id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05012v1
|
Towards Reliable and Empathetic Depression-Diagnosis-Oriented Chats
| 2024-04-07T16:35:53 | 2024-04-07T16:35:53 |
Kunyao Lan, Cong Ming, Binwei Yao, Lu Chen, Mengyue Wu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Chatbots can serve as a viable tool for preliminary depression diagnosis via
interactive conversations with potential patients. Nevertheless, the blend of
task-oriented and chit-chat in diagnosis-related dialogues necessitates
professional expertise and empathy. Such unique requirements challenge
traditional dialogue frameworks geared towards single optimization goals. To
address this, we propose an innovative ontology definition and generation
framework tailored explicitly for depression diagnosis dialogues, combining the
reliability of task-oriented conversations with the appeal of empathy-related
chit-chat. We further apply the framework to D$^4$, the only existing public
dialogue dataset on depression diagnosis-oriented chats. Exhaustive
experimental results indicate significant improvements in task completion and
emotional support generation in depression diagnosis, fostering a more
comprehensive approach to task-oriented chat dialogue system development and
its applications in digital mental health.
|
[
-0.5375851989,
-0.8540538549,
1.0314768553,
0.5002183318,
-0.0781818405,
-0.1646976918,
-0.2317827493,
-0.0789011493,
0.3866710365,
0.3820914924,
-1.0483283997,
-0.5949194431,
-0.5986690521,
0.5123664737,
-0.3337413967,
0.9088283777,
0.3329497278,
0.0638897046,
-0.1313222945,
0.2066539228,
-0.3574227989,
-0.2892664969,
-1.3457722664,
-0.0524058975,
0.5101951957,
0.4704024196,
0.8773146868,
0.237472415,
0.5853203535,
0.2962123454,
0.1340806633,
0.228908211,
-0.5333080888,
0.4547466636,
-0.1159727648,
-0.4859128296,
-0.8576283455,
-0.4280254543,
-0.1531814933,
0.4721027315,
-0.2797112763,
-0.2752866745,
0.2773993909,
0.3199745715,
-0.2269880474,
0.0908880755,
-0.2876772285,
0.4017295837,
0.1029204354,
-0.2862016559,
-0.0565836988,
-0.222898677,
0.1015657932,
-0.7539577484,
0.1167172343,
-0.4640386701,
0.4230307639,
0.413659215,
-0.103971459,
-0.4468145072,
-0.5858394504,
0.7296124101,
-0.6491381526,
-0.0156179825,
0.7960247993,
0.588308394,
-0.3576383889,
-0.5654895902,
-0.4537176192,
0.0993528664,
0.1019445062,
0.3684272766,
-0.4746074378,
0.1905870885,
0.0517805256,
0.2118793428,
-0.2976058125,
0.0117255738,
0.2600499094,
-0.0179482903,
0.5485613346,
0.520590663,
0.4937635362,
-0.4414414167,
0.0112278173,
0.3777084053,
-0.0589582622,
-0.3642989397,
0.1597866118,
0.3623132408,
-0.3911516368,
0.286816597,
-0.1434393376,
0.5117567182,
0.2740491033,
-0.3379743397,
0.0167903677,
-0.4473154545,
-0.041086603,
-0.0691136569,
0.7484090924,
0.7106372714,
-0.0300563574,
0.0266319122,
0.0060230526,
0.3032397628,
0.540276885,
-0.6402782798,
-0.5989888906,
0.813418448,
-0.5466469526,
-0.4810153246,
-0.499948889,
-0.7886365652,
-0.6094536185,
-0.1191373467,
0.2321871817,
-0.5765276551,
-0.571680665,
0.1395342052,
-0.2957915068,
-0.4654401839,
0.6169819832,
-0.6547460556,
0.1929623634,
0.7038118243,
0.7662411332,
0.2902943492,
0.2572721243,
-0.447694391,
-0.0566732064,
-0.1859826446,
0.7363262177,
-0.5222288966,
-0.3696765006,
-0.0037270759,
-0.2347435802,
0.226829648,
-0.1702764928,
0.7805067897,
0.4138265252,
0.45004794,
-0.0702537,
-0.3862163424,
0.1683880389,
0.7180709839,
-0.2486255318,
0.5790519118,
0.5213659406,
-0.8859375715,
0.1604499817,
-0.8295241594,
-0.0547698997,
0.2065968364,
-0.2096412629,
-0.1402221173,
-0.0830331594,
-0.1355033219,
0.8571056128,
-0.8026589155,
0.3144002557,
-0.5355631709,
0.005594667,
0.2157624513,
-0.31776914,
0.6216083169,
0.1207060739,
-0.2881573737,
-0.3812657297,
-0.8222825527,
0.0780056119,
0.0127462745,
0.0766512528,
-0.318538636,
0.2496165633,
-0.1818085909,
0.3501459956,
0.0931498259,
-0.9401734471,
-0.2384513766,
-0.5126587152,
0.5357335806,
0.5022101998,
-0.0751861036,
-0.0001559491,
-0.3675958514,
0.6485010982,
0.2633359134,
0.5475363731,
-0.5067519546,
-0.7723651528,
-0.5099939108,
-0.7718223929,
-0.1150841787,
0.6420363784,
-0.2769254148,
1.0015954971,
0.0145375868,
-0.6441005468,
-0.4691775441,
-0.0829142481,
0.4548389614,
0.710170567,
0.2917935252,
-0.5418468714,
-0.4746145904,
-0.7446061969,
0.1522929966,
0.0198953934,
-0.2207827717,
0.6803054214,
-0.2186118364,
-0.7512800694,
0.9016842246,
-0.4784148633,
-0.5166727304,
-0.3154672384,
-0.0556357019,
0.147846967,
0.3422964215,
0.5643678904,
-0.6289988756,
-0.7160034776,
0.0812453479,
-0.830848515,
-0.1117921621,
0.0116944974,
-0.4246561229,
-0.050159432,
0.0543884821,
-0.742081821,
0.7090681195,
0.7325618863,
-0.5941907763,
-0.0141307944,
0.0563083366,
0.2349094898,
-1.4746135473,
-0.1400703788,
0.0048845075,
-0.5196159482,
-0.6178318262,
-0.8631469011,
-0.4285389781,
-0.2614873052,
-0.0926703811,
0.2822403014,
0.2446324676,
0.1355081052,
-0.2693617642,
0.7104377747,
0.1272642165,
0.2194463462,
-0.1032948494,
-0.1738640517,
1.0418921709,
-0.5646638274,
0.6652944684,
0.9939697385,
0.2071035206,
1.1418491602,
-0.4461669028,
-0.1171628162,
0.0700463504,
0.3839932382,
-1.030766964,
-0.2742056549,
0.5039913058,
-0.5963270068,
0.0583749302,
0.1763722748,
-0.288341403,
-0.3054776192,
0.0143752359,
0.3294630945,
0.5119866729,
-0.3183346689,
0.5292239785,
0.262884587,
-0.6326211095,
-0.1017574295,
-0.6581658125,
0.1127084047,
-0.2459603846,
-0.8882685304,
0.3210330904,
0.0529533215,
-0.3561007977,
-0.1133079082,
0.0781801343,
-0.0917392895,
0.166967243,
0.3193981647,
-0.1182035357,
-0.0450144857,
0.5025620461,
0.2495246828,
-0.421266526,
0.1765958965,
0.1665094197,
0.8308785558,
0.211155951,
-0.4221067131,
-0.8596689105,
0.6422618032,
0.2325436175,
0.4645712376,
0.4283184707,
0.2326133996,
-0.2163647413,
-0.1355727613,
-0.2656390667,
-0.4659132659,
-0.4463952184,
0.1498710662,
-0.4428676069,
-0.7968572378,
0.401101768,
-0.2747158706,
0.2242926955,
0.3205911517,
0.6748946309,
-0.1488258392,
1.6703323126,
0.5374644399,
0.4805085063,
0.2272767127,
0.1982735991,
0.7435732484,
-0.471532613,
0.1995525211,
-0.4732195437,
-0.1419548094,
-0.5987817645,
-0.1958369762,
0.4215049446,
-0.0056542638,
-0.3061041534,
0.2674801052,
-0.6607815027,
-0.1571045369,
-0.016026346,
0.3911552429,
0.2713547051,
-0.3903166652,
0.1654495448,
-0.2008060366,
-0.6217467189,
-0.6784400344,
0.9424442053,
0.2174510509,
0.4243183434,
0.0510108434,
0.7593755126,
0.4436618984,
0.1773415506,
-0.6214451194,
0.3256219327,
-0.1333465725,
-0.5031762719,
-0.3830341399,
-0.5918813944,
-0.9681994319,
-0.2552036643,
0.0590491407,
-0.9392222762,
0.0929271877,
0.3953129351,
-0.5078620315,
-0.0450758971,
-0.4285148084,
1.0652543306,
-0.2497178018,
0.2011679709,
-0.551807344,
-0.6806147099,
0.3492695689,
-0.55049932,
0.1496629119,
-0.6207783818,
0.0557130538,
0.3773847222,
-0.3902983367,
1.070076108,
-0.0725095198,
-0.3864058256,
0.1298074275,
0.2754050791,
-0.0046148016,
0.3675396442,
-0.1048446521,
0.1102849692,
0.2626403868,
-0.2793926597,
-0.9591888785,
0.4683830738,
-0.7166017294,
-0.5355488062,
0.1550940275,
-0.2325405926,
-0.5532807112,
0.054288771,
0.2374969572,
0.5420479774,
-0.3458845615,
-0.0401312411,
0.2659173906,
-0.4215897322,
-0.0493264981,
0.3479913175,
-0.1391428113,
-0.1488204896,
0.7081087232,
-0.4373821914,
0.2846795917,
0.23790811,
0.3718767464,
0.1044143811,
0.4146279097,
0.0519195125,
0.1281642765,
-0.6892413497,
-0.5921071172,
-1.0346179008,
-0.0757696256,
-0.4966669381,
-0.3392792344,
-0.8537417054,
-0.7575231791,
-0.4604535699,
-0.1362839639,
0.8476055264,
0.5378319025,
-0.4529919922,
0.1148133725,
-1.1882859468,
0.4337356389,
0.0258411951,
0.3678435385,
-0.0394784175,
-0.1629874259,
-0.0832633972,
0.3646069467,
-0.6433221698,
-0.6735138297,
0.2908058465,
0.3693181276,
0.3110963702,
0.8997317553,
0.4784294665,
0.5224705338,
-0.1497112215,
0.7824375033,
0.7977800965,
-0.9993833303,
0.9219237566,
-0.4619894922,
-0.182573542,
0.299233377,
0.691328764,
-0.8038035035,
-0.8441839814,
-0.8816105127,
-0.5222615004,
0.8845739961,
0.3359909952,
0.3220421374,
-0.4628895521,
0.2190630734,
0.479028374,
-0.0569420159,
-0.0585926622,
-0.0879141167,
-0.5559958816,
-0.6291306615,
-0.1858625263,
-0.1690728068,
-0.6621754766,
-0.1386615038,
0.2656391859,
-0.2552792132,
0.7901806831,
0.2996578515,
0.6336066127,
-0.3097631335,
0.1071507409,
0.0298381448,
0.5122703314,
0.251075089,
-0.1855571717,
-0.1731795967,
-0.1252503693,
-0.0732655451,
0.010778402,
0.3800186515,
0.0409321189,
-0.0308252517,
0.6636554003,
0.3177090585,
-1.0391443968,
0.7869300842,
-0.3781293035,
-0.2946963608,
-0.3810709715,
0.3169152439,
0.2210389823,
0.5020400882,
-0.0141013227,
-0.0395488851,
0.119552277,
-0.4903836548,
0.3425528705,
0.2026792616,
-0.6227284074,
-0.592779398,
0.2487190515,
0.6885021329,
-0.7767353058,
0.7604179382,
-0.1670265198,
-0.4634399414,
0.3162029386,
0.4825611115,
1.0395653248,
0.0162968151,
0.6356419325,
0.2569076717,
-0.4874582291,
-0.0376331508,
0.5790902972,
-0.4146997333,
-1.0227370262,
-0.0060038595,
-0.4804682434,
-0.7025820017,
-0.2932121754,
-0.4986302853,
0.4512461424,
-0.3114959896,
-0.798340857,
-0.1340227723,
-0.3065936565,
-0.3866738975,
0.3899426758,
0.0841516033,
0.4599127471,
-0.553658545,
0.3130170107,
0.4108726382,
-0.1063695922,
-0.4870848358,
-0.0063077607,
0.0490618572,
-0.4854712188,
0.3895046413,
0.2312205285,
0.09962219,
0.1037036031,
-0.3127698898,
-0.850094676,
0.9824331403,
0.2794832289,
-0.3977836072,
0.0744453967,
0.0323389731,
0.7168765664,
-0.6599341035,
0.4030535221,
0.6010798812,
0.5169399381,
-0.0002431868,
-1.2489677668,
0.032872282,
-0.3412011862,
-0.1568139941,
0.2378347218,
-0.6509359479,
0.6230600476,
0.0362051502,
-0.2786533535,
0.3181760609,
0.0309524536,
0.1786033213,
0.1357577741,
0.4417352974,
0.6455746293,
0.6721693873,
-0.1502278745,
1.1121892929,
-0.8225724697,
0.0026862116,
0.5396518707,
-0.3395598829,
0.4481156468,
0.0617756993,
0.0528762452,
0.3502722979,
0.5607642531,
0.0962192714,
0.2179291546,
-0.156991303,
-0.2843671739,
-0.6276903749,
-0.361294359,
-0.104302302,
0.5539078712,
0.6592196822,
-0.4754094779,
-0.3284289241,
0.2600147724,
0.0692894086,
0.0630674064,
-0.0575480573,
0.8468091488,
0.2721614838,
-0.4796785414,
0.4370355308,
-0.1437840462,
0.3647626042,
-0.419873327,
0.0548816286,
-0.0679306984,
0.3636749983,
-0.3304735124,
-0.6850752831,
0.418733716,
0.1976101547,
0.0170416832,
-0.4032457471,
0.6534417272,
-0.1276732087,
-0.344437778,
0.588650763,
0.7032504082,
0.4650896788,
-0.0713201091,
-0.7525318265,
0.0172644202,
-0.1075142026,
-0.2774061263,
0.3710161746,
0.9615811706,
0.3802526295,
0.7787844539,
0.0883085653,
-0.1255563498,
-0.3159042299,
0.0349481665,
0.9559818506,
-0.590972662,
-0.5236339569,
-0.4746374786,
0.5387513041,
-0.1223848611,
-0.5429848433,
0.6417363286,
0.0328895412,
0.4378201067,
0.2151641846,
1.1210830212,
-0.4340022504,
0.9642033577,
0.1171565279,
0.5876277685,
-0.6993132234,
-0.2978197634,
-0.5786855817,
-0.8065174818,
-0.2150415331,
0.795745492,
0.0148898065,
-0.0442989767,
0.5761480927,
0.697291851,
0.1029857993,
0.4899793565,
0.5332118869,
0.3072473407,
0.3919487,
0.5939044356,
1.0724618435,
-0.1760530621,
0.6417866349,
-0.2191514522,
-0.4590450823,
-0.2780651152,
-0.5208665729,
-0.9168335199,
-0.4949098229,
-0.4783147275,
-0.1723339111,
-0.0001601447,
0.8137376308,
0.3099290729,
-0.4212682247,
0.1648384184,
-0.5214860439,
-0.217828393,
-0.1443367153,
-0.2743526697,
-0.0102967909,
-0.6288470626,
-0.6896217465,
0.197477147,
0.6506748796,
-0.1992447525,
-0.415958941,
-0.1272514611,
0.4702405632,
0.1474480182,
0.5897952914,
0.1150967106,
-0.4539789557,
-0.1062827706,
-0.2207922786,
-0.1857870817,
0.224592194,
0.8284543753,
-0.4865797758,
0.292440623,
0.299584806,
0.5020434856,
-0.0444853306,
0.2391762882,
1.1099606752,
-0.2355063111,
-0.0139617119,
0.7094529271,
0.0049754377,
0.3491823673,
-0.6084201932,
0.3585858941,
0.0512364544,
-0.6713727117,
-0.8237226605,
0.4674670994,
-0.8663149476,
-0.0806344077,
0.9879371524,
-0.6005674601,
0.1213191077,
-0.6462699771,
-0.4357206821,
0.3323372602,
-0.5514766574,
1.0775785446,
0.3157327175,
-0.7706547379,
-0.0311407782,
-0.0050988169,
0.7104822993,
0.3457636535,
-0.6935334802,
0.1666769534,
0.4120828509,
-0.1826858521,
0.3086933196,
0.9636867642,
-0.109058246,
0.3361905515,
0.1426948458,
-0.0484823026,
0.5231779814,
-0.0291592125,
0.2912468314,
0.0838179365,
-0.3468242586,
0.1475656182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02314v1
|
A geometric framework for interstellar discourse on fundamental physical structures
| 2024-04-07T16:03:01 | 2024-04-07T16:03:01 |
Giampiero Esposito, Valeria Fionda
|
cs.IT
|
cs.IT, cs.CL, math.IT
|
This paper considers the possibility that abstract thinking and advanced
synthesis skills might encourage extraterrestrial civilizations to accept
communication with mankind on Earth. For this purpose, a notation not relying
upon the use of alphabet and numbers is proposed, in order to denote just some
basic geometric structures of current physical theories: vector fields,
one-form fields, and tensor fields of arbitrary order. An advanced civilization
might appreciate the way here proposed to achieve a concise description of
electromagnetism and general relativity, and hence it might accept the
challenge of responding to our signals. The abstract symbols introduced in this
paper to describe the basic structures of physical theories are encoded into
black and white bitmap images that can be easily converted into short bit
sequences and modulated on a carrier wave for radio transmission.
|
[
-0.7106720209,
-0.8828142881,
0.9575331807,
0.3545202017,
-0.1591462493,
0.1675592512,
0.1499393731,
-0.6432579756,
0.7254633307,
0.2107905596,
-0.5335193276,
-0.4255119264,
-0.4537701309,
-0.1036909074,
-0.4665623307,
0.4524745345,
0.0072773504,
-0.1393084079,
-0.0641524941,
-0.2078361511,
-0.0925257653,
-0.6439344287,
-0.3201645315,
-0.2002521455,
0.4846484959,
0.1944202185,
0.9219688177,
0.391030252,
0.8857260942,
0.3426378667,
-0.4048781395,
0.0647595599,
-0.0054209423,
-0.22290425,
-0.3709668219,
-0.2651238143,
-0.5536648631,
0.1156120896,
0.913701117,
1.2579581738,
0.1171275899,
0.354316622,
-0.1701822579,
0.7072270513,
0.014219353,
0.0977761447,
-0.3321133256,
0.3266777992,
0.0257138088,
-0.4375140965,
0.0029857992,
-0.3913161457,
0.0950476229,
-0.9784127474,
0.1377425641,
0.5124343634,
0.591973722,
-0.0173420031,
-0.2723133862,
-0.3109249473,
-0.8287236094,
0.0764741674,
-0.078132838,
0.4794295728,
0.4094947278,
0.4397532642,
-0.3739293814,
-0.6438761353,
-0.6376521587,
-0.376991719,
-0.2196146399,
0.281921804,
0.0016483924,
0.3096426427,
0.3644007444,
0.5037741065,
-0.3716386557,
-0.1262233257,
-1.2411849499,
-0.0644064769,
0.4224802256,
0.3839262128,
0.2490803897,
0.3443098962,
-0.1916095912,
0.0781596899,
-1.0532734394,
0.0313681141,
0.5848713517,
-0.038428925,
-0.4590108991,
0.6689684987,
-0.054492984,
0.4288029969,
0.1710030437,
0.5068152547,
-0.2836970985,
-0.1120990962,
-0.0525266416,
-0.1871349961,
0.456661582,
0.5921817422,
-0.4094927609,
-0.3718178272,
0.1566563547,
0.5734535456,
0.4872309864,
-0.7211869955,
-0.3016951084,
0.2324653566,
-0.6225147247,
-0.0777853653,
0.4861485958,
-0.5424123406,
-0.1787676364,
-0.318655163,
0.1449881643,
-0.0509601533,
-0.2133516222,
0.2125575393,
0.0700280145,
0.1383868903,
0.2139451802,
-1.1232949495,
0.4532060623,
0.5994282961,
0.6981865168,
0.6452891827,
-0.1958729923,
0.3049806058,
0.3539764881,
-0.4097720981,
1.1369073391,
-0.3809713423,
-1.0335053205,
-0.3373625278,
0.0202431772,
0.5837241411,
-0.0026301965,
0.5725221038,
-0.4101645052,
0.4145674706,
-0.5834100246,
-0.3214333355,
-0.8357235789,
0.1385912448,
-0.5839602947,
0.3926044703,
0.158472985,
-0.3142821491,
0.168746978,
-1.0135755539,
-0.2274083346,
0.6239359975,
-0.6232634783,
-0.1934663653,
0.3056676984,
-0.1767686754,
0.121208258,
-0.4390424788,
-0.0455166698,
-0.4717600346,
-0.4207108319,
0.2873640358,
-0.0607791282,
0.2120018899,
0.5289640427,
-0.332559377,
-0.0933147445,
-0.8023326993,
0.3244664073,
-0.1142079309,
-0.3981894851,
-0.0655235872,
0.1991726607,
0.1105277315,
0.3179329634,
-0.1246138886,
-0.6834176183,
0.4332228601,
-0.4688768387,
0.6386942267,
0.7145479918,
-0.0290597528,
0.8337858319,
-0.2728543878,
0.3731609583,
-0.2121859342,
0.0134151373,
-0.2995049655,
-0.3065097928,
-0.7597255707,
-0.0978355855,
-0.4243893921,
0.207483381,
-0.3681194484,
0.515745461,
-0.1636617631,
-0.6029126048,
-0.2245892286,
-0.3799353242,
0.525619328,
0.3838094473,
0.32497558,
-0.1135737598,
-0.7560293674,
-0.7564198375,
-0.1497254819,
-0.5051034689,
0.0600144118,
0.265760839,
0.2890855372,
-0.1774302572,
0.5433565974,
-0.4115393162,
0.0792858824,
0.3032586873,
-0.1233029664,
0.3052479327,
0.6092121601,
0.4315079749,
-0.7755423784,
-0.0776332542,
0.329216063,
-1.0094199181,
0.284753859,
0.0164438337,
-0.3933705091,
-0.3455454409,
0.693266809,
-0.5668773055,
0.2015349418,
0.3222666979,
-1.0860204697,
-0.0334972478,
-0.1743884981,
0.3501125574,
-0.7939060926,
0.3196988106,
0.1105854362,
-0.1945126504,
-0.4661425948,
0.3081347346,
-0.2059948891,
-0.2959058285,
-0.5506288409,
0.3685413897,
-0.4792674482,
-0.2343734354,
-0.1447596401,
-0.1854279041,
0.0456083678,
0.3077393472,
0.2213485986,
0.3647980094,
0.3540705144,
-0.8027216196,
0.1970078796,
0.5837312341,
-0.2151433676,
0.9217350483,
-0.9085469842,
0.1115594879,
-0.7414849401,
0.4824407101,
-0.6976471543,
0.0280892402,
0.466168493,
-0.3330391347,
-0.1578184515,
-0.1256785691,
-0.0724851638,
-0.2856912613,
0.1358298957,
0.5829439759,
0.1534039229,
-0.1897040009,
0.5618149638,
0.4180855155,
-0.2338343412,
0.0607936643,
-0.4956345558,
-0.0325037129,
-0.2782701254,
-0.9449026585,
0.4438193738,
-0.1263698936,
-0.7091526985,
0.0933862329,
0.083611019,
-0.0153511837,
0.1225458905,
0.6692433953,
0.6488548517,
-0.4219325483,
-0.1797214448,
-0.0031406423,
-0.2930871844,
0.0599266626,
-0.7562628984,
0.2884916067,
-0.71118325,
-0.0678785667,
-0.4194612801,
0.8002608418,
0.7621158361,
0.4127908647,
0.2697488964,
0.2634670138,
-0.4749099314,
0.4139506519,
-0.2395451218,
-0.1901982874,
-0.5078291297,
0.3389621079,
-0.4764856696,
-0.7342631221,
0.4299713969,
-0.1286664158,
0.4394383132,
0.5670901537,
0.4278400242,
-0.642501235,
0.7898566723,
0.8741688728,
0.4746741652,
0.2181649804,
-0.5166674256,
0.1442876905,
-0.8541286588,
-0.5975938439,
-0.4945746958,
-0.4428931773,
-0.2692848742,
-0.332947284,
0.4984638989,
0.1210171208,
-0.5323109031,
0.4748735428,
-0.8887165785,
0.7259327769,
0.1635724455,
-0.1432770789,
0.2054680735,
0.2128255516,
0.027337119,
0.0396226011,
-0.2934221029,
-0.9677596092,
0.7012246251,
0.5727617145,
0.9235209823,
0.3872282207,
0.2819232643,
0.1831536591,
0.3136300147,
-0.5286801457,
0.3909407556,
-0.0385240652,
-0.6695287824,
0.2047520131,
-0.2226217836,
-0.7387501597,
0.5710875392,
-0.6172830462,
-0.4124343991,
0.3665390611,
0.1336262822,
-0.6830316186,
0.2232684344,
-0.8689825535,
0.3286775351,
-0.006768012,
0.14904131,
-0.3353679776,
-0.5920523405,
0.1996695995,
0.5014827847,
0.5020488501,
-0.1164981872,
0.0773333386,
0.5467582941,
-0.2779367864,
0.6048653722,
-0.0745587796,
-0.1766426116,
0.6449158788,
0.3436079025,
-0.0527839437,
0.5630252361,
0.3757660687,
0.3306602538,
0.292275995,
-0.308488071,
-0.3651323318,
0.4287211299,
-0.9179981947,
-0.4517699182,
-0.2893553376,
-0.5467013121,
0.0402932689,
0.127563864,
0.4922094941,
0.5548275113,
-0.4073261023,
0.0269547328,
0.4890346825,
0.0362509862,
0.3446176052,
0.4594718516,
-0.4560132623,
-0.50631392,
0.5120830536,
-0.0461491197,
0.1537879705,
0.4312587976,
-0.1894025058,
-0.4597462714,
-0.231739074,
-0.4151352942,
0.1885745525,
-1.013125062,
0.11301779,
-0.6994437575,
-0.1178359091,
0.0481828637,
-0.7223904729,
-0.2942485511,
-0.8813812137,
-0.0359897427,
-0.2908061743,
0.1433392316,
1.1555268764,
0.0452810675,
0.6503737569,
-0.6927440166,
0.4320576787,
-0.178971529,
0.3861477673,
-0.3046806157,
-0.2255137563,
-0.3384545147,
0.1413698047,
-0.5388077497,
-0.0896752104,
-0.151497364,
-0.0299536064,
0.3864626586,
0.1344630122,
-0.7490977049,
0.86715132,
-0.7149592042,
0.5291375518,
0.6479765773,
-0.9314053059,
0.2946094871,
-0.3622588813,
0.065926224,
0.3936486244,
0.1646716744,
-0.672739625,
-0.3010849953,
-0.8439579606,
-0.6473987103,
0.0920213386,
-0.0396144688,
0.0784634873,
0.0080693271,
0.4729983211,
0.1424807161,
0.01016156,
-0.9285026789,
-0.4967519939,
-0.2735806108,
-0.077842094,
0.1197647527,
0.1229454055,
-0.4975370169,
-0.1168751121,
0.2258128375,
0.0103692869,
0.6710087657,
0.5608152747,
-0.0148138842,
-0.2446278483,
0.1277118623,
0.7956542969,
0.7832802534,
0.1090470701,
0.3162243068,
-0.332698971,
-0.7176501155,
0.4030512273,
-0.1406636983,
-0.0207628459,
-0.0752208456,
0.1680931747,
0.5449658632,
0.0333650969,
0.0308547411,
-0.0893266723,
-0.3154621422,
-0.3620489538,
-0.5420745611,
-0.3175278306,
0.0646011233,
0.4193101227,
0.4064248502,
0.3934127688,
0.0305555575,
-0.9173051119,
0.0540136285,
0.422970593,
-0.4470928013,
-0.949275732,
1.0710043907,
0.390209794,
-0.0726976991,
0.178891018,
0.0105734449,
-0.3239247501,
0.4986319244,
0.5597096086,
0.571855545,
0.2165513188,
0.1206800118,
0.3624987006,
0.5716873407,
0.129587397,
0.6801913381,
0.0043543996,
-0.3793049455,
-0.2667527497,
-0.6761581302,
-0.4194619656,
-0.519085288,
-0.0613097474,
0.4308130145,
-1.2180137634,
-0.0840259567,
0.2379079908,
-0.1807039678,
-0.5959707499,
0.1241927072,
0.6385997534,
0.843439281,
-0.5836831331,
0.3354199529,
0.994317472,
-0.600966692,
-0.6792621613,
-0.6186833382,
-0.024763979,
-0.4439310431,
0.8558495045,
0.0579921044,
-0.305685848,
0.0538302921,
-0.5246391892,
-1.076777339,
0.9175768495,
0.2958787382,
-0.4682040513,
-0.0598799102,
0.0765785128,
0.3170152009,
-0.2683652043,
0.2794368863,
0.2006127983,
0.4975436926,
0.1499105841,
-0.5861622691,
0.071218729,
-0.5629752278,
0.0979497656,
0.4250816703,
-0.6862365007,
0.9314959645,
-0.2343599647,
-0.5342898369,
0.3502321541,
0.987724185,
0.0666407943,
0.1614456028,
0.0651661158,
0.42794469,
0.4047249258,
-0.2319436967,
0.8628641367,
-0.0851645619,
0.4099621177,
0.1858237088,
0.1215194836,
-0.0819429383,
0.5416775942,
-0.6618862152,
0.5236218572,
0.4618989825,
0.0002599239,
0.4142757654,
0.0590496175,
-0.2718462646,
0.2278540879,
0.127440244,
-0.7146581411,
0.5267698169,
0.9424687028,
-0.1392474324,
-0.2318464369,
-0.2481869906,
-0.0096772984,
0.1814029217,
-0.6114201546,
0.6656438112,
0.4072419107,
-0.4884564877,
0.5537581444,
0.1297448128,
0.6135175824,
-0.6091927886,
-0.2760162354,
0.1362127364,
-0.0278205723,
-0.4796973765,
-0.7251971364,
0.5988271236,
-0.4110102057,
-0.1619227976,
-0.2605046332,
0.2135774046,
-0.3467556536,
-0.6626653075,
-0.3518182337,
-0.0465696231,
0.1928237528,
0.2590554655,
-0.2808264792,
0.0339080282,
-0.3193105757,
0.1956592351,
-0.0821291059,
0.111064136,
-0.0884068087,
0.281414181,
0.9818323255,
0.2253137529,
0.1859476417,
-0.6354630589,
0.8323292732,
-1.2022687197,
-1.2326947451,
-0.7288663983,
0.4409321845,
0.1860820651,
-0.4543184936,
0.4039292336,
0.4155193865,
0.5967949629,
-0.0447156467,
0.8907840252,
-0.4772214592,
-0.0423863456,
-0.6544701457,
0.6311357021,
0.1565068364,
0.2023563385,
-0.3459739089,
-1.2818539143,
-0.5553761125,
0.7370584011,
0.0124226855,
-0.2534496486,
0.8402264714,
0.2744532824,
-0.0255669374,
0.4662384093,
0.3352951407,
0.059481889,
0.631965816,
0.4611439109,
1.2557096481,
-0.4162333906,
0.2117040753,
-0.0608683825,
-0.1478714049,
0.0700522363,
-0.4978542626,
-0.4748809934,
-0.7206242085,
-0.1077066511,
-0.529548943,
-0.2706493139,
0.9573508501,
0.6552559733,
-0.2777202725,
-0.0781336203,
-0.2457665354,
-0.2272655219,
0.2294389606,
-0.1148269102,
0.3968352377,
0.0722613931,
-0.6334218979,
0.4600302279,
0.7352083325,
0.4804543853,
-0.4286548495,
0.0665861666,
0.4019120932,
0.0511694513,
0.9290510416,
0.8299794793,
-0.5290386081,
-0.5358725786,
-0.0290226322,
-0.0511211343,
-0.0521824956,
1.1446539164,
-0.6813061237,
0.0153188845,
0.066011101,
0.3124715388,
0.2147131711,
-0.0087928167,
0.5802078247,
-0.2727795243,
0.9919284582,
0.3650010824,
0.5971853137,
0.2132823914,
-0.5942481756,
0.3986906111,
0.2872676253,
-0.417832911,
-0.6129772663,
0.4709219933,
-0.8969114423,
-0.1418599784,
0.8153584003,
0.0471151173,
-0.3081360459,
-0.2657775879,
-0.3102278411,
-0.3368745446,
0.0621504113,
0.8531090021,
0.5590918064,
-0.1284011006,
0.2719185054,
-0.282238096,
0.2228914797,
0.2201135904,
-0.7430853248,
-0.3119454682,
0.6755837798,
0.0446226448,
0.4862526357,
0.9064927697,
-0.5929426551,
0.3890017271,
0.3025916517,
-0.0646904632,
0.0555128194,
-0.4049814939,
-0.15074718,
-0.026040338,
-0.0430943258,
-0.0351049826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04997v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04997v2
|
Adapting LLMs for Efficient Context Processing through Soft Prompt Compression
| 2024-04-07T15:44:20 | 2024-04-18T23:23:53 |
Cangqing Wang, Yutian Yang, Ruisi Li, Dan Sun, Ruicong Cai, Yuzhu Zhang, Chengqian Fu, Lillian Floyd
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has inaugurated a
transformative epoch in natural language processing, fostering unprecedented
proficiency in text generation, comprehension, and contextual scrutiny.
Nevertheless, effectively handling extensive contexts, crucial for myriad
applications, poses a formidable obstacle owing to the intrinsic constraints of
the models' context window sizes and the computational burdens entailed by
their operations. This investigation presents an innovative framework that
strategically tailors LLMs for streamlined context processing by harnessing the
synergies among natural language summarization, soft prompt compression, and
augmented utility preservation mechanisms. Our methodology, dubbed
SoftPromptComp, amalgamates natural language prompts extracted from
summarization methodologies with dynamically generated soft prompts to forge a
concise yet semantically robust depiction of protracted contexts. This
depiction undergoes further refinement via a weighting mechanism optimizing
information retention and utility for subsequent tasks. We substantiate that
our framework markedly diminishes computational overhead and enhances LLMs'
efficacy across various benchmarks, while upholding or even augmenting the
caliber of the produced content. By amalgamating soft prompt compression with
sophisticated summarization, SoftPromptComp confronts the dual challenges of
managing lengthy contexts and ensuring model scalability. Our findings point
towards a propitious trajectory for augmenting LLMs' applicability and
efficiency, rendering them more versatile and pragmatic for real-world
applications. This research enriches the ongoing discourse on optimizing
language models, providing insights into the potency of soft prompts and
summarization techniques as pivotal instruments for the forthcoming generation
of NLP solutions.
|
[
-0.3608182669,
-0.7445227504,
0.6336296201,
0.274512589,
-0.4190562367,
-0.1062515974,
-0.6540518403,
-0.1260482073,
0.0248021781,
0.3978962302,
-0.6763789058,
-0.4141998589,
-0.4064069986,
0.4690274596,
-0.2316668928,
1.0643372536,
0.0597023629,
-0.3248747885,
-0.3374447525,
-0.2682794631,
-0.6195262074,
-0.4285759926,
-0.4260926843,
-0.1238630041,
0.2234424055,
0.4232356548,
0.7550923824,
0.3529208004,
0.2393440902,
0.4001533091,
-0.3796260357,
0.3043627143,
-0.4321978986,
0.7798982263,
0.0659224242,
-0.0594650805,
-0.3920076191,
-0.2002040893,
0.8489466906,
0.9984211326,
-0.2211984098,
0.0960173011,
0.5980013013,
0.4844655991,
-0.6452891827,
0.1190707684,
-0.5738060474,
-0.0797139853,
0.1224150062,
-0.6200450659,
-0.2995997667,
-0.22837089,
0.1288713217,
-0.4210961163,
0.131352976,
-0.2003584206,
0.2856852412,
0.3520918787,
-0.4112208188,
-0.276270926,
-0.6156904697,
0.6619757414,
-0.7815448046,
0.0713858828,
-0.2437399626,
0.2019446194,
-0.4358702004,
-0.857945621,
-0.3906177282,
-0.0650074407,
0.0211272761,
-0.0247818213,
-0.0987554267,
0.1610506475,
0.2130898684,
0.3341078162,
-0.4473997951,
0.1261208206,
0.057081867,
-0.3376821578,
0.3576588333,
0.4220352471,
0.2321134955,
-0.2745290399,
-0.4178875685,
0.0959052294,
-0.680537641,
0.175897643,
0.063007094,
0.650588572,
-0.1596174389,
0.4659323692,
-0.2592244446,
0.7717422843,
-0.2093004882,
-0.3344736993,
0.0202965271,
-0.4577507079,
-0.1720208079,
0.0104736434,
0.6144068837,
0.4490577877,
0.2566664517,
-0.2567424774,
-0.3484974802,
-0.1287050992,
0.1730428189,
-0.8721359968,
0.2962284088,
0.4180460274,
-0.3301900029,
-0.0844075605,
-0.2607095838,
-0.6322479844,
-0.4163224399,
-0.5262654424,
0.1400749534,
-0.3207135201,
-0.1113295853,
0.1888473481,
-0.0276029799,
-0.0431935266,
0.4640924037,
-0.8148533702,
0.3535119593,
0.9182645679,
1.174118638,
-0.1895970702,
0.0709044933,
-0.6540162563,
0.1531847566,
-0.0854575261,
0.8256931305,
-0.399794966,
-0.4640245736,
0.3076857328,
-0.0351555645,
0.1404937357,
-0.5601865649,
0.7878364325,
-0.3001050353,
0.1478594691,
-0.0483887009,
-0.4764904976,
0.0753930062,
0.3154444695,
-0.6854914427,
0.7916184664,
0.0968692675,
-0.619323194,
0.1293525845,
-0.37357077,
-0.5736341476,
0.3319274187,
0.0317061096,
-0.1079889536,
0.4608388543,
0.1952196658,
0.7430131435,
-0.3533221483,
0.6620418429,
-0.1215648279,
-0.457115382,
0.1681687981,
-0.4456755519,
0.5563337207,
0.1456494927,
-0.14627859,
0.3246569037,
-0.5074618459,
-0.1866989583,
0.0206205137,
-0.513046205,
-0.3368713558,
-0.0508621521,
0.1675095111,
0.1405283809,
0.380628854,
-0.0806980133,
0.3927315772,
-0.5437592864,
0.5365584493,
0.7545679808,
-0.1158481613,
0.7759141922,
-0.1407953948,
0.5726543069,
-0.2336200178,
0.1079877466,
-0.7124873996,
-0.131373316,
-0.4001238644,
-0.3087988496,
0.1392583102,
0.5439354777,
-0.7522693872,
0.4720907211,
-0.4575496018,
-0.1205575094,
-0.1889386475,
0.2464517951,
0.0399619862,
0.8123155236,
0.2670356333,
-0.1414823085,
-0.4334061444,
-0.871909678,
-0.4172099233,
0.1242025793,
-0.3295966685,
0.2006485313,
0.1242537051,
-0.0606684536,
1.1407088041,
-0.4271534085,
-0.3475016654,
-0.8112060428,
0.2590526938,
0.6119484901,
0.4592179358,
0.4604172409,
-0.9079916477,
-0.1613355428,
-0.5952998996,
-0.5480328202,
-0.5648643374,
-0.3367834389,
0.0340846814,
0.1093490198,
0.5046859384,
-0.6637057066,
0.108514607,
0.4524581134,
-0.3318706751,
0.7064338326,
-0.2098746598,
-0.0303350054,
-1.1002346277,
0.0825404674,
-0.0074852048,
-0.43533957,
-0.7121036053,
0.1176105887,
0.0214105174,
-0.1105659604,
-0.6177892089,
0.6521464586,
-0.6038188934,
0.1067504361,
-0.4868693948,
0.2071045339,
0.1256070435,
0.4402121603,
0.1311728656,
0.8261334896,
0.3214987814,
-0.7727674246,
0.116025649,
0.0752219781,
-0.2275068164,
0.4888718128,
-0.648330152,
-0.150287658,
-0.3591504693,
0.614035368,
-0.8424098492,
-0.1699408889,
0.0032441828,
0.0013512396,
0.3420107961,
-0.1842611879,
-0.6574728489,
0.0370447151,
-0.6810769439,
0.4140463471,
0.6022349596,
-0.3651508689,
0.9424259663,
0.2948131263,
-0.5858248472,
-0.3020760119,
-0.4819283187,
0.4639814794,
-0.3844331205,
-0.598515749,
0.6381805539,
-0.2299494296,
-0.3240261078,
-0.2027028054,
-0.1169926673,
0.2402430177,
0.3143849373,
0.2003276944,
0.2215904742,
-0.0814642459,
0.0063578449,
0.2048872411,
-0.2946758866,
-0.0931386948,
-0.2395464778,
0.5445435047,
-0.0023052497,
0.0978562459,
-0.1566864997,
0.579873085,
0.4030051827,
0.2658142149,
0.8008585572,
0.5124183297,
-0.4154568315,
-0.2705836594,
-0.5031261444,
-0.1746485382,
-0.5653064251,
0.1663247496,
-0.1965588331,
-1.1253584623,
0.5525395274,
-0.4504591227,
0.3870074451,
0.1883846372,
0.5725299716,
0.2455761433,
1.0269219875,
0.651941061,
0.0831315145,
0.5598288774,
-0.0334990956,
0.1457377523,
-0.9785215259,
-0.1667892188,
-0.4419691265,
-0.2590104342,
-0.3375664353,
-0.2831838131,
0.6216551661,
0.0544006638,
0.0347940885,
0.1946854442,
-0.3857425749,
0.4439030588,
0.3190337121,
-0.0714537278,
0.2049158514,
-0.1265100837,
0.0037049721,
-0.1932331175,
-0.890007019,
-0.751047194,
0.6386691332,
0.2225773185,
0.5830070972,
0.2166263312,
0.4507834315,
0.3740385771,
0.2965461612,
-0.8527291417,
0.8737964034,
-0.1911387742,
-0.0503092073,
-0.0087234154,
-0.5075613856,
-0.9630374312,
0.3004003167,
-0.2428136319,
-0.6343379021,
-0.0344285779,
0.1745201051,
-0.5618807673,
0.0112035666,
-0.688292563,
0.7050160766,
-0.0222477745,
-0.7227551341,
0.0077366978,
-0.623503089,
0.3927227259,
0.0821039453,
0.3754310608,
-0.2531027794,
-0.4959782362,
0.6074664593,
-0.5011258721,
0.779537499,
-0.1278761178,
-0.3907146156,
0.2970125079,
0.2039523274,
0.4820450246,
0.2478003353,
-0.1133885905,
-0.0575350598,
-0.3008746505,
-0.2332300693,
-0.7026839852,
0.7039359808,
-0.0326008461,
-0.5787109137,
-0.2699211538,
-0.7271553278,
-0.2537724078,
0.1025754884,
0.1597005874,
0.9943832755,
-0.1524359882,
0.0981576517,
0.5870213509,
-0.3875673711,
0.7767642736,
0.4762797654,
0.2463563681,
-0.2776589394,
0.5589556098,
-0.033643771,
0.0425125137,
0.2997049093,
0.2046640366,
-0.4859288335,
-0.7313852906,
-0.2106358856,
0.0438047685,
-0.8135564327,
-0.5416140556,
-0.700517714,
0.1231409535,
-0.6777635217,
-0.4888888001,
-0.0830127597,
-0.4396816194,
-0.4702792466,
0.1926248372,
0.1664377451,
0.4321518242,
0.0808100253,
0.3134111762,
-0.8552543521,
0.3787118196,
0.1066623628,
0.1801914573,
-0.1004112586,
-0.5948194861,
-0.032667838,
-0.2408626825,
-0.0513216518,
-0.9050803185,
0.5801290274,
0.4539559484,
0.3101530373,
0.197381258,
0.3820061982,
0.6135317683,
-0.6237731576,
1.0252722502,
0.0733090937,
-0.9080030918,
0.5695029497,
-0.2912537456,
0.7990249991,
0.7573035359,
0.175481528,
-0.5478278995,
-0.3541638553,
-0.4370801151,
-1.5764424801,
0.483159095,
0.0962113217,
0.4240187109,
-0.0400230587,
0.5404940844,
0.2171375155,
0.2234300375,
-0.4734817445,
0.0929739848,
0.0664808601,
-0.5419017076,
-0.1008553654,
-0.4907514453,
-0.0825256407,
0.0103700738,
0.3938002586,
-0.4864418209,
-0.0233036373,
0.190419659,
-0.4452960789,
0.2863214612,
0.5696524978,
0.6173887849,
0.4696282744,
-0.0204077139,
0.4027400017,
0.2952064872,
-0.4019290507,
0.0940580517,
0.0596769825,
-0.1713168025,
0.0515238643,
0.6497629881,
0.5492938161,
0.7246389985,
-1.0387090445,
0.5529718399,
-0.3032433987,
0.1732051373,
-0.2131006569,
0.1891518235,
-0.138984248,
0.2675449848,
0.6175659299,
-0.1262038946,
0.5475404263,
-0.5319307446,
0.0664511546,
0.5033637881,
0.0860884115,
-0.3445115089,
0.5454059839,
0.4092947841,
-0.2403793335,
0.3829442859,
-0.0907617062,
-0.6052090526,
0.3722760677,
0.5266213417,
0.9479771852,
0.0307505671,
-0.0429076515,
0.2409458756,
0.034111809,
-0.2932787538,
-0.0231680907,
-0.4958193898,
-0.4210680127,
-0.6502879262,
-0.786372304,
-0.4448652864,
0.0350517035,
-0.4634740055,
0.3189471066,
-0.4397301078,
-0.2805249989,
-0.4595642984,
-0.0239974763,
-0.5378252268,
0.0486037657,
0.2752863169,
1.1646009684,
-0.7535113096,
0.2581618428,
0.5752339363,
0.0981691256,
-0.6095122695,
0.004564438,
0.118001014,
-0.4269402325,
0.1950646788,
0.5788242817,
-0.0906798393,
-0.0546855107,
-0.4904485941,
-0.5352844,
0.9644368887,
0.5826243758,
-0.5851194263,
0.1243758723,
-0.073619999,
0.5082077384,
-0.3197717369,
0.2596338391,
0.6692229509,
0.3735088408,
0.136533469,
-0.7120053768,
0.443492204,
-0.3702141941,
0.0057898695,
0.103834115,
-0.3024453223,
0.4194931686,
-0.149941653,
-0.4907419384,
0.1106864586,
0.7901760936,
0.2921049595,
0.2355835289,
0.6016070247,
0.1021803916,
0.4076978564,
-0.1133920178,
1.0812029839,
-0.3467706442,
0.0359832123,
0.9871219993,
-0.3466050923,
0.5778685212,
0.5539188385,
0.0990571827,
0.455463618,
0.5242914557,
0.4558388889,
0.4772748351,
0.016298674,
-0.5231636763,
-0.1509007066,
-0.5379427671,
-0.1498842388,
0.2452117652,
0.3498715162,
-0.0373310745,
-0.3201405108,
0.0835866928,
0.1810684055,
0.2126041204,
-0.2826128006,
0.8822332621,
0.1050158516,
-0.9420824647,
0.4434088171,
0.0670347363,
1.1163882017,
-0.7625405788,
0.0757848918,
-0.2482772768,
-0.0476527773,
-0.0693695322,
-0.7634100914,
0.3898252249,
0.1996315569,
0.0462808348,
-0.7898219228,
0.9756615758,
-0.4035519063,
-0.2566531897,
0.0800544992,
0.3396948874,
-0.0136539238,
-0.159457624,
-0.6043736339,
0.3005127013,
-0.458322078,
-0.5271840096,
0.3198333383,
0.5390071869,
0.0979809761,
0.6313947439,
0.5769536495,
0.2432867885,
-0.3995121121,
0.3893613815,
1.001726985,
-0.6399837136,
-0.7090762258,
-1.0509344339,
0.6346168518,
-0.0367106199,
-0.234212622,
0.5886541605,
0.4400445521,
0.1862313598,
0.2255856991,
0.5925379395,
0.018147815,
0.1276123822,
-0.6898705363,
0.2460252345,
-0.5329310894,
0.5378585458,
-0.3095636666,
-0.9115909934,
-0.4631899595,
0.2642012239,
-0.1358867437,
0.0804501176,
0.3385787904,
0.5447494388,
-0.056385763,
-0.1023064926,
-0.0107385051,
0.0928190425,
0.3085837066,
0.5389277339,
0.5852252841,
0.1126320809,
0.4536427557,
-0.0386137366,
-0.4284567833,
-0.3566930592,
-1.3968967199,
-0.6589672565,
-0.5808836818,
-0.2574327886,
-0.1138517484,
-0.1313324869,
0.9990745187,
0.6387072206,
-0.4720394015,
-0.044438567,
-0.0995132327,
0.0988293588,
-0.0953712687,
-0.299405396,
0.2001218051,
-0.5008857846,
-0.7212691307,
0.5338047743,
0.5736913681,
0.1513810754,
-0.3768365979,
-0.0417266563,
0.1837909073,
0.1615714431,
0.8717247844,
0.1300964206,
-0.4099673629,
0.1204836816,
-0.1383543313,
-0.0292362347,
-0.2053839266,
1.1762584448,
-1.1356158257,
0.0700312257,
0.7103722692,
0.5207220912,
-0.045104336,
0.2284139097,
0.7873097658,
-1.0430819988,
0.4310953617,
0.4206635356,
0.4676655829,
0.6941583157,
-0.4864290953,
0.3939106166,
0.0516885258,
-0.3197479546,
-1.1696504354,
0.2320928872,
-1.1119918823,
-0.6979202628,
1.2508084774,
0.0439671837,
-0.3173156381,
-0.1645472795,
-0.2712695003,
0.2748912275,
-0.4519511461,
0.6274924278,
0.3976174295,
-0.0890659988,
-0.0794481486,
-0.4419002831,
0.4821722806,
0.5665056705,
-0.8133326769,
0.3021042049,
0.6332811713,
0.0809399411,
-0.0457769185,
0.6938489676,
0.1207837015,
0.0224719681,
-0.4069403112,
-0.3693975508,
-0.2644448876,
-0.3150862753,
-0.7492568493,
0.5843034983,
-0.2406346053,
0.324195385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04990v1
|
MLaKE: Multilingual Knowledge Editing Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-07T15:23:28 | 2024-04-07T15:23:28 |
Zihao Wei, Jingcheng Deng, Liang Pang, Hanxing Ding, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The extensive utilization of large language models (LLMs) underscores the
crucial necessity for precise and contemporary knowledge embedded within their
intrinsic parameters. Existing research on knowledge editing primarily
concentrates on monolingual scenarios, neglecting the complexities presented by
multilingual contexts and multi-hop reasoning. To address these challenges, our
study introduces MLaKE (Multilingual Language Knowledge Editing), a novel
benchmark comprising 4072 multi-hop and 5360 single-hop questions designed to
evaluate the adaptability of knowledge editing methods across five languages:
English, Chinese, Japanese, French, and German. MLaKE aggregates fact chains
from Wikipedia across languages and utilizes LLMs to generate questions in both
free-form and multiple-choice. We evaluate the multilingual knowledge editing
generalization capabilities of existing methods on MLaKE. Existing knowledge
editing methods demonstrate higher success rates in English samples compared to
other languages. However, their generalization capabilities are limited in
multi-language experiments. Notably, existing knowledge editing methods often
show relatively high generalization for languages within the same language
family compared to languages from different language families. These results
underscore the imperative need for advancements in multilingual knowledge
editing and we hope MLaKE can serve as a valuable resource for benchmarking and
solution development.
|
[
-0.319758147,
-0.7271421552,
0.5130604506,
0.3879849911,
0.0787704214,
0.1022972837,
-0.4808383584,
-0.5574971437,
0.1499429345,
0.2336839736,
-0.628192842,
-0.7787647843,
-0.4627361596,
0.4756270051,
-0.0980397761,
0.4803293645,
-0.1646816134,
0.2216134369,
-0.2895967662,
-0.4587183893,
-0.6037626266,
-0.3222043812,
-0.6092782617,
-0.2052077204,
0.916282475,
0.5104912519,
0.7947733998,
0.4022978842,
0.3192533255,
0.2531953156,
-0.2857175171,
0.3120503128,
-0.2145340443,
0.158188507,
-0.3695405424,
-0.5368306041,
-0.5559273362,
-0.0775989071,
0.9977104068,
0.957087934,
0.0734774619,
0.2754703164,
-0.1753234863,
0.6871057153,
-0.8367130756,
-0.015910238,
-0.6497219205,
0.1539613008,
-0.281675756,
0.1507402509,
-0.5100798011,
-0.4810829759,
-0.3096953332,
-0.9470158219,
-0.1993021816,
-0.0395644456,
0.6136282086,
0.1403940618,
-0.3922570944,
-0.1743905693,
-0.3805594444,
0.6703820825,
-0.6454718709,
0.8203785419,
0.3748548031,
0.1358129084,
-0.1700151265,
-0.6231888533,
-0.5031491518,
-0.056082543,
-0.0174217056,
0.0434343852,
-0.2982499003,
-0.0611883812,
0.2215632349,
-0.1331675202,
-0.5366886854,
0.2040964365,
-0.1422706991,
-0.2502078116,
0.4582128227,
0.0823353305,
0.3074252605,
-0.2602395415,
-0.2171059847,
-0.0582267568,
-0.652780056,
0.0260470547,
0.5592098832,
0.2829261422,
0.1003465876,
0.7501528263,
-0.4337699413,
0.863111496,
-0.2672148645,
-0.4477754831,
0.1699718386,
-0.3273184597,
-0.0502434634,
0.0381755978,
0.8139432073,
0.535826683,
0.369315654,
-0.2558517754,
0.259919256,
-0.3386835754,
-0.2311562896,
-0.5891327262,
-0.0769905373,
0.0541108996,
-0.2545080781,
-0.0873177648,
-0.0387594365,
-0.9576207399,
-0.5191378593,
-0.2295995653,
0.2739156783,
-0.5255946517,
-0.3950490355,
0.3385121226,
-0.0923715085,
0.0168360379,
0.5796986818,
-0.3856765926,
-0.1278418154,
0.4926827252,
0.8547561765,
-0.1849802881,
-1.023837924,
-0.3597820997,
0.3348074853,
-0.6211102009,
0.8546006083,
-0.6732061505,
-0.4682326317,
0.0049968036,
-0.165248692,
-0.136049062,
-0.5451675653,
0.4474847317,
-0.6352357864,
-0.0718743205,
-0.5521554351,
-0.6333773732,
-0.1243308485,
0.3795719445,
-0.6398421526,
1.1394795179,
-0.1459949166,
-0.9543754458,
0.4986236989,
-0.6605015993,
-0.5549378395,
-0.1806057245,
0.2519220114,
-0.2074695379,
-0.0627920553,
0.2500298023,
0.4053297043,
-0.1032754257,
0.2465081811,
-0.4476438165,
-0.0500631146,
0.2544167936,
-0.2134094387,
0.8476395011,
0.1907112598,
0.0428701043,
0.1468554884,
-0.9314221144,
0.0764880106,
0.1015809923,
-0.7079873085,
-0.4973441958,
-0.2996137738,
0.0578728132,
0.2522046268,
0.3180756867,
-0.5223708153,
0.5489811301,
0.1704284102,
-0.1931454241,
0.7690899372,
0.0935217813,
0.2172024846,
-0.0682383627,
0.5469325781,
-0.0257991385,
0.1595429629,
-0.0500062741,
-0.6792553067,
-0.739143312,
-0.2675817311,
0.7102928758,
0.6077566147,
-0.6489328146,
0.1102882996,
-0.3474612832,
-0.523604095,
-0.6778778434,
0.5347669125,
0.0484305024,
0.312063098,
0.2852801979,
0.0411827527,
-0.5722195506,
-0.9956506491,
-0.6816738844,
-0.1195260361,
0.1148117483,
-0.1109021455,
0.266688019,
-0.3616762459,
0.9099778533,
-0.2957737148,
0.0472667404,
-0.2951561213,
0.2448685467,
0.095262751,
0.1762472838,
0.4734281898,
-0.5555303693,
-0.7236760855,
0.2611351013,
-0.9467797875,
-0.1484660208,
-0.1372147799,
-0.2448942214,
0.1693381071,
0.5933952332,
-0.8094041944,
0.155457437,
0.5990439653,
-0.1749750376,
0.8164676428,
-0.1859591305,
0.505879879,
-1.1255100965,
0.2531600595,
-0.3809229136,
-0.1592819542,
-0.5485088825,
0.3193886876,
0.510050714,
-0.0142222513,
-0.3315588236,
0.6543362141,
-0.3687086105,
0.0741451457,
-0.0812314972,
0.1452552974,
-0.0493151285,
0.2668381631,
-0.0410400443,
0.8924244642,
0.3285307586,
-0.474291116,
0.4756687284,
0.2364205122,
-0.7332903743,
0.6429313421,
-0.2744036615,
0.2364160717,
-0.095472455,
-0.0683146492,
-0.8012652397,
-0.197563231,
-0.0412844568,
-0.408282131,
0.1171991527,
-0.2352336496,
-0.9641813636,
0.0468353219,
-0.2306518704,
0.206234768,
-0.0643701851,
-0.5003557801,
0.5647028089,
0.0941904485,
-0.366042763,
-0.9645979404,
-0.6361507773,
0.4600518942,
-0.1629521549,
-0.8124332428,
-0.0559721142,
-0.383305043,
-0.3440561891,
-0.015844794,
0.0223777462,
-0.155407548,
-0.0139292497,
-0.3082885444,
0.1529579759,
-0.2329894155,
0.2663032711,
0.2845284641,
-0.1236848831,
-0.0971304029,
0.0478884391,
0.4138178229,
0.0932518169,
-0.2776573002,
-0.1922916919,
0.4538230598,
0.7264312506,
-0.4937790334,
0.8039612174,
0.7011965513,
-0.3286289275,
-0.0884858146,
-0.7639739513,
0.2963051498,
-0.3896217346,
0.5193400383,
-0.7686174512,
-0.8616142273,
0.5702551603,
-0.4418302774,
0.1080586016,
0.5036152005,
0.4329749942,
0.0639309287,
0.6004449725,
0.4547099769,
-0.2483659238,
0.0721552819,
0.0806069374,
0.0784565732,
-0.5412312746,
-0.0629103631,
-0.5304630995,
-0.345577538,
-0.4811072946,
-0.5474629402,
0.5272067785,
0.419577688,
0.0744611174,
0.4439766705,
0.0511079319,
0.6732020378,
0.5332885981,
-0.1720440835,
0.7842679024,
-0.2342282087,
-0.6445324421,
-0.1035322398,
-0.8623594046,
-0.219768554,
1.3309197426,
0.1070013195,
0.6530069113,
0.2831471562,
0.4640395641,
0.1830934286,
0.1033705622,
-0.5032249689,
0.5354843736,
0.0206608623,
-0.8515387774,
-0.3445261717,
-0.4376744032,
-0.7452075481,
0.2498185039,
-0.2444934398,
-0.5648287535,
0.1477559805,
0.0964819863,
-0.0883427858,
0.6875526905,
-0.8853162527,
0.988517642,
-0.0804316029,
-0.5255684853,
-0.3462477922,
-0.4902552366,
0.3560766578,
-0.2175623924,
0.6331877112,
-0.2586764693,
-0.1102462038,
0.5007315278,
0.0502406284,
0.6078757644,
-0.1661015749,
-0.0801992118,
0.131783098,
0.3660834432,
0.5823304653,
0.3695159256,
-0.2330443263,
0.3918002546,
0.0741983727,
-0.3317168653,
-0.4623315334,
0.7466250658,
-0.7044976354,
-0.3328430057,
-0.2836185992,
-0.7634279728,
-0.6432939172,
0.3336645365,
0.155087024,
0.0395910107,
-0.2478128821,
0.0622310005,
0.5417237282,
-0.5106520653,
0.2252967209,
0.6142349839,
-0.6490265727,
-0.4590240121,
0.6466968656,
0.1940462887,
0.2698338628,
0.6030394435,
0.3267495036,
-0.0098377066,
-0.4538524747,
-0.5176146626,
0.1087905914,
-1.1244220734,
-0.2350790352,
-0.8294377923,
0.0232379083,
-0.2876119018,
-0.0815093294,
-0.6172588468,
-0.5607876778,
0.3238421679,
-0.0416804105,
0.3023825884,
0.8493717909,
-0.3523747921,
-0.0819404945,
-0.5382574201,
0.4373029172,
0.4490732551,
0.6617691517,
-0.0705280676,
-0.1819092035,
-0.4522862136,
-0.2185217887,
-0.050476104,
-0.7782204151,
-0.2736752629,
0.1525102705,
0.6455655098,
0.1176411957,
-0.0500519685,
0.803614676,
-0.653087914,
0.5062101483,
0.1693096012,
-0.8206728101,
0.4851472676,
-0.3571528196,
0.6739800572,
0.6712160707,
0.5487077236,
-1.1195830107,
-0.2565007508,
-0.1305446923,
-0.547696352,
0.4442248046,
-0.0193496682,
-0.1160329506,
0.1616993248,
0.2206168771,
0.4832146764,
0.1545151323,
-0.6636253595,
-0.2984548807,
-0.0078556584,
0.0266741347,
-0.1120934635,
-0.2886400521,
0.1213363484,
-0.5831913352,
0.7471233606,
0.0476871766,
0.0812834203,
0.1594099104,
-0.426315695,
-0.1645123661,
0.6194995046,
0.6338128448,
0.9331231117,
-0.1681304425,
0.0547256693,
0.5386550426,
-0.3367409408,
0.0534885563,
0.0644189268,
-0.2527720928,
0.2279373109,
0.5743751526,
0.5122551918,
0.3488993943,
-0.5859225988,
0.1417556405,
-0.067465283,
-0.2264979482,
-0.0870413035,
-0.0550371185,
0.5531733632,
0.0939082056,
0.127570495,
0.2880273461,
-0.0484172553,
-0.3098934591,
-0.0299431123,
0.1699189842,
0.1340404451,
-0.1601104289,
0.5488214493,
0.0008198144,
-0.1194523647,
0.3411538005,
-0.13255997,
-0.1950008869,
-0.1132779792,
0.1998006254,
0.5957278609,
-0.3800331354,
0.0316167846,
0.783611834,
0.6673604846,
0.1961405426,
-0.0163242482,
0.1576271206,
-0.8811697364,
-0.6817128658,
-0.6356985569,
-0.6462442279,
0.2962755263,
-0.446180582,
0.4464889765,
-0.4027147889,
-0.1217686012,
0.2437607646,
-0.1714629531,
-0.7515351772,
-0.1245265454,
-0.0852591395,
1.3049645424,
-0.658706069,
0.9827847481,
0.9519312382,
-0.1218566224,
-0.3634827137,
-0.1171953827,
0.1260701269,
-0.6510785222,
0.3486366868,
-0.022417808,
-0.1726132929,
-0.2105377167,
-0.3802538812,
-0.8550431728,
0.8029934764,
0.745057404,
-0.5043879151,
-0.0794766769,
0.4413101375,
0.1494750232,
0.0020128684,
-0.1330623478,
0.5864459872,
0.9638142586,
-0.203281045,
-0.9705865979,
-0.5120154023,
-0.3470489979,
-0.1113092452,
0.0515598767,
-0.6544294953,
0.5717242956,
-0.0520071313,
0.1796639264,
0.1115409583,
0.39413324,
-0.0000909606,
0.0347662568,
0.4264641106,
0.6997308731,
0.7410005331,
-0.0259200037,
0.8371066451,
-0.3603813052,
0.3280980885,
1.2065873146,
-0.344660908,
0.8549275398,
0.5780159831,
-0.4905000329,
0.4552963674,
0.4330728948,
0.2319572568,
0.199436307,
-0.0834980756,
-0.4185664654,
-0.4966911674,
0.0987237096,
-0.282638371,
0.6576535702,
0.040650636,
0.130527392,
-0.2688858807,
0.2086772919,
0.5560905337,
0.1893392652,
-0.1854381561,
0.714625895,
-0.2863813937,
-0.6580363512,
0.2846272886,
0.3886452019,
0.7030547261,
-1.0725796223,
0.1448435485,
-0.2569160461,
0.2063666135,
-0.0444714688,
-0.8021516204,
0.2610816658,
0.2471299618,
-0.2569575906,
-0.1320376694,
0.6687666178,
-0.4176371396,
-0.9300506115,
0.620898664,
0.6771532297,
-0.087645404,
-0.1765437722,
-0.6366728544,
0.2851396203,
-0.0779551864,
-0.3595385253,
0.3445406258,
0.4545438886,
0.2291687578,
0.6150861382,
0.5444886088,
0.1869117022,
0.3994566202,
0.0481303148,
0.5461405516,
-0.5851925611,
-0.3269980252,
-0.5699368715,
0.6506740451,
-0.1426734775,
-0.4597463906,
0.9318381548,
0.9177827835,
1.3091454506,
-0.3050089777,
1.0466506481,
-0.1389395297,
0.639918685,
-0.7047179937,
0.9765184522,
-0.6904928088,
-0.1790624559,
-0.4879481196,
-1.0452677011,
-0.4564347565,
0.4643679559,
-0.2108854651,
0.0793723911,
0.8346552253,
0.6773658991,
-0.1729328185,
-0.0012744487,
0.6456566453,
0.2838574052,
-0.0484935679,
0.3353583813,
0.6407330036,
-0.3784425557,
0.5483077765,
-0.5935428143,
-0.1002683938,
0.1538091749,
-0.8476347327,
-1.0289121866,
-0.582775414,
-0.2685023546,
0.10239283,
0.1526800543,
1.0192396641,
0.506962657,
-0.9016136527,
-0.4476548731,
0.3155102432,
0.1997500062,
-0.3432457447,
-0.1521569937,
0.2942375541,
-0.5653835535,
-0.7081874013,
0.6960527897,
0.4330028594,
-0.384095341,
-0.0291976165,
-0.1783354878,
-0.8097292185,
-0.1491692811,
0.7852560282,
0.1077642664,
-0.5915124416,
-0.289024055,
0.1306028068,
0.1925607622,
0.2137826532,
0.8719619513,
-0.1701700985,
0.9143176079,
0.1561706066,
0.7468419075,
0.3383872211,
-0.43575418,
0.3857193291,
-0.8971773982,
0.213145569,
-0.1721318811,
0.5616984367,
0.4809693396,
-0.0092928298,
0.4515374303,
0.4228321016,
-0.3718549013,
-0.5138411522,
0.1272059679,
-0.7152661681,
-0.402513653,
1.1688956022,
-0.1760818362,
0.1568836868,
-0.1093396991,
-0.2760537863,
0.2278224379,
-0.0409290157,
0.4164288342,
1.3249013424,
0.0873964503,
-0.4073915184,
-0.8211767673,
0.108241193,
0.3404322267,
-0.8185461164,
0.364477545,
0.4412677586,
0.4241111577,
-0.0276523549,
0.3328895271,
-0.0713478401,
0.5628220439,
0.0886956975,
0.4212663472,
-0.2516537309,
-0.4409683645,
-0.1119591221,
0.2709774375,
0.4372951388,
0.2661768794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04963v1
|
SemEval-2024 Task 2: Safe Biomedical Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials
| 2024-04-07T13:58:41 | 2024-04-07T13:58:41 |
Mael Jullien, Marco Valentino, André Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are at the forefront of NLP achievements but
fall short in dealing with shortcut learning, factual inconsistency, and
vulnerability to adversarial inputs.These shortcomings are especially critical
in medical contexts, where they can misrepresent actual model capabilities.
Addressing this, we present SemEval-2024 Task 2: Safe Biomedical Natural
Language Inference for ClinicalTrials. Our contributions include the refined
NLI4CT-P dataset (i.e., Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials -
Perturbed), designed to challenge LLMs with interventional and causal reasoning
tasks, along with a comprehensive evaluation of methods and results for
participant submissions. A total of 106 participants registered for the task
contributing to over 1200 individual submissions and 25 system overview papers.
This initiative aims to advance the robustness and applicability of NLI models
in healthcare, ensuring safer and more dependable AI assistance in clinical
decision-making. We anticipate that the dataset, models, and outcomes of this
task can support future research in the field of biomedical NLI. The dataset,
competition leaderboard, and website are publicly available.
|
[
0.2450669557,
-0.7393293381,
0.7809233665,
0.4506555796,
-0.1236732677,
-0.2158470899,
-0.0938500687,
-0.4993900061,
-0.180841431,
0.761074841,
-0.4405755103,
-0.5385977626,
-0.7471697927,
0.3297699392,
-0.090267092,
0.9551666975,
-0.0642860457,
0.1908759028,
-0.4442824423,
-0.1450452507,
-0.5012350082,
-0.5788940787,
-0.7980371714,
-0.2204193473,
0.777592361,
0.2141060084,
0.4033646286,
0.470295012,
0.7301234007,
0.2066208869,
-0.0052173138,
0.0181576442,
-0.3047100306,
0.28518489,
-0.3159748912,
-0.417943418,
-0.6118662953,
0.112417601,
0.2095380872,
0.8177888989,
-0.1686678529,
-0.208882153,
0.1674192548,
0.2466423213,
-0.4620048404,
-0.0205299538,
-0.5712217689,
-0.0075875386,
-0.1867274046,
-0.3571219444,
-0.5692073703,
-0.4672964215,
0.1864868999,
-0.4553467929,
0.0831976607,
0.0948410481,
0.6047591567,
0.4823415279,
-0.7743147612,
-0.4029487371,
-0.3658470213,
0.8886393309,
-1.1477614641,
0.074787803,
0.7894459367,
0.2491058856,
-0.3332523406,
-0.9447647333,
-0.1086768284,
-0.191799894,
0.0460738316,
0.1822646707,
-0.1673808396,
0.3208788335,
0.2364415079,
-0.2001217902,
-0.6079344153,
0.3209008873,
-0.262540102,
-0.217904523,
0.6868706942,
0.2442964762,
0.2641840875,
-0.0982444808,
-0.2141940594,
0.1883174926,
-0.968731761,
-0.3182744086,
-0.0903388262,
0.3210354149,
-0.0405259617,
0.685089767,
-0.0303849783,
0.2015292943,
-0.3889841735,
-0.015614951,
0.4912961423,
-0.7504120469,
-0.2944020331,
0.1186618209,
0.8924815059,
0.5717934966,
-0.1514452994,
-0.2637716234,
0.0525099263,
0.232107833,
0.3711440563,
-0.7240676284,
-0.0806689337,
0.4604177773,
-0.3417141438,
-0.5033466816,
-0.4396656156,
-0.8641461134,
-0.5427562594,
-0.1801208705,
0.5677583218,
-0.3678524792,
0.1143318415,
0.1375509202,
-0.0251838323,
0.0519048683,
0.4672763646,
-0.5292055607,
0.3107323349,
0.72802037,
0.509942472,
-0.1179286242,
-0.2095435411,
-0.6513162851,
0.2201074362,
-0.164649725,
0.6426708102,
-0.3654564917,
-0.4054745436,
-0.0535445586,
0.3143981099,
-0.2905216217,
-0.4431320429,
0.9924870133,
-0.1777591705,
0.2489054352,
-0.335421294,
-0.6931895614,
-0.0514621288,
0.0965322703,
-0.4594256282,
0.6616227627,
-0.3008701503,
-0.8437266946,
0.2320936024,
-0.5563958883,
-0.6875486374,
0.1317668259,
-0.1362400055,
-0.6185865402,
0.0235592872,
0.1033104062,
0.436063081,
-0.5347878337,
0.6354273558,
-0.6944670081,
-0.0084683606,
0.1079481095,
-0.4433918297,
0.7412303686,
0.2490503043,
-0.6501936913,
-0.0232598335,
-0.6370635033,
-0.1076285318,
0.2029247284,
-0.1756828576,
-0.2941824496,
-0.0228423961,
-0.0334147923,
0.1155461818,
0.1599965394,
-0.6469542384,
-0.2721656561,
-0.6683330536,
0.6013353467,
0.6086385846,
0.3099202216,
0.3436250985,
-0.1585510969,
0.4773572385,
-0.3195130229,
0.2672296464,
0.1630860418,
-0.7421122789,
-0.3862659335,
-0.074234046,
0.5037050247,
0.7021420598,
-0.727784574,
0.3893117309,
-0.023344744,
-0.2665688694,
-0.1973675191,
-0.1834840178,
0.4184678793,
0.6638552547,
0.37900576,
0.2166777551,
-0.6923012733,
-1.0367875099,
-0.3006952405,
-0.0538460575,
-0.2141372114,
0.4198103547,
0.7457074523,
-0.6365913749,
0.5134982467,
-0.157384783,
-0.1823381037,
-0.2520207465,
0.4737013578,
0.1946775168,
0.6556333899,
0.3115864098,
-0.5334523916,
0.1162299067,
-0.1795128584,
-0.9047703147,
-0.5343806148,
-0.0890790299,
-0.2370622307,
0.1041105241,
0.6314225197,
-0.2610118985,
0.6499907374,
0.4793075025,
-0.4341864884,
0.1231327578,
-0.3235376775,
0.1665240377,
-1.0364040136,
0.2163417339,
-0.0938315317,
-0.2024780065,
-0.7844442129,
-0.1058507264,
-0.0208916292,
0.2286731303,
-0.2518494427,
0.504165113,
0.0138744116,
0.2432758212,
-0.2643577456,
-0.1250832528,
0.0325858183,
0.1528435946,
0.044050552,
0.6132769585,
0.2398800403,
-0.4795128107,
-0.1128991917,
0.4966406524,
-0.0990194529,
0.1736344397,
-1.1003386974,
0.1096476614,
0.0223163087,
0.2943615913,
-0.5545923114,
-0.4669116437,
0.1209081411,
-0.4743385315,
0.1443307698,
0.0308126975,
-0.4994113147,
-0.3163098693,
-0.1239910647,
0.3450191021,
0.3518847525,
-0.1756683588,
0.3515286744,
0.7284476757,
-0.4928028584,
-0.4459710121,
-0.9558927417,
0.3583163619,
-0.1736253351,
-0.4862662554,
0.2633402944,
0.01542255,
-0.1174333766,
-0.1056956723,
0.1815900952,
-0.1097930968,
0.1912483424,
0.454526335,
0.329772532,
0.0568546355,
0.1272374094,
0.2292329967,
-0.1501116306,
0.3143616617,
0.1822541356,
0.0156515483,
-0.0650799796,
-0.4973139763,
-0.4212707281,
0.4851537347,
0.3714151382,
-0.1624842882,
0.5080540776,
0.4529147744,
-0.7768226862,
0.1046044752,
-0.4694265723,
-0.2811493278,
-0.3969467878,
0.3945926428,
0.0357522666,
-1.155611515,
0.0390327238,
-0.2355547547,
0.1973215789,
0.383233726,
0.7608895898,
-0.154957518,
1.3167545795,
0.0973307043,
0.2819648683,
-0.2139758915,
-0.062450055,
0.3420059085,
-0.7381646037,
-0.4196568429,
-0.6610692143,
-0.1198375821,
-0.4057908952,
-0.7168045044,
0.6058105826,
-0.1741797179,
-0.4185813069,
0.1753550619,
-0.2505892813,
0.0126818558,
0.6011299491,
0.2622021735,
0.0360517018,
-0.1509944052,
-0.288549155,
-0.2231707573,
-0.6048970222,
-0.5373414755,
1.2005842924,
0.469476074,
0.6497321725,
0.1870371699,
0.7297390699,
0.2090306878,
0.1060586274,
-0.4146634936,
0.4380077422,
-0.0648027211,
-0.7527906895,
-0.206294179,
-0.4618252814,
-0.9769227505,
-0.0675917044,
-0.2732935548,
-0.6053012013,
0.1494108438,
-0.0658859164,
-0.5655463338,
-0.1582178473,
-0.5396014452,
0.9384401441,
-0.3876573741,
-0.5342856646,
-0.0885890946,
-1.0493736267,
0.2850814462,
-0.1421717554,
0.3394929469,
-0.3790623844,
-0.1541432589,
0.6972480416,
-0.5736203194,
0.9029532671,
-0.206840679,
0.1933713704,
0.2056376934,
-0.2071840167,
0.629979074,
0.3422463834,
-0.2150487751,
0.0622115545,
0.2338523716,
-0.3766005635,
-0.341191709,
0.6232659221,
-0.5248466134,
-0.3908412158,
-0.5037286878,
-0.2113675922,
-0.5220085382,
0.193649739,
0.3182015121,
0.5963475108,
-0.2346293926,
0.3784683943,
0.5262346268,
-0.6145595908,
0.1913284361,
0.3134061694,
0.2765805125,
-0.5598139167,
0.6531400681,
-0.3515494168,
0.1160580143,
0.2038657516,
0.2267811596,
-0.7016518116,
-1.0363166332,
0.0364359878,
0.3496892452,
-0.60002321,
-0.2611989677,
-0.883271575,
-0.1806620359,
-0.6404542923,
-0.0895383358,
-0.3510918021,
-0.3093395233,
-0.4770979285,
-0.1591730118,
0.0886183605,
0.7044115663,
-0.1708820909,
-0.0350060761,
-0.912774384,
0.126162678,
0.218474552,
0.0440903828,
-0.4832158685,
-0.5683783293,
0.1054311767,
-0.0209876839,
0.0871039107,
-0.6936738491,
0.5689134002,
0.2128821462,
0.582034409,
0.2726964653,
0.1521635056,
0.4863184094,
-0.7910291553,
0.5911011696,
0.2194951177,
-0.5465500355,
0.8836727142,
-0.5013771653,
0.2020172775,
1.0542052984,
0.2659359276,
-0.3369220793,
-0.4745705426,
-0.5488439202,
-0.8289530873,
0.4818415046,
0.5855626464,
-0.2281909287,
-0.1804324687,
0.2652543783,
0.0423730202,
0.1737814993,
-0.4356888831,
0.0935206637,
0.2065241188,
-0.4646544158,
0.0788226798,
-0.5054786205,
-0.437476784,
-0.2669525146,
0.8421599865,
-0.2463319153,
0.3799918592,
0.3229821324,
0.0291539337,
0.0639237165,
0.3608187139,
0.5842568874,
0.5028722286,
-0.2063406557,
0.2639607787,
0.4861738384,
-0.3686031997,
-0.0000174451,
0.3716189563,
-0.0199183784,
-0.246335119,
0.6096007228,
0.690759778,
0.4668231606,
-0.9875384569,
0.7028855085,
-0.3628374636,
-0.4378173053,
-0.4319100678,
-0.1987068951,
0.1330872327,
0.2546998262,
-0.0688698143,
0.2781949639,
0.5157954097,
-0.1365297139,
0.4073786736,
0.3058606684,
-0.5136302114,
-0.3832726777,
1.0050650835,
0.3459149897,
0.0363017768,
0.2694261372,
-0.1281791925,
-0.3499328494,
0.667008698,
0.5107671022,
0.6708261967,
0.0045183469,
0.0824211836,
0.5240516067,
0.3426667452,
-0.0894521996,
0.3127926886,
0.5687693954,
-0.5297875404,
-0.4212612808,
-0.4917230904,
-0.4660974741,
0.3657963574,
-0.3632618785,
0.3373831511,
-0.4217888117,
-0.2649611235,
0.0661421642,
-0.1358940154,
-0.3547547758,
0.2167294472,
0.3232658803,
0.7826359868,
-0.6696703434,
0.7496938705,
0.5865623951,
0.0360100977,
-0.7013879418,
-0.4815581441,
0.4766389132,
-0.4828471243,
0.4510286152,
0.1350970864,
0.0113361189,
-0.2451820523,
-0.6646305323,
-0.6943067312,
1.1133532524,
0.2516203821,
-0.5291139483,
-0.2758321762,
0.2791236937,
0.4581114352,
-0.1961452812,
0.2267101705,
0.6531865597,
0.4783282876,
0.2889238596,
-0.7851937413,
0.1635895818,
-0.2743547261,
-0.1488975883,
-0.0891485065,
-0.1877028346,
0.4001312554,
-0.2366865873,
-0.0053395922,
0.4967625439,
0.5011251569,
0.5839913487,
0.680608809,
0.3945542872,
0.7148320675,
0.8344936967,
-0.1679167002,
1.035141468,
-0.0858011022,
0.168315351,
1.1483552456,
-0.621393621,
0.7538974881,
0.4406723082,
-0.2622154057,
-0.053417936,
0.5345544219,
0.085638769,
0.5682667494,
-0.1165909618,
-0.4475034177,
-0.4032992721,
-0.3048064113,
-0.388495028,
0.5037971139,
0.6043925285,
-0.4666842222,
-0.1360000968,
0.1034440473,
0.2163973451,
-0.1636402905,
0.2268526554,
0.7368938327,
0.2409875393,
-0.6918497682,
0.2615820169,
-0.0544882752,
0.4192146361,
-0.5754851699,
-0.1536562592,
0.068143487,
0.245706737,
0.020395143,
-0.4726713896,
0.4263854325,
0.030461764,
0.3058946729,
-0.1095898598,
0.9173972607,
-0.3133504391,
-0.5500573516,
0.2574447095,
0.28698349,
0.0750404894,
-0.0250933077,
-0.8217831254,
-0.0586845279,
0.0910865963,
-0.1296086013,
0.2644776702,
0.325990051,
-0.0145405,
0.5106027722,
0.5250140429,
0.1300487965,
-0.0694667175,
0.2019667476,
0.5831844807,
-0.5924144387,
-0.223550275,
-0.6742818356,
0.196133852,
-0.1965613067,
-0.2941327393,
0.6407015324,
0.4851004779,
-0.0250527747,
0.1804918051,
0.8161764741,
0.1139550284,
0.8284546733,
-0.5296306014,
0.7355130911,
-0.5797787905,
0.1287002414,
-0.1035013124,
-0.2289395481,
-0.6074489951,
0.3569579422,
-0.3673329353,
-0.1478227526,
0.8741226196,
0.7519840002,
0.4048970342,
0.5261854529,
0.1812810153,
0.3789209425,
0.5104214549,
0.7432591915,
0.7271495461,
-0.5247501731,
0.3588340878,
-0.3460335732,
-0.3527434766,
-0.2280501425,
-1.0240018368,
-0.8957890868,
-0.2597458661,
-0.3368648589,
-0.389188081,
0.2664975524,
1.0480890274,
0.4734691679,
-1.1361418962,
0.2043870538,
-0.4371874928,
-0.086756207,
0.1797970682,
-0.1403136402,
0.2984885573,
-0.3446652591,
-0.7162690163,
0.6990652084,
0.5120059252,
-0.0730667338,
0.3184248507,
-0.0883517042,
-0.4560688138,
0.0180094261,
0.5721236467,
0.2170500457,
-0.7205290794,
-0.2407564819,
0.0572852306,
-0.3583228588,
-0.2452031374,
0.6920333505,
-0.6277071834,
0.3430299461,
0.4973411858,
1.0607568026,
0.2552668452,
-0.1974084377,
0.8143928647,
-0.335968852,
0.0461120941,
0.6583834887,
0.4973595738,
0.1401860714,
-0.2918614447,
0.8482960463,
0.4140997231,
-0.9029405713,
-0.8273723722,
-0.0577044897,
-0.9424978495,
-0.2541693747,
1.3739414215,
-0.0262463745,
-0.3493691087,
-0.447859019,
-0.1505273134,
0.2785643339,
-0.1906226426,
0.3041562736,
0.3071158528,
-0.1208293289,
-0.0238287523,
-1.0401939154,
0.7035169005,
0.7394902706,
-1.1165275574,
-0.1747811735,
0.5049157143,
0.0258373208,
-0.2262695134,
0.7402558327,
-0.324061811,
0.3087269664,
-0.1967789382,
-0.1214024276,
0.2677583098,
-0.2338171899,
-0.3799450994,
-0.0617872551,
-0.0217468329,
0.0756620616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04959v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04959v1
|
A Two Dimensional Feature Engineering Method for Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-07T13:37:30 | 2024-04-07T13:37:30 |
Hao Wang, Yanping Chen, Weizhe Yang, Yongbin Qin, Ruizhang Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transforming a sentence into a two-dimensional (2D) representation (e.g., the
table filling) has the ability to unfold a semantic plane, where an element of
the plane is a word-pair representation of a sentence which may denote a
possible relation representation composed of two named entities. The 2D
representation is effective in resolving overlapped relation instances.
However, in related works, the representation is directly transformed from a
raw input. It is weak to utilize prior knowledge, which is important to support
the relation extraction task. In this paper, we propose a two-dimensional
feature engineering method in the 2D sentence representation for relation
extraction. Our proposed method is evaluated on three public datasets (ACE05
Chinese, ACE05 English, and SanWen) and achieves the state-of-the-art
performance. The results indicate that two-dimensional feature engineering can
take advantage of a two-dimensional sentence representation and make full use
of prior knowledge in traditional feature engineering. Our code is publicly
available at
https://github.com/Wang-ck123/A-Two-Dimensional-Feature-Engineering-Method-for-Entity-Relation-Extraction
|
[
-0.305829227,
-0.7577149272,
0.6840482354,
0.4141085148,
-0.1450063735,
-0.3888180554,
0.0106235649,
-0.7036736012,
0.1824074239,
0.7786982656,
-0.1821704954,
-0.1701405495,
-0.5126024485,
-0.4208471477,
0.0485632308,
0.7783666253,
-0.3206143081,
-0.0331300423,
-0.514723599,
-0.0032034016,
-0.5425965786,
-0.397767514,
-0.014732182,
-0.1658444256,
0.2814333439,
0.3861433268,
0.7346484661,
0.8755915165,
0.6820574403,
0.1557358652,
-0.1634192616,
0.3699028492,
-0.3950903416,
-0.0643214136,
-0.1020494923,
-0.3679052293,
-0.6107537746,
0.518556118,
0.2512152791,
0.8976677656,
0.3423545659,
0.1217541918,
-0.0151536381,
0.5982072949,
-0.5003077984,
0.7141335607,
-0.548027873,
0.1564684063,
-0.4116331041,
0.0172872879,
-0.0265319198,
-0.3387589157,
0.227927044,
-0.6199859977,
-0.1548436135,
-0.0145553751,
1.2718118429,
0.0158080738,
-0.4605192244,
-0.2309762985,
-0.7267765999,
0.3333334029,
-0.309841603,
0.4873017073,
0.4940097034,
0.2597605884,
-0.1885194778,
-0.8305966258,
-0.6753477454,
-0.1762301922,
-0.735737443,
0.0101769092,
0.3000988662,
-0.2599464953,
0.2385166585,
0.2997121513,
-0.5686453581,
0.2545795143,
-0.4430004954,
-0.0520669818,
0.8737701774,
-0.2083803117,
0.5148975849,
-0.5410060287,
-0.9174288511,
-0.0944516137,
-0.5442348123,
0.122957699,
0.1132777333,
0.046867393,
-0.0607743524,
0.6124340296,
0.2212007791,
0.0418840423,
-0.4162810445,
0.0991999581,
0.3159562945,
-0.2167708129,
0.0559365489,
-0.184781298,
1.002746582,
0.3633585274,
0.2879814506,
-0.1909584254,
-0.031137595,
0.1443242878,
0.125186637,
-0.8089972734,
-0.5996388793,
0.2086483836,
-0.5316795111,
-0.1614022553,
0.3069760203,
-1.0871186256,
-0.4973348677,
-0.0357731171,
0.1022322774,
-0.5302733779,
-0.7428846359,
-0.3731538355,
-0.2135161012,
0.0539473593,
-0.1962034553,
-1.0080827475,
0.0599229895,
0.9068338275,
0.76849401,
0.0786929503,
-0.2380120903,
-0.4669193625,
0.2450317591,
-0.3835916221,
0.867898345,
-0.3941072226,
-0.2385981977,
0.0773957744,
-0.7677903771,
0.2748509645,
-0.5028278828,
0.3676976562,
-0.5911346674,
0.3513311148,
-0.1849912405,
-0.482648164,
-0.1989263296,
-0.047736641,
-0.8410276175,
0.9822633266,
0.4810545146,
-0.7123128772,
0.1003040671,
-0.4839585721,
-0.4081436992,
0.0183395743,
-0.6868584156,
-0.6033016443,
-0.2032864243,
0.5190389156,
0.3191159964,
-0.0536161102,
-0.1115648374,
-0.5443266034,
-0.1648998111,
-0.0510886274,
0.3821384609,
1.0440410376,
0.220805198,
0.0995782465,
-0.4407597482,
-0.6382390261,
0.000107807,
0.1706351191,
-0.0110912211,
-0.475569576,
-0.0887483507,
0.0537974313,
0.5611894727,
0.5262522697,
-0.5523213148,
0.283275485,
-0.9342916012,
0.4490922987,
0.0345620327,
0.3316729963,
0.7601937056,
0.2844420671,
0.0533903316,
0.3348319829,
-0.2916354537,
-0.1278070658,
-0.4892066121,
-0.367942661,
-0.0716968104,
0.5209685564,
0.8261421919,
-0.7952687144,
0.6574999094,
-0.4094852805,
-0.143805787,
-0.3044672012,
0.3352155387,
0.3919640779,
0.1184718013,
0.5470322371,
0.0637115836,
-0.7430848479,
-0.9449751377,
-0.2191108912,
-0.3902428746,
-0.3368348479,
0.1302577406,
0.1939873248,
0.1426722705,
1.268261075,
-0.8962709308,
-0.7214275002,
-0.2900736332,
0.1878290623,
-0.144912973,
0.43046543,
0.7883225679,
-0.8538278341,
-0.295111686,
0.2807821333,
-1.2305705547,
0.2060258538,
-0.1505240947,
-0.3361387551,
0.094549045,
0.4810626209,
-0.8462657928,
0.540628612,
0.2033226341,
-0.1230220646,
-0.0021253598,
-0.2803406119,
-0.2390280217,
-1.1411570311,
-0.1149391234,
0.1220446005,
0.1460198909,
-0.5974488258,
0.2762832344,
0.390514046,
-0.4033665061,
-0.0952590033,
0.2581309378,
-0.895701766,
-0.3473714292,
-0.1851310581,
0.7257592082,
0.0059155896,
0.7577725649,
-0.0131345801,
0.3713470697,
0.2459449917,
-0.3068668842,
0.4119724631,
0.6920198202,
-0.2679355443,
0.4594613016,
-0.0741377622,
0.5340642333,
-0.1551405787,
-0.0439627916,
-0.9866644144,
0.0047094794,
0.2665399313,
-0.496286869,
0.2925029397,
0.1698677391,
-0.4784364104,
-0.5339031816,
-0.3857135475,
-0.191415295,
0.3577553928,
-0.5772330165,
0.4357428253,
0.6190856695,
-0.5384005904,
-0.2487621903,
-0.7803836465,
0.2048321366,
-0.0106780492,
-0.9955084324,
0.627995193,
0.6806655526,
-0.1011382937,
0.260689795,
-0.2362323403,
-0.3593858778,
-0.1291033328,
0.0507471226,
0.2741618454,
-0.1940264702,
0.0870627388,
0.2830560505,
-0.2864317298,
0.3845922053,
0.2024092674,
0.160397768,
0.5443590283,
0.3257736564,
-0.5840681195,
0.5208874345,
0.3012929261,
-0.5135811567,
0.1977573186,
0.5419870615,
-0.7291804552,
-0.1370179951,
-0.3377042413,
-0.1565177441,
-0.3699831963,
0.904417634,
-0.7656482458,
-0.5991954803,
0.3476790488,
-0.3094508052,
0.1983665079,
0.3141317368,
-0.076418452,
-0.2111441642,
0.7720560431,
0.8852362037,
-0.1871725172,
0.0861656442,
-0.2434467673,
0.6952867508,
-0.9581262469,
-0.5749274492,
-0.5794937611,
-0.4232245982,
-0.366745919,
-0.2482115328,
0.3758495152,
0.7167938352,
0.2166124582,
0.755836904,
-0.2453906834,
-0.0217527673,
0.1802232563,
0.2848796844,
0.0172840469,
0.2622760534,
-0.1243157908,
-0.4666596651,
-0.1969524026,
-0.3711942136,
0.3308568597,
0.6218602061,
0.1742670387,
0.2119136006,
0.5521817803,
-0.2892971039,
-0.1966403276,
-0.4917957187,
0.4514923692,
-0.4353825748,
-0.0943334326,
-0.5922624469,
-0.4935491681,
-0.8326755166,
0.2959418893,
-0.4003252685,
-1.0297625065,
0.252604872,
-0.2027136981,
-0.3308802843,
0.1169235483,
-0.7623456717,
0.7040870786,
-0.3334437609,
0.0446964763,
-0.0983014256,
-0.6550288796,
0.419334352,
0.0278744251,
0.0940774083,
-0.0038661871,
0.1361714751,
0.7233154178,
-0.6800811887,
0.3297516704,
-0.4792321622,
-0.1153150424,
0.0690395162,
0.1205315068,
0.6392596364,
0.3975214958,
-0.1372082829,
0.2138526142,
-0.0162105113,
-0.061168965,
-1.3374341726,
0.520676136,
-0.7281297445,
-0.4852285087,
0.0400221162,
-0.5758495331,
-0.4753860533,
0.104226768,
-0.0100041637,
-0.1025053635,
-0.0505432859,
-0.0325518437,
0.2030377239,
-0.0879974812,
0.4209883511,
-0.1808963567,
-0.4023339748,
-0.5662899017,
0.76541394,
0.3967306912,
-0.3632085919,
0.5671266317,
0.0882163942,
-0.4348526001,
-0.1719737202,
-0.5960812569,
0.1696329266,
-0.0472145453,
-0.2565577626,
-0.9370985627,
-0.7668667436,
-0.6496292949,
0.2951100469,
-0.2721793056,
-0.6348086596,
-0.1384124458,
-0.1648313105,
0.3604100645,
0.6214091182,
0.1307540834,
-0.1372416168,
-0.6915824413,
0.6336007118,
0.5665214062,
0.1853483468,
-0.1624965817,
-0.1285392791,
-0.1580682695,
0.0866671801,
-0.5165249109,
-1.0263960361,
0.0933240131,
-0.0079309326,
0.5631581545,
0.4319922626,
-0.133615762,
0.6571305394,
-0.3651660979,
0.755027473,
0.0996952876,
-0.639275372,
0.7000608444,
0.1629015952,
-0.2255849093,
0.2618667781,
0.1883694828,
-0.247456193,
-0.1562004536,
-0.5089020133,
-0.7236590981,
0.7901713848,
0.5871519446,
0.0935592353,
0.2811059654,
0.9601453543,
-0.1954941899,
-0.0166251622,
-0.3390748799,
-0.4528556466,
-0.2788523734,
-0.085734956,
0.3782530427,
-0.8877926469,
0.408333689,
0.0812734291,
0.3590950668,
0.3834286332,
0.3845233023,
-0.0212450027,
-0.0430067517,
0.0213498101,
-0.0413894132,
0.3115093708,
0.6765238047,
-0.2919810712,
0.1243491471,
-0.0203908123,
-0.5045662522,
-0.1869916916,
0.7041916847,
-0.2499811202,
0.0212150831,
0.4879522026,
0.6049848199,
-0.1300522834,
0.3953356445,
0.6678840518,
0.5254921317,
-0.3265289664,
-0.1145808995,
-0.1617510021,
0.3358837962,
0.3042905033,
0.0990968198,
-0.1651298106,
0.1874666214,
-0.6010165215,
0.5429148078,
0.2810453773,
-0.5047084093,
-0.0509892628,
0.850953877,
0.2493055612,
-0.4040108621,
1.0228444338,
-0.2107786536,
-0.3623941243,
0.4679835141,
0.3677041531,
0.5865442753,
-0.1064632162,
0.2156209052,
0.4973649979,
0.1417211741,
0.1514608115,
0.1073704362,
0.1207345054,
-0.8643969297,
-0.2547779083,
-0.3230416477,
0.1160109118,
0.4447811842,
-0.661622107,
0.4997118711,
-0.4273938835,
0.1654860675,
0.3070937693,
0.2276629657,
-0.3630666733,
-0.0196967684,
0.3162427545,
0.700594008,
-0.4868520796,
0.9920284748,
0.907284677,
-0.7409940362,
-0.8861746788,
-0.0212423615,
-0.0598448478,
-0.5644035935,
0.7364705801,
0.2037296742,
0.2745079398,
-0.3359622955,
-0.0063547119,
-0.662109673,
1.1541799307,
0.3752050996,
-0.4985792339,
-0.2449841201,
0.6001471877,
0.5042002797,
-0.5485044718,
0.1562158316,
0.7587236166,
0.3673624098,
0.0851599425,
-0.5973581076,
0.2557961345,
-0.3161135912,
0.931640923,
0.2615462542,
-0.4840473235,
0.4826438725,
-0.1830355078,
-0.3962108493,
0.0874110982,
1.2797807455,
0.2749427557,
0.1937052459,
0.6787647009,
0.5520054102,
0.6159378886,
0.0908910036,
0.3003602028,
-0.15453206,
0.5291131139,
1.2694497108,
-0.6348163486,
1.0293693542,
0.3349636197,
-0.3005942106,
0.701849699,
0.3362975717,
-0.1826142371,
0.7273004055,
0.1919198632,
0.3150347769,
0.0614789538,
0.3007844687,
-0.2882512808,
0.7635419965,
0.3386022449,
-0.2716428936,
-0.472748965,
-0.1360166967,
0.2049704045,
0.6040881872,
0.1123436689,
0.8678722978,
0.2822089791,
-0.3436614871,
0.0912130177,
0.072625421,
0.0450641587,
0.002298166,
-0.6046282649,
-0.3607377708,
-0.1110729352,
-0.2460445762,
-0.9252502322,
0.2670485079,
-0.3017427027,
-0.1875772327,
-0.0593863316,
0.4699907601,
-0.6626700163,
-0.402649045,
0.3459418416,
0.3031949699,
0.2038984895,
-0.1244164184,
-0.5109574795,
-0.3285728097,
0.0728941411,
-0.0999625176,
0.1457699239,
0.7842745781,
-0.2355040461,
-0.0138265761,
0.3379174173,
0.2129826695,
-0.476283282,
0.0559478849,
0.8216733932,
-0.574568212,
-0.7561600208,
-0.7257457376,
0.5696244836,
-0.5577325821,
-0.3419348598,
0.3485630751,
0.7975115776,
0.6056168675,
0.2193165272,
0.7974399328,
-0.240822956,
0.6907772422,
-0.6609161496,
0.817229867,
-0.1743698418,
0.3731789291,
-0.1289675981,
-1.296595335,
-0.4978496134,
0.6505117416,
-0.2125048637,
0.1097953916,
1.0687625408,
0.7986665368,
0.0078650024,
0.0949831232,
0.120771341,
0.3840593696,
0.3279987276,
0.6085588336,
0.507696569,
-0.8053181171,
0.8043919802,
-0.5785343647,
-0.3530423641,
0.0682561994,
-0.5062392354,
-1.057725668,
-0.6928137541,
-0.3362280726,
-0.3355515301,
-0.086766988,
0.5513670444,
0.5270469189,
-0.5023309588,
0.0603868403,
0.1413663626,
-0.0360040851,
-0.3884340227,
-0.2066206485,
0.9614183903,
-0.3585796952,
-0.5387958884,
0.1311133504,
0.4656418264,
-0.2417552024,
-0.3511373103,
0.1988170892,
-0.363291651,
-0.5392713547,
0.5746314526,
-0.0859386474,
-0.4688442945,
-0.4936778843,
-0.2038431913,
-0.3101670444,
0.2359507233,
0.9171019793,
-0.5364865065,
0.2681401372,
0.6457012296,
0.5146727562,
0.8435294628,
0.1408901811,
0.5127085447,
-0.8702089787,
0.2765253484,
-0.1726382971,
0.1927745938,
0.2319908589,
-0.8765208721,
0.6044111848,
0.116693683,
-0.2933956981,
-0.3352100849,
0.3648955226,
-0.9768627882,
-0.2263311595,
0.9978406429,
-0.2566950917,
-0.1499631554,
-0.1522897035,
-0.1535397768,
0.3109370172,
-0.0398815908,
0.9037897587,
0.4676020741,
-0.341376394,
-0.5350664258,
-0.4475515187,
0.5759775639,
-0.0505803227,
-0.924941361,
-0.0152755687,
0.166362524,
-0.0041223369,
0.5474135876,
0.3008601069,
-0.5379613042,
0.1232686266,
0.0996019915,
0.2967607379,
-0.3113155663,
-0.2456627339,
0.1416965574,
0.3673195243,
-0.1024250612,
-0.2843883336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04949v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04949v1
|
SilverSight: A Multi-Task Chinese Financial Large Language Model Based on Adaptive Semantic Space Learning
| 2024-04-07T13:02:21 | 2024-04-07T13:02:21 |
Yuhang Zhou, Zeping Li, Siyu Tian, Yuchen Ni, Sen Liu, Guangnan Ye, Hongfeng Chai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being applied across various
specialized fields, leveraging their extensive knowledge to empower a multitude
of scenarios within these domains. However, each field encompasses a variety of
specific tasks that require learning, and the diverse, heterogeneous data
across these domains can lead to conflicts during model task transfer. In
response to this challenge, our study introduces an Adaptive Semantic Space
Learning (ASSL) framework, which utilizes the adaptive reorganization of data
distributions within the semantic space to enhance the performance and
selection efficacy of multi-expert models. Utilizing this framework, we trained
a financial multi-task LLM named "SilverSight". Our research findings
demonstrate that our framework can achieve results close to those obtained with
full data training using only 10% of the data, while also exhibiting strong
generalization capabilities.
|
[
0.1750238538,
-0.6341201663,
0.4791948497,
0.2599960268,
-0.0713612363,
0.2399013042,
-0.1305849403,
-0.3717985749,
-0.1645837575,
0.6210954189,
-0.4027285874,
-0.7446728945,
-0.7324565649,
-0.2985637486,
-0.4265326262,
1.1214095354,
0.1147705987,
0.0153519502,
0.1645624042,
-0.1779613346,
-0.4698126316,
-0.2043710351,
-0.8616618514,
-0.2070576847,
0.127288729,
0.31626001,
0.7488563061,
0.5343359113,
0.6045824885,
0.4595229328,
0.1224240363,
0.3586013019,
-0.2961244881,
-0.3272526562,
-0.1902936101,
-0.4650149643,
-0.745755434,
-0.1903097481,
0.683322072,
0.791372478,
-0.4368103743,
-0.0688259676,
0.0369625054,
0.678211987,
-0.8493393064,
0.5442972779,
-0.9904978871,
0.1268114597,
0.1305135041,
-0.070015043,
-0.4634134769,
0.199623853,
0.4602765441,
-1.0989454985,
0.1070087776,
0.18150042,
0.5278449059,
0.2296404839,
-0.6182755828,
-0.3036702573,
-0.438629657,
0.8812739849,
-0.7386212945,
0.380325824,
0.2150568813,
0.3467556536,
0.0656189099,
-0.6634745598,
-0.2801027894,
-0.052186124,
0.1491018385,
0.3171830475,
-0.2440373451,
-0.0875550359,
-0.0830636099,
-0.0886873752,
-0.3378737271,
0.1458051205,
-0.3926535249,
-0.1107875481,
0.7250455618,
0.2350580543,
-0.1320344806,
0.355003804,
-0.5019876361,
-0.4219803214,
-0.3868930638,
-0.2168629616,
0.1565662324,
0.5384882689,
-0.1392407715,
0.0967178419,
-0.1833099872,
0.8750300407,
0.0617434904,
-0.3400689363,
0.504416585,
-0.1586790383,
-0.5729194283,
0.0269010607,
0.3174677193,
0.2408660948,
0.0389962904,
-0.3357211947,
-0.3715240359,
0.0152137643,
0.245799765,
-0.2440190464,
-0.4028533697,
0.2206391841,
-0.2751069963,
0.0464230366,
0.153082788,
-0.6038604379,
-0.5833050609,
-0.3448089361,
0.3131715655,
-0.5545505285,
-0.0626548231,
0.4792352617,
-0.1702861637,
0.2352241129,
0.4635603428,
-1.0188852549,
0.3488862216,
0.8507517576,
0.8081290722,
-0.2191981673,
-0.6439490318,
-0.9752579331,
0.6205821633,
-0.3526135385,
0.8437380791,
-0.3280960619,
-0.3815415204,
-0.0838693306,
-0.1209987551,
-0.3939638138,
-0.4458103776,
0.2282918245,
-0.5697598457,
-0.1523347944,
-0.0347441435,
-0.4416517913,
-0.2961105704,
0.420394361,
-0.5942713022,
0.4398381114,
0.2566788793,
-0.6167185307,
0.7561425567,
-0.9578948617,
-0.4230648577,
0.1246407852,
0.0370760262,
-0.3446749151,
-0.0848710686,
0.239697367,
0.6277922988,
0.1035505086,
0.0996051878,
-0.4920370579,
-0.2017797828,
0.3357107639,
-0.2877023816,
0.2659156024,
0.2280497849,
-0.2159672827,
0.3990196586,
-1.0155017376,
-0.2696320713,
0.0187311843,
-0.2978995442,
-0.7500026822,
0.1808303148,
0.2636966109,
0.1682879776,
0.416857481,
-0.4120627046,
0.1208132803,
-0.9833648205,
0.3744098842,
1.142095089,
-0.404427141,
0.7219715714,
-0.4027588964,
0.1855965704,
0.4282096922,
0.0630019903,
0.1239409894,
0.0456115082,
-0.7155088186,
-0.0993581861,
0.0679859743,
0.7203236818,
-0.6779997349,
0.1724910885,
-0.2434774041,
-0.3596381843,
-0.4936030507,
0.465372473,
0.1815755516,
0.2108271569,
0.374517858,
-0.090173848,
-0.2865945399,
-0.7537736893,
-0.2511245906,
-0.1223860383,
0.1822994053,
0.3743706048,
0.5237262845,
-0.4099263549,
0.7187643647,
-0.8284060359,
-0.6655589342,
-0.1186715439,
0.1633128077,
0.2670446932,
0.2609055042,
0.5875848532,
-1.2456228733,
-0.5231570005,
0.6513085365,
-0.4884187579,
0.2857285738,
-0.407891959,
-0.1170640439,
0.1976760477,
0.4238424301,
-0.4450402558,
0.2624149024,
0.8036651611,
-0.8373038769,
0.3932506144,
-0.6357214451,
-0.1397583932,
-1.3253170252,
0.0565344542,
0.2153353542,
-0.1869534105,
-0.5352582932,
0.1149054915,
0.2352166176,
0.0903539136,
-0.3528321683,
0.892308712,
-0.3956486285,
-0.510199368,
-0.5540685058,
0.3754869401,
-0.2311058939,
0.382822752,
-0.0395139307,
0.8156163096,
0.689430654,
-0.5660778284,
0.5177595615,
0.4709027112,
-0.3699283302,
0.613547802,
-0.3461368978,
-0.2308360338,
-0.0479275286,
-0.0741998479,
-1.2283725739,
-0.1072471589,
0.0524588674,
-0.1329776645,
0.0722857639,
0.4076831341,
-0.2520777881,
-0.0334815048,
0.0214289892,
0.0413624533,
0.0717576966,
-0.4406832159,
0.9985753298,
0.3433033228,
-0.4404633939,
-0.8197307587,
-0.6691105366,
0.1530460566,
-0.3386214972,
-0.5922319889,
0.4302482307,
-0.0570061915,
-0.5872471929,
0.0659530908,
-0.0200445317,
0.0563560724,
0.566313684,
0.0895522833,
0.6921449304,
-0.0302571692,
0.2853810191,
-0.1023179963,
-0.2998465896,
-0.1632820815,
-0.580586493,
0.30133304,
-0.088820681,
-0.4616608918,
-0.0059410362,
0.110187225,
0.4877598286,
-0.3515967131,
0.8909289241,
0.4746361971,
-0.1155363992,
-0.4444658458,
-0.4501574039,
0.2691187561,
-0.5169320107,
0.8865295649,
-0.333528012,
-0.997828424,
0.7200799584,
-0.2136600316,
0.7974518538,
0.641425848,
0.6708461642,
0.2933809459,
1.2166112661,
1.0130161047,
-0.4292290509,
0.5021602511,
-0.1899505556,
0.0569243841,
-0.5810191631,
-0.1335893422,
-0.2464684248,
-0.2297330052,
0.0211569183,
-0.4380894005,
0.4336896837,
-0.4026402235,
-0.364156425,
0.0115099335,
-0.099758774,
0.3275109828,
0.1904421151,
-0.0342033207,
0.3372566998,
-0.1035863087,
0.0025366938,
0.3298285007,
-0.580332458,
-0.0579583198,
1.1430664062,
0.3587604761,
0.9670868516,
0.1075826362,
0.2575735152,
0.4718964994,
0.2218004465,
-0.624530375,
0.370277375,
-0.8646988273,
-0.1528475434,
-0.4407584369,
-0.5820949674,
-0.841715157,
0.4510179758,
-0.2860302329,
-0.6877427697,
0.0685316548,
0.0444703922,
-0.7650296688,
0.2275498956,
-0.6624904871,
0.7852669954,
-0.4918581545,
-0.051393535,
-0.3541370034,
-0.4461888969,
0.253261745,
-0.6515831351,
0.5927039981,
-0.069464162,
-0.2475970685,
0.7468978167,
-0.045159664,
0.9250078201,
-0.2676460147,
-0.2436708659,
-0.1794754416,
-0.1218075082,
0.7481876612,
-0.0715381578,
-0.1251325756,
-0.1988364607,
0.0242709015,
-0.4555777311,
-0.4333918095,
0.6629204154,
-1.0932613611,
-0.4048876166,
-0.3642990887,
-1.1924940348,
-0.5846294165,
0.0841310024,
-0.2967109084,
0.0573989078,
-0.1185063198,
0.2093159258,
0.3842814863,
-0.1248562112,
0.3746816218,
0.7897073627,
-0.1138775349,
-0.3646407127,
0.8816516995,
0.0101697464,
0.3192806542,
0.2137167156,
-0.0742110908,
-0.3941022754,
-0.7007975578,
-0.1766917259,
0.1248909757,
-0.9978507161,
-0.1694890708,
-0.6769214869,
-0.2552176416,
-0.6467242241,
-0.5183383822,
-0.3906679749,
-0.0275655743,
-0.4652989805,
-0.0476387292,
0.3343267441,
0.4158351421,
0.1110187545,
0.6568625569,
-0.9699129462,
0.2002773732,
0.3672466874,
0.2303461879,
0.1557952017,
-0.5909036398,
-0.6408965588,
0.0539562181,
-0.2330327332,
-0.222155422,
0.7669771314,
0.4582490325,
0.6788920164,
0.5574305654,
-0.1379816085,
0.949254334,
-0.2113238871,
0.4734091759,
0.3036777973,
-0.9150756598,
0.1382534206,
-0.2352362871,
0.6314416528,
0.3925555944,
0.0370010249,
-0.7077499032,
-0.5301113725,
-0.5101537108,
-0.9382110238,
0.6305261254,
-0.3733915985,
0.1395036429,
0.3303148448,
0.3230159283,
0.3765546679,
0.2136959732,
-0.6465062499,
0.0067257001,
-0.0747713298,
-0.3206528723,
-0.4257516861,
0.150399968,
-0.1627983153,
0.0908754021,
0.8308947086,
-0.7544150352,
-0.03682914,
-0.1511989832,
-0.0667272881,
0.0001419026,
0.1838240623,
0.3718287945,
1.0941383839,
0.1053590775,
-0.1605049223,
0.563893795,
-0.4019359052,
-0.076578185,
0.5137227774,
0.1043896526,
-0.3787010312,
0.438232094,
1.0620555878,
0.5613974929,
-1.0439627171,
0.4471513629,
0.0298484378,
-0.6302587986,
-0.507442534,
0.2930755913,
0.0645579919,
0.8830707669,
0.7741336823,
0.1858821213,
0.1366165727,
-0.5331884623,
0.3754857779,
0.5164200068,
-0.2467158735,
-0.1807677597,
0.7616169453,
-0.0365939364,
0.3017907143,
0.6140186787,
0.0886058509,
-0.43248716,
0.5398225784,
0.6816005707,
0.7093874812,
-0.0527783073,
0.2722185254,
-0.1245070621,
-0.1461124271,
-0.2038747966,
0.3039754331,
0.1810394675,
-1.0138030052,
-0.7023313046,
-0.8301169872,
-0.343211621,
-0.1116046458,
-0.3910256624,
0.1308480203,
-0.7162806988,
-0.1162401512,
0.1870775074,
0.0701611638,
-0.5106220245,
0.321333617,
0.3542510271,
1.1979911327,
-0.9343673587,
0.753672421,
0.820091486,
0.239437148,
-0.6766073704,
-0.3192091286,
0.0237848219,
-1.0496315956,
0.781024754,
-0.1695280075,
-0.0494239554,
0.1505201757,
-0.4219545722,
-0.9294788241,
1.3015702963,
0.2707946897,
-0.6206825376,
-0.3009537458,
-0.0105497371,
0.381390959,
-0.6090534329,
-0.3374121785,
0.4676634371,
0.4584262669,
0.4893753827,
-0.8564906716,
-0.5038376451,
-0.2430857122,
-0.0575901344,
0.3422470093,
-0.9665241838,
1.1427779198,
-0.1543472707,
0.0194932111,
0.1065549329,
0.9501839876,
0.476195544,
0.5210608244,
0.7661064863,
0.4405650496,
0.8147330284,
0.0484104566,
0.6498535275,
-0.5063257813,
0.5421132445,
0.9113416672,
-0.7579911947,
1.0170999765,
0.4275764227,
-0.1447823793,
0.3925383389,
0.4558405578,
-0.3179590702,
0.6758300066,
-0.1487085223,
-0.1913886964,
-0.4499688148,
0.0472781733,
-0.0989868343,
0.8044944406,
0.4602113664,
-0.2366914302,
-0.2634596229,
0.343427062,
-0.2998253703,
0.0220328756,
-0.6269376874,
0.9602423906,
0.1384204179,
-0.3804924786,
-0.1144085154,
0.3042871356,
0.85172683,
-1.1135889292,
0.0464456119,
0.0898146853,
0.5469595194,
-0.0500537418,
-0.5490811467,
0.2861298919,
-0.2977458537,
0.0314462632,
-0.0932107121,
0.9700356126,
-0.3544834554,
-0.7423380613,
0.3543482125,
0.4633753896,
-0.1762105823,
-0.0265662242,
-0.8932939172,
-0.3424591124,
-0.1581557095,
-0.1277659684,
0.6112163067,
0.4556396306,
-0.0430460088,
0.8671286106,
0.9471091628,
0.3554869294,
-0.1195416898,
-0.2175715864,
0.832503438,
-0.6598354578,
-1.1692080498,
-0.7679523826,
0.3914487362,
-0.1259699166,
-0.2494564056,
0.8509694338,
0.4816298187,
0.9262226224,
-0.0653726906,
0.9397347569,
0.3592342138,
0.377848953,
-0.6441525817,
0.6786597371,
-0.7798005939,
0.244353503,
-0.2735839486,
-0.8884610534,
-0.4417769611,
0.6746323109,
-0.6387216449,
-0.025548961,
0.3040740192,
0.4501515031,
-0.1663430482,
0.0253044739,
0.5470966101,
0.2699782252,
0.1344377249,
0.9494594336,
0.5408053398,
-0.2183384597,
0.3846789598,
0.0937276036,
-0.0441668518,
-0.2419402897,
-0.6401178837,
-0.733823359,
-0.5840708613,
-0.259005785,
-0.0835414827,
0.0086893085,
0.8897197843,
0.5667401552,
-0.7150058746,
-0.4659531713,
0.2526207864,
-0.3359336555,
-0.4300622344,
-0.1377944946,
0.7118504047,
-0.2965812981,
-0.6643345356,
0.3043589294,
0.7058796287,
-0.0117168017,
-0.3342068493,
-0.3877721727,
-0.1790455282,
-0.1055260152,
0.7082460523,
0.0655012578,
-0.4165211022,
-0.4433971047,
0.0349551663,
0.0350824185,
-0.1965970546,
0.4529197514,
-0.5343301892,
0.2849034667,
0.1850810498,
1.0213271379,
0.1825565249,
0.1092924476,
0.4324728847,
-0.6327526569,
0.3383035064,
-0.0579416715,
0.4443864226,
0.111962676,
-0.4354581833,
0.3616991639,
0.1884743869,
-0.5017043352,
-0.3640524447,
-0.2769566178,
-0.9270501733,
-0.7151295543,
1.1937717199,
-0.2424621135,
-0.4371009469,
-0.2081679106,
-0.2737230659,
0.0692451298,
-0.2724594474,
0.8845803738,
0.7804518938,
0.1040315926,
-0.107370317,
-0.656642735,
0.0707778335,
0.4910356998,
-0.801933527,
0.3415803313,
0.5068270564,
0.2626394331,
0.1736803502,
0.5554986596,
0.2275971919,
0.6379047036,
0.1527532488,
-0.2250681221,
-0.0698528513,
-0.4236319661,
-0.2902562916,
0.3631821573,
0.1726099998,
0.0293244999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04941v1
|
Prompting Large Language Models for Zero-shot Essay Scoring via Multi-trait Specialization
| 2024-04-07T12:25:35 | 2024-04-07T12:25:35 |
Sanwoo Lee, Yida Cai, Desong Meng, Ziyang Wang, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Advances in automated essay scoring (AES) have traditionally relied on
labeled essays, requiring tremendous cost and expertise for their acquisition.
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have achieved great success in various
tasks, but their potential is less explored in AES. In this paper, we propose
Multi Trait Specialization (MTS), a zero-shot prompting framework to elicit
essay scoring capabilities in LLMs. Specifically, we leverage ChatGPT to
decompose writing proficiency into distinct traits and generate scoring
criteria for each trait. Then, an LLM is prompted to extract trait scores from
several conversational rounds, each round scoring one of the traits based on
the scoring criteria. Finally, we derive the overall score via trait averaging
and min-max scaling. Experimental results on two benchmark datasets demonstrate
that MTS consistently outperforms straightforward prompting (Vanilla) in
average QWK across all LLMs and datasets, with maximum gains of 0.437 on
TOEFL11 and 0.355 on ASAP. Additionally, with the help of MTS, the small-sized
Llama2-13b-chat substantially outperforms ChatGPT, facilitating an effective
deployment in real applications.
|
[
-0.3600391448,
-0.9457467794,
0.8129605651,
0.471244365,
-0.0372056514,
0.1353119016,
-0.4827978611,
-0.4166919589,
0.3268710375,
0.2673204243,
-0.4479298592,
-0.754145503,
-0.559543252,
0.3986056447,
-0.2121272832,
1.1317925453,
0.0274350811,
-0.269713372,
-0.218842566,
-0.1543795764,
-0.5017374158,
-0.4225306511,
-0.8717781305,
-0.027309848,
1.0607637167,
0.9075940251,
-0.0058289175,
0.4002588987,
0.2906903625,
0.2681973577,
0.2708638608,
0.2293617278,
-0.2466349751,
0.441108346,
0.343685925,
-0.6151028275,
-0.6671544909,
0.1749488264,
0.7266027331,
0.5625447035,
-0.0008688628,
0.4417042136,
0.2842935622,
0.1764242947,
-0.6119055152,
0.2296665609,
-0.6104677916,
0.1099663228,
-0.1595749557,
-0.2269263268,
-0.7736254334,
-0.3547048271,
-0.0328198336,
-0.4813686609,
0.0840975344,
-0.0682784244,
0.49068591,
-0.1347370595,
-0.4782052636,
-0.0259149801,
-0.362375617,
1.079023242,
-0.6004900932,
-0.1772465557,
0.2628321648,
0.1684566885,
0.1311341822,
-0.2019289881,
-0.5094127059,
-0.3192251325,
0.01305982,
0.1447838098,
0.0423600897,
0.2922732234,
0.3670082688,
0.4805709124,
-0.7138309479,
0.4896920621,
-0.2317945808,
-0.0677537248,
0.4868279994,
0.3741722405,
-0.0462178327,
-0.0896596834,
-0.0228487011,
-0.1437031925,
-0.6358494759,
0.4928843379,
0.4645059109,
0.5788286328,
-0.1750999093,
0.6787010431,
-0.1858396232,
0.6676940918,
0.1601174921,
-0.2019609213,
0.1064786389,
0.1104990989,
-0.1350549906,
-0.2648627162,
0.9316304922,
0.4952691495,
0.2232027501,
0.1417729408,
-0.108118847,
-0.0127581097,
0.2019388676,
-0.9000915885,
-0.0075652436,
0.3472822309,
-0.3910325468,
-0.6345227361,
-0.3643844724,
-1.1916804314,
-0.4728454351,
-0.1460465938,
0.513361454,
-0.4753554165,
-0.0401357412,
0.0411536396,
-0.331318289,
0.6450949311,
0.3584183156,
-1.1228865385,
-0.01508795,
0.5572949052,
0.9500656128,
-0.2743002474,
-0.5046054125,
-0.774255991,
-0.1340430677,
-0.4680511057,
1.2207711935,
-0.8043304682,
-0.5815464854,
0.2209240049,
-0.3632867336,
-0.3506472707,
-0.1863463074,
0.9081200957,
-0.008033623,
0.2566877902,
-0.3934455514,
-0.5490761995,
-0.0428878143,
0.7440143824,
-0.3536653817,
1.2936525345,
0.0826221853,
-0.4827436209,
0.4080713391,
-0.8718599677,
-0.5088889003,
0.1347893327,
-0.318223387,
-0.4554369152,
0.3162458539,
0.3745539486,
0.8614145517,
-0.2388720065,
-0.102343373,
-0.5962664485,
-0.3807657063,
0.2382237166,
-0.6451247334,
0.2987514734,
-0.2876959145,
-0.06214495,
0.0281247608,
-0.7841039896,
0.2792740166,
-0.1219706163,
-0.5760489702,
-0.0692201927,
-0.2648600638,
-0.2291813046,
0.1481156498,
0.0877423659,
-0.7565844655,
0.4438296854,
-0.182614103,
0.1669056118,
0.94332093,
0.0504350066,
0.2190941721,
-0.7302668095,
0.6993623972,
-0.2501845062,
0.1358896494,
-0.5922495723,
-0.7250702977,
-0.885997057,
-0.7315755486,
-0.0131243672,
0.6028546095,
-0.5274195671,
0.5188375115,
-0.0696433559,
-0.6281890869,
-0.5558580756,
-0.0236499291,
0.3794472516,
0.5023962259,
0.4758540988,
0.0468741991,
-0.1603843421,
-0.7394872308,
-0.3289351761,
-0.209305793,
-0.1956879944,
0.4199665785,
0.3203669786,
0.3394761384,
0.7421406507,
-0.8336946368,
-0.5195674896,
-0.6370268464,
0.6032865047,
0.1457019448,
0.2463035583,
0.8337368369,
-0.1373422593,
-0.9178451896,
-0.1431574374,
-0.5365063548,
-0.3227346539,
-0.1804724187,
-0.0130582927,
0.1187109277,
0.3074109554,
-0.7148284912,
0.315333575,
0.5495279431,
-0.2240908891,
1.1510002613,
-0.0046706893,
0.5137607455,
-1.0413496494,
0.1267925352,
0.16912283,
-0.0115551623,
-0.6338541508,
0.0936656818,
-0.1104021147,
-0.0481083989,
-0.0933743715,
0.5933283567,
-0.0714110285,
0.3254792392,
-0.1534207463,
-0.2190683633,
0.3094928563,
0.7131424546,
-0.0293536894,
0.7473359108,
0.7144321203,
-0.4573316574,
0.0483222269,
0.2231040746,
-0.0702652037,
0.9913499951,
-0.5818527341,
0.1119519025,
-0.1455657631,
0.2027653754,
-1.0580815077,
-0.2639079988,
-0.1718155593,
-0.520298481,
0.3886160851,
-0.1793313175,
-0.1649222374,
-0.2568405867,
-0.8765588403,
0.0651933104,
0.3619086444,
-0.2122867554,
0.774697423,
-0.130880937,
-0.4680067599,
-0.5358250141,
-0.5685477257,
0.1471018493,
-0.2770223022,
-0.4857457876,
0.0611600503,
-0.4468568861,
0.0273187365,
-0.2926864624,
0.272098273,
-0.088317126,
-0.1404265314,
0.1322966963,
0.4434108138,
-0.5979527831,
0.1946828067,
0.2524831295,
-0.1159508377,
-0.1192199215,
-0.4381943345,
0.3134931922,
0.062178839,
-0.3944625854,
-0.4140231609,
0.908541739,
0.9069261551,
-0.2757104337,
0.8911836147,
0.5021397471,
0.0607429259,
-0.4339437485,
-0.7936276793,
-0.298358202,
-0.4640759528,
0.166994825,
-0.4450911283,
-1.1546621323,
0.3474087715,
0.0326933153,
0.4233301282,
0.310911119,
0.5359054208,
-0.1736901551,
0.9760267735,
0.8060433865,
0.0066745901,
0.4309030473,
-0.1609853357,
0.5075944662,
-0.7458637953,
-0.0648636296,
-0.8395389318,
-0.2563410699,
-0.2993607223,
-0.4844014943,
0.6363187432,
-0.2382554263,
-0.0664841309,
0.0284280386,
-0.3480134904,
0.8024446368,
0.4598144889,
-0.208731696,
0.1438430399,
0.0188910458,
-0.6272186041,
-0.155277431,
-0.4846967161,
-0.4439838231,
1.3912400007,
0.2075183541,
0.3760156333,
-0.094290249,
0.710087657,
0.2513056099,
0.4831617475,
-1.0225135088,
0.7156357169,
-0.3908610344,
-0.3304350674,
-0.4933973849,
-0.2891628742,
-0.377417177,
0.3033661544,
-0.3951153755,
-0.8716900945,
0.0741245598,
0.191024676,
-0.7988033295,
0.1978689581,
-0.7201125622,
0.8267469406,
0.0513869934,
-0.3037355244,
-0.1646102518,
-0.1684112102,
0.3789354563,
-0.1281361282,
0.0101614092,
-0.3039512336,
0.1074614748,
0.4816310108,
0.0565220043,
1.0334228277,
-0.0402159579,
-0.024012709,
0.1989165992,
0.1830321997,
0.4173626602,
-0.1210595742,
-0.5999016166,
0.0792065114,
-0.0486464985,
-0.2790016532,
-0.6217423081,
0.6330857873,
-0.6161237359,
-0.5165843368,
-0.2215891778,
-0.2637362778,
-0.5094540715,
-0.0026921448,
0.319231689,
0.5386859775,
-0.2997179329,
0.2368249148,
0.6586005092,
-0.296020031,
0.5868035555,
0.8095840216,
-0.0672708303,
-0.1999117881,
1.0038772821,
-0.001114593,
0.1953483373,
0.4389688969,
0.3500564694,
-0.3016636968,
-0.4361568093,
-0.5500187874,
0.1004731879,
-0.6916230917,
-0.3938381374,
-0.9079492092,
-0.1544121206,
-0.4137832224,
-0.580552876,
-0.2373232096,
-0.4640409052,
-0.1056005284,
-0.4137664139,
0.3416762948,
0.6593980193,
-0.0285852198,
0.2993937433,
-0.8802479506,
0.1338580549,
0.398792088,
0.4639730752,
0.129355073,
-0.7605781555,
-0.0831893384,
-0.3530377448,
-0.4594534338,
-0.6897411942,
0.1976193041,
0.4905255735,
0.4499439597,
0.7029217482,
-0.001142112,
0.5253186822,
-0.4399108589,
0.9434614778,
0.0571695417,
-0.8300656676,
0.2815529108,
-0.545904398,
0.2965944111,
0.700189352,
0.4308037758,
-0.8242051005,
-0.8522306681,
-0.0822874457,
-0.6544886231,
0.7057666183,
-0.0918445438,
0.4842107296,
-0.0583407134,
0.3273600638,
0.4122771323,
0.1458005607,
-0.8958377838,
-0.0108527122,
-0.1148484945,
-0.4480751157,
0.0140347593,
-0.4473862946,
0.0519392788,
-0.3301513195,
0.6257169247,
-0.5794188976,
0.2476627231,
0.0174589995,
0.186277613,
0.0120798843,
0.6752746701,
0.5362874866,
0.0577873141,
0.0342333615,
-0.0176841542,
0.2758541107,
-0.4305719137,
0.1987488717,
-0.0412924886,
-0.2301193625,
-0.268917352,
0.553419292,
0.5996803641,
0.2251121253,
-0.5550143719,
0.7774423957,
-0.2129213214,
-0.5790107846,
-0.0684117898,
0.109420456,
-0.1749001741,
-0.0147354854,
0.4070693552,
-0.1446589679,
-0.0858381763,
-0.3513254225,
-0.0386193544,
0.4069894254,
-0.27921772,
-0.2464480847,
0.2214462459,
0.4802374244,
0.0062068254,
0.5859994292,
-0.4593248963,
-0.4395258129,
0.410172224,
0.3625157475,
1.0112141371,
-0.4204178452,
0.6539008617,
0.5732328892,
0.3476012051,
0.0940584987,
0.4100991786,
-0.0899108127,
-0.5891811252,
-0.7030156255,
-1.098944664,
-0.5043663979,
0.3034739494,
-0.2952511311,
0.4358086884,
-0.5438088775,
0.0122610535,
0.0655458197,
-0.1654675752,
-0.4193841517,
-0.0669744536,
0.1971656978,
0.8786121607,
-1.0588063002,
0.5881550908,
0.6510334015,
-0.347453624,
-0.9688053131,
0.1330456287,
0.297437638,
-0.6071788073,
0.1691833138,
0.5428285003,
-0.095947586,
0.0160110798,
-0.3317604959,
-0.392467469,
0.8075810671,
0.2683442533,
-0.2527851462,
0.0058095655,
0.4559613466,
0.5664587617,
-0.5332791805,
0.6999914646,
0.4482947886,
0.5887539387,
0.2168797851,
-0.7712774277,
-0.1679957509,
-0.2471515834,
-0.4252550602,
-0.0201494321,
-0.6999562979,
0.9866640568,
-0.1649270952,
0.1012846231,
0.0443326868,
0.2531895936,
0.064777866,
0.0876756608,
0.3971648216,
0.515090704,
0.7319885492,
0.0217929948,
0.7207962275,
-0.251013726,
-0.0696657524,
0.7224078774,
-0.5340422988,
1.0190324783,
0.1850053221,
0.1198773161,
0.736207664,
0.2424620986,
-0.0027936369,
-0.0664474219,
-0.128794834,
-0.7100805044,
-0.4432767928,
-0.2478943467,
0.0205438267,
0.9315009117,
0.4075618982,
-0.117302537,
-0.2626870275,
0.0637656823,
0.0902232677,
0.0225676503,
-0.1918868572,
0.8113820553,
0.0619646311,
-1.0823196173,
0.133078292,
0.2111317962,
0.6618154049,
-0.8928435445,
-0.2715589106,
-0.5101501942,
0.0357562192,
-0.0793690681,
-0.9013738036,
0.2042555213,
0.3469583094,
-0.2510238886,
-0.447774291,
0.6682831049,
-0.4683972895,
-0.5815336704,
0.2270843834,
0.4967143536,
-0.0784033239,
-0.1934126168,
-0.3448572457,
-0.1047117412,
-0.3485064507,
-0.2013878524,
0.5120600462,
0.5959587097,
-0.0327121057,
0.4404843152,
0.7628288865,
0.0182759054,
-0.0864065588,
0.1320832074,
0.773163259,
-0.5113980174,
-0.6578906178,
-0.8887268305,
0.6307187676,
-0.2650496066,
-0.3309686184,
0.7238890529,
0.4487424791,
0.2840225697,
-0.0720945075,
0.9868832827,
-0.0150915682,
0.7206397653,
-0.3671440482,
0.7316058278,
-0.3947588801,
-0.0278711058,
-0.1559832096,
-0.7982171178,
-0.3481203616,
0.4334638119,
-0.2768024504,
-0.0451085418,
0.8902839422,
0.9557099342,
0.1290666163,
0.0272638034,
0.6609466672,
0.0853167027,
0.3940812945,
0.690901041,
0.8749584556,
0.130665049,
0.6983512044,
0.1672007143,
-0.6878502965,
-0.3361654878,
-1.0672127008,
-1.2059402466,
-0.4036723077,
-0.1701749414,
0.0447682254,
-0.2143693417,
0.9291617274,
0.4808911681,
-0.6468263865,
-0.1833612472,
0.3876417875,
0.0802805275,
-0.2158727795,
-0.2848835588,
0.0586357638,
-0.6299130917,
-0.5122492909,
0.3976862133,
0.7947740555,
-0.0669961274,
-0.3154578507,
0.2151313126,
-0.0004134278,
0.5913648605,
0.7778035998,
0.3440082371,
-0.3228402138,
-0.4792690873,
0.2044143379,
-0.1013139337,
0.0694250911,
1.1054301262,
-0.442193985,
0.0883120149,
0.3036216199,
0.3657141924,
0.016987633,
-0.3080317974,
0.5371536613,
-0.9650713801,
0.0162510872,
0.281085521,
0.1840320379,
0.3353792429,
-0.4140672088,
-0.0308196098,
0.1290064156,
-0.5916357636,
-0.6201965809,
0.1232756972,
-0.706111908,
-0.1375614256,
1.0206682682,
-0.4536818266,
0.0863819569,
-0.2345825881,
-0.3282431662,
-0.2103067636,
-0.4699976146,
1.1126587391,
0.9413112998,
-0.3010584116,
-0.2774096727,
-0.4647078812,
0.5700209737,
0.4230176806,
-0.9759874344,
0.3029951453,
0.4492124617,
0.1090027615,
-0.0234237518,
0.9006575942,
0.0324850455,
0.3531218767,
0.0544810481,
-0.0876805708,
-0.0093835946,
-0.4881327152,
-0.3501532078,
0.5277585387,
0.305911243,
0.0748644546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04932v1
|
Towards Understanding the Influence of Reward Margin on Preference Model Performance
| 2024-04-07T12:10:04 | 2024-04-07T12:10:04 |
Bowen Qin, Duanyu Feng, Xi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is a widely used framework
for the training of language models. However, the process of using RLHF to
develop a language model that is well-aligned presents challenges, especially
when it comes to optimizing the reward model. Our research has found that
existing reward models, when trained using the traditional ranking objective
based on human preference data, often struggle to effectively distinguish
between responses that are more or less favorable in real-world scenarios. To
bridge this gap, our study introduces a novel method to estimate the preference
differences without the need for detailed, exhaustive labels from human
annotators. Our experimental results provide empirical evidence that
incorporating margin values into the training process significantly improves
the effectiveness of reward models. This comparative analysis not only
demonstrates the superiority of our approach in terms of reward prediction
accuracy but also highlights its effectiveness in practical applications.
|
[
-0.5447310805,
-0.1052034125,
0.2422465831,
-0.1425875127,
0.0784708858,
-0.1161546037,
-0.4513841867,
-0.5022065639,
0.1644586772,
0.2361507863,
-0.7169778943,
-0.3565495014,
-0.5050311685,
-0.1587186307,
0.4487821162,
0.8623515964,
0.1018336713,
0.1928441077,
-0.3231253624,
-0.3690383434,
-0.2700392306,
-0.9376654625,
-0.446290493,
-0.6170116067,
0.7451028228,
0.4956564605,
0.4714330733,
0.6644545197,
0.3191337287,
0.1612781733,
-0.0007905799,
0.0231231842,
-0.463095516,
-0.0081538083,
-0.1232917532,
-0.3570043147,
-0.2564756572,
0.3574178219,
0.2817209363,
0.5290131569,
-0.3785738051,
0.0561984628,
0.1400875896,
1.1628530025,
-0.956120491,
0.177951172,
-0.1721399277,
0.2549018562,
-0.0787503496,
-0.2731769085,
-0.6862409115,
-0.5415027738,
0.3720289171,
-0.6781067848,
-0.106898807,
-0.225112319,
0.8485005498,
0.1719577909,
-0.2245684713,
-0.1796330959,
-0.3354662955,
1.0347288847,
-0.717758894,
0.4241727591,
0.4023912251,
0.3327704072,
0.0413153023,
-0.2636140287,
-0.1258247495,
-0.4190277159,
-0.0767740309,
0.0708058998,
0.2549288571,
0.1173038259,
0.1158303842,
0.0240667481,
-0.1679615974,
0.2634449005,
-0.0578985959,
-0.1714484096,
0.7344291806,
0.069194518,
0.0570794977,
-0.2647379637,
-0.4217294753,
-0.8456394672,
-0.6328915358,
1.019947648,
0.5361253023,
0.5757176876,
-0.0740052685,
0.1731248498,
-0.36220631,
0.7319554687,
0.0634925365,
-0.3505309522,
0.2809923291,
0.3475152254,
0.1066427007,
0.0405247174,
0.655900538,
0.7341346741,
0.2662031651,
-0.1115758419,
-0.3727271557,
-0.0164984185,
0.3899559081,
-0.6677241325,
-0.0780738443,
-0.0567857809,
-0.6458006501,
-0.5728870034,
0.2884997427,
-0.5683162808,
-0.5296681523,
-0.3322991431,
0.1060926318,
-0.0674143136,
-0.4279691279,
-0.062005084,
-0.2610934675,
0.2207995653,
0.1734173447,
-1.1156343222,
0.2339538783,
0.776032269,
0.5049510002,
-0.5491119623,
-0.2347879261,
-0.7559218407,
-0.3175399601,
-0.2305474132,
0.9259826541,
-0.6046513915,
-0.684176743,
0.1432736665,
-0.1440224349,
0.096231401,
-0.7760012746,
0.9892327785,
-0.6851397157,
-0.0059585362,
-0.5331619978,
-0.6709284186,
-0.134466961,
0.3019222915,
-0.7425501347,
0.8264992833,
0.1122166738,
-0.6488888264,
0.7329168916,
-0.5417842865,
-0.2424086183,
-0.0852072164,
-0.1470025778,
-0.3751522005,
0.0730085,
0.2721072137,
0.1998222321,
-0.0155091807,
0.3233122826,
-0.5582562089,
-0.2270639688,
0.7446910739,
-0.3746310174,
0.280729264,
-0.0261995643,
-0.403716594,
0.4445059299,
-0.3930550516,
0.115804337,
-0.1861275584,
-0.6155644059,
-0.4695966542,
0.0610248111,
0.1547218412,
0.1948111057,
0.0707881525,
-0.5562152267,
0.2988844216,
-0.4532243311,
0.0427366458,
1.1366820335,
-0.2261838913,
0.6547688842,
-0.2428610176,
0.8133254051,
-0.3788677156,
0.1613608897,
0.3681651652,
-0.1677809358,
-0.5179151893,
-0.0940197632,
0.6397109628,
0.2706607878,
-0.1204985753,
0.3257894218,
0.010294213,
-0.3588005006,
-0.636384964,
-0.0262000244,
0.5009303093,
0.6790675521,
0.4146057069,
-0.1902540326,
-0.4202747643,
-1.168851018,
-0.45537889,
-0.2675977051,
0.109000206,
0.6245965362,
-0.0007345999,
0.2011288851,
1.1220872402,
-0.5616843104,
-0.1102449074,
-0.3995576799,
0.2134821862,
0.2245302647,
0.4281043112,
0.2623898387,
-0.7631599307,
-0.4873380661,
-0.1301207542,
-0.4199286997,
0.0114440201,
0.2245226651,
-0.1646067947,
0.4085400105,
0.0963680744,
-0.0017480031,
0.4366864264,
0.5347103477,
-0.3080684841,
0.490452528,
-0.1976515502,
0.2837897837,
-0.3251586258,
0.1808195263,
0.2599160373,
-0.21109128,
-0.3252685666,
-0.2646939456,
0.3742629588,
0.1950631887,
-0.5089333653,
0.6971025467,
0.0150356246,
0.0446758829,
-0.5598697662,
-0.2399397343,
-0.206735447,
0.8054029346,
0.7816815376,
0.8190670013,
0.062126603,
-0.5892262459,
-0.0442307033,
0.0253533218,
-0.272782892,
0.5308588147,
-0.5360398293,
-0.0340533443,
0.1324258596,
0.3049223721,
-0.9296022058,
-0.2526938021,
0.1990656406,
-0.6264750361,
0.1837833375,
-0.333309412,
0.1305751801,
-0.1166326329,
-0.3631548882,
0.2974505723,
0.5550384521,
-0.7360488772,
0.2850926518,
0.6549973488,
-0.0970108733,
-0.9943839908,
-0.2183811516,
-0.39635095,
-0.3419950902,
-0.1663163155,
0.3172830641,
0.1575796455,
-0.186292395,
-0.2561093271,
-0.1778482944,
0.2442943603,
0.3903664649,
0.5352492332,
0.4741282463,
0.1823067069,
0.3236005306,
-0.0689077154,
-0.6061303616,
0.1909039021,
-0.1814727038,
0.4255817831,
-0.2909611464,
-0.2943795025,
-0.4797846377,
0.0065603075,
0.1412284821,
-0.3501389027,
0.6036829948,
0.350490123,
0.0440195613,
-0.2858531773,
-0.514479816,
-0.4785579741,
-0.4710800648,
0.1791717261,
-0.1765959263,
-0.7458224893,
0.0890438482,
0.1428571939,
-0.0456586182,
0.2577957213,
0.2924410999,
-0.112523973,
1.2460304499,
0.6758964062,
-0.2677681744,
0.5646854639,
-0.1296589822,
-0.1601788402,
-0.706513226,
-0.3249141574,
-0.4087773263,
-0.5212816,
-0.5592442751,
-0.0379517265,
0.401006788,
0.1555869728,
-0.169892475,
-0.0039605224,
-0.615067184,
0.3779499829,
0.7458154559,
0.2081451863,
0.0440317988,
0.0011704672,
-0.1451674849,
-0.2572185099,
-0.5569786429,
-0.5609109998,
1.0998464823,
0.4992320836,
0.6885228157,
-0.0083230501,
0.7738839984,
0.4577098191,
0.6641453505,
-0.864470005,
0.1508147717,
0.0487398766,
-0.3719730377,
-0.6388282776,
-0.245286867,
-0.796652019,
0.3315015137,
-0.1467537284,
-0.6436994672,
0.2935278118,
0.2275567055,
-0.5744274259,
0.1560062915,
-0.5680373311,
0.9918784499,
-0.4370949268,
-0.6500068307,
-0.2415444404,
-0.6301297545,
0.0190295447,
0.5391798019,
0.1741069555,
-0.18061845,
0.119151473,
1.2911640406,
-0.4606488645,
0.7321478724,
-0.5743191838,
-0.0596416183,
0.1230561733,
-0.0668236911,
0.3945722282,
0.226266399,
-0.3365549147,
-0.1970893145,
-0.1405668557,
-0.4349527359,
-0.6028969884,
0.652163744,
-0.9410918355,
-0.5025148392,
-0.5441371202,
-0.5105727315,
-0.6820979118,
-0.0681158379,
0.0755072534,
0.3515162468,
-0.1644881815,
0.0193769764,
0.6015486717,
-0.3021863699,
0.5525379181,
0.3797637522,
-0.1451026946,
-0.5706378222,
0.7716972232,
-0.1653469801,
0.2819572985,
0.5901862979,
0.4465114176,
-0.7936922908,
0.0094102295,
-0.5652436614,
0.1650156379,
-0.7498164177,
0.0141937127,
-0.3468885124,
0.2290371656,
-0.2545699179,
-0.3163923025,
-0.4509173334,
-0.3353461921,
0.0131922737,
-0.3769923747,
0.2534282506,
0.8643675447,
-0.2362377644,
0.1416011006,
-0.6581275463,
-0.2630884945,
0.5319530964,
0.5160586834,
0.3429046869,
-0.4575041234,
-0.364806205,
0.0953435227,
-0.138665095,
-0.7157509327,
0.466350317,
-0.4419431686,
0.9196395278,
0.3387933671,
0.2719916999,
0.4445334375,
0.0638888702,
0.6326924562,
0.2857388556,
-0.8420739174,
0.3625920713,
-0.193603158,
-0.0015620906,
0.8133746982,
0.346987009,
-0.5129759908,
0.3675118387,
-0.6540792584,
-0.7272182107,
0.9368659854,
-0.344250828,
-0.2785716951,
0.2565023899,
0.1323063374,
0.287814647,
0.225037992,
-0.8647866845,
-0.1912473887,
-0.211871326,
0.0227972884,
-0.2962356508,
-0.2491259575,
-0.1608245075,
-0.1345410645,
0.7684423327,
-0.1019303799,
-0.051576335,
-0.0303203259,
-0.2315425426,
-0.1854902506,
0.4792310297,
0.6795765758,
0.6667556763,
-0.5835593939,
0.0276067946,
0.056252867,
0.0013050354,
0.335205555,
-0.1511415988,
0.123995997,
-0.2748840451,
0.2638761699,
0.9721779823,
-0.0011886638,
-0.8252896667,
0.6261017919,
-0.0673752427,
-0.1879219264,
-0.1265271902,
0.1196945235,
0.2046751231,
0.0498599298,
0.3276975751,
-0.1136975586,
0.0860744938,
-0.2378336936,
0.3454767466,
0.4353538454,
-1.1613119841,
0.0213550869,
0.1136178076,
0.4114910066,
-0.3960493505,
0.5334854722,
-0.0825361013,
-0.7160727978,
0.5963124633,
0.2062206417,
0.6667125225,
-0.0948579535,
0.4262064993,
0.4914258718,
-0.2421206981,
-0.1773631126,
-0.2404935807,
-0.3852639198,
-0.6806123257,
-0.2613831162,
-0.5464336872,
-0.4865040779,
-0.0903729498,
-1.1390794516,
0.0761318132,
-0.2758736908,
-0.4624868929,
-0.1997834891,
-0.0830592737,
-0.4342621863,
0.2109508067,
0.41283831,
0.7886611819,
-0.8072099686,
0.7048395276,
0.7474773526,
-0.5140445828,
-1.1880433559,
-0.097125195,
-0.1696912497,
-0.6661296487,
1.0576645136,
0.2919315696,
-0.3056120574,
-0.3449111879,
-0.217094183,
-0.5050613284,
0.8010266423,
0.0046885847,
-0.3072440922,
0.1142891571,
-0.0095351385,
0.4011598527,
-0.4137934744,
0.6220168471,
0.6656888127,
0.5421782136,
-0.142871514,
-0.7063170075,
-0.1789210588,
-0.2289062291,
-0.0448688157,
0.2920244634,
-0.5922518373,
0.6619372964,
-0.183040306,
0.0226604268,
-0.2089121789,
0.6620076299,
0.6421144009,
0.1355605572,
0.7716426849,
0.4736709595,
0.639072597,
0.001766913,
1.0968308449,
-0.2196592093,
0.5151405931,
0.8815667629,
-0.2035497576,
1.1037989855,
0.6477294564,
-0.3449116647,
0.812206924,
0.9356390834,
0.3338119984,
0.9152388573,
0.4241915643,
-0.0334220268,
-0.6268140674,
-0.3028695583,
-0.5212041736,
0.0049938024,
0.0768286511,
-0.1977968067,
-0.1217313781,
-0.0282418672,
-0.1758074015,
0.3723792136,
-0.2584143281,
0.8538720608,
-0.0409258641,
-1.1463606358,
0.6507235169,
0.1360710859,
0.91326195,
-0.4604302347,
-0.0946032181,
-0.215389058,
0.4286574125,
-0.2434528321,
-0.7494713664,
-0.3037576973,
-0.0816340968,
-0.2839393914,
-0.3448589742,
0.4663771093,
-0.2368617654,
-0.2453010231,
0.3984044492,
0.2523353994,
-0.3770365715,
0.0046406635,
-0.6162645221,
-0.0535712242,
0.1220931336,
-0.3110024035,
0.5054473281,
-0.0886273384,
-0.0049538664,
0.687168777,
0.6436159611,
-0.0732798502,
-0.3559308052,
0.0795630589,
0.494797796,
-0.6878345609,
-1.0114731789,
-0.8685237765,
0.6482237577,
-0.2612319291,
-0.3724530637,
0.4113108218,
0.5435264111,
0.8437934518,
-0.2530510128,
1.0040920973,
0.263032198,
0.8086400032,
-0.3856152594,
0.5195962787,
-0.5133391619,
0.3116075695,
-0.1928406507,
-0.4651068151,
-0.0419386439,
0.7663114667,
-0.7707912922,
0.0520151667,
0.4302328527,
0.7941187024,
0.149978444,
0.0597522259,
0.1263747215,
-0.5550146103,
0.3490935862,
0.6367872953,
1.1428604126,
0.1346319467,
0.2762426138,
-0.598285377,
-0.3188152611,
-0.4427659214,
-0.8506813049,
-0.7405182719,
-0.3462311327,
0.0493113361,
-0.5260283947,
0.1634418219,
1.3325815201,
0.9139558673,
-0.9810552597,
-0.8178141117,
0.0370497964,
0.2297877073,
-0.5437648296,
-0.205230251,
0.5810684562,
-0.4481889009,
-0.5156562924,
0.1770378351,
0.1605137587,
-0.1887884587,
-0.2832492292,
-0.734290123,
-0.1597291976,
-0.1587342769,
0.1780040711,
0.4231017828,
-0.8572395444,
-0.1861672848,
0.1507204622,
-0.2906929553,
0.226056397,
0.9855168462,
-0.8734019399,
0.305172056,
0.509455502,
0.8704609871,
0.4329400063,
0.4396511316,
0.8206432462,
-0.4871253967,
0.0679580644,
0.0455772616,
0.1625479907,
0.4273047447,
-0.2697838843,
0.5131813884,
0.1567528695,
-0.4315447509,
-0.8163382411,
0.2618179619,
-0.9458190799,
-0.3471475542,
1.2129812241,
-0.1178349629,
-0.3137218952,
0.3187865913,
-0.2418631166,
0.1417854875,
-0.965546608,
0.8317422867,
0.7090129256,
-0.388487339,
-0.0319181643,
-0.0466252677,
0.8581700325,
0.7928349972,
-0.5610665679,
0.2340655774,
0.2804634273,
0.2535843849,
0.0053341673,
0.4603720009,
0.1283755302,
0.4484305382,
-0.38037467,
0.3324358761,
-0.1812230945,
-0.1244508401,
-0.6226705909,
0.3935909271,
0.629496038,
-0.2352030724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04925v1
|
Multilingual Large Language Model: A Survey of Resources, Taxonomy and Frontiers
| 2024-04-07T11:52:44 | 2024-04-07T11:52:44 |
Libo Qin, Qiguang Chen, Yuhang Zhou, Zhi Chen, Yinghui Li, Lizi Liao, Min Li, Wanxiang Che, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual Large Language Models are capable of using powerful Large
Language Models to handle and respond to queries in multiple languages, which
achieves remarkable success in multilingual natural language processing tasks.
Despite these breakthroughs, there still remains a lack of a comprehensive
survey to summarize existing approaches and recent developments in this field.
To this end, in this paper, we present a thorough review and provide a unified
perspective to summarize the recent progress as well as emerging trends in
multilingual large language models (MLLMs) literature. The contributions of
this paper can be summarized: (1) First survey: to our knowledge, we take the
first step and present a thorough review in MLLMs research field according to
multi-lingual alignment; (2) New taxonomy: we offer a new and unified
perspective to summarize the current progress of MLLMs; (3) New frontiers: we
highlight several emerging frontiers and discuss the corresponding challenges;
(4) Abundant resources: we collect abundant open-source resources, including
relevant papers, data corpora, and leaderboards. We hope our work can provide
the community with quick access and spur breakthrough research in MLLMs.
|
[
-0.6068504453,
-0.737323761,
0.3294227123,
0.1809851825,
0.1041236296,
0.2637425959,
-0.394467324,
-0.485224098,
0.2272578925,
0.5293092728,
-0.4011653364,
-0.3490130007,
-0.6841951609,
0.1835544705,
-0.3333579004,
0.8440362215,
0.0829872489,
0.2947733998,
-0.0829199106,
-0.4288460612,
-0.3170401752,
-0.7619745731,
-0.4700857401,
-0.0838562548,
0.7528092861,
-0.0458652042,
0.4680476785,
0.1910776496,
0.5439787507,
0.3705706894,
-0.5154587626,
0.2331184745,
-0.2171759903,
0.3609834313,
-0.1043549776,
-0.1224317625,
-0.5640196204,
-0.2672004998,
1.1363492012,
0.9932373762,
-0.2578890622,
0.1641275585,
0.1843318641,
0.5732206702,
-0.6205906272,
0.0605989322,
-0.5249776244,
0.0131177446,
-0.4859291911,
0.1342715621,
-0.4580493569,
-0.0737538487,
0.1346265078,
-0.2582680285,
-0.0388879329,
-0.1745898873,
0.3072052598,
-0.3002662659,
-0.8216633797,
-0.3502985537,
-0.7498331666,
0.9444681406,
-0.7944708467,
0.7760902643,
0.1165194288,
0.4737101197,
0.0260346103,
-0.8224256039,
-0.290720582,
-0.1966711581,
0.0221809763,
-0.3288447261,
-0.1404242218,
-0.296623677,
-0.0351540968,
0.404171288,
-0.5810831189,
0.4814462066,
-0.3751770556,
-0.2995894551,
0.707544148,
0.3129391074,
0.1344985962,
-0.053027615,
-0.3384084404,
0.2048063576,
-0.6811503768,
0.1193898544,
0.089041695,
0.5289365053,
-0.0223690458,
0.4391854703,
-0.2877302766,
1.0199307203,
-0.6539099216,
-0.313094914,
0.3669415116,
-0.7351051569,
-0.1367106587,
-0.4938741028,
1.013667345,
0.3330148757,
-0.1377511322,
-0.0460454635,
-0.2110729218,
-0.4720855355,
-0.1952521503,
-0.5755173564,
0.2698339522,
0.2405611426,
-0.5141714811,
0.1572480351,
-0.1053617746,
-1.0541212559,
-0.4304731786,
-0.4304902554,
-0.1204280332,
0.0076748757,
-0.8018442988,
0.0853702575,
0.1110737622,
0.1325300038,
0.44126001,
-0.7276123166,
0.1548905671,
0.7314397693,
0.9808821082,
-0.2986751795,
-0.5096167326,
-0.3030620515,
-0.0890727416,
-0.211619243,
0.6766269207,
-0.3959555626,
-0.2927939594,
0.4667764306,
0.2060911357,
-0.0068842308,
-0.3097287416,
0.3731402457,
-0.6981469989,
0.2606826127,
-0.4940268099,
-0.3063677251,
-0.2264102995,
0.704738915,
-0.8643621802,
0.8229879737,
-0.1585017592,
-0.723533392,
0.1218126491,
-0.6768986583,
-0.2526257634,
0.1425869763,
0.0489504412,
-0.0787293985,
0.0178640913,
0.1637282223,
0.5077501535,
-0.4721835852,
0.5800305009,
-0.3999349773,
0.181848973,
0.3196240366,
-0.298150748,
1.1657415628,
0.456589222,
0.102287069,
0.3440252542,
-0.5997589231,
0.115630649,
0.0341279767,
-0.2477784902,
-0.3613216877,
0.0512453727,
0.4751073718,
0.5367741585,
0.4815917611,
-0.4774987102,
0.3526397049,
-0.0657656938,
0.398986876,
0.3789473176,
-0.1554120183,
0.4866192639,
0.0771205276,
0.5548545718,
-0.210361883,
0.3868392408,
-0.3653398156,
-0.5272597671,
-0.3652820289,
-0.0471951142,
0.3724418879,
0.331505686,
-0.7430510521,
0.1676582992,
-0.2046351433,
-0.6026973724,
-0.415971905,
0.081290096,
0.2099881172,
0.1247898266,
0.1902262121,
-0.2351909876,
-0.5849469304,
-0.8478731513,
-0.13490206,
-0.037708804,
0.1335873753,
0.1727994084,
0.439953953,
-0.3014884889,
0.7543004155,
-0.3528915942,
-0.2153405398,
-0.2558893561,
-0.0409927629,
0.0715317652,
0.2428691536,
0.5847991109,
-1.0865671635,
-0.5557305217,
0.2820210755,
-0.6643416882,
0.2219915837,
0.4436022639,
0.0652615055,
0.4190728068,
0.5570390224,
-0.56425035,
-0.2231141776,
0.6509212255,
-0.2912507355,
0.5343011618,
0.0333127752,
0.0970131159,
-1.0610530376,
0.3361262977,
-0.1721318215,
0.0960989222,
-0.8290261626,
0.5345054865,
-0.0124978581,
0.1114385575,
-0.442995429,
0.7746560574,
-0.6191484928,
-0.06111525,
-0.2003353536,
0.2111656219,
-0.1293665022,
0.1170782819,
0.0937094539,
0.3781299293,
0.7369710207,
-0.5894795656,
0.6196054816,
0.3455936313,
-0.303278327,
0.3184517622,
-0.2869076431,
-0.2025201321,
-0.2380992025,
0.3339496851,
-0.815425694,
-0.1767031103,
0.0917679742,
-0.3339235783,
0.3783628345,
-0.0644028932,
-0.5090095401,
-0.6055757999,
-0.2662603259,
0.3693582416,
0.2098888904,
-0.1390945315,
0.4474311173,
0.8108311892,
-0.5951898098,
-0.8558283448,
-0.5663814545,
0.3302821815,
-0.1928443909,
-0.483881712,
-0.0721217245,
-0.2738549411,
-0.5100896955,
-0.1249954179,
0.3758057654,
-0.3117364645,
0.0725523755,
-0.3898688853,
0.242307961,
-0.3876202703,
0.3004073799,
-0.3773117959,
0.2514308691,
0.0268689413,
-0.1825591922,
0.6321264505,
-0.1346691102,
-0.2375553697,
0.1048685908,
0.8003666997,
0.7260314226,
-0.8216454983,
0.8396582007,
0.7695182562,
-0.4076495469,
0.12652044,
-0.6607758999,
0.0679132417,
-0.3291396201,
0.5767788291,
-0.2640779018,
-1.2907425165,
0.582873404,
-0.0394675359,
0.4448731244,
0.6283556223,
0.8704108596,
0.2528635561,
0.9048542976,
0.8968154788,
-0.119193472,
0.3518555462,
0.0188207813,
0.2595895827,
-0.8453868032,
-0.5343558788,
-0.8325642943,
0.0373379551,
-0.6261121035,
-0.3491384685,
0.3164445758,
-0.0290851146,
-0.1126092002,
0.038695436,
-0.2782010138,
-0.0329177305,
0.3304229677,
-0.4853226542,
0.4781529903,
-0.005702178,
-0.1409513205,
-0.1193303764,
-0.7307985425,
-0.4453004599,
1.0271536112,
0.3874750435,
0.4684130251,
0.3596412539,
0.2738421857,
-0.1090613678,
0.4091814458,
-0.6221047044,
0.3503935337,
0.0184177309,
-1.0026568174,
-0.6679139137,
-0.4501274526,
-1.0931558609,
0.7739915252,
-0.0626041442,
-0.7221334577,
0.008415875,
-0.0833260715,
-0.1617705673,
0.5923432708,
-0.2841419578,
0.8674733043,
-0.2735547423,
-0.3940847516,
-0.0363986269,
-0.8106968999,
0.6835463643,
-0.2799350023,
0.6900622845,
-0.192496255,
-0.074717842,
0.674420476,
-0.1841513962,
0.5718334317,
-0.1964345425,
-0.6929540634,
0.411672473,
-0.1824817061,
0.2882733345,
-0.210925281,
-0.1375086308,
0.1605496258,
0.0649283677,
-0.2722002566,
-0.2468377799,
0.7234323621,
-0.289285332,
-0.2873525918,
-0.4682185948,
-0.5963484645,
-0.4614025056,
0.4273461998,
0.1741760373,
0.4197847843,
-0.3941046,
0.2435140759,
0.378292948,
-0.2788397968,
0.64225775,
0.7614994645,
-0.812673986,
-0.3667278588,
0.8088605404,
0.3006315231,
0.171955213,
0.3761548102,
-0.1291054934,
-0.5288501978,
-0.6713359356,
-0.4524793029,
0.2690834999,
-0.578982234,
-0.1286534518,
-0.8505991101,
-0.1982628703,
-0.7006476521,
0.2664869428,
-0.3865888119,
-0.185401842,
0.0746053383,
0.2625361383,
0.1125574112,
0.9654653072,
0.0190721825,
0.0779892877,
-1.0403811932,
0.0356094465,
0.199697718,
0.467022568,
0.3529079854,
-0.2232616246,
-0.4998273849,
0.1111579835,
-0.1784867644,
-0.5539317131,
0.3817919195,
-0.0613106303,
0.6695635915,
0.2892463803,
-0.2060894519,
0.3966035545,
-0.7026287913,
0.9724807143,
0.4124370515,
-0.5826982856,
0.0488990545,
-0.3881860077,
0.3691599965,
0.2692759633,
0.6235201955,
-1.0702412128,
-0.1346359253,
-0.2195016295,
-0.9359499216,
0.4785873592,
-0.1073185503,
0.2122587115,
0.2303269655,
-0.36401999,
0.1703597903,
0.4517500699,
-0.7759187222,
-0.3064388931,
0.2216874957,
0.2612658143,
-0.4174778759,
-0.3533165455,
-0.1229875758,
-0.3180927336,
0.5863441825,
-0.1338441223,
0.0366350524,
-0.2920345366,
-0.0752316639,
-0.0040365001,
0.6393917799,
0.7039312124,
0.8552132845,
-0.0530505627,
0.0900145322,
0.1136738434,
-0.3067712784,
0.1191661209,
0.322245717,
-0.1049539894,
0.1804886907,
0.4241896868,
0.6909868717,
0.2230846435,
-0.8082827926,
0.4563538134,
-0.0148303295,
-0.1001615897,
-0.1957120001,
-0.5409267545,
0.3775689006,
0.1709474176,
0.4452155828,
-0.0360894352,
0.2359751314,
-0.5325491428,
-0.0284337196,
0.665502429,
-0.1375902295,
-0.2640343606,
0.4524008334,
0.1608738899,
0.024705328,
0.3751446605,
-0.2140187174,
-0.4912498295,
0.3145601451,
0.4013221264,
0.5612333417,
-0.4532507956,
0.1760100126,
0.4199605286,
0.3013700843,
-0.1167542413,
0.2028851062,
0.0664782599,
-0.5512008667,
-0.6604755521,
-0.8739996552,
-0.2707157731,
0.2761470973,
-0.5968418121,
0.1273363084,
0.0957009867,
-0.1267406493,
0.0202439688,
0.0100694504,
-0.4080141485,
-0.0248407349,
0.3369705081,
1.0253998041,
-0.6175718904,
0.6214171052,
0.8046353459,
-0.2273104489,
-0.3481720388,
-0.3288641274,
0.0751332119,
-0.3243921995,
0.4403552711,
-0.0890606195,
0.0370037407,
-0.2103261799,
-0.2536172867,
-1.2113478184,
0.7171186209,
0.1275339127,
-0.5245928168,
-0.2350130081,
0.0591228157,
0.5645107627,
-0.2349334806,
0.0295350365,
0.460773319,
0.6304501295,
0.0784005523,
-1.1291072369,
-0.3442015052,
-0.4107894003,
-0.0276213083,
0.4158971906,
-0.73892802,
1.1878602505,
0.0178908464,
-0.0733576491,
0.3424942493,
0.504791677,
0.1564956754,
0.3345882595,
0.2349015921,
0.2773759961,
0.5978710651,
-0.0111061158,
1.091881752,
-0.1245556846,
0.6301338673,
0.8263633251,
-0.5247540474,
0.9798038602,
0.3132463098,
-0.5951423049,
0.144636333,
0.5929624438,
0.0299726389,
0.1366150081,
0.0935222208,
-0.4024625719,
-0.1522521079,
-0.3654074669,
-0.7060211301,
0.5175526738,
0.4384555519,
-0.2156838924,
-0.5641347766,
0.1773874909,
0.0317634903,
0.0011913445,
-0.5726175904,
0.6024431586,
0.0052488199,
-0.7672739029,
0.5058621168,
0.2609888613,
0.7994788885,
-0.8488336205,
0.0756639913,
-0.0748083368,
-0.1030258238,
-0.1546128392,
-0.7981317639,
0.2490212619,
0.0531021319,
-0.1640965939,
-0.3894568384,
0.6522259712,
-0.6483046412,
-0.4404174387,
0.3981663883,
0.9750396609,
0.0643720776,
-0.055709742,
-0.5801683068,
0.2633272707,
-0.0599789806,
-0.2159772068,
0.3529158533,
0.3826898932,
-0.1477616131,
0.599407196,
0.5239474773,
0.0845423415,
0.3542514145,
0.1531218886,
0.6595777869,
-0.6962233186,
-0.4092658162,
-0.7162842751,
0.5279762745,
-0.1167041436,
-0.373256892,
1.0123748779,
0.7224422693,
0.8391836882,
-0.085599646,
0.833093226,
-0.150308609,
0.7562168241,
-0.3971275389,
0.8307231665,
-0.8115717173,
-0.1141028404,
-0.3232020736,
-0.8463987708,
-0.5219815969,
-0.0186568294,
0.050597012,
0.2794349194,
0.5725861788,
0.4562447667,
0.0591615364,
-0.0976676419,
0.3115755618,
0.2867950201,
0.1569222957,
0.2930854559,
0.916885972,
-0.0850423872,
0.2660480142,
-0.0136464983,
-0.0150247784,
-0.3152499199,
-0.7013539076,
-0.5266712904,
-0.9022223949,
-0.0668642372,
-0.0648339465,
-0.3757981062,
0.7308587432,
0.5904436111,
-0.8690288067,
-0.471329689,
0.2388519347,
0.1888078004,
-0.0101775704,
-0.169627741,
0.3052557111,
-0.4330379367,
-0.837965548,
0.2310634255,
0.2745072544,
0.0033985164,
-0.7237718105,
-0.1906428039,
-0.6106697917,
-0.3038368225,
1.1236512661,
0.3998077512,
-0.8988593221,
0.3948872089,
0.1282058805,
-0.2629022896,
-0.0943868533,
0.8597431779,
-0.3791371882,
0.415235281,
0.4040359259,
0.6466977,
0.2432499528,
-0.5910076499,
0.3809742033,
-0.5357831717,
0.1010988578,
0.2864804566,
0.575814724,
0.5772292614,
-0.0011171135,
0.4577760994,
0.1271611303,
-0.3897689879,
-1.0913692713,
0.4180291593,
-0.789647162,
-0.4842291772,
1.0095001459,
0.0062467214,
0.0989598855,
-0.0642949045,
-0.108929418,
0.0697672516,
0.071641475,
0.2779400945,
0.9463698268,
0.0020423713,
-0.2813838422,
-0.7001944184,
0.3141577244,
0.1412144601,
-0.8608660698,
0.2617578208,
0.692838788,
0.0745436475,
0.3833017647,
0.7230428457,
-0.36052531,
0.0263332706,
-0.2127292901,
0.0916378945,
0.2660623789,
-0.3988128304,
-0.5999800563,
0.5452125072,
0.300621897,
0.2585437894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08679v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08679v1
|
Your Finetuned Large Language Model is Already a Powerful Out-of-distribution Detector
| 2024-04-07T10:32:49 | 2024-04-07T10:32:49 |
Andi Zhang, Tim Z. Xiao, Weiyang Liu, Robert Bamler, Damon Wischik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
We revisit the likelihood ratio between a pretrained large language model
(LLM) and its finetuned variant as a criterion for out-of-distribution (OOD)
detection. The intuition behind such a criterion is that, the pretrained LLM
has the prior knowledge about OOD data due to its large amount of training
data, and once finetuned with the in-distribution data, the LLM has sufficient
knowledge to distinguish their difference. Leveraging the power of LLMs, we
show that, for the first time, the likelihood ratio can serve as an effective
OOD detector. Moreover, we apply the proposed LLM-based likelihood ratio to
detect OOD questions in question-answering (QA) systems, which can be used to
improve the performance of specialized LLMs for general questions. Given that
likelihood can be easily obtained by the loss functions within contemporary
neural network frameworks, it is straightforward to implement this approach in
practice. Since both the pretrained LLMs and its various finetuned models are
available, our proposed criterion can be effortlessly incorporated for OOD
detection without the need for further training. We conduct comprehensive
evaluation across on multiple settings, including far OOD, near OOD, spam
detection, and QA scenarios, to demonstrate the effectiveness of the method.
|
[
-0.7101563215,
-0.8213356733,
0.7640426755,
-0.2971838713,
-0.3372735381,
-0.4200542867,
-0.3441817462,
-0.1796987504,
-0.1407634169,
0.6400194168,
-0.445030272,
-0.298664242,
-0.512329638,
0.0863230601,
-0.5737950206,
0.7561581135,
0.3187648654,
0.0967208892,
-0.2370315194,
-0.2456748039,
-0.4093852937,
-0.5910729766,
-0.8056486845,
-0.3137516975,
0.4005926251,
0.2765827775,
0.5702934265,
0.3158779442,
0.7135005593,
0.2244829535,
-0.2185651362,
0.2531961799,
-0.611823678,
0.0293328241,
-0.2345098704,
-0.8329768181,
-0.3528245091,
-0.2994485497,
0.7504446507,
0.5992826223,
-0.2386269271,
0.1294258982,
0.0216231607,
0.6178093553,
-0.7492334247,
-0.2336009592,
-0.8640565872,
0.0602523237,
-0.3611957133,
-0.4413934052,
-0.4953962266,
-0.1831429601,
-0.1487979591,
-0.4346254468,
0.1425865591,
0.0882145017,
0.4363307953,
0.2649639249,
-0.5052777529,
-0.2265206724,
-0.6289522052,
0.8476976156,
-0.8585340381,
0.6542630792,
0.4262334406,
0.4532614648,
-0.4592792094,
-0.5020260811,
-0.8969805241,
-0.3118281364,
0.1838652641,
-0.1339789331,
-0.1750252396,
0.0987114534,
0.2371993661,
0.8202730417,
-0.6047220826,
0.2199460715,
-0.1932075024,
-0.1504928172,
0.4365405142,
-0.01175257,
0.336487174,
0.1617818922,
-0.0081832912,
0.0152714103,
-0.6993083954,
-0.1653725207,
0.5423535109,
0.1918231994,
0.0732266381,
0.717174232,
0.0335762911,
0.7496042252,
0.2033394426,
-0.0912101567,
0.0632037446,
-0.2575610876,
-0.2464027703,
-0.1101866215,
0.7949552536,
0.0961805061,
0.1939253658,
0.0157059953,
-0.3732786775,
-0.1948755383,
-0.018212948,
-0.8654870391,
-0.1044274718,
0.1093878075,
-0.48916924,
-0.1730241328,
-0.0470054783,
-0.3431651592,
-0.6562663317,
-0.0188070703,
0.5582984686,
-0.3130703568,
-0.4974935651,
0.5332300067,
-0.0032895836,
0.1074494272,
0.024532754,
-0.7556157708,
0.0567729808,
0.7277463078,
0.6936812401,
-0.0852681473,
0.1083616093,
-0.980695188,
-0.2991761267,
-0.4578174055,
0.5993793011,
-0.31673792,
0.2956619859,
0.1196503788,
-0.0679405555,
0.1204636544,
-0.7851350904,
0.4434379339,
-0.9161667228,
0.3168245256,
0.0906155482,
-0.8452038169,
-0.0159873143,
0.4231009185,
-0.8001796603,
0.8232650757,
0.2481776476,
-0.8304468989,
0.4315431118,
-0.3221149445,
-0.2972772717,
-0.0321061276,
-0.3269111812,
-0.4582587779,
0.249913305,
0.2581647336,
0.4804694355,
-0.3566219211,
0.2038586736,
-0.686398387,
-0.384837538,
0.402525723,
-0.7010790706,
0.9832729697,
0.3182024956,
-0.1005468518,
-0.1979099661,
-0.8911603689,
-0.0089099528,
-0.1470850706,
-0.5325071216,
-0.424500376,
-0.0593766235,
-0.3438076377,
0.095006533,
0.1504859626,
-0.7148122787,
-0.2166928649,
-0.6808301806,
0.4919482768,
0.4542163312,
0.0134122605,
0.6096485853,
-0.3125181794,
0.5617236495,
0.0124008851,
0.1732091308,
0.1199209541,
-0.4314496517,
-0.6801243424,
-0.372941345,
0.1529673338,
0.4748622775,
-0.8752043843,
0.9430642128,
0.0656917617,
-0.3043735325,
-0.4814275503,
0.2544778287,
0.2639765739,
0.3863879144,
0.2130452693,
-0.271707654,
-0.3675739765,
-0.4021082819,
-0.1797401905,
-0.2975441813,
-0.0823995247,
0.0730848014,
0.2448389083,
0.0269365348,
0.9640304446,
-0.3768898547,
-0.4782776237,
-0.6250730157,
-0.3768746853,
0.4906322658,
0.3213703632,
0.5659588575,
-0.59010607,
-0.2727199197,
0.1819669753,
-0.7924997807,
-0.0755581856,
0.1499909461,
-0.2701879144,
0.0921450928,
1.0310561657,
-0.5336638689,
0.355491221,
0.4506085217,
-0.274636656,
0.2657068968,
-0.2872089744,
-0.0491161644,
-1.0551922321,
-0.0393860228,
-0.2126923054,
-0.3347035646,
-0.568500936,
0.2622229755,
0.1112425327,
-0.0548016801,
-0.4904726446,
0.6419532895,
-0.2023346871,
-0.064129889,
-0.0741952285,
0.1315529943,
0.0601872131,
0.0955623537,
-0.0959667638,
0.6372515559,
0.3058773279,
-0.7474708557,
0.3306210935,
0.049087327,
-0.7509613037,
0.6528484225,
-0.5333344936,
0.0282794181,
-0.539671123,
0.1256374419,
-1.3009647131,
0.0490076058,
0.224930346,
-0.3733105958,
0.1437910348,
-0.3204739392,
-0.5891097784,
-0.3811473846,
-0.2357993275,
0.6632406116,
0.5262939334,
-0.6506374478,
0.4177542329,
0.2084338069,
0.093394354,
-0.4016550183,
-0.8337872624,
-0.4961459339,
-0.4257546663,
-0.6130211949,
-0.0219299756,
-0.2178270519,
-0.2216012478,
-0.2597955167,
0.146236062,
-0.3668379486,
0.2418710142,
-0.1647783071,
0.0482568815,
-0.5786460638,
0.5424024463,
-0.0189621225,
0.1670985967,
0.0651687682,
-0.3766473532,
0.7872658968,
0.0696618557,
-0.5443309546,
-0.3743763566,
0.1101730466,
0.5622197986,
-0.2814557254,
0.7385978103,
0.7509333491,
-0.3134786487,
-0.1455039531,
-0.7002240419,
-0.5034221411,
-0.484901309,
0.5791962743,
-0.1327490807,
-0.6608946919,
0.4936304688,
0.2550314665,
0.0211014226,
0.2942461967,
0.2782674432,
-0.0487823337,
0.9124712944,
0.726606369,
-0.096098654,
0.7922025323,
-0.226180315,
0.3709180057,
-0.6375775933,
0.1641600579,
-0.3330138326,
-0.1392750293,
-0.4013109207,
-0.2297032177,
0.4179992676,
0.4934559464,
-0.3634328842,
-0.0259845406,
-0.2051664442,
0.6139566302,
0.4262478948,
0.3959092498,
0.5702313781,
0.2001907825,
0.1856326461,
0.2887211144,
-0.7206345797,
-0.3776962161,
1.4278122187,
0.5440465808,
0.6663453579,
0.1890716404,
0.8857359886,
0.217085883,
0.292606473,
-0.7766432166,
0.5943915844,
-0.407137394,
-0.6754181385,
-0.6565215588,
-0.5683389306,
-0.8334893584,
0.1617252827,
-0.2013915777,
-0.3678056896,
0.2568522692,
0.2246428579,
-0.7859148383,
0.4529164433,
-0.5921797156,
0.9271203876,
0.0158094019,
0.068289347,
-0.0887342319,
-0.1112437323,
0.5210957527,
-0.0959490165,
0.1587461233,
-0.2346336991,
0.0885247439,
0.6743100286,
-0.6384581327,
0.6678388119,
-0.0862309113,
-0.3925427496,
0.5163146257,
-0.0421461165,
0.4503029883,
0.2237303704,
-0.3549359739,
-0.0788369477,
0.034482684,
-0.2123776376,
-0.5705983639,
0.4775084257,
-0.5865224004,
-0.3208695352,
-0.0897929221,
-0.6082267165,
-0.1646672785,
0.2467794865,
0.6863327026,
0.6304527521,
-0.0055414834,
0.3320280612,
0.8598304391,
-0.2480315417,
0.3654943407,
0.4480571747,
-0.4546955228,
-0.3314424455,
0.7676627636,
0.0287568048,
0.5136852264,
0.4512477517,
0.4373541772,
-0.5216732621,
-0.7439563274,
-0.4780621827,
0.2356005013,
-0.8800496459,
-0.2591464221,
-0.4243017137,
-0.3415902555,
-0.180914104,
0.1917642057,
-0.2595883906,
-0.1133814603,
-0.3642936051,
0.0969057158,
0.3797028363,
0.5602792501,
0.0196129065,
0.4345929325,
-0.4750275612,
0.366471529,
0.4922499359,
0.2534458041,
-0.0330102742,
-1.0433303118,
0.0482395813,
0.1199472621,
-0.2498873174,
-0.5576940179,
0.3039531708,
0.4702200294,
0.5074471235,
0.7254066467,
0.4583036602,
0.4533083141,
-0.1801158637,
0.4442582428,
0.292070508,
-0.5863726139,
0.2746893466,
-0.0961966962,
0.1051094905,
0.4741119742,
0.3639169335,
-0.2256291509,
-0.6102045774,
-0.2780576646,
-0.5026012659,
0.5183621645,
-0.024303304,
0.2606287897,
-0.3099576831,
0.3621780872,
0.256397903,
0.3045870662,
-0.7700921893,
-0.145695135,
0.3107780516,
-0.4028094709,
-0.2753050029,
-0.3568922877,
0.1062153503,
-0.1059683636,
0.444811821,
-0.0257055908,
0.2183713913,
0.0715871081,
-0.278396666,
-0.054729633,
0.4123193324,
0.2768750489,
0.6906265616,
-0.4680351913,
0.3518564701,
0.1113387123,
-0.5469190478,
0.1044194475,
0.0789418444,
-0.2548851073,
-0.0344268791,
0.3915495872,
0.4990568757,
-0.0843170881,
-0.7593672872,
0.7648116946,
-0.0005925794,
-0.0744653568,
-0.3673971891,
-0.0001724058,
-0.1496830732,
0.4501476288,
0.2608462274,
-0.0928016677,
0.2866819203,
-0.8369330764,
0.3002288342,
0.6009722352,
-0.4325164557,
-0.0426014513,
0.229040876,
0.0160789732,
-0.0859645978,
0.5837353468,
-0.6013426185,
-0.3359465599,
0.6366912127,
0.4963549078,
0.5421567559,
-0.1431045234,
0.0854098201,
0.1049530059,
0.2793619931,
-0.3033834398,
0.6059200168,
0.1465423703,
-0.9981484413,
-0.4923986793,
-0.5499204397,
0.1853193492,
0.6104070544,
-0.7469876409,
0.3554804027,
-0.4594434202,
-0.2159930468,
0.0808680207,
-0.1564515084,
-0.6991998553,
0.0770233646,
0.2108516693,
0.7624295354,
-0.69003582,
0.6427813768,
0.48775509,
-0.2888997793,
-0.6189094782,
0.084243834,
-0.3528007865,
-0.8569319248,
0.6581978202,
0.1984841675,
0.1245301217,
0.1828862578,
-0.2605100274,
-0.709400773,
0.8775545359,
0.7933678627,
-0.8323456049,
0.2866116464,
0.2280212939,
0.3645056188,
-0.283562392,
0.4939792454,
0.76454705,
0.0950462222,
0.0264301822,
-1.0503175259,
-0.1424844116,
0.1375115067,
-0.2526653707,
0.4669862688,
-0.0994321406,
1.1706039906,
-0.3245902359,
-0.2271613479,
0.292997092,
0.612197578,
0.2357557863,
0.5226428509,
0.6745327115,
0.5654484034,
0.7807309031,
0.1943432242,
0.9455578327,
-0.153377831,
0.353718698,
0.9209443331,
-0.0820280686,
1.2641559839,
0.4774836898,
-0.1759042144,
0.1350199431,
0.4322994947,
0.4946580827,
0.7125284672,
0.5014573932,
-0.4152826071,
-0.6387248039,
-0.068689622,
-0.6479033828,
0.1761068553,
0.1687808335,
-0.368496716,
-0.3013155758,
0.337189585,
-0.2533281147,
0.2245743722,
-0.754792273,
0.607611835,
0.0866751224,
-0.5602537394,
1.003842473,
-0.2423369884,
0.8011351228,
-0.3734741211,
0.0963618383,
-0.5278337598,
0.6601876616,
-0.2293553054,
-0.8732097149,
0.1534781158,
-0.3505084217,
-0.1573156863,
0.2670856714,
0.6591725945,
-0.7944492698,
-0.4588036835,
0.1099295169,
0.5269777775,
0.2596211433,
-0.6006186008,
-0.2716398537,
-0.0024832836,
-0.161950618,
0.0530987382,
0.3510108888,
0.82428509,
-0.0516586639,
0.6893247962,
0.6042751074,
0.0001355468,
0.3150596619,
0.1982210875,
0.7918069363,
-0.2418058217,
-0.6238090396,
-0.9051373005,
0.1237936318,
-0.0521958098,
-0.3441494107,
0.4701554477,
0.3912394345,
0.9607281685,
-0.2759408355,
0.7700542212,
0.0510343388,
0.3826414049,
-0.6930596232,
0.7100284696,
-0.7051318884,
0.4149505794,
0.0796631202,
-0.909494698,
-0.211382404,
0.7012885213,
-0.4823399186,
0.0033112622,
0.6650537848,
0.9878394008,
-0.2901281118,
-0.1839401871,
0.6723588109,
-0.0588480756,
0.2891401947,
0.7595732808,
1.0682677031,
-0.6162021756,
0.9495971203,
-0.1562545151,
-0.2292366326,
-0.4436194003,
-0.8794429898,
-1.4531601667,
-0.4736287594,
-0.2529705167,
-0.3264158964,
0.0238476768,
0.8316255808,
0.7644706368,
-0.8374374509,
-0.0727670193,
-0.4978994131,
0.228075847,
-0.1431431919,
-0.1841460168,
0.1678753793,
-0.4258107841,
-0.4278033972,
0.2927904427,
0.0984370261,
0.1530195922,
-0.4016745389,
-0.1022914127,
-0.0007513495,
0.1462061107,
0.7130938172,
0.270054549,
-0.5195503235,
-0.2738324106,
-0.079911463,
-0.205325067,
-0.2312183529,
0.6820486188,
-0.5024825931,
0.2874744236,
0.7990228534,
0.6367692351,
-0.0001874869,
-0.3188582957,
0.5682274699,
-0.7588522434,
0.2290218323,
0.2733386457,
0.3731858134,
0.1537970304,
-0.3961247206,
0.3423581421,
0.0316968486,
-0.4398194849,
-1.0959137678,
0.3726918101,
-0.7444526553,
-0.0862559155,
1.3284457922,
-0.2084287703,
-0.174741298,
-0.4412883818,
-0.2160008848,
-0.0314670056,
-0.3633220792,
0.6716397405,
0.4733225107,
0.1968798488,
-0.1917250305,
-0.5972275138,
0.5456568599,
0.4803022444,
-0.851893127,
0.019860955,
0.2580284774,
0.3343068659,
0.1026163846,
0.7416159511,
0.0030365079,
0.4653328955,
-0.320133388,
-0.025706308,
-0.1417434365,
-0.2280950546,
-0.3276602626,
0.2242266983,
0.4399445951,
-0.5434122086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04900v1
|
Radial Networks: Dynamic Layer Routing for High-Performance Large Language Models
| 2024-04-07T09:52:31 | 2024-04-07T09:52:31 |
Jordan Dotzel, Yash Akhauri, Ahmed S. AbouElhamayed, Carly Jiang, Mohamed Abdelfattah, Zhiru Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with strict memory, latency, and
power demands. To meet these demands, various forms of dynamic sparsity have
been proposed that reduce compute on an input-by-input basis. These methods
improve over static methods by exploiting the variance across individual
inputs, which has steadily grown with the exponential increase in training
data. Yet, the increasing depth within modern models, currently with hundreds
of layers, has opened opportunities for dynamic layer sparsity, which skips the
computation for entire layers. In this work, we explore the practicality of
layer sparsity by profiling residual connections and establish the relationship
between model depth and layer sparsity. For example, the residual blocks in the
OPT-66B model have a median contribution of 5% to its output. We then take
advantage of this dynamic sparsity and propose Radial Networks, which perform
token-level routing between layers guided by a trained router module. These
networks can be used in a post-training distillation from sequential networks
or trained from scratch to co-learn the router and layer weights. They enable
scaling to larger model sizes by decoupling the number of layers from the
dynamic depth of the network, and their design allows for layer reuse. By
varying the compute token by token, they reduce the overall resources needed
for generating entire sequences. Overall, this leads to larger capacity
networks with significantly lower compute and serving costs for large language
models.
|
[
-0.5487467647,
-1.0354776382,
0.3530714214,
-0.001999513,
-0.1170583367,
0.2887877822,
-0.1889526099,
-0.4329418242,
0.2756057084,
0.7288482189,
-0.5236803889,
-0.3123953938,
-0.3484052718,
-0.1190847307,
-0.6466572285,
0.6729177833,
0.1932223886,
-0.218846187,
0.1338216811,
-0.0742855594,
-0.2575394511,
-0.5063526034,
-1.0166604519,
-0.3175640106,
1.1020553112,
0.3655108809,
0.801733613,
0.831762135,
0.6157213449,
0.4012981057,
-0.4861368835,
0.0980820879,
-0.5132918358,
0.4894253612,
0.0094607994,
0.0165581349,
-0.4513137937,
-0.4900021255,
1.1418548822,
1.049038291,
-0.2651616633,
0.1385252327,
-0.3008588254,
0.9183825254,
-0.3425911963,
-0.1914272159,
-0.5371310115,
0.389193505,
-0.3190359175,
-0.0569271855,
-0.2732316554,
-0.1343594342,
0.0875092745,
-0.2487451285,
0.1307681948,
0.1157527193,
0.6291379929,
0.1684284806,
-0.3051952422,
-0.0646583959,
-1.0721908808,
0.4872101247,
-0.7248986363,
0.4839308858,
0.0835691094,
0.4526904821,
-0.0226642694,
-0.8891891241,
-0.3293202519,
-0.3960389495,
-0.0067019728,
-0.1626973301,
-0.2844109535,
0.1604707241,
0.4793323874,
0.3782294691,
-0.4537664056,
0.277380228,
-0.3884987831,
0.0771840587,
0.3426559865,
0.0872966945,
0.2703360617,
0.261534512,
-0.3065574169,
0.001150012,
-0.7414204478,
0.0140327644,
0.5135434866,
0.2875334322,
0.0621254966,
0.4590343833,
-0.1868153214,
0.9897437692,
-0.0325167067,
0.0136618875,
-0.0461710952,
-0.1093459576,
-0.1242234483,
0.1686340421,
0.5110750794,
-0.4717648029,
0.1067130864,
-0.3572758734,
-0.4147389531,
-0.3559315801,
0.0819339603,
-0.6295360327,
-0.3589054048,
0.0524423122,
-0.3124935329,
-0.3227246404,
-0.0208036322,
-0.5893267989,
-0.1102018654,
-0.4583856165,
0.2606583238,
-0.4103957117,
-0.4568711519,
0.4702067375,
0.0873376355,
-0.0328121372,
0.2566210926,
-0.6387547851,
0.6899433732,
0.6177443266,
0.8540670872,
0.1105863303,
-0.1450668573,
-0.7944104075,
0.3574215472,
-0.0930307284,
0.3337484896,
-0.6886985898,
0.0401431285,
-0.0477630496,
-0.2294488996,
-0.0769619048,
-0.6890332699,
0.3843426108,
-0.8797763586,
-0.0687738881,
-0.0336720571,
-0.1805023402,
-0.2378681153,
0.1350791305,
-0.8050572872,
1.1556224823,
-0.0942429602,
-0.7095899582,
-0.2539382875,
-0.304869622,
-0.6460108161,
-0.0277685039,
0.2347240299,
-0.2657280564,
0.3706026673,
0.0039879838,
0.4208243787,
-0.0937193111,
0.4089643061,
-0.2691200078,
-0.4167716801,
0.3635755479,
-0.4346312582,
0.4845437109,
0.156667009,
-0.423048526,
0.1501175314,
-1.1124082804,
-0.259180218,
-0.0954192802,
-0.410605818,
-0.4029422402,
0.1669237167,
-0.0348239094,
0.3203551471,
-0.0562201552,
-0.2678508759,
0.0528141372,
-0.4010458589,
0.5741596818,
0.7538389564,
-0.3426046669,
0.2891402543,
-0.1076281518,
0.5254275799,
0.0568051077,
0.0735727102,
-0.0670852512,
0.0423576199,
-1.1675182581,
-0.4083999395,
0.3254734874,
0.3180611134,
-0.7331928015,
0.561491549,
-0.2662864923,
-0.4778983593,
0.0099553075,
-0.072730504,
0.4771783054,
0.5524215102,
0.2859027088,
-0.4919664562,
-0.393348217,
-0.8954724073,
-0.0724026635,
0.0348140374,
0.3863215446,
0.5479468107,
0.204167828,
-0.0745334923,
0.6436554193,
-0.3879209757,
-0.2070361227,
-0.5687036514,
-0.2122438401,
0.3110709488,
0.4503369331,
0.2990008891,
-0.450311482,
-0.3354662359,
0.1963264644,
-0.3482352495,
-0.1045178026,
-0.0207847245,
-0.3248614073,
-0.0232366845,
0.5017235279,
-0.602551043,
-0.007291649,
0.7023887634,
-0.2215235382,
0.4761128426,
-0.2957865596,
-0.4767506719,
-0.7772628665,
0.2812040746,
0.2395920455,
-0.3940846622,
-0.6732749343,
-0.069821775,
-0.3424903452,
-0.3502966464,
-0.319899559,
0.7022818923,
-0.6716316342,
-0.4533299506,
0.00802451,
0.0876990333,
-0.014484847,
0.3713278472,
-0.1010176688,
0.5673031211,
0.6077039242,
-0.6172519326,
0.6666848063,
-0.25129807,
-0.2272523195,
-0.0618818365,
-0.7586582899,
0.0217000246,
-0.053051848,
0.466111213,
-0.963753581,
-0.1148253158,
0.1823343784,
-0.2055559754,
0.3945837915,
-0.1950859129,
-0.47176373,
-0.3593742549,
-0.0073743705,
0.7204977274,
0.5908252001,
-0.359523654,
0.6843645573,
0.2701812685,
-0.0473806672,
-0.8324690461,
-0.5761950612,
0.2683385909,
-0.2989543974,
-0.8100717068,
0.4412552118,
0.2615388632,
-0.1862211525,
0.0611057952,
-0.0227897633,
-0.0984798297,
0.1694986224,
0.0376776569,
-0.1250795126,
-0.4195301235,
-0.1134297326,
0.1712568253,
-0.1107328013,
0.1616152376,
-0.4189934731,
0.9892930984,
-0.0186605547,
-0.455100745,
-0.6732762456,
0.2050208896,
0.7170907855,
-0.3842808902,
0.9856052399,
0.7280879617,
-0.1892460883,
-0.4386184216,
-0.8457931876,
-0.1684444696,
-0.5469924808,
0.6516960263,
-0.2327493727,
-1.0731066465,
0.7308366895,
-0.1488598734,
-0.2795736194,
0.205074057,
0.4009105861,
0.0680028722,
0.6370710135,
0.4897313714,
-0.1615958959,
0.7402323484,
-0.2926890552,
0.38641572,
-0.7687174082,
-0.3143394291,
-0.5340157151,
-0.5267265439,
-0.2225991189,
-0.5099081397,
0.4044407904,
0.0664369538,
-0.604611814,
-0.1002533883,
-0.2718240619,
0.4982995093,
0.5211699605,
0.1725846976,
0.2797333002,
0.5903513432,
-0.3064031601,
0.3141741455,
-0.9784736037,
-0.2648946643,
0.2459031343,
0.6806218624,
0.7987752557,
0.2211978883,
0.4264304042,
0.1848213971,
-0.0864988938,
-0.649359405,
0.8812212944,
-0.3100847304,
-0.311943084,
-0.4383626282,
-0.7922683954,
-0.8171837926,
0.1928957552,
-0.1082392931,
-0.3157753348,
-0.0403393954,
0.3248768747,
-0.3336466551,
0.789688766,
-0.3833126128,
0.3887387216,
-0.4093818069,
-0.717117548,
-0.3215055466,
-0.6145252585,
0.2699536681,
0.1918072253,
0.062310569,
0.037088871,
0.1446491331,
0.6788600683,
-0.3202465177,
1.0351513624,
-0.2440414876,
-0.0262785051,
0.0750333592,
0.4079529047,
0.5892191529,
0.0420353115,
-0.1465604752,
0.1964326352,
-0.4275968075,
-0.1757517755,
-0.3194703162,
0.8152678609,
-0.9366525412,
-0.4937609136,
-0.2491725683,
-0.3666453362,
-0.1207758412,
0.3766672611,
-0.4158145785,
0.885142386,
-0.0551748537,
0.3006034791,
0.8782336116,
-0.6616526246,
0.46737203,
0.2411253005,
-0.0927154273,
-0.4046803117,
0.7566971779,
0.0872079805,
0.3151051104,
0.5105710626,
0.1963647455,
-0.3159579635,
-0.7333062291,
-0.4570813775,
0.6185137033,
-0.3531756699,
-0.1688903272,
-0.6610740423,
-0.6794762015,
-0.1243744642,
-0.1524766684,
-0.5471168756,
-0.6041279435,
-0.2235596925,
-0.0273810197,
0.3384487033,
0.7082537413,
0.0196138583,
0.4457184076,
-0.8221905231,
-0.1660558134,
0.1719845831,
0.5834447145,
0.7375375032,
-0.6309977174,
-0.4910154641,
-0.259211421,
-0.1540536135,
-0.2654598951,
0.5513249636,
0.1264792681,
0.439784348,
0.3276325762,
-0.1346154809,
0.7437761426,
-0.822861433,
0.5548620224,
0.3622774482,
-0.9410235882,
0.1827628762,
-0.5386327505,
-0.022457812,
0.0292260982,
0.3127915263,
-0.6363256574,
-0.1367947757,
-0.4862753749,
-1.0514140129,
0.6870145202,
0.0395644903,
0.3728426695,
0.2563143373,
0.8003942966,
-0.0854106918,
0.0067949882,
-0.6300444603,
-0.1710195988,
0.1755760908,
-0.1073469073,
0.1764665097,
-0.5989740491,
-0.200624451,
-0.2092992514,
0.4692071378,
0.2847076654,
0.1080698892,
-0.0680220574,
0.169446677,
-0.0862631723,
-0.0373832472,
0.6937257648,
0.8979421854,
-0.1942487657,
0.4423925579,
0.0361613184,
-0.3152469099,
0.2677794695,
-0.1152548343,
-0.0058730668,
0.0757771432,
0.3577271998,
1.1072744131,
0.1140580848,
-0.5652552843,
0.2334245145,
-0.0201645438,
-0.0573497079,
-0.5830751061,
0.2151748091,
0.0915364921,
0.4238087833,
0.265065074,
0.026899837,
-0.1746494174,
-0.2299441993,
0.1325519234,
0.5380007029,
-0.4649341404,
-0.5067722797,
0.372782588,
0.3551969826,
-0.4463006556,
0.6513501406,
0.4805079103,
-0.3992137611,
0.6056649089,
0.5055294633,
0.5575470328,
-0.1053817645,
0.1080805287,
0.3544581532,
0.1711045057,
-0.2089717537,
-0.3943095803,
0.019825913,
-0.5850548148,
-0.6456670165,
-0.6186316013,
-0.3061196208,
0.1743869036,
-0.5864771605,
0.1839390695,
-0.6142314672,
-0.2743139267,
-0.3862889111,
-0.1080070958,
-0.2983885109,
0.2751457393,
0.1003322452,
0.9581760764,
-0.705544591,
0.8185023069,
0.5916079283,
-0.1152250916,
-0.7553150654,
-0.2562434673,
-0.4058214724,
-0.7385485172,
1.1218458414,
-0.0208579917,
-0.4347677529,
0.0918004364,
-0.1154067293,
-1.1619522572,
0.9411753416,
0.3871186674,
-0.6117461324,
-0.2536069155,
0.1307961047,
0.4454704523,
-0.127831012,
0.2154832333,
0.1201158017,
0.1515314579,
0.3486964703,
-0.6340142488,
0.0724741817,
0.0490910336,
0.3030994236,
0.1939230561,
-0.8527292609,
0.9508113265,
0.1342800111,
-0.0290934835,
-0.0296338759,
0.5701531172,
0.3268457949,
-0.0312627591,
0.5635883808,
0.5612411499,
0.5288787484,
-0.0204303712,
0.7825246453,
-0.3733321726,
0.2404915094,
0.6597324014,
-0.4140871763,
0.7872559428,
0.4157386124,
0.0156672876,
0.4730418026,
0.3812485933,
0.3232001066,
0.4397844374,
0.7621421814,
-0.4102003574,
-0.2432360947,
-0.0958502814,
-0.5285212398,
0.2010798752,
0.2238637656,
-0.4502087533,
-0.1044034138,
-0.2156726718,
0.1574618369,
-0.1914281696,
-0.2221288234,
0.5901228786,
0.0307870936,
-0.3893874288,
0.6526707411,
0.1873515844,
0.5598997474,
-0.7090290189,
0.116580829,
-0.669895947,
0.4285414815,
-0.1284544617,
-0.417067945,
0.3460948467,
-0.0035020746,
-0.2524498403,
-0.3073596358,
0.6683158875,
-0.3341352046,
-0.7109552622,
0.3949546814,
0.5926597714,
-0.0614587478,
0.314232409,
-0.6350997686,
0.5478157997,
-0.2115005851,
-0.5112705827,
0.5422944427,
0.8874537945,
0.1546420902,
0.8946938515,
0.6942763925,
0.6281342506,
0.317990005,
0.1707120836,
1.2721786499,
-0.6951094866,
-0.1503341198,
-0.8299094439,
0.4178958237,
-0.0738189369,
0.0192445349,
0.4242979288,
0.5349228382,
0.8011287451,
0.1136564314,
0.4072899818,
0.2643043995,
0.424567461,
-0.7220869064,
0.6924589872,
-0.6733425856,
0.6590229273,
-0.1628712416,
-0.966807425,
-0.5820091367,
0.9455088377,
-0.0569114983,
0.2234785706,
0.4361769259,
0.8406305909,
-0.5142498612,
-0.3489273489,
0.2818624973,
0.2794904709,
0.6031259894,
0.4312241971,
0.9116930366,
-0.147156179,
0.25141716,
-0.2497090548,
-0.2089007646,
-0.1636937559,
-0.9047365785,
-0.925532639,
-0.3102591336,
-0.3601911366,
-0.4924556315,
0.2570302188,
0.646807611,
0.7554295063,
-0.3953278363,
-0.6686070561,
-0.1769859195,
0.0887660161,
-0.0621161796,
-0.2007608414,
0.5379211903,
-0.2561896443,
-0.3486382365,
0.1591319442,
0.3397297263,
-0.0631514937,
-0.5860015154,
0.176545009,
-0.1176324934,
-0.0462700687,
0.7693861127,
0.2183693051,
-0.6635859609,
-0.0644905195,
0.0596911646,
0.1125504524,
-0.1604100466,
0.9945005774,
-0.7707493305,
-0.0934456661,
0.396453619,
0.8357295394,
0.5124659538,
-0.1124501005,
0.4728625119,
-0.6715974212,
0.3815463185,
0.3386903107,
0.1949670166,
0.2129209489,
-0.1640598625,
0.2676514983,
0.2666439116,
-0.571002543,
-1.0715602636,
0.2789414525,
-1.0837595463,
-0.1940118819,
1.2533503771,
-0.0654772818,
-0.2307286859,
0.0077038161,
-0.1923529059,
0.1331371218,
-0.3380734026,
0.6912754178,
0.5321396589,
-0.2008924335,
-0.5166009068,
-0.4778624177,
0.3097376525,
0.5564294457,
-0.3813582361,
0.2984757125,
0.6342763901,
0.1274691522,
-0.2155991048,
0.4588666856,
-0.0142290462,
-0.4685213566,
-0.3624212444,
-0.1755904853,
-0.5247062445,
-0.6630660295,
-0.0821068585,
0.3159816861,
0.1649820507,
0.2460646927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04892v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04892v1
|
Elementary fractal geometry. 5. Weak separation is strong separation
| 2024-04-07T09:21:09 | 2024-04-07T09:21:09 |
Christoph Bandt, Michael F. Barnsley
|
math.DS
|
math.DS, cs.CL, 28A80, 11A63, 37B10, 54B15, 68Q45
|
For self-similar sets, there are two important separation properties: the
open set condition and the weak separation condition introduced by Zerner,
which may be replaced by the formally stronger finite type property of Ngai and
Wang. We show that any finite type self-similar set can be represented as a
graph-directed construction obeying the open set condition. The proof is based
on a combinatorial algorithm which performed well in computer experiments.
