id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03865v1
|
FFN-SkipLLM: A Hidden Gem for Autoregressive Decoding with Adaptive Feed Forward Skipping
| 2024-04-05T02:35:43 | 2024-04-05T02:35:43 |
Ajay Jaiswal, Bodun Hu, Lu Yin, Yeonju Ro, Shiwei Liu, Tianlong Chen, Aditya Akella
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Autoregressive Large Language Models (e.g., LLaMa, GPTs) are omnipresent
achieving remarkable success in language understanding and generation. However,
such impressive capability typically comes with a substantial model size, which
presents significant challenges for autoregressive token-by-token generation.
To mitigate computation overload incurred during generation, several early-exit
and layer-dropping strategies have been proposed. Despite some promising
success due to the redundancy across LLMs layers on metrics like Rough-L/BLUE,
our careful knowledge-intensive evaluation unveils issues such as generation
collapse, hallucination of wrong facts, and noticeable performance drop even at
the trivial exit ratio of 10-15% of layers. We attribute these errors primarily
to ineffective handling of the KV cache through state copying during
early-exit. In this work, we observed the saturation of computationally
expensive feed-forward blocks of LLM layers and proposed FFN-SkipLLM, which is
a novel fine-grained skip strategy of autoregressive LLMs. More specifically,
FFN-SkipLLM is an input-adaptive feed-forward skipping strategy that can skip
25-30% of FFN blocks of LLMs with marginal change in performance on
knowledge-intensive generation tasks without any requirement to handle KV
cache. Our extensive experiments and ablation across benchmarks like MT-Bench,
Factoid-QA, and variable-length text summarization illustrate how our simple
and ease-at-use method can facilitate faster autoregressive decoding.
|
[
-0.4129007161,
-0.7386184335,
0.3169243932,
0.6067633629,
-0.2176811397,
0.4658996761,
0.0850960985,
-0.2364793271,
-0.2882449031,
0.2436918914,
-0.6662935615,
-0.2449423224,
-0.7110044956,
-0.0463864878,
-0.6405597925,
0.7024655342,
-0.2251779139,
-0.0844643041,
0.0103786224,
0.189618513,
-0.4931915104,
-0.203200534,
-0.9281962514,
-0.463457793,
0.335600704,
0.2225428373,
0.599234581,
1.2221366167,
0.21031259,
0.1765077561,
-0.2560348213,
0.3084508181,
-0.493324101,
0.0542154312,
0.0277543999,
-0.1810083687,
-0.5976451039,
-0.2117228508,
0.7443937063,
0.5823071599,
-0.2868064046,
-0.1411910951,
0.2395878434,
0.8779472113,
-0.8582179546,
0.2959401309,
-0.6016242504,
0.3226582408,
-0.2694807947,
-0.3604947031,
-0.4316221178,
-0.1991839856,
-0.2265761793,
-0.432620883,
0.0406588539,
-0.0609768108,
0.4989794195,
0.4728227854,
-0.2455466688,
-0.3715822101,
-0.890625,
0.6994464397,
-0.6459138989,
0.5904201269,
0.3609692454,
-0.0360543355,
-0.2790670395,
-0.3879736066,
-0.4022343457,
0.1494469196,
0.0667726099,
0.1352298111,
-0.2929847538,
-0.0874417424,
0.0330070034,
0.5444343686,
-0.640552938,
0.2085976005,
-0.1430349499,
-0.4352912009,
0.3795438707,
0.3275476694,
-0.0612807833,
-0.2094512433,
-0.4111012518,
-0.0077072312,
-0.87272048,
-0.1365270913,
0.3683287501,
0.2066884041,
0.1139177755,
0.1821302027,
-0.3169219494,
0.6573618054,
