880435705,
0.2792106867,
0.1460396349,
-0.6422397494,
0.6862079501,
0.7978212833,
0.8845473528,
-0.0776025057,
0.8699524999,
0.119397521,
0.9059581757,
-0.126911208,
0.9123808146,
-0.5368583798,
-0.1339182407,
-0.1340624392,
-0.8033105731,
-0.3241710067,
0.5834338665,
-0.1353798658,
0.0670111179,
1.0672054291,
0.7623514533,
0.1695471555,
0.4874517918,
0.4972808957,
0.0477857776,
-0.5910042524,
0.3994452357,
0.6568619013,
-0.5885938406,
0.590343833,
-0.1198541671,
-0.0653994679,
-0.3717918992,
-0.6814581752,
-1.031811595,
-0.6344185472,
-0.5134897828,
-0.2523225546,
0.2428205013,
1.1071299314,
-0.1663600504,
-0.9976494908,
-0.276827991,
0.0341747105,
0.0094470819,
-0.2224918902,
-0.1553945839,
0.4984135628,
-0.0256931521,
-0.9636794925,
0.0615523383,
-0.0684529915,
0.0295544919,
-0.0142678376,
0.0365222208,
-0.3885136545,
0.2494804859,
0.1807155162,
0.3670012057,
-0.4092572629,
-0.1280639917,
-0.5081294775,
-0.91196841,
0.1604319811,
0.6427384019,
-0.6678129435,
0.3236810565,
0.4257001281,
0.7694115639,
0.5676885247,
0.0109441057,
0.2153421938,
-0.4823470712,
0.487151444,
0.2926968336,
0.2045856267,
0.2094151527,
-0.0762049779,
0.4400391579,
-0.0835826024,
-0.6592979431,
-0.4654957652,
0.1790907234,
-1.2128896713,
-0.1694830507,
0.8612282872,
-0.3457697332,
-0.3360696733,
-0.5397104025,
-0.601082027,
0.3943499625,
-0.5043039918,
0.5713447332,
0.5446058512,
0.3563246131,
-0.2326054573,
-0.4031639099,
0.7658233643,
0.7044374347,
-0.7852393389,
-0.3689639568,
0.4118742347,
-0.0062931688,
0.2688851357,
0.4548543096,
-0.002719006,
0.215396598,
0.2982262969,
0.4718170166,
-0.1876588762,
-0.4015766978,
-0.3362708092,
0.4722083211,
0.1526181549,
-0.1120343953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18585v1
|
FREB-TQA: A Fine-Grained Robustness Evaluation Benchmark for Table Question Answering
| 2024-04-29T10:55:08 | 2024-04-29T10:55:08 |
Wei Zhou, Mohsen Mesgar, Heike Adel, Annemarie Friedrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Table Question Answering (TQA) aims at composing an answer to a question
based on tabular data. While prior research has shown that TQA models lack
robustness, understanding the underlying cause and nature of this issue remains
predominantly unclear, posing a significant obstacle to the development of
robust TQA systems. In this paper, we formalize three major desiderata for a
fine-grained evaluation of robustness of TQA systems. They should (i) answer
questions regardless of alterations in table structure, (ii) base their
responses on the content of relevant cells rather than on biases, and (iii)
demonstrate robust numerical reasoning capabilities. To investigate these
aspects, we create and publish a novel TQA evaluation benchmark in English. Our
extensive experimental analysis reveals that none of the examined
state-of-the-art TQA systems consistently excels in these three aspects. Our
benchmark is a crucial instrument for monitoring the behavior of TQA systems
and paves the way for the development of robust TQA systems. We release our
benchmark publicly.
|
[
-0.6366909146,
-1.1360390186,
0.6056455374,
0.173896715,
-0.416541338,
-0.096657224,
0.2664361298,
-0.4245404005,
-0.323741734,
0.0308034997,
-0.3085464835,
-0.5086836219,
-0.0393357053,
0.0983423218,
-0.3798182607,
0.8680522442,
-0.0397510268,
0.2002994269,
-0.4648333788,
-0.3289881647,
-0.6564288139,
-0.270334661,
-0.3081406057,
-0.0260226186,
0.4546425641,
0.4762365222,
0.7303671837,
0.3953218162,
0.6358346343,
0.2543989718,
-0.0430171713,
-0.0440984406,
-0.3272306323,
0.3194824755,
-0.2129296511,
-0.4763169289,
-0.610373795,
-0.3614253402,
0.6448063254,
0.4592117667,
-0.2909470201,
0.6518201232,
0.1043276861,
0.8452287912,
-0.6669842601,
0.3392326236,
-0.8700787425,
-0.1235063523,
-0.3865392208,
0.2403613478,
-0.3309473097,
-0.9709079862,
-0.1830641031,
-0.135399729,
-0.1325318515,
-0.2947661579,
0.9668069482,
0.1813227534,
-0.2560189962,
0.1952132732,
-0.828648746,
0.41084373,
-0.685305357,
0.7143563628,
0.1774404049,
0.7000948191,
-0.0851832181,
-0.8478322029,
-0.4766904712,
-0.2042212635,
0.0773952976,
-0.0267761033,
-0.2585780323,
-0.181380257,
0.1898112446,
0.2946125865,
-0.7015293241,
-0.1315508485,
-0.1621114463,
-0.0635164455,
0.2463705093,
0.2987826765,
0.1677191108,
0.0621975288,
-0.4024323821,
-0.210371986,
-0.3035044968,
0.2907143533,
-0.0391065702,
0.3963374496,
-0.0685247034,
0.1962709278,
-0.4235835969,
0.7036326528,
-0.0776610523,
0.1226766929,
-0.0478488766,
-0.0548070222,
-0.4079897702,
-0.4952857494,
0.5832358599,
0.3120054305,
0.0393435173,
-0.5973174572,
-0.4572226703,
0.195389986,
0.4334898591,
-0.7516422868,
0.0247514118,
0.3706755042,
-0.3152647614,
-0.2858308256,
0.152072072,
-1.018684268,
-0.0162167437,
0.1325900406,
0.7154334784,
-0.4047531188,
0.0286951512,
-0.1736314446,
0.1011852175,
0.6442089677,
0.2799423039,
-0.7531508207,
0.5467970371,
0.8834193349,
0.5133808255,
-0.1070852429,
-0.2754012644,
-0.6371411681,
0.1144096404,
-0.473218441,
1.1826257706,
-0.4559687972,
-0.0993518606,
-0.1133229285,
-0.1593880206,
0.0188938268,
-0.5283665657,
0.7584285736,
-0.7050514817,
-0.0042122225,
-0.4873987138,
-0.1248496622,
-0.1397593617,
0.5798275471,
-0.5245659947,
0.9648393989,
0.5434570909,
-0.767937541,
0.4853583872,
-0.3670432568,
-0.1747078449,
-0.2163215429,
0.0184443928,
-0.4952349961,
0.1854931414,
0.1354321688,
0.2236106396,
-0.5450206995,
0.5575737953,
-0.6046500802,
-0.3928152025,
0.5762902498,
-0.4899996519,
0.3246518672,
0.4197255969,
-0.0678725317,
0.086515449,
-0.789466083,
0.6203552485,
-0.1002745554,
-0.2115910649,
-0.127655983,
-0.0618844517,
-0.1310175657,
0.1449258327,
0.1143808961,
-0.427093029,
-0.010423311,
-0.1168889552,
0.3730250597,
0.7210620046,
0.1190287024,
-0.0007680629,
-0.5377362967,
0.422089994,
0.0060303849,
0.3593967557,
0.5052734613,
-0.2208093107,
-0.2221413106,
-0.0121215861,
0.753062427,
0.5378607512,
-0.7354566455,
-0.1159889325,
-0.1743416041,
-0.8717556,
0.0061315941,
-0.2486680001,
0.4942484796,
0.567897737,
0.4176773429,
-0.4238528609,
-0.1353948414,
-1.1685819626,
-0.4707370698,
-0.3069987595,
-0.2856430113,
0.0183284394,
0.3920896351,
0.0853785798,
0.7210523486,
-0.4526787996,
-0.0496549644,
-0.2185301781,
0.1037295237,
0.0609908961,
0.5705915093,
0.6427157521,
-0.507491827,
-0.4887140691,
-0.0872066244,
-0.5648154616,
-0.1249107048,
-0.0367331207,
-0.4913085997,
0.0672372431,
0.2232494652,
-0.4583380222,
0.1610483825,
0.0521716438,
-0.3241229653,
0.4151822031,
0.1391092241,
0.1836987138,
-0.8610852957,
0.4049707055,
-0.0970638171,
-0.0393109098,
-0.7369143367,
0.4008857906,
0.1759165674,
-0.0683368146,
-0.4245336354,
0.3473659456,
-0.0828137323,
-0.2041918784,
0.2281736732,
0.2386159748,
0.1584537774,
0.6069177985,
-0.3463255763,
0.7423989773,
0.2106258571,
-0.5628510714,
-0.1589788944,
0.3964124024,
-0.1331111491,
0.903239429,
-0.8481256366,
0.2312543839,
-0.0208332036,
-0.189888224,
-0.8753988743,
-0.2102824897,
0.1480131894,
-0.4987300932,
0.3684035242,
-0.0158996675,
-0.1953201592,
-0.4685794115,
-0.4704816341,
0.0823075175,
0.2214089036,
-0.0410205461,
0.5799473524,
0.5128160715,
-0.0763375461,
-0.4399777055,
-0.6365677118,
-0.260605365,
-0.2697077096,
-0.5807941556,
0.139154911,
0.1221225783,
-0.4472500384,
-0.2409840971,
-0.8305963278,
-0.7875006199,
0.4047919512,
-0.0640432909,
0.001449455,
-0.4389004707,
-0.0954520553,
0.1942195445,
-0.0140581885,
0.3447382748,
0.1484245807,
0.5286252499,
-0.6175280809,
0.0415760055,
-0.6464811563,
0.2486410886,
0.7441100478,
-0.3313178718,
0.4327030182,
0.5063438416,
-0.6126425862,
0.069499433,
-0.3993855119,
-0.2390919179,
-0.4717585742,
0.2177160829,
-0.5682742,
-0.3650084734,
0.9572502375,
0.2040070295,
0.1657230407,
0.5127301812,
0.1338846534,
-0.088143833,
0.7412442565,
0.3614167869,
0.3722812533,
0.1434622854,
0.0965533331,
-0.2689295113,
-0.5838714838,
-0.4219926596,
-1.3146342039,
-0.2638414204,
-0.5907242894,
-0.2075427175,
0.3733071983,
0.0858458206,
-0.5903319716,
0.1919417679,
-0.4497435987,
0.4266901314,
0.6413975358,
0.1479919851,
0.290502578,
-0.3195855319,
-0.2034008652,
0.0903162137,
-0.5224109292,
-0.8216540813,
0.5526086092,
0.3612791896,
0.9275283217,
0.2284559608,
0.5946207047,
0.2552641332,
0.4466328025,
-0.4559735656,
0.6301444769,
-0.1597158611,
-0.6151509881,
-0.5214191675,
-0.5008093715,
-0.7673021555,
0.1245766431,
-0.1466162056,
-1.0330420732,
0.349465102,
0.1154149175,
-0.4594279528,
0.2894926965,
-0.766125083,
1.3387830257,
-0.0684904233,
-0.7136616111,
0.3159955144,
-0.7132382393,
0.3186624646,
-0.0905901864,
-0.0645152852,
-0.204426378,
0.1786002368,
0.8094035983,
-0.3924484551,
0.5154413581,
-0.455203563,
-0.1269496679,
0.3924650848,
0.5109286904,
0.405225575,
0.4350368381,
-0.2905676067,
0.0792971924,
0.8052786589,
-0.4896803796,
-0.5836445689,
0.5445459485,
-0.5231060386,
-0.5273751616,
-0.3980016112,
-0.4466160834,
-0.9650307298,
0.4009468257,
-0.2564274371,
0.6764098406,
-0.4930443168,
0.4258992374,
0.5197877288,
0.0332556553,
0.2847547233,
0.5665245652,
0.0489130467,
-0.578093946,
0.6474534273,
0.1958823055,
0.100551948,
0.6744260192,
0.153416872,
-0.5330632925,
-0.8669927716,
-0.7972274423,
-0.1487277746,
-0.443718195,
-0.6639741063,
-0.4171350002,
0.0426482745,
-0.0765217617,
-0.0750676841,
-0.2635808289,
-0.5435460806,
0.1602543145,
-0.0524611212,
0.0344024748,
0.6423150897,
0.104380779,
0.0090719778,
-1.1949328184,
0.7212477922,
0.7582503557,
1.0535730124,
0.0909682438,
-0.2719698846,
-0.0213749073,
0.0564509444,
-0.4848037958,
-1.1048313379,
-0.1204826161,
0.0617257059,
0.7572515011,
0.329395771,
0.4290868938,
0.6084873676,
-0.273211211,
0.6646155715,
-0.3828379214,
-1.2600724697,
0.5441529751,
-0.5811956525,
0.3867123723,
1.1529767513,
0.1341690123,
-0.1068323329,
-0.6905602217,
-0.3758124113,
-0.7119771242,
0.6423540115,
0.1995042264,
-0.0615958124,
-0.0369404033,
0.4074413478,
0.4088794887,
0.2163847536,
-0.7071860433,
-0.0528937206,
-0.2698975205,
0.067946516,
0.4796782732,
-0.4177995324,
-0.0549848042,
0.0826706737,
0.5680639148,
-0.170392856,
0.207837373,
0.2152837813,
-0.027574325,
-0.1453155875,
0.7439895868,
0.5264425874,
0.8081721067,
-0.6250110269,
0.0662504733,
0.3678085506,
-0.6744627357,
0.2078092992,
0.2547515631,
-0.5689455867,
-0.2244761139,
-0.1506869197,
0.3056873977,
-0.0642890707,
-0.3748981953,
-0.0294217579,
-0.4877980053,
-0.0650738999,
0.2386536896,
0.0444076024,
-0.172892049,
0.2725405991,
0.4938394129,
-0.0228345022,
0.3413203657,
-0.6559803486,
0.4574075639,
0.5352715254,
-0.5255227685,
-0.2877440453,
0.964255631,
0.068555437,
-0.1093756557,
0.2598358393,
-0.1244669333,
-0.2733467221,
0.6166834831,
0.431630373,
0.9651600718,
-0.200863421,
0.496745795,
0.2129091918,
0.6493744254,
0.2089728713,
0.8649235964,
-0.0099961217,
-0.3325256407,
0.1853891015,
-0.6939418316,
-0.6296485662,
0.0948439613,
-1.1193175316,
-0.0933979601,
-0.4326480925,
-0.2967516184,
0.1473128349,
0.1356279999,
-0.4195373654,
0.3944167197,
-0.2465728819,
1.1560440063,
-0.714158237,
0.5627697706,
0.7571231723,
-0.3583315015,
-0.9190919399,
0.2254749388,
-0.5323987603,
-0.3433903456,
-0.0417289361,
0.0673189238,
-0.0320557207,
-0.2204531431,
-0.3439995944,
-0.7681505084,
0.9339267015,
0.6106755137,
-0.1694864184,
0.1439770907,
0.3351542056,
0.7733836174,
0.259629041,
0.1302929074,
0.7846770883,
0.6647003889,
-0.1581206173,
-0.8646520376,
0.4001132846,
-0.1336827725,
0.0378722623,
0.3756631017,
-0.9030207992,
0.4954943359,
-0.1274973601,
-0.2111568302,
0.2416522056,
0.7928353548,
0.0555050895,
0.7025899887,
0.3662980795,
0.4667249918,
0.6119378805,
-0.6677205563,
0.6112281084,
-0.1968655437,
0.1584468484,
1.2130349874,
-0.4290676713,
1.0548232794,
0.3641211689,
-0.4732051492,
0.5131365061,
0.5816968083,
0.1215715855,
0.4535043538,
0.2983037531,
0.0890833214,
-0.1978422999,
0.0279700384,
-0.5218632221,
0.7421807051,
0.2183258384,
0.1744755507,
-0.5051322579,
-0.3246623576,
-0.1882160604,
0.1377682835,
-0.3472259641,
0.9420647621,
-0.1678297222,
-0.6618930101,
0.7914458513,
-0.1161912829,
-0.1094595343,
-0.5980734825,
0.1823322922,
-0.7510892749,
-0.0245152786,
-0.1018938273,
-0.8401076198,
0.6460711956,
0.2204031795,
-0.0123351915,
0.2041528225,
0.4223250449,
-0.0810204223,
-0.1983210444,
-0.2437697351,
0.9173461795,
-0.0462143458,
0.0427751355,
-0.5380173922,
0.0690602586,
-0.1276971251,
-0.0242685638,
0.2335074842,
0.7928250432,
-0.2967767715,
0.6867833138,
0.1989708692,
-0.446531415,
-0.230410248,
0.065704897,
1.0677870512,
-0.7565506697,
-0.4092580378,
-0.5972729325,
0.3730007112,
0.1208672225,
-0.2258531749,
0.5963842273,
0.651191175,
0.5189417005,
-0.1556250453,
0.2437567413,
-0.1899612546,
0.3299874067,
-0.4317251742,
0.916390717,
-0.4533059895,
0.1571975648,
-0.6973431706,
-0.9971994162,
-0.4583162069,
0.2820177674,
-0.0539377294,
0.0997866988,
0.6827666759,
0.5670851469,
0.0318509899,
0.0655444264,
0.3761760294,
0.3355611563,
0.0418345556,
0.3330605924,
0.7558184862,
-0.5242059827,
0.766648531,
-0.5132082105,
0.0149406223,
0.0340940505,
-0.7166129351,
-0.5771127939,
-0.5527350307,
-0.285019964,
-0.3802235723,
0.185545221,
0.4273897111,
0.3257494271,
-1.140876174,
0.0115055852,
-0.0830082372,
0.4220593274,
-0.5363745093,
-0.2960918546,
0.5772494078,
-0.2426024079,
-0.5163791776,
0.0363016166,
0.1664351821,
0.2680018842,
-0.0441734195,
0.588081181,
-0.0261212606,
0.3343140185,
0.4634970725,
0.3709912896,
-0.2849924564,
-0.42295596,
0.2068087012,
-0.1346076131,
0.1862085611,
0.3434641957,
-0.694000721,
0.1843529493,
0.5629436374,
0.6041770577,
0.1317598075,
0.3251184523,
0.5045797229,
-0.5182806253,
-0.1644241512,
0.4666747153,
0.1919448227,
0.0357000716,
-0.0131410426,
0.6082698107,
-0.3049833775,
-0.6451088786,
-1.2800751925,
-0.0275991913,
-1.1908657551,
-0.0350924134,
0.6127300858,
-0.129171133,
-0.3362655938,
-0.3018315434,
-0.1091559678,
0.1790593565,
-0.5200909972,
1.2444448471,
0.4527331293,
-0.1138610989,
0.2271133065,
-0.319340229,
0.5543221831,
0.2580394149,
-1.2625169754,
0.2185892612,
0.5877520442,
0.1940789372,
0.0243600067,
0.4981710911,
-0.3438614905,
0.6792280078,
0.1731289625,
-0.3297410011,
0.0272919927,
-0.4040087163,
-0.0918667391,
0.6942687631,
0.467120856,
-0.2378906161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.04585v1
|
PoPE: Legendre Orthogonal Polynomials Based Position Encoding for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T10:30:59 | 2024-04-29T10:30:59 |
Arpit Aggarwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
There are several improvements proposed over the baseline Absolute Positional
Encoding (APE) method used in original transformer. In this study, we aim to
investigate the implications of inadequately representing positional encoding
in higher dimensions on crucial aspects of the attention mechanism, the model's
capacity to learn relative positional information, and the convergence of
models, all stemming from the choice of sinusoidal basis functions. Through a
combination of theoretical insights and empirical analyses, we elucidate how
these challenges extend beyond APEs and may adversely affect the performance of
Relative Positional Encoding (RPE) methods, such as Rotatory Positional
Encoding (RoPE).
Subsequently, we introduce an innovative solution termed Orthogonal
Polynomial Based Positional Encoding (PoPE) to address some of the limitations
associated with existing methods. The PoPE method encodes positional
information by leveraging Orthogonal Legendre polynomials. Legendre polynomials
as basis functions offers several desirable properties for positional encoding,
including improved correlation structure, non-periodicity, orthogonality, and
distinct functional forms among polynomials of varying orders. Our experimental
findings demonstrate that transformer models incorporating PoPE outperform
baseline transformer models on the $Multi30k$ English-to-German translation
task, thus establishing a new performance benchmark. Furthermore, PoPE-based
transformers exhibit significantly accelerated convergence rates.
Additionally, we will present novel theoretical perspectives on position
encoding based on the superior performance of PoPE.
|
[
-0.3212587535,
-0.1203331053,
0.2581871748,
0.5517396927,
-0.1010793447,
-0.1743350029,
-0.3383221924,
-0.5430566669,
-0.0082258126,
0.410725981,
0.0297419801,
0.0139150089,
-0.8713973165,
0.3421542048,
-0.2632697225,
0.6836431623,
0.1199606732,
0.1357534677,
0.205488354,
-0.0729864761,
-0.0699571222,
-0.8843567371,
-0.2586590052,
-0.3924795687,
0.2445284277,
0.3823819458,
0.9851084352,
0.8553568721,
0.6881077886,
0.2846007049,
-0.0495526418,
0.0188234486,
-0.6857246757,
-0.0423402451,
-0.0900193304,
-0.5253176689,
-0.5728755593,
-0.047247652,
0.899900496,
0.9114283919,
0.0034236254,
0.2084705532,
0.1440632939,
0.7044452429,
-0.4757527113,
0.2214046419,
-0.6992202997,
0.1939568222,
-0.0419196412,
-0.603700161,
-0.5593506098,
-0.1386643499,
0.1645839512,
-0.2565523088,
0.4627433419,
-0.0948860869,
0.6510912776,
0.1580865085,
-0.419688642,
-0.0546294004,
-0.9510746002,
0.9830303788,
-0.7389454842,
0.9729714394,
0.4427455664,
0.0025757102,
-0.2224048376,
-0.398883611,
-0.3942664564,
-0.2580773234,
0.0161116123,
-0.0095039206,
-0.0843290389,
-0.1484129876,
0.3308975697,
0.3669381142,
-0.389166981,
-0.0472317822,
-0.5662159324,
0.2234111279,
0.6840151548,
-0.274569571,
0.0203310195,
-0.2078751624,
-0.4360646605,
-0.4035838544,
-0.7651493549,
0.3626839221,
0.3870916963,
0.125858441,
-0.1237769499,
0.4771098793,
0.2603588998,
0.5728731155,
0.4565777779,
-0.3861228824,
0.1341294795,
0.2453017682,
-0.0800973922,
0.1266301572,
0.6087017655,
0.3790185452,
0.3030610979,
-0.3647946715,
-0.1910678595,
-0.4821435511,
0.4717918634,
-0.6703892946,
-0.051062692,
0.0009887243,
-0.6408694386,
-0.3274155259,
0.4036431015,
-0.7224366069,
-0.0939765424,
-0.3124673367,
0.0488496497,
-0.4893498719,
-0.0630148351,
-0.0330491513,
0.0037643136,
0.4461092353,
0.1245085523,
-1.2772028446,
0.3831982017,
0.7309138775,
0.5456363559,
-0.3030922115,
-0.5098009109,
-0.3558620512,
0.4023152292,
-0.4999148846,
0.6635580659,
-0.4632332623,
-0.3425133526,
0.0379194729,
0.1162582859,
-0.33810848,
-0.6379433274,
0.5728548765,
-0.53035146,
-0.1671656668,
-0.0679550022,
-0.2214579433,
-0.4018068612,
-0.1476580054,
-0.858915925,
0.956704855,
0.2123656422,
-0.5237359405,
-0.0116622625,
-0.2542457581,
-0.6076789498,
-0.1416039169,
-0.27714926,
-0.1885269433,
0.5370064974,
0.237879321,
0.3532811403,
-0.576407671,
0.3302274048,
-0.1950464249,
-0.5237935185,
0.5454475284,
-0.7575367093,
0.6504226923,
-0.043965254,
-0.6615660191,
-0.167305395,
-0.7585436106,
-0.04479957,
0.0385335498,
-0.2183957249,
-0.1714964658,
0.1404196173,
-0.0323124304,
0.1791551262,
0.2605944574,
-0.2446718812,
0.160564512,
-0.2744407356,
0.5976436734,
0.5852165818,
-0.282235533,
0.5795115829,
-0.0532970205,
0.5823277235,
-0.3584204912,
0.1454538703,
-0.0431502983,
-0.5606087446,
-0.4855285883,
0.0843898207,
0.2835185528,
0.816834271,
-0.4147144556,
0.3589405417,
-0.3333261609,
-0.1950148195,
-0.2591410875,
0.0009528361,
0.1683098078,
0.5521081686,
0.2912026942,
-0.2630739212,
-0.4021714032,
-0.9967482686,
0.1080123633,
-0.4584788382,
-0.1600340754,
0.4334714115,
0.1974289268,
0.2248332053,
0.7232957482,
-0.3325198293,
-0.2169250399,
-0.3823108077,
0.2366215587,
0.4896001518,
0.5574079752,
0.7392725945,
-1.0557893515,
-0.3224701285,
0.0834489539,
-0.6691225767,
-0.0567730032,
-0.225221619,
0.2761426568,
0.1657569706,
0.3473971486,
-0.5845894217,
0.3497060239,
0.7735860944,
0.2036887556,
0.568292141,
-0.4824211597,
0.4083932042,
-0.5387355089,
0.1861807555,
-0.187684536,
-0.1212375611,
-0.8705525994,
0.084831126,
0.3242822886,
-0.5005358458,
-0.3487609625,
0.004789209,
-0.3353975117,
-0.0924941003,
-0.3798136413,
-0.1348272711,
-0.1887471825,
0.9111256599,
0.3502596319,
0.9983468652,
0.3710663319,
-0.3878316879,
-0.0652104914,
0.1597820818,
0.1564637274,
0.2372114211,
-0.9085140228,
0.1814128608,
-0.1855062991,
0.1984424293,
-0.8371652961,
0.1771551818,
0.2452251464,
-0.5464614034,
0.4360255003,
-0.2133927345,
-0.184173286,
-0.4114677012,
-0.3790235221,
0.5525243282,
0.4279564619,
-0.4708099961,
0.3979435265,
0.2925728858,
-0.2492948622,
-0.8387385607,
-0.4020108283,
0.1611238122,
-0.3172656298,
-0.5326734781,
0.6968775988,
0.0873124823,
-0.0240076296,
-0.2269884646,
-0.3195800781,
-0.1967826635,
-0.1957342029,
0.0923467427,
0.211797595,
-0.4571828246,
-0.1035719812,
-0.3322827518,
-0.2484657466,
0.0231064279,
-0.6083547473,
0.5790560246,
-0.1889207065,
-0.1963906884,
-0.3680763841,
0.6987502575,
0.8264274597,
-0.3752210438,
0.7528727055,
0.3804537654,
-0.3948355019,
-0.1872120202,
-0.5582851768,
-0.1394817531,
-0.4710249901,
0.3252271712,
-0.294392705,
-0.7375406027,
0.481253624,
-0.0511772372,
-0.2798917592,
0.3158813417,
0.2615268528,
-0.0243272837,
1.2379146814,
1.1119160652,
-0.1115353405,
0.3250465393,
-0.3157495558,
0.6675671339,
-0.8915321827,
-0.1217261702,
-0.6832689643,
-0.2732653022,
-0.4977758527,
-0.6113137603,
0.2839016616,
0.751614809,
-0.1906565726,
0.5553067327,
-0.4206428528,
0.1678901911,
0.4839268327,
-0.2171311975,
0.1588650197,
0.1524662226,
-0.0121775148,
-0.4545439184,
-0.8989386559,
-0.5937069058,
0.9567038417,
0.5233759284,
0.831373632,
-0.0196733959,
0.1930028796,
0.1993529946,
0.0901408345,
-0.7654797435,
0.2823704183,
-0.4802688062,
-0.0870870352,
-0.3334821761,
-0.0551392809,
-0.5273817182,
0.2478241473,
0.1159073412,
-0.8704357147,
0.8408309221,
0.209758997,
-0.3512054384,
0.3080711067,
-0.3482752144,
0.7596570253,
-0.4367982447,
-0.1496124119,
-0.0097349733,
-0.4812412262,
0.0656635836,
-0.1071858704,
0.0954222009,
0.1773342341,
-0.0194544196,
0.5348143578,
-0.2518441081,
0.8815707564,
0.0283990782,
-0.5417011976,
-0.0408972241,
-0.1132163629,
0.7019423246,
0.3542972803,
-0.2658608258,
0.6097481847,
-0.2601065338,
-0.1991814971,
-0.6748645306,
0.4352084398,
-0.7994675636,
-0.8219416142,
-0.3326156735,
-0.8186773062,
-0.2251509279,
0.0840728804,
0.5751493573,
0.6131316423,
0.1617187262,
0.3693127036,
0.7727950215,
-0.2494662553,
0.359190762,
0.4469878078,
0.0181757491,
-0.6686237454,
0.8149792552,
0.1062799618,
0.2485902756,
0.7280836105,
-0.019220436,
-0.1841326505,
-0.7561094165,
-0.4060079157,
0.3694075644,
-0.5271676183,
-0.1580813229,
-0.4423374832,
-0.2681832314,
-0.6245825291,
-0.3121479154,
-0.5379477143,
-0.6199300885,
-0.0346666537,
0.2668852806,
-0.0687670857,
0.5724826455,
-0.2611883581,
0.3320299089,
-0.721745491,
0.4012844265,
0.3262431622,
0.327152878,
0.2444946617,
-0.4825814068,
-0.1718827337,
-0.0331019647,
-0.2835320532,
-0.9847416282,
0.5674379468,
0.2028587013,
0.7087596059,
0.5305262208,
0.1446757764,
0.8136481643,
-1.1219112873,
0.5930052996,
0.0279009547,
-1.0223679543,
0.2273278385,
-0.1434788853,
0.0575933792,
0.2532757819,
0.5413106084,
-0.6392381191,
-0.4237006307,
-0.4528996944,
-0.8289868236,
0.8240326643,
0.3282267451,
0.0444860049,
-0.0496651754,
0.2953258455,
0.2170609385,
0.1701053679,
-0.6164851785,
-0.312279582,
-0.3977200389,
0.2143874913,
-0.1850784868,
-0.376545012,
0.0037816591,
-0.2659535706,
0.6207305193,
-0.2154475749,
0.6872035861,
0.5102999806,
-0.2785734236,
-0.3353346586,
0.2841285765,
1.117218852,
0.977607131,
-0.1960267872,
0.2117225826,
0.1787468046,
-0.429015398,
0.0238836203,
0.2217346728,
-0.1636072397,
0.1174872667,
0.54613024,
0.8471498489,
0.5300253034,
-0.5292525291,
0.444904536,
0.1113527343,
0.0410596281,
-0.6252256632,
-0.2481997907,
-0.1013149023,
0.2685297132,
1.0208530426,
0.2279046625,
0.049588602,
-0.2225486785,
0.3768309057,
0.3075798154,
-0.5865292549,
-0.5083020329,
0.8493804932,
-0.1029497832,
-0.5804539323,
0.4419670999,
0.0808636472,
-0.8579571247,
0.7439274788,
1.0324999094,
0.6031041145,
-0.6228590608,
0.2589138448,
0.2665621638,
0.422977984,
-0.1487790942,
0.1587042063,
-0.295556277,
-0.5693939924,
-0.5027362704,
-0.5698325634,
-0.2797725797,
0.2432261705,
-0.687641561,
0.0621648952,
-0.2704232633,
0.0081425868,
-0.1464067996,
-0.4422879517,
-0.1944755614,
-0.1861839741,
0.2423103303,
0.9191246629,
-0.6369495988,
1.0724905729,
0.7540935278,
-0.0382623002,
-0.9394349456,
0.1756351441,
-0.309645474,
-0.7657926083,
1.0503805876,
0.2216674834,
-0.3435522318,
-0.1236924678,
-0.2551913559,
-1.0100003481,
0.8561602235,
0.5797713399,
-0.4434476495,
-0.1024402007,
0.7169528604,
0.5776756406,
-0.5479499698,
-0.0242486168,
0.2902858555,
0.3312691748,
-0.1250244975,
-1.1068476439,
-0.1856151968,
-0.4034533501,
0.4603111148,
0.1929951906,
-0.5385397077,
1.0177538395,
-0.0050156699,
0.0942184031,
0.1819491386,
0.7158312798,
0.1106624305,
-0.3733030856,
0.3414747417,
0.225254938,
0.4499079883,
0.2200666517,
0.995046854,
-0.7712808251,
0.4724954367,
0.7186686397,
-0.16203852,
0.9129469991,
0.5326769948,
-0.1931232214,
0.2490250915,
0.0352170318,
-0.1198977754,
0.4110874534,
-0.1750555784,
-0.0094616702,
-0.2664177418,
-0.1159128845,
-0.6549763083,
0.4721800089,
0.2879652381,
-0.6481702924,
-0.2350107878,
0.1785509735,
-0.2704764307,
0.1805700809,
-0.2824583054,
0.2889508903,
0.1707130671,
-0.6581937075,
1.1744171381,
0.1003195047,
0.6323474646,
-0.611859858,
-0.2754862905,
-0.1073358729,
0.3731814325,
0.0062982864,
-0.4752732217,
0.1442845613,
-0.2318091542,
-0.4455777705,
-0.5272963643,
0.6151334047,
-0.5415688753,
-0.5431905389,
0.2849911451,
-0.0046579465,
0.037022382,
0.1256597638,
-0.5045790076,
0.1644690633,
-0.0420961305,
0.0418369733,
0.0830404982,
0.3521009386,
-0.2777442336,
0.4372799098,
0.4390951395,
0.1705456525,
0.0452391505,
-0.09660694,
0.2840312719,
-0.7406913042,
-0.7331335545,
-0.5547472239,
0.0948172063,
0.0792519078,
-0.2108422667,
0.5803303123,
0.3622030616,
0.7600041032,
-0.4391929507,
0.490106374,
-0.0397417992,
0.1816813499,
-0.2001742125,
0.7034662366,
-0.2312654704,
0.2923766971,
-0.2525076866,
-1.1203192472,
-0.3567578197,
0.8667883277,
-0.2493229508,
-0.2921871245,
0.7970600128,
0.4643670917,
-0.1589810997,
0.3228578568,
0.3435690999,
0.10914395,
0.1932742,
0.7681206465,
0.6266357899,
-0.6460176706,
0.5971357226,
-0.6639083028,
-0.3286858499,
-0.1680565774,
-1.008191824,
-0.7520548701,
-0.6373460889,
0.0584218837,
0.1605874747,
0.1624839008,
0.8928046823,
0.816775322,
-1.1080141068,
-0.6565951705,
0.1366289258,
-0.001155126,
-0.7499611378,
-0.1640848666,
0.6562793851,
-0.3408924937,
-0.8506413698,
0.4901031256,
0.5163938403,
-0.06949123,
-0.1038694978,
-0.2192841321,
-0.0712864324,
-0.2132039964,
0.7290896177,
0.5505729914,
-0.7288272381,
-0.5149266124,
0.2933875322,
-0.0634625331,
0.4630233645,
1.1883605719,
-0.7592616081,
-0.3022383749,
0.5105534792,
0.5657588243,
0.1880206615,
0.118208766,
1.0872167349,
-0.3134618104,
0.3905025721,
0.2049704194,
0.320530653,
0.2419622391,
-0.5826311111,
0.3770134449,
0.1188368276,
-0.4244522154,
-0.775128305,
0.1447217017,
-0.9912176728,
-0.1870549619,
0.8023725748,
-0.1495538652,
-0.3210414052,
-0.0059607271,
-0.0583071746,
0.0699227527,
-0.3122027516,
0.9448056221,
0.5692349076,
-0.354744494,
-0.2867387831,
-0.7018151879,
0.4899767637,
0.584007442,
-0.2111354321,
0.2798150182,
0.1667545289,
0.0882035568,
0.4876353741,
0.2045763582,
-0.3431910872,
0.533136785,
-0.2361309826,
-0.0983273014,
-0.0309513118,
-0.5443388224,
-0.5684886575,
0.6787790656,
0.0528884158,
0.2743785083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18570v1
|
Analyzing Semantic Change through Lexical Replacements
| 2024-04-29T10:20:41 | 2024-04-29T10:20:41 |
Francesco Periti, Pierluigi Cassotti, Haim Dubossarsky, Nina Tahmasebi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern language models are capable of contextualizing words based on their
surrounding context. However, this capability is often compromised due to
semantic change that leads to words being used in new, unexpected contexts not
encountered during pre-training. In this paper, we model \textit{semantic
change} by studying the effect of unexpected contexts introduced by
\textit{lexical replacements}. We propose a \textit{replacement schema} where a
target word is substituted with lexical replacements of varying relatedness,
thus simulating different kinds of semantic change. Furthermore, we leverage
the replacement schema as a basis for a novel \textit{interpretable} model for
semantic change. We are also the first to evaluate the use of LLaMa for
semantic change detection.
|
[
-0.0690039247,
-0.9580577016,
0.6197428107,
-0.0608562194,
-0.5101656318,
-0.2703337669,
-0.0321942717,
-0.867457509,
0.6863603592,
0.4565441906,
-0.6584492922,
-0.232111305,
-0.891272366,
0.4687273502,
-0.7331860065,
0.7566760182,
-0.3382469416,
0.0536777563,
0.3410984278,
-0.255513072,
-0.9110956788,
-0.1049515083,
-0.3517734706,
-0.5632187724,
0.711671412,
0.2701881826,
0.9427352548,
0.5685809255,
0.3455501199,
0.3118429482,
-0.4979794323,
-0.1419802308,
-0.38594082,
0.2773370743,
-0.4124291241,
-0.6450298429,
-0.2946152985,
0.1530189812,
0.7419042587,
0.8782414794,
-0.2648360133,
-0.1540401429,
-0.2586426139,
0.2447977066,
-0.763252914,
0.2832785845,
-1.6517752409,
0.187883094,
-0.377088815,
-0.490270555,
-0.160595715,
0.3373565674,
0.1127988324,
-0.976085186,
0.1530929655,
-0.1403321922,
0.7950877547,
0.4873166084,
-0.2499186993,
-0.4121395648,
-0.7255680561,
0.6840463281,
-0.7366316319,
0.4746899605,
0.2879744172,
0.3623292148,
-0.7094308734,
-0.9449027181,
-0.9236018658,
-0.47752738,
0.0062214667,
0.0308275223,
-0.1834805459,
-0.0927400514,
-0.0278132278,
0.1573076248,
0.3313233554,
-0.0141407233,
-0.0836006552,
-0.0904665962,
0.2901554406,
0.5234003067,
0.7907375097,
-0.1966541111,
-0.3374410272,
-0.3044857979,
-0.6619743705,
-0.238507852,
0.1806104481,
0.2823372483,
0.3080234826,
0.654427588,
-0.552564621,
0.7848670483,
-0.1487130374,
-0.2439014316,
0.3343285918,
-0.5225555897,
-0.4347470999,
0.3239538372,
-0.1406138539,
0.5042151213,
-0.0033741347,
-0.2899295092,
-0.3269918859,
0.6594237089,
0.1912825853,
-0.2132695764,
0.0792099684,
-0.2074899375,
-0.2890591323,
-0.4805012345,
-0.1766953319,
-0.272511065,
-0.5887658596,
-0.5319156051,
0.3862202168,
-0.5892341733,
-0.2195567787,
0.6499894857,
-0.2877895534,
0.4922316074,
0.7819029689,
-0.8001220226,
0.0812207609,
0.4481111467,
0.5075845718,
-0.0860316902,
-0.7407585979,
-0.0496116392,
0.1899237484,
-0.5109837055,
0.9502488375,
-0.8140126467,
-0.6384347677,
-0.0038953009,
0.2383574992,
-0.1045620069,
-0.4950013459,
0.1022391096,
-0.8108651042,
-0.2134724408,
-0.333753407,
-0.4088565111,
0.0258324966,
0.3843656182,
-0.6966086626,
1.1223104,
0.1194031164,
-1.0110341311,
0.6084342599,
-0.3240990639,
-0.0613160841,
-0.0514499843,
0.2756020129,
-0.2333896756,
0.2179723531,
-0.2541795075,
-0.0032973657,
0.0126689617,
0.2398097813,
-0.0899458528,
-0.7251860499,
0.6999400258,
-0.0897865072,
0.584381938,
0.0558912568,
-0.0560580418,
0.050673496,
-0.9387581348,
-0.3232530951,
0.1647357196,
-0.3412129879,
-0.7960813642,
0.3202877343,
0.128113389,
-0.0999513939,
0.3439576626,
-0.6823273301,
0.1460387856,
-0.3269688189,
0.3663390577,
0.6653985381,
0.0719150826,
0.6751981378,
-0.2614483237,
0.3083852828,
0.1822538078,
0.099864468,
-0.1919680685,
-0.5926107168,
-0.7616782784,
0.0632157326,
0.2384215593,
0.3317524195,
-0.8083142638,
-0.2517140508,
-0.1834321022,
-0.4287714958,
-0.2688805759,
0.0638202131,
-0.2468182445,
0.4370102286,
0.7029398084,
-0.3199168146,
-0.8783102036,
-0.6554723978,
-0.7085527778,
-0.2923318446,
0.1615785211,
-0.1011464745,
0.6142828465,
-1.097900033,
1.3085490465,
-0.4443988204,
-0.3068947494,
-0.1042923257,
-0.0854868516,
-0.2472473681,
0.367075026,
0.1718368828,
-0.5985707641,
0.1705797762,
-0.0986074135,
-0.4576817453,
-0.4787757099,
-0.4147322476,
-0.0383393131,
-0.1751985103,
1.2149859667,
-0.4893753231,
0.7006469369,
0.3321811259,
-0.3465430439,
0.7873725891,
-0.1359291524,
-0.1754596978,
-0.9273540974,
-0.323841244,
-0.5448001027,
0.1768561155,
-0.6125851274,
0.2404082716,
0.0018086026,
0.1619755328,
-0.7844482064,
0.8384339809,
-0.3228770792,
-0.166713044,
-0.2305230349,
0.3153943717,
-0.2158089578,
-0.0188407414,
-0.0823538825,
0.5942261219,
0.2478690743,
-0.5912049413,
0.0587177277,
0.4145819545,
-0.3877073228,
0.5228075981,
-0.53851372,
-0.1470156014,
-0.5492577553,
0.6221706271,
-0.9015318751,
-0.3713504374,
0.5183458328,
-0.186334148,
-0.2144192904,
0.1644550413,
-0.6717216372,
0.1423193514,
-0.2393057346,
0.4759654105,
-0.0868270323,
-0.4523990452,
0.5958875418,
0.2128551304,
0.2649980783,
-0.2891260982,
-0.8573327661,
0.5739788413,
-0.2583173513,
-0.495603621,
0.8378273845,
0.0297622308,
-0.5135551095,
0.2865290642,
-0.0424953625,
-0.0451085381,
0.4650134146,
0.1162298918,
0.3171292245,
-0.1197483912,
0.4145332873,
0.2830382884,
-0.2601439655,
-0.2248534858,
0.0355889276,
0.368865937,
-0.107971549,
-0.2335003167,
-0.379398495,
0.2743271887,
0.3548996449,
-0.1807557791,
0.7740086913,
0.4253436625,
-0.5906118751,
0.2277988344,
-0.3577916324,
-0.0880806744,
-0.445468843,
0.5329087973,
-0.3015445173,
-0.5881534815,
0.7095379829,
-0.1391824931,
-0.195089981,
0.3940970302,
0.5411278605,
0.032884527,
0.7044180632,
0.4870523512,
0.5378842354,
0.9222067595,
0.1010419801,
0.1199131459,
-1.0037975311,
-0.2068976909,
-0.2048201859,
-0.3944638968,
-0.7626392841,
-0.5745543242,
0.3587566614,
0.1743174493,
0.0235370006,
0.6733874679,
-0.0697878003,
0.5718097091,
0.1979007721,
0.1240504161,
0.4919747114,
-0.1791870594,
-0.0694368035,
0.0181524809,
-0.374684751,
-0.508022666,
0.7862147689,
0.084088631,
1.0143694878,
0.1136993542,
0.6795597076,
0.2304369807,
0.5147380829,
-0.8990460038,
0.8605555296,
0.1906365603,
-0.1939361393,
-0.3213945031,
0.0779362768,
-1.41865623,
0.6208024621,
-0.5519824028,
-0.7964544296,
-0.0433682129,
0.0230025519,
0.341385901,
0.4117944837,
-0.4553661942,
0.5606601834,
0.2933306694,
-0.029301621,
-0.3717753589,
-0.4201157689,
0.1810680777,
-0.0781659931,
0.0822408646,
-0.0631343126,
-0.345721662,
0.4262024462,
-0.4783680737,
1.0494017601,
0.0659925565,
-0.1949480176,
0.3125150204,
0.395265162,
0.4847605228,
-0.1034045666,
-0.1232064143,
0.2107124776,
0.135013625,
-0.4052528739,
-0.4988392591,
0.6017548442,
-0.6291081905,
-0.7179596424,
-0.6372667551,
-0.8891188502,
-0.2642446756,
-0.0278935321,
0.0843802765,
0.0295544397,
-0.3491968215,
-0.3301604092,
0.2335077077,
-0.2971832156,
0.3261802495,
0.4720081687,
-0.0125087816,
0.2200517356,
0.4833791852,
0.0406663343,
0.2798194885,
0.0723105147,
0.3736296594,
-0.1297487468,
-0.1861745268,
-0.5027189851,
0.2037108839,
-0.8775422573,
-0.005967713,
-0.4531872571,
0.08373712,
-0.0638567358,
-0.3047356009,
-0.0861944705,
-0.3035665751,
-0.5280922651,
0.0221724212,
0.3469167948,
0.8982681632,
0.0277722646,
0.5816019773,
-0.4917327464,
-0.226957038,
0.5318251848,
0.0955063105,
0.0454521291,
-0.5389388204,
-0.1392977834,
0.0043462738,
-0.0816648304,
-1.3605618477,
0.1873923093,
0.1532540917,
0.4800238609,
-0.0568518415,
-0.248026073,
0.6785184741,
-0.8727830052,
0.757717967,
0.1809748262,
-1.1185957193,
0.5468736291,
-0.3127131462,
0.6506635547,
0.4560011029,
-0.3684322536,
-1.107937932,
-0.3805189729,
-0.5574971437,
-0.7845985889,
0.3628842831,
-0.0302098412,
0.6817116141,
-0.2355969399,
0.4832965434,
0.1402307153,
0.0540417507,
-0.6931971908,
0.0529008023,
-0.2474265695,
0.0710624605,
0.2864484191,
-0.3449624181,
0.17332986,
0.0206975974,
0.4919568002,
-0.0022529727,
0.177703619,
0.2256152928,
-0.5132663846,
0.0496683456,
0.4196952283,
0.6796881557,
0.6546081305,
0.089768976,
0.331658572,
0.6841492057,
-0.2960417867,
0.004746981,
-0.2295465022,
-0.2829509377,
0.3266176879,
0.4789090157,
0.6991333961,
1.0096919537,
-0.7079942226,
0.2832794785,
0.2014385611,
0.2927356958,
-0.4762571752,
0.1062867343,
0.1418613344,
-0.0503831133,
0.0481823236,
0.1707543731,
0.1416024864,
-0.9321406484,
0.1489634216,
0.1191040128,
-0.6566311717,
-0.4130268097,
0.6419583559,
-0.2091504335,
-0.3329088092,
0.1056452468,
-0.2452370673,
-0.6168742776,
0.5025669932,
0.825322032,
0.4332278967,
-0.6815684438,
0.2888945043,
0.0528818816,
0.0796572864,
-0.0359338224,
-0.0980777517,
0.0455762967,
-1.1642165184,
-0.1812688708,
-0.5120413899,
-0.4293728471,
-0.1211169735,
-0.5098826289,
0.5549650192,
-0.3005745411,
0.0092061972,
-0.05898083,
-0.7982189059,
-0.646673739,
0.322943151,
-0.0571184382,
0.9714357257,
-0.9399979711,
0.9580877423,
1.0558853149,
-0.3742444217,
-0.4928835034,
0.2384348363,
0.0164456889,
-1.0813872814,
0.8665710092,
-0.1193282679,
-0.5549436212,
-0.3193379939,
-0.4472387433,
-0.7654292583,
1.0193737745,
0.1593500674,
-0.1261510849,
-0.018696595,
0.3309187889,
0.732358098,
-0.2601314783,
0.0488224365,
0.7150028348,
0.3580170274,
0.0440487973,
-0.5708135366,
-0.0342931524,
0.1120473817,
0.5864962935,
0.1395721883,
-0.0934665129,
1.224951148,
-0.1679567099,
-0.3348309696,
0.3619302213,
0.557533741,
0.0133911483,
0.3728206158,
0.9465844631,
0.5362610221,
0.6873452663,
0.2184216529,
1.0137140751,
-0.2215929329,
0.4670790136,
1.1852492094,
-0.260220319,
1.0546090603,
0.9052904844,
-0.0308435429,
0.8826879263,
0.7022380829,
0.3841753602,
0.630918324,
0.4733389914,
-0.5320611596,
-0.2858206928,
-0.1647820771,
-0.5572128296,
0.9304482341,
0.7033290863,
-0.0902669281,
-0.7045724392,
-0.001035092,
0.354788959,
0.1155250371,
-0.3903667033,
0.3766699433,
0.0118805245,
-0.2963735461,
0.4067785144,
0.4122115374,
0.6319087744,
-0.6351017356,
-0.261615485,
-0.2188097835,
0.1817933917,
-0.0842084289,
-0.397084862,
0.5771074891,
-0.3688355982,
0.0751596093,
-0.1225374267,
0.8526389599,
-0.3630521297,
-0.5060096979,
0.7434754372,
0.3094057441,
-0.0412564836,
0.0475240871,
-0.5847454667,
0.4592977464,
-0.1753718406,
0.0086819064,
0.4771590829,
0.3927466273,
-0.3859438002,
0.4033002257,
0.6518648863,
-0.0004671332,
0.2536752224,
-0.1036256328,
0.8705871105,
-0.5889229774,
-0.6879681945,
-0.526946187,
0.2007488161,
0.1558593661,
-0.6674878001,
0.4303548336,
-0.187992692,
0.9170310497,
-0.0728776753,
0.3963290751,
-0.0066521522,
0.1659460366,
-0.7437457442,
0.4780522883,
-0.8760892153,
0.6052876115,
-0.5031238794,
-0.8637256026,
-0.4525761604,
0.7494080663,
-0.1991941333,
-0.4918143153,
0.8464984298,
1.1276650429,
-0.2337596267,
0.388391912,
0.4468193054,
0.6402063966,
0.0200277437,
0.1218476892,
1.0107374191,
-0.5711733103,
0.2541317344,
0.2137639374,
-0.2322114557,
-0.3829067647,
-0.911277771,
-0.2614729702,
-0.9727591276,
-0.3424535096,
-0.5675866008,
0.2474413216,
0.8028596044,
0.0989530012,
-0.6247642636,
-0.0662703365,
-0.1911319345,
0.1061617434,
-0.1163205206,
-0.2311651111,
0.1140800416,
-0.5241725445,
-0.6710053682,
0.6619057059,
0.0792020038,
0.0943923667,
-0.2507916391,
0.1852494776,
-0.2665774822,
0.3827235103,
0.7830820084,
0.1375720799,
-1.1316150427,
-0.9870555401,
-0.0218023583,
-0.1122009009,
-0.0069781891,
0.8853804469,
-0.9736135602,
0.5927773714,
0.359221518,
0.7620007396,
0.4558038414,
-0.6001660824,
0.2295244783,
-0.3290547132,
0.4717391431,
-0.2757348418,
0.7489724755,
0.5325564146,
-0.0614129491,
0.6098828316,
0.6254817843,
-0.0423422866,
-0.7361929417,
0.590575695,
-1.0026830435,
-0.4549484253,
1.2889589071,
0.1148854345,
-0.3033196926,
-0.1257543117,
-0.5087285042,
0.240267843,
-0.000484311,
1.0339878798,
0.8180726171,
-0.17699489,
0.3058526516,
-0.4257816672,
0.1828550547,
0.7092696428,
-0.6148820519,
-0.3924922347,
0.4382188916,
0.5985739827,
0.1319790781,
0.5946976542,
-0.1742173135,
0.2556902766,
0.1409507543,
-0.0660897195,
0.4056253135,
0.1161779314,
-0.098973237,
-0.5508341193,
-0.0274077281,
-0.2515738308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18564v1
|
Injecting Salesperson's Dialogue Strategies in Large Language Models with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-04-29T10:12:04 | 2024-04-29T10:12:04 |
Wen-Yu Chang, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent research in dialogue systems and corpora has focused on two main
categories: task-oriented (TOD) and open-domain (chit-chat) dialogues. TOD
systems help users accomplish specific tasks, while open-domain systems aim to
create engaging conversations. However, in real-world scenarios, user intents
are often revealed during interactions. A recent study introduced SalesBot,
which simulates dialogues transitioning from chit-chat to task-oriented
scenarios to train sales agents. Unfortunately, the initial data lacked smooth
transitions and coherent long-turn dialogues, resulting in poor naturalness in
sales-customer interactions. To address these issues, this paper presents
SalesBot 2.0, an improved dataset. It leverages commonsense knowledge from
large language models (LLMs) through strategic prompting. Additionally, we
introduce a novel model called SalesAgent, trained on salesperson's
interactions, using chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. This model excels in
transitioning topics, understanding user intents, and selecting appropriate
strategies. Experiments using diverse user simulations validate the
effectiveness of our method in controlling dialogue strategies in LLMs.
Furthermore, SalesBot 2.0 enhances coherence and reduces aggression,
facilitating better model learning for sales-customer interactions.
|
[
-0.2302144021,
-0.9862523079,
0.5641262531,
-0.0215106327,
-0.2922508717,
0.1826452464,
-0.3873817623,
-0.4102238119,
-0.1487676501,
0.8610202074,
-0.6825923324,
-0.386685431,
-0.0171663146,
-0.2558134794,
-0.0412928127,
1.0887265205,
0.1503718048,
0.0582675673,
-0.3483048379,
0.0868270323,
-0.6093072295,
-0.6173477173,
-0.9075503945,
-0.319406718,
0.3106963634,
0.4474723339,
0.8817833066,
-0.1221506819,
0.1382121444,
0.2535288036,
0.094220981,
0.3462517858,
-0.6617627144,
0.5535982847,
-0.5306969285,
-0.4799915254,
-0.6159110069,
-0.2168101817,
0.0083402582,
0.573577106,
-0.3533648551,
-0.0022083709,
-0.0425500795,
0.2384953946,
-0.4484203756,
0.2520337105,
-0.7939098477,
-0.2821336389,
0.3952833116,
-0.2647963762,
-0.7669674158,
-0.0812173635,
0.360014379,
-0.582721889,
0.0002137051,
-0.1575704068,
0.7624096274,
-0.0082780318,
-0.5161550641,
-0.3416782916,
-0.9937182069,
0.7406150103,
-0.6358292103,
0.5380157232,
0.2731024027,
0.369922936,
-0.3906462193,
-0.5300094485,
-0.3350498974,
-0.2801455855,
0.0992990881,
0.1463872939,
-0.4471591711,
0.1055406928,
0.2338035852,
-0.1694039553,
-0.2444596142,
0.0705313906,
-0.2810566723,
0.17995359,
0.7162559628,
0.1985220015,
-0.0158378594,
0.0733565018,
-0.5916278958,
-0.160289228,
-0.4136587083,
0.0972302929,
0.2512566447,
0.419960767,
-0.0397709347,
0.3785238266,
-0.3600920439,
0.6387283206,
0.241976887,
-0.1974424124,
-0.1677189767,
-0.4068048298,
-0.2997571826,
-0.0013003636,
0.6489056349,
0.4730358124,
0.473297447,
-0.1183670238,
-0.3913755119,
0.0066892295,
0.2174077928,
-0.5297242403,
-0.1170384139,
0.4082966447,
-0.1309685409,
-0.3245642185,
-0.1151230261,
-0.6074873209,
-0.2261958122,
-0.411188364,
0.3129259944,
-0.3356325924,
-0.2862988412,
0.1264768094,
-0.1819230765,
0.1804068089,
0.5477885008,
-0.771900475,
0.7770192027,
0.8033695817,
0.494820267,
-0.0000371882,
-0.067061834,
-0.5578538775,
0.4286231697,
-0.4309633374,
0.6198518276,
-0.5584939718,
-0.1929244995,
0.0883042142,
-0.2217353582,
-0.0685651898,
-0.6607720852,
0.0320062451,
-0.585989356,
0.3187960684,
0.0924352258,
-0.3513183296,
-0.1064300686,
0.5937111974,
-0.1944122612,
0.8466777205,
0.2416186631,
-0.0982914716,
0.1388995051,
-0.6858082414,
-0.556971252,
0.1700622439,
-0.1326672435,
-0.0458048545,
-0.0473890603,
0.1661383063,
0.3490644991,
-0.3614693284,
0.5457866788,
-0.0339674056,
-0.0425616913,
0.4235002995,
-0.4405038357,
0.6297855973,
0.148173064,
-0.4463847578,
0.0099371588,
-0.3947104812,
-0.05897801,
0.1947987676,
0.1352416724,
-0.2649590075,
-0.0887852609,
-0.1926540136,
0.3255733252,
0.1632624716,
-0.2232683748,
0.4034739733,
-0.4806051552,
0.4044623375,
0.6969301701,
0.1799554825,
0.4643743932,
-0.2406343371,
0.7469214201,
0.1101460233,
0.301271677,
-0.0846710578,
-0.7041342854,
-0.8007867336,
-0.0397720113,
-0.0362439528,
0.4442462921,
-0.7435644269,
0.3747488856,
-0.3927440047,
-0.5157664418,
0.0394712687,
0.0738977417,
0.1602546424,
0.3294616044,
0.1865862012,
-0.2651888728,
-0.2037627995,
-0.612896502,
-0.2317486256,
-0.3070132434,
0.0452880673,
0.4333829582,
0.3193269372,
-0.1996598542,
1.0896039009,
-0.6857568026,
-0.0683199391,
-0.749192059,
-0.0016030605,
0.0953125358,
0.2939203084,
0.0243564229,
-0.5616499782,
-0.4319771528,
0.1054051891,
-0.3762795031,
0.0083882231,
-0.5871402621,
-0.4158951044,
0.3274413943,
0.5101819038,
-0.8125596046,
0.5213083029,
0.2777485251,
-0.2162310332,
0.5447936654,
-0.2504360378,
-0.0891520828,
-1.0330978632,
-0.3472357988,
-0.0137561057,
-0.3442780674,
-0.7304159999,
-0.3213469982,
-0.3065930307,
-0.37911129,
-0.497077316,
0.5996708274,
-0.2880703509,
-0.2464369386,
-0.1110478491,
0.2732701004,
0.2420486957,
0.8002454042,
0.2948258519,
0.8990610242,
0.2975677252,
-0.8507677913,
0.2597825229,
0.7050948739,
-0.379119873,
0.6866840124,
-0.7153683305,
0.3176433444,
0.0823701173,
0.6972821951,
-0.9807925224,
-0.1605632305,
0.481318146,
-0.1488600522,
-0.1028835475,
-0.2726582587,
-0.478708744,
-0.3516999483,
0.0802782476,
0.2373985946,
0.5693955421,
-0.5297803283,
0.5421640277,
0.1627343446,
-0.3476011753,
-0.1121043116,
-0.4434455335,
0.2188365161,
-0.0714275762,
-0.7325327396,
-0.0010418157,
0.0942966342,
-0.3049858809,
-0.4444903731,
0.072841391,
-0.0545116626,
0.0429314524,
-0.0807313398,
0.3985545337,
0.1263360232,
0.3895351291,
0.1441620886,
0.0166125856,
0.2162638456,
-0.6008392572,
0.9477453828,
0.1596929282,
-0.2735464573,
-0.6646726131,
0.2362198979,
0.6624019146,
-0.298469007,
0.5284910798,
0.1341643482,
-0.066568166,
-0.3323726952,
-0.3708415627,
-0.5440978408,
-0.5085713267,
0.5030736327,
-0.4717752337,
-0.5319027901,
0.2033370882,
-0.4059921205,
0.004909202,
-0.0532659255,
0.7114540339,
-0.1343644112,
1.285407424,
0.1918258667,
0.4537813962,
0.4728305936,
-0.4740882814,
0.8441743851,
-0.7306283116,
-0.5383152962,
-0.1168099418,
-0.2948835492,
-0.1477120817,
-0.6578080654,
0.2559923828,
0.0347002074,
-0.4088945091,
0.4560928643,
-0.2330690324,
0.2239992023,
0.4833538234,
0.2284405679,
0.1631279737,
0.0985335559,
0.1469533145,
0.1889601648,
-0.8228675723,
-0.5051177144,
0.733047545,
0.4577027857,
0.9707905054,
0.2787361741,
0.4868550301,
-0.0003153222,
-0.0920709595,
-1.2131260633,
0.8403974771,
0.2070277482,
-0.5669078231,
-0.2399132252,
-0.3660455644,
-1.0465530157,
0.005475604,
0.1141789332,
-0.9662918448,
0.3101553321,
0.168172121,
-0.4879347384,
0.1829465479,
-0.6906894445,
0.8368987441,
-0.6014688611,
-0.5293546319,
-0.3726248145,
-0.4954241812,
0.1298271418,
0.1463727355,
0.0890093818,
-0.0968018249,
0.0052819373,
0.6970008612,
-0.6818506718,
1.024679184,
-0.0428401157,
-0.5316597819,
0.5071755648,
0.2603503168,
1.0522903204,
-0.2310481966,
0.1768147796,
-0.2123417407,
-0.2483888566,
-0.3711789846,
-0.9504224062,
0.3849585056,
-0.3641142845,
-0.7659682631,
-0.197242707,
-0.7655060887,
-0.7202397585,
-0.0687371269,
0.0285856128,
0.4984809458,
-0.3177409768,
0.0217087064,
0.2851538658,
-0.0281784534,
-0.0169503484,
0.3001595736,
-0.0868580714,
-0.3636016548,
0.7561644912,
-0.1281696111,
0.8897222877,
0.1471391171,
0.3060554266,
-0.691465795,
-0.1089619622,
-0.2819477618,
0.2102808505,
-0.6579310894,
-0.180521369,
-0.6677914262,
0.0720487833,
-0.5927108526,
-0.1500634849,
-0.0869290084,
-0.3840616345,
-0.1034250036,
-0.0309547335,
0.4883153737,
0.7731953263,
0.4128412902,
0.4578252137,
-0.7355757952,
-0.0486139953,
0.5609797239,
0.0817843452,
0.3281045258,
-0.479136765,
-0.2910040915,
0.3975042403,
-0.4218751788,
-0.7006023526,
0.2806831598,
-0.0452828929,
0.4152608216,
0.7062550783,
0.2932455838,
0.5246462822,
-0.1868563145,
0.9200809002,
0.3691115379,
-0.8621993661,
0.7032365799,
-0.6545170546,
0.2521947324,
0.5783528686,
0.3288282454,
-0.6428551078,
-0.2415862828,
-0.7219999433,
-0.6403360963,
0.9058707952,
0.0045450553,
0.3315666914,
-0.2083101869,
-0.2611111104,
0.1744595915,
0.4616959691,
-0.2577401996,
0.1550849229,
0.0153229348,
-0.1947715431,
0.0735745579,
0.0484683886,
-0.158969149,
-0.2120964527,
0.6621920466,
-0.2759032249,
0.0351549014,
0.0827712044,
-0.0721347407,
0.0584823862,
0.3586626053,
0.4327196181,
0.7571899891,
-0.1005327255,
-0.1517005712,
0.0069738291,
-0.122524716,
0.2392034978,
-0.2849506438,
-0.1014840975,
-0.2135758996,
-0.143142432,
0.9751619697,
0.3069660962,
-1.0210306644,
0.5267278552,
0.3417457938,
-0.3523445129,
-0.1222099215,
0.0683090761,
-0.0386382081,
0.4251006246,
-0.015459138,
0.1210970581,
0.1398115605,
-1.0247015953,
-0.083035551,
0.4356895685,
-0.6051543951,
-0.1396201104,
0.3811401427,
0.5965651274,
-0.6707491279,
0.6099380851,
-0.2826031446,
-0.9292369485,
0.3561536968,
0.7458440065,
0.7838144302,
0.0054212366,
0.6217575669,
0.1235719621,
-0.1224153042,
-0.2013117969,
0.0563886948,
-0.3552445769,
-0.6853661537,
-0.2702515125,
0.0203396883,
-0.6396489739,
0.0435258858,
-0.418035239,
0.3916195631,
-0.3744196594,
-0.2083403766,
-0.1482626051,
-0.0795363933,
-0.5666826963,
0.0959164277,
0.078575924,
0.901293695,
-0.5019017458,
0.7335132957,
0.3850737512,
-0.2743769288,
-0.7163380384,
0.0854980424,
-0.2394721508,
-0.6309483051,
0.7958644032,
-0.0068669035,
-0.366953522,
-0.0299836751,
-0.5136723518,
-0.3174183071,
0.9077152014,
0.1673718542,
-0.7650889158,
0.0786800608,
0.2841861546,
0.4213683605,
-0.5367751122,
0.1981588602,
0.613629818,
0.3323274553,
0.3425218165,
-0.5866604447,
-0.0175981168,
-0.0495769605,
-0.1430669874,
0.3484180272,
-0.715269506,
0.6036662459,
-0.3610410988,
-0.0531110726,
0.3996637464,
0.3390623331,
0.3998946548,
0.5788411498,
0.8279905915,
0.4616770744,
0.9106361866,
0.0444745719,
0.9005488157,
-0.1286870241,
0.1633692235,
1.3210151196,
-0.6144914031,
1.0014607906,
0.382399261,
-0.0416777097,
0.9183257818,
0.3260290325,
-0.0491846129,
0.2919642329,
0.247475028,
-0.3484284878,
-0.6129398942,
-0.3094417453,
-0.0790436268,
0.6728251576,
0.3726525903,
-0.0884981304,
-0.0307261627,
0.0308049861,
0.1012144089,
0.0280670021,
0.0159609132,
0.9987869263,
-0.0957244188,
-0.9773034453,
0.6489518285,
-0.3479589224,
0.3977029324,
-0.6927546859,
0.0169224031,
-0.0303606838,
0.2717347443,
0.1078166589,
-0.7847677469,
-0.1961515397,
-0.0334860198,
0.1409811974,
-0.2173582315,
0.6666140556,
-0.7313554883,
-0.2477290928,
0.2506491542,
0.5455858111,
0.2218779325,
-0.2641204596,
-0.7088602781,
-0.1077566966,
-0.0481885448,
0.0337142721,
0.0620351732,
0.3358132541,
-0.3284400702,
0.7323617339,
0.8707668185,
-0.2232390493,
-0.4493871629,
0.5403406024,
0.8005239964,
-0.5758544207,
-0.6836458445,
-0.3708298206,
0.3811537623,
-0.4348013401,
-0.2078779787,
0.7436000705,
0.5755970478,
0.6861109734,
-0.0299739297,
0.6684263945,
0.3926549852,
0.2981369197,
-0.2584429085,
0.447209686,
-0.4375375807,
0.314326793,
-0.1508774906,
-0.8575857282,
0.2047426254,
0.4027433693,
-0.5767686367,
0.1936417669,
0.5438956618,
0.7306839228,
-0.1211175919,
0.0575236231,
0.3490071595,
0.3011599183,
0.4640223384,
0.5896129608,
1.0939302444,
-0.4212147295,
0.8396937847,
-0.0880594924,
-0.1643136889,
-0.3898265362,
-0.3471101224,
-1.0252976418,
-0.2470964044,
-0.4432674348,
-0.5475686789,
0.2547001541,
1.1724181175,
0.7182005048,
-0.5930655003,
-0.625643611,
-0.3161703646,
-0.0516380407,
-0.3690351546,
-0.2435807288,
-0.1190280691,
-0.565428853,
-0.7554132938,
0.4679577053,
0.3614475727,
0.1987147927,
-0.2824220955,
-0.409651041,
-0.2606622875,
0.5443058014,
0.7229520082,
0.034000244,
-0.6652415991,
-0.0142197851,
0.1917462051,
0.0138599603,
0.1144761369,
0.9690386653,
-0.9181015491,
0.4526433945,
0.4449529648,
0.3573308289,
0.3680425882,
0.1284024417,
0.9664981365,
-0.4199670255,
0.1822862476,
0.4206960797,
-0.0160060581,
0.2199908495,
-0.3745692074,
0.4350137711,
0.0399089679,
-0.3537413478,
-0.5580169559,
0.6290714145,
-1.0426440239,
-0.4657927454,
1.2394479513,
0.1472655982,
-0.1625526696,
-0.4370637238,
-0.5362046361,
0.0686165318,
-0.7634337544,
0.4289627969,
0.4424808323,
-0.054432027,
-0.0806964338,
-0.2419075966,
0.4228328168,
0.4602183104,
-0.8416394591,
0.37981987,
0.2784576118,
-0.1532025784,
0.0854010731,
0.704406321,
0.2991390526,
0.2883051038,
-0.0335095227,
-0.3116091192,
0.0996715873,
-0.4045633376,
0.0486382246,
-0.1687978655,
-0.0477854908,
-0.129058212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18557v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18557v1
|
Can GPT-4 do L2 analytic assessment?
| 2024-04-29T10:00:00 | 2024-04-29T10:00:00 |
Stefano Bannò, Hari Krishna Vydana, Kate M. Knill, Mark J. F. Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated essay scoring (AES) to evaluate second language (L2) proficiency
has been a firmly established technology used in educational contexts for
decades. Although holistic scoring has seen advancements in AES that match or
even exceed human performance, analytic scoring still encounters issues as it
inherits flaws and shortcomings from the human scoring process. The recent
introduction of large language models presents new opportunities for automating
the evaluation of specific aspects of L2 writing proficiency. In this paper, we
perform a series of experiments using GPT-4 in a zero-shot fashion on a
publicly available dataset annotated with holistic scores based on the Common
European Framework of Reference and aim to extract detailed information about
their underlying analytic components. We observe significant correlations
between the automatically predicted analytic scores and multiple features
associated with the individual proficiency components.
|
[
-0.2511436641,
-1.076264739,
0.8413677216,
0.0726370141,
0.0197704025,
0.2796590626,
-0.1752974391,
-1.1140506268,
0.0448186733,
0.1994357705,
-0.1289754063,
-0.5380657911,
-0.5238167048,
0.2293306142,
-0.3459864259,
0.9608389139,
-0.4638006687,
-0.1630983353,
-0.1021985486,
-0.2114936858,
-0.5285995603,
-0.3572999835,
-0.8120957017,
-0.3475508988,
0.5614545345,
0.4837603867,
0.3484621644,
0.4261991382,
0.7129335403,
0.2671847045,
0.694685638,
-0.218580693,
-0.1852684468,
0.1324353665,
-0.2788538933,
-0.371852994,
-0.7661091089,
0.3662174046,
0.6146202683,
0.3947870731,
0.1495633125,
0.5099765062,
0.4070685804,
0.4531164467,
-0.3251599371,
0.5123869777,
-0.6228098273,
-0.1553747505,
-0.2520875335,
-0.0043791318,
-0.4103130698,
-0.2961882651,
0.2104922235,
-0.610894978,
0.2252151966,
-0.2638598382,
0.8052128553,
0.2527104616,
-0.3509491384,
-0.4257567823,
-0.6838321686,
0.7437216043,
-0.5375872254,
-0.0872774199,
0.4732353389,
0.396797359,
0.4869645536,
-0.5281518698,
-0.5568597913,
-0.1004825309,
-0.0971870944,
0.3344413042,
-0.0961042643,
-0.0261885971,
0.1928790659,
0.0589795671,
-0.7530296445,
0.2209281474,
-0.5228088498,
-0.4778565168,
1.110409379,
0.2140790522,
0.0892796963,
0.1651496738,
0.0046558734,
0.0881202891,
-0.4953330755,
0.2609137297,
0.6653729081,
0.2737208009,
-0.1560282856,
0.6301307082,
0.0525359176,
0.4302714467,
0.1407933533,
0.0626811534,
0.2671278119,
-0.3209391534,
0.1323194206,
0.0102596572,
0.7028065324,
0.5995474458,
0.460896343,
0.144639805,
-0.2902185321,
0.5443074703,
0.2074603885,
-0.6182029843,
-0.3350364864,
0.2233755141,
0.0294600893,
-0.2938072681,
-0.0258199889,
-0.9958918691,
-0.1169592366,
-0.4032629132,
0.5278351903,
-0.1172128096,
-0.1280861348,
-0.1205381453,
-0.0243118927,
0.6689633727,
0.4173552096,
-0.9128855467,
0.5720624924,
0.6747328639,
0.88705194,
-0.4768525064,
-0.4150669873,
-0.3527325094,
-0.1595530808,
-0.6539564133,
1.1598514318,
-0.7316770554,
-0.4265662432,
0.1913920045,
-0.2827855647,
0.0197342839,
-0.2517168522,
0.6224812865,
-0.4283772707,
0.4180791378,
-0.4372738302,
-0.7486917973,
-0.1755214036,
0.1724150032,
-0.544002831,
1.4679250717,
0.4263980687,
-0.6192114949,
0.2965714037,
-0.6827504635,
-0.4719997048,
0.1955447942,
-0.4787494242,
-0.4273110628,
-0.0040105861,
-0.1214173883,
0.3183870018,
-0.0140820555,
-0.0540732704,
-0.246911034,
-0.6103086472,
-0.0582385175,
-0.5099163055,
0.2215627581,
-0.2855882049,
-0.7779420018,
-0.2404060364,
-0.683142364,
0.3213584125,
0.0237945337,
-0.2768027484,
-0.0451831333,
-0.423656255,
-0.0054721399,
0.2380777299,
0.3846594989,
-0.5278671384,
0.2718896866,
-0.4332817793,
0.0676688328,
0.6509758234,
0.3224173784,
0.2963553965,
-0.3226744831,
0.6545676589,
-0.4045864642,
-0.3474902809,
-0.1069915071,
-0.9819298983,
-0.5363512635,
-0.1694209576,
0.2385310084,
0.8179609776,
-0.4320693016,
0.7135952711,
0.0007155449,
-0.7009497285,
-0.7431191802,
0.2014638186,
0.5157557726,
0.4968083501,
0.4184853137,
-0.3027146757,
-0.1300106645,
-0.8649644256,
-0.4930222034,
-0.1828086823,
-0.0204403587,
0.0409093574,
0.6338493228,
-0.0471717119,
0.8859189153,
-0.4487474859,
-0.5960387588,
-0.3030035794,
0.5715635419,
-0.1288865656,
0.138044253,
0.688806951,
-0.1682207882,
-0.9637126923,
0.0084863249,
-0.8277382255,
-0.4798355997,
0.0440462902,
0.0674793944,
0.4964124262,
0.235808149,
-0.3381591141,
0.7068616152,
0.4573098421,
-0.353990674,
0.7355843186,
-0.3745525479,
0.1906701773,
-0.5533229113,
0.0261001196,
0.2408292741,
-0.0843782425,
-0.520802021,
-0.1821833551,
0.0215495694,
0.1230432838,
-0.0751682669,
0.8560660481,
-0.1856230646,
-0.4513507783,
-0.3775510788,
0.2979907691,
0.2986533642,
0.5201256871,
0.0276017301,
0.8782272935,
0.5125912428,
-0.1410702467,
0.1330640465,
-0.0251676794,
-0.241843313,
0.7205393314,
-0.7160092592,
0.5095229149,
0.04104219,
0.172175318,
-1.2107644081,
-0.5066450238,
-0.0648711994,
-0.4970229566,
0.4705076218,
0.3059417903,
-0.1825239509,
-0.1801017672,
-0.6231934428,
0.3236112893,
0.4647701383,
0.0569525957,
0.4880878031,
0.4009642601,
-0.5413306355,
-0.2580725253,
-0.6291089654,
0.0566982962,
-0.2062672973,
-0.4273222983,
0.1363765597,
-0.1044987291,
-0.4074813128,
-0.0160199385,
0.196266219,
-0.0304944701,
-0.0753707811,
0.1779477894,
0.4110628068,
-0.1494345665,
0.0067617553,
0.1964518428,
-0.3572950959,
0.1386528462,
-0.1752556115,
0.1887607127,
-0.3671883047,
-0.5766392946,
-0.8123321533,
0.5262616277,
0.6096201539,
-0.2938965261,
0.2002695054,
0.5884058475,
-0.5729439855,
-0.2325874567,
-0.5665584803,
-0.111248225,
-0.4346958995,
0.5440666676,
-0.4766503572,
-0.6680738926,
0.5145558715,
0.298287034,
0.2489571422,
0.9109981656,
0.7202220559,
-0.308706969,
0.9487438202,
0.4077274203,
-0.1170385182,
-0.0103180045,
-0.4218641818,
0.5198841095,
-0.6968369484,
-0.0499251746,
-0.5026894212,
-0.310100317,
-0.6121525764,
-0.3049573302,
0.6759859324,
-0.0659556463,
-0.1898139268,
0.0198426377,
-0.4706687033,
0.6018458605,
0.1628996283,
-0.2864245176,
0.1357053667,
-0.0442207269,
-0.290335089,
-0.2184352726,
-0.0100658778,
-0.8789002299,
1.3618642092,
0.5610530376,
0.0711178854,
-0.00780835,
0.6720730066,
0.6951622963,
0.6200954318,
-0.788345933,
0.4985799193,
0.019400144,
-0.6028677821,
-0.5792253017,
0.1178584918,
-0.5399808884,
0.0158534199,
0.0309576262,
-0.8878616691,
-0.1697467268,
0.1708400548,
-0.6492228508,
-0.1673619449,
-0.741473496,
0.8490691781,
-0.4782519639,
-0.7889174819,
-0.0711343437,
-0.3726711571,
0.187844038,
-0.6248019934,
0.3174390197,
-0.1370676309,
-0.0401163809,
0.9297832251,
0.1732965261,
0.8066913486,
-0.4214799404,
-0.3357032239,
0.7028791904,
0.1437260807,
0.4850114286,
-0.1434233785,
-0.4741047025,
0.3605712354,
0.1894514412,
-0.3722771108,
-0.7573527098,
0.7270019054,
-0.9112000465,
-0.4481290579,
-0.7752820253,
-0.027419446,
-0.3881119192,
0.1150669754,
0.2549966276,
0.4641637802,
-0.1764537692,
-0.3215689957,
0.0578085706,
0.0562114418,
0.3672965765,
0.544858098,
-0.1353029907,
-0.1733475327,
0.8631082177,
0.3202000856,
0.1634250879,
-0.0412433185,
0.2704668939,
-0.7109178901,
-0.5746206641,
-0.437502563,
0.3715848029,
-0.8398705721,
-0.0137965335,
-0.3303733468,
-0.046194952,
-0.4882265925,
-0.4906918406,
-0.2521991134,
-0.2278349251,
-0.0689382255,
-0.6191940308,
-0.0282405186,
1.1559118032,
-0.1508637965,
0.0243024267,
-0.6581273079,
0.1081336066,
0.0719922781,
0.2751277983,
-0.2578286529,
-0.684871316,
-0.2648590803,
-0.0960080102,
-0.4991815686,
-0.740059495,
0.0903109014,
0.2973640263,
0.4222936034,
0.5178815126,
-0.4175227582,
0.4899955988,
-0.6701163054,
1.1192510128,
-0.1197219044,
-1.0361685753,
0.3616427779,
-0.4540093243,
0.0364276879,
0.9601195455,
0.4497819841,
-0.1788490564,
-0.3476090431,
-0.4275268018,
-0.5794091821,
0.482431531,
0.0801955014,
0.035956841,
0.1657869667,
0.7701793909,
0.2722359896,
-0.0307543613,
-0.6863203049,
0.1242577359,
-0.0039887009,
-0.6203537583,
-0.325471431,
-0.1867814958,
0.1529565752,
-0.4387661517,
0.7032845616,
-0.2303346545,
0.3162143826,
0.2497190535,
0.2747536004,
-0.2610633373,
0.1140316054,
0.4867062867,
0.6063395739,
-0.0869048834,
0.056389045,
0.2066380829,
-0.6107369065,
0.3066144586,
-0.0524914078,
-0.1776255965,
-0.1995515674,
0.9211794734,
0.3408467174,
0.0953976959,
-0.5926653743,
0.6488402486,
0.0446984097,
-0.5150626302,
-0.7209228873,
0.1280405819,
-0.1478130817,
0.0677625909,
0.1291276515,
-0.1527740359,
0.1782932729,
-0.8177416325,
0.4002189934,
0.3310288787,
-0.4240051508,
-0.8264427781,
0.436591357,
0.3127127886,
-0.4242970347,
0.3436037302,
-0.6030305028,
-0.6319737434,
0.4325512946,
0.3559815884,
0.9391492009,
-0.6464785337,
0.2570245266,
0.4153496325,
0.3817902505,
0.0434597395,
0.493088007,
0.0348765813,
-0.7234736681,
-0.3039378822,
-0.8560912013,
-0.3316566944,
0.1819976419,
-0.6090804935,
0.4026243985,
-0.2793343365,
-0.0670901164,
0.1222318709,
0.3771256208,
-0.8635231853,
0.3428781927,
0.1703581363,
0.4540683329,
-1.1671565771,
0.8812323213,
0.6022464037,
-0.3977801204,
-1.0210996866,
0.1422303766,
0.3238845468,
-0.6596512198,
0.6324984431,
0.4225446582,
-0.4268235862,
0.1453490257,
-0.0265788045,
-0.633377552,
1.0937018394,
-0.0582086034,
-0.4225167036,
-0.2160562426,
0.6379358768,
1.0718514919,
-0.5107463598,
0.6845096946,
1.0632164478,
0.7716013193,
-0.160762161,
-1.0383273363,
-0.3403666019,
-0.2758849859,
-0.5483537316,
-0.063850075,
-0.3294172287,
0.6635264158,
-0.0591779761,
-0.1619517505,
-0.0849901587,
0.2059256136,
-0.1087534428,
0.7352952361,
0.200988397,
0.6349624991,
0.8088410497,
0.0003663983,
1.020629406,
-0.497371912,
0.4069526494,
1.0127805471,
-1.2194949389,
1.1494910717,
-0.0366575532,
-0.3162205219,
0.5682820082,
0.4433107376,
0.0434528217,
0.3557041585,
0.1596075445,
-0.4201821089,
0.1063106433,
0.273788482,
0.010877056,
0.9432346225,
0.5746372938,
-0.0338583216,
-0.1802630723,
-0.1212962195,
0.0649507344,
0.2330194563,
-0.1281938404,
0.8304828405,
-0.0148619134,
-1.1184799671,
0.1660306603,
0.221838221,
0.2373256832,
-0.5436281562,
-0.3229139745,
-0.1145954579,
0.2258551419,
-0.2087544054,
-1.0785622597,
0.6487451792,
0.2869604826,
0.27009058,
-0.0918760598,
0.8306418657,
-0.3908024132,
-0.7229822278,
0.5491163731,
0.5744443536,
0.2448668033,
0.0108274743,
-0.4383428395,
-0.0587632991,
-0.2010956705,
-0.2102765441,
0.1992107034,
0.3819846213,
-0.1126770601,
0.0645524412,
0.470638901,
0.0859829187,
-0.1546559185,
-0.0299905166,
0.3551255167,
-0.4346176088,
-0.4653154314,
-0.7456943393,
0.4354751408,
-0.0757893398,
-0.4191429615,
0.7150476575,
0.7852964401,
0.7374024391,
0.1716406494,
1.3121038675,
0.3678412735,
0.7747004628,
-0.3750263155,
0.4827353656,
-0.3004766703,
0.1424942464,
-0.3133242428,
-1.074575901,
-0.3074567318,
0.7730867267,
-0.6376314163,
0.1542708576,
1.0185592175,
0.6477278471,
0.2458674014,
0.1695784926,
0.5183464885,
0.1774271876,
0.4891396761,
0.4074092507,
0.6305814385,
-0.3170397878,
-0.1398307234,
-0.0829878449,
-0.6713228226,
-0.0907218531,
-0.6877701283,
-0.9751692414,
-0.6453941464,
-0.2933561802,
-0.1122504622,
-0.0218074117,
0.6354602575,
0.0253661536,
-0.7147241831,
-0.0341630615,
0.1103368625,
-0.6120537519,
0.0330415703,
-0.2963217497,
0.689489305,
-0.1858284026,
-0.6094830632,
0.2835772038,
0.6218202114,
-0.1422543973,
-0.6007805467,
0.075899221,
0.1550859511,
0.4672139287,
0.5022901893,
0.0287086815,
-0.6081365347,
-0.8636602163,
0.1064084843,
-0.0120828208,
-0.0422635004,
0.8617810011,
-0.5933772326,
0.2596296668,
0.1645155847,
0.5849283934,
0.2487863451,
0.1133285165,
0.2563460767,
-0.4312283099,
-0.1057230756,
0.4459170997,
0.3636346459,
0.3157505691,
-0.4927574694,
0.2962175012,
0.3491033316,
-0.8256102204,
-0.435808301,
0.1351927668,
-0.8982290626,
0.1950227767,
1.1969996691,
-0.3568191826,
0.2031203955,
-0.4501285851,
-0.2002749592,
0.1627404839,
-0.2626999915,
1.0278160572,
1.0479384661,
-0.4869356155,
0.2154588848,
-0.8878067136,
0.6168473363,
0.2209713012,
-1.1551309824,
-0.0442541465,
0.4513578415,
0.3515796959,
0.3705150187,
0.9827765226,
-0.1053892374,
0.2069095522,
-0.0009650302,
-0.1372142732,
0.1977669448,
-0.4856241941,
-0.4721854925,
0.2735674977,
0.2038615346,
0.1303864419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18543v1
|
Time Machine GPT
| 2024-04-29T09:34:25 | 2024-04-29T09:34:25 |
Felix Drinkall, Eghbal Rahimikia, Janet B. Pierrehumbert, Stefan Zohren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.LG, I.2.1, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) are often trained on extensive, temporally
indiscriminate text corpora, reflecting the lack of datasets with temporal
metadata. This approach is not aligned with the evolving nature of language.
Conventional methods for creating temporally adapted language models often
depend on further pre-training static models on time-specific data. This paper
presents a new approach: a series of point-in-time LLMs called Time Machine GPT
(TiMaGPT), specifically designed to be nonprognosticative. This ensures they
remain uninformed about future factual information and linguistic changes. This
strategy is beneficial for understanding language evolution and is of critical
importance when applying models in dynamic contexts, such as time-series
forecasting, where foresight of future information can prove problematic. We
provide access to both the models and training datasets.
|
[
-0.105162546,
-0.8033427,
0.6115077734,
0.2228075862,
-0.2914987803,
0.3365012705,
-0.1922579408,
-0.4573889971,
-0.1400858015,
0.3884011209,
-0.7297326326,
-0.2607222199,
-0.5775154829,
-0.0675834119,
-0.6124549508,
1.094628334,
-0.1049675345,
-0.2493678033,
0.3891572356,
-0.1130616739,
-0.3418640196,
-0.6729983091,
-0.7809929252,
-0.6628471017,
0.3505325019,
-0.0326023139,
0.7587195635,
0.6294205785,
0.1242737472,
0.1467988938,
0.0361601114,
0.0227129888,
-0.2899670899,
0.2720694244,
-0.249692142,
-0.1451745927,
-0.2678622603,
-0.0129152993,
0.8621118665,
0.8862014413,
-0.1969131678,
0.2073649913,
0.1895055175,
0.3322611451,
-0.2754274607,
0.3465329409,
-0.8042299747,
0.3205165565,
-0.1626045257,
-0.5972086787,
-0.4707044959,
-0.2783492208,
0.1947864294,
-0.4106313586,
0.3622094989,
0.0476839468,
0.6361371279,
0.3263728023,
-0.2543891966,
0.1002783179,
-1.0289299488,
0.9176726937,
-0.6501051784,
0.4297930896,
0.0975672007,
0.4761911333,
-0.4424185157,
-0.6811038256,
-0.3746627271,
-0.4124490023,
0.1925783753,
-0.1519649476,
-0.0573497117,
-0.1438564509,
0.1699235886,
-0.0357494652,
-0.7397928834,
0.3482535183,
0.1356646419,
-0.0303542465,
0.2422036976,
0.2357047349,
0.0567920245,
0.0397451296,
-0.3717159629,
0.2842462659,
-0.7324259877,
-0.2678050697,
0.0972808301,
0.533518672,
-0.0225468073,
0.4137870073,
0.112838231,
0.6575782895,
0.0042041945,
-0.4008778036,
-0.0130842542,
-0.0345776305,
-0.3208389282,
0.1598512977,
0.64965868,
-0.1019510776,
0.3931130767,
-0.4471006989,
-0.2838190794,
-0.2035987079,
0.0291961282,
-0.7021343112,
-0.2435505241,
0.1543729901,
-0.3823298216,
-0.4277115762,
-0.2604238391,
-0.744197309,
-0.2561564744,
-0.3818792403,
0.2480315715,
-0.6166151166,
-0.3101964593,
-0.2209896892,
0.0891831368,
0.1778906882,
0.3226421177,
-0.9223667979,
0.0133411754,
0.5616136193,
1.0690498352,
-0.0165520981,
-0.4457363188,
-0.4388387501,
0.6206619143,
-0.5616941452,
0.7970265746,
-0.6765632629,
-0.5931956768,
0.0399300344,
0.3565988243,
-0.0794780105,
-0.4218788445,
0.2056359947,
-0.5390712023,
0.4711971879,
0.2089430988,
-0.4096788168,
-0.2468952835,
0.2432014942,
-0.2676781714,
1.1313481331,
0.4434759617,
-0.6894643307,
0.5426501036,
-0.9405690432,
-0.4712216854,
0.1520608068,
0.0064082979,
-0.4040543139,
0.0817524716,
0.4338820875,
0.6384745836,
-0.3492563665,
0.9390442371,
-0.4032049775,
-0.1962510347,
0.2594511509,
-0.5734423995,
0.5790103674,
0.3559069932,
-0.3697615266,
-0.0433406904,
-0.6851238012,
0.025971543,
0.3387621641,
-0.3435297906,
-0.1882906854,
0.2446078807,
-0.0027817115,
0.2671327591,
0.3805911839,
-0.2448857129,
0.3564934731,
-0.1560379416,
0.7419398427,
0.9290562868,
0.1896952689,
0.0654546842,
-0.3748983145,
0.6480689049,
0.0708591342,
0.3363680243,
-0.1887453347,
-0.3861366808,
-0.6386562586,
-0.0507944748,
0.1375558972,
0.7601817846,
-0.8964876533,
0.2752918601,
-0.5165557861,
-0.4518714249,
-0.1055202186,
-0.0492919162,
0.0437827334,
0.4455520213,
0.2120980322,
0.0119176013,
-0.54138726,
-0.7040522099,
-0.2799360156,
-0.2554109693,
-0.3108118176,
0.0128474869,
0.3593019843,
-0.4163851142,
0.7775200605,
-0.3658305705,
0.1613148004,
-0.3429848254,
0.4291929305,
0.3592485785,
0.1882570088,
0.6351168156,
-0.321642518,
-0.1767848283,
-0.0573309176,
-0.8712357879,
-0.2891355157,
-0.2016381919,
0.3613627553,
0.4089688361,
0.3964488804,
-0.2863834798,
-0.0785019919,
0.851467073,
-0.1611937881,
0.305455327,
-0.1121033654,
0.0666095167,
-1.1912242174,
0.1595332175,
-0.1324963272,
-0.4750610888,
-0.5903517604,
-0.4781994522,
-0.2423112094,
-0.4778700471,
-0.4497877657,
0.7719419003,
-0.4142196178,
-0.095812574,
-0.3416397274,
0.030145986,
-0.3843056262,
0.4534132481,
0.1668362319,
0.8626463413,
0.3505576551,
-0.5974568129,
0.1119080633,
-0.1174794286,
-0.3309676647,
0.260769248,
-0.4776515663,
0.3439447284,
-0.1352484524,
-0.0134825129,
-0.6482859254,
-0.0443036705,
0.1809307188,
-0.4351375699,
0.6394619346,
-0.3935981691,
-0.6179717183,
-0.2706014216,
-0.0316140763,
0.2219552249,
0.4720797241,
-0.6462341547,
0.397156775,
0.3907800615,
-0.5299910307,
-0.5866314173,
-0.5422427654,
0.0959475413,
-0.3903451562,
-0.4406503439,
0.0454241,
0.0928385779,
-0.2726077735,
-0.0201956797,
0.1275980324,
-0.1992655545,
0.1169273332,
0.1390518099,
0.2856939137,
-0.3007776141,
0.3552299738,
-0.1811969429,
-0.1929159462,
-0.2225897908,
-0.7578686476,
0.7517021298,
0.1157295927,
-0.0484461822,
-0.2935733497,
0.345695883,
0.4867428839,
0.0753789917,
0.8315374255,
0.637414515,
-0.5381432176,
-0.2137466073,
-0.4778991938,
0.0107757924,
-0.464862138,
0.404921025,
-0.1373358369,
-0.9873279929,
0.3499892056,
-0.2339301109,
0.0835539624,
0.5512344241,
0.7160401344,
-0.0343976915,
0.7627444267,
0.815238595,
-0.2847837508,
0.8869566917,
0.106623359,
0.1892728209,
-0.4689799845,
-0.2534272671,
-0.2837863863,
-0.0332570113,
-0.685285151,
-0.2881601453,
0.2473609895,
-0.2013494819,
-0.5884396434,
0.1997437328,
-0.4620550275,
0.285898,
0.3433208168,
-0.1432949156,
0.2780005634,
0.1857229769,
0.0489355028,
-0.1366402507,
-0.5738985538,
-0.6582003236,
1.2232922316,
0.4517130554,
0.744710803,
-0.0935295299,
0.2451556474,
0.3849143684,
0.4312823713,
-0.5552917123,
0.363589108,
-0.303958714,
-0.5829803348,
-0.4190886915,
-0.4518624544,
-1.0648736954,
-0.1144342646,
0.0533184744,
-0.7747160792,
-0.0600441843,
-0.0379506424,
-0.1852111965,
0.6045992374,
-0.6059360504,
0.7111893296,
-0.3884195983,
-0.1145477071,
0.018783832,
-0.5344561934,
0.20343858,
-0.5319331884,
0.2303914279,
-0.3970531523,
-0.1481060386,
0.9265968204,
-0.4296101928,
0.8275581598,
-0.4546929598,
-0.0022782611,
0.2581742108,
0.2938657403,
0.5560975671,
0.0900104046,
0.0345630907,
0.2953986824,
0.0814117268,
-0.4364717007,
-0.4963583052,
0.6744628549,
-0.8870379925,
-0.4783962369,
-0.6515734196,
-0.7160165906,
-0.4140840471,
0.1366520822,
0.1082610264,
0.4027682841,
-0.3396652937,
-0.212700054,
0.5355091095,
-0.3207333088,
0.7082881927,
0.6541466117,
-0.1836077571,
-0.2364418954,
0.6001675129,
0.2738597691,
0.200941667,
0.7653545141,
0.2855162024,
-0.3552695513,
-0.826443851,
0.0250082221,
0.4281257391,
-0.5652989149,
0.0417117588,
-0.4776573479,
-0.2459495813,
-0.4215074182,
-0.1273233742,
-0.265596658,
-0.6007582545,
-0.220411092,
0.0751909539,
0.6326112747,
0.8879518509,
0.1065480337,
0.6396069527,
-0.8286070228,
-0.0435243174,
0.0700008795,
0.3003418744,
-0.3786963224,
-0.7750604749,
-0.1775123924,
-0.213911429,
-0.376159966,
-0.6772574186,
0.7301810384,
0.2550615072,
0.4996546209,
0.2734458148,
-0.2419560552,
0.5114902854,
-0.6653399467,
0.9285606742,
-0.0054556644,
-0.8935456276,
0.6886621118,
-0.6518363357,
0.4164168835,
0.119366318,
0.4878623486,
-0.7737073898,
-0.1712236404,
-0.5917671919,
-0.5403462648,
0.5050943494,
-0.2264700234,
-0.1645748913,
0.0651099458,
0.5025517941,
0.3553791642,
0.442355305,
-0.6468157768,
0.1054078415,
-0.3335385025,
-0.1219805181,
-0.6148840785,
-0.3529624641,
-0.024163492,
-0.1043189019,
0.5996044278,
-0.2066861093,
0.6380072236,
-0.1818678081,
0.022641575,
-0.0628335848,
0.4478050768,
0.5254186988,
0.9025300145,
-0.3008972704,
-0.0760154128,
0.3263446689,
-0.4880459607,
0.3305560648,
0.3126088679,
-0.0356012769,
0.1633262038,
0.5440838337,
0.7052156925,
0.1390960664,
-0.4861330688,
0.2708013654,
0.2502993941,
-0.0420209169,
-0.8156573772,
-0.3191152811,
-0.2193043083,
0.4804100692,
0.3134438992,
-0.2615030408,
-0.3516099453,
-0.6788647175,
0.102833569,
0.1576705128,
-0.2514276505,
-0.5567702651,
0.8429630995,
-0.1575085521,
-0.2307574898,
0.8319801688,
-0.015661139,
-0.2958691716,
0.1584821492,
0.6677153707,
1.0401047468,
-0.6460307837,
0.2371405363,
-0.008090334,
0.4029077291,
-0.1146415994,
0.3536478281,
0.4228267968,
-0.6424384117,
-0.5264217854,
-0.6203192472,
-0.2655749619,
0.6366021037,
-0.1235744134,
0.3870052993,
-0.8262637854,
-0.3676456511,
-0.1857510209,
0.063868627,
-0.6708328724,
0.2358606309,
-0.1301797479,
0.6963635683,
-0.9009727836,
1.2954809666,
0.4053840339,
-0.1344190091,
-0.55394876,
0.2148468792,
-0.0696481168,
-1.2265416384,
0.6921234727,
-0.1340735257,
0.0489772856,
-0.0612969249,
-0.4937950373,
-0.7680202723,
1.2014039755,
0.6968686581,
-0.6300261021,
-0.4905683398,
0.0774352327,
0.5183018446,
-0.2681041658,
-0.0991581008,
0.4665217996,
0.4227409363,
0.0015929244,
-0.8518260717,
-0.050593283,
0.0510650873,
0.1119622067,
0.70914042,
-0.4800804555,
0.8623248339,
-0.0853036866,
-0.3370254338,
-0.025652891,
0.4154780805,
-0.1045410335,
0.1619544774,
0.3794737458,
0.382807225,
0.8614487648,
-0.3078698218,
1.1067693233,
-0.4226028919,
0.2664975524,
1.0808006525,
-0.1823750138,
0.7297543287,
0.5158208609,
-0.3340698481,
0.2690866888,
1.0426564217,
-0.1818894446,
0.6896908283,
0.0404017977,
-0.4502450228,
-0.2839692831,
-0.2739371657,
-0.4428905547,
0.1938558966,
0.5226011872,
-0.4456538558,
-0.2821453512,
-0.0045958851,
0.2735741436,
-0.2379586846,
-0.2194501013,
0.5278677344,
0.1028304547,
-0.4395085573,
0.6114143133,
-0.0750491172,
0.4171847999,
-0.8112869859,
0.2913185358,
-0.0924733356,
0.2407543063,
0.0120348763,
-0.7860465646,
0.3866294622,
-0.0369144492,
-0.1070748195,
-0.1980727464,
0.3794145584,
-0.3372301459,
-0.6209599972,
0.3956301212,
0.6335665584,
0.2118050903,
0.0017927007,
-0.7207173705,
-0.1371489763,
-0.1812526137,
-0.1995584816,
0.3141625524,
0.6556343436,
-0.3127311468,
0.9260703325,
0.3755325377,
0.1843654066,
-0.0392093807,
0.161065191,
0.6447293758,
-0.8542554975,
-0.3487416804,
-1.0044003725,
-0.0069538392,
0.3419129848,
-0.1043904275,
0.3748027384,
0.3693029284,
0.5720633268,
0.0212253612,
1.0566729307,
0.3731027246,
0.8659277558,
-0.7774803042,
0.4517225325,
-0.5195431113,
0.2271996737,
-0.1378138214,
-0.9394393563,
-0.4170675576,
0.1800282449,
-0.4539572001,
0.2494576871,
0.9224848747,
0.457603693,
0.1047756523,
0.1209109798,
0.361296922,
0.3854619861,
0.5886530876,
0.7126255035,
1.0670306683,
0.0956381485,
0.5006381273,
0.1090687439,
-0.3070982099,
-0.139621228,
-1.1714515686,
-1.0800579786,
-0.603199482,
-0.2538686097,
0.0042524659,
0.4531583786,
0.9471570253,
0.4795529246,
-0.7041725516,
-0.1450296193,
0.2282402962,
-0.2808016539,
-0.009424624,
-0.2059894204,
0.4183576703,
-0.3707296252,
-0.6073437333,
0.6593299508,
0.3579496443,
0.5702355504,
-0.3497474194,
0.2913858891,
-0.0676546171,
0.0137178535,
0.7383331656,
0.3575487733,
-0.4377484024,
-0.6491565704,
-0.0556490347,
0.484024018,
0.2146645486,
0.9437322021,
-0.6783741713,
0.2389320135,
0.2038835436,
0.5062840581,
0.5713400841,
-0.2629368901,
0.843408525,
-0.7931129336,
0.5336198807,
0.2929420769,
0.4989394844,
0.5738837123,
-0.3466147482,
0.5263844728,
0.4465860128,
-0.7516273856,
-0.7643796206,
0.2505384088,
-0.6147449017,
-0.3842163086,
0.9787396193,
-0.0602960065,
-0.1241910309,
-0.3869217336,
0.2562836409,
0.3884046376,
-0.4369777739,
0.8229702115,
0.7758753896,
-0.2275666893,
-0.1724553257,
-0.8839500546,
0.3655902445,
-0.0852025002,
-0.7521159649,
0.1241964921,
0.0335243866,
0.6072244048,
-0.1048153862,
0.644239068,
-0.2559252381,
-0.2894646227,
-0.1321106404,
-0.2798958421,
-0.0457330644,
-0.5208096504,
-0.4092099667,
0.1349018812,
0.4510926008,
-0.1782068163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18534v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18534v2
|
Evaluating and Mitigating Linguistic Discrimination in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T09:22:54 | 2024-05-10T07:09:02 |
Guoliang Dong, Haoyu Wang, Jun Sun, Xinyu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.SE
|
By training on text in various languages, large language models (LLMs)
typically possess multilingual support and demonstrate remarkable capabilities
in solving tasks described in different languages. However, LLMs can exhibit
linguistic discrimination due to the uneven distribution of training data
across languages. That is, LLMs are hard to keep the consistency of responses
when faced with the same task but depicted in different languages.
In this study, we first explore the consistency in the LLMs' outputs
responding to queries in various languages from two aspects: safety and
quality. We conduct this analysis with two datasets (AdvBench and NQ) based on
four LLMs (Llama2-13b, Gemma-7b, GPT-3.5-turbo and Gemini-pro). The results
show that LLMs exhibit stronger human alignment capabilities with queries in
English, French, Russian, and Spanish (only 1.04\% of harmful queries
successfully jailbreak on average) compared to queries in Bengali, Georgian,
Nepali and Maithili (27.7\% of harmful queries jailbreak successfully on
average). Moreover, for queries in English, Danish, Czech and Slovenian, LLMs
tend to produce responses with a higher quality (with 0.1494 $F_1$ score on
average) compared to the other languages. Upon these findings, we propose
LDFighter, a similarity-based voting, to mitigate the linguistic discrimination
in LLMs. LDFighter ensures consistent service for different language speakers.