|
[
-0.6049976349,
-0.8876424432,
0.2879751027,
0.2692817748,
-0.2421209216,
-0.2055532336,
0.0038076923,
-0.5187586546,
0.2585835159,
0.3683753908,
-0.4039358497,
-0.1480755508,
-0.7386571765,
0.2191837579,
-0.6401142478,
1.002632618,
-0.1459720582,
-0.166929841,
0.0452506319,
-0.7212343812,
-0.0418267846,
-0.2707339823,
-0.2851128578,
-0.1738588065,
0.3689022362,
0.3222199082,
1.162828207,
0.8510811329,
0.5993114114,
0.4162495434,
-0.3525843322,
-0.0491881333,
-0.60138762,
0.258926332,
0.0481447652,
-0.2776389718,
0.1191130728,
-0.0737798214,
0.8944811821,
1.0825353861,
0.0400393829,
-0.3936244547,
0.3200414777,
0.8257126212,
-0.3545280397,
-0.0478707664,
-0.1972706318,
0.6105496883,
-0.5370253921,
0.1811605096,
0.0850918964,
-0.3491325974,
0.2654442787,
-0.5772821903,
0.5563232303,
-0.0016773684,
1.1484361887,
0.1015693396,
-0.4056166112,
-0.4539361298,
-0.7179211378,
0.8485940099,
-0.3150102794,
0.7908478975,
0.2793133557,
0.3260968626,
-0.2790904641,
-0.8804004192,
-0.4233505428,
0.2870228589,
-0.4358066022,
-0.0279628783,
-0.2194633335,
0.013718605,
0.3940881491,
1.2142745256,
-0.4379343987,
0.1166982725,
-1.0583404303,
-0.0165743176,
0.3827937543,
0.1809674799,
0.5367339253,
-0.310026139,
-0.4116728008,
0.2185686678,
-0.9305205941,
0.004774197,
0.3624923527,
0.333988905,
-0.1343287975,
0.515676558,
-0.1561085433,
0.5821461678,
0.1032133177,
-0.5360693932,
-0.0191774461,
-0.3277341127,
-0.3355732858,
-0.1581358612,
0.6648497581,
-0.1608829796,
0.2835469246,
-0.1856068671,
-0.4127173126,
-0.4396820664,
-0.3435249031,
-0.8497166038,
-0.5944979191,
0.282265842,
-1.1208586693,
-0.4049097896,
0.4608982503,
-0.5471292734,
-0.3839184642,
-0.1384618133,
0.2741994858,
-0.0964574739,
-0.488915056,
-0.2293801308,
0.0823356882,
-0.0232697409,
0.119680889,
-1.0436366796,
0.7780299783,
0.7517612576,
0.9996544719,
-0.0179617871,
-0.3918767273,
-0.5261195302,
-0.0160565693,
-0.2996871471,
0.7518908978,
-0.2326200902,
-0.4542455673,
-0.177047357,
-0.0254634377,
0.1884974539,
-0.6722091436,
0.1374458522,
-0.3802734911,
0.4397447407,
-0.3238601387,
-0.5403229594,
-0.3144427836,
-0.1749882996,
-1.1116913557,
0.3821460903,
0.3700306118,
-0.6755632758,
0.5235399008,
-0.3406556249,
-0.9859582186,
-0.1881788075,
-0.45126158,
-0.6728199124,
-0.1089568064,
-0.0638522357,
0.2233292311,
-0.1752128005,
-0.3247405887,
-0.9153629541,
-0.1453329772,
-0.0636679009,
-0.040193066,
1.0933451653,
0.8272404075,
-0.3637205064,
0.0851099417,
-0.5311768651,
0.2069624811,
0.051556699,
-0.3286758363,
-0.256485641,
0.2688497603,
-0.4513987899,
0.1350979507,
0.2485521138,
-0.3493515551,
0.165499866,
-0.2471788824,
0.5128014088,
0.9481588006,
0.1245579571,
0.5132755637,
-0.1040297002,
0.1316090673,
0.1953165382,
0.2683873475,
0.4063574672,
-0.4557639956,
-0.7404441237,
-0.4194552302,
0.2150295973,
0.163386628,
-0.0892583206,
0.3651582301,
0.2782688737,
-0.192823872,
-0.2358648479,
0.6572068334,
0.4458311498,
0.32286641,
0.0410462171,
-0.1746875495,
-0.4624133706,
-0.7833991051,
0.2263712585,
0.1416386962,
0.3288556337,
0.2166275829,
0.2081964314,
0.3061627746,
0.5779429078,
-1.0149081945,
-0.4507014453,
-0.1448962539,
-0.0193023309,
0.6687771678,
0.4724152088,
0.8239652514,
-0.8773519397,
-0.5154961944,
0.0622634292,
-1.1053407192,
0.1752175987,
0.3813248873,
-0.1822157204,
-0.1900152862,
0.5912598372,
-0.5300241709,
0.5945507288,
0.3478638828,
-0.5344403386,
0.4395744503,
0.0646048412,
0.0170751531,
-0.7573215365,
-0.1733024716,
-0.1508404315,
-0.2815684676,
-0.4958401322,
0.3007749915,
-0.6421423554,
-0.4796097875,
-0.428751111,
0.1111501828,
-0.6052800417,
-0.5313204527,
-0.0720276162,
-0.1816671789,
-0.2367576808,
0.3608415425,
0.0085088266,
0.5805498958,
0.8689237237,
-0.8248303533,
0.2800791562,
0.3534675539,
-0.0710388571,
0.7099041343,
-0.9221132994,
-0.1587629169,
-0.0656027645,
0.0816544443,
-0.9546865821,
-0.1857634187,
0.2553074658,
0.2650030851,
-0.1452092975,
-0.1853464246,
-0.379653424,
-0.4312447906,
-0.0344285965,
0.5662010908,
0.5471171141,
-0.9312695265,
0.2630847692,
0.0042388989,
-0.0495988689,
-0.4327957332,
-0.3640794754,
-0.7391594648,
-0.2857269347,
-0.8997130394,
-0.1579979807,
-0.1483425349,
-0.7990451455,
0.3019402027,
-0.2224152982,
-0.63054353,
0.1490915865,
0.628071785,
-0.1201411411,
-0.5559310317,
0.0085697891,
0.1733892113,
-0.0785798356,
-0.2358038872,
-0.2672940493,
0.416215986,
-0.3973986208,
-0.5062427521,
-0.3516457677,
0.4558220208,
0.5700467825,
-0.0936271623,
0.3915527463,
0.4121443033,
-0.5736139417,
-0.1946182847,
-0.0836008042,
-0.1896016002,
-0.5331013203,
-0.1025843397,
-0.7613152266,
-1.1793036461,
0.9186223745,
0.2111390084,
0.3240218759,
0.763433814,
0.3841098547,
-0.3604736924,
0.6975041628,
0.1669237763,
-0.1116956845,
0.3829112053,
-0.4432453811,
0.3536161482,
-0.3489109278,
-0.0360306874,
-0.6494084597,
-0.6091215014,
-0.5403760076,
0.312487036,
0.1512736827,
0.7681825757,
-0.2291072905,
0.2165888846,
-0.5254030824,
0.8566663265,
0.554762423,
-0.0360516794,
0.3353099525,
0.1526933014,
-0.197456643,
-0.1763677895,
-0.4102757573,
-0.0222301465,
0.8247978687,
0.1400305629,
0.7066689134,
0.5066412091,
1.2322632074,
0.4394232333,
0.1781702191,
-0.5005331635,
0.3970332444,
-0.4072329998,
-0.77900666,
-0.5967627168,
-0.5805524588,
-1.1402702332,
0.4700720012,
-0.220506832,
-0.7381588817,
0.5148804784,
0.086843729,
-0.2581112385,
0.7170892954,
-0.7009247541,
0.7703447342,
0.0526934564,
-0.1836474836,
-0.2801679969,
-0.4300042689,
0.6496370435,
0.0991619453,
-0.1571826339,
0.0153944697,
0.5639805198,
0.5795961022,
-1.180748105,
0.5399078727,
-0.1840296984,
-0.0914689004,
0.9734048843,
0.6756253839,
0.2502515912,
0.1315355748,
0.1264163107,
-0.0944509581,
-0.0452428833,
-0.5034922957,
-0.6805456877,
0.7461913228,
-1.0677568913,
-0.5057271123,
-0.09228912,
-0.1932734102,
0.3982119858,
0.7162966132,
0.6085951924,
0.8186510801,
-0.1714263707,
0.2299788147,
0.4643660188,
0.6285884976,
0.667977035,
0.1570884585,
-0.273685813,
-0.4318241775,
1.0837824345,
0.4716192484,
0.2731009424,
-0.0350282975,
0.403986156,
-0.3360961676,
-0.5609284043,
-0.1608287245,
0.2255991399,
-0.7930530906,
-0.0424145274,
0.0314188264,
-0.5719710588,
-0.2205268592,
-0.4720509648,
-0.2925417125,
-0.8447574377,
-0.2431516945,
0.1119016334,
-0.0112549262,
1.3471759558,
-0.494669944,
-0.0807815865,
-0.5687427521,
0.3514551818,
1.025931716,
0.588804841,
0.1478629857,
-0.1330120713,
-0.0360889845,
-0.4759091735,
-0.3464816213,
-0.4412945509,
-0.2699260414,
0.2868211865,
0.3948797882,
1.4230448008,
-0.1540374607,
0.6642657518,
-0.1253697872,
0.300673008,
0.4651480019,
-0.5601617098,
0.5081518888,
-0.4613315761,
-0.2133671343,
0.4974243641,
0.3968183696,
-0.0789577886,
-0.376029551,
-1.0145933628,
-0.1772439778,
0.0570873246,
0.6812298894,
-0.5344831347,
-0.0726653188,
0.3315942287,
0.2752041519,
0.0032977641,
-0.9353393316,
-0.4439247549,
-0.4143096805,
0.1342203021,
0.2570472658,
-0.2513913214,
-0.5832613707,
-0.0747957379,
-0.0262285341,
0.269048214,
0.2910286784,
0.2844924629,
-0.0152112013,
-0.4639981389,
0.1747062802,
0.6467199326,
0.8240886927,
-0.3584095538,
0.463683635,
-0.0483161509,
-0.2894344032,
0.3353908956,
0.0543138459,
-0.077016823,
-0.3044700921,
0.5886682272,
0.1446791738,
-0.1356789172,
0.1376704872,
0.4396867454,
0.4054984748,
-0.353684634,
0.0574360862,
0.3803482056,
-0.2008758634,
0.2162796557,
0.0578394495,
0.0646909103,
0.3043758869,
-0.4664823711,
0.357272625,
0.1365440935,
-0.5006287694,
-0.5478901267,
0.5681503415,
0.2626124918,
-0.3519444168,
1.0373655558,
-0.4352200925,
-0.3531171083,
0.5965117812,
0.7922281027,
0.7024789453,
-0.2177404314,
-0.0197148919,
0.3031263649,
0.1766103655,
0.060825143,
0.3042791188,
-0.2547404766,
-0.6734066606,
-0.0168183502,
-0.2142179906,
-0.2240605801,
-0.1722639948,
-0.5176775455,
0.197920382,
-1.1808972359,
0.0949406475,
0.0247061234,
-0.1219676286,
-0.5570886135,
0.2870210707,
-0.3218772709,
0.3493388295,
-0.974719286,
0.2983828187,
0.3199572563,
-0.5246374607,
-1.0201535225,
-0.2990017831,
0.2824549675,
-0.5254935026,
0.6307892203,
-0.1304640472,
-0.0985764191,
-0.4247404039,
-0.5206930041,
-0.9645119309,
1.0514527559,
0.0071754628,
-0.3712323606,
0.3166217208,
-0.0797653273,
0.4555671513,
-0.3781782389,
-0.1853822172,
0.2329491228,
0.4061648846,
0.1231313944,
-0.7723191381,
0.1213544011,
-0.1489562392,
-0.3591883481,
0.7289298177,
-1.0318104029,
1.1744132042,
-0.4774982631,
-0.507910192,
-0.0015710396,
1.3143061399,
0.1804256439,
0.2139299661,
0.9078272581,
1.0777384043,
0.850685358,
-0.2850986421,
0.8810101748,
-0.1459948123,
0.6014053822,
0.7451931834,
-0.0387061015,
0.4441661537,
0.0832327306,
-0.4958602786,
0.5969799161,
0.5720216036,
0.001961594,
0.6476842165,
-0.0000694006,
-0.2341092378,
-0.1630782932,
0.1595391631,
-0.7625454664,
0.3320784271,
0.1780232489,
-0.4150883257,
-0.365262866,
-0.5433158278,
0.2099280059,
-0.0258966666,
-0.3317593932,
0.3699229062,
0.3073636889,
-0.2349468321,
0.2546262741,
-0.3519617617,
0.2457628399,
-0.3895789683,
-0.0996113345,
-0.2266000956,
-0.0198380053,
-0.753367722,
-1.220214963,
0.3995220661,
-0.4892110229,
-0.1442560405,
0.1870176941,
0.9427551031,
-0.0674901828,
-0.3421958983,
-0.0258225184,
0.4874409139,
0.3898890316,
0.6271924973,
-0.428606838,
-0.1984710693,
0.0225209352,
-0.1939254999,
0.0220916104,
0.6678999662,
-0.0629263818,
0.6118485332,
0.5621133447,
0.0640087575,
0.0933066085,
0.0650007874,
0.9159981608,
-0.7083469033,
-0.790553093,
-0.6069531441,
0.0395131484,
0.0119957905,
-0.6554352045,
0.8232546449,
0.5700125694,
0.318739295,
0.1275150776,
0.5267910361,
-0.2500682175,
0.315330565,
-0.4594798386,
0.6266189218,
-0.2426919639,
-0.1059755459,
-0.5495468378,
-1.2489908934,
-0.2787510455,
0.7635166049,
-0.1953125149,
0.087665759,
1.0016359091,
0.3978974521,
-0.515247941,
0.0485689193,
0.0572430231,
0.1029796675,
0.3838074803,
0.396677047,
0.7529143095,
-0.0344664976,
0.6325769424,
-0.479116112,
-0.0640707314,
0.1398180276,
-0.4619941413,
-0.8873513341,
-0.5862596631,
-0.3393460512,
-0.7302117348,
-0.0703673884,
0.3452109993,
0.8982821107,
-0.766741395,
-0.2608349919,
-0.3462999165,
0.8524098992,
-0.4551337659,
-0.2237247378,
0.7445105314,
0.0642761737,
-0.3646101058,
0.1907302588,
0.3820071816,
0.6421393156,
-0.5278602242,
-0.3463299274,
0.2156784832,
-0.2261987329,
0.4764570892,
0.9231592417,
-0.485291332,
-0.393552959,
-0.4933748841,
-0.2090563029,
0.3317141533,
0.8680335283,
-0.1773284227,
0.4210405946,
0.9450032711,
-0.011739091,
0.4248182476,
0.0215927996,
0.3358699083,
-0.4523645341,
0.547098577,
-0.0594494119,
0.6256783605,
-0.1581820101,
-0.3486354053,
0.8456453681,
0.4930265844,
-0.4384484589,
-0.5525577068,
0.503246367,
-0.9231629372,
-0.0418014452,
0.8131213188,
-0.2294756323,
-0.2417872548,
-0.2084255815,
0.1875607371,
-0.2913586795,
-0.0308865383,
0.6822994351,
0.781280756,
-0.4101482034,
0.0264934655,
0.2416832894,
0.3070390522,
0.2234393954,
-0.7928494811,
-0.5055245757,
0.3794130087,
0.5899361968,
0.3153298497,
0.7362657785,
-0.4910037518,
0.4923709035,
0.2606871426,
-0.273792237,
-0.0586670898,
-0.5821028352,
-0.0531313084,
0.7227852941,
0.3242180943,
-0.2431263626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04889v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04889v1
|
Ethos and Pathos in Online Group Discussions: Corpora for Polarisation Issues in Social Media
| 2024-04-07T09:10:47 | 2024-04-07T09:10:47 |
Ewelina Gajewska, Katarzyna Budzynska, Barbara Konat, Marcin Koszowy, Konrad Kiljan, Maciej Uberna, He Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Growing polarisation in society caught the attention of the scientific
community as well as news media, which devote special issues to this
phenomenon. At the same time, digitalisation of social interactions requires to
revise concepts from social science regarding establishment of trust, which is
a key feature of all human interactions, and group polarisation, as well as new
computational tools to process large quantities of available data. Existing
methods seem insufficient to tackle the problem fully, thus, we propose to
approach the problem by investigating rhetorical strategies employed by
individuals in polarising discussions online. To this end, we develop
multi-topic and multi-platform corpora with manual annotation of appeals to
ethos and pathos, two modes of persuasion in Aristotelian rhetoric. It can be
employed for training language models to advance the study of communication
strategies online on a large scale. With the use of computational methods, our
corpora allows an investigation of recurring patterns in polarising exchanges
across topics of discussion and media platforms, and conduct both quantitative
and qualitative analyses of language structures leading to and engaged in
polarisation.
|
[
-0.7190352678,
-0.7830166221,
0.5554929972,
0.202448979,
-0.487577945,
0.5096775293,
-0.4153761566,
-0.3656378984,
0.829014957,
0.2915122509,
-0.3549762964,
-0.3957704306,
-1.0403206348,
0.247119233,
-0.1488979012,
1.0112551451,
-0.0058035576,
0.6075939536,
-0.0009328448,
-0.5701161623,
-0.0120746205,
-0.9167664051,
-0.9910413027,
-0.0464257039,
0.6652551889,
0.2973733246,
0.601936698,
0.1345776021,
0.3857150078,
0.3386603892,
-0.3450342715,
-0.1178821549,
-0.6943170428,
0.5124180317,
-0.2626226544,
-0.4676161408,
-0.1749265045,
0.302354753,
0.5534977317,
0.7413501143,
-0.1239134967,
0.1248366013,
-0.000934027,
0.6111133695,
-0.2861352265,
0.0177901331,
-0.6613271832,
0.1720912606,
-0.0726938844,
-0.7506768107,
-0.1956245005,
-0.7714203,
0.1151305065,
-0.8241794705,
0.1842245609,
0.2787561417,
0.3275765181,
-0.1800798476,
-0.3107370436,
-0.9030535221,
-0.8282150626,
0.7002892494,
-0.2549610436,
0.0950244218,
0.5244057178,
0.221629113,
0.0963620692,
-0.5229113698,
-0.4230324924,
0.1841268986,
0.2001972497,
-0.0469182916,
-0.2623573542,
-0.1042553633,
0.0547499135,
0.0659953579,
-0.1871433556,
-0.2869262993,
-0.8792437315,
-0.1938544065,
0.4340508282,
-0.1803413033,
0.2920989394,
-0.1077198014,
0.0424185432,
-0.0756741986,
-0.682900548,
-0.0207867995,
0.8107812405,
0.1943352669,
0.0183769912,
0.5773923397,
0.1028343961,
0.3013046086,
0.5237275362,
0.1192295551,
-0.1106062606,
-0.3128181696,
0.1788638383,
0.4234485626,
0.6329283714,
0.5174022317,
0.2751834691,
0.0592526942,
0.3634570837,
0.5097490549,
0.1556139141,
-0.7369942069,
-0.0639485121,
0.4020181298,
-0.4815458059,
-0.6016864777,
-0.0006913337,
-1.0122128725,
-0.6605854034,
-0.2054651976,
-0.0444211364,
-0.2018803954,
-0.404959321,
0.0545494594,
-0.409391284,
0.1289844811,
0.3411005437,
-0.6920418143,
0.3892805874,
0.8953186274,
0.8546699882,
0.1113627926,
-0.0857798606,
-0.4640594125,
0.1429498345,
-0.2617122531,
0.8231551051,
-0.7958604693,
-0.4339117706,
0.1943519861,
-0.1613306701,
0.0732776225,
-0.0800873637,
0.7204555869,
-0.6020750403,
0.9153974056,
-0.3845483959,
-0.4752525687,
0.0211135857,
0.3597257137,
-0.5019420385,
0.7103061676,
-0.3038651049,
-0.9777541161,
0.1246833503,
-0.6892505288,
-0.3549898267,
-0.2160692364,
-0.4369747937,
-0.1351083815,
0.0801622495,
-0.0981385708,
0.4528649151,
-0.3876661658,
0.4275509119,
-0.5477754474,
0.0058424505,
0.4008142054,
0.0794811174,
0.8815847039,
0.2707867324,
-0.7148766518,
0.4249484837,
-0.2799432576,
-0.2665353715,
0.1014830247,
0.1403053403,
-0.8521139622,
0.3187436759,
-0.0498788841,
0.2943584919,
0.0101677924,
-0.479088068,
0.0453897454,
-0.397025466,
1.0822149515,
0.8738583326,
0.0527981259,
0.4789803028,
-0.1700096726,
0.4066614211,
-0.0276657939,
0.5143580437,
0.370472014,
-0.8910972476,
-0.6853414774,
0.0263986159,
-0.1785814017,
0.2564947903,
-0.6461905241,
-0.0760668665,
-0.1968676299,
-0.3080660105,
-0.5881317854,
0.0873121619,
0.300812155,
0.0988258645,
0.1633756012,
-0.2648421228,
-0.4805334508,
-0.8165460229,
-0.1700456589,
-0.5325877666,
0.0435068198,
0.1861244291,
0.1533662528,
0.1826483309,
0.8547320366,
-0.3054021895,
-0.0363647304,
-0.3801742792,
0.7312101126,
-0.4040833414,
-0.1104826257,
0.3590624928,
-1.0698053837,
-0.7343156934,
-0.1338484883,
-0.5562468171,
-0.0649909154,
0.1712301373,
-0.003813253,
0.1138236746,
0.4731222987,
-0.4216639996,
-0.0599917173,
0.6266757846,
-0.5063517094,
0.1484067291,
0.2093029618,
0.6971535683,
-1.4196579456,
-0.1912036538,
0.1206744015,
-0.1595073044,
-0.7551192045,
0.0608026572,
-0.4186145067,
-0.2627974451,
-0.6673179865,
0.1944766492,
-0.4795823991,
0.1727871746,
-0.2367727607,
0.667530179,
0.0544429347,
0.2290482223,
0.2475595176,
0.5215926766,
0.7314479351,
-0.3703497946,
0.2121229172,
0.3894286156,
0.1708393991,
0.9170633554,
-0.6324746609,
0.3255833685,
-0.360496968,
0.3709182441,
-0.8871644735,
-0.1827007681,
0.6641365886,
-0.5143422484,
0.0002316271,
-0.298363328,
-0.0374407694,
-0.1378783882,
-0.8552441001,
0.5552541614,
0.1459220201,
-0.1356767863,
0.6020893455,
0.9366180301,
-0.6638085842,
-0.4413107336,
-0.1843044609,
0.3580438197,
-0.7050880194,
-0.7868099213,
0.2348894328,
-0.0738755688,
-0.8444013,
-0.2608817816,
0.337810725,
0.0308390241,
-0.1669912487,
0.2290620357,
0.1779663116,
0.0370578468,
-0.0265962873,
0.1204567105,
0.0622555651,
0.3544532955,
-0.1902733594,
0.8025403619,
-0.4248136878,
-0.1340515614,
-0.3018133342,
0.7084872723,
0.6165190935,
0.0720165446,
0.9725356698,
0.3011579812,
-0.2453470826,
-0.0570900477,
-0.697856009,
-0.3710403144,
-0.4396362305,
-0.0396507606,
-0.0520899929,
-0.9938445687,
0.6149433851,
-0.3010652363,
-0.2146306932,
0.4930265844,
0.516592145,
-0.2284720242,
0.7044383883,
0.5909965634,
-0.0868182257,
0.1027476341,
0.008877892,
0.3738586605,
-0.5180578232,
-0.1537767202,
-0.6090975404,
-0.075533852,
-0.6202067733,
-0.5157439709,
0.3514752984,
-0.0286232978,
0.20930475,
0.3783684075,
-0.7418516874,
0.1585782021,
0.0467010215,
0.0248717871,
0.430536896,
0.1410862654,
0.1289218217,
-0.2214955688,
-0.6396702528,
-0.7648243308,
1.0577555895,
0.2962356508,
0.371694833,
0.1811119467,
0.4077076018,
0.4880696535,
0.6294693947,
-0.7652904987,
0.7078030109,
0.4686300755,
-0.8110492229,
-0.239406243,
-0.4567786753,
-0.8754794598,
0.0840802118,
-0.277772963,
-0.5225483179,
0.3068310022,
0.0871739909,
-0.1664979607,
0.4705945551,
-0.1800502986,
0.7851746082,
-0.2407152653,
-0.4637331367,
-0.5469812155,
-0.8881677389,
0.065996252,
0.0565168187,
0.6189383864,
0.11054831,
0.0937275887,
1.0822675228,
0.0291530434,
1.0443811417,
0.1314084083,
-0.1334678978,
0.5014871359,
-0.237147063,
0.365771085,
-0.0772358105,
0.0819043219,
0.4140733182,
0.204797104,
-0.1061556414,
-0.2059794068,
0.7078464031,
-0.8666748405,
-0.5407959223,
-0.5976105928,
-0.1071853638,
-0.1634693444,
-0.2222361267,
0.3224291801,
0.2714102864,
-0.7383266091,
0.170047164,
0.9474266171,
-0.0817469358,
0.2101735771,
0.1601497531,
-0.1671721637,
-0.8331682086,
0.9306508899,
-0.1509227455,
0.5016610622,
0.0284272712,
0.3868988156,
-0.1142646819,
-0.1247600541,
-0.3219697177,
0.0832097232,
-0.9612957239,
0.2787200511,
-0.6364927292,
0.2205979973,
-0.5611818433,
-0.3716632724,
-0.3240753114,
-0.7999839783,
-0.1386145651,
0.0053438093,
0.3528909683,
0.9049808979,
-0.0224816538,
0.3029889762,
-0.2732287347,
0.0964754894,
0.1226132214,
0.0347354226,
-0.2854630649,
-0.1667030603,
0.1863693148,
-0.0753115118,
-0.4818762243,
-1.3848955631,
0.0857786983,
0.0077123446,
0.3175921738,
0.6189621687,
0.0071491594,
0.127972737,
-0.4388455153,
0.6264986396,
0.4128715694,
-0.7421898842,
0.5631250143,
-0.7087649703,
-0.5320929289,
0.7480603456,
1.0787069798,
-0.7278485298,
-0.7286917567,
-0.7874380946,
-0.7693113089,
0.3166315854,
0.3967451155,
-0.1229498014,
-0.1070092991,
0.0983611122,
0.2961953878,
0.5341039896,
-0.8121307492,
-0.3978238702,
-0.3189736009,
-0.0184929036,
0.0247016922,
-0.2223190069,
-0.9532958865,
-0.2979749441,
0.6950831413,
-0.0003816241,
0.2507948875,
0.1841422766,
0.1855596304,
-0.4325222671,
0.542956233,
0.6201037765,
0.8813329935,
-0.1077671647,
0.2728875279,
-0.1625662148,
-0.484342128,
0.1840873361,
0.0114481514,
-0.3784326613,
0.1086522564,
-0.1645379215,
0.5229697824,
0.2405212522,
-0.0802679732,
0.4525648355,
-0.2119726241,
-0.3355482221,
-0.5009610057,
-0.5098605752,
0.3305616081,
0.0252561048,
0.4575338066,
0.1173890233,
0.05184073,
-1.1520298719,
-0.0588887483,
0.5843942761,
-0.3347725868,
-0.3825266361,
0.6023210287,
0.4421409369,
-0.5602494478,
-0.0571416505,
-0.3033684194,
-0.8925722837,
0.3546239436,
0.1808871925,
0.8981462717,
-0.1848676652,
0.7604657412,
0.1654237807,
0.4043406844,
-0.0670825019,
0.1586406529,
-0.0689166859,
-0.5775194168,
-0.1194187477,
-0.456987679,
-0.9039205313,
-0.1615906656,
-0.4290049672,
0.2419937551,
-0.5931789279,
-0.5131565928,
0.1136200428,
-0.1507654786,
-0.173960641,
-0.3247337639,
0.2707864642,
0.2207530141,
-1.0065177679,
0.4321779311,
0.7547730207,
-0.318113327,
-0.3383446038,
0.0021258369,
0.1799067259,
-0.191833064,
0.5569937229,
0.0589099601,
-0.4640582204,
-0.145251736,
-0.5862094164,
-0.6066377759,
0.7590684891,
0.2260230631,
-0.2147146016,
0.2078933567,
0.5863720775,
0.5243605375,
-0.4233601391,
0.3412639499,
-0.0787395164,
0.6181662083,
0.0812282562,
-0.7314614654,
0.2404489517,
-0.3657317758,
-0.4071551859,
0.0202640127,
-0.8981077671,
0.7336775661,
0.2646850348,
-0.2390650064,
-0.3926214278,
0.5698769689,
0.09051238,
0.5351963639,
0.4194069505,
0.1732103378,
0.6108949184,
-0.0449760705,
0.7079144716,
-0.8195815086,
0.1980543137,
0.680593133,
-0.4373256564,
0.6837117672,
0.775929749,
0.013308499,
0.4973497689,
0.5590805411,
0.422750473,
0.3838888407,
0.2978834808,
-0.4340431988,
-0.0652158633,
-0.0826766714,
-0.4419498146,
0.0755826607,
0.4231956005,
-0.2429931164,
0.0244206823,
0.2107311338,
0.1061699465,
0.3463840187,
-0.4169268608,
0.588552773,
0.2026280165,
-0.8431873918,
0.0266935695,
0.2729470432,
0.7040407062,
-0.6348031163,
0.1576357931,
0.0209314767,
-0.1369773746,
-0.0484852828,
-0.4891045392,
0.4475304484,
-0.1381065398,
0.2360086888,
-0.4544929862,
0.8851955533,
-0.2279177308,
-0.5279690623,
0.4837495685,
0.4798876643,
0.1957057565,
-0.0232718438,
-0.6051328182,
0.270785898,
-0.3969548643,
-0.2127129734,
0.4071857929,
0.350981921,
-0.0782336146,
0.6013899446,
0.5266435742,
0.1187046543,
0.0968326479,
0.2437349409,
1.1937191486,
-0.3091907501,
-0.480584681,
-0.7238882184,
0.1431443095,
-0.529830873,
-0.5439704657,
0.9740271568,
0.4771935046,
0.7449598908,
0.1540478617,
0.6308447123,
-0.333252281,
0.1767863929,
-0.2278745025,
0.8196820021,
-0.2107170969,
0.1324588954,
-0.5081794858,
-0.8622041345,
0.0404246151,
0.7336175442,
-0.6835796833,
-0.3195004165,
0.9170262218,
0.5095934868,
-0.1198563948,
0.7629851699,
-0.2266046703,
0.3602985144,
0.1406836659,
0.1743260771,
1.0140707493,
-0.1844560802,
0.5802199244,
-0.2497584224,
-0.4663335681,
0.0222147983,
-0.7369424105,
-1.2363221645,
-0.7418270707,
-0.4881499708,
-0.5811033845,
0.4010576606,
1.0128105879,
0.2024653554,
-0.8298422694,
-0.4989962876,
-0.1505997032,
0.0712003931,
-0.0055805813,
-0.1908948272,
0.1245704666,
0.0771451741,
-0.4516609907,
0.2733870447,
0.4474325776,
-0.4948561192,
-0.8628486991,
-0.0609313063,
-0.3714060187,
0.3045358658,
0.7441328168,
0.4051383138,
-0.4821951389,
-0.2298636287,
0.0727824569,
0.033298973,
0.2910304666,
1.1295751333,
-0.2100653797,
0.1005526707,
0.4340197444,
0.2508944869,
0.4845684767,
0.1098844931,
0.5631108284,
-0.2183045149,
0.2198165804,
0.5418723822,
0.1939110309,
0.6592693329,
-0.286368072,
0.3165501654,
0.4987497926,
-0.4204286933,
-0.6525745392,
0.0690668672,
-1.0104987621,
-0.2353296876,
1.2464592457,
0.1553149521,
-0.1707072258,
-0.4398281276,
-0.2768634856,
0.2492789328,
-0.4284504652,
1.1953115463,
0.9074593186,
0.0906068161,
0.1359974444,
-0.5332930684,
0.5899887681,
0.4466070235,
-0.7956417799,
-0.0635600165,
0.4538237453,
0.2956502438,
0.5945830941,
0.9125826955,
-0.1397381723,
-0.1562043726,
-0.1938234717,
-0.1743264347,
0.2919071615,
-0.4292125702,
0.0724918172,
0.7150597572,
-0.2447574735,
0.4153912067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04850v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04850v1
|
Lucky 52: How Many Languages Are Needed to Instruction Fine-Tune Large Language Models?
| 2024-04-07T07:44:33 | 2024-04-07T07:44:33 |
Shaoxiong Ji, Pinzhen Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning large language models for multilingual downstream tasks requires
a diverse set of languages to capture the nuances and structures of different
linguistic contexts effectively. While the specific number varies depending on
the desired scope and target languages, we argue that the number of languages,
language exposure, and similarity that incorporate the selection of languages
for fine-tuning are some important aspects to examine. By fine-tuning large
multilingual models on 1 to 52 languages, this paper answers one question: How
many languages are needed in instruction fine-tuning for multilingual tasks? We
investigate how multilingual instruction fine-tuned models behave on
multilingual benchmarks with an increasing number of languages and discuss our
findings from the perspective of language exposure and similarity.
|
[
-0.5131989121,
-0.2971512079,
0.2750304043,
0.274480015,
-0.0817026794,
-0.0833623409,
-0.5136728883,
-0.5050546527,
-0.3675411046,
0.5809329748,
-0.797614634,
-0.2936024368,
-0.5274973512,
0.2260223478,
-0.0174709801,
1.2098995447,
0.1459658295,
0.2625566721,
0.1432700902,
-0.1164240167,
-0.6590015292,
-0.2550160885,
-0.4203643799,
-0.0220024269,
0.4121524394,
0.9584769607,
0.7097256184,
0.6172856688,
0.7179794908,
0.3705414534,
0.2464217246,
0.3502363265,
-0.5626517534,
-0.1578792185,
-0.3743109703,
-0.9918760061,
-0.3996944427,
-0.1071498543,
0.7429142594,
0.8746756911,
0.1848390847,
0.5434997082,
0.0560934991,
0.714174509,
-0.8326871991,
0.1903790385,
-0.4567204416,
0.0227129422,
-0.3810095191,
-0.0897065029,
-0.3800187409,
-0.3599489331,
0.0092333928,
-0.6783795953,
0.2624696791,
-0.2102136165,
0.3874379098,
0.2816162407,
-0.4706244469,
-0.1916438937,
-0.5099056363,
1.2187074423,
-0.6751480699,
0.3716197908,
0.6025589108,
0.25987342,
0.1026973277,
-0.3232564032,
-0.2621918619,
0.0689979941,
0.2373130918,
-0.1333315372,
0.3119845092,
-0.0240480546,
0.2541487515,
0.3626628518,
-0.3055069745,
0.4773212373,
-0.4446771443,
-0.0703721493,
0.761808753,
0.3688721657,
0.2317087352,
0.2376295477,
0.0802094266,
-0.3625543416,
-0.6038081646,
-0.058509212,
0.7187598348,
0.4831828773,
-0.4716535509,
0.345769912,
-0.4130948782,
1.0368754864,
-0.0424521901,
-0.3069152832,
-0.0536719598,
-0.672624588,
-0.174338147,
0.0808050483,
0.6114298105,
0.2927157581,
0.8618478179,
-0.2155754566,
0.0529264472,
-0.2402723581,
0.2305345237,
-0.7888385653,
-0.07018058,
0.0996289998,
-0.2191139609,
-0.0058113257,
0.0760686994,
-0.6729125381,
-0.1004977226,
-0.3605213463,
0.1797248721,
-0.5807238817,
-0.1413423866,
0.4244638383,
-0.2599079311,
0.3044831455,
0.2256399691,
-1.2678157091,
0.1806419492,
1.0184862614,
0.2192888409,
0.0353952982,
-0.9550768733,
-0.5812313557,
-0.0250363518,
-0.6477578878,
0.5836822987,
-0.9106885791,
-0.1033153385,
0.109503597,
0.4965067208,
-0.1795054525,
-0.4199741483,
0.4676538408,
-0.4435712695,
0.0242310893,
-0.5382506847,
-0.6175885201,
-0.4768932164,
0.0863121226,
-0.7102612853,
0.534511745,
-0.0341207981,
-0.3975765407,
0.3631091118,
-0.4142210484,
-0.6967586875,
0.1434698105,
0.2107770592,
-0.0559835881,
0.4940452278,
-0.1904085129,
0.5622882247,
-0.2249389738,
0.0221518632,
-0.3289389312,
-0.6043125391,
0.2560280263,
-0.7180540562,
0.8193631768,
0.3282566369,
-0.3746539056,
-0.152775228,
-0.7726049423,
0.35939008,
-0.3259949982,
-0.6139259338,
-0.4417841136,
-0.0988831818,
0.0324500874,
0.2143040746,
0.4801981151,
-0.2898259461,
0.193092823,
-0.4314091206,
0.2013001293,
0.5384001136,
-0.2794876695,
0.4676541686,
-0.1988045573,
0.6541098952,
0.0668397918,
0.031646423,
-0.4764048159,
-0.448159337,
-0.7648575306,
-0.0837361738,
0.4807130396,
0.5873196721,
-0.4347469211,
0.107150875,
-0.1958250701,
-0.4150655568,
-0.9003344774,
0.4648027122,
0.8728090525,
-0.4140030444,
0.1680167466,
-0.3966694772,
-0.3027521074,
-0.9014658928,
-0.3974514902,
0.4781710505,
0.2848612666,
0.1815610528,
0.3019900024,
0.0372194387,
0.2775755823,
-0.4746940732,
-0.193682164,
-0.111343123,
0.088722989,
0.1783457994,
0.3846922517,
0.8322839737,
-0.7777632475,
-0.8067276478,
0.3451413214,
-0.5883603096,
0.3775040507,
0.0179621149,
-0.0699813962,
0.3795877099,
0.3582894206,
-0.5276968479,
-0.043312829,
0.6390932798,
-0.0340422578,
0.3222566247,
-0.5291458964,
0.312052995,
-0.9228040576,
-0.0975654051,
0.0207322743,
-0.0355303846,
-0.5346799493,
0.63843894,
0.2393703759,
-0.1491360962,
-0.5784876943,
0.4722796679,
-0.8155232072,
0.0350788608,
-0.3904142082,
-0.1167294905,
-0.0887689814,
0.3627542853,
-0.1878223717,
0.5804358721,
0.8435681462,
-0.6329459548,
0.3526608348,
-0.0872438625,
-0.5864868164,
0.4515291452,
-0.2111077011,
0.1620331109,
0.0328634828,
-0.0193788093,
-0.7315266132,
-0.5163303614,
-0.1976973414,
-0.0025436315,
0.6451893449,
0.0012983133,
-0.3911497891,
-0.2176414281,
-0.3096960187,
0.4164699614,
0.1237496808,
-0.2795701027,
0.1220483184,
0.3405585289,
-0.1460019946,
-0.9235175252,
-0.6089191437,
-0.0280026421,
-0.2148589343,
-0.2812852263,
0.1269400865,
-0.2810444236,
-0.2306006551,
-0.1161611527,
-0.0163084846,
-0.2093337625,
0.2340395302,
0.2608358264,
-0.1320842355,
-0.3702337146,
0.1523437649,
0.1716198623,
-0.0959864482,
0.0034175427,
-0.19488886,
0.4778088927,
-0.3037627637,
-0.4407886863,
-0.2249995619,
0.8246623278,
0.756503582,
-0.6022855043,
0.8349105716,
0.6744176149,
-0.3253515363,
-0.2982269228,
-0.4029927552,
-0.1308620572,
-0.4826374054,
0.7369818091,
-0.7102262974,
-0.800480783,
0.4231871665,
0.1944432855,
0.0724238306,
0.4563225806,
0.855509758,
0.2841417193,
1.0155563354,
0.8947454095,
-0.3551436663,
0.3894738555,
0.038969405,
0.2386332005,
-0.1049974114,
-0.0152620086,
-0.6962631345,
-0.3153644204,
-0.9994228482,
-0.4338203669,
0.0081432723,
0.0268675555,
-0.1818911582,
0.2711643577,
-0.3862050474,
1.001532197,
0.8894523978,
0.0798885971,
0.1519831419,
0.020514274,
-0.0639276356,
-0.0236893035,
-0.7401311398,
-0.2422222346,
0.9373754859,
0.1253809035,
0.886954248,
0.3771173954,
0.6459053755,
-0.2818611562,
-0.0382944271,
-0.7009456754,
0.4601269662,
-0.8332805037,
-1.0183815956,
-0.3649614453,
-0.1956461221,
-0.6703773737,
-0.2098304629,
0.0170987956,
-0.420753032,
0.1196386814,
0.0731652528,
-0.5536970496,
-0.1166876182,
-1.0851075649,
1.1290869713,
-0.3584079742,
-0.3624669313,
-0.74494946,
-0.8306709528,
0.4347606301,
-0.2898963094,
0.2769126296,
0.0350523405,
0.3533373475,
0.4407027066,
0.1089630798,
1.1444474459,
0.1542100012,
-0.2913118303,
0.1138384417,
0.007857685,
0.4064762592,
-0.1782844812,
-0.0945113525,
0.008009064,
0.1999945045,
-0.3692369759,
-0.1752267927,
1.044046402,
-0.8639985323,
-0.5412985682,
-0.1277799308,
-0.8579729795,
-0.1241511256,
0.3370075226,
0.3150471151,
0.5208348632,
0.0355281942,
0.2120359242,
0.7150187492,
-0.5016503334,
0.6707429886,
0.7356545329,
0.1585436612,
0.1611830145,
1.3830013275,
0.3164435923,
0.4783149064,
0.626499176,
-0.1236125231,
0.0082126986,
-0.2463943362,
-0.4324690104,
0.4322717488,
-0.8377228975,
-0.2436048687,
-0.5144841671,
-0.0690402165,
-0.335370481,
0.0505840592,
-0.5989918709,
-0.414398551,
-0.4258856177,
0.1813488752,
0.4126051366,
0.5953261852,
-0.1285163313,
0.0779010132,
-1.1741485596,
0.4365133643,
0.5291631818,
0.6393217444,
-0.0588577539,
-0.6094692349,
-0.7480322719,
0.353749156,
-0.30927068,
-0.6926611066,
0.1155729815,
0.8300486803,
0.679120481,
0.3648830056,
0.0333323032,
0.8144699335,
-1.0305504799,
0.4224781394,
-0.1246558651,
-0.8139386773,
0.2439925522,
-0.3529914021,
0.4716182947,
0.614988327,
0.8117278218,
-0.4392642081,
-0.4069590867,
-0.446860224,
-0.4709623754,
0.8199436069,
-0.6135950685,
0.5166457891,
-0.055298008,
-0.0162373111,
0.2907488942,
0.1507673711,
-0.3832223117,
-0.2178058028,
-0.0744268894,
-0.2572196722,
-0.1822311878,
-0.2416153252,
-0.2808725834,
-0.0126119452,
0.3275052011,
-0.3517464995,
0.130469501,
-0.6337270737,
0.0026261031,
-0.3417128026,
0.5109348893,
0.960549593,
0.7795411944,
-0.1040442213,
0.0371732377,
0.2324748337,
-0.4239493012,
-0.1091104969,
0.0844117329,
0.3925072551,
-0.2637640834,
0.3790506124,
1.0217494965,
0.5608943105,
-0.6863849759,
0.1611482948,
0.0977562591,
0.1792954057,
0.1251821965,
0.6054193377,
0.3300226629,
0.1842054725,
0.1704675853,
0.0294130258,
0.1215983257,
-0.740470767,
0.0951173306,
0.5582568049,
-0.4291324019,
-0.4970541596,
0.4194790423,
0.1012797281,
-0.4129932225,
0.6065664887,
-0.2334867567,
-0.4062021077,
0.7559264898,
0.4822569191,
0.569483459,
-0.5849018693,
0.1550388038,
0.4140964448,
0.3116899729,
-0.4473072588,
0.1820943207,
0.1602662355,
-0.6484496593,
-0.8517079353,
-0.7329932451,
-0.6198676229,
-0.2213080525,
-0.7433191538,
0.3751132786,
0.1269639879,
0.098183088,
0.3584756851,
0.0230410993,
-0.9428573847,
0.3186052442,
0.444178015,
0.8926307559,
-1.033110857,
1.0229953527,
0.778619349,
0.0050968053,
-1.0706301928,
-0.3301044405,
0.0055210395,
-0.74103266,
0.5262622833,
0.273154676,
0.0551908836,
0.2134048343,
-0.4087911248,
-0.5492215753,
0.3712819517,
0.7245154977,
-0.8308096528,
0.0523490608,
0.213206321,
0.5307919383,
-0.3356088996,
0.1000860333,
0.6009503007,
0.3563411534,
-0.3376954794,
-1.2707577944,
-0.1801421046,
-0.1378444135,
-0.26858145,
0.2350264341,
-0.7430734634,
0.845587194,
-0.5900787711,
0.0929338261,
-0.0975773185,
0.1608476043,
0.3448856175,
0.052684322,
0.0380926207,
0.376170814,
0.4761572778,
0.1073014066,
1.3131655455,
-0.5682834387,
0.3615963757,
1.0757555962,
-0.0960967392,
0.8316153884,
0.2152158767,
-0.294380337,
0.0043658703,
0.7964214087,
0.1140883863,
0.687402606,
-0.0189773049,
-0.206319645,
-0.4627527595,
-0.1692873091,
-0.5050738454,
0.6794996262,
0.3332955539,
-0.1299629956,
-0.1737853885,
0.1584204435,
0.0431575924,
-0.1840831339,
-0.3290533423,
0.4970138967,
0.1953436285,
-1.1656112671,
0.5716754794,
0.1120924503,
0.467220366,
-0.512586236,
-0.1157426238,
-0.4225471914,
0.4924558401,
-0.0651294217,
-0.850479424,
0.1419865936,
-0.0738186911,
-0.3374001384,
-0.1796536744,
0.3904574215,
-0.6512046456,
-0.7420476675,
0.1352456957,
0.334757477,
0.3207824826,
0.0016378588,
-0.4654025137,
0.0908346772,
0.1416592598,
-0.2063359618,
0.6358869076,
1.0966402292,
-0.0659798756,
0.5995393991,
0.4666776955,
0.0031187197,
0.3975452781,
0.1889092773,
0.6577845216,
-0.5836436749,
-0.4993235469,
-0.9264763594,
0.6175829768,
0.2884567678,
-0.7175764441,
0.9651342034,
0.4037055671,
0.9319757819,
-0.4762285352,
0.5912227035,
0.0716329962,
0.3532551825,
-0.3842999637,
0.5101816058,
-0.7319446802,
0.0265046582,
-0.2286150753,
-0.9964877963,
-0.2685193419,
0.5261546373,
-0.1393685192,
0.0694834739,
0.5371779203,
0.7263615131,
-0.2886133194,
-0.0234612245,
0.3399682939,
-0.0856286809,
-0.1946231276,
0.8066272736,
0.5598261952,
-0.4297799468,
0.4167833924,
-0.1498486549,
-0.0968626589,
-0.2405327559,
-0.862437427,
-0.5968431234,
-0.4211693108,
-0.4282065928,
0.1761158705,
-0.0290163346,
0.5636050701,
0.7478071451,
-1.0208966732,
-0.4035284221,
0.2343408912,
0.2486370057,
-0.4783318043,
-0.1540228873,
0.0437444635,
-0.6789264679,
-1.0904210806,
0.3287142217,
0.2607627213,
-0.1966081709,
-0.254680723,
0.0461678617,
-0.1348699331,
-0.1833358556,
0.418790549,
0.3689386547,
-0.4969969094,
-0.3273207843,
0.3374886513,
-0.3651417792,
-0.2765258253,
0.6242461801,
-0.2433031946,
0.4888322353,
0.3950760663,
0.6371075511,
0.4548978209,
-0.3310075104,
0.7143414617,
-0.9489837289,
0.4289174378,
-0.1613277048,
0.0186536927,
0.304592967,
-0.151092276,
0.4658700526,
-0.1915097237,
-0.7196907401,
-0.9294731617,
0.1242855266,
-0.8186240196,
-0.4065241218,
1.0501208305,
-0.2122751325,
0.0743101239,
-0.0740355551,
0.0341101922,
0.1172493473,
0.1600566208,
0.526817739,
1.1107450724,
0.2442625165,
-0.499891609,
-0.8751429319,
0.4459636509,
0.4555590153,
-0.6650599837,
0.0945040211,
0.2681897879,
0.3002183139,
0.2993596196,
0.2210029513,
0.3202855885,
0.5152068734,
0.172993809,
0.0071292007,
0.3583433628,
-0.664657414,
-0.2813200057,
0.1671176404,
0.3021497428,
-0.2629318833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04846v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04846v1
|
F-MALLOC: Feed-forward Memory Allocation for Continual Learning in Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-04-07T07:39:45 | 2024-04-07T07:39:45 |
Junhong Wu, Yuchen Liu, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the evolving landscape of Neural Machine Translation (NMT), the
pretrain-then-finetune paradigm has yielded impressive results. However, the
persistent challenge of Catastrophic Forgetting (CF) remains a hurdle. While
previous work has introduced Continual Learning (CL) methods to address CF,
these approaches grapple with the delicate balance between avoiding forgetting
and maintaining system extensibility. To address this, we propose a CL method,
named $\textbf{F-MALLOC}$ ($\textbf{F}$eed-forward $\textbf{M}$emory
$\textbf{ALLOC}ation)$. F-MALLOC is inspired by recent insights highlighting
that feed-forward layers emulate neural memories and encapsulate crucial
translation knowledge. It decomposes feed-forward layers into discrete memory
cells and allocates these memories to different tasks. By learning to allocate
and safeguard these memories, our method effectively alleviates CF while
ensuring robust extendability. Besides, we propose a comprehensive assessment
protocol for multi-stage CL of NMT systems. Experiments conducted following
this new protocol showcase the superior performance of F-MALLOC, evidenced by
higher BLEU scores and almost zero forgetting.
|
[
0.1182201058,
-0.5950983763,
0.5368781686,
0.4740980864,
-0.2053331435,
0.0837796405,
-0.3390408754,
-0.1652648896,
0.1652826667,
0.3020579219,
-0.5584517717,
-0.2635393143,
-0.5143756866,
-0.0023854901,
-0.3299415708,
1.0391218662,
-0.3505062163,
0.0262568127,
-0.1898336112,
-0.2795805633,
-0.7570906281,
-0.377638787,
-0.7224047184,
-0.2522366643,
0.8577184677,
0.4781801701,
0.4486058056,
0.6551269293,
0.4189174771,
0.3602538407,
0.0127398996,
0.2643507719,
-0.6369805336,
0.3240268826,
-0.2399568856,
-0.3390511274,
-0.4277582765,
-0.2208686471,
1.0251803398,
0.6837211847,
-0.2810210586,
-0.0759647787,
-0.1194228679,
0.6213839054,
-0.6326898336,
-0.2245736718,
-0.9853470922,
0.2989675403,
-0.0306598265,
-0.2009884268,
-0.6313452721,
-0.1756738871,
0.1823616922,
-0.53194803,
-0.1548721194,
0.1898412704,
0.5254563093,
0.2198529989,
0.0206227396,
-0.333624661,
-0.7514056563,
0.8753177524,
-0.3195170164,
0.3777917922,
0.2519285977,
0.2336238325,
-0.0180242229,
-0.7348899245,
-0.3028348982,
-0.4768747389,
0.3405425847,
0.1519067734,
0.078474462,
-0.0702048168,
-0.023662651,
0.3893897235,
-0.5910601616,
-0.1083142906,
-0.4409551919,
-0.2821097374,
0.1746112853,
0.0729654506,
0.1476322412,
0.4792913496,
-0.8270907402,
0.146099627,
-0.5749465227,
-0.6116166115,
-0.2567905486,
0.0890623331,
0.3075684905,
0.0786627904,
-0.0183258262,
0.3001984954,
-0.0798337311,
0.2147009522,
0.3521068394,
-0.1539876908,
-0.3840052187,
0.0872051194,
0.6471968293,
0.0979499072,
0.2291160822,
-0.7917667031,
-0.5398691893,
-0.4140755236,
0.7556419969,
-0.6610351205,
-0.0927024335,
0.0888302028,
-0.2580207884,
-0.1411115378,
-0.1043681949,
-0.5596422553,
0.0616018772,
0.0989043862,
0.7215084434,
-0.6480910182,
-0.1485994756,
-0.2726650238,
0.2661504149,
-0.0414573327,
0.1770277023,
-0.9680085778,
0.2466752678,
0.4623014331,
1.2491059303,
-0.4714852571,
-0.9155746698,
-0.6006948948,
0.3161525726,
-0.2539441288,
0.6770597696,
-0.153319478,
-0.3944356143,
-0.1703923792,
-0.0715336129,
-0.4789262712,
-0.7775096893,
0.5443504453,
-0.3635545075,
-0.1105244309,
-0.2595125735,
-0.2162158191,
-0.2326069623,
0.3561707139,
-0.4244102836,
0.7081161737,
0.3916171193,
-0.1630768776,
0.1039948687,
-0.4913893342,
-0.424985677,
-0.2491189688,
0.1790447086,
-0.4495053887,
0.3503783047,
-0.1024539843,
0.3708230257,
-0.1788941324,
0.4131224155,
-0.2291056365,
-0.3969950378,
0.4054550827,
-0.4959766865,
0.2342483103,
0.3902639151,
-0.399622798,
0.3691200316,
-0.5007501841,
-0.0094614187,
0.1569008827,
-0.1512879878,
-0.1224469319,
-0.0660219043,
-0.1280564368,
0.3551183343,
0.138411209,
-0.3842150867,
0.1118335053,
-0.4718385637,
0.6867337227,
0.8737815619,
-0.1606085151,
0.7239829302,
-0.5691848993,
0.2013397217,
0.3854465187,
0.4129128158,
-0.4003399014,
-0.2038780302,
-0.7729762197,
0.0883197114,
0.0798864141,
0.6235454679,
-0.4358635843,
0.0869587734,
-0.2178580314,
-0.404407233,
-0.1517196596,
0.1775321662,
0.5314435363,
0.5718153715,
0.775693059,
-0.3283932507,
-0.3387458026,
-0.6228789091,
0.1858823448,
0.02452798,
0.1855821013,
0.1743906736,
0.4697468281,
-0.3392343223,
0.0749310032,
-0.2487532049,
-0.4874200225,
0.1300164163,
-0.0205638371,
-0.0182946995,
0.9133663177,
0.5402174592,
-0.4670084119,
-0.0568785928,
-0.0207208283,
-0.5549499989,
0.1586846709,
-0.7256876826,
-0.543738842,
0.2619618773,
0.3733894825,
-0.7953659296,
0.1317370534,
0.2931871116,
-0.0662188977,
0.7430410981,
-0.2282775342,
0.007285621,
-0.7132459283,
0.3148245215,
-0.5718244314,
-0.0912681744,
-0.4668046534,
0.0336336493,
0.0873995349,
0.1439124048,
-0.5279116035,
0.5310546756,
-0.367867291,
-0.0226916987,
-0.2894973755,
0.2979324162,
-0.0458468832,
0.5829027891,
-0.1841987222,
0.5863439441,
0.3299817145,
-0.5691285133,
-0.0021846592,
0.1026292741,
0.2189209908,
0.4545910358,
-0.1680019349,
0.3299833834,
0.2568473816,
0.127487123,
-0.7797703147,
0.4083953798,
0.4926862121,
-0.4796850681,
0.414588362,
0.3510745466,
-0.2865280509,
-0.3653928638,
-0.063552998,
0.4142381549,
0.0980284214,
-0.3274049759,
0.55458498,
0.101133287,
-0.012586588,
-0.7087147832,
-0.8833739161,
0.0230542067,
-0.0188079327,
-0.3536627293,
0.5438293219,
-0.2649582028,
0.0918586478,
-0.0623849966,
-0.5963377953,
-0.2630158663,
0.276237011,
0.2298012525,
0.131767869,
-0.5679608583,
0.1492355317,
0.2681299746,
-0.2693565786,
0.0634673312,
-0.9651908875,
0.5351279974,
-0.3693515658,
-0.1642216593,
-0.1897590905,
0.4739715457,
0.6262151003,
-0.1457358301,
0.6436489224,
0.7189922333,
-0.4474887848,
-0.2624842525,
-0.5015894175,
-0.1663442254,
-0.4606907666,
0.3646681607,
-0.1835920215,
-0.780311048,
0.581319809,
-0.2449022681,
0.1382503062,
0.5282752514,
0.5328772068,
-0.2318926752,
0.4063419402,
0.5029111505,
-0.1178958118,
0.4262482524,
-0.2849549949,
-0.1182955727,
-0.811342001,
-0.2685750425,
-0.1727713943,
-0.7038220167,
0.1270106882,
-0.561311841,
-0.2780570388,
0.4366181791,
-0.3685514927,
0.1853111833,
-0.5136489272,
0.4449642897,
0.4089500308,
-0.0325114317,
0.1209610626,
-0.2554597259,
-0.599473834,
0.1439544261,
-0.5997462273,
-0.119203873,
0.9608932734,
0.2562396526,
0.2795180976,
-0.1121976227,
0.9003230333,
0.0788221508,
0.6974942088,
-0.7954585552,
0.5182814598,
-0.0794874951,
-0.2105392814,
0.0297581032,
-0.4952623844,
-0.6540439129,
0.1208322197,
0.0988305286,
-0.8401564956,
0.0561680384,
0.3664279282,
-0.6033068895,
0.5762591362,
-0.695420742,
0.8100781441,
-0.6410496831,
-0.3977707028,
-0.4039832056,
-0.6579031348,
0.2746098042,
-0.2415534705,
-0.1959817708,
0.1414879858,
-0.1433802992,
0.3698394299,
-0.2570503354,
0.47283867,
-0.3433169127,
0.1443624198,
0.2800038755,
0.1856024563,
0.320140481,
0.2226947248,
-0.0570049435,
0.2272518873,
-0.1899879277,
-0.3011739254,
-0.4067462683,
0.948924005,
-0.5567811728,
-0.2798123956,
-0.4967454374,
-0.8872054815,
-0.1111671403,
0.6368314028,
-0.0695582703,
0.1610899717,
-0.2522197664,
0.1251304895,
0.720080018,
-0.1677671969,
0.4481479228,
0.3369233012,
-0.3653346896,
-0.8116840124,
1.282599926,
0.1755344421,
0.4296944141,
0.5425371528,
0.289450109,
-0.1624077857,
-0.9772248864,
-0.5259393454,
0.1854106337,
-0.4830682874,
-0.5677831173,
-0.8157250881,
-0.4112646282,
0.0559608638,
-0.4875341356,
-0.5931411386,
-0.4191429615,
-0.2846699953,
0.086267747,
0.1698299795,
0.2627564073,
-0.2843886018,
0.5126276612,
-0.9138296843,
0.2664356232,
-0.0683332607,
0.3396376073,
0.2550557554,
-0.4173589349,
-0.5229583979,
0.1316152811,
-0.7343968749,
-0.6620543003,
0.3319428265,
0.4820728898,
0.6761918068,
0.389970392,
-0.2817846537,
0.6775355935,
-0.6671309471,
0.4708969891,
0.2225169539,
-0.8570321798,
0.4177183211,
-0.2470154464,
0.4811820984,
0.6441745758,
0.3200647831,
-0.5813654661,
-0.3167874217,
-0.4794890583,
-1.1484074593,
0.5181844234,
0.0307231713,
0.0137586035,
-0.2819859684,
0.4974163771,
0.1343232393,
0.3009429276,
-0.3801977932,
-0.1569719315,
-0.2984031737,
-0.0910486579,
0.1977541298,
-0.0259582754,
0.1228595376,
-0.1910979301,
0.5359967351,
-0.1417236626,
0.7211251259,
0.3252520859,
-0.5030673742,
-0.0897757709,
0.0437218621,
1.0384702682,
0.7679850459,
-0.2562551498,
-0.0420445837,
0.4484415054,
-0.856362164,
0.0444346368,
-0.0284340344,
-0.3687424362,
-0.1714896113,
-0.1730623543,
0.733070612,
0.6383559704,
-0.5065012574,
0.0942235366,
0.1796713024,
-0.4836919308,
-0.3384050131,
-0.0103316857,
0.1678774208,
0.3404932916,
0.4699906707,
0.66584903,
-0.1033325493,
-0.3820114136,
0.8457126021,
0.0559033565,
-0.6016095281,
-0.3005627096,
0.6074370146,
0.0073455777,
-0.2011456341,
0.8929202557,
-0.2161854059,
-0.6285500526,
0.3606400788,
0.9767785668,
1.1777200699,
-0.5337020159,
0.2080115676,
0.4197326005,
0.4380618334,
-0.3786129057,
0.2055512816,
-0.2114392221,
-0.4816583693,
-0.4158196449,
-0.7287663817,
-0.188766703,
0.0073262858,
-0.3806892931,
-0.1725536585,
-0.9157099724,
0.0707905889,
-0.4903783202,
0.0100260526,
-0.2990204394,
0.1784800291,
0.3758417666,
0.9582602382,
-0.361155957,
1.2548168898,
0.424589783,
-0.4739256501,
-0.473328203,
0.0618005209,
0.1786610782,
-0.7244704962,
0.573012054,
0.4532227218,
-0.2999568284,
0.2696590424,
-0.1877006143,
-0.8291708827,
1.2875577211,
0.2964165509,
-0.5940214396,
-0.0840991512,
-0.0820596442,
0.2513832748,
-0.4999888837,
0.2711789608,
0.3978458643,
0.5004429817,
0.2994539738,
-0.6207088232,
0.1209089905,
-0.0891887024,
-0.263891995,
0.2823402882,
-0.8228899837,
0.7843479514,
-0.523314476,
-0.236018911,
0.3779281378,
0.8982406855,
0.1773041338,
0.4521150887,
0.4555006921,
0.6411056519,
0.8867192268,
-0.2423676252,
0.4391448498,
-0.0347779542,
0.1577884108,
1.2268258333,
-0.0526027344,
0.9328308105,
0.6290276051,
0.1834634542,
0.155062139,
0.3247370124,
-0.2126446217,
0.5990329385,
0.3419349492,
0.0009133136,
0.1298420578,
-0.0027312839,
-0.2283247709,
0.2055372,
0.566609025,
-0.4820931256,
-0.1538320333,
0.1030184105,
0.1584394127,
-0.0752501264,
-0.4222196043,
0.4527367651,
0.4308318496,
-0.7407965064,
0.899739325,
-0.2805531323,
0.6044569612,
-0.7194296718,
0.1479318291,
-0.4903469086,
0.541697681,
0.0350370407,
-0.5226178765,
0.9250587821,
-0.3511077762,
-0.3887036145,
-0.4145751595,
0.4234628081,
-0.512206018,
-0.1287150234,
0.3362811208,
0.2524167001,
-0.0378407016,
-0.3388948441,
-0.9818878174,
0.0861385167,
-0.0590106547,
-0.0633371845,
0.4123925567,
0.5010256767,
-0.1277654916,
0.7151367068,
0.549687922,
0.1287371367,
0.2814725041,
-0.1241020188,
0.8928941488,
-0.7295092344,
-0.2344034761,
-0.8318862915,
0.4056023359,
0.1383834481,
-0.5415514708,
0.3947460651,
0.4207062423,
0.8181414604,
-0.0640564263,
0.3499536812,
-0.0552585684,
-0.1299513131,
-0.540584445,
1.0586150885,
-0.5347833037,
-0.0067668608,
-0.2598048449,
-0.9140805006,
-0.5633746386,
0.6431279778,
-0.1964955181,
-0.147535935,
1.1842491627,
0.5757870674,
-0.0496191345,
0.1148527339,
0.3370087743,
0.4245288968,
0.0814670697,
1.1314300299,
0.874909997,
-0.5388817191,
0.8309058547,
-0.2444232702,
-0.0727190003,
-0.1299768686,
-0.6987176538,
-0.538805902,
-0.5669831038,
-0.1795498282,
-0.1371043772,
0.226673916,
0.7574358582,
0.4966201186,
-0.8818496466,
-0.0646176487,
-0.1489259005,
0.1572539806,
-0.8320484161,
-0.0746710449,
0.1800856441,
-0.6783800721,
-0.4172943532,
0.5321691632,
0.6649755836,
-0.1822280884,
-0.2646402121,
-0.2678432763,
-0.601126194,
-0.2861882448,
0.5673307776,
0.4453839958,
-0.540602386,
-0.1864520311,
0.3314816952,
0.0200826451,
0.2586320937,
0.8278129101,
-0.5865805745,
0.3522791862,
0.3899886608,
1.1300017834,
0.1758743078,
-0.3345205784,
0.7253141999,
-0.6093993783,
0.1608967185,
0.5341456532,
0.1693594456,
0.1656594872,
-0.3315114975,
0.2043081522,
0.3783537447,
-0.8517768979,
-0.7123580575,
-0.0291276854,
-1.0905557871,
0.0420394726,
0.7770820856,
-0.4149160683,
-0.3529458344,
0.1048556641,
-0.0249161292,
0.2541221678,
-0.3325143754,
0.6428588033,
0.4472768307,
0.3529316187,
-0.2056671381,
-0.8548672795,
0.1866193116,
0.6654816866,
-0.5419721007,
0.0562522374,
0.322624892,
0.0422843136,
0.3035631776,
0.6979889274,
-0.2629516125,
0.2600204051,
0.0251698159,
-0.2399758399,
-0.2208422571,
-0.877948463,
-0.0506025627,
0.0765444487,
0.0007985077,
-0.4106139541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04845v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04845v2
|
SLPL SHROOM at SemEval2024 Task 06: A comprehensive study on models ability to detect hallucination
| 2024-04-07T07:34:49 | 2024-04-09T07:21:37 |
Pouya Fallah, Soroush Gooran, Mohammad Jafarinasab, Pouya Sadeghi, Reza Farnia, Amirreza Tarabkhah, Zainab Sadat Taghavi, Hossein Sameti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language models, particularly generative models, are susceptible to
hallucinations, generating outputs that contradict factual knowledge or the
source text. This study explores methods for detecting hallucinations in three
SemEval-2024 Task 6 tasks: Machine Translation, Definition Modeling, and
Paraphrase Generation. We evaluate two methods: semantic similarity between the
generated text and factual references, and an ensemble of language models that
judge each other's outputs. Our results show that semantic similarity achieves
moderate accuracy and correlation scores in trial data, while the ensemble
method offers insights into the complexities of hallucination detection but
falls short of expectations. This work highlights the challenges of
hallucination detection and underscores the need for further research in this
critical area.
|
[
-0.3319921494,
-0.6434140801,
0.9741429687,
0.1427164972,
-0.2310698032,
-0.4819502234,
0.0578320734,
-0.5593594909,
0.1500575095,
0.9950180054,
-0.4820834696,
-0.45706141,
-0.5385933518,
0.3407589197,
-0.9218752384,
0.7786706686,
-0.0006538924,
0.0469844267,
-0.4396927953,
-0.0170088839,
-0.3566332161,
-0.7887270451,
-0.1973777115,
-0.3332563341,
0.1994075179,
-0.0190302059,
0.5596235991,
0.1731795371,
0.6128345728,
0.3016884625,
0.1144056246,
0.3134103715,
-0.3299419582,
0.5288448334,
-0.1171673089,
-0.2797655761,
-0.1476551145,
-0.2492988408,
0.3874789476,
0.4973560274,
-0.1367354542,
-0.1593094915,
0.1692281067,
0.4279594421,
-0.511701107,
0.0820572153,
-0.9150335789,
0.2128601223,
-0.1325395703,
-0.5035431981,
-0.6486037374,
-0.1232993826,
-0.0534068272,
-0.1739041954,
0.6984728575,
0.2438106388,
0.7459898591,
0.5822631717,
-0.2889307141,
-0.7439897656,
-0.623742044,
0.7470445037,
-0.8040111661,
0.447203815,
0.5711999536,
0.1627004445,
-0.027435882,
-0.8022142053,
-0.6162413955,
-0.2943026721,
-0.2331322283,
-0.1274772882,
0.048621133,
-0.0785033032,
0.4129088223,
0.2519465685,
-0.7332472205,
-0.184675619,
-0.508554697,
-0.5042189956,
0.4909305871,
0.1881403774,
0.3461088836,
-0.5309624672,
-0.2244407088,
-0.020691812,
-0.3746098578,
-0.7424563169,
0.3322459161,
0.2707571685,
0.2598962188,
0.595318377,
-0.1506523788,
0.4639135301,
-0.3132533729,
0.1401673406,
0.5060645938,
-0.4668866396,
-0.1991078705,
0.2538759112,
0.5125960708,
0.2653329968,
-0.0996050462,
-0.3680173755,
-0.5741205812,
0.2460863292,
0.5726704001,
-0.4459632337,
-0.3126966059,
0.1694060117,
-0.5794229507,
-0.6292345524,
-0.1550289989,
-0.8171640635,
-0.600297749,
-0.4393989444,
0.8400794268,
-0.5195216537,
-0.2094740719,
0.0717395693,
-0.260225147,
0.4246220589,
0.1958339065,
-0.6837353706,
0.4246124923,
0.6102451086,
0.8786139488,
-0.6414427161,
-0.4827924669,
-0.4825196862,
0.0181472227,
-0.2962386608,
0.9938243032,
-0.4225141406,
-0.2750536501,
-0.0789720565,
0.1726548225,
-0.164682284,
-0.8409264088,
0.8116945624,
-0.0493891053,
0.1469068676,
-0.3825480044,
-0.5546146631,
-0.226518482,
-0.0845406055,
-0.5567629337,
0.9411128759,
-0.0641790926,
-0.7449349165,
0.098083809,
-0.1447052509,
-0.4809287488,
0.1345230639,
-0.4636597335,
-0.441046983,
0.5354480743,
-0.0346001647,
0.664924264,
-0.0273856744,
0.3358646631,
-0.1366982013,
-0.4747844934,
0.1941249222,
-0.239867568,
0.3138596117,
0.3963771462,
-0.6633746624,
0.2681725025,
-0.7876873016,
-0.2276219726,
0.1946350336,
0.3270893097,
-0.4423142672,
0.1967049092,
0.1480294317,
0.1957574934,
0.1358441412,
0.0104570808,
-0.3347329199,
-0.2135504633,
0.2778198719,
0.6710256338,
0.2227946967,
0.1296319962,
-0.431089431,
0.1362151951,
0.2471075952,
-0.2248255014,
-0.1209767833,
-0.5284018517,
-0.8585880399,
0.3233049512,
-0.0698770806,
0.2021765262,
-0.8131871819,
0.5847252011,
-0.0048649912,
-0.3947372437,
-0.3253209293,
-0.1325704455,
0.2243501842,
0.5004719496,
0.4883202612,
-0.090281859,
-0.7149140239,
-0.931322515,
-0.1726386845,
0.0106612323,
0.0263041798,
0.0119177708,
0.9177132845,
-0.4256675839,
0.1454672366,
-0.4361631274,
-0.3055370748,
-0.0618743151,
0.4491451681,
-0.2015526146,
0.4766649306,
0.5754365325,
-0.7897440195,
-0.0522300899,
-0.0590532757,
-1.1633344889,
-0.3268942535,
-0.2276904881,
0.0602824911,
0.4697262049,
0.6352386475,
-0.4961446822,
0.5135431886,
0.4036944509,
-0.382961154,
0.6321876049,
-0.128397733,
0.4692653716,
-1.0251959562,
-0.0860338882,
-0.4347110689,
-0.0987318531,
-0.8897535205,
0.2068396211,
-0.1349209845,
-0.0757493675,
-0.2346843779,
0.1268749833,
-0.2047893852,
-0.4103806615,
-0.5082582831,
0.1518655866,
-0.1904464513,
0.3495976329,
0.3588417172,
0.5780370235,
0.2899994254,
-0.6385623813,
0.1956573278,
0.1303554326,
-0.5085382462,
0.2718971968,
-0.5083119869,
0.2670785189,
-0.1727509201,
-0.1403780878,
-1.0580952168,
-0.4976072907,
0.1930865198,
-0.4759459794,
-0.1960953921,
0.5276941061,
-0.5931062698,
-0.1405977458,
-0.1680395603,
0.122739628,
0.5787323713,
-0.3631485403,
0.5797156096,
0.2314626873,
0.0865405202,
-0.1210199818,
-0.8219197989,
0.0289233457,
-0.379298985,
-0.4187669754,
0.4164912105,
0.028244555,
-0.3835399151,
-0.2255729437,
-0.2798237801,
0.0263118912,
0.1280912161,
0.2835643291,
0.1232099086,
-0.1247049496,
0.0920162648,
0.022043163,
0.1273317784,
0.3873977959,
-0.0056661409,
0.8923018575,
0.0318323001,
-0.4894380867,
-0.2989707589,
0.3255991936,
0.7149322629,
0.1910901666,
0.7329862714,
0.6264083385,
-0.8003854752,
-0.2652935982,
-0.7930232882,
-0.5724390149,
-0.3970198035,
0.3490013778,
-0.6240198612,
-0.470998317,
0.6251904368,
0.2607779205,
-0.2894356251,
0.5832470059,
0.7243339419,
0.177632302,
1.1441310644,
0.0701105818,
0.241671443,
-0.0928645581,
0.0533162132,
0.4639712274,
-0.5366879702,
-0.3718368411,
-0.7321962714,
0.0772232115,
-0.4413207769,
-0.5615723729,
0.1292676181,
-0.1438674778,
0.1887106746,
0.4861541092,
-0.6723148227,
0.2291008234,
0.4161555171,
0.0067328489,
0.2554746568,
0.0870526582,
-0.1334997416,
-0.3745978773,
-0.2242770642,
-0.6291952729,
0.808056891,
0.0695228502,
0.4949383736,
-0.0411967859,
0.9771233201,
0.4780679047,
-0.3775866628,
-0.3972889781,
0.7448421717,
0.1015742421,
-0.3267038763,
-0.3122026622,
-0.2417557538,
-0.4930958152,
0.4143923521,
-0.1664601266,
-0.7685610056,
0.1835875809,
-0.1234456375,
-0.0563558713,
0.0347177312,
-0.5302411318,
0.7664102912,
-0.0818939656,
-0.2250932008,
-0.2739174664,
-0.451441735,
0.5397963524,
-0.2767200768,
0.1591012925,
-0.0905216634,
0.248258099,
0.6761881113,
-0.1683677435,
0.6430885792,
-0.0314958803,
-0.2166356742,
0.1797337681,
0.2594634891,
0.6393063068,
-0.3194393218,
-0.118581675,
-0.0045647458,
0.2014133185,
-0.2255506217,
-0.4936392307,
0.789483726,
-0.5982477665,
-0.5500536561,
-0.5905934572,
-0.5628560781,
0.0026150867,
0.0494826026,
0.6610048413,
0.1268711537,
-0.1425481141,
0.2633576691,
0.7130854726,
-0.2687369287,
0.1807751656,
0.1180722937,
-0.4288716614,
-0.0937675089,
1.0469121933,
0.0340508893,
0.2018669695,
0.0745258182,
-0.0038177499,
-0.3146096468,
-0.7319068313,
0.0906217545,
0.266328454,
-0.9593131542,
-0.039291922,
-0.9093382955,
-0.598559618,
-0.9475666881,
-0.0618296638,
-0.1493494213,
-0.3831309676,
-0.2967480123,
-0.1039955243,
0.0043722647,
0.7546998858,
0.0906632245,
-0.1554853469,
-0.539191246,
0.4889057577,
0.2330283523,
-0.4348820746,
0.0205501206,
-0.6745329499,
0.1343812048,
-0.1664965749,
-0.2677528262,
-1.0160218477,
0.6255281568,
-0.0980976596,
0.6199227571,
0.4426074028,
0.1877972484,
0.6839420199,
-0.3997853398,
0.9910534024,
-0.0136535475,
-0.9961759448,
0.7879223824,
-0.1031505913,
0.0388455801,
0.4201572835,
0.4006964862,
-0.305598408,
-0.6583608389,
-0.6567287445,
-0.4903758168,
0.4899744689,
0.6610715985,
0.0577721111,
-0.1637691706,
0.1731913984,
0.3544685841,
0.2367227972,
-0.8556796908,
0.0945711806,
-0.1235767007,
-0.1189450026,
-0.0425322503,
-0.3758225739,
0.0446954593,
-0.1170459464,
0.6175447702,
-0.0052739885,
0.3034891188,
0.2306535244,
-0.235721156,
-0.0424214713,
0.1013741866,
1.0061186552,
0.596541822,
-0.0998069122,
0.5447656512,
0.4569427967,
-0.2197392732,
-0.1204496026,
-0.0726900324,
-0.3507512212,
0.3604674637,
0.6224084496,
0.9033353329,
0.2451231033,
-0.7524950504,
0.5038608313,
0.1420386732,
-0.526130259,
-0.4206810892,
0.1320250928,
-0.05850989,
0.0782645494,
0.2384470403,
0.2111096829,
0.6315762997,
-0.6141603589,
0.4470521808,
0.1755310744,
-0.4294121265,
-0.5070418715,
0.7140788436,
-0.1617453992,
-0.303902179,
0.6414411068,
-0.2564175725,
-0.6791145802,
0.576394558,
0.7530071735,
0.9164648056,
-0.3597338498,
0.1933045983,
0.3059619963,
0.2228675783,
-0.3884879053,
0.4100941718,
-0.1364259422,
-0.8341786861,
-0.0913524404,
-0.826425612,
-0.1094473898,
0.5410519242,
-0.7221558094,
0.5059859753,
0.1744705439,
0.1415219009,
0.1199863106,
-0.4252879024,
-0.3904493451,
-0.0392024368,
0.3013084531,
0.3266320527,
-1.1558070183,
0.7444927692,
0.4378277063,
-0.357892096,
-0.4217710197,
0.2147680074,
0.163835004,
-0.6384714246,
0.5769885778,
0.3272871375,
-0.1115341634,
-0.1437554359,
-0.3779619932,
-0.454883486,
0.9342907071,
-0.003900765,
-0.4016436338,
-0.4221820533,
0.20415546,
0.6076628566,
-0.3371148407,
-0.1719439775,
0.8112399578,
0.4031626582,
0.3637413383,
-0.6476616263,
0.2275969237,
-0.0399171934,
0.0602039173,
0.110345915,
-0.1525440067,
0.6657150984,
0.0202699434,
-0.128256917,
0.2954380214,
0.7265527844,
0.5096029043,
0.6004927754,
0.4813961983,
0.6295746565,
0.7105184197,
-0.0237026457,
0.6573706865,
-0.3619966805,
0.2770809531,
1.2345634699,
-0.6918352246,
0.7867668867,
0.7031957507,
0.1055431664,
0.2438861132,
0.4814460874,
-0.1706495434,
0.7945320606,
0.1404364705,
-0.2860212028,
-0.3483386934,
-0.1515280008,
-0.4718934,
0.3358476162,
0.528460443,
-0.6057308912,
-0.0169911087,
0.4019718468,
-0.4625407457,
0.2898856103,
0.0324639268,
0.784768939,
0.2088722736,
-0.9756507277,
0.430041194,
-0.3435684443,
0.368311882,
-0.2157455832,
-0.3252680004,
-0.1502906978,
0.1938334107,
-0.1698471457,
-0.3452363908,
0.792318821,
-0.2311273664,
0.0632944331,
-0.0975584909,
1.0188860893,
-0.2574408948,
-0.3742622733,
0.4588067234,
0.4322763979,
0.6529816985,
-0.2644503713,
-0.3883699477,
0.3557098806,
0.1880173385,
0.1169159785,
0.1266670078,
0.5772882104,
-0.0740871727,
0.4322732091,
0.2342993021,
0.094642207,
0.2208923399,
0.245694831,
0.4949408472,
-0.6495279074,
-0.2900336683,
-0.8626016378,
-0.0310672186,
-0.1763152033,
-0.1158500016,
0.875025034,
0.6551063061,
0.8496536016,
-0.4839880764,
0.699731648,
-0.0498221964,
0.4260341227,
-0.6590543389,
0.5629771948,
-0.5171025991,
0.2880488336,
-0.3684962392,
-0.9744566083,
-0.1351553649,
0.8276945949,
-0.2439101785,
-0.2395099699,
1.1768689156,
1.0579915047,
-0.0251339264,
0.3603344262,
0.7521070242,
0.2312314808,
-0.0446652919,
0.347879529,
1.0519903898,
-0.6168932319,
0.462395072,
-0.3386469185,
0.2960627675,
-0.2573753893,
-0.4977736771,
-1.1211400032,
-1.1812624931,
-0.3367315531,
-0.5023662448,
0.1711775362,
0.5861363411,
0.4212729931,
-1.1924438477,
-0.1518637687,
-0.509506166,
-0.0103539499,
-0.2221320868,
-0.3025344312,
0.2975122333,
-0.7583006024,
-0.7724140286,
0.3309864402,
0.2948884964,
0.311029017,
-0.3072517812,
-0.1445094347,
-0.0820828229,
-0.0424481556,
0.5404825807,
-0.3782946169,
-1.162856698,
-0.4691676497,
0.0695118532,
-0.2146809846,
-0.2204987407,
0.7749230862,
-0.4847644567,
0.2440882921,
0.9171543717,
0.4512701631,
0.557122767,
-0.1570311636,
0.4466322064,
-0.3416897058,
0.1777753383,
0.3405837715,
0.3950921893,
0.2335930318,
-0.3413546383,
0.8445647359,
0.479835093,
-0.7719010115,
-1.1943227053,
0.109291546,
-0.7670661807,
-0.5045332909,
0.9430950284,
0.1453508586,
-0.1733052582,
-0.2484439015,
-0.2140035331,
0.110124886,
0.1560490578,
1.0069260597,
0.9830262065,
-0.123946771,
-0.0801880583,
-0.7865284085,
0.6880243421,
0.5730048418,
-0.7720287442,
-0.050654348,
0.4600029886,
-0.188570857,
0.4527563751,
0.385958761,
-0.0050750105,
0.3051287532,
0.1501898617,
0.0049136071,
0.4619155228,
-0.4288402498,
-0.3219427764,
0.1844798923,
-0.1063113585,
-0.0564513803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04838v1
|
Data Bias According to Bipol: Men are Naturally Right and It is the Role of Women to Follow Their Lead
| 2024-04-07T07:24:45 | 2024-04-07T07:24:45 |
Irene Pagliai, Goya van Boven, Tosin Adewumi, Lama Alkhaled, Namrata Gurung, Isabella Södergren, Elisa Barney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce new large labeled datasets on bias in 3 languages and show in
experiments that bias exists in all 10 datasets of 5 languages evaluated,
including benchmark datasets on the English GLUE/SuperGLUE leaderboards. The 3
new languages give a total of almost 6 million labeled samples and we benchmark
on these datasets using SotA multilingual pretrained models: mT5 and mBERT. The
challenge of social bias, based on prejudice, is ubiquitous, as recent events
with AI and large language models (LLMs) have shown. Motivated by this
challenge, we set out to estimate bias in multiple datasets. We compare some
recent bias metrics and use bipol, which has explainability in the metric. We
also confirm the unverified assumption that bias exists in toxic comments by
randomly sampling 200 samples from a toxic dataset population using the
confidence level of 95% and error margin of 7%. Thirty gold samples were
randomly distributed in the 200 samples to secure the quality of the
annotation. Our findings confirm that many of the datasets have male bias
(prejudice against women), besides other types of bias. We publicly release our
new datasets, lexica, models, and codes.
|
[
-0.3256857395,
-0.3624927402,
0.2291336507,
0.4978018999,
0.2459727526,
0.2531163692,
-0.1714973599,
-0.4276817441,
-0.1306464225,
0.5297756791,
-0.5783568621,
-0.2991483808,
-0.7137103677,
0.119309254,
-0.160829857,
1.3237407207,
0.2205521017,
0.7150588036,
-0.0677377582,
-0.3359164298,
-0.4630980194,
-0.8120903373,
0.0070387693,
-0.3635468781,
0.3845284879,
0.3258227408,
0.7487239242,
0.2654639781,
0.2373767197,
0.09968438,
-0.3682123125,
0.175930202,
-0.5884264708,
-0.1157596856,
-0.4890917838,
-0.6534749866,
-0.3701536655,
0.4393341839,
0.2206492424,
0.8297054172,
0.0473225079,
0.5453586578,
0.2081376612,
1.0226671696,
-0.6527904868,
0.3295100629,
-0.3528142571,
-0.074775748,
-0.472756058,
0.0943637118,
-0.4720676541,
-0.467695564,
0.3803811967,
-0.3040047586,
0.4189840257,
0.3088106513,
0.753079772,
0.0190898739,
-0.7341959476,
-0.4016554058,
-0.7511713505,
0.9726963043,
-0.4158824086,
0.3808071315,
0.5217772722,
0.4178195,
-0.1270698011,
-0.3317463696,
-0.1371933073,
0.1006935686,
0.1044158116,
-0.0596559234,
0.1754469573,
-0.2995045781,
0.4369870126,
0.1299527138,
-0.1417698562,
-0.131575793,
-0.3865169287,
-0.3047261238,
0.8821958899,
-0.1172792986,
0.2437721789,
0.2789146006,
-0.3240687251,
-0.1421077847,
-0.9704063535,
-0.164363429,
0.8431525826,
0.4378018677,
-0.23764126,
0.5236985683,
-0.0127047058,
0.4595940709,
-0.1523915231,
0.233435601,
0.5762901902,
-0.6094825268,
0.1304858625,
0.2132704258,
0.848444283,
0.5321272016,
0.8245722055,
0.0787665993,
0.1814122349,
0.3279547095,
0.0590910837,
-0.4055798948,
-0.2261333764,
-0.1073518395,
-0.4007916749,
-0.2249154598,
0.0900485069,
-1.2897986174,
-0.687808454,
0.0928958803,
-0.0834854841,
0.1527902633,
-0.1740661114,
0.0463527963,
-0.2569403052,
0.0494050048,
0.0339804478,
-0.978559792,
0.2548161149,
0.3633261323,
0.3415255547,
0.0576580502,
-0.3267875314,
-0.3716126382,
0.0841801986,
-0.6938447952,
0.7819755077,
-0.6875116825,
-0.0025811598,
0.1344414651,
-0.0338663086,
0.2623456717,
-0.6656512618,
0.7045826912,
-0.1612497419,
0.3928132355,
-0.8976700902,
-0.2033939809,
-0.0843852758,
0.0134699233,
-0.6532763243,
1.1943595409,
0.0165905152,
-1.1007891893,
0.8532116413,
-0.4254373908,
-0.370757997,
-0.50908494,
-0.4805015624,
-0.5509105325,
-0.0838551223,
0.2999157608,
0.0234920364,
-0.8470432758,
0.4205135703,
-0.5386033058,
-0.1751403213,
0.2119538784,
-0.299335897,
1.2223587036,
0.0095400894,
-0.6110785007,
-0.0235641859,
-0.2515174448,
-0.4314697981,
-0.1939872652,
-0.3336101472,
-0.3763569891,
0.1881905347,
-0.0289733838,
0.4745413959,
-0.1420044452,
-0.5433529615,
-0.0403677039,
-0.0247907303,
0.2270330042,
0.9490216374,
-0.1802607924,
0.3773087561,
-0.2109573036,
0.2399163693,
-0.0245259311,
0.3552101254,
0.3590706885,
-0.7059708238,
-0.353545934,
-0.1167187467,
0.5361646414,
0.339610368,
-0.534586966,
0.2082663029,
0.0034870785,
-0.2891596556,
-0.4843856096,
0.1748568118,
0.6273510456,
0.3570624888,
0.1822179258,
-0.2756692767,
-0.6732436419,
-1.2735710144,
-0.6455492973,
-0.1048339382,
-0.0798120722,
0.392594099,
0.478194356,
-0.0755558759,
0.8566868305,
-0.4063586295,
-0.5355216861,
-0.1728314906,
0.2124865055,
0.1579046994,
0.1986795813,
0.7909485698,
-0.6641193628,
-0.585598588,
-0.4228480756,
-0.7402704358,
-0.6076157093,
0.344058007,
-0.5536008477,
0.177236408,
0.3789708912,
-0.1516994387,
0.2985993028,
0.6193330288,
-0.4815580249,
0.6532390714,
0.2184301019,
-0.0589629225,
-0.6637678146,
-0.1301320344,
0.2501761913,
-0.1078573093,
-0.6622804999,
-0.3448683321,
-0.0840590969,
0.3466025591,
-0.4247544408,
0.4196246862,
-0.6995349526,
-0.2517392933,
0.1405908614,
0.0786001608,
0.0543356314,
0.2943015695,
-0.1124712229,
0.6045217514,
0.6413029432,
-0.4141871333,
0.045649536,
0.4178192317,
-0.3894303739,
0.380672127,
-0.3961586952,
0.1876303852,
-0.3134151697,
0.4877282083,
-1.0598483086,
-0.0400772579,
0.0521687679,
-0.4162603915,
0.0249186344,
-0.2452055961,
-0.539560318,
-0.4308583736,
-0.4223523438,
0.1328204572,
0.3436902165,
-0.3178765774,
0.3332729936,
0.9350270629,
-0.1119820774,
-0.921605587,
-0.8763290048,
-0.1904639751,
-0.0760904402,
-0.2562877834,
-0.2190127969,
-0.1601230949,
-0.4106980264,
-0.2873407602,
-0.1480087787,
-0.0452672951,
-0.1404258758,
0.1721568108,
0.3980976939,
0.2491708249,
-0.1010799631,
-0.163967371,
-0.0170741007,
0.1995725781,
-0.0222391374,
0.710423708,
0.1137434766,
-0.1045397297,
0.0326999798,
0.2382474542,
0.5322571993,
-0.1063113809,
0.4745381773,
0.3486461639,
-0.3195468783,
0.0418455005,
-0.4759024382,
-0.1605587602,
-0.3668705821,
0.1373130679,
-0.0993808955,
-0.64109236,
0.5072568655,
0.3830614388,
0.3111457825,
0.180215314,
0.791923821,
0.0063807359,
1.5100005865,
0.5835164189,
-0.6741574407,
0.2295608819,
-0.094568491,
0.1663389057,
-0.5728321075,
-0.1814899147,
-0.7222510576,
-0.3957899213,
-0.883543849,
-0.189351365,
0.1534901857,
-0.255663693,
-0.4134985805,
-0.2183633745,
-0.4719330668,
0.3510070443,
0.7420063615,
0.0512152314,
0.0271833148,
0.0745561123,
-0.1711381376,
-0.2785620987,
-0.7561167479,
-0.5409668684,
1.3509283066,
0.2754408419,
0.8991894126,
0.0482056253,
0.0726578236,
0.5178072453,
0.571946919,
-0.0573648848,
0.399207592,
-0.2367728651,
-1.5329008102,
-0.0118567627,
-0.2590436637,
-0.6852365732,
0.1198518947,
-0.248100251,
-0.570530355,
0.6142448783,
0.2734523118,
-0.0038689252,
0.1330148578,
-0.7385106087,
0.5751078129,
-0.1483395696,
-0.9489653111,
0.1455419064,
-0.9058680534,
0.3997302353,
0.1580398232,
0.5261749029,
-0.5623050928,
0.3693666458,
0.9480124712,
-0.2451103032,
0.7998815179,
-0.4829864502,
-0.0394206606,
0.2023115754,
-0.2282012105,
0.1941815466,
-0.233849749,
-0.2571201026,
0.3885873258,
-0.2171339095,
-0.6245564818,
0.0437405333,
0.2278572321,
-0.7784705758,
-0.2637228966,
-0.6340897679,
-0.4874843955,
-0.3283266425,
0.183549732,
0.4251790047,
0.3263736963,
0.071407862,
0.0915969834,
0.4035838544,
-0.3666248322,
0.108225368,
0.2623617053,
-0.4610779583,
-0.0867703259,
0.4814985693,
0.4054196775,
0.3115541339,
0.0020780158,
0.3201931417,
-0.3119647503,
-0.0182302445,
-0.5112405419,
0.328458339,
-0.299721092,
-0.0024196415,
-0.4115671217,
-0.0358107239,
-0.4370101094,
0.0793824345,
-0.5384581685,
0.0038857409,
0.338919431,
-0.2766693532,
0.1277130544,
0.7187792063,
-0.0502469651,
0.075453192,
-0.2986761928,
0.3800296783,
0.2207372487,
0.3518613875,
-0.2365960628,
-0.2492495626,
-0.1039878801,
0.1855774969,
-0.1260707527,
-1.0929176807,
0.3614138663,
-0.0286434256,
0.5932369828,
0.2346365005,
0.1820364445,
0.223626256,
-0.4460594356,
0.688326478,
-0.1649117321,
-0.7012668252,
0.4062094986,
-0.5000821352,
-0.1218226478,
0.7179781199,
0.5421358347,
-0.3459565341,
-0.4925251007,
-0.608343184,
-0.7382853031,
0.9594632387,
0.1125470251,
-0.0447782129,
-0.0870683566,
0.0006802065,
0.2246085554,
0.7260163426,
-0.5944586992,
-0.7402710319,
-0.0096878512,
-0.1416266859,
-0.249416694,
-0.6637648344,
-0.4005967677,
-0.0300049148,
0.6048318148,
-0.0639450401,
0.3279715478,
0.1230283231,
-0.1281295866,
0.0509962216,
0.3733250797,
0.3654210567,
0.7735962272,
-0.3857400417,
0.2924794555,
-0.0305465776,
-0.6725772619,
0.3660822511,
-0.0159537066,
-0.4775764048,
0.0872455016,
0.2252914608,
0.6681582928,
-0.2266860455,
-0.6368454099,
0.4938837886,
-0.0165359341,
-0.2741893828,
-0.222394526,
-0.1641044021,
0.0128968265,
0.1590241194,
0.427085042,
-0.1376780272,
0.18980892,
-0.9185529351,
0.0634800196,
0.3791542053,
-0.738317132,
-0.4645929337,
0.8351848125,
0.2400185615,
-0.006736001,
0.4581083357,
-0.1881212145,
-0.7336699367,
0.4426235557,
0.2782720625,
0.5611900687,
-0.2047173679,
0.2458823174,
0.2673223913,
0.6347725987,
-0.3014203608,
0.5785985589,
0.4033675194,
-0.9669907093,
-0.2534423172,
-0.2306688577,
-0.4123799503,
0.0008133492,
-0.6749750972,
0.3103092611,
-0.3733261526,
-0.2615793347,
0.0516611934,
0.0488545038,
-0.5654582977,
0.0731162205,
0.1169806197,
0.90653795,
-1.5120414495,
0.5009536147,
0.6940151453,
-0.3185555041,
-0.4878920019,
0.1088569686,
0.4285684526,
-0.5357572436,
0.6433828473,
0.2939695418,
0.144401148,
-0.3872965574,
-0.6666929126,
-0.5736578107,
0.5515803099,
0.5635907054,
-0.3665246964,
0.1330371797,
0.3287669718,
0.5894775987,
-0.3856149316,
0.4268111289,
0.8037871122,
0.6149803996,
-0.5810833573,
-0.775493145,
-0.2491826415,
-0.3009067774,
-0.2352636158,
-0.0416329652,
-0.9290565848,
0.8594151139,
0.0854389444,
0.0593991429,
-0.6031601429,
0.3077516854,
0.4614440501,
0.521643281,
0.5000008345,
0.1374841928,
0.6232548356,
-0.3601394892,
0.9024859667,
-0.2018327266,
0.2443853617,
1.3450905085,
-0.7427552342,
0.1833358556,
0.3683443367,
-0.377656281,
0.5453839898,
0.5907629132,
0.0755384788,
0.5409416556,
0.1090768725,
-0.0267410353,
0.1007724106,
-0.4553676844,
-0.1795839667,
0.3936035037,
0.2056087852,
-0.4600750208,
-0.1105293185,
-0.1084134206,
0.4864673615,
0.1096875966,
-0.1456064135,
0.4146508873,
-0.1086054966,
-0.6772164106,
0.2439259589,
-0.3167874515,
0.6252787113,
-0.5050954819,
0.1151716411,
-0.4057602882,
0.2118776888,
-0.3344448209,
-0.7149305344,
0.0542638302,
0.0244069658,
-0.3151727915,
-0.173641637,
0.7475137711,
-0.4746593535,
-0.4061532915,
0.4216426015,
0.54473418,
0.2295476496,
-0.0551274978,
-0.5362343192,
0.10823901,
0.370750308,
-0.2228923142,
0.3093338907,
0.2277421653,
-0.4791353941,
0.7655285001,
0.5092473626,
0.3604297638,
0.486603111,
0.293379128,
0.6273860931,
-0.3840288222,
-0.3405067325,
-0.8846797347,
0.2959539294,
-0.4227451384,
-0.2188286036,
0.9858820438,
0.7730891109,
0.7817592025,
0.1257834285,
1.0600371361,
0.0276207086,
0.9126046896,
-0.161868602,
0.6528255343,
-0.0743725821,
0.0325812474,
-0.585385859,
-1.1211116314,
-0.0558879897,
0.5152832866,
-0.414593339,
0.3114685714,
0.5478907228,
0.777533114,
0.106385164,
0.0003361694,
-0.1421556324,
0.4022197127,
0.3276524246,
0.2400571257,
0.6941980124,
-0.3807590902,
0.3833870888,
-0.2249152809,
-0.5017874241,
-0.2377341241,
-0.7599185705,
-0.9245331883,
-0.2650249302,
-0.2014422417,
-0.3824619353,
0.3393998742,
0.8063105941,
0.7679194212,
-0.7379647493,
-0.4624399841,
0.1356072575,
0.283053726,
-0.287938863,
-0.2168924958,
0.2192426026,
-0.0320363045,
-0.8327081203,
-0.1741443872,
0.1611629725,
-0.4464303851,
-0.3308657706,
0.0628256127,
-0.7000350952,
0.162490651,
0.4648736119,
0.1225551739,
-0.1884822845,
-0.4535322189,
-0.034085609,
-0.1975817978,
0.054301545,
0.6183145642,
-0.3678722978,
0.4951036274,
0.6463842988,
0.256223917,
0.481734246,
-0.0647823289,
0.7356093526,
-0.789010942,
0.1287721694,
-0.2051855177,
0.361528784,
0.5046095848,
-0.0269282423,
0.9334045053,
0.3015263677,
-0.6000568271,
-1.0621452332,
0.3320418,
-0.3830011189,
-0.0981402248,
1.196241498,
0.0081088208,
-0.1544241905,
-0.5427036285,
-0.2713681161,
0.3222283125,
-0.4024642408,
0.8907939792,
0.9985686541,
-0.2435130477,
-0.0051419795,
-1.1407159567,
0.6259632111,
0.6010047793,
-0.6518756747,
0.5983077884,
0.5499833226,
0.2778129876,
0.1612825543,
0.7823036909,
-0.3634312153,
0.006201826,
-0.0555300936,
0.3828293979,
0.493178457,
-0.3634205461,
0.025244372,
-0.191694051,
0.0118973898,
-0.1824373305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04818v1
|
DWE+: Dual-Way Matching Enhanced Framework for Multimodal Entity Linking
| 2024-04-07T05:56:42 | 2024-04-07T05:56:42 |
Shezheng Song, Shasha Li, Shan Zhao, Xiaopeng Li, Chengyu Wang, Jie Yu, Jun Ma, Tianwei Yan, Bin Ji, Xiaoguang Mao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal entity linking (MEL) aims to utilize multimodal information
(usually textual and visual information) to link ambiguous mentions to
unambiguous entities in knowledge base. Current methods facing main issues:
(1)treating the entire image as input may contain redundant information. (2)the
insufficient utilization of entity-related information, such as attributes in
images. (3)semantic inconsistency between the entity in knowledge base and its
representation. To this end, we propose DWE+ for multimodal entity linking.
DWE+ could capture finer semantics and dynamically maintain semantic
consistency with entities. This is achieved by three aspects: (a)we introduce a
method for extracting fine-grained image features by partitioning the image
into multiple local objects. Then, hierarchical contrastive learning is used to
further align semantics between coarse-grained information(text and image) and
fine-grained (mention and visual objects). (b)we explore ways to extract visual
attributes from images to enhance fusion feature such as facial features and
identity. (c)we leverage Wikipedia and ChatGPT to capture the entity
representation, achieving semantic enrichment from both static and dynamic
perspectives, which better reflects the real-world entity semantics.
Experiments on Wikimel, Richpedia, and Wikidiverse datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of DWE+ in improving MEL performance. Specifically, we optimize
these datasets and achieve state-of-the-art performance on the enhanced
datasets. The code and enhanced datasets are released on
https://github.com/season1blue/DWET
|
[
-0.7676461935,
-0.778319478,
0.3588777483,
0.1951260865,
-0.2528918087,
0.3097641766,
-0.1044565514,
-1.0248849392,
0.3630746007,
0.121334739,
-0.6254840493,
-0.2880181074,
-0.3763247728,
0.1350927502,
-0.1825611442,
0.5801069736,
-0.1883080751,
-0.1292683184,
-0.6264012456,
-0.3585417867,
-0.2829627395,
0.1443238258,
-0.6568843126,
-0.1585191488,
0.9312691092,
0.414780736,
0.9997695088,
0.6134727001,
0.7592554092,
0.3255411088,
0.2966324091,
0.6048331857,
-0.3499708176,
0.3139196932,
-0.4638549685,
-0.2434005737,
-0.7022694945,
-0.0384361632,
0.5142768621,
0.4446820319,
0.1136076376,
0.2294609994,
-0.0888719708,
0.5991778374,
-0.6426663399,
0.2695995569,
-0.7877265811,
-0.1265856177,
-0.4802929461,
-0.2902761102,
0.0939674079,
-0.0933168232,
0.0135887237,
-0.9105356932,
0.0642159805,
0.2532907724,
0.8893014789,
0.2896370292,
-0.9716181159,
-0.279127121,
-0.3485040963,
0.5830093026,
-0.4544378519,
0.4720954895,
0.2557916939,
0.2002171278,
-0.2949943244,
-0.7716547847,
-1.2413764,
-0.2788586617,
-0.1217305139,
0.1444050819,
0.0379887149,
0.2257315665,
0.3545580506,
0.7790859342,
-0.2567625642,
-0.0022317579,
-0.1018098891,
-0.2871210575,
0.8001080751,
0.0884974971,
0.584187746,
-0.2369708568,
-0.8072026372,
-0.1278543174,
-0.5628682971,
-0.3291831911,
0.438670963,
-0.0470588505,
-0.1824350506,
0.7101216316,
-0.115852505,
0.6657270193,
0.0902665928,
-0.3433901072,
0.5340620279,
-0.3947151601,
0.0925578773,
-0.0573609136,
0.6876707673,
0.8037413955,
0.018512072,
-0.2507019043,
-0.0174268186,
0.4652890563,
-0.155158326,
-0.7268563509,
-0.3046326935,
0.0507605821,
-0.3238219917,
-0.3349308968,
-0.0721042603,
-1.1446701288,
-0.5747909546,
-0.5160114765,
0.5889505148,
-0.3296529949,
-0.6734887958,
-0.1115298644,
-0.3581272066,
-0.1021077335,
0.2981700301,
-0.8150089979,
0.1733304262,
0.2497748435,
0.5607607961,
-0.2595764697,
-0.3718967438,
-0.179041028,
0.6732125878,
0.1285933554,
0.5527639389,
-0.6430729628,
-0.2139679193,
-0.1804284751,
-0.0829966366,
-0.043517109,
-0.5331118107,
0.3963580132,
-0.6750128865,
0.020875439,
-0.2910438776,
-0.516083777,
-0.2956373096,
0.2325215042,
-0.9553323984,
1.1659173965,
0.04829273,
-1.0240595341,
0.4289157093,
-0.7369206548,
-0.6045719385,
-0.0928825513,
-0.4299190044,
-0.0583011359,
-0.0598806366,
0.0833389089,
0.32411924,
-0.2958903909,
0.4166069031,
-0.7030800581,
-0.1425593048,
0.0097505059,
-0.4941367209,
0.5201739669,
0.1161142588,
-0.5197193623,
-0.0804291219,
-1.2228058577,
-0.1705227494,
0.3274015784,
-0.3827095926,
-0.7033730149,
-0.0287344679,
0.0687886477,
0.578543365,
0.377076149,
-0.6880401969,
0.3502151966,
0.0140555883,
0.257072866,
0.5857864022,
-0.1151508838,
0.5746424794,
-0.0384577401,
0.1017211303,
0.3440957963,
0.0864252299,
-0.0197291728,
-0.5081495643,
-0.7911177278,
-0.4213122427,
0.3245441318,
0.5662606955,
-1.1712645292,
0.2698644102,
-0.2633068562,
-0.1189500764,
-0.6781855226,
0.2078656852,
0.1609432399,
0.7735144496,
0.5888202786,
-0.2705269754,
-0.7416342497,
-1.0706036091,
0.2289385498,
-0.0325867496,
-0.0286773741,
0.5556984544,
0.3687905669,
-0.6003036499,
0.7437850833,
-0.4151016474,
-0.1696983278,
0.1676157415,
-0.0372228958,
-0.3437722623,
0.3737979531,
0.5693962574,
-1.4467488527,
-0.5561491847,
0.0587501898,
-0.994969666,
0.1257390231,
0.229999423,
-0.5338977575,
-0.2289465964,
0.2240377069,
-0.6192760468,
0.3356454074,
0.8135924339,
-0.2892484963,
0.229999423,
0.0449431501,
0.5489947796,
-1.3205224276,
0.0991908312,
0.1495117396,
-0.3653645217,
-0.190827623,
0.0732913464,
0.145768702,
-0.1573548466,
-0.0569595173,
0.5882409215,
-0.6284006238,
0.1001417041,
-0.1923606396,
0.4994143248,
0.3430189788,
0.5502843857,
-0.074835971,
0.7078451514,
0.8101161122,
-0.6687678695,
1.0183486938,
0.2295954376,
-0.0344548225,
0.8180761933,
-0.2014415413,
0.0911356732,
-0.1917593479,
0.2524731159,
-0.8692413568,
-0.3137073815,
0.1841169298,
-0.0763507038,
0.834312737,
0.2449959815,
-0.3633491993,
-0.4286572933,
-0.613587141,
0.4728561938,
-0.0053213323,
-0.6233254671,
0.6720120907,
0.5433911681,
-0.054015696,
-0.680345118,
-0.6415061951,
0.3417261541,
-0.074413158,
-0.8909229636,
1.0485373735,
-0.080530785,
-0.1880928725,
0.4227038324,
-0.2907145023,
-0.032300584,
-0.0632189587,
0.2019743621,
0.4650222957,
-0.1928600967,
0.1691007167,
0.1839210242,
-0.0557021648,
-0.3748960793,
-0.0627316535,
0.2252503335,
0.0962640122,
-0.3538038433,
-0.4723408818,
0.6627827883,
0.7229258418,
-0.2284470499,
0.767608583,
1.0198458433,
-0.409664005,
0.3835747838,
-0.7856385112,
-0.0394406356,
-0.4617345631,
0.415417701,
-0.6301009059,
-0.7450853586,
0.5563074946,
-0.3314768076,
0.0508279949,
0.5800293088,
0.1998210996,
-0.2485231608,
0.8991513252,
0.9320727587,
-0.0647013932,
0.5676753521,
-0.1200227737,
0.1245704144,
-0.943347156,
-0.5227150321,
0.0037367216,
-0.6575917006,
-0.7796357274,
-0.3997893035,
0.145571664,
0.4268893898,
0.1988888532,
0.4089936912,
-0.3171333969,
0.0960784703,
0.6325908899,
0.4398030341,
0.4976354539,
0.0564922504,
-0.2612471581,
-0.0699126571,
-0.577970922,
-0.2827315927,
0.7339849472,
0.2740522623,
0.9661495686,
0.310741514,
0.5162783265,
0.1231191829,
0.1942416281,
-0.6270632744,
0.6558021903,
0.0349626355,
-0.7381983995,
-0.1268378347,
-0.6221478581,
-0.7161021829,
0.234579429,
-0.6020955443,
-0.4264889061,
0.4439959526,
0.3370369971,
0.1857492328,
0.392175585,
-0.7524419427,
0.7373122573,
-0.2659614682,
-0.6691431999,
-0.5015812516,
-0.7943962216,
0.2758687139,
0.09703134,
0.1563626081,
-0.3793967962,
-0.3580848277,
0.4548356235,
-0.0101925274,
0.4911114275,
-0.1846896708,
-0.257915318,
0.2403328866,
-0.1204574034,
0.4152960479,
0.3428433836,
-0.0180096682,
0.2470598668,
-0.1138046235,
-0.3528866768,
-0.6220197082,
1.0755062103,
-0.4416904449,
-0.5822665095,
-0.0102741774,
-0.5998989344,
-0.3796059489,
0.0441490561,
0.1164007932,
0.6980917454,
0.0263060499,
0.0890537351,
0.7422953248,
-0.0510838255,
0.3866972625,
0.3848741651,
-0.120095484,
-0.5000926852,
0.818846643,
-0.2592417002,
0.2274839878,
0.6621057391,
-0.2518014014,
-0.5241151452,
-0.2542397976,
-0.8958055973,
0.0810723603,
-0.6852064729,
-0.5848243237,
-0.5883295536,
0.1363654584,
-0.2556011379,
0.1992838085,
-0.1418436617,
-0.3818251193,
-0.0007908801,
0.0087362155,
0.5826899409,
0.4161128104,
-0.0920856819,
-0.4623118639,
-0.7109767795,
0.6896025538,
0.4960320294,
0.6188864112,
0.145248428,
0.1291728318,
-0.0361955427,
0.1719921678,
-0.2197286934,
-1.0809795856,
-0.4630837739,
0.4298985004,
0.7325232029,
0.2646227479,
-0.0563577451,
1.0110156536,
-0.6081616879,
0.4430989921,
0.5072764158,
-0.5903726816,
0.6281137466,
-0.1873873472,
-0.092062369,
0.6113279462,
0.5210520625,
-0.4243718982,
-0.23407197,
-0.378616631,
-0.9701854587,
0.2075229734,
0.1338826567,
0.1668862998,
-0.2984192371,
0.3455451131,
0.0474797487,
0.2422565669,
-0.6762945056,
-0.5664992929,
0.0079028802,
-0.5302853584,
0.2902992964,
-0.4301832914,
-0.1993646175,
-0.4279313684,
0.6748718023,
-0.0853858516,
0.2187901884,
0.3289671242,
-0.45212695,
-0.1332232505,
0.0901649594,
0.2110779732,
0.6799869537,
-0.0312820747,
0.3281109929,
0.1771900058,
-0.567285955,
0.112577565,
0.4327417016,
0.0511254147,
0.0788544491,
0.1798080057,
0.781680882,
0.4849304259,
-0.3898326457,
0.5585101843,
-0.0222062785,
0.0480856411,
0.0864311755,
0.020496523,
0.197697714,
0.4445359707,
0.4245763123,
0.2089998871,
0.361953944,
-0.7470423579,
0.3409214914,
0.4800791144,
-0.2221996039,
-0.2732452452,
0.6924554706,
0.7813411355,
0.2190524638,
0.3833294213,
-0.2579039335,
-0.3423535228,
0.2725696564,
0.5998356342,
0.3945596516,
-0.043788828,
-0.1081132367,
0.3232940435,
-0.0783725455,
0.2372554988,
0.1826142669,
-0.3964777589,
-0.7225868106,
-0.4499692321,
-0.7097539902,
-0.1166999638,
-0.0395831652,
-0.6846300364,
0.3013522327,
0.0576199107,
-0.2996958196,
0.1926593184,
0.0957560465,
-0.7932581306,
0.2253091782,
0.3868416846,
0.9899142981,
-0.4806153774,
0.880546093,
0.9520858526,
-0.615747869,
-0.6308805346,
-0.1429135352,
0.0651394129,
-0.6394222379,
0.3470963538,
0.0549783148,
-0.2827079296,
0.2510152757,
-0.0626321584,
-0.8621589541,
1.4139537811,
0.4872217774,
-0.860378027,
-0.0683966875,
-0.3355621397,
0.0771862939,
-0.1176667213,
0.0429457128,
0.1132451892,
0.4853798449,
0.3713835478,
-1.073225379,
0.1981000453,
-0.2453138083,
0.0453776717,
0.5405315757,
-0.5297466516,
0.3841375113,
-0.2882369459,
-0.3554375768,
-0.0319231823,
0.6627739668,
-0.1264252514,
0.5322504044,
0.5694285631,
0.7506633997,
0.8161309958,
0.0409920402,
0.6985685825,
-0.3350550234,
0.418448478,
0.9024487734,
-0.4436318874,
0.8238115907,
0.6367500424,
-0.2509840429,
0.7198770642,
0.4393055737,
-0.0356768966,
0.7969374061,
-0.1714344472,
-0.7012884617,
0.0304343887,
-0.1986242533,
-0.5711997151,
0.2134827673,
0.3085671961,
-0.209525004,
-0.3147395253,
0.1916894466,
-0.1267485619,
0.1361022294,
-0.4486377239,
0.7912251353,
0.0479670279,
-0.2696979642,
0.1301982254,
-0.0239795092,
1.1463569403,
-0.5486646891,
-0.2340855151,
-0.0694416687,
0.0345840901,
-0.5092661977,
-0.7884671092,
0.1859761775,
-0.2584313154,
-0.3583019376,
0.1599677354,
1.2306158543,
-0.8084285855,
-0.2339724302,
0.4974828959,
0.2590769529,
-0.234230414,
0.0881092772,
-0.8490338326,
-0.0352499932,
0.0054879915,
-0.1888253242,
0.3698346317,
0.5344167948,
-0.0854860023,
0.5221438408,
0.5429247618,
-0.2855302095,
-0.021032311,
0.2642446756,
1.0617411137,
-0.5724048018,
-0.0477682352,
-0.9361432791,
0.5657796264,
-0.5791390538,
-0.0920029432,
0.7451099753,
0.6819813848,
0.9140736461,
0.1510952115,
0.5802645683,
-0.5145478249,
0.0127386888,
-0.4095821679,
0.2410013825,
-0.7970799208,
-0.1780952066,
-0.3209539354,
-1.1226530075,
-0.1307994723,
0.4350661635,
0.1781661063,
0.0203699656,
0.578465879,
0.7894716859,
-0.4026622474,
-0.0358998701,
0.3456073999,
-0.2280128151,
-0.048734054,
0.4529455006,
0.7954529524,
-0.5404444933,
0.6294127703,
-0.3022058904,
-0.3967337906,
-0.1456977725,
-0.9902668595,
-0.6497182846,
-0.6395574212,
-0.6171506643,
-0.2752187252,
-0.1187450364,
0.6703585982,
0.794444859,
-0.5098795295,
0.43737638,
0.0844565704,
0.0364734977,
-0.0655178428,
-0.2281201035,
0.2033851296,
0.0023739485,
-0.7458841801,
0.2571569979,
0.7676743269,
0.2369644344,
-0.3585062921,
0.023916373,
-0.3671814799,
-0.1827690303,
0.7307904959,
-0.0497489236,
-0.6284655333,
-0.2475241721,
-0.1606478393,
-0.3142699003,
0.0808763877,
0.6486515403,
-0.4290380478,
0.5187630057,
0.3328172863,
0.5053792,
0.6523951888,
-0.122857675,
0.4109115303,
-0.8616791964,
0.4292354882,
0.1631315798,
0.4856466055,
0.5595980883,
-0.4910104573,
0.4430405796,
0.3525338769,
-0.2338495404,
-0.4885370433,
0.4436047077,
-1.1252704859,
-0.0018022873,
0.9510771632,
-0.1852900535,
-0.0411471315,
-0.0018755388,
-0.3229618073,
0.3569566011,
-0.2235997617,
0.5266622305,
0.5716898441,
-0.0135149956,
-0.0853291228,
-0.6256894469,
0.5084862709,
-0.0969526693,
-0.6878405213,
-0.2799117267,
0.5757449865,
0.4115267992,
0.3174902797,
0.5265337229,
-0.2358241379,
0.2000008523,
0.311785996,
0.1169213504,
-0.244740054,
-0.2177010179,
0.2905929089,
-0.1141343638,
-0.0532694049,
-0.4948487282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04817v1
|
FRACTAL: Fine-Grained Scoring from Aggregate Text Labels
| 2024-04-07T05:54:28 | 2024-04-07T05:54:28 |
Yukti Makhija, Priyanka Agrawal, Rishi Saket, Aravindan Raghuveer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are being increasingly tuned to power complex
generation tasks such as writing, fact-seeking, querying and reasoning.
Traditionally, human or model feedback for evaluating and further tuning LLM
performance has been provided at the response level, enabling faster and more
cost-effective assessments. However, recent works (Amplayo et al. [2022], Wu et
al. [2023]) indicate that sentence-level labels may provide more accurate and
interpretable feedback for LLM optimization. In this work, we introduce methods
to disaggregate response-level labels into sentence-level (pseudo-)labels. Our
approach leverages multiple instance learning (MIL) and learning from label
proportions (LLP) techniques in conjunction with prior information (e.g.,
document-sentence cosine similarity) to train a specialized model for
sentence-level scoring. We also employ techniques which use model predictions
to pseudo-label the train-set at the sentence-level for model training to
further improve performance.
We conduct extensive evaluations of our methods across six datasets and four
tasks: retrieval, question answering, summarization, and math reasoning. Our
results demonstrate improved performance compared to multiple baselines across
most of these tasks. Our work is the first to develop response-level feedback
to sentence-level scoring techniques, leveraging sentence-level prior
information, along with comprehensive evaluations on multiple tasks as well as
end-to-end finetuning evaluation showing performance comparable to a model
trained on fine-grained human annotated labels.
|
[
-0.4425896108,
-1.3156683445,
0.4338843822,
0.1232501566,
-0.0693655387,
-0.241729185,
-0.3171933591,
-0.2420680225,
-0.2187669426,
0.2719740868,
-0.4680293798,
-0.7496655583,
-0.5053644776,
0.2350777835,
-0.1713822782,
1.2669993639,
0.2134371102,
-0.0962914526,
-0.5734086037,
-0.0444956943,
-0.2782390416,
-0.6360551715,
-0.7111077309,
-0.4286234677,
0.5856564641,
0.3603828549,
0.4010312557,
0.6640459895,
0.5435648561,
0.3967816532,
-0.2168099284,
0.2999296784,
-0.7152712941,
0.1568668187,
0.0858763605,
-0.5348538756,
-0.6650475264,
0.3285809457,
0.8086177111,
0.7707842588,
-0.3536193073,
0.3386145234,
0.3643883169,
0.5966706276,
-0.4546611011,
0.5125827193,
-0.6312268376,
0.2556729615,
-0.1347329021,
-0.1336611807,
-0.7655165792,
-0.6117597222,
0.0197405256,
-0.5846258402,
0.1369382292,
0.3107007146,
0.6993521452,
0.4350168109,
-0.0830579847,
-0.4538493454,
-0.4349413514,
1.0959564447,
-0.6491245031,
0.0958492756,
0.4277573526,
-0.0168484244,
-0.0979617462,
-0.6654471159,
-0.2951743305,
-0.348510474,
-0.270578444,
0.1955278516,
-0.4374839365,
0.1140040457,
0.3014783859,
0.5941323042,
-0.4242351055,
0.3100955486,
-0.1027479842,
-0.3507357836,
0.6250976324,
0.3971517086,
-0.0756903291,
-0.0639215633,
-0.2277350426,
-0.1448569149,
-0.4415965676,
0.2777374983,
0.128134504,
0.4512851834,
-0.0892277285,
0.5905911326,
-0.0794084966,
1.0719411373,
0.3360102475,
-0.3621656895,
0.1658390164,
-0.2126370817,
-0.3250527084,
0.1671492755,
0.9901716113,
0.3303634524,
0.2070631683,
0.0022033006,
-0.3857227862,
-0.0343852527,
0.1540636867,
-0.9097549915,
-0.3773532212,
-0.0109199369,
-0.47195068,
-0.4265025854,
-0.0249022953,
-0.9085397124,
-0.3247222602,
-0.4220848978,
0.4991475046,
-0.5590135455,
0.3843208849,
0.0281734616,
0.2484950572,
-0.2497671247,
0.2702724934,
-0.8477087617,
0.2857800722,
0.5499113798,
1.0426094532,
0.1842033118,
-0.3559197783,
-1.1750080585,
-0.0202156529,
-0.3163034022,
0.8966055512,
-0.772639513,
-0.392198652,
-0.0347511061,
-0.4428706467,
-0.2413016707,
-0.6235808134,
0.4106231332,
-0.3388884068,
0.5029641986,
-0.118695654,
-0.8085343242,
-0.1552378386,
0.3794225454,
-0.6951981783,
1.1282835007,
0.0521325171,
-0.7267796397,
0.2666260302,
-0.559132874,
-0.5622957945,
-0.1077211946,
0.0001065759,
-0.6689638495,
0.2296038121,
0.2913667262,
0.7443766594,
-0.2328570187,
0.0303859394,
-0.3173156381,
-0.1840512753,
0.1144671589,
-0.5578653812,
0.3526624441,
0.3560373485,
-0.1104780808,
0.3096740246,
-0.8185118437,
0.0546982288,
-0.3649441302,
-0.7983757854,
-0.3509273529,
0.0087363776,
-0.2549315393,
0.0241127275,
0.4355610311,
-0.3212513626,
0.3261560202,
-0.3393150568,
0.3108842373,
0.6926736236,
-0.0233423449,
0.4331375659,
-0.3664468229,
0.3684128225,
0.0423259549,
0.1297551394,
-0.3007506728,
-0.4818609357,
-0.7267981172,
-0.3132016361,
0.258657366,
0.485324502,
-0.5645984411,
0.7927598357,
-0.1416901648,
-0.4782347381,
-0.6328583956,
0.3090482354,
0.5362569094,
0.8375675678,
0.5522170067,
-0.0092328759,
-0.2036626488,
-0.7949560881,
-0.267747134,
-0.1677696258,
-0.0268389303,
0.2679353952,
0.1188849509,
0.0874173716,
0.9306194782,
-1.0064325333,
-0.7311205268,
-0.397998631,
0.6291341782,
0.188407585,
0.1638513356,
0.3355048299,
-0.5649422407,
-0.3760827184,
-0.0046740845,
-0.6281378865,
-0.3898852766,
-0.2261233628,
0.2405221611,
0.2509545684,
0.7063118815,
-0.2768818438,
-0.0120372316,
0.6063587666,
-0.3343474865,
0.3429729044,
-0.4772944152,
0.233853206,
-1.0214086771,
-0.0943581164,
0.5875180364,
-0.3045907021,
-0.3923594058,
-0.12120004,
-0.2265321612,
0.1728560627,
-0.1936143637,
0.2514923215,
-0.4463720918,
0.1822179258,
-0.178959161,
0.049583368,
-0.1188040227,
0.4319457114,
-0.2164508253,
0.9914501905,
0.423528403,
-0.6474573016,
0.2154952437,
-0.06239428,
-0.5640832782,
0.3906731308,
-0.4743134677,
0.0480381995,
-0.1740448326,
0.2496047318,
-1.0310915709,
-0.1791319996,
-0.169551,
-0.1234337911,
0.1883560419,
0.1144346371,
-0.5506839156,
-0.2494871914,
-0.372661531,
0.2303792685,
0.5360776186,
-0.3340674937,
0.5881263018,
0.519590497,
-0.2071821541,
-0.1855890304,
-0.5527018905,
-0.2584773004,
-0.2897976041,
-0.3501199484,
0.1337750256,
-0.0926917866,
-0.3814654946,
-0.2624529898,
0.0811545476,
-0.1063756272,
0.1631708145,
0.0765631571,
0.1387195289,
-0.2817541659,
0.3003407121,
0.287878722,
-0.1644667983,
-0.1107497811,
-0.142980054,
0.6588370204,
-0.4915632606,
0.0804450065,
-0.4767454267,
0.2602075934,
0.2592206597,
-0.2118742317,
0.7919685841,
0.7505818605,
-0.2351210713,
-0.2219357193,
-0.3872797787,
-0.0802016258,
-0.456117183,
0.4044389129,
-0.4767489731,
-1.396868825,
0.186261639,
-0.2242192775,
0.199443996,
0.5473988056,
0.8268787861,
-0.2250317186,
0.9697076678,
0.7232806087,
-0.2900916934,
0.4244916439,
-0.2366507798,
0.2951634526,
-0.5315258503,
-0.2970050275,
-0.4930325449,
-0.3110638261,
-0.2818571925,
-0.4248245656,
0.5008085966,
0.5130324364,
-0.0542609021,
0.0567876846,
-0.4239975214,
0.701153934,
0.3403955996,
0.1291344911,
0.4098849893,
0.072036013,
-0.0148366522,
-0.1281667799,
-0.7681229115,
-0.5918607116,
0.8165971637,
0.3865961432,
0.7391744256,
0.0650457665,
0.7769583464,
0.5138169527,
0.5688435435,
-0.8752815723,
0.5489139557,
-0.5788457394,
-0.0579292364,
-0.5290473104,
-0.7881758809,
-0.7869123816,
0.3144749105,
-0.1963791102,
-0.8793487549,
-0.2514286637,
0.3661330044,
-0.679907918,
0.014346323,
-0.9694628119,
0.840038836,
0.0282994248,
-0.2374949157,
-0.2422633916,
-0.3185564876,
0.3539168537,
-0.279297024,
0.4003470838,
0.0821320117,
0.0392221846,
0.7270299792,
-0.4623054266,
1.0862183571,
0.1002448648,
-0.3717917204,
0.4056726098,
0.0422003008,
0.2979734838,
0.0205186699,
-0.3862077594,
0.1103837937,
-0.1603221893,
-0.1545525342,
-0.4748825729,
0.9440463185,
-0.7633219957,
-0.6377771497,
-0.1950486302,
-0.7965771556,
-0.2362259477,
0.1473568976,
0.2894431055,
0.5364741087,
-0.1008683741,
0.2658944726,
0.8779820204,
-0.0218619741,
0.5740514994,
0.1740140319,
-0.1778993309,
-0.420178324,
0.9346226454,
0.0879948288,
0.1941824257,
0.6783503294,
0.4603355527,
-0.5325103998,
-0.4332263172,
-0.2102626562,
-0.0586765036,
-0.4367386103,
-0.4431902468,
-0.6132633686,
0.034699291,
-0.3957253397,
0.0338691883,
-0.0759274736,
-0.2769160569,
-0.3938985467,
-0.1200324446,
0.3442222476,
0.843606472,
-0.0310846008,
0.5592097044,
-0.8836571574,
0.3224669695,
0.3041580617,
0.3596402705,
0.1452047378,
-0.5955078602,
-0.335137099,
0.0105395559,
-0.4608457685,
-0.535141468,
0.1640214473,
0.4626259506,
0.3902301788,
0.3941115737,
-0.0464486443,
0.8486156464,
-0.62199682,
0.8262116313,
0.3683210909,
-1.1151219606,
0.6165511608,
-0.1698392928,
0.4097157419,
0.6629702449,
0.4054953754,
-0.175962016,
-0.5089932084,
-0.2264485806,
-0.8734120131,
0.9214023352,
0.1697637886,
0.0354732536,
-0.142232582,
0.3997182846,
0.1875398457,
0.1719046086,
-0.8589555621,
-0.2269485146,
-0.0746662021,
-0.5712311268,
-0.2851524949,
-0.2611266673,
-0.1400193423,
-0.3751529157,
0.5424212217,
-0.245048821,
-0.2304383665,
0.1156765595,
-0.2019661516,
0.0041506956,
0.3329980969,
0.6452807188,
0.3636505604,
-0.1337153614,
0.2379279882,
0.2090437263,
-0.5056446791,
0.1062296927,
0.0922752842,
-0.0751669258,
-0.0749646574,
0.6489537358,
0.5756468177,
0.2117942423,
-0.3826951087,
0.2458523065,
0.0525645539,
-0.1240087673,
0.1939848661,
0.2494583577,
0.0688735619,
0.1821862012,
0.2511521876,
-0.1135651246,
0.2154872715,
-0.6179079413,
0.4870806336,
0.1055731103,
-0.6207413673,
-0.0648546815,
0.6141919494,
0.1585336626,
-0.3624122143,
0.5533021092,
-0.2139714807,
-0.266846925,
0.4768901467,
0.494790256,
0.6551486254,
-0.3259055614,
0.3987347782,
0.4694560468,
0.1841947883,
-0.1649028808,
-0.0649297833,
-0.1670728177,
-0.4834907055,
-0.4770759046,
-1.0569040775,
0.0583454035,
0.2098636627,
-0.737814784,
0.0839170292,
-0.6196356416,
-0.3451513052,
0.2564352453,
0.0620385334,
-0.2553931177,
0.4250583053,
0.2285441458,
0.7834439874,
-0.9330282807,
0.8234888911,
0.9124100208,
-0.577180326,
-0.8750306368,
0.2388339937,
-0.0114258574,
-0.4526942074,
0.6040404439,
0.2987048328,
-0.2265522182,
0.2278146744,
-0.3204992414,
-0.6846051216,
0.9763377905,
0.2226238698,
-0.9973210096,
0.181908384,
0.2247627378,
0.7869431376,
-0.5005447268,
0.4064616561,
0.5940061808,
0.3785645962,
-0.062037684,
-0.8384041786,
-0.0997850895,
0.008378421,
0.1223298162,
0.2561843991,
-0.7392073274,
0.8916407824,
-0.1277249157,
0.0746560544,
0.1019363776,
0.8639569879,
0.4226252139,
0.3536282778,
0.7189201713,
0.7555419207,
0.8687440753,
-0.2708353996,
1.1518616676,
-0.1348638237,
0.7453933954,
1.0663815737,
-0.0883971676,
0.8531213403,
0.3841295838,
-0.2034735382,
0.4694244862,
0.6859739423,
-0.0662031695,
0.5404118299,
0.3778896928,
-0.2471550107,
-0.6723153591,
-0.1900109053,
-0.158481881,
0.3482738137,
0.2943699062,
-0.2716644704,
-0.4954818189,
-0.0788771361,
0.0986747518,
0.497146368,
-0.4846715331,
0.9689665437,
0.1544277817,
-0.6227923036,
0.4552769363,
0.1110915244,
0.6748868823,
-0.5005865693,
-0.1770091802,
-0.4382582307,
0.394530803,
-0.3038757145,
-0.9389494061,
0.2216154337,
0.2254201621,
-0.5612310767,
-0.1790656894,
0.2830066085,
-0.6143409014,
-0.8572541475,
0.0895265043,
0.2296571732,
0.1908503473,
0.1429501325,
-0.8109873533,
0.1340610534,
0.1300475746,
-0.3496434987,
0.4280819595,
0.6669415832,
-0.0842352733,
0.6301255226,
0.490113318,
-0.008960356,
0.0095345238,
0.5249111652,
0.7862371802,
-0.5050257444,
-0.4662595391,
-1.0693789721,
0.1977307647,
-0.1446709335,
-0.4234738946,
0.6116445661,
0.9621224403,
0.7361542583,
-0.0305462386,
0.6024185419,
0.0972546414,
0.3657948077,
-0.8990870714,
0.7553173304,
-0.6075741649,
0.4680350125,
-0.3339691758,
-1.0646059513,
-0.4547210336,
0.6995350718,
-0.4464719892,
0.0919038653,
0.7125926614,
0.5089519024,
-0.0648814514,
-0.0781463832,
0.3796016276,
0.4556411505,
0.3795830309,
0.6618018746,
0.7372947335,
-0.3365030885,
0.6938381791,
-0.2322273701,
-0.4264729321,
-0.0475696176,
-0.7204683423,
-0.9279465675,
-0.5531497002,
-0.5040239692,
-0.0666078478,
-0.095581837,
0.585893929,
0.5264057517,
-0.7567114234,
-0.3724151552,
-0.021691462,
0.0903324708,
-0.0789295137,
-0.3074807227,
0.3321638107,
-0.8012288213,
-0.7558807135,
0.1381210387,
0.4142020941,
-0.180851534,
-0.0547125041,
0.0726174936,
-0.1936270893,
-0.0485118516,
0.907746613,
-0.2372253984,
-0.7204009295,
-0.237723276,
-0.3192566335,
-0.2306261957,
0.0309043266,
0.8140175343,
-0.7273467779,
0.1016317457,
0.3028709292,
0.3386801183,
0.1964606792,
0.3587018549,
0.4900485873,
-0.8053699732,
0.0950905234,
0.2130237967,
0.2853099406,
0.255584389,
-0.4815579355,
0.2233468294,
0.0315880775,
-0.4554362595,
-0.5751318932,
0.1072756425,
-0.9882345796,
-0.466447413,
1.1525126696,
-0.3770326972,
-0.2406314015,
0.0626043901,
-0.2610260248,
0.1390154809,
-0.54278934,
1.1459158659,
0.8386316895,
-0.3617805541,
-0.0583895631,
-0.0094205495,
0.5628985167,
0.4562055469,
-0.9837217927,
0.1496989727,
0.8997626305,
0.091100201,
0.3258554339,
0.5119456053,
-0.0469588786,
-0.0165355243,
-0.1495088488,
-0.1446117014,
-0.1062337756,
-0.4385579526,
-0.39033553,
0.6122748852,
-0.0101447841,
-0.1806774884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04809v1
|
Low-Resource Machine Translation through Retrieval-Augmented LLM Prompting: A Study on the Mambai Language
| 2024-04-07T05:04:38 | 2024-04-07T05:04:38 |
Raphaël Merx, Aso Mahmudi, Katrina Langford, Leo Alberto de Araujo, Ekaterina Vylomova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study explores the use of large language models (LLMs) for translating
English into Mambai, a low-resource Austronesian language spoken in
Timor-Leste, with approximately 200,000 native speakers. Leveraging a novel
corpus derived from a Mambai language manual and additional sentences
translated by a native speaker, we examine the efficacy of few-shot LLM
prompting for machine translation (MT) in this low-resource context. Our
methodology involves the strategic selection of parallel sentences and
dictionary entries for prompting, aiming to enhance translation accuracy, using
open-source and proprietary LLMs (LlaMa 2 70b, Mixtral 8x7B, GPT-4). We find
that including dictionary entries in prompts and a mix of sentences retrieved
through TF-IDF and semantic embeddings significantly improves translation
quality. However, our findings reveal stark disparities in translation
performance across test sets, with BLEU scores reaching as high as 21.2 on
materials from the language manual, in contrast to a maximum of 4.4 on a test
set provided by a native speaker. These results underscore the importance of
diverse and representative corpora in assessing MT for low-resource languages.
Our research provides insights into few-shot LLM prompting for low-resource MT,
and makes available an initial corpus for the Mambai language.
|
[
-0.5208435059,
-0.9357855916,
0.4674047232,
0.0859725475,
-0.5102604628,
-0.022686746,
-0.3244499564,
-0.2313238084,
0.2568956614,
0.5844293833,
-0.4725399315,
-0.3174384534,
-0.85742414,
0.8364259005,
-0.1239446178,
0.5310291052,
-0.2484334707,
-0.1130928621,
0.2271938473,
-0.5380800962,
-0.6755942702,
-0.345178932,
-0.5969310999,
-0.1878852993,
0.902159214,
0.9041441679,
0.6771410704,
0.4887312949,
0.3925182521,
0.1369933635,
-0.3506504893,
0.5627678037,
-0.4946378767,
-0.1982164085,
0.1693670452,
-0.7817399502,
-0.1665455997,
-0.110481441,
0.698949635,
0.7795635462,
-0.0115191787,
0.4184571207,
0.4287848473,
0.74135077,
-0.9009444118,
0.0159522723,
-0.5639961958,
0.0359972566,
-0.5051230788,
-0.169046402,
-0.5676414967,
-0.303350538,
-0.3502215147,
-0.5211425424,
-0.1797025055,
0.1627288163,
0.5878737569,
0.6624664068,
-0.6776077151,
-0.2860710025,
-0.3763292134,
0.9652302861,
-0.5499056578,
0.183913067,
0.6785159707,
0.2733546197,
-0.2075434029,
-0.2109912336,
-0.6077082753,
-0.1577327847,
-0.1241229549,
0.1309297681,
-0.3343147635,
0.0136964293,
0.383875221,
0.2144999951,
-0.529237628,
0.4622021019,
-0.4095380008,
0.0025017161,
0.4468729198,
0.2547050118,
-0.0177288018,
-0.5837661028,
-0.0502875857,
-0.0690390766,
-0.9626860619,
-0.0006172776,
0.3463935554,
0.6677165031,
-0.1631958634,
1.2022025585,
-0.178019166,
1.0434545279,
-0.1186730862,
-0.4919060171,
0.184882015,
-0.5727245212,
-0.2021687776,
0.2286351621,
0.9023371339,
0.4038897455,
0.2166493833,
0.3003437221,
-0.2098750025,
-0.2034209371,
0.0472778603,
-0.746991694,
0.3260490596,
0.0962139219,
-0.6078535318,
-0.3123509884,
-0.2589482367,
-0.8072727919,
-0.4043598175,
0.0764205977,
0.2281856537,
-0.5459542871,
-0.0747569948,
-0.2380446941,
0.2298354357,
0.2605296075,
0.0904233679,
-0.909968257,
0.0115316464,
0.2769384086,
1.1559296846,
-0.1853719503,
-0.2774709761,
-1.0107822418,
0.16531308,
-0.4431405365,
0.469607234,
-0.6441460252,
-1.1000337601,
0.1768476367,
0.0339819342,
-0.1006879732,
-0.831148088,
0.6520050764,
-0.3084978461,
-0.0358510502,
-0.4399636686,
-0.2206685692,
-0.3138842583,
0.1353714466,
-0.6505400538,
1.227442503,
0.1601839513,
-0.4334566891,
0.2726365924,
-0.6812880039,
-0.6962867379,
-0.0289385263,
-0.0117909536,
-0.2143786401,
0.2973394096,
0.5921853781,
0.4803559184,
-0.3210586011,
-0.1664082706,
0.0175412856,
-0.4369940758,
0.2697691917,
-0.5398692489,
0.605488658,
0.4760132432,
-0.0566171817,
-0.2269270718,
-0.5636396408,
-0.2145255804,
0.2723720968,
-0.6231971979,
-0.2019753754,
-0.3381184638,
-0.1310486943,
-0.0618151203,
0.2477934211,
-0.3593308628,
0.4815433919,
-0.3636387289,
0.3182712495,
0.5036511421,
0.1227700189,
0.6186410785,
-0.2901251018,
0.6411790252,
0.18157956,
-0.0655080229,
-0.2897664011,
-0.8718408942,
-0.586673975,
-0.3367902637,
0.2772197425,
0.8589959145,
-0.971340239,
0.2881532609,
-0.2102368772,
-0.3249763846,
-1.1933788061,
0.6513649225,
0.2110508978,
0.5169430375,
0.5110709667,
-0.0691979229,
-0.3441522121,
-0.9276931286,
0.0741612837,
-0.1717554629,
-0.2271976024,
0.7553785443,
0.2443981618,
-0.432286799,
0.5178121924,
-0.3731960654,
-0.4441382289,
-0.6147664189,
0.2124123573,
0.458805263,
0.0991061479,
0.6816456318,
-0.6027926803,
-0.2120286077,
0.0948180407,
-0.6304639578,
-0.3309882283,
0.0685719028,
-0.050530795,
0.3892147243,
0.2604987025,
-0.4833301604,
0.1043838188,
0.7534117699,
0.4039156139,
0.0863855183,
-0.1642357856,
0.4087856114,
-1.3249685764,
0.2583743036,
-0.1483654976,
-0.0924182013,
-0.0617268272,
0.0297777783,
-0.0617076531,
-0.2908547819,
-0.7784169912,
0.5446737409,
-0.3974738121,
-0.039264489,
-0.3749260902,
0.5308540463,
-0.1511502415,
0.1579161286,
-0.2685612738,
1.2632805109,
0.032963872,
-0.8338535428,
0.3095141649,
0.3274663091,
-0.1461362988,
0.5265114903,
-0.4182207286,
0.1473616511,
0.0900845677,
0.0314911976,
-0.8765277267,
-0.304793328,
0.4865365922,
-0.247223258,
0.3280757666,
-0.4896842539,
-0.6698371172,
-0.3422114551,
0.0776513591,
0.479346782,
0.7054455876,
-0.4207738936,
0.28488639,
0.2316491306,
-0.4046620727,
-0.6109181046,
-0.876283288,
0.2641470432,
-0.0443615429,
-0.3555287123,
-0.097211957,
-0.0004582309,
-0.2119408101,
-0.0629235879,
0.2327754796,
-0.0275867134,
0.2873164415,
0.1058178544,
0.3319877386,
-0.5071713328,
-0.0060570305,
0.3085642457,
-0.1359575987,
-0.2975040376,
-0.3401761055,
0.4721117318,
0.0743301362,
-0.3169434071,
-0.515827775,
0.3404415846,
0.1973365992,
-0.358437717,
1.0057356358,
0.6344555616,
-0.2406621873,
0.2393841892,
-0.594440937,
-0.0333209522,
-0.3802390695,
-0.0171315707,
-0.7222107053,
-0.951630652,
0.2641912997,
-0.4570803344,
-0.2059703767,
0.3453026116,
0.6977179646,
-0.1024883538,
0.8228504658,
0.6080771089,
-0.4488322139,
0.437335968,
-0.3638104498,
-0.0424213968,
-0.7977591157,
0.0768865421,
-0.5518268943,
-0.54908216,
-0.763426125,
-0.4520034492,
0.4101478159,
0.3267312944,
0.4047189653,
0.4309367836,
-0.3158329427,
0.5208210349,
0.4527840912,
0.157024622,
0.337233752,
0.0180539042,
-0.3801252544,
-0.0604961552,
-0.8059345484,
-0.9307199717,
1.1366443634,
-0.1317114234,
0.4162934422,
0.2948387265,
1.1160713434,
0.1269511282,
0.1999630779,
-0.9890185595,
0.5014110804,
-0.0796630085,
-0.2315736562,
-0.2249998748,
-0.5463564992,
-1.2917462587,
0.1748498529,
-0.3154024482,
-0.3361473083,
-0.0558482781,
-0.0580727942,
-0.4987431169,
0.2546103895,
-0.7906119823,
0.7617293596,
-0.1744823605,
-0.2032108158,
-0.391089797,
-0.4124795496,
0.4626826048,
-0.3124938905,
0.3412122428,
-0.18440108,
-0.5102810264,
0.3771126568,
-0.2098046541,
0.8018622994,
-0.0035668174,
-0.1106712073,
0.6126615405,
0.2781120539,
0.4455656707,
0.0484821871,
-0.523827076,
0.1784339547,
-0.0954783112,
-0.8818513751,
-0.5363480449,
0.5811042786,
-0.723501265,
-0.6832357049,
-0.1782426536,
-0.4570456445,
0.1464372277,
0.26558429,
0.3905619681,
-0.1007138193,
-0.2632027864,
0.0295699853,
0.5173352957,
-0.3469721973,
0.2556406856,
0.4546946287,
-0.0111160018,
-0.4336564839,
0.845159173,
0.2829470932,
0.1985754371,
0.3819933832,
0.1091319844,
-0.0687671006,
-0.5292740464,
-1.0118291378,
0.4734537303,
-0.5009269118,
-0.2830854952,
-0.2956630886,
0.1768745035,
-0.2340893,
-0.2198124528,
-0.1518093497,
-0.3703804612,
-0.4386036396,
-0.1625049412,
0.2767647803,
0.9323889613,
0.0429748558,
0.379788965,
-1.1474221945,
0.1786006838,
-0.0558802485,
-0.3020181358,
-0.2358886302,
-0.6844866276,
-0.2099057436,
0.0767927617,
-0.30535537,
-0.9679124355,
0.4050600231,
0.0109623102,
0.5292378664,
0.1599943489,
0.2300345451,
0.7132388353,
-0.6720992327,
0.9260765314,
0.091890797,
-0.7412086129,
1.0621384382,
0.0417518206,
0.2780599594,
0.5645818114,
0.5191233158,
-0.5102730989,
-0.3855216503,
-0.2486382425,
-0.5607517362,
0.4930748641,
0.0720432773,
0.1152545065,
-0.2561671138,
0.5285819173,
0.1287739128,
0.2166393846,
-0.3368629813,
-0.1939805746,
0.004203368,
-0.2849340737,
-0.27808851,
-0.439841181,
-0.1513175517,
0.2081263065,
0.4562123716,
-0.3779875636,
0.0122840898,
0.2112568766,
-0.5732151866,
-0.26099962,
0.5319170952,
0.6416257024,
0.2493210137,
0.1038606986,
0.0280894917,
0.8422555327,
-0.2314156592,
0.3875240982,
0.1320945024,
-0.2713805139,
0.1791482568,
0.28820315,
0.5765292645,
0.3640348911,
-0.509149909,
0.4289612472,
0.2984010875,
0.168982923,
0.0876066163,
0.0497300252,
-0.1198820546,
0.227859363,
0.3048296571,
0.0205067862,
0.0513521284,
-0.2855345905,
-0.1851168722,
0.1020541787,
-0.1332312822,
-0.107698828,
0.7751716971,
0.4179670513,
-0.3061974943,
0.6825978756,
-0.4381329119,
0.0298312642,
0.0844192132,
0.2913422287,
0.5046104193,
-0.2568923831,
0.1255014241,
0.5304665565,
0.5795846581,
-0.0517605618,
0.1925390214,
-0.1480765939,
-0.4319387972,
-0.5773437619,
-0.5165961385,
-0.6331723928,
-0.1723649204,
-0.5474429727,
0.4967712164,
-0.2405380458,
-0.3663652241,
-0.3281546533,
0.1577942818,
-0.6357730031,
-0.3316788077,
0.2547310293,
0.969522357,
-0.6602556705,
0.9668956995,
0.7225068212,
-0.9911875725,
-0.5782573819,
-0.0574708208,
0.202723369,
-0.9709393978,
0.7167333961,
0.0350850001,
-0.2767496705,
0.1770554632,
-0.389837265,
-0.4887689054,
1.1390311718,
0.6502236724,
-0.6345447898,
0.1393494159,
0.3682047725,
0.2170987278,
-0.1601709127,
0.1356033981,
0.4854486287,
0.5746572018,
0.0265139062,
-0.9773600101,
0.0609565973,
0.1493753344,
0.1537078917,
0.1863385737,
-0.7457435727,
0.3168912828,
-0.5975531936,
-0.2712635696,
0.4307787716,
0.7582688928,
0.4112178087,
0.206966728,
0.2911991775,
0.3066962957,
1.037091732,
-0.022381844,
1.3852653503,
-0.3051974177,
-0.1768710762,
0.5599943399,
-0.5120922923,
1.2503602505,
0.6836714149,
-0.1540153325,
0.2746066749,
0.7087786794,
0.1296972632,
0.2689428031,
-0.1181608588,
-0.5231727362,
-0.1653765291,
-0.6084084511,
-0.2635006011,
0.2848474085,
0.3595178425,
-0.2495114952,
0.0916693807,
0.2507985532,
0.1132766083,
0.1084284857,
-0.2510999441,
0.7490469813,
0.479944855,
-0.5982000828,
0.9599511623,
0.0526025817,
0.7079370022,
-0.4382277131,
0.1043448746,
-0.4154379368,
0.0050223107,
-0.2570540905,
-0.8880620599,
0.3015863001,
0.3050115108,
-0.0752957389,
-0.1283285022,
0.3583748341,
-0.3502116501,
-0.5441206694,
0.3668821752,
0.8601729274,
0.4254836738,
0.2026917636,
-0.612519443,
0.2346746624,
-0.1171804965,
-0.0271619838,
0.3880912662,
0.5732547641,
0.0736254081,
0.6013677716,
0.6783162355,
0.1464832723,
0.0559457578,
0.1655021906,
0.6389926672,
-0.5752107501,
-0.1342040598,
-0.8957549334,
0.0901767612,
0.2463156879,
-0.2575008273,
0.6799411178,
0.7567760944,
0.7939194441,
-0.0237410739,
0.7166478038,
0.3103906512,
0.3144599497,
-0.8440525532,
0.489993602,
-0.6542922854,
0.1909378618,
-0.1530682296,
-0.8976113796,
-0.2232329249,
0.4505575001,
-0.2942094803,
-0.3391996026,
0.5947442651,
0.9447088838,
0.0040700925,
-0.2411245704,
0.5935001373,
0.1862966418,
-0.0341692753,
0.6142881513,
0.6666828394,
-0.449188292,
1.2273529768,
0.0009934081,
-0.132095769,
-0.4331766665,
-0.6401184201,
-0.6737374067,
-0.258730948,
-0.1502038985,
-0.3735026121,
0.037901938,
1.1051143408,
0.245132491,
-0.7702913284,
-0.4559170008,
0.427257061,
0.3116723597,
-0.2567287087,
-0.1280084103,
0.0174937863,
-0.4680099189,
-0.9939367771,
0.864659965,
0.3326821625,
0.2175341994,
-0.0516090021,
-0.3953738213,
-0.287458986,
-0.1335601509,
0.8100398779,
0.1743814498,
-0.9594163299,
-0.0693702474,
0.1930203438,
-0.4229853153,
0.1654488742,
0.5786383152,
-0.7376359701,
0.2984651327,
0.3199863136,
0.9124872088,
0.5548217297,
-0.2961854637,
0.5667137504,
-0.8754325509,
0.6218232512,
-0.0511308983,
0.5673475862,
0.4795298874,
-0.2081512511,
0.7972341776,
0.4100913703,
-0.2956432104,
-0.6995441914,
0.30295524,
-0.7400118709,
0.0333350673,
1.1556562185,
-0.0481395163,
-0.5040969253,
0.1234073415,
-0.6966598034,
0.4422044456,
-0.5064784884,
0.4050167203,
0.8060994744,
-0.031385161,
-0.4523286223,
-0.7463284135,
0.0596637726,
0.4868019223,
-0.4392021894,
-0.2203861028,
0.2952515483,
0.0007077284,
0.215660423,
0.5790142417,
0.0223110002,
0.1603535563,
-0.1191384792,
-0.2143636793,
-0.0217128098,
0.274623543,
-0.5610194206,
-0.1841139495,
0.3374159038,
-0.3401810229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04793v1
|
SqueezeAttention: 2D Management of KV-Cache in LLM Inference via Layer-wise Optimal Budget
| 2024-04-07T03:08:14 | 2024-04-07T03:08:14 |
Zihao Wang, Shaoduo Gan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Optimizing the Key-Value (KV) cache of the Large Language Model (LLM) has
been considered critical to saving the cost of inference. Most of the existing
KV-cache compression algorithms attempted to sparsify the sequence of tokens by
taking advantage of the different importance of tokens. In this work, we found
that by identifying the importance of attention layers, we could optimize the
KV-cache jointly from two dimensions. Based on our observations regarding
layer-wise importance in inference, we propose SqueezeAttention to precisely
optimize the allocation of KV-cache budget among layers on-the-fly and then
incorporate three representative token sparsification algorithms to compress
the KV-cache for each layer with its very own budget. By optimizing the
KV-cache from both sequence's and layer's dimensions, SqueezeAttention achieves
around 30% to 70% of the memory reductions and up to 2.2 times of throughput
improvements in a wide range of LLMs and benchmarks. The code is available at
https://github.com/hetailang/SqueezeAttention.
|
[
-0.1690440476,
-0.4619104564,
0.3712183833,
0.5674831867,
-0.1777362972,
-0.0363127962,
-0.0392095931,
-0.2641178071,
0.3730698824,
0.4636573493,
-0.3287604153,
-0.0499755219,
-0.2983074784,
-0.6228733659,
-0.2260210216,
0.377784729,
-0.0110847987,
0.0902775154,
-0.5024161935,
-0.0030315006,
-0.3864462674,
-0.2483657748,
-0.2808459699,
-0.1745352596,
0.4459542036,
0.7960635424,
0.4691324234,
0.9096565843,
0.2706637084,
0.2997054458,
-0.2890560031,
0.2132425308,
-0.5524829626,
0.1618304551,
-0.0205758531,
-0.7099263668,
-0.1789054126,
0.1025121808,
0.6104711294,
0.2055236399,
-0.077427417,
0.1436087489,
-0.0567536838,
1.0472452641,
-1.1364452839,
-0.09822689,
-0.602376163,
0.055420056,
-0.1412478387,
-0.2422661632,
-0.3184790909,
-0.4783943892,
0.1918718368,
-0.5731915832,
0.2293135822,
-0.1375192851,
0.7985189557,
0.418282479,
-0.1289408952,
0.0070695281,
-0.6053845286,
0.7902520895,
-0.4641723931,
0.3645622134,
0.2623063326,
0.0907821655,
-0.0567082837,
-0.8462407589,
-0.5686643124,
0.0344151556,
0.2181854099,
0.2364899516,
-0.0342513397,
0.1649504006,
-0.070336096,
0.3354956806,
-0.299254775,
0.2773429155,
-0.4132377505,
-0.4276879728,
0.3096534014,
0.078293398,
0.1258657277,
-0.1279907972,
-0.6791113615,
-0.2259973884,
-0.8760797977,
0.0035967133,
0.3979083598,
0.1061887294,
0.1266148686,
0.4291681051,
0.0136522492,
0.262117058,
0.1435541809,
-0.1752190441,
0.0888162553,
-0.200742498,
-0.2864273489,
0.1046523303,
0.2825812995,
0.2555730045,
0.1966889203,
-0.4061515331,
-0.0679756552,
-0.1167438254,
0.5091809034,
-0.9661346674,
-0.2836526334,
0.4641597867,
-0.3191757798,
-0.5354887247,
-0.0963797793,
-0.972279191,
-0.3314870298,
-0.2485554963,
0.454752177,
-0.2261756957,
-0.2083974034,
0.1782673299,
-0.3422758281,
0.20424366,
0.3309235573,
-0.6632604003,
0.4086712003,
0.6114777923,
1.0232821703,
-0.2002438307,
-0.0566206425,
-0.6335408688,
0.3304916024,
-0.1689765751,
0.7970824242,
-0.3503069878,
-0.3155154884,
0.0557273887,
-0.4745185971,
-0.1383459419,
-0.8119472861,
0.4746574461,
-0.8348323107,
-0.3614626527,
-0.2561074793,
-0.6667278409,
-0.1006035432,
0.3020355403,
-1.0304647684,
1.237244606,
0.3057636321,
-0.4811519086,
0.1517845392,
-0.307251513,
-0.3912058473,
0.0814991593,
0.0509212576,
-0.5878446698,
0.4702646136,
0.326905787,
0.3133249879,
-0.3181616664,
-0.0249762461,
-0.2589428425,
-0.21511814,
0.2696244717,
-0.036691688,
0.6401920915,
0.1015771478,
-0.447294116,
-0.0587354153,
-0.6720007658,
0.2918147445,
0.132082507,
-0.4792200923,
-0.359737128,
-0.0030109943,
0.3357122242,
0.1823868155,
0.1856833994,
-0.1619022042,
0.3923758268,
-0.6063219309,
0.7833324075,
0.9223183393,
-0.0634471551,
0.8034948111,
0.0792133287,
0.6576849222,
0.2883096337,
0.2512561083,
0.1218342781,
-0.1185819209,
-1.0107181072,
-0.4655778408,
0.5082054138,
0.5211808681,
-0.4133525491,
0.1823506355,
-0.228689447,
-0.2235424668,
-0.5144838095,
0.2063026279,
0.335229069,
0.2501541376,
0.2457139343,
-0.214291364,
-0.4487859011,
-1.0609599352,
-0.1372877061,
-0.3170474768,
0.4218604565,
0.5713731647,
0.1847807765,
0.0726590529,
0.9933199883,
-0.4234594405,
-0.2830404639,
-0.1280315667,
-0.0418245979,
-0.1855918169,
0.6244344115,
0.4942620993,
-0.8089622259,
-0.3489916325,
-0.2185650021,
0.1892151982,
-0.2933801413,
-0.2266943604,
-0.3771006167,
0.1207828671,
0.4509411752,
-1.0004703999,
0.4634774923,
0.394628644,
0.1097375974,
0.8409767151,
-0.0027045151,
-0.2874513865,
-0.8262640238,
0.0403658785,
-0.2709591389,
-0.2432832271,
-0.4226842523,
0.3197153509,
0.3382972479,
0.149793461,
-0.3987900615,
0.6840814948,
-0.7072606683,
-0.0720773712,
-0.1987551004,
0.3928667009,
0.1673389375,
0.5323374867,
-0.344358623,
0.9284734726,
0.2584981918,
-0.5270389318,
0.1472298205,
-0.0521725118,
-0.5217057467,
0.1217262149,
-0.5354526043,
0.4254467785,
0.141737029,
0.2503115535,
-1.2710148096,
-0.1231310666,
0.0118888589,
-0.2806915939,
0.6600505114,
-0.307956785,
-0.6776207089,
-0.3467841744,
-0.4543285966,
0.6154728532,
0.4458951056,
-0.7518663406,
0.7151015997,
0.7040196657,
0.1676443964,
-0.6498188376,
-0.7038263083,
-0.0809437409,
-0.3703831136,
-0.61687994,
0.5758703351,
0.1197229251,
0.0023616375,
0.0728694052,
-0.5320104361,
-0.0422271527,
0.0138938427,
0.1697317362,
0.0745544285,
-0.198331967,
0.2349113971,
0.2485643774,
-0.2339317352,
0.029389102,
-0.9614522457,
0.6368202567,
0.15178819,
-0.3316741884,
-0.3664215505,
0.1703666896,
0.6323917508,
0.0038176507,
0.5937331915,
0.5474580526,
-0.2189205438,
-0.3968200088,
-1.0446178913,
-0.1132505313,
-0.5237789154,
0.4174255133,
-0.2728771865,
-1.1796350479,
0.6285537481,
-0.3862968385,
-0.2102345526,
0.3210138679,
0.7182220221,
0.0944341421,
0.7355312705,
0.2795730531,
-0.7922770977,
0.3002448976,
-0.4281181991,
0.3003257513,
-0.8263636231,
-0.2140256464,
-0.770280838,
-0.6827149987,
-0.388643831,
-0.9776411653,
0.3256961405,
0.3912924826,
-0.1459757239,
0.0845269263,
-0.4929399788,
0.8010728955,
0.5065706968,
0.0816881061,
-0.2630416751,
0.1433358341,
-0.3721941113,
-0.0256570112,
-0.7475060821,
-0.0767158344,
0.6150827408,
0.3909689784,
0.780520916,
0.1898524612,
0.5508131981,
0.0317956731,
-0.1110763177,
-1.0032496452,
0.4597785175,
0.1192240715,
-0.5608987808,
-0.0856875405,
-0.4265903234,
-0.6895609498,
0.2522375882,
0.4308627844,
-1.1485139132,
0.271604389,
0.5429493785,
-0.3266676962,
0.1801655591,
-0.7400789857,
0.5790523291,
-0.0272906702,
-0.4887373447,
-0.6376823187,
-0.7024285197,
0.343952477,
0.3142946362,
-0.2086170614,
0.1066364199,
-0.3563920856,
0.4884935915,
-0.5886726975,
0.9322557449,
-0.3944292963,
-0.0035710279,
0.4486771524,
0.2379152626,
0.9800609946,
0.104238078,
0.1849500388,
-0.1417062432,
-0.1523902416,
-0.492554456,
-0.8196023107,
0.9310870767,
-0.8931875229,
-0.6738641858,
0.0538491569,
-0.5593828559,
-0.292273134,
0.0343582407,
-0.0811444893,
0.4809584022,
-0.0270897467,
0.0877716988,
0.8471771479,
-0.1822334975,
0.2275908142,
0.1164603531,
0.0540000349,
-0.5123516917,
1.0698516369,
0.0714479163,
0.3411121368,
0.7334235907,
0.4722417891,
-0.3598399758,
-0.5535703897,
-0.4217208028,
0.185184598,
-0.5908746123,
-0.5564424992,
-0.7348054051,
-0.3074504733,
-0.4158867002,
-0.1870453358,
-0.5640760064,
-1.0089949369,
-0.2908333838,
-0.222149983,
0.3794723451,
-0.0020960607,
-0.2045095563,
0.428945899,
-0.7289847732,
-0.0497090444,
0.3616665304,
0.1650856584,
0.4037289917,
-0.4876565039,
-0.576274693,
-0.3943373561,
-0.4218680859,
-0.6830486655,
0.3558801115,
0.2321035862,
0.4123807549,
0.722495079,
-0.1983163357,
1.1104252338,
-0.4835633337,
0.8169161081,
0.1514598429,
-1.0240726471,
0.2853828371,
0.0370365866,
0.3820238113,
0.5389194489,
-0.1111166924,
-0.3500998318,
-0.2149166316,
-0.5092959404,
-1.2360582352,
0.7630853653,
0.2032302469,
0.3141905963,
0.0061511765,
0.5499202609,
-0.2486705631,
0.0376040228,
-0.3376567066,
-0.2452175468,
0.0372592509,
0.0403332226,
0.4672092795,
-0.7461283803,
-0.0158325806,
-0.2939871252,
0.691560626,
-0.0915787742,
0.4938310087,
0.03203962,
-0.1923792362,
-0.0802361965,
-0.0233726278,
0.7365420461,
0.3792955279,
0.1162738875,
0.3809899688,
0.0502123348,
-0.8155096173,
0.1096507981,
-0.0463586524,
-0.0624960512,
-0.2005074322,
0.0389448851,
0.746178627,
0.3518634737,
-0.6298334599,
0.4641508758,
0.263946116,
-0.2647157907,
-0.2014966011,
0.1312980354,
0.3170650899,
0.5078166127,
0.1414352804,
-0.1279314756,
0.3095161319,
0.1419977993,
0.0658994466,
0.4442279339,
-0.2948418558,
-0.2755875289,
0.483740449,
0.1632980257,
-0.0356712714,
0.8014114499,
0.1553282589,
-0.9064497948,
0.7889985442,
0.5855988264,
1.1412736177,
-0.3520700932,
0.0499136299,
0.4979692698,
0.3004995883,
0.0090461764,
0.0787857175,
-0.3896745741,
-0.8270840049,
-0.5480937362,
-0.5693313479,
-0.0144304475,
0.3355497122,
-0.7250636816,
0.0604478419,
-0.3996911347,
0.0676103607,
0.0227689482,
0.0660267174,
-0.6810808182,
-0.0398527682,
-0.1274102181,
1.3054037094,
-0.4141286314,
0.8662151098,
0.2921815217,
-0.0840242431,
-0.9148491621,
0.0229894761,
0.3776068091,
-1.0535564423,
0.850841105,
0.2818873823,
-0.2228205949,
0.0762202367,
-0.6690189838,
-1.1156402826,
0.975163281,
0.2849361598,
-0.5531787872,
-0.0344320349,
0.133522287,
0.0321449414,
-0.0878363699,
0.0197585952,
0.6596744657,
0.5959299803,
0.1483686715,
-0.5428711772,
-0.0726637691,
-0.2645166814,
0.4059796035,
0.5914485455,
-0.891253829,
0.3099401295,
-0.1987908334,
-0.2283013016,
0.2518446147,
0.7109742165,
0.1350661218,
-0.096573092,
0.7422789335,
0.9899009466,
0.5179483294,
0.0911888108,
0.7982349992,
-0.2455347627,
0.3694533706,
0.8775328994,
-0.2155989707,
0.6667466164,
0.9311907887,
-0.3332514465,
0.2974037826,
0.5994753838,
0.2056653202,
0.779147625,
0.6023983955,
-0.3481529355,
-0.1566352397,
0.1503904909,
-0.0291172396,
0.3337121308,
0.5637677312,
-0.2178039253,
-0.0782453716,
-0.2320347428,
0.0071020941,
-0.580139935,
-0.0628334954,
0.6805171371,
0.0373238772,
-0.633646965,
0.3112909794,
0.0287322514,
0.0521994419,
-0.3667749763,
0.1046336144,
-0.2486619055,
0.4604493976,
0.0427303687,
-0.3181412518,
-0.0591061562,
-0.2205388695,
-0.4029344022,
-0.1407133341,
0.8819816709,
-0.4312851727,
-0.2381803244,
0.1924496144,
0.2614236176,
0.1699234247,
-0.0909372494,
-0.6164236069,
0.1866239458,
-0.1437807232,
-0.5433793068,
0.5439605713,
0.4833504856,
0.0437686183,
0.5435839295,
0.5007719398,
0.1563342661,
0.1733222753,
0.4468710721,
1.287512064,
-0.4273410141,
-0.7178836465,
-0.8780239224,
0.6322343349,
-0.0439623408,
-0.2191419303,
0.5791397691,
0.7628721595,
0.6105672121,
-0.0140476096,
0.6272515059,
0.0393083058,
0.1140109599,
-0.7997106314,
0.4963434041,
-0.7247386575,
0.0810742602,
-0.210615471,
-0.8276940584,
-0.2593747675,
0.6470683217,
0.062451452,
0.0929803327,
0.527390182,
1.0242282152,
-0.1936962306,
-0.0467959084,
0.0786243826,
0.1241943166,
0.2325524092,
0.500197649,
0.726115644,
-0.202020362,
0.5323039293,
-0.2774739861,
-0.1244997159,
-0.4800406694,
-0.8159075379,
-0.7119348049,
-0.6159282923,
-0.3707461357,
-0.488350749,
-0.0744836479,
0.7118229866,
1.0818333626,
-0.6508835554,
-0.0496494696,
-0.2917654812,
0.0982336476,
-0.3819727302,
-0.314430654,
0.6748574376,
-0.6281970739,
-0.5731762052,
0.2547599971,
0.7059899569,
-0.2696594596,
-0.5877069235,
-0.0342456922,
-0.0560035035,
0.2286508232,
0.5310515165,
0.1532954872,
-0.9793254137,
-0.2878872454,
0.1116155088,
-0.1494504809,
0.0869039968,
1.482162118,
-0.7634550929,
0.5609036088,
0.5474369526,
1.0928667784,
0.9422012568,
-0.0182126798,
0.377579093,
-1.0093793869,
0.340416491,
0.207045123,
0.1623724848,
0.0172618795,
-0.4994751811,
0.3942189217,
0.2692565024,
-0.7509683967,
-0.7792004943,
0.0970279649,
-1.2177633047,
-0.140161708,
1.2100123167,
-0.0412341058,
-0.4417727888,
-0.0049556401,
-0.1880764365,
0.0596560687,
-0.4194821417,
0.9473756552,
0.7836641073,
0.1657565534,
-0.5461987853,
-0.3836277127,
0.4733338356,
0.5439673066,
-0.6342127323,
0.07803303,
0.4979258776,
0.0359517075,
0.2115615606,
0.464392066,
-0.1415088177,
0.2317707986,
-0.0124354223,
-0.122452952,
0.0557479188,
-0.4070450664,
-0.0374032781,
0.1586774886,
-0.1356855929,
-0.369857192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08677v1
|
PMG : Personalized Multimodal Generation with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-07T03:05:57 | 2024-04-07T03:05:57 |
Xiaoteng Shen, Rui Zhang, Xiaoyan Zhao, Jieming Zhu, Xi Xiao
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the
capabilities of text comprehension and generation. Multi-modal generation
attracts great attention from both the industry and academia, but there is
little work on personalized generation, which has important applications such
as recommender systems. This paper proposes the first method for personalized
multimodal generation using LLMs, showcases its applications and validates its
performance via an extensive experimental study on two datasets. The proposed
method, Personalized Multimodal Generation (PMG for short) first converts user
behaviors (e.g., clicks in recommender systems or conversations with a virtual
assistant) into natural language to facilitate LLM understanding and extract
user preference descriptions. Such user preferences are then fed into a
generator, such as a multimodal LLM or diffusion model, to produce personalized
content. To capture user preferences comprehensively and accurately, we propose
to let the LLM output a combination of explicit keywords and implicit
embeddings to represent user preferences. Then the combination of keywords and
embeddings are used as prompts to condition the generator. We optimize a
weighted sum of the accuracy and preference scores so that the generated
content has a good balance between them. Compared to a baseline method without
personalization, PMG has a significant improvement on personalization for up to
8% in terms of LPIPS while retaining the accuracy of generation.
|
[
-0.6805940866,
-0.9244627953,
0.6620748639,
0.2191803604,
-0.283580035,
-0.0621136874,
-0.5312421918,
0.3422535658,
0.1577552259,
0.3955478072,
-0.79177773,
-0.6035764217,
-0.3774170876,
0.1822905838,
0.1665804535,
0.8875429034,
0.287650615,
0.0334003195,
-0.3707014024,
0.1031166241,
-0.5698238015,
-0.4526103735,
-0.4373521209,
-0.3939216137,
0.7059522271,
0.4055580199,
0.6375619173,
0.4026500285,
0.1173936725,
0.3122228384,
0.1648825407,
0.701099515,
-0.3886317313,
0.4338914454,
0.001183004,
-0.0925065875,
-0.4334712923,
-0.1200460792,
0.550422132,
0.2390725166,
-0.2202982455,
0.0658726096,
-0.0092834067,
0.490576297,
-0.4564012289,
0.0008873075,
-0.6363418698,
0.1135473028,
-0.311517477,
-0.5577130318,
-0.560546875,
-0.2960201502,
-0.0189312045,
-0.4451541901,
0.2324069887,
0.3052476943,
0.4294472635,
0.0274844803,
-0.8905128837,
-0.2146416157,
-0.6535811424,
1.0562133789,
-0.7428018451,
0.3681198061,
0.3441189528,
0.4391308427,
-0.1541626751,
-0.6494062543,
-0.8944857717,
-0.6183227301,
0.0717414021,
0.2381482571,
-0.0676625296,
0.1050209403,
0.1066503301,
0.408167094,
-0.6983111501,
-0.2113057673,
0.0098808631,
-0.1487975121,
0.5967056155,
0.2502893209,
0.3137342036,
-0.4878446162,
-0.5819134116,
-0.1873732805,
-0.6212795377,
-0.1525258571,
0.6874991059,
0.1783515215,
-0.0964023545,
0.8667066693,
-0.2953950763,
0.7441176772,
0.3379892409,
-0.6272892356,
0.507965982,
-0.8283934593,
-0.1001223922,
-0.1891773194,
1.1057192087,
0.7116263509,
0.2437513322,
-0.0453606583,
-0.1202590093,
-0.2623707652,
0.1038631424,
-0.8002082109,
-0.1054453626,
-0.0053428789,
-0.5298841596,
-0.3251399398,
-0.028444346,
-0.7355726957,
-0.3699426055,
-0.5277448893,
0.2476698905,
-0.4163973331,
-0.0707762465,
0.0062845401,
0.0685484931,
-0.173166424,
0.1579922587,
-1.0290163755,
-0.2553140223,
0.0837688223,
0.7283514142,
-0.1975319982,
-0.0951289907,
-0.5191004276,
0.4402591288,
0.1140358597,
0.780362308,
-0.5070478916,
-0.5848001242,
0.2309423685,
-0.2852191329,
0.1285695732,
-0.3835349381,
0.3336998224,
-0.3423033953,
0.5053709149,
-0.2146548033,
-0.4129149914,
-0.1010792777,
0.4722671509,
-0.2989864945,
0.6993901134,
0.0123739336,
-0.6527747512,
0.4978064597,
-0.5144127011,
-0.2764907181,
0.1848539114,
-0.2035090327,
-0.3463552594,
0.1305110008,
0.3999960423,
0.9061110616,
-0.4412033558,
0.5366651416,
-0.4084345102,
0.2375009954,
0.411943078,
-0.4917270243,
-0.0690169111,
0.5269317627,
-0.027330542,
0.3589240015,
-0.7754731774,
0.1561270058,
0.2308376431,
-0.7941114902,
-0.1297281235,
0.2158167809,
0.4569324553,
0.387850821,
0.5617336631,
-0.4829032421,
0.2594085634,
-0.102850914,
0.4484107494,
0.9528381824,
0.1079232097,
0.4381352365,
-0.4417461455,
0.5732244253,
0.1578046232,
-0.1188560128,
-0.8290351033,
-0.3397211134,
-0.3848851025,
-0.25279212,
0.0610132143,
0.2016851306,
-0.7854678631,
0.5266742706,
-0.1507781446,
-0.1992542595,
0.0814370364,
0.6664996147,
0.3607371449,
0.247256875,
0.0413723774,
-0.1609936804,
-0.3766538799,
-0.9946104288,
0.0336158201,
-0.037161354,
-0.078789793,
0.9023830891,
-0.139348805,
-0.5572139621,
1.0128308535,
-0.9036121368,
-0.1800479889,
-0.3903479278,
0.1905607879,
-0.0672885999,
0.2222656161,
0.4383018315,
-0.9177041054,
-0.5249733925,
0.007172307,
-0.4872318506,
-0.265455842,
-0.2063303739,
-0.1002468094,
-0.163614288,
0.1406391263,
-0.3970335424,
-0.5766622424,
0.8578262329,
-0.3415192664,
0.5136460662,
-0.4108399451,
0.0659455135,
-1.6940906048,
-0.0713202581,
0.4156676829,
-0.5061957836,
-0.5000688434,
-0.0152097847,
-0.2803701758,
-0.1922474504,
-0.4339087009,
0.6995545626,
-0.2696389556,
0.3919964433,
-0.3622280955,
0.3008286357,
-0.067205444,
0.4907169342,
-0.1657751501,
0.7205555439,
0.2960687578,
-0.5715304017,
0.4644519389,
0.3022382855,
-0.0912702829,
0.4878619313,
-0.4180970788,
0.3792904317,
-0.289388746,
0.0967965275,
-1.2140859365,
-0.4523852468,
0.1260513961,
-0.1283321679,
0.1488589793,
0.1845939755,
-0.595718503,
-0.0577404313,
-0.4227386415,
0.1985764056,
0.377489537,
-0.5331190825,
0.6383229494,
0.3023481369,
-0.3529803157,
-0.1147413999,
-0.0994743407,
0.114312157,
-0.28139624,
-0.9618740082,
0.4680597782,
-0.6651275754,
-0.1793413609,
-0.4422039092,
0.2714224756,
0.3596050739,
-0.2566343546,
0.369189024,
0.0475082323,
-0.2000366747,
0.272036314,
0.2690932751,
-0.2106729746,
-0.2966063023,
-0.0912463441,
0.9478663206,
0.1086547896,
-0.0733455941,
-0.1073262095,
0.3729147315,
0.4120877981,
-0.3567062318,
0.5313513279,
1.1796138287,
0.1011940762,
-0.270575732,
-0.8523929119,
-0.1416502297,
-0.5203842521,
0.2809557021,
-0.4418625534,
-1.0049740076,
-0.0354325809,
-0.3102661967,
0.0220743064,
0.1096796021,
1.0512844324,
0.016710652,
1.4497637749,
0.6776843071,
0.1295671165,
0.7107621431,
0.1127764434,
0.0873034,
-0.7439072132,
-0.3593815863,
-0.1186360046,
-0.3378601968,
-0.5397213101,
-0.2584690154,
0.5348283648,
0.0803846642,
0.0294520073,
-0.016713148,
-0.3106590509,
0.2029808015,
0.7094678879,
0.3627671301,
0.3285509646,
0.1860164851,
-0.2383530289,
-0.1756422371,
-0.4026101232,
-0.6766318679,
1.1692795753,
0.0555549748,
0.8778809905,
0.1993501633,
0.6215086579,
0.6076788306,
0.1032397747,
-0.6760061979,
0.5580311418,
-0.3709261417,
-0.3647915423,
0.0386042483,
-0.4226414561,
-0.6291520596,
0.3451269567,
-0.6102573276,
-0.3711090088,
-0.2371840924,
0.4971466064,
-0.3230347335,
-0.1754738092,
-0.7889609337,
0.6128252149,
-0.3883445263,
-0.4594526887,
-0.335064888,
-0.2763220966,
0.6612032056,
-0.2723371983,
0.0020651135,
-0.2896565199,
-0.0344328061,
0.3791389763,
-0.0446951278,
0.588832438,
-0.1006549075,
0.0284279119,
0.0205189586,
0.0053712251,
0.5101545453,
0.2546602488,
0.042734623,
-0.0966290906,
-0.4376222789,
0.0131392134,
-0.348580122,
1.0201909542,
-0.5785740018,
-0.6023809314,
0.0006322018,
-0.6004545093,
-0.2385653704,
0.2869476676,
0.2859852016,
0.3935741484,
-0.1698860228,
0.2949041426,
0.6092480421,
-0.5404605865,
0.5108758807,
0.2795127928,
-0.3701461852,
-0.7795313001,
1.1634302139,
-0.2788844705,
0.0119360136,
0.4674805999,
0.6473571658,
-0.3862704039,
-0.5375711322,
-0.4935255647,
0.2584739327,
-0.3912152648,
-0.0593662262,
-0.8381397724,
0.3047889471,
-0.4219717681,
-0.2875439525,
0.1009535342,
0.0826992393,
-0.344940573,
0.0719293058,
0.0295251366,
0.5442042351,
0.290042311,
0.6361922622,
-0.8746203184,
0.594016552,
0.5897011161,
-0.1563836336,
-0.4213513434,
-0.0366912894,
-0.1226840764,
-0.0495122299,
-0.7906877398,
-0.8313632011,
0.5866048932,
0.3349480927,
0.5377466679,
0.9475185871,
-0.2785066366,
0.4695129991,
-0.5935865641,
1.0049057007,
0.5815677643,
-0.840651691,
0.4309892058,
-0.6446756124,
0.3825844526,
0.1651452333,
0.1893034726,
-0.5175760984,
-0.0787705407,
-0.2864581645,
-0.7812591791,
0.581412375,
0.0490471274,
0.5328517556,
-0.152077347,
0.3608361185,
0.279203862,
0.4821952879,
-0.7284835577,
-0.191212371,
-0.1174818575,
-0.2601651847,
-0.5553464293,
-0.5708668232,
0.0283323713,
0.2417672276,
0.5502473712,
-0.450214684,
0.0709908083,
-0.1868227273,
-0.0358684696,
0.0236808844,
0.3767353296,
0.89253968,
0.6993672252,
-0.0895516947,
0.1798427999,
-0.1132751256,
-0.0721306801,
0.1215796992,
-0.1125813276,
-0.1943064928,
0.040316131,
-0.1185863391,
0.7054105997,
0.0866118819,
-0.9138441682,
0.7027444243,
-0.1035200655,
0.0254033487,
-0.453009367,
0.1242963374,
0.0851052478,
0.2219271362,
0.0601617359,
0.0808208585,
0.0122388871,
-0.3659377396,
0.0573919564,
0.6606631279,
0.0606788509,
-0.487026453,
0.8099836707,
0.4002947509,
-0.1415834278,
0.2134094685,
-0.146722123,
-0.0667464882,
-0.1014191359,
0.7316686511,
0.9704070091,
-0.2129862905,
0.3973979056,
0.3782794476,
-0.0990098491,
0.0931583419,
0.0885012373,
-0.4565544128,
-0.9239598513,
-0.372430712,
-0.8749734759,
-0.2257182151,
0.1269777268,
-0.2358523458,
0.4392481446,
-0.4348520339,
-0.4843810201,
0.0574695244,
-0.2322285324,
-0.5654129982,
0.1580899507,
0.4990209639,
0.402217418,
-0.6556310058,
0.6495165825,
0.818150878,
-0.2790578008,
-0.381062746,
-0.1190550104,
0.0554158986,
-0.6350073814,
0.5944015384,
-0.035072431,
-0.1862304509,
-0.0110984826,
-0.3387908041,
-0.4392986894,
1.0828384161,
0.3621628284,
-0.6018309593,
-0.1494739652,
0.0877591819,
0.1997703463,
-0.582377851,
0.3243558705,
0.0548319556,
0.6162606478,
0.1186358333,
-0.5796364546,
-0.0297161378,
-0.1733886153,
0.3865253925,
0.1597500145,
-0.7352359295,
0.8819113374,
-0.1486962438,
0.0079485206,
-0.0864742771,
0.4627851248,
0.405593127,
0.2990919948,
0.5754440427,
0.4060193002,
0.425288856,
-0.007654794,
1.1143451929,
-0.5308207273,
0.0886922479,
0.7655736208,
-0.3033464551,
0.5218319893,
0.4070317447,
0.027644271,
0.2740696371,
0.3176497817,
-0.0115403393,
0.579575479,
0.00851712,
-0.6085876822,
-0.6219262481,
-0.1627185494,
-0.1354050934,
0.3734392226,
-0.03297491,
-0.8505972028,
-0.2336288691,
0.4322154522,
0.1631639302,
0.187348485,
-0.0285786893,
0.9339950085,
-0.0729725137,
-0.6272800565,
0.104904063,
0.5852821469,
0.9379222393,
-0.8823557496,
0.0457164347,
-0.1701719314,
0.2255971283,
-0.136909321,
-0.4036997259,
-0.262041837,
-0.1245159879,
-0.499863863,
-0.829734683,
0.7899259329,
-0.587552309,
-0.3758050203,
-0.1425501257,
0.6366006136,
-0.1646865159,
-0.2029325366,
-0.4505715668,
-0.1483802497,
0.2177496403,
-0.3822086453,
0.4968773723,
-0.0339985713,
0.2772382796,
0.7043670416,
1.0436836481,
0.0597355478,
0.4334610403,
0.0656765774,
0.7562295794,
-0.5467159748,
-0.4848498404,
-0.9963256717,
0.4891321361,
0.2220733762,
-0.5657941699,
1.0608026981,
0.5589379668,
0.6844127774,
-0.3507900238,
0.9291821718,
-0.1570023298,
0.152217716,
-0.7018016577,
0.4068121612,
-0.6651580334,
0.0517538637,
-0.1960121989,
-1.2010319233,
-0.0022284153,
0.2583019733,
-0.061083518,
0.3261603415,
0.4573944509,
0.851172626,
-0.0945902094,
-0.2736690342,
0.690623343,
-0.0057322164,
0.6193294525,
0.4192538559,
0.8105998039,
0.0589752831,
0.4211036265,
-0.288602829,
-0.145570904,
-0.1657086611,
-0.7470802665,
-0.9892029762,
-0.7803764343,
-0.2102757692,
-0.2861947417,
-0.1873903126,
1.2401481867,
0.9040958881,
-0.3967542946,
-0.1565990299,
0.2285272926,
-0.182549119,
0.047936175,
-0.2262201607,
0.0163838193,
-0.2827786505,
-1.0662578344,
0.6180745959,
0.1493078023,
-0.0330761075,
-0.6957011223,
-0.2891687453,
0.1266252249,
0.0605796874,
0.9769441485,
-0.203046754,
-0.7516987324,
-0.0545287393,
0.01706337,
-0.0195256677,
-0.0167316142,
1.0677232742,
-0.606197238,
0.7308979034,
0.7431095243,
0.2041224241,
0.5223770142,
0.3263667822,
0.7061921954,
-0.9736386538,
-0.1403532326,
-0.0421950556,
0.4793764353,
0.2844136357,
-0.2964559197,
-0.1409356892,
0.1041800678,
-0.6024839878,
-0.503423512,
0.4807463288,
-1.2953886986,
-0.02919342,
1.4736243486,
-0.0199665762,
0.2457368523,
0.2443690598,
-0.541136384,
0.0082630748,
-0.6402743459,
0.7312833667,
0.5534974337,
-0.1434402466,
-0.2795995772,
-0.4199230075,
0.1259187013,
0.2607605159,
-0.7102261782,
-0.2416641265,
0.8074059486,
0.2814827859,
0.2130296081,
0.5765604973,
0.0718099475,
-0.1065942869,
-0.3249551356,
0.2478452921,
-0.6221486926,
-0.1481946856,
-0.2953166068,
0.6526569724,
0.0517323837,
-0.0938425437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07999v1
|
A Multi-Level Framework for Accelerating Training Transformer Models
| 2024-04-07T03:04:34 | 2024-04-07T03:04:34 |
Longwei Zou, Han Zhang, Yangdong Deng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The fast growing capabilities of large-scale deep learning models, such as
Bert, GPT and ViT, are revolutionizing the landscape of NLP, CV and many other
domains. Training such models, however, poses an unprecedented demand for
computing power, which incurs exponentially increasing energy cost and carbon
dioxide emissions. It is thus critical to develop efficient training solutions
to reduce the training costs. Motivated by a set of key observations of inter-
and intra-layer similarities among feature maps and attentions that can be
identified from typical training processes, we propose a multi-level framework
for training acceleration. Specifically, the framework is based on three basic
operators, Coalescing, De-coalescing and Interpolation, which can be
orchestrated to build a multi-level training framework. The framework consists
of a V-cycle training process, which progressively down- and up-scales the
model size and projects the parameters between adjacent levels of models via
coalescing and de-coalescing. The key idea is that a smaller model that can be
trained for fast convergence and the trained parameters provides high-qualities
intermediate solutions for the next level larger network. The interpolation
operator is designed to break the symmetry of neurons incurred by de-coalescing
for better convergence performance. Our experiments on transformer-based
language models (e.g. Bert, GPT) as well as a vision model (e.g. DeiT) prove
that the proposed framework reduces the computational cost by about 20% on
training BERT/GPT-Base models and up to 51.6% on training the BERT-Large model
while preserving the performance.
|
[
-0.5185448527,
-0.3003857732,
0.2521861792,
0.3849527538,
0.0749301836,
0.1818032265,
-0.2387952209,
-0.302160114,
-0.1463770717,
0.3976437747,
-0.667937994,
-0.1691346914,
-0.7396317124,
-0.3155933022,
-0.5920801163,
0.6706527472,
0.2031667531,
0.1772617996,
-0.19076401,
-0.011216105,
-0.5221955776,
-0.4064102769,
-0.6733219624,
-0.5141681433,
0.512145102,
0.2113406658,
0.4847016633,
0.5264053345,
0.6093512774,
0.3068249822,
-0.0724692941,
-0.1811611801,
-0.5875291228,
0.2918889523,
-0.039318487,
-0.3570058048,
-0.3346274495,
-0.2175751179,
0.643366456,
0.5889062881,
-0.0595009774,
0.1264622808,
0.1153656468,
0.7767632008,
-0.6471690536,
0.3508623242,
-0.847571969,
-0.0008387227,
0.1876737773,
-0.12379504,
-0.304728806,
0.0087036593,
0.0533254333,
-0.4529081881,
0.447645843,
-0.3468055725,
0.7918922305,
0.492233485,
-0.1067991033,
0.2066131979,
-0.7211807966,
0.6008941531,
-0.5860197544,
0.5887940526,
-0.1892923117,
0.5238569379,
0.2015502453,
-0.8432847261,
-0.5202718377,
-0.1063971817,
-0.1006541625,
0.1570390761,
0.0485129803,
0.1432655752,
0.5065922737,
0.3700829744,
-0.3337416053,
0.3833503127,
-0.3669379652,
0.2367424965,
0.2808260322,
0.0955023915,
-0.0945480913,
0.2549029291,
-0.4934053719,
-0.3914375603,
-0.458004266,
0.1876060218,
0.3080375195,
0.665407598,
-0.184672296,
0.3018946052,
-0.1951169819,
0.4894581735,
0.0890435353,
0.0920384303,
0.4727725685,
-0.0697155967,
-0.0807881057,
-0.0337068923,
0.331915468,
0.3240600526,
0.2602629662,
-0.3666590452,
-0.0351493619,
0.1238718703,
0.5954892635,
-1.2244329453,
-0.1651031673,
0.2496578544,
-0.3045005202,
-0.3573099375,
-0.153756544,
-0.8983157873,
-0.3674791753,
-0.5403098464,
0.3919942081,
-0.390393585,
-0.3741230369,
0.2220090777,
-0.0672087371,
0.6236970425,
0.2274184078,
-1.074067831,
0.1654824167,
0.786036551,
0.5905564427,
0.1199735776,
-0.4096063077,
-0.4541806281,
-0.1783895642,
-0.1847660691,
0.5449132323,
-0.7576021552,
-0.0910754576,
0.1502257138,
0.0659635216,
-0.2090119272,
-0.1974729747,
0.550032258,
-0.5413630009,
0.1937667429,
-0.023059722,
-0.4463117421,
-0.1542193443,
0.2726642191,
-0.6191780567,
1.3792800903,
0.1137832403,
-0.6083417535,
0.4712584615,
-0.8239274025,
-0.3079547286,
0.0047385888,
-0.1299040318,
-0.5946627855,
0.2213272154,
0.5809902549,
0.634267211,
-0.677862525,
0.1728518754,
-0.2307139039,
-0.4013526738,
-0.4978636503,
-0.3082815111,
0.5937010646,
-0.0881940126,
-0.5185467005,
0.2634130418,
-0.9502876401,
0.1451620311,
-0.0448565371,
-0.243230179,
-0.1203856841,
-0.0043436871,
-0.1025027931,
0.7151783109,
0.049950175,
-0.430991739,
0.3766141534,
-0.4163764417,
0.4597481489,
0.7131435275,
-0.1939991862,
0.3138246834,
0.0406956784,
0.5515021086,
0.2694176733,
0.1871499717,
-0.5413812995,
-0.4536132812,
-0.9473526478,
-0.2317242622,
0.1964469552,
0.3247497082,
-0.6508158445,
0.7113714814,
-0.6444639564,
-0.6596089602,
-0.7696344852,
-0.1349934489,
0.3092118204,
0.5574324727,
0.8160861135,
-0.0669731572,
-0.2431573421,
-0.9342758656,
-0.4285875261,
0.1823111922,
-0.0385771021,
-0.0031392919,
0.3636445701,
-0.2060065269,
0.7674170732,
-0.1456587911,
-0.1838828772,
0.0043510455,
0.2095048577,
0.3487197161,
0.6476973891,
0.7123124003,
-0.930580914,
-0.4576588571,
0.0333565101,
-0.5488961935,
0.1133463979,
-0.127118811,
-0.0482689887,
-0.4334082603,
0.5895500183,
-0.2831856906,
0.3561815619,
0.5719934702,
0.1120659634,
0.166643098,
-0.1217305586,
0.0700823665,
-1.0004581213,
0.0077618109,
0.0887699202,
-0.0024072751,
-0.7395533323,
0.213926062,
0.2361366004,
-0.266258508,
-0.3668839931,
0.2286671549,
-0.2278859913,
-0.2002356201,
-0.1938178837,
-0.2048583776,
0.0729404613,
0.7979345322,
0.084449172,
0.6616134644,
1.053432703,
-0.4887745678,
0.1398674697,
0.0505999029,
-0.2218890935,
0.6465190649,
-0.663017571,
0.1030064672,
-0.3303856552,
0.0190146584,
-0.9792262912,
0.0863409638,
-0.2886157036,
-0.1762515455,
0.2275381386,
-0.251321137,
-0.5212773681,
-0.6694434285,
-0.2072183192,
0.3412103653,
0.4873182178,
-0.9767065048,
1.01022017,
0.0543893352,
0.2241583765,
-0.9338437319,
-0.5662074685,
0.021773681,
-0.1352341771,
-0.6729832888,
0.5528823733,
0.0758238733,
0.2521791458,
-0.0920990184,
-0.0511905178,
-0.1846419424,
0.0943313614,
0.2140479088,
-0.0172927994,
-0.2221221924,
0.1864932328,
0.043708805,
-0.2615357935,
-0.0136455316,
-0.6650086045,
0.7245091796,
-0.3101507127,
-0.357091397,
-0.2582508624,
0.2943295836,
0.7336139679,
-0.397709161,
0.8501126766,
1.0249121189,
-0.3655115664,
-0.1684827656,
-0.5117672086,
-0.222892344,
-0.4950972795,
0.5889142156,
-0.6167330146,
-0.6590350866,
0.4331181049,
-0.3276186585,
0.4418271184,
0.6431902647,
0.8802517056,
0.192380771,
1.0380374193,
0.7954788208,
-0.0588818043,
0.6805282235,
-0.5324699879,
0.2502656579,
-0.7837769389,
-0.183537364,
-0.5958504677,
-0.4905181527,
-0.5321860313,
-0.4986326396,
0.4448096156,
0.1545698792,
-0.2348575294,
0.6004734039,
-0.7152180076,
0.558288157,
0.4939665496,
-0.0510474481,
0.0038002713,
0.0730049834,
-0.1624497175,
0.1207493544,
-0.8671694398,
0.0848153308,
0.8134268522,
0.3804068267,
0.7405828834,
-0.209800303,
0.4426006675,
0.1043003798,
0.2215401977,
-0.7073870897,
0.3182779551,
-0.3695409894,
-0.6441248655,
-0.2122043818,
-0.37333408,
-0.7302145958,
0.6774896979,
-0.3564860523,
-0.6391221285,
0.5189439654,
0.1238222569,
-0.0779814571,
0.5297899246,
-0.6384041309,
0.8972170353,
-0.2510522902,
-0.5409878492,
-0.3799355328,
-0.920306325,
0.2226414531,
-0.1440766454,
0.0478437841,
-0.1942396909,
0.2696816027,
0.3561916053,
-0.2215258777,
0.6314934492,
-0.4937512279,
-0.1605429798,
0.0284173377,
-0.3387874961,
0.5050171614,
-0.219063133,
-0.2611106336,
0.3338654935,
-0.495823741,
-0.4469536245,
-0.5669693351,
0.5649683475,
-0.6202462316,
-0.1785576493,
-0.0076926141,
-0.5909171104,
-0.3926295936,
0.186820522,
0.1078202873,
0.4511475861,
0.0613526329,
0.578430593,
0.3787625134,
-0.1665314436,
0.3323690891,
0.0968916267,
-0.0047187349,
-0.1922771037,
0.8325750828,
-0.0804715455,
0.4784196019,
0.5302058458,
0.1168768406,
-0.3340512514,
-0.524695158,
-0.3170603216,
-0.1541501582,
-0.8320979476,
-0.2315566093,
-0.7551338673,
-0.4251924455,
-0.4586508572,
-0.1582945287,
-0.4742459953,
-0.3537104726,
0.0728139132,
-0.016716145,
0.2222098559,
0.4003152549,
0.1173591837,
0.829934299,
-0.5379327536,
0.5566084981,
0.4283582568,
0.4648653269,
0.0026587767,
-0.3355122805,
-0.5748326182,
-0.1274346709,
-0.3721048236,
-0.2891348898,
0.2871031761,
0.3681108952,
0.5485081077,
0.0778197348,
-0.2781167328,
0.9046337008,
-0.6238601208,
0.7478001714,
0.461800307,
-0.8890784383,
0.2469286472,
-0.2207814604,
0.1459034085,
0.5104264617,
0.340249896,
-0.2967606783,
-0.3275381327,
-0.7497884035,
-1.2019625902,
0.7299456596,
0.1377652138,
0.3074910939,
0.3480606377,
0.4784820974,
-0.0446707867,
0.3969936669,
-0.7109415531,
-0.0990628302,
-0.4964896739,
-0.1051395386,
0.1361035705,
0.090410538,
0.0028180734,
-0.3696377873,
0.6660275459,
-0.5277207494,
0.2478509694,
-0.2020770013,
-0.2014119923,
0.0317337289,
0.1499648094,
0.141069904,
0.4357203245,
-0.2559450567,
-0.0288725179,
0.1101396233,
-0.3204150796,
0.1782526374,
0.3145182431,
0.0937491581,
-0.3100409806,
0.2824290693,
1.1415317059,
0.3604151607,
-0.2429578453,
0.5898400545,
-0.2018038332,
-0.2078224123,
0.0726952404,
0.2584300041,
0.0643919706,
0.4366401136,
0.3187402487,
0.3228613138,
-0.077527009,
-0.112754181,
0.2868167162,
0.3703062832,
-0.5103465319,
-0.2009389251,
0.8445670009,
0.2387230843,
-0.1579963565,
0.4986479282,
0.2647467852,
-0.5425414443,
0.6570001245,
0.3629252017,
1.1264768839,
-0.1433188021,
-0.190738067,
0.5045002103,
0.444768846,
-0.0514183417,
0.1094707176,
-0.1452287585,
-0.6721465588,
-0.5968554616,
-0.7650663853,
-0.188191399,
0.0840704665,
-0.7967095971,
0.4538534284,
-0.2748683095,
-0.0964369401,
0.1983112097,
-0.2517342269,
-1.0581362247,
0.3433715105,
0.250441581,
0.8708985448,
-0.6825916767,
1.1035616398,
0.1664343625,
-0.3140318096,
-0.5213597417,
0.0805954039,
-0.4583953023,
-1.014603734,
0.6467930079,
0.4833160341,
-0.2877580225,
0.3151794076,
-0.2665325701,
-0.6224399805,
1.0827440023,
0.5627740622,
-0.9024720788,
-0.4748859704,
0.0864277706,
0.5990049243,
-0.5524910092,
0.3955145478,
0.607711494,
0.4250264466,
0.0593135655,
-0.5854206681,
-0.2904483378,
-0.1324771792,
0.3332379758,
0.100657478,
-0.5131621957,
1.1039162874,
-0.0164796822,
-0.0181915779,
-0.0619255938,
0.5646371245,
-0.0772779584,
-0.3637391031,
0.8165304661,
0.6834827662,
0.4710219204,
-0.1868699491,
1.0049049854,
-0.7933444977,
0.6277239919,
0.9861989021,
-0.2229843736,
0.4807219505,
0.3615383506,
-0.1062032506,
0.5480878353,
0.3525217175,
-0.1890935749,
0.5269601345,
0.1749627441,
0.0242721438,
-0.3313401043,
0.1087938398,
-0.6089241505,
0.2557678223,
0.4487972558,
-0.4830835462,
-0.5019717216,
0.1391956657,
-0.3841438591,
-0.1924922317,
-0.2863283157,
0.6827719808,
-0.1762771308,
-0.5163837671,
0.6478209496,
-0.0879626423,
0.5505809784,
-0.7072803378,
-0.0143804485,
0.1654784679,
0.3865741789,
-0.0770681277,
-0.6164176464,
0.0247259829,
-0.1125970185,
-0.164945811,
-0.4270884097,
0.5685950518,
-0.4886951745,
-0.6134889722,
0.743547976,
0.391990006,
-0.1405048221,
-0.087627545,
-0.9730114937,
-0.0584905371,
-0.3665875494,
-0.26771456,
0.1662354916,
0.336019665,
0.1482636929,
0.3454150856,
0.6878090501,
-0.1634505093,
0.4485415816,
0.4277465045,
1.1708705425,
-0.3887036443,
-0.5049906373,
-0.7037512064,
0.8608403802,
-0.1300831288,
-0.2757398188,
0.4403548539,
0.4362571239,
0.6298409104,
0.0635141209,
0.7803483605,
-0.0351440758,
0.3652510345,
-0.4861535132,
0.2789878547,
-0.6655404568,
0.1841532439,
-0.3692227602,
-1.1666623354,
-0.384082526,
0.4961903393,
-0.2226611078,
0.2033840418,
0.3588178158,
0.6271791458,
-0.2964071333,
0.042773515,
0.284934938,
0.2225980461,
0.7493850589,
0.4399718046,
0.7000510693,
-0.6393896937,
0.2846620381,
-0.3540842831,
-0.1491768807,
-0.1550316215,
-0.8931933641,
-0.8127064705,
-0.5254617333,
-0.1139162332,
-0.2898152769,
-0.0399936512,
0.8067248464,
1.1403564215,
-0.5512953401,
-0.1455030441,
-0.4795528352,
-0.2686513364,
-0.6049845219,
-0.2207056433,
0.3046954572,
-0.8685911298,
-0.7479105592,
0.4815246463,
0.3388953507,
-0.2350085974,
-0.5301295519,
0.0918842405,
-0.1834232956,
0.0016823064,
0.6846342087,
0.109271206,
-0.4726960659,
-0.2272262722,
-0.1446104199,
0.1298390776,
0.510555923,
1.0438342094,
-1.0074319839,
0.6393899322,
0.4075970054,
0.9981703758,
1.0219579935,
-0.0161671769,
0.4646384418,
-1.1472889185,
0.4527646303,
0.2363546789,
0.3054738939,
0.3604863584,
-0.2477560341,
0.5755184293,
0.1776772141,
-0.4463123679,
-0.7929919362,
0.24114196,
-0.8139948249,
-0.0789768621,
0.6242134571,
-0.0806938931,
-0.0107846363,
0.1980084479,
0.0720102042,
0.2273821384,
-0.188013494,
0.6690739989,
0.4605448544,
-0.2263295949,
-0.1119970009,
-0.4530899823,
0.3812276125,
0.3318463266,
-0.9676195383,
0.359988749,
0.1054919511,
-0.08483731,
0.3930353224,
0.3063983917,
-0.1016194448,
-0.045026198,
0.0778308287,
0.2226705849,
0.0312144179,
-0.8239569068,
-0.602476418,
0.37411654,
-0.3593873978,
-0.0952369124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04770v1
|
Generating Uncontextualized and Contextualized Questions for Document-Level Event Argument Extraction
| 2024-04-07T00:50:21 | 2024-04-07T00:50:21 |
Md Nayem Uddin, Enfa Rose George, Eduardo Blanco, Steven Corman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents multiple question generation strategies for
document-level event argument extraction. These strategies do not require human
involvement and result in uncontextualized questions as well as contextualized
questions grounded on the event and document of interest. Experimental results
show that combining uncontextualized and contextualized questions is
beneficial, especially when event triggers and arguments appear in different
sentences. Our approach does not have corpus-specific components, in
particular, the question generation strategies transfer across corpora. We also
present a qualitative analysis of the most common errors made by our best
model.
|
[
-0.5949449539,
-1.2831702232,
0.6560961008,
-0.2302935272,
-0.4115742743,
-0.2639636695,
-0.1777287573,
-0.2542329431,
-0.2444909662,
0.2647472322,
-0.5363912582,
-0.3159046471,
-0.1490709335,
0.228718549,
-0.5299755335,
1.0335558653,
-0.2568205297,
-0.0733412728,
-0.5274592042,
-0.2224050015,
-0.4119953513,
-0.6733210683,
-0.9760710001,
0.0753621235,
0.4807904661,
0.6315986514,
0.0477569811,
-0.0026776695,
0.0844707713,
0.2066435963,
-0.0177795999,
0.2979616821,
-0.0413082093,
0.4284786582,
-0.2976857126,
-0.2267332971,
0.1302748471,
-0.0209008344,
0.5202290416,
0.8343616724,
0.0793678984,
0.2874135077,
-0.2086894661,
-0.0286666974,
-0.817171514,
-0.3181584477,
-0.7555820346,
0.1191114336,
-0.1660115272,
-0.6849486828,
-0.3891958296,
-0.2537854016,
0.0060013402,
-0.4622958601,
0.4007324576,
-0.1278315932,
0.8007160425,
-0.1344749928,
-0.8330593109,
-0.4873661697,
-0.7178375721,
0.6170589924,
-0.459204644,
-0.2314753085,
0.0657962859,
0.0230401568,
-0.1602156013,
-1.018701911,
-0.5287541747,
0.1096153036,
-0.0324598961,
0.3868194818,
-0.2994102836,
-0.2836699188,
0.412651509,
-0.1476072818,
-0.579215169,
-0.1621985137,
-0.5123646855,
0.1397165954,
0.6404362321,
0.156668812,
0.4049398303,
-0.6854823232,
-0.3043994308,
-0.1088109761,
-0.57063061,
0.2938093245,
0.5426722169,
-0.0584466346,
0.2418736964,
0.3511046767,
-0.0095913876,
0.6027797461,
0.5179337263,
0.0625145137,
-0.4969461858,
-0.6409652233,
0.0557184592,
0.1697511822,
0.6398849487,
0.568187356,
0.1413415521,
-0.147421822,
0.2606256008,
-0.1331384033,
0.3508148789,
-0.7906361222,
0.3550291955,
0.8164069057,
-0.2600449324,
-0.4384704828,
0.1583252251,
-1.2142537832,
-0.139885217,
-0.0173654873,
0.2584009171,
-0.2400563806,
-0.2028786987,
-0.183266148,
-0.6805183887,
0.4909756482,
0.5245290399,
-0.8628382087,
-0.040865317,
0.4000516236,
0.0448145717,
-0.3648025095,
0.1022602618,
-0.7462639213,
0.3306770325,
-0.6037950516,
1.1588691473,
-0.5370762348,
-0.6170960069,
0.3965853453,
0.1495728195,
-0.1698876321,
-0.5598926544,
0.5877124071,
-0.5717440844,
0.9000808001,
-0.4657259285,
-0.7434831858,
0.0714121088,
0.2696915865,
-0.0712975636,
1.2059514523,
-0.1122379825,
-0.8345030546,
0.6057755947,
-0.8601190448,
-0.5538388491,
0.4329527915,
-0.6000460386,
0.1957886666,
0.0158346295,
0.4592330456,
0.4168629348,
-0.2412688434,
0.6014457345,
0.0304544661,
0.311124444,
0.2703367174,
-0.3194095194,
0.6779155135,
0.0870961696,
-0.7977519631,
-0.0035592094,
-0.972861886,
0.1108687967,
0.1842899621,
-0.4685143828,
-0.4747019708,
0.2683565915,
0.1803814173,
0.1404064894,
0.3270153701,
-0.6400799751,
0.0457358137,
-0.2213358879,
0.1162821725,
0.371268332,
0.8843577504,
0.4311842918,
0.071755603,
0.6483011842,
0.2392602116,
0.1153304726,
-0.2648319304,
-0.5427359343,
-0.5619818568,
0.4575219154,
0.0305532124,
0.5513744354,
-0.8015668988,
0.0106682349,
0.4109063148,
-0.2836145461,
0.0546527058,
-0.0646643192,
0.1703921258,
1.0670619011,
0.2506948709,
0.4140277207,
-0.6456497908,
-0.6411242485,
-0.0599511936,
-0.4496298432,
0.0842349529,
0.1588565111,
0.5707744956,
0.2800433338,
1.0921258926,
-0.6841794848,
0.4219143689,
-0.3323613703,
0.7246423364,
-0.244116962,
0.4313542545,
0.6033120751,
-1.0847291946,
-0.2604027689,
0.1295874715,
-0.9844625592,
-0.1953233033,
-0.5131255388,
-0.0991921946,
0.5159864426,
0.7899181843,
-0.5033168793,
0.3958082199,
-0.0809630528,
-0.3650686443,
0.3096764684,
-0.2012134492,
0.399697572,
-1.584941864,
0.0815643817,
-0.2419825047,
0.0197525192,
-0.922745347,
0.2015033364,
0.0159690138,
-0.226801604,
-0.7073916197,
0.6701996922,
-0.1315778047,
0.2670288682,
-0.1613511294,
0.5860898495,
0.3573490083,
0.2638673782,
0.0966696665,
0.5119757056,
0.4013025165,
-0.6360370517,
0.3844538033,
0.2758128941,
-0.0832294002,
0.8907189965,
-0.6576660275,
0.2417176217,
-0.4148233533,
0.0419359803,
-1.2366876602,
-0.3032689989,
0.0144952051,
-0.419836849,
0.2112445533,
-0.1930108517,
-0.2855867147,
-0.0870843157,
-0.3181332946,
0.3852406442,
0.2487438619,
-0.5564479828,
0.4572088718,
0.4264304042,
-0.3541852534,
-0.5364323258,
-0.4637669921,
0.1157359406,
-0.6237798333,
-0.845613718,
0.2162539661,
-0.2628460824,
-0.4430605471,
-0.0052594501,
0.0213332623,
0.0170422457,
-0.0684211627,
0.1391952634,
0.1512323916,
-0.4544978738,
0.2115847319,
0.307879746,
0.2824192345,
0.0038603796,
-0.159689486,
0.2887663543,
0.0804421678,
-0.3332200646,
-0.1314702481,
1.3881556988,
0.268955946,
-0.2023177743,
0.4582288861,
0.6121354699,
-0.6113948822,
-0.0435163639,
-0.7963389754,
-0.085231863,
-0.396004498,
0.1519278139,
-0.2498257905,
-0.8424949646,
0.6670278907,
-0.1301613152,
0.4013842642,
0.5150346756,
0.9101390839,
-0.3517506421,
1.1628700495,
-0.0808136687,
0.5037696958,
0.3053428829,
-0.0468758829,
-0.009229254,
-0.6331629157,
-0.3582627177,
-0.7036733627,
-0.0494132154,
-0.2410407662,
-0.420409441,
0.345870018,
0.4018169343,
-0.076844424,
0.3880761266,
-0.1945774406,
0.2361915708,
0.501809001,
-0.6249880195,
0.1751372814,
-0.2186748981,
-0.2832465768,
0.0570207946,
-0.832562983,
-0.8780569434,
0.7577427626,
-0.1765935421,
0.1796896011,
0.0630675852,
0.8566862345,
0.0544707142,
0.0986960977,
-0.3128108084,
0.3600963056,
0.286585182,
-1.1702787876,
-0.5589321852,
-0.2824737132,
-1.3717298508,
0.5139063001,
-0.2103826851,
-1.1907212734,
0.7930145264,
-0.1989636272,
-0.6242251396,
0.2674458325,
-0.7951880097,
1.0816438198,
-0.0152593087,
-0.1359982044,
0.3326175809,
-0.4688515663,
0.2183695287,
-0.1906256676,
0.1871129423,
0.1666672826,
0.1443339437,
1.0634256601,
-0.2613861263,
0.4793796837,
-0.0498998873,
-0.0894497484,
0.8681576252,
0.0426837355,
0.3790621758,
0.593423903,
-0.0001387847,
-0.3962743878,
0.480881393,
-0.092863895,
-0.6120339036,
0.4241896868,
-0.518304348,
-0.9393257499,
-0.0257595144,
-0.4566332996,
-0.2861190438,
0.1639309078,
0.4942036569,
0.9623180628,
-0.4053637087,
0.2301760763,
0.6582702398,
-0.3451809287,
0.9874007702,
0.5920931697,
0.3546598256,
-0.2651714385,
0.3795914054,
0.0508439913,
0.2012214959,
0.390188247,
0.2897790968,
-0.4127765596,
-0.2875764966,
-0.7126350999,
-0.1885052174,
-1.074678421,
-0.2373797148,
-1.1090261936,
0.0964822099,
-0.6977574229,
-0.3994780183,
-0.2531151772,
-0.6106309295,
-0.6884897351,
-0.4893339276,
0.0509667657,
0.2879644632,
-0.0498902202,
0.0050188629,
-0.6812736392,
0.4224829078,
0.5280604959,
-0.5822432041,
-0.2559838891,
-0.1048308834,
0.2809583545,
-0.2292607874,
-0.8190036416,
-1.34739995,
0.0962106586,
-0.1031410396,
0.6785036325,
0.5609501004,
0.4816816151,
0.6435099244,
-0.5368741751,
1.1131834984,
0.1528923959,
-0.8112596273,
0.983478725,
-0.4336041212,
0.1672326624,
0.6795121431,
0.5974911451,
-0.4936014116,
-0.5689179897,
-0.9790001512,
-0.8633745909,
0.7445321679,
0.0776663497,
0.2207165658,
-0.6072586775,
0.4108980298,
-0.0371808298,
-0.0026984906,
-0.5296210647,
-0.0801736861,
-0.1153251976,
0.0899122432,
0.2350049019,
-0.2492397428,
-0.5906205177,
-0.0840133652,
0.1100050732,
-0.2322484404,
-0.0608673654,
0.5768613815,
0.0443162583,
-0.4863865077,
0.5890903473,
0.9045311213,
0.9955344796,
-0.2841654122,
0.1473176777,
0.5987509489,
0.0600912757,
0.1137105525,
-0.0584254041,
-0.4397652745,
0.1956042051,
0.5250520706,
0.6188712716,
0.3592944443,
-0.5551585555,
0.5588939786,
-0.3373104632,
-0.6884849668,
-0.3819853663,
-0.2388731092,
0.3897833824,
0.3436312377,
0.5287222266,
-0.5790631175,
-0.0939951017,
-0.977208674,
0.3331843317,
0.4517314732,
-0.2880708575,
0.0886848718,
0.9144561887,
0.1062506512,
-0.0754252002,
0.1797735095,
-0.0381724313,
-0.3021493554,
0.6303067207,
0.6419447064,
0.4653384387,
0.0051967129,
0.5428935885,
0.4387449324,
0.2626088858,
0.2728727758,
0.4524331689,
-0.0751734078,
-0.6877241135,
-0.1282432228,
-0.3746986389,
-0.4853171706,
0.3132310212,
-0.6864407063,
0.2177287936,
-0.3414763808,
-0.1910637468,
0.2897465229,
0.0242493954,
-0.2629365921,
0.2857721448,
0.0557221174,
0.8411757946,
-0.5567839146,
0.3229755461,
0.9653969407,
-0.8829655647,
-0.6648664474,
-0.0535809584,
-0.3966667652,
-0.081175819,
0.6619358063,
-0.4613491297,
0.2962267697,
-0.3360794187,
-0.4174222648,
-0.7205674648,
0.8998817801,
0.1157180071,
0.0531391203,
-0.0826884285,
0.1386206746,
0.5187853575,
-0.5717815161,
0.2193882614,
0.2160378397,
0.5968181491,
0.3909730315,
-0.2607965767,
0.270660013,
-0.0713591799,
-0.0582679398,
0.0031667603,
-0.3162843883,
0.8158879876,
0.0405284427,
-0.5512024164,
-0.1650390476,
0.7103416324,
-0.0143720973,
0.5514616966,
0.4163317978,
0.078383252,
0.791257143,
-0.0507168733,
1.2032119036,
-0.135095641,
0.1008733362,
0.8965038061,
-0.3983371854,
0.6945941448,
0.5725957155,
0.3834943175,
0.4549742937,
0.7202637196,
0.2088558525,
0.3020032346,
0.0864145383,
-0.2801159322,
-0.4639074206,
0.0047715055,
-0.5333485007,
0.5119690895,
0.1687246263,
0.1696251631,
-0.7024287581,
0.0758781731,
0.2843779922,
0.0299105085,
0.203157872,
1.0175504684,
-0.1275000423,
-1.307089448,
0.3826837838,
0.3727968335,
0.1807482094,
-0.6105639935,
0.2011247426,
-0.5632065535,
-0.1823369265,
-0.0753408298,
-0.413980037,
0.3034235239,
0.4327792227,
-0.1616097093,
-0.0316034295,
0.8637970686,
-0.4457891583,
-0.4659972787,
0.0416423641,
0.6791229248,
0.1219398081,
0.0945008844,
-0.4828007519,
-0.3208688796,
-0.2049592882,
-0.458566606,
0.4913770556,
0.6741411686,
-0.3481079936,
0.0667861775,
0.7374421358,
-0.1836476475,
0.226679951,
0.1400126219,
0.6464757323,
-0.507854104,
-0.18963328,
-0.6829759479,
0.7740833163,
-0.4413871169,
-0.6021082997,
0.6253435612,
0.3508416712,
0.5649490356,
0.0306011625,
0.5871986747,
-0.1138532981,
0.1952206045,
-0.1978508234,
0.3418628275,
-0.8011883497,
-0.1995825768,
-0.6597405076,
-0.5090993047,
-0.0703693703,
0.4222588539,
-0.110430479,
-0.1295592338,
1.189207077,
0.5770449638,
0.2211039662,
0.4077145755,
0.4503498673,
-0.4199177623,
0.5546984673,
0.6510872245,
1.0758426189,
-0.5787346363,
0.5653499365,
0.0571929403,
-0.2857934833,
-0.0811911374,
-1.0913712978,
-0.9910460711,
-1.0241308212,
-0.7892449498,
-0.0825357586,
-0.1502806395,
0.843401432,
0.5591909289,
-0.8822312951,
-0.1403385103,
0.1563994139,
0.2531868219,
0.2320669442,
-0.2998637259,
0.4091418087,
-0.6626968384,
-0.8252427578,
0.6863339543,
0.1951340735,
-0.1082641408,
0.1748132557,
0.4250979722,
-0.7814409137,
0.5153354406,
0.7453939319,
0.3654330075,
-0.2924233079,
-0.6343550086,
-0.2214610875,
0.1694438457,
-0.1538668424,
0.9840459228,
-0.1997213513,
0.0915419012,
0.5062494874,
0.7031908631,
0.5419680476,
0.3203686178,
0.6258978844,
-1.1833779812,
0.1443104744,
0.0309968684,
0.452508837,
0.2196985483,
-0.581394434,
0.2885305882,
0.3013394773,
-0.2839435637,
-0.8097531796,
0.2208887488,
-1.0722236633,
-0.5515048504,
1.611806035,
0.0206906702,
-0.0064571328,
-0.2696256638,
-0.3100056052,
0.3336857259,
-0.0378561504,
0.5254473686,
1.0386976004,
-0.4314988256,
-0.1305208355,
-0.6404233575,
0.5182164311,
0.42277354,
-1.1417950392,
-0.0175016858,
0.4398526847,
0.2361879796,
0.4221617281,
0.725523293,
-0.4171886444,
0.317481935,
-0.0950887948,
-0.1777853221,
0.2041183412,
-0.2035183907,
0.03700611,
0.9541234374,
-0.3399934471,
-0.0874255672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04759v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04759v1
|
What Happens When Small Is Made Smaller? Exploring the Impact of Compression on Small Data Pretrained Language Models
| 2024-04-06T23:52:53 | 2024-04-06T23:52:53 |
Busayo Awobade, Mardiyyah Oduwole, Steven Kolawole
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Compression techniques have been crucial in advancing machine learning by
enabling efficient training and deployment of large-scale language models.