0.1688423008,
0.2493020892,
0.1136727855,
-0.5598371029,
-0.4036364853,
0.0422288626,
0.8322128057,
-0.0594458468,
0.0515296534,
-0.2061404288,
-0.2734718025,
-0.3564417958,
-0.0680282116,
-0.8156852126,
-0.5791256428,
0.1940080971,
-0.4090554714,
-0.3816205263,
-0.4762591124,
-0.4571632743,
-0.1428037584,
0.2447363585,
0.3526963294,
-0.7108994126,
-0.2342533171,
0.1026930436,
0.1963968873,
0.4753379524,
0.4910855293,
-0.7712500691,
0.2991804779,
0.6853142977,
0.9219155312,
-0.2725808024,
-0.4376003146,
-0.8839709163,
-0.0685986727,
-0.5272961259,
0.4558042288,
-0.2238878757,
-0.7157359719,
-0.3640033305,
-0.1472809464,
-0.1582948267,
-0.4334900081,
0.297414571,
-0.6795672178,
-0.0054338952,
-0.3202008605,
-0.3909453452,
-0.1644031107,
0.0971864611,
-0.5638423562,
0.8480570912,
-0.0412112772,
-0.5343561172,
0.3874537945,
-0.3826506138,
-0.6559432745,
-0.0401593335,
0.0448349304,
-0.1351634115,
0.2566611767,
0.4893491864,
0.5447866321,
-0.3101381361,
0.1234171614,
-0.0048119281,
-0.377132982,
0.150180012,
-0.7933152914,
0.6561322212,
0.5046522021,
-0.2916056812,
-0.2743073702,
-0.8416349292,
-0.1658344269,
0.3214023709,
-0.5329628587,
-0.24748151,
0.0697995946,
-0.155544281,
0.3667638302,
0.1807244569,
-0.2803016603,
-0.0119585115,
-0.316613704,
0.290489018,
0.9281998277,
-0.0502681062,
0.5211473703,
-0.3215797544,
0.4154068828,
0.2271253169,
0.1943748742,
-0.820748508,
-0.2093081474,
-0.8968068957,
-0.2126035392,
0.3593101799,
0.593180716,
-0.7012085319,
0.2706414163,
0.0302587207,
-0.1827017069,
-0.5776740909,
0.4181403816,
0.5850608945,
0.6944247484,
0.4897662699,
-0.3522471189,
-0.2202439308,
-0.7161951065,
-0.2800782323,
-0.276511997,
0.2940433025,
0.2106335759,
0.2133917958,
-0.1880129725,
0.9477795959,
-0.440290153,
-0.2203256041,
0.0143959438,
0.2520603836,
0.0867748782,
0.7152596712,
0.2351055741,
-0.4204508066,
-0.2246271521,
0.0290419646,
-0.5321833491,
-0.0790873617,
-0.2937720418,
-0.1651662439,
0.5148037672,
0.4252477586,
-0.4532169998,
0.2572945654,
0.2656861246,
-0.2197653204,
0.4923518896,
-0.1652501822,
0.0688375309,
-0.7266748548,
0.1312248856,
-0.2866415381,
-0.3264981508,
-0.4610568583,
-0.0729185268,
0.2233744711,
0.3268687725,
-0.5183169246,
0.6330389977,
-0.5761719346,
-0.1118509471,
-0.3952995241,
-0.2891899943,
0.1031533405,
0.4897149503,
-0.0061542206,
0.7955696583,
0.3761685789,
-0.6176889539,
0.165159598,
0.0420204736,
0.1759518236,
0.0597718507,
-0.2652189434,
0.1980077773,
-0.1566449553,
0.1434322298,
-0.8256779909,
0.0186071675,
0.3500064611,
-0.4650101066,
0.6396093965,
-0.3279471099,
-0.4504959285,
-0.2676591277,
-0.2769571841,
0.5268989801,
0.6357119679,
-0.6223376393,
0.5751461983,
0.0118894083,
-0.2095174044,
-0.9193874598,
-0.9863364697,
0.1289533675,
0.0193239432,
-0.4413523078,
-0.0837682858,
-0.2338334918,
0.1068407223,
0.1026635468,
-0.2713898718,
0.0785598457,
0.2519680858,
-0.0163122844,
0.064590849,
-0.3878884912,
-0.2887024879,
0.3655673563,
-0.1674202979,
0.2806357443,
-0.5880992413,
0.7309200168,
-0.3205637336,
-0.3713873029,
-0.1422835141,
0.2361445427,
0.3606490791,
-0.0330313295,
0.5764565468,
0.6691421866,
-0.33463642,
-0.3836825192,
-0.4892754257,
0.0803385153,
-0.4908075035,
0.3865756691,
-0.1378428638,
-0.725189805,