We evaluate LDFighter with both benign queries and harmful queries. The results
show that LDFighter not only significantly reduces the jailbreak success rate
but also improve the response quality on average, demonstrating its
effectiveness.
|
[
-0.2924553454,
-0.6715349555,
0.4605681896,
0.4296672046,
-0.2565193474,
0.3166814446,
-0.4348516464,
-0.6454923153,
0.3073255122,
0.6532691121,
-0.2394939065,
-0.56722188,
-0.666452229,
0.2303863317,
-0.31303671,
0.9030473232,
-0.1636690646,
0.2843921185,
-0.0157881305,
-0.4325832427,
-0.5886107087,
-0.8494963646,
-0.7051841021,
-0.235822618,
0.5637459755,
0.101853542,
0.708791852,
0.4687404335,
0.5920946002,
0.3455256224,
-0.2772655785,
0.0471047424,
-0.5264846683,
0.313596189,
-0.4296349287,
-0.6364949942,
-0.0892699733,
-0.1927628517,
0.560428381,
0.4281010926,
-0.2812830806,
-0.1732339561,
0.0664387867,
0.8209408522,
-0.653369844,
-0.0908767134,
-0.9088757038,
-0.0525586158,
-0.4081469476,
0.2050207406,
-0.3743658066,
-0.559705019,
-0.3799680769,
-0.28290236,
0.092338413,
0.0828018859,
0.9464007616,
0.1451988518,
-0.3961710334,
-0.340708226,
-0.4773945212,
0.7682103515,
-0.8415940404,
0.6016302705,
0.6014202833,
0.3499619663,
-0.1926281303,
-0.0866134018,
-0.4893804789,
-0.2674275041,
0.0108827762,
-0.0852157697,
0.0539441481,
-0.0663128197,
0.1544938833,
0.0581732728,
-0.763066113,
0.8215828538,
-0.1521278769,
-0.549423039,
0.7387293577,
0.1722980887,
0.3481588364,
-0.0833522752,
-0.1564339548,
-0.0760470182,
-0.9996581078,
0.0828217939,
0.785946846,
0.4006118476,
-0.1062157676,
0.5944702029,
-0.309250325,
0.7822300792,
-0.1312595755,
-0.2435752898,
0.291931659,
-0.2348904908,
-0.0262501668,
-0.0290239099,
1.0102664232,
0.5340017676,
0.4283057749,
-0.1582303941,
-0.3573548794,
0.2306374609,
-0.0313352421,
-0.7427623272,
0.0721594915,
0.0899202302,
-0.4311169088,
-0.1046925858,
-0.0991469026,
-0.713938117,
-0.5763796568,
-0.0669321343,
0.2249708921,
-0.2147953808,
-0.3356988728,
0.0989084467,
0.2598535419,
0.284665674,
0.2565792501,
-1.0200930834,
0.1562113017,
0.7302310467,
0.6781933308,
-0.3356586397,
-0.2006535381,
-0.5684756041,
-0.0160582643,
-0.3825643659,
0.5799423456,
-0.4686519206,
-0.2645470798,
0.0450448617,
0.0773368329,
-0.1694377214,
-0.9333238602,
0.5426416993,
-0.7709754109,
0.0683230311,
-0.3562276661,
-0.5405765772,
0.0148836737,
0.4688176513,
-0.655336082,
0.8871051073,
-0.1986068934,
-0.8797404766,
0.5111169219,
-0.0991851911,
-0.3944578171,
-0.1024217308,
-0.3596411347,
-0.539139986,
-0.0073506543,
0.2121501565,
0.3325393796,
-0.2617515028,
0.3268143833,
-0.4071011841,
-0.4707506597,
0.2736490071,
-0.2869597971,
0.7950096726,
0.2074136883,
-0.381659627,
0.1195188388,
-0.5742661357,
0.0311146248,
0.1539438665,
-0.6559761167,
-0.4028525651,
0.2165541202,
0.0186144467,
0.3966589272,
0.0271956529,
-0.9056111574,
-0.0601689108,
-0.6228516698,
0.2455567122,
0.834954083,
-0.2965952754,
0.1241960004,
-0.2102420926,
0.5979278088,
-0.0034341111,
0.0563604236,
0.3559970558,
-0.5153595805,
-0.5647267699,
-0.1214773655,
0.30708462,
0.6830024123,
-0.85672611,
0.3124284148,
-0.2334445566,
-0.3607380092,
-0.5671138763,
0.4606139958,
0.5482961535,
0.255892396,
0.0198993422,
-0.4208049476,
-0.4721307456,
-0.9452172518,
-0.3708294332,
-0.4814974666,
0.0904684588,
0.1502355486,
0.2856945992,
-0.090837203,
0.6553971171,
-0.1894421428,
-0.1331858337,
-0.3531629145,
-0.4203566611,
0.2288571,
0.3976348639,
0.8501255512,
-0.9114569426,
-0.7364425659,
0.211605832,
-0.6924378276,
-0.1940992624,
0.2251565903,
-0.058081124,
0.5541741252,
0.4590148628,
-0.4386101067,
0.3010653257,
0.7058682442,
-0.4055572748,
0.5139586926,
0.0139620407,
0.3627827466,
-0.9921063185,
-0.146356076,
-0.1028551161,
-0.1845233142,
-0.5022588968,
0.2622619569,
0.0813460127,
0.1852013022,
-0.5276115537,
0.7188796997,
-0.107597068,
-0.0352870785,
-0.3668784797,
0.3211376965,
-0.183892265,
0.1569566131,
0.0012706741,
0.7397446036,
0.4793120623,
-0.3295393288,
0.4799552262,
0.2233502716,
-0.6001346111,
0.6070068479,
-0.6955823898,
0.1721305847,
-0.3238891959,
-0.0408992879,
-1.0499489307,
-0.0631501153,
0.1546241492,
-0.4957469106,
0.0853063613,
-0.1569689214,
-0.7624120116,
-0.2158463001,
-0.22828345,
0.2389733046,
0.3362188339,
-0.6104496717,
0.1856645048,
0.4065980315,
-0.1961947381,
-0.745942831,
-0.7087065578,
0.0837918594,
-0.3749521375,
-0.6472396851,
-0.0937694907,
-0.1458049119,
-0.3876402378,
-0.16930525,
-0.0673943758,
-0.2112036496,
0.3296422958,
0.1226602048,
0.3569183052,
-0.1215531677,
0.0037450844,
-0.0786246285,
0.0917094126,
-0.0548088215,
-0.0559362881,
0.5977740288,
0.1274938136,
-0.5082027316,
-0.0534582995,
0.3740947843,
0.5192626119,
-0.3283771873,
1.1138978004,
0.5362263918,
-0.1116210818,
-0.0755064636,
-0.7668406963,
-0.0943875611,
-0.46245718,
0.4477697015,
-0.42024073,
-1.3268783092,
0.7713775039,
0.2844539285,
0.203243047,
0.188228339,
0.833843708,
0.0031579935,
1.1266243458,
0.6301242113,
-0.393320024,
0.4864870906,
0.4179145098,
0.1992256641,
-0.5507383943,
-0.3676227033,
-0.962400496,
-0.2591024935,
-0.9199903011,
-0.2629171908,
0.1581482887,
0.2818857729,
-0.2406674922,
0.3471876383,
-0.299667865,
0.6953885555,
0.2610303462,
0.0242647808,
0.2830947936,
0.2406738251,
-0.4701144099,
-0.3535972834,
-0.577681601,
-0.4231552184,
1.0250216722,
0.2370374352,
0.9278886318,
0.5711733103,
0.8609136939,
0.0198492501,
0.30398947,
-0.568672359,
0.5826853514,
-0.3251141608,
-0.8462640047,
-0.1879325956,
-0.8265119195,
-0.9293265939,
0.646351397,
-0.2000311911,
-0.9261825085,
0.0806844383,
-0.0747957304,
0.1662458181,
0.3375307024,
-0.5627651811,
0.6953931451,
-0.3917902708,
-0.4963999391,
-0.1796547174,
-0.4976310432,
0.3469461799,
-0.4634248018,
0.3973248601,
-0.4559557438,
0.1125171483,
0.6988199949,
-0.342723906,
0.7799952626,
-0.2533273101,
-0.2998030484,
0.0763593912,
0.2094070464,
0.5060759783,
-0.0147869717,
-0.5671860576,
0.2043279707,
-0.0777750835,
-0.5109752417,
-0.4504323304,
0.8372833729,
-0.744438231,
-0.7300646305,
-0.1628668606,
-0.4350636303,
-0.2290805578,
0.197434485,
0.2121346891,
-0.0126139754,
-0.0850643739,
0.1321295798,
0.6042959094,
-0.5766244531,
0.3111924529,
0.9663322568,
-0.5638000369,
-0.1906723976,
0.8129023314,
-0.0336629041,
0.4169810414,
0.309502691,
0.2051561177,
-0.4429830909,
-0.7268872857,
-0.5697019696,
0.2886973619,
-0.7215257287,
-0.2962840497,
-0.4039997458,
-0.0875606313,
-0.2674361765,
0.0250427574,
-0.3049775958,
-0.3387783766,
0.1820008904,
-0.0977363586,
0.191412583,
0.657168448,
0.0392543077,
0.1253288388,
-0.7152107954,
0.3046154678,
0.0640111566,
0.5268736482,
-0.0815615803,
-0.6042385101,
-0.2012404203,
-0.1357013732,
-0.1816705316,
-0.8477993011,
0.188006103,
0.186577186,
0.8231042027,
0.1792481393,
-0.0229775514,
0.4372673929,
-0.4866045713,
0.664634645,
0.2507093549,
-0.8300346732,
0.5893653631,
-0.2104506046,
0.1130939722,
0.6911282539,
0.4154930413,
-0.6174690127,
-0.8800135851,
0.0110125672,
-0.824014008,
0.7249866724,
0.2349960655,
0.2649368346,
-0.1527276933,
0.2889897227,
0.0506469868,
0.1413352489,
-0.971855104,
-0.077182807,
0.0310829915,
-0.1955309808,
-0.0526069812,
-0.2283624113,
-0.0064652557,
-0.0817603767,
0.4481767118,
0.0470297933,
-0.1555175185,
-0.1239993721,
-0.1863615811,
0.1158248112,
0.5074862242,
0.5553742051,
0.508612752,
-0.0517456234,
0.0859646723,
-0.0072265365,
-0.4927973449,
0.5336331129,
-0.0363117494,
-0.1773828715,
0.0322391205,
0.4068121314,
0.607124269,
-0.1111631915,
-0.8268063068,
0.363538146,
-0.1831705123,
-0.0231967866,
0.289896369,
0.2418608963,
0.2044752538,
0.166538924,
-0.0249366611,
-0.1908832937,
-0.096284695,
-0.4731840491,
0.0086610569,
0.5389212966,
-0.2071164697,
-0.097483255,
0.7126885653,
0.2293655425,
-0.236348182,
0.6938468814,
-0.1606650352,
-0.6294850707,
0.6847931147,
0.6070327163,
0.5952282548,
-0.4700664878,
0.0307229012,
0.4280996919,
0.5869101882,
-0.1795666069,
0.3872264028,
0.1557605714,
-0.9743697643,
-0.5351622701,
-0.7786563635,
-0.2900216579,
-0.1533389091,
-0.6730566621,
-0.0200081598,
-0.5494983196,
-0.2477713525,
-0.0872130767,
-0.0002798684,
-0.4246677756,
-0.0258197021,
0.1517677456,
0.8490885496,
-0.9157699943,
1.0081408024,
0.758060813,
-0.1856634915,
-0.7712863684,
-0.1684283763,
0.1071815491,
-0.8366012573,
0.8959383965,
0.1692699045,
-0.0176319573,
-0.4772687554,
-0.3113328815,
-0.6154925823,
0.5067484975,
0.7612866163,
-0.9074338078,
0.3546198606,
0.4774606824,
0.6240367889,
-0.0929760784,
0.0554255284,
0.6208153367,
0.377499938,
-0.1628759205,
-1.2593482733,
0.0072030826,
-0.1002615169,
0.0731099546,
0.4152037203,
-0.585191071,
0.6140996218,
-0.2023189515,
-0.07088162,
0.1624376476,
0.1561340541,
0.5575428009,
0.1021601781,
0.4555593729,
0.5793625712,
0.7003248334,
-0.3110156357,
0.9951116443,
-0.0681912825,
0.3804063201,
1.0720239878,
-0.6431828737,
0.9276763797,
0.4226688445,
-0.2493421584,
0.316686362,
0.4997670949,
0.0525596328,
0.5174975395,
0.3985322416,
-0.2288743258,
-0.2258454561,
-0.2004215568,
-0.1962469965,
0.5560013652,
0.1174416989,
-0.226396665,
-0.2611334026,
0.1382116228,
0.1099522561,
0.4851933718,
-0.2412216216,
0.7590356469,
0.0254696682,
-0.4993194044,
0.7837054729,
0.2933600843,
0.8857522607,
-0.5518566966,
0.1487592906,
-0.645676136,
0.0922742337,
-0.3638288081,
-0.9999619126,
0.4005616605,
0.3073806763,
-0.3541640937,
0.0449248105,
0.413595438,
-0.443878144,
-0.5354904532,
0.653331399,
0.3449489176,
0.277500391,
0.0747182891,
-0.8453785777,
0.6746261716,
0.1282601953,
0.0077378461,
0.6079200506,
0.2182769328,
-0.2817060649,
0.732270658,
0.5071456432,
0.3589034081,
0.2399289459,
0.2451007366,
0.712008357,
-0.4541787505,
-0.4840241373,
-0.9404791594,
0.1183044538,
-0.0076173819,
-0.071201697,
0.8845205903,
0.5926493406,
1.0071713924,
0.1221271753,
0.4950475693,
-0.0731242374,
0.5681208372,
-0.7101368308,
0.7561759353,
-0.5050381422,
0.5758139491,
-0.2584901452,
-1.0837575197,
-0.2823975384,
0.5871027112,
-0.3221637309,
0.0926380679,
0.3252965212,
0.9109142423,
0.142693013,
-0.4121094048,
0.5559445024,
0.1596234441,
0.5274379849,
0.7305642366,
0.972101748,
-0.2458670884,
0.5825977325,
0.0431692339,
0.06381993,
-0.0800157413,
-0.5205173492,
-0.9766625166,
-0.1991648376,
-0.1966977865,
-0.5303561687,
0.1918501854,
0.6654901505,
0.6320041418,
-0.961394608,
-0.4598213136,
0.2629393339,
0.4211149216,
0.1710444242,
-0.240068078,
0.2168997079,
-0.2075944394,
-0.7123093605,
0.2791202962,
0.2754024565,
-0.1511971653,
-0.1170059666,
-0.2904976606,
-0.0249603298,
-0.1405835897,
0.5859203935,
0.3235423267,
-0.8678151965,
-0.2796711028,
-0.1923030168,
-0.3853828609,
0.055705905,
0.6814916134,
-0.5972972512,
0.529350996,
0.40052104,
0.8372423649,
0.2107695341,
-0.149569422,
0.4489989579,
-0.7072506547,
0.4149465561,
0.1949534714,
0.374671936,
0.5895431042,
-0.2943675816,
0.4540201426,
0.0102012744,
-0.6487491131,
-0.7656838298,
0.4235209227,
-0.6246387959,
-0.2867270112,
1.1363450289,
-0.2901328504,
0.0549549796,
-0.2759764493,
-0.1371350735,
-0.1121455058,
-0.212691471,
0.7627604008,
0.8211517334,
0.0011152036,
-0.0911647156,
-0.6445076466,
0.3172961473,
0.6026985049,
-0.7481965423,
0.0534272976,
0.4155654907,
0.6734758019,
-0.1261390597,
0.6168735027,
-0.3678043783,
0.2299201488,
-0.3595772982,
-0.060311228,
0.2980556786,
-0.0912972093,
-0.4882102311,
0.0209705457,
0.4451336265,
0.0633873045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18532v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18532v2
|
MileBench: Benchmarking MLLMs in Long Context
| 2024-04-29T09:19:05 | 2024-05-15T05:43:30 |
Dingjie Song, Shunian Chen, Guiming Hardy Chen, Fei Yu, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Despite the advancements and impressive performance of Multimodal Large
Language Models (MLLMs) on benchmarks, their effectiveness in real-world,
long-context, and multi-image tasks is unclear due to the benchmarks' limited
scope. Existing benchmarks often focus on single-image and short-text samples,
and when assessing multi-image tasks, they either limit the image count or
focus on specific task (e.g time-series captioning), potentially obscuring the
performance challenges of MLLMs. To address these limitations, we introduce
MileBench, a pioneering benchmark designed to test the MultImodal Long-contExt
capabilities of MLLMs. This benchmark comprises not only multimodal long
contexts, but also multiple tasks requiring both comprehension and generation.
We establish two distinct evaluation sets, diagnostic and realistic, to
systematically assess MLLMs' long-context adaptation capacity and their ability
to complete tasks in long-context scenarios. Our experimental results, obtained
from testing 22 models, revealed that while the closed-source GPT-4o
outperforms others, most open-source MLLMs struggle in long-context situations.
Interestingly, the performance gap tends to widen with an increase in the
number of images. We strongly encourage an intensification of research efforts
towards enhancing MLLMs' long-context capabilities, especially in scenarios
involving multiple images.
|
[
-0.6626402736,
-0.6216549873,
0.7168442607,
0.5201993585,
-0.3537632823,
-0.0490034074,
-0.449839294,
-0.6996178031,
-0.3081640303,
0.3897716105,
-0.5623832345,
-0.4479369521,
-0.4912326634,
0.1119677424,
-0.2924019396,
0.8182229996,
-0.3628086746,
0.0223966427,
-0.5905316472,
-0.7690657377,
-0.5086266398,
-0.5282788277,
-0.5345625281,
0.0826242343,
0.8537971377,
0.060925737,
0.4608961642,
0.2490784824,
0.5235040784,
0.2751849592,
0.2502934635,
0.1920640916,
-0.404396683,
0.3343890011,
-0.1736882925,
0.0241204854,
-0.2103735059,
-0.0480817072,
0.9576708674,
0.6519604325,
0.0424600504,
0.3319272399,
0.0754515007,
0.8877584934,
-0.8997357488,
0.0170154851,
-0.3052957058,
-0.0038469695,
-0.2132475972,
0.135711059,
-0.1914510429,
0.0095805181,
-0.0478503779,
-0.4595633447,
0.1001354307,
0.3149821758,
0.5555096269,
0.234128952,
-0.6109156013,
-0.0423567146,
-0.7058172822,
0.8401568532,
-0.641710043,
0.7652590871,
0.2681964338,
0.7551221848,
-0.0444914475,
-0.77512151,
-0.567920208,
-0.5734928846,
0.077099584,
-0.0092539098,
-0.1448287815,
-0.0976976529,
0.4776244462,
0.0960167944,
-0.6850582957,
0.0529105663,
-0.4194815755,
-0.1440459639,
0.4090239108,
0.1133747548,
-0.1270826161,
0.0033246435,
-0.7326829433,
-0.2147370726,
-0.5841506124,
0.022274591,
0.0467516109,
0.1201052964,
-0.1944568455,
0.4754357934,
-0.4483682811,
0.7623370886,
-0.5893190503,
-0.0930412561,
0.4493035674,
-0.3611456454,
-0.2424313873,
-0.2050636858,
0.6722281575,
0.7460702658,
0.0114644263,
-0.1984028965,
-0.3010202348,
-0.0856552795,
0.1047421992,
-1.0433992147,
0.0533298552,
0.2609199286,
-0.3459089696,
-0.0053336956,
-0.2350258231,
-0.9646915793,
-0.5054703355,
-0.2592794895,
0.4702223539,
-0.2602016032,
-0.197126016,
-0.1438143253,
-0.1827969253,
0.0890876725,
0.1545076221,
-0.460921675,
0.1612392515,
0.566403985,
1.0130764246,
-0.4530183375,
-0.8912419081,
-0.8882555366,
0.0249432679,
-0.3083340824,
0.7167171836,
-0.3393907845,
-0.1531656832,
-0.0731329545,
0.2137196809,
-0.1501062959,
-0.5855787396,
0.520966351,
-0.4563974142,
0.0921472535,
-0.3381678462,
-0.4968911409,
-0.0452595912,
0.6427518129,
-0.892375946,
1.0965825319,
0.3809035718,
-0.546257019,
0.4611863494,
-0.9288549423,
-0.3761795759,
-0.1468754113,
-0.1566145718,
-0.2965112925,
0.1746170968,
0.1302499175,
0.5764650106,
-0.3590599,
0.2125057131,
-0.6349775195,
-0.2900904119,
0.2321575284,
-0.6086090207,
0.3277517557,
0.1148100123,
-0.4032446444,
0.510209322,
-0.7095168233,
0.0906723142,
0.214265421,
-0.22506392,
-0.2664579749,
0.0222507007,
0.4507602453,
0.5263370872,
0.0585885048,
-0.6359741688,
-0.0459238701,
0.133727774,
0.3528227508,
0.6222302318,
-0.2114001513,
0.0575175025,
-0.2695021629,
0.4602828622,
0.1365284622,
0.2517378628,
-0.3089673221,
-0.1840398312,
-0.7313990593,
-0.2924805582,
0.0924104154,
0.1520534456,
-0.8245567679,
0.0312045552,
-0.5334985256,
-0.3706212342,
-0.2508999109,
0.2067214847,
0.4110143185,
0.4125887752,
0.5609757304,
-0.4081842005,
-0.319632858,
-1.1019920111,
-0.2170520872,
0.2723647952,
-0.1488189548,
0.5455390215,
0.6553148627,
-0.1891036928,
0.7638721466,
-0.2572484314,
-0.1104081571,
0.0064629144,
-0.0355301239,
-0.1010588035,
0.347589612,
0.620932281,
-0.7926687002,
-0.366699934,
-0.1557826698,
-0.7103178501,
0.2456031144,
-0.1772990376,
-0.0483306497,
0.499384433,
0.5247898698,
-0.640521884,
0.2400114089,
1.0426905155,
-0.3748573661,
0.8808016181,
-0.2528109848,
0.1809777915,
-0.8388858438,
0.4003922045,
-0.1642340273,
-0.4361101687,
-0.5571562648,
0.2249859422,
0.3938262463,
-0.1608824432,
-0.518953681,
0.6817643046,
-0.493231982,
-0.3685644269,
-0.2184890211,
0.1363429725,
0.1937689185,
0.4760860205,
-0.1123938635,
0.9231224656,
0.5081507564,
-0.4088401794,
0.535806179,
-0.189923048,
-0.7411835194,
0.7039028406,
-0.5888029933,
0.110044919,
0.0256979521,
0.4982038438,
-0.8087916374,
-0.2406722307,
-0.0202764794,
0.2302581668,
0.1730769277,
0.036525961,
-0.729249239,
-0.4988987744,
-0.322719872,
0.5750358701,
0.27790308,
-0.7125492096,
0.5633769631,
-0.0308109615,
0.0239731576,
-0.3948177397,
-0.3298340142,
0.3817438185,
-0.4537574053,
-0.565328002,
0.214912802,
-0.3425617814,
-0.0975118205,
-0.2478181422,
-0.1371565908,
0.1172753274,
0.0239523519,
0.4254076779,
0.0167827383,
-0.3513123989,
0.3619242907,
-0.2253918052,
0.0593463928,
0.0405217744,
-0.0506454781,
0.5950183868,
-0.5605632067,
-0.6712400317,
0.1551491916,
0.5189756155,
0.9020220637,
-0.5162298679,
0.6501829028,
0.9088503122,
-0.0495263487,
-0.1466713399,
-0.8764956594,
0.0369888917,
-0.4636913836,
0.5855725408,
-0.555662632,
-0.9831885695,
0.3059003949,
-0.3014924526,
-0.0243247021,
0.2700637281,
0.3365826011,
-0.1487994641,
0.726208806,
0.6177130342,
-0.2443164587,
0.2750570178,
0.0183073618,
-0.1451949626,
-0.9868757129,
0.0430318005,
-0.0645621791,
-0.2967563868,
-0.3895492554,
-0.7757644653,
0.4596320689,
0.14165245,
-0.3228668272,
0.1889204383,
-0.2249022573,
0.5480700731,
0.401343286,
0.1101453155,
0.1802303642,
-0.0871005729,
-0.0491127856,
0.2017164677,
-0.5870244503,
-0.3106349707,
1.0491684675,
0.3701459765,
0.21941787,
0.2674169242,
0.3568181396,
0.1883988976,
0.4614665508,
-0.5938289762,
0.5435268879,
0.0320532173,
-0.7000596523,
-0.3722985685,
-0.2200225592,
-0.9093725681,
0.5038795471,
-0.0057471539,
-0.511775732,
-0.047567714,
0.0275857914,
-0.2018021792,
0.3092079163,
-0.4554375112,
1.3031005859,
-0.6094518304,
-0.6933088303,
-0.2511553168,
-0.8235993385,
0.291852653,
-0.3501324654,
0.3581395447,
-0.4943316877,
-0.1442816257,
0.4948791564,
-0.060930308,
0.6932536364,
-0.311596483,
-0.0814859271,
0.0227713529,
0.005355373,
0.4784894884,
-0.287876159,
-0.0324698985,
0.3259829879,
0.2943860888,
-0.4933234751,
-0.3854846358,
0.8322723508,
-0.3971076906,
-0.3590152264,
-0.203239888,
-0.6324606538,
-0.5221137404,
0.4121813178,
-0.0432547964,
0.407151252,
-0.4818014801,
0.4168799222,
0.1241976023,
-0.1385515183,
0.6761291623,
0.4069538414,
-0.4993253052,
-0.2723731995,
0.8653227687,
-0.3479412198,
0.441429615,
0.028003931,
0.1306843907,
-0.3784530163,
-0.5896054506,
-0.8468292356,
0.0351841971,
-0.9226893783,
0.058592461,
-0.3253307641,
0.1327403188,
0.0328004844,
0.049310904,
-0.4835543334,
-0.2071425766,
0.0825067312,
0.3088136613,
0.1066230461,
0.4698688984,
0.2224280089,
-0.1639903784,
-0.9218166471,
0.2806307673,
0.2845837474,
0.7580850124,
0.0426571593,
-0.2072030008,
-0.3867044747,
-0.1295156777,
-0.180790171,
-0.44193995,
0.0518246852,
0.2110670507,
0.4772062302,
0.295764029,
-0.0235683694,
0.8918735385,
-0.7712230086,
0.8153633475,
0.2877118587,
-0.6772542,
0.0999271199,
-0.3559859693,
0.5451250076,
0.6443107724,
0.304084003,
-0.6074836254,
-0.1242149994,
-0.2303316295,
-0.7880319357,
0.2225766927,
0.2821837664,
0.1645030677,
0.1634479165,
-0.1090403497,
0.1142922863,
0.349306047,
-0.6131984591,
0.0868206248,
-0.3801716268,
-0.0213992614,
-0.5565344691,
-0.2540173233,
-0.4541154504,
-0.2264876366,
0.2446212023,
-0.341635108,
0.0138281388,
0.2549944818,
-0.2640951276,
0.0436943397,
0.4953792989,
1.1238284111,
0.9514719248,
-0.2126604915,
0.2269869447,
0.3731754422,
-0.1508901119,
-0.0752902552,
0.4970425963,
0.4420676231,
-0.00279212,
0.4645759165,
1.0144034624,
0.2258394659,
-1.0384575129,
0.5385520458,
0.1186483875,
-0.1784799248,
-0.3791956604,
-0.1460935622,
0.2928960919,
0.4732396603,
0.2414768636,
-0.0283418521,
0.0673235208,
-0.4260192811,
0.1377081126,
0.5288830996,
-0.1999463737,
-0.069713518,
0.5382889509,
0.2049388885,
-0.062940523,
0.5311826468,
-0.1386610121,
-0.3967165351,
0.6517823339,
0.4612458348,
0.7555032969,
0.1951336116,
-0.2579106987,
0.258073926,
0.1939481348,
-0.1281623989,
-0.0419648997,
-0.3821882308,
-0.4366488755,
-0.3920810819,
-0.7084396482,
-0.387630403,
0.2077326477,
-0.5587189794,
-0.115917936,
-0.1554395556,
-0.1708300859,
0.1557135433,
-0.2328581065,
-0.7519904375,
0.0461442508,
0.4309278429,
0.9085270762,
-0.4071224034,
0.8975721598,
0.4460644126,
-0.0156464968,
-0.4136965573,
-0.1410287619,
-0.0969659463,
-0.6065263748,
0.6277867556,
0.6813945174,
-0.2947873771,
-0.104411304,
-0.3643198609,
-0.8334228396,
1.3368983269,
-0.0396382809,
-0.8467195034,
0.1606441289,
0.2379120737,
0.512350738,
-0.45606637,
-0.0799687952,
0.5386881232,
0.685577333,
-0.1101044118,
-1.187812686,
0.2913167477,
-0.1776380688,
0.1284947544,
0.368735522,
-0.6672350764,
0.7296639681,
-0.224560976,
-0.106054917,
0.3244075775,
0.4547283947,
0.3938298225,
0.6617667675,
0.8188378811,
0.3728365898,
0.4292236269,
0.0941005126,
1.1663122177,
-0.4581568241,
0.3717472255,
1.3736201525,
-0.5568913817,
1.0940144062,
0.6499135494,
-0.2452072799,
0.4927008748,
0.4129627049,
-0.3196160495,
0.3822984695,
0.1931382567,
-0.5268637538,
-0.1919249147,
-0.0384553857,
-0.3722996414,
0.4016696513,
0.1604619175,
-0.3679462075,
-0.3358200192,
0.3073851466,
-0.251396805,
-0.3245161772,
-0.1304030418,
0.4401404262,
0.0160138048,
-0.824846983,
0.8064246774,
-0.1011433378,
0.5758584142,
-0.657822907,
0.1255201697,
-0.0353566445,
0.2589632273,
0.084158957,
-0.7349362969,
0.1548802257,
-0.0996654481,
-0.1131388694,
-0.033220429,
0.6773378849,
-0.4392938018,
-0.5034500957,
0.3726453483,
0.5223762989,
0.2082097381,
-0.5072056055,
-0.6982792616,
0.3654490709,
-0.1882464588,
-0.526268363,
0.5191906095,
0.0633036122,
-0.1987590641,
0.6783093214,
0.7561395764,
-0.3064312935,
0.006562287,
0.2613218427,
0.979450345,
-0.7760124803,
-0.1308151484,
-0.9756488204,
0.4812438488,
-0.2741049826,
-0.3677376211,
0.8722025752,
0.8121840954,
0.7295527458,
-0.1119596288,
0.6007305384,
0.0609137118,
0.1833096445,
-0.5347370505,
0.7644018531,
-0.8556187153,
-0.1129058674,
-0.0256722365,
-0.9011352658,
-0.2864905,
0.0456364751,
-0.1936797649,
0.1501665413,
0.9131349325,
0.6175356507,
-0.3026287258,
-0.1031632051,
0.5808619857,
-0.0296026729,
0.3116142452,
0.5712431073,
0.9534726143,
-0.1296271086,
0.6513524055,
-0.5191009045,
-0.0029021553,
-0.1054122448,
-1.2122919559,
-0.9842382073,
-0.5541975498,
0.0784751773,
-0.0999510661,
0.0442382433,
0.6409479976,
0.8564199805,
-0.5684812665,
-0.1742176861,
0.1201916933,
-0.3023571372,
-0.2754870653,
-0.1657754779,
0.500949502,
-0.093379207,
-0.4661976397,
0.6176970005,
0.3852028251,
0.0503920503,
-0.4285837114,
-0.1267162114,
0.1552010477,
-0.1939916462,
1.1375552416,
0.266902566,
-0.8183761239,
-0.3711256683,
-0.1554411799,
-0.0827459842,
0.0369678997,
0.772223115,
-0.7522220612,
0.6077846885,
0.0248167869,
0.5613910556,
0.7913820148,
-0.0173497982,
0.2513896227,
-0.8071334362,
0.2455023825,
0.210120827,
0.3553177714,
0.4971736968,
0.1973160654,
0.5472434163,
0.0008244819,
-0.6474497914,
-0.9054932594,
0.1721831411,
-1.1179808378,
-0.5210182667,
1.2008652687,
-0.0992025137,
0.005530857,
0.0268701911,
-0.0206222273,
-0.0809934884,
-0.0574944913,
0.5003284216,
0.7545664907,
-0.0918535069,
-0.2771238983,
-1.0444126129,
0.2337915897,
0.4397379756,
-0.871817112,
0.2809057236,
0.7945019603,
0.5104848742,
0.1081270054,
0.4551780522,
0.1819403768,
0.2487146854,
-0.0132111143,
0.0455921814,
-0.423173964,
-0.2979821563,
-0.2598338723,
0.3005024195,
0.1346838474,
-0.2297852486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01589v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01589v2
|
GPT-4 passes most of the 297 written Polish Board Certification Examinations
| 2024-04-29T09:08:22 | 2024-05-09T10:21:57 |
Jakub Pokrywka, Jeremi Kaczmarek, Edward Gorzelańczyk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Introduction: Recently, the effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) has
increased rapidly, allowing them to be used in a great number of applications.
However, the risks posed by the generation of false information through LLMs
significantly limit their applications in sensitive areas such as healthcare,
highlighting the necessity for rigorous validations to determine their utility
and reliability. To date, no study has extensively compared the performance of
LLMs on Polish medical examinations across a broad spectrum of specialties on a
very large dataset. Objectives: This study evaluated the performance of three
Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT) models on the Polish Board
Certification Exam (Pa\'nstwowy Egzamin Specjalizacyjny, PES) dataset, which
consists of 297 tests. Methods: We developed a software program to download and
process PES exams and tested the performance of GPT models using OpenAI
Application Programming Interface. Results: Our findings reveal that GPT-3.5
did not pass any of the analyzed exams. In contrast, the GPT-4 models
demonstrated the capability to pass the majority of the exams evaluated, with
the most recent model, gpt-4-0125, successfully passing 222 (75%) of them. The
performance of the GPT models varied significantly, displaying excellence in
exams related to certain specialties while completely failing others.
Conclusions: The significant progress and impressive performance of LLM models
hold great promise for the increased application of AI in the field of medicine
in Poland. For instance, this advancement could lead to the development of
AI-based medical assistants for healthcare professionals, enhancing the
efficiency and accuracy of medical services.
|
[
-0.3526858985,
-0.6306337714,
0.9569113255,
0.2748020589,
-0.3167443573,
-0.1121407226,
-0.1087000817,
-0.4032993317,
-0.2120925337,
0.4174990952,
-0.4301352799,
-0.7690171599,
-0.654923439,
0.3623070419,
-0.1868479103,
0.8464505672,
-0.3701461852,
0.4943378568,
0.0341420285,
0.4399598837,
-0.3429180682,
-0.6507354379,
-0.2486322075,
-0.5776311755,
-0.0881881416,
-0.0124887135,
0.5214360356,
-0.0507867299,
0.7251239419,
0.2983046174,
0.0112201329,
-0.1266515404,
-0.1476076096,
-0.1983941197,
0.0329528451,
-0.5461241007,
-0.6829534769,
0.299393028,
0.6911731958,
0.5439358354,
-0.3389935791,
-0.030102076,
-0.0679416209,
0.4706019461,
-0.1897470355,
0.3356452584,
-0.4514758289,
0.2641361654,
-0.269236356,
0.0783746317,
-0.6416683793,
-0.3809333742,
0.0376283675,
-0.6625234485,
0.2650008798,
-0.3010286093,
0.9680101275,
0.0658495948,
-0.3720859289,
-0.3414710462,
-0.7132522464,
0.5446444154,
-0.7208692431,
0.5413885713,
0.2214624435,
0.3157808483,
-0.1842263639,
-1.17007339,
-0.4338093102,
-0.3229190111,
0.1765474826,
0.4602602124,
-0.0345517434,
0.3574306369,
0.3284811676,
0.484300822,
-0.7726305127,
0.2113304138,
-0.5909188986,
-0.2303382307,
0.3477603793,
0.4568210542,
0.4346568286,
0.0506728068,
-0.4586139023,
-0.1091284081,
-0.8507871032,
-0.1413053572,
0.2726032436,
0.0881939456,
-0.1204524115,
0.4228340387,
0.0067345407,
0.7916660309,
-0.1004719958,
-0.3669194877,
0.5888194442,
-0.6166253686,
-0.3545352221,
-0.2680874765,
0.9756909013,
0.2623539865,
0.2264460474,
-0.1623521298,
0.0096875839,
0.1415513009,
0.3715251684,
-0.698043108,
-0.3241319954,
0.056470003,
-0.3973686993,
-0.2335257977,
0.1520652026,
-0.7859729528,
0.0504665151,
-0.3060306311,
0.5225518346,
-0.3112885654,
-0.0655373409,
0.5171243548,
0.2990139723,
0.7293945551,
0.4942270517,
-0.7971307635,
0.51084584,
0.679590404,
0.7579481006,
-0.4120341241,
-0.232523784,
-0.0001043173,
-0.2254700214,
-0.6478981376,
0.5543150306,
-0.3990077674,
-0.5239900351,
-0.1909483522,
0.1692554206,
-0.6577346921,
-0.4511407912,
0.7150822878,
-0.6374678612,
0.2923581898,
-0.0577501394,
-0.4436243176,
-0.0785018057,
0.4360985458,
-0.5801036358,
0.9062747359,
0.3606786728,
-0.5102344751,
0.4152654707,
-0.5238243937,
-0.4115173221,
0.1371591538,
-0.3686292768,
-0.6819152236,
-0.0501902476,
0.0462460034,
0.3592578769,
-0.454964608,
0.2515554428,
0.0276114941,
-0.6796502471,
-0.083869718,
-0.4191779792,
0.6588611007,
-0.06663654,
-0.4410081804,
0.1580210179,
-0.585285604,
0.194435209,
0.104985714,
-0.3895791769,
0.1755206883,
-0.3281661272,
-0.0944203585,
0.6144722104,
-0.0744312704,
-0.843177557,
0.3099446893,
-0.4899712801,
0.2394200265,
0.7122275829,
0.012630132,
-0.0751041248,
-0.1041133627,
0.9689264297,
-0.1615692377,
0.5649445057,
0.2442186326,
-1.1619595289,
-0.3060096502,
0.0120146452,
0.4571774304,
0.6797634363,
-0.6459525824,
0.5072583556,
-0.2160026431,
-0.7176320553,
-0.5108652115,
-0.0421615504,
0.3081760108,
0.8204631805,
0.2804800868,
0.0047231955,
-0.17081438,
-0.8626193404,
-0.1347390264,
-0.0741830021,
-0.1721660942,
0.1591773778,
0.6003193259,
-0.1838222891,
0.3813965023,
-0.4275457263,
-0.468472302,
-0.4467693567,
-0.1671935916,
0.5964865088,
0.3290965259,
0.6454789639,
-0.6396787167,
-0.8428192139,
-0.0740340427,
-0.5170646906,
-0.0328184254,
0.2080273479,
-0.0532388203,
0.1240993515,
0.124156788,
-0.5708596706,
0.4907393157,
0.8001936078,
-0.5692713261,
0.741614759,
-0.4920227826,
0.3056041598,
-0.5747991204,
0.060747195,
-0.2803985775,
-0.178228274,
-0.7921591401,
-0.1248387396,
0.2360404134,
-0.2801094949,
-0.5601528287,
0.3737198114,
-0.2870109379,
-0.0788460225,
0.0682071447,
-0.1718634218,
-0.0258801412,
0.4176219702,
-0.0977749825,
0.9277603626,
0.6631149054,
-0.3344610631,
0.2518291473,
0.5797111988,
-0.5137377381,
0.1471992433,
-0.6272400618,
0.0886700898,
0.3219681084,
0.064189516,
-0.8839033246,
-0.1658385694,
0.1349544674,
-0.2123879939,
0.3955814242,
0.0625458509,
-0.6127822995,
-0.766456604,
-0.1549780071,
-0.0309482049,
0.9289450049,
-0.3772196472,
0.804669559,
0.0542125255,
-0.1566414684,
-0.312559098,
-0.8277081847,
-0.1112423837,
0.0460930243,
-0.7416236401,
0.2914829552,
-0.0647585616,
0.0793823525,
-0.303704381,
-0.0087731183,
-0.0431877859,
0.0779837593,
0.2086611688,
0.6527600884,
-0.2269663811,
-0.1798918396,
-0.1402758211,
-0.2552623451,
0.2543700933,
0.0472325832,
0.6555237174,
-0.4736678302,
-0.7303555012,
-0.7388227582,
0.1279595792,
0.8215765357,
-0.141178593,
0.768909812,
0.4523634911,
-0.0608670935,
0.2511118948,
-0.7345122695,
0.0378271639,
-0.4869496524,
0.512535274,
-0.5560573936,
-0.6904010177,
0.6495552063,
-0.0678938702,
-0.2051356882,
0.714204371,
0.7657954693,
0.0956107304,
1.0993336439,
0.2886300385,
0.0910877511,
0.1261376441,
-0.1872229129,
0.350781709,
-0.8048121929,
-0.2610708773,
-0.343685627,
0.1039440706,
-0.7790750861,
-0.3926297426,
0.818235755,
-0.1972813457,
-0.3445791602,
-0.2731011212,
-0.5386664867,
0.4238066375,
0.4422670603,
0.3502233922,
0.4194351435,
-0.076604791,
-0.147957623,
-0.1342378557,
-0.6915409565,
-0.6634258032,
1.5880175829,
0.4528321326,
0.633084178,
-0.0362851359,
0.5436159372,
-0.1589864939,
0.7340963483,
-0.5650507808,
0.4102776349,
-0.4650344849,
-0.619495213,
-0.4101592004,
-0.2760516405,
-0.6791079044,
0.3231865168,
0.111370869,
-0.3997096121,
0.0829387382,
0.0546360873,
-0.3550428152,
0.5727983117,
-0.6108438373,
1.0012383461,
-0.2933607399,
-0.1366069168,
0.2179121524,
-0.689031601,
0.4977889359,
-0.6621231437,
0.0663337409,
-0.050778389,
-0.1177470982,
0.8311058283,
-0.3891138136,
0.5878170729,
-0.374371171,
-0.0596479997,
0.1691407114,
-0.2190224975,
0.5089453459,
-0.1881185472,
-0.3936777115,
0.4225580096,
0.0300981943,
-0.2114233524,
-0.3732101321,
0.4995253384,
-0.8924779296,
-0.6090374589,
-0.4016325772,
-0.186092034,
-0.5933541656,
0.3830758035,
0.6167587638,
0.3959865272,
-0.1913550049,
-0.1557580829,
0.6411135197,
-0.3327258229,
0.1692940146,
0.6522676945,
0.0230431333,
-0.4352503717,
0.3461900055,
0.1338507384,
0.4686277509,
-0.118846342,
0.2473077327,
-0.3161928952,
-0.8313129544,
-0.4511975944,
0.6145736575,
-0.8393056989,
-0.0787634403,
-0.5289685726,
-0.331356436,
-0.3288640976,
-0.021217037,
-0.4965788722,
0.0430091284,
-0.0533862449,
-0.2095913887,
0.1038769186,
1.0057730675,
0.3007416725,
0.3007992506,
-0.5811223984,
0.1099868044,
0.1522518545,
0.6748220325,
-0.2420762628,
-0.5203214288,
0.1097483858,
-0.3778790534,
-0.5079041123,
-0.8897548914,
0.2883524597,
0.0234501641,
0.7833614945,
0.1779871434,
-0.1788583696,
0.4272836447,
-0.8004351258,
1.07929492,
0.1976426989,
-1.0001164675,
0.4319704175,
-0.4798989594,
0.1402901709,
0.7608370185,
0.396661073,
-0.0503262281,
-0.2738032043,
-0.6119244099,
-0.6349258423,
0.7017728686,
0.2323525399,
0.1378518045,
0.0381022133,
0.5292075276,
0.0936917141,
0.0012814694,
-0.827364862,
-0.1818423271,
-0.0715500042,
-0.2525759637,
-0.0819715485,
-0.2925992608,
-0.0200609732,
-0.2590785325,
0.8526167274,
0.1283701509,
0.4159311056,
0.3661418259,
0.1892355084,
0.1110759676,
0.4054657221,
0.8673040271,
0.9152400494,
-0.1440256089,
-0.2351935953,
0.2036917359,
-1.1904345751,
0.4553955197,
0.0795796365,
0.0073233615,
0.1736273915,
0.4320009053,
0.5723335743,
0.1103652194,
-0.4561766684,
0.9523174167,
-0.1458678842,
-0.7387679815,
-0.4393634796,
-0.0353777297,
-0.0394647717,
-0.0925388262,
0.1379634291,
-0.2544196546,
0.0292036701,
-0.3623087108,
0.2204166949,
0.1300414503,
-0.2763015926,
-0.4327282608,
0.6442883611,
0.0905676559,
0.0119335363,
0.9905447364,
0.1041992605,
-0.7241566181,
0.6365867257,
0.6753627658,
0.4941365123,
-0.7312381268,
-0.1532974094,
0.3615225852,
0.4093041122,
-0.4346804619,
0.7169790864,
0.2657856643,
-0.5792533159,
-0.6918835044,
-0.5071639419,
-0.5556071401,
0.3868289888,
-0.7464332581,
0.1663322449,
-0.3277799189,
-0.4908219278,
-0.4784012735,
-0.0252096727,
-0.8318862319,
0.3296927214,
0.1045507267,
0.994894743,
-1.2469286919,
0.8276691437,
0.5418644547,
-0.3757455051,
-1.1623401642,
-0.1327976584,
-0.3881253302,
-0.8752744198,
0.7978704572,
-0.0389444977,
0.2123274803,
-0.0360664092,
-0.067367129,
-0.7341079116,
1.131611228,
0.4311349094,
-0.7346788049,
-0.3973553479,
0.4008838534,
0.6073733568,
-0.0742586777,
0.331759423,
0.6722590923,
0.5780447125,
-0.0783050358,
-1.5317708254,
-0.1259239614,
-0.2803262472,
-0.1048850119,
0.2083280981,
-0.4937267303,
1.0632549524,
0.0527780503,
0.1524309963,
0.0277483277,
-0.0088521596,
0.6588714123,
0.1963338852,
0.2869750857,
0.5510590076,
0.6303796172,
-0.353253454,
1.4122519493,
-0.4864833057,
0.4029681087,
0.8252686858,
-0.5793204308,
0.5945757627,
0.2649878561,
-0.7391218543,
0.5308927894,
0.508074522,
-0.2692634761,
0.4076518118,
0.1367779821,
-0.2124756873,
-0.3992502987,
0.5228654742,
-0.5837582946,
0.3961016834,
0.3849887848,
-0.5805740952,
-0.1586349458,
0.4568365216,
-0.200835377,
-0.1966729164,
-0.4442383051,
0.5630998015,
0.0983408168,
-0.5558421612,
0.2864429653,
-0.2519516647,
0.4145566225,
-0.8627466559,
-0.1170625687,
-0.0381764323,
0.3105864227,
-0.1996773779,
-0.8025661111,
0.2291378528,
0.0540056191,
0.0592661649,
-0.3211197555,
0.6231709123,
0.0257688407,
-0.6349961758,
0.1831586212,
0.4066070616,
0.4835824072,
0.0609246157,
-0.646441102,
0.0189463049,
-0.0558398254,
-0.3699957132,
0.2301063389,
0.0972850621,
-0.0715991557,
0.5377246141,
0.2990724444,
0.509408772,
0.1228581965,
0.3378718495,
0.8239132166,
-0.3134163618,
-0.8230903745,
-0.8053283691,
0.2413230985,
0.1749874502,
-0.1079152077,
0.7887150049,
0.6653572321,
0.642596364,
-0.3785915375,
0.6648208499,
0.5224142671,
0.5667480826,
-0.758394599,
0.7529487014,
-0.0458479896,
0.2463996857,
-0.363607645,
-0.5926525593,
-0.4230757654,
0.6728906035,
-0.7575519085,
0.3282036185,
0.6752011776,
0.4023286104,
-0.0241789389,
0.0301396567,
0.6299934983,
0.1377928704,
0.4524537027,
0.8170969486,
0.7363550067,
-0.6273428202,
0.285551548,
-0.1714969873,
-0.1844551414,
0.1013576314,
-0.512194097,
-0.7465919852,
-0.1767013669,
-0.2563070953,
-0.3276167214,
0.0254532751,
0.535107255,
0.6369722486,
-0.7934679389,
0.0972657204,
-0.1542120129,
-0.4408360422,
0.0241819918,
-0.1532087475,
0.8707197309,
-0.1100041866,
-0.4064724147,
0.3744888604,
0.0605471618,
0.3483570218,
-0.1559495479,
-0.1010608897,
0.1682966053,
-0.1339822114,
0.3104024827,
-0.1907095909,
-0.8532822132,
0.0360033549,
0.0474645235,
-0.151203528,
0.3945131004,
0.815948844,
-0.686402142,
0.5694465041,
0.475350678,
0.2520025373,
0.5366124511,
0.0491363369,
0.5277656913,
-0.0305145998,
0.0832060724,
0.4284866452,
0.4702766538,
0.1485428959,
-0.4906181097,
0.5630882382,
0.2945999801,
-0.5847197175,
-0.729399085,
-0.2386220545,
-0.7264309525,
-0.1820201427,
0.9020586014,
-0.3866214752,
-0.0857106224,
-0.2920995057,
0.1175446808,
0.168146506,
0.1633191705,
0.4570783675,
0.810597837,
-0.5972795486,
0.1336693317,
-1.0323454142,
0.5894694328,
0.4409720302,
-0.9893228412,
-0.1414776891,
0.1096502841,
0.8441621661,
0.0206619967,
1.0213500261,
-0.8199390173,
0.5501778126,
-0.134819597,
0.2345708013,
-0.2645592988,
-0.042462483,
-0.6450316906,
0.2759326398,
0.1039085165,
-0.1241760924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18518v1
|
From ChatGPT, DALL-E 3 to Sora: How has Generative AI Changed Digital Humanities Research and Services?
| 2024-04-29T09:03:19 | 2024-04-29T09:03:19 |
Jiangfeng Liu, Ziyi Wang, Jing Xie, Lei Pei
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Generative large-scale language models create the fifth paradigm of
scientific research, organically combine data science and computational
intelligence, transform the research paradigm of natural language processing
and multimodal information processing, promote the new trend of AI-enabled
social science research, and provide new ideas for digital humanities research
and application. This article profoundly explores the application of
large-scale language models in digital humanities research, revealing their
significant potential in ancient book protection, intelligent processing, and
academic innovation. The article first outlines the importance of ancient book
resources and the necessity of digital preservation, followed by a detailed
introduction to developing large-scale language models, such as ChatGPT, and
their applications in document management, content understanding, and
cross-cultural research. Through specific cases, the article demonstrates how
AI can assist in the organization, classification, and content generation of
ancient books. Then, it explores the prospects of AI applications in artistic
innovation and cultural heritage preservation. Finally, the article explores
the challenges and opportunities in the interaction of technology, information,
and society in the digital humanities triggered by AI technologies.
|
[
-0.6008697748,
-1.0084981918,
0.3123700619,
-0.40445894,
0.0870165154,
0.0905851871,
-0.2032453418,
-0.7391134501,
-0.2359317094,
0.5106949806,
-0.4801568985,
-0.0225901641,
-0.5050755143,
0.1474582553,
-0.8328667283,
1.191360116,
0.2355228513,
0.2845770419,
-0.0826100335,
-0.0302220378,
-0.0639233589,
-0.5382791758,
-0.7223056555,
-0.206168592,
0.3160247505,
0.2118745148,
0.9921056032,
0.5276879668,
0.8687708974,
0.4484139681,
-0.1352539361,
0.0060823625,
-0.3634388447,
0.2044345289,
0.0505353846,
-0.6633117795,
-0.4702178836,
0.107363157,
0.7541436553,
0.3402779698,
-0.2210983485,
0.0413181074,
-0.1052460596,
0.8792960644,
-0.2569784224,
0.2735143602,
-0.2714262903,
0.0503314398,
-0.5632260442,
-0.2841885388,
-0.4091949761,
-0.5034017563,
0.2693361938,
-0.8604230881,
0.3701701164,
0.2554035187,
0.663117528,
0.2871161103,
-0.016603509,
-0.4587533474,
-1.2230992317,
0.7600208521,
-0.6590837836,
0.2441666722,
0.6084079742,
0.3553588986,
-0.215552628,
-0.8602436781,
-1.2369940281,
-0.2362554371,
0.309779793,
0.1198410019,
-0.320546329,
-0.0637309924,
0.2792256773,
0.7686961889,
-0.5763982534,
0.2713370621,
-0.5106146336,
0.1720077544,
0.7543259263,
0.2994766533,
0.8500851393,
0.0665773526,
0.0853209049,
-0.2646102607,
-0.709148705,
-0.2598834932,
0.2439896613,
-0.1448165625,
0.0610957034,
0.6590039134,
0.1976703852,
0.5366669297,
-0.1871507019,
-0.1103110388,
-0.1079471484,
-0.3800331652,
-0.1158218384,
-0.1476115286,
0.7824004292,
0.1601198465,
0.3450828791,
-0.0199330971,
0.234164983,
0.2939963937,
0.2302392125,
-0.618416667,
-0.3373486102,
0.0191180836,
-0.5889536142,
-0.160813719,
-0.2544082403,
-0.6067883968,
-0.9381641746,
-0.3359119594,
-0.1082832217,
-0.6879339218,
-0.5092334151,
0.2767600417,
-0.2059371471,
0.4446166456,
0.420194298,
-1.1553912163,
0.1146339178,
0.8269878626,
0.7819744349,
-0.0297921114,
-0.4819535315,
0.147151649,
0.2378348261,
-0.4122128189,
0.7606704235,
-0.5657294989,
-0.4315749109,
0.2346410304,
-0.217566967,
0.3146091998,
-0.4291900694,
0.6421060562,
-0.8577762246,
0.1631193161,
-0.020983668,
-0.3315448463,
-0.3353921175,
0.3720685244,
-1.0299909115,
0.8642134666,
-0.0972724706,
-0.811362803,
0.0799886808,
-0.9198794961,
-0.256097585,
0.4412936866,
-0.0864608809,
-0.6464326978,
0.1020974517,
-0.1496894062,
0.2306955755,
-0.9270446897,
0.2814331651,
-0.3049489558,
-0.2200169712,
0.4299184382,
-0.4885237813,
0.9152562022,
0.2914479077,
-0.3395832777,
0.0507082008,
-0.655738771,
-0.2288212925,
0.2420698702,
-0.3289766014,
-0.4586637616,
0.211148724,
0.4739136696,
-0.059247613,
0.1154381111,
-0.3732428551,
0.4578268826,
-0.2159416527,
0.9261310697,
0.6152136922,
-0.6273832917,
0.5716212392,
-0.5792499781,
0.3615141213,
-0.3011138439,
0.104649201,
-0.222260192,
-0.5573071241,
-0.6996213198,
-0.2683481872,
0.3575837016,
0.2816118896,
-0.980399549,
0.0903589353,
-0.324532032,
-0.7305051684,
-0.6627392173,
-0.4426966906,
-0.1021939889,
-0.0862913728,
0.1376947016,
-0.1574508399,
-0.3821184039,
-0.4537824988,
-0.031677641,
-0.4173586071,
-0.0217381064,
0.1109511554,
0.3075868189,
-0.3665315509,
0.8165374398,
-0.1222260445,
-0.2606888711,
-0.1075445935,
0.4635170996,
-0.1949521005,
0.3350884318,
0.3043753803,
-1.3321448565,
-0.2265107036,
0.2270552367,
-0.8773567677,
0.1019525155,
-0.0027288946,
0.0494064651,
0.455550164,
0.445030421,
-0.7438479066,
0.3208931386,
0.5975946188,
-0.3109437525,
0.5894563794,
-0.292198807,
0.4053047001,
-1.0957219601,
0.0901511982,
-0.1600477844,
0.3654372096,
-0.7683871388,
0.2543087006,
-0.1333358735,
-0.3541708291,
-0.0645673871,
0.6177412271,
-0.4871392846,
-0.0583818704,
-0.5076226592,
-0.0813030154,
-0.29572317,
-0.0199467372,
0.0977938473,
0.7854567766,
0.4919888675,
-0.4784067273,
0.2954279184,
0.4252455831,
-0.4300708473,
0.3946296573,
-0.2012533695,
0.2931108177,
-0.2044161409,
0.3357570469,
-0.6971556544,
-0.1444071531,
0.1136631593,
-0.2935435474,
0.0915463045,
0.2788591981,
-0.7523764968,
-0.3818489015,
-0.3748804629,
0.790882349,
0.3847027421,
-0.1712451726,
0.8432663083,
0.6407274008,
-0.7359322906,
-0.306425333,
-0.5370811224,
0.3255146742,
-0.3143354058,
-0.6498592496,
0.4802872241,
-0.4666368067,
-0.4364582896,
0.0324817263,
0.2833094895,
-0.0917382464,
0.1718871593,
0.2039049715,
0.5901874304,
-0.2642311752,
0.0044255392,
-0.37195158,
-0.129777953,
-0.0504405797,
-0.3600035012,
0.8604177833,
-0.2046196908,
-0.3250587285,
-0.6154739261,
0.4270936847,
0.9976247549,
-0.3480359018,
0.7358000875,
0.5858290195,
-0.2907957435,
0.1653415859,
-0.7195607424,
-0.1066134125,
-0.4400611818,
0.3076865375,
-0.0710167885,
-1.1194652319,
0.3025674522,
-0.0376446322,
0.1657558531,
0.5910188556,
0.790966928,
-0.1620660573,
0.7155097127,
0.7523415089,
-0.2934474349,
0.866358459,
-0.5159259439,
0.5534624457,
-0.6169020534,
-0.0635789335,
-0.8593478799,
-0.169322595,
-0.8887687922,
-0.1520676017,
0.5688384771,
-0.0543692186,
-0.4007943273,
-0.1440573186,
-0.5014249682,
0.1902275532,
0.7252616882,
-0.2088645846,
0.593937099,
0.2375690192,
0.6711000204,
0.1692046076,
-0.6553729177,
-0.766728878,
1.0435106754,
0.3287795484,
0.8201962709,
0.1098295897,
0.2153591365,
0.8323631883,
0.4571459591,
-0.6800442338,
0.4660487473,
-0.2336420268,
-0.5415573716,
-0.7435904145,
0.0137710497,
-0.8371354938,
-0.1824437082,
-0.1865589321,
-0.3002861738,
0.145803228,
-0.1447634399,
-0.3572220206,
0.2721834183,
-0.3449249864,
0.4328816533,
-0.1698566228,
-0.1542244554,
-0.6636523008,
-0.338547945,
0.0692034811,
-0.0895297006,
0.4747208357,
0.0299088173,
0.3840713799,
0.6570814848,
0.1425958872,
0.6326366067,
0.3049307764,
-0.22522223,
0.428283006,
0.2268126458,
0.4085664451,
-0.3098226786,
-0.30887869,
0.3784262836,
0.1940442175,
-0.232132107,
-0.3159406483,
0.4915034175,
-1.067561388,
-0.7664923072,
-0.4293221533,
-0.8512573838,
0.1373405606,
0.1307742298,
-0.0302969925,
0.1741622239,
-0.4282747209,
0.1465148628,
0.5996385813,
-0.2531098127,
0.587711215,
0.3969734609,
0.2012183368,
-0.0609722137,
0.8928987384,
0.1898654252,
0.0527313724,
0.2699050307,
0.1855246425,
-0.0615986288,
-0.736355722,
-0.6101127863,
0.0186453816,
-0.5352060795,
-0.0082337689,
-0.5997450352,
-0.3917738199,
-0.3219810128,
-0.3337234259,
-0.0808834359,
-0.2159481496,
-0.2043756843,
0.1863933504,
0.4851905107,
0.9439228773,
0.007701003,
0.2651612461,
-0.7234823704,
0.2711126804,
0.279153198,
0.0660898834,
0.3199873567,
-0.1060980335,
-0.2469868064,
-0.0390362702,
-0.3215753734,
-0.4879774451,
0.3285652697,
0.1300613284,
0.2558317184,
0.3776347935,
-0.0667959824,
0.1849271208,
-0.8394402266,
0.7989663482,
0.1292169094,
-0.541087985,
0.0614031292,
-0.698294282,
0.0522808395,
-0.0043756794,
0.3829612136,
-0.7689721584,
-0.1519844383,
-0.4600922465,
-0.7867153883,
0.7262991071,
0.0659435019,
0.3547008336,
0.2601692975,
0.0636433139,
0.2631580532,
0.0419298895,
-0.8300671577,
-0.0737821758,
-0.2248424292,
-0.1382095814,
0.0795014501,
-0.4291390181,
-0.0973456576,
-0.0594524145,
0.8032326102,
-0.0620481074,
0.1120257974,
-0.1770450771,
0.2063441575,
0.0541231334,
0.5039083958,
0.2725927234,
0.3860058784,
0.4080447555,
-0.0142230252,
-0.2383509874,
-0.6735159159,
0.032415837,
0.4235285819,
-0.58209306,
-0.4862924516,
0.2011296302,
0.5383771658,
-0.386046946,
-0.5791046619,
-0.0354871489,
-0.0230640527,
0.0643698499,
-0.7926458716,
-0.0070973388,
0.0908847526,
0.6581463218,
0.4592846334,
-0.0683395043,
0.3208830655,
-0.9886605144,
-0.226712063,
0.5159395933,
0.0691237226,
-0.0849209353,
0.5959106684,
-0.0057168691,
-0.4818875194,
0.8109596968,
0.1510226876,
-0.311673969,
0.5601830482,
0.6320653558,
0.713132143,
-0.1848311126,
0.3718500137,
-0.0761177316,
0.0648740381,
-0.2264059037,
0.0259444639,
-0.0759808272,
-0.8476637006,
-0.0844401941,
-0.7626896501,
-0.3382364213,
0.1109524146,
-0.1102878004,
0.1842567623,
-0.300126493,
-0.1859674007,
0.3832431138,
-0.14236103,
-0.5895419121,
0.0100604445,
0.3980509639,
0.5404322147,
-0.5570399761,
0.7729086876,
0.6576824784,
-0.545689404,
-0.5518965721,
0.1135461852,
0.0811809674,
-0.5447039008,
0.6339203715,
-0.3444255292,
-0.1295105666,
0.3743336499,
-0.6607582569,
-0.840921104,
1.0072809458,
0.1908585727,
-0.4224776924,
-0.2434534878,
0.1703046709,
0.8242806196,
0.0196143799,
0.4834513664,
0.674787879,
0.493632257,
0.0662379339,
-0.9463313222,
-0.3005715907,
-0.541862309,
0.2337719351,
0.0870391577,
-0.5003777742,
0.8221845627,
0.0416897982,
-0.259306252,
0.5841141939,
0.5811128616,
0.3623142838,
0.2761644125,
-0.0157098509,
0.4039703906,
0.6466293931,
-0.2044498324,
1.3414510489,
-0.148957327,
0.1081699133,
0.3934209943,
-0.2718133926,
0.6056312919,
0.0730095655,
-0.2339717895,
0.5602837801,
0.5908529758,
-0.32623896,
0.3139359355,
0.2706211507,
-0.7176430225,
0.2136582732,
-0.6237015724,
-0.4915063977,
0.4219706655,
0.5006455183,
-0.0238225348,
0.1045056358,
0.4136510491,
0.2178773284,
0.1709003896,
-0.4883716702,
0.8956276774,
-0.090777196,
-0.5738067627,
0.4132574499,
0.2328851074,
0.5506079197,
-0.4581421912,
-0.1375421584,
-0.1358105242,
0.2256403118,
-0.0724196956,
-0.5128061771,
0.0944876224,
-0.0744777098,
-0.4376029372,
-0.2100092769,
0.6136685014,
-0.0973342583,
-0.4875962734,
0.0346407592,
0.3842243552,
0.0936188698,
0.0486500822,
-0.393268317,
0.1978032738,
-0.3324021101,
-0.1459589303,
0.2517123818,
0.685266912,
-0.4864640832,
0.773825109,
0.8010314703,
0.2521322966,
-0.0556428954,
0.1339485645,
0.8868073225,
-0.6713454127,
-0.4207424521,
-0.997852087,
0.2124341577,
0.1288396567,
-0.0957590789,
0.5605854392,
0.3558944464,
0.9711507559,
-0.0477015749,
1.1922031641,
-0.4724959135,
0.0853790119,
-0.388047874,
1.1966797113,
-0.2817187011,
-0.1685691923,
-0.3499623835,
-0.7707105875,
-0.3669334054,
0.329125613,
-0.5170273185,
0.027678594,
0.5487120748,
0.5717402101,
0.1994373351,
0.4983413815,
0.2362467349,
0.412419796,
0.4509396255,
-0.098693274,
1.1372562647,
-0.2361263335,
0.3125226796,
0.3831216395,
-0.3343953788,
-0.1839185506,
-0.5236256123,
-0.7378706932,
-1.103728652,
-0.1198749393,
-0.2188803554,
0.1658013612,
0.629832387,
0.4001506567,
-0.8472261429,
-0.304444164,
-0.0960838497,
-0.1885293573,
-0.1975293458,
-0.150758639,
0.6303062439,
-0.0130361896,
-0.9816312194,
0.0533869192,
0.3948863447,
0.1370326579,
-0.6634786725,
-0.0227333866,
-0.1582807302,
-0.09490484,
0.6385340095,
0.4850221574,
-0.8329820633,
0.0577668548,
-0.0108245322,
-0.1980773956,
-0.0541730672,
1.0252498388,
-0.4921113253,
0.4152725339,
0.4537568688,
0.9747434855,
0.5903041363,
-0.3053185344,
0.7083148956,
0.3255500495,
0.0944864899,
0.4475044608,
0.3086987436,
0.4920969307,
-0.2183849663,
0.6038824916,
0.1897700131,
-0.7798163295,
-0.6912151575,
0.2761039138,
-0.4877203107,
-0.340198487,
0.8582445979,
0.0022088666,
-0.1116774231,
-0.3273543417,
-0.5345218778,
0.4918668866,
-0.0025329522,
1.5858405828,
0.9488093853,
0.007875016,
-0.5973876715,
-0.8800536394,
0.7500003576,
0.3477924466,
-0.9990874529,
0.0798653886,
0.6524358988,
-0.2726010084,
0.4352704287,
0.7082660794,
-0.3365266621,
0.2484877557,
-0.1573815197,
0.4256001413,
-0.0130397147,
-0.3129473031,
-0.1564754248,
0.19706361,
0.3717571795,
0.2154054344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18510v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18510v2
|
Explainability of machine learning approaches in forensic linguistics: a case study in geolinguistic authorship profiling
| 2024-04-29T08:52:52 | 2024-07-01T15:58:11 |
Dana Roemling, Yves Scherrer, Aleksandra Miletic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Forensic authorship profiling uses linguistic markers to infer
characteristics about an author of a text. This task is paralleled in dialect
classification, where a prediction is made about the linguistic variety of a
text based on the text itself. While there have been significant advances in
recent years in variety classification, forensic linguistics rarely relies on
these approaches due to their lack of transparency, among other reasons. In
this paper we therefore explore the explainability of machine learning
approaches considering the forensic context. We focus on variety classification
as a means of geolinguistic profiling of unknown texts based on social media
data from the German-speaking area. For this, we identify the lexical items
that are the most impactful for the variety classification. We find that the
extracted lexical features are indeed representative of their respective
varieties and note that the trained models also rely on place names for
classifications.
|
[
-0.5264953971,
-0.7932613492,
0.8463841677,
-0.138196677,
-0.109954372,
0.2353642583,
-0.4944011867,
-0.6335858107,
0.1033431217,
0.5004613996,
-0.4905384183,
-0.7491865754,
-0.8498555422,
0.133754611,
-0.7871164083,
1.1563109159,
0.106050618,
0.1827296168,
0.1055767462,
-0.5691791773,
-0.1550614238,
-0.9349822402,
-0.293679446,
-0.1252046227,
0.3816284835,
0.0961483493,
0.7609318495,
0.8414123654,
0.5187877417,
0.4303609729,
-0.0865086392,
-0.0562123805,
-0.4928520024,
0.1571168303,
-0.2197594494,
-0.5893518925,
0.3654170036,
0.0780820921,
0.1691299081,
1.1694668531,
-0.0164362676,
-0.0301722456,
-0.0849758834,
0.5679056644,
-0.6907122731,
-0.1035212502,
-0.7270448208,
-0.0146101136,
-0.3893717527,
-0.1214010343,
-0.4186266661,
-0.4446778297,
0.3561009765,
-0.631778717,
0.9843320847,
-0.0236416273,
0.7690646648,
0.0133671761,
-0.2479498982,
-0.6207899451,
-1.0615856647,
0.6216897964,
-0.1960717142,
0.1791941822,
0.6652629375,
0.7136670351,
-0.029922897,
-0.5256509185,
-0.4242446125,
-0.1802666783,
-0.5376377106,
-0.3210018873,
-0.0523318388,
0.0000036791,
0.2644690573,
0.6504345536,
-0.5545463562,
0.2672596276,
-0.2049890161,
-0.297075808,
0.7814250588,
-0.0247470792,
0.3155389726,
-0.0362339169,
0.0509867109,
0.1369140595,
-0.5246811509,
0.2812093496,
0.7119018435,
0.5294178128,
-0.1607731581,
0.2873760462,
-0.2862280905,
0.5952678919,
-0.1033125371,
-0.1406796426,
0.3729777038,
-0.1604784727,
-0.1093686223,
0.1100381538,
0.8736758828,
-0.1271260232,
0.2765264511,
-0.2896763682,
0.1100145802,
-0.3018735945,
0.275131464,
-0.5535876155,
-0.4834961593,
0.3871769011,
-0.5632761717,
-0.3360320628,
0.320192188,
-0.6078823209,
-0.7898753285,
-0.0249303691,
0.2110876143,
-0.7388713956,
-0.2918551564,
-0.0234502517,
-0.2566921115,
0.0764378607,
0.4634603858,
-1.0012466908,
0.1429684609,
0.8176531196,
0.8047807813,
-0.1184038669,
-0.2347632647,
-0.5156471133,
-0.2258736044,
-0.1730125397,
0.5785404444,
-0.4173276424,
-0.2878356278,
0.0954367518,
0.1632235795,
0.1428561956,
-0.6039946079,
0.2402410209,
-0.6382753253,
0.4204071462,
-0.108544074,
-0.4197814465,
-0.8503246307,
-0.124327153,
-0.7227445245,
0.9141834974,
0.2901875973,
-0.9581262469,
0.6793674231,
-0.4676490128,
-0.7053280473,
0.3403187096,
-0.1003294364,
-0.6103397608,
0.1471907496,
-0.0004106627,
0.7932686806,
0.1281097084,
0.6948593855,
-0.5238313079,
-0.1522373408,
0.5518416762,
-0.3213894963,
1.2387422323,
0.3483155668,
-0.6565288305,
-0.3106941879,
-1.0408530235,
-0.3857446015,
0.1585069001,
-0.2055870146,
-0.4953226149,
0.1590024829,
0.0799384266,
-0.2157268822,
0.006538447,
-0.604165554,
-0.3504039943,
-0.3255097568,
0.2524715662,
0.2848899364,
-0.1143057197,
0.4887380004,
-0.386164099,
0.5664820671,
-0.0657524392,
-0.3120581806,
-0.2082372755,
-0.4468138516,
-0.4493731856,
-0.6134867668,
0.6668406129,
0.7197562456,
-0.5382709503,
0.4114915431,
-0.243947953,
-0.7977702618,
-0.6617540717,
0.1504500508,
0.336932838,
0.4379369915,
0.1491437256,
-0.1067994758,
-0.7884492874,
-1.1078531742,
-0.6765412688,
-0.217148602,
-0.306578666,
0.57425493,
0.408721447,
0.1214587763,
1.137745142,
-0.0566447005,
0.1748025119,
-0.4041674435,
0.4505895674,
0.196565792,
0.3565567732,
0.6958936453,
-1.0618706942,
-0.3886139691,
0.3252860904,
-1.0544087887,
-0.0751218423,
-0.0707811788,
0.2357188612,
0.1538487077,
0.3288992345,
-0.1763527542,
0.6120997667,
0.1637187898,
-0.2088460773,
0.6767487526,
0.0260457452,
0.1468098015,
-0.8213270307,
-0.0499426275,
0.0379948765,
-0.5463973284,
-1.0523862839,
-0.0146754598,
-0.2117453218,
0.0331483893,
-0.47598809,
0.0582112297,
-0.2791913152,
-0.2123155296,
-0.0865464583,
0.0392138138,
-0.4233028591,
0.1699089408,
0.0740797967,
0.4528580606,
0.7114788294,
-0.5615779757,
0.2682124972,
-0.0180187374,
-0.6011555791,
0.3921057284,
-0.1596235335,
-0.0498309806,
-0.3537676632,
-0.0228364524,
-1.2124115229,
-0.5638654232,
-0.0221325755,
-0.8170117736,
0.1805288643,
-0.5306345224,
-0.3950808048,
0.0102063436,
-0.0666469634,
0.1467701197,
0.5326277614,
-0.6055199504,
0.7887143493,
0.462361604,
-0.2386300117,
-0.3885752857,
-0.7564886212,
0.1233924851,
-0.7673040628,
-0.74417907,
0.2168106288,
0.2480321974,
-0.739502728,
-0.067311272,
0.4105547071,
-0.3535670638,
0.8533549905,
0.467864573,
0.0008628144,
-0.3557652533,
0.1554574966,
-0.0541827604,
0.102811791,
0.1563005596,
-0.0970923305,
0.6383806467,
-0.0487577841,
-0.0666866899,
-0.5424221158,
0.5619719028,
0.2848798633,
0.2400858104,
0.9123581052,
0.5638129711,
-0.1923234016,
-0.3310602903,
-0.4629899859,
-0.1172016338,
-0.4392068982,
0.2202037275,
-0.4010748267,
-1.1151846647,
0.8805219531,
-0.1020487994,
-0.0240948088,
0.7529512048,
0.6619391441,
-0.2875434458,
0.4732478559,
0.7571285367,
-0.0862951726,
0.2692961991,
-0.0809323192,
0.297146678,
-0.0856960714,
-0.0559586957,
-0.7709485888,
-0.1850981712,
-1.1447255611,
0.2471263856,
0.2858935595,
0.0040788404,
0.1287827492,
0.4697679281,
-0.30074507,
0.5756127834,
0.7667451501,
-0.0981802121,
0.2839801908,
0.373609364,
-0.0449374057,
0.179418996,
-0.5635813475,
-0.7160708308,
1.133689642,
0.352791518,
0.2212222666,
0.0579534844,
0.7915400863,
0.4312677383,
0.0493301824,
-0.8483812213,
0.2409252077,
-0.3703301847,
-0.8889499307,
-0.5755865574,
-0.3886289597,
-0.9443740249,
0.2757492959,
-0.2846438289,
-0.9910205603,
0.2050128132,
-0.0186081138,
-0.4339255691,
0.3983910978,
-0.5295764208,
0.4536593258,
-0.1776267886,
-0.0351866819,
0.0162356161,
-0.9576457739,
0.2360200435,
-0.2616830468,
0.7631326318,
0.0468581915,
0.4699597955,
1.0481841564,
-0.4885190129,
0.9403275847,
-0.3540218771,
-0.0118396524,
0.1642581522,
0.4556240737,
0.0081585627,
-0.081924282,
-0.0546062477,
0.5300834775,
-0.1082428172,
-0.1752887815,
-0.6786262989,
0.282340616,
-0.6205925941,
-0.6015715003,
-0.0116215125,
-0.580031991,
-0.1714552641,
0.0505768545,
0.7346394062,
0.4624777734,
-0.129178986,
0.2476079762,
0.6859223247,
-0.2081908733,
0.482765466,
0.4667066336,
-0.0834940821,
-0.2786125243,
0.9845221043,
0.2105917335,
-0.1373490691,
0.2522525191,
0.3573135138,
0.0471642204,
-0.973221302,
-0.5445863008,
0.1322635114,
-0.781683743,
0.4628374577,
-0.8556904197,
-0.1558494419,
-0.2944431603,
-0.4157047868,
0.0595818721,
-0.771135509,
-0.3634315133,
-0.1423788965,
0.4014728665,
0.9086564183,
0.0746939853,
0.7139682174,
-0.4956869483,
0.1614535898,
-0.1663729697,
0.0988759622,
-0.2703070641,
-0.7173374295,
-0.1834323108,
-0.2319762558,
-0.2132035643,
-1.0749979019,
0.3012920618,
0.1530351937,
0.5122941732,
0.565102756,
-0.1509304494,
0.0772660077,
-0.3521474004,
1.0318145752,
-0.1671085656,
-0.858643055,
0.5767878294,
-0.6640288234,
-0.2983446419,
0.7149447799,
0.8369327784,
-0.3162636459,
-0.6939324141,
-0.8403499722,
-0.8352862,
0.7104112506,
0.1971782744,
0.005625206,
0.3602142036,
0.341555208,
1.0230240822,
0.2394212186,
-0.7148151398,
-0.3739100099,
-0.1441312432,
-0.2153379023,
-0.3860626221,
-0.1884814054,
-0.3577159643,
-0.0826482326,
0.6291080713,
-0.0399382226,
0.1469322443,
-0.0083693014,
-0.3345070779,
0.4066041708,
0.2728516161,
0.6361507773,
0.8075883985,
0.0802016854,
0.2841617167,
-0.0003909314,
-0.4534604549,
0.1640912294,
0.3137548566,
-0.4455870092,
0.401230514,
0.7630953193,
0.7484565973,
-0.3537557423,
-0.4751121104,
0.4380167723,
0.2297102809,
-0.6292984486,
-0.5336040854,
0.0807367414,
-0.0360425375,
0.1166150793,
0.5456569195,
-0.0303787924,
0.710223496,
-0.4295925498,
-0.0818871558,
0.3996079266,
-0.441088289,
-0.3028098643,
0.3822040856,
-0.211017698,
-0.5158492327,
0.505309701,
-0.3638684452,
-0.876069963,
0.6268383265,
0.2314561903,
1.0312956572,
-0.1493777484,
0.4428377748,
0.111857377,
0.2652369142,
0.1803811193,
0.1550464481,
-0.2594738305,
-0.7017217278,
-0.1745075136,
-0.6324644685,
-0.2959712744,
0.196348682,
-0.6297687292,
0.0453225672,
-0.6507566571,
0.0059165182,
0.4838922322,
-0.5596318245,
-0.5448306799,
0.1314437985,
0.2031843662,
0.4886319041,
-1.2408666611,
0.5072700381,
0.6505026221,
0.0121495044,
-0.5150159001,
-0.158224538,
0.3666555285,
-0.786467433,
0.7617621422,
0.40846017,
0.0244687758,
-0.3686842024,
-0.8210647702,
-0.6881949306,
0.5709407926,
0.3190475702,
-0.2337297201,
0.2181302309,
0.4427597523,
0.6343443394,
-0.2995385826,
-0.07938575,
0.6270093918,
0.3440604806,
0.0073008342,
-0.9082886577,
0.0309498943,
-0.1921006143,
-0.0648550019,
0.3310172856,
-0.1156791821,
0.7685672641,
-0.1257216483,
-0.3907445967,
0.0122304698,
0.5232919455,
0.009743182,
0.6801306009,
0.4620564282,
0.4282200336,
1.0713145733,
-0.3550658226,
1.2078418732,
0.0116295991,
0.3699517846,
1.0127868652,
0.0360114053,
0.3890323639,
0.2531922758,
-0.4599339962,
0.899037838,
0.9031308293,
-0.2975670695,
0.5372903347,
0.351116389,
-0.3010861576,
-0.1603215635,
0.0792204067,
0.0799413398,
0.7606425881,
0.394084394,
-0.6891114116,
-0.2057286948,
0.3654486835,
0.2038077116,
0.1361800134,
-0.2228143811,
0.9961361289,
-0.2695907354,
-0.5221616626,
0.4480485916,
-0.0018753125,
0.4999024868,
-0.2606877387,
0.2675488293,
0.1342508048,
-0.1176932827,
-0.546564877,
-0.7977736592,
0.3893327415,
-0.118408978,
-0.435147047,
-0.029379094,
0.4996812046,
-0.2463108152,
-0.3783657551,
0.0398572311,
0.4055458903,
0.6093221903,
-0.1480880231,
-0.3082877696,
-0.5441046357,
0.033930663,
-0.0628157705,
0.2599153519,
0.6643120646,
-0.212006852,
0.714639008,
0.5449991822,
0.0577881001,
0.1587682366,
-0.2866082489,
0.4191834033,
-0.5657731295,
-0.6265282035,
-1.2227135897,
0.3061746955,
-0.0289702192,
-0.2063148171,
0.9655195475,
0.5611984134,
0.8177666664,
0.0177108534,
1.254478693,
-0.2184163928,
0.8368304372,
-0.6368166804,
0.8281440735,
-0.2966472805,
0.1358219832,
0.0283281785,
-0.4062528312,
-0.3807674348,
0.3441739082,
-0.5255362988,
0.2329466194,
0.743991971,
0.5485611558,
-0.1609956324,
0.4211289585,
0.3139512241,
0.0826096535,
0.0261912122,
0.1103485227,
0.7939614058,
0.0494772866,
0.427233398,
-0.6076340079,
-0.2819914818,
-0.2106816769,
-0.7713980675,
-0.9014165998,
-0.9060050845,
-0.2383861244,
-0.4628750682,
-0.1065574288,
0.3712527752,
0.7624708414,
-1.1157603264,
-0.1579469293,
0.0024185809,
0.0828802586,
0.0099814711,
-0.296795547,
0.4793193936,
-0.1700325757,
-0.4047572315,
0.3299147189,
0.1349591166,
0.125913769,
-0.1301503032,
0.3531759679,
0.091113463,
-0.3980402052,
0.3430655897,
0.314707458,
-0.9308226705,
-0.0874002799,
-0.1916774809,
0.1483280361,
0.2319867611,
1.0411890745,
-0.8283381462,
0.4356257319,
0.3207702935,
0.9261186719,
0.394941777,
0.1100875065,
0.4349101186,
-0.5972331762,
-0.0437264554,
0.101371333,
0.4495408833,
0.5409066677,
-0.8354810476,
0.5060805678,
0.5129641891,
-0.5377254486,
-0.559319973,
0.3203131855,
-0.8600221276,
-0.5162463784,
1.1126308441,
-0.4446286559,
-0.2408979535,
-0.7874202728,
0.167915225,
0.0890546516,
-0.1169563532,
1.0079543591,
0.9853408933,
0.0097681154,
0.1519489437,
-0.6948050857,
0.5393306613,
0.3195548952,
-0.5487414002,
0.1604403406,
0.5913043618,
0.5029000044,
0.4994941354,
0.2893399894,
-0.1834171116,
0.3623050749,
-0.2583148479,
-0.1546872258,
0.042405311,
-0.2129625976,
-0.5827565193,
0.7620730996,
-0.1462942213,
-0.0615155622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18470v1
|
ECC Analyzer: Extract Trading Signal from Earnings Conference Calls using Large Language Model for Stock Performance Prediction
| 2024-04-29T07:11:39 | 2024-04-29T07:11:39 |
Yupeng Cao, Zhi Chen, Qingyun Pei, Prashant Kumar, K. P. Subbalakshmi, Papa Momar Ndiaye
|
cs.CE
|
cs.CE, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-fin.RM, q-fin.TR
|
In the realm of financial analytics, leveraging unstructured data, such as
earnings conference calls (ECCs), to forecast stock performance is a critical
challenge that has attracted both academics and investors. While previous
studies have used deep learning-based models to obtain a general view of ECCs,
they often fail to capture detailed, complex information. Our study introduces
a novel framework: \textbf{ECC Analyzer}, combining Large Language Models
(LLMs) and multi-modal techniques to extract richer, more predictive insights.
The model begins by summarizing the transcript's structure and analyzing the
speakers' mode and confidence level by detecting variations in tone and pitch
for audio. This analysis helps investors form an overview perception of the
ECCs. Moreover, this model uses the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) based
methods to meticulously extract the focuses that have a significant impact on
stock performance from an expert's perspective, providing a more targeted
analysis. The model goes a step further by enriching these extracted focuses
with additional layers of analysis, such as sentiment and audio segment
features. By integrating these insights, the ECC Analyzer performs multi-task
predictions of stock performance, including volatility, value-at-risk (VaR),
and return for different intervals. The results show that our model outperforms
traditional analytic benchmarks, confirming the effectiveness of using advanced
LLM techniques in financial analytics.
|
[
-0.1793916374,
-0.8437808156,
0.2710843682,
0.0384304523,
-0.4349827468,
0.6462144852,
-0.2587594688,
-0.849278748,
0.4526625276,
0.4067507982,
-0.7182303071,
-0.630935967,
-0.5995310545,
-0.049424421,
-0.5341777205,
1.001617074,
0.3256387115,
0.272849977,
-0.1336653084,
0.1625011712,
-0.2707442939,
-0.6467715502,
-0.738498807,
0.0098023452,
0.1978183836,
0.4161110818,
0.3591295481,
0.5363622308,
0.614405036,
0.3355228603,
-0.2547268271,
0.4367153347,
-0.2173030525,
0.17694965,
0.3465546966,
-0.3150575459,
-0.9662515521,
-0.2159625739,
0.402143687,
0.6835930943,
-0.3852449954,
0.3017112613,
0.3438689113,
0.3837303221,
-0.5178261995,
0.449652046,
-0.6196370125,
-0.0482336208,
-0.3411934078,
-0.7044743896,
-0.5767802,
0.0212115627,
0.1025556102,
-0.3151183426,
0.1113978624,
0.3062104285,
0.6961619258,
0.0008039023,
-0.3992355764,
-0.2007714957,
-1.0426027775,
0.868488431,
-0.7527549863,
0.4552288949,
0.2246682644,
0.2350481004,
0.0931966528,
-0.7255733013,
-0.1431755871,
-0.2268549353,
0.1597949713,
0.3315075636,
-0.1327451319,
0.0532241985,
0.0284014381,
0.4696191549,
-0.1613744646,
0.4775424004,
-0.6989543438,
0.0827129036,
0.6603370905,
0.3468720019,
-0.1149443761,
0.1479735374,
-0.4664319456,
-0.066279158,
-0.6398758888,
0.1657121629,
0.4220528305,
0.4541542828,
0.083165355,
0.33150208,
-0.002839979,
0.3365147114,
-0.0002126189,
-0.1780194044,
0.2086783648,
-0.0131817749,
-0.0666953847,
0.3558906019,
0.4699600339,
0.2591407001,
-0.0388807058,
-0.1020676121,
-0.2724839747,
-0.1739005893,
0.1905181408,
-0.8818210959,
-0.1933122277,
0.3985661864,
-0.8969552517,
-0.3629075289,
0.2436081767,
-1.2008492947,
-0.1804344058,
-0.5967389345,
-0.049657505,
-0.2227768749,
-0.2480176836,
-0.0437015817,
-0.1614107639,
0.5397683382,
0.0999540985,
-0.8854978681,
0.6600238085,
0.982951045,
0.7448028922,
-0.4193267822,
-0.0904668793,
-0.9759544134,
0.0895246714,
-0.195142433,
1.1035556793,
-0.6559283733,
-0.6281916499,
0.0270914044,
-0.1974477768,
0.181637153,
-0.3933437467,
0.5181162953,
-0.6742480993,
-0.2039975226,
-0.1027796417,
-0.8174679279,
-0.1082161516,
-0.1550981551,
-0.7802131772,
0.9066631794,
-0.457831502,
-0.5804514885,
0.445419997,
-0.9383761883,
-0.2971215546,
0.3848870993,
-0.357024312,
-0.3459202945,
0.0059430012,
0.2070976198,
0.5510219336,
-0.2991580665,
-0.1174886152,
-0.5935429931,
-0.1149095967,
0.7104385495,
-0.5444855094,
0.1423601806,
0.2154428512,
-0.3074851036,
0.1771796793,
-0.9411768913,
0.2152812183,
0.0243730415,
-0.0345279388,
-0.3433052301,
0.6014990807,
0.3105198741,
0.0150978928,
0.1985846013,
-0.4255006313,
-0.1378786415,
-0.5033993125,
0.1172090396,
0.8266243339,
-0.0610443428,
0.2130614817,
0.0172671918,
0.7938603163,
-0.08797241,
0.0817170516,
-0.2202104479,
-0.2170336097,
-0.3794225156,
-0.4464813173,
0.4919827878,
0.5925915241,
0.0307108443,
0.6569583416,
-0.1566167176,
-0.5026246309,
-0.3989551663,
0.1841568351,
0.0420084074,
0.1539960057,
0.2521407604,
-0.4131006598,
-0.6504866481,
-0.8594185114,
-0.3119785488,
0.2791740298,
-0.0792995244,
0.0338392034,
0.2898291051,
0.0670776814,
0.5908631086,
-0.785281539,
-0.1485583782,
-0.4751874506,
0.3635641634,
0.3963761926,
0.0482081808,
0.2112468779,
-0.7883071899,
-0.2071168125,
0.2303002477,
-0.3213661909,
0.0665209889,
-0.088717252,
0.0018348146,
0.2109161764,
0.7560092211,
-0.0753807351,
0.6701639891,
0.7472161055,
-0.4640393257,
0.7128609419,
-0.0367930532,
-0.0329171941,
-0.9936999083,
0.2545385063,
0.2168505192,
-0.2354602069,
-0.4336526394,
-0.4238779545,
-0.1563574523,
0.0732456818,
-0.2314606905,
0.2441853285,
-0.4778781235,
-0.4007036984,
-0.7124176025,
0.1983620822,
-0.1131270975,
0.3295917511,
-0.0329689197,
0.6497634649,
0.4665512741,
-0.6845676899,
0.2522872388,
0.1076989919,
-0.5516346097,
0.2064837664,
-0.5674958825,
0.1282539368,
0.2089220732,
0.0176452864,
-0.964846313,
0.1354312003,
-0.1258026212,
-0.3358753324,
0.4127806723,
0.1201922819,
-0.2990769148,
-0.0825170279,
-0.3152887821,
0.2371121645,
0.3272645772,
-0.4258847237,
0.9764069915,
0.5527452826,
-0.6653996706,
-0.6103503704,
-0.4955248833,
0.0189870354,
-0.219497174,
-0.3447035551,
0.5699635148,
-0.1424855143,
-0.4136933982,
-0.0904535875,
-0.229718551,
-0.1203269958,
0.2978413403,
0.3834749758,
1.0863691568,
-0.0440596491,
-0.0315921567,
0.0068683014,
-0.2741003633,
0.2700927556,
-0.0405707769,
0.6118249893,
-0.29478544,
-0.276599139,
-0.5189183354,
0.5082253814,
0.4774080813,
-0.4435156882,
0.8247289658,
0.3556040823,
-0.1619986147,
-0.1540177912,
-0.4868524373,
-0.2900928557,
-0.5145650506,
0.6628991961,
-0.1760992855,
-0.5798919797,
0.8046787381,
-0.3544431329,
0.1558120847,
0.6665016413,
0.6415600777,
-0.0938300267,
1.3359066248,
0.8571951389,
-0.0017410716,
0.6422361732,
-0.3378026485,
0.3884144127,
-0.7584487796,
-0.385016799,
-0.4209065437,
-0.5229012966,
-0.508552134,
0.0198444221,
0.1972032487,
-0.0474076085,
-0.0415341593,
0.0675252676,
-0.4699728489,
0.4578585923,
0.5083873868,
-0.0996162072,
0.5465928316,
0.0089616105,
0.0720001385,
-0.0279028974,
-0.2963148654,
-0.6533415318,
1.3410369158,
0.57187289,
0.7117055058,
-0.2708868384,
0.3281813562,
0.329611063,
0.3379690647,
-0.9022113085,
0.3630536497,
-0.3071573675,
-0.3802011013,
0.0523391925,
-0.4373525083,
-0.6648972631,
0.2020896822,
-0.3078692555,
-0.7837116122,
0.3314351439,
-0.1391523033,
-0.5707447529,
0.3855244517,
-0.5180889964,
0.5506739616,
-0.6432592273,
-0.0466207005,
-0.3473891318,
-0.2069129497,
0.1305884272,
-0.2449989766,
0.3893688321,
-0.0717284605,
-0.2122555822,
1.0945174694,
-0.2691892087,
0.9054405093,
0.0947135016,
-0.1355393678,
0.1717132926,
0.019760672,
0.5333353877,
0.0129591506,
0.0297439899,
0.3285857737,
0.2433965653,
-0.1723674387,
-0.3092752993,
0.5366319418,
-0.6070332527,
-0.2039956748,
-0.3615084887,
-0.3187116385,
-0.2350891829,
-0.086067915,
0.1612575799,
0.4466229081,
-0.2756212652,
0.3824886978,
0.0729416311,
0.095516488,
0.5890837312,
0.3010276854,
-0.1205071658,
-0.4948481917,
0.5981779695,
0.056915313,
0.0729787424,
0.2486861795,
-0.0501525663,
-0.4505617619,
-0.6617268324,
0.1727426648,
-0.0672769547,
-0.5834243894,
-0.4422572255,
-0.4327397346,
-0.2330041975,
-0.3243971169,
0.0003243371,
-0.7328563333,
-0.1681215018,
-0.3761255741,
-0.4982531071,
0.4114067852,
0.6445206404,
0.0346952602,
0.3165351152,
-1.0597145557,
0.1484673768,
0.1548156291,
0.4230156839,
0.0676628351,
-0.4564488828,
-0.4951765537,
0.1376835406,
-0.7802579999,
-0.8188663125,
0.8847799301,
0.1224896014,
0.4324641228,
0.6191551685,
-0.0368423462,
0.7034518719,
-0.2206568569,
0.4621273875,
0.3490746915,
-0.9410833716,
0.3417774737,
-0.0968598947,
-0.1869580746,
0.329720974,
0.1981913298,
-0.3939056396,
-0.3454504311,
-0.6465044022,
-1.3152544498,
0.655379951,
0.0440580249,
-0.1812952757,
0.0672156811,
0.1710710824,
0.2475010753,
0.2919608951,
-0.5291165709,
-0.3292828798,
0.0184175055,
-0.215046376,
0.0001015866,
-0.4655252099,
-0.1233878732,
-0.1033710912,
0.5171572566,
-0.2626212537,
0.3386472166,
0.127554968,
0.2569186687,
-0.2266216576,
0.1834039539,
0.3059600294,
0.8645610213,
-0.3277053535,
-0.3466618657,
0.5359005332,
-0.2919414341,
-0.5810679197,
0.3873313665,
0.4453178346,
-0.2059004307,
0.4108540118,
0.630002141,
0.3342301846,
-1.0921918154,
0.3615582287,
-0.1597915143,
-0.1809408516,
-0.7902277708,
-0.1592738926,
-0.0871091038,
0.5269917846,
0.9176182747,
-0.0029748953,
0.4427636564,
-0.4762437344,
0.2736934125,
0.3324876726,
-0.329112947,
-0.3176404536,
0.6619594693,
0.2301188558,
-0.0943177268,
0.5698648691,
0.0989454687,
-0.6293114424,
0.8507853746,
0.2230076194,
1.1652132273,
-0.1050478593,
-0.0882822201,
0.0445577465,
-0.1234328896,
0.0730985403,
0.2138802409,
0.1463792771,
-0.4536934793,
-1.0777884722,
-0.5722019672,
-0.5887442231,
0.0999275371,
-0.8900002837,
0.375685364,
-0.3354306817,
-0.2741706073,
0.342559278,
0.192330882,
-0.773704946,
-0.0125886742,
0.5046758652,
0.7726100087,
-0.5745663643,
0.5475859046,
0.3922629654,
-0.162700668,
-0.831084609,
-0.2444116622,
-0.0522819683,
-0.5014330745,
0.6717450023,
0.2064570189,
-0.3488948047,
-0.3233753145,
-0.5837472677,
-0.610468924,
1.1347248554,
0.1329287291,
-0.8702167869,
0.1748882979,
-0.164364785,
0.2891223133,
-0.8312668204,
0.410641402,
0.7096760869,
0.2939857543,
0.3085040152,
-0.8905567527,
-0.2215522379,
-0.3268307745,
-0.349903971,
0.2926683128,
-0.5621534586,
0.7134622931,
0.0433577597,
-0.1057040766,
-0.0638924465,
0.9343742728,
0.2159934938,
0.6217813492,
0.4007960558,
0.1470381469,
0.7614623904,
0.0722429305,
1.1113042831,
-0.6402989626,
0.4420475066,
1.1562328339,
-0.3019744158,
1.3004519939,
0.3053881228,
-0.0680224597,
0.5735709667,
0.48295632,
-0.2819992602,
0.4390473962,
-0.1652996689,
-0.24991256,
-0.4595109522,
0.0458440371,
-0.2729363143,
0.9116292,
0.5425196886,
-0.4800730944,
0.2025361955,
-0.3660725355,
-0.1606615782,
-0.0419983007,
-0.4475363791,
0.8933615088,
0.2265066504,
-0.1986605823,
0.0455544777,
0.0156996381,
0.8041819334,
-0.6272249222,
0.0015860533,
0.0689541996,
0.3812363148,
-0.0561655238,
-0.4876547456,
0.4101716876,
0.0382980891,
0.0740330443,
-0.1308134794,
0.7475888133,
-0.3673439622,
-0.6440452337,
0.6006032228,
0.4609689415,
0.0295369755,
-0.1548788846,
-0.5687711835,
0.019277608,
0.0356669314,
-0.2788594961,
0.2895047367,
0.2606378794,
0.5121888518,
0.7037446499,
1.0176619291,
0.3225436807,
-0.1268236637,
-0.1190974265,
0.7913038731,
-1.1074569225,
-0.5944911838,
-0.9152933955,
0.4811065495,
-0.3024148643,
-0.2619932294,
0.4692379832,
0.8084682226,
0.4463928342,
0.0506415777,
0.5617309213,
0.5018548965,
0.6137362719,
-0.4955074489,
0.5938307643,
-0.4052733481,
0.5879074335,
-0.1826155931,
-0.842391789,
-0.1057387739,
0.1510030478,
-0.4485700428,
0.0661937892,
0.7596281767,
0.6102638245,
0.0070048724,
0.5259128809,
0.2748747766,
0.3060581088,
0.3911324739,
-0.0465970859,
0.7863182425,
-0.3534641862,
0.9418478012,
-0.2500605583,
-0.2703047991,
-0.4792202115,
-0.8387923837,
-0.6030026674,
-0.340731889,
-0.4582182169,
-0.3056578934,
-0.197394684,
0.99671489,
0.4779055715,
-0.7754639387,
-0.4596384466,
0.2930513918,
-0.320045948,
-0.4694465697,
-0.2952953875,
0.6671178937,
-0.346088618,
-0.9307317734,
0.4953459799,
0.3238256872,
-0.033066351,
-0.0202660076,
0.072043173,
0.1468209773,
0.1503190547,
0.6960068941,
0.2028458118,
-0.3430925608,
0.0195227955,
0.14631854,
0.2492026538,
-0.0912962332,
0.8216200471,
-0.4668216109,
0.0335531756,
0.235398218,
0.5814505816,
0.4389231801,
0.1110077128,
0.6183763146,
-0.5512188673,
0.116527237,
0.3735665381,
0.4901854098,
-0.1277493984,
-0.4702839851,
0.0657129213,
-0.0531802662,
-0.6907889247,
-0.725179553,
-0.2677493691,
-1.3079611063,
-0.4573580325,
1.1200338602,
0.3294158876,
-0.5423424244,
0.1177143231,
-0.2155063897,
0.1813612729,
-0.7311317325,
0.824410677,
0.5115680695,
-0.1879214793,
0.0176638439,
-0.7858694196,
0.2586737871,
0.4822377861,
-0.669850409,
0.3325200081,
0.2482993752,
0.0922250897,
0.0073565277,
0.279314667,
-0.196793586,
0.3016141057,
-0.0573837273,
0.1688538641,
0.0103428224,
-0.2734482586,
-0.2105320245,
0.3178276718,
0.0367348082,
-0.5783073306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18466v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18466v1
|
HFT: Half Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T07:07:58 | 2024-04-29T07:07:58 |
Tingfeng Hui, Zhenyu Zhang, Shuohuan Wang, Weiran Xu, Yu Sun, Hua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) with one or more fine-tuning phases have become
a necessary step to unlock various capabilities, enabling LLMs to follow
natural language instructions or align with human preferences. However, it
carries the risk of catastrophic forgetting during sequential training, the
parametric knowledge or the ability learned in previous stages may be
overwhelmed by incoming training data. In this paper, we find that by regularly
resetting partial parameters, LLMs can restore some of the original knowledge.