However, these techniques have received limited attention in the context of
low-resource language models, which are trained on even smaller amounts of data
and under computational constraints, a scenario known as the "low-resource
double-bind." This paper investigates the effectiveness of pruning, knowledge
distillation, and quantization on an exclusively low-resourced, small-data
language model, AfriBERTa. Through a battery of experiments, we assess the
effects of compression on performance across several metrics beyond accuracy.
Our study provides evidence that compression techniques significantly improve
the efficiency and effectiveness of small-data language models, confirming that
the prevailing beliefs regarding the effects of compression on large, heavily
parameterized models hold true for less-parameterized, small-data models.
|
[
-0.4985100329,
-0.6308441758,
0.2478329986,
0.0039238925,
-0.297840476,
-0.2520870864,
-0.6307004094,
-0.411798209,
0.1428099275,
0.3393155336,
-0.3736831844,
0.0093428195,
-0.7216489911,
0.1182317585,
-0.3688013256,
0.727514863,
0.2504425943,
-0.0429350249,
-0.1646723151,
-0.2596865892,
-0.6279751062,
-0.7859460711,
-0.5123180747,
-0.2766755223,
0.3847742677,
0.6608314514,
1.0294579268,
0.8661569357,
0.4850897193,
0.2945359349,
-0.2116625905,
-0.1334253699,
-0.4751754701,
-0.1542627364,
0.2272705138,
-0.8284698129,
0.0905108303,
0.2702627182,
0.7774866819,
0.9521257877,
-0.2895628512,
0.5362169147,
0.3420444429,
0.7912644744,
-0.8028411865,
-0.1414402425,
-0.3876727521,
-0.0447146036,
-0.2482132465,
0.0930788666,
-0.4029832184,
-0.2670631111,
-0.1729397029,
-0.2413257957,
0.4780848026,
0.0855564848,
0.6750324965,
0.9169864655,
-0.4453477859,
-0.2627677321,
-0.8853288889,
0.7022171617,
-0.4361555278,
0.4227833152,
0.2314396203,
0.1842158288,
0.0586053543,
-0.7594894767,
-0.5714175701,
0.1159802154,
-0.3562808037,
-0.5565720201,
-0.5711832643,
0.0482629612,
0.6577378511,
0.3985972106,
-0.350564301,
0.2949958742,
-0.725341022,
-0.0321277045,
0.4530390501,
-0.1366607398,
0.2324345559,
0.1592944562,
0.2395475358,
-0.4291431308,
-0.992726922,
0.0968901441,
0.5668544173,
0.4905418754,
0.1509891152,
0.5334383845,
-0.1511604041,
1.0314756632,
0.0472082086,
-0.1547843963,
-0.1902917176,
-0.1045699269,
-0.4998462796,
-0.0621893592,
0.7932477593,
-0.0752524361,
0.1601795554,
0.0506524928,
-0.0552978814,
0.2546345294,
0.1487626731,
-1.1370830536,
-0.7772174478,
-0.0963258147,
-0.6237565279,
-0.3652944267,
-0.0959791839,
-0.6311607957,
-0.3876902759,
-0.2990528941,
0.4322611392,
-0.173779726,
0.0735440329,
0.1666149646,
-0.1351549625,
-0.4386230111,
0.1266050935,
-0.9604073763,
0.5451441407,
0.4297447503,
0.9857443571,
0.4508039951,
-0.0048153717,
-0.7901633978,
-0.3622838259,
-0.1516127884,
0.5013475418,
-0.4454088807,
-0.3631337583,
-0.2873599827,
-0.1395391226,
0.1670372486,
-0.705321908,
0.4923008382,
-0.273919493,
-0.1508746743,
-0.1220775023,
-0.2323186696,
-0.0302431136,
-0.3619118929,
-0.9875454903,
0.6220245957,
-0.0473188087,
-0.5654556751,
0.2735511959,
-0.2252245545,
-0.6340338588,
-0.3104299009,
-0.1181818098,
-0.4136992395,
0.7956485748,
0.1005825624,
0.1705051661,
-0.7574083209,
-0.306828171,
-0.2980239689,
-0.3363955617,
0.3982386887,
-0.623044014,
0.5661756992,
0.2278800756,
0.0720575824,
-0.5609081984,
-0.5877736211,
0.3431343436,
0.1807742268,
-0.3627204597,
-0.4270166755,
-0.3103637397,
-0.2082741261,
0.45229882,
0.0792046115,
-0.3884951174,
0.7510436177,
-0.4243167043,
0.5484080911,
0.2960221469,
-0.0725349486,
0.8014794588,
-0.2144221961,
0.6197176576,
-0.2421770245,
0.2735673785,
0.3112102449,
-0.3687230945,
-0.9559032321,
-0.1539463401,
0.9888045788,
0.1573521048,
-0.7492029667,
-0.0405203737,
-0.3667507768,
-0.5462106466,
-0.9402862787,
0.3430909216,
0.3322149217,
-0.0177840814,
0.1716175228,
-0.2498450279,
-0.5221871734,
-0.9909771085,
-0.235469386,
-0.0995016918,
-0.3216074109,
0.2260033339,
0.5032358766,
0.015531647,
0.8988253474,
-0.8218091726,
-0.478149116,
-0.1238775179,
0.4823826253,
0.0662610829,
0.6264492273,
0.6536491513,
-0.7758895159,
-0.5411578417,
-0.3805625439,
-0.0487610511,
-0.2500511706,
0.0891794339,
0.2031085044,
0.0490071774,
0.076245971,
-0.7082056403,
0.6829156876,
0.8843674064,
-0.0995145217,
0.3825717866,
-0.2720668614,
0.0754858926,
-0.4937568307,
-0.0311135463,
-0.2032712102,
-0.0451135412,
-0.7139388323,
-0.034552265,
0.1061406285,
-0.3922665417,
-0.4013415277,
0.3123486936,
-0.5858407021,
-0.1945226043,
-0.4626003802,
-0.0326405019,
0.2225305289,
0.3993875384,
0.1575420052,
1.0201295614,
0.2509974241,
-0.6752803922,
0.0168237053,
0.26887995,
-0.3968876004,
0.0441474169,
-0.7366207242,
0.3753629029,
-0.0909270495,
0.1489783674,
-0.4342380464,
-0.1041352302,
-0.1485676914,
-0.4097028077,
0.5639826059,
-0.6017558575,
-0.7991827726,
-0.409249723,
-0.2391456366,
0.5926010609,
0.8020824194,
-0.6242634654,
0.2431389689,
0.5293758512,
0.0000658415,
-0.3916198909,
-1.0556436777,
-0.0855462551,
-0.2428002059,
-0.6105888486,
0.0798062682,
-0.1651640534,
-0.3646283746,
0.0099598272,
-0.1689615548,
-0.3701874018,
0.3559703529,
0.3180611134,
-0.078135848,
-0.0374966189,
0.2894862592,
0.0079270788,
0.0134019693,
-0.2515226603,
-0.461786747,
0.7129823565,
-0.1777027547,
-0.1595037729,
-0.5036859512,
0.0974865407,
0.1861966252,
0.0307072829,
1.2775064707,
0.2332983613,
-0.2430193126,
-0.346128583,
-0.2782344222,
-0.429202497,
-0.4938259721,
-0.2076759934,
-0.3171165287,
-0.9942197204,
0.1426374316,
-0.2712408304,
-0.3021698892,
0.3382427394,
0.2647291422,
-0.1206327304,
0.9993957281,
0.8339915872,
-0.0877732635,
0.4462643564,
-0.5276793242,
0.2253847718,
-0.5830531716,
0.3666447997,
-0.8796719909,
-0.6872951984,
-0.6219614744,
-0.6643351912,
0.3031483889,
0.7547122836,
0.0332964286,
0.3990968168,
-0.6735137701,
0.7068971992,
0.6198372841,
-0.0841649026,
0.2034007907,
-0.1717961282,
0.3180958629,
-0.0353041328,
-1.2127437592,
-0.3900737762,
0.968364954,
0.1654914916,
0.7904626727,
0.3612860739,
0.7235158086,
0.3787806034,
0.2635982633,
-0.8796298504,
0.1440666914,
-0.4666787386,
-0.3656248152,
-0.2060442567,
-0.585175693,
-0.9503840208,
0.3144245446,
-0.3562134802,
-0.6729367971,
0.3840833008,
0.5347912908,
-0.7450653911,
0.1189042926,
-1.067799449,
0.8618170023,
-0.1534766406,
-0.1562818438,
-0.2461294681,
-0.4400589168,
0.3662882149,
-0.3456040621,
0.3943618238,
0.2525406182,
-0.0373197906,
0.8773329854,
-0.9162582755,
0.8034250736,
-0.1442593187,
0.1955662072,
0.3576544523,
0.2678771019,
0.6386064291,
-0.0842557102,
0.222946018,
0.3132482171,
0.3469833434,
-0.4225797951,
-0.9053633213,
0.5011978745,
-0.7045487165,
-0.5182344913,
-0.3068532348,
-0.3493762016,
-0.0898266435,
-0.0499086082,
0.3074169755,
0.5458276272,
-0.0251909364,
0.3790712953,
0.5577272773,
-0.1998487264,
0.2143365294,
0.6993644238,
0.0512425527,
-0.1777026802,
0.769539237,
0.4628160298,
0.3198095262,
0.1479718089,
0.1253347844,
0.0862251222,
-0.5517929792,
-0.3313637972,
0.374076426,
-0.5209044814,
-0.5442094803,
-0.4154336154,
-0.0088804318,
-0.5800589919,
0.0297383796,
-0.6409125924,
-0.9302334189,
-0.3187162876,
0.1435026824,
0.1800266802,
0.7477363944,
-0.3306531012,
0.9152359962,
-1.0126146078,
0.0521260686,
0.3408128023,
-0.002450153,
-0.0325509571,
-0.4900055826,
-0.6158496737,
0.237839669,
0.053306751,
-0.6131982207,
0.4930239916,
0.4366436899,
-0.1061106995,
0.3272892237,
0.2360648513,
0.6482799053,
-0.630122304,
0.6424273849,
0.1411404163,
-0.7977113724,
0.4303259254,
0.2412087023,
0.4960282445,
0.6900470853,
0.1269669831,
-0.4839392602,
-0.1046781763,
-0.8994477391,
-0.4600395858,
0.8020912409,
0.369852066,
-0.2136445493,
0.2511404157,
0.2755343616,
-0.0059020766,
0.6155769229,
-0.4313702881,
-0.3416962922,
0.3090863228,
-0.2025545388,
-0.0572083034,
-0.465857625,
-0.2284993082,
-0.1523024738,
0.6555894017,
-0.131884709,
0.3750426769,
-0.3928970098,
-0.3917678893,
-0.0434070751,
0.2554105818,
0.3304591477,
0.0643621385,
0.13728109,
0.2423329502,
0.091902867,
-0.3690114319,
0.3106383383,
0.0437970608,
-0.2437484562,
-0.050882984,
0.3849204779,
0.7766523361,
0.0699170157,
-0.4919143617,
0.4723702073,
-0.506328702,
0.2326626182,
-0.0576615781,
0.2001995295,
-0.2788901329,
0.1781303287,
-0.0082988618,
0.3645586371,
0.0765248984,
-0.4723482728,
0.0645730421,
0.3280055821,
-0.0336675234,
-0.3579178154,
0.4693898857,
0.0556930825,
-0.2520794868,
0.6001363993,
-0.0282755103,
-0.4993497133,
0.4425889552,
0.1286092997,
0.375387162,
-0.0733321682,
0.102526173,
0.232491672,
0.5430771112,
-0.3631218672,
-0.1008284464,
-0.4152185321,
-0.5972808003,
-0.5567791462,
-0.806212604,
-0.0444571786,
-0.0094577353,
-0.6753431559,
0.2009657621,
-0.374881506,
-0.4155078828,
0.0512099415,
0.3876768649,
-1.0366927385,
0.2336764187,
0.0849017426,
0.9816899896,
-0.9507185221,
1.2533171177,
0.4858845472,
-0.6531170011,
-1.0333076715,
-0.0044848621,
0.2101965696,
-0.5211439729,
0.8030593395,
0.0022823787,
-0.0388135947,
0.0773848668,
-0.4424309731,
-1.0293924809,
0.7387623191,
0.6844813228,
-0.6013558507,
0.0062175724,
0.3006180227,
0.6668937802,
0.0153608462,
-0.1099137813,
0.9193684459,
0.2734247446,
0.0052582743,
-1.1357462406,
-0.140691191,
-0.0099594062,
-0.0613007061,
0.609526515,
-0.8472376466,
0.8248451948,
0.0176858418,
-0.5869328976,
0.2008704245,
0.6273304224,
-0.1761709303,
-0.0833257586,
0.5160318017,
0.7593596578,
0.9329325557,
-0.1975365579,
1.0813043118,
-0.4200991392,
0.4291340113,
1.1722716093,
0.0600724518,
0.7843095064,
0.5766789913,
-0.3621518314,
0.1279500574,
0.3531524539,
0.330817163,
0.5882304907,
0.177885443,
-0.1690779775,
-0.023684321,
-0.3545473814,
-0.1350279599,
0.3539994955,
0.3071041107,
-0.0463892892,
0.1675028205,
0.3115430176,
0.0359090082,
0.0127596594,
-0.2497036904,
0.6720939279,
0.310741812,
-0.4221436679,
0.7883552909,
0.0619142912,
0.5922116041,
-0.3685951829,
0.2099196762,
-0.0559783205,
0.1798454821,
-0.1219618767,
-0.5044768453,
0.4425993264,
0.1221762002,
-0.3571914136,
-0.4173437059,
0.8736323118,
-0.4740432501,
-0.3249794245,
-0.0246796589,
0.4130130708,
0.1477375925,
-0.2560076714,
-0.2968933284,
0.3848284781,
0.0007283011,
-0.1195534542,
0.631898284,
0.5137270093,
0.3248947561,
0.6805297136,
0.4870329797,
0.5333616138,
-0.1767278016,
-0.1685374826,
1.0332885981,
-0.2783996761,
-0.4052003324,
-0.6913893819,
0.1755362749,
-0.1457344294,
0.07335601,
0.6410320997,
0.4505852163,
0.8009288311,
0.0865340084,
0.6681003571,
-0.3557869196,
0.3161787987,
-0.5815287232,
0.6689741015,
-0.5627058148,
0.3086743951,
0.2049729526,
-0.681530416,
-0.1784040183,
0.5683755279,
-0.3415353894,
-0.1820643395,
0.7320213318,
0.5544344187,
-0.0399657562,
-0.0391023159,
0.3836164474,
0.2578042746,
0.0669540167,
0.5011937618,
0.5468122959,
-0.4267101884,
0.6618133783,
-0.8271445632,
-0.0430552736,
-0.1760996729,
-0.5233108997,
-0.8257293105,
-0.640407145,
-0.302390337,
-0.228042528,
-0.1620652378,
0.8550384641,
0.7741863132,
-0.5820248723,
-0.0413066186,
0.137895599,
0.0272654071,
-0.1220554635,
-0.1702119559,
0.3262896836,
0.0227637272,
-0.6751109362,
0.4583705962,
0.0370048732,
0.2657203972,
-0.1348754764,
0.0380067453,
0.0348377563,
0.0347765125,
0.2572700679,
0.5358675122,
-0.2340735793,
-0.387218684,
-0.4048374295,
-0.0601141714,
-0.2774394155,
1.1524460316,
-1.038443327,
0.1544575095,
0.4134286046,
0.4736411273,
0.4330800772,
0.0785189644,
0.7399498224,
-1.2677853107,
0.8611939549,
0.2306161374,
0.4023716152,
0.2744596601,
-0.4005114734,
0.7261013985,
0.1235680878,
-0.6575450301,
-1.1136263609,
0.2706700563,
-0.3087249398,
-0.462280184,
1.0760766268,
-0.0265407562,
-0.3613453209,
0.4132118821,
-0.2164946198,
0.4313499033,
-0.2766421437,
0.7329046726,
0.7209738493,
-0.1299111694,
-0.1732274145,
-0.6790362597,
0.8252127767,
0.3227186799,
-0.4157411158,
0.1553120613,
0.7760459185,
-0.0487065464,
0.0769453794,
0.4273913801,
0.5776083469,
0.0134931142,
0.1509805322,
-0.2472642362,
-0.0767743066,
-0.5079180598,
-0.6655138135,
0.2975737453,
0.3240155578,
0.024891803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04748v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04748v1
|
Multilingual Brain Surgeon: Large Language Models Can be Compressed Leaving No Language Behind
| 2024-04-06T22:16:32 | 2024-04-06T22:16:32 |
Hongchuan Zeng, Hongshen Xu, Lu Chen, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have ushered in a new era in Natural Language
Processing, but their massive size demands effective compression techniques for
practicality. Although numerous model compression techniques have been
investigated, they typically rely on a calibration set that overlooks the
multilingual context and results in significant accuracy degradation for
low-resource languages. This paper introduces Multilingual Brain Surgeon (MBS),
a novel calibration data sampling method for multilingual LLMs compression. MBS
overcomes the English-centric limitations of existing methods by sampling
calibration data from various languages proportionally to the language
distribution of the model training datasets. Our experiments, conducted on the
BLOOM multilingual LLM, demonstrate that MBS improves the performance of
existing English-centric compression methods, especially for low-resource
languages. We also uncover the dynamics of language interaction during
compression, revealing that the larger the proportion of a language in the
training set and the more similar the language is to the calibration language,
the better performance the language retains after compression. In conclusion,
MBS presents an innovative approach to compressing multilingual LLMs,
addressing the performance disparities and improving the language inclusivity
of existing compression techniques.
|
[
-0.4163655639,
-0.3533471823,
0.3253634274,
0.3440467417,
-0.2537573278,
0.1528135538,
-0.6457589269,
-0.2960291803,
0.6593668461,
0.4528396428,
-0.6844127774,
-0.3557728231,
-0.4120691121,
0.2387167215,
0.1688229442,
0.7857033014,
0.3599805534,
0.7477381229,
-0.260186553,
-0.1459341943,
-0.6532960534,
-0.57561028,
-0.6698766351,
-0.4457537234,
0.6794492602,
0.106169872,
0.5972436666,
0.5657550693,
0.1674601138,
0.3148378134,
-0.2160051465,
0.3310628533,
-0.3312515616,
0.0541989729,
-0.0337590948,
-0.5749942064,
-0.1985587478,
-0.3726298511,
0.5767902136,
0.9715316296,
-0.6132876277,
-0.0356639698,
0.152106896,
0.7423998713,
-0.5823411345,
0.0134177906,
-0.6694952846,
0.1520996541,
-0.2468848974,
-0.5021262765,
-0.7179236412,
-0.3848799169,
-0.4980639815,
-0.2250956893,
-0.0141747938,
-0.2521112263,
0.3641535044,
0.4302546382,
-0.5292833447,
0.1821281016,
-0.2637683451,
0.9746307731,
-0.614967823,
0.5732964873,
0.1884347498,
0.4754382372,
0.0578197688,
-0.0663542151,
-0.4614730775,
0.2024410069,
0.1132822186,
-0.124486126,
0.1138719544,
0.0432044379,
0.1682151407,
0.2054937482,
-0.5298631787,
0.3725908995,
-0.366907537,
-0.5317352414,
0.5260750055,
-0.1186686456,
0.2672581077,
-0.1922846138,
-0.1965411156,
-0.4205133617,
-1.1462017298,
-0.1565046906,
0.6038190722,
0.367500782,
-0.0844614878,
0.2587623894,
0.1495196968,
1.1319391727,
-0.3965372443,
-0.555277884,
0.4396058321,
-0.0280476138,
-0.2350744903,
0.0859604254,
0.5998398066,
0.5138949752,
0.3092710376,
-0.1477542967,
0.0061725383,
-0.0182764102,
0.0208557434,
-0.8120788932,
-0.226871714,
0.2867413759,
-0.2493130714,
-0.0691402033,
-0.4031569958,
-0.8457764983,
-0.5065933466,
-0.2628394067,
0.0218807161,
-0.3534966111,
-0.3557974696,
0.3370857835,
0.01505733,
-0.009963138,
0.1448877603,
-1.0618540049,
0.0597241521,
0.4453001916,
0.6680956483,
0.0143822655,
-0.3293061852,
-0.592497766,
0.3720456064,
-0.3074883521,
0.7751717567,
-0.3043072224,
-0.3005929887,
0.0786673874,
0.0029893001,
0.123302646,
-0.6651633978,
0.3004501164,
-0.3570636511,
-0.1412469298,
-0.2475156933,
-0.1143420786,
-0.383251071,
0.4915774763,
-0.6592960954,
0.5804095268,
-0.1164774671,
-0.3572384417,
0.1414996833,
-0.1554691344,
-0.5373423696,
0.1308057755,
-0.5301335454,
-0.0756539032,
0.2573583424,
0.6098028421,
0.6125814319,
-0.3247146308,
0.2738902569,
-0.4329647124,
-0.2969064415,
0.0155250188,
-0.5388382077,
0.9348015189,
0.1731453091,
0.4223494232,
-0.3042538464,
-0.494769901,
0.3807717562,
-0.0842123553,
-0.3899828196,
-0.1455157846,
-0.1312847883,
0.1966882497,
0.1637138128,
0.1990191191,
-0.7342426777,
0.5520837307,
-0.5441566706,
0.6148870587,
0.4670277238,
-0.0792645141,
0.2020865232,
-0.3786608875,
0.5876558423,
-0.1685260981,
-0.0950222686,
-0.5018056035,
-0.2385657281,
-0.4677024782,
-0.5961622596,
0.4099107087,
0.7324211001,
-0.9022740722,
0.3722714484,
-0.6949647665,
-0.6792730689,
-0.7455675602,
0.1003755778,
0.2154813856,
0.2471158653,
0.2309516817,
-0.2488151044,
-0.5772750378,
-1.1816266775,
-0.413097769,
-0.0899571329,
-0.225331828,
0.3036945462,
-0.084306784,
-0.072582379,
0.5837285519,
-0.5306806564,
-0.3398537338,
-0.0947207436,
0.1157900393,
0.434233427,
0.7010429502,
0.5485989451,
-0.6816293001,
-0.2970984578,
-0.0061151623,
-0.5519031882,
-0.1146177277,
-0.0114748739,
0.2976694703,
0.2738799751,
0.364523232,
-0.5950800776,
0.0810757801,
1.0396382809,
0.3136925697,
0.3520913124,
-0.4403114319,
0.427408427,
-1.0421088934,
0.0287032593,
-0.2815072834,
-0.3889174163,
-0.4034648538,
0.3279559612,
0.4526586235,
-0.2185861915,
-0.6255795956,
0.34630844,
-0.700388968,
0.1242509931,
-0.2262429148,
-0.1084971353,
0.0029876153,
0.5398557186,
0.1242425665,
0.6731770039,
0.6221417785,
-0.5247792006,
0.2781245112,
0.2433729321,
-0.4053868651,
0.7988690734,
-0.400275588,
0.3093851507,
-0.4489578307,
0.3954283893,
-0.8303787708,
-0.1209080294,
-0.2766706049,
-0.4074696004,
0.7899854183,
-0.3250486851,
-0.759154737,
-0.3062662184,
-0.342992872,
0.6210481524,
0.3682801127,
-0.5046162605,
0.4996019304,
0.8346643448,
-0.2945295274,
-0.674986124,
-1.3116326332,
0.3665429354,
-0.0906620696,
-0.6147848964,
0.4337503016,
-0.6331346035,
0.0756105334,
-0.5077523589,
-0.0615515746,
-0.2931925058,
-0.2431630492,
-0.1321463883,
0.2786431015,
0.1336089671,
0.1551637053,
0.3497968614,
0.0557181835,
-0.158137545,
-0.0999838635,
0.7380744219,
0.3498478234,
-0.351424545,
-0.1015671343,
0.4264463782,
0.464976877,
-0.137363404,
0.6041266322,
0.3680229485,
-0.5736445189,
0.0621846057,
-0.9498540759,
-0.4386853576,
-0.4343441129,
0.4834935367,
-0.4323241711,
-0.8493387699,
0.3034232259,
-0.1658261865,
0.1744572818,
0.1510171145,
0.5578349233,
0.2898254991,
1.1494156122,
0.6827393174,
-0.244428575,
0.1645525843,
0.1058826894,
0.1651701629,
-0.8069353104,
-0.1769784242,
-0.6058763266,
-0.4481380284,
-0.4332932532,
-0.4908638,
0.6382180452,
0.0826138183,
0.2009084076,
0.3258100748,
-0.5926182866,
0.8836231828,
0.1505310237,
0.1714162827,
-0.0070381332,
0.3178393245,
-0.3361217976,
-0.3300465941,
-0.7591186762,
-0.2812204361,
0.9603068829,
0.1198060885,
0.6016103029,
0.221101433,
0.5345241427,
-0.2148001641,
0.4694200456,
-0.7201340795,
0.4854192436,
-0.2523592412,
-0.5249965787,
-0.0265115704,
-0.6397627592,
-0.9077887535,
0.3889710605,
-0.0773261115,
-0.9894388914,
0.0471349396,
0.13746503,
-0.5475908518,
0.4537570775,
-0.6850020885,
0.5274494886,
0.0235188417,
-0.2738291025,
-0.5650599599,
-0.685012579,
0.3195936978,
-0.353125155,
0.5600018501,
-0.0105521083,
-0.1449358314,
0.50807482,
-0.2284207195,
0.660054028,
-0.2205361873,
-0.191046387,
-0.1928241253,
0.2817366421,
0.3525147438,
0.1636627316,
-0.1977546513,
0.6111736298,
0.3035566211,
-0.3652461469,
-0.5956116319,
1.0605055094,
-0.3050246537,
-0.3647041917,
-0.2329032719,
-0.8840546012,
-0.4805874527,
0.0447740518,
0.1355175227,
0.4059726298,
0.0280965939,
0.189089641,
0.4198141694,
-0.5176836848,
0.4846970141,
0.6522772908,
-0.1539447755,
-0.8952906728,
0.7198218703,
0.1977540404,
-0.0260121934,
0.6706675887,
-0.0280653816,
-0.1025951132,
-0.3999637663,
-0.7881516814,
0.333548069,
-0.5465578437,
-0.5609966516,
-0.5930934548,
0.0125983106,
-0.5901706219,
-0.0589490645,
-0.3015291691,
-0.3071122169,
0.305627346,
0.1964043528,
0.0192387383,
0.39625144,
-0.2342125028,
0.4945960939,
-1.0750374794,
0.0172807779,
0.0042507923,
0.2534793913,
-0.1671986282,
-0.1858910173,
-0.3469472528,
0.1619352847,
-0.3234885931,
-1.1474709511,
0.7456472516,
0.1489618421,
0.3226870298,
0.3367423117,
-0.2586008906,
1.0402503014,
-0.8482124805,
0.8372032642,
0.432213217,
-0.5352676511,
0.134974435,
-0.0268296171,
0.7645782828,
0.6425055265,
0.2752252221,
-0.8610609174,
-0.0607110746,
-0.0953137353,
-0.7986536622,
0.5851027966,
-0.3886680603,
0.3712034822,
-0.1242078692,
0.3384162784,
0.1985111088,
0.5786149502,
-0.8744586706,
-0.2744545043,
0.3317298889,
-0.4461151361,
-0.3100574017,
-0.2240921855,
-0.2774670124,
-0.2818756104,
0.7122821808,
-0.4392458797,
0.3914780021,
-0.1299347579,
-0.1806308478,
-0.1407995522,
0.1732122004,
0.4536527991,
0.2851600647,
0.043307174,
0.2001849264,
0.3443838954,
-0.520755887,
0.0542076342,
0.2114753872,
0.0177576225,
-0.0808231607,
0.0397269391,
0.4545070529,
0.3517439961,
-0.8524363637,
0.5739288926,
-0.1242366806,
0.0396126322,
-0.2767188847,
-0.3923253715,
0.072064817,
0.120568648,
0.2349389493,
0.3553299904,
0.0470163003,
-0.0959606245,
0.0337317921,
0.649587512,
-0.2020899206,
-0.224268958,
0.4942577481,
-0.0192874074,
-0.2410359383,
0.5610580444,
0.1186111569,
-0.4046079218,
0.2178352922,
0.4533358216,
0.5670268536,
-0.557264328,
-0.1949648857,
0.5356680155,
0.5839738846,
-0.1607631445,
0.370218873,
-0.1046365201,
-0.7416267991,
-1.1023168564,
-0.486751318,
-0.2427310199,
0.3150722086,
-0.5209139585,
0.5507602096,
-0.1435459554,
-0.0652161911,
-0.137184009,
-0.0797208399,
-0.5888537765,
0.1552992463,
0.197639212,
1.1745276451,
-0.5366760492,
0.9549921155,
0.6505581737,
-0.0256114136,
-0.6774585843,
-0.1853090525,
0.219234854,
-0.8681131601,
0.3780730367,
0.4498743117,
0.0726871789,
0.0833674744,
-0.4119037092,
-0.7757457495,
0.7133259773,
1.1293773651,
-0.6705010533,
-0.0766553208,
0.1497741342,
0.2341810763,
-0.043939624,
0.4351581931,
0.1950559914,
0.4647131264,
-0.0656467304,
-0.9901643395,
-0.2009657919,
-0.1819859743,
-0.1350851804,
0.4536191225,
-0.4960556328,
0.5257081985,
0.0109238289,
-0.0378867425,
0.1064811647,
0.413582623,
0.3812662065,
-0.3447415829,
0.6878540516,
0.644746542,
0.8141052723,
0.0150823081,
1.0309038162,
-0.9379925132,
0.146450758,
0.8239665031,
-0.0902215168,
0.8865199685,
1.0106842518,
-0.0212394558,
0.33518067,
0.5446711779,
0.1861918718,
0.4789267778,
0.3019553423,
-0.263766855,
-0.3235487044,
-0.1943688989,
-0.232146278,
0.2928494811,
0.1362261027,
0.0262494106,
-0.1748455316,
0.2761852443,
0.257907778,
0.090634644,
-0.341563493,
0.3767327368,
0.0955850184,
-0.9439916015,
0.7865160108,
0.1522409767,
0.9308995008,
-0.8839299679,
0.0426285528,
-0.0385333486,
0.1440175176,
-0.0666721091,
-0.5172483921,
0.4400661886,
-0.2498695999,
-0.0958891809,
-0.5665296912,
0.3326240182,
-0.8276228309,
-0.3949035406,
0.0665578395,
0.4006117582,
0.6083884239,
-0.2038446367,
-0.3245404661,
0.2001243681,
0.0393303446,
-0.0697111115,
0.3522210717,
0.1697165221,
0.3333379328,
0.653708756,
0.5602547526,
0.7172778249,
-0.2921305299,
0.0579714961,
0.6103500724,
-0.3390594125,
-0.5764449835,
-0.8771785498,
0.2501692474,
-0.0740124136,
-0.2220093906,
0.622349143,
0.7687752843,
0.9444497228,
-0.1934981644,
0.4216586649,
0.1661525667,
0.5287287235,
-0.5596559644,
0.8446096778,
-0.8206101656,
0.1348907948,
-0.0219036974,
-0.8108679652,
-0.6329241991,
0.7049071789,
-0.016088739,
0.0474435166,
0.7457957864,
1.0008153915,
0.0235298257,
-0.1351693422,
0.5340493321,
0.0932012126,
0.0976578519,
0.7203532457,
0.2250035405,
-0.1870557666,
0.6000156999,
-0.1720978022,
-0.2811813653,
0.0570459366,
-0.9730708599,
-0.5406948924,
-0.3764632344,
-0.2239827961,
-0.1564324647,
-0.3503850102,
1.0616619587,
1.280053854,
-0.5863694549,
-0.5540091395,
0.2647642493,
-0.1498001516,
-0.5072666407,
-0.1244346946,
0.0791715905,
-0.1121553779,
-1.1740168333,
0.7498112321,
0.3386565447,
-0.1228732541,
-0.6107499003,
0.0059741042,
0.0478486419,
0.0839667395,
0.3866946995,
0.1146196499,
-0.5829252005,
-0.0525378399,
-0.1155500859,
-0.0081069265,
0.1013821214,
0.7113361359,
-1.0729259253,
0.6773917675,
0.2528738976,
0.8176406622,
0.4090947807,
-0.6888990402,
0.6521000862,
-1.2487534285,
0.6262747049,
0.1652368009,
0.6171868443,
0.6555684805,
-0.3653465211,
0.4960360229,
0.1381226778,
-0.502317667,
-1.0865066051,
0.4102042913,
-0.8837336302,
-0.3051768541,
1.0772938728,
0.0785237551,
-0.3250513971,
0.3723468781,
-0.4813105166,
0.2666783929,
-0.2011071593,
0.7302033901,
0.8819451332,
0.3040194511,
-0.1787375957,
-0.6346433163,
0.2478816211,
0.6558408737,
-0.6183959246,
0.0377879776,
0.4781955779,
0.1524673104,
0.1446733028,
0.5499849916,
-0.2266675979,
0.0283987243,
-0.3663788438,
0.545103848,
-0.0163675658,
-0.2020477653,
-0.7952772975,
0.278832823,
-0.1211015508,
0.1254561096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04735v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04735v1
|
MACM: Utilizing a Multi-Agent System for Condition Mining in Solving Complex Mathematical Problems
| 2024-04-06T21:39:01 | 2024-04-06T21:39:01 |
Bin Lei
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA
|
Recent advancements in large language models, such as GPT-4, have
demonstrated remarkable capabilities in processing standard queries. Despite
these advancements, their performance substantially declines in
\textbf{advanced mathematical problems requiring complex, multi-step logical
reasoning}. To enhance their inferential capabilities, current research has
delved into \textit{prompting engineering}, exemplified by methodologies such
as the Tree of Thought and Graph of Thought. Nonetheless, these existing
approaches encounter two significant limitations. Firstly, their effectiveness
in tackling complex mathematical problems is somewhat constrained. Secondly,
the necessity to design distinct prompts for individual problems hampers their
generalizability. In response to these limitations, this paper introduces the
\textit{Multi-Agent System for conditional Mining} (\textbf{MACM}) prompting
method. It not only resolves intricate mathematical problems but also
demonstrates strong generalization capabilities across various mathematical
contexts. With the assistance of MACM, the accuracy of GPT-4 Turbo on the most
challenging level five mathematical problems in the MATH dataset increase from
$\mathbf{54.68\%} \text{ to } \mathbf{76.73\%}$. The code is available in
\url{https://github.com/bin123apple/MACM}.
|
[
-0.5952939391,
-0.7134338617,
1.0754483938,
0.5938847065,
-0.0851064771,
0.2601957023,
-0.1258575171,
-0.1990447938,
0.1710376441,
0.4979146719,
-0.9713128209,
-0.5711959004,
-0.6359724998,
0.3635158837,
0.1435600817,
1.003328681,
-0.3193132579,
-0.1593586653,
-0.1864573061,
-0.0172981936,
-0.6535342336,
-0.7349054813,
-1.1277868748,
-0.3369688094,
0.2263228297,
0.5948784351,
0.7697489262,
-0.2586216331,
0.6848250031,
0.3918822408,
0.4547976255,
0.4591150284,
-0.1298633218,
0.5323126912,
-0.0757280812,
-0.6878613234,
-0.4964010715,
0.1451188177,
0.3841935396,
0.3124360442,
-0.4162806571,
-0.1044767052,
-0.077815637,
0.4676575363,
-0.3790115118,
0.6989811659,
-0.6764093637,
0.075488396,
0.0832520574,
-0.5969356298,
-0.4244558215,
-0.107669495,
-0.0550583601,
-0.7749173641,
0.3022241592,
0.0683655739,
0.9733071327,
0.6502649784,
-0.3956495225,
-0.3878232837,
-0.3419817686,
0.8827980757,
-0.4535903931,
-0.1164078638,
0.7506712675,
0.5425773263,
-0.5128082633,
-0.7194245458,
-0.5466127396,
-0.3158418536,
-0.0372800529,
0.2198057771,
-0.2131242305,
0.1999351084,
0.6719608307,
-0.120675005,
-0.1915619671,
-0.3477660418,
-0.0178118516,
-0.5248519182,
0.2829004824,
0.4483416378,
0.64052701,
-0.3513405919,
-0.3052808046,
-0.0519701242,
-0.203267321,
0.393953234,
0.2943417132,
0.2378469557,
0.0041871555,
0.4463487864,
-0.2133024037,
0.3180214167,
-0.0126799569,
-0.0701182932,
0.3238933384,
-0.2819426656,
-0.1927303225,
-0.0518574119,
0.601958096,
0.1940915734,
0.3058744073,
0.1499632746,
-0.5572681427,
0.3343757093,
0.0243302584,
-0.8941453695,
-0.4937291741,
-0.0566157624,
0.0070875646,
0.1100694165,
0.2748101652,
-0.341614306,
-0.2127927095,
-0.4193492532,
0.6609369516,
-0.440746665,
-0.2997119725,
0.1962862909,
-0.23793374,
-0.0777968541,
0.242438823,
-0.5086961389,
0.4239216745,
0.5515310168,
0.9646733999,
0.309033066,
-0.2409147173,
-0.9357498288,
-0.0560332984,
-0.3279368877,
0.8145403862,
-0.8202083707,
-0.4254987538,
-0.5085515976,
0.0802992582,
-0.1710529625,
-0.5678477883,
0.8560169935,
-0.4586600661,
0.176243633,
-0.5215402246,
-0.0126072317,
-0.3364351392,
0.6201119423,
-0.5997411609,
1.0483657122,
0.1277525425,
-0.6255853772,
0.3000878096,
-0.8789312243,
-0.3130863607,
-0.0382640138,
-0.1929961443,
-0.5174118876,
-0.1815850288,
0.5490751266,
0.35576123,
-0.3820644915,
0.4577673674,
-0.4969640374,
-0.0869709924,
0.0533719994,
-0.1529405862,
0.5507300496,
0.5028532743,
-0.36460796,
0.123610355,
-0.3357187212,
0.2405833602,
0.1126565635,
-0.0607647039,
-0.4454007149,
0.1349131167,
-0.7063866258,
0.6333185434,
0.285113126,
-0.2756652236,
0.2486855686,
-0.2613728642,
0.4809371829,
0.7705757618,
0.3295020461,
0.1595024467,
-0.4490581155,
0.8934073448,
0.2296314985,
0.1439987421,
-0.1820969433,
-0.6294001937,
-0.7677727342,
-0.4459436536,
0.1922131181,
0.719425261,
-1.1648137569,
0.0332982913,
0.3342654705,
0.2254802734,
-0.3704073727,
-0.0135968644,
0.2612891793,
0.440636307,
0.5235809088,
-0.0231120605,
-0.6941165328,
-0.9074042439,
-0.001735529,
0.041237656,
0.0184689406,
0.1805015504,
0.1210763752,
-0.5938284993,
1.1306961775,
-0.4755294919,
-0.0453361943,
-0.0276078135,
0.3542057276,
0.7451720834,
0.3212183714,
0.4329621196,
-0.7132848501,
-0.7031754851,
-0.1203955039,
-0.7165466547,
-0.3293733895,
0.1185682267,
-0.3176386654,
0.0582991689,
0.4580993652,
-0.8165175319,
0.5357948542,
0.4865477085,
-0.0308986697,
0.4082947373,
-0.4159439802,
0.3939729035,
-0.936052084,
-0.0800820813,
0.112462543,
-0.3938296139,
-0.4038054645,
-0.059058737,
-0.0069524245,
-0.5682958364,
-0.0686094239,
0.3718594015,
-0.7356939316,
0.2185590267,
-0.387454778,
-0.0125879804,
-0.2428110391,
0.5387308002,
-0.2325342745,
0.5798714757,
0.9199601412,
-1.1050076485,
0.3087510467,
-0.1163524985,
0.2182336897,
0.7131240964,
-0.591455996,
0.118302308,
-0.2144770771,
0.4519362152,
-0.6281558275,
-0.1725956947,
0.6064448953,
-0.6309267879,
0.1465169638,
-0.0330794118,
-0.5857049823,
-0.5256012082,
-0.4203867912,
0.3079634309,
0.2782597542,
-0.4489466548,
0.7234658003,
0.252821207,
-0.4542180002,
-0.5397488475,
-0.200261116,
0.2263567895,
0.0759682357,
-0.7724434733,
0.2150432318,
-0.3435283005,
-0.3234989643,
0.1591267884,
-0.3314434588,
0.0556488112,
0.1271596998,
0.3794202805,
0.3384692371,
0.2158356309,
0.1862196177,
0.2965944111,
-0.6667649746,
0.407851547,
-0.2526827753,
0.5562976003,
-0.1289695799,
-0.3615013361,
-0.4174402356,
0.2533131242,
0.3422750533,
-0.2958398461,
0.3962556124,
0.2898253202,
-0.66915977,
-0.6177617908,
-0.2433831245,
-0.3764500618,
-0.515257895,
-0.1026544869,
-1.0068832636,
-0.5887630582,
0.5924405456,
-0.1259583384,
-0.1418276429,
0.7265757322,
0.5697910786,
0.3389903009,
1.8278032541,
0.5821604729,
-0.1656352729,
0.2370459139,
-0.2597289085,
0.2544435263,
-0.4218623042,
-0.406670779,
-0.580014348,
-0.3079518676,
-0.5614020824,
-0.1904860288,
0.5865345001,
-0.0183850508,
-0.1894637942,
0.0543961003,
-0.5875713229,
0.3497962952,
0.5934032202,
0.272125721,
0.1604057103,
-0.1978397816,
-0.8693367839,
0.2656114995,
-0.6725712419,
-0.2926888466,
0.6289491653,
-0.0129354587,
0.6261945963,
0.1441856325,
0.6754258275,
0.1920568198,
0.4608544111,
-0.8730890751,
0.5856275558,
0.309674263,
-0.8667988181,
-0.243962124,
-0.8450900316,
-1.0957680941,
0.0798881501,
-0.1955764443,
-0.3407907784,
0.1593823433,
0.1875948161,
-0.4274470508,
0.1790660173,
-0.7889011502,
0.5370209813,
-0.1622614712,
0.0968730152,
-0.2884716392,
-0.6825290918,
0.4157085121,
-0.2304294556,
0.3786393702,
-0.4438572824,
-0.120064877,
0.3372856975,
-0.9889039397,
0.5716750026,
-0.6024658084,
0.2080479264,
0.4996580482,
0.1919147521,
0.7505880594,
0.3525893986,
-0.3620734513,
-0.2279749364,
0.2319245487,
-0.6142466068,
-0.6594622731,
0.9465562105,
-0.7767329216,
-0.6861237288,
-0.8750525713,
-0.4931986034,
-0.4897804856,
0.3060132563,
0.1481622458,
0.3710129857,
0.3994641304,
-0.200545758,
0.2844980955,
0.0559239723,
0.595435977,
0.5678517818,
-0.1162270829,
-0.2805456519,
1.01618433,
-0.157469064,
-0.1893103123,
0.3413589001,
0.2876582742,
-0.4571784139,
-0.2172776908,
-0.1040128618,
0.2265288532,
-0.5989653468,
-0.5488862991,
-0.6770206094,
-0.1506074667,
-0.1375037879,
0.1453843117,
0.3136132061,
-0.2651268542,
-0.3037815988,
-0.1708794385,
0.3586854935,
0.4147698879,
-0.1746643037,
-0.0829099566,
-0.8857026696,
0.5356843472,
0.5242118835,
0.4134109616,
-0.1477002501,
-0.0268136747,
-0.0537264533,
0.0737641901,
-0.4784768522,
-0.7623144984,
0.4171862006,
0.2281825393,
0.801209569,
0.2716570497,
0.4222259521,
0.5476386547,
-0.297362268,
0.1655742824,
0.3356918395,
-1.1574765444,
0.5819481611,
-0.0660187826,
0.0294643715,
0.6581702828,
0.4357256293,
-0.5450769067,
-0.4435105026,
-0.8338147402,
-0.5624597669,
1.0284171104,
0.338175416,
-0.176765576,
-0.257349968,
0.6426249743,
-0.0444844849,
0.2227735668,
-0.5092362761,
-0.1691475362,
-0.3460634351,
-0.2551842928,
-0.2674890459,
0.102134414,
0.1472113431,
-0.083287701,
0.7212260962,
-0.1370290667,
0.1041431502,
0.3879528046,
-0.2394850254,
-0.2529624104,
0.247230351,
0.4917991757,
0.8750918508,
-0.2523646951,
0.4295946062,
0.2876783013,
-0.3008487821,
0.3813684881,
0.3677588403,
-0.0497169271,
-0.0630921498,
-0.0628743544,
0.5893976092,
0.0104578817,
-0.4483003914,
0.1979941875,
-0.0528034866,
-0.3831543624,
0.0107647749,
0.2149186134,
-0.2776463628,
0.0773373693,
0.4209235907,
0.2546387911,
0.3474527597,
-0.746368289,
0.1200491488,
0.6377921104,
-0.4135157466,
-0.464014858,
0.5625855923,
0.096375756,
-0.5159980059,
0.625826776,
-0.6498551965,
-0.9426442981,
0.8358000517,
0.4628819525,
0.7125943899,
-0.2823947966,
0.2469732165,
0.3261019289,
0.4672468007,
-0.2462313473,
0.4818457961,
-0.0431447215,
-0.706382513,
-0.6052271128,
-0.2970798016,
-0.7982712388,
-0.2792663574,
-0.2554813027,
0.4033498168,
-0.7130095959,
-0.5509469509,
-0.1722946465,
0.2905265987,
-0.703466177,
0.443865329,
-0.1796048433,
0.428506583,
-0.3959338367,
0.6021040082,
0.8231434226,
-0.3500343263,
-1.1265202761,
-0.2755032182,
-0.0149242515,
-0.8761097193,
0.4484673738,
0.3035302162,
-0.5083543062,
0.1211091131,
-0.7677355409,
-0.4477736652,
0.7725635171,
0.42617172,
-0.4264022708,
0.1832212955,
-0.3111250997,
0.2665020227,
-0.1354754716,
0.4856487811,
0.408798337,
0.9365808368,
0.2099589109,
-0.7129442692,
0.244825542,
-0.5105965734,
-0.3579729199,
0.9092748165,
-0.6109414101,
1.0597538948,
-0.3745176792,
-0.3694864213,
-0.1631618887,
0.3100605905,
0.5668254495,
0.9831913114,
0.8106929064,
0.6117835045,
1.1334400177,
-0.1631879359,
0.9865384102,
-0.4323316813,
0.5205910206,
0.4992407262,
-0.26815027,
0.2581799924,
0.0456447899,
-0.1243465245,
0.5860716701,
1.0140761137,
0.339974165,
0.3339318335,
0.3983423114,
-0.4703834653,
-0.7271655202,
0.1332380623,
-0.4334837198,
-0.0948809758,
0.5265355706,
0.2008072287,
-0.2028232813,
-0.0381368548,
0.0362961255,
-0.2108275294,
-0.4700852633,
0.3345110714,
0.5521090031,
-0.9683045745,
0.1930291802,
0.3353644609,
0.5808819532,
-0.7940894365,
-0.2519836426,
-0.2577382922,
0.0382346921,
-0.4028092623,
-0.2008202672,
-0.0868699402,
-0.2044334412,
-0.4415734112,
-0.1000727117,
0.7265762091,
-0.0709263757,
-0.712279439,
0.2309195697,
0.5195401907,
0.1774992794,
-0.3851858675,
-0.8192539811,
-0.2937689424,
-0.1798948795,
0.2558724284,
-0.095742695,
0.9302651286,
-0.3843287528,
0.8278118968,
0.9010000229,
-0.1313953102,
-0.1589605659,
0.4283906221,
0.9064067602,
-0.938025713,
-0.5189109445,
-1.0443409681,
0.1327853352,
0.1092868224,
-0.0243926477,
0.8183799386,
0.4209064841,
0.1744684726,
0.3416189849,
0.8069125414,
0.1803750545,
0.5387257338,
-0.6886319518,
0.2229714841,
-0.5081262589,
0.372793287,
-0.4409459829,
-1.018353343,
-0.5394681692,
0.4168457389,
-0.2784428596,
0.265066117,
1.1182867289,
0.6097360253,
-0.1824179888,
-0.1092979461,
0.1029755026,
-0.0300223213,
0.6471850276,
0.6325674653,
1.0544323921,
0.1571534276,
0.7834228873,
0.0197545532,
-0.5752574205,
-0.2287252247,
-0.9506269693,
-0.7473174334,
-0.3363831937,
-0.1428013593,
-0.2446649671,
-0.1943179816,
1.0715118647,
0.7056905627,
-0.8058294654,
0.0240696725,
-0.2036945224,
0.436909914,
-0.2041687965,
-0.2228289545,
0.2444501072,
-0.9365617037,
-0.5638881922,
0.3516717255,
0.4867962301,
-0.1650720835,
-0.0038970464,
-0.3538024127,
0.0455331467,
0.2978011072,
0.6420307159,
0.3179041147,
-0.3235095739,
-0.1605864763,
0.2015032768,
0.0760994777,
0.130788669,
0.9814171195,
-0.7473149896,
0.7099963427,
0.3370097876,
0.4405809045,
1.004234314,
0.1620364338,
0.3836910129,
-0.4354401231,
0.0664917529,
0.3150749207,
0.5461941957,
0.1545669138,
-0.3494282961,
0.3501987159,
0.314360261,
-0.7001002431,
-0.4307322204,
0.1659056693,
-0.9900708199,
-0.1077361852,
0.7722349763,
0.2048519552,
-0.0097390432,
-0.2173561752,
-0.6155405045,
0.1236724481,
-0.8821613789,
0.5802791119,
0.8705145717,
-0.4677649736,
-0.0949914679,
-0.5640236139,
0.4293283224,
0.4126268625,
-1.0095795393,
-0.9128148556,
0.4275845587,
0.2355723381,
0.065892376,
0.8109247088,
0.2997711897,
0.2673226595,
-0.2424746007,
0.0796236917,
-0.0683336407,
-0.4048275948,
0.0356287509,
0.2978609204,
0.2419715971,
-0.3141878843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04728v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04728v1
|
Navigating the Landscape of Hint Generation Research: From the Past to the Future
| 2024-04-06T20:42:46 | 2024-04-06T20:42:46 |
Anubhav Jangra, Jamshid Mozafari, Adam Jatowt, Smaranda Muresan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Digital education has gained popularity in the last decade, especially after
the COVID-19 pandemic. With the improving capabilities of large language models
to reason and communicate with users, envisioning intelligent tutoring systems
(ITSs) that can facilitate self-learning is not very far-fetched. One integral
component to fulfill this vision is the ability to give accurate and effective
feedback via hints to scaffold the learning process. In this survey article, we
present a comprehensive review of prior research on hint generation, aiming to
bridge the gap between research in education and cognitive science, and
research in AI and Natural Language Processing. Informed by our findings, we
propose a formal definition of the hint generation task, and discuss the
roadmap of building an effective hint generation system aligned with the formal
definition, including open challenges, future directions and ethical
considerations.
|
[
-0.2772493064,
-0.6785291433,
0.6773614287,
0.1017480567,
0.0252164081,
0.2283009142,
-0.1878638864,
-0.3184765577,
-0.0761123076,
0.0289886296,
-0.9289475083,
-0.3772965968,
-0.4816163778,
0.300096184,
-0.6710350513,
1.2609623671,
0.3231749535,
0.1248503849,
-0.7043577433,
0.5448005795,
-0.3033743799,
-0.3315402865,
-1.2040709257,
-0.1501038671,
0.434230119,
0.6996101141,
0.1147866175,
0.6106607318,
0.4611820281,
0.1862684488,
0.1820178181,
-0.0840190351,
-0.2738596797,
0.3718321025,
-0.1572355181,
-0.7611610889,
-0.2443919927,
-0.0789473206,
0.2423416972,
0.3074988425,
0.0264123511,
0.3989900351,
0.03948595,
0.6707111597,
-0.6186506748,
0.1462789625,
-0.4315369427,
-0.0158984177,
-0.3471431434,
-0.4665712714,
-0.3057544529,
-0.5765448809,
0.2045432627,
-0.6352247,
0.6483631134,
-0.1045937613,
0.4539681673,
0.4246443808,
-0.1568977982,
-0.7648789883,
-0.8406587243,
0.8014771938,
-0.7194276452,
0.0115782954,
0.4070826173,
0.774692893,
-0.2809743285,
-0.9341976643,
-0.1658012718,
0.0551163964,
0.5406284332,
0.1170310378,
-0.1077960581,
-0.2456984669,
0.1118843406,
0.2363957018,
-0.0429414436,
-0.2332419157,
-0.7300313711,
-0.2305973023,
0.817158401,
0.046182137,
0.175457865,
-0.1983387321,
-0.3310502768,
0.1404293329,
-0.9208405614,
0.2799522877,
0.330540508,
0.4399600327,
0.2088234723,
0.3263854682,
-0.2776875198,
0.6137887836,
0.5176091194,
-0.188694939,
-0.5218129754,
-0.7568632364,
0.4675862491,
0.4171764553,
0.800152123,
0.3161753118,
0.1670167148,
0.0490101017,
-0.0972412899,
0.0140689788,
0.4163084626,
-0.5138494372,
-0.641215682,
0.2392455786,
0.1629452556,
-0.2694992125,
-0.0496073589,
-0.9480937719,
-0.4109107554,
-0.1663593799,
0.0933341384,
-0.6008105874,
-0.3298609555,
-0.1278947294,
-0.4098851979,
0.1777254194,
0.6404407024,
-0.8249117136,
0.1816240251,
0.6524097919,
0.6036196947,
-0.001794485,
0.0567546152,
0.0123677906,
0.2818060815,
-0.1263015419,
0.8333148956,
-0.4960276484,
-0.5291312933,
0.0477038696,
-0.4858317375,
-0.0088393828,
-0.2231635302,
0.4674187005,
-0.1853245795,
0.6084864736,
-0.3892410398,
-0.376419872,
-0.1682308614,
0.436753124,
-0.2512786984,
1.0587980747,
-0.1123476028,
-0.971470654,
0.4105706811,
-0.7019062042,
-0.3273576796,
0.3663872182,
-0.5234522223,
-0.3232890368,
-0.1413403302,
0.580270052,
0.2039470524,
-0.4457172155,
0.3736420572,
0.0050181597,
-0.1930228323,
-0.2142075151,
-0.2080288529,
0.8726471066,
0.1547663659,
-1.0253634453,
0.0702656731,
-0.5011987686,
0.1459063739,
0.2844348252,
-0.1247884184,
-0.3477288485,
0.0003863761,
-0.4684001207,
0.2182994187,
0.3495160043,
-0.3765396178,
0.3305228651,
-0.1038561463,
0.7320905328,
0.5388093591,
0.1315136701,
0.430375278,
-0.2988773882,
0.7689926028,
-0.0417280532,
0.3955400884,
-0.4999459386,
-0.5952617526,
-0.7011092305,
-0.0427922942,
0.110374026,
0.2597346306,
-0.8599390388,
0.309144944,
-0.0605938956,
-0.4464653432,
-0.7556716204,
0.0314937755,
0.2486060709,
0.3872626722,
0.1737934947,
0.0843107551,
-0.4574421942,
-0.2595895827,
-0.2661578953,
-0.0860083699,
0.092689462,
0.3744288385,
0.4429501295,
0.0566404238,
1.3940719366,
-0.1591842026,
-0.2592315972,
-0.2210619003,
0.1044825315,
-0.3153726757,
0.482661128,
0.2425810099,
-0.6695945263,
-0.2113011777,
-0.409517318,
-0.6977015734,
0.2516315877,
-0.0212601628,
0.2786263824,
-0.1754043996,
0.781788528,
-0.3956101239,
0.2029971927,
0.1053914726,
-0.2368493378,
0.7608245611,
-0.1309463829,
0.1848284304,
-0.9856197834,
0.0106667718,
-0.1519964188,
0.0609665923,
-0.3453496695,
0.0289048944,
-0.1191149279,
-0.0337276645,
-0.0807488859,
0.6043949127,
-0.5727606416,
0.2019579709,
-0.2006628364,
0.5347055793,
-0.1749901623,
0.0861786157,
-0.3755174875,
0.6494544744,
0.5788198113,
-0.7501257658,
0.490667522,
0.0366019309,
-0.021451097,
0.9513462782,
-0.5494453311,
0.3581069112,
-0.0947692692,
0.3851570487,
-0.734128058,
-0.2470435351,
0.4487023652,
-0.7198470831,
0.1333665997,
0.1758119911,
-0.1865093559,
-1.0704469681,
-0.4119114578,
0.564687252,
0.2441325784,
-0.5253297687,
0.2545914352,
0.0781241581,
-0.4462256134,
-0.7110398412,
-0.072202526,
0.3577357531,
-0.1063375399,
-0.6353651285,
0.0810245275,
-0.0390497446,
-0.3226000965,
0.159299314,
-0.159937188,
0.0129107768,
0.1423947811,
0.2571125031,
-0.0961378515,
-0.167707324,
0.1185674593,
0.1052005142,
-0.1550287902,
0.444666326,
-0.6804454327,
0.2273635715,
0.0829341784,
-0.4310460687,
-0.1102877185,
0.14068304,
0.3309985995,
-0.3890684545,
-0.0927422568,
0.6320031285,
-0.1896170378,
-0.5765872598,
-0.3271570802,
-0.683680892,
-0.4691277444,
0.0334398784,
-0.288372159,
-0.6352448463,
0.1751912236,
-0.4916127324,
0.147792086,
0.3488408625,
0.2020484358,
-0.1288409978,
1.1062084436,
1.0758048296,
0.1511093676,
0.5118605494,
-0.5798911452,
0.5787152052,
-0.6665556431,
-0.4079918563,
-0.6221063733,
0.0379564092,
-0.0214046184,
-0.1273618937,
0.3759892583,
0.2919639349,
0.1440828294,
-0.0298482571,
-0.7434208393,
0.1925685257,
1.3356342316,
0.0437443368,
0.3085682094,
-0.3187538087,
-0.2387137115,
0.0396049134,
-1.0978716612,
-0.4802339971,
1.1423331499,
0.0182758849,
0.4939289689,
-0.3706245124,
1.0067003965,
0.4450442791,
-0.0118723596,
-0.7178593874,
0.6440876722,
0.4059428275,
-0.7414184809,
-0.3280920684,
-0.1748497635,
-0.9424737096,
-0.5634849668,
0.0274409503,
-0.6868976951,
-0.2602346838,
0.4512548745,
-0.4697105289,
0.2130739689,
-0.3398609459,
0.7133114338,
-0.3168213367,
-0.3897676468,
-0.200090304,
-0.7423588634,
0.5820934176,
0.2276340127,
0.295891881,
0.138011232,
0.470990628,
0.8315607905,
-0.2321607023,
0.9157816768,
-0.3041831553,
-0.3550999761,
0.8115900755,
-0.0221396498,
0.4015209377,
-0.2467381507,
0.101755999,
-0.2634311914,
0.3659924567,
-0.4022498727,
-0.4790257514,
0.5522177815,
-0.4523442984,
-0.7743932605,
-0.2827557325,
-0.6153217554,
0.0159621779,
0.1909203827,
0.7158931494,
0.5352452993,
-0.0888910964,
-0.3698886931,
0.79197824,
0.1416568458,
0.4624309242,
0.1952248067,
-0.1885741949,
-0.1705703288,
1.3639314175,
0.0584728941,
0.048605293,
0.069080472,
0.419608593,
-0.4059080482,
-0.7253237963,
-0.5305557847,
0.1595924646,
-0.863935113,
-0.1390885413,
-0.2304118127,
-0.2070279568,
-0.8974805474,
-0.4174313545,
-0.2709861696,
-0.3884032667,
-0.2921717763,
-0.2168271095,
0.48049891,
1.5362427235,
-0.16043742,
0.3108136356,
-0.7130121589,
-0.2454557866,
0.3308089375,
0.0164979417,
0.0965378582,
0.0129143475,
-0.3226636052,
0.1284239441,
-0.2586791813,
-0.6083467007,
-0.0775583908,
0.1441635042,
0.4904189408,
0.7158341408,
0.4475773871,
0.2924380302,
-0.3163388073,
1.2992889881,
0.2032058984,
-0.6038287878,
0.911229372,
-0.4763408005,
0.5364035964,
0.3904867172,
0.515982151,
-0.4899894297,
-0.7796428204,
-0.9682525396,
-0.9032876492,
0.3619341254,
-0.4015863836,
-0.2731212676,
0.0424767956,
0.409656316,
0.3697761893,
0.4615055323,
-0.3686482608,
-0.3713620603,
-0.3332768679,
-0.703184247,
0.0937362239,
-0.0278546158,
-0.4292218983,
-0.2034702897,
0.6409843564,
-0.4167955816,
0.4690058231,
0.1140740514,
0.042169597,
-0.1882404536,
0.1841546744,
0.572612524,
0.6573480964,
0.0682744011,
0.2076915503,
-0.5644233823,
-0.6652289033,
0.0631224886,
-0.0307667349,
-0.7445373535,
-0.0849288255,
0.1695694029,
0.512670517,
0.1859794855,
-0.3755704463,
0.6667922735,
-0.0065208245,
-0.193348214,
-0.3795779049,
0.3620570004,
-0.1603343636,
0.2723844051,
0.7039070725,
0.052700188,
0.1263849586,
-0.3186757267,
0.3446977437,
0.6292695403,
-0.4597167075,
-0.6154084206,
0.6968768239,
0.6351813674,
-0.4553942084,
0.4148091376,
-0.4594835639,
-0.6966650486,
0.5944254994,
0.7449766397,
0.9833371639,
-0.1146597788,
0.569865644,
0.5464703441,
0.2462046593,
-0.0712214932,
0.2372875363,
-0.6191748977,
-0.1718582511,
-0.1233055294,
-0.2074523121,
-0.3139579594,
-0.2010192126,
-0.4680453539,
0.1744467616,
-0.5588002205,
-0.2854644656,
-0.1883297563,
0.0049140905,
-0.6261395216,
0.3198752701,
0.1376894861,
0.8500317931,
-0.5530011654,
0.5436844826,
0.8937343955,
-0.2897842824,
-0.760507226,
0.0642321035,
0.2720040977,
-0.5223732591,
0.565819025,
0.1264103502,
-0.285928458,
0.5121714473,
-0.9038429856,
-1.0229948759,
1.1624213457,
0.0774082467,
-0.3316215277,
-0.8110643625,
0.0662609264,
0.3016781211,
-0.149223417,
0.444537282,
0.507912755,
0.4365771711,
0.1945279986,
-0.6869700551,
0.0512878522,
-0.2111938149,
-0.5525732636,
0.0964910537,
-0.3608697653,
0.57268852,
-0.8325828314,
-0.6092950106,
0.0442103371,
0.587133348,
-0.1079617515,
0.675722599,
0.0900041908,
0.4544215202,
0.8350740671,
-0.3747483492,
0.756111145,
-0.4803420305,
-0.0593584217,
1.0676846504,
0.4788454473,
0.5447239876,
0.6336988211,
-0.197032243,
0.577254355,
0.7909713984,
0.049784068,
0.442307353,
0.2009949088,
-0.3619771004,
0.0226771533,
-0.2538475096,
-0.2986615598,
0.1562735289,
0.6917129755,
-0.0692403764,
-0.4810459614,
0.1290451437,
-0.0724599808,
0.2536097169,
-0.6161341667,
0.8471968174,
0.0996792838,
-0.8493877053,
0.1383580118,
-0.3935157359,
0.8325628042,
-0.6715699434,
-0.0596556365,
-0.0378184244,
0.1015649587,
-0.220588237,
-0.5122218132,
-0.2019010484,
-0.1808938235,
-0.1129140258,
-0.1156386808,
0.6896803975,
-0.5649000406,
-0.2569279671,
0.0357087478,
0.6306422353,
-0.0965538025,
0.008018353,
-0.7951357365,
-0.3712815642,
0.0007072063,
0.0755532086,
0.0006007283,
0.578437686,
-0.1008062065,
1.1526955366,
0.4422065318,
0.2536665797,
0.7997355461,
-0.357757479,
0.3976739049,
-0.8042757511,
-0.6637813449,
-0.4219239056,
0.358230263,
0.0767819583,
-0.5036341548,
1.2349178791,
0.001892647,
1.0169955492,
0.177383408,
1.1111218929,
-0.3027049005,
0.4024370611,
-0.0904690623,
0.2855193317,
-0.1822243929,
-0.0130151836,
-0.2288899869,
-0.5159163475,
0.0283081289,
0.0863805041,
-0.5327818394,
0.1316829622,
0.5814525485,
0.4248183072,
0.4458176494,
0.2139120847,
-0.2844952643,
-0.1403701007,
0.471306324,
0.2378918231,
0.9753718376,
-0.3765463531,
0.6023001671,
-0.4538205564,
-0.0725561827,
-0.4005104005,
-0.6846151352,
-0.7843052745,
-0.7714301944,
-0.4430458844,
-0.1454684883,
0.3738143146,
0.7867015004,
0.5201196074,
-0.7115055919,
-0.1844263971,
-0.5191323757,
0.2715995014,
-0.5491204262,
-0.2828918099,
0.3028612733,
-0.6039356589,
-0.7833386064,
0.3476050198,
0.1785408407,
0.114252001,
-0.7839411497,
0.0508036427,
-0.2183536738,
-0.0563137867,
0.3541350663,
0.6800507307,
-0.5968190432,
-0.1545228064,
0.1617536843,
-0.215503931,
-0.1192370802,
1.0855762959,
-0.8484060764,
0.7019549012,
0.2950119674,
0.8121187687,
0.1958788037,
-0.0123159634,
1.067548275,
-0.7496198416,
-0.3081138432,
0.5179629922,
-0.0795485675,
0.6656579971,
-0.5476711988,
0.3513174057,
0.22728239,
-0.5512546301,
-0.7465439439,
0.0502011441,
-0.3171364069,
-0.3414680958,
0.7212462425,
-0.1292358488,
-0.4360488057,
-0.2652030885,
-0.3515045047,
0.3017213643,
-0.4917561114,
1.30435431,
0.3442887068,
-0.2143195271,
-0.1598852277,
-0.3654994071,
1.118740201,
0.4734193385,
-0.8022190332,
-0.1586865038,
0.419721663,
0.0089466143,
0.5611960888,
0.4718725979,
0.1665174514,
0.4999209046,
0.1974499077,
0.167155534,
-0.0415619723,
-0.8560294509,
-0.1760308892,
0.0558559112,
0.1791262329,
-0.1897241026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04722v1
|
PoLLMgraph: Unraveling Hallucinations in Large Language Models via State Transition Dynamics
| 2024-04-06T20:02:20 | 2024-04-06T20:02:20 |
Derui Zhu, Dingfan Chen, Qing Li, Zongxiong Chen, Lei Ma, Jens Grossklags, Mario Fritz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.SE
|
Despite tremendous advancements in large language models (LLMs) over recent
years, a notably urgent challenge for their practical deployment is the
phenomenon of hallucination, where the model fabricates facts and produces
non-factual statements. In response, we propose PoLLMgraph, a Polygraph for
LLMs, as an effective model-based white-box detection and forecasting approach.
PoLLMgraph distinctly differs from the large body of existing research that
concentrates on addressing such challenges through black-box evaluations. In
particular, we demonstrate that hallucination can be effectively detected by
analyzing the LLM's internal state transition dynamics during generation via
tractable probabilistic models. Experimental results on various open-source
LLMs confirm the efficacy of PoLLMgraph, outperforming state-of-the-art methods
by a considerable margin, evidenced by over 20% improvement in AUC-ROC on
common benchmarking datasets like TruthfulQA. Our work paves a new way for
model-based white-box analysis of LLMs, motivating the research community to
further explore, understand, and refine the intricate dynamics of LLM
behaviors.
|
[
-0.3682884276,
-1.0492269993,
0.9460101724,
-0.0307336431,
-0.3775483668,
0.1398792118,
-0.1224593669,
-0.4658775926,
0.1731328666,
0.6680686474,
-0.6056671143,
-0.7464239001,
-0.6811448932,
-0.0257645436,
-0.8264320493,
0.7549943328,
0.0858029798,
-0.0863605216,
-0.2826243639,
0.5003551841,
-0.2536091208,
-0.5903762579,
-0.4111791551,
-0.6638118625,
0.0852591917,
-0.0093875704,
0.8689185977,
0.3255168796,
0.2041343749,
0.2599607408,
-0.2307546139,
0.347884059,
-0.6844202876,
0.3090595007,
0.1292567849,
-0.4563125074,
-0.2500497997,
-0.01078609,
0.4552773535,
0.6529515386,
-0.3950585127,
0.1781949252,
0.0945937857,
0.2594540417,
-0.4108709395,
0.5050261617,
-0.8306875825,
0.184347108,
-0.2769404352,
-0.206847176,
-0.8048772216,
-0.3902022541,
0.0078222696,
-0.3793769777,
0.1589201391,
0.1329955161,
0.6504721642,
0.1730753034,
-0.4573085606,
-0.0834961534,
-1.0435564518,
0.4491808712,
-0.7146672606,
0.6392686963,
0.2416878194,
0.2333807349,
-0.5966261029,
-0.808334887,
-0.658946991,
-0.5143995285,
0.1493770331,
0.0462638773,
-0.486309886,
-0.125046581,
0.1843139082,
0.2412632257,
-0.469489783,
0.0405192748,
-0.4381678402,
-0.5137925148,
0.4798204899,
0.3343347609,
0.4112161398,
-0.1679851413,
-0.0985931158,
0.0570366308,
-0.5647297502,
-0.308370769,
0.4324238002,
0.3988652825,
-0.1375313103,
0.5153515339,
-0.0062157037,
0.76452595,
-0.2397205979,
-0.1560360193,
0.1600943506,
0.1081473529,
0.1007729471,
0.232664749,
1.0029911995,
0.2608365119,
0.3587434888,
-0.4574935138,
-0.1431951821,
0.3641510606,
0.3215745389,
-0.9521223903,
-0.5696553588,
0.2847372293,
-0.4181706309,
-0.3399098217,
0.0740701109,
-0.969456017,
-0.8536512852,
-0.3399896026,
0.4035487473,
-0.4702163935,
-0.6134204865,
0.342852056,
0.020460546,
-0.0695946068,
0.2706925869,
-0.5834957361,
0.372915864,
0.9961172938,
1.152143836,
-0.4515573084,
-0.3134381473,
-0.3928445578,
-0.0168153215,
-0.6026952267,
0.8887081742,
-0.6141012311,
-0.4684319794,
0.1176703498,
-0.0491845533,
0.037633013,
-0.7613201141,
0.1165019646,
-0.374437958,
0.0439663678,
0.1055359617,
-0.4179154336,
-0.3284288943,
0.1800732464,
-0.6596500874,
1.1670155525,
-0.1835519224,
-0.6035304666,
0.1788545996,
-0.3157915175,
-0.2634705007,
0.0891327336,
-0.184818387,
-0.4741160274,
0.4600231647,
0.0314739831,
0.3782115579,
-0.2582825124,
0.4929187,
-0.5502020121,
-0.4644420147,
0.5040585995,
-0.4600377679,
0.8695607781,
0.1181229055,
-0.4047856033,
0.1965240985,
-0.8493336439,
-0.1785728484,
0.2403886169,
0.2518642843,
-0.0259998292,
0.3802940845,
-0.2101493627,
0.1204919592,
0.0463092327,
-0.4833907187,
0.1883121431,
-0.2615888715,
0.4240758717,
0.7712702751,
0.1955812722,
-0.1349053383,
-0.1863915771,
0.7634220123,
0.2021726668,
0.279173702,
0.113678515,
-0.7866370678,
-0.6959406734,
-0.1109541208,
-0.1021780968,
0.3653148115,
-0.6255561113,
0.2368599772,
-0.0825937688,
-0.5386613607,
-0.5962862968,
-0.2301297635,
-0.105376415,
0.3864557445,
0.2187025249,
-0.2777625918,
-0.3729252219,
-0.7131100297,
0.0571486466,
-0.5126430392,
0.2580981255,
-0.0791475251,
0.486286521,
-0.2703199685,
0.749625504,
-0.7762990594,
-0.0784987807,
-0.1318271011,
0.4050888419,
0.4299347401,
-0.0989024565,
0.1013032496,
-0.4849841595,
-0.0486488566,
-0.1098026484,
-0.5261803865,
-0.2770578265,
-0.0398055203,
-0.1374569088,
0.0517514013,
0.756596446,
-0.4643160105,
0.3264143467,
0.9020311236,
-0.4173403084,
1.0415655375,
-0.101026006,
-0.0408785269,
-0.8743102551,
-0.1255155802,
-0.0935302749,
-0.1946680546,
-0.7675675154,
-0.0583478995,
-0.2612200975,
-0.309768945,
-0.2765039802,
0.1562429368,
-0.4506242275,
-0.0329169035,
-0.4042533636,
0.1842697859,
-0.4013263881,
0.2500269115,
0.0706837848,
0.8159929514,
0.6701015234,
-0.4588004649,
0.3422540128,
0.2457121313,
-0.7487953901,
0.1406053752,
-0.2366022468,
0.3185889721,
-0.3549135923,
0.0907419771,
-1.0287438631,
0.170657143,
0.5659701228,
-0.3644468486,
-0.0544696711,
-0.2082582563,
-0.567740798,
-0.2208756208,
-0.1452622712,
0.2477139384,
0.5907171369,
-0.4766446352,
0.4466391802,
0.5887334347,
0.0550670102,
-0.0426266603,
-0.4029792249,
0.2743822932,
-0.0142174261,
-0.3280297816,
0.0607872456,
-0.0625179484,
-0.3260671794,
-0.0008775842,
-0.010588483,
0.0692555085,
0.0997554064,
0.490691781,
0.4276886582,
-0.1262446195,
-0.0550175831,
-0.373608321,
-0.1358706504,
0.4675309658,
-0.4129698277,
0.9715493321,
-0.0072952835,
-0.307961762,
-0.3340726197,
-0.1678976417,
0.7245782018,
-0.2911047935,
0.8420163989,
0.6147400737,
-0.4153622985,
-0.7913265228,
-0.2728775442,
-0.1805754304,
-0.4582544863,
0.3931101263,
-0.3269988894,
-0.7393928766,
0.5368592143,
-0.1900920719,
-0.288477689,
0.1865949184,
0.8569758534,
0.2575131059,
1.1999595165,
0.5955428481,
0.1009957343,
0.4636565745,
-0.236021176,
0.5282723308,
-0.6931790709,
-0.5300037265,
-0.3320805728,
0.0697362795,
-0.7279726863,
-0.5966080427,
0.6089517474,
-0.2638108134,
0.0255723838,
0.0653391853,
-0.7449874282,
0.1984016895,
0.2647719979,
0.1869395673,
0.4439361393,
0.0977808461,
-0.060250558,
-0.2005084157,
-0.4513355792,
-0.501596272,
1.0356053114,
0.1607493907,
0.9923344254,
-0.0216443073,
0.7397877574,
0.2983867824,
0.4346179962,
-0.9026370049,
0.9550691247,
-0.041136086,
-0.4651207328,
-0.3625485301,
-0.5532443523,
-1.0608272552,
0.658793509,
-0.3954569995,
-1.2470582724,
0.0317886434,
0.1582354754,
-0.0060651172,
0.540405035,
-0.4492837489,
0.9203472137,
-0.1502302736,
-0.1150549203,
-0.1516031921,
0.102183491,
0.6566466093,
-0.1295010746,
0.265527308,
-0.4349229932,
0.1145701557,
0.557854116,
-0.3503280282,
0.8636006117,
0.0204308871,
-0.4098277986,
0.3137971163,
0.5721404552,
0.6095903516,
-0.2915397286,
-0.0639958903,
0.3760259151,
0.1183516383,
0.1624296904,
-0.5568596721,
0.4810308218,
-0.5865592957,
-0.6988816261,
-0.5283176899,
-0.5230455995,
-0.3038390279,
0.0764764845,
0.2493537515,
0.5166808367,
-0.2505382001,
-0.1266333163,
0.3791470528,
-0.1010584161,
0.1030173823,
0.4339974523,
-0.8619837761,
-0.2499329299,
1.1874389648,
0.3138937652,
0.1002685204,
0.056916602,
0.3275503516,
-0.3556625545,
-0.924138844,
-0.1378210187,
0.5118809342,
-0.4802606404,
0.107545048,
-0.4730189145,
-0.3392201066,
-0.4325997531,
0.3584234416,
-0.2394121736,
-0.1279325187,
-0.2011084408,
-0.1084945127,
0.1549105346,
0.9135770798,
0.0909676552,
0.1545569599,
-0.2877824306,
0.5426249504,
0.2434043884,
0.4743861854,
0.2106242329,
-0.6029556394,
-0.030803442,
-0.1916662455,
-0.3469957113,
-1.3299481869,
0.3644115329,
-0.2303501368,
0.3764132857,
0.5334470272,
0.2913122177,
0.6419503689,
-0.6229797602,
0.7127863765,
0.1630229205,
-1.0726120472,
0.1925907284,
-0.1470389813,
0.2029035091,
0.1642366499,
0.1702862978,
-0.8683183193,
-1.0091465712,
-0.559309423,
-0.7489400506,
0.6782514453,
0.0199993104,
0.0601656698,
-0.0204364713,
0.0037160474,
0.2337707132,
0.3809073865,
-0.9159824252,
-0.1627138108,
-0.0903230682,
-0.1618282944,
-0.1002788693,
-0.2722463012,
-0.0938582867,
-0.2630253434,
0.7473945022,
-0.0642269179,
0.2973048687,
-0.0316816047,
-0.2735888958,
-0.2153467685,
0.0875621811,
0.3861495256,
1.0609200001,
-0.3002679944,
0.5791181922,
0.066640988,
-0.4249813557,
0.2232706994,
0.1197685078,
-0.6322367787,
0.2535347342,
0.426638633,
1.0314103365,
0.1152539179,
-0.6013255715,
0.5274375677,
0.2768492699,
-0.0865588114,
-0.4587863386,
0.0786977559,
0.0462707579,
0.2226949185,
0.1252993643,
-0.4549982846,
0.310562551,
-0.8754879832,
0.2120200694,
0.6255845428,
-0.5265817642,
-0.436207056,
0.9133338928,
-0.0057689343,
-0.540176034,
0.7107155323,
-0.306155175,
-0.6471766233,
0.450812459,
0.8664440513,
1.0682358742,
-0.1568591446,
0.8862668872,
0.1651934981,
0.6880024672,
-0.3060367107,
0.1760631502,
0.085418351,
-0.8568800092,
-0.4797272682,
-0.6088292599,
-0.5692162514,
0.5019717216,
-0.5758365393,
0.2579329014,
-0.3881894946,
-0.3128920794,
-0.0618155152,
-0.2800137103,
-0.2662741542,
0.0086561758,
0.6402451396,
0.6094270349,
-0.9576843977,
0.5367319584,
0.4489147663,
-0.0375660248,
-0.4529035389,
0.2742623687,
0.2159562558,
-0.9396191835,
0.1263339669,
0.3086191118,
-0.521022141,
0.0512207225,
-0.5772361159,
-0.5969728231,
0.7587206364,
0.7321592569,
-0.5351032615,
0.271499753,
0.2355700582,
0.6363958716,
-0.1394174695,
0.2024679333,
0.7168034911,
0.5543873906,
-0.06835109,
-0.5283413529,
0.3045919538,
0.0464311354,
-0.0557946116,
0.6364396214,
-0.6557974219,
0.6661585569,
-0.1774886847,
-0.632306695,
-0.2089562863,
0.6086428165,
0.2284679264,
0.3002982438,
0.7190254927,
0.4134026468,
0.877086997,
-0.1870790124,
0.7411258817,
-0.5237649083,
0.4333748519,
0.8157161474,
-0.2567997277,
0.8360157609,
0.3362587392,
-0.2856680751,
0.6950489283,
0.4256280661,
-0.3275960684,
0.1404366046,
0.4274709821,
-0.2369638234,
-0.6425853372,
-0.179225266,
-0.2763673663,
0.4393569827,
0.1183284372,
-0.010138941,
-0.1883536726,
-0.1778707653,
0.208974883,
-0.0410820059,
-0.0368546657,
0.6861488223,
0.1622731388,
-0.6895399094,
0.6479390264,
-0.2432280034,
0.3349317312,
-0.6491928101,
-0.1722484082,
-0.0902051702,
-0.0391452983,
-0.0607248768,
-0.740434587,
-0.0335078947,
-0.113395907,
0.1063160077,
-0.2429522723,
0.4286854267,
-0.618873477,
-0.6915070415,
0.6188479662,
0.4944724441,
0.4248797297,
-0.1793955863,
-0.5417279601,
0.4626524448,
-0.0440011658,
-0.0940805823,
0.0174238347,
0.4064729214,
-0.0655894205,
0.8116785288,
0.6669744253,
0.6012245417,
0.0512123331,
0.2348827422,
0.5496324897,
-0.6502834558,
-0.6078199744,
-1.0246798992,
0.2946456373,
-0.1050456166,
-0.2241316885,
0.6105847955,
0.708527565,
0.7998069525,
0.083544299,
0.6867184639,
0.2453672141,
0.1383441836,
-0.7206302881,
0.7778123021,
-0.4573974013,
0.124090299,
-0.1800459027,
-1.0121273994,
-0.1284066588,
0.3790555,
-0.386741519,
-0.2500086427,
0.8291230798,
1.0920921564,
-0.0752710924,
-0.0449475683,
0.5199910402,
0.7181466222,
0.286958456,
0.3354845345,
1.1941748857,
0.0303102657,
0.8711038828,
-0.2560472786,
-0.2155985087,
-0.2601005137,
-0.7091094255,
-0.9179980755,
-0.9304743409,
-0.4857161045,
-0.6664076447,
0.0540083013,
0.6344408989,
0.6648388505,
-0.8244407773,
-0.6536394358,
0.1074840799,
0.2982290685,
-0.2557974458,
-0.2379255891,
0.3259012401,
-0.2032162249,
-0.6812618971,
0.3673600852,
0.4223798513,
0.1004268229,
-0.5998347402,
0.108344838,
0.2085279524,
0.2497039884,
0.5876463652,
0.0629332736,
-0.7938270569,
-0.2548857033,
-0.4132407308,
0.0941756666,
0.0277713314,
1.0731304884,
-0.5575928688,
0.8186649084,
0.3073354363,
0.2341871411,
0.8238652945,
-0.0238802303,
0.5264722109,
-0.1738663018,
0.268409133,
0.0907135308,
0.2113465667,
0.2719322145,
-0.1305729002,
0.4096375108,
0.4136405885,
-0.3398876786,
-1.2919492722,
0.3841496408,
-0.727958262,
-0.494183749,
1.1106721163,
0.5264917612,
-0.3939579129,
-0.1133612916,
-0.2554353774,
0.2366051674,
-0.2155184746,
1.3164317608,
0.9239369631,
-0.2560427785,
-0.2725374103,
-0.7170034051,
0.5339445472,
0.1571592838,
-0.9743391275,
0.2887252867,
0.6109508276,
0.0732694194,
0.1023403406,
0.6293914914,
0.0295095742,
-0.0674396977,
0.116602771,
0.0413095243,
-0.3459764123,
-0.4456013739,
-0.229989633,
0.3275937736,
0.1511381716,
-0.2111492604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04689v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04689v1
|
Multicalibration for Confidence Scoring in LLMs
| 2024-04-06T17:33:37 | 2024-04-06T17:33:37 |
Gianluca Detommaso, Martin Bertran, Riccardo Fogliato, Aaron Roth
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper proposes the use of "multicalibration" to yield interpretable and
reliable confidence scores for outputs generated by large language models
(LLMs). Multicalibration asks for calibration not just marginally, but
simultaneously across various intersecting groupings of the data. We show how
to form groupings for prompt/completion pairs that are correlated with the
probability of correctness via two techniques: clustering within an embedding
space, and "self-annotation" - querying the LLM by asking it various yes-or-no
questions about the prompt. We also develop novel variants of multicalibration
algorithms that offer performance improvements by reducing their tendency to
overfit. Through systematic benchmarking across various question answering
datasets and LLMs, we show how our techniques can yield confidence scores that
provide substantial improvements in fine-grained measures of both calibration
and accuracy compared to existing methods.
|
[
-0.321737349,
-0.62566185,
0.8646185994,
0.3931012154,
0.0317302234,
0.0776781887,
-0.411993593,
-0.3322111368,
0.2701511979,
0.1882882267,
-0.4012531638,
-0.6646746397,
-0.4423719049,
0.0745896548,
-0.0593663305,
0.636244297,
-0.0623471476,
0.4023447335,
-0.5449802876,
-0.2796672881,
-0.4413658977,
-0.74973768,
-0.5049738884,
-0.4112173021,
0.8282023668,
0.5890433788,
0.584361136,
0.51104182,
0.4003088474,
0.2268597484,
0.3214037716,
0.4380303621,
-0.4217710495,
0.2661259174,
0.20142667,
-0.7246231437,
-0.3787045181,
0.2283154577,
0.9392576814,
0.8016337752,
-0.1477173269,
0.2430469394,
0.2412506938,
0.4522313476,
-0.6528859138,
0.2221154422,
-0.512491107,
-0.0655636787,
-0.0240465682,
-0.5957064033,
-0.5776137114,
-0.7323793173,
-0.1850991845,
-0.3788350821,
0.0155108105,
0.0529668778,
0.134689182,
0.3958184421,
-0.5508670807,
-0.4461641312,
-0.5153704882,
1.2529370785,
-0.5238907337,
0.1166540906,
0.6943805814,
0.3952213526,
0.0299676657,
-0.3439618647,
-0.2443664968,
-0.1643079221,
-0.1032674462,
0.1894767433,
0.4099043012,
-0.004897079,
0.1785338968,
0.4390307665,
-0.5316554308,
0.0105504757,
-0.1493795067,
-0.5185702443,
0.6455290318,
0.0878961533,
-0.2631855905,
0.0415653363,
-0.2558351457,
-0.2223978341,
-0.774695158,
0.1478017569,
0.42799142,
0.6118756533,
0.1625983268,
0.720749259,
-0.0402278341,
0.6680884957,
-0.0574591868,
-0.4015065432,
0.2787134945,
-0.5646417737,
0.1806663573,
-0.010557903,
0.6128991842,
0.7058585286,
0.5080200434,
-0.0777171925,
-0.0048651919,
0.0034818074,
0.0271285903,
-0.5951381326,
0.0424787588,
0.4681877792,
-0.1725709587,
-0.0493220426,
0.1634337902,
-0.794704318,
-0.2283792049,
-0.4359259307,
0.3543139696,
-0.0899665654,
0.0194152053,
0.0350909755,
0.0541176721,
0.4394440353,
0.4450883269,
-0.583992064,
0.2268062979,
0.3872116208,
0.691722095,
-0.1020837799,
-0.5173751116,
-0.87214607,
0.0399801806,
-0.5324211121,
0.828099668,
-0.5117025971,
-0.3718552589,
0.1741475016,
-0.1930905581,
-0.2365768254,
-0.3773182333,
0.3173374832,
-0.5650518537,
0.1206233427,
-0.4540364742,
-0.675993979,
-0.1886126846,
0.5843595266,
-0.5735744834,
1.3219183683,
-0.1432026923,
-0.3770676553,
0.1751775146,
-0.194222793,
-0.2471970469,
-0.1004350036,
-0.2396900505,
0.0183607899,
0.0424307361,
0.2600373328,
0.4931485355,
-0.3578934669,
0.2231830209,
-0.5175881386,
-0.2669575214,
0.502089262,
-0.585931778,
0.1714530289,
0.0728244111,
0.0856525376,
-0.0456063561,
-0.8009418249,
0.7832762003,
-0.4561347365,
-0.4034686983,
-0.2831736505,
-0.0548436083,
-0.0809103549,
0.1652907878,
0.5948803425,
-0.563588202,
-0.0029368554,
-0.052682925,
0.2407652438,
0.5001358986,
0.0552316941,
0.3130719662,
-0.6424471736,
0.4000073373,
-0.1069797799,
0.0484989323,
-0.4742264152,
-0.6670420766,
-0.6476851106,
-0.015882615,
0.4148419499,
0.6979843378,
-0.6002706289,
0.4144421518,
-0.0539674573,
-0.7581683993,
-0.6441459656,
0.2574338913,
0.5212850571,
0.2801874876,
0.5894518495,
-0.3169018328,
-0.2943606079,
-0.632596612,
-0.0953997374,
-0.1849401891,
0.1206402257,
0.3285084367,
0.2354047596,
0.1207801774,
1.0209383965,
-0.6489503384,
-0.2095917165,
0.2240664065,
0.3771117926,
0.0720195547,
0.5535515547,
0.3696026802,
-0.6074303985,
-0.4788948298,
-0.2886064351,
-0.6591823697,
-0.0305957943,
0.1352528185,
0.2125958651,
-0.1334223747,
0.7439988852,
-0.3130252957,
0.2518831491,
0.7542526126,
0.2337488681,
0.6343533993,
-0.4263246655,
0.6743808985,
-1.2431150675,
-0.1946795285,
0.2052396536,
-0.4636727273,
-0.5840704441,
0.0549541824,
0.0938702449,
0.4634889364,
-0.3133943975,
0.5223516226,
-0.3992677033,
-0.0006893157,
-0.0992934331,
0.3753849268,
0.244587332,
0.1583566219,
-0.166755259,
0.9889079928,
0.5120973587,
-0.5216170549,
0.5511263609,
0.0262196288,
-0.2942394614,
0.6960613132,
-0.705711484,
0.2906623483,
-0.1917072982,
0.191566959,
-1.7184541225,
-0.2347530276,
-0.1905533522,
-0.508898437,
0.1653014123,
-0.1322674453,
-0.6419492364,
-0.2284373343,
-0.5950297713,
0.8253164291,
0.0478047729,
-0.3373433352,
0.4447717667,
0.4686748981,
-0.2157238871,
-0.5996628404,
-1.0674858093,
-0.18065238,
-0.2145890892,
-0.5255977511,
0.2657124698,
-0.3932771683,
-0.1634061337,
-0.3421903849,
0.1864438802,
-0.1970951855,
-0.1746919304,
0.2474891841,
0.1194939464,
-0.3205963373,
0.4385112822,
-0.0363228433,
-0.2270868272,
-0.1101600453,
0.071798332,
0.6319004297,
-0.1633064896,
-0.7756457925,
-0.1921077818,
0.6606484652,
0.5631477237,
-0.1123178154,
0.6743419766,
0.5588601232,
-0.4929634333,
0.1450356096,
-1.0751882792,
-0.4377253056,
-0.4153740704,
0.1032480896,
-0.5234165192,
-1.1381218433,
0.7680119872,
-0.0945646167,
0.0998417214,
0.4118153155,
0.6128000617,
-0.0472469442,
1.1472158432,
0.5376396179,
-0.0438053794,
0.0669655204,
0.2106740028,
0.0595439486,
-0.770702064,
-0.1090068147,
-0.7829042673,
-0.143724665,
-0.6415111423,
-0.7810915709,
0.4433998764,
0.1079295054,
0.0723004341,
0.2310717404,
-0.2129707783,
0.5936754346,
0.7362797856,
-0.0146747008,
0.3709232807,
-0.0953840837,
-0.3306842744,
-0.2760512531,
-0.5165330172,
-0.6978959441,
1.1923110485,
0.3048232198,
1.0125716925,
0.0644308478,
0.7589713931,
0.0874763578,
0.3862077296,
-0.806114018,
0.2645302713,
0.0055543822,
-0.6063404679,
-0.4489745796,
-0.6089259386,
-0.6712909341,
0.2120017111,
-0.1172035635,
-0.9116255045,
0.0817763433,
0.1152632385,
-0.8355483413,
-0.1664062887,
-0.9800184965,
0.6907172203,
-0.062925078,
-0.1762327552,
-0.1945916116,
-0.6279180646,
0.2296939492,
-0.2617281079,
0.3457617164,
-0.3377332389,
-0.0312156826,
0.462839365,
-0.0136691835,
1.0728437901,
0.0602986738,
-0.1162636653,
0.4467248321,
-0.1627684385,
0.1795621365,
0.277710259,
-0.5654759407,
0.0779283494,
0.6077681184,
-0.1726737916,
-0.5954780579,
0.9053960443,
-0.6872808933,
-0.4059961736,
-0.4148847461,
-0.8576548696,
-0.4947986305,
-0.03108407,
0.0208247826,
0.5939112902,
-0.1155664772,
0.2146096975,
0.3883084953,
-0.0487236641,
0.4114388227,
0.2835233212,
-0.1747657657,
-0.7167579532,
0.7462697625,
0.2992018759,
0.5061398149,
0.4332814217,
0.0930344313,
-0.787078917,
-0.0961565822,
-0.3323584795,
0.4832051098,
-0.9981272817,
-0.379408747,
-0.152139917,
-0.3686300218,
-0.6217147112,
0.1078581139,
-0.3096624017,
-0.4651629925,
-0.2699696124,
0.0217887852,
0.2885735035,
0.785942018,
-0.0769591704,
0.4467312992,
-0.9959328771,
-0.0996770039,
0.4604825079,
0.239493832,
-0.2299718112,
-0.503783524,
-0.1398767084,
0.1719184816,
-0.213905111,
-0.814291656,
-0.0084958989,
0.3284148276,
0.6347937584,
0.1465122551,
0.092766948,
1.0027335882,
-0.5519371033,
0.6585624814,
0.1528616697,
-0.8053500652,
0.3936322927,
0.1047787145,
0.4193467498,
0.9060300589,
0.4443021417,
-0.6692795157,
-0.3630497456,
-0.0824813172,
-0.5465466976,
0.3538063765,
-0.157611534,
0.2322675139,
-0.1008334607,
0.514631331,
-0.0770331249,
0.3694125116,
-0.5851314068,
-0.3739560544,
0.1954786628,
-0.5621116757,
-0.6018224359,
-0.5500937104,
-0.4280769825,
-0.0369216949,
0.4780151546,
-0.6787258387,
0.0537987873,
0.2593517303,
-0.059665896,
-0.2150269896,
0.3131689429,
0.5915871859,
0.7706142664,
-0.0986748934,
0.3156500757,
0.2159910947,
-0.269818902,
0.1766332686,
0.1122688726,
0.1240362972,
-0.1344934851,
0.2895776033,
0.2194860727,
0.125351876,
-0.3877646923,
0.6616571546,
-0.2200297117,
-0.1416756511,
-0.2886357307,
-0.1269762516,
0.0658051595,
0.195607692,
0.3685500324,
-0.0367486365,
0.0109059028,
-0.4002723992,
0.3463807404,
0.5344498158,
-0.6151984334,
-0.0672320202,
0.2505834699,
-0.1608943045,
-0.0209849477,
0.2459962219,
-0.1578432918,
-0.2774057686,
0.4855359793,
0.4898217022,
0.4121506512,
-0.6229710579,
0.2870618999,
0.6002445817,
0.4835483432,
-0.3272717893,
0.4759654403,
0.0313189514,
-0.9825046062,
-0.8442428112,
-0.6350981593,
-0.749456048,
-0.1845212281,
-0.7540711761,
0.1426581442,
-0.211980328,
-0.4834209085,
-0.0995613635,
-0.0007407483,
-0.4358509481,
0.264293462,
0.1699269861,
0.8147438765,
-0.9112407565,
0.709436357,
0.6730348468,
-0.2727997899,
-0.9826714396,
-0.0776449665,
0.0007370082,
-0.9208982587,
0.1172512695,
0.5814561844,
-0.3720557392,
0.1467128694,
-0.334615767,
-1.1608272791,
1.094022274,
0.291551888,
-0.3668939471,
-0.0385095105,
0.3971142471,
0.4105132222,
-0.5623884797,
0.7138318419,
0.6486551762,
0.5674951673,
0.4545992017,
-1.0383355618,
-0.1262561977,
0.0063200798,
-0.0285388771,
0.011148775,
-0.5787016749,
0.777877152,
-0.1643234044,
0.0508929566,
0.2942124903,
0.4480179548,
0.4568416774,
0.3139635026,
0.5148875117,
0.4731827676,
0.9810376763,
-0.4550803006,
0.7923983932,
-0.5639878511,
0.482851088,
1.2228153944,
-0.3439895809,
1.0134502649,
0.734052062,
-0.2581450641,
0.2274357975,
0.7492905855,
0.2687919736,
0.2911544442,
0.1777637899,
-0.3319080472,
-0.5593183041,
-0.1948767453,
-0.3112523258,
0.3533354104,
0.5513371825,
-0.0405394845,
-0.3763944805,
-0.0579792969,
-0.1991205066,
0.1857685745,
-0.2893597782,
0.5886673331,
0.3408138454,
-1.0437732935,
0.3108139038,
0.0280875638,
0.5045754313,
-0.5398982167,
-0.0036021071,
-0.0822964758,
0.3148229122,
-0.2525984347,
-1.0233317614,
0.2233810425,
-0.3650964499,
-0.2371831089,
-0.1357555091,
0.3527721167,
-0.9109569192,
-0.6053289771,
0.3614875078,
0.9051528573,
0.3022081852,
-0.2072786242,
-0.5945988894,
-0.0823452324,
-0.1567330062,
-0.0531396754,
0.0777357966,
0.3870017231,
0.1466914713,
0.5557745695,
0.6070082188,
0.0147547824,
0.3427838087,
0.4660169184,
0.650755465,
-0.3611876369,
-0.1065871716,
-0.8348129988,
0.393427968,
0.0037139531,
-0.3998135626,
0.8265996575,
0.54911834,
0.6150999665,
0.2455631196,
0.4642552733,
0.2312962562,
0.7418527007,
-0.6440656781,
0.28323102,
-0.6164118648,
0.0447618775,
-0.2756320238,
-1.015421629,
-0.716778934,
0.7604442835,
-0.4475568533,
0.2865669429,
0.9163563251,
1.1855427027,
0.2474005222,
-0.0843750834,
0.5624475479,
-0.137763992,
0.2039745301,
0.5270827413,
0.9623263478,
-0.6089633703,
0.5021642447,
-0.2218269706,
-0.5310106874,
-0.0699265823,
-0.9665403962,
-0.7706817389,
-0.6691280603,
-0.306219399,
-0.2607485652,
-0.3436896503,
0.8830869794,
0.8679432869,
-0.9924242496,
-0.4897250235,
0.4612007439,
0.088015683,
-0.1229885891,
-0.1874331087,
0.0868507326,
-0.7862894535,
-0.7255593538,
0.3521874249,
0.3149572015,
0.0590935126,
-0.511975646,
0.0390897095,
-0.2996244431,
0.1393926889,
0.5227655768,
0.0301633254,
-0.6918853521,
-0.4589633942,
0.1705562025,
-0.4063351154,
0.2636526227,
0.6008836627,
-0.37767905,
0.4348351955,
0.249428615,
0.6408555508,
0.3882369697,
0.3093959391,
0.4882372022,
-1.1023480892,
-0.0624824725,
0.1207007393,
0.4324435592,
0.5715264678,
-0.1939592957,
0.3489534855,
-0.0892390609,
-0.8771255612,
-0.552996099,
0.2773431242,
-0.8253850341,
0.2129273862,
1.2227038145,
-0.3046299219,
-0.1243916005,
-0.1152613238,
-0.1832669079,
0.0410154276,
-0.2679630816,
0.550747633,
1.2384556532,
0.0142287202,
-0.1272734553,
-0.5195449591,
0.2683551013,
0.4905381501,
-0.8333919644,
0.0356121324,
0.6085923314,
0.2097328007,
0.7171481848,
0.7126422524,
-0.2048973888,
0.2888812423,
-0.2206806093,
0.0143310931,
0.5269302726,
-0.5038540363,
-0.3060231209,
0.4071659744,
0.4191605151,
-0.1958737373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04676v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04676v1
|
Order-Based Pre-training Strategies for Procedural Text Understanding
| 2024-04-06T16:39:07 | 2024-04-06T16:39:07 |
Abhilash Nandy, Yash Kulkarni, Pawan Goyal, Niloy Ganguly
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we propose sequence-based pretraining methods to enhance
procedural understanding in natural language processing. Procedural text,
containing sequential instructions to accomplish a task, is difficult to
understand due to the changing attributes of entities in the context. We focus
on recipes, which are commonly represented as ordered instructions, and use
this order as a supervision signal. Our work is one of the first to compare
several 'order as-supervision' transformer pre-training methods, including
Permutation Classification, Embedding Regression, and Skip-Clip, and shows that
these methods give improved results compared to the baselines and SoTA LLMs on
two downstream Entity-Tracking datasets: NPN-Cooking dataset in recipe domain
and ProPara dataset in open domain. Our proposed methods address the
non-trivial Entity Tracking Task that requires prediction of entity states
across procedure steps, which requires understanding the order of steps. These
methods show an improvement over the best baseline by 1.6% and 7-9% on
NPN-Cooking and ProPara Datasets respectively across metrics.
|
[
-0.1327605247,
-0.8217115998,
0.5777763128,
0.4504010677,
-0.3801687658,
0.0310042016,
-0.1654393971,
-0.1669928133,
0.3430191576,
0.9430558085,
-0.8687366247,
-0.6249005795,
-0.6923411489,
0.4459442794,
-0.3852466345,
0.8814153671,
-0.1811501682,
0.4274732172,
0.0635974258,
0.3103676438,
-0.3679669499,
-0.5438657999,
-0.6949494481,
-0.1767977327,
0.4270878732,
0.3176648617,
0.4872377515,
0.9667314887,
0.5407907367,
0.4504009187,
0.0715076923,
0.2538388073,
-0.4272893667,
0.282887429,
-0.112817131,
-0.5592778325,
-0.3637828231,
0.0261909589,
0.1552898139,
0.6828688383,
-0.2855387926,
0.0800445452,
-0.0987047479,
0.4240493178,
-0.628857553,
0.5032156706,
-0.4432531595,
0.1624958515,
-0.321205616,
-0.571502924,
-0.6611122489,
-0.4327555895,
0.3875159323,
-0.9925086498,
0.3229746819,
0.0768027231,
0.816839993,
0.3514574468,
-0.2961602211,
-0.637891531,
-0.6650976539,
0.5934162736,
-0.5683692694,
0.3126222789,
0.5274971724,
0.2065746039,
-0.333039254,
-1.167775631,
-0.5728161335,
0.1316034496,
-0.1029529199,
0.2813464403,
0.4399858117,
0.1284216493,
0.2753392458,
0.4929108322,
-0.5639071465,
0.274127394,
-0.0417579263,
-0.0675114393,
0.3525829315,
0.1493017524,
0.3493293524,
-0.0566710122,
-0.2692127228,
-0.4903289378,
-0.5403221846,
-0.0403912812,
0.2159585655,
0.3679915667,
0.1527080834,
0.3884189725,
-0.1919933856,
0.7041701674,
0.3266137838,
-0.0930654928,
0.4286220074,
-0.5227731466,
-0.5405545235,
0.3306682408,
0.8708637357,
0.0423901565,
0.3813869953,
-0.0060767862,
-0.1233943626,
-0.0272268131,
0.5698289275,
-0.9691306353,
-0.2377285808,
-0.2376749963,
-0.2066875249,
-0.1485732645,
0.2317548245,
-0.58928895,
-0.2021424472,
-0.5523054004,
0.0540305898,
-0.491060853,
0.0164079629,
0.1334120184,
0.2026623935,
0.3711775541,
0.4253168106,
-1.266045332,
0.5647314787,
0.8461833596,
0.7698044777,
-0.0595830679,
-0.1722880304,
-0.7109356523,
0.0693159774,
-0.3460693657,
0.9403963089,
-0.5998775959,
-0.4346192181,
0.073144719,
0.1724546701,
-0.2992858291,
-0.4498228133,
0.6544676423,
-0.5932417512,
0.3734975755,
-0.1917086095,
-0.5350757837,
-0.2664560676,
-0.068207562,
-0.5188055634,
0.828168273,
-0.04723382,
-0.5597838163,
0.470128566,
-0.4147266746,
-0.8207164407,
-0.0030548961,
-0.2779287696,
-0.2933468819,
0.0388194546,
0.4462161064,
0.493516475,
-0.0820311308,
0.2276910543,
0.1921099871,
-0.2965913713,
-0.1393023282,
-0.2787591517,
0.5030894279,
0.153636381,
-0.2924635708,
0.406376332,
-0.6624329686,
0.0769809932,
0.1196725518,
-0.148080945,
-0.3126434386,
-0.0426520221,
-0.0766624808,
0.1162839085,
-0.1389795244,
-0.0641886666,
0.2003888935,
-0.7843725085,
0.3929462433,
0.7476933599,
0.2427534312,
0.8101970553,
0.0023041733,
0.6250257492,
0.1266276985,
0.1109612882,
-0.6685974598,
-0.4313809574,
-0.6587397456,
-0.0683931857,
0.3245900571,
0.9144672751,
-1.092585206,
0.5364368558,
-0.3280619979,
-0.3135533035,
-0.3311722577,
-0.1490620226,
0.7649989724,
0.735271275,
0.7021092772,
-0.6951122284,
-0.6527281404,
-0.3592647612,
-0.4301854372,
0.0406105444,
-0.2007210553,
-0.0530620627,
0.2862537801,
-0.0968526751,
0.5988592505,
-0.7885919213,
-0.1775367707,
-0.190768674,
0.5872485638,
0.3966991007,
0.4651821852,
0.1336204261,
-0.9259532094,
-0.6878020167,
-0.0747872218,
-0.6680136919,
0.0439258739,
-0.2217620909,
-0.1727807075,
0.1760012209,
0.5862736106,
-0.653619647,
0.6913384199,
0.030029336,
-0.1071255878,
0.4121694863,
-0.2328357548,
0.310084492,
-0.9854456782,
-0.6468385458,
0.1604023427,
-0.151692003,
-1.1046509743,
-0.2798774242,
0.0318448097,
0.2615780532,
-0.5350593925,
0.2370013148,
-0.6329712272,
0.0864251927,
-0.0058800699,
-0.3451520503,
-0.049584467,
0.643573761,
0.6263059974,
0.7882758975,
0.4412784278,
-0.689552784,
-0.0214978736,
0.4982664585,
-0.5936187506,
0.2743063569,
-0.3983752429,
0.3894264102,
-0.0927186906,
0.2745891511,
-0.7676333189,
0.0217093322,
0.5972201228,
-0.3689831197,
0.6647803783,
-0.3052394688,
-0.4515542388,
-0.1810440123,
-0.0531571172,
0.0365586989,
0.3506406546,
-0.2153597921,
0.6776493788,
0.0251083523,
-0.2369576693,
-0.6076464057,
-0.5441149473,
-0.1496951282,
-0.1653356552,
-0.2715020776,
0.6600157022,
0.0219515897,
-0.0452409424,
-0.3744739592,
-0.5476917624,
-0.46881935,
-0.0930808038,
0.3093982637,
0.1110121906,
-0.4292541742,
-0.2937631309,
0.0931964889,
-0.3209308386,
0.2480158359,
-0.5830076933,
0.5585993528,
0.2077468187,
0.0248626843,
-0.5852011442,
-0.0698122978,
0.0791615173,
-0.2708482146,
0.8764341474,
0.3403231204,
-0.2156339586,
-0.0738135278,
-0.3494552672,
-0.2414184362,
-0.5451241136,
0.1046391204,
-0.4541451037,
-0.450453192,
0.2112639993,
-0.1147371605,
0.153187111,
0.1261196434,
0.406268537,
-0.3685126305,
0.5516861677,
0.4238908291,
0.1110909134,
0.8446553946,
-0.2450378537,
0.2147212178,
-0.387024492,
-0.126287207,
-0.4988989234,
0.1348847449,
-0.5724369287,
-0.5385069251,
-0.0152538968,
0.0440331511,
-0.291095525,
0.6365295649,
-0.4218809009,
0.5326576829,
0.4834948778,
0.1989414692,
0.3470707834,
0.1894951314,
-0.0876766816,
-0.0411794111,
-0.4547865987,
-0.5678850412,
0.8841424584,
0.0410547256,
0.7076312304,
-0.4021548927,
0.9117327929,
0.0418216288,
0.2595261037,
-0.8077257872,
0.4525069594,
-0.151667282,
-0.0276622195,
-0.7050799131,
-0.4520747662,
-1.0174403191,
0.2291022092,
-0.0852409601,
-0.3749403954,
-0.0251923818,
0.1196546778,
-0.33529526,
-0.0963535979,
-1.0358636379,
0.8625354767,
-0.3058323562,
-0.1413549632,
0.231098935,
-0.9039773941,
-0.0265504718,
0.1347295791,
0.2045168281,
0.3041059375,
0.2291117311,
0.6577246189,
-0.8899389505,
0.6050078273,
-0.2730830908,
-0.0257365797,
0.3360466063,
0.0011201774,
0.5112560987,
0.0464740843,
0.0543566495,
0.0361767709,
-0.1758498996,
-0.170451358,
-0.9243787527,
0.2157951295,
-0.5540626645,
-0.6973512769,
-0.5589104295,
-0.1198187172,
-0.0560404882,
0.4708466828,
0.5991976261,
0.4957241416,
0.0368177295,
-0.2280509919,
0.9608901143,
-0.0565870702,
0.4771913588,
0.4606484473,
0.0287156291,
-0.2412809283,
0.7612709999,
0.3180240691,
0.0909635201,
0.9312708378,
0.0226205941,
-0.2403391451,
-0.8263520598,
-0.3952041566,
-0.0401743539,
-0.6121439934,
-0.201590538,
-0.7639390826,
-0.1913552731,
-0.5279335976,
-0.1386499405,
-0.338206321,
-0.1041406915,
-0.5570477247,
-0.1797133386,
0.2615312338,
0.7082613707,
0.6964496374,
0.6550646424,
-0.613117516,
0.5592824817,
0.0123038907,
0.292363286,
-0.0896763951,
-0.5369156599,
-0.0557319522,
0.0075187129,
-0.2432500869,
-1.0031058788,
0.6630914211,
0.0611598641,
0.3002749681,
0.4228630364,
-0.0675701126,
0.9696282148,
-0.9048159122,
0.4541859627,
0.1729764193,
-0.9234892726,
0.7748736143,
-0.2271507829,
0.3340548277,
0.6932677627,
0.6535522938,
-0.2631484866,
-0.1971624941,
-0.4386440814,
-0.9374591112,
0.9439140558,
0.4348889887,
-0.0396355726,
-0.0894775093,
0.4760887325,
0.2433744073,
0.2865716815,
-0.4249937236,
-0.43079108,
-0.5305161476,
-0.3454488218,
-0.1468799561,
0.0012892357,
0.3973558247,
-0.2772220969,
0.5942586064,
-0.1066747084,
0.1497710049,
0.1867992133,
-0.4905612171,
0.1411874443,
0.1591505706,
0.5559995174,
0.8940432668,
-0.0970925763,
-0.0948489457,
0.1537025571,
-0.9639453888,
0.1026008204,
0.0035365794,
-0.0586085171,
-0.0491150692,
0.5834597945,
0.8044175506,
0.3903663158,
-0.2365470231,
0.3986236155,
-0.3556225896,
-0.0529288836,
-0.3744584322,
0.0886750966,
-0.0359687731,
-0.0731067732,
0.1328674555,
0.0022483813,
0.2811970413,
-0.5599610209,
0.1825804114,
-0.1660034657,
-0.3733647168,
-0.4775547385,
0.1612376571,
-0.0846311674,
-0.6094895601,
0.9607884288,
-0.1845350564,
-0.2856248915,
0.6677476764,
0.644485414,
0.7429599166,
-0.5374558568,
0.3141882718,
0.1489361227,
0.1175285503,
-0.4859571457,
0.4239113927,
-0.1527918279,
-0.7187021971,
-0.6436838508,
-0.6183331609,
-0.4177643061,
-0.0417439304,
-0.8638907075,
0.4075838625,
-0.5860198736,
0.0370218195,
0.1889560521,
-0.2553473413,
-0.8026456833,
0.2837536931,
-0.111114569,
0.7992877364,
-0.5652704239,
0.9046716094,
0.7588880658,
-0.525695622,
-0.7770072818,
0.2126578838,
0.0107099228,
-0.6751309037,
0.684705615,
0.4297127128,
-0.1183274463,
0.1316607445,
-0.3652067482,
-0.7105757594,
0.9067254663,
0.1604345143,
-0.5654913783,
-0.4026754498,
0.0698472187,
0.6696808338,
-0.4207617342,
0.643933475,
0.6145148277,
0.3264072537,
0.400402993,
-0.739657402,
-0.1040619314,
-0.0862231031,
0.126585111,
0.3862301409,
-0.1136789769,
0.4492392242,
0.0935104489,
-0.392087549,
-0.0414482057,
0.9054291844,
-0.1465784609,
0.3781825304,
0.553938508,
0.4835234582,
0.6614255905,
-0.1517782062,
0.9077711701,
0.1342574805,
-0.0244227313,
1.6384415627,
-0.3700781167,
0.5701332092,
0.4104859829,
-0.1829307526,
0.782825768,
0.9002460241,
0.1918029189,
0.7570040822,
0.3819159567,
0.1906456947,
0.0504561327,
-0.0438915789,
-0.1859825402,
0.3007600307,
0.4562312663,
-0.4233208001,
0.0365868434,
-0.0585541874,
0.107972011,
0.2293147743,
-0.2967028916,
1.1777175665,
0.1305977106,
-0.8009780049,
0.5224862695,
-0.2277312577,
0.4588847458,
-0.6449311972,
-0.226984933,
-0.2253018618,
-0.0815221891,
-0.1930184811,
-0.7116200328,
0.2523705363,
-0.0215683542,
-0.3160383105,
-0.9029639959,
0.4033534229,
-0.2219745517,
-0.3816899061,
0.1486187428,
0.3091744781,
0.0380672291,
-0.1374525577,
-0.5287865996,
-0.2273792773,
-0.2491125315,
-0.4981524348,
0.176711902,
0.5963962674,
-0.2595333457,
0.2924522161,
0.6367661357,
-0.1157975644,
0.2219634205,
0.2924127877,
0.7821234465,
-0.6418743134,
-0.7792490721,
-0.9316056371,
0.2661411762,
0.0187078416,
-0.1225307211,
0.6528385878,
0.3832914233,
1.2494233847,
-0.3321371973,
0.28052634,
0.1238447428,
0.3041805029,
-0.9096190929,
0.2408707887,
0.2084338069,
0.2650623024,
-0.3164019883,
-1.0141787529,
-0.3006731868,
0.6744065285,
-0.639395535,
-0.0598927736,
0.9319138527,
0.7322009206,
-0.0156387854,
0.4199368656,
-0.1298751235,
0.2356275022,
0.0782794654,
0.2041829526,
0.9598330855,
-0.287038058,
0.2181122303,
-0.2879613042,
-0.1252816617,
0.1763768047,
-0.8347865939,
-1.0054092407,
-0.5204008818,
-0.1750538647,
-0.1432980895,
0.1745712012,
1.0449746847,
0.8113232851,
-1.0072094202,
-0.2676208019,
-0.5182350874,
0.2285008281,
-0.4931198657,
-0.1958108395,
0.2751631737,
-0.6501316428,
-0.6516484022,
0.5389481783,
0.4061807096,
-0.0130119361,
0.272222966,
0.0261769798,
-0.4765937328,
-0.0640786663,
0.5876290798,
0.1813338548,
-0.7360799313,
0.1582727283,
0.1978671849,
0.0692750961,
0.4584480822,
1.1935213804,
-0.7242193222,
0.4310206473,
0.5422990322,
0.600433588,
0.7773987651,
0.163452372,
0.656619966,
-0.6461064816,
0.0399543531,
0.102864407,
0.1052957922,
0.0339505114,
-0.6807975173,
0.670948863,
0.0611820966,
-0.3032748401,
-0.4723553658,
0.2413202077,
-0.7783154845,
-0.1027204469,
0.7217408419,
-0.4688551128,
-0.3002454042,
-0.2539308369,
0.0017147105,
0.64937675,
-0.4009800255,
0.509174943,
0.4600400329,
-0.1869709194,
-0.0891073346,
-0.4872048199,
0.7205376625,
0.3496515453,
-1.0058293343,
-0.2147662491,
0.2138424963,
-0.0132930651,
0.2164819837,
0.6869384646,
-0.0310755987,
-0.0731228366,
-0.4426210225,
-0.3736670911,
-0.0404667184,
-0.6063967347,
-0.2247405797,
-0.1176554784,
-0.3025235534,
-0.1535336524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04671v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04671v3
|
PhyloLM : Inferring the Phylogeny of Large Language Models and Predicting their Performances in Benchmarks
| 2024-04-06T16:16:30 | 2024-06-16T14:39:20 |
Nicolas Yax, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer, Stefano Palminteri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.PE
|
This paper introduces PhyloLM, a method adapting phylogenetic algorithms to
Large Language Models (LLMs) to explore whether and how they relate to each
other and to predict their performance characteristics. Our method calculates a
phylogenetic distance metrics based on the similarity of LLMs' output. The
resulting metric is then used to construct dendrograms, which satisfactorily
capture known relationships across a set of 111 open-source and 45 closed
models. Furthermore, our phylogenetic distance predicts performance in standard
benchmarks, thus demonstrating its functional validity and paving the way for a
time and cost-effective estimation of LLM capabilities. To sum up, by
translating population genetic concepts to machine learning, we propose and
validate a tool to evaluate LLM development, relationships and capabilities,
even in the absence of transparent training information.
|
[
-0.2221551239,
-0.4598516822,
0.373147279,
0.0628050566,
-0.3606112897,
0.3672343493,
-0.2928598523,
-0.5869122744,
0.0387555845,
0.66378057,
-0.4432367384,
-0.506289959,
-0.4467124641,
0.2582685351,
-0.2664242089,
0.3945637047,
0.2577825785,
0.2371502817,
-0.339381218,
-0.2309515327,
-0.0662254542,
-0.878852427,
-0.2158431262,
-0.3666311204,
0.4452652335,
0.3324871063,
0.5588573813,
1.2590904236,
0.5551717281,
0.2631849051,
-0.2937148213,
0.2694076002,
-0.5018479228,
0.3415331542,
-0.1298599094,
-0.5559217334,
-0.3092243671,
-0.2157464325,
0.9010895491,
1.1127700806,
-0.0682628825,
0.3847996294,
0.1382380873,
0.6010180712,
-0.2626253366,
0.3246716857,
-0.8170671463,
0.1753281951,
-0.4205908775,
-0.2421093881,
-0.5129895806,
-0.5987192392,
0.4180359244,
-0.2946803868,
-0.0264169462,
0.3843799531,
0.48055318,
0.1620347053,
-0.0850561783,
-0.0368904136,
-0.8169736862,
0.8794384003,
-0.9688122272,
0.5493786335,
0.175106287,
0.2511948049,
-0.6140828133,
-0.6029997468,
-0.2859831154,
-0.546012044,
0.0253825467,
-0.2276639342,
-0.0291814748,
0.2585372925,
0.2564888597,
0.5362486243,
-0.8575493097,
0.396725446,
-0.3685773909,
0.0881285369,
0.7135952711,
0.0064963936,
0.4378346801,
0.1673618406,
-0.1271509081,
-0.2032666057,
-0.596378386,
-0.2100540102,
0.386598587,
0.4055019319,
0.0175000038,
0.558747828,
0.1103538424,
0.6392452121,
-0.2165188193,
-0.4977753758,
0.2815335393,
0.008472776,
-0.1373156607,
0.3807355762,
0.5726833344,
0.1148797646,
0.5303602219,
-0.2346089631,
0.0203829557,
-0.1373211741,
-0.139588207,
-0.7670353651,
-0.5477656722,
0.0103813568,
-0.6297659874,
-0.1200176328,
-0.123200886,
-1.1368836164,
-0.5056204796,
-0.1345429122,
0.0169268437,
-0.500344336,
-0.3452803195,
-0.1883107275,
-0.1934818774,
0.0706238672,
0.0552582815,
-0.9421785474,
0.6155759692,
0.8796703815,
1.0748298168,
-0.4778560698,
-0.590685606,
-0.2450763583,
0.2198142856,
-0.4192993045,
0.5329204202,
-0.5235939026,
-0.4692121148,
-0.2119310945,
-0.0052259313,
-0.16239658,
-0.8787811995,
0.1954813749,
-0.2522984147,
-0.0982084721,
0.2410849482,
-0.9677370191,
-0.5099673271,
-0.0689722598,
-0.7560304403,
0.85187608,
0.2889269888,
-0.7480647564,
0.3339139223,
-0.4330159426,
-0.3641529083,
0.537335813,
0.311177969,
-0.3879675865,
0.1108882874,
-0.0375993922,
0.4969617128,
-0.2878538966,
0.1560854018,
-0.8805487156,
-0.0787082165,
0.0132825002,
0.083072409,
0.8443315625,
0.2177577168,
-0.0016813714,
0.2617661953,
-0.7527710199,
-0.0542577617,
0.0816325098,
-0.2737048566,
-0.4794661105,
0.3259194195,
-0.3796074688,
-0.1385050565,
0.1456965655,
-0.3152037561,
0.3662469387,
-0.8110859394,
0.6509675384,
0.6535804868,
-0.0094471704,
0.3667348623,
-0.28355968,
0.6009998918,
-0.4815539122,
-0.0709451959,
-0.0578493886,
-0.5284392834,
-0.3604338765,
-0.2644310892,
0.3849549294,
0.476223737,
-0.1677113026,
0.4463798702,
-0.4217440486,
-0.9169762731,
-0.1491931081,
0.4253176749,
0.1022731587,
0.3833043873,
0.1292565316,
-0.9031156898,
-0.778172791,
-0.5372960567,
-0.131121695,
-0.7718140483,
0.1785163134,
0.5172377229,
0.4632132649,
-0.084334597,
0.6700040698,
-0.2794519067,
0.1996338069,
-0.4067514837,
0.0624649525,
0.2749969363,
0.4390684962,
0.5392260551,
-0.3210376501,
-0.2950751185,
0.2118858844,
-0.6809325814,
-0.2185376287,
0.4032767415,
0.0786163807,
0.122505635,
0.5443447232,
-0.5178554058,
-0.2454925478,
0.9093332291,
-0.0405864529,
0.7477268577,
-0.1874106228,
-0.27522856,
-0.9872156382,
0.2788615823,
0.2023059726,
0.1178383306,
-0.4730909169,
0.0894163921,
-0.3259888589,
-0.0657130629,
-0.3696182668,
0.6936100125,
-0.3975639641,
-0.7257581353,
0.2744776607,
0.0073032156,
-0.4188567102,
0.2801150084,
-0.0534928031,
0.6635587215,
0.4732297659,
-0.4772209227,
0.6449425817,
0.0254711043,
-0.4973258674,
0.182127744,
-0.3437244594,
0.0560662262,
0.1592131555,
0.2938658893,
-1.0352561474,
-0.4172726572,
0.1326127052,
-0.3760736585,
0.0548914783,
-0.3587833941,
-0.5673464537,
-0.6032724977,
-0.1308262795,
0.4766760767,
0.8048967123,
-0.5489829183,
0.4991285503,
0.5514509082,
-0.4523477554,
-0.1336855143,
-0.4266585112,
-0.0431823321,
-0.7472776175,
-0.6635212302,
0.1759732515,
-0.0149314338,
-0.5584401488,
-0.1652204096,
-0.0556589104,
-0.266082406,
0.559746623,
0.3356881142,
0.2416068614,
-0.6450945139,
0.351095736,
-0.3821445107,
0.2233674079,
0.2116603404,
-0.7308082581,
0.6947951317,
0.1981520951,
-0.2325553745,
-0.1269390136,
-0.4138711691,
0.862077713,
-0.4426597357,
0.5165412426,
0.0620439947,
-0.3580374122,
-0.8281327486,
-0.2414884418,
-0.3708312809,
-0.3847896457,
0.5079233646,
-0.0186251737,
-0.7311599851,
0.2683396339,
-0.684492588,
-0.1151079759,
0.2871198654,
0.5056455731,
0.1679287702,
1.0088961124,
0.736648798,
-0.3842276931,
0.3051887155,
-0.07882566,
0.018963499,
-0.4662105143,
-0.3627369106,
-0.7227538228,
-0.1938660443,
-0.6495602727,
-0.3334140182,
-0.0096165352,
0.2756998241,
-0.3343550861,
0.4390505552,
-0.3918053806,
0.2568399608,
0.5239881873,
-0.4548558891,
0.2859043181,
0.1204798296,
-0.4635938406,
0.1181937307,
-0.7381103039,
-0.5366976857,
1.0778764486,
0.490061909,
0.5489804745,
0.0234972872,
0.5868161321,
0.3167790473,
0.3599761128,
-0.8821360469,
0.6973774433,
-0.5122162104,
-0.2546907663,
-0.3319753408,
-0.5245060325,
-1.0283347368,
0.1743247807,
0.0613236204,
-1.0765287876,
-0.0999253988,
0.0511170588,
-0.1392604113,
0.4820235372,
-0.4155379832,
0.8427141309,
-0.7369604707,
-0.0277904011,
-0.3403410316,
-0.5840964913,
0.5750834346,
-0.2944182456,
0.0823328048,
-0.5376388431,
-0.0004353684,
0.9837237,
-0.4508887529,
0.5778749585,
0.1353356391,
-0.0195150319,
-0.0081302011,
0.4419945478,
-0.0069738701,
-0.3858184516,
-0.4086793363,
0.3177859783,
0.1261292696,
-0.1082703471,
-0.2385757864,
0.7693237662,
-0.7686445713,
-0.4233058095,
-0.2974500954,
-0.6425228119,
-0.4775371552,
0.2985003293,
-0.2489717901,
0.1375495344,
-0.2283583581,
0.2868404388,
0.4336201251,
-0.2214390486,
0.4027949572,
0.366964817,
-0.5966826081,
-0.3860555887,
0.9123584032,
0.1634788066,
0.1987917423,
0.3800674677,
0.4206408858,
-0.4535762668,
-0.9208773375,
-0.4964107871,
0.37191239,
-0.5037794113,
0.0408896282,
-0.2684013546,
-0.1639709026,
-0.1084052697,
0.1769549251,
0.037503425,
-0.3480856717,
-0.1056257859,
-0.0819602013,
0.4959996641,
0.944072485,
0.1145277843,
0.2078652084,
-0.6941537857,
-0.0679148585,
0.2606419027,
0.3581161797,
0.1916756928,
-0.5252893567,
-0.0032389145,
0.0230719466,
-0.1483665854,
-0.8638827205,
0.7399448752,
0.6356532574,
0.7346992493,
0.2344337851,
-0.2965853214,
0.5263040066,
-0.3267679214,
0.8321217895,
0.0373971388,
-0.7931178808,
0.3705475628,
-0.2679251432,
-0.1993631124,
0.1569925994,
0.5151188374,
-0.4803623855,
-0.2880561948,
-0.5154867768,
-0.7468522787,
0.6462733746,
-0.065699771,
-0.2052566856,
0.2329974771,
0.24247998,
0.1294310987,
0.1932886094,
-0.3512949049,
-0.1851448268,
0.106022343,
-0.3309007287,
-0.4895214736,
-0.0867760107,
0.2584741414,
-0.4636338055,
0.6256957054,
-0.2103150934,
-0.2961464524,
-0.1897145063,
-0.1163004562,
-0.4602679312,
-0.0709799528,
0.3683530688,
1.0244588852,
-0.2945631444,
0.3594370186,
0.3940145075,
-0.3736350834,
0.1798380315,
0.1510287821,
0.2033869326,
0.1865007877,
0.6057376266,
0.5337867737,
0.0302581415,
-0.98847121,
0.0271260347,
0.3783171177,
-0.1136441007,
-0.0320831276,
0.1067046896,
0.3817110956,
0.1903960854,
0.2498594671,
-0.2879550159,
-0.1094705537,
-0.7009769082,
0.5385260582,
0.3153305352,
-0.2168496251,
-0.3597616851,
0.5167062283,
0.1445592493,
-0.5020258427,
0.5388845205,
0.1424217224,
-0.7474105954,
1.0391702652,
0.4702343345,
0.8458108902,
-0.6832492948,
0.133036077,
0.3987776339,
0.0052948091,
-0.2904631197,
-0.1365682185,
0.3066215217,
-0.5758260489,
-0.4360093772,
-1.0049074888,
-0.4581003189,
0.3581983745,
-0.1616156995,
0.2585327625,
-0.7153967023,
0.0865327939,
0.3793176711,
0.1619556844,
-0.0822689235,
-0.0276038591,
0.5668717623,
1.0820531845,
-0.7672800422,
1.0098725557,
0.5973854065,
-0.1423561126,
-1.0391945839,
0.0224334467,
0.253972739,
-0.969435215,
0.8923208714,
0.1433372349,
-0.1829653382,
0.1584545523,
-0.3107423484,
-0.9004555345,
0.9555610418,
0.5984666944,
-0.7632492185,
0.1499865502,
0.1634673029,
0.7282871604,
-0.5960264802,
-0.0666912198,
0.639026165,
0.2681900859,
-0.0189719591,
-1.0549659729,
-0.1158184409,
-0.1095388755,
0.1435278505,
0.3111323416,
-0.3067889214,
1.053384304,
-0.1455485821,
-0.3249022067,
0.5185230374,
0.2855112255,
0.372487247,
0.1070552766,
0.3759143949,
0.5328125358,
0.9102940559,
-0.0280652661,
0.917959094,
-0.8329311013,
0.3088881671,
0.9514240026,
-0.4912430346,
0.9296566844,
0.337534368,
-0.3433218002,
0.547336936,
0.8941011429,
-0.5946460366,
0.2201248109,
0.7178857327,
-0.159789145,
-0.0723631829,
-0.316942364,
-0.3315964639,
0.3167734742,
0.3736140728,
-0.6833873987,
-0.1024904773,
-0.4671230018,
-0.1619975567,
0.1679789871,
-0.4101856649,
0.8712875843,
0.2221631706,
-0.7886425257,
0.7333925962,
-0.0277577359,
0.3535630107,
-0.4971644878,
-0.1924879253,
-0.1903677434,
0.394749701,
-0.2547379434,
-0.8031774163,
-0.0335535593,
-0.3571592867,
0.1539176255,
0.0747319385,
0.7131926417,
-0.4907436073,
-0.4841496348,
0.5964568257,
0.6830437779,
0.314357698,
0.414409101,
-0.6479917765,
-0.0378966294,
-0.0975320414,
0.1957287639,
0.1807325631,
0.2796680331,
-0.1697423309,
1.0763037205,
0.6211184859,
0.6034747362,
0.1125030145,
-0.142536521,
0.3214964867,
-0.2606196404,
-0.3027841449,
-1.371316433,
-0.2199293077,
0.1588563174,
-0.0685655996,
0.9910405874,
0.6859879494,
0.966589272,
-0.0929488242,
0.8637850285,
0.3559391499,
0.4998860061,
-0.3100610375,
0.6472299099,
-0.402058661,
0.2115413547,
-0.2328463495,
-1.1914445162,
-0.3328216374,
0.3945736289,
-0.4369841218,
-0.1233721003,
0.5469236374,
0.7972201705,
-0.0706755742,
-0.0338695459,
0.1806524247,
0.4273780584,
-0.0221278947,
0.6296027303,
0.9258980155,
0.5101645589,
0.3895657361,
-0.4195664823,
0.0216640905,
-0.4452597797,
-0.8445562124,
-0.8215664625,
-0.4864784479,
-0.1394788772,
-0.2025667429,
0.3390565813,
0.9886660576,
0.8134153485,
-0.8522794247,
-0.9339229465,
-0.2382023484,
0.2273161262,
-0.3010454178,
-0.1480529308,
0.2760853171,
0.0078447117,
-0.4158870578,
0.2232393622,
0.3078728616,
0.1874559224,
-0.5299087167,
-0.4145637453,
0.0221343469,
0.0834650025,
0.4409071505,
0.4731429219,
-0.9453578591,
-0.2154213041,
-0.266035974,
0.0899767727,
0.1988531053,
0.6179370284,
-0.579955399,
0.3162837923,
0.407630831,
0.5892387629,
0.1359174699,
0.1170752496,
0.8266364336,
-0.4358555973,
-0.0262974799,
0.3769393563,
0.4337871671,
0.4587782621,
0.1267294884,
0.6281919479,
0.4636628032,
-0.4296867847,
-1.0668798685,
0.2216651738,
-0.7777522802,
-0.4259949625,
1.1756370068,
-0.3320914507,
-0.3858775496,
-0.0723164678,
-0.1003886685,
0.2230794281,
-0.119347699,
0.7095967531,
0.5445891023,
0.0268701222,
-0.3154459298,
-0.3899775147,
0.6754658222,
0.1875572354,
-0.8883769512,
0.2110900879,
0.3014911115,
0.3824962974,
0.2039740831,
-0.0549627692,
0.0746279433,
0.1055787653,
-0.2086807787,
0.0266708434,
0.0874540731,
-0.2031221688,
-0.3533269763,
0.4124571681,
0.7669414282,
0.202042371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04659v1
|
Multilingual Pretraining and Instruction Tuning Improve Cross-Lingual Knowledge Alignment, But Only Shallowly
| 2024-04-06T15:25:06 | 2024-04-06T15:25:06 |
Changjiang Gao, Hongda Hu, Peng Hu, Jiajun Chen, Jixing Li, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite their strong ability to retrieve knowledge in English, current large
language models show imbalance abilities in different languages. Two approaches
are proposed to address this, i.e., multilingual pretraining and multilingual
instruction tuning. However, whether and how do such methods contribute to the
cross-lingual knowledge alignment inside the models is unknown. In this paper,
we propose CLiKA, a systematic framework to assess the cross-lingual knowledge
alignment of LLMs in the Performance, Consistency and Conductivity levels, and
explored the effect of multilingual pretraining and instruction tuning on the
degree of alignment. Results show that: while both multilingual pretraining and
instruction tuning are beneficial for cross-lingual knowledge alignment, the
training strategy needs to be carefully designed. Namely, continued pretraining
improves the alignment of the target language at the cost of other languages,
while mixed pretraining affect other languages less. Also, the overall
cross-lingual knowledge alignment, especially in the conductivity level, is
unsatisfactory for all tested LLMs, and neither multilingual pretraining nor
instruction tuning can substantially improve the cross-lingual knowledge
conductivity.
|
[
-0.3778288364,
-0.4663808346,
0.1937012225,
-0.0183407236,
-0.409024775,
0.1304758042,
-0.4539142549,
-0.6053276658,
0.261846602,
0.1163620725,
-0.6557124257,
-0.3240216374,
-0.649998486,
0.0110796085,
0.026385393,
0.8423087001,
-0.0484182574,
0.5512623191,
-0.3845553994,
-0.3450672626,
-0.9063802958,
-0.3009589911,
-0.2854587734,
-0.532260716,
0.450624764,
0.7170389295,
0.6511369348,
0.6512285471,
0.2011080533,
0.3385671377,
0.1443883181,
0.3805528879,
-0.4995373487,
-0.1226269528,
-0.244452998,
-0.7402510643,
-0.3961492479,
-0.0662175417,
0.6272489429,
0.5736332536,
-0.1293817461,
0.1338866651,
0.3126534224,
0.6749489307,
-0.7145407796,
-0.2689880431,
-0.4495075643,
-0.0244958177,
-0.3886356056,
-0.4184636474,
-0.3346466124,
-0.2646086216,
0.2780633271,
-0.9738516212,
-0.1554977596,
0.1149129197,
1.0271551609,
0.3831612766,
-0.5028788447,
-0.4865432382,
-0.3779319227,
0.9004222751,
-0.7488092184,
0.7620990276,
0.0580611266,
-0.0671224296,
0.2038906217,
-0.1992394179,
-0.3105463088,
0.0927599445,
-0.451500833,
0.2325511426,
0.2422717661,
-0.1208645925,
0.0779543668,
-0.0333970375,
-0.5932933092,
0.5268037915,
-0.3509518504,
-0.3684998751,
0.4859895408,
-0.1073778272,
0.6407672763,
0.3086787164,
-0.5317733884,
0.0748865902,
-0.8924657106,
0.1669884175,
0.7490931749,
0.1168106496,
-0.4024317861,
0.3285780549,
0.0697130784,
1.156748414,
0.2890886068,
-0.6461857557,
0.2708230615,
-0.608989656,
0.1579662412,
0.5454105139,
0.4226819575,
0.3994601965,
0.7583947778,
-0.193408668,
0.2776387334,
-0.0202541091,
0.2013941854,
-0.660140574,
0.0187801607,
-0.0607229397,
-0.2699114084,
0.1586144269,
-0.0976321101,
-0.6812189221,
-0.1396136284,
-0.9210281968,
0.4329805374,
-0.4974614084,
-0.5370702744,
0.1132286265,
0.0402204059,
0.5193539858,
-0.0321188755,
-1.1762980223,
0.0203065593,
0.8289226294,
0.4804496765,
-0.303463608,
-0.8222463727,
-0.1132719442,
0.2364828438,
-0.2835446894,
0.6104633808,
-0.5819225311,
-0.0189546999,
0.1233466938,
0.000902906,
-0.4868741035,
-0.4825776219,
0.0072584073,
-0.4303879738,
0.2084553093,
-0.534396708,
-0.6067463756,
-0.059859667,
0.2311036289,
-0.518604219,
0.6998063326,
-0.3373179734,
-0.9205419421,
0.7130819559,
-0.3291996717,
-0.707544148,
-0.4390422404,
-0.0900162756,
-0.3780349791,
-0.1524829865,
0.3240765333,
0.3041554689,
0.001000865,
0.191520825,
-0.1534478068,
-0.5524907708,
0.1330656558,
-0.0186322238,
0.7389934659,
-0.062874265,
-0.4760460556,
0.1711444855,
-0.8023992181,
0.1570800543,
-0.2326509804,
-0.1901343316,
-0.5626820922,
-0.2966372371,
-0.591548562,
0.2607198656,
0.5282539725,
-0.3750020564,
0.0321604945,
-0.5441311598,
0.1852783114,
0.862054348,
-0.2574501038,
0.8336071968,
-0.3170628846,
0.7509015799,
0.3874336779,
0.1687365621,
-0.1254982203,
-0.3304157555,
-1.0767074823,
-0.1388153434,
0.5233081579,
0.7947010994,
-0.4963283241,
0.2407840192,
-0.293505162,
-0.5128731132,
-0.9827973247,
0.436545372,
0.9305374622,
0.6295785308,
0.2443950176,
-0.1463215947,
-0.7638400793,
-0.8846191168,
-0.5082746148,
0.4341468513,
0.5332245827,
0.0837036446,
0.2546362579,
-0.0536107495,
0.5745518208,
-0.0425047874,
-0.0941228196,
-0.0167276785,
-0.0368236341,
0.063560456,
0.559540987,
0.5212160349,
-0.4550285935,
-0.8489159942,
0.5119069219,
-0.6431450844,
-0.0527839214,
0.1509901732,
-0.4455892444,
0.5086657405,
0.3640173972,
-0.4575406611,
0.0967053846,
0.6550098062,
-0.0479096882,
0.4796565771,
-0.1335223764,
0.2404559106,
-1.0289511681,
0.0465659909,
-0.3739769757,
-0.1114612743,
-0.6599471569,
-0.0486344211,
0.3223062754,
-0.0195002835,
-0.5593053102,
0.5772472024,
-0.7923288345,
-0.2068431973,
-0.1074212417,
0.4203902185,
0.0052300608,
0.3825829923,
0.206456542,
0.8914310336,
0.6011436582,
-0.9061690569,
0.1136329174,
0.0447332859,
-0.6097386479,
0.8079228997,
-0.3964552879,
0.2689386308,
-0.1050656736,
-0.2105417997,
-0.7516058087,
0.1187154651,
-0.135842979,
-0.4165356159,
0.7125105858,
-0.0175747629,
-0.1026461124,
0.1303483844,
-0.0427941866,
0.5537756085,
0.2628340721,
-0.7002278566,
0.7646107674,
0.2666126192,
0.1318081617,
-1.3091440201,
-0.5105791092,
-0.61118716,
-0.5178202391,
-0.9802564979,
0.3414788544,
-0.1854455024,
-0.1079576313,
-0.1209953427,
-0.2424676865,
0.1485095322,
0.1951515675,
-0.1548071504,
0.1302324384,
-0.3452406824,
0.0281417184,
0.1186420321,
-0.2510683835,
-0.0783138126,
-0.448811084,
0.6895394921,
0.0650226921,
-0.3781506121,
-0.485070914,
0.155072391,
0.251044333,
-0.4589976668,
0.8027089238,
0.7800225616,
0.0189264677,
-0.216415897,
-0.6249809265,
-0.0151923951,
-0.4611583352,
0.1772090644,
-0.5236522555,
-0.8866010308,
0.5770132542,
-0.1515947282,
0.0863962322,
0.0127885761,
0.6106378436,
-0.1158478335,
0.7958481312,
0.8349364996,
-0.1655270606,
0.3618354201,
0.1408963203,
0.3707957268,
-0.6524989009,
-0.2242037058,
-0.4879148006,
-0.6746552587,
-0.5590343475,
0.130165875,
0.2936943471,
0.2125445008,
-0.3599258661,
0.1547578424,
-0.2493081391,
0.5743657947,
0.6346596479,
0.0669738203,
0.1652750075,
-0.0257889219,
-0.4273789227,
-0.2918790281,
-0.9238424897,
-0.1641828418,
1.1904169321,
0.0901007652,
0.7275466919,
0.2582263947,
0.8163213134,
-0.3460892439,
0.1851255894,
-0.4207111895,
0.1602496207,
-0.0895254463,
-0.5998279452,
-0.2789118588,
-0.2665822208,
-1.0247393847,
0.2972816825,
-0.2544381022,
-0.5479841828,
0.0712024644,
0.4344321787,
-0.0918091536,
0.0172612369,
-0.893784225,
1.1108968258,
-0.7480193377,
-0.3802482784,
-0.2750866711,
-0.7147632241,
0.4957781434,
-0.2155155391,
0.5705029964,
0.1547492892,
-0.0125598786,
0.70588696,
-0.3268618286,
0.9546334147,
-0.2423232198,
-0.4039557278,
-0.0627655238,
-0.2796888351,
0.4229874015,
-0.138790682,
0.1556740701,
0.2599157393,
0.1045738235,
-0.4435738921,
-0.5247058868,
0.7589201331,
-1.175855279,
-0.6508991718,
-0.0430196673,
-0.716914475,
-0.4868946671,
0.4645397961,
0.5961639881,
0.0011396476,
-0.1107047349,
-0.1438295692,
0.9651642442,
-0.1631252766,
0.2035185546,
0.9311621189,
-0.1749350429,
-0.4920042753,
0.9077453613,
0.2966688275,
0.5823782682,
0.6217907071,
0.0912553146,
-0.2381048948,
-0.2989582121,
-0.4408508241,
0.4031075537,
-0.8234964013,
-0.1226571426,
-0.2105979174,
0.1431244314,
-0.6580521464,
-0.2583228648,
-0.3850890994,
-0.1165590137,
-0.2545793355,
-0.2013820112,
0.0007320152,
0.4259208143,
-0.1026068628,
0.4402228296,
-0.6517167091,
-0.0464371666,
0.0951471925,
0.3906795979,
-0.0297914762,
-0.5410766602,
-0.6008179784,
0.1794142574,
-0.108676672,
-0.6187323928,
-0.0134123499,
0.281264931,
0.7395926714,
0.391500026,
-0.2979739308,
1.2421706915,
-0.665650785,
0.4839015305,
0.3856673241,
-1.1267387867,
0.3777580857,
0.1356345415,
0.3718161285,
0.5363054276,
0.7213606834,
-0.3252932131,
0.0074493093,
-0.3007517159,
-0.5217821598,
0.72450912,
-0.4962030351,
-0.0607875176,
0.3712289631,
0.1206313372,
0.3290122747,
0.1484838277,
-0.7555813789,
-0.2950147986,
-0.2553623319,
-0.3818874955,
-0.224436745,
-0.2624006867,
-0.3573868573,
-0.2625494003,
0.9206856489,
-0.0236306358,
-0.1740418226,
-0.1270123124,
-0.4636741877,
-0.2152437568,
0.2716032267,
0.9370023012,
1.1770150661,
0.2682175338,
-0.1090335399,
0.2812830508,
-0.2774473727,
0.2664808631,
-0.1626161337,
-0.2624086738,
-0.0769779533,
0.5853982568,
0.9083287716,
0.6316994429,
-0.512110889,
0.3973740339,
0.0755603984,
-0.2283779532,
-0.3380863965,
0.0810191929,
0.3873354495,
0.1101082936,
-0.3295758665,
-0.2543551326,
-0.4121903181,
-0.4041533768,
0.0242250189,
0.6221673489,
-0.023401631,
-0.2239235342,
0.3316470385,
0.1808434129,
-0.0867278054,
0.5393928885,
0.256455034,
-0.4582303464,
0.4278462231,
0.7769432068,
0.2215201557,
-0.6855698824,
-0.1565951407,
0.4325466454,
0.6629015803,
0.2002485096,
0.4238254726,
-0.1775433868,
-0.9485254288,
-0.5792630315,
-0.5490768552,
-0.2042952329,
-0.1085107327,
-0.8274701834,
0.5513720512,
-0.1911333501,
0.1468181461,
-0.2086918652,
-0.0041452362,
-0.8080506921,
0.185193941,
0.0552803539,
0.7604860663,
-0.8414776325,
0.9603591561,
0.7884888649,
-0.1450155079,
-1.0398313999,
-0.224262014,
-0.0904611126,
-1.0522294044,
0.6489930749,
0.2495806664,
-0.2082659453,
0.0733964369,
-0.1603392661,
-1.3165507317,
1.194306016,
0.5968828797,
-0.8999190331,
0.0220609494,
0.5016912818,
0.3238011301,
-0.3467490673,
0.0830973908,
0.6105551124,
0.6717387438,
-0.3210434318,
-1.2123025656,
-0.2119556367,
-0.1571671069,
-0.3185482323,
0.3765642345,
-0.6851565838,
0.6017867327,
0.0168780871,
-0.2031355202,
-0.0548572466,
0.6630740762,
0.265309751,
0.2283238173,
0.3676321805,
1.0100804567,
1.0035856962,
-0.0613307171,
0.6114968657,
-0.8135361075,
-0.0326677933,
1.0900775194,
-0.2753952146,
0.5197100639,
0.5592631698,
0.0748494789,
0.594347477,
0.5961895585,
0.2645577192,
0.5838923454,
0.1100895554,
0.1750515848,
-0.3145721257,
0.1269889474,
-0.6553377509,
0.4465736747,
0.303486675,
-0.1407765597,
-0.0281304084,
0.2217396349,
0.3418193758,
0.0985625088,
-0.4706964195,
0.8180397153,
0.1126715466,
-1.247641921,
0.9356637001,
-0.2025945038,
0.9178075194,
-0.7514300346,
0.1996024102,
-0.1919244081,
0.2874876857,
-0.4672451913,
-0.4463915527,
0.2434414327,
-0.2038171887,
-0.1703130305,
-0.1414763182,
0.7247727513,
-0.7115362287,
-0.1520731747,
0.589895308,
0.3724671602,
0.1069947854,
0.6107008457,
-0.6658975482,
0.1294950545,
0.0896547139,
0.0800807551,
0.670314312,
0.4867167473,
0.1999538541,
0.4245821536,
0.5286524296,
0.0709884465,
0.4595244527,
0.1637023836,
0.4936266541,
-0.3309355378,
-0.4714492559,
-0.8583798409,
0.6901467443,
0.1182720363,
-0.494171381,
0.8924869299,
0.4138282835,
1.3122904301,
-0.1100003794,
0.5473730564,
0.2325232327,
0.4637056887,
-1.0308425426,
0.4572360516,
-0.7362717986,
0.1393250674,
0.0227191728,
-0.7822816968,
0.144271642,
0.4159167409,
-0.3185431063,
0.0341447107,
0.757456243,
0.7321311235,
-0.2440076768,
-0.1199841201,
0.3233715594,
0.0940245986,
-0.1367602646,
0.5868880749,
0.6957912445,
-0.1030678451,
0.5311595201,
-0.370188117,
-0.1778238714,
0.0667978749,
-0.9358232617,
-1.1179790497,
-0.410698086,
-0.0807326362,
-0.114477694,
0.2595148683,
0.4287412167,
0.7231937051,
-0.6426169276,
-0.4720518291,
0.1559853405,
0.1542557329,
-0.3940951228,
-0.1247955486,
0.1977631003,
-0.8534511328,
-0.6816421151,
0.446593821,
-0.0069656004,
-0.2360308915,
-0.3361910284,
-0.3047601879,
-0.4355712831,
-0.1481043994,
0.3100250959,
0.1930629909,
-0.6658568382,
-0.0628275275,
0.1832055897,
-0.0000535124,
0.1196095943,
0.7294883728,
-0.3231948912,
0.4439014494,
0.4018093646,
0.7213324308,
0.4028816521,
-0.0037698259,
0.7402051687,
-0.9111831188,
0.2592646778,
-0.2093607485,
0.5281261802,
0.2684172094,
-0.411646992,
0.2619033158,
0.0362447836,
-0.6708932519,
-0.4845549464,
0.3423621356,
-0.6871775985,
-0.2831870019,
0.9759191871,
-0.2606556118,
-0.2522392273,
-0.0187011808,
0.1067648157,
0.4069738388,
0.1258516163,
0.5497261882,
1.1353727579,
0.0492040925,
-0.210301891,
-0.3823604882,
0.533619225,
0.9521614909,
-0.6183772087,
-0.1783589572,
0.1635922939,
0.5257467031,
0.3013686836,
0.5036509037,
-0.0429760106,
0.3237448037,
-0.482223928,
0.0733379424,
0.0889128521,
-0.4775793552,
-0.2334132344,
-0.2177846879,
0.1046189889,
-0.0275438502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04656v1
|
Binary Classifier Optimization for Large Language Model Alignment
| 2024-04-06T15:20:59 | 2024-04-06T15:20:59 |
Seungjae Jung, Gunsoo Han, Daniel Wontae Nam, Kyoung-Woon On
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) to human preferences through preference
optimization has been crucial but labor-intensive, necessitating for each
prompt a comparison of both a chosen and a rejected text completion by
evaluators. Recently, Kahneman-Tversky Optimization (KTO) has demonstrated that
LLMs can be aligned using merely binary "thumbs-up" or "thumbs-down" signals on
each prompt-completion pair. In this paper, we present theoretical foundations
to explain the successful alignment achieved through these binary signals. Our
analysis uncovers a new perspective: optimizing a binary classifier, whose
logit is a reward, implicitly induces minimizing the Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO) loss. In the process of this discovery, we identified two
techniques for effective alignment: reward shift and underlying distribution
matching. Consequently, we propose a new algorithm, \textit{Binary Classifier
Optimization}, that integrates the techniques. We validate our methodology in
two settings: first, on a paired preference dataset, where our method performs
on par with DPO and KTO; and second, on binary signal datasets simulating
real-world conditions with divergent underlying distributions between thumbs-up
and thumbs-down data. Our model consistently demonstrates effective and robust
alignment across two base LLMs and three different binary signal datasets,
showcasing the strength of our approach to learning from binary feedback.
|
[
-0.3361021876,
-0.3204310238,
0.7580003738,
0.0105142174,
-0.5142278075,
0.1927968413,
-0.4357291758,
-0.2341834456,
0.0482728519,
0.3844783008,
-0.5951090455,
-0.4186835587,
-0.6309293509,
-0.0879789516,
-0.0683758184,
1.0339103937,
0.0688003823,
0.086111553,
-0.2312886566,
-0.0221136604,
-0.6228816509,
-0.3678231835,
-0.5964280367,
-0.4801639915,
0.6708802581,
0.6025521755,
0.8661126494,
0.861590147,
0.496050626,
0.2059317231,
-0.114480488,
-0.1156373471,
-0.5936775804,
0.1200310364,
0.0388357565,
-0.5175735354,
-0.0822905749,
-0.2565196753,
0.7089204788,
0.6689532995,
-0.083464101,
0.0583131872,
-0.040812593,
0.8728556037,
-0.5779306293,
-0.0444003791,
-0.614200592,
-0.0056093009,
-0.073708646,
-0.2673404813,
-0.5054762959,
-0.799859643,
0.1356839687,
-0.2671249807,
-0.0741664246,
0.0032054058,
0.7089168429,
0.5150668621,
-0.5979566574,
-0.2193243653,
-0.6839595437,
0.943569541,
-0.6517048478,
0.5065453053,
-0.0675590858,
0.1147690862,
-0.152070269,
0.2622038126,
-0.5525633097,
-0.2068969905,
-0.0161330029,
-0.0465875305,
0.0107933218,
-0.0496813618,
0.0053104637,
0.1121809483,
-0.5729971528,
0.53896451,
-0.1976138651,
-0.1788947135,
0.5604560971,
0.0246336479,
0.0086093331,
-0.0804573596,
-0.4460501075,
-0.3529515266,
-0.5677362084,
0.3083263338,
0.6434670091,
0.4599640965,
0.0469846167,
0.6393638849,
0.0473300442,
0.6920656562,
0.5945355296,
-0.2151773125,
0.3244669735,
-0.1942589581,
0.1676337123,
0.5782446861,
0.7232189178,
0.5779837966,
0.1745311171,
-0.1397880614,
-0.3299289346,
0.3642778695,
0.3008582592,
-0.6599112749,
-0.0119425822,
0.4725956321,
-0.4285590053,
-0.8526939154,
-0.177043885,
-0.53082937,
-0.4865521193,
-0.7394046187,
0.4936915636,
-0.1536295563,
-0.3814903498,
0.2703751028,
-0.0186794829,
0.4433568418,
0.1057824418,
-1.3425574303,
0.102071166,
1.2468798161,
0.6144044995,
-0.2755621672,
0.1058707163,
-0.6375564933,
0.001997509,
-0.4074802101,
0.6289675832,
-0.5958083868,
-0.0393402204,
-0.0832681879,
-0.3105709553,
0.2006791234,
-0.3773898184,
0.6820567846,
-0.7248168588,
0.2365665734,
-0.3214465976,
-0.72242558,
0.0016910221,
0.0912175998,
-0.5258319974,
1.0964574814,
-0.0742478594,
-0.8244126439,
0.5662997365,
-0.405590862,
-0.2871315479,
-0.1185615137,
-0.1828242242,
-0.5113589764,
0.300391376,
-0.0182514098,
0.5050189495,
-0.1936123222,
0.4644183218,
-0.451662302,
-0.4705749452,
0.4062396288,
-0.093212381,
0.7500288486,
0.0158043727,
-0.5585044622,
0.3109155297,
-0.4908083081,
-0.0246194992,
0.0569083914,
-0.2921488285,
-0.4448268712,
0.3111578226,
-0.0019845625,
0.1337209791,
0.4320893884,
-0.5968939066,
0.4699237943,
-0.3808392882,
0.3241397142,
1.2709004879,
-0.3975869119,
0.5692471266,
-0.144634217,
0.3661839068,
-0.042948667,
0.326990366,
0.4318588376,
-0.1128006205,
-0.5634939671,
-0.2989824712,
0.5938615799,
0.4360799193,
-0.1817219108,
0.9364005327,
-0.5815728903,
-0.3241408169,
-0.6868801117,
0.1199568063,
0.2542002797,
0.4891571999,
-0.0526169538,
-0.3057953715,
-0.3007876575,
-1.0729192495,
0.2826429009,
-0.1520865411,
0.1848608404,
0.1300963312,
0.0677315518,
-0.2511433661,
0.8808259368,
-0.5028734207,
0.1615460664,
-0.0710105896,
-0.1770798564,
0.5448418856,
0.3322162926,
0.5564572811,
-0.937956214,
-0.5633702874,
0.2442258745,
-0.3608715236,
-0.2314165682,
-0.0485916659,
-0.4453906119,
0.4282541871,
0.2236968428,
-0.3487093747,
-0.1155550778,
0.7612004876,
-0.1290590912,
0.6944146752,
0.1332617253,
0.0766308457,
-1.0771030188,
0.0256719682,
-0.149928689,
-0.3271448314,
-0.5253229737,
-0.2549249232,
0.2424202263,
0.0595470108,
-0.1018505469,
0.435470432,
-0.2517024875,
-0.1132155359,
-0.4385547936,
0.2397256196,
-0.3509674072,
0.5867610574,
0.2489649504,
0.4600670338,
0.6351978183,
-0.5376284122,
0.4378680289,
0.3532472849,
-0.2517742217,
0.7238039374,
-0.5244718194,
0.2840347886,
-0.2700855732,
0.0300592426,
-1.2516372204,
-0.0513242446,
0.459913522,
-0.4590606689,
0.4625327587,
-0.175657481,
-0.4162540734,
-0.0465628952,
-0.5184341073,
0.5586929917,
0.707075119,
-0.8569854498,
0.3472063243,
0.2688080668,
-0.2057303935,
-1.0034127235,
-0.1687955856,
-0.2152813524,
-0.4008578956,
-0.4696899354,
0.2576369941,
-0.0275979042,
-0.0500477813,
0.0440319963,
-0.3577333093,
0.4183209836,
0.1085560322,
0.0167793836,
0.6907276511,
-0.1197975427,
0.3068789244,
0.102014035,
-0.427598685,
-0.0332244858,
-0.4629333019,
0.727971673,
0.0281740315,
-0.2982591391,
-0.3092697263,
0.2732677758,
0.2599784732,
0.0457109697,
0.4870738685,
0.4292950928,
0.0121626314,
0.0944491848,
-0.6703470945,
-0.1665612906,
-0.5043420196,
0.3062154651,
-0.2317964882,
-0.887124002,
0.0704457462,
0.0939189866,
0.2367595732,
0.157074362,
0.6587459445,
-0.0578903332,
1.2700734138,
0.6602221727,
-0.436340183,
0.6123225689,
0.3318632245,
0.3638755679,
-0.7616578341,
-0.01990241,
-0.5702554584,
-0.601259768,
-0.8604337573,
-0.1606128365,
0.2038550824,
0.0240419041,
-0.3261334598,
0.420203805,
-0.7861279249,
0.4893834293,
0.7692908645,
0.1623916179,
0.1250669211,
0.0567498021,
-0.1311290711,
-0.0260540638,
-0.5893775225,
-0.628836751,
1.1213879585,
0.2758361101,
0.8005017638,
0.1952500641,
1.0459340811,
0.1387273669,
0.1945711523,
-1.0979104042,
0.5063447356,
-0.1351012439,
-0.5165340304,
-0.3628426194,
-0.6057062745,
-0.9515759349,
0.0570388921,
-0.3120749891,
-0.7347216606,
0.1759934425,
0.3453385532,
-0.1065100208,
0.0529507212,
-0.6968563795,
0.9501088262,
-0.7099583149,
-0.2913903892,
-0.2265551686,
-0.8696474433,
0.2299856544,
-0.2148686796,
0.0462236367,
-0.2365226001,
-0.1479759663,
0.4302617311,
0.0088124787,
0.8278518319,
-0.1493378729,
-0.3122840226,
-0.3078765571,
-0.0144308964,
0.5239160657,
-0.3321424723,
-0.0017533283,
0.0345248021,
0.1162213013,
-0.5319898725,
-0.6057199836,
0.5874128938,
-0.8901629448,
-0.4617957175,
-0.3918396235,
-0.3134214282,
-0.2889322937,
0.2149854004,
0.0016532012,
0.2627526224,
-0.0177582167,
0.1461916566,
0.7583259344,
-0.0957647562,
0.1515395641,
0.2664290369,
-0.3051372468,
-0.4772470593,
0.9990596771,
-0.4403075278,
0.4611668289,
0.7450070381,
0.50183779,
-0.6342455149,
-0.5936555862,
-0.4269880056,
0.4119092822,
-0.7874779105,
-0.1007534638,
-0.1878068596,
0.1977319568,
-0.3964123726,
-0.4235019386,
-0.2650274038,
-0.3249416649,
-0.0088806832,
-0.0564705729,
0.176517576,
0.448215276,
-0.0634156913,
0.1933784783,
-0.7596776485,
0.0831730366,
0.1861416698,
0.4998398721,
0.0100059062,
-0.3242513239,
-0.1225158423,
0.0622235872,
-0.1678684801,
-0.6631638408,
0.0079139629,
-0.2292617857,
0.5061978102,
0.5402466655,
0.0532772429,
0.3180953562,
-0.3920461535,
0.2960121036,
0.5086396337,
-0.9599493146,
0.4298137426,
-0.3044471145,
0.057498958,
0.6858979464,
0.652908206,
-0.7986063957,
-0.105774425,
-0.3915246129,
-0.6916959286,
0.6754877567,
0.0674778521,
0.1226289645,
0.0775596201,
0.4106112123,
0.4846211672,
0.3430255055,
-0.8228929639,
-0.2569751441,
0.1257852465,
-0.7201638222,
-0.2642615736,
-0.3448503613,
-0.2346728444,
0.0067302021,
0.8214410543,
-0.2015158832,
0.3602474332,
-0.3075106144,
0.0004848134,
-0.1429627985,
0.261975497,
0.5360056162,
0.3948633373,
-0.3189893961,
-0.0039405623,
-0.3264392316,
-0.254696399,
0.4579069912,
0.0607161596,
-0.3824309409,
-0.1758238673,
0.0534956679,
1.0355250835,
0.3449196815,
-0.5680633783,
0.4719167054,
0.0035378574,
-0.1836795509,
-0.13694188,
0.0972551107,
0.2065403312,
0.3410542309,
0.2539715469,
-0.0841845125,
0.0818343163,
-0.3916607797,
-0.0502241403,
0.772831738,
-0.3295640647,
-0.2114640772,
0.4771352112,
0.234087497,
-0.374437362,
0.525657773,
-0.0082995854,
-0.706176579,
0.3837201893,
0.3025721014,
0.926271975,
0.0235254355,
0.2978589833,
0.2941882908,
0.004989617,
-0.2443774343,
-0.0090802182,
-0.3645001352,
-1.1174206734,
-0.4871322215,
-0.6769050956,
-0.6228898168,
-0.3514133096,
-0.7410432696,
0.6007817388,
-0.1715866327,
-0.1029909402,
0.4242815077,
0.0831120387,
-0.5108334422,
-0.0101568205,
0.4456054568,
0.3480743468,
-0.8630929589,
0.5821660161,
0.5311068892,
-0.0348938443,
-0.7796279788,
-0.0136340493,
0.0124419089,
-1.121342659,
0.6570894122,
0.3868747354,
-0.207723096,
0.1099809036,
-0.4520635903,
-0.8889456391,
0.713876605,
0.3558754623,
-0.8858736157,
0.123284623,
0.147417292,
0.3536388576,
-0.2767839134,
0.0700340942,
0.6030170918,
0.5452798605,
0.1980662346,
-0.8822768331,
0.1529358774,
0.0546871945,
-0.0621692911,
0.908878088,
-0.6274386644,
0.0908850133,
-0.1757982671,
-0.0180481356,
-0.1609475017,
0.174238205,
0.3605026901,
0.0315833166,
0.940144062,
0.4982680678,
0.7338098884,
-0.1510867029,
0.8916516304,
-0.061877504,
0.3865199685,
0.8780180812,
-0.4221173525,
0.9064723849,
0.7718167305,
-0.2455568463,
0.3640310168,
0.968167901,
0.0110739199,
0.731764555,
0.1359341443,
-0.2254980206,
-0.4532800317,
0.0235106461,
-0.1752584726,
0.4049871862,
-0.1258411109,
-0.2385699004,
0.1574727595,
-0.2694400549,
-0.2318839282,
-0.1606484801,
-0.1440261155,
1.0041091442,
-0.2527419925,
-0.8774247169,
0.6280553937,
-0.2186445296,
0.8113029003,
-0.4683193862,
0.3049738705,
-0.1088844687,
0.2885974646,
-0.1393109411,
-0.7145998478,
0.0190542061,
-0.1928985268,
-0.3111740947,
-0.2019159645,
0.4150071144,
-0.4876867533,
-0.5223251581,
0.2011167407,
0.0313405357,
0.1229754612,
0.1351350844,
-0.6307690144,
0.2795951962,
0.2535535693,
-0.146616593,
0.4873539209,
0.342890799,
-0.0055495356,
0.4765164554,
0.6162437201,
0.0934787989,
-0.152382955,
0.0730395317,
0.6785786748,
-0.7737895846,
-0.450014025,
-1.0371910334,
0.3448809385,
-0.1179049313,
-0.040668346,
0.2876981795,
0.7147003412,
0.893435061,
-0.10093835,
0.7430677414,
-0.0627176687,
0.380502224,
-0.6314746737,
0.1067011803,
-0.5108733177,
0.126831457,
-0.3128834069,
-1.2984253168,
-0.1024421677,
0.6212881804,
-0.3991550803,
-0.1341718286,
0.6047987938,
0.8661745191,
-0.0229094196,
-0.1505960524,
0.0919226333,
-0.1317384839,
0.2038278133,
0.7060111761,
0.8947894573,
-0.0887722671,
0.5764054656,
-0.417817682,
-0.4874997437,
-0.4693659544,
-1.2162528038,
-0.7154632807,
-0.5281895995,
-0.4941731691,
-0.1879855543,
-0.031199906,
1.2809985876,
0.6122031212,
-0.7004045844,
-0.2820190489,
0.0631494746,
0.2620432675,
-0.3304568827,
-0.2146925926,
0.3674822152,
-0.39467296,
-0.8268137574,
-0.1360456347,
0.2319951057,
-0.0019837443,
-0.1742335707,
-0.1267692149,
0.0526165403,
-0.1483219713,
0.4467612803,
0.0492873527,
-0.7052357793,
-0.612121582,
0.1684546471,
-0.1084356457,
0.2669172287,
0.7913529277,
-0.384604454,
0.3795083761,
0.4180680215,
0.8458174467,
0.3481189013,
0.2370336652,
0.6994788647,
-0.6718174219,
-0.0851580575,
0.2664230168,
0.0874213502,
0.4572818875,
-0.4998345971,
0.398991406,
-0.0719726905,
-0.7695308924,
-0.9287420511,
0.2524191439,
-1.3430005312,
-0.1332185864,
1.2091311216,
0.5048261285,
-0.2025430053,
0.2057237178,
-0.5103370547,
0.0739206448,
-0.5885272622,
1.106951952,
0.957967937,
-0.1938146651,
-0.116980806,
-0.1650766283,
0.4133677185,
0.6954908371,
-0.3988315165,
0.1986365318,
0.6640512347,
0.3957602978,
0.1090367138,
0.5163477659,
0.0827263296,
0.2835304141,
-0.408426553,
0.2991618812,
0.2476857454,
0.1026204303,
-0.6353002191,
-0.1611828357,
0.3522777557,
-0.3606311977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08676v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08676v3
|
ALERT: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Assessing Large Language Models' Safety through Red Teaming
| 2024-04-06T15:01:47 | 2024-06-24T08:50:22 |
Simone Tedeschi, Felix Friedrich, Patrick Schramowski, Kristian Kersting, Roberto Navigli, Huu Nguyen, Bo Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, I.2
|
When building Large Language Models (LLMs), it is paramount to bear safety in
mind and protect them with guardrails. Indeed, LLMs should never generate
content promoting or normalizing harmful, illegal, or unethical behavior that
may contribute to harm to individuals or society. This principle applies to
both normal and adversarial use. In response, we introduce ALERT, a large-scale
benchmark to assess safety based on a novel fine-grained risk taxonomy. It is
designed to evaluate the safety of LLMs through red teaming methodologies and
consists of more than 45k instructions categorized using our novel taxonomy. By
subjecting LLMs to adversarial testing scenarios, ALERT aims to identify
vulnerabilities, inform improvements, and enhance the overall safety of the
language models. Furthermore, the fine-grained taxonomy enables researchers to
perform an in-depth evaluation that also helps one to assess the alignment with
various policies. In our experiments, we extensively evaluate 10 popular open-
and closed-source LLMs and demonstrate that many of them still struggle to
attain reasonable levels of safety.
|
[
-0.0903017223,
-0.8240870833,
0.1944810599,
0.2738846838,
0.0909837112,
0.0111462902,
-0.4007677138,
-0.557955265,
-0.3377087712,
0.488243252,
-0.1043573245,
-0.6955531836,
-0.7480955124,
-0.0680233166,
-0.7826495171,
1.034701705,
0.0534903146,
-0.176172629,
-0.0977837369,
0.0118322195,
-0.3548598289,
-0.4962899983,
-0.7369701862,
-0.0626828,
0.6340364814,
0.0046291207,
0.7352690101,
0.576196909,
1.0148026943,
0.2822944224,
-0.1835938394,
-0.1428647488,
-0.5403166413,
0.186757192,
-0.188992545,
-0.5619360805,
-0.5346939564,
0.0797965527,
0.3365698159,
0.6461368203,
-0.2031981349,
0.2299485207,
0.0748218969,
0.4417377114,
-1.0238935947,
0.0031108262,
-0.9692101479,
-0.1250658929,
-0.2312057614,
-0.1531639397,
-0.5959178209,
-0.6908539534,
0.1937598288,
-0.1754651219,
-0.2959965169,
0.1708764285,
0.6067630053,
0.3029778302,
-0.3270674646,
-0.044347804,
-0.4722509384,
0.8637747765,
-0.5684053302,
0.0695566535,
0.2369459569,
0.6773945093,
-0.3892507553,
-0.5757191777,
-0.2354135662,
-0.1996150315,
0.1489785165,
-0.0652330741,
-0.4891058803,
0.1129666567,
0.048106432,
0.1242339909,
-0.6418325305,
0.5041136742,
-0.1424751133,
-0.1040837765,
0.7205842137,
0.1584422886,
0.4812472761,
0.1640337557,
-0.6911961436,
-0.2919734716,
-0.8851383924,
-0.2341739088,
0.2646526694,
0.6473240256,
-0.3278527856,
0.3723157048,
-0.1396435201,
0.4431693256,
-0.3553940654,
-0.0755221546,
0.318344295,
-0.1931332499,
-0.420499742,
0.1349883229,
1.1052333117,
0.8790195584,
0.4982065558,
-0.3766445816,
-0.3655641973,
0.376149565,
0.440351367,
-0.523671627,
-0.180315733,
0.150259316,
-0.2567071021,
-0.603304863,
-0.251888454,
-0.9889122248,
-0.7567625046,
0.0871450976,
0.4004501998,
-0.3105119467,
-0.2707279325,
0.0908611119,
0.0800212026,
0.2272408307,
0.1167072579,
-0.789832592,
0.3353883624,
1.1071357727,
0.6315279603,
-0.2927030325,
-0.446644485,
-0.6930616498,
0.0061628451,
-0.4922197461,
0.6430797577,
-0.2769486606,
-0.3385784626,
0.429887563,
-0.1094646677,
0.0297975671,
-0.5276706219,
0.5175409913,
-0.4777350426,
-0.1404836774,
0.1513413042,
-0.3628350496,
-0.1564875543,
0.6176953912,
-0.2778148949,
0.8920369744,
-0.1139760762,
-0.669506669,
0.3754836619,
-0.5087803602,
-0.5260902643,
0.0602040105,
-0.2147684097,
-0.2551713884,
-0.2183609009,
-0.1969131827,
0.5107026696,
-0.6509952545,
0.341106087,
-0.6039224863,
-0.0181275364,
0.2401750684,
-0.561657548,
0.7890854478,
0.0716336668,
-0.4344241917,
0.4692759514,
-0.5286095738,
0.2231036276,
0.0157281831,
-0.2505061626,
-0.548831284,
-0.0601526387,
0.0473367758,
0.2372916341,
0.320545882,
-0.2763794363,
-0.2202596962,
-0.3013946414,
0.3496412933,
0.9063416123,
-0.0151697258,
0.3266011477,
-0.4118047059,
0.4022404253,
-0.2805150449,
0.4574961066,
-0.0119530214,
-0.1991905719,
-0.5859349966,
-0.2464761436,
0.2981020212,
0.6119446754,
-0.2818950713,
0.7885881662,
-0.3589752018,
-0.7749737501,
-0.1809952259,
0.0155345714,
0.7439815998,
0.1486066282,
0.2232850045,
-0.0875616297,
-0.5092186928,
-0.8536260724,
-0.1789697111,
-0.2207361162,
-0.0461170785,
0.2125625312,
0.6351017952,
-0.6362056732,
0.5558695793,
-0.3760868311,
-0.0996054187,
-0.0936424583,
0.2067191452,
-0.0270273443,
0.5229308605,
0.6537937522,
-0.6173582673,
-0.5181870461,
0.1185034439,
-0.9013080001,
-0.0124906376,
-0.0148360049,
-0.2288678735,
0.238487348,
0.7169546485,
-0.3644606173,
0.098606661,
0.7914947271,
-0.2723177969,
0.467027396,
0.0120684914,
-0.1193705648,
-0.916485846,
0.160577327,
0.1133259684,
-0.0720355958,
-0.6649628878,
0.3365153074,
0.1414425075,
0.0794359073,
-0.7762157321,
0.4820125401,
-0.120829545,
-0.0621307865,
-0.1141719446,
0.2011373937,
-0.3099763989,
0.060874708,
-0.3704919517,
0.8647387624,
0.8538576365,
-0.7279614806,
0.3725531995,
-0.0365380794,
-0.6682219505,
0.4530648589,
-0.7233207822,
0.0697703362,
0.2153343558,
-0.0471009612,
-0.5213955045,
-0.2817922831,
-0.0668966994,
-0.278729856,
0.2661688328,
-0.0043979194,
-0.7295923233,
-0.2430954129,
-0.3784569204,
0.1829396188,
0.6030834317,
-0.4091385901,
0.3267216384,
0.9267373681,
-0.1065926626,
-0.5252433419,
-0.6440421939,
0.1606925279,
-0.5228370428,
-0.5956845284,
0.0905341804,
-0.0704203993,
-0.7213849425,
-0.1630900502,
-0.0712778047,
-0.1240830943,
0.7960993052,
0.3775290847,
0.3426788449,
-0.0283833407,
-0.0110016,
-0.5803108811,
-0.2545042932,
0.2128436565,
0.1112331226,
0.616527617,
-0.3420791924,
-0.2132478952,
-0.1144698337,
0.2346572578,
0.7961421013,
-0.1504983753,
0.6834238172,
0.3566318452,
-0.4342692196,
-0.2667041421,
-0.3702022135,
-0.0838636309,
-0.4773604572,
0.4226852357,
0.1953905374,
-0.8899504542,
0.4083214104,
-0.1348531991,
0.274230212,
0.3602652848,
0.5413168073,
0.0410457812,
0.8648356795,
0.6905246973,
-0.4020286798,
0.3701912761,
0.118996948,
0.0857167542,
-0.7044121027,
-0.2215774208,
-0.6675674915,
-0.1404952854,
-0.5631004572,
-0.3363910317,
0.4939031899,
-0.0665873587,
-0.5836120248,
0.5207384825,
-0.4243627489,
0.6049402356,
0.5781050324,
-0.2954359949,
-0.0379149653,
-0.3825440407,
-0.0301172473,
0.2666336596,
-0.2899893522,
-0.6324250102,
1.2810330391,
0.4944705665,
1.156395793,
0.3387130499,
0.6410683393,
0.3333038688,
0.3702326715,
-0.7163174748,
0.7769778371,
-0.3095975518,
-0.6621624827,
-0.2348552495,
-0.5869722366,
-0.9911205173,
0.0862757713,
-0.3643141389,
-0.9716259241,
-0.3372891247,
-0.018413946,
-0.4520100951,
0.094805561,
-0.788241744,
0.925339818,
-0.578741014,
-0.1202965677,
-0.1017560661,
-0.5587841868,
0.5862602592,
-0.2901621461,
0.287183702,
-0.43864429,
-0.0065296665,
0.7377119064,
-0.0171485208,
1.0334591866,
0.2199335694,
-0.0849123597,
0.0906371027,
0.2179124057,
0.6378740072,
-0.2934768498,
-0.1316515505,
0.2853117287,
-0.1698364317,
-0.1391117275,
-0.2453298569,
1.0146826506,
-0.73010391,
-0.6647408605,
-0.5402130485,
-0.6833148003,
-0.2896698415,
0.4521200955,
-0.0419233069,
0.2639420629,
-0.3095024526,
0.5548433661,
0.6448895335,
-0.2569077015,
0.5419217348,
0.6014085412,
-0.153134644,
-0.36657691,
0.7055519819,
-0.1719779223,
0.5811931491,
0.3960334361,
0.1638586372,
-0.2837429345,
-1.0161417723,
-0.0168482903,
-0.1358729303,
-0.7913598418,
-0.4777365327,
-0.524384439,
-0.1606498808,
-0.3995428979,
-0.2644487619,
-0.4767694175,
0.0436036624,
0.0279811565,
-0.0192112401,
0.3655869067,
0.5654629469,
0.2086676508,
0.0482138544,
-0.9747204185,
-0.087703988,
0.4192443788,
0.4550008476,
-0.2860408723,
-0.2463018596,
-0.1235229373,
-0.1469652206,
-0.2114610523,
-0.314837873,
0.283828795,
-0.1025758609,
0.8739974499,
0.3482391238,
0.6520964503,
0.2478454858,
-0.6643755436,
0.7247031927,
0.5390086174,
-0.8468830585,
0.5401368141,
-0.5605140328,
0.1294294,
0.6534132361,
0.272937566,
-0.4849072993,
-0.439080447,
-0.4875871837,
-1.0851922035,
0.4268242419,
0.1123272777,
-0.0730158985,
-0.3074244261,
-0.1901756376,
-0.1826887578,
0.2093152553,
-0.6571374536,
-0.2989909053,
0.2936308384,
-0.1909312755,
-0.1516886055,
-0.2096481621,
-0.7456915975,
0.430921942,
0.5497151017,
-0.1557336301,
0.0901074335,
-0.2733061314,
-0.0004448436,
-0.1754493117,
0.4485335648,
0.597157836,
0.4033327103,
-0.3080359995,
0.5988325477,
0.3039598465,
-0.2823637128,
-0.0029433793,
0.0672067329,
-0.0693109632,
-0.4732162058,
0.617636919,
0.452496469,
0.4933991432,
-1.0124071836,
0.5687503815,
-0.0632074252,
-0.0258766543,
-0.1802652478,
0.3750481904,
-0.173154369,
0.2065477371,
0.0908368677,
0.310177505,
-0.1012724414,
-0.6823844314,
0.2857035995,
0.6189434528,
-0.4026919305,
-0.1756825149,
0.4123646617,
0.5290483236,
-0.2957897186,
-0.0507557951,
-0.0982410312,
-0.4984203577,
0.6888972521,
0.5247962475,
1.2157350779,
-0.1129812151,
-0.1252862066,
0.2058135569,
0.6250605583,
-0.3135958612,
-0.1287752986,
0.6181080937,
-0.7106854916,
-0.0799744576,
-0.5583729148,
-0.5367051959,
0.3086893559,
-0.62409091,
0.1096505001,
-0.6578859091,
-0.1280789375,
0.1959775239,
-0.1494106501,
-0.2365522832,
0.0781939104,
0.2805144191,
1.1598045826,
-0.8157731295,
0.6321440339,
0.6955236197,
-0.0650114194,
-0.6241074204,
0.2179720849,
0.4355257154,
-0.8117637634,
0.6266320944,
0.3434987068,
-0.1792598814,
-0.4120180607,
-0.3409858346,
-0.7376260757,
1.0424866676,
0.3107306063,
-0.6508473158,
0.2112377882,
-0.041830644,
0.4774281681,
-0.2957711816,
0.0170104932,
0.6156579256,
0.3759715557,
-0.1159824282,
-1.1021043062,
0.1224771738,
-0.0770439655,
-0.0380790681,
0.462112397,
-0.6104972959,
0.8618227839,
-0.1158840954,
-0.4447163939,
-0.0254244134,
0.2238165885,
0.0970929861,
0.2943172455,
0.600922823,
0.4725905657,
0.8424935937,
-0.18986848,
1.2375967503,
-0.475137949,
0.2834779024,
1.270819068,
-0.545648098,
1.1178267002,
0.2234642804,
-0.2582288682,
0.0214871429,
0.3052224219,
0.0334248058,
0.6524752975,
0.2372788191,
-0.2736341655,
-0.4050807059,
-0.2354343832,
-0.413713932,
0.4497865438,
0.3108173013,
-0.4370045066,
-0.3726835251,
-0.2206673026,
0.2451720834,
0.3085610867,
-0.407040596,
0.836470902,
0.0870857835,
-0.7611827254,
0.7206290364,
-0.275822401,
0.8351364732,
-0.5069715381,
0.4271282554,
0.1145595834,
0.647924006,
-0.0507184826,
-1.0712503195,
0.3704899549,
0.3091166019,
0.0238138381,
-0.0698390752,
0.4976535141,
-0.2382325232,
-0.2451711446,
0.710891664,
0.1010912955,
-0.137047857,
0.105767332,
-0.6688321829,
0.3723071218,
-0.1866577566,
0.0740975216,
0.7035039663,
0.3325092196,
-0.0552273914,
1.0262002945,
0.6342266798,
-0.0104737272,
-0.0111548416,
-0.0174650289,
0.8770017028,
-0.623073101,
-0.2920095921,
-0.9781566858,
0.2955731153,
-0.0221730545,
-0.4078379571,
0.9785152674,
0.3694557846,
0.6764835119,
0.0856681913,
0.8327443004,
0.106448777,
0.3519597948,
-0.5063203573,
0.937390089,
-0.3395297825,
0.3777877986,
-0.3712368309,
-0.6301903129,
-0.7193006277,
0.3329071701,
-0.489636451,
-0.3036465049,
0.6913319826,
0.8474982381,
0.3770988286,
-0.072144933,
0.4907158315,
0.3277425468,
0.5068878531,
0.5606580973,
0.9210523963,
-0.279895246,
0.9508726597,
-0.163117215,
-0.3789218962,
-0.4749330878,
-1.0861434937,
-1.1878499985,
-0.1666051149,
-0.5178370476,
-0.3756867647,
0.2149475515,
1.0767328739,
0.6612148881,
-0.8319131136,
-0.1435661465,
-0.2909601033,
0.0438889712,
-0.180250302,
-0.2059770823,
0.1891126782,
-0.486402601,
-0.6135716438,
0.5439075828,
0.4824365079,
0.1880483627,
-0.2320766747,
0.0600179546,
-0.1782070547,
-0.0916547999,
0.5111045837,
0.2400183231,
-0.6084107757,
-0.6882216334,
-0.1670186967,
-0.5417847633,
-0.3436107934,
0.2685655355,
-0.1641618758,
0.2627302408,
0.5157581568,
0.8796139956,
-0.314334631,
-0.3507555127,
0.6791538,
-0.670220077,
0.0423321985,
0.3902213275,
0.5076698661,
0.3213833272,
-0.2145355642,
0.7331543565,
-0.1685575545,
-0.7386956215,
-1.1663805246,
0.248665452,
-1.1444437504,
-0.0452995338,
1.5320471525,
-0.486110121,
-0.3305987716,
-0.1115090698,
0.1960483789,
0.053622853,
-0.4820467234,
0.9344391227,
0.3292551339,
0.4383870363,
0.0723314807,
-0.5536255836,
0.5181400776,
0.1584824622,
-1.1453590393,
0.5387636423,
0.1986285299,
0.195199132,
0.4491904378,
0.0989184901,
-0.0963583738,
0.3612933159,
0.099969022,
0.1304158866,
0.0699095875,
-0.4320123792,
-0.3251471817,
0.2090406865,
0.0701663867,
-0.3715194762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04645v1
|
HyperTTS: Parameter Efficient Adaptation in Text to Speech using Hypernetworks
| 2024-04-06T14:34:46 | 2024-04-06T14:34:46 |
Yingting Li, Rishabh Bhardwaj, Ambuj Mehrish, Bo Cheng, Soujanya Poria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Neural speech synthesis, or text-to-speech (TTS), aims to transform a signal
from the text domain to the speech domain. While developing TTS architectures
that train and test on the same set of speakers has seen significant
improvements, out-of-domain speaker performance still faces enormous
limitations. Domain adaptation on a new set of speakers can be achieved by
fine-tuning the whole model for each new domain, thus making it
parameter-inefficient. This problem can be solved by Adapters that provide a
parameter-efficient alternative to domain adaptation. Although famous in NLP,
speech synthesis has not seen much improvement from Adapters. In this work, we
present HyperTTS, which comprises a small learnable network, "hypernetwork",
that generates parameters of the Adapter blocks, allowing us to condition
Adapters on speaker representations and making them dynamic. Extensive
evaluations of two domain adaptation settings demonstrate its effectiveness in
achieving state-of-the-art performance in the parameter-efficient regime. We
also compare different variants of HyperTTS, comparing them with baselines in
different studies. Promising results on the dynamic adaptation of adapter
parameters using hypernetworks open up new avenues for domain-generic
multi-speaker TTS systems. The audio samples and code are available at
https://github.com/declare-lab/HyperTTS.
|
[
-0.3016344011,
-0.6942324042,
0.4300101399,
0.2684630752,
-0.3697729707,
0.0270356592,
-0.5559427142,
-0.1377842426,
0.3220370412,
0.2469294071,
-0.4142181873,
-0.2430709302,
-0.539855063,
0.186463967,
-0.5409679413,
0.8123096228,
0.3522318602,
-0.2734609842,
0.1760080159,
-0.2184617668,
-0.3679152727,
-0.3889959753,
-0.6787469387,
-0.417008847,
0.471276015,
0.3109223843,
0.6129148602,
0.7673047185,
0.2337236702,
0.3352696896,
-0.1941877007,
0.3308468163,
-0.4784876108,
0.4470095932,
-0.2942681909,
-0.2047484666,
-0.3540795445,
-0.3044878542,
1.0042042732,
0.4758944809,
-0.0780034363,
0.193567276,
0.2159336358,
0.6188099384,
-0.4358831942,
0.1066427305,
-0.8736394644,
0.086187914,
-0.213687554,
-0.6115436554,
-0.6025343537,
-0.2941587567,
0.3702019155,
-0.7468946576,
-0.0375157036,
0.1286545247,
0.4937673807,
0.2813472748,
-0.2041080892,
0.0705326572,
-1.0213778019,
0.6516246796,
-0.6289229989,
0.8319074512,
0.0774900094,
0.4879441261,
-0.3846739829,
-1.0818927288,
-0.5635185242,
-0.162781775,
0.1789463758,
0.1526056826,
-0.4418467581,
0.1297072619,
0.1269493848,
-0.1174656004,
-0.6765912175,
0.1352674365,
-0.0312060546,
-0.1541668475,
0.0755906254,
-0.0278012715,
0.1367410868,
-0.1093011424,
-0.2264980972,
-0.1921082884,
-0.5689448714,
-0.3736496866,
0.2272184789,
0.761980772,
-0.0750204101,
0.2151492536,
-0.0760363042,
0.895947516,
0.080216527,
0.0808802545,
0.1543063223,
-0.0848577097,
-0.2801198661,
0.1594911963,
0.6288360357,
0.0625863448,
0.4175387621,
-0.280293107,
-0.0605795234,
-0.4763935208,
0.1963518113,
-0.788500011,
-0.1457930654,
0.0705911294,
-0.3538017869,
-0.0993888378,
-0.4672889709,
-0.7715803385,
-0.3589548469,
-0.4680411518,
0.5729538798,
-0.2660275102,
-0.1704765409,
0.095241189,
-0.4250070453,
-0.2577831447,
0.2361759692,
-0.9062687755,
0.5200298429,
0.2896290123,
1.0613105297,
-0.3967882097,
-0.5187697411,
-0.6930799484,
0.5009820461,
-0.2596981227,
0.6633728147,
-0.3467207551,
-0.2510781288,
-0.1091121957,
-0.3078792393,
-0.1964092255,
-0.7080532312,
0.2546847761,
-0.3566466868,
-0.0918665081,
-0.030560432,
-0.3488087654,
0.2051847875,
0.0135045387,
-0.5841166973,
0.8739805818,
0.0179093108,
-0.4227417409,
-0.063088201,
-0.9498099089,
-0.4321837127,
0.1499195397,
-0.0163753182,
-0.4112187922,
0.130187422,
0.0134718027,
0.3125886023,
-0.584657371,
0.1591281444,
-0.1005554125,
-0.5198800564,
0.3673619032,
-0.5767856836,
0.4425267279,
0.1656909883,
-0.4159302115,
0.2218959183,
-0.8505779505,
0.3273697793,
-0.051590506,
-0.4484966397,
-0.2681534588,
0.2137629837,
0.4468792975,
0.0782009214,
-0.2257870138,
-0.318975687,
-0.2295316905,
-0.563290894,
0.7410745621,
0.7423757315,
0.0079712551,
0.0856466368,
-0.1971506476,
0.1261254996,
-0.0584856197,
0.073619999,
0.1292188615,
-0.4632347524,
-0.6913826466,
-0.2566581368,
0.5661463141,
0.284275949,
-1.059252739,
0.3441725373,
-0.3206082284,
-0.5302004814,
-0.1084136739,
-0.1716905981,
0.3516075909,
0.4627188444,
0.4623021781,
-0.0559637845,
-0.696726799,
-0.8156495094,
-0.5430858135,
-0.3055782616,
-0.070701316,
0.0096284095,
0.2722931802,
0.0725718439,
0.9054747224,
-0.3828554451,
-0.0782574639,
-0.1608897746,
-0.0358346291,
0.0581202507,
0.5759424567,
0.6432362199,
-0.7178541422,
-0.4563741386,
0.1076270491,
-0.3301525414,
0.0858103111,
-0.0856167078,
-0.1972696185,
-0.2379809767,
0.5821701884,
-0.2541168034,
0.253704071,
0.7463828921,
-0.060352657,
0.6626495123,
-0.2477406561,
-0.1642185748,
-1.1449205875,
0.0630747303,
0.2250363678,
-0.4848176539,
-0.8356946707,
-0.2917036712,
-0.2773851454,
-0.4565237164,
-0.5556119084,
0.5445557237,
-0.2127185166,
-0.1632768959,
-0.4241887927,
0.3120676577,
-0.1872650087,
0.6566434503,
-0.1485377252,
0.9769228101,
0.6030709743,
-0.6424686313,
0.6394149065,
0.4061081707,
-0.1357220113,
0.5031456351,
-0.6474020481,
0.4721985757,
0.2674384713,
0.3357798457,
-0.7387569547,
0.0159254689,
0.1650761217,
-0.4130229056,
-0.0218908861,
-0.3259941339,
-0.5005533099,
-0.0886057168,
-0.0395712741,
0.400152117,
0.4336318076,
-0.7323023677,
0.6324095726,
0.3784635365,
-0.3897418082,
-0.0874183029,
-0.7683421373,
0.3999916911,
-0.1153882891,
-0.1879695803,
0.5936335921,
-0.134240672,
0.138592869,
0.0258681383,
-0.0675785467,
-0.379824996,
-0.2290158719,
-0.0203307103,
-0.2117168158,
-0.4190107286,
0.2443650663,
0.320938319,
-0.2058937103,
-0.0748516992,
-0.8795135617,
0.4695550501,
-0.0278752632,
-0.2358329743,
-0.9228873849,
0.4685905278,
0.8204610348,
-0.1606278121,
0.3725413084,
0.4924471676,
-0.4503701925,
-0.5542004704,
-0.1573499441,
-0.1912777424,
-0.5608454943,
0.7236517072,
-0.4324823618,
-0.7928781509,
0.1605363637,
-0.4801302552,
-0.1854624003,
0.2549472153,
0.6825190783,
0.0578501001,
0.8194184899,
0.4517102838,
0.0366161577,
0.804762423,
-0.0448587909,
0.0018162954,
-0.7925033569,
0.1190961599,
-0.8055179119,
-0.4586479068,
-0.7471964359,
-0.2342225164,
0.7876843214,
-0.6950913072,
-0.3253231347,
0.5567294359,
-0.5753477812,
0.3201314807,
0.8238085508,
0.3262186348,
0.0250092838,
0.148332417,
-0.0339352228,
0.0109144533,
-0.8631083369,
-0.2865733504,
0.7977372408,
0.1771256328,
0.3306637704,
0.1874979138,
0.5635663867,
0.4409421682,
-0.1795567125,
-0.8009719253,
0.5901579261,
-0.433244884,
-0.4192855954,
-0.6189558506,
-0.5418230891,
-0.9714612961,
0.0881856829,
-0.3773501217,
-0.8127838373,
0.3544040918,
0.2946974337,
-0.4787468016,
0.3031541407,
-0.7872501016,
0.4152660072,
0.1588094085,
-0.3023388088,
-0.3371497095,
-0.6789911985,
-0.448870033,
-0.197924301,
-0.1571489871,
0.0248091295,
0.3268738985,
1.2187681198,
-0.0374212861,
0.7973735929,
-0.4111033678,
0.3233611286,
0.1963110715,
0.1048384979,
0.4306806028,
0.0551089421,
-0.4760627747,
-0.1912674606,
-0.0408722796,
-0.3134914041,
-0.904784739,
0.7391473651,
-0.6734181046,
-0.4539432526,
0.0017948095,
-0.8717802167,
-0.7681587338,
0.4491312802,
-0.0610063933,
1.0346359015,
-0.2870097756,
0.4397595823,
0.7288991809,
-0.1796849519,
0.6171956062,
0.1295114756,
0.0587533936,
-0.5215207338,
1.1196641922,
0.1039931476,
0.295011729,
0.4256267548,
0.4945821166,
-0.2209442109,
-1.0456475019,
-0.6923657656,
0.1334653944,
-0.4903375208,
-0.1220151335,
-0.0682548136,
-0.2402491271,
-0.2211125046,
0.0879476815,
-0.5730352402,
-0.5183836222,
-0.3176318109,
0.0786716491,
0.3643073738,
0.5860159993,
0.1041674316,
0.5792593956,
-0.7339168787,
0.5333566666,
0.5841914415,
0.583378315,
-0.1165908799,
-0.7650805712,
-0.6641852856,
-0.0542710721,
-0.2943150401,
-0.7747460604,
0.1764260381,
0.4240095615,
0.443787992,
0.0112749906,
0.09631221,
0.6151227951,
-0.6908219457,
0.5195792913,
0.2869283557,
-1.1445217133,
0.3564708233,
-0.4178175032,
0.3197160661,
0.4302483499,
0.0663123727,
-0.616848886,
-0.2290676683,
-0.3796994388,
-0.6284861565,
0.7569618821,
0.70753479,
0.230452165,
0.4169256389,
0.5488018394,
-0.1746998131,
0.0301588625,
-0.2847769856,
-0.3404951692,
-0.3351374567,
-0.4485864043,
-0.0831121653,
0.0067281835,
-0.2774707675,
-0.3290712535,
0.7512343526,
-0.3376394808,
0.5903478861,
0.0214294121,
0.0352128148,
-0.0908327252,
0.2065562755,
0.7255917192,
0.7107474804,
-0.1770279706,
0.3077250719,
0.3151510358,
-0.5127235651,
0.2299515009,
0.1717000455,
0.2248579264,
0.2749628127,
0.1716690063,
1.1613174677,
0.0790971294,
-0.3435819447,
0.3663394749,
-0.1349010468,
-0.2176274806,
0.1000331491,
0.0793482289,
0.0844038948,
0.2312229872,
0.3193584979,
0.3338285387,
0.0920687169,
-0.4599663615,
0.3205567896,
-0.0850000009,
-0.5251317024,
-0.4255080819,
0.6016300917,
0.5428575277,
-0.8390949965,
0.3608991504,
0.017085636,
-0.2031988502,
0.3383705914,
0.899331212,
1.0820316076,
-0.3725042045,
0.0463442132,
-0.1136193946,
0.082977511,
0.144297421,
0.1866974682,
0.0723638311,
-0.5196694732,
-0.4309867322,
-0.3577265441,
-0.71234411,
-0.0256222747,
-0.4404161274,
0.2281270921,
-0.4848409891,
-0.4450468719,
0.2351877242,
-0.4714393318,
-0.246017307,
0.5070141554,
-0.090454042,
0.8563088775,
-0.644017458,
1.0602664948,
0.6400739551,
0.2245502025,
-0.5913621783,
0.4280248284,
-0.1400635093,
-0.5410679579,
0.442114681,
-0.4983670115,
-0.5451292992,
0.458994627,
-0.2106377184,
-0.7860347033,
0.7192310095,
0.7240076065,
-0.5644237399,
-0.0654363781,
0.2944381237,
0.5481407046,
0.0047083776,
0.1397556961,
0.4892459214,
0.573137641,
-0.178233549,
-1.0782673359,
0.0756871775,
-0.1871963292,
0.2535299957,
0.0938206241,
-0.5327219963,
0.359528929,
0.322893858,
0.260736078,
0.0087597566,
0.8665973544,
0.1344486028,
0.1558960229,
0.720967412,
0.0133288829,
0.5718836188,
-0.1479872912,
0.5688892007,
-0.2184324712,
0.3231664598,
0.9819412231,
-0.0431424268,
0.8426918983,
0.5840005279,
-0.1750726551,
0.4172612429,
0.1075584888,
0.4274904728,
0.5744100213,
0.4204574823,
-0.1694149226,
-0.1292963922,
0.0138905505,
-0.3202916384,
0.673660934,
0.292583555,
-0.1362839788,
-0.0482478738,
0.1353731453,
-0.1822469383,
0.0258449987,
-0.0063352729,
0.6497758627,
0.036690522,
-0.3101148903,
0.8271254897,
-0.0518174954,
0.3401738703,
-0.7783600092,
0.0508577079,
0.1696574241,
0.1124611646,
-0.0356473774,
-0.5499386191,
0.3637646735,
-0.0611590259,
-0.3333521783,
-0.2902979553,
0.5874342918,
-0.2080651671,
-0.0420921296,
0.2435075641,
0.5939729214,
-0.1439773589,
-0.1599546522,
-0.6907765269,
0.1502619237,
-0.0912382305,
-0.2940481901,
0.3235303462,
0.5428925157,
0.108699508,
0.472854197,
0.6570618749,
0.376580745,
0.0145804873,
0.327847898,
0.8551458716,
-0.6933414936,
-0.6210329533,
-0.654292047,
0.1680078954,
-0.0872661918,
-0.5960489511,
0.577082932,
0.6111441255,
0.6132684946,
-0.0412683152,
0.8671684861,
0.2993699312,
0.588348031,
-0.5623935461,
0.8308731318,
-0.4880343676,
-0.0612423234,
-0.5280426741,
-0.7881564498,
-0.4144161642,
0.108256489,
0.078595154,
0.0622694232,
0.9165596366,
0.8011262417,
-0.1342918426,
0.1438214034,
0.5546075702,
0.2852556407,
0.3930489719,
0.2328011543,
0.7988854647,
-0.3690220416,
0.7329990268,
0.0023908592,
-0.2392455637,
-0.2054402232,
-0.7725351453,
-0.4769437611,
-0.9141873121,
-0.4406109452,
-0.2342199087,
0.7117210627,
1.0342000723,
1.0783567429,
-0.7207444906,
-0.6356837153,
-0.045410946,
0.0366916806,
-0.4765208662,
-0.1011566967,
0.5359328389,
-0.1162234172,
-0.9310323,
0.8992166519,
0.4090985954,
0.0021661851,
0.1375626475,
-0.0533616804,
-0.0244854186,
0.4180473983,
0.6255931258,
0.2868460417,
-0.2788624465,
-0.4020892084,
-0.2279654592,
0.1360336244,
0.0761354119,
0.8958464861,
-0.5674632192,
0.54259938,
0.4679186642,
0.873857677,
0.576333046,
-0.2905162573,
0.5810855031,
-0.8506031036,
0.1272725165,
0.2952979207,
0.2471031994,
0.1898930967,
0.0294695515,
-0.0686954632,
0.4149777591,
-0.5444459319,
-0.9166305661,
0.2161553949,
-1.1146196127,
-0.2587472796,
1.2755235434,
0.0713660344,
-0.1558641195,
-0.2861249745,
-0.2030022591,
0.6786826253,
-0.3425643146,
0.5865349174,
0.1822051704,
-0.2589266896,
0.2292742282,
-0.4236582518,
0.4836448729,
0.5597950816,
-0.8351698518,
0.1974567622,
0.0393255837,
0.1376580894,
-0.0172558688,
0.4292285144,
0.2050365061,
0.2925013006,
-0.1408410519,
-0.0822999403,
-0.1951806247,
-0.5608151555,
-0.1743393391,
0.1676562577,
0.1185227334,
-0.5734052062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04633v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04633v3
|
Context versus Prior Knowledge in Language Models
| 2024-04-06T13:46:53 | 2024-06-16T12:05:34 |
Kevin Du, Vésteinn Snæbjarnarson, Niklas Stoehr, Jennifer C. White, Aaron Schein, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To answer a question, language models often need to integrate prior knowledge
learned during pretraining and new information presented in context. We
hypothesize that models perform this integration in a predictable way across
different questions and contexts: models will rely more on prior knowledge for
questions about entities (e.g., persons, places, etc.) that they are more
familiar with due to higher exposure in the training corpus, and be more easily
persuaded by some contexts than others. To formalize this problem, we propose
two mutual information-based metrics to measure a model's dependency on a
context and on its prior about an entity: first, the persuasion score of a
given context represents how much a model depends on the context in its
decision, and second, the susceptibility score of a given entity represents how
much the model can be swayed away from its original answer distribution about
an entity. We empirically test our metrics for their validity and reliability.