0.7849355936,
-0.0365041979,
0.2652593255,
0.4557413459,
0.5196077824,
-0.005426032,
0.6080167294,
0.3008565307,
-0.0670103729,
0.2005819976,
-0.2991120219,
-0.1685408056,
-0.7736678123,
-0.2488631755,
-0.1873341501,
-0.0906747505,
-0.0612115525,
-0.7412524223,
-0.2197741866,
0.4117680788,
-0.1376985312,
0.0481062382,
-0.2583654523,
0.4626996219,
0.1493673176,
-0.2845830917,
0.5567288399,
-0.0956081003,
-0.2882393599,
0.104968451,
-1.0275253057,
0.0390900895,
0.9099094868,
0.507183671,
0.9850800633,
-0.2180537581,
0.8365177512,
0.6570860147,
0.1888782829,
-0.726510942,
0.4948353469,
-0.3110854924,
-0.144722864,
-0.216264084,
-0.6170197129,
-0.5813511014,
0.2294344455,
0.1110443324,
-0.3114060462,
0.4651244283,
0.5285250545,
-0.4737021327,
0.4295507073,
-0.412261337,
0.6251043677,
-0.1045150533,
-0.3594314754,
0.0151578253,
-0.438003093,
0.7026647925,
-0.3912231624,
0.2162056565,
0.008888091,
-0.0722628832,
0.5916724801,
-0.5860522389,
0.4657930434,
-0.2554449439,
-0.3374981582,
0.1683052927,
0.4980922937,
0.7456952929,
0.0505484641,
0.092813395,
0.1922230721,
-0.5432949662,
-0.3537879884,
-0.4065553546,
0.9433639646,
-0.6369380951,
-0.2950340211,
-0.4020286202,
-0.4577097297,
-0.2145701945,
0.2276919633,
0.3581709564,
0.5196444392,
-0.239416495,
-0.1059574485,
0.9558960199,
-0.2608134747,
0.8486438394,
0.5882451534,
-0.3254857063,
-0.4310228229,
1.1700742245,
0.1231010556,
0.25845626,
0.3460513055,
0.0567885935,
-0.3151009083,
-1.0103231668,
-0.6438692808,
0.1220519096,
-0.790866375,
-0.4477194846,
-1.0039770603,
-0.6324445605,
-0.1349128634,
-0.3064194918,
-0.7006282806,
-0.4355333745,
-0.4728706479,
-0.0053617954,
0.3855841756,
0.6501806974,
-0.3552826643,
0.4215545356,
-0.9323395491,
0.1214738637,
0.2029730678,
0.3584816158,
0.6219748855,
-0.472501725,
-0.417072773,
-0.2881048918,
-0.1054782122,
-0.5871005654,
0.4712278843,
0.1413127035,
0.4956786036,
0.3814751506,
-0.0167718343,
0.7261937857,
-0.3964186907,
0.5478752255,
0.1016603038,
-1.0787369013,
0.389547497,
-0.489892453,
0.5451406837,
0.3199867606,
0.1844357848,
-0.4031475186,
-0.5105252266,
-0.2796296179,
-1.2806270123,
1.0953279734,
0.326326102,
-0.1988160759,
-0.1557780951,
0.3169331849,
0.2476367354,
0.0890558288,
-0.4442022145,
-0.3493814468,
-0.3689143658,
0.0486004166,
0.082951501,
-0.2439538389,
0.1995015144,
0.1359306574,
0.7751282454,
-0.0888453647,
0.3382347226,
0.2315199822,
-0.5170852542,
-0.1879728436,
0.2150073498,
0.585175097,
0.3688914776,
-0.2067784071,
-0.0711547211,
0.3131834567,
-0.6874146461,
0.1502993405,
0.1863593906,
-0.3456677198,
-0.2023109496,
0.3273375034,
0.8844124675,
0.1334442943,
-0.2978416383,
0.2152161896,
-0.2894337773,
-0.4058161676,
-0.168031916,
0.1930945367,
0.1496325582,
0.1734663844,
0.8867442012,
0.2469104528,
0.1281752437,
-0.1532671899,
0.3247773945,
0.2776880264,
-0.2961570024,
-0.2507399023,
0.670196116,
0.2659246624,
-0.1622414142,
0.5895816088,
-0.2465322018,
-0.2496790439,
0.4943757355,
0.4856333733,
1.1278386116,
-0.2477651983,
0.0556129813,
-0.0259136707,
0.5388517976,
-0.2799147666,
0.1580821574,
-0.3279049695,
-0.5982363224,
-0.6754101515,
-0.962970078,
-0.1021953672,
0.3092644811,
-0.6413342953,
-0.0262626223,
-0.6043565869,
0.2322332859,
-0.4396153092,