Inspired by this, we introduce Half Fine-Tuning (HFT) for LLMs, as a substitute
for full fine-tuning (FFT), to mitigate the forgetting issues, where half of
the parameters are selected to learn new tasks while the other half are frozen
to remain previous knowledge. We provide a feasibility analysis from the
perspective of optimization and interpret the parameter selection operation as
a regularization term. Without changing the model architecture, HFT could be
seamlessly integrated into existing fine-tuning frameworks. Extensive
experiments and analysis on supervised fine-tuning, direct preference
optimization, and continual learning consistently demonstrate the
effectiveness, robustness, and efficiency of HFT. Compared with FFT, HFT not
only significantly alleviates the forgetting problem, but also achieves the
best performance in a series of downstream benchmarks, with an approximately
30% reduction in training time.
|
[
-0.5084694624,
-0.9678639174,
0.5422394276,
0.0246049538,
-0.4636791945,
0.0674226359,
-0.5862931013,
-0.0488222502,
-0.099331148,
0.6201273799,
-0.7649341226,
-0.1578689963,
-0.3725393713,
-0.0035264546,
-0.2486994863,
0.9560768008,
-0.2355377376,
-0.261235714,
-0.0913787484,
-0.0698879957,
-0.4433317482,
-0.2446062267,
-1.3190075159,
-0.696143508,
0.5322960019,
0.4938105047,
0.6279155612,
0.9835443497,
0.1849633604,
0.217882663,
0.0110773565,
0.0031306157,
-0.9094676971,
0.0254229791,
-0.329734385,
-0.4850369394,
-0.3247475922,
-0.0362507738,
0.8180390596,
0.8729806542,
-0.5040411353,
0.1952544153,
0.200350076,
1.2528467178,
-0.5654618144,
0.2603440583,
-0.8392011523,
0.1594872922,
-0.0301307552,
-0.4137260318,
-0.0388147533,
-0.0746058896,
0.1513382047,
-0.6322200894,
0.3983331621,
0.3384973705,
0.9027304053,
0.7481926084,
-0.07066603,
0.0697874799,
-0.7676107287,
0.8436974287,
-0.6909188032,
0.6580873132,
0.6340043545,
0.2213821411,
-0.3151933253,
-0.2457068563,
-0.5078292489,
-0.0424983576,
0.1048545614,
0.0007271876,
-0.0509971641,
0.3162468076,
0.3166624308,
0.4500338137,
-0.4233146012,
0.0903361589,
-0.1469653994,
-0.453109324,
0.3394954801,
0.0796618238,
-0.1942001879,
0.31067577,
-0.2244299799,
-0.0477559641,
-0.9394349456,
-0.0033158821,
0.2614543438,
0.3618849218,
-0.0011203587,
0.1668926775,
-0.45120278,
0.7480341792,
0.3955538869,
-0.418033272,
0.0250121374,
-0.1116655916,
-0.4317685068,
-0.1907275766,
0.5739510059,
0.047081992,
0.5467408895,
-0.1881021857,
-0.4300206304,
-0.3818501234,
0.0875537395,
-0.6411114335,
-0.2299013287,
0.0131576667,
-0.3168818653,
0.1548703462,
-0.3303948045,
-0.6013042331,
-0.1938391477,
-0.6996131539,
0.4755712152,
-0.4792713225,
-0.0762536973,
0.5837513804,
0.0068150619,
0.0168102439,
0.3696381152,
-1.0498796701,
0.3258183002,
0.6048387885,
0.5167176127,
-0.2377626598,
-0.727992475,
-0.6348923445,
0.0983388498,
-0.3339348733,
0.438154608,
-0.3218098283,
-0.1381054223,
-0.0443495177,
0.0539662838,
-0.0896679014,
-0.7300159335,
0.5483319163,
-0.6769424081,
0.0300075766,
-0.4399100244,
-0.5394746065,
-0.0062773898,
0.3543198705,
-0.5478448868,
1.0632607937,
0.2336492985,
-0.5107321143,
0.3914600015,
-0.0417573191,
-0.6558617353,
-0.215443328,
0.1174382195,
-0.8019022346,
0.1139825359,
0.0015564699,
0.3533073962,
-0.5504409075,
0.2686094344,
-0.3547376096,
-0.4955001473,
-0.3648026586,
-0.3580256999,
0.3002669513,
0.036786139,
-0.2267208099,
-0.024032997,
-0.6053307652,
-0.3006282747,
0.1202900708,
-0.7668758035,
-0.256118089,
0.0342236534,
-0.2188534588,
0.104810968,
0.4219046831,
-0.5811988711,
0.0025518083,
-0.5902531147,
0.5611695051,
0.7374449968,
0.1466380358,
0.5928530097,
-0.4957357049,
0.4490755498,
0.0326040573,
0.2855484188,
-0.2636817098,
0.0190975461,
-1.1712578535,
-0.1322414875,
0.3769780099,
0.3869815767,
-0.7324423194,
0.5332594514,
0.1164929271,
-0.1032174304,
-0.4499744177,
0.541118443,
0.3703979254,
0.5161329508,
0.2875102162,
0.0804105774,
-0.7373547554,
-0.9747484326,
-0.1141879931,
-0.065509215,
-0.0533979163,
0.0811567977,
0.3433917165,
-0.0850273967,
0.9163725972,
-0.3692196608,
-0.5181095004,
-0.014750978,
-0.058117073,
0.1175478026,
0.3825581372,
0.3422970176,
-0.6076626778,
-0.4933912754,
-0.2162534744,
-0.3282242715,
0.1727073044,
-0.2808405757,
-0.2797813714,
0.3569455147,
0.5728189945,
-0.5331927538,
0.0512899719,
0.2508664131,
-0.0943020135,
0.2898203731,
-0.5183575153,
-0.1199072152,
-0.7376352549,
-0.075275071,
-0.0526351407,
-0.4015163183,
-0.3357055485,
-0.0822315663,
0.2825776637,
0.144321084,
-0.1954568475,
0.6873207092,
-0.46812433,
0.3544253707,
-0.4668429196,
-0.1032857969,
-0.1322409213,
0.7347086072,
-0.0787659213,
0.6808408499,
0.5781869292,
-0.5489641428,
0.180330351,
-0.0353994071,
-0.1529790014,
0.2863991261,
-0.3976913095,
0.151221782,
-0.3103167415,
0.0637000501,
-0.6644735336,
-0.0529757626,
-0.2018446028,
-0.042703975,
0.5063762665,
-0.2348538786,
-0.7824269533,
-0.2757548392,
-0.3475171924,
0.0980324298,
0.7322223186,
-0.3986024559,
0.473028481,
0.3989700675,
-0.0423017628,
-0.2794320881,
-0.2391821295,
-0.0554637052,
-0.2028109133,
-0.2182989269,
0.2894299924,
-0.0581451058,
0.2266795188,
-0.2398926318,
-0.4209134877,
0.1274227947,
0.1803051829,
-0.0231691729,
0.0930677876,
-0.120054327,
0.1656624526,
0.3660826683,
-0.2393239588,
-0.2950864136,
-0.5852939487,
0.7101215124,
-0.0453899093,
-0.2254272997,
-0.3802093863,
0.2609049976,
0.5353781581,
-0.230856806,
0.5529741049,
0.4953374267,
-0.657276988,
-0.3517662287,
-0.8602108955,
-0.4138287306,
-0.5018324256,
0.4192946851,
-0.3237463236,
-1.3245499134,
0.4153871536,
-0.0875927061,
0.1003726572,
0.2824684381,
0.6397066116,
-0.3865330517,
0.7805141807,
1.0633087158,
-0.3561210632,
0.6657642722,
0.0673661456,
0.1677888632,
-0.5233833194,
0.0496269986,
-0.4006679058,
-0.2764308453,
-0.3941148818,
-0.1196576208,
0.4776314795,
0.4240938723,
-0.5613003373,
0.1853364855,
-0.0945127904,
0.7617690563,
0.630469799,
0.1097700223,
0.2821237147,
0.0696221739,
0.0784527808,
0.1255579293,
-0.7159169912,
-0.2340159416,
0.7810101509,
0.4660177231,
0.8745655417,
-0.2791795731,
0.6857638359,
0.0197850484,
-0.1754452288,
-0.8296406269,
0.3761117458,
-0.3271431029,
-0.5690968037,
-0.7602459788,
-0.4303854406,
-0.7300009131,
-0.0134157548,
-0.1667088568,
-0.5339255929,
0.0355656967,
0.6166920066,
-0.8250106573,
0.1992677003,
-0.5317741632,
0.5902506113,
0.0843787938,
-0.4425348043,
-0.3074878156,
-0.5812525749,
0.1053729281,
-0.5907610655,
0.0380505249,
-0.3807331622,
0.0755297169,
0.7625699639,
-0.0676299855,
0.9496001005,
-0.2877237499,
-0.0830699578,
-0.030646082,
0.1401387751,
0.6203867197,
0.1877180487,
-0.1906961054,
-0.1189583242,
0.3267793357,
-0.5037674904,
-0.5986350179,
0.6690006256,
-0.5651814342,
-0.7842919827,
-0.0549820326,
-0.6402030587,
-0.6829361916,
0.4619559646,
0.0472732112,
-0.0756754801,
0.0342178755,
0.1412175,
1.0482225418,
-0.1256442517,
0.4871486723,
0.7095432878,
-0.1390874684,
-0.2716045678,
0.9195193648,
-0.0154228108,
0.3376059532,
0.4276233315,
0.3570562005,
-0.0078204563,
-0.7342815399,
-0.4551646709,
0.4807041883,
-0.1837110966,
-0.3529107571,
-0.4351869524,
-0.1534906477,
-0.0547254533,
-0.1356701702,
-0.6560492516,
-0.3233422041,
-0.3386309147,
0.0352012552,
0.194100365,
0.2271062881,
0.0485003851,
0.3933590651,
-0.7759386301,
0.4000959992,
0.3411790133,
0.6606325507,
0.0493012406,
-0.6739971042,
-0.5957709551,
0.1886785328,
-0.2371221483,
-0.2091252506,
0.1012075171,
0.5472931266,
0.4527195096,
0.3903259933,
-0.0374373347,
0.7154436707,
-0.7528725863,
0.330150485,
0.1134555042,
-0.8271936178,
0.3117791414,
-0.5574205518,
0.6449377537,
0.8739452362,
0.2298728824,
-0.5381892323,
-0.2217150927,
-0.2281331867,
-0.6572731137,
0.6964008808,
0.0232509263,
0.1843844652,
0.259863317,
0.8119313121,
0.3091283441,
0.2503251731,
-0.1296114624,
-0.1827356517,
0.0666887388,
-0.1619723737,
-0.2025131434,
-0.4427309632,
-0.1413857788,
-0.6115248799,
0.7889010906,
-0.2742830813,
0.0774684697,
-0.219708398,
0.0813462138,
-0.598765552,
0.1919595301,
0.4234989285,
0.7475703359,
-0.3324116468,
0.1115056798,
0.3599909544,
-0.3290281296,
-0.014403956,
0.0609052293,
-0.2057832628,
-0.4056657553,
0.2594797015,
0.8733829856,
0.3935719728,
-0.633897543,
0.2124655098,
0.1405452192,
-0.3118310869,
-0.2715991437,
0.2225730866,
0.2988791764,
0.1502593309,
0.3779017627,
0.0575600937,
-0.0886240378,
-0.7035105228,
0.4021863341,
0.3951767385,
-0.4854588509,
-0.249476254,
0.4476960301,
-0.0140105318,
-0.300593704,
0.5247952938,
-0.1109408587,
-0.5558918715,
0.3623907566,
0.5531651378,
0.6440743208,
-0.0404345877,
-0.0523961298,
0.4467891753,
0.4483849406,
-0.5539095998,
0.3366193473,
-0.0039384658,
-0.8034175038,
-0.357522279,
-1.1841709614,
-0.2643564641,
0.0342221893,
-0.652623117,
0.2526420951,
-0.7044863701,
-0.0512331054,
-0.0312639177,
0.0043902071,
-0.5710104108,
0.2087326795,
0.0157208014,
1.0618168116,
-0.6911166906,
1.3287875652,
0.5215221047,
-0.1919354647,
-0.5262457728,
0.130833149,
-0.0140097737,
-0.6712737679,
0.0298202299,
-0.3577680588,
-0.1422077566,
0.1520877481,
-0.4009492993,
-0.9731928706,
0.9208755493,
0.7872514129,
-1.0199654102,
-0.2885211408,
0.20643875,
0.5998020172,
-0.0467351638,
-0.3488133252,
1.313133359,
0.3726685643,
0.2860680223,
-1.2040528059,
0.0706141964,
0.217704013,
-0.000128694,
0.6611305475,
-0.8902238607,
0.7629244924,
-0.1003527865,
-0.1604159921,
-0.0334437378,
0.4083479047,
0.1529963613,
0.079841353,
0.7338462472,
0.5373999476,
0.6370074749,
-0.1453337669,
0.6011787653,
-0.2565646768,
0.6257893443,
1.2530485392,
-0.2065007091,
0.8378298879,
0.786072731,
-0.2710410058,
-0.2518777549,
0.7456645966,
0.1247715056,
0.6999139786,
0.1806915849,
0.0089252638,
-0.6705603004,
0.2804068029,
0.007687463,
0.1999463141,
0.1295876205,
0.0701705515,
-0.3785308599,
0.3198305666,
0.2036858201,
0.015562064,
-0.1729689389,
0.8924777508,
0.3462637365,
-0.6624284387,
0.9282239676,
0.1216215044,
0.7553985715,
-0.5815796852,
0.071923025,
-0.4809225798,
0.2892583311,
-0.0086735692,
-0.4456556439,
0.3864286244,
-0.2879790068,
-0.4692291915,
-0.4268581867,
0.3468043506,
-0.6582145095,
-0.3127247989,
0.2060348094,
0.2438716888,
-0.4075734913,
-0.275821954,
-0.6946227551,
0.0074931676,
0.2587824166,
-0.2943049669,
0.4875775278,
0.3250425756,
-0.0029006375,
0.7543768287,
0.4438465834,
0.1227629185,
-0.0408732519,
-0.0294144116,
0.8464631438,
-0.6973333359,
-0.2667806745,
-0.8986558318,
0.0437831283,
0.2005296797,
-0.365876317,
0.4705563486,
0.6732691526,
0.9688788652,
-0.0102230003,
0.7175599337,
0.2513965964,
0.7759373784,
-0.8757091165,
1.0042647123,
-0.7039985061,
0.281168133,
0.0699430704,
-0.8615948558,
-0.2897123992,
0.2305972725,
-0.1227249354,
0.024215322,
0.7909750938,
0.7256723642,
-0.2354247421,
0.0848506913,
0.6467126012,
0.269043386,
0.164336592,
0.7455562353,
0.5202035904,
-0.2409761995,
0.2407131195,
-0.5273985267,
-0.2879987359,
-0.0088723376,
-0.6098456383,
-1.0665746927,
-0.8388462067,
-0.2826947272,
0.007416653,
0.3012016714,
0.9664366841,
0.8425014019,
-0.837605238,
-0.2258744091,
0.0600948595,
0.0032092824,
-0.0780768842,
-0.1007312462,
0.3968424201,
-0.4989773333,
-0.6310160756,
0.3914923668,
0.4779311717,
0.0754466951,
-0.3304570615,
-0.0516839363,
-0.143332094,
0.1992511153,
0.560076654,
0.4031974673,
-0.6567949057,
-0.3020595014,
-0.1013811529,
0.0830203593,
0.0644477531,
0.7712132335,
-0.7179492116,
0.2458782494,
0.2922482789,
0.7584571838,
0.9234932661,
-0.2579000592,
0.6758692861,
-0.5697787404,
0.1002069786,
0.1499597728,
0.4560581148,
0.2491133809,
-0.299436897,
0.1864091158,
-0.016227968,
-0.4788559377,
-0.6989616752,
0.1774043292,
-0.8089667559,
-0.1771721393,
1.1188521385,
0.0378263742,
-0.1686201096,
-0.0961405486,
-0.2796786129,
0.2511773407,
-0.385638088,
0.9734597802,
0.7338117957,
-0.0086663635,
-0.2700973749,
-0.5573496819,
0.8119238019,
0.6202281117,
-0.6255877614,
0.2649422884,
0.2588036954,
0.6436396241,
-0.3724833131,
0.6314387321,
0.1351082325,
0.1050407514,
-0.4334798157,
-0.096182704,
-0.0969446599,
-0.4428189099,
-0.3681497276,
0.1853402704,
0.2918244898,
0.0798105076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18963v1
|
RE-GrievanceAssist: Enhancing Customer Experience through ML-Powered Complaint Management
| 2024-04-29T07:03:23 | 2024-04-29T07:03:23 |
Venkatesh C, Harshit Oberoi, Anurag Kumar Pandey, Anil Goyal, Nikhil Sikka
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In recent years, digital platform companies have faced increasing challenges
in managing customer complaints, driven by widespread consumer adoption. This
paper introduces an end-to-end pipeline, named RE-GrievanceAssist, designed
specifically for real estate customer complaint management. The pipeline
consists of three key components: i) response/no-response ML model using TF-IDF
vectorization and XGBoost classifier ; ii) user type classifier using fasttext
classifier; iii) issue/sub-issue classifier using TF-IDF vectorization and
XGBoost classifier. Finally, it has been deployed as a batch job in Databricks,
resulting in a remarkable 40% reduction in overall manual effort with monthly
cost reduction of Rs 1,50,000 since August 2023.
|
[
-0.481944859,
-0.3491694331,
0.0446609519,
-0.0055601294,
-0.1689966917,
0.5201782584,
0.2503829002,
-0.3421521187,
0.5836812854,
0.694210887,
-0.6044335365,
-0.5881832242,
-0.3146719038,
-0.1541936398,
-0.6059767008,
1.2933784723,
-0.3192493916,
-0.3427512646,
-0.1430143714,
-0.0356113277,
-0.4198486209,
-0.4927844405,
-0.678771317,
-0.3135240376,
0.65715909,
0.2311624289,
0.6647870541,
0.1289332062,
0.479155153,
0.3770677745,
0.3689748049,
-0.0676803663,
-0.3368830681,
0.4073086679,
-0.1993541121,
-0.534752667,
-0.1465896219,
-0.0679032058,
0.2910595834,
0.2112813294,
-0.3699397743,
0.4863280356,
-0.2898348272,
0.9387362003,
-0.9899328947,
0.0796838105,
-0.295024842,
0.3746613562,
0.3244181871,
-0.1642858833,
-0.0683350414,
-0.238971144,
-0.1344005764,
-0.4265958369,
0.4112679362,
0.1976747513,
1.1510103941,
0.7777155042,
-0.216121316,
-0.2553126216,
-0.7866918445,
0.5746916533,
-0.4304431081,
0.4892932177,
-0.1937163621,
0.9935125113,
-0.1820489913,
-1.1353971958,
-0.2194734067,
0.0563223809,
-0.2013535947,
0.1424057186,
-0.2972355485,
-0.1043028831,
0.1400208175,
0.5549117327,
-0.5375432968,
-0.0971603692,
-0.2403037846,
-0.3344327509,
0.6131743789,
0.6299729347,
-0.0834252611,
-0.3340324759,
-0.4119668305,
0.2042004466,
-0.2759712934,
0.2619393766,
0.6269154549,
-0.0287621934,
0.3182967007,
0.1818861961,
-0.3773753047,
0.5223695636,
-0.0877210423,
0.02003772,
0.1285537928,
0.0537166744,
-0.3951005042,
0.3920242488,
0.4002487361,
0.392609477,
0.1203101426,
-0.2392624915,
-0.6855762005,
0.5989145637,
0.5818528533,
-0.9269217253,
-0.5592155457,
0.6648285985,
-0.4809286296,
-0.4906495512,
0.1895636469,
-1.0425817966,
-0.5002618432,
-0.4945889115,
-0.153028518,
0.1781987846,
-0.5157765746,
0.0137428241,
-0.2056638151,
0.2435862571,
0.5121290684,
-0.381955564,
0.4031807184,
0.947829783,
0.6032193303,
0.1863169372,
0.0098080635,
-0.6043904424,
0.0077366834,
-0.2360215187,
1.0843477249,
-0.6458927989,
-0.3154569268,
0.1730876118,
-0.0313886255,
0.1341579854,
-0.9637289047,
0.5256333351,
-0.3134139776,
0.3720552325,
0.1801401824,
-0.3671421409,
-0.2259620577,
0.8608853817,
-0.2652740479,
0.9612908959,
0.7391127348,
-0.2655516565,
0.522678256,
-0.6155610085,
0.0614569634,
0.33664307,
-0.1533467621,
-0.648419261,
0.2511330843,
0.2592053413,
0.3705178797,
-0.3632870615,
0.0859481767,
0.0088489344,
-0.5226839781,
-0.1759273857,
0.078572154,
0.4938480854,
0.5478594899,
-0.2409067303,
0.1093721539,
-0.8588055372,
-0.097965695,
0.0992752165,
-0.1979726255,
0.0409172662,
-0.2979928851,
-0.0123644639,
0.4652925432,
0.3870996833,
-0.9544238448,
0.1682052165,
0.1656535417,
0.2544342875,
0.7566290498,
-0.0714184046,
0.0031468275,
-0.4851616621,
0.8855038881,
0.1467012763,
0.3444928229,
-0.1492928118,
-0.2557398379,
-0.7411663532,
-0.5673331618,
0.2391945869,
0.5650470257,
-0.4423464835,
0.1319761276,
-0.5221739411,
-0.749607563,
-0.690607965,
0.1329645663,
0.0933505744,
0.3329716623,
0.0496381149,
-0.2262668461,
-0.583306849,
-0.7269639373,
-0.5422991514,
-0.3308123648,
-0.1500300616,
0.4853212237,
0.0254480559,
-0.5948903561,
1.2428370714,
-0.6483268738,
-0.5306578875,
0.0855978429,
0.3488719165,
0.3263040483,
-0.0907954946,
0.7399888635,
-0.76171422,
-0.5812656283,
0.1763536036,
-0.9187087417,
-0.5033189058,
-0.2694945037,
0.2807252705,
0.4903306961,
0.4005784988,
-0.5136557817,
0.5603321791,
0.2765654624,
-0.4485260844,
0.8417599797,
0.1331815124,
0.4292743206,
-1.0967664719,
-0.0761346221,
0.3690022528,
-0.4491803944,
-0.5098792315,
0.098391749,
-0.3401920497,
-0.4189850092,
-0.3831511438,
0.1610969156,
-0.3056916296,
-0.4243165851,
-0.3576727211,
-0.1225266457,
0.0023715589,
0.8874675035,
-0.1448907554,
0.6201656461,
0.2471659333,
-0.6461382508,
0.8902631998,
0.2104367614,
-0.2837680876,
0.5960615873,
-0.4687013626,
0.0947127789,
-0.3706483841,
0.3320153654,
-1.3597921133,
0.076901637,
0.5875349045,
-0.4144461155,
0.0670025051,
-0.2648590803,
-0.3835429847,
-0.5186395645,
-0.3414880633,
0.0264897365,
0.5467634797,
-0.9253533483,
1.1460940838,
0.0092986524,
-0.164294526,
-0.5431771278,
-0.5828217268,
0.4697691798,
-0.2589814067,
-0.5771753192,
0.1851611435,
0.3133743405,
-0.3079942763,
0.0119560361,
-0.0882328153,
0.0267853625,
-0.2006537467,
0.4091466367,
-0.2237985283,
-0.0073138033,
0.0071755415,
-0.1590506136,
-0.6166353226,
0.4341856837,
-0.0057197646,
0.4349420965,
-0.0904987156,
-0.504935205,
-0.518122077,
0.2603830695,
1.0563877821,
0.1382831335,
0.223861903,
0.6470492482,
-0.3754811287,
0.3570361137,
-0.7755407095,
-0.1092682108,
-0.5091730356,
0.3885549009,
-0.3073109686,
-0.8510280252,
0.9111744761,
-0.8699355721,
0.6471372247,
0.0303244572,
0.465231657,
0.0835619643,
0.7404718399,
0.2887687385,
-0.2436732948,
0.6094061136,
-0.1316117942,
0.874607563,
-0.4987702668,
-0.5115400553,
-0.7080786228,
-0.6448841691,
-0.5699185729,
0.2299448103,
0.086808145,
-0.0632127449,
-0.2904021442,
0.5313246846,
-0.5836320519,
-0.0380258411,
0.0443412438,
0.0622039065,
0.0642006248,
0.0961192846,
0.3631326258,
-0.2737861872,
-0.5966876745,
-0.3293103278,
0.4814166427,
0.7244790196,
0.7931237817,
0.5596581697,
0.7861572504,
0.6291667819,
0.4819750786,
-1.067997098,
0.5343489051,
0.0214555394,
-0.2798814178,
0.0512867495,
-0.3293177485,
-0.698361814,
0.258977741,
-0.1338175982,
-0.6660571694,
0.545601666,
-0.0562385321,
-0.3210007548,
0.5247499943,
-0.781232059,
0.5709840655,
0.2953800261,
-0.3515327275,
-0.2643398345,
-0.1039632484,
0.2376949191,
-0.1953031272,
0.2119413614,
-0.2034207582,
-0.0184882917,
0.7012616396,
-0.9830539823,
0.5388077497,
-0.6522011757,
-0.2032613605,
0.4615353644,
0.0745688304,
0.8798632622,
0.0134702995,
0.1437624693,
0.2496816367,
-0.0875886232,
-0.5059983134,
-0.860530138,
0.6931189299,
-0.6409476399,
-0.660821557,
-0.2558396757,
-0.2434953302,
-0.0003388922,
-0.2759195864,
0.055890888,
0.2697488666,
0.0902648345,
0.0807740018,
0.3757811487,
0.0574653596,
0.6816363335,
0.5211454034,
-0.6777819991,
-0.4162797332,
1.2422400713,
-0.0285831951,
-0.3141091466,
0.2151753157,
0.1363425553,
-0.4761627316,
-0.0930918157,
-0.2596734464,
-0.2069478929,
-0.6744346619,
-0.5332897902,
-0.9537138343,
0.043722827,
-0.4366410673,
-0.3305226564,
-0.6794117689,
-0.2235104442,
-0.073056303,
0.0237611122,
0.1987642795,
0.6681178808,
0.1737323552,
0.5769121051,
-1.0992082357,
0.4380226731,
0.6031469107,
0.2646985054,
-0.3097376525,
-0.7408505678,
-0.4211889505,
-0.2181392908,
-0.2051360458,
-0.3852640986,
0.7579742074,
-0.103344135,
0.5218769908,
0.5837686062,
0.3035099506,
0.497669667,
0.0343228802,
1.1146819592,
0.372368902,
-0.5659236312,
0.2554984391,
-0.2597920299,
0.1680343151,
0.449257791,
0.1784203202,
-0.7130174041,
-0.2040417045,
-0.5624103546,
-0.9086589217,
0.1988842189,
-0.1922207475,
0.1133812517,
-0.0275735483,
0.4126573503,
0.0677165985,
0.4542472363,
-0.026014775,
-0.3410436809,
-0.39409253,
0.2772626877,
0.4280223846,
-0.5054932237,
0.0362814814,
-0.2520023286,
0.8709642887,
-0.0439780615,
0.3008759022,
-0.0777334273,
0.0303271748,
-0.1491645575,
0.4464848042,
0.5145564079,
0.6577997804,
-0.4639481306,
-0.4225421846,
-0.0873419717,
-0.2711231709,
0.3757582605,
-0.0284761153,
0.3681513369,
0.529553175,
-0.1641115993,
0.6436434388,
-0.0443802625,
-0.172460407,
0.3778826594,
-0.3422859013,
-0.6505578756,
-0.5511297584,
-0.3211452067,
-0.3775820136,
0.3254510462,
0.6027231812,
0.1314085871,
0.2474906892,
-0.3871265948,
0.3018223047,
-0.0797205567,
-0.7573390007,
0.1613673568,
0.2756198645,
0.3530531824,
-0.6058719754,
0.8796778917,
0.0043224553,
-0.5862175822,
0.355284214,
0.1978398561,
1.3171464205,
-0.1144680828,
0.232340917,
0.0645880401,
0.1537097245,
0.3539740741,
0.0570054464,
0.2555362284,
-0.673999548,
-0.5265224576,
-0.3538427949,
-0.5181919932,
-0.1533315182,
-0.8338047266,
0.1882115155,
-1.1317590475,
-0.1812547147,
-0.3231319487,
0.1948857605,
-0.3679065108,
0.3385715485,
-0.216978386,
1.0267881155,
-0.7972008586,
0.1816978455,
0.9813307524,
-0.111902371,
-0.3502756357,
-0.1035521477,
-0.253764689,
-0.6261118054,
0.8571197987,
0.2172690183,
-0.0935656056,
-0.0895742103,
-0.509226203,
-0.0636571944,
1.1187796593,
0.4959218204,
-0.8759413362,
0.7317926288,
0.1827247441,
0.6672600508,
-0.3042868376,
0.2592455745,
0.5349920988,
0.4877277911,
0.2084699869,
-0.2604119778,
-0.1765568703,
-0.5432108641,
-0.0411775112,
0.6400248408,
-0.9066343307,
0.4495723248,
0.1902210414,
0.0578774996,
-0.292329073,
0.7850193381,
-0.0335008129,
0.4482289553,
0.6477396488,
1.0335303545,
0.6303091049,
-0.3954764009,
0.9010439515,
-0.6178464293,
0.5646469593,
0.7887353897,
-0.1482360214,
0.3587710857,
0.7835418582,
-0.4954776168,
0.7984852791,
0.8276628256,
0.0011525865,
0.371760577,
0.6810176969,
-0.7227878571,
-0.5402706265,
-0.7358471751,
-0.4113872349,
0.2889954448,
0.3492373526,
-0.0640954897,
-0.4891942441,
-0.2026604265,
-0.2789437771,
0.0748076439,
-0.3583745658,
0.8164738417,
-0.0002610133,
-0.0483674407,
0.3763148785,
-0.0776408464,
0.8459928036,
-0.5141143799,
-0.3022430837,
-0.3818460107,
0.2331061214,
-0.6710001826,
-0.7143028378,
0.5485908389,
-0.314977318,
-0.3721949458,
-0.2089641839,
0.8101066351,
-0.02888727,
-0.2796016335,
0.3376608491,
-0.0391545519,
0.4774257541,
-0.5546184778,
-0.96181494,
0.0365186557,
-0.0431331992,
-0.2605337203,
0.3986241817,
0.4361386299,
-0.0943762884,
0.9206667542,
0.6142903566,
-0.2555699348,
-0.0727917403,
0.2463329136,
1.1750757694,
-0.5682918429,
-0.4187047184,
-0.4248306453,
0.4873546362,
-0.1874356419,
-0.1667164117,
0.1443721354,
0.4946180284,
0.5364609957,
-0.1057691947,
0.8125674129,
0.1785224825,
0.6146082282,
-0.0089717219,
0.331756711,
-0.3891327083,
0.3706543744,
-0.2329394072,
-1.218355298,
-0.2580889463,
0.3828321397,
-0.3058993816,
0.2278512716,
0.4408483803,
0.8877506256,
0.3107010722,
0.1648793966,
0.6463307142,
-0.3672896624,
0.7161556482,
0.474798888,
0.7174139023,
-0.8852006197,
0.6656170487,
-0.0192246288,
-0.0140632978,
-0.3801366985,
-0.7841338515,
-0.5691540837,
0.1598219872,
-0.8309714794,
-0.5452185273,
0.0434378721,
0.9569800496,
0.3692778349,
-1.1576123238,
0.0293280352,
-0.1313208342,
0.1123270243,
-0.2791334689,
-0.3082469404,
0.0539873131,
-0.5904416442,
-0.5911132693,
-0.2077750266,
0.4294571877,
-0.2508874834,
-0.6243317127,
-0.3032597601,
0.103415221,
-0.4075936973,
0.4274396598,
0.4449259341,
-0.4979175627,
-0.2960989475,
-0.4401971102,
-0.0276934095,
-0.0317150988,
1.1472661495,
-0.9459033012,
0.1093024015,
0.5996602774,
1.0860470533,
0.3360434175,
0.0075232931,
0.6497089267,
-0.842374742,
0.1553439498,
-0.0973074138,
0.6052541137,
0.231605947,
-1.067954421,
0.5879814625,
0.550323844,
-0.4672016203,
-0.3345053196,
0.0896055773,
-0.6396839023,
-0.2852682769,
0.7752690315,
-0.3802752495,
-0.2030033469,
-0.5906013846,
-0.3846717179,
0.1155331954,
-0.8726251721,
1.053529501,
0.5279541612,
-0.2009541392,
-0.71021384,
-0.2585752904,
0.1544529796,
0.693477869,
-0.6800703406,
0.2415526658,
0.6227949858,
0.036566861,
0.5239610672,
0.3253433108,
-0.0940872654,
0.2246597409,
0.1628403068,
0.231552884,
-0.5768261552,
-0.4430245161,
-0.270625174,
0.409088254,
-0.3142833114,
-0.621588707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18460v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18460v1
|
Ethical Reasoning and Moral Value Alignment of LLMs Depend on the Language we Prompt them in
| 2024-04-29T06:42:27 | 2024-04-29T06:42:27 |
Utkarsh Agarwal, Kumar Tanmay, Aditi Khandelwal, Monojit Choudhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Ethical reasoning is a crucial skill for Large Language Models (LLMs).
However, moral values are not universal, but rather influenced by language and
culture. This paper explores how three prominent LLMs -- GPT-4, ChatGPT, and
Llama2-70B-Chat -- perform ethical reasoning in different languages and if
their moral judgement depend on the language in which they are prompted. We
extend the study of ethical reasoning of LLMs by Rao et al. (2023) to a
multilingual setup following their framework of probing LLMs with ethical
dilemmas and policies from three branches of normative ethics: deontology,
virtue, and consequentialism. We experiment with six languages: English,
Spanish, Russian, Chinese, Hindi, and Swahili. We find that GPT-4 is the most
consistent and unbiased ethical reasoner across languages, while ChatGPT and
Llama2-70B-Chat show significant moral value bias when we move to languages
other than English. Interestingly, the nature of this bias significantly vary
across languages for all LLMs, including GPT-4.
|
[
-0.0109317349,
-0.4707973599,
0.9475166202,
0.2316121161,
-0.3968650103,
0.1548743695,
-0.1811268926,
-0.7395554185,
-0.1981949359,
0.5549667478,
-0.2880138457,
-0.2383958101,
-0.5494505167,
0.289126873,
0.5602072477,
0.9291850924,
0.0365071557,
0.7728927732,
0.0962860584,
-0.6840388775,
-0.2674574256,
-0.8531033993,
-0.8321183324,
-0.5426388383,
0.5410478711,
0.2631608546,
0.9118532538,
0.4026429057,
0.4707513154,
0.2570153475,
-0.1294003278,
-0.0197901335,
-0.417979002,
0.0609348975,
-0.5704703927,
-0.5474464297,
-0.1686245054,
0.3405032754,
0.2281317115,
0.2454592437,
-0.1201145947,
0.104332827,
-0.1594966054,
0.5611133575,
-0.3064446747,
-0.0079513472,
-0.6148436666,
-0.1179718524,
-0.0762377754,
-0.3474513292,
-0.1655728519,
-0.887783587,
0.0807411224,
-0.3309462368,
-0.4854187369,
-0.1676480174,
0.9591451883,
0.3093916476,
-0.6501854658,
-0.5231358409,
-0.2909310758,
1.2508542538,
-0.6590837836,
0.4995048344,
0.5561196208,
0.0037900526,
0.1016817242,
-0.2666919827,
-0.4842564464,
-0.0476051234,
-0.0581664667,
-0.0470131487,
0.1196634918,
0.0584423505,
0.0350903943,
0.1797274202,
-0.0943497047,
0.4220252931,
-0.2439802885,
-0.0809982792,
0.4872094393,
-0.1091823056,
0.2897452414,
-0.1782758087,
-0.2720211446,
0.1115400866,
-1.0309146643,
0.4275265932,
0.9003714323,
-0.0383098796,
-0.1469790041,
0.3168412149,
0.4129148424,
0.4514231682,
-0.0500178672,
-0.3397811651,
0.113192156,
-0.4880656302,
-0.0269833859,
0.1535318047,
0.8909041286,
0.8452344537,
0.8960341811,
0.4603538215,
0.096283108,
-0.0493265353,
-0.0267152451,
-0.5789945722,
0.1407268643,
0.282903105,
-0.4475300908,
-0.3802830577,
-0.3221334815,
-0.3261088133,
-0.2673251331,
-0.3617477119,
-0.0144738536,
-0.4475104213,
-0.195372954,
0.4439276457,
0.1167884469,
0.7738454938,
0.4867783785,
-0.7802206278,
-0.2890367508,
0.7106720209,
0.4316237569,
0.1366956532,
-0.1952751726,
-0.5581586361,
0.2730965614,
-0.5050135255,
0.6523903608,
-0.9834500551,
-0.2953139544,
-0.0967090577,
0.181937024,
0.3128567338,
0.0274753124,
0.9754457474,
-0.3779552877,
0.4042840302,
-0.8003889918,
-0.3018819988,
-0.5975212455,
0.339710772,
-0.3208648264,
0.5864117742,
-0.3250478804,
-0.610216558,
0.4513543844,
-0.4140149057,
-0.4232529402,
0.2508639395,
-0.6451104879,
-0.175686717,
-0.1468362361,
0.0982735679,
0.4999125004,
-0.5127937198,
0.4735915065,
-0.2240591496,
-0.4427318275,
0.284161061,
-0.6331337094,
1.306704998,
0.2246771008,
-0.3511208296,
-0.1968833655,
-0.3977225125,
0.2361705303,
0.162430197,
-0.3318331838,
-0.4402491748,
0.1929798275,
-0.1365550607,
0.3225913644,
0.2050109059,
-0.4985131919,
-0.0842421576,
-0.1405044943,
0.804336071,
0.9355489016,
0.0549804308,
0.2242820114,
-0.3798167706,
0.4933567643,
-0.3134891093,
0.3153998852,
0.2154161036,
-0.6848391891,
-0.5292081237,
-0.1258192062,
-0.1643446088,
0.8719733357,
-0.2607507408,
-0.0452139266,
-0.0283902436,
-0.149648428,
-0.7628148794,
-0.0719748884,
0.4554917514,
0.0273133386,
0.2154576033,
0.1563922018,
-0.2094650865,
-1.0745719671,
-0.5890334249,
-0.4319367409,
0.2713066041,
0.3155874014,
0.3836976886,
0.1404382735,
0.3474170268,
0.0699610263,
0.0492161736,
-0.1872166246,
-0.2266834229,
0.434928745,
0.3586011231,
0.6429787278,
-0.8120097518,
-0.3815429509,
0.2732694745,
-0.7906262875,
-0.23847498,
-0.1793409437,
-0.2280174941,
0.2633948028,
0.2696225941,
-0.3522971272,
0.0664717406,
0.7561764717,
-0.3756541908,
0.4091448784,
-0.0885953158,
0.5442755818,
-1.0299286842,
-0.341786921,
-0.2718130052,
-0.1269082278,
-0.3811390996,
-0.0511622094,
0.0445911027,
0.3679040968,
-0.6872705221,
0.6738862991,
-0.5270370841,
0.0445300378,
0.0962880328,
0.0846060589,
0.1303778291,
0.1462718844,
0.0951594785,
0.8404736519,
0.486820668,
-0.4468869269,
0.4179004133,
0.3797460794,
-0.1504463702,
0.9836646914,
-0.655905962,
0.115953885,
0.0245144144,
0.2236351073,
-0.4045392275,
-0.0474057719,
0.3363927007,
-0.3873431683,
-0.1335350275,
-0.6044468284,
-0.4342812896,
0.1017958894,
-0.4808103144,
0.5559284687,
0.552305162,
-0.4459191263,
0.3816798031,
0.4210816026,
-0.1211700365,
-1.1544686556,
-0.8621839881,
0.063123785,
-0.4964050353,
-0.7877824903,
-0.1885809153,
-0.0077761738,
-0.8292120695,
-0.184702903,
0.013564189,
0.0494044833,
-0.0299438518,
0.0202898216,
0.2482588291,
-0.0978918448,
0.1153448522,
0.1563899517,
0.0621315204,
0.0832033753,
-0.3447067142,
0.2981062233,
-0.8433010578,
-0.521956861,
-0.1185179949,
0.431936115,
0.6353216767,
-0.4505003095,
0.7028360963,
0.2913189232,
-0.1928961277,
0.3214693964,
-1.0213449001,
0.0376665927,
-0.5042154193,
-0.116773352,
-0.2481599897,
-1.1335451603,
0.5476796627,
0.4009420574,
0.2252072096,
0.2193227559,
0.82282269,
-0.1920705587,
0.7798296213,
0.3113018274,
0.2556127012,
0.1575915366,
0.0327486321,
0.44249928,
-0.7140265107,
-0.1038376912,
-0.4169182479,
0.0340966024,
-1.1318076849,
-0.5637344718,
0.3298188448,
0.1649419814,
-0.4469130933,
-0.119738251,
-0.4149931073,
1.0692611933,
0.1850170344,
-0.2859301269,
0.6100643277,
-0.158568427,
-0.2144393623,
0.0107409842,
-0.3720455766,
-1.1040970087,
0.6539736986,
0.3127554059,
0.5994713306,
0.3814475834,
0.5103956461,
-0.2579904199,
0.0657345355,
-0.586545825,
0.470022738,
-0.2397298664,
-0.6553317904,
-0.1725361049,
-0.2425005138,
-0.9879792333,
0.4111810029,
0.1544538885,
-0.771566391,
0.2501421273,
-0.1447685659,
-0.2237183601,
0.4373629689,
-0.5684371591,
0.5375876427,
-0.7936952114,
-0.484736681,
-0.3051789403,
-0.973539114,
0.3575101793,
0.0786085948,
0.4967270792,
-0.5871737003,
-0.108284533,
0.4056816399,
-0.1038354337,
0.6960929036,
0.239698872,
-0.5820158124,
0.2412795722,
0.1249094233,
0.3439403474,
0.619786799,
-0.3272723258,
0.6595720053,
0.328307122,
-0.308329165,
-0.0677066073,
0.8425100446,
-0.7621344924,
-0.941989243,
-0.6572898626,
-0.5205669403,
-0.3613190651,
0.305378139,
0.3202408552,
-0.0159294344,
-0.0863030925,
0.1673609614,
0.5297959447,
-0.6241716743,
0.2496768087,
0.6491807699,
-0.0478751548,
-0.240669772,
0.4515696764,
-0.056972608,
0.6063418984,
0.1862361431,
0.4664663672,
-0.4506301582,
-0.1452441663,
-0.6372600794,
0.6178664565,
-1.1194217205,
-0.0828551427,
-0.6057124138,
-0.0663834214,
0.0734200254,
-0.8363166451,
-0.2998616695,
-0.2321027666,
-0.0634562597,
-0.2818777263,
0.7091934681,
0.6025865674,
-0.2050887346,
-0.2139169723,
-1.048473835,
0.0165424868,
0.2673079967,
0.442106694,
-0.4717982709,
-0.2109719068,
0.5082055926,
0.3056443036,
-0.0774738789,
-0.8444387913,
-0.169395119,
-0.0462981127,
0.7202379107,
0.3265794516,
-0.3069015145,
0.3903242052,
-0.604480803,
0.8151766658,
0.1214940026,
-0.8644272089,
0.3552650511,
-0.7453075051,
-0.0237283111,
0.5803257227,
0.5512005687,
-0.7213118672,
-0.6738809347,
-0.5482342839,
-0.3959797323,
0.6001851559,
0.3330974281,
0.44192487,
-0.2564889789,
0.2670122981,
0.2613042891,
0.0342693664,
-0.9852455258,
0.0567044467,
-0.2348814011,
-0.0377650522,
0.1883397549,
-0.1808326095,
-0.3376487792,
-0.1404969841,
0.3512001634,
-0.0380668379,
-0.0057132943,
0.0011487535,
0.1116116345,
-0.1673713624,
0.6364114285,
0.6424936652,
0.8214731812,
0.0702630281,
0.1082739606,
0.3144527674,
-0.3589470387,
0.5235355496,
-0.2342295945,
0.0415604897,
-0.2732530236,
0.2300534546,
0.547462821,
0.139660567,
-0.4677075148,
0.5281950831,
-0.1582793593,
-0.0625882,
-0.2425171286,
-0.2225608975,
0.3552641273,
0.3818679154,
-0.043701414,
-0.2543168366,
-0.1447823197,
-0.6963649392,
-0.1857901365,
0.6674205065,
0.0163310617,
-0.2175011784,
0.6514594555,
0.342974335,
-0.0954008177,
0.5158436894,
-0.2897440791,
-0.7847129703,
0.5452657938,
0.1926960647,
0.6104179621,
-0.4314471781,
0.2530799806,
0.1868213415,
0.5871775746,
-0.2138042897,
0.6312644482,
0.2829914093,
-1.1513134241,
-0.8394084573,
-0.5902811289,
-0.5548875332,
0.0017540082,
-0.3092339039,
0.2580970526,
-0.2292847484,
-0.0106553063,
-0.2633100152,
-0.1120751277,
-0.5041901469,
-0.0385256968,
0.0597136728,
0.1278774589,
-0.3608059585,
0.7253257632,
0.5784214735,
-0.3364802599,
-0.8394466639,
-0.0620504916,
0.204841584,
-1.2569659948,
0.680582881,
0.118871361,
-0.6665238738,
-0.0097940415,
-0.4718649387,
-0.7598665953,
0.8399395347,
0.6133135557,
-0.3354287446,
0.2168257684,
0.1776203215,
0.4606696069,
-0.1487245858,
0.1825992167,
0.5365399718,
0.8283627033,
-0.0679084584,
-1.1719244719,
-0.0809098259,
0.008933275,
-0.1840841323,
0.3476151824,
-0.8268349767,
0.7134180069,
-0.5526261926,
-0.055800546,
-0.2640937567,
-0.0100373132,
0.6309416294,
-0.0388615951,
0.2815871537,
0.2368616462,
0.7612832189,
-0.1182267442,
1.0290534496,
-0.3565630019,
0.1649243385,
0.662876904,
-0.3929249644,
0.2747480571,
0.5479547977,
-0.0701564774,
0.4166079164,
0.6554000974,
-0.1118809879,
0.1549406052,
0.0317613184,
-0.0445769094,
-0.284629643,
-0.4047727585,
-0.4072082341,
0.7009396553,
0.4368280172,
-0.0882573724,
0.0634445325,
-0.2140806764,
0.5882096887,
-0.1727330685,
-0.3379425406,
0.4512998462,
0.3790617585,
-0.6048710346,
0.6301326752,
0.0122869126,
0.5368146896,
-0.5163016915,
-0.1001594067,
-0.1302491575,
0.0018263523,
-0.276299268,
-1.297524333,
0.1298519075,
0.2426140606,
0.3406035006,
-0.5963199139,
0.4645724595,
-0.3446409702,
-0.3899372816,
0.4622194767,
0.6906192303,
0.3094599247,
0.3072116077,
-0.6768246293,
-0.0210106727,
0.2347863019,
-0.3192313612,
0.2017801106,
0.7074790001,
-0.5138316751,
0.7465207577,
0.8753506541,
0.0728801861,
-0.0902771875,
0.2593082786,
0.3834741414,
-0.5720276237,
-0.4072286189,
-1.0944365263,
0.291919142,
0.0703494549,
-0.3518902957,
0.566056788,
0.1908745468,
0.8498775363,
0.1861880273,
0.6382766962,
0.1044237018,
-0.0467237309,
-0.9854953289,
0.6839359403,
-0.4936820567,
0.379360646,
-0.222981751,
-0.7938336134,
-0.0682793558,
1.0021970272,
-0.4877471328,
0.3801241815,
0.9110543132,
0.3803246617,
0.2789905369,
0.2928363681,
0.3451164961,
-0.0139756389,
0.4862839878,
0.5772553086,
1.1853151321,
-0.0090281246,
0.4945458472,
-0.1044586226,
-0.0149284434,
0.1746778041,
-1.2803884745,
-0.714165926,
-0.3281854987,
-0.0396524854,
-0.1803937405,
-0.0277135726,
0.940758884,
0.3407863081,
-0.5438426733,
-0.2748895586,
0.0566499569,
0.3564473093,
0.0030269737,
-0.1889467239,
0.2382735908,
-0.1320148557,
-0.6638469696,
0.1845742315,
0.5839221478,
0.0422212742,
-0.0286623761,
-0.1326676905,
-0.2655309737,
0.4259992838,
0.6017193198,
0.0149404015,
-1.1674274206,
-0.7504140735,
0.0200703014,
-0.2339396775,
0.2500692606,
0.7427675724,
-0.1106033623,
0.0814327523,
0.3012679517,
0.4370242059,
-0.1619750559,
-0.0872543082,
0.7651276588,
-0.2724252939,
0.2348111123,
0.6175707579,
0.6667956114,
0.4389481246,
-0.5632112622,
0.8321096897,
-0.0226141233,
-0.9294465184,
-0.587352097,
0.5975726843,
-0.8903101683,
-0.2541653514,
1.6076705456,
0.064863272,
0.2656034827,
-0.3711616695,
-0.3336588144,
-0.0772181302,
-0.2870535553,
0.3078290224,
1.0432473421,
-0.2625040114,
-0.2610638738,
-0.8927247524,
0.6358011961,
0.4860787988,
-0.7437323332,
0.0770562217,
0.5474801064,
0.4532611966,
-0.1337204874,
0.8212884068,
-0.5200229287,
0.3978803158,
-0.5304566026,
-0.0409499444,
0.2327664793,
0.1536730528,
-0.1486469805,
-0.4214508235,
0.0474055819,
0.2490203679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18443v1
|
BMRetriever: Tuning Large Language Models as Better Biomedical Text Retrievers
| 2024-04-29T05:40:08 | 2024-04-29T05:40:08 |
Ran Xu, Wenqi Shi, Yue Yu, Yuchen Zhuang, Yanqiao Zhu, May D. Wang, Joyce C. Ho, Chao Zhang, Carl Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, q-bio.QM
|
Developing effective biomedical retrieval models is important for excelling
at knowledge-intensive biomedical tasks but still challenging due to the
deficiency of sufficient publicly annotated biomedical data and computational
resources. We present BMRetriever, a series of dense retrievers for enhancing
biomedical retrieval via unsupervised pre-training on large biomedical corpora,
followed by instruction fine-tuning on a combination of labeled datasets and
synthetic pairs. Experiments on 5 biomedical tasks across 11 datasets verify
BMRetriever's efficacy on various biomedical applications. BMRetriever also
exhibits strong parameter efficiency, with the 410M variant outperforming
baselines up to 11.7 times larger, and the 2B variant matching the performance
of models with over 5B parameters. The training data and model checkpoints are
released at \url{https://huggingface.co/BMRetriever} to ensure transparency,
reproducibility, and application to new domains.
|
[
-0.0847214162,
-0.7445487976,
0.5275608301,
0.2912760675,
-0.1778378785,
0.1016696021,
-0.5508727431,
-0.6083167791,
-0.0130339377,
0.6169735193,
-0.2573648989,
-0.4671672285,
-0.8406413794,
0.2537266016,
-0.3477017879,
0.9940960407,
0.2454486787,
0.3901466727,
-0.3760496378,
-0.1316339672,
-0.360504806,
-0.4780739844,
-0.3825799823,
-0.6376898885,
0.7876319289,
0.4113074839,
0.7431109548,
0.5955764055,
1.0172958374,
0.2610652745,
-0.1770645082,
0.2548814118,
-0.9267951846,
0.427595526,
-0.7393593788,
-0.1778128594,
-0.1802327633,
-0.1762385219,
0.67587924,
1.1236732006,
-0.1698721498,
0.1751140505,
-0.1444881856,
0.8502436876,
-0.7950230837,
-0.1807343662,
-0.4944671094,
-0.2304035872,
-0.3299642801,
-0.3143179119,
-0.6784413457,
-0.3914141059,
0.254175216,
-0.4723270237,
0.4768352509,
0.3219551444,
0.8474190235,
0.4201840162,
-0.3727226853,
-0.1202869564,
-0.7990900874,
0.7914237976,
-0.4079969525,
0.8266642094,
0.5318434238,
0.3682250381,
-0.325034529,
-1.0899372101,
-0.0278392136,
-0.0971542597,
-0.2013667971,
0.0661040246,
-0.4537752271,
0.2353362888,
0.353164643,
0.3584104776,
-0.8537134528,
0.0732636377,
-0.4834110439,
-0.2785014808,
0.543617785,
0.0206428766,
0.130283311,
0.073073633,
-0.1246097982,
-0.2324603051,
-0.7684890032,
-0.4431617558,
-0.1526460648,
0.1868208498,
0.2299547195,
0.8693179488,
-0.3466654122,
0.7655469775,
0.010471981,
0.1754337698,
0.4068701863,
-0.4236294925,
-0.3071944118,
0.0966984704,
0.5322670937,
0.1521997005,
-0.0977584422,
-0.4528653324,
-0.2778711617,
-0.2094489485,
0.4894544482,
-1.4225449562,
-0.4795815945,
0.3165540099,
-0.7468680739,
0.0834934264,
-0.1237926185,
-0.7915282845,
-0.3656665683,
-0.3059399128,
0.5049710274,
-0.6496063471,
-0.0412784889,
0.6273729801,
-0.3802411258,
-0.12171074,
0.2196971774,
-0.6987326741,
0.1448492855,
0.52967906,
0.7707417607,
0.0015447858,
-0.0910782516,
-0.9111711979,
0.43841061,
-0.1293362826,
0.7334547639,
-0.8680502176,
-0.5747911334,
-0.2320284843,
0.1716096401,
-0.1288580149,
-0.7814792395,
0.4999245107,
-0.6387414336,
-0.1277541071,
-0.3853594065,
-0.7709555626,
-0.0863608196,
-0.0138553809,
-0.6285892129,
0.9127173424,
0.1027639955,
-0.7609954476,
0.3061360419,
-0.6289024949,
-0.5183100104,
0.3726679087,
0.1656818092,
-0.3344009519,
0.3266912997,
-0.0223589204,
0.5494040847,
-0.2408590615,
0.260140866,
-0.4895583093,
-0.3237932324,
0.1941871494,
-0.0093057593,
0.5667027235,
0.172258392,
-0.1120374128,
0.1104869395,
-0.6757329106,
-0.1233085915,
-0.0437805057,
-0.4104175866,
-0.6739482284,
0.0465488993,
0.4633267224,
-0.041623991,
0.4254283607,
-0.8854531646,
0.0231633484,
-0.3683792055,
0.4111231863,
0.2329801917,
-0.0810325518,
0.2989655137,
-0.3321996331,
0.3876709938,
-0.2070670277,
0.1129685417,
0.0334345773,
-0.3196326792,
-0.2009792477,
-0.6636118293,
0.6356082559,
0.3881046176,
-0.6000390053,
0.3445762992,
-0.1947324872,
-0.7114698291,
-0.7125709653,
0.1947136968,
0.6799138188,
0.5716761947,
0.7858436108,
-0.168313399,
-0.6753494143,
-0.869582057,
-0.0583801232,
0.1814360321,
-0.0714498088,
0.4431529641,
0.6345674992,
-0.9385598898,
0.6645166874,
-0.698894918,
-0.1035765409,
-0.1139110178,
0.0887344405,
-0.1091765985,
0.5084644556,
0.4031763673,
-0.8045653105,
0.045089636,
0.2866468728,
-0.7773851156,
-0.0449204296,
0.4462571442,
-0.4953560233,
0.038510263,
0.6764546633,
-0.6270571351,
0.1096215099,
0.5481353998,
-0.3586937785,
0.5682585835,
-0.5577358007,
-0.06346827,
-0.9645521641,
0.7683194876,
-0.0912260413,
-0.4890834987,
-0.3285117745,
0.0672926828,
0.2742102146,
-0.0217435546,
-0.1899409592,
0.8276373744,
-0.508417964,
0.0576732755,
-0.331012845,
-0.0609868467,
0.1289119571,
-0.3067317605,
-0.0310527682,
0.6644473672,
0.3709796369,
-0.4850203991,
0.1566062868,
0.6955412626,
-0.2659719884,
0.3096674383,
-0.9298272729,
0.0890150294,
-0.4139171541,
0.3444785476,
-0.6321631074,
-0.4625056088,
-0.1411434859,
-0.3417761922,
0.3718358576,
-0.2596714199,
-0.63072896,
-0.4238812625,
-0.0285733845,
0.4853436649,
0.4644978046,
-0.6745643616,
0.3345462978,
0.4824390411,
-0.2983628511,
-0.5744329095,
-0.5741091371,
-0.0406837463,
0.1634985805,
-0.3471148312,
0.3623758256,
-0.369803369,
0.0419109538,
0.0103145624,
0.1081754118,
0.0162426382,
0.0099864649,
0.2271515131,
0.1925081164,
-0.2353410572,
0.3062395453,
0.287019223,
-0.083376348,
-0.1062313244,
-0.2382435352,
0.3564011455,
0.2356751263,
-0.1230647266,
-0.0323924311,
0.3106111288,
0.2386476994,
-0.5340433121,
0.74556458,
0.7075220942,
-0.4685923159,
0.018235283,
-0.7461774349,
-0.4229674041,
-0.4925248921,
0.5492733121,
-0.0817010775,
-1.1619316339,
0.234732613,
-0.1789175719,
-0.0740082785,
0.0753177032,
0.7610858679,
-0.0208876692,
1.077227354,
0.6021156907,
-0.0366124175,
0.3222517669,
-0.1152859852,
-0.1326491684,
-0.7332894802,
-0.4945820868,
-0.6586395502,
-0.3197273314,
-0.3910911381,
-0.5158458948,
0.229523465,
0.1131267026,
-0.1917493939,
0.0803021491,
-0.5240655541,
0.5700401664,
0.5314304829,
0.4037817121,
0.2885736823,
-0.0573359355,
-0.1309294403,
0.0317500569,
-0.7424795032,
-0.4130474329,
1.1871203184,
0.1961319447,
0.8089458942,
0.1267042905,
0.5195946097,
-0.0200574119,
0.3297564983,
-0.6342592239,
0.2429854125,
-0.452948451,
-0.9413667321,
-0.1050260365,
-0.711530447,
-1.395341754,
0.0361045264,
-0.4368455112,
-0.3955756128,
0.2782691419,
0.3388164639,
-0.261198014,
-0.1114102378,
-0.5894926786,
1.0636802912,
0.066579625,
-0.4993999004,
-0.4007187188,
-0.7885998487,
0.1669862419,
-0.0665153041,
-0.0715624616,
-0.0425772369,
-0.0471402518,
0.4679139256,
-0.2264651954,
0.4872341156,
-0.2629087567,
0.2838236094,
-0.232956171,
0.0899809599,
0.2455372959,
0.1448154002,
-0.3856149614,
0.1122145355,
0.2660318613,
-0.7730515003,
-0.3032902181,
0.6228482127,
-0.5199414492,
-0.2026844472,
-0.2235338092,
-0.7236850262,
-0.261493355,
0.5562910438,
0.3825247884,
0.6614878774,
-0.4211978316,
0.6194025874,
1.006124258,
-0.3335940838,
0.166090861,
0.6657623649,
-0.1208379567,
-0.3220854104,
0.8936985135,
-0.2227948755,
-0.0077767111,
0.5870480537,
0.1057975441,
-0.4214180112,
-0.9119983315,
-0.3502065837,
0.5603783727,
-0.2815277278,
-0.5425938964,
-0.8016201854,
-0.2202762961,
-0.2519906759,
0.0350764245,
-0.4027109444,
-0.2165051401,
-0.2968051136,
-0.0564245284,
0.689186573,
0.7144358754,
-0.1879156977,
0.2989960015,
-1.0118988752,
0.3063068092,
-0.1155883148,
0.5492970943,
-0.3162779212,
-0.5004246235,
-0.6354977489,
0.0524786152,
0.0030333621,
-0.4345979393,
0.4540544152,
0.3170303404,
0.3845276833,
0.2364170402,
-0.1355495155,
0.5342909098,
-0.7701122165,
0.1184323803,
-0.139841482,
-0.5234696865,
0.7163374424,
-0.4475324154,
0.1978188455,
0.9192349911,
0.5487728715,
-0.2233058959,
-0.3182413578,
-0.3609472215,
-0.8979508877,
0.5237990022,
0.1516765803,
-0.0219817627,
-0.0820565149,
0.6699524522,
0.1979708374,
0.2474395335,
0.1482797265,
-0.0404128246,
-0.0511170812,
-0.4203410745,
-0.4713738859,
-0.2634423673,
-0.1817457229,
-0.3710488677,
0.6350985169,
-0.0421262234,
0.2093727589,
0.4464641213,
-0.5025844574,
-0.1159805283,
-0.0250769816,
0.5883322954,
0.5654149055,
-0.5514315367,
0.104718022,
-0.2504082322,
-0.8121959567,
-0.1586800367,
0.7251896262,
0.0090160249,
0.0840104669,
0.2231007367,
0.506801188,
0.3786746562,
-1.028740406,
0.4088557065,
-0.1454016268,
-0.1388859451,
0.1307920069,
0.0552390739,
0.1540926546,
0.3986997604,
0.2502790689,
0.0280695464,
0.5772577524,
-0.0580491275,
0.4793713093,
0.5669632554,
-0.4423395395,
-0.2614487112,
0.9000360966,
0.1286662221,
-0.0025507314,
0.6025726199,
-0.1980757415,
-0.003381605,
0.1382169724,
0.6913731694,
0.2831213474,
-0.3762436509,
0.1319719553,
0.3099433482,
0.1203173995,
-0.6065137386,
0.2400955856,
0.283457756,
-0.5814573765,
-0.5694378018,
-0.9015825391,
-0.5480731726,
-0.0433523841,
-0.8023305535,
0.0841067955,
-0.348416239,
-0.3436102271,
0.3600223362,
0.1226338446,
-0.498342216,
0.1988779157,
-0.0988258272,
1.092702508,
-0.5193114877,
0.7970221639,
0.8892890811,
-0.414395541,
-0.380793035,
-0.3749026954,
-0.2529374659,
-0.5759425163,
0.6909359694,
-0.0656957999,
0.0256785955,
0.3483222723,
-0.4931044877,
-0.8483507633,
0.9897848368,
0.7630542517,
-0.8331711292,
-0.0981367901,
-0.2364267558,
0.65841645,
-0.04431412,
0.2597905397,
0.5582704544,
0.4953220189,
0.090380542,
-0.8364171386,
0.1273144037,
-0.3086092472,
-0.0124507342,
0.3004371822,
-0.5862871408,
0.2775061429,
-0.1614121348,
0.2940233946,
0.258038342,
0.4995399415,
0.573271215,
0.4524006248,
-0.0288387127,
0.4844359756,
1.1220715046,
0.0081251618,
1.2861450911,
-0.1942853183,
0.3091968596,
0.8554124236,
-0.3734801114,
0.9057200551,
0.1784200817,
0.2069759965,
0.4025522172,
0.5450186729,
-0.1495514214,
0.286944598,
0.1037747264,
-0.2030078024,
-0.2696789801,
-0.2065221369,
-0.4254535735,
0.2566545606,
0.5394980311,
-0.4279398322,
-0.0454738922,
0.3639705479,
0.110530898,
0.0917541608,
-0.2703143358,
0.6054884195,
0.0153094716,
-0.3868686259,
0.5562092066,
-0.0685331374,
0.5186199546,
-0.4452797472,
0.0586499237,
-0.1965853125,
0.400555253,
-0.2439801246,
-0.4549458027,
0.2261946797,
-0.1418631077,
-0.528559804,
-0.117454268,
0.8510193229,
-0.612293005,
-0.6809126735,
0.6265540123,
0.4353320003,
0.1664056182,
-0.1609363705,
-0.7171647549,
0.1857999861,
-0.3309555352,
-0.2368269563,
0.3260006905,
0.5020182729,
0.1399899423,
0.6624697447,
0.7044528723,
0.3017756939,
0.0219629575,
0.2772163749,
0.8427146077,
-0.7501128316,
0.1088372171,
-0.6869502068,
0.125225246,
-0.117056787,
-0.0753312632,
0.5753419995,
1.1970653534,
0.7112079263,
-0.0699030533,
0.5623205304,
0.2212386429,
0.8684182167,
-0.5093759894,
1.0256322622,
-0.6005131006,
-0.1260126382,
-0.1089112461,
-0.7607957125,
-0.566861093,
0.5630965233,
-0.2236459106,
0.2379200161,
0.6882933378,
1.0046317577,
-0.3762520552,
-0.0121774133,
0.2940857708,
0.4931513965,
0.0448240526,
0.363561213,
0.5502656698,
-0.2156416178,
0.363117367,
-0.0825981349,
-0.3086743653,
-0.5686436296,
-0.508060813,
-1.0051060915,
-0.3268705606,
-0.2284287512,
-0.484980166,
0.5624321103,
0.9448632598,
1.0036507845,
-0.6919112802,
-0.1066885591,
0.1758997887,
-0.23200652,
0.1233466566,
-0.1527707875,
0.2259141356,
-0.5656706691,
-0.561006248,
0.5853611231,
0.2667692006,
-0.0025392722,
0.0916771218,
0.0482029617,
-0.2584476769,
-0.0116780493,
0.87403965,
0.3567217886,
-0.2016451806,
-0.1091626361,
0.1835071295,
-0.333954215,
-0.0927993357,
0.8196265697,
-0.8514797091,
0.3358088732,
0.3401446044,
1.0671323538,
0.8286220431,
0.1119475663,
0.5735025406,
-0.6633206606,
0.1629026979,
0.3772589862,
0.2852542102,
0.5960128903,
-0.4369381666,
0.5060660839,
0.0531145111,
-0.9108042717,
-0.957278192,
-0.0705582201,
-1.0884305239,
-0.460922718,
1.1553959846,
0.2570158839,
-0.1597708464,
-0.2549860775,
-0.195064038,
0.2637841105,
-0.4331676066,
0.7085617185,
0.3569357395,
-0.044903826,
0.1175261214,
-0.7811563611,
0.6098048687,
0.6463384628,
-0.800963223,
0.195404768,
0.6451870799,
0.4085814953,
-0.2223656029,
0.6835887432,
-0.1712581366,
0.3785650432,
-0.4940588474,
0.1669564843,
-0.0005797872,
-0.3135849833,
-0.3350917995,
-0.1303281188,
0.1437292248,
0.2023490667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18416v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18416v2
|
Capabilities of Gemini Models in Medicine
| 2024-04-29T04:11:28 | 2024-05-01T17:12:10 |
Khaled Saab, Tao Tu, Wei-Hung Weng, Ryutaro Tanno, David Stutz, Ellery Wulczyn, Fan Zhang, Tim Strother, Chunjong Park, Elahe Vedadi, Juanma Zambrano Chaves, Szu-Yeu Hu, Mike Schaekermann, Aishwarya Kamath, Yong Cheng, David G. T. Barrett, Cathy Cheung, Basil Mustafa, Anil Palepu, Daniel McDuff, Le Hou, Tomer Golany, Luyang Liu, Jean-baptiste Alayrac, Neil Houlsby, Nenad Tomasev, Jan Freyberg, Charles Lau, Jonas Kemp, Jeremy Lai, Shekoofeh Azizi, Kimberly Kanada, SiWai Man, Kavita Kulkarni, Ruoxi Sun, Siamak Shakeri, Luheng He, Ben Caine, Albert Webson, Natasha Latysheva, Melvin Johnson, Philip Mansfield, Jian Lu, Ehud Rivlin, Jesper Anderson, Bradley Green, Renee Wong, Jonathan Krause, Jonathon Shlens, Ewa Dominowska, S. M. Ali Eslami, Katherine Chou, Claire Cui, Oriol Vinyals, Koray Kavukcuoglu, James Manyika, Jeff Dean, Demis Hassabis, Yossi Matias, Dale Webster, Joelle Barral, Greg Corrado, Christopher Semturs, S. Sara Mahdavi, Juraj Gottweis, Alan Karthikesalingam, Vivek Natarajan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Excellence in a wide variety of medical applications poses considerable
challenges for AI, requiring advanced reasoning, access to up-to-date medical
knowledge and understanding of complex multimodal data. Gemini models, with
strong general capabilities in multimodal and long-context reasoning, offer
exciting possibilities in medicine. Building on these core strengths of Gemini,
we introduce Med-Gemini, a family of highly capable multimodal models that are
specialized in medicine with the ability to seamlessly use web search, and that
can be efficiently tailored to novel modalities using custom encoders. We
evaluate Med-Gemini on 14 medical benchmarks, establishing new state-of-the-art
(SoTA) performance on 10 of them, and surpass the GPT-4 model family on every
benchmark where a direct comparison is viable, often by a wide margin. On the
popular MedQA (USMLE) benchmark, our best-performing Med-Gemini model achieves
SoTA performance of 91.1% accuracy, using a novel uncertainty-guided search
strategy. On 7 multimodal benchmarks including NEJM Image Challenges and MMMU
(health & medicine), Med-Gemini improves over GPT-4V by an average relative
margin of 44.5%. We demonstrate the effectiveness of Med-Gemini's long-context
capabilities through SoTA performance on a needle-in-a-haystack retrieval task
from long de-identified health records and medical video question answering,
surpassing prior bespoke methods using only in-context learning. Finally,
Med-Gemini's performance suggests real-world utility by surpassing human
experts on tasks such as medical text summarization, alongside demonstrations
of promising potential for multimodal medical dialogue, medical research and
education. Taken together, our results offer compelling evidence for
Med-Gemini's potential, although further rigorous evaluation will be crucial
before real-world deployment in this safety-critical domain.
|
[
-0.3612822592,
-0.496113658,
0.89651227,
0.0052592214,
-0.1989549994,
-0.1269838512,
-0.0355934575,
-0.5534027219,
0.2942924798,
0.3475574553,
-0.7236630917,
-0.4726118445,
-0.9926784635,
0.0880936608,
-0.4637271762,
1.0649348497,
0.124820061,
0.51841712,
-0.3048942089,
-0.2025529146,
-0.3163043857,
-0.5652623177,
-0.3974148631,
0.0150284991,
0.6210947633,
0.080487296,
1.0222754478,
0.6069434881,
0.9446048141,
0.2755389512,
0.0729944408,
0.1568285525,
-0.056831874,
0.2865508199,
-0.2930821478,
-0.3330715597,
-0.5740683675,
0.1019456685,
0.3565894961,
0.5594835877,
-0.2413033098,
-0.1338390559,
-0.6001492143,
0.6084920168,
-0.4400742352,
0.0655152053,
-0.330778271,
-0.0434131436,
-0.1869695038,
0.0703845099,
0.0645561963,
-0.1727016866,
0.4659369588,
-0.6989196539,
0.0174584277,
-0.0942102075,
0.796615243,
0.6156698465,
-0.6063973904,
-0.4533146918,
-0.5203213692,
0.3511654735,
-0.5818914175,
0.391025275,
0.0657483786,
0.6184346676,
-0.2215289921,
-1.1442788839,
-0.3045085967,
-0.5022499561,
0.1714036018,
0.5062273145,
0.0522062331,
0.0552854985,
0.0673107728,
0.1991154999,
-0.4022385478,
-0.0537150092,
-0.6260019541,
-0.1006594449,
0.225083977,
0.3344174922,
0.2545800507,
-0.2578521967,
-0.2861754596,
0.0988033265,
-0.3443175554,
-0.02931601,
-0.2104029804,
-0.1703508049,
-0.1153939441,
0.5970296264,
0.0454963967,
0.5066179633,
-0.1078671068,
-0.2645344436,
0.177630201,
-0.3213030696,
-0.0547397323,
-0.4097498357,
0.6680221558,
0.3329494596,
-0.163779065,
0.0261056758,
-0.0984781906,
0.4977994561,
0.5067655444,
-0.714680016,
-0.1271255314,
0.5232012868,
-0.8711343408,
-0.0629713461,
0.0158051196,
-0.3007605076,
-0.4288288355,
-0.2123865187,
0.7956278324,
-0.7807107568,
-0.2429453135,
0.3260283768,
-0.4041972458,
-0.3430201709,
0.227381587,
-0.7377319932,
0.2252898365,
0.7349292636,
0.6066343784,
-0.2444893271,
-0.1735834181,
-0.1298488528,
-0.1371884495,
-0.4762324989,
0.4928605258,
-0.6169241071,
-0.431217581,
-0.2837762535,
-0.2664585114,
-0.1997171342,
-0.6977642179,
0.5328056812,
-0.1516015977,
0.3279581368,
-0.0881644413,
-0.4170957208,
0.0026591795,
0.4928373098,
-0.5579664111,
0.5673161149,
0.2538334131,
-0.563500464,
0.3775794506,
-0.9815185666,
-0.3723877966,
-0.1946056336,
-0.3744956553,
-0.339648217,
0.3251187503,
0.3900983036,
0.5810227394,
-0.4085172415,
0.4778657556,
-0.2046757489,
-0.3295091391,
0.5472196937,
-0.4221246243,
0.228384167,
0.2740912139,
-0.0953177139,
0.3152908087,
-0.7351444364,
-0.2434490919,
-0.0413322113,
-0.4092759192,
-0.2534505129,
-0.1006762907,
0.15982382,
0.5882162452,
0.1495382637,
-0.4933383465,
0.2240633518,
-0.5080467463,
0.6775362492,
0.4193776846,
-0.1448768377,
0.1350843757,
-0.3175527453,
0.495803833,
0.2494461089,
1.0045957565,
-0.3748544455,
-0.8070149422,
-0.4243481159,
-0.7635671496,
0.3891586661,
0.1868074089,
-0.8825818896,
0.0323342569,
-0.2060145885,
-0.507447958,
-0.8340519667,
-0.3978662789,
0.4025046527,
0.7127584815,
0.4550577402,
-0.5924315453,
-0.1687673181,
-1.1437526941,
-0.2093364596,
0.0564021878,
-0.0852699876,
0.6578666568,
0.6583929658,
-0.8956893682,
0.6582567096,
-0.208848998,
-0.2263450027,
-0.1181606203,
0.1144055277,
0.611269176,
0.2673116624,
0.4586428702,
-1.2075937986,
-0.2694524527,
-0.1272372752,
-0.7591455579,
0.1908640265,
-0.0380355455,
0.0345265009,
0.1742064655,
0.1248518974,
-0.7453351021,
0.4021761417,
0.754745841,
-0.568577826,
0.4218089283,
-0.5525003672,
0.2553288639,
-1.1964887381,
0.3863052726,
-0.0126573108,
-0.1407238245,
-0.6490636468,
0.1792500615,
0.4640116096,
-0.0591443405,
-0.3897277713,
0.4240232706,
-0.1080509499,
-0.0933074951,
-0.1051591188,
-0.0674613565,
-0.1904006004,
0.0656408668,
-0.0512036569,
0.3686955273,
0.7314903736,
-0.5712902546,
0.3497634232,
0.2436881661,
-0.2566988468,
0.6814162731,
-0.4300750792,
-0.2405669093,
-0.4075471163,
0.3387033939,
-0.8115054369,
-0.4151310623,
0.0980221853,
-0.6864649057,
0.4354043901,
-0.0608601272,
-0.2359674424,
-0.6589157581,
-0.1864122003,
0.2137504369,
0.381064117,
-0.3654162288,
0.8938522339,
0.2339459211,
-0.1281194389,
-0.9237234592,
-0.32282722,
0.3183728158,
0.0653812289,
-0.6759155989,
0.7405902147,
-0.0735178292,
0.0251589492,
-0.0126270903,
-0.3369608223,
0.0202477686,
0.0585949309,
0.5156823993,
0.7957540751,
-0.0572315082,
0.2514476776,
0.1323489398,
-0.4697253406,
0.0570487678,
-0.310433507,
0.3288222253,
-0.1308894455,
-0.5365842581,
-0.3610551357,
0.278962642,
1.1570804119,
-0.1751119047,
0.7453507781,
0.7285708785,
-0.4771059453,
0.5360321999,
-0.7295582294,
-0.3828106225,
-0.3803205788,
0.6263883114,
-0.3211232126,
-0.6839256287,
0.3837962449,
-0.06675338,
0.0069779605,
0.6032925248,
0.5531745553,
-0.3846026659,
1.2059233189,
0.394477427,
0.0021396121,
0.2004562318,
-0.284817189,
-0.230172962,
-0.7503836155,
-0.6553894877,
-0.313283205,
-0.4008621871,
-0.5646477938,
-0.4721257091,
1.0918329954,
-0.5533233881,
-0.207431376,
-0.1933323741,
-0.5542654395,
0.0604514219,
0.6855253577,
0.4487634301,
0.2189027369,
-0.3876959085,
-0.4697061181,
-0.0945177302,
-0.6904969811,
-0.061291445,
1.4373230934,
0.3824136257,
0.8155735135,
0.0682845339,
0.393340528,
0.0382300317,
0.7403817177,
-0.7314921021,
0.2016166747,
-0.5451756716,
-1.2146382332,
0.0327817351,
-0.4599632323,
-0.7898292542,
0.2335992754,
-0.8453805447,
-0.1983577758,
-0.2425257266,
0.0445004851,
-0.6577698588,
0.0575177558,
-0.3260186017,
0.8165825605,
-0.4906827509,
-0.2847804725,
-0.4164642394,
-1.160492897,
0.2171129286,
-0.1098462641,
0.2690961659,
0.053681545,
-0.4071760476,
0.3574980795,
-0.1672791243,
0.5096004605,
-0.1108786836,
0.4865940213,
-0.2378885597,
-0.2192309797,
0.0165000632,
0.1322874725,
0.2372127026,
0.1774017662,
0.3278764486,
-0.2403600067,
-0.456320405,
0.6884248257,
-0.9061712623,
-0.3882135749,
-0.5616071224,
-0.4782686532,
-0.1916712224,
0.158353284,
0.3440023661,
0.6488728523,
-0.0915104672,
0.2515998185,
0.4058208466,
-0.4437641799,
0.1806996912,
0.5099270344,
-0.2924365103,
-0.6005985737,
0.5433539748,
0.0202640034,
0.0710861981,
0.5268110037,
0.3075900376,
-0.6109002829,
-0.5940573215,
-0.5942919254,
0.3365474641,
-0.5759999156,
0.0263578035,
-0.7787879705,
-0.2091268301,
-0.2084368169,
0.0376466624,
-0.7178518772,
-0.5202032328,
-0.0341957696,
0.3855997324,
0.0067987526,
0.7550597191,
0.0692117661,
0.0653318092,
-0.9624356031,
0.6832348108,
0.1126029789,
0.5049602389,
-0.5415244699,
-0.2354717702,
-0.1273323894,
-0.2419043928,
-0.4693415761,
-0.8130782843,
0.2985467017,
-0.1061423793,
0.6262107491,
0.5321674943,
-0.3306581378,
0.6228013039,
-0.2181209624,
0.6205918789,
0.4816220999,
-0.6426945329,
0.3886250257,
-0.4170001745,
0.2245155573,
0.3243800402,
0.6053145528,
-0.6524247527,
-0.0919378102,
-0.5971862078,
-0.6898828745,
0.4033496976,
0.3426696062,
-0.0265303832,
-0.1205297634,
0.8094879985,
0.2992908955,
0.307913959,
-0.3340270221,
-0.2519637346,
-0.2875414193,
-0.4976376295,
-0.123482421,
0.0564398766,
-0.1148481146,
-0.2058142424,
0.4490146637,
-0.1938807368,
0.3613617718,
0.3995416164,
0.2480046451,
0.198621124,
0.2286983877,
0.4857898653,
0.5721278787,
-0.1490150094,
-0.1554920822,
-0.0223108679,
-0.7271650434,
-0.1919383556,
0.3778278232,
0.2808098197,
-0.1908356994,
0.1108272746,
0.3163458109,
0.2705585063,
-0.8412489891,
0.6601876616,
-0.4389817715,
-0.1177343354,
-0.2623866498,
0.1031102091,
0.2911301851,
0.4264627397,
0.2756756246,
0.7832458615,
0.441783458,
-0.6754398346,
0.0560435206,
0.5256927609,
-0.3543860912,
-0.1432670802,
1.0064128637,
0.2392061651,
0.0148834698,
0.9042655826,
0.5259730816,
-0.2568469048,
0.7785469294,
0.4813268185,
0.1574467123,
-0.2409690917,
-0.0401766598,
0.2518782318,
0.1324264556,
-0.4647156596,
0.518219471,
0.2144310176,
-0.5919554234,
-0.3381524682,
-0.1344539225,
-0.6587308645,
-0.0913852379,
-0.5650443435,
0.1993259043,
-0.5082274079,
-0.8527722955,
0.2138082832,
-0.2236539871,
-0.7438628674,
0.4966215491,
0.3071418107,
1.1740466356,
-0.2903074026,
0.746794939,
0.80739218,
-0.2359493822,
-0.361208111,
-0.3357228339,
0.1051436067,
-0.7680841088,
0.2706080675,
0.4708508253,
0.025847096,
-0.3742434978,
-0.3764290214,
-0.9023865461,
1.2594561577,
0.3296349049,
-0.4661973119,
-0.2191367894,
-0.2067506611,
0.6620982885,
-0.4809548259,
0.5860645771,
0.4993017316,
0.3202659488,
0.2772135437,
-1.1099272966,
-0.169358179,
-0.3291170597,
-0.0431143492,
0.1275209039,
-0.6086063981,
0.9332625866,
-0.5055140853,
0.1175753325,
0.5007146597,
0.0806211829,
0.3684296012,
0.6538538337,
0.183900401,
0.3910301328,
0.6383639574,
-0.3310933411,
1.2981650829,
-0.5144842267,
0.0435698256,
0.4571091533,
0.009759238,
0.8325013518,
0.5113505721,
0.0417750068,
0.4205350578,
0.4381870925,
0.1948967725,
0.4342810512,
-0.15620175,
-0.1992343068,
-0.3009911478,
0.1257577091,
-0.4609854519,
0.4773382246,
0.81563586,
-0.7132049799,
0.4957616329,
0.1488773376,
-0.0811385512,
-0.0993274599,
-0.4048466086,
0.5084857941,
0.0968227312,
-0.861687839,
0.2104341537,
0.2132005841,
0.8757258654,
-0.8564655781,
0.1081989557,
-0.0361878127,
0.513828516,
-0.1230068579,
-0.5383347273,
0.231686607,
-0.3116340637,
0.0173720866,
0.0631586388,
0.7327839732,
0.1112049744,
-0.490255326,
0.2821227908,
0.5475880504,
0.0911048502,
-0.181403935,
-0.6813076735,
-0.1490639746,
-0.3467334807,
-0.0896148905,
0.2849256098,
0.1429390162,
0.1078715324,
1.0868706703,
0.7070782185,
0.0449302085,
-0.0816655755,
-0.0424905866,
1.0589387417,
-0.9229586124,
-0.3642038703,
-0.8261628151,
0.5257769227,
-0.0017657962,
-0.5091525912,
0.2392127961,
0.4540273547,
0.4218522012,
-0.2328825742,
0.7723498344,
-0.0045569395,
0.4863000214,
-0.3955914378,
0.8668367267,
-0.7833865285,
0.0044773472,
0.0469383635,
-0.4267256856,
-0.665708065,
0.6291935444,
-0.1781095117,
0.2767835259,
0.7330465913,
0.6747075915,
-0.1203967109,
0.1323563457,
0.4945274293,
0.3894363344,
0.2334320843,
0.7752028704,
1.1512343884,
-0.3040346205,
0.5369257331,
-0.0215508118,
-0.6136751771,
-0.3317112625,
-0.4937028885,
-1.0434571505,
-0.4116595089,
0.1031596884,
-0.3398599625,
0.2284374386,
1.1751884222,
1.0831538439,
-0.4255808592,
0.3136099279,
0.4172420502,
-0.3054167628,
-0.4148201644,
-0.0155398902,
0.2465880215,
0.0748437941,
-0.5105950236,
0.4703679383,
0.7282290459,
-0.0465514697,
-0.3022209406,
-0.243810609,
0.1483727098,
0.039974574,
0.4016250372,
-0.0219592769,
-0.8600467443,
0.1307249963,
0.3733145893,
-0.3820036054,
0.0486093275,
0.8024315834,
-0.9274208546,
0.619863987,
0.1403639466,
0.4106889963,
0.6902340651,
-0.1223292574,
0.349234134,
-0.2140175402,
-0.2001514882,
0.4129129648,
0.6176578403,
0.2294043154,
-0.3049904704,
0.47295928,
0.1858285069,
-0.4472384751,
-0.2309484929,
0.1707659215,
-0.8684013486,
-0.5723061562,
0.7518597245,
-0.0260544699,
-0.0032709518,
-0.1881579906,
-0.3931939006,
0.2313346863,
-0.3219467402,
1.1508959532,
0.3275809586,
-0.3944723606,
0.1005350128,
-0.633457005,
0.2450945079,
0.3862490356,
-0.7912272811,
-0.5927124619,
0.4528518617,
0.6134737134,
0.2350432575,
0.673209846,
-0.7364052534,
0.720336616,
-0.0645056739,
-0.1754233688,
-0.3904653192,
-0.7215793133,
-0.0967110246,
0.3319219351,
-0.1906415522,
-0.1376717389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00732v1
|
LoRA Land: 310 Fine-tuned LLMs that Rival GPT-4, A Technical Report
| 2024-04-29T04:01:45 | 2024-04-29T04:01:45 |
Justin Zhao, Timothy Wang, Wael Abid, Geoffrey Angus, Arnav Garg, Jeffery Kinnison, Alex Sherstinsky, Piero Molino, Travis Addair, Devvret Rishi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Low Rank Adaptation (LoRA) has emerged as one of the most widely adopted
methods for Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) of Large Language Models
(LLMs). LoRA reduces the number of trainable parameters and memory usage while
achieving comparable performance to full fine-tuning. We aim to assess the
viability of training and serving LLMs fine-tuned with LoRA in real-world
applications. First, we measure the quality of LLMs fine-tuned with quantized
low rank adapters across 10 base models and 31 tasks for a total of 310 models.
We find that 4-bit LoRA fine-tuned models outperform base models by 34 points
and GPT-4 by 10 points on average. Second, we investigate the most effective
base models for fine-tuning and assess the correlative and predictive
capacities of task complexity heuristics in forecasting the outcomes of
fine-tuning. Finally, we evaluate the latency and concurrency capabilities of
LoRAX, an open-source Multi-LoRA inference server that facilitates the
deployment of multiple LoRA fine-tuned models on a single GPU using shared base
model weights and dynamic adapter loading. LoRAX powers LoRA Land, a web
application that hosts 25 LoRA fine-tuned Mistral-7B LLMs on a single NVIDIA
A100 GPU with 80GB memory. LoRA Land highlights the quality and
cost-effectiveness of employing multiple specialized LLMs over a single,
general-purpose LLM.
|
[
-0.5600582957,
-0.9261979461,
0.5703104138,
0.083586216,
-0.2877117693,
0.0586046614,
-0.3689305186,
-0.5843482018,
-0.0422772504,
0.6428923607,
-0.1447871327,
-0.4111215174,
-0.5049023032,
-0.0577296168,
-0.2989497185,
1.0004235506,
-0.0355572812,
-0.24984321,
0.303746134,
-0.2706613839,
-0.3800438941,
-0.4176633954,
-0.7188531756,
-0.4216756523,
0.8417313099,
0.4476221204,
0.7332920432,
0.4409037232,
0.4728810489,
0.2517497838,
-0.1380899101,
0.3447144628,
-0.8582175374,
-0.176063031,
-0.2609007359,
-0.5852261782,
-1.0156924725,
-0.0713256001,
0.6655122042,
0.5489233732,
-0.2100895345,
0.3109883666,
0.1158504486,
0.7739474177,
-0.6826168299,
-0.0658768117,
-1.024566412,
-0.0358303413,
-0.2951703072,
-0.3283721209,
-0.2796317935,
-0.3587305844,
-0.0694358125,
-0.7722272277,
-0.062811479,
0.1005564407,
0.865902245,
0.5760921836,
-0.222507596,
0.1444705427,
-0.817617178,
0.7672565579,
-0.8843224645,
0.173800081,
0.3784024417,
0.4004432559,
-0.3440741897,
-0.5114647746,
-0.2874957025,
0.0115073454,
0.568880558,
0.0852021053,
-0.2442942262,
0.0962719321,
0.3605962694,
0.5372299552,
-0.2360454202,
0.5498045087,
-0.2206069678,
0.0584163442,
0.3650000989,
0.0553812645,
-0.1144471839,
0.205593437,
-0.0861254483,
0.1678624898,
-1.1585786343,
-0.050038822,
0.5444232225,
0.5991734266,
-0.1048218235,
0.5108238459,
-0.3714823723,
0.9682226181,
0.2833658755,
-0.374288857,
-0.1497944295,
-0.2624095976,
-0.3380842805,
-0.218921572,
0.5486962795,
0.1602139026,
0.4162115753,
-0.2332556546,
-0.342071116,
0.0361280479,
0.1206120029,
-0.7077707052,
-0.0943099931,
-0.0903500095,
-0.1842033118,
-0.1793072373,
-0.3030309081,
-0.6982191205,
-0.4239709973,
-0.2389968932,
0.5847243071,
-0.3549971879,
0.0502195545,
0.3423736393,
0.1100262254,
0.4154457748,
0.6888285279,
-0.9915585518,
0.537584126,
0.6700231433,
0.7122612596,
-0.4062779248,
-0.3135876954,
-0.8603557348,
0.0318901204,
-0.1190495789,
1.0708318949,
-0.2739703953,
-0.1110327765,
-0.2187913656,
0.01671285,
-0.1201289296,
-0.7308157086,
0.4901841283,
-0.7102137208,
-0.2103180885,
-0.153728053,
-0.2665679753,
-0.0623320043,
0.2606543899,
-0.7228812575,
1.0151222944,
0.4001675546,
-0.32633394,
0.2821348608,
-0.6904286742,
-0.3582991362,
-0.0981921926,
0.1647057533,
-0.4283230305,
0.3619001806,
0.0953486711,
0.2087862194,
-0.5105589032,
-0.118229419,
-0.3858198822,
-0.6919633746,
0.0219596699,
-0.3969082832,
0.1085836962,
0.2971864939,
-0.312631458,
0.0405989625,
-0.6433863044,
0.1738404781,
-0.0210842676,
-0.8377978802,
-0.0034744956,
0.0559807159,
0.0394247547,
-0.0674924925,
0.4575594366,
-0.330327183,
0.2854515314,
-0.4527415931,
0.6306125522,
0.7090013027,
-0.1589549929,
0.3669264913,
-0.3646084368,
0.566627264,
-0.1485592276,
0.1563758403,
0.2053173482,
-0.5184871554,
-0.9717584848,
-0.1055030599,
0.4441055655,
0.4062000513,
-0.5563411117,
0.3254375458,
-0.4100219607,
-0.5219659805,
-0.3791294694,
0.3861401081,
0.333771646,
0.1803788096,
0.2576779127,
-0.226374954,
-0.3656200171,
-0.7186890244,
-0.3760150373,
0.1467560828,
0.315918982,
0.3171609044,
0.3782584965,
-0.1366216093,
0.8485912085,
-0.2859493196,
-0.1892210692,
-0.158637628,
-0.057744123,
0.4531623721,
0.1866654158,
0.7938374877,
-0.4239177406,
-0.6102312207,
0.4239086807,
-0.4312648773,
0.031674698,
0.4092204273,
0.0148227485,
0.2272595912,
0.2113275081,
-0.2624916434,
0.297139734,
0.8835080862,
-0.3052146137,
0.2261185646,
-0.5406540632,
-0.0488752611,
-0.8125388622,
-0.0541552529,
-0.1555964351,
-0.4893677831,
-0.2680819035,
0.0709988475,
-0.2206982672,
-0.0579190627,
-0.3257664442,
0.5401474237,
-0.2148886472,
-0.4297895133,
-0.396057725,
0.1175932884,
-0.0787242576,
0.4886774123,
-0.2920599282,
1.1546020508,
0.3114778399,
-0.6309147477,
0.1787256896,
0.0435937122,
-0.4469326138,
0.4969452024,
-0.6312353015,
0.3273930848,
0.1984936744,
0.0293719899,
-0.6433209777,
-0.2389753908,
-0.0738252625,
0.0982540473,
-0.2580917776,
-0.4617898166,
-0.5314127207,
-0.0229414981,
-0.1834878474,
0.1734060645,
0.7712353468,
-0.5445670485,
0.6374798417,
0.3412932456,
-0.0502939336,
-0.2992190123,
-0.522705555,
-0.0140154725,
-0.4499263763,
-0.3043637574,
0.1818224192,
-0.2340365499,
-0.1728646755,
-0.2732227445,
-0.0870094746,
-0.0533037893,
0.3604839146,
0.4762330949,
-0.1285049021,
-0.5795471072,
-0.3412903249,
0.121981144,
-0.0849024951,
-0.3850154877,
-0.2381810695,
0.5411824584,
-0.5418022275,
-0.483392328,
-0.2169041932,
-0.1319514662,
0.6410942674,
0.0164300855,
0.6302352548,
0.4522833228,
-0.3547274172,
-0.2613683045,
-0.5134272575,
0.2096695155,
-0.4889272153,
0.3173645139,
-0.5924309492,
-0.9596259594,
0.5974313021,
-0.4675356746,
0.0796635151,
0.5306121111,
0.5438777804,
-0.2231621295,
0.6960373521,
0.7398753762,
-0.2080552727,
0.5999105573,
-0.2466133982,
0.1590979546,
-0.6554477811,
0.2152697891,
-0.4504633248,
-0.540604353,
-0.6453592181,
-0.5185065269,
0.4067066908,
0.3374423981,
-0.4497713149,
0.3323438764,
-0.2711368799,
0.6930943131,
0.4607081413,
0.1773509234,
0.7278866768,
0.3247270882,
0.3328876495,
0.0802755654,
-0.6623837948,
-0.5579327941,
1.0463870764,
0.3708436489,
1.0230833292,
0.2641223669,
0.4691703022,
0.4064572453,
0.1767658293,
-0.8262453079,
0.5116147995,
-0.6687174439,
-0.2896157801,
-0.4759471416,
-0.1369365752,
-0.9142755866,
0.0745618418,
-0.16448614,
-0.6243439913,
0.0630350411,
0.2585015893,
-0.77193892,
0.4212114811,
-0.748730123,
0.4954018295,
-0.3967072368,
-0.4223178327,
-0.4368683398,
-0.1312060505,
0.109263584,
-0.5655682087,
0.1001335457,
-0.454488337,
-0.0565500595,
0.7546020746,
-0.2887483835,
0.8057637811,
-0.2573426366,
-0.5113441944,
0.0466469377,
-0.140834406,
0.6476714015,
0.0812307298,
-0.4498908222,
0.1554443687,
0.1152349263,
-0.4049926698,
-0.4422158003,
1.1565603018,
-1.2868629694,
-0.4206455946,
-0.1592992693,
-0.523984015,
-0.5307125449,
0.29100281,
0.1960777342,
0.2182705104,
-0.2512283921,
0.0953042358,
0.7280655503,
-0.1675717831,
0.2864620686,
0.6050953269,
-0.2768065035,
-0.3182945549,
0.9482684731,
0.0955652967,
0.4145555496,
0.3167347014,
0.0624187812,
0.1676745117,
-1.0606374741,
-0.3378355801,
0.1190853268,
-0.542719245,
-0.2456366867,
-0.1779515147,
-0.3066451848,
0.0624445602,
-0.1211087555,
-0.7361360788,
-0.4113751054,
-0.2399079949,
0.296864897,
0.7193719745,
1.0509160757,
0.2905607522,
0.8914419413,
-0.3423427641,
0.5809921622,
0.3716695011,
0.6609044671,
-0.4035771191,
-0.9683440328,
-0.2417802513,
0.1469296366,
-0.2323289812,
-0.185489729,
0.1777783334,
0.4481766224,
0.327442348,
0.2414362878,
-0.1750093102,
1.0442806482,
-0.5916221142,
0.4853852391,
-0.1495767087,
-0.7751805782,
0.4713954031,
-0.6550536156,
0.3112895489,
0.745231986,
-0.1062433422,
0.0227705557,
0.0381708592,
-0.3252157569,
-0.522834003,
0.5813834667,
-0.1416010261,
0.0791455358,
0.4478875399,
0.6569740772,
0.3791647851,
-0.0200585537,
-0.7153859138,
-0.1110784113,
-0.0451870784,
0.0510072634,
-0.2126672417,
-0.2273132503,
-0.2145651579,
-0.3104884326,
0.5816575289,
-0.4776354134,
0.1860673726,
-0.3294986188,
-0.0688828006,
-0.270329833,
0.403749764,
0.6488981843,
0.8158125281,
-0.4073570967,
0.0555127524,
0.6059798002,
-0.388615936,
-0.0345323905,
0.0836968496,
-0.0170527548,
-0.2418511659,
0.1325124502,
1.0029578209,
0.4827549756,
-0.5253941417,
0.1060929522,
-0.0080894837,
-0.2147938162,
-0.2045291811,
0.5100981593,
0.180600062,
0.302011162,
0.2331936657,
0.1446724236,
-0.2015972435,
-0.4695131779,
-0.3157698214,
0.5001351237,
-0.2364437729,
-0.5136831403,
0.4494850934,
0.3126304448,
-0.1982767731,
0.2894726694,
0.0192631837,
-0.062729463,
0.3934818208,
0.5219672322,
0.4321777225,
0.1124088541,
-0.1398627758,
0.1882962883,
0.2915072441,
-0.2060286552,
0.4479417205,
0.2334106714,
-0.7042998672,
-0.5705392361,
-0.855830729,
-0.6668096781,
0.3112054169,
-0.483073324,
0.2697304785,
-0.644549191,
-0.3463171422,
-0.0520040095,
0.1344414055,
-0.6561601162,
-0.0854719132,
0.2617280483,
1.0580410957,
-0.747753799,
1.1653590202,
0.7815898657,
-0.0693718642,
-0.6891928911,
-0.1838241369,
-0.4548784792,
-1.011860013,
0.4411262274,
-0.3675853014,
-0.4677953422,
0.3757879436,
-0.539086163,
-0.9944522977,
1.1800687313,
0.8330446482,
-0.7287858725,
-0.1096353009,
0.3324297071,
0.5265171528,
-0.09260571,
-0.0364813432,
0.7647206783,
0.5534543395,
-0.0676730499,
-1.2924329042,
-0.2699289918,
0.1219956353,
-0.0516045019,
0.2379276156,
-0.7225895524,
0.8792364001,
-0.1699952632,
0.2141331136,
0.5088536143,
0.4379509985,
0.4988334775,
0.0092264209,
0.5615906715,
0.5386553407,
0.8088167906,
-0.2932158113,
0.902769804,
-0.4211942852,
0.3803581595,
1.1308984756,
-0.469609797,
1.128185153,
0.6400173306,
-0.4060949683,
0.5094835758,
0.5469514728,
0.1561276466,
0.6110768914,
0.1355420947,
-0.1754178703,
-0.383408457,
-0.034773618,
-0.4862768054,
0.5741955042,
0.4481339753,
0.0343730822,
-0.3388303816,
0.0022769228,
-0.1251916587,
-0.1439081132,
-0.5243515372,
0.709610939,
0.1699083745,
-0.7077662349,
0.8479650617,
0.1357583106,
0.7954272628,
-0.7296264768,
0.0712303519,
-0.4582832456,
0.5507580638,
-0.2991061509,
-0.587857008,
-0.0684180856,
0.1332464665,
-0.2046636939,
-0.1563901305,
0.6871033907,
-0.0122773647,
-0.1872888505,
0.2581937015,
0.6909120679,
0.197852388,
-0.3101036549,
-0.5218863487,
0.2887392044,
-0.1707659215,
-0.2833039761,
0.752476573,
0.5098818541,
-0.215402633,
0.6858929396,
0.6326797009,
0.2914379835,
0.1306908131,
0.0735577121,
0.936397016,
-0.7354669571,
-0.3225006461,
-0.5962766409,
-0.0175510086,
0.3274930418,
-0.3330826163,
0.6904580593,
0.5602658391,
0.4390372932,
-0.0963398218,
0.8273625374,
0.115292564,
0.3460695148,
-0.6516129971,
0.5084260106,
-0.4648529589,
0.2910137475,
0.0561657287,
-1.0966025591,
-0.0324958935,
0.4006131291,
-0.4813968539,
0.1041734517,
0.4525434971,
0.5499910116,
-0.4057887793,
-0.2239200026,
0.5762845874,
0.2329087704,
0.0419254228,
0.805519402,
0.8934558034,
-0.6528457403,
0.4525737762,
-0.0180853028,
-0.0418584533,
-0.3419951499,
-1.0160118341,
-0.8211507201,
-0.1410981864,
-0.2551787794,
-0.1388304681,
0.4042613506,
0.5100845098,
0.9548948407,
-0.923605442,
-0.2463292629,
-0.0394100174,
-0.0193509143,
-0.1040286869,
-0.1208317876,
0.1523400545,
-0.0729323402,
-0.7537600994,
0.6381443739,
0.3002264798,
-0.0539762042,
-0.2550949156,
-0.3272069693,
0.0290375501,
0.0362858512,
0.7107285261,
0.4691660702,
-0.9003491998,
-0.3472152352,
-0.1591770351,
-0.1793936938,
0.1395249814,
0.5422559977,
-0.860049367,
-0.0245533455,
0.2059852183,
0.6443116069,
0.5512858033,
0.06130445,
0.459734261,
-0.4582485259,
0.12896052,
-0.0826756656,
0.4700336456,
0.0575296246,
-0.1181910783,
0.6913414001,
-0.075469777,
-0.6649849415,
-0.6779238582,
0.0418349914,
-1.3845002651,
0.0307438653,
1.2512050867,
-0.0115671344,
-0.0672324523,
-0.1350801438,
-0.2755184174,
-0.0880452693,
-0.3411566019,
0.5009382963,
0.4535734355,
-0.2637693584,
-0.1036513224,
-0.8846353889,
0.3875097036,
0.4874566197,
-1.1205830574,
-0.0499907807,
0.1758093387,
0.4626553655,
0.0189609677,
0.4943223,
0.1218720675,
0.2013054192,
-0.3795446455,
-0.0944641605,
-0.0358052701,
-0.0608573556,
-0.4240107536,
0.2159474045,
0.8556605577,
0.0976444334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18410v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18410v1
|
Mixture-of-Instructions: Comprehensive Alignment of a Large Language Model through the Mixture of Diverse System Prompting Instructions
| 2024-04-29T03:58:12 | 2024-04-29T03:58:12 |
Bowen Xu, Shaoyu Wu, Kai Liu, Lulu Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the proliferation of large language models (LLMs), the comprehensive
alignment of such models across multiple tasks has emerged as a critical area
of research. Existing alignment methodologies primarily address single task,
such as multi-turn dialogue, coding, mathematical problem-solving, and tool
usage. However, AI-driven products that leverage language models usually
necessitate a fusion of these abilities to function effectively in real-world
scenarios. Moreover, the considerable computational resources required for
proper alignment of LLMs underscore the need for a more robust, efficient, and
encompassing approach to multi-task alignment, ensuring improved generative
performance. In response to these challenges, we introduce a novel technique
termed Mixture-of-Instructions (MoI), which employs a strategy of instruction
concatenation combined with diverse system prompts to boost the alignment
efficiency of language models. We have also compiled a diverse set of seven
benchmark datasets to rigorously evaluate the alignment efficacy of the
MoI-enhanced language model. Our methodology was applied to the open-source
Qwen-7B-chat model, culminating in the development of Qwen-SFT-MoI. This
enhanced model demonstrates significant advancements in generative capabilities
across coding, mathematics, and tool use tasks.