Finally, we explore and find a relationship between the scores and the model's
expected familiarity with an entity, and provide two use cases to illustrate
their benefits.
|
[
-0.5718836784,
-0.7857357264,
0.894423902,
0.1290467232,
0.0734225363,
-0.5895538926,
-0.348033756,
-0.5596576333,
-0.0465307906,
0.4125100374,
-0.1768617481,
-0.2957615554,
-0.6114435196,
-0.3558450937,
-0.2763471007,
0.9165143371,
-0.0969428569,
0.1136299819,
-0.7362956405,
-0.2827578485,
-0.7044097185,
-0.8950787187,
-0.3499849737,
-0.3082644045,
0.5544880033,
0.1292417645,
0.562322557,
0.1513296813,
0.414316237,
0.284817338,
0.0794135407,
-0.5281959772,
-0.2394883633,
0.2582066953,
-0.7439519763,
-0.7538608313,
-0.252389729,
0.2808566689,
0.5549715757,
0.961691618,
-0.0906921104,
0.2556146979,
0.1435323507,
0.2915632129,
-0.9724712968,
0.0614362359,
-0.7202310562,
-0.2307558954,
-0.1504397839,
-0.236422345,
-0.3153202236,
-0.104170233,
0.6328065395,
-0.6031016707,
-0.0623777695,
-0.1287044436,
0.9975258708,
0.207946375,
-0.6430707574,
-0.3537124991,
-0.897864759,
0.7430877686,
-0.5810236335,
0.6582209468,
0.5349867344,
0.3190591037,
0.144267112,
-0.7494972944,
-0.5402100086,
-0.4436169863,
-0.3979214728,
0.069734849,
-0.1809079498,
-0.2818710208,
0.310225457,
0.1608103812,
-0.3069050014,
-0.0368399248,
-0.242953524,
-0.2132368684,
0.2920362353,
-0.0210972503,
0.1972196698,
-0.1082715392,
-0.4406028092,
-0.0226230137,
-0.8639364243,
0.1376216412,
0.2312797159,
0.1148332655,
-0.0327398442,
0.3153513074,
-0.2571627498,
0.7163739204,
0.1220322326,
0.0766102299,
0.1141146496,
-0.4543787241,
-0.0143514778,
-0.0225349087,
0.6542171836,
0.3509558141,
0.3779011071,
0.0158930812,
-0.1854675263,
0.0376825631,
0.0687504262,
-0.7029607296,
-0.0165025275,
-0.0710380971,
-0.3806167841,
0.2348531783,
0.18552351,
-0.2556376755,
-0.031787388,
-0.424397558,
0.6651066542,
-0.4418336153,
-0.6649429798,
-0.2111204118,
-0.1117195114,
0.1966281682,
0.4040344059,
-0.918217063,
0.2704218328,
0.6607800722,
0.6245653033,
-0.0749051496,
-0.3969925642,
-0.4608509839,
0.1249241158,
-0.2669245303,
0.8186760545,
-0.6441153288,
-0.2567275763,
-0.0230546426,
0.0151058091,
-0.1864863783,
-0.3111878037,
0.2172813267,
-0.7070707679,
0.5200752616,
-0.5884584785,
-0.8777636886,
-0.2719932497,
0.2188612968,
-0.5547528267,
0.8213359118,
0.2756640017,
-1.0094995499,
0.7382413149,
-0.2822090685,
-0.3756025732,
-0.0617476963,
-0.2910107076,
0.2702869475,
0.230719164,
-0.0900797173,
0.596124649,
-0.2877511084,
0.4738899469,
-0.3750346899,
-0.1643248945,
0.4455232918,
-0.2582210004,
0.4975907505,
0.2178443074,
-0.0474224575,
-0.1960887164,
-0.5422902703,
-0.1526327282,
-0.0414406098,
-0.3285190165,
-0.955534935,
0.1636305153,
-0.3034079373,
0.2638109326,
0.4005641937,
-0.2083967775,
-0.1505428851,
-0.4112140536,
0.1359167695,
0.6382710338,
0.2127715498,
0.8177200556,
-0.4136643112,
0.3267916143,
0.2165921479,
-0.1329731196,
-0.1280570179,
-0.4716099501,
-0.4822776616,
0.2465922087,
0.3597427607,
0.4138192534,
-0.2703199983,
0.3241305351,
-0.3462987542,
-0.4472609162,
-0.1890810579,
-0.0361762121,
0.1976501197,
0.8560969234,
0.2763129175,
-0.5480108261,
-0.559828341,
-0.7456343174,
-0.455400914,
-0.5608953238,
-0.0751514658,
0.4905660748,
0.6207367182,
0.1436320394,
1.1712058783,
-0.496781826,
-0.1021184176,
-0.2430296987,
-0.1668934226,
0.1977642328,
0.5672043562,
0.758908689,
-0.8072668314,
-0.5046032667,
-0.0717900768,
-0.5480017066,
0.0424469002,
0.1472241431,
-0.0158836395,
-0.0529732294,
0.4958352447,
-0.4702804685,
0.3207577169,
0.4628246427,
-0.3340711594,
0.6968800426,
-0.0215108916,
0.3352950811,
-1.1313124895,
0.2315934598,
0.0849877521,
-0.1204018891,
-0.8079181314,
-0.0776522383,
-0.187867865,
0.3577267826,
-0.5661349297,
0.8696912527,
-0.2573516369,
-0.1235080063,
0.0464224108,
0.2225593179,
0.0621157624,
0.3841976523,
0.3990365863,
0.6843276024,
0.5484910607,
-0.9936603308,
0.0776097551,
0.0628989935,
-0.6122842431,
0.8782065511,
-0.762229383,
0.1640821099,
-0.0794709921,
0.0478013791,
-0.8786365986,
-0.2066206187,
0.1738865227,
-0.6387649775,
0.0891181678,
-0.2624197304,
-0.155310303,
0.1580474675,
0.3870163262,
0.4279171228,
0.4136277735,
-0.2871440649,
0.5306236744,
0.4405841231,
-0.258459121,
-0.4713371992,
-0.7259292006,
-0.5137965679,
-0.4163991809,
-0.5937442183,
0.3177371025,
-0.0727168769,
-0.5460231304,
0.352005899,
-0.088065654,
-0.3755725622,
0.2343722582,
0.2741692662,
0.0061660344,
-0.6125116348,
0.3695099354,
-0.1276058257,
-0.135553509,
0.2655734718,
-0.3401987553,
0.4620421827,
-0.1717896312,
-0.6210108995,
-0.1795486808,
0.4036410749,
0.3300825655,
-0.1769895852,
1.0476769209,
0.257720381,
-0.4867734909,
0.1854205728,
-0.7284448147,
-0.3809527159,
-0.3772887886,
0.4081460834,
-0.6624190807,
-0.8470155001,
0.6516883373,
-0.130378142,
-0.2482352704,
0.5169156194,
0.568102181,
-0.1581335366,
1.0009123087,
0.6245241165,
-0.1933583766,
0.696192801,
0.0460471064,
-0.0920261145,
-0.654935658,
-0.1011882275,
-0.661167562,
0.0134918354,
-0.2198059857,
-0.0084066605,
0.0161914807,
0.5804659724,
-0.1253309697,
0.4262894988,
-0.0561696552,
0.3703320622,
0.6806332469,
-0.0721141472,
0.2789002061,
-0.2217098475,
-0.3333956599,
-0.111182861,
-0.6352423429,
-0.4870702624,
1.1049488783,
0.2941544354,
0.4015767574,
0.2442640513,
0.3911710978,
-0.159689486,
0.5184608102,
-0.5391939878,
0.3598611355,
0.2570986748,
-0.9234932065,
-0.3276981413,
-0.3604860604,
-0.8544138074,
0.2851935923,
-0.2767383158,
-0.9640258551,
0.1567646712,
0.2055878341,
-0.1675347686,
-0.0640171096,
-0.785556972,
1.0165827274,
-0.0651370138,
-0.3153333664,
-0.2378069013,
-0.5131781101,
0.2443985492,
-0.040365655,
0.3437365294,
-0.0371452682,
0.2454924434,
0.905818522,
-0.461298883,
0.6714221835,
-0.2253716439,
0.0140643753,
0.3401944041,
0.1009610966,
0.3494994044,
0.082368508,
-0.1018455699,
0.095899269,
0.4204900563,
-0.1752862781,
-0.9782722592,
0.5450792313,
-0.5608743429,
-0.8940896988,
-0.2473451644,
-0.2474513352,
-0.3449965715,
0.2746794224,
0.3786269426,
0.3830781579,
-0.4326301813,
0.199826017,
0.5694422722,
-0.0171578061,
0.0514498241,
0.9751247168,
-0.2088570893,
-0.0184278004,
0.5631675124,
0.218364507,
0.5750510693,
0.4825680256,
0.397601366,
-0.4231848121,
-0.2843088508,
0.0271562431,
0.1089412197,
-0.9558682442,
0.1123488694,
-0.4064090848,
-0.2622530758,
-0.4240728021,
-0.0007465741,
-0.2222518623,
-0.2007090002,
-0.2606387138,
-0.2099125087,
0.1910090744,
0.7324871421,
-0.2018899769,
0.3255209029,
-0.6180542111,
-0.3661239445,
0.2897544503,
0.311429441,
-0.0456259213,
-0.646402359,
-0.272382915,
0.0888240784,
0.0275550932,
-1.3001502752,
-0.1204863861,
0.0181988887,
0.9328250885,
0.5888374448,
-0.0905857831,
0.4327915311,
-0.5009519458,
0.7232672572,
0.1982268095,
-0.9424862266,
0.6852630973,
-0.0218754914,
0.262511462,
0.7722868919,
0.7748299837,
-0.7116461992,
-0.6336910725,
-0.7016597986,
-0.3414765596,
0.4994966388,
-0.2077594697,
0.2138254046,
-0.0338396281,
0.3726108074,
0.1211859211,
0.1179878265,
-0.7189974189,
-0.2389495522,
-0.0912674442,
-0.032086689,
-0.2970845997,
-0.3486793637,
-0.0242838953,
-0.2146160007,
0.4086447954,
0.1162040904,
-0.044890482,
0.1037552133,
-0.4992805123,
0.2199224979,
0.2894381881,
0.5103419423,
0.8299225569,
-0.1762284189,
0.2898870409,
0.3713251352,
-0.3544985056,
0.0732990876,
-0.2589287162,
-0.260581553,
0.0600859821,
0.705722034,
0.8747371435,
0.4026232958,
-0.1814757437,
0.8002414703,
0.0927550271,
-0.1365896463,
-0.180047825,
0.1202397197,
0.224213317,
0.0240438506,
0.0966346562,
0.2304472625,
0.053706713,
-0.5900385976,
0.4860886633,
0.4301549792,
-0.7026206255,
-0.555105865,
0.4310183823,
-0.0235867184,
-0.1481206119,
0.1772177219,
0.005781047,
-0.5377858281,
0.4130416512,
0.5161884427,
0.3537969887,
-0.6342791319,
0.0677505136,
0.5424711704,
0.1151959822,
-0.1759843975,
0.0002708153,
-0.3213218749,
-1.0618699789,
-0.3635186851,
-0.4143459797,
-0.2116701901,
0.1161554381,
-0.7404546738,
0.20663625,
-0.304350853,
-0.3476281762,
-0.071427457,
-0.1169769689,
-1.0478026867,
0.3410846889,
-0.3258963227,
0.9251939654,
-0.9801845551,
0.7713564038,
0.8173549771,
-0.734174788,
-1.0421488285,
-0.0007438755,
-0.2374875695,
-0.5813722014,
0.9154368043,
0.1023143306,
0.105621554,
-0.0936677977,
-0.2095837146,
-1.1657446623,
0.9552161694,
0.3472910821,
-0.5190342665,
0.0927926153,
-0.1139350533,
0.4786914587,
-0.5874949098,
0.6026619673,
0.6585008502,
0.3926880956,
0.1604450196,
-0.9754443169,
0.1529901624,
-0.0026559629,
-0.2086678743,
-0.0231256224,
-0.2331210226,
0.7478090525,
-0.1726423502,
-0.4540752769,
-0.2689075172,
0.835932672,
0.1221783012,
0.358276397,
0.8231918812,
0.2775281668,
0.8087969422,
0.0160316732,
0.9398547411,
-0.4237254858,
0.2267025709,
1.3414150476,
-0.2262254059,
1.0669468641,
0.5105388165,
-0.1983023584,
0.778170228,
0.563811481,
0.4828672707,
0.685829401,
0.0814830065,
-0.1172412783,
-0.3167890906,
-0.1718073487,
-0.7473546267,
0.3792794645,
0.41096434,
-0.2402209193,
-0.1099355966,
-0.0436056703,
0.0480435118,
0.1294829994,
0.0059223766,
0.7750146985,
0.2792466581,
-0.9239203334,
0.1438010186,
-0.1003105491,
0.2320204526,
-0.6644159555,
0.2238326222,
-0.2578957677,
-0.1130479127,
-0.0559213758,
-0.7917113304,
0.4473572075,
-0.3144173026,
-0.3765029609,
0.0423747674,
0.7614625096,
-0.4153905809,
-0.1059358418,
0.3727433085,
0.8066106439,
0.2367475927,
-0.1356139779,
-0.5130221844,
-0.1254631281,
-0.4229497015,
-0.399638176,
0.4096072018,
0.4716013968,
-0.0022025139,
0.5798766017,
0.6251268387,
0.2516139448,
-0.1278768331,
0.1800018251,
0.6590268016,
-0.3726083636,
-0.6212772131,
-0.8899123073,
0.426554352,
-0.0619232617,
-0.3531079888,
0.8828696609,
0.2568140328,
0.9666112661,
0.1654387563,
0.7299360037,
0.0580019876,
0.4427042007,
-0.6885140538,
0.6790672541,
-0.6513557434,
0.4125435054,
-0.3514274955,
-1.0589997768,
0.0386114642,
0.7159537077,
-0.80367589,
0.1697224528,
0.8521178961,
0.6104090214,
-0.0757577419,
-0.1541722864,
0.3517411947,
0.0655440614,
0.0416957997,
0.7661918402,
1.2573701143,
-0.0559428893,
0.3173871338,
-0.0054767556,
-0.2743643224,
-0.122221753,
-0.8794472218,
-0.8812673092,
-1.0725516081,
-0.2956469953,
-0.2742716968,
-0.1321650296,
0.547213912,
0.9286501408,
-0.8457279205,
-0.0548012927,
0.0275049657,
0.4627246559,
-0.0692527145,
-0.2400148958,
0.1296596229,
-0.2605621517,
-0.4469313622,
0.1670119464,
0.1446772963,
0.1008823141,
-0.3110983074,
-0.2119418383,
-0.0978549495,
0.1736374497,
0.300781697,
0.2218451053,
-0.627733469,
-0.683424294,
0.0495774671,
-0.3068265021,
-0.1112775505,
0.9129789472,
-0.8387733698,
0.1681579351,
0.6558222771,
0.3097809851,
0.3590121567,
-0.0508702025,
0.833360374,
-0.7156965137,
0.2600558698,
0.0287876409,
0.5647411942,
0.2329926044,
-0.277255863,
0.2305300385,
0.296592474,
-0.3597973287,
-0.6671373248,
0.6546715498,
-0.4615772665,
-0.4305671751,
1.1000692844,
-0.3771110773,
-0.1155164912,
-0.1381305605,
0.1659628004,
-0.0936632454,
-0.1002561003,
0.2162927538,
1.1160613298,
0.2553165853,
0.0134039689,
-0.5003280044,
0.5944598913,
0.5796229243,
-0.491257906,
-0.3142226934,
0.3315084577,
0.6535637379,
0.247522071,
1.0344777107,
0.173809126,
0.2104302794,
0.1857260019,
-0.1436354369,
0.2076882273,
-0.4466110468,
-0.0856788829,
0.2236341387,
0.223185882,
0.0294265468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04631v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04631v1
|
On the Limitations of Large Language Models (LLMs): False Attribution
| 2024-04-06T13:38:15 | 2024-04-06T13:38:15 |
Tosin Adewumi, Nudrat Habib, Lama Alkhaled, Elisa Barney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we provide insight into one important limitation of large
language models (LLMs), i.e. false attribution, and introduce a new
hallucination metric - Simple Hallucination Index (SHI). The task of automatic
author attribution for relatively small chunks of text is an important NLP task
but can be challenging. We empirically evaluate the power of 3 open SotA LLMs
in zero-shot setting (LLaMA-2-13B, Mixtral 8x7B, and Gemma-7B), especially as
human annotation can be costly. We collected the top 10 most popular books,
according to Project Gutenberg, divided each one into equal chunks of 400
words, and asked each LLM to predict the author. We then randomly sampled 162
chunks for human evaluation from each of the annotated books, based on the
error margin of 7% and a confidence level of 95% for the book with the most
chunks (Great Expectations by Charles Dickens, having 922 chunks). The average
results show that Mixtral 8x7B has the highest prediction accuracy, the lowest
SHI, and a Pearson's correlation (r) of 0.737, 0.249, and -0.9996,
respectively, followed by LLaMA-2-13B and Gemma-7B. However, Mixtral 8x7B
suffers from high hallucinations for 3 books, rising as high as an SHI of 0.87
(in the range 0-1, where 1 is the worst). The strong negative correlation of
accuracy and SHI, given by r, demonstrates the fidelity of the new
hallucination metric, which is generalizable to other tasks. We publicly
release the annotated chunks of data and our codes to aid the reproducibility
and evaluation of other models.
|
[
-0.2014328539,
-0.5539028645,
0.9267646074,
0.3235156834,
-0.1828056276,
-0.3940498531,
-0.2361826301,
-0.877522707,
0.3006286621,
0.7458845377,
-0.4591385126,
-0.3566828072,
-0.6979792714,
0.4006534517,
-0.7916277051,
0.9983341098,
0.0536611713,
-0.2887924314,
-0.2338377684,
-0.1070438027,
-0.3211808503,
-0.6529682279,
-0.3097966313,
-0.252143383,
0.893086493,
0.2341752201,
0.7739546895,
0.8800733089,
0.6108551621,
0.222592473,
0.1088573858,
0.1101911068,
-0.5332924724,
0.0348455347,
-0.1219604462,
-0.5597401857,
-0.4521649778,
0.0455416031,
0.6807268858,
0.4529399872,
-0.0387827083,
0.2454859316,
-0.0362204239,
0.6550734639,
-0.6916123033,
-0.1768584102,
-0.805515945,
0.0035886094,
-0.2558451891,
-0.3542519808,
-0.6754135489,
-0.5464730859,
-0.0586659089,
-0.5138671398,
0.1474856734,
0.3856423795,
0.9533554912,
0.5614575148,
-0.1719198078,
-0.6007272601,
-0.6851720214,
1.0663044453,
-0.7608467937,
-0.063854292,
0.6308258772,
0.202003926,
-0.0022131957,
-0.2313488573,
-0.7733351588,
-0.3143087924,
-0.1522563547,
-0.283129096,
-0.2301508635,
-0.3081252575,
0.3888774216,
0.5118374825,
-0.4828137457,
0.2373147905,
-0.3162488639,
-0.1948416084,
0.9270116687,
0.2589805424,
0.3241983056,
-0.5329489112,
-0.3596289158,
0.046754647,
-0.840419054,
-0.5025116205,
0.5522364974,
0.2644017935,
0.068948634,
0.864130795,
0.2376093864,
0.4574225843,
-0.1164103821,
-0.1067928672,
0.240218401,
-0.2694126368,
0.0260207094,
0.2807298601,
0.9320834875,
0.3432098031,
0.4552319348,
-0.1603928357,
-0.3264154792,
0.1040999964,
0.3539151251,
-0.6290150285,
-0.0485596955,
0.1770916581,
-0.3698201478,
-0.2788535953,
0.0340764895,
-0.705904007,
-0.9835838675,
-0.1152509153,
0.7245188951,
-0.3921447098,
-0.1654870957,
0.1561433375,
0.0215377267,
0.2374881953,
0.3260723948,
-0.8550595641,
0.4154946208,
0.5245764256,
1.1024028063,
-0.386570096,
-0.5295933485,
-0.5169783831,
0.2071591169,
-0.5342722535,
0.7963856459,
-0.3411488235,
-0.0192852672,
-0.1246080324,
-0.042802684,
0.114275001,
-0.7815091014,
0.414513588,
-0.1459850669,
0.01032189,
-0.3792207837,
-0.5177898407,
-0.3319754601,
-0.0112346355,
-0.8671071529,
0.9134555459,
0.0190766472,
-0.560593605,
0.1140342802,
-0.3340970278,
-0.3001542687,
-0.068676576,
-0.3484245241,
-0.3443275094,
0.357793808,
0.0241891202,
0.6338313222,
-0.3906828165,
0.3805043995,
-0.1448940635,
-0.7286557555,
0.491691947,
-0.4851445854,
0.8774604797,
-0.0748477131,
-0.5525896549,
0.0394523293,
-0.8813231587,
-0.247151047,
0.2498847097,
-0.0376533158,
-0.4386224747,
0.0073827803,
0.2191787213,
-0.1041078418,
0.1079106405,
-0.444722712,
0.2036857307,
-0.2988185287,
0.1526930779,
0.812466681,
-0.0825570375,
0.0682208017,
-0.6069685817,
0.4381088912,
-0.2451358885,
-0.2389029264,
-0.0720387772,
-0.4547566175,
-0.6342648864,
-0.469627887,
0.3357767165,
0.5103799701,
-0.3243202567,
0.7871744037,
-0.2717590332,
-0.6171175241,
-0.6892021894,
0.0028657201,
0.4098367393,
0.0405916721,
0.2852568328,
-0.3289613724,
-0.5495192409,
-0.8611329794,
-0.389307797,
-0.3278097808,
-0.3862077594,
0.3668968081,
0.7862003446,
-0.1491136253,
0.6039954424,
-0.440715611,
-0.7598041892,
-0.2273678929,
0.1783318967,
0.2413984984,
0.3496493995,
0.3515519202,
-0.4547575414,
-0.5559425354,
-0.1535882652,
-0.9979603291,
-0.1717426181,
-0.4097163975,
0.0797822028,
0.4766573012,
0.2946118414,
-0.616717875,
0.5154284239,
0.5283760428,
-0.4586729109,
0.8716514111,
-0.097804822,
0.0058916816,
-0.7739961147,
0.0353920087,
0.0058851545,
-0.1227341443,
-0.419421941,
-0.0304184966,
0.0660505071,
0.236039266,
-0.4092420638,
0.6494857073,
-0.4814029038,
-0.1028848961,
-0.1277046502,
0.3240916133,
-0.180456683,
0.4959406555,
0.0024664807,
0.5383704305,
0.3195565939,
-0.5542850494,
0.3606327474,
0.2037438899,
-0.7646980286,
0.3020841777,
-0.6088578105,
0.1483528167,
-0.0256992094,
0.1836962402,
-0.9517034292,
-0.3579983115,
0.2383658737,
-0.4070409834,
0.1195176169,
0.4307509065,
-0.7591807842,
-0.0161338653,
-0.4395902753,
0.4039577544,
0.449482888,
-0.519946456,
0.6863932014,
0.1715975255,
-0.0113155423,
-0.5253689289,
-0.9173344374,
0.2061697394,
-0.3185719252,
-0.4012522995,
0.2905220985,
-0.0898052678,
-0.4349800944,
0.1807782948,
-0.0989681035,
0.2008198798,
-0.1620856225,
0.4248003662,
0.3167234659,
-0.150332287,
0.041337721,
-0.3323363364,
-0.1785266399,
0.1379170418,
0.2245113552,
0.4588638246,
-0.2168531269,
-0.5146529675,
-0.5736225247,
0.2743150294,
0.405454278,
0.2866955996,
0.8648319244,
0.582633853,
-0.7431056499,
-0.0853855163,
-0.7953423858,
-0.2345771939,
-0.4332332313,
0.4649251699,
-0.3462109268,
-0.6702538729,
0.7168853879,
0.6256119013,
-0.0719658509,
0.7242566347,
0.723521471,
0.2452808619,
0.7699078321,
0.6883070469,
-0.2952516675,
0.0191403758,
-0.0874677449,
0.4204446077,
-0.8027793169,
-0.1544204205,
-0.5381810069,
-0.3431752324,
-0.6553092599,
-0.3202751279,
0.1041632667,
-0.0036484995,
-0.0056136181,
0.4181507826,
-0.5232778192,
0.7424632907,
0.5173028111,
-0.0141337663,
0.6532083154,
0.1439968795,
0.326009661,
-0.1745294183,
-0.318985939,
-0.7957781553,
1.4046229124,
0.46721223,
0.7556385398,
0.2985621691,
0.6730927825,
0.4564875662,
0.3293770254,
-0.9383776784,
0.7115932703,
-0.0076152682,
-1.0698348284,
-0.6919980049,
-0.413051486,
-0.6183016896,
0.1727744937,
-0.1741887927,
-1.1569561958,
0.1509384811,
-0.0635560527,
-0.6555879712,
0.3667180836,
-0.5481361151,
0.7032340765,
-0.0321772434,
-0.4291201532,
-0.1017173305,
-0.4523214698,
0.4670571983,
-0.5325653553,
0.1024398431,
-0.2856630385,
-0.1623842269,
1.0038708448,
-0.1985402107,
0.8546875715,
0.026965091,
-0.2440411597,
0.3845598102,
0.2253309041,
0.7212949991,
-0.1438033432,
-0.3837617934,
0.3385818005,
0.1570834368,
-0.2937516272,
-0.5496656299,
0.5879511833,
-0.8333839774,
-0.6035927534,
-0.7935020924,
-0.6402388811,
0.0024105536,
0.1474908441,
0.4349961281,
0.3235841691,
-0.0138018858,
0.4235615134,
0.4291716516,
-0.2715177834,
0.2681499124,
0.2877009213,
-0.3516260982,
-0.2423518151,
1.1879695654,
0.2951405644,
0.1910146326,
0.0526362956,
0.3043958843,
-0.2783633769,
-0.6093917489,
-0.2153481394,
0.7559945583,
-0.7199183106,
-0.0676888376,
-0.7114073038,
-0.3876479268,
-0.2324478775,
-0.3521664441,
-0.4443286657,
-0.25438115,
-0.4853527248,
-0.0356336236,
0.2483622879,
0.9908916354,
-0.052639354,
0.414052546,
-0.4565299451,
0.2841578126,
-0.0410219617,
0.2772506177,
0.2661040127,
-0.9365670085,
-0.3731873035,
-0.4036386907,
-0.3290713429,
-0.9078546166,
0.5465424061,
0.0549849309,
0.2602438331,
0.6406410933,
0.3600257635,
0.7863110304,
-0.448559016,
0.8377332687,
0.3489032984,
-0.8524211645,
0.0386654548,
-0.2081399709,
0.0190618765,
0.6026013494,
0.6669220328,
-0.6000560522,
-0.6695480943,
-0.673171699,
-0.8097141981,
0.8106687665,
0.2308497131,
0.1361700296,
0.1134256572,
0.2799966931,
0.5693584085,
0.1938183904,
-1.2269217968,
-0.2338067889,
0.2157727331,
-0.3282194436,
-0.3716766834,
-0.6270126104,
-0.071745649,
-0.4046994746,
0.7278861403,
0.0226609837,
0.4196772575,
0.1563031971,
-0.0650701448,
-0.3521264195,
0.0216035768,
0.5931802392,
0.8270944953,
-0.4571149647,
0.3457103074,
0.1363408566,
-0.525929451,
0.1104511023,
-0.1719365716,
-0.0782364234,
0.0437692553,
0.8550986648,
0.7209474444,
-0.1193521023,
-0.7424747348,
0.5668184161,
0.3259344697,
-0.4643886983,
-0.7596573234,
0.0454091989,
-0.0207483023,
0.3932842016,
0.4769281745,
-0.0653338954,
0.094066523,
-0.6741267443,
0.1048083901,
0.2389797717,
-0.4196901619,
-0.445299089,
0.6358726621,
-0.2347538471,
-0.4164435565,
0.5331340432,
-0.4262425601,
-0.3559158444,
0.3997622728,
0.7123405337,
0.9933578968,
0.0138404621,
0.1084407866,
0.3797124624,
0.5403991938,
-0.3109482825,
0.064851813,
0.3176867068,
-0.6782646179,
-0.3164300323,
-0.8128169775,
-0.2652983367,
0.5414966345,
-0.3840017617,
0.3386856318,
-0.2692585886,
-0.0378812328,
-0.013302342,
0.1397921443,
-0.4300090075,
-0.153635323,
0.0901507959,
0.4643425643,
-1.0693770647,
0.649913609,
0.190334633,
-0.3810998201,
-0.6760235429,
0.2244818211,
0.2206201702,
-0.7552836537,
0.3694419265,
0.4810649753,
-0.0647700727,
0.0386661813,
-0.4975497425,
-0.8707119823,
0.9039634466,
0.3405375481,
-0.6338806748,
-0.301471293,
0.1575071067,
0.4449732006,
-0.5116662979,
0.1681851298,
0.5506083369,
0.6097378135,
0.1309693307,
-0.7601115704,
0.4473926425,
0.0417141765,
-0.1323058456,
0.0580458418,
-0.4429023862,
0.6980490088,
-0.3410767317,
-0.2570198178,
0.2179140151,
0.6548182964,
0.4923885167,
0.4236513674,
0.6375442147,
0.3557526767,
0.8304387927,
0.0686646849,
1.0731929541,
0.0300985295,
0.1628216654,
1.0878962278,
-0.2206851244,
0.9880365133,
0.7676555514,
-0.3138028383,
0.3684526384,
0.6425512433,
-0.2727868557,
0.394282937,
0.4387345016,
-0.0646943152,
-0.0856929794,
-0.1945950687,
-0.2641549706,
0.2038404644,
0.0885380059,
-0.4752088189,
0.2009582072,
-0.0702143013,
0.1442331672,
0.032792788,
-0.0277719274,
0.4439246058,
0.3181136549,
-0.4276077449,
0.7766824365,
-0.0746375248,
0.801832974,
-0.4967836738,
0.1618273407,
0.0032991911,
0.2100125849,
-0.4937338531,
-0.5120781064,
0.5367879272,
0.1305036992,
-0.117945917,
-0.0364375524,
0.5005477667,
-0.255042702,
-0.7560468316,
0.2976433933,
0.355055809,
0.8021005988,
-0.4716879129,
-0.1935352534,
0.3464655876,
0.1353541464,
-0.6283929944,
0.1750107557,
0.6804053187,
0.0304773711,
0.6537511945,
0.3090494275,
0.4999058843,
0.0316642337,
-0.1812608093,
0.4248963594,
-1.0175073147,
-0.1124313176,
-1.2080441713,
0.308177501,
0.1143703014,
-0.2290219665,
1.0161136389,
0.5884796381,
0.688914299,
-0.0000973726,
0.7336730361,
-0.0094474554,
0.4422273338,
-0.4428370893,
0.8307854533,
-1.0116852522,
0.3972063661,
-0.3873622417,
-1.3197009563,
-0.4618228972,
0.7176557183,
-0.4021210968,
-0.1389088184,
1.1508899927,
0.8414856195,
0.1888811886,
0.0203530248,
0.5338272452,
0.3289760947,
0.1422723383,
0.4643750787,
0.7316327691,
-0.4405851364,
0.5166163445,
-0.0504749641,
-0.2839127183,
-0.5531254411,
-0.9895449281,
-0.8644365072,
-0.6655943394,
-0.3846444488,
-0.3341008425,
-0.1020862311,
0.8216242194,
0.3577048779,
-0.7940413952,
-0.4251081645,
0.1254502833,
0.0600929298,
-0.312061429,
-0.2268250436,
0.5840039849,
-0.044001054,
-0.634853363,
0.0496353433,
0.2007889897,
0.0248289499,
-0.6814325452,
-0.0852570161,
-0.1009577513,
0.2706731856,
0.5474517345,
-0.0606004633,
-1.0656223297,
-0.5282331705,
-0.0697168633,
-0.2527925968,
0.0162750613,
0.5609360337,
-0.4628623426,
0.2504265606,
0.1715858579,
0.5984124541,
0.5104291439,
-0.0517829992,
0.4346603155,
-0.394349426,
-0.0682294965,
0.3847048879,
0.0645122305,
0.2946163118,
-0.5105552077,
0.5986171961,
0.3360743225,
-0.6647580862,
-1.2665498257,
0.0770789683,
-0.9518312812,
-0.2488630265,
1.4053964615,
0.1652867198,
-0.4686494172,
-0.071339801,
-0.0142075419,
0.0862087011,
-0.2842348516,
1.083024025,
1.1461155415,
-0.1308058053,
0.0754667222,
-0.9993823767,
0.5540502667,
0.4775328338,
-0.5772399306,
0.4320326149,
0.6495582461,
-0.1229104325,
0.5063221455,
0.8939068317,
-0.1188880801,
-0.1434614658,
0.2607648373,
0.3649858832,
-0.1499940157,
-0.6403338313,
-0.181674391,
0.1552222222,
0.1609336436,
0.0845721588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04626v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04626v1
|
Towards Analyzing and Understanding the Limitations of DPO: A Theoretical Perspective
| 2024-04-06T13:24:37 | 2024-04-06T13:24:37 |
Duanyu Feng, Bowen Qin, Chen Huang, Zheng Zhang, Wenqiang Lei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), which derives reward signals directly
from pairwise preference data, has shown its effectiveness on aligning Large
Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences. Despite its widespread use
across various tasks, DPO has been criticized for its sensitivity to the SFT's
effectiveness and its hindrance to the learning capacity towards
human-preferred responses, leading to less satisfactory performance. To
overcome those limitations, the theoretical understanding of DPO are
indispensable but still lacking. To this end, we take a step towards
theoretically analyzing and understanding the limitations of DPO. Specifically,
we provide an analytical framework using the field theory to analyze the
optimization process of DPO. By analyzing the gradient vector field of the DPO
loss function, we find that the DPO loss function decreases the probability of
producing human dispreferred data at a faster rate than it increases the
probability of producing preferred data. This provides theoretical insights for
understanding the limitations of DPO discovered in the related research
experiments, thereby setting the foundation for its improvement.
|
[
-0.6197984815,
-0.4798638821,
0.7690545917,
0.2783687115,
-0.1298351139,
-0.0608855598,
-0.1343063265,
-0.3480516374,
-0.2376262993,
0.357034862,
-0.7197231054,
-0.0197287984,
-0.5611393452,
0.4236107469,
-0.0241751596,
0.6974440217,
-0.2587744296,
-0.0888274834,
-0.4941575527,
0.1495410651,
-0.4179070592,
-0.6130524874,
-0.5726172924,
-0.5101587772,
0.2404578328,
0.5402538776,
0.3543428779,
0.6958115697,
0.7733873129,
0.2672348619,
-0.1302517354,
-0.1595939398,
-0.8247632384,
0.0831063688,
-0.0608625896,
-0.6147320271,
-0.3529752791,
0.1885235757,
0.7163801789,
0.8578459024,
0.0691152513,
-0.2319653034,
0.2306764573,
1.0661587715,
-0.5275648236,
-0.0110747414,
-0.6412570477,
0.2555862367,
-0.0503625274,
-0.5486641526,
-0.1449553072,
-0.0551031865,
0.5165643692,
-0.6985198855,
0.4539011121,
-0.2063691616,
0.5569198728,
0.3091324866,
-0.5690924525,
-0.0612647273,
-1.0137872696,
0.8803421855,
-0.207729876,
0.1852090955,
0.6553703547,
0.1729146391,
-0.3507375419,
0.0043968814,
-0.7061015368,
-0.3253812194,
-0.0270823929,
0.0323797762,
-0.1003588364,
0.3578898013,
0.3477805555,
0.7085641623,
-0.2527855039,
0.1029591709,
-0.1675616205,
0.0200875215,
0.7929322124,
0.3329108953,
-0.1004878879,
-0.2026692033,
-0.6305200458,
-0.0556060635,
-0.5620678067,
0.3768126965,
0.6593119502,
0.0514787287,
0.1282616258,
0.3437955081,
-0.4122992456,
0.7721605897,
0.2647684216,
-0.0542166159,
0.1036778763,
-0.046984531,
-0.1265593469,
-0.4081787765,
0.6823369265,
0.4790335596,
-0.0621037818,
-0.024814941,
-0.1568402201,
0.0424627438,
0.1214207783,
-0.5101664066,
0.285182029,
0.3169992268,
-0.3705891073,
-0.8025678396,
-0.1699033529,
-0.9049788117,
-0.4741939008,
-0.2725348473,
0.1119014323,
-0.3615774214,
-0.5049195886,
0.2504950166,
-0.3570919931,
-0.026569372,
0.0206221715,
-1.2467947006,
0.4949800968,
0.6601747274,
0.7678051591,
-0.2869294286,
-0.312818557,
-0.2587489188,
-0.0597563013,
-0.0413509049,
0.6319181323,
-0.455208838,
-0.7758076787,
-0.080476895,
-0.4597904682,
-0.0848366618,
-0.522482276,
0.9293456078,
-0.5147827268,
-0.2709940374,
-0.66449368,
-0.6099843979,
-0.0231244527,
0.1441469193,
-0.7516074181,
0.7669609189,
0.1915678531,
-0.7807692289,
0.5429230332,
-0.4937549829,
-0.3392995,
-0.0390317664,
-0.3405783772,
-0.1030312404,
0.446923852,
-0.2630335093,
0.3970027864,
-0.3791597486,
0.416079402,
-0.5624504685,
-0.4899207652,
0.463512212,
-0.1499378532,
0.6880671978,
0.2238197029,
-0.3353917301,
-0.1998217553,
-0.9661710262,
-0.5331539512,
0.3216379881,
-0.3962312043,
-0.5535548925,
0.4680183828,
-0.4374189973,
0.0926263928,
-0.0801861063,
-0.6380479336,
0.3999287784,
-0.381549716,
0.654574573,
1.1324410439,
-0.4050069451,
0.8107548356,
-0.1372161508,
0.6559491158,
-0.1158866957,
0.2612573802,
0.33083722,
0.0462941788,
-0.4641052783,
-0.3373646736,
0.0897193477,
0.5133180618,
-0.4458513856,
0.4629218876,
-0.1339557916,
-0.0290797036,
-0.1578539759,
0.0439455099,
0.0440550148,
1.0948284864,
0.1084482446,
-0.1390189976,
-0.4955018163,
-1.1654917002,
0.0875884742,
-0.2111945748,
0.1344128847,
0.4107203782,
0.2755143642,
-0.0267363563,
1.0589152575,
-0.6697576642,
-0.2016789913,
-0.2241777629,
-0.2622778118,
0.249784708,
0.3168867826,
0.5066148639,
-0.8535545468,
-0.3583899736,
-0.1953386217,
-0.5197347403,
-0.2582633495,
0.2097582519,
-0.1375490427,
-0.0139837461,
-0.0867787898,
-0.5748351216,
0.3390790224,
0.5917435884,
-0.1708799303,
0.574260354,
-0.0195747782,
0.1919949949,
-0.3982468843,
0.1969823688,
0.1861886531,
0.1506841779,
-0.7155989408,
-0.312233448,
-0.0855023414,
-0.2740350962,
-0.0387691781,
0.4824118912,
-0.1591541171,
-0.049195651,
-0.4458846152,
0.0503410064,
0.1926348209,
0.4591233134,
0.2826801836,
0.6123763919,
0.5272934437,
-1.07353127,
0.3452286422,
0.3538703024,
0.0323468931,
0.6046387553,
-0.7178094387,
0.0631409213,
-0.326043874,
0.2685951889,
-1.0168088675,
0.0215154476,
0.4236194193,
-0.3242838681,
0.28893435,
-0.1811944693,
-0.0517447069,
-0.4451407492,
-0.5630230308,
0.4708611369,
0.4294754267,
-0.5225846171,
0.0765970051,
0.2498255223,
0.1994472295,
-0.9399364591,
-0.3025276065,
-0.4295710921,
-0.4589378238,
-0.6911426783,
0.6601926684,
-0.023140287,
-0.4278500676,
-0.1610033065,
-0.3250598609,
0.1219942868,
0.2614932358,
0.1072883382,
0.2421931922,
0.3026293814,
0.395088017,
0.0494915545,
-0.2864706218,
0.1285336018,
-0.1554639339,
0.4608389139,
0.0671183467,
0.0416124426,
-0.4716785848,
0.4800429344,
0.1857963353,
-0.0537097678,
0.304656595,
0.0400113687,
0.0019945914,
-0.3592381179,
-0.2677078843,
-0.1803276986,
-0.5015580058,
0.3497290909,
-0.7096326351,
-0.6446602941,
0.384924382,
-0.1081804112,
-0.2376488745,
0.7189335227,
0.1047065109,
0.0378120393,
0.8671848178,
0.7465358377,
-0.0312984921,
0.5533442497,
-0.350980103,
-0.0663554072,
-1.0145436525,
-0.1918990761,
-0.4669131339,
-0.4104785621,
-0.561336875,
0.0063490658,
0.1612350345,
0.3710146248,
-0.0223250762,
0.052319292,
-0.6753249764,
0.2153690755,
0.6148492694,
0.1336705834,
0.3731379509,
0.2210995555,
-0.0608770885,
-0.1553737223,
-0.6490128636,
-0.4569494724,
1.1715737581,
0.558358252,
0.5648861527,
-0.2069875151,
0.7530731559,
0.2153332382,
-0.1392622888,
-0.9379114509,
0.4569290578,
-0.06829229,
-0.6567111015,
-0.3937646151,
-0.5274178386,
-0.9101776481,
0.2868117988,
-0.1806009263,
-0.608902514,
0.4238164425,
0.572648108,
-0.2942112088,
0.1649937481,
-0.5066261888,
0.7135818005,
-0.3815668225,
-0.6915775537,
-0.184375748,
-0.4130283892,
0.37718153,
0.1698738933,
0.0677174628,
-0.5010282397,
-0.1169898361,
0.6805083752,
-0.1919793785,
0.6103656292,
-0.3437180817,
-0.1800811887,
0.2506069243,
0.0035342292,
0.433676213,
0.2040876895,
-0.3903627098,
0.2364566475,
-0.0228970665,
-0.4079756141,
-0.3992663026,
0.7217056155,
-0.7810855508,
-0.7598919868,
-0.5540411472,
-0.3505136669,
-0.4378988147,
0.0076774433,
0.4263106883,
0.1590668559,
-0.4525639415,
-0.3068913519,
0.6306886077,
-0.3706198633,
0.1933403015,
0.3699954152,
-0.0928147808,
-0.2735640109,
0.6605885625,
-0.0105284955,
0.2240022719,
0.5988267064,
0.546594739,
-0.3333619535,
-0.8509678841,
-0.2604829669,
0.3150782585,
-0.6427305937,
0.1508881152,
-0.203572154,
0.3908259869,
-0.2533331215,
-0.0234622713,
-0.1356191784,
-0.2915484011,
-0.3815277219,
-0.1477626264,
0.2921427786,
0.57044065,
-0.1231550574,
0.2750836611,
-0.439397186,
0.1692358255,
0.2562495172,
0.6945032477,
-0.1611097753,
-0.3398222029,
0.0180293694,
0.1540341675,
-0.5854331851,
-0.9490519762,
0.1602912694,
-0.1595308781,
0.6619852185,
0.3008923233,
0.1813801825,
0.3751584888,
-0.4610945582,
0.4238478541,
0.1857830882,
-1.0847076178,
0.7261710763,
-0.5935178995,
-0.2193894088,
0.621019125,
0.5481881499,
-0.4094038904,
0.3219704926,
-0.6102922559,
-0.8442887664,
0.8506240845,
0.0286506098,
0.0893088728,
0.0159152541,
0.7356963754,
0.4071094394,
0.2473916113,
-0.4863652587,
-0.2944535613,
0.0303749517,
0.0355013534,
-0.207896471,
-0.4793351293,
-0.3988894224,
-0.2937517464,
0.5568783879,
0.0367836058,
0.5555586815,
0.5315027833,
0.1475528628,
-0.34166798,
0.2111354768,
0.815819025,
0.7999843955,
-0.4993329942,
-0.0256536305,
-0.1197810248,
-0.3141718805,
0.4032302797,
0.3797600865,
-0.2527922392,
-0.1876797974,
0.1782025844,
1.0348851681,
-0.2509923875,
-0.5457519889,
0.53187114,
-0.0276243854,
-0.523157835,
-0.2876327932,
-0.137899667,
-0.3140377998,
0.0186706968,
0.6272714138,
0.0122433836,
0.3829964101,
-0.3215644658,
0.0749391913,
0.5986157656,
-0.3258511722,
-0.3986197114,
0.6249097586,
0.8376814723,
-0.184952423,
0.3476523459,
-0.0152490847,
-0.5641771555,
0.6539567709,
0.3454805911,
0.7522569895,
0.0176036507,
0.3916676044,
0.218338564,
-0.0232191626,
-0.075732708,
-0.0481266305,
-0.2404214144,
-0.8855422139,
-0.4370016754,
-0.6394155025,
-0.3518581986,
0.3369870782,
-0.6177755594,
0.2102075219,
-0.5250338912,
-0.3856802881,
0.155268833,
0.2038921863,
-0.7194393277,
0.0542400666,
-0.0491023995,
0.4643301666,
-0.6720924973,
0.5703154206,
0.4839114249,
-0.1868676692,
-0.4889940023,
-0.0055618412,
-0.0282707345,
-1.0087865591,
1.08276546,
-0.0007142058,
-0.2963453233,
-0.0535568595,
-0.2015030682,
-0.6505427957,
0.8531125784,
0.4614209235,
-0.691141367,
0.168907702,
0.1707850397,
0.4959008098,
-0.2028649449,
-0.0894677043,
0.629345119,
0.3483325839,
-0.0715149865,
-0.8722735643,
0.1791828871,
0.0583057851,
0.0595741346,
0.4800353944,
-0.7149406672,
0.6596266031,
-0.1098927557,
-0.144441694,
-0.3911288083,
0.1386561841,
0.0950781032,
0.4178345799,
0.6714091897,
0.3476123512,
0.4411016405,
0.0763346851,
1.316726923,
-0.0596010648,
0.6128851771,
0.4021525383,
-0.4484463632,
0.631957233,
0.8807743788,
-0.6930575371,
-0.0018473566,
0.6908503771,
0.2169617265,
0.5030269027,
0.7143369913,
-0.5220175385,
0.0266899671,
-0.0489117727,
-0.4110646546,
0.6144901514,
-0.125820905,
-0.5039032698,
0.3455954492,
-0.1414519846,
-0.2558144629,
0.3055955172,
-0.2676756084,
0.5157933831,
-0.0637476966,
-0.760992229,
0.7446084023,
-0.1131153628,
0.7354380488,
-0.5114935637,
0.0794586465,
-0.3212658763,
0.4589144588,
-0.2238836139,
-0.432972461,
0.3235129416,
-0.2926241457,
-0.3002827168,
-0.2760830522,
0.7921308279,
-0.2614308298,
-0.267382592,
0.4954129159,
0.203177169,
-0.3202070892,
-0.0741090626,
-0.5378813744,
0.3854219913,
0.0992573947,
-0.4701683223,
0.4035743475,
0.1743769795,
0.457636714,
0.5803146362,
0.3777578175,
0.1712911874,
-0.470695287,
-0.3883016706,
0.7299193144,
-0.5680460334,
-0.4295034707,
-1.1114697456,
0.3408638239,
-0.2132594734,
-0.3437059522,
0.536245048,
0.3764558136,
0.9033768177,
-0.2630648315,
1.1624704599,
-0.1546792537,
0.4374708533,
-0.4395507574,
0.2011358887,
-0.6546706557,
0.4755625129,
-0.4138999879,
-0.7665686607,
-0.0443399064,
0.6613346338,
-0.5281841755,
-0.0613449253,
0.7326120138,
0.3357991576,
0.2213160843,
-0.0765110403,
0.3313075006,
-0.337475121,
0.1889612228,
0.742824614,
0.8979486823,
-0.1786826253,
0.689003706,
-0.8013388515,
-0.6529077291,
-0.287143141,
-0.9377508163,
-0.7950738072,
-0.6854487062,
-0.0939160883,
-0.1406228691,
-0.0873151273,
0.6418270469,
0.555822432,
-0.320309341,
-0.4900031388,
-0.3937018812,
0.2000577152,
-0.4070600271,
-0.2402339131,
0.2022485882,
-0.1191459671,
-0.8701696396,
0.2582000792,
0.2307240069,
0.1242781878,
-0.1719012111,
-0.3246442974,
-0.0384432301,
-0.1395979524,
0.7142589688,
0.4347292185,
-0.5203462243,
-0.2613503933,
0.198664695,
0.1384462416,
0.0093900226,
1.3445518017,
-0.4496430159,
0.4637836218,
0.6599569917,
0.6109710336,
0.4585585892,
0.0572711341,
1.0329329967,
-0.5556520224,
0.2894800007,
0.3292757571,
0.1155387834,
0.1532401741,
-0.6740748286,
0.5069722533,
0.5982066989,
-0.5951579809,
-0.81298244,
0.6608576775,
-1.0255936384,
-0.2000227422,
1.260269165,
0.1244118661,
0.0865626782,
0.1508746594,
-0.2908334434,
0.1537448466,
-0.6053738594,
0.8432904482,
0.8337415457,
-0.6736186743,
0.0811832398,
-0.5784848332,
1.001547575,
0.600194335,
-0.4266084433,
0.2957020998,
0.5145308971,
0.3702313304,
-0.1030068174,
1.0784881115,
0.2477832437,
-0.0570879318,
0.1233497411,
-0.1640545428,
-0.2890979946,
0.1210158169,
-0.6752715707,
0.0771941617,
0.3695304692,
-0.4952902496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08675v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08675v1
|
RecGPT: Generative Personalized Prompts for Sequential Recommendation via ChatGPT Training Paradigm
| 2024-04-06T12:38:54 | 2024-04-06T12:38:54 |
Yabin Zhang, Wenhui Yu, Erhan Zhang, Xu Chen, Lantao Hu, Peng Jiang, Kun Gai
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
ChatGPT has achieved remarkable success in natural language understanding.
Considering that recommendation is indeed a conversation between users and the
system with items as words, which has similar underlying pattern with ChatGPT,
we design a new chat framework in item index level for the recommendation task.
Our novelty mainly contains three parts: model, training and inference. For the
model part, we adopt Generative Pre-training Transformer (GPT) as the
sequential recommendation model and design a user modular to capture
personalized information. For the training part, we adopt the two-stage
paradigm of ChatGPT, including pre-training and fine-tuning. In the
pre-training stage, we train GPT model by auto-regression. In the fine-tuning
stage, we train the model with prompts, which include both the newly-generated
results from the model and the user's feedback. For the inference part, we
predict several user interests as user representations in an autoregressive
manner. For each interest vector, we recall several items with the highest
similarity and merge the items recalled by all interest vectors into the final
result. We conduct experiments with both offline public datasets and online A/B
test to demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.5195236802,
-0.8532066345,
0.4356635511,
0.2722368836,
-0.2183499038,
-0.0552706756,
-0.0325461961,
0.0096352817,
0.2902016044,
0.3322780132,
-0.9099777937,
-0.4937538505,
-0.2803136408,
0.006869467,
-0.4748814106,
1.3582917452,
0.1556384265,
-0.1354147345,
0.0563744232,
0.1206893399,
-1.0292230844,
-0.3609894514,
-1.0644353628,
-0.2353853136,
0.5586277843,
0.522256434,
0.4191899896,
0.2359143496,
0.2079428136,
0.2851317227,
0.2213854939,
0.0985629931,
-0.635289669,
0.3759799004,
-0.1730839461,
-0.339127779,
-0.128191337,
-0.0931557193,
0.2827310264,
0.4421997666,
-0.5465824008,
-0.0391235277,
0.3618705273,
0.7660424113,
-0.1931108534,
0.2783191502,
-0.5096214414,
0.2728993297,
0.0393344983,
-0.2004824728,
-0.4751296341,
-0.4307190478,
0.6307148337,
-0.7439899445,
0.6165244579,
0.3907049298,
0.6039922237,
0.1081634015,
-0.255941689,
-0.1545765102,
-0.8108615875,
0.3847714067,
-0.4175342023,
0.2640092075,
0.4767180979,
0.5757750869,
-0.2183600068,
-0.9796124697,
-0.5543065667,
-0.3996917903,
-0.1674522609,
0.0927783325,
-0.1319724619,
0.0647578165,
0.0814387351,
0.617751658,
-0.8054301739,
-0.1425989866,
0.0292087197,
0.0482235216,
0.369053483,
0.1886053085,
0.1188156232,
0.0161550473,
-0.6715441942,
-0.1574031264,
-0.4916990995,
-0.0751952454,
0.2478823066,
0.2569787204,
-0.126665011,
0.5192134976,
-0.5158880949,
0.7029716969,
0.5742121339,
0.3711736202,
0.3349213302,
-0.6009840965,
-0.1268740147,
-0.1119023114,
0.9551054239,
0.4463878572,
0.3780545294,
-0.1030255035,
-0.0430594571,
-0.258798033,
0.2389911711,
-0.7592728734,
-0.6413606405,
-0.0585104674,
-0.5221975446,
-0.2927863896,
0.0732730031,
-0.6944897771,
-0.5388396382,
-0.1846981198,
0.4508527815,
-0.4045611322,
-0.0150112361,
0.2067148238,
0.0405207202,
-0.0495085977,
0.5003424883,
-1.1666185856,
0.1603800058,
0.4989668429,
0.8485247493,
-0.2007055283,
-0.2858753502,
-0.4847809672,
-0.1907626688,
0.1803775579,
1.2210965157,
-0.7165982723,
-0.7323712707,
0.0552892759,
0.0106541114,
-0.0243408997,
-0.1844374686,
0.4623365402,
-0.4944136739,
0.7809984088,
-0.2341037393,
-0.6442654729,
-0.3077774048,
0.3916920722,
-0.2998540401,
0.9603303671,
0.1719465107,
-0.7712875605,
0.4482341111,
-0.8171234131,
-0.3705316186,
0.3631142378,
-0.1040341556,
-0.2366016954,
-0.1513631195,
0.3245914578,
0.4488048553,
-0.3895754218,
0.2693783939,
-0.346147418,
-0.3540801704,
0.0424360856,
-0.6218605042,
0.0793848857,
0.3175271153,
-0.0939507335,
0.4648221731,
-0.550009191,
-0.2238748819,
0.1302351803,
-0.1312318444,
-0.0886334553,
0.0640297458,
0.1248039752,
-0.02225109,
0.33321926,
-0.473025918,
0.4763801694,
-0.4103862047,
0.5538274646,
0.7988317609,
0.3742167652,
0.4188736975,
-0.5260871649,
0.4751520157,
-0.1386500299,
0.1111975908,
-0.7006136775,
-0.6593161225,
-0.633067131,
0.1212985441,
0.2683598995,
0.6508184671,
-0.7113007307,
0.7282696962,
-0.0916978791,
-0.2000851035,
-0.2198859304,
-0.1451838166,
0.1134863719,
0.5117582083,
0.2766366601,
-0.5886512399,
-0.4806473553,
-0.7396897078,
-0.1007102504,
-0.300968647,
-0.3775423169,
0.5908681154,
0.0855656192,
-0.4995423555,
1.1069179773,
-0.8644921184,
-0.5016270876,
-0.2084123939,
0.4656100869,
0.3997575939,
0.2799826264,
0.2839817703,
-0.6125395894,
-0.7522039413,
-0.106139861,
-0.2755285203,
-0.0306861382,
-0.2272483408,
-0.1129279137,
-0.3305526376,
0.1469512731,
-0.39627859,
0.2691695988,
0.135881409,
-0.5039898157,
0.2007501572,
-0.4699319899,
0.158122912,
-1.2916226387,
-0.2744299471,
0.156856209,
-0.3045773506,
-0.5132721663,
-0.5650114417,
-0.3948744535,
-0.2212913632,
-0.0703114122,
0.6731354594,
-0.0167243145,
0.2607996464,
-0.4376376271,
0.1106847376,
-0.1935403645,
0.8139113784,
0.0698165819,
0.7213310599,
0.3531098664,
-0.4753760993,
0.449123472,
0.5916644335,
-0.3974835575,
0.6678193808,
-0.8947558999,
0.4184063077,
-0.112350218,
0.5026651621,
-1.3664374352,
-0.0534123182,
0.4436474741,
-0.3149107993,
-0.0626715869,
-0.3308579326,
-0.3486221135,
-0.2940594554,
-0.1949093938,
0.2177886814,
0.5847613215,
-0.5282546282,
0.4591373503,
0.1007619053,
-0.4097199142,
-0.3274828494,
-0.1692716032,
-0.0863180608,
-0.1287490129,
-0.5297314525,
0.3951809108,
-0.4414140582,
0.3730439842,
-0.0806415677,
0.201697275,
0.0886005834,
-0.0817111507,
0.3746474981,
0.2266244292,
-0.0223333072,
0.1354526877,
-0.2114224136,
-0.4020564556,
-0.1950902194,
-0.7422777414,
0.858749032,
-0.2755649984,
-0.3274148107,
-0.5758215785,
0.2912704051,
0.0520877689,
-0.0882505476,
0.4586316943,
1.0708681345,
-0.0224527959,
-0.0149428509,
-0.7252405882,
-0.3791290224,
-0.4900585115,
0.4323794544,
-0.3096812367,
-1.1033087969,
0.2904494107,
0.0349454805,
0.1207142696,
0.2359139323,
0.7319585681,
-0.1463732868,
1.0801122189,
0.5105236173,
-0.2774198055,
0.9842316508,
-0.2330966443,
0.1211527139,
-0.6453153491,
-0.1293515414,
-0.2142052352,
-0.2112473249,
-0.7211507559,
-0.1329039931,
0.2094716579,
-0.0443075784,
-0.511308074,
0.221465528,
-0.4833470881,
0.4126287103,
0.8305795193,
0.2206214517,
0.2040104121,
0.114014104,
-0.0429589264,
0.1054893583,
-0.5914993882,
-0.1835224628,
0.8063343167,
0.2643301785,
0.8460795879,
-0.184438467,
0.5321925879,
0.6766918302,
0.2457283437,
-0.861346662,
0.3432856202,
-0.1267819703,
-0.2659817934,
-0.2595638633,
-0.211646542,
-1.0782790184,
0.0864366442,
-0.2069399804,
-0.6957157254,
0.2539351881,
0.4624679983,
-0.6417399645,
-0.1232976392,
-0.8756762743,
0.899143517,
0.0339287445,
-0.172903493,
-0.2967762351,
-0.5796114802,
0.0769404247,
0.0553406402,
-0.1957909614,
-0.200010553,
0.2574756742,
0.6362524033,
-0.2885337472,
0.9572398663,
-0.3064866662,
0.2312199771,
0.2276217341,
0.0631220639,
0.8718455434,
0.3442121744,
0.2236713171,
-0.0826237798,
-0.2066370249,
-0.1016837806,
-0.7266557217,
0.6429072618,
-0.5807420611,
-0.7048293352,
-0.2894252837,
-0.2464103401,
-0.2802355289,
0.3756824136,
0.3247640729,
0.4306695759,
-0.4175908864,
0.2551254928,
0.5215987563,
-0.1890915632,
0.2452743202,
0.6015244126,
-0.2007392198,
-0.5485435724,
0.8946024179,
-0.493827045,
-0.0930048674,
0.6583029032,
0.4103885889,
-0.4532782137,
-0.5134370923,
-0.3332162797,
0.0627203733,
-0.4440592527,
-0.0017955364,
-0.6206476688,
-0.0088730892,
-0.2575262189,
0.0223544762,
-0.1461146474,
-0.120224528,
-0.3377871513,
0.0388263538,
0.5536836982,
0.9287297726,
0.2861460447,
0.4852430224,
-0.7657695413,
0.3962357938,
0.5866152644,
0.5245194435,
-0.0106540387,
-0.6434537768,
-0.2164488882,
0.1022270396,
-0.3040145934,
-0.528291285,
0.4956697226,
0.2051859945,
0.4245514572,
0.6222148538,
0.0581628494,
0.4542901814,
-0.8508163691,
0.7739558816,
0.2423704416,
-0.4701528549,
0.5265973806,
-0.5586462021,
0.402389586,
0.6600629091,
0.3372316062,
-0.9486522675,
0.0291085262,
-0.5367182493,
-0.7474818826,
0.7238094211,
0.242846638,
0.1306598932,
-0.1761149764,
0.3893044293,
0.3035123944,
0.2860537469,
-0.3678708673,
-0.4227050543,
-0.3152729869,
-0.3358583152,
-0.2230350673,
-0.4852073193,
0.1913233548,
0.0549176633,
0.5200023651,
0.0091961371,
0.581751585,
0.1708345562,
0.1529066414,
0.3051016033,
0.2054535151,
0.4179132283,
0.2272663265,
-0.3680325449,
-0.3175247908,
0.1008986086,
-0.4847069085,
0.1516085863,
0.309913367,
-0.0433846898,
-0.1949002445,
-0.1274180263,
1.127892971,
0.3812640011,
-0.1837857813,
0.4478827715,
-0.6247358918,
-0.072700046,
-0.6462112665,
0.1233552843,
-0.0808529258,
0.2532652617,
0.2049392462,
0.279715538,
0.3224850297,
-0.4184651375,
0.1955002844,
0.3232591152,
-0.5177049041,
-0.3605348766,
0.6207519174,
0.5952484012,
-0.5753924251,
0.7094054222,
-0.2927960753,
-0.2418538332,
-0.0494139194,
0.3411339223,
1.3051749468,
-0.1565231532,
0.3016862273,
0.3440851867,
-0.227060318,
-0.3625615835,
-0.0446675643,
-0.5984792709,
-0.9607055187,
-0.14757438,
-0.4530703723,
-0.4796748459,
-0.0039736805,
-0.5550001264,
0.3066951334,
-0.1835657656,
-0.0531325713,
-0.1168592125,
-0.1098866984,
-0.7017493844,
-0.1401931345,
-0.0845797956,
0.5660982132,
-0.5748215318,
0.8111838698,
0.4756231308,
-0.3963071406,
-0.477098465,
0.0556466058,
-0.11297708,
-0.8700915575,
0.5269663334,
0.0949466601,
-0.0264680889,
0.3385575116,
-0.0898736343,
-0.7719573975,
0.9627681375,
0.0852277577,
-0.7177509665,
-0.2358337194,
-0.207144469,
0.4784373343,
-0.5561479926,
0.515896976,
0.3903898001,
0.2904655039,
0.3412662148,
-0.8293580413,
-0.1796618998,
-0.3471887708,
0.1583432108,
0.1475358456,
-0.3677119315,
0.6252853274,
-0.2177556455,
-0.3018269837,
0.2253536284,
0.7346742749,
0.1746737957,
0.173235476,
0.8579241633,
0.3130457997,
0.6151798964,
-0.0143997846,
1.3035150766,
-0.2939928174,
0.4296633303,
1.3948434591,
-0.2372579575,
0.6706108451,
-0.0441790186,
-0.2261895984,
0.613011539,
0.9343203902,
-0.1951626986,
0.7019410133,
-0.0119702918,
-0.4181183577,
-0.0540929921,
-0.0375384726,
-0.4410756826,
0.0713614002,
0.2368147671,
-0.4153744876,
-0.1086823344,
0.2175896913,
-0.2647893131,
-0.2781122625,
0.0483889319,
1.2179270983,
-0.0119425831,
-0.771600306,
0.393319279,
-0.1301254183,
0.8094587922,
-0.6432470083,
-0.2321360558,
-0.3657101393,
0.2527031302,
0.0358512923,
-0.7164895535,
-0.2338642478,
-0.1734660566,
-0.3759162426,
-0.4644927382,
0.5982787609,
-0.6499252915,
-0.292365849,
-0.1849277765,
0.1985519528,
0.1169681102,
-0.2354538143,
-0.7711555958,
-0.5964848399,
0.3233572841,
-0.2836974859,
0.2358083725,
0.3599405885,
0.0997549444,
0.7396400571,
0.6651624441,
-0.0938105062,
-0.3384287059,
0.454939276,
0.5679550767,
-0.6471253037,
-0.8895974755,
-0.7283220887,
0.2762286663,
0.0374050029,
-0.3359966576,
0.7513629198,
0.294138521,
0.8033232093,
-0.1811334938,
0.6871206164,
0.0871657655,
0.5856521726,
-0.3910984099,
0.3516290486,
-0.0209494755,
0.5337677002,
-0.0166818704,
-0.89684093,
0.0677814111,
0.5816838145,
-0.3340159357,
0.4169559777,
0.7065389752,
0.7167258859,
0.1405742615,
0.3095596731,
0.1423171014,
0.1619961262,
0.3352031708,
0.6106563807,
0.8924424052,
-0.1618519872,
0.3971662223,
-0.2106082886,
-0.1221350208,
-0.4239603877,
-0.7614889741,
-0.8914501667,
-0.9214474559,
-0.2103033066,
-0.0996749625,
0.0830646232,
1.2135528326,
0.7514882088,
-0.8057454228,
-0.1009003818,
-0.4140708447,
-0.0396193229,
-0.1076309085,
-0.2684386671,
0.4159502983,
-0.3926458955,
-0.647888124,
0.4921062589,
0.1014933735,
0.2047151625,
-0.256105423,
0.0926679894,
-0.0111122895,
-0.4034370482,
0.6577293873,
0.1766213477,
-0.5682272911,
-0.2883827388,
-0.1777898371,
0.1744382828,
0.1622882485,
1.1479990482,
-1.0520737171,
0.6394006014,
0.7548478246,
0.5275364518,
0.8554800749,
0.3283312619,
0.9993251562,
-0.7383463979,
0.0992055982,
0.0047992002,
0.3847387433,
0.2293919474,
-0.5225803256,
0.3639175296,
0.183810994,
-0.6680354476,
-0.4543431997,
0.2065265477,
-0.8972572088,
0.1341183782,
0.993992269,
-0.2821407914,
0.3188355267,
-0.3087924421,
-0.6076025367,
0.0813197568,
-0.8197456598,
0.8809939027,
0.5511085987,
-0.3009220362,
-0.1445511132,
-0.4393011332,
0.5694577098,
0.2994858623,
-0.5693982244,
0.1413609385,
0.2686675787,
0.2570137382,
-0.1881316453,
0.7571700215,
0.2559318542,
0.2084593922,
-0.3289008737,
-0.0443903804,
-0.1877146512,
-0.1623354852,
-0.4054228365,
0.1646237224,
0.2357485443,
-0.4169991016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04545v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04545v1
|
TCAN: Text-oriented Cross Attention Network for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-06T07:56:09 | 2024-04-06T07:56:09 |
Ming Zhou, Weize Quan, Ziqi Zhou, Kai Wang, Tong Wang, Dong-Ming Yan
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.CL
|
Multimodal Sentiment Analysis (MSA) endeavors to understand human sentiment
by leveraging language, visual, and acoustic modalities. Despite the remarkable
performance exhibited by previous MSA approaches, the presence of inherent
multimodal heterogeneities poses a challenge, with the contribution of
different modalities varying considerably. Past research predominantly focused
on improving representation learning techniques and feature fusion strategies.
However, many of these efforts overlooked the variation in semantic richness
among different modalities, treating each modality uniformly. This approach may
lead to underestimating the significance of strong modalities while
overemphasizing the importance of weak ones. Motivated by these insights, we
introduce a Text-oriented Cross-Attention Network (TCAN), emphasizing the
predominant role of the text modality in MSA. Specifically, for each multimodal
sample, by taking unaligned sequences of the three modalities as inputs, we
initially allocate the extracted unimodal features into a visual-text and an
acoustic-text pair. Subsequently, we implement self-attention on the text
modality and apply text-queried cross-attention to the visual and acoustic
modalities. To mitigate the influence of noise signals and redundant features,
we incorporate a gated control mechanism into the framework. Additionally, we
introduce unimodal joint learning to gain a deeper understanding of homogeneous
emotional tendencies across diverse modalities through backpropagation.
Experimental results demonstrate that TCAN consistently outperforms
state-of-the-art MSA methods on two datasets (CMU-MOSI and CMU-MOSEI).
|
[
-0.3923263848,
-0.5661845803,
0.463044256,
0.5250334144,
-0.5391764641,
0.0418803357,
-0.4297088087,
-0.2746974826,
0.5415295959,
0.2391953319,
-0.5659114122,
-0.4701962769,
-0.5356782675,
0.0830042958,
0.1394578964,
1.0084292889,
0.0677790716,
0.1501799673,
0.0285589006,
-0.5392177701,
-0.3984109461,
-0.2381735295,
-0.4823551774,
-0.0062595117,
1.000729084,
0.2567557991,
0.5007634759,
0.2378798574,
0.6618760824,
0.273419857,
0.0223959927,
0.2582604289,
-0.2690871656,
0.221828267,
-0.2019566298,
-0.1637883484,
-0.5221883655,
0.072990045,
0.5706843138,
0.4613420665,
0.1416133046,
0.1825904548,
0.0855274722,
0.6229271293,
-0.8965613842,
0.1516630501,
-0.4666856229,
0.4165344238,
-0.2647551,
-0.4912883937,
-0.2310242951,
0.2744205296,
0.1387123913,
-0.4396809042,
-0.0991865993,
-0.1633723676,
0.6325014234,
0.2826847732,
-0.832290709,
0.0059712492,
-0.5158191919,
1.0355278254,
-0.5098329186,
0.4378821552,
0.1777023971,
0.0667871311,
0.2362400442,
-0.4212535322,
-0.7048851848,
-0.0810719728,
-0.0092884572,
0.7618128061,
-0.0268145613,
0.1540031284,
-0.1127940714,
0.3233104944,
-0.6384956837,
-0.2579431832,
-0.1380314231,
-0.1293470711,
0.2988299429,
0.1553837955,
0.3970219493,
-0.6142151952,
-0.8514760137,
-0.276234597,
0.0474043339,
0.0399040543,
0.1105136126,
0.4744413495,
-0.2645890713,
0.6312536001,
-0.0935219377,
0.2801941335,
0.0316271037,
-0.0625148192,
0.6266701221,
-0.6108124852,
-0.4883903265,
0.0838837028,
1.2461055517,
0.352865845,
-0.1641051173,
0.0289209373,
-0.2388379574,
0.2688969076,
0.2422717512,
-0.3700474799,
0.2176302075,
0.2297000736,
-0.8604418039,
-0.3482782841,
0.0469014198,
-1.1421568394,
-0.2584133148,
-0.3383652866,
0.5419567227,
-0.0527183041,
-0.6345188022,
-0.0864740089,
-0.0583141446,
0.0806142241,
-0.0218081754,
-0.6461405158,
-0.0716807917,
0.3914434016,
1.0273623466,
-0.1216337457,
-0.2608827055,
-0.3716114461,
0.2242047191,
-0.0868639126,
0.6587260365,
-0.7745049,
-0.2777608335,
-0.1942361891,
0.0246284492,
-0.4671360552,
-0.2026650608,
0.4999046922,
-0.3134453595,
0.5190511942,
-0.0474959798,
0.137812376,
-0.3436845243,
0.6413573623,
-0.8489781022,
0.8768575788,
-0.0941109359,
-0.7994422913,
-0.0298203435,
-0.741589427,
-0.4960554838,
-0.610740006,
-0.0496733971,
-0.5052409172,
0.1206386909,
0.2309253365,
0.7037769556,
-0.4362620711,
0.0298638213,
-0.4131090939,
-0.0426081941,
0.2896588743,
-0.5896122456,
0.5257355571,
0.4390210807,
-0.5041835904,
0.3226510584,
-0.7710831165,
0.0155697223,
-0.1433189213,
-0.1451689303,
-0.639703095,
-0.332418561,
0.5841860771,
0.6057500839,
0.0488386601,
-0.6042169333,
-0.1975167841,
-0.3355333507,
0.2868928015,
0.627207458,
0.0001986398,
0.4475599825,
0.0257075857,
0.5839114785,
0.5433701873,
0.2346868217,
-0.1970815361,
-0.2905902565,
-0.4831995368,
-0.3399128616,
-0.0445948727,
0.407356739,
-0.9093177319,
0.2049426287,
-0.1225061715,
-0.2335264385,
-0.4041799009,
0.3609349728,
0.5794041753,
0.3969478607,
0.3541983962,
-0.674413085,
-0.4706436098,
-0.8764175177,
-0.0773095265,
-0.2490825951,
0.2087880671,
0.1542909294,
0.0493929498,
-0.3986457288,
0.5862568021,
0.0659721121,
-0.8325892091,
-0.4199077189,
0.4126632214,
-0.2021935135,
0.3486764431,
0.4947547615,
-1.071988821,
-0.3638596535,
0.3884239495,
-0.7424861193,
0.1065894961,
-0.558831811,
-0.2936182618,
0.2399278432,
0.3194643855,
-0.4619184732,
0.2151058912,
0.8055052757,
-0.3786794543,
-0.0644594282,
0.3094095886,
0.3040867746,
-1.5985820293,
0.1577040702,
0.4376912117,
-0.0966967791,
-0.4072190523,
-0.2892726958,
0.0092797242,
0.0161803309,
-0.2986909151,
0.3343512714,
-0.4900155663,
-0.073102735,
-0.1984077841,
0.3970522583,
0.124277994,
0.9657610059,
0.1254280955,
0.3057822883,
0.2824474573,
-0.153612107,
0.4948836863,
-0.0432347022,
0.2687195241,
0.7400054336,
-0.5367740393,
0.0789045095,
-0.1747612506,
0.0698038787,
-1.081171751,
0.0698673204,
0.5766629577,
-0.5034576058,
0.3262040615,
0.2112665623,
-0.0160377137,
0.0021914886,
-0.6026110649,
0.6778982282,
-0.2369347215,
-0.2707090974,
1.3037672043,
0.3175597489,
0.0255465787,
-0.9265297055,
-0.8156796098,
0.2315726578,
-0.0874311998,
-0.5640096664,
-0.0661699548,
-0.0245418679,
-0.2213947177,
0.1234041303,
-0.1562608033,
-0.1515004039,
-0.1324226409,
0.2972988486,
0.1953217238,
-0.4376440346,
0.3942278922,
0.0644775331,
-0.2293007523,
0.0652898774,
-0.1160312071,
0.3236939013,
-0.2285200953,
-0.0377602726,
-0.7679970264,
0.5218267441,
0.7355838418,
-0.5708085299,
0.4272664487,
0.8682051301,
-0.1763754636,
-0.121406205,
-0.4117667377,
0.011283488,
-0.3653769493,
0.5955529809,
-0.3855148852,
-0.58802706,
0.4447993636,
0.2420829087,
-0.2380191237,
0.4229690433,
0.7319688201,
-0.1958836317,
1.0008262396,
0.5942978263,
-0.3122544587,
0.8231771588,
-0.1981696934,
0.062437363,
-0.8386493921,
-0.2494456917,
-0.3613927662,
-0.5180307627,
-0.5249201059,
-0.3416976631,
0.3041537106,
-0.5924462676,
0.0148794185,
-0.0169181339,
-0.1927758753,
0.3215665221,
0.2796693742,
0.2811542749,
0.1915639788,
0.016847644,
0.17331478,
0.0616356097,
-0.5255830288,
-0.137824133,
0.9586812854,
0.4741135836,
0.7789658308,
-0.0174660347,
0.3261221647,
0.3175996244,
0.1555126905,
-0.9004056454,
0.3482136428,
-0.195783034,
-0.4329288602,
-0.1309557855,
-0.7655505538,
-0.7006992698,
0.360153079,
-0.2440811843,
-0.1795094609,
0.5444000959,
-0.0257571246,
-0.1869259626,
0.3532227576,
-0.7380917072,
1.0904864073,
-0.1438013315,
-0.3892834485,
-0.3441044092,
-1.0175009966,
0.4222923815,
0.2850213945,
0.068138741,
0.0136099746,
-0.2015008926,
0.4643422961,
0.073891513,
1.0706148148,
-0.0311133247,
-0.2108974755,
0.1391842365,
-0.0123590045,
0.1334582418,
0.165514037,
0.3373857439,
0.1041419581,
-0.1088541299,
-0.3652083576,
-0.7164174318,
0.7751176953,
-0.9610375166,
-0.0856377706,
-0.4714788496,
-0.4691837132,
-0.468141824,
0.1690808833,
-0.0082358764,
0.7452202439,
-0.0500759333,
0.3270121515,
0.8379529715,
0.0182573851,
0.6876140237,
-0.0008591682,
0.2365261018,
-0.6958836317,
1.0372495651,
-0.2059139758,
0.3700007796,
0.6832787991,
0.2158773988,
-0.1985534281,
-0.0361141749,
-0.4151056409,
0.2420952022,
-0.6579460502,
-0.2818475068,
-0.956297338,
0.132232368,
-0.4086653292,
0.1413421035,
-0.6362195611,
-0.4456121922,
-0.3120959997,
-0.0191135779,
-0.0223256815,
0.4069372416,
-0.0568010546,
0.205989778,
-0.843465209,
0.5798491836,
0.471563071,
0.3931464553,
0.0710836276,
-0.2211970091,
-0.1962972134,
-0.0111110602,
-0.1233272254,
-0.8560582399,
0.410336405,
0.1753719449,
0.2805526853,
0.5739135146,
-0.0033098548,
0.4300363064,
0.2723089457,
0.6520406604,
0.5422911048,
-0.8768553734,
0.4235528708,
-0.4105595052,
0.4403138161,
0.5617542863,
0.2752684355,
-0.8334557414,
-0.368308723,
-0.2144396156,
-0.7213827968,
0.6650315523,
0.1753569096,
0.1945642978,
0.0450821854,
-0.0610215701,
-0.0660165101,
0.195126757,
-1.0210335255,
-0.3114230931,
-0.8234608769,
-0.8032367229,
-0.0681681111,
-0.3040171564,
-0.1428135037,
0.3429010808,
0.6422820091,
-0.4496222734,
0.276550889,
0.4519100487,
-0.1623384804,
-0.2630531192,
0.404204458,
0.6778301001,
0.2228541374,
-0.0521384589,
0.3528767824,
-0.1699762791,
-0.7323365808,
-0.149026528,
-0.063237384,
0.1364144385,
-0.08519876,
0.2879271805,
0.6774010062,
0.0031599584,
-0.51327914,
0.6268292665,
-0.362506777,
0.0992950574,
-0.0202722363,
-0.3997965455,
-0.1848226041,
0.430857271,
0.2195141613,
0.4511871636,
0.3155595064,
-0.811173439,
-0.0682969689,
0.2810920179,
-0.9889953732,
-0.5646883845,
0.2988335192,
0.4910466075,
0.1971412003,
0.1032972485,
0.0486877561,
-0.5504524708,
0.6481585503,
0.226502046,
1.3328560591,
-0.1040298492,
0.402526319,
0.1313532144,
0.5601995587,
0.2359953523,
0.3536938131,
-0.1558473706,
-0.8083351254,
-0.3191969991,
-0.2190683782,
-0.1865672469,
-0.17908369,
-0.5612024665,
-0.086285457,
-0.6097544432,
-0.2045052201,
-0.2886213064,
-0.1158593297,
-0.3521325588,
0.5570108294,
0.2626876831,
0.3921307325,
-0.7448611856,
0.4782739282,
0.9022399187,
-0.6544508338,
-0.6703506708,
0.1401985437,
0.264657557,
-0.3549895287,
0.6039971113,
0.2068744153,
-0.4699171782,
-0.3785331547,
-0.2591075003,
-0.47627303,
0.926315546,
0.032192193,
-0.4452497661,
0.2179161906,
0.1712754816,
0.5389488935,
-0.4386224449,
0.498678863,
0.1412715763,
0.4932155907,
-0.1051011235,
-0.8806787133,
0.0107521955,
-0.6327576041,
0.1075086892,
0.1515056789,
-1.2044569254,
0.6079107523,
0.1229654551,
-0.1601270586,
-0.2700104117,
0.9319034219,
-0.2161227018,
0.7482167482,
0.7508955002,
0.4868899882,
0.2576069534,
-0.0109087201,
0.8356747031,
0.0472357944,
0.1507796198,
0.9577301741,
-0.191793263,
0.6402210593,
0.7254977822,
0.3159915507,
0.5000218749,
0.4078050554,
0.3641772568,
0.48686409,
-0.4587297738,
-0.2824243605,
-0.4795449078,
-0.3699259758,
-0.2920312583,
0.8395678997,
0.1253646463,
-0.4787489474,
-0.08430399,
0.5417346358,
-0.1537558436,
0.239413321,
-0.5157715678,
0.790256083,
0.2102055103,
-0.1474537551,
-0.0139736887,
-0.1454995573,
0.8450111747,
-0.6813944578,
0.1311222315,
-0.328074038,
0.2448140681,
-0.1877937764,
-0.5343607664,
0.1585170776,
-0.2831555307,
-0.4482305348,
-0.1220224649,
0.6584444046,
-0.5232176185,
-0.4122309983,
0.5524101257,
0.3276724219,
-0.4021733701,
-0.1280600131,
-0.6390128732,
0.0765812472,
-0.0197585206,
-0.6939854026,
0.191236645,
0.9682974815,
-0.0542866066,
0.5329115391,
0.3805202246,
-0.0711657479,
-0.0412125178,
0.3552741706,
0.9645472765,
-0.8878755569,
-0.629881382,
-0.589053452,
0.4684664607,
-0.0130189434,
-0.7161430717,
0.655112803,
0.2636443079,
0.7582312822,
0.0108232414,
0.6105244756,
0.0058216476,
0.2828061283,
-0.6525170207,
0.5982671976,
-0.9231792092,
-0.0152781243,
-0.4723871648,
-0.9729301929,
-0.5157114267,
0.3527314365,
0.1294648796,
0.2083960325,
0.8160921931,
0.7526112795,
-0.1518012583,
0.1129163057,
0.3165099621,
0.238072291,
0.0935405195,
0.6212813854,
1.0035084486,
-0.4050143957,
0.8007634878,
-0.4445396662,
-0.1609738767,
0.0530206859,
-0.7290323973,
-1.0604637861,
-0.5585540533,
-0.1298910677,
-0.2229035348,
-0.1139101088,
1.13920331,
0.5160921812,
-0.6899080276,
-0.1242461801,
0.4903131127,
0.1315532476,
-0.2843108773,
-0.2890098095,
0.3135543764,
-0.4902920127,
-0.7393744588,
0.2846939266,
0.5715625882,
-0.237372458,
-0.4300462008,
0.0414244793,
-0.3490574956,
0.0650880784,
0.6418165565,
0.1259803921,
-0.4727512896,
-0.172322318,
0.1302470118,
-0.4287156463,
0.1376891285,
1.0861244202,
-0.5619751215,
0.6758682728,
0.7686701417,
0.8292014599,
0.1154274642,
-0.1608427614,
0.4805667698,
-0.8434237242,
0.2708264887,
0.2262147814,
0.4067816734,
0.2346910089,
-0.3542352319,
0.353515327,
0.4414221942,
-0.2271134555,
-0.5755813122,
-0.0818867981,
-1.7593281269,
-0.2384073287,
1.1082952023,
0.1426985413,
-0.5521780252,
-0.0808760747,
-0.4736948907,
0.3007976115,
-0.6884217262,
0.8692013025,
0.3372997642,
0.3229069114,
-0.4292016625,
-0.1264663041,
0.1275923848,
0.7871128917,
-0.8303703666,
0.0404675677,
0.5431092381,
-0.1442839503,
0.3930246532,
0.4390531182,
-0.1873673648,
0.3389593661,
-0.1559301466,
0.2203417718,
-0.1114688143,
-0.5595818162,
-0.4425795078,
0.489648968,
-0.6260067225,
-0.372336179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04538v1
|
Soft-Prompting with Graph-of-Thought for Multi-modal Representation Learning
| 2024-04-06T07:39:44 | 2024-04-06T07:39:44 |
Juncheng Yang, Zuchao Li, Shuai Xie, Wei Yu, Shijun Li, Bo Du
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The chain-of-thought technique has been received well in multi-modal tasks.
It is a step-by-step linear reasoning process that adjusts the length of the
chain to improve the performance of generated prompts. However, human thought
processes are predominantly non-linear, as they encompass multiple aspects
simultaneously and employ dynamic adjustment and updating mechanisms.
Therefore, we propose a novel Aggregation-Graph-of-Thought (AGoT) mechanism for
soft-prompt tuning in multi-modal representation learning. The proposed AGoT
models the human thought process not only as a chain but also models each step
as a reasoning aggregation graph to cope with the overlooked multiple aspects
of thinking in single-step reasoning. This turns the entire reasoning process
into prompt aggregation and prompt flow operations. Experiments show that our
multi-modal model enhanced with AGoT soft-prompting achieves good results in
several tasks such as text-image retrieval, visual question answering, and
image recognition. In addition, we demonstrate that it has good domain
generalization performance due to better reasoning.
|
[
-0.647154808,
-1.322259903,
0.7077050805,
-0.326190263,
-0.6246410608,
-0.0404545963,
-0.2669432163,
-0.1426996291,
0.4188539386,
0.0280269254,
-0.7573973536,
-0.2529231608,
-0.2657293081,
0.2712275982,
0.3319036067,
0.9578769803,
-0.0207519531,
-0.0359293371,
0.1492610276,
-0.3821206689,
-0.9369664192,
-0.215220958,
-0.7107104659,
-0.3117571473,
0.9680525661,
0.1351049244,
0.6684165597,
0.2061095536,
0.0613669828,
0.3765946329,
-0.0092124157,
0.6498898864,
-0.3546622097,
0.4415711164,
-0.2620908618,
-0.2654403448,
-0.9739221334,
-0.0853063241,
0.7171623111,
0.7003706098,
-0.0351318605,
-0.1131979972,
0.2744364142,
0.7276020646,
-0.5503594875,
0.2955083251,
-0.4792086184,
-0.0497528911,
0.1816855967,
-0.2084434777,
-0.4103291035,
-0.2519477606,
0.037455447,
-0.6986731887,
0.0744878575,
-0.0134556107,
0.1333972663,
0.1396101117,
-0.7084028721,
-0.2892734706,
-0.3486511111,
0.3860408962,
-0.1291884482,
0.4689891338,
0.1980748922,
0.1483144909,
-0.0459831692,
-0.6641373038,
-0.5812935233,
-0.1224401072,
0.0748295933,
0.2971606851,
0.1706071049,
0.2624252141,
0.2394438833,
0.174303472,
-0.4916783869,
-0.3327321112,
-0.1857419461,
-0.2201634794,
0.2076837122,
0.1297370195,
0.0855343342,
-0.0916436836,
-0.6311731935,
-0.0531019121,
-0.4375192821,
0.0757265314,
0.0677611083,
0.6808615923,
-0.0792173147,
0.3375172913,
0.0668197125,
0.8885205984,
0.1746104956,
0.1958543807,
0.5522298217,
-0.3608202338,
-0.1510104835,
-0.1357510686,
0.5900970101,
0.1452938914,
0.3642957509,
0.0070134313,
-0.4052454829,
0.0332662314,
0.2942286134,
-0.5962693095,
-0.0074785119,
-0.0634899363,
-0.6377477646,
-0.0123929651,
0.0929382145,
-0.8134596944,
-0.2693302035,
-0.3836764395,
0.7289812565,
-0.6416500211,
-0.5177927017,
0.1493414342,
-0.0974331796,
-0.3354067504,
0.6317923665,
-0.6658833027,
0.2982686162,
0.442610085,
0.9904050827,
0.0402891524,
-0.5102789402,
-0.7329639196,
0.0006289255,
-0.2042119801,
1.0775752068,
-0.7190262675,
-0.3234000504,
-0.1170749441,
-0.1587696671,
-0.4737560153,
-0.0603047125,
0.2402748466,
-0.5281944275,
0.2957575619,
-0.4577090144,
-0.3423544466,
-0.3920255303,
0.549213469,
-0.90742594,
0.8096588254,
0.2655098438,
-0.5797280073,
0.4537646174,
-0.8384038806,
-0.4956642985,
0.2387708575,
-0.4167880416,
-0.3012424111,
0.0713588744,
0.4518225491,
0.3517387211,
-0.1475456804,
0.1363106072,
-0.400105536,
-0.5131736994,
0.4699344933,
-0.5890588164,
0.4902688861,
0.1956383139,
-0.1976931393,
0.2830605507,
-0.3845147491,
0.1915949732,
0.0672705695,
-0.2216936946,
-0.3159519434,
-0.194712624,
-0.3286666572,
0.3672561347,
0.0918470323,
-0.132582128,
0.6957415342,
-0.1738248616,
0.5871710181,
1.0970584154,
0.2920651734,
0.423066318,
-0.3201347589,
0.5167939067,
0.2070024461,
0.2893915176,
-0.626911521,
-0.7263213992,
-0.5645033121,
-0.3279564679,
0.307754606,
0.3852056265,
-1.0643808842,
0.224998042,
0.0854135454,
-0.026776813,
-0.1788803339,
0.1282411367,
0.3326736987,
0.6997054219,
0.3855570257,
-0.4389969409,
0.0203945972,
-0.3705213666,
-0.0561307035,
-0.1664968729,
0.2272297889,
0.4272187352,
0.5989521742,
-0.0520976521,
0.7009603381,
-0.6170751452,
-0.2698592842,
-0.1359532326,
0.4977481961,
0.3416590691,
0.3529281914,
0.3225447237,
-0.9319954515,
-0.2400636673,
-0.2067242116,
-0.5118123293,
0.17844823,
-0.2487451732,
-0.2562877536,
0.035867881,
0.3309042752,
-0.7657263875,
0.3444690108,
-0.1222038567,
-0.5424594879,
0.5172789693,
-0.3804779053,
0.4615920484,
-0.926867485,
-0.1802704483,
-0.0519235693,
-0.194323644,
-0.2254237086,
0.026672069,
0.1628171802,
-0.3245805204,
-0.3135056198,
0.2492260635,
-0.6330666542,
0.2033088654,
-0.2710624337,
0.16087313,
0.1571704149,
0.9231465459,
-0.087451674,
0.8504542112,
0.9864759445,
-0.7344376445,
0.3347815871,
0.1023371071,
0.0063840519,
0.8986741304,
-0.411976546,
0.7162126303,
-0.3615249097,
0.6472136974,
-1.17337358,
0.0050078738,
0.3660164475,
-0.2189093083,
0.3264343441,
-0.2355351001,
-0.4436292052,
-0.4383511841,
-0.4218394756,
0.7312328219,
0.2275382727,
-0.3919931352,
1.0359648466,
0.063272275,
-0.1015661135,
-0.3392725885,
-0.4271691442,
-0.2214524597,
-0.0574662872,
-0.5885692835,
0.2393946499,
-0.2227429152,
0.1604606658,
0.0251368415,
-0.0531466082,
-0.0018845317,
-0.2264104635,
0.0473239943,
0.3964215517,
-0.3479646742,
0.5858436823,
0.2624306679,
-0.2202608883,
-0.1337545365,
-0.5530796051,
0.472904712,
-0.5187738538,
-0.544551909,
-0.0639340281,
0.5231211782,
0.5728714466,
-0.2928462029,
0.415535152,
0.6933836341,
-0.2742116749,
-0.3750782013,
-0.2865969837,
-0.4572400451,
-0.5127292275,
0.0732561052,
-0.5823692679,
-0.7760663033,
0.5312227011,
-0.5291688442,
-0.1500006318,
0.0979675129,
0.6231011748,
-0.0748639405,
1.4537147284,
0.2671041489,
0.2592037022,
0.5934879184,
-0.4162576199,
0.1162595227,
-0.7614064217,
-0.3669627905,
-0.1116120368,
-0.5997089148,
-0.2650310695,
-0.6045681238,
0.7304821014,
0.0375829749,
-0.3154985309,
-0.2014125288,
-0.6952027082,
0.4861780405,
0.371172905,
0.72340554,
0.1628336459,
-0.0290723443,
-0.5289472342,
0.3470410705,
-0.7164732814,
-0.0871926695,
0.6428758502,
-0.1369998455,
0.7975087166,
-0.0074279313,
0.413518995,
0.5123255849,
0.0239198767,
-0.8061532974,
0.7211850286,
0.1233630106,
-0.3790373802,
-0.2441532463,
-0.4186490774,
-1.0819063187,
0.5282182693,
-0.1185976639,
-0.5218422413,
0.3407593369,
0.3926533759,
-0.4232300222,
0.3297296762,
-0.8468942642,
0.6049803495,
-0.30174613,
-0.4365508556,
-0.3880379498,
-0.6554577351,
0.0071578398,
0.1954081804,
0.2496997565,
0.0631855056,
-0.3182117939,
0.4965595603,
-0.3539108336,
0.9697449207,
-0.2794424295,
0.1125512496,
0.8365495801,
0.2145519555,
0.7329506874,
0.0480166934,
-0.0063210111,
-0.1283389628,
-0.7455747724,
-0.2904031575,
-0.8608894944,
0.479118228,
-0.4016434848,
-0.4808332324,
-0.3906858265,
-0.5941532254,
-0.2354343086,
0.3752207458,
0.143674314,
0.9300464988,
0.0232818946,
-0.2484333217,
0.591588676,
0.3714229465,
0.3775832951,
0.2543303967,
-0.2474206388,
-0.7243802547,
0.926671505,
0.161030367,
0.2467303574,
0.1001623571,
0.368122071,
-0.4560886323,
-0.2228097022,
-0.6377180219,
0.3083600998,
-0.8192336559,
-0.40437904,
-0.5736118555,
0.2815751433,
-0.3383538425,
-0.2375911027,
-0.0019025616,
-0.4635099471,
-0.220988065,
-0.1878835708,
0.5537780523,
0.7610262036,
-0.0806620792,
0.0427670814,
-0.4796478748,
0.5620574355,
0.8285694122,
0.5929259062,
0.3223176003,
-0.2646050155,
-0.0164340325,
0.1051135585,
-0.5292612314,
-1.0962039232,
-0.0881429389,
0.3622696102,
0.3908361793,
0.4630808532,
-0.1570133716,
0.7430170774,
-0.4552662075,
0.5910827518,
0.5168418884,
-0.8481871486,
0.7023528218,
-0.4939783812,
0.4551487267,
0.5460794568,
0.1525742859,
-0.3810116947,
-0.1675289273,
-0.4082670808,
-0.7703028917,
0.670455873,
-0.0489734188,
0.236149773,
-0.3289478421,
0.1975863576,
0.4208644927,
0.2680793107,
-0.64249897,
-0.2870128155,
-0.5635385513,
0.1053478047,
0.4573121369,
0.0086502284,
0.062406376,
-0.4200232625,
0.3640837967,
-0.6585569382,
0.5641964078,
0.3109771013,
-0.1990134567,
-0.4541575313,
0.3767254651,
0.356697917,
0.7360569239,
-0.0676666051,
0.416041851,
0.3429740369,
-0.3588359952,
0.1101432666,
-0.0983162522,
-0.0199057441,
-0.2908542156,
0.173128143,
1.0068142414,
0.2339078635,
-0.2830819786,
0.4748322368,
-0.0638477653,
-0.2649129927,
0.2229645699,
0.2119636089,
-0.0965186581,
0.3704257905,
0.5515645742,
0.4419436753,
0.230413422,
-0.6852187514,
0.1143160909,
0.2555499971,
-0.4601776004,
-0.4934429526,
0.6227616668,
0.3346848488,
-0.5227321386,
0.8039533496,
-0.300127089,
-0.7341096401,
0.4169363678,
0.6651076078,
0.8577205539,
-0.1847737581,
0.3756631911,
0.2678536177,
0.04564761,
0.0919821933,
0.7892209888,
-0.43457973,
-0.5824763775,
-0.5513077378,
0.0239945427,
-0.264927119,
-0.0158967637,
-0.4746416211,
0.3623690903,
-0.432590127,
-0.6432198286,
-0.1546972245,
-0.3243982792,
-0.7292134166,
0.1444320679,
0.3818258643,
0.7720143795,
-0.8671376705,
0.5613495111,
0.8537717462,
-0.6488289237,
-0.8242171407,
-0.1119483337,
-0.1205606312,
-0.7056520581,
0.2584793866,
0.3802555501,
-0.6145601273,
0.112664558,
-0.5156726241,
-0.5890325904,
0.9826352596,
0.3797141016,
-0.31250301,
0.0490293652,
-0.3394542933,
0.2798175514,
-0.4825922847,
0.3976021707,
0.0264278147,
0.628092289,
0.1076510549,
-0.6375789642,
0.4004702568,
-0.3648720682,
-0.3352713883,
0.412789613,
-0.8998686671,
1.2917808294,
-0.4910363555,
-0.1965984851,
-0.4396051466,
0.6599801183,
0.3139564097,
0.4432353377,
1.0750465393,
0.2006381601,
1.05696702,
0.2809546888,
0.8486315012,
-0.049550008,
0.3259200156,
0.8179704547,
-0.389131248,
0.2443564981,
0.3021631241,
-0.0314423144,
0.9192460775,
0.4091967344,
0.2591056228,
0.5694445372,
-0.324436456,
-0.3453505337,
-0.5078477263,
-0.0064299623,
-0.4686309695,
0.1317543536,
0.6236432195,
-0.2002129108,
-0.2426177561,
0.1968540549,
-0.2723353803,
-0.1521503776,
-0.5572074056,
0.7541592717,
0.1774363667,
-1.0190739632,
0.6100853682,
-0.4551445842,
0.5335627794,
-0.5482691526,
-0.3626383245,
0.0993430838,
-0.0001771053,
0.0591665395,
-0.8566713929,
-0.3249860406,
-0.3040287495,
-0.1184817553,
-0.4557439685,
1.1291350126,
-0.430524826,
-0.4024089873,
0.2927748859,
0.8875867128,
0.0384528264,
-0.1933045983,
-1.0590745211,
-0.1849194318,
-0.2807964683,
-0.4598226547,
0.1848558187,
0.7697260976,
-0.1776762456,
0.4678751826,
0.5663065314,
-0.2297106534,
-0.109636277,
0.6327875257,
1.2050249577,
-0.6030900478,
-0.8489436507,
-0.9434062243,
0.46152246,
0.0133430883,
-0.4000266492,
0.3184993565,
0.2480778396,
0.3269709945,
0.0420129709,
0.6221132278,
-0.1566568464,
0.1289688796,
-0.5922623277,
0.3975299001,
-0.5498533249,
-0.2648174763,
-0.333265394,
-0.8665403128,
-0.0480043329,
0.6636173129,
-0.2947734892,
0.5104485154,
1.2102388144,
0.6157584786,
-0.3299948573,
0.3634090126,
0.1095572934,
0.0060456088,
0.0262547042,
0.595169127,
0.8422906995,
-0.0242571011,
0.5190873742,
0.0200736094,
-0.2800647616,
-0.1265748292,
-0.9574699402,
-0.9014934897,
-0.8628633618,
-0.2198493928,
-0.3680801094,
-0.0313144587,
1.0987027884,
0.6744714975,
-0.4303429723,
0.1246079952,
-0.1655988097,
0.3222530782,
-0.6542990804,
-0.1601532847,
0.5388196111,
-0.5278737545,
-0.2838177681,
0.3968871534,
0.324888736,
-0.0660980716,
-0.153731972,
-0.1136571765,
-0.4143901765,
0.1123036444,
0.6708756685,
-0.0868520662,
-0.4012208879,
-0.2444576621,
-0.0961951986,
0.1858149618,
0.4024873972,
1.4254472256,
-1.1781724691,
0.6742267013,
0.5605372787,
-0.030160116,
0.5234596133,
0.165547207,
0.4395824671,
-0.7973687053,
0.241018042,
0.2834308445,
0.4864593148,
0.1219215244,
-0.5060614944,
0.3755319417,
0.365600884,
-0.4736046791,
-0.5597889423,
0.3958922327,
-1.0771336555,
-0.511844337,
0.7598627806,
0.1472773701,
-0.4675390124,
-0.4135793746,
-0.5047672391,
0.4653986394,
-0.8639153838,
0.6530429721,
0.4891826808,
-0.4452554286,
-0.0647290796,
-0.0809938312,
-0.0444950424,
0.2763964236,
-0.6211446524,
0.0729876459,
0.6642485261,
-0.0367634594,
0.1633042395,
0.9710942507,
0.1133796498,
0.6208526492,
0.0510113277,
-0.3337884843,
-0.5107368231,
-0.4921273589,
-0.2152466476,
0.4268026054,
-0.1193288937,
-0.1225762293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04530v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04530v2
|
A Morphology-Based Investigation of Positional Encodings
| 2024-04-06T07:10:47 | 2024-05-30T14:44:10 |
Poulami Ghosh, Shikhar Vashishth, Raj Dabre, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Contemporary deep learning models effectively handle languages with diverse
morphology despite not being directly integrated into them. Morphology and word
order are closely linked, with the latter incorporated into transformer-based
models through positional encodings. This prompts a fundamental inquiry: Is
there a correlation between the morphological complexity of a language and the
utilization of positional encoding in pre-trained language models? In pursuit
of an answer, we present the first study addressing this question, encompassing
22 languages and 5 downstream tasks. Our findings reveal that the importance of
positional encoding diminishes with increasing morphological complexity in
languages. Our study motivates the need for a deeper understanding of
positional encoding, augmenting them to better reflect the different languages
under consideration.
|
[
-0.073869966,
-0.4357383847,
0.7145172954,
0.2129216939,
-0.245695591,
-0.0143465232,
-0.1880652159,
-0.5603114963,
0.2844287753,
0.1982956231,
-0.3158017993,
-0.3473154902,
-1.0708687305,
0.2154241055,
-0.404728353,
0.2934469581,
-0.0165714752,
0.4646072388,
0.0181190167,
-0.0929386094,
-0.4553107619,
-0.959980607,
-0.4341579378,
-0.3437975049,
0.518659234,
-0.1435634494,
1.0500520468,
1.0253367424,
0.6364019513,
0.4272904396,
-0.3589001596,
-0.1173772067,
-0.2165214121,
0.1862691343,
-0.2197410166,
-0.7490026355,
-0.113135621,
-0.2050404847,
0.7364856005,
1.3257039785,
-0.0537590384,
-0.2779726386,
-0.1317675114,
0.4500079751,
-0.7496033907,
-0.0192679577,
-0.4702907503,
0.2105206996,
-0.3823022842,
-0.2783564031,
-0.4050748348,
-0.0534000024,
0.2524612546,
-0.1639419645,
0.1802050918,
-0.628737092,
0.8361048698,
0.3130870759,
-0.3356444836,
-0.375793308,
-0.7579432726,
0.6780561209,
-0.4693978727,
0.886400342,
0.3766975999,
-0.1373436749,
0.0171318129,
-0.7364316583,
-0.2468589842,
-0.034708865,
-0.3865957856,
0.0994275436,
-0.1226307899,
0.1460302621,
0.0031993911,
0.4521552026,
-0.5571500063,
0.6585806608,
-0.4592283368,
-0.145566538,
0.5807054043,
0.1062461883,
0.770716548,
-0.2357099056,
0.1008783579,
-0.4365952611,
-0.6600264311,
0.1223817617,
0.4046974182,
0.3000291288,
-0.1240216717,
0.7271586657,
-0.0357660875,
0.5368085504,
0.185839355,
0.0692683682,
0.2312515676,
-0.2948558033,
-0.2408480942,
0.3570777774,
0.7435315847,
-0.16970478,
-0.1181940064,
-0.091222778,
-0.21916008,
-0.0394457988,
0.681987226,
-0.727799058,
-0.0147049548,
0.0767704621,
-0.3083624542,
-0.167972222,
0.1442726552,
-0.254789263,
-0.4031555057,
-0.3695149422,
0.2004819363,
-0.7539530993,
-0.3326466382,
0.3107536733,
0.1481207907,
0.5900195241,
0.2091915905,
-1.3303995132,
0.1569637954,
1.0304416418,
0.7757014632,
-0.1770116985,
-0.5865005255,
0.0385019705,
-0.153951183,
-0.8489489555,
0.7303889394,
-0.9126146436,
-0.5375164747,
0.1821174175,
0.1633917689,
-0.2500210404,
-0.4635972083,
0.3903911114,
-0.5079950094,
0.1718680561,
-0.0223078616,
-0.6209548116,
-0.2442458123,
0.0163799766,
-0.7511555552,
0.7287858725,
0.0364032313,
-0.477260828,
0.3651781678,
-0.2389080971,
-0.718452394,
0.124394998,
-0.4001565874,
-0.1460910738,
0.65967834,
0.1228812933,
0.5419254303,
0.1509514749,
0.3513631821,
0.1216715798,
-0.3312450945,
0.266975224,
-0.4828881323,
0.5905636549,
0.1272862256,
-0.2596414685,
0.1093440279,
-0.4761363566,
-0.2109105885,
0.2199020088,
-0.3042184711,
-0.4248550832,
-0.0389047675,
-0.4416898787,
-0.014572775,
0.3909253478,
-0.2741495967,
0.1508500576,
-0.6327562332,
0.5472949743,
0.4707728028,
-0.1521469653,
1.0500274897,
0.3576138616,
0.5555462837,
0.192409277,
0.1041578427,
-0.1374550909,
-0.5380932093,
-0.8055547476,
0.1054389477,
0.2946711779,
0.4663799405,
-0.5428064466,
0.2511305213,
-0.4909495413,
-0.5387594104,
-0.4806993008,
-0.1795052141,
0.5519328117,
-0.0340811722,
0.1381819695,
-0.6116895676,
-0.4257282615,
-0.8866155744,
0.1003337353,
-0.1439583004,
0.1750032902,
-0.0570279956,
0.4477665424,
-0.2600868642,
0.5703482628,
-0.2834426463,
0.3085680902,
-0.2742542922,
0.3425279558,
0.3333095908,
0.5922859907,
0.859490037,
-0.8207028508,
-0.2284058034,
0.0915183723,
-0.7927643657,
0.3610488176,
0.1160557717,
0.0645333827,
0.0919410735,
0.5847297907,
-0.9342900515,
0.3433888555,
0.6302705407,
-0.114620164,
0.3514993787,
-0.6895227432,
0.0695620701,
-0.9141690135,
-0.1470102072,
-0.2530098855,
0.2808762491,
-1.1877123117,
0.2598381639,
0.2271373272,
-0.3431847095,
-0.4988426566,
0.3689371049,
-0.6086394191,
-0.2916840613,
-0.1642953455,
-0.3647996783,
-0.1250812709,
0.4974273741,
0.4966875017,
0.7534171343,
0.7028409243,
-0.7213460803,
-0.1589176953,
0.2105534077,
-0.3457629085,
0.1846970618,
-0.5727965236,
0.2076393366,
-0.3539400995,
-0.1146365181,
-0.7999037504,
-0.3789708316,
0.1414897442,
-0.4485324025,
0.7854250669,
-0.3682250977,
-0.2884477675,
-0.188170135,
-0.1190510988,
0.5883713365,
0.6434311867,
-0.1899501383,
0.181961298,
0.3890049458,
-0.0554395914,
-0.6809186935,
-0.6691501737,
-0.0063320296,
-0.3147377074,
-0.3266833425,
0.5649867654,
0.1529777944,
-0.2147261202,
-0.2764768004,
-0.3229967952,
-0.315182507,
0.2355185449,
0.1820428669,
-0.1288833618,
-0.5465071797,
0.0029991963,
0.0934591442,
-0.0258684848,
0.0780657008,
-0.5764158368,
0.9802376032,
0.1205077991,
-0.5385445356,
-0.4427860379,
0.2415135801,
0.6463266015,
-0.506708622,
0.7929896712,
0.4830594957,
-0.4543665051,
0.1517127603,
-0.2750014365,
-0.0453593954,
-0.523131609,
0.6453372836,
-0.681661129,
-0.7059350014,
0.5750547647,
0.0790043846,
-0.3705961108,
0.4496488571,
0.4145521224,
-0.1594529897,
1.1454530954,
0.9186066389,
-0.0248830244,
0.7635019422,
-0.3159793913,
0.2729786336,
-0.4542898536,
-0.4267118573,
-0.6287823319,
-0.1690069884,
-0.8437364697,
-0.5131946802,
-0.0864590853,
0.251544714,
-0.0313562155,
0.5284278989,
-0.5830873847,
0.4224430919,
0.3999637961,
0.1689223349,
-0.2321565896,
0.0475699492,
0.0733421743,
-0.0751120597,
-0.7320507765,
-0.4254991412,
0.7017294168,
0.3764379025,
0.549471736,
-0.0128260311,
0.7477201819,
0.0756907463,
-0.4194130003,
-0.9660003781,
0.3717050552,
-0.5719641447,
-0.1734707355,
-0.4126963615,
0.0241790302,
-1.4730279446,
0.1989581883,
0.1527768373,
-0.6303536892,
0.6751965284,
-0.1337081492,
-0.254834801,
0.203455776,
-0.664917469,
0.8081442118,
-0.5971443057,
-0.0204995535,
-0.262660414,
-0.6070102453,
-0.0758158937,
0.1180354953,
0.1052350253,
0.1585858166,
0.0119050862,
0.7895953059,
-0.5267611742,
0.8394082189,
-0.0482707396,
-0.6064912081,
0.0308300462,
0.3055367172,
0.1826834679,
-0.1280184835,
0.0183130167,
0.3865469396,
-0.1867586225,
-0.4562474787,
-0.6732524633,
0.5042110682,
-0.9816832542,
-0.7106804848,
-0.3305248916,
-0.5032631159,
-0.0851076618,
0.3204317391,
0.5886244774,
0.7107444406,
-0.0728902593,
0.0096004587,
0.8413573503,
-0.4125559926,
0.5301709175,
0.0506108031,
0.0597489066,
-0.1038260609,
0.8352197409,
0.2733407915,
-0.0266592465,
0.9917763472,
0.2019412965,
-0.3436565399,
-1.2259581089,
-0.3605346084,
0.224710986,
-0.9249004126,
0.1759651452,
-0.6329934597,
-0.4909667075,
-0.586830616,
-0.3104272485,
-0.6165707111,
-0.2950139046,
-0.3389485478,
-0.2510994077,
0.1394266635,
1.2065657377,
0.0580618605,
0.3673013151,
-0.863609314,
0.1720803529,
0.2842675149,
0.3939169943,
-0.1379814893,
-0.5219064355,
-0.1152326614,
0.1511314809,
0.3224947453,
-1.0003461838,
0.5094709396,
0.1387962997,
0.8526198268,
0.3983307481,
-0.3953135312,
0.758715868,
-0.7307865024,
0.914018631,
0.1028648764,
-0.8846424222,
0.6312521696,
-0.156441167,
0.4088498056,
0.3038736284,
0.6526845694,
-0.3899964988,
-0.2268635035,
-0.5301480293,
-0.8470953107,
0.8378623724,
0.2751893997,
0.5662407875,
-0.2498291731,
0.4543465674,
0.3781571984,
-0.0890437216,
-0.3794168532,
-0.114622198,
-0.4002469182,
-0.2266016454,
-0.2639040351,
-0.6602634192,
0.2991700172,
-0.1670761853,
0.1132648736,
0.1400569081,
0.5316681862,
0.1216995269,
-0.7126927376,
0.385984242,
0.1762153804,
1.0248645544,
0.6032002568,
0.1239002943,
0.378827244,
0.0750965625,
-0.8555202484,
0.1976813972,
-0.1644133627,
-0.0954242647,
0.2173164189,
0.6953371763,
1.1291921139,
0.3617398143,
-0.3223420084,
0.2885592878,
0.1233428866,
-0.0344056077,
-0.1701645851,
-0.0584690683,
-0.0335280821,
0.1553838998,
0.1319804192,
-0.0396163687,
0.1815921515,
-0.5377044082,
0.1241196841,
0.2943351269,
-0.6432201862,
-0.766808331,
0.2703049779,
0.0445223823,
-0.463073343,
0.833314538,
0.0202989131,
-0.6344857812,
0.7157495022,
0.5629332662,
0.7689305544,
-0.6195785403,
0.1239254028,
0.4451568723,
0.1889230907,
-0.0630334616,
0.1892369837,
-0.0132552776,
-0.8286437988,
-0.4786348343,
-0.8715852499,
-0.2170329839,
0.1371816695,
-0.5438334346,
0.0915527195,
-0.3306492567,
-0.0254360586,
0.0668356791,
-0.4107514918,
-0.5092085004,
0.3100673556,
0.7560166121,
0.6206718087,
-0.6441460252,
0.8189951181,
1.0925564766,
-0.4456477165,
-0.7135131955,
-0.2181525975,
-0.2415350974,
-1.0121977329,
0.8885022402,
0.2980599999,
-0.3055972457,
-0.0523472242,
-0.4684849679,
-1.1179577112,
0.9339415431,
0.5131579041,
-0.1808049381,
-0.1902098358,
0.7222727537,
0.8496688008,
-0.0984443799,
0.1651977003,
0.4539322853,
0.2052041739,
-0.0935696661,
-0.8506299853,
-0.0701729432,
-0.4373310506,
0.3481085896,
0.3956976533,
-0.2204968035,
0.8771444559,
0.127695471,
-0.4842977524,
0.0156470146,
0.5992396474,
-0.1002657562,
-0.4179250598,
0.2092534304,
0.3764895499,
0.688862741,
-0.1219926625,
1.3330500126,
-0.355294764,
0.0520478114,
0.8302122951,
-0.0045339423,
0.6663735509,
0.4298374653,
-0.1688578129,
0.4083369374,
0.9596190453,
0.0011125195,
0.6579877734,
0.0143080056,
0.1272501945,
-0.1876396388,
-0.2243065387,
-0.420132935,
0.7309732437,
0.516230166,
-0.3687177896,
0.0230388008,
0.1226698905,
0.001352115,
0.0694469586,
-0.468705982,
0.8173252344,
0.1011627167,
-0.7494518757,
0.6356222034,
-0.0452635884,
0.667247653,
-0.7098838687,
0.0515649691,
-0.4728762209,
0.0566902757,
-0.0487516783,
-1.118586421,
0.3279352486,
-0.2957218587,
-0.0676564574,
-0.6343278289,
0.8214240074,
-0.243589133,
-0.282232821,
0.4207912087,
0.5033727884,
0.3668452799,
-0.0491735004,
-0.3196121156,
-0.0500307903,
-0.3697147369,
-0.1682571918,
0.3208308816,
0.6117030978,
-0.3693757653,
0.5066452622,
0.5138233304,
-0.0909950286,
0.5267313719,
0.3588225842,
0.4008444846,
-0.6974274516,
-0.5758854151,
-1.0001559258,
0.395188421,
0.2192822397,
-0.0756744221,
0.5265547037,
0.3149334788,
1.0932706594,
-0.510442853,
0.416372776,
-0.0946552753,
-0.3867068589,
-0.6400090456,
0.7412327528,
-0.5227215886,
-0.0407546274,
0.0092343092,
-0.8266364336,
-0.5051732063,
0.4990495741,
-0.4578947425,
-0.1005183235,
0.75556916,
0.4560230672,
-0.2651059628,
-0.1528064907,
0.4994868338,
-0.0913165361,
-0.0230615996,
0.3384133875,
1.1445996761,
-0.3108024001,
0.3908721805,
-0.7425811291,
0.3914052844,
-0.133833617,
-0.4285791516,
-0.6834166646,
-0.7542853355,
-0.1569025218,
0.1528390944,
-0.0430475548,
0.551635623,
0.7526448369,
-1.0171554089,
-0.2754181623,
-0.4112955034,
0.0175660718,
-0.2920552194,
-0.055303663,
0.5386648178,
-0.5824488401,
-1.0757430792,
0.5238696337,
0.3651714325,
0.4087522626,
-0.0517943725,
-0.0411255471,
-0.18658714,
-0.1670646667,
0.7821103334,
0.1313459426,
-0.8137592077,
-0.3247772455,
0.438247025,
-0.4145655632,
0.4822028279,
1.0296547413,
-0.5025833845,
0.1138609052,
0.8459858894,
0.7092531323,
0.3666679263,
-0.3442723155,
0.7889335155,
-0.8778260946,
0.3388972282,
0.0492296256,
0.582213223,
0.4256324768,
-0.5089184642,
0.5452542305,
0.0158479176,
0.1250884086,
-0.6333853602,
0.4875105321,
-0.8944967389,
-0.4014545083,
0.8310149908,
-0.0837923065,
-0.2478055954,
0.085409373,
-0.0215047207,
0.5292617083,
0.0894735232,
0.4657261968,
0.5995217562,
-0.1014598235,
-0.4168639183,
-0.1914716214,
0.4584434628,
0.4645810127,
-0.5644941926,
-0.2736138999,
0.1989669353,
0.0108645856,
0.591551125,
0.3298220336,
-0.1806434393,
0.0182780735,
0.1973060966,
-0.1312647313,
0.3227642179,
-0.4609075189,
-0.868694663,
0.2762504518,
0.2108322084,
-0.1271168739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04525v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04525v1
|
IITK at SemEval-2024 Task 10: Who is the speaker? Improving Emotion Recognition and Flip Reasoning in Conversations via Speaker Embeddings
| 2024-04-06T06:47:44 | 2024-04-06T06:47:44 |
Shubham Patel, Divyaksh Shukla, Ashutosh Modi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper presents our approach for the SemEval-2024 Task 10: Emotion
Discovery and Reasoning its Flip in Conversations. For the Emotion Recognition
in Conversations (ERC) task, we utilize a masked-memory network along with
speaker participation. We propose a transformer-based speaker-centric model for
the Emotion Flip Reasoning (EFR) task. We also introduce Probable Trigger Zone,
a region of the conversation that is more likely to contain the utterances
causing the emotion to flip. For sub-task 3, the proposed approach achieves a
5.9 (F1 score) improvement over the task baseline. The ablation study results
highlight the significance of various design choices in the proposed method.
|
[
-0.7529935241,
-0.5638386011,
0.4668596089,
0.1906345934,
-0.2513245642,
-0.1527032554,
-0.0508947596,
-0.4896920323,
0.5688511133,
0.6637893915,
-0.5075800419,
-0.1324719936,
-0.6062093973,
0.0479177274,
-0.3389695883,
0.5299969316,
0.158719644,
-0.1517970115,
-0.065034993,
-0.2409493476,
-0.2216736227,
-0.4149399698,
-0.6067213416,
-0.7560697198,
0.1532697529,
0.9566422105,
0.0568693243,
0.0597122684,
0.1616089046,
0.318128109,
-0.1918197572,
-0.063736029,
-0.2840616405,
0.3177670538,
-0.2389359027,
-0.1356306523,
-0.4929824769,
-0.1059346199,
0.1179835349,
0.2460300475,
-0.3330203295,
-0.2935497165,
-0.1712608337,
0.6123257279,
-0.4697089493,
0.1269309074,
-0.5752977729,
0.2087046057,
-0.0294668954,
-0.4259801209,
-0.7490640283,
0.032538157,
0.2534319162,
0.1639279872,
0.1228321567,
0.1039165556,
0.4689650238,
0.2424627692,
-0.8318842053,
-0.1625119597,
-0.7501316667,
0.35975492,
-0.5485529304,
0.6472479701,
0.3514679968,
0.1859749854,
0.2933886349,
-0.4773790538,
-0.743670404,
0.1765007377,
0.1214339212,
0.279335469,
-0.219625771,
0.2240004092,
0.4143090546,
0.2553554177,
-0.2586986721,
-0.2366767824,
-0.1074266955,
-0.177540645,
0.5289218426,
0.1339456886,
0.2029007524,
-0.0839026868,
-0.1786252856,
-0.2793696225,
-0.6409249306,
0.1604850441,
0.6008357406,
0.2193812877,
0.0582928509,
0.4634956121,
-0.3319929838,
0.190534547,
0.3144720197,
0.3145797551,
0.4962151349,
-0.1415489316,
-0.114986062,
0.5351558924,
0.3062560856,
0.3512330055,
0.0943846405,
0.3217993975,
0.0837426856,
-0.3001671433,
0.5829725266,
-0.8320209384,
-0.4290125966,
0.313739568,
-0.3608923554,
-0.1875356138,
-0.0052627106,
-0.9227203727,
-0.4007286727,
-0.0263236389,
0.7157415748,
-0.4221042395,
-0.5304656625,
0.0282592345,
0.0767158344,
0.3168036938,
0.5085480809,
-0.8817407489,
0.4052803814,
0.6678321362,
0.2837399244,
0.1960199773,
0.0080973981,
-0.477599591,
-0.0921211913,
0.0831275359,
1.0541695356,
-0.7316402197,
-0.4251900613,
0.0515007824,
0.3976301849,
-0.0077809314,
-0.333604455,
0.9007867575,
-0.3347066641,
0.3012809455,
-0.4809635282,
-0.4501088858,
-0.4052430987,
0.2694041133,
-0.5696340203,
1.0291399956,
-0.1493025124,
-0.8129276037,
-0.0886626914,
-0.6070376039,
-0.4971394241,
0.0147708347,
-0.1030667052,
-0.6821042895,
0.0595652424,
0.2014864534,
0.3428762257,
0.0166488104,
-0.0457402952,
-0.0716873705,
-0.4143846333,
0.1214086488,
-0.0234756153,
0.1794455498,
0.1346970052,
-0.9344558716,
-0.0082991188,
-0.4752165079,
-0.0675429329,
-0.0021677071,
-0.0607726797,
-0.2450516373,
0.0906244442,
-0.1524007916,
0.1140410677,
-0.2925114632,
-0.821608603,
0.0418710969,
-0.4758952856,
0.1976972073,
0.8594783545,
0.2031636387,
0.5673792958,
0.1615134627,
0.3447157145,
0.4579720497,
0.0229033232,
-0.5563459396,
-0.7498765588,
-1.1157361269,
0.1012012288,
0.0014911051,
0.5194280744,
-0.6900705695,
0.1473452151,
0.0513080508,
-0.3736405075,
-0.4037029147,
-0.5000195503,
0.3726758957,
0.6763651967,
0.3488267958,
0.0294336621,
-0.5695781708,
-1.0483096838,
-0.4948912561,
-0.1471469998,
0.2713119388,
0.6780515313,
0.3132093251,
-0.2415754944,
0.5660364628,
-0.2984729111,
0.0811852142,
-0.2041878551,
0.4202409685,
0.1576388031,
0.4253671765,
0.1246777475,
-1.0027606487,
-0.6398804784,
0.0297305528,
-0.2396633029,
-0.5142017603,
0.0200773254,
-0.0728278533,
0.4144500494,
0.6725879908,
-0.2580867708,
0.8342351913,
0.3104039133,
-0.7187715769,
0.1752012372,
0.0694909394,
0.609772861,
-0.8202552795,
-0.24082537,
-0.0750400349,
-0.2641136348,
-1.0521602631,
-0.597954154,
0.2415305078,
-0.1782647073,
-0.3977349102,
0.6185273528,
-0.2266837955,
-0.1303357482,
-0.3630875945,
-0.1735043675,
-0.0739385411,
0.600826025,
0.2327050716,
0.4334098995,
0.1227544621,
-0.4190943837,
0.2815788388,
0.3244019747,
-0.2515675128,
0.8538451791,
-0.580883503,
0.6186195016,
-0.0646310598,
0.1949436516,
-0.9922613502,
-0.0922916904,
0.285882622,
-0.4365296662,
0.6146547198,
-0.0712221414,
0.0179897323,
-0.292530328,
-0.1148875952,
0.3792698681,
0.4674518704,
-0.6506504416,
1.1378173828,
0.3249458373,
-0.4615083933,
-0.3940929174,
-0.5352918506,
0.1286443323,
-0.2390279919,
-0.7679229975,
0.5668094754,
0.014345861,
-0.1835949272,
-0.1270167679,
-0.0945541635,
0.3863208592,
-0.1616497189,
0.5988980532,
-0.3077163398,
0.117099002,
0.2866816223,
0.0195943359,
-0.4264824986,
-0.0582753979,
0.0396621712,
0.5051297545,
-0.490945816,
-0.6787590384,
-0.2303219736,
0.7055742741,
0.3474713266,
-0.077677004,
0.6258378029,
0.652049005,
-0.4483484924,
-0.3057700992,
-0.9157081842,
-0.45416677,
-0.4531981647,
0.5067644119,
-0.5703036189,
-1.1401863098,
0.7201583385,
-0.5071696043,
-0.463665694,
0.3071779013,
0.8760547638,
-0.1921083033,
1.1551003456,
0.6997417808,
0.1946331412,
0.5815040469,
0.0073109684,
0.763052702,
-0.9863683581,
-0.5959138274,
-0.6407909393,
-0.5135346651,
-0.4359264672,
-0.5109151602,
0.5700421929,
-0.225126788,
-0.4657710791,
0.3911153972,
-0.4870911539,
0.2905719578,
0.4871506393,
0.1454791576,
-0.0611656047,
-0.2400101572,
-0.0462231003,
-0.1123862714,
-0.3220820725,
-0.2501806021,
0.5021240115,
0.5538342595,
0.615101397,
0.1223939657,
0.8652139306,
0.166409865,
-0.035952881,
-0.5721902251,
0.7220320106,
0.3048074543,
-0.53672719,
-0.4844475091,
-0.145184055,
-0.4060134888,
0.1814404875,
0.2222244292,
-1.1035908461,
0.5150709152,
-0.088103883,
-0.0127173364,
0.241735369,
-0.6734756827,
0.8966379762,
-0.0395152532,
0.0706689581,
-0.4342679083,
-0.6420673132,
-0.0135420971,
0.2693220675,
0.192522049,
-0.1301925331,
0.2863138318,
0.6916892529,
-0.5439115167,
0.6468985677,
-0.4929688275,
0.1618525386,
0.417257309,
0.2423517555,
0.9415646195,
-0.105026722,
-0.294475913,
-0.1289000213,
-0.2822990417,
-0.1045020893,
-0.6794548631,
0.4351048768,
-0.5600587726,
-0.6923030019,
-0.3205052614,
0.0470613725,
-0.3889819086,
-0.3057095408,
0.26486063,
0.2439686209,
-0.1176708862,
0.31800282,
0.8948863745,
-0.431252569,
0.3328349888,
0.5111085773,
0.1904558241,
-0.3618329465,
0.6629807949,
-0.0797007531,
0.0130810076,
0.3302671313,
0.3731701672,
-0.2156146169,
-0.1524572074,
-0.0211283229,
-0.0398102738,
-0.9772196412,
-0.2637197077,
-1.0880283117,
-0.2478150874,
-0.58786273,
-0.2164634317,
-0.6522336602,
-0.4612196684,
-0.0995060727,
-0.4687845111,
0.4704680741,
0.4873829782,
-0.2000042349,
0.2334081531,
-0.4701113403,
-0.1286492348,
0.6834281683,
0.3533164859,
-0.1183323637,
-1.0037567616,
-0.1994670928,
-0.1618295461,
-0.3743906021,
-0.9784024954,
0.594091177,
0.4656395614,
0.5632283688,
0.4862015545,
0.2676728964,
0.4551438391,
-0.4733222723,
0.7060270905,
0.0889261663,
-1.1638309956,
0.9070963264,
-0.1690904647,
0.2312458903,
0.3979953825,
0.2896803021,
-0.8651128411,
-0.0277420171,
-0.876860559,
-0.799315393,
0.9741854072,
0.167733252,
0.2455016524,
0.0612875968,
0.1333294809,
-0.0760908872,
0.0427744836,
-0.5066322684,
-0.1278821826,
-0.4157882035,
-0.2024888843,
0.0698851869,
-0.8847799897,
-0.0864655897,
-0.1681305617,
0.8361819983,
-0.2800071239,
0.8523943424,
0.3196721077,
0.131581068,
-0.3482463062,
0.4160751998,
0.64294976,
-0.2386593819,
-0.2106094807,
0.5144970417,
0.4191453755,
-0.4308335185,
-0.0383275524,
-0.187278524,
0.2257288396,
-0.1010712683,
0.317614913,
1.1220533848,
0.4469227493,
-0.445641011,
0.7448137403,
-0.0431866683,
-0.2705967128,
-0.3290969729,
-0.2719013989,
0.3454752862,
0.8626878262,
0.3761477172,
-0.0886521265,
0.3698414862,
-0.5526345372,
0.3037662804,
-0.0759295076,
-0.5818530917,
-0.5870418549,
0.3193659782,
0.5503791571,
-0.628175199,
0.8091040254,
-0.2163969427,
-1.4173363447,
0.5230309963,
0.4596996307,
1.1158610582,
-0.6463397741,
0.185308367,
0.4558746219,
0.098282285,
0.239222154,
0.7179244757,
-0.2357117087,
-1.0024962425,
-0.1283855587,
-0.2004143298,
-0.7693684101,
-0.4731374085,
-0.4611267745,
0.4590528607,
0.0406790413,
-0.0918009058,
-0.2717119455,
-0.10937953,
-0.6649723053,
0.1020774394,
0.4116284549,
0.7204976082,
-0.9186137915,
0.6594297886,
0.7120429277,
0.0992183909,
-0.7879598141,
-0.3046527207,
0.2201161981,
-0.6292324662,
0.7692236304,
0.1245981678,
0.1221874207,
-0.1499277651,
-0.5660634637,
-0.5505990386,
1.1252020597,
0.0746403635,
-0.333889693,
0.4503674507,
0.2060876787,
0.3550660908,
-0.5398511887,
0.8388435245,
0.3149265945,
0.4768629968,
0.6335832477,
-1.0118927956,
-0.1578566432,
-0.5249154568,
-0.3207679689,
0.3369648159,
-0.7913711071,
0.7757747173,
-0.1091416106,
0.0088921255,
-0.5971060395,
0.533377111,
0.0951811597,
0.6769703031,
0.7543705106,
0.8280776739,
0.5268800259,
-0.2347453237,
0.672534585,
-0.1068123877,
0.2447732538,
1.0607093573,
-0.390707314,
0.9081369042,
0.6021084785,
-0.26984635,
0.5904435515,
0.6252464652,
0.3973773718,
0.6799300909,
-0.1648119539,
-0.4620046616,
-0.6754140258,
-0.2011605203,
-0.2489397377,
0.6234275699,
0.4318588376,
-0.2878067791,
0.0452800058,
0.4895327389,
-0.095084019,
-0.1823007464,
-0.0950592458,
0.7790740728,
0.3505068719,
-0.4716294408,
-0.1028922871,
-0.1063338295,
0.442284584,
-0.0329651497,
-0.1431076229,
-0.3168455362,
0.2224723697,
-0.2879298925,
-0.7650538087,
0.4022830129,
-0.1884597242,
0.0869330242,
-0.5419566631,
1.070140481,
-0.4465399683,
-0.0744126737,
0.2589588463,
0.2283207327,
0.2675749362,
-0.4296236038,
-0.3457058668,
0.2787629366,
0.1499159336,
-0.74010396,
0.2619839907,
0.7139005065,
0.0213707108,
0.6479764581,
-0.0167049784,
-0.3692294359,
-0.1243029907,
0.4356456995,
0.75313133,
-0.8396217227,
-0.6481282711,
-0.5621652603,
0.660567224,
-0.0984393582,
-0.0258610565,
0.4892831743,
0.163510859,
0.373123765,
-0.1221333817,
0.3767334819,
-0.0787434503,
0.7905346155,
-0.1152939573,
0.294552356,
-0.3525022566,
0.1336142123,
-0.6179201603,
-0.8009645343,
0.1969463378,
0.7181398869,
-0.4994525611,
-0.0427227281,
0.6384854913,
0.7553012967,
0.178057611,
0.7274002433,
0.4949036539,
0.2580005229,
0.5141162872,
0.6398892999,
0.9515022039,
-0.6136732697,
0.3060236275,
-0.494051069,
-0.058898773,
-0.6775068641,
-1.1054519415,
-0.6133725047,
-1.0262190104,
-0.7263992429,
-0.322366327,
-0.1336006969,
0.9429174066,
0.5945411325,
-0.9752237201,
0.1175467968,
0.1575073898,
0.0994143412,
0.023101043,
-0.1746978611,
0.07748615,
0.1386918575,
-0.6652334332,
0.40079844,
0.7397684455,
-0.1034629121,
0.1983995885,
-0.2799941003,
-0.2581673563,
0.1181521714,
0.4999309778,
0.2317390889,
-0.5001572967,
-0.8791649342,
0.0656762198,
0.2264605016,
-0.0352760926,
0.8366834521,
-0.7110127211,
0.7435880303,
0.6663627028,
0.5799817443,
0.9346961379,
0.0480946861,
0.5257850289,
-0.3638448715,
0.1643254161,
0.5387574434,
0.4547583759,
0.2378489524,
-0.3540092707,
0.7766245008,
0.3067980111,
-0.9111343622,
-0.9216825366,
0.1462476104,
-1.0637797117,
0.1629252881,
0.9385674,
-0.1440477818,
-0.1271404177,
-0.0167434625,
-0.2807664871,
0.1993461996,
-0.4060499072,
0.5926216245,
0.7407847047,
-0.687367022,
-0.8384444714,
-0.2934318483,
0.3891049325,
0.5987316966,
-0.6104721427,
-0.1835193187,
-0.0122975111,
-0.1077218726,
0.2133427113,
0.722093761,
-0.1692029387,
0.095864065,
0.035457965,
0.3442595601,
0.0410762802,
-0.3259706199,
-0.3628175557,
-0.006036975,
-0.2806262672,
0.1699476689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04522v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04522v2
|
Q-PEFT: Query-dependent Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning for Text Reranking with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-06T06:44:41 | 2024-04-12T00:18:06 |
Zhiyuan Peng, Xuyang Wu, Qifan Wang, Sravanthi Rajanala, Yi Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods have been extensively utilized
in Large Language Models (LLMs) to improve the down-streaming tasks without the
cost of fine-tuing the whole LLMs. Recent studies have shown how to effectively
use PEFT for fine-tuning LLMs in ranking tasks with convincing performance;
there are some limitations, including the learned prompt being fixed for
different documents, overfitting to specific tasks, and low adaptation ability.
In this paper, we introduce a query-dependent parameter efficient fine-tuning
(Q-PEFT) approach for text reranking to leak the information of the true
queries to LLMs and then make the generation of true queries from input
documents much easier. Specifically, we utilize the query to extract the
top-$k$ tokens from concatenated documents, serving as contextual clues. We
further augment Q-PEFT by substituting the retrieval mechanism with a
multi-head attention layer to achieve end-to-end training and cover all the
tokens in the documents, guiding the LLMs to generate more document-specific
synthetic queries, thereby further improving the reranking performance.
Extensive experiments are conducted on four public datasets, demonstrating the
effectiveness of our proposed approach.
|
[
-0.2020275444,
-0.9154410362,
0.7143318057,
0.0035365717,
-0.4524553716,
0.2323480099,
-0.402274549,
-0.1399416625,
0.2451310903,
0.6616353393,
-0.5514194965,
-0.4956735969,
-0.698515892,
0.1538772881,
-0.3306983113,
0.883554101,
0.1335534155,
-0.2433254719,
-0.2224382013,
-0.0484127067,
-0.3194980323,
-0.712882638,
-0.8644739389,
-0.0750580654,
0.6934143305,
0.5725888014,
0.338227272,
0.5525138974,
0.4056887925,
0.2557631135,
-0.125290677,
0.5022034049,
-0.8690188527,
0.4680140913,
-0.5038140416,
-0.5137543678,
-0.2749403119,
0.1048426405,
0.9535433054,
0.5331647992,
0.0638004318,
0.100605458,
0.2859826088,
0.8548811674,
-0.8211686015,
0.0899638161,
-1.0446292162,
-0.2696586549,
-0.374322623,
-0.4743630588,
-0.5796513557,
-0.2739097476,
0.0247666296,
-0.5903997421,
0.2257443219,
0.2575438619,
0.7314679027,
0.275025934,
-0.530115664,
0.1784431785,
-0.3171232939,
0.905189693,
-0.5347207189,
0.73239398,
0.5962802172,
0.1098620892,
-0.1812819093,
-0.8664131165,
-0.2916772664,
-0.1758543551,
-0.0669935197,
-0.0654374585,
0.2950617075,
0.1301554292,
0.0705555156,
0.2241707444,
-0.3831659853,
-0.0782810077,
0.0378434844,
-0.1421881467,
0.4915424883,
-0.0239154398,
-0.0548548214,
0.1844839305,
-0.1593127996,
-0.1692532152,
-0.8118823171,
0.0408633426,
0.2210779488,
0.5205501914,
0.3892813027,
0.3518249393,
-0.6010940075,
0.596321106,
0.6162033677,
-0.0871452317,
0.1611692756,
-0.4684109688,
-0.1326989084,
-0.1530235708,
0.4877628386,
0.2649796009,
0.1836701035,
-0.4951712489,
-0.1935589164,
-0.5561044812,
0.2837040126,
-1.0302498341,
-0.1082489938,
0.1444859058,
-0.2965435684,
-0.2937412262,
-0.0470396318,
-0.6928163767,
-0.2444672436,
-0.2307137102,
0.6355268359,
-0.3667528033,
0.0545390919,
-0.1322044581,
-0.027461119,
0.235900715,
0.3055214286,
-0.9665400982,
0.1251524985,
0.7846147418,
0.6791042089,
-0.2785565555,
-0.5487626791,
-1.1215115786,
0.2981818616,
-0.1518658996,
0.9233893156,
-0.9005625844,
-0.2949620783,
-0.1229116842,
0.1918545961,
-0.4303149581,
-0.4774093032,
0.8213056326,
-0.6667259336,
0.141870141,
-0.4001927376,
-0.7440597415,
0.0550516285,
0.5348289609,
-0.4052214622,
1.1946501732,
0.0268279966,
-0.6317466497,
0.2636410296,
-0.2811774015,
-0.4308438301,
-0.0236126091,
-0.0507082492,
-0.4731284082,
0.0693965331,
0.5005771518,
0.3402819037,
-0.4410921931,
0.2765728235,
-0.2956071496,
-0.6144345999,
-0.1137363836,
-0.4366360307,
0.4039551318,
-0.1041704714,
-0.2628009319,
0.0980394781,
-0.5620093346,
0.2418544739,
0.0802897736,
-0.6168228388,
-0.4578759372,
0.1095039696,
-0.0569391623,
-0.1601104438,
0.4026044607,
-0.5845018625,
0.4824783206,
-0.7673735619,
0.4602710307,
0.5056970716,
0.3175917566,
0.6018925309,
-0.3897076249,
0.3312918842,
-0.3642281592,
0.0536262095,
-0.2310932726,
-0.2534615695,
-0.4953238964,
-0.2212895453,
0.7030100226,
0.3196483254,
-0.6486114264,
0.3175641596,
-0.085197024,
-0.553402245,
-0.329105258,
0.1264549643,
0.4523813426,
0.55788517,
0.2023174763,
0.2282894105,
-0.1400802583,
-0.8004984856,
-0.751606524,
-0.010406821,
0.0401802585,
0.4261783659,
0.1628132463,
0.1012292802,
0.6528003812,
-0.69158113,
-0.4080945551,
-0.0385622419,
0.0602583326,
0.1259103119,
0.4991197288,
0.3907101154,
-0.8910967112,
-0.7672078013,
-0.2695238888,
0.1300041527,
-0.1958409995,
-0.0798875391,
-0.3648468852,
0.1351897866,
0.8532711864,
-0.4997958541,
-0.1277193576,
0.3096410036,
-0.4384856522,
0.3777100146,
-0.3337664604,
0.2801146805,
-0.7828396559,
0.1513537169,
-0.0698055699,
-0.3536778092,
-0.2814432681,
0.3311704993,
0.421448499,
-0.0425196588,
-0.3239667118,
0.5932770967,
-0.313808769,
0.4510291517,
-0.2575000823,
-0.0034128309,
0.233660996,
0.821220994,
-0.1789368242,
0.7335348129,
0.504529655,
-0.4364407957,
-0.0605493411,
0.0131216832,
-0.0041354476,
0.3781120777,
-0.4741269648,
0.3066362143,
-0.003991832,
0.30154562,
-1.0054103136,
0.0150182722,
0.1687412709,
-0.310308516,
0.4425167739,
-0.439575702,
-0.7410186529,
0.2566173077,
-0.6311897635,
0.413074553,
0.1738886982,
-0.6518804431,
0.4288265109,
0.3983514011,
-0.2491420805,
-0.3361949325,
-0.1965492815,
0.0287565887,
-0.2572372258,
-0.3207963109,
1.0987145901,
-0.0971742049,
0.1938144863,
-0.2356089503,
-0.2467875928,
-0.1849151552,
0.0507743731,
-0.0987239406,
-0.2545198202,
0.0690883696,
0.288846761,
0.5216315389,
-0.0649204329,
-0.2150649428,
-0.3087001741,
0.467661947,
0.0989815667,
-0.2491632402,
-0.1960099787,
0.5174399018,
0.8711593747,
-0.638158083,
0.7853760719,
0.4114041924,
-0.394223392,
-0.3171307147,
-0.5989506841,
-0.33314237,
-0.4812133908,
0.2756454349,
-0.3464592397,
-0.9682667255,
0.228839159,
-0.4620380402,
0.0047564982,
0.3710258901,
0.5285714269,
-0.0115509341,
1.1806200743,
0.674587667,
-0.0905748233,
0.7215921283,
-0.1544563472,
-0.0324550159,
-0.7495472431,
-0.1901706755,
-0.6099134684,
-0.3724431098,
-0.6918645501,
-0.2821443975,
0.3460957706,
0.2486893237,
-0.3061859608,
0.0477406681,
-0.4220378399,
0.7659646273,
0.6111319661,
0.2181569338,
0.3655440807,
-0.0581062734,
-0.1934247464,
-0.0673159882,
-0.4470989704,
-0.0415463485,
1.2344521284,
0.1215622798,
0.491848588,
0.0061161229,
0.7919588089,
0.1748055667,
-0.0975314528,
-0.6640546918,
0.3471389711,
-0.4282396138,
-0.3281031251,
-0.5065873265,
-0.3024336994,
-0.8124737144,
0.4777674973,
-0.22390607,
-0.7004601359,
0.3247046769,
0.1032036096,
-0.3172654212,
-0.0708966553,
-0.7164263129,
0.8303950429,
-0.1428564638,
-0.4683670998,
-0.2513194084,
-0.3308498263,
-0.0538247041,
-0.424181819,
-0.1862194836,
-0.0386250839,
-0.2107960582,
0.7203595042,
-0.3497796655,
0.6165046096,
-0.2425114214,
-0.0498822927,
0.0116685797,
-0.0558065288,
0.9901860952,
0.3920260966,
-0.2991371155,
-0.1283110231,
0.2663661838,
-0.2781643569,
-0.6230252385,
0.8589166999,
-0.3788048327,
-0.7209481597,
-0.0898271352,
-0.4409540892,
-0.6146917343,
0.4948707521,
0.3186510503,
0.3959265649,
0.0490124039,
0.7098931074,
0.7401556373,
-0.0977012739,
0.2346711904,
0.6745871305,
-0.0717085153,
-0.3036322594,
0.9653450251,
0.3625248075,
-0.0828912631,
0.7985417843,
0.2153334469,
-0.5677783489,
-0.7439446449,
-0.1586929113,
0.2668153346,
-0.2593339682,
-0.3891251087,
-0.6451004148,
-0.1148877963,
-0.3588944674,
-0.1140286252,
-0.5081571937,
-0.3939347267,
-0.1974446177,
0.1319606751,
0.3277514279,
0.0691955015,
0.3684184253,
0.3380917609,
-0.7137051225,
0.3888303936,
0.3141888082,
0.6516565681,
-0.0811208263,
-0.549757719,
-0.3137940466,
-0.1855597645,
-0.4651321471,
-0.905931294,
0.3777905107,
0.5550901294,
0.7003060579,
0.0838590935,
0.3855223656,
0.4761061072,
-0.5368596911,
0.4628488719,
-0.2800388336,
-0.7895834446,
0.4719718993,
-0.4851448536,
0.301836282,
0.9518042207,
0.1196559742,
-0.2389929146,
-0.6523649693,
-0.4568631053,
-1.0321760178,
0.7528994679,
0.2199366391,
0.1025453284,
0.0898664817,
0.6904258728,
0.0962523445,
0.0871111155,
-0.3240668774,
-0.1431072503,
0.1640677452,
-0.0972121134,
-0.02055154,
-0.4531534612,
0.1848919541,
-0.4840435088,
0.6763617396,
-0.2770442069,
-0.0889747366,
0.2976436615,
-0.1671669483,
-0.1963615268,
0.3099230528,
0.2785826623,
0.491243422,
-0.4943979681,
0.1457107514,
0.1539389044,
-0.4150598943,
-0.015824059,
0.2635858059,
-0.1274220347,
-0.0783589482,
-0.0354324952,
0.3403779566,
0.4078604281,
-0.718300581,
0.3889608383,
-0.1328405589,
-0.3497953117,
0.0769950897,
0.2133226544,
0.2367692739,
0.3832125068,
0.5887935162,
-0.3201788366,
0.158742398,
-0.4472791255,
0.3854361773,
0.497518599,
-0.0872373953,
0.042968519,
0.6139640808,
0.3066821992,
-0.3145471215,
0.3850929737,
-0.152974695,
-0.4425080717,
0.3985709846,
0.5049062967,
0.6878036261,
-0.0346442014,
0.053271763,
0.299957484,
0.1753493696,
-0.1357845217,
0.2884011269,
-0.1939526498,
-0.4015304446,
-0.591660738,
-0.7088158131,
-0.5202755928,
0.3303901255,
-0.4635720253,
0.2284869701,
-0.3800279796,
-0.150702253,
0.0388491303,
0.3360933363,
-0.3572939932,
0.1020738855,
-0.0916649476,
0.8903474212,
-0.4279826581,
1.0507750511,
0.7380690575,
-0.1628549844,
-0.6042470932,
0.5387861729,
-0.4345802963,
-0.4458655417,
0.4589308202,
-0.0406775996,
-0.0413020439,
0.4626246989,
-0.4321885109,
-1.1960144043,
0.9100173116,
0.7163867354,
-0.7750841379,
-0.1691165566,
-0.0785439089,
0.3920058012,
-0.1298087835,
0.0581395142,
0.6074438691,
0.4442639053,
-0.0908369794,
-0.8200982213,
0.1871660352,
-0.0633162484,
-0.2186267674,
0.5398033261,
-0.8886805773,
0.722527504,
0.1483496875,
-0.0838559121,
-0.1015639529,
0.3990424275,
0.3430232406,
0.3238517344,
0.5252168775,
0.4549506009,
0.7866895199,
0.0997135565,
0.8449047804,
-0.4718413651,
0.5928958058,
1.1569901705,
-0.0880452991,
0.978427887,
0.5269914865,
-0.0090662912,
0.0909899399,
0.5597479343,
0.0542448163,
0.8412402272,
-0.0335845053,
-0.0312241893,
-0.4929717481,
-0.0417133719,
-0.3142028749,
0.557309866,
0.3014003336,
-0.4884982407,
-0.4987952113,
-0.1115220264,
-0.1236115471,
0.0493446179,
-0.2915534079,
0.696341157,
0.0105338348,
-0.8649157286,
0.7877214551,
0.3209820986,
0.6804162264,
-0.369461596,
-0.1511444151,
-0.3570865095,
0.1811073869,
0.0193399638,
-0.5244826078,
0.171384573,
-0.0055748932,
-0.4873492718,
-0.3623080254,
0.8530771136,
-0.565140903,
-0.4187382758,
0.0470779799,
0.4797612727,
-0.0695156902,
-0.7980149984,
-0.7608498931,
-0.1186688021,
0.0153716905,
-0.5179610252,
0.7739801407,
0.4359791577,
-0.0708974451,
0.4529843032,
0.6944879889,
-0.0089322608,
-0.2124568075,
0.0264089722,
0.8818374872,
-0.6127357483,
-0.6991633773,
-0.9325281382,
0.1045274362,
0.040560782,
-0.2631627619,
0.5355934501,
0.4977035522,
0.7211667299,
0.2067743987,
0.4998011887,
0.2936593592,
0.6692195535,
-0.6204614043,
0.9882262349,
-0.7541664839,
0.1761870384,
-0.1654113233,
-0.9878280759,
-0.2863063514,
0.1708175391,
-0.2958502769,
-0.0764320791,
0.6420551538,
0.7250526547,
0.0535182394,
-0.356879741,
0.3405224383,
0.1598801762,
0.265209496,
0.4693188369,
0.4034597576,
-0.2470153272,
0.8118383288,
-0.2224600911,
-0.1102934405,
-0.4506866336,
-0.80300349,
-0.6572652459,
-0.5918192267,
-0.3600803018,
0.0483501442,
0.2711425126,
0.6672668457,
0.6461837292,
-0.6856406331,
0.3157034814,
-0.0901808739,
0.2936631739,
-0.2135539502,
-0.2246001512,
0.7340808511,
-0.5313792825,
-0.9744995236,
0.5581579208,
0.1845545024,
-0.3669324219,
0.1199151278,
0.1027453095,
-0.2275516242,
0.1306716204,
0.7307190299,
0.2373104095,
-0.513520658,
-0.234412685,
0.0735787228,
-0.0270488672,
-0.0527401492,
0.6821430922,
-0.9648292661,
0.250126332,
0.6899743676,
0.838199079,
0.5294716954,
0.2549868524,
0.4805902839,
-0.988990128,
-0.1828511953,
0.1917733848,
0.2857051194,
0.008766721,
-0.6223452687,
0.3147010207,
0.2184618562,
-0.6097456813,
-0.9291850328,
-0.0481817834,
-0.9729337692,
-0.50206846,
1.1185129881,
0.0327289291,
0.0079710903,
0.0092805633,
-0.5279414654,
0.1728742123,
-0.6125356555,
0.7472035885,
0.4504848719,
-0.1031705961,
-0.3758436143,
-0.1536368728,
0.5202816129,
0.5904697776,
-0.4678428769,
0.3051317632,
0.1685138494,
0.3977050185,
-0.1877319664,
0.6326525807,
-0.1048850268,
0.0162830614,
-0.2884606421,
-0.5977893472,
-0.2128698826,
-0.2988724709,
-0.0316760391,
0.6122301221,
0.2666885257,
-0.2620721757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04520v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04520v1
|
IITK at SemEval-2024 Task 4: Hierarchical Embeddings for Detection of Persuasion Techniques in Memes
| 2024-04-06T06:28:02 | 2024-04-06T06:28:02 |
Shreenaga Chikoti, Shrey Mehta, Ashutosh Modi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Memes are one of the most popular types of content used in an online
disinformation campaign. They are primarily effective on social media platforms
since they can easily reach many users. Memes in a disinformation campaign
achieve their goal of influencing the users through several rhetorical and
psychological techniques, such as causal oversimplification, name-calling, and
smear. The SemEval 2024 Task 4 \textit{Multilingual Detection of Persuasion
Technique in Memes} on identifying such techniques in the memes is divided
across three sub-tasks: ($\mathbf{1}$) Hierarchical multi-label classification
using only textual content of the meme, ($\mathbf{2}$) Hierarchical multi-label
classification using both, textual and visual content of the meme and
($\mathbf{3}$) Binary classification of whether the meme contains a persuasion
technique or not using it's textual and visual content. This paper proposes an
ensemble of Class Definition Prediction (CDP) and hyperbolic embeddings-based
approaches for this task. We enhance meme classification accuracy and
comprehensiveness by integrating HypEmo's hierarchical label embeddings (Chen
et al., 2023) and a multi-task learning framework for emotion prediction. We
achieve a hierarchical F1-score of 0.60, 0.67, and 0.48 on the respective
sub-tasks.
|
[
-0.6504735947,
-0.9185379148,
0.2970129848,
0.5979007483,
-0.332960844,
0.2778432369,
-0.0199386701,
-0.1510234922,
0.2952724695,
0.069200702,
-0.7109851837,
-0.7670913935,
-0.7998791337,
0.1508031785,
0.0122405896,
0.7615422606,
-0.1410229802,
-0.0946776345,
-0.3292882442,
-0.0294237603,
-0.3125761151,
-0.6849473119,
-0.4123364687,
-0.2230535001,
0.4490176439,
0.7443202138,
0.2035381496,
0.404928565,
0.1060377434,
0.3305777013,
0.1051993147,
-0.2017441094,
-0.2202270627,
0.2140645534,
-0.3672094345,
-0.2015138268,
-0.2580850422,
0.3626565039,
0.2306484133,
0.032074675,
-0.0483304113,
-0.0464571305,
0.3310956359,
0.2778149247,
-0.7733629346,
0.2700518072,
-0.5184887648,
0.2555978894,
-0.3451334834,
-0.7075372338,
-0.5353056192,
-0.1480684876,
0.1344498545,
-0.2695147097,
-0.2377773076,
0.2336711586,
0.5394558907,
0.0943492875,
-0.6293236017,
-0.6085284948,
-0.1780712605,
1.01418221,
-0.6457568407,
0.2993981838,
0.5262217522,
0.1627774835,
-0.0087272534,
-0.4518387318,
-0.5365799069,
0.1988683343,
0.1821173579,
0.3457496464,
-0.507974267,
0.0149272531,
0.1747234166,
0.0095111541,
-0.4463623464,
0.3825342655,
-0.1137466654,
-0.5218919516,
0.1626905501,
-0.066969499,
0.1509638578,
-0.7188084722,
-0.6301581264,
-0.3397232592,
-0.5655296445,
-0.0290530827,
0.5249132514,
-0.1375697702,
-0.1984158903,
0.4589317143,
-0.183196485,
0.2125490755,
0.4011074007,
-0.3580480516,
0.2604215443,
-0.361651212,
-0.0710487813,
0.2269319892,
0.7981431484,
0.2842290401,
0.109715879,
0.4306264222,
0.0387078933,
0.1549054533,
0.1085386127,
-0.9479589462,
-0.3664479852,
0.076919131,
-0.6028737426,
-0.4927247167,
-0.3215176463,
-1.3062826395,
-0.3060622215,
-0.1212033704,
0.4078055024,
-0.4612740576,
-0.281473577,
-0.1890680343,
-0.1507049948,
0.0505647622,
0.3393413126,
-0.8682165146,
0.0259809289,
0.5957654715,
0.5996516347,
0.1101008654,
-0.1502186805,
-0.2555607557,
0.0989854187,
-0.0736148357,
0.9789270163,
-0.8165504336,
-0.086356692,
0.1192792282,
0.2736531496,
-0.1480041593,
-0.3244624734,
0.8478781581,
-0.1811739355,
0.2511214614,
-0.3203939497,
-0.7303346992,
-0.4405108392,
0.5618566871,
-0.645524323,
0.5259009004,
-0.0997050852,
-0.7022840977,
0.2886371911,
-0.4960891306,
-0.3115142584,
-0.0555292852,
-0.1997123659,
-0.5634540915,
-0.2568921149,
0.141838491,
1.0030882359,
-0.1272783726,
-0.0197523814,
-0.2977246344,
-0.0327194259,
-0.0552456863,
-0.4169480205,
0.2613635063,
0.3279095888,
-0.7289264202,
0.0029537936,
-0.2668538392,
0.0413876697,
-0.1430642456,
-0.2505309582,
-0.5714501739,
0.0649808645,
-0.107678771,
0.5123713613,
0.1804903299,
-0.6838101149,
0.0719563141,
0.0600763634,
0.2914659083,
0.987026751,
0.1920680404,
0.3544336259,
-0.0577661321,
0.5614517927,
0.3453626931,
0.1398820728,
-0.1750581115,
-0.7767524123,
-0.2247429043,
-0.3657552898,
0.1870938241,
0.5527206659,
-1.0337662697,
0.4662706256,
0.0741167143,
-0.6221069098,
-0.1453183293,
0.0993339345,
0.415712148,
0.3174130023,
0.3813692331,
0.2636328042,
-0.7137839198,
-0.8660514355,
-0.2941306531,
-0.1295122355,
0.3550277352,
-0.0465056486,
0.7366537452,
-0.4424632192,
0.2001897395,
-0.1835746616,
-0.3402050138,
-0.0895746201,
0.6689820886,
-0.0067542344,
0.5821530223,
0.702088654,
-0.7507773638,
-0.557523191,
-0.1238439456,
-0.7001645565,
-0.1310073733,
0.0336599909,
0.0196386781,
0.2255117744,
0.5561973453,
-0.0362279639,
0.3863758147,
0.7541834712,
-0.4833771884,
0.572847724,
0.1749842316,
0.7713291645,
-1.2373459339,
-0.6766286492,
0.5814129114,
0.066675216,
-0.5645719767,
-0.3641862869,
0.2991497219,
0.102555953,
-0.4024165869,
0.3932181299,
-0.3199615777,
0.3943316936,
-0.1552213728,
-0.1819408834,
-0.1734509766,
0.6093016863,
0.0155612901,
0.330896914,
0.6474264264,
-0.5211945176,
0.2674730122,
0.1016017348,
-0.357473731,
1.2403975725,
-0.3875436485,
0.061616119,
-0.0260526761,
0.1304164678,
-1.2985231876,
-0.2338536233,
0.5499491692,
-0.4825305343,
0.4623078108,
-0.0285309125,
-0.5922940373,
-0.4671777189,
-0.6231232882,
0.3746546507,
0.329097122,
-0.6537398696,
0.3712967932,
0.4550850093,
-0.2797196805,
-0.6736168861,
-0.3129971027,
0.0097389724,
-0.4976777434,
-0.5078600049,
0.2207724452,
-0.0450738855,
0.0906637907,
0.0454304181,
0.0120432843,
0.1361325681,
-0.1396498829,
0.4004555345,
-0.1478572488,
-0.025632197,
0.1755382866,
0.562828064,
-0.1843632013,
-0.0422682762,
-0.0669866949,
0.5446020365,
-0.2894741893,
-0.5297250748,
-0.576540947,
0.4826133847,
0.5811812282,
0.0210414324,
0.3259034157,
0.6970459819,
-0.657450974,
-0.0262964983,
-0.7754841447,
-0.2455081344,
-0.4697924554,
0.5487302542,
-0.5531399846,
-0.8728046417,
0.2898579538,
-0.6038579345,
-0.1148881689,
0.5427429676,
0.6750940681,
-0.3284701705,
1.3859491348,
0.2762771547,
-0.1625726968,
0.3920553923,
-0.3019431829,
0.2298845649,
-0.5170430541,
-0.5878816843,
-0.6758688092,
-0.6261174083,
-0.7370997667,
-0.5807614923,
0.3904127181,
-0.0732977092,
0.0054466142,
0.3160294592,
-0.4801702499,
0.1501174271,
0.4296301901,
-0.0849452987,
-0.1266062558,
0.4701589644,
-0.1093127802,
-0.5208854675,
-0.5031660795,
-0.6045751572,
0.7254285216,
0.6437142491,
0.9474335909,
0.1436892599,
0.7207533121,
0.577976346,
0.2437273115,
-0.9201600552,
0.5494810939,
-0.1679408252,
-0.2995015383,
-0.2005287409,
-0.1143181175,
-1.055462122,
0.0586419962,
-0.4656452239,
-0.6203399897,
0.3344751596,
0.0209647492,
0.3021750152,
0.4241324067,
-0.4402484596,
0.9666554332,
-0.0669984445,
-0.294993341,
-0.594840765,
-0.2661906779,
0.0436192304,
0.0007793571,
0.3413925469,
-0.0977540836,
-0.0039708535,
1.1344844103,
-0.0815910622,
0.9172907472,
-0.335092932,
-0.0211206861,
0.4802376032,
-0.0781253204,
0.4696211815,
-0.3466073275,
-0.1802542061,
0.0003783489,
0.0561120659,
-0.4899496138,
-0.4706552327,
0.8571808338,
-0.5962079167,
-0.4089388549,
-0.4044730961,
-0.0993518382,
-0.1041489094,
-0.0738742352,
0.4493376017,
0.5179278851,
-0.323890388,
0.5943225026,
0.5751772523,
-0.1064162478,
0.311692059,
0.0486699343,
0.4723849893,
-0.5452674031,
1.1908601522,
0.1433453411,
-0.1217066497,
0.3487420678,
0.4759263694,
-0.7687852383,
-0.327373296,
-0.3198018372,
0.0122800274,
-0.9986583591,
-0.2735822201,
-0.7030746341,
0.1561381072,
-0.5276351571,
-0.167355299,
-0.0162993912,
-0.4284340143,
-0.2876326144,
-0.2863311172,
0.0734486133,
0.9086379409,
-0.1084067672,
0.418053776,
-0.5430243015,
-0.0624382682,
0.3805410564,
-0.0333501026,
-0.0598698668,
-0.3585166335,
-0.1083582863,
0.0540382341,
-0.8709540367,
-1.2246440649,
0.2653617859,
0.2492012978,
0.7918283343,
0.8739914298,
0.0219783038,
0.5233885646,
-0.2706432641,
0.5675975084,
0.4749295712,
-0.8806477189,
0.7095839381,
-0.1549122632,
-0.1056976095,
0.3600647748,
0.9498284459,
-0.2744730115,
-0.4633898735,
-0.8165199161,
-0.485116303,
0.247967869,
0.1144594252,
0.2022845596,
-0.3708896637,
0.2433981895,
0.1941829175,
0.3467712998,
-0.7160497308,
-0.2064266652,
-0.5009137392,
-0.3378602862,
0.0867238939,
-0.6353566051,
0.0580682792,
-0.3507792354,
0.7380257249,
-0.1816947162,
0.1177133694,
-0.0945783257,
0.0907237157,
-0.1409491152,
0.4827335179,
0.4240525067,
0.1789418459,
-0.103284359,
0.5030845404,
-0.0844831467,
-0.3877293468,
0.4734400213,
-0.2276210487,
0.2925805748,
-0.0744903758,
0.214838773,
0.6723296642,
0.3326645494,
-0.33898893,
0.6160777211,
0.1865999252,
-0.4205590487,
-0.1021750271,
-0.3525084853,
-0.0284336247,
0.434340626,
0.1850343049,
0.0571133047,
0.480822295,
-0.7858477831,
0.5275185704,
0.3967389166,
-0.4502811134,
-0.6823019981,
0.3630531728,
0.3581014276,
0.1540413201,
0.0922660381,
-0.4254440367,
-0.8469166756,
0.6480774283,
0.6402292848,
0.7420834303,
-0.7546331286,
0.4465922117,
0.7369180918,
0.2299250066,
0.0271869339,
0.407994926,
-0.0488724187,
-0.554276526,
-0.1361021399,
-0.3862018585,
-0.4177597165,
0.1848532557,
-0.3312116563,
0.3895483017,
-0.4582012296,
-0.1813143641,
0.1958081573,
0.0013194589,
-0.4397153258,
0.3327369392,
0.1581988931,
0.7512167096,
-1.0505137444,
0.4284641445,
0.9063850045,
0.0330309011,
-0.5999898911,
-0.0208465736,
0.4082601368,
-0.5250219107,
0.4120758474,
0.4113380313,
-0.0385936648,
0.0348192267,
-0.8865735531,
-0.3810582161,
0.9182652235,
-0.0411528274,
-0.2621982396,
0.2668364048,
-0.1690428406,
0.2992472351,
-0.5397443175,
0.1653219908,
0.2672385871,
0.6947958469,
0.4810303152,
-0.5224716663,
0.1599987,
-0.4272963703,
-0.4422445297,
0.0099540791,
-0.2690941691,
0.9179320931,
-0.0521365069,
-0.0160437524,
-0.0714756027,
0.7156315446,
0.3682243824,
0.615256846,
0.8436663151,
0.4311445355,
0.7081775069,
-0.2631570101,
0.9035092592,
-0.0861708373,
0.31448704,
0.5460700393,
0.1410899013,
0.8178374767,
0.4222383797,
0.1395979077,
0.8604762554,
1.053386569,
0.0514356643,
0.7625243664,
0.259688586,
-0.2122999281,
-0.354981333,
-0.1444649547,
-0.4270467758,
0.4649945498,
0.880757153,
-0.117906481,
-0.2148284018,
0.3398862183,
0.2844965756,
0.0616916381,
-0.2965267301,
0.7953950167,
-0.019130189,
-0.6166290641,
0.6184387207,
0.0844750404,
0.885504663,
-0.3536287546,
-0.2517178059,
0.4058956802,
0.1626827419,
-0.3364822268,
-0.9538449645,
0.0528507866,
-0.3640421033,
0.0828517973,
-0.2089679092,
1.0524200201,
-0.5405088067,
-0.2448824942,
0.3721594214,
0.5744068623,
0.2408740669,
-0.2595062852,
-0.9403011799,
-0.1259673536,
-0.0454675369,
-0.2292092144,
0.3148925602,
0.8394333124,
-0.2426838577,
0.5486986041,
0.3541001081,
-0.2671808898,
0.0471092947,
0.1859154552,
0.6725681424,
-0.5293254852,
-0.6792771816,
-0.8880684972,
0.3219584227,
-0.1730831414,
0.0681584999,
1.0003837347,
0.2653667331,
0.3912439346,
-0.2651312351,
0.8114318848,
-0.0847600922,
0.1761578619,
-0.3573295474,
0.3611328304,
-0.7773588896,
-0.1521049738,
-0.8388371468,
-0.7852079868,
0.1157117784,
0.6035090685,
-0.2283568531,
-0.0432651229,
0.6678376794,
0.4934318364,
0.0425609909,
0.3277609646,
0.3587845266,
0.2382563055,
0.3567875624,
0.5245293379,
1.1131242514,
-0.2363744676,
0.4783186316,
-0.6008388996,
-0.6145958304,
-0.495320797,
-0.8825457096,
-1.0733847618,
-0.8783625364,
-0.6303819418,
-0.270976305,
-0.1997006088,
0.7884872556,
0.7489288449,
-0.9202058911,
-0.101748094,
0.2247568816,
0.3813512623,
-0.1380231231,
-0.2165173441,
0.2827197015,
-0.1102494076,
-0.9732208848,
0.1683147699,
0.5345619321,
0.1874203682,
-0.1315103322,
-0.11116492,
-0.6093304157,
0.011895393,
0.892747879,
0.0720609576,
-0.5914353132,
-0.5036367774,
0.0496793464,
0.0420729704,
-0.1677648723,
0.6164949536,
-0.3369158208,
0.523037374,
0.6351437569,
0.329606235,
0.1687840819,
0.1973418891,
0.2282249033,
-0.7193362117,
0.3029097915,
0.2740276754,
0.586774528,
0.2166388035,
-0.3683722615,
0.4257689714,
0.4054646194,
-0.4878440797,
-0.4507061839,
0.0793942809,
-0.9407228827,
-0.1860367805,
1.0610473156,
-0.1243904531,
-0.2563551366,
-0.4780246615,
-0.3699711561,
0.0768314302,
-0.5294290185,
0.5382983088,
0.8723635674,
-0.1146508008,
-0.1854605675,
-0.3579395115,
0.5302962065,
0.5131613016,
-0.9315387011,
-0.4202133417,
0.3554837704,
0.1406125873,
0.5361900926,
0.5385954976,
-0.0951963961,
0.3841415346,
-0.2921206951,
0.0649795383,
0.3067649007,
-0.4175423086,
0.1029659882,
0.3250603676,
-0.3255033791,
-0.4246917367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06652v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06652v1
|
Large Language Model (LLM) AI text generation detection based on transformer deep learning algorithm
| 2024-04-06T06:22:45 | 2024-04-06T06:22:45 |
Yuhong Mo, Hao Qin, Yushan Dong, Ziyi Zhu, Zhenglin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, a tool for detecting LLM AI text generation is developed based
on the Transformer model, aiming to improve the accuracy of AI text generation
detection and provide reference for subsequent research. Firstly the text is
Unicode normalised, converted to lowercase form, characters other than
non-alphabetic characters and punctuation marks are removed by regular
expressions, spaces are added around punctuation marks, first and last spaces
are removed, consecutive ellipses are replaced with single spaces and the text
is connected using the specified delimiter. Next remove non-alphabetic
characters and extra whitespace characters, replace multiple consecutive
whitespace characters with a single space and again convert to lowercase form.
The deep learning model combines layers such as LSTM, Transformer and CNN for
text classification or sequence labelling tasks. The training and validation
sets show that the model loss decreases from 0.127 to 0.005 and accuracy
increases from 94.96 to 99.8, indicating that the model has good detection and
classification ability for AI generated text. The test set confusion matrix and
accuracy show that the model has 99% prediction accuracy for AI-generated text,
with a precision of 0.99, a recall of 1, and an f1 score of 0.99, achieving a
very high classification accuracy. Looking forward, it has the prospect of wide
application in the field of AI text detection.
|
[
-0.1398892999,
-0.9878982902,
0.4887143672,
-0.0486030467,
-0.3336047828,
0.2997821867,
-0.2071689367,
-0.3747949302,
-0.1738686562,
0.5648446679,
-0.5678946972,
-0.7017578483,
-0.8834926486,
0.3899523616,
-0.6524903774,
0.7653340697,
0.0953158289,
-0.0959496126,
0.0624333248,
0.2679182589,
-0.5397274494,
-0.2540067136,
-0.8151199818,
-0.4135297537,
0.1277978569,
0.4992268085,
0.4286160469,
0.5544881821,
0.7020916343,
0.4337903857,
-0.3145621121,
0.3515678644,
-0.3136554956,
0.2224550098,
0.3522386849,
-0.5567685366,
-0.5562062263,
-0.07134597,
0.790394485,
-0.3064951003,
0.0920151174,
-0.0601462312,
0.0032832383,
0.4362972379,
-0.1558687687,
0.0071106022,
-0.9302783608,
0.0693703815,
-0.3401351273,
-0.1294665635,
-0.6104123592,
-0.1273643523,
-0.3641827703,
-0.074158065,
0.2683899403,
0.270773977,
0.8177884221,
0.5571221709,
-0.5494217277,
-0.454272151,
-0.7375477552,
0.7270870805,
-1.1676386595,
0.2512504458,
-0.0082833907,
0.4211620092,
-0.1007243246,
-0.9331014156,
-1.1700780392,
-0.5068218112,
0.0785933957,
0.0963338464,
-0.2471208423,
-0.0156577565,
0.2177349925,
0.50541085,
-0.5515543818,
0.5662998557,
-0.1513480395,
-0.2820826769,
0.801748693,
0.2808561325,
0.6631014943,
-0.1990739405,
-0.1344171464,
-0.0254992694,
-0.8401041031,
-0.1586074382,
0.3628332317,
0.1710254401,
-0.373655349,
0.549349308,
0.107253924,
0.5330691338,
-0.0073979571,
-0.3966094255,
0.3695684373,
-0.0883995742,
-0.3105144799,
0.0483678728,
1.2125344276,
0.2876010537,
0.6761944294,
0.1451865733,
-0.2291450053,
-0.0166128147,
0.0310840979,
-1.0121210814,
0.1431008577,
-0.0843544006,
-0.5174734592,
-0.5015743971,
-0.0570218414,
-0.6194096208,
-0.5045015216,
-0.1090456694,
-0.1894079596,
-0.4604225457,
-0.1239661947,
-0.0841087401,
0.3533116877,
0.3415495455,
0.2792430818,
-0.6383023262,
-0.2922060192,
0.6547737122,
0.6207607985,
-0.392644465,
-0.2092819214,
-0.4027417302,
0.0026861718,
-0.1774327308,
0.8525643349,
-0.3906471431,
-0.2552205026,
0.2025444806,
-0.0240204744,
0.065076448,
-0.5165569186,
0.7921478748,
-0.5548047423,
0.3722039461,
0.5637569427,
-0.7963899374,
-0.1313042045,
0.4140639603,
-0.8849018216,
0.9972342253,
-0.0793546587,
-0.757011354,
0.4933611155,
-0.5179570317,
-0.7019152045,
0.4234629571,
-0.1236300841,
-0.941506207,
-0.1138340756,
0.5564627051,
0.6570158005,
-0.4152118862,
0.5925052166,
0.2327574193,
-0.4682923257,
0.2508872747,
-0.9575303197,
0.5940981507,
0.1590388417,
-0.4362595975,
0.2488890886,
-0.8665909171,
-0.1692361236,
0.2046658993,
-0.6707937717,
0.1265934706,
-0.1359258294,
0.3334760368,
0.1529248655,
0.2464343011,
-0.527043581,
0.2096146792,
-0.5759600997,
0.334120959,
0.6039626002,
0.1047239527,
0.3361538947,
0.0682254583,
0.5776851177,
0.1491583735,
-0.0537544005,
-0.4606150389,
-0.7899059653,
-0.9643329382,
-0.2498194426,
0.2916878164,
0.7684934735,
-0.8120987415,
1.0880389214,
-0.2522955835,
-0.3873859346,
-0.5413048267,
0.2522439659,
0.2022644132,
0.5001553893,
0.1065755934,
0.2248472273,
-0.513034761,
-0.7753553987,
-0.2091530561,
-0.119268477,
-0.0450884402,
0.1796063185,
0.6955099702,
-0.6100617051,
0.7372650504,
-0.3720193207,
-0.4410570562,
-0.6217861772,
0.1854474247,
0.382647872,
0.2805887759,
0.3927695155,
-0.8256371021,
-0.7536680102,
-0.0016718503,
-0.8054202199,
-0.1077184379,
-0.2133328766,
0.3222867846,
0.358076632,
0.8487700224,
-0.4787557125,
0.5698462725,
0.4063854516,
-0.3610827327,
0.2536239028,
-0.0828579068,
0.0856306255,
-1.5561075211,
-0.0429283939,
0.1990366131,
-0.4849934876,
-0.7012848258,
0.1719802916,
0.1806297004,
-0.0617938638,
-0.4741195738,
0.5497189164,
-0.1558723003,
0.4840152562,
-0.642994225,
0.1155095622,
-0.0120893326,
0.1528894603,
-0.1664704531,
1.1475578547,
0.217389062,
-0.3584424257,
0.4772504568,
0.2188570648,
-0.5865917802,
0.2508639395,
-0.4411773682,
0.2594243288,
-0.1176341698,
0.1871974021,
-1.168620348,
-0.0281250775,
0.2972187698,
-0.6160386205,
0.378595978,
0.4127729237,
-0.6026744246,
-0.7459801435,
-0.0835181922,
0.1688101143,
0.612326026,
-0.5991635323,
0.6642499566,
0.1018822938,
-0.144144848,
-0.3684586585,
-0.7529988289,
0.2904874086,
-0.1176039353,
-0.8002883792,
0.3558018804,
-0.1601765752,
-0.0336541608,
-0.2962490916,
0.4317925572,
-0.063408263,
0.0833370015,
0.1669818163,
0.3375932872,
-0.3731263578,
0.0679072589,
0.0974694192,
-0.2860657573,
-0.0434110612,
0.3028424382,
0.7906286716,
0.0804309994,
-0.2750597894,
-0.944047153,
0.087715961,
0.727306962,
-0.2238823026,
0.624666512,
1.0765196085,
-0.3838736415,
-0.288705647,
-0.5735269785,
-0.0968153402,
-0.5163155794,
0.583237052,
-0.1681005508,
-0.9027602673,
0.3105496466,
-0.249874115,
-0.1820456237,
0.8521853685,
0.7763577104,
0.0731464252,
1.1086262465,
0.8278021216,
-0.6500662565,
0.4588346183,
-0.2579843402,
0.5199648738,
-0.6365551353,
-0.2404070795,
-0.5392543674,
-0.1992548704,
-0.5061160326,
-0.1237372458,
0.0447253548,
-0.0321828648,
-0.396114856,
0.0415911078,
-0.7482082248,
0.3752847016,
0.700388968,
0.0493519902,
0.5110820532,
0.0691907406,
0.1108329967,
-0.1064845845,
0.0001598194,
-0.5727570653,
1.0991027355,
0.4653357565,
0.5891373754,
-0.0991932079,
0.5329412222,
0.6778069139,
0.5031969547,
-0.922970593,
0.5248029828,
-0.1963392198,
-0.3254851103,
-0.3494828343,
-0.2018835098,
-0.61280936,
-0.2677955925,
-0.3358987868,
-0.5640761256,
-0.4782088399,
-0.1485985667,
-0.0989893228,
0.5323510766,
-0.4156769514,
0.4740459025,
-0.2316956222,
0.1396143734,
-0.0032339238,
-0.236443907,
0.5212120414,
-0.2850730419,
-0.0910973027,
-0.0439381003,
0.2130880505,
0.8173952103,
-0.1797624081,
0.8023709655,
0.0078633437,
-0.4360932112,
0.5652044415,
-0.1131764203,
0.9367455244,
-0.0331263319,
-0.2249565423,
0.1526381075,
-0.9532318115,
0.2775921822,
-0.2708832622,
0.4479684532,
-0.7398963571,
-0.6223394871,
-0.2522549033,
-0.6846338511,
0.2630763352,
0.4394173622,
0.6243448257,
0.0020377745,
-0.1730230749,
0.2222836763,
0.5976936221,
-0.4339134693,
0.673351109,
0.4436261058,
-0.2841003239,
-0.584733367,
0.6644073129,
-0.4592513442,
-0.1718966961,
0.5396267176,
0.1407383233,
-0.1747182906,
-0.690549314,
-0.5606897473,
0.1101983041,
-0.4213388562,
-0.7105998397,
-0.5415828228,
-0.7903897762,
-0.6045257449,
-0.0628162697,
-0.0283232424,
0.124059625,
-0.5763811469,
-0.0630097985,
0.4182537794,
0.8528641462,
0.6334471703,
0.9643306136,
-0.6799907684,
0.4465485513,
0.1112762615,
0.0014484104,
0.0193709154,
-0.8261574507,
-0.0625907034,
-0.1908552051,
-0.6280459762,
-0.6425400376,
0.739248693,
0.1196396947,
0.2209099978,
0.6151301861,
-0.2933472097,
0.1209419444,
-0.6805460453,
0.8190034032,
0.3047272265,
-1.0321830511,
0.5002339482,
-0.2255510241,
0.5314741731,
0.1668495089,
-0.1389969438,
-0.5435288548,
-0.6042870283,
-0.4038446546,
-0.6117958426,
0.6580181718,
0.2470817864,
0.2498874217,
0.2634453773,
0.4201707542,
-0.0921799242,
0.1524685025,
-1.1420111656,
-0.3545548022,
0.1504836679,
-0.6868852377,
-0.1152574643,
-0.5203367472,
0.4384953678,
-0.1552380025,
0.7288166285,
-0.1616503298,
0.2980783582,
-0.2219402492,
-0.0446952917,
-0.0921190009,
0.3572514653,
0.6812514663,
0.1273051798,
0.069139421,
-0.2073622644,
0.2979590297,
-0.7800154686,
0.3142659664,
0.0568919219,
-0.5042393804,
0.0264830384,
0.7810192108,
0.7163196802,
-0.4379270375,
-0.5573230982,
0.7285384536,
-0.091415219,
-0.197133854,
-0.488134712,
0.2314203084,
0.0405209772,
0.3099600077,
0.5907495022,
-0.0252959169,
0.0860781372,
-0.1537038833,
0.2370207012,
0.4758522213,
-0.3020527363,
0.0978171006,
0.7355231643,
0.2098688334,
-0.9875805378,
0.9223609567,
-0.1197790951,
-0.8642360568,
1.0456613302,
0.9024549127,
0.9406552315,
-0.5328233242,
0.144283995,
0.212732777,
0.515735805,
0.2205550075,
0.1805455685,
0.2939646244,
-0.938773036,
-0.3769498765,
-0.566431284,
-0.1029890031,
0.7341137528,
0.0203214008,
0.5522505641,
-0.4139794409,
-0.0787016004,
0.105314292,
0.0305184908,
-0.6681165695,
0.4115004838,
0.4763317406,
0.9672187567,
-0.9089018106,
0.9509611726,
0.3909699023,
-0.2271566391,
-0.7346788049,
0.3036468625,
-0.0709037259,
-1.0498158932,
0.7939414382,
0.692063272,
-0.0326049104,
0.1146290228,
-0.6979342699,
-0.6873483062,
1.0614168644,
0.1368394643,
-0.9745521545,
0.050408151,
0.5100512505,
0.6149802804,
-0.5317659378,
0.3973636329,
0.5655058026,
0.7085931897,
0.0465537757,
-0.6714816093,
0.0744306073,
-0.2361050099,
-0.0648297146,
0.2238319814,
-0.5296301842,
0.86488837,
0.045109272,
-0.1938897371,
0.3269361556,
0.7722963095,
0.1489689499,
0.3821989,
0.2902131677,
0.5602063537,
0.7029300332,
-0.0746598169,
0.7141353488,
-0.3364309967,
0.3545986414,
0.7432329059,
-0.3383814394,
0.6352028847,
0.2556086183,
-0.0540226437,
0.6696798205,
0.3707970381,
-0.4852485359,
0.3254403472,
0.2761655748,
-0.2846159935,
-0.1715235114,
-0.0104613854,
-0.3262816668,
0.6260588765,
0.4095012844,
-0.9469565153,
-0.0914236084,
0.2789745033,
0.0546984375,
0.1224033386,
-0.2431388497,
0.9444531798,
0.0479694754,
-0.6483639479,
0.3951629102,
0.3764817715,
1.0314494371,
-0.2173522562,
-0.096666716,
-0.1377529651,
0.60189569,
-0.0705531389,
-0.7913032174,
-0.096580036,
0.0230261087,
-0.2228973657,
0.0860590264,
1.1654750109,
-0.330547452,
-1.0011564493,
0.2711813152,
0.4930901825,
-0.048611071,
-0.1074537039,
-0.7036416531,
0.1697213203,
0.2995499074,
-0.2892123163,
-0.2108697742,
0.6368940473,
0.1918682605,
0.6349887252,
0.5354496241,
-0.0453229062,
-0.0403907523,
0.2786579728,
0.6620197296,
-0.6086018682,
-0.3987093866,
-1.3170590401,
0.3757946789,
-0.3371698856,
-0.3567776084,
0.6030246019,
0.5278220177,
0.3573627174,
-0.1022323743,
0.8778803945,
0.2108773142,
0.323662281,
-0.5709840655,
1.0474426746,
-0.4455691278,
0.3049208522,
-0.2942153215,
-0.9847791791,
-0.6983948946,
0.4619969726,
-0.1202129722,
0.189484179,
0.6499243975,
0.7386370301,
0.0376768187,
-0.015656,
0.4203752875,
0.1657755822,
0.5538334846,
0.5394075513,
0.7471072674,
-0.7448834777,
0.5761793256,
0.0783896521,
-0.1473250538,
-0.3522299826,
-0.9066573381,
-1.290692687,
-0.486597687,
-0.229834199,
-0.2885998785,
-0.2448035181,
0.580935359,
0.5006759763,
-0.8166131973,
0.0777845308,
-0.4110409021,
0.2410007715,
0.1820104867,
-0.3132854104,
0.5400610566,
-0.1103284061,
-0.9419564605,
0.3890210986,
0.1184477508,
0.1553155482,
-0.3014152348,
-0.1290064901,
-0.3303526044,
-0.0376763046,
0.5287358165,
-0.2190036625,
-0.7390848398,
-0.15641433,
-0.1408797801,
-0.3364079595,
0.212010473,
0.6633526087,
-0.644012928,
0.0100437487,
0.3571203053,
0.7710314393,
0.3649792075,
-0.2371765524,
0.2577352524,
-0.7281899452,
0.2319499105,
0.1480163932,
0.4315919578,
0.4535159767,
-0.8224655986,
0.2889053524,
0.0936203897,
-0.7706398368,
-0.5845495462,
0.1357714087,
-0.643902123,
-0.1092820466,
1.0929275751,
0.0633979589,
-0.3691567481,
0.1763064563,
-0.5360908508,
0.6213827729,
-0.526414454,
0.7316322327,
0.3898500502,
0.1993999779,
-0.4598967731,
-0.1871270835,
0.4213770628,
0.0977391154,
-1.0744841099,
-0.2089724243,
0.2812724411,
0.0939197168,
0.3823332787,
0.4203940332,
0.2825469077,
0.0902137235,
-0.2706497014,
0.3297058642,
-0.2277542502,
-0.3487620354,
-0.3218224347,
0.1469070315,
-0.0753953755,
-0.0619445071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07234v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07234v1
|
Goal-guided Generative Prompt Injection Attack on Large Language Models
| 2024-04-06T06:17:10 | 2024-04-06T06:17:10 |
Chong Zhang, Mingyu Jin, Qinkai Yu, Chengzhi Liu, Haochen Xue, Xiaobo Jin
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Current large language models (LLMs) provide a strong foundation for
large-scale user-oriented natural language tasks. A large number of users can
easily inject adversarial text or instructions through the user interface, thus
causing LLMs model security challenges. Although there is currently a large
amount of research on prompt injection attacks, most of these black-box attacks
use heuristic strategies. It is unclear how these heuristic strategies relate
to the success rate of attacks and thus effectively improve model robustness.
To solve this problem, we redefine the goal of the attack: to maximize the KL
divergence between the conditional probabilities of the clean text and the
adversarial text. Furthermore, we prove that maximizing the KL divergence is
equivalent to maximizing the Mahalanobis distance between the embedded
representation $x$ and $x'$ of the clean text and the adversarial text when the
conditional probability is a Gaussian distribution and gives a quantitative
relationship on $x$ and $x'$. Then we designed a simple and effective
goal-guided generative prompt injection strategy (G2PIA) to find an injection
text that satisfies specific constraints to achieve the optimal attack effect
approximately. It is particularly noteworthy that our attack method is a
query-free black-box attack method with low computational cost. Experimental
results on seven LLM models and four datasets show the effectiveness of our
attack method.
|
[
-0.2031552196,
-1.1875547171,
0.7606347799,
0.0651779324,
-0.2910264134,
0.0681074485,
-0.2080934048,
-0.1134374589,
-0.2904827595,
0.4566853046,
-0.4450297654,
-0.8245870471,
-0.75042665,
0.0283806454,
-0.3636660874,
0.717414856,
0.3186330795,
-0.1313588768,
-0.0658313483,
0.3434023559,
-0.5733402967,
-0.418731153,
-0.6764659882,
0.0193183031,
0.6073242426,
0.0991841853,
0.8370475769,
0.4340111613,
0.4567452073,
0.1997048855,
-0.3852927983,
-0.0176933222,
-0.362670362,
0.3379225135,
-0.0933072269,
-0.8294283748,
0.0834542066,
-0.3011569679,
0.4387808442,
0.4564396441,
-0.186056599,
-0.3657166362,
0.0821267441,
0.3186659217,
-0.854834199,
-0.0456025042,
-0.5642246008,
0.1854179949,
-0.3415085971,
-0.2243645936,
-0.7564899921,
-0.1735355258,
-0.0609410629,
-0.5859153271,
0.0593551807,
0.0169058219,
1.0100727081,
0.2273457497,
-0.5243356228,
-0.5009733438,
-0.4543237388,
0.857437253,
-0.7702887654,
0.1560507417,
0.2708676755,
0.498506546,
-0.6731612086,
-0.3554682732,
-0.4324019849,
-0.2697574794,
-0.0629467517,
-0.0391961299,
-0.5331783295,
0.3063060045,
0.4202827811,
0.1432284713,
-0.605104506,
0.3513319194,
-0.088647671,
-0.2790270448,
0.4597004056,
0.2755963802,
0.5730945468,
-0.4792114794,
-0.6058377624,
-0.033564616,
-0.8612940907,
-0.0042893654,
0.6070439219,
0.4441728294,
-0.172108829,
0.5138645172,
-0.352640152,
0.7040938139,
0.148473829,
-0.3100784421,
-0.1901785582,
-0.5599204898,
-0.1473228484,
-0.1165785864,
1.1537094116,
0.2800366282,
0.1791361868,
-0.0652050897,
-0.2285305411,
-0.1416208744,
0.2824496925,
-1.0405400991,
-0.1317909658,
0.2503710389,
-0.1306176037,
-0.4643415809,
-0.1886279732,
-0.904569149,
-0.5004415512,
0.1505938321,
0.3477904201,
-0.5079512,
-0.0358983763,
0.0893431529,
-0.2420798987,
0.2311911285,
0.1847084165,
-1.0490669012,
-0.0356448404,
0.6633562446,
0.9079905152,
-0.0718984678,
0.2089769989,
-0.7721548676,
0.3683059514,
-0.3963266313,
0.6821552515,
-0.5023034811,
-0.8278672695,
0.2906236351,
-0.2582294941,
0.2145595253,
-0.3402295113,
0.540876925,
-0.9146467447,
0.4132725,
-0.368258357,
-0.757039547,
-0.080266349,
0.385237515,
-0.3703472018,
0.5056225657,
-0.0612345599,
-0.5505462885,
0.2290064096,
-0.6257894039,
-0.5159087181,
0.2067631632,
-0.1998173147,
-0.3537626565,
0.1513320357,
0.3938848078,
0.5019276738,
-0.2398378402,
0.1746884137,
-0.3458738327,
-0.0939863846,
0.2283547223,
-0.5725351572,
1.1697788239,
0.1678514332,
-0.1680966318,
0.2290086299,
-0.4963851571,
0.1578110009,
0.3475709856,
-0.2973187864,
-0.4924803078,
-0.1649990678,
-0.2542575598,
-0.3269514441,
0.214367792,
-0.2426540256,
0.5058354735,
-0.6316695809,
0.3239966035,
0.6758000851,
0.5578393936,
0.4608125687,
0.1495784223,
0.6670460105,
-0.022764951,
0.4626999795,
-0.3625179231,
-0.571470201,
-0.1621075571,
-0.7124739885,
0.2862714231,
0.7911579609,
-0.8628653288,
0.4975721836,
0.21300295,
-0.374815613,
-0.2206402123,
0.1558081359,
0.4392972887,
0.5503702164,
0.3611142039,
0.048319377,
-0.0505175814,
-0.9293472767,
-0.1784568131,
-0.2477777302,
-0.3641492724,
0.128878057,
0.3340542316,
-0.2260093987,
0.7129509449,
-0.8913604021,
-0.1413519382,
-0.1651843339,
-0.0156560633,
0.3962822855,
0.3271574378,
0.6201145053,
-0.6014078259,
-0.7086314559,
-0.0707988068,
-0.7878111005,
-0.2590633035,
-0.3202423155,
-0.2893276513,
0.0112168519,
0.4224006534,
-0.9415322542,
0.4946360886,
0.2922478318,
-0.4027955234,
0.6699440479,
-0.1565515846,
0.1508469582,
-1.164819479,
-0.141946435,
0.0319290422,
-0.1097283661,
-1.0917381048,
0.5318700075,
0.2232923508,
-0.019178519,
-0.5505349636,
0.6144410968,
-0.4587869346,
0.2277942747,
-0.3224600255,
0.0211933274,
0.1495015323,
0.3390707076,
-0.3815351427,
0.8997804523,
0.6620458961,
-0.5534980297,
0.2577871382,
0.3413683474,
-0.3977194428,
0.839848876,
-0.8975396752,
0.1144371033,
0.0081884572,
0.1516354233,
-1.0305199623,
-0.2299009264,
0.7787024975,
-0.5577353835,
0.5577555895,
-0.2219199687,
-0.4753602147,
0.0424623415,
-0.355076015,
0.2904549241,
0.760537982,
-0.5917831659,
0.4180654287,
-0.1115920022,
-0.1009586081,
-0.833501339,
-0.5552501082,
0.5818393826,
-0.3659784198,
-0.6258051991,
0.3711472452,
-0.0702680871,
-0.2494815737,
-0.2228261828,
0.3916240036,
0.1134599,
0.4236957133,
-0.0729272068,
0.2761853337,
0.0172187537,
-0.249620989,
0.2015924901,
-0.1693481356,
0.1322398633,
-0.1814018041,
0.5643468499,
0.4897491932,
-0.6093311906,
-0.8588624001,
0.6920269132,
0.3696260452,
-0.0328627415,
0.7950283885,
0.4954501688,
-0.3306975961,
-0.2533315718,
-0.2814128399,
-0.1690468192,
-0.5033579469,
0.5395152569,
-0.4887270033,
-0.51094836,
0.3082523942,
0.2493791133,
0.0577474535,
0.2095539719,
0.5054110289,
-0.0185824092,
1.2163454294,
0.4132324159,
0.0235378202,
0.5112059712,
-0.2722743154,
0.1663925946,
-0.7461946607,
-0.2148333639,
-0.5484505892,
0.1203889176,
-0.2334870398,
-0.313005507,
0.3547220528,
0.4733921289,
-0.0493671075,
0.1177346036,
-0.303422451,
0.4828544259,
0.7258293033,
0.024491882,
0.0697349906,
0.1690496802,
-0.2745425403,
-0.0860616043,
-0.6035007834,
-0.375744909,
1.0845932961,
0.3315823078,
0.6700442433,
0.3960816264,
0.7524542212,
0.4565262198,
0.0620433241,
-0.8500234485,
0.6012949944,
0.0348171927,
-0.3172921538,
-0.1454156041,
-0.4214141965,
-1.0558129549,
0.1699690521,
0.0396689624,
-0.6994183064,
0.1977505535,
0.1732419729,
-0.4778357744,
0.1864373982,
-0.8430371881,
0.8377069235,
-0.2343502939,
-0.2885808051,
-0.0893422961,
-0.5136243701,
0.3840099573,
-0.0112689659,
-0.0552777573,
0.0862727389,
-0.4324150681,
0.2448719144,
-0.3902209699,
0.904743433,
-0.517952323,
-0.3669703901,
0.1827223301,
0.088046141,
0.8525340557,
0.1495874673,
0.182139203,
0.2902154624,
-0.3255660236,
-0.6830781698,
-0.7388213873,
0.3334153593,
-0.4658533037,
-1.1968125105,
-0.253837347,
-0.4717210233,
-0.0836288407,
0.2299720943,
0.2554703951,
0.381683141,
-0.2496710569,
0.0110660782,
0.8761582971,
-0.643253684,
0.4353320301,
0.282823205,
-0.0421941429,
-0.6975322962,
0.8001962304,
-0.2431028485,
0.8829798698,
0.5164710879,
0.19974567,
-0.4817141593,
-0.8995862603,
-0.7398138046,
0.0938551277,
-0.7301346064,
-0.3260735571,
-0.4502738118,
0.0607120134,
-0.3716704845,
-0.2377463728,
0.1121408269,
0.0251022317,
-0.5340285897,
0.1484712958,
0.1854797751,
0.3939048946,
0.1110401675,
0.6692374945,
-0.5494071841,
0.3091000319,
0.2893462479,
-0.1240325049,
-0.1088849008,
-0.5141068101,
0.0671788007,
0.0258900765,
-0.3385969996,
-1.3809710741,
0.3992081285,
-0.0322219841,
0.47739923,
0.8647695184,
0.0447250009,
0.3186480999,
-0.5341502428,
0.8078663349,
0.3839390278,
-0.6528918743,
0.6047857404,
-0.5008147359,
0.6995882392,
0.2465738058,
0.3552021086,
-0.5601748824,
-0.4901203811,
-0.2911380529,
-0.6123889685,
0.3054813147,
0.1939447671,
0.2536657155,
-0.2022264004,
0.40802899,
-0.0578912534,
0.1652310789,
-0.3466258645,
-0.2946281135,
0.1040264219,
-0.2933377922,
0.1551389098,
-0.4803391099,
-0.2186885774,
0.3168441951,
0.6309201121,
-0.2079001665,
0.3344499767,
0.0260924455,
-0.0210400373,
0.3182555139,
0.4567922354,
0.6411944628,
0.1894964874,
0.1722054332,
0.0746738464,
0.0947268084,
-0.382032007,
0.2973627746,
0.3291928768,
-0.8186950684,
-0.0645641685,
0.4052796364,
0.6707366705,
0.0458032228,
-0.6197446585,
0.5704180598,
-0.1388812214,
-0.0090048509,
-0.0181931537,
0.1929335594,
0.0965066999,
0.4032602608,
0.4656588733,
-0.1289759129,
0.1033221707,
-0.2565032542,
0.0703156069,
0.959862709,
-0.3031223714,
-0.1410963982,
0.6218392849,
-0.0063985963,
-0.5270317793,
0.468059212,
-0.3547157347,
-0.6642948389,
0.5744673014,
0.4674795866,
0.923615694,
-0.4363626838,
0.2632440031,
0.3791960776,
0.3166108131,
0.1572251022,
0.0676423386,
0.003075555,
-0.3310354948,
-0.3565018475,
-0.4020558298,
-0.2464546412,
-0.0111888321,
-0.4074259996,
0.2577915788,
-0.5893672109,
-0.0726804063,
-0.0957209095,
-0.1373256743,
-0.3347339332,
-0.0803538188,
0.0026893085,
0.8258702159,
-0.4306922257,
0.3939060867,
0.0964766592,
-0.4084433913,
-0.3171032667,
0.0576092675,
0.0877208859,
-0.8874245882,
0.6353126764,
0.1207906678,
0.2694466412,
-0.2008439302,
-0.4802615643,
-0.695397377,
0.7305265069,
0.4054293633,
-0.7385709882,
-0.0550303869,
0.2308353335,
0.284496963,
-0.0052310028,
0.0057099182,
0.3294215202,
0.3683386147,
0.0124875065,
-0.3683696985,
0.2355597913,
0.0405637622,
0.0670493245,
0.4531066418,
-0.3910589516,
0.5017364621,
-0.5179210305,
-0.5766513348,
0.2954187691,
0.9030553102,
0.1464398801,
0.0005825012,
0.5636439323,
0.6375423074,
0.8378335238,
0.0215898585,
1.3304259777,
-0.1743352115,
0.0916934758,
0.7829433084,
-0.021890521,
0.7225999236,
0.5055782199,
-0.2447972447,
0.2607269883,
0.4852750599,
-0.1615998,
0.7875614166,
0.3340988159,
-0.6279703975,
-0.0968388841,
-0.206523627,
-0.3666466475,
-0.012836542,
0.3830281496,
-0.2280447632,
-0.1294390112,
0.1658770293,
0.4774461389,
0.0823167711,
-0.0573459864,
0.8096935749,
-0.0679837391,
-0.6146613955,
0.7265552878,
0.1733253598,
0.6311329603,
-0.7743651271,
0.1122804955,
-0.3100361228,
0.1109380871,
0.0532594323,
-0.6308898926,
-0.0885092914,
0.0983421504,
-0.1681594104,
0.077179946,
0.6069077253,
-0.4495246112,
-0.3192198575,
-0.0070981989,
0.2409581542,
-0.1226275191,
-0.0542263351,
-0.7203161716,
0.0519691966,
0.0815379545,
-0.3063701093,
0.3322230279,
0.1538944542,
0.1358029693,
0.740110755,
0.7529770136,
0.1391357481,
-0.0027088982,
0.1125508696,
0.590770781,
-0.4398628473,
-0.5886690617,
-1.2019444704,
0.3928346336,
-0.3022496104,
-0.1127279475,
0.8727379441,
0.260175854,
0.4283717871,
0.1204579398,
0.8834616542,
0.1381499767,
0.0822466016,
-0.6774827242,
0.5664132237,
-0.385322094,
0.3422988355,
-0.1205255315,
-0.6146833897,
-0.4185805321,
0.234629333,
-0.3070994318,
-0.0320132114,
0.5778248906,
1.1065353155,
0.1853049695,
-0.1891749501,
0.4023970068,
0.2065610141,
0.8692780733,
0.8091951013,
0.9928264022,
-0.3457362056,
0.6966481805,
-0.1475149244,
-0.4124595821,
-0.1824824065,
-0.9038375616,
-1.2534923553,
-0.1560605168,
-0.3720122874,
-0.3706592321,
0.4407213628,
0.6168251634,
0.5272493362,
-0.7087890506,
0.126090467,
-0.0435083434,
0.2348369211,
0.0449284092,
-0.2754971981,
0.4702830613,
-0.5642314553,
-0.7942087054,
0.5320340991,
0.2148885876,
0.2458637804,
-0.6597132683,
-0.1076738387,
-0.1944214553,
0.2101335824,
0.4087782502,
0.266516149,
-0.891053021,
-0.3342254758,
0.0995071381,
-0.2790958881,
-0.1194139197,
0.4383120537,
-0.4459843338,
0.4572217464,
0.379914254,
0.9901074767,
-0.0022296282,
-0.0480973087,
0.6555708647,
-0.8393465877,
0.0134644601,
0.0406210832,
0.2600538731,
0.3517780304,
-0.640401721,
0.1762680858,
0.2822389305,
-0.3178385198,
-1.0053230524,
0.4961252511,
-0.7996759415,
-0.5121436715,
1.3959761858,
-0.2093646079,
-0.3058906198,
-0.0146141378,
-0.420941174,
0.0289973933,
-0.6015985012,
0.7004769444,
0.544800818,
0.2097107917,
-0.0133442786,
-0.7028321028,
0.4933772981,
0.5105473399,
-0.9334551692,
0.0274423808,
0.5987101793,
0.0771675631,
0.1510141641,
0.1598533094,
0.0510943867,
0.4182985425,
0.0449063443,
-0.1782739908,
-0.1545929611,
-0.2565508187,
-0.3741041124,
0.675875783,
-0.0479699709,
-0.3229039311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04516v1
|
Language Models as Critical Thinking Tools: A Case Study of Philosophers
| 2024-04-06T06:12:13 | 2024-04-06T06:12:13 |
Andre Ye, Jared Moore, Rose Novick, Amy X. Zhang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Current work in language models (LMs) helps us speed up or even skip thinking
by accelerating and automating cognitive work. But can LMs help us with
critical thinking -- thinking in deeper, more reflective ways which challenge
assumptions, clarify ideas, and engineer new concepts? We treat philosophy as a
case study in critical thinking, and interview 21 professional philosophers
about how they engage in critical thinking and on their experiences with LMs.
We find that philosophers do not find LMs to be useful because they lack a
sense of selfhood (memory, beliefs, consistency) and initiative (curiosity,
proactivity). We propose the selfhood-initiative model for critical thinking
tools to characterize this gap. Using the model, we formulate three roles LMs
could play as critical thinking tools: the Interlocutor, the Monitor, and the
Respondent. We hope that our work inspires LM researchers to further develop
LMs as critical thinking tools and philosophers and other 'critical thinkers'
to imagine intellectually substantive uses of LMs.
|
[
-0.5137280226,
-0.7040910125,
0.8033099771,
-0.1463715732,
-0.1277302057,
0.2562957704,
-0.0584722646,
-0.2730698586,
0.152532354,
0.6610526443,
-0.4657669961,
0.064274244,
-0.516423285,
-0.0744443238,
-0.5495910048,
0.5864157677,
-0.0538262576,
0.0973538086,
0.2887448967,
-0.1263630986,
-0.3303712904,
-0.3306959569,
-0.5655513406,
-0.4654710591,
0.354016602,
0.4623738527,
0.7700334191,
0.2763797045,
0.5689352155,
0.3277207911,
0.1623972654,
-0.3035351634,
-0.30510059,
0.3039080799,
-0.4595784843,
-0.384621948,
-0.3359586298,
0.3832727075,
0.5822370648,
0.8150799274,
-0.3339456916,
0.4527111948,
-0.0475529768,
0.7201059461,
-0.4356527328,
0.0303743836,
-0.652068615,
0.3593389392,
0.0037224884,
0.1986234933,
-0.3041275144,
-0.6261247396,
0.3159886897,
-0.2370108515,
0.1536860168,
-0.1287484616,
0.3207581639,
0.2199359685,
-0.093049176,
-0.284478724,
-1.0353572369,
0.5542324781,
-1.0154650211,
0.3160693347,
0.0147940619,
0.1137969792,
-0.0642951876,
-0.423386693,
-0.6446585655,
-0.1570380628,
0.2242245972,
0.0236192755,
0.1122527495,
0.0851393864,
0.3304365277,
0.6430885792,
-0.3362292945,
-0.2369757295,
-0.6248144507,
-0.1887006462,
0.5350635052,
0.3858159781,
0.2590643764,
0.0479805097,
-0.2059715986,
-0.0238265656,
-0.4975593984,
0.1521774232,
0.2729094625,
0.2035626769,
0.5252010822,
0.2910713255,
-0.096033752,
0.5537150502,
-0.4506245852,
-0.0502324514,
-0.1191813871,
-0.1668858081,
-0.205761835,
-0.1428317726,
0.8481797576,
0.3541012108,
0.5977749228,
0.1304219961,
-0.1498183012,
0.1318143755,
0.4074649215,
-0.7014437914,
-0.5211600065,
0.0501202196,
-0.3909144998,
-0.2016762942,
-0.2237759084,
-0.6428502798,
-0.4465664327,
0.0740881711,
0.5512485504,
-0.2518638372,
-0.7336475849,
0.4517788589,
-0.1312144846,
0.0484481715,
0.3086339235,
-0.6566938758,
0.6095030308,
0.3885947764,
0.6116480231,
0.1750544012,
-0.2363217622,
0.1216409206,
-0.0051169447,
-0.706566453,
0.6313633323,
-0.6047278047,
-0.7109560966,
0.1762036085,
-0.2138985097,
0.0900586322,
-0.4877467155,
0.6671359539,
-0.1343073994,
0.4474330544,
-0.5885807872,
-0.7294979692,
-0.4154533446,
0.2990207374,
-0.6495537162,
1.16013062,
-0.1266839206,
-0.345251292,
0.1609539986,
-0.6254314184,
-0.1176941469,
0.4212784469,
-0.5055848956,
-0.1189528331,
0.1892299205,
-0.2474373281,
0.6896258593,
-0.5605964661,
0.1761433482,
-0.4642885327,
-0.1064476073,
0.6681416035,
-0.0908562914,
0.632417202,
0.0468764603,
-0.3208780289,
-0.097859174,
-0.3558416069,
0.3826130629,
0.3725693226,
-0.1929325312,
-0.3012907505,
0.3545716405,
-0.2447384149,
0.3420484662,
-0.006375642,
-0.6327167749,
0.2478425652,
-0.441113025,
0.5960603952,
0.7526637316,
-0.1113732755,
0.3188100457,
-0.1828549206,
0.546233058,
-0.3999421895,
0.3822564185,
-0.1002201289,
-0.5680116415,
-1.1073026657,
0.1990134716,
-0.0902141035,
0.6090248823,
-0.309578687,
-0.1080487147,
0.1777311563,
-0.7944331765,
-0.6216769814,
0.4754663408,
0.623380065,
0.667976737,
0.1242848933,
-0.6228459477,
-0.1503641903,
-0.9116744995,
-0.6716551781,
-0.4162421227,
0.3825368285,
0.3261388242,
0.5520626307,
0.2263669819,
0.6347257495,
-0.7334207892,
-0.1606497616,
-0.443603009,
0.0683119372,
0.2250813246,
0.2219269127,
0.3118851781,
-0.3905213475,
-0.2164072245,
-0.5539979339,
-0.6716274619,
-0.0325694121,
0.1331559867,
0.0623213202,
-0.3983678818,
0.6425039768,
-0.5230711699,
0.2341598272,
0.1888677031,
-0.255350858,
0.4841811061,
-0.1251890063,
-0.203246519,
-0.8508139253,
-0.1272679418,
-0.051627852,
-0.014423837,
-0.8594491482,
0.1315955669,
-0.0917294174,
-0.3435561061,
-0.3301774561,
0.5229569077,
-0.5597628951,
0.0312580727,
-0.3047097027,
0.3872497082,
0.0059850304,
0.0514307097,
-0.0263007153,
0.6602888703,
0.4160439968,
-0.6540561318,
0.0037712955,
-0.1331717074,
-0.6996777058,
0.1872719079,
-0.4298204482,
0.3924425542,
0.0322054476,
-0.0370570458,
-0.7998487353,
0.0472619981,
0.4966003001,
-0.1006839052,
0.0269338731,
0.1102796718,
-0.409149915,
-0.5607609153,
-0.2597345114,
0.3858192861,
0.418214649,
0.1493601054,
0.5752909184,
0.7173019052,
-0.3690849245,
-0.4815964103,
-0.5955597758,
-0.0119505422,
-0.1507023871,
-0.1946158558,
-0.1496786028,
-0.4025609493,
-0.582955122,
0.0855642334,
0.0305166207,
-0.3345619738,
0.3935974836,
0.1948100626,
0.2549817562,
-0.2113711983,
0.3190576136,
-0.2148623019,
-0.0259740241,
0.4286124408,
-0.117086269,
0.4061923325,
-0.5369837284,
-0.4419119954,
-0.2958307862,
0.4245992899,
0.4890345335,
-0.332945317,
0.3001075387,
0.2428103387,
-0.3606138527,
-0.2365370691,
-0.9749335051,
-0.3434803486,
-0.4679228663,
0.2346804142,
-0.2640648782,
-0.9869360328,
0.3165878057,
-0.3359807432,
0.0646374449,
0.2791918814,
0.6715283394,
-0.2465891242,
0.6094467044,
0.8192747235,
-0.0401032865,
0.3865630329,
-0.4471399486,
0.7012718916,
-0.9497442245,
0.0273131598,
-0.1812362671,
-0.2200761884,
-0.0454593971,
-0.546182394,
0.2854920924,
-0.0381784365,
-0.034097366,
0.1535722166,
-0.6325076222,
0.5681400895,
0.2855529189,
-0.1337355524,
0.1225871518,
-0.6433708668,
-0.0705825165,
-0.1432820559,
-0.6331492662,
-0.8557257652,
0.9465010762,
0.4673268199,
0.8875787854,
0.057339415,
0.4776085317,
0.2618513107,
0.279052794,
-0.9131369591,
1.0829628706,
0.2868632674,
-1.0785993338,
-0.4606109262,
0.1596564204,
-0.4717734754,
0.3083020151,
0.12204469,
-0.6712732911,
0.196773231,
0.3078617752,
-0.6897589564,
0.4883072972,
-0.5093073249,
0.8699358106,
-0.0603149086,
-0.1118957922,
-0.6413030624,
-0.551163435,
0.4089992046,
0.1552277058,
0.4265830517,
-0.5832158923,
0.0841718167,
0.8436392546,
-0.0825981796,
0.9953572154,
-0.0076117883,
-0.1654306203,
0.769369185,
0.8159933686,
-0.0545088202,
-0.0180901475,
-0.0034798947,
-0.0751986653,
0.0842835531,
-0.1255184412,
-0.4609577358,
0.4582755864,
-0.516626358,
-1.0253121853,
-0.5838451982,
-0.5493557453,
-0.1448054165,
0.3003756702,
-0.0529026277,
0.3643789589,
-0.5552433133,
-0.0749597773,
0.8592714071,
0.4795644283,
0.7431941628,
0.8205418587,
-0.493093431,
-0.1272648424,
0.628905952,
0.5266836286,
0.5311099887,
0.047325328,
0.3319227099,
-0.0095718242,
-0.3506730199,
-0.3847291768,
0.2426858097,
-1.0028249025,
0.1800382435,
-0.5760613084,
-0.285687685,
-0.1353767663,
0.0190602578,
-0.6404583454,
-0.5738430023,
-0.0651939586,
-0.0679144114,
0.0654621497,
0.9409006834,
-0.0301793702,
0.1037314087,
-0.5777772665,
-0.1086604372,
0.7086217999,
0.1851468831,
0.0839618444,
-0.2738189101,
-0.1667307615,
-0.4764328897,
-0.3627305925,
-1.1109086275,
0.0802955106,
0.1076431274,
0.5059403181,
0.5385986567,
-0.1178757474,
0.3053426445,
-0.8260638714,
0.8626541495,
-0.0664506704,
-1.0598118305,
0.5694930553,
-0.1751861721,
0.1667715907,
0.4603785276,
0.395285815,
-0.6614899635,
-0.5609648824,
-0.446623534,
-0.3246515393,
0.2823749781,
-0.0192998704,
0.4032808244,
-0.0159294419,
0.5857168436,
0.2073022723,
0.3050680161,
-0.9400548339,
0.0191865973,
-0.0494379029,
0.1291102171,
-0.3030465841,
-0.5169143677,
-0.5120222569,
-0.2188064456,
0.5635664463,
-0.1510326862,
-0.089228116,
0.6189379692,
0.0500720963,
-0.1761323065,
0.5570908189,
0.3881789446,
0.7681289911,
0.0552167259,
0.2042695135,
0.3368960619,
-0.278650105,
0.1762603521,
-0.397236675,
-0.0424729474,
-0.1741597503,
0.1003162265,
0.2962973118,
0.1682760864,
-0.7564324737,
0.4005293846,
-0.1825263798,
0.045100946,
-0.5581567883,
0.3270168602,
0.2843443751,
0.5247783065,
0.1057255268,
-0.0231815986,
0.5056326985,
-1.06001091,
-0.22530891,
0.5664249063,
-0.5750758052,
-0.4722135663,
0.4126300514,
0.2620512247,
-0.7253898978,
0.1701866388,
-0.0327131487,
-0.7896376252,
0.213020727,
0.3843381107,
1.0812898874,
-0.6794133782,
0.4242484272,
-0.1291920245,
0.6739695072,
-0.2172975838,
0.5935044885,
-0.1127209812,
-1.0456365347,
-0.2944873273,
-0.2854675651,
-0.8090364337,
0.1839092076,
-0.4783472419,
-0.0450825952,
-0.8468266129,
-0.4712512791,
-0.1576509327,
0.0460620113,
-0.464392066,
0.2446774542,
0.2354980111,
0.9189749956,
-0.9781749249,
0.7504609823,
0.4992634058,
-0.2953456044,
-0.8373313546,
-0.0067035961,
0.0085600363,
-0.5980007648,
0.5260250568,
0.1647411436,
-0.7031077147,
-0.2100233287,
-0.3540012538,
-0.8438028693,
0.6958344579,
0.4608790278,
-0.5591196418,
0.0426001512,
-0.0237718001,
0.451148808,
-0.4461583197,
0.2114562988,
0.3321009278,
0.0715721324,
-0.426705569,
-1.0958557129,
0.078540802,
-0.3337366879,
-0.0751482472,
0.3504452109,
-1.0307822227,
1.189435482,
-0.3137854636,
-0.0046850955,
0.0397858024,
0.381616801,
-0.2386448979,
0.2254595459,
0.3721977472,
0.5348292589,
0.6271451712,
0.2363402843,
0.7751040459,
-0.4368326068,
0.3273403347,
0.970582962,
-0.4626017809,
0.9064575434,
0.3807005882,
0.0697542429,
0.7228495479,
0.3054789305,
0.2860765755,
0.3173513114,
0.0705143735,
-0.3699120581,
-0.6204906702,
-0.060781572,
-0.4967359006,
0.3159235716,
0.6036580801,
-0.3696869016,
0.0257611722,
-0.1076035723,
0.2316271961,
0.3741773665,
-0.2906786501,
0.4433094859,
0.4257291257,
-0.5288835764,
-0.0176999755,
-0.2056928724,
-0.1913302541,
-0.2520045936,
0.0642956272,
0.0449408442,
0.4104578197,
0.2543345094,
-1.2642611265,
0.060155943,
-0.3141509593,
-0.1315683275,
-0.4304215014,
0.8915694356,
0.0795650631,
-0.6545914412,
0.4379170239,
0.8562658429,
0.3206629455,
0.1463457942,
-0.8948262334,
0.1956714839,
-0.2226916552,
-0.2723060548,
0.0463152789,
0.3528416157,
0.1329662055,
1.1382079124,
0.2536151409,
0.1642048806,
0.1067896783,
0.1604222059,
0.9328221679,
-0.825868547,
-0.1183913425,
-1.0299167633,
0.2853708863,
-0.1914051324,
-0.5150343776,
0.6519321203,
0.5081217289,
0.8786475658,
-0.0472826287,
0.6924037337,
0.1357986927,
0.7432391644,
-0.3444469273,
0.6538293958,
-0.2558735609,
0.0128618395,
-0.4160286784,
-0.8020122647,
0.0274571273,
0.7438435555,
-0.5518658161,
-0.1683246642,
0.6306607127,
0.5230616927,
0.1857297122,
0.1607962847,
0.3194372654,
0.3233451247,
0.3076760173,
0.4445622861,
1.0821902752,
-0.3303780556,
0.2710135579,
-0.2980645001,
-0.1034292951,
-0.0341437273,
-0.714235723,
-1.2266894579,
-0.7188257575,
-0.2470210195,
-0.1315315813,
-0.070596531,
0.8216304779,
0.517056942,
-0.3523687124,
-0.75409168,
-0.0340503789,
0.1052121222,
0.1656654179,
-0.2111209929,
-0.2385781258,
-0.220801115,
-0.407519877,
0.5277378559,
0.6855925322,
-0.1314627081,
-0.9791231155,
0.2548209429,
-0.1770289242,
0.6810791492,
0.3497767448,
0.3861700296,
-1.1271393299,
-0.4640418887,
0.0769808069,
0.1404889971,
0.0002755449,
1.0398979187,
-0.7633468509,
0.7951755524,
0.2619143128,
0.23653543,
0.198494643,
-0.4339247048,
0.5071136951,
0.1291978359,
0.2224618644,
0.7708486319,
0.4491253793,
0.3233080208,
-0.0976131409,
0.4556333721,
0.2008747607,
-0.6996641159,
-1.0699599981,
0.6303458214,
-0.4750747085,
-0.2508987486,
0.6138937473,
0.0029912586,
-0.1315646023,
0.062390402,
-0.2740084827,
-0.0235578697,
-0.1897792667,
0.941716671,
1.0824078321,
-0.2756635249,
-0.4096253514,
-0.9151242971,
0.5715619922,
0.7503487468,
-0.3941355348,
-0.0061774477,
-0.0200169254,
0.4733932316,
0.4030058086,
1.0784974098,
0.0309821479,
0.0733703524,
-0.0924400538,
0.2223260254,
0.545976758,
-0.4271265864,
-0.0089992927,
0.1244196743,
0.4332080185,
0.2117335945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04514v1
|
Joint Visual and Text Prompting for Improved Object-Centric Perception with Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-04-06T05:59:02 | 2024-04-06T05:59:02 |
Songtao Jiang, Yan Zhang, Chenyi Zhou, Yeying Jin, Yang Feng, Jian Wu, Zuozhu Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) such as GPT-4V and Gemini Pro face
challenges in achieving human-level perception in Visual Question Answering
(VQA), particularly in object-oriented perception tasks which demand
fine-grained understanding of object identities, locations or attributes, as
indicated by empirical findings. This is mainly due to their limited capability
to effectively integrate complex visual cues with textual information and
potential object hallucinations. In this paper, we present a novel approach,
Joint Visual and Text Prompting (VTPrompt), that employs fine-grained visual
information to enhance the capability of MLLMs in VQA, especially for
object-oriented perception. VTPrompt merges visual and text prompts to extract
key concepts from textual questions and employs a detection model to highlight
relevant objects as visual prompts in images. The processed images alongside
text prompts are subsequently fed into MLLMs to produce more accurate answers.