-0.0850654617,
-0.6181212068,
0.2349268645,
0.2737987041,
1.1489198208,
-0.6746359468,
0.8449177146,
0.2223982811,
0.1035729349,
-0.7075844407,
0.2461243123,
0.0708757192,
-0.8096627593,
0.6566900611,
-0.2562573552,
-0.3349563479,
0.1064424813,
-0.0921520814,
-0.8991234303,
1.1215415001,
0.1444824189,
-0.5140124559,
-0.2263997793,
-0.1004382521,
0.0848326609,
-0.4400924146,
0.114004001,
0.734924674,
0.4324583411,
0.4124915004,
-0.7405067682,
0.3229195476,
-0.20046103,
0.0601313896,
0.384678632,
-0.8071590066,
0.9202259779,
-0.0968462005,
-0.1459665895,
0.1088482291,
0.8042681217,
0.0588989593,
0.2223521769,
0.5119988918,
0.2730135024,
0.4849415123,
-0.063016057,
0.7339985967,
-0.2511024773,
0.2107766718,
0.9809075594,
-0.1097729132,
0.6133179069,
0.2871435285,
-0.001600581,
-0.0370234065,
0.57431072,
0.1991959065,
0.6210062504,
0.0843918025,
-0.0639448389,
-0.2664186954,
0.3956640065,
-0.362462163,
0.469751209,
0.5694416761,
-0.4032256901,
-0.4547749162,
0.0586916171,
0.1342648715,
-0.2918643653,
-0.4860111177,
0.7181002498,
0.1538315415,
-0.3941338658,
0.710047245,
-0.0007929569,
0.8865360022,
-0.664180696,
0.1435065717,
-0.5693469644,
0.0405310877,
-0.1847201884,
-0.6497546434,
0.5480558872,
0.0281859916,
-0.3334758282,
-0.4637267888,
0.8661817312,
-0.3412297964,
-0.3355319202,
0.4458733499,
0.6990994811,
-0.0287223086,
0.2540954053,
-0.675599277,
0.2661244869,
0.015316125,
-0.4391639233,
0.3971262872,
0.3627402186,
0.0549263954,
0.634306252,
0.8155685663,
0.2377495617,
0.2588217854,
-0.2382163554,
0.9462245107,
-0.8511722684,
-0.6486712098,
-1.0334892273,
0.2241712511,
0.2888641059,
-0.0462055169,
0.7574685812,
0.6707440019,
0.7215158939,
0.1814804673,
0.7276171446,
0.1813361794,
0.0897938833,
-0.8682349324,
0.9696583152,
-0.5632517338,
0.5435285568,
-0.3890269995,
-0.7879322171,
-0.1240615621,
0.3157545924,
0.1553376913,
0.0734158754,
0.4393428862,
0.4803118706,
-0.0495324284,
-0.0456659235,
0.2828223705,
0.5334536433,
0.2501289845,
0.6823319197,
0.9427236915,
-0.429687202,
0.6328033805,
-0.0504787229,
-0.1478238255,
-0.2909093499,
-0.9909788966,
-0.5381197333,
-0.3072339594,
-0.431853801,
-0.3960618973,
0.21342282,
0.6514343023,
0.6515814066,
-0.5235664248,
-0.1373256743,
-0.233501628,
0.2392448932,
-0.1536410451,
-0.2317008972,
0.2391013652,
-0.3538927436,
-0.4921925962,
0.6753563881,
0.5989147425,
0.1615792066,
-0.5130793452,
-0.3351231813,
-0.076026842,
0.2999574542,
0.4620043933,
0.6411707401,
-0.5704820752,
0.2646270096,
0.166348815,
-0.0496800952,
0.0785611272,
0.8560532928,
-1.0588188171,
0.1990164816,
0.5710417032,
0.752448976,
0.6159114838,
-0.1637680978,
0.7210631967,
-0.6545897126,
-0.0185436532,
0.1872391552,
0.2850863934,
0.3674744964,
-0.5924742222,
0.1587039828,
0.2526319623,
-0.4173555076,
-0.9016613364,
0.1180045903,
-0.7849959731,
-0.2724085748,
0.9916278124,
-0.1177528203,
-0.4477510452,
-0.2723409235,
0.2165740728,
0.0081138853,
-0.6284407973,
0.4567499757,
0.7923064828,
-0.1768174917,
-0.327501893,
-0.3114503026,
0.7130033374,
0.4112370908,
-0.410467118,
0.5059499145,
0.4450681806,
0.2025058419,
-0.019318603,
1.0072797537,
-0.2289248109,
0.5025030375,
0.0027366339,
-0.2425642163,
-0.7113353014,
-0.438085407,
-0.7584058642,
0.1297167987,