|
[
-0.2403450757,
-0.8705271482,
0.4931742251,
0.293092221,
-0.2104864269,
0.5043331981,
-0.1403227597,
-0.0846800953,
-0.064523384,
0.5839542747,
-0.748801589,
-0.4991526008,
-0.5085278153,
-0.0404243767,
-0.523425281,
0.686199367,
0.0863227546,
0.2249633521,
-0.3850356638,
-0.1991332173,
-0.8417637944,
-0.3147243559,
-0.1478196084,
-0.2537281513,
0.2847096026,
0.6668484807,
0.5348729491,
0.7593333721,
0.6867733002,
0.382430017,
0.2342016101,
0.4979724586,
-0.5940697193,
0.2292046845,
-0.1083127782,
-0.5096768141,
-0.4645427763,
-0.2476082295,
0.7088719606,
0.8300930858,
-0.5033932924,
-0.2204280049,
0.4376161993,
0.5496100783,
-0.6569944024,
-0.284293741,
-0.3873831034,
-0.2129365355,
-0.2149294615,
-0.1873589307,
-0.4826751649,
-0.2527378201,
0.0807078853,
-0.6774536967,
-0.1684925407,
0.0572864935,
0.3971058428,
0.2147586942,
-0.0898822919,
-0.194878608,
-0.8117688894,
1.1631584167,
-0.6518279314,
0.3935834169,
-0.2204511911,
0.3355444968,
-0.3755129874,
-0.4061539173,
-0.5826330185,
-0.0816674009,
0.1912777424,
0.285090059,
-0.2085275501,
0.2607397437,
0.1005363017,
0.5187562108,
-0.5731102228,
0.3388742208,
-0.1481655538,
-0.1064778939,
0.3135825098,
0.3188374341,
0.7434319258,
0.195734337,
-0.6813889742,
-0.1938358992,
-0.5947699547,
-0.3379590809,
0.4122632742,
0.226562202,
-0.5643882751,
0.9234858751,
-0.2216175944,
0.9015161991,
0.3065926433,
-0.4182533324,
0.0675038546,
-0.5944828391,
-0.1800919622,
0.1730373949,
1.1105768681,
0.3435217142,
-0.1916168183,
-0.1477803737,
-0.1331647038,
0.0284223966,
0.2661670446,
-0.579366982,
-0.0324402489,
0.2433579564,
-0.356422931,
-0.2166081965,
0.0051816418,
-0.7475161552,
-0.381809175,
-0.5730592608,
0.4863735139,
-0.7884379029,
-0.1094830036,
0.2340285182,
-0.1682154387,
0.1854477525,
0.4303897321,
-0.8223922849,
0.2294280082,
1.0278837681,
0.7562504411,
-0.2533505261,
-0.284147054,
-0.7772343159,
0.193747431,
-0.1629141569,
0.5371384621,
-0.9519836307,
-0.506768465,
-0.2095828503,
-0.4394629896,
-0.1579520553,
-0.4984451532,
0.2814103663,
-0.1638099551,
0.5537011623,
-0.0710265264,
-0.6701080203,
-0.1975761652,
0.1076087728,
-0.5339298844,
1.1429829597,
0.3663232327,
-0.6602373719,
-0.2033135444,
-0.5910433531,
-0.4080043137,
0.07023184,
-0.3724877834,
-0.0046111811,
0.2426605225,
0.167632997,
0.3172483146,
-0.5798612833,
0.3420329094,
-0.2146420032,
-0.4878492951,
0.4487132728,
-0.6891291142,
0.9105901718,
0.0678634346,
-0.4047091007,
0.3135326505,
-0.7179831862,
-0.215153262,
-0.3212718666,
-0.0907717794,
-0.2935803831,
-0.1022660732,
-0.408801645,
0.0847881511,
0.4380621016,
-0.3599963486,
0.3308802247,
-0.1780474335,
0.2662610412,
0.6063693166,
-0.2559166551,
0.7016711235,
-0.392645061,
0.6594748497,
0.1144119874,
0.1243010089,
-0.501549542,
-0.4686437845,
-0.8031929135,
-0.5989796519,
0.3498595655,
0.8948712945,
-0.8624376059,
0.7726724148,
-0.4066016674,
-0.5562404394,
-0.7593818903,
0.101655148,
0.6296867728,
0.5436574221,
0.3232072294,
-0.2840328813,
-0.4449433982,
-0.9500548244,
0.3067829013,
-0.0475792624,
-0.0004272799,
0.0232126024,
0.1080606058,
-0.1593080759,
0.4849114418,
-0.3003458679,
0.3293562531,
-0.2827464044,
0.2695837319,
-0.1379799545,
0.764578104,
0.259298861,
-0.3987832367,
-0.4086314738,
0.3289107978,
-0.6612829566,
-0.2944541276,
-0.0992444307,
-0.7576576471,
-0.2467720658,
0.3553106487,
-0.4952946305,
-0.0453725234,
0.7996200919,
0.3231551945,
0.5814960599,
-0.1532000005,
0.533551693,
-1.3977013826,
-0.1133506671,
-0.116523616,
-0.1482815892,
-0.5883361697,
0.3093470037,
-0.0079091694,
-0.1036140025,
-0.4204027057,
0.2439947575,
-0.5748776197,
0.2612108886,
-0.3585042655,
0.074208945,
0.1021133587,
0.340533644,
-0.2726173997,
1.0076761246,
0.8138873577,
-0.5740146637,
0.44761464,
0.0491695479,
-0.2902178466,
0.8720892072,
-0.3791873455,
0.2732158303,
-0.0987321436,
0.1112257168,
-0.9730018377,
-0.2707050145,
0.4497947693,
-0.0192245562,
0.4429258704,
0.1461804211,
-0.4314722717,
-0.0556090213,
-0.2595254779,
0.6113783121,
0.6995848417,
-0.252235949,
1.0197963715,
0.2368478924,
-0.1128101945,
-0.7695146203,
-0.4833932817,
-0.0614971295,
-0.3972695172,
-0.6980397105,
0.7537547946,
-0.0250628758,
-0.2934768498,
-0.0437451378,
-0.0364364833,
0.2492932379,
0.1160055175,
0.0372396857,
0.5086269379,
-0.4627377093,
-0.265917629,
0.280818373,
-0.0151597681,
-0.3463014066,
-0.3491051197,
0.8444911242,
0.3223124146,
-0.6771530509,
-0.7610203624,
0.7458292842,
0.7205505967,
-0.381308496,
0.7567387223,
0.3979830742,
-0.3124935925,
-0.0807296485,
-0.6709453464,
-0.0861947462,
-0.469753474,
0.3633363545,
-0.2248273939,
-0.8199689388,
0.5134130716,
-0.1799867451,
0.172841832,
0.2496272475,
0.3653237522,
-0.2135797739,
1.0596894026,
0.7195834517,
-0.1555724144,
0.6861346364,
0.0287975762,
0.3357383013,
-1.0074763298,
-0.1522413492,
-0.594661653,
-0.5103293657,
-0.5715553164,
-0.8068705797,
0.3503126502,
0.3413767815,
-0.128371045,
0.3928510249,
-0.6404623985,
0.4574902654,
0.6018721461,
0.1597308815,
0.0726488531,
0.1574194878,
-0.219292134,
0.1609074026,
-0.9172760844,
-0.5808093548,
0.8259388208,
0.0034107328,
0.8751114011,
0.0034174572,
0.9671943784,
0.0584853999,
0.236029774,
-0.6041290164,
0.6503862739,
-0.4851477146,
-0.1318985224,
-0.1343878508,
-0.4629986584,
-0.7144801617,
0.2394512892,
-0.1845248789,
-1.0103491545,
0.0359752104,
0.0533166416,
-0.7520746589,
0.0227978081,
-0.8348329663,
0.8478657007,
-0.4691791236,
-0.286786586,
-0.307734251,
-0.643052876,
0.6495814919,
0.0761471018,
0.2068546116,
-0.0622752234,
-0.0744600594,
0.3954952657,
-0.4327176213,
0.9049206376,
0.2732389867,
-0.2786770463,
0.3389724493,
0.0737657622,
0.3865143359,
-0.5755174756,
-0.0106608635,
-0.0634424239,
-0.2842305005,
-0.2959692478,
-0.8172590137,
0.6967813373,
-0.6328424811,
-0.5985046625,
0.0356622189,
-0.8408128023,
-0.0751483217,
-0.0661549345,
0.2015977055,
0.7820079923,
-0.1977337152,
0.2569923401,
0.8315487504,
-0.3667038977,
0.0972782075,
0.2237636447,
-0.1141840443,
-0.5460000038,
1.2883061171,
-0.0809371769,
0.6953194737,
0.7750304937,
0.1012512296,
-0.0854441375,
-0.3720543683,
-0.730776608,
-0.0289756283,
-0.5814840198,
-0.236186251,
-0.6542496085,
-0.1568896025,
-0.1811386496,
-0.2251017392,
-0.2352248281,
-0.2846038342,
-0.2958898246,
0.270267725,
0.0901020095,
0.3974248171,
0.295332253,
0.7675014138,
-1.2535794973,
0.2906468511,
0.0934228152,
0.036824014,
0.0613900982,
-0.2332602143,
-0.1929223835,
0.4237493277,
-0.4739981294,
-1.1198357344,
-0.0353943482,
0.0206630714,
0.7754412293,
0.4182106853,
-0.2488450557,
0.9826439023,
-0.4263308048,
0.7819191813,
0.5148226619,
-1.0209511518,
0.2473563999,
-0.3620289266,
0.3399202824,
0.4605278373,
0.0985593125,
-0.550466001,
-0.6318057179,
-0.3881188929,
-0.7216666937,
0.6656141877,
0.2322727293,
0.1874348819,
0.0171396881,
0.0764887109,
0.4552614987,
0.2883551717,
-0.1038217172,
-0.0483980551,
0.2853521407,
-1.0080510378,
0.3969243467,
-0.0557839274,
-0.3031266034,
-0.0194875095,
0.5992617011,
-0.038448818,
0.34163481,
-0.3474755585,
-0.1727108806,
0.0939652771,
0.3163429499,
0.7951232791,
0.539057374,
0.2965052128,
0.18505992,
-0.0973701775,
-0.2697235048,
0.2907580137,
0.2442274839,
-0.13982822,
-0.3088828325,
0.3918707967,
0.8031036854,
0.4129266143,
-0.6302967668,
0.1969196796,
0.1565342247,
0.1101371273,
0.4446521699,
0.5738728642,
0.2233979404,
0.1340878308,
0.1576483995,
0.0246276371,
0.2174420506,
-0.6392034292,
0.0500120185,
0.501539886,
-0.1525453031,
-0.1579392999,
0.4147169888,
0.4771323502,
-0.3203643858,
0.7280266881,
-0.0743267834,
-0.5742030144,
0.5182594657,
0.5016976595,
0.9529693127,
-0.4261902571,
0.2066878825,
0.1445553452,
0.1726114452,
-0.3123087585,
0.3980179429,
-0.0498778969,
-0.7683650851,
-0.7641016841,
-0.4064181745,
-0.3770022094,
-0.1663542539,
-0.405359149,
0.2278335243,
-0.0204428788,
0.0958257318,
-0.0262933485,
-0.5050452948,
-0.4465789497,
0.0286317412,
0.3491758108,
0.5140802264,
-0.7174212337,
0.5023762584,
0.5825849771,
-0.2580776215,
-0.8118775487,
0.0476843566,
0.1035298035,
-0.8082796335,
0.1072202995,
0.3432795107,
-0.2362015098,
-0.0688571334,
-0.576943934,
-0.7455824018,
0.8731129169,
0.6340018511,
-0.9898136854,
0.1144512743,
0.2456553727,
0.195620656,
-0.6263905168,
0.218394801,
0.5312495828,
0.2771047056,
0.0870448723,
-0.8706352115,
0.0138578005,
-0.1451174021,
-0.0545956194,
0.4950073361,
-0.6018795371,
0.6615927219,
0.0497659892,
-0.2906283438,
0.1826739311,
0.7897738218,
0.3775233626,
-0.0898034945,
0.5195362568,
0.6476064324,
0.9464426637,
-0.19897829,
1.0103667974,
-0.497390151,
-0.2845444381,
1.127646327,
-0.4363825619,
0.5722663403,
0.4425771236,
-0.1074916348,
0.6257241964,
0.3530221581,
0.3444955647,
0.5074930787,
0.0685464069,
-0.4882307649,
-0.3381582499,
-0.2007509172,
-0.2442992926,
0.3968447149,
0.3828255534,
-0.0742891729,
-0.1042954177,
0.0301156547,
-0.2925107777,
-0.0561452806,
-0.102418974,
0.8804134727,
0.0131639503,
-0.9619098306,
0.2871097624,
-0.0800839961,
0.6805278659,
-0.5219489932,
-0.3453840315,
-0.0311074071,
-0.0009219473,
-0.0793086961,
-0.7654054761,
-0.0226880256,
0.0017096866,
-0.1216447279,
-0.0678939,
0.4565389752,
-0.8104621768,
-0.6588234901,
-0.0357313938,
0.6093272567,
0.0100410581,
0.1572488546,
-0.6543434858,
0.2898834646,
0.1156633943,
0.3228665888,
0.297672838,
0.6284561157,
-0.1603253186,
0.5833370686,
0.4959868193,
-0.4204256237,
0.2514007986,
0.2529186606,
0.8751875162,
-0.3377848566,
-0.3202680051,
-1.149990201,
0.9540877938,
-0.1265737712,
-0.1710242331,
0.6029179096,
0.6079898477,
0.654592514,
0.2020807117,
0.8689383268,
-0.018510174,
-0.0402648635,
-0.7343577743,
0.0620312914,
-0.4889447689,
0.2222854793,
-0.1490946412,
-1.105258584,
0.0400407426,
0.4010216594,
0.0285956375,
0.0276881754,
0.570985198,
0.9074503779,
-0.3862029612,
0.1368573308,
0.0780101269,
-0.3365032971,
0.1510451585,
0.3611452281,
1.0042316914,
-0.1174821779,
0.3520814776,
-0.4245127738,
-0.3112718165,
-0.277556777,
-0.8105106354,
-0.5873836875,
-0.4288422167,
-0.6064987779,
-0.1949961483,
-0.0110940514,
1.0831991434,
0.5666604042,
-0.5727239251,
-0.3902251124,
-0.0777871758,
0.0581412129,
-0.6603008509,
-0.1965232641,
0.0379483849,
-0.4207067788,
-0.8638077974,
0.6140986681,
0.6857067347,
0.1439518631,
-0.3275016546,
-0.0787215084,
-0.0273286253,
0.1972385794,
0.4260112047,
-0.2070058137,
-0.7210240364,
0.0360299535,
0.3493080139,
-0.4748936892,
0.1534813792,
0.7948206067,
-0.2199578881,
0.6989575028,
0.7613922358,
0.7449102402,
-0.0532196462,
0.3234043717,
1.2218798399,
-0.6599171758,
-0.0101401368,
0.1132542863,
0.393694073,
0.6182166934,
-0.3247357011,
0.1563981473,
-0.2092303783,
-0.3097806871,
-0.742223978,
0.222499758,
-1.2336224318,
0.0143405953,
0.9560288191,
-0.0026165282,
-0.4087683856,
0.2248508036,
-0.608993113,
0.4309612513,
-0.4505110085,
0.5559492707,
0.9458973408,
-0.0666978583,
-0.1045082062,
-0.2739333212,
-0.1289978623,
0.5142067671,
-0.8622570634,
-0.0584021062,
0.6744703054,
-0.0164001882,
0.2880256772,
0.337395072,
-0.1113387272,
0.2279949337,
0.052248735,
0.1946554631,
0.2255833894,
-0.275421381,
-0.1319759637,
0.1089834347,
-0.1532085836,
-0.6090998054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18400v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18400v2
|
LLM-SR: Scientific Equation Discovery via Programming with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T03:30:06 | 2024-06-02T20:17:59 |
Parshin Shojaee, Kazem Meidani, Shashank Gupta, Amir Barati Farimani, Chandan K Reddy
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
Mathematical equations have been unreasonably effective in describing complex
natural phenomena across various scientific disciplines. However, discovering
such insightful equations from data presents significant challenges due to the
necessity of navigating extremely high-dimensional combinatorial and nonlinear
hypothesis spaces. Traditional methods of equation discovery, commonly known as
symbolic regression, largely focus on extracting equations from data alone,
often neglecting the rich domain-specific prior knowledge that scientists
typically depend on. To bridge this gap, we introduce LLM-SR, a novel approach
that leverages the extensive scientific knowledge and robust code generation
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to discover scientific equations
from data in an efficient manner. Specifically, LLM-SR treats equations as
programs with mathematical operators and combines LLMs' scientific priors with
evolutionary search over equation programs. The LLM iteratively proposes new
equation skeleton hypotheses, drawing from its physical understanding, which
are then optimized against data to estimate skeleton parameters. We demonstrate
LLM-SR's effectiveness across three diverse scientific domains, where it
discovers physically accurate equations that provide significantly better fits
to in-domain and out-of-domain data compared to the well-established symbolic
regression baselines. Incorporating scientific prior knowledge also enables
LLM-SR to search the equation space more efficiently than baselines. Code is
available at: https://github.com/deep-symbolic-mathematics/LLM-SR
|
[
0.0551561192,
-0.6131685972,
1.0619012117,
0.482026428,
-0.1839489192,
0.43173033,
-0.1598211825,
-0.2978178263,
0.379078269,
0.2131251544,
-0.6376006603,
-0.6349906325,
-0.7064255476,
0.3123603463,
-0.1052105278,
0.5667033792,
-0.2791016102,
0.5098867416,
-0.5054935813,
0.2415628284,
-0.0066028461,
-0.4358156323,
-0.3316560686,
-0.533631146,
0.4751710892,
-0.0600464195,
0.3883375227,
0.6475723982,
0.782348156,
0.2751533091,
0.0144756045,
0.3344405293,
-0.6956996918,
0.4419198334,
0.0305214394,
-0.5338875055,
0.1052839011,
-0.2316609621,
0.7916656733,
0.6770517826,
-0.0927379429,
0.1747958809,
-0.3627927601,
0.627151072,
-0.461304158,
0.6954494119,
-0.7342644334,
0.1189709604,
-0.2498173416,
-0.5271300077,
-0.2872734666,
-0.3594896495,
0.1388674974,
-0.8088716865,
0.3417100906,
0.0188827105,
0.6298274398,
0.4957535863,
-0.2425466478,
-0.2934246659,
-0.7575449944,
1.0574005842,
-0.5807564259,
0.5627097487,
0.1932947785,
0.1994933635,
-0.7784628868,
-0.7250516415,
-0.2715842426,
-0.5274417996,
0.0992308706,
0.0140194315,
-0.3236646652,
-0.2695356607,
0.2023576945,
-0.0601735674,
-0.701469183,
-0.0141343996,
-0.4328994751,
-0.2820237279,
0.7600431442,
0.1716629565,
0.3719520569,
-0.1173608303,
-0.1821759343,
-0.0008704446,
-0.9884212613,
-0.2516346574,
0.1863610446,
0.5762951374,
-0.0771560296,
0.8081305623,
0.1302609891,
0.4219680429,
-0.496217221,
-0.2573982477,
0.0186599605,
-0.0964362547,
0.0358481146,
0.0258584525,
0.6370344758,
-0.1067074984,
0.0476157516,
-0.1685551703,
-0.2930831313,
0.32791242,
-0.0914051309,
-0.7557706237,
-0.3308240771,
-0.0764051527,
-0.3449984193,
-0.0998687893,
-0.2772119939,
-0.5751547813,
-0.4935645461,
-0.6055842638,
0.5210070014,
-0.1966976523,
-0.1198664233,
0.0995438695,
-0.1597310156,
-0.1971359998,
0.4863552153,
-0.3217024803,
0.1008518413,
0.6820213795,
1.0392076969,
-0.0766862407,
0.039225623,
-0.5279815793,
0.0860225856,
-0.4505302012,
0.5770776272,
-0.8444923162,
-0.4231629372,
-0.3289891481,
-0.3074998856,
-0.0090370486,
-0.5742127299,
0.3398464918,
-0.5151108503,
-0.1004228666,
0.08029107,
-0.52018255,
0.175355792,
-0.18386814,
-0.5255815387,
1.1535439491,
0.0809409469,
-0.563426137,
-0.1163883433,
-0.7149466872,
-0.1644630283,
0.1858809888,
-0.303978622,
-0.3923740089,
0.4866842926,
0.1811729819,
0.218690902,
-0.6973992586,
0.4601925015,
-0.474840492,
-0.2389604151,
0.2246976793,
-0.0632014349,
0.5463991165,
0.2919201255,
0.029360434,
-0.0182935353,
-0.5682669282,
-0.0267820489,
0.6427018642,
-0.0174653083,
-0.692299962,
0.2418511659,
-0.3585885167,
-0.1229145974,
0.35208565,
-0.6780644059,
0.397064656,
-0.1660486013,
0.5679470897,
0.7506115437,
-0.191592887,
0.2114230245,
0.0235839188,
0.5703927875,
-0.3546131551,
-0.0289261844,
-0.0357390828,
-0.5175417662,
-0.3002353907,
-0.3500677943,
0.0667995885,
0.1742877662,
-0.5939490795,
0.1352374256,
-0.4708207846,
-0.5559864044,
-0.4444675744,
0.1962166578,
0.3518366218,
0.6020605564,
0.531665802,
0.256585449,
-0.8543053865,
-0.8427821398,
-0.1586994082,
-0.1503269821,
-0.1272874624,
0.5312080979,
0.6686608791,
-0.5038664341,
0.8914529085,
-0.959974587,
-0.0604906939,
-0.0725066066,
0.1886817962,
0.2329413146,
0.3669152558,
0.2819783688,
-0.7310840487,
-0.3973489106,
0.0301417783,
-0.9507419467,
-0.4663271308,
0.12306761,
-0.030621253,
-0.049617257,
0.4649110734,
-0.5977018476,
0.1339780539,
0.6078995466,
0.1498451531,
0.6728605628,
-0.1332391053,
-0.1333083063,
-0.8278427124,
0.08231242,
0.5119535327,
0.0733478293,
-0.4911538661,
0.4587087333,
0.1245705485,
-0.107886225,
-0.2272931933,
0.5590541959,
-0.6846529841,
-0.1786804497,
-0.0042448547,
0.1041248515,
-0.3585448861,
0.1774860173,
0.2556981444,
0.6976821423,
0.6521174908,
-0.394079268,
0.2650243342,
0.0915117785,
-0.0905871689,
0.0859027579,
-0.6976149678,
0.1414160281,
-0.4847430885,
0.3974943161,
-0.6782021523,
-0.1762931347,
-0.0545554794,
-0.4560033679,
0.2934231758,
-0.4921901822,
-0.4478671551,
-0.3690163791,
-0.3007840812,
0.589147687,
0.4489182234,
-0.6447540522,
0.8383345008,
0.5271084309,
-0.4765169322,
-0.5241462588,
-0.0030315325,
0.0751595795,
-0.0631993935,
-0.6975932717,
0.431194365,
-0.2039527744,
-0.3529088497,
0.0230078921,
-0.849727571,
-0.0790171251,
-0.0305340514,
0.1185254157,
0.4287198484,
-0.2437098622,
0.0204287842,
0.0594597496,
-0.2345030159,
0.3242458701,
-0.4270856678,
0.7405699492,
-0.0761790797,
-0.2452664524,
-0.1069199666,
0.1681195349,
0.4664423466,
-0.1019150764,
0.2073119283,
0.1605582237,
-0.6693434715,
-0.4692753255,
-0.3281448185,
-0.2548282146,
-0.4533674419,
0.5388919711,
-0.2400490344,
-0.825158596,
0.3911679983,
-0.4708257914,
-0.0427362211,
0.1807363629,
0.3704673648,
0.0373413824,
1.3535716534,
0.5969612598,
0.1734094322,
0.1951913983,
-0.1865596026,
0.4976107478,
-0.5866586566,
-0.6688578129,
-0.8492388129,
-0.1896124035,
-0.1640592515,
-0.6208179593,
0.6787459254,
0.1720089316,
-0.4148415029,
0.336710155,
-0.4438996613,
0.4854871631,
0.4014949203,
0.2150905728,
0.1966379881,
0.0534836352,
-0.2643720508,
-0.3437335789,
-0.4679457545,
-0.3077321351,
1.0115323067,
0.3362086415,
1.22445786,
0.0755013153,
0.9130926728,
0.0714298114,
0.6030424237,
-0.8392256498,
0.5040330887,
-0.2145707309,
-0.1240304485,
-0.113400951,
-0.9884569049,
-0.973295927,
0.3554267883,
-0.2471379191,
-0.7028654814,
-0.3025898039,
0.292976886,
0.0091513488,
0.1307032704,
-0.6320816875,
0.472620368,
-0.6179105043,
-0.2680552602,
-0.1984208822,
-0.6465322375,
0.4995335042,
-0.4171527922,
0.4267435372,
-0.1415255368,
0.0044865105,
0.5789198875,
-0.3724737167,
0.7300975919,
-0.2023607492,
-0.3160946965,
-0.0445546843,
0.3949992061,
0.7630285025,
0.2518395782,
0.1313102841,
0.163889125,
0.0261993185,
-0.3391996622,
-0.8979631066,
1.1142382622,
-0.671474576,
-0.7248912454,
-0.5058009028,
-0.8052618504,
-0.0772533417,
0.2121194154,
-0.24370718,
0.1590858251,
0.2591059506,
0.2665323019,
0.7758140564,
-0.3312093019,
0.0932447985,
0.7337697744,
-0.354413718,
-0.3352481723,
0.979944706,
-0.0470507145,
-0.101917319,
0.6204532981,
0.5918405056,
-0.5180612803,
-0.6340722442,
-0.1167694181,
0.5032218099,
-0.4403715134,
-0.6500560641,
-0.5613618493,
-0.1441220939,
-0.228281498,
-0.1413319409,
-0.3012679517,
-0.3629710674,
-0.1628862321,
0.0229511876,
0.2922287583,
0.6032379866,
-0.0950924456,
0.0102549363,
-0.7724505067,
0.541732192,
-0.1163869947,
0.2097018659,
-0.1912693381,
-0.0521662571,
-0.0221916046,
0.2468364239,
0.0356332138,
-0.7818279266,
0.7751632929,
0.0773252472,
0.806912303,
-0.0212151464,
0.0476103835,
0.8771265149,
-0.4515405595,
0.5311732292,
0.395083636,
-1.0577442646,
0.516516149,
-0.1500684023,
-0.1649914533,
-0.253460139,
0.7629307508,
-0.1829162836,
-0.3348308802,
-0.3246265948,
-0.9738434553,
0.3886280656,
0.2375904173,
-0.0269530974,
0.1691518724,
0.5202626586,
0.1179234758,
0.1387242377,
-0.8305677176,
-0.2211129069,
-0.0531282425,
-0.4299052954,
-0.0253935177,
0.0814513043,
-0.3445328176,
-0.3176892698,
0.5658066869,
-0.2820510268,
0.2202300727,
0.2693992853,
-0.2372792214,
-0.4686911404,
-0.1295313239,
0.7017549276,
0.6708676815,
-0.1777693331,
0.5164630413,
-0.1351114661,
-0.5760467052,
-0.112973012,
0.290564537,
-0.0742615312,
0.022876095,
0.4175825119,
0.4603697658,
0.3290367126,
-1.0615230799,
0.082198076,
0.0181769207,
-0.3432894647,
-0.3951404989,
-0.0523771569,
0.2049544454,
0.3273663819,
0.7969101071,
0.1666096002,
-0.0406001508,
-0.2799698412,
0.0905486271,
0.8897688985,
0.2188354284,
-0.3770021796,
0.7620417476,
-0.139636755,
-0.2460128963,
0.4714153707,
0.166708529,
-0.6310018301,
0.7534173727,
0.8930941224,
0.5135205984,
0.0267852861,
0.3189062178,
0.2201835364,
0.0474443622,
-0.22363621,
0.3064447939,
0.1083748341,
-0.5528922081,
-0.5741063952,
-0.7466303706,
-0.277638346,
0.2136143744,
-0.3958776295,
0.2060312182,
-0.4103365541,
0.0267906431,
0.2918990552,
0.1319185644,
-0.4621893167,
-0.1857814193,
0.0774396211,
0.8696639538,
-0.8229503632,
0.62107265,
0.6455951333,
-0.184637621,
-0.78548944,
-0.34908095,
0.1568682045,
-1.2044297457,
1.1930706501,
-0.0827166885,
-0.4262029529,
0.1892442852,
-1.1710889339,
-1.2962161303,
1.1315245628,
0.7144229412,
-0.5923088193,
0.02263638,
-0.1635470986,
0.7144753337,
-0.3893122077,
-0.0189934466,
0.1957426369,
0.5684174299,
0.377386272,
-0.7578470707,
0.0626250207,
-0.3893727958,
-0.0280525181,
0.6086657643,
-0.2425493449,
0.7479841709,
-0.5394363403,
-0.2431219518,
0.1507106125,
0.4972360432,
0.8092056513,
0.5393394828,
0.0653964952,
0.4631567597,
0.7107554674,
-0.1198020801,
0.7461922169,
-0.3819862604,
0.6604858637,
0.6634704471,
-0.5725623965,
0.706076622,
0.743090868,
-0.3289495409,
0.3462173641,
0.5202775598,
-0.1091478541,
0.4622169733,
0.8322014809,
-0.3158303201,
-0.4628378153,
-0.1905025393,
-0.2761677206,
-0.1235635579,
0.5717420578,
-0.2510784864,
-0.3328401446,
-0.3440414667,
0.0303416289,
0.1634343565,
-0.3574330509,
0.2771648467,
0.2033541352,
-0.2382211834,
0.6114436984,
-0.0489649251,
0.5754680037,
-0.9212439656,
-0.5161922574,
-0.1556015313,
0.0300916936,
-0.1939663589,
-0.6392859221,
0.036236465,
0.0252126046,
-0.0425047092,
-0.1529002339,
0.5935662985,
-0.4408759475,
-0.6678853631,
0.2125055939,
0.5548260212,
0.1517881453,
0.3282779455,
-0.3746259212,
0.2308699191,
-0.0614376627,
0.0029310579,
0.2274320573,
0.1625968218,
-0.2179362327,
1.2376459837,
1.1065950394,
0.2167210281,
0.2163551152,
-0.0853370428,
1.0719213486,
-0.4164904952,
-0.0406744182,
-0.6767503023,
0.0771771148,
0.1031833515,
0.1095490605,
0.5868862867,
0.7825141549,
0.7529116273,
-0.4100449681,
0.8731296062,
0.0917352289,
0.2971223593,
-0.660076499,
0.2624120712,
-0.6383851171,
0.4802975357,
-0.2781623602,
-0.958425045,
-0.83738482,
0.8247212172,
-0.2504802644,
-0.1182232276,
0.6465720534,
0.8584033847,
-0.0863083676,
-0.0591214783,
-0.0948783606,
0.2881639302,
0.5631723404,
0.353864044,
0.8951496482,
0.1653275192,
0.3077019155,
-0.1721227616,
-0.333478272,
-0.0428845771,
-1.195273757,
-0.5258907676,
-0.4393734634,
-0.2288628668,
-0.2763739824,
0.1867624968,
1.3896490335,
0.5420498252,
-0.6379814744,
-0.1745287329,
-0.2629451156,
0.1632355005,
-0.1446253508,
-0.287284255,
0.3466867208,
-0.2843692303,
-0.6906719804,
0.82587713,
0.2763494551,
0.2246670425,
-0.2758751214,
-0.3925363719,
0.1830956042,
0.1873353571,
0.5436948538,
0.5067446828,
-0.56120193,
-0.0142646162,
0.3948687911,
0.143481046,
-0.2212613374,
1.2202390432,
-0.7069471478,
0.202804029,
0.5223582387,
0.5719219446,
0.6599797606,
-0.0944424942,
0.7341085672,
-0.647175014,
-0.2171690315,
0.4919877946,
0.6359398365,
0.1745098233,
-0.2209587544,
0.590818882,
0.4954919815,
-0.3821173012,
-1.2381768227,
0.4507835805,
-1.0717579126,
-0.5201923847,
1.0095582008,
-0.1106888875,
-0.0757889897,
0.075469695,
-0.1333942115,
-0.0678175911,
-0.3997510374,
1.117585063,
0.2351894677,
-0.5642495155,
-0.280251354,
-0.4027211666,
0.2933736145,
0.141590327,
-0.5586751103,
0.0970118493,
0.5678724051,
0.3532622159,
0.2996248305,
0.040540833,
-0.2390305698,
-0.1970618814,
-0.2120510191,
-0.0726577565,
-0.4232245684,
-0.4236839712,
0.0684861392,
0.1942912638,
-0.1797179729,
0.4839006364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18398v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18398v1
|
MM-TTS: A Unified Framework for Multimodal, Prompt-Induced Emotional Text-to-Speech Synthesis
| 2024-04-29T03:19:39 | 2024-04-29T03:19:39 |
Xiang Li, Zhi-Qi Cheng, Jun-Yan He, Xiaojiang Peng, Alexander G. Hauptmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Emotional Text-to-Speech (E-TTS) synthesis has gained significant attention
in recent years due to its potential to enhance human-computer interaction.
However, current E-TTS approaches often struggle to capture the complexity of
human emotions, primarily relying on oversimplified emotional labels or
single-modality inputs. To address these limitations, we propose the Multimodal
Emotional Text-to-Speech System (MM-TTS), a unified framework that leverages
emotional cues from multiple modalities to generate highly expressive and
emotionally resonant speech. MM-TTS consists of two key components: (1) the
Emotion Prompt Alignment Module (EP-Align), which employs contrastive learning
to align emotional features across text, audio, and visual modalities, ensuring
a coherent fusion of multimodal information; and (2) the Emotion
Embedding-Induced TTS (EMI-TTS), which integrates the aligned emotional
embeddings with state-of-the-art TTS models to synthesize speech that
accurately reflects the intended emotions. Extensive evaluations across diverse
datasets demonstrate the superior performance of MM-TTS compared to traditional
E-TTS models. Objective metrics, including Word Error Rate (WER) and Character
Error Rate (CER), show significant improvements on ESD dataset, with MM-TTS
achieving scores of 7.35% and 3.07%, respectively. Subjective assessments
further validate that MM-TTS generates speech with emotional fidelity and
naturalness comparable to human speech. Our code and pre-trained models are
publicly available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MMTTS-D214
|
[
-0.5755141973,
-0.6975752711,
0.486782372,
0.4158200026,
-0.2667105198,
0.2792533934,
-0.3280982375,
-0.0874069482,
0.4379104972,
-0.0243099574,
-0.9540309906,
-0.5729147792,
-0.3638886809,
0.624427855,
-0.2300903201,
0.9409937263,
0.1435015649,
-0.0003142369,
0.1905341148,
-0.0982015356,
-0.3296834826,
-0.5845869184,
-0.3559551835,
0.0230249614,
0.7946223617,
0.4790458381,
0.2929905653,
0.2865187228,
0.2255795449,
0.2925435305,
0.067953974,
0.3571197689,
-0.1116428897,
0.6491687298,
0.1341257542,
-0.0174655505,
-0.6411448121,
-0.1108564287,
0.3768562376,
0.0560892485,
-0.2776020765,
0.003464479,
0.040121872,
0.4587889612,
-0.6384760737,
-0.1764394492,
-0.3139972091,
0.1993771642,
-0.1162745431,
-0.3924310505,
-0.6140193343,
-0.1599334925,
0.2976109087,
-0.5323038697,
-0.2246732414,
0.1243364885,
0.2305305153,
0.2942119539,
-0.9229573011,
-0.3751670718,
-0.5402008891,
0.5857297778,
-0.3605036736,
0.7471381426,
-0.1186835319,
0.2537670732,
0.1790401787,
-0.5930262208,
-0.7208444476,
-0.2359952629,
0.2904337943,
0.6406404376,
-0.3838335574,
0.327555716,
-0.0150784943,
-0.047410544,
-0.7477875352,
0.07241375,
0.0122424597,
-0.2278550863,
0.2142878771,
0.3040192425,
0.4874831736,
-0.3700504601,
-0.4880367517,
-0.223210752,
-0.3965230286,
-0.1300128102,
0.2816799283,
0.6861904263,
-0.4211856127,
0.8408818245,
0.0298570376,
0.2617950439,
0.0364133082,
-0.1547022015,
0.3915190697,
-0.2353392243,
-0.2358970344,
0.1674557626,
1.0326658487,
0.6522108912,
0.1041948423,
-0.0116960034,
-0.219896853,
0.4797938764,
0.0126815094,
-0.8928085566,
0.3579215705,
0.5014666915,
-0.2059288919,
-0.2264452875,
-0.0238554142,
-1.3080035448,
-0.2605361342,
-0.5237347484,
0.4198235273,
-0.4836324453,
-0.46993348,
-0.0126327453,
-0.3253076971,
-0.2576333582,
0.1267311275,
-0.7131214142,
-0.0817201212,
0.3085380495,
0.873444438,
0.0306806583,
-0.3976415396,
-0.5989656448,
0.2143285125,
-0.1646458954,
0.5826718211,
-0.6230091453,
-0.5921760201,
0.0657466948,
-0.2375160605,
0.0397764444,
-0.175296694,
0.8642906547,
0.065601632,
0.3902219236,
-0.1846722811,
-0.3380713165,
0.2792332172,
-0.0336855613,
-0.4398002028,
0.9258037806,
-0.3119355738,
-0.5104275942,
0.0425089896,
-0.8806306124,
-0.3710811138,
-0.4432348311,
0.035663262,
-0.1742264479,
0.3612371683,
0.3814949691,
0.4940927029,
-0.4744727612,
0.3261058331,
-0.3214722872,
-0.0740867704,
0.3606037199,
-0.7913166881,
0.1637811959,
0.5744553804,
-0.3739296198,
0.2407683879,
-0.7876765132,
0.077861771,
0.0835067555,
-0.1365026683,
-0.0711902082,
-0.1582844406,
0.4030072093,
0.4614672363,
-0.0698438361,
-0.6666440964,
-0.1545664668,
-0.2045462877,
0.5252030492,
0.882343173,
-0.1975083947,
0.309661895,
-0.228848964,
0.5671397448,
0.1403178275,
-0.0602471642,
-0.7760147452,
-0.4149392247,
-0.4351537526,
-0.569047749,
-0.0385921337,
0.5635635853,
-0.6970164776,
0.425321877,
-0.1339837909,
-0.5412477851,
-0.7954493165,
-0.6911248565,
0.4380179942,
0.6020728946,
0.446841538,
0.0821099654,
-0.7480971217,
-0.6290439963,
-0.1363045573,
-0.2400716096,
-0.2937604785,
0.1210366488,
0.2095106989,
-0.36596632,
0.8616604805,
-0.211487174,
-0.3471816182,
0.2243316472,
0.6046044827,
-0.3618921041,
0.4183311164,
0.4371138811,
-0.55520612,
-0.3080637753,
0.0017927161,
-0.4995393753,
-0.5879689455,
-0.0764446333,
0.115128696,
0.233872667,
0.3441409767,
-0.6821852326,
-0.0065793726,
0.6930661798,
-0.4648799002,
0.7615177035,
-0.1843509823,
0.6316286922,
-1.3579033613,
0.1149167344,
0.1499506086,
-0.0679838732,
-0.669295609,
-0.2374036014,
-0.0711318031,
-0.4194212854,
-0.508107543,
0.4480193257,
-0.3240890205,
-0.0063229073,
0.0427128561,
0.5040568709,
0.1478001773,
0.6038095355,
-0.202829659,
0.7439934611,
0.5531634688,
-0.3416256607,
0.5594415069,
0.2740796506,
0.238687396,
1.4197379351,
-0.5240284801,
0.207760185,
-0.3016850948,
0.3770424426,
-0.96922791,
-0.2606167495,
0.135760501,
-0.6913121939,
0.1539008617,
0.1284473985,
-0.3692188263,
-0.2435105443,
-0.3078750968,
0.1973123699,
0.4860550761,
-0.4828878045,
1.1470297575,
0.343752712,
-0.6843008995,
-0.3122688234,
-0.8010416031,
0.3012160659,
-0.3078349531,
-0.6458421946,
0.4435325265,
-0.4608691037,
0.0708659589,
-0.0940572917,
0.1063704565,
-0.039137993,
-0.2623058558,
0.2791431248,
0.1472958773,
-0.1313762367,
0.4042667747,
0.4956631064,
-0.2214631885,
0.0513234138,
-0.0121429451,
0.4442019165,
-0.1992926747,
-0.5588885546,
-0.8268478513,
0.7954719067,
1.3081322908,
-0.4461226463,
0.2321499288,
0.8485059142,
-0.3893488348,
0.0308772214,
-0.3467092216,
-0.1606922746,
-0.4564864635,
0.5834692717,
-0.482930243,
-0.8902789354,
0.3501495421,
-0.2280118167,
-0.029882608,
0.3424512148,
0.7178955078,
-0.1576540321,
1.5793173313,
0.2714682519,
0.0911185965,
0.6245723367,
0.3778052032,
-0.0367660522,
-0.8204135299,
-0.4075555503,
-0.6562171578,
-0.2138141096,
-0.438937366,
-0.1575197428,
0.579235971,
-0.542729497,
-0.45082587,
-0.2067442536,
-0.6375018358,
0.1304619759,
0.3469346464,
0.1052883863,
-0.0165877212,
0.0477659293,
-0.328964442,
-0.453866154,
-0.2983551323,
-0.5694441795,
0.9943762422,
0.2286490649,
0.5091856122,
0.3157888055,
0.5196005702,
0.2598011196,
0.2628889978,
-0.6471646428,
0.4338580966,
-0.2071419507,
-0.3718021214,
-0.0124018099,
-0.5309188962,
-0.6862749457,
0.2785896659,
-0.5626263022,
-0.6669368744,
-0.1610150784,
0.0457248129,
-0.3855626583,
0.1136647761,
-1.1216914654,
0.6672638655,
-0.2857115567,
-0.1904460043,
-0.0464883782,
-0.8337128162,
0.1018813774,
-0.1172683686,
0.4151628613,
-0.1685205847,
-0.1321247965,
0.629533112,
-0.1403534859,
0.7911237478,
-0.1630090922,
-0.1150103062,
0.0684951022,
0.1286646426,
0.3981949091,
-0.1432384104,
-0.0479816832,
-0.1984032094,
-0.1298024058,
0.1120681986,
-0.6148843765,
0.5513466597,
-0.5273249745,
-0.1831188798,
-0.211451441,
-0.4579549134,
-0.4059445858,
0.1046781093,
0.220124647,
0.7936806083,
-0.4031853974,
0.1037691385,
0.5408741236,
-0.2286501676,
0.4405321777,
0.3713203967,
-0.3797947466,
-1.0110654831,
0.9868166447,
-0.1569981128,
0.2365354747,
0.3852245212,
0.1776460856,
-0.517320931,
0.0952011719,
-0.5363187194,
0.1528311372,
-0.5469889045,
-0.2817584574,
-0.743131578,
0.2457637787,
-0.3621026874,
-0.3565809131,
-0.5764113069,
-0.1918062717,
-0.705899775,
-0.2949895263,
0.3761467934,
0.565529108,
-0.211558044,
0.2228966802,
-1.1688016653,
0.5540049076,
0.3580065668,
0.2862039804,
-0.1835935712,
-0.4332442582,
0.1489892602,
0.3483493626,
-0.3050569594,
-1.2253587246,
0.5533323288,
0.3088642657,
0.0439389721,
0.408138603,
0.1646677256,
0.7547395229,
-0.757058382,
0.9203799367,
0.8215187192,
-1.3519439697,
0.543969214,
-0.3525628746,
0.2574067116,
0.0836552531,
0.0533220358,
-0.8502470851,
-0.5198055506,
-0.3622036576,
-0.9610650539,
0.637680769,
0.3965288997,
0.0119699538,
-0.0543065965,
-0.0391189605,
-0.0265285429,
0.2580469549,
-0.3515906632,
-0.3964157701,
-0.3500538766,
-0.9350731373,
-0.0188637897,
-0.3177542984,
-0.0309205875,
0.1937233657,
0.5737730265,
-0.2294089794,
0.63398242,
0.240271166,
0.0998095572,
-0.266241014,
0.6978398561,
0.8425448537,
-0.1520761997,
-0.2123316824,
0.3247781098,
-0.003515688,
-0.2317144871,
0.4099567533,
0.2681652904,
0.3182313144,
0.1849250644,
-0.1500518471,
0.8882417083,
0.1933945417,
-0.8127271533,
0.4633149505,
-0.171520412,
0.0562548637,
0.1936880648,
-0.4937531948,
0.1673244983,
0.386272639,
0.4127355516,
0.2507927418,
0.0415473133,
-0.3685717583,
0.2771543562,
0.1491477489,
-0.489802748,
-0.7482319474,
0.8452747464,
0.6821973324,
-0.4050401747,
0.260643363,
-0.0889104754,
-0.601631701,
0.3790726066,
0.6440190673,
1.1636531353,
-0.6545743942,
0.288977474,
0.2200203389,
0.3342589438,
0.2120096236,
0.6629685163,
0.1225373372,
-0.3417094648,
-0.1497576684,
-0.3358213902,
-0.6543366909,
-0.4489763081,
-0.6069074273,
0.304751724,
-0.1371764094,
-0.5006787777,
-0.1680947095,
-0.6927991509,
-0.3965109289,
0.5566741228,
0.4264380932,
0.5068199039,
-0.832354784,
0.2662260532,
0.6836871505,
-0.3203339875,
-0.6871652007,
-0.2689629197,
0.4905030429,
-0.3287350833,
0.3595996201,
0.3304333389,
-0.4600362182,
0.2830666006,
-0.1911822408,
-0.5935764313,
1.0279749632,
0.7707561851,
-0.5516403317,
0.0703993663,
0.2115735561,
0.5122535229,
-0.5298821926,
0.5673817396,
0.1451480538,
0.4206808209,
0.1371656507,
-0.9560548663,
-0.0553240478,
-0.3085903823,
-0.1786947846,
0.1593353301,
-0.5645552278,
0.6319690347,
-0.2115302682,
-0.4219007492,
0.0013628246,
0.6253119111,
0.5449231863,
0.3632593453,
0.4223937094,
0.59872365,
0.8493444324,
-0.3993262649,
0.6550298333,
-0.2879007161,
0.1971590221,
0.7531345487,
-0.4475643337,
0.8932390809,
0.5099186301,
-0.0764512718,
0.2161470354,
0.4215451479,
0.5517404079,
0.4866617918,
-0.1632683426,
-0.417691052,
-0.0926073194,
-0.4920846522,
-0.508045435,
0.2650697231,
0.3908216357,
-0.1690596342,
0.0020728367,
0.4189013243,
-0.0678814873,
-0.2254317701,
-0.0247303937,
0.6216180921,
0.1063185707,
-0.3995269835,
0.070308499,
-0.142192021,
0.8776271939,
-0.7916361094,
0.129727751,
0.015525925,
-0.254205972,
-0.0253659133,
-0.8017699718,
0.1400880665,
0.4132937789,
-0.1584433019,
-0.4660094082,
0.3614375293,
-0.6594617367,
-0.093927592,
0.2827825248,
0.548171401,
-0.2707574666,
-0.1868745983,
-0.5572862029,
0.3224443793,
-0.0186208263,
-0.4269171655,
0.1214443669,
1.0077066422,
0.5157685876,
0.5831478238,
0.7339746356,
-0.2307627499,
0.0233091209,
0.2756781876,
0.7200095654,
-0.6800123453,
-0.7321676016,
-0.7478030324,
1.0371800661,
0.265067935,
-0.4774102271,
0.3770603836,
0.2391048223,
0.2273206562,
0.008533163,
0.7723144293,
0.0255695768,
0.3635884523,
-0.6074809432,
0.5315542221,
-0.8503295183,
-0.1145567149,
-0.810783565,
-0.7728423476,
-0.3323815763,
0.3385723531,
0.4609214365,
0.0075500049,
0.7451788783,
0.7449282408,
0.3398827612,
0.3100492358,
0.4445623457,
0.2177236527,
0.3848195374,
0.4889720678,
1.0817483664,
-0.1950584501,
0.6648153067,
0.0425702818,
-0.3241757154,
-0.1353406161,
-1.016687274,
-0.3227662444,
-0.8495944738,
-0.2583174407,
-0.1007460952,
-0.059901353,
1.3735762835,
0.4722784758,
-0.4364752471,
0.0196616892,
0.1364908963,
-0.147662729,
0.0723691657,
-0.1993193924,
0.0465061478,
-0.103675276,
-0.9020445347,
0.5770323277,
0.6992273331,
0.4261305332,
0.0389792137,
-0.2077728212,
0.075884141,
0.3442700803,
0.8184594512,
-0.0519509353,
-0.7939050198,
-0.1810860038,
0.3162541389,
-0.249128148,
-0.0093728006,
0.6589921117,
-0.3965288997,
0.8009717464,
0.2310058773,
0.6253675222,
-0.0879333466,
-0.2909995019,
0.589076221,
-0.9280897379,
0.0364037976,
0.2823396921,
0.5969716311,
0.3162095547,
-0.036811538,
0.0776323006,
0.2982609272,
-0.5123482347,
-0.9309036136,
0.4436691701,
-1.2869606018,
-0.0003771644,
1.0733249187,
0.1152874604,
-0.0563429222,
0.1925217807,
-0.7530140281,
0.6048511863,
-0.9204108119,
0.4855729938,
0.5266205668,
0.0240966212,
-0.0730495676,
-0.0953913555,
0.1283852458,
0.5801753402,
-0.9864903688,
0.2742465734,
0.9347854853,
-0.2444406152,
0.1853905618,
0.410181582,
0.0503893159,
0.2023728639,
-0.0804505721,
0.3174243867,
-0.1044914573,
-0.4622454941,
-0.4723902643,
0.3828888237,
-0.5296755433,
-0.1110699028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18384v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18384v1
|
Exploring the Limits of Fine-grained LLM-based Physics Inference via Premise Removal Interventions
| 2024-04-29T02:43:23 | 2024-04-29T02:43:23 |
Jordan Meadows, Tamsin James, Andre Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models can hallucinate when performing complex and detailed
mathematical reasoning. Physics provides a rich domain for assessing
mathematical reasoning capabilities where physical context imbues the use of
symbols which needs to satisfy complex semantics (\textit{e.g.,} units,
tensorial order), leading to instances where inference may be algebraically
coherent, yet unphysical. In this work, we assess the ability of Language
Models (LMs) to perform fine-grained mathematical and physical reasoning using
a curated dataset encompassing multiple notations and Physics subdomains. We
improve zero-shot scores using synthetic in-context examples, and demonstrate
non-linear degradation of derivation quality with perturbation strength via the
progressive omission of supporting premises. We find that the models'
mathematical reasoning is not physics-informed in this setting, where physical
context is predominantly ignored in favour of reverse-engineering solutions.
|
[
-0.2070573866,
-1.1009967327,
0.9229245186,
0.0485224351,
-0.1517391801,
-0.1555870175,
-0.0812998191,
-0.5764457583,
-0.1716117114,
0.5717593431,
-0.4069503844,
-0.3404041827,
-0.3471568525,
-0.0232682284,
-0.4924402535,
0.9280864596,
-0.2941903174,
0.0894077346,
-0.3423858583,
0.2608597577,
-0.0869140178,
-0.1788439304,
-0.0903493762,
-0.7757195234,
0.1548820734,
0.3194916844,
0.6656279564,
0.5676550865,
0.4213977754,
0.1331206858,
-0.3071395457,
0.0188002661,
-0.6034847498,
-0.1361834109,
-0.5008535981,
-0.2669129074,
-0.4287842512,
0.0637842938,
0.6386274695,
1.3292733431,
0.0429388173,
0.050621815,
0.0819771811,
0.3173630536,
-0.8054698706,
0.0559738763,
-0.8043859601,
0.170642361,
0.3099859357,
-0.2034835219,
-0.5939952731,
0.1816163957,
0.1703581512,
-0.6854373217,
0.2495055646,
-0.1688043773,
1.1219357252,
0.0531850867,
-0.1235897765,
-0.0083355326,
-1.0289254189,
1.0949010849,
-0.5760857463,
0.3882962465,
0.6538717151,
0.0844070688,
-0.2854967415,
-0.4121232629,
-0.1987175345,
-0.1281269342,
0.0467382036,
0.1496764421,
-0.0286001526,
0.1094026491,
0.5071489811,
0.2504908442,
-0.266931802,
0.1407411098,
-0.4932562113,
-0.2380657345,
0.5486343503,
0.1340804696,
0.1679431498,
-0.2895493507,
-0.1375130862,
0.1767313778,
-1.0739057064,
-0.0445924997,
0.1678467244,
0.4175790548,
-0.034594737,
1.1171642542,
-0.3886587322,
0.3619582057,
-0.0107560605,
-0.1979281604,
-0.2058703303,
-0.0709101632,
-0.5843179822,
0.1139187664,
0.6587148905,
0.2062070519,
0.2490625679,
-0.3280229568,
-0.2518870533,
-0.063997671,
-0.111465238,
-0.884114325,
-0.1277065426,
0.3604569435,
-0.2477022558,
-0.1025274992,
-0.2011157125,
-0.5515065193,
-0.4949652553,
-0.4288412333,
0.5863747001,
-0.5367002487,
-0.0941058993,
0.603307426,
-0.2020682693,
0.2958287001,
0.447045207,
-0.7678792477,
0.373555541,
0.7496398091,
0.5422660112,
0.5458239317,
-0.3241671324,
-0.1370623708,
0.3154871464,
-0.3526287973,
0.8155195713,
-0.7050974369,
-0.6991633773,
-0.5750605464,
-0.1122865602,
0.165743947,
-0.6495780349,
0.6332675219,
-0.1995647103,
0.1953367293,
-0.1031931713,
-0.6673676372,
-0.2093574554,
0.0189408809,
-0.2615891993,
0.6806463599,
-0.141178906,
-0.2250128686,
0.1825740933,
-0.4039044976,
-0.5900455713,
-0.2293977141,
-0.2221790701,
-0.2999458313,
0.591123879,
0.1783642173,
0.3323803246,
-0.3766961694,
0.4988541901,
-0.7821500897,
-0.3050186634,
0.11664965,
-0.6921635866,
0.3720578551,
0.4047048688,
-0.3199629784,
-0.2724135518,
-1.0984383821,
-0.1620533615,
0.1541790664,
0.2521425486,
-0.4797135592,
0.298422277,
-0.2926734686,
0.162774682,
0.0440479778,
-0.7493891716,
0.1487823278,
-0.7207365632,
0.2806289792,
0.5727197528,
-0.0201763827,
0.6573002934,
-0.1578229964,
0.2514488995,
-0.1770697832,
0.001202621,
0.0128290821,
-0.4906817973,
-0.4123982489,
-0.5606248975,
-0.2027098238,
0.3527210653,
-0.375575155,
0.1459632665,
-0.3181812167,
-0.3592654765,
-0.1880368292,
-0.0565756001,
0.4347590804,
0.9603821635,
0.6089890003,
0.311830461,
-0.396371603,
-0.8961145878,
-0.6820630431,
-0.0273965318,
-0.3612725139,
0.1486580223,
0.5383880734,
0.0957839414,
1.1503418684,
-0.4481357038,
0.143780306,
-0.0788189843,
-0.0609905347,
0.1833605617,
0.4124730229,
0.1304958016,
-0.4566304088,
0.1050508767,
0.107389167,
-1.1934041977,
-0.401550889,
-0.2691867054,
0.0232818648,
-0.1176728159,
0.3222960532,
-0.8117879033,
0.73125875,
0.1101002097,
-0.4501857162,
0.8907902837,
0.0975815207,
0.0264532939,
-0.5704784393,
0.0390774719,
0.2614785433,
-0.197651282,
-0.6859481335,
0.3637053668,
-0.1928475201,
-0.3223540783,
-0.6403763294,
0.9878672957,
-0.2154823542,
-0.1940603703,
-0.2364915907,
0.2219663411,
0.5037241578,
-0.007977006,
0.4200905561,
0.4272911847,
0.6169686317,
-0.7925158143,
-0.274073869,
-0.140876323,
-0.1053993702,
0.3152378798,
-0.7645391822,
-0.4296090007,
-0.0611867346,
0.0121888099,
-0.9363593459,
-0.399017632,
0.2106499374,
-0.0941080153,
0.3151948154,
-0.2151864618,
-0.5050781369,
-0.0090000909,
-0.2821435928,
0.50012815,
0.5512826443,
-0.3330828846,
0.7101872563,
-0.0239858385,
0.1815935969,
-0.3070897162,
-0.9142713547,
-0.0818897933,
-0.2078239471,
-0.3835572302,
0.0672247559,
0.0112055447,
-0.8006119132,
0.1217952222,
-0.454526931,
-0.0573265702,
0.4084832072,
0.2357898802,
0.2803955078,
-0.2492390871,
0.101522617,
0.3444620967,
-0.1187829375,
0.1833033115,
-0.2732156813,
0.3504778147,
-0.2090461105,
-0.7210355997,
-0.6536517143,
-0.0227563586,
0.6618530154,
0.1394922286,
0.7160234451,
0.1550321132,
-0.6607075334,
-0.0967394561,
-0.355150193,
-0.4354542792,
-0.4710823894,
0.2797324359,
-0.8497006297,
-0.6525345445,
0.6241517663,
-0.0518421307,
0.1324263811,
0.6423181295,
0.4419539869,
-0.1639096439,
0.9503949881,
-0.0873644203,
0.3585458994,
0.0995866209,
-0.3285632133,
0.4433913231,
-0.8756307364,
-0.1996969134,
-0.3428049386,
0.0072042849,
-0.2639986575,
-0.2411622852,
0.0300419312,
0.54680264,
-0.3366829455,
0.2940571308,
-0.3088473976,
0.7852125764,
-0.172625646,
0.313198477,
0.277772963,
0.3656950593,
-0.0750094354,
0.001716658,
-0.264675945,
-0.6755077243,
0.9995849729,
0.5166458488,
0.9934769273,
-0.0307879355,
0.6384947896,
-0.2968703806,
0.291040659,
-1.0337705612,
0.6870242357,
-0.0564371049,
-0.6237586737,
-0.2031122297,
-0.7536237836,
-0.6317963004,
0.4301299751,
-0.0675203651,
-1.0700860023,
-0.1458546072,
-0.1468117535,
-0.4979153872,
0.6415547132,
-0.8374561071,
0.5341573954,
0.0359797366,
-0.8052096963,
-0.3149335384,
-0.0676541775,
0.7327493429,
-0.1455288082,
0.5214218497,
-0.4301527739,
0.2049126923,
0.2833486199,
-0.4928338826,
0.9084871411,
-0.1369362622,
-0.4932740331,
0.6296697855,
0.7401583195,
0.281637758,
0.1341637671,
-0.4156412482,
0.2478714436,
0.2136496305,
-0.5427570343,
-0.6115415096,
0.821185112,
-0.7383601665,
-0.6401370764,
0.0718279928,
-0.796431601,
-0.3277300894,
0.2625750303,
-0.0120604252,
0.635935545,
0.0642836094,
0.1055833548,
0.5800872445,
-0.3531576395,
0.3269738555,
0.4563106596,
-0.4952563047,
-0.0887436718,
0.8570837379,
0.0629334599,
0.5373389125,
0.4294187725,
0.6869591475,
-0.527064085,
-0.5619170666,
0.0156546887,
0.3781982958,
-0.8160755634,
0.1550456583,
-0.3863742948,
-0.1902552098,
-0.4400590956,
-0.2811997533,
-0.4760679901,
-0.7584668398,
-0.4887093008,
-0.2041668594,
0.1172070801,
0.5277602077,
0.1368233562,
0.1373167336,
-0.6880311966,
0.4895186126,
-0.1516619921,
0.3921155632,
-0.1618675143,
-0.9037908912,
0.0292454995,
0.2486822158,
-0.3157526255,
-0.2974110842,
0.155785799,
0.1559487283,
0.3743842244,
0.5806060433,
-0.0902308449,
1.197902441,
-0.5942376256,
0.7560406923,
0.2380790561,
-1.0917127132,
0.5909517407,
-0.3605578244,
0.3375193477,
0.1188223064,
0.19910869,
0.1103969067,
-0.5664567947,
-0.7154741287,
-0.3566580415,
0.3265373409,
0.2443348318,
0.1538431346,
-0.028730249,
1.0131130219,
0.1452781409,
0.0134546729,
-0.7793420553,
0.0091969483,
-0.1119375229,
-0.0527925305,
0.0563366562,
-0.0773802474,
-0.0409665816,
-0.4684289992,
0.5371231437,
-0.1939901561,
-0.0215566568,
0.4801053703,
-0.1483990848,
-0.39234519,
0.3095835447,
0.8695871234,
0.7285508513,
-0.2586880326,
0.3107087314,
0.1169928908,
-0.2618345916,
-0.0012781974,
-0.0535191074,
-0.329651922,
-0.3248672485,
0.5756988525,
0.4500711262,
0.4160874188,
-0.8047733307,
-0.00161273,
0.1989851445,
-0.4487820566,
0.1657094359,
-0.0548202209,
-0.2206203341,
0.0804087296,
0.3571945131,
0.2223163098,
0.2481622398,
-0.5683229566,
0.3540703654,
0.6772714853,
-0.3270601034,
-0.6867532134,
0.6692761779,
-0.5152817369,
0.0954935998,
0.130719021,
-0.1080031618,
-0.1596732587,
0.545552671,
0.5891394019,
0.8194096088,
0.1634577811,
0.078536205,
0.4102689624,
0.2830636501,
-0.1703218073,
0.1953760982,
0.2123602629,
-0.7546274662,
-0.7151458859,
-0.7809939384,
-0.3418217897,
0.3608881831,
-0.5462254286,
0.5545959473,
-0.9095210433,
0.0311437063,
0.0672264174,
0.0160779357,
-0.3095962107,
0.2271376848,
0.3438476622,
0.6620836854,
-0.9161071777,
0.6518953443,
0.4296940863,
-0.4619729817,
-0.7300567627,
-0.1202182397,
0.16785945,
-0.684873879,
0.6754052043,
0.0659430698,
-0.5354760289,
-0.1442501247,
-0.7111138701,
-0.6968178153,
0.5738584995,
0.6556299925,
-0.4425550401,
0.0571947247,
0.1770133227,
0.6623676419,
0.084110111,
0.4598934054,
0.379652977,
0.2871839106,
0.3210408092,
-0.9872586131,
-0.0094846105,
0.2987597585,
-0.532207191,
0.0745857805,
-0.3363482058,
0.9729997516,
-0.206990853,
-0.2632951438,
0.3755709231,
0.4835886359,
0.646412015,
0.52832371,
0.0374524891,
0.7677961588,
0.4906644821,
0.0173276607,
1.1488345861,
-0.2429954112,
0.8429710269,
1.103386879,
-0.742269516,
0.7166864872,
0.7814369798,
-0.1562252492,
0.4072911143,
0.4418654442,
0.1689626873,
0.4656559527,
0.1676488221,
-0.2392650694,
-0.5714813471,
-0.2979695201,
-0.022354031,
0.5322770476,
0.6598546505,
-0.0450888909,
-0.8248708248,
0.0180286467,
0.0853830874,
0.1732903868,
-0.3578798771,
0.2892451286,
0.3840857148,
-0.3574486673,
0.780682385,
-0.115361169,
0.039329391,
-0.5518264771,
-0.0246622711,
-0.1361390352,
0.3411629498,
-0.3774845302,
-0.8975761533,
0.4674945772,
0.0457966961,
-0.0886568874,
-0.2362270802,
0.6710239649,
-0.1184289381,
-0.5448334813,
0.2089960575,
0.5049772263,
0.4085641205,
0.0364292599,
-0.5784876943,
-0.1186115816,
-0.3238149285,
-0.3668671548,
0.4529493749,
0.5522935987,
-0.0266484506,
0.8722512126,
0.6446326971,
0.2574471831,
-0.1386424899,
0.3050762117,
0.7576729059,
-0.556671977,
0.0795585215,
-1.2358601093,
0.1276790053,
0.2218834162,
0.0397223569,
0.9674252868,
0.682407558,
0.6040707827,
-0.0360025093,
0.5399106145,
0.2496014982,
0.0634339675,
-0.7975018024,
0.3811693788,
-0.7496575117,
0.6843289137,
-0.3885918856,
-0.7532837391,
-0.7634603381,
0.5794175267,
-0.7640603781,
-0.0238960851,
0.6208516359,
0.674757421,
-0.468331933,
0.0207113512,
0.707395792,
0.3500182927,
0.697848618,
0.5600907207,
1.0687856674,
-0.5608514547,
0.1299228668,
-0.3415903449,
-0.0879077539,
-0.0564943962,
-0.9473784566,
-0.9121339917,
0.105247438,
-0.3981884122,
-0.452770561,
-0.4255490303,
0.8722868562,
0.447470516,
-0.8806285858,
-0.0648414716,
-0.3658626378,
0.1491753161,
-0.0505836681,
-0.3189300001,
0.3333146572,
-0.2866240144,
-0.5426813364,
0.6991968155,
0.4397369921,
0.1024949849,
-0.2577382326,
0.1648214161,
-0.0256156065,
0.3246784806,
0.8890857697,
0.4431351423,
-1.137275219,
-0.7174070477,
0.2232754976,
0.0199669227,
-0.1069487184,
0.5814425349,
-0.8221675158,
0.4548856616,
0.4085398018,
0.4745816588,
0.1794293225,
0.0361566097,
0.3306340277,
-0.6998633742,
0.4120846093,
0.1291631907,
0.5753930211,
-0.0388705507,
-0.2344205081,
0.2595947087,
0.6603159904,
-0.2100187242,
-1.1248803139,
0.2584697604,
-0.7386397719,
-0.7505312562,
1.345433116,
0.0206671022,
-0.3770549893,
-0.0087631661,
0.0636285245,
0.0228409767,
-0.0653262734,
0.6334742904,
0.8485356569,
-0.3599449396,
-0.2723744512,
-0.560608983,
0.1231039762,
0.6618231535,
-0.6289919019,
0.2877267599,
0.5137864947,
0.3926948607,
0.3107730746,
0.1331982315,
-0.284378916,
0.1077413261,
0.0458787419,
-0.0107119866,
-0.0130604273,
-0.5179830194,
-0.5770823956,
0.2961996496,
-0.0085344808,
0.2644472718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01588v1
|
Towards Unbiased Evaluation of Detecting Unanswerable Questions in EHRSQL
| 2024-04-29T02:26:15 | 2024-04-29T02:26:15 |
Yongjin Yang, Sihyeon Kim, SangMook Kim, Gyubok Lee, Se-Young Yun, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Incorporating unanswerable questions into EHR QA systems is crucial for
testing the trustworthiness of a system, as providing non-existent responses
can mislead doctors in their diagnoses. The EHRSQL dataset stands out as a
promising benchmark because it is the only dataset that incorporates
unanswerable questions in the EHR QA system alongside practical questions.
However, in this work, we identify a data bias in these unanswerable questions;
they can often be discerned simply by filtering with specific N-gram patterns.
Such biases jeopardize the authenticity and reliability of QA system
evaluations. To tackle this problem, we propose a simple debiasing method of
adjusting the split between the validation and test sets to neutralize the
undue influence of N-gram filtering. By experimenting on the MIMIC-III dataset,
we demonstrate both the existing data bias in EHRSQL and the effectiveness of
our data split strategy in mitigating this bias.
|
[
-0.5091717243,
-0.6971297264,
0.7186263204,
-0.1809806377,
-0.443176955,
0.1506046504,
0.4527282715,
-0.0966676548,
0.320851177,
0.6173895597,
-0.5029563308,
-0.3524177969,
-0.3190974295,
0.2040617317,
-0.4099705219,
1.0069644451,
0.1105497107,
0.3323206007,
-0.2305306643,
-0.5786697268,
-0.3704769313,
-0.3047072291,
-0.1460941881,
-0.5869276524,
-0.0047857719,
0.4856138229,
0.8370954394,
0.3803826571,
0.3234090209,
0.0022548831,
-0.1590468884,
0.2400668412,
-0.1481156051,
0.1638862342,
0.1156150326,
-0.5542914271,
-0.2530767918,
-0.2890146971,
0.4908234775,
0.5092483759,
-0.2557736039,
0.588904202,
0.3643003404,
1.0160363913,
-0.6548045278,
-0.2024873644,
-0.339143604,
0.216588214,
-0.2332223356,
-0.2167764008,
-0.2255483121,
-0.5588390231,
-0.2293180674,
-0.3843306601,
0.1207404062,
0.076716505,
0.7402604818,
0.4225343466,
-0.4099496603,
0.253485024,
-0.7322147489,
0.6678697467,
-0.6744443774,
0.32040447,
0.4703174829,
0.4372382164,
-0.1098161787,
-0.1975293905,
-0.4156172276,
0.2183284461,
-0.0516336896,
0.0470626764,
-0.6133538485,
-0.0911318436,
0.4272403419,
0.2537377775,
-0.4826331437,
-0.1529461741,
-0.2365100831,
0.0071214838,
0.3774030209,
-0.01052042,
0.4981813729,
-0.208440721,
-0.1475197226,
0.0116735222,
-0.471041441,
-0.0164296739,
0.2932650447,
0.106392622,
0.2080641687,
0.5415140986,
-0.3850023746,
0.5249618888,
0.6481990814,
0.2520801127,
0.6527248025,
0.0205101315,
-0.2583978772,
0.0636803284,
0.6580020189,
0.4151386917,
0.1227861866,
-0.1441016793,
-0.4418394864,
0.2606571019,
0.4329878986,
-0.4676171839,
-0.0650901645,
0.7459712625,
-0.6127377152,
-0.4799911678,
0.2411480844,
-1.1804692745,
-0.5163102746,
0.0842426494,
0.5486770272,
-0.1646391451,
-0.1669276953,
0.1790835112,
-0.1099493355,
0.1222674996,
0.0996719599,
-0.4176313877,
0.6173791289,
0.4352627993,
0.3024330437,
0.1163544208,
0.1992598772,
-1.0040510893,
-0.3666541278,
-0.2683192194,
0.9024848342,
-0.3978770971,
-0.4433047473,
-0.01693579,
0.0087504545,
0.1183428839,
-0.7621731758,
0.6854202151,
-0.762124598,
0.2318815291,
-0.3877260983,
-0.528236866,
-0.1405869573,
0.5466191769,
-0.8547821641,
1.0881786346,
0.1020391956,
-1.0078917742,
0.4016103148,
-0.6517848969,
-0.1489369124,
0.0432451144,
-0.2447327673,
-0.6804820895,
0.0674864948,
0.7790174484,
-0.0475510508,
-0.3206829131,
0.1386360377,
-0.541430831,
-0.3912956417,
0.370762676,
-0.3218798637,
0.7603127956,
0.1626557708,
-0.3662753701,
-0.2132332325,
-0.7754184604,
0.7367880344,
-0.2182578593,
0.0103010731,
-0.3982422948,
-0.1913868785,
0.0287844893,
0.0319938362,
-0.1265268624,
-0.8740632534,
-0.1830622405,
-0.1446728855,
-0.0803296119,
0.5566153526,
0.4966461957,
0.1311936527,
-0.6998221278,
0.8475135565,
0.2212905884,
0.6535598636,
0.4124614298,
-0.4133097827,
-0.3189477324,
0.0218089726,
0.5098205209,
0.3677041233,
-0.8385635018,
0.4061686099,
0.0827023312,
-0.3398184776,
-0.9564858079,
0.1616318375,
0.5745778084,
0.6240592003,
0.7225031257,
-0.4268371165,
-0.3219815493,
-0.9892178178,
-0.659712851,
-0.0832370371,
-0.2756979465,
0.0641184524,
0.3876043558,
-0.2487336546,
0.7875704765,
-0.5808211565,
-0.4879081547,
-0.0336853601,
-0.0355368927,
0.1338415295,
0.3725885153,
0.2563643157,
-0.6370928884,
-0.3748092949,
-0.2274873853,
-0.6797787547,
-0.340722084,
0.3252216876,
-0.1364851892,
-0.1072092801,
0.3036364913,
-0.3465349376,
0.522352159,
0.3603786528,
-0.5230705738,
0.2996918559,
-0.3043031991,
0.4048721492,
-0.7396149039,
0.0676051229,
0.0781971663,
-0.0367072821,
-0.4958644509,
-0.1203130931,
0.2699400187,
0.3413593471,
-0.1870420575,
0.3626413643,
-0.6312080026,
0.0233562719,
-0.0685161799,
0.0925775245,
0.4404276609,
0.1889264584,
-0.4876314402,
0.1381597668,
0.5759847164,
-0.3262913227,
0.10620711,
0.6133298874,
-0.4946041107,
0.8217245936,
-0.7283002734,
0.3012551367,
-0.3437706232,
0.2691783011,
-0.6350972056,
-0.0708723664,
0.297853291,
-0.4433697462,
-0.0095244823,
-0.4994814098,
-0.538713336,
-0.2291669846,
-0.414312005,
0.6131027937,
0.8486838341,
-0.6354956031,
0.5021563768,
0.5253542066,
0.5252066851,
-0.7746053934,
-0.6029179096,
-0.5121669769,
-0.2521697879,
-0.197804153,
0.1003480181,
0.0970532075,
-0.5608274937,
0.2685746551,
-0.4161656797,
-0.4219081998,
0.0289540589,
0.5322785378,
0.4159599245,
-0.0818471834,
0.1424126923,
0.161097765,
-0.0940521508,
0.2240044326,
-0.1887923926,
0.1372827739,
0.1509047151,
-0.8457148075,
-0.5781778097,
0.20959723,
0.8817076087,
-0.3654047549,
0.2852376997,
0.1351470202,
-0.4566770494,
-0.3525406718,
-0.6374312043,
-0.2533452809,
-0.3395190835,
0.011238317,
0.1508866996,
-0.5806732774,
0.4997843504,
0.2612388432,
-0.0106539214,
0.4659838974,
0.0932179093,
0.0784567073,
1.1437654495,
-0.0082981503,
-0.1331911981,
-0.0493789092,
0.3163270652,
0.1804074496,
-1.0698456764,
-0.2472497076,
-0.59031564,
-0.1659392416,
-0.6316957474,
-0.5584273934,
0.5931658745,
0.0265823938,
-0.0263540428,
-0.4256198704,
-0.4774454236,
0.582598269,
0.4099152088,
0.5439715385,
0.5080878735,
-0.1927907318,
-0.2945088744,
0.2739061117,
-0.4978176951,
-0.4253948331,
1.4724397659,
0.2930289805,
0.7588447928,
0.0091646891,
0.6504414678,
0.3697852194,
0.2496842444,
-0.3859103322,
0.1045923308,
-0.1074788943,
-0.7078350186,
-0.4087461829,
-0.2428047359,
-0.758382678,
0.4288996458,
-0.3074339032,
-0.5578504801,
0.3238210082,
0.189597562,
-0.8776935339,
0.4731319547,
-0.4653234482,
0.6371613145,
-0.0617842637,
-0.2765184045,
0.1353077888,
-0.4865510464,
0.1612217277,
-0.3089091778,
0.4974468052,
0.0569054708,
0.3586113155,
0.738686204,
-0.5815392137,
0.4369787276,
-0.4136794209,
0.108761996,
0.3949365616,
0.1575900167,
0.3724881411,
0.33585307,
-0.0881847292,
0.0267470405,
0.50371176,
-0.4926627278,
-0.7956573367,
0.3829952776,
-0.6762039661,
-0.3429911733,
-0.5361751318,
0.0267276801,
-0.7230451703,
0.2605592608,
0.1423674226,
0.5073770881,
-0.3520044386,
0.0157883801,
0.823966682,
-0.1337892562,
-0.1656110883,
0.7116298079,
-0.3807468414,
-0.1868053377,
0.1542306542,
0.1549444646,
0.1025185138,
0.210313186,
0.1849097311,
-0.5174407959,
-0.4650011063,
-0.5188450813,
0.1108991131,
-0.4853104949,
-0.1848354191,
-0.5826146007,
0.0369965024,
-0.1996760666,
0.4526757598,
-0.2279585451,
-0.1699023098,
-0.2419147342,
-0.265907079,
0.3638100624,
0.7282141447,
-0.0706506073,
0.0226553436,
-0.9996981025,
0.6697543859,
0.4209168553,
0.6106889248,
-0.112317495,
-0.8279396892,
0.059041325,
0.1066972911,
-0.1209266782,
-1.1032543182,
0.1742159873,
-0.3499559164,
0.4799312353,
0.5507953167,
0.4920373857,
0.4645116627,
-0.4184562862,
0.517303586,
-0.1492138505,
-0.9996453524,
0.5164985657,
-0.2760109007,
0.3475266397,
1.0068997145,
0.1535006911,
-0.3926417232,
-0.188898325,
-0.8362429738,
-0.5910872221,
0.4005406499,
0.1274494082,
-0.2748223841,
-0.0663293377,
0.3833388686,
-0.0222741254,
0.1863228828,
-0.2876769304,
-0.4949525595,
0.0697084367,
0.038625218,
0.0749625787,
-0.5837289691,
-0.4009317458,
-0.0377275012,
0.70687747,
-0.103880614,
-0.0678177252,
0.3589107394,
-0.0156436693,
-0.4654374719,
0.6695126295,
-0.1527938396,
0.4646045864,
-0.4749587476,
0.1583409905,
0.0875643864,
-0.5720046759,
0.2744075954,
-0.0386732556,
-0.5170701742,
0.1836228967,
0.0030930678,
0.2807777226,
-0.1283963025,
-0.5693118572,
0.5516695976,
-0.1481395513,
-0.3359244168,
-0.1393684596,
-0.1926848292,
-0.3716766536,
0.1934946924,
0.3518202901,
0.0530208945,
0.2262580842,
-0.1818623096,
0.6014081836,
0.4917865992,
-0.940661788,
-0.2606264353,
0.5348961353,
-0.0389328189,
0.0122784842,
0.6372584105,
-0.0341581292,
-0.4890226126,
0.5412287116,
0.1714262664,
0.9612655044,
-0.4359230399,
0.6233665943,
0.3134838939,
0.367731899,
-0.3894480765,
0.5826976895,
0.2554088831,
-0.8283088207,
-0.0549420677,
-0.3345413208,
-0.4293696284,
0.2673790455,
-1.4505143166,
0.114284575,
-0.5407884121,
-0.2446787953,
-0.08078821,
-0.0999849662,
-0.5232367516,
0.4404476583,
-0.3231735528,
0.6546855569,
-0.9605472088,
0.5086921453,
0.6915792823,
-0.1853679419,
-0.8117182255,
0.3528940082,
0.1833247542,
-0.8106442094,
0.4228380322,
-0.0324231535,
0.0008623117,
-0.2993835509,
-0.2962722182,
-0.6669288874,
0.750723958,
0.1493733674,
-0.3666959107,
0.3676372766,
0.074291639,
0.600141108,
-0.002049759,
0.4971708655,
0.6757880449,
0.5186766982,
-0.267387718,
-0.9543870687,
0.276779741,
-0.421284169,
-0.38128829,
0.4481914341,
-0.5120486021,
0.6933634281,
-0.2730802298,
-0.304499954,
-0.2133879066,
-0.0533659682,
0.186882183,
0.4984864593,
0.7565748692,
0.6393705606,
0.9505853057,
0.0398715362,
0.8403269053,
-0.1862720847,
0.3358055055,
1.2496960163,
-0.5085352063,
0.5337889194,
0.7618914843,
-0.2169778347,
0.5164092183,
0.2616592944,
-0.1722515523,
0.4460636079,
0.4322196543,
-0.1582308859,
-0.2505266666,
-0.3352265358,
-0.5522993803,
0.4873426855,
-0.1062234864,
-0.2897183597,
-0.3873230517,
-0.1365412921,
0.057608474,
0.0822582021,
-0.1318299174,
0.6343732476,
-0.0984278768,
-0.5355044603,
0.3579699397,
-0.1842845231,
0.2227373123,
-0.2249587327,
-0.0946472436,
-0.4326576591,
0.2003655434,
-0.4754856527,
-0.6458628774,
0.0863314569,
0.2378260344,
-0.2338850647,
-0.0716811866,
0.4426816702,
-0.0594622195,
-0.3199425042,
0.199666366,
1.0652638674,
-0.0800692663,
-0.4842021465,
-0.699485898,
-0.1742640883,
0.2329765856,
-0.0924427882,
0.4820962548,
0.6306398511,
0.0301928688,
0.6756193638,
0.5426365733,
0.1542959958,
-0.3094084561,
0.1715658605,
0.8787873983,
-0.4294284284,
-0.7655324936,
-0.711081326,
0.459715724,
0.1108639315,
-0.128680706,
1.0131447315,
0.4768604934,
0.5071769357,
0.0893227831,
0.8404076099,
0.282317698,
1.0194188356,
-0.4056046009,
0.7803742886,
-0.4656601846,
0.515624404,
-0.4147724807,
-0.4381482005,
-0.3618483245,
0.1696497351,
-0.0686338991,
0.1396246552,
0.7196280956,
0.5491014123,
0.1553420573,
0.2221169621,
0.3316090107,
0.0614211224,
-0.0431462713,
0.3338049054,
0.8126216531,
-0.7560321093,
0.2274028212,
-0.3224077225,
-0.3031253517,
0.0893871263,
-0.5611481071,
-0.7650506496,
-0.1211740598,
-0.4952459335,
-0.8765560389,
0.0605450757,
0.6031225324,
0.2612737119,
-0.9769980907,
0.0780593604,
0.2303827405,
0.3883515298,
-0.4071418643,
-0.1829344928,
0.4176647067,
0.1421577632,
-0.2870857716,
0.1634456813,
0.075224705,
0.0978515446,
-0.1019220129,
0.3306415975,
0.1253355145,
-0.0227098726,
0.0633687899,
0.3536487222,
-0.3172875643,
-0.1497085392,
0.1865733862,
0.3267584443,
0.2030839026,
0.581694901,
-0.9547592402,
0.5331915617,
0.1491612196,
0.4831081033,
0.0871609375,
0.4226782024,
0.2076728642,
-0.3850659728,
-0.416539371,
0.288985461,
0.1509984583,
0.1364471018,
-0.5156764388,
0.2623189986,
-0.0668048859,
-0.588981986,
-1.1679157019,
0.0143683814,
-0.7079231739,
-0.1311472952,
1.2461713552,
0.2302445471,
-0.2359742224,
-0.5509281754,
0.1015826985,
0.0519825183,
-0.4102783203,
1.0194190741,
0.5605181456,
-0.4239111543,
0.1076253802,
-0.6583713889,
0.6088832021,
0.7098129392,
-0.8510255814,
-0.02499073,
0.590282023,
0.4836879373,
-0.0851874128,
0.6856688857,
-0.6269682646,
0.349642247,
-0.1271032542,
-0.0390971676,
0.1225453913,
0.1261080652,
-0.7377566099,
0.2519207299,
0.1511780322,
-0.7170289159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18371v1
|
QANA: LLM-based Question Generation and Network Analysis for Zero-shot Key Point Analysis and Beyond
| 2024-04-29T02:17:31 | 2024-04-29T02:17:31 |
Tomoki Fukuma, Koki Noda, Toshihide Ubukata Kousuke Hoso, Yoshiharu Ichikawa, Kyosuke Kambe, Yu Masubuch, Fujio Toriumi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The proliferation of social media has led to information overload and
increased interest in opinion mining. We propose "Question-Answering Network
Analysis" (QANA), a novel opinion mining framework that utilizes Large Language
Models (LLMs) to generate questions from users' comments, constructs a
bipartite graph based on the comments' answerability to the questions, and
applies centrality measures to examine the importance of opinions. We
investigate the impact of question generation styles, LLM selections, and the
choice of embedding model on the quality of the constructed QA networks by
comparing them with annotated Key Point Analysis datasets. QANA achieves
comparable performance to previous state-of-the-art supervised models in a
zero-shot manner for Key Point Matching task, also reducing the computational
cost from quadratic to linear. For Key Point Generation, questions with high
PageRank or degree centrality align well with manually annotated key points.
Notably, QANA enables analysts to assess the importance of key points from
various aspects according to their selection of centrality measure. QANA's
primary contribution lies in its flexibility to extract key points from a wide
range of perspectives, which enhances the quality and impartiality of opinion
mining.
|
[
-0.3224377334,
-0.9739543796,
0.8581160903,
-0.016736567,
-0.3555375934,
-0.0409591496,
0.1360491216,
-0.2096029222,
0.5971827507,
0.5489892364,
-0.5350726247,
-0.8582622409,
-0.2350738645,
0.0436281487,
-0.4416760504,
0.8910352588,
0.2106655538,
-0.0836199895,
-0.2413410842,
-0.2987150252,
-0.3646381497,
-0.5259041786,
-0.8547950983,
0.0950510502,
0.8229939342,
0.4234788418,
0.769382,
0.197038874,
0.4233573675,
0.2193368226,
0.0000737957,
0.2578014731,
-0.4202736914,
0.5130944252,
-0.1199521571,
-0.8871845603,
-0.7899879217,
-0.0821317583,
0.5313287377,
0.5333129168,
0.2138830274,
0.6079769135,
-0.2090626061,
0.7638156414,
-0.6169176698,
-0.0002772428,
-0.7778043151,
-0.0341938138,
-0.1550002992,
-0.4478180408,
-0.0595453642,
-0.8038856983,
0.0312308911,
-0.364166081,
0.1015880033,
-0.0072748852,
0.7277153134,
0.0626542196,
-0.5045772195,
-0.3792977035,
-0.7293556929,
0.4476862252,
-0.9277898669,
-0.2713965476,
0.1564513892,
0.5436658859,
-0.0166002009,
-0.4929276705,
-1.0095053911,
0.38951388,
0.3051086068,
0.24370417,
-0.2442782819,
0.0330172703,
-0.0323572867,
0.3096298575,
-0.6795381904,
-0.1331690848,
-0.3838256001,
0.2709584534,
0.9063629508,
0.3146256208,
0.3173961341,
-0.6267489791,
0.1438876688,
-0.0417195447,
-0.9973524809,
0.1795290709,
0.7353646159,
0.3052992821,
0.2726819515,
0.6155573726,
-0.6141220331,
0.5368600488,
0.0822423473,
0.0994402394,
0.0298275705,
-0.2740330398,
-0.3679574728,
-0.22831662,
1.0045880079,
0.6582109928,
0.1450760812,
-0.007950752,
0.0697916001,
-0.0436349921,
0.09636271,
-0.9128832817,
-0.3053939939,
0.7216124535,
-0.5445165634,
-0.7277171016,
0.009273069,
-0.5732773542,
-0.3580737114,
-0.0821300149,
0.3783407211,
0.0782415867,
-0.6621150374,
-0.1397016197,
-0.0083759846,
0.4491635859,
0.2894984782,
-0.3321394324,
0.0671588778,
0.5674337745,
0.9596115351,
0.1039276347,
0.1987539679,
-0.4403304458,
-0.1523202211,
-0.5874631405,
1.0912262201,
-0.4431977868,
-0.3453833163,
0.3150857687,
-0.0828400925,
0.0709823817,
-0.6025173068,
-0.0644696206,
-1.0296173096,
-0.0083394917,
-0.6663695574,
-0.6285533309,
-0.2940793931,
0.7655286789,
-0.5699076056,
0.8851175308,
-0.1453606933,
-0.4895239472,
0.2182811499,
-0.6653997898,
-0.1254232973,
0.096626997,
-0.4103762805,
-0.3983433545,
-0.0437570177,
0.3029722571,
0.6463153362,
-0.3509527147,
0.1276048571,
-0.6270816922,
-0.0538745038,
0.6740175486,
-0.1105995476,
0.8273853064,
0.0702139214,
-0.1718923151,
0.3359285593,
-0.7748999596,
0.2941552401,
0.2070460171,
-0.0190446898,
-0.2414734811,
0.0183850881,
-0.1780021489,
0.4563676715,
0.1463381946,
-0.6416680813,
-0.028309457,
-0.4454360902,
0.4516374767,
0.561821878,
0.8192762136,
0.2335753739,
-0.2851389349,
0.76943928,
-0.0056523439,
0.2873565555,
-0.0342412516,
-0.6253266335,
-0.6098510027,
0.2589078844,
0.1248211637,
0.4660466015,
-0.7138103247,
0.2600333691,
-0.2883470654,
-0.6468946934,
-0.5652402639,
0.2545753419,
0.2207304835,
0.323443085,
0.0922191441,
-0.4164313078,
-0.179131791,
-0.8611505032,
0.0692279637,
-0.5521391034,
0.0987465754,
0.2846652567,
0.2403015494,
0.3048822582,
1.2038698196,
-0.6451789141,
-0.0764150992,
-0.4873105586,
0.143574506,
0.2040683925,
-0.0246462896,
0.5654882789,
-0.7590390444,
-0.6420779228,
-0.2480399609,
-0.9307221174,
-0.1866659373,
-0.1330676377,
-0.3144402504,
-0.2800936997,
0.3779436052,
-0.6463850141,
0.3088727891,
0.4443781376,
-0.0456991792,
0.4436630905,
0.3806064427,
0.2010665834,
-1.5434732437,
0.1368974,
-0.0801067576,
-0.1554096192,
-0.8130548596,
-0.0849677622,
-0.1282386184,
-0.4362406433,
-0.5364559293,
0.4438858032,
-0.2365023345,
-0.1887456328,
-0.5274005532,
0.5418787599,
0.2152449787,
0.6999053955,
-0.2357529402,
0.434319973,
0.1460437328,
-0.4125667512,
0.3946882188,
0.3066239953,
-0.1375952214,
0.8051586151,
-0.9363254309,
0.473305136,
-0.1961554289,
-0.0269157179,
-1.4135180712,
-0.1027778611,
0.1765189469,
-0.8840908408,
0.0503434911,
-0.255730629,
-0.4850866199,
0.002026621,
-0.5928460956,
0.4978517592,
0.1680952162,
-0.2200270444,
0.235591948,
0.5307990909,
-0.4075170457,
-0.3565606177,
-0.1771556139,
-0.0031492587,
-0.0452334322,
-0.9015037417,
-0.082620427,
-0.0265220702,
-0.3812502921,
0.3965276182,
0.1224228665,
-0.0662630647,
0.157938391,
0.4695468843,
0.2131750584,
-0.2889014482,
0.160777241,
0.3359799683,
0.1499134153,
0.358585149,
0.0136697674,
0.5394343138,
-0.1711911708,
-0.2795463204,
-0.4524977803,
0.2945804894,
0.4768693447,
-0.4286671877,
0.5395740867,
0.0822432339,
-0.158111915,
-0.4337480068,
-0.3098785877,
-0.0092163412,
-0.4062141776,
0.316031903,
-0.1544459164,
-0.9024028778,
0.634431839,
0.0084467074,
0.3641361594,
0.5386555791,
0.766625762,
-0.318397671,
0.8697824478,
0.3949557245,
-0.1162277013,
0.5318189859,
-0.4139230549,
0.4300691485,
-0.7058852911,
0.0917090327,
-0.2599437535,
-0.4222608805,
-0.4782158732,
-0.2480035275,
0.542833209,
0.1426718235,
-0.0429398194,
0.0595337823,
-0.2733312845,
0.3451919854,
0.4013843238,
0.027140785,
0.1958528012,
-0.2670632601,
0.4141564369,
0.4494723678,
-0.4568012059,
-0.6608278751,
1.7671115398,
0.2831127346,
0.0981665775,
0.3150395453,
0.7722287774,
0.3181380033,
0.5471848249,
-0.8436286449,
0.7029125094,
0.3456380665,
-0.8800067902,
-0.5783239007,
-0.3718898892,
-0.7446653843,
0.3119656444,
-0.3923188448,
-0.4537704885,
0.3634507358,
0.1206449419,
-0.9472413063,
0.3900167346,
-0.3184194565,
0.6643558741,
0.1188993603,
-0.2790443301,
-0.1813773364,
-0.5493792295,
0.5852546096,
0.1681864411,
-0.1183757633,
-0.3478989005,
0.4617861807,
0.8568704724,
-0.5510768294,
0.8626530766,
-0.4244024754,
0.1276085824,
0.8800106049,
0.1038793996,
0.2510201633,
0.2932094634,
-0.0956883654,
0.1397765428,
0.2090058327,
-0.3478082418,
-0.9426679611,
0.6291885376,
-0.8773342371,
-0.5764570236,
-0.1291265041,
-0.4486910105,
-0.4422696829,
0.1077004299,
-0.0440560505,
0.5170029402,
-0.150630787,
0.1568269283,
0.5904348493,
-0.171403721,
0.2664510608,
0.2158015519,
-0.2749175429,
-0.6426170468,
0.7873840928,
0.4775120914,
0.33479321,
0.3634794652,
-0.0240432005,
-0.1761660576,
-0.7771277428,
-0.4106168151,
0.263156265,
-0.6530630589,
-0.501091063,
-0.5190227032,
-0.376524806,
-0.3998201489,
0.0514821634,
-0.2859255373,
-0.5867906809,
-0.0653959885,
-0.4436229467,
0.2503121495,
0.6035410762,
0.1764745861,
0.6419149637,
-0.7032594681,
0.1851438135,
0.5681889653,
0.0158118773,
0.1259047687,
-0.1060938388,
-0.2080814391,
-0.1919133812,
-0.5635563135,
-1.3152297735,
0.3361381292,
-0.0804304108,
0.1507639736,
0.5724059939,
0.1376993805,
0.3743941188,
-0.0272734873,
0.8557214737,
0.0424250178,
-0.6068895459,
0.6278568506,
-0.3656673729,
-0.0453597605,
0.7303946614,
0.2952390909,
-0.5521557927,
-0.4516510367,
-0.6713081598,
-0.9086912274,
0.1716890186,
0.3138683736,
0.1144284382,
-0.3496299088,
0.7112519741,
-0.2268425524,
0.5179924965,
-0.5036277175,
-0.1731314212,
-0.2293488681,
-0.3638940752,
0.3207247555,
-0.3485559523,
-0.0428534113,
0.2316141278,
0.6266186237,
-0.3066899478,
0.1151906624,
0.2938627303,
-0.1056742221,
-0.2618079185,
0.3346990049,
0.1449738145,
0.7775877118,
-0.4654383957,
-0.0422720499,
-0.0329645909,
-0.1259696484,
0.0304076355,
-0.2892966866,
-0.6161937118,
-0.0113185355,
0.1931398809,
0.5939007401,
-0.3029506803,
-0.4166201651,
0.7170133591,
-0.1088727489,
-0.3087964952,
-0.3673165143,
0.0018564571,
0.0899851844,
0.3889606893,
0.3237563372,
-0.3169439733,
0.1510586888,
-0.7422510386,
-0.1272169054,
0.6332300901,
-0.4275813401,
-0.6626564264,
0.4271135628,
0.1977368444,
-0.0897846371,
0.3972135186,
-0.2973559797,
-0.2927121222,
0.7393689156,
0.0626536533,
1.0504742861,
-0.0878307298,
0.5793622136,
0.4369882643,
0.2720026374,
0.4157950282,
0.652205646,
-0.0842500404,
-0.7895109057,
-0.3080636859,
-0.6043819189,
-0.6802831292,
0.1444170624,
-0.6909032464,
-0.0897766575,
-0.8634417057,
-0.3776847124,
-0.100639917,
0.2739413977,
-0.5618767142,
0.5328157544,
-0.2013455629,
0.434001416,
-1.0517060757,
0.651412487,
0.6268317103,
-0.6811887026,
-0.8438120484,
0.0359109864,
0.0016138606,
-0.6172189116,
0.5156458616,
-0.040524032,
0.0273439642,
-0.1048514172,
-0.5759725571,
-0.793076992,
1.5350959301,
0.0122021064,
-0.4185354114,
-0.0026625211,
0.4109641612,
0.5193526745,
-0.4065736532,
0.2768667936,
0.3101396859,
0.0083686542,
0.1361681074,
-0.3382530808,
0.229506284,
-0.4541151524,
0.0027703841,
0.1758771986,
-0.8038482666,
0.7850946188,
0.0275853276,
-0.2685766518,
-0.1473419219,
0.9122623205,
0.3213447332,
0.4757860601,
0.541221261,
0.2987451851,
0.9187160134,
0.3157574534,
0.7843216658,
-0.5890102386,
0.1710618883,
1.0294636488,
-0.4175885916,
1.2248160839,
0.4519270062,
-0.1027101874,
0.5927007794,
0.6744174957,
0.2514497638,
0.3240404129,
0.2030251622,
-0.1433031857,
-0.2457337826,
0.0118237408,
-0.1328727156,
0.1545972973,
0.2063503265,
-0.1885090768,
-0.1462258399,
-0.4540038705,
0.0252117384,
-0.043929942,
-0.4374990165,
0.8322475553,
0.2550714314,
-0.317822814,
0.0177812744,
-0.0215713531,
0.220179975,
-0.5031331182,
0.1165260375,
-0.6365960836,
-0.3021631539,
-0.3386643827,
-0.8065082431,
0.4170882702,
0.0796548054,
-0.2682768404,
0.2808789015,
0.619682312,
-0.1543192714,
-0.493740797,
0.0481543988,
0.808349967,
0.1799917817,
-0.4754249454,
-0.4617902637,
-0.3624129295,
-0.2914237976,
-0.5624127388,
0.3444979489,
0.4463490546,
-0.2018571347,
0.3682411611,
0.8677071929,
0.2852842808,
0.1088521481,
0.0957947746,
0.8594821692,
-0.6983195543,
-0.3221064806,
-0.7936638594,
0.4673842192,
-0.3828870952,
-0.4516799152,
0.8193065524,
0.4074574411,
0.6339293122,
0.2564170957,
0.9948215485,
0.0657369867,
0.5330870152,
-0.3970349729,
0.775418222,
-0.5788244605,
0.2349546701,
-0.2865166664,
-1.0780404806,
-0.3821650147,
0.2616026998,
-0.5847665668,
-0.2525442243,
0.5388615727,
1.1110229492,
0.200019449,
-0.0226621907,
0.409837544,
0.0789515302,
0.6665084362,
0.4668206573,
0.8006473184,
-0.5299296975,
0.6461231112,
-0.0627176538,
-0.2769368589,
-0.1502766013,
-0.4957277477,
-1.0547469854,
-0.4603656828,
-0.3269340396,
-0.3922873437,
-0.2619966269,
0.8958634138,
0.5326818824,
-0.8166359067,
-0.2547153533,
0.0273956545,
0.2166970223,
0.0303146951,
-0.2541847229,
0.6594971418,
-0.3712274134,
-0.3978793323,
0.2825821042,
0.5042387843,
-0.4562047422,
-0.619538486,
0.1553301811,
-0.0723731965,
0.5949375033,
0.6728904843,
0.4336889088,
-0.4003468454,
-0.2199617475,
0.3509494066,
0.0914034471,
0.0892715007,
0.6828730106,
-0.2595597208,
0.463499248,
0.6807781458,
0.6975950003,
0.4780614972,
0.1351524293,
0.5162962675,
-0.5931751132,
-0.3892459869,
0.136230886,
0.1518666297,
0.3537175655,
-0.2408675104,
0.1792727709,
0.1549035013,
-0.5414136648,
-0.7134436965,
0.2794373333,
-0.9591775537,
-0.2482762784,
1.2484383583,
-0.1355853975,
-0.6049823761,
-0.0162485167,
-0.2272591144,
0.2043621838,
-0.1827905327,
0.9425391555,
0.5179097056,
-0.1276351064,
-0.1589754373,
-0.5742272735,
0.3037874103,
0.319811821,
-0.9649852514,
-0.163774088,
0.3684924841,
0.5226361156,
0.244694978,
1.052123785,
-0.1736405343,
0.325034976,
-0.2587251663,
0.1714194268,
-0.1268010288,
-0.2547777593,
-0.2625969648,
0.9402606487,
0.3620419204,
-0.343316853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18359v1
|
FoundaBench: Evaluating Chinese Fundamental Knowledge Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-29T01:49:07 | 2024-04-29T01:49:07 |
Wei Li, Ren Ma, Jiang Wu, Chenya Gu, Jiahui Peng, Jinyang Len, Songyang Zhang, Hang Yan, Dahua Lin, Conghui He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the burgeoning field of large language models (LLMs), the assessment of
fundamental knowledge remains a critical challenge, particularly for models
tailored to Chinese language and culture. This paper introduces FoundaBench, a
pioneering benchmark designed to rigorously evaluate the fundamental knowledge
capabilities of Chinese LLMs. FoundaBench encompasses a diverse array of 3354
multiple-choice questions across common sense and K-12 educational subjects,
meticulously curated to reflect the breadth and depth of everyday and academic
knowledge. We present an extensive evaluation of 12 state-of-the-art LLMs using
FoundaBench, employing both traditional assessment methods and our CircularEval
protocol to mitigate potential biases in model responses. Our results highlight
the superior performance of models pre-trained on Chinese corpora, and reveal a
significant disparity between models' reasoning and memory recall capabilities.