Our experiments with GPT-4V and Gemini Pro, on three benchmarks, i.e., MME ,
MMB and POPE, demonstrate significant improvements. Particularly, our method
led to a score improvement of up to 183.5 for GPT-4V on MME and enhanced MMB
performance by 8.17\% for GPT-4V and 15.69\% for Gemini Pro.
|
[
-0.7046811581,
-1.1924573183,
0.9697660804,
0.1540456712,
-0.4269444942,
-0.1956323832,
-0.3687156737,
-0.4436473548,
-0.2527597547,
0.4336749017,
-0.6615355015,
-0.6503762007,
-0.2845821977,
0.3347627819,
-0.1009668857,
0.6774131656,
0.0076240827,
0.1087396592,
-0.5940163732,
-0.047011923,
-1.0527145863,
-0.3729870915,
-0.5152218938,
0.0885458589,
0.7299544811,
0.4764020145,
0.4946567118,
0.159856841,
0.4769583046,
0.346509248,
0.0821623877,
0.407556355,
0.1296024173,
0.3123208582,
-0.2790203989,
-0.3527599573,
-0.2344047278,
-0.4137409329,
0.25486359,
0.2512227297,
0.0522578135,
0.1764098108,
0.0848948509,
0.5264820457,
-0.7816779613,
0.2868973613,
-0.4054895043,
0.016286023,
0.0867274627,
-0.5215719342,
-0.5130508542,
0.1647024006,
0.2718343735,
-0.8132027388,
0.2802635431,
0.0428978242,
0.6113061905,
0.2704048157,
-0.1989769936,
-0.1382111162,
-0.4189117849,
0.7980497479,
-0.2581784129,
0.5015123487,
0.2367497832,
0.3393465877,
0.1381799132,
-0.6295073628,
-0.7924475074,
-0.3660238683,
0.0205034278,
0.4905689359,
-0.1115325317,
0.0429222696,
0.3324893117,
-0.0717708692,
-0.7142098546,
-0.0602020025,
-0.2089015841,
-0.3316597641,
0.1121301055,
0.1333429068,
0.2605023384,
-0.369771421,
-0.5557147861,
-0.4414907396,
-0.3066591024,
0.340195924,
0.0234828629,
0.2397243381,
0.0543824844,
0.7179805636,
-0.3030816615,
0.9854920506,
-0.0246260911,
-0.0411993153,
0.2705616653,
-0.5296241045,
-0.2419830412,
-0.2399505526,
0.8100911379,
0.8947405815,
0.4122759402,
0.1821488738,
-0.0790744722,
0.1208399832,
0.2439620793,
-0.6626204848,
-0.1334912032,
0.3057991266,
-0.5559418201,
-0.0588966198,
0.1837186068,
-0.9635186195,
-0.4702836573,
-0.5235983729,
0.7951002717,
-0.4247780144,
-0.1038106233,
0.1685828716,
-0.4563445151,
0.2871073484,
0.9407522678,
-0.9785980582,
-0.2169836909,
0.4290503561,
0.5328829288,
-0.0479163565,
-0.2752248645,
-0.8953005672,
0.208404243,
0.0725286528,
1.0026351213,
-0.69286865,
-0.4358749986,
-0.0947635993,
-0.0496310294,
-0.0031972036,
-0.5588107705,
0.4191232324,
-0.1529163867,
0.5483244061,
-0.5847620368,
0.0231382251,
-0.178534016,
0.8477197289,
-0.4455819428,
0.9957159758,
-0.0325683765,
-0.93175143,
0.3539020121,
-0.542308867,
-0.0414370447,
0.0717658773,
-0.4796059728,
-0.2122984827,
-0.0611509532,
1.0963000059,
0.7466657162,
-0.2191045433,
0.0267726425,
-0.2808321118,
-0.3540977836,
0.3797194064,
-0.9098113179,
0.0467585772,
-0.0499189384,
-0.2364909053,
0.5056833625,
-0.5320876241,
0.0569685884,
-0.0381595939,
-0.0751764476,
-0.2932986319,
-0.1739267111,
0.1299782246,
0.2364897728,
0.4225392044,
-0.3247202039,
0.3810895085,
-0.0193154011,
0.199938938,
0.7050077319,
0.0173891895,
0.2369573414,
-0.0195126757,
0.4265052378,
0.3990741074,
0.5820082426,
-0.5364828706,
-0.815064013,
-0.6260492206,
-0.192294091,
-0.1161469221,
0.7400548458,
-1.4754931927,
-0.1009878367,
0.0528915152,
-0.0917060971,
-0.3971749246,
-0.0030137051,
0.4124002755,
0.763406992,
0.7186595798,
-0.0852830932,
-0.270601362,
-0.7373528481,
-0.0980036408,
-0.4638020694,
-0.3328522146,
0.4312459528,
0.3761813939,
0.0100581711,
0.7162880898,
-0.5369824171,
-0.2247656435,
-0.1973088384,
0.22104913,
0.0360504463,
0.1137953028,
0.4272409081,
-1.168799758,
-0.518296361,
0.1556726098,
-0.6210877299,
0.0189670604,
0.0088690221,
0.09273123,
0.2069318742,
0.5626298785,
-0.5232076645,
0.3264216483,
0.3471189439,
-0.5525255203,
0.7818356752,
-0.3633972704,
0.5094319582,
-1.1162434816,
-0.0517150834,
0.1361255199,
-0.1847936362,
-0.5432431102,
-0.095926322,
0.1026059538,
0.0847523734,
-0.6514248252,
0.6940253377,
-0.3830848038,
0.0857198983,
-0.097788468,
0.4188946784,
0.2050907314,
0.4758355618,
0.1321288049,
1.0000368357,
0.7833072543,
-0.4703955352,
0.4616423249,
0.2153051049,
-0.0718888044,
1.0001575947,
-0.6765469909,
-0.0775565431,
-0.5454348326,
-0.0670427531,
-0.9696998596,
-0.3179733753,
0.3668831885,
-0.4491460025,
0.0618800744,
0.0829774737,
-0.4495997131,
-0.5019082427,
-0.4434269071,
0.3223914504,
0.3545351624,
-0.5770276785,
0.7462763786,
-0.2720953524,
-0.274177134,
-0.8970903158,
-0.5144044757,
0.054488644,
-0.0401914455,
-0.56924963,
0.0601527467,
-0.1577821225,
-0.0286148954,
-0.0599653907,
0.0237361025,
0.0316079296,
-0.1615360379,
0.2317057848,
0.6733157039,
-0.3312748671,
0.2885552347,
-0.0923308358,
-0.1933950186,
0.0007715755,
-0.20279634,
0.6379512548,
-0.2618155181,
-0.5153338313,
-0.5717736483,
0.407163322,
0.5296955705,
-0.5281488895,
0.5293015838,
1.1460206509,
0.02400757,
0.1458803713,
-0.6017004251,
-0.4195839465,
-0.4815060794,
0.4155299664,
-0.5895190239,
-1.0212211609,
0.2901326716,
0.2011358589,
-0.1815190464,
0.291259706,
0.6994197965,
-0.1206059828,
1.279666543,
0.3484183252,
0.2775380909,
0.6778860092,
0.0137903467,
-0.0684343576,
-0.7970690727,
-0.5234075785,
-0.3486142457,
-0.0581741072,
-0.2414406091,
-0.7401738763,
0.647166729,
0.1234287694,
0.0667596757,
-0.0560221635,
-0.6705756783,
0.5209056735,
0.7114913464,
0.3929176033,
0.4344830513,
0.0564791784,
-0.2096327245,
-0.0347519703,
-0.4867385626,
-0.3254601955,
0.7475566864,
0.1137373522,
0.565826714,
-0.0958995298,
0.3796693981,
-0.1783636659,
0.2089346498,
-0.7892118096,
0.6745581031,
-0.1499077827,
-0.3976716399,
-0.3559452593,
-0.3348569274,
-0.7113978267,
0.4808267653,
-0.6303291917,
-0.9277511835,
0.0815631002,
0.2877870202,
-0.4012939632,
0.0021884369,
-0.8416819572,
1.0682522058,
-0.0801429227,
-0.5028988719,
0.0641971827,
-0.5303173661,
0.1524006128,
0.3176084161,
0.0469568931,
0.0436777659,
-0.1369066685,
0.3116850257,
-0.0472103059,
0.8099930882,
-0.3597233295,
-0.1016567275,
0.2870124578,
-0.2590801418,
0.5069312453,
0.2411365658,
0.1150320917,
-0.187365517,
0.0324674807,
-0.2130811214,
-0.9157127142,
0.4560147524,
-0.4747668803,
-0.6259788871,
-0.1373951882,
-0.6427827477,
-0.2429446578,
0.1768249869,
0.3345901966,
0.7530972958,
0.0608957335,
0.3013827801,
0.7688180804,
-0.4305508435,
0.4947923124,
0.3121319413,
-0.416194886,
-0.4525190592,
0.8117426038,
-0.3619598746,
0.2272401303,
0.6142358184,
0.2811951637,
-0.6785331964,
-0.5667520165,
-0.7120471001,
0.0658410564,
-0.7902892828,
-0.1826498806,
-0.8761907816,
0.1764133871,
-0.1826209277,
-0.0864325762,
0.0039776955,
0.031190671,
-0.4039454758,
0.1829984635,
0.4497886598,
0.3838368952,
0.4984121621,
0.2193534672,
-1.0298327208,
0.6382998228,
0.6972607374,
0.1355257779,
-0.1012535319,
-0.2356867939,
0.0815550685,
0.0459872745,
-0.2338021249,
-0.7967998981,
0.1167628616,
-0.2233363986,
0.3243145347,
0.2997302413,
0.0578065328,
0.8440060019,
-0.4049686491,
1.0182788372,
0.5032987595,
-0.8546664119,
0.6097617745,
-0.4448112249,
0.5933402777,
0.5389345884,
0.1013543829,
-0.5588074923,
-0.4904874265,
-0.20239757,
-0.7090914845,
0.4923888445,
0.272878468,
0.0264642835,
0.0817389563,
0.1363460422,
0.0610724278,
0.2333962917,
-0.6555390954,
0.0122104222,
-0.2931193411,
-0.4852606356,
0.0392460041,
-0.1236604303,
0.0756660178,
-0.2014690638,
0.1944213808,
-0.4270680547,
0.2420607656,
0.5294334888,
0.042093154,
0.2593767941,
0.4837453961,
0.6438853741,
0.590497613,
0.0037318235,
0.2204296738,
0.1818019897,
-0.5491399765,
-0.0509852171,
0.0205348413,
-0.021139631,
-0.0608042516,
0.4597119391,
0.9363073707,
-0.1511719823,
-0.7709677219,
0.729809165,
-0.4422237277,
-0.2024180144,
-0.026446322,
0.1978294253,
-0.0328139253,
0.5231540799,
0.3505575657,
0.1061971411,
0.174328357,
-0.5767300725,
-0.0292993225,
0.4258946776,
-0.4905087352,
-0.1046191305,
0.6827683449,
0.1501246244,
-0.0345584713,
0.3477367461,
0.058243528,
-0.5404580235,
0.462921083,
0.4299213588,
0.577421546,
-0.0826684833,
0.4783609509,
0.3591055274,
0.0965862274,
-0.2025256157,
0.6822564602,
-0.3172693253,
-0.5266000628,
-0.5734545588,
-0.4134003818,
-0.4820225239,
0.006340283,
-0.5298762918,
0.3716337979,
-0.2280038595,
-0.0940321609,
0.0877414569,
-0.3087393641,
-0.5332266688,
0.2971231937,
0.2116914988,
0.6623998284,
-0.6582095623,
0.5594014525,
0.913354218,
-0.4331695735,
-0.7780541778,
0.1892147511,
-0.1770487577,
-0.6115970016,
0.6046944261,
0.5683457851,
-0.0724244118,
-0.0092530353,
-0.4687494934,
-0.3791346848,
0.9595897198,
0.2028722763,
-0.5959899426,
0.0536186025,
0.1304059178,
0.4591527283,
-0.1305509508,
0.5129305124,
0.1726424247,
0.8411844373,
0.24163194,
-0.9031050801,
-0.0149057023,
-0.1802518219,
-0.0094277188,
0.3516936302,
-0.4717626274,
0.8155059218,
-0.2230989039,
0.0401958451,
0.0904440209,
0.576055944,
0.4975196421,
0.5925706029,
0.7262025476,
0.1280586571,
0.6032882333,
-0.191737175,
0.9566383958,
0.1131676286,
0.1185643077,
0.8284983039,
-0.0581371635,
1.0777647495,
0.8721284866,
0.0492990725,
0.3762796819,
0.3976116478,
0.0439958908,
0.2959873676,
-0.3251924813,
-0.4679614604,
-0.4213000834,
-0.1928131878,
-0.3419705331,
0.4447495043,
0.2911890447,
-0.1347578019,
-0.1691345572,
0.5625125766,
-0.352129519,
0.1646548957,
-0.3688819706,
0.8032850027,
-0.0579732023,
-0.9026637673,
0.3640918732,
-0.2239891142,
0.7182739973,
-0.4672467113,
-0.2740780711,
0.0240459722,
0.1744841933,
-0.0871782526,
-1.1390948296,
-0.081082575,
0.121475026,
-0.3561246693,
-0.2278046608,
0.5968977213,
-0.646982789,
-0.4246080518,
0.1360080689,
0.4795470238,
-0.0626872554,
-0.6764621735,
-0.6862264276,
0.1296581179,
0.004413052,
-0.1756235063,
-0.005180255,
0.7167249322,
-0.3194029629,
0.6789324284,
0.6968206167,
-0.3474459052,
-0.0467782542,
0.3960562348,
0.9093651772,
-0.6312878728,
-0.3919856548,
-0.9478540421,
0.7105744481,
-0.1478434503,
-0.2771576345,
0.744328618,
0.1298574358,
0.7062453032,
-0.46964854,
0.4724265635,
-0.0161046013,
0.165799126,
-0.9011664391,
0.3984886706,
-0.8152443171,
0.1148420498,
-0.4334942997,
-1.0631096363,
-0.3824853301,
0.3871607184,
-0.2548656166,
0.0280492697,
0.822730124,
0.8546949625,
-0.0640631691,
-0.1549197137,
0.5784943104,
-0.0946600065,
0.3032006323,
0.6118388176,
1.1325306892,
-0.2016215324,
0.793387413,
-0.1387660205,
-0.037526764,
-0.3333391547,
-0.7284039259,
-1.1747612953,
-0.6840552092,
-0.1399194598,
-0.0923382789,
-0.0660265386,
0.6637607813,
0.4370038211,
-0.5047124028,
0.2776311636,
-0.0636122525,
-0.1763427854,
-0.1603571177,
-0.2444678247,
0.3070991635,
-0.2345060557,
-0.8094576001,
0.1224922687,
0.5477056503,
0.2563424706,
-0.3061742187,
-0.0236494038,
-0.0104983542,
-0.1705935746,
0.9079533815,
-0.0710454658,
-0.9061805606,
-0.4174477458,
0.3213238418,
-0.0143672768,
0.0519929416,
0.6325578094,
-0.9182109237,
0.7518624067,
0.7522100806,
0.4072770178,
0.3250453472,
0.2960233688,
0.3970604837,
-0.8025622964,
0.49068138,
0.1191792041,
0.2338634282,
0.5204643011,
-0.448105067,
0.0618545748,
0.1519022882,
-0.2545485198,
-0.471115917,
0.3085379004,
-1.3493463993,
-0.4741607308,
0.9636585712,
0.1435957998,
-0.4829702079,
-0.1020202041,
-1.0603222847,
0.0162220169,
-0.430318594,
0.5099965334,
0.7092025876,
0.0222574044,
-0.6534946561,
-0.6174424887,
0.2415784746,
0.6341872215,
-1.0911068916,
-0.0181493741,
0.6172088981,
-0.1604869515,
0.1420296729,
0.4736607671,
-0.0172092896,
0.5570118427,
-0.0894563273,
0.0181506723,
-0.3955859542,
-0.5820278525,
-0.1224635094,
0.2552329004,
-0.1641668826,
-0.3095867634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04513v1
|
IITK at SemEval-2024 Task 1: Contrastive Learning and Autoencoders for Semantic Textual Relatedness in Multilingual Texts
| 2024-04-06T05:58:42 | 2024-04-06T05:58:42 |
Udvas Basak, Rajarshi Dutta, Shivam Pandey, Ashutosh Modi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper describes our system developed for the SemEval-2024 Task 1:
Semantic Textual Relatedness. The challenge is focused on automatically
detecting the degree of relatedness between pairs of sentences for 14 languages
including both high and low-resource Asian and African languages. Our team
participated in two subtasks consisting of Track A: supervised and Track B:
unsupervised. This paper focuses on a BERT-based contrastive learning and
similarity metric based approach primarily for the supervised track while
exploring autoencoders for the unsupervised track. It also aims on the creation
of a bigram relatedness corpus using negative sampling strategy, thereby
producing refined word embeddings.
|
[
-0.5216975808,
-0.4060609341,
0.3363833427,
0.3444419503,
-0.4843827486,
-0.166814819,
-0.2424395382,
-0.7105680704,
0.4297949672,
0.5047925115,
-0.7202625275,
-0.5252135992,
-0.4402304888,
0.3470161557,
-0.2557855248,
0.9739211798,
-0.2215282023,
0.0606537201,
-0.3496381044,
-0.6292276382,
-0.4201564193,
-0.7696673274,
-0.3645831048,
-0.4690991938,
0.4718014598,
0.3879543543,
0.1554559916,
0.4162060022,
0.6368728876,
0.2313758433,
0.2225983739,
-0.0701490194,
-0.2728261054,
0.4063841701,
-0.5200001597,
-0.3390384614,
-0.1695197821,
-0.1432644129,
0.2879270911,
0.4353756905,
0.3001199663,
0.1568932086,
0.4000561535,
0.5395211577,
-0.4215718508,
0.3252586424,
-0.6520013213,
0.0576960482,
-0.2939537466,
-0.197966367,
-0.0352245457,
0.0365155712,
0.011472174,
-0.5224116445,
0.4641107619,
0.0035485262,
0.9465168118,
0.4592771828,
-0.6392124295,
-0.7501775026,
-0.1970958114,
0.9559500813,
-0.5949614644,
0.3852851987,
0.7704473734,
-0.0289611276,
0.2851106822,
-0.5528648496,
-0.5673827529,
-0.0347982533,
-0.2770246267,
0.3924706876,
0.2847680449,
-0.2335670888,
-0.0664438158,
0.1560871452,
-0.6417331696,
0.2858098447,
-0.1099303886,
-0.4498207569,
0.4571989179,
0.1300930977,
0.0869237781,
-0.4251464903,
-0.5061154962,
-0.0469898023,
-0.6017409563,
-0.2659474015,
0.5467209816,
0.1470746398,
-0.2608478963,
0.434659332,
-0.3624961674,
0.2692455351,
-0.2106630653,
0.2918803394,
0.6669075489,
-0.9307668209,
0.2284737974,
0.1611267179,
0.5911074877,
0.2880606949,
0.1193294972,
0.1257539243,
-0.1481277645,
0.2464271784,
0.0192267187,
-0.6784396768,
-0.4131090045,
-0.0047874525,
-0.6283729672,
-0.1815785915,
-0.129104048,
-0.6967331767,
-0.1128575131,
-0.5062042475,
0.6936209798,
-0.6320410371,
-0.1696226448,
-0.3637592793,
0.1648685485,
0.4276337028,
0.2464439124,
-0.7677861452,
0.0853266194,
0.6376293898,
0.5942866206,
-0.1847389936,
-0.5577660799,
-0.2570632994,
0.1365014166,
-0.081755951,
0.831946969,
-0.3605641425,
-0.1202006042,
-0.0311953742,
0.3642808199,
0.1108103096,
-0.5873605609,
0.7023415565,
-0.3648529053,
0.1612955481,
-0.380399555,
-0.6724544168,
-0.2610063553,
0.5445778966,
-0.6904776692,
1.192902565,
-0.0858680233,
-0.8605938554,
0.4020332396,
-0.4384144843,
-0.5857657194,
-0.0059805741,
-0.2746722698,
-0.6103386879,
-0.2209065557,
0.1838013977,
0.5452720523,
-0.0095082521,
0.1059226543,
-0.2607462704,
-0.3781137466,
-0.1054215357,
-0.2479819357,
0.6392816305,
0.410526365,
-0.4967964292,
-0.0213623922,
-0.759431839,
-0.1858505607,
0.0642493442,
-0.2536356151,
-0.7857119441,
-0.2112758309,
0.1882284284,
0.338113755,
0.5370059609,
-0.6548719406,
-0.1783737093,
-0.3937493563,
0.3174549341,
0.6115852594,
0.199745819,
0.1509917527,
-0.0991738066,
0.2118733078,
0.4328108132,
-0.2057632357,
-0.6578602791,
-0.2489739358,
-0.989366293,
-0.0429807641,
0.5504955649,
0.594900012,
-0.939140141,
0.5209137201,
-0.091564104,
-0.2369279712,
-0.3915213346,
0.2001796663,
0.5531625152,
0.4127084911,
0.3644208014,
-0.2440576255,
-0.6495968103,
-1.1094925404,
-0.0153489048,
0.0162798949,
0.1332465261,
0.1107595786,
0.7333620191,
-0.4917868376,
0.4028485119,
-0.3334718049,
-0.4725893736,
0.2659007013,
0.3614974022,
0.1027319208,
0.6652331352,
0.6895286441,
-0.8920696974,
-0.7022783756,
0.0241344161,
-0.878080368,
-0.3054490983,
0.3748247921,
-0.1158570275,
0.4629479647,
1.2031602859,
0.0151229436,
0.3671652675,
0.4120900035,
-0.3185940087,
0.2240116745,
-0.3649016023,
0.3200063109,
-1.4895451069,
0.0309383851,
-0.0893446133,
-0.2410057932,
-0.1964984536,
-0.009266072,
0.0640657395,
-0.0623027869,
-0.2345442474,
0.544649601,
-0.3360192776,
-0.0818359107,
-0.243945092,
0.0360274166,
-0.2409557104,
0.6252416372,
0.0504255071,
0.8664896488,
0.0975412503,
-0.6382752061,
0.3845430017,
0.3620453775,
-0.287235409,
0.9130911827,
-0.4776055217,
-0.0756961852,
-0.2734753489,
0.054001797,
-1.1661727428,
-0.1093616039,
-0.0573583022,
-0.6170766354,
0.1642740369,
0.1856872737,
-0.6352742314,
-0.2347047776,
-0.4899660349,
0.7096080184,
0.3384964764,
-0.4548862576,
0.1352051198,
0.3326830864,
-0.6281626821,
-0.4504886568,
-0.9142841697,
0.0986221656,
-0.1580816358,
-0.3607513309,
0.2561200857,
-0.0630510598,
-0.129973948,
0.3310523927,
0.2367134094,
-0.1855679154,
0.0820330307,
0.1384731978,
0.0550998375,
-0.2254260778,
0.5321446657,
0.0323529691,
-0.2696530223,
-0.0394106023,
-0.3189119399,
0.5194830298,
0.0496076047,
-0.3489193022,
-0.0466235243,
0.5872035623,
-0.0010708666,
-0.226821512,
0.5732078552,
1.0574985743,
-0.4401490986,
0.1078640968,
-0.5531668663,
-0.1047202796,
-0.3983741701,
0.5866316557,
-0.6039010286,
-1.0397744179,
0.7122404575,
-0.151867643,
-0.0896297246,
0.7178864479,
0.7684813738,
-0.3329857588,
0.7004945874,
0.6557791829,
-0.0698616281,
0.3705222011,
-0.1027640402,
0.0765246004,
-0.6984958053,
-0.3126702011,
-0.7194486856,
-0.1808745861,
-1.0400993824,
-0.402987957,
0.2240385115,
-0.1910008639,
-0.3551671803,
0.5323780775,
-0.2110558003,
0.4032254219,
0.6720395088,
-0.0129831657,
0.2137809396,
-0.0177678354,
-0.4680681825,
-0.3757490814,
-0.4540409744,
-0.2780572176,
0.8899930716,
0.079649739,
0.4534082413,
0.165101245,
0.9399710298,
0.4913344085,
-0.0467513464,
-0.5644246936,
0.4171774089,
-0.4252509773,
-0.407156229,
-0.2511245608,
-0.2045246661,
-0.9850690365,
0.1004417911,
-0.1770520657,
-0.3888969123,
0.131483078,
-0.0533443466,
0.2648654878,
-0.1262959689,
-0.4961083531,
0.7723962069,
0.0595969558,
-0.3237389624,
-0.3512855172,
-0.9617803097,
0.0086249718,
-0.3284128904,
0.2223855853,
-0.0931480229,
-0.2398241907,
0.7711476088,
-0.4333460927,
0.7041115761,
0.0718111694,
-0.2765638828,
0.169048667,
-0.0376392417,
0.2510417998,
-0.043405436,
-0.3189341128,
0.1244282126,
0.0772565976,
-0.7386540174,
-0.1617234498,
1.0539592505,
-0.654933095,
-0.09368743,
-0.4453770518,
-0.253136009,
-0.2914075553,
0.3648751676,
0.4910606742,
0.4631693959,
-0.4165207446,
0.2018074095,
0.6536791325,
-0.3263526857,
0.628684938,
0.4185007811,
0.0861025304,
-0.5609519482,
1.1383302212,
0.0299986638,
-0.0555746704,
0.5780315399,
-0.1366089135,
-0.4593925774,
-0.3584274352,
-0.2996994555,
0.3130648136,
-0.8548492789,
-0.225637719,
-0.7019382119,
-0.2995159924,
-0.4859219193,
-0.1792631447,
-0.2027127445,
-0.3715235889,
-0.3308976591,
0.0121821836,
0.1313679963,
0.7980493903,
-0.1698248684,
-0.0521435365,
-0.762521863,
0.2136070281,
0.2804014683,
0.2682913542,
-0.2195882201,
-0.5069692135,
-0.5016716719,
-0.251109302,
-0.1812785864,
-0.2456799597,
0.210767597,
0.2684446275,
0.4652036428,
0.0757144839,
0.2664913833,
0.3524634838,
-0.5633465052,
0.808891356,
0.2016144842,
-0.7951180339,
0.6857135892,
-0.3551841676,
0.5559520721,
0.9396620393,
0.4987210631,
-0.3790837824,
-0.3410326838,
-0.5946901441,
-0.8546531796,
0.4946736395,
0.3963727057,
0.2586611509,
-0.0643476844,
0.1643127799,
0.4246953428,
0.2345832139,
-0.7596173286,
-0.2215566039,
-0.270448029,
-0.698481679,
-0.2635723352,
-0.4365651011,
0.2852377594,
0.0863760784,
0.9183866978,
-0.2137412131,
0.2547192276,
0.3364470601,
-0.2972066104,
0.2329254597,
0.3778043389,
0.4238880277,
0.4450866878,
-0.0329833813,
0.1969142556,
0.352237165,
-0.5287712812,
0.1367056221,
0.3234347999,
-0.0599631071,
0.0622445904,
0.737455368,
0.6660802364,
0.1543917656,
-0.5572931767,
0.6514673829,
0.0288894102,
-0.3343874514,
-0.4098730087,
-0.4954527915,
0.1262079626,
0.1740221977,
0.1363684982,
-0.3288979828,
0.3021499813,
-0.5658482313,
0.4160986841,
0.1545639783,
-0.8135203123,
-0.4276991189,
0.3935623467,
0.647693038,
-0.0251538511,
0.3316349685,
-0.3802589476,
-0.8497433066,
0.7462188601,
0.4886155427,
0.6836971045,
-0.3346436918,
-0.1770814061,
0.6916561127,
0.2723507583,
0.3232129216,
0.3756682277,
-0.2117082477,
-0.5960267782,
-0.3840569258,
-0.5415280461,
-0.2204303145,
0.1310008764,
-0.6062893271,
0.594563365,
0.0085554356,
0.2086735815,
-0.0129417991,
0.1249314249,
-0.7137564421,
0.3677282035,
-0.0210586507,
0.5003691912,
-0.7600782514,
0.9889965653,
0.992625773,
-0.2933385968,
-0.5152142644,
0.2039151192,
-0.0301851835,
-0.6186175346,
0.8742628694,
0.2214172333,
0.0268942732,
-0.0517184995,
-0.2503975928,
-0.5472051501,
1.171143651,
0.0090928636,
-0.5324695706,
0.2132828534,
0.0845882446,
0.5493992567,
-0.0649006814,
0.0630550608,
0.3115444481,
0.2817179263,
0.0443623215,
-0.9742561579,
-0.2150661051,
-0.3678007722,
-0.0836296007,
0.6107113957,
-0.9234339595,
0.8263351321,
0.1861633211,
0.0907601193,
0.2651979923,
0.7056713104,
-0.1559820622,
0.5010287166,
0.4535491765,
0.8620179892,
0.4534530342,
0.1183559373,
0.5602346063,
-0.4141341448,
0.5080385804,
1.3242152929,
-0.4332923591,
0.6879761815,
0.4355144203,
-0.1286582053,
0.4197837114,
0.6698873043,
0.1098614633,
0.6962273121,
0.0321682692,
-0.3376314342,
-0.1509563774,
-0.4262260795,
-0.5162765384,
0.5203957558,
0.3567941785,
-0.3652724326,
-0.3778639734,
0.3532393873,
-0.1008636653,
0.429189235,
-0.2569452524,
1.0612001419,
0.2264505625,
-0.5240492821,
0.2142558694,
-0.0234082956,
0.9200430512,
-0.6019340754,
-0.3107163012,
-0.1645384878,
0.3121601045,
-0.0388376191,
-0.9026236534,
0.5060294867,
-0.2031440735,
-0.1694815457,
0.1060268357,
0.9970898032,
-0.7514334321,
-0.3892948925,
0.5298707485,
0.4414228201,
0.0417711996,
0.2723125517,
-0.6750507951,
-0.0561893545,
0.0307146646,
0.1355493516,
0.382777065,
0.8227158189,
-0.2931413651,
0.3256310523,
0.26969257,
-0.1841058433,
-0.1690814942,
0.1618638635,
0.5520423651,
-0.9528331757,
-0.9132321477,
-0.7144593596,
-0.2084894031,
-0.0474765152,
-0.2734922171,
0.8291849494,
0.751236558,
1.1097018719,
-0.0480150692,
0.8571814299,
0.0486268289,
0.8789155483,
-0.6496617794,
0.4006296694,
-0.6134350896,
0.2333386689,
-0.3380229175,
-1.0675774813,
-0.0373993516,
0.4648858011,
-0.0982296839,
-0.2627577484,
0.9864379764,
0.6089725494,
-0.2696303427,
0.0674213096,
0.3405805528,
0.0863311961,
-0.0024882322,
0.6806108356,
0.6852607131,
-0.6866027117,
0.6038856506,
-0.3461899757,
-0.0483659729,
-0.2494630963,
-0.970649302,
-0.8625754118,
-1.1199028492,
-0.3416375518,
-0.3019244075,
0.1205962077,
0.9501945972,
0.349943459,
-1.1015822887,
-0.1629311591,
-0.0351544656,
-0.1483393759,
0.3362261355,
-0.2281423509,
0.5422154665,
-0.3747769594,
-0.6948639154,
-0.125924781,
0.3817428052,
0.1088023707,
-0.1131582186,
-0.0031257521,
-0.6265233159,
-0.0271208808,
0.6938020587,
0.0141878743,
-0.4034006894,
-0.4354973137,
-0.3759090304,
-0.3265327513,
-0.0584771931,
0.6834759116,
-0.7508245111,
0.3617917895,
0.6576459408,
0.8957179189,
0.6340469718,
-0.0272831973,
0.3129647672,
-0.6973912716,
0.5661981702,
0.2752370834,
0.3497076035,
0.4951678813,
-0.217072323,
1.0370675325,
0.2794608474,
-0.7025994062,
-0.4292292893,
0.3364691138,
-0.738695085,
-0.2178748995,
1.0415813923,
-0.3565199077,
-0.1953009218,
-0.467446506,
-0.3134246171,
0.2123312652,
-0.0104107494,
0.4487580955,
0.9627515674,
-0.0279963072,
0.1457813233,
-0.4260677397,
0.3921569884,
0.6599854827,
-0.824955821,
-0.3106782734,
0.2967386246,
0.3382354081,
0.1633363217,
0.6713687181,
-0.0845451951,
0.1977116764,
-0.0287226588,
0.0493038334,
0.229443565,
0.0760179907,
-0.4325849116,
-0.1509176791,
-0.1388422251,
-0.2937897444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04510v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04510v1
|
IITK at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Exploring the Capabilities of LLMs for Safe Biomedical Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials
| 2024-04-06T05:44:53 | 2024-04-06T05:44:53 |
Shreyasi Mandal, Ashutosh Modi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language models (LLMs) have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance
in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks across multiple domains, yet
they are prone to shortcut learning and factual inconsistencies. This research
investigates LLMs' robustness, consistency, and faithful reasoning when
performing Natural Language Inference (NLI) on breast cancer Clinical Trial
Reports (CTRs) in the context of SemEval 2024 Task 2: Safe Biomedical Natural
Language Inference for Clinical Trials. We examine the reasoning capabilities
of LLMs and their adeptness at logical problem-solving. A comparative analysis
is conducted on pre-trained language models (PLMs), GPT-3.5, and Gemini Pro
under zero-shot settings using Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) framework,
integrating various reasoning chains. The evaluation yields an F1 score of
0.69, consistency of 0.71, and a faithfulness score of 0.90 on the test
dataset.
|
[
0.1466526985,
-0.8620666862,
0.7564999461,
0.2328884155,
-0.2212436646,
-0.0706897601,
-0.0621013865,
-0.4879526496,
-0.2484002113,
0.7570258975,
-0.3932062089,
-0.730682373,
-0.7625142336,
0.4460511208,
-0.2479869127,
0.948009491,
-0.0970705822,
0.3027079701,
-0.3020445704,
-0.3079389334,
-0.4432322681,
-0.5050337315,
-0.6899899244,
-0.248132512,
0.4394422472,
0.0443816409,
0.511828959,
0.595323205,
0.71479249,
0.270522207,
-0.0014135129,
0.3073890805,
-0.2320075631,
0.4603858292,
-0.4450481534,
-0.5292505026,
-0.3446695507,
0.0912910774,
0.1736182868,
0.5012577176,
-0.0809147432,
-0.2424497902,
0.1787406504,
0.4853201807,
-0.4777876139,
0.0148286438,
-0.8119256496,
-0.1809016764,
0.0172724053,
-0.166447565,
-0.5528187156,
-0.6837595105,
0.1441316307,
-0.6634069085,
0.1001956463,
-0.0822693557,
0.8958399296,
0.4553231299,
-0.5906603336,
-0.5380468965,
-0.3125865757,
0.7858818173,
-1.1199740171,
0.0349732712,
0.658036232,
0.3620735407,
-0.3845994174,
-0.7384181023,
-0.2519575953,
-0.2971446812,
0.0242145862,
0.2070528567,
-0.0481708348,
0.2425824851,
0.2080281675,
0.0392818451,
-0.5991419554,
0.2256422341,
-0.0475672744,
-0.3868098259,
0.5192254782,
0.1486147195,
0.1896305531,
-0.2748938501,
-0.2656792104,
0.2570955753,
-0.8138165474,
-0.1781523228,
-0.0642747581,
0.3493550122,
0.02948297,
0.8477900028,
-0.1689562649,
0.6137652397,
-0.2941952646,
-0.2402879596,
0.1083607972,
-0.6664426923,
-0.380580008,
0.0163352732,
0.8251799345,
0.2886682153,
0.2421360463,
-0.2133124024,
0.1537104398,
0.4205016494,
0.3732247949,
-0.6528645158,
0.0785306245,
0.4079584479,
-0.3295358717,
-0.2864999771,
-0.146370545,
-0.3230119646,
-0.2188580483,
-0.2336747795,
0.8877211213,
-0.7188869715,
0.0318748727,
0.3413749337,
0.0962700844,
0.1455185413,
0.3594951928,
-0.4104893804,
0.2331951708,
0.8669657707,
0.5271015167,
-0.112359792,
-0.0211831145,
-0.7847884893,
0.2577564418,
-0.2032563835,
0.726267159,
-0.1543828547,
-0.4305876195,
-0.0845618844,
0.1516776681,
-0.3927128911,
-0.5053896904,
1.0048681498,
-0.3243486881,
0.2180986851,
-0.4370859265,
-0.812967062,
-0.0505359247,
0.4228201807,
-0.1872900128,
0.6795786619,
-0.2377882898,
-0.8149310946,
0.3597328663,
-0.233499974,
-0.4532805681,
-0.0714323521,
-0.2431756854,
-0.4930616915,
-0.0839178339,
0.1218605042,
0.3951405585,
-0.0187863298,
0.3992327154,
-0.5336613059,
-0.2614650428,
0.4354617,
-0.4285154343,
0.7392495275,
0.2909491658,
-0.4448288381,
-0.0629793257,
-0.608807385,
0.1012039408,
0.0184483919,
-0.352971822,
-0.1304709464,
-0.0559611507,
-0.4591345489,
0.1779027581,
0.0237952247,
-0.7463724613,
0.1011661291,
-0.7107877135,
0.4441911876,
0.522166729,
0.1273645759,
0.1045377851,
-0.382917434,
0.2881611586,
-0.0674869865,
0.0884710327,
-0.0448321961,
-0.7219409943,
-0.6705197096,
-0.2717612684,
0.4647566974,
0.6238186955,
-0.8360922337,
0.2570585608,
-0.1146658733,
-0.181138292,
-0.3370907605,
-0.0035148035,
0.6005808115,
0.8304153085,
0.3516648114,
0.1776711047,
-0.5162292123,
-0.9585066438,
-0.5500352979,
-0.0721773207,
-0.0632266551,
0.1436282545,
0.7054738998,
-0.4562139511,
0.7928717136,
-0.0631260574,
-0.0214520376,
-0.264397949,
0.3608669937,
0.3438083827,
0.4164502621,
0.1873732209,
-0.5102165341,
-0.2537103593,
-0.1969442815,
-0.8124015927,
-0.5114322901,
-0.0488367304,
-0.1924139112,
0.3944070935,
0.3743901849,
-0.6791818738,
0.7875445485,
0.3834498525,
-0.4672475457,
0.3731312454,
-0.4105848074,
0.2412922531,
-1.0498398542,
0.0001059461,
0.0912237614,
-0.4857241213,
-0.5979998708,
-0.1998665631,
-0.0778654665,
0.4492152631,
-0.2829687297,
0.4415134788,
-0.1892969459,
0.0276157577,
-0.3826917708,
-0.0907495171,
0.1913164109,
-0.0663418844,
0.0947745591,
0.7206116915,
0.2018686533,
-0.6560511589,
-0.1128948629,
0.4328883886,
-0.2619121969,
0.3586242199,
-0.8357287049,
0.1173428968,
-0.0013385827,
0.0862585083,
-0.7295957804,
-0.2817464173,
0.0646098629,
-0.5206168294,
0.2027136385,
-0.0419761725,
-0.6466657519,
-0.2953493297,
-0.1099262238,
0.0361411013,
0.4477276802,
-0.2357258797,
0.4791535735,
0.2375103384,
-0.2667139173,
-0.6323300004,
-0.9713745117,
0.0519282557,
-0.0251033846,
-0.6068015695,
0.1347219199,
-0.0641400293,
-0.3682613671,
-0.0826382563,
-0.1752682626,
-0.0281651132,
-0.0110286949,
0.3291046321,
0.2727260292,
-0.1151223406,
-0.0118726781,
0.1065352187,
-0.3232499659,
-0.0001543162,
0.0672545433,
-0.0020647608,
-0.2326924801,
-0.7342271805,
-0.407694608,
0.2788513005,
0.4088200033,
0.0242104828,
0.7451591492,
0.3933128119,
-0.46794945,
0.061135944,
-0.6603239179,
-0.2235158384,
-0.4085378647,
0.0979017988,
-0.227199167,
-1.1865558624,
0.3187652528,
0.0230000243,
0.1137743071,
0.4111218452,
0.8239573836,
-0.2585660517,
1.0981849432,
0.1312167495,
0.365652442,
-0.39907372,
0.0356776901,
0.1898270845,
-0.6301495433,
-0.3247599304,
-0.5922361016,
0.048584681,
-0.3127593696,
-0.5794861317,
0.6547763944,
0.0958350599,
-0.4702139795,
0.1501079053,
-0.346783191,
0.2992455959,
0.5172744393,
0.1883570403,
0.4097006917,
-0.1241851076,
-0.3760423064,
-0.2573785484,
-0.6556890011,
-0.7108322382,
1.1196693182,
0.3473137915,
0.5213131905,
0.2377424091,
0.4315803349,
-0.0346525498,
0.2864775658,
-0.4622237086,
0.4819270074,
-0.2249528021,
-0.7513670325,
0.0055313203,
-0.5442872047,
-0.9087071419,
0.1902458817,
-0.3218987286,
-0.6417415142,
-0.1397365183,
-0.1348965317,
-0.4778712392,
0.0561788715,
-0.5225381255,
0.7257043123,
-0.4554382861,
-0.537635982,
0.0266495124,
-1.0236047506,
0.3839247227,
-0.0063118082,
0.2840250432,
-0.3757830262,
-0.073098734,
0.3876819015,
-0.5671069622,
0.6791225672,
0.0882463008,
0.1429367959,
0.461117357,
0.2408777624,
0.4354273677,
0.2371837646,
-0.2981491983,
0.0690173879,
0.3045448363,
-0.3228328228,
-0.3261413574,
0.6221641302,
-0.517952919,
-0.5598364472,
-0.5779110789,
-0.5224614143,
-0.5980282426,
0.2604860365,
0.3404778838,
0.4277369976,
0.0051395264,
0.3778205812,
0.8038596511,
-0.5231026411,
0.1564460844,
0.7025316954,
0.0166555829,
-0.4660241008,
0.473629117,
0.0231107827,
0.4023364186,
0.3140466511,
0.2058599144,
-0.6083838344,
-0.9087179303,
-0.0672742724,
0.3498843014,
-0.6146510839,
-0.3422727287,
-0.8119764924,
-0.3992078304,
-0.492477417,
-0.1158812419,
-0.3500857055,
-0.4069847465,
-0.3098970652,
-0.2276960909,
0.1607104391,
0.4978267848,
-0.1210551858,
0.0458832756,
-0.9568942189,
0.3681337237,
0.17271474,
0.0972445682,
-0.6877380013,
-0.6179428697,
0.1263774633,
0.0271635819,
-0.1179153621,
-0.7195134759,
0.4511332512,
0.0962665677,
0.6423603296,
0.2467595786,
-0.0532993339,
0.294893384,
-0.2298509032,
0.6511890292,
0.0623918027,
-0.5932091475,
0.7288032174,
-0.799197793,
0.4359502792,
0.8983627558,
0.227008909,
-0.0439848192,
-0.5640701056,
-0.5148223042,
-0.4645960033,
0.4607693851,
0.6673220396,
-0.2281293124,
-0.1317065358,
0.6000362635,
0.3571459949,
0.1961278319,
-0.5631108284,
0.0332397521,
-0.0793541595,
-0.6174759865,
0.1015357375,
-0.5255405307,
-0.3107052743,
-0.2474723458,
0.7761415839,
-0.2547759116,
0.1250228137,
0.3636204302,
0.0457632802,
0.173354134,
0.4673354626,
0.5339437127,
0.6169793606,
-0.3077350259,
0.29378438,
0.3573985398,
-0.4703055918,
0.0445217192,
0.0997796059,
-0.11246299,
-0.1668797582,
0.5836757421,
0.4237340391,
0.1904641837,
-0.855009377,
0.5862015486,
-0.2254262865,
-0.4294950366,
-0.0698525235,
0.0488155074,
0.3274222314,
0.1587096602,
0.0116273733,
0.1712745279,
0.1335931718,
-0.307893455,
0.2184409052,
0.492313534,
-0.4327173829,
-0.166064322,
0.8519883156,
0.0194761045,
0.080339238,
0.4455225468,
0.0053093759,
-0.3742723763,
0.5797182918,
0.632605195,
0.5908415318,
-0.020993473,
0.1706615686,
0.361947,
0.4316295683,
-0.1921135634,
0.4636012614,
0.4135970175,
-0.8419545293,
-0.5676162839,
-0.5864394903,
-0.5109736919,
0.1419491768,
-0.3483799994,
0.2519880533,
-0.3882231116,
-0.3894968033,
-0.1748015583,
-0.0173083209,
-0.3223841786,
0.3626963794,
0.1679446995,
1.0165777206,
-0.4401504695,
0.8442534804,
0.5723654628,
-0.1175886169,
-0.8943440914,
-0.4795949757,
0.3750350773,
-0.6045356393,
0.479611516,
0.1904634386,
-0.1187012047,
-0.3272383809,
-0.5005803108,
-0.6147506237,
1.2016779184,
0.5736081004,
-0.5039889812,
0.0772204995,
0.4618653357,
0.5264946818,
-0.183577612,
0.2682617009,
0.5316064358,
0.3851071,
0.4143118858,
-0.9885071516,
-0.0567936264,
-0.1201764569,
-0.1883282065,
-0.1515242606,
-0.3262252808,
0.5186399221,
-0.2783344686,
0.0514220186,
0.4955281019,
0.4654860198,
0.8762555122,
0.6684536934,
0.1540493369,
0.8939582705,
0.6983007789,
-0.3408448398,
1.0142935514,
-0.1381668448,
0.1308918297,
0.9743172526,
-0.4201762974,
0.7086526752,
0.3758103251,
-0.1066528931,
0.3390829563,
0.4719901681,
0.3452062309,
0.5567340255,
-0.1605882645,
-0.3453387916,
-0.4852659106,
-0.0823789686,
-0.2520262897,
0.3442167342,
0.4865043163,
-0.3330176473,
-0.1571947336,
-0.0430301055,
0.245218128,
0.09129145,
-0.1000188738,
0.6295681,
0.5036843419,
-0.6176535487,
0.2570583522,
-0.031591814,
0.4436452687,
-0.7624949217,
-0.0024300094,
0.0406142399,
0.3621029258,
-0.0968799815,
-0.7795804143,
0.5639145374,
0.1329614669,
0.1518119723,
0.0456258096,
1.1137965918,
-0.0776772276,
-0.5841555595,
0.0199101735,
0.4896939993,
-0.0326116532,
0.0167029668,
-0.7990638018,
0.1341908574,
-0.0808689445,
-0.223363474,
0.2759316564,
0.3601048589,
0.0919822007,
0.8827669024,
0.5246503949,
0.1217395961,
0.050381463,
0.0565247983,
0.4522528946,
-0.4637377262,
-0.1713543236,
-0.8444647193,
0.3927002549,
-0.0391023383,
-0.2605118752,
0.9290181398,
0.4867367446,
0.1078519896,
0.1671167761,
0.7734034657,
0.362003684,
0.9259323478,
-0.7706549168,
0.5948351622,
-0.2118938565,
0.3093064725,
0.041771099,
-0.435716033,
-0.5273823142,
0.5512368083,
-0.5683724284,
0.0318855308,
0.75354141,
0.689293921,
0.1871612817,
0.4459166527,
0.0920184627,
0.5143370628,
0.4269499779,
0.7097229958,
0.7829139233,
-0.4299903512,
0.2949083745,
-0.117438294,
-0.1003734767,
-0.07892894,
-1.0341502428,
-0.8462424874,
-0.1127624139,
-0.348498106,
-0.6758700609,
0.2331006378,
0.8852171898,
0.5080307722,
-0.956905663,
0.1852913052,
-0.3691271245,
-0.0521314666,
0.1717295945,
-0.1668920815,
0.2930859923,
-0.3331493139,
-0.3988146782,
0.5472177863,
0.570514679,
-0.0395909436,
0.1172538176,
-0.2427911907,
-0.3092679679,
0.2803078592,
0.4870047271,
0.175562188,
-0.7132666111,
-0.2374540269,
0.0148839308,
-0.4470196068,
-0.1613268107,
0.4718750417,
-0.8924219012,
0.4396034181,
0.4637801349,
0.7908137441,
0.3532249629,
0.1353837699,
0.6133345962,
-0.191433087,
-0.1089211106,
0.5346438289,
0.3732770383,
0.3558722138,
-0.1451118588,
0.7285262346,
0.3109070957,
-0.8801238537,
-0.7206873894,
0.0195941664,
-1.1475461721,
-0.3553125262,
1.4364204407,
-0.0603589229,
-0.149095431,
-0.4317854047,
-0.203226164,
0.3162066042,
0.0726294219,
0.5121952295,
0.5059481859,
-0.3249593973,
0.0184876788,
-0.8805783987,
0.541575253,
0.6566502452,
-0.8299544454,
-0.4283486903,
0.3291128278,
0.4545824528,
-0.2173607647,
0.87557441,
-0.3955894709,
0.1007596627,
-0.2004383504,
-0.4600154161,
-0.0055621238,
-0.047821708,
-0.1015835404,
0.0433651246,
0.026011562,
0.1434484124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04487v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04487v1
|
KazQAD: Kazakh Open-Domain Question Answering Dataset
| 2024-04-06T03:40:36 | 2024-04-06T03:40:36 |
Rustem Yeshpanov, Pavel Efimov, Leonid Boytsov, Ardak Shalkarbayuli, Pavel Braslavski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce KazQAD -- a Kazakh open-domain question answering (ODQA) dataset
-- that can be used in both reading comprehension and full ODQA settings, as
well as for information retrieval experiments. KazQAD contains just under 6,000
unique questions with extracted short answers and nearly 12,000 passage-level
relevance judgements. We use a combination of machine translation, Wikipedia
search, and in-house manual annotation to ensure annotation efficiency and data
quality. The questions come from two sources: translated items from the Natural
Questions (NQ) dataset (only for training) and the original Kazakh Unified
National Testing (UNT) exam (for development and testing). The accompanying
text corpus contains more than 800,000 passages from the Kazakh Wikipedia. As a
supplementary dataset, we release around 61,000 question-passage-answer triples
from the NQ dataset that have been machine-translated into Kazakh. We develop
baseline retrievers and readers that achieve reasonable scores in retrieval
(NDCG@10 = 0.389 MRR = 0.382), reading comprehension (EM = 38.5 F1 = 54.2), and
full ODQA (EM = 17.8 F1 = 28.7) settings. Nevertheless, these results are
substantially lower than state-of-the-art results for English QA collections,
and we think that there should still be ample room for improvement. We also
show that the current OpenAI's ChatGPTv3.5 is not able to answer KazQAD test
questions in the closed-book setting with acceptable quality. The dataset is
freely available under the Creative Commons licence (CC BY-SA) at
https://github.com/IS2AI/KazQAD.
|
[
-0.5598130226,
-0.701476872,
0.3097276986,
-0.0534474775,
-0.4669493437,
-0.0613780655,
-0.0394329727,
-0.2601175308,
-0.1737094522,
0.7657033205,
-0.6372231841,
-0.7337522507,
-0.1812801957,
0.1597380638,
-0.1364057064,
0.9907450676,
-0.2061931193,
0.2219068855,
-0.0623843372,
-0.2785496414,
-0.1626274139,
-0.2967565656,
-0.1938273311,
0.0314315893,
0.5732796788,
0.8293610811,
0.8835400343,
0.3698629737,
0.4176747501,
0.0324397832,
0.0177213997,
0.1185920015,
-0.3403722644,
0.0309730005,
0.1298789084,
-0.2557945848,
-0.1147743165,
-0.1391255558,
0.6906991005,
0.7418808341,
-0.1017603949,
0.5734972358,
0.0077186576,
0.9987748861,
-0.8814582825,
-0.0243594311,
-0.0866540745,
0.1328505129,
-0.3341051638,
0.0666182637,
-0.3373653293,
-0.5515895486,
0.0946646854,
-0.867505908,
0.0774908811,
-0.0560559705,
0.9348620176,
0.1351159066,
-0.8254498243,
-0.3926850259,
-0.742854476,
0.5371932983,
-0.7054818273,
0.3492746949,
0.4682420194,
0.6405588388,
-0.1848193407,
-0.6842216849,
-0.885700047,
0.0120164892,
0.140604347,
0.2927623987,
0.1432714015,
0.0474720784,
0.1422236413,
0.6427913308,
-0.9060816169,
-0.3906257153,
-0.7754098177,
0.0691765621,
0.6839786172,
0.2604753077,
0.5053517818,
-0.1895389557,
-0.2805863917,
-0.2641389668,
-0.7920379043,
0.3282574117,
0.5834188461,
0.5498687625,
0.3210800886,
0.8213086724,
-0.884948194,
0.8857372999,
-0.1634531766,
0.1306411177,
0.3136748374,
-0.5274724364,
-0.2965375483,
-0.1424554586,
0.7486152053,
0.1794433147,
0.0112614036,
-0.1843536645,
0.1872715503,
-0.3735109866,
0.2240157872,
-0.5777818561,
-0.3963236213,
0.5619430542,
-0.366197437,
0.0462637767,
0.4182857573,
-0.9138284922,
-0.3276889026,
-0.0605969802,
0.8461122513,
-0.3633992076,
-0.0703637451,
0.4090335965,
0.0534056015,
0.6623532176,
0.1938225329,
-0.6868081093,
0.4783040285,
0.3103823364,
0.5639711022,
-0.003373401,
-0.1452699155,
-0.4967645109,
-0.2690615356,
-0.621833086,
0.8075429797,
-0.3551820815,
-0.0397889987,
0.1543643773,
0.1171894148,
-0.1478371471,
-0.5669931173,
0.8473030329,
-1.0267928839,
0.4001587331,
-0.7239596248,
-0.3579581976,
-0.351750195,
0.1138700768,
-0.8902743459,
1.1703172922,
0.5537054539,
-0.7220262289,
0.3365271389,
-0.7612480521,
-0.0010372618,
0.1511983573,
0.1348619014,
-0.1130786911,
-0.3910443485,
0.3762252629,
0.0076803034,
-0.3268942237,
-0.1845690608,
-0.0210676398,
-0.5447868705,
0.1108574867,
0.0368082486,
1.0164102316,
0.3884289861,
-0.0454526581,
-0.1333730668,
-0.5568771362,
0.4452848732,
-0.0880265012,
-0.4178521335,
-0.0375620648,
-0.1030245274,
0.1005484834,
0.4440565407,
0.0109160068,
-1.0412564278,
0.1780088991,
-0.3993149698,
-0.0302837286,
0.3956342041,
0.1960030943,
0.2819114327,
-0.3497256339,
0.8935554028,
0.1123084947,
0.3122257888,
0.149688527,
-0.6354267597,
-0.5953310132,
0.0706769004,
0.5279314518,
0.6475303173,
-1.136824131,
0.086471267,
-0.2353049964,
-0.5191207528,
-0.9381329417,
0.1541175693,
0.3733798862,
0.4424678683,
0.4658772945,
0.0546219572,
0.0736317784,
-0.9152774811,
-0.2581267059,
-0.1091356352,
-0.2607080936,
0.2942978144,
0.641164422,
0.5349031091,
0.649970293,
-0.5888686776,
-0.4723700583,
-0.0667422563,
-0.3123668432,
0.2813875377,
0.1425865144,
0.5693486333,
-1.0872620344,
-0.9666020274,
0.0498024598,
-0.5545899868,
0.0304714888,
0.2262805849,
-0.5300832987,
0.0779215693,
0.2543566525,
-0.7730107307,
0.4493471086,
0.2149153501,
-0.7829092741,
0.563888371,
0.0919860601,
0.6851906776,
-1.063644886,
0.2484715581,
-0.4732287824,
0.2738224864,
-0.7765269279,
0.4533886015,
0.2177330703,
0.0179211665,
-0.6784396768,
0.5434940457,
-0.3646559417,
-0.1097053215,
0.0053558019,
0.524248898,
0.1503286511,
0.5496760607,
-0.430912137,
1.0914324522,
0.2940017581,
-0.5903339982,
0.6871442199,
1.0070257187,
-0.7675123811,
0.4091952145,
-0.5353490114,
0.3290702105,
-0.264166683,
0.0576293133,
-1.0402408838,
-0.4055637121,
0.8059516549,
-0.7569996119,
-0.1401412338,
-0.1727778167,
-0.7000263333,
-0.3634697795,
-0.3407247961,
0.367401123,
0.4683962762,
-0.6336981654,
0.3068014383,
0.1182297841,
-0.4586544335,
-1.0158735514,
-0.4494745731,
-0.1428989172,
0.0319826417,
-0.7236304879,
-0.0182262585,
-0.1782405376,
-0.1800865084,
0.396358937,
-0.2102459073,
-0.4539251626,
-0.0354953036,
-0.0652983487,
0.2750627697,
-0.6418295503,
0.3576125205,
0.0887181386,
0.2201406807,
0.0749544203,
-0.2846084237,
0.3598096967,
0.053790506,
-0.3787479997,
-0.1661632508,
0.6389831901,
0.3563230932,
-0.4043900669,
1.0595226288,
0.4913682342,
-0.3514678776,
-0.0355180688,
-0.0327238999,
0.220128879,
-0.4219020009,
0.2850852907,
-0.3189857006,
-0.7129501104,
0.7577255964,
0.7138686776,
0.2860276699,
0.6249498129,
0.3640614748,
-0.2042862326,
0.8697006106,
0.1525306851,
-0.0132268472,
0.0530809052,
-0.1129648983,
0.2251330018,
-0.7779198289,
-0.477185756,
-0.7834166884,
-0.1363832206,
-0.3359770775,
-0.245320946,
0.3151131868,
0.178826943,
-0.2386438549,
-0.1356753856,
-0.2043697089,
0.7481091022,
0.6863893867,
0.3192540705,
0.3869628906,
-0.0752374977,
0.150128305,
0.2474234551,
-0.5947477221,
-0.7318211198,
1.3680405617,
-0.1478230953,
0.3792853653,
0.5007256866,
0.2644563019,
0.4898607135,
0.1630219966,
-0.6674970388,
0.3510382175,
0.0213510916,
-0.9588618875,
-0.5929222703,
-0.4194419086,
-1.0687382221,
0.2222735435,
-0.1890158951,
-0.7265501022,
0.1145342812,
-0.0256399736,
-0.6828398108,
0.3829624951,
-0.4254601896,
1.061070323,
0.4063641131,
0.0179787725,
0.2206022292,
-0.7457783222,
0.5413415432,
-0.0127417585,
-0.1405178308,
-0.1030282825,
-0.0489988662,
0.8259170055,
-0.3777537942,
0.0574958809,
-0.3397331238,
0.0448718332,
0.7250221968,
-0.1315326244,
-0.0899857208,
-0.033345297,
-0.1216428578,
-0.2632321417,
0.7656356096,
-1.0633215904,
-0.8677631617,
0.3432095945,
-0.9836158156,
-0.3331568241,
-0.4325888753,
-0.5698048472,
-0.4252550006,
0.2229824662,
0.247412324,
0.7370548844,
-0.2692557275,
0.3348356485,
0.7877552509,
-0.4231434762,
-0.1591574699,
0.4369823039,
-0.1918856651,
-0.4098034501,
0.6816884875,
0.2053232044,
0.468693912,
0.2274586856,
-0.1511898339,
-0.449020803,
-0.6067370176,
-0.9103457332,
0.1841676235,
-1.0215953588,
-0.3107697666,
-0.4860800207,
-0.4946941137,
-0.4976552427,
0.4010853469,
0.061382167,
-0.45869717,
-0.1129957959,
-0.1137670204,
0.4275393486,
0.8100636005,
0.2557322085,
0.3054857254,
-0.8944648504,
0.6799485683,
0.1482450068,
0.4968890846,
-0.2060138732,
-0.700229466,
-0.4624214768,
0.3707106411,
-0.3260830045,
-1.0287983418,
0.2316477597,
0.2556696832,
0.4629160166,
0.1400425434,
0.9027330875,
0.249428004,
-0.0955036059,
1.0586221218,
-0.5609964728,
-0.4572193623,
0.2353985608,
-0.5194189548,
0.5049989223,
0.9132060409,
0.7779862881,
-0.7391654253,
-0.3074412346,
-0.2755403817,
-0.583214581,
0.9038999677,
0.4428311884,
0.0070251017,
-0.0441131406,
0.6160501242,
0.2739976943,
0.0945413783,
-0.1581987739,
-0.5395750403,
-0.1190999299,
-0.5326091051,
-0.0854213312,
-0.1723234206,
0.0946632102,
-0.038253963,
0.8682134748,
-0.096843712,
0.3815939128,
0.4826641977,
-0.1945331991,
-0.1632652134,
0.3431613147,
0.4138609469,
0.7268882394,
-0.3668200672,
-0.2918980122,
-0.0955893695,
-1.0596687794,
0.1224464476,
0.1110711098,
-0.4951499701,
-0.0483119935,
-0.0691954046,
0.3404388428,
-0.4834857583,
-0.8788591623,
0.4809508324,
-0.1965408772,
-0.6270298362,
-0.3036574721,
0.0559122637,
-0.0647039935,
0.3544234633,
0.7282176614,
-0.4145336151,
0.3428027034,
-0.4482014775,
0.2613536119,
0.0971717313,
-0.4153222442,
-0.1639729738,
0.3996054828,
-0.1033463404,
-0.2540917993,
0.9762329459,
-0.1986118108,
-0.5245441794,
0.685790062,
-0.0089661786,
0.4044667482,
-0.032609392,
0.6006187797,
0.4662526548,
0.2947270274,
0.0741880834,
1.1095637083,
-0.1427533776,
-0.6548808813,
-0.2420469224,
-0.3808068037,
-0.6036113501,
0.3073855639,
-1.1769785881,
-0.0256219674,
-0.2542620003,
0.07773754,
-0.1104240939,
0.6061040759,
-0.5373191237,
0.3259146214,
-0.1697787642,
1.2385648489,
-0.7886072397,
0.5432454348,
0.7265888453,
-0.5227842927,
-0.5822915435,
0.12954247,
-0.3092270494,
-0.194468677,
0.2747200727,
-0.0893213004,
0.2163611948,
0.1247124374,
-0.6140460968,
-0.864641428,
1.0389904976,
0.1929739267,
0.2601189017,
0.1177040339,
0.3702604473,
0.3823256195,
-0.0551809296,
0.0009814878,
0.7028967142,
0.371810019,
-0.0668463558,
-0.8250496984,
-0.1349623501,
-0.6131312251,
-0.6867980361,
0.439206481,
-0.6606444716,
0.7299293876,
-0.3090477586,
-0.4552272558,
0.6551211476,
0.5802423358,
0.105897449,
0.461830169,
0.1788938642,
0.2228921205,
0.7501165271,
-0.1120745689,
0.8793708682,
-0.1006295457,
0.157437399,
1.0630612373,
-0.01445188,
0.9680155516,
0.2927903533,
-0.2437865585,
0.3515096903,
0.8689656854,
0.151451841,
0.707070291,
0.0651109964,
-0.4853492975,
-0.2771313488,
-0.1254033595,
-0.4123163819,
0.3204928339,
0.0238074791,
-0.0410215966,
-0.2919645607,
0.0487810038,
-0.3119045198,
0.2136544734,
-0.218149811,
0.4019540548,
-0.1825212389,
-0.5855805278,
0.4241101444,
-0.0693763047,
-0.126797393,
-0.4899224043,
-0.1315375268,
-0.3370785415,
-0.0310564302,
0.0172339212,
-1.0476332903,
0.2009358555,
-0.1295669526,
-0.0695204213,
0.2634519637,
0.3998400867,
-0.507412374,
-0.4599063993,
-0.1973713189,
0.7626932859,
0.3426207006,
-0.1354291439,
-0.3792971075,
-0.355709374,
-0.2266782969,
-0.3609108329,
0.4228809774,
0.6190220714,
0.0581037812,
0.7873472571,
0.3796369731,
0.031929858,
0.2721390128,
-0.1914413571,
0.9560386539,
-0.7122040391,
-0.4242189825,
-0.2637371719,
0.3155286908,
0.1229985282,
-0.5465388894,
0.7952334881,
0.4983169138,
0.9671990275,
-0.1993065923,
0.6780788302,
0.0302025843,
0.7266412377,
-0.6372564435,
0.9121012092,
-0.4598120749,
-0.2791545391,
-0.1858258843,
-0.7999195457,
-0.1944461018,
0.3822451532,
-0.0791954696,
0.0244826432,
0.5240606666,
0.5701539516,
0.0675223768,
0.3007708788,
0.3534390628,
0.0029199442,
-0.0551143847,
0.771838367,
0.9737432003,
-0.9893587828,
0.8613301516,
-0.2638950944,
0.1627902687,
0.0624478981,
-0.1859520525,
-0.8944838047,
-0.8987696767,
-0.2009517848,
-0.4593602717,
0.2414923459,
0.9194456935,
0.2651597559,
-0.8658007979,
0.0031638821,
0.5417971015,
0.1018272564,
-0.2636599243,
-0.2037119716,
0.603267312,
-0.0255060289,
-0.4044604599,
0.0251843669,
-0.1381572038,
-0.0812147111,
-0.1028471217,
-0.1422888786,
-0.3291459382,
0.1324915588,
0.3563539982,
0.517410934,
-0.5886413455,
-0.3583089709,
0.5905186534,
-0.065817982,
0.1821668893,
0.4362109303,
-0.758459866,
0.3575642705,
0.5912978649,
0.5904644728,
0.2393295169,
0.3601827323,
0.4749205112,
-0.2513771653,
-0.305730015,
0.3720305264,
-0.1743529439,
0.1746023595,
-0.2884618342,
0.3676395118,
-0.114174284,
-0.4886520207,
-0.9412360191,
0.0660432652,
-0.8564412594,
-0.1244065762,
0.9913942814,
-0.3930367529,
-0.3923353553,
-0.7032415867,
-0.2593330145,
0.150355354,
-0.2710743546,
0.8004661798,
0.872954905,
0.0743772835,
-0.287566632,
-1.073264122,
0.5896648169,
0.1248072907,
-0.774759233,
0.2796291113,
0.5633813739,
0.2713757753,
-0.238973707,
0.8022239804,
-0.3168089092,
0.812296629,
0.0753265694,
0.0453396179,
-0.1725195795,
-0.3945085704,
-0.283185482,
0.1052155793,
0.0824742168,
-0.4796792567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04475v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04475v1
|
Length-Controlled AlpacaEval: A Simple Way to Debias Automatic Evaluators
| 2024-04-06T02:29:02 | 2024-04-06T02:29:02 |
Yann Dubois, Balázs Galambosi, Percy Liang, Tatsunori B. Hashimoto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
LLM-based auto-annotators have become a key component of the LLM development
process due to their cost-effectiveness and scalability compared to human-based
evaluation. However, these auto-annotators can introduce complex biases that
are hard to remove. Even simple, known confounders such as preference for
longer outputs remain in existing automated evaluation metrics. We propose a
simple regression analysis approach for controlling biases in auto-evaluations.
As a real case study, we focus on reducing the length bias of AlpacaEval, a
fast and affordable benchmark for chat LLMs that uses LLMs to estimate response
quality. Despite being highly correlated with human preferences, AlpacaEval is
known to favor models that generate longer outputs. We introduce a
length-controlled AlpacaEval that aims to answer the counterfactual question:
"What would the preference be if the model's and baseline's output had the same
length?". To achieve this, we first fit a generalized linear model to predict
the biased output of interest (auto-annotator preferences) based on the
mediators we want to control for (length difference) and other relevant
features. We then obtain length-controlled preferences by predicting
preferences while conditioning the GLM with a zero difference in lengths.
Length-controlling not only improves the robustness of the metric to
manipulations in model verbosity, we also find that it increases the Spearman
correlation with LMSYS' Chatbot Arena from 0.94 to 0.98. We release the code
and leaderboard at https://tatsu-lab.github.io/alpaca_eval/ .
|
[
-0.787850976,
-0.9651457667,
0.4474446774,
0.195733577,
-0.4593900442,
0.052909214,
-0.2481296659,
-0.633462131,
0.5520872474,
0.3683201671,
-0.453789562,
-0.2752848268,
-0.8941611648,
0.0410920121,
-0.294672668,
1.1046886444,
-0.2064892501,
-0.2820825875,
-0.1448807418,
-0.4016723931,
-0.4804578722,
-0.3192703128,
-0.771633029,
-0.3348130882,
0.7499537468,
0.1829321682,
1.2727934122,
0.9301139712,
0.5395157337,
0.1627788693,
0.1160063893,
0.3708153367,
-0.2590201199,
0.0625791773,
0.2485503554,
-0.2383347005,
-0.6481560469,
0.2845463157,
0.3271262944,
0.4302350581,
0.0092663439,
0.4907405376,
0.2473062128,
0.7543558478,
-0.7497242689,
0.2839155495,
-0.4323220551,
0.0143671818,
-0.0138005065,
-0.3500651419,
-0.2026888281,
-0.3930028677,
0.0423548333,
-0.4132935405,
-0.1540553421,
0.0072933105,
0.8530520201,
0.9298212528,
-0.3044210076,
-0.5076480508,
-0.8847323656,
0.9203547239,
-0.6476866603,
0.376057446,
0.6022957563,
0.3881572485,
0.0832435712,
-0.1699364036,
-0.1374674141,
-0.5346787572,
-0.3285279572,
-0.0065327813,
-0.3278844655,
0.0198653899,
0.0482801981,
0.0424214713,
-0.5678152442,
0.4314323664,
-0.4713047743,
-0.3921016455,
0.9812128544,
0.34274441,
-0.000886859,
-0.1493809372,
-0.2529878914,
0.1223107427,
-0.6075009108,
0.034975782,
0.5484980941,
0.0629024059,
-0.0572287478,
0.5718727708,
-0.3108557165,
0.6622204185,
0.1461753845,
-0.0851449743,
0.0371911302,
0.1329138279,
-0.2855066657,
-0.1330257058,
0.8586835265,
0.4387525618,
0.1799928695,
-0.0004962235,
-0.1974158287,
0.3372972608,
0.1348182857,
-0.7145760059,
0.0282468796,
0.3564504981,
-0.5563515425,
-0.3274493515,
-0.3565080166,
-0.7106182575,
-0.3450807929,
-0.4685212076,
0.6138526201,
-0.1009262502,
0.3901321292,
0.0811902955,
0.292314142,
0.0676755309,
0.3707906604,
-0.734074235,
0.5238267779,
0.3988868296,
0.739086926,
-0.4636735618,
-0.2059594542,
-0.8171299696,
-0.2340907753,
-0.4323212206,
0.4781324267,
-0.3862196803,
-0.4814895391,
-0.1277852654,
-0.3452424407,
0.2967216671,
-0.2105114311,
0.2730004787,
-0.4996271729,
0.5022601485,
0.0690138638,
-0.5517007113,
0.2041838914,
0.0379037857,
-0.577293098,
0.7733935118,
-0.017646471,
-0.5662263632,
0.6211369038,
-0.8172478676,
-0.079815045,
-0.2839700878,
-0.2434388399,
-0.5289238691,
-0.1450009644,
0.501086235,
0.0909856856,
-0.4041254818,
0.2834169567,
-0.3040316105,
-0.5337517858,
0.260933727,
-0.6842494011,
0.5259757042,
0.4363084733,
-0.4970507622,
0.3564150035,
-0.6744978428,
0.0217673481,
-0.1229539216,
-0.3045017719,
-0.2052281648,
0.0822040066,
-0.5152583122,
-0.067174308,
0.348146081,
-0.4282757342,
0.2363027483,
-0.1305881143,
0.0744385421,
0.7482969761,
0.0233502313,
0.6493577957,
-0.326001972,
0.5714604855,
-0.3682349622,
0.8621408343,
0.1847241968,
-0.1399162114,
-1.1645983458,
-0.6010116339,
0.395640552,
0.2791479826,
-0.5217879415,
0.5998976827,
0.1180734411,
-0.4820659459,
-0.8439299464,
0.4994625449,
0.3215018511,
0.2716341317,
0.546538949,
-0.5719624758,
-0.4445698857,
-1.1793444157,
-0.1868365109,
-0.4218405485,
-0.2257378548,
0.3795697391,
0.2088602781,
-0.3817020655,
1.2844418287,
-0.7242518663,
-0.4357827306,
-0.0430798121,
0.2076029181,
0.2028066963,
0.2647299767,
0.7117003798,
-0.2394036651,
-0.2822895944,
-0.6685236692,
-0.5543185472,
-0.6153407693,
-0.1276559234,
-0.2378461808,
0.2722180188,
0.1383520663,
-0.7054829001,
0.8652669787,
0.3050695658,
-0.2890245318,
0.4570648074,
-0.2081720233,
0.018915372,
-0.2025507092,
-0.2151494622,
0.0433896631,
-0.2530696988,
-0.1605951488,
-0.2418386191,
0.0125977984,
0.3728365898,
-0.3930851221,
0.6891736388,
-0.2295868397,
-0.1884340644,
-0.6127585173,
0.069767125,
0.2785318494,
0.4997822046,
-0.1585150957,
0.642072022,
0.0688826889,
-0.7008640766,
0.5122927427,
0.1581225097,
-0.069946982,
0.2203402817,
-0.7904732227,
0.2057997435,
-0.0604799017,
0.4090635478,
-0.7548280358,
-0.025555566,
0.417982012,
-0.5233960152,
0.0344868638,
-0.1040699556,
-0.2128924578,
-0.5077927113,
-0.4001303613,
-0.0393713489,
0.7211751938,
-0.6032344699,
0.4504830241,
0.1988017857,
-0.0621515885,
-0.6676721573,
-0.564258039,
-0.104500182,
-0.607791245,
-0.3088818789,
-0.036874976,
-0.4751122594,
-0.4647585154,
-0.2160425037,
-0.0201475583,
0.0337259881,
0.1563827693,
0.4231488705,
0.4739075005,
0.2517246008,
0.2194355726,
0.2077450752,
-0.2293464094,
0.1905530542,
0.0407163426,
0.5294139981,
-0.2072251886,
-0.4923271239,
-0.3707930744,
0.0967465267,
0.4532796741,
-0.1799847782,
0.3104676008,
0.5741933584,
0.0113428747,
-0.0941758007,
-0.8085074425,
-0.2756471038,
-0.4312778413,
0.2210533619,
-0.1046745852,
-0.8280708194,
0.5200682878,
0.4445709288,
0.1350311041,
0.4715130627,
0.6475531459,
0.0406281278,
1.0960426331,
0.6385571361,
-0.3216213584,
0.2307163626,
-0.2365790755,
-0.0029870521,
-0.6575439572,
0.077182278,
-0.2667537034,
-0.3584373295,
-0.3694245517,
-0.4233665168,
0.3507721424,
-0.044517599,
-0.2673522532,
0.1929891706,
-0.5134555697,
0.399515599,
0.3043781519,
-0.0182452723,
0.2854917347,
-0.4298014641,
0.2445931435,
-0.0663078874,
-0.3672747612,
-0.5931454301,
1.0036215782,
0.8062909842,
1.0851596594,
0.0370196179,
0.8024032712,
0.777389884,
0.5242392421,
-1.0075055361,
0.3959369063,
0.220700264,
-0.4467454851,
-0.5770940781,
-0.3553256094,
-0.7993430495,
0.2401189953,
0.1419439912,
-0.6529330015,
0.2637598515,
0.3411758542,
-0.6595278978,
0.0114990575,
-0.38394925,
0.3011838794,
-0.6435254812,
-0.605823338,
-0.1458182335,
-0.4919018149,
0.110657081,
-0.2598567903,
0.2538389862,
-0.5164964795,
-0.1473654062,
0.8434404135,
-0.4699888527,
0.8524238467,
-0.0789330229,
-0.0758189559,
0.5629079938,
0.3565409482,
0.3795077503,
0.3521547019,
-0.0497648194,
0.084484756,
-0.1138700619,
-0.254314214,
-0.623231709,
0.6662192941,
-0.9068323374,
-0.8449001312,
-0.298581332,
-0.4764657319,
-0.3123033047,
-0.1592975259,
0.0876194462,
0.0856195986,
-0.2747504115,
-0.0316856392,
0.1451136023,
-0.2251230776,
0.708597362,
0.6176313758,
-0.5960130095,
-0.4526332021,
0.3330425024,
0.1462100893,
0.186066255,
-0.1125341952,
0.3677334189,
-0.2983185947,
-0.0615716279,
-0.6635329127,
0.0219043475,
-0.5776474476,
-0.3963293731,
-0.4334629774,
-0.1363591403,
-0.090150401,
-0.1404246986,
-0.5600143671,
-0.4434139729,
-0.4052343369,
-0.2653706372,
0.513966918,
0.6905372739,
-0.2659361362,
0.4428716004,
-0.498663336,
0.2146834433,
0.5442635417,
0.3914000094,
-0.181603983,
-0.7247188091,
-0.2725828886,
0.0427899025,
-0.2723413706,
-0.7018307447,
0.7425046563,
0.1399026215,
0.3508144319,
0.4247460365,
0.0165014341,
0.6251534224,
-0.2045133561,
0.6852107048,
0.1238932386,
-1.0340799093,
0.6107136011,
-0.0941151008,
0.2151124775,
0.5029286146,
0.4791755676,
-0.3127182126,
-0.4060996771,
-0.5996688604,
-0.7674971819,
0.2732325494,
0.3549027145,
0.1138067618,
-0.0410597511,
0.3642903268,
0.3795365393,
0.1711189747,
-0.4266572297,
-0.2277394384,
-0.2333272845,
0.0150236432,
0.0259618293,
-0.4954818487,
-0.3323958814,
-0.1651577502,
0.5812760592,
-0.2258670777,
0.0191578716,
0.312669009,
-0.259118259,
-0.258466363,
0.3923882544,
0.2469863743,
1.0675438643,
-0.5412864089,
0.1508777142,
0.4187082052,
-0.1327058971,
0.1776135564,
0.1061042473,
-0.2371587306,
0.1660612077,
0.2100571245,
0.9623748064,
-0.3960157335,
-0.3804399967,
0.3963898122,
-0.057862442,
0.0439827107,
-0.3769411147,
0.0622059219,
-0.2439310849,
0.1121807396,
0.3649260998,
-0.2966048419,
0.2086681575,
-0.2086708397,
0.2636790276,
0.3602639437,
-0.6561213136,
-0.0629116967,
0.7433670759,
0.3324488699,
-0.1825476289,
0.2623024285,
-0.0956136808,
-0.2390381843,
0.7797207832,
0.0374587663,
0.797817111,
-0.1571137309,
0.0982051492,
0.1567296088,
0.3324179053,
0.2840538919,
-0.0378568396,
0.0267389342,
-0.5224252343,
-0.492153883,
-0.7837567925,
-0.4929805398,
0.2184009254,
-0.756709516,
0.3394001722,
-0.475646466,
-0.6528642774,
-0.068320781,
0.234995842,
-0.8131265044,
0.3719660044,
0.2380693853,
0.8616982102,
-0.8752804995,
0.8210256696,
-0.0754963681,
-0.4804548323,
-0.4979789853,
-0.3770432472,
0.1292257458,
-0.6980961561,
0.6994276047,
-0.0756127685,
-0.191040501,
-0.5404385328,
-0.5720092654,
-0.9998393059,
1.0376645327,
0.0605930798,
-0.6625740528,
0.1401089728,
0.3065362275,
0.6584838033,
-0.5803697109,
0.6095248461,
1.0001788139,
0.4270019531,
-0.2622221708,
-1.1549474001,
-0.2054572105,
0.0704139322,
0.0599338897,
0.1065806746,
-1.0133628845,
0.5018376708,
-0.1354253441,
0.3699581623,
0.0757252276,
0.8721709847,
0.1433961838,
0.2860942781,
0.6336202621,
0.2397614419,
0.4994859695,
0.0737903342,
0.8319677114,
-0.3976461887,
0.5511140227,
1.4543821812,
-0.2459540367,
0.5098429918,
0.5614829063,
-0.1489365995,
0.2946762741,
0.6321514249,
-0.0428560302,
0.3729295731,
0.454608649,
0.0642952248,
-0.2149529904,
-0.0759901181,
-0.1531622857,
0.7798913121,
0.3153799474,
-0.5045070052,
0.007763199,
0.0661738738,
0.3552677929,
-0.1128489003,
-0.0493022464,
0.6222125292,
0.1002582684,
-0.6056834459,
0.5823171735,
-0.1657274216,
0.838050127,
-0.6516171694,
0.2130733579,
-0.5681509972,
0.0996882319,
-0.0573155768,
-0.6256188154,
0.422626406,
0.1897278875,
0.0615847446,
-0.0229108594,
0.7311162353,
-0.2296173871,
-0.2487782687,
0.5878849626,
0.6756743789,
0.025756266,
0.2194318771,
-0.6141235232,
0.4855512083,
-0.0873045325,
-0.5114767551,
0.1373258382,
-0.2098721266,
-0.3157939613,
0.8529507518,
0.5028635859,
0.2003869414,
-0.1420938224,
0.058675427,
0.8751792312,
-0.4457090497,
-0.2482641339,
-1.1076939106,
0.1101707593,
0.0049636345,
-0.2768117785,
0.6241690516,
0.5189449191,
0.5065433383,
0.1060044244,
0.7428843975,
-0.0066162781,
0.4782269895,
-0.2577858567,
0.7453901172,
-0.4407031834,
0.4251139462,
-0.0271883514,
-0.9647933245,
-0.1724913567,
0.3525367975,
-0.5333486795,
-0.0852019712,
0.3373327851,
0.532105267,
0.1988027841,
-0.4090863764,
0.3033989966,
0.0580126792,
0.6354284883,
0.3780420125,
0.8909341693,
-0.1674410105,
0.6137705445,
-0.4874273837,
-0.3891587257,
-0.2642818391,
-0.9375342727,
-0.766050756,
-0.0859234482,
-0.4716137052,
-0.3493596017,
0.2638317645,
1.1209869385,
0.5590322614,
-0.5198583603,
-0.4384570718,
0.4791019261,
-0.1435246468,
0.1367644817,
-0.2060263455,
0.510984242,
-0.3695916235,
-0.653142035,
0.173162967,
0.3140460253,
-0.0321822949,
-0.5991486907,
-0.2404098511,
0.2039362639,
0.573728323,
0.4288624823,
0.2798649073,
-0.8490934968,
-0.5865523815,
-0.2253115475,
-0.2548577785,
0.1881007999,
0.4003352225,
-1.0043543577,
0.4657700956,
0.3050956726,
0.2588982284,
0.4997752905,
0.0361972637,
0.4621055424,
-0.5615953207,
0.2915739715,
0.2224829048,
0.4862672687,
0.2465814501,
-0.5073191524,
0.72390306,
-0.3285543323,
-0.7201988697,
-0.4697740972,
0.1595254838,
-0.7440789938,
-0.08965379,
1.2177830935,
-0.0470531844,
-0.2503115833,
0.2872848213,
-0.4197731018,
0.386544764,
-0.4423612058,
1.3101950884,
0.4751942158,
-0.4989226162,
0.0630413294,
-0.4340462983,
0.7057773471,
0.6457179189,
-0.7626714706,
0.0053696665,
0.6509264112,
0.2778794467,
0.2979280949,
0.638659656,
-0.0845654011,
0.1895586401,
-0.5019397736,
0.1920892149,
-0.1354630738,
-0.3928976059,
-0.3562690318,
-0.2918143272,
0.2810413539,
-0.2359571457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04445v1
|
Towards Realistic Few-Shot Relation Extraction: A New Meta Dataset and Evaluation
| 2024-04-05T23:12:46 | 2024-04-05T23:12:46 |
Fahmida Alam, Md Asiful Islam, Robert Vacareanu, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
We introduce a meta dataset for few-shot relation extraction, which includes
two datasets derived from existing supervised relation extraction datasets
NYT29 (Takanobu et al., 2019; Nayak and Ng, 2020) and WIKIDATA (Sorokin and
Gurevych, 2017) as well as a few-shot form of the TACRED dataset (Sabo et al.,
2021). Importantly, all these few-shot datasets were generated under realistic
assumptions such as: the test relations are different from any relations a
model might have seen before, limited training data, and a preponderance of
candidate relation mentions that do not correspond to any of the relations of
interest. Using this large resource, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
six recent few-shot relation extraction methods, and observe that no method
comes out as a clear winner. Further, the overall performance on this task is
low, indicating substantial need for future research. We release all versions
of the data, i.e., both supervised and few-shot, for future research.
|
[
-0.4691860676,
-0.6650037169,
0.585952878,
-0.2005702257,
-0.2488272935,
-0.4755370915,
0.0036545284,
-0.5628170967,
0.1666302532,
0.3634981215,
-0.8747187853,
-0.5427306294,
-0.5733554959,
0.3848034143,
-0.1679911017,
0.9950116277,
0.406300962,
-0.0367069617,
-0.1723406166,
-0.3330255449,
-0.1639373302,
-0.0764705241,
-0.233424738,
-0.2773702741,
0.8434475064,
0.5555862784,
0.5648082495,
0.5116458535,
0.8956747651,
0.0817311928,
0.0627706945,
0.0536336638,
-0.7477235794,
-0.2180460691,
-0.084502399,
-0.2075317502,
-0.4683673382,
0.3280735314,
0.4761372209,
0.6065006256,
0.1625502408,
0.6047757268,
-0.1334366649,
0.3803503811,
-1.2888391018,
0.2471100837,
-0.7449054718,
0.2233887911,
-0.68828547,
-0.0089883525,
-0.4346694052,
-0.1546765417,
0.2499335557,
-0.6420661807,
-0.0021499628,
-0.1420006603,
1.1420061588,
0.0053456444,
-0.570168972,
-0.0046264702,
-0.7294649482,
0.4850228727,
-0.6146619916,
0.1398249567,
0.5192633867,
0.8768943548,
-0.1571935266,
-0.9913840294,
-0.4477730989,
-0.0463922098,
-0.2071153522,
0.2540967464,
-0.2934206426,
-0.0700624585,
0.44702968,
0.1358067393,
-0.3866330087,
-0.1215582639,
-0.3141105175,
0.0638018623,
0.7357523441,
0.4898652434,
-0.1103361174,
-0.5476720929,
-0.2658467293,
0.1591118425,
-0.7815178633,
-0.1595135182,
0.128981486,
0.4727875292,
-0.1153144017,
0.70567137,
-0.187400192,
0.6320549846,
-0.1804145426,
-0.5900056958,
0.0118002482,
-0.5541636348,
-0.1109817773,
-0.3259052336,
1.2637815475,
0.3417070508,
0.5804040432,
-0.1147435308,
0.0182199422,
0.0314566568,
-0.0335287377,
-0.7688425779,
-0.2254493982,
-0.0549193211,
-0.6942039132,
-0.483374387,
0.3530615866,
-0.9133849144,
-0.1989326477,
0.2529457211,
0.492289573,
-0.3068800867,
-0.4290166199,
-0.4606009722,
-0.3231802881,
0.5483219624,
0.0441826619,
-0.7719646096,
0.4758576453,
0.8295871615,
0.7766170502,
-0.1572347581,
-0.2906119227,
-0.4599354267,
0.2140155584,
-0.4465231895,
0.8645086884,
-0.723544538,
-0.2165832967,
-0.1465736181,
-0.2549384236,
0.0922556967,
-0.4800902009,
0.4381475747,
-0.5917428136,
0.1735782176,
-0.4644371569,
-0.4803927541,
0.1501739174,
0.5526052117,
-1.0254416466,
0.697409749,
0.2626052201,
-1.0334209204,
0.5089910626,
-0.4511243999,
-0.1391339153,
-0.1341259331,
-0.284581095,
-0.4252696931,
-0.0435524918,
0.2207578868,
0.4555872977,
-0.4685258865,
-0.1973216236,
-0.8844907284,
-0.3059184253,
0.1503034979,
-0.2217608541,
0.8894981146,
0.2668659091,
0.0977994874,
-0.5313895941,
-0.8511455059,
-0.0486044176,
0.1428457648,
0.1566369534,
-0.1160647124,
-0.3966718614,
-0.0773421004,
0.560652256,
-0.0209312141,
-0.6678720117,
0.4577750564,
-0.2685627937,
-0.0880488977,
0.3685801923,
0.6832490563,
0.4991878867,
0.0759714693,
0.8505478501,
0.0887776986,
0.2466151416,
-0.2716691196,
-0.2735556066,
-0.3791406155,
-0.2588464618,
0.7516900897,
0.3329193294,
-0.7936071157,
0.0371128172,
-0.5444014072,
-0.4994650483,
-0.3119836152,
0.0849928334,
0.4929299355,
0.7175112367,
0.1382408291,
-0.168116644,
-0.6923651099,
-0.9704304338,
-0.4863418639,
-0.2044326365,
0.0141906459,
0.293948859,
0.7781373262,
0.108311452,
1.5371459723,
-0.8041270971,
-0.5146193504,
-0.3943274021,
0.1467083544,
0.2925732136,
0.0674455687,
0.8620761037,
-0.4855213463,
-0.7659057379,
-0.0598323569,
-1.1484079361,
0.2696231306,
0.04630059,
-0.0944188237,
-0.2136637866,
0.0095504113,
-0.8273977637,
0.6608106494,
0.1558751762,
0.0791913122,
0.5606289506,
0.6915234923,
0.0087028239,
-0.8660221696,
0.1752084792,
0.1081347615,
-0.4926569462,
-0.4901291728,
0.0588524044,
-0.0579160638,
-0.1267483085,
-0.8759616613,
0.7813547254,
-0.2834449112,
-0.2999431491,
-0.1862268001,
0.1133420765,
-0.1484718621,
0.2709039152,
0.0122671612,
0.37618801,
0.4012100399,
-0.46879673,
0.3875681162,
0.4690659344,
-0.1166348904,
0.3838404715,
-0.4808510542,
0.1762332469,
-0.04117148,
0.3922150731,
-0.724211514,
-0.5025149584,
0.5157393813,
-0.5220113993,
0.1235104725,
-0.643899262,
-0.5885975957,
-0.2268170118,
-0.5748556852,
0.1778938323,
0.3735319376,
-0.3789924085,
0.3741704226,
0.1781560332,
0.0421586744,
-0.7777779698,
-0.5960536003,
0.0652818754,
-0.2958227694,
-0.4133270085,
0.0761651546,
0.4081506431,
-0.4264801145,
0.3608882129,
-0.2261761278,
-0.6672572494,
-0.0455266722,
0.0957843214,
0.2437231839,
-0.1209910065,
0.1020505279,
-0.3559785783,
-0.4308102131,
-0.0083696712,
0.368359834,
0.0532243103,
0.176637426,
-0.0379515849,
-0.4638373554,
0.060283713,
0.0838022679,
-0.0647938401,
0.7651492357,
0.8737555146,
-0.7265684605,
0.208701998,
-0.4029642344,
-0.3246953189,
-0.3043695688,
0.2406242639,
-0.7878289819,
-0.3294376433,
0.4187598526,
-0.1032927558,
0.2092731893,
0.7180122733,
0.2053145468,
-0.3913367689,
0.5536150336,
0.7422168851,
-0.0452754535,
0.3406714797,
-0.6230547428,
-0.1551083177,
-0.6222456694,
-0.206704095,
-0.3917206824,
-0.3399168849,
-0.7207916379,
0.2587887049,
0.4641036987,
0.0879309401,
0.1433965415,
0.6961629987,
0.1600094289,
0.6679589748,
0.2544843853,
0.2027359605,
0.4088460803,
-0.2689135075,
0.2861129344,
-0.4961685538,
-0.9393215775,
-0.7378907204,
1.4785020351,
0.0215908997,
0.5357649922,
-0.0051146047,
1.1318012476,
0.0207462851,
0.5426000953,
-0.8930174112,
0.3331250846,
-0.046958629,
-1.0515809059,
-0.293296963,
-0.6206176281,
-1.105992198,
0.1769933701,
-0.6589905024,
-0.6896474957,
0.2193012536,
0.0264921002,
-0.6553329825,
0.0246228501,
-0.4661672115,
0.8735046387,
0.0117819272,
-0.6653518081,
0.0922938883,
-1.0892904997,
1.0180302858,
-0.0237551667,
0.0554501638,
-0.3281178474,
-0.0626011491,
0.8566454053,
-0.2467098385,
0.5871084929,
-0.2140960693,
0.4362820089,
0.5303236246,
0.2102722228,
0.2920095921,
0.1196753755,
-0.3499959111,
-0.0165859293,
0.5067353249,
-0.4076415896,
-0.7611518502,
0.2913143933,
-0.3570881188,
0.0583857819,
-0.6259738207,
-0.1952348202,
-0.2100773901,
0.3879009187,
0.6346754432,
0.2846107781,
-0.7663021088,
0.1513120383,
0.0768965781,
0.198257491,
0.7310637832,
0.1584327072,
-0.0361158215,
-0.7220513225,
0.5289843082,
0.3484781086,
0.0521652959,
0.1756544411,
0.2361617386,
-0.1801781207,
-0.0301397759,
-0.0395557024,
0.3573793173,
-0.5122739077,
-0.6228176951,
-0.3595438004,
-0.0059679574,
-0.4684499502,
0.3450466692,
-0.6497856379,
-0.6210980415,
-0.1598997414,
-0.0340285413,
0.2837352157,
0.7998242974,
-0.0845403522,
0.4598834515,
-1.1437013149,
0.7437937856,
0.24345918,
-0.0476789214,
-0.2522126436,
-0.3087675571,
-0.2427903861,
-0.1365776807,
-0.5858827829,
-1.0931740999,
0.322496593,
0.4800680578,
0.422234416,
0.7757790089,
0.2605331242,
1.0004661083,
-0.5006392002,
0.8043826818,
0.2521608472,
-0.5630776882,
0.6354199052,
-0.1778115928,
0.0126446532,
1.25514853,
0.574239254,
0.0036214734,
0.3500199616,
-1.2832562923,
-0.2284831405,
0.7614314556,
0.4319727719,
0.009045478,
0.0477830954,
0.7483910322,
0.084988147,
0.257211417,
-0.71098876,
-0.4031751752,
0.3103203773,
-0.0914898738,
0.2049951255,
-0.4235240221,
-0.299869597,
-0.0525684319,
0.3401526809,
-0.0255930331,
0.2465276122,
-0.0561853349,
-0.0797068998,
-0.0197127778,
0.1921770424,
0.2356533855,
1.0508826971,
-0.5289289951,
0.1715436727,
0.317738235,
-0.1729302555,
0.1125183031,
-0.0404205807,
-0.0455025844,
0.2435019761,
1.0790731907,
0.2916547656,
0.3200448155,
-0.2709155083,
0.9512583017,
0.2259161919,
-0.1350806355,
-0.1900370717,
-0.1773715764,
-0.116713196,
0.1691891849,
0.2826368213,
-0.1423005164,
0.314601481,
-0.8435558677,
0.4354560673,
0.4771389067,
-0.1756643504,
-0.6020664573,
0.3901051879,
0.1751585752,
-0.1316952407,
0.6437126398,
-0.4774306417,
-0.2152051479,
0.2312138528,
0.2905277312,
0.7747322321,
0.2919799685,
0.0970033035,
0.7753869295,
0.2573462725,
0.0144905653,
-0.1838404685,
-0.1260898709,
-0.6082542539,
-0.4007973075,
-0.2239749283,
-0.4305434525,
0.3313787878,
-0.8072443008,
0.7896008492,
-0.4185937941,
-0.4429816008,
-0.1440661401,
0.4405419827,
-0.8826477528,
0.0919136107,
-0.1139887795,
0.9298024774,
-1.0496146679,
0.7020992041,
0.3912997842,
-0.7084668875,
-0.5388503075,
0.0906683654,
0.2990178168,
-0.4106733501,
0.5663443208,
-0.0093909623,
0.0385042578,
-0.218624562,
-0.816839397,
-0.5706103444,
1.2130146027,
0.81066221,
-0.5636638403,
-0.15613392,
0.0378897525,
0.3386036754,
-0.4357433915,
0.3554167151,
0.8950557709,
0.4720868766,
0.2501932383,
-0.7084347606,
-0.3210879862,
0.0106929168,
-0.303394407,
-0.1507504731,
-0.6370636821,
0.3876335621,
-0.2925039232,
-0.4010995626,
0.0954167843,
0.7627218962,
0.5193205476,
0.6335123777,
0.2987989783,
0.5293956995,
0.3122188151,
-0.0341525488,
1.1485557556,
0.084593527,
0.5752708912,
1.5694925785,
-0.3910595775,
0.9627428651,
0.5849584341,
-0.5526507497,
0.1218319833,
0.8213723898,
-0.0551246479,
0.6778122783,
-0.4713146091,
-0.0875238478,
-0.4351302683,
-0.0798254907,
-0.2716542482,
0.7718424797,
0.0497219115,
-0.2903223336,
-0.5606937408,
-0.3532794714,
-0.0486831032,
-0.1263363957,
0.234399572,
1.1214840412,
0.3972055316,
-0.187779516,
0.2379714698,
-0.1777492762,
0.4397354126,
-0.6786383986,
-0.2646860778,
-0.2229219824,
-0.2185949534,
-0.5672404766,
-0.5236968398,
0.2916825116,
0.4133045673,
-0.0192076266,
0.3295075595,
1.0019415617,
-0.2046934068,
-0.5748676062,
-0.0921218693,
0.8110153675,
0.359906584,
0.0156799871,
-0.6382046342,
-0.0932092145,
-0.3726576269,
-0.253007859,
0.1639811099,
0.5642793775,
0.2232157439,
0.4216378331,
0.4361097515,
0.3157962263,
-0.0549948178,
-0.1694686115,
0.7701424956,
-0.6512386799,
0.1017870232,
-1.0663294792,
0.5179300904,
-0.1676750034,
-0.5135396719,
0.7769237161,
0.6146475077,
0.3438702226,
-0.0741226301,
0.6183427572,
-0.1939519793,
0.3572722673,
-0.3294093609,
0.3029924631,
-0.2730172873,
0.0933194607,
-0.7010096908,
-1.1887565851,
-0.5025081038,
0.5017549992,
-0.2225072235,
0.011384856,
0.7094060779,
0.5222327709,
-0.466706574,
-0.3390896618,
0.4073796868,
-0.1302337646,
0.2202182859,
0.4623307288,
0.8098827004,
-0.9059420824,
0.8883875012,
-0.632373333,
0.0426644869,
-0.1193371043,
-1.0942013264,
-0.7662484646,
-0.184962824,
-0.3483148813,
-0.1300263107,
-0.1146561429,
0.9814133644,
0.7998063564,
-0.4389150739,
0.0311304815,
0.0094484342,
0.0912063643,
-0.1729488075,
-0.2303059697,
0.1893464029,
-0.0916560292,
-0.5818403959,
0.3223301172,
0.1671571285,
-0.0029843834,
-0.0529727265,
-0.1175616756,
-0.3650689721,
-0.4263967872,
0.7029436827,
0.3653858304,
-0.4663885534,
-0.1974787414,
-0.0478983223,
-0.0607298389,
0.1416321993,
0.6578137875,
-0.8445563912,
0.350692153,
0.6036177278,
0.5012149811,
0.8454926014,
0.1910281777,
0.4107599556,
-1.1108583212,
0.1424648017,
0.3076207638,
0.0420317352,
0.1169290692,
-0.0571020953,
1.1106334925,
0.3219271898,
-0.0627490431,
-1.0242928267,
0.1267353892,
-0.9335432053,
0.2030776888,
1.1244006157,
-0.401828289,
-0.1261604577,
0.1952682137,
0.2085377872,
0.3213619292,
-0.1998375207,
0.4072101116,
0.7206405997,
-0.5826060176,
-0.4190679491,
-0.6032420993,
0.3874076009,
-0.1584860981,
-1.0207535028,
-0.1083205119,
0.4010877907,
0.4974430501,
0.112594381,
0.7513685822,
-0.2865919769,
0.5512387156,
0.2371977568,
-0.1841444522,
-0.1031111702,
-0.5378623605,
-0.3364805579,
0.1548777074,
0.12795645,
-0.393053174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04393v1
|
Counting Like Transformers: Compiling Temporal Counting Logic Into Softmax Transformers
| 2024-04-05T20:36:30 | 2024-04-05T20:36:30 |
Andy Yang, David Chiang
|
cs.LO
|
cs.LO, cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LG
|
Deriving formal bounds on the expressivity of transformers, as well as
studying transformers that are constructed to implement known algorithms, are
both effective methods for better understanding the computational power of
transformers. Towards both ends, we introduce the temporal counting logic
$\textbf{K}_\text{t}$[#] alongside the RASP variant $\textbf{C-RASP}$. We show
they are equivalent to each other, and that together they are the best-known
lower bound on the formal expressivity of future-masked soft attention
transformers with unbounded input size. We prove this by showing all
$\textbf{K}_\text{t}$[#] formulas can be compiled into these transformers. As a
case study, we demonstrate on paper how to use $\textbf{C-RASP}$ to construct
simple transformer language models that, using greedy decoding, can only
generate sentences that have given properties formally specified in
$\textbf{K}_\text{t}$[#].
|
[
-0.3969551027,
-0.2689779401,
0.6472516656,
0.3044251204,
-0.010477691,
0.3226754665,
-0.315741241,
-0.6486986279,
0.1531000584,
0.5070407391,
-0.6014552712,
-0.1981547773,
-0.6936432123,
-0.0274720509,
-0.6019716859,
0.9353086352,
0.0716368705,
-0.148104012,
0.1552610993,
-0.1530494094,
-0.2708437145,
-0.3167189956,
0.0123787383,
-0.2292979807,
0.3481155932,
0.3656050563,
0.6277083158,
0.3505302668,
0.4256611466,
0.4041455984,
0.0919868648,
-0.1267082542,
-0.1269918084,
0.3959529102,
0.0426598713,
-0.4082605243,
-0.4720080793,
0.0826998428,
0.5736887455,
0.5850474834,
0.0023142819,
0.3618543148,
-0.0810641721,
0.269325465,
-0.6818521023,
0.4969778359,
-0.4238363504,
0.52127707,
-0.0894995853,
-0.5199333429,
-0.7464157343,
-0.2366544753,
0.0633386225,
-0.2849710286,
0.4664711058,
-0.2456279248,
0.7683417201,
0.3293837905,
-0.4960006475,
-0.2961478829,
-1.1810913086,
1.1852048635,
-0.5774877071,
0.7284451723,
0.1237384677,
0.5701577663,
0.2802447081,
-0.9837386608,
-0.6275690198,
-0.1909720749,
-0.3880698979,
0.2019896954,
-0.1823852211,
0.2203585058,
0.6811629534,
0.4064311385,
-0.3925668001,
-0.1260872185,
-0.6072379947,
-0.2335722893,
0.3639691472,
0.2017202675,
0.0317458995,
-0.2467924058,
-0.0108884554,
0.0289540477,
-0.3976467252,
-0.2786473036,
0.1566344947,
-0.1083115116,
-0.2451035678,
0.6836599112,
-0.1028637365,
0.4975005984,
0.2113515884,
-0.0981716439,
0.0477148965,
-0.1928352118,
-0.1853944361,
-0.1959975064,
0.3548051715,
0.0891107842,
0.9026967883,
-0.5558698773,
-0.2680572271,
0.3648210168,
0.2529034913,
-0.9662896991,
0.067718558,
0.0114230337,
-0.4980612397,
-0.1351841539,
0.0086174337,
-0.6169812679,
0.3281745911,
-0.45901829,
0.1719036698,
-0.1562282294,
-0.1019992679,
0.2646418512,
-0.1664549261,
0.6630424857,
-0.176901713,
-0.8806164861,
0.7372222543,
0.8180702329,
0.6980654001,
0.2071231753,
-0.0371783748,
-0.7584559917,
0.0574192256,
-0.1967820227,
0.8097423911,
-0.631645143,
-0.3085714579,
0.2229992449,
0.099457331,
-0.0619185269,
-0.3644171655,
0.566233933,
-0.8725031018,
0.0574054457,
0.1879156828,
-0.3760113418,
0.0739233047,
0.1280280501,
-0.6262690425,
0.7487200499,
0.3035605252,
-0.2206154764,
0.484174192,
-0.6257445812,
-0.6707610488,
0.1713615954,
-0.1357244402,
-0.3098207414,
0.3692041934,
-0.0059385193,
0.6151691079,
-0.2535652518,
0.3407481313,
-0.1820268035,
-0.2748960257,
0.5871013999,
-0.2573809624,
0.7824353576,
0.516526401,
-0.5764873028,
-0.0524929538,
-0.555527389,
0.1259488761,
0.0318516046,
0.0410841331,
0.0501718521,
0.1818589866,
0.1021921188,
0.2851480246,
0.1165354699,
-0.7046687603,
0.3870512843,
-0.4647473395,
0.7090708613,
0.7675155401,
-0.0986799225,
0.4596557021,
-0.2085624784,
0.7269911766,
-0.1592153311,
0.3377622962,
-0.138657406,
-0.4463765919,
-0.920058012,
-0.0747857764,
0.4258674681,
0.5463443995,
-0.8399462104,
0.3725608289,
-0.5954479575,
-0.5693431497,
-0.0772991627,
-0.1401281059,
0.2507067323,
0.3186371624,
0.3221147358,
-0.1340727359,
-0.6137796044,
-0.9358378649,
-0.2662014067,
0.0383698121,
-0.2152466327,
0.306628108,
0.5330035686,
-0.0070367279,
0.9376604557,
-0.9178934693,
-0.1919517815,
-0.404619664,
0.0453719124,
0.3723791838,
0.4119901955,
0.5748035908,
-0.7771416903,
-0.6732571125,
-0.34735322,
-0.5141050816,
-0.2570936978,
0.0887774006,
0.1935564429,
0.2365248501,
0.5829918385,
-0.8551414609,
0.4394978583,
0.3853651285,
-0.4734534025,
0.5516033769,
0.2639618516,
0.4003925323,
-0.6966375113,
0.0616698749,
-0.2588149011,
-0.4502995312,
-0.7572646141,
0.2395976186,
0.0430640504,
-0.2873486876,
-0.680773139,
0.6304046512,
-0.3688577414,
-0.3021163344,
0.0018243198,
-0.3070725501,
-0.2757817507,
0.8764142394,
0.1464916617,
0.391048044,
0.3778445125,
-0.7048341632,
0.1483393908,
-0.1111638546,
-0.4539458752,
0.468906343,
-0.9395261407,
0.2929442227,
0.148299247,
0.3564860821,
-0.6522268057,
-0.0127331922,
0.1911174208,
-0.6471893191,
0.4839861691,
-0.562481463,
-0.8220827579,
-0.4684788883,
-0.2668405473,
0.782088995,
0.883916378,
-0.337449491,
0.7818690538,
0.3100923896,
0.0921648592,
-0.641027391,
-1.0597709417,
-0.2203421593,
0.0299899615,
-0.6369762421,
0.5142709017,
-0.1407072842,
-0.3311878741,
0.1319961548,
-0.0103160078,
-0.0050434317,
-0.2357041538,
0.1111308113,
0.1887100339,
-0.2855939865,
-0.1093774587,
0.0894466266,
-0.5628510714,
0.0510237664,
-0.5556198359,
0.8748640418,
-0.1467031389,
-0.4058451056,
0.1309397519,
0.4698738754,
0.4960043728,
-0.0494394861,
0.5730749965,
0.7508363128,
-0.6809456348,
-0.2923284769,
-0.6462487578,
-0.3866696656,
-0.574618876,
-0.071099624,
-0.4290896356,
-1.1245592833,
0.5629819632,
0.5635886192,
0.3477926552,
0.8795393705,
0.6563639045,
0.2227556258,
1.2181119919,
0.6386806965,
0.3144567013,
0.4788568318,
-0.3716002703,
0.2774840295,
-0.4548166096,
-0.3600012064,
-0.6499415636,
-0.5289766192,
-0.9319249988,
-0.4229137301,
0.2169353217,
-0.444860369,
-0.3706018627,
0.6721862555,
-0.7404178977,
0.6102083325,
0.4512971044,
-0.0781039372,
0.2704283297,
-0.0575061925,
0.1917861998,
-0.477861017,
-0.6736438274,
-0.0075806421,
0.8247451782,
0.1082112566,
0.6376000643,
0.1348955184,
0.3362368345,
0.5550637841,
0.509565115,
-1.1862882376,
0.7767456174,
-0.3354510665,
-0.7515074015,
0.1582894474,
-0.5267605782,
-0.9482825994,
-0.3661426902,
-0.008769311,
-0.706066072,
0.2944808304,
0.0326727368,
-0.1075276211,
0.3636118174,
-0.8627363443,
0.6739698648,
0.0211326089,
0.1014459059,
-0.4035148621,
-0.62926507,
0.3226715624,
0.3596666455,
-0.2139872164,
-0.010313062,
-0.3423484266,
0.8208220005,
-0.5170263648,
0.7780183554,
-0.1053674966,
0.201859802,
0.7471193671,
0.3627013266,
0.3824451566,
-0.1696486026,
0.3015027642,
0.124112986,
0.0662762597,
-0.6490698457,
-0.6976101398,
0.7136257887,
-0.5087782145,
-0.2392435521,
-0.7680348158,
-0.4242070317,
0.0008929557,
0.2031731158,
0.2910248041,
0.8695821166,
0.0989402831,
0.1796374917,
0.669231236,
-0.1848636866,
0.6588876843,
0.8481509089,
0.0235688556,
-0.2226923108,
0.8651137948,
0.4552918077,
0.2282805592,
0.9254639149,
0.0685363635,
-0.5553604364,
-0.0462520346,
-0.2124625295,
0.3003939688,
-0.6418907046,
-0.467395246,
-0.9373733401,
-0.5673666596,
-0.7382391691,
-0.4306446612,
-0.2422721684,
-0.751775682,
0.106256038,
0.0739454702,
0.578532517,
0.5734119415,
-0.1868160218,
0.1820181161,
-0.9911209345,
0.7069557309,
0.5015513301,
0.8331634402,
0.1054015383,
-0.5853116512,
-0.1753507257,
-0.4537846744,
-0.4538300931,
-0.8488886356,
0.4319654405,
0.0702818185,
0.2603497803,
0.2064377367,
0.0555415861,
0.4313756824,
-0.638017714,
0.5821303129,
0.07195618,
-1.2221144438,
0.0876511633,
-0.1414262056,
0.6411120892,
0.3252896369,
0.1815503389,
-0.701233685,
-0.3880277276,
-1.0226647854,
-0.7065761685,
0.600664258,
0.4397993386,
0.2313611954,
-0.1843585074,
-0.0000293049,
-0.0646523684,
0.1995114088,
-0.7317217588,
-0.3928247094,
-0.1080931798,
-0.2526096106,
-0.0339052454,
-0.5631228685,
0.3419178724,
-0.1084068567,
0.4131580293,
0.0767378658,
0.8066815138,
0.0128008658,
-0.3460682034,
0.1104111448,
0.5727995038,
0.5557284951,
0.582485199,
-0.1548372805,
0.3522818983,
0.1783754081,
-0.5187289715,
0.0381578133,
0.2661557794,
-0.2747398913,
0.1388409734,
0.3754108548,
0.0432940349,
0.4242196679,
-0.7495859265,
0.3982876837,
0.1829046309,
-0.0972943157,
-0.6165103912,
-0.0723748878,
0.0230624881,
0.2477032989,
0.4156337678,
0.1149402335,
0.465890944,
-0.5033313036,
0.4386921525,
0.247957319,
-0.6973497272,
-0.3084278107,
0.6901510954,
0.1408947259,
-0.5673263669,
0.7102609873,
-0.3595304191,
-0.823482275,
0.9448440075,
0.4476923048,
1.2414114475,
-0.1299787462,
-0.0010267028,
0.4054775834,
0.4475671053,
0.1875591427,
0.1361136436,
-0.5377486348,
-0.5122019053,
-1.0759065151,
-0.4916374087,
-0.3446348906,
0.0162416976,
-0.617475152,
0.3638917208,
-0.3456121683,
-0.0522863381,
0.1147256196,
-0.0988413692,
-0.9683201313,
-0.0770918876,
-0.0193121266,
0.7164923549,
-0.6284911633,
0.4802027643,
0.2128762603,
-0.0604609251,
-0.4771301746,
-0.2466479391,
-0.2699307501,
-0.8779496551,
0.4280663431,
0.3555555642,
-0.3606989384,
-0.1257954687,
-0.869848907,
-0.4723781645,
0.7959421277,
0.1814735979,
-0.5226041675,
0.2390783578,
0.0855821744,
0.6816469431,
-0.0460256264,
0.378407836,
0.7509011626,
0.5594249368,
-0.0210296437,
-0.6909899116,
0.0875259116,
-0.4465816319,
-0.608184576,
0.7847049832,
-0.5625668168,
0.4785091281,
-0.1961046755,
-0.6196937561,
0.1204699576,
0.8258579969,
-0.0999227464,
0.4817003608,
0.7167672515,
0.4790773094,
-0.1649776548,
-0.1834931523,
1.1159578562,
-0.3708086908,
0.449562341,
0.9655560255,
0.1850273013,
0.1829250306,
0.1411325485,
-0.3287357688,
0.397252053,
0.1614604592,
-0.1790631115,
0.1088685095,
0.0377325974,
-0.0911298096,
-0.4472525716,
-0.2912206948,
-0.3033912182,
0.271589756,
0.3590590656,
-0.4642903209,
-0.0203163661,
-0.4098116755,
0.146141246,
-0.0024282266,
-0.2971473336,
0.4116274714,
0.3502270877,
-0.7946655154,
0.370863229,
0.0741407052,
0.8527624607,
-0.6277804971,
-0.1019834876,
-0.0325778462,
0.1970278025,
-0.2642326653,
-1.0658097267,
0.5709045529,
0.1899539828,
-0.3030462563,
-0.5265230536,
0.9036971927,
-0.3363531828,
-0.790401876,
0.1256225556,
0.3855690658,
0.1731604636,
0.166994065,
-0.4505150616,
-0.3547050655,
-0.1678796411,
-0.2741125524,
0.123234354,
0.1214815304,
0.1182325482,
0.792881906,
0.382884562,
-0.0107813934,
0.1169519573,
0.3481184244,
0.6360832453,
-0.8169263005,
-0.4813936055,
-0.8070931435,
0.2218179405,
0.1503419578,
-0.3028892577,
0.4166964889,
0.6458156109,
0.6325039268,
-0.388061583,
0.3008583188,
-0.4510198534,
0.4388700128,
-0.437117666,
0.3374574482,
-0.498629868,
0.0661566854,
-0.2772301733,
-1.1507233381,
-0.4507133961,
0.2443241626,
-0.3343761563,
0.230888024,
0.6152445078,
0.7118926644,
-0.3964588344,
-0.1425248832,
0.2599183619,
0.2051815093,
0.3092480302,
0.9091897607,
0.8624696136,
-0.3627144992,
0.914226532,
-0.5090921521,
-0.0453645028,
-0.0174011197,
-0.8751449585,
-0.7262713909,
-0.67153126,
-0.2329132855,
-0.5754790902,
-0.3828208745,
0.5100938082,
0.7444117069,
-0.7916802764,
-0.090043813,
0.1380851418,
0.4263877273,
-0.3043235838,
-0.3775415719,
0.3167588115,
-0.0052114641,
-0.9384238124,
0.0102456193,
0.28522861,
0.1000055298,
-0.3375136554,
-0.0482982099,
0.2082767189,
0.264721334,
0.9161085486,
0.6364225149,
-0.3882451355,
-0.4630834758,
0.3643240333,
0.0040913527,
-0.0260050707,
1.5428780317,
-0.9934615493,
0.2143475711,
0.9414971471,
0.2486370504,
1.0271786451,
-0.344833374,
0.5426552296,
-0.5914180279,
0.3448848128,
0.7470384836,
0.3526772559,
0.1130543426,
-0.0681025758,
0.662661314,
0.3319858611,
-0.5767430067,
-0.7852304578,
0.753723681,
-1.3587341309,
-0.0238836948,
1.1627434492,
0.1980959475,
0.0642430335,
-0.3563296199,
0.2950575054,
0.3019958735,
-0.4603790939,
0.6202949882,
0.3349635601,
-0.0133052291,
-0.131163165,
-0.4179169834,
0.2764902115,
0.3626272678,
-0.4404971898,
-0.4267625213,
0.2016030401,
0.0709156319,
0.4043502212,
0.6180599928,
-0.2333678603,
0.321321547,
-0.0002557995,
-0.1459742934,
0.0395771004,
-0.452911973,
0.1093165725,
0.1706728041,
-0.3537133336,
-0.1033147722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08674v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08674v1
|
Effects of Different Prompts on the Quality of GPT-4 Responses to Dementia Care Questions
| 2024-04-05T19:24:57 | 2024-04-05T19:24:57 |
Zhuochun Li, Bo Xie, Robin Hilsabeck, Alyssa Aguirre, Ning Zou, Zhimeng Luo, Daqing He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Evidence suggests that different prompts lead large language models (LLMs) to
generate responses with varying quality. Yet, little is known about prompts'
effects on response quality in healthcare domains. In this exploratory study,
we address this gap, focusing on a specific healthcare domain: dementia
caregiving. We first developed an innovative prompt template with three
components: (1) system prompts (SPs) featuring 4 different roles; (2) an
initialization prompt; and (3) task prompts (TPs) specifying different levels
of details, totaling 12 prompt combinations. Next, we selected 3 social media
posts containing complicated, real-world questions about dementia caregivers'
challenges in 3 areas: memory loss and confusion, aggression, and driving. We
then entered these posts into GPT-4, with our 12 prompts, to generate 12
responses per post, totaling 36 responses. We compared the word count of the 36
responses to explore potential differences in response length. Two experienced
dementia care clinicians on our team assessed the response quality using a
rating scale with 5 quality indicators: factual, interpretation, application,
synthesis, and comprehensiveness (scoring range: 0-5; higher scores indicate
higher quality).
|
[
-0.476892978,
-0.8091890216,
1.1685775518,
0.1749435365,
-0.3394063413,
-0.4368390441,
0.0525342226,
-0.5731104612,
0.2847617567,
0.1314375997,
-0.8680999875,
-0.2818626165,
-0.7162174582,
0.4447684288,
0.1508702487,
1.2841815948,
-0.122190766,
0.09575589,
-0.016312696,
-0.1686455309,
-0.9106166363,
-0.4395630658,
-0.989683032,
-0.1120629087,
0.7223323584,
0.2121694386,
0.6147113442,
0.1593092233,
0.4909698069,
0.2233798206,
-0.0587732792,
0.2162997127,
-0.234230265,
0.2688789368,
0.0435340703,
-0.2093655616,
-0.6952893734,
0.3058448434,
0.0591869988,
0.3778454959,
-0.021905452,
0.2266877443,
0.2347279936,
0.4065025449,
-0.3913706243,
0.0808182061,
-0.1063671485,
0.0270317961,
0.0468779057,
-0.4674368799,
-0.0972883254,
-0.5790414214,
0.4012124538,
-0.7671073079,
0.4119490683,
-0.3035271466,
1.0129998922,
0.1445839256,
-0.4092089832,
-0.6961638927,
-0.5392332673,
0.3168721497,
-0.9094923735,
-0.0028728428,
0.5395154953,
0.2413269132,
0.0811656117,
-0.5012488961,
-0.3036046624,
-0.0635887161,
-0.0831509456,
0.3673172891,
-0.3875794113,
0.0778177083,
0.4065478444,
0.1800514013,
-0.7610332966,
0.1205792055,
-0.269780159,
-0.4759824276,
0.1821354777,
0.4575055242,
0.4369232357,
-0.10295894,
-0.1427755505,
0.1098190248,
-0.3828157783,
0.4402502775,
0.3831828237,
0.1085904092,
-0.0268844943,
0.5307579637,
-0.0766685456,
0.5613313317,
0.2744699717,
-0.2141636908,
0.0160772298,
-0.5388338566,
0.0794198141,
-0.015039607,
0.5604833364,
0.9494147897,
0.0449652001,
0.0424215235,
-0.1873570532,
0.3635105789,
0.2131742388,
-0.6824057102,
-0.3869777024,
0.4193329215,
-0.6238993406,
0.2758719921,
0.186672315,
-0.5301331878,
-0.1393955648,
-0.1488009244,
0.3151717484,
-0.5792182088,
-0.1071106046,
0.3814016879,
-0.3105890453,
0.3683987856,
0.6077702045,
-0.6872710586,
0.3028525412,
0.4839439988,
0.6678298116,
-0.5972541571,
-0.091592215,
-1.114149332,
-0.0939169824,
-0.1638460606,
0.9479121566,
-0.3638215959,
-0.5935897827,
0.0489145257,
0.0530432612,
0.0963741317,
-0.5322234035,
0.7010028362,
-0.6718233824,
0.6636759639,
-0.90033108,
-0.3383306861,
0.0687585995,
0.3389798403,
-0.6705082655,
0.7634044886,
0.3017715812,
-0.6945501566,
0.5917364359,
-0.4276135266,
-0.3757620752,
0.2918045819,
-0.2212795019,
0.1012905613,
0.3167317808,
0.4383833706,
0.3640247285,
-0.2014725059,
0.0057750954,
-0.02188446,
-0.2528927624,
0.4527795613,
-0.5560436845,
0.4625890553,
-0.0447941758,
-0.2588583529,
0.1125102118,
-0.3758674264,
0.119741492,
-0.0857850686,
-0.4816517234,
-0.3586781919,
-0.5698013306,
-0.3909951746,
0.6702818274,
0.2017836422,
-0.6271736026,
0.0139134824,
-0.0681352317,
0.4500376284,
0.8037052751,
0.529067874,
0.099247627,
-0.6102759242,
0.7479936481,
0.1072691754,
0.4403939545,
-0.1967749298,
-0.9114325643,
-0.0602593906,
-0.207484737,
-0.1896780431,
0.3632341623,
-0.655323863,
0.03371609,
-0.1112479568,
-0.0036891163,
-0.7321027517,
-0.3766768873,
0.5123176575,
0.5909284949,
0.5971657038,
-0.2891543508,
0.1852457672,
-0.7895180583,
-0.183088854,
-0.4216201305,
-0.1794174016,
0.5568898916,
0.2674730122,
-0.1052314043,
0.7853297591,
-0.5629430413,
-0.074386321,
-0.0365767255,
-0.0241244938,
0.0867819041,
-0.0097036818,
0.3287681937,
-0.4201308787,
-0.1497870833,
-0.5108271837,
-0.402541995,
-0.2651849985,
-0.0602774769,
-0.0253815372,
0.2726413012,
0.1918288767,
-0.9810405374,
0.2910164893,
0.6818200946,
-0.427364856,
0.870362103,
-0.4398246706,
0.5104145408,
-0.9858035445,
-0.2572695315,
-0.1535103172,
0.2839615047,
-0.5838430524,
-0.3461307585,
-0.1871793717,
0.0425991938,
-0.4209438264,
0.5670739412,
-0.3721525073,
-0.1742940992,
0.0263594408,
0.1038637683,
0.2565885186,
0.2057879865,
-0.3089734316,
0.9107424617,
0.3831319213,
-0.6337283254,
0.2309733778,
0.1934153289,
0.0555466488,
0.7813670635,
-0.9675442576,
0.2017312646,
-0.134700641,
0.249094516,
-1.4670749903,
-0.2927746475,
0.4524546862,
-0.3332616985,
-0.0472179204,
0.2472454756,
-0.2787132263,
-0.382383585,
-0.4562185407,
0.4011923671,
0.3768821061,
-0.140246287,
0.49018538,
-0.0128694465,
-0.465118289,
-0.120974049,
-0.6391126513,
-0.0064368569,
-0.3224963844,
-0.6215898395,
0.6544855237,
-0.4147685468,
-0.11955183,
0.2456999719,
-0.5800696015,
0.0804263279,
-0.2041123807,
0.1554528028,
0.2198157907,
-0.1232866496,
0.0278927907,
-0.0629460812,
-0.2602870166,
0.2980983853,
-0.1495418698,
0.7089880109,
-0.165288806,
-0.4553178549,
-0.8223795295,
0.6264420748,
0.480956018,
-0.2780926824,
0.3849872947,
0.524613142,
-0.1747293621,
0.045812808,
-0.6180627346,
-0.4036465287,
-0.5077905059,
-0.2313682884,
-0.4143233597,
-1.2865673304,
0.7896526456,
0.2221098393,
0.013498744,
0.3726029098,
0.4516537189,
-0.3153617084,
0.9010562301,
0.2316388488,
0.0662525594,
0.2735995054,
0.0916311592,
0.1305966228,
-0.8698083758,
-0.3909545243,
-0.3364665806,
-0.0580350533,
-0.7367190719,
-0.3920183182,
0.4598509073,
-0.2172847092,
-0.2432899028,
-0.0036628707,
-0.4975779355,
-0.2068018913,
0.5376502275,
0.5105611682,
0.132268995,
-0.3603219986,
0.1664011627,
-0.1446012855,
-0.7491330504,
-0.6232321858,
0.4447745085,
0.1629086137,
0.6496773958,
0.2340397388,
0.5784296989,
0.2772446275,
0.0488858595,
-0.7339185476,
0.6722974181,
-0.0035718018,
-0.2741678655,
-0.3776863813,
-0.5399189591,
-1.0676019192,
-0.2936784327,
0.181584388,
-0.3485177755,
0.0944216326,
-0.0040542204,
-0.8201781511,
-0.1694651395,
-0.4888625443,
0.6054214239,
-0.4353117049,
0.0297848824,
0.2891356051,
-0.6783394217,
-0.0119526759,
0.0994481742,
-0.0358530283,
-0.2137166411,
-0.2389058918,
0.6856182218,
-0.3481023312,
0.694290638,
-0.1741918474,
-0.2230737358,
0.3441246152,
0.1527263671,
0.4992138147,
0.2903208733,
-0.0272910465,
-0.0902227983,
-0.0148138152,
-0.3740684092,
-0.5809037089,
0.7687622905,
-0.7656241059,
-0.8518627882,
-0.3424649835,
-0.4593971968,
-0.3430044651,
-0.0118874619,
0.5638382435,
0.6520506144,
-0.1492809504,
-0.4610936046,
0.9277276993,
-0.6402359009,
0.3822989762,
0.5414722562,
0.3931697011,
-0.259131968,
0.3995015919,
0.1877037287,
0.3939218521,
0.0066383299,
0.3322294652,
-0.1343379766,
-0.3948463202,
-0.455842495,
0.541437149,
-0.63612324,
-0.146830529,
-0.6343294382,
0.1175342724,
-0.470918864,
-0.0566821694,
0.0631983578,
-0.1031007767,
-0.5236240029,
-0.3421073556,
0.5733033419,
0.6866009235,
0.2197181433,
0.0403367355,
-0.8488582373,
0.308314383,
0.5880400538,
0.4517746866,
-0.2976737916,
-0.5054978132,
0.2849494815,
-0.1548638642,
0.1606909633,
-1.0403138399,
0.0773272589,
-0.0418648571,
0.7178220153,
0.3235268593,
-0.0007524419,
0.7061908841,
-0.6047319174,
1.4371601343,
0.3202295601,
-0.4302686453,
0.5248831511,
-0.5605013967,
0.5419009328,
0.6580244899,
0.4989129305,
-0.5674374104,
-0.2479417622,
-0.4954494834,
-0.9602499008,
0.4478705227,
0.0087428093,
0.3147876263,
-0.4495066106,
0.7323978543,
0.3220946491,
-0.0572182201,
-0.1101878881,
-0.2476813942,
-0.400018245,
0.2465090603,
0.165454939,
-0.5831078291,
-0.2243076712,
0.2929339707,
0.2519173026,
0.1060416102,
0.6954736114,
0.2645097971,
0.39391011,
-0.1205714047,
0.304836452,
0.6323702335,
0.5577465296,
0.0074936501,
0.1310211569,
0.1278875768,
-0.3625817597,
0.0910158232,
0.0342082344,
0.0149821509,
0.1927802712,
0.6143379807,
0.687394917,
-0.3499209583,
-0.2067209035,
0.4339761138,
-0.3807958961,
-0.1240337864,
0.0702529326,
0.2744007409,
0.136207208,
-0.0222440697,
0.1815380752,
-0.1766794175,
0.2994696796,
-0.6066837907,
0.2856141031,
0.21950984,
-0.5177478194,
-0.4993831217,
0.5154117346,
-0.1131077856,
-0.3309694231,
0.6648256779,
-0.1651112437,
-0.1498060226,
0.3995070755,
0.4893575907,
0.6196112037,
-0.4424804449,
0.5575839281,
0.1675025374,
0.1108515039,
-0.1638271511,
0.5919416547,
0.2465267181,
-0.5779250264,
-0.3581463993,
-0.3197174668,
-0.3855006993,
0.3046139777,
-1.0217243433,
-0.3617750108,
-0.275796324,
-0.7549707294,
-0.1587221473,
-0.0677789897,
-1.079182744,
0.2138362229,
-0.2745503783,
0.8410454988,
-0.7954389453,
0.2354228944,
1.0768904686,
-0.7253177762,
-1.0739835501,
0.5205298662,
0.0888107046,
-0.5761283636,
0.5649279356,
0.2035840601,
-0.3628257215,
-0.1419541389,
-0.2226231396,
-0.7564058304,
1.123711586,
0.1406091452,
0.0877684653,
-0.2367320061,
0.1074906513,
0.7531754375,
-0.3318971395,
0.1277758479,
0.4725019932,
0.3732848465,
-0.0225231741,
-0.8184825778,
0.417496562,
-0.2360201478,
0.0945563912,
-0.288767606,
-0.5920575857,
0.91364187,
-0.0839425996,
-0.3793258369,
0.1086771637,
0.405349344,
0.6030537486,
0.365180552,
0.2778167129,
0.3828200996,
0.9035078883,
-0.285167098,
1.2231390476,
-0.2190967649,
-0.217494905,
1.0464087725,
-0.2870373428,
0.2684268355,
0.5020501018,
0.1220347732,
0.4838708341,
0.8645964265,
0.455022186,
0.6450228095,
0.1677119285,
-0.4680632651,
-0.0559444502,
-0.410060823,
-0.4026064873,
-0.018606849,
0.4438458383,
-0.1101040021,
-0.2706563175,
0.1587491781,
0.1866026372,
-0.3274132013,
-0.1478872001,
0.8346356153,
0.0760085657,
-0.8892672658,
0.3265694678,
-0.079021886,
0.6190391183,
-0.7041866183,
-0.1494309306,
-0.5343165994,
-0.3688342869,
-0.0695172399,
-1.1348644495,
0.157810241,
0.0756442845,
-0.4187583625,
-0.3821625412,
0.483612299,
-0.0130529087,
0.1887509078,
0.4068541527,
0.8499459624,
0.4242625833,
-0.0617814325,
-0.7685121894,
0.1566518098,
-0.3435283899,
-0.5394144058,
0.3248435557,
0.9970884919,
-0.3256153166,
0.4641955197,
0.6549880505,
0.2248011529,
0.0098945666,
0.1561838537,
1.1507874727,
-0.3628008962,
-0.256249249,
-0.756467104,
0.4541054666,
0.1173262894,
-0.814848423,
0.782145679,
0.1270146072,
0.6146759391,
-0.0247916169,
0.7193132639,
0.0346909128,
0.214420408,
-0.4456892014,
0.0953647494,
-0.2187793553,
0.3066450953,
-0.2414099276,
-0.6698154807,
-0.2348495275,
0.3562244773,
-0.5602207184,
0.4593573213,
0.8714245558,
0.8366461396,
0.1942605823,
-0.1564188451,
0.1163460538,
0.0419299453,
0.5945266485,
0.5626468062,
0.8271478415,
0.0626721829,
0.4083406031,
0.184175089,
-0.1563570201,
-0.2153834254,
-0.7014481425,
-0.6476154923,
-0.5408190489,
-0.1121084467,
-0.5865671039,
0.3928261399,
0.7449592948,
0.2362197042,
-0.5761525035,
0.3045742214,
0.3029665351,
-0.5497266054,
-0.3690803945,
-0.2445403934,
0.848739326,
-0.2448192686,
-0.1482931376,
0.1967916787,
0.4047418833,
-0.028761236,
-0.0950636789,
-0.0820638239,
0.1913256794,
-0.0430872664,
0.7055438757,
0.0165318418,
-0.7917532921,
-0.6343722939,
0.5680490732,
-0.5942852497,
0.0777163357,
0.7305135131,
-0.4783333242,
0.1812763363,
0.5061780214,
0.5339983106,
0.382527411,
0.3698831201,
0.4216179848,
-0.3596125543,
-0.5539516807,
0.4142743051,
0.2151742131,
0.3672446907,
-0.6615310311,
0.1475134641,
0.1717003733,
-0.6370613575,
-0.1512220353,
0.3793170452,
-1.1679524183,
-0.3288390338,
1.4847638607,
-0.3542694747,
0.0652753562,
-0.3264583051,
-0.4957767129,
0.2160502821,
-0.8366263509,
0.7662084103,
0.8891052008,
-0.8118594885,
-0.1886998564,
-0.9231642485,
0.7035630345,
0.2483801842,
-0.8284037709,
-0.0840055794,
0.9151322842,
0.428707689,
-0.1492869407,
1.1155217886,
-0.2223915756,
0.5531956553,
-0.4584804773,
-0.3486898243,
-0.1905719191,
-0.2404309213,
-0.5145632029,
0.2771182656,
0.0183537304,
-0.0911076516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04361v1
|
Deciphering Political Entity Sentiment in News with Large Language Models: Zero-Shot and Few-Shot Strategies
| 2024-04-05T19:14:38 | 2024-04-05T19:14:38 |
Alapan Kuila, Sudeshna Sarkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentiment analysis plays a pivotal role in understanding public opinion,
particularly in the political domain where the portrayal of entities in news
articles influences public perception. In this paper, we investigate the
effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) in predicting entity-specific
sentiment from political news articles. Leveraging zero-shot and few-shot
strategies, we explore the capability of LLMs to discern sentiment towards
political entities in news content. Employing a chain-of-thought (COT) approach
augmented with rationale in few-shot in-context learning, we assess whether
this method enhances sentiment prediction accuracy. Our evaluation on
sentiment-labeled datasets demonstrates that LLMs, outperform fine-tuned BERT
models in capturing entity-specific sentiment. We find that learning in-context
significantly improves model performance, while the self-consistency mechanism
enhances consistency in sentiment prediction. Despite the promising results, we
observe inconsistencies in the effectiveness of the COT prompting method.
Overall, our findings underscore the potential of LLMs in entity-centric
sentiment analysis within the political news domain and highlight the
importance of suitable prompting strategies and model architectures.
|
[
-0.5228279829,
-0.9137558937,
0.9439163804,
0.2011785805,
-0.7291845083,
0.1408711523,
-0.5090420246,
-0.1370904893,
0.4395448864,
0.520249486,
-0.4022346735,
-0.8232132196,
-0.6402531266,
0.1904365867,
-0.3654822409,
1.1950068474,
0.1106505021,
0.3137248456,
0.0446266569,
-0.156227231,
-0.2110668421,
-0.5793346167,
-0.348097384,
-0.3967731297,
0.7843250632,
0.3456997275,
0.5243133307,
0.3472720087,
0.233033523,
0.0534627773,
-0.1634965688,
0.066284284,
-0.5825710893,
0.0431459025,
-0.2703898251,
-0.5825830698,
-0.127377972,
0.1341828853,
0.5920154452,
0.4225179851,
-0.0190949664,
-0.0249649417,
0.0203008093,
0.5895160437,
-0.7524629235,
0.1792244464,
-1.135862112,
-0.0373601057,
-0.2618331909,
-0.1245002896,
-0.5920048952,
0.0288819559,
0.166211307,
-0.0762621239,
-0.0236080382,
-0.041986268,
0.7431041002,
-0.0330549218,
-0.6375182271,
-0.2880218327,
-0.552295208,
0.9769470692,
-0.7307657599,
0.3965385556,
-0.0326678045,
-0.1119012311,
-0.1597386748,
-0.1316460371,
-0.9129990339,
-0.1264807135,
0.2399427593,
0.1628343761,
-0.0711565241,
-0.0066829943,
-0.064128235,
0.0900571346,
-0.1953792274,
0.0609063543,
-0.1189221665,
0.2030345052,
0.4381317794,
-0.0544507578,
-0.0342627615,
-0.9457271099,
-0.8796727657,
0.1707182825,
-0.9828845263,
-0.0865529329,
0.427292943,
0.7327945828,
-0.2288084775,
0.5686425567,
-0.0327366963,
0.6192042828,
0.151437059,
-0.155778721,
0.0271867942,
-0.0141272368,
-0.4618935883,
0.131017074,
0.8826381564,
0.2236291915,
0.1820262969,
0.021693226,
-0.4443292618,
0.2042255849,
0.2819215655,
-0.5031584501,
0.1039326712,
0.2468031347,
-0.535271585,
-0.5891341567,
0.1000231802,
-1.0832160711,
-0.6207783818,
-0.4866054356,
0.1138200313,
-0.3123636246,
-0.3699713349,
-0.0895877481,
0.0120080542,
0.4434831142,
0.5597192645,
-0.5447368026,
0.0572382957,
0.9182304144,
0.9441952109,
-0.4311831594,
-0.0679291561,
-0.4999744892,
-0.0113392007,
-0.6647683382,
1.0832493305,
-0.7459211946,
-0.2855066061,
0.0699026436,
-0.2408130616,
0.103646785,
-0.376580596,
0.3743835688,
-0.70000875,
0.0209433474,
-0.4970038831,
-0.8279551864,
-0.0535496548,
0.6439180374,
-0.6333343983,
0.700226903,
-0.0274561476,
-0.8058180809,
0.5233757496,
-0.4623434842,
-0.3407540917,
-0.2703694403,
-0.4421858788,
-0.3519661725,
0.5889594555,
0.3127163351,
0.7679604888,
-0.1376406699,
0.3327797949,
-0.5196298957,
-0.0696941912,
0.2687081695,
-0.30473423,
0.5280269384,
0.0181117225,
-0.3243976533,
-0.02441765,
-0.4975684285,
-0.2647421956,
0.0301290676,
-0.2003100663,
-0.3768332005,
0.0527063981,
-0.1060928553,
0.2859219015,
-0.0611794777,
-0.5918832421,
0.3533297479,
-0.4432984889,
0.2147994936,
0.8912470341,
0.430732578,
0.7817077637,
0.1313296109,
0.411388725,
0.4260006547,
-0.225254029,
-0.0823642537,
-0.3133464754,
-0.4042064846,
-0.2913794816,
0.3537315726,
0.4104490578,
-0.8083957434,
0.1812632382,
-0.2376030385,
-0.266787678,
-0.410446763,
0.0941531137,
-0.00569676,
0.4840032756,
0.2929986119,
0.0056727408,
-0.5448395014,
-0.6214504242,
-0.573585391,
-0.4308769107,
0.3283909261,
0.1681257933,
0.6678525805,
-0.0463591367,
0.8583267331,
-0.1824574471,
-0.2296060324,
-0.3343882561,
0.3287025988,
0.1865479201,
-0.1414490044,
0.4582716525,
-0.6581668258,
-0.3001433313,
-0.0825652927,
-0.5721632242,
0.3090440631,
-0.1945015788,
-0.1263208836,
0.6711866856,
0.2420540154,
-0.7930576205,
0.3101601899,
0.5735846758,
-0.0419612341,
0.3717115819,
0.5369604826,
0.1093898267,
-1.0754238367,
-0.3051635921,
0.3213017583,
-0.4219496548,
-0.5661535263,
-0.0563913919,
-0.04426926,
0.1746660024,
-0.8762728572,
0.5328826904,
-0.3807349801,
0.0100738304,
-0.5203016996,
0.4387401044,
-0.0537572429,
0.2553085685,
0.304908663,
0.4889656603,
0.6057398319,
-0.2665646076,
0.2682060301,
-0.0690174401,
-0.5827533007,
0.6952123046,
-0.4026441872,
0.2664742172,
-0.4847272038,
0.4468259513,
-0.9817410111,
-0.133929044,
0.1682125032,
-0.3261772692,
0.4031563699,
-0.3420019448,
-0.6429600716,
0.0105100032,
-0.4157730639,
-0.0531774797,
0.2279983908,
-0.525839746,
0.5108880401,
0.4636760354,
0.2679864168,
-0.7770104408,
-0.6428923011,
0.1305976659,
-0.3171363771,
-0.109756045,
0.0850788504,
0.5312737823,
-0.3919028342,
0.1849467456,
-0.1479614079,
0.1963328868,
-0.2289223522,
0.0591887906,
0.4459825158,
-0.2682614625,
0.5091122985,
-0.1905959398,
0.1117942259,
0.0748571903,
-0.3393211663,
0.6351333857,
-0.2489263862,
-0.09341833,
-0.3771041632,
0.1656296402,
0.6729397774,
-0.2051609606,
1.1198055744,
0.4514371157,
-0.4163406193,
-0.3412623703,
-0.5215197802,
-0.205510363,
-0.3023124635,
0.264031291,
-0.2077299356,
-0.7193530202,
0.4599883258,
-0.2909663022,
-0.2413542569,
0.4641269445,
0.8324768543,
-0.1760685593,
0.90841645,
0.3840831816,
-0.7393498421,
0.4458191097,
-0.354410857,
0.4005824625,
-0.783636868,
-0.0684544742,
-0.4309590757,
-0.1963536739,
-0.6325578094,
-0.2890275717,
0.2372646779,
0.0422597043,
-0.158688277,
-0.0457581282,
-0.2797017694,
0.5271545053,
0.2043695599,
0.0676473901,
0.0721325949,
0.2853568494,
0.1017620489,
0.0390437655,
-0.4491599202,
-0.7585428357,
0.9022588134,
0.4930236042,
0.8591278791,
-0.1509083211,
0.9657172561,
0.1631637961,
0.3523156345,
-1.1338522434,
0.3562385142,
-0.1533180624,
-0.5083799362,
-0.3038541675,
-0.4373764694,
-0.6483209729,
0.271220535,
-0.3444812596,
-0.6573445201,
0.2943889201,
-0.2128723562,
-0.2798438966,
0.6627069116,
-0.1848207265,
0.6327980757,
-0.0782632157,
-0.1282098591,
-0.296924144,
-0.4543699026,
0.3734150231,
0.0610042699,
0.2293958515,
-0.4385294318,
-0.347217232,
0.421602875,
-0.0070828958,
0.9469916224,
-0.3154958189,
-0.2966550291,
0.3763994575,
-0.070835568,
0.5900623798,
0.2564992905,
-0.4130346179,
0.3307090104,
-0.2732374966,
-0.3300327957,
-0.4874365032,
0.9969687462,
-0.94599998,
-0.6824945211,
-0.3366770744,
-0.3699301183,
-0.1421312988,
-0.0333635285,
0.4226019382,
0.3212721348,
-0.3532320857,
0.4015889764,
0.6954697371,
0.0891688913,
0.3963330984,
0.3052717149,
-0.2045929134,
-0.3662531078,
0.6069486141,
0.3316985071,
0.1607612222,
0.4838691056,
0.1612006724,
-0.3670518994,
-0.208867386,
-0.6297775507,
0.1536667794,
-0.7217537165,
-0.6576961279,
-0.6025177836,
0.0970546454,
-0.0918776765,
-0.1473424882,
-0.5451647043,
-0.2301926762,
-0.4926673472,
-0.1874642223,
0.2903240621,
0.7570000887,
0.3341853023,
0.3590444624,
-0.5206903815,
0.336202085,
0.0274171494,
0.3856866956,
-0.184135735,
-0.3661976755,
0.0105474498,
0.1453405917,
-0.3848654032,
-1.5491482019,
0.359284848,
-0.0203067381,
0.2930658758,
0.5033180118,
0.1915394962,
0.4655143619,
-0.5102418661,
1.0677126646,
0.1419738978,
-1.1223977804,
0.7403191924,
-0.3572094142,
0.0969251394,
0.4895066619,
0.4978852868,
-0.1811728925,
-0.7074137926,
-0.4358046055,
-0.5864268541,
0.5000581145,
-0.0771369785,
0.5004119873,
-0.562435329,
0.4457331598,
0.0448042639,
0.3540324271,
-0.8498151898,
-0.2034135014,
-0.1831657588,
-0.2144405693,
0.0119017372,
-0.2761007845,
-0.1103156805,
0.0228940919,
0.7031219006,
-0.2939878702,
0.1547161788,
0.3017814159,
-0.0668021515,
-0.4088861644,
0.5707926154,
0.5888367295,
0.6775325537,
0.0330203474,
0.1127190441,
0.2619874775,
0.1147477329,
0.1657157391,
-0.4290758371,
-0.1718337089,
0.4481579661,
0.2625991404,
0.9123748541,
0.2013639212,
-0.1559314281,
0.890329659,
0.1902700067,
-0.0182591844,
-0.3088530898,
-0.362419486,
0.1853623688,
0.3141022921,
0.4311353266,
0.0679802373,
0.0615113862,
-1.0304049253,
-0.0680583045,
0.8298226595,
-0.396227926,
-0.3397809863,
0.3933233023,
0.0757474229,
0.0883545503,
0.3942240179,
-0.2529476881,
-0.6408861279,
0.506973505,
0.4933313727,
0.8801785111,
-0.1404263973,
0.4310978055,
0.1181577072,
0.3176768422,
-0.1600403339,
0.2566188574,
0.2245670557,
-0.8421110511,
-0.5429121256,
-0.5844070315,
-0.4370424449,
0.1990001053,
-0.705173552,
0.6028912067,
-0.6104685664,
-0.4514395893,
0.0818315968,
0.3101606667,
-0.6796009541,
0.1945144236,
0.5358334184,
0.9004206657,
-0.846552968,
0.8495186567,
0.7511113882,
-0.3609701395,
-0.7922302485,
0.3897066414,
0.2291695327,
-0.6024787426,
0.4448805451,
0.1312872469,
-0.1229212135,
-0.1927629262,
-0.9172050953,
-0.4908181429,
0.7009040117,
0.5300018787,
-0.7141044736,
-0.0020581193,
-0.0167027321,
0.4732404053,
-0.8771952987,
-0.0218654815,
0.4147394598,
0.3796283305,
-0.033933159,
-0.4438531101,
0.0087509453,
0.3716621995,
0.1022007093,
0.4648319781,
-0.7046832442,
0.8270224929,
-0.1053650603,
-0.1770444214,
-0.2628228962,
0.9144634008,
0.2925108075,
0.3513974547,
0.6772514582,
0.3193156421,
0.7284865379,
0.0133694867,
1.0772657394,
-0.5833740234,
0.4896655977,
0.925188005,
-0.4997808039,
1.3532090187,
0.5796080828,
0.1327090114,
1.0180069208,
0.3261372745,
0.0780735016,
0.5490498543,
0.1385190636,
-0.4941296279,
-0.2936757207,
-0.175001815,
-0.0371850915,
0.7222291231,
0.4058763385,
-0.4692866206,
-0.2768887579,
0.1809671968,
0.1343856901,
0.0587770194,
-0.564545393,
0.9269624352,
0.3992726505,
-0.5463482738,
0.2194920033,
-0.0386372544,
0.5336586237,
-0.1808597147,
-0.0041888738,
0.0281300042,
-0.0812169313,
-0.2571770251,
-1.1414319277,
0.2008678615,
0.2043753564,
-0.3539740443,
-0.0107193617,
0.8133999705,
-0.5238707662,
-0.4404557943,
0.3915708661,
0.7305136919,
0.0238918643,
-0.2764779627,
-0.5579565167,
0.3446152508,
-0.1673303545,
-0.5701062679,
0.1941275448,
0.7121988535,
0.05775306,
0.261652559,
0.530926764,
0.3351722062,
-0.4005883336,
0.2211566567,
0.9739925861,
-0.6805598736,
-0.1996270418,
-1.2564502954,
0.331243813,
-0.0478561521,
-0.0201534554,
0.5390003324,
0.3808537424,
0.8934813738,
-0.1107348651,
0.7570326924,
0.2706947029,
0.4963179529,
-0.574608326,
0.6273671389,
-0.3999102414,
0.2370437831,
-0.2597833574,
-0.909843266,
-0.3229797482,
0.5825591683,
-0.5923400521,
-0.0643183067,
0.5195764303,
0.7214124799,
-0.0122615127,
-0.0834212601,
0.3186245561,
0.2651295066,
0.051879216,
0.2226928622,
0.9803059101,
-0.0546843298,
0.4398135543,
-0.2652169168,
0.1127404198,
-0.0525839888,
-1.0354278088,
-1.0231810808,
-0.3642116189,
-0.2601504624,
-0.4412404895,
0.0895330086,
1.2609790564,
0.6276009083,
-0.7146216035,
-0.0843217969,
-0.0586774759,
0.3208696842,
0.3169565499,
-0.3148111701,
0.3791646957,
-0.6456361413,
-0.782818675,
0.0657666549,
0.4740159512,
-0.3296510577,
-0.4151990712,
0.1038533971,
-0.2923308313,
0.543815732,
0.8325421214,
-0.0146498764,
-1.203791976,
-0.5805149674,
0.0324444808,
-0.3599300086,
0.209243983,
0.7479408979,
-0.9408473372,
0.3658376932,
0.4430025816,
0.4598519206,
0.161686942,
0.253734827,
0.4066465497,
-0.9837917089,
0.1529206038,
0.3160727322,
0.4594593644,
0.5055818558,
-0.4412561953,
0.2327551991,
0.0636003315,
-0.4354011714,
-0.6952419877,
0.1631088555,
-0.8209629059,
-0.2765612006,
1.3744449615,
-0.0410129726,
-0.5191137195,
0.2925054133,
-0.1164714172,
0.1261773109,
-0.6301724315,
0.6739435792,
0.6853239536,
-0.0012199485,
-0.5395097136,
-0.4744378626,
0.2333814651,
0.1699757278,
-0.6596769691,
-0.1652272344,
0.4461614192,
0.1655317992,
0.0351368859,
0.6426493526,
-0.0378280282,
0.0981021225,
-0.2885008752,
-0.1402225941,
0.4654577076,
-0.4065124691,
-0.494143337,
0.2119256854,
-0.1029917374,
-0.1488240212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04360v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04360v1
|
Prompt Public Large Language Models to Synthesize Data for Private On-device Applications
| 2024-04-05T19:14:14 | 2024-04-05T19:14:14 |
Shanshan Wu, Zheng Xu, Yanxiang Zhang, Yuanbo Zhang, Daniel Ramage
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Pre-training on public data is an effective method to improve the performance
for federated learning (FL) with differential privacy (DP). This paper
investigates how large language models (LLMs) trained on public data can
improve the quality of pre-training data for the on-device language models
trained with DP and FL. We carefully design LLM prompts to filter and transform
existing public data, and generate new data to resemble the real user data
distribution. The model pre-trained on our synthetic dataset achieves relative
improvement of 19.0% and 22.8% in next word prediction accuracy compared to the
baseline model pre-trained on a standard public dataset, when evaluated over
the real user data in Gboard (Google Keyboard, a production mobile keyboard
application). Furthermore, our method achieves evaluation accuracy better than
or comparable to the baseline during the DP FL fine-tuning over millions of
mobile devices, and our final model outperforms the baseline in production A/B
testing. Our experiments demonstrate the strengths of LLMs in synthesizing data
close to the private distribution even without accessing the private data, and
also suggest future research directions to further reduce the distribution gap.
|
[
-0.4013622999,
-0.3728741407,
0.7579903603,
0.1707399935,
-0.1982705295,
0.2451184094,
-0.4028347433,
-0.2939010262,
0.080952242,
0.3350702524,
-0.5072664022,
-0.8030123711,
-0.3324835002,
0.1733893305,
-0.3717838824,
0.7535227537,
-0.0364191867,
-0.0994538441,
-0.1076596454,
0.0311279222,
-0.2730522454,
-0.7825574875,
-0.1596391946,
0.0015620642,
0.4959031045,
0.4567624629,
0.6846929789,
0.6189705133,
0.270288676,
0.2946411371,
0.0086081326,
0.1662533283,
-0.5671261549,
0.1246115714,
-0.030279791,
-0.4262749851,
-0.4407043457,
0.2576874197,
0.7260329127,
0.5329755545,
-0.0390503928,
0.1725301445,
0.0168092046,
0.6388641,
-0.5891902447,
0.1710035801,
-0.698163569,
0.1343207806,
-0.3726482689,
0.0432961136,
-0.51012218,
-0.7509852648,
0.0599827953,
-0.4385255277,
0.3870546818,
0.0501687005,
0.7733896971,
0.0387007371,
-0.1933283359,
0.1462684572,
-0.8473743796,
0.5418394804,
-0.6177505851,
0.889380753,
0.5339723229,
0.2597001791,
-0.3733299375,
-0.8094854951,
-0.8009470701,
-0.4473082721,
-0.0334178843,
-0.2271313369,
-0.0309861805,
0.0670012236,
0.2118477225,
0.3488788903,
-0.4135453105,
0.4447672665,
-0.2761109173,
-0.2159035206,
0.8843584061,
0.1320270598,
0.089412652,
0.2242612988,
-0.0881343558,
-0.141244635,
-1.211468935,
-0.0845546052,
0.539712429,
0.4660416543,
-0.1486981213,
0.4133737087,
-0.4920842946,
0.8045392036,
0.1486172378,
-0.2122849673,
0.3858059347,
-0.2361111641,
-0.1564474404,
0.1545223892,
0.7851241231,
0.2532117665,
0.149072662,
-0.1892721355,
-0.5129857659,
-0.1525541842,
-0.0150278918,
-0.7966080308,
-0.2963497043,
0.1810657978,
-0.2990346849,
-0.3249623179,
0.1428857446,
-0.7893948555,
-0.7508767843,
-0.5958530307,
0.3053332567,
0.2021211088,
-0.1825430393,
0.2588362992,
0.3819458783,
-0.2533383071,
0.4145034254,
-1.0922513008,
0.2941384912,
0.6250691414,
0.9439277649,
-0.0903028473,
-0.2300856262,
-0.8003005981,
0.0898561478,
-0.2823999822,
0.579769969,
-0.4094622135,
-0.4945725799,
0.0845368579,
-0.0093687288,
-0.0706934035,
-0.5769729018,
0.3301657438,
-0.4996117353,
0.4435594976,
-0.2591496706,
-0.5033167601,
0.1863976568,
-0.0251481924,
-0.5071693063,
0.5545788407,
-0.1328739822,
-0.7331876755,
0.3571246862,
-0.7351426482,
-0.5376117229,
0.1023081392,
-0.2277052552,
-0.5012860894,
0.2768208086,
0.4747545719,
0.8698759675,
-0.2262069285,
0.3905128539,
-0.538120091,
-0.3177944124,
0.3973698318,
-0.2336723953,
0.5052903891,
0.3522895277,
-0.3113157153,
0.0849756002,
-0.8842522502,
-0.0925474539,
-0.1053692773,
-0.4427235425,
-0.2584468722,
0.0007069895,
-0.1830214262,
0.0665028021,
0.1985699087,
-0.7647792697,
0.0892405584,
-0.4300370514,
0.4798841774,
1.0007855892,
-0.1954207569,
0.5703257322,
-0.1224672422,
0.580375731,
-0.1856029332,
0.2180123329,
-0.1219902337,
-0.5072699189,
-0.2335282266,
-0.3697317839,
0.5373015404,
0.3250855803,
-0.3393627107,
0.5362102389,
-0.5548934937,
-0.4046723545,
-0.4302776158,
0.2093442678,
0.221926704,
0.6177605987,
0.0665367395,
-0.1988271922,
-0.3605244458,
-0.5185964704,
0.0112249749,
-0.1271730214,
-0.2876781821,
0.4242820442,
0.0887709036,
-0.44400841,
1.0474621058,
-0.6038507819,
-0.2816043198,
-0.1281896681,
0.0464819483,
0.1839628071,
0.2349914014,
0.2264690399,
-0.6982984543,
-0.500991106,
0.0315379426,
-0.3687274456,
-0.312866509,
0.0978507176,
0.0520416908,
0.1790459007,
0.3315591514,
-0.6149377823,
0.1267752945,
0.7819315195,
-0.23287718,
0.4908998907,
-0.3145344555,
0.0845845714,
-1.07363379,
-0.0065191295,
-0.090644531,
-0.2430442274,
-0.6122229695,
-0.1969394982,
0.2069879323,
-0.5805519223,
-0.6767507792,
0.7244260907,
-0.4900238812,
-0.2196816355,
-0.0880166292,
0.1725064218,
-0.1666535586,
0.044267416,
0.1055691168,
1.1291347742,
0.5975884795,
-0.7729418874,
0.3350936174,
0.3033308685,
-0.5463525653,
0.0312820449,
-0.6605243087,
0.2040556073,
-0.0693206936,
0.3022956848,
-1.0750604868,
-0.6088402271,
-0.0173299164,
-0.1849449575,
0.1616090536,
0.0375052206,
-0.7523201704,
-0.5198231936,
-0.2463173866,
-0.0677719936,
0.7551959157,
-0.9542247057,
0.3100855052,
0.6098915935,
-0.2208032161,
-0.3384063542,
-0.7801790237,
-0.1611589491,
-0.1988507211,
-0.8363978267,
0.3976193368,
-0.0040422888,
-0.1407912523,
-0.2707649469,
-0.0256356485,
-0.2182130963,
0.2646177113,
0.3408970237,
0.1846232265,
-0.2404215485,
0.3570716679,
0.2500003576,
-0.043118,
0.1066918746,
-0.2252070904,
0.5064647794,
0.1322996616,
-0.2177252769,
-0.7133408785,
-0.2760615349,
0.3225938082,
-0.4279968739,
0.7776092291,
0.2667888701,
-0.1913511455,
-0.2206908613,
-0.4513918757,
-0.3895071745,
-0.5923170447,
-0.0437607765,
-0.2405741662,
-0.9683712721,
0.4163546264,
-0.1403322667,
0.0157013983,
-0.2283029258,
0.5167986155,
0.1437072754,
1.0985141993,
0.4312981963,
-0.3133857548,
0.7288119197,
-0.0474931672,
0.2541592121,
-0.3726703823,
-0.1180761456,
-0.4564293325,
-0.1792643517,
-0.652780652,
-0.2634252906,
0.3182888031,
-0.0557586327,
-0.1089474335,
0.1931944638,
-0.3418564498,
0.7152156234,
0.5031588674,
0.3541936874,
0.1750658005,
0.3428479433,
-0.0625783354,
0.0760755613,
-0.3092602491,
-0.4768488407,
1.4574171305,
0.5143886209,
0.9092002511,
-0.0594899692,
1.16448915,
0.1569537967,
0.4582428932,
-0.3073445559,
0.6260489821,
-0.2497700751,
-0.4920129776,
-0.2572576106,
-0.585303545,
-0.8784145117,
0.0159793403,
-0.1800589263,
-0.7814785838,
0.2051188648,
0.3789089024,
-0.507679224,
0.0334022082,
-1.0021041632,
0.8275241852,
-0.1518347263,
-0.5171641111,
-0.0222679209,
-0.3655309975,
0.3947378397,
-0.3794730902,
0.1353445053,
-0.2263031006,
0.1114335582,
0.6753154397,
-0.4816995263,
0.740486145,
-0.4739272594,
-0.2626801431,
0.1981920898,
-0.1472180486,
0.7315467,
0.2099235952,
-0.1974877864,
0.0319938809,
-0.5555420518,
-0.0537369438,
-0.4697831869,
0.8418594003,
-0.7704039812,
-0.7592639923,
-0.0372728072,
-0.2634537816,
-0.5162327886,
0.1154995784,
0.1520541459,
0.458327949,
-0.0507965609,
0.3869786859,
0.8488192558,
-0.4337253571,
0.2258258611,
0.6510090828,
-0.3199406564,
-0.2273130864,
0.7556572556,
0.0210942272,
0.0704184994,
0.6014356017,
0.4490096569,
-1.0090985298,
-0.6870010495,
-0.4241710007,
0.3264612257,
-0.4677343369,
-0.2522717118,
-0.6909855008,
-0.0225632768,
-0.6501962543,
-0.0497747138,
-0.3748551905,
-0.3535225987,
-0.4220543802,
-0.4253172278,
0.5319734812,
0.5394656062,
-0.2155729532,
0.6601420045,
-0.9907746315,
0.3667612672,
0.3506111503,
0.5126723051,
-0.2351039946,
-0.5609707236,
-0.0839071646,
0.3210769594,
-0.3119297922,
-0.6918143034,
0.3529702425,
0.3205359578,
0.4431940019,
0.2418490201,
0.1058303937,
0.5311487913,
-0.6015776396,
0.7209243178,
0.1960809231,
-0.924713254,
0.5218966603,
-0.4561893046,
0.2219808549,
0.6368252635,
0.5752705932,
-0.2832142711,
-0.465279609,
-0.3652665615,
-0.5551033616,
0.7648135424,
0.0300275665,
0.4893407226,
0.2838174701,
0.1200745255,
0.1671565622,
0.3210691214,
-0.6340565085,
-0.2272790521,
-0.0081625925,
-0.4127106071,
-0.337236613,
-0.0566548631,
0.127609387,
-0.3082036972,
0.3892674446,
0.170739904,
0.2170119286,
-0.1111670211,
0.103589274,
-0.0175815448,
0.2483332008,
0.5511071086,
0.8192893267,
-0.1032015458,
-0.0416835025,
-0.1029081568,
-0.6679704785,
0.4659983218,
0.4995373487,
-0.2846704125,
0.0653042793,
-0.0555733219,
0.7874003649,
0.0219723061,
-0.5893298388,
0.6253096461,
-0.3000711799,
-0.0788938999,
-0.0471436009,
0.2249924392,
0.070983544,
0.0596961826,
0.2510687709,
-0.2672936022,
-0.002879445,
-0.3351915777,
0.2521197498,
0.1041979119,
0.1380597949,
-0.5338875055,
0.8860216141,
0.4892387688,
-0.3050236702,
0.5744225383,
-0.1972022951,
-0.334161967,
0.177205354,
0.4917158782,
0.7574111223,
-0.5915267467,
0.5673978329,
0.0565039553,
-0.012238591,
-0.407471776,
0.333163619,
-0.1726166755,
-0.6257073283,
-0.4150686562,
-0.7352324724,
-0.2775920033,
0.5095592141,
-0.1985601336,
0.4285336137,
-0.7331374288,
-0.165966168,
-0.1453175992,
0.0219582897,
-0.7595898509,
0.2849604189,
0.2680857778,
0.6090931296,
-0.9038282633,
1.0233604908,
0.473056376,
-0.1389558613,
-1.0482040644,
0.1175710112,
-0.1921147704,
-0.5897078514,
0.729364574,
0.2626844645,
0.1376411319,
0.1045202985,
-0.4362643957,
-0.8730908036,
0.8019051552,
0.6051410437,
-1.0744343996,
0.2067201585,
0.4177750945,
0.6899827123,
-0.2530823946,
-0.1030874625,
0.2651754022,
0.4641725421,
-0.2851878703,
-0.9741405845,
0.1946503669,
0.1989741921,
-0.0891097486,
0.2897349894,
-0.1917542368,
0.8029780984,
-0.2270301878,
-0.4164149165,
-0.140213713,
0.6536111236,
0.3281361759,
0.4812452793,
0.305270344,
0.291128546,
1.0778737068,
0.100286819,
1.0559922457,
-0.1986017227,
0.1047884822,
1.1125696898,
-0.6786597967,
0.8112596273,
0.2057373822,
-0.2048901767,
0.2653305531,
0.6210165024,
0.1871928424,
0.9025402069,
0.3306938112,
-0.5459287167,
0.110169515,
0.0887507573,
-0.5219208002,
0.2143956423,
0.1478968114,
-0.5156758428,
-0.0726900101,
0.3646631241,
-0.1368905604,
0.3260991871,
-0.3661414087,
0.633997798,
0.0137338405,
-0.4147416353,
0.8004228473,
0.2223851085,
0.5956965089,
-0.4882856607,
0.48234424,
-0.4487776458,
0.36393255,
-0.1846186072,
-0.5822745562,
-0.0020320062,
0.1968677491,
0.0618669502,
-0.412948221,
0.5505356789,
-0.4332459867,
-0.3161803186,
0.0402074531,
0.2722868323,
0.247740835,
-0.2852688432,
-0.5520330071,
0.1259967238,
0.0615561306,
-0.3083502054,
0.4344879389,
0.4349921942,
-0.0128589999,
0.5509446263,
0.7879613638,
0.1690962762,
0.4008755088,
0.2430284321,
1.0259603262,
-0.3516899645,
-0.8000977039,
-0.7087535858,
0.3232380152,
-0.0197327826,
-0.2229810804,
0.8242852092,
0.5208294392,
1.1045218706,
-0.3771449327,
0.8182968497,
0.1177575514,
0.681902647,
-0.6726192832,
0.9059742689,
-0.3415124714,
0.286798209,
0.0120175602,
-1.0520025492,
-0.234697029,
0.4481813312,
-0.7333216071,
-0.1748993844,
0.4200892448,
1.1009252071,
-0.4487966001,
0.1828786582,
0.3483882248,
0.1002005413,
0.2988113761,
0.2889490724,
0.8856941462,
-0.262586683,
0.2204995304,
-0.3952945769,
-0.12278568,
-0.1805446297,
-0.8122528195,
-0.9016865492,
-0.6359326839,
-0.202459529,
-0.0858243778,
0.2599208951,
0.9538266659,
0.9213218093,
-0.7700300217,
-0.2374271154,
-0.396307826,
0.073304221,
0.2586466968,
-0.1519659162,
0.1888306439,
-0.2126587033,
-0.6166371107,
0.6437705755,
-0.1905425638,
0.4574210644,
-0.2707847357,
-0.2305830121,
0.2177735865,
-0.2425272167,
0.5307673812,
0.2237723768,
-0.3299292028,
-0.1215065643,
-0.0599408001,
-0.0556817353,
-0.0313843712,
0.9505646825,
-0.7998121381,
0.3480754197,
0.6057180762,
0.7604482174,
0.3888327479,
0.2520341873,
0.7699304223,
-1.0313470364,
0.4243876636,
0.141520083,
0.1471615583,
0.4878543615,
-0.5883016586,
0.1807397455,
-0.0105666155,
-0.6000458002,
-1.1227799654,
0.1367161125,
-0.4179481268,
-0.0354108885,
1.2288286686,
-0.4446182251,
-0.424087584,
0.0232757367,
-0.0234278031,
-0.0322041512,
-0.7052681446,
0.9871634841,
0.4144978821,
0.1792759746,
0.0554038249,
-0.1181671992,
0.6659300327,
-0.0015066237,
-0.9880183339,
0.4479935169,
0.6936782002,
0.2425729334,
-0.0585335866,
0.8101255298,
-0.0397990905,
0.2179589421,
-0.2669928372,
-0.2502180934,
-0.3853945732,
-0.6451476216,
-0.5286801457,
-0.0108766081,
0.0945138931,
-0.3744573593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04351v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04351v1
|
Assisting humans in complex comparisons: automated information comparison at scale
| 2024-04-05T18:44:54 | 2024-04-05T18:44:54 |
Truman Yuen, Graham A. Watt, Yuri Lawryshyn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.8
|
Generative Large Language Models enable efficient analytics across knowledge
domains, rivalling human experts in information comparisons. However, the
applications of LLMs for information comparisons face scalability challenges
due to the difficulties in maintaining information across large contexts and
overcoming model token limitations. To address these challenges, we developed
the novel Abstractive Summarization \& Criteria-driven Comparison Endpoint
(ASC$^2$End) system to automate information comparison at scale. Our system
employs Semantic Text Similarity comparisons for generating evidence-supported
analyses. We utilize proven data-handling strategies such as abstractive
summarization and retrieval augmented generation to overcome token limitations
and retain relevant information during model inference. Prompts were designed
using zero-shot strategies to contextualize information for improved model
reasoning. We evaluated abstractive summarization using ROUGE scoring and
assessed the generated comparison quality using survey responses. Models
evaluated on the ASC$^2$End system show desirable results providing insights on
the expected performance of the system. ASC$^2$End is a novel system and tool
that enables accurate, automated information comparison at scale across
knowledge domains, overcoming limitations in context length and retrieval.
|
[
-0.3923942745,
-0.6461856365,
0.5515314937,
0.0963077545,
-0.2249062061,
0.2220753133,
-0.2846077979,
-0.6991924644,
0.0502457172,
0.320366025,
-0.1728739291,
-0.6394235492,
-0.5938881636,
0.3965170681,
-0.7133331299,
0.8201056719,
-0.1802505553,
0.007977563,
-0.5953106284,
-0.3441059887,
-0.0004305016,
-0.3096350729,
-1.2535352707,
-0.4759969413,
0.3137187064,
0.3916064799,
0.7390136719,
0.5710366368,
0.8511384726,
0.3848775923,
-0.1038330197,
0.4462836683,
-0.4254033864,
0.3966245949,
-0.2102659792,
-0.4348452091,
-0.6532629728,
-0.0524244383,
0.4099520445,
0.733723104,
-0.0119021246,
0.2677018344,
-0.0055333734,
0.7508050203,
-0.7808722258,
0.1852042228,
-0.4862615168,
-0.0368852913,
0.2446023226,
-0.3556929827,
-0.355494678,
-0.4482921958,
-0.0571062192,
-0.5563525558,
0.13277255,
0.2052710205,
0.7698436379,
0.3372267187,
-0.7774420977,
-0.5371166468,
-0.4212346971,
0.5301837325,
-1.002831459,
0.1377319545,
0.1216306686,
0.4739408493,
0.0458933115,
-0.6532273293,
-0.6859027743,
-0.266266644,
-0.1557076424,
0.1100317687,
-0.5136576891,
0.1598851532,
0.3339917362,
0.3033567071,
-0.6657851934,
0.2638253272,
-0.4192990065,
-0.042355869,
0.6478366852,
0.3395176232,
0.1199147329,
-0.283235997,
-0.2247815579,
-0.2382635027,
-0.8034767509,
-0.0355682708,
0.2703104317,
0.1556108743,
0.0023785981,
0.7623768449,
-0.5979965329,
0.6758391857,
-0.0467386693,
0.1094808877,
0.2019175738,
-0.2768271267,
-0.2915694714,
-0.1440413296,
0.7771132588,
1.0888015032,
0.1114077494,
-0.2840708196,
-0.4912621081,
0.1266284436,
0.1091214567,
-0.9350405931,
0.1008882597,
0.2788698077,
-0.7006317377,
-0.2698410451,
0.0746043548,
-0.4735977054,
-0.332054615,
-0.6508663893,
0.5413843393,
-0.1752185822,
0.0488554165,
-0.0841900706,
-0.3257380724,
0.2327190191,
0.5437793136,
-0.7519567013,
0.7044884562,
0.6463775635,
1.1628470421,
-0.6027182937,
0.0064201425,
-0.2494847327,
0.1265901029,
-0.5604406595,
1.0100375414,
-0.3977513611,
-0.3903889358,
-0.2334514707,
-0.2566239238,
0.3886164725,
-1.054084897,
0.447734803,
-0.5822184682,
0.048283685,
-0.1328139305,
-0.5731909275,
-0.1536300331,
0.5145507455,
-0.5113771558,
0.9823220372,
0.113119334,
-0.7824258208,
0.4894991517,
-0.5973562598,
-0.4310314357,
-0.1593041718,
-0.4592103958,
-0.3433287144,
-0.1067427993,
-0.1326770037,
0.411468327,
-0.7862064242,
0.098311156,
-0.1455185711,
-0.3292247355,
-0.0601770058,
-0.1581200063,
0.5342082381,
0.420594573,
-0.3821630478,
0.5368746519,
-0.8194758296,
0.1324741989,
-0.0066297874,
-0.5169795156,
-0.3893895447,
-0.0891578272,
0.0319623798,
0.1198044345,
0.5204848051,
-0.352386117,
0.1093704998,
0.0159492139,
0.3527406454,
0.4712766707,
-0.1649274379,
0.449948281,
-0.2954536974,
0.2975011766,
-0.1723129302,
-0.0427877456,
-0.3619710207,
-0.2389784157,
-0.7799434066,
-0.2388617694,
0.3780643046,
0.6293165684,
-0.4961325824,
0.7946030498,
-0.3519612849,
-0.4090477526,
-0.2755803168,
-0.2458606064,
0.4605523646,
0.501776278,
0.5100653768,
-0.337593317,
-0.4870812893,
-1.1209229231,
-0.1799702942,
-0.3065526783,
-0.8668991923,
0.3282845914,
0.443633467,
-0.2431156635,
0.9452925324,
-0.5306838155,
-0.1497551799,
-0.1819801778,
0.4158371687,
0.1042620018,
0.239232108,
0.1832464337,
-0.705163002,
-0.387978524,
0.2347486615,
-1.0900841951,
-0.2908976674,
-0.081677936,
0.1058609188,
0.1363094151,
0.6767548919,
-0.6661006212,
0.4406724274,
0.0952277109,
-0.6933920383,
0.3991719186,
-0.5267831683,
0.7635610104,
-0.9773535132,
0.298599124,
-0.2986977994,
-0.4739473164,
-0.4157662094,
0.0734506622,
0.1987807751,
0.086755164,
0.1319607794,
0.5019868016,
-0.3626517355,
-0.5875024796,
-0.4515037239,
0.4021415412,
0.1319191754,
0.2205979675,
0.0509851128,
0.6317379475,
0.1917082071,
-0.5410954952,
0.4969700277,
0.1522925496,
-0.1508554667,
0.5732027292,
-0.7781652212,
-0.1361588836,
-0.0301932469,
0.3518119156,
-1.0203393698,
-0.0657766238,
-0.1273944974,
-0.6933720112,
0.2417965978,
0.3196179867,
-0.77378124,
-0.0227887481,
-0.6343518496,
0.4865063429,
0.5848404169,
-0.2838959098,
0.5985093117,
0.2580328584,
-0.4640653133,
-0.3817745447,
-0.5101909637,
0.4915750325,
-0.0949426964,
-0.6698892713,
0.192250669,
-0.1399463266,
-0.7325983644,
-0.1124347076,
-0.1495649815,
0.2361865491,
-0.0883465931,
0.0594352856,
0.3199763,
-0.2180434018,
-0.0162495673,
0.3806061745,
-0.1422527879,
0.0982289687,
-0.2213049829,
0.2394311428,
-0.1096383259,
-0.3975803554,
-0.1457796544,
0.3972767889,
0.780892849,
0.1203474849,
0.4160949588,
0.0680335462,
-0.4302659035,
0.2581534088,
-0.7047553062,
-0.2550101876,
-0.3803161383,
0.2501196265,
-0.3783188164,
-0.8516175747,
0.5880311728,
-0.1230086833,
0.3521715403,
0.6248656511,
0.5379286408,
0.1399288774,
1.0611402988,
0.3445592225,
0.1028608829,
0.0811703056,
-0.2182902545,
0.1558800042,
-0.7322967052,
-0.3292073309,
-0.4670187235,
-0.4374017119,
-0.2392255515,
-0.582727313,
0.5059126019,
0.2441569418,
-0.4482629597,
0.357765615,
-0.3973105252,
0.4985028505,
0.2630617619,
-0.1315358728,
0.8690384626,
-0.0947024524,
0.0295674987,
0.2035204619,
-0.4309331477,
-0.6948410869,
1.2371954918,
0.320853442,
0.7378254533,
0.4411242604,
0.2246272415,
0.7305234671,
0.402215302,
-0.7223998308,
0.6958851814,
-0.1782346517,
-0.2270806283,
-0.681933701,
-0.6115587354,
-0.6692729592,
0.3667544723,
-0.2634292543,
-0.5920500755,
0.0182890277,
-0.0437482968,
-0.3451052606,
0.2722240984,
-0.5377934575,
0.6170498133,
0.0728850216,
-0.2831664681,
-0.3373835981,
-0.9964538813,
0.121963881,
-0.0525034703,
0.068749696,
-0.1400220543,
-0.3695193529,
0.8119512796,
-0.6257970333,
0.3339425623,
0.1180597618,
-0.0829378217,
0.1590123922,
0.198911339,
0.4264090955,
-0.0652069896,
-0.2169231325,
0.2528014481,
-0.0790018663,
-0.2917993367,
-0.8657861948,
0.6313859224,
-0.7354882956,
-0.3032813966,
-0.2052601874,
-0.5145848393,
0.0151010798,
0.2058593631,
0.3252623975,
0.4800994098,
0.069135718,
0.1793153435,
0.6482675672,
0.0146541409,
0.2442442775,
0.9184188843,
-0.1556964368,
-0.1210367829,
0.6430956721,
-0.1086765602,
0.3994628191,
0.8091781735,
-0.102801986,
-0.5169489384,
-0.5539814234,
-0.6495267749,
-0.0815431252,
-0.8857011199,
-0.5270511508,
-0.8582819104,
-0.1146061346,
-0.4696714878,
-0.3831834197,
-0.1816351712,
-0.5913639069,
-0.0336655267,
-0.1785824448,
0.1799864471,
0.8900435567,
-0.0499470122,
0.0530767068,
-0.4342751801,
0.3782042563,
0.0940636322,
0.1049929038,
0.1274084449,
-0.6357941628,
0.0111052413,
-0.3776777983,
-0.2567561269,
-0.5606600046,
0.1013071463,
0.0948659331,
0.3065516651,
0.6456703544,
-0.0135325296,
0.3793361187,
-0.3871059716,
0.6384803057,
0.2754492462,
-0.9549567103,
0.4125519693,
-0.2755519152,
0.4984299541,
0.7292077541,
0.2848881185,
-0.5965850949,
-0.470705539,
-0.4232516885,
-1.2047148943,
0.4636946619,
0.4594522119,
-0.4250389338,
0.0570184514,
0.4395073354,
0.187568143,
0.2890353799,
-0.306499213,
-0.3155516386,
0.1161318496,
-0.2890012562,
-0.0163297728,
-0.1461644024,
0.092487663,
0.1046649665,
0.5354440808,
-0.3473954201,
-0.0661554113,
0.237805441,
-0.0265879016,
-0.0763967633,
0.2543219626,
0.3961850107,
0.8245494962,
-0.0145235676,
0.420837611,
0.534953773,
-0.1607275903,
0.1234254465,
-0.0391587429,
-0.2948004007,
0.0537989587,
0.5632455945,
0.4313508272,
0.3689036369,
-1.1759989262,
0.5570649505,
-0.3255650699,
-0.0578527451,
-0.2991058528,
-0.0007639159,
0.1279931068,
0.3021218777,
0.501241684,
0.1505385339,
0.7161102295,
-0.5809951425,
0.3106112778,
0.4250797927,
-0.0964115113,
0.0792223513,
0.6407596469,
0.179917708,
-0.3181815445,
0.6078679562,
-0.3273912072,
-0.0688981339,
0.803448379,
0.2747811377,
0.4299125373,
-0.2345299125,
-0.1312476099,
0.4843063354,
0.0794385448,
-0.2163462043,
0.1955162585,
-0.5111535192,
-0.4942665398,
-0.2271471769,
-0.5080464482,
-0.5267686248,
-0.1257902831,
-0.8048388362,
0.397644341,
-0.4055200517,
0.0398118347,
0.0491233617,
-0.1231478229,
-0.271135211,
0.3684844375,
-0.0390393622,
1.165995121,
-0.8226937652,
0.2617453635,
0.5414468646,
-0.3568284214,
-0.5398325324,
-0.1537858397,
0.1018225476,
-0.4570029378,
0.6855982542,
0.2200261205,
-0.464977771,
-0.235670343,
-0.2844421268,
-0.602519691,
1.4348186255,
0.1981750727,
-0.508464992,
-0.1760636568,
-0.0003988782,
0.7968259454,
-0.5733494759,
0.877374053,
0.7864171863,
0.3840458095,
0.5772717595,
-0.9909713268,
0.2526939809,
-0.4292740822,
-0.2865659893,
0.2376137078,
-0.4355166256,
0.9129964709,
-0.3521581888,
-0.2485077232,
0.2379557937,
0.6870229244,
0.2773578167,
0.5769873261,
0.6525321603,
0.4522409141,
0.5452097654,
0.1114962623,
0.6358781457,
-0.3767542541,
0.4084139764,
1.3116943836,
-0.4105723798,
1.0175747871,
0.1749558002,
-0.3135244548,
0.4298771918,
0.8845727444,
0.0046945256,
0.1992620081,
0.4752955437,
-0.4756818116,
-0.0214612614,
-0.2097626626,
-0.0983486921,
0.221735388,
0.390277952,
-0.3136054575,
-0.4690821469,
-0.3910209239,
-0.0825676471,
0.1441675276,
-0.4155434072,
1.0657509565,
-0.0055416292,
-0.6386327147,
0.4516064227,
0.2886640429,
0.6631138325,
-0.7453868389,
-0.1607477814,
-0.1871017963,
-0.0223672967,
-0.4761946797,
-0.6306924224,
0.4338228405,
0.1430321336,
-0.2999561727,
0.0892963111,
0.5804265738,
-0.5163122416,
-0.2253721654,
0.4602564275,
0.3383261561,
0.4495604932,
-0.2029759139,
-0.4897651374,
0.0312972851,
-0.1813610196,
-0.1413975507,
0.1984292716,
0.3401059508,
-0.3864304423,
0.9364770055,
0.3984272182,
0.0521759354,
-0.3691628277,
0.2247373313,
0.8958345652,
-0.5830308795,
-0.6957412362,
-0.7750487328,
0.1946609169,
-0.4653181434,
-0.1292708665,
0.6242139935,
1.1266602278,
0.6632441878,
0.190076381,
0.9456087351,
-0.1795754582,
0.6062727571,
-0.3806477487,
0.7041315436,
-0.7251679897,
0.4140094519,
0.0996569023,
-0.8555199504,
-0.216267556,
0.4543260336,
-0.2232778966,
-0.0151894223,
0.8585065007,
0.7854600549,
-0.0559049547,
0.0064278189,
0.4637642205,
0.2595158815,
0.298582375,
0.3355906606,
0.4816019237,
-0.3013965189,
0.3942317367,
0.4620795548,
-0.6925762296,
-0.3150696158,
-0.583807826,
-0.8538232446,
-0.646702826,
-0.0696263909,
-0.2651991844,
0.1186647564,
1.153578043,
0.5285525322,
-0.8742216825,
-0.262894094,
-0.0158668905,
0.0121296495,
0.1872983277,
-0.2276604474,
0.4272570908,
-0.2206300944,
-0.6179077029,
0.2139922082,
0.7917234302,
-0.0554082282,
-0.4451248646,
0.0357390568,
0.1455377787,
0.1409369707,
0.7702290416,
0.0965759605,
-0.7792682052,
-0.1502960771,
-0.1435732096,
-0.2420247793,
-0.0430817306,
1.2509042025,
-0.656396389,
0.3121951818,
0.5975443721,
0.7099183798,
0.2369554788,
0.1667070091,
0.6727375388,
-0.3593063056,
-0.2002035975,
0.1555688977,
0.1956952959,
0.440566957,
-0.4612750411,
0.6884612441,
-0.1511762738,
-0.5410637856,
-0.4407947063,
0.2901138663,
-0.9177784324,
-0.4170459509,
1.0802180767,
-0.3285871744,
0.0351545326,
-0.2508964241,
-0.2179341018,
0.2701668143,
-0.4806123972,
1.0682320595,
0.4168713689,
-0.4555026293,
0.2731835544,
-0.3042997718,
0.4028754532,
0.260027945,
-1.168377161,
0.0984573513,
0.339705646,
0.1985354424,
0.1545779556,
0.7131549716,
-0.0423229486,
0.1631121188,
0.0749907419,
0.1849323362,
0.091507487,
-0.1227629781,
-0.3369618952,
0.1426890939,
-0.0165328439,
0.1832810193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04332v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04332v1
|
Scope Ambiguities in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-05T18:01:02 | 2024-04-05T18:01:02 |
Gaurav Kamath, Sebastian Schuster, Sowmya Vajjala, Siva Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sentences containing multiple semantic operators with overlapping scope often
create ambiguities in interpretation, known as scope ambiguities. These
ambiguities offer rich insights into the interaction between semantic structure
and world knowledge in language processing. Despite this, there has been little
research into how modern large language models treat them. In this paper, we
investigate how different versions of certain autoregressive language models --
GPT-2, GPT-3/3.5, Llama 2 and GPT-4 -- treat scope ambiguous sentences, and
compare this with human judgments. We introduce novel datasets that contain a
joint total of almost 1,000 unique scope-ambiguous sentences, containing
interactions between a range of semantic operators, and annotated for human
judgments. Using these datasets, we find evidence that several models (i) are
sensitive to the meaning ambiguity in these sentences, in a way that patterns
well with human judgments, and (ii) can successfully identify human-preferred
readings at a high level of accuracy (over 90% in some cases).
|
[
-0.2685173452,
-0.7011541724,
0.829256773,
0.0831829756,
-0.1713581979,
-0.1183644384,
-0.1864015013,
-0.9951948524,
-0.0809809864,
0.4781860113,
-0.5123825073,
-0.2255363911,
-1.1297498941,
0.1105317026,
-0.6137657166,
0.6765070558,
-0.248257786,
-0.2011044323,
0.2806711793,
-0.3717906773,
-0.474276334,
-0.6182758212,
-0.0548173487,
-0.2615522742,
0.5032162666,
0.1670819521,
1.2976540327,
0.5080688596,
0.8115184307,
0.2732514143,
-0.0054904465,
0.047123149,
-0.0837783664,
0.27532354,
-0.1804230213,
-0.4657570124,
-0.3763257563,
-0.0993938446,
0.8042867184,
0.9385922551,
0.0297660828,
0.0591696464,
-0.1084580347,
0.532690227,
-0.7334502935,
0.2640164196,
-0.7739190459,
0.0734508038,
-0.2992285788,
0.3665920794,
-0.1755893975,
0.2174092084,
0.422368288,
-0.6858847737,
0.1802653074,
-0.1194616184,
1.13230443,
0.4622766376,
-0.8508912921,
-0.428583771,
-0.5505011082,
0.872210741,
-0.6313835382,
0.4566113353,
0.3786005974,
0.2277369946,
-0.139203459,
-0.4103601575,
-0.5046693087,
0.0564235859,
-0.196281448,
-0.0701480061,
-0.5738120675,
-0.0587824658,
0.2745583951,
0.1485237032,
-0.5583286881,
0.2460599393,
-0.2790088058,
-0.0958706439,
0.5030531287,
0.0218065269,
0.1049800813,
-0.5435324907,
-0.3968887031,
-0.1850211024,
-0.7384639382,
-0.202851519,
0.7015565634,
-0.0051980866,
0.023392817,
0.8879861832,
-0.4113018513,
1.2849290371,
-0.1916720271,
0.4734265208,
0.2346334755,
-0.3321141601,
-0.2708747983,
-0.4797845781,
0.8030301929,
0.346876204,
0.4073727429,
-0.2500784099,
-0.1968533546,
0.2548480034,
0.2449171096,
-0.1714050472,
0.0105867321,
0.0151335727,
-0.2316452265,
-0.2555514574,
0.2584722042,
-0.5535149574,
-0.0914482996,
-0.2816562653,
0.5273324251,
-0.0238900539,
-0.1641559303,
0.4782360196,
-0.1318793595,
0.2939365208,
0.3334686756,
-0.8801072836,
0.2393731773,
0.5490175486,
0.5647341013,
-0.1068491116,
-0.5590538979,
-0.463368535,
0.2929061949,
-0.0997578129,
0.7545720339,
-0.7743683457,
-0.2450414896,
-0.2709950507,
0.0264953543,
-0.0045850072,
-0.3817743659,
0.4093090892,
-0.5736519694,
0.3768156767,
-0.44462502,
-0.3853369057,
-0.2513028085,
0.2601510286,
-0.6001233459,
0.4115455449,
0.1956339777,
-0.7948688865,
0.6088414788,
-0.6015850306,
-0.1715362817,
-0.1833456457,
-0.3833318353,
-0.2138592005,
0.2621073723,
0.2247874737,
0.2515146136,
-0.3432207108,
0.4144139886,
-0.067982614,
-0.1753331274,
0.4429804683,
-0.5624053478,
0.6767747998,
0.4278970063,
-0.2712595761,
0.0217770971,
-0.3999722898,
0.0826437101,
0.0295521505,
-0.1393620819,
-0.3847143352,
0.0068188556,
-0.0494926944,
0.1351284683,
0.2219039053,
-0.2804732025,
0.3466668129,
-0.3007996082,
0.6959872842,
0.4906986356,
-0.0291136242,
0.2707095742,
-0.3698781729,
0.5018810034,
0.3756172955,
0.082444936,
-0.0209528729,
-0.8204887509,
-0.6713756323,
0.1661941409,
0.1376161575,
0.5601112843,
-0.2622185647,
0.356712997,
-0.3018729389,
-0.1053572148,
-0.3238474131,
0.1094238013,
0.2986646593,
0.1434562653,
0.3052950799,
-0.3259856999,
-0.3019550443,
-1.2253922224,
-0.7528449297,
-0.3180098832,
-0.2023769617,
0.3212257028,
0.5144872665,
-0.5926662683,
1.2469149828,
-0.6960619688,
-0.1578764021,
0.2692139447,
0.4581720233,
-0.0647540092,
0.1515235007,
0.3943066597,
-1.1144570112,
-0.2028999478,
-0.0841497108,
-0.6637537479,
-0.2299049348,
-0.0807135627,
0.0066847666,
0.1234856993,
0.3376790583,
-0.7315045595,
0.5256690979,
0.6386737227,
-0.6084907651,
0.3671129346,
-0.1732128263,
0.0952762589,
-0.8363280296,
-0.2241802514,
-0.0882052481,
-0.3511515558,
-0.5202210546,
0.3131769896,
0.2859075963,
0.3110977411,
-0.3402639925,
0.5626940727,
-0.5853847265,
-0.2011856437,
-0.1556492299,
0.309826076,
0.166870743,
0.1996660084,
0.0692966208,
0.5005607605,
0.3488385379,
-0.3929402828,
0.2359045148,
0.4009529352,
-0.3918227553,
0.2656799555,
-0.5652216077,
-0.041924499,
-0.0744326636,
0.2201620042,
-0.9686394334,
-0.585493505,
0.3048062623,
-0.3315111995,
0.1596260965,
-0.040060401,
-0.5990356207,
-0.3191613853,
0.0999310091,
0.7332295179,
0.2147348523,
-0.397726804,
0.2128951401,
0.4615539908,
0.1695868969,
-0.9494057298,
-0.9517822266,
0.2939031124,
-0.366001457,
-0.6750501394,
0.0032928393,
0.301189512,
-0.659460485,
0.2749109268,
-0.1373788714,
-0.1842076629,
0.0273911152,
0.1661624014,
0.1537014544,
0.0608169027,
0.2302832901,
-0.1433723569,
0.0191316009,
0.0563655198,
-0.2184422314,
0.0949689597,
-0.3260630965,
-0.6923437119,
0.1321366429,
0.4120351672,
0.6481868625,
-0.0849702284,
0.3199352026,
0.3459328711,
-0.474656105,
0.3085618317,
-0.7947881818,
0.0753485262,
-0.393317461,
0.4972945154,
-0.5626178384,
-0.9989522696,
0.7299851179,
0.4525637627,
-0.1570913494,
0.5454810262,
0.6460493207,
0.2808635533,
0.9624370933,
0.3015293181,
-0.0716191903,
0.3455189764,
-0.0364373736,
0.2331403494,
-1.0526639223,
0.2428092808,
-0.2539824247,
-0.221184209,
-0.6924892664,
-0.5252626538,
0.3352182806,
-0.0254296809,
-0.1756570339,
0.3971266448,
-0.2980027497,
0.6303340793,
0.320102036,
-0.0915082395,
0.5247728825,
-0.3476307988,
0.0482309088,
0.1327382028,
-0.435926944,
-0.5487810373,
1.2578492165,
0.395888418,
0.742102623,
0.6348949671,
0.2921994328,
0.1732327342,
-0.0204886813,
-0.6494391561,
0.1472337395,
-0.3275339603,
-0.9656312466,
-0.4100626409,
-0.4698035121,
-1.1784169674,
0.6990603209,
-0.074700065,
-0.9498156309,
0.5078938007,
-0.0544739068,
-0.2694370747,
0.2676000595,
-1.1879870892,
0.9749802947,
-0.142675221,
-0.276861012,
0.0296912566,
-0.9039367437,
0.4979386032,
-0.2607881427,
0.3162100613,
-0.2609137297,
-0.2213418186,
0.2385009378,
-0.3321141601,
0.8407304883,
0.0982042477,
-0.3407350481,
0.2812620103,
0.0725595802,
0.7073953748,
0.0756134167,
0.0101323547,
0.4054008722,
0.0447094291,
-0.4470587969,
-0.3311366737,
0.5873545408,
-0.8335955739,
-0.8000583649,
-0.6218794584,
-0.9308968186,
-0.2835620642,
0.3037476242,
0.5157080293,
0.2105675191,
-0.0310663264,
-0.0724778473,
0.2570045888,
-0.1615542173,
0.2424253225,
0.6436392665,
-0.1449004114,
0.2403684705,
0.3073166907,
0.27905339,
0.7658013701,
0.2818776667,
-0.0106786648,
-0.2318047881,
-0.2989215851,
-0.4320777655,
0.1999172866,
-0.7675269842,
-0.2209016383,
-0.7246180773,
-0.1463214755,
-0.3156035841,
-0.0618257672,
-0.0184592251,
-0.4618639946,
-0.2724276185,
0.0631430969,
0.361708194,
1.0993049145,
-0.0514589958,
0.407946676,
-0.5981357694,
0.3607899845,
0.4792066216,
0.321590066,
-0.2766670585,
-0.4976467192,
0.0044782287,
0.225797683,
-0.2311654389,
-1.0423549414,
0.3475533128,
-0.0125537366,
0.2734597623,
0.1523381174,
-0.2004550397,
0.6878718734,
-0.4715844393,
0.6496409774,
0.0318589471,
-1.0970166922,
0.2964093089,
-0.6909156442,
0.8332977891,
0.2374620587,
0.0435921364,
-0.6613781452,
-0.8803997636,
-0.5407938361,
-0.902156949,
0.7076703906,
0.2594464719,
-0.0152534824,
-0.1012748927,
0.5151489973,
0.1436962932,
0.1975484341,
-0.7992194891,
0.0509160943,
-0.0175013077,
-0.1056207269,
-0.1219282225,
-0.2817532718,
-0.1426159292,
0.1287793219,
0.0050497577,
0.0073739835,
0.1919077188,
0.2220962942,
-0.3896171749,
-0.4684322774,
0.4884805679,
0.6321692467,
0.8890131116,
-0.2581652105,
0.3208522797,
0.2071927488,
-0.5451314449,
0.1605084538,
0.0395640507,
0.0435682014,
-0.149808377,
0.4845298529,
0.7387420535,
0.4566605687,
-0.5838462114,
0.6426276565,
-0.2654233873,
-0.2380469888,
-0.4130747616,
0.0787017196,
-0.0790499747,
0.3737178743,
0.3273286223,
0.3844082057,
0.4275667369,
-0.5516704321,
0.1859892756,
0.6339885592,
-0.0689956918,
-0.1117725298,
0.7784335017,
-0.137861684,
-0.0020174009,
0.4475646019,
-0.388541609,
-0.6308563948,
0.5584346652,
0.2214193642,
0.6736994386,
0.2450537235,
-0.1020105407,
-0.0432796553,
0.4533323348,
-0.1800685674,
0.0550513901,
0.0266942736,
-0.8949513435,
-0.6212102771,
-0.3969419003,
-0.5837342739,
-0.0717529878,
-0.8621307015,
0.2115045637,
0.1754175425,
-0.2511337399,
0.0914437249,
-0.100261502,
-0.8177477121,
-0.0449744947,
0.132694751,
0.4632036984,
-0.9825954437,
1.0135520697,
0.5970740318,
-0.1698543131,
-0.6125835776,
0.361032337,
0.1175139472,
-0.8163475394,
0.9172886014,
-0.0609891973,
-0.1876800209,
-0.088186197,
-0.106870167,
-1.2337725163,
0.7576871514,
0.3564374447,
-0.7883812785,
-0.218913421,
0.1589677781,
0.4827906489,
-0.2012946755,
0.0817926973,
0.6706040502,
0.6732641459,
0.0677268282,
-1.1884737015,
0.0175519343,
0.0495551899,
-0.1393413097,
0.5894305706,
-0.8309395909,
1.0041351318,
-0.217825681,
-0.1019928306,
0.0792620257,
0.2126545608,
-0.0089490591,
-0.0773931146,
0.6134509444,
0.6469401717,
0.6988804936,
-0.2621357739,
1.0262153149,
-0.0744631439,
0.5497502685,
1.2546855211,
-0.2635698915,
0.8100472689,
0.3506670296,
-0.3642590642,
0.2729463875,
0.5878557563,
-0.0129137961,
0.3216262162,
0.1647803634,
-0.1598780155,
-0.2830304503,
0.4801575541,
-0.3800150454,
0.7567660213,
0.5318928361,
-0.1228244603,
-0.4149874747,
-0.0262963232,
0.002167685,
-0.2533766925,
0.1023533344,
0.4346609414,
-0.0440362804,
-0.7885133624,
0.4637875259,
0.0479470231,
0.636913538,
-0.540332675,
0.183084324,
0.17429851,
0.1463692337,
-0.1838658452,
-0.9972800612,
0.535930872,
0.0829719082,
-0.2409505099,
-0.100819014,
0.4487146735,
-0.356284678,
-0.4887727797,
0.3121780455,
0.5043739676,
0.2556745112,
-0.0895320848,
-0.6559845209,
0.1282009631,
-0.0004126458,
-0.2727322578,
0.179637298,
0.6625306606,
-0.2819880247,
0.4829096794,
0.2641585171,
0.1109378561,
0.3002567887,
-0.0775155798,
0.7022418976,
-0.8032036424,
-0.2210428864,
-0.7787169814,
0.1842515022,
0.1499058902,
-0.5621741414,
0.7921735644,
0.2401707321,
0.7516109347,
0.1721499115,
0.7086217403,
0.0144844539,
0.4715713561,
-0.4597494602,
0.4738280773,
-0.5859178305,
0.5352982283,
-0.1811511517,
-0.8353847265,
-0.6418377161,
0.7742116451,
-0.717557013,
0.1934273392,
0.607096076,
0.3835087419,
-0.242825523,
-0.001689045,
0.3307244778,
0.4870067537,
0.3908706307,
0.8238636255,
0.8884285092,
-0.5407540202,
0.4017980099,
0.1009669751,
-0.0259065926,
-0.3665539622,
-0.9723125696,
-0.4531055987,
-0.5504675508,
-0.2141810805,
0.0054456173,
0.1402876377,
0.4670628905,
0.6151607633,
-0.5853528976,
-0.1759213507,
-0.2507022917,
0.1031146944,
0.1111469343,
-0.2018869966,
0.3195204437,
-0.3916732371,
-0.8082302213,
0.1103271618,
0.1265583336,
0.1171858087,
-0.3902077377,
0.1396799088,
-0.2995127439,
-0.0223091338,
0.3739074469,
0.1163419336,
-1.1023094654,
-0.7244591713,
-0.0643829033,
-0.0077500832,
-0.0653899983,
0.5669851303,
-0.7402259111,
0.6150699258,
0.2120130658,
0.2261253744,
0.4031728208,
0.0654702857,
0.7088609934,
-0.6392786503,
0.4082889855,
0.0279254783,
0.3447836041,
0.2780185938,
-0.5491911769,
0.6101539135,
0.013995003,
-0.8093239665,
-0.8596258163,
0.5999063849,
-0.8843088746,
-0.5063212514,
1.3029155731,
-0.0593767129,
0.0579591878,
-0.1241315976,
0.1481428146,
0.0863268897,
-0.0733854175,
0.7751235366,
1.3983130455,
-0.2628878057,
0.3286559582,
-0.9543050528,
0.1555958539,
0.5434784889,
-0.4033568799,
0.24111408,
0.66645962,
0.2041659802,
0.0551530235,
0.2251923084,
-0.2026348859,
0.2659336627,
-0.1343007982,
-0.3707197309,
0.2759677768,
-0.0613723472,
-0.4439226389,
-0.1338440776,
0.3331533074,
-0.1128453314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04326v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04326v1
|
Hypothesis Generation with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-05T18:00:07 | 2024-04-05T18:00:07 |
Yangqiaoyu Zhou, Haokun Liu, Tejes Srivastava, Hongyuan Mei, Chenhao Tan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Effective generation of novel hypotheses is instrumental to scientific
progress. So far, researchers have been the main powerhouse behind hypothesis
generation by painstaking data analysis and thinking (also known as the Eureka
moment). In this paper, we examine the potential of large language models
(LLMs) to generate hypotheses. We focus on hypothesis generation based on data
(i.e., labeled examples). To enable LLMs to handle arbitrarily long contexts,
we generate initial hypotheses from a small number of examples and then update
them iteratively to improve the quality of hypotheses. Inspired by multi-armed
bandits, we design a reward function to inform the exploitation-exploration
tradeoff in the update process. Our algorithm is able to generate hypotheses
that enable much better predictive performance than few-shot prompting in
classification tasks, improving accuracy by 31.7% on a synthetic dataset and by
13.9%, 3.3% and, 24.9% on three real-world datasets. We also outperform
supervised learning by 12.8% and 11.2% on two challenging real-world datasets.