0.1010056883,
-0.2235348076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03862v1
|
Verifiable by Design: Aligning Language Models to Quote from Pre-Training Data
| 2024-04-05T02:27:09 | 2024-04-05T02:27:09 |
Jingyu Zhang, Marc Marone, Tianjian Li, Benjamin Van Durme, Daniel Khashabi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For humans to trust the fluent generations of large language models (LLMs),
they must be able to verify their correctness against trusted, external
sources. Recent efforts aim to increase verifiability through citations of
retrieved documents or post-hoc provenance. However, such citations are prone
to mistakes that further complicate their verifiability. To address these
limitations, we tackle the verifiability goal with a different philosophy: we
trivialize the verification process by developing models that quote verbatim
statements from trusted sources in pre-training data. We propose Quote-Tuning,
which demonstrates the feasibility of aligning LLMs to leverage memorized
information and quote from pre-training data. Quote-Tuning quantifies quoting
against large corpora with efficient membership inference tools, and uses the
amount of quotes as an implicit reward signal to construct a synthetic
preference dataset for quoting, without any human annotation. Next, the target
model is aligned to quote using preference optimization algorithms.
Experimental results show that Quote-Tuning significantly increases the
percentage of LLM generation quoted verbatim from high-quality pre-training
documents by 55% to 130% relative to untuned models while maintaining response
quality. Further experiments demonstrate that Quote-Tuning generalizes quoting
to out-of-domain data, is applicable in different tasks, and provides
additional benefits to truthfulness. Quote-Tuning not only serves as a
hassle-free method to increase quoting but also opens up avenues for improving
LLM trustworthiness through better verifiability.
|
[
-0.1331919432,
-0.4401193559,
0.6652061939,
-0.0628234372,
-0.415897727,
0.2471599877,
-0.4579002559,
-0.4293558002,
0.048009336,
0.6904213428,
-0.6256030202,
-0.3547338545,
-0.4157907367,
-0.0053680516,
-0.2064951956,
1.0290333033,
-0.0041893367,
0.1079902425,
-0.3229957223,
-0.027538443,
-0.3802421689,
-0.7195279002,
-0.5044753551,
-0.3282563388,
0.450583905,
0.2827146947,
0.9112311602,
0.873328805,
0.5733786821,
0.2540970445,
0.1174148992,
0.326472789,
-0.5024399161,
0.3080776036,
-0.3232042789,
-0.7304883003,
-0.2657098174,
0.2089472115,
0.5525714159,
0.2389929742,
-0.1528586298,
0.0905696005,
-0.0070955511,
0.6615587473,
-0.6014473438,
-0.0282952413,
-1.17773211,
-0.1356405914,
-0.3502042294,
-0.2528256476,
-0.474584192,
-0.7384999394,
0.006341259,
-0.5863848329,
0.152338177,
0.363388896,
1.250117898,
0.4908420742,
-0.249104172,
-0.4199323952,
-0.6417248845,
0.8694345951,
-0.7055070996,
0.2917585969,
0.6440403461,
0.3660033345,
-0.059826944,
-0.5958695412,
-0.5266213417,
-0.3415513933,
-0.2635581791,
-0.0413101315,
0.0059955474,
-0.1968712658,
0.2597169578,
0.4894834757,
-0.5020067096,
0.1407423168,
-0.0264301728,
-0.4056233764,
0.5568140149,
-0.16853486,
0.114826262,
0.0409160703,
-0.4469586909,
-0.1605119854,