The insights gleaned from FoundaBench evaluations set a new standard for
understanding the fundamental knowledge of LLMs, providing a robust framework
for future advancements in the field.
|
[
-0.1423292011,
-0.788153708,
0.4906875491,
0.3996416032,
-0.0581114776,
0.0296093337,
-0.5240012407,
-0.2599870861,
-0.0427877791,
0.5675753951,
-0.3893097043,
-0.6206477284,
-0.3534359634,
-0.1214358583,
-0.299143225,
0.5063406825,
-0.1226207539,
0.1997202635,
-0.1062545404,
-0.2292795777,
-0.3347099423,
-0.3965710104,
-0.4120755494,
-0.3984766603,
0.5658376813,
0.398562938,
0.5441946983,
0.4513713121,
0.6982263923,
0.1662347168,
-0.4342953861,
0.5011973977,
-0.6713318825,
-0.07694529,
-0.2213906497,
-0.2868912816,
-0.3806462288,
0.0200188812,
0.8343342543,
0.9959806204,
-0.4014971852,
0.2351791859,
0.0282513648,
0.7177565098,
-0.5117498636,
-0.0644419491,
-0.8323947787,
0.0694125593,
-0.2670948803,
0.0919081867,
-0.2893850207,
-0.6421068311,
0.2541170716,
-0.7393827438,
0.247992292,
-0.1403111964,
0.6933866739,
-0.182890296,
-0.4678528011,
-0.4084708691,
-0.3768186271,
0.7745742798,
-0.8106690645,
0.5028634667,
0.2123385072,
0.4581138492,
0.0167204365,
-0.9744420648,
-0.4609334469,
-0.6769009233,
0.0191849209,
0.0811870024,
0.2622816563,
-0.0119360778,
0.1865079552,
0.6272643805,
-0.6845784187,
0.1957801282,
-0.3107514977,
-0.4330162704,
0.6195377111,
0.1392423064,
0.3563879132,
-0.2676658332,
-0.3012512922,
0.0730138645,
-0.8063728809,
0.044805374,
0.1379612386,
0.2544972003,
0.0618762709,
0.1850208193,
-0.3730019629,
0.5109108686,
-0.063659057,
-0.2121234536,
0.109930113,
-0.4550843835,
-0.1154750213,
-0.118242383,
0.7152107954,
0.1950501353,
0.2530382574,
-0.0774015859,
-0.2994983494,
-0.1889038831,
0.0873856694,
-0.7146671414,
-0.1063019931,
-0.0520064794,
-0.3993613124,
-0.1373955905,
0.2029948086,
-0.574025929,
-0.5173327923,
-0.1989150643,
-0.000618192,
-0.3686006069,
-0.4227018654,
-0.0160138085,
-0.0871643499,
0.4616606832,
0.5023375154,
-0.7715455294,
0.1317050159,
1.022460103,
0.8866240978,
-0.1459953189,
-0.4625498056,
-0.2399749309,
0.0610148981,
-0.7955393791,
0.7574106455,
-0.3113295436,
-0.3654077053,
0.2660336196,
-0.0777962804,
0.1010027528,
-0.8951485753,
0.8076936603,
-0.5685108304,
-0.3908791244,
-0.6744689941,
-0.4761650562,
-0.4578584731,
0.6641927361,
-0.7295287848,
1.0447541475,
-0.0153561132,
-0.5853254199,
0.2902345955,
-0.3197515011,
-0.4163718522,
0.2573307157,
-0.3015427291,
0.0139966551,
-0.1123267487,
-0.0425865948,
0.4219604731,
-0.6747645736,
0.6701130867,
-0.6014463305,
-0.3517442346,
0.364669323,
-0.6597428322,
1.0381278992,
-0.0361231826,
-0.3096865118,
0.0774618015,
-0.7102549076,
0.1828913391,
0.0805994049,
-0.2751483321,
-0.2915383279,
-0.2563121319,
0.0104477648,
-0.0227346122,
0.6513457894,
-0.4285826981,
0.0750992522,
-0.1833760142,
0.3842142522,
0.8707478642,
-0.266924113,
0.1606687158,
-0.250862062,
0.126624912,
-0.2360872179,
0.1576327085,
-0.1802752167,
-0.0549280681,
-0.7518385053,
-0.1382839531,
0.2507496774,
0.3513178825,
-0.440233022,
0.1891106814,
-0.3081538677,
-1.098757863,
-0.4725329578,
0.5480943918,
0.3442391157,
0.3392938972,
0.0750211552,
-0.088938199,
-0.1829370856,
-1.0112799406,
-0.1565369815,
-0.2161213011,
-0.2673816383,
0.4994828105,
0.4484808147,
-0.5211706758,
0.5082037449,
-0.4164037406,
-0.044878494,
-0.2860884666,
0.0027475199,
0.177689001,
0.2149658501,
0.3816151023,
-0.6830678582,
-0.4147949219,
0.4774376452,
-1.022257328,
-0.2056782991,
0.0494108126,
-0.0915131047,
-0.1833285838,
0.4065179825,
-0.6008514166,
0.0059014289,
0.3414278924,
0.0656372234,
0.9460600615,
-0.1361973882,
0.0936988965,
-0.5073742867,
0.5485053658,
-0.3183815777,
0.0318827406,
-0.6076593995,
0.511192143,
0.4432478845,
0.0742178485,
-0.3469045758,
0.7905074954,
-0.5486835241,
-0.1154277921,
-0.1906210184,
0.7584093213,
-0.0206453167,
0.3988644779,
0.0138675915,
0.6113304496,
0.4573792219,
-0.8956726193,
0.7446829081,
0.018454032,
-0.655379951,
0.3314724863,
-0.6718939543,
0.357693553,
0.2212597877,
0.1593893319,
-0.910545826,
-0.2189952433,
-0.1011301279,
-0.3248672485,
0.1167173609,
0.2356424034,
-0.5558792353,
-0.4334848821,
-0.3412571847,
0.2962086201,
0.1042052656,
-0.6965178251,
0.5875333548,
0.369263947,
-0.1409456432,
-0.6385981441,
-0.3905332983,
-0.0532920472,
0.0044828379,
-0.8190258741,
0.2168588489,
-0.188959986,
-0.3371758163,
-0.384580642,
-0.2931555808,
-0.2130502462,
0.4159334004,
-0.0817368254,
0.2391906977,
-0.4953784347,
0.0169187021,
0.0034582298,
0.0774613693,
0.1429934055,
-0.0737103969,
0.5215699673,
-0.3672908545,
-0.558144927,
0.1548708826,
-0.1277413666,
0.5882213712,
-0.1184456721,
0.4554585218,
0.4446325302,
-0.4488008618,
-0.3456062675,
-0.6745218635,
-0.088817507,
-0.5001202226,
0.647685349,
-0.0762692541,
-0.7939137816,
0.7451401353,
-0.1538204104,
0.4268970191,
0.343596071,
0.600243926,
0.2624259591,
0.4609496593,
0.3474999964,
-0.0486711301,
0.097955212,
-0.0183803868,
0.1865865141,
-0.8347793221,
-0.3120865524,
-0.3164609075,
0.0471392088,
-0.466134876,
-0.5853440166,
0.1190672517,
0.1178012416,
-0.4458422661,
0.2131239623,
-0.1620882154,
0.2403664738,
0.5212160349,
0.238101095,
0.4859967232,
-0.4393391609,
-0.4367656112,
0.0793039054,
-0.6791447997,
-0.8328002691,
1.1379772425,
0.472830534,
0.5308709741,
0.1124553233,
0.1729641408,
0.1280015707,
0.550106287,
-0.7287647128,
0.8499217629,
-0.1970747411,
-0.9296423793,
-0.4935122132,
-0.5251212716,
-0.4716222882,
0.4017072022,
0.2911221683,
-0.4353730679,
-0.3042514026,
-0.0018622116,
-0.340806067,
0.2497073263,
-0.3772625625,
0.78897053,
-0.611141324,
-0.4208486676,
-0.3946466744,
-0.2597762048,
0.7219759226,
-0.3412460685,
0.1564924866,
-0.1873432547,
0.0685250461,
1.022382021,
0.0018837156,
0.7787558436,
-0.0551624186,
-0.2457674444,
0.4357788861,
0.1041401923,
0.2160077393,
0.2280661166,
-0.2030374855,
0.5196046233,
0.1809054166,
-0.447342217,
-0.6180491447,
0.8265681267,
-0.632650435,
-0.8035089374,
-0.2865927815,
-0.3001992702,
-0.0937262177,
0.4738515317,
0.0061140037,
0.2254975289,
-0.8777477145,
0.4553756714,
0.8089562058,
-0.5324705243,
0.1489537954,
0.9003904462,
-0.5410107374,
-0.3323355615,
0.7650084496,
0.4014451802,
0.3586273193,
0.4214073122,
0.2780730724,
-0.0786502734,
-0.1614263356,
-0.2205756158,
0.2537015975,
-0.9556239247,
-0.0090434626,
-0.426637888,
-0.5688106418,
-0.4570094049,
-0.1206171587,
-0.6708374023,
-0.0185319874,
-0.1477487981,
-0.341948688,
-0.0702004284,
0.5400403738,
-0.1541876793,
0.2564985454,
-0.6979738474,
0.3670303226,
0.563361764,
0.4948578477,
0.4756953418,
-0.778842628,
-0.4708676338,
0.1559353769,
-0.4502744377,
-0.5922134519,
0.11283461,
-0.1020052955,
0.9658293724,
0.8748736382,
0.0627817661,
0.59471035,
-0.3793426156,
0.7734884024,
0.0381083265,
-0.9383003712,
0.1887905449,
-0.3117572367,
0.231916517,
0.5045922399,
0.2350962609,
-0.9234134555,
-0.0743511245,
-0.5169523358,
-0.4696449339,
0.3722257018,
-0.0858348384,
0.1656221002,
0.1217994019,
0.1668328494,
0.1632129401,
0.1813342869,
-0.7162926793,
-0.1882573515,
-0.1436062306,
0.0677649304,
0.1800391674,
-0.4380668998,
0.1172078252,
-0.1849090755,
0.4905522168,
-0.0172658227,
0.0589015596,
0.0043423306,
-0.2230229378,
0.0586711243,
0.209433496,
0.5514732003,
0.9895860553,
-0.1625861377,
0.0358506516,
0.3518300653,
-0.6051136255,
-0.1793960333,
-0.0489234254,
-0.3358564377,
0.0764620304,
0.7811863422,
0.7278397083,
0.535474062,
-0.9573869705,
0.2616043091,
0.0740782842,
-0.1095762029,
-0.5528382659,
0.0762414932,
0.2208373845,
-0.0625472292,
0.5927685499,
-0.2858621776,
-0.0529409945,
-0.6623433232,
0.3266583681,
0.4690147042,
-0.4607512355,
-0.4092485905,
0.2109816074,
0.333606869,
-0.1328424215,
0.6662635207,
0.1532738954,
-0.889490962,
0.6012430191,
0.2124760449,
0.7055109143,
-0.3620756269,
0.2232481092,
0.6005604267,
0.6951157451,
-0.1901794076,
-0.1780315489,
-0.0351628996,
-0.9963917732,
0.078854166,
-0.3111587763,
-0.4775677323,
0.2953023314,
-0.6108332276,
0.3296434581,
-0.843206346,
0.0696687251,
-0.2470087707,
0.446998924,
-0.5500146747,
0.0372779332,
0.1939146966,
1.21763134,
-0.6854874492,
0.7315510511,
0.3575220704,
-0.1918596178,
-0.8035442233,
0.0635874346,
-0.0871779025,
-1.0697274208,
0.8760905266,
0.4926671982,
-0.0351078026,
-0.2234109789,
-0.5958361626,
-0.8165624738,
1.166433692,
0.2595895529,
-0.6692531705,
0.0146526722,
-0.010150386,
0.4943386614,
-0.1095938534,
0.714289844,
0.7633284926,
0.5914272666,
0.0606482625,
-1.0355776548,
-0.1139636412,
-0.1817222536,
-0.1880167723,
-0.1941680759,
-0.9648858905,
0.7251538038,
-0.1827358454,
-0.4409677982,
-0.0883390382,
0.9067261219,
0.7789349556,
0.6239814162,
0.0861569718,
0.0714151487,
1.2510985136,
0.0407722667,
0.7168446779,
-0.2693779171,
0.2789975107,
0.8566961884,
-0.568596065,
0.7644790411,
0.153036505,
-0.1343316436,
0.3632052243,
0.6774779558,
0.0448111668,
0.2953774929,
0.3305033445,
-0.1140034422,
-0.3080762923,
-0.1706307381,
-0.3470932245,
0.1465113461,
0.3502213359,
0.0062261578,
-0.1523403376,
-0.2892574072,
0.0824561566,
0.3135675788,
-0.3341643214,
0.5456691384,
0.318517983,
-0.6232318282,
0.7057445049,
0.0313744619,
0.7967967987,
-0.7189207077,
0.1118426695,
-0.7534605265,
0.0990006551,
0.0352567062,
-0.7649255991,
-0.0885456949,
0.0965723097,
-0.1139272302,
0.1199513078,
0.5849906206,
-0.2860858142,
-0.5748326182,
0.6246256232,
0.1985817999,
-0.1518501341,
-0.0387612991,
-0.5805838704,
0.0200829469,
0.1731474549,
-0.2091142386,
0.0967445374,
0.8413047194,
0.0117292134,
1.1009101868,
0.570309937,
0.219389841,
0.0806250796,
-0.061087843,
0.6759921908,
-0.8354265094,
-0.300812304,
-0.7328106165,
0.0411843508,
-0.145046711,
-0.3425917625,
0.9426726103,
0.5862812996,
0.8968003988,
0.0343988016,
0.8753299117,
0.2113308161,
0.8007334471,
-0.4389676154,
0.9339758754,
-0.450380981,
0.4714289308,
-0.3119452,
-0.8234307766,
-0.0480054617,
0.6583192348,
-0.5255644917,
0.0321430117,
0.6762693524,
0.8485813737,
0.0037288454,
-0.0657519922,
0.5783136487,
0.1815007627,
0.3873748779,
0.5357416868,
0.9471450448,
-0.3176369667,
0.4504666626,
-0.1663594544,
-0.3716120422,
-0.1839271635,
-0.6666797996,
-1.06452775,
-0.4942373335,
-0.0232813898,
0.1406941712,
-0.0953679234,
0.7494558692,
0.4115653932,
-0.8297811747,
-0.5900374651,
0.1173620448,
0.3081620038,
-0.1480509937,
-0.2220944762,
0.4886306524,
-0.1212624833,
-0.3220947981,
0.3050389886,
0.202937007,
-0.3310894668,
-0.5938053131,
-0.1928767264,
-0.2160733342,
0.0813652948,
0.602414012,
0.2200671881,
-0.9534971714,
0.0107782334,
0.3930368423,
-0.4629791081,
-0.2896567285,
0.8117433786,
-0.4705559015,
0.1718248129,
0.4348921776,
0.6633914113,
0.1995899528,
-0.2120817751,
0.6033670902,
-0.3222437501,
0.1482636929,
0.1592684239,
0.2454804331,
0.5973392129,
-0.0795515478,
0.4471359849,
0.260830164,
-0.4061754644,
-0.9941183925,
-0.1113143936,
-0.7328184247,
-0.3853383064,
1.1686383486,
-0.3207198381,
-0.0350782759,
0.1490882933,
-0.175144583,
0.2513245344,
-0.1339020431,
0.9063115716,
0.8789322972,
0.7025814652,
-0.2845194042,
-0.6918047071,
0.2321415991,
0.419280827,
-0.5159256458,
0.5694654584,
0.4181194901,
0.1569086909,
0.1950270087,
0.4677699506,
0.1137651801,
0.4343276322,
-0.0358295962,
-0.0616120622,
0.1101997346,
-0.3887084126,
0.0883901492,
0.0429947414,
0.2229574472,
0.3578706682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18311v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18311v4
|
Towards Incremental Learning in Large Language Models: A Critical Review
| 2024-04-28T20:44:53 | 2024-05-05T08:46:32 |
Mladjan Jovanovic, Peter Voss
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Incremental learning is the ability of systems to acquire knowledge over
time, enabling their adaptation and generalization to novel tasks. It is a
critical ability for intelligent, real-world systems, especially when data
changes frequently or is limited. This review provides a comprehensive analysis
of incremental learning in Large Language Models. It synthesizes the
state-of-the-art incremental learning paradigms, including continual learning,
meta-learning, parameter-efficient learning, and mixture-of-experts learning.
We demonstrate their utility for incremental learning by describing specific
achievements from these related topics and their critical factors. An important
finding is that many of these approaches do not update the core model, and none
of them update incrementally in real-time. The paper highlights current
problems and challenges for future research in the field. By consolidating the
latest relevant research developments, this review offers a comprehensive
understanding of incremental learning and its implications for designing and
developing LLM-based learning systems.
|
[
-0.1741801202,
-1.0084905624,
0.3619596362,
0.1386844367,
0.0557897054,
0.3938206434,
-0.4155614376,
-0.6520565152,
-0.3665431738,
0.2669739127,
-0.5180741549,
-0.2362052202,
-0.5938193202,
-0.0294638146,
-0.5055291057,
0.6988794208,
-0.0984841809,
0.0710479915,
-0.1001423001,
-0.2138528228,
-0.695440948,
-0.5759010911,
-0.9133378863,
-0.5327219367,
0.3731475174,
0.5796872377,
0.3427886665,
0.5108572841,
0.4229701161,
0.264023304,
-0.1318578273,
-0.006663688,
-0.5169911385,
0.6194726825,
-0.339299202,
-0.3744361103,
-0.2744603157,
-0.1730942875,
1.1555732489,
0.9487301707,
-0.2011292428,
0.1243960857,
0.2765474021,
0.7521312833,
-0.3043804169,
0.3115321398,
-0.7689134479,
0.197811991,
0.0226329397,
0.0409059487,
-0.3592144847,
-0.4776081145,
0.3087782264,
-0.1929526031,
0.0316552222,
-0.407536298,
0.334107697,
0.0138055924,
-0.2536956072,
-0.6194671988,
-0.9928812981,
0.8221142888,
-0.7323223352,
0.5318661928,
-0.1499818414,
0.3189119399,
-0.0331683196,
-0.6947892904,
-0.4023588598,
-0.7276427746,
0.4236620367,
-0.029036589,
0.3113890886,
-0.2045714706,
0.2017829716,
0.4612988532,
-0.2913984954,
0.3320929408,
-0.1421297193,
0.0917852297,
0.4985181391,
0.3964136839,
0.2998085916,
0.4309855998,
-0.3320383132,
-0.0145948436,
-1.0087291002,
-0.0163989551,
0.0034584978,
0.2348368317,
-0.0819557682,
0.1651184708,
-0.2787574232,
0.7207790613,
0.0038197655,
-0.579256773,
0.1900042742,
-0.3480999768,
-0.0265011638,
-0.2627771199,
0.2993920445,
-0.4932034612,
0.3329570591,
-0.2230869085,
-0.3187173009,
-0.2906749249,
0.1307355911,
-0.393327117,
0.0124772713,
0.2177501768,
-0.0378603414,
-0.113985762,
-0.0810184628,
-0.5508421063,
-0.1465635002,
-0.6808550358,
0.3699448407,
-0.5957401991,
-0.5251486301,
-0.0467517599,
0.3779959679,
0.2899633944,
0.7274648547,
-0.7352057695,
0.123321496,
0.7458479404,
0.7140564919,
-0.2055338472,
-0.7480868101,
-0.234943822,
0.0699808523,
-0.5626914501,
0.6130132079,
-0.6014050841,
-0.3108193278,
0.2688123882,
-0.0003762968,
-0.1650210768,
-0.7583979368,
-0.0749053434,
-0.6281815767,
-0.094314903,
-0.2029449344,
-0.6485051513,
-0.3371946514,
0.3821377158,
-0.2743760943,
0.8769087791,
0.0818797126,
-0.3524047136,
0.3639012277,
-0.4589624405,
-0.4499326646,
0.2894669175,
-0.0461934023,
-0.315603137,
0.0986533165,
-0.4263641238,
0.5851698518,
-0.1775925905,
0.596118331,
-0.4310783744,
-0.026009433,
0.4314790666,
-0.302793175,
0.5534018278,
0.2102226168,
-0.3889823556,
0.1017440856,
-0.5897139311,
-0.2476098537,
0.1886007339,
-0.6712279916,
-0.1367000192,
0.3680781722,
-0.2856924534,
0.3470109701,
0.3516614139,
-0.2590771019,
0.4452185035,
-0.0789817348,
0.5655513406,
0.9146038294,
0.1659406126,
0.5050174594,
-0.2639106512,
0.337176919,
0.1074332297,
0.3872705996,
-0.5746325254,
-0.062601313,
-0.9436308742,
-0.0064067408,
0.5000169277,
0.6206456423,
-0.7827326655,
0.1700603366,
-0.3437024951,
-0.4798878729,
-0.1504296362,
0.3962184191,
0.276986897,
0.3321262598,
0.3050173223,
-0.2996093631,
-0.1237775758,
-0.4174438119,
0.0414143726,
-0.0035954828,
0.2874740958,
0.1922736764,
0.6762657166,
-0.3947137892,
0.5094879866,
-0.2062667906,
-0.1365784109,
-0.4037424624,
-0.0514586531,
-0.053429395,
0.7124968171,
0.1698144823,
-0.654019475,
-0.5396222472,
0.259665221,
-1.0543481112,
0.3504983783,
-0.3139836192,
0.4453105628,
0.097193256,
0.7209231257,
-0.3060298562,
-0.0589114614,
0.2697025537,
-0.021733297,
0.565105021,
-0.3698072135,
-0.1753917783,
-0.6595920324,
-0.0497957021,
0.0962354466,
-0.2098934799,
-0.6576366425,
0.5933519006,
0.1414084435,
-0.0928600505,
-0.3473739624,
0.6761684418,
-0.5182319283,
0.0283352956,
-0.3211117685,
0.0906328261,
-0.5389682055,
0.4078626335,
0.0148931164,
0.4977099299,
0.5881622434,
-1.0167285204,
0.3559794426,
-0.1872642785,
-0.4625431597,
0.4701452851,
-0.3859682679,
0.1704927534,
-0.0686957166,
0.2435147017,
-0.8040590882,
-0.199762851,
0.0998926833,
-0.3661902249,
0.6550427079,
0.1921667755,
-0.665774107,
-0.0250575077,
-0.0107987728,
0.238519907,
0.3163949251,
-0.2735053003,
0.3764179647,
0.6007579565,
-0.4772217572,
-0.4433188736,
-0.2810843587,
0.1153994873,
0.0262870397,
-0.2049751729,
-0.0909141749,
-0.0698171481,
-0.4758860767,
-0.0649584457,
0.0370479412,
0.0261333417,
0.2880259752,
-0.0102876592,
0.161156103,
0.0241968576,
0.6579220891,
-0.14744398,
-0.242948696,
-0.230571866,
-0.7017931342,
0.4830647111,
-0.0720642954,
-0.2302087992,
-0.2994588912,
0.3733050525,
0.682471633,
-0.1171769127,
0.6667371988,
0.439591825,
-0.3209492266,
-0.3231844008,
-0.7359226942,
-0.1475269943,
-0.3710831106,
0.5264857411,
-0.4589473307,
-1.1216799021,
0.3029858768,
-0.3443505764,
0.3637619317,
0.5439797044,
0.6197349429,
-0.0675794557,
0.8954665065,
1.1644778252,
-0.2073331475,
0.686763525,
-0.2821678519,
-0.0751440972,
-0.8076533675,
-0.4807099998,
-0.4577256143,
-0.1257801801,
-0.3828815222,
-0.1605965346,
0.3917831779,
-0.1502730995,
-0.4197718799,
0.0049127033,
-0.1413799077,
0.0890511423,
0.3353927135,
-0.016826123,
0.4682651758,
-0.1415277421,
-0.1368013918,
0.1324284524,
-0.7443074584,
-0.20383057,
0.738953352,
0.4205431342,
0.709059298,
-0.0124073923,
0.2298928797,
0.3857678175,
0.5834716558,
-0.7765452266,
0.4493067861,
0.0813835487,
-0.6609395146,
-0.4814215004,
-0.5119972825,
-0.8140220046,
0.2436973751,
-0.1857722551,
-0.3616259396,
0.1949145645,
0.0280856919,
-0.0464196615,
0.5079370141,
-0.4191566706,
0.4505446553,
-0.3205505311,
-0.4071223736,
-0.6055947542,
-0.5541633368,
0.3152268231,
-0.4433667064,
0.3118390739,
0.0728982165,
-0.3529174328,
0.4902016222,
0.0497941859,
0.9503344297,
-0.2667285204,
-0.3455793858,
0.3864712119,
0.1746750176,
0.6337045431,
-0.1147263795,
0.0764259547,
0.1284586638,
-0.0625837743,
-0.5045605302,
-0.2380772382,
0.7502686977,
-0.6482518911,
-0.4514211714,
-0.4897154272,
-0.4777878523,
-0.4508082271,
-0.0636433586,
-0.0098180035,
0.4749696255,
-0.1631821692,
0.2836332321,
1.2587968111,
-0.2418927103,
0.3612205684,
0.6598284245,
-0.3731389046,
-0.3717699349,
1.0888643265,
0.7224714756,
0.5218356848,
0.4786089361,
0.0002931044,
-0.1190793663,
-0.8817577362,
-0.2320454121,
0.5039360523,
-0.8540243506,
0.150559634,
-0.7952740192,
-0.2204143405,
-0.2877644002,
-0.0655744597,
-0.2895482779,
-0.2492351234,
-0.3345506787,
-0.0426182225,
-0.0152779985,
1.0411952734,
-0.1517756879,
0.0112413177,
-0.829369247,
-0.0404465087,
0.5920554996,
0.0992267281,
0.6383125782,
-0.7349573374,
-0.5929213762,
-0.1524638534,
-0.3201224804,
-0.4661795497,
0.1703228652,
0.2553870976,
0.6349793077,
0.3356251121,
-0.235122323,
0.5367246866,
-0.5485208631,
0.6916934848,
0.1382243186,
-0.8915438652,
0.3321278095,
-0.3205820918,
0.5069695711,
0.5936104655,
0.5211489201,
-0.8133229613,
-0.2207519114,
-0.6100177765,
-0.9840378165,
0.2660852373,
-0.6249881387,
0.4169161618,
0.2229142338,
0.6649320722,
0.5177691579,
0.3274559975,
-0.8491148949,
0.0032938444,
0.3459116518,
0.0660436973,
-0.1340815425,
-0.4591815174,
0.1861692816,
-0.3228298426,
0.8653782606,
-0.1717400551,
0.049199421,
0.022934068,
-0.5134738684,
0.0476251766,
0.2810768783,
0.5844607949,
1.1592636108,
0.0307130013,
-0.2115657479,
0.4705310464,
-0.4433293641,
0.3595812917,
-0.5061576366,
-0.2221001834,
-0.1991872489,
0.50744313,
0.6050243974,
0.4101639092,
-0.6790196896,
0.2257234454,
0.2615512013,
-0.1671389192,
-0.6474558711,
0.0926124603,
-0.1361222863,
0.3353323638,
0.6000486612,
0.0442753993,
-0.2389336526,
-0.9628506899,
0.1633754373,
0.4623906612,
-0.7975698709,
-0.5499246716,
0.2917905748,
0.1456021965,
-0.1964834929,
0.5850052834,
0.001415421,
-0.2863311768,
0.3760280013,
0.5021585822,
0.8635808825,
-0.4617423415,
0.1102943569,
0.3788137436,
0.3567836285,
-0.3162778914,
-0.0206995402,
-0.4426346719,
-0.5472279787,
-0.6554736495,
-0.5352963209,
-0.8553674221,
0.2762259841,
-0.3039992452,
-0.066012308,
-0.7048741579,
0.1472246349,
-0.3270651996,
-0.0458848402,
-0.4536916018,
0.371144563,
0.0379560664,
1.0587553978,
-0.6466395855,
1.0540100336,
0.5731911659,
-0.2940922976,
-0.5363901854,
-0.0231423266,
-0.0955727696,
-0.6000994444,
0.6626111865,
-0.1229329929,
-0.0327266157,
0.2366062701,
-0.6618974209,
-0.8614529371,
0.9055178761,
0.2419786602,
-0.4789257348,
-0.0685923025,
-0.1778560132,
0.4762172997,
-0.5860700011,
-0.007139409,
0.3866571486,
0.3348312974,
0.1331032664,
-0.6579083204,
-0.2337793261,
-0.0286848657,
0.0422409549,
0.1580742151,
-0.8335565925,
0.9953956604,
-0.1948490739,
-0.2582316995,
-0.048248753,
0.6577541828,
-0.0454161279,
0.1833413541,
0.2975163758,
0.5455060005,
0.6260576248,
-0.0576703101,
0.9852219224,
-0.1184491739,
0.5275945663,
1.0766121149,
-0.5053544641,
0.9415355921,
0.1458676755,
-0.4009237289,
0.5973129869,
0.8210247159,
0.1775209606,
0.360689044,
0.0147678712,
-0.4821732342,
-0.2963841856,
0.088901341,
-0.5976819396,
0.1460512877,
0.6274659038,
-0.0963172764,
-0.1705949754,
0.364718467,
-0.0073452126,
-0.1881034672,
-0.4681994319,
1.1008313894,
0.1709197313,
-0.6558318734,
0.452555269,
-0.2000599205,
0.4975948334,
-0.8188493252,
-0.0853042528,
-0.1649646461,
0.4125638604,
-0.0274130851,
-0.5134435892,
0.1649636775,
-0.0927993953,
-0.1844846308,
-0.1611564308,
0.5570954084,
-0.3587190807,
-0.3927941024,
0.3995678127,
0.6750748158,
-0.0999065042,
0.1281805485,
-0.8572093844,
0.2038033605,
-0.0376302749,
-0.0880599543,
0.7087599635,
0.4422812462,
0.2055209279,
1.1619281769,
0.6564679742,
0.2415962517,
0.0664274096,
-0.2032684386,
0.6821072102,
-0.7786061764,
-0.2538421154,
-0.8818868995,
0.4849068522,
0.2356765568,
-0.082263343,
0.7306205034,
0.184722349,
1.1250495911,
-0.0853371173,
1.0175468922,
0.0536682084,
0.6820049882,
-0.5943979025,
0.3104465604,
-0.5459979773,
0.3737128675,
-0.0154873459,
-0.9675271511,
-0.2701333761,
0.3612866998,
-0.4469023049,
-0.0493250638,
0.681093812,
0.3457680643,
0.1444700211,
-0.1068009287,
0.4012459219,
0.3451869786,
0.2252279073,
0.3952188492,
1.0877016783,
-0.0772494376,
0.0747813955,
-0.0002180635,
-0.2794393897,
-0.3017258048,
-0.5692366362,
-0.3523343205,
-0.8342599273,
-0.4078982174,
-0.1401123405,
0.0234313253,
0.9902111888,
0.5880123377,
-0.8601400256,
-0.6280912757,
-0.0732121393,
0.4477742612,
-0.4482221901,
-0.2225957662,
0.0876069069,
-0.9253772497,
-0.7339571714,
0.3103576601,
0.7602747679,
-0.0291401073,
-0.6242303848,
0.0725299194,
-0.4203324914,
0.0218534898,
0.8216601014,
0.776248157,
-0.3476714194,
-0.216850847,
-0.2136551738,
0.0494903289,
0.1181289256,
0.8584715724,
-0.8597142696,
0.4570544958,
0.3803861439,
0.8582733274,
0.5010361671,
-0.3293845057,
0.1877659857,
-0.1456085294,
0.0464714542,
0.2396237701,
0.1965766251,
0.5376470685,
-0.1399857402,
0.4342474043,
0.4187612534,
-0.7827441096,
-0.8490042686,
0.4074466825,
-0.578366816,
-0.3575778902,
1.0080449581,
-0.2009098828,
0.0117653916,
-0.4997790456,
0.1731387526,
0.0002652919,
-0.1366424114,
0.7860626578,
0.6892551184,
-0.0787970573,
-0.1358156502,
-0.8322300911,
0.1900261939,
0.0153154498,
-0.7395554185,
0.1301130652,
0.3685199916,
0.5360409021,
0.1644861251,
0.5836209059,
-0.2793654501,
0.1382952929,
-0.0852643028,
-0.1615355015,
0.2878746688,
-0.6344801188,
-0.6884331107,
0.3943300545,
0.3772601187,
0.2918411791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18286v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18286v2
|
Comparing LLM prompting with Cross-lingual transfer performance on Indigenous and Low-resource Brazilian Languages
| 2024-04-28T19:24:28 | 2024-04-30T10:00:44 |
David Ifeoluwa Adelani, A. Seza Doğruöz, André Coneglian, Atul Kr. Ojha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models are transforming NLP for a variety of tasks. However,
how LLMs perform NLP tasks for low-resource languages (LRLs) is less explored.
In line with the goals of the AmericasNLP workshop, we focus on 12 LRLs from
Brazil, 2 LRLs from Africa and 2 high-resource languages (HRLs) (e.g., English
and Brazilian Portuguese). Our results indicate that the LLMs perform worse for
the part of speech (POS) labeling of LRLs in comparison to HRLs. We explain the
reasons behind this failure and provide an error analysis through examples
observed in our data set.
|
[
-0.3242838681,
-0.5799389482,
0.2827433348,
0.5237067342,
-0.1287270039,
0.4236103594,
-0.527977109,
-0.8575662971,
0.1239624992,
0.416474402,
-0.5350033641,
-0.4040032625,
-0.5568411946,
0.718791008,
-0.3816986978,
0.9716633558,
-0.0400904715,
-0.2070875764,
-0.116995357,
-0.1861813366,
-0.2257936746,
-0.3935928345,
-1.1065983772,
-0.5240846276,
0.8392744064,
0.2674225867,
0.81228441,
0.2010742277,
0.3155691922,
0.2018456608,
-0.5140636563,
0.1717465371,
-0.3980047703,
0.0367750041,
-0.3235344887,
-0.5380014777,
-0.3789179325,
-0.1232681274,
0.6399407387,
0.8153324723,
0.035728462,
0.1815174967,
0.396373421,
0.621535778,
-0.5285974145,
0.0569911934,
-0.5510177612,
0.4029541314,
-0.1455072314,
-0.3557080925,
-0.4226041734,
-0.3530489504,
0.3028907478,
-0.2938230932,
0.2332100123,
0.1727533638,
0.6789174676,
0.3745369017,
-0.1986480504,
-0.3305808008,
-0.6748027802,
0.8738028407,
-0.6071610451,
0.4065588713,
0.478638947,
-0.1151005477,
0.1952688545,
-0.3728291094,
-0.3145434558,
-0.3187665641,
-0.1478155404,
-0.2308976054,
-0.417858243,
0.0069305031,
0.5439347029,
0.201801911,
-0.5208693147,
0.670558393,
-0.5360442996,
-0.251740098,
0.5731387734,
-0.0631223321,
0.1328459829,
-0.171870783,
-0.5380452871,
0.0470706969,
-1.1774814129,
0.0989160612,
0.242581889,
0.7724465728,
-0.3544647396,
0.4794877172,
-0.0681709945,
1.1005043983,
-0.3258741796,
-0.4047310054,
-0.0251488294,
-0.3537212908,
-0.2216003835,
-0.016423421,
0.7959657907,
0.2934246659,
0.3773359656,
-0.1755797863,
-0.290274173,
-0.3331342638,
-0.1626633257,
-0.3820172548,
0.3036123514,
-0.0435913168,
-0.3456844985,
0.2158962935,
-0.5078749061,
-0.6947545409,
-0.4178729355,
-0.210445568,
0.2179599702,
-0.2030989826,
0.1254437417,
-0.1871422231,
0.0577536188,
0.3583464921,
0.3936107159,
-0.9702632427,
0.2576002479,
0.4406197071,
0.9633256197,
-0.6479119062,
-0.5390244722,
-0.5293531418,
-0.2361798882,
-0.1957660019,
0.8601995707,
-0.3219613135,
-0.5759021044,
0.4280635715,
0.0724141598,
-0.211677745,
-0.8008426428,
0.6155472994,
-0.4640183151,
-0.0106768813,
-0.9894432425,
0.0685516745,
-0.0248120148,
0.1497616172,
-0.489882201,
1.179246664,
0.3498576283,
-0.4443174601,
0.3710648715,
-0.5536737442,
-0.5615590215,
-0.0336362496,
-0.1478540748,
0.14115417,
-0.0246455334,
0.2542415559,
0.4788527787,
-0.6112048626,
-0.1182852313,
-0.0144924875,
-0.5053340793,
0.3545310497,
-0.6693725586,
1.0357236862,
0.2942673862,
-0.1109918877,
-0.1550144255,
-0.5230330229,
-0.0545300767,
0.1081131846,
-0.7987154126,
-0.09490408,
-0.2476965487,
-0.0573557466,
0.4159283936,
0.1609478593,
-0.3973390758,
0.4401780665,
-0.2400796264,
0.4805345535,
0.5649324656,
-0.3335592747,
0.6172457933,
-0.2439097464,
0.8694912791,
-0.3750181794,
-0.1786935776,
0.0976979062,
-0.5763375163,
-1.0065948963,
0.18729873,
0.3157252371,
0.8234083056,
-0.983365953,
0.1390050352,
-0.2634097636,
-0.1335788071,
-0.6622892618,
0.4172794819,
0.4459948242,
0.5122333169,
0.5628347397,
-0.2690300345,
-0.4189015627,
-0.9880593419,
-0.1574166119,
-0.1379734576,
-0.1755706817,
0.2559597194,
0.2071900517,
0.0808903128,
0.6028869748,
0.0635877326,
-0.4962823391,
-0.5638296604,
0.035175547,
0.1807156652,
0.2025490105,
0.8113383651,
-0.1455318928,
-0.6713626385,
0.0395684168,
-0.3326544464,
-0.5530876517,
-0.0152520863,
0.2830452919,
0.7774519324,
0.5567667484,
-0.2848974466,
0.3168388307,
0.9544811845,
-0.0384434871,
0.3515214622,
-0.1622059941,
0.1000000015,
-0.6246632338,
0.0719464645,
-0.078903161,
-0.0879837424,
-0.297986567,
-0.291637212,
-0.3051804602,
-0.184384495,
-0.8053668737,
0.6799506545,
-0.7685101032,
-0.6920961738,
-0.2459956855,
0.2842572331,
-0.1002371833,
0.5455400348,
0.3371560872,
0.978959024,
0.4048498571,
-0.6818091273,
0.5061026216,
0.0742568821,
-0.2175210416,
0.728497088,
-0.6807352901,
0.1520113349,
0.2235451043,
0.2087413967,
-0.6748484969,
0.1886804402,
0.2338043004,
-0.1050805226,
0.369582653,
-0.551269412,
-0.394652158,
-0.3839714527,
0.0012722937,
0.3589526713,
0.5556178689,
-0.565772593,
0.2043736279,
0.1019061059,
-0.5514785647,
-0.8860090971,
-1.0977998972,
0.33601439,
-0.2541756034,
-0.4882235229,
0.2856699526,
0.2616342306,
-0.2499831915,
-0.0512737781,
0.2117203176,
0.1420353651,
0.0307541918,
-0.1156363487,
-0.012761456,
-0.3635986149,
0.02172824,
-0.1386028528,
-0.0350965448,
0.0328163356,
0.0149585642,
0.7488546371,
-0.2171933055,
-0.6060940623,
-0.4010501206,
0.3207762837,
0.02341705,
-0.1623073816,
0.7109367251,
0.6843895912,
0.0263011474,
-0.2616330683,
-0.4620943367,
-0.0155444909,
-0.4208031297,
0.2112808228,
-0.2289268374,
-0.8695239425,
0.6504877806,
0.0358440913,
0.2225377262,
0.3267922103,
0.4989061356,
-0.0056263581,
0.5464479327,
0.5875111818,
-0.0929413363,
0.5394785404,
-0.4363888204,
0.057834778,
-0.9049832225,
-0.0970750898,
-0.9035532475,
-0.5076058507,
-0.7198733091,
-0.7008260489,
0.2657113075,
0.0023286964,
0.1495958269,
0.5011952519,
-0.3985311985,
0.4795216322,
0.7733155489,
-0.3221409619,
0.4336047471,
0.3099086285,
0.0099264877,
-0.1584789455,
-1.2237179279,
-0.6204864383,
0.8068826199,
0.2095946074,
0.871943593,
-0.00366106,
0.7162395716,
0.3381479681,
0.3133735061,
-0.8618863821,
0.6965031028,
-0.2323831916,
-0.298709631,
-0.2712866366,
-0.085679926,
-1.4453161955,
0.355876267,
-0.4753032029,
-0.7886963487,
0.2563838959,
0.0692985058,
-0.4152027369,
0.3277419806,
-0.4770974219,
0.6234224439,
-0.4578316212,
-0.4140670598,
-0.1450540125,
-0.5317355394,
0.1119598225,
0.1731638014,
0.2125950456,
-0.2018473595,
-0.2833983302,
0.9590426683,
-0.1472647786,
0.843921423,
-0.0304807425,
-0.5855821371,
0.4866397083,
0.1595243514,
0.5068555474,
-0.1949422061,
-0.2477934211,
0.2758103311,
-0.3364475071,
-0.4165281951,
-0.268119067,
0.7029497623,
-0.5522184372,
-0.6402637362,
-0.4716915488,
-0.5368521214,
-0.329718262,
-0.1174896657,
0.3999719918,
0.0539331734,
-0.0678832531,
0.1340759993,
0.4527771175,
-0.497022599,
0.7881430984,
0.6275051236,
-0.1522271931,
-0.0817847252,
0.7194887996,
0.3251959682,
0.5167986751,
0.3114035726,
-0.0182509217,
-0.4280779362,
-0.702537775,
-0.5834700465,
0.2924576104,
-0.6930431724,
-0.1100181788,
-0.3425205052,
-0.0844680667,
-0.5205216408,
-0.3526439071,
-0.2726615667,
-0.4123912752,
-0.2348051369,
-0.0744344369,
0.2421268821,
0.6120494008,
-0.3866253197,
0.4347680807,
-0.9502646923,
-0.0242151991,
0.4094746709,
-0.0675964877,
-0.025185952,
-0.8845442533,
-0.2993538678,
-0.0267857965,
-0.1619199067,
-0.9236770868,
0.4896176159,
0.1756091267,
0.5423570871,
0.2875563502,
0.1464575529,
0.6327255964,
-0.2846143246,
0.9302321672,
-0.0332972221,
-0.8472223878,
0.6428018212,
-0.1080675051,
0.265411973,
0.2853040695,
0.5830921531,
-0.768963933,
-0.3393697739,
-0.6230883598,
-0.8793196082,
0.9612894058,
-0.0671306029,
0.0340280533,
0.0499476939,
0.0647890344,
0.0463673137,
0.095653303,
-0.9744250178,
-0.3050037622,
0.4495030344,
0.4394779205,
-0.2036028951,
-0.3252536356,
-0.2839709222,
0.1342080683,
0.5666959286,
-0.2073704004,
0.2417879999,
0.4071673453,
-0.1946421117,
-0.2656683326,
0.572733283,
0.6856305599,
0.6813957095,
0.1049234197,
0.1664768159,
0.7601894736,
-0.0083774123,
0.1316149086,
0.1073918417,
-0.3062348068,
0.0851113722,
0.9726432562,
0.972661972,
0.2029432356,
-0.6011414528,
0.1601413786,
0.2087357938,
0.1306051612,
0.0175349973,
0.1057397127,
0.1101951078,
0.154572919,
0.3935232759,
-0.1273219883,
-0.1505380124,
-0.7117146254,
-0.4151853323,
0.3937460184,
-0.3069343567,
-0.3945418298,
0.3590601683,
0.6767808795,
-0.5332913995,
0.612303257,
-0.1957215667,
-0.5337834954,
0.4918986559,
0.4989383817,
0.5405240655,
-0.274745822,
0.1398812532,
0.3414687812,
0.6341423392,
0.1650627702,
0.2670501471,
-0.3455792964,
-0.658505559,
-0.8473623395,
-0.6612658501,
-0.5613538623,
0.2004316598,
-0.6395172477,
0.2090346515,
-0.1953744739,
-0.2211307138,
-0.2911706865,
0.0193822309,
-0.8323088288,
0.0540289544,
0.3661093116,
0.7673877478,
-1.2111462355,
0.5960933566,
0.7408585548,
-0.2486728281,
-0.5521603227,
-0.3222956061,
-0.068848148,
-1.1946337223,
0.8917664886,
-0.2169496119,
-0.0560481809,
-0.2017135918,
-0.3101151586,
-0.8875306845,
0.8558594584,
0.5573450923,
-0.5855490565,
-0.1039099693,
0.6352664232,
0.7298635244,
-0.1016743258,
0.1322090924,
0.5499742627,
0.5732825398,
0.0456847511,
-1.5804144144,
0.033316195,
0.4065746367,
-0.0764098391,
-0.0652316362,
-0.6946350932,
0.7864928246,
-0.540373683,
-0.3410654366,
-0.0710953996,
0.7086243629,
0.2688341439,
0.2157268226,
0.4797516763,
0.3453803957,
0.6532051563,
-0.3312231004,
0.9889115095,
-0.0938741341,
0.0084292209,
1.0053220987,
-0.4513925314,
0.9795029759,
0.6446931958,
-0.7510284781,
0.2342195958,
0.6826186776,
0.1696248353,
-0.035487812,
0.2254934162,
-0.2172377259,
-0.1429393888,
-0.4511882961,
-0.5697491765,
0.4848096669,
0.5017644763,
-0.4071286917,
-0.3451887071,
-0.0166852865,
0.0007152451,
-0.1568882167,
-0.4428079724,
0.6623575091,
0.3605984151,
-0.9843632579,
1.0566396713,
-0.1124679446,
0.8402358294,
-0.4887176454,
0.1670621336,
-0.3499210477,
-0.1824817508,
-0.325066328,
-1.0246708393,
0.5058815479,
0.1939819604,
0.1073978171,
-0.6192944646,
0.6303235292,
-0.5296721458,
0.0053985026,
0.5524971485,
0.8903785944,
0.4337221384,
0.1934403777,
-0.8960064054,
0.1996433437,
0.1351287067,
-0.0986455306,
0.4877538085,
0.3400804698,
-0.1310825646,
0.8860348463,
0.6275619268,
0.4737040102,
0.1185665876,
0.2087592781,
0.3709356785,
-0.6793708205,
-0.255169332,
-0.6464345455,
-0.0204481538,
0.1461518854,
-0.3839740157,
0.7888166308,
0.388995111,
0.9371454716,
-0.1102681756,
0.5571764112,
-0.16113621,
0.5052877665,
-0.814509809,
0.3523890078,
-0.4832753539,
0.5229024887,
0.0159223489,
-1.1502329111,
0.0198070388,
0.5729391575,
-0.2438932061,
-0.0740121901,
0.7207825184,
0.678837359,
0.1878969669,
-0.3854950368,
0.4565864205,
0.1798439026,
0.0394193903,
0.6533280611,
1.1127659082,
-0.0063521308,
0.7766907811,
-0.4726107717,
0.0704890266,
-0.2474261224,
-1.0351028442,
-0.6797654033,
-0.3632389605,
-0.420719564,
-0.5117679238,
0.0238839015,
0.9429284334,
0.4224494994,
-0.7488108873,
-0.4293820262,
0.3352493048,
0.4505962729,
-0.125658527,
-0.2202496827,
0.3601397574,
-0.3156991899,
-1.1410162449,
0.7350897789,
0.1901050806,
0.2943590283,
-0.3756056428,
-0.0467405058,
-0.1456463933,
-0.2549228668,
0.6801441908,
0.8474722505,
-0.9329687953,
-0.1170904338,
-0.0917860046,
-0.1678595394,
0.0565245263,
0.7216108441,
-0.8665501475,
-0.1650500149,
0.6390166283,
0.3853276372,
0.2489466071,
-0.2984859943,
0.538972199,
-0.9165235162,
0.4144878983,
0.4551902711,
0.4782690406,
0.594792068,
0.0245516021,
0.7113763094,
0.1914852709,
-0.6747848392,
-0.7879785895,
0.1838858724,
-1.0826970339,
-0.015113824,
1.5687885284,
-0.1930008233,
-0.1766340584,
-0.1961345375,
-0.2618215382,
-0.0137134651,
-0.4599059224,
0.5745385885,
0.6717510819,
-0.4219119251,
0.0173508693,
-0.4632758796,
0.7486262918,
0.5517763495,
-0.6630482078,
0.0274333917,
0.3908967078,
0.1963670552,
0.3672790527,
0.8582963943,
0.2258698344,
0.2037638575,
-0.185299471,
-0.056514807,
0.2987112403,
-0.0611010492,
-0.5102552772,
-0.0606482252,
0.2655813396,
0.2264375389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01587v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01587v1
|
Improve Academic Query Resolution through BERT-based Question Extraction from Images
| 2024-04-28T19:11:08 | 2024-04-28T19:11:08 |
Nidhi Kamal, Saurabh Yadav, Jorawar Singh, Aditi Avasthi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Providing fast and accurate resolution to the student's query is an essential
solution provided by Edtech organizations. This is generally provided with a
chat-bot like interface to enable students to ask their doubts easily. One
preferred format for student queries is images, as it allows students to
capture and post questions without typing complex equations and information.
However, this format also presents difficulties, as images may contain multiple
questions or textual noise that lowers the accuracy of existing single-query
answering solutions. In this paper, we propose a method for extracting
questions from text or images using a BERT-based deep learning model and
compare it to the other rule-based and layout-based methods. Our method aims to
improve the accuracy and efficiency of student query resolution in Edtech
organizations.
|
[
-0.646148026,
-1.4064805508,
0.641099751,
-0.1595513076,
-0.3945748508,
0.2308751494,
-0.1351040155,
-0.5411933064,
0.2282382399,
0.4682298303,
-0.6654888988,
-0.3574908972,
-0.2696717381,
-0.0331159346,
-0.4636372924,
0.4661052227,
0.0000730654,
0.2424029559,
-0.7669610381,
0.1342862844,
-0.4045085907,
-0.2758086622,
-1.0484825373,
-0.0113045201,
0.3256878555,
0.4969434142,
0.2926413715,
0.2140391916,
0.9660630226,
0.3222566843,
-0.044503659,
0.3298253119,
-0.1460684538,
0.3454540372,
0.2102261037,
-0.3210634887,
0.0966274738,
-0.0275670327,
0.5572935939,
0.6502230763,
-0.0229305048,
0.0633519813,
0.029845044,
0.6060676575,
-0.282520026,
0.0226261616,
-0.6796233058,
0.1153616011,
0.2676645815,
-0.174774617,
-0.4676460028,
-0.74942559,
0.32597965,
-0.7204045653,
0.3818818033,
-0.2905293107,
1.3358590603,
0.1448894888,
-0.181752339,
-0.3324119449,
-0.4812256098,
0.5420745015,
-0.6621866822,
0.2735224664,
0.4119471908,
0.5504199266,
-0.0848834738,
-0.9106786847,
-0.5220150948,
0.2432652414,
-0.1699207872,
0.2934249043,
0.1947708875,
0.0166104101,
0.2037539482,
0.0918320194,
-0.5853562951,
0.0449524559,
-0.7744199038,
-0.1928741187,
0.4863728583,
-0.1064982191,
0.259711504,
-0.2203894854,
-0.3359084427,
-0.3654265702,
-0.2927035093,
0.2238608748,
0.072228387,
0.1803918183,
0.5648809075,
0.1916300952,
0.0024611112,
0.750620842,
0.1425360739,
0.2017940283,
-0.1503651887,
0.1171143204,
-0.1150968894,
-0.0339263827,
0.5657061934,
0.2759715021,
0.17458722,
0.1508322507,
-0.0542436205,
-0.1666856259,
0.294308722,
-0.984785378,
-0.3508279622,
0.3290949762,
-0.634827733,
0.048259791,
0.0446136296,
-0.9946379066,
-0.1801281273,
-0.3680939972,
0.5915300846,
-0.7807738185,
-0.0027922527,
-0.2598995566,
-0.1486610919,
0.6381184459,
0.9363699555,
-0.4033906162,
0.17171821,
0.4468307495,
0.4835149646,
-0.0722951889,
0.2454227209,
-0.1839437634,
-0.3483036757,
-0.2827048898,
0.9551522136,
-0.5691414475,
-0.4701781869,
0.2319941521,
-0.0521113314,
-0.0497127362,
-0.4649734497,
0.4589543045,
-1.0226049423,
0.5706671476,
-0.2795212269,
-1.0078226328,
-0.2958014011,
0.5364949107,
-0.4169488549,
1.1226608753,
-0.3143916726,
-0.2641583979,
0.2448067963,
-0.7861784101,
-0.3279202878,
0.4596403241,
-0.419503659,
-0.2841009796,
-0.2783662975,
0.7907047272,
0.5100752711,
0.0309718587,
0.3062472641,
-0.0272730384,
-0.5009524226,
0.1001098156,
-0.2280273438,
0.9036967158,
0.3152628839,
0.0946928635,
-0.1966143101,
-0.6377273798,
0.5111859441,
0.3100643754,
-0.4633774459,
-0.4889360964,
0.0361059718,
-0.1320336908,
-0.0949532762,
0.4134314954,
-0.8582396507,
0.3234514296,
-0.0591695495,
0.1259503514,
0.7664890289,
0.0617926754,
0.1744055003,
-0.0311586317,
0.2477267087,
-0.2322482169,
0.2386257052,
-0.2564560473,
-0.7176464796,
-0.6420795918,
-0.3667980433,
0.4067648947,
0.3857518137,
-0.9249815941,
0.1675503254,
0.0315627754,
-0.7016788721,
-0.7554857731,
-0.0181309283,
0.0748810768,
0.991812408,
0.552461803,
-0.1342555285,
-0.4030088782,
-0.7442365885,
-0.0756123811,
-0.2250219733,
-0.0874039307,
0.7893560529,
0.4915315509,
0.1872066557,
1.1175829172,
-0.8606036901,
-0.1647537798,
-0.0485700704,
0.5122939348,
0.3214669526,
0.6838030815,
0.620618999,
-1.0975661278,
-0.7357205153,
-0.2215477377,
-0.8504698873,
0.1551996619,
-0.2865057886,
-0.1457725912,
0.3066038787,
0.4996802509,
-0.5934069753,
0.4629747868,
-0.1855710298,
-0.2373672873,
0.4542789459,
-0.2369805127,
0.4081318378,
-0.8180425763,
0.0049754269,
0.2253964245,
-0.1573019773,
-0.3491296172,
0.1638156325,
0.3705269992,
-0.4544742107,
-0.3139953613,
0.2608148158,
-0.2497411519,
0.0269764103,
-0.0277402624,
0.2746018767,
0.3547935486,
0.4445417523,
0.1437383592,
0.9397761226,
0.5508868694,
-0.5978113413,
0.4418440759,
0.5712805986,
-0.5254912376,
0.5455113053,
-0.934797585,
0.4992309809,
-0.4033100605,
0.126903221,
-1.4522470236,
-0.1361272335,
-0.2234368771,
-0.5307767987,
0.4251170754,
-0.0164912287,
-0.6158237457,
-0.587641716,
-0.3301024735,
0.2391253412,
0.6808735132,
-0.8180113435,
0.4220927656,
0.0159609169,
-0.4213190675,
-0.4777703583,
-0.5021595955,
0.0253883265,
0.1520585567,
-0.5990763903,
0.4657185972,
-0.1859489828,
-0.0234406143,
0.1591534019,
-0.0466790907,
-0.6993233562,
0.1587378234,
-0.0774224177,
0.6604828835,
-0.2963976264,
0.4624304175,
0.349134028,
0.5617461801,
0.2788773477,
0.0096013825,
0.5196760297,
0.0190037601,
-0.3755099773,
-0.7008484006,
0.7154358029,
0.4891074896,
-0.3340739012,
0.4489262402,
0.4133903086,
-0.4579230845,
-0.0374937877,
-0.8463948369,
-0.6184082031,
-0.4994601309,
0.2590491176,
-0.1555216014,
-0.5581670403,
0.4980070591,
-0.2662662864,
0.2396674156,
0.4653701782,
0.0678890646,
-0.8957270384,
0.9097083211,
0.5237461925,
0.2724364698,
0.7175711393,
-0.3715576231,
-0.113373436,
-0.5309030414,
-0.5019512177,
-0.8489497304,
-0.5014021397,
-0.1222948804,
0.0034763217,
0.3279018402,
-0.1255429089,
-0.2532521784,
0.3009952307,
-0.8149936199,
0.4135653079,
0.8547509313,
0.6364237666,
0.0056668399,
0.3412173092,
-0.2870616019,
-0.2298679054,
-0.464589119,
-0.4396365881,
0.7871537209,
0.0838901252,
0.7388404012,
0.0517328456,
0.8090010285,
0.2394049019,
0.134133786,
-0.751665175,
0.6856703162,
-0.0809007958,
-1.0080085993,
-0.5908970833,
-0.4020867646,
-0.8328177929,
0.2393373251,
-0.2728516757,
-0.8044541478,
0.4480930567,
-0.3277041614,
-0.4452628195,
0.4356938004,
-0.7505553961,
0.6163299084,
-0.3836244047,
-0.3203889728,
0.1206216961,
-0.7004275918,
-0.1135350615,
-0.159274444,
-0.0941643119,
-0.0342356004,
0.3814764619,
1.1061064005,
-0.3759970069,
0.8426257372,
-0.2408019453,
0.0207897797,
0.5895137787,
-0.1421047896,
0.3180058897,
-0.1107926145,
-0.1869627833,
-0.146293208,
0.1732964218,
-0.3905037045,
-0.6299208403,
0.4296659827,
-0.8825678229,
-0.7073092461,
-0.0151458355,
-0.5992785096,
-0.1834812462,
0.2839184403,
0.1197052673,
0.4161472321,
-0.1178211942,
0.4510180652,
0.9269098639,
-0.3715275824,
0.7462078333,
0.3753274381,
-0.1929639131,
-0.0790728629,
0.6265615821,
0.4023800492,
-0.1236526072,
0.2417908162,
0.0226895977,
-0.6750486493,
-0.2244062871,
-0.4842979014,
0.0306448434,
-0.7825811505,
-0.5133128166,
-0.5444400311,
-0.3257786036,
-0.6613563299,
-0.2432960123,
-0.13466084,
-0.4258283973,
-0.6568159461,
0.0740763023,
0.3737668395,
0.2013221532,
0.2359658927,
0.2621386945,
-0.7743313313,
0.2921012342,
0.7949171662,
0.3713794053,
-0.1817658544,
-0.6208383441,
0.2604669034,
0.0163156427,
-0.5821605325,
-0.9869990349,
0.2541282475,
0.6464310884,
0.561835587,
0.5055541992,
0.2985211909,
0.8602761626,
-0.2743059695,
0.7497585416,
0.2009249479,
-0.6404698491,
1.2093814611,
-0.0388302803,
-0.0689908043,
0.7271881104,
0.5526067615,
-0.1373375654,
-0.0806213319,
-0.6307224035,
-0.7944967151,
0.4701568186,
0.008857063,
0.4921903014,
0.1392152458,
0.7199257612,
0.2051430196,
-0.0325982384,
-0.4281102121,
-0.2661915421,
-0.1954352707,
-0.2120644301,
0.442501694,
-0.3688431084,
0.0523696057,
-0.6574854255,
0.5948912501,
-0.0243386254,
0.2609595656,
0.5831400156,
0.0179500431,
-0.0307755917,
0.2243991643,
0.1832311898,
0.5244270563,
-0.5802716017,
-0.2506910264,
-0.0283172876,
-0.5303551555,
-0.1783629954,
0.3034509122,
-0.2949074805,
0.383857578,
0.0528354533,
0.1046170816,
-0.4420622289,
-0.6092622876,
0.5281066895,
-0.3839888871,
-0.6014281511,
-0.2026695758,
-0.0882094055,
-0.2588652074,
0.217903316,
0.7787775397,
-0.213439554,
0.1794726253,
-0.5072031021,
0.4112091064,
0.521879077,
-0.495603025,
0.4397822917,
0.5934455395,
0.4097040296,
-0.4033088088,
1.1488466263,
0.3114469051,
-0.3115594387,
1.1568464041,
0.5853911638,
0.3752024174,
0.0257053543,
0.5367757082,
0.500447154,
0.1512690932,
0.20137842,
0.7351500392,
-0.0151188923,
-0.701333344,
-0.4430595636,
-0.2539862096,
-0.6874675751,
0.0725418478,
-0.8809717298,
0.0365246125,
-0.7128854394,
-0.2388197184,
0.2490089983,
0.1774902344,
-0.5557009578,
0.4338846803,
-0.0045158751,
1.1177256107,
-0.3075687289,
0.6800654531,
1.174683094,
-0.4965184629,
-0.6991437078,
-0.3890048563,
-0.4808796346,
-0.6248992085,
0.789675951,
0.3609273434,
0.3586170673,
0.1053458154,
-1.1872318983,
-0.4856610894,
0.8954490423,
0.1702967584,
-0.5450304747,
0.2226924896,
-0.0693272352,
0.4512757361,
-0.0481277592,
0.2342956364,
0.2092252523,
0.3590946794,
0.3809274435,
-0.3180653751,
-0.1788710356,
-0.3973381519,
-0.3317114413,
0.1721085459,
-0.2153692544,
0.8354695439,
-0.1148524284,
-0.1803921014,
0.0334935822,
0.6951602697,
-0.0612804592,
0.3830848038,
0.3607744873,
0.3844734728,
1.0612268448,
-0.4072577059,
0.7756137848,
-0.07319282,
0.5959768295,
0.9215670824,
-0.0288665127,
0.846160531,
0.744682014,
-0.1185775027,
0.5319027901,
0.9840779305,
-0.4643028378,
0.6008612514,
0.0308725983,
0.0044700406,
-0.5461399555,
-0.2243007869,
-0.592751801,
0.4888820052,
0.5814440846,
-0.2129808813,
-0.1992532909,
-0.0294390284,
-0.1904753,
0.3150351346,
-0.3458821476,
1.0552357435,
-0.2535449266,
-0.6470525265,
0.2694988847,
-0.3259382844,
0.5149374604,
-0.1759266555,
-0.4146939218,
-0.5182207227,
-0.0844517499,
-0.0492280796,
-0.931876421,
0.0555621199,
-0.0395975858,
0.0784088671,
-0.1269008964,
1.0808454752,
-0.275046438,
-0.8184320331,
-0.116129674,
0.7243154049,
0.3212144375,
-0.0684596077,
-0.9099532366,
-0.4024507105,
-0.1247827336,
-0.0102631589,
-0.1720884442,
0.4347831607,
0.4696370661,
0.5525155663,
0.7147698998,
-0.2131521404,
0.1436236948,
-0.1909871995,
0.923948586,
-0.4546002746,
-0.1387587041,
-0.5996925831,
0.3429937363,
-0.6019096971,
-0.1212379336,
0.2712754607,
0.2586130202,
0.57644099,
-0.0300965086,
0.5304385424,
-0.191805318,
0.3086098731,
-0.1602264494,
0.9435620904,
-0.9441523552,
0.2141726762,
-0.3884526193,
-0.5853913426,
-0.3853202164,
0.9111260772,
-0.219982788,
-0.1046074033,
0.3858467638,
0.4957374334,
0.0493954644,
0.2460318506,
0.1489167511,
-0.0481210165,
0.4686004221,
0.1925036758,
0.7977646589,
-0.595866859,
0.8007991314,
-0.5622926354,
0.0330599546,
-0.3967040777,
-0.6365919113,
-0.8665825725,
-0.4908022583,
-0.5717998147,
-0.1130817756,
0.0011818582,
0.7237040401,
0.6159225702,
-0.8791656494,
0.2151802182,
0.1673042178,
0.3925802112,
-0.2091367841,
-0.2634199262,
0.8662796021,
-0.6449872851,
-0.7142661214,
0.0158953145,
-0.1538914889,
0.2109908164,
0.2315528989,
0.5267002583,
-0.6663665771,
0.2089542598,
0.5186154246,
0.1551213712,
-0.412553966,
-0.3995502591,
0.2749477625,
-0.2641283572,
0.2445515692,
0.3934370279,
-0.7607858777,
0.4601541162,
0.427121222,
1.0427927971,
0.4452218413,
0.1362499893,
0.0903425738,
-1.0825109482,
-0.1340728551,
0.3741424978,
0.266374439,
0.1695645899,
-0.5413450599,
0.5299298167,
0.1943174154,
-0.4538325369,
-0.4852681756,
-0.1417504549,
-1.0638333559,
-0.7700157166,
0.6529189348,
-0.3108088076,
-0.1313782185,
-0.0073495083,
-0.5930095911,
0.251254797,
-0.5800909996,
1.0508339405,
0.5101252794,
-0.2401547432,
-0.4158123434,
-0.525218606,
-0.0342080183,
0.519751668,
-0.8513954878,
-0.5799744725,
0.4294694364,
-0.0025768394,
0.3315654397,
0.2667150795,
-0.136675179,
0.3066242933,
-0.2613376975,
0.1689673662,
-0.0033358836,
-0.1544550955,
0.2109134793,
0.6984634995,
-0.3521723151,
-0.6596589088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18276v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18276v1
|
Bias Neutralization Framework: Measuring Fairness in Large Language Models with Bias Intelligence Quotient (BiQ)
| 2024-04-28T18:47:14 | 2024-04-28T18:47:14 |
Malur Narayan, John Pasmore, Elton Sampaio, Vijay Raghavan, Gabriella Waters
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, D.1; I.2
|
The burgeoning influence of Large Language Models (LLMs) in shaping public
discourse and decision-making underscores the imperative to address inherent
biases within these AI systems. In the wake of AI's expansive integration
across sectors, addressing racial bias in LLMs has never been more critical.
This paper introduces a novel framework called Comprehensive Bias
Neutralization Framework (CBNF) which embodies an innovative approach to
quantifying and mitigating biases within LLMs. Our framework combines the Large
Language Model Bias Index (LLMBI) [Oketunji, A., Anas, M., Saina, D., (2023)]
and Bias removaL with No Demographics (BLIND) [Orgad, H., Belinkov, Y. (2023)]
methodologies to create a new metric called Bias Intelligence Quotient
(BiQ)which detects, measures, and mitigates racial bias in LLMs without
reliance on demographic annotations.
By introducing a new metric called BiQ that enhances LLMBI with additional
fairness metrics, CBNF offers a multi-dimensional metric for bias assessment,
underscoring the necessity of a nuanced approach to fairness in AI [Mehrabi et
al., 2021]. This paper presents a detailed analysis of Latimer AI (a language
model incrementally trained on black history and culture) in comparison to
ChatGPT 3.5, illustrating Latimer AI's efficacy in detecting racial, cultural,
and gender biases through targeted training and refined bias mitigation
strategies [Latimer & Bender, 2023].
|
[
-0.515081346,
-0.8157262206,
0.2139881998,
0.2682450116,
0.0028590444,
0.1986931264,
-0.288143754,
-0.4048242867,
0.0152992215,
0.4527564645,
-0.3056255579,
-0.2792857289,
-0.4247865081,
-0.3124437928,
-0.2968690395,
1.2802327871,
0.1681302786,
0.6447016001,
-0.1886129826,
-0.349475354,
-0.3773332834,
-0.7330405712,
-0.7013320923,
-0.7990761399,
0.3779153228,
0.1114637032,
0.8282080293,
0.5879099965,
0.4299487174,
0.2513515353,
-0.2745123506,
-0.2850565612,
-0.7155291438,
-0.2241495848,
-0.2563139498,
-0.4208750129,
-0.4549449682,
-0.0265489873,
0.7847869396,
1.1140164137,
-0.1283026487,
0.279122889,
-0.0910755694,
0.6677331328,
-0.7704287767,
0.0133066177,
-0.5511066318,
0.2393133342,
-0.5617890358,
0.1933890432,
-0.1310569793,
-0.6653920412,
-0.1824350506,
-0.1347669959,
0.2221661061,
-0.0648418739,
0.697160542,
0.2350037545,
-0.7913812995,
0.1053520441,
-0.8644273877,
0.8901882768,
-0.8279946446,
0.4028131664,
0.1645085961,
0.3321352005,
-0.1085823476,
-0.4287565947,
-0.8152431846,
0.0952851772,
0.1506619453,
0.1132814437,
0.2012775093,
0.2166443318,
0.4157132506,
0.4112187326,
-0.2635240555,
0.1941163093,
-0.5549625158,
-0.4442332387,
0.5442997217,
0.2980957329,
0.1653719842,
-0.0599468052,
-0.210644871,
0.2889014482,
-0.7032519579,
0.2414729595,
0.6808959246,
0.0178431123,
-0.1423451453,
0.5177152157,
-0.2998115718,
0.4035217762,
-0.1280226707,
-0.2452627867,
0.3894628882,
-0.4489720762,
-0.1480122209,
0.1538498253,
0.7144643664,
0.4735240042,
0.4330557585,
-0.262031436,
-0.2291978747,
0.3524163067,
0.067900978,
-0.9233593941,
0.0163146444,
0.1402297318,
-0.60366714,
-0.3438351154,
-0.125785619,
-0.9174388051,
-0.7589045167,
-0.1921920925,
-0.0902827755,
-0.0555681922,
-0.1193432361,
-0.1088784784,
0.0646791086,
0.668764472,
0.1675601453,
-0.7310156822,
0.1905523092,
0.877537787,
0.5258575082,
-0.0963876992,
-0.0469899923,
-0.4688002169,
0.2284259349,
-0.3252504766,
0.4517123699,
-0.5087189078,
-0.2937934101,
0.1636719555,
-0.2364866287,
0.323913604,
-0.5821152925,
0.8023074865,
-0.6003231406,
0.0833665952,
-0.349879384,
-0.3519525528,
-0.2515232265,
0.2892159224,
-0.5776622295,
0.7623492479,
0.0797182769,
-0.8493519425,
0.4854391515,
-0.5534469485,
-0.4456299245,
-0.0518740639,
-0.2149583846,
-0.5920570493,
-0.0257193409,
0.2859157324,
-0.1086113825,
-0.3533110619,
0.6908387542,
-0.785612464,
-0.6294363141,
0.1978746504,
-0.611615479,
1.2559367418,
0.1086014956,
-0.6596795321,
0.1141634881,
-0.5922861695,
-0.0507750139,
0.0944302604,
-0.3625414371,
-0.1330581009,
0.047804825,
0.0075452188,
0.1582534909,
0.1905832887,
-0.5397946835,
-0.342985779,
-0.6787056923,
0.3722097576,
1.0258420706,
-0.3943597972,
0.7156441212,
-0.2845547199,
0.4180530012,
-0.0051138829,
0.2942774892,
0.0833586305,
-0.2786334753,
-1.0564430952,
-0.4048643708,
0.3615182042,
0.6513467431,
-0.4735252261,
0.3960283995,
-0.2442332357,
-0.129536286,
-0.7706151009,
0.0625605956,
0.3322080076,
0.5217227936,
0.0663723499,
-0.4042641222,
-0.418928653,
-0.9723265767,
-0.2970529497,
-0.1708980501,
0.0402565785,
0.1083697081,
0.4059072137,
-0.2217911929,
0.9861099124,
0.1663034856,
-0.1818260401,
-0.0585574731,
-0.0152678201,
0.3058509231,
0.2710025012,
0.6480870843,
-0.5897370577,
-0.1670345217,
-0.1997667402,
-0.6605195403,
-0.3454186618,
0.182684198,
-0.2657096386,
0.1202135459,
0.4113076329,
-0.3352078795,
0.7197828889,
0.3293313384,
-0.438531518,
0.3361561596,
0.3421930969,
0.2106562108,
-0.5555306673,
0.1528567374,
-0.2063391507,
-0.34573102,
-0.7243171334,
-0.050854817,
-0.0966705233,
0.0248396862,
-0.4257826805,
0.8243932128,
-0.2005066127,
-0.2732581198,
-0.3624590635,
0.3677757084,
-0.0283703208,
0.4016655087,
-0.3762722611,
0.5462313294,
0.0047676079,
-0.4135323763,
0.2661733925,
0.0856633335,
-0.4059984088,
0.7730211616,
-0.7516030669,
0.2194060832,
-0.4418264031,
0.3306353986,
-0.6786551476,
0.2066516131,
0.5312758088,
-0.4004119337,
0.009023685,
0.0200910587,
-0.3160912097,
-0.3532840014,
-0.3469035327,
0.7712346315,
0.2441605777,
-0.5639703274,
0.5220854878,
0.6937934756,
-0.2304830402,
-1.0296038389,
-0.726327002,
-0.0605263598,
-0.1380370259,
-0.6534113288,
0.2770647407,
-0.2580265999,
-0.5920979381,
-0.0749971718,
0.027415568,
-0.040651083,
0.3288068771,
0.0934165269,
0.3214153349,
-0.0335394405,
-0.1860765815,
0.0647951663,
0.0986574367,
0.264311254,
-0.0279176831,
0.6293845773,
-0.0982870832,
-0.5832307935,
-0.1576178968,
0.1733140945,
0.3223903179,
-0.4582264721,
0.8619989753,
0.9796759486,
-0.4971787333,
0.1571782082,
-0.7630593181,
-0.0107404627,
-0.4006759226,
0.4682526588,
0.1093899012,
-1.1225488186,
0.6281625032,
0.3022058904,
0.2007852495,
0.0181789827,
0.8175920248,
0.2298043817,
1.1160080433,
0.6099604368,
-0.5040721893,
0.4869388044,
0.0058072768,
0.7362070084,
-0.7713467479,
-0.4076949656,
-0.7045044899,
-0.4150045216,
-0.6096013784,
-0.4106312692,
0.1471711099,
0.2233190536,
-0.7154060006,
-0.7675007582,
-0.2877423763,
0.6102026701,
0.6236803532,
-0.109701857,
0.2425390929,
-0.0683165714,
-0.0573204234,
-0.0509544946,
-0.3671556413,
-0.6072670221,
1.1510014534,
0.632761538,
0.3667301536,
0.1851300895,
0.4340022206,
0.4653855562,
0.6864476204,
-0.6152610183,
0.494392544,
0.0477730483,
-0.9616300464,
-0.2476945221,
-0.6961687803,
-0.6083126068,
0.3803757429,
-0.3419416845,
-0.5980061889,
0.2624146938,
0.054999508,
-0.2077008337,
0.4441272914,
-0.6250128746,
0.7741631866,
-0.3755175173,
-0.5653344393,
-0.2593294978,
-0.3600433469,
0.6986623406,
-0.0673582032,
0.5364513993,
-0.5151363015,
0.0004687105,
0.7091425657,
-0.2709646225,
0.699819088,
-0.4019132853,
0.1332139224,
0.074805133,
-0.0292911362,
0.2348112315,
0.2815622687,
-0.374034673,
0.7584480643,
-0.2642446458,
-0.7068000436,
-0.2375139594,
0.6357557178,
-0.7976480126,
-0.5449444652,
-0.5900163651,
-0.5764439702,
-0.0435517281,
0.3764211833,
-0.1015219837,
0.1922326386,
-0.5722200274,
0.0204760116,
0.5804848075,
-0.5746434927,
0.4225943089,
0.4405244589,
-0.3108544946,
-0.613951087,
0.5485391617,
-0.1705155075,
-0.0524240546,
0.1681976169,
-0.0212933291,
-0.2391572148,
-0.4943068624,
-0.2033425719,
0.2921141088,
-0.6397436857,
-0.2711005509,
-0.4855343699,
-0.362166971,
-0.576197505,
-0.0861843526,
-0.0468489192,
-0.4067702293,
0.0242953785,
-0.1057465971,
-0.0628295243,
0.5929924846,
0.0070169349,
0.3407358229,
-0.298435539,
0.3099372089,
0.1431464255,
0.4625032842,
0.1127723977,
-0.6110548377,
-0.2584601641,
0.2346616238,
-0.3729538918,
-0.5520467758,
0.2244331539,
-0.0739550367,
0.7005966306,
0.4143591523,
-0.0465103723,
0.494604826,
-0.5646113753,
0.7577783465,
0.3604065478,
-1.1803095341,
0.1503898203,
-0.2619310319,
0.3491345346,
0.4567374885,
0.0496892743,
-0.6745080948,
-0.5269380212,
-0.1684450954,
-0.8583095074,
0.7976907492,
-0.0543271266,
0.2552827597,
-0.1187746227,
0.3533923626,
-0.1320606917,
0.5311946869,
-1.1994607449,
-0.5111410022,
-0.3009694815,
-0.39831388,
0.0529199429,
-0.50407511,
-0.2514713407,
-0.2028089613,
0.6767864823,
0.0521954037,
0.1498759091,
-0.1126330495,
-0.1252916008,
0.0105586937,
0.3991754055,
0.2220899016,
0.8034479618,
-0.131100446,
-0.09339834,
0.2153493166,
-0.4097194374,
0.1042779908,
0.3002349436,
-0.7285425067,
-0.2227776498,
0.2633631527,
0.7033780217,
-0.2507712543,
-0.5698236823,
0.6177656651,
-0.0415042229,
0.0857118219,
-0.4231739044,
-0.0940346941,
-0.0598092526,
0.3759291768,
0.0201544557,
-0.0291672554,
0.2437576503,
-0.4627273977,
-0.0899759457,
0.7121800184,
-0.5542407036,
-0.058246199,
0.7228631973,
0.6154597402,
-0.1012326106,
0.7606175542,
-0.2918851972,
-0.6430324316,
0.4888069332,
0.2398590297,
0.5919266343,
-0.3276453316,
0.1819757074,
0.2424566597,
0.6328537464,
0.2019310147,
0.048149161,
0.1542021334,
-1.0771087408,
-0.3720947802,
-0.6820299625,
-0.1350625157,
0.1508058906,
-0.3904511929,
0.2657616436,
-0.815877378,
-0.394013226,
-0.1870706379,
0.1336720437,
-0.8058825135,
0.0585843548,
0.3951121271,
0.670111239,
-0.5762763023,
0.4590356946,
0.5032201409,
-0.3816077411,
-0.2578235865,
0.0473567098,
0.211490795,
-0.6412234902,
0.4820429981,
0.1277679056,
0.0764124021,
-0.4552490711,
-0.4266964495,
-0.5107486844,
0.8718985319,
0.7634524107,
-0.5557426214,
0.1816874295,
0.4272559881,
0.4748243392,
-0.2247129679,
0.7375397086,
0.8642135859,
0.5127081275,
-0.360201776,
-0.8482435346,
-0.1185119003,
-0.141473487,
0.2500234246,
0.2367087007,
-0.882820785,
0.6332745552,
-0.2094364464,
-0.1211139411,
-0.095702894,
0.7921789885,
0.2141901553,
0.6833047867,
0.4811039567,
0.5043039918,
0.9198058248,
-0.3919185698,
0.7325182557,
-0.1425776631,
0.1271261871,
1.0566928387,
-0.5818077922,
0.1830405891,
0.3385644853,
-0.1739985347,
0.401907891,
0.4866167307,
0.1209603325,
0.2646460831,
0.6109836102,
-0.4024097621,
-0.0331929661,
-0.5909512043,
-0.3079821169,
0.3882761896,
0.161466673,
-0.0170585532,
-0.0324321128,
0.0086254468,
0.4014627934,
0.4116840661,
-0.5777819753,
0.4544287324,
0.0420549363,
-0.5137703419,
0.2435582578,
0.3333464861,
0.8182518482,
-0.4269371033,
0.1323408335,
-0.6260021925,
0.3059454262,
-0.1275577843,
-0.6333169937,
0.2088532001,
0.055671718,
-0.5140750408,
0.0708211586,
0.4919010103,
-0.4291567802,
-0.6234967709,
0.655905664,
0.2858616114,
-0.1661527157,
0.3496259451,
-0.9043105841,
0.3766338229,
0.1414109617,
0.114093855,
0.1479872018,
0.5309639573,
-0.1938441694,
0.7037947178,
0.4538393617,
0.3410334587,
0.1057278141,
0.548458755,
0.6334921718,
-0.5821452737,
-0.3487908542,
-0.6120652556,
0.3813942671,
-0.2797298133,
-0.0054635373,
0.4851638973,
0.5063136816,
1.0825426579,
0.4618842304,
0.8788363934,
0.0614320114,
0.6571053267,
-0.3631066084,
0.6285637021,
-0.3742572963,
0.5036743283,
-0.2836941183,
-1.1021444798,
-0.1941307932,
0.5255898833,
-0.4214517176,
0.5726020932,
0.3313483596,
0.9267978668,
0.1259135157,
0.0518448725,
0.1466991007,
0.4008600414,
0.4610207677,
0.402756542,
0.9012143612,
-0.2388061583,
0.7054162621,
-0.0887830928,
-0.3923675418,
-0.0569543801,
-0.7259147763,
-1.1187208891,
0.0945284441,
-0.154021129,
-0.4476559162,
0.2867659032,
0.7604916096,
0.5367169976,
-0.9279333949,
-0.4188030362,
0.477522999,
0.5078295469,
0.0743257478,
-0.2642301023,
0.0758667737,
-0.1186378375,
-0.7769799232,
-0.1275963634,
0.2668346167,
-0.3042239845,
-0.3915228248,
-0.2720642984,
-0.0597964674,
0.2132692486,
0.5235692263,
0.1367212832,
-0.6567097306,
-0.2502628565,
-0.3584176302,
-0.0863045752,
-0.1036117673,
0.8794745207,
-0.6794732213,
0.4004080296,
0.3686581254,
0.7343147993,
0.2774675488,
-0.1904648989,
0.6556640863,
-0.4138062596,
0.4019399285,
0.3415483832,
0.4127853811,
0.6045640707,
-0.2575003803,
0.4727223217,
0.2379486859,
-0.6972143054,
-0.9721280932,
0.3145635724,
-0.5424975157,
-0.0361045189,
0.8882217407,
0.2127359658,
-0.1469121873,
-0.2917342186,
0.0204592049,
0.3213175833,
-0.4943417013,
0.9792179465,
0.6596227288,
0.3364928365,
-0.022969719,
-0.5512220263,
0.3235363364,
0.5726267099,
-0.6637904048,
-0.0202598311,
0.6541484594,
0.113989599,
-0.0990246087,
1.0041136742,
-0.4460913241,
0.2353800982,
-0.5490944386,
0.3531134725,
0.1622735858,
-0.0807819292,
-0.4566200674,
-0.1882533431,
-0.0102807563,
0.302829951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18271v1
|
Parameter-Efficient Tuning Large Language Models for Graph Representation Learning
| 2024-04-28T18:36:59 | 2024-04-28T18:36:59 |
Qi Zhu, Da Zheng, Xiang Song, Shichang Zhang, Bowen Jin, Yizhou Sun, George Karypis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Text-rich graphs, which exhibit rich textual information on nodes and edges,
are prevalent across a wide range of real-world business applications. Large
Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in understanding
text, which also introduced the potential for more expressive modeling in
text-rich graphs. Despite these capabilities, efficiently applying LLMs to
representation learning on graphs presents significant challenges. Recently,
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods for LLMs have enabled efficient new
task generalization with minimal time and memory consumption. Inspired by this,
we introduce Graph-aware Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning - GPEFT, a novel
approach for efficient graph representation learning with LLMs on text-rich
graphs. Specifically, we utilize a graph neural network (GNN) to encode
structural information from neighboring nodes into a graph prompt. This prompt
is then inserted at the beginning of the text sequence. To improve the quality
of graph prompts, we pre-trained the GNN to assist the frozen LLM in predicting
the next token in the node text. Compared with existing joint GNN and LMs, our
method directly generate the node embeddings from large language models with an
affordable fine-tuning cost. We validate our approach through comprehensive
experiments conducted on 8 different text-rich graphs, observing an average
improvement of 2% in hit@1 and Mean Reciprocal Rank (MRR) in link prediction
evaluations. Our results demonstrate the efficacy and efficiency of our model,
showing that it can be smoothly integrated with various large language models,
including OPT, LLaMA and Falcon.
|
[
-0.2818901241,
-0.7038453817,
0.4844183028,
-0.1871930957,
-0.6398846507,
0.1962781399,
-0.5507321358,
-0.4372983575,
0.3056345582,
0.5024295449,
-0.4282033443,
-0.7830467224,
-0.7676163912,
0.0313685313,
0.1009072438,
0.9504554868,
0.0634354725,
-0.0080828397,
0.0829337761,
-0.0895856917,
-0.2607212067,
-0.2352289557,
-0.9347048998,
-0.2257502824,
0.7498514056,
0.1866012365,
0.7811668515,
0.9413099289,
-0.032112997,
0.3636503518,
-0.2330186218,
0.7238427997,
-0.8106455207,
0.0178077687,
-0.1859010458,
-0.047266528,
-0.4055232108,
-0.0898151472,
0.8457484841,
1.0115908384,
0.1247246042,
0.0160098765,
0.3094830513,
0.3535817564,
-0.2086088359,
0.6533817053,
-1.0145599842,
-0.2753557861,
-0.0155067444,
-0.1168514565,
-0.5641350746,
-0.2332319915,
-0.0950684026,
-0.6917142272,
0.1260466725,
0.2307382524,
1.0032714605,
0.1641107798,
-0.266430974,
-0.0609545186,
-0.2304725349,
0.5528561473,
-0.5132172704,
0.5809468031,
0.2292762548,
0.146773532,
-0.2311164141,
-0.878554523,
-0.2340351045,
-0.2573736906,
-0.0293507129,
-0.2347579151,
-0.0927245244,
0.3651012778,
0.2193502933,
0.084356539,
-0.4402763546,
0.4987941384,
0.0425371006,
-0.3471023738,
0.3253205419,
0.109602645,
0.2100987732,
-0.103028968,
0.0944569036,
-0.0956772044,
-0.6015607119,
-0.1722082496,
0.5487408042,
0.8519209623,
0.2325500101,
0.4085609317,
-0.3292108476,
0.9764348269,
0.0706840232,
0.2126141042,
0.0874210522,
-0.2374888211,
-0.2302511334,
-0.0716300607,
0.7550350428,
0.1728989035,
0.6196440458,
-0.4160018265,
-0.1616609544,
-0.0498646535,
-0.0350507498,
-1.0917602777,
-0.4055479169,
-0.1692047119,
-0.2942734659,
-0.0043026754,
-0.1730188727,
-0.4950755239,
-0.4321990013,
-0.303635031,
0.1088358015,
-0.3996683657,
-0.0096199103,
0.2792086005,
0.0151399281,
-0.2053360343,
0.503395021,
-0.9406958818,
0.0666025579,
0.6689106226,
0.7719394565,
0.1227353215,
-0.3090742528,
-1.004376173,
0.2562895119,
-0.3883145154,
0.4799799919,
-0.9003779292,
-0.0318826959,
-0.0478326753,
0.2085184455,
-0.2346629798,
-0.4648762345,
0.2783164382,
-0.6706603169,
-0.1939356923,
-0.0661905184,
-0.7002403736,
-0.1721811295,
0.2177923322,
-0.7319124341,
0.8151679039,
0.2025636733,
-0.6952419877,
0.4122824073,
-0.2505989671,
-0.4564548731,
0.1702972949,
-0.1464768201,
-0.4596464336,
-0.0907954872,
0.5799431801,
0.8447306752,
-0.2433291972,
0.1993438751,
-0.3747538924,
-0.4176806509,
-0.1231482849,
-0.3463680148,
0.4041271508,
-0.0952516645,
-0.0820779726,
0.3165863156,
-0.6226274967,
0.1493000686,
0.2760091424,
-0.3315138519,
-0.3190710247,
-0.0530953594,
-0.1798444092,
-0.0861424059,
0.3824120462,
-0.3640313745,
0.3088455796,
-0.6762005687,
0.6682208776,
0.8647621274,
0.0322544016,
0.3547413647,
0.1404465139,
0.2818143368,
-0.3317511976,
-0.1218194515,
-0.3114494383,
-0.635623455,
-0.366435349,
-0.3115807474,
0.5141494274,
0.1758904904,
-0.7749429345,
0.4015832245,
-0.373036474,
-0.3722791374,
-0.3749212921,
0.3868751228,
0.2829985619,
0.7248411179,
0.3919766843,
-0.0602631718,
-0.1649774164,
-0.4492904842,
-0.3798274696,
-0.147670567,
0.0757692903,
0.7604194283,
0.2778389752,
-0.3386094868,
0.6205368638,
-0.6541108489,
-0.0759811774,
-0.4278606474,
0.0554506332,
0.3677697182,
0.3340068161,
0.4847896099,
-0.5717667341,
-0.6608502865,
0.2198374569,
-0.2508707643,
0.083147049,
0.0287943725,
-0.0890389532,
0.0685445517,
0.5715619326,
-0.5591617823,
0.1061904654,
0.6485669613,
-0.3639964163,
0.404856503,
-0.3514493406,
-0.0674947724,
-0.9891031981,
-0.0659865439,
0.1211296543,
-0.549793303,
-0.290301621,
-0.0931692421,
0.0897533149,
-0.4084482789,
-0.0938728601,
0.7371733189,
-0.616042614,
0.0681258664,
-0.063917093,
0.3993659914,
0.0390210114,
0.6399621367,
-0.2373955846,
0.7025792003,
0.6476155519,
-0.5795512199,
0.3072153628,
0.084968023,
-0.2594394088,
0.0454019681,
-0.7945793867,
0.2263626456,
-0.2581863105,
0.2662138045,
-1.0809626579,
-0.2917051613,
0.3912283182,
-0.346644491,
0.6669028997,
-0.5686015487,
-0.6852372289,
-0.3240554929,
-0.081855692,
0.2928724289,
0.2660126388,
-0.7724222541,
0.5459263325,
0.2252350301,
-0.2255380601,
-0.3913225234,
-0.335585326,
0.2061458677,
0.0166807938,
-0.6511464715,
0.4824773073,
0.0351187997,
0.4046256244,
0.0293292589,
0.014896458,
0.1393313706,
0.1891077012,
-0.0825100169,
-0.0387278497,
-0.0628200993,
0.2677177787,
0.3425883949,
-0.455170691,
-0.2771573663,
-0.6572127342,
0.8802419305,
-0.0810623839,
-0.3454968929,
-0.3735572398,
0.0941194594,
0.3612304032,
-0.524240315,
0.7662729621,
0.6461642385,
-0.3726593852,
-0.3659501076,
-0.1431543231,
-0.1995228082,
-0.5039493442,
0.8248636127,
-0.2435956448,
-1.2327688932,
0.6013448834,
-0.5332986712,
-0.3434773982,
0.3514359593,
0.3063006997,
0.2090031356,
1.3631793261,
0.4744116962,
-0.4055601358,
0.6542171836,
-0.4224415421,
0.1707490534,
-0.7192891836,
-0.1265131384,
-0.5913035274,
-0.2327587157,
-0.6725437641,
-0.6371031404,
0.1204411015,
0.2656005621,
-0.476311177,
0.2639162242,
-0.5161644816,
0.5950700641,
0.1791258752,
0.2813354731,
0.108663924,
0.1703721285,
-0.2996332943,
0.0292384084,
-0.7352723479,
-0.3069360852,
0.8199766874,
0.4283665121,
0.7657828927,
-0.2130415738,
0.6766933203,
0.0284783971,
0.0838471204,
-0.8379386067,
0.6209038496,
-0.4768084586,
0.1567840129,
-0.5491682291,
-0.7502799034,
-1.0170143843,
0.0812278688,
-0.1713140458,
-0.9999691248,
-0.1499059647,
0.3634928763,
0.017782772,
0.3820488751,
-0.5412284136,
1.0011985302,
-0.151807338,
-0.2980357409,
-0.2297673523,
-0.3660237193,
-0.2225648314,
0.1432743818,
-0.1606713384,
-0.2813507318,
-0.1121789515,
0.5178273916,
-0.3598986864,
1.0078811646,
-0.4680362046,
-0.0219428837,
0.0910744444,
-0.0569308996,
1.193910718,
0.3058534265,
-0.3502882421,
0.0977103114,
-0.7344864607,
-0.3323614895,
-0.7775129676,
0.7621686459,
-0.6371641755,
-0.3629390597,
0.1491736323,
-0.4411233366,
-0.387147218,
0.4487447441,
0.1443123519,
0.6924788356,
-0.1764001101,
0.0969298929,
0.7493803501,
-0.2308091968,
0.2836466134,
0.021830488,
-0.2207862288,
-0.6114474535,
1.0557975769,
0.1926333755,
0.1315392107,
0.3826744854,
0.2343873233,
-0.4651313722,
-0.8078741431,
-0.7842144966,
0.5089797974,
-0.7349624634,
-0.3799274266,
-0.7580656409,
-0.0950600803,
-0.2653661668,
-0.1156665459,
-0.3269372582,
-0.2115174234,
-0.6790292859,
-0.1583030522,
0.5612564683,
0.5370637178,
0.4188640118,
0.3965407908,
-0.6142382026,
0.1475603282,
0.3290593922,
0.7511568069,
0.1327510774,
-0.3646165133,
-0.4864588678,
0.0654700845,
0.1358617246,
-0.7198185921,
0.2311625183,
0.5170853138,
0.6815188527,
0.3864023685,
-0.1278587431,
0.6754245758,
-0.582495153,
0.5007817149,
0.1416295618,
-0.9432391524,
0.3813344538,
-0.5473917127,
0.115713276,
0.514644146,
0.4780546427,
-0.3288487196,
-0.3371951282,
-0.2730193436,
-0.9564012885,
0.5098781586,
-0.2035097778,
0.5410071015,
-0.1839892417,
0.6978338957,
-0.0173586197,
0.1876984984,
-0.565090239,
-0.0889675915,
-0.2822759449,
-0.3092847764,
-0.250965178,
-0.1648391187,
0.1621272862,
-0.5276722312,
0.5078288317,
-0.8784769773,
0.0729019344,
-0.2150830775,
-0.1192479506,
-0.0112560941,
-0.0289404858,
0.1672507226,
0.687105298,
0.0092681954,
0.1398914307,
0.2282452434,
-0.1854138225,
-0.1610952467,
0.435367316,
-0.0062754261,
-0.0101881521,
0.2584528625,
1.1512240171,
0.318063885,
-0.4965265095,
0.4345799685,
-0.0498403981,
0.0288877059,
0.4361250401,
0.1034549177,
0.3118996322,
0.1876454651,
0.1069741175,
-0.2008356452,
-0.0521098189,
-0.3679997325,
0.1066070721,
0.6168428659,
-0.4492968619,
-0.1481981277,
0.6919540763,
0.0782748908,
-0.1957128942,
0.7626386881,
-0.4618869126,
-0.6163743734,
0.4788016677,
0.8194183707,
0.7724581361,
-0.0793797374,
0.5258846283,
0.4001831114,
0.0793330371,
0.1396124363,
0.2455687225,
0.0890991986,
-0.6808722019,
-0.6197208166,
-0.6828873754,
-0.2944512367,
-0.2317731678,
-0.1918598413,
0.1913163662,
-0.5912911892,
-0.1768582761,
-0.0778163448,
0.192981109,
-0.6404905915,
0.1333251894,
-0.0974901095,
0.8123154044,
-0.7494046092,
0.7965761423,
0.697168231,
-0.1838148832,
-1.043320179,
0.0009980712,
-0.5501493216,
-0.8986646533,
0.3790714741,
0.3124089539,
-0.1664919555,
0.402463764,
-0.6466270089,
-0.869564116,
0.9988836646,
0.9144971371,
-0.6719962358,
0.0550314821,
0.098667413,
0.5324156284,
-0.5144647956,
0.1613157988,
0.2071120888,
0.4513497949,
0.125723362,
-0.6251228452,
0.2899610996,
-0.1055181175,
0.3169912696,
0.4418814182,
-0.7093483806,
0.8233652115,
-0.2362695187,
-0.1643511802,
-0.0666659027,
0.7349022031,
0.1896239966,
0.0664642379,
0.454461813,
0.3467611074,
1.3394912481,
-0.0728251338,
1.1119662523,
-0.575070858,
0.3247639537,
1.0232805014,
-0.0384496488,
0.5375785232,
0.0926220194,
0.2636043131,
0.5125999451,
0.7880845666,
0.0615264811,
0.4036415517,
0.4077874124,
0.1464283615,
-0.4945673645,
-0.2553441823,
-0.270688206,
0.3909110427,
0.3827712536,
-0.4960603714,
-0.2539015412,
-0.1787392348,
0.1645609885,
0.0373076946,
-0.5633922219,
0.6573810577,
-0.0178301372,
-0.2729894221,
0.6533925533,
0.1740643084,
0.3303922117,
-0.6427868605,
-0.1217039376,
-0.0178266633,
-0.0544859469,
-0.0425645895,
-0.5428202748,
-0.0646985397,
-0.1644236892,
-0.2007673085,
-0.1365633309,
0.8512130976,
-0.5608058572,
-0.4195781648,
0.6021382213,
0.2885211706,
-0.1025768444,
-0.2738979757,
-0.696860671,
0.1791779697,
-0.0666214004,
-0.1544531733,
0.3615545928,
0.7040303349,
0.0130542293,
0.5511529446,
0.4942642748,
0.2296417207,
-0.1167537123,
0.3881641328,
1.2739144564,
-0.5198485851,
-0.6454464793,
-0.7595432401,
0.3281537592,
-0.1855493188,
-0.2469212264,
0.5702095628,
0.4592802227,
0.7126249075,
0.2409305871,
0.5165275335,
0.4348817766,
0.0963843912,
-0.7742027044,
0.7966948152,
-0.5254055858,
0.1054875702,
-0.5194677711,
-1.05605793,
-0.3604921103,
0.4639808238,
-0.3208301365,
0.4070777893,
0.2969876826,
0.7940708399,
-0.1506556422,
-0.16580984,
0.1492183805,
0.2217277735,
0.3760312796,
0.3818816245,
0.4191874862,
-0.170195058,
0.5511613488,
0.1692552119,
-0.2102709711,
-0.2006491274,
-1.0356793404,
-0.9977703691,
-0.4247330129,
-0.3805059493,
-0.3597516716,
0.2021209002,
0.9448508024,
0.8040040731,
-0.5301315784,
0.1405635029,
-0.1507027745,
0.3312366903,
-0.1135097668,
-0.1612187028,
0.6070200801,
-0.497146517,
-0.7224814296,
0.4780211747,
0.3495786488,
-0.0592034608,
-0.122474052,
-0.3371533155,
0.0600061789,
0.0386910215,
0.5035093427,
0.1110308841,
-0.394040823,
-0.6304244995,
-0.0213360265,
0.0102464231,
0.105333291,
0.6134646535,
-0.6573224068,
0.4836874604,
0.4425831735,
0.9440853596,
0.6572928429,
0.016615415,
0.364484638,
-0.8798527718,
0.0196954515,
0.2599425316,
0.5158029199,
0.4521414042,
-0.4832763076,
0.2470896095,
0.2067524791,
-0.4480632842,
-0.6031319499,
0.410761565,
-0.8785225153,
-0.2808449268,
0.927955389,
-0.1937657148,
-0.2059957683,
0.0926214308,
-0.2479207963,
0.4399476945,
-0.5058467984,
0.4519189,
0.2035668045,
-0.0314624608,
-0.1838655919,
-0.0505199321,
0.4133185446,
0.04827483,
-0.5155004859,
0.3353604674,
0.4371583462,
0.1291926801,
-0.147739768,
0.5933237672,
0.2334302813,
-0.1019181386,
-0.1479186565,
-0.3556750119,
-0.496042192,
-0.6167342067,
-0.1553779691,
0.2215090692,
0.2865060568,
0.0340229459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.15784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15784v1
|
CLARINET: Augmenting Language Models to Ask Clarification Questions for Retrieval
| 2024-04-28T18:21:31 | 2024-04-28T18:21:31 |
Yizhou Chi, Jessy Lin, Kevin Lin, Dan Klein
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Users often make ambiguous requests that require clarification. We study the
problem of asking clarification questions in an information retrieval setting,
where systems often face ambiguous search queries and it is challenging to turn
the uncertainty in the retrieval model into a natural language question. We
present CLARINET, a system that asks informative clarification questions by
choosing questions whose answers would maximize certainty in the correct
candidate. Our approach works by augmenting a large language model (LLM) to
condition on a retrieval distribution, finetuning end-to-end to generate the
question that would have maximized the rank of the true candidate at each turn.