Furthermore, we find that the generated hypotheses not only corroborate
human-verified theories but also uncover new insights for the tasks.
|
[
-0.1922159195,
-0.8064581752,
0.9665086269,
0.0568846911,
0.0061667515,
-0.1245589778,
-0.5697966218,
-0.2280906588,
0.3118360043,
0.5212042928,
-0.3804975748,
-0.4317526519,
-0.5862016082,
0.0247535557,
-0.3633000255,
0.7229574323,
0.1694641262,
-0.4095158577,
-0.1341361701,
0.0879217908,
-0.3431159854,
-0.5261154175,
-0.5735415816,
-0.4344312549,
0.8227627873,
0.437813431,
0.5714833736,
0.7738041282,
0.2527545094,
0.2253047079,
0.0528097525,
0.1315923184,
-0.5362551808,
0.3158751428,
-0.0443715267,
-0.7050243616,
-0.1715229005,
-0.1115152463,
0.5341781378,
0.6916079521,
-0.2858785093,
-0.0237431005,
0.0048355549,
0.4098213315,
-0.5594046116,
0.3058337569,
-0.80845052,
-0.237165302,
-0.2740882635,
-0.4963992536,
-0.4851613939,
-0.1310501397,
0.3077014089,
-0.5933361053,
0.3259034753,
0.1348357797,
0.6594263315,
0.0436082855,
-0.1965429187,
-0.3363593221,
-0.6109524369,
1.0042296648,
-0.8314210773,
-0.0497245975,
0.3329651356,
0.2430136949,
-0.5077633262,
-0.5756219029,
-0.6207258105,
-0.377541095,
0.2175143063,
-0.2585198879,
-0.1873787493,
-0.23593086,
0.4861988723,
0.0730813593,
-0.3270789087,
0.4968883395,
-0.2905362546,
-0.0918129236,
0.9458290339,
0.0701581761,
0.0395609774,
-0.2542518675,
-0.0225035995,
-0.4932028353,
-1.2069952488,
0.1642784029,
0.4950604439,
0.6618818641,
0.1102279723,
0.7728470564,
-0.3881982565,
0.6169168353,
-0.1768370122,
-0.6010878682,
0.3016224205,
-0.135616675,
-0.083543919,
0.0970076397,
0.7228323817,
0.3650537431,
0.1236028671,
0.0242660735,
-0.1481968611,
0.099416256,
0.0079933098,
-0.9209329486,
-0.3048440218,
0.4706303477,
-0.1333172619,
-0.5262482166,
-0.1359260827,
-0.7973982692,
-0.4569075406,
-0.124253571,
0.5229492188,
-0.4122951925,
-0.3656768799,
0.3152237833,
-0.2968673408,
-0.0208705775,
0.3415415883,
-0.8634036183,
-0.0485770665,
0.6423453689,
0.6361789107,
-0.2347089052,
-0.3641279638,
-0.6529595256,
0.1855198294,
-0.5970198512,
0.8883330226,
-0.3386746347,
-0.359092772,
0.163751781,
-0.2508970499,
0.1441381574,
-0.4197213352,
0.4593513608,
-0.3758107424,
0.0737120733,
-0.3184034228,
-0.7562610507,
-0.1409650445,
0.2259597182,
-0.6425983906,
0.8319078684,
-0.1324048638,
-0.762840271,
0.7069237232,
-0.8095661402,
-0.457257539,
0.2302318811,
-0.237207517,
-0.4360575974,
0.0066453274,
0.2862344682,
0.4831133485,
-0.4983314276,
0.7109418511,
-0.3343436718,
-0.1182459667,
0.6186339855,
-0.274902463,
0.4945600629,
0.1297949553,
-0.4888606966,
0.0663963407,
-0.3622362316,
-0.0301905535,
0.2912293375,
-0.2775454819,
-0.3268190324,
0.2553824782,
-0.1950731128,
0.085633643,
-0.1302941144,
-0.5845961571,
0.4020164609,
-0.2012512088,
0.4623925686,
0.6908436418,
0.1807921678,
0.1853642911,
-0.4861384034,
0.5592080951,
-0.1274486631,
-0.3686981797,
-0.7371460199,
-0.440197289,
-0.4953711033,
-0.5193834305,
0.5875558853,
0.2452244908,
-0.8740071654,
0.4510996342,
-0.3591820002,
-0.4987846315,
-0.4070546925,
0.091644749,
0.0340722166,
0.3640376329,
0.1838035733,
0.0247096568,
-0.327280581,
-0.8587880731,
-0.3220608532,
-0.1665244251,
-0.3468506336,
0.2927894592,
0.6042025685,
-0.2412217408,
1.0180795193,
-0.7310699821,
0.006835694,
-0.3340514004,
0.3938127458,
0.2520097494,
0.2952352464,
0.4515308142,
-0.8831973076,
-0.0654362291,
-0.2218065858,
-0.8335378766,
0.1346063614,
-0.2056737393,
0.1078083217,
0.3043211401,
0.39273718,
-0.6841514707,
0.2396107167,
0.2610830367,
-0.0266832095,
0.6244262457,
-0.1201768667,
0.0742197037,
-1.0350170135,
0.1061599851,
0.234935388,
0.0853418857,
-0.5048109889,
0.0973565504,
-0.0172489509,
-0.0940030366,
-0.3357706368,
0.4548428655,
-0.3043645024,
0.2335134447,
-0.3303377628,
-0.0179722346,
-0.3816582561,
0.2970959544,
0.181608364,
0.2798139155,
0.8827291131,
-0.7353597879,
0.278731823,
0.0682199523,
-0.6834022999,
0.076370053,
-0.6215413809,
-0.1704033017,
-0.1730289757,
0.4509580731,
-0.9180270433,
-0.6420065165,
-0.274181217,
-0.5205895901,
0.1835483015,
-0.0701989681,
-0.7414450049,
-0.5782275796,
-0.3342082202,
0.0465454496,
0.6757471561,
-0.7645816207,
0.1857904792,
0.3906506598,
-0.596636951,
-0.534729898,
-0.4231166542,
0.2580322027,
-0.6697573662,
-0.60150069,
0.1100102961,
0.0255087949,
-0.392627418,
-0.1163536459,
0.1263069808,
0.4373335242,
0.2048225552,
0.0336085893,
0.3332313299,
-0.0997564271,
0.3500010073,
0.0617458113,
-0.0898825452,
0.2287348956,
-0.3714251518,
0.4938533604,
0.2643472254,
-0.2136386633,
0.038817592,
0.2804352045,
0.3982993662,
-0.0503681265,
0.5237870812,
0.3213597238,
-0.4459341466,
-0.4584090412,
-0.4148121774,
-0.4482341111,
-0.4636134803,
0.408751905,
-0.4368979633,
-0.9868992567,
0.2399260551,
-0.2846733034,
0.3532934785,
0.3921391964,
0.7186079621,
0.0191219132,
0.8949245214,
0.6752544641,
0.0150743872,
0.2341076732,
-0.3053851128,
0.4801162183,
-0.5875040889,
0.0374822989,
-0.4674418569,
0.0007288409,
-0.7475143075,
-0.5680797696,
0.490359813,
0.0294822138,
0.0713204294,
0.2845294476,
-0.1220038086,
0.3675496876,
0.7646743655,
-0.1086698249,
0.1451642662,
0.0831321478,
0.0178943612,
0.1006620675,
-0.8611483574,
-0.5780901313,
1.6069823503,
0.2686564624,
0.8033234477,
0.0315147229,
0.9649617076,
0.3550959826,
0.5396567583,
-0.8919135928,
0.3153111637,
0.4438575506,
-0.5416250825,
-0.6195468307,
-0.5057063699,
-1.1669406891,
0.2587293386,
-0.5258160233,
-0.8592148423,
0.0227684751,
0.3713682592,
-0.3932951391,
0.2228107154,
-0.5619514585,
0.6578476429,
-0.1663316637,
-0.5949341655,
-0.1557557881,
-0.3955332339,
0.6153193116,
-0.331546098,
0.3880215883,
-0.0786013231,
0.3329097033,
0.846961081,
-0.1620741189,
0.7441186905,
-0.2634482682,
-0.5647065639,
0.6383354068,
0.1554817408,
0.5320064425,
0.1010199264,
-0.238151148,
-0.0518447645,
-0.2513372898,
-0.3673036397,
-0.4328759909,
0.7199360728,
-0.2855499983,
-0.7984116077,
-0.3218317628,
-0.7937718034,
-0.1110961661,
0.1173200086,
0.4210360348,
0.3678832054,
-0.1629379392,
0.3706206679,
0.6589132547,
-0.347486943,
0.4013648629,
0.3574723303,
-0.2237187028,
-0.0131713478,
1.0704387426,
0.0966558307,
0.2813430429,
0.2666203976,
0.4011561871,
-0.5233075619,
-0.5419911146,
-0.4070751965,
0.1497880667,
-0.3477119207,
-0.337507695,
-0.5943568945,
0.1728156656,
-0.4256941378,
-0.214289546,
-0.1877354831,
-0.3058628738,
0.1659526825,
-0.2190672308,
0.4142437577,
0.5472068191,
-0.4026299715,
0.1383211911,
-0.55151546,
0.3093803227,
0.4396993518,
-0.0901270434,
0.1185032576,
-0.3299604356,
-0.3319983482,
0.3305467367,
-0.4924385846,
-0.6284762621,
0.7285609245,
-0.0109983981,
0.540930748,
0.2905168235,
0.0210627262,
0.3496746421,
-0.4986602664,
0.7588866949,
0.3938359022,
-0.6622531414,
0.5910287499,
-0.7027700543,
0.0904051214,
0.1033134013,
0.4263009429,
-0.308935076,
-0.4230892062,
-0.9823406339,
-0.9530001283,
0.3043846488,
0.1673350781,
-0.1261134297,
0.0077804103,
0.0547793508,
0.4147432446,
0.4209135473,
-0.5078073144,
0.0356521718,
0.2072766423,
-0.0359329022,
-0.5725557804,
0.0647914112,
-0.2963963449,
-0.0739346668,
0.5680238008,
-0.6234415174,
0.3369414508,
0.0286155678,
-0.0495844558,
-0.3025158048,
0.4159143865,
0.4686542153,
0.8351328969,
-0.1981274635,
0.1226766184,
-0.0587811656,
-0.0147146601,
0.0512280166,
0.2034445703,
-0.2459030449,
-0.1043253466,
0.503754735,
0.7478616834,
-0.0931607485,
-1.1410551071,
0.3396279514,
0.0816111937,
-0.3715452254,
-0.3195290267,
0.2812268734,
0.3991297781,
0.2096809,
0.8283005953,
-0.2024410218,
0.1686989665,
-0.8363781571,
0.1604263484,
0.4945528805,
0.3942543566,
-0.3318731785,
0.4014593363,
-0.0507918037,
-0.2465752363,
0.2681176662,
-0.2814205587,
-0.5405548811,
0.8080258369,
0.6899092197,
0.52085042,
0.0435962155,
0.3550950587,
0.5856428742,
0.1940883547,
-0.4400985837,
0.0479814708,
0.0491968654,
-0.8279320002,
-0.6857723594,
-0.715066731,
-0.5706908703,
0.4183656871,
-0.6614741683,
0.2218485177,
0.1361052692,
0.0253592692,
0.3887145221,
-0.0687451437,
-0.6121666431,
0.1433421522,
0.199427247,
0.7527617812,
-1.01232934,
0.7696594,
0.3527353704,
-0.0290964432,
-0.6392982006,
0.0875669569,
-0.0073780892,
-0.595508039,
0.4113001227,
0.1864975542,
0.1606568098,
-0.207004115,
-1.047262907,
-1.0707556009,
1.0290391445,
0.2912677228,
-0.6261899471,
0.1518326104,
-0.1262717098,
0.4808995724,
-0.5679508448,
-0.2563537359,
0.7763881683,
0.5623118877,
0.1474646777,
-0.7104563713,
0.0905707404,
-0.0909685865,
-0.2068860978,
0.2215489447,
-0.2796140611,
0.9494105577,
-0.9218608737,
-0.0406327695,
0.193441093,
0.757504642,
0.8771351576,
0.2718548179,
0.5576491952,
0.4935951233,
0.9135611653,
-0.0834427252,
1.3154757023,
0.0465786569,
0.2884672582,
0.9961654544,
-0.384909302,
0.8994369507,
0.4995144904,
-0.0918981507,
0.4803880453,
0.7252954245,
-0.0470949821,
0.4250999987,
0.5691301227,
-0.0444336832,
-0.3557823896,
-0.0535593629,
-0.171627298,
0.4318527877,
0.6299515367,
-0.0701315552,
-0.0781931132,
0.0684061572,
0.1593415886,
-0.0355449095,
-0.0844785124,
0.5546969771,
-0.0553751215,
-1.0487837791,
0.7512964606,
0.0130697368,
0.8004049659,
-0.6237022877,
-0.24170959,
-0.0112135941,
0.1490201503,
0.0460891947,
-0.8276900649,
-0.3076043725,
0.1241701916,
0.0723718554,
-0.0815230235,
0.6489113569,
-0.6545479894,
-0.4255433679,
-0.0720422789,
0.516418159,
0.1123395711,
-0.0483552516,
-0.1754149348,
-0.0496427603,
0.0988919437,
-0.330173403,
0.4438306689,
0.460080117,
-0.0732594058,
0.8042616844,
0.9533778429,
0.2076195776,
-0.0889793038,
-0.2969386578,
0.840803802,
-0.7618815899,
-0.6629456282,
-0.7582123876,
0.3272637129,
-0.1813177168,
-0.2038809806,
0.8464987278,
0.4623063505,
0.6042330861,
-0.1569221467,
1.1992098093,
-0.2132766992,
0.6306234002,
-0.5317630172,
0.4332145154,
-0.531527102,
0.0848143622,
-0.337713331,
-0.6036139727,
-0.1279906332,
0.3337972462,
-0.1897116303,
-0.1694463491,
0.6818027496,
0.6064847112,
0.1058896855,
-0.0189889614,
0.2107223123,
0.2603390217,
0.6315535903,
0.5582498312,
0.7376386523,
-0.1704004854,
0.0238363966,
-0.1567690223,
-0.4023170471,
-0.382292062,
-1.0497153997,
-0.8101626635,
-0.5003479719,
-0.2531939745,
-0.3063919246,
-0.1987154335,
0.7861736417,
0.5675751567,
-0.6096751094,
-0.4499283731,
0.0362764411,
0.0014709781,
-0.3467884064,
-0.2921053469,
0.537778616,
-0.3325384259,
-0.705226481,
0.6910205483,
0.0524342619,
-0.0982041806,
-0.2114507705,
-0.1393069774,
-0.2610504031,
0.2601238787,
0.7660885453,
0.5267794728,
-0.5132642388,
-0.3202570081,
0.0969841853,
0.2141333818,
-0.206647113,
0.8987631202,
-0.8039306998,
0.2949641645,
0.1124559715,
0.6994016767,
0.8286165595,
-0.0635820553,
0.7904831171,
-0.5805574059,
0.2853073478,
0.3012378812,
0.4963255227,
0.4639087915,
-0.136471048,
0.3957205117,
0.0968006477,
-0.3510240614,
-1.2705023289,
0.2360399961,
-0.7463465929,
-0.3673862517,
1.3776262999,
-0.1669677645,
-0.4011037052,
0.2854144573,
-0.0880913511,
-0.0623395257,
-0.5090136528,
1.0873095989,
0.6901076436,
-0.2311012,
0.2052013725,
-0.5128349662,
0.5422085524,
0.3692774177,
-0.9966265559,
0.3516738117,
0.5767445564,
0.3215025961,
0.3772172034,
0.377881676,
0.1552824974,
0.2630276978,
0.11106617,
0.1591271162,
0.1020800099,
-0.5496364832,
0.0058700326,
0.3205930889,
0.1184282005,
0.0693672672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04254v1
|
Watermark-based Detection and Attribution of AI-Generated Content
| 2024-04-05T17:58:52 | 2024-04-05T17:58:52 |
Zhengyuan Jiang, Moyang Guo, Yuepeng Hu, Neil Zhenqiang Gong
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Several companies--such as Google, Microsoft, and OpenAI--have deployed
techniques to watermark AI-generated content to enable proactive detection.
However, existing literature mainly focuses on user-agnostic detection.
Attribution aims to further trace back the user of a generative-AI service who
generated a given content detected as AI-generated. Despite its growing
importance, attribution is largely unexplored. In this work, we aim to bridge
this gap by providing the first systematic study on watermark-based, user-aware
detection and attribution of AI-generated content. Specifically, we
theoretically study the detection and attribution performance via rigorous
probabilistic analysis. Moreover, we develop an efficient algorithm to select
watermarks for the users to enhance attribution performance. Both our
theoretical and empirical results show that watermark-based detection and
attribution inherit the accuracy and (non-)robustness properties of the
watermarking method.
|
[
-0.3029132485,
-0.6043357849,
0.4326904714,
0.0051463568,
-0.3150779009,
0.0306155514,
0.2776632905,
-0.5975565314,
0.1202315614,
0.3998230398,
-0.574531436,
-0.2049897909,
-0.5428280234,
-0.0568959005,
-0.6951397061,
0.8281315565,
-0.0457465909,
-0.6789489388,
-0.3948175311,
-0.316626519,
-0.1195578203,
-0.4076922834,
-0.7570405006,
-0.4026640356,
0.5204287171,
0.2687060833,
0.6601985097,
0.881382823,
0.4324451685,
0.2358163744,
0.0745073706,
0.2172310501,
-0.2664327919,
0.02644879,
-0.2024310827,
-0.4864894152,
-0.0079950029,
0.1769124269,
0.5922353268,
-0.1503445655,
0.133177951,
0.5049450397,
0.0429371744,
0.4702001512,
-1.2394434214,
0.1162181795,
-0.7084088922,
-0.0889446437,
-0.6336132884,
-0.377702862,
-0.369133234,
-0.3293716609,
-0.2975763679,
-0.911485672,
0.1011622399,
0.2446185946,
0.8449673057,
0.4545339346,
-0.1740469038,
-0.519099474,
-0.8283833861,
0.9258005619,
-0.5596206188,
-0.1259853095,
0.6676539183,
0.3513164818,
0.05166189,
-0.7181758881,
-0.8619320989,
0.0572367236,
0.1839779764,
0.0908164978,
-0.4946883917,
-0.6063843966,
0.0177378859,
0.3102556169,
-0.274903357,
0.0801234618,
0.125287354,
-0.2485686988,
0.8350253701,
-0.1253362596,
0.4149931371,
0.0080123805,
-0.4693185389,
-0.2059239,
-0.7013885379,
0.158848837,
0.6788413525,
-0.0928840041,
-0.0373642482,
0.7085612416,
0.1206619292,
0.3012887537,
-0.1551162601,
0.1086657122,
-0.0065018646,
-0.4016521573,
0.2505966127,
0.1349813193,
1.018886447,
0.0663407817,
0.8447607756,
-0.1516969651,
-0.3208045959,
0.0207345746,
0.4455328584,
-0.4591445625,
-0.4798843861,
-0.2194437832,
-0.605597198,
-0.6879437566,
0.2549088299,
-0.1968526691,
-0.6939675808,
0.1155135036,
0.6868264079,
-0.2555318177,
-0.4411868453,
-0.2742748857,
-0.3475784063,
0.0664211214,
0.2028449774,
-0.5446202755,
0.0379716605,
0.6421170831,
0.8215802312,
-0.5730229616,
-0.1171251684,
-0.4979083836,
0.6311266422,
-0.2127108723,
1.1298310757,
-0.5563769937,
-0.0661202073,
0.0898417905,
-0.2618502676,
0.2595203221,
-0.7979225516,
0.2962676585,
-0.8216763139,
0.05614179,
-0.3445957899,
-0.7726478577,
-0.1202550083,
0.1730386168,
-0.9845848083,
0.5519738197,
0.1038509682,
-0.8748601079,
0.725025475,
-0.9080635309,
-0.5335888863,
0.342610687,
-0.2670577765,
-0.7923035026,
-0.034266822,
0.2243700027,
0.1275622696,
-0.1035191566,
0.0686925128,
-0.0624165013,
-0.4645165801,
0.4728289247,
-0.7534531355,
0.9633536339,
0.172666043,
-0.3557637632,
0.2303539962,
-0.5996832252,
0.0108422171,
0.4591053724,
-0.2358486801,
-0.4243110418,
0.1030251309,
0.146916613,
-0.3420846164,
0.145762369,
-0.4974986315,
0.0535647683,
0.33976987,
0.3306784928,
0.7977932096,
0.1464800239,
0.2984720767,
-0.2078000903,
0.6506322026,
-0.0310472958,
0.1937329471,
-0.2642555833,
-0.7268725634,
-0.0957876816,
-0.6732698083,
0.3686675429,
0.6400600076,
-0.8059476018,
0.3453504145,
-0.0915837288,
-0.4857526422,
-0.5631053448,
0.164136067,
0.4243510962,
0.5826780796,
0.5515258908,
-0.4855467975,
-0.0108969035,
-0.9118186235,
-0.5176929832,
-0.6325318813,
-0.2486407608,
0.5717999339,
0.4267802835,
-0.0895108134,
1.1186324358,
-0.5283618569,
-0.5216374993,
-0.029623827,
0.6115507483,
-0.2026825994,
0.5560923815,
0.7104828358,
-0.9139240384,
-0.6405918002,
-0.3587418199,
-0.8672882915,
-0.3267570734,
-0.1121947318,
0.1418017,
-0.0375667736,
0.3682917953,
-0.4647390246,
0.8097468019,
0.3921587765,
-0.3066242933,
0.6880486012,
-0.1112697423,
0.4388490021,
-0.7571668029,
0.3128542006,
-0.0026631686,
-0.2492603362,
-0.1537684351,
-0.2010797858,
-0.0645167306,
-0.1626650542,
-0.4330295324,
0.6079301238,
-0.1868974566,
-0.1705533415,
-0.5714159012,
-0.387572825,
0.0708608255,
0.260294199,
-0.0043476135,
1.0453926325,
0.4572563469,
-0.430811435,
0.4637786746,
0.3009783924,
-0.4374086857,
0.5841752291,
-0.9143736959,
0.0796421543,
-0.0142040448,
0.0819693208,
-1.1076475382,
0.1537774056,
0.7687842846,
-0.5629764199,
-0.0039300141,
-0.4786965549,
-0.8790668249,
0.0464325212,
-0.2787855864,
0.7152248621,
0.4429485798,
-0.5492219329,
0.4405198395,
0.0541353859,
-0.0697934404,
-0.1621416211,
-0.7065906525,
0.0494172052,
-0.5144290924,
-0.5828278661,
0.7250007987,
0.0796892717,
-0.2942847013,
0.3528378904,
-0.0109057296,
-0.3334349096,
0.3032769859,
0.3878946602,
-0.0524178818,
-0.2335319519,
-0.4174396396,
-0.2505777776,
-0.3697245121,
0.094188109,
0.0613825247,
0.246858865,
0.14493379,
-0.984197557,
-0.9980834723,
0.522358954,
0.3229627013,
-0.5214396715,
0.7427582741,
0.835737884,
-0.393381685,
0.0384748951,
-0.3795750141,
-0.3074882329,
-0.5143128633,
-0.1864080727,
0.1746000499,
-0.4490537941,
0.780924499,
0.103538081,
0.0803618729,
0.5755457878,
0.2778840065,
-0.4909457564,
0.921492815,
0.5914683342,
-0.4508528411,
0.8509533405,
-0.0900450796,
0.1060978547,
-0.4647642672,
-0.1264193952,
-0.5943813324,
-0.3968130052,
-0.4437643588,
-0.0199384298,
0.1664619148,
0.0397533588,
-0.1688035727,
0.3312852085,
-0.3140806258,
0.3830423653,
0.9927283525,
0.1187228486,
0.3893873394,
0.2501865923,
0.6158316731,
0.0503231026,
-0.3481787145,
-0.4334388077,
1.0507413149,
0.0730851218,
0.7474384308,
0.1823189706,
0.5690003633,
1.3905831575,
0.3630638719,
-0.457829088,
0.2748464644,
-0.0455673076,
-0.6826375127,
-0.4364284277,
-0.2319873124,
-0.9973373413,
-0.4224640131,
-0.1640444845,
-0.6674601436,
-0.1226196662,
0.3639448583,
-0.2646922767,
0.24127388,
-0.5356702209,
0.7224889398,
-0.155075714,
-0.5375933647,
-0.3175342381,
-0.3189738989,
-0.1096249148,
-0.186189577,
0.0210890062,
0.0016309873,
-0.0012699553,
0.9176696539,
-0.2589803636,
0.4669265449,
-0.5533553362,
-0.2521980405,
0.7552531362,
0.0536239482,
0.6230300665,
0.2609096169,
0.0079942085,
0.1690178812,
-0.5608970523,
-0.2621552944,
-0.5296395421,
0.279289335,
-0.5571419597,
-0.4246635139,
-0.3301587999,
-0.179740712,
0.1558400244,
0.4241010249,
0.3683930039,
0.0894735456,
0.1634783596,
0.1218680888,
0.5954098701,
-0.3393802047,
0.4665639699,
0.5406510234,
0.2807763815,
-0.1658985764,
1.2635161877,
-0.1692267358,
-0.2291640937,
-0.0051368778,
0.2228290737,
-0.2561528385,
-0.7719771862,
-0.6216269135,
0.0669442788,
-0.5315034389,
-0.2198976278,
-0.2044395506,
-0.3359164596,
-0.0247451328,
-0.3296703994,
-0.6710034013,
-0.0125835165,
-0.5209468007,
0.4136195481,
0.3152686357,
0.4498343766,
0.0543859079,
0.4625050128,
-0.4574747682,
0.5601933002,
0.3617087603,
0.2360635698,
-0.0168096069,
-0.5315346718,
-0.0650371835,
0.1905985624,
-0.4861850142,
-0.5486574769,
-0.0208189748,
0.4581758976,
0.7172190547,
0.7042027116,
0.1386040449,
0.4642991722,
-0.1664782912,
0.9647480249,
0.0912026986,
-0.8467636704,
0.7667236328,
-0.0708894357,
0.0394083224,
0.4740645587,
0.3453619778,
-0.0151196588,
-0.2022112459,
-0.7515429854,
-0.8848254085,
0.4983780086,
0.6314657927,
0.1848435551,
0.2749396563,
0.4166505635,
0.1132220179,
0.1888368875,
-0.4462952018,
-0.3236940801,
-0.2904157937,
-0.0482369512,
-0.0091234185,
-0.0707138479,
-0.0660751462,
0.0999187157,
0.6368458867,
-0.218348965,
0.5889768004,
-0.042628929,
-0.2951394618,
-0.1895757914,
-0.1619995683,
0.3651078641,
0.5559748411,
0.0317337513,
-0.0122671798,
-0.4991573691,
-0.3694161773,
0.1045223325,
0.0530226044,
-0.5552809238,
-0.1048578545,
0.9213913679,
0.5659961104,
-0.5159720182,
-0.6494274735,
0.8567537665,
-0.0697905868,
0.0460210368,
-0.5827214122,
0.3888973594,
-0.1552512199,
0.4759636521,
0.7395224571,
0.0083435709,
0.3247428238,
-0.4772510529,
0.405780524,
0.61850214,
-0.3242025971,
-0.4230748713,
0.8805727959,
0.0242648143,
-0.2542510033,
0.9664120078,
0.0124346949,
-0.5178428292,
0.7693536282,
0.4559162259,
0.8720747828,
0.130336836,
0.1229958534,
-0.0497857779,
-0.0329601131,
0.1386961788,
0.2896793485,
-0.4919267893,
-1.1363085508,
-0.0271441583,
-0.2598332167,
-0.4622024596,
0.1505909711,
-0.7980679274,
-0.0665664077,
-0.3065677583,
-0.4431786239,
0.2887195051,
-0.2116838247,
-0.5050631166,
0.1788678318,
0.4043436348,
0.6174117327,
-0.9523460865,
0.4365766644,
0.7454305291,
-0.3273712397,
-0.3138780296,
0.2582084537,
0.1119170785,
-1.0122202635,
0.2514296174,
0.186236918,
-0.101030156,
0.2492191344,
-0.8629773259,
-0.5014823675,
1.1331707239,
0.3859788477,
0.1584575027,
0.4786133468,
0.3318132162,
0.3043680489,
-0.2941581011,
-0.0406931937,
0.0859350488,
0.5260002613,
-0.0604921989,
-0.4402915835,
0.0485792309,
-0.3778412342,
-0.1564865112,
-0.2471387684,
-0.3989846706,
0.4029639959,
-0.0537778437,
-0.116628699,
-0.1567790359,
0.7733094096,
0.3923610449,
0.5564033985,
0.6503629088,
0.3015184402,
0.454128772,
0.1755950153,
0.8905389309,
-0.0420778058,
0.0856733993,
0.71415627,
-0.1557390839,
0.5990347266,
0.6170918345,
-0.170114696,
0.446367979,
0.4546817541,
-0.602486074,
1.0290013552,
0.1892176419,
-0.3882944882,
-0.1221597195,
-0.7565299273,
-0.2721875012,
0.4944427013,
0.1367655843,
-0.7695176601,
0.1755945086,
-0.2505313754,
0.0180492681,
-0.0962055326,
-0.2582899332,
1.0101867914,
-0.1618031859,
-0.5251517892,
0.4390449226,
0.1551793665,
0.8234428167,
-0.5799990296,
0.0606079809,
-0.1430385858,
0.1794532686,
-0.3267078996,
-1.0078021288,
0.5427083373,
0.2950471342,
-0.2383042574,
-0.3470647335,
1.1436063051,
-0.0605850704,
-0.1211858839,
-0.0104161547,
0.3524062932,
0.1691099852,
-0.6490858793,
-0.5293813348,
0.098254472,
-0.0032978985,
-0.5297641158,
0.1335539222,
0.1815302074,
-0.3699637949,
1.0039404631,
0.6821476221,
-0.0757261366,
-0.0820579603,
-0.0092353085,
0.6374574304,
-0.2834867537,
-0.4779101014,
-0.9974079728,
0.4853438735,
-0.0323198773,
-0.1791264564,
0.5853821039,
0.5405783653,
0.7720061541,
-0.2320057899,
1.1852471828,
-0.3288625181,
-0.3087281585,
-0.1352949142,
0.985009253,
-0.9007068276,
-0.0760053545,
-0.423312366,
-0.8855425715,
-0.0616705567,
0.350905478,
0.2433579564,
-0.087726526,
-0.0170436464,
0.5993878841,
-0.3036355674,
0.0675089061,
-0.0829735324,
-0.7586596012,
0.6670926213,
0.2384302765,
0.7754995823,
-0.314841032,
0.5292896628,
-0.1707298011,
-0.3432132304,
-0.2217942029,
-1.1974961758,
-0.5216216445,
-0.607363224,
-0.7239094377,
0.1331899315,
0.0600748397,
0.2237225622,
0.7108822465,
-1.0517725945,
0.3239360452,
-0.1263099909,
-0.0531983636,
-0.6227528453,
-0.1798176169,
0.5086529851,
0.4291114211,
-0.194186911,
0.077712588,
-0.0090814121,
0.3374269903,
-0.3019959927,
-0.1191303432,
0.0060850461,
0.1830840707,
0.2205611169,
0.4805627167,
-0.283372581,
-0.2879812717,
-0.301910162,
0.0044747852,
-0.0430123731,
0.8990741372,
-0.474101752,
0.0456341207,
0.470066905,
0.7405619621,
0.3686454892,
0.5612986088,
0.3823864758,
-0.8308142424,
-0.0273847897,
0.1960007101,
-0.1063269079,
0.40242064,
-0.4112292528,
0.3481574953,
0.5932225585,
-0.3976468742,
-0.553425312,
0.2165766507,
-0.5262290239,
0.0211036112,
0.8893004656,
-0.6977735162,
0.1214604005,
-0.0403032489,
0.1715164185,
0.5467141271,
-0.4929130673,
1.0305677652,
0.5904396176,
-0.171047464,
-0.1432573497,
-0.1502463669,
0.4679925144,
0.3325376511,
-0.7737693787,
0.1085565388,
0.2237272114,
0.2512461543,
0.2258062959,
0.505468905,
-0.062995106,
0.2820999622,
0.0449112952,
-0.0078012538,
-0.5092626214,
-0.4492511153,
0.258916229,
0.1985267997,
0.1015054211,
-0.4700071216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04251v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04251v2
|
Who Evaluates the Evaluations? Objectively Scoring Text-to-Image Prompt Coherence Metrics with T2IScoreScore (TS2)
| 2024-04-05T17:57:16 | 2024-05-22T20:19:27 |
Michael Saxon, Fatima Jahara, Mahsa Khoshnoodi, Yujie Lu, Aditya Sharma, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With advances in the quality of text-to-image (T2I) models has come interest
in benchmarking their prompt faithfulness-the semantic coherence of generated
images to the prompts they were conditioned on. A variety of T2I faithfulness
metrics have been proposed, leveraging advances in cross-modal embeddings and
vision-language models (VLMs). However, these metrics are not rigorously
compared and benchmarked, instead presented with correlation to human Likert
scores over a set of easy-to-discriminate images against seemingly weak
baselines.
We introduce T2IScoreScore (TS2), a curated set of semantic error graphs
containing a prompt and a set increasingly erroneous images. These allow us to
rigorously judge whether a given prompt faithfulness metric can correctly order
images with respect to their objective error count and significantly
discriminate between different error nodes, using meta-metric scores derived
from established statistical tests. Surprisingly, we find that the
state-of-the-art VLM-based metrics (e.g., TIFA, DSG, LLMScore, VIEScore) we
tested fail to significantly outperform simple (and supposedly worse)
feature-based metrics like CLIPScore, particularly on a hard subset of
naturally-occurring T2I model errors. TS2 will enable the development of better
T2I prompt faithfulness metrics through more rigorous comparison of their
conformity to expected orderings and separations under objective criteria.
|
[
-0.1520960033,
-0.5543454289,
0.8556677103,
0.1421182305,
-0.4982722998,
-0.0050895168,
0.0135199847,
-0.5420438051,
-0.195930019,
0.1296481937,
-0.4998621345,
-0.5990962386,
-0.7537646294,
0.3163903952,
-0.3290617466,
0.8901250958,
-0.1336830109,
0.3305487335,
-0.5093632936,
-0.5053852201,
-0.6676107049,
0.0883105472,
-0.5787078738,
-0.1282954365,
0.3489915431,
0.4645514786,
0.7505018115,
0.4143752754,
0.7043066621,
0.1672530323,
0.158736065,
0.3468773365,
-0.5254803896,
0.2275085002,
-0.289508462,
-0.4232286811,
-0.459795624,
0.2228551954,
0.4775355756,
0.4257666767,
0.3757271767,
0.3809719086,
0.3992484808,
0.4543027282,
-0.5922430158,
0.0695668831,
-0.2165884674,
0.1664700955,
0.0127435001,
-0.3647663593,
-0.5223776102,
-0.5962356329,
0.3713024855,
-0.482504636,
0.3032240868,
0.260494411,
0.9986530542,
0.291711688,
-0.3235607147,
-0.4277879,
-0.3618333638,
1.0666395426,
-0.1069469452,
0.5003532767,
0.4294751883,
0.4281777442,
0.0821283609,
-0.6908363104,
-0.0431139469,
-0.3725076616,
-0.060908597,
0.4321240187,
-0.4132816494,
-0.1339548379,
0.2002535164,
0.1059198454,
-0.6570721269,
0.0725395605,
-0.1000834256,
-0.4959617257,
0.3671701849,
0.2601255476,
0.3953372538,
-0.2428189516,
-0.541947782,
-0.1725170314,
-0.3345695734,
0.249368161,
0.0441367179,
-0.2084170133,
-0.0846175626,
0.8218631148,
-0.0564691201,
0.4154727757,
0.2248536646,
-0.1753805727,
0.2373680919,
-0.7352078557,
0.1689252853,
-0.2567369342,
1.0552792549,
1.0374457836,
0.3035144806,
-0.3634593189,
-0.3669600487,
0.4835422933,
0.0811354816,
-0.8526737094,
-0.0124801882,
0.2338344455,
-0.5335565209,
-0.2416692674,
0.0532518663,
-0.6163670421,
-0.2052499205,
-0.2246523798,
0.472705245,
-0.6027881503,
-0.0726613998,
-0.4363065362,
-0.6716973782,
0.1613769531,
0.640440166,
-0.3099243641,
0.25032112,
0.8379082084,
0.9775983691,
-0.4603351653,
-0.4154268205,
-0.6797909737,
-0.1951550692,
-0.7877208591,
1.1641961336,
-0.50190413,
-0.4302513897,
-0.1001456305,
-0.0593614727,
0.2347566485,
-0.4251245856,
0.9295284748,
-0.367631048,
0.2997688651,
-0.5778953433,
-0.5372156501,
0.0369343646,
0.4916987717,
-0.4197399914,
1.1466268301,
0.3357754052,
-0.6480153203,
0.7373425961,
-0.3644491732,
-0.043020919,
-0.0613222346,
-0.1948400885,
-0.4510819912,
0.3235643804,
0.0289611388,
0.2513183951,
-0.5765032768,
0.3393507898,
-0.408942014,
-0.4494947195,
0.252078563,
-0.4400072396,
0.5425246954,
0.0414125621,
-0.2313354015,
-0.0123245427,
-0.6030133963,
0.4430876076,
-0.0687468573,
0.2698638439,
-0.3913170099,
-0.03124642,
0.0405165851,
0.1515029967,
0.1402834952,
-0.6368222833,
-0.4125121236,
-0.0223120153,
0.283854574,
0.5572736263,
0.117481865,
0.3045133352,
-0.3460766971,
0.0901435763,
0.1476264745,
0.3584518135,
-0.2791325748,
-0.7529945374,
-0.604983449,
-0.1235760376,
0.024169568,
0.5255349874,
-0.6650674939,
0.5219667554,
-0.3947702944,
-0.7716057301,
-0.4765667617,
-0.1468514651,
0.8488729596,
0.8858286738,
0.442247957,
-0.6767385602,
-0.090054661,
-1.014621377,
-0.4947119951,
-0.4949406087,
-0.1554154903,
0.4222727418,
0.3535144329,
0.002740691,
1.0312410593,
-0.247734502,
-0.2218004912,
0.2057242244,
0.2957974672,
-0.0947943777,
0.4127614796,
0.6056607962,
-0.3431929648,
-0.3347038329,
-0.3837868869,
-0.9402953386,
-0.3787989914,
0.2230956554,
-0.0440349169,
0.3458324075,
0.2408129275,
-0.3832772374,
0.4657500386,
0.473126471,
-0.7801998258,
0.7146196365,
-0.1980269104,
0.6902447343,
-0.9563988447,
0.0797204748,
0.1670786589,
-0.4190360904,
-0.3268642426,
-0.1207971051,
0.1277723163,
-0.0381994285,
-0.2282101512,
0.5162842274,
-0.4539526701,
-0.4551806748,
-0.0291950833,
0.1629085243,
0.5860650539,
0.1585273445,
-0.1130855903,
0.9518127441,
0.5019603372,
-0.3884681165,
0.2416733056,
0.4334132075,
-0.4698334634,
1.4334160089,
-1.0795567036,
0.4589132369,
-0.060356684,
0.1838978827,
-1.4062889814,
-0.0932549909,
0.2437283993,
-0.6854400635,
0.247254163,
0.0395766273,
-0.5022462606,
-0.1628627479,
-0.5078659654,
0.5722296238,
0.7441960573,
-0.523588419,
0.3816933036,
0.001443895,
0.2175870985,
-0.3628737628,
-0.9525653124,
0.3510063589,
0.2098815292,
-0.9283624887,
0.1809989214,
0.0147561403,
-0.2264946252,
0.1986029893,
0.0219794754,
-0.0709674507,
0.0267131757,
0.3382460177,
0.220863387,
-0.2524433434,
0.0825699866,
0.0467742719,
-0.4287512302,
0.1705813557,
-0.3199278414,
0.2161987722,
-0.2010328472,
-0.584956944,
-0.8934367895,
0.366733849,
0.4786839187,
-0.104985863,
0.2227248251,
0.6162332296,
-0.0810153708,
0.1015633941,
-0.6973543763,
-0.0575319789,
-0.4025377631,
0.5270928741,
-0.3750885129,
-0.6364066601,
0.4080547094,
0.137908414,
0.0589599237,
0.7549133301,
0.2011632025,
-0.4025996625,
1.0150104761,
0.1926888376,
0.4478073418,
0.3881536424,
-0.1050493643,
-0.1233692914,
-0.7886823416,
-0.4836312532,
-0.6170087457,
-0.1506881267,
-0.4602626264,
-0.4993376732,
0.6167395711,
-0.0010315105,
-0.3294946253,
0.2521499991,
-0.3937718868,
0.4560826719,
0.4238842428,
0.4495730102,
0.266484946,
0.2172873616,
-0.0357202142,
-0.2763685286,
-0.2875758708,
-0.6880842447,
0.9686347246,
0.4432918727,
0.5942345262,
-0.0764830485,
0.3474986851,
0.6869533062,
0.079142347,
-0.9468488693,
0.6012772918,
-0.3609935641,
-0.1526697576,
-0.0016419806,
-0.2306956202,
-0.6481852531,
-0.2812319398,
-0.1119147167,
-0.6070432067,
0.2315091342,
0.1207453236,
-0.1324062496,
-0.0413886607,
-0.805801034,
0.8674182892,
-0.1711021811,
-0.6378616691,
-0.2497837991,
-0.5486412644,
0.0982644856,
0.1154378206,
-0.2308666557,
-0.1826442778,
-0.6538994908,
0.7478586435,
-0.482703805,
0.5964455605,
-0.1672434956,
0.0783644095,
0.4668416083,
0.3533582389,
0.4200809896,
-0.045335494,
-0.1503813118,
0.6489340067,
0.1472947448,
-0.4910367131,
-0.6998381019,
0.4293790162,
-0.9719997048,
-0.3316064477,
-0.3160987496,
-0.0806357414,
-0.3780998588,
0.0703255981,
0.6171627641,
0.9217165112,
-0.3910759687,
-0.0603015795,
0.3632720113,
-0.0618228689,
0.3879427612,
0.2837261856,
0.1792620569,
-0.7591053843,
0.8157672882,
0.1348470151,
0.4384330213,
0.0619899742,
0.2124861181,
-0.5199717283,
-0.497202754,
-0.7042359114,
-0.01604902,
-0.9142422676,
-0.2826162577,
-0.5442706347,
-0.0414035283,
-0.1415357292,
0.0189921558,
-0.3378745019,
-0.2574268579,
-0.5227047205,
0.1466143727,
0.1748437732,
0.7422665954,
0.2347214222,
0.0565284938,
-0.9096485376,
0.2286904007,
0.1931127757,
0.7538668513,
-0.1709994227,
-0.7782775164,
0.1303283274,
-0.1663106233,
-0.2060766369,
-0.827772975,
-0.0907612965,
0.3424611688,
0.3176721036,
0.3876353204,
-0.0729940832,
0.8267234564,
-0.5108958483,
1.2194094658,
0.556514442,
-0.9981659651,
0.6452370286,
-0.1415083259,
0.1467902958,
0.7784250975,
0.0407435857,
-0.4490092397,
-0.4969826937,
-0.3672268093,
-0.334179163,
0.7819646597,
0.2073025107,
0.0458004661,
-0.0635854006,
0.3796591759,
0.3065654337,
-0.0778212622,
-0.1751220226,
-0.0347473212,
-0.4376267791,
-0.3929116428,
-0.0929206833,
-0.6926047206,
-0.0363108777,
0.0381339267,
0.2311797887,
-0.2142031491,
0.3583669662,
0.6650318503,
-0.1134736165,
-0.3790748715,
0.2262662202,
0.4182590246,
0.607708931,
-0.0844591558,
0.1605677605,
0.0828446522,
-0.6041712761,
0.2981826961,
-0.351426512,
-0.4154050052,
0.1977551728,
0.7169454694,
0.9525127411,
-0.0603896044,
-0.4826609492,
0.957264483,
-0.2405454516,
-0.0436667949,
-0.2255002856,
0.0470884256,
-0.4810457528,
0.2495118231,
0.2620295584,
0.7147787213,
0.3613769412,
-0.4680512249,
0.1351669133,
0.4082453847,
-0.9471955895,
-0.6969383955,
0.2905878425,
0.2481233627,
-0.462379843,
0.6182488799,
-0.2745090127,
-0.4008490741,
0.6502111554,
0.3357749581,
1.331076622,
-0.018653091,
0.2051107734,
0.6642052531,
0.3747713268,
-0.1971887201,
0.4135707319,
-0.0832541063,
-0.3968764246,
-0.0500483066,
-0.2708865702,
-0.5233718157,
-0.4837989509,
-0.657826364,
0.4552981257,
-0.4514142573,
-0.5294578075,
-0.1159749255,
-0.1087199971,
-0.710631907,
0.3844537735,
0.0274400879,
1.0540914536,
-0.8172646761,
0.2631995678,
0.6074247956,
-0.2351576835,
-0.6753839254,
0.1715141982,
0.0694208071,
-0.7872003317,
0.5522100329,
0.3973799646,
-0.2292050123,
-0.2288966626,
-0.5701750517,
-0.7042087913,
1.2701128721,
0.3188337386,
-0.4639849067,
0.1402018964,
0.0894021764,
0.7631679773,
-0.3200037181,
0.9708724618,
0.4840863049,
0.4149132967,
0.260755688,
-0.8286982179,
0.1823146045,
-0.2768858075,
0.0613198578,
-0.0800168589,
-0.8143306971,
0.3907318115,
-0.4166434109,
-0.5013638139,
0.3547237217,
0.4920789301,
0.1911570579,
0.8548045158,
0.6981177926,
0.5939184427,
0.6074113846,
-0.4287424982,
1.2150377035,
-0.2398628891,
0.3135604262,
0.8910731673,
-0.1076909751,
0.8382219672,
0.4930842817,
-0.1633045524,
0.3833776116,
0.7923259735,
-0.305649668,
0.5693387985,
-0.3855766952,
0.2487965226,
-0.3252078593,
-0.6735411882,
-0.2760894299,
0.2482624203,
0.1168072298,
-0.4785892963,
-0.3822622597,
-0.2836612463,
-0.3578497171,
0.0211478807,
-0.2031117678,
1.0029883385,
0.1357363313,
-1.0862226486,
0.4512814283,
-0.2990480363,
0.4215849936,
-0.3971675634,
0.0745879188,
-0.2050778568,
0.0246197693,
-0.4358122945,
-1.3897528648,
0.4321294427,
0.3001378477,
-0.3212755322,
-0.1245141849,
0.6124103069,
-0.2214861214,
-0.4794225693,
0.4746125638,
0.428573072,
0.2099154592,
0.1977628022,
-0.7685191035,
0.0704365298,
-0.401737839,
-0.1062669456,
-0.1752640158,
0.3484045267,
-0.1343833506,
0.3177680671,
0.2440976799,
-0.2704375386,
-0.3098639846,
0.1994575709,
0.6792750955,
-0.4545923769,
-0.4055066705,
-0.8588183522,
0.3983486593,
-0.1890794784,
-0.5632933974,
0.6644150019,
0.5576605797,
0.3671967089,
0.0468754359,
0.5006404519,
0.1480653882,
0.4033456743,
-0.3671480119,
0.5671457052,
-0.8041428924,
-0.0102301408,
-0.3974715173,
-1.012624979,
0.0537588075,
-0.0849265754,
-0.2723189592,
0.104570508,
0.8447281122,
0.8071185946,
-0.020941982,
0.0326328017,
0.4250808656,
0.1160274744,
0.1227327064,
0.5904632807,
1.125097394,
-0.6635331511,
0.4918755591,
-0.0058155823,
-0.4002837241,
-0.1100528166,
-0.8345690966,
-0.9812367558,
-0.4721355736,
-0.5171321034,
-0.8430632949,
0.1402327567,
0.8703903556,
0.5216656327,
-0.9279773831,
0.1471665949,
-0.1002648398,
-0.0529658347,
-0.0455160663,
-0.1862301677,
0.5527042747,
-0.4580917358,
-0.5802261233,
-0.0850505605,
0.6533129215,
0.1850935519,
-0.1852276325,
-0.1866364777,
0.6012296081,
0.033988338,
0.4610875547,
-0.2101916522,
-0.8866006732,
-0.3971684873,
0.2741524875,
-0.6177225709,
0.2380550206,
0.4172171354,
-0.5671287179,
0.6832405925,
0.8163766265,
0.3237269521,
-0.0114999879,
0.0551403388,
0.4001995027,
-0.485060811,
-0.0824343339,
0.2339583486,
0.2834922075,
0.5184039474,
-0.1831285357,
0.4912533164,
0.5370471478,
-0.4107533097,
-0.7675244808,
0.194554314,
-1.284162879,
0.1694480479,
1.1083219051,
-0.3787043691,
-0.4976301789,
-0.0959509611,
-0.2735513747,
0.1535600126,
-0.4450484812,
0.6031858325,
0.5515417457,
0.1316934228,
-0.1859599054,
-0.2333082855,
0.4807136655,
0.474797368,
-0.6861276627,
-0.4541963041,
0.5376210213,
0.5317337513,
0.3545900285,
0.5153117776,
-0.2696287334,
0.7199522853,
0.0736385956,
-0.3672623932,
-0.1725596488,
-0.1737132967,
-0.2500726581,
0.20624277,
0.0764241219,
-0.2581933737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04242v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04242v1
|
Physical Property Understanding from Language-Embedded Feature Fields
| 2024-04-05T17:45:07 | 2024-04-05T17:45:07 |
Albert J. Zhai, Yuan Shen, Emily Y. Chen, Gloria X. Wang, Xinlei Wang, Sheng Wang, Kaiyu Guan, Shenlong Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Can computers perceive the physical properties of objects solely through
vision? Research in cognitive science and vision science has shown that humans
excel at identifying materials and estimating their physical properties based
purely on visual appearance. In this paper, we present a novel approach for
dense prediction of the physical properties of objects using a collection of
images. Inspired by how humans reason about physics through vision, we leverage
large language models to propose candidate materials for each object. We then
construct a language-embedded point cloud and estimate the physical properties
of each 3D point using a zero-shot kernel regression approach. Our method is
accurate, annotation-free, and applicable to any object in the open world.
Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach in various
physical property reasoning tasks, such as estimating the mass of common
objects, as well as other properties like friction and hardness.
|
[
-0.332111299,
-1.0884777308,
0.9539894462,
-0.126727134,
-0.2574712336,
-0.1867293119,
-0.2058911026,
-0.7831187248,
0.2078323364,
0.4963596463,
0.0394255072,
-0.3914209008,
-0.4322981834,
-0.505002439,
-0.176172331,
0.4516227245,
-0.1728307009,
-0.2037539035,
-0.5540930033,
-0.1036414802,
-0.1281017214,
-0.2963725626,
0.067763932,
-0.2381401956,
0.3320243061,
0.0609213412,
0.8939090967,
0.7194601893,
0.3250362575,
0.2381407171,
0.1107546166,
-0.0687749386,
-0.0353764109,
-0.1402422488,
-0.2092431635,
-0.3486368656,
-0.1202763692,
-0.0995355546,
0.5144286752,
0.8976310492,
0.3590976298,
0.0672002807,
0.1869503409,
0.3678905964,
-1.0103189945,
0.222403422,
-0.699277997,
0.6183304191,
-0.0642537102,
-0.2006697208,
-0.4157096148,
0.3311243653,
0.0615812577,
-0.9251955152,
0.6920114756,
-0.1800364554,
0.9131951928,
0.1251646429,
-0.1817252636,
0.1838491261,
-0.8653528094,
1.1295031309,
0.0683533773,
0.7761906385,
0.8445331454,
0.428981632,
0.0371531062,
-0.0734364092,
-0.4703181088,
-0.3213852644,
-0.1500923187,
0.2364528775,
0.3579939604,
-0.0287489127,
-0.0490440652,
0.1940295398,
-0.419572264,
-0.1941580176,
-0.3648138344,
-0.1625759602,
0.7163316011,
-0.1576130539,
0.2689895034,
-0.0403903201,
-0.2716480792,
-0.4026905596,
-0.3295347095,
0.048052825,
-0.118749693,
0.3495272994,
-0.1238677949,
0.9034545422,
-0.17484653,
0.8295330405,
-0.2231363058,
-0.2185859531,
0.047402747,
-0.0877475217,
-0.28861624,
-0.0406066477,
0.713201344,
0.1827278733,
0.2095758468,
-0.3243117034,
-0.0936739668,
-0.1274572909,
0.1626988649,
-0.576218307,
-0.5402500629,
0.3868888021,
-0.4263524711,
-0.3438178301,
0.3106737137,
-0.5637794733,
-0.7647188902,
-0.1914790422,
0.5357066393,
-0.3568011224,
-0.4584151506,
0.2049072236,
-0.2172969729,
0.0687645525,
0.5984330177,
-1.0351420641,
0.2836030722,
0.724413991,
0.8484041691,
0.4248601496,
-0.4955667257,
-0.3513993621,
0.1654727012,
-0.3632544875,
1.0227445364,
-0.6769199967,
-0.4453615546,
-0.2431312203,
-0.241618365,
0.5405551195,
-0.4093477726,
-0.0524387769,
-0.0460692309,
-0.1584888101,
-0.073925972,
-0.0450265929,
-0.2600399852,
0.2693624794,
-0.7599009871,
1.0376527309,
0.2184077948,
-0.5761176944,
0.8072162271,
-0.3335511088,
-0.3813552856,
0.2713561058,
-0.281976223,
-0.4240599573,
0.5930615067,
0.3119439781,
0.7567788363,
-0.1259209067,
0.2082626969,
-0.6550213099,
-0.2895526886,
0.5574265718,
-0.1754213423,
0.2764184773,
0.2477303147,
-0.1355500966,
-0.1709390134,
-0.7504712343,
-0.0589635633,
0.0507874154,
0.0525146909,
-0.4700080454,
0.5749961138,
0.1706006229,
-0.0238867961,
0.663658917,
-0.8582100272,
0.070880346,
-0.0236302707,
-0.2356079221,
0.4199036658,
-0.2100109756,
0.7991917133,
0.1821157485,
0.1379416138,
0.2046709359,
0.2281691432,
0.0180625301,
-0.5295417309,
-0.2977492511,
-0.4296772182,
-0.2173119187,
0.2894702852,
-0.3744663596,
0.3696025908,
0.0046700612,
-0.6047800183,
-0.2108770311,
0.4552591145,
0.3392037749,
0.572581172,
0.3997715116,
0.1167802513,
-0.2615992129,
-0.7033420205,
-0.1820471734,
-0.2236127555,
-0.4316703081,
0.7054599524,
0.1572620571,
0.1142210066,
1.0861369371,
-0.8758998513,
-0.0133970426,
0.0029660049,
0.263282299,
0.0382234789,
0.345374018,
0.4290960431,
-0.8174281716,
-0.3925056159,
0.8453069925,
-1.2488979101,
0.019282423,
-0.1767335385,
-0.0489472039,
0.1252184659,
0.1898410469,
-0.1968498826,
0.4913308918,
0.3766251504,
-0.7111845016,
0.2320534289,
-0.2540334761,
-0.0777438805,
-0.5778398514,
0.1793118864,
0.7884853482,
-0.1209907085,
-0.3628627658,
0.0691542998,
0.0593074821,
-0.477525562,
-0.71501261,
1.014030695,
-0.6186185479,
-0.6215845346,
-0.204810679,
0.0558046252,
0.1734014302,
0.434237808,
0.6448423862,
0.3674042523,
0.8714178205,
-0.6483708024,
0.2734967172,
0.0817497075,
-0.3887561858,
0.7463815808,
-0.4747074544,
-0.0844896436,
-0.3483922184,
-0.2325685769,
-0.4623068571,
-0.0987283289,
-0.0120367808,
-0.4745899141,
0.0519523509,
-0.199576363,
-0.3583427966,
-0.0398914814,
-0.1478401124,
0.3362611234,
0.183084473,
-0.3045793474,
0.8932228684,
0.3998861611,
0.090314351,
-0.5831167698,
-0.5702316165,
-0.0945762321,
0.0537176505,
-0.5933650136,
0.1131846607,
-0.1895633042,
-0.5772427917,
0.2696835399,
0.0892702416,
-0.6905940771,
0.4141969681,
0.5386937261,
0.1850359589,
-0.2195263505,
0.0488432683,
-0.2157989591,
-0.0148363113,
-0.2227627486,
-0.3982560039,
0.2900585234,
-0.4813021719,
-0.1895090193,
-0.2629570961,
0.1393153518,
0.4875527918,
-0.1039582342,
0.4737799168,
0.3981212676,
-0.7085091472,
-0.365588963,
-0.5306589603,
-0.1557875574,
-0.4346248209,
0.5669290423,
-0.6737492085,
-0.438752234,
0.506785512,
0.3476763368,
-0.1149251536,
0.3413557708,
0.2753123939,
-0.4606553316,
0.9983544946,
0.8812823892,
0.3139469624,
0.5504319072,
-0.4260214269,
0.1674941331,
-0.5773569942,
-0.6821928024,
-0.2519130111,
-0.5267493129,
-0.2749711573,
-0.4364217818,
0.3075269759,
0.3599455655,
-0.1944912076,
0.4891465306,
-0.7464776635,
0.6287767887,
0.3043709397,
0.6647080779,
0.0685474798,
0.0922696888,
0.0724059343,
0.0395415835,
-0.1657771766,
-0.3199909627,
0.8357322812,
0.3876349032,
0.5947757959,
-0.44052279,
0.3813897967,
0.0289403219,
0.1591626108,
-1.1229174137,
0.5478682518,
-0.2450309247,
-0.3093713224,
-0.4523868561,
-0.534255743,
-0.7786210775,
0.341832757,
-0.3757367134,
-0.8505485058,
0.2195979655,
0.3227051497,
-0.1835107952,
0.6208204031,
-0.7293277979,
0.8662079573,
-0.7827318907,
-0.4759518206,
-0.1003284454,
-0.1166958287,
0.1823213249,
-0.0963511616,
0.2627997398,
-0.1946506798,
-0.0537053309,
0.5769531131,
-0.3983286619,
0.8027894497,
-0.4063474536,
0.0490138233,
0.5689351559,
0.4893653095,
0.0074725216,
0.097535342,
-0.1634996086,
0.5220854282,
0.1081604064,
-0.6757368445,
-0.975807488,
0.6404875517,
-0.9955426455,
-0.063264139,
-0.2591178119,
-0.6801671982,
-0.1344721168,
0.2524514496,
0.0668987855,
0.2463907301,
-0.1753933579,
0.0235563256,
0.3552681506,
-0.2473893911,
0.4213252068,
0.4115893245,
-0.2093548924,
-0.207825169,
1.2664755583,
0.1565265507,
-0.1344651878,
0.8243846297,
0.7117441297,
-0.2439547777,
-0.5049740672,
-0.1172523201,
0.2448075265,
-0.4534505308,
-0.0197755489,
-0.6486254334,
-0.0640424192,
-0.0941271707,
-0.9366306663,
-0.4615620077,
-0.426215142,
-0.2602002323,
-0.2075355053,
0.4901070893,
1.0758239031,
0.0903451741,
0.1600824893,
-0.7281146646,
0.2806462944,
0.3278091252,
0.6909412146,
-0.2419967651,
-0.1413689554,
-0.4482571185,
0.2119691521,
-0.1482013017,
-0.3192753792,
0.4105710089,
0.1053284705,
0.4033932388,
0.5601037145,
-0.2677123547,
0.5686517358,
-0.17849949,
0.8240833879,
0.4106009603,
-0.9470540881,
0.804613471,
-0.2219067961,
0.1403832734,
0.4560894072,
0.1789310724,
-0.085742794,
-0.1523679197,
-0.7533327937,
-0.4198713005,
0.1980383396,
-0.1447390169,
-0.048554793,
-0.0684080869,
0.1428137869,
0.0891680419,
-0.0124232639,
-0.6917544007,
0.3561208248,
-0.707405746,
-0.2152460366,
0.0241575502,
-0.0316127054,
0.0786378533,
-0.1302186102,
0.1264823526,
-0.3393664956,
0.2956504226,
0.1249026656,
-0.3261108398,
-0.2185126096,
-0.2431417406,
0.6495261192,
0.6199452877,
-0.6389113665,
0.4934763312,
-0.0518677533,
-0.6678808331,
-0.1563802958,
-0.2270397395,
-0.055798471,
-0.0107258465,
0.2157399058,
0.5664618611,
0.2674615681,
-0.6961650252,
0.4956161678,
0.2608248591,
-0.3493717015,
-0.3926930726,
-0.3183910549,
-0.4370311201,
0.1337310821,
0.2742350996,
-0.0879920647,
-0.1547933668,
-0.6241257191,
0.3478028178,
0.5708295107,
-0.8538093567,
-0.771720171,
0.5308821201,
0.2077977508,
0.0210561641,
0.5743314624,
0.0396425873,
-0.221887365,
0.7933199406,
0.3028085828,
0.9311303496,
0.1280046999,
0.3162361383,
0.3769591153,
0.0988779664,
-0.1148164645,
0.4045097828,
-0.346916616,
-1.2050361633,
-0.3873376548,
-0.8354256749,
-0.5201588273,
-0.0961719304,
-0.1503073871,
0.4510586858,
-1.189858079,
0.2408201694,
-0.0326691717,
0.0655263811,
-0.8052276373,
0.5186664462,
0.4601382315,
0.6689175963,
-1.2489387989,
0.6893613338,
0.6817171574,
-0.7210760713,
-0.4320165217,
-0.3878163695,
-0.2173584104,
-0.9142388701,
0.9244105816,
0.0112925572,
-0.183153525,
-0.4104657173,
-0.6851827502,
-0.7017445564,
1.0428968668,
0.3872917891,
-0.1364907175,
0.4122180343,
0.1407642961,
0.179149583,
0.0002766433,
0.4314600527,
0.0177720021,
0.485560894,
0.2351502478,
-0.7579225302,
-0.1519708931,
-0.32187289,
-0.1904385239,
0.4896460176,
-0.3455560207,
0.8856983781,
-0.1478825361,
-0.1204011962,
-0.2910413444,
0.7930391431,
0.278015852,
0.3396293521,
0.4237172604,
0.7392753363,
0.6927255988,
0.1316341311,
1.2571175098,
-0.375877142,
0.4813504815,
0.5867931247,
-0.4324692786,
0.9314483404,
0.4277986884,
-0.0394548178,
0.3805214763,
0.2012995481,
-0.2199448198,
0.4048792422,
0.060323704,
-0.5388112664,
-0.1936561167,
-0.2785821855,
0.1205778196,
0.7456191182,
0.5558884144,
-0.1777313203,
-0.0755914524,
-0.029903857,
-0.1275667399,
0.2432313114,
-0.3080480099,
0.6463450789,
-0.0096381661,
-0.3401353061,
0.4091852903,
-0.1843804866,
0.5435785055,
-0.4622251093,
-0.2398944646,
0.1575054079,
0.0230180789,
-0.3683122694,
-1.25004673,
0.4901648164,
-0.1603930295,
-0.1394079477,
-0.3425650299,
0.6133642197,
-0.1349740624,
-0.8832387328,
0.0940223187,
0.2407283038,
0.4229436219,
-0.4657452703,
-0.2905607522,
-0.0766560659,
-0.4863657355,
0.0415041186,
0.4791497588,
0.5328112245,
-0.2218823284,
0.4896491766,
0.5540221334,
0.2979804277,
-0.1748148352,
-0.2189869583,
0.5101984143,
-0.8938305378,
-0.3073970675,
-0.468646884,
0.7079669833,
-0.1073250324,
-0.2072591186,
0.4151473641,
0.6582537293,
0.7983332872,
-0.2006960511,
0.966596663,
-0.0417262018,
0.0441509485,
-0.5120947361,
0.6083349586,
-0.5554359555,
-0.1771482974,
-0.178646028,
-1.2261434793,
-0.653957963,
0.8863572478,
-0.2952731252,
-0.0923543721,
0.7903644443,
0.7838497162,
-0.4063710272,
-0.3732877374,
0.8757303953,
0.1000254303,
0.3071142435,
0.3713126779,
0.4364949763,
-0.1866412014,
0.349111706,
-0.767404139,
-0.3855292499,
0.0620413944,
-1.1125346422,
-0.6902532578,
-0.55803895,
-0.319183588,
-0.207479313,
-0.4016550779,
0.3983224332,
0.8449617624,
-0.6289272308,
-0.2754431367,
-0.2236864269,
-0.157750234,
-0.2957905829,
-0.2001153976,
0.441926688,
0.2067683935,
-0.5347630382,
0.5175059438,
0.3868724406,
0.1607682258,
-0.4205501974,
0.1929916888,
0.1804904789,
-0.1350382119,
0.7655460835,
0.6996646523,
-0.7944047451,
-0.58525455,
0.0902555585,
0.0213635974,
-0.0197069198,
0.8608236313,
-0.9599958658,
0.7330148816,
0.8333113194,
0.6127642393,
0.653676331,
-0.0665188953,
0.5222737789,
-0.8841703534,
0.6853788495,
0.323066473,
0.7693906426,
0.4644827247,
-0.633240521,
0.2934000492,
0.2494297177,
-0.1233791858,
-0.3712937534,
0.268663615,
-1.4661799669,
-0.4917061031,
0.8420949578,
0.059887331,
-0.7100449204,
0.0176331885,
0.0333300568,
-0.0900537446,
-0.1682838798,
0.8810195327,
0.3862229586,
-0.0636543483,
-0.7733304501,
-0.5512424111,
-0.1319701821,
0.3042071164,
-0.7296912074,
-0.06239466,
0.4180802703,
0.0537761152,
0.4103645682,
0.3142029047,
-0.2483338565,
0.0971036851,
0.1032661721,
0.3902693987,
-0.2599245906,
-0.7389464974,
-0.1096530333,
0.1746871024,
0.1940512061,
-0.1131918877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04237v1
|
Cleared for Takeoff? Compositional & Conditional Reasoning may be the Achilles Heel to (Flight-Booking) Language Agents
| 2024-04-05T17:36:26 | 2024-04-05T17:36:26 |
Harsh Kohli, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid progress of large language models (LLMs) has seen them excel and
frequently surpass human performance on standard benchmarks. This has enabled
many downstream applications, such as LLM agents, to rely on their
sophisticated reasoning to navigate complex task requirements. However, LLMs
are known to unexpectedly falter in simple tasks and under seemingly
straightforward circumstances - underscoring the need for better and more
diverse evaluation setups to measure their true capabilities. To this end, we
choose to study compositional and conditional reasoning, two cornerstones of
human cognition, and introduce GroundCocoa - a lexically diverse benchmark
connecting these reasoning skills to the real-world problem of flight booking.
Our task involves aligning detailed user preferences with available flight
options presented in a multiple-choice format. Results indicate a significant
disparity in performance among current state-of-the-art LLMs with even the best
performing model, GPT-4 Turbo, not exceeding 67% accuracy despite advanced
prompting techniques.
|
[
-0.4096181989,
-0.3670132458,
0.8608641624,
0.1466875374,
-0.149612084,
0.4239331782,
-0.2456701547,
-0.3715394139,
0.0822062418,
0.6040810347,
-0.6369714141,
-0.5325251818,
-0.3505238295,
-0.1665166765,
-0.3057788312,
0.7759391069,
0.0309477262,
-0.2496754974,
-0.6954703927,
-0.1582426727,
-0.8409297466,
-0.8516985178,
-0.7059077621,
-0.5173290968,
0.4840792716,
0.3808279037,
0.8877189159,
0.2424351871,
0.2501386702,
0.2140090764,
-0.09490408,
0.1009531543,
-0.1136367545,
0.0848545954,
-0.4858230054,
-0.4285470843,
-0.132137239,
0.1745356619,
0.4216243029,
0.8934122324,
-0.4693979025,
-0.5196609497,
-0.3216089606,
0.6999628544,
-0.7232969999,
-0.0838158503,
-0.7873612046,
-0.1475324333,
0.1958348155,
0.0650988668,
-0.2967204154,
-0.0993203223,
0.0365779102,
-0.8136683106,
-0.1513317972,
0.0760307759,
0.9815286398,
0.5675991178,
-0.7161452174,
-0.5224086642,
-0.541808784,
0.6669656634,
-0.3216384649,
0.6156286001,
0.4317063987,
0.4195689559,
-0.3022292852,
-0.762727499,
-0.5849615335,
-0.6612685323,
0.0265598129,
0.2796124518,
-0.1361538023,
0.1405856907,
0.2478817701,
0.0124255102,
-0.5495688915,
0.3102863133,
-0.1244230866,
-0.4706136584,
0.4131952524,
0.2355273366,
0.4169628322,
0.150580436,
-0.1949239075,
0.062870115,
-0.5252423286,
0.3976607919,
0.3393064141,
0.1935553104,
-0.1646672785,
0.4616413414,
-0.6760153174,
0.9075237513,
-0.1345719993,
-0.1036074162,
-0.2263571471,
-0.1665213555,
-0.4991679192,
-0.1200162321,
0.2842104733,
0.4031001329,
0.2140687704,
-0.4109771252,
-0.2865728438,
0.2148533911,
0.4345578849,
-0.5480427742,
-0.0753856897,
0.5246822834,
0.0053534992,
-0.087404266,
-0.0035845453,
-0.2791507244,
-0.3413198888,
-0.6988435388,
0.256020546,
-0.3052997291,
-0.0584815405,
0.4468233883,
-0.2927166224,
0.3364036381,
0.4242085516,
-0.6190848351,
0.2587866187,
1.0260790586,
0.6462617517,
-0.2165371031,
-0.4841677547,
-0.4707103074,
-0.1100865752,
-0.5227374434,
0.9758616686,
-0.5824668407,
-0.4052405953,
0.0219583381,
-0.2267172784,
-0.1716214716,
-0.5493257046,
1.0446267128,
-0.8182114363,
0.0695024058,
-0.8080390096,
-0.3687673211,
-0.3211529553,
0.4481893182,
-0.4249841571,
0.5273833871,
0.1500694603,
-0.3036714494,
0.711329937,
-0.0037799699,
-0.6310607195,
0.0931882933,
-0.5940673947,
-0.1151256561,
-0.1010422111,
0.0292158872,
0.0289580096,
-0.3671912849,
0.4349238873,
-0.1975817084,
-0.4933790267,
0.1221599057,
-0.0584763736,
0.7549934983,
0.3498762548,
-0.1485746801,
-0.0572465137,
-0.6208052635,
0.0931121036,
-0.1225908995,
-0.5385555625,
-0.1048854589,
0.1328311265,
-0.2540109456,
0.4702863097,
0.3225115836,
-0.0494606569,
0.2580905557,
-0.4328782856,
0.344275862,
0.6230751872,
-0.1141255945,
0.4105893373,
-0.4930256903,
0.6811614037,
0.0645048171,
0.0035582406,
0.079009302,
-0.3611350954,
-0.7480745316,
-0.2135663033,
-0.0685967654,
0.4804195762,
-0.4426389635,
0.5880087018,
-0.1919196844,
-0.5686231852,
0.1644135267,
-0.0152719421,
0.1722264737,
0.4576439857,
0.0738340616,
0.0237113349,
-0.4844843149,
-0.8347361088,
-0.6375775337,
-0.2384239435,
0.236395061,
0.3329999149,
0.2982076406,
-0.2948120832,
1.00466609,
-0.4443600774,
-0.0060992423,
-0.2061513364,
-0.1384844035,
0.2269999087,
0.3622140884,
0.6003082395,
-0.7887126207,
-0.2438027859,
0.1515427977,
-0.6015991569,
-0.1637248993,
-0.2990886271,
-0.3681662977,
0.2523401082,
0.4805209041,
-0.8874394298,
0.2413764745,
0.4134281874,
-0.5221931338,
0.5828565955,
-0.1014399827,
0.1048617736,
-0.4977556467,
0.0807470083,
-0.3956522346,
-0.0683042482,
-0.3720583618,
0.1057543606,
-0.1329445243,
-0.1964427978,
-0.3342859447,
0.5622079372,
-0.3908730149,
-0.3762752116,
-0.5326871872,
0.0835833102,
0.3815433681,
0.4560193419,
0.2248694301,
0.9426646829,
0.5894415379,
-0.7608469725,
0.1481485069,
0.1047925204,
-0.0965986326,
0.5442730188,
-0.4429515004,
0.1959823668,
-0.0391130634,
0.4510635734,
-0.9814788699,
-0.300401777,
0.1404856592,
-0.2180616707,
-0.1213453189,
-0.2868215442,
-0.1475300342,
-0.1962238699,
0.0202212296,
0.2129497677,
0.4151540995,
-0.416005671,
0.8582832813,
0.214276582,
0.1097018346,
-0.5842306018,
-0.3997006118,
0.3658162951,
-0.0102372672,
-0.6205918789,
0.3425183296,
-0.0636488199,
-0.4708023667,
-0.2212968618,
-0.6427226067,
-0.1797834635,
0.2515323162,
0.3947011828,
0.1667264104,
-0.0021589461,
0.0675390139,
0.1725209206,
0.0023881106,
0.1289860308,
-0.6445074081,
0.3644962907,
-0.3688010871,
-0.4308443666,
-0.1579501927,
0.1858366132,
0.7850126624,
-0.1819747686,
0.6755568385,
0.0927503183,
-0.4815208614,
-0.1599694341,
-0.6818913221,
0.0384882651,
-0.4464162588,
0.0264108181,
-0.8998988867,
-0.6212880611,
0.5442929268,
0.0890963152,
-0.1340435743,
0.3713043332,
0.4699130356,
-0.004428817,
0.6791648269,
0.3732854724,
0.1638239324,
0.2032927424,
-0.2702299953,
0.2214402854,
-0.4468824267,
-0.5214462876,
-0.7183983326,
0.12550053,
-0.4365943968,
-0.3239395916,
0.1414002329,
0.170484975,
-0.2545051873,
0.185507834,
-0.265173912,
0.7580196261,
0.3611222804,
-0.1720034778,
0.3494407833,
-0.1632944643,
-0.5132595897,
0.3213122189,
-0.4944911003,
-0.741876781,
0.7670403123,
-0.0588959493,
0.4944032431,
-0.0544249266,
0.3919787705,
0.1430793703,
0.0911364853,
-0.8914657235,
0.6110744476,
-0.0798766539,
-0.6012568474,
-0.0416374169,
-0.2293304503,
-0.6725277901,
0.4108582437,
0.1179097742,
-0.5172919631,
0.215833649,
-0.024632154,
-0.5785296559,
0.0071116961,
-0.7516486645,
0.8081502318,
-0.5503652692,
-0.3275375068,
-0.1152782962,
-0.6361378431,
0.3231275976,
-0.1761666834,
0.1293178052,
-0.4234188497,
-0.3525899649,
0.6488362551,
-0.3501921892,
0.5959118009,
-0.1872400641,
-0.0553075075,
0.3448430002,
0.3384722471,
0.3545844853,
0.0711518005,
-0.2524023056,
0.2856411338,
0.055463925,
-0.3638926744,
-0.7091025114,
0.9031080604,
-0.9700822234,
-0.6952320337,
-0.609644413,
-0.2846750617,
-0.5810847282,
0.337973088,
0.1795843691,
0.3637662828,
-0.0484982729,
-0.0948183686,
0.0077709053,
-0.1007969156,
0.2032169402,
0.6886668205,
-0.0623836517,
-0.5204355121,
0.5914122462,
0.097289592,
0.1035201997,
0.5202021599,
0.2070929408,
-0.6640789509,
-0.738548398,
0.0571435839,
0.2220848203,
-1.1931955814,
0.0779359341,
-0.8827322721,
-0.0239607636,
-0.2910431027,
-0.5292105675,
-0.3674200177,
-0.4672758579,
-0.1665025949,
-0.1667948365,
-0.2662781775,
0.4818925858,
0.2575238347,
0.2816744745,
-0.4090572596,
0.2036546469,
0.4399270117,
0.3106802404,
-0.2069558203,
-0.5203059316,
-0.3976288438,
0.0167152472,
-0.3784206212,
-0.4409055412,
0.0299505014,
-0.0834014937,
0.9473276138,
0.3179184794,
0.0352524258,
0.5925583839,
-0.0941734537,
0.8171990514,
0.0152380001,
-1.0122767687,
0.5529158115,
-0.2576907277,
-0.0666929111,
0.8385664225,
0.2711406946,
-0.5222717524,
-0.351932317,
-0.5688269138,
-0.5608513355,
0.7762300372,
0.2744971514,
-0.1477799416,
-0.0068134861,
0.3380404711,
0.0354822278,
0.4003988504,
-0.6518199444,
0.1033804938,
-0.4357145727,
0.2228990197,
-0.3477808833,
0.0380460173,
-0.0840554982,
-0.2760350406,
0.4991597533,
-0.2107008249,
-0.0390487947,
0.2313474119,
-0.1180737391,
0.0679744184,
0.1504912525,
1.0581150055,
1.0966980457,
-0.339597255,
0.2488518506,
-0.1239173338,
-0.1698624939,
0.4798662961,
-0.1570733786,
0.027704034,
-0.363073647,
0.4142905772,
0.6265692711,
-0.0002460933,
-1.0001481771,
0.4905866086,
-0.0187047925,
-0.1133975089,
-0.3218101859,
0.2183121443,
0.1460366845,
-0.2056000829,
0.1772697866,
0.3322792053,
0.1562644541,
-0.4428612292,
0.2657974958,
0.4731645882,
-0.0417857468,
-0.2191242427,
0.7420347929,
0.4820260108,
-0.2690661848,
0.4979755878,
-0.2350901514,
-0.7084553242,
0.8939206004,
0.0988247395,
1.1364108324,
0.4183646142,
-0.0151741412,
0.140299812,
0.5035427213,
0.003209728,
0.108960785,
-0.1645160764,
-1.1023788452,
-0.3711881936,
-0.47718665,
-0.709310472,
-0.0502420515,
-0.3395982683,
0.3890262842,
-0.584564805,
-0.1776497066,
-0.2052170187,
0.2155826837,
-0.7660976052,
0.5420221686,
0.2899383307,
0.9268411398,
-0.8057310581,
0.640706718,
0.9554238319,
-0.6653299332,
-1.1742168665,
0.4445334673,
-0.1915170401,
-0.705000639,
0.8197490573,
0.3146068752,
-0.3949148655,
-0.14212735,
-0.0378191695,
-0.4625851214,
0.8784451485,
0.6465839148,
-0.635253191,
-0.1626447886,
0.1115486845,
0.3842163086,
-0.4039922953,
0.4648485184,
0.9047913551,
0.503498733,
0.303034544,
-0.7027131319,
0.0730600506,
0.1403612345,
-0.0308900848,
-0.1735332012,
-0.8285498023,
0.7680776119,
-0.1628646553,
-0.1330735832,
-0.1594637483,
0.3036395013,
0.4621037841,
0.6189428568,
0.7186725736,
0.6802861691,
0.9264207482,
-0.1434317082,
1.3738018274,
-0.3781105578,
0.117325671,
0.8501939178,
-0.854095459,
0.5902372599,
0.4725977182,
-0.2645948529,
0.5586365461,
0.6802771688,
0.5182819366,
0.5610178709,
0.2132207304,
-0.2697581947,
-0.7688908577,
0.0371040404,
-0.1282429993,
0.7758144736,
0.0789637938,
0.4147203863,
-0.1536978185,
-0.0557406433,
-0.0763802305,
0.2036043555,
0.0235916916,
0.6970931888,
0.1821171194,
-1.4209806919,
0.769549489,
0.1539181024,
0.3367033005,
-0.5264566541,
0.1758875251,
-0.5932995081,
-0.1245829687,
-0.2022487223,
-0.6248272061,
0.3661694825,
-0.1905892342,
-0.0538945422,
-0.0973537043,
0.6436316371,
-0.0993126929,
-0.2628334463,
0.4853475988,
0.4539706707,
0.0563645549,
-0.4419341683,
-0.4972047508,
0.3044883013,
-0.0892094076,
0.0428090021,
-0.0289999582,
0.2665890455,
-0.1527327448,
0.8591322303,
0.7506973743,
0.1543740183,
-0.0045513907,
0.3735982478,
0.9172115326,
-0.8847658038,
-0.8849206567,
-0.8046764135,
0.400344789,
0.1315926313,
-0.1408007741,
0.4179604352,
0.7922424674,
0.6116138697,
-0.0178657677,
0.8252714872,
0.2414564639,
0.2608257532,
-0.8760554194,
0.3509744406,
-0.5828514695,
0.6092500687,
0.1336007416,
-0.6531119347,
-0.0948993787,
0.4160018861,
-0.4567453861,
0.2712657452,
0.9533920884,
0.7153497934,
0.0098353466,
-0.0585753843,
0.5859252214,
-0.2187760323,
0.9030445218,
0.6867249012,
1.357704401,
-0.1363771707,
0.5614520311,
-0.243474558,
-0.0132677238,
-0.4620572627,
-1.0077613592,
-0.7389370799,
-0.2795736492,
-0.5273923874,
-0.2079277933,
0.1479120702,
0.956415236,
0.781753242,
-0.4865308702,
-0.2391090095,
-0.5384600163,
0.5709614754,
-0.3333910704,
-0.1817538738,
-0.0551999994,
-0.4648628831,
-0.4617791772,
0.6342989206,
0.1822661608,
0.0944595784,
0.0086008059,
-0.3661589622,
0.1838983297,
0.4171655476,
0.3928341568,
0.2237912118,
-1.0330383778,
-0.2859764695,
-0.1549285054,
-0.3348375261,
-0.0024175807,
1.1011923552,
-0.8622274399,
0.2487063855,
0.3931355178,
0.7266809344,
0.1798008829,
0.1401135623,
0.4029777944,
-0.6866769791,
0.4928320944,
0.4874098301,
0.3907896876,
0.1427261233,
-0.3763550222,
0.3312606514,
0.4585822523,
-0.5982695818,
-0.8067425489,
0.0871098265,
-1.4508788586,
-0.3209150136,
1.1943036318,
0.1420219839,
0.2137541026,
-0.1930198222,
-0.3383583128,
-0.0920153931,
-0.3663192987,
0.3325541019,
0.9274544716,
-0.0612342954,
0.257181555,
-0.325841248,
0.4067085981,
0.4682710767,
-1.0273268223,
-0.0734756589,
0.6488893032,
0.4853493273,
-0.0127940644,
0.9631157517,
0.3843177259,
0.4855892658,
0.1692477167,
0.0254059695,
-0.1613806933,
-0.6378384233,
-0.3433559835,
0.1335584223,
0.5708701015,
-0.2323475778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04234v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04234v3
|
player2vec: A Language Modeling Approach to Understand Player Behavior in Games
| 2024-04-05T17:29:47 | 2024-06-07T22:01:05 |
Tianze Wang, Maryam Honari-Jahromi, Styliani Katsarou, Olga Mikheeva, Theodoros Panagiotakopoulos, Sahar Asadi, Oleg Smirnov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Methods for learning latent user representations from historical behavior
logs have gained traction for recommendation tasks in e-commerce, content
streaming, and other settings. However, this area still remains relatively
underexplored in video and mobile gaming contexts. In this work, we present a
novel method for overcoming this limitation by extending a long-range
Transformer model from the natural language processing domain to player
behavior data. We discuss specifics of behavior tracking in games and propose
preprocessing and tokenization approaches by viewing in-game events in an
analogous way to words in sentences, thus enabling learning player
representations in a self-supervised manner in the absence of ground-truth
annotations. We experimentally demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed
approach in fitting the distribution of behavior events by evaluating intrinsic
language modeling metrics. Furthermore, we qualitatively analyze the emerging
structure of the learned embedding space and show its value for generating
insights into behavior patterns to inform downstream applications.
|
[
-0.0730162561,
-0.6922590137,
0.3412784934,
0.0958496109,
0.0400284491,
0.1312156469,
-0.1717601866,
-0.3474303484,
0.2053290308,
0.5865756273,
-0.7452628613,
-0.5195988417,
-0.2713564634,
-0.5784251094,
0.0525385924,
1.0781046152,
0.0267162025,
-0.3081852198,
-0.4629274011,
-0.1282425076,
-0.7821366191,
-0.7154529691,
-0.6939887404,
-0.490331322,
0.0428286493,
0.3183172047,
0.3825038671,
0.4645730555,
0.4067625999,
0.2912063301,
0.1059267148,
0.0835429803,
-1.1057529449,
0.4287348688,
-0.2490875274,
-0.6590567827,
-0.3360125721,
0.1659746468,
0.3273506165,
0.1455425173,
-0.2955878377,
0.1046614721,
0.0355287381,
0.2541769445,
-0.2795189321,
0.5890276432,
-0.2495561242,
0.353371501,
-0.0242882017,
-0.2054000348,
-0.6152430177,
0.1948810369,
0.0538771525,
-0.7329281569,
0.3295886815,
-0.1572403759,
0.3224453032,
0.1224252805,
-0.3332434297,
-0.4970923662,
-1.1721384525,
0.9016084671,
-0.2388988733,
0.5295524597,
0.6773266792,
0.4058818221,
-0.2586535513,
-0.5809580684,
-0.4020038843,
0.0196108855,
-0.0479923002,
0.1067730039,
-0.3120096922,
-0.0752742589,
0.2972331047,
-0.0991617888,
-0.392190963,
0.0798698664,
-0.2593020201,
-0.1579997391,
0.827239871,
0.1876559705,
0.2261897326,
0.1298812777,
-0.4711872935,
-0.0015585445,
-0.6215056181,
0.7322221994,
0.4857472777,
0.0973090082,
-0.1359143108,
0.5285466909,
0.194587633,
0.1366756707,
0.3038336337,
-0.1963066906,
0.2323000878,
-0.3380640149,
0.3318135142,
-0.087255314,
0.519212544,
0.5875892639,
0.1400003582,
-0.5209007263,
-0.0114155784,
-0.0278059933,
0.4634118676,
-0.8739733696,
-0.6036429405,
0.0704001933,
-0.7020516992,
-0.3300704956,
0.215509519,
-0.989138484,
-0.7351099849,
0.0447039865,
0.2535583377,
-0.1432220191,
-0.3630037904,
-0.1327723861,
-0.1101760864,
0.4792100489,
0.0083028143,
-1.2317345142,
0.4757327437,
0.7747708559,
0.7350783944,
-0.4851530194,
0.0243962388,
-0.7728747725,
0.2914673686,
-0.1584645361,
0.7370310426,
-0.7741790414,
-0.7848031521,
0.1966609657,
0.0557411648,
0.3806449473,
-0.3455396593,
0.475697577,
-0.4565132558,
0.1389890015,
-0.1091193333,
-0.7619332075,
-0.0461112149,
0.2591569424,
-0.5564562678,
1.0849485397,
-0.1575608104,
-0.307194978,
0.4206604958,
-0.6686211824,
-0.5176721215,
0.2563348413,
-0.115995422,
-0.3946297467,
0.3256702721,
0.149766475,
0.4286113381,
0.2318758667,
0.2441997528,
-0.2262679785,
-0.4995314479,
0.2042424977,
-0.1508907974,
0.1761099994,
-0.1168032959,
-0.2064210773,
0.0886299908,
-0.2851791978,
-0.3323790431,
0.0990598276,
-0.248331964,
-0.3271619081,
0.9231017232,
-0.1374554783,
0.5030508637,
-0.0362010077,
-0.3920792937,
0.3740725219,
-0.3024409413,
0.4632315338,
0.5100613832,
0.0814602971,
0.7511461377,
0.1365446895,
0.538967967,
-0.1153774261,
0.2255605608,
-0.4883457124,
-0.5837463737,
-0.302903384,
-0.1142522171,
-0.0619373247,
0.3766131997,
-0.8231859207,
0.3457691371,
-0.3642007411,
-0.2690104842,
-0.3476359844,
0.0290156752,
0.1753051281,
0.3209490478,
0.4597713649,
-0.2277480811,
-0.5741292238,
-0.361245364,
-0.3795754015,
-0.6346604228,
0.0092872884,
0.7172591686,
0.2841540873,
-0.4016677439,
0.9914081693,
-0.497669369,
-0.6120126247,
-0.4609019458,
0.2922919393,
-0.0466071442,
0.5092669725,
0.5089658499,
-0.7871747017,
-0.2002423704,
-0.1755068004,
-0.5532034039,
-0.046269048,
-0.1963037997,
0.0741365999,
-0.1134168059,
0.9352081418,
-0.0834985673,
0.7174776196,
0.7640349269,
-0.9071500301,
0.0531893857,
-0.2999140322,
0.1044433638,
-0.6854144931,
-0.2058625817,
0.0513849296,
-0.4765612185,
-0.8634961843,
-0.0235858951,
-0.4665329456,
0.1765395403,
-0.2257622182,
0.5224996805,
-0.2273133099,
-0.2184741199,
-0.4555698633,
0.0270297118,
-0.141588673,
0.4691362083,
0.5210974813,
0.7400472164,
0.2481647283,
-0.5911356211,
0.5872420669,
0.3450863659,
-0.248660326,
0.4631441236,
-0.6652845144,
0.1526441425,
-0.2855952978,
0.2161215991,
-1.1518758535,
0.1855583042,
0.2220529318,
-0.6495105028,
0.0763539746,
-0.9228491187,
-0.3149098754,
-0.2800544798,
-0.1596444994,
0.4253979027,
0.8751618862,
-0.5950686336,
0.7945609093,
0.9056885242,
0.1940565258,
-0.0258664452,
-0.617792666,
-0.1577299833,
-0.3525141478,
-0.416624248,
0.4116416872,
-0.1684484333,
0.0728140697,
-0.3087312877,
-0.0402161032,
-0.1636172235,
0.1880050153,
0.5673382282,
0.1646005213,
-0.1887648404,
0.3519507051,
-0.3891357481,
-0.0855478272,
0.2467869073,
-0.4303865135,
0.4874487817,
0.1657395959,
-0.147001639,
-0.204542011,
0.1425840408,
-0.0517768562,
-0.2087241113,
0.5531072021,
0.7982232571,
-0.2579006553,
-0.2244169861,
-0.3231021166,
-0.244327262,
-0.4892480671,
0.5548244119,
-0.2776340246,
-1.0898314714,
0.6202125549,
-0.3520799577,
-0.078811571,
0.3903391957,
0.5522674918,
-0.5062519908,
1.3528624773,
0.8096116781,
0.2128732055,
0.6583159566,
-0.1437725872,
0.1473167241,
-0.6129701734,
-0.817068398,
-0.2086346149,
-0.3731171489,
-0.8074788451,
-0.987542212,
0.0722052082,
0.1436304301,
0.0174467359,
0.322096169,
0.0803748146,
0.7937884331,
0.120700188,
-0.0081914831,
-0.0281890836,
0.0072110272,
0.0909273922,
-0.5003376603,
-0.4549657702,
-0.1609676629,
0.7075573802,
0.6179825664,
0.6850520372,
0.5307381749,
0.5391609669,
0.6114549637,
0.0303362533,
-1.1033480167,
0.0846018419,
-0.1099203601,
-0.6189851761,
-0.4384718835,
-0.2542457283,
-0.8677882552,
0.0575528592,
-0.5660482645,
-1.1405090094,
0.1292985678,
0.1574290991,
-0.3897421956,
0.1909973621,
-0.3992623091,
0.9322439432,
-0.1295318902,
-0.7308987975,
-0.1927375048,
-0.1952774823,
0.1601288617,
0.151475057,
0.4202973843,
-0.0375004262,
-0.0106425816,
0.8482272029,
-0.1368168294,
0.8092986941,
-0.3856761754,
-0.0224314723,
0.5451638699,
0.6232013106,
0.8719516993,
0.3489572704,
0.3088152111,
0.0091289207,
-0.0854401961,
-0.3329752684,
-0.6710556149,
0.6153959632,
-0.6524066329,
-0.2276797742,
-0.2537343502,
0.0613230988,
-0.4009014964,
-0.0645772889,
-0.0655856431,
0.2210925668,
-0.70815593,
0.3413060308,
0.7992273569,
-0.1770130694,
0.506475389,
0.5583465695,
-0.3268559873,
0.1336879432,
1.1515914202,
-0.4556502998,
-0.4511198103,
0.2847393751,
0.1592310965,
-0.5104401112,
-0.4900260866,
-0.0914348587,
0.1900933534,
-0.4279303253,
0.1107616574,
-0.5472263694,
0.2746808529,
-0.155293256,
0.0212601274,
-0.4054515064,
0.1117359623,
-0.4408302605,
-0.2995393276,
0.1279856414,
1.1309417486,
0.0512438267,
0.7974977493,
-0.6285955906,
0.228419289,
0.4522528648,
0.7717903852,
-0.1006503254,
-0.7252574563,
-0.3510412872,
-0.028023066,
-0.0912579596,
-0.7667645216,
0.4967936873,
0.28035447,
0.6638838053,
0.4988137782,
-0.4331465662,
0.6531736851,
-0.7097565532,
1.2331266403,
0.2685350478,
-0.9321584702,
0.643463254,
-0.3093055189,
-0.033100795,
0.3681302965,
0.2852870524,
-0.8605892062,
0.4588865638,
-0.5083142519,
-0.6225680113,
1.0535875559,
0.2624378502,
0.3534321785,
-0.0356564522,
0.3031817675,
0.0562281609,
-0.0629556775,
-0.4635948241,
-0.2891835272,
-0.2507711351,
0.0467899777,
-0.5638165474,
-0.4840306044,
0.2880871594,
-0.2108555883,
0.441301167,
-0.2409294248,
0.3224954307,
-0.1701270342,
-0.4344759285,
-0.0310676228,
-0.3607507348,
0.37508443,
0.2463401556,
-0.0253832117,
-0.0332677439,
0.1709757,
-0.6049103737,
-0.0556168929,
-0.2895314991,
0.0298048016,
-0.193876341,
0.4473786354,
0.8013389111,
0.336832881,
-0.6990793347,
0.9557002187,
-0.3416037261,
-0.1090996489,
-0.3127961755,
-0.033875864,
0.0284930859,
0.4447774589,
0.1532948017,
-0.1550451517,
0.4442663789,
-0.7542507052,
0.543618083,
0.2189378589,
-1.1243085861,
-0.9195420146,
0.5817073584,
0.5108596683,
-0.2100305706,
0.6910725832,
-0.0745155513,
-0.4304480255,
0.3407434523,
0.6096031666,
0.7151869535,
-0.3278612792,
0.5295484066,
0.446560204,
-0.0374345966,
-0.2238556147,
0.0851561874,
-0.2184019089,
-0.5481574535,
-0.6293605566,
-0.4150818884,
0.1212205589,
-0.1075893044,
-0.4420422912,
0.270224452,
-0.2935463488,
-0.4415836632,
0.0016415119,
-0.0494135097,
-0.8944708705,
-0.227821812,
0.7753542662,
0.3915878832,
-1.0125166178,
0.7673249841,
0.6327621341,
-0.4941641688,
-0.3332964778,
-0.1076974422,
-0.0579341799,
-0.661549747,
0.5771017075,
-0.2338138819,
-0.0612925664,
-0.1362080425,
-0.6008537412,
-0.7178019285,
0.8797585368,
-0.2099687159,
-0.3247183263,
-0.1518170387,
0.1334767938,
0.8785102367,
-0.5777203441,
0.5685645342,
0.6652011275,
0.1838941425,
0.5206239223,
-0.3673714101,
-0.3663523793,
-0.0416294485,
0.0189201795,
0.1352328658,
-0.4021918774,
0.4246097505,
-0.3084269464,
-0.1502415538,
-0.3549049795,
0.9093872905,
-0.0405246094,
0.2920628786,
0.3534671068,
0.0457932949,
0.6258739233,
-0.0749608055,
0.8239790201,
0.2145885676,
0.5906308293,
1.0868581533,
-0.2882198095,
0.7441767454,
0.3734898865,
-0.342099756,
0.7248105407,
0.3153524101,
-0.1442035437,
0.7323117256,
0.4003283679,
0.1844022572,
-0.6093095541,
-0.1892576963,
0.1048239619,
0.8119912148,
0.6055722237,
-0.2437093854,
-0.1637311578,
-0.1183852404,
-0.1243697926,
0.2057252079,
-0.396761179,
1.3104081154,
-0.1901469976,
-0.6041327715,
-0.2217630297,
0.0051777172,
0.7791799903,
-0.3618944287,
-0.412846297,
-0.2889983356,
0.1755550355,
-0.1196704656,
-0.9186583757,
0.1639773697,
0.155585885,
-0.2466677129,
-0.2070600539,
0.6074529886,
-0.4325491786,
-0.2426747084,
0.4238453209,
0.5821305513,
0.2991271615,
-0.0329020135,
-0.4974094927,
0.0556208231,
-0.0492348261,
-0.1280652583,
0.2174135447,
0.3145230711,
-0.2777855992,
0.5309147239,
0.4663740098,
-0.0622583218,
-0.0124782501,
-0.1025753394,
0.4888287783,
-0.6359388232,
-0.814212203,
-0.8716107607,
0.3878062367,
-0.0237513762,
-0.111842908,
0.6443125606,
0.6323224902,
0.8006621599,
-0.0478674136,
0.7069271803,
0.1339979917,
0.2707143426,
-0.2554948032,
0.4386616349,
-0.0919478461,
0.2068399042,
0.0986735672,
-0.7994514108,
-0.0401662402,
0.5748190284,
-0.21111314,
-0.0400426909,
0.1151182279,
0.3022134304,
-0.2447044104,
-0.1273716241,
0.4596476257,
0.0389059819,
0.5985758901,
0.4751387537,
0.8958805203,
-0.4070561826,
0.5523506999,
0.0265778229,
-0.1378091425,
-0.4522300661,
-0.770452559,
-1.3319557905,
-0.7598458529,
-0.2956596911,
-0.5604037642,
0.1993836612,
1.0196177959,
0.7607495189,
-1.0243097544,
-0.3266911805,
0.1280151755,
-0.0196514893,
-0.2795293927,
-0.1602520794,
0.2153061032,
-0.0408169851,
-0.5769879222,
0.5451368093,
-0.0402935408,
0.0519739427,
-0.3047948182,
-0.4348421693,
0.0377094373,
0.1350895613,
0.8139945865,
0.4260198474,
-0.6046280861,
-0.3643086851,
0.1926266998,
0.1205780432,
0.0840391144,
1.162071228,
-1.1650048494,
0.7478331923,
0.5673380494,
0.2525915205,
0.8283105493,
0.2300792038,
0.643928647,
-0.9375309348,
0.0675477833,
0.3762401342,
-0.0297687799,
0.1359623224,
-0.2639292181,
0.4038421214,
0.3222161829,
-0.119193539,
-0.5616188645,
0.2080631405,
-0.5859534144,
-0.1553406864,
1.362123251,
-0.2443569899,
-0.1469016224,
-0.1376005262,
-0.1836397052,
0.270139575,
-0.5486345887,
0.602592051,
0.7112030983,
-0.114144288,
-0.1574243456,
-0.5008295774,
0.9397470951,
-0.288951695,
-0.3895682096,
0.2484187037,
0.478708595,
0.0302475262,
-0.1198479831,
0.3832195103,
-0.0556216612,
0.0121893622,
-0.0927357376,
0.1742408723,
-0.0473622829,
-0.3515312672,
-0.4925982058,
-0.0980540738,
-0.1138957739,
0.0010767168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04232v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04232v2
|
Benchmarking and Improving Compositional Generalization of Multi-aspect Controllable Text Generation
| 2024-04-05T17:26:22 | 2024-06-03T12:08:20 |
Tianqi Zhong, Zhaoyi Li, Quan Wang, Linqi Song, Ying Wei, Defu Lian, Zhendong Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compositional generalization, representing the model's ability to generate
text with new attribute combinations obtained by recombining single attributes
from the training data, is a crucial property for multi-aspect controllable
text generation (MCTG) methods. Nonetheless, a comprehensive compositional
generalization evaluation benchmark of MCTG is still lacking. We propose
CompMCTG, a benchmark encompassing diverse multi-aspect labeled datasets and a
crafted three-dimensional evaluation protocol, to holistically evaluate the
compositional generalization of MCTG approaches. We observe that existing MCTG
works generally confront a noticeable performance drop in compositional
testing. To mitigate this issue, we introduce Meta-MCTG, a training framework
incorporating meta-learning, where we enable models to learn how to generalize
by simulating compositional generalization scenarios in the training phase. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of Meta-MCTG through achieving obvious
improvement (by at most 3.64%) for compositional testing performance in 94.4%
cases.
|
[
-0.4190872908,
-0.6982811689,
0.4079702795,
0.22063528,
-0.3036661148,
0.1084072217,
-0.3160482645,
-0.1710634083,
-0.225320369,
0.2384765446,
-0.707392633,
-0.8048616648,
-0.5910865068,
0.1652526855,
-0.0522731729,
1.0180453062,
-0.2660396695,
-0.0079799583,
-0.3455984294,
-0.1545423567,
-0.4879843891,
-0.4785308242,
-0.4662072062,
-0.5024927855,
0.3443987668,
0.4710792005,
0.3738449514,
0.701759398,
0.6241073012,
0.2803418934,
0.2673427761,
0.3166338801,
-0.1552495509,
0.1365452111,
-0.0437147357,
-0.2239195853,
-0.5570892692,
0.3808701336,
0.5829617977,
0.6052244902,
-0.3627145886,
0.182089299,
0.2905985415,
0.5224306583,
-1.0731770992,
0.3040425181,
-0.4663784504,
0.2800882459,
0.1643290371,
-0.166552186,
-0.5272178054,
-0.3450181782,
0.0801325068,
-0.5761430264,
0.5559586287,
-0.0820267722,
0.324413985,
0.0317507535,
-0.5585047603,
-0.0955372676,
-0.63839674,
0.9139338732,
-0.4892517626,
0.5953915715,
0.2157023251,
0.3827229738,
0.0578876659,
-0.8233813643,
-0.403960079,
-0.34834674,
-0.0845482498,
0.5460506082,
-0.1061600447,
0.251416862,
-0.0556973591,
0.3769790828,
-0.7423219681,
-0.3660817742,
0.128145054,
-0.3086735606,
0.5720598102,
0.1939277351,
0.0912604779,
-0.2747977376,
-0.3574965596,
-0.4365313053,
-0.5956021547,
-0.0297779236,
0.2596048117,
0.0936442241,
-0.0664521456,
0.3147931099,
-0.3155742586,
0.8280299306,
0.2809414864,
-0.231618911,
0.481167078,
-0.595639348,
-0.3620760739,
-0.0790198296,
1.1013988256,
0.4109144807,
-0.2280258834,
-0.2256872654,
0.1271740496,
-0.2833311856,
0.4852727354,
-0.9289579988,
-0.3558786809,
0.1071980894,
-0.5535138249,
-0.2807090878,
0.3830128014,
-0.5796601176,
-0.0224473253,
-0.4952569902,
0.4136619866,
-0.6232255697,
-0.2624158263,
-0.0470004827,
-0.1102759019,
0.0997681469,
0.0279823784,
-0.9035735726,
0.021105865,
0.7016228437,
0.6784328818,
-0.5143784285,
-0.4259912074,
-0.4668166935,
0.551209867,
-0.2546661198,
0.7020982504,
-0.6570623517,
-0.4690472782,
-0.2721829414,
-0.0704704523,
-0.3956238329,
-0.6556475163,
0.4463631213,
0.0836546123,
0.0454445295,
-0.2952456474,
-0.2093620598,
-0.1105413362,
0.6599981785,
-0.5114250779,
0.9669488072,
0.0603896752,
-0.6838387847,
0.67008394,
-0.5038756728,
-0.465750277,
-0.3020878136,
-0.4043234885,
-0.8843044639,
0.346488744,
0.2712918818,
0.6042502522,
-0.2742478251,
0.2453222722,
-0.3296613693,
-0.1583790481,
0.2012597769,
-0.3367131948,
-0.0269286875,
0.0748337656,
-0.5537765622,
0.0800714642,
-0.9710538387,
0.460555613,
-0.284956187,
-0.6506876945,
-0.0623374283,
0.129748404,
-0.0459991321,
0.1124871075,
-0.0126853269,
-0.404497534,
-0.0203788094,
-0.0195347928,
0.2805047929,
0.5161661506,
0.0846803263,
0.4170643091,
-0.3831801116,
0.5521019697,
0.3937364817,
0.2191935778,
-0.1913106143,
-0.0108050387,
-0.8385319114,
-0.321657747,
0.4302503467,
0.2416744232,
-0.9350306988,
0.4888575673,
-0.2037792802,
-0.660915494,
-0.0136213452,
0.0178728774,
0.7491190434,
0.2287557274,
0.4146832526,
-0.2438650876,
-0.3143360615,
-1.0604168177,
-0.4760663211,
0.0048192847,
-0.1601939797,
0.3168946803,
0.3009816408,
-0.1970546693,
0.7154358625,
-0.615427494,
0.0697220713,
-0.2874312699,
0.8163741827,
-0.3044113517,
0.7174095511,
0.4573435187,
-0.6593331099,
-0.5640548468,
0.2029781491,
-0.5069174767,
-0.2986203134,
0.0859919786,
-0.1497913599,
0.1450860798,
0.5264130831,
-0.2043897659,
0.1458033025,
0.9473164678,
-0.0373032801,
0.7611100674,
-0.2464994788,
0.5416832566,
-1.1824249029,
0.161327213,
-0.0966526717,
-0.3741088212,
-0.4477059841,
0.3753732443,
0.3886716366,
-0.1890027523,
-0.5274314284,
0.0679164529,
-0.4903323948,
0.1775220931,
-0.4225833416,
-0.1955969334,
0.0342613049,
0.6129592061,
0.0028167921,
0.781093359,
0.285148561,
-0.8901360035,
0.0455777384,
-0.2089517415,
0.0359689444,
0.8666763902,
-0.5373854637,
0.0806196555,
-0.0203375816,
0.4403382242,
-0.7966758609,
-0.2107528299,
0.2074540257,
-0.0947362632,
0.2950779796,
0.1052268296,
-0.5346367955,
-0.2237538844,
-0.3503986597,
0.5286349654,
0.0706730857,
-0.4420090914,
0.9904378653,
-0.1869655997,
-0.0341008008,
-0.3522367179,
-0.6456910372,
-0.185381636,
0.0085673099,
-0.3301259279,
0.5161284804,
-0.2235641479,
0.2379219234,
-0.4307768643,
-0.3265787959,
-0.0551656485,
-0.096138604,
0.3009290099,
-0.3871791959,
0.0179065857,
0.1851464957,
0.4884707332,
-0.2927990854,
0.1599691063,
-0.2007925063,
0.6684007049,
0.003146142,
-0.4250385165,
-0.1105254218,
0.3764096797,
0.1452732533,
-0.4441673756,
0.3979261816,
0.6811518669,
-0.0080457898,
-0.4206028283,
-0.3732839823,
0.0300705489,
-0.4724187553,
0.4085313976,
-0.507563591,
-0.7023801208,
0.2068181187,
-0.2070982903,
0.0391614847,
0.3839779496,
0.4362936318,
0.1005112231,
0.9971773624,
0.6519835591,
0.3355587721,
0.4542776346,
-0.2907080352,
-0.1713577509,
-0.876173079,
-0.3303578794,
-0.3730297387,
-0.4043310583,
-0.9131149054,
-0.4801043272,
0.6229883432,
0.024057338,
-0.1301739216,
0.3798169196,
-0.6510544419,
0.5749382377,
0.6298559904,
0.5994752049,
0.4914211631,
-0.2674171627,
-0.4616224468,
-0.051046364,
-0.6635514498,
-0.3210806549,
1.4149583578,
-0.1130174473,
0.6780409813,
0.053351853,
0.8322390318,
0.1299490631,
0.607817173,
-0.4236499071,
0.3329425454,
-0.2144197822,
-0.4244116545,
0.1722572297,
-0.7625994682,
-0.742215991,
0.381362319,
-0.2785542011,
-0.3186597824,
0.0308472887,
0.4712670743,
-0.1592628211,
0.1197191477,
-0.7345266938,
0.8920291066,
-0.0900306776,
-0.2641302645,
-0.1183569506,
-0.3956182897,
0.5558639169,
-0.1370853335,
0.0011725061,
0.1719757766,
-0.1103689671,
0.620954752,
-0.3766593635,
0.7264197469,
0.0587543398,
-0.075721249,
0.2574847341,
0.1454544365,
0.2154428065,
0.0597049929,
0.0300466791,
0.1153329685,
-0.1756732762,
-0.3960796297,
-0.4302741289,
0.6125400662,
-0.7191906571,
-0.1347515285,
-0.2838482857,
-0.6356064677,
-0.3658238649,
0.1206808165,
0.6054185629,
0.3624791801,
-0.5443559289,
0.2891774178,
0.7550262213,
-0.3202622831,
0.8067989349,
0.4847203791,
0.0884427428,
-0.908442378,
0.9031395316,
-0.1717486978,
0.4738667011,
0.5729361176,
0.4056279063,
-0.0877638087,
-0.3704110682,
-0.2701054513,
-0.166442126,
-0.4544733167,
-0.4492299855,
-0.8759865761,
-0.1449180543,
-0.3259427249,
0.1030147895,
-0.3281150162,
-0.1732662916,
-0.1584847718,
0.0175668448,
-0.2468822896,
0.5953371525,
-0.1324679255,
0.9922692776,
-0.8698799014,
0.3143914342,
0.5355847478,
0.5063260198,
-0.0667866692,
-0.0196828023,
-0.2698007226,
0.0413181186,
-1.3083130121,
-0.6625554562,
-0.2245476097,
0.3452795446,
0.4523694813,
0.5455984473,
-0.2434040159,
0.4470710754,
-0.5998598933,
0.6799154878,
0.4414144754,
-1.2535448074,
0.5104724169,
-0.5188740492,
0.5165933967,
0.7372517586,
0.180843398,
-0.4375103414,
-0.5462864041,
-0.799208045,
-0.6644647717,
0.4922492802,
0.3337103724,
-0.1288478822,
-0.1404254884,
0.4375455379,
0.407220751,
0.6076782942,
-0.8642943501,
-0.1856037974,
-0.2988236248,
-0.2992322743,
-0.185986191,
-0.0765896961,
-0.0361157134,
-0.0950173587,
0.4380212724,
-0.3421718776,
0.1624914706,
0.1298433393,
-0.0692288354,
0.1064601988,
0.4023036063,
0.821389854,
0.7509322166,
-0.1411003917,
0.4276142716,
-0.0652356297,
-0.6475015879,
0.4338435531,
0.1306704134,
0.0212162882,
-0.1247159019,
0.5193412304,
0.5038612485,
0.2435816228,
-0.2837206721,
0.6119692326,
-0.0334100425,
-0.6024139524,
0.213083595,
0.4011321664,
-0.0553496927,
-0.1096770912,
0.282815069,
-0.0556517057,
0.286072433,
-0.3808719516,
0.2903716266,
0.3438956141,
-0.3107704818,
-0.2341144234,
0.6121960282,
0.3741458356,
0.0469916873,
0.0492142364,
-0.2200205922,
-0.5531657934,
0.5226734281,
0.5553264022,
1.0849840641,
-0.3012070656,
0.411172688,
0.4682559371,
0.4244056046,
-0.0773463398,
0.2791087627,
-0.3094381988,
-0.3946204484,
-0.5351499915,
-0.3906044066,
-0.649908185,
0.0685957223,
-0.5443412066,
-0.0026000636,
-0.6109422445,
-0.1678447276,
-0.2923306525,
-0.1089638174,
-0.6977493167,
0.5027960539,
-0.1783087701,
0.5907614827,
-0.9434691668,
0.228151083,
0.709610641,
-0.2154201716,
-0.7242538333,
0.2768137157,
-0.3319886029,
-0.3807710409,
0.3006880581,
0.4167782366,
0.0866299048,
-0.189475745,
-0.5843195915,
-0.5630351305,
1.3238168955,
0.325883925,
-0.5993449092,
0.3022709489,
0.6162294745,
0.3656786382,
-0.4855833054,
0.5277623534,
0.8106828332,
0.6511859298,
0.1243773252,
-0.7936022878,
-0.0128319496,
0.0370345302,
0.223444581,
0.4711603224,
-0.9089721441,
0.8379960656,
0.3436613679,
-0.060579855,
-0.1743159145,
0.5740379691,
0.5619075894,
0.4020874798,
0.389787972,
0.9381437898,
0.3395579159,
-0.4792819619,
0.9816637635,
-0.211358875,
0.3881904483,
1.3574906588,
0.0332432203,
0.5363747478,
0.3127161562,
0.0353324935,
0.4320867956,
0.5974135995,
0.1511407793,
0.5784602761,
0.2620442808,
-0.3878132999,
-0.3328406811,
0.1492802799,
-0.2746695578,
0.4841118157,
-0.2598357201,
-0.6179545522,
-0.4611369371,
0.1667585075,
-0.0464588925,
-0.0026285853,
-0.2990093529,
0.9275506735,
-0.195690304,
-0.6501582265,
0.311596632,
0.2421245873,
0.5198505521,
-0.6235326529,
0.0201883018,
-0.3201055527,
0.2789093554,
-0.0679016337,
-0.3000123799,
0.1795745194,
-0.3197087944,
-0.2530516684,
-0.1760896146,
0.356251508,
-0.5704739094,
-0.6271380782,
-0.0049418039,
0.4873871207,
-0.2092462778,
-0.4248543382,
-0.6103389263,
-0.0001458373,
-0.20399037,
-0.0756736547,
0.0937448889,
0.5746730566,
0.1803265661,
0.4080137014,
0.3282852173,
-0.1114184558,
0.1499115825,
-0.083638221,
0.7415708899,
-0.6937001944,
-0.4668702483,
-0.9881161451,
0.5194582343,
-0.0016043069,
-0.3045302927,
0.5986047983,
0.9550359845,
0.8308390975,
-0.0709362701,
0.9941468835,
-0.1882632673,
0.1461556554,
-0.692535162,
0.7224401236,
-0.3835915923,
-0.2410068214,
-0.4907489717,
-1.306084156,
-0.2126479,
0.2033830583,
-0.0307984091,
0.4264613688,
1.1043689251,
0.5175839663,
-0.6024869084,
-0.0880984962,
0.3031305671,
-0.1971533149,
0.6358858347,
0.6672685146,
0.6082621813,
-0.7010478377,
0.5684760809,
-0.2916422784,
-0.4609639049,
0.0757660419,
-1.2779399157,
-1.0599273443,
-0.3983080387,
-0.3768764436,
-0.1507241726,
-0.091210179,
0.7224818468,
0.9810429811,
-0.5954762101,
-0.0304001849,
-0.4369958639,
-0.081726335,
-0.4550919831,
-0.2233604044,
0.2769237459,
-0.3115877211,
-0.5953670144,
0.0783706754,
0.1210814938,
0.2259612828,
-0.1966470778,
0.1584694386,
0.1170247123,
-0.0689984038,
0.6905584335,
-0.1950371712,
-0.3035343587,
-0.243062824,
-0.3500347435,
-0.0773883983,
0.1324184984,
1.2783464193,
-0.4123600125,
0.2971228063,
0.4386866391,
0.5654294491,
0.4275716841,
0.3476947844,
0.7254522443,
-1.2481997013,
-0.121256344,
-0.150721103,
-0.0067898617,
0.1758191288,
-0.1181604266,
0.4618413746,
0.1944299936,
-0.5836678743,
-0.2310276181,
0.2806323469,
-0.9863283038,
-0.190264374,
1.138551116,
-0.083084397,
-0.2553225756,
0.438665539,
-0.0329294689,
0.369408071,
-0.3503012955,
0.732304275,
0.7170799971,
-0.1941237748,
-0.23639898,
-0.1229382232,
0.4049279094,
0.329682678,
-1.4390509129,
0.2138011754,
0.5990539193,
0.477522105,
0.1205245927,
0.5507674217,
-0.0349520817,
0.3844191134,
-0.2466923296,
0.4232403338,
-0.1341399699,
-0.3922314346,
-0.1281875074,
0.2627153993,
-0.2731740475,
-0.4361228049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04221v1
|
How Lexical is Bilingual Lexicon Induction?
| 2024-04-05T17:10:33 | 2024-04-05T17:10:33 |
Harsh Kohli, Helian Feng, Nicholas Dronen, Calvin McCarter, Sina Moeini, Ali Kebarighotbi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In contemporary machine learning approaches to bilingual lexicon induction
(BLI), a model learns a mapping between the embedding spaces of a language
pair. Recently, retrieve-and-rank approach to BLI has achieved state of the art
results on the task. However, the problem remains challenging in low-resource
settings, due to the paucity of data. The task is complicated by factors such
as lexical variation across languages. We argue that the incorporation of
additional lexical information into the recent retrieve-and-rank approach
should improve lexicon induction. We demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed
approach on XLING, improving over the previous state of the art by an average
of 2\% across all language pairs.
|
[
-0.2315704674,
-0.330221653,
0.38773489,
0.1497632116,
0.0293826759,
0.280901581,
-0.3217758238,
-0.5454484224,
0.2234186977,
0.1815797538,
-0.284070909,
-0.2335339785,
-0.8544125557,
0.3010237217,
-0.2012465745,
0.7434159517,
0.0281196553,
0.040959198,
-0.1972861886,
-0.4663202465,
-0.4591079056,
-0.5358352065,
-0.731716454,
-0.2946827412,
0.6302242875,
0.6500987411,
1.0753792524,
0.7942599058,
0.2278745174,
0.2467341721,
-0.4420692325,
0.6563889384,
-0.6059336662,
0.133284077,
-0.1986265481,
-0.6755714417,
-0.2437488884,
-0.2854980528,
0.9597125053,
1.2600449324,
-0.1558483839,
-0.2121353149,
-0.0349410139,
0.7371001244,
-0.9521427751,
0.0846687555,
-0.919716835,
0.0472112298,
-0.2903395295,
-0.2137965411,
-0.460491389,
-0.1698085368,
0.1281544119,
-0.4976588488,
0.0615268722,
0.2312181741,
0.6261354089,
-0.0608390532,
-0.4702775478,
-0.5366227627,
-0.8760825992,
0.8486639261,
-0.3494641483,
0.8556352258,
0.4415946007,
0.1561836153,
0.1665056199,
-0.4821606278,
-0.4487735927,
-0.2095779777,
-0.1475706398,
0.1618241072,
-0.0084137246,
-0.3270969987,
0.4484033883,
0.3388780951,
-0.3823754787,
0.4194664657,
-0.2679289281,
0.0526983552,
0.585067153,
0.1330907792,
0.5081019402,
0.1399675459,
-0.1696944535,
-0.0667856708,
-0.9232875109,
0.0000096972,
0.2051938325,
0.6571025252,
-0.0794378817,
0.6369712353,
-0.0673562437,
0.2409457713,
0.0303570088,
-0.0400192142,
0.5430609584,
-0.8168665767,
0.1034257561,
0.4129701853,
0.5085155964,
0.0972951651,
0.1451745331,
-0.5384124517,
-0.3808087111,
-0.2733306885,
0.0622735433,
-0.6224491596,
0.1568739712,
0.0423251092,
-0.1144029424,
0.106393531,
0.1826423854,
-0.5618807077,
-0.3419860899,
-0.3591653109,
0.311293155,
-0.3575296402,
-0.4050738513,
-0.2140310556,
-0.2282185256,
0.3533287942,
0.1519259363,
-1.478585124,
0.3801327348,
0.7198124528,
0.881149292,
-0.2777090669,
-0.3098036051,
-0.7514544725,
0.1242917404,
-0.6953491569,
0.5384219885,
-0.4895295501,
-0.7041956782,
0.3424907029,
0.1773289889,
-0.2695553303,
-0.8577216864,
0.2224917263,
-0.468131721,
0.0301654041,
-0.5153057575,
-0.3890593946,
0.208720237,
-0.0361142531,
-0.6828543544,
1.0323171616,
0.017181363,
-0.8733334541,
0.5174682736,
-0.4455561936,
-0.4873255193,
0.0822927505,
-0.0314563476,
-0.2376908064,
0.1240310892,
0.4544129074,
-0.044650279,
-0.0011097285,
0.0052819215,
-0.199786678,
-0.3341307938,
0.3053763807,
0.0258263908,
1.0010601282,
0.1190617904,
-0.2852372825,
-0.4101645052,
-0.3649377227,
-0.1930111647,
-0.0513431467,
-0.1159651577,
-0.419789046,
-0.052728951,
-0.2477512807,
0.0277603958,
0.2242166102,
-0.6656411886,
0.0798915252,
-0.8454890847,
-0.0729899928,
0.2983074784,
-0.1477954537,
0.8943195939,
-0.2622254193,
0.1941850185,
0.3665826321,
-0.2149156183,
-0.1291590929,
-0.5230192542,
-0.7137419581,
-0.2814415991,
0.6291923523,
0.7911729217,
-0.7486829758,
0.3459278047,
-0.3554896712,
-0.4881041646,
-0.5945997238,
0.6093016267,
0.4459472001,
0.1800966114,
0.3831162453,
-0.2360329926,
-0.5487458706,
-0.8018357754,
-0.0162690431,
0.0740365386,
0.1432323009,
0.3841490746,
0.2532141805,
-0.4662764966,
0.6259164214,
-0.2428595722,
-0.00159471,
-0.5558940768,
0.1349376142,
0.3080452681,
0.3827354312,
0.6130968928,
-0.8010527492,
-0.6279796958,
0.5850679278,
-0.9708461165,
-0.068654716,
0.2026639432,
-0.413539201,
0.5123723745,
0.4947240651,
-0.3249299824,
0.3363899291,
0.3652545214,
-0.0253640022,
0.2538146675,
-0.5502864122,
-0.0964004844,
-1.0734990835,
-0.0053714286,
-0.0870575383,
-0.2927246988,
-0.6119936705,
0.1020473018,
0.315512538,
-0.0769473314,
-0.4405963123,
0.5566949248,
-0.5779002309,
-0.259395659,
-0.2989966571,
0.1978484392,
-0.2655142248,
0.1927983165,
0.2317765057,
0.6554641724,
0.7264670134,
-0.5474745631,
0.188581571,
0.2823935151,
-0.1068950891,
0.1802261025,
-0.2094438821,
0.0920677856,
-0.2784803212,
-0.0093834409,
-0.8404850364,
-0.0403456464,
-0.0960860848,
-0.4206447005,
0.4602348208,
0.0067228326,
-0.627317071,
-0.1453238875,
-0.2412788421,
0.6011920571,
0.7153478861,
-0.9714651108,
0.1875777096,
0.5588982701,
-0.4108262062,
-0.6840802431,
-0.7216135263,
-0.0481325127,
0.1219331548,
-0.3617579341,
0.5058062673,
0.1161597818,
-0.4661576152,
0.0333879404,
-0.0150175504,
-0.2037267238,
0.1008145288,
-0.022561064,
0.0438739322,
-0.2853595316,
0.0652947649,
0.2270326912,
-0.010632203,
-0.071481593,
-0.2871031165,
0.2558879852,
0.1568897516,
-0.1444087327,
-0.5778590441,
0.5075104833,
0.5696086287,
-0.2513357699,
0.8787990212,
0.467048347,
-0.5954850316,
-0.3608315885,
-0.3205718398,
-0.0341614187,
-0.4020459652,
0.2692143023,
-0.1917840242,
-0.4213916659,
0.4924532473,
0.0134928534,
-0.0121819377,
0.2809295058,
0.9457753301,
0.0618067384,
1.2361847162,
0.908985436,
-0.1819752157,
0.3848781884,
-0.4768547714,
0.4310798645,
-0.6108045578,
-0.3365039527,
-0.5255130529,
-0.1490948051,
-1.002527833,
-0.1815560907,
0.3152836561,
-0.0657732338,
0.1288995296,
0.2489902824,
-0.073206231,
0.3532003164,
0.5743023157,
0.1339450777,
0.1651897132,
0.0757184848,
-0.5576812029,
-0.1542318612,
-0.877356708,
0.0720418766,
1.2276711464,
0.0279031619,
0.4368067384,
0.3479563892,
1.1704457998,
-0.0221076068,
0.1414889246,
-0.5675887465,
0.0997562781,
-0.2882007062,
-0.3989997208,
-0.2773491442,
-0.5184191465,
-1.112798214,
0.1397333145,
-0.4229518175,
-0.789437592,
0.2404819578,
0.0649899244,
-0.2497840822,
0.2216191441,
-0.7788719535,
0.6917436123,
-0.2416927367,
-0.5752619505,
-0.1797456741,
-0.2587537766,
0.1330075115,
-0.2944498956,
0.5486692786,
0.2338133603,
-0.0153212911,
0.5122442245,
-0.581214726,
0.5077946782,
-0.1990253329,
-0.1221088991,
0.0839645341,
-0.0540376306,
0.257458806,
0.2989018559,
-0.1301075071,
-0.0642173812,
0.0343319029,
-0.5994255543,
-0.8234875798,
0.8563938737,
-0.9195321202,
-0.3947001696,
-0.2901324034,
-0.8176659346,
-0.3870520592,
-0.1328397095,
0.2443336844,
0.677396059,
0.1476443261,
0.1090452746,
0.6334123015,
-0.1380856782,
0.5249587893,
0.1050454378,
-0.2905225456,
-0.3457224667,
1.1183743477,
0.3629390597,
0.1337103993,
0.6096507311,
0.2193995267,
-0.4546375871,
-0.286775589,
-0.4216267467,
0.4406287372,
-0.4350903928,
0.0736807808,
-0.5478821993,
-0.5231902003,
-0.7162738442,
-0.3349882066,
-0.4123122394,
-0.5211855769,
0.2115616947,
-0.0704213977,
-0.1737478226,
0.7546628714,
-0.2329044342,
0.0621694773,
-0.7261442542,
0.3718751669,
0.4594119191,
0.0598403253,
0.0790461376,
-0.4723224044,
-0.518207252,
0.1920536906,
-0.3579508364,
-0.844265461,
0.4679097533,
0.2646260858,
0.9602745175,
0.3586745262,
-0.2243952155,
0.5123574734,
-0.5698973536,
0.7743706107,
0.1479416043,
-0.7282676697,
0.4201122224,
0.0069430317,
0.3658909798,
0.2534621358,
0.7526908517,
-0.536252737,
-0.6736277342,
-0.6573404074,
-0.7764812112,
0.6692037582,
0.3054582477,
0.1931517869,
-0.1031372026,
0.2156774551,
0.3189154267,
-0.027011266,
-0.7005384564,
-0.187851578,
0.0677502751,
-0.1022377759,
-0.4292430282,
-0.4144633412,
0.1158612072,
-0.5843114853,
0.5130987167,
0.0788867623,
0.2046655715,
-0.0017258838,
-0.550997436,
-0.0292727053,
0.1148066521,
0.3472831249,
0.985960722,
-0.014235775,
0.2235731781,
0.5720773339,
-0.1956673265,
-0.0868407115,
0.0543825254,
-0.1019431129,
0.3180516064,
0.5514735579,
0.757130146,
0.4710161388,
-0.4012885094,
0.5098240972,
0.2262950242,
-0.3656229377,
-0.24666664,
-0.0425269715,
-0.0039851209,
0.2076984346,
0.3370715976,
-0.2709711492,
-0.050461784,
-0.8123381734,
0.0819446668,
0.4238570631,
-0.2493661791,
-0.3109411895,
0.4563326836,
0.0335418396,
-0.3674146831,
0.6574781537,
-0.555860877,
-0.6429008245,
0.5837417245,
0.9479922056,
0.4905227721,
-0.2157223523,
0.021536814,
0.7048761249,
0.138843298,
-0.0132283261,
0.3763288856,
-0.3711522818,
-1.003991127,
-0.2644735873,
-0.4599393606,
-0.6899448037,
-0.2859756351,
-0.6264663935,
0.5113946199,
-0.0835781172,
0.2002078742,
0.0260947905,
0.1071581617,
-0.6288002133,
-0.0980933234,
0.7766370773,
0.7962597013,
-1.1102517843,
0.8610609174,
0.7636133432,
-0.2746758461,
-0.6140517592,
0.0321026109,
-0.1477093697,
-0.8150625229,
0.9693716764,
0.2838931978,
0.0075974856,
-0.049143292,
-0.1191862673,
-0.8660655618,
0.9323677421,
0.1567848176,
-0.11074844,
-0.1446504891,
0.2740668654,
0.5156628489,
-0.4019672871,
0.3238509893,
0.5888351798,
0.3267707229,
-0.0706741661,
-0.9718236923,
-0.1968896389,
-0.2511481345,
0.1972399056,
0.2546136677,
-0.1545360982,
0.5949252844,
-0.2971660495,
-0.2772751451,
0.0274109971,
0.6638601422,
0.1493452042,
0.5995779634,
0.6716067195,
0.6698258519,
0.9511643648,
0.0977493003,
1.0350372791,
-0.4117415547,
0.1439554691,
0.6334469318,
-0.4537860751,
0.9007914662,
0.3762561679,
-0.1141216084,
0.735650897,
0.4468649924,
0.2412190586,
0.5823743939,
-0.0648243278,
-0.1800032407,
-0.2520239055,
-0.1797691584,
-0.2520994246,
0.5379051566,
0.5070592761,
-0.3870757818,
-0.4041907787,
0.1029879972,
-0.03431632,
0.2687101662,
-0.4496650696,
0.9002103806,
0.015018289,
-0.8717390895,
0.8711848259,
-0.190319106,
0.386025697,
-0.258718282,
0.1202379018,
-0.5796993375,
0.0286777206,
-0.2207172066,
-0.4361134171,
0.2663885355,
0.0421883389,
-0.158829093,
-0.3074327707,
0.3280953765,
-0.6443932652,
-0.6908478141,
0.4998771548,
0.9570447206,
0.0533689335,
0.5181312561,
-0.2549009621,
-0.252276212,
-0.2700569928,
0.3356023431,
0.3701778352,
0.4548805356,
-0.1728061885,
0.411429584,
0.5806369185,
0.3315666914,
0.3371999264,
0.1492857635,
0.5098270774,
-0.6024667025,
-0.5654608011,
-0.8289945722,
0.1317680627,
-0.1876193136,
-0.1702525318,
0.5693679452,
0.7848152518,
0.9988758564,
0.1092707217,
0.6303271055,
0.0028164834,
0.5610409379,
-0.5973274112,
0.4450812638,
-0.736559391,
0.0018559817,
0.1734100282,
-0.9004557729,
-0.4388827682,
0.2356233895,
-0.3273363709,
-0.2118707746,
1.1589075327,
1.0666309595,
-0.2446125299,
-0.0189280137,
0.4651613533,
0.1965223253,
-0.1571490765,
0.5595809221,
0.961782217,
-0.0822714791,
0.4463029504,
-0.658905983,
-0.3567050695,
-0.181231603,
-0.5001456738,
-0.7870277762,
-0.6616870761,
-0.1145142913,
-0.3304908574,
0.3778898418,
1.0420440435,
0.6885432005,
-0.7590469718,
-0.5878706574,
-0.0652364269,
0.4926823378,
-0.4956497848,
-0.0953511819,
0.1463920921,
-1.0965249538,
-1.0729641914,
0.3478383422,
0.1038787887,
-0.411976248,
0.0100061577,
-0.0401116125,
-0.2796943784,
-0.1055222079,
0.6476697922,
0.4419184923,
-0.3936899304,
-0.1547969729,
-0.0007274441,
-0.3600924611,
0.1960197538,
0.717197299,
-0.6690219045,
0.5713924766,
0.4274623692,
0.9892926216,
0.5084483624,
-0.2176225632,
0.5859364271,
-0.8084716797,
0.3978292644,
-0.1054935977,
0.6512998939,
0.3618350327,
-0.2877580822,
0.3690039217,
0.461399287,
-0.4797548056,
-0.9380581379,
0.1469791979,
-0.8683083653,
0.0467392989,
1.3326796293,
0.1332404166,
-0.5251116753,
0.0931982547,
-0.0894393176,
0.307120502,
-0.0098713487,
0.6438530087,
0.4162035286,
-0.0797647089,
0.0132597117,
-0.4060365856,
0.254099369,
0.5872752666,
-0.452147156,
-0.0178850759,
0.0237257648,
0.0350770205,
0.2508938909,
0.3246768415,
-0.1724151671,
0.5373517275,
0.017925676,
-0.1325573325,
0.283965677,
-0.4522354305,
-0.2250592858,
-0.0021726592,
0.4785627723,
-0.1132208779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04212v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04212v1
|
Unlocking Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Low-Resource Language Translation
| 2024-04-05T16:42:28 | 2024-04-05T16:42:28 |
Tong Su, Xin Peng, Sarubi Thillainathan, David Guzmán, Surangika Ranathunga, En-Shiun Annie Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods are increasingly vital in
adapting large-scale pre-trained language models for diverse tasks, offering a
balance between adaptability and computational efficiency. They are important
in Low-Resource Language (LRL) Neural Machine Translation (NMT) to enhance
translation accuracy with minimal resources. However, their practical
effectiveness varies significantly across different languages. We conducted
comprehensive empirical experiments with varying LRL domains and sizes to
evaluate the performance of 8 PEFT methods with in total of 15 architectures
using the SacreBLEU score. We showed that 6 PEFT architectures outperform the
baseline for both in-domain and out-domain tests and the Houlsby+Inversion
adapter has the best performance overall, proving the effectiveness of PEFT
methods.
|
[
-0.4596488774,
-0.8593938351,
0.4336033762,
0.2504200637,
-0.4988533258,
0.1230179891,
-0.6210818291,
-0.3065580428,
-0.3645863533,
0.3262583911,
-0.2675040662,
-0.1608145982,
-0.5409253836,
0.2387486994,
0.0073463973,
0.9172218442,
-0.1665662229,
0.0516605861,
0.2456465364,
-0.2928282022,
-0.2340542972,
-0.4473716915,
-0.7673833966,
-0.3205599487,
0.335503161,
0.4410981834,
0.7535409331,
0.6958360672,
0.7218417525,
0.2491230965,
-0.1492720842,
0.38688007,
-0.4103784561,
-0.0546583124,
-0.3554847836,
-0.2443303168,
-0.6712757945,
-0.2607422173,
0.8158358932,
0.7993795276,
-0.0326977633,
0.3868675828,
0.3842679262,
0.9251439571,
-0.6231795549,
-0.1669665873,
-0.7633213401,
-0.1234620661,
-0.2445876598,
-0.2804115415,
-0.4492729902,
-0.2949435115,
0.1538170129,
-0.4706369042,
0.0684082508,
-0.0001288714,
0.7249497771,
0.5223288536,
-0.1349254549,
0.0319158174,
-0.7571191192,
1.0520346165,
-0.8064488173,
0.6934863329,
0.4082052112,
0.1650306433,
-0.0859844312,
-0.5504407287,
-0.1158846468,
-0.2158571482,
-0.030152658,
-0.0362610519,
-0.1798027754,
0.3216148019,
0.2369914502,
0.3354204595,
-0.4494282603,
0.3097933531,
-0.3302752972,
-0.0641485825,
0.4037156105,
0.0277467556,
0.0014670372,
0.0540658571,
-0.2154616863,
-0.119036518,
-0.6688531637,
0.1272599101,
0.3511891067,
0.5005609989,
-0.1162847653,
0.326510191,
-0.2533107102,
1.0275373459,
0.532111764,
-0.1231468618,
0.1794920564,
-0.5044023991,
-0.34177351,
-0.1274494976,
0.662070334,
0.1914342344,
0.1035404131,
-0.3720168769,
-0.4748983383,
-0.4852108657,
0.2419947535,
-0.8536365032,
-0.0857089087,
-0.0711488575,
-0.6738317609,
-0.1175139323,
-0.4249953032,
-0.6674420834,
-0.1232062876,
-0.2331125289,
0.4971418083,
-0.6045026779,
-0.2371169627,
0.0325714871,
0.0054220962,
0.4546990097,
0.353527844,
-0.8527444601,
0.4784587622,
0.4333076775,
0.9145477414,
-0.5505597591,
-0.4510135353,
-0.6811346412,
-0.290838033,
-0.3849891126,
0.6681534052,
-0.4754461348,
-0.0949458554,
-0.4173598886,
0.1490900367,
-0.4493788481,
-0.6893388629,
0.8174222112,
-0.5242405534,
-0.4226482213,
-0.2629464269,
-0.2541466951,
-0.1835610569,
0.1345937848,
-0.5646826029,
1.0227214098,
0.3350582421,
-0.0230591688,
0.1831965894,
-0.6899333596,
-0.4793460071,
0.0401696004,
0.124322705,
-0.4098538756,
0.6335763335,
0.1163353622,
0.567378819,
-0.4727445841,
0.0530940667,
0.0112233758,
-0.5565895438,
0.1345497519,
-0.8037902713,
0.4394418895,
0.4045032561,
-0.4792220294,
-0.1199059859,
-0.7050498724,
0.2193678021,
0.1404557079,
-0.6636672616,
-0.4441977441,
-0.1893263012,
0.1589339972,
0.080197759,
0.192646578,
-0.3691299856,
0.0944683477,
-0.6613918543,
0.6610634327,
0.5672426224,
-0.0880079344,
0.8222582936,
-0.1748485118,
0.4503183067,
-0.2198405862,
0.1162397861,
0.1018517613,
-0.3412589729,
-0.455379039,
-0.0532256961,
0.4420316815,
0.3391113579,
-0.5922596455,
0.2444489598,
-0.1219705939,
-0.6837559938,
-0.5563829541,
0.2812622786,
0.705760777,
0.5526040792,
0.3863488436,
0.0171558987,
-0.0982678309,
-1.1554875374,
-0.5720419884,
0.1419247389,
0.1728785634,
0.3590514362,
0.2809562087,
0.1450799406,
0.2462991327,
-0.1047878265,
0.0366176404,
-0.1238214523,
0.0628307089,
0.5340967178,
0.6748630404,
0.8773447275,
-0.7773462534,
-0.7556151748,
0.3747248948,
-0.1186861098,
-0.0078850538,
-0.215733245,
-0.1448069215,
0.3849346042,
0.3243264854,
-0.2906178832,
0.0899277702,
0.7421358824,
-0.1002369821,
0.2559928596,
-0.4850127399,
0.4129019678,
-0.7363996506,
0.1571427733,
-0.1836951077,
-0.3543887138,
-0.6737300158,
0.2531222105,
0.4036238194,
-0.0462326743,
-0.7437105775,
0.2861196995,
-0.5518134236,
0.1379138678,
-0.1930397451,
-0.0490992032,
-0.0972379297,
0.6597776413,
-0.0917961001,
1.2177519798,
0.2441640943,
-0.6849657893,
-0.2084117383,
-0.1200526208,
-0.2104331255,
0.3605183959,
-0.6573167443,
0.4348022044,
0.1247980371,
-0.3347810507,
-0.8127305508,
0.018767003,
0.1514733136,
-0.1635151654,
0.2895908356,
-0.299095124,
-0.3681788445,
0.1373765171,
-0.2646029294,
0.6095522046,
0.6326001883,
-0.4992492199,
0.5981452465,
0.2680461407,
0.0220350046,
-0.4130554497,
-0.5712797046,
-0.2354688197,
-0.2893792391,
-0.1650455743,
0.6996881366,
-0.1817692965,
-0.0477226898,
-0.2248494327,
-0.3153914213,
-0.2280389667,
0.3518271744,
-0.011646742,
-0.1249844879,
-0.4395038784,
-0.1478196084,
0.5323988795,
-0.0575567447,
-0.318118602,
-0.2587528825,
0.7287858129,
-0.696365416,
-0.1646706015,
-0.2633528709,
0.3276309371,
0.7656518817,
-0.3111394048,
0.7684887052,
0.5209053755,
-0.4877299368,
-0.2040856332,
-0.390743196,
0.0965836644,
-0.4912874103,
0.5278874636,
-0.6663765311,
-0.758346796,
0.4476941824,
-0.4669653177,
0.0401293524,
0.4959100485,
0.7446810603,
-0.0922283158,
0.9237064123,
0.5476270318,
0.1014491394,
0.4596642554,
-0.1719515175,
0.1742108613,
-0.9207322598,
0.1958637834,
-0.6225296855,
-0.5972453952,
-0.6976761222,
-0.3105282187,
0.254262358,
0.6359775066,
-0.1137717962,
0.7399331331,
-0.7521708608,
0.7513774037,
0.5320913792,
0.1784623116,
0.2639085054,
0.0562977418,
-0.0986486897,
-0.1085638106,
-0.7301971316,
-0.4792135656,
1.0027947426,
0.0921418145,
0.501103878,
0.0050261407,
0.6000935435,
0.0170279238,
-0.0133522255,
-0.8282821178,
0.3887381554,
-0.5798510909,
-0.3930375874,
-0.4280001521,
-0.1971395463,
-0.6894951463,
0.1937229484,
-0.085542649,
-0.6686916947,
0.4689806998,
0.4806489646,
-0.5713544488,
0.2693635821,
-0.8914390206,
0.7680723071,
-0.5702784061,
-0.3734111786,
-0.3274973035,
-0.4310542047,
-0.1303672194,
-0.5999100208,
-0.0764926821,
-0.1562113315,
-0.2825501561,
0.7004573941,
-0.1230015382,
0.5749596357,
-0.2494563907,
0.022764802,
-0.0262452755,
0.2287338227,
0.6516320705,
0.0831917673,
-0.4657505453,
0.4394150078,
0.1812625527,
-0.4063947499,
-0.5095205903,
0.7662853003,
-0.8182305694,
-0.4154037535,
-0.0225848444,
-0.6097614169,
-0.3742085099,
0.3736867905,
0.4656860828,
0.0519725159,
-0.1710570604,
0.5038735271,
0.6530100107,
-0.2848370373,
0.4600729048,
0.5297710896,
0.2850500345,
-0.3546849787,
0.8663136363,
0.3324041367,
0.4382427931,
0.54934448,
0.3761650622,
0.0266333316,
-1.0420897007,
-0.6088671684,
0.0220992882,
-0.3403109014,
-0.460147351,
-0.3917515278,
-0.1570461094,
-0.0288889538,
-0.4483053982,
-0.8695753813,
-0.5782926083,
-0.0232539866,
0.2018023282,
0.3601581752,
0.1310859919,
-0.0240121223,
0.5298845768,
-0.8701850176,
0.3200007975,
-0.1094452217,
0.4341211021,
-0.1525551528,
-0.684972167,
-0.4169015884,
-0.0000314134,
-0.237200141,
-0.7114977837,
0.1305863261,
0.5910037756,
0.6949760318,
0.2424264103,
0.1714532077,
0.8726812005,
-0.6488385797,
0.5931882262,
-0.0372963808,
-0.9909739494,
0.5644674897,
-0.2646981776,
0.2490160763,
0.8330172896,
0.3043428361,
-0.1441266537,
-0.0195110384,
-0.2594480217,
-0.856007278,
0.7427389026,
0.2530712187,
0.2760790288,
0.2666421533,
0.7793006897,
0.4336551726,
0.0794231221,
-0.3121519387,
-0.2607015669,
-0.0086780619,
-0.1390586495,
0.012870091,
-0.0341293812,
0.084608674,
-0.5100956559,
0.544203639,
-0.3105805814,
0.2842719555,
0.1146665514,
-0.24927634,
-0.3414286971,
0.251563549,
0.7484399676,
0.6442557573,
-0.303724438,
0.1390753835,
0.6253691912,
-0.5841015577,
0.1267024577,
0.0332091786,
-0.3019636869,
-0.1850282252,
0.1596393585,
0.7921979427,
0.2582702637,
-0.5294889808,
0.1377599388,
-0.0240723193,
-0.4306257069,
0.061807055,
0.2624282837,
-0.0276778955,
0.320618242,
0.16592969,
0.4692846239,
0.1951211095,
-0.1355273277,
0.0525793508,
0.3707864881,
-0.2693464756,
-0.5015990138,
0.5993044376,
0.0940135196,
-0.5659274459,
0.4302335083,
0.0355407,
-0.2062089294,
0.3440334499,
0.6721083522,
0.9336568713,
-0.2852158546,
0.0092250202,
0.2951547205,
0.5647425056,
-0.1744596362,
0.1589451432,
-0.3375103474,
-0.5870084167,
-0.5554448366,
-0.9734169245,
-0.3741396368,
0.2569711506,
-0.739628315,
-0.0583301336,
-0.3747441173,
-0.2867447436,
-0.0147481076,
-0.0400095917,
-0.7872764468,
-0.1070341691,
-0.159915626,
1.1041016579,
-0.6408644319,
1.0396077633,
0.9530193806,
-0.1336230487,
-0.7745089531,
0.0297147781,
-0.3473285735,
-0.8393821716,
0.57377249,
-0.4250206947,
-0.3286150396,
0.2574751973,
-0.3096829057,
-0.9620572925,
0.8890638947,
0.9099045396,
-0.7474709749,
-0.0598384105,
0.2718091011,
0.4734767675,
-0.0150618618,
-0.1957206577,
0.9629836679,
0.5538081527,
-0.4734677076,
-1.1194883585,
0.0773126334,
-0.1887481064,
0.1525479406,
0.4415583909,
-0.7704300284,
0.6449055076,
0.0801811963,
0.0947457701,
0.1525547206,
0.2893409431,
0.2140846848,
-0.0245843343,
0.5792323351,
0.2238772362,
0.6956507564,
-0.1838704944,
0.9250398278,
-0.5932459235,
0.3486985862,
0.9979369044,
0.1406939477,
0.9251998663,
0.8137306571,
-0.0812778249,
-0.1705680043,
0.5238274932,
0.1035706028,
0.8348039985,
-0.0244738385,
0.1026300713,
-0.4851080179,
-0.0308224764,
-0.2507835031,
0.4003874958,
0.389475584,
-0.5290089846,
-0.2042159587,
0.0958760753,
-0.0879673809,
0.0258859806,
-0.3739448786,
0.6585258245,
0.2229190469,
-0.6546218395,
1.0156689882,
0.2365929782,
0.5477602482,
-0.3830154538,
-0.0957116485,
-0.2838446796,
0.4571681917,
-0.0689513907,
-0.5286461711,
0.455463469,
0.0127002401,
-0.2073408663,
-0.4974167645,
0.8585627079,
-0.0493946113,
-0.2888489068,
0.3971322775,
0.7628856301,
0.0674312264,
-0.2529845834,
-0.8624982834,
0.0769432858,
-0.1620269269,
-0.5389609933,
0.5270998478,
0.4400739074,
-0.075658977,
0.1653318852,
0.5850510597,
0.2741077542,
0.0530488156,
-0.1735046208,
0.7803142667,
-0.4755603075,
-0.130978018,
-0.9961186647,
0.3091068864,
0.1071774587,
-0.548466444,
0.6961910129,
0.5248161554,
0.9177405834,
-0.3137585521,
0.4774790704,
0.0640558004,
0.1192854643,
-0.6296221018,
0.9197583199,
-0.6073872447,
0.1006079763,
-0.2867097557,
-0.9995631576,
-0.3518203497,
0.665928185,
-0.2415431887,
-0.2098985761,
0.6689012051,
0.6432844996,
-0.2584876716,
-0.3063827157,
0.6494112015,
0.1194655076,
0.1072602421,
0.6626229286,
0.5770233274,
-0.6973283887,
0.5633277297,
-0.4721128941,
-0.2414358258,
-0.1029093638,
-0.8498003483,
-0.8028888702,
-0.5615546703,
-0.1786481887,
-0.0827140287,
0.2276358455,
0.9760708213,
0.8430473804,
-0.9817757607,
-0.1196153462,
-0.1639549732,
-0.0493572243,
-0.7271458507,
-0.1050531864,
0.5376223922,
-0.3881716132,
-0.864613235,
0.7316263914,
0.4996220171,
-0.1757524908,
0.1193404496,
-0.3717207015,
0.0898956656,
0.1158998236,
0.5884094834,
0.2079939991,
-0.629099369,
-0.248215422,
0.3602367342,
0.059824381,
0.1686501354,
0.8208111525,
-0.5544270277,
0.0983600393,
0.6151357889,
1.0261933804,
0.3642397225,
-0.0907320976,
0.61078614,
-0.6794439554,
0.1273790896,
0.2045626789,
0.3596068323,
-0.0390319936,
-0.4385737777,
0.5355309844,
0.000586477,
-0.6121529937,
-0.9706926346,
0.0392150134,
-1.0223799944,
-0.1932431906,
0.8445413709,
-0.0143351555,
-0.3774037063,
-0.0123088947,
-0.203870222,
0.1800893992,
-0.4078775346,
0.4846291542,
0.4354730248,
-0.3506326973,
-0.3092054129,
-0.5572609305,
0.6367822886,
0.4307088256,
-0.6073060632,
0.0802151784,
-0.065472886,
0.267132014,
0.1401161551,
0.6466844082,
-0.1807509214,
0.3096163869,
-0.2615842521,
-0.4184524417,
-0.1878001988,
-0.2563696802,
-0.4419267178,
0.1637425274,
0.4032824337,
-0.1680038571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04204v1
|
Social Skill Training with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-05T16:29:58 | 2024-04-05T16:29:58 |
Diyi Yang, Caleb Ziems, William Held, Omar Shaikh, Michael S. Bernstein, John Mitchell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
People rely on social skills like conflict resolution to communicate
effectively and to thrive in both work and personal life. However, practice
environments for social skills are typically out of reach for most people. How
can we make social skill training more available, accessible, and inviting?
Drawing upon interdisciplinary research from communication and psychology, this
perspective paper identifies social skill barriers to enter specialized fields.
Then we present a solution that leverages large language models for social
skill training via a generic framework. Our AI Partner, AI Mentor framework
merges experiential learning with realistic practice and tailored feedback.
This work ultimately calls for cross-disciplinary innovation to address the
broader implications for workforce development and social equality.
|
[
-0.1583051234,
-0.6263178587,
0.5252463222,
0.2904520631,
0.1288103312,
0.5369142294,
-0.3759441674,
-0.7988715768,
0.265406698,
-0.0494934618,
-0.5865778327,
-0.2139817923,
-0.7792966366,
-0.1677071899,
-0.0601801462,
0.6841400266,
0.2099054307,
0.2610807717,
-0.1560735255,
-0.4546750784,
-0.4601000547,
-0.5308846831,
-1.0734084845,
-0.5150466561,
0.3976415098,
0.5589421988,
0.6256557107,
0.4016264379,
0.409150362,
0.3761942685,
-0.2332131267,
0.083931528,
-0.5765315294,
-0.1339202821,
-0.3884357214,
-0.51394701,
-0.1826821119,
0.1179255396,
0.6593607664,
0.9873870611,
-0.154679209,
-0.0684399605,
0.1021858901,
0.6099456549,
-0.1983383894,
0.4303662181,
-0.7243720889,
0.1052052006,
-0.1765523255,
0.4092939794,
-0.1898607761,
-0.2283112109,
0.0710690245,
-0.6406024694,
0.2953746021,
-0.1730022877,
0.5922749043,
0.0253665354,
-0.443651408,
0.1985286921,
-0.8976075053,
0.5065957904,
-0.3734109402,
0.3302111924,
0.4578106999,
0.6800715923,
-0.1851139963,
-0.3955457509,
-0.3350814879,
-0.0232397411,
0.227121681,
-0.0214605536,
0.4628317952,
0.0967720672,
0.2006839663,
0.0272665229,
-0.0539430007,
0.2639738023,
-0.6963880062,
0.3195879161,
0.9436256289,
0.3913202882,
0.3158338368,
0.4636501968,
0.3338531852,
-0.1177167445,
-0.6311212182,
0.4218934476,
0.2891684771,
0.203473404,
-0.4433912635,
0.1704274416,
-0.1793780029,
0.3436520994,
-0.1448631734,
-0.0928018987,
-0.0356704146,
0.0141359037,
0.2309013605,
-0.2417419404,
0.3209709823,
0.2428551465,
0.3670420945,
-0.2568445504,
0.0524882674,
0.0621807352,
0.4134103656,
-0.3937976658,
0.1609715968,
-0.0885939449,
-0.4593386352,
-0.3124296665,
0.0452199541,
-0.5617001057,
-0.7874583006,
-0.2888607681,
0.0669661909,
-0.3394931555,
-0.5630458593,
-0.0297935028,
-0.3723100722,
0.2930711508,
0.6058171988,
-0.9629880786,
0.4066883028,
0.8611088395,
1.002767086,
0.1444822401,
-0.4669990838,
-0.5564272404,
0.1528366059,
-0.3076119721,
0.4509508312,
-0.9027144909,
-0.3204967082,
0.3006086349,
-0.0278762616,
0.0740299746,
-0.4713360369,
-0.1043931991,
-0.3014095426,
-0.2803831398,
-0.3044974506,
-0.3327645957,
0.1818319261,
0.1587559283,
-0.4323740005,
0.8713322282,
0.5096333623,
-0.3169041574,
0.4649372101,
-0.8068941236,
-0.5650784373,
0.3918400109,
-0.4224366248,
-0.1504374146,
0.0759848207,
-0.2512948513,
0.3958657086,
-0.3420548439,
0.350289464,
-0.7570681572,
-0.4997099638,
0.1182219833,
0.0319846198,
0.7518521547,
0.0032586728,
-0.5000760555,
0.1711116582,
-0.7092004418,
-0.2498565614,
0.2272133678,
-0.4550411999,
-0.3409391642,
-0.0545290411,
0.0369882733,
0.3635282815,
-0.1744076461,
-0.5183334947,
0.0340796076,
-0.3163952827,
0.7230708599,
0.7575595975,
-0.4565613866,
0.539214313,
-0.3166984916,
0.526073575,
-0.1188530326,
0.2135145217,
0.2886795998,
-0.4394637048,
-0.494435221,
-0.0191514958,
-0.2155092508,
0.2718159556,
-1.0694925785,
0.463427633,
-0.0658280849,
-0.7051192522,
-0.7500579953,
0.3939362764,
0.4629282951,
0.0390835106,
0.2399140447,
-0.4617745876,
-0.3941425681,
-0.3570918143,
-0.5540109277,
-0.1795908213,
0.1917486787,
0.3944856226,
0.586648047,
-0.0776508451,
0.630692184,
-0.1482973099,
-0.4657506049,
-0.5646618009,
-0.0933205411,
0.0141765773,
0.5337643027,
0.3453436792,
-0.8606163859,
-0.682937026,
0.1063926592,
-0.9230207801,
0.2193685621,
0.0479566529,
-0.0285723489,
-0.1395496279,
0.9101395011,
-0.3279621899,
0.5581370592,
0.4014905393,
-0.4059914351,
0.2815723717,
-0.201948002,
0.0014049152,
-0.8140479922,
0.1140101999,
0.2902535498,
-0.3210704327,
-0.7307296395,
0.0264066868,
-0.1059151441,
-0.5180345774,
-0.3113018572,
0.8590245247,
-0.4354843199,
-0.0679362491,
0.0797959492,
0.0317570642,
-0.4244332016,
0.3039701283,
0.2532215714,
0.3480101824,
0.4250169992,
-0.3874705732,
0.4282832742,
0.4031584263,
-0.5171986222,
0.9420753121,
-0.9682501554,
0.2158130407,
-0.2307455689,
0.3293341696,
-0.6557282805,
-0.4021105468,
0.0091737686,
-0.1680035293,
0.2246796936,
-0.1249866858,
-0.0452543907,
-0.5474020839,
-0.164944604,
0.3634643257,
0.3194211125,
-0.3874829113,
0.5032882094,
0.6104214787,
-0.4765455723,
-0.5232713223,
-0.4196738303,
0.1131407544,
0.1360657215,
-0.6615759134,
0.3305118084,
-0.0127608478,
-0.3186556101,
0.0066468781,
0.2506430149,
-0.2292306274,
0.2428874373,
0.4631522894,
0.0450153463,
0.0508338176,
0.1166443899,
0.1426504254,
-0.0901091248,
0.0080356747,
0.0989989415,
0.4289808273,
-0.1130703464,
-0.6474840641,
-0.1370479465,
0.631621778,
0.6180816889,
-0.2921532989,
1.1296095848,
0.3580704927,
-0.3929196,
-0.1312002838,
-0.6685364842,
-0.2245431095,
-0.4868118763,
0.8183634281,
-0.070799239,
-1.075393796,
0.4069923759,
-0.024807483,
0.1857295185,
-0.4286874235,
0.2108485997,
0.057182543,
0.9692450166,
0.9660595059,
0.0263155624,
0.8788827062,
-0.159694612,
0.3699371815,
-0.715942204,
-0.3730300963,
-0.223953411,
-0.3208454847,
0.1349121332,
-0.2415177971,
0.4013831913,
-0.2077237815,
-0.2993287146,
0.047128547,
-0.3209768236,
0.3979615271,
0.7355695963,
0.3622258306,
0.0859606266,
-0.272398442,
0.0862415582,
-0.1818694025,
-0.6557558775,
-0.2155559659,
0.6364821792,
0.5681306124,
0.5469604731,
0.0560559556,
0.566144228,
0.2410352975,
0.6384413242,
-0.4771330357,
0.3910655975,
0.0295372792,
-0.7310085297,
-0.5477128029,
-0.3399529755,
-0.605858326,
0.0682872906,
-0.3767070472,
-0.4690004587,
0.1650410593,
0.119251661,
-0.3899003565,
0.3334126472,
-0.6948048472,
0.8785482645,
0.1178819314,
-0.4423300922,
-0.3253708482,
-0.8448517919,
0.0157199148,
-0.064864859,
0.4664544463,
-0.1643706262,
0.3214076459,
0.5272609591,
-0.3121936023,
1.2451041937,
-0.3132352531,
0.0376303457,
0.0738541707,
-0.1484927237,
0.5983319283,
-0.1212109029,
0.0260504652,
0.0048457244,
-0.1321676821,
-0.5706866384,
-0.501424551,
0.2944021523,
-0.9790369272,
-0.6273275018,
-0.2175897509,
-0.581944406,
-0.3652901947,
-0.0753072277,
0.2141969949,
0.0034453548,
-0.599519372,
0.3753330708,
0.4501138628,
-0.3082892299,
0.1436086446,
0.6955449581,
0.1309401393,
-0.1652428657,
0.697951436,
0.4684981704,
0.3677895963,
-0.066269204,
-0.1431992948,
-0.0197462142,
-0.1468288749,
0.0680904463,
0.4401744306,
-0.6908065677,
-0.0276612807,
-0.6481388807,
-0.534793973,
-0.8097338676,
-0.6603474617,
-0.347206682,
-0.0506518856,
0.0904817283,
-0.1776446998,
0.3542922139,
1.0121850967,
-0.4574049711,
0.2531405091,
-0.6445648074,
0.0413712189,
0.5324242711,
0.5899512172,
0.4358986318,
-0.2445145249,
-0.5373095274,
0.0945642963,
-0.1550363153,
-0.6182513833,
0.171554327,
0.3330942094,
0.3806102872,
0.3612693548,
0.0995993987,
0.4112896025,
-0.7023856044,
0.5603137016,
0.3798304498,
-0.8250740767,
0.4945669174,
-0.354060322,
-0.152409941,
0.6499006152,
0.6492797732,
-1.0643717051,
-0.5263920426,
-0.7505124211,
-0.9623535275,
0.765707314,
-0.1653022468,
0.4494704604,
-0.0224390663,
0.4073548913,
-0.0019611605,
0.1370466202,
-0.8249213696,
0.0328326039,
-0.092311047,
-0.2561544478,
-0.0845198259,
-0.0157411899,
-0.438267827,
-0.5887929797,
0.3713448942,
-0.1463390291,
0.2160651088,
-0.0377006121,
0.1234291866,
-0.2793426514,
0.1385376453,
0.0570222996,
0.6944729686,
0.2240605056,
-0.0571223684,
0.2870951295,
-0.2833355665,
0.545519948,
-0.1694607437,
0.4114640355,
-0.2969819307,
0.3510780036,
0.4851724505,
0.3025881052,
-0.69715482,
0.8156754971,
-0.092515938,
-0.4111097753,
-0.6270106435,
0.621154964,
0.4023304582,
0.5412917733,
0.2789285481,
-0.163035512,
-0.2919380963,
-0.7540622354,
-0.0438503996,
0.5240121484,
-0.6855617166,
-0.160311833,
0.770576179,
0.6603717804,
-0.7135435343,
0.4185290635,
-0.198726207,
-0.3406803906,
0.6702162027,
0.5298841,
0.4841190875,
-0.1968093067,
0.4393172562,
-0.1203636453,
0.1201162413,
-0.3863262534,
0.1485043019,
0.0005521298,
-0.804408133,
-0.3592199385,
-0.092408672,
-0.7661932111,
0.0220098067,
-0.6039505601,
0.2137233019,
-0.7066089511,
0.0594096296,
0.1444224119,
-0.1835798025,
-0.9175978899,
0.0102316197,
-0.0975981429,
0.7905020714,
-1.2498185635,
0.713860333,
0.9514920115,
-0.4657784402,
-0.6087623239,
-0.473590523,
0.1176701263,
-0.8794110417,
0.7672321796,
0.1984784007,
0.1348467171,
0.0613607354,
-0.7951386571,
-0.3293509781,
0.9868770242,
0.4193559289,
-0.332218051,
-0.3542332351,
0.1420950592,
0.6108733416,
-0.5454085469,
0.178276673,
0.5598354936,
0.1812294573,
-0.2043419182,
-0.8392649889,
0.0086241495,
-0.5870947242,
0.2726916075,
-0.1927991211,
-1.0396773815,
0.4335246384,
-0.1876089424,
0.0625277013,
0.0065861093,
0.5434655547,
0.089799352,
0.4017153084,
0.4504646063,
0.1296252012,
0.7202816606,
-0.0026783154,
0.6699470282,
-0.1741523296,
0.1138115972,
1.063732028,
-0.6102705598,
0.5270538926,
0.1970368177,
-0.1207732335,
0.5500943661,
0.4326788783,
0.2250847071,
0.2536587417,
0.1990439296,
-0.5571511388,
-0.2836906314,
-0.5269803405,
-0.4300958514,
0.2534992993,
0.4888522327,
-0.284902066,
0.0480529964,
0.1893543303,
0.0483707935,
0.403308779,
-0.2958969176,
0.6694797277,
0.3452111185,
-0.5505512357,
0.0260423403,
-0.2402181625,
0.6271234155,
-0.5223258138,
-0.4082651734,
-0.0989399552,
0.2588649988,
-0.1272867471,
-0.6304081678,
0.2396312356,
-0.1508019716,
0.0177181736,
-0.167496115,
0.7421354055,
-0.5727915764,
-0.2359722853,
0.6263694763,
0.6527004242,
-0.073900871,
-0.0283202995,
-0.5208673477,
-0.1610640287,
-0.4324005246,
0.2276104689,
0.5392067432,
0.9342021942,
0.1673498452,
0.7782120109,
0.5326167345,
0.4336981177,
-0.157195434,
0.1174564213,
0.9769340754,
-0.67073524,
-0.6709290743,
-0.5155935884,
0.4828777313,
-0.626763761,
-0.6382879019,
0.1999569237,
-0.1612683833,
0.7284421921,
0.1859870851,
0.9515966177,
-0.209781751,
0.4512796998,
-0.0957807899,
0.6662541628,
-0.4053714573,
-0.0276301447,
-0.6023019552,
-0.7267796993,
-0.2507771552,
0.8430802226,
-0.6080752611,
0.2608453035,
0.4538320601,
0.6253933907,
0.0594474338,
-0.1453877687,
0.6279404163,
-0.0477494746,
0.5275994539,
0.706035018,
0.9157062173,
0.1184287369,
0.2876489162,
-0.0424237959,
-0.4441247284,
-0.3346589208,
-0.5615650415,
-1.2232666016,
-0.6131886244,
-0.1652576625,
-0.535522759,
0.488759011,
1.2249386311,
0.8743978143,
-0.2549138963,
-0.3378329575,
-0.0080495244,
0.1754418015,
-0.3673108816,
-0.2787876427,
-0.1494650543,
-0.4215072691,
-0.4647652507,
0.1433214843,
0.2335140854,
0.0526614897,
-0.249226585,
-0.291628778,
-0.1250148565,
-0.1540993303,
0.5969794989,
0.6951994896,
-0.1509737372,
-0.406324625,
-0.2255913019,
0.0096983649,
-0.0117440671,
0.9160299301,
-0.3486032486,
0.0598982722,
0.1567243636,
1.0326815844,
0.1395578831,
-0.4123181701,
0.9167867899,
-0.7558348179,
0.4583258331,
0.2171834409,
0.3156133294,
0.4099632204,
-0.5891110301,
0.8540471792,
0.3866372108,
-0.4221211374,
-0.8709011078,
0.2670746446,
-0.1731705219,
-0.2885878086,
1.039581418,
-0.4563647509,
-0.0882860273,
-0.6601493359,
-0.2232197672,
0.3203424215,
-0.3910632432,
1.2050013542,
0.8370155692,
0.010817253,
-0.2738687098,
-0.5180957913,
0.5701690316,
0.4857152402,
-0.6497417092,
0.0006811339,
0.0590681322,
0.105795823,
0.0920956656,
1.0069212914,
-0.0266705286,
0.5413383842,
0.0584227331,
0.1401676387,
0.0205239262,
-0.6005874872,
-0.2120084316,
-0.206627652,
0.4033556283,
0.5418945551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08673v1
|
Sentiment analysis and random forest to classify LLM versus human source applied to Scientific Texts
| 2024-04-05T16:14:36 | 2024-04-05T16:14:36 |
Javier J. Sanchez-Medina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, 68
|
After the launch of ChatGPT v.4 there has been a global vivid discussion on
the ability of this artificial intelligence powered platform and some other
similar ones for the automatic production of all kinds of texts, including
scientific and technical texts. This has triggered a reflection in many
institutions on whether education and academic procedures should be adapted to
the fact that in future many texts we read will not be written by humans
(students, scholars, etc.), at least, not entirely. In this work it is proposed
a new methodology to classify texts coming from an automatic text production
engine or a human, based on Sentiment Analysis as a source for feature
engineering independent variables and then train with them a Random Forest
classification algorithm. Using four different sentiment lexicons, a number of
new features where produced, and then fed to a machine learning random forest
methodology, to train such a model. Results seem very convincing that this may
be a promising research line to detect fraud, in such environments where human
are supposed to be the source of texts.
|
[
-0.2374191582,
-0.531455934,
0.4280920625,
0.1171451956,
-0.18553859,
0.4646349847,
-0.0513001345,
-0.8731637597,
0.2306984812,
0.6384165287,
-0.5756285787,
-0.556609869,
-0.5125879049,
0.4072621465,
-0.6081832647,
1.4174826145,
-0.0353350863,
0.3504749835,
-0.6073866487,
-0.2170845121,
-0.0860134661,
-1.02536273,
-0.5870981216,
-0.2953883708,
0.6769021749,
0.0840187594,
0.3305377364,
0.1890331358,
0.8410128355,
0.3217440248,
-0.0690852851,
0.026108766,
-0.2368357778,
0.0491106622,
0.0368471257,
-0.7332514524,
-0.3084389269,
0.3002711535,
0.3415598571,
0.0110387616,
-0.0625219494,
0.1181703806,
0.2809782326,
0.4734170735,
-0.209379524,
0.2486462593,
-0.464940846,
0.3914679587,
-0.3781514168,
-0.6221925616,
-0.3966332078,
-0.6162781119,
0.3060052395,
-0.4985427558,
0.6525550485,
0.2976991832,
0.7801818848,
0.1701199114,
-0.0954827145,
-0.4732988775,
-0.5312566757,
1.1024591923,
-0.642732501,
-0.1183775216,
0.0052623176,
0.3450289667,
-0.1484467685,
-0.5006195903,
-0.5118187666,
-0.2815684378,
0.0806412473,
0.2950573266,
0.0905987471,
0.1363584697,
-0.0150422258,
0.2448993921,
-0.3398457468,
0.2384602129,
-0.2859992385,
-0.3817929029,
0.8702610731,
-0.1037478074,
0.2604056597,
-0.5354683995,
-0.4249960482,
-0.355656296,
-0.5364310741,
-0.024533974,
0.5736907721,
0.210233137,
0.2823006511,
0.5245395303,
-0.1310192645,
0.3280568123,
-0.5050006509,
-0.0864338204,
0.2954405844,
-0.1365983337,
-0.2634777427,
0.1295225918,
1.0024607182,
0.2035997957,
0.3996146619,
0.1580239832,
-0.4491339922,
0.3590401411,
0.2520089746,
-0.6108202934,
-0.4045783281,
-0.0670956746,
-0.6258710027,
-1.0159783363,
-0.087863408,
-0.8916233182,
-0.7151127458,
-0.1870164424,
0.1863158345,
-0.3408156335,
-0.2557804585,
-0.1686353832,
-0.1469683647,
0.0529617146,
0.6050802469,
-0.6560557485,
0.1553579122,
0.6076601148,
0.9353094697,
-0.2295030355,
-0.2346912026,
-0.0852275565,
-0.5258683562,
0.0331453122,
1.1938503981,
-0.3686800003,
-0.5406677723,
-0.0105113331,
-0.4100399613,
0.1578223705,
-0.3711175919,
0.8740152121,
-0.6178297997,
0.7745884061,
-0.2410315275,
-0.4045793414,
-0.5616646409,
0.3529524207,
-0.4652945101,
0.9373521805,
0.1821168661,
-0.997523725,
0.4249920547,
-0.8657966256,
-0.2000405043,
0.1989071369,
-0.3479239345,
-0.5274140239,
-0.0529364161,
-0.0014062184,
0.4087247252,
-0.4493764043,
0.3983834386,
-0.7470927835,
-0.0049344082,
0.7387329936,
-0.7871730328,
0.9554946423,
0.402002722,
0.0295742638,
-0.012665851,
-0.5409941673,
0.1699808985,
-0.0547799766,
-0.3557545245,
-0.4199547768,
0.3727805316,
0.3184414506,
0.1887177825,
0.1559235454,
-0.725356102,
0.1868572831,
-0.3865290284,
0.4014989138,
0.8326771855,
0.1354277879,
0.3148117363,
-0.3102867305,
0.4725340307,
0.0184329767,
0.016170973,
-0.0012024936,
-0.6516621113,
-0.7181980014,
-0.2875481248,
0.5857958198,
0.8109368682,
-0.4239161313,
0.461232692,
-0.1783581227,
-0.1534546465,
-0.5985209942,
0.0114364428,
0.1297924668,
0.4014750123,
0.1757300049,
-0.4821231663,
-0.7255262136,
-0.6972011924,
-0.4344793856,
-0.4490465522,
-0.1794294715,
0.2172129452,
0.4763626158,
-0.1137265265,
1.3731343746,
-0.5105275512,
-0.457565099,
0.1350207329,
0.666054368,
-0.1201264113,
0.2325444818,
0.6405456066,
-0.7394995093,
-0.2439593971,
0.2375861853,
-1.1830146313,
-0.1994009465,
-0.0018107728,
0.064070262,
0.4497428834,
0.0576519519,
-0.4795931578,
0.2089818418,
0.3759717941,
-0.1408165097,
0.4768351316,
0.0770270526,
0.3158995509,
-1.0537068844,
-0.1011255011,
0.3577973247,
-0.1748498678,
-0.4628686607,
-0.2444885969,
-0.2945481241,
-0.0578475781,
-0.2088649422,
0.3391389847,
-0.2573523521,
-0.0388834812,
-0.5175600052,
0.0570744239,
-0.2245284319,
0.330385685,
0.0944997519,
0.4882622361,
0.3604252934,
-0.1984584779,
0.4595764875,
0.1308988184,
-0.3574921191,
0.6672705412,
-0.1693676561,
0.0788074061,
-0.1999045163,
0.376429528,
-0.730655849,
-0.419575572,
0.4628065526,
-0.8247341514,
0.1177134812,
0.1248128712,
-0.4861073196,
-0.3952445686,
-0.4247570038,
-0.0322475806,
0.6819381118,
-0.4044929147,
0.4879529476,
0.2891955078,
-0.1782429069,
-0.4553973377,
-0.7229427695,
0.1392291635,
-0.5671164393,
-0.690030098,
0.0541796871,
-0.0431258194,
-0.372035116,
0.2426861823,
-0.0306216814,
-0.2327002138,
0.2601614892,
0.1999554485,
0.5500669479,
-0.3281852901,
0.0356395133,
-0.0583356507,
-0.0004750848,
0.3851137459,
-0.2104714215,
-0.0232312623,
-0.1083614603,
-0.2278565764,
-0.4465338886,
0.2802549005,
0.4679713845,
-0.0159720313,
0.5289004445,
0.4247635603,
-0.1418909281,
-0.3742066324,
-0.4433523417,
-0.2959098518,
-0.457788378,
0.3270972669,
-0.0063910419,
-1.0517168045,
0.2444170564,
-0.1268216521,
0.1320364773,
0.5107977986,
0.4091794491,
-0.5907675028,
1.0030896664,
0.8158424497,
-0.3299503326,
0.4858879447,
-0.0949941725,
0.2811210454,
-0.4507444799,
-0.128127113,
-0.8496206403,
-0.2685657144,
-0.7786962986,
-0.3997607827,
0.201610297,
-0.0338017642,
0.1316990554,
-0.0359235369,
-0.8216671944,
0.3748672009,
0.580611527,
-0.0638150871,
0.3602330387,
0.4526235759,
0.1345164925,
-0.0780043527,
-0.6647850871,
-0.7597314119,
0.8968787789,
0.4851552248,
0.4853328764,
-0.3881354332,
0.9616833329,
0.7457281947,
1.2159671783,
-0.9743705988,
0.630717814,
0.0039445064,
-0.5564014316,
-0.266461283,
-0.5021149516,
-0.6582904458,
0.3012426794,
-0.3497909009,
-0.5581585765,
0.2054076195,
-0.0360243767,
-0.1479894966,
0.2748069763,
-0.7429665327,
0.5558795929,
-0.364266783,
0.1658575684,
-0.3000194132,
-0.4667594433,
0.5085654855,
-0.3305833042,
0.2984515429,
-0.1457397044,
0.1948954612,
1.024302721,
-0.1200286821,
1.09220016,
-0.2735280991,
-0.0157705788,
0.6738734245,
-0.1253247708,
0.4541952312,
-0.0307911672,
-0.1755107194,
0.2388172895,
0.0239965506,
-0.1460891813,
-0.487157464,
0.6517171264,
-1.174652338,
-0.4363012314,
-1.0377836227,
-0.2130823731,
-0.1360184997,
0.0142782461,
0.3720130622,
-0.0785898268,
-0.4472960532,
0.2394987643,
0.6697455049,
-0.0715217516,
0.3841833174,
0.4101869762,
-0.1447641551,
-0.5139114857,
1.0643193722,
0.1413746029,
-0.1552619934,
0.432492584,
0.1811996996,
-0.2037884146,
-0.7122496367,
-0.1937474012,
0.1260937303,
-0.7181521058,
-0.5825825334,
-0.6546734571,
-0.5067851543,
-0.1244566962,
-0.1525415629,
-0.083428368,
-0.2899063826,
-0.5331426859,
-0.0293672271,
0.5995702147,
0.6871677041,
0.2385239303,
0.4776650369,
-0.9356740117,
-0.1615830809,
0.161762014,
0.1471303999,
-0.2846176326,
-0.3261080384,
-0.2350603044,
0.1897458583,
-0.6917926073,
-0.8785920143,
0.7690452933,
0.030050464,
0.3938681185,
0.2600597441,
-0.0514652245,
0.1958401203,
-0.0211783573,
0.6026037931,
0.3469138145,
-0.739028275,
0.3562461138,
-0.3376405239,
-0.3401747346,
0.4684917033,
0.3571556807,
-0.6738472581,
-0.4761845171,
-0.7493272424,
-0.4535856843,
0.8855003119,
0.1844791025,
-0.0815253034,
0.3609004617,
0.2043219656,
0.2154078782,
0.3485385776,
-0.8886435628,
0.2805900872,
-0.3336296678,
-0.5436090827,
-0.1095175296,
-0.1370880753,
-0.2081972063,
0.0843623653,
0.637360394,
-0.2520451844,
0.2737449408,
0.2201377898,
-0.0083870152,
-0.1427351981,
0.2518031001,
0.2444360852,
0.1133558825,
-0.2513099909,
-0.0548414923,
0.1621125042,
-0.5793158412,
0.2154027522,
-0.167341873,
-0.5046609044,
-0.1717332751,
0.3553844988,
0.5317208767,
0.0281359404,
-0.4314629138,
0.2856533527,
-0.0073689702,
-0.5341001153,
-0.3530340195,
0.2823563218,
-0.1227383837,
0.2402981073,
0.3605064154,
0.8454535007,
0.3978040218,
-0.3120208681,
0.0072640907,
0.3240153193,
-0.1939923614,
-0.4914680123,
0.2472358346,
0.4391928911,
-0.4157116413,
0.7193995118,
-0.1483503133,
-0.5176335573,
0.6241022348,
0.2203958482,
1.2653713226,
-0.1154946536,
0.4930279553,
0.0592518337,
0.2261687517,
-0.3801232278,
0.1163769513,
0.0552462339,
-0.8616028428,
-0.5284118652,
-0.9090555906,
-0.5197384953,
-0.0976118669,
-0.3084510863,
0.4577689767,
-0.3906795382,
-0.1204416752,
-0.0068160947,
0.1387715489,
-0.3646669686,
0.301332444,
0.251334995,
0.6834023595,
-1.0880672932,
0.996016562,
0.7462237477,
-0.1467726827,
-0.3318620026,
-0.0355917066,
0.1550501734,
-0.4588484764,
0.6350453496,
0.2419499904,
-0.2460053116,
-0.0476440936,
-0.8168489337,
-0.8210703731,
0.9917963147,
0.0439757705,
-0.3935692608,
0.1716927439,
-0.0482856072,
0.9473091364,
-0.3962855041,
0.1141980439,
0.2005649656,
0.4248162806,
0.1255324185,
-0.4108252525,
-0.3671725094,
-0.2276414633,
-0.0164199695,
0.200970307,
-0.6552991867,
0.6264032722,
0.2013784796,
-0.3077736497,
-0.005583737,
1.0912659168,
0.3038815856,
0.555395782,
0.3958839774,
0.3501569927,
1.0431064367,
-0.1858690232,
0.9126393199,
-0.0832950845,
0.5605635643,
0.6175299287,
-0.4052318335,
0.842705667,
0.3475013673,
-0.4680764675,
0.5841923356,
0.9522557855,
-0.3180902898,
0.4784708619,
0.2899549007,
-0.6443232894,
-0.0060490044,
-0.0042615863,
-0.1461255848,
0.5013703704,
0.4412544966,
-0.3204961419,
-0.0085783498,
0.1827121228,
-0.0765115023,
0.0528049059,
-0.1053806692,
0.600243032,
0.2877624929,
-0.6752562523,
0.0658803359,
0.2546975911,
0.9579947591,
-0.4967615008,
0.1963658035,
-0.1662664413,
0.2044527084,
-0.42410326,
-0.8130030632,
0.3718321025,
0.3020694256,
-0.1382327974,
-0.4958079159,
0.9987802505,
0.014075595,
-0.5294448137,
0.0707296357,
0.3611419797,
0.2476902455,
0.0707761645,
-0.8732638955,
-0.3130375445,
0.2434572279,
-0.5407291055,
0.4830576777,
0.6866054535,
-0.3360298276,
0.7854681611,
0.824598372,
0.0443616807,
-0.1401647925,
-0.0205499362,
0.7240428925,
-0.8310508132,
-0.4975835681,
-0.8476669192,
0.1142984852,
-0.3327779174,
-0.2355306596,
0.9731791615,
0.4558988214,
0.5256738067,
-0.1052648798,
1.2038574219,
-0.1936347634,
0.4280205369,
-0.2381998897,
0.6478127837,
-0.2563691735,
0.3533911109,
-0.0717626661,
-1.0001064539,
-0.4056880176,
0.5777764916,
-0.2050490081,
0.1189377084,
0.9138177037,
0.7040230036,
0.0665245205,
0.6515651941,
-0.0114744082,
0.1394768655,
0.3746771812,
0.1428679377,
1.0689399242,
0.0185752437,
0.4419653416,
-0.1255438626,
-0.5266250372,
-0.3902499378,
-0.9915142059,
-0.7175772786,
-0.258300513,
-0.3966739774,
-0.446243763,
-0.2147361487,
0.8363022208,
0.3661551774,
-0.8601135015,
-0.3689514995,
-0.3492584825,
0.1934837103,
-0.1462216973,
-0.2923562825,
0.1589823216,
-0.3951848447,
-0.4708022773,
0.0560989641,
0.4335310757,
0.1713592112,
-0.7277254462,
-0.0768681169,
0.1925755292,
0.2069792151,
0.5689323545,
0.3408336937,
-0.4755458832,
-0.3688772023,
0.1969200671,
-0.2829657793,
0.2197901607,
0.9692497849,
-0.8463359475,
0.1718663126,
0.7261221409,
0.5040630102,
0.3276072145,
-0.0431246012,
0.3743464351,
-0.5610921979,
-0.1101629809,
0.6747183204,
0.041771628,
0.4063285291,
-0.485965699,
0.4349375367,
0.6901476383,
-0.8906421065,
-0.872005403,
-0.0962786004,
-1.1460813284,
-0.211555317,
0.787848115,
-0.0748239085,
-0.6403745413,
-0.0049927821,
-0.4919273257,
0.1512960196,
-0.4433088303,
1.2951594591,
0.9262551069,
-0.2959367931,
0.088974297,
-0.6268986464,
0.6614660025,
0.4127596319,
-1.1249632835,
-0.0265830047,
0.4567790329,
0.1308117807,
0.3616770208,
0.7112235427,
-0.1738691777,
0.1113994718,
-0.0308828186,
0.4896607697,
0.2604289353,
-0.1797592789,
-0.2677914202,
0.3629401028,
0.2060933113,
-0.0487350747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04316v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04316v2
|
Parameter Efficient Quasi-Orthogonal Fine-Tuning via Givens Rotation
| 2024-04-05T15:28:44 | 2024-06-07T03:54:01 |
Xinyu Ma, Xu Chu, Zhibang Yang, Yang Lin, Xin Gao, Junfeng Zhao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the increasingly powerful performances and enormous scales of pretrained
models, promoting parameter efficiency in fine-tuning has become a crucial need
for effective and efficient adaptation to various downstream tasks. One
representative line of fine-tuning methods is Orthogonal Fine-tuning (OFT),
which rigorously preserves the angular distances within the parameter space to
preserve the pretrained knowledge. Despite the empirical effectiveness, OFT
still suffers low parameter efficiency at $\mathcal{O}(d^2)$ and limited
capability of downstream adaptation. Inspired by Givens rotation, in this
paper, we proposed quasi-Givens Orthogonal Fine-Tuning (qGOFT) to address the
problems. We first use $\mathcal{O}(d)$ Givens rotations to accomplish
arbitrary orthogonal transformation in $SO(d)$ with provable equivalence,
reducing parameter complexity from $\mathcal{O}(d^2)$ to $\mathcal{O}(d)$. Then
we introduce flexible norm and relative angular adjustments under soft
orthogonality regularization to enhance the adaptation capability of downstream
semantic deviations. Extensive experiments on various tasks and pretrained
models validate the effectiveness of our methods.
|
[
-0.4171475768,
-0.7434699535,
0.7473034859,
-0.3948717415,
-0.6043316126,
-0.3008815944,
-0.5706907511,
-0.3437372148,
0.012968217,
0.2447502911,
-0.8338832259,
-0.1501611918,
-0.4755342901,
-0.0744145736,
-0.0224009026,
1.1900085211,
-0.0306785312,
0.0960255414,
0.4535065293,
-0.5220409632,
-0.26418975,
0.0949494988,
-0.4156115055,
-0.0408715233,
0.6729068756,
0.472039789,
1.1023653746,
0.7223644257,
0.5074189305,
0.329390794,
0.1303579211,
0.4853551388,
-0.9987767339,
-0.1680478305,
-0.3881520331,
-0.8082489371,
-0.7679486871,
0.0931531489,
0.805901289,
0.9017013907,
-0.2217863202,
0.2319866121,
0.3344621658,
0.9491141438,
-0.6946056485,
0.0143408384,
-0.8653995395,
0.0516356863,
-0.1754522473,
-0.1925915927,
0.3083406687,
-0.7020425797,
-0.0655631721,
-1.4913645983,
0.0996831283,
0.1269972622,
0.910431385,
0.3583578467,
0.0804936215,
-0.0805903226,
-0.8904832006,
1.1955996752,
-0.6955220103,
0.9442455769,
0.7910745144,
0.3765143752,
-0.1189705729,
-0.6049120426,
-0.5922210217,
-0.2175588906,
0.1546104103,
0.2966245711,
-0.1503508389,
0.3742548525,
0.1920596212,
0.4040191472,
-0.3796753883,
-0.0746348575,
-0.3321555555,
-0.0366436429,
0.5936222076,
0.1877976358,
-0.1508537233,
0.3100975156,
-0.3330838084,
-0.5133003592,
-0.6598564982,
0.0245661251,
0.567607224,
0.2756360471,
0.0137014333,
0.3476330042,
-0.5395334959,
0.7907276154,
0.6951087713,
-0.4342164993,
0.0716062486,
-0.3214549124,
-0.0450918339,
-0.552305758,
0.3018667996,
0.5550628901,
0.1553916186,
-0.2568345964,
-0.4527263939,
-0.259396255,
0.4735735357,
-0.4147500396,
-0.1562785506,
-0.0694485232,
-0.8011056185,
0.1181887761,
0.1450823247,
-0.7746710181,
0.0780749843,
-0.971416235,
0.8842160702,
-0.5640707016,
-0.3025000989,
0.4601888061,
-0.1298537999,
0.239702791,
0.372204423,
-0.7046522498,
0.0951452404,
0.6542389989,
0.5245876908,
0.0848633572,
-0.2715133429,
-0.5446729064,
0.0044886139,
-0.5863872766,
0.6045694351,
-0.2623432875,
-0.3142855763,
-0.1078676358,
-0.5607948899,
-0.1920453161,
-0.6734439731,
0.4287495017,
-0.6997762918,
-0.2024136186,
-0.3249787092,
-0.1557808369,
-0.2496381253,
0.3013759255,
-0.1135000065,
0.9378299713,
0.6549494863,
-0.3145020604,
0.446993202,
-0.4573281705,
-0.1604260504,
-0.0869912356,
-0.1859923601,
-0.5760360956,
0.5643988252,
-0.0823276341,
0.1536921114,
-0.507537365,
0.2078966349,
-0.6562315822,
-0.1934259236,
-0.195215717,
-0.12817882,
0.6175385714,
0.5523864031,
-0.2400509566,
0.278342247,
-1.037468791,
0.5177028775,
-0.2210744768,
-0.0670826808,
-0.5520648956,
-0.1221775413,
-0.1654829532,
-0.101175867,
0.1220442951,
-0.3140850961,
0.4083084166,
-0.3470919728,
0.2261967808,
0.7137057781,
-0.332519114,
0.6959223747,
-0.5290237665,
0.556139648,
-0.2741588652,
0.4290499091,
0.6257494688,
-0.0988075063,
-0.6498553753,
-0.5881052017,
0.276658535,
0.3920444846,
-1.1095914841,
0.4799402356,
-0.207300052,
-0.6766291857,
-0.3758893609,
0.1793515086,
0.4682113826,
0.6359418035,
0.4903220832,
-0.0247188862,
-0.3418380022,
-0.8082643151,
-0.4592217207,
-0.2581880391,
-0.5103558898,
0.1324094385,
-0.1856646538,
-0.2135142684,
0.8185033798,
-0.7958725691,
-0.5581304431,
0.0568216704,
0.3741602898,
0.1874738485,
0.48310408,
0.8894520402,
-0.4860852063,
-0.4925691485,
0.106582813,
-0.4619002044,
-0.3170761168,
-0.0480579287,
-0.4619738758,
-0.343867451,
0.7597075701,
-0.34310022,
0.4270549417,
0.3300943673,
-0.3042126,
0.49595806,
-0.5652532578,
0.18441239,
-0.5378783345,
-0.3108042181,
-0.2932174206,
-0.4099994302,
-0.5117743611,
0.1300664991,
0.2732391357,
0.1414588988,
-0.1446688026,
0.1618617773,
-0.4646928608,
0.4165918231,
-0.3707127571,
-0.249518469,
-0.3117294908,
0.5112209916,
-0.1573509723,
0.6216732264,
0.636738658,
-0.794434309,
-0.1607767195,
0.1131390482,
-0.0283938255,
1.0318375826,
-0.5326489806,
0.1944333315,
-0.1957957,
-0.0118812798,
-0.6464275718,
0.2277376503,
0.3391737342,
-0.0678092688,
0.2953285277,
-0.1458634883,
-0.2541419268,
0.2650786042,
-0.7141433358,
0.5828757882,
0.7099026442,
-0.4603910744,
0.949236989,
0.1154521629,
0.0227121413,
0.0601943731,
-0.1757183224,
-0.5743747354,
-0.3378547132,
-0.6594591737,
0.5207459927,
0.0333485194,
-0.1298803985,
-0.0917471275,
-0.2674412131,
-0.0124583645,
-0.0656786114,
-0.0845717266,
0.1491028368,
-0.6255878806,
-0.0811128318,
0.4273519218,
-0.2496512532,
-0.2665935755,
-0.7005690336,
0.2668672204,
-0.285592705,
-0.1645477563,
-0.2587085962,
0.3279254735,
0.4295760393,
-0.1222853437,
0.568588376,
0.8186494112,
-0.290966779,
-0.2987034619,
-0.602324605,
-0.2549038827,
-0.5779577494,
0.5814948678,
-0.323366195,
-0.7632936835,
0.6052923203,
-0.2126060128,
-0.0529295206,
0.4548943043,
0.293610841,
-0.2917446494,
1.0018357038,
0.7314624786,
0.0666568056,
0.7624980807,
-0.4314002395,
0.432677269,
-0.6972741485,
0.3347117901,
-0.6453039646,
-0.5184320211,
-0.8290082812,
-0.4018691182,
0.8943021297,
0.5233707428,
-0.100773789,
0.2545608878,
-0.0595677681,
0.2846544087,
0.6107845902,
0.2509087324,
0.093970269,
-0.1758099794,
0.136621505,
0.0734434053,
-0.8011428118,
-0.1901332885,
0.9420453906,
0.1663950533,
0.8934727311,
-0.0288171284,
0.556291163,
-0.0550823286,
0.0170015786,
-0.5099160075,
0.4307334423,
-0.3610724509,
-0.2138686478,
-0.4905362129,
-0.4963763952,
-0.8596339822,
0.1609090418,
-0.2950997651,
-0.575884521,
0.5025203228,
0.6685429215,
-0.6493581533,
0.1914450079,
-0.666249752,
0.250916481,
-0.1731111556,
-0.4463482797,
-0.6002559662,
-0.5640263557,
-0.2223054171,
-0.0590907596,
0.2298583984,
-0.2032958418,
-0.0306369737,
0.6211737394,
-0.6736329198,
0.5149647593,
-0.650255084,
0.0979554132,
0.2438478023,
0.0338638015,
0.4581571817,
0.4731172919,
-0.0977668464,
0.4932799041,
0.166177392,
-0.2938073277,
-0.6521139145,
0.440258503,
-0.8150444627,
-0.5309070349,
-0.0972393826,
-0.8591589332,
-0.6972792745,
0.4946091175,
0.3768517077,
0.3136749268,
0.2772475183,
0.1582970768,
0.6123806238,
0.115839228,
0.0771044642,
0.3985823393,
-0.0780308023,
-0.261667639,
0.9501599669,
0.1930918545,
0.3581400514,
0.2149416208,
0.6227490902,
-0.3853144646,
-0.9404746294,
-0.3641900718,
0.1924080849,
-0.2687810957,
-0.6911082268,
0.0301662907,
0.0783727095,
-0.1861705184,
-0.3881845772,
-0.8138281703,
-0.5399638414,
-0.3250750303,
0.2226754129,
0.5054068565,
0.4001555145,
-0.4556097686,
0.4946776032,
-0.8491764665,
1.0282926559,
0.4705703557,
0.8239556551,
-0.1142826825,
-0.7610975504,
-0.1226527765,
0.3883525431,
-0.5302474499,
-0.387254566,
-0.0546578243,
0.7340111136,
0.611820519,
0.6013584733,
0.2038603276,
1.0663095713,
-0.5532054901,
0.3666799664,
0.1857569516,
-0.7200809121,
0.2128216475,
-0.6868178248,
0.1275202483,
0.8499278426,
0.2319118232,
0.0017347079,
-0.4452919066,
-0.3400405347,
-0.7822268009,
0.7413903475,
0.3346930146,
0.1147758737,
0.277631253,
0.6252856851,
0.4835114479,
-0.1078245044,
-0.2281779945,
-0.2549165189,
-0.3730271459,
-0.3364571333,
0.183148697,
-0.0602555275,
-0.0157526135,
-0.5549128652,
0.7230297923,
-0.2967744172,
0.3103198707,
0.2957120538,
-0.2147347629,
-0.230923444,
0.0265793428,
0.537203908,
0.889416337,
-0.2064562291,
-0.0232691579,
0.2115942985,
-0.6239040494,
0.0255256146,
0.1510194838,
-0.1820733696,
-0.3366553783,
0.094687447,
0.6385970712,
0.080671221,
-0.2636443973,
0.0769116804,
-0.0098500093,
-0.4645100534,
0.0540336259,
0.446857065,
-0.2178642154,
0.5235565305,
0.5245380402,
0.1016730666,
0.2417212874,
-0.2659250498,
-0.0903473794,
0.6045910716,
-0.2330127656,
-0.5185436606,
0.5407494307,
-0.113185823,
-0.2725463808,
0.4477233887,
-0.3836787641,
-0.4096624553,
0.0700950548,
0.3053826988,
0.7812678218,
-0.0183754954,
-0.2970679104,
0.4750210047,
0.052931942,
-0.2077751756,
0.4874984622,
-0.2087785006,
-0.7102371454,
-0.1112631038,
-0.6476089954,
0.0784097686,
0.1543020308,
-0.8728082776,
0.2726783454,
-0.6593745351,
-0.1424895376,
0.0139695704,
-0.4691909552,
-0.6774066091,
0.1802265048,
-0.0572278835,
0.5983396173,
-0.614561677,
0.8775463104,
0.7091938853,
-0.0646600574,
-0.8447135091,
0.2629289627,
-0.079350397,
-0.8431580067,
0.2515381277,
-0.4824830592,
-0.6772416234,
-0.0475681089,
-0.3109698892,
-0.9322847128,
0.8260994554,
0.5164279938,
-0.8018625975,
0.1825955957,
0.4600518346,
0.6364174485,
0.2486575246,
-0.0431669727,
0.5013418198,
0.5481779575,
-0.4674256146,
-1.1819317341,
-0.3275270164,
0.0883497447,
0.5122356415,
0.5612234473,
-0.6940028071,
0.6635081768,
0.034533307,
0.250459969,
0.0442689098,
0.9459821582,
0.0959131494,
0.1763526797,
1.1455204487,
0.4283024669,
0.4788059592,
0.0649319217,
0.6822126508,
-0.0438273139,
0.5881650448,
0.7728293538,
-0.0562394485,
0.5936385989,
0.8148519397,
-0.5428342819,
-0.0092875045,
0.0002269516,
0.415509671,
0.9195746779,
0.1434145421,
0.2194050401,
-0.1997418404,
0.2712011039,
-0.497739464,
0.7369984388,
0.2412100881,
0.1492216885,
-0.4434523284,
0.1979231834,
-0.1977183819,
0.3324360251,
-0.6732122898,
0.6866799593,
-0.0222242754,
-0.7815057635,
1.0363922119,
0.1674334854,
0.8312178254,
-0.9667605162,
-0.0650105849,
-0.2256893516,
0.5763396025,
-0.1150512099,
-0.3756149411,
0.6489571333,
-0.2935576439,
-0.4140339196,
-0.5071991682,
0.759406209,
-0.3565337062,
-0.5981783271,
0.2775532305,
0.2677731216,
-0.516800642,
-0.2405437231,
-0.5261489749,
-0.0701395348,
0.1370113343,
-0.1806659549,
0.5654156208,
0.447409898,
-0.2101917863,
0.0572525337,
0.5292674303,
0.0731596425,
0.2098444551,
-0.2590655386,
0.8417881727,
-0.4261528552,
-0.7871021628,
-0.3821563721,
0.219155103,
0.4277784824,
-0.8015508056,
0.4187207818,
0.2305922806,
1.1812064648,
-0.2642048895,
0.2711729109,
-0.2701456547,
0.7214177251,
-0.9596253037,
0.8105248213,
-0.829962492,
0.0784406066,
-0.1294860393,
-0.8780533075,
-0.0917537138,
1.0046623945,
-0.2871571481,
0.3379801214,
0.5169810057,
0.90712744,
-0.6453669071,
0.0692161098,
0.4298784733,
0.1468196958,
0.0002824173,
0.2808854878,
0.8184095025,
-0.3022224605,
0.3201373518,
-0.5898541212,
-0.5241214037,
-0.2014099211,
-0.9172645211,
-0.4181419611,
-0.7025175095,
-0.3796745837,
-0.0218896754,
0.2552191019,
0.8058832288,
0.9547404647,
-0.7943767905,
-0.0458813831,
-0.090692021,
-0.4115972221,
-0.6790852547,
-0.1392698288,
0.4142677188,
-0.4102104008,
-0.4041455388,
0.1811223179,
0.199195534,
-0.4215323329,
0.3455952108,
-0.1058365777,
0.035267435,
-0.0626760051,
0.5274893045,
0.3022425473,
-0.5980693698,
-0.6947793961,
0.070965372,
0.2128836215,
0.2186160833,
0.8885774016,
-0.4605336785,
0.3264414966,
0.4180696905,
0.569580555,
0.371175319,
-0.1520504653,
0.5943982601,
-0.5224561095,
0.4077425599,
0.5503838062,
0.1562559009,
-0.1711723655,
-0.3492094576,
0.3241557777,
-0.0970602632,
-0.4507774413,
-0.5467919111,
0.1867281944,
-1.0869817734,
-0.1403553933,
1.1269029379,
-0.1495999247,
0.0680359155,
-0.2207121104,
-0.4571955204,
0.4592675567,
-0.0543723442,
1.0101088285,
0.1660126299,
-0.3201184869,
0.3829442561,
-0.265827477,
0.6015755534,
0.9302508831,
-0.6787109375,
-0.0635246709,
0.302715838,
0.3610137403,
-0.0038873048,
0.419043839,
-0.2593008876,
0.5476040244,
-0.2763414085,
-0.3957277238,
-0.078620024,
-0.2144294679,
-0.1507454664,
-0.3130884171,
0.4676923752,
-0.4633157551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04169v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04169v1
|
Do Sentence Transformers Learn Quasi-Geospatial Concepts from General Text?
| 2024-04-05T15:22:02 | 2024-04-05T15:22:02 |
Ilya Ilyankou, Aldo Lipani, Stefano Cavazzi, Xiaowei Gao, James Haworth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Sentence transformers are language models designed to perform semantic
search. This study investigates the capacity of sentence transformers,
fine-tuned on general question-answering datasets for asymmetric semantic
search, to associate descriptions of human-generated routes across Great
Britain with queries often used to describe hiking experiences. We find that
sentence transformers have some zero-shot capabilities to understand
quasi-geospatial concepts, such as route types and difficulty, suggesting their
potential utility for routing recommendation systems.
|
[
-0.3528718352,
-0.6928895712,
1.0424095392,
-0.1145940647,
-0.1826613545,
-0.5501906276,
-0.1227249652,
-0.4533550739,
0.322779268,
0.5646907091,
-1.1040670872,
-0.4244354963,
-0.180636391,
-0.0091733364,
-1.0177689791,
0.9520494938,
-0.1113530993,
-0.221082449,
-0.2666566372,
-0.0497484915,
-0.5198656917,
-0.5680429339,
-0.171494469,
-0.2629935145,
0.5377002358,
0.4193503261,
1.0328922272,
0.1662922502,
0.4231842458,
0.2792350352,
0.1764829606,
-0.1246641278,
-0.1349699646,
0.3267830908,
-0.5180892944,
-0.5774303675,
0.404014498,
0.0795529708,
0.5429727435,
0.8541020155,
-0.1860323101,
0.2044070512,
-0.3927001953,
0.2017458826,
-0.3205436766,
-0.2140299827,
-0.7186559439,
0.1411601007,
-0.1569796056,
-0.4308530688,
-0.1804827601,
-0.1911375523,
0.7452155948,
-0.7256608009,
0.9479558468,
0.732373178,
0.9886387587,
0.0271411259,
-0.4368239343,
-0.804508388,
-0.8103023171,
0.5740993619,
0.0006907182,
0.2037796527,
0.5581671596,
0.593157053,
-0.0823435709,
-0.7205364704,
-0.5198240876,
-0.0310672633,
-0.624316752,
-0.0180196892,
-0.2123209536,
-0.0719577521,
0.1753076464,
0.3202506006,
-0.8205816746,
0.0649895892,
-0.5605174899,
-0.0801788047,
0.5478010774,
0.5277653337,
0.7918838263,
-0.7452950478,
-0.228887707,
-0.0803104639,
-0.6677083373,
0.3901906908,
0.4068878591,
0.3724139631,
-0.2149187624,
0.90300107,
-0.3286622167,
0.9385243058,
-0.2999864817,
0.471290648,
-0.0201223549,
-0.2642029226,
-0.0035440638,
0.1029829755,
0.7907518148,
0.2835874259,
0.439964205,
-0.8253278136,
-0.0387811363,
0.0332177505,
0.6142676473,
-0.499987781,
-0.4409718812,
-0.0418721288,
-0.2374944389,
0.0791734979,
0.5110538602,
-0.6311839819,
0.0550715029,
0.0109085552,
0.4582092166,
-0.4279216528,
0.148611635,
0.4876944125,
-0.761038959,
0.4888825715,
-0.0241821054,
-1.0095611811,
0.2239713222,
0.3533912599,
0.9412335157,
0.3138744831,
-0.6830773354,
-0.329780668,
0.1116125286,
-0.0650568455,
1.2360807657,
-0.7804277539,
-0.8514776826,
0.1929815263,
0.459333241,
-0.1926361918,
-0.2194375098,
0.7752096057,
-0.6732336879,
0.812094152,
-0.2566352189,
-0.1103975251,
-0.1299070418,
0.1176171377,
-0.3758060932,
1.009052515,
0.1918264329,
-0.7201986313,
0.3948325217,
-0.5669853091,
-0.7209062576,
0.0280693695,
-0.1126387417,
-0.0373622812,
0.2457288802,
0.5174106956,
0.2500239015,
-0.5180906057,
0.2003448159,
0.2124173045,
-0.6705191731,
0.1156100258,
-0.1611636281,
0.7211478949,
-0.0836162493,
-0.486025095,
-0.0363119952,
-0.4487831295,
0.1307876557,
0.1834999621,
-0.1132370159,
-0.6564228535,
0.205541715,
0.1017003804,
0.0586032458,
-0.1835841238,
-0.6678863168,
0.4752855003,
-0.7306177616,
0.4909167588,
0.6170533895,
0.0606527925,
0.8605101705,
-0.0630883574,
0.5269811749,
-0.2466182113,
0.1238014325,
-0.2509595752,
-0.7049177885,
-0.9659575224,
0.3987881243,
-0.0720247105,
0.4748243093,
-0.8580480814,
0.5505557656,
-0.4897144437,
-0.6327834725,
-0.4497361779,
-0.1793040186,
0.058263205,
0.5692538619,
0.799684763,
0.2205975205,
-0.4703731835,
-0.7417440414,
-0.2833407223,
-0.1665971875,
-0.5216400027,
0.3578309119,
0.3500957191,
-0.2837015092,
1.130155921,
-0.9262039661,
-0.2826932967,
-0.1387990564,
0.2139350474,
0.0865263939,
-0.1059703827,
0.6593288779,
-0.9908701777,
-0.2368865162,
-0.3897646964,
-0.6297873855,
-0.1510517001,
-0.0852240995,
-0.2145814598,
-0.2583777308,
0.4481362402,
-0.9987396002,
0.2584760189,
0.2647087574,
-1.0799933672,
0.1423809528,
-0.2474551648,
-0.0311540402,
-0.9345853329,
-0.1426842064,
0.1844535619,
-0.1320479363,
-0.3944003582,
0.1361098289,
-0.1621058434,
-0.2986697555,
-0.3257587552,
0.3046605289,
-0.2630269527,
-0.2070151865,
0.0315430872,
0.3709779084,
0.0262768809,
0.0528175943,
-0.002793153,
0.8701177835,
0.8273395896,
-0.5736719966,
0.4094973803,
0.6386255026,
-0.148402378,
0.5711891055,
-0.6104326844,
0.0722006261,
-0.3305175304,
0.2396729439,
-1.1131614447,
-0.2922089696,
-0.1295433193,
-0.2945685089,
-0.4445691407,
-0.0758059174,
-0.6527475119,
-0.7360609174,
0.0246914607,
0.0133850034,
0.5743529201,
-0.5246251822,
0.5385318398,
0.0495566651,
0.1069462076,
-0.0717684105,
-0.7394356132,
-0.0129451668,
-0.2864848077,
-0.4270470142,
0.2117088586,
0.1531608254,
0.1223935261,
0.2057120353,
-0.0572793484,
0.0835046172,
-0.0236081574,
0.5635017157,
0.2813818753,
-0.06490767,
0.3793719709,
-0.3251575232,
-0.1091423482,
0.2074075043,
-0.6587666869,
0.8499462605,
-0.0265857186,
-0.2951763868,
-0.0905023366,
0.4347499311,
0.1845201254,
0.0169271976,
0.6412909627,
0.5487353802,
0.0950899273,
-0.1282884926,
-0.1409807354,
-0.1275261641,
-0.5619108081,
-0.0949183851,
-0.4091086686,
-1.3287662268,
0.1886171699,
0.1209278777,
-0.4048296511,
0.883452177,
0.0618165843,
-0.5181474686,
0.4975081384,
0.8185061216,
-0.1985838562,
0.0147239026,
-0.3467439413,
0.5743099451,
-0.3306174576,
-0.3388151824,
-0.7947100997,
-0.3663602769,
-1.0121513605,
-0.2203037739,
0.3654867411,
0.0159258675,
-0.4751059115,
0.5701118708,
-0.4814049602,
0.6155917645,
0.7199940681,
-0.0796317756,
-0.1577313393,
0.1026480123,
-0.1217365861,
0.0694048405,
-0.6558626294,
-0.2847114503,
0.8410425782,
-0.3131922781,
0.7801349759,
0.1665544361,
0.2651213706,
0.318875432,
-0.2610464692,
-0.761192441,
0.5391075611,
-0.3081615567,
-0.515899241,
-0.4119637609,
-0.2972185314,
-0.9350522757,
-0.2507891953,
-0.3850675821,
-0.8438144326,
-0.1454535872,
-0.0992480144,
-0.4123260081,
0.3491834104,
-0.7977201939,
0.6888222694,
-0.4257083237,
0.3425892591,
0.0938338414,
-0.8768768907,
-0.3087687492,
0.2305966467,
-0.2007677108,
0.1041555256,
0.2818157077,
0.5332006216,
0.0008288439,
0.4757984281,
-0.2229064405,
0.3493287563,
0.3561398089,
0.0765704811,
0.2540821135,
-0.169266209,
0.0814457089,
0.1123936772,
-0.158629477,
-0.1353489608,
-0.8158231974,
0.6486837268,
-0.8525804281,
-0.7097024918,
-0.1515059173,
-0.3917945325,
-0.2149704397,
0.1640244871,
0.4926297367,
0.4088244736,
-0.1193069816,
0.1306013465,
0.2856692076,
-0.3824552298,
0.4405138493,
0.461055845,
-0.1506683677,
0.034590967,
0.5184033513,
-0.0310701244,
0.1326836944,
0.7189812064,
0.2361237556,
-0.5461500287,
-0.1529259533,
-0.368923068,
0.0346542932,
-0.5769328475,
-0.1524021029,
-0.9249405265,
-0.212935701,
-0.2127542496,
-0.6038876176,
0.2808881402,
-0.481902808,
-0.3093518317,
-0.4312704206,
0.665299952,
0.8848403692,
0.3584259152,
0.7962372303,
-0.4680993855,
0.6372279525,
0.2941619456,
0.265694052,
-0.4261468649,
-0.3321174383,
-0.2152289152,
-0.0524051115,
-0.3563289046,
-0.6104610562,
0.2262023389,
0.2604140043,
0.4688839912,
0.2262760848,
-0.0791915283,
0.8743308187,
-1.015191555,
1.2814730406,
0.3488522768,
-0.6791625619,
0.8708391786,
-0.4683774412,
0.3528347313,
0.3649196327,
0.8319416642,
-0.6989251375,
-0.2646802366,
-0.6300766468,
-0.8761830926,
0.6515085697,
0.1145283282,
0.4861472547,
-0.1662612408,
0.5621161461,
-0.0771891698,
0.0666859299,
-0.5778258443,
-0.2204536796,
-0.5532186031,
-0.0683517978,
-0.6541656852,
-0.2477428466,
0.0648134053,
-0.2040603012,
0.1972168237,
-0.0393537246,
0.3438849151,
0.3499638438,
-0.0973254889,
-0.1454865038,
0.7022276521,
0.2170473188,
0.4088312685,
-0.3591404855,
0.4359326363,
0.0621140487,
-0.2739260197,
0.4926127791,
0.1553467512,
-0.4755249023,
0.1093827486,
0.1692297459,
0.6089448333,
0.1451771408,
-0.5237579942,
0.4572868347,
0.0000090442,
-0.1549541801,
-0.1876927465,
0.3349432051,
0.1438141912,
0.2488883138,
0.490236938,
0.1300322413,
0.4429528117,
-0.7999348044,
0.3675993681,
0.4576827586,
-0.5688325167,
-0.5543618798,
0.7241331935,
0.0622413866,
-0.5762496591,
0.9114650488,
0.07902015,
-0.5622304082,
0.1800029427,
0.5526290536,
1.0013576746,
-0.0107915197,
0.5274834037,
0.1910708845,
0.5198411345,
-0.1469280571,
0.005341582,
-0.162356019,
-0.5932255387,
-0.0704948306,
-0.917437017,
-0.1107330248,
-0.2739498019,
-0.5899321437,
0.4769455194,
-0.0831452385,
-0.0563986935,
-0.0515800752,
-0.4305061102,
-1.0525624752,
0.3874447346,
-0.0507246144,
0.8307353258,
-0.9929321408,
0.5001887083,
0.8868558407,
-0.5881417394,
-0.8045488596,
0.4956515133,
-0.4402734041,
-0.5472612381,
0.7595263124,
0.2879998386,
-0.5437838435,
-0.1769366115,
-0.4221476316,
-0.6291515827,
1.0879478455,
0.1464948356,
-0.1459246129,
-0.7219521999,
0.6749079227,
0.8122388721,
-0.4113924205,
0.3453654349,
0.2682107091,
0.0741532072,
0.043651741,
-0.9218210578,
-0.1348801553,
0.0187826175,
0.1266672015,
0.228087917,
-0.3569402993,
0.7854496241,
0.133327499,
-0.3456270397,
0.2478603721,
0.2270135731,
-0.287224263,
0.1765032709,
0.4217989147,
0.6925787926,
0.3911646605,
-0.2423825562,
1.3321726322,
0.0547478497,
0.4919514656,
0.9627177119,
-0.26060462,
0.943695724,
0.4413759708,
0.0687014014,
1.0860610008,
0.4645472467,
0.1485311985,
0.9392024279,
0.0962106884,
-0.0075918986,
-0.3357518613,
0.0888209939,
-0.0156091908,
0.7392145395,
0.1645162851,
-0.2954241335,
-0.6386315227,
0.0935159251,
-0.2066829056,
0.1039757207,
-0.4086110592,
0.6238400936,
-0.1899895519,
-0.6572747231,
0.2885967791,
0.0162972454,
0.5544548035,
-0.8134485483,
0.1163777336,
0.000627091,
-0.1468031257,
-0.1316924989,
-1.2013266087,
0.5865713358,
0.0212004893,
-0.3213885725,
-0.4020922184,
0.6990611553,
-0.1508518308,
-0.5042001009,
0.2603002787,
0.4775670767,
-0.0701793879,
-0.0915532038,
-0.3677796423,
-0.6318526864,
-0.099076584,
-0.0700030774,
-0.0184830371,
0.5676878691,
0.0248267073,
0.706976831,
0.4410310686,
0.096206896,
0.111707136,
-0.0918499604,
0.9497165084,
-1.1692599058,
-0.7924459577,
-0.7220758796,
0.4485296905,
0.0707646683,
-0.1914857328,
0.9599762559,
0.5872446895,
1.0673775673,
-0.1833093017,
0.757368803,
-0.0687597543,
0.4979341626,
-0.803393364,
0.3650069237,
-0.432361424,
0.1065824926,
0.039031256,
-0.9411892891,
-0.1655654907,
0.5935556293,
-0.7722827792,
-0.2314932942,
0.8410746455,
0.7368345857,
-0.5988077521,
0.1382177025,
0.0569627918,
-0.3838275373,
0.3010546267,
0.3890821934,
0.9770242572,
-0.5730260015,
0.5620976686,
0.1388758719,
0.3662114739,
0.1830780655,
-0.3393551409,
-0.9826372862,
-0.8383302093,
0.3247536719,
-0.1450992823,
0.1698625833,
0.454111129,
0.6410902739,
-0.5402804613,
-0.1733410805,
-0.5007386208,
-0.1977123469,
0.423312515,
-0.3140181303,
0.3491168022,
-0.4072811007,
-0.1772735119,
0.3988220096,
0.4807501733,
-0.0213872362,
-0.4098190069,
0.1920155585,
-0.2576520443,
0.0137862246,
0.4969103038,
-0.0351518095,
-0.6914966106,
-0.7049275637,
0.4013788998,
0.1076697782,
-0.0356435515,
1.2800844908,
-0.9157660604,
0.4665454924,
0.1865482628,
0.4227992892,
0.3848547935,
0.133557409,
0.3710071146,
-1.0080682039,
0.5589270592,
0.0051703714,
0.3111956716,
0.4909003675,
-0.4176662266,
0.4733368754,
0.2786633074,
-0.4881668985,
-0.2142303586,
0.3593460321,
-0.7023819089,
-0.100846976,
1.4049113989,
0.0687499866,
-0.2136780471,
0.0206226185,
-0.1551321596,
-0.1087424234,
0.0686962679,
0.6563830376,
0.5353015065,
-0.0944020003,
-0.1878160238,
-0.6720787287,
0.3332895935,
0.0071880757,
-0.5921348333,
-0.3635204732,
0.5379516482,
0.3987388313,
0.4133199155,
0.4900038242,
0.3616537154,
-0.0672863722,
-0.3389836252,
-0.2578447163,
0.4073952138,
-0.4583791196,
0.1183613539,
0.195121184,
-0.0189943071,
-0.1273574978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04167v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04167v3
|
Chinese Tiny LLM: Pretraining a Chinese-Centric Large Language Model
| 2024-04-05T15:20:02 | 2024-04-09T10:48:19 |
Xinrun Du, Zhouliang Yu, Songyang Gao, Ding Pan, Yuyang Cheng, Ziyang Ma, Ruibin Yuan, Xingwei Qu, Jiaheng Liu, Tianyu Zheng, Xinchen Luo, Guorui Zhou, Binhang Yuan, Wenhu Chen, Jie Fu, Ge Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we introduce CT-LLM, a 2B large language model (LLM) that
illustrates a pivotal shift towards prioritizing the Chinese language in
developing LLMs. Uniquely initiated from scratch, CT-LLM diverges from the
conventional methodology by primarily incorporating Chinese textual data,
utilizing an extensive corpus of 1,200 billion tokens, including 800 billion
Chinese tokens, 300 billion English tokens, and 100 billion code tokens. This
strategic composition facilitates the model's exceptional proficiency in
understanding and processing Chinese, a capability further enhanced through
alignment techniques. Demonstrating remarkable performance on the CHC-Bench,
CT-LLM excels in Chinese language tasks, and showcases its adeptness in English
through SFT. This research challenges the prevailing paradigm of training LLMs
predominantly on English corpora and then adapting them to other languages,
broadening the horizons for LLM training methodologies. By open-sourcing the
full process of training a Chinese LLM, including a detailed data processing
procedure with the obtained Massive Appropriate Pretraining Chinese Corpus
(MAP-CC), a well-chosen multidisciplinary Chinese Hard Case Benchmark
(CHC-Bench), and the 2B-size Chinese Tiny LLM (CT-LLM), we aim to foster
further exploration and innovation in both academia and industry, paving the
way for more inclusive and versatile language models.