When evaluated on a real-world retrieval dataset of users searching for books,
our system outperforms traditional heuristics such as information gain on
retrieval success by 17% and vanilla-prompted LLMs by 39% relative.
|
[
-0.5269853473,
-1.1355284452,
0.7649454474,
0.266185075,
-0.4492303431,
-0.2308716923,
-0.388007611,
-0.598388195,
-0.0235566758,
0.7551214695,
-0.7447585464,
-0.4226855338,
-0.3891841471,
0.0457950756,
-0.4428376555,
0.7773825526,
0.2848797441,
-0.0589354113,
-0.2839861512,
-0.1834100932,
-0.5643445849,
-0.3964698911,
-0.6552978158,
-0.273078531,
0.4148136675,
0.4795511365,
0.866261363,
0.5379372239,
0.600376606,
0.2567566633,
-0.291136682,
0.102828525,
-0.465497762,
0.5857025385,
-0.4093251228,
-0.7864131331,
0.1416667402,
-0.3901659846,
0.4944842756,
1.1844277382,
-0.1872465461,
0.4340497851,
-0.3171357512,
0.6192376614,
-0.6389626861,
0.06676507,
-0.5720428228,
-0.1451224834,
-0.3118413687,
-0.2536841929,
-0.4244060814,
-0.7872743607,
0.5344688892,
-0.5052577257,
0.0877043456,
0.1722411662,
0.7406166196,
0.2092139274,
-0.6995930076,
-0.4805130959,
-0.8161197901,
0.5906361341,
-0.5038461089,
0.5863733888,
0.4016992152,
0.667149961,
-0.1876000911,
-0.6107677817,
-0.3523187637,
-0.3158747852,
-0.1440764964,
0.070203498,
-0.0991766304,
0.0579969957,
0.2274134904,
0.2612256408,
-0.7395629883,
-0.4019931257,
-0.4426236749,
-0.1248550192,
0.4054238498,
-0.2387442291,
0.2296477705,
-0.054020986,
-0.1966591924,
-0.1502780765,
-0.4956885278,
0.4006304145,
0.7062643766,
0.2937951982,
0.6143078208,
0.6618306041,
-0.3930792212,
1.3954610825,
0.3038871884,
0.0809920058,
-0.1089208573,
-0.1980083287,
0.0676075593,
0.1235061139,
-0.0416726172,
0.3045386076,
0.0148657216,
-0.089006491,
-0.3495635092,
-0.2135225236,
0.1404716522,
-0.6847630143,
0.0708435476,
0.3117626309,
-0.2713949382,
0.0815475285,
0.1934039295,
-0.6338896751,
-0.2981306911,
-0.5739268661,
0.5766889453,
-0.3605510294,
-0.2294653654,
0.2700366378,
-0.3486852348,
0.0817229375,
0.2872851789,
-0.9115209579,
0.2557145059,
0.5040345192,
0.2615506947,
0.1027978733,
0.3760409653,
-0.6057488918,
0.2547100484,
-0.3300232887,
0.8566660285,
-0.7992759943,
-0.4440810084,
0.1578702629,
0.031179281,
0.3667059839,
-0.7192591429,
0.7932432294,
-1.0340379477,
0.1254665107,
-0.4039240181,
-0.7681902051,
-0.2627078891,
0.2863856852,
-0.6928163767,
0.9845145345,
0.2013271898,
-0.4375737906,
0.3706978559,
-0.2367176563,
-0.3521691263,
0.211358279,
0.011550785,
-0.022937499,
0.0865946412,
0.333053112,
0.0242937524,
-0.3333801627,
0.3954299986,
-0.2587785125,
-0.39188236,
0.4074327648,
-0.4647191167,
0.6102619171,
0.2718601823,
0.0702113509,
-0.092400983,
-0.7021368146,
0.3770389855,
-0.1908473223,
-0.6421527863,
-0.4428994954,
-0.3778552711,
-0.2844778597,
-0.3643254042,
0.8801465631,
-0.4608924985,
0.3249201477,
-0.573125124,
0.0960666388,
0.5128483176,
0.3709094524,
0.5768995285,
-0.4522101879,
0.574736774,
-0.4117697477,
0.3727206886,
-0.1818507463,
-0.6328969002,
-0.538582027,
0.1410458386,
0.5656841993,
0.6137394309,
-0.6115486026,
0.2251879573,
0.1600398272,
-0.4458958805,
-0.806394279,
0.1656143665,
0.3175300658,
0.636811316,
0.3658748567,
0.1489688307,
-0.4755280614,
-1.1163773537,
-0.2699957192,
-0.4009313583,
0.0806526095,
0.4952116907,
0.0347599499,
-0.0988697857,
1.1275660992,
-0.5770659447,
0.2184797823,
-0.234392345,
0.2312376499,
0.4420529306,
0.2904469669,
0.3992581367,
-1.380402565,
-0.3248331845,
-0.0124683063,
-0.3731378913,
-0.5309974551,
-0.0811879858,
-0.2331918478,
0.1398235112,
0.4186989367,
-0.6369333863,
0.4165444076,
0.1964399219,
0.0476282835,
0.549957335,
-0.3819713891,
0.0910393298,
-0.5516580939,
0.1950465739,
-0.3000936508,
-0.2922354341,
-0.6057983637,
0.3383012712,
0.0813052952,
0.0070074494,
-0.0250754151,
0.7947845459,
-0.3172519803,
-0.1305675656,
-0.2319935709,
0.5731104612,
0.0712135956,
0.1522016823,
-0.1902883649,
0.6247269511,
0.5818666816,
-1.0013102293,
0.5595667362,
0.207859084,
-0.3399091363,
0.6464470029,
-0.5856962204,
-0.1318771839,
-0.4660204351,
0.1674364209,
-1.2190452814,
-0.6016067863,
-0.1064542532,
-0.3370366096,
0.2495682687,
-0.2690702975,
-0.3889146745,
-0.6919457912,
0.0548707433,
0.6159284711,
0.375102371,
-0.7591635585,
0.3558041155,
0.3559490144,
-0.348005712,
-0.7623098493,
-0.4641577005,
-0.1886664331,
-0.0286208577,
-0.9525159001,
0.3087615967,
-0.5476654172,
-0.3766168058,
0.0056619532,
-0.5259307623,
-0.2794605792,
0.1067439988,
-0.1107853353,
0.2369439304,
-0.1255276799,
0.4668497741,
0.1111496612,
0.0317507014,
-0.2453649789,
-0.5180979371,
0.5685789585,
-0.2966403365,
-0.6012870073,
-0.2090434879,
0.3529094458,
0.1356932521,
-0.1601246148,
0.1112534329,
0.4940600097,
-0.1819915771,
-0.1862388253,
-0.9022445083,
-0.4261688888,
-0.5100243092,
0.0378063768,
-0.4589024186,
-0.994607687,
0.7756593227,
-0.0516718328,
-0.212677002,
-0.0434161425,
0.2797936797,
-0.086628668,
1.342818141,
0.3900735676,
0.3473499715,
0.3996243775,
0.0530787744,
0.1805835664,
-0.5549692512,
-0.2564032376,
-0.5219548941,
-0.3008293509,
-0.3361168802,
-0.1941048503,
0.4950657785,
0.3262471855,
0.1568671167,
0.3287656605,
-0.5525155067,
0.4776724875,
1.0801486969,
0.315061748,
0.3671517074,
-0.3468634188,
-0.1617326438,
0.0751676038,
-0.3968886435,
-0.4658434391,
0.8795234561,
-0.1913242936,
0.658526957,
0.6120436192,
0.6743595004,
0.2475325614,
0.0632858276,
-0.5922616124,
0.6451362371,
0.2689623237,
-1.1140959263,
-0.4886855185,
-0.3482133448,
-1.0736762285,
0.2022986412,
-0.0089889001,
-0.7383317351,
0.4227896333,
0.2084050775,
-0.4978719354,
-0.2595587969,
-0.4823635817,
0.6883070469,
-0.4205352664,
-0.3511951864,
0.1450731009,
-0.8756062388,
0.3638024926,
-0.1351060122,
0.2387611121,
0.0812010095,
-0.0809663385,
0.2389884442,
-0.4082193375,
0.4565162659,
-0.2205944061,
-0.0875267163,
0.6408034563,
0.380856216,
0.547016263,
0.2195063382,
-0.5242651105,
-0.6439869404,
0.3030123711,
-0.3537297249,
-1.1303217411,
0.4544803202,
-0.4381905496,
-1.2108846903,
-0.1433880031,
-0.6104179621,
-0.3573492765,
0.461101979,
0.1102490798,
0.5194632411,
0.0867050514,
0.3963007629,
0.7449586391,
-0.1254445761,
0.0318351872,
0.743966341,
-0.6609120965,
-0.1367522329,
0.7174451351,
0.0866716951,
0.2574857771,
0.4220108986,
0.2963005602,
-0.6399469972,
-0.5958070755,
-0.490413934,
0.4159016609,
-0.9147194028,
-0.1453472972,
-0.264336288,
0.0700270236,
-0.5566076636,
-0.0736154318,
0.1738519371,
-0.6065499187,
-0.3600174487,
-0.2459166944,
0.1407298297,
0.732116282,
-0.0968429893,
0.5387758017,
-0.7647884488,
0.2107278854,
0.4312151968,
0.2242386192,
-0.4264632463,
-0.7962694168,
0.0393681116,
0.1141763255,
-0.2036389261,
-1.0895774364,
0.3094938099,
0.1425145268,
0.8511185646,
0.5041075349,
0.3492264152,
0.9206588864,
-0.2153531313,
0.7879657745,
-0.1697587669,
-0.6773907542,
0.7597907782,
-0.4549337029,
0.3988473713,
0.9230836034,
0.3099171817,
-0.3991674781,
-0.5275012255,
-0.5545306802,
-0.9340600967,
0.7284590006,
0.0986423716,
0.0359797291,
-0.0322707556,
0.6792417765,
0.1195596457,
0.4419717789,
-0.6256458759,
-0.0931529403,
0.0841712579,
-0.2584033906,
0.4236939549,
-0.3091562092,
-0.0855458379,
-0.1442076266,
0.8304427862,
-0.017236365,
-0.12157619,
0.2667157352,
-0.1002401859,
-0.132034421,
0.4002046585,
0.4745965898,
0.7475107908,
-0.5199051499,
0.0531447977,
-0.0437352881,
-0.0004575044,
0.0170337409,
0.145218581,
-0.5169551373,
0.0784160793,
0.0645403638,
0.6617063284,
0.2495498508,
-0.9527624846,
0.4879769385,
-0.0192193426,
0.0217161868,
-0.3485246599,
0.2422944456,
0.1196451411,
0.4054387212,
0.50858742,
-0.057788372,
0.4292005897,
-0.7369465828,
0.3965595663,
0.5538881421,
-0.2725363076,
0.0675643533,
0.3844876289,
-0.1598833352,
-0.4644516706,
0.4330461621,
-0.4018084407,
-0.4881215394,
0.4733636081,
0.7227035165,
0.2271330208,
-0.2438696176,
0.347043395,
0.3123203814,
0.2890082002,
-0.4134099483,
0.5740241408,
-0.3422896266,
-0.3142280281,
-0.1034914777,
-0.7112902403,
-0.6366477013,
-0.1148713082,
-0.7626173496,
0.4052915275,
-0.2916559875,
-0.5795426369,
-0.1633861959,
-0.1926213652,
-0.4140963256,
0.1270292252,
-0.0250659827,
1.018184185,
-0.2524422407,
0.4103328288,
0.6626781821,
-0.7496564984,
-0.7187755704,
-0.0908837169,
-0.2916570306,
-0.5320149064,
0.8982353806,
0.0024327482,
-0.0686673,
0.0325670801,
-0.7548392415,
-1.3074191809,
1.001460433,
0.4403472841,
-0.3489628434,
-0.1041028723,
0.1421164423,
0.6209502816,
-0.1258761287,
0.5419793725,
0.6616906524,
1.0022855997,
0.5188387632,
-0.7468636036,
-0.191647172,
-0.0538677536,
-0.1176045388,
0.1449418664,
-0.4490465522,
0.7891122103,
-0.13743788,
-0.2482113987,
0.5061813593,
0.6403800845,
0.2506296635,
0.3785973787,
0.5060523748,
0.3631370664,
1.4559782743,
-0.17003645,
1.2576135397,
-0.3749080598,
0.0649860501,
1.2333272696,
-0.2232818753,
0.782877326,
0.4434852898,
0.0400331579,
0.369787544,
0.8820214272,
0.2232028544,
0.5634647012,
0.3746100068,
-0.4479854703,
-0.6248406768,
-0.2599813938,
-0.204041332,
0.2127340287,
0.5918415189,
0.0127142332,
-0.394097954,
0.2052400708,
-0.3667330146,
0.3244686425,
-0.1542206854,
0.7025429606,
-0.1395131648,
-1.1668959856,
0.4773696363,
-0.0502333008,
0.1294318587,
-0.6952143908,
0.0238569379,
-0.2278046161,
0.0913491398,
-0.0874921754,
-0.812014401,
0.0799216405,
-0.3136734962,
-0.3720878065,
0.1158146635,
0.6543672085,
-0.6435607672,
-0.6360273361,
0.1571677029,
0.2474383265,
0.3029061258,
-0.0189423412,
-0.61311239,
0.0269580297,
0.1733713299,
-0.0744737536,
-0.0948693603,
0.6872572899,
-0.0739522427,
1.0304088593,
0.7173658609,
0.3013422191,
0.3232237995,
0.0888698548,
0.6389738321,
-0.268002212,
-0.4585607052,
-0.4554922879,
0.2619853914,
-0.275231272,
-0.1012640074,
0.7823550105,
0.4037101567,
0.6897258759,
0.0496399514,
0.733258903,
0.1695460677,
0.8785141706,
-0.4370507598,
0.1303603649,
-0.6529811621,
0.5909208059,
0.0900275409,
-1.0452544689,
-0.3805344701,
0.6713848114,
-0.4763675928,
0.0545011982,
0.4159914851,
0.866848588,
-0.1310289353,
0.3564655781,
0.2151124328,
0.1702292114,
0.3709200025,
0.2173768282,
0.7908591032,
-0.1446421444,
0.9161663055,
-0.2052926272,
-0.1571297795,
-0.6894639134,
-0.7082756162,
-0.5468196273,
-0.5563012958,
-0.1203964949,
-0.1258191168,
0.1460338533,
1.0164498091,
0.5950324535,
-0.7119030356,
-0.298499465,
0.0630864128,
0.323303014,
0.0421708636,
-0.2715916336,
0.1914460659,
-0.6696799397,
-0.8300406933,
0.5078185201,
0.1214140281,
0.0749489218,
-0.2593207359,
0.2258229852,
-0.3289306164,
0.2857662737,
0.2729984522,
0.3682948649,
-0.7447669506,
-0.4407708943,
0.234284237,
0.0021700196,
-0.2698293328,
0.6709147692,
-0.7612633705,
0.7775883675,
0.4936475456,
0.9022768736,
0.6735173464,
0.5411121845,
0.639084518,
-1.027222991,
-0.0319731086,
0.4526094198,
0.280102253,
0.3175194263,
-0.4265769124,
0.3913742602,
0.0022970052,
-0.7799492478,
-0.9039183855,
0.4593361616,
-1.1460661888,
-0.436976999,
1.1490061283,
0.1782962382,
-0.4552805126,
-0.336915195,
-0.625048995,
0.1111408249,
-0.6180710196,
0.5849457383,
0.9270312786,
-0.1649732888,
0.1055152118,
-0.6004594564,
0.3851884007,
0.6027209163,
-0.3069815636,
0.0540777892,
0.7033867836,
0.0499452315,
0.4063801765,
0.4129223526,
0.1845566481,
0.3397755325,
-0.4417676926,
-0.296451062,
0.1013044566,
-0.2134516239,
-0.0202991553,
0.4900802076,
0.2073713243,
0.2623918355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18264v1
|
Modeling Orthographic Variation Improves NLP Performance for Nigerian Pidgin
| 2024-04-28T18:07:13 | 2024-04-28T18:07:13 |
Pin-Jie Lin, Merel Scholman, Muhammed Saeed, Vera Demberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Nigerian Pidgin is an English-derived contact language and is traditionally
an oral language, spoken by approximately 100 million people. No orthographic
standard has yet been adopted, and thus the few available Pidgin datasets that
exist are characterised by noise in the form of orthographic variations. This
contributes to under-performance of models in critical NLP tasks. The current
work is the first to describe various types of orthographic variations commonly
found in Nigerian Pidgin texts, and model this orthographic variation. The
variations identified in the dataset form the basis of a phonetic-theoretic
framework for word editing, which is used to generate orthographic variations
to augment training data. We test the effect of this data augmentation on two
critical NLP tasks: machine translation and sentiment analysis. The proposed
variation generation framework augments the training data with new orthographic
variants which are relevant for the test set but did not occur in the training
set originally. Our results demonstrate the positive effect of augmenting the
training data with a combination of real texts from other corpora as well as
synthesized orthographic variation, resulting in performance improvements of
2.1 points in sentiment analysis and 1.4 BLEU points in translation to English.
|
[
-0.3641278744,
-0.8535534739,
-0.0951293781,
0.2091987431,
-0.0920905918,
-0.1247071326,
-0.3573216796,
-0.789670527,
0.4462962449,
0.5758059025,
-0.5191376805,
-0.5109795332,
-0.4850175977,
0.3611041307,
-0.1741227806,
0.7968028784,
-0.0776991174,
0.2064754367,
0.2552714348,
-0.2964965999,
-0.5215454102,
-0.5236467123,
-0.4107263982,
-0.4523222744,
0.4255459011,
0.3929475546,
0.8948212862,
0.5301517844,
0.4533636272,
0.2158469856,
-0.380472362,
0.354830265,
-0.417075336,
0.4238122106,
-0.2868803442,
-0.8005771041,
-0.4966420531,
-0.0128543554,
0.6426628828,
1.0440224409,
-0.2416096181,
-0.2163723111,
-0.1096577197,
0.8522471189,
-0.5786227584,
-0.0533159338,
-0.5465084314,
0.2432687879,
-0.4773874283,
-0.0231349319,
0.2257603854,
-0.0774027482,
0.2894634008,
-0.6146047711,
0.4958108366,
-0.2940831482,
0.6021092534,
0.2880600393,
-0.0733653083,
-0.502838552,
-0.3792177737,
0.469496578,
-1.000203371,
0.4990181923,
0.3164460063,
-0.2864095271,
-0.3825780451,
-0.5627942085,
-0.5871380568,
-0.0950131267,
-0.0579268225,
0.0801877379,
0.3147568405,
0.0536672063,
0.463665247,
0.8178240061,
-0.3543102443,
0.1047407612,
-0.2090548724,
0.1262506694,
0.8090759516,
0.0906141773,
0.4500094652,
-0.3045424223,
0.2370761931,
-0.2680920362,
-0.6754042506,
0.2614705265,
0.8997895122,
0.4976482987,
-0.0931497291,
0.8413278461,
-0.2402299196,
0.7413937449,
0.0036662656,
-0.2955034971,
0.5154883265,
0.0220781509,
-0.1335844249,
0.0206594151,
0.8321130872,
0.1915409714,
-0.0381756537,
0.0496085547,
-0.425477773,
0.1532346159,
0.2061418742,
-0.6779323816,
-0.2808243036,
0.0642071217,
-0.2531418204,
-0.3496827781,
0.0951533765,
-0.7656784058,
-0.7176030278,
-0.2233410627,
0.0347957946,
-0.8279311061,
-0.53858459,
0.4825646579,
-0.1374786198,
-0.0330162309,
0.2587673962,
-1.1068571806,
-0.0467307568,
0.6993050575,
0.6822707653,
-0.4223911166,
-0.3077557087,
-0.2443946749,
-0.4966388941,
-0.5144690871,
0.5675400496,
-0.6847058535,
-0.68189466,
0.147737667,
-0.2546440661,
-0.4622276425,
-0.8489663601,
0.8092522025,
-0.3173759878,
0.3380746841,
-0.1208888441,
-0.6598823667,
-0.4113030136,
0.0768158808,
-0.7525067925,
1.3480616808,
0.3443172276,
-0.9119867682,
0.2892715037,
-0.8310619593,
-0.6478462815,
0.1847730726,
-0.3958555758,
-0.4417987168,
0.5763280392,
0.1900336295,
0.273047775,
-0.0324277952,
0.0368385613,
-0.2648795545,
-0.2245334834,
0.4348405004,
-0.3950316012,
0.8455060124,
-0.103642799,
-0.4303164482,
-0.3506893516,
-0.9186658859,
-0.0844015256,
-0.2392083853,
-0.494119525,
-0.2354396582,
-0.0034044764,
0.3492690027,
0.0421058498,
-0.0728537962,
-0.7123965621,
0.2844214141,
-0.8351848722,
0.4472229779,
0.0023847183,
0.0766821727,
0.4314271808,
-0.2741587758,
0.8140074611,
0.0216224957,
-0.1650610566,
-0.2646511495,
-0.5764312744,
-0.7079905272,
-0.2741635144,
0.826149404,
0.4720332623,
-0.7038118839,
0.1618544012,
-0.2240502089,
-0.2327144593,
-0.7784232497,
0.0254074112,
-0.0921404809,
0.6267116666,
0.1812459826,
-0.6881619096,
-0.585680306,
-0.6534187198,
-0.382060796,
-0.1506461203,
-0.1245226488,
0.2513928413,
0.2894204557,
-0.2491594255,
0.9446793199,
-0.0147295399,
-0.3134059906,
-0.2767421007,
0.3123829365,
0.3671709299,
0.6230837703,
0.4042253494,
-1.0884990692,
-0.573774457,
0.0117813181,
-0.5667788386,
-0.2254300267,
-0.3053431809,
0.0901377201,
0.5161758661,
0.4468098581,
-0.4193990529,
0.7698382735,
0.6546745896,
-0.1306418031,
0.6011093855,
0.0219010096,
0.0812124088,
-0.7322223783,
0.0868742764,
-0.2514832914,
-0.3483039737,
-0.7438630462,
0.1598234773,
0.1136533692,
-0.262925595,
-0.3710342646,
0.1733830273,
-0.3416522741,
0.219521299,
-0.2846989632,
-0.0189773291,
-0.1379285157,
0.2134901881,
0.4559976757,
0.7972443104,
0.5544564724,
-0.3571228385,
0.0520040318,
0.1746052951,
-0.3766669929,
0.9416438341,
-0.7203883529,
0.0577497147,
0.0051298644,
-0.0432291366,
-0.8405497074,
-0.5678717494,
0.3556545675,
-0.4663700759,
0.6536221504,
-0.1133801639,
-0.4410367012,
0.0038539197,
-0.2260032296,
0.2315118611,
-0.1106926501,
-0.2663066387,
0.6756359935,
0.351226747,
-0.3173874021,
-0.5517625213,
-0.7901429534,
0.1616769731,
-0.1935270727,
-0.6959220767,
0.5704186559,
-0.0166393612,
0.0225733593,
-0.0784540698,
-0.0367038958,
0.0856692865,
0.0885240585,
0.4713623822,
0.1960445642,
-0.4415504932,
0.2077055871,
0.1341128051,
0.1554685831,
-0.0280675516,
-0.1345751435,
0.5743538737,
-0.1411913782,
-0.1583993584,
-0.3359044194,
0.5621176958,
0.2475955784,
-0.1824049205,
0.8520861268,
0.6326468587,
-0.1502053142,
-0.0252053272,
-0.4971883595,
0.0083129844,
-0.4276951551,
0.5609566569,
-0.5368275046,
-0.751123786,
0.4135065675,
-0.1017452031,
0.0836545974,
0.4002338946,
0.3794583678,
-0.3494385779,
0.5978661776,
0.6759871244,
-0.0280927122,
0.743599236,
-0.3773518801,
0.0469486266,
-1.0719130039,
-0.0041850307,
-0.2932432592,
-0.5246991515,
-1.0025122166,
-0.3228242099,
0.4918560982,
0.4279703498,
0.3326970041,
0.0351606421,
-0.1402528584,
0.3717260659,
0.5417289734,
0.3537557721,
0.1127050966,
0.2728507817,
-0.1094614044,
-0.2342480272,
-1.0396494865,
-0.4430404007,
1.3897969723,
0.0822022557,
0.452973038,
-0.0467549935,
0.7628617287,
0.248615846,
0.2910313904,
-0.6701256037,
-0.0083555914,
-0.1761775613,
-0.5493812561,
-0.4952557385,
-0.3943190873,
-0.87076509,
0.3695856333,
-0.4824535549,
-0.6324705482,
0.7604829073,
0.1502321362,
-0.2811703682,
0.1903547794,
-0.3566105366,
0.6416347027,
0.0742092207,
-0.0839956775,
-0.0003352431,
-0.6682990789,
0.1405070573,
-0.1157503128,
0.0811881199,
0.1234874874,
-0.205745399,
0.6265975237,
-0.4373369515,
0.9292705059,
0.1720084548,
-0.2451554388,
0.1043484807,
0.0047363373,
0.4009799361,
0.3047857285,
-0.5113818049,
0.349478513,
-0.2789551914,
-0.3188446164,
-0.4600251615,
0.5158236027,
-0.7877639532,
-0.4207821488,
-0.2878757417,
-0.7198116779,
-0.2347290218,
-0.0497486815,
0.6570650935,
0.321418047,
-0.4001386464,
0.4411441386,
0.7921187878,
-0.180172503,
0.4454519451,
0.3202521205,
-0.0152555397,
-0.6674742103,
0.5531368852,
0.2453226298,
0.0954195037,
0.3039471805,
0.0964403972,
-0.2808058262,
-0.422609359,
-0.5036907196,
0.449536413,
-0.3954553306,
-0.0989557132,
-0.7282286286,
-0.0744342133,
-0.4538690448,
0.0808778927,
-0.5088017583,
-0.8362506032,
-0.5004467964,
0.1712228805,
0.195020631,
0.5558798909,
-0.4560317397,
0.4621901214,
-0.4638694227,
0.3686013222,
0.1317066252,
0.3011838794,
-0.2610000074,
-0.8521347642,
-0.2258942425,
0.2940206528,
-0.4366744161,
-1.0721484423,
0.5629730821,
0.5369718671,
0.2604943514,
0.1044412181,
0.080416739,
0.4567660689,
-0.304095149,
0.7793651223,
0.1667851061,
-0.9739379883,
0.452050209,
-0.4450449347,
0.2067968249,
0.5969666243,
0.3335759044,
-0.8881997466,
-0.4620191753,
-0.8475162387,
-1.0504868031,
0.826847136,
0.4439934492,
0.1336797029,
0.2445667088,
0.5486277342,
0.4275394082,
0.5728051662,
-0.4576380253,
-0.3920466304,
-0.3916441798,
0.0244845152,
-0.1902053207,
-0.4378092885,
0.0071319812,
-0.0426503085,
0.8691504002,
0.1641259789,
0.0365185663,
0.3553981185,
-0.2690609694,
-0.0840130746,
0.1690835804,
0.7369267941,
0.634295702,
-0.1630356908,
-0.1816645712,
-0.0394899324,
-0.8448541164,
-0.2160484493,
0.2464308292,
-0.607613802,
0.4959559143,
0.3735848963,
0.9125409722,
-0.1918061525,
-0.4530428648,
0.1233240962,
0.018103091,
-0.2209202051,
-0.0139009859,
0.2156526893,
-0.0057805674,
0.2172468454,
0.2175252736,
0.3079432845,
0.2391319573,
-0.4431555867,
-0.0801443756,
-0.0753739476,
-0.2191192806,
-0.3031845093,
0.3162773848,
0.0812218264,
-0.6981778145,
0.5802415013,
0.0891424865,
-0.6145355701,
0.3829008937,
0.3242843449,
0.5840113759,
-0.4008000493,
0.4638979137,
0.0909572393,
0.2715708315,
-0.0648051202,
0.5675612092,
0.0615595952,
-0.7907508016,
-0.2800416052,
-0.4945067763,
-0.4579912126,
0.3207438886,
-0.9528977871,
0.1627328694,
-0.1594988704,
-0.3042612672,
-0.0229672529,
-0.0733451694,
-0.7859826088,
0.4430239797,
-0.0343027264,
0.5717899203,
-0.6989001036,
0.6198394299,
0.9710426927,
-0.1678257734,
-0.7459340096,
-0.0255642589,
-0.3375991583,
-0.4496957362,
0.5239929557,
0.0986909345,
0.227593109,
-0.2564041615,
-0.1928581744,
-0.5690882206,
0.4448994994,
0.4871135056,
-0.7004454732,
0.4485634267,
0.8631864786,
0.720194459,
-0.6027675867,
0.288859278,
0.7982845902,
0.1718619466,
-0.1221912801,
-0.7607833147,
-0.3214831054,
-0.3746591806,
0.5241235495,
0.1161373332,
-0.2041922212,
0.9179668427,
0.1980247051,
-0.0636219531,
0.0652653798,
0.7396634817,
0.0412790887,
-0.0136084473,
0.3963881135,
0.5118654966,
1.0371559858,
0.0022224137,
1.076110363,
-0.3604740202,
0.1867235005,
1.4948372841,
-0.0241085254,
0.9225659966,
0.5722749829,
-0.1143916249,
0.3698551357,
0.7239563465,
0.3847974241,
0.2137960792,
0.0824920908,
-0.3329147995,
-0.061873205,
-0.28325966,
-0.6623228192,
0.5937278271,
0.5935472846,
-0.5263382792,
0.0730055198,
0.0985115767,
0.008917274,
0.1816419065,
-0.1773387492,
0.6268441677,
-0.0615913421,
-0.4239851534,
0.9280510545,
0.2097174972,
0.6977183819,
-0.3477705121,
0.0211226847,
-0.7046468854,
0.0084814904,
-0.3128905296,
-0.527941823,
0.3343618214,
-0.0380428024,
-0.3217685521,
-0.1749157906,
0.318511188,
-0.7207541466,
-0.6766642928,
-0.184268862,
0.1104114801,
0.0532437004,
-0.3673100471,
-0.7070208788,
0.1085277572,
0.114233166,
-0.2910580039,
0.190583244,
0.8375859857,
0.1738316119,
0.269028753,
0.4348495305,
0.6619487405,
0.2776136696,
0.0171099938,
0.8993672132,
-0.2863499522,
-0.5242547989,
-0.6201525927,
0.397475034,
-0.1853150725,
-0.6429637074,
0.5278789401,
0.6063337922,
1.0284895897,
-0.2545977831,
0.7824980617,
-0.13721174,
0.7137437463,
-0.497710079,
0.5102491379,
-0.4835009575,
0.3026595712,
-0.2133021653,
-0.9349763989,
-0.3579382896,
0.8839598298,
-0.2834715545,
-0.4465922415,
0.6327806711,
0.9631636143,
-0.1759709418,
0.3714149892,
0.4012169838,
0.0733939707,
0.1613597423,
0.173336342,
0.6655071974,
-0.8010287881,
0.168974638,
-0.490285486,
-0.157046333,
-0.1832900494,
-0.8077574968,
-0.8528370261,
-0.2043237686,
-0.4743258059,
-0.2866563499,
0.1874735206,
0.8848430514,
0.4836039841,
-0.8718325496,
-0.5305204988,
-0.2785912454,
0.0361550823,
-0.2191690803,
-0.2226420343,
0.4027193189,
-0.4159543216,
-0.7713183165,
0.3208476603,
0.1689081788,
0.1162214205,
-0.0485845692,
0.030455973,
-0.0422203392,
-0.0492472909,
0.3069060147,
0.5104020238,
-0.5158829093,
0.1536683142,
-0.1362734884,
0.0691594854,
0.3328726292,
0.9223582745,
-0.4672189355,
0.736566782,
0.4548244178,
0.6522283554,
0.5005675554,
-0.1459122747,
0.8720479012,
-0.8129930496,
0.4787225723,
0.3182350695,
0.3252230883,
0.6399289966,
-0.4442367554,
0.6242722273,
0.4427770376,
-0.1518035531,
-0.7016675472,
0.2436343879,
-0.510795176,
0.016679652,
1.0331715345,
-0.461600095,
-0.0609328635,
0.0643329695,
-0.2131209075,
0.1557935774,
-0.562590301,
1.0205503702,
0.7423599958,
-0.0447866395,
0.0276390146,
-0.3502641916,
0.606244266,
0.6529176831,
-0.5419130325,
-0.1416412443,
0.2919375002,
0.0974850133,
0.1737590581,
0.2392624915,
-0.0735813156,
0.3705507517,
-0.0531703457,
0.0009147129,
-0.0214584954,
-0.1051712409,
-0.4347877502,
0.2263762504,
-0.3032364249,
-0.0735064894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18257v1
|
Mapping 'when'-clauses in Latin American and Caribbean languages: an experiment in subtoken-based typology
| 2024-04-28T17:43:24 | 2024-04-28T17:43:24 |
Nilo Pedrazzini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, 68T50, 68U15, 68T35, (Primary), 86A32, 15A03 (Secondary), I.2.7
|
Languages can encode temporal subordination lexically, via subordinating
conjunctions, and morphologically, by marking the relation on the predicate.
Systematic cross-linguistic variation among the former can be studied using
well-established token-based typological approaches to token-aligned parallel
corpora. Variation among different morphological means is instead much harder
to tackle and therefore more poorly understood, despite being predominant in
several language groups. This paper explores variation in the expression of
generic temporal subordination ('when'-clauses) among the languages of Latin
America and the Caribbean, where morphological marking is particularly common.
It presents probabilistic semantic maps computed on the basis of the languages
of the region, thus avoiding bias towards the many world's languages that
exclusively use lexified connectors, incorporating associations between
character $n$-grams and English $when$. The approach allows capturing
morphological clause-linkage devices in addition to lexified connectors, paving
the way for larger-scale, strategy-agnostic analyses of typological variation
in temporal subordination.
|
[
-0.4216397703,
-0.4576601684,
0.5798915029,
0.5784593821,
-0.6568850279,
0.3811609447,
-0.1321441382,
-0.5505441427,
0.8083840609,
0.3316421509,
-0.6519027948,
-0.7258808017,
-0.532568872,
0.3792876601,
-0.3645555079,
0.5656311512,
0.0663108453,
-0.1381872743,
-0.2410061657,
-0.2732810676,
-0.0661491528,
-1.0191150904,
-0.4210163355,
-0.1842887104,
0.7458987832,
0.1666866392,
0.9604808688,
0.6630897522,
0.5011329651,
0.3331726193,
-0.018291913,
0.2409394234,
0.1941162795,
-0.0203414559,
-0.5079154968,
-0.7422896624,
-0.3748500347,
0.134686619,
0.1760454476,
0.9756891131,
0.0398846753,
0.0396977141,
-0.3605929613,
0.341637671,
-0.692902863,
0.5423405766,
-0.7493952513,
0.0370778851,
-0.6647781134,
-0.7992420197,
-0.051804401,
-0.3382080793,
-0.0158777833,
-0.4256243706,
0.2570012212,
0.2866130769,
0.6933706999,
0.335241586,
-0.4623481035,
-0.1915743053,
-0.4485274255,
0.7525145411,
-0.492610395,
0.5041411519,
0.4408268034,
0.0978136361,
-0.3328293264,
-0.5487309694,
-0.3155543208,
-0.1752263457,
-0.166371271,
0.2941959798,
0.0073985732,
-0.0125248274,
-0.0239866991,
0.1172405705,
-0.4738532901,
0.0412691943,
-0.2834489644,
-0.1727131307,
0.4050398171,
-0.1189966947,
0.3448671401,
-0.3157936633,
-0.1076893657,
0.4387135506,
-0.8504395485,
-0.1012679935,
0.61904037,
0.6927485466,
-0.0736617818,
0.9405846596,
0.0306827724,
0.6946678758,
0.055919636,
-0.095551081,
0.1244236827,
-0.6578269005,
-0.0076626255,
-0.0513321497,
0.7064142823,
0.1893076748,
0.4653792977,
-0.2523550987,
-0.1584384739,
0.3348748088,
-0.0290130638,
-0.0647473484,
0.1899314076,
0.0909796506,
-0.3570008576,
-0.06730555,
-0.0543611422,
-0.8541696072,
-0.0613922738,
-0.3288946748,
-0.0603904799,
-0.3062429726,
-0.0711091831,
0.4121896625,
-0.0844568983,
0.3032422662,
-0.1559427977,
-0.7550259233,
0.6295694113,
0.6831473112,
0.7622101307,
-0.2925428152,
-0.4172192514,
-0.3319663405,
-0.1150863022,
-0.4653010368,
0.9260604978,
-0.7108669877,
-0.5760228038,
0.1767585278,
0.2368832976,
-0.2674013674,
-0.593216002,
0.5653384328,
-0.4387406707,
0.2038015574,
-0.1881820858,
-0.2611841857,
0.103642337,
0.0675050989,
-0.2572884262,
0.6761134267,
0.2227693498,
-0.7155072689,
0.4672954977,
-0.1336558163,
-0.5684148073,
0.0222666338,
-0.4680132866,
-0.1415667981,
0.2288769484,
0.2841106951,
-0.2320061624,
-0.5723594427,
0.3174292445,
-0.2993048131,
-0.2211367488,
0.3717395663,
-0.1227126792,
1.0715167522,
0.0028994512,
-0.6301546097,
-0.0359933786,
-0.489423722,
0.0123111634,
-0.0256611295,
0.0789518431,
-0.3383788466,
0.3142422438,
-0.1020481065,
0.2090594918,
0.3483143151,
-0.6062290072,
0.2998461723,
-0.1128154546,
0.5198352337,
0.061296124,
0.3333752751,
0.2347162664,
-0.2763549984,
0.7053333521,
0.2847373188,
0.6337333322,
0.1596452296,
-0.6350297332,
-1.084753871,
-0.1138345078,
0.5477198958,
0.649641037,
-0.6917964816,
0.3984693587,
-0.2065436393,
-0.490942955,
-0.2204114795,
-0.3881005347,
0.5075491071,
0.0568680726,
0.4962822795,
-0.3628801107,
-0.7279243469,
-1.0540376902,
-0.1312704235,
-0.8048804402,
0.4319022894,
0.1173294112,
0.2541554868,
-0.0745448768,
0.8780412674,
-0.3576808274,
-0.2935686409,
-0.2948744297,
0.3543706536,
0.0953786299,
0.3500041664,
0.8974134922,
-0.6590127349,
-0.1221280769,
-0.0036552146,
-0.3468297422,
-0.6641011238,
-0.0261381604,
0.1318632513,
0.4743524194,
0.9941889644,
-0.3223210275,
0.595854938,
0.4549326301,
-0.2658596337,
0.602478683,
-0.4985597432,
0.3444049954,
-0.635488987,
-0.3789733946,
-0.2451294363,
-0.194868505,
-0.101270996,
0.1522572488,
0.0305789486,
0.049231153,
-0.523721993,
0.231905356,
-0.6276137829,
-0.3788533211,
-0.0717634484,
-0.0081130536,
-0.2487185895,
0.4945918918,
0.259447962,
0.7147510052,
0.3971132338,
-0.4293666184,
-0.2102601081,
-0.1564654708,
-0.2990682125,
0.4456671178,
-0.662294507,
0.0081344824,
-0.1274589598,
0.1195494831,
-0.7037038803,
0.1154575199,
0.09930785,
-0.4557730556,
-0.0330479145,
-0.7240920663,
-0.7404602766,
-0.0946298093,
0.1995005459,
0.8354554176,
0.4508861303,
-0.2060831189,
0.4298821986,
0.5556129813,
0.0086347284,
-0.4414865077,
-0.6284624934,
-0.0681181625,
-0.4649164975,
-0.3867738545,
0.6243910789,
0.1542585194,
-0.4947176576,
-0.1269498914,
-0.0996782854,
-0.1524092704,
0.0801272243,
0.1946907789,
0.2915307283,
-0.1797250211,
-0.1765124798,
0.2344930023,
0.0551839061,
0.0105661731,
-0.7281958461,
0.8682454824,
0.008513811,
-0.5623009801,
0.0431104414,
0.6789008975,
0.8272177577,
-0.536477387,
0.6952556968,
-0.0240542386,
-0.3578645885,
0.1585512459,
-0.5024631023,
0.3066835701,
-0.4299452305,
-0.0998338908,
-0.4216362536,
-0.4281845093,
0.8428786993,
-0.0542125553,
-0.0239288993,
0.4980258346,
0.252232939,
-0.1063559055,
0.6907352209,
0.3067607582,
0.2054364085,
0.4170936644,
-0.0651553869,
0.2401943803,
-0.4521220922,
-0.5766099691,
-0.9039053321,
-0.0671614483,
-1.1108647585,
-0.7197574973,
0.2582953572,
-0.0822233185,
-0.0323070362,
0.4940932095,
0.1881602854,
0.5263773799,
0.3902478218,
-0.3901915252,
0.1103782877,
-0.2110996097,
-0.6435497999,
-0.379907757,
-0.6419675946,
-0.1376248449,
0.7833394408,
-0.4137106538,
0.6204739213,
0.1604148895,
0.7465417981,
0.3870203495,
-0.190745756,
-0.5832459927,
0.6497008204,
-0.4426111579,
-0.4318415225,
0.0905632898,
-0.0993949175,
-1.3523538113,
0.19073084,
-0.1986526251,
-0.7201867104,
0.8698267937,
-0.0268360432,
0.2389906943,
0.0149945412,
-0.7605990767,
0.5599814653,
-0.3127537668,
0.0302255508,
0.1031235009,
-0.776475668,
-0.1325638741,
-0.2149979472,
0.4866145551,
-0.0436891876,
-0.3679755628,
0.3001679182,
-0.4748754501,
0.7793037891,
0.1280235797,
0.25845173,
0.5999605656,
0.3170915544,
0.1514108181,
0.0967650041,
0.1654124111,
0.2892115116,
0.0918486565,
-0.5627481937,
-0.7286948562,
0.5091165304,
-0.7257317305,
-0.7130649686,
-0.6758779287,
-0.371345669,
-0.3934082389,
0.0554102734,
0.5898153782,
0.6293412447,
-0.0096148048,
-0.1416616589,
0.2920839787,
-0.1771783978,
0.5678387284,
0.3392329514,
-0.4341170192,
-0.3280588686,
0.7289088368,
0.4140407741,
0.1585931182,
0.6802304387,
-0.1331975609,
-0.5558416843,
-0.5941125154,
0.1267635226,
0.570527494,
-0.4886792302,
-0.1089198664,
-0.4922808111,
-0.2753590345,
-0.6015487909,
-0.351872474,
-0.2935981452,
-0.8237022161,
-0.0225648209,
0.0771397501,
-0.0859746039,
0.1244793609,
0.0792106763,
0.2002862245,
-0.4587006271,
-0.076841794,
0.0467115901,
0.0137279304,
-0.4433903992,
-0.1836803854,
0.1539591849,
-0.4525238276,
0.2243757695,
-1.0206038952,
0.4640834928,
0.1873432696,
0.5644558072,
0.1029940099,
-0.0101602376,
0.8488713503,
-0.5252023935,
0.6450840831,
-0.0490354672,
-1.0853710175,
0.5492582917,
-0.6451256871,
0.570510447,
0.4713017642,
0.3125976026,
-0.7102636695,
-1.1213254929,
-0.8425920606,
-1.0542167425,
0.2159856111,
0.3806046844,
-0.3124817908,
-0.7192785144,
0.4155721962,
0.2262814939,
0.1560025513,
-0.6780192256,
-0.4458807409,
-0.2229440808,
-0.0103039499,
-0.273529768,
-0.0870953575,
0.084306851,
-0.0370804071,
0.1914822459,
-0.0619006045,
0.4340440929,
0.3950903416,
-0.4690086842,
0.327637285,
0.4755315483,
0.7300480008,
0.8203874826,
-0.2015432715,
0.6260082126,
-0.3065417111,
-0.1813143343,
0.2053977698,
0.1571499854,
-0.2862781584,
0.3057512343,
0.6560389996,
0.3463395834,
0.316046834,
-0.4588888288,
0.0982292742,
-0.0621901564,
0.0451553129,
-0.4604819417,
-0.0858327895,
0.157719478,
0.2172355801,
0.2965737581,
-0.0050248592,
0.1228536665,
-0.8114897609,
-0.0176371932,
0.2073272616,
-0.2590101659,
-0.4794246256,
0.5353106856,
-0.1028214246,
-0.61423105,
0.3458039463,
-0.054115124,
-0.6948534846,
0.7748327255,
0.7378659844,
0.706448853,
0.0113269342,
0.2986352146,
0.1335825175,
0.6533818245,
0.2751921415,
0.7497498989,
0.0522894524,
-0.4524322748,
-0.1968295723,
-0.3850924671,
-0.1368032694,
-0.161009565,
-0.6282550693,
0.3330889046,
-0.4198173285,
-0.6296673417,
-0.0231397357,
-0.2463209778,
-0.5933898091,
0.1426158696,
-0.1844560802,
0.6961948276,
-0.9551770687,
0.6216571331,
0.6418518424,
-0.3882248104,
-0.15517205,
0.3931521177,
0.0139861982,
-0.7588860989,
0.7414507866,
-0.4220559895,
-0.337146163,
-0.3649944067,
-0.191758886,
-1.117814064,
0.5894691944,
0.3062090576,
-0.275852561,
0.1371836066,
0.5695652366,
0.9683884978,
-0.626316011,
0.2220294774,
0.678950429,
0.2864235938,
-0.0815529972,
-0.8761438727,
-0.1322310418,
-0.1527225375,
0.0114988973,
0.7592887878,
-0.7911382318,
0.7942396402,
0.0312481001,
-0.3445690274,
-0.1803966016,
0.7732932568,
0.1634678096,
-0.0278955735,
0.7200209498,
0.1949312538,
0.4797950089,
-0.342656225,
0.9848097563,
-0.4180032909,
-0.0079225656,
1.1991755962,
0.0119134095,
0.5380673409,
0.7014945745,
-0.2535946965,
0.5772927999,
1.015666604,
0.4547765553,
0.607947886,
0.2628821433,
-0.1020244956,
-0.4000464082,
-0.3601133525,
-0.2622662485,
0.5782362223,
0.5184723735,
-0.1355609149,
-0.2553594112,
-0.4581383765,
0.0563579649,
-0.0967545584,
-0.2079877853,
0.3295849264,
0.0174061935,
-1.2012194395,
0.5102133751,
0.0042224904,
0.1122989655,
-0.4815485775,
0.3573091328,
-0.9061117768,
-0.3171026111,
-0.0339923315,
-0.4905046821,
0.4610041082,
0.0548091568,
0.0724643171,
-0.0465443991,
0.1623818874,
-0.5798068047,
-0.5476709604,
0.5545466542,
0.6913403273,
0.1074216068,
0.5046750903,
-0.4429733157,
-0.1363126487,
-0.2311972827,
0.4932353795,
0.2277987748,
0.6285784245,
-0.7387945652,
0.6587918997,
0.2208511978,
0.2919604778,
0.6106024981,
0.458470881,
0.3865348697,
-0.5412994623,
-0.4560821652,
-0.5589128733,
0.1539834887,
0.1337718219,
-0.473739326,
0.4003491402,
0.688492775,
0.7741604447,
0.0192316566,
0.2029629499,
0.0427715778,
-0.0392649099,
-0.6423059106,
0.1814901531,
-0.8181766868,
0.1414057463,
-0.1008232757,
-1.0135508776,
-0.5268921852,
0.0920135453,
-0.1903995425,
-0.2450226992,
1.4574066401,
0.3441797495,
-0.0931758508,
-0.209717378,
0.2186053544,
-0.1730372608,
0.297164917,
0.1930122823,
0.5891889334,
0.0433490872,
0.5936983228,
-0.2006420195,
-0.1105779409,
0.0528313853,
-0.6993413568,
-0.7471621037,
-0.8928477764,
-0.5266128778,
-0.362316221,
0.2429230064,
1.0465620756,
0.3559761643,
-0.5669899583,
-0.5773103833,
-0.1759729236,
0.248085767,
-0.3389551938,
-0.1344688833,
0.3721660376,
-0.562277317,
-1.0041166544,
0.3780927956,
0.5985864997,
0.4314310849,
-0.154622972,
0.6400405169,
-0.2231417298,
0.5016714334,
0.2218905091,
0.4545668066,
-0.767706573,
-0.2434688509,
0.2446013093,
-0.0849654898,
0.2808926404,
1.3142747879,
-0.7479132414,
0.3298155367,
0.4719933271,
0.2420691401,
0.5274189115,
-0.3642271459,
0.7432001233,
-0.8656454086,
0.7010647655,
0.1881398261,
0.8859938979,
0.238322705,
-0.0020269514,
0.5959537625,
0.5214239359,
-0.2565565407,
-0.4231595993,
0.6526395679,
-1.1681089401,
-0.179148674,
1.1075414419,
-0.2599740922,
-0.4048889875,
-0.5679681301,
0.2255272865,
0.1859115362,
-0.0289646965,
1.0533138514,
0.711595118,
-0.0575215407,
0.1198545396,
-0.0244606715,
0.456430912,
0.4414752126,
-0.9994439483,
-0.3192219138,
0.245631963,
0.0383575037,
0.2873591483,
0.6940053701,
-0.4699338973,
0.1135107055,
-0.0215412974,
-0.4280711412,
0.4815107286,
-0.5103220344,
0.2633086443,
0.1811289191,
-0.0670475885,
-0.1948863119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18255v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18255v5
|
PatentGPT: A Large Language Model for Intellectual Property
| 2024-04-28T17:36:43 | 2024-06-05T03:02:48 |
Zilong Bai, Ruiji Zhang, Linqing Chen, Qijun Cai, Yuan Zhong, Cong Wang, Yan Fang, Jie Fang, Jing Sun, Weikuan Wang, Lizhi Zhou, Haoran Hua, Tian Qiu, Chaochao Wang, Cheng Sun, Jianping Lu, Yixin Wang, Yubin Xia, Meng Hu, Haowen Liu, Peng Xu, Licong Xu, Fu Bian, Xiaolong Gu, Lisha Zhang, Weilei Wang, Changyang Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
In recent years, large language models(LLMs) have attracted significant
attention due to their exceptional performance across a multitude of natural
language process tasks, and have been widely applied in various fields.
However, the application of large language models in the Intellectual Property
(IP) domain is challenging due to the strong need for specialized knowledge,
privacy protection, processing of extremely long text in this field. In this
technical report, we present for the first time a low-cost, standardized
procedure for training IP-oriented LLMs, meeting the unique requirements of the
IP domain. Using this standard process, we have trained the PatentGPT series
models based on open-source pretrained models. By evaluating them on the
open-source IP-oriented benchmark MOZIP, our domain-specific LLMs outperforms
GPT-4, indicating the effectiveness of the proposed training procedure and the
expertise of the PatentGPT models in the IP domain. Remarkably, our model
surpassed GPT-4 on the 2019 China Patent Agent Qualification Examination,
scoring 65 and matching human expert levels. Additionally, the PatentGPT model,
which utilizes the SMoE architecture, achieves performance comparable to that
of GPT-4 in the IP domain and demonstrates a better cost-performance ratio on
long-text tasks, potentially serving as an alternative to GPT-4 within the IP
domain.
|
[
-0.2145729661,
-0.3036407828,
0.4438644648,
0.2403611839,
-0.5503666401,
-0.0122298943,
-0.1988459229,
-0.5827342272,
-0.166214332,
0.6752170324,
-0.0388188623,
-0.5440618396,
-0.8308778405,
-0.0810606033,
-0.0097907046,
0.9920184016,
-0.2972676456,
0.1165586039,
0.1366295815,
0.0209958218,
-0.0998285338,
-0.7552661896,
-0.4507603645,
-0.5772061944,
0.2457517982,
0.0646674335,
0.1739629209,
0.5786940455,
0.7313969135,
0.1093201414,
-0.1168242171,
-0.1498787701,
-0.2556987405,
-0.3319172263,
-0.4797293246,
-0.1830906272,
-0.724193871,
0.4206269979,
0.5122632384,
0.3748801947,
-0.2056018561,
0.196912244,
0.0025967201,
0.4533396959,
-0.2897305489,
0.3481591344,
-0.9429073334,
0.0824388042,
-0.2955898046,
-0.2178760469,
-0.55706352,
0.0121413236,
0.4151238203,
-0.375472337,
0.2721550167,
0.1786060631,
0.8575934768,
-0.0245359018,
-0.313456744,
-0.0463246703,
-0.2891506255,
0.645506978,
-0.8171391487,
0.1787449569,
0.0698414445,
0.1346767992,
-0.0739044175,
-1.1429687738,
-0.6078228354,
-0.8279635906,
0.3571796715,
-0.113143526,
0.0677082837,
0.189188689,
0.3909066916,
0.1761356145,
-0.6533688307,
0.3280163407,
-0.4641964138,
0.0161501039,
0.394189626,
-0.2639308572,
0.316042155,
0.1022975072,
-0.7627261281,
0.2623054385,
-1.1893293858,
-0.1688390374,
0.2729001343,
0.2993986309,
0.0895762295,
0.6309101582,
-0.3070867658,
0.4209544361,
-0.1388528943,
-0.1298144907,
0.152212441,
0.1084616482,
-0.2195858657,
0.0524913929,
0.6943754554,
0.077891469,
0.2895142734,
-0.1990931034,
-0.3626817465,
-0.4205528796,
0.0031656781,
-1.2607387304,
-0.4262472391,
-0.0589687899,
-0.3684507906,
-0.1538368016,
-0.0488082543,
-0.4007594883,
-0.4982661009,
-0.3658245504,
0.5991575718,
-0.3746310771,
-0.1557950377,
0.2610554993,
-0.1050005853,
0.417738378,
0.2575379312,
-0.9697053432,
0.3668273389,
0.9441264272,
0.9035506845,
-0.3618779182,
-0.648584187,
-0.4690955579,
0.3009838462,
0.0010472776,
0.769022882,
-0.4036337435,
-0.2098815292,
-0.3338910937,
-0.1076596081,
-0.2227898985,
-0.5831744671,
0.6232596636,
-0.8417652845,
0.0233494081,
0.1091928482,
-0.5983936787,
0.089243941,
0.5631700754,
-0.4670412242,
0.3597165644,
-0.1137189344,
-0.8854843974,
0.4363204241,
-0.9778792858,
-0.2917759717,
0.3968250155,
-0.0492019057,
-0.5110931993,
-0.414196223,
0.1757847667,
0.5622540712,
-0.7005832791,
0.2437756807,
-0.1754933447,
-0.4050256312,
0.0076752668,
-0.255320698,
0.8707934618,
0.0862576142,
-0.5407521129,
0.0332108736,
-0.7080793977,
0.0709135532,
0.2297243476,
-0.3346062899,
-0.0924466848,
-0.2587836981,
-0.4768011868,
0.1468761563,
0.6212961674,
-0.7332273722,
0.3602120876,
-0.3038461804,
0.7053279281,
0.8745242357,
-0.0442077592,
0.3201993406,
0.0023162572,
0.5693742037,
-0.1039208695,
0.1190911829,
-0.2411091626,
-0.7057820559,
-0.5649378896,
-0.6070893407,
0.5930560231,
0.4882433712,
-0.518296957,
0.3064753711,
-0.4479387999,
-0.5920383334,
-0.1874522865,
0.0203785338,
0.3411287665,
0.3690687418,
0.1295778155,
-0.4678075016,
-0.0593161061,
-0.7142214775,
-0.2472255975,
-0.1228057444,
-0.0417053811,
0.2921188772,
0.6993023753,
-0.0961849019,
0.675000906,
-0.5415344834,
-0.3444544971,
-0.2012146264,
0.7246697545,
0.2981472015,
0.3151760101,
0.3774249256,
-0.5392813087,
-0.8842315674,
0.3891345561,
-0.3423846066,
-0.2450703532,
0.3657195568,
0.1403688341,
0.1594104022,
0.2397072315,
-0.9245173335,
0.2821111083,
0.4642976522,
-0.0352220088,
0.8205890059,
-0.3162408173,
0.0525005348,
-0.7335508466,
0.3238594234,
-0.0638422072,
-0.0822805911,
-0.4420740008,
0.2855173051,
0.1530016363,
-0.673334837,
-0.6887136102,
0.7503306866,
-0.562964499,
0.0332745574,
-0.3819005787,
-0.0808458999,
-0.0320258625,
0.4638727009,
0.1522240043,
1.1538646221,
0.582139194,
-0.327111572,
0.5642532706,
-0.0537325069,
-0.421987474,
0.4295538664,
-0.7302976251,
0.5685312748,
0.0830157101,
0.0199031774,
-0.2669401169,
-0.1142407134,
0.2223497033,
-0.1027184874,
0.4150805771,
-0.5537216663,
-0.6755360365,
-0.3842539787,
-0.1450062394,
0.0814848319,
0.6079078317,
-0.7563896775,
0.3294473886,
0.284452945,
-0.5324070454,
-0.7809614539,
-0.3588435948,
0.1927098185,
-0.2881464362,
-0.7745509744,
0.5172929764,
0.0326823704,
0.1333846301,
-0.0320075676,
0.1026542112,
-0.6108878255,
-0.2157472223,
-0.022225989,
0.0123655507,
-0.3678861856,
-0.0091928113,
-0.3863052428,
-0.2096338272,
-0.0729596987,
-0.7449754477,
0.5240730643,
-0.1530009657,
-0.4737300873,
-0.390717864,
0.1733279973,
0.4847485721,
-0.5159263015,
0.6771590114,
0.1241137311,
-0.1908337027,
-0.6480515599,
-0.328956604,
0.0912904367,
-0.469768405,
0.3861799538,
-0.6081779599,
-1.0147424936,
0.3406084776,
-0.3478752673,
-0.218492955,
0.2569436729,
0.4975818098,
0.3740016222,
0.6098740697,
0.8397956491,
-0.3764133453,
0.2887672782,
-0.0743361935,
0.8811886311,
-0.4950993359,
-0.0503279567,
-0.4595557749,
0.1509903073,
-0.2251047045,
-0.44330585,
0.2989576161,
0.1187289134,
-0.524625659,
0.4291716218,
-0.5691164732,
0.8140093684,
0.8199870586,
0.019703038,
0.4370955825,
0.1032306254,
-0.091356203,
-0.0168643035,
-0.397913754,
-0.8542371392,
1.2173035145,
0.5650589466,
0.8543995619,
-0.1298514009,
0.6857261658,
0.2085074037,
0.5328431129,
-0.7048332095,
0.7129345536,
-0.3860571086,
-0.5168684721,
-0.4076080322,
-0.302017808,
-0.5187894106,
0.140166223,
0.4975946248,
-0.7922413349,
-0.077226609,
0.1468021572,
-0.0966240838,
0.4822419882,
-0.7738825679,
1.0329611301,
-0.4691407979,
-0.268181175,
-0.1278686225,
-0.4160829186,
0.4836792946,
-0.489281714,
-0.4350648522,
-0.3215447068,
0.0583600923,
0.5979557037,
-0.4074114561,
0.6673228741,
-0.3625063002,
0.0366470367,
0.377368778,
-0.286013186,
0.8328611851,
-0.2369447351,
-0.310054183,
0.2871564627,
-0.2727552652,
-0.2032278627,
-0.2568074763,
0.6442967653,
-0.6108675003,
-0.7489714622,
-0.6043309569,
-0.3036864102,
-0.0329002738,
0.5852421522,
0.2917033434,
-0.0510055088,
-0.3627922833,
0.003069646,
0.7554352283,
-0.3478671312,
0.1064585298,
0.7116413713,
0.2336290926,
-0.2192499638,
0.9369617105,
0.2054629326,
0.2138030231,
0.4233362377,
0.1271089315,
-0.2447103411,
-0.9682468772,
-0.2113569379,
0.3358988762,
-0.7947030663,
-0.1695324033,
-0.6338808537,
-0.65914464,
-0.4425547421,
0.1920999885,
-0.3062626123,
-0.365735054,
-0.1634564996,
-0.080893591,
0.1359812915,
0.5446007848,
0.1906709969,
0.4504176378,
-0.6473150849,
0.3343255222,
0.6951367855,
0.719922781,
-0.2256682515,
-0.666995883,
-0.2412712872,
-0.1980550587,
-0.6129032373,
-0.2800130844,
0.4805873334,
0.2967677712,
0.5652882457,
0.2061597556,
0.0096371816,
0.2200428694,
-1.1110601425,
0.9250309467,
0.2314534485,
-1.0021059513,
0.3531047106,
-0.5063812137,
-0.2150761038,
0.1214644387,
0.3473960161,
-0.1882746816,
0.0273198523,
-0.5224623084,
-0.8507759571,
0.6624954939,
-0.0737323239,
0.3082313538,
0.2359927744,
0.3961519003,
0.1785553247,
0.4357695878,
-1.2749116421,
0.2730586529,
-0.0313830189,
0.0302306283,
0.3951213062,
-0.3477315307,
-0.1870008111,
0.0989489183,
0.9477303624,
-0.0649118945,
0.440481782,
-0.1569669098,
-0.0825248808,
0.2366489619,
0.5065821409,
0.6024679542,
0.8716662526,
-0.3220597506,
0.0870215371,
-0.1896333694,
-0.4927762449,
0.2545233369,
0.5998415351,
-0.0955143869,
-0.223080337,
0.0236837938,
0.7256928682,
-0.4649310708,
-0.7221551538,
0.9944947362,
0.2783635557,
-0.4013851583,
-0.2516817451,
0.0064693522,
-0.0415269062,
0.3235612512,
0.1880180836,
-0.3366729021,
0.0657826141,
-0.2986749113,
0.3202029765,
0.3528062105,
-0.0787976459,
-0.2782393694,
0.7651176453,
0.3623375893,
-0.1577923298,
0.4770024717,
-0.3605845869,
-0.6941583157,
0.5944181085,
0.6642858386,
1.0173670053,
-0.0309606157,
0.175544858,
-0.1071875393,
0.4151193202,
-0.3172316253,
0.1143655479,
0.2015898973,
-0.5773311853,
-0.4956844151,
-0.4050620794,
-0.8177837729,
0.4641044438,
0.0756049678,
0.4892165363,
-0.8202919364,
-0.0904755741,
-0.1097936928,
-0.0718366429,
-0.5679152012,
0.071954079,
0.0566074774,
1.1111308336,
-0.5835198164,
1.2048274279,
0.5031036735,
-0.399505347,
-0.6842354536,
0.1126191095,
-0.4557586312,
-0.8335515857,
1.2197109461,
0.2398235053,
-0.04127983,
0.1460408568,
-0.8644391298,
-0.5535222888,
0.9625659585,
0.6406834126,
-0.4094665945,
0.08304739,
0.4681102037,
0.5251524448,
-0.4537213147,
-0.3666821718,
0.4126812816,
0.1868741363,
-0.0859458447,
-1.1483664513,
-0.1639937609,
-0.2036522776,
-0.1542457938,
0.0996592417,
-0.6895584464,
0.9387554526,
-0.0895131379,
-0.010371007,
0.3465299904,
0.4233286679,
0.5404810309,
0.3362599015,
0.1421855092,
0.6331025958,
0.7385376692,
-0.1025274098,
0.8653519154,
-0.5145261288,
0.3089887798,
1.2066079378,
-0.8370227218,
0.8980294466,
0.2835737467,
-0.106732972,
0.0240828265,
0.3668654561,
-0.1965313703,
0.7461535335,
0.5625257492,
-0.6572501659,
0.2184167653,
-0.1607275009,
-0.3737900257,
0.0043406477,
0.1598114669,
-0.5475050807,
0.0368952192,
-0.036944706,
-0.0362076499,
-0.2304704487,
-0.2220938802,
0.5065097809,
0.4101947844,
-0.378136754,
0.3443470597,
0.4048701823,
0.6423377991,
-0.6466457844,
0.0265763197,
-0.0372232422,
0.1918797195,
0.1993731558,
-0.669563055,
-0.2366871834,
0.3836648464,
-0.1440942287,
-0.3621026874,
0.6578348875,
-0.2414343655,
-0.1386055052,
0.1919481009,
0.0309715737,
0.311506629,
-0.3963401616,
-0.6269338131,
-0.3367851675,
-0.1981953532,
-0.2456815988,
0.2361268401,
0.8084443212,
-0.0929427072,
0.664185822,
0.4718925655,
0.4620857239,
0.4194384217,
0.2331368625,
0.8441858888,
-0.6038098335,
-0.5373223424,
-0.4676702321,
0.4783382416,
-0.268894732,
-0.168693915,
0.3149299622,
0.3740883172,
0.7241254449,
-0.3386663198,
1.1047912836,
0.0954778045,
0.5767409801,
-0.5874444246,
0.7806450725,
-0.0468422584,
0.4684427977,
0.1035259888,
-1.0614081621,
-0.4350887835,
0.4734486341,
-0.5457440019,
-0.0772707909,
0.7358142734,
0.6897288561,
-0.2813646793,
-0.1901639253,
0.3341840506,
0.0579502657,
0.7588686943,
0.4871198833,
0.7957167029,
-0.2802212834,
0.4112418592,
-0.1987257451,
-0.3047134578,
-0.0092329923,
-1.2564855814,
-0.9974366426,
-0.0509540103,
-0.323782444,
0.1134894192,
0.2251085639,
0.9060981274,
0.6962611079,
-0.7136483788,
-0.1270584017,
-0.0675367266,
-0.3081242442,
0.1257499307,
-0.158306703,
0.5673190951,
-0.2301528752,
-0.6567263007,
0.2980546355,
0.5385174155,
0.2809577584,
-0.0772473589,
-0.0585539341,
0.1960490346,
-0.0151384389,
0.5989667773,
0.4091058373,
-0.6695355177,
-0.2255466282,
-0.1075417399,
-0.2051531821,
0.2130463421,
1.000266552,
-0.1841580719,
0.4477496743,
0.5345349908,
0.7462513447,
0.6319350004,
-0.1827868074,
0.7052922845,
-0.688198626,
0.4995760322,
0.3756932318,
0.4866620302,
0.2560055554,
-0.3233097196,
0.5632711053,
0.2139420211,
-0.82736516,
-0.6604431868,
0.2456154525,
-0.8830264211,
-0.0854134858,
0.9006775618,
-0.6975460649,
0.0301640835,
0.059184961,
-0.3200801611,
-0.0950807482,
-0.3276450336,
0.8010731339,
0.7494562864,
-0.0006991695,
-0.4082722664,
-0.5130458474,
0.2687215507,
-0.0319766663,
-0.8176381588,
0.0990144834,
0.1136927307,
0.377281785,
-0.0546124987,
0.8865965605,
-0.4046043158,
0.0740347654,
-0.113897644,
0.3996667266,
-0.1908619255,
-0.4393035471,
-0.2326478958,
0.3878446221,
0.7106620669,
-0.1495957524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01586v1
|
Transfer Learning and Transformer Architecture for Financial Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-28T17:15:07 | 2024-04-28T17:15:07 |
Tohida Rehman, Raghubir Bose, Samiran Chattopadhyay, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Financial sentiment analysis allows financial institutions like Banks and
Insurance Companies to better manage the credit scoring of their customers in a
better way. Financial domain uses specialized mechanisms which makes sentiment
analysis difficult. In this paper, we propose a pre-trained language model
which can help to solve this problem with fewer labelled data. We extend on the
principles of Transfer learning and Transformation architecture principles and
also take into consideration recent outbreak of pandemics like COVID. We apply
the sentiment analysis to two different sets of data. We also take smaller
training set and fine tune the same as part of the model.
|
[
-0.4037815034,
-0.5098364949,
-0.0556191877,
0.2863555551,
-0.1980235577,
0.2153152674,
0.0641001463,
-0.619856596,
0.0779748484,
0.5875993967,
-0.5025030375,
-0.4433837235,
-0.7422528863,
-0.2552098334,
-0.30698964,
1.5597347021,
0.1821913868,
0.2419359088,
-0.1114103645,
-0.0433534645,
-0.0058983057,
-0.6793029308,
-1.0053685904,
-0.4511491358,
0.0857462212,
0.3412118554,
0.7496466637,
-0.1911720335,
1.082285285,
0.2199279368,
0.2479833215,
-0.2955550253,
-0.4800534546,
-0.4240266383,
-0.2153247893,
-0.4800908267,
-0.7379912138,
0.177416265,
0.025841333,
0.6093021631,
-0.0420906954,
0.3841857612,
0.1909086853,
0.7896995544,
-0.397231102,
0.4727738798,
-0.1412390172,
0.1575094163,
0.0726345479,
-0.1390873492,
-0.6473084688,
-0.4163672626,
0.8290386796,
-0.3782990873,
0.110688597,
-0.0324258246,
0.9089533091,
0.185118258,
-0.4925940037,
-0.2630104125,
-0.9407570958,
0.7213561535,
-0.3374484777,
0.1282254159,
0.2522262335,
0.5341774225,
0.4498252571,
-0.7506944537,
-0.1619871259,
-0.0106428098,
-0.1031709015,
0.293420881,
-0.4082561135,
-0.2394848317,
-0.2731717229,
0.2789100707,
-0.3139826953,
-0.0222127717,
-0.6489911675,
-0.2567715347,
0.8369277716,
0.0939669907,
0.0852382928,
-0.1454848647,
-0.6894927621,
-0.6754084229,
-0.4756515622,
0.3200785518,
0.2220325917,
0.2402362674,
-0.3743040264,
-0.1714974046,
0.282564044,
0.4597561061,
0.1088634804,
-0.2138406336,
0.4059645832,
-0.0545931309,
-0.4594308138,
0.2203338444,
0.624578774,
0.2150914371,
0.2501318157,
0.1061736643,
-0.2564881146,
0.1039957032,
0.5953069925,
-0.5449599624,
-0.3714474142,
-0.0785234272,
-0.71833992,
-0.5861135721,
0.2481538057,
-1.0508643389,
-0.2312109917,
-0.3867546618,
0.3000349998,
-0.421649158,
-0.3086342514,
0.2717919946,
-0.2079275697,
0.7405207753,
0.2008452415,
-0.5805267096,
0.7239398956,
0.7545163631,
0.4483397603,
-0.1351991445,
0.167014733,
-0.5654426813,
-0.081352368,
0.0080913706,
0.9263311625,
-0.7157807946,
-0.4433010519,
-0.047367543,
-0.3219715357,
-0.128742218,
-0.2601278424,
0.4331293106,
-0.6478823423,
0.3783805966,
0.0032064083,
-0.3504906595,
-0.5042895079,
0.2005003989,
-0.6489527822,
0.5936164856,
0.6601614356,
-0.7697435021,
0.2201908082,
-0.9793643355,
-0.6749256849,
-0.1077588424,
0.3001401424,
-0.6469036341,
0.0801426768,
0.2052038014,
0.4267895222,
-0.3895506263,
0.1587359458,
-0.4579420388,
-0.0097960541,
0.3679338694,
-0.2127906978,
0.4344223142,
0.4330613613,
-0.2468657494,
-0.0545126237,
-0.8076449633,
-0.3481477201,
-0.1782550961,
0.0234815832,
-0.6905980706,
-0.0150330206,
0.388445735,
0.1524896771,
0.2318250537,
-0.2804158032,
0.2554981411,
-0.7129921317,
0.3944904506,
0.6310559511,
0.0434259959,
0.7997601032,
-0.3242088854,
0.8238623738,
0.5545979738,
0.4554550946,
0.3781911433,
-0.1211093068,
-0.6937384605,
-0.2522715628,
0.1346827447,
0.9019352198,
-0.5032176375,
0.2361235768,
-0.3036460578,
-0.5482147932,
-0.5670080185,
-0.0220060498,
0.0759811848,
0.584019959,
0.5304775834,
-0.1230931655,
-0.7417590618,
-0.8570890427,
-0.2908775806,
0.0204990394,
0.3786498606,
-0.0231992211,
0.2583487332,
-0.405834347,
0.870557785,
-0.7058287263,
-0.3990003169,
-0.5255894661,
0.2854724228,
0.3168897033,
0.378477931,
0.8899143338,
-0.9308743477,
-0.4697409272,
0.3475524485,
-0.4314567447,
0.2065110654,
-0.2919047177,
0.1499249637,
0.0012351579,
0.4557457268,
-0.0968475789,
0.5114222765,
0.6282632351,
-0.2879253626,
0.1741047353,
0.0033223445,
-0.0948216394,
-1.5744783878,
-0.0118786767,
0.335642904,
-0.4341104925,
-0.8185295463,
-0.1785975248,
-0.2409006506,
-0.1991414279,
-0.1360170096,
0.5493556857,
-0.0942003876,
0.0519643277,
-0.4549927711,
-0.1101747826,
0.1781095713,
0.2589071691,
-0.0189450514,
0.5448533893,
0.8725979924,
-0.5315898657,
0.4543445706,
0.2402974218,
-0.3941300213,
0.6779460907,
-0.4995773733,
0.0203791782,
-0.0372334085,
0.06594491,
-1.0479859114,
0.1618355811,
0.4071423709,
-0.1535828561,
0.3437094986,
0.212436825,
0.2543845475,
-0.4967263341,
-0.1627130955,
0.2320547104,
0.6867910028,
-0.4830503464,
0.8065950871,
0.2464889586,
-0.3400690258,
-0.7638348937,
-0.7502903938,
-0.1774442941,
-0.5901722312,
-0.5483050942,
0.4135366678,
0.189217329,
-0.4859346449,
0.1709558368,
-0.00724936,
-0.173606649,
0.2067736536,
0.142100215,
0.5682756305,
-0.4390365779,
0.2498000711,
-0.0070048291,
-0.3888230324,
0.1443711668,
-0.265581876,
0.4284985065,
-0.3123838305,
0.0126354964,
-0.5160897374,
0.2573600113,
0.6235510707,
-0.277254343,
0.8383564353,
0.3635539711,
-0.030584313,
-0.1674323529,
-0.3400593996,
0.0912339836,
-0.5277474523,
0.2670244277,
-0.4014908969,
-0.7697957158,
0.5318065286,
-0.254902631,
-0.1899092346,
0.7737090588,
0.5225794911,
0.0171268322,
0.4930229187,
1.1959571838,
-0.7741402388,
0.7241464257,
-0.1328310817,
0.5502308011,
-0.2823625505,
-0.2071802914,
-0.545004189,
-0.2951374352,
-0.3807396591,
-0.0264011193,
0.4375514984,
0.0583737567,
-0.0772980675,
0.4471886158,
-0.1992958784,
0.1662712246,
0.1850330383,
0.1855953187,
0.0065950709,
0.1728229523,
-0.0452527702,
0.2773616016,
-0.3210670352,
-0.3827060163,
0.8337751031,
0.6153233051,
1.0255355835,
-0.1878819168,
0.7135025263,
0.6755000353,
0.6219433546,
-0.6916520596,
0.1357426494,
-0.5334841609,
-0.070675768,
-0.1212448925,
-0.4501968622,
-0.6534392834,
-0.3046343923,
-0.2143275887,
-0.1337331384,
0.5248903036,
-0.0532937609,
-0.6206989288,
-0.0607010163,
-0.6829170585,
0.649513185,
-0.019912269,
0.2193870395,
-0.4430225492,
-0.4412361979,
0.3799181581,
-0.1880866289,
0.4737009108,
0.1589776576,
0.3688274324,
0.6493836045,
-0.4459336698,
1.1026101112,
-0.2641150951,
-0.2044803798,
0.4511937201,
-0.1275921762,
0.4256627262,
0.0465090163,
-0.1760769933,
-0.068996489,
0.18554914,
-0.4304973185,
-0.6011172533,
0.4119893909,
-1.0892430544,
-0.4326516092,
-0.300056994,
-0.4259355068,
-0.4030888379,
-0.3601772189,
0.2129796892,
0.1031226665,
-0.4857999086,
-0.0325642079,
0.4632105529,
-0.0294891559,
0.4928345978,
0.2778114974,
-0.0946388915,
-0.3460057378,
0.7422184348,
-0.1416304559,
0.0737894326,
0.4858136177,
0.5110800266,
-0.160463497,
-0.0631745234,
0.0858363956,
0.0271988921,
-0.7616311908,
-0.4617438614,
-0.4132812321,
-0.3288711011,
-0.7799457908,
-0.2872231007,
-0.3527585268,
-0.223370567,
-0.3827303052,
-0.47438097,
0.7725490928,
0.7111147642,
-0.1189355627,
0.6499251127,
-1.1981710196,
0.225208655,
0.3050059974,
0.1924723834,
-0.1024084017,
-0.620388329,
-0.2395837754,
-0.1682672501,
-0.0586317368,
-0.7285681963,
0.7257789969,
0.3737627268,
0.3577308059,
0.7988444567,
0.1169205084,
0.6251411438,
0.0329646021,
0.5082071424,
0.42369923,
-1.2327516079,
0.6206089854,
0.207274586,
-0.0078952415,
0.6473699808,
0.7353913784,
-0.5540382266,
-0.2167077512,
-0.6972802877,
-0.4112625718,
0.6074341536,
-0.4186548591,
0.3168850541,
0.1642631143,
0.6000519991,
0.379354775,
-0.1175860912,
-0.5995770097,
-0.1664929092,
-0.4815435112,
-0.4559091926,
-0.2410983294,
-0.3489741981,
-0.0609296449,
-0.54166466,
0.592220664,
-0.0786700174,
0.1248311773,
0.0836046934,
-0.0175756328,
-0.0945953131,
0.3086893559,
0.5479589701,
0.4766014814,
0.0795379728,
-0.0722343251,
0.0510910377,
-0.5036731362,
0.1380812228,
-0.0809641331,
0.1987685561,
-0.225014478,
0.5105731487,
0.9980130196,
0.1861138791,
-0.3651774228,
0.84764117,
-0.0896230042,
-0.4126800895,
-0.3154917955,
0.0213050116,
0.0008141699,
0.3752889037,
0.4378705621,
0.6810825467,
0.1466459185,
-0.6703939438,
0.4575640559,
0.2509686649,
-0.7159582376,
-0.6972830892,
0.1969911456,
0.2399351746,
-0.1117980257,
0.8339500427,
0.2760540247,
-0.5543858409,
0.4360856712,
0.6096771955,
0.9526911378,
-0.5858899355,
0.5421059728,
0.0489573888,
0.1684674174,
-0.2651855052,
0.4054229856,
0.1453974545,
-0.8661179543,
-0.6017892957,
-0.95530653,
-0.3051689863,
-0.0616302639,
-1.2684365511,
0.4009445012,
-0.6502863169,
-0.1570938528,
0.0524141565,
-0.2580381334,
-0.8604310751,
0.5067469478,
0.3015667796,
0.9594913721,
-1.2362954617,
1.0059540272,
0.6863895059,
-0.3151747286,
-0.7717146873,
-0.3543116748,
-0.515275538,
-0.969145596,
0.9320971966,
0.0182579104,
-0.2291477174,
-0.2376200706,
-0.6278729439,
-0.754974544,
0.6150140166,
0.2549571395,
-0.5827797651,
-0.0542182326,
0.2931462824,
0.8567636013,
-0.7819830179,
-0.2250220925,
0.8222949505,
0.5663798451,
0.2580746114,
-0.630300343,
-0.3929894567,
-0.2965879142,
-0.4095438421,
0.110800162,
-0.6591331959,
0.8147340417,
0.0798246041,
0.0017791414,
-0.4495705962,
0.8639544249,
-0.588011384,
0.5221512318,
0.4085078239,
0.5296443701,
0.8715795279,
-0.0810037628,
1.1399581432,
-0.3198163211,
0.5779440403,
0.9397056699,
-0.3933190405,
0.9821098447,
0.3225946724,
-0.1931557804,
0.9131327868,
0.4993856847,
-0.0534206927,
0.6244009137,
0.0712759122,
-0.1580408663,
-0.3844135702,
0.1647969335,
-0.3168730438,
0.8349922895,
0.4535210729,
-0.5288052559,
-0.1685156971,
0.8461061716,
-0.2139332443,
-0.0522078425,
-0.5768677592,
0.9242998958,
0.4852848053,
-0.3197660446,
-0.1000533253,
-0.047720328,
0.509549737,
-0.6790761948,
0.2565447688,
-0.3459476531,
0.3303332925,
-0.1795267463,
-0.4349291921,
0.9690520763,
-0.2426590472,
-0.3731357455,
-0.3988446295,
0.8477306366,
-0.0039020001,
-0.7455377579,
0.565531671,
0.5344341993,
-0.0217499807,
-0.0213821903,
-0.6524532437,
-0.4764668941,
-0.1159749255,
-0.4752413929,
0.4743891656,
0.4808450639,
-0.2151883543,
0.6292276978,
0.5383430719,
0.0507507026,
-0.0975643992,
0.1751926094,
0.7925460935,
-1.0114148855,
-0.7021096349,
-0.983048439,
0.0492359437,
0.0604100972,
-0.1618310213,
0.4656466842,
0.2513024509,
0.5777287483,
-0.4678848684,
0.7522280812,
0.2258505672,
0.3920055032,
-0.2986888289,
0.6290209889,
-0.1498133987,
0.1376418471,
-0.2218044251,
-0.8889504075,
-0.5397571325,
0.5715373755,
-0.7663283348,
-0.3243015409,
0.5568887591,
0.4161917865,
0.0352754742,
0.2752210498,
0.2770751715,
0.0348320343,
0.0948231891,
0.3272284865,
0.7439550161,
-0.477845192,
0.589404285,
-0.0830221102,
-0.0736045912,
-0.2480379492,
-0.7521482706,
-0.8409084082,
-0.229533419,
-0.5626177192,
-0.3966280818,
-0.3343838453,
0.8174512982,
0.4544622004,
-1.0120946169,
-0.2558403313,
0.1733302921,
-0.0779236034,
-0.5108636618,
-0.290330559,
0.5302138329,
-0.5689481497,
-0.4284811616,
0.2067764699,
0.4435169995,
0.0959550291,
-0.3231339455,
0.1409948468,
0.2858269513,
0.3023756742,
0.7447065115,
0.0256256089,
-0.0128067639,
-0.5635563135,
-0.1497421861,
-0.2136526704,
0.321010381,
1.0334612131,
-0.6989061832,
0.0100691691,
0.5673577785,
0.9398713112,
0.3039189875,
0.1043876037,
0.6585708261,
-0.5598725677,
0.0476813279,
0.1492895037,
0.2344752401,
0.0777443424,
-0.7386145592,
0.1463132501,
0.1274587959,
-0.2332565039,
-0.1697200835,
0.0619389303,
-1.2009606361,
-0.4016223848,
0.8226183057,
-0.1999415457,
-0.5744397044,
-0.153896302,
-0.1196080893,
0.0552502871,
-0.1688821614,
0.8330368996,
0.6518213749,
-0.1274152547,
-0.2137884051,
0.1042013988,
0.6836256981,
0.2686771154,
-0.9076895118,
-0.2514172792,
-0.0346605889,
0.5061620474,
0.2918715477,
0.5137937069,
-0.0973331854,
0.266853869,
-0.0071772733,
0.0747703984,
0.1426248699,
-0.3700154424,
-0.4960141182,
0.6964069009,
-0.2461171448,
-0.0746637955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18243v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18243v1
|
LEGENT: Open Platform for Embodied Agents
| 2024-04-28T16:50:12 | 2024-04-28T16:50:12 |
Zhili Cheng, Zhitong Wang, Jinyi Hu, Shengding Hu, An Liu, Yuge Tu, Pengkai Li, Lei Shi, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large Multimodal
Models (LMMs), their integration into language-grounded, human-like embodied
agents remains incomplete, hindering complex real-life task performance in
physical environments. Existing integrations often feature limited open
sourcing, challenging collective progress in this field. We introduce LEGENT,
an open, scalable platform for developing embodied agents using LLMs and LMMs.
LEGENT offers a dual approach: a rich, interactive 3D environment with
communicable and actionable agents, paired with a user-friendly interface, and
a sophisticated data generation pipeline utilizing advanced algorithms to
exploit supervision from simulated worlds at scale. In our experiments, an
embryonic vision-language-action model trained on LEGENT-generated data
surpasses GPT-4V in embodied tasks, showcasing promising generalization
capabilities.
|
[
-0.2753899693,
-0.5062093735,
0.7372433543,
0.1645556241,
-0.1118609011,
0.0482177995,
0.0220831651,
-0.7575070262,
0.4166625738,
0.6241829991,
-0.3634209335,
-0.6644428372,
-0.1912911236,
-0.1906336993,
-0.2497566938,
0.5799219012,
-0.3268799484,
0.0364544541,
-0.5219393373,
-0.6770037413,
-0.1698503643,
-0.6343984604,
-0.3513199687,
-0.2867429256,
0.6514181495,
0.2783833742,
0.799705565,
0.5342831016,
0.3785952628,
0.3950266838,
0.5142590404,
0.2569286525,
-0.2988808751,
0.3353470862,
-0.3751567602,
-0.4199154973,
-0.8260400891,
-0.1476220638,
0.5331954956,
0.6902745962,
0.003491739,
0.1771829277,
-0.0804774985,
0.275026083,
-0.5960074067,
0.3887228072,
0.14804627,
0.1308168322,
0.0686950162,
0.1941094548,
-0.1229579598,
-0.1493967474,
-0.1755606085,
-0.7572799921,
0.140811339,
-0.0916927606,
0.3654959202,
0.3993420303,
-0.1866678745,
0.1350071281,
-0.796720922,
0.5023204088,
-0.5551541448,
0.7955530286,
-0.0568190068,
0.5060828328,
-0.0072346423,
-1.0330559015,
-0.615188241,
-0.3655927181,
0.1484832913,
-0.0963578969,
0.0517753847,
0.3575192392,
0.1534079313,
0.0718772411,
-0.5404958725,
0.1329019666,
-0.1551562101,
-0.0338958725,
0.3631285727,
0.2456184924,
0.672288835,
0.222492218,
-0.5743278265,
-0.3796975017,
-0.6149845719,
-0.1372017115,
0.1840968877,
0.5456654429,
-0.448009342,
0.9873076677,
-0.1223794445,
0.5126228333,
-0.1989124119,
0.2391595244,
0.0191217642,
-0.1905943751,
-0.0440796241,
-0.1129829958,
0.7211627364,
0.23952277,
-0.1309457272,
-0.2826915085,
-0.4765630662,
0.1111877337,
0.285741061,
-0.853048265,
-0.0834155083,
0.534445703,
-0.3792760372,
-0.2265770733,
0.1247285306,
-0.9062683582,
-0.8221908808,
-0.5047104359,
0.4971752167,
-0.1005057469,
-0.5317284465,
0.2467887551,
-0.15095447,
0.4719805717,
0.4265003502,
-0.6638374329,
0.4029559195,
0.7454057932,
1.1100465059,
-0.1485667527,
-0.5217682719,
-0.5816519856,
0.2406752557,
-0.4045683742,
0.550250113,
-0.5767221451,
-0.3782583177,
-0.031582091,
0.018416727,
0.1296075583,
-0.1963275373,
0.3946582675,
-0.2845826745,
0.0736817345,
-0.2884629965,
-0.1749016345,
0.0764937103,
0.2449189425,
-0.9530641437,
0.7601626515,
0.2945253849,
-0.7514603734,
0.5078496933,
-1.0628238916,
-0.0742951855,
0.2243721485,
-0.4952272475,
-0.0612195283,
0.1580332816,
0.0805449858,
0.416369915,
-0.1237371862,
0.0443584882,
-0.2210892588,
-0.5704473853,
0.06207899,
-0.1762011349,
0.4548983574,
0.0134718912,
-0.6435974836,
0.5612691045,
-0.7279811502,
-0.1587929875,
0.1682706028,
-0.1577302516,
-0.3053874075,
0.0794621706,
0.1574676931,
0.1312922239,
0.5192449689,
-0.7566785812,
0.3591100872,
-0.4784849584,
0.341439724,
0.6585476398,
-0.3524963558,
0.5979592204,
-0.2061569691,
0.596380651,
-0.2090296,
-0.0047723418,
-0.0493723787,
-0.257717222,
-0.8945777416,
-0.4692086279,
-0.0752300695,
0.1024038047,
-1.28370893,
0.0056957421,
-0.4984892309,
-0.4318877757,
-0.4765644372,
-0.1216972023,
0.42065534,
0.0056443647,
0.1080537066,
-0.1317900568,
-0.2939723432,
-0.8042433858,
0.2037961483,
-0.3355890512,
-0.3334334493,
0.321688503,
0.6569373608,
-0.3571098745,
0.9944481254,
-0.179088667,
0.1727262884,
-0.1711273044,
0.0042681871,
-0.1023096293,
0.5038375854,
0.6748399734,
-0.7916962504,
-0.0746442378,
0.5029360056,
-1.2562856674,
0.1234853491,
0.1233717427,
-0.2252250612,
-0.0765773207,
0.2688147128,
-1.0203546286,
0.2143558711,
0.8140999079,
-0.5023483038,
0.5900479555,
-0.4366204143,
0.2099529207,
-0.9591929913,
0.3739096522,
-0.3782941103,
-0.3224085569,
-0.7829244137,
0.6521248221,
-0.1100510359,
-0.5863003135,
-0.7680855393,
1.043956399,
-0.546844542,
-0.554618001,
-0.3650778234,
0.2380632609,
0.1464672238,
0.5154040456,
0.3279691637,
0.9130049348,
0.6446920633,
-0.645231545,
0.6420388222,
0.4150179625,
-0.0475628003,
0.5617552996,
-0.9662560821,
0.4587582946,
0.1087793186,
0.2878453135,
-0.558190465,
-0.579430759,
0.5178842545,
-0.1949664354,
0.0559350848,
0.1574738622,
-0.5083302855,
-0.4241796136,
-0.2479040623,
0.7394115925,
0.172490567,
-0.988317132,
0.9052817225,
0.2513564825,
0.048060365,
-0.4962099791,
-0.6813364029,
0.2919379771,
-0.0466497652,
-0.641232729,
-0.0641446486,
0.1423278302,
-0.5348127484,
-0.2166458219,
-0.161266908,
-0.0380242169,
-0.3052702844,
0.3972743452,
0.0716158152,
-0.4522295296,
0.0666604936,
-0.0155925713,
-0.1025305614,
0.2004310191,
-0.5649798512,
0.4366915822,
-0.3528939188,
-0.9376674294,
-0.2000686377,
0.3226777017,
1.1300703287,
-0.2797680199,
0.5369752645,
0.4669502079,
-0.4482476115,
-0.236848101,
-0.2810925245,
-0.1376214772,
-0.5066268444,
0.1983774602,
-0.5212640762,
-0.815195024,
0.4798510671,
-0.0880403519,
0.2139998525,
-0.1088756397,
0.4882601202,
0.1402138919,
0.9238298535,
0.7976127863,
0.3152443469,
0.2054156661,
-0.2719577551,
0.015582338,
-0.7295200825,
-0.3691084981,
-0.3021828234,
-0.4914058447,
-0.4243732989,
-1.1471251249,
0.2645454109,
-0.2595538795,
-0.3126469254,
0.4955611229,
-0.6878026724,
0.1722494066,
0.5725313425,
0.3363015652,
0.1183468029,
-0.30248034,
-0.2244906127,
0.1005534902,
-0.5358046889,
-0.7900642753,
0.8763849735,
0.4800110161,
0.7373672128,
0.1998375803,
0.5484042168,
0.3713485301,
0.2051893622,
-0.5779301524,
0.8410655856,
0.2356742322,
-0.4849842489,
-0.3619813323,
-0.0731734857,
-0.8123323321,
0.6658633947,
-0.1257925034,
-0.7121010423,
0.519438982,
-0.076976411,
-0.0136560909,
0.6233803034,
-0.3433576524,
0.8296150565,
-0.4830240309,
-0.7709780931,
-0.1132044494,
-0.6484134793,
0.2980456352,
0.0324358605,
0.0566468649,
-0.0835004002,
-0.6058121324,
0.3245361149,
-0.533336997,
1.1160219908,
-0.513777256,
-0.4483208358,
0.3898243308,
0.1899369359,
0.592125535,
-0.0011474985,
0.0556859784,
0.362229377,
-0.1233131811,
-0.6349177361,
-0.5220264792,
0.7116994858,
-0.7351437807,
-0.2344945967,
-0.2815567553,
-0.4934284091,
-0.469735086,
0.1626353115,
-0.1983922124,
0.3185237646,
-0.7973464131,
0.1917888522,
0.5710719228,
-0.3789387047,
0.2594295144,
0.5338589549,
-0.5395798087,
-0.3784664273,
1.0214030743,
-0.6025055647,
0.1393750608,
0.424310565,
0.1051503122,
-0.3154173493,
-0.1877050549,
-0.704895854,
0.2734196186,
-0.5520089269,
0.0486910753,
-0.658744216,
-0.069600746,
-0.0833041221,
-0.4785716236,
-0.5064915419,
-0.2431659251,
-0.1752789319,
-0.3808784187,
0.1197596714,
0.9725306034,
-0.25513345,
0.1922979951,
-0.8353924155,
0.6010510921,
0.3975373805,
0.4740193188,
-0.1355025768,
0.1714922339,
-0.1714157164,
0.4073946476,
0.0944774076,
-0.4758120477,
0.1534783542,
0.0476491079,
0.6324385405,
0.6164326072,
-0.0257459786,
0.3123134375,
-0.2835633159,
0.982252717,
0.434235096,
-0.6627025008,
0.3319887519,
-0.8250904679,
0.2123488933,
0.2005927116,
0.1129701063,
-0.3491460979,
-0.4651643336,
-0.3769488633,
-0.5618153214,
0.5620930791,
0.289444834,
0.3567556143,
0.0533136502,
0.1509513408,
0.4243940711,
0.4949557483,
-0.5956279039,
0.2115239948,
-0.431409359,
-0.0608283617,
-0.0992648974,
-0.0455689132,
-0.2232831419,
-0.1173427626,
0.0781484917,
-0.3792426288,
0.3749061823,
0.1525992602,
-0.0280101001,
-0.0273952708,
-0.0063137976,
0.6399182081,
0.6429524422,
0.0734815374,
0.0810879841,
-0.0070696995,
-0.4296526909,
0.2547779977,
-0.0639993921,
-0.025079608,
-0.0486331359,
0.4570399225,
1.009706974,
0.5665535331,
-0.9818285108,
0.5384399891,
0.0837278441,
-0.3841675222,
-0.0865371004,
0.0241404139,
0.1940069348,
0.6531549692,
-0.0260061044,
-0.0734538361,
0.0573770404,
-0.3989916444,
0.2690187097,
0.3047808707,
-0.6912622452,
-0.6351162791,
1.2070219517,
0.6127842069,
-0.2043908685,
0.3849473596,
0.2973463237,
-0.0822542533,
0.5499690771,
0.3054350317,
1.1314576864,
-0.0759077817,
0.4715064466,
0.1459433138,
0.1587002277,
-0.1937170774,
0.2861388028,
-0.2018062174,
-0.6722742319,
-0.2479637414,
-0.8175322413,
-0.6293122172,
-0.263448745,
-0.3783656061,
0.2149749547,
-0.356115222,
-0.059821073,
-0.5573041439,
-0.32747823,
-0.5804962516,
-0.1233244166,
0.2936153114,
0.8600264192,
-0.7069072127,
0.6213107705,
1.0422985554,
-0.7316461802,
-0.3154114187,
-0.1105334833,
-0.1061617956,
-0.6962859035,
0.411837399,
0.0977954641,
-0.4574745297,
-0.0463028885,
-0.5984241366,
-0.5879853368,
1.2388744354,
0.6800763607,
-0.2672681212,
-0.4037770331,
0.5161099434,
0.7692248821,
-0.3674537539,
0.1426074356,
0.261659503,
0.7106975913,
0.2176131457,
-0.8034318089,
0.0585854314,
-0.1280010194,
-0.0990944952,
0.2565375268,
-0.8439018726,
0.8938340545,
-0.2445467263,
-0.1399279684,
0.3716923296,
0.678171277,
0.397636503,
0.4321698844,
0.3417000473,
0.3638785779,
0.4887880087,
-0.1008188203,
0.9212847948,
-0.2412282676,
0.0240478646,
0.8959472179,
-0.618696034,
0.7839142084,
0.2704009712,
-0.005543449,
0.4352865815,
0.2008214146,
0.2788848579,
0.1629583538,
0.1100246161,
-0.6095660925,
-0.2022860944,
-0.1346037239,
-0.1328687668,
0.670145154,
0.244153589,
0.0901723206,
-0.25357306,
0.4294781089,
-0.3638426661,
0.2448218465,
-0.2171649486,
0.5970975161,
0.122741513,
-0.1447882205,
0.2001062185,
-0.3320201337,
0.3442712426,
-0.5684930086,
-0.5718983412,
-0.2137839794,
0.1187030748,
0.0585201159,
-0.5276612043,
-0.0288443007,
-0.1415238827,
0.2947864234,
-0.3785438836,
0.8766151667,
-0.3023183346,
-0.2591089606,
0.4356045723,
0.9814284444,
0.3278248608,
-0.2517336309,
-0.4757886827,
0.2038255483,
-0.4826158583,
-0.3128809929,
0.3650148213,
0.6249116063,
-0.2306491733,
0.9187809825,
0.5774669051,
-0.0548617393,
-0.1734201312,
-0.0930705443,
1.0472359657,
-0.6586418748,
-0.4133537114,
-0.3350287974,
0.6922701597,
-0.1124499068,
0.044017382,
0.5343479514,
0.7049215436,
0.4255076349,
-0.1594736576,
0.7742572427,
-0.2631726563,
0.2582219839,
-0.3157797754,
0.931540966,
-0.4829143286,
-0.0348339044,
-0.0888395011,
-1.1873896122,
-0.1263732165,
0.3666422367,
0.1638575792,
0.0770394877,
0.6273160577,
0.5599571466,
-0.4205606878,
-0.2779089808,
0.7676684856,
0.031847138,
0.4094033837,
0.3272617757,
0.8881012797,
-0.1044788286,
0.3151028454,
0.0783000886,
-0.2111202776,
-0.1681699902,
-0.6242854595,
-0.8976572156,
-0.6473095417,
-0.0945957229,
-0.0222881753,
0.3043182492,
0.6805276871,
0.6083343029,
-0.6178313494,
-0.4022938311,
-0.3047404587,
-0.2246159464,
-0.2501803637,
-0.1785908937,
0.1418905109,
-0.0546815917,
-1.0112087727,
0.7858130336,
0.3505919576,
0.0392412059,
-0.79589504,
-0.3098567724,
0.1743215173,
0.0959962457,
0.6958585978,
0.5631695986,
-0.6923618913,
-0.6335064769,
-0.0087890234,
-0.2844336033,
-0.1027286425,
1.0307282209,
-0.8740724325,
0.6648933887,
0.3919679224,
0.5366514325,
0.3636927009,
0.1921173036,
1.033088088,
-0.6987416744,
0.4994088411,
0.3547712266,
0.298310101,
0.2453291118,
-0.0553620942,
0.7679511309,
0.0683499351,
-0.4010266364,
-0.7944908738,
0.0761017799,
-1.0182418823,
-0.2426487952,
1.1569452286,
-0.1058852151,
-0.274792999,
0.0067271907,
-0.4335844517,
0.0964180678,
-0.1032031775,
0.3531451225,
0.4382545054,
-0.1338261813,
-0.175182417,
-0.7589100003,
0.1349571943,
-0.3207495809,
-0.9095512033,
0.2399166971,
0.9495337605,
-0.0685199872,
0.1350487173,
0.6394810081,
0.027024176,
0.2549477816,
0.6614119411,
0.6873965263,
-0.3286487162,
-0.4830596149,
-0.0821014568,
0.2116066962,
0.2017514259,
-0.4805192351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18239v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18239v4
|
SOUL: Unlocking the Power of Second-Order Optimization for LLM Unlearning
| 2024-04-28T16:31:32 | 2024-06-24T20:24:53 |
Jinghan Jia, Yihua Zhang, Yimeng Zhang, Jiancheng Liu, Bharat Runwal, James Diffenderfer, Bhavya Kailkhura, Sijia Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have highlighted the necessity of effective
unlearning mechanisms to comply with data regulations and ethical AI practices.
LLM unlearning aims at removing undesired data influences and associated model
capabilities without compromising utility beyond the scope of unlearning. While
interest in studying LLM unlearning is growing, the impact of the optimizer
choice for LLM unlearning remains unexplored. In this work, we shed light on
the significance of optimizer selection in LLM unlearning for the first time,
establishing a clear connection between second-order optimization and influence
unlearning (a classical approach using influence functions to update the model
for data influence removal). This insight propels us to develop a second-order
optimization-based LLM unlearning framework, termed Second-Order UnLearning
(SOUL), which extends the static, one-shot model update using influence
unlearning to a dynamic, iterative unlearning process. Our extensive
experiments show that SOUL consistently outperforms conventional first-order
methods across various unlearning tasks, models, and metrics, indicating that
second-order optimization offers an effective and broadly applicable solution
for LLM unlearning. Codes are available at https://github.com/OPTML-Group/SOUL.
|
[
-0.1338247955,
-0.3367221951,
0.4871049821,
-0.1200336367,
-0.6513822675,
0.3060879111,
-0.4588251114,
-0.2347847968,
-0.4500314593,
0.7315022349,
-0.7692489624,
-0.4437976778,
-0.7516000867,
-0.4134970307,
-0.1044391096,
0.9555755854,
0.3313871622,
0.5775123835,
-0.236302644,
-0.0817498565,
-0.2248574048,
-0.325753808,
-0.9110609889,
-0.7761554718,
0.2562110126,
0.5688945651,
0.3596309125,
0.5049445629,
0.4008261263,
0.2221056819,
-0.1287338436,
0.2599944174,
-0.8798772097,
0.2198627889,
-0.1838662922,
-0.6851521134,
-0.2818850577,
-0.0095289657,
0.2623182833,
0.6664953232,
-0.1007609218,
0.3510046303,
0.0258863922,
1.2338019609,
-0.7233433723,
0.0889211595,
-1.0497709513,
0.1153429821,
-0.1131973639,
-0.3021198213,
-0.503603816,
-0.1531998664,
0.0482119396,
-0.3747187555,
-0.0971061662,
-0.1796435863,
0.2079394609,
0.9766736031,
-0.1984935701,
-0.2700098455,
-0.6416937113,
1.0615311861,
-0.4605279565,
0.6257193685,
0.2592559457,
0.1919234097,
-0.1101797298,
-0.7449811697,
-0.350672245,
0.3580336273,
0.2517717779,
0.302606076,
-0.0811672062,
0.1658130437,
-0.0101516899,
0.171998933,
-0.2314751297,
0.4550894797,
-0.4118783176,
0.0216662399,
0.6758277416,
-0.0044592042,
0.0443424471,
-0.0508501045,
-0.1798054129,
-0.0058221971,
-0.7007128,
0.1917073429,
0.275752455,
-0.0317086242,
0.3129618168,
0.5034364462,
0.0470232926,
0.3220732808,
0.0293878671,
-0.2876320481,
0.09111467,
0.2553265095,
-0.0539847091,
0.034109287,
0.4885442257,
0.6213030815,
0.5236251354,
-0.4470211864,
-0.3577646911,
-0.0305776168,
0.4433159828,
-0.9411394,
0.028459182,
0.2408988625,
-0.6252274513,
-0.3775081635,
0.0126522649,
-0.8567860126,
-0.4102866352,
-0.4773970544,
0.2779756188,
-0.2088636905,
-0.1673678458,
0.0440415405,
0.0437627286,
0.3716760278,
0.1176517457,
-0.8342882395,
0.2126375586,
1.0059874058,
0.6665107608,
-0.1853945851,
-0.086083889,
-0.3167537749,
-0.1032594293,
-0.2985022068,
0.3442035019,
-0.5835468769,
-0.7572801113,
-0.2253048271,
-0.1537298262,
0.2746100426,
-0.5653114319,
0.7326781154,
-0.7600668073,
-0.0746438056,
-0.3396572471,
-0.6158055067,
-0.3618569076,
-0.517387569,
-0.0677028,
0.9675861597,
0.2209400833,
-0.3885202408,
0.4629986286,
-0.4722953141,
-0.4397732019,
-0.0097993072,
-0.1961748749,
-0.457888931,
0.6663738489,
-0.2999608219,
0.4620791078,
-0.2642577291,
0.2694101036,
-0.2309810668,
-0.4418472052,
-0.0294192228,
-0.5320650339,
0.6984514594,
0.2603057027,
-0.5221631527,
-0.0871761367,
-0.6612263322,
0.2634008229,
0.3036237359,
-0.3207522035,
-0.4785421491,
0.3228719831,
-0.0837136284,
0.1391162723,
0.2471020818,
-0.3433588445,
0.1581854075,
-0.6068150997,
0.5005460978,
0.9507862926,
0.0383761898,
0.665240407,
0.0611006804,
0.1621852517,
-0.391153723,
0.1905986518,
0.2177733332,
-0.1410571933,
-0.7425579429,
0.1351860613,
0.0339313895,
0.5490593314,
-0.1917482913,
0.2132217288,
-0.1080479845,
-0.5727693439,
-0.8993282914,
0.5050816536,
0.8585212827,
0.474350363,
0.423017323,
-0.1043282822,
-0.7188176513,
-0.8764399886,
-0.5126994252,
-0.1016085446,
0.1931935996,
0.2497209311,
0.4345666766,
-0.4018903673,
0.9190686941,
-0.4923194051,
-0.1499811858,
-0.2842767239,
-0.1595061123,
0.2033973634,
0.3813852072,
0.3346676826,
-0.8883647323,
-0.4423477948,
-0.0280579086,
-0.7919373512,
-0.2579244077,
0.0188510418,
-0.3257175088,
0.3227438331,
0.4950276315,
-0.2990622818,
0.4629344046,
0.2168079019,
0.1002470627,
0.4293414354,
-0.2898683846,
-0.3191969097,
-1.0328460932,
0.0006376139,
-0.3698113263,
-0.0240007602,
-0.7426277399,
0.0386034474,
0.0143259056,
0.0697764233,
-0.3430451453,
0.5921066999,
-0.6599482894,
-0.3799164593,
-0.6521242261,
0.1479335874,
-0.1985003352,
0.6924228072,
0.1088472009,
0.7872155905,
0.3834932745,
-0.5832383633,
-0.1809509397,
0.3100565374,
-0.1916312277,
0.3546375036,
-0.6960234046,
0.5305473208,
-0.2899289727,
-0.165043965,
-0.5536577106,
0.1856743842,
-0.0942220613,
-0.4204326868,
0.4738384187,
-0.3793419302,
-0.3985978663,
-0.1279386133,
-0.1517351121,
0.1454472393,
0.7923648357,
-0.706913352,
0.5174816251,
0.621001482,
0.3138847649,
-0.8338194489,
-0.5613111854,
-0.1195972264,
-0.1565880626,
-0.3920296431,
0.3631219268,
-0.3859466314,
-0.5072554946,
-0.3073196411,
-0.6255756617,
0.168532595,
0.4206630588,
0.4630553722,
0.0714963302,
0.2339269072,
-0.0669799596,
0.3636811078,
-0.4890466928,
0.3533543348,
-0.5300798416,
0.6529592872,
0.0497695804,
-0.2577124238,
-0.2470990866,
0.1074914336,
0.7989755273,
-0.3239729702,
0.7151640058,
0.6455966234,
-0.3380684853,
-0.5400760174,
-0.4248735011,
-0.303506732,
-0.5299209952,
0.6237281561,
-0.2818421125,
-0.5724977255,
0.2470284551,
-0.2410300076,
0.5615486503,
-0.0531961098,
0.5482516885,
-0.0268148854,
1.0990864038,
0.6229350567,
-0.1851680726,
0.4093405008,
-0.4297753572,
0.1424213052,
-1.2208321095,
-0.5418238044,
-0.1465388536,
-0.3805194497,
-0.4313822091,
-0.1725486368,
0.377430737,
0.5710621476,
-0.0741765797,
-0.0487742238,
-0.4654498696,
0.8813077807,
0.4863925576,
0.2589533925,
0.2273747027,
0.0135926763,
-0.0214557797,
0.025515981,
-0.1510666013,
-0.5498402715,
1.4277005196,
0.075940907,
0.4987352192,
0.2385462373,
0.7147881985,
0.0850111619,
0.1399284601,
-0.9531146288,
0.5651242733,
-0.6433753967,
-0.2290671319,
-0.0482414663,
-0.1841831654,
-0.7577410936,
0.5096399188,
-0.029534677,
-0.8130744696,
-0.16297324,
0.04173664,
-0.3084226549,
0.3474270105,
-0.4679173529,
0.5952270031,
-0.5284819603,
-0.6180604696,
-0.4678089321,
-0.8761790395,
0.2471923381,
-0.3205842674,
0.1460511386,
0.0524603389,
-0.1809495986,
0.7755479813,
-0.4471668899,
0.6650947332,
-0.426555872,
-0.1814202964,
0.1293499023,
0.221134007,
0.6071664691,
0.2931582332,
-0.1887525618,
0.012132654,
-0.3140688241,
-0.1308897734,
-0.6276295185,
0.4441085458,
-0.9202595353,
-0.7113878131,
0.1071168482,
-0.1861949563,
-0.4497469366,
0.3718888164,
0.5203108191,
0.4040743113,
0.0292286538,
0.2546440065,
0.829082191,
0.0582349934,
0.5926175714,
0.7773992419,
-0.1626015157,
-0.337356329,
1.050229907,
-0.0975789949,
0.419708848,
0.3344765604,
0.3346768022,
-0.244662568,
-0.8494870067,
-0.1799025685,
0.3220950961,
-0.7423785329,
0.0214424264,
-0.8407245874,
-0.0235682447,
-0.2580309212,
-0.3844646513,
-0.4792242646,
-0.1002452597,
-0.5840016007,
-0.1464836746,
-0.0802430809,
0.6094514728,
-0.1709441841,
0.3974127173,
-0.6135179996,
0.1361600608,
0.1630437821,
0.1128953919,
0.0226572622,
-0.6718894839,
-0.1579810679,
-0.0050135693,
-0.1491720825,
-0.9028583765,
0.2610424161,
0.1180162877,
0.6701549292,
0.8166998625,
-0.1135942042,
0.6257554889,
-0.5093261003,
0.3339917362,
0.0214774627,
-0.95924896,
0.483599931,
-0.1839023232,
0.16005826,
0.9751038551,
0.0208996516,
-0.606690228,
0.0689597875,
-0.5455930829,
-0.939665854,
0.7795757651,
-0.0625103414,
-0.1179829016,
0.4512148201,
0.8764097095,
0.3211278915,
0.6854845285,
-0.2801793814,
-0.6584132314,
-0.0491259582,
-0.1342246681,
-0.3045520782,
-0.3017446399,
0.3016409576,
-0.2186840326,
0.8950660825,
-0.1861200035,
0.023261806,
-0.1389222443,
-0.4365845621,
-0.2644042969,
0.1620077193,
0.4607724547,
0.5198155642,
-0.0222757626,
-0.0547791384,
0.2515557706,
-0.6134806871,
-0.0527484864,
-0.4423909783,
-0.5061033964,
-0.4184740782,
0.0581926331,
0.8472306728,
0.3494733274,
-0.6985601783,
0.2936019599,
0.1308777928,
0.0024740868,
-0.5469861031,
0.3487397134,
-0.2025232613,
0.4085965753,
0.4806323946,
0.2618226707,
0.2229022384,
-0.4219220877,
0.3270900249,
0.8520013094,
-0.4271532297,
-0.424046278,
0.627045691,
0.0716013014,
-0.3523472846,
0.532679081,
-0.2130683511,
-0.9844170809,
0.4772053659,
0.4311028719,
1.0247380733,
-0.1360378265,
0.1277976036,
0.1443304718,
0.4362436533,
-0.1865032613,
0.2463244796,
-0.0969451964,
-0.7119731307,
-0.1072091237,
-0.787330091,
-0.3475316763,
0.2593342662,
-0.8931394219,
0.0633724481,
-0.6119681001,
0.0664635822,
-0.3651659489,
0.4485720098,
-0.59775877,
0.1864344031,
0.0344632044,
0.5606042147,
-0.3856731057,
0.6466892958,
0.5698723793,
0.0047182068,
-0.5194201469,
0.0370068029,
0.6081849933,
-1.2345569134,
0.7000120282,
0.238255471,
-0.3626940846,
0.393838048,
-0.3623080254,
-0.7312620282,
1.1534224749,
0.3686104119,
-0.7239998579,
0.0009796576,
-0.1005830541,
0.4431231022,
-0.3440883458,
0.4311704338,
0.7085276246,
0.4193104804,
0.0187356174,
-0.2778719664,
-0.2503764927,
-0.1413375288,
-0.1104269624,
0.501383841,
-1.0113333464,
0.4718474746,
-0.7788100839,
-0.2896385491,
-0.0515363365,
0.6725329757,
0.0184594765,
0.3227658868,
0.5458344221,
0.4731379449,
0.8680671453,
0.0282533746,
0.4462560117,
-0.5434505343,
0.2943569422,
1.0368833542,
-0.338454634,
0.738297224,
0.6532030106,
-0.1697750539,
0.2278828323,
0.7952741385,
0.0126369186,
0.7073673606,
0.2861174643,
-0.1864458025,
-0.2802039087,
-0.0247419886,
-0.1083565354,
0.5591977239,
0.2224281728,
-0.2667864263,
-0.0867778435,
-0.0009642006,
0.3130420148,
-0.2202825099,
-0.2836525142,
1.0109243393,
0.1711424142,
-0.5867035389,
0.3789861798,
-0.0452154092,
0.6636024714,
-0.5383957028,
0.181493178,
-0.3574829102,
0.5257934928,
-0.3108379245,
-0.3939872086,
0.074024789,
0.1310327053,
-0.1934608519,
-0.3121748269,
0.6391173005,
-0.3834859431,
-0.1734714657,
0.7087548375,
0.5264434218,
0.2043160349,
0.0484741703,
-0.7807371616,
-0.1504574418,
0.146652922,
-0.5282075405,
0.4843732417,
0.1672408134,
0.3891116977,
0.7875581384,
0.8522437811,
0.0661031306,
-0.181568861,
0.1200766712,
0.6055131555,
-0.3218367398,
-0.1646769196,
-1.0243040323,
0.4847105443,
0.0984371081,
-0.3197153211,
0.6182972193,
0.5967335701,
0.9925823212,
0.2911750972,
0.879509151,
0.2159737498,
0.2164486349,
-0.779030025,
0.8159754872,
-0.9628300071,
0.4243464172,
-0.0161321461,
-1.018016696,
0.0916196778,
0.3085315526,
-0.0662259758,
0.2159670591,
0.6523054242,
0.7810664177,
0.14391689,
0.2061597854,
0.496158123,
0.0917180553,
0.0379080437,
0.475414902,
0.3838197887,
-0.1133357435,
0.2282527089,
-0.5298790336,
-0.2149351984,
-0.014711991,
-0.4630411267,
-1.2075968981,
-0.5391122699,
0.0627390966,
-0.30746454,
0.2113150507,
1.2296417952,
0.4264804721,
-0.5808920264,
-0.2393954843,
-0.3277854919,
0.0365536511,
-0.0534979366,
-0.1739898771,
0.3046034276,
-0.3320574164,
-0.8496933579,
0.7384044528,
0.2655718923,
-0.0560068004,
-0.4146276712,
-0.3266212046,
0.28118065,
0.0383863188,
0.5725397468,
0.1523031592,
-0.8140390515,
0.137490049,
0.1688279361,
0.0803107694,
-0.0589466654,
1.0977549553,
-0.5618287325,
0.1945802569,
0.258040309,
0.8994564414,
0.2659590542,
-0.0026858815,
0.2597710192,
-0.7008468509,
-0.208382234,
-0.0128169945,
0.3693843186,
-0.0081429174,
-0.5436745286,
0.7549700141,
0.3299142122,
-0.6156123281,
-1.0187184811,
0.3394699991,
-0.601242125,
-0.4761628807,
1.2787618637,
0.2263058722,
-0.3488597572,
0.0235874988,
-0.1477290839,
0.4481634498,
-0.5517079234,
0.5253169537,
0.3405501544,
-0.1110955402,
-0.2460023165,
-0.5076026917,
0.6028273702,
0.8217039704,
-0.8396404982,
0.389516294,
0.299036622,
0.1838996559,
-0.1266559958,
0.4585499465,
-0.0503232032,
0.0567466766,
-0.4662927389,
-0.1304436028,
-0.3118117154,
-0.6207888722,
-0.458442241,
-0.0781930909,
-0.1301335096,
0.1245540455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18231v1
|
From Persona to Personalization: A Survey on Role-Playing Language Agents
| 2024-04-28T15:56:41 | 2024-04-28T15:56:41 |
Jiangjie Chen, Xintao Wang, Rui Xu, Siyu Yuan, Yikai Zhang, Wei Shi, Jian Xie, Shuang Li, Ruihan Yang, Tinghui Zhu, Aili Chen, Nianqi Li, Lida Chen, Caiyu Hu, Siye Wu, Scott Ren, Ziquan Fu, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
boosted the rise of Role-Playing Language Agents (RPLAs), i.e., specialized AI
systems designed to simulate assigned personas. By harnessing multiple advanced
abilities of LLMs, including in-context learning, instruction following, and
social intelligence, RPLAs achieve a remarkable sense of human likeness and
vivid role-playing performance. RPLAs can mimic a wide range of personas,
ranging from historical figures and fictional characters to real-life
individuals. Consequently, they have catalyzed numerous AI applications, such
as emotional companions, interactive video games, personalized assistants and
copilots, and digital clones. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive survey
of this field, illustrating the evolution and recent progress in RPLAs
integrating with cutting-edge LLM technologies. We categorize personas into
three types: 1) Demographic Persona, which leverages statistical stereotypes;
2) Character Persona, focused on well-established figures; and 3)
Individualized Persona, customized through ongoing user interactions for
personalized services. We begin by presenting a comprehensive overview of
current methodologies for RPLAs, followed by the details for each persona type,
covering corresponding data sourcing, agent construction, and evaluation.
Afterward, we discuss the fundamental risks, existing limitations, and future
prospects of RPLAs. Additionally, we provide a brief review of RPLAs in AI
applications, which reflects practical user demands that shape and drive RPLA
research. Through this work, we aim to establish a clear taxonomy of RPLA
research and applications, and facilitate future research in this critical and
ever-evolving field, and pave the way for a future where humans and RPLAs
coexist in harmony.
|
[
-0.4481497407,
-0.8209394217,
0.5687589645,
0.3889601231,
0.3393170834,
0.5133450031,
-0.1400483251,
-0.5225018263,
0.4385884106,
0.7888863087,
-0.5855258107,
-0.1739477813,
-0.2661287487,
-0.0131259952,
-0.0164806508,
0.6343445778,
0.4773948491,
0.0625254363,
-0.3520447612,
-0.014467909,
-0.6286551356,
-0.8503164649,
-0.7985695601,
-0.5782689452,
0.800336957,
0.3818462491,
0.5957697034,
0.6429558992,
0.2422589213,
0.4158575237,
0.1885710359,
0.0839417726,
-0.2054338604,
0.5352470279,
-0.1944877207,
-0.5185053349,
-0.6071379781,
0.1774971783,
0.5258297324,
0.6340376139,
0.0612750165,
0.0419758372,
-0.2769885063,
0.5194587708,
-0.2851261497,
0.3364792764,
-0.1967895329,
0.1597299427,
-0.3121854067,
-0.3514922261,
-0.5033800006,
-0.2951464951,
0.1803432554,
-0.5312276483,
-0.0193514936,
-0.0132035958,
0.2497773021,
0.1191206276,
-0.5184749961,
-0.3224428594,
-1.1032598019,
0.8273261189,
-0.4551998675,
0.2617024481,
0.3284800947,
0.5251989365,
-0.2962735295,
-0.6301857233,
-0.2367946953,
-0.5529569983,
-0.104390204,
0.0895505473,
0.0189507939,
-0.0548612699,
0.1675221175,
0.1147340983,
-0.5148556232,
0.3491396904,
-0.0209013354,
-0.025930319,
0.7921726704,
0.193004176,
0.7577397823,
0.3024140596,
-0.0985709429,
-0.1896885782,
-0.6950672269,
0.1849194318,
0.572209239,
0.1474544406,
-0.0276780948,
0.4428500831,
-0.1398324221,
0.4656612575,
-0.0154259512,
-0.4182724357,
0.1145902202,
0.0991407186,
-0.0115805259,
-0.2842481136,
0.7494703531,
0.0234761443,
0.6509360671,
-0.1925582439,
-0.0515050776,
-0.2574800849,
0.2721069157,
-0.4045747519,
-0.1627459377,
0.2133525461,
-0.5597759485,
-0.2373278588,
-0.1027217507,
-1.0215976238,
-0.8381419182,
-0.2760300338,
-0.1009853855,
-0.1592821777,
-0.1722634435,
-0.3977229297,
0.3199063241,
0.4049728811,
0.3500981033,
-0.9969097972,
0.2989658713,
0.8937425017,
0.4664180875,
-0.2195235342,
-0.5978586078,
-0.420440346,
0.1062408313,
-0.2792676389,
1.0085091591,
-0.641035378,
-0.4764983058,
0.3445707262,
-0.2382643223,
-0.016352322,
-0.6606398225,
0.1473849714,
-0.6310511231,
0.2888744771,
-0.1894875765,
-0.3223617971,
0.0999138802,
0.334630996,
-0.5782319903,
0.5860084295,
-0.0767927542,
-0.2420055568,
0.1514646113,
-0.6655012965,
-0.428416729,
0.3828866482,
-0.3215380609,
-0.3422287107,
-0.0232941005,
-0.0929901749,
0.5328034759,
-0.3386447132,
0.2006676495,
-0.1641715467,
-0.2442658842,
0.7124003768,
-0.1627602726,
0.6055297256,
0.246697858,
-0.1512266695,
0.3318172991,
-0.3740567267,
-0.1884222776,
0.1900596619,
-0.1979084015,
-0.142491132,
0.2759592533,
0.0616691485,
0.2488999665,
0.4601901472,
-0.3017737269,
0.2111425549,
-0.1729495674,
0.3915725052,
0.8105012774,
0.055379156,
0.527146399,
-0.3955736756,
0.8585529923,
-0.3283539712,
0.3053222001,
-0.3567250967,
-0.7357263565,
-0.4629004002,
-0.4086157084,
0.0766073167,
0.6661595702,
-0.4362664819,
0.4107559621,
-0.1530708969,
-0.5100788474,
-0.2249386907,
-0.0751152486,
0.2787240744,
0.1587760895,
0.0015224053,
-0.338992089,
-0.3070224524,
-0.9442095757,
-0.4905211329,
-0.5304689407,
0.0051884856,
0.6323615313,
0.082383886,
-0.3568480611,
1.0596467257,
-0.4743744135,
-0.4868247211,
-0.6170322299,
-0.0855364278,
-0.2189050168,
0.365617156,
0.6598635912,
-0.7128948569,
-0.7760394216,
0.1278415769,
-0.6198984385,
-0.3066188693,
-0.362845242,
0.3095594049,
0.0489134789,
0.3908653259,
-0.4398901165,
0.0642547309,
0.4563271403,
-0.3792610168,
0.4212912023,
-0.3287645578,
0.0307648331,
-0.9945085645,
0.2821239829,
0.0128563577,
-0.3806428611,
-1.0166753531,
0.1032208502,
-0.46452263,
-0.1641032696,
-0.2816179693,
0.9159045815,
-0.4226720631,
-0.5359386802,
-0.3824012578,
0.302254498,
-0.4904548526,
0.4515254796,
-0.0209039487,
0.8941217661,
0.4445826411,
-0.3882606328,
0.4445560873,
0.283867687,
0.0068235076,
0.5121596456,
-0.4757447839,
0.3606434762,
-0.1817092896,
0.4291629493,
-0.5836653113,
-0.35815382,
0.4731729329,
-0.278064847,
0.0342112519,
-0.0189686436,
-0.5805775523,
0.0057830531,
-0.2269171476,
0.3362350166,
0.6248635054,
-0.2567383647,
0.9966843724,
0.6731159687,
-0.5389339924,
-0.5357446074,
-0.565613687,
0.366579175,
-0.3702057302,
-0.3044964373,
0.3337737322,
-0.397629112,
-0.584747076,
-0.2694250047,
0.3769224584,
-0.2096521854,
0.2451401949,
0.1870627701,
-0.0703968406,
0.1200054362,
-0.1263645291,
-0.2919587195,
-0.1970608085,
0.0406005718,
0.2117136419,
0.7558408976,
-0.1366146356,
-0.2487214655,
-0.4820620716,
0.3751643598,
0.5116852522,
-0.3352847993,
0.6147815585,
0.5277026296,
-0.0687733591,
-0.2567743957,
-0.5874873996,
-0.0583602078,
-0.4266867042,
0.2072400898,
-0.3967135847,
-0.8306005001,
0.8543570638,
-0.1572818458,
0.228477031,
-0.0370763466,
0.6800628304,
-0.0396964662,
0.8539859653,
0.6759548187,
-0.108200416,
0.894615829,
0.0277245324,
0.3017103672,
-0.550706327,
-0.4786769748,
-0.4435035884,
-0.2798464894,
-0.7791684866,
-0.4309318662,
0.126396358,
-0.5538307428,
-0.0847807154,
0.0937236249,
-0.1016027778,
0.4006226659,
0.5830676556,
-0.3108324409,
0.2680492997,
-0.3250344396,
0.5003839135,
-0.0606430732,
-0.3218494654,
-0.7867975235,
0.9004336596,
0.7094838619,
0.6890497208,
0.3259405792,
0.6911620498,
0.72047925,
0.5906663537,
-0.8070066571,
0.8550875783,
-0.1307599097,
-0.4583863616,
-0.2786313593,
-0.1926144511,
-0.8505706787,
0.2794005871,
-0.0512858108,
-0.7816103697,
0.1694818288,
0.3197159767,
-0.2010866106,
-0.01097418,
-0.4822720885,
0.8215504885,
-0.3869009912,
-0.2628971338,
-0.2556179464,
-0.6940419078,
0.3720754683,
-0.0071841124,
0.2084063739,
-0.0969048589,
-0.2950953543,
0.3625077605,
0.0160295665,
1.0131597519,
-0.2641217113,
-0.2938704193,
0.1620124876,
0.0646190047,
0.4713267386,
0.0320300274,
0.0308322962,
-0.1888015419,
0.0720639825,
-0.3407091498,
-0.5819705129,
0.7796289921,
-0.8568948507,
-0.6110894084,
-0.6430147886,
-0.5553134084,
-0.4892563224,
0.1462458372,
-0.2899645269,
0.0576102138,
-0.8581619859,
0.052478049,
0.8472065926,
-0.5476529002,
0.3369457722,
0.5016725659,
-0.3634124994,
-0.2791790366,
1.1274363995,
-0.1910299808,
0.0524437986,
0.5613073707,
0.2114521861,
-0.2455422431,
-0.3666521311,
-0.1420682073,
0.5011721849,
-0.6069278121,
0.1920366734,
-0.632791698,
-0.0220654476,
-0.6997625232,
-0.1552600414,
-0.2911952138,
-0.0288291387,
-0.4138913751,
0.2085052282,
-0.1059566736,
0.9991746545,
0.2078067511,
0.4348590076,
-0.4238447547,
0.2108830363,
0.677880466,
0.2717383504,
-0.0997083709,
-0.1037139818,
0.0641136914,
-0.2691836953,
-0.0053538857,
-0.8151142597,
0.5040111542,
0.2253189087,
0.8608110547,
0.4100508094,
-0.3437278867,
0.3037434518,
-0.4945584238,
0.9420401454,
-0.306760788,
-0.661765337,
0.2146099955,
-0.4061056376,
-0.0293328278,
0.3314881921,
-0.0492506325,
-0.9289492369,
-0.0848573819,
-0.3864064217,
-0.4406340122,
0.7082676888,
-0.1150490567,
0.3524044156,
0.2880324423,
0.49487257,
0.1124064252,
0.2025914639,
-0.7977113128,
-0.4902975261,
-0.1312378645,
-0.1222101599,
-0.3316552937,
-0.1996081769,
-0.0490342043,
0.3570509553,
0.5987258554,
-0.3739209175,
0.2845421731,
-0.121819742,
0.0177397281,
0.0848683789,
0.3642948568,
0.8821381927,
0.5819979906,
-0.0787320882,
0.021273043,
-0.2439882457,
-0.3567855954,
0.1492014676,
-0.052589234,
-0.3245418668,
-0.4624496996,
0.3419724703,
0.5197800398,
-0.0067848805,
-1.091684103,
0.4315888286,
-0.2635186315,
0.0913335308,
-0.6921448112,
0.0389707312,
0.0200096387,
0.3461873531,
0.2440796345,
-0.1510750651,
-0.0731077567,
-0.9521170259,
0.0338353105,
0.5036943555,
-0.1879389584,
-0.5728749633,
0.4475034475,
0.4150369167,
-0.8481938839,
0.1471997797,
-0.0117918523,
-0.1334775537,
0.5478535295,
0.4814113081,
1.1918865442,
-0.4374862909,
0.5118698478,
-0.3033811748,
0.1830682904,
0.0925053135,
-0.0281810146,
0.0234332923,
-0.7093418241,
-0.0040859892,
-0.3372831643,
-0.6615410447,
0.3308081329,
-0.2133809328,
-0.1039860025,
-0.6837873459,
-0.0369826742,
-0.149151668,
0.2062719017,
-0.5055418611,
0.0441079549,
0.1155519858,
0.606831193,
-0.8224214315,
0.8757256269,
1.1043478251,
-0.3461323082,
-0.1736483127,
0.3517001271,
-0.1372197568,
-0.5159167051,
0.5084095597,
-0.1521596164,
0.0171881337,
0.086692892,
-0.2093108147,
-0.6732188463,
1.2171891928,
0.2410773039,
-0.0454573669,
-0.1170607209,
0.4074755013,
0.9825959802,
-0.8144598603,
0.1914085895,
0.6868335009,
0.4723862112,
-0.1975733787,
-0.4938027263,
-0.234464854,
-0.0827993155,
0.2875334024,
-0.3464872539,
-0.9725710154,
0.6108890772,
0.1744836271,
-0.0597188845,
0.359619379,
0.7593482137,
0.422691673,
0.3362515569,
0.4765997529,
-0.0931548998,
0.3411742747,
0.1144006476,
0.8984729052,
-0.2554250062,
-0.0666114613,
0.928401053,
-0.595769465,
0.540594995,
0.4434622824,
-0.1205694601,
0.589917779,
0.5795601606,
0.068897672,
0.2971742451,
0.1284680218,
-0.3327442408,
-0.2151598036,
-0.3946597874,
0.0137661807,
0.4337657094,
0.3405449986,
-0.3630024493,
0.0841807649,
0.2243915349,
-0.0876004025,
0.5492072701,
-0.0225479025,
0.8828526139,
-0.0341355093,
-0.9640946984,
-0.4234162271,
0.1763343066,
0.5726826787,
-0.7174075246,
-0.0419258364,
-0.4778858721,
0.1201468855,
0.0902955681,
-0.678129375,
0.0739770457,
-0.0295244679,
-0.0239375457,
-0.7855476737,
0.8727261424,
-0.3210039735,
-0.0275671482,
0.2638346553,
0.8174225688,
0.2465383708,
0.2169920504,
-0.7523065805,
0.1726171225,
-0.1522037089,
-0.2711833119,
0.5647900105,
-0.022536654,
-0.1217551529,
1.0780436993,
0.326723516,
0.1773919463,
0.1124710739,
0.2235239744,
0.6374158263,
-0.6373602748,
-0.5270621777,
-0.434923768,
0.2767870426,
0.1812875271,
-0.3256505728,
0.7051990628,
0.4705135524,
0.5622174144,
-0.318767637,
0.7386095524,
-0.0767307878,
0.5227636695,
-0.1455634236,
0.5903677344,
-0.2492358685,
0.2241255641,
-0.1978452951,
-0.8979543447,
-0.2696358562,
0.3514645696,
-0.2133012265,
0.371499449,
0.11483787,
0.6208058,
0.0947757885,
-0.2903696299,
0.5414669514,
0.001304785,
0.8053988814,
0.0663600042,
0.9326514602,
0.0062214225,
0.0813000277,
-0.2775659859,
-0.4470980167,
-0.4575294852,
-0.6490668654,
-0.968313992,
-0.675915122,
-0.3195927739,
0.1385433376,
0.0460066088,
1.0122518539,
0.575099051,
-0.6377373934,
-0.6344159842,
-0.0583806559,
0.2110917717,
-0.3109543025,
-0.2774859071,
-0.1172741205,
-0.2743470073,
-1.1466830969,
0.748603344,
0.2138839662,
0.1002913937,
-0.9930446744,
-0.1012106985,
-0.172161147,
0.3919472098,
0.7089893818,
0.8995119333,
-0.9363245964,
-0.2157634348,
0.0183289964,
-0.1941114962,
-0.1295058727,
1.1931710243,
-0.8830415606,
0.278501451,
0.5674453378,
0.5923189521,
0.1208886728,
0.2079223096,
0.7294136286,
-0.7674000263,
0.1027327329,
0.3982616961,
0.0409517698,
0.3099781275,
-0.4445427954,
0.387837708,
0.1371397972,
-0.7343345284,
-0.8537800312,
0.6041939259,
-1.0165253878,
-0.1955962926,
0.9496815205,
-0.1910200715,
-0.0394601934,
-0.225146234,
-0.2130230814,
-0.0832060054,
-0.4605167508,
0.7693449259,
0.4118321538,
-0.5778040886,
-0.4158182442,
-0.5272142887,
0.6586524248,
0.2699674368,
-1.2235338688,
0.2144238502,
0.5621809959,
0.2816928923,
0.2746112943,
0.8649784923,
0.0792878121,
0.063502878,
-0.4345242977,
0.1443780065,
0.046846319,
-0.4918061793,
-0.4147834778,
0.298032254,
0.4714203775,
0.2505262792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18228v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18228v1
|
TextGram: Towards a better domain-adaptive pretraining
| 2024-04-28T15:44:57 | 2024-04-28T15:44:57 |
Sharayu Hiwarkhedkar, Saloni Mittal, Vidula Magdum, Omkar Dhekane, Raviraj Joshi, Geetanjali Kale, Arnav Ladkat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
For green AI, it is crucial to measure and reduce the carbon footprint
emitted during the training of large language models. In NLP, performing
pre-training on Transformer models requires significant computational
resources. This pre-training involves using a large amount of text data to gain
prior knowledge for performing downstream tasks. Thus, it is important that we
select the correct data in the form of domain-specific data from this vast
corpus to achieve optimum results aligned with our domain-specific tasks. While
training on large unsupervised data is expensive, it can be optimized by
performing a data selection step before pretraining. Selecting important data
reduces the space overhead and the substantial amount of time required to
pre-train the model while maintaining constant accuracy. We investigate the
existing selection strategies and propose our own domain-adaptive data
selection method - TextGram - that effectively selects essential data from
large corpora. We compare and evaluate the results of finetuned models for text
classification task with and without data selection. We show that the proposed
strategy works better compared to other selection methods.
|
[
-0.383498162,
-0.4393879771,
0.3369930387,
-0.0350514613,
-0.2160461992,
0.3003924191,
-0.3841782808,
-0.4389995933,
-0.2032254636,
0.569127202,
-0.4075910747,
-0.4593124986,
-0.7541085482,
0.2193130106,
-0.2280975282,
1.1797282696,
-0.116331771,
-0.0915785357,
-0.3733501136,
-0.0542779751,
-0.6777079105,
-0.4176618755,
-0.8131944537,
-0.5419882536,
0.1733485609,
0.2779578567,
0.5109817386,
0.2238261253,
0.6821055412,
0.3293318152,
0.1496558785,
0.3773237467,
-0.6186949611,
-0.069510214,
-0.3833587468,
-0.4230436683,
-0.2841885388,
0.060993582,
0.3167697787,
0.7374763489,
0.1965167224,
0.1447050422,
0.1530366838,
0.7870231271,
-0.5545047522,
0.1664693058,
-0.9236029983,
0.2383338809,
-0.0676937997,
-0.4097080827,
-0.4640504122,
-0.1397388428,
0.1168593764,
-0.9942800403,
0.3084351122,
0.3639821708,
0.9662581682,
0.4806664586,
-0.0951757282,
-0.3114734292,
-0.8270581961,
0.9574046731,
-0.238461405,
0.4951331913,
0.7446537018,
0.1250393242,
0.2610161304,
-0.7898856997,
-0.4957785904,
-0.0455173962,
-0.1799520254,
0.4179866314,
-0.4197469354,
0.1251306087,
0.1350240856,
0.1339203268,
-0.8121806383,
0.2149254978,
-0.4399603903,
-0.3070135713,
0.5069063306,
-0.0097587565,
0.1749592423,
0.0997351333,
-0.012874498,
-0.3836447001,
-0.3660264611,
-0.3822331727,
0.3481400311,
0.4262058735,
0.1210190654,
0.247743085,
-0.0740068853,
0.810631454,
0.1508796513,
0.1369734854,
0.3660919964,
-0.4751872122,
-0.2984287441,
0.0391474552,
0.5363616347,
0.174079895,
0.5080700517,
-0.1697649807,
-0.0563893579,
0.2001696974,
0.5885064602,
-1.0359122753,
-0.5695857406,
0.3372181952,
-0.5394317508,
-0.0017134486,
-0.1705539078,
-0.8167847991,
0.0060211625,
-0.6308831573,
0.124162443,
-0.5253753662,
-0.0519281849,
0.2758577466,
-0.1471096873,
-0.1661930084,
0.3708639145,
-0.9858677387,
0.3548215032,
0.413808465,
0.8026514649,
-0.4160671234,
-0.1775400192,
-0.4653858542,
0.0243714973,
-0.454367131,
0.999319911,
-0.8355481625,
-0.5831736922,
-0.1783260405,
-0.0674335137,
-0.342602998,
-0.5689963102,
0.5401223302,
-0.7224433422,
0.3363445997,
0.1387612224,
-0.5427707434,
-0.145889312,
0.1805347204,
-0.6739903092,
1.0060886145,
0.4299720824,
-0.9886531234,
0.5971297026,
-0.8952431679,
-0.5138070583,
0.0891493708,
0.0204763729,
-0.5154781938,
-0.2231811881,
0.3022800386,
0.7401759624,
-0.0639746785,
0.0727906153,
0.0080188457,
-0.2834272087,
-0.2667705417,
-0.3315505683,
0.6356732845,
0.5735430717,
-0.1430991143,
0.1671579778,
-0.8716576099,
0.2090351135,
0.0513352528,
-0.3274525702,
-0.563768208,
0.0625680014,
0.3496135771,
-0.1106790081,
-0.003510138,
-0.2542675138,
0.0771840513,
-0.4590955377,
0.3145926297,
0.7168291211,
-0.2176972032,
0.5458368659,
-0.3007212281,
0.6696556211,
-0.1729481816,
-0.1438898593,
0.125629425,
-0.0214269571,
-0.5353972316,
-0.2560415864,
0.6371870637,
0.6597028971,
-0.9265906215,
0.7770297527,
-0.4313618541,
-0.7331572175,
-0.3735823035,
0.0922591537,
0.1027921513,
0.2171225846,
0.610479176,
-0.1859391779,
-0.5582911968,
-0.2828595042,
-0.1337206066,
0.0107385609,
-0.1682718396,
0.4349012971,
0.5108446479,
-0.5993605256,
1.0025662184,
-1.0063238144,
-0.3881533146,
-0.306855619,
0.1197880879,
0.1164296344,
0.4475196302,
0.7265462279,
-1.137093544,
-0.5291919112,
0.2149432003,
-0.4275008142,
-0.0496080481,
-0.3068380356,
-0.3279117048,
0.0045105652,
0.5748177767,
-0.4931682944,
0.3226639628,
0.7619280815,
-0.3227066696,
0.30220294,
-0.4258418977,
0.1517554373,
-0.8581867218,
0.2971445918,
-0.0779553428,
-0.4777582884,
-0.4498918056,
-0.3540989161,
-0.0528295264,
-0.1709436178,
-0.2536934912,
0.6386248469,
-0.4242472947,
0.0613664016,
-0.3822700381,
0.0202652346,
0.0810283944,
0.3664086461,
0.3771015704,
0.8426007032,
0.5385060906,
-0.9184138775,
0.0872110426,
0.7530203462,
-0.396838367,
0.2696111798,
-0.3230574727,
0.398309648,
-0.2161286771,
0.2453696132,
-0.7899632454,
0.075405784,
-0.0298053641,
-0.3909562826,
0.3941064775,
0.3178588152,
-0.2342619747,
-0.3562574089,
0.0322420448,
0.4295717478,
0.507190764,
-0.6068163514,
0.6447253823,
0.5113355517,
-0.2583791018,
-0.1811183989,
-0.5123246312,
-0.1370764375,
-0.2274454087,
-0.0791412517,
0.6329792738,
-0.3243839145,
0.0590127967,
-0.0543488786,
-0.1416158378,
-0.2922112048,
0.2671364844,
-0.0175144896,
0.2448167205,
0.0552471466,
0.1167170256,
-0.0374393128,
-0.3828001618,
-0.2163632959,
-0.4987771511,
0.6728365421,
0.3538948298,
0.0048993961,
-0.3707743287,
0.1511044055,
0.2442862689,
-0.4202606082,
0.4885199368,
0.5876002312,
-0.2869545817,
-0.5821746588,
0.0223716479,
0.0439594537,
-0.501858294,
0.614146769,
-0.053475257,
-0.8716346025,
-0.1832893938,
-0.4421494603,
0.1623030007,
0.4599857032,
0.4087617099,
0.0418632366,
0.7346090078,
0.988761425,
-0.229737252,
0.7629262209,
-0.2034096271,
0.3816811144,
-0.5704039931,
0.0717587173,
-1.0016601086,
0.0996285379,
-0.4494030774,
-0.4973389804,
0.0436514094,
-0.1722732037,
-0.2813662291,
0.4740281403,
-0.9229558706,
0.4549454749,
0.3084515631,
-0.0220077112,
0.0097003141,
0.0839153454,
0.2880854309,
-0.0745553523,
-0.7066660523,
-0.5436223745,
1.1254751682,
0.0234467648,
0.5803825259,
-0.4931801856,
0.2951850891,
0.3830379546,
0.305728972,
-0.7713841796,
0.4033093154,
-0.6079824567,
-0.3658974171,
-0.4201014936,
-0.5304515362,
-1.2699537277,
0.1806670278,
-0.3682695329,
-0.4056497216,
-0.2392460108,
0.2689272761,
-0.5184254646,
0.1686404496,
-0.5857843757,
0.8576350808,
-0.2591894567,
0.1638394743,
-0.3370401561,
-0.4776187241,
-0.3474245369,
-0.7019900084,
0.296539098,
-0.055063948,
0.266225785,
1.0645488501,
-0.1723636985,
0.6151029468,
-0.2955741286,
0.1394997686,
0.2839330733,
-0.1790872514,
0.4785748422,
-0.3400977552,
-0.2178019434,
0.3849938512,
-0.0684805959,
-0.2755116522,
-0.3579520583,
0.1001893133,
-0.8048445582,
-0.3230005801,
-0.3239630461,
-0.3135313392,
-0.5202269554,
0.370228976,
0.5069602728,
0.1464631706,
-0.3331120908,
0.4138656557,
0.5986895561,
-0.3703088462,
0.4541088045,
0.1931512207,
0.0189287625,
-0.2036566585,
0.8188907504,
0.1518736929,
0.2528997064,
0.6876727939,
0.1590212137,
-0.0678519011,
-1.0294274092,
-0.0489997193,
-0.2079913169,
-0.5838603377,
-0.4677149057,
-0.9291735291,
-0.2919571996,
-0.2882127464,
-0.3919343054,
-0.2704392672,
-0.0770352855,
-0.5330327153,
-0.2698413432,
0.3588994741,
0.3418964446,
0.3128055632,
0.5218892694,
-0.8709716797,
0.5107852221,
0.1670144051,
0.2221981436,
-0.2563482225,
-0.4866313338,
-0.3126719296,
-0.0733262151,
-0.2458586246,
-0.2154979557,
0.4877143502,
0.394816339,
0.478009522,
0.0479062423,
0.0741784126,
0.5940282941,
-0.9064434767,
0.6226614714,
0.2285915911,
-0.936981976,
0.7118723392,
-0.1562278122,
0.3619020581,
0.8452652097,
0.6391775012,
-0.419783622,
-0.1709438264,
-0.5520551801,
-0.944460392,
0.7170049548,
0.2746092379,
0.4172991514,
0.1285104603,
0.2167464495,
0.41563344,
0.1747551262,
-0.4829650819,
0.0247202404,
-0.4083333611,
-0.4742306769,
-0.3650155663,
0.2440700978,
0.1831793934,
-0.2786642313,
0.8095211983,
-0.4802296162,
0.3295136094,
0.1298867762,
-0.1265772283,
0.0469745882,
-0.0046391925,
0.1577893645,
0.7523491383,
-0.0460274927,
-0.1572348624,
0.3462007046,
-1.0313378572,
-0.0344495475,
0.0802541822,
-0.0052259546,
0.0915363133,
0.3782200515,
0.9919192791,
-0.0322839878,
-0.822367847,
0.5351401567,
-0.170111388,
-0.3554307222,
-0.1480909884,
0.405228883,
-0.1828282177,
-0.0719609186,
0.159806937,
0.5010115504,
-0.0227003265,
-0.2246486247,
0.3253175616,
0.2603498697,
-0.2406252474,
-0.1480629891,
0.675139606,
0.244915992,
-0.194658637,
0.712128818,
0.0432756357,
-0.4539562762,
0.5725013614,
0.4960360825,
0.6927395463,
-0.1473143995,
0.3014799953,
0.349683702,
0.0748417303,
-0.1610810906,
0.02402482,
0.0985537991,
-1.1011018753,
-0.4234358072,
-0.8704467416,
-0.2990548611,
0.2236770689,
-0.4172206521,
0.2592396438,
-0.6169025898,
-0.135146454,
0.1130759567,
0.250734657,
-1.0489349365,
0.8268303275,
-0.0213473327,
0.8697611094,
-0.7600951791,
0.8856171966,
0.4654468298,
0.0845678002,
-0.7405166626,
0.1435944587,
-0.482405901,
-0.8304381371,
0.7220230103,
0.1105959639,
-0.1501272619,
0.2661661804,
-0.6074082851,
-0.8327865601,
0.9144742489,
0.2649538517,
-0.7308708429,
0.0332530476,
-0.1456610858,
0.5097522736,
-0.2498311102,
0.1052972972,
0.4929822683,
0.5362811685,
0.0811208934,
-0.7201390266,
-0.0653623492,
-0.0581652485,
0.0885442644,
0.2628790438,
-0.6083016396,
0.5071347356,
0.1518091112,
-0.319788605,
-0.253138274,
0.7075717449,
0.0503256321,
0.1903766096,
0.8208530545,
0.2017401308,
1.1956218481,
0.0972092673,
0.9794105291,
-0.3070565462,
0.3987240195,
0.8815114498,
-0.5633914471,
0.7928948998,
0.2307663858,
-0.5014512539,
0.0523876511,
0.8603571653,
-0.2567806542,
0.8129295111,
0.2252729982,
0.0474301986,
-0.1769540459,
0.0587791577,
-0.1569862664,
0.692278266,
0.1839614362,
-0.0109306341,
-0.0464259684,
0.243005693,
0.101879105,
0.1923602223,
-0.4474772811,
0.8633549213,
-0.011340851,
-0.7652240396,
0.5319635272,
-0.0638218671,
0.8772274256,
-0.8003494143,
0.0880130604,
0.0969727114,
0.1232111976,
-0.3547500074,
-0.514162302,
0.5411578417,
0.156780839,
-0.1642568409,
-0.6346362829,
0.8860656619,
-0.2860340774,
-0.4068304896,
0.3537412882,
0.2790774405,
0.0800833181,
-0.1912249625,
-0.6875896454,
-0.1109015122,
0.2127237022,
-0.2358380407,
0.2221537828,
0.30114609,
-0.1622196883,
0.2949238122,
0.9199904203,
0.1751726121,
-0.3785685897,
-0.0242291167,
0.8135088086,
-0.5331804752,
-0.8330175877,
-0.5961995125,
0.2871677279,
-0.1627380997,
-0.3619762957,
0.4245351553,
0.540656209,
1.1362993717,
-0.0015262663,
1.1449513435,
0.0399861112,
0.4991539717,
-0.8965830207,
0.7940226793,
-0.3903473616,
-0.1036063358,
-0.3518981338,
-1.1587077379,
-0.328269124,
0.8538759947,
-0.4148751497,
0.2179567963,
0.9635327458,
0.617934525,
-0.0816322342,
0.1715203375,
0.3315048516,
0.0367018618,
0.2825185657,
0.4704732597,
0.5352665186,
-0.2037054002,
0.3372249007,
0.2960694432,
-0.1643964648,
0.056168586,
-0.95076859,
-0.9186125398,
-0.6429706216,
-0.5169785619,
-0.016997721,
-0.1579525322,
0.9682034254,
0.94292593,
-0.8974204063,
0.0944238827,
-0.2070628256,
-0.1819871664,
-0.2024615109,
-0.1118290499,
0.5700787306,
-0.4500840008,
-0.7754912376,
0.3005041182,
0.139342308,
0.0873996168,
0.4197769165,
0.0711840987,
-0.0710143074,
0.151418224,
0.5807684064,
0.0914505124,
0.1087204739,
-0.4461227953,
-0.371968925,
0.0854231417,
0.3157194853,
0.8742453456,
-0.7357012033,
0.212125048,
0.37470752,
1.2104238272,
0.6068191528,
-0.0249249022,
0.3725515604,
-0.6178805232,
0.343554914,
0.4576114714,
0.1687278152,
0.4071255624,
-0.6380788684,
0.6288913488,
0.1262474656,
-0.7034456134,
-0.4964978993,
-0.09175767,
-0.8544278741,
-0.8387773633,
1.1281524897,
-0.0835627988,
-0.2079455554,
-0.3711663485,
-0.4343402982,
0.2068423182,
-0.054868754,
0.5340045691,
0.652577877,
-0.0922090709,
0.2906675041,
-0.6610020399,
0.7668514848,
0.4297307432,
-1.2610718012,
0.2549184859,
0.3360207677,
0.1385854185,
0.2297770679,
0.9165325761,
0.2378810346,
-0.1507484019,
0.0124984467,
-0.0912378058,
0.1432091594,
-0.5172265768,
-0.1806231588,
0.2030719221,
-0.1088510379,
-0.1856005341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18216v1
|
L3Cube-MahaNews: News-based Short Text and Long Document Classification Datasets in Marathi
| 2024-04-28T15:20:45 | 2024-04-28T15:20:45 |
Saloni Mittal, Vidula Magdum, Omkar Dhekane, Sharayu Hiwarkhedkar, Raviraj Joshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The availability of text or topic classification datasets in the low-resource
Marathi language is limited, typically consisting of fewer than 4 target
labels, with some achieving nearly perfect accuracy. In this work, we introduce
L3Cube-MahaNews, a Marathi text classification corpus that focuses on News
headlines and articles. This corpus stands out as the largest supervised
Marathi Corpus, containing over 1.05L records classified into a diverse range
of 12 categories. To accommodate different document lengths, MahaNews comprises
three supervised datasets specifically designed for short text, long documents,
and medium paragraphs. The consistent labeling across these datasets
facilitates document length-based analysis. We provide detailed data statistics
and baseline results on these datasets using state-of-the-art pre-trained BERT
models. We conduct a comparative analysis between monolingual and multilingual
BERT models, including MahaBERT, IndicBERT, and MuRIL. The monolingual MahaBERT
model outperforms all others on every dataset. These resources also serve as
Marathi topic classification datasets or models and are publicly available at
https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP .
|
[
-0.4864854217,
-0.7679972053,
0.6402080655,
0.3873537779,
-0.3769347668,
0.05837496,
-0.5260289311,
-0.5457467437,
0.2655363381,
0.5810751915,
-0.3561690748,
-0.6001954675,
-0.7795939445,
0.1022518873,
-0.61982584,
1.3104315996,
0.139566198,
-0.0581770279,
-0.2096337974,
-0.2889563441,
-0.4739406705,
-0.5519162416,
-0.4228846729,
0.1394848824,
0.8036828637,
0.6983577609,
0.7428077459,
0.0992050841,
0.489792496,
0.1596431136,
0.0036523754,
0.3244256973,
-0.0785924122,
0.0264114812,
-0.1574888825,
-0.3579774797,
-0.1252871901,
-0.0282067899,
0.5240541697,
0.4862522781,
-0.1097778603,
0.0756056681,
0.2027447224,
0.88460958,
-0.6632733941,
0.3452780843,
-0.2450905442,
-0.1328870505,
-0.8999629021,
0.1247611046,
-0.6340881586,
-0.6823636293,
-0.1545092911,
-0.2232500017,
0.1671477705,
0.01083373,
1.024285078,
-0.0785236582,
-0.6975522041,
-0.5420553684,
-0.5416483283,
0.9331133366,
-0.5627056956,
0.3808822036,
0.4806607664,
0.4388275146,
0.1398451477,
-0.61678195,
-0.4002285004,
0.0253477171,
-0.2236317694,
0.1051981971,
-0.10126926,
-0.1403449625,
0.1049760878,
0.4307019711,
-0.6297501326,
0.2625583112,
-0.5900551677,
-0.2499340773,
0.3408531249,
0.1484437734,
0.1965274513,
-0.718072772,
-0.086498037,
0.1780130714,
-0.2245230675,
0.043728821,
0.329470396,
0.4812658429,
-0.1501803696,
0.6501808167,
-0.3426835239,
1.0481280088,
-0.3265637457,
-0.4012473524,
0.347886771,
-0.2826576829,
0.0088447798,
0.2689138353,
0.7028192282,
0.1273111552,
0.0216589998,
0.1883866787,
0.0682380497,
0.2293777913,
0.2029040903,
-0.6977594495,
-0.1194626018,
0.0096657518,
-0.5041367412,
-0.4371339977,
-0.0450158343,
-0.8971077204,
-0.5711846948,
-0.2671543956,
0.2264255434,
-0.4441212714,
0.0866529793,
0.1528815925,
0.1603717804,
0.361984998,
0.4328455329,
-1.025303483,
0.2767566442,
0.5973513126,
0.8881618381,
-0.3978041708,
-0.0254998468,
-0.3734293878,
0.0314234942,
-0.2484807968,
0.6413542628,
-0.4186895192,
-0.3059304059,
0.0929895863,
-0.0291211829,
0.1836918145,
-0.1569486409,
1.138694644,
-0.4939807951,
0.3819408417,
-0.006097002,
-0.5279504061,
-0.1903022677,
0.2680434287,
-0.898970902,
0.9782858491,
0.1952514648,
-1.2172290087,
0.3548786342,
-0.5294750333,
-0.7257490754,
-0.1031133309,
-0.2712753117,
-0.6725883484,
-0.0488277227,
0.6219792366,
0.6324275732,
-0.1953641623,
0.3783463836,
-0.164569363,
-0.1259476095,
-0.0044936915,
-0.3977243304,
0.8950297236,
0.476323247,
0.0086690933,
0.0568270236,
-0.892739892,
-0.191359669,
-0.0458097532,
-0.3875555992,
-0.5535828471,
0.1038961112,
0.1651962847,
0.0629395247,
0.3128327429,
-0.9094768763,
0.2781368494,
0.0547659807,
0.2698340118,
0.4462284148,
0.1448679864,
0.3593012094,
-0.3084669709,
0.3193868101,
0.2142468691,
0.4780714512,
-0.0160764176,
-0.7955999374,
-0.7866198421,
-0.4291275144,
0.6075582504,
0.4488573074,
-0.8280830383,
0.1851953417,
-0.5750871301,
-0.6135333776,
-0.4482213557,
-0.0101437513,
-0.020873988,
0.4535908401,
0.3937623501,
-0.0410457589,
-0.6130261421,
-1.2284369469,
-0.092388913,
0.1546545923,
0.2837385535,
0.1313816607,
0.197815001,
-0.499948442,
1.1839475632,
-0.5394381285,
-0.4569526017,
-0.519456625,
0.4113509357,
0.5274006128,
0.2023606598,
0.4776881635,
-1.0621471405,
-0.2751332521,
-0.2263946235,
-0.7129024267,
0.0440530255,
0.1041251048,
-0.1942935884,
0.7016083598,
0.4527204633,
-0.5369524956,
0.5772814751,
0.6181255579,
0.0464899838,
0.5478280187,
-0.0520165861,
0.1040110514,
-1.2377057076,
-0.381970048,
-0.0664461628,
-0.46672225,
-0.4165236652,
-0.2124117613,
0.4875754118,
-0.5061385036,
-0.5814743042,
0.5357337594,
-0.3336522579,
-0.1124773622,
-0.4056072533,
0.2052582055,
0.0226237848,
0.4173304737,
0.2825349569,
0.6962314844,
0.4719223678,
-0.6757802367,
0.4940871596,
0.4287792444,
-0.8194998503,
0.1562112868,
-0.1008901149,
-0.2486957163,
-0.1120021716,
0.3962462842,
-0.6146470904,
-0.3335848749,
0.1696813256,
-0.5580282807,
0.2303585112,
0.062879391,
-0.8235698938,
-0.5453165174,
-0.3109753132,
0.2507683039,
0.5150310397,
-0.5328198075,
0.5082603693,
0.4121568799,
-0.3746116757,
-0.5338051319,
-0.9224792719,
0.0291302949,
-0.0968570262,
-0.559578836,
0.0204639602,
0.2467408478,
-0.0300634671,
0.1107103676,
-0.073338978,
-0.2902142406,
-0.2290041596,
0.2782149911,
0.3571846485,
-0.0700400174,
0.440274179,
0.0057432801,
-0.0046372167,
-0.1606251448,
-0.0631707236,
0.1939329505,
-0.4041704237,
-0.1116219983,
-0.0506291762,
0.3206396103,
0.3980292082,
-0.3807732463,
0.8886766434,
0.8445327282,
-0.2106467634,
-0.0765477642,
-0.4439200759,
0.1566066742,
-0.3659489155,
0.1736361086,
-0.2672823668,
-0.7988992333,
-0.0400510877,
0.2421973497,
0.157750532,
0.53692168,
0.4850303531,
-0.1011041999,
0.6170141697,
0.8461906314,
-0.5054906607,
0.2704467177,
-0.0604995824,
0.3290469646,
-0.5088306665,
-0.0628426969,
-0.6162780523,
0.0473203585,
-0.9088654518,
-0.3854778707,
0.2292540967,
-0.218587786,
0.2137573212,
0.4073892534,
-0.4811349809,
0.3138673007,
0.5661981106,
0.2875754535,
0.2797516286,
-0.1251351684,
0.2219559252,
-0.1054726243,
-0.5689287782,
-0.5140797496,
1.0473546982,
0.2805110216,
1.00517869,
0.3459707201,
0.8908609748,
0.6937013268,
0.2650053799,
-0.8721903563,
0.5361104012,
-0.2736931443,
-0.9001439214,
-0.3527019322,
-0.3612802625,
-0.9848941565,
0.0595847666,
-0.2574232221,
-0.3531731069,
0.1190268695,
-0.4253779054,
-0.2738364041,
0.3787043095,
-0.528660655,
0.6898152828,
-0.3729504943,
-0.1464504153,
-0.262016058,
-0.5279530883,
0.6467493773,
-0.4597069323,
0.6704615951,
-0.3921654224,
-0.0715750083,
1.008005023,
-0.3863382936,
0.6234760284,
0.0561685152,
-0.0726410225,
0.4191843271,
-0.3823927641,
0.2337331176,
0.2285839021,
-0.070537135,
0.2064893693,
-0.2478748262,
-0.8443614841,
-0.2575418949,
0.7081246376,
-0.8551112413,
-0.4291263223,
-0.786832571,
-0.2899924219,
-0.4594274759,
0.2894133627,
0.3135749102,
0.8213506341,
0.0779062286,
0.4764332473,
0.6713798642,
-0.4358477592,
0.4251083434,
0.4553285837,
-0.5450666547,
-0.0544886813,
1.0038580894,
-0.0555296429,
-0.1010834053,
0.5143152475,
-0.0051244581,
-0.1217983738,
-0.4553450346,
-0.1347540617,
0.0678060055,
-0.8571229577,
-0.2671868801,
-0.6715660095,
-0.5752215385,
-0.3495423794,
-0.1249390617,
-0.2840101719,
-0.4048253894,
-0.2711888254,
-0.113358736,
0.2750492096,
0.5911054611,
-0.0238550864,
0.1479803324,
-1.0223163366,
0.5974658728,
0.3653495908,
0.3648449779,
-0.4245588779,
-0.4521007538,
-0.4397976398,
-0.0529757626,
-0.4595664144,
-0.9493143559,
0.1916975081,
0.0111946007,
0.4174512327,
0.2067490965,
0.2353132814,
0.221628949,
-0.3344993889,
0.7988062501,
0.219463706,
-0.7923420668,
0.9417594671,
-0.5400509834,
0.2665250897,
0.6124439836,
0.718877852,
-0.3962191045,
-0.520078063,
-0.4460487068,
-0.8625491858,
0.6641266942,
0.3719928861,
-0.0197909605,
-0.2560820282,
0.0113386856,
0.359511137,
-0.0306913052,
-0.8305496573,
-0.0825432912,
-0.0806432441,
-0.3935039043,
-0.3243281841,
-0.3967973888,
0.2784047127,
-0.2079869956,
0.9576200843,
0.1821534783,
0.1155707464,
0.0897937939,
-0.5771050453,
0.5630541444,
0.6483995914,
0.6386850476,
0.7435578108,
-0.4832876325,
-0.0074962219,
0.1166562885,
-0.5922707915,
0.1775618494,
0.1047023907,
0.0293850154,
0.498478502,
0.3362113833,
0.6901435852,
0.3733717501,
-0.5333595276,
0.6101263762,
-0.3262025118,
-0.1097709686,
-0.5082534552,
-0.2349115312,
0.0531074703,
-0.0653988197,
0.1387807131,
-0.0419051312,
0.2312378287,
-0.6515663266,
0.1597749293,
-0.1791656166,
-0.3385536075,
0.3127891421,
0.4506116211,
0.446615845,
0.1978809983,
0.9259333611,
0.0877197087,
-0.2545368671,
0.4222705066,
-0.0774941891,
0.4848369658,
0.1827316284,
0.2613407373,
0.4769726992,
0.2677739561,
-0.0383937173,
-0.059546344,
-0.1643047184,
-0.5190241933,
-0.345420897,
-1.0540014505,
-0.665656209,
0.1837293357,
-0.9623727202,
0.7216522098,
-0.235244289,
-0.3077934384,
0.3104796708,
0.3244768083,
-0.295261234,
0.2049170882,
0.5778017044,
1.1346255541,
-0.7638331056,
1.3942368031,
0.5196996331,
-0.4226661026,
-0.35160923,
-0.0798601881,
-0.1226410568,
-0.4056966901,
0.6540243626,
0.4234479666,
0.0300752129,
-0.1589203626,
-0.3288967609,
-0.6569803953,
0.809163034,
-0.1694767028,
-0.740468204,
0.0093504004,
0.1119956225,
0.1968247443,
-0.0822690651,
-0.0623654909,
0.4025743604,
0.5881741047,
-0.3649227619,
-0.7759335041,
-0.4801391661,
-0.0269750375,
0.0162694156,
0.5976539254,
-0.6206935644,
0.7018254399,
-0.1424834579,
-0.0598000437,
0.0836646259,
0.9526894689,
0.114050068,
0.1855802834,
0.3143959939,
0.6176905632,
0.6056485176,
-0.3198814392,
1.1788398027,
-0.1169669479,
0.4930453598,
1.1021066904,
-0.0229322519,
0.8407042027,
0.089073211,
-0.1857668161,
0.6944828033,
0.8560826778,
-0.0659798905,
0.6470075846,
0.1536496133,
-0.2528589368,
-0.0995477065,
0.1662254333,
-0.319524616,
0.4117891788,
0.4791828692,
0.0298605412,
-0.4988937974,
0.700507462,
0.0559650734,
0.08511585,
-0.4852793515,
0.523593843,
0.070061475,
-0.4751847088,
0.3873602748,
0.2999049425,
0.8746317625,
-0.774763763,
0.4210301042,
-0.2691034377,
0.3195134997,
-0.2098380029,
-1.2171486616,
0.4797589779,
0.0957029536,
-0.4719527662,
-0.0103930673,
1.02612257,
-0.2770671844,
-0.5271121264,
0.1750098467,
0.149708584,
0.2187955379,
0.0268359613,
-0.4565165937,
0.1506364495,
-0.1753747463,
-0.0888450071,
0.2442592382,
0.2597449124,
-0.4584782124,
0.5312972665,
0.3217856586,
-0.1242961287,
0.1420488656,
0.0679236725,
0.5409780145,
-0.829610467,
-0.6692372561,
-0.6156996489,
0.0002582582,
-0.2250256836,
-0.0989394039,
0.9497314692,
0.9312545657,
0.6394114494,
-0.1219087467,
1.0267204046,
-0.1787129343,
0.8664405942,
-0.5355998874,
0.5993285179,
-0.5763409734,
-0.1161700413,
-0.0144074345,
-0.8449910283,
-0.0762876645,
0.1922230721,
-0.3483977318,
-0.0125356354,
0.7275974154,
0.3272434175,
-0.1900704354,
0.3224467039,
0.2824147344,
0.0915299207,
0.1866748929,
0.6154364944,
0.8695273995,
-0.190031603,
0.74840343,
-0.4436795712,
-0.237086013,
-0.5425747037,
-0.7119581103,
-0.8933885694,
-0.8138823509,
-0.1979193091,
-0.1772457808,
0.0941634476,
0.4756159484,
0.6886664033,
-0.7535678148,
-0.036983259,
0.0251881275,
0.1258076876,
0.2922365665,
-0.2886038423,
0.4233696461,
-0.6298918724,
-0.5237315893,
0.0645887032,
0.2204117477,
-0.1255721748,
0.0461446531,
0.1450943351,
-0.4716436863,
0.1161450446,
0.784864068,
0.3693553805,
-0.5772020221,
-0.0389640816,
-0.4246400893,
-0.7120640278,
-0.0118933711,
0.5850424767,
-0.7517234683,
0.2510559261,
0.3924480677,
0.5709397793,
0.8331797123,
-0.0844940543,
-0.0167824607,
-0.7918112278,
0.3920152783,
0.2702636719,
0.3578248322,
0.414742887,
-0.2102471888,
0.6087607145,
0.0161316097,
-0.521445334,
-0.5059197545,
0.1484950334,
-1.2920330763,
-0.5681973696,
1.2292587757,
0.0901813284,
-0.4429026246,
-0.0947192982,
-0.4430550337,
0.2825073004,
-0.2187996209,
0.4974885881,
0.9937498569,
-0.0727391839,
-0.2396216094,
-1.0085054636,
0.4046450555,
0.1877098829,
-1.0791567564,
-0.1550714225,
0.5237396359,
0.1893589944,
0.2236079127,
0.7006534338,
-0.236944288,
0.4026277065,
-0.3522034883,
0.1465829164,
0.0238358676,
-0.4589750767,
-0.1834677905,
0.0414540991,
-0.0639499947,
-0.3706678748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01585v1
|
Tabular Embedding Model (TEM): Finetuning Embedding Models For Tabular RAG Applications
| 2024-04-28T14:58:55 | 2024-04-28T14:58:55 |
Sujit Khanna, Shishir Subedi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In recent times Large Language Models have exhibited tremendous capabilities,
especially in the areas of mathematics, code generation and general-purpose
reasoning. However for specialized domains especially in applications that
require parsing and analyzing large chunks of numeric or tabular data even
state-of-the-art (SOTA) models struggle. In this paper, we introduce a new
approach to solving domain-specific tabular data analysis tasks by presenting a
unique RAG workflow that mitigates the scalability issues of existing tabular
LLM solutions. Specifically, we present Tabular Embedding Model (TEM), a novel
approach to fine-tune embedding models for tabular Retrieval-Augmentation
Generation (RAG) applications. Embedding models form a crucial component in the
RAG workflow and even current SOTA embedding models struggle as they are
predominantly trained on textual datasets and thus underperform in scenarios
involving complex tabular data. The evaluation results showcase that our
approach not only outperforms current SOTA embedding models in this domain but
also does so with a notably smaller and more efficient model structure.
|
[
-0.3433759809,
-1.3132380247,
0.5537356734,
-0.0967278183,
-0.197356075,
0.2641429305,
-0.0149987843,
-0.0141033707,
0.1053649262,
0.7048377395,
-0.1828145832,
-0.7491449118,
-0.4208808243,
-0.32697317,
-0.3674688041,
0.8732385039,
-0.2298473567,
0.1762729883,
-0.583001852,
0.0891933367,
-0.849281013,
-0.2427001745,
-0.3453065753,
-0.1913642436,
0.2276644558,
0.7847765088,
0.6218443513,
0.8095023036,
0.6741095781,
0.2524346709,
-0.0927782133,
0.4366375506,
-0.6475108266,
0.2708612382,
-0.253649205,
-0.5247127414,
-0.8466255665,
-0.1741132438,
0.8809295893,
0.7572992444,
-0.3939623237,
0.3915750086,
0.071640268,
0.5647502542,
-0.4178735912,
0.0599746406,
-0.7867359519,
0.2121203989,
-0.408893466,
-0.3359161615,
-0.5979704261,
-0.458483696,
0.040892154,
-0.4918482602,
0.2117908448,
0.1720860004,
0.7322713137,
0.26991871,
-0.380979836,
0.0215707105,
-0.9362949729,
0.554746747,
-0.6579099894,
0.4394725263,
0.1923459172,
0.6317741275,
-0.1361439675,
-0.7978578806,
-0.4035856724,
-0.3280529678,
0.0889574364,
-0.1267153472,
0.097229287,
-0.1586924642,
0.1493662,
0.2469792068,
-0.7945007682,
0.0185266268,
-0.2397927493,
0.4402290285,
0.1593753844,
0.6855247021,
0.3495779634,
0.0934485123,
-0.5136148334,
0.1617236286,
-0.7451024652,
-0.2339520156,
0.0066700149,
0.4420321286,
-0.1226103902,
0.6662676334,
0.0858391002,
0.7406296134,
-0.1159960404,
0.1551631838,
-0.0542130098,
-0.0041527967,
-0.4149935842,
-0.3973886371,
0.1747490466,
0.1118833721,
0.0258622486,
-0.3821525872,
-0.3857501447,
0.2041243911,
0.5784375072,
-0.6149057746,
0.0653773248,
0.1690207273,
-0.2440056801,
-0.4468951821,
0.1131496876,
-0.7977068424,
-0.5246067047,
-0.3185752034,
0.5553177595,
-0.3512546718,
-0.1445248872,
0.0745758712,
0.2173178494,
0.2393249422,
0.3014190495,
-0.5726233721,
0.5803951621,
1.1215873957,
0.8486070037,
-0.2317865193,
-0.1258373857,
-0.8241379261,
0.35641101,
-0.5509610772,
1.0939846039,
-0.9507804513,
-0.2051659226,
0.0974898338,
-0.0634249225,
-0.0393108055,
-0.6777592301,
0.5491960049,
-0.7261122465,
-0.309807986,
-0.0828136578,
-0.9135990143,
-0.2513575256,
0.4383720756,
-0.8863785267,
0.9009379745,
0.3678417802,
-0.4944946468,
0.2982006669,
-0.7416291237,
-0.0094667571,
0.3369134068,
-0.1605925113,
-0.6982092857,
0.3164849579,
-0.1605743915,
0.7000167966,
-0.780836165,
0.4300659597,
-0.4784924686,
-0.322995156,
0.1446210444,
0.0835291147,
0.1016752943,
0.2417303175,
0.1144881397,
-0.0300967935,
-0.30957219,
0.1222340912,
0.2112205178,
-0.1407807022,
-0.3144136071,
-0.1035918146,
0.2535546422,
0.0626777336,
0.1316844374,
-0.4157378972,
0.3399665356,
-0.2334779948,
0.2277982682,
0.475297153,
-0.0143342875,
0.7040723562,
-0.5105662942,
0.6474879384,
0.2332697064,
-0.003731671,
0.0600162409,
-0.1211343557,
-0.3770145178,
-0.0887241513,
0.7856569886,
0.4451189637,
-0.7048561573,
0.10098169,
-0.4851000905,
-0.7288199663,
-0.1871310771,
0.0010178339,
0.3577758372,
0.4880725145,
0.2938801646,
-0.0726193935,
-0.391941309,
-1.0207539797,
-0.5011183619,
0.5505046844,
0.1223727539,
0.2681879997,
0.5181726813,
-0.3928128183,
0.8580482006,
-0.5706069469,
-0.5092157125,
-0.6354052424,
0.0645334497,
0.1171447262,
0.6613546014,
0.3576134145,
-0.8853089809,
-1.0173429251,
0.3143545985,
-0.598651588,
-0.0269952137,
-0.0552991554,
-0.1109153554,
0.1913646907,
0.3580115139,
-0.5071405172,
0.6451157928,
0.233002618,
-0.6766003966,
0.2260867655,
-0.0949370936,
-0.0432851613,
-1.0018268824,
-0.0751992166,
0.1928447634,
-0.6466211677,
-1.0145334005,
0.4336944222,
0.3351662457,
-0.3366969526,
-0.386177212,
0.5194313526,
-0.5097315311,
-0.2765335143,
-0.2497929484,
0.1326693594,
0.2569302619,
0.3463158607,
-0.2551001012,
0.6243225932,
0.345664382,
-0.60913831,
0.069425717,
0.2801125348,
-0.1143169478,
0.5850253701,
-0.6403087974,
0.0580165535,
-0.1735234261,
0.0139389643,
-0.8947856426,
-0.0745654404,
-0.1218771636,
-0.3250364661,
0.8880982399,
-0.3422973454,
-0.4052106738,
-0.1896966696,
-0.4359378815,
0.4739393294,
0.3012933433,
-0.4162269533,
0.9026723504,
0.9210144877,
-0.1953462809,
-0.2968099415,
-0.4420526028,
-0.0516319498,
-0.4122851491,
-0.7692124844,
0.8564795852,
0.1696576774,
-0.083247602,
0.163531363,
-0.2845919132,
-0.3163663149,
0.08307942,
-0.0334207453,
0.3253933191,
-0.229730323,
0.1436883956,
0.0667408556,
-0.3286957443,
-0.2476436943,
-0.2399163246,
0.8009845614,
-0.3598327637,
-0.0699625164,
-0.3526158929,
0.565969944,
0.4055356681,
-0.2877395749,
0.9415636659,
0.5237115622,
-0.8224281073,
-0.4635449946,
-0.7509267926,
0.0189330205,
-0.4708024859,
0.5752804279,
-0.498572439,
-0.6402820945,
0.6324179173,
-0.3472547531,
0.1037943289,
0.3336006701,
0.703687489,
-0.2243370712,
0.7413708568,
0.7253060341,
0.2560588121,
0.4244360626,
-0.5782533884,
0.0411854573,
-0.8388027549,
-0.364438206,
-0.5801958442,
-0.4506138265,
-0.546502769,
-0.827481091,
0.4745517671,
-0.268312186,
-0.3098552227,
0.1641989946,
-0.4304800928,
0.6059683561,
0.2211920023,
0.1473344713,
0.1267974824,
0.2400700301,
-0.0670513585,
-0.1012584567,
-0.7202200294,
-0.7420020103,
1.0388535261,
0.4966723919,
0.9808524847,
0.0374807566,
0.6074230671,
0.6024808288,
0.2040311843,
-0.7125146389,
0.4174673259,
-0.5725076199,
-0.391181618,
-0.4826579988,
-0.4810779691,
-0.9434909225,
0.1353913099,
-0.2653951943,
-0.6801692843,
0.0853393003,
0.0591848828,
-0.3149955869,
0.598033309,
-0.7149415612,
1.0595574379,
0.2212436795,
-0.6659576297,
-0.035184823,
-0.0669256076,
0.1614032835,
-0.1271466315,
0.159510076,
-0.0627681687,
-0.1731215119,
0.7275647521,
-0.4469934404,
0.5281335711,
-0.5315978527,
0.0572915375,
0.4969201684,
0.5022523403,
0.7098053098,
0.0708991289,
0.0592213944,
-0.1508605182,
0.1094312817,
-0.2969297171,
-0.8113823533,
0.8101075292,
-0.4983095527,
-0.6185072064,
-0.1256127805,
-0.6572296023,
-0.355933249,
-0.0824602917,
-0.1505059302,
0.6438215971,
-0.1576841474,
0.6431010962,
0.7531452179,
-0.1453570873,
0.0940155536,
0.4538839757,
-0.1482761651,
-0.2231694907,
0.9519944191,
0.5096606612,
-0.1851088852,
0.5687789321,
0.301522404,
-0.2698411942,
-0.5078339577,
-0.2693151236,
0.1489618272,
-0.3412347734,
-0.6183464527,
-0.6116871238,
-0.1128411889,
-0.1195982844,
-0.1285682172,
-0.678863883,
-0.5902610421,
-0.0294570327,
0.0156317856,
0.4490902722,
0.9057098627,
0.2433454543,
0.4791326225,
-1.0024744272,
0.5995285511,
0.0772566348,
0.7137176394,
0.1142797396,
-0.7256808877,
-0.5852006078,
-0.1663662195,
-0.4279994965,
-1.2143307924,
0.6139990091,
-0.0248247925,
0.553622365,
-0.1296095103,
-0.1304561794,
0.6781856418,
-0.7377676368,
0.3666135073,
-0.3083434105,
-0.8775746822,
0.2842472494,
-0.4565611184,
-0.0464213789,
0.4201068878,
0.312394619,
-0.280488193,
0.0807359591,
-0.4586592913,
-0.839429915,
0.6610978246,
-0.1389589906,
-0.0685984939,
0.3185572028,
0.5260403156,
0.3111609817,
0.0089044655,
-0.7303141952,
-0.0659527481,
0.2165388018,
-0.2740162015,
0.334387809,
-0.6017802358,
0.1337084621,
-0.1473723203,
0.5986610651,
0.1264252812,
0.3882451653,
-0.1471529901,
-0.3350719213,
-0.2236926258,
0.3272028863,
0.2411130071,
0.5623728633,
-0.0572464839,
-0.0923490748,
0.3467198908,
-0.5007395148,
0.1042458341,
0.0058605503,
-0.2595089674,
-0.1306641698,
-0.1095587909,
0.4722043276,
0.1784428954,
-0.2468030453,
0.3714726269,
-0.0638429075,
-0.029659532,
-0.2884347737,
-0.1278881282,
0.1185308099,
0.4078516364,
0.273704499,
-0.3420741856,
0.4334539473,
-0.3905979693,
0.3285549581,
0.5811483264,
-0.1068996862,
-0.1545679122,
0.5489195585,
-0.2692435682,
-0.5008506775,
0.1901161075,
-0.156624347,
-0.3779835403,
0.7324643135,
0.7931907177,
0.888068974,
-0.3743574619,
0.3942515552,
0.10032738,
0.2212567329,
0.1088711023,
0.5963941216,
0.3315481246,
-0.4138117731,
-0.1540034264,
-0.5496441722,
-0.497811228,
0.0679989606,
-0.6994505525,
0.4455980062,
-0.3426879346,
-0.3467659354,
-0.1266926825,
0.1479656994,
-1.1026828289,
0.1002450809,
-0.0094064977,
0.8346859217,
-0.6865342855,
0.7069633603,
0.8531460166,
-0.189785853,
-0.8273171782,
-0.1288579702,
-0.4254852533,
-0.4049065411,
0.3451229036,
0.0472955443,
0.2509923577,
-0.020372862,
-0.2565499544,
-0.867334187,
1.103767395,
0.3420580626,
-0.5303599238,
-0.151451081,
0.5070726275,
0.4426175356,
-0.5314742327,
0.1390093714,
0.741484642,
0.4662060738,
-0.2391417325,
-0.5543251038,
0.2106517702,
-0.2039757371,
0.3548587263,
0.2532308996,
-0.478018105,
0.96610111,
0.1010637432,
-0.0904621407,
-0.1474517733,
0.5568947792,
0.2901941836,
0.520296514,
0.3181333542,
0.7015852332,
0.6429927349,
-0.094404459,
0.8529936075,
-0.1533386558,
0.4448232651,
1.335113883,
-0.3522526324,
1.0120019913,
0.2708667219,
-0.1017395779,
0.4089283049,
0.3367545307,
-0.0551813133,
0.4233923256,
0.196892783,
0.0193385072,
-0.1709209085,
-0.1594760716,
-0.3820632696,
0.5671733618,
0.7423380613,
-0.1464406848,
-0.4002288282,
-0.0693936273,
-0.2857041061,
0.3615549803,
-0.4075750411,
0.7223459482,
-0.0153327845,
-0.2375507802,
0.5177433491,
0.1195022687,
0.219845593,
-0.2009831369,
-0.1861065626,
-0.3329997659,
0.0556930564,
-0.3191884756,
-0.6514922976,
0.5863005519,
0.284354955,
-0.1234703511,
-0.0206375122,
0.7991481423,
-0.4028099477,
-0.4828585386,
0.1934845448,
0.9227868915,
-0.0543236211,
0.0514731929,
-0.4408243299,
0.0559143014,
-0.3381194174,
-0.4595894516,
0.2919783592,
0.815177381,
-0.1613746136,
0.6907721162,
0.3715509474,
-0.1083754823,
0.0842922032,
0.1873426288,
1.1838458776,
-0.8619844317,
-0.6345109344,
-1.0141967535,
0.7067647576,
0.0792970881,
0.4075404704,
0.4514844716,
0.7534241676,
0.3566446602,
-0.3978383541,
0.388417244,
0.2241558433,
0.7468028069,
-0.4242651761,
0.8046811819,
-0.7648801804,
0.4338614941,
-0.35513255,
-1.0646885633,
-0.4988874793,
0.4793271124,
-0.4390120208,
0.0997647345,
0.5526048541,
0.7735113502,
-0.2256366462,
-0.0569501147,
0.5960367322,
0.3081561625,
0.2149815857,
0.4649741352,
0.8866302371,
-0.3121270239,
0.384239465,
0.0617597476,
-0.2114439607,
-0.3367056251,
-0.7711350918,
-0.9372814894,
-0.5789208412,
-0.120282419,
-0.0518262796,
0.0037399654,
0.8624255657,
0.4895628393,
-0.6352249384,
-0.1139680296,
-0.1823033988,
0.2866277099,
0.1573367566,
-0.2931163311,
0.3548123538,
-0.3974881768,
-0.7237936258,
0.1814683825,
0.2509229779,
0.0060254494,
-0.1614364833,
0.2542173564,
-0.1040930897,
0.1948980242,
0.4776236713,
-0.0181162078,
-0.4518185854,
-0.0260619093,
0.0868450031,
-0.043980442,
0.2111571431,
0.6649340987,
-0.7796918154,
0.2038026303,
0.6144626141,
1.0375163555,
0.7421447039,
-0.0144817475,
0.5487645864,
-0.6846993566,
-0.1200238243,
0.4019777775,
0.5107344389,
0.2038365304,
-0.5214655399,
0.6605808139,
-0.2464811057,
-0.5672588944,
-1.2263189554,
0.0515464097,
-0.9943618178,
-0.1202855036,
0.8477802277,
-0.0583012141,
-0.3214648068,
-0.0570443645,
-0.0597601719,
0.4808381498,
-0.2265846431,
0.8342353702,
0.274017334,
0.2271713167,
0.0527172163,
-0.6760806441,
0.2598489225,
0.2983942926,
-1.0544098616,
0.1541250795,
0.1240866929,
0.1821243912,
-0.0097850282,
0.2667821348,
-0.3015953302,
0.3412995934,
0.0519424006,
-0.1189090535,
-0.4408308268,
-0.7421998978,
-0.2321124822,
0.4318894148,
0.0443899073,
-0.1101772189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01509v1
|
Learnable Linguistic Watermarks for Tracing Model Extraction Attacks on Large Language Models
| 2024-04-28T14:45:53 | 2024-04-28T14:45:53 |
Minhao Bai, Kaiyi Pang, Yongfeng Huang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving domain of artificial intelligence, safeguarding the
intellectual property of Large Language Models (LLMs) is increasingly crucial.
Current watermarking techniques against model extraction attacks, which rely on
signal insertion in model logits or post-processing of generated text, remain
largely heuristic. We propose a novel method for embedding learnable linguistic
watermarks in LLMs, aimed at tracing and preventing model extraction attacks.
Our approach subtly modifies the LLM's output distribution by introducing
controlled noise into token frequency distributions, embedding an statistically
identifiable controllable watermark.We leverage statistical hypothesis testing
and information theory, particularly focusing on Kullback-Leibler Divergence,
to differentiate between original and modified distributions effectively. Our
watermarking method strikes a delicate well balance between robustness and
output quality, maintaining low false positive/negative rates and preserving
the LLM's original performance.
|
[
-0.306124121,
-0.9179073572,
0.2977176905,
0.21050708,
-0.5960395336,
0.2955506742,
-0.2539528906,
-0.4864517152,
0.2516824901,
0.8936032653,
-0.2579130828,
-0.4454408288,
-0.7661104798,
-0.3153052926,
-0.7042341828,
0.7708160877,
0.1600203961,
-0.0632735044,
0.0665969253,
-0.1759209484,
-0.1681273282,
-0.7426919341,
-0.6621553302,
-0.279280901,
0.4621005356,
-0.1677868068,
0.5359912515,
0.8968624473,
0.5130406618,
0.196744591,
-0.2769366503,
-0.0480226912,
-0.3129796386,
0.4572224021,
-0.0502690077,
-0.5907501578,
-0.2864135504,
-0.1773099005,
0.7567833066,
0.4672631025,
0.0071363994,
0.0459188633,
0.1416207552,
0.5185539126,
-0.7687950134,
0.5176097155,
-0.7746757269,
0.1004129127,
-0.6179648638,
-0.3692348301,
-0.7961956263,
-0.2703692615,
-0.2382101119,
-0.4101900458,
0.0256796032,
0.0191276353,
0.9038219452,
0.3656657338,
-0.1512843519,
-0.1707294583,
-0.9789509177,
0.81793046,
-0.9936892986,
0.4891716242,
0.4613288343,
0.3678648174,
-0.182028845,
-0.7887033224,
-0.2347788215,
-0.2367752641,
0.2229916006,
0.0199624486,
-0.3894951046,
-0.3134652972,
0.4081089199,
0.0807637721,
-0.0854993239,
0.1518644243,
-0.0427374206,
-0.253665626,
0.667306602,
-0.0168204997,
0.2523441017,
0.2749555707,
-0.1467051357,
-0.2063724995,
-1.0106195211,
-0.1502023637,
0.6140535474,
0.5025160313,
-0.1050805077,
0.4125193059,
-0.0450940691,
0.3424993455,
-0.0939348787,
-0.2090704292,
0.0834398195,
0.0614805967,
0.0103579098,
0.1756823659,
0.7067530155,
-0.1725613475,
0.4953104556,
-0.072537899,
-0.496591717,
-0.1442513615,
0.126287207,
-0.7559880018,
-0.5463808775,
-0.0912047401,
-0.3739930093,
-0.4552678764,
0.0720674545,
-0.8225009441,
-0.5677022338,
-0.0219894927,
0.4192501903,
-0.3156607449,
-0.6209182143,
0.0000097259,
-0.235207662,
0.121751152,
-0.0691040456,
-0.975946784,
0.277433157,
0.6384820938,
0.5544799566,
-0.2494185269,
0.1587509513,
-0.603526175,
0.56327039,
-0.4516077042,
0.7929218411,
-0.7341988683,
-0.2424431741,
0.1057788506,
-0.0952575654,
0.0825371891,
-0.7328197956,
0.1146325096,
-1.105804801,
-0.0403151996,
-0.0740107521,
-0.8308705091,
-0.0606817752,
-0.1196299717,
-0.967892468,
0.8674422503,
-0.0018495879,
-0.950728178,
0.3148589134,
-0.7016659379,
-0.4379796982,
0.2324880362,
-0.1110956669,
-0.7435522676,
0.0072423071,
0.136607796,
0.3389849365,
-0.0343072861,
0.1608690172,
-0.5531901121,
-0.0617171936,
0.5849844813,
-0.8582699299,
0.9438989162,
0.0172663089,
-0.5667794347,
0.026044352,
-0.879373908,
0.0841237083,
0.3108583391,
-0.4336391985,
-0.532972753,
0.2986488044,
-0.0737210289,
-0.3934218287,
0.2090655267,
-0.3396910429,
-0.0231900979,
-0.2452055961,
0.3740012348,
0.8562921286,
0.2264807075,
0.3318146765,
-0.0910293832,
0.5537187457,
0.1450071931,
0.1427558362,
-0.0917234719,
-0.4657863677,
-0.6937175989,
-0.8178799152,
0.5168968439,
0.4176869094,
-0.6241990924,
0.3827052414,
-0.0682642981,
-0.5619687438,
-0.3593150377,
0.3230959475,
0.1410830617,
0.3548124731,
0.2486305833,
-0.1733102053,
-0.2330622673,
-0.7445194125,
-0.4817806184,
-0.1901149452,
-0.0705703497,
0.2251796126,
0.4132715464,
-0.1180926636,
0.9228198528,
-0.5180903077,
-0.0173688363,
-0.2634255886,
0.1151864231,
0.0024831283,
0.5893335342,
0.5370138884,
-0.7890766263,
-0.3816353083,
0.0236310158,
-0.5935256481,
-0.5392308831,
0.0270630755,
-0.0790652484,
0.2450303435,
0.6683613062,
-0.585308373,
0.5084604025,
0.4066375494,
-0.4341426194,
0.5870277286,
-0.1228517815,
-0.2668154836,
-0.8635276556,
0.1021245718,
-0.3070861995,
-0.3305173516,
-0.46210742,
0.1033709496,
0.1714721173,
0.2419272214,
-0.2832203507,
0.6358489394,
-0.4250983894,
0.0651875287,
-0.3876314759,
-0.2760156989,
-0.1235438213,
0.1756573617,
-0.1865768433,
0.3541453481,
0.6803575754,
-0.4815272093,
0.3034891188,
-0.1260768324,
-0.3506828845,
0.39617154,
-0.6099383831,
0.1616262794,
-0.1075321585,
-0.0101330802,
-0.862722218,
-0.0192955192,
0.3079921901,
-0.1409839243,
0.551202476,
-0.4293593168,
-0.5578117371,
0.3187405169,
-0.2053977996,
0.2555973232,
0.7364810109,
-0.6354843974,
0.5438174605,
0.5029501915,
-0.3867503405,
-0.446352452,
-0.6378215551,
-0.0068608089,
-0.5747563243,
-0.2122659385,
0.1902518272,
-0.1293971241,
-0.4240389764,
0.0002093576,
-0.0328445397,
-0.3033961952,
0.456043601,
0.3171517551,
0.289452523,
-0.3105381131,
-0.0088208597,
0.1576192379,
-0.2610353827,
0.2142053694,
-0.1979587227,
0.6748310328,
0.2587168813,
-0.5895053148,
-0.3788998425,
0.3867112398,
0.5025756955,
-0.3709789813,
0.6238842607,
0.6547010541,
-0.4950514436,
-0.5220868587,
-0.5017088056,
-0.3927900791,
-0.5015513897,
0.3574462831,
0.0228590127,
-0.7945612073,
0.5285402536,
-0.1645224243,
0.1736152917,
0.4363509715,
0.3821014166,
-0.0390610136,
1.0590679646,
0.8148353696,
-0.2924438715,
0.7919370532,
-0.1709656715,
0.2164835036,
-0.5359211564,
-0.1194155514,
-0.5574820638,
-0.0319070481,
-0.4795255959,
-0.3077047467,
-0.0816878006,
0.3075933754,
-0.3246800005,
0.0765133202,
-0.158728838,
0.506693244,
0.7351952791,
-0.1192923933,
0.2987857163,
0.3811258376,
-0.1130800173,
-0.1247130781,
-0.5158417821,
-0.4944473803,
1.0371084213,
0.3586488068,
1.003136158,
0.1150564477,
0.8061822057,
0.5958470702,
0.5794407129,
-0.5588060617,
0.3588275909,
-0.0815503299,
-0.392523855,
-0.2639932632,
-0.4944751561,
-0.9272019863,
0.0131963464,
-0.1942914575,
-0.8522322178,
0.0196147542,
0.1445915699,
-0.0359903537,
0.5042507052,
-0.3243643939,
0.5891990662,
-0.0449617207,
-0.2175242901,
-0.155498907,
-0.1805207878,
0.0642348677,
-0.4369404316,
0.4009355903,
-0.1755066663,
-0.1408195049,
0.9165328145,
-0.2693318129,
1.0231668949,
-0.4300073385,
-0.3244749308,
0.2289131731,
0.4496291876,
0.6684464216,
-0.0002625202,
0.055002097,
0.2969999313,
0.0154173244,
-0.3627123237,
-0.3903323412,
0.3711077869,
-0.4911248982,
-0.6563752294,
-0.1331814229,
-0.5364957452,
-0.0109099913,
0.5275384188,
0.1008106843,
0.4399706423,
0.0328623019,
0.217666015,
0.6590568423,
-0.1833247095,
0.725564301,
0.5290669799,
-0.1743143201,
-0.4903209805,
1.1568382978,
0.198483482,
0.3493852615,
0.2084676772,
0.3653913736,
-0.3596526086,
-0.8071488142,
-0.1699132621,
0.2251083255,
-0.8213976026,
-0.2419059724,
-0.4028328657,
-0.488201797,
-0.1152272224,
0.0043835035,
-0.5749729872,
-0.4591824114,
-0.2076084614,
0.0192216747,
0.5034040809,
0.8377466798,
-0.0107866721,
0.487745434,
-0.6742142439,
0.1690579653,
0.2585679889,
0.3805933595,
-0.0228912029,
-0.7366179824,
-0.1167047396,
0.1897181869,
-0.2160764635,
-0.75773561,
0.5851718783,
0.3101748526,
0.6585523486,
0.6907242537,
0.2020797282,
0.4296703339,
-0.4451290667,
0.6066301465,
0.0938789248,
-0.9316803813,
0.4281437695,
-0.140359059,
0.1575659066,
-0.0149659449,
0.1151695326,
-0.1677956432,
-0.7951497436,
-0.7146476507,
-1.0188404322,
0.3039637804,
-0.0344529897,
0.3560011387,
-0.0012905728,
0.2110112458,
0.16265136,
0.1606015116,
-0.8733274341,
-0.2888035476,
-0.0549684986,
-0.2695655525,
0.130920887,
-0.4025311172,
-0.296104461,
0.0422044545,
0.6890720129,
-0.1353075504,
0.125733465,
-0.0932359621,
-0.3014906347,
0.0161925815,
0.0738474131,
0.3610033691,
0.5651518703,
0.0357012674,
0.5358733535,
-0.0787822679,
-0.5245172977,
0.0351770446,
-0.0429249965,
-0.4525483549,
0.0882037058,
0.6614188552,
0.5777705312,
-0.0463445187,
-0.6680167317,
0.4376941025,
0.0140869301,
0.0240339357,
-0.4212422073,
0.2237505168,
0.4080693126,
0.5362824202,
0.3817897141,
-0.0672082007,
-0.1628092825,
-0.075398311,
0.2549390495,
0.629896462,
-0.4072366953,
-0.4234981239,
0.7251245379,
-0.1784834862,
-0.3961575627,
0.4294399917,
0.077823095,
-0.4320011735,
0.5736666322,
0.6898259521,
0.9333793521,
-0.3606564999,
0.0260574147,
0.0958890393,
0.3992671669,
-0.095579572,
0.3184738159,
-0.0838982537,
-0.7842657566,
-0.2240990251,
-0.5559856892,
-0.3398586214,
0.1551971585,
-0.7499767542,
0.0883774832,
-0.6932343245,
-0.1907142401,
0.2687807977,
-0.4244195819,
-0.3868916035,
0.0021222006,
0.4530370533,
0.6922459602,
-0.7863548398,
0.8860756159,
0.1076374054,
-0.0672814772,
-0.5572512746,
-0.078174144,
-0.1463392526,
-0.8237003088,
0.662799418,
0.0006076827,
-0.0565095618,
0.0293390285,
-0.8410542011,
-0.9941110015,
0.79360497,
0.8297592998,
-0.3989843726,
0.5717287064,
0.3940806091,
0.3776137233,
-0.2582912743,
-0.0793054178,
0.5242411494,
0.4234264493,
-0.2486137897,
-0.5005273223,
0.2058722973,
-0.2597018182,
-0.1506668329,
0.2595997751,
-0.4252871871,
0.6121610403,
-0.1147803888,
-0.2816341519,
-0.2114216834,
0.5197151899,
0.3134518862,
0.0394535288,
0.6406155825,
0.2592467964,
0.8625712395,
-0.081568636,
0.8037056923,
-0.4123100936,
0.2325848192,
1.0861445665,
-0.2353957444,
1.1833206415,
0.714692235,
-0.0565143004,
0.3368951678,
0.337085098,
-0.2251135409,
0.6843994856,
0.4876078963,
-0.4169940352,
-0.2393559813,
-0.1316071898,
-0.2944268882,
0.3651044071,
0.4362747371,
-0.5438941717,
0.0577392951,
-0.1881828159,
0.2152456045,
-0.1573858559,
-0.0590576716,
0.7947621346,
0.2186059952,
-0.1801154613,
0.6097390652,
-0.0892034471,
0.6212133765,
-0.7146167159,
-0.1827811599,
-0.2915020287,
0.2160842121,
-0.1515505612,
-0.4811655581,
0.2882179022,
0.0758649185,
-0.1329150349,
-0.1905709058,
0.7089486718,
-0.5814668536,
-0.536575079,
0.5573145151,
0.2942975163,
0.1266715825,
-0.0908965245,
-0.4937652647,
0.2694393992,
-0.0088079376,
-0.5794706941,
0.3015407026,
0.2482693791,
-0.1269413978,
0.9596732259,
0.8062516451,
0.5489308238,
0.3584663868,
0.3513039351,
0.7089288235,
-0.6110162139,
-0.5253232121,
-1.2014758587,
0.2151313871,
-0.2240116596,
0.0397883244,
0.6666449308,
0.3821150661,
0.6238180995,
-0.1021918654,
0.960537076,
0.1545782834,
0.1516530663,
-0.4284451306,
1.1328246593,
-0.1798428595,
0.4744852781,
-0.3116460741,
-0.8807602525,
-0.5285391212,
0.3848615885,
0.1326382458,
-0.0813259929,
0.403850466,
0.9788036346,
-0.023578655,
-0.093664445,
0.3800673187,
0.2694654763,
0.6593992114,
0.1393153369,
0.9683801532,
-0.1892984509,
0.5135521293,
-0.530811429,
-0.1645734608,
-0.1064839363,
-1.1453984976,
-0.7711572051,
-0.3284267187,
-0.7379708886,
-0.3198664784,
0.0297807585,
0.5160675645,
0.61167413,
-1.0702255964,
-0.2228453904,
0.1637801379,
0.1589440852,
-0.3196094632,
-0.2706439793,
0.6501293182,
-0.0996957347,
-0.6278916001,
0.3210960031,
0.2777193189,
0.3611873388,
-0.2785822451,
-0.0422268324,
0.193298474,
0.2848427892,
0.3326081634,
0.2050288916,
-0.5272912979,
-0.4720671475,
-0.2894003391,
0.0505289473,
-0.166574046,
0.6331681609,
-0.3552768528,
0.3874824345,
0.3457659185,
0.7947969437,
0.3915964663,
-0.3749785125,
0.4331344068,
-0.6585403085,
0.3737757206,
0.2694091499,
0.5414550304,
0.4268242121,
-0.221609503,
0.2607823908,
0.5330720544,
-0.1963537037,
-1.1352300644,
0.005670649,
-0.8912123442,
-0.1141521037,
1.2084345818,
-0.4719003737,
-0.2394092232,
-0.1435703635,
-0.0932126939,
0.2456267774,
-0.2192617059,
0.8613967299,
0.604675591,
0.279027015,
-0.0772606656,
-0.491216898,
0.5329782367,
0.3648508489,
-0.7133952975,
0.4127274752,
0.1809344441,
0.6394817829,
-0.0134947598,
0.2391021699,
-0.3924983144,
0.0728168041,
0.2150921673,
0.1948930323,
-0.0538572855,
-0.1717419177,
-0.2994899154,
0.3086920679,
0.2412155122,
-0.1254324317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18191v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18191v2
|
Exploring the Robustness of In-Context Learning with Noisy Labels
| 2024-04-28T14:05:23 | 2024-05-01T09:15:16 |
Chen Cheng, Xinzhi Yu, Haodong Wen, Jingsong Sun, Guanzhang Yue, Yihao Zhang, Zeming Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG, math.OC
|
Recently, the mysterious In-Context Learning (ICL) ability exhibited by
Transformer architectures, especially in large language models (LLMs), has
sparked significant research interest. However, the resilience of Transformers'
in-context learning capabilities in the presence of noisy samples, prevalent in
both training corpora and prompt demonstrations, remains underexplored. In this
paper, inspired by prior research that studies ICL ability using simple
function classes, we take a closer look at this problem by investigating the
robustness of Transformers against noisy labels. Specifically, we first conduct
a thorough evaluation and analysis of the robustness of Transformers against
noisy labels during in-context learning and show that they exhibit notable
resilience against diverse types of noise in demonstration labels. Furthermore,
we delve deeper into this problem by exploring whether introducing noise into
the training set, akin to a form of data augmentation, enhances such robustness
during inference, and find that such noise can indeed improve the robustness of
ICL. Overall, our fruitful analysis and findings provide a comprehensive
understanding of the resilience of Transformer models against label noises
during ICL and provide valuable insights into the research on Transformers in
natural language processing. Our code is available at
https://github.com/InezYu0928/in-context-learning.
|
[
-0.504088819,
-0.5685591698,
0.1556081772,
0.055861406,
-0.0606630631,
0.1197478101,
-0.4919654131,
-0.7335036397,
-0.6036602259,
0.1892579049,
-0.5000359416,
-0.2238975167,
-0.5777623653,
0.2704446614,
-0.7593730092,
1.2318174839,
0.3142855167,
0.0026868151,
-0.5440117717,
-0.1931594014,
-0.2924055457,
-0.4541840553,
-0.4908301532,
-0.3773952425,
0.1923510432,
0.3824714422,
0.6954300404,
0.3126935661,
0.3540383875,
0.2751927376,
-0.3219526112,
0.0307340696,
-0.5760552287,
0.5570778251,
0.0886790529,
-0.5129801631,
0.0721233562,
-0.2984079123,
0.8801329732,
0.6642036438,
0.168633461,
0.0597803853,
0.6514067054,
0.3576919138,
-0.5007787943,
0.4289277792,
-1.000567317,
0.0497380793,
-0.1838437915,
0.1972738355,
-0.8100512028,
-0.0017431709,
0.1537008435,
-0.3257923126,
0.2579124272,
-0.0211236142,
1.0067759752,
0.9539065957,
-0.1072134301,
-0.3408996463,
-1.0253558159,
0.7867974043,
-0.4035875499,
0.7628477812,
0.5123804808,
0.2532117665,
-0.1859087199,
-1.1367913485,
-0.3738175333,
-0.3300127983,
-0.2726551592,
0.1534959674,
-0.4110431075,
-0.1126258895,
0.6105757952,
0.3812103271,
0.0458187722,
0.3168291152,
-0.2383319736,
-0.1383113861,
0.0364429802,
-0.1636867076,
0.2160798907,
0.3203333616,
-0.4702393115,
-0.3560957313,
-0.5078852773,
0.4597391486,
0.3722663522,
0.1820147336,
-0.124094516,
0.033010859,
0.2046032548,
0.6438276768,
0.265644908,
-0.4659629464,
0.1843598485,
-0.1892547011,
-0.0334104411,
0.1895204186,
0.6103236675,
-0.2229186893,
0.109097749,
-0.6111633182,
-0.4629190266,
-0.1097984612,
0.5229882002,
-0.9092322588,
-0.2943220735,
0.0496689044,
-0.3497503996,
-0.4144243598,
0.0010165141,
-0.6675846577,
-0.1847392172,
-0.1953127086,
0.5130717754,
-0.5804718137,
-0.0378545709,
-0.1029316559,
0.2316994071,
0.1270480454,
-0.109488219,
-0.959769249,
0.3406030536,
0.7109307051,
0.4311949015,
-0.0751986206,
-0.3084199429,
-0.6319120526,
-0.0749242604,
0.0320773162,
0.9183567762,
-0.4597196579,
-0.3647491336,
-0.1370952427,
-0.0222097933,
-0.2113361955,
-0.8358834386,
0.779500246,
-0.5326398015,
-0.150118053,
-0.0777789354,
-0.3391671181,
0.0952374786,
0.1377905905,
-0.6523287296,
1.2091984749,
0.292622298,
-0.9891789556,
0.6768696308,
-0.4722414017,
-0.6229800582,
-0.1750483215,
-0.1469525546,
-0.9898793697,
0.0409507081,
0.0979124531,
0.2600969076,
0.1030445993,
0.2949994802,
-0.2156811357,
-0.6623308659,
0.8262768984,
-0.965282023,
0.7762667537,
-0.0109652523,
-0.5348657966,
-0.04544615,
-0.9077525735,
-0.3876247406,
-0.2990094423,
-0.3998371661,
-0.0418685749,
0.1037996411,
-0.2842967212,
0.2535729408,
-0.2567580044,
-0.3731456995,
-0.1314201653,
-0.594291687,
0.3794735372,
0.6861231327,
-0.1548922956,
0.3907411397,
-0.3197792768,
0.416549027,
0.1681352258,
0.1323603839,
-0.2747033238,
-0.3385832012,
-0.759372592,
-0.5698968768,
0.3881566823,
0.1886250079,
-0.7318007946,
0.1785131097,
-0.2888908982,
-0.4478760958,
-0.5116066933,
0.1293048263,
0.2382380366,
1.16553545,
0.5637993813,
-0.0047346577,
-0.5064849257,
-0.814972043,
-0.2335600853,
-0.1161500216,
-0.1682381183,
0.1255523115,
0.3582613766,
-0.4138872027,
1.0866004229,
0.035895355,
-0.1185448989,
-0.1689802557,
0.0186579451,
0.0208681133,
0.2260442376,
0.5966808796,
-0.8117057085,
-0.4650710821,
-0.3562036753,
-0.4640181959,
-0.3841373324,
-0.1870700568,
0.1554740518,
0.1341542453,
0.7451411486,
-0.2250060439,
0.5956532359,
0.3741540909,
0.0275725592,
0.5574139357,
0.0181250777,
-0.4330955148,
-0.9411199093,
-0.231916219,
0.0387099832,
-0.1523292959,
-0.6288148165,
-0.2361999899,
0.0232104883,
0.0353621691,
-0.3861327767,
0.0831220374,
-0.2127023935,
0.0701417625,
-0.3953338861,
-0.1367430389,
-0.2453640848,
0.3193753362,
-0.1047838181,
0.9579337239,
0.9090862274,
-0.7481904626,
-0.3865860701,
0.276884824,
-0.486618191,
0.5387479067,
-0.3844931424,
-0.0376980975,
-0.3081204295,
0.3213235438,
-1.0708715916,
-0.3025787771,
0.2249438763,
-0.1503711194,
0.6846966147,
-0.114431873,
-0.5768050551,
-0.1476879567,
0.0409022905,
0.3372299969,
0.5563004017,
-1.1298779249,
0.3999367952,
0.4523771107,
0.2629577518,
-0.5137383938,
-0.7702389359,
-0.0802608281,
-0.5512079597,
-0.504922688,
0.3343349695,
-0.2839004099,
-0.4031075835,
-0.2935075164,
-0.3610725403,
-0.2016705722,
0.3846889734,
0.6178929806,
0.1380619109,
-0.1396266073,
0.2824255526,
-0.2603982985,
-0.3581195474,
0.2602345645,
-0.0150656067,
0.2840072811,
-0.4839687347,
-0.4086582661,
-0.3628892004,
-0.2715181708,
0.5963218212,
0.1488179862,
0.7365349531,
0.8800395131,
-0.2930961549,
-0.404044807,
-0.2678317428,
-0.4671014249,
-0.5890986919,
0.3989196718,
-0.2331741154,
-0.7581587434,
0.3249198496,
-0.1012265757,
0.114057675,
0.2297476679,
0.3666591942,
-0.2429601848,
0.649245739,
0.5789111853,
-0.1134362072,
0.5622196198,
-0.1100710109,
0.4552363157,
-0.7301490307,
-0.2059782892,
-0.6495978832,
-0.5539702177,
-0.4614455998,
-0.154863894,
0.493110925,
-0.0116508948,
-0.3282807171,
0.2889567614,
-0.5290448666,
0.4322752357,
0.483615756,
0.1102155074,
0.4351290464,
0.3911968768,
0.094445914,
-0.3947222531,
-0.7365153432,
-0.409111172,
0.5740945339,
0.5453386307,
0.9086738229,
-0.0731311142,
0.4497900009,
-0.1205934137,
0.6801247001,
-0.7845918536,
0.2369460762,
-0.0505478978,
-0.2553236187,
-0.2117565125,
-0.2040527165,
-0.9834444523,
0.1331190765,
-0.3176783919,
-1.0524946451,
0.314252317,
0.058972802,
-0.2900833189,
0.616720438,
-0.5572572351,
0.4815487266,
-0.0976052284,
-0.4215717316,
0.3178370297,
-0.8753720522,
0.2856519222,
-0.3072833717,
0.3864038587,
0.3656739891,
0.1718902141,
0.4746823907,
-0.1501047909,
1.2088389397,
0.23301965,
-0.3114649057,
0.4132156372,
0.0736854598,
0.4558437169,
0.1279801726,
-0.0335973054,
0.1380937845,
-0.3800848722,
0.0043311738,
-0.4975416362,
0.5218257904,
-0.702799499,
-0.2606364787,
-0.1573764235,
-0.8474849463,
-0.372202754,
-0.0175488871,
0.6712326407,
0.6008303165,
0.1854074746,
0.6522320509,
1.0217311382,
-0.0388976783,
0.844001472,
0.3044283986,
0.1518259943,
-0.2701701522,
1.1812769175,
0.3059417605,
0.4556735456,
0.2342954278,
0.1452674121,
-0.2497737706,
-0.4638434947,
-0.1704746634,
-0.3035925925,
-0.7782034278,
-0.2712039351,
-0.8397112489,
-0.5311713815,
0.1886807531,
-0.240138948,
-0.4645250738,
-0.3197200894,
-0.3140016794,
-0.1351718307,
0.0649429485,
0.7496423721,
0.0922800973,
0.3160647452,
-0.5222914219,
0.2255213261,
0.3779790699,
0.4290533364,
0.1459007561,
-0.7628157139,
-0.3552616835,
-0.0267717708,
-0.4688789546,
-0.4714765549,
0.1045032963,
0.2865486741,
0.483749181,
0.5412819386,
0.3446089923,
0.6223641038,
-0.0974489599,
0.6913273335,
-0.2449887842,
-0.6996600628,
0.01014785,
-0.0876054689,
0.3395338356,
0.674305141,
0.0985292718,
0.0175375957,
-0.8773024082,
-1.0019849539,
-0.9139457345,
0.6003994346,
0.3619598448,
0.050668329,
0.0884975493,
0.1446339935,
0.3337732852,
0.0282155909,
-1.0426590443,
-0.4029642642,
-0.3271890581,
-0.0817791447,
0.2007211894,
-0.2872593701,
0.0151340403,
-0.3811143935,
0.6090059876,
-0.1804502308,
-0.0166011862,
0.0493835136,
-0.261641711,
0.0157509558,
0.2972531021,
0.469009608,
0.2630575001,
-0.0817176923,
0.3583692312,
0.4628137946,
-0.6468012333,
0.0164397433,
0.2105478942,
-0.4578304291,
-0.0547945946,
0.5946950912,
0.7919794321,
0.7812507153,
-0.6739165187,
0.4119476676,
-0.3462870419,
-0.0596473999,
-0.3047255278,
0.0929550827,
-0.1301763654,
0.1321429014,
0.394092828,
0.6106461883,
0.0069666333,
-0.3239560127,
0.4942828417,
0.4205499887,
-0.8947922587,
-0.4157846272,
0.8982436061,
-0.2299147695,
-0.3969935179,
0.6779004335,
-0.1713567823,
-0.5254102349,
0.5117005706,
0.9742168784,
0.9228985906,
0.1791138053,
-0.0161493346,
0.3599151969,
0.3617304564,
-0.0508860163,
-0.352792263,
-0.3883391619,
-0.7179634571,
-0.3269768953,
-0.6343141198,
-0.4810401201,
0.0859778598,
-0.6236265302,
0.2196574211,
-0.1557120681,
-0.0700025335,
-0.3284470141,
-0.5035375953,
-0.5475224853,
0.0791952908,
0.1537297368,
0.7215161324,
-0.6550679207,
0.7711695433,
0.5260370374,
-0.0357559323,
-0.7787121534,
0.5504466295,
-0.178170979,
-0.4048742354,
0.6505960822,
0.4910879135,
-0.3332246244,
-0.1110546291,
-0.7239767909,
-0.7543393373,
1.0017119646,
0.6789916158,
-0.2608600259,
0.5502269268,
0.3964830637,
0.7236340046,
-0.1120819747,
0.291934371,
0.625752151,
0.4961082041,
0.1047782749,
-0.6619430184,
-0.1320856512,
0.0931970701,
-0.4650133848,
0.0095889065,
-0.8931526542,
0.4534565508,
-0.1202711761,
-0.3516492844,
-0.068508029,
0.9106740952,
0.0723128766,
0.3658288717,
0.8388799429,
0.5122631788,
0.8716910481,
-0.3615692556,
0.9813702106,
-0.4377246797,
0.1813383996,
1.2377948761,
0.132529363,
0.5027984977,
0.5569708347,
-0.1003643647,
0.4701255262,
0.40486148,
0.0162549093,
0.4487015307,
0.0334784389,
-0.5191595554,
-0.3528884947,
-0.2896600962,
-0.1477871686,
0.4917420149,
0.4349104464,
-0.1720294058,
-0.2838302851,
0.1760587841,
-0.1374952048,
0.0468533486,
0.0648279712,
0.7107297182,
0.1413713843,
-0.4974506199,
0.4710960388,
-0.6772575974,
0.7194669247,
-0.4254450798,
0.0842398405,
-0.0063582491,
0.2400608659,
-0.1918185055,
-0.7839643955,
0.58468014,
-0.260839045,
-0.1451852918,
-0.3488503695,
0.917798996,
-0.3359041214,
-0.3489660025,
0.2355583757,
-0.0219118483,
-0.0528080426,
0.2012019306,
-0.2754772305,
0.2247679532,
-0.0709708631,
-0.0979703143,
0.7108451724,
0.4119700193,
0.1670842469,
1.0543413162,
0.3540184796,
-0.368491292,
0.1272067428,
0.0289109685,
0.9635035396,
-0.0396172479,
-0.164748773,
-0.9587303996,
0.7160148621,
0.0059225955,
-0.3251029253,
0.7928450704,
0.6161510944,
1.0974485874,
-0.1449531466,
0.6175129414,
0.0904425532,
0.1943408847,
-0.2937516868,
0.7480792999,
-0.2198482305,
0.6354815364,
-0.3196302652,
-0.6908299923,
-0.452709049,
0.4231679738,
-0.0615484715,
-0.1489894986,
0.4707742929,
0.9244011641,
-0.3554692566,
0.2515376508,
0.4404330552,
0.4394616187,
0.3010297418,
0.086011067,
0.9711990356,
-0.4186339974,
0.9113903046,
-0.7601727247,
0.1037629321,
0.0300343558,
-0.7129299641,
-0.9337309599,
-0.6073379517,
-0.4171972871,
-0.6876490712,
-0.2942794561,
0.683797121,
0.5215632915,
-0.7819972634,
0.0243471637,
-0.0413566306,
0.2984271049,
-0.4288092852,
-0.2922939956,
0.3537731469,
-0.7181892991,
-0.964302361,
0.7111724615,
0.2306622416,
0.1891622692,
0.0092124147,
0.0532818697,
0.295136869,
-0.2213859558,
0.5199415684,
0.4278018177,
-0.347827822,
-0.4282360077,
-0.2482144535,
-0.0119372541,
0.2588697672,
0.5619053245,
-1.037406683,
0.591078639,
0.2465192974,
0.7702967525,
0.3387202621,
0.0049310755,
0.3602442741,
-0.9657284617,
0.4625316262,
0.178471908,
0.4139247537,
0.3342722952,
-0.3501647711,
0.5707713366,
0.1299755871,
-0.7875233293,
-1.1199971437,
0.2271715254,
-0.7841382623,
-0.0262722075,
1.1024366617,
0.1560787708,
-0.0912522599,
-0.4525780678,
-0.2701944113,
0.267654568,
-0.1879063994,
1.1764069796,
0.6638467908,
-0.1359042227,
-0.014441954,
-0.5785033703,
0.665610373,
0.3422089517,
-0.2919089198,
-0.0320690759,
-0.0560824871,
0.1698573232,
0.2167014778,
0.0047508469,
0.0639455691,
-0.0155240679,
0.0695903972,
-0.5001416802,
-0.093863897,
-0.3467569649,
-0.34381935,
0.3909664154,
0.2308464646,
0.037171036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18185v1
|
Ranked List Truncation for Large Language Model-based Re-Ranking
| 2024-04-28T13:39:33 | 2024-04-28T13:39:33 |
Chuan Meng, Negar Arabzadeh, Arian Askari, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.3.3
|
We study ranked list truncation (RLT) from a novel "retrieve-then-re-rank"
perspective, where we optimize re-ranking by truncating the retrieved list
(i.e., trim re-ranking candidates). RLT is crucial for re-ranking as it can
improve re-ranking efficiency by sending variable-length candidate lists to a
re-ranker on a per-query basis. It also has the potential to improve re-ranking
effectiveness. Despite its importance, there is limited research into applying
RLT methods to this new perspective. To address this research gap, we reproduce
existing RLT methods in the context of re-ranking, especially newly emerged
large language model (LLM)-based re-ranking. In particular, we examine to what
extent established findings on RLT for retrieval are generalizable to the
"retrieve-then-re-rank" setup from three perspectives: (i) assessing RLT
methods in the context of LLM-based re-ranking with lexical first-stage
retrieval, (ii) investigating the impact of different types of first-stage
retrievers on RLT methods, and (iii) investigating the impact of different
types of re-rankers on RLT methods. We perform experiments on the TREC 2019 and
2020 deep learning tracks, investigating 8 RLT methods for pipelines involving
3 retrievers and 2 re-rankers. We reach new insights into RLT methods in the
context of re-ranking.