|
[
0.0005683491,
-0.5973601937,
0.4439368248,
0.2062557638,
-0.3375962377,
0.1457501352,
-0.7950415015,
-0.3232151866,
0.0131575344,
0.2858242989,
-0.2890758812,
-0.3994799256,
-0.4541699886,
-0.0824644715,
-0.1015587077,
0.7744461298,
0.2117010653,
0.5132044554,
0.2573070228,
-0.1738579273,
-0.4165304601,
-0.5527572036,
-1.0029610395,
-0.2027305067,
0.7096155286,
0.5525811315,
0.6476312876,
1.030549407,
0.4771157801,
0.1824398339,
0.0100506153,
0.0296987109,
-0.5319330692,
-0.6271470785,
0.1079724878,
-0.7066887021,
-0.6297134161,
0.1202447042,
0.7552993894,
0.8377851844,
0.0002379584,
0.1594358981,
0.2306945324,
0.4862286747,
-0.4200668633,
0.0569469854,
-0.887380898,
0.0206079222,
-0.5807161927,
-0.0235350467,
-0.5995309353,
-0.2349554896,
0.0626410395,
-0.509078145,
0.0884172916,
0.0483344756,
0.5242455602,
0.1488979459,
-0.4029762745,
-0.0708305538,
-0.4950728416,
0.7576605082,
-0.6442098022,
0.3331644535,
0.0880077705,
0.2534111738,
0.1261493266,
-0.9129369259,
-0.3281449378,
-0.4058806896,
0.0548778288,
0.0895192027,
0.3217301965,
0.1274636686,
0.022379756,
0.3239522278,
-0.7022972107,
0.7003800869,
-0.2874132693,
-0.2395640016,
0.6396647692,
0.1909872144,
0.3613470793,
0.1935912222,
-0.3747189939,
0.094293125,
-1.1821285486,
0.0452391207,
0.1217875779,
0.7067130208,
-0.2434242964,
0.3705390096,
0.2045446634,
0.6660936475,
0.0078238063,
-0.0578844063,
-0.0346575342,
-0.5326529741,
-0.2458907664,
0.2439534962,
0.8489434719,
-0.0528911799,
0.1418064386,
0.0389049426,
-0.3559096754,
-0.2893847823,
0.0055767181,
-0.7984439135,
-0.2783846259,
0.1803462356,
-0.5610166192,
-0.103074871,
0.0233129561,
-0.1966056973,
-0.4132974446,
-0.3720603585,
0.1994309574,
-0.3205621541,
-0.3684439361,
-0.1424482316,
0.2861448228,
0.5476613641,
0.2928195596,
-1.1195720434,
-0.0746921152,
0.825061202,
0.9630122781,
-0.4595696926,
-0.3254817724,
-0.4053795636,
0.1772416234,
-0.675211966,
0.641558826,
-0.2503947616,
-0.3907264769,
0.177881822,
0.0934332535,
-0.0544632077,
-0.564729929,
0.3300322592,
-0.3399148583,
0.0719042271,
-0.1580239683,
-0.2014876008,
0.1750031561,
0.5147348046,
-0.7557029128,
0.9605864882,
-0.0414024368,
-0.6398117542,
0.2260025889,
-0.5194751024,
-0.5134451985,
0.2601212859,
-0.3648881018,
-0.1092204228,
0.0806839615,
-0.0783078372,
0.3826758862,
-0.5521197915,
0.0815741047,
-0.30346784,
-0.5744412541,
-0.0610128008,
-0.3575739563,
0.9147876501,
0.3389812708,
-0.0264760926,
0.35865134,
-0.5613164306,
0.062947996,
0.3175687492,
-0.4547632039,
-0.333114773,
-0.2334318757,
0.2337646782,
0.4022048712,
0.856177032,
-0.2693500817,
0.2720752954,
-0.7330500484,
0.6386270523,
0.7172548175,
-0.5167376995,
0.6338325143,
-0.1767368317,
0.3338077366,
0.0896398798,
0.1675986946,
-0.1056005433,
-0.0599783584,
-0.8944195509,
-0.2050005645,
0.5692012906,
0.5145529509,
-0.7634991407,
0.2962841094,
-0.3727793097,
-0.5571097732,
-0.6734135151,
0.1950390041,
0.2928573191,
-0.0038882252,
0.0492541492,
-0.2377917469,
-0.5409300327,
-0.8110101223,
-0.0480064489,
-0.249677062,
-0.1485171616,
-0.0869859233,
0.1436626911,
-0.0531244501,
0.6732912064,
-0.3422189057,
-0.3968213201,
-0.8786463737,
-0.1736828834,
0.1933092326,
0.5244788527,
0.4503411055,
-0.6671228409,
-0.7473312616,
0.2974608839,
-0.3058744371,
0.0416685976,
-0.211631909,
-0.0731281564,
0.260338366,
0.7828044891,
-0.3633823991,
0.029243622,
0.5265769362,
0.0105076283,
0.5621017218,
-0.3264887631,
-0.3258206546,
-1.181710124,
-0.02053288,
-0.2448923141,
-0.0184312332,
-0.6344001293,
0.1699178368,
0.3263720274,
0.0830196887,
-0.8055065274,
0.6818623543,
-0.65416646,
0.025928922,
-0.5154029727,
0.3953103423,
-0.4556398988,
0.5410105586,
0.2310340852,
0.8130738735,
0.3535300195,
-0.498413533,
0.1337538362,
-0.0395604372,
-0.1092160344,
0.1368424594,
-0.5265448093,
0.2032537162,
0.2638062239,
0.0329481699,
-0.976708889,
0.080903329,
-0.0274635106,
-0.2640926838,
0.5531769395,
-0.0254205242,
-0.7327193618,
-0.3938369453,
-0.4371263981,
0.5712032914,
0.3502370119,
-0.5465563536,
0.2446542531,
0.3629954457,
-0.1591228396,
-0.394248873,
-0.8378229141,
0.0504858531,
-0.1419058442,
-0.4338172078,
0.2882830501,
-0.2463815361,
-0.0386450365,
-0.3133727908,
-0.024106402,
-0.2363632619,
0.3115693629,
-0.0952675268,
0.4565831125,
-0.5355103016,
0.0734364092,
-0.2451007366,
-0.1544792056,
-0.1114008725,
-0.6555661559,
0.6902237535,
-0.0513515174,
-0.1956809759,
-0.2458773851,
-0.1653975695,
0.1738914847,
-0.2068718672,
0.6348698735,
0.6903359294,
-0.4308402836,
-0.2641812861,
-0.3678449988,
-0.0880400836,
-0.4554668367,
0.6526346803,
-0.2030709535,
-1.1207190752,
0.3216147721,
-0.1026742607,
0.2602317035,
0.388708204,
0.9319006801,
0.1246065423,
0.8247401118,
1.066100359,
-0.485963732,
0.6619554758,
-0.06098748,
0.2383200526,
-0.5866804719,
0.1971710622,
-0.3664547205,
-0.1808554381,
-0.7873057127,
-0.5958575606,
0.1697143763,
-0.0430592448,
-0.3915496171,
0.4024102986,
-0.2866003215,
0.5018289089,
0.4429899156,
-0.0566897355,
0.2630734742,
-0.3671658933,
-0.1854217499,
-0.0334223285,
-0.8479907513,
-0.5532963872,
1.2654855251,
0.3051270247,
0.3841986358,
-0.0551050641,
0.4578957856,
-0.0019630967,
0.4210908115,
-0.8962864876,
0.5475137234,
-0.5713624358,
-0.5525320172,
-0.4232284427,
-0.1009655073,
-0.8651360273,
0.3702968061,
0.1398108006,
-0.4227012694,
-0.4309938848,
0.0437510759,
-0.6253475547,
0.1833861917,
-0.6852830648,
1.0769270658,
-0.655790031,
-0.3744744956,
-0.2758517861,
-0.726668179,
0.6064991355,
-0.4606736004,
0.1492447406,
0.0552901402,
-0.3354620934,
0.7626076937,
-0.3171263039,
0.8104670048,
0.0200937893,
-0.1813725978,
0.3680393994,
-0.1041531265,
0.4415190518,
-0.0167686548,
-0.058525566,
0.2982486188,
0.0052517531,
-0.5278409719,
-0.1762793809,
0.5173206925,
-0.8641337156,
-0.7974048257,
-0.3938180804,
-0.4052336514,
-0.1959132999,
0.5338019133,
0.3369330466,
-0.0881474838,
-0.4447479844,
0.3247632086,
0.5915679336,
-0.3889814019,
0.5594639778,
0.6642125249,
-0.1078928038,
-0.167525053,
0.7865279913,
0.3457948864,
0.3919358552,
0.6752191782,
0.1875631362,
-0.2025507689,
-0.9516665339,
-0.2489016205,
0.270806551,
-0.3263291717,
0.0887488425,
-0.3981407285,
-0.5698340535,
-0.4844309688,
-0.088175483,
-0.6851923466,
-0.2179553807,
-0.2784256935,
-0.1086360663,
-0.2321805507,
0.4691233039,
-0.0008807642,
0.5892264843,
-0.7269459367,
0.0990658104,
0.1601270437,
0.183082372,
0.0016289204,
-0.7786038518,
-0.8075976968,
0.0578283593,
-0.3561542928,
-0.2135555744,
0.3435029685,
-0.1951330453,
0.5310208797,
0.5559087396,
-0.0708729178,
0.6819607019,
-0.5937516093,
1.0847055912,
0.2749131322,
-0.6921490431,
0.40116629,
-0.3877681196,
0.3322408199,
0.5200943351,
0.0573637821,
-0.6279425025,
-0.2550499439,
-0.3548794985,
-0.808512032,
1.0016613007,
-0.1480872333,
0.0644109026,
0.0954605788,
0.1665467173,
0.0908742025,
0.1805955321,
-0.9984617233,
-0.1779064685,
-0.0129149994,
-0.3371604383,
-0.1440533847,
-0.4384615123,
-0.0151577424,
-0.2098832428,
0.5583474636,
-0.4451625347,
0.1559594274,
-0.2314877361,
-0.2628646791,
0.1323409528,
0.184172973,
0.4940603375,
0.5631851554,
0.1077286452,
0.028996367,
0.4036787748,
-0.5675777793,
-0.0356881097,
-0.0364493988,
-0.05330199,
-0.2508654594,
0.4990993738,
0.4693269432,
0.22077775,
-0.7353937626,
0.6170013547,
-0.002166752,
-0.0666632578,
-0.5852432847,
-0.0101599786,
0.3064122498,
0.0797726214,
0.2771795392,
-0.486792773,
-0.189519912,
-0.4653135836,
0.0092735132,
0.438976109,
-0.4268157482,
-0.4872894883,
0.7515101433,
0.2967403531,
0.0360952467,
0.5623340011,
-0.0576519966,
-0.4048642218,
0.7262595296,
0.4246383905,
0.9476879239,
-0.1519721299,
-0.1090846136,
0.363887161,
0.645822525,
-0.3869793713,
0.039767947,
0.1303174794,
-0.7419872284,
-0.2032340467,
-0.4352297485,
-0.3252343237,
0.3171990514,
-0.3632405698,
0.71681422,
-0.8069358468,
0.18516922,
-0.382119149,
0.4541073442,
-0.6647610068,
0.1661726683,
0.513248086,
1.1392315626,
-0.4973979592,
1.5093823671,
0.6920858622,
-0.4514541328,
-1.0867090225,
0.1430568248,
0.1291481405,
-1.1526268721,
0.633115232,
0.2868302166,
0.2282834947,
0.0683615878,
-0.6301315427,
-0.7927401662,
1.3414480686,
0.350055784,
-0.844483912,
-0.0874213651,
0.3312631249,
0.6790046096,
-0.466552943,
0.325805068,
0.8206967115,
0.4018526673,
0.0046596462,
-0.904343307,
-0.0151937138,
0.0245264247,
0.2421237975,
-0.0654813871,
-1.3530430794,
0.9693405032,
-0.3408620954,
-0.310814321,
0.3567180037,
0.7070335746,
0.3585495353,
0.1787184924,
0.4439867139,
0.1729940325,
0.6778308749,
-0.2358467132,
0.6316740513,
-0.5095582604,
-0.0414971337,
1.1402254105,
-0.4110941589,
0.9247365594,
0.4280581474,
-0.1118358374,
0.0655956715,
1.0619786978,
0.1080500185,
0.4086327255,
0.2308666259,
-0.1055165678,
-0.3045760393,
-0.1418261081,
-0.4125168622,
0.533804059,
0.3525443971,
-0.121962741,
0.0231806729,
-0.2566566765,
0.0926056132,
0.0356459171,
-0.5518900752,
0.7433831096,
0.3659071624,
-0.4095598459,
0.3932417035,
0.181141451,
0.9956632853,
-0.8371511102,
0.4412854016,
-0.4208584428,
0.193208769,
-0.0979575738,
-0.5148506761,
0.0309851673,
0.040791139,
-0.0133029912,
-0.2926777303,
0.4590389132,
-0.621599853,
-0.3675843179,
0.3204197586,
0.6039760113,
0.0869122595,
-0.0077709565,
-0.638946116,
0.0665216148,
0.1636973917,
-0.2376922369,
0.6046237946,
0.8344889879,
-0.2808717191,
0.4445535243,
0.6096500754,
0.3796292841,
-0.1199662834,
0.1107616201,
0.6508845687,
-0.9701714516,
-0.7255884409,
-0.935963273,
0.2996530235,
0.187352702,
-0.1981680244,
0.7287801504,
0.725695312,
1.1631798744,
-0.1107340977,
0.90683043,
0.0454387739,
0.2352522761,
-0.4805959463,
0.9520546794,
-0.5548260212,
0.4032068253,
0.0886624753,
-0.8167043328,
-0.3241416514,
0.1848756671,
-0.3387316465,
0.0315174051,
0.7454496622,
0.6491524577,
0.2819636762,
-0.1372361332,
0.5182211995,
0.4299542904,
0.3266265392,
0.9931371808,
0.7999333739,
-0.243334502,
0.8540662527,
-0.0416641571,
-0.1103134379,
-0.299857229,
-0.7769075632,
-0.8922573328,
-0.3458915949,
-0.0748462453,
0.1302207559,
-0.1917169988,
1.2072610855,
0.5886442065,
-0.8976055384,
-0.5135645866,
0.0921801478,
0.1725141406,
-0.2033250779,
-0.1507632732,
0.4070675969,
-0.4851134121,
-0.9257017374,
0.2759785354,
0.4247298837,
0.1941523999,
-0.3113688529,
-0.131799385,
-0.0609517582,
-0.0869073346,
0.7496648431,
0.2743204534,
-0.694846034,
-0.2277932167,
-0.0142086688,
-0.6602288485,
0.0878241882,
0.9724074602,
-0.5156875849,
0.126163438,
0.2330024391,
0.8953096867,
0.0969368145,
-0.3779647946,
0.6264909506,
-0.7574543953,
0.6298089027,
0.1059421673,
0.3005586565,
0.3661617637,
-0.3198738098,
0.6155908108,
0.256662786,
-0.3393038511,
-0.8758353591,
-0.0242503751,
-1.0384081602,
-0.3810249269,
1.2466701269,
-0.0580476597,
-0.1313948333,
0.0800707713,
-0.2820501029,
0.3864372373,
-0.0965912119,
0.5928180814,
0.8232212663,
0.2479237914,
-0.1764540523,
-0.451049,
0.4088500142,
0.3839751184,
-0.5911019444,
0.2974840403,
0.1908946186,
0.2348908037,
-0.1749868095,
0.8951018453,
-0.1976001859,
0.2964601219,
-0.0931572914,
0.1066448167,
-0.0043345899,
-0.3738032579,
-0.3589513898,
0.0923252776,
0.5233026743,
-0.2059891969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04163v1
|
Dwell in the Beginning: How Language Models Embed Long Documents for Dense Retrieval
| 2024-04-05T15:16:16 | 2024-04-05T15:16:16 |
João Coelho, Bruno Martins, João Magalhães, Jamie Callan, Chenyan Xiong
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
This study investigates the existence of positional biases in
Transformer-based models for text representation learning, particularly in the
context of web document retrieval. We build on previous research that
demonstrated loss of information in the middle of input sequences for causal
language models, extending it to the domain of representation learning. We
examine positional biases at various stages of training for an encoder-decoder
model, including language model pre-training, contrastive pre-training, and
contrastive fine-tuning. Experiments with the MS-MARCO document collection
reveal that after contrastive pre-training the model already generates
embeddings that better capture early contents of the input, with fine-tuning
further aggravating this effect.
|
[
-0.4960983694,
-0.5633795857,
0.8253765702,
0.1096729189,
-0.2054446936,
-0.2047580183,
-0.201685667,
-0.1764255315,
0.0661415607,
0.433054179,
-0.2584487796,
-0.1735635549,
-0.9884176254,
-0.0406951569,
-0.6797236204,
0.7504695654,
-0.1047729552,
0.1379740834,
-0.3526489437,
-0.0401767008,
-0.5319629908,
-0.5546939373,
-0.5477321744,
-0.5109145045,
0.5499197245,
0.1707476974,
0.9504688382,
0.4943909347,
0.1517315209,
0.1797873378,
-0.0551021621,
-0.3189182878,
-0.7343232036,
0.38784796,
-0.0547564588,
-0.6743489504,
0.4900092483,
0.0751360878,
0.7241494656,
0.8934972882,
-0.1700973362,
-0.3075520694,
0.1736643165,
0.4274147749,
-0.733664453,
-0.0435457453,
-0.4556883872,
0.1159681752,
-0.2015853673,
-0.27257514,
-1.0260906219,
-0.1981720477,
0.3042356372,
-0.5546353459,
0.5758236647,
-0.1531589478,
1.0094679594,
0.3389837146,
-0.6107749939,
-0.4212130606,
-0.8427990675,
0.7614892125,
-0.3578841686,
0.7645616531,
0.6591488123,
-0.0525017828,
0.0854993314,
-0.5418576002,
-0.6091536283,
-0.1192680746,
-0.6142878532,
-0.1285138279,
-0.1022203937,
-0.0004125782,
0.4585828781,
0.0717405975,
-0.5203099847,
0.0817213431,
-0.3155101836,
0.060463056,
0.3066136539,
-0.1094875485,
0.2223081589,
-0.1020976901,
-0.023860136,
-0.4914862514,
-0.7826401591,
-0.1990001649,
0.2990950942,
0.2427504659,
-0.0714707822,
0.507874012,
0.3124945164,
0.4483036995,
0.3311017454,
0.375184983,
0.0368933342,
0.0264081787,
-0.2452419698,
0.0984386504,
0.595440805,
-0.0429940037,
0.2826341987,
-0.1635872275,
-0.4151111543,
0.0119123505,
0.6753249764,
-0.86185956,
-0.0531152263,
-0.0244827047,
-0.6056379676,
-0.1569297165,
0.2680819333,
-0.2190690935,
-0.4213631749,
-0.3864920735,
0.375330627,
-0.4998510778,
0.1711824089,
0.0962575823,
0.0097901924,
0.4892057776,
0.0753806084,
-1.1704893112,
0.4573485851,
0.442576319,
0.7037685513,
-0.1726237386,
-0.2883079946,
-0.2511596084,
0.1032866836,
-0.4736815393,
0.668156743,
-0.7142062187,
-0.7084188461,
0.4847441018,
0.2878672779,
0.0332094505,
-0.5333419442,
0.5923631191,
-0.9575497508,
0.5267745852,
-0.3470959067,
-0.5011313558,
0.0676093847,
0.0244607423,
-0.9582182765,
1.0299750566,
0.1204376593,
-0.9050070047,
0.5386112928,
-0.2653545439,
-0.5396305323,
-0.4406472445,
-0.2740091085,
-0.3534209132,
0.2915431857,
0.1715005487,
0.6783089042,
-0.0523128398,
0.178782627,
-0.0362185538,
-0.5338292718,
0.0781231448,
-0.1443831623,
0.5887454748,
0.1635825783,
-0.3041365147,
-0.1703938693,
-0.7306770682,
-0.5612197518,
0.4173722565,
-0.3723114133,
-0.8097245693,
0.2631215453,
0.0161909238,
0.1605956703,
0.2258501053,
-0.4334897101,
0.1668750793,
-0.30736956,
0.0386481248,
0.5568255782,
0.0330321528,
0.9660711288,
-0.1302356571,
0.4188284874,
0.3891798258,
-0.03877002,
-0.7198670506,
-0.0253412072,
-0.9797844291,
0.6074448824,
0.3328447044,
0.2742932141,
-0.6817943454,
0.1805215329,
-0.2973202765,
-0.161565423,
-0.2850219607,
0.0496764928,
0.3491810858,
-0.0112084933,
0.3828188777,
-0.2707969844,
-0.4296199977,
-0.9789843559,
0.0054896777,
0.1962108612,
-0.1838826537,
0.1599708349,
0.3834277987,
-0.3735694587,
0.7253083587,
-0.6320884228,
-0.1094870046,
-0.106518589,
0.2681946754,
0.157226041,
0.4679529369,
0.5457997918,
-0.8777396679,
-0.5465610027,
-0.2796834409,
-0.6768409014,
0.1810645014,
-0.1808182597,
-0.0636212379,
0.0606387779,
0.7619177103,
-0.8107557893,
0.3617003262,
0.3427807391,
-0.3545608521,
0.099488005,
-0.3265716732,
-0.0510312878,
-1.0663282871,
-0.0982049704,
0.0197564848,
-0.1251410544,
-0.4980891347,
-0.155048728,
0.2539500892,
-0.2640831172,
0.0012591674,
0.4960006177,
-0.680398643,
0.0126496591,
-0.337992698,
0.3360741138,
0.3143197298,
0.2640740275,
0.2417085767,
0.7776591182,
0.0987738892,
-0.6658526659,
-0.5626692772,
0.3470082581,
-0.1515197009,
0.1956186295,
-0.7994719744,
0.3136321604,
-0.5179058909,
0.159172684,
-0.8503372073,
-0.06592457,
-0.0720781758,
-0.366920203,
0.8885808587,
-0.1881395578,
-0.4807940423,
-0.2627084255,
-0.1207847446,
0.4685774744,
0.4520536959,
-0.393499881,
0.3664568365,
0.359695822,
-0.1537460536,
-0.5873585343,
-0.6128262281,
-0.3376625478,
0.1874035299,
-0.2463913858,
0.7156974673,
0.206254065,
-0.0231370907,
-0.0888769329,
0.2672367096,
-0.1511873305,
-0.0743602887,
0.1784332097,
-0.1028778553,
-0.2530843318,
0.3472494483,
0.1314270496,
-0.1179316267,
0.1937094033,
-0.1832811534,
0.7133009434,
0.3331546783,
-0.4483499229,
0.1224185228,
0.599429369,
0.489043802,
-0.1602373421,
0.9768708348,
0.3242346048,
-0.5766689777,
-0.2629763186,
-0.6509462595,
-0.3835558593,
-0.415186137,
0.2567385435,
-0.1070061177,
-0.8246920705,
0.6593772173,
0.1401364356,
-0.1773525029,
0.4743528664,
0.2880103886,
-0.2194374353,
0.9344524741,
1.112752676,
0.0120975198,
0.9020864964,
-0.3699318767,
0.1744047552,
-0.7638723254,
-0.3824682832,
-0.6702727079,
-0.2713890374,
-0.5576243401,
-0.5544884801,
0.0231048875,
0.2183737904,
-0.5138620138,
0.2256647795,
-0.4515009224,
0.6241517663,
0.4618346691,
0.2219335884,
-0.0626424104,
-0.2027949989,
-0.3663959205,
-0.3528838754,
-0.6219438314,
-0.5565321445,
1.0849434137,
0.3487437367,
0.9168252945,
-0.1481157094,
0.7489367127,
0.272801578,
0.2178809345,
-0.6746184826,
0.0785671547,
-0.1520997584,
-0.4672909081,
-0.3338501751,
0.2046186328,
-1.3510682583,
0.0976081789,
0.0283451807,
-0.4072694778,
0.6576901078,
-0.0962032154,
-0.2637090683,
-0.0042961352,
-0.4378926158,
0.7900893092,
-0.1419268698,
-0.6375283003,
-0.1800949872,
-0.7335124016,
0.0929382965,
0.1144791842,
-0.0000114847,
0.4381894171,
0.1237006858,
0.7464315891,
-0.22387366,
0.821559608,
-0.5167244077,
-0.1246812716,
0.1104535982,
0.3709946573,
0.6689291,
-0.1374419779,
0.0031878166,
-0.1934004873,
-0.2980579436,
-0.450709343,
-0.7146120667,
0.3288510442,
-0.9234384894,
-0.3581660986,
-0.4357266426,
0.1593551189,
-0.1751391143,
0.3281499147,
0.4401084483,
0.4371261597,
-0.4564231336,
0.5338519216,
1.4240249395,
-0.318233341,
0.4401202202,
0.4264971018,
-0.2784896195,
-0.0280235615,
0.3111454248,
0.0394300409,
-0.0175663121,
0.7113180757,
0.0179290082,
-0.2331571728,
-0.5446681976,
-0.0701691881,
0.3364600539,
-0.9803054929,
-0.1420394629,
-0.7124824524,
-0.2759656012,
-0.2770205438,
-0.3773070872,
-0.4845896959,
0.0957557261,
-0.625300467,
-0.2455383092,
-0.1710232049,
1.1160533428,
0.3750551343,
0.7419425845,
-0.7032939196,
0.1470306963,
0.0529172681,
0.4350505471,
0.1843639463,
-0.7622078061,
-0.7740734816,
-0.275275737,
-0.517555654,
-0.9135930538,
0.2977043986,
-0.0819818899,
0.7521559596,
0.6150289178,
-0.2932699621,
0.2089872807,
-0.6163505912,
0.9851999283,
-0.069628574,
-0.7382106781,
0.7433030605,
-0.4610378444,
0.5183836818,
0.6259619594,
0.955529511,
-0.4902635813,
0.0150553491,
-0.509275198,
-0.6941897273,
0.6077436805,
-0.1451182961,
0.4977540672,
-0.4462741315,
0.4371182621,
0.2031050622,
0.0650225431,
-1.0878705978,
-0.1425634921,
-0.3708670735,
0.0633990914,
-0.1973129958,
-0.6940801144,
0.1351578981,
-0.2104121745,
0.5524828434,
-0.1692060381,
0.5532855392,
0.320959866,
-0.7280045152,
0.0116444025,
0.2205569297,
0.5939702988,
0.5127642155,
-0.0378317386,
0.1265376359,
-0.088059932,
-0.2667817175,
0.2295809984,
-0.0050311019,
-0.4179082811,
0.2265135348,
0.4805478156,
0.9840340614,
1.0613476038,
-0.2406728119,
0.7695983052,
0.0378904045,
0.0630897358,
-0.466362983,
-0.3233810961,
0.0174424872,
0.0150673203,
0.5385965109,
-0.2226879448,
0.1919860542,
-0.5283051729,
0.2976083755,
0.262164861,
-0.6733819246,
-0.4039683342,
0.7772165537,
-0.0813208967,
-0.1766804606,
0.78679353,
-0.0599303208,
-0.4921148717,
0.1840604097,
0.6721800566,
0.9892873764,
-0.4070767462,
0.2238045633,
0.5329263806,
0.2711238861,
-0.2124679834,
-0.0611298159,
-0.1205167919,
-0.9797776937,
-0.2187529504,
-0.8273637295,
-0.0667598993,
-0.1906973273,
-0.6769656539,
0.4409908056,
-0.3047012091,
-0.1813536137,
-0.2997639775,
-0.1421781033,
-0.9889586568,
0.131278798,
0.3674806356,
0.7982046604,
-0.8729957342,
0.8946083784,
0.4056754112,
-0.7282291651,
-0.5751012564,
0.1203915179,
-0.3913461268,
-0.5926601291,
0.8215671182,
0.151689142,
-0.0728129297,
-0.0339953676,
-0.6433464885,
-0.9567207098,
1.0978883505,
0.3588728309,
-0.5383166671,
-0.5787073374,
0.0506401993,
0.6195873618,
-0.4071168602,
0.5207213163,
0.3409653306,
0.2598188221,
-0.1867439151,
-0.4754720926,
0.1060252488,
-0.1754880399,
0.2265363336,
0.2199373841,
-0.6009151936,
1.0431938171,
0.0095096091,
-0.440176785,
-0.2759533525,
0.5024382472,
-0.184062168,
0.0573242754,
0.2792180181,
0.5985264778,
0.5934593081,
-0.116819419,
1.4682478905,
-0.3706866503,
0.2207224816,
1.1068298817,
-0.1060235649,
1.0320096016,
0.5672591925,
-0.1792016923,
0.9220920801,
0.6770116687,
0.1296727061,
0.7496827245,
0.1418757737,
0.0230538473,
-0.0240531489,
0.1088677496,
-0.3137865663,
0.2610676885,
0.4138473868,
-0.9074867964,
-0.0140000023,
0.1920718551,
-0.0436271168,
0.2076732963,
0.1194688082,
0.8500375748,
0.2238817513,
-0.7351776958,
0.4409400225,
-0.0003478688,
0.653865397,
-0.7222760916,
0.0178090334,
-0.5074574947,
-0.1001609862,
-0.0306831393,
-0.6215059757,
0.183484599,
-0.5203154087,
-0.6525642872,
-0.5120788813,
0.8662317395,
-0.3945601881,
-0.1672473103,
0.7312120795,
0.4223675728,
-0.1248238236,
-0.2165442854,
-0.3415178657,
0.1695161611,
-0.3471631408,
-0.6931763291,
0.3447068632,
0.5032737255,
-0.0960569754,
0.4321050942,
0.4883544445,
-0.2625007033,
0.2913697958,
0.4115293622,
0.9042782187,
-0.8151587844,
-0.5469370484,
-0.7718526721,
0.459125787,
0.0777615532,
0.0832150057,
0.4616836011,
0.6478329301,
1.020275712,
-0.1851530075,
0.6630498171,
0.1765017658,
0.2392376363,
-0.5575532913,
0.8842885494,
-0.3975514472,
-0.0158366896,
-0.2138790488,
-1.1610885859,
-0.1661459506,
0.7407253981,
-0.250714004,
0.1284154654,
0.8947773576,
0.5492748618,
-0.2399266511,
-0.1873208582,
0.465200305,
0.237761423,
0.1719361991,
0.240700841,
0.7890996933,
-0.7239624262,
0.1563881785,
-0.1942172796,
0.179404065,
-0.4209695756,
-0.6952975392,
-0.5930534005,
-0.9212620258,
0.2385355234,
-0.4594256282,
0.0718956366,
0.703209281,
0.6558405161,
-0.8645242453,
-0.0785526782,
0.0273614638,
0.1415974498,
0.4476310909,
-0.2162018716,
0.3423022926,
-0.490144223,
-0.6006639004,
0.2719916105,
0.0554560684,
0.3999893963,
-0.5034673214,
-0.2452692538,
-0.3354185522,
0.0052904761,
0.7352958322,
0.1569995582,
-0.5521163344,
-0.4246970713,
0.1765369177,
-0.3683168888,
0.3434745371,
1.2359074354,
-0.9637495279,
0.502984941,
0.3569179475,
0.73849684,
0.9129864573,
-0.1480764896,
0.7914303541,
-0.9366912842,
0.299425602,
0.215877831,
0.6009294391,
0.4435660839,
-0.4389947057,
0.2210902572,
0.1166559905,
-0.4271228909,
-0.6687893271,
-0.0332946293,
-0.721108973,
-0.1962696612,
0.8037126064,
0.0851777196,
0.0192999542,
0.0968765765,
-0.0087886145,
0.5138278604,
-0.1575157344,
0.6999883652,
1.0767798424,
0.1231303066,
-0.2681669593,
-0.5929063559,
0.5204768181,
0.4138633311,
-0.3825156093,
-0.0755356178,
0.4267811179,
0.1070711836,
0.4356316924,
0.6884780526,
-0.2380075306,
0.0056650084,
0.3256628513,
0.0226713121,
0.360216856,
-0.5720234513,
-0.4934627414,
0.1201369762,
0.2978888452,
0.1921807677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04113v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04113v1
|
BEAR: A Unified Framework for Evaluating Relational Knowledge in Causal and Masked Language Models
| 2024-04-05T14:13:55 | 2024-04-05T14:13:55 |
Jacek Wiland, Max Ploner, Alan Akbik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge probing assesses to which degree a language model (LM) has
successfully learned relational knowledge during pre-training. Probing is an
inexpensive way to compare LMs of different sizes and training configurations.
However, previous approaches rely on the objective function used in
pre-training LMs and are thus applicable only to masked or causal LMs. As a
result, comparing different types of LMs becomes impossible. To address this,
we propose an approach that uses an LM's inherent ability to estimate the
log-likelihood of any given textual statement. We carefully design an
evaluation dataset of 7,731 instances (40,916 in a larger variant) from which
we produce alternative statements for each relational fact, one of which is
correct. We then evaluate whether an LM correctly assigns the highest
log-likelihood to the correct statement. Our experimental evaluation of 22
common LMs shows that our proposed framework, BEAR, can effectively probe for
knowledge across different LM types. We release the BEAR datasets and an
open-source framework that implements the probing approach to the research
community to facilitate the evaluation and development of LMs.
|
[
-0.4751511514,
-0.9797273874,
0.6262040734,
0.1619509757,
-0.133091554,
0.0025503053,
-0.2290182561,
-0.3249076605,
0.2046746016,
0.7126277089,
-0.5568256378,
-0.6521925926,
-0.4956305623,
0.0913505405,
-0.38333413,
0.8431428075,
0.2872959673,
0.0419285707,
-0.4866778851,
-0.4510386288,
-0.4822057188,
-0.4064406753,
-0.3792706728,
-0.2813161314,
0.4266426861,
-0.1019345745,
0.7592028379,
0.3535379469,
0.5414050221,
0.2868115306,
-0.1068763733,
0.1389610022,
-0.6376245618,
0.2406543642,
-0.5081031322,
-0.2216568589,
-0.2165157646,
0.0235997718,
0.7073390484,
1.0964407921,
-0.0347682871,
0.3379458785,
-0.1556468904,
0.7546748519,
-0.978049159,
0.1626084447,
-0.6084125638,
-0.1208189279,
0.0000742378,
-0.0366173163,
-0.6489053965,
-0.3250486553,
0.2767945528,
-0.6396481991,
0.2092749923,
0.3541430235,
0.8446804285,
-0.0020416714,
-0.7550267577,
-0.179506585,
-0.4975515008,
0.6737759113,
-0.5209406614,
0.6072932482,
0.5561749935,
0.3185748458,
-0.1714116633,
-0.680408299,
-0.3277190626,
-0.2646825314,
-0.7168976068,
-0.1299729049,
-0.0887803957,
0.1556098312,
0.2215463519,
0.4288897216,
-0.7630235553,
-0.4332124591,
-0.2063510418,
-0.3286856413,
0.5491262674,
0.1355436742,
0.2279054821,
-0.0811374858,
-0.2524249256,
-0.1675431281,
-0.8234897852,
-0.1310337484,
0.2836117744,
0.328294456,
0.1749208719,
0.4413910508,
-0.1895648539,
1.1126195192,
0.0968576744,
0.032664489,
-0.0803701058,
-0.1377993673,
-0.5016698241,
-0.111590974,
0.8553701043,
0.2825066745,
-0.0444374643,
-0.4342185557,
-0.2765542865,
-0.0576024242,
0.2309002429,
-0.7122921944,
-0.1775936186,
0.0647100881,
-0.145724088,
-0.3023384511,
0.1232547164,
-0.5866456032,
-0.5682362914,
-0.3433001637,
0.6590489149,
-0.2366704047,
-0.7153867483,
0.3030365109,
0.1259231716,
0.148023814,
-0.0295239463,
-0.7713600993,
0.6037291288,
0.7838289738,
0.3795359135,
-0.037871059,
-0.108649075,
-0.8693448305,
0.0259820204,
-0.5744726658,
0.6083723903,
-0.5119222999,
-0.1998076737,
0.1721165478,
0.0912766978,
-0.2429072708,
-0.5587963462,
0.3881879449,
-0.9845205545,
0.2983266413,
-0.4804211855,
-0.7434538007,
-0.5601055026,
0.4106868505,
-0.8892521858,
1.1755172014,
0.3480934203,
-1.0651054382,
0.6061778069,
-0.5648598075,
-0.3880708516,
0.1741171479,
-0.4248760045,
-0.3019140661,
0.0893324688,
0.2851981819,
0.5306512117,
-0.6398375034,
1.0040565729,
-0.5883966684,
-0.3924363852,
0.4595100582,
0.1820551455,
1.24933815,
0.1221843511,
-0.3701998889,
0.1040152758,
-0.6235288978,
0.0020055636,
-0.0793143138,
-0.1024749279,
-0.6964995861,
-0.1271347255,
-0.2630894482,
-0.2253654897,
-0.3187799454,
-0.4602174163,
-0.0601412766,
-0.3168059289,
-0.1058243811,
0.4083096981,
0.0356649645,
0.4467440844,
-0.2514606714,
0.4697733223,
-0.2965858877,
0.1519825459,
-0.1467513591,
-0.2429640889,
-0.8168667555,
-0.404959023,
0.3836243749,
0.3021300435,
-0.5245687366,
0.4276924431,
-0.2221257091,
-0.3018569052,
-0.4782117307,
0.1161312461,
0.7032408714,
0.5629159808,
0.1787749231,
-0.4426037371,
-0.4519617856,
-0.7021920085,
-0.6240952611,
-0.4297248125,
-0.0348124094,
0.4863827825,
0.4210197031,
-0.1452896446,
1.1765040159,
-0.417268157,
-0.17864196,
0.0138619635,
0.4934229553,
0.3801068962,
0.2761843801,
0.6660497189,
-0.7235093117,
-0.3882904649,
0.0277416147,
-1.1779665947,
0.0442368612,
0.0749084353,
-0.2528269589,
0.1110062078,
0.5482898355,
-0.591109395,
0.3653603494,
0.5720373392,
-0.5350494385,
0.609716773,
0.1812801659,
0.2629652023,
-0.6274724007,
0.3612153828,
-0.2755270898,
-0.2261712253,
-0.6543816328,
0.5681823492,
0.1744402647,
-0.0301219635,
-0.2962578237,
0.9520623088,
-0.6784806848,
-0.2659161985,
0.0364319682,
0.2290417254,
-0.0309027936,
0.3188197315,
0.1905860901,
0.435621649,
0.8888362646,
-0.7871263623,
0.4566496313,
-0.0192107707,
-0.8271889687,
0.6015202403,
-0.4970769584,
0.3617026508,
0.0087868283,
-0.1199016422,
-0.8503000736,
-0.1789193749,
0.3026524484,
-0.5372594595,
0.5326318741,
-0.0950580239,
-0.3988740146,
-0.0041358834,
-0.0161464512,
0.5161677599,
0.117736578,
-0.4336888194,
0.9230188131,
0.3219032288,
0.0199005753,
-0.9026302099,
-0.3417932689,
0.0361658148,
-0.2712351978,
-0.835218668,
-0.1864834279,
-0.148409307,
-0.6058990955,
0.2868097723,
-0.1900475919,
-0.13644512,
0.1592741907,
0.080890514,
0.1680226326,
-0.6294785142,
0.352825582,
-0.0808630213,
-0.0469139032,
0.3993314803,
-0.3633379936,
0.245343864,
-0.4160431623,
-0.5736094117,
0.0730943307,
0.0996946469,
0.1785115749,
-0.1283073723,
0.7760029435,
0.4863998592,
-0.3728973269,
0.0520191342,
-0.8934617639,
-0.5093728304,
-0.4547728896,
0.1732327193,
-0.5726801157,
-1.1757619381,
0.3549522161,
-0.0767686144,
-0.1419203728,
0.2563010454,
0.1249295771,
-0.0200570971,
0.4660946131,
0.8413851261,
-0.0760848224,
-0.2069863677,
0.1213749573,
0.3004127145,
-0.5793691278,
-0.1844753325,
-0.5057244301,
0.1580685377,
-0.3821829855,
-0.270865947,
0.3102752566,
0.3464633226,
-0.4128697813,
0.3736279607,
-0.0889845043,
0.494961977,
0.4633669257,
0.1655659825,
0.5325547457,
-0.1097878367,
-0.4333984256,
-0.0619122162,
-0.4681755602,
-0.359506011,
1.2563164234,
0.1169572845,
0.6405900121,
0.2514201701,
0.4120361805,
0.2516326606,
0.8158301115,
-0.7210531235,
0.5990920067,
0.363306433,
-1.5399495363,
-0.7462149858,
-0.5660839081,
-0.6967987418,
0.3938273787,
-0.1835460365,
-0.8067626953,
0.1244834438,
0.1388908625,
-0.0834612399,
0.2306202501,
-0.3858465552,
0.9672626257,
-0.2492811829,
-0.3491037488,
0.0596631691,
-0.807639122,
0.7843077183,
-0.4161136448,
0.4180097282,
-0.06951873,
0.2175952941,
0.7719106078,
-0.0720535517,
0.9374639988,
-0.0310636535,
0.0069158725,
0.4146113694,
0.6405361891,
0.2231215537,
0.185963273,
-0.0972598195,
-0.0572212823,
0.1844419092,
-0.2505478561,
-0.9381406903,
0.2616175711,
-0.4051187336,
-0.7069320083,
-0.5747639537,
-0.4226861298,
-0.4488862157,
0.2980885506,
-0.0832805336,
0.3568563461,
-0.6339499354,
0.418641299,
0.8376784325,
-0.2282354087,
0.0094156768,
1.0610096455,
-0.8146378398,
-0.2859429121,
0.6937602758,
-0.4774369001,
0.3044517934,
0.7626874447,
0.2579980493,
-0.3757916689,
-0.0686185583,
-0.2580810189,
0.5205984712,
-0.7914928794,
-0.3195612431,
-0.6967875361,
-0.0472593643,
-0.4919780195,
0.1004807651,
-0.3252907097,
-0.0611255579,
0.1162959412,
-0.2684901953,
0.3667214215,
0.6595778465,
-0.2763855755,
0.2966982722,
-0.583090663,
0.0079920199,
0.6631459594,
0.3980189562,
-0.3910698891,
-0.5568048358,
-0.0908429623,
0.0067164861,
-0.0967336968,
-1.0071409941,
0.2798207104,
0.1650296748,
0.6872562766,
0.669811964,
0.3802971244,
0.469819665,
-0.0307916366,
0.4310413003,
0.2694618702,
-1.1779419184,
0.483856082,
-0.4828490615,
-0.1453107446,
0.6693509817,
0.7666394114,
-0.5716257095,
-0.3730497956,
-0.5310652852,
-0.3053584099,
0.7871025801,
0.2410375774,
-0.0883399844,
0.1607975066,
0.346907407,
0.0867013112,
0.2993882895,
-0.9333404899,
-0.3520320058,
0.0835570395,
0.1436642855,
-0.2817955911,
-0.3179442286,
-0.6515569687,
-0.2288033068,
0.6455774307,
-0.227490887,
0.2042880207,
-0.1030132324,
-0.5131687522,
-0.1352665275,
0.1154342592,
0.3559919298,
1.0344334841,
-0.7365753055,
0.4629980028,
0.1717915386,
-0.3115326166,
0.1088279635,
-0.0027744237,
-0.2935990691,
0.1858689487,
0.6207788587,
0.8274371028,
0.5001280904,
-0.6108230948,
0.6651877761,
-0.1516742855,
-0.30395329,
0.0026948436,
-0.2196647376,
0.3119566441,
0.0473905243,
0.1178512424,
-0.3628252447,
0.1829622984,
-0.5932866931,
0.3856703043,
0.3041999042,
-0.724517107,
-0.291094631,
0.2865639627,
0.0466785058,
-0.0869866759,
0.7784918547,
-0.3534142673,
-0.4447852671,
0.3675903082,
0.4351142049,
0.8149946332,
-0.6385462284,
0.4706345797,
0.5549321771,
0.6845368147,
0.1624599397,
0.0576903783,
-0.177632153,
-0.9057483077,
-0.5296509266,
-0.7253636122,
-0.2972493768,
0.4127153456,
-1.0252511501,
0.2698633969,
-0.1511392295,
-0.0278725326,
-0.2809766531,
-0.0245797895,
-0.700891614,
0.4098121822,
-0.4439607263,
0.7781012058,
-1.0329662561,
0.6541080475,
0.8328169584,
-0.4093401432,
-0.6862110496,
-0.3176018894,
0.1513497233,
-0.9048739672,
0.911865294,
0.1328882873,
-0.1868106425,
-0.3487933874,
-0.6029893756,
-0.8592153192,
0.8490099311,
0.5650778413,
-0.349221319,
0.3583390713,
0.1652252078,
0.303050369,
-0.4204360247,
0.4779432118,
0.6180752516,
0.5292779207,
0.1210839227,
-0.9206517339,
0.3424759507,
-0.1160243601,
-0.2257822305,
0.1865369231,
-0.1144307926,
0.5895636678,
-0.1732571572,
-0.5129498839,
-0.179304257,
0.7171215415,
0.2838311791,
0.4568732977,
0.653190136,
0.4236702323,
0.7269510627,
-0.1386608332,
0.7870203257,
-0.1897763014,
0.6220871806,
1.2084025145,
-0.2755961418,
0.5116858482,
0.3543080986,
-0.141550228,
0.2439126223,
0.6636128426,
0.3544172645,
0.5712094903,
0.4905773997,
-0.3470321,
-0.5255324244,
-0.0219855886,
-0.4896499217,
0.2203721404,
0.4984551966,
-0.1712672263,
-0.1727275699,
-0.1962411404,
0.171095863,
0.1242687181,
0.1521114558,
0.8210336566,
0.131016016,
-0.8255510926,
0.708319068,
-0.1079699397,
0.092140995,
-0.5927106738,
0.1583769321,
-0.5956775546,
-0.0002015878,
0.0194830243,
-0.5877867937,
0.4397534728,
-0.2646324933,
0.0870569348,
0.0292497762,
0.7561849952,
-0.2748447657,
-0.3673616946,
0.5944581032,
0.5488749743,
0.4017413855,
-0.4044448137,
-0.4522640705,
0.2694281638,
-0.1659038663,
-0.2704615891,
0.3766808212,
0.6408316493,
0.1399854571,
0.6386366487,
0.4158951044,
-0.1151185259,
-0.0012322263,
0.0209961738,
0.9877234697,
-0.6708672047,
0.0031716044,
-0.5359501839,
0.5876969695,
-0.1094469279,
-0.2084867209,
0.5425316691,
0.5605031848,
0.9749576449,
-0.0323817991,
0.6376832724,
-0.0674951151,
0.6040902734,
-0.5917983651,
0.799746573,
-0.51106143,
0.2326514423,
-0.4478858411,
-1.0733271837,
-0.4399476647,
0.8035542369,
-0.2748809755,
-0.0153743792,
1.0986981392,
1.0404590368,
-0.2254609466,
0.2416253537,
0.6147297025,
0.2741315365,
0.131269753,
0.2589552701,
0.9893686771,
-0.5252842903,
0.4856787622,
-0.2138554752,
-0.4747454524,
-0.0948102698,
-1.2918063402,
-1.3279588223,
-0.7895632982,
-0.3424045146,
-0.2662744224,
0.3136891425,
0.34436059,
0.9146335721,
-0.8206169605,
-0.5997328758,
0.0911001712,
0.1570350379,
-0.3103660643,
-0.2037917972,
0.5417791605,
-0.4258242548,
-0.1577086151,
0.4858657718,
0.1393369436,
-0.4444403052,
-0.2458471954,
-0.2860758603,
-0.2919510007,
-0.0790459365,
0.6555323005,
0.3665626645,
-0.7399837971,
-0.2233159095,
0.3411504924,
-0.0199262872,
-0.3930401504,
1.1050724983,
-0.6614302993,
0.8766810894,
0.2212557942,
0.9769263268,
0.7659605742,
-0.3587911427,
0.7152990103,
-0.67075032,
0.0021334663,
0.2621432543,
0.1061976925,
0.385176897,
-0.2374032289,
0.7606624365,
0.3339124322,
-0.4762305319,
-0.9396596551,
0.2852454185,
-0.8284870982,
-0.2770002782,
1.0405369997,
-0.4775300026,
0.0050615305,
-0.2382762879,
0.1366546452,
0.1572663188,
-0.0438777246,
0.7539527416,
0.8673517704,
0.0835194886,
-0.1308720112,
-0.5041714311,
0.4869539738,
0.5113143325,
-0.6485990882,
-0.0285882205,
0.5051564574,
0.4169201553,
0.1510728598,
0.7692520022,
-0.1415482312,
0.1649458706,
-0.0628973916,
0.0112854447,
0.0704220682,
-0.4690997601,
-0.0501501113,
-0.0247288886,
-0.0785073116,
0.0880463794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04108v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04108v1
|
Large language models as oracles for instantiating ontologies with domain-specific knowledge
| 2024-04-05T14:04:07 | 2024-04-05T14:04:07 |
Giovanni Ciatto, Andrea Agiollo, Matteo Magnini, Andrea Omicini
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.LO
|
Background. Endowing intelligent systems with semantic data commonly requires
designing and instantiating ontologies with domain-specific knowledge.
Especially in the early phases, those activities are typically performed
manually by human experts possibly leveraging on their own experience. The
resulting process is therefore time-consuming, error-prone, and often biased by
the personal background of the ontology designer. Objective. To mitigate that
issue, we propose a novel domain-independent approach to automatically
instantiate ontologies with domain-specific knowledge, by leveraging on large
language models (LLMs) as oracles. Method. Starting from (i) an initial schema
composed by inter-related classes andproperties and (ii) a set of query
templates, our method queries the LLM multiple times, and generates instances
for both classes and properties from its replies. Thus, the ontology is
automatically filled with domain-specific knowledge, compliant to the initial
schema. As a result, the ontology is quickly and automatically enriched with
manifold instances, which experts may consider to keep, adjust, discard, or
complement according to their own needs and expertise. Contribution. We
formalise our method in general way and instantiate it over various LLMs, as
well as on a concrete case study. We report experiments rooted in the
nutritional domain where an ontology of food meals and their ingredients is
semi-automatically instantiated from scratch, starting from a categorisation of
meals and their relationships. There, we analyse the quality of the generated
ontologies and compare ontologies attained by exploiting different LLMs.
Finally, we provide a SWOT analysis of the proposed method.
|
[
-0.2585651278,
-0.8320106268,
0.5680758953,
0.0048371437,
0.2380057275,
-0.0721707493,
-0.2639582753,
-0.5041306019,
0.2040534019,
1.0443897247,
-0.1535606533,
-0.5268681049,
-0.3965782225,
0.1403114647,
-0.4576883316,
0.4755654633,
0.0268444195,
-0.1099122837,
-0.1535728872,
-0.0094953747,
-0.141995132,
-0.4973197877,
-0.3046175241,
-0.1267466545,
0.3226131201,
0.2309688181,
0.6311967373,
0.9406601191,
0.1841239929,
0.3689111471,
0.1542257071,
0.5284952521,
-0.0905752629,
0.1742083132,
-0.4779394269,
-0.20580405,
-0.6713906527,
-0.1431240141,
0.341734916,
0.8192458749,
-0.1763141155,
0.2315093875,
0.2580527961,
0.2123365402,
-0.5014525056,
0.4428020418,
-1.0342561007,
0.1759018153,
-0.1098453552,
-0.339549154,
-0.5504808426,
-0.1503508836,
0.3408534229,
-0.8647869229,
-0.0699308366,
0.1022172049,
0.6289179325,
0.240602538,
-0.2701515853,
-0.4841258228,
-0.8338564038,
0.7923176289,
-0.7991114259,
0.2395122051,
0.2267169058,
0.2758318186,
-0.2956129313,
-0.7444373965,
-0.8685865998,
-0.1171677634,
-0.1174820662,
-0.0505886525,
0.1307660639,
-0.1453471631,
-0.020548014,
0.1718196422,
-0.4781109691,
0.1323270202,
0.2713361979,
0.1701891273,
0.6415466666,
0.4865390658,
0.5037126541,
-0.4894935489,
-0.2419212013,
0.0992508158,
-0.9174670577,
-0.3648121655,
-0.0561437868,
0.7998855114,
0.2651486099,
0.8666478992,
-0.2811307013,
0.8140366077,
0.1303532571,
-0.3555595577,
0.1857306808,
-0.3831189871,
-0.1631787717,
0.0481850654,
0.612054944,
-0.0232822876,
0.2549383342,
-0.3423444033,
-0.1932577938,
-0.0610624924,
0.265628159,
-0.4060981572,
0.062756896,
0.4969691932,
-0.0564983971,
-0.1288333982,
-0.3125974834,
-0.4528875649,
-0.3696368039,
-0.5255836248,
0.7597873807,
-0.3663246036,
-0.0935005024,
-0.0160454083,
0.2577308714,
0.4471755028,
0.3357046843,
-0.9148071408,
0.1574752182,
0.7447122335,
0.346730113,
-0.0576831549,
-0.2638352215,
-0.2838287354,
0.8505532742,
-0.291531682,
0.9625551105,
-0.6337370276,
-0.2408267856,
0.2694397867,
0.1471610665,
0.2310011238,
-0.7531999946,
0.1221850365,
-0.7153663635,
0.1050418615,
-0.2790842056,
-0.8613746166,
0.0537389256,
0.2446071953,
-0.2723640501,
1.0339250565,
0.1766238064,
-0.5385590196,
0.588774085,
-0.4871449172,
-0.4330636859,
0.4569087327,
-0.3929293454,
0.1494479626,
-0.2252863497,
-0.0024724833,
0.6670343876,
-0.7478967309,
0.2727078497,
-0.289606601,
0.2493336052,
0.0507869087,
0.3172079027,
0.6000375152,
0.0168449413,
-0.231231302,
-0.0616150983,
-0.9318762422,
0.4181453586,
0.2533114851,
-0.2003358454,
-0.8011077642,
0.0674531385,
-0.3420945406,
0.3456846178,
0.2906420529,
-0.3158911467,
0.4946244955,
-0.606893003,
0.2527947128,
0.7943080664,
-0.0727653578,
0.5457921028,
0.0672253668,
0.1569017023,
-0.0217398982,
0.1308147609,
-0.1514041871,
-0.2185518742,
-0.8731276989,
-0.2279286832,
0.2947835028,
0.6274456978,
-0.9204978943,
0.868468523,
-0.1570081711,
-0.3550207317,
-0.1391768008,
0.282076627,
0.3275787532,
0.5270917416,
0.4583838582,
-0.2836349905,
-0.3753162622,
-0.5654394031,
-0.1223250926,
0.0403461121,
-0.1178165153,
0.6191307306,
0.4242132902,
-0.3277543783,
1.0302525759,
-0.7936750054,
-0.5875083208,
-0.2395547479,
-0.238303557,
-0.0566982739,
0.3323545456,
0.430118829,
-0.4630871117,
-0.7444953918,
0.2139073312,
-1.1744571924,
-0.1702876538,
0.122181721,
-0.4022554457,
0.1518404037,
0.2350901663,
-0.5788801312,
0.2798378766,
0.1250449419,
-0.3661762476,
0.5619261265,
-0.3289783299,
-0.2309689075,
-1.1964843273,
-0.0437237583,
-0.0603092089,
0.1448656917,
-0.6221702099,
0.1216968596,
-0.1218954399,
0.0612226836,
-0.5263925195,
1.0132451057,
-0.4847200513,
-0.2863154411,
-0.0880848244,
0.2478857934,
0.2083644271,
0.3545663357,
0.2470063269,
0.3661445677,
0.6024647355,
-0.8533505797,
0.340839833,
0.4969425201,
-0.4901579916,
0.4197146297,
-0.6522009969,
-0.0726389587,
0.082503289,
0.1933654696,
-0.6321490407,
-0.3530474603,
0.337723285,
-0.0319441669,
0.0492386818,
-0.153287217,
-0.7979789972,
-0.2364747077,
0.3065370619,
0.0713877678,
0.3397422135,
-0.6735393405,
1.090342164,
0.6730219126,
-0.264023602,
-0.4122215509,
-0.5783792138,
0.1268447787,
-0.0718659312,
-0.7225988507,
0.3137830496,
0.0194711704,
-0.3732889295,
0.2227700353,
0.1669019014,
-0.2338407636,
-0.2802429199,
0.2802043259,
0.2008035779,
-0.297351867,
0.3177920282,
0.2493873537,
-0.124187015,
-0.1786995232,
-0.8704532385,
0.5073893666,
0.2546225786,
-0.3206869066,
-0.3503156602,
0.5342366695,
0.3396571279,
-0.337449342,
0.8561715484,
0.137614876,
-0.2993859947,
-0.757813096,
-0.5649484396,
-0.2496856749,
-0.5141239166,
0.178946346,
-0.4362101257,
-0.5053732991,
0.6261099577,
-0.2058085501,
0.2713836432,
0.403370291,
0.7054954767,
0.1774750501,
0.7586855292,
0.7498801947,
0.4245957434,
0.1918879896,
-0.4490939975,
0.2410709709,
-0.5991243124,
-0.3380962312,
-0.4794141054,
0.3584395349,
-0.2115843445,
-0.7198991776,
0.3066773713,
-0.4348231256,
-0.4156189859,
0.2808511555,
-0.3802241385,
0.3882201314,
0.1039714143,
-0.2355846316,
0.4976444244,
0.1112554967,
-0.2871977985,
0.0772058293,
-0.7510347962,
-0.6789354086,
1.2493380308,
-0.1838674396,
0.8203012943,
0.1534761339,
0.4670126736,
0.3523076773,
0.5055312514,
-0.6129009724,
0.7854816318,
-0.5442823768,
-0.5338737369,
-0.2837921381,
-0.4836033583,
-0.8588005304,
0.3217675388,
-0.1494090855,
-0.5160585642,
0.173971951,
0.1372354627,
-0.4290323555,
0.2213194519,
-0.6565780044,
0.6602029204,
-0.4160856009,
-0.4972372949,
0.192187205,
-0.48531124,
0.1945551485,
-0.4920477569,
0.1642381549,
-0.2145925462,
-0.1621637046,
0.4981206954,
-0.6312327385,
0.9085866809,
-0.1182463393,
-0.4633464515,
0.4936562479,
0.1663050205,
0.5565280914,
0.0630427524,
-0.1827310622,
0.0409207381,
-0.2099972814,
-0.2949400246,
-0.8452517986,
0.7980343103,
-0.7790415287,
-0.6448635459,
-0.2932748497,
-0.375174433,
-0.4807065129,
0.3647381961,
-0.1934307218,
0.4778495133,
0.0423756987,
-0.3908152878,
0.5932805538,
-0.39079234,
0.1160605177,
1.0120582581,
-0.4028181732,
-0.0481362939,
0.884547174,
0.4013468623,
0.359536916,
0.3857286572,
0.096876815,
-0.2528225183,
-0.1087134778,
-0.4785079658,
0.1981913894,
-0.6502642632,
-0.1793331951,
-0.9181649685,
-0.1712574214,
-0.4950706363,
-0.2085923702,
-0.6583549976,
-0.3562292755,
-0.1867126822,
0.2974556684,
0.2576388121,
0.6609525084,
0.1512589157,
-0.0024102258,
-0.8542896509,
0.2159532905,
0.4960813224,
0.2211248279,
0.4820529222,
-0.6568564177,
-0.1592327207,
-0.2190045714,
0.0813864842,
-0.4551307559,
0.6537937522,
0.335539341,
0.5650703311,
0.4669878185,
0.1686219722,
0.4888907373,
-0.641528666,
0.7114704251,
-0.0928281024,
-0.8260778189,
0.431155473,
-0.188362211,
0.0030040033,
0.2384650856,
0.5916749835,
-0.1697235703,
-0.3698016107,
-0.480617702,
-1.1674623489,
0.4561896622,
-0.1995293051,
0.2226613611,
-0.1147077158,
0.6420517564,
0.4735195041,
0.1003917158,
-0.3703733385,
-0.3235792816,
-0.0224896595,
-0.0134109436,
0.3273378015,
-0.1436244547,
-0.2578923106,
-0.0666499361,
0.6162315607,
-0.1995027512,
0.0782810599,
-0.0693070218,
-0.1673640758,
0.0541665778,
0.103115648,
-0.0665597022,
0.9430481195,
-0.0021945983,
0.2186839432,
0.1107574776,
-0.1873388439,
0.2987805009,
-0.1133849695,
-0.2147478163,
-0.2790611088,
0.199037075,
0.231779471,
-0.0478259474,
-0.9019746184,
0.2179912031,
-0.0871927068,
0.041612938,
-0.561576426,
0.128665328,
-0.0323184691,
0.3212843239,
0.3773895204,
-0.355440259,
-0.2452405095,
-0.4971296191,
0.3560744524,
0.2119463384,
-0.0013604157,
-0.3938485086,
0.4529161453,
0.4030798674,
0.0480237976,
0.397792995,
-0.4026203156,
-0.2277260274,
0.2618311346,
0.6358328462,
0.7282432914,
-0.3898669183,
0.1247994602,
0.1109488457,
-0.0360489152,
0.0074991453,
0.2749430537,
0.063455157,
-1.0573887825,
-0.5792295933,
-0.9316709042,
-0.325468719,
-0.0276266448,
-0.3538355529,
0.1045738533,
-0.3646560013,
-0.0659923032,
0.3932554424,
-0.0824049786,
-0.6034578681,
0.3594467342,
-0.1051858142,
0.8158576488,
-0.8627643585,
0.9769678116,
0.7885070443,
-0.4360622466,
-0.9285904169,
0.081146121,
-0.1862176061,
-0.8802842498,
1.1407475471,
-0.5995317101,
0.0027380018,
-0.1147154868,
-0.1872180551,
-0.870890379,
0.7625852823,
0.1233855262,
-0.2456694543,
-0.0896485746,
0.5339301229,
0.5564832091,
-0.7086312771,
0.0095984479,
0.4064053595,
0.5757763386,
0.032581497,
-0.6555559039,
0.1911974847,
-0.0915375724,
0.0480529666,
-0.0475755967,
-0.6488472819,
0.7591347098,
-0.2135846019,
-0.0774459094,
0.0381144881,
0.7985917926,
0.0156610832,
0.0044506816,
0.3916306496,
0.5290342569,
0.59301126,
0.2139037251,
0.9301285148,
-0.7225990295,
0.2678488493,
1.1760159731,
-0.7906681299,
0.7556592822,
0.2520337403,
-0.2395848334,
0.288787663,
0.3547517955,
0.0215415787,
0.5282113552,
0.2628384829,
-0.3906412423,
-0.3824866414,
-0.3477504551,
-0.5373783708,
0.6781859994,
0.6185457706,
-0.4639293849,
-0.1764996052,
-0.0388133377,
-0.0069760452,
-0.1440998465,
-0.080012992,
0.8786531091,
0.0799650848,
-0.410385251,
0.3947520554,
0.0436831377,
0.1838904768,
-0.7255845666,
-0.0058799279,
-0.2423900068,
0.2125945538,
-0.1515297741,
-0.7030590177,
0.2745576799,
-0.0720973462,
-0.2261852324,
-0.0107943201,
0.650008738,
-0.4798877835,
-0.437836647,
0.4244627059,
0.8442747593,
0.000071804,
0.2000835836,
-0.5896337628,
-0.034878511,
-0.2977001965,
-0.3043710291,
0.5005390644,
0.6965817809,
-0.0025035923,
0.6760390997,
0.5918206573,
0.1151298806,
0.0802801773,
-0.1368986219,
1.0311335325,
-0.6531181335,
-0.4414974451,
-0.4324866235,
0.1405209005,
0.1065267846,
-0.0953071192,
0.8879298568,
0.4404088855,
0.7220014334,
-0.1203282773,
1.0047353506,
-0.3702653646,
0.4778727293,
-0.4213438928,
0.7845405936,
-0.8499130011,
0.5672513843,
-0.3240212202,
-1.0150355101,
-0.4573774338,
0.2825604379,
-0.3725937903,
0.029358834,
0.3888883293,
0.8362507224,
-0.0483970977,
-0.2495373636,
0.266391933,
0.5170409679,
0.2672037184,
0.1769626439,
0.7629867792,
0.0389615968,
0.381929189,
-0.0158416312,
-0.2779447734,
-0.321878612,
-0.734891355,
-0.5762377381,
-0.569606185,
-0.2570215166,
-0.4504938126,
0.2458486557,
0.9098811746,
0.7588192225,
-0.7709155679,
-0.20897609,
0.32953462,
0.0251927376,
-0.0021718517,
-0.1985429376,
0.7541824579,
-0.2555329204,
-0.5211475492,
0.2880326509,
0.5108107328,
-0.1560404301,
-0.5122112632,
0.0520010926,
0.0356892087,
0.5528787971,
0.9014196992,
0.4429434538,
-0.7923742533,
-0.3329176009,
-0.2027989924,
-0.1461262852,
-0.0189686734,
0.6098523736,
-0.6912795305,
0.3702715039,
0.4145687222,
0.6794183254,
0.0453750156,
-0.1090999916,
0.3117651939,
-0.5893387198,
0.0715673864,
0.0761657506,
0.181625545,
0.1550252587,
-0.2781206965,
0.4007901251,
0.1438144147,
-0.4691208899,
-0.757451117,
0.1959181428,
-0.9493009448,
-0.2841300666,
1.123233676,
-0.2755006552,
-0.4268420935,
-0.2300399393,
0.229749009,
-0.0721616149,
-0.1871478558,
0.9255809188,
0.0775682852,
-0.287830025,
0.4154659212,
-0.3254297376,
0.4017421901,
0.235352695,
-1.0695339441,
0.2503712475,
0.2136601806,
0.4316935241,
0.2233396918,
0.3851014972,
-0.1867075861,
-0.1990994066,
0.0636765957,
0.4726187587,
0.1883662343,
-0.4040145874,
0.4064951837,
0.3995912671,
-0.1677534133,
0.3929624557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04103v1
|
Improving Factual Accuracy of Neural Table-to-Text Output by Addressing Input Problems in ToTTo
| 2024-04-05T13:59:12 | 2024-04-05T13:59:12 |
Barkavi Sundararajan, Somayajulu Sripada, Ehud Reiter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural Table-to-Text models tend to hallucinate, producing texts that contain
factual errors. We investigate whether such errors in the output can be traced
back to problems with the input. We manually annotated 1,837 texts generated by
multiple models in the politics domain of the ToTTo dataset. We identify the
input problems that are responsible for many output errors and show that fixing
these inputs reduces factual errors by between 52% and 76% (depending on the
model). In addition, we observe that models struggle in processing tabular
inputs that are structured in a non-standard way, particularly when the input
lacks distinct row and column values or when the column headers are not
correctly mapped to corresponding values.
|
[
-0.036283277,
-0.7731685638,
0.8964270353,
0.1254856288,
0.0005432698,
-0.2162283659,
-0.3639081419,
-0.336302042,
0.0890198797,
0.6688104868,
-0.5952110887,
-0.5864906907,
-0.9372609854,
0.1621038914,
-0.6362667084,
1.2505844831,
0.1587013602,
0.1660815626,
-0.2935199142,
0.0055165519,
-0.7896205783,
-0.6444402337,
-0.4332410991,
-0.3634519577,
0.7225057483,
0.7483581901,
0.6414641142,
0.8544456959,
0.5697640181,
0.3526067734,
-0.0228681024,
0.3750426471,
-0.6287238002,
0.0704860538,
-0.397151798,
-0.6014090776,
-0.3838544786,
-0.2997030914,
0.7009920478,
0.8357192874,
-0.0536302552,
-0.0137915844,
0.1567286104,
0.760614574,
-0.4638903439,
0.3991561234,
-0.6656216383,
0.1676065028,
-0.3187541664,
-0.4378419518,
-0.8265719414,
-0.4368466437,
-0.1201581135,
-0.5111854076,
0.3679926395,
0.0110957101,
0.9278292656,
0.5921951532,
-0.3373185396,
-0.5642029047,
-1.1026413441,
0.2654143274,
-0.8436245918,
0.3116136193,
0.3689034581,
-0.0108104162,
-0.4373006225,
-0.6460573077,
-0.7366470695,
-0.3312217295,
-0.3909823895,
0.1090576425,
0.08460778,
0.0961060151,
0.4399165809,
-0.1376031786,
-0.3795925677,
-0.0088596167,
-0.4306655228,
-0.1800827086,
0.5709964037,
0.2005066425,
0.2967237532,
-0.3439517617,
0.082289055,
-0.3737097979,
-0.482468307,
-0.112359345,
0.4994366169,
0.6000809073,
0.2328126729,
0.9316975474,
-0.1528956443,
0.8695956469,
0.272244513,
-0.0036016658,
-0.1736316383,
-0.4770806432,
-0.1661171019,
0.4088089764,
0.6912734509,
0.2503892481,
0.0814779773,
-0.4164539576,
-0.3813592494,
0.0259318631,
0.4761812091,
-0.6886409521,
-0.2479378581,
0.33499071,
-0.2535788715,
-0.4490162432,
0.0162237249,
-1.1269489527,
-0.8272738457,
-0.3068535924,
0.7897300124,
-0.1781893075,
0.0319813751,
-0.1592498273,
-0.2396531552,
-0.164788872,
0.4780743122,
-0.8618890047,
0.540184319,
0.5283331871,
0.8559726477,
-0.1090873107,
-0.2693041265,
-0.5926958323,
-0.0991705805,
-0.8333739042,
1.168918848,
-0.1360374391,
-0.1733203977,
-0.0275800806,
-0.1966595501,
-0.2741603553,
-0.7286918163,
0.3593426943,
-0.2535373867,
0.27749753,
-0.9469704628,
-0.5482837558,
-0.0801991299,
0.1361226439,
-0.9704369903,
0.6198089719,
-0.1203754917,
-0.6351248026,
0.3420058489,
-0.871730566,
-0.5100277066,
-0.4721766114,
-0.2432249635,
-0.5133980513,
0.4989443421,
-0.0118412469,
0.4052865803,
-0.3365782201,
0.7797129154,
-0.0304913931,
-0.3021869063,
0.6139181852,
-0.3501390517,
0.6577402949,
-0.2424848229,
-0.4835444987,
0.4384987056,
-1.1856434345,
-0.369541198,
0.1727185249,
-0.255828917,
0.0547857396,
0.3790484071,
0.1048412099,
0.1222414225,
-0.1856812686,
-0.4969552159,
0.0792355612,
-0.2477914542,
0.3828301132,
0.6536929607,
-0.0441732518,
0.4096273482,
-0.5228663087,
-0.1535073221,
0.4011671543,
-0.3601211309,
0.0367804393,
-0.5895501375,
-0.997780323,
0.1731038094,
0.7070778608,
0.6270993352,
-0.88973248,
0.3785980046,
-0.3688105345,
-0.3685483336,
-0.1355752647,
-0.3671576977,
0.0587398,
1.2164565325,
0.3816184103,
-0.1716624051,
-0.2946451306,
-0.8618320227,
-0.2133329511,
-0.227414757,
0.2350201011,
-0.0185810663,
0.7216645479,
0.1717640311,
0.9051535726,
-0.2005668133,
-0.4967137575,
0.1371123046,
0.4342727661,
0.0079073003,
0.545153439,
0.2114252746,
-0.4306510985,
-0.1767594218,
0.0803363398,
-0.6825506091,
0.0469846614,
-0.5015265942,
0.020946715,
0.5022934079,
0.2769307494,
-0.6823108792,
0.7962793708,
0.2197181284,
-0.5173077583,
0.5151057839,
-0.2291146219,
0.3712673783,
-1.1531449556,
0.2061889619,
-0.0923580974,
-0.1005636603,
-0.9657728076,
-0.3752440512,
0.0775924549,
-0.1367056817,
-0.2910914123,
0.1426944286,
-0.0775308385,
-0.206213668,
-0.1049496979,
0.0000463925,
0.1986366361,
0.568128407,
0.1588786095,
0.9337895513,
-0.0715931952,
-0.4582222998,
0.4495034814,
0.3403417468,
-0.2715361118,
0.3402585983,
-0.7631875277,
0.2230090797,
-0.3058444262,
0.0875798389,
-1.5214580297,
-0.4875642657,
0.6701074839,
-0.7474985719,
0.6400263309,
0.0215403438,
-0.5755224824,
0.3186830282,
-0.2060820758,
0.0246521775,
0.1430297345,
-0.5594640374,
0.5715513229,
0.1213807911,
0.011317065,
-0.9241124988,
-1.0074814558,
0.267246455,
0.0449884757,
-0.5508154631,
0.5388777256,
0.3480982184,
-0.115740709,
0.2501430213,
-0.0301399585,
-0.3937700689,
-0.1756830812,
-0.0347944722,
0.1620074362,
-0.1979408264,
0.3796905279,
0.1179606766,
0.1588865817,
0.565870285,
-0.0871154517,
0.5190479159,
0.1756396443,
-0.1056514755,
-0.7305333018,
0.3598954976,
0.6024426818,
0.024266541,
0.9968976974,
0.2825094461,
-0.6624373198,
-0.278367877,
-0.4758248329,
-0.3979712725,
-0.423622191,
0.8261371255,
-0.1452217102,
-0.2568654418,
0.8874346018,
0.2228756696,
0.0588333979,
0.8145862222,
0.5625699759,
-0.271700263,
0.7237812877,
0.4098860919,
0.3587624729,
0.1022576243,
-0.0855493993,
0.1809987724,
-0.4459588826,
-0.6435037851,
-1.0629599094,
-0.3036811948,
-0.6752750278,
-0.2951482832,
0.1305706054,
-0.6666157842,
-0.1377242357,
-0.0262855217,
-0.7011259794,
0.3000981808,
0.5475437045,
0.3646311462,
0.2024898827,
0.2302933484,
0.1662731469,
-0.2862914801,
-1.1487270594,
-0.1997132301,
1.0721626282,
0.2665657699,
0.6232008934,
-0.0292602219,
0.6418952346,
0.2283602953,
0.388916105,
-0.8560121655,
0.3061574101,
-0.3721043468,
-0.7101911306,
-0.4421681762,
-0.6965864897,
-0.5284856558,
-0.1570434868,
-0.4950283468,
-0.7314516902,
0.6720221639,
0.4056858718,
-0.5245572925,
0.5271077752,
-0.6347410679,
0.9026888013,
-0.1508756131,
-0.7289099693,
0.1443561912,
-0.5302926302,
0.5849226713,
-0.0729645342,
-0.0038772214,
0.2163562775,
0.2176867574,
1.1036788225,
-0.5420358181,
1.0602810383,
-0.0585925542,
-0.1489431262,
0.1797147244,
0.0431161001,
0.5728052855,
0.1111174226,
-0.1216752827,
0.3306722045,
-0.0459548347,
-0.0236040894,
-0.7106388211,
0.4397161603,
-0.966385603,
-0.7056676745,
-0.8412591219,
-0.7763870358,
-0.2062969506,
-0.1079529598,
0.8165671825,
0.6995247602,
-0.0055815713,
0.2878444195,
0.9397441745,
-0.2955032587,
0.5410792828,
-0.0949049443,
-0.14366436,
-0.4448177516,
0.9576473236,
0.8304185867,
-0.0452191681,
0.183340326,
0.1179976091,
-0.4788747728,
-0.5231165886,
-0.7350104451,
0.0896795467,
-0.934053719,
-0.43214342,
-0.4891513586,
-0.3405722976,
-0.3167665303,
0.3340731263,
-0.713229537,
-0.6530892849,
-0.6486384869,
0.0618789457,
0.3418141007,
0.9595518708,
0.0006868495,
0.358417064,
-0.6537820101,
0.3908368647,
0.3135509491,
0.4329168499,
-0.0177845564,
-0.9650819898,
0.0925522894,
0.0333443247,
-0.0994657353,
-1.5539534092,
0.2879126966,
0.2134491056,
0.0397471823,
0.0390637368,
-0.0464457348,
0.8414401412,
-0.6652021408,
0.646274507,
0.1504443586,
-1.0970772505,
0.3834522367,
-0.2665005326,
0.1207356825,
0.4997941554,
0.1852265298,
-0.4331870377,
0.0514739268,
-0.3185839057,
-0.3987489641,
0.8407292962,
0.2461800128,
0.1034330726,
0.1784882545,
0.6774174571,
0.1115801111,
0.1513140649,
-0.7731865644,
-0.0528937764,
-0.4446763694,
-0.1292456388,
0.1719502211,
-0.3714630306,
-0.2947879732,
-0.3418400884,
0.5098692775,
0.0466243811,
0.5334607959,
0.4478339553,
0.0094454112,
-0.4549875259,
0.1993410438,
1.1724283695,
0.9069808722,
-0.113824524,
0.0811839253,
0.1618117094,
-0.2665310502,
0.0550717115,
0.0161513127,
-0.483427763,
0.3544638455,
0.2296794504,
0.775120914,
-0.1680804342,
-0.1990989745,
0.2827656865,
-0.1817363501,
-0.4974198937,
-0.2452847511,
-0.0785453841,
0.1765017509,
-0.0124724284,
0.2360454202,
0.630995512,
0.449649483,
-0.8283730745,
0.1314507574,
0.2383453697,
-0.2962464094,
-0.3424169421,
0.7745050788,
0.0408873744,
-0.5763096213,
0.9824845791,
0.0683766752,
-0.6023371816,
0.7902587652,
0.8096109629,
0.5359392166,
-0.1222413629,
0.3130069375,
0.3540406823,
0.6303616166,
-0.2878429294,
0.1997127235,
0.3967622519,
-0.7737320065,
-0.6159344912,
-0.1219318807,
-0.6408808231,
0.3689880669,
-0.616009593,
0.185609594,
-0.653694272,
-0.4486356974,
0.2183370888,
0.0183531754,
-0.523881197,
0.4040484726,
0.0492047109,
0.4427157044,
-1.0465999842,
0.6954994798,
0.5866125226,
-0.4283647537,
-0.8827731609,
-0.155356884,
-0.3217300773,
-0.2720325887,
0.635945797,
-0.0881222561,
0.0033941139,
-0.2310694754,
-0.602437973,
-0.7471103072,
0.4855984747,
0.5975374579,
-0.7515056729,
-0.0979307443,
0.6892647743,
0.4703600705,
-0.1092449352,
-0.0559214838,
0.6646094918,
0.7216388583,
-0.027954882,
-0.6223003268,
0.1318802387,
-0.3282679319,
-0.0324754156,
0.0699265376,
-0.4499623775,
0.8950260282,
-0.0061841477,
0.044831045,
-0.2846057713,
0.7002946138,
0.1701824963,
0.5646140575,
0.253352493,
0.4147855341,
1.0018655062,
-0.5629304051,
0.783026278,
-0.0646558627,
0.1449941844,
1.2698024511,
-0.4393731654,
0.6869027615,
0.6564104557,
0.1885905713,
0.1771623343,
0.6230428815,
-0.2411392331,
0.3649555445,
0.1754397899,
0.2314383984,
0.2157984823,
-0.0699660182,
-0.3059109747,
0.399600327,
0.5931178927,
-0.2713510394,
-0.0828059614,
-0.1658912748,
0.1882096678,
0.2831424773,
-0.0554844029,
0.6883739829,
-0.2467874289,
-0.8967778087,
0.4965336323,
0.0599379949,
0.3112106323,
-0.2520722151,
-0.3846698999,
-0.450520128,
-0.0343537219,
-0.4636928141,
-0.3897415102,
0.8876088858,
0.0611123703,
-0.3847905695,
0.0353762284,
0.8445693851,
-0.4932925999,
-0.5921881795,
-0.0547238663,
0.4656102657,
-0.1282213479,
-0.1355076581,
-0.3409551382,
0.3254185319,
-0.0337577164,
-0.3317030072,
0.0535660349,
0.5284906626,
0.0644056275,
0.1280839592,
0.501046896,
0.1851603091,
0.2331932932,
-0.3782922328,
0.7706781626,
-0.6364895105,
-0.197864309,
-0.9998933673,
0.6276712418,
-0.221839264,
-0.5668615103,
0.3633822799,
0.3101499975,
0.7583481073,
-0.3381643593,
0.5116963387,
0.0019578617,
0.1841734052,
-0.6374031305,
1.3017619848,
-0.5072209239,
0.2411444336,
0.065735653,
-1.1118013859,
-0.4469557703,
0.7663059235,
-0.190666616,
0.0095631769,
1.0322713852,
0.7449898124,
0.1541461796,
-0.0998683274,
0.5282702446,
0.4679590166,
0.0277452115,
0.4437076151,
0.8713101149,
-0.7266908288,
0.386388123,
-0.6154899001,
0.1710894704,
-0.1125710979,
-0.8167792559,
-0.8069061637,
-0.7590513229,
-0.4269090593,
-0.6933979392,
0.4948862791,
0.833614409,
0.6054138541,
-0.9955357909,
-0.3887093663,
-0.1718163639,
0.2040292621,
0.001004929,
-0.1373731494,
0.5729878545,
-0.6316828728,
-0.5911653042,
0.2137589455,
0.0306685176,
-0.2078235149,
0.1047605574,
0.3796427846,
-0.1330940425,
0.3544912934,
0.4419534504,
0.0012522879,
-0.4698063135,
-0.4958527684,
0.2782879472,
-0.1093569398,
0.5118710995,
0.6801769137,
-0.4996826947,
0.4536949992,
0.678445816,
0.9168037772,
0.3174419105,
-0.1139036119,
0.5472773314,
-0.7250240445,
0.0384660922,
0.3074994385,
0.1244424656,
0.47517699,
-0.7193086743,
0.2766157091,
0.3542793691,
-0.5360078812,
-0.9969745278,
-0.2249041647,
-0.8423816562,
-0.3128221929,
0.8107784986,
0.109698914,
-0.5589127541,
0.0659864917,
-0.0156222051,
0.8069785237,
-0.2490426451,
1.2870771885,
1.0037838221,
0.0748042166,
-0.1074674577,
-0.7192369103,
0.8364980221,
0.7087802887,
-1.0859252214,
0.0893594846,
0.5058351755,
0.1908994317,
0.3533073664,
0.261972785,
-0.0839916542,
0.6016889811,
0.2584482431,
0.0170715824,
-0.0219735187,
-0.8280551434,
-0.3954311013,
0.3480457067,
0.0582464039,
-0.0519398712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04102v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04102v2
|
ROPO: Robust Preference Optimization for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-05T13:58:51 | 2024-05-28T17:11:53 |
Xize Liang, Chao Chen, Shuang Qiu, Jie Wang, Yue Wu, Zhihang Fu, Zhihao Shi, Feng Wu, Jieping Ye
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Preference alignment is pivotal for empowering large language models (LLMs)
to generate helpful and harmless responses. However, the performance of
preference alignment is highly sensitive to the prevalent noise in the
preference data. Recent efforts for this problem either marginally alleviate
the impact of noise without the ability to actually reduce its presence, or
rely on costly teacher LLMs prone to reward misgeneralization. To address these
challenges, we propose the RObust Preference Optimization (ROPO) framework, an
iterative alignment approach that integrates noise-tolerance and filtering of
noisy samples without the aid of external models. Specifically, ROPO
iteratively solves a constrained optimization problem, where we dynamically
assign a quality-aware weight for each sample and constrain the sum of the
weights to the number of samples we intend to retain. For noise-tolerant
training and effective noise identification, we derive a robust loss by
suppressing the gradients of samples with high uncertainty. We demonstrate both
empirically and theoretically that the derived loss is critical for
distinguishing noisy samples from clean ones. Furthermore, inspired by our
derived loss, we propose a robustness-guided rejection sampling technique to
compensate for the potential important information in discarded queries.
Experiments on three widely-used datasets with Mistral-7B and Llama-2-7B
demonstrate that ROPO significantly outperforms existing preference alignment
methods, with its superiority growing as the noise rate increases.
|
[
-0.206674695,
-0.3743878305,
0.3207381666,
-0.0231346786,
-0.2574444413,
-0.1456051916,
-0.398694545,
-0.3487912118,
0.0691827163,
0.5230175853,
-0.5255458355,
-0.2346219569,
-0.5632564425,
-0.19904612,
-0.120505169,
0.7855241895,
0.1551679522,
0.0949598923,
-0.2838457823,
-0.1362655461,
-0.3028470874,
-0.157184273,
-0.5660582185,
-0.3438146412,
0.4793038964,
0.6383653879,
0.7739318609,
0.9823363423,
0.4141136408,
0.1788949072,
-0.2193559259,
0.2039916515,
-0.6867032647,
0.4852314293,
-0.0551144965,
-0.529060185,
-0.4153369069,
-0.1718160063,
0.6842572093,
0.6105493307,
-0.2299667597,
0.125464946,
0.2416881621,
0.696457088,
-0.8267764449,
-0.1855468303,
-0.8694769144,
0.2231862396,
-0.2297352105,
-0.1658352613,
-0.3696669042,
-0.4501832128,
0.0441295914,
-0.7034929395,
0.0215477888,
0.1174028665,
1.0747404099,
0.4544257522,
-0.0107780928,
-0.1929460019,
-0.6311291456,
1.2104967833,
-0.5318229198,
0.4796164334,
0.7456731796,
0.0087536694,
-0.3726846576,
-0.0737829879,
-0.350143373,
-0.006234216,
0.2416548878,
0.2014157176,
0.0492351837,
-0.1757212877,
-0.141765371,
0.3183674216,
-0.5402072072,
0.2894048393,
-0.1351890564,
-0.4013175666,
0.3392424881,
-0.1539622545,
0.0206647199,
0.1196230203,
-0.2123705745,
-0.0732747912,
-0.5264016986,
0.2446481586,
0.8786600828,
0.6759490371,
0.146247834,
0.3997085989,
-0.0811428726,
0.892383039,
0.1719125062,
-0.6320726871,
0.1027635932,
-0.2404798418,
0.0401262604,
-0.0169867054,
0.9563987255,
0.355157584,
0.2875211835,
0.0520959795,
-0.2483169585,
-0.0073507247,
0.185219422,
-0.5596854687,
-0.1419745088,
0.2757194042,
-0.5922501087,
-0.6602973342,
-0.2849531174,
-0.8927810788,
-0.3812895119,
-0.2327119261,
0.1670072228,
-0.3237999976,
-0.2067763209,
0.1943413615,
0.1550623924,
0.1031534746,
0.23406519,
-1.137188673,
0.0995554104,
0.7071293592,
0.6448985934,
-0.2211440206,
-0.1436106116,
-0.8742290139,
-0.0110411281,
-0.5123866796,
0.9373128414,
-0.7959010601,
-0.4312264919,
-0.0924098566,
-0.4279920459,
0.0442056395,
-0.7489678264,
1.0391360521,
-0.5048597455,
0.2792326212,
-0.3007487953,
-0.3616029918,
0.2180623859,
0.2465227693,
-0.3887472153,
1.1130281687,
0.0616898462,
-0.6446223855,
0.6606174111,
-0.1145364121,
-0.3587881923,
-0.4506024122,
0.0963530689,
-0.8634387255,
0.1232802197,
0.093322061,
0.02152179,
-0.3058375418,
0.1579331756,
-0.6758724451,
-0.2832331955,
0.1902127415,
-0.1829572022,
0.7479640841,
0.4179074466,
-0.0054907822,
0.4335440993,
-0.9601257443,
0.1033622921,
0.0567026511,
-0.3333430588,
-0.4912755787,
0.27504462,
-0.2689268887,
-0.0391554683,
0.1841396689,
-0.2207794487,
0.2413859516,
-0.2471494824,
0.4371220767,
1.059348464,
-0.3966940939,
0.6721284986,
-0.3030813634,
0.4937966466,
-0.2391417921,
0.4482286572,
0.3858973384,
-0.3407734931,
-0.5007840395,
-0.6110648513,
0.2547176778,
0.4604479373,
-0.1020364091,
0.6639422774,
-0.3222678602,
-0.260896951,
-0.6652839184,
0.4694210887,
0.1062676013,
0.9665475488,
0.2383399755,
-0.251827687,
-0.3725431859,
-1.0016485453,
-0.2400913686,
-0.3299131393,
-0.0356732123,
0.256996423,
-0.146149829,
-0.0766974613,
0.8734437227,
-0.380186677,
-0.4143880308,
-0.0049244156,
-0.2843132913,
0.1759087294,
0.4672240317,
0.4394331872,
-0.6120680571,
-0.5252162814,
-0.1084459275,
-0.1523496509,
-0.5248194337,
0.1300274283,
-0.3838962317,
0.0040265974,
0.1499483138,
-0.1245281249,
-0.0110026868,
0.5545409918,
0.0348337293,
0.3814860582,
0.0657208413,
-0.1206801832,
-1.0503749847,
0.077583082,
-0.1739462763,
-0.3166165054,
-0.3860207796,
-0.2908028066,
-0.0099283773,
-0.0191006847,
0.0048558102,
0.3261310458,
-0.3721711636,
-0.1453750879,
-0.4076351225,
0.1480729729,
0.1175390407,
0.2028865367,
0.3060728312,
0.7737539411,
0.6753168702,
-0.5190219879,
0.0112296948,
0.2545289397,
-0.1773867905,
0.651379168,
-0.3780287206,
0.1586287469,
-0.1555111408,
0.0782055855,
-0.9858933687,
-0.1268056035,
0.5200806856,
-0.4496154785,
0.3022237122,
-0.4460158348,
-0.0902052447,
0.0656462088,
-0.5779277682,
0.3804807961,
0.4071356654,
-0.5005276203,
0.3923750818,
0.4016553164,
-0.2169054151,
-1.0562318563,
-0.4104709327,
-0.2699044645,
-0.4875096679,
-0.3275299966,
0.099350065,
-0.0443735197,
-0.2081987262,
-0.1286206543,
-0.4362593591,
-0.045540709,
0.150347814,
0.1257768571,
0.390856564,
-0.0714467987,
0.0221005231,
-0.0982262567,
-0.379170388,
-0.1857860088,
-0.4777521193,
0.6483916044,
0.1315829158,
-0.2481475323,
-0.4131736755,
0.3776063621,
0.6326213479,
-0.1780195385,
0.440923512,
0.5007695556,
-0.2163239866,
-0.2878424525,
-0.3809796274,
-0.1134899929,
-0.4445037246,
0.2547947764,
-0.35971573,
-0.7286522985,
0.5895371437,
0.1343257874,
0.2523127198,
0.1268227994,
0.3173950613,
0.0238259006,
0.8124307394,
0.4400910437,
-0.5161325932,
0.8647715449,
0.227236405,
0.4293383658,
-0.6426635981,
0.1046763808,
-0.9946408868,
-0.3219839931,
-0.3611107767,
-0.1738996506,
0.123778969,
0.1762763411,
-0.2048991323,
0.1154807061,
-0.7262134552,
0.3898693621,
0.834946692,
-0.1071924865,
0.3810378015,
0.2910938859,
0.174525097,
-0.3480756879,
-0.6582086682,
-0.5120152235,
1.066696763,
0.2556273937,
1.1100329161,
0.2111812234,
0.6162551641,
0.0198755078,
0.0947122425,
-1.1507070065,
0.2959564328,
-0.1160874143,
-0.3082464337,
-0.2947680652,
-0.4955761135,
-0.8013189435,
0.2120612413,
-0.4602517188,
-0.8296642303,
0.4916538596,
0.5005045533,
-0.3798846602,
0.2189151496,
-0.5102428198,
0.4944393337,
-0.1609126329,
-0.7555785179,
-0.0301574934,
-0.6944292784,
0.243908897,
-0.0091643678,
0.2548273206,
-0.1967713237,
-0.0131133078,
0.5536835194,
-0.3146733642,
0.5694594383,
-0.0391741171,
-0.2681533694,
0.1381853521,
0.1309110224,
0.6387112737,
-0.0126409167,
-0.4018575549,
-0.0078507829,
-0.0005808003,
-0.3622658253,
-0.33570081,
0.845980823,
-0.8231976628,
-0.4199873805,
-0.2810265124,
-0.6891670823,
-0.3738627136,
0.4265762568,
0.5281232595,
0.1381971687,
0.2442815155,
0.1175914258,
0.8128329515,
-0.1046894267,
0.1622444987,
0.270494312,
-0.184325248,
-0.6103708744,
1.1437090635,
0.1432044059,
0.4970625937,
0.3774814904,
0.6083566546,
-0.4031959176,
-0.7288865447,
-0.2993313968,
0.0855080262,
-0.4678165615,
-0.2122445107,
-0.3771647513,
0.2667696178,
-0.5486595631,
-0.3049578965,
-0.7442510724,
-0.324747622,
-0.2610604167,
0.0425563008,
0.0574517697,
0.1713539213,
-0.1859078109,
0.225478977,
-0.3646059632,
0.3105476499,
0.2851932943,
0.5867874026,
-0.3101865649,
-0.6625711322,
0.1780832708,
-0.2259698957,
-0.1135359704,
-0.588899076,
0.4187070727,
0.293573916,
0.4207995236,
0.8394367695,
0.4467889369,
0.7798893452,
-0.103016831,
0.5709997416,
-0.1362723261,
-0.7797368169,
0.5558910966,
-0.4664444625,
-0.0761921331,
0.9020067453,
0.154346779,
-0.1580597758,
-0.2206716388,
-0.4502739906,
-0.9830345511,
0.6334832907,
-0.1275943816,
-0.0086715156,
0.2539580464,
0.542499423,
0.1937437952,
0.2497362047,
-0.7893653512,
-0.2535649538,
-0.1825633049,
-0.262264967,
0.2089402527,
-0.515417695,
-0.4499387741,
0.109584935,
1.0069098473,
-0.3700869083,
0.1296172291,
0.1081235483,
0.1955318898,
-0.3329083622,
0.3320679665,
0.647051692,
0.3522078097,
-0.4466298521,
0.1463513225,
-0.3026496768,
-0.4400058091,
0.0459581167,
-0.1068005636,
-0.4465007484,
-0.2255123407,
0.1198916882,
0.6449879408,
-0.2209464461,
-0.6106470823,
0.3762820661,
-0.0714825094,
-0.1575936675,
-0.0600773543,
0.0949078724,
-0.1193602905,
-0.2108153552,
0.0897686258,
0.2162527442,
0.2691784501,
-0.3638795614,
-0.056634374,
0.703186214,
-0.6400014162,
-0.0989426002,
0.7054279447,
-0.017051572,
-0.2324226052,
0.3573962152,
0.1323542148,
-0.3542654812,
0.2718208432,
0.5457572341,
0.7159771919,
-0.1906321645,
-0.0428639129,
0.4126873314,
0.272374779,
-0.3342640698,
0.1469861418,
-0.2764457166,
-1.0745152235,
-0.142965436,
-0.5225687623,
-0.5623515844,
0.1178898588,
-0.9221072197,
0.2516049147,
-0.608708322,
-0.1426188201,
-0.2528479397,
-0.175452888,
-0.028429687,
0.0021907266,
-0.2281978279,
0.4756138027,
-0.812553823,
0.7016773224,
0.6378526688,
0.1028958037,
-0.7165452242,
0.1801894158,
0.3688696921,
-0.9056658745,
0.1339981258,
-0.1746611595,
-0.3916299343,
-0.1835937947,
-0.5543148518,
-0.9982517362,
0.5776304007,
0.7075842023,
-0.5178762674,
0.544041574,
-0.087528497,
0.2348935157,
-0.1392066628,
-0.0577446483,
0.3295753896,
0.4885900915,
0.3076183498,
-0.7960240841,
-0.2348376513,
-0.029938573,
-0.1500634551,
0.3348993659,
-1.0122343302,
0.4794745743,
-0.1140103415,
0.0091967573,
0.0884589478,
0.5670437217,
0.3437899351,
0.0797886029,
0.7714075446,
0.51756531,
1.047898531,
-0.0902323648,
0.6607834697,
-0.2893866897,
0.2765306234,
1.2800590992,
-0.4780390561,
0.7881845832,
0.8480034471,
-0.1800458431,
-0.0740016922,
0.8664785028,
0.3167207241,
0.6693303585,
0.1745412499,
-0.2835387588,
-0.5216146708,
-0.4415631592,
-0.3578872681,
0.3256908059,
0.0840170011,
-0.1871675551,
0.0921507105,
-0.2865395546,
0.0307939537,
0.3081784844,
-0.0504902899,
0.7451750636,
-0.1458119899,
-0.8110156655,
0.5469419956,
-0.29533571,
0.8076253533,
-0.7960031033,
0.3535516262,
-0.3077582419,
0.3656611741,
-0.260938406,
-0.5112169385,
0.4178721309,
-0.2951418757,
-0.4799179137,
-0.3350273967,
0.7598569393,
-0.4706828892,
-0.3058482409,
0.2258414179,
0.1174010113,
-0.1581358016,
0.1528371274,
-0.496958524,
0.3927877545,
0.256475538,
-0.2706617117,
0.5761181116,
0.1350263208,
-0.0938662216,
0.8444091678,
0.5981171727,
0.3542919457,
-0.1443658769,
0.0291421786,
0.6385350823,
-0.2471938282,
-0.4698989391,
-0.6018747091,
0.2577735186,
-0.0155226961,
-0.3879380226,
0.4336605966,
0.5624023676,
0.6485554576,
0.074570924,
0.7922782302,
0.1328656077,
0.6441345215,
-0.3864168823,
0.4431600571,
-0.6234127879,
0.4629382193,
-0.352389127,
-1.0109399557,
-0.5527373552,
1.022331357,
-0.1139230877,
-0.1647897512,
0.2072431445,
1.1278232336,
-0.1030279398,
-0.2501426041,
0.2545743287,
-0.0989322066,
0.3968319893,
0.2893072367,
0.5343493819,
-0.2887927294,
0.6290689111,
-0.309838593,
-0.2606380582,
-0.1569020152,
-1.0169892311,
-0.3824960291,
-0.3886938989,
-0.4445330799,
-0.4862388074,
-0.0291407071,
1.006229043,
0.7720935345,
-0.883615315,
-0.1987736523,
0.0805046037,
0.4299039841,
-0.4036781192,
-0.2547678053,
0.3157242239,
-0.3514797986,
-1.0778113604,
0.4791480601,
0.2688612342,
0.0299940556,
0.0371797495,
-0.0251942165,
0.03041902,
-0.0689766929,
0.2866262197,
0.5877635479,
-0.5929628611,
-0.4908359647,
0.1454919279,
-0.0587172061,
0.1430784911,
0.6561191678,
-0.3503265977,
0.6559644938,
0.617411375,
0.6111359596,
-0.0341298543,
0.1431568116,
0.720919013,
-0.4797430336,
0.28080073,
0.1690886468,
0.3733540475,
0.2707965076,
-0.4324797094,
0.4856256247,
0.2175844014,
-0.7074635029,
-1.0945943594,
0.2248330116,
-1.2609535456,
-0.0203999691,
1.2204385996,
0.0832074583,
-0.0497195795,
-0.1799353212,
-0.3634583652,
-0.1346449107,
-0.7510851026,
0.9816753864,
0.8361235857,
-0.2493586689,
-0.2144432068,
-0.3317250013,
0.5608888865,
0.7904121876,
-0.2486859709,
0.2524160147,
0.7043095231,
0.3972457051,
0.1725606322,
0.6326271296,
-0.1901497394,
-0.0650862679,
-0.1453990191,
0.049474597,
0.0412489027,
-0.0423104465,
-0.3581439853,
0.4394976795,
0.5200122595,
-0.3502836227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04068v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04068v2
|
Assessing the quality of information extraction
| 2024-04-05T12:51:48 | 2024-05-22T09:04:52 |
Filip Seitl, Tomáš Kovářík, Soheyla Mirshahi, Jan Kryštůfek, Rastislav Dujava, Matúš Ondreička, Herbert Ullrich, Petr Gronat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Advances in large language models have notably enhanced the efficiency of
information extraction from unstructured and semi-structured data sources. As
these technologies become integral to various applications, establishing an
objective measure for the quality of information extraction becomes imperative.
However, the scarcity of labeled data presents significant challenges to this
endeavor. In this paper, we introduce an automatic framework to assess the
quality of the information extraction/retrieval and its completeness. The
framework focuses on information extraction in the form of entity and its
properties. We discuss how to handle the input/output size limitations of the
large language models and analyze their performance when extracting the
information. In particular, we introduce scores to evaluate the quality of the
extraction and provide an extensive discussion on how to interpret them.
|
[
-0.3713355958,
-0.9146835804,
0.5977212191,
0.1943923384,
-0.2423132211,
0.0349720977,
-0.427913934,
-0.6574652791,
-0.0087071694,
0.4838262498,
0.2217914909,
-0.4815168083,
-0.9501484632,
0.1073528379,
-0.7756764889,
0.8169539571,
-0.1966266781,
-0.1279877275,
-0.0672880709,
0.0733609572,
-0.476639837,
-0.2763470709,
-0.4390003383,
-0.1264596581,
-0.039198976,
0.3771461844,
0.819145143,
1.1699364185,
0.8422697186,
0.3873540461,
0.1666970849,
-0.0380681939,
-0.3659215868,
0.2525390387,
-0.5722426772,
-0.0458366424,
-0.301897347,
0.2004981041,
0.9201673865,
0.7643233538,
-0.2815665007,
0.687233448,
0.1336035281,
0.171894148,
-0.5171837807,
0.4775504768,
-0.4257477522,
-0.0222606715,
-0.1533623487,
-0.3058975935,
-0.3699380159,
-0.4136137664,
0.3266704679,
-0.3736081421,
0.000694285,
0.2062708735,
1.2080298662,
0.2107230127,
-0.3311467469,
-0.6151904464,
-1.0124270916,
0.859534204,
-0.4677830935,
0.5092014074,
0.3545924127,
0.4651429653,
-0.1128675863,
-0.8240013719,
-0.4863098562,
-0.2194770724,
-0.0079267686,
-0.0789879858,
-0.2584967315,
0.0121605219,
0.1985385418,
0.7191095948,
-0.3827971518,
0.0671495497,
-0.4146673679,
-0.1586607993,
0.7324703336,
-0.205289498,
0.5201393366,
-0.5099899769,
-0.2286029756,
-0.0430245772,
-0.0987916738,
-0.0629107729,
0.3908580244,
0.1568408161,
0.5451520085,
0.8647548556,
-0.2723169327,
0.6690989137,
-0.1005854234,
-0.3207070827,
0.0215341188,
-0.5711035728,
-0.4630050659,
-0.0700793192,
0.7697528601,
0.0950695872,
-0.0017968611,
-0.4869987071,
-0.7050993443,
-0.4608234465,
0.248704806,
-0.7599995732,
-0.2239460498,
0.3149535358,
-0.8072735071,
-0.088146396,
0.4135187566,
-1.0751316547,
-0.0930458754,
-0.4697727561,
0.5929469466,
-0.3091848493,
-0.5105934143,
-0.0841780603,
-0.2243843377,
0.0822365731,
0.2995782495,
-0.6417417526,
0.3890246153,
0.4516404867,
0.6752021909,
-0.6067196131,
0.3316989243,
-0.7578675151,
-0.0412717685,
-0.279237777,
0.7524104118,
-0.7307692766,
-0.0435405001,
-0.3302751482,
-0.0129314372,
0.1433326602,
-0.8114843965,
0.6338297725,
-0.7117622495,
0.144231528,
0.0173913911,
-0.8166444302,
-0.2072766423,
0.1701111197,
-1.0266896486,
1.1369229555,
0.5635330677,
-0.3580429256,
0.3673992157,
-0.6474283338,
-0.2636707127,
0.3438277543,
0.001815478,
-0.0788556561,
0.1010672152,
0.0591448061,
0.3577445149,
-0.7495976686,
0.6156132817,
-0.1724419296,
-0.1191538721,
0.3347720504,
-0.3185127676,
0.6496827602,
0.3882547319,
-0.3147974312,
-0.1852447391,
-1.0518833399,
0.3758106232,
-0.0395391658,
-0.824803412,
-0.2098634094,
-0.0225397963,
0.0819529295,
0.2666561306,
0.4984617829,
-0.6399719715,
0.0701260194,
-0.275464803,
0.31507653,
0.5350536108,
0.2111707032,
0.5940902233,
0.2573966086,
0.3904174268,
-0.2017628402,
0.2031358033,
0.2348425239,
0.0414114371,
-0.7516261935,
-0.6437812448,
1.022351265,
0.5456288457,
-0.6679530144,
0.963724792,
-0.4580671787,
-0.5160064697,
-0.6027467251,
0.4203038216,
0.1863999963,
0.3874170184,
0.4295695126,
-0.5550391078,
-0.345343262,
-0.7544472218,
0.0156579744,
-0.1221164837,
-0.2731332481,
0.1034225821,
0.4710858464,
0.0956195742,
1.0579184294,
-0.2447016686,
-0.0176658612,
-0.2062740177,
0.4294103384,
0.3538235426,
0.6018663049,
0.0273402706,
-1.0632888079,
-0.0195269696,
0.0440219007,
-1.0648514032,
-0.2028989941,
-0.0629124194,
-0.2197817862,
-0.3131111562,
0.1195961684,
-0.6821640134,
0.4329496324,
0.1759370118,
-0.0314145945,
0.4079496861,
0.0405979864,
0.3738567531,
-0.6475907564,
0.5841220617,
0.1467128843,
-0.3301213384,
-0.3465891778,
0.215089947,
-0.0399553664,
-0.0962187499,
-0.1494004577,
0.4543889463,
-0.7247571349,
-0.7038806677,
-0.1049645841,
0.3711463809,
0.3657859266,
0.1147015393,
0.013738025,
0.5739360452,
0.1093754768,
-0.6505224705,
0.718396008,
0.0404511504,
-0.6726464033,
0.5501198173,
-0.6164988875,
-0.010706638,
-0.288015753,
-0.2379982173,
-0.8133813739,
-0.3249106109,
-0.0547967479,
-0.3668293953,
0.581253469,
-0.1411575675,
-0.9486575127,
-0.2571790218,
0.0393009298,
-0.0364922434,
0.3035656512,
-0.3769344389,
0.5723286867,
0.7494303584,
-0.4655614495,
-0.5267736316,
-0.0995498002,
0.1492504776,
-0.2065007389,
-0.390835464,
-0.0093083968,
0.0495997332,
-0.4625467658,
0.290507406,
-0.1629020125,
-0.5486192107,
0.3867753744,
-0.0998473763,
0.4028817415,
-0.2973969281,
0.4688543975,
0.071853891,
0.0728987679,
0.0460540205,
-0.3825679421,
0.2763231993,
0.1276889592,
-0.1728258431,
-0.36876598,
0.4342778623,
0.3628952205,
-0.4838156104,
0.4679864943,
0.4218331575,
-0.7160990238,
0.1131369025,
-0.5354585648,
0.1393784285,
-0.3307838738,
0.5536656976,
-0.2732530534,
-0.4077829719,
0.2753501236,
-0.1433817595,
-0.0099722212,
0.8311175704,
0.1753435731,
0.0215867907,
1.0336787701,
0.7508792281,
0.0263586696,
0.3153129816,
-0.1434905529,
0.4005897045,
-0.536739707,
-0.3544074595,
-0.8155984879,
0.0293089673,
-0.0976923853,
0.0349417329,
0.1750725508,
0.7263620496,
-0.0131981643,
0.4781564176,
-0.6657932401,
0.3353501856,
0.306435436,
-0.1531374156,
0.5186855197,
0.0130948946,
0.2792581916,
0.0860608742,
-0.1779331267,
-0.9923166037,
0.9764274955,
0.5686024427,
0.4710499048,
0.308408618,
0.4626865089,
0.6166218519,
0.39165622,
-0.785333395,
0.2559110522,
0.0305957999,
-0.7058600187,
-0.5811988711,
-0.7491064072,
-0.8124153614,
0.0175869334,
-0.3250986636,
-1.1254817247,
0.2497639954,
-0.119337,
-0.3602969348,
-0.0371749699,
-0.6202472448,
0.800581634,
-0.301063627,
-0.3228218853,
0.22760351,
-0.4768695831,
0.3173066676,
-0.4805791676,
0.2389997542,
-0.2715182006,
-0.0116139511,
1.0308308601,
-0.1155788153,
0.085505873,
-0.1741919667,
-0.0859619454,
0.451751858,
0.2385550141,
0.3802257478,
-0.056910377,
-0.4160764813,
0.1998877078,
0.3884754181,
-0.231799379,
-0.845774889,
0.3211954236,
-0.4860245883,
-0.1977692693,
-0.1184065491,
-0.2256260514,
-0.0241093654,
0.6867280602,
0.2907583416,
0.3557653725,
-0.2270220369,
0.0384660847,
0.5747209787,
-0.3411435187,
0.2546418011,
0.3704717755,
-0.1681669056,
-0.2397494018,
1.1628623009,
0.5551573634,
0.0446972996,
0.3081128597,
-0.1345051527,
-0.7342444658,
-0.5741184354,
-0.6847115159,
-0.0389657058,
-0.9503349662,
-0.4121483266,
-0.6873236895,
-0.4300373495,
-0.3336620629,
0.6818115711,
-0.3894073665,
-0.4085889161,
-0.4968736768,
-0.1603775024,
-0.2529877424,
0.9534862041,
0.0548566356,
-0.0011559223,
-1.0207433701,
0.1456515938,
0.1001913473,
0.2934012711,
-0.1147290021,
-0.4891610742,
-0.1341446936,
-0.1931369156,
-0.0556373969,
-0.8121610284,
0.3620714247,
0.0452805571,
0.7399571538,
0.4092843533,
0.1016500592,
0.4726388752,
-0.0944127738,
0.6976071,
-0.002739311,
-1.1059987545,
0.5958146453,
0.200829193,
-0.3056896031,
0.5746864676,
0.4839862287,
0.0064370297,
-0.2835132778,
-0.7860949636,
-0.8067940474,
0.4914620817,
0.2041142285,
-0.2599335015,
-0.0454157777,
0.4473296702,
0.1458064467,
0.4559563696,
-0.6080805659,
0.0899160802,
-0.0669541955,
-0.4011189938,
0.137821123,
-0.4724195898,
0.1374972314,
0.096583873,
0.4871933758,
0.1698326916,
0.2537959516,
0.1191253439,
-0.5555413961,
-0.098668389,
0.4697782993,
-0.0894166455,
1.1115413904,
-0.254014194,
0.3642647564,
-0.2230017334,
-0.2028776854,
0.1472162455,
0.3189466,
-0.0774183571,
0.1125011593,
0.5338946581,
0.2683242559,
-0.1738312244,
-0.758297503,
0.7059063911,
-0.1053223312,
0.3271409273,
-0.1591528356,
0.0881442875,
-0.4648502767,
0.1336600035,
0.4790993929,
-0.3343757987,
0.7162291408,
-0.474078089,
0.5131366253,
0.1526443958,
-0.3828830421,
-0.1215085909,
0.1212450638,
-0.0426310971,
-0.0949072763,
0.9256403446,
-0.3026609719,
-0.2175707519,
0.5302456617,
0.2649578452,
0.2625779808,
-0.1505133957,
0.0842881873,
0.5773627162,
0.4718834162,
-0.3413554132,
0.0068059266,
-0.2386342138,
-0.4995253086,
-0.578399837,
-0.8824272156,
-0.0568989329,
0.2646238804,
-0.9477241635,
0.0374723449,
-0.2564745843,
-0.2919550836,
0.3496293724,
0.2112389803,
-0.7546782494,
0.4906667471,
-0.200350821,
0.8181608915,
-0.643212378,
0.6748908758,
0.2835868895,
-0.7423827648,
-0.8599567413,
-0.2895087004,
-0.2908317149,
-0.5102315545,
0.9025449157,
0.0357556753,
0.1541867554,
0.0329986401,
-0.6355204582,
-1.1895129681,
0.75845474,
0.4864660203,
-0.3576872945,
-0.012799846,
-0.0714985579,
0.4886276424,
-0.1971642375,
0.4233268797,
1.046086669,
0.6503894925,
-0.1042301506,
-0.9967753291,
0.0943141356,
-0.3343396485,
-0.0619277582,
0.1849778295,
0.142185837,
0.7264533043,
0.2185094357,
-0.8285210729,
0.0435572341,
0.7161821723,
-0.5815418363,
-0.0308303647,
0.5076498389,
0.1749701649,
1.2238906622,
-0.0085785864,
0.9444924593,
-0.0608662665,
0.5621262789,
1.0133981705,
-0.2483247966,
0.9630633593,
0.1690459847,
-0.0417254902,
0.0473482497,
0.6810357571,
-0.2421571016,
0.2077589482,
0.286896944,
-0.0125497095,
-0.2549009621,
-0.3728524148,
-0.0390146188,
0.7706377506,
0.4169802368,
-0.6919506788,
-0.2585805357,
0.0284261499,
-0.0560803674,
-0.1040335596,
-0.0831976309,
0.9895134568,
-0.2426807731,
-0.8700438738,
0.3486971259,
0.2593339086,
-0.0098893698,
-0.1189652234,
-0.4278094769,
-0.0608047433,
-0.2797220647,
-0.261762172,
-1.0000135899,
0.3108769655,
0.1603429317,
-0.3508623838,
0.1579436064,
0.6610481739,
-0.4417444468,
-0.4002162218,
0.4064263999,
0.467142731,
0.6651093364,
-0.0462266617,
-0.5508633256,
0.0927861258,
-0.0784713328,
-0.2005221099,
0.1694274396,
0.5602591634,
0.0674707443,
0.4612608254,
0.5371392369,
0.4073177278,
-0.0899025574,
-0.3829855025,
0.6243857741,
-0.6013147831,
-0.062437322,
-0.7196475863,
0.2450630665,
-0.6644051075,
-0.2206867188,
0.4599048495,
0.6077697873,
0.5632959008,
0.509439826,
0.7683262229,
-0.3563863635,
0.4994159937,
-0.604257524,
0.6124199629,
-0.4574588239,
0.2911807895,
-0.2535591722,
-1.3075093031,
-0.0028282157,
0.5610210896,
-0.1848880649,
-0.1733203828,
0.5993263721,
0.5679876804,
-0.2683491409,
-0.037513461,
0.2445578724,
0.1173902154,
0.316531688,
0.2650018334,
0.8264569044,
-0.3572221994,
0.5987575054,
-0.0078867385,
-0.6834370494,
0.0197565816,
-0.78743577,
-0.3776554465,
-0.6469262242,
-0.2900940478,
-0.5079504251,
-0.2411630452,
0.7565267682,
0.7422066927,
-0.6618050337,
0.0644559935,
0.3725027442,
0.2219922096,
0.0175491963,
-0.3305991888,
0.6378551126,
-0.2632343471,
-0.663525641,
0.2780889273,
0.4896028042,
-0.0006537003,
-0.1718478948,
0.3201642931,
-0.1394331604,
-0.0833378211,
0.538356781,
0.3575371206,
-0.2855912149,
-0.5075709224,
-0.2471300811,
-0.4051616788,
0.2223710418,
0.4208477736,
-0.1856704354,
0.6124994159,
0.3471240103,
0.9182828665,
0.2881380022,
0.1832286716,
0.5782257915,
-0.5119704604,
-0.4832998216,
0.1751112044,
0.2430524528,
0.4072425961,
-0.5177340508,
0.5456389189,
-0.0259581394,
-0.4962872565,
-0.8677478433,
-0.1839085519,
-0.7680894136,
-0.1534550041,
1.1777163744,
-0.55706954,
-0.4076144695,
-0.3728863299,
-0.0983488783,
0.5542513132,
-0.3468984365,
0.7203857899,
0.9391144514,
0.0137470067,
0.0048814211,
-0.7602065802,
0.1917050183,
-0.1023669541,
-1.0470525026,
-0.116603002,
0.5690724254,
0.3830382526,
0.4680709839,
0.6277970076,
-0.3850162029,
0.0451819003,
-0.2636121809,
0.3560162783,
0.2917658985,
-0.4663952589,
-0.2207262963,
0.572668016,
0.2099230289,
-0.1316471696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04067v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04067v3
|
CLUE: A Clinical Language Understanding Evaluation for LLMs
| 2024-04-05T12:51:37 | 2024-06-24T12:32:41 |
Amin Dada, Marie Bauer, Amanda Butler Contreras, Osman Alperen Koraş, Constantin Marc Seibold, Kaleb E Smith, Jens Kleesiek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are expected to significantly contribute to
patient care, diagnostics, and administrative processes. Emerging biomedical
LLMs aim to address healthcare-specific challenges, including privacy demands
and computational constraints. Assessing the models' suitability for this
sensitive application area is of the utmost importance. However, evaluation has
primarily been limited to non-clinical tasks, which do not reflect the
complexity of practical clinical applications. To fill this gap, we present the
Clinical Language Understanding Evaluation (CLUE), a benchmark tailored to
evaluate LLMs on clinical tasks. CLUE includes six tasks to test the practical
applicability of LLMs in complex healthcare settings. Our evaluation includes a
total of $25$ LLMs. In contrast to previous evaluations, CLUE shows a decrease
in performance for nine out of twelve biomedical models. Our benchmark
represents a step towards a standardized approach to evaluating and developing
LLMs in healthcare to align future model development with the real-world needs
of clinical application. We open-source all evaluation scripts and datasets for
future research at https://github.com/TIO-IKIM/CLUE.
|
[
0.2952552438,
-0.4731577635,
0.9941796064,
0.3871473968,
-0.4452428818,
0.0231979936,
-0.3707352281,
-0.641700089,
-0.0145014375,
0.3225079477,
-0.6698914766,
-1.0887024403,
-0.7777876258,
0.2274816632,
-0.2257292271,
0.6664646864,
-0.009034005,
0.5046252608,
-0.6516622901,
-0.1225106344,
-0.4963631034,
-0.0669146404,
-0.6188148856,
-0.4600160718,
0.5616647601,
0.1461483389,
0.3001006544,
0.8983255029,
0.9124878049,
0.2510179281,
-0.1863840967,
0.0332548469,
-0.6128748059,
0.127451539,
-0.0982864648,
-0.6923673153,
-0.6138505936,
-0.0667826459,
0.4888968468,
1.0792880058,
-0.1387441903,
0.2170946449,
-0.4053583145,
0.5526077151,
-0.6662434936,
0.4111355245,
-0.5998410583,
-0.0373999178,
-0.2425552458,
-0.1091210097,
-0.4024706781,
-0.3061125875,
0.3548046052,
-0.59542799,
0.2549358308,
-0.0790238157,
0.4028171599,
0.3061571419,
-0.3232095838,
-0.5794532895,
-0.1777897924,
0.6157123446,
-0.9438364506,
0.5842968225,
0.2855057418,
0.3876267374,
-0.2463238835,
-0.8235659599,
-0.2108626664,
-0.3663164973,
-0.0269109402,
0.2465098947,
-0.0577137358,
0.2703473568,
0.2154259235,
0.3271925747,
-0.7607364058,
0.292430222,
-0.2071095705,
-0.2757237852,
0.5956757665,
0.4478531778,
0.3681343794,
-0.0111289565,
-0.3062930405,
0.2507157624,
-0.7886382937,
-0.0094589954,
-0.3508126438,
0.3438529074,
-0.4895876944,
0.4161815345,
-0.1528578699,
0.7216669321,
-0.4190619886,
-0.5077783465,
0.2100286931,
-0.3525637388,
-0.3788212538,
0.0674711168,
0.7891893983,
0.5385793447,
-0.0231290106,
-0.4925172031,
-0.0393144451,
0.3270339966,
0.0533727184,
-0.8360695243,
-0.1165443286,
0.5330094695,
-0.4828553498,
-0.3038073778,
-0.5411875248,
-0.4738677144,
-0.8125438094,
-0.0014899812,
0.106892556,
-0.5247698426,
0.0247053523,
0.5366681218,
-0.017855579,
0.2511745691,
0.4816979766,
-0.5911324024,
0.2614875734,
0.9647740722,
0.9803752899,
-0.2546958625,
0.0187701657,
-0.6216655374,
0.0061533824,
-0.2865410149,
0.8914294243,
-0.5552398562,
-0.6178051829,
0.0339138284,
-0.0721695498,
-0.3373072147,
-0.7130619884,
0.8644081354,
-0.270973593,
-0.2316268086,
-0.2365216911,
-0.8961650133,
0.19304052,
0.2104464173,
-0.4316189587,
0.525587976,
0.0892286673,
-0.5739099383,
0.469637841,
-0.6537476182,
-0.3639567792,
0.6269621253,
-0.3737546802,
-0.2311274111,
0.2572653294,
0.1039954424,
0.3112154007,
-0.7360793352,
0.3353342414,
-0.5688919425,
-0.5083603859,
0.4632763565,
0.0066206777,
0.6990212798,
0.1728913188,
-0.1285669208,
0.1995570064,
-0.7684520483,
0.0473129712,
0.0467109457,
-0.1293821782,
-0.3357097805,
-0.0183673929,
-0.1548728049,
0.0118811149,
0.3990336657,
-0.5762084723,
0.0213607717,
-0.5461925268,
0.3446804881,
0.4387653172,
-0.1366381347,
0.0381480902,
-0.2207533419,
0.829931438,
-0.1650944501,
0.317696631,
-0.238440901,
-0.5363447666,
-0.583325088,
-0.6377943754,
0.2716550827,
0.3728764653,
-0.3439421952,
0.2543216348,
-0.2535807788,
-0.5337580442,
-0.981861949,
0.0920759439,
0.8315885067,
0.5390450954,
0.216724962,
-0.0742884055,
-0.2825172246,
-0.8755809665,
-0.5166561604,
-0.0997829437,
-0.1877328753,
0.6026975513,
0.4221670032,
-0.4334593415,
0.5702310205,
-0.3788281381,
-0.2770057619,
-0.1144940928,
0.0721559376,
0.3050384223,
0.0749901459,
0.2795983255,
-0.274921,
-0.2684416771,
0.1325139552,
-0.8687429428,
-0.2521267235,
0.2484491318,
0.0875242725,
-0.2384627163,
0.6159933209,
-0.5124474168,
0.4439699054,
0.67775172,
-0.4290468693,
0.5612472892,
-0.3254445493,
-0.1732477993,
-0.6708983183,
0.238419041,
-0.2131835967,
-0.2652582228,
-0.4955901504,
0.1701117605,
0.3155069947,
-0.0609499775,
-0.3951339126,
0.6625331044,
-0.5594124198,
-0.0016782917,
-0.0327858776,
0.473128438,
-0.0377076901,
-0.104749091,
-0.0232369006,
0.6503255367,
0.7133708596,
-0.4568253756,
0.2450762391,
0.0833192468,
-0.7961435914,
0.5220324397,
-0.8579721451,
0.3094265163,
0.0266104378,
0.0660512373,
-0.8874385357,
-0.1230709627,
-0.0908054262,
-0.4299472868,
0.1672113538,
-0.132176742,
-0.2819218338,
-0.2799406946,
-0.1534763724,
0.3271351457,
0.2152534723,
-0.2985748351,
0.2621772587,
0.423393935,
-0.1004054621,
-0.5018225312,
-0.55043751,
0.1123667881,
-0.0434629954,
-0.5847668052,
0.3269636631,
-0.2048435062,
-0.3499687314,
-0.1487004608,
-0.2371874303,
0.1012164801,
0.1963958442,
0.098369129,
0.1400078386,
-0.3509284854,
0.3334179819,
0.0299607441,
-0.1927734911,
0.3931138515,
-0.0434029624,
0.3539561331,
-0.0622611195,
-0.5904987454,
-0.4506816268,
0.1068499014,
0.7570379972,
-0.1936971545,
0.4955430329,
0.5628843904,
-0.4682233334,
-0.1690595746,
-0.3971844316,
-0.1014193073,
-0.4466438591,
0.6852648854,
-0.4014430344,
-0.7712154984,
0.6269503236,
-0.3277419806,
-0.1070279703,
0.2087489665,
0.7170212269,
-0.1442639083,
0.922873199,
0.5375585556,
0.2070297897,
-0.1274500787,
0.090316087,
0.3723430932,
-0.9377690554,
-0.5561733842,
-0.573902607,
-0.1564648002,
-0.5114604235,
-0.7992418408,
0.6186162233,
0.0676075518,
0.3167965412,
-0.1005192548,
-0.2201542407,
0.2849225998,
0.1343811601,
0.3826019168,
0.4983716011,
-0.4607199132,
-0.4701115191,
-0.1203444749,
-0.5356914401,
-0.549151659,
1.2606309652,
0.6128602028,
0.7672847509,
0.2876426578,
0.6740836501,
0.0681605041,
0.6407846212,
-1.1530156136,
0.564227283,
-0.1988541633,
-0.3023397326,
-0.2776120305,
-0.3877670765,
-1.0652372837,
0.0238615014,
-0.0128050083,
-0.8735473156,
-0.0191372316,
-0.0583449788,
-0.3427316844,
-0.2325445265,
-0.665697515,
0.9758155942,
-0.2870835662,
-0.2043541819,
-0.2179341912,
-0.5701087117,
0.4414316714,
-0.1091574207,
0.3843694627,
-0.5102526546,
-0.3712562323,
0.7019249797,
-0.3862903416,
0.7428431511,
-0.0413507856,
-0.2296757251,
-0.2401591837,
0.0637530908,
0.2784147263,
0.3263761103,
-0.2552339137,
0.0319886394,
0.3249249756,
-0.3839557469,
-0.662152648,
0.7259175181,
-0.4301040471,
-0.4025467932,
-0.2982190847,
-0.8214979768,
-0.7299085855,
0.2406801134,
0.2966203392,
0.6297807693,
-0.4283165634,
0.0839045793,
0.757827878,
-0.5143873096,
0.0380871445,
1.0146665573,
-0.2870859802,
-0.0881006718,
0.5039704442,
-0.4468821883,
0.3463921249,
0.5012848973,
0.4558166862,
-0.6173030138,
-1.0580877066,
-0.2695992291,
0.6244372129,
-0.7795087695,
-0.070727177,
-0.5529119968,
0.0486641414,
-0.496260643,
0.0422041304,
-0.3247033954,
-0.0640328228,
-0.0758726448,
0.0361448899,
0.4644640386,
0.879758656,
0.2232501358,
0.2073495686,
-0.7862401009,
0.1615171731,
0.0494962893,
0.7713576555,
-0.2711977363,
-0.6175392866,
-0.3729947805,
-0.0742463171,
0.1297567487,
-0.7783619165,
0.2769086957,
0.1329934448,
0.7029880881,
0.5849909782,
-0.0644940883,
0.7013388276,
-0.4197137952,
0.3477137089,
0.2675593495,
-0.8951352835,
0.4598296583,
-0.4900095165,
0.488256067,
0.6684116125,
0.2121663839,
-0.6144990921,
-0.3742503822,
-0.3854692578,
-0.6250402331,
0.5778452754,
0.0072220201,
-0.2996344268,
0.071038641,
0.5333656073,
-0.0065729106,
0.2003926337,
-0.3529542089,
-0.4216180742,
0.5799331069,
-0.4182544351,
-0.2466189116,
-0.2860856354,
-0.3115796447,
-0.1641068757,
0.1256144941,
-0.1374264657,
0.5171394944,
0.1534022391,
-0.2916160226,
0.0395597778,
0.2639869452,
0.7031928301,
0.8193185329,
-0.5860114694,
-0.024831498,
0.0695256442,
-0.7015904188,
-0.3173275888,
0.1512904465,
0.0668147355,
0.1473863125,
0.7872610688,
0.8100240231,
0.458090663,
-1.0514234304,
0.6403068304,
-0.3098068833,
-0.112427175,
0.105714567,
0.0197681356,
0.4589035511,
0.118488811,
-0.1103718504,
-0.3507636786,
0.4289859533,
-0.5256047249,
0.1652556211,
0.4858800769,
-0.7061507702,
-0.2650165856,
0.4252285957,
0.168861419,
-0.330414325,
0.3896120489,
-0.2387524843,
-0.3268992901,
0.6797397733,
0.7547958493,
0.8870123029,
-0.1710916162,
0.1301352382,
0.21502994,
0.4030768275,
0.3383352458,
0.5145408511,
0.142116487,
-0.4771018624,
-0.5650484562,
-0.6518098712,
-0.7622078061,
0.3477508426,
-0.8161896467,
0.4243850708,
-0.4113835692,
-0.0694732815,
0.1447945386,
0.0187082011,
-0.7937477231,
0.2387157828,
0.099340111,
1.1401926279,
-0.5922414064,
0.898630321,
0.7300848961,
0.0212889984,
-0.6007672548,
-0.2018943727,
0.1685044318,
-1.3356353045,
0.5703517199,
0.2310745269,
-0.1554401517,
-0.2628744245,
-0.3607746065,
-0.6607349515,
0.9560226202,
0.5544077754,
-0.8105723262,
-0.0096294368,
0.2672055364,
0.8018811941,
-0.4419993758,
0.5882917643,
0.9735256433,
0.3500704765,
0.0001259855,
-1.0277011395,
0.2423714548,
-0.3253124654,
-0.2449545562,
-0.052387055,
-0.3294037879,
0.6330655217,
-0.5448241234,
-0.3327673972,
0.3006592393,
0.0350090042,
0.4243024588,
0.6577407718,
0.2990065515,
0.4312929213,
1.1288911104,
-0.1184177622,
1.1155583858,
-0.4118872881,
0.2991890013,
1.0965214968,
-0.4415660799,
0.6605782509,
0.2479167432,
-0.492530942,
0.2991662323,
0.5548889041,
0.4782787859,
0.4008957446,
0.5093861818,
-0.4739050567,
-0.2218295485,
-0.4349248409,
-0.4322246313,
0.4504463375,
0.9330499768,
-0.3475714326,
-0.2506800294,
-0.3176727891,
-0.0352752544,
0.0671481937,
-0.1450147927,
0.7839545608,
0.3651586473,
-0.4129821956,
0.6888775826,
-0.124732472,
0.2991060615,
-0.7760827541,
0.1223388389,
-0.2028876543,
0.3133156598,
-0.1906591654,
-0.4141842127,
0.1174809113,
0.07804811,
0.0509366058,
0.0807210505,
0.5192454457,
-0.3684545457,
-0.5351521373,
0.5501172543,
0.3953199983,
0.3755800724,
0.0236796867,
-0.8528983593,
0.4029208124,
-0.1882176548,
0.2213431299,
0.2938345969,
0.6370680332,
0.1188795418,
0.8610236645,
0.5854821205,
0.3493433595,
-0.1692463607,
0.5583574176,
0.6908382773,
-0.7634811997,
-0.3127015233,
-0.8019285798,
0.1125382483,
0.0637806877,
-0.4206539094,
0.5602272153,
0.4727026224,
0.2713494003,
0.1035730168,
0.7359751463,
0.4445149899,
0.6966264248,
-0.6417887807,
0.675775528,
-0.5199667215,
0.520819068,
-0.3405196667,
-0.1871303618,
-0.5950883031,
0.4894503057,
-0.5443415642,
-0.1207274795,
1.0197085142,
0.6499670744,
0.2649365366,
0.1518055052,
0.5549253225,
0.3575100899,
0.3069305718,
0.8363036513,
0.8066931963,
-0.2534893751,
0.1710806042,
-0.2015313804,
-0.5218552351,
-0.2598464489,
-1.1522272825,
-1.0506563187,
-0.0930311829,
-0.3532253504,
-0.2032075673,
0.1549291462,
0.7885963321,
0.6595557928,
-0.8026770949,
-0.3196773827,
0.0049180021,
0.0358737484,
-0.2601033449,
-0.109007515,
0.5317953229,
-0.4444730282,
-0.6067485213,
0.702246666,
0.649718225,
-0.3122876883,
-0.2442557216,
-0.0863226205,
-0.0637810305,
-0.1536708772,
0.5769656897,
0.1168958396,
-0.8195387125,
0.2131819874,
0.3362491429,
-0.2415043861,
-0.0968759358,
0.9270128012,
-0.6483386159,
0.8962296247,
0.20533292,
0.7465180755,
0.4846265614,
-0.3358403444,
0.6418910027,
-0.2908643484,
0.1293174177,
0.3742591143,
0.4605460465,
0.3294208348,
-0.3884209394,
0.3793938458,
0.2012593597,
-0.3246461749,
-0.9784103632,
0.0031778822,
-1.0396655798,
-0.0178631954,
0.96020329,
-0.395876646,
-0.2449114174,
-0.3802243769,
0.155414328,
0.152071923,
-0.2134459019,
0.6415579915,
0.4275611341,
-0.2326110601,
0.0948484465,
-0.6497715712,
0.5863943696,
0.5718455911,
-0.856703043,
0.152827844,
0.1800907254,
0.3111507297,
-0.2175109237,
0.8748788238,
-0.4288843572,
0.4442019463,
-0.2926451266,
0.0403440259,
0.2159078568,
-0.0531279035,
-0.3877774477,
-0.3779319525,
0.2649635077,
-0.1996427625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04066v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04066v1
|
VoicePilot: Harnessing LLMs as Speech Interfaces for Physically Assistive Robots
| 2024-04-05T12:45:10 | 2024-04-05T12:45:10 |
Akhil Padmanabha, Jessie Yuan, Janavi Gupta, Zulekha Karachiwalla, Carmel Majidi, Henny Admoni, Zackory Erickson
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Physically assistive robots present an opportunity to significantly increase
the well-being and independence of individuals with motor impairments or other
forms of disability who are unable to complete activities of daily living.
Speech interfaces, especially ones that utilize Large Language Models (LLMs),
can enable individuals to effectively and naturally communicate high-level
commands and nuanced preferences to robots. Frameworks for integrating LLMs as
interfaces to robots for high level task planning and code generation have been
proposed, but fail to incorporate human-centric considerations which are
essential while developing assistive interfaces. In this work, we present a
framework for incorporating LLMs as speech interfaces for physically assistive
robots, constructed iteratively with 3 stages of testing involving a feeding
robot, culminating in an evaluation with 11 older adults at an independent
living facility. We use both quantitative and qualitative data from the final
study to validate our framework and additionally provide design guidelines for
using LLMs as speech interfaces for assistive robots. Videos and supporting
files are located on our project website:
https://sites.google.com/andrew.cmu.edu/voicepilot/
|
[
-0.2362278998,
-0.5378327966,
0.6150976419,
0.2887023091,
0.1026175469,
0.1257999539,
-0.1140873805,
-0.4341664016,
0.6317494512,
0.6957317591,
-0.7579364181,
-0.28425017,
-0.4480667412,
0.1325190216,
-0.0627554432,
0.3097432554,
-0.0139302555,
0.2366623878,
-0.0952097997,
0.2049126476,
-0.3754038513,
-0.5654616952,
-0.4557905495,
-0.6819481254,
0.5913347602,
0.5630623698,
0.6404802799,
0.3691528141,
0.4494139254,
0.3454605043,
-0.03680503,
0.25466609,
0.0369431898,
0.2137184739,
0.1176286042,
-0.4115820229,
-0.8562725782,
-0.3117036521,
0.4944714606,
1.016782999,
-0.2146425843,
0.0385446697,
0.2611336112,
0.5936676264,
-0.2513714433,
0.2697890103,
-0.2423211932,
0.2101172954,
-0.095649384,
-0.3355544806,
-0.1540414542,
-0.2948256135,
-0.0176786985,
-0.6672716737,
-0.3185843229,
-0.0168342851,
0.3432210386,
0.6296438575,
-0.0413998179,
-0.4362616837,
-0.6616746187,
0.4796781242,
-0.926512897,
0.3362765908,
0.6670922637,
0.3728739619,
-0.5545658469,
-0.4249334633,
-0.7288575172,
-0.6066301465,
0.202891171,
0.0971852913,
-0.3667164445,
0.4159533381,
0.1981559545,
-0.1179217249,
-0.5544629097,
0.4783641994,
-0.2396741658,
-0.0486811213,
0.497682929,
0.0406542085,
0.3287319541,
-0.4339146912,
-0.5340504646,
-0.1023091301,
-0.5372263789,
0.1499388516,
0.5805999637,
0.8479218483,
-0.4702353776,
1.1878905296,
-0.4219104052,
0.771478951,
-0.0313362144,
-0.2902374566,
0.6946895719,
-0.0509926565,
-0.1992668808,
0.0796969756,
0.5851023197,
0.2945376337,
0.5012795329,
-0.0898460522,
-0.0805274099,
-0.3738677204,
0.2828830481,
-0.28764081,
-0.2310304344,
0.5647475719,
-0.4661848545,
0.1049838215,
-0.0994090885,
-0.6920416951,
-0.8770233393,
-0.6678138971,
0.4626140296,
-0.0956564173,
-0.3664389551,
0.276684016,
-0.1062970012,
0.0757402107,
0.2580876648,
-0.7662991285,
0.2221916318,
0.6262283921,
0.8394232392,
-0.280374825,
-0.1783252507,
-0.9380873442,
0.2699313462,
0.0048313527,
0.7394827604,
-0.4880630374,
-0.6466068029,
-0.0369723998,
0.4564651251,
-0.0823834911,
-0.7173973918,
0.6241308451,
0.0552866459,
-0.088718079,
0.0239448287,
-0.3554365039,
-0.233776778,
-0.093068935,
-0.5976952314,
0.5704234838,
0.2172608674,
-0.070390068,
0.0155814067,
-1.0594736338,
-0.6944827437,
0.2802249789,
-0.2126813084,
-0.2056251466,
-0.1167996675,
0.055641681,
0.7379996181,
0.0204789843,
0.0809277147,
-0.3959340155,
-0.1075774506,
0.2607954144,
-0.4156761169,
0.6948731542,
0.2436733991,
-0.3620746434,
0.5304167867,
-0.6938147545,
0.0129333744,
-0.0704177693,
-0.389780283,
0.2858808935,
0.3073566854,
-0.04825335,
-0.0831698328,
0.4100485146,
-0.4828214347,
0.133883968,
-0.3193131089,
0.332472831,
0.511783123,
-0.1545411348,
0.4211016297,
-0.4032105505,
0.8126065731,
-0.6669142246,
0.1442033648,
0.0436975472,
-0.5908577442,
-0.5284200907,
-0.4115713835,
-0.031419985,
0.6452370882,
-0.752382338,
0.7257460356,
0.0468591228,
-0.2665131986,
-0.2137853503,
0.3237222135,
-0.0643259734,
0.3757561147,
0.2384856045,
-0.0196283888,
-0.6079360247,
-0.8413588405,
0.3539330959,
-0.2867681384,
-0.9186842442,
0.4142693281,
0.0589476787,
0.0932668969,
0.8300600648,
-0.0468473062,
-0.5832836628,
-0.5947157145,
-0.0559974015,
0.2137953937,
0.4576168358,
0.3756370842,
-0.5289034843,
0.0984548926,
0.0006222235,
-0.6438544393,
-0.3996811211,
-0.1455335021,
0.251675874,
0.0763023421,
0.3642341793,
-0.6428192258,
0.3546254635,
0.8788611293,
-0.0873372927,
0.1751715392,
-0.285467267,
0.0941427425,
-0.7323944569,
0.1241810247,
-0.0332703218,
-0.2748403847,
-0.5809988379,
-0.4106586874,
-0.4995720685,
-0.3099958599,
-0.5831979513,
0.2332408279,
-0.4632537961,
-0.4079855084,
-0.5587846041,
0.3997025192,
-0.1843342036,
0.4861096442,
0.183946535,
0.767965138,
0.2785924375,
-0.442941308,
0.4024462998,
-0.0139929689,
-0.1129882559,
0.5620154738,
-0.9494626522,
-0.0381179787,
0.1433722675,
0.1637331098,
-1.1146428585,
-0.5815963745,
0.7127359509,
-0.6098309755,
0.0537545048,
0.0965946093,
-0.4478126168,
-0.3172476888,
-0.1420676112,
-0.2075036317,
0.4439248145,
-0.3401474357,
1.040501833,
0.9771787524,
-0.4693215191,
0.1178753451,
-0.5923370719,
-0.0178263914,
-0.190943256,
-0.490521729,
0.2066726834,
-0.1400670707,
-0.0742191225,
-0.3666551709,
0.1044472903,
0.0958882868,
0.1971906573,
0.5667193532,
0.0403636284,
0.0473013259,
0.0433427319,
0.0508276336,
-0.1618659794,
0.1140440032,
0.0633297861,
0.8790935874,
0.0718440562,
-0.8190151453,
-0.9203101397,
0.3095449507,
0.61055547,
-0.0264887698,
0.0408724956,
0.4056656361,
-0.3956753612,
0.170548588,
-0.3092043102,
-0.0687981769,
-0.5132598877,
0.2582934797,
-0.3101501763,
-0.7617201209,
0.2195319831,
-0.2471543103,
0.0358613767,
-0.0407170504,
0.6218421459,
-0.4737602472,
1.0599646568,
0.4493008852,
0.0148838339,
0.5793520808,
0.1250143349,
-0.14630647,
-1.1605293751,
-0.4321267903,
-0.7620326877,
-0.5078456402,
-0.359548986,
-0.9318698645,
0.3363090158,
-0.230220452,
-0.2002370954,
0.264287442,
-0.5477211475,
0.1925635189,
0.4174742103,
0.1747047007,
0.160455212,
0.0043735774,
0.1734164208,
0.1339894235,
-0.6540366411,
-0.8505395651,
0.6357259154,
0.6105437875,
0.8659842014,
0.0759934559,
0.3435947895,
0.4670551121,
0.0870633572,
-0.8768296242,
0.7252622843,
-0.3267832398,
-0.1482892036,
-0.6347296834,
-0.1530173868,
-1.0791041851,
0.0488553606,
-0.1485643685,
-1.0600298643,
0.263939023,
0.2500265837,
-0.3983635306,
0.1993932575,
-0.7590615153,
0.5414223671,
-0.74996984,
-0.1467601359,
-0.0082968241,
-0.7935855389,
-0.0638746396,
0.2180911005,
0.13931638,
-0.4798582792,
-0.1706566066,
0.6247107983,
-0.1947350204,
1.3931715488,
-0.5442237854,
-0.206945926,
0.2049507499,
-0.2686392665,
0.3061228991,
-0.2696325183,
-0.2802305222,
0.2647476792,
-0.2118608505,
-0.062644653,
-0.4043159485,
0.5084061623,
-0.631462872,
-0.4410550892,
-0.0967454314,
-0.5073022842,
-0.4657875299,
0.0049636336,
-0.4507049024,
0.2380200773,
0.1807821095,
0.5068638921,
0.4535866976,
-0.3134626746,
0.2209033072,
0.445766896,
-0.4009319544,
-0.3646544814,
0.9849312305,
-0.0952613354,
0.4109006822,
0.4493405819,
0.3387695551,
-0.4407081008,
-0.5648530722,
-0.3166995645,
0.214826405,
-0.2659244537,
-0.0134726632,
-0.4716812372,
-0.159538269,
-0.3667562008,
-0.1033693105,
-0.1225455552,
-0.4918144345,
-0.6198918819,
0.1263400912,
0.0838981345,
0.7268842459,
-0.1521359831,
0.6171076298,
-0.5176049471,
0.6616818905,
0.310159862,
0.1330334395,
-0.0956232771,
-0.4175058007,
0.1671337634,
0.1779102236,
-0.3278106451,
-0.7649630308,
0.3191355765,
-0.1041746959,
0.9536929727,
-0.0297785867,
0.0666774213,
0.5676387548,
-0.5151343346,
1.0201283693,
0.3239257038,
-0.8598999381,
0.6473761201,
-0.3687734902,
0.5243678689,
0.357767731,
0.3446585238,
-0.2340589017,
-0.2794571519,
-0.1827711612,
-0.9928193688,
0.3687312603,
0.0532508567,
0.0276161861,
0.2316590846,
0.1665501297,
0.0480120182,
0.3327461481,
-0.4923761189,
-0.0255435314,
-0.0835611895,
-0.416087687,
0.0998550877,
-0.0853730813,
-0.1776863337,
-0.0199723374,
0.4636595547,
-0.4495363533,
0.3127784729,
0.076274313,
0.2548688948,
-0.153790921,
0.0703193918,
0.853492856,
0.603992641,
-0.1175823882,
-0.0161013361,
0.0273544099,
-0.2833605409,
-0.1757318377,
0.2867652476,
0.2257765234,
-0.1131773368,
0.1567005068,
0.6976984143,
0.41340065,
-1.0584716797,
0.2543547451,
0.0749294236,
-0.1054510921,
-0.5405231714,
0.1431352496,
0.5053352118,
0.5660939217,
0.4295284152,
-0.1343758255,
0.1243095547,
-0.2138350308,
0.3138683438,
0.5178219676,
-0.2139682323,
-0.2567965984,
0.5957355499,
0.6427574158,
-0.9482210279,
0.0437585153,
0.1373578161,
-0.2735116482,
0.4252956212,
0.3377495408,
0.8698019385,
-0.2204906046,
0.2272492498,
-0.0281263553,
0.3306390643,
0.3677171171,
0.3376333416,
-0.3436199725,
-0.377897948,
-0.542386651,
-0.5465431213,
-0.9084247351,
-0.0094762705,
-0.3848435879,
0.191440329,
-0.296836406,
-0.3492906392,
-0.1136923134,
-0.1170166805,
-0.387699306,
-0.032806091,
0.5028654933,
0.6886803508,
-0.4089080989,
0.6334617138,
0.7004538178,
-0.2526631653,
-0.8362783194,
0.0598649196,
0.1593188643,
-1.188216567,
0.7961773276,
-0.1345060766,
-0.5804517865,
-0.1427128017,
-0.2842432559,
-0.7560554743,
1.0614305735,
0.3662505746,
-0.7767102718,
-0.1143299937,
0.4858859479,
0.322175622,
-0.4778363109,
0.054441791,
0.1315944493,
0.668380022,
0.3658313155,
-1.2663220167,
-0.2055308074,
0.008998204,
0.0313821435,
-0.2398469001,
-0.6559461951,
0.3411182165,
-0.0745525509,
0.0490882955,
0.5019254088,
0.7359481454,
0.6366194487,
0.3035932481,
0.8891659379,
-0.1036660448,
0.864092648,
-0.0867505744,
0.7562397718,
-0.1934660822,
-0.2161110789,
1.2006292343,
-0.5551986098,
1.0399819613,
0.5927907825,
-0.2794224918,
0.2772754133,
0.2250029594,
0.3290397227,
0.2427432835,
0.5339530706,
-0.2127340436,
-0.415420711,
-0.4701337218,
-0.18493779,
0.733027935,
0.4271290898,
-0.2111385912,
0.0216626655,
0.5167298913,
-0.0220168401,
0.1524835974,
0.0000133111,
0.66599828,
0.0530615859,
-0.3737888336,
0.1170967594,
-0.5667321086,
0.6224937439,
-0.8702229857,
-0.28915295,
0.2203695029,
0.1242023557,
-0.1881904453,
-1.0615541935,
0.1189997867,
0.1564685404,
-0.0404528677,
-0.4844749272,
0.5896067619,
-0.2762400806,
-0.3786655366,
0.1253358424,
0.5291339755,
0.4388348162,
0.1895344406,
-0.6730977893,
0.6663274169,
0.0577604137,
-0.2183299959,
0.2107639164,
0.1706162691,
0.3285724521,
0.9448281527,
0.612128377,
0.3903069794,
-0.0491822213,
0.369350493,
0.6794855595,
-0.3449570537,
-0.1770040393,
-0.3306879103,
0.7973670959,
-0.0955725312,
-0.2381366044,
0.6248465776,
0.3901115656,
0.4341181517,
0.0748607889,
0.6760408282,
-0.1779375374,
0.8280327916,
-0.716576755,
0.5956192613,
-0.6783303618,
0.3577510417,
-0.0761845484,
-0.539855063,
-0.2838704586,
1.0685117245,
-0.2144512683,
0.2377260625,
0.0873727053,
0.6516026855,
0.2940755785,
-0.0134123936,
0.4931418896,
-0.0787534565,
0.6232916117,
0.3671867549,
0.8848316073,
0.2175952494,
0.4113688171,
-0.1996683776,
-0.3422136009,
-0.2493085116,
-0.9650434852,
-0.6529344916,
-0.4981530607,
-0.1739435196,
0.0457678139,
0.1952648461,
1.1142677069,
0.9263752103,
-0.3251702189,
-0.7189283967,
-0.0135382656,
0.1299580634,
-0.0181133691,
-0.2373561561,
-0.0546139367,
-0.0969346091,
-0.9537284374,
0.8318561316,
0.2502115369,
0.1761460155,
-0.6669155955,
-0.2189697325,
-0.0563028976,
-0.283931762,
0.5915358663,
0.5752871037,
-1.0028684139,
-0.6420443654,
0.2043090016,
0.3134248853,
0.0476142354,
0.7737067342,
-0.8755716085,
0.4653607607,
0.2904245853,
0.596028924,
0.2267985195,
0.1784832776,
0.7026931643,
-0.5178627372,
0.0567144416,
0.3902041018,
0.3426516056,
0.4773493111,
-0.0826941133,
0.4970500767,
-0.1343574077,
-0.823069036,
-0.8838801384,
0.1579283178,
-1.6272646189,
0.0588600785,
1.2003624439,
0.0774690285,
-0.2035030127,
-0.0907316208,
-0.5905365348,
0.0660114139,
-0.4279007316,
0.3502648771,
0.1911108643,
-0.8129383922,
-0.1865226924,
-0.8399913907,
0.1875223517,
0.1879822165,
-1.0551605225,
0.1206967533,
0.5459957719,
0.0551557429,
0.3489156067,
0.5421140194,
0.1082858369,
0.1375286132,
-0.2700765729,
0.1662999839,
-0.2366283089,
-0.1722970307,
-0.3059915602,
0.3481761515,
0.1234248355,
-0.5938284397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04042v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04042v1
|
Teaching Llama a New Language Through Cross-Lingual Knowledge Transfer
| 2024-04-05T11:52:02 | 2024-04-05T11:52:02 |
Hele-Andra Kuulmets, Taido Purason, Agnes Luhtaru, Mark Fishel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores cost-efficient methods to adapt pretrained Large Language
Models (LLMs) to new lower-resource languages, with a specific focus on
Estonian. Leveraging the Llama 2 model, we investigate the impact of combining
cross-lingual instruction-tuning with additional monolingual pretraining. Our
results demonstrate that even a relatively small amount of additional
monolingual pretraining followed by cross-lingual instruction-tuning
significantly enhances results on Estonian. Furthermore, we showcase
cross-lingual knowledge transfer from high-quality English instructions to
Estonian, resulting in improvements in commonsense reasoning and multi-turn
conversation capabilities. Our best model, named \textsc{Llammas}, represents
the first open-source instruction-following LLM for Estonian. Additionally, we
publish Alpaca-est, the first general task instruction dataset for Estonia.
These contributions mark the initial progress in the direction of developing
open-source LLMs for Estonian.
|
[
-0.0894924775,
-0.8064631224,
0.4295367897,
0.234333396,
-0.5288460255,
0.1122022495,
-0.5776167512,
-0.6699334383,
0.3428183496,
0.5405594707,
-0.2924720645,
-0.5754072666,
-0.7853858471,
-0.0849826038,
-0.2867210209,
0.6539862752,
-0.224188894,
0.2262338996,
-0.1670157909,
-0.0485436432,
-0.7714114785,
-0.569075644,
-0.6448904276,
-0.2377850562,
0.4390234351,
0.9865721464,
0.4820830822,
0.4593426585,
0.1225970089,
0.2685983181,
-0.0058649248,
-0.0744371265,
-0.6597419381,
-0.3716828823,
-0.1873266995,
-0.9546743631,
-0.2410842031,
-0.1456684023,
0.5719563961,
0.5283356309,
-0.3484366536,
0.327870667,
0.0055277185,
0.5011532903,
-0.5047124624,
0.0766933188,
-0.770802021,
0.0919310749,
-0.2912444472,
0.0023042706,
-0.5317872763,
-0.2322070301,
0.0253653973,
-0.8955924511,
-0.4363475442,
-0.0003904239,
0.6578953862,
0.3153717518,
-0.4991713464,
-0.4781581461,
-0.5838439465,
1.0969361067,
-0.3662055433,
0.687709868,
0.4937010407,
0.2296050489,
0.0876193866,
-0.6290723681,
-0.3724160194,
-0.2801395059,
-0.0275095385,
-0.129879877,
-0.5143890381,
-0.4215528965,
-0.3626970351,
0.1740264744,
-0.1065191701,
0.6712118387,
-0.5756882429,
0.1276036054,
0.5012440681,
-0.0319136493,
0.275077641,
0.1360835731,
-0.7030671239,
0.0455715582,
-0.988260746,
-0.0447268225,
0.4060595036,
0.2049190551,
-0.5492690206,
0.4101031423,
0.1835566312,
0.405852735,
0.2379869819,
-0.2265137583,
0.1622686535,
-0.4044416845,
-0.0912337601,
0.1197154298,
0.4496768713,
0.1010782942,
0.4635554254,
-0.1403705329,
0.0462732576,
-0.000307605,
0.0693153143,
-0.4080107212,
0.0636769682,
-0.1817144156,
-0.4635031223,
-0.0865514055,
-0.5546397567,
-0.7554039359,
0.0822458789,
-0.5263152122,
0.500289917,
-0.3466276526,
-0.2946576178,
0.4090333283,
0.4138216674,
0.3768308461,
0.4807172418,
-1.0394073725,
0.4033505321,
0.7196692824,
0.6606839895,
-0.2419691384,
-0.5481394529,
-0.5980916023,
0.1312790215,
-0.5094202161,
0.7929128408,
-0.6858620048,
-0.3941494823,
-0.0847930908,
0.0565118641,
0.1396259516,
-0.3516878784,
0.2047558427,
-0.4085173011,
0.4995193779,
-0.1407622099,
-0.3062212169,
-0.2880194783,
0.0290682856,
-0.5054053068,
1.1875265837,
0.1382047683,
-0.4479157031,
0.0953545198,
-0.5953110456,
-0.667213738,
-0.0744712874,
0.1607013494,
0.1667474508,
0.0344602093,
0.1745524853,
0.3098433018,
-0.6180507541,
0.1762287915,
0.2341373414,
-0.170693323,
-0.3061932921,
-0.2697305381,
0.8719426394,
0.2097492218,
-0.393527478,
0.0123459082,
-0.7247906327,
-0.1127982587,
0.1156515777,
-0.6896852255,
-0.4360806942,
-0.332398802,
-0.1250782162,
-0.0090154773,
0.5907946229,
-0.4164647758,
0.0954543054,
0.0380590148,
0.094027333,
0.8549115062,
-0.5840313435,
0.6488910913,
-0.11105147,
0.9000629783,
0.0784157887,
0.3874081969,
-0.1171021461,
-0.4434438646,
-1.2382329702,
-0.106013611,
0.3906834424,
0.7979971766,
-0.9724289775,
0.1867092401,
-0.0852396414,
-0.6197918653,
-0.7501001954,
0.5840685964,
0.5674042106,
0.4549116492,
0.470020324,
-0.412933141,
-0.6290606856,
-0.9557151794,
-0.1071005017,
-0.2109116316,
0.1734746248,
0.1433222145,
0.2479648888,
-0.243720755,
0.1637665033,
-0.1399241984,
-0.348421067,
-0.1864377558,
-0.0766633376,
0.0757477954,
0.3650675416,
0.7471241355,
-0.1737740934,
-0.6722022295,
0.3133502603,
-0.4717488587,
-0.0591299236,
0.3139285743,
-0.4947239757,
0.5392228365,
0.6479030252,
-0.4401732981,
0.048089236,
1.0570892096,
-0.5110040903,
0.4784846008,
-0.2005118579,
-0.0466002263,
-1.0929472446,
-0.172832042,
-0.3592383862,
-0.2436153144,
-0.4946006536,
0.0274670273,
-0.3209154606,
-0.0601118319,
-0.9276838303,
0.7595283985,
-0.6708988547,
-0.0544896834,
-0.1980402619,
-0.2196885049,
-0.3425185382,
0.6088089943,
0.0824771374,
0.9468932152,
0.6992842555,
-0.4594786167,
0.2073589712,
0.356118679,
-0.6271157861,
0.7083027959,
-0.4198535681,
0.4724272192,
-0.2621070445,
0.0778942555,
-0.4565429091,
0.1817165762,
0.2676744163,
-0.0482945219,
0.2771557868,
-0.3686431348,
-0.2424959689,
0.2360980213,
-0.0662311539,
0.3636299074,
0.7681353688,
-0.8571118116,
0.8560163379,
0.569033742,
-0.4393298924,
-0.7821758986,
-0.7024917006,
0.2526068687,
-0.2452950329,
-0.5096544027,
0.1189857572,
0.0507863872,
-0.3285554349,
0.2286785841,
0.2497342974,
-0.0540741719,
0.1892457306,
-0.1359772086,
0.2054951191,
-0.5723555088,
0.2910823226,
0.0784215927,
-0.1676343828,
0.0097798035,
-0.5175354481,
0.6072586775,
-0.2507634461,
-0.3838333189,
-0.4161059856,
0.3808021545,
0.4221051335,
-0.3482218385,
0.6791478395,
0.5023613572,
-0.1434987932,
-0.1763675958,
-0.6213895679,
0.1129773036,
-0.4413366616,
0.4551800489,
-0.2337417006,
-0.9982350469,
0.2204220593,
-0.0884349421,
0.2018895298,
0.1904563159,
0.5896503329,
0.0065419814,
0.3191546798,
1.0749440193,
-0.1867789328,
0.6939533353,
-0.0496235415,
-0.0140769696,
-0.4890325963,
-0.4112756848,
-0.5549287796,
-0.5447480679,
-0.4363968968,
-0.9190882444,
0.167267859,
0.1096042544,
-0.2633745968,
0.3346618414,
0.0139867049,
0.753059864,
0.8713442087,
-0.0801922455,
0.4304464161,
0.3191772401,
-0.03956379,
0.231153667,
-1.0678650141,
-0.7098408937,
1.4145092964,
0.3093236387,
1.0555148125,
0.1519126147,
0.7305045724,
0.0130183138,
0.295707792,
-0.5584830642,
0.4380696714,
-0.5344206095,
-0.2212466598,
-0.455568105,
-0.2238903791,
-1.0215185881,
0.1833576113,
-0.3286507726,
-0.4919887185,
-0.0594325364,
0.1877132952,
0.0037321437,
0.5552485585,
-0.9379174709,
0.632437408,
-0.8625693917,
-0.4090105593,
-0.6260644197,
-0.3819322288,
0.3452139497,
-0.2085510045,
0.5175060034,
-0.0591021106,
-0.317579031,
0.7534416914,
-0.176717177,
1.0361405611,
-0.1450806409,
-0.6663626432,
0.3897383213,
0.1155045778,
0.5887989998,
-0.1215552837,
0.0033409798,
0.6192154884,
-0.1506952643,
-0.5809957981,
-0.2959686816,
0.6488727927,
-0.9869499803,
-0.8882547617,
0.1182792783,
-0.6693665385,
-0.1305831969,
0.1015519798,
0.0699969903,
-0.142415151,
-0.2744388878,
-0.035256099,
0.574424088,
-0.4280059338,
0.0913943499,
0.664668262,
-0.2704728246,
-0.4437026978,
0.6135161519,
-0.0071949097,
0.3863774538,
0.4709278345,
0.2961063385,
-0.1111963838,
-0.2442526519,
-0.5462180376,
0.32853356,
-0.8964901567,
-0.1198003218,
-0.3724300861,
0.2903887331,
-0.2083978653,
-0.2523669004,
-0.577391088,
-0.6223015785,
-0.4951781631,
-0.2264042944,
0.5110172629,
0.8465636373,
-0.3088987172,
0.4544371963,
-0.7229152322,
0.064633809,
0.5512573123,
0.4114801586,
0.161468938,
-0.6160559058,
-0.4155561328,
0.0528738238,
-0.0114043048,
-0.6174715161,
0.0942949429,
0.1993743181,
0.5284625292,
0.0605966039,
-0.296654284,
0.5166236162,
-0.6888383031,
0.5690473914,
0.5473424196,
-1.1548240185,
0.3768689632,
0.0167113189,
0.1975123733,
0.3448357582,
0.567602098,
-0.6222607493,
0.082686983,
-0.4368027151,
-0.5812379122,
0.7449673414,
-0.2832049727,
0.5535545945,
0.2087396085,
0.0755311623,
0.5805232525,
-0.0227005221,
-0.7131642699,
-0.0647414923,
-0.0407952219,
-0.1224435046,
-0.3668519557,
-0.4379983246,
-0.1242730469,
-0.296354115,
0.8055360913,
-0.1103746369,
0.1590562314,
-0.3567742407,
-0.3419449031,
-0.4004162848,
0.4231134951,
0.6629715562,
0.6662700772,
0.4359326661,
0.2280197442,
0.7895149589,
-0.2890804112,
0.4583216012,
-0.1024616286,
-0.0330981165,
0.0291795265,
0.5289402604,
1.118330121,
0.6880755424,
-0.619312644,
0.3422719836,
0.1585975438,
-0.1871905476,
-0.3349733055,
0.0288569424,
0.5497134924,
0.3624189794,
0.0959093422,
-0.4106160998,
-0.597012639,
-0.6549429297,
-0.1814059466,
0.3964477777,
-0.1509328038,
-0.5222371817,
0.5706549883,
0.563960731,
-0.3812015355,
0.4259667993,
0.3476808965,
-0.471021235,
0.4522587657,
0.6611814499,
0.5458843112,
-0.4976063371,
0.2154735476,
0.1335819215,
0.63362813,
0.071341835,
0.5986067653,
-0.1344328076,
-0.4728016257,
-0.5211307406,
-0.5390526652,
-0.4880850315,
0.0790321305,
-0.4787400365,
0.7334524393,
-0.3571496904,
0.1297751516,
-0.321259886,
-0.211891681,
-0.9543133974,
-0.1222152188,
0.2541675568,
1.0590463877,
-0.9398753047,
0.8405022025,
0.873339653,
-0.1199758798,
-0.743054688,
-0.4981916845,
-0.2988978326,
-1.3576017618,
0.7738602757,
-0.2530789971,
-0.2718448937,
0.0355455019,
-0.5670785904,
-1.1993845701,
1.0153019428,
0.9396781921,
-0.8299393654,
-0.1862872392,
0.3162995875,
0.4369051158,
-0.271048665,
-0.0925209299,
0.454849422,
0.5048406124,
-0.0882261768,
-1.1575059891,
-0.1928328276,
-0.0427475497,
-0.3045931756,
0.2540667653,
-0.853951633,
0.8951428533,
-0.2900390625,
-0.2088275701,
-0.0644067675,
0.6794707775,
-0.0912648588,
-0.0040651052,
0.5477135181,
0.8089869022,
0.8400914669,
0.2958153188,
0.8465771675,
-0.3885897994,
-0.1670215577,
1.1276528835,
-0.2124150991,
1.0007566214,
0.7488787174,
-0.1436030865,
0.8399192691,
0.2195561975,
0.2550291121,
0.3006363213,
0.1789269745,
-0.1526907086,
-0.3397611678,
-0.2591631413,
-0.5012337565,
0.8409253955,
0.2281703204,
-0.1871204078,
-0.2406181246,
0.1387141049,
0.3130707741,
-0.0102506932,
-0.4423882961,
0.8405872583,
0.2700517178,
-0.6458737254,
0.9662976265,
0.0327109024,
0.9770012498,
-0.7077323198,
-0.0443250537,
-0.4937693477,
-0.0533394814,
-0.0875711739,
-0.5420656204,
0.1314659715,
0.4235711098,
0.0749898106,
-0.3224236071,
0.6682065725,
-0.8400939107,
-0.6156570315,
0.5332163572,
0.6776095033,
0.3821008503,
0.5356996655,
-0.3082302511,
0.0122836921,
-0.0598369092,
-0.0495805666,
0.39842242,
0.5853207707,
-0.2166944295,
0.6203894019,
0.7367992997,
0.1530057937,
0.276838541,
-0.2309712768,
0.7207666039,
-0.4185444415,
-0.5875108838,
-0.4663333595,
0.3328311741,
0.5928349495,
-0.4186664522,
0.5468543172,
0.3230178356,
1.2748260498,
-0.2419973463,
0.6534360051,
0.2183479518,
0.1658422649,
-0.9577542543,
0.6189763546,
-0.5405214429,
0.1867572814,
0.2389810979,
-0.8654477,
0.2639877498,
0.3585807383,
-0.1104121506,
-0.1486929804,
0.6380662918,
0.5417749882,
-0.2380601764,
-0.1405472159,
0.4038069248,
0.1320962608,
-0.2363539338,
0.8319480419,
1.0028567314,
-0.1888804138,
0.7495300174,
-0.329868257,
-0.1724818647,
-0.0207317006,
-1.0455681086,
-0.8503644466,
-0.4268447161,
-0.198676005,
0.1155338809,
0.3358431458,
0.9494383931,
0.6690426469,
-0.5862496495,
-0.6739589572,
0.244890824,
0.0607198663,
-0.0046114288,
-0.039120689,
0.2732740939,
-0.4108309746,
-0.7948746085,
0.566670537,
-0.0321513005,
0.1908255219,
-0.3762784004,
-0.2773557603,
-0.4077649415,
0.0283696949,
0.8281621337,
0.2082268894,
-0.7303061485,
-0.2678715289,
0.1219983548,
0.1148485616,
0.1948472112,
0.6742274165,
-0.8085961938,
0.0595738925,
0.1356870234,
0.7977569103,
0.5725876689,
-0.3928925991,
0.7012768984,
-0.6328202486,
0.5291092396,
-0.0244380087,
0.2627420127,
0.4529366493,
-0.4426292479,
0.5880795121,
-0.0772310197,
-0.112957038,
-0.6361926198,
0.1165050864,
-0.3872354031,
-0.2850852907,
1.2205244303,
-0.0908684283,
-0.3277714849,
0.0413312092,
-0.1912458539,
0.2502875924,
-0.1166849285,
0.8251568079,
0.7445890903,
0.1637371927,
-0.2821552455,
-0.2845008671,
0.1365228593,
0.821793437,
-1.237803936,
0.015290807,
0.3720042408,
0.4240191579,
-0.04526411,
0.5726056099,
-0.0321685746,
0.4237366319,
-0.0382220261,
0.3901560009,
-0.2646789253,
-0.4862194657,
-0.4350472987,
-0.3046177626,
0.2692502439,
-0.2471490204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04035v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04035v1
|
A Dataset for Physical and Abstract Plausibility and Sources of Human Disagreement
| 2024-04-05T11:37:40 | 2024-04-05T11:37:40 |
Annerose Eichel, Sabine Schulte im Walde
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a novel dataset for physical and abstract plausibility of events
in English. Based on naturally occurring sentences extracted from Wikipedia, we
infiltrate degrees of abstractness, and automatically generate perturbed
pseudo-implausible events. We annotate a filtered and balanced subset for
plausibility using crowd-sourcing, and perform extensive cleansing to ensure
annotation quality. In-depth quantitative analyses indicate that annotators
favor plausibility over implausibility and disagree more on implausible events.
Furthermore, our plausibility dataset is the first to capture abstractness in
events to the same extent as concreteness, and we find that event abstractness
has an impact on plausibility ratings: more concrete event participants trigger
a perception of implausibility.
|
[
-0.5730742812,
-0.6837677956,
0.7817187309,
0.103078343,
-0.1895140558,
-0.1274122149,
-0.0478526242,
-0.8037516475,
0.585790813,
-0.2020263672,
-0.540109694,
-0.1707129776,
-0.2861485481,
0.364803642,
-0.6452394128,
1.1838347912,
-0.2243856788,
-0.2022625804,
-0.5450667143,
-0.1645683348,
-0.0440274961,
-0.5971690416,
-0.286162287,
-0.4310467541,
0.6716549993,
0.5011416674,
0.9374037385,
0.4141648114,
0.3193897903,
0.2770281136,
0.2988750041,
0.223228842,
-0.430470705,
-0.0444165543,
-0.5894703269,
-0.2486083061,
-0.1212886572,
0.0582937188,
0.4962852299,
0.7791550756,
0.0133116208,
0.1081844419,
-0.0982513428,
0.4156154096,
-0.4579461813,
0.1229664162,
-0.7828947306,
0.2797546089,
-0.4857018292,
-0.0584883019,
-0.1379474699,
-0.3959885538,
0.2146785557,
-0.8138911724,
0.6483227611,
-0.0826626569,
1.191442728,
-0.0152466968,
-0.1807411015,
-0.3392626345,
-0.599747479,
0.4779483378,
-0.3079406917,
-0.0394824892,
0.6761122346,
0.1328196228,
-0.1182452366,
-0.9212616086,
-1.1423903704,
-0.2506099641,
-0.2129639536,
0.0401993506,
-0.1820775121,
-0.1658759564,
0.1784573197,
0.3301881254,
-0.6076583266,
-0.1020070538,
-0.4686795771,
-0.3652282655,
0.9552957416,
0.1480379999,
0.5998796225,
-0.2337104082,
0.1182788312,
0.204304859,
-0.6903607249,
0.0370644443,
0.7711287141,
-0.1447187364,
-0.1950626671,
0.666903019,
-0.2974372208,
0.4249182045,
0.0625735074,
0.128316626,
0.3391352296,
-0.2916021347,
0.2167287767,
0.146249488,
0.8547517657,
0.3213459551,
0.3036677837,
-0.536465466,
0.063392736,
0.1951429546,
-0.0728449225,
-0.6192743778,
-0.8204001188,
0.5084695816,
-0.3853526115,
-0.3902049959,
0.4909181297,
-0.4968556464,
-0.6331036091,
-0.334992826,
0.4115540385,
-0.235435009,
-0.3676355481,
0.0593156107,
-0.3757148087,
-0.16556485,
0.3634270132,
-0.572243154,
0.0768396258,
0.6364479065,
0.8407161832,
0.0126041314,
-0.7292176485,
-0.113380298,
0.0913217813,
-0.1065587699,
1.2209533453,
-0.5219330192,
-0.1275584996,
-0.3718637228,
0.2192435116,
0.2836524844,
-0.4630654454,
0.8406236768,
-0.203581214,
0.2610783577,
-0.151199162,
-0.5659274459,
-0.171633631,
-0.0766673312,
-0.8032769561,
0.7644740343,
-0.2920794189,
-0.9722499251,
0.5329450965,
-0.7493671775,
-0.7380972505,
0.2267942131,
-0.4385212958,
-0.2639623582,
0.2659581304,
-0.1207472011,
0.0859510005,
0.1234069392,
0.4754239321,
-0.5269807577,
-0.218699038,
0.6994806528,
-0.4735662341,
0.6462174058,
-0.1019161344,
-0.4595346451,
-0.1013642028,
-1.0886751413,
-0.4379449785,
0.2611179352,
-0.0675807297,
-0.317263484,
0.6513543129,
0.0589589737,
0.5723686218,
0.5097318292,
-0.7065824866,
0.0113533335,
-0.6227832437,
0.524461031,
0.7478716373,
0.2272218317,
0.1713169366,
-0.6583020687,
0.0297196396,
0.0568250045,
-0.0093079461,
-0.1394306123,
-0.794783473,
-0.3665204644,
-0.2873879969,
0.1023900136,
0.3871691823,
-0.558388412,
0.4070530534,
-0.2775259316,
-0.4820579886,
-0.4441203177,
0.013464883,
0.1687684208,
0.8483211994,
0.0768535361,
0.0035655035,
-0.8772134781,
-1.0470409393,
-0.3655536771,
-0.5571695566,
-0.3913548887,
0.0638691634,
0.8074037433,
0.3111635447,
1.2297247648,
-0.2810167968,
0.0868599787,
0.2914015949,
0.6672741771,
0.0472191498,
0.2073589414,
0.3749054968,
-0.9660630822,
-0.1654421091,
-0.0197962839,
-1.0486409664,
-0.2306704521,
-0.0087102288,
-0.0146203479,
0.2340580076,
0.0700572655,
-0.3331822753,
0.5264035463,
0.3314227164,
-0.5546019077,
0.6423868537,
-0.130726248,
0.1608500034,
-0.7496199012,
0.1531734616,
-0.0133759482,
-0.289255321,
-0.313883692,
-0.1088021845,
-0.1927816719,
0.081359446,
-0.6086884141,
0.5181270838,
-0.1182286069,
0.0153770093,
-0.3614572585,
0.356076926,
0.2439419627,
0.0531321391,
0.3914676309,
0.3805876374,
0.2491873801,
-0.518713057,
0.4470107257,
0.4199152887,
-0.4460624456,
0.6915927529,
-0.651817441,
0.1502676457,
-0.6013580561,
0.3348330557,
-1.0787534714,
-0.7222518921,
0.2035796642,
-0.4387759268,
-0.3262531459,
-0.0809122697,
-0.5669871569,
-0.1509060562,
-0.4325681925,
0.3018581867,
0.1609757841,
-0.3967743814,
0.4744480252,
0.5070475936,
-0.4548656344,
-0.2169383913,
-0.6377682686,
0.3708178699,
-0.0285391081,
-0.7671430111,
0.1826545447,
-0.2453982532,
-0.5717266202,
0.2767662704,
0.0629350469,
-0.2610648572,
-0.0669556558,
0.7307313681,
0.2716561854,
0.0654909387,
0.0364581831,
-0.1628329456,
0.0155158257,
0.2463573366,
-0.1933742613,
0.1729390174,
0.1183887795,
-0.4399469793,
-0.6898362637,
0.3831290603,
0.3952319324,
0.369983077,
0.720646143,
0.0152143454,
-0.7196105719,
0.322855413,
-0.218504861,
-0.0433397666,
-0.3930361569,
0.3134783208,
-0.3936024606,
-0.4690405726,
0.6745141745,
0.3409042954,
0.3972441256,
0.6483948827,
0.5978881717,
-0.4994778037,
1.0096566677,
-0.0417916365,
0.1452399492,
0.1402804554,
0.2174023837,
-0.0772414431,
-0.1513615698,
-0.4213980436,
-0.662763834,
-0.6558380127,
-0.3273955286,
-0.083320491,
0.0919073373,
-0.0804108083,
-0.3260690272,
0.020071663,
-0.2774727046,
0.7346652746,
0.1678513139,
0.2337332368,
0.5357378125,
0.1121647656,
0.1110275164,
-0.4575371444,
-0.4324151576,
-0.7884485722,
0.7895339727,
0.2492812723,
0.2452026606,
0.2135011703,
0.2918104231,
0.4103907049,
0.6151284575,
-0.4132682979,
0.2896799147,
0.0620122105,
-1.0869557858,
-0.521660924,
-0.3730075657,
-0.8714452982,
-0.2146229148,
-0.4100415111,
-0.7603843212,
0.3604591489,
0.1770274192,
-0.0605886728,
0.313254714,
-0.6732864976,
0.5685240626,
-0.0147237163,
-0.3740333021,
-0.0702655464,
-0.6930671334,
0.4889948368,
-0.271355629,
0.7058882117,
-0.2758878767,
-0.0880902559,
0.8712695241,
-0.6985647678,
0.9037963748,
-0.1266750544,
-0.0247256681,
0.3023192585,
0.1591462493,
0.7249327898,
0.3082316518,
-0.1212252602,
0.2400570065,
-0.0558695421,
-0.7320014238,
-0.4424547553,
0.6209408045,
-0.9400393963,
-0.1863753349,
-0.3210339248,
-0.3247179091,
-0.1041972339,
0.0580581501,
0.5899321437,
0.3628016114,
-0.2963143587,
-0.2485857308,
0.4713973701,
0.0318536349,
0.4792920351,
0.630278945,
-0.0438526683,
-0.5009287596,
1.1905688047,
0.381975919,
-0.0278484672,
0.3538856804,
0.2236715108,
-0.4147745967,
-0.5676373839,
-0.1846715063,
0.0894341394,
-0.7748258114,
0.1180401593,
-0.494838506,
-0.1304052621,
-0.117480427,
-0.3335846961,
-0.0216028243,
-0.8671292663,
-0.0646811277,
-0.6062170267,
0.397664845,
0.8473376632,
-0.2091151476,
-0.2182966769,
-0.4955326915,
0.6155144572,
0.2797385454,
0.2463864982,
-0.2409675419,
-0.5962474942,
-0.0255741887,
0.041686181,
-0.1719134897,
-0.9374832511,
-0.1029046774,
0.3331308365,
0.4048088193,
0.6388110518,
0.3635302186,
0.5652518868,
-0.4947374165,
0.8778892159,
0.3021439016,
-1.0659434795,
0.579746902,
-0.3486761153,
-0.1653162241,
0.7110825181,
0.5115298629,
-0.1838799119,
-0.5876891017,
-1.0177990198,
-1.0995897055,
0.5489479899,
0.4059030712,
-0.1161326617,
-0.1118033826,
0.3524914682,
0.5187321305,
0.1625208855,
-0.7280439138,
-0.461492002,
-0.5058339238,
-0.3818078041,
0.0120048709,
-0.1575936824,
-0.2776002586,
-0.2718132138,
0.6310385466,
0.0562564395,
-0.2889244854,
0.4279148281,
-0.2934039235,
-0.2462674677,
-0.1038071737,
0.8175106645,
1.3168928623,
-0.1323684305,
0.5153612494,
0.2148633897,
-0.6155458689,
0.2406598777,
0.2019500285,
-0.4052232206,
0.3887652457,
0.5483324528,
0.5531958342,
0.2955889106,
-0.8575287461,
0.4031146765,
-0.1273782253,
-0.4949204028,
-0.6705426574,
-0.3944999874,
0.0423327759,
-0.0788783506,
0.6859113574,
-0.0509462841,
0.3156253994,
-0.5873095989,
0.4985751808,
0.0090272389,
-0.0650399253,
-0.7721672654,
0.8952934742,
0.2775627971,
-0.1763435304,
0.228793487,
-0.3917085826,
-0.0548940077,
0.425349474,
0.003161839,
0.5247938633,
0.2621420026,
0.3600793481,
0.3447741568,
0.3578296006,
0.0259383768,
0.2673943043,
0.1625273079,
-0.6953229308,
-0.5781101584,
-0.5990109444,
-0.5890086889,
0.3898135722,
-0.3004659712,
0.4657433629,
-0.4136333466,
0.0711887702,
0.5021308064,
0.0224309657,
-0.4074581563,
0.1900778264,
0.1806546897,
0.9749490619,
-1.2749823332,
0.385013938,
1.1216043234,
-0.6763392091,
-0.5544199944,
0.1703981459,
-0.0226607025,
-0.4883481562,
0.4761433601,
-0.2206383348,
0.2132750601,
-0.1950462162,
-0.6186892986,
-0.4314490557,
0.8401297331,
0.6520298719,
-0.5384950638,
-0.0693398267,
0.216274932,
0.3991597593,
0.1079976559,
0.2273990512,
0.3955545425,
0.7943801284,
0.0592994839,
-0.8088116646,
0.1018650457,
-0.3103310764,
-0.3604145944,
0.0096816625,
-0.4963467717,
0.5236931443,
0.0841990486,
-0.3283791542,
-0.0898439214,
0.8597303033,
0.4825858772,
0.8301416039,
0.6008390784,
0.4492256939,
1.0020847321,
-0.2376567125,
0.9181227088,
-0.2031237334,
0.151186198,
1.1369458437,
-0.3514901996,
0.7072083354,
0.407106936,
-0.4731580317,
0.6854237914,
0.5503695011,
0.3110670745,
0.386253804,
0.2726425529,
-0.6621621847,
-0.1203578413,
0.0432650559,
-0.0839448571,
0.3308034539,
0.1646082848,
-0.0631338581,
-0.4665566683,
0.085313566,
0.2226522863,
0.2041582614,
-0.3245897591,
0.7434428334,
-0.2306504101,
-0.4925548434,
0.0841980129,
-0.1426013112,
0.438211143,
-0.3443367779,
-0.0612679943,
-0.2586182952,
-0.3072645664,
-0.730666697,
-1.0406817198,
0.5575174093,
0.1968235373,
-0.5734151006,
0.2022458315,
0.7465339303,
-0.1365250647,
-0.4997399151,
-0.3253530562,
0.2140928209,
0.8359832168,
-0.1572186947,
-0.2930716276,
-0.0794172809,
-0.1990828812,
-0.3187912107,
0.5167959929,
0.9150198698,
-0.2008768618,
0.2415208668,
0.7435029149,
0.1272822767,
-0.0092023006,
-0.1152928397,
0.5900654793,
-0.591127634,
-0.546298027,
-0.973372817,
0.6389304399,
-0.3925301135,
-0.3387059271,
0.5980186462,
0.7597520351,
0.7045994997,
0.2001835853,
1.2886291742,
-0.3079710603,
0.495785296,
-0.1185410172,
0.7356312871,
-0.1605019867,
0.0636747256,
0.0105289267,
-0.3360491395,
-0.1003568172,
0.5978976488,
-0.2231284827,
-0.1875677854,
0.4316198826,
0.4445281923,
0.038814798,
0.2300654352,
0.2484977245,
0.3845391273,
0.0963510051,
0.4411228001,
1.1120269299,
-0.095708169,
0.586042583,
-0.2482836843,
-0.4137537479,
-0.2278222293,
-1.1902470589,
-0.6301997304,
-0.901809454,
-0.7973111272,
-0.6010254622,
0.1371337622,
0.8101053238,
0.3994311094,
-1.1081660986,
0.2562080026,
-0.3712468743,
0.2257923931,
0.0618779548,
-0.331967324,
0.2586305439,
-0.0036751246,
-0.6664754748,
0.1958919466,
0.2529416978,
0.0994034484,
-0.164580822,
0.0312392693,
0.0299404599,
0.2210705131,
0.4231200218,
0.9335781336,
-0.4728804231,
-0.5023244619,
-0.543456614,
0.0919839665,
-0.1774552613,
0.6960352659,
-0.862670958,
0.0926931947,
0.5736504793,
0.1971558481,
0.280275017,
0.0125165507,
0.5569356084,
-0.9973310232,
0.3366212845,
0.2526783943,
0.4075394869,
0.2263402492,
-0.3344223797,
0.3058928251,
0.7118682861,
-0.5117012858,
-1.0768395662,
0.2350741178,
-0.6559964418,
-0.3480190933,
0.7710468173,
-0.1946997494,
-0.0613899454,
-0.8181318045,
-0.16096659,
0.045036152,
-0.1660358608,
1.2181366682,
1.264239192,
-0.5088635087,
0.0846528634,
-0.4995743334,
0.4155973494,
0.0001150594,
-0.7023803592,
0.0118338792,
0.6413456798,
0.439860791,
0.3319123983,
0.513678968,
-0.003349768,
0.3294473886,
0.0779146925,
0.0835043862,
-0.3392785788,
-0.182622686,
-0.2442844063,
0.5786628127,
0.072592862,
-0.0117772724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04031v1
|
Willkommens-Merkel, Chaos-Johnson, and Tore-Klose: Modeling the Evaluative Meaning of German Personal Name Compounds
| 2024-04-05T11:24:41 | 2024-04-05T11:24:41 |
Annerose Eichel, Tana Deeg, André Blessing, Milena Belosevic, Sabine Arndt-Lappe, Sabine Schulte im Walde
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
We present a comprehensive computational study of the under-investigated
phenomenon of personal name compounds (PNCs) in German such as
Willkommens-Merkel ('Welcome-Merkel'). Prevalent in news, social media, and
political discourse, PNCs are hypothesized to exhibit an evaluative function
that is reflected in a more positive or negative perception as compared to the
respective personal full name (such as Angela Merkel). We model 321 PNCs and
their corresponding full names at discourse level, and show that PNCs bear an
evaluative nature that can be captured through a variety of computational
methods. Specifically, we assess through valence information whether a PNC is
more positively or negatively evaluative than the person's name, by applying
and comparing two approaches using (i) valence norms and (ii) pretrained
language models (PLMs). We further enrich our data with personal,
domain-specific, and extra-linguistic information and perform a range of
regression analyses revealing that factors including compound and modifier
valence, domain, and political party membership influence how a PNC is
evaluated.
|
[
-0.4869436324,
-0.9539960623,
0.6573678851,
0.217077747,
-0.2093924135,
0.3219624162,
-0.4067232609,
-0.0938581899,
0.1919919848,
0.2606078088,
-0.4204976559,
-0.5459443927,
-0.9091764092,
0.1755993366,
-0.3559145927,
1.0739600658,
-0.1639110148,
0.2660551071,
-0.0692471191,
0.1522724181,
0.0422316156,
-1.0001213551,
-0.1962166578,
-0.5035113692,
0.9089285135,
0.0695144758,
0.6061142683,
0.1442328095,
0.5654158592,
0.2748782933,
-0.3519361913,
-0.3676960766,
-0.6384154558,
0.0733845383,
-0.3916564286,
-0.204788506,
-0.2980320454,
0.1493310779,
0.5269935131,
1.0521211624,
-0.0068566427,
0.1697127819,
0.0368789248,
0.641866684,
-0.7107496262,
0.2532078624,
-0.3072774112,
-0.0827839598,
-0.1983279884,
-0.063247256,
-0.1676630229,
-0.329023093,
0.322642535,
-0.2160882354,
0.0236268975,
-0.0006391071,
0.9707812071,
-0.3467263579,
-0.6623066664,
-0.3132615685,
-0.9237037301,
0.6431542039,
-0.4471499622,
0.6044854522,
0.2248906344,
0.2810130715,
-0.5279074907,
-0.4729618728,
-0.5910063386,
-0.5413870811,
-0.1587490588,
0.1668766886,
-0.4986192286,
0.3762259185,
0.0956772119,
0.6077862978,
-0.5258966684,
-0.1165207624,
-0.4707456827,
-0.2166608721,
0.6590781808,
0.0814730525,
0.0140761659,
-0.2866173983,
-0.5543287992,
-0.0598968305,
-0.5857884288,
0.1590756327,
0.9477891326,
0.6365588307,
-0.3167197406,
0.5075724721,
-0.4517917037,
0.4910551608,
0.0705354065,
-0.0471890569,
0.4012310505,
-0.2267166972,
-0.4516896605,
0.0109589314,
0.6439582109,
-0.0775063559,
0.3562051654,
-0.3749496937,
-0.0800820738,
0.1785315424,
0.1225609779,
-0.8798338175,
-0.810507834,
0.1591702998,
-0.65729177,
-0.7052870989,
0.3438794017,
-0.69794029,
-0.5036144853,
-0.769557476,
0.4117074907,
-0.0939801782,
-0.3650795221,
0.0700039417,
-0.0615271404,
0.0086547164,
0.4089598954,
-0.3695103228,
0.5073611736,
0.6573569179,
0.2500981987,
-0.4631966054,
-0.3083323836,
-0.3270951211,
-0.4139627814,
-0.2547824085,
0.9659160376,
-0.6652622223,
-0.8935633898,
0.1229599342,
0.2676724792,
0.0705494359,
-0.5410820842,
0.5798883438,
-0.4970465004,
0.441798836,
-0.7135302424,
-0.637021184,
-0.2730859816,
0.034650743,
-0.5804843307,
0.5383918881,
0.4335020483,
-0.6993082762,
0.1313912272,
-0.5188995004,
-0.5477681756,
0.0701413229,
-0.1388875097,
-0.1532266736,
0.5093033314,
-0.535505414,
0.3903629482,
-0.4666074514,
0.3530955017,
-0.3364672959,
0.0608120449,
0.8092334867,
-0.4016101956,
0.8850587606,
0.1128836721,
-0.0428553224,
0.1203879192,
-0.6787208915,
-0.0839116797,
0.0005578632,
-0.3086134493,
-0.1665302217,
0.0147979623,
0.3134822249,
0.3362805247,
0.1219957322,
-0.3860535622,
-0.04078288,
-0.2790855765,
-0.0334082283,
0.9060613513,
0.254907757,
0.2582044601,
-0.2260228395,
0.7563058734,
0.3043113649,
-0.0495023504,
-0.1442492306,
-0.4813678265,
-0.6665807962,
-0.057237491,
0.6966158748,
0.6185061932,
-0.3022329211,
0.3151458204,
-0.2102672458,
-0.446962148,
0.1145438924,
-0.0186018776,
0.5769282579,
0.3606232405,
0.0141576538,
-0.2456440926,
-0.7405770421,
-1.3908182383,
-0.6860918403,
-0.5595089197,
-0.0587385856,
0.5772017837,
0.8219880462,
-0.1871618629,
0.6146214604,
-0.5336350799,
0.131152004,
-0.065434441,
0.4610698819,
0.3206284046,
0.1358812451,
0.1350237876,
-0.7907168865,
-0.4321050346,
-0.1214682981,
-0.1523909718,
-0.2554726303,
-0.0383901782,
-0.1719337851,
-0.0815913156,
-0.0159522537,
-0.2966241241,
0.3063035607,
0.5419473052,
-0.6126737595,
1.1706200838,
0.0229965411,
0.1661267877,
-1.0522488356,
0.226704821,
0.0609418228,
-0.1904253811,
-0.9112986922,
-0.0409722216,
-0.2465305775,
0.1068573445,
-0.7902077436,
0.7061882019,
-0.3535599411,
0.2164312303,
-0.2319246829,
-0.0186203904,
-0.2520029843,
0.5187043548,
-0.2537748218,
0.5878449082,
0.4181359708,
-0.6256974936,
0.5340349078,
0.0928457752,
-0.3109049499,
0.7879855633,
-0.2678754032,
0.0338979512,
-0.1347521245,
0.0925945044,
-1.0406781435,
-0.52700001,
0.418014735,
-0.4194043875,
0.298448652,
0.0930675268,
-0.5930607319,
-0.3771458268,
-0.0679854602,
0.2788312137,
0.4353396595,
-0.4763766825,
0.4318608344,
0.5152021646,
-0.1354034841,
-0.0433888622,
-0.3074857593,
0.2502695024,
-0.5839520693,
-0.3240214586,
0.7043294311,
-0.0642885417,
-0.6571128964,
-0.0421295017,
0.0089198258,
-0.3170444667,
0.2864524424,
0.1803556979,
0.3958799839,
0.1141703576,
0.2467016578,
-0.1109825671,
-0.2650121152,
0.2176974714,
-0.1092496961,
0.4424777329,
-0.4327448606,
0.1309954375,
-0.4013897181,
0.4831072092,
0.2456368655,
-0.0927494392,
0.5572776198,
0.2491090894,
-0.4459702373,
-0.078675352,
-0.3311044276,
-0.2735826671,
-0.394987911,
0.3184334934,
-0.5617182851,
-0.8914272785,
0.716283381,
-0.5370592475,
-0.5300029516,
0.3503383398,
1.0190309286,
-0.1313762665,
0.8940532804,
0.7043110132,
0.0449270494,
0.1441962123,
0.1124859229,
0.5573596954,
-0.7006992698,
-0.0981790945,
-0.4148303568,
-0.3944273889,
-0.9831061959,
-0.3070223927,
0.1475159377,
0.0385195091,
-0.3508820236,
0.3438059092,
-0.2688035965,
0.3264104426,
0.2804889381,
-0.2706452012,
0.1155591458,
0.0936770067,
-0.0758667067,
-0.1607531905,
0.0015432116,
-0.5147134662,
0.8272889853,
0.2516584992,
0.7127395868,
0.0323072746,
0.6055032611,
0.3322025537,
0.3793805242,
-0.6964517236,
0.4229247868,
-0.0633379966,
-0.6054637432,
0.2322793603,
-0.4127387106,
-0.8146263957,
0.2252145857,
-0.1615099758,
-1.1992675066,
0.3393725455,
0.0159349721,
-0.4315085113,
-0.0328783914,
-0.3737700582,
0.8742011786,
-0.5645304918,
-0.254673332,
-0.1143647879,
-0.6005829573,
0.5983021855,
-0.178284049,
0.1784763783,
-0.3826033473,
-0.0384424962,
0.7815371752,
-0.148556307,
0.6887671947,
-0.0277254824,
-0.2040529847,
0.0330894291,
0.2915317714,
0.5266923308,
-0.297837764,
0.1670475155,
0.4653039575,
0.0996014774,
-0.0408554263,
-0.664306283,
0.7053242922,
-0.5636572838,
-0.4345965683,
-0.3382587135,
-0.32997787,
-0.1157896072,
0.12503241,
0.4056577384,
0.0747124031,
-0.6036432385,
0.2396833003,
0.2594639957,
-0.3892100751,
-0.1258192211,
0.7150731087,
-0.6018348932,
-0.5875674486,
1.1012979746,
0.2757311165,
-0.0174522232,
0.1653146595,
0.4204539955,
-0.2901691198,
-0.0924990177,
-0.0061898115,
0.4381865859,
-0.537135601,
0.0065186056,
-0.4581400454,
-0.0924379677,
0.0476308353,
-0.0482495017,
-0.2305929214,
-0.5396808982,
-0.2141952813,
-0.1672054082,
-0.0631672218,
0.476426363,
0.0925838575,
0.614480257,
-0.1472468525,
0.2181636393,
-0.0205905475,
0.5485626459,
-0.476991564,
-0.349488765,
-0.0680123121,
-0.0731039643,
-0.500741601,
-1.5574383736,
0.4209022522,
-0.1002666354,
0.4843078256,
0.6411602497,
0.014580152,
0.4788481295,
-0.3571794331,
0.8321867585,
0.2412943542,
-1.0220293999,
0.1952541471,
-0.442224592,
-0.0908724442,
0.5919393897,
0.2411043197,
-0.9398702979,
-0.2852651477,
-0.9606454968,
-0.9660787582,
0.60861516,
0.5719337463,
0.2981523275,
-0.0677326396,
0.1669023335,
0.1111762747,
0.6545289755,
-0.5691891909,
-0.6037787199,
0.2345423847,
0.0028049822,
0.0696641728,
-0.4332956076,
-0.2144476473,
-0.2635498047,
0.8806228638,
0.151274249,
0.4487918019,
-0.0555259548,
0.1843811721,
-0.2086105347,
0.4282740355,
0.7452534437,
0.5304231644,
0.0530455075,
0.360753864,
0.2676354349,
-0.0859227777,
0.2499899566,
0.2097582966,
0.1403310895,
0.1098789126,
0.0312087126,
0.8534043431,
0.3627005219,
-0.5944159627,
0.5057746172,
0.0307160281,
-0.202336818,
-0.6362295151,
-0.2249969691,
0.1530309767,
-0.0371551886,
0.1448806077,
-0.1347512454,
0.3847644329,
-0.4188527763,
0.1658292264,
0.5011245608,
-0.2245106399,
-0.8111740947,
0.3596250415,
0.0067297528,
-0.7103082538,
0.3331104219,
-0.5162020922,
-1.0241965055,
0.4654997587,
0.4521592259,
1.199652791,
-0.6398509145,
0.3311866522,
0.3244804144,
-0.0550097264,
0.3684869111,
0.4176289737,
-0.1979891211,
-0.6966380477,
0.0702916533,
-0.8021889329,
-0.2636862993,
0.4218420088,
-0.5393869281,
0.5395976305,
-0.1742639691,
-0.3449245095,
-0.0118673034,
0.1124896631,
-0.6869148016,
0.0360544026,
0.7419734001,
0.5950374007,
-0.9766992331,
0.6488961577,
0.6710876822,
-0.0695828125,
-0.8703177571,
-0.0041018385,
0.2446288764,
-0.1432606578,
0.8335879445,
0.1755822003,
-0.041610837,
-0.1095807701,
-0.2530843616,
-1.0831243992,
0.6307107806,
0.2679815292,
-0.3950761557,
-0.1018609405,
0.3096738458,
0.5792602897,
-0.3271818161,
0.1902281791,
0.856808126,
0.9205003381,
-0.0721595585,
-0.8002445698,
-0.1645157188,
-0.4565905631,
0.1296767741,
0.261901468,
-0.3096852303,
1.1069761515,
0.0993571505,
-0.4557126462,
-0.1263100505,
0.5433821678,
0.1281986237,
0.0823767856,
0.4950816929,
0.342859596,
0.9104790092,
-0.1198542714,
1.2820550203,
-0.7292826772,
0.6102476716,
1.0723205805,
-0.2344221026,
0.4735235572,
0.4984093308,
-0.6468476653,
0.7337429523,
0.6501758695,
-0.2172748446,
0.4079749882,
0.6116162539,
-0.2914645672,
-0.193596378,
-0.0816933885,
-0.0841625333,
0.6307258606,
0.3271483779,
-0.6796748042,
-0.4859481752,
-0.0151064703,
0.3537350893,
-0.233725369,
0.0974084437,
0.6555470824,
0.2803609371,
-0.5673663616,
0.4135609865,
0.3188608289,
0.035963688,
-0.3987554312,
0.1208489016,
0.1462028176,
0.2721791565,
-0.1717098206,
-0.5249780416,
0.1575277746,
0.0335011631,
-0.1091373414,
-0.2369808257,
0.5913072824,
-0.3671598732,
-0.7838605046,
0.4559916556,
0.757512629,
0.3112855554,
-0.2372939438,
-0.6982807517,
-0.1773876548,
-0.1055355147,
-0.597069025,
0.302910924,
0.0287173279,
-0.1225356087,
0.2491391003,
0.7676780224,
0.2658398747,
-0.0823364407,
-0.0063650617,
0.8268969655,
-0.5036069751,
-0.5923204422,
-1.1288461685,
0.4923071861,
0.1303894967,
-0.3822156489,
1.0148152113,
0.6868013144,
0.8255243301,
-0.0116613442,
0.7955097556,
0.1074332222,
0.4702186584,
-0.01488923,
0.8465805054,
-0.2455031127,
0.0542503186,
-0.5142408609,
-0.8858827353,
-0.159153372,
0.5074627399,
-0.7130366564,
0.076273188,
0.597340405,
0.6080054641,
0.0430723354,
0.2004248947,
0.4568484128,
0.5300562978,
0.397265017,
0.3057696819,
1.0270308256,
-0.1244471073,
-0.0836723223,
-0.5734282136,
-0.1477985084,
-0.3619431853,
-0.7809665203,
-0.6760067344,
-0.7838689089,
-0.3370286524,
-0.3965465426,
0.116400443,
1.1553635597,
0.4821686447,
-0.8026832342,
-0.4562339485,
-0.2692426741,
0.0613334551,
0.0563419499,
-0.2433237731,
0.4532571733,
-0.2925671339,
-0.6925857663,
0.1722330451,
0.0923125967,
0.0669027716,
-0.4795465171,
-0.0902591199,
0.3857643008,
0.4778056741,
0.6270955205,
0.0907447487,
-1.0504785776,
-0.1310451776,
-0.0816236436,
-0.0573786199,
0.2219635099,
1.011256814,
-0.9493016601,
0.5844990611,
0.6152631044,
0.0883470997,
-0.0188587978,
0.5010492802,
0.5620985031,
-0.2767350972,
-0.1407348216,
0.2686656415,
0.386259973,
0.3495960832,
-0.5213078856,
-0.0226895325,
0.4180828333,
-0.3859786987,
-1.0424839258,
0.5262503624,
-0.7365136743,
-0.286023587,
1.3006137609,
-0.0150200352,
-0.425223887,
0.0223388877,
-0.1396203041,
0.1775493622,
-0.408739835,
0.9298271537,
0.9282441139,
-0.199189499,
0.1403047442,
-0.5591645241,
0.5646606088,
0.0730131567,
-0.6956349611,
0.3459720612,
0.4356698394,
0.1240766048,
0.2726658285,
0.3487048745,
-0.1737875193,
0.3495138586,
-0.2218115032,
-0.0328981839,
-0.0332783088,
-0.509042263,
-0.6089635491,
0.2285415977,
-0.3033366203,
0.260320127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04022v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04022v2
|
Good Books are Complex Matters: Gauging Complexity Profiles Across Diverse Categories of Perceived Literary Quality
| 2024-04-05T11:06:07 | 2024-04-14T17:30:24 |
Yuri Bizzoni, Pascale Feldkamp, Ida Marie Lassen, Mia Jacobsen, Mads Rosendahl Thomsen, Kristoffer Nielbo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we employ a classification approach to show that different
categories of literary "quality" display unique linguistic profiles, leveraging
a corpus that encompasses titles from the Norton Anthology, Penguin Classics
series, and the Open Syllabus project, contrasted against contemporary
bestsellers, Nobel prize winners and recipients of prestigious literary awards.
Our analysis reveals that canonical and so called high-brow texts exhibit
distinct textual features when compared to other quality categories such as
bestsellers and popular titles as well as to control groups, likely responding
to distinct (but not mutually exclusive) models of quality. We apply a classic
machine learning approach, namely Random Forest, to distinguish quality novels
from "control groups", achieving up to 77\% F1 scores in differentiating
between the categories. We find that quality category tend to be easier to
distinguish from control groups than from other quality categories, suggesting
than literary quality features might be distinguishable but shared through
quality proxies.
|
[
-0.2437643409,
-0.5688282251,
0.1688783318,
0.0864696056,
-0.1809335798,
0.4552853107,
0.1082283258,
-0.7194300294,
0.0584099591,
0.5382304788,
-0.2030587047,
-0.4366515577,
-0.9169188142,
0.1144304797,
-0.2930146158,
1.2158634663,
0.0842858478,
-0.0556427799,
-0.3254088759,
-0.4139358401,
-0.1143324673,
-0.432043165,
-0.1616515219,
-0.4343586862,
0.6977710128,
-0.2948731482,
1.2611458302,
0.5249051452,
0.7374663353,
0.262558639,
-0.3463617861,
0.2001129538,
-0.4512118101,
0.2917006016,
-0.6819559932,
-0.7544190884,
-0.0436085649,
0.0839379802,
0.4356518686,
0.7181843519,
0.1903166026,
-0.0846328288,
0.3586229384,
1.0103685856,
-0.465087086,
0.1556369513,
-0.1341643482,
0.0958450139,
-0.3716415465,
-0.4234243929,
-0.5225664973,
-0.6859602332,
0.2170453072,
-0.8142368793,
0.5486824512,
0.408465147,
1.4124644995,
-0.0123449741,
-0.6156201959,
-0.8572657704,
-1.025547266,
0.9486346841,
-0.3842459619,
-0.0717534795,
0.4725131094,
0.0880098864,
-0.3293533325,
-0.3544484079,
-0.436162442,
-0.1855881959,
-0.5228720307,
0.2316649109,
-0.4726476371,
0.0997017696,
-0.1307746768,
0.7890169621,
-0.6339117289,
-0.0546806082,
-0.1424937844,
-0.2078421861,
0.5490543246,
0.1194428802,
0.463083744,
-0.3266593218,
-0.0145764053,
-0.1903370172,
-0.3533708155,
0.8494252563,
0.6949923635,
0.1364812106,
0.3947043419,
0.4772375226,
-0.2728837729,
0.4694674313,
-0.1340417564,
-0.4171972573,
0.312772274,
-0.4979148805,
-0.1250094473,
-0.2438833416,
0.7428349257,
0.17108877,
0.324966222,
-0.1955174357,
-0.3596345186,
-0.1728217453,
0.2530234754,
-0.4701904953,
-0.2751779556,
0.3302609324,
-0.7241029143,
-0.2706624866,
0.2310207188,
-0.5054584146,
-0.5008842945,
-0.4160276949,
0.7665560246,
-0.1909254491,
-0.2813956141,
0.2232298255,
-0.4576661587,
0.101164028,
0.4404134452,
-0.8116490245,
0.2013465464,
0.4780320823,
0.6303703785,
-0.403956145,
-0.1375338733,
-0.2270110995,
0.1228799149,
-0.6257859468,
0.824275136,
-0.3895294666,
-0.0554939248,
0.1212183014,
-0.0256024357,
0.2476071119,
-0.5712302327,
0.8328014612,
-0.4499124885,
0.3852457404,
-0.2206922323,
-0.462667942,
-0.4080222845,
0.3217937052,
-0.9445111752,
0.9506381154,
0.2171836346,
-0.7207832336,
0.5319321752,
0.1395369768,
-0.6138753891,
0.1430518925,
-0.1027490348,
-0.3926037848,
0.2928602695,
0.1574540734,
0.7227932215,
-0.3877266943,
0.3122909665,
-0.1304329336,
-0.3006091714,
0.5289266109,
-0.1922424138,
0.5723868012,
0.3426293433,
-0.1695296317,
0.2034342289,
-0.8480546474,
0.1476738751,
-0.215517655,
-0.4564903975,
-0.7592941523,
0.0129308682,
0.2757952511,
-0.2315286547,
0.1861834377,
-0.1634579599,
0.4044830203,
-0.2091989517,
0.4501199722,
0.3906437755,
0.1032402888,
0.3091028333,
-0.6906170845,
0.5771480799,
0.0956302732,
0.1526004523,
-0.1330372542,
-0.4443764091,
-0.5738039017,
-0.5760479569,
0.4885541201,
0.5489711165,
-0.5435217619,
0.7149789333,
-0.0069506429,
-0.9112742543,
-0.4628022909,
0.0365309231,
0.5614856482,
-0.3857542276,
0.0992261767,
-0.3889768422,
0.5571804643,
-0.7662866116,
-0.640072763,
-0.3246929348,
-0.1341255158,
0.2758124173,
0.2459713221,
0.1424819231,
0.8906409144,
-0.4215986729,
-0.3536722958,
-0.2005987465,
0.4885361195,
0.3983352482,
0.4177698791,
0.6387147903,
-0.9907255769,
-0.1747971922,
0.1797574461,
-0.7390746474,
-0.1242220402,
-0.2749646306,
-0.4285911322,
-0.2813263237,
0.465713203,
-0.4301403761,
0.1176746339,
0.1066352651,
-0.5663471222,
0.7937375307,
-0.2969083488,
0.6952588558,
-0.7259252071,
-0.1267367452,
0.1176048517,
0.245345667,
-0.2287004292,
0.2131428272,
-0.0079907412,
0.211915493,
-0.0776719376,
0.4556756914,
-0.2412505448,
0.1610392481,
0.2950207889,
-0.1887863427,
0.4711049497,
0.4773641825,
-0.2757599652,
0.1860917956,
0.3926097453,
-0.6193552613,
0.2617928088,
-0.1218558475,
-0.7370881438,
0.6748819351,
-0.4610163569,
-0.5236456394,
-0.3155565858,
0.0388596654,
-1.4614511728,
-0.4847504795,
-0.1318328083,
-0.2846700549,
0.5097078681,
0.1041709706,
-0.6861003041,
-0.0881790072,
-0.0182422101,
0.4364044964,
0.2889682949,
-0.1768025607,
0.6336073875,
0.1246362552,
-0.2738375962,
-0.7313622832,
-0.6404151917,
-0.2129184753,
-0.2155892104,
-0.257920593,
0.4078049362,
-0.251123935,
-0.2081712931,
0.1891907454,
0.0026164453,
-0.3724258542,
-0.0548262484,
0.2800457478,
-0.139713347,
-0.1092659608,
0.4876147211,
0.5798438191,
0.0573155694,
-0.3369196355,
-0.1051199958,
0.0656938627,
-0.1085652709,
-0.0917863622,
-0.2964369655,
0.4526557624,
0.8403074741,
-0.4550783932,
0.4498740137,
0.5245367885,
-0.2778990865,
-0.4979295731,
-0.25761953,
0.1936732531,
-0.4182739556,
0.1813706905,
-0.506290257,
-0.9588605762,
0.4278153181,
0.2317772657,
0.0208201092,
0.6329075694,
0.322027266,
-0.2927750051,
0.57034868,
0.7104391456,
0.0513013899,
0.4268598855,
-0.1347751766,
0.253279835,
0.0000383398,
-0.2335341126,
-1.0378248692,
-0.4342438877,
-0.6034266353,
0.0199166648,
0.1718036383,
0.9190901518,
-0.3745493889,
0.1993605644,
-0.8496466279,
0.838814199,
0.7783914208,
0.0393916033,
0.7828457952,
0.2173630595,
-0.0161876921,
-0.1289094687,
-0.2827947438,
-1.0239129066,
1.0217348337,
0.4779206812,
0.9476246834,
0.5190383792,
0.5941867232,
0.8799204826,
0.2704930902,
-0.9498096704,
0.3079929948,
-0.3443585932,
-0.7854201198,
-0.5128070712,
-0.4314873517,
-1.2191705704,
0.2259604782,
-0.114555195,
-0.4661360383,
0.4749571979,
-0.1366747469,
-0.4811987281,
0.1350926459,
-0.4730599821,
0.7571057081,
-0.0889011398,
-0.2196255624,
-0.1768793464,
-0.4971936643,
0.2042498291,
-0.0501161702,
0.3029135764,
-0.1564410031,
0.0286186822,
0.8953158259,
0.129219085,
0.5274968147,
0.4823564887,
0.0775737017,
0.5477383733,
0.6855772734,
0.0329160802,
-0.2634930015,
-0.2178319842,
0.1818404794,
0.5498272181,
-0.8141862154,
-0.6363813281,
0.4454413354,
-1.2595411539,
-0.2209475338,
-0.5918459296,
-0.3038187027,
-0.2697416842,
0.4003229141,
0.5035073161,
0.7671951056,
-0.0702381954,
0.2572763264,
0.5531826019,
-0.3511066735,
0.3401618898,
0.2763947845,
-0.1276125014,
-0.6043877006,
1.0382425785,
0.6038640141,
0.5057999492,
0.784609139,
0.3023613691,
-0.0977750495,
-0.9112964869,
-0.3417174518,
0.1984490156,
-0.8161346316,
-0.0840689838,
-0.660847187,
-0.1801460236,
-0.1531751305,
-0.2651252151,
0.0294595584,
-0.2390560508,
-0.2322690636,
-0.0396730527,
-0.0169693902,
1.0378311872,
0.3464642465,
0.372176528,
-0.735627532,
0.1465904266,
0.3750977218,
0.2459255159,
-0.036260508,
-0.3806400299,
-0.4131582081,
-0.6552138329,
-0.7167581916,
-0.5814326406,
0.5039890409,
0.2562564909,
0.6000639796,
0.5598342419,
0.5586172342,
-0.1123121828,
-0.0382888243,
1.0661327839,
0.1886192709,
-0.8021863699,
0.4044164717,
-0.5514000058,
0.1358681768,
0.6855803132,
0.7988082767,
-0.1120207235,
-0.838609159,
-0.6682868004,
-0.7226213813,
0.4189321101,
0.3953649998,
0.1217214689,
0.2012937814,
0.2743284106,
0.3933693171,
0.5665001273,
-1.1493498087,
-0.1670242697,
-0.1259833276,
-0.3108416796,
-0.4436774254,
-0.2315167487,
-0.2732407749,
-0.1133425832,
0.3093370497,
0.1611653417,
-0.0626628175,
0.2985306382,
0.0868694708,
-0.1676227003,
0.6309568882,
0.37509951,
0.6560175419,
-0.2379213125,
0.3191392422,
-0.7896008492,
-0.6017351151,
0.372602731,
-0.447547853,
-0.0033109176,
0.0777723864,
1.0228996277,
0.325014323,
-0.2728419602,
-0.5224913359,
0.3440084457,
0.2200882882,
-0.1251824796,
0.2198945582,
0.5228890777,
-0.230229944,
0.3933199942,
0.4686729908,
0.3266633451,
0.3113012314,
-0.8572365046,
0.0211328678,
-0.0051140445,
-0.3900325298,
-0.0068431552,
0.096277684,
0.3691338301,
-0.312862277,
0.2346714288,
-0.4090558589,
-0.3587324917,
0.8359634876,
0.2888144255,
0.648999691,
0.1431360692,
0.3376323879,
0.3988063335,
0.6169803739,
-0.1971571743,
-0.1728185564,
0.1625433862,
-0.7075166106,
-0.0268063787,
-1.1230341196,
-0.5824078321,
0.144418627,
-0.5354779363,
0.1229694858,
-0.5312285423,
0.0350268967,
0.1074060947,
-0.0473754294,
-0.4740766287,
0.3632780612,
-0.2829989195,
0.4676445127,
-0.957629323,
0.5909107924,
0.3486838341,
-0.5841671824,
-0.7404453754,
0.2628889382,
-0.1412802339,
0.1509218067,
0.6871714592,
0.2311950773,
-0.0190406367,
0.0855970159,
-0.4059998095,
-0.8171684742,
0.7388179898,
0.1550508589,
-0.5435672998,
0.032327801,
-0.060370449,
0.7427129149,
-0.1788677573,
0.516557157,
0.2106214166,
0.4531193078,
0.0052606747,
-0.8632326126,
-0.5254310966,
-0.3101026118,
-0.189810276,
0.2721252441,
-0.620496273,
0.8043224812,
0.1240229011,
-0.2483650893,
0.1561154425,
0.6525869966,
-0.0546055287,
0.6663119197,
0.1897087395,
0.3562165797,
1.0823005438,
-0.3805204034,
0.8618213534,
0.0236545149,
0.5416500568,
0.7054820061,
0.2517152727,
0.9146109223,
-0.0152397752,
-0.4847951531,
0.639564693,
1.1624462605,
0.0450896025,
0.6211196184,
0.5861790776,
-0.172705695,
-0.4253105521,
0.1263944507,
-0.4514597356,
-0.0454896726,
0.3002489507,
-0.4720775485,
0.0648797899,
0.4678538144,
-0.1914276481,
0.4418344498,
-0.4294279814,
0.6788918972,
0.0311773047,
-0.8888942003,
0.524743855,
0.06718871,
0.6440755129,
-0.6025853753,
0.1774396896,
-0.2439934611,
0.2342818081,
-0.4864526689,
-1.2170866728,
-0.049758222,
-0.4393255115,
-0.9464401007,
-0.0442972742,
0.3350034654,
-0.1795910597,
-0.5725054145,
0.2416200936,
0.3156125247,
0.3567495346,
-0.0470485613,
-0.5727037191,
0.0167725123,
-0.175343141,
-0.537946105,
0.2077135146,
1.0392065048,
0.0366649143,
0.5982526541,
0.3531362116,
-0.053888198,
-0.1174856126,
0.0577539951,
0.1316274256,
-0.8673336506,
-0.7864274979,
-0.4809086323,
0.4328013957,
0.1083857045,
-1.0217140913,
0.770162642,
0.2860058546,
0.8325307965,
-0.1567998677,
0.6048238873,
0.1874884963,
0.3782577813,
-0.4981447756,
0.9436863661,
-0.7439623475,
0.2671154439,
-0.4807477891,
-0.8019619584,
-0.565348208,
0.4196064174,
-0.1452130526,
-0.0002563536,
0.8150269985,
0.7833012342,
0.060453862,
-0.0143012339,
0.4499213099,
0.1573062092,
0.5559278727,
0.3142879009,
0.7923600078,
-0.2718352675,
0.3696048856,
0.2014152557,
-0.6250924468,
-0.3849905729,
-0.8414700031,
-0.8661035299,
-0.9030280113,
-0.6062858701,
-0.7762106061,
-0.055402983,
0.5429323316,
0.4126881063,
-0.7961236835,
-0.1952354014,
-0.0441197939,
0.5129618645,
-0.7016683817,
-0.2813743651,
0.6053636074,
-0.494856298,
-0.6645020247,
-0.3722203374,
0.1717196703,
-0.1390286982,
-0.4518988431,
-0.0197322108,
0.3766540885,
0.5038523674,
0.7174460888,
-0.0299510863,
-0.9659634233,
-0.0508669987,
-0.4237023294,
-0.8365482688,
-0.0159396082,
0.8723576069,
-0.4058867693,
0.7188922167,
0.7606357932,
0.6409662962,
0.1789642423,
-0.3428793252,
0.1688205153,
-0.08937902,
-0.3862706721,
0.4075285196,
0.1439722925,
-0.0332614072,
-0.4669269323,
0.3959907889,
0.5244134665,
-0.8256424069,
-0.7344440818,
0.2421087623,
-1.471380353,
-0.6461434364,
1.0705795288,
-0.2430427969,
-0.2469249219,
-0.3619554043,
-0.5047131181,
-0.2002036721,
-0.158615917,
0.7684874535,
1.4605320692,
-0.2592831254,
0.1159359589,
-0.484364152,
0.7160907388,
0.4330598712,
-0.9281547666,
-0.0107657621,
0.4178642631,
-0.003041605,
0.6239472032,
0.1135743409,
-0.3500243425,
0.0090069845,
-0.2028743923,
0.2126232684,
0.1594912112,
-0.5495647788,
-0.2009066641,
0.976798594,
0.2298086435,
0.3142640293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04003v1
|
BuDDIE: A Business Document Dataset for Multi-task Information Extraction
| 2024-04-05T10:26:42 | 2024-04-05T10:26:42 |
Ran Zmigrod, Dongsheng Wang, Mathieu Sibue, Yulong Pei, Petr Babkin, Ivan Brugere, Xiaomo Liu, Nacho Navarro, Antony Papadimitriou, William Watson, Zhiqiang Ma, Armineh Nourbakhsh, Sameena Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The field of visually rich document understanding (VRDU) aims to solve a
multitude of well-researched NLP tasks in a multi-modal domain. Several
datasets exist for research on specific tasks of VRDU such as document
classification (DC), key entity extraction (KEE), entity linking, visual
question answering (VQA), inter alia. These datasets cover documents like
invoices and receipts with sparse annotations such that they support one or two
co-related tasks (e.g., entity extraction and entity linking). Unfortunately,
only focusing on a single specific of documents or task is not representative
of how documents often need to be processed in the wild - where variety in
style and requirements is expected. In this paper, we introduce BuDDIE
(Business Document Dataset for Information Extraction), the first multi-task
dataset of 1,665 real-world business documents that contains rich and dense
annotations for DC, KEE, and VQA. Our dataset consists of publicly available
business entity documents from US state government websites. The documents are
structured and vary in their style and layout across states and types (e.g.,
forms, certificates, reports, etc.). We provide data variety and quality
metrics for BuDDIE as well as a series of baselines for each task. Our
baselines cover traditional textual, multi-modal, and large language model
approaches to VRDU.
|
[
-0.3546857834,
-0.9046814442,
0.2265518755,
0.4477824271,
-0.5190009475,
0.0330917276,
-0.2145888358,
-0.5790048242,
0.0331780501,
0.5774971247,
-0.5028517842,
-0.5877890587,
-0.5344204307,
0.1096134335,
-0.2723794281,
0.994782567,
0.0141527709,
-0.2053575665,
-0.2099947184,
-0.1243683472,
-0.7414485812,
-0.3075967133,
-0.528949976,
0.0349877588,
0.4228360951,
0.4057407677,
0.1936503947,
0.4081185758,
0.5683445334,
0.2424528748,
0.3101255,
0.3752703667,
-0.5684246421,
0.3959287107,
-0.2977212667,
-0.3002606332,
-0.2691330314,
0.0356793255,
0.5606246591,
0.2185533941,
-0.0984317064,
0.2943913043,
0.0311843157,
0.5184257627,
-0.5569392443,
0.7465427518,
-0.4776644111,
-0.3071412444,
-0.5405250788,
-0.4278642535,
-0.4383634031,
-0.0086112292,
0.0362068489,
-0.8159558177,
0.5951357484,
0.143763721,
1.4432215691,
0.1636538804,
-0.3775152266,
-0.2055425495,
-0.5836164355,
0.676802218,
-0.1713209301,
0.6276754737,
0.3373065889,
0.232011199,
0.0122827766,
-0.9109647274,
-0.5349882841,
0.3044214845,
-0.1092108861,
0.3231276274,
-0.3503761292,
0.0370984077,
0.3359158635,
0.4074196219,
-0.4813723862,
-0.0354906172,
-0.552359879,
-0.0648522153,
0.4018808305,
0.0507195219,
0.0296847317,
-0.6882015467,
-0.4635742903,
-0.3504834473,
-0.2858391404,
0.2207280099,
0.1185273975,
0.152668491,
0.1199721321,
0.4928175509,
-0.1650284678,
0.821141839,
-0.1641509086,
-0.2257123888,
0.1708157361,
-0.8218564987,
-0.7725918889,
0.0772222206,
0.7579027414,
0.1822369546,
-0.0076474412,
-0.3581636548,
-0.1764187515,
-0.0841917694,
0.5816828609,
-0.9387720823,
-0.3182369769,
0.344489783,
-0.5552877188,
-0.1485372484,
0.0990745872,
-0.9435294271,
-0.5254033804,
-0.5170302987,
0.1783365905,
-0.6881295443,
-0.3444332182,
-0.0484569855,
-0.5370292664,
0.3412750065,
0.693877995,
-0.6580617428,
0.1113042161,
0.7494491339,
0.9598542452,
-0.0252181124,
-0.1772479862,
-0.869641304,
0.2883124352,
-0.324943006,
0.9356521964,
-0.5162014365,
-0.4756794274,
-0.2715451717,
0.1306322515,
-0.2091315091,
-0.4209703803,
0.8541331887,
-0.3899464011,
-0.1791012883,
-0.5548069477,
-0.3423944414,
-0.457121253,
0.287537694,
-1.0152846575,
0.8919452429,
0.3480585217,
-1.0327771902,
0.9262626171,
-0.612452507,
-0.3419660926,
0.5866543055,
-0.8073263168,
-0.1866754442,
0.2235163003,
0.3420794606,
0.8357505202,
-0.4805513322,
0.1782226264,
-0.0190784633,
-0.2882947624,
-0.1306616962,
-0.4890508652,
1.013086319,
0.1746075302,
-0.0424506292,
0.1875764281,
-0.8119210601,
-0.284968406,
0.1908757687,
-0.4086740911,
-0.7138462663,
-0.2611049712,
0.718409121,
0.2885679901,
0.1068299413,
-0.7861765027,
0.2997016907,
0.0785183758,
0.2943696678,
0.754273355,
0.1381973177,
-0.1928616613,
-0.2804789543,
0.5063360333,
0.0987339616,
-0.0345753394,
-0.1687835604,
-0.4848898649,
-0.2753276825,
-1.148773551,
0.3574569225,
0.3772351146,
-0.6286797523,
0.1107380986,
-0.7563468218,
-0.5110321641,
-0.955873251,
0.2579107881,
0.0658943877,
0.5210223794,
0.1307826936,
-0.4053357244,
-0.2923968732,
-1.0254743099,
-0.0425308459,
-0.0536033697,
0.238850385,
0.3391852379,
0.284396708,
-0.1389443427,
1.0339028835,
-0.3374045491,
-0.6633618474,
-0.3104082346,
0.6978256702,
0.1983542591,
0.2803198993,
0.5154866576,
-1.3540804386,
-0.2487961352,
0.109388113,
-0.6582926512,
0.4260731041,
-0.6216425896,
-0.357706368,
-0.030796038,
0.2843493819,
-0.7373674512,
0.4491419196,
0.1581522822,
-0.1989859194,
0.4886144996,
-0.2010313272,
0.1832918227,
-1.2725077868,
0.1938406378,
0.5073097944,
-0.3532763124,
-0.4147898555,
-0.045311328,
0.4111357331,
0.0337587185,
0.0154923052,
0.4795869589,
-0.4858252108,
-0.1335021257,
0.0454242527,
0.0241529495,
0.5013022423,
0.5376226306,
0.2882617116,
0.92537117,
0.6032288074,
-0.4369056523,
0.5023774505,
0.6207107306,
-0.6414319873,
0.9995133877,
-0.4609794319,
-0.0337216966,
-0.4652242959,
-0.1494138241,
-0.927519083,
-0.177925691,
0.2007107288,
-0.1868771762,
0.6014696956,
-0.2671971917,
-1.0661252737,
-0.0695861131,
-0.186997503,
-0.0427810214,
-0.0134057971,
-0.4760251641,
0.6877070069,
0.2716573179,
-0.4702501297,
-0.5705436468,
-0.5620393753,
0.2422487736,
-0.1151864529,
-0.6034587026,
0.4152078927,
0.1245101094,
-0.1374619752,
0.3294255137,
-0.3709153235,
-0.4153921008,
0.0949548855,
0.4592892528,
0.4691090882,
-0.0151987895,
0.1378485411,
0.036601156,
0.1239588186,
-0.0025452957,
0.0127202263,
0.2001660615,
-0.121761702,
-0.1578831822,
-0.3075818717,
0.5100551248,
0.5886405706,
-0.70392555,
0.6340110302,
0.9304211736,
-0.511308074,
-0.0817270949,
-0.6061410904,
0.379252702,
-0.3664747179,
0.4999822676,
-0.7567253709,
-0.3673548698,
0.1351679415,
-0.0291760415,
0.6264672279,
0.539501369,
0.4362236261,
-0.026980212,
0.455626756,
0.9747607708,
-0.1083747596,
0.6374041438,
-0.4889666736,
0.2524849474,
-0.7662881017,
-0.5816708803,
-0.5755111575,
0.0431356467,
-0.4092477858,
-0.3734864593,
0.2254622132,
0.2007277608,
0.4047407508,
0.5923531055,
-0.5435433984,
-0.0060180896,
0.7911508679,
0.0775244981,
0.2572561204,
0.1874122471,
0.251537025,
0.037911322,
-0.5145978332,
-0.4017909169,
1.0920137167,
0.1015537456,
0.8049066067,
0.0516045056,
0.7974081039,
0.2808244526,
0.2058619261,
-0.855584383,
0.1662425399,
-0.1553794444,
-0.6955246925,
-0.4299223721,
-0.4131290317,
-0.9679347277,
0.3438129425,
-0.2108807564,
-0.8571021557,
0.6690325737,
-0.220118925,
-0.3380919993,
0.050899826,
-0.8252727985,
1.162650466,
-0.2259724736,
-0.5851870179,
-0.2391380817,
-0.3722104132,
0.2901417315,
-0.3717139065,
0.2090131789,
-0.1207308695,
0.1872445196,
0.8513002396,
0.0042686956,
0.4433781803,
0.0680802539,
0.1000236273,
0.0816543847,
-0.0776315033,
0.4688096642,
0.2488201261,
-0.1371231675,
0.1704583764,
0.4898021519,
-0.5042513013,
-0.5045547485,
0.5027301908,
-0.3641054332,
-0.2682310343,
-0.6715394258,
-0.6520591378,
-0.0516571663,
0.5036793351,
0.2638298571,
0.7805860639,
-0.1040085033,
0.4257436991,
0.7363377213,
0.1083669066,
0.2379938215,
0.1948498338,
0.3082369864,
-0.1853275746,
1.1026213169,
0.3024663031,
-0.2530441284,
0.3704398572,
-0.2399942279,
-0.4740469456,
-0.4146022499,
-0.574975729,
0.1930437535,
-0.9461663961,
-0.1036402062,
-0.9082503915,
-0.1399309486,
-0.4539250731,
0.0341077298,
-0.0489915796,
-0.0147054382,
-0.3742272258,
-0.0916994438,
0.379186213,
0.7650421262,
0.1737001389,
-0.1995409876,
-0.8515174389,
0.7933006287,
0.3061877787,
0.3362357318,
-0.1955119669,
0.0162550155,
-0.3567302227,
-0.2331250012,
-0.1024336666,
-1.0470583439,
0.2977142632,
0.1130141243,
0.758552134,
0.5741564631,
0.0061283675,
0.8647655249,
-0.0778562576,
0.477766484,
0.0340430029,
-0.5393707752,
0.3876960576,
-0.1590839773,
-0.1733197868,
0.782589376,
0.6099635363,
-0.4602381885,
-0.0826199055,
-0.7329261303,
-0.8416987062,
0.834671855,
0.3546120226,
-0.1265041381,
0.0736262575,
0.233329922,
0.4070473909,
0.6069318056,
-0.333614409,
-0.119468689,
-0.4071268737,
-0.2500291467,
-0.0855932236,
-0.1991833746,
-0.1463939995,
-0.1226985827,
0.5272241831,
0.0699992403,
0.2044101208,
0.3025539815,
-0.1925265491,
0.0947133526,
0.3359784484,
0.0692326874,
1.0153810978,
-0.6066612005,
-0.0257510655,
-0.5790668726,
-0.6838314533,
-0.2950584888,
0.6194009781,
-0.0281219296,
0.3332182467,
0.3360486925,
0.8656401634,
-0.1088346019,
-0.7507247925,
0.5383636951,
-0.2929138541,
-0.0789578557,
-0.1158653349,
-0.0858895779,
-0.237387836,
0.2860374451,
0.2307694107,
-0.0625809282,
0.3360112607,
-0.6150425673,
0.1904634386,
0.4323297441,
-0.1964030415,
0.0642487183,
0.6108465791,
0.0045243278,
0.055340752,
0.7668381333,
-0.4224350452,
0.0883943811,
0.4876205027,
0.22684744,
0.8743054867,
0.4067443609,
0.2879087925,
0.275274843,
0.4605343342,
-0.0016258445,
0.5631344318,
-0.4622130096,
-0.343367666,
-0.2991452515,
-0.7515878677,
-0.3424636424,
0.4147080481,
-0.7965450883,
0.2973157465,
-0.3254925311,
-0.1520549059,
0.4998414516,
0.2856163979,
-1.1845539808,
0.3197798729,
-0.1841040403,
0.8730597496,
-0.6149245501,
0.9533669949,
0.7215114236,
-0.9905125499,
-0.540191412,
-0.0086312778,
-0.2124955356,
-0.4693292379,
0.7848601937,
0.2800734639,
0.1041002497,
0.1204480827,
-0.3094800115,
-0.4073904157,
1.0738544464,
0.193188861,
-0.6015245914,
-0.3861891329,
-0.343210429,
0.1343442947,
0.0271511562,
-0.0768140703,
0.4566078186,
0.4013306797,
-0.1083894819,
-0.5320823193,
0.0209394265,
-0.4680589736,
-0.0501591489,
0.1063064337,
-0.5527222753,
0.7030743957,
0.2166710943,
-0.2949462533,
-0.445838958,
0.5315633416,
0.0797718018,
0.0938281268,
0.4685250521,
0.4488856494,
1.0080424547,
-0.0355997607,
1.0454556942,
-0.1438889951,
0.0916511789,
1.1743187904,
-0.1284325868,
0.5988345742,
0.4070000947,
0.1264532208,
0.2927213907,
0.7600437999,
-0.4126717448,
0.4868576527,
-0.0689314529,
-0.035273008,
-0.3612460494,
-0.3488852382,
-0.0746333003,
0.3590850234,
0.4950799346,
-0.0696908236,
-0.2844743729,
0.0043556783,
-0.1840062737,
-0.2510264218,
-0.0494010448,
0.7627097368,
-0.0835999548,
-0.3247501254,
0.1972378492,
0.1405579895,
0.328692317,
-0.6497223377,
-0.2860793471,
-0.005492778,
-0.2797144055,
-0.1542092413,
-0.877594173,
0.041267179,
0.2200855315,
-0.2100711614,
-0.4124719203,
0.740591228,
-0.2160712779,
-0.5095645189,
0.0549809225,
0.3331001997,
0.2654187381,
-0.440544188,
-0.647508204,
-0.020148728,
-0.2626085877,
-0.279447794,
0.1006574631,
0.9284715056,
-0.1112513468,
0.4372525513,
0.5533094406,
0.2847580016,
0.2023514509,
0.0562876016,
0.8726984262,
-0.5533745289,
-0.6461622119,
-0.4855052233,
0.3732660711,
-0.4688900113,
-0.3265628517,
0.6742795706,
0.9078407288,
0.8672577143,
0.141499728,
1.1941708326,
-0.2176140547,
0.1447817087,
-0.4536910355,
0.5702163577,
-0.8878060579,
-0.2426698804,
-0.4657995403,
-0.8015983701,
0.1797662973,
0.4226476848,
-0.0494123697,
-0.3022518456,
0.6347357631,
0.5510708094,
-0.3964606225,
0.0225718096,
0.1897634268,
-0.0260314699,
0.4474822581,
0.3300303519,
0.2375682592,
-0.2355451435,
0.7703989148,
-0.4913012087,
-0.18002069,
-0.2593320906,
-0.6248965263,
-0.8996533155,
-0.9876399636,
-0.473401159,
-0.247673884,
-0.1658341736,
0.8902872801,
0.8379698992,
-0.4799826145,
0.0314464457,
-0.0923791379,
-0.0063857362,
-0.5505251884,
-0.2350027859,
0.6513860822,
-0.3566608429,
-0.8082074523,
0.3307307959,
0.5770879984,
-0.0712123811,
-0.0020509558,
0.3981793225,
-0.404904604,
-0.051674176,
0.4018473625,
0.211049214,
-0.561814785,
0.1477957517,
-0.1378725767,
-0.3112236857,
0.3433991075,
0.7279583216,
-0.4411141276,
0.9982508421,
0.4959377348,
1.014081955,
0.7335758209,
0.108560726,
0.2211272568,
-0.757098794,
0.1515647471,
0.0192206725,
0.3854897618,
0.333271265,
-0.5923640132,
0.4557928443,
0.4484578073,
-0.0618770048,
-0.6740891933,
0.0421759635,
-1.3890448809,
-0.3867168128,
0.814804256,
-0.1540795714,
-0.3014624715,
-0.3841556609,
-0.4997570217,
0.4706957638,
-0.4995975196,
0.5556410551,
0.9492029548,
-0.0284242667,
-0.2484635115,
-0.9586062431,
0.399294883,
-0.0145779112,
-0.9489902854,
0.345670253,
0.6664848328,
0.0474624038,
0.1776402593,
0.9934799671,
0.0178550463,
0.4150750339,
0.1969966441,
0.0738438889,
-0.4902237356,
-0.5958404541,
-0.1388432086,
0.3772177696,
0.0456445999,
-0.5857443213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03987v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03987v1
|
Investigating the Robustness of Modelling Decisions for Few-Shot Cross-Topic Stance Detection: A Preregistered Study
| 2024-04-05T09:48:00 | 2024-04-05T09:48:00 |
Myrthe Reuver, Suzan Verberne, Antske Fokkens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For a viewpoint-diverse news recommender, identifying whether two news
articles express the same viewpoint is essential. One way to determine "same or
different" viewpoint is stance detection. In this paper, we investigate the
robustness of operationalization choices for few-shot stance detection, with
special attention to modelling stance across different topics. Our experiments
test pre-registered hypotheses on stance detection. Specifically, we compare
two stance task definitions (Pro/Con versus Same Side Stance), two LLM
architectures (bi-encoding versus cross-encoding), and adding Natural Language
Inference knowledge, with pre-trained RoBERTa models trained with shots of 100
examples from 7 different stance detection datasets. Some of our hypotheses and
claims from earlier work can be confirmed, while others give more inconsistent
results. The effect of the Same Side Stance definition on performance differs
per dataset and is influenced by other modelling choices. We found no
relationship between the number of training topics in the training shots and
performance. In general, cross-encoding out-performs bi-encoding, and adding
NLI training to our models gives considerable improvement, but these results
are not consistent across all datasets. Our results indicate that it is
essential to include multiple datasets and systematic modelling experiments
when aiming to find robust modelling choices for the concept `stance'.
|
[
-0.4752641618,
-0.7008249164,
0.6771001816,
0.0478833951,
-0.3664483428,
-0.4578005672,
-0.0803341568,
-0.1957074702,
0.088092573,
0.3611706793,
-0.4872709811,
-0.7959009409,
-1.0057418346,
0.0684051365,
-0.2023341209,
1.0804892778,
0.0864697397,
0.4558552504,
-0.1018415242,
-0.6543325186,
-0.1867678463,
-0.2871685922,
-0.5014752746,
-0.2069221437,
0.3815628886,
0.1715273708,
0.8365027905,
0.252723217,
0.4746187627,
0.1884545833,
-0.2867330611,
-0.2347624749,
-0.3595977426,
-0.2915974259,
-0.2682300806,
-0.7719074488,
-0.620932281,
0.1705744714,
0.7779297829,
0.5264467001,
0.1066095531,
-0.016194243,
0.0585131831,
0.4460414052,
-0.7393516302,
-0.375033766,
-0.6778515577,
-0.0196024254,
-0.3007408381,
0.2740419805,
-0.4733700752,
0.1255840063,
0.1535471082,
-0.3562112749,
0.0534611531,
-0.0698466972,
1.0776233673,
0.1538721323,
-0.4570207298,
-0.0152124604,
-0.4854347706,
1.1216014624,
-0.9852441549,
0.6015257239,
0.5011994243,
0.1316577643,
-0.0475535765,
-0.1202793121,
-0.5588405728,
-0.0283290092,
-0.0918136537,
0.1092139333,
-0.6471034288,
-0.0627505481,
0.3665780723,
-0.0095766671,
-0.5840274692,
0.4027436078,
-0.0166456494,
-0.1126064062,
0.2837438583,
-0.0009892019,
0.0716070384,
-0.5893181562,
-0.4765999317,
0.1341563761,
-0.6616458893,
0.2572242618,
0.8165742159,
0.5102261901,
-0.5685067177,
0.8406426907,
-0.2416290045,
0.796603322,
0.4734350741,
-0.264945507,
-0.0410405993,
-0.4002042711,
-0.2889763713,
-0.3266273439,
0.8066875935,
0.3118098378,
-0.101285927,
0.1568794698,
-0.0839812905,
0.1078867689,
0.3850714564,
-0.5067402124,
0.0389602408,
0.3042488694,
-0.6769396663,
-0.361307621,
0.0677642077,
-0.4370862544,
-0.4716648459,
-0.2663303614,
0.2884615958,
-0.5715284348,
-0.3511329889,
0.2487111241,
-0.0868106112,
0.613224268,
0.3514172435,
-0.6585767865,
-0.0413866229,
0.9592937827,
0.7473394871,
-0.5539916754,
-0.2476563305,
-0.4820393324,
-0.1003391445,
-0.3595795333,
0.9256200194,
-0.5910757184,
-0.369540602,
-0.1603523493,
-0.2132083774,
0.0583346486,
-0.1415356398,
0.6028569937,
-0.4423206449,
0.3002371788,
-0.2959628105,
-0.6437440515,
-0.0734493732,
0.8821237683,
-0.6926631331,
0.7242776752,
-0.1008362025,
-1.3489478827,
1.0505206585,
-0.3551923335,
-0.2949153483,
-0.4958370328,
-0.436591953,
-0.658729732,
0.1560543031,
0.2980979383,
0.3587948978,
0.107760258,
0.2312725633,
-0.7239950895,
0.0298125688,
0.17322056,
-0.3800831735,
0.8634000421,
-0.1128251329,
-0.106914565,
0.2944091558,
-0.6866827011,
-0.3462565839,
-0.199068144,
-0.4941399992,
-0.5072788596,
-0.0414478704,
-0.1531094164,
0.2164306194,
-0.1682415009,
-0.3116814494,
0.2496182173,
-0.4659698009,
-0.119984746,
0.4190390706,
0.0866419822,
0.7090401053,
-0.3532912135,
0.7092605233,
0.4253593385,
0.0991936624,
0.081246838,
-0.5578237176,
-0.595664978,
-0.3614753187,
0.3870960474,
0.3360875845,
-0.5453996658,
0.3830506802,
-0.111772947,
-0.2113901228,
-0.3223615885,
0.1224175245,
0.3293233812,
0.4330235124,
0.1481309086,
-0.4579139948,
-0.6372208595,
-0.9898803234,
-0.7816448808,
-0.3626691997,
0.2560877502,
0.0688333362,
0.4864988029,
-0.1918564439,
1.1284056902,
0.0510455817,
-0.1430575252,
-0.672991693,
0.5038560033,
0.3049082756,
0.2653532922,
1.0183968544,
-0.8178335428,
-0.3723133206,
-0.2310831994,
-0.594345212,
0.2931622565,
-0.3374707401,
-0.3009490967,
0.3635861278,
0.0104092751,
-0.7714083195,
0.7005777955,
0.4112451375,
-0.0096400753,
0.3090008795,
0.2401175648,
0.0891848356,
-1.1414263248,
-0.2434400022,
0.5032432079,
-0.3249422014,
-0.6396715045,
-0.0106954854,
-0.2434039265,
-0.0017322197,
-0.8477506042,
0.4202534556,
-0.2769775987,
-0.3804062903,
-0.4338553548,
0.0504271388,
0.0807653591,
0.2416646779,
0.4112897515,
0.4962448478,
0.8499753475,
-0.5757039785,
-0.2273092568,
0.2319134325,
-0.2648547292,
0.8713544607,
-0.5080950856,
0.1018351093,
-0.1773314923,
0.3404117525,
-1.0695322752,
-0.1366307288,
0.4546297491,
-0.3959982097,
0.3571723998,
-0.9240043163,
-0.0611799285,
-0.0129524544,
-0.5382183194,
0.1075892225,
0.0611394495,
-0.3198925257,
0.862326026,
0.4406008422,
0.0799985602,
-0.945509553,
-0.7310002446,
-0.1478090584,
-0.5411546826,
-0.486694634,
0.0524435751,
0.2941818833,
-0.4677179158,
-0.0360200778,
-0.3968294561,
-0.0073234746,
0.0288682655,
0.2486706078,
0.320269078,
-0.3798747659,
-0.1699141115,
-0.1256344467,
-0.1883924752,
-0.1707496494,
-0.3468655646,
0.4531219006,
-0.1704068482,
-0.7096147537,
-0.5904524326,
0.3058567941,
0.599219799,
-0.0487604849,
0.7628589869,
0.9002971053,
-0.3214396834,
-0.1401082873,
-0.357731998,
-0.0257334877,
-0.3771201074,
0.1857089251,
-0.4004630744,
-0.4341519475,
0.4099803567,
0.1544988155,
0.0953939185,
0.1936561167,
0.6703786254,
-0.3625120819,
0.898923099,
0.8332381845,
-0.4984129965,
0.5553594232,
-0.4745276272,
0.1775341332,
-0.5499236584,
0.2178120464,
-0.5196775794,
-0.4011214674,
-0.6589655876,
-0.4353318214,
0.2288915217,
-0.02857011,
0.1080019325,
0.4159437418,
-0.0628922954,
0.3018216193,
0.4181605279,
0.1388026625,
0.2545984685,
-0.0530811176,
0.0295097157,
-0.1409277767,
-0.6264715195,
-0.7461392879,
1.3087514639,
0.2587542534,
0.9142755866,
0.0641535968,
0.9510084391,
0.1691530645,
0.1154242977,
-1.1447826624,
0.406193763,
-0.2346992493,
-0.6599069238,
-0.1238609776,
0.0652403235,
-0.7303085923,
0.339337796,
-0.5692285895,
-0.5486806035,
0.4500900507,
0.2232313454,
-0.4799575806,
0.4577273428,
-0.3246545494,
0.9619732499,
-0.3749495447,
-0.5616200566,
-0.2859928012,
-0.5649251342,
0.2772930264,
0.2461753488,
0.0542921573,
-0.0836691931,
0.0752084851,
0.5818136334,
0.0168189649,
1.1356304884,
-0.2602467835,
-0.1054934785,
0.3105809987,
-0.0338600762,
0.3646884263,
0.2267300338,
-0.3521502316,
0.2293372303,
-0.1013913676,
-0.3992138803,
-0.390014559,
0.4177474976,
-0.7991779447,
-0.9529936314,
-0.5545517206,
-0.2963462472,
-0.4177334905,
0.3294081092,
0.5395004749,
0.3434614837,
-0.4971322715,
0.2679917216,
0.4019036293,
0.1091109887,
0.2550731599,
0.5227268934,
-0.1798184961,
-0.0647705942,
0.4012801051,
-0.1311999261,
0.1772464663,
0.4299289882,
0.3099418283,
-0.2306600213,
-1.0719957352,
-0.3176092803,
0.0766606331,
-0.7115949392,
-0.0080393991,
-0.5470573902,
0.2409185916,
-0.327383697,
-0.1414825171,
-0.5857841969,
-0.3347751796,
-0.2174126208,
-0.2874810398,
0.1231344566,
0.472460866,
-0.0728667974,
0.4081082642,
-0.4611735344,
0.6841616035,
0.0907003582,
0.0628432035,
-0.5541368723,
-0.5061516762,
0.0168118328,
0.151301384,
-0.3398119211,
-0.9696867466,
0.1365690678,
-0.1044245884,
0.767537415,
0.6742135882,
0.0987291485,
0.5063726902,
-0.0940486789,
0.746109426,
0.1339803636,
-0.7975997925,
0.7708181143,
-0.557094872,
0.0319074132,
0.8448665738,
0.8452436328,
0.1272747517,
-0.3997436464,
-0.5254232883,
-0.4025706649,
0.9300928712,
0.133801505,
0.1030827761,
0.1888596117,
0.0540765561,
0.3593646884,
0.1287110746,
-0.8784589767,
0.0595036857,
-0.2383980155,
0.0716884807,
0.2167104185,
-0.065184921,
-0.4828842282,
-0.1184807345,
0.6341718435,
-0.2777410746,
0.0772482604,
-0.0853797644,
-0.2983195186,
0.0433344729,
0.5170660615,
0.3480339348,
0.623357594,
-0.1547152996,
-0.0626101047,
0.2196441293,
-0.1663084477,
-0.0573550612,
-0.1491051912,
-0.3935889006,
0.2426853925,
0.4101076424,
1.1068680286,
0.3144684434,
-0.0985270739,
0.6399085522,
0.0442708619,
-0.0131540205,
0.0129764434,
-0.0107040321,
-0.0879839659,
0.2869563699,
-0.2406251729,
0.4406195879,
0.2026780695,
-0.7576192617,
0.1913904697,
0.8602250814,
-0.1660362482,
-0.4678398967,
0.4319173098,
-0.0411105566,
-0.0455927886,
0.144508779,
-0.1639196277,
-0.4381981492,
0.5303716063,
0.2753732502,
0.7791410089,
0.3701792657,
0.3423812091,
0.2713533342,
0.1148116663,
-0.1019816324,
0.2142427266,
-0.0627889708,
-1.0781466961,
-0.0112327235,
-0.3305382431,
-0.6240434647,
0.1550670564,
-0.9732103348,
0.8711546659,
-0.5227174759,
-0.7411142588,
0.2528924644,
-0.0962557048,
-0.7732765675,
0.0616990924,
0.388661325,
0.7546099424,
-1.0224596262,
0.8696664572,
1.0907652378,
-0.3748065829,
-0.5881240368,
0.594072938,
0.6151723266,
-0.547981739,
0.2736919522,
-0.0836670324,
-0.4463124275,
-0.5847367048,
-0.4798526168,
-0.587233007,
0.80060637,
0.3322228193,
-0.3602492809,
-0.0254186206,
0.0643168837,
0.4514547884,
-0.4841292202,
0.1201985851,
0.4367489815,
0.4616697729,
0.0488019362,
-0.6560162902,
-0.4342834353,
0.1922018528,
-0.1618254334,
-0.1630998254,
-0.663779676,
0.7820076942,
-0.1919380128,
-0.0805074945,
-0.001248331,
0.5221764445,
0.4801069796,
0.512640655,
0.5752630234,
0.6479218006,
0.3972786069,
0.1175733656,
1.1696270704,
-0.2564875484,
0.3475838304,
1.0395239592,
-0.4159786701,
0.9805800915,
0.5479079485,
-0.2971175611,
0.4787937999,
0.5215560198,
0.028771678,
0.5365117192,
-0.483591944,
0.0638189539,
-0.5974126458,
0.1174937487,
-0.0801327825,
0.8674856424,
0.2436021268,
-0.136689961,
-0.4462608099,
-0.0005480792,
0.0552384071,
0.0695625246,
-0.0764088482,
0.7129568458,
0.0639395937,
-0.6906028986,
0.3199332356,
0.147037074,
0.8904060125,
-0.6887505054,
0.3816240132,
-0.1451853365,
0.1170971319,
-0.3595274985,
-0.9311010242,
0.4174607694,
0.247701183,
-0.2970163822,
-0.1329746246,
1.0406906605,
-0.1788033992,
-0.5444203615,
0.2007679939,
0.7760327458,
-0.0175554492,
0.2864377797,
-0.7931396961,
0.2868598402,
-0.0944947675,
-0.3201555908,
0.5418941379,
0.3231321871,
-0.2755158544,
0.3469288945,
0.5682836175,
0.0473953336,
0.0245788116,
0.2121563554,
0.8059270978,
-0.2825407982,
-0.6341128349,
-0.8617307544,
0.5124360323,
0.0435321927,
-0.3741396368,
0.8944737315,
0.4522866309,
0.8715034723,
-0.0723190308,
0.7604520917,
0.0479868054,
0.2451957017,
-0.6503564715,
0.476922214,
-0.5217812061,
0.3847908974,
-0.2869518995,
-0.5821183324,
-0.3432285488,
0.7482696772,
-0.6873186231,
-0.0129416417,
0.3256316185,
0.8119500279,
-0.458606869,
0.0336073861,
0.2004568577,
-0.0977895036,
0.0765228942,
0.257497102,
0.900429368,
-0.2453165501,
0.3580679893,
-0.2930561304,
0.2069318295,
-0.179605335,
-1.1023757458,
-1.1904839277,
-0.3371554315,
-0.5533723831,
-0.2250782549,
0.0266569015,
0.8430688381,
1.1299095154,
-0.9980228543,
0.005294641,
-0.0101246973,
0.3009422123,
-0.1454704851,
-0.1196203977,
0.1469811946,
-0.2013303488,
-0.7888243198,
0.4816741943,
0.2014966458,
0.0146319028,
-0.0987270102,
-0.0801371261,
-0.4713897705,
0.1654763669,
0.4140402377,
0.4391297102,
-1.0074260235,
-0.3623352647,
-0.0185178034,
-0.1027923822,
0.3949492276,
0.9071515799,
-0.6207979918,
0.3129627705,
0.7166242599,
0.5868635178,
0.6626957655,
0.4234879613,
0.495541662,
-1.0319051743,
0.5411533713,
0.1906453967,
0.6071696281,
0.4108601511,
-0.1729915142,
0.2736027837,
0.1905877441,
0.0808970705,
-0.805660665,
0.402638644,
-1.1952489614,
-0.1351214945,
1.2592914104,
-0.3091523051,
-0.0937537104,
-0.0833447874,
-0.1526498944,
0.1792561114,
-0.2497675121,
0.3643533289,
0.9121266007,
-0.4776719213,
-0.1617806256,
-0.2638808191,
0.2212375998,
0.5088150501,
-0.4938527644,
-0.2558946908,
0.4923151433,
0.4679045677,
0.1674285829,
0.4945340455,
-0.0210285969,
0.2395033687,
0.0109093143,
-0.4844740927,
0.1888642013,
-0.4197696447,
-0.6346598268,
0.0636101142,
0.1854241788,
-0.3904969394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03977v1
|
SEME at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Comparing Masked and Generative Language Models on Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials
| 2024-04-05T09:18:50 | 2024-04-05T09:18:50 |
Mathilde Aguiar, Pierre Zweigenbaum, Nona Naderi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes our submission to Task 2 of SemEval-2024: Safe
Biomedical Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials. The Multi-evidence
Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trial Data (NLI4CT) consists of a
Textual Entailment (TE) task focused on the evaluation of the consistency and
faithfulness of Natural Language Inference (NLI) models applied to Clinical
Trial Reports (CTR). We test 2 distinct approaches, one based on finetuning and
ensembling Masked Language Models and the other based on prompting Large
Language Models using templates, in particular, using Chain-Of-Thought and
Contrastive Chain-Of-Thought. Prompting Flan-T5-large in a 2-shot setting leads
to our best system that achieves 0.57 F1 score, 0.64 Faithfulness, and 0.56
Consistency.
|
[
0.0431836434,
-0.8434875011,
0.6559971571,
0.5369082689,
-0.2409063429,
-0.203980118,
-0.1249059215,
-0.5607970953,
0.1497154385,
0.8170764446,
-0.331782639,
-0.5351673365,
-0.5651715398,
0.3919549584,
-0.2868281901,
0.8385497332,
-0.2054055482,
0.3102054894,
-0.2709019184,
-0.1903552711,
-0.6790855527,
-0.3947759271,
-0.8158957958,
-0.3540227413,
0.4855976701,
0.1181086078,
0.3896450996,
0.3892123997,
0.57099998,
0.2094099373,
0.1254619062,
0.0111769298,
-0.2508602738,
0.3663266301,
-0.2343987674,
-0.4188740253,
-0.5484948158,
0.1631120592,
0.1238758489,
0.6725518703,
-0.2052230239,
-0.3007576168,
0.1136474982,
0.3136896491,
-0.6655105948,
-0.0914027467,
-0.611694932,
0.0207275972,
-0.0194259994,
-0.103729561,
-0.6822007895,
-0.495064646,
0.2255017906,
-0.6284292936,
0.3456540406,
0.1163709536,
0.7672532201,
0.198300153,
-0.7439606786,
-0.4734778702,
-0.3480212986,
0.7968904376,
-1.0491601229,
0.328424871,
0.8348820806,
0.1203085706,
-0.0497398786,
-0.9191630483,
-0.428381741,
-0.3022243977,
0.0018622739,
0.4492481053,
-0.11586456,
0.2918220758,
0.2183575779,
0.1212621257,
-0.6519176364,
0.0882637948,
-0.3152691722,
-0.3409411609,
0.5763403177,
-0.0072871898,
0.1749475151,
0.0505281277,
-0.4736955464,
0.0544940121,
-0.8651528358,
-0.405886054,
0.0737271085,
0.1589578539,
-0.1117447838,
0.6303765774,
-0.4003295004,
0.4681638777,
-0.0795348659,
0.2808324397,
0.3536126316,
-0.70167768,
-0.5126268268,
0.1532950699,
0.8931460381,
0.7719862461,
0.1312768608,
-0.3002687097,
-0.0459966809,
0.2526691258,
0.4094663262,
-0.7178952098,
-0.0638068393,
0.4442489445,
-0.5160821676,
-0.4634557366,
-0.0350445583,
-0.8825902343,
-0.4011227489,
-0.2132294327,
1.0027631521,
-0.4182600975,
-0.0334705412,
0.3382805884,
-0.3502725661,
0.1390018761,
0.4720528722,
-0.6856349111,
0.4925367534,
0.7214841247,
0.5778744817,
-0.1619739085,
-0.1211730614,
-0.7321317196,
0.1406271756,
-0.3929421306,
0.8000295162,
-0.3866834641,
-0.2042022198,
0.1310004443,
0.2181973606,
-0.382755667,
-0.5391340852,
1.0031877756,
-0.2456810474,
0.6180543303,
-0.4637562037,
-0.8791642189,
-0.1371998638,
0.2351471484,
-0.463545382,
0.9148246646,
-0.1486862302,
-0.6554169655,
0.4530128241,
-0.6724533439,
-0.6211212277,
0.1041394919,
-0.1436286122,
-0.4814002812,
0.1212535128,
0.1275263876,
0.3153477907,
-0.24044393,
0.503988564,
-0.4269132912,
-0.1848263144,
0.1946735084,
-0.4655148983,
0.7027562261,
0.2677410245,
-0.8170461059,
-0.0463237725,
-0.4624516964,
0.0286338553,
0.1147314981,
-0.0783721656,
-0.3322805464,
-0.1830409169,
0.0637650788,
0.1221925616,
-0.0350799859,
-0.8055927753,
-0.137304157,
-0.5960305333,
0.5160245299,
0.429338932,
0.170044288,
0.1542012095,
-0.2918910384,
0.3351030946,
-0.131362319,
0.087561205,
-0.1000822335,
-0.7149467468,
-0.80165869,
-0.0222433191,
0.6283205152,
0.419416517,
-0.7504177094,
0.3298435807,
0.0012178712,
-0.1009764522,
-0.3209529817,
-0.4504191875,
0.5960521698,
0.4274438918,
0.3732408285,
-0.2521427274,
-0.7156156301,
-1.1866055727,
-0.2650765479,
-0.0089240521,
-0.251932323,
-0.006669227,
0.9052667618,
-0.2755385935,
0.4953664541,
-0.1393607408,
-0.2141803503,
-0.1891508698,
0.4978218973,
-0.0186641626,
0.6918514371,
0.4344587326,
-0.4845660627,
-0.2516918182,
-0.1498787105,
-0.8823106885,
-0.446518451,
-0.1822621226,
-0.202944383,
0.1322447509,
0.6462045312,
-0.3819522262,
0.8258619905,
0.3879328966,
-0.5287525654,
0.212065205,
-0.3094595075,
0.5940744877,
-1.0221506357,
0.012765591,
-0.1080832779,
-0.3950100541,
-1.0429626703,
0.0311407074,
0.1517423242,
0.3050789237,
-0.2283696383,
0.4915881157,
-0.2761321664,
0.1709441692,
-0.2587423623,
-0.1878291219,
0.3651013672,
0.2322776318,
0.0781228095,
0.6343948841,
0.3342037201,
-0.4362410307,
-0.2064805329,
0.4220274389,
-0.2422528416,
0.3837295473,
-1.0415079594,
0.3257041574,
0.0567255877,
0.1522827148,
-0.7356908917,
-0.4331977665,
0.0094849011,
-0.3534522653,
0.197437346,
0.1984710693,
-0.4326881766,
-0.2733328342,
-0.3751993477,
0.3610132635,
0.4377820194,
-0.1531956792,
0.3061572909,
0.3691633344,
-0.1367440969,
-0.268766284,
-0.950248003,
0.3620009422,
-0.0747080296,
-0.3744715452,
0.4870451987,
-0.0365462899,
-0.2772725523,
-0.1780944765,
-0.1231476888,
-0.2774318457,
-0.0279186256,
0.1911569536,
0.1123972684,
-0.3526391983,
-0.1247548163,
0.1504048705,
-0.0054388875,
0.1692441106,
0.0363362394,
0.2711234689,
-0.0594379939,
-0.6011846662,
-0.4527532756,
0.7419932485,
0.3422834575,
-0.1080468372,
0.6516259909,
0.2760094702,
-0.8197544813,
0.190235883,
-0.8089886308,
-0.2733984888,
-0.3889809847,
0.0366551876,
-0.2078528553,
-1.0794850588,
0.2699226141,
0.2279118448,
0.0745906755,
0.5503388047,
0.7837563753,
-0.1092514694,
1.1336561441,
0.2176224291,
0.5079950094,
-0.036075674,
-0.0050891191,
0.3138598502,
-0.7913251519,
-0.3023897111,
-0.5978039503,
0.0706318095,
-0.2376147807,
-0.532353878,
0.5105237961,
0.0772998855,
-0.2706000209,
0.3013884127,
-0.3543196619,
0.2906944752,
0.5900105834,
0.3117409945,
0.1588254124,
0.0199679974,
-0.2961579561,
-0.1722222716,
-0.5330924988,
-0.4974945188,
1.1624467373,
0.4542960525,
0.3502882123,
0.1469028294,
0.593325913,
0.269662112,
0.2191949934,
-0.405594945,
0.4155386686,
-0.1073783785,
-0.7763016224,
-0.0829174742,
-0.0387057364,
-0.9495776892,
0.2923547626,
-0.2357013822,
-0.6834760904,
0.1854023784,
-0.0412110202,
-0.4323907495,
-0.1415841728,
-0.7204967141,
0.9732117057,
-0.0608309507,
-0.4605790973,
-0.0291009191,
-0.856990397,
0.460411042,
-0.0743528083,
0.058697354,
-0.1556682885,
0.0031573514,
0.7790592909,
-0.4165806174,
0.781462431,
-0.001499864,
0.1234704927,
0.3291417658,
-0.0116897365,
0.5079009533,
0.0950691849,
-0.3519237339,
0.1627907753,
0.2121167928,
-0.2985901833,
-0.4694395959,
0.3641673326,
-0.3491869867,
-0.4085063636,
-0.5877840519,
-0.2103338242,
-0.2246481925,
0.2749526799,
0.5552678108,
0.8375585079,
-0.3421725631,
0.4481657743,
0.7213510275,
-0.3991768956,
0.1600013822,
0.4359400868,
0.1511532962,
-0.532705307,
0.449776113,
-0.3005973995,
0.5426476598,
0.4163531661,
0.2441996336,
-0.5584193468,
-0.8159313202,
-0.1321695596,
0.2319235802,
-0.58521384,
-0.2689289153,
-0.9416077733,
-0.3219161928,
-0.8046981096,
-0.0834596083,
-0.3442632556,
-0.2742756307,
-0.0330426581,
-0.0644455701,
0.0377155989,
0.751090765,
0.0389731675,
0.0467315391,
-0.5601667166,
0.3314775229,
0.13014853,
0.1074177101,
-0.5962751508,
-0.5646842718,
0.1056236327,
0.1763378233,
-0.1856407821,
-0.8897405267,
0.197732985,
0.3873950243,
0.5627754331,
0.3473864794,
0.1046748981,
0.6499711275,
-0.6444392204,
0.7717165351,
0.3787336349,
-0.8896593451,
0.8458736539,
-0.5047207475,
0.3440506458,
0.9976044297,
0.0701901615,
-0.4903698564,
-0.7570371628,
-0.5927848816,
-0.592964232,
0.4381678104,
0.8725368977,
-0.1455958486,
-0.2398016304,
0.1612602919,
0.298042804,
0.2382068187,
-0.561077714,
0.0436691046,
-0.0789205953,
-0.4305381179,
0.1661482155,
-0.5608226657,
-0.3677440584,
-0.0863241479,
0.5416381359,
-0.2953479886,
0.6262224317,
0.5508531928,
0.0702380016,
0.0318964049,
0.4888469577,
0.9112212062,
0.6494900584,
-0.2503733039,
0.5267723203,
0.5336334705,
-0.604106009,
-0.0720663294,
-0.0089634378,
-0.2215219587,
0.0480520912,
0.7666357756,
0.8630398512,
0.3277268708,
-0.6375781298,
0.7962882519,
-0.2923001349,
-0.7922434807,
-0.2284067273,
-0.0725147873,
-0.0754995719,
-0.0499804579,
-0.0734752268,
0.1352588981,
0.5063582659,
-0.3914615512,
0.3234187961,
0.3249619603,
-0.6176463366,
-0.3803441525,
1.0860062838,
0.1253832281,
-0.0633006394,
0.3231087327,
-0.2588422298,
-0.5426854491,
0.7285655737,
0.644184351,
0.9542199969,
-0.1150021181,
0.1827651709,
0.5891039371,
0.3800753653,
-0.3076466918,
0.4570963383,
0.4265915453,
-0.6501258612,
-0.3883179128,
-0.4805850387,
-0.2886090577,
0.3533587754,
-0.7652683258,
0.1714829206,
-0.0826809034,
-0.0114593692,
0.3012882769,
-0.2144257873,
-0.5048274994,
0.2381845862,
0.0897607207,
1.0101828575,
-0.876460433,
0.7931216359,
0.5353116393,
-0.1190823764,
-0.735443294,
-0.1812792867,
0.294423461,
-0.4627252519,
0.3573916256,
0.3818751872,
0.0117175439,
-0.1799547225,
-0.5721799135,
-0.5769978166,
1.0173022747,
0.1786631942,
-0.3550145924,
0.1616074443,
0.1979784667,
0.5319091082,
-0.4221534431,
0.3904701769,
0.6530550718,
0.3891327381,
0.2819159329,
-1.0430295467,
0.1818297207,
-0.2987149954,
-0.1203170195,
-0.0154409893,
-0.1984830946,
0.5343961716,
-0.1008205861,
-0.1808116734,
0.3759774864,
0.6032440066,
0.4078354836,
0.8168043494,
0.6072135568,
0.6203343868,
0.6765456796,
-0.2393903136,
0.948794663,
0.0043244814,
0.3628265858,
1.1533122063,
-0.7924221754,
0.7959262133,
0.379981339,
-0.2543058693,
0.2759531438,
0.5372822285,
0.1002175808,
0.808444798,
-0.1188228577,
-0.4095380902,
-0.3010942042,
-0.3075369895,
-0.3507978916,
0.4116176069,
0.3195281625,
-0.2094531506,
-0.1148905754,
0.1009180173,
0.1518178582,
-0.0160137508,
0.2974075079,
0.8362677097,
0.196582526,
-1.1464397907,
0.3752533197,
0.0267289858,
0.3134794831,
-0.4773369431,
-0.1375043392,
-0.1552649289,
0.147745952,
0.0561560653,
-0.6721526384,
0.5499324799,
0.1066961363,
0.1674643159,
-0.1862456501,
0.8960030675,
-0.5592983365,
-0.5413439274,
0.0940551162,
0.2605770528,
0.1318047196,
-0.0406687818,
-0.7653102875,
-0.0705128983,
-0.0308671072,
-0.1398561895,
0.0994881988,
0.3328956962,
-0.1561634839,
0.3691519499,
0.4923955202,
-0.0650872216,
0.0428596288,
0.5282296538,
0.4787319899,
-0.5335333943,
-0.4546749294,
-0.7729820013,
0.3606806099,
-0.3601121902,
-0.3743326366,
0.7202168107,
0.7992526293,
0.096489273,
0.0129648354,
0.6179797649,
-0.1093852893,
0.47845155,
-0.7973203659,
0.5338555574,
-0.4216222167,
-0.0877091959,
-0.0408405662,
-0.3959821165,
-0.4658156037,
0.5226646662,
-0.1624270082,
-0.0651313961,
1.2362232208,
0.849627316,
0.0266405717,
0.5322051644,
0.2768214345,
0.2407857776,
0.286760807,
0.7309508324,
0.7983821034,
-0.8405365348,
-0.0390422419,
-0.1596550792,
-0.2194779217,
-0.1521404982,
-0.9706151485,
-0.98766011,
-0.4710991979,
-0.5435762405,
-0.5674988627,
0.1754618436,
0.8852593899,
0.5821965337,
-1.2723015547,
0.1943616718,
-0.4426280558,
-0.1622125059,
-0.1547886133,
-0.1617278159,
0.3019085526,
-0.2385112345,
-0.6641200185,
0.5253319144,
0.5292432904,
0.0063832626,
0.1977225989,
-0.0913975239,
-0.4128970206,
0.0799001604,
0.560236156,
-0.1010960788,
-0.9584634304,
-0.4435213804,
0.1443009377,
-0.3838447034,
-0.0933034047,
0.7726889849,
-0.4683127701,
0.5861967206,
0.4931937158,
0.6099253893,
0.4503507018,
-0.1424174756,
0.8068844676,
-0.4515755773,
0.0783695802,
0.3668379784,
0.3349208832,
0.0959107429,
-0.2181552798,
0.910801053,
0.148034066,
-0.7433922887,
-0.779301405,
0.072847642,
-1.1148873568,
-0.1769370586,
1.2171303034,
-0.0874376893,
-0.1516027153,
-0.5047427416,
-0.1727858335,
0.2582772672,
0.0120358914,
0.3928482234,
0.5816524625,
-0.0040437994,
-0.063655816,
-1.166307807,
0.6227313876,
0.6415107846,
-1.0163136721,
-0.2535701692,
0.3188783228,
0.1682708561,
-0.1735099256,
0.9097378254,
-0.1686208695,
0.330389142,
0.0894504786,
-0.0637861118,
0.2575502992,
-0.0784401894,
-0.4085673988,
-0.077716127,
-0.3226240575,
-0.1791853905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03969v1
|
Transformers for molecular property prediction: Lessons learned from the past five years
| 2024-04-05T09:05:37 | 2024-04-05T09:05:37 |
Afnan Sultan, Jochen Sieg, Miriam Mathea, Andrea Volkamer
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.QM
|
Molecular Property Prediction (MPP) is vital for drug discovery, crop
protection, and environmental science. Over the last decades, diverse
computational techniques have been developed, from using simple physical and
chemical properties and molecular fingerprints in statistical models and
classical machine learning to advanced deep learning approaches. In this
review, we aim to distill insights from current research on employing
transformer models for MPP. We analyze the currently available models and
explore key questions that arise when training and fine-tuning a transformer
model for MPP. These questions encompass the choice and scale of the
pre-training data, optimal architecture selections, and promising pre-training
objectives. Our analysis highlights areas not yet covered in current research,
inviting further exploration to enhance the field's understanding.
Additionally, we address the challenges in comparing different models,
emphasizing the need for standardized data splitting and robust statistical
analysis.
|
[
-0.7300311327,
-0.1939625442,
0.68020612,
-0.3134343922,
0.2161118686,
0.118719615,
-0.0587781891,
-0.5407739878,
-0.1348062158,
0.6270315051,
-0.2812371552,
0.1619010121,
-1.1078898907,
-0.0177862849,
-0.2931069136,
0.9854905605,
0.0616743043,
0.1277092844,
-0.1049341932,
0.0364443585,
0.0288247485,
-0.5559328794,
0.0090648253,
-0.4605550766,
0.5043970942,
0.4022189379,
0.8259902,
0.7062901258,
1.1867238283,
0.3122465312,
-0.2381242216,
-0.2762294114,
-0.2082232684,
-0.0466525294,
-0.3397532403,
-0.4380888343,
-0.3506212234,
0.4532776773,
0.3614827096,
1.0665615797,
0.1078298688,
0.1163111255,
-0.1055877283,
0.7539813519,
-0.8670529127,
-0.0364652313,
-0.8931910992,
0.555703938,
-0.1455446631,
-0.2497050613,
-0.3516507149,
0.1535557061,
0.5553659201,
-0.2621291578,
0.8135973215,
-0.1684961468,
1.0641751289,
0.385474503,
-0.8253587484,
-0.0120531069,
-1.1790630817,
0.8482992649,
-0.4210624993,
0.5921573639,
0.1447889656,
1.0217570066,
-0.2938672006,
-0.9960675836,
-0.4123907089,
-0.7320942879,
-0.0754047632,
0.0777909607,
0.0550030656,
0.2391207516,
0.1699537784,
0.7384485602,
-0.2306019813,
-0.0554670841,
-0.6636301875,
-0.078155987,
0.3509465158,
0.0686605722,
-0.1449124515,
-0.1380103081,
-0.7327153087,
-0.4508672953,
-0.4520179033,
0.3272207379,
0.2388585508,
0.3478726149,
0.2056716532,
0.7752696276,
-0.0092059299,
0.4141022265,
0.1359841973,
0.0375062451,
-0.0767556578,
-0.4020828307,
-0.3133472204,
-0.1759636551,
0.5428236723,
0.2721801102,
0.3318108916,
-0.1093802378,
-0.0904088095,
0.1031444967,
0.4505261481,
-1.0787819624,
-0.7158277035,
0.3280000389,
-0.5690945983,
-0.6055031419,
0.5308364034,
-1.2253876925,
-0.6319309473,
-0.3167721331,
0.1744018197,
-0.1675894707,
-0.1786220372,
-0.0198158305,
-0.5847699642,
0.0728149191,
-0.1012462303,
-1.3945701122,
0.4581596851,
0.6439294219,
0.6606049538,
-0.3996819854,
-0.4794585407,
-0.1078180522,
-0.0414889008,
-0.0440848544,
0.942384243,
-0.9071472287,
-0.4487710595,
-0.4529758692,
0.1610262692,
-0.1945159584,
-0.8410238028,
0.2637672722,
-0.2437384427,
-0.2762658298,
-0.1077585518,
-0.4205390811,
0.0357324742,
0.0633731112,
-0.822427392,
0.4407021105,
0.6062367558,
-0.6369971633,
0.7399209142,
-0.5819427371,
-0.1209014207,
-0.2607132792,
0.0088433279,
-0.8355969787,
0.4186871052,
0.2542032599,
0.6010513306,
-0.2297649235,
0.0727370083,
-0.3840302229,
-0.0613374263,
0.4473517835,
-0.57004565,
0.4133062959,
0.3658500016,
-0.0587462336,
0.1934424788,
-1.038182497,
-0.2941116989,
-0.1545951813,
-0.1739167869,
0.6971446276,
0.0224017799,
0.13259013,
0.273648262,
-0.0455524363,
-0.5176953077,
0.3818381131,
-0.2148316652,
0.4285390377,
0.7634598613,
0.060333278,
0.9071083665,
-0.1363714039,
0.7147971988,
0.3141085505,
0.4815514684,
-0.1454113573,
-0.4165383279,
-0.5418700576,
0.0588085987,
0.5963289738,
0.5375413299,
-0.1420897394,
0.1271306872,
-0.1436682492,
-0.9629267454,
-0.1074619219,
0.005568862,
0.0047302512,
0.328274101,
0.685008347,
-0.3420918882,
-0.5092748404,
-0.9548870921,
-0.5177406669,
0.1179923192,
-0.0451060608,
0.2342023998,
0.6559923291,
-0.402120322,
0.8501945138,
-0.7626803517,
-0.3223475814,
-0.404748857,
-0.0613209382,
0.251265347,
0.4280889332,
0.5693305135,
-0.9663849473,
-0.4778809249,
0.3698735833,
-0.2496365607,
0.3526191711,
0.0805752724,
0.1991241276,
-0.1225654036,
0.2871266305,
-0.6628021002,
0.3398552239,
0.7460486293,
-0.1550687104,
0.6251490116,
-0.2139548063,
0.1892738789,
-0.8068545461,
0.035454452,
0.4075834453,
-0.0629368201,
-0.8773089051,
-0.0023810249,
-0.1855814457,
-0.2852117717,
-0.5124003887,
0.0996906906,
-0.2387715429,
-0.0839788765,
-0.378148526,
-0.8988102674,
-0.1448217332,
0.2915526628,
-0.0182954166,
0.7845958471,
0.3837503493,
-0.4570505917,
0.3840736449,
-0.0159368347,
-0.020971667,
0.3037765026,
-0.3601288199,
-0.0757296681,
0.0677209347,
0.2216705382,
-0.5421025157,
-0.3182265759,
0.1184620112,
-0.5489188433,
0.6367847323,
-0.7169455886,
0.1134361103,
-0.4666849375,
-0.0168737825,
0.0629921779,
0.4988166094,
-0.3956922889,
1.0158215761,
0.2896375954,
0.3123786151,
-0.3811380565,
-0.4345395565,
-0.2216767222,
-0.4375272691,
-0.3499688804,
0.3580035865,
0.170228973,
0.0293274373,
-0.325504452,
-0.282307148,
-0.4589397907,
0.1556025892,
0.5286471844,
-0.0187392514,
-0.0368972309,
-0.0959939063,
-0.3673879802,
-0.8275569081,
0.2056981325,
-0.4738900959,
0.4055829644,
-0.1840342879,
0.1239997298,
-0.0924936607,
0.1924372166,
0.6319116354,
-0.4163858593,
0.9056735635,
0.6479279995,
0.004552932,
-0.1619823873,
-0.0311452486,
-0.5565428138,
-0.5507915616,
0.431720078,
-0.3475137949,
-0.5434013009,
0.0815785751,
-0.6906564832,
-0.4216466844,
0.5370189548,
0.5462306738,
-0.5328531861,
0.7845177054,
1.1431061029,
0.2401037067,
0.4119457901,
-0.5305783153,
0.5463036299,
-0.4636587799,
-0.3310541809,
-0.4404516816,
-0.5130369067,
-0.9664024115,
-0.4862415791,
0.4878667593,
-0.0005143894,
-0.3740517795,
0.5516133308,
-0.6676049232,
0.4485584199,
0.737308383,
0.0672452226,
-0.0207637325,
0.0808377936,
0.178993687,
-0.0120086558,
-0.3434145153,
-0.502912581,
1.428016901,
0.5177055597,
0.261811614,
-0.467048198,
0.2286742181,
0.0644271821,
0.0908057764,
-0.702922523,
0.3390099406,
-0.2161291093,
-0.7083274722,
-0.2769404054,
-0.3541509807,
-1.0020521879,
0.111494489,
-0.4089554548,
-0.5821889043,
0.7007772326,
0.6869474649,
-0.2492656857,
0.6963384748,
-0.607734561,
0.9979234338,
-0.1833659858,
0.0205731168,
0.1330345273,
-1.0426920652,
0.1322125643,
-0.1455304027,
-0.3160156906,
-0.1943136901,
0.2949254215,
0.3072428405,
-0.4356193244,
0.2541611195,
-0.213922888,
0.0712362677,
0.1387263089,
-0.0596498996,
0.2893718779,
-0.3075318933,
-0.026732726,
0.1236745343,
0.3366705477,
-0.3474888802,
-0.6049506664,
0.3608983755,
-0.6681756377,
-0.3691541255,
-0.4999587536,
-0.3945336938,
-0.3153289258,
0.0411248803,
0.5711635947,
-0.1718382835,
0.129072085,
0.2687782943,
0.5246242881,
0.0184625909,
0.3521776795,
0.2281060517,
-0.1090083048,
-0.2888461053,
1.2719535828,
0.4350076318,
0.3900183439,
0.6299394369,
0.4972099662,
0.2087148726,
-0.8994556069,
0.0549060628,
-0.3000241816,
-0.5169400573,
-0.1022976488,
-0.7246066332,
-0.3403549194,
-0.3132121563,
-0.0772217363,
-0.8436902761,
-0.5462422967,
-0.1252420098,
-0.4153719842,
0.2909047604,
0.7277041674,
-0.163390547,
0.4361305535,
-0.8098231554,
0.5968075395,
0.3696993291,
0.4833701551,
-0.3129740059,
-0.16499345,
-0.2958298922,
0.2007995546,
-0.7806123495,
-0.8665240407,
0.412953943,
0.172008276,
0.2437836081,
0.387253046,
-0.2268334627,
-0.0727760419,
-0.5870735049,
0.7695888877,
-0.1126897931,
-0.5540328026,
0.7556112409,
-0.3463486433,
-0.0772255361,
0.5485819578,
0.6126835942,
-0.0749034956,
0.2009738535,
-0.6280634999,
-0.8118914962,
0.1113223508,
0.4472613335,
-0.201700747,
0.4876497388,
0.1432524472,
0.2456059903,
0.1615993828,
-0.6763908267,
-0.2910359204,
-0.4973026514,
-0.053965617,
-0.2619369626,
-0.1060144305,
0.1618134379,
-0.6754772067,
0.4736129642,
-0.1137708127,
0.3350422382,
-0.0872786492,
0.1251770258,
0.0893665031,
0.3325668275,
0.3996160924,
0.5441994071,
-0.7251397967,
0.1428009272,
0.210734874,
-0.8279574513,
0.4743581414,
0.3293934166,
0.2931718826,
-0.4733842909,
0.1497966498,
0.6296607256,
-0.5419813395,
-0.4231376946,
0.4416539371,
0.2385941744,
-0.2913134098,
-0.2955918908,
0.2017504275,
-0.2314965129,
0.3431329727,
0.2055967599,
0.7542030811,
0.3276436925,
-0.5169526935,
0.2385065854,
0.2482567579,
-0.7039155364,
-0.4529618919,
0.6157237887,
0.0808913335,
0.0482210256,
0.5934050083,
0.2548226118,
-0.5513901711,
0.8655006886,
0.1369430721,
0.7395727634,
-0.4650702178,
0.0592188984,
0.0289025102,
0.3383369446,
0.207733348,
-0.0064338953,
-0.1851585358,
-0.7791260481,
0.1673912108,
-0.615291059,
-0.5794091225,
-0.0547598973,
-0.3287953138,
0.129404068,
-0.6048466563,
-0.3917328417,
0.4820363224,
0.2131369114,
-0.8108832836,
0.5124781728,
0.1117026284,
0.6849244237,
-1.0750032663,
0.8244683743,
0.4312884808,
-0.3109673858,
-0.6593624949,
-0.2045833766,
0.0813721195,
-0.1960195452,
0.5257858634,
0.2133382261,
0.0542970374,
-0.1738321781,
-0.5410757065,
-0.8741056919,
1.0696679354,
0.457500726,
-0.6392295957,
0.0739926472,
0.8493002057,
0.6044475436,
-0.1939149201,
0.3847959042,
1.1857016087,
0.5842072964,
0.1145682484,
-0.6772259474,
-0.4469214678,
-0.1724836379,
0.0403900743,
0.4521914124,
-0.3168598711,
0.8033172488,
-0.1994576305,
-0.0157144964,
-0.0006792432,
0.7570767999,
0.1636511087,
0.3494971693,
0.1962322593,
0.4348397553,
0.4854968786,
-0.4561851919,
1.3802577257,
-0.4091074765,
0.3404925764,
0.8278001547,
-0.2363096327,
0.9312686324,
0.7014402747,
-0.6293084025,
0.2389526814,
0.5151530504,
-0.7828329802,
0.4746590555,
0.3989753723,
-0.1088759974,
-0.0079153515,
-0.1166574955,
-0.3816812634,
0.5478095412,
0.2770008147,
-0.818647027,
0.162376672,
0.1300658137,
-0.5168215036,
0.021378722,
-0.0112133967,
0.5079715252,
0.1240199059,
-0.4429477155,
-0.1021797955,
-0.0655883625,
0.4639498591,
-0.4725601077,
-0.2824420035,
-0.0446261503,
0.5494810939,
-0.2073791176,
-0.84324646,
0.3325740397,
-0.5249985456,
-0.5764760971,
-0.3976738453,
0.8200211525,
-0.0846884847,
-0.7273319364,
0.2477772534,
-0.107042484,
-0.0815209672,
-0.3696240187,
-0.4434401989,
-0.3200240731,
-0.2727422714,
-0.2700899243,
0.2371999174,
0.1438617259,
0.3958995342,
0.8185469508,
0.7123325467,
0.0370562114,
0.1156336144,
-0.3261013627,
0.8239813447,
-0.8290664554,
-0.0371204168,
-0.5640896559,
0.6133069396,
0.0320001692,
-0.2324088663,
0.6549047232,
0.5796974301,
0.817237556,
-0.3773546815,
0.6123632789,
0.4849857092,
0.5052469969,
-0.4013681114,
0.58907938,
0.0811422765,
0.2639419138,
-0.1327941418,
-1.2954599857,
-0.1031605452,
0.368571043,
-0.0293492917,
0.5144847631,
0.6847752333,
0.8899653554,
-0.278126657,
0.0937655494,
0.1082363799,
0.0884006694,
0.7254472971,
0.6340641975,
0.8822234869,
-0.5762489438,
0.234271273,
-0.8362479806,
0.100178279,
-0.0620473959,
-0.9199675918,
-0.7879234552,
-0.5566339493,
-0.0876866356,
-0.3566513956,
-0.1044783965,
0.8794567585,
0.97054708,
-1.0617582798,
-0.2428719997,
-0.6951494813,
-0.1753860116,
-0.2611552179,
-0.1689710915,
0.2503943741,
0.0896164104,
-0.4333000481,
0.406828016,
0.3622291088,
0.6933544874,
-0.4342307746,
0.1302210391,
0.074453786,
-0.0459395275,
0.2595375776,
0.4602641463,
-0.4538747668,
0.0504985042,
-0.098131679,
0.1479868591,
0.4165652096,
1.1274918318,
-0.9233869314,
0.3314251602,
0.5702750087,
0.5171771646,
0.5579872131,
-0.0188900717,
1.0256532431,
-0.4113869965,
0.0723601505,
0.4825353622,
0.3804314733,
0.2592982054,
-0.474971801,
0.5141897202,
0.0786869377,
-0.7252044678,
-0.6155692935,
0.2346466482,
-0.9463738799,
-0.3511244059,
0.7233175039,
0.1372521222,
-0.1953798831,
0.141211912,
-0.0349087119,
0.0384020247,
0.062589705,
0.5071389675,
0.4352857172,
-0.0842054859,
-0.5925425291,
-0.5457484722,
0.7983626723,
0.3697127402,
-0.864387691,
-0.0451581888,
0.0186235271,
-0.017658297,
0.2100418955,
-0.239237681,
0.1010305509,
0.1437285542,
0.129134208,
-0.1450679898,
-0.1185790524,
-1.1291701794,
-0.3949924707,
0.3918356299,
-0.0504233949,
0.1153859571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03938v1
|
Data Augmentation with In-Context Learning and Comparative Evaluation in Math Word Problem Solving
| 2024-04-05T07:57:03 | 2024-04-05T07:57:03 |
Gulsum Yigit, Mehmet Fatih Amasyali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Math Word Problem (MWP) solving presents a challenging task in Natural
Language Processing (NLP). This study aims to provide MWP solvers with a more
diverse training set, ultimately improving their ability to solve various math
problems. We propose several methods for data augmentation by modifying the
problem texts and equations, such as synonym replacement, rule-based: question
replacement, and rule based: reversing question methodologies over two English
MWP datasets. This study extends by introducing a new in-context learning
augmentation method, employing the Llama-7b language model. This approach
involves instruction-based prompting for rephrasing the math problem texts.
Performance evaluations are conducted on 9 baseline models, revealing that
augmentation methods outperform baseline models. Moreover, concatenating
examples generated by various augmentation methods further improves
performance.
|
[
-0.2757555842,
-0.7929204106,
0.2545988858,
0.3050282896,
-0.490709722,
0.2565188408,
-0.1689808667,
-0.5503875613,
-0.0120392563,
0.2974855006,
-0.6920017004,
-0.2294208556,
-0.6495025754,
0.4311048687,
-0.1279938072,
0.6606985927,
-0.2770287097,
0.3176814914,
-0.7005473971,
-0.2467243969,
-1.0449844599,
-0.6653670073,
-0.4275562167,
-0.6780253053,
0.1693751514,
0.4944984317,
0.7002288699,
0.4087285399,
0.9205591083,
0.3524286151,
-0.1671484113,
0.5140820146,
-0.4355370402,
0.0424337536,
-0.0974296704,
-0.4810464084,
-0.0611537397,
-0.1414996535,
0.4374392033,
1.2303880453,
-0.2879527807,
0.0495248884,
0.138504684,
0.7568005919,
-0.5195410252,
0.3548460901,
-0.8281784654,
0.1555427462,
0.0942536816,
-0.4065083265,
-0.0960902125,
-0.3736400008,
0.3110499978,
-0.7377810478,
0.0271724761,
-0.1474032402,
0.3890537322,
0.2754833102,
-0.208397612,
-0.4740208387,
-0.3921794295,
0.9086595774,
-0.8586091399,
0.3202981353,
0.3988046348,
0.1318315864,
-0.4570902586,
-0.4408826828,
-0.6463968754,
-0.1203648895,
-0.037295159,
0.0569032393,
-0.3550620973,
-0.1995089799,
0.4449625611,
0.4442558587,
-0.2419730574,
0.0589363128,
-0.4526563883,
-0.110367924,
0.6039924622,
0.2771298289,
0.2421342134,
-0.1348983198,
-0.1724542677,
-0.2023667097,
-0.7101407051,
0.0686666816,
0.1932163984,
0.2356021702,
-0.037494354,
0.7828418612,
-0.3185462058,
0.9377738833,
-0.195014134,
-0.3857112825,
0.6550502777,
-0.0578567684,
-0.2723403275,
-0.0570680052,
-0.0017561041,
0.477365911,
0.0739273429,
-0.1340118498,
-0.3004468977,
0.2443849593,
0.1202816665,
-0.5304762125,
0.2116729468,
-0.1776828021,
-0.1429696083,
-0.3424757719,
-0.177607432,
-0.2177771926,
-0.1989192516,
-0.8060745001,
0.8140271306,
-0.525632143,
0.163603887,
0.2957130373,
-0.2003403157,
0.2321900874,
0.2485237718,
-0.5291087627,
0.2456187755,
0.785318315,
0.6774625778,
-0.1340090781,
-0.2611124814,
-0.4193249345,
-0.0707131848,
-0.4787892103,
0.7894690633,
-0.8785369396,
-0.7541688085,
-0.0085021332,
-0.2550393641,
0.2023314238,
-0.9637081027,
0.5569325686,
-0.3484476507,
0.5871250629,
-0.3830370903,
-0.7073827386,
-0.4391669929,
0.400180459,
-0.4953871071,
1.3916088343,
0.3345525861,
-0.7023664117,
0.2133163661,
-0.7389308214,
-0.382501632,
0.0530255362,
0.1164987832,
-0.2200694978,
0.4944132566,
0.7572026253,
0.2592184246,
-0.2033461332,
0.2540441155,
-0.0395665541,
-0.5890292525,
0.1745210588,
-0.584203124,
0.4869645536,
-0.0218314156,
0.0210013073,
-0.1150675416,
-0.8981671929,
-0.075288862,
0.2252012938,
-0.3124427199,
-0.4733868837,
-0.0341498516,
-0.4015532732,
0.0505827256,
0.2887316942,
-0.5499773026,
0.2794550061,
-0.7254396081,
0.001222078,
0.649023056,
0.0392144211,
0.2345029712,
-0.4867770672,
0.3145924211,
0.026992064,
-0.0500323065,
-0.2978761196,
-0.7372668982,
-0.6421445012,
0.1363879889,
0.1790856421,
0.6404559016,
-1.1124174595,
0.2140622139,
-0.2996065915,
-0.3876526356,
-0.445769012,
0.1791059971,
0.3188938797,
1.1702258587,
0.8117784262,
-0.1869869381,
-0.6204786897,
-0.7198309898,
-0.2749457955,
0.2369761616,
-0.1614387929,
0.3525593877,
0.2596456409,
-0.2939157188,
1.0877792835,
-0.7285017371,
-0.34639588,
-0.3007091582,
0.1801416874,
0.3304652572,
0.3602358401,
0.232846871,
-0.6675445437,
-0.2981179059,
-0.0695436969,
-0.5806476474,
-0.6515631676,
0.2044247091,
0.1910843402,
0.025701791,
0.2908985615,
0.0449442007,
0.5644633174,
0.5274586082,
-0.0277259983,
0.4584513605,
-0.3252859712,
0.1950478703,
-1.0946108103,
-0.2599247098,
0.0456303731,
-0.0467234105,
-0.6256469488,
0.3643945158,
0.005972662,
-0.3316219747,
-0.4405875504,
0.3147682846,
-0.3719009161,
-0.0297013205,
-0.5096618533,
0.181608513,
-0.0044897688,
0.361238271,
-0.0671821237,
1.0655200481,
0.3277424574,
-0.5751490593,
0.5265300274,
0.2421754748,
-0.413819164,
0.5594416261,
-0.5711464286,
0.2070642412,
-0.3821258545,
0.238392964,
-0.9865225554,
0.162467286,
-0.0963926762,
-0.3710353076,
0.0114501249,
0.0340548456,
-0.4451345503,
-0.2907299399,
-0.4499481916,
0.6228950024,
0.4794745743,
-0.8348809481,
0.3531184196,
0.2165581882,
-0.2326960117,
-0.6823655963,
-0.6215906143,
0.1575987339,
-0.3305015266,
-0.5739498734,
0.7836988568,
-0.117006138,
-0.2926064134,
-0.1264475733,
-0.1399717033,
-0.0268274564,
0.0449097641,
-0.1472043395,
0.4574217796,
0.1180529445,
0.2339104414,
0.2233730704,
-0.2898854613,
0.0979262888,
0.0817355141,
0.5683017373,
0.2311788052,
-0.3395593464,
-0.0970897749,
0.4973673224,
-0.1694938987,
-0.2447042763,
0.4698762894,
0.3271952271,
-0.7347759604,
-0.0405987762,
-0.6052404642,
-0.1472564936,
-0.5004202127,
0.262509495,
-0.5122478008,
-0.7725329995,
0.5227305889,
-0.2291974723,
0.1477512866,
0.282946229,
0.4729169011,
-0.0142145362,
1.040536046,
0.5687708259,
-0.0814708397,
0.5204724073,
-0.346601963,
0.1487962455,
-1.0561820269,
-0.2685153782,
-0.2767775059,
-0.4643102288,
-0.2295143157,
-0.6668262482,
0.5130668283,
0.1070317179,
0.2816163599,
0.4354492724,
-0.533051908,
0.7040378451,
-0.0019603381,
0.2167903632,
0.4715201259,
0.2558301985,
-0.3462369442,
-0.4905311465,
-0.5481621623,
-0.168814525,
1.1841188669,
-0.0002724265,
0.5470035076,
0.2865497172,
0.6082146764,
0.1181151867,
0.76236099,
-0.8447572589,
0.4023605585,
-0.1200909689,
-0.1898222864,
-0.0780580416,
-0.5890142918,
-0.9830827117,
0.5889858007,
-0.3871133924,
-0.7855995297,
-0.135734871,
-0.1034921929,
0.1078258678,
0.0811913535,
-0.6986536384,
0.2801892161,
0.0201454591,
-0.0429906026,
-0.3857484758,
-0.1522599012,
0.3082483113,
-0.0740500242,
0.3629974127,
-0.0064978786,
-0.216332525,
0.5521498322,
-0.6892991662,
0.4914008677,
-0.0652859211,
-0.457965821,
0.1438684613,
-0.0294622965,
0.6423010826,
-0.0358571708,
-0.150326848,
0.0369896218,
-0.1923512369,
-0.181973666,
-0.9887444377,
0.7058365941,
-0.3815543056,
-0.698137641,
-0.2063213736,
-0.9380135536,
-0.6232141852,
-0.2003047764,
0.0376626998,
0.7435859442,
0.2943942845,
0.3020808995,
0.3302617073,
-0.1530400813,
0.4125877917,
0.3990790248,
-0.2567189336,
-0.479377389,
0.9816718102,
0.2574562132,
0.1256749034,
0.4182144403,
0.5266063213,
-0.5961652398,
-0.3841191828,
-0.3024125993,
0.0957447365,
-0.9045413733,
-0.4056023061,
-0.191227138,
-0.076135464,
-0.1262322664,
-0.3877748549,
0.0801979601,
-0.4576569498,
-0.2667392492,
-0.0176131576,
0.4612388909,
0.3527313471,
0.0512928553,
0.3638253808,
-0.6126126647,
0.4902156293,
0.2633019984,
0.3977378905,
0.0674762353,
-0.8229290843,
-0.0760227963,
0.0855923146,
-0.4384970367,
-1.0549120903,
0.4523729086,
0.097050719,
0.4612892568,
-0.0703510717,
-0.2173225284,
1.1846441031,
-0.5314460397,
0.5309999585,
0.1809246987,
-1.0713342428,
0.3299538791,
0.0400382727,
0.2527116537,
0.4059675634,
0.1645725816,
-0.5640980601,
-0.0808603913,
-0.5918789506,
-0.8030366302,
0.248381719,
0.2914676666,
0.4055462778,
0.1291075349,
0.5624597669,
0.154577896,
0.2056785971,
-0.42340976,
-0.2826975286,
0.0740363747,
-0.2311918736,
-0.0022873764,
-0.0111130215,
-0.0112350788,
-0.654124856,
0.5644494295,
-0.2577280104,
0.0507102236,
0.2262669355,
-0.2963692546,
0.0832143277,
0.2672003806,
0.5594390631,
0.9381321073,
-0.0158697162,
-0.2443438917,
0.8696377277,
-0.533359766,
0.0803565532,
0.2268886119,
-0.0517389998,
0.0930808708,
0.3304817379,
0.4586552978,
0.3647765219,
-0.6790402532,
0.2680024505,
0.0843679234,
-0.2396846712,
-0.016051501,
-0.0522829331,
-0.0423452929,
-0.1186602935,
0.7648919821,
-0.2309960425,
0.4055386484,
-0.4865061939,
0.0428490341,
0.5683469176,
-0.0740781352,
0.1011414528,
0.2085844874,
0.051188454,
-0.4939017594,
0.3807037175,
-0.1131986231,
-0.6639409065,
0.5810332298,
1.1225168705,
0.3108225763,
-0.0272531323,
-0.0291904695,
0.2674336433,
0.1029735282,
0.1831336617,
0.6229357123,
-0.1544472724,
-0.8306625485,
-0.7837421894,
-0.1705414206,
-0.6928318739,
0.2206503451,
-0.7023129463,
0.2733280957,
-0.249324739,
0.0225597955,
-0.1741245538,
0.2890539765,
-0.6315059662,
0.492305547,
0.0640677363,
0.8460202217,
-0.5063951612,
0.455758214,
0.7960316539,
0.0553849638,
-0.8166217208,
-0.0364757106,
-0.1480278075,
-0.808519721,
0.3659340739,
0.4038068056,
-0.2304451913,
0.0752667189,
-0.4707178771,
-0.778719902,
0.9807122946,
0.3295231462,
-0.3989395201,
0.3158132136,
0.2248264104,
0.503555119,
-0.3486352563,
0.2224235684,
0.5189648271,
0.3023663759,
0.1040431187,
-0.7839407921,
-0.161367178,
-0.2419843674,
0.2094604522,
0.2817203403,
-0.0683891922,
0.4745318294,
-0.1926189512,
-0.0808405727,
-0.1545988321,
0.7907285094,
0.5316264629,
0.3480689228,
0.5708873868,
0.8614591956,
0.6627711654,
-0.1226872653,
0.9116325378,
-0.0446621329,
0.3867180645,
0.946482718,
-0.1034477577,
0.8914958835,
0.7073376775,
-0.4778297842,
0.6036545634,
0.4323618114,
0.1397558153,
0.3589185476,
0.5077240467,
-0.2710980177,
-0.0185794719,
-0.1899390221,
-0.7104966044,
0.5731987357,
0.4387488067,
0.1210850254,
-0.5040434003,
-0.019182682,
-0.0625334978,
0.3273667097,
-0.4417339265,
0.6422716975,
0.0346185863,
-0.3856188357,
0.5823765993,
0.4694164991,
0.8439286947,
-0.5393089652,
-0.4112612605,
-0.3075097501,
-0.0054729348,
-0.2352639139,
-0.6554316282,
0.4879208505,
0.0376243591,
-0.086316064,
0.1641455144,
0.5342622995,
-0.3600131869,
-0.9252785444,
0.0248921588,
0.4642964602,
-0.0582777895,
0.0827762187,
-0.768286705,
-0.0416322947,
-0.1967221498,
0.0964784175,
0.2597337961,
0.2447005659,
-0.249992311,
0.8612455726,
1.049856782,
0.0380850099,
-0.0540462546,
0.3248217106,
1.1067583561,
-0.3772174716,
-0.5461091399,
-0.7552313805,
0.4357637465,
-0.1107266024,
-0.3687751889,
0.6972470284,
0.5379177332,
0.9199818969,
0.0674606636,
0.4125596285,
0.288005501,
0.6084199548,
-0.6076621413,
0.0196724739,
-0.5584087968,
0.5491195321,
-0.5314215422,
-1.1763337851,
-0.5280672908,
0.7263951898,
-0.4572081268,
-0.1498767138,
0.6065992117,
0.5766810775,
-0.1088036075,
0.0686687455,
0.2961371541,
-0.373942852,
0.1907256693,
0.5184804201,
0.6537898779,
-0.5738709569,
0.3810995519,
-0.636171937,
-0.1870310009,
-0.0036600458,
-0.9988202453,
-0.5081399679,
-0.443143636,
-0.1142307594,
-0.0513566285,
-0.2270517498,
1.1573450565,
0.1872877926,
-0.5768668652,
-0.1502923667,
0.0927547887,
0.3437609971,
-0.4126611352,
-0.2862078846,
0.2460151762,
-0.4921267033,
-0.7011108398,
0.7472434044,
0.1866505295,
0.0257514585,
-0.1912112683,
0.1499552876,
0.118321918,
0.2628179193,
0.7555100322,
-0.0949219242,
-0.4562369287,
-0.1101624146,
-0.1310854256,
0.2677536309,
0.2663577795,
0.9123191237,
-1.1151373386,
0.5589843988,
0.4341787398,
0.9954132438,
0.1823695153,
0.3750101924,
0.5046101809,
-0.9710066915,
0.3371011317,
0.0750664622,
0.569398284,
0.6424818635,
-0.307528913,
0.4177483618,
0.3876603544,
-0.1057121381,
-0.8854752779,
0.1878020167,
-0.605807364,
-0.2241124809,
0.866930604,
0.1253626198,
-0.020364251,
-0.0289194081,
-0.4625421464,
-0.0482443608,
-0.1528817564,
0.8505012989,
0.8919279575,
-0.1702756882,
-0.0148284845,
-0.3465169668,
0.1706725508,
0.6263391376,
-0.9147866368,
-0.281085372,
0.4360836148,
0.1650344133,
0.0523491055,
0.1748081595,
-0.1793265194,
0.1427825689,
-0.3142802715,
-0.2884537876,
-0.3065363169,
-0.0438022129,
-0.5154526234,
-0.035701625,
-0.2968447208,
-0.0952835083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04306v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04306v1
|
AuditGPT: Auditing Smart Contracts with ChatGPT
| 2024-04-05T07:19:13 | 2024-04-05T07:19:13 |
Shihao Xia, Shuai Shao, Mengting He, Tingting Yu, Linhai Song, Yiying Zhang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
To govern smart contracts running on Ethereum, multiple Ethereum Request for
Comment (ERC) standards have been developed, each containing a set of rules to
guide the behaviors of smart contracts. Violating the ERC rules could cause
serious security issues and financial loss, signifying the importance of
verifying smart contracts follow ERCs. Today's practices of such verification
are to either manually audit each single contract or use expert-developed,
limited-scope program-analysis tools, both of which are far from being
effective in identifying ERC rule violations. This paper presents a tool named
AuditGPT that leverages large language models (LLMs) to automatically and
comprehensively verify ERC rules against smart contracts. To build AuditGPT, we
first conduct an empirical study on 222 ERC rules specified in four popular
ERCs to understand their content, their security impacts, their specification
in natural language, and their implementation in Solidity. Guided by the study,
we construct AuditGPT by separating the large, complex auditing process into
small, manageable tasks and design prompts specialized for each ERC rule type
to enhance LLMs' auditing performance. In the evaluation, AuditGPT successfully
pinpoints 418 ERC rule violations and only reports 18 false positives,
showcasing its effectiveness and accuracy. Moreover, AuditGPT beats an auditing
service provided by security experts in effectiveness, accuracy, and cost,
demonstrating its advancement over state-of-the-art smart-contract auditing
practices.
|
[
-0.3943114877,
-0.8275801539,
0.5115839839,
-0.2349542528,
-0.510710299,
-0.0559960008,
0.039992664,
-0.5365486741,
0.2644784749,
1.0398714542,
-0.4454540312,
-0.5020413995,
-0.3804480731,
0.0752007216,
-0.6577605009,
1.6792764664,
-0.0354791619,
-0.174149856,
0.1395045221,
0.2452178597,
-0.3647432327,
-0.4117868543,
-0.3209389746,
-0.1571208388,
0.2784743607,
0.4326397479,
0.4036002159,
0.5553458333,
0.5346820354,
0.3640744686,
-0.1662816554,
0.2862406373,
-0.2244756371,
-0.2005551755,
0.0977695137,
-0.3472768068,
-0.9158431292,
-0.1327882856,
0.3108006418,
-0.1863928735,
-0.3602941334,
0.04440872,
-0.1299933195,
0.4848171175,
-0.5494188666,
0.3620606065,
-0.6012834907,
-0.1058487445,
-0.1320706904,
-0.3715563416,
-0.3359934092,
-0.6242160797,
0.2961828411,
-0.3724336624,
0.036228925,
0.0505293198,
1.0828661919,
0.0904261172,
-0.4754121602,
-0.6299589872,
-0.4040959477,
0.5034623742,
-0.7076079845,
0.5135993361,
0.2946824431,
0.1472971886,
0.0716350377,
-0.8257897496,
-0.5401995182,
-0.592078805,
-0.0125590581,
0.226520732,
-0.0295250565,
0.3593397737,
0.3395100832,
0.1993678808,
-0.5116992593,
-0.2048635781,
-0.309830457,
-0.2871844172,
0.4951536953,
0.1916135252,
0.2460892051,
-0.1025520265,
-0.2740140855,
0.0895900577,
-0.7841160297,
-0.2220045179,
0.7739843726,
0.0242066346,
-0.0318548158,
0.4699548185,
-0.3275400996,
0.4660150111,
-0.1731926799,
-0.0863165706,
-0.0368417427,
-0.3507608771,
-0.0501719788,
0.0879052728,
0.5063409209,
0.2640826404,
0.4426885247,
-0.3173449636,
-0.5921831727,
-0.263340503,
0.2409920543,
-0.6972036958,
-0.3327666223,
0.3585626185,
-0.2386706918,
-0.3509105742,
0.3731926084,
-0.720276475,
-0.4679572582,
-0.5679408908,
0.0987609699,
-0.3367582262,
-0.0900786072,
0.2735356688,
-0.0721540004,
0.3341294825,
0.3922768235,
-0.7028199434,
0.5647380948,
1.2831919193,
0.5920202732,
0.4304938912,
-0.3745024204,
-0.8004820347,
-0.0868841633,
-0.1473866403,
0.8982998729,
-0.1673114747,
0.0279889312,
0.1281385124,
-0.2641043365,
0.1002618596,
-0.3636010587,
0.5347628593,
-0.7789335251,
0.0601499639,
0.1018993258,
-0.5800756216,
-0.1808568984,
0.583509028,
-0.4173357487,
0.698464036,
-0.2559321821,
-0.788624227,
0.4845140278,
-0.7702782154,
-0.1177423671,
0.3430652618,
-0.1987009943,
-0.5714089274,
-0.217522949,
0.0715796575,
0.368983686,
-0.2352988124,
0.150244236,
-0.2442578673,
-0.1278302521,
0.5032858849,
-0.1838402897,
0.7521445155,
0.1748695374,
-0.4732297957,
0.3314582705,
-0.6424539685,
0.3478400707,
-0.0438695215,
-0.3984518051,
-0.0474049784,
0.1100335047,
0.0864215866,
-0.1060663536,
0.3106167912,
-0.4585259259,
0.1080579311,
-0.2032671571,
0.7351759076,
0.7783877254,
0.0943341702,
-0.2948950827,
-0.2396166623,
0.3410260975,
-0.2376440018,
0.3158516586,
-0.0619436838,
-0.3531940281,
-0.8494982123,
-0.47103405,
0.4520662427,
0.855920136,
-0.2079775184,
0.7964286208,
-0.2989222109,
-0.4612496197,
-0.1441272497,
0.1634892076,
0.1736011803,
0.1234222576,
0.0196628775,
-0.2435871363,
-0.6264020801,
-0.9013195634,
-0.4203491807,
-0.583316803,
-0.0319222435,
0.0815117061,
0.9596477747,
-0.3572436571,
0.8099938035,
-0.4543439746,
-0.2204298228,
-0.0509873815,
0.0580069199,
0.1731268317,
0.2463134527,
0.1897784173,
-0.467122525,
-0.3521983325,
0.3429272175,
-0.4656449258,
-0.0658971071,
-0.0437892824,
0.1504326612,
0.1245980337,
0.6279872656,
-0.398794204,
0.3829254508,
0.3742362261,
-0.6288058758,
0.7470391393,
-0.3650919795,
0.0408769585,
-0.4369716048,
0.1975271553,
-0.2200629264,
-0.727013588,
-0.4567184448,
0.2471007556,
0.5401252508,
-0.0784957781,
-0.2740933299,
0.0189723745,
-0.2040347755,
0.0698412061,
0.1136130467,
0.0516033843,
-0.2161055654,
0.3367744386,
-0.0499652624,
0.5825291872,
0.2896513045,
-0.4733934999,
0.6126156449,
-0.0337151103,
-0.4429346323,
0.506182313,
-0.7019429207,
0.6423198581,
0.1568971872,
0.1884686202,
-0.5904718637,
-0.0445921905,
0.1125060469,
-0.0135599915,
-0.0105787981,
-0.4706309736,
-0.700271666,
0.0748674944,
-0.3335477114,
-0.0501989685,
0.3826877773,
-0.4245016873,
0.8435983658,
0.2489376366,
-0.0483589433,
-0.62915802,
-0.4384725988,
0.3978798091,
-0.3572441638,
-0.5704351068,
-0.2392533273,
0.0579108596,
-0.4017567337,
-0.1579692066,
0.0298997145,
-0.1046136543,
0.195262149,
0.2973574996,
0.3550767601,
-0.1070423126,
-0.2403249443,
-0.5584365726,
-0.2102770209,
-0.0221858844,
-0.5068502426,
0.454531908,
-0.6434336901,
-0.5645520091,
-0.612020731,
0.2026972175,
0.9363772273,
-0.3648088276,
0.3738413453,
0.0469640605,
-0.2766982615,
-0.0958432406,
-0.9938279986,
-0.2441411018,
-0.462616533,
0.5581106544,
-0.4758404195,
-0.6444266438,
0.792576313,
0.0866500661,
0.3321611881,
0.2328530252,
0.5632730126,
0.2532765269,
0.7860096097,
0.6353097558,
-0.0809260234,
0.7092072964,
-0.144306913,
0.2689734399,
-0.4909462333,
-0.204806298,
-0.7443394661,
0.3824427724,
-0.5796085596,
-0.2090512067,
0.3223285973,
-0.1198586598,
-0.2327895314,
0.4645978808,
-0.1060470641,
0.7169991136,
0.2482993901,
0.1645675153,
0.5806572437,
-0.2917080522,
-0.1195393056,
0.207011506,
-0.4274017215,
-0.9281641245,
1.0936032534,
0.5498666167,
0.7983499765,
0.1729167998,
0.8900065422,
0.3477727771,
0.3022676408,
-0.8218430281,
0.5542396307,
0.2064661682,
-0.6868630648,
-0.238629669,
-0.5360953212,
-0.6057956815,
-0.0102354363,
0.1207192689,
-0.6829680204,
-0.1037182957,
0.3775699437,
-0.2559091449,
0.3337962031,
-0.8889330029,
0.6890630722,
-0.1851455569,
-0.1444989741,
-0.2575750649,
-0.1958341748,
0.2768648267,
-0.1418874264,
0.1276027411,
0.1514554769,
-0.3248777688,
0.5782283545,
-0.8275666833,
0.8284367323,
0.0410475805,
-0.2553890049,
0.5429404378,
0.3411074281,
1.1430389881,
0.5634682775,
0.3130979538,
0.0630916655,
0.1423515677,
-0.1077874973,
-0.1910276264,
0.6707005501,
-0.6719220281,
-0.2813126147,
-0.4283100665,
-0.2147318274,
-0.0030817115,
0.397420764,
0.0088211549,
0.3274262249,
-0.3457109928,
-0.2005242258,
0.6236643791,
0.1340756267,
0.035771817,
0.7255749106,
-0.1243629605,
-0.3741096258,
0.7882020473,
0.0711696148,
0.1731483191,
0.2212461829,
0.1313486546,
-0.3162840009,
-0.7987716794,
-0.2567420304,
0.2801050842,
-0.8044509888,
-0.2504014969,
-0.57576859,
0.1678514332,
-0.4908274412,
0.1954214424,
-0.569169879,
-0.2403584719,
0.2157432437,
-0.0744480267,
0.3754893541,
0.8559269905,
0.0472796299,
-0.0151620246,
-0.7825599909,
0.1404731274,
0.9012421966,
0.7085574865,
-0.4125230908,
-0.3385320306,
-0.1315484643,
-0.4124782979,
-0.2971118391,
-0.8863412142,
0.1705598235,
0.049285993,
0.223258391,
0.7113195062,
-0.0372737683,
0.433275342,
-0.4987937808,
0.5018207431,
0.0685895234,
-1.3091372252,
0.2971544862,
-0.5028588772,
-0.0443174765,
0.450381279,
-0.3671340644,
-0.9796040058,
-0.5328536034,
-0.7294765115,
-0.8322197795,
0.4738260508,
0.1235672459,
-0.2453012615,
0.1309066713,
0.2469999641,
-0.1564994454,
0.1090816557,
-0.5377641916,
0.1085587293,
-0.1751514375,
0.0295082219,
0.3560195565,
-0.3036102951,
-0.4738366306,
0.4782997668,
0.8576903343,
-0.2496400177,
0.1748581678,
0.3644797504,
-0.0210141838,
-0.0143406559,
0.4330287874,
0.6490051746,
0.8432555199,
-0.2364270836,
0.1334581077,
0.5947887301,
-0.59053123,
-0.317832768,
0.0898894817,
-0.1728342324,
-0.0962280259,
0.5760342479,
0.4711762369,
-0.049281057,
-0.8700219393,
0.3846911788,
-0.3335439861,
-0.3826200366,
-0.6627274752,
-0.0488844775,
0.0001122865,
0.2495951056,
0.1074838266,
-0.1337926537,
0.1657978743,
-0.3439202309,
0.2150096148,
0.3251342773,
-0.4270563126,
-0.2771006823,
0.2397096604,
0.276743263,
-0.2131972909,
0.7024451494,
0.0390684232,
-0.895442903,
0.8554620743,
-0.0061287587,
1.0785964727,
0.2456239313,
-0.2102103382,
-0.0200415067,
0.6632449031,
-0.0856150761,
0.2363173068,
0.0955469385,
-0.41725564,
-0.6892385483,
0.0300867986,
-0.5335291624,
0.1773292869,
-0.3723871112,
0.4998897016,
-0.6967068315,
-0.0539938174,
0.0305593349,
0.1010978594,
-0.7986291051,
-0.2252249867,
0.1559066474,
0.844173193,
-0.6261361241,
0.5823815465,
0.8219528198,
-0.0858907327,
-0.8399792314,
-0.1249023378,
0.2732655108,
-0.8704504371,
0.5437989831,
-0.0407942533,
-0.1987447143,
-0.2169979662,
-0.5329545736,
-0.2761042118,
0.7928308249,
0.3677956164,
-0.6600131392,
0.3276070654,
0.0644541234,
0.4048927426,
0.1140092537,
0.5851911306,
0.5816401243,
0.6670604944,
-0.4720875323,
-1.1920534372,
-0.0370979905,
-0.0727965906,
-0.5979067683,
0.5179396868,
-0.7726828456,
0.5725073814,
-0.1330782175,
-0.1227740869,
0.0659959018,
0.3748078644,
0.1107257903,
0.0908108577,
0.7087048888,
0.4800955355,
0.7335320711,
-0.1006763279,
0.8991757035,
-0.2969706655,
0.7957271338,
0.7972096205,
-0.2374656945,
0.4582363665,
0.7055174708,
-0.1503081322,
0.3082314134,
0.286937654,
0.0463651083,
0.1511987895,
0.4173900783,
-0.3249465227,
-0.4426585734,
-0.1438545138,
-0.1639306098,
0.2573752999,
0.0964360982,
-0.1105799153,
0.0465984754,
-0.5447500348,
0.2448730916,
-0.2520677447,
-0.0945578292,
1.0481107235,
-0.0697431564,
-0.5389407873,
0.2729720771,
0.0243428275,
0.5523026586,
-1.0023514032,
-0.1000860035,
-0.0706795231,
0.5726474524,
-0.337369591,
-0.4742544591,
-0.0477438755,
0.3426027298,
0.1808569133,
-0.2983314395,
0.521817863,
-0.2044358999,
0.0168041699,
0.1931255013,
0.3213870823,
0.2197281122,
-0.2976255417,
-0.6178408861,
-0.1474860907,
0.2109217346,
-0.4380376339,
0.2111683786,
0.668961823,
-0.0793819427,
0.8665449023,
0.7305370569,
0.3835796118,
-0.0030441557,
0.0122140348,
0.7082620263,
-0.5296709538,
-0.8663264513,
-0.9570283294,
0.4561498165,
-0.1533622444,
-0.4911952913,
0.5298805833,
0.6303409338,
0.7384375334,
-0.0864794478,
0.7808316946,
0.0731145367,
0.3067697585,
-0.5798642039,
0.5920495391,
0.0225828681,
0.447152406,
-0.1214284748,
-0.7900952101,
-0.3305228651,
0.4835053086,
-0.2841716707,
-0.0501542538,
0.840960145,
0.914509654,
-0.1086763069,
0.2343303859,
0.2120947987,
0.0225963388,
0.8591653109,
0.2402042896,
0.9868994355,
-0.4293205738,
1.0475209951,
-0.3237424791,
-0.1802929491,
-0.4120991528,
-1.202005744,
-0.9095362425,
-0.0812204257,
-0.7493255138,
-0.4045281112,
0.0363593698,
0.9470004439,
0.8402160406,
-0.9079015255,
-0.2999627292,
-0.2374122292,
0.1620679647,
-0.3295326531,
-0.2163420767,
0.4891639352,
-0.2127929926,
-0.6298273802,
0.1295927763,
0.238630265,
0.1382479072,
-0.2276377082,
-0.1639527231,
0.149865672,
-0.0268613473,
0.094794035,
0.3391182721,
-0.43855232,
-0.4266266227,
-0.2352567315,
-0.1274481118,
-0.3032886386,
1.181286931,
-0.1805770099,
0.3334666491,
0.7646895051,
0.4451936781,
0.3808266521,
-0.3266578019,
0.3983713388,
-0.3869919479,
0.0438946225,
0.325453788,
0.5453100801,
-0.1653063148,
-0.4774920344,
0.4806973338,
0.0734156221,
-0.8442772031,
-0.7729434967,
0.1297106445,
-0.8530874252,
0.1617654413,
0.7788518071,
-0.3449396193,
-0.1042675823,
-0.5402881503,
-0.4197383821,
0.0853791386,
-0.6482492089,
0.8986597061,
0.8957824707,
0.0393489636,
0.1274802536,
-0.8859718442,
0.3614405394,
0.5825486779,
-0.8626714945,
0.4651297033,
0.3605996966,
0.4894124866,
0.127319783,
0.3044280112,
-0.2614104748,
0.3489947617,
-0.087037392,
0.1738396138,
-0.3182217181,
-0.0770367756,
-0.393455565,
-0.0727994666,
0.260440886,
-0.0315287523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03921v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03921v2
|
Simple Techniques for Enhancing Sentence Embeddings in Generative Language Models
| 2024-04-05T07:07:15 | 2024-05-15T13:34:14 |
Bowen Zhang, Kehua Chang, Chunping Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentence Embedding stands as a fundamental task within the realm of Natural
Language Processing, finding extensive application in search engines, expert
systems, and question-and-answer platforms. With the continuous evolution of
large language models such as LLaMA and Mistral, research on sentence embedding
has recently achieved notable breakthroughs. However, these advancements mainly
pertain to fine-tuning scenarios, leaving explorations into computationally
efficient direct inference methods for sentence representation in a nascent
stage. This paper endeavors to bridge this research gap. Through comprehensive
experimentation, we challenge the widely held belief in the necessity of an
Explicit One-word Limitation for deriving sentence embeddings from Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs). We demonstrate that this approach, while beneficial for
generative models under direct inference scenario, is not imperative for
discriminative models or the fine-tuning of generative PLMs. This discovery
sheds new light on the design of manual templates in future studies. Building
upon this insight, we propose two innovative prompt engineering techniques
capable of further enhancing the expressive power of PLMs' raw embeddings:
Pretended Chain of Thought and Knowledge Enhancement. We confirm their
effectiveness across various PLM types and provide a detailed exploration of
the underlying factors contributing to their success.
|
[
-0.2641689777,
-0.9670743942,
0.9456255436,
0.4053291976,
-0.3418026865,
-0.0952450857,
-0.1080161333,
-0.0462002568,
0.1476591378,
0.5206440687,
-0.63518399,
-0.3548642099,
-0.3059464991,
0.1881295294,
-0.3019549549,
0.7414298058,
-0.13392362,
-0.1350194961,
-0.5110541582,
0.0935140699,
-0.549243927,
-0.5742452741,
-0.1848014742,
0.1335087568,
0.3442609608,
0.1195330545,
0.6587669253,
0.4697574079,
0.0191465355,
0.1786550134,
-0.0291168187,
0.3416567743,
-0.1892793328,
0.2610940337,
0.0755939707,
-0.7377942204,
-0.2280222923,
0.2050761878,
0.473099798,
0.7718394995,
-0.2697829902,
-0.2151291519,
0.1260213703,
0.3906425834,
-0.8032100797,
0.1246099025,
-0.6269044876,
0.2476019263,
-0.2031352967,
-0.1577749848,
-0.6217217445,
-0.4720476866,
0.1689395905,
-0.718524158,
0.0552516319,
0.1648526043,
0.7232313752,
0.3150772452,
-0.4712841213,
-0.4297049344,
-0.4042848945,
0.6141312122,
-0.6495759487,
0.2460526377,
0.2085011452,
0.0497389846,
-0.2604557574,
-0.9585828781,
-0.6813495755,
-0.5952046514,
-0.0955210254,
0.0631811768,
-0.3574103415,
0.382679671,
0.4376332164,
0.3944969177,
-0.2517831326,
0.1540173441,
0.2557481825,
-0.0039781793,
0.2426857203,
0.0269123986,
0.4179484844,
-0.2237845808,
-0.4815078974,
-0.2226589024,
-0.9810955524,
-0.089970313,
0.254573971,
0.2751435935,
0.0113701634,
0.7054764032,
-0.0982203931,
0.6416317821,
-0.0206410717,
0.4250651002,
0.0984188691,
-0.2744159698,
-0.2486159503,
-0.0787454471,
0.6354020834,
0.0433088355,
0.2899450362,
-0.1683331579,
-0.1999173164,
0.3038676381,
0.3452217281,
-0.5549849272,
-0.0372996442,
-0.087506406,
-0.1596302241,
-0.305775255,
0.2608108819,
-0.5947021246,
-0.4940630496,
-0.0547638275,
0.3126005232,
-0.3669907749,
-0.1315338463,
0.3410412669,
-0.3281749785,
0.1617442966,
0.1794514358,
-0.5416038632,
0.0532379337,
0.7390416861,
0.7322551012,
0.3434946239,
-0.0939041153,
-0.6180532575,
0.0282323081,
-0.556012094,
0.7373171449,
-0.5828519464,
-0.3538242579,
0.3689843118,
-0.2580870986,
-0.0351241119,
-0.3992841542,
0.8892762065,
-0.6251243949,
0.2888247371,
-0.4714877605,
-0.924944222,
-0.0976405591,
0.0126843555,
-0.494135201,
0.6628302932,
-0.033424858,
-0.8125545382,
0.1850416213,
-0.5659416318,
-0.5609360337,
-0.0096096927,
-0.213324666,
-0.1083637029,
0.5762243271,
0.5182707906,
0.5077654719,
-0.296677798,
0.3937235475,
-0.4572007358,
-0.1539784223,
0.4767865539,
-0.5892333984,
0.7432293296,
0.1849399656,
-0.0578113683,
-0.1674334407,
-0.3049161136,
-0.0556729324,
0.0225387886,
-0.0454518534,
-0.4399165213,
-0.1084130183,
-0.1552165151,
0.058164902,
0.1802763343,
-0.4002192318,
0.4413850904,
-0.6729749441,
0.4887103736,
0.7541397214,
0.2284092307,
0.5756833553,
-0.3748561442,
0.8538917303,
0.1139867306,
0.0311872587,
-0.5309750438,
-0.3568721116,
-0.9406045675,
-0.1375838816,
0.3262678981,
0.4723769426,
-0.9436914325,
0.4577302039,
-0.1459654719,
-0.1412886679,
-0.862354517,
0.1629891098,
0.1340910792,
0.3481729627,
0.4205232263,
0.0648792461,
-0.7941820621,
-0.8782135844,
-0.5532518029,
-0.0033977646,
-0.1288213581,
0.0544788018,
0.1268824339,
-0.0895748213,
1.2004041672,
-0.7385172844,
-0.0525987893,
-0.5053112507,
0.0782405958,
0.2538452446,
0.4379459023,
0.527911067,
-0.6998713017,
-0.3204941154,
-0.4968806505,
-0.828365922,
-0.2438341975,
-0.4904027879,
-0.159832418,
-0.1832143813,
0.5063280463,
-0.949893713,
0.4233340025,
0.2959281206,
-0.3600103259,
0.435590744,
-0.271312207,
-0.089399606,
-0.863034308,
-0.3950989842,
-0.0109091531,
-0.2995234132,
-0.6074085832,
0.1965324432,
0.1428392678,
-0.0921837837,
-0.2038637251,
0.4209086895,
-0.637013495,
0.3478940725,
-0.181380704,
0.2381259948,
0.0511158556,
0.3558179736,
-0.2384243757,
0.7675814629,
0.7357671857,
-0.7115827799,
0.089375414,
0.3643609583,
-0.4305995405,
0.2565642297,
-0.7428176999,
0.3056261539,
-0.3208317757,
0.3438800871,
-0.8647569418,
-0.0720860511,
0.4742107689,
-0.0513659492,
0.2147429585,
-0.089599818,
-0.7055001259,
-0.3840576112,
-0.4735419154,
0.0656168163,
0.848988533,
-0.6109716892,
0.4727150798,
0.2536663115,
-0.0799657926,
-0.2337662578,
-0.6038489938,
0.3391917348,
-0.3173865378,
-0.5529288054,
0.550734818,
0.0337376967,
-0.2535750568,
-0.0926302224,
-0.1743891537,
0.1154731438,
0.2286257744,
0.1848906279,
0.273515135,
-0.2760667503,
0.3557406962,
0.604108572,
-0.0908192918,
0.065609239,
-0.3616656065,
0.4583487809,
-0.0333525985,
-0.3007485569,
-0.491838038,
0.2542335093,
0.2411665171,
-0.218901366,
0.8004056215,
0.2019222528,
-0.2955872715,
-0.4860485792,
-0.765011847,
-0.2524974048,
-0.5380352736,
-0.0334378481,
-0.4022144377,
-1.0191404819,
0.1542185694,
-0.3919250071,
-0.2247883081,
0.2817264497,
-0.0344672389,
-0.1135207191,
0.8812056184,
0.6623697877,
0.2204675525,
0.525205493,
0.0011892128,
0.2650805116,
-0.9035180211,
0.169428587,
-0.3279212117,
0.0900375471,
-0.5718622804,
-0.6482023597,
0.432302624,
0.5284869671,
-0.1440033019,
0.2806574106,
-0.1309978366,
0.2244540751,
0.4387071729,
0.2859478295,
0.1300691068,
0.0051353676,
-0.4694071412,
-0.1677307934,
-0.9734177589,
-0.7830296755,
0.8280115724,
0.3128314912,
0.6855759621,
-0.2161336541,
0.5788208842,
0.2641948462,
0.1718214899,
-0.5489072204,
0.6286094189,
-0.1895390898,
-0.2465170324,
-0.0063639963,
-0.3024395704,
-0.663289547,
0.1573172659,
-0.1836439669,
-0.4826668501,
0.2599840462,
0.1359397322,
-0.5348334908,
0.1228774711,
-0.6250305176,
0.7263407707,
-0.2075972557,
-0.1977116168,
-0.1858986914,
-0.3608326316,
0.2097119093,
0.2595604658,
0.0206946414,
0.1650602818,
-0.1922920644,
0.6031864285,
-0.5788217187,
1.0905053616,
-0.2802798152,
-0.3119043708,
0.5201538801,
0.0663732737,
0.7584345937,
0.2102694362,
-0.0029080778,
-0.3039749861,
-0.3191040754,
-0.2597473562,
-0.9330737591,
0.5532628298,
-0.3254188001,
-1.0187464952,
-0.2506202161,
-0.2801164985,
-0.4866817892,
-0.0683435127,
0.0955372155,
0.4163731635,
-0.2690037489,
0.1373115182,
0.7274692655,
-0.5825485587,
0.580350101,
0.1524796933,
-0.1560717821,
-0.3661827147,
0.3710921705,
-0.0711644366,
0.072988227,
0.590539217,
0.2410313785,
-0.3841902018,
-0.2254005075,
-0.1783076376,
0.2671641707,
-0.6957931519,
-0.2232611626,
-1.0140396357,
-0.0335230343,
-0.6571457386,
-0.2351754457,
-0.154487446,
-0.5474748611,
-0.5527278781,
-0.4981718361,
0.4634645283,
0.5712203979,
0.0637545809,
0.3869698346,
-0.6706059575,
0.2262438089,
0.3853714764,
-0.028732501,
0.1666159183,
-0.3436121047,
0.0396847688,
0.2605302334,
-0.2338843942,
-1.0305492878,
0.2777150571,
0.233056426,
0.6114854813,
0.6439266205,
0.3482311964,
0.8051957488,
-0.472432375,
0.8073600531,
0.1279326081,
-1.0733712912,
0.8151357174,
-0.1621165574,
0.0724930912,
0.3323349357,
0.3776986003,
-0.4978403449,
-0.3463095725,
-0.5703377128,
-0.7001139522,
0.1863556206,
0.219691664,
0.6527916193,
-0.4521084726,
0.5846689939,
0.2119371146,
0.4473690093,
-0.6084513068,
-0.0732374489,
-0.1798284799,
-0.1776761264,
-0.0208969489,
-0.4353037477,
0.1355498731,
-0.1226354167,
0.4559778869,
-0.007450351,
0.2691343129,
0.3345215619,
-0.4886151552,
0.3586331308,
0.4813173711,
0.3813824058,
0.3717196286,
0.1378686875,
0.2466699183,
0.2926304042,
-0.0620993301,
0.0570360348,
0.118276976,
-0.3106797636,
0.028318407,
0.4953416288,
1.0431518555,
0.3474472165,
-0.6595931649,
0.6178889871,
0.2289964706,
0.3229340613,
-0.3542463183,
0.1682098359,
0.057553675,
0.2469038516,
0.3860329688,
0.0205413606,
0.0238452815,
-0.6332857013,
0.1961186677,
0.4389443398,
-0.3833190799,
-0.3242979348,
0.7006197572,
0.156321153,
-0.197042048,
0.7285199761,
-0.2976589799,
-0.5721513629,
0.402669847,
0.6133039594,
1.0383212566,
-0.0153305558,
0.6017832756,
0.108173348,
0.3682297468,
-0.2437975556,
0.0796197504,
-0.1191204265,
-0.8592953086,
-0.4450898767,
-0.5614517927,
0.0048827454,
-0.1928861141,
-0.6192025542,
0.2360677868,
-0.3517021537,
-0.1526349783,
-0.4491673708,
-0.2372124642,
-0.8523155451,
-0.1671558917,
0.1332230568,
1.0947986841,
-0.8424821496,
0.672866106,
0.6237443686,
-0.5429867506,
-0.5050997734,
0.1952114254,
-0.416075021,
-0.5884929299,
0.6063868403,
0.355561167,
0.1407892704,
0.2210232764,
-0.6035653949,
-0.3788452744,
0.9795672297,
0.5937975645,
-0.6839493513,
-0.3880233467,
0.0675727576,
0.5147066116,
-0.598466754,
0.1306593716,
0.3590420187,
0.3532519639,
-0.1562155336,
-0.4384941459,
0.4182460308,
-0.0571750142,
0.3950624764,
-0.1734736264,
-0.1425751746,
0.7736130357,
-0.3499623835,
-0.599350214,
0.3176810443,
0.9099035859,
0.2962872386,
0.0493971929,
0.5833310485,
0.7315528989,
0.9088235497,
0.0120840389,
1.3327296972,
-0.0723539293,
0.1478714794,
1.1411975622,
-0.3560178876,
0.6476436853,
0.4722060263,
-0.1869399548,
0.733925581,
0.4487196505,
0.0914253518,
0.7671334743,
0.3901937306,
-0.484536469,
-0.4828736484,
-0.3066173196,
-0.3032668829,
0.2741748095,
0.3399763405,
-0.3120715618,
-0.1188193336,
0.4225278795,
0.0862996206,
0.2058897465,
-0.0974216759,
0.6124805212,
0.4290039241,
-0.5652704835,
0.1995515823,
-0.117609486,
0.8493714333,
-0.4310466349,
-0.1596485525,
-0.3655963242,
-0.211860761,
0.2227959335,
-0.4753795266,
-0.1014891863,
0.1106863022,
0.1777279377,
-0.6655093431,
0.7039345503,
-0.3651632965,
-0.4086705446,
0.1078851745,
0.7399631739,
-0.3182430267,
-0.2949842513,
-0.341357708,
-0.1130431145,
-0.1932601333,
-0.3000509739,
0.0409453399,
0.6372541785,
0.3575352728,
0.7378165722,
0.5329268575,
0.0922325701,
0.0235974099,
0.1760943532,
1.0269553661,
-0.710175693,
-0.7033960223,
-0.9191837311,
0.5744636655,
-0.0916104093,
-0.2508782446,
0.8423791528,
0.3169768751,
0.5556608438,
-0.292180717,
0.8882180452,
0.011252502,
0.2344995886,
-0.8902222514,
0.5049914718,
-0.2864015996,
0.3877143562,
-0.2265885025,
-0.734262526,
-0.1894910932,
0.7303842902,
-0.2907330394,
-0.0319708996,
0.7935110927,
0.7030395269,
0.058640305,
0.0504787527,
0.1943598539,
0.4147674143,
0.2672298253,
0.3765756488,
1.2510119677,
-0.428755939,
0.2494171709,
-0.2402522415,
-0.0884857997,
-0.0584941246,
-1.0527843237,
-0.9399345517,
-0.6447064877,
-0.4292367399,
-0.196948573,
0.153440401,
0.9701915383,
0.3428543508,
-0.5550275445,
0.12335971,
-0.6154051423,
0.1489102393,
-0.2554394603,
-0.2276952267,
0.1656805724,
-0.6616410613,
-0.4829885662,
0.6922298074,
0.2087608129,
0.2341803014,
-0.1793545038,
0.138814196,
-0.2806409895,
0.1610585302,
0.6171650887,
-0.0365349241,
-0.7738285661,
-0.3667646646,
0.123357363,
0.0001870953,
-0.2049757838,
1.165029645,
-1.1305696964,
0.4144420922,
0.4031811357,
0.6916252971,
0.2174638361,
0.0005664288,
0.9272837043,
-0.8530516028,
0.1148436517,
0.3551600873,
0.432659179,
0.323589921,
-0.3437680602,
0.3779407442,
0.1600627899,
-0.0665073991,
-0.9230152369,
0.3445420563,
-0.7733070254,
-0.2814890444,
0.9655375481,
-0.3078959286,
0.1452231705,
0.1745118648,
-0.1537843347,
0.5050810575,
-0.1027709022,
0.7039542794,
0.6329541802,
0.1138038114,
-0.2882975638,
-0.4948779345,
0.5312291384,
0.5114867091,
-0.8457512259,
0.0607053787,
0.4318038821,
0.0484302677,
-0.0361480489,
0.3451656699,
0.1744169742,
0.0314874649,
0.0756335035,
-0.2491573244,
-0.1473631114,
-0.2064990401,
-0.394238174,
0.2478434294,
-0.0054551507,
-0.0969217718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03912v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03912v1
|
Forget NLI, Use a Dictionary: Zero-Shot Topic Classification for Low-Resource Languages with Application to Luxembourgish
| 2024-04-05T06:35:31 | 2024-04-05T06:35:31 |
Fred Philippy, Shohreh Haddadan, Siwen Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In NLP, zero-shot classification (ZSC) is the task of assigning labels to
textual data without any labeled examples for the target classes. A common
method for ZSC is to fine-tune a language model on a Natural Language Inference
(NLI) dataset and then use it to infer the entailment between the input
document and the target labels. However, this approach faces certain
challenges, particularly for languages with limited resources. In this paper,
we propose an alternative solution that leverages dictionaries as a source of
data for ZSC. We focus on Luxembourgish, a low-resource language spoken in
Luxembourg, and construct two new topic relevance classification datasets based
on a dictionary that provides various synonyms, word translations and example
sentences. We evaluate the usability of our dataset and compare it with the
NLI-based approach on two topic classification tasks in a zero-shot manner. Our
results show that by using the dictionary-based dataset, the trained models
outperform the ones following the NLI-based approach for ZSC. While we focus on
a single low-resource language in this study, we believe that the efficacy of
our approach can also transfer to other languages where such a dictionary is
available.
|
[
-0.4238503277,
-0.4961710274,
0.4048218429,
-0.1557983905,
-0.4542077184,
-0.0287464168,
-0.4376390874,
-0.0322477072,
0.4447680116,
0.5047305226,
-0.5063067675,
-0.5765172243,
-0.6183055043,
0.0911119506,
-0.4867758155,
0.8452984691,
-0.0459824204,
-0.1759778708,
0.0061793202,
-0.2831510901,
-0.3570978045,
-0.5539988875,
-0.0697823688,
-0.1376957148,
0.6375578642,
0.9862832427,
0.4377980828,
0.5536869764,
0.4622774422,
0.2198938429,
-0.184819594,
-0.0783545077,
-0.5025680065,
0.0096763894,
-0.3054831326,
-0.390329212,
0.2168423831,
0.0897696391,
0.379627794,
0.961389482,
-0.2149913013,
0.0739343241,
-0.0557697974,
0.5426251888,
-1.1048009396,
0.0890545174,
-0.6887198091,
0.1209829077,
-0.5224053264,
-0.0494594723,
-0.1925297529,
0.1587726623,
0.1434223652,
-0.4641682804,
0.4555099308,
-0.2986700833,
0.9753158689,
0.2050641179,
-0.2230790108,
-0.4346956015,
-0.5913745165,
1.0374871492,
-0.5644070506,
0.2783446908,
0.5286338925,
0.1541544497,
0.2149810046,
-0.4819772542,
-0.7910598516,
-0.1295046657,
-0.0214908961,
0.1923761666,
-0.1821138114,
-0.0264988635,
0.1109005436,
0.3205558658,
-0.3526822627,
0.1300545484,
-0.3151048422,
-0.1355223507,
0.4034314156,
-0.006077067,
0.2739200592,
-0.5627384782,
0.0612753853,
-0.113572672,
-0.5672543049,
-0.1270701438,
0.221322462,
0.8112413883,
-0.0678631887,
0.6442704201,
-0.6832893491,
0.8952419758,
0.00369027,
-0.1471830904,
0.4189758301,
-0.5458529592,
-0.0130289756,
0.2984807193,
0.7016060352,
0.2078428566,
0.131136775,
-0.382214129,
0.0084956838,
0.1034347117,
0.1627147198,
-0.8669525981,
0.0108931819,
0.1511594802,
-0.2752690315,
-0.3560664058,
0.1005984172,
-0.5875945091,
-0.0352144986,
-0.0397430211,
0.2570166886,
-0.4663470089,
-0.22333619,
0.0380888879,
-0.2110083401,
0.0810657144,
0.2504612505,
-1.0389229059,
0.0390902981,
0.6428519487,
1.2580916882,
0.0960103199,
-0.1719811261,
-0.5498844981,
0.1532727331,
-0.6122896671,
0.7650358677,
-0.4357319474,
-0.556876719,
0.0151387099,
-0.0681478232,
0.2815451622,
-0.254924655,
0.7317669392,
-0.1172894239,
0.3399988413,
-0.382006079,
-0.553170681,
0.0058861598,
0.2266250998,
-0.5216008425,
0.7146052718,
0.3671002388,
-0.9677531719,
0.4867416918,
-0.6175729036,
-0.5845789313,
0.3073831201,
-0.2799192071,
0.0663422421,
0.2321240604,
-0.0682054311,
0.5905332565,
-0.1882453561,
0.3417792618,
-0.3724848032,
-0.4036053121,
-0.1105309799,
-0.5463851094,
0.7307989001,
0.3986882865,
-0.0165631734,
-0.3922508955,
-0.8382081985,
-0.0982680842,
-0.1249947175,
-0.2613515556,
-0.7011828423,
0.1968079954,
0.1963618547,
0.315846473,
0.1935138404,
-1.027536869,
0.0746975467,
-0.6672388315,
0.5874177814,
0.2260121256,
-0.0595550388,
0.6954787374,
-0.051634416,
0.1442371905,
0.1909830123,
-0.1373510659,
0.1505623162,
-0.5373708606,
-0.8039556146,
-0.1894047558,
0.6503461599,
0.7021322846,
-1.1682547331,
0.611877203,
-0.4052873254,
-0.6727067232,
-0.4883046746,
0.3743872046,
-0.0528082773,
1.0196361542,
0.2970825434,
-0.2518345416,
-0.2622185946,
-0.9201967716,
0.4379113019,
-0.2863458991,
-0.3357389271,
0.3952083588,
0.3070948124,
-0.0191782042,
1.0906959772,
-0.4071567953,
-0.4667851031,
-0.5362501144,
0.3765268326,
0.4724290073,
0.1706362069,
0.8769340515,
-0.7502503395,
-0.4916704595,
-0.1337181181,
-0.6387619972,
-0.1979580671,
0.0008438791,
-0.2652598917,
0.2570913732,
0.1526436806,
-0.1677875817,
0.3423607945,
0.1833132058,
-0.278033942,
-0.1184065714,
-0.2409193516,
-0.0321218818,
-1.2447023392,
0.0966973156,
0.1746432185,
0.2070890367,
-0.8441784382,
-0.1711803824,
0.1657573581,
-0.1827424765,
-0.7155941725,
0.6993896365,
-0.1200637296,
0.2808074355,
-0.436037004,
0.1080367193,
-0.2013849765,
0.2629809976,
0.7251380086,
0.6847776175,
0.761218369,
-0.5188778043,
0.3621490598,
0.4922128916,
-0.4524793029,
0.6308544874,
-0.3147564232,
-0.3327794969,
-0.1998265088,
-0.1867318302,
-0.6889120936,
-0.0871360376,
0.4154998362,
-0.2977510393,
0.3559653759,
-0.2523728907,
-0.3706872761,
-0.2822077274,
-0.3730693161,
-0.1896382868,
0.4513823688,
-0.3808708489,
0.2295947969,
0.2809011042,
-0.0941442102,
-0.8422269225,
-1.0807011127,
0.2523851097,
-0.1992238909,
-0.277381748,
0.3368234932,
0.0862223059,
-0.136405021,
0.3560607731,
-0.0759062022,
-0.6124559641,
0.3842076957,
0.230212152,
0.2289715111,
-0.267231822,
0.3533146977,
-0.0017339723,
-0.1393600702,
-0.5457488894,
0.0427461751,
0.3201783597,
-0.0555025749,
-0.2723292112,
-0.4249122143,
0.5439808369,
0.3522408009,
-0.0735672712,
0.9393911362,
0.5172274113,
-0.310454458,
-0.1061191857,
-0.4225625098,
-0.0218965001,
-0.3904423714,
0.254853487,
-0.3376320302,
-0.771969378,
0.1747026145,
0.0179551169,
0.0183794405,
0.5544783473,
0.4867451191,
-0.2785048485,
0.291212678,
0.8916949034,
-0.7145719528,
0.6631072164,
-0.4109693468,
0.3316158354,
-0.5480374098,
0.3109525442,
-0.7253472209,
-0.3082537949,
-0.6008540392,
-0.2167842537,
-0.022170851,
0.4283562899,
0.0481569171,
0.6908015013,
-0.3830909431,
0.3931455314,
0.7031279802,
-0.0451734699,
0.1028407663,
0.2426518649,
0.1862933338,
-0.0073140808,
-0.9909778237,
-0.5774899125,
1.169298172,
-0.0981529579,
0.5351954699,
0.1110099778,
1.1709779501,
0.2238525748,
0.1227274612,
-0.9914659858,
0.2903978825,
-0.7764794827,
-0.4313082695,
-0.6133708358,
-0.5769160986,
-0.6989117265,
0.1447407603,
-0.271625191,
-0.7057850957,
0.5397942662,
-0.0943867564,
-0.5806436539,
0.432836026,
-0.8330213428,
0.8527995348,
-0.2975716293,
-0.3369916081,
-0.23952353,
-0.4166120887,
0.1698751599,
-0.312636584,
0.2948304713,
-0.3089932501,
-0.0723658577,
0.6842797399,
-0.6061198711,
0.7450660467,
-0.1326365918,
-0.0566453524,
0.4856152236,
-0.1159848198,
-0.1583619863,
0.1329932511,
-0.5087943077,
0.6672811508,
0.2857267559,
-0.4734756351,
-0.6084038019,
0.6958646178,
-0.644993782,
-0.3833452463,
-0.5148335099,
-0.2227750272,
-0.1715187281,
0.2027953267,
0.3098371923,
0.4790208042,
-0.2857645452,
0.2539338768,
0.3236660361,
-0.2020335644,
0.6242724657,
0.9144964218,
0.4428941905,
0.1322949827,
1.3081729412,
0.4900875688,
-0.076021634,
0.5619843602,
0.1314762831,
-0.152634576,
-0.5660488605,
-0.5233849883,
0.0672228485,
-0.5200179815,
-0.2769246995,
-0.3692730069,
-0.304720968,
-0.408646673,
-0.3131889701,
-0.3614042699,
-0.611023128,
-0.6218430996,
0.1738322079,
0.3926312923,
0.3377610147,
-0.5539107919,
0.2529533207,
-0.8051315546,
0.6393259764,
0.2333533913,
0.5532321334,
-0.2302822918,
-0.5784312487,
-0.0592242442,
0.2203727067,
-0.1097844839,
-0.9487345815,
0.3559302986,
0.6349896193,
0.578260839,
0.6254581809,
0.4911170304,
0.5064871907,
-0.632560432,
0.6429275274,
0.2716628611,
-1.0856201649,
0.8977608085,
0.1336645186,
0.0283277016,
0.8632608652,
0.5231954455,
-1.0710090399,
-0.3817365468,
-0.5031222701,
-0.8406368494,
0.9774278998,
0.195464015,
0.4606753886,
-0.3806085587,
0.4708355963,
-0.1249603257,
0.2960589528,
-0.2523912489,
-0.1846475005,
-0.4093327522,
-0.4178765416,
-0.275663048,
-0.3845010698,
0.2236388028,
-0.2219631523,
0.7009779215,
-0.2435915321,
-0.0112985596,
0.124268122,
-0.2953680456,
-0.0436646678,
0.5468640327,
0.3623488247,
0.480784893,
-0.5099233389,
0.085694015,
0.271463722,
-0.3088161349,
0.2228839695,
-0.0529481284,
-0.3911822736,
0.3914451003,
0.4553997219,
0.5467278957,
0.1679424495,
-0.8102838397,
0.7183740735,
-0.0490221791,
-0.2941617668,
0.1599434167,
0.029917011,
0.0242272113,
-0.0441946015,
0.0265169553,
-0.257117182,
0.1510015279,
-0.6298166513,
0.3243123293,
0.3015806377,
-0.4351152778,
0.0327620283,
0.17608428,
0.3488433957,
-0.0869843215,
0.8219992518,
-0.3921958506,
-0.2862471044,
0.4070406258,
-0.0128012598,
0.5290188193,
-0.0331147648,
0.6162414551,
0.422726661,
0.2443708181,
-0.1206930429,
0.2820144594,
-0.3461232781,
-1.0987964869,
-0.3813077211,
-0.6945732236,
-0.5539827943,
0.2202684879,
-0.7743039727,
0.3357288837,
-0.3138098419,
0.00365927,
0.248603493,
0.0378639922,
-0.5301395059,
-0.0979838222,
0.5357122421,
1.0678403378,
-1.0268770456,
1.2266649008,
0.5136863589,
-0.6384786367,
-0.2725739479,
-0.0939106569,
-0.1504095942,
-0.564950645,
0.9130517244,
-0.1445538998,
0.0319829136,
-0.2791616023,
-0.463234216,
-0.9142484665,
0.7294713855,
0.2728258967,
-0.7906276584,
0.1724747568,
0.2611862719,
0.5797017813,
0.0645716563,
0.0220030602,
0.4198416173,
0.3167274892,
0.291123867,
-0.812863946,
-0.5157471895,
-0.1490306109,
0.0683100969,
0.1471452415,
-0.3661460876,
0.6715898514,
-0.0213416889,
-0.3794587553,
0.0802277476,
0.5754196048,
-0.2876338959,
0.0413472801,
0.3625076711,
0.6900313497,
0.6456013322,
-0.2779231966,
0.8881387115,
-0.5993651152,
0.4993299246,
1.1521258354,
-0.7103900313,
1.1128764153,
0.6053020954,
0.0093758004,
0.1533118039,
0.6565481424,
-0.2615972161,
1.0043306351,
0.1737680435,
-0.3033590019,
-0.3650880158,
-0.3944449723,
-0.179027155,
0.5978857875,
0.4694949687,
0.1182845533,
-0.8982573748,
0.1428050101,
-0.2528978586,
0.0620691217,
-0.2611806989,
0.8189021945,
-0.1914466918,
-0.0077391583,
0.5453659892,
0.2803640068,
1.0237178802,
-0.621932447,
0.0233237892,
-0.3301475644,
-0.0838912725,
0.0635839999,
-0.9113844633,
0.5184053779,
0.4122742414,
-0.2552134395,
-0.3246165812,
0.608581543,
-0.5630010366,
-0.827701807,
0.1489191055,
0.6907188296,
0.2828682661,
0.0626584142,
-0.6133499146,
-0.5300195813,
-0.2208902091,
0.1365362108,
0.2998681068,
0.6699593067,
0.084581092,
0.5695343018,
0.2561721802,
0.3813687861,
-0.3195234239,
0.0172868744,
0.634927094,
-0.6110861897,
-0.4902856052,
-0.7077850103,
-0.121509552,
-0.0357687809,
-0.290397048,
0.5528114438,
0.527661562,
1.0567721128,
0.1227394342,
0.9933393002,
-0.3317926824,
0.7916080952,
-0.2525408268,
0.9480674863,
-0.6959657073,
0.010220211,
-0.2301838398,
-0.5324274898,
-0.3581647277,
0.836712122,
-0.3891496658,
-0.5026668906,
0.4217473567,
0.5682659149,
-0.1864171773,
-0.2095952928,
0.620518744,
-0.178588599,
-0.1011666581,
0.5726034045,
0.8025192022,
-0.1383846253,
0.4491256773,
-0.896304667,
-0.090786539,
0.00213542,
-0.8408058286,
-0.7600142956,
-0.6512357593,
-0.4402123392,
0.0568293333,
0.0134381084,
0.8475639224,
0.628759861,
-1.2514774799,
-0.27868402,
0.0148507254,
0.2584565878,
0.1397816986,
-0.1723240763,
0.3995440304,
-0.5035746098,
-0.5995692015,
0.3703999221,
0.2381138355,
0.0866741985,
-0.0486803651,
0.165993005,
-0.3524706066,
-0.1361784488,
0.5023659468,
0.4194505215,
-0.8336423635,
-0.2841461897,
-0.1826894283,
-0.0837455541,
0.0607285239,
0.7499171495,
-0.8050386906,
0.3403225839,
0.4279773533,
0.6886150837,
0.0891761184,
-0.3782871366,
0.2074730396,
-0.8702119589,
0.6159026027,
0.0871391818,
0.5536507368,
0.2243273556,
-0.2108543962,
0.5452178121,
0.3735245764,
0.2762534916,
-0.7109481692,
0.0143022574,
-0.859315455,
-0.7032182813,
0.9118952751,
-0.1329608858,
-0.2967082262,
-0.1614037156,
-0.0491898246,
0.2837609351,
-0.4045078158,
0.9720999599,
1.0339895487,
0.2615240514,
-0.0084283799,
-0.598041296,
0.233842358,
0.1804302782,
-0.6676832438,
0.1068520546,
0.3101828396,
0.3376066387,
0.4259168804,
0.5885145068,
0.2835213244,
0.0444195531,
-0.1979904175,
0.1157130525,
0.0698829666,
-0.2575676441,
-0.5468158722,
0.2471923083,
-0.1343548894,
-0.3716667295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08672v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08672v1
|
Taxonomy and Analysis of Sensitive User Queries in Generative AI Search
| 2024-04-05T05:14:46 | 2024-04-05T05:14:46 |
Hwiyeol Jo, Taiwoo Park, Nayoung Choi, Changbong Kim, Ohjoon Kwon, Donghyeon Jeon, Hyunwoo Lee, Eui-Hyeon Lee, Kyoungho Shin, Sun Suk Lim, Kyungmi Kim, Jihye Lee, Sun Kim
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Although there has been a growing interest among industries to integrate
generative LLMs into their services, limited experiences and scarcity of
resources acts as a barrier in launching and servicing large-scale LLM-based
conversational services. In this paper, we share our experiences in developing
and operating generative AI models within a national-scale search engine, with
a specific focus on the sensitiveness of user queries. We propose a taxonomy
for sensitive search queries, outline our approaches, and present a
comprehensive analysis report on sensitive queries from actual users.
|
[
-0.4269011319,
-0.911123395,
0.268530488,
0.1298774332,
0.2703383565,
0.0531529151,
0.0507727414,
-0.733774364,
0.106412828,
0.6151188016,
-0.7318984866,
-0.365346998,
-0.3634990454,
0.2090044767,
-0.5469378233,
0.580362916,
0.3225413561,
-0.4499995112,
-0.3726167977,
-0.3606964946,
-0.2724792957,
-0.9328019619,
-0.7830163836,
0.3076710999,
0.547770083,
0.1959582418,
0.8044975996,
0.1231695488,
0.9676476121,
0.2735658884,
-0.330815345,
-0.1001048088,
-0.3738716245,
0.7293048501,
-0.3336758614,
-0.8498633504,
-0.2503398061,
-0.1640410274,
0.5256041884,
0.6080062389,
-0.2946022153,
0.0735386461,
-0.1651282459,
0.3559967875,
-0.9228060246,
-0.1126879901,
-0.8908096552,
0.3173649311,
-0.3768847585,
-0.0909415409,
-0.3900195658,
-0.1779430956,
0.3385441303,
-0.5209156275,
0.5527971983,
-0.0107981004,
0.4458326995,
0.395211786,
-0.5997065902,
-0.5139091015,
-0.7456348538,
0.8100599051,
-0.5720253587,
0.0995472521,
0.5302687287,
0.2920886576,
0.0431870595,
-0.9748078585,
-0.323040694,
-0.1026598588,
-0.1413899362,
0.0145835187,
-0.5174992681,
0.0613916591,
0.3583191335,
0.5235096812,
-0.6590100527,
0.5916973352,
-0.1568575054,
-0.2108491808,
0.868545413,
0.6131860018,
0.4467791915,
-0.1462325454,
-0.4626565874,
0.2724594176,
-0.6195642352,
-0.1783064902,
0.2782444954,
0.3971220255,
0.0368836187,
0.5721285939,
-0.4316155016,
0.8375751972,
-0.2942854166,
0.1803684831,
-0.1332382262,
-0.2813518643,
0.0031810349,
-0.3670243323,
0.7907129526,
0.165606007,
0.2650245726,
-0.27235201,
-0.4346888363,
-0.0421552844,
0.5864953995,
-0.7445748448,
0.1951007247,
0.0695955977,
-0.394230783,
-0.3160797656,
-0.2160890549,
-0.6759179235,
-0.5731937289,
0.1188604683,
0.1159568354,
-0.0495393574,
-0.3159588873,
-0.2570751905,
0.0160993915,
0.3614266515,
-0.0323996097,
-1.2283432484,
0.345359385,
0.6612312794,
0.8059417605,
-0.1364807189,
0.0029458536,
-0.2176902443,
-0.0173506849,
0.1050910503,
0.8328649998,
-0.7987189293,
-0.9732630849,
0.4338837266,
-0.3639813364,
-0.2829938531,
-0.9707864523,
0.4148161709,
-1.1294429302,
0.0414375812,
-0.2831721604,
-0.4209092259,
0.037896838,
0.3055359423,
-0.5816124678,
0.8772521615,
0.4931023419,
-0.7162618637,
0.3096346259,
-0.9007145762,
-0.3960031271,
0.6753537655,
-0.2959648669,
-0.14197056,
0.1805517375,
0.1561890244,
0.3551352918,
-0.4303464592,
0.0412650108,
-0.1487131119,
-0.2211084068,
0.5597609878,
-0.3127147257,
0.8953429461,
0.5089264512,
-0.1701084077,
0.3432593942,
-0.3458919823,
-0.0191583522,
0.1843103319,
-0.2615359426,
-0.3724661469,
0.0809497833,
0.1906194091,
-0.0850078613,
0.3344192207,
-0.0972558558,
0.3038022816,
-0.5186963677,
0.7110692859,
0.7268488407,
0.1102674976,
0.1764767617,
-0.1939635873,
1.0082287788,
-0.125894323,
0.4006175697,
0.0010395088,
-0.6186845303,
-0.6151062846,
0.0444087684,
0.0307487305,
0.5400534272,
-0.6501899362,
0.3124493659,
-0.241936639,
-0.256139189,
-0.4906463027,
0.1555473953,
0.2889890373,
0.5164185762,
0.1017246544,
-0.5056604147,
-0.2107624412,
-1.0912436247,
-0.1595676988,
-0.482000798,
-0.3339494467,
1.0538135767,
0.3485651314,
-0.5017837286,
0.9032161832,
-0.6587468386,
-0.4093126655,
0.1452547759,
0.2996084392,
-0.1266165823,
0.0741730928,
0.6422854662,
-1.2972285748,
-0.5056658983,
-0.2267994285,
-0.8182647824,
-0.178371489,
0.2774463594,
-0.1412169188,
0.2465066165,
0.5091434717,
-0.7224304676,
0.3878957331,
0.2356436849,
-0.2646871805,
0.4576528072,
0.2588410079,
-0.0860207677,
-1.0734921694,
0.2504402399,
0.1967900544,
0.01837519,
-0.7142108083,
0.7456970215,
-0.1267692596,
-0.3091294765,
-0.627848804,
0.4275924563,
-0.3782526255,
-0.1903083324,
-0.1268732846,
0.0665425658,
-0.32793203,
0.197852999,
-0.0414122939,
1.3744598627,
0.4099553227,
-0.8198032975,
0.4567809999,
0.5242984891,
-0.3485658169,
0.6193915606,
-0.5438165069,
0.4093819261,
0.1156684458,
-0.3133023679,
-0.7059334517,
-0.4952208996,
0.0955782756,
-0.3811194301,
0.1526278108,
-0.2139558196,
-0.5429171324,
-0.4315426052,
-0.1521832049,
0.7922562361,
0.3536834717,
-0.3806578219,
0.4568638802,
0.5807595849,
-0.4349933267,
-0.3323587775,
-0.4243378043,
0.368062228,
-0.5632449985,
-0.7997363806,
0.3924307525,
-0.143858552,
-0.3798760474,
0.0446586683,
0.0954576507,
-0.377338469,
0.7811467648,
0.0355491787,
0.0197922122,
-0.3329173625,
-0.039993424,
-0.4010841846,
0.0480127782,
0.2794501185,
0.2322200537,
0.6196412444,
-0.0839003772,
-0.4558546841,
-0.3983629048,
0.5119623542,
0.4737023115,
-0.3263085485,
0.6513481736,
0.433629483,
-0.4256087542,
-0.1941265613,
-0.4330841601,
-0.2670769393,
-0.5097883344,
0.2730848491,
-0.2204041928,
-1.3399310112,
0.9283124804,
0.0461835898,
-0.3934945762,
0.7356897593,
0.7432231307,
-0.2022797465,
1.1461082697,
0.8130688071,
-0.3539329469,
0.3513616621,
-0.0599274598,
0.1942583621,
-0.9733404517,
-0.3682802022,
-0.7872933745,
-0.1962837279,
-1.0070214272,
-0.0987418219,
0.674431622,
-0.317089498,
-0.297411561,
-0.0891825855,
-0.6467273831,
0.1839682907,
0.7229140997,
-0.0289481245,
0.0965287015,
-0.0980724543,
0.2729944587,
-0.1366064548,
-0.563871026,
-0.4163288176,
0.9423692822,
-0.029313257,
0.9697035551,
0.6320725679,
0.1158019453,
0.6036131382,
0.4596122205,
-1.0189623833,
0.4089316428,
-0.1654440612,
-1.1360882521,
-0.3769863546,
-0.5387866497,
-1.1066325903,
-0.042738758,
-0.0334078856,
-1.0210251808,
0.127034694,
-0.1338614225,
-0.522636354,
0.2345559746,
-0.540995717,
0.6593889594,
-0.3638123274,
-0.1953334063,
-0.0149269393,
-0.7218132615,
0.3330276012,
-0.085175924,
-0.1563753635,
-0.18553406,
-0.1120918617,
0.7246974111,
-0.0200314466,
1.0310746431,
-0.1792095155,
-0.0291143078,
0.4028903544,
0.2472353429,
0.2611507773,
0.1496643722,
-0.2447195947,
0.041957438,
-0.2701079547,
-0.3294938803,
-0.485555917,
0.7323902845,
-0.6455692053,
-1.0296076536,
-0.3962236941,
-0.5846031904,
-0.4640133083,
0.283160001,
0.3135259449,
-0.0756795183,
-0.3823917806,
0.2165515572,
0.9183575511,
-0.3339392543,
0.2026518881,
0.5576632619,
0.03022586,
0.0929068476,
0.5527152419,
0.0936503336,
0.0078081121,
0.3936237991,
-0.0144171678,
-0.346978128,
-0.6606011987,
-0.1350213885,
-0.1163806543,
-0.4205411375,
-0.4318901002,
-0.4471766055,
-0.4596667886,
-0.4164468348,
-0.0168751553,
-0.006478834,
-0.0545950904,
-0.7881449461,
0.0189602673,
0.3902621269,
0.4699141979,
0.4058096111,
0.4946534336,
-0.5253484845,
0.4325700104,
0.4906532168,
0.5583437681,
-0.0741740391,
-0.5632811189,
-0.0358483009,
-0.2056031376,
-0.4388624132,
-0.6968773603,
0.4605740607,
0.3833908141,
0.6961352825,
0.6060097814,
0.3480198085,
0.2560991645,
0.0872102529,
1.0175884962,
-0.0735452324,
-0.5826706886,
0.8833609223,
-0.4607197046,
0.0935049653,
0.5870098472,
0.790872395,
-0.6688694358,
-0.1592747569,
-0.3964440525,
-1.2304621935,
0.7795138955,
0.2605091333,
0.8465774655,
0.0156313702,
0.6014772654,
-0.0089701973,
0.1204210818,
-0.3486152291,
-0.3409388065,
0.2428487539,
0.1096779481,
0.1917376369,
-0.8170873523,
-0.288682133,
0.0833783671,
0.3016023934,
-0.1801205128,
0.3242402971,
0.0083122673,
-0.1681965142,
0.1848364919,
0.2829113007,
0.2229706049,
0.5809074044,
-0.2902201116,
-0.0164164882,
0.0331635177,
-0.3431736529,
-0.0694245473,
0.1469096243,
-0.3625491261,
-0.517555654,
0.3939563632,
0.5994610786,
0.0719699636,
-0.6928161383,
0.4953136146,
-0.299790442,
0.0016213126,
-0.4139898121,
0.2777295411,
-0.0044919872,
-0.0749751329,
0.4177880585,
-0.364465028,
0.6175993681,
-0.4342773259,
-0.0274840761,
0.634057045,
-0.3939815462,
-0.2873485982,
0.933899045,
0.4689623415,
-0.4971354008,
1.3087383509,
-0.0067196707,
-0.5305427909,
0.6735687256,
0.5476474166,
1.1905120611,
-0.425965786,
-0.0291460715,
0.0131807635,
0.2117447555,
0.5165930986,
0.396119982,
-0.2574385703,
-0.9112940431,
0.0476556867,
-0.5183246136,
-0.7312799096,
0.2133481503,
-1.1154630184,
-0.1837151796,
-0.4970983565,
-0.737593174,
0.2453287691,
-0.1024840847,
-0.758990705,
0.0388903618,
0.0379169099,
0.8343645334,
-0.6351546049,
0.0725957006,
0.7790268064,
-0.5985327363,
-0.1928212047,
0.0889898911,
-0.0160692837,
-1.1089274883,
0.6491609216,
-0.1343109906,
-0.0023398909,
-0.1321686655,
-0.6147049069,
-0.6904936433,
0.9407031536,
0.2617913783,
-0.2048899084,
0.1363087893,
0.4316628575,
0.7242268324,
-0.0869744644,
0.162850827,
0.6832801104,
0.1186114103,
-0.1533676386,
-0.8321240544,
-0.0218039583,
-0.340667665,
0.3414263129,
-0.0596525967,
-1.041277647,
0.5614358783,
0.0878628418,
-0.4493269622,
0.1885005832,
0.4672739804,
-0.101700753,
0.4821667075,
0.2288674265,
0.5515566468,
0.7374851108,
-0.0787035599,
1.2806948423,
-0.2177088857,
0.2796186209,
0.792838037,
-0.5347914696,
0.7326333523,
0.2603637576,
-0.5077206492,
0.0908149257,
0.7093284726,
-0.0027321819,
0.3165630996,
0.3503738344,
-0.8799207211,
-0.1743575335,
-0.6664492488,
-0.3771850467,
0.7257056832,
0.6673458815,
-0.3342288136,
-0.0502929389,
-0.1060533077,
-0.123096019,
0.2150495946,
-0.2030514479,
1.1980582476,
0.1359286159,
-0.3415276408,
0.3260999918,
0.1740777642,
0.8882009387,
-0.3280537426,
0.3500198722,
-0.6514014006,
-0.3476217985,
-0.2870750129,
-0.7929509878,
0.5475158095,
0.3359062672,
-0.3504756391,
-0.075570561,
0.7875567079,
0.4009690881,
-0.4774599969,
0.3471137583,
0.5669164062,
0.1021582261,
-0.28580603,
-0.7099508047,
-0.0126383724,
-0.2230341136,
-0.4140991569,
0.4105461836,
0.1994865239,
-0.324416399,
1.0134541988,
0.4087325335,
-0.1925171465,
0.0782399997,
0.3719140291,
0.901522398,
-0.8270166516,
-0.2552165091,
-0.6078075767,
0.144318074,
0.2044317275,
-0.3773435056,
0.4672244489,
0.6233956814,
0.7839778066,
0.1153532788,
1.0334625244,
-0.0108698094,
0.2323150039,
-0.3877902329,
0.9437484741,
-0.4537695944,
0.4073721766,
0.1713303179,
-0.8174444437,
-0.5387399197,
0.2586652935,
-0.2522553205,
0.2572289705,
-0.0789225549,
1.0707002878,
-0.0568523109,
-0.1506551057,
0.3705540299,
0.0959159955,
0.4093002677,
0.3489492834,
1.2610259056,
-0.0015666939,
0.3740112782,
-0.1651182622,
-0.0457217135,
-0.531000793,
-0.5535964966,
-0.4074563682,
-0.5698136687,
-0.2727591693,
0.0111914929,
0.0277399831,
0.2949794531,
0.6239619255,
-0.8791185617,
-0.0890397877,
0.0038458223,
0.2091648728,
0.2303492427,
-0.3109840453,
0.1736470163,
-0.4521181881,
-0.7128318548,
0.2967126667,
0.0659764484,
-0.0388830788,
-0.3744731843,
0.2843388319,
-0.016642509,
0.0734089613,
0.5530902743,
0.5068625212,
-0.5364776254,
-0.13964127,
0.1239314005,
-0.2187666446,
0.0265133865,
0.9490731955,
-0.5381341577,
0.6821289062,
0.203791514,
0.7470638752,
0.5632317066,
0.2505331635,
0.2290804833,
-0.8831914067,
0.0043570125,
0.7456924319,
0.0125687458,
0.4031170905,
-0.7870126963,
0.5594081283,
0.1424533278,
-0.5158489943,
-0.8526289463,
0.4527842999,
-0.9264711738,
-0.1424481273,
1.0768970251,
-0.0985682532,
0.2488591075,
0.0132091399,
0.0715845674,
0.0122672301,
-0.1681869775,
1.0732699633,
0.5023866296,
-0.4880665839,
0.1530794054,
-0.5030388832,
0.3080566525,
0.2600234449,
-0.6572410464,
0.0546705388,
0.4920266867,
0.0930450782,
0.0183043927,
0.666544199,
-0.1293438524,
0.1910238266,
-0.0732438117,
-0.095135659,
0.2539523542,
-0.0336740427,
-0.4096773565,
0.3590334356,
0.6633797288,
0.092940338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03887v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03887v3
|
SAAS: Solving Ability Amplification Strategy for Enhanced Mathematical Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-05T04:25:47 | 2024-04-24T15:17:17 |
Hyeonwoo Kim, Gyoungjin Gim, Yungi Kim, Jihoo Kim, Byungju Kim, Wonseok Lee, Chanjun Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study presents a novel learning approach designed to enhance both
mathematical reasoning and problem-solving abilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs). We focus on integrating the Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and the
Program-of-Thought (PoT) learning, hypothesizing that prioritizing the learning
of mathematical reasoning ability is helpful for the amplification of
problem-solving ability. Thus, the initial learning with CoT is essential for
solving challenging mathematical problems. To this end, we propose a sequential
learning approach, named SAAS (Solving Ability Amplification Strategy), which
strategically transitions from CoT learning to PoT learning. Our empirical
study, involving an extensive performance comparison using several benchmarks,
demonstrates that our SAAS achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. The
results underscore the effectiveness of our sequential learning approach,
marking a significant advancement in the field of mathematical reasoning in
LLMs.
|
[
-0.3897301257,
-0.8713014722,
0.7065437436,
0.6435959339,
-0.5090582371,
0.5049888492,
-0.1261574775,
-0.1933505982,
0.2428876907,
0.3963861167,
-0.5802856684,
-0.2307525277,
-0.6801689863,
0.2069661766,
-0.2854044139,
0.6675350666,
-0.0715542734,
0.4756425917,
-0.3901189268,
0.1717536747,
-0.5860338807,
-0.5531430244,
-0.9283584356,
-0.2552342713,
0.4160051942,
0.5534146428,
0.6090732813,
0.5996430516,
0.5532087088,
0.2803438306,
-0.1195682511,
0.3911376894,
-0.3779503107,
0.4794974029,
-0.3451395631,
-0.7479397058,
-0.257235378,
-0.5409755111,
0.7618954182,
0.6629995108,
-0.3906647861,
0.2029854059,
-0.2617323697,
0.8901847601,
-0.5865940452,
0.1550792009,
-0.7149189711,
-0.1308773905,
-0.0304023754,
-0.3194215,
-0.5558104515,
-0.3570410609,
0.2466793358,
-0.5394625068,
-0.0546084233,
-0.1606689095,
0.4133158326,
0.3965175152,
-0.0508004688,
-0.4992167056,
-0.8905853033,
0.8191921115,
-0.4261016846,
0.2498711795,
0.1794825941,
0.5491435528,
-0.1579321474,
-0.5981526375,
-0.4668090045,
-0.012110319,
0.3864262104,
-0.1820473969,
0.1034651846,
-0.2873334289,
0.3520569801,
0.3248502016,
-0.3616240025,
-0.08259435,
-0.568435967,
0.065939188,
1.0776555538,
0.0501842164,
0.188471511,
0.2769112587,
-0.4058648944,
-0.0599702001,
-0.8321562409,
0.0042753383,
-0.0488263331,
0.440828532,
0.1292401403,
0.4674600065,
0.1658098996,
0.4668040276,
-0.4146135747,
-0.2702473402,
0.3097516298,
-0.0546468161,
-0.2720333934,
0.1385588348,
0.3734847009,
-0.7965246439,
0.2334243059,
-0.0858365446,
-0.4000598192,
0.2858657539,
0.2911662459,
-0.4637589157,
-0.0024629284,
0.2105437219,
0.0009388014,
-0.1740166843,
-0.0869879648,
-0.7108020186,
-0.364574194,
-0.4927946329,
0.6581575871,
-0.3503437638,
-0.2644037604,
0.1569475234,
0.2238301188,
0.0069450401,
0.183148548,
-0.8537678123,
0.6230168939,
0.9514796734,
1.0157448053,
-0.1423836648,
-0.4039088488,
-0.8508445621,
0.0355009288,
-0.6339566112,
0.7445068359,
-0.5766426921,
-0.4242188632,
-0.0947506726,
-0.4895847142,
0.0722965226,
-0.5612115264,
0.4724827707,
-0.8568157554,
-0.3202818334,
-0.5081809163,
-0.5188002586,
-0.028659068,
-0.294747889,
-0.5321459174,
1.0556386709,
-0.0674646199,
-0.1253037006,
0.1016172767,
-0.9072862864,
-0.6656342149,
0.2860595584,
-0.3704798222,
-0.4473802149,
0.1919946223,
0.2898020148,
0.2285535485,
-0.375002861,
0.3026977181,
-0.0932667926,
-0.4793382883,
0.3518400788,
-0.1315510869,
0.6022763252,
0.4146202803,
-0.420806706,
0.4280929267,
-0.7000359893,
0.0297300946,
0.5821092725,
0.2364184707,
-0.2306933254,
0.0592095964,
-0.5631716251,
0.3888942003,
0.2917248905,
-0.1811160445,
0.313562274,
-0.5034886599,
0.5095658898,
1.0049427748,
0.1141083837,
0.4252363145,
-0.0923567936,
0.6459598541,
-0.0260912534,
0.2324743122,
-0.2014079839,
-0.6038039327,
-0.9666212797,
-0.3452919722,
0.3174845874,
0.4644080698,
-0.8264284134,
0.2760231495,
-0.0076400726,
-0.4963573515,
-0.4370696247,
0.4083940089,
0.5891922116,
0.1709301174,
0.4710094333,
-0.1973002702,
-0.6260184646,
-0.6754968166,
-0.1793222874,
0.1292774975,
0.1548423171,
0.3005728424,
0.5884618163,
-0.0339132622,
0.7084288001,
-0.8052225709,
-0.3944407701,
-0.3059170544,
0.1208962426,
0.0956562459,
0.1660437286,
0.2886324823,
-0.9827357531,
-0.3969511092,
-0.2242242247,
-0.6870253682,
-0.1173095554,
0.014471435,
-0.1999823898,
0.2060519308,
0.3046705723,
-0.3361877799,
0.4978558421,
0.2477907538,
-0.3017036319,
0.6468902826,
-0.2193193585,
-0.0976487845,
-0.8908631802,
-0.3104463518,
0.0619899072,
0.0710292235,
-0.4848516583,
0.2898896933,
-0.170748353,
-0.3748495877,
-0.3058413565,
0.1980345398,
-0.4322822988,
-0.6940891743,
-0.398827225,
0.3576896787,
-0.1991934925,
0.4991292357,
0.0320870839,
1.3395729065,
0.8615629077,
-0.8081911206,
0.3014557064,
0.1654833853,
-0.4405604005,
0.1457162201,
-0.6746323705,
0.2791445851,
-0.0101763625,
0.1553465575,
-1.0140297413,
0.0886982009,
-0.315970391,
-0.3887783289,
-0.1593901664,
0.1783451587,
-0.5167846084,
-0.3312998116,
0.1721746325,
0.5350398421,
0.4362467825,
-0.5682405829,
0.9337064028,
0.3322225213,
-0.660671711,
-0.5948243737,
-0.5686112642,
-0.034725897,
-0.0003293102,
-0.4837717712,
0.3166344762,
0.1217072606,
-0.2569785714,
-0.1405399293,
-0.1812966019,
0.0158603322,
0.0531408042,
-0.0402164832,
0.3966284096,
-0.1487763077,
0.5288472772,
0.2002006918,
-0.320237726,
0.1253294796,
-0.3293586969,
0.9771164656,
-0.4800181389,
-0.4184347689,
-0.2954348922,
0.4300677776,
0.7668232918,
-0.7861695886,
0.9630964994,
0.0393189415,
-0.4543167055,
-0.401351124,
-0.4292020798,
-0.1908780038,
-0.4806070328,
0.2654884458,
-0.7478776574,
-0.4814653993,
0.6893217564,
-0.3163005412,
0.1546284854,
0.2273637354,
0.517845571,
0.1088939458,
1.1505904198,
0.4442429543,
0.140067637,
0.4678452313,
-0.6728554964,
0.4410589039,
-0.6930824518,
-0.5474021435,
-0.5134037733,
-0.1773902476,
0.0567841865,
-0.5234841704,
0.3889075816,
0.227119714,
-0.5806748867,
0.1375990361,
-0.4065431654,
0.5647649765,
0.4073952734,
0.2328048348,
0.4807914197,
0.1134004742,
-0.3464514613,
0.041682139,
-0.7063552737,
-0.383700639,
1.1575630903,
0.2141355127,
0.4127423465,
0.4786714911,
0.754625082,
0.1807974875,
0.3212642372,
-0.8015152812,
0.7938086987,
-0.0949217156,
-0.230529055,
-0.6869925857,
-0.5966923237,
-0.8045623899,
0.3513803482,
-0.3401876688,
-0.6981515288,
0.0499374494,
-0.0329094157,
-0.2492329329,
0.2091807723,
-0.7260394692,
0.3816437721,
-0.6039402485,
-0.4972012937,
-0.64495188,
-0.3596972525,
0.2154307812,
-0.241155237,
0.3572278619,
0.3189508915,
-0.3699575067,
0.6508243084,
-0.5419103503,
0.4877159595,
-0.1567412764,
-0.2658187449,
0.4044511318,
0.0480184816,
0.7249491811,
-0.0300525185,
0.000171796,
-0.0310171694,
-0.2157531381,
-0.6437867284,
-1.1154661179,
0.7891137004,
-0.9360283017,
-0.854239285,
-0.6522693038,
-0.6079185605,
-0.4861064851,
0.2280135453,
-0.2195787579,
0.3801321983,
0.2635813951,
0.1442668438,
0.891921401,
0.081545487,
0.110887818,
0.5062907934,
-0.4972782135,
-0.7729021907,
1.051808238,
0.3372521996,
0.4668405354,
0.1837907583,
0.3573256433,
-0.5055276752,
-0.5775627494,
-0.2416484356,
0.3616011739,
-0.8069532514,
-0.0337075554,
-0.4099056125,
-0.4557105899,
-0.3954494298,
-0.191959694,
-0.445335567,
-0.3468859494,
-0.1226589456,
0.0062751449,
0.4189293981,
0.6231461763,
0.254481554,
0.1639080197,
-0.4775388539,
0.4510389566,
0.3769834936,
0.4683711529,
0.4194957018,
-0.4183327854,
-0.1578627974,
0.0694670677,
-0.3511998653,
-0.7664584517,
0.2261868715,
0.0152042452,
0.6232172251,
0.4015904367,
-0.136708051,
0.868471384,
-0.3465657234,
0.529966116,
0.2204193026,
-1.1218415499,
0.7562195063,
0.0201780051,
0.2709543407,
0.4374451041,
0.5080572963,
-0.0112179592,
0.0591271147,
-0.7381900549,
-0.7494410276,
0.3390451968,
0.3524189889,
-0.2771682441,
0.0652745292,
0.427518487,
0.0466734692,
0.2325244546,
-0.3319370449,
-0.2218413353,
0.1228542477,
0.0048029344,
-0.2828205824,
-0.1109821573,
-0.1399072558,
-0.4675768316,
1.0551594496,
-0.0941293165,
0.0962550268,
0.1021131203,
-0.0664745569,
-0.1358703524,
0.2097881287,
0.7040041089,
1.0511424541,
0.2728773654,
-0.2083375156,
0.2230309248,
-0.6124455929,
0.3140722513,
-0.1013119742,
-0.139185816,
-0.2959539294,
0.0745689422,
0.8375016451,
0.3528763652,
-0.9352914691,
0.372556299,
0.1960787624,
-0.2852837145,
-0.423108995,
0.1703225523,
0.0961118117,
0.3723401427,
0.9550579786,
0.1229069382,
0.0340217054,
-0.5783237815,
0.1928500086,
0.3101126552,
0.0350826792,
0.1757883877,
0.2367462665,
0.170327127,
-0.8006736636,
0.4018577933,
-0.0500628352,
-0.6585025787,
0.8197563291,
0.9551848769,
0.8048422933,
-0.3776936829,
0.2295692861,
0.1408586502,
0.1470312923,
-0.2569996715,
0.6192275882,
-0.4005858898,
-0.5400925279,
-0.7454028726,
-0.4963403642,
-0.4448204637,
0.1476016194,
-0.7952864766,
0.4246219099,
-0.7314409614,
-0.0787714198,
0.0867252052,
0.2982435226,
-0.3807139695,
0.1493028998,
-0.0994300693,
1.1208819151,
-0.9614281058,
0.6273813844,
0.6599783897,
-0.4943383038,
-0.9643437266,
-0.0830704346,
-0.2025905848,
-0.776886344,
0.57146281,
-0.1120947152,
-0.5977979302,
0.2316788137,
-0.3541516364,
-1.2353457212,
1.227320075,
0.4447034597,
-0.7745900154,
0.2053275257,
-0.0840889215,
0.6001915336,
-0.6534333825,
-0.1553174257,
0.5802156925,
0.0014609081,
0.6598016024,
-0.6495406032,
-0.1220005974,
-0.2151407152,
0.1270129383,
0.4308984876,
-0.7226768136,
0.5629051328,
-0.6687002778,
-0.2526079118,
0.2781970501,
0.9803242087,
0.9237080812,
0.5630051494,
0.5597785115,
0.5878813267,
1.0285389423,
-0.0592251047,
0.6936807036,
-0.0410908051,
0.2259784192,
1.1004360914,
-0.4607846141,
1.2682480812,
0.6055383682,
-0.4602476656,
1.0440844297,
0.475033313,
0.2174617201,
0.6424261928,
0.46400401,
-0.5235459208,
-0.4174848497,
0.2115543187,
-0.657051146,
0.3744030893,
0.8116796613,
-0.4375838637,
0.1108324826,
0.2693651915,
-0.3877747357,
0.4316094816,
-0.5710789561,
0.7374373674,
0.1483008265,
-0.7840170264,
0.5918516517,
-0.2715543211,
0.1593871117,
-0.7564889789,
-0.2015109956,
0.1102647185,
0.2472450733,
-0.1682757884,
-0.6713790298,
0.1888670325,
-0.0448622443,
-0.0682607964,
0.1318290979,
0.5127387643,
-0.2297277153,
-0.7697927952,
0.1275075823,
0.4062761366,
0.2119780481,
0.2626867592,
-0.6518612504,
0.2420154959,
-0.4210003614,
0.158253774,
0.2986600995,
0.2344401777,
-0.2353094965,
1.2566225529,
0.9899971485,
0.2833076417,
-0.0699714348,
0.4625003338,
1.0395234823,
-0.4359842837,
-1.0041735172,
-0.7454390526,
0.193564862,
-0.2195264995,
-0.1749497205,
0.6046597958,
0.6060938835,
0.587906599,
0.0405064188,
0.7324192524,
0.3883348703,
0.3388379812,
-0.5472006798,
0.2440125644,
-0.307510674,
0.761501193,
-0.4479819834,
-1.0809454918,
-0.3773750663,
0.6988042593,
-0.8110125065,
0.0627417341,
0.8019739985,
0.516889751,
0.2795195282,
0.5592947006,
0.1297271103,
0.2309127897,
0.2527337074,
0.7231166363,
0.6962341666,
-0.3012125492,
0.4487914443,
-0.1602814943,
-0.7582252622,
-0.0389728993,
-0.6898089647,
-0.7042931318,
-0.6003863811,
-0.1500870734,
-0.423206389,
0.2051407844,
1.0499101877,
0.4066313207,
-0.8274804354,
-0.1932002455,
-0.580697,
0.1092065424,
-0.7897033691,
-0.2002444714,
0.4670126736,
-0.5789088607,
-0.3838341832,
0.3939411938,
0.4467015564,
-0.1566611826,
-0.8571692705,
-0.2424937636,
-0.4631380439,
0.4705489576,
0.775167644,
0.3996019363,
-0.7862338424,
0.2904982269,
0.1385599077,
0.1876281053,
-0.1396344602,
1.149790287,
-0.9560809135,
0.5357673168,
0.3440721631,
0.9369357824,
0.7458990812,
-0.0233457517,
0.5428441763,
-0.4052703083,
0.2224083841,
0.3457843959,
0.4388028383,
0.0699198544,
-0.4517624378,
0.4411828518,
0.1889002472,
-0.4640128613,
-1.0178694725,
0.4920191467,
-0.7707130909,
-0.2379692495,
1.0214403868,
-0.0748902708,
-0.1360871643,
-0.1331508011,
-0.2188962847,
0.0682887211,
-0.3208800554,
1.0495817661,
0.637989521,
-0.256195277,
-0.1938807517,
-0.1246035844,
0.2520295382,
0.6840801239,
-0.8199141622,
-0.1090249792,
0.1866912991,
0.0523832478,
0.4572568834,
0.4113605618,
-0.3479771912,
0.5742548704,
-0.0248568002,
-0.4842443764,
-0.2462061048,
-0.9702777267,
-0.3260199428,
0.2264471501,
0.0271897074,
-0.1166912392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03881v1
|
A Bi-consolidating Model for Joint Relational Triple Extraction
| 2024-04-05T04:04:23 | 2024-04-05T04:04:23 |
Xiaocheng Luo, Yanping Chen, Ruixue Tang, Ruizhang Huang, Yongbin Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current methods to extract relational triples directly make a prediction
based on a possible entity pair in a raw sentence without depending on entity
recognition. The task suffers from a serious semantic overlapping problem, in
which several relation triples may share one or two entities in a sentence. It
is weak to learn discriminative semantic features relevant to a relation
triple. In this paper, based on a two-dimensional sentence representation, a
bi-consolidating model is proposed to address this problem by simultaneously
reinforcing the local and global semantic features relevant to a relation
triple. This model consists of a local consolidation component and a global
consolidation component. The first component uses a pixel difference
convolution to enhance semantic information of a possible triple representation
from adjacent regions and mitigate noise in neighbouring neighbours. The second
component strengthens the triple representation based a channel attention and a
spatial attention, which has the advantage to learn remote semantic
dependencies in a sentence. They are helpful to improve the performance of both
entity identification and relation type classification in relation triple
extraction. After evaluated on several publish datasets, it achieves
competitive performance. Analytical experiments demonstrate the effectiveness
of our model for relational triple extraction and give motivation for other
natural language processing tasks.
|
[
-0.4362536073,
-0.9722915292,
0.4635947347,
0.4187463224,
-0.3251202404,
0.1545019597,
-0.0581045337,
-1.1139291525,
-0.0307417791,
0.579895854,
-0.1809952408,
-0.2390983254,
-0.6380373836,
0.2365016043,
0.144574061,
0.7557405829,
-0.1541874558,
0.040600311,
-0.2787887156,
0.0397494473,
-0.8583828807,
-0.047611177,
-0.3018092513,
-0.2063022256,
0.191845715,
0.562256813,
0.8203793168,
0.3007069826,
0.7073773742,
0.2624305785,
0.1012864411,
0.447578311,
-0.3335350752,
0.1749560535,
-0.3384434581,
-0.3357307315,
-0.4493851364,
0.1922069639,
0.8415743113,
0.991912961,
0.1544424146,
0.0236916039,
-0.0643198416,
0.5226777196,
-0.5702423453,
0.6241144538,
-0.5368354917,
-0.2703493536,
-0.1736998558,
0.0501373149,
-0.0837973654,
-0.4748646617,
0.4091274142,
-0.3961555362,
0.2800555527,
-0.0186857153,
1.054610014,
-0.0489849634,
-0.7318962216,
-0.0428946465,
-0.933521688,
0.2632878125,
-0.1988920867,
0.2807616591,
0.2506431937,
0.2016652972,
-0.084493123,
-0.2589102685,
-0.6351379156,
0.0849565715,
-0.4559459388,
0.0379425511,
-0.2030984759,
-0.160099104,
-0.0032387604,
0.6116190553,
-0.2532735467,
-0.1384831965,
-0.5716336966,
0.178541705,
0.4424998462,
0.0794791877,
0.6148958802,
-0.3905666471,
-0.6484648585,
0.418266803,
-0.654179275,
0.0221165679,
-0.013390041,
0.4656313062,
-0.2247873247,
0.7735735178,
-0.1586901993,
0.5290190578,
0.0263937023,
0.0808083564,
0.4331667423,
-0.6632078886,
-0.1298055649,
-0.1299040765,
0.8591831923,
0.4558474123,
0.1785700023,
-0.4667215347,
0.1026007906,
0.2451338917,
0.105165571,
-0.5872090459,
-0.3596970737,
0.2014959455,
-0.4427141547,
0.000531884,
0.1868791133,
-0.9207320809,
-0.1067113727,
-0.4715244174,
0.2927955389,
-0.6326303482,
-0.6359833479,
0.2745724022,
-0.0054892171,
-0.1130233705,
-0.2115170956,
-1.0280711651,
0.5661411881,
0.6497351527,
0.8214351535,
0.0061770738,
-0.2203129828,
-0.7240306139,
0.5622238517,
0.0588690676,
0.7995728254,
-0.5451923609,
-0.1990540326,
-0.1017682776,
-0.0338391252,
0.1270138919,
-0.4857096374,
0.0909321234,
-0.7258028388,
0.4727273583,
-0.0172916576,
-0.3704344928,
-0.3996917009,
0.180951044,
-1.1303764582,
0.9191210866,
0.3227688372,
-0.8829479218,
0.4344248176,
-0.4867508411,
-0.2985688448,
0.4315800965,
-0.1787641197,
-0.790541172,
-0.0424051061,
0.4363322258,
0.4170852304,
-0.4967953563,
0.1532694697,
-0.5849652886,
-0.278545022,
-0.2533844709,
0.2527787089,
0.964735508,
-0.296549052,
-0.0802635029,
-0.439396441,
-0.8320210576,
-0.1791160852,
0.1583521217,
-0.3720243871,
-0.5880143642,
-0.3166560829,
-0.3070409894,
0.3035462201,
0.2275884151,
-0.7017280459,
0.4094963968,
-0.7997164726,
-0.1688064486,
-0.0699498355,
0.7540456057,
0.7728279829,
0.0187694971,
0.213717103,
0.1898457706,
-0.059150409,
0.2766222954,
-0.4396219552,
-0.4397371709,
-0.3789024651,
0.3989021778,
0.5410565138,
-0.9616968632,
0.4783037901,
-0.7192545533,
-0.1733233035,
-0.3845698833,
0.2445095032,
0.5339177847,
0.156943053,
0.4455112815,
0.0606253259,
-0.787383914,
-1.016884923,
-0.2248192281,
0.1073691025,
0.0748710334,
-0.2562206089,
0.3913242817,
0.0157846324,
1.0885441303,
-0.3664155006,
-0.3417273462,
-0.4330090284,
0.3047784865,
0.1765337586,
0.2889102697,
0.3527209461,
-1.1053481102,
-0.6212413907,
0.1582212001,
-0.7854922414,
0.2170268595,
0.1914768815,
-0.2572132349,
0.1708814651,
0.1030240282,
-1.0123347044,
0.5383754373,
0.108268261,
-0.239320308,
0.1925712377,
-0.1714203805,
-0.2774372101,
-1.0307215452,
-0.0274612084,
-0.0497391485,
-0.2553573549,
-0.5861573815,
-0.0095873112,
0.2412484139,
0.0680503994,
-0.0369548053,
0.1253131181,
-0.9188913703,
-0.3043154478,
-0.0788451731,
0.5944096446,
0.2436506003,
0.6735850573,
0.0797541812,
0.2519207001,
0.410304755,
-0.6257117987,
0.5379261374,
0.4555841088,
-0.3592211306,
0.504637301,
-0.3048789501,
0.0073831277,
-0.161473006,
0.1921463311,
-0.7553107142,
-0.096014671,
0.5171695948,
-0.3017295599,
0.3447707295,
0.0297579225,
-0.7321688533,
-0.4008779228,
-0.1368629634,
0.301538527,
-0.2426653057,
-0.7055797577,
0.7594717145,
0.6234924197,
-0.245273605,
-0.345674783,
-0.5821713805,
-0.0606063604,
-0.1128501594,
-0.8199058175,
0.6509003639,
0.4780550897,
-0.2388570756,
0.447113663,
-0.0419666693,
0.1339470148,
-0.1632814854,
0.140367344,
0.7645850182,
-0.0634791404,
0.3503255546,
-0.3955456913,
-0.3048192263,
0.0460821576,
-0.059221819,
0.3338013291,
-0.2854814231,
0.3945222795,
-0.4667031169,
0.8235734701,
0.4388526976,
-0.4244014025,
0.8122580051,
0.5154816508,
-0.6463473439,
0.2227057368,
-0.5228685737,
0.3023456037,
-0.3250068128,
0.3122724295,
-0.5899435878,
-0.6129699349,
0.2916805446,
-0.108130917,
-0.1475813091,
0.3320172727,
0.428881824,
0.1356944144,
0.8868399858,
0.6766588688,
0.118736133,
0.1187920645,
-0.5625717044,
0.5913528204,
-0.8573590517,
-0.6904590726,
-0.3011853397,
-0.1559947729,
-0.5265027285,
-0.1642300785,
0.2590686977,
0.5524466038,
-0.1714624465,
0.4839539528,
-0.2673184276,
0.5157295465,
0.4202629328,
0.3811786473,
0.3313694894,
0.2709719241,
-0.1561950594,
0.0526935346,
-0.3017945886,
-0.2570243776,
0.5636854172,
0.2265372872,
-0.0975050777,
0.7625478506,
0.6297084093,
-0.1681247503,
0.0443468988,
-0.4495814145,
0.3447081447,
-0.0246372614,
-0.5743766427,
-0.1083779633,
-0.5743899941,
-0.9877340198,
0.4333817065,
-0.6091168523,
-1.0265365839,
0.5015533566,
-0.4348148406,
-0.6480754614,
0.2375800312,
-0.8594200015,
0.7334315777,
-0.1058778688,
-0.6652987599,
0.0243999176,
-0.7897456288,
0.673725903,
0.1669288427,
0.2542800605,
-0.1759742498,
-0.0984243751,
0.3007076085,
-0.2934074402,
0.5141658187,
-0.2483805418,
0.1340019256,
0.0355914943,
0.2714316249,
0.5343645215,
0.2647920251,
0.1279063076,
-0.0083564194,
-0.0636208802,
-0.3729602396,
-0.7862884402,
0.3725688457,
-0.7719786763,
-0.4099216163,
-0.1827322692,
-0.5342471004,
-0.5983439684,
0.3824654818,
-0.0366943218,
0.4465822577,
-0.0467607044,
0.1283459961,
0.0617002323,
0.1715648025,
0.5282050967,
0.2471909076,
-0.5398144126,
-0.6951974034,
0.7294520736,
-0.2292990834,
0.2399641722,
0.5279233456,
-0.0844025537,
-0.2887692451,
-0.2034291923,
-0.0187767446,
0.5650277138,
-0.3819923997,
-0.502743423,
-0.8566721678,
-0.1526218951,
-0.5363062024,
0.3055050075,
-0.0488221385,
-0.375000447,
-0.1619470119,
-0.195186168,
0.1998141557,
0.9317879677,
-0.2854075134,
0.1465533078,
-0.9988390803,
0.8071845174,
0.327935487,
0.4761871099,
-0.1552432179,
0.2025906295,
-0.2630491853,
-0.116139546,
-0.2193319052,
-0.8572235703,
0.3724597394,
-0.1536189616,
0.3742055595,
0.0856176987,
-0.2394757867,
0.7385793328,
-0.1025160253,
0.5356129408,
0.49793455,
-0.7585856318,
0.4023202658,
-0.3224607408,
0.1059337482,
0.5942775011,
0.4008009434,
-0.1146922708,
-0.2630865276,
-0.6565945745,
-0.6966660619,
0.9625783563,
0.4533714056,
-0.3465902209,
-0.1107808799,
0.4580029249,
-0.0445115231,
-0.2435073555,
-0.9328072667,
-0.0675335154,
0.2251634151,
0.0914593264,
0.3655369878,
-0.6433703303,
0.1102856994,
-0.1692034602,
0.6019408107,
0.4758437574,
0.1361961514,
0.0637451485,
0.0091683473,
-0.0650529638,
-0.0444790795,
-0.1207801923,
0.4091666341,
-0.4881002307,
0.2798580229,
-0.0525974967,
-0.1972577274,
-0.0916544572,
0.392278403,
0.1351705492,
0.0828676,
0.5103271008,
0.5289188623,
0.4187202752,
0.1130350903,
0.7723680735,
-0.1168015227,
-0.1787172854,
-0.1692750901,
-0.2946016788,
0.3237074018,
0.3559219539,
-0.0404275469,
0.4319483042,
0.3145982027,
-0.7448987961,
0.2782136798,
0.3664852083,
-0.1330487281,
0.1189867631,
0.1902202368,
0.293568939,
-0.3845685422,
0.8731303215,
-0.3796941042,
-0.6927688122,
0.3771678805,
0.5320449471,
0.4974086881,
-0.0968940482,
0.0440900736,
0.5719596148,
0.0437501892,
0.0122669432,
0.3063598275,
-0.2861588895,
-0.8775663972,
-0.3224518895,
-0.2104320824,
0.0938001275,
-0.1930015534,
-0.7498582006,
0.6556987166,
-0.0760896578,
0.0858708993,
0.1386389881,
0.4992376864,
-0.6838769913,
-0.0320670642,
0.3611661196,
0.3884732425,
-0.5897171497,
0.8196952939,
0.2044912428,
-0.8065627813,
-0.8212879896,
-0.1037404165,
-0.1449290663,
-0.2568933666,
0.7059089541,
0.4187527597,
-0.2891424,
-0.4216131568,
-0.1765435189,
-0.985648036,
0.9865532517,
0.2250830382,
-0.3937312663,
-0.3314560652,
0.2446991354,
0.2902065516,
-0.8087511063,
0.1331768185,
0.8446186185,
0.2907547951,
0.1557637304,
-0.6616737843,
0.1348663718,
-0.4098413289,
0.3364711106,
0.3773315251,
-0.3228318095,
0.6680676937,
-0.1537475437,
-0.6988608837,
0.0449907556,
0.5344291925,
0.3979196846,
0.0333351307,
0.6013518572,
0.393612802,
0.7120394707,
0.0600926653,
0.9364621043,
-0.0182770602,
0.4465401769,
1.6697809696,
-0.3837285936,
0.8478073478,
0.2921040952,
-0.0635886192,
0.7970788479,
0.3538953066,
-0.093367897,
0.5599526763,
-0.1286788732,
-0.3415063024,
-0.3187722266,
0.0617257021,
-0.2061100155,
0.7427415848,
0.6678628325,
-0.1701934636,
-0.4738014638,
-0.0746526867,
-0.0850169808,
0.2402534187,
-0.059084665,
0.7587276697,
-0.1849475205,
-0.7460027933,
0.2802605033,
-0.2327460498,
0.1684311777,
-0.0701929778,
-0.3471528888,
0.0170338564,
0.2674113214,
-0.2511796653,
-0.5905259848,
0.4840455651,
-0.3826369345,
-0.5164165497,
-0.0649215356,
0.4823101461,
-0.7412290573,
-0.6161703467,
0.7247920632,
0.2354791313,
-0.0672978461,
-0.0915772393,
-0.4083446264,
-0.0602609925,
0.0250436943,
0.1864210665,
-0.3102598488,
0.8653919697,
0.1418088973,
0.1973643899,
0.3516055644,
0.2801573873,
-0.0835617408,
0.1288972646,
0.7707059979,
-0.5916929841,
-0.4021094739,
-0.7985920906,
0.5164403319,
-0.6977624893,
0.0533224307,
0.4954096079,
0.7613233924,
0.5127179623,
0.2930311859,
0.5052444935,
-0.0724008009,
0.8904674053,
-0.5655300617,
0.1686056107,
-0.3712173402,
0.5508272052,
-0.1180116758,
-0.9661312699,
-0.8763887286,
0.132479012,
-0.5081636906,
-0.0596243553,
0.9537318349,
0.5645950437,
-0.1159995049,
0.4147323668,
-0.0394321419,
0.2193054259,
0.2979109287,
0.7702167034,
0.7758603692,
-0.5768455863,
0.8342633843,
-0.5446588397,
-0.2109505832,
-0.0769297928,
-0.575489223,
-0.7521318197,
-0.5770148635,
-0.250520885,
-0.3398060501,
-0.2817868888,
0.7058287859,
0.4591634274,
-0.4365367889,
0.2208515406,
-0.3421068192,
0.0927951932,
-0.2036505342,
-0.2469745278,
0.6148615479,
-0.3914683461,
-0.6191871166,
0.0887914523,
0.5924880505,
-0.1379494518,
0.0074475673,
0.4014539719,
-0.8915621638,
-0.5337426066,
0.5112886429,
-0.026331488,
-0.6863586307,
-0.4721378088,
-0.3715659976,
-0.1684629321,
0.1424182355,
0.8041923642,
-0.8135747313,
0.605497539,
0.3975681067,
0.3633159697,
0.6407502294,
0.111031197,
0.7704650164,
-0.7106693983,
0.0626768395,
-0.0107308123,
0.5300337076,
0.5335682631,
-0.6409391761,
0.6510061622,
0.2024600208,
-0.3986592591,
-0.1926855147,
0.1202309728,
-1.0458712578,
-0.2838574648,
1.0810595751,
-0.0302986763,
-0.176877439,
-0.6275174618,
-0.1259932667,
0.5292075872,
-0.068308562,
0.6827540994,
0.6827769876,
-0.1935625821,
-0.2674594223,
-0.2376227975,
0.2361885309,
0.0150643205,
-0.6515880227,
0.3251230121,
0.5337150693,
0.1813089103,
0.5222049356,
0.3656699955,
-0.4465830326,
0.4214181304,
0.009089523,
0.3400004208,
0.0691266283,
-0.4126771092,
-0.2412156165,
0.4593307674,
-0.3987232745,
-0.5046908855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03868v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03868v1
|
Extract, Define, Canonicalize: An LLM-based Framework for Knowledge Graph Construction
| 2024-04-05T02:53:51 | 2024-04-05T02:53:51 |
Bowen Zhang, Harold Soh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this work, we are interested in automated methods for knowledge graph
creation (KGC) from input text. Progress on large language models (LLMs) has
prompted a series of recent works applying them to KGC, e.g., via zero/few-shot
prompting. Despite successes on small domain-specific datasets, these models
face difficulties scaling up to text common in many real-world applications. A
principal issue is that in prior methods, the KG schema has to be included in
the LLM prompt to generate valid triplets; larger and more complex schema
easily exceed the LLMs' context window length. To address this problem, we
propose a three-phase framework named Extract-Define-Canonicalize (EDC): open
information extraction followed by schema definition and post-hoc
canonicalization. EDC is flexible in that it can be applied to settings where a
pre-defined target schema is available and when it is not; in the latter case,
it constructs a schema automatically and applies self-canonicalization. To
further improve performance, we introduce a trained component that retrieves
schema elements relevant to the input text; this improves the LLMs' extraction
performance in a retrieval-augmented generation-like manner. We demonstrate on
three KGC benchmarks that EDC is able to extract high-quality triplets without
any parameter tuning and with significantly larger schemas compared to prior
works.
|
[
-0.3107142746,
-0.7211225033,
0.7139573693,
0.0260587633,
-0.1922816336,
-0.0030182139,
-0.2808642983,
-0.3037341237,
0.2766104639,
0.6147408485,
-0.1782372892,
-0.9357104897,
-0.5922909975,
0.3738777637,
-0.2583356798,
0.9685585499,
-0.4344443083,
-0.2662411034,
-0.2977255583,
0.1259486526,
-0.1196711361,
-0.1661749333,
-0.4176383615,
-0.1838396192,
0.6369039416,
0.6265597343,
0.3308490217,
1.0977236032,
0.3387327492,
0.1631189734,
0.1213013902,
0.5411047339,
-0.4038560092,
0.4087651372,
-0.0820887908,
-0.2182104737,
-0.7219444513,
0.091216892,
0.9835848212,
0.8535367846,
0.0340238251,
0.2018978596,
0.2783323228,
0.671066761,
-0.6185399294,
0.8566166162,
-0.6582379937,
-0.2545030415,
-0.1400207877,
-0.2926092446,
-0.4692372084,
-0.5829766393,
0.0313113742,
-1.0841300488,
0.1092368737,
-0.0573391952,
0.8847227097,
-0.0891169608,
-0.6129596233,
-0.4038204551,
-0.7889299989,
0.333120048,
-0.5185362697,
0.4931644201,
0.3907984495,
0.2306985706,
-0.2188542038,
-0.983799696,
-0.5464535356,
0.0181333832,
-0.2072576433,
0.0777217373,
0.1212993637,
0.1653218865,
0.1231936067,
0.2169075012,
-0.2994075119,
-0.0074838516,
-0.5913880467,
-0.0609826744,
0.4115045667,
0.1268912852,
0.0415853038,
-0.5851371288,
-0.2630745769,
0.1746498644,
-1.1498780251,
-0.3093594313,
0.3938720822,
0.5552657843,
0.3212798536,
0.7421505451,
-0.5325344205,
0.7380489111,
0.1341560632,
-0.3478507698,
0.0647968873,
-0.4560151994,
-0.1266796738,
-0.0827790871,
0.8052236438,
0.2024737448,
0.0581232011,
-0.5315476656,
0.0367819332,
-0.3651095331,
0.3040658832,
-0.7300546169,
-0.3408398628,
0.141498521,
-0.3067233562,
-0.5892795324,
0.0888212249,
-0.6090384126,
-0.2022318393,
-0.600685358,
0.2307059467,
-0.5173163414,
-0.1817287058,
-0.2150242925,
0.0597873703,
0.1185716912,
0.2391214222,
-0.9519148469,
0.3421152234,
0.7023735642,
0.6305574775,
-0.5496351719,
-0.1795060635,
-0.3853318393,
0.7646745443,
-0.5315824151,
0.693503499,
-0.2547886372,
-0.2606361806,
0.0876412764,
0.1055761054,
-0.0695152879,
-0.4561435282,
0.2772607803,
-0.8520139456,
0.075181216,
-0.2963441908,
-0.5919682384,
-0.1263556927,
0.2618474364,
-0.5704740286,
1.3409126997,
0.3474340141,
-0.7197002769,
0.5639317036,
-0.762013495,
-0.6418207288,
0.3956911266,
-0.4090960026,
0.0888137445,
-0.3787768781,
0.2257354707,
0.7207564116,
-0.3727258146,
0.4995542467,
-0.2820322216,
0.2145752013,
-0.4012209177,
0.1228516847,
0.5625445247,
0.2127053291,
-0.2650289834,
-0.0644059479,
-1.027274847,
0.1442782879,
0.1485920846,
-0.725464046,
-0.3745501637,
0.0731803924,
-0.6620603204,
0.0904616117,
0.4139666557,
-0.5949561596,
0.4532637596,
-0.5118389726,
0.3632538319,
0.8171824813,
0.0374666862,
0.7388205528,
0.1305560768,
0.4515478313,
-0.0941378176,
-0.122776404,
-0.036418926,
-0.2043351382,
-0.9965023994,
-0.5350356102,
0.4215062261,
0.3976037502,
-1.1890386343,
0.7255030274,
-0.823838532,
-0.427733779,
-0.1642845422,
0.3189378679,
0.1348167956,
0.7020203471,
0.1934297234,
0.1038065255,
-0.5087869167,
-1.1184287071,
0.0387616083,
-0.2726028562,
-0.041889675,
0.3146508634,
0.4542835951,
0.1987225264,
1.408816576,
-0.8592313528,
-0.2179490328,
-0.2854480743,
0.2314245701,
-0.0536981151,
0.2714393735,
0.163125664,
-0.3590457439,
-0.5020788908,
0.311714977,
-1.2087287903,
-0.2439334542,
0.3407740295,
-0.4208579659,
0.0646796823,
0.6730825305,
-0.5309355855,
0.2677460313,
0.1796925664,
0.0364000387,
0.4657096267,
-0.0242670365,
0.090046756,
-1.3775494099,
0.1487387866,
-0.3073539436,
-0.2156604379,
-0.6281763315,
0.2612167299,
0.3589502275,
0.1387580186,
-0.3159021735,
0.3233111799,
-0.4367639422,
-0.1207505018,
0.0024388663,
0.5690040588,
0.1517527103,
0.4561470747,
-0.0478490666,
0.4598941803,
0.2916788757,
-0.7446992993,
0.3747301698,
0.0988044515,
-0.0123318695,
0.6039186716,
-0.4255028367,
0.2214614898,
-0.0278376453,
0.5155341625,
-0.6820869446,
-0.4981006682,
0.5448601246,
-0.1060672253,
0.3652774096,
-0.2111971974,
-1.0194665194,
-0.5962802172,
-0.1131825447,
0.2697255909,
0.1361204386,
-0.8052927852,
0.8426974416,
0.2838381827,
-0.3586345017,
-0.2468540817,
-0.2082027048,
-0.0251119435,
-0.0120804412,
-0.9549761415,
0.369219929,
0.035065718,
0.0792021379,
-0.0582406558,
0.0418626368,
0.0123024806,
0.0634788424,
0.3505282104,
0.2329594791,
-0.2005154938,
0.3651083112,
0.5042717457,
-0.0877991095,
0.0099639725,
-0.8532193303,
0.3613830209,
-0.0001727735,
-0.2504725158,
-0.3126467466,
0.1177759841,
0.4303371906,
0.0084630279,
0.5063673258,
0.2216327786,
-0.4314825237,
-0.1511846036,
-0.5232039094,
-0.0076468578,
-0.4818507433,
0.1375090629,
-0.3953412175,
-0.7915676832,
0.2777379751,
-0.2782038152,
0.2085235119,
0.6107848287,
0.4046874642,
0.0308622848,
0.7148286104,
0.420573622,
0.2474853247,
0.0511746332,
-0.1018650606,
0.1382998079,
-0.779602468,
-0.2362315059,
-0.3873542249,
0.1127508581,
-0.3118669093,
-0.2479456961,
0.4283592999,
0.3673963845,
-0.0635388345,
0.5031205416,
-0.4625496268,
0.4996319115,
0.4786579609,
-0.0459995195,
0.5500659943,
0.1759099215,
-0.3989938498,
0.1600012034,
-0.5893985629,
-0.713309586,
1.4984964132,
0.2334348857,
0.2656129897,
0.1415388733,
1.0408498049,
0.0028185127,
0.4966109693,
-0.7056692243,
0.7013061047,
0.0423938558,
-0.5293824077,
-0.3193923533,
-0.538951695,
-0.9038966894,
0.2218663394,
-0.0659987926,
-0.7150181532,
-0.0979857221,
0.1330805272,
-0.3395059407,
0.3913583159,
-0.5367996693,
0.2628169954,
0.162950173,
-0.296222955,
0.2698192298,
-0.5663666725,
0.3477351665,
-0.3513281941,
0.4016867578,
-0.0475917161,
-0.0342462063,
1.007535696,
-0.3140102029,
0.8077840805,
-0.1308203787,
-0.4129975438,
0.4068190157,
0.3863809407,
0.8270229101,
0.0157980435,
0.1111713797,
0.1489104182,
0.0154165449,
-0.2554295957,
-0.7199115157,
0.6921614408,
-0.6508815289,
-0.5478487015,
0.1084176227,
-0.6359943748,
-0.3075049818,
0.6043784618,
0.0819887146,
0.4108890295,
-0.1766386479,
0.2022511214,
0.4377919734,
0.084059909,
0.3320291936,
0.6541671157,
-0.4165431857,
-0.7528348565,
0.992207408,
0.3314285874,
0.5117202401,
0.2733254731,
0.1996739358,
0.004214236,
-0.5455250144,
-0.4889911711,
0.1946281195,
-0.8864563107,
-0.4184727371,
-0.8260822892,
-0.2631466985,
-0.9177621007,
-0.0709879473,
-0.3540798128,
-0.7585991025,
-0.4267359674,
-0.3547330201,
0.310921222,
1.212880373,
-0.2852894366,
0.3806325197,
-0.7144132257,
0.2941984236,
0.3293509781,
0.2688816488,
-0.1718124449,
-0.214701429,
-0.2273102254,
-0.2076378167,
-0.4089300632,
-0.6635462046,
0.1660273373,
-0.033393003,
0.4665209353,
0.432300359,
-0.0246032439,
0.4120841622,
-0.5259535313,
0.890622437,
0.1662680507,
-0.5797301531,
0.5660117865,
-0.7084185481,
-0.0332193524,
0.5041568875,
0.3984341025,
-0.2248093188,
-0.3035334647,
-0.6695397496,
-0.9098622799,
0.9167920351,
0.3982383907,
-0.2474542707,
-0.2475677431,
0.54534477,
0.3724900186,
0.1757822037,
-0.8036192656,
-0.4824679494,
0.1363939643,
-0.381604284,
0.3238192797,
-0.4094378948,
-0.5406155586,
-0.1379712075,
0.7296096087,
-0.3261713088,
0.0447539389,
0.0558091551,
-0.1700987816,
-0.0686218143,
0.0587166771,
0.2179160118,
0.595487535,
-0.116938889,
0.4058429301,
-0.0216151327,
-0.432225734,
-0.1199732721,
0.4007548392,
-0.5021437407,
-0.3710701168,
0.4701623321,
0.2952488065,
0.3405164778,
-0.0770364255,
0.4953688085,
0.2273678184,
-0.6036063433,
-0.0673206821,
-0.1857934594,
0.067826286,
0.1127106473,
0.4093519747,
-0.3103057742,
-0.1358380467,
0.0164237078,
0.2591256201,
0.2340238243,
-0.2052508593,
-0.2312387824,
0.3762908876,
0.3873110116,
0.0037536526,
0.5089514256,
-0.5054961443,
-0.4055430889,
0.3059724569,
0.5220913887,
0.6067990065,
0.069003731,
0.3329096437,
0.4512528479,
0.3441153765,
0.1733602285,
-0.0130646518,
-0.3061389029,
-0.7942971587,
-0.1628177464,
-0.561483562,
0.1924687326,
-0.1604939401,
-0.6190769672,
0.3759931624,
-0.4886401892,
0.1030448973,
-0.0215959363,
-0.113932319,
-0.6386989355,
-0.2055996656,
0.0059400159,
0.6947751641,
-0.7286816239,
0.8550419211,
0.2795889378,
-0.5062256455,
-1.1252481937,
-0.3128457963,
-0.0047278283,
-0.8119125962,
0.956163466,
-0.1031186879,
0.0819986388,
0.2846806049,
-0.6481327415,
-1.2216875553,
1.6197156906,
0.2138566077,
-0.154247582,
-0.3407712877,
0.2796789408,
0.2736096978,
-0.6759653687,
-0.0826349258,
0.7757829428,
0.5595852733,
0.2085018009,
-0.8079187274,
0.2266996354,
0.1551932991,
-0.2184101194,
0.1739298105,
-0.1831361055,
0.8136295676,
0.0883258432,
-0.5627585649,
-0.0274607018,
0.7118240595,
0.2153927535,
0.0418228582,
0.4117183387,
0.4606398046,
0.9095271826,
0.041789379,
0.9344752431,
-0.4081277549,
0.3239867091,
1.4244662523,
-0.3467275202,
0.6380268931,
0.4587063789,
-0.1560661197,
0.5491502285,
0.5893912315,
0.2454329878,
0.412173301,
0.0373900086,
-0.1805333346,
-0.1507962644,
0.0147214886,
-0.3667496443,
0.1553080231,
0.4475334883,
-0.7772573233,
-0.508339107,
-0.2224951982,
0.3043186367,
-0.275244236,
-0.1033299267,
0.9645846486,
-0.0638690963,
-0.6800258756,
0.4722392857,
0.0027579092,
0.1739509404,
-0.4886600673,
-0.0774643049,
0.0190533195,
-0.2689946592,
-0.2357730567,
-0.559330523,
-0.0504159331,
-0.3015199602,
-0.2286185473,
-0.2974851131,
0.8031244278,
-0.4833109081,
-0.5948085189,
0.3087054193,
0.6375439763,
0.1889772266,
0.1708285362,
-0.149428606,
-0.2185707837,
0.0105470037,
-0.18983908,
0.1322814226,
0.5358291268,
-0.0265519116,
0.2580724061,
0.7400937676,
0.0937886387,
0.1426881105,
-0.1089306399,
1.0447474718,
-0.3321203887,
-0.1298084557,
-0.5905501842,
0.2427283227,
-0.1750024408,
-0.0446355529,
0.5329630375,
0.6477394104,
0.5446014404,
0.178403154,
0.927285552,
-0.4029833376,
0.4053670466,
-0.6137341261,
0.5300019979,
-0.3564863503,
0.3113974333,
-0.3436828256,
-0.945105195,
-0.440217942,
0.0650590211,
-0.4017440677,
-0.2767033875,
0.9950886369,
0.8837945461,
0.0474729054,
0.3057478666,
0.0976449549,
0.2437057197,
0.5922095776,
0.0721135139,
0.5754814744,
-0.2310321927,
0.8150897622,
-0.2396920025,
-0.4124717414,
0.1075178459,
-0.9927375317,
-0.6660793424,
-0.7328506708,
-0.1271755397,
-0.5230680108,
-0.1083210483,
0.8402507901,
0.6114692688,
-0.4111139178,
0.0795190185,
-0.1452140361,
0.25158903,
0.1179001108,
-0.2455436438,
0.6437367201,
-0.3411802351,
-0.3675605357,
0.5496457219,
0.3389602304,
-0.0835954845,
-0.2811203599,
0.1010541767,
-0.1496039927,
-0.1709311754,
0.8632127047,
0.1440869719,
-0.7460742593,
-0.7222859263,
-0.1682719588,
-0.1602697372,
0.0932985693,
0.93454808,
-0.6899041533,
0.5930966139,
0.2977455854,
0.44769907,
0.5197299123,
-0.073389858,
0.7926880717,
-0.9439010024,
-0.3220950663,
-0.1616520435,
0.1722659022,
0.1302774549,
-0.4712303281,
0.6378483176,
0.3995648921,
-0.3307910562,
-0.5211522579,
0.2791775465,
-0.8706011176,
-0.2476030439,
1.6278394461,
-0.0994850993,
-0.2356157303,
-0.2335330844,
-0.0385299884,
0.3223060966,
-0.3972818851,
0.3991558254,
0.7276047468,
-0.1657904536,
0.6353481412,
-0.3366693854,
0.3509640992,
-0.2045425922,
-0.9542482495,
0.3623724282,
0.5757009387,
0.5145405531,
0.3670710027,
0.6706089973,
-0.351737082,
-0.1765323281,
-0.1509468108,
0.285693258,
-0.1612313241,
-0.4965862632,
0.0357644409,
0.548173666,
-0.1287024766,
0.0511166714
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.