|
[
-0.5266680717,
-0.747772336,
0.3596208394,
-0.1875294596,
-0.2691525221,
0.5120218992,
-0.2774412632,
-0.6425036788,
0.3808935285,
0.5924491882,
-0.6239615679,
-0.4584947526,
-0.5711997151,
0.0675032735,
-0.6785566211,
0.9748353362,
0.3610550165,
-0.4719862044,
-0.1750767827,
-0.0754000992,
-0.4024835825,
-0.7359067798,
-0.6740503907,
-0.2722939551,
0.8682197928,
0.5987733006,
0.7343316674,
0.6607858539,
0.7172123194,
0.1461221576,
-0.2745733559,
0.119572632,
-0.7631649971,
0.4542121589,
0.0359370485,
-0.3868792951,
-0.3678468466,
0.2884736955,
1.0634416342,
0.8031867146,
-0.3804362118,
0.4144220352,
0.2930338085,
0.6718457341,
-0.7717359066,
-0.3882853389,
-0.5285137296,
0.1374404281,
-0.3350133002,
-0.2747131884,
-0.83087641,
-0.494040072,
0.190550223,
-0.2143169641,
0.4157734215,
0.0843778253,
0.7588084936,
0.1479555517,
-0.3901065886,
0.2576288879,
-0.9424497485,
0.7921866179,
-0.7189131975,
0.8463346958,
0.1414827108,
0.3235805929,
0.0335227847,
-1.0272773504,
0.0722758248,
-0.5018880963,
-0.032967262,
-0.1151829734,
0.3324999511,
-0.1031622887,
0.2750393748,
0.4770034552,
-0.6202425957,
0.222598657,
-0.3561452925,
-0.134913221,
0.6759055257,
-0.082324177,
-0.0975186452,
0.0758726075,
-0.2741414905,
-0.1765304953,
-0.9173099399,
-0.0687050819,
0.3391675651,
0.3565645516,
0.3382711411,
0.4715561867,
-0.2042501718,
0.5957301855,
-0.0894209966,
0.0999650434,
-0.0028053138,
-0.3205372393,
0.0282998178,
-0.252573669,
0.4565829635,
0.2384018451,
0.2583053112,
-0.301527977,
-0.3702532947,
-0.605240047,
0.3617408276,
-0.6685494184,
-0.2044332325,
-0.0251875725,
-0.5941153765,
-0.3823791444,
0.1597243845,
-0.8767020702,
-0.3813197017,
0.055068288,
0.3220514655,
0.0152128702,
-0.3654822111,
-0.3350977004,
0.1137882248,
0.2542862594,
0.1466459036,
-0.637475431,
0.4053708613,
0.9302072525,
0.6488614082,
-0.3309687674,
-0.3052746654,
-0.9680495858,
-0.1613302976,
-0.1909113973,
0.7465948462,
-0.7148559093,
-0.5862646699,
0.156520918,
-0.2810609639,
0.0410477258,
-0.6477547288,
0.621511817,
-0.8132807612,
0.3672583103,
-0.0429030955,
-0.5909064412,
-0.049085144,
0.3481550217,
-0.8584964275,
1.1182303429,
-0.2667986453,
-0.4120712876,
0.3591879308,
-0.5073119998,
-0.3821841776,
0.10450425,
0.0297387037,
-0.5758436918,
0.1559194028,
0.1679674238,
0.2889707685,
-0.2757126093,
0.1965481788,
-0.2400236428,
-0.5298169851,
0.1164719462,
-0.5516657829,
0.4729607701,
0.2124622166,
-0.0475270152,
0.0000973296,
-0.5447801948,
0.5216408372,
0.0001611239,
-0.5596233606,
-0.1660949439,
-0.0425019935,
0.0209495407,
0.1127006784,
0.2654537857,
-0.5281398892,
0.376788497,
-0.556710124,
0.3732757866,
0.6408116817,
0.1468605548,
0.3181536496,
-0.1346673667,
0.7914159298,
-0.4963258505,
0.3104794323,
0.3134666979,
-0.100785464,
-0.7316403389,
-0.0548948683,
0.8856543303,
0.4104145467,
-0.367596209,
0.1695054173,
-0.5322798491,
-0.6219569445,
-0.5358893871,
-0.2150631994,
0.4258241355,
0.271061182,
0.1525029987,
-0.272252202,
-0.5834534168,
-0.9657088518,
-0.5998665094,
-0.1299967319,
0.3140975833,
0.2425513864,
0.2428159118,
0.05175687,
1.0423253775,
-0.6313053966,
-0.0166507717,
-0.3169379234,
0.0592500791,
0.1662584096,
0.3745533824,
0.0824935064,
-0.8480315804,
-0.3231983185,
-0.2827899456,
-0.307297051,
0.1167837605,
0.1839162409,
0.0288833864,
0.2580069304,
0.4705989659,
-0.2796026766,
0.5831884742,
0.230149731,
0.0149451988,
0.7469251156,
-0.2108110189,
0.2016042322,
-0.7650758624,
0.1444991082,
-0.1430615783,
-0.5072646737,
-0.6468218565,
0.3574742973,
0.1313491464,
-0.0989557207,
-0.5594065785,
0.5586286783,
-0.4563409686,
-0.3581340611,
-0.1510779858,
0.4105361998,
0.0476763546,
0.2128759623,
0.0314948708,
0.7853364348,
-0.0472760461,
-0.6209314466,
0.1564121246,
0.1092251614,
-0.2073921561,
-0.0910108536,
-0.423229903,
0.3250817657,
0.0529612117,
0.3084908128,
-0.9003170729,
0.3556517065,
0.1421553642,
-0.3848517239,
0.3978134096,
-0.3653321862,
-0.452660501,
-0.4624535143,
-0.3335084617,
0.8026615977,
0.2661343217,
-0.4930143654,
0.1275531948,
0.3078339696,
-0.1863520592,
-1.0022763014,
-0.5430085063,
0.2593758106,
-0.4181731939,
-0.2225053161,
0.3905749321,
-0.2094051242,
-0.0487143137,
-0.1122397631,
-0.2695516646,
-0.0532838516,
0.2651234567,
-0.1093986109,
0.2414168417,
0.0177477375,
-0.0329459906,
-0.4397708476,
-0.1020637453,
-0.0816768706,
-0.2385930121,
0.5779306293,
-0.3301588595,
-0.5037679672,
-0.26452443,
0.4259464443,
0.4875662327,
-0.6677038074,
0.7317193151,
0.5924651623,
-0.2531321645,
-0.0358549096,
-0.833212316,
-0.3638544381,
-0.4161037803,
0.4991491139,
-0.3992337883,
-1.2554365396,
0.6140057445,
0.0738929808,
0.4483623207,
0.3807784617,
0.3191963434,
0.0054029152,
0.7648105025,
0.7578529716,
-0.0494986326,
0.5725086331,
-0.4439705908,
0.3923079073,
-1.0438156128,
-0.2360419035,
-0.5503323078,
-0.566209197,
-0.8557931781,
-0.0904099941,
0.0859205946,
-0.1939780563,
-0.1517979354,
0.1258560568,
-0.5712207556,
0.5924464464,
0.6376757026,
0.1332240701,
0.3561258316,
0.1896276474,
-0.3011685014,
-0.1311004311,
-0.564855516,
-0.1974809915,
1.1882776022,
0.3951966763,
0.5764144063,
0.2374542356,
0.9858859181,
0.5825819969,
0.1462452561,
-0.8332316875,
0.7355179191,
-0.1477226764,
-0.511144042,
-0.5798311234,
-0.4431944788,
-1.0448100567,
0.5047007203,
-0.014147277,
-0.6776689887,
0.2387711257,
-0.0322437361,
-0.379899025,
0.4436160326,
-0.317713052,
0.5612065196,
-0.0607103035,
-0.4938352704,
-0.3215512037,
-0.7751951218,
0.3412519395,
0.0910088643,
0.1716289818,
0.0792358592,
-0.099071607,
0.9231184721,
-0.3781477213,
0.5055418015,
-0.2461269647,
-0.2028386444,
0.0020238769,
0.2642561197,
0.7489689589,
0.0416674204,
-0.2619804144,
0.0107279262,
0.1064356714,
-0.2343224883,
-0.6829687953,
0.7120121717,
-0.593580842,
-1.060532093,
-0.3902009726,
-0.3295348883,
-0.2154019773,
0.4539894462,
0.1229772866,
0.5801488161,
-0.2280992717,
0.4756999612,
0.5989651084,
-0.0531989373,
0.2831037641,
0.3965265453,
-0.5209326744,
-0.4159110487,
0.8455166221,
0.3179807365,
0.3021616936,
0.5615103245,
0.0549678169,
-0.513820231,
-0.7542530894,
0.1622547805,
0.3721044362,
-0.5480523705,
0.0318048261,
-0.4219243228,
-0.7215410471,
-0.5164209008,
0.2264371067,
-0.6141889691,
-0.8275436759,
-0.0845819041,
-0.1299909353,
0.0641922429,
0.6456463933,
-0.0505666807,
0.111879468,
-0.6787124276,
0.0079145124,
0.0749770552,
0.5222850442,
0.0442819819,
-0.6293185353,
-0.4791717529,
0.0206067394,
-0.1703874171,
-0.4274058044,
0.3563421369,
0.2455009818,
0.7355090976,
0.1934983879,
0.0823296756,
0.8007749915,
-0.5085344315,
0.8365444541,
-0.164652735,
-0.3741430044,
0.5236093998,
-0.0631489456,
0.0578945763,
0.6277814507,
-0.0658637807,
-0.9007530212,
-0.4248276651,
-0.7493953109,
-1.0439456701,
0.4787395298,
0.1790420115,
-0.2041489929,
0.0145107144,
0.7384892106,
0.1107348651,
0.2677862942,
-0.7420517802,
-0.5203621387,
0.242251277,
0.1796662509,
-0.2048292458,
-0.7273999453,
0.1335314065,
-0.041173365,
0.7333567142,
0.4033019245,
0.1911697388,
0.1578831077,
-0.3257497549,
0.0300080962,
0.5529561639,
0.6773586869,
0.7326839566,
-0.4611026943,
0.1260402054,
0.0315896869,
-0.5292124748,
0.2463300228,
-0.0082017928,
-0.169502303,
-0.1577683985,
0.3263133168,
0.5099875927,
0.2433745414,
-0.5351631045,
0.1190377474,
-0.1580929905,
-0.2263331264,
-0.2928805649,
-0.0754912198,
-0.1407440007,
0.1975414902,
0.4985595047,
-0.0727509931,
0.2353959233,
-0.283690989,
0.6394138932,
0.6314629316,
-0.3503567576,
0.0533707142,
0.5356912613,
0.2424573451,
-0.548420608,
0.9135303497,
0.2701082528,
-0.4634462893,
0.4655303061,
0.3020901978,
0.82193923,
-0.2797231376,
0.1962839216,
0.2878654897,
0.382063359,
-0.0762262791,
-0.127286911,
-0.0548233427,
-0.4653501213,
-0.6729936004,
-0.3717295825,
-0.3871080279,
0.2061161548,
-1.0514079332,
0.0848505273,
-0.3020248413,
-0.3455674648,
-0.4746804535,
0.5912001729,
-0.5559641719,
0.0156202735,
0.1131423116,
1.0941056013,
-0.5038430095,
0.64496243,
0.6695023775,
-0.1719859093,
-0.653093338,
0.3872058094,
-0.1576856524,
-0.6536748409,
0.5657498837,
0.0706197768,
-0.2896267176,
0.421484679,
-0.1826784015,
-1.1719117165,
1.1036425829,
0.2503229678,
-0.5863838792,
-0.2436647117,
0.2258260995,
0.3080840707,
-0.2447892725,
0.3804717362,
0.6463506222,
0.4205174446,
0.0231756773,
-0.9571954012,
-0.0508641675,
-0.0986161307,
0.0866344795,
0.4031760991,
-0.8543946743,
0.3709909022,
-0.2133842558,
-0.2113521844,
0.1956055611,
0.7971894741,
0.4845937788,
0.1653764546,
0.636348784,
0.5512359142,
0.8418784738,
0.1704283953,
0.8377633691,
-0.0128940111,
0.6445403695,
1.2315883636,
-0.3022690415,
1.1386716366,
0.4486174881,
-0.2132129073,
0.4132386744,
0.8787305355,
0.089592889,
0.5440656543,
0.2828573287,
-0.0630058125,
-0.4345213473,
-0.0873683095,
-0.5226564407,
0.1650987417,
0.2741308808,
-0.2589178085,
-0.2796177268,
0.094273895,
-0.1658722758,
-0.1126106828,
-0.1556088775,
0.5529330373,
0.1119602025,
-0.6679298878,
0.8037452698,
-0.0545679182,
0.4047523141,
-0.0587642379,
0.0170003679,
-0.4205965698,
0.0243523382,
-0.0590011999,
-0.9654819369,
0.0827334449,
-0.1193737984,
-0.2732596993,
-0.351567626,
0.7811478376,
-0.4681505561,
-0.4728661776,
0.2235773206,
0.8189373016,
0.3853715062,
-0.0058585769,
-0.6800145507,
0.1233687773,
0.2177187353,
-0.4811986983,
0.4146956503,
0.1298041791,
-0.0732212588,
1.099573493,
0.4680911303,
0.1283913404,
0.1066088453,
0.3583225608,
0.6152830124,
-0.7219126225,
-0.3743255436,
-0.796705544,
0.3744986653,
0.0897519812,
0.2498773634,
0.4573063254,
0.7969747186,
0.5937951803,
0.1738935858,
0.5563352108,
0.0831696168,
0.8366113305,
-0.3683618009,
0.8157458305,
-0.932659626,
0.6201780438,
-0.0408158414,
-0.9829569459,
-0.4692629278,
0.2523037791,
-0.3793963194,
0.3339331746,
0.7006521225,
0.6832526326,
0.0569421276,
-0.2101944834,
0.4204855859,
0.2649284005,
0.5231588483,
0.3198543191,
0.9059743881,
-0.3334250152,
0.9474747181,
-0.3409820795,
0.0941566825,
-0.5813592672,
-0.7664772868,
-0.4178591073,
-0.4669450223,
-0.4670494497,
-0.2921527028,
0.3013162017,
0.7344422936,
0.6056316495,
-0.4441971779,
-0.2214926928,
0.2813287973,
0.4073475897,
-0.397287637,
-0.2566190064,
0.5392060876,
-0.095469065,
-0.6132054329,
0.4134232998,
0.0018996729,
-0.407956183,
-0.2838139832,
0.1157309264,
-0.4778097868,
-0.5027328134,
0.5878323317,
0.3828054368,
-0.9710270762,
-0.533778429,
-0.0593007617,
0.117491588,
0.1114273295,
0.7360849977,
-1.1269618273,
0.1092550978,
0.3556490242,
0.5307021141,
0.4171552956,
0.3144514263,
0.5648418665,
-1.0419276953,
-0.1398664415,
0.3359321654,
0.034237884,
0.0732506216,
-0.4295032918,
0.5951895714,
0.1633160263,
-0.8120605946,
-1.144297123,
0.312287122,
-0.7577440739,
0.0185125582,
0.9765771627,
0.0285065789,
0.0364017002,
0.1927744895,
0.0565393269,
0.3420270085,
-0.3832121193,
0.533588469,
0.6966139674,
-0.1255299002,
-0.7297649384,
-0.7061852813,
0.2537167072,
0.4277939498,
-0.4336929917,
0.3277143538,
0.3702156246,
0.4704090953,
-0.0553101972,
0.3927586675,
-0.1127210706,
0.1076344699,
-0.6354240179,
0.024157146,
-0.0533012673,
-0.3526428044,
-0.1027552187,
0.4517018497,
0.4257028699,
-0.1401494592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18180v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18180v1
|
EkoHate: Abusive Language and Hate Speech Detection for Code-switched Political Discussions on Nigerian Twitter
| 2024-04-28T13:25:11 | 2024-04-28T13:25:11 |
Comfort Eseohen Ilevbare, Jesujoba O. Alabi, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Firdous Damilola Bakare, Oluwatoyin Bunmi Abiola, Oluwaseyi Adesina Adeyemo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nigerians have a notable online presence and actively discuss political and
topical matters. This was particularly evident throughout the 2023 general
election, where Twitter was used for campaigning, fact-checking and
verification, and even positive and negative discourse. However, little or none
has been done in the detection of abusive language and hate speech in Nigeria.
In this paper, we curated code-switched Twitter data directed at three
musketeers of the governorship election on the most populous and economically
vibrant state in Nigeria; Lagos state, with the view to detect offensive speech
in political discussions. We developed EkoHate -- an abusive language and hate
speech dataset for political discussions between the three candidates and their
followers using a binary (normal vs offensive) and fine-grained four-label
annotation scheme. We analysed our dataset and provided an empirical evaluation
of state-of-the-art methods across both supervised and cross-lingual transfer
learning settings. In the supervised setting, our evaluation results in both
binary and four-label annotation schemes show that we can achieve 95.1 and 70.3
F1 points respectively. Furthermore, we show that our dataset adequately
transfers very well to three publicly available offensive datasets (OLID,
HateUS2020, and FountaHate), generalizing to political discussions in other
regions like the US.
|
[
-0.5726034641,
-0.8679897785,
0.2939413786,
0.1412269473,
-0.3972608447,
0.0117559517,
-0.2979676127,
-0.7052972913,
0.5869566798,
0.7799500227,
-0.075534232,
-0.5993344188,
-0.8723595142,
0.258833915,
-0.6431745291,
1.3892031908,
0.0063806749,
-0.243387267,
0.5115587711,
-0.5014740825,
-0.147031188,
-0.4803576469,
-0.4964035451,
0.0458070375,
0.4011137187,
0.2984002531,
0.5605718493,
0.410595417,
0.1451116502,
0.2724297643,
0.1642643809,
-0.0090553844,
-0.6129769683,
0.2215165049,
-0.2014337033,
-0.294847846,
-0.2078157514,
-0.2702668905,
0.1997299939,
-0.025506435,
-0.1583130658,
0.1734661311,
-0.0112976376,
0.3945371807,
-0.799480319,
0.0853775814,
-1.1577194929,
-0.0949250609,
-0.6250298023,
-0.0217867531,
-0.0308658872,
-0.564353168,
-0.1246687099,
-0.6039652228,
-0.0267238878,
-0.2245205343,
0.6581466794,
0.0219673123,
-0.4128456414,
-0.7803088427,
-0.4896971285,
0.6452098489,
-0.6508589387,
0.150645569,
0.5326565504,
0.3530609012,
0.104923211,
-0.3759573102,
-0.764016211,
0.0569402725,
0.0520061217,
0.086644128,
-0.2007180899,
-0.0533715338,
-0.1084089875,
0.1238343045,
0.0286975,
0.1402705163,
-0.3276077509,
-0.5063972473,
0.7273064852,
-0.0783744305,
0.3451573551,
-0.4316706955,
-0.4964685738,
0.0181063637,
-0.3805273175,
-0.2761282921,
0.9333105087,
0.6794078946,
-0.0135690058,
0.0893361419,
-0.1919507235,
0.3277488649,
0.0698136017,
0.0050309328,
0.3307629228,
0.002881485,
0.0460720062,
0.3333511055,
1.1832858324,
0.4102026522,
0.3471046686,
0.0365107283,
-0.3214328289,
0.5158879757,
0.3748823702,
-0.9391275644,
-0.1701337248,
0.298453629,
-0.1277617067,
-0.6307808161,
-0.3685019314,
-1.4363409281,
-0.9571098089,
0.1295142919,
0.3800896406,
-0.2099304646,
-0.2849636972,
-0.2807340026,
-0.0410555266,
-0.1422979236,
0.4635639489,
-0.9865137935,
0.2131576687,
0.5383921266,
0.4560439289,
-0.2671524584,
0.1252824366,
-0.2006061673,
-0.0741364807,
-0.2516352534,
0.5630576015,
-0.6273685098,
-0.0533702224,
0.3376167417,
-0.1958491355,
0.190534085,
-0.7824510932,
0.9162648916,
-0.6714276671,
0.0670526698,
0.0313733779,
-0.2534109652,
-0.300483942,
0.1887977719,
-0.7071647048,
1.0270097256,
0.236092791,
-0.5061252713,
0.4481021464,
-0.6752964258,
-0.4160506427,
0.1018512845,
-0.1376567632,
-0.6468105316,
-0.2204066515,
0.3580104113,
0.4688641727,
-0.0161331221,
0.2766473889,
-0.4790922701,
0.0014902721,
0.1009549424,
-0.1400834471,
0.8776509166,
0.3069801629,
-0.8786779046,
0.0251071472,
-0.8081179261,
-0.2161026001,
0.0008999129,
-0.0824909136,
-0.4058920741,
-0.0104991505,
0.5224080086,
0.3346605301,
-0.1042514741,
-0.9511997104,
-0.1582359821,
-0.0282804687,
0.3331771791,
0.9852750897,
-0.1135065705,
0.1971811056,
-0.2383007109,
0.5414886475,
0.0356452912,
-0.079120189,
0.4151009917,
-0.6378433704,
-0.33539626,
0.0274665244,
0.1266306788,
0.7603377104,
-0.7881430984,
0.0203365944,
-0.2981157005,
-0.2422999442,
-0.6539654136,
0.0648921952,
0.1420240402,
0.2167136222,
0.4920829535,
0.1963583678,
-0.6456203461,
-0.8308796287,
-0.6244302988,
-0.2476696521,
0.1911328733,
0.3936325014,
0.7644246817,
-0.1526588053,
0.6549897194,
0.1582426727,
-0.508320868,
-0.0371620655,
0.3436292112,
-0.1547499001,
0.0619311817,
0.8690245152,
-0.9886118174,
-0.8903321028,
0.276476711,
-0.24381724,
-0.5390285254,
-0.0596854575,
-0.1639656276,
0.2483679205,
0.2074070126,
0.1017913967,
0.4212907255,
0.8130745888,
-0.3581790924,
0.4990284145,
0.8182404041,
0.6323669553,
-1.1374503374,
-0.1047312096,
-0.2030244917,
-0.6587407589,
-0.6713698506,
0.0146390432,
-0.2659312487,
0.0368829891,
-0.4335848391,
0.5470133424,
-0.0335745923,
0.4605749846,
-0.2524251342,
0.2419901043,
-0.5714530945,
0.4579941034,
0.1114215627,
0.6727690101,
0.2663694918,
-0.2943273485,
0.5622178912,
0.2612781823,
-0.3771369457,
0.8190641999,
-0.1574326009,
0.4157947302,
0.2022033185,
-0.0545051694,
-0.9286321998,
-0.1545164883,
0.7460118532,
-0.4432500005,
0.070643045,
-0.2749498487,
-0.1983082741,
-0.035441272,
-0.3643283844,
0.2232707739,
0.0522104874,
-0.4498949647,
0.5416995287,
0.9463403821,
-0.2196798921,
-0.6770364046,
-0.5273701549,
0.2453726679,
-0.5684785247,
-0.1749910116,
0.432228446,
0.3093797565,
-0.1049426645,
0.1725873351,
0.0197023004,
-0.2289730757,
-0.1364002079,
0.1709126979,
-0.1139858142,
-0.1227533221,
-0.1336092651,
0.0145201432,
0.3656896353,
0.3190816045,
0.0514899902,
0.427663058,
-0.2326418459,
0.3168366849,
-0.1780758798,
0.3781892955,
0.3639783859,
0.1841411442,
0.7884058356,
0.7164294124,
-0.4302518666,
-0.3594969809,
-0.3012234569,
-0.1297570318,
-0.3687083125,
0.6441967487,
-0.1329973191,
-0.9647558928,
0.6813443303,
0.0590877905,
0.2601133883,
0.2596024275,
0.6726421714,
-0.0429874621,
0.6662159562,
0.1543458551,
-0.2805648446,
0.5386174321,
-0.0374498554,
0.2039438486,
-0.5138491988,
0.2225252986,
-0.7594584823,
-0.4574151337,
-0.9109713435,
-0.1671203077,
0.2707622945,
-0.1720313579,
-0.124202393,
0.3786685169,
-0.3433943987,
0.287537992,
-0.0908748284,
0.2662183642,
-0.0146684274,
0.2015795857,
0.1484155655,
-0.1172599271,
-0.366073668,
-0.3976204395,
1.1911600828,
0.0094976109,
0.4839703739,
0.2961189151,
0.7166338563,
0.6055296063,
0.91377002,
-0.7880682945,
0.3606644571,
-0.1631484777,
-1.0733126402,
-0.5674886107,
-0.7287461162,
-1.0338499546,
0.3669452965,
-0.3237262666,
-0.886855185,
0.2950084209,
0.0943984017,
-0.0480915867,
0.870701015,
-0.1795704961,
0.765440166,
-0.118917428,
-0.3884399831,
-0.2020033002,
-0.495852977,
0.3458478153,
-0.2231468856,
0.7190734148,
-0.1257446408,
-0.0787496045,
1.1212859154,
-0.3943285942,
0.7441961765,
-0.1788291484,
-0.2858592272,
0.2750236988,
0.0898121968,
0.3043200076,
-0.3422281146,
-0.1620630622,
0.4844132066,
-0.177380383,
-0.0879777223,
-0.4469821453,
0.567143321,
-0.6696833372,
-0.2258958519,
-0.3961051702,
-0.4049954712,
-0.2318068147,
0.2832685709,
0.2425973415,
0.3809089959,
-0.3315815628,
0.2665553391,
0.3318458796,
-0.1236180291,
0.0579889417,
0.0938801989,
-0.3134348691,
-0.6009464264,
0.8672354221,
-0.0228897147,
0.1888696104,
0.2070042193,
0.2977603078,
-0.4219539762,
-0.333438307,
-0.6909051538,
-0.0220198222,
-0.6726143956,
-0.3972338438,
-0.5653017163,
0.2332805693,
-0.2950276136,
-0.1090629622,
-0.5095757842,
-0.513014853,
0.0321355797,
0.1571948081,
0.4078306258,
0.7808940411,
-0.1875166148,
0.4597131014,
-0.3793074191,
0.6130037904,
0.1396143883,
0.329691112,
-0.3603793681,
-0.8056534529,
-0.0966125354,
0.2435690612,
-0.6742136478,
-1.6118408442,
0.1407291442,
0.3032027483,
0.2685251832,
0.4979095459,
0.3689196408,
0.4607191682,
-0.2282269299,
0.4665576518,
0.0273526143,
-0.7184637189,
0.5337184668,
-0.3658460975,
-0.3270093203,
0.6836861968,
0.684269309,
-0.5831489563,
-0.6842122674,
-0.5857290626,
-0.6548386216,
0.7920339108,
0.3445637226,
0.3008044362,
-0.1123559698,
-0.0445614196,
0.1344409883,
0.3530045748,
-0.886937499,
-0.7399312258,
-0.2031275481,
-0.0828816965,
0.3589974344,
-0.1401924938,
-0.1841608584,
-0.1407225728,
0.8830019832,
-0.0066178404,
0.2370322347,
-0.232934013,
-0.0639631823,
-0.1152228042,
0.5675606728,
0.2303551733,
0.5040258765,
-0.2068950236,
-0.1960858554,
-0.1008723453,
-0.7997330427,
0.1637127697,
0.2147893757,
-0.2683185041,
0.2427506894,
-0.0826437622,
0.837808311,
0.0904029682,
-0.261272341,
0.5171350837,
0.1249750406,
-0.3467012644,
-0.0470525809,
-0.1902412027,
-0.0573220812,
-0.2372008264,
0.0891837701,
0.0969035253,
0.4134958684,
-0.8158037663,
0.1638908684,
0.2476506531,
-0.4533060491,
-0.2031368464,
0.7640565038,
0.62639153,
-0.1966682076,
0.4120816588,
-0.2524677813,
-1.0674874783,
0.458617866,
0.5125049353,
0.7985399961,
-0.545684576,
0.5373097658,
0.5113002062,
0.4878182113,
0.6821469069,
0.4127773345,
-0.2420529872,
-1.1926091909,
-0.0933279991,
-0.6811571717,
-0.155273214,
0.5728729367,
-0.8616539836,
0.1634993106,
-0.5806282759,
-0.3477910161,
0.045948498,
0.0980878472,
-0.4772762954,
0.0260290485,
0.3689440191,
0.3812611103,
-1.1172540188,
0.3313193023,
0.7727842331,
0.0844823197,
-0.3436233103,
-0.2911055982,
0.1750234812,
-0.8053530455,
0.3151569664,
0.1513502598,
-0.2529858053,
-0.1127723083,
-0.6032355428,
-0.2123599201,
0.2556682527,
0.3277247846,
-0.5371393561,
0.6138732433,
0.4070388079,
0.3459696472,
-0.0760450289,
0.2256657183,
0.6701767445,
0.4024416506,
-0.1909967363,
-0.9305358529,
0.1472944766,
-0.2511151731,
-0.3405975997,
0.8151608706,
-0.5003085732,
0.4851247668,
0.0725775361,
-0.4414189458,
-0.1116569415,
0.408640027,
-0.0214719195,
0.3397493958,
0.6184082031,
0.6915973425,
0.5392280817,
-0.2033574879,
0.9055126905,
-0.1449386477,
0.2892674208,
1.0280649662,
-0.1145834699,
0.7513574958,
0.3370687068,
-0.3748517036,
0.6651901007,
0.2254023999,
0.369959414,
0.4084355235,
0.196845144,
-0.2894043326,
-0.0801688954,
-0.2104854733,
-0.3756071627,
0.5673306584,
0.8099685907,
-0.1517529786,
-0.3532719314,
0.1123344377,
0.5525636673,
0.3749364614,
-0.3243512511,
0.7016844749,
-0.1061626524,
-0.2188018709,
0.6206387281,
0.061688263,
0.7945272326,
-0.54187572,
-0.3354928792,
0.0105978735,
-0.0475141481,
-0.1921372116,
-0.9618722796,
0.367623508,
0.1070525795,
0.274645865,
-0.1823860854,
0.481639415,
-0.5581334233,
-0.1032381728,
0.3313803375,
-0.0806325227,
0.3409048617,
-0.3026060462,
-0.9652318954,
0.1998634785,
0.0197511613,
0.0329200551,
0.2387869656,
0.6053499579,
-0.2606796622,
0.2814723253,
0.6432572603,
0.3873165548,
0.2428961098,
-0.0264742542,
0.7372326255,
-0.2534335256,
-0.6522480845,
-0.6541515589,
0.0674583092,
-0.1477628052,
-0.7812247276,
0.6906696558,
0.5070334673,
1.0862253904,
0.1138567924,
0.9369542599,
-0.4579755664,
0.6360624433,
-0.3864224851,
0.7056043744,
-0.3823584616,
-0.1534195691,
-0.5854292512,
-0.7674792409,
-0.1721450686,
0.7678384781,
-0.2827466428,
0.071439229,
0.4458575547,
0.829859376,
-0.1141156331,
0.2994142175,
0.2624943256,
0.5523149371,
0.2564689517,
0.4737896919,
0.8735066056,
-0.6687613726,
0.660505414,
-0.5584108233,
-0.2845992446,
-0.3325246572,
-0.7784357071,
-0.771581471,
-0.5510126352,
-0.3010470271,
-0.5601008534,
0.2165359706,
0.6143592,
0.547131896,
-1.2668998241,
-0.3497211337,
0.2287931293,
0.1058095917,
-0.0344116539,
-0.2985835671,
0.2866010368,
0.1314078569,
-0.7566486597,
-0.2022481859,
0.0266124737,
-0.5150373578,
0.1108884588,
0.0260189902,
-0.3815644979,
-0.0307668615,
0.673253119,
0.4412026703,
-0.5781170726,
-0.3217918277,
-0.4840589762,
-0.0480182879,
0.038226869,
0.6528856754,
-0.6325143576,
0.5363976359,
0.2454188317,
0.788875103,
0.2237293571,
0.1989632845,
0.1225279644,
-0.4505337775,
0.2127364725,
0.5097123981,
0.158349365,
0.3199364543,
-0.3139592409,
0.3173053861,
0.3294006884,
-0.7083643079,
-0.6382165551,
0.020273082,
-0.7079959512,
-0.0224925708,
1.0638995171,
0.149367094,
-0.2402623892,
-0.4320675731,
-0.2024325877,
0.1070129052,
-0.765715003,
1.0586465597,
0.7472906113,
0.0681714416,
0.0691703856,
-0.840642035,
0.6807194948,
0.2761697769,
-0.9526750445,
-0.0220873952,
0.5465816855,
0.2643657625,
0.177247256,
0.6654248834,
-0.2252410054,
0.4748185873,
-0.0334663279,
0.0219095722,
0.3517116606,
-0.2516814172,
-0.0490072966,
-0.0613075607,
-0.7337613702,
-0.451780498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18154v1
|
Explaining vague language
| 2024-04-28T12:11:34 | 2024-04-28T12:11:34 |
Paul Égré, Benjamin Spector
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.IT, math.IT, 91A86, I.2.7
|
Why is language vague? Vagueness may be explained and rationalized if it can
be shown that vague language is more useful to speaker and hearer than precise
language. In a well-known paper, Lipman proposes a game-theoretic account of
vagueness in terms of mixed strategy that leads to a puzzle: vagueness cannot
be strictly better than precision at equilibrium. More recently, \'Egr\'e,
Spector, Mortier and Verheyen have put forward a Bayesian account of vagueness
establishing that using vague words can be strictly more informative than using
precise words. This paper proposes to compare both results and to explain why
they are not in contradiction. Lipman's definition of vagueness relies
exclusively on a property of signaling strategies, without making any
assumptions about the lexicon, whereas \'Egr\'e et al.'s involves a layer of
semantic content. We argue that the semantic account of vagueness is needed,
and more adequate and explanatory of vagueness.
|
[
-0.3813049793,
-0.886903286,
0.8644590974,
0.1483359933,
-0.3177243173,
-0.1666137725,
-0.3831944764,
-0.5400984883,
0.3568605781,
0.3939361274,
-0.4413607717,
-0.1602645814,
-0.6217780709,
0.0471551977,
-0.5663923025,
1.0988131762,
0.235428676,
-0.1941188574,
0.159203425,
0.0398833975,
-0.2060060054,
-0.1472303122,
-0.6738453507,
-0.4692524672,
0.6158860922,
0.3451663852,
1.1749150753,
0.6135472059,
0.470652163,
0.3816516995,
-0.0980595276,
-0.5889155269,
-0.2817590237,
0.1835045069,
-0.1474698931,
-0.7222595215,
-0.0050643543,
-0.3238942921,
0.4509125352,
1.0972880125,
-0.2293412387,
-0.0949259624,
0.1314701885,
0.5879971385,
-0.4907613397,
-0.0480715558,
-0.6288102269,
-0.0693312362,
-0.3912718892,
-0.1868193448,
0.2751755118,
-0.2023679465,
0.6531540155,
-0.9543386102,
0.5719476938,
-0.0915880874,
1.2006380558,
0.2261930257,
-0.2515823841,
-0.5564546585,
-1.0449904203,
0.6215956807,
-0.8431974649,
0.0882642493,
0.3137843013,
0.2378986478,
-0.1239531413,
-0.4622254968,
-0.6734261513,
-0.2973537445,
0.2450377047,
0.369594723,
-0.0843957737,
0.4475503564,
0.3899477124,
0.3673314154,
-0.3917837441,
-0.1105808318,
-0.2355541438,
-0.1265541315,
0.4223003983,
-0.0843753368,
-0.0209087115,
-0.1880476475,
-0.5200898647,
0.2140227258,
-0.2211234123,
0.0978156775,
0.3433763683,
0.1868956834,
0.1067115888,
0.4086642265,
-0.1632712483,
0.5783401132,
0.0312553905,
-0.0714468285,
-0.200368166,
-0.2019663602,
0.0987651646,
-0.2003962994,
0.6814268827,
0.3414978087,
0.169270277,
-0.4612625539,
-0.3782241046,
-0.0307714865,
0.0089592095,
-0.6062811017,
-0.1543487906,
0.3703205287,
-0.3302364647,
0.2337682843,
0.1608317196,
-0.7379649878,
-0.0935469195,
0.1358917356,
0.3201027215,
-0.2881758213,
-0.3169175386,
0.4522815049,
-0.5022885203,
0.3255858719,
0.1536201537,
-0.958290875,
0.8594593406,
0.7117420435,
0.6293766499,
0.0618835054,
-0.2942661941,
0.1182267442,
0.3040063083,
-0.3996716142,
0.9468011856,
-0.4958373904,
-0.3818362951,
0.1213299781,
-0.4244090319,
0.2405215651,
-0.6833897233,
0.5974849463,
-0.1268594116,
0.4885602295,
-0.3643017113,
-0.7347797751,
-0.1957878619,
-0.3596299887,
-0.333332926,
0.8488492966,
0.0986382365,
-0.6035090685,
0.9584324956,
-0.283395648,
-0.3494238555,
0.4697802067,
-0.2494333684,
-0.0361510292,
0.5874541402,
-0.3009586334,
0.2177856565,
-0.3453564346,
0.394382596,
-0.4633287191,
-0.5503700376,
0.8432973027,
-0.3343438506,
-0.0225557014,
0.3871711493,
-0.5413758159,
-0.2975393832,
-0.5750602484,
0.2435155511,
0.0237214901,
-0.3493189216,
-0.3726665378,
0.3982229531,
-0.0407843404,
0.1339146942,
0.3408934176,
-0.4506016076,
-0.2640978694,
-0.6567152739,
0.2311594039,
0.4433530271,
-0.1383053064,
0.6824947,
-0.6012063622,
0.3749406338,
-0.3116689324,
0.2741515338,
0.2967473269,
-0.5889597535,
-0.8035973907,
-0.3631725609,
0.409899503,
0.5752552748,
-0.4731599987,
0.0308947545,
-0.263692379,
0.2029131651,
-0.5248135328,
0.0113494154,
0.2838754952,
0.1959703714,
0.0760595128,
-0.569609642,
-0.3554937243,
-0.9818194509,
-0.5775971413,
-0.2227602899,
-0.1445386559,
0.4405597746,
0.378932327,
0.2659130096,
0.8469925523,
-0.3378898203,
0.0630313233,
-0.3151238263,
0.0410943814,
0.3794063032,
0.2615390122,
0.313544631,
-0.7777451873,
-0.2530537844,
-0.0742488876,
-0.5493782759,
-0.2314828634,
-0.2693220675,
0.1783425659,
-0.3824626505,
0.2149516642,
-0.5557155609,
0.4545994103,
0.0607336722,
-0.1117214486,
0.2878910005,
-0.1137929261,
-0.2950841784,
-0.7246562839,
-0.1067811847,
0.1195961833,
-0.3869319856,
-0.9284297228,
0.159813419,
-0.5152386427,
-0.1313127279,
-0.139682278,
0.5913678408,
-0.3696638644,
0.1227877513,
-0.7862983346,
0.6659650803,
-0.1396354735,
0.2345034182,
0.0194024537,
0.1270951331,
0.7400004268,
-0.7951919436,
0.2292000055,
-0.1644290984,
-0.0504659191,
0.4147618115,
-0.9012261033,
-0.3893126845,
-0.2515349984,
-0.1429428756,
-0.9782033563,
-0.222506851,
0.6316731572,
-0.4074649513,
0.3053171933,
-0.0868782401,
-0.3168238699,
-0.3452787101,
-0.1392048746,
0.1853015274,
0.6367971897,
0.0519632474,
0.0475659631,
0.2892438173,
-0.0750974491,
-0.5525694489,
-0.6645612121,
-0.0200851504,
-0.5233730078,
-0.3254617453,
0.2903834283,
0.0053940201,
-0.5487157702,
0.2240992039,
-0.6754539609,
-0.5809414387,
0.3746976554,
0.1893053204,
-0.1482334435,
-0.2860418856,
0.2515402734,
-0.269952476,
-0.3426986039,
0.1552732885,
-0.5057387352,
0.0629543737,
-0.0839814171,
-0.2288191319,
-0.2386198938,
0.5964355469,
-0.1001485437,
0.7112397552,
0.5963211656,
0.4320363104,
-0.1651175767,
-0.0722891688,
-0.393664062,
-0.3294140399,
-0.4435595274,
0.1189007834,
-0.4126796424,
-0.8899784088,
0.7594797015,
-0.3558124006,
-0.27904284,
0.5648062229,
0.0078130234,
-0.1709063798,
0.7320505381,
0.8145438433,
0.4446046352,
0.3624254465,
0.2272777706,
0.1217349395,
-0.4709402323,
-0.0607700162,
-0.5728291869,
0.0959452316,
-0.9046760201,
-0.1025077626,
-0.1019518375,
0.3800618649,
0.0936152637,
0.0006282441,
-0.2637843788,
0.5113179684,
0.3556723893,
-0.0065446543,
0.0026887641,
-0.2545907795,
-0.1983656734,
-0.1200435907,
-1.2149947882,
-0.8071611524,
0.6698269248,
0.4400383234,
0.8963458538,
0.2864012718,
0.7658289671,
-0.1390714794,
0.0086512612,
-0.9399869442,
0.5436936617,
0.0284636319,
-1.0057457685,
-0.41511181,
-0.655130744,
-1.0142298937,
0.4036906362,
-0.3066620827,
-0.7845555544,
0.1399638653,
0.1185584813,
-0.1786650121,
0.0344253257,
-0.7245596051,
0.7184432149,
-0.2363387197,
-0.1917169541,
0.1329800487,
-0.6988995075,
0.3407697082,
-0.0564042851,
0.6017574668,
-0.2962822318,
-0.604724884,
0.7245658636,
-0.7670718431,
0.6807202101,
0.0501752794,
-0.0892607197,
0.2559390366,
-0.186623469,
-0.0076669902,
0.0471897498,
0.2471849322,
0.0421944559,
0.0974746794,
-0.8026019335,
-0.7751523256,
0.3634449542,
-0.5350313187,
-0.8124853373,
-0.4959445,
-0.4025123119,
0.1112294197,
0.1729289889,
0.4905748665,
0.4989851415,
-0.3254294097,
-0.3428204954,
0.9022669792,
-0.0770431459,
0.2664059401,
0.4462424219,
-0.2217349559,
-0.0434792005,
1.0435041189,
0.1180622727,
0.5451151729,
0.7351257205,
0.3861775994,
-0.241774559,
-0.6565307379,
0.0658193827,
0.2553236485,
-0.737462163,
0.4219095707,
-0.1238445342,
0.0904944018,
0.1048227027,
-0.0454539843,
-0.097277604,
-0.6983453631,
0.032932993,
0.3581267893,
0.1634955108,
0.9947874546,
-0.4394666553,
0.6453515291,
-0.3074537516,
0.412452668,
0.2450793087,
0.4533093572,
-0.0795178935,
-0.5250572562,
-0.2435573786,
0.1045944244,
-0.0585900322,
-1.2612251043,
-0.1821721494,
0.5144658685,
0.8394982815,
0.5815162063,
-0.2389001548,
0.761205256,
-0.3630181551,
0.6448557377,
0.2780407071,
-1.2644416094,
0.4460480213,
-0.3442699909,
0.4589091241,
0.3933598101,
0.4048793018,
-0.4627774656,
-0.9687076211,
-1.0026530027,
-1.1736621857,
0.3760998249,
0.1603469551,
0.0504838377,
-0.1921513379,
0.6625871062,
0.4340282679,
0.4834207594,
-0.7382799983,
-0.5081534386,
-0.2971461415,
0.0017065681,
-0.0387063771,
-0.5056596398,
-0.4087009132,
0.2434648424,
0.3418039083,
0.0647641718,
0.4591548741,
0.2875233591,
-0.1026292667,
0.0617518574,
0.6177803874,
0.7130793333,
1.0614439249,
-0.0805728436,
0.3710006773,
0.1859848052,
-0.342636317,
0.0123591982,
0.272672087,
-0.4338713586,
0.5476526022,
0.5801159739,
0.7652765512,
0.6425250173,
-0.4879990816,
0.6517422199,
0.0428844392,
-0.4845478237,
-0.1022197977,
0.1444435269,
-0.1272253841,
0.1761769205,
0.5677944422,
0.2625022233,
0.2351633608,
-0.5914770961,
0.2070517242,
0.4912597239,
-0.3856908679,
-0.3216586709,
0.6640794873,
0.1312944293,
-0.0308596473,
-0.0665563196,
-0.33229357,
-0.5585970283,
0.3617587388,
0.3682676554,
0.6333334446,
0.0890260711,
0.401851207,
-0.0446942523,
0.4065160453,
-0.0733837783,
0.6040397882,
-0.3294086158,
-0.5536748767,
-0.4359193742,
-0.3013987243,
-0.468896687,
-0.0490371287,
-0.7892035842,
-0.4140719175,
-0.5843946338,
-0.574858129,
0.1986248344,
0.0165993907,
-0.5851407051,
-0.0264580995,
0.0527485162,
0.710041225,
-0.5159407854,
0.0609525554,
0.4552830458,
-0.3258860707,
-0.5980338454,
0.4760940671,
-0.2105686963,
-0.6646009088,
0.5232270956,
-0.2521993518,
-0.1998620033,
-0.228589043,
-0.5534901619,
-0.848279357,
0.4730868936,
0.246437788,
-0.4248872399,
0.3951871991,
0.1970429122,
0.626137197,
-0.1190749034,
0.4659961164,
0.0095984861,
0.5361892581,
0.1885606647,
-0.7969769239,
0.0588573366,
0.1217267141,
0.353000313,
0.3814172149,
-0.4446991086,
0.4640176892,
-0.5573973656,
-0.7479375601,
0.2782875597,
0.8292348385,
-0.3815778494,
0.2201931328,
0.0429801457,
0.2981703579,
0.7461661696,
-0.3930435479,
1.1014262438,
-0.224477604,
0.3738575876,
0.7329789996,
-0.187233001,
0.6558986902,
0.4496710598,
-0.2211447358,
0.4887522161,
0.6000674367,
0.2632965744,
0.6320495605,
0.6961683631,
-0.4309532046,
-0.2174483836,
-0.1549764574,
-0.2822935283,
0.2027322054,
0.5108376741,
0.0743010119,
-0.4468249977,
0.0392461382,
0.0297877528,
0.0549520962,
-0.3693259954,
0.8353342414,
0.2804946899,
-0.2459550947,
0.5470901728,
-0.0471621975,
0.6606277823,
-0.727042079,
0.2845808864,
0.0660926849,
-0.003876522,
-0.2016177475,
-0.9930140376,
0.2068279237,
-0.2146153599,
-0.0744279474,
-0.0969518796,
0.7550286651,
-0.5112482309,
0.0003824412,
0.0801699236,
0.8973563313,
0.5898208022,
0.301376164,
-1.0975874662,
-0.1421851069,
-0.4666228592,
0.1322348714,
0.0510137081,
0.9496338367,
0.5296162367,
0.9096938968,
0.419533819,
0.4974566102,
0.2526289225,
-0.0771972761,
0.4936745167,
-0.7539087534,
-0.2559214532,
-0.8314758539,
0.187731728,
0.0461892076,
-0.6074655652,
0.9039773345,
0.3373066485,
0.6407881379,
0.1181941181,
0.8380801082,
-0.2744402587,
0.2511829138,
-0.6472589374,
0.0927465782,
-0.372238189,
0.276756078,
-0.0938112587,
-0.7596579194,
-0.1682953238,
0.6555381417,
-0.3789609075,
0.3479697406,
1.0565284491,
0.3976482749,
0.0000204136,
-0.0634296536,
0.5039803982,
0.2866616249,
-0.3431591392,
0.6747264862,
1.2861411572,
-0.3196872175,
0.5687758327,
-0.0174616762,
-0.3067790866,
-0.179625228,
-0.6701661348,
-0.7569846511,
-0.6345537305,
-0.3194704056,
-0.2732910812,
0.2191040963,
0.2970198393,
0.6087449193,
-0.3831993043,
-0.4855862558,
-0.2751426399,
0.5310204625,
-0.3009301722,
-0.2715914845,
-0.3151167631,
-0.2840997279,
-0.3618037701,
-0.0635304302,
0.3405376971,
0.2389217317,
-0.0093576545,
-0.00753754,
0.2208080143,
0.2229053974,
0.1288784891,
0.7193353772,
-1.0179165602,
-0.3477552533,
-0.1974865198,
-0.1578349024,
-0.0800671279,
0.7802487612,
-0.4357273877,
0.391628027,
0.2200383395,
0.1213860586,
0.2092415988,
-0.2450059652,
0.7325956821,
-0.3530216217,
0.0572778024,
0.3597173989,
0.1163382977,
0.3674831986,
-0.1537668854,
0.0287891589,
0.3365782201,
-0.4315298796,
-0.2825215459,
0.5859732628,
-0.9190843701,
-0.3563534617,
0.9623740315,
-0.1661611795,
-0.3247214258,
-0.5027353764,
0.2176291943,
0.1006069928,
-0.6095351577,
0.5413904786,
0.9473198056,
-0.1681948304,
-0.1730280966,
-0.9774881601,
0.7935990691,
0.4460217953,
-0.4723103642,
-0.3535000384,
0.0556178428,
0.4318103492,
0.0760244355,
0.7146131396,
0.4059498608,
0.3404678702,
0.3101627231,
-0.4282216132,
0.5864994526,
0.0293773636,
-0.3180495203,
-0.0060769864,
0.3358027637,
-0.151504159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01584v1
|
Lightweight Conceptual Dictionary Learning for Text Classification Using Information Compression
| 2024-04-28T10:11:52 | 2024-04-28T10:11:52 |
Li Wan, Tansu Alpcan, Margreta Kuijper, Emanuele Viterbo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP
|
We propose a novel, lightweight supervised dictionary learning framework for
text classification based on data compression and representation. This
two-phase algorithm initially employs the Lempel-Ziv-Welch (LZW) algorithm to
construct a dictionary from text datasets, focusing on the conceptual
significance of dictionary elements. Subsequently, dictionaries are refined
considering label data, optimizing dictionary atoms to enhance discriminative
power based on mutual information and class distribution. This process
generates discriminative numerical representations, facilitating the training
of simple classifiers such as SVMs and neural networks. We evaluate our
algorithm's information-theoretic performance using information bottleneck
principles and introduce the information plane area rank (IPAR) as a novel
metric to quantify the information-theoretic performance. Tested on six
benchmark text datasets, our algorithm competes closely with top models,
especially in limited-vocabulary contexts, using significantly fewer
parameters. \review{Our algorithm closely matches top-performing models,
deviating by only ~2\% on limited-vocabulary datasets, using just 10\% of their
parameters. However, it falls short on diverse-vocabulary datasets, likely due
to the LZW algorithm's constraints with low-repetition data. This contrast
highlights its efficiency and limitations across different dataset types.
|
[
-0.2234456092,
-0.5425220132,
0.2511901855,
0.1544553787,
-0.4860051572,
-0.0365006216,
-0.252481401,
-0.4794418812,
0.180665791,
0.0421574824,
-0.2460550964,
-0.4375389218,
-0.9089152813,
0.0644944236,
-0.5565485358,
0.8740684986,
0.0771398321,
0.0088326596,
-0.3178150356,
-0.0615691878,
-0.273958832,
-0.4756003916,
-0.404843539,
-0.3804554343,
0.435708642,
0.5428492427,
0.4624281228,
0.8340917826,
0.4904979169,
0.2518033385,
-0.1498020589,
0.0533656739,
-0.631721139,
0.1164094061,
0.1556249857,
-0.3179433048,
-0.1248082519,
-0.088665694,
0.4795422852,
0.9425035715,
-0.4452756643,
0.0064802812,
0.3542504013,
0.7551873326,
-0.8930470347,
0.3189069331,
-0.8349553347,
0.2081453651,
-0.4441745877,
-0.2242040485,
-0.467376858,
-0.0061351699,
0.0593016259,
-0.6212680936,
0.5475007892,
0.183112666,
0.8561835885,
0.3845386803,
-0.5347900987,
-0.4220343232,
-0.3624071181,
0.688541472,
-0.2587001622,
0.5968873501,
0.2492855936,
0.0971281081,
0.1379843205,
-0.9110122323,
-0.7195262313,
0.0323209651,
0.2328628451,
0.2610215843,
0.0332920514,
0.1976361871,
0.0038875397,
0.3574943542,
-0.513964355,
0.1944102943,
-0.5865702033,
-0.0425323844,
0.4637876153,
0.1053976417,
-0.1755255014,
-0.1635678262,
-0.4125198126,
-0.2817304432,
-0.3113355637,
0.001207518,
0.0146745527,
0.4029729068,
-0.1337153912,
0.5474700928,
-0.3908038437,
0.7627702951,
-0.0883151591,
-0.3343684375,
0.4191316664,
-0.0965209082,
-0.0531510226,
0.2829204202,
0.7496691346,
0.4807059765,
0.1056395769,
-0.1645751595,
-0.2291540205,
-0.065680787,
0.2739157379,
-1.0079585314,
-0.3020855188,
-0.058806017,
-0.7380679846,
-0.5130681396,
0.2975634634,
-0.5639516115,
-0.5821498632,
-0.1422064602,
0.5457935333,
-0.1803690493,
-0.0770857856,
0.1798990816,
-0.5062106848,
-0.1958701611,
0.4266752303,
-0.9930433035,
0.5812042952,
0.5376647711,
1.1075433493,
-0.1501283646,
-0.1546586901,
-0.2009041458,
0.1525847912,
-0.5078866482,
0.6634065509,
-0.1491228491,
-0.3554460108,
-0.0760494322,
-0.5161220431,
0.287491262,
-0.6118271947,
0.6242097616,
-0.1112607643,
-0.1882301867,
-0.1403451115,
-0.6066317558,
0.0213217754,
0.0650769547,
-0.8039163947,
1.209409833,
0.3484604657,
-1.110743165,
0.5546268821,
-0.0956281126,
-0.4805702865,
0.2543770969,
-0.2674039602,
-0.3445293009,
0.2158838212,
-0.1920108795,
0.8613625169,
-0.5500981212,
-0.1166384369,
-0.3363521099,
-0.4669805169,
-0.057699468,
-0.1833078563,
0.4896336198,
0.3248444796,
0.0527844019,
-0.3302558959,
-1.0728752613,
-0.0270587895,
0.2665250599,
-0.3593070209,
-0.8274260759,
0.1563242674,
0.3549465835,
0.0675728321,
0.5135660768,
-0.5442917347,
0.3054012656,
-0.3126711845,
0.252132237,
0.6645612121,
-0.150201723,
0.3642132282,
-0.2303210199,
-0.1188100278,
0.0416951701,
0.1428497434,
0.2999357283,
-0.4825716019,
-0.7857247591,
-0.2784024477,
0.4716593027,
0.7177538276,
-0.9087792039,
0.6888338923,
-0.546315968,
-0.6263702512,
-0.2039713562,
0.5318773985,
0.1730158478,
0.6901127696,
0.3954495788,
-0.3986646533,
-0.401550442,
-0.6840237975,
0.0533819385,
-0.3685537279,
-0.1308144033,
0.0163112488,
0.3914443851,
-0.0664604828,
0.9788997173,
-0.6297520995,
-0.5413025618,
-0.3530862927,
0.4736446738,
0.2218120247,
0.3795539141,
0.5406838059,
-1.1412574053,
-0.4932720065,
-0.1806799173,
-0.6931092739,
-0.3757549524,
0.1066299975,
0.334720999,
-0.0960911587,
0.4624295235,
-0.3922288418,
0.4411342442,
0.4368858635,
-0.3036436439,
0.0460597388,
-0.2208025157,
-0.2702711821,
-1.1480487585,
-0.3223275542,
0.1461198628,
0.0825893804,
-0.655657351,
-0.2785304189,
0.2742275,
0.158211723,
-0.1526065767,
0.4196946025,
-0.2180438638,
0.1878279895,
-0.3298895061,
0.0508995503,
-0.067657873,
0.395326823,
0.2003278732,
0.563945055,
0.3192415237,
-0.8860824704,
0.3568166494,
0.1784670055,
-0.4708696902,
0.65555197,
-0.5233253241,
-0.1397498101,
-0.3630541265,
0.1798124611,
-0.8275833726,
-0.1188032851,
0.0809315369,
-0.4001851678,
0.4266000092,
0.1637440175,
-0.5304840803,
-0.1891890168,
-0.4566772282,
0.4624998271,
0.5301052332,
-0.6141719818,
0.4769681692,
0.456466943,
-0.1030731127,
-0.6962980628,
-0.8505957723,
-0.1703344882,
0.0082569513,
-0.247875005,
0.5858602524,
-0.0587965883,
-0.1634170115,
0.0926889107,
-0.4384373724,
-0.45066607,
0.2389965206,
0.3355746269,
0.0236474369,
0.3739870489,
0.4820382893,
0.1580815613,
0.0392796621,
-0.314814955,
-0.2051196098,
0.472130537,
0.1104733869,
0.1567466408,
-0.1671396792,
0.2213079184,
-0.0327397063,
0.2729170024,
0.9309942722,
0.616333425,
-0.483225584,
-0.5753792524,
-0.2239463776,
-0.0294497255,
-0.4538326859,
0.5935711861,
-0.5315511823,
-0.7965990901,
0.1247951761,
-0.1321356893,
-0.0441478267,
0.692932725,
0.3588010669,
-0.2221453488,
0.8268630505,
0.8932751417,
-0.2160833478,
0.5183306336,
-0.3299284577,
-0.0512543507,
-0.3959099054,
-0.3274803162,
-0.7544957995,
-0.2214110345,
-0.4773223102,
-0.0898011401,
0.4828935564,
0.5902077556,
-0.1923315674,
0.1075291187,
-0.6802981496,
0.3105123341,
0.3729088306,
0.1301640272,
0.0545593351,
0.0241120942,
-0.1247665882,
0.0290784463,
-0.908166647,
0.0123356888,
1.1907340288,
0.3265024424,
0.89842695,
0.0328911431,
0.7796452641,
0.567065537,
0.1676831245,
-1.0737243891,
0.337708652,
-0.356815815,
0.0522386879,
-0.1185283065,
-0.9126069546,
-0.8414263129,
0.1023246273,
-0.5975446105,
-0.5851678848,
0.162705496,
0.0914707184,
0.0501942933,
0.0976034105,
-0.7460842729,
0.5708227158,
0.0244916454,
0.02357064,
-0.2525030077,
-0.6907119155,
0.2884425521,
-0.2804850042,
0.3612709045,
0.017852338,
-0.4237048626,
1.1302447319,
-0.6637334824,
0.598218441,
-0.1865046769,
-0.1093305871,
0.0867619067,
-0.1905724853,
0.2107549906,
-0.1366878599,
0.0404932015,
0.5373595357,
0.1447509229,
-0.3620766997,
-0.601932466,
0.3863057792,
-0.7876628041,
-0.1184453517,
-0.6544510126,
-0.3812299073,
-0.1420208216,
0.2623581588,
0.6054352522,
0.4801579714,
0.0222895592,
0.4377092421,
0.7877113223,
0.2325191498,
0.244212687,
0.2902784646,
0.1603787392,
-0.5431565046,
1.0532681942,
0.4653101265,
-0.0313138999,
0.8709545135,
0.2415004969,
-0.0995938107,
-0.8506617546,
-0.0485713705,
-0.1095492914,
-0.9731264114,
-0.4614715576,
-0.3101030886,
-0.3179418743,
-0.4706302881,
-0.0150895137,
-0.2403450161,
-0.7068154216,
-0.1970484704,
0.1015105173,
0.2552448809,
0.9834385514,
-0.0469902381,
0.535161972,
-0.5790550709,
0.6410748959,
0.2217103392,
0.3109593093,
-0.0126067791,
-0.1842488796,
-0.5645828843,
-0.2440423369,
-0.2221399099,
-0.8226425648,
0.1333449632,
0.6436940432,
0.3507372737,
0.6734840274,
0.4828124642,
0.3720280826,
-0.538703382,
0.8535140753,
0.3104942739,
-0.9293940663,
0.2459166795,
0.288872689,
0.0823692158,
0.6895409822,
0.4270509779,
-0.4916715622,
-0.1733338386,
-0.4879246354,
-0.867782712,
0.5104300976,
0.0827580243,
-0.0617806464,
-0.0816493109,
0.7388092875,
-0.0598892905,
0.4497851133,
-0.5980449915,
-0.4446562529,
-0.2961629629,
-0.925951004,
-0.1372414529,
-0.4649986625,
0.0218961202,
-0.2534303665,
0.6864011288,
-0.3642161191,
0.2548871934,
0.269090116,
-0.1341519803,
0.1954804361,
0.0825862661,
0.2922876179,
0.3049903512,
-0.2572958171,
0.4879792631,
0.1791338474,
-1.0282108784,
0.1275844574,
0.2145899385,
-0.275577873,
0.1258278787,
0.5506014228,
0.5417580605,
-0.039902553,
-0.6499706507,
0.7506430149,
-0.3791606128,
-0.4278713763,
-0.1471147239,
0.0960860848,
-0.3913074136,
0.1355753839,
0.6274741292,
0.0780688524,
0.4562205374,
-0.1842133999,
-0.081428647,
0.4843207598,
-0.128556788,
0.1227058545,
0.4919069707,
0.0475901514,
0.1199529693,
0.3988302648,
-0.1212087274,
-0.4135824144,
0.4255177677,
0.2099271566,
0.6267539263,
-0.138024658,
-0.1024368182,
0.093448177,
0.3440683186,
-0.3810422719,
0.3039761782,
-0.6462638378,
-0.8900618553,
0.0764456391,
-0.6334124804,
-0.3540183008,
-0.0366961434,
-0.7168591022,
0.2916871905,
-0.6688864231,
-0.0448767468,
-0.111586988,
0.2554078102,
-0.4430348873,
0.2887017727,
-0.0111863138,
1.3657280207,
-0.7374033332,
0.9724329114,
0.3350097239,
-0.3144987524,
-0.6135774255,
0.1176398471,
-0.0908247381,
-0.3833206892,
0.8684104085,
0.3702595234,
-0.1280408204,
0.0212401506,
-0.6348403692,
-0.5898217559,
1.1476796865,
0.1677082479,
-0.5289145112,
-0.1785571575,
0.0784326717,
0.3502343297,
-0.0301142987,
0.0511280745,
0.1584826857,
-0.0031684523,
0.0696218014,
-1.0515352488,
-0.2079141736,
-0.4907690287,
0.3305984735,
0.11284253,
-0.6405071616,
0.9694335461,
0.1933574229,
-0.1863579601,
0.1852831393,
0.8704257011,
-0.0292309001,
0.4363178909,
0.6352982521,
0.8072275519,
0.936453104,
-0.1856035292,
0.8687468171,
-0.3457894921,
0.5833938718,
0.7916951776,
-0.2554245591,
1.068651557,
0.5162543654,
-0.0106554544,
0.4955210388,
0.6293855906,
0.1296081394,
0.7765562534,
0.2414856255,
-0.3721806705,
-0.0088304775,
-0.2074357271,
-0.454887569,
0.4303356409,
0.5717251897,
-0.1379368007,
-0.1495216489,
0.0879267603,
-0.1719407737,
0.0161102582,
-0.5382480621,
0.9118344784,
0.0638601184,
-0.0368716642,
0.6782082915,
0.444322288,
0.9615854025,
-0.7679541707,
-0.0841837674,
0.2062461227,
0.3041211963,
-0.1913400441,
-0.4574555159,
-0.1113200411,
-0.1431243122,
-0.3102980852,
-0.1579990387,
0.7551634312,
-0.4690193832,
-0.3659388721,
0.030330779,
0.0902371779,
0.0469657965,
0.1861964017,
-0.5959192514,
0.1850795746,
-0.6144015789,
-0.1201293021,
0.2911060452,
0.5431622863,
0.1638084054,
0.634689033,
0.2586208284,
0.3528686762,
-0.1128495112,
-0.0731266811,
0.7833154798,
-0.4906651676,
-0.8033889532,
-0.6099077463,
-0.0680532157,
-0.2416253984,
-0.2427191287,
0.6315793991,
0.7086096406,
1.1037647724,
0.1066502482,
0.9338677526,
-0.2144350559,
0.5646947026,
-0.9146710038,
0.6376256347,
-0.6251319647,
0.1542388648,
-0.2621255219,
-0.7654047012,
-0.2891675234,
0.8934242725,
0.2367818952,
0.078435123,
0.6963783503,
0.4387527406,
0.1207341552,
-0.1032714024,
0.0481679663,
0.0944119915,
0.0204811078,
0.6939391494,
0.5208183527,
-0.4910612702,
0.4293530881,
-0.5783743858,
-0.3514252305,
-0.1126414835,
-0.9279657006,
-0.9204333425,
-0.9985117316,
-0.2058306634,
-0.4662567675,
-0.1230130717,
1.1642551422,
0.8072596192,
-0.4679643214,
-0.1817930788,
-0.4253532887,
0.1289691627,
-0.3917526007,
-0.2947019935,
0.3123604655,
-0.3504320979,
-0.5566913486,
0.1754102409,
-0.0135754347,
0.0856081322,
-0.0995745435,
-0.3042925298,
0.1964861006,
-0.0372784287,
0.5348208547,
0.1140648946,
-0.2990422845,
-0.0857425332,
-0.5579194427,
-0.2909317017,
-0.1226863787,
0.7421715856,
-0.8170787096,
0.351005435,
0.6757238507,
0.7180248499,
0.4470937848,
-0.1453022361,
0.0137830535,
-1.247684598,
0.5256415606,
0.0599873699,
0.3472137749,
0.180318132,
-0.3102365732,
0.3296925128,
0.486649096,
-0.2419181764,
-0.8655918241,
0.0020437005,
-1.1559514999,
-0.6107644439,
0.932985425,
0.201264441,
-0.2483483851,
0.0004385722,
-0.2021731287,
0.2973902524,
-0.3051381409,
0.8689702153,
0.755300045,
-0.0272513889,
-0.4070688188,
-0.4498761296,
0.7334677577,
-0.0709937438,
-0.7500467896,
-0.1837976128,
0.2985482514,
0.0636263415,
0.3513060808,
0.6942823529,
0.3637972772,
0.1910697669,
0.1662972122,
0.1867650151,
-0.123249121,
-0.595014751,
-0.3872100711,
0.5686389804,
0.1434401721,
-0.0006575669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18130v1
|
Logic Agent: Enhancing Validity with Logic Rule Invocation
| 2024-04-28T10:02:28 | 2024-04-28T10:02:28 |
Hanmeng Liu, Zhiyang Teng, Chaoli Zhang, Yue Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has emerged as a pivotal technique for
augmenting the inferential capabilities of language models during reasoning
tasks. Despite its advancements, CoT often grapples with challenges in
validating reasoning validity and ensuring informativeness. Addressing these
limitations, this paper introduces the Logic Agent (LA), an agent-based
framework aimed at enhancing the validity of reasoning processes in Large
Language Models (LLMs) through strategic logic rule invocation. Unlike
conventional approaches, LA transforms LLMs into logic agents that dynamically
apply propositional logic rules, initiating the reasoning process by converting
natural language inputs into structured logic forms. The logic agent leverages
a comprehensive set of predefined functions to systematically navigate the
reasoning process. This methodology not only promotes the structured and
coherent generation of reasoning constructs but also significantly improves
their interpretability and logical coherence. Through extensive
experimentation, we demonstrate LA's capacity to scale effectively across
various model sizes, markedly improving the precision of complex reasoning
across diverse tasks.
|
[
-0.1435766667,
-0.9505119324,
1.0298074484,
-0.0207393114,
-0.1759623438,
0.3681903481,
-0.1423185021,
-0.369140178,
0.0291179139,
0.6847580075,
-0.436360836,
-0.1965817362,
-0.3775549531,
0.2536774576,
-0.4163175523,
0.8000786304,
0.0173325259,
-0.0750629231,
-0.2608128488,
0.0074604773,
-0.5087389946,
-0.4438955486,
-0.7567565441,
-0.7776817083,
0.2366192788,
0.2168324441,
1.0495271683,
0.2477179766,
0.3383646309,
0.3695471883,
0.1015974358,
0.8334957957,
-0.2349040955,
0.4231308103,
-0.7985749841,
-0.5930059552,
-0.8379343152,
-0.0412637033,
0.6010032892,
0.4290744662,
-0.2812325358,
0.1096437126,
-0.213417083,
0.5586913228,
-0.6339581609,
0.1204290763,
-0.9153667688,
-0.4105739892,
0.1394108534,
-0.3390019536,
-0.8924284577,
-0.4603559971,
0.020649448,
-0.6048609018,
-0.4138920903,
0.1663965434,
0.8148663044,
0.3540827632,
-0.4861941934,
-0.322455883,
-0.7599720359,
0.6409258842,
-0.6571600437,
0.3033370972,
0.0747969002,
0.4507696033,
-0.683493197,
-0.8558912873,
-0.9751901627,
-0.4865891635,
0.0109339822,
-0.1091223657,
-0.2483408898,
0.1461359859,
0.5588000417,
-0.1689848006,
-0.1252556145,
-0.5116608143,
0.0916636884,
-0.0936953351,
0.5895986557,
0.1067757159,
0.3778336048,
0.1985019743,
-0.4440114796,
0.0055026137,
-0.7821176648,
0.0977986455,
0.2749958634,
0.3776002228,
0.3610940278,
0.4985048473,
-0.2925562859,
0.6902594566,
0.2776321173,
-0.256831646,
0.0907796919,
-0.2555592656,
-0.3307558894,
0.3068302572,
0.5303354263,
0.3256215453,
0.4653513134,
0.1041799337,
-0.4520351887,
0.1164376661,
0.4748604596,
-0.5689884424,
0.1547305733,
0.3222259283,
-0.1677361876,
-0.1417205334,
0.3892487288,
-0.341650635,
-0.5225329399,
-0.5681976676,
0.5130949616,
-0.5658726096,
-0.3263200819,
0.4476579428,
-0.2584211528,
0.5062439442,
0.5894595981,
-0.320168227,
0.535264492,
0.792394042,
0.5018071532,
0.1609113216,
-0.1312932372,
-0.9448919296,
0.3245054483,
-0.631084621,
0.9232677817,
-0.7381518483,
0.0765569583,
-0.1203631088,
-0.1187973619,
-0.1097200662,
-0.7508658767,
0.6514501572,
-0.8339710832,
-0.3720636666,
-0.3164177239,
-0.5210530162,
-0.0385716408,
0.6284498572,
-0.6100114584,
0.8729139566,
0.1555709541,
-0.0312724598,
0.4297025502,
-0.8455893993,
-0.4304290116,
0.2361827195,
-0.469111979,
0.0681578591,
-0.1300659478,
0.1734359413,
0.2916214764,
-0.4829954803,
0.2832981944,
-0.074030973,
-0.1636488587,
0.5453494787,
-0.1613023281,
0.649862349,
0.2022764087,
-0.3675255477,
0.4313858151,
-0.7605395317,
0.3739200234,
0.0533963516,
0.048697982,
-0.1645783186,
0.1346400827,
-0.5718817115,
0.4808351696,
0.041436404,
-0.4430987835,
0.0918584317,
-0.5472794771,
0.2583590448,
0.7274551988,
0.166725263,
0.4233654439,
-0.5199440718,
0.5658684373,
-0.0587884858,
0.1996676028,
0.277918011,
-0.446052134,
-0.5508977175,
-0.4032711089,
-0.0530328639,
0.5497332215,
-1.1676347256,
0.6812608838,
-0.2462462634,
-0.3584378958,
-0.3272691667,
0.1906551123,
0.145765692,
0.6030414701,
0.2361605167,
0.0951497182,
-0.3138783574,
-0.5589383245,
-0.2702593803,
-0.264120996,
0.1569711715,
-0.1423369199,
0.5589540005,
-0.3123886585,
1.0611630678,
-0.1678583473,
-0.0295264237,
-0.7108743787,
-0.2878397703,
0.3972666562,
0.1243903935,
0.3066600859,
-0.5900954604,
-0.3507634997,
0.1616039276,
-0.8057096601,
-0.174969703,
-0.1870268732,
-0.5552674532,
0.1799867302,
0.6723687649,
-0.7255532146,
0.4983840287,
0.0951975212,
-0.6715333462,
0.7407721877,
-0.095304966,
0.1806901544,
-0.7696661949,
-0.1879612356,
-0.4012732208,
-0.5700010657,
-0.6191735864,
0.2044814378,
-0.066764459,
0.1261356324,
-0.5122448802,
0.5602545738,
-0.1180890352,
0.1887510717,
-0.5147097707,
0.4950291812,
0.383333385,
0.1413631886,
-0.0744036958,
0.6590332985,
0.3676043153,
-0.769156456,
0.7446993589,
0.0897679552,
-0.2189310938,
0.7670842409,
-0.5959036946,
0.1097980812,
-0.0917050615,
0.5822921991,
-0.6420895457,
0.0137207303,
0.3804366291,
-0.0902677849,
-0.186322704,
0.1600973606,
-0.7761649489,
-0.0903147608,
-0.1612903923,
0.3957097828,
0.4336329401,
-0.6351401806,
1.1210056543,
0.0181164499,
0.2724353671,
-0.4313621521,
-0.2968017459,
-0.0043523405,
0.0768385082,
-0.7178014517,
-0.0590638146,
0.0391729698,
-0.8484559655,
-0.0484596528,
-0.0949735641,
0.3309676349,
-0.1182615086,
0.0052656592,
0.29374668,
-0.0289718304,
0.3799611628,
0.1185260043,
-0.0002151825,
0.4279380739,
-0.5839768648,
0.5640636683,
-0.3751737475,
-0.3898422122,
-0.4312105775,
0.1600722075,
0.6920241714,
-0.5002172589,
0.7860997915,
0.0367846489,
-0.4934668839,
-0.9397386312,
-0.4165852964,
-0.2969069183,
-0.5305525064,
-0.024443049,
-0.7185293436,
-0.3647367358,
0.3883197308,
-0.5710191131,
-0.1653569341,
0.3611023724,
0.4748482704,
0.1371435821,
0.9290603399,
0.253438592,
0.2851899266,
0.2665695548,
-0.2639299333,
0.412789613,
-0.6879121065,
-0.2414019108,
-0.2457402349,
-0.0269767921,
-0.2342305332,
-0.572825253,
0.3526747823,
-0.165596813,
-0.4605922103,
0.0304849371,
-0.4391104281,
0.7179633379,
0.1632585078,
0.324608475,
0.4308171272,
-0.0980540365,
-0.3992407918,
0.4710482955,
-0.4928242564,
-1.0074013472,
0.7195129991,
0.2072778195,
0.7560252547,
0.4057599604,
0.4166514277,
0.5312181711,
0.1315673441,
-0.8944810629,
0.9661899805,
0.22258389,
-0.5663820505,
-0.3761104345,
-0.2560516894,
-0.6414478421,
0.2905510962,
-0.2490353137,
-0.7722665071,
0.1425935626,
0.1458290517,
-0.4687021673,
0.3528012335,
-0.4989641309,
0.560565412,
-0.2875882685,
-0.4886874259,
-0.4761195481,
-0.3800024092,
0.1683846563,
0.0171363559,
0.0234599058,
-0.2193998843,
-0.2130447328,
0.3205658793,
-0.9395808578,
0.5613405108,
-0.0018142884,
-0.3252115548,
0.7451246381,
0.3123421967,
0.9936232567,
-0.1336346865,
-0.4147020578,
-0.4110563099,
0.0321973115,
-0.4610834718,
-1.2181327343,
0.2709978521,
-0.5269789696,
-0.7387056947,
-0.563575387,
-0.5185552835,
-0.4538597167,
0.2459957153,
-0.1320079416,
0.5417540669,
0.0325012244,
0.0594952181,
0.6658183932,
0.0881152302,
0.0594065823,
0.1972798854,
-0.3017401993,
-0.2121884972,
0.6777974963,
-0.1231004521,
0.8044232726,
0.3754308522,
0.2759931684,
-0.4675480127,
-0.2893268168,
-0.3143082261,
0.1247213855,
-1.0343332291,
-0.1698707938,
-0.3457944095,
-0.3934682906,
-0.1649648696,
-0.2557677627,
-0.332619071,
-0.2112099677,
0.2746868432,
-0.203929767,
0.3737205565,
0.832351625,
0.4639082253,
0.0161630232,
-0.3408947587,
0.1741565764,
0.2447569817,
0.15518336,
0.0396644324,
-0.5400021076,
-0.0198733769,
-0.0026008671,
-0.2852380574,
-0.7087283134,
0.0430795662,
0.0555762462,
0.689406395,
0.4730702341,
0.3950348496,
0.5739777088,
-0.3317821026,
0.5517583489,
0.000534593,
-1.2054992914,
0.870762825,
-0.4370351732,
0.2796087563,
0.4341767728,
0.0130157406,
-0.0451202691,
-0.6735246181,
-0.5880995393,
-0.6311580539,
0.405513078,
0.2371804267,
-0.1378557682,
-0.112801902,
0.5156239867,
-0.0842604041,
0.3045865595,
-0.415152669,
0.1614906341,
-0.0356609374,
-0.3863795996,
0.3149448335,
0.0911222473,
-0.2117705196,
-0.2772224844,
0.9507784843,
-0.507922411,
-0.0326828957,
0.4865693748,
-0.2467584312,
-0.0793124735,
0.4502770305,
0.5628021955,
1.0196871758,
-0.0646359846,
0.3242503703,
0.3474646509,
-0.3640546501,
0.4335570633,
-0.2649415135,
-0.2514533401,
-0.3002718985,
0.5219310522,
0.4262980521,
-0.1753339469,
-1.0682498217,
0.3840660751,
-0.0227672867,
-0.2118862718,
-0.2861902714,
0.416303575,
-0.2931969166,
0.6082941294,
0.1701483279,
0.0562687181,
0.139834106,
-0.9366693497,
0.2425867766,
0.3277585208,
-0.2127069682,
0.0776027143,
0.3400427997,
0.2497915924,
-0.2955909669,
0.5672864914,
-0.5060466528,
-0.6614071727,
0.5760112405,
0.7354881167,
0.772362709,
0.1975126266,
0.2832746208,
0.1274478287,
0.4270124733,
-0.2247868776,
0.5159265399,
0.0623587444,
-1.1143016815,
-0.3699662685,
-0.3126544952,
-0.5462583303,
-0.2305954397,
-0.2537987828,
0.1318114251,
-0.8033822775,
-0.3795785308,
-0.3026614189,
0.1998511255,
-0.470697403,
0.228570208,
0.115673393,
1.0872279406,
-0.3980793953,
0.9958096743,
0.89673841,
-0.3679638207,
-1.3022469282,
0.125951007,
0.0896954909,
-0.3213974833,
0.5021916032,
-0.0298359506,
-0.9901233912,
-0.2018292844,
-0.6049067974,
-0.5411817431,
1.2176917791,
0.6680146456,
-0.3978058696,
0.3914231062,
0.1534217298,
0.6311123967,
-0.858537972,
0.2935278416,
0.6425926685,
0.4883937836,
0.4228768349,
-0.7073381543,
0.641935885,
-0.2986813486,
-0.279620558,
0.1785707921,
-0.6649921536,
0.6476307511,
-0.299300164,
-0.0177276284,
0.0198509581,
0.6624019146,
0.7635513544,
0.3777879477,
0.8712244034,
0.1958120912,
1.3076974154,
-0.0489815958,
1.0556952953,
-0.1798244864,
-0.2720251381,
1.2673809528,
-0.8934224844,
0.9160706997,
0.3525497913,
0.197849825,
1.2236362696,
0.0043701692,
0.2041985244,
0.1346642375,
0.2478184104,
-0.5609975457,
-0.6112216115,
-0.42765975,
-0.0074152383,
0.4276866317,
0.4262599051,
-0.24319534,
0.0162857454,
-0.2226799428,
-0.021540314,
0.614985168,
-0.4981182516,
0.5409640074,
0.0834447891,
-0.896615386,
0.2601616979,
-0.2557283342,
0.0603036359,
-0.72353369,
-0.2385156155,
0.3019529283,
0.6796492934,
-0.261402905,
-0.7150498629,
0.1136824861,
-0.1528603882,
-0.0822956413,
-0.306206882,
0.9696176648,
-0.1803928763,
-0.4211376309,
0.6651926041,
0.5062121749,
-0.0537304692,
-0.2031562775,
-0.5557188392,
0.1378533244,
-0.4619825184,
-0.0693661422,
-0.2033424526,
0.7887765765,
-0.4902241826,
0.8889898062,
0.5875272751,
0.2472569197,
-0.1553748399,
0.45765692,
0.9086152911,
-0.6673021913,
-0.3613880575,
-0.990758419,
0.540954411,
-0.3801530302,
0.1466659009,
0.6391049027,
0.3180567026,
0.7215165496,
0.0697706714,
0.7378802299,
-0.1083138362,
-0.0029646694,
-0.582444787,
0.6259253621,
-0.3975675106,
0.4400662184,
-0.2149249315,
-0.6564870477,
-0.0743065923,
0.5965082049,
-0.4845450222,
0.16245915,
0.9955729842,
0.9815324545,
0.2439669371,
0.0112126591,
0.4616043568,
0.2065855861,
0.6526762247,
0.5072646141,
1.2212438583,
-0.2624999285,
0.4326297641,
0.1581889093,
-0.3900519013,
0.1151069999,
-0.8865887523,
-1.15292418,
-0.3062226772,
-0.2504323423,
-0.7250984907,
0.1473052651,
1.6834702492,
0.7247278094,
-0.6505156159,
-0.2628635168,
-0.1400363594,
0.4929888546,
-0.5570127368,
-0.1857154816,
0.0807660893,
-0.5807401538,
-0.3065468669,
0.4788464606,
0.3501089513,
-0.3173502982,
-0.061255116,
-0.3905292749,
-0.5683858991,
0.8272348046,
0.9669784307,
-0.0061208932,
-0.8169814348,
-0.4351201952,
-0.1682075709,
-0.0519907922,
-0.1854221523,
0.7538981438,
-0.9414470196,
0.4480501115,
0.4821069539,
0.4548162222,
-0.1147064567,
0.1263631582,
0.8394937515,
-0.47135818,
0.0124590062,
0.2252021432,
0.3399178982,
-0.0263507143,
-0.5173889995,
0.5229607821,
0.1265811473,
-0.3821345866,
-0.6961144805,
0.489225775,
-1.0826426744,
-0.1643215716,
1.1462317705,
0.0958683714,
-0.4698607326,
-0.1847168356,
-0.5165618062,
0.0715540722,
-0.6076206565,
0.3611545265,
0.7509683967,
-0.3524117768,
-0.0136951655,
-0.3686285615,
0.5467593074,
0.1294358522,
-1.163136363,
-0.0668200776,
0.2194839865,
0.1482928395,
0.2188006788,
0.6801171303,
-0.1096339375,
0.4952380657,
0.0489845537,
-0.1308725923,
0.0373418964,
-0.5598188043,
0.0296510831,
0.1592239439,
0.3073323965,
0.114168115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.18094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.18094v1
|
USAT: A Universal Speaker-Adaptive Text-to-Speech Approach
| 2024-04-28T06:50:55 | 2024-04-28T06:50:55 |
Wenbin Wang, Yang Song, Sanjay Jha
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Conventional text-to-speech (TTS) research has predominantly focused on
enhancing the quality of synthesized speech for speakers in the training
dataset. The challenge of synthesizing lifelike speech for unseen,
out-of-dataset speakers, especially those with limited reference data, remains
a significant and unresolved problem. While zero-shot or few-shot
speaker-adaptive TTS approaches have been explored, they have many limitations.
Zero-shot approaches tend to suffer from insufficient generalization
performance to reproduce the voice of speakers with heavy accents. While
few-shot methods can reproduce highly varying accents, they bring a significant
storage burden and the risk of overfitting and catastrophic forgetting. In
addition, prior approaches only provide either zero-shot or few-shot
adaptation, constraining their utility across varied real-world scenarios with
different demands. Besides, most current evaluations of speaker-adaptive TTS
are conducted only on datasets of native speakers, inadvertently neglecting a
vast portion of non-native speakers with diverse accents. Our proposed
framework unifies both zero-shot and few-shot speaker adaptation strategies,
which we term as "instant" and "fine-grained" adaptations based on their
merits. To alleviate the insufficient generalization performance observed in
zero-shot speaker adaptation, we designed two innovative discriminators and
introduced a memory mechanism for the speech decoder. To prevent catastrophic
forgetting and reduce storage implications for few-shot speaker adaptation, we
designed two adapters and a unique adaptation procedure.
|
[
-0.3005306125,
-0.6772681475,
0.3120522499,
0.0505559407,
-0.440233022,
0.0898129568,
-0.1915163547,
-0.2966054976,
0.0626994148,
0.4204691648,
-0.3112677634,
-0.2638961375,
-0.1894714683,
0.1333156675,
-0.1756276935,
0.8964809775,
0.43515113,
-0.2312122881,
0.4710329473,
-0.1567327231,
-0.7954361439,
-0.4110891223,
-0.5660755038,
-0.3461709023,
0.1072205156,
0.7832878828,
0.6663100719,
0.4506855309,
-0.0673419163,
0.1647823453,
-0.038949661,
-0.0729809403,
-0.5725830793,
0.1996335387,
-0.3446247876,
-0.1773609072,
-0.406481266,
-0.490847379,
0.7230018973,
0.4573883116,
-0.1220883057,
-0.1547815055,
0.0513546914,
0.5472383499,
-0.6121845841,
-0.399745971,
-1.1556754112,
0.2413160652,
-0.0475665927,
-0.443051368,
-0.5802035332,
-0.0182018634,
0.3190844655,
-0.5810761452,
0.3961030245,
-0.3339532912,
0.1331994385,
0.1165163517,
-0.3636802435,
0.0972601846,
-1.2008330822,
0.4359426498,
-0.5658960938,
0.4543347061,
-0.2049646974,
0.3202097714,
-0.4023027122,
-0.3389401734,
-0.4681346118,
-0.1281131059,
0.4364904463,
0.4355290234,
-0.3786037564,
0.1792094558,
-0.0936704725,
0.0186832286,
-0.825447619,
0.1592276394,
-0.0368750319,
-0.3062320948,
0.4693930447,
0.0377580486,
0.3029820323,
-0.159502849,
-0.4636299312,
-0.1283814311,
-0.4843348563,
-0.1610925794,
-0.0814457983,
0.9156624675,
-0.0580830351,
0.1547727287,
-0.31890136,
0.5394989252,
-0.051199995,
-0.0452082641,
-0.0821006447,
-0.1456175596,
-0.1085763276,
0.2927111089,
0.789757669,
0.2711073756,
0.6019204259,
-0.4545271993,
0.1397411972,
-0.2494902015,
0.1812909544,
-0.7640432119,
-0.0817071497,
-0.0443990938,
0.0081911944,
0.2520239353,
-0.1004601493,
-1.1337022781,
-0.1950691193,
-0.072119236,
0.9159926772,
-0.5010644794,
-0.2954838872,
0.0557416491,
-0.2647198737,
0.1241639182,
0.1518183202,
-1.2388401031,
0.5331661701,
0.2085555941,
0.7993255854,
-0.1967847943,
-0.3509628475,
-0.4894256592,
0.4745423794,
-0.4680859149,
0.9564493299,
-0.2615616918,
-0.7977823615,
-0.0048646643,
-0.3438056707,
-0.1091602668,
-0.1573682129,
0.6474571824,
-0.1226160154,
-0.0065692612,
-0.3531116545,
-0.4686720073,
0.1022890434,
-0.1533675343,
-0.2191533893,
0.858897686,
0.0979627296,
-0.519297719,
0.2970069349,
-0.8792896867,
-0.3503339887,
0.1684895456,
-0.1770287454,
-0.14563784,
0.5643669963,
0.4085720479,
0.5468501449,
-0.188015759,
0.0956453905,
0.0237388164,
-0.7885265946,
0.1944065392,
-0.8278193474,
0.565020144,
0.3233496547,
-0.2098420709,
-0.1568324566,
-0.9984828234,
-0.0676329136,
0.3248974383,
-0.1369611919,
-0.3196362555,
-0.0352962166,
0.363681376,
-0.2555683553,
-0.1864100099,
-0.6257050037,
0.0010325306,
-0.5274262428,
0.4121273756,
0.8473846316,
0.2234155685,
0.3967205882,
-0.2024898827,
0.3249672651,
-0.2827931643,
-0.0070286202,
-0.5286842585,
-0.0721566081,
-0.6704629064,
-0.1400190294,
0.1686705053,
0.8257901073,
-0.6316508651,
0.2378187031,
-0.6018418074,
-0.4653357863,
-0.1212124676,
-0.2404943854,
0.385145992,
0.5187779069,
0.4316938818,
-0.5428344607,
-0.6623099446,
-0.457903713,
-0.4275654852,
-0.3032566011,
-0.4400531054,
0.0821663737,
0.2237803787,
0.0392856523,
1.2145562172,
-0.2744471729,
-0.3035216331,
-0.0694545507,
0.0312850028,
0.0586694814,
0.4539863765,
0.5730082989,
-0.4473980367,
-0.4768519402,
-0.0017751048,
-0.5008711815,
0.0099747078,
-0.4620831013,
0.2750593424,
0.1724625379,
0.2470836788,
-0.4642280042,
0.4482206404,
0.4224261642,
-0.4105032086,
0.4333157837,
-0.4808750451,
0.1632869244,
-1.2260097265,
-0.2599607706,
-0.1323473454,
-0.2320794761,
-0.9942551851,
-0.2763993144,
-0.2323328406,
-0.3887180984,
-0.5590820312,
0.7503700256,
-0.1801068783,
-0.2712492049,
-0.2360781133,
0.3668554127,
-0.0407108478,
0.4630460441,
-0.0353813879,
1.1201720238,
0.4799268246,
-0.6115679145,
0.3816839457,
0.4088055491,
0.1579237282,
1.0728082657,
-0.5598603487,
0.4937930703,
-0.0678982139,
0.4992857873,
-1.0826281309,
-0.1704144478,
0.0897923484,
-0.6172010303,
0.4963670373,
-0.1903713197,
-0.273925215,
-0.1989201605,
-0.3787967265,
0.2589990199,
0.5086042285,
-0.6551891565,
0.6359203458,
0.2151930034,
-0.5522968173,
-0.1276694089,
-0.7332622409,
0.6095283628,
-0.1305801868,
-0.3397825658,
0.4671013057,
-0.294634521,
0.180572018,
-0.2699275017,
-0.2781402171,
-0.3877030611,
-0.1573338211,
-0.1278520375,
0.0466841981,
-0.3139489591,
0.269610703,
0.0230745152,
-0.3136708438,
-0.4703802168,
-0.4699795246,
0.2486727685,
0.0595428646,
-0.1856017411,
-0.7134984136,
0.6249678731,
0.5377655625,
0.2383341044,
0.1225500032,
0.6447292566,
-0.140171513,
-0.1177424118,
-0.6721664071,
-0.0884654447,
-0.44049564,
0.7917006612,
-0.6242087483,
-0.9749336243,
0.3507940173,
-0.0787589625,
0.0837554932,
0.2637326121,
0.4317073524,
-0.0394825153,
0.6853120327,
0.689920485,
-0.2729570866,
0.611392498,
0.2565799356,
-0.1123862863,
-0.7647253275,
0.1239865571,
-0.7553777099,
0.0482200012,
-0.6759829521,
-0.2531059086,
0.2860342562,
-0.147874102,
-0.3684205711,
0.4759472609,
-0.8491567373,
0.588757515,
0.5549789071,
-0.0760651305,
0.2856650054,
0.307515949,
-0.0942311957,
-0.0911539197,
-0.6393921375,
-0.3144778609,
1.3878419399,
0.2735791504,
0.7073929906,
-0.0745446607,
0.7030953765,
0.5432991385,
-0.2301238626,
-0.5168125629,
0.5076858997,
-0.4574629068,
-0.5247757435,
-0.5557886958,
-0.46764189,
-0.8843882084,
0.307823807,
-0.0088657225,
-1.1950018406,
0.038696181,
0.3004770279,
-0.6102927923,
0.3427353203,
-0.8255287409,
0.5451783538,
-0.083637245,
-0.0110349385,
-0.0723868981,
-0.7296154499,
-0.1661411971,
-0.0889245868,
0.2684619725,
-0.1301218569,
0.1819084287,
0.7640619874,
0.0973167643,
0.7160840631,
-0.4053104818,
0.1839664727,
0.4033701718,
0.0597782955,
0.313831687,
0.0000084935,
-0.1726789474,
0.1123522669,
0.2488572448,
-0.5683888793,
-0.3913827837,
0.3984127641,
-0.7806545496,
-0.3761639595,
-0.2992233932,
-0.6530951262,
-0.7214058638,
0.0213605464,
0.4021790922,
0.6409883499,
-0.9086025357,
0.1427634507,
0.6928189993,
-0.2060121298,
0.7084720731,
0.633191824,
0.0158636384,
-0.7860984802,
1.0378495455,
0.0632437393,
0.379673928,
0.5724182129,
0.3597931862,
-0.2527524829,
-0.7748699188,
-0.5950686932,
0.0474306792,
-0.4511292875,
-0.1988589764,
-0.3051174581,
-0.2809570134,
-0.4577895403,
-0.3668994904,
-0.5923039913,
-0.5750402212,
-0.5122847557,
-0.0074310377,
0.5715159178,
0.3968009353,
-0.3924716115,
0.6570664048,
-0.9033784866,
0.8041582108,
0.7820628285,
0.39239645,
-0.301466465,
-1.1362667084,
-0.0383856148,
0.1074873433,
-0.346727401,
-0.7360752821,
0.0828795433,
0.6713400483,
0.3535572886,
0.1124911681,
0.159640193,
0.8324347734,
-0.8177467585,
0.8043919206,
0.3163858354,
-0.9859047532,
0.5545528531,
-0.4792221785,
0.5205491185,
0.6162572503,
-0.2179287225,
-0.7697663903,
-0.2386189997,
-0.4532375038,
-0.6214835644,
0.8112049103,
0.359756887,
0.7621959448,
0.2414466143,
0.5477143526,
0.1467250437,
-0.2315535992,
-0.5794743896,
-0.1992295235,
-0.5618874431,
-0.287563026,
-0.1398150176,
-0.4437871873,
0.0865632743,
-0.1248760372,
0.6056219339,
-0.3241271973,
0.5301650167,
0.4638549984,
-0.0359752923,
-0.1870886683,
0.9157250524,
0.5833135247,
0.4513494372,
-0.4609182477,
0.0029744077,
0.4311110079,
-0.6220770478,
0.3492682278,
0.2194270045,
-0.2701592743,
0.1592776775,
0.0772390142,
0.8836330771,
0.3412720561,
-0.4207082093,
0.3386943638,
-0.1239503101,
-0.2439133525,
-0.1952520758,
0.0821902081,
-0.0901211426,
0.0464809947,
0.7832050323,
0.1920711249,
-0.0663211867,
-0.5579752922,
0.4347756803,
0.2988850772,
-0.6901264787,
-0.682703495,
0.5889811516,
0.4387972951,
-0.7191818953,
0.2118065357,
-0.1633901298,
-0.3136401772,
0.1006440967,
0.9388452172,
1.1177498102,
-0.7958487868,
0.3073223233,
0.1039332524,
0.2009336054,
-0.0148912175,
0.3101478815,
-0.0842515677,
-0.7430520654,
-0.1740643829,
-0.4875777364,
-0.5384235382,
0.1221239939,
-0.4502043724,
0.039011199,
-0.4350111187,
-0.02893617,
-0.240580067,
-0.2343411446,
-0.5063984394,
0.4064253271,
0.1990705281,
0.7523169518,
-0.9214353561,
0.7569156289,
0.3353638649,
-0.0879534036,
-0.5312799811,
0.1906449795,
0.0656515062,
-0.6780996323,
-0.1334967166,
-0.1144089326,
-0.1193584055,
0.4803430438,
-0.2113384008,
-0.6673724055,
0.8281005621,
0.9061543941,
-0.4428945482,
-0.0378117673,
0.4333107471,
0.4195906222,
-0.2222051173,
0.1937828064,
0.7741919756,
0.1398421824,
0.4500244856,
-1.1321054697,
-0.274284035,
0.2062049061,
0.3389738202,
0.0050696186,
-0.5282007456,
0.5099621415,
-0.03268582,
-0.074348487,
0.1353831738,
0.5903488994,
0.1356783956,
0.2570219636,
0.4825317264,
0.3861464858,
0.4116927385,
0.1174665689,
0.5299962163,
0.2355726212,
0.2156441659,
1.2909644842,
-0.2096935064,
0.8431765437,
0.5209425688,
-0.5397104025,
0.075850822,
0.2154864371,
0.2233474851,
0.5633305907,
-0.0357423425,
-0.4600955546,
-0.1199491546,
-0.2635106742,
-0.3963590264,
0.8784139752,
0.3040392995,
0.2511961758,
-0.4060748518,
0.0895413831,
-0.2241681516,
0.2636093795,
-0.1413231045,
0.9024167061,
-0.0138155008,
-0.2760094404,
0.7030665278,
-0.3808378279,
0.6179792285,
-0.5746142268,
-0.0517977066,
-0.1946411133,
-0.0761177316,
0.0888917223,
-0.5077915788,
0.2015899271,
0.2772015035,
-0.1148889065,
-0.063589856,
0.5767136812,
-0.1130250022,
-0.400810957,
0.2032772154,
0.324837327,
0.1197375432,
-0.1977896541,
-0.6113575697,
0.1922169328,
0.1956750751,
-0.2469791174,
0.3499421775,
0.6071349978,
0.1542266756,
0.2994693816,
0.5438868999,
0.2069259137,
-0.0042788954,
0.3663369417,
0.6096634865,
-0.7712317705,
-0.6112728119,
-0.7629036307,
0.5858120918,
0.2167018205,
-0.2471486181,
0.3937759399,
0.3803334832,
0.6290192008,
0.1023851335,
0.8378930688,
0.1499888748,
0.7765023112,
-0.5124103427,
0.550667882,
-0.3751363158,
0.0891567469,
-0.7551501989,
-0.9541084766,
-0.4283148348,
0.4128029346,
0.3369685411,
-0.0557434112,
0.5387721062,
0.5876768231,
0.034276545,
0.1814259142,
0.8034680486,
0.3373563886,
0.4420199096,
0.6444451809,
0.5536385775,
-0.686052382,
1.0042788982,
-0.0009668806,
-0.3529502153,
-0.2360405773,
-0.9507302046,
-0.6114341021,
-0.5410866737,
-0.264046222,
0.308914423,
0.2895795703,
0.7464900613,
0.7649455667,
-0.8706001639,
-0.2484878153,
-0.2688062191,
-0.1130853593,
0.0318978317,
-0.2032885402,
0.3644385636,
-0.2105473578,
-0.4991775453,
0.7605873346,
0.7279948592,
0.4344275296,
0.334474206,
0.0332009979,
0.1324824989,
0.3340417147,
0.5139502287,
0.7435230613,
-0.655655086,
-0.7500401139,
-0.1348088086,
0.2568362355,
0.3121066391,
0.6215664148,
-0.8125599027,
1.0085662603,
0.0648187995,
0.7272033691,
0.4908775091,
-0.0040805852,
0.5861748457,
-1.0419273376,
0.5320917368,
0.3181377351,
0.0492259972,
0.4023496211,
-0.071296908,
0.1732666492,
0.1688985229,
-0.6481316686,
-0.8155035973,
0.2644852698,
-1.0908038616,
-0.1917994022,
0.8466821313,
-0.0304441862,
0.3047677577,
-0.3128798008,
-0.3801105917,
0.4601266086,
-0.7137967944,
0.8836904168,
0.2263540924,
-0.3076301217,
-0.0282526966,
-0.5540162325,
0.2489308715,
0.3380047679,
-0.7137879729,
0.2447792143,
0.3929379582,
0.3324146867,
0.0794709697,
0.9996393919,
0.1463197917,
0.3939195573,
0.0902551785,
0.0154052833,
0.1460659802,
-0.2742013037,
-0.4729224741,
0.0727075562,
0.1416645795,
-0.402677536
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.