-1.0137153864,
-0.2149614841,
0.4813196063,
0.405952096,
0.0338348597,
0.7015099525,
-0.1262043417,
0.5248131156,
-0.0184269864,
0.240873009,
0.1708970517,
-0.5806070566,
-0.2598809302,
0.1192097291,
0.6646459103,
0.2689026892,
0.591358304,
-0.2783794701,
-0.1690464765,
0.2286007851,
0.6051203012,
-0.4864066243,
-0.124224551,
0.0492927544,
0.0088593913,
-0.5013713837,
-0.0506911688,
-0.3892564774,
-0.3514656723,
-0.5231485963,
0.5351045132,
-0.399636507,
-0.0565990098,
0.1383914053,
-0.0119808642,
0.187204361,
0.2908608317,
-0.9136659503,
-0.1458017677,
0.7775748372,
0.7440769076,
0.0267699026,
-0.1837803721,
-0.4430909753,
0.4128655195,
-0.4831105769,
0.8681256175,
-0.5013958812,
-0.2243696749,
0.3348839879,
-0.1284488291,
0.1100607812,
-0.2836204767,
1.1172671318,
-0.6319420338,
0.1678514332,
-0.5824154019,
-0.6912573576,
0.3568825424,
0.3548771441,
-0.5365537405,
1.0686452389,
-0.0691835806,
-0.739351511,
0.6608867049,
-0.3386572897,
-0.4087392986,
-0.0621924102,
-0.3861676455,
-0.5085506439,
0.2340770364,
0.1801417023,
0.2279960513,
-0.4822849035,
0.2498250306,
-0.3940788209,
-0.1793451905,
0.5047923923,
-0.3503971398,
0.5816016197,
0.4747362137,
-0.0659215301,
0.1479288191,
-0.6296518445,
0.24117136,
0.0971800461,
-0.3598583043,
-0.4671456218,
-0.0950754434,
-0.1131379381,
0.0853915587,
0.443187952,
-0.5174475908,
0.1382163018,
-0.6073115468,
0.4517193139,
1.0302749872,
-0.2898080349,
0.3585561216,
-0.6383621097,
0.262802273,
-0.0925304368,
0.1591297239,
0.0068762591,
0.0600012355,
-0.7146821618,
-0.4220014811,
0.1893496513,
0.2932636738,
-0.5548988581,
0.7319761515,
-0.5827952623,
-0.4317957759,
-0.5693959594,
0.3976181746,
0.4354309142,
0.8042066693,
0.3924763799,
-0.1429279596,
-0.7858271003,
-0.9037921429,
-0.5136864185,
-0.4470141828,
-0.1914691925,
0.2381953448,
0.2023406029,
0.0538496114,
1.0585967302,
-0.5550100207,
-0.0497397408,
-0.0169699937,
0.0607249252,
0.0287435018,
0.6187832355,
0.3898115158,
-0.5920523405,
-0.4935956299,
-0.0023023386,
-0.7941429615,
-0.1190963909,
0.0046565966,
-0.58408916,
0.1524050385,
0.530584991,
-0.6138314605,
0.1092492044,
0.2435865998,
-0.1157343537,
0.3718827069,
-0.3753466904,
0.1727406085,
-1.276548028,
-0.0988841951,
-0.0543332025,
-0.5000535846,
-0.1921085566,
-0.0990945026,
0.1659231931,
0.1225169078,
-0.1239741445,
0.3393501639,
-0.3588555455,
0.2350901812,
-0.3290612698,
0.0535363518,
0.2123600096,
0.1332064867,
0.0244046953,
0.9610697031,
0.4683685899,
-0.4589355588,
0.0603939556,
0.3955291808,
-0.7334344983,
0.8740668893,
-0.7825890183,
0.3312291801,
0.0254718103,
0.065377526,
-0.9106687307,
-0.1387348771,
0.0290332697,
-0.2857625484,
0.3140130639,
-0.2359983325,
-0.5485239625,
-0.0099949632,
-0.2436982989,
0.0853173956,
0.5345178843,
-0.7021962404,
0.4593980312,
0.3510140181,
-0.0641789138,
-0.6695784926,
-0.648360014,
0.1032191366,
-0.2435158491,
-0.6377828717,
0.5070462227,
-0.2092095315,
0.0491649322,
-0.1385437995,
-0.3507868648,
-0.0722142607,
0.2054076791,
0.22206074,
0.5038970113,
-0.2442512065,
0.3218100071,
0.072396189,
-0.1255452484,
-0.0417355336,
-0.4025022686,
0.2726089656,
-0.0899224654,
-0.438036114,
-0.281253159,
0.2352900058,
0.4618226886,
-0.2802329063,
0.7427526712,
0.2692964077,
-0.1975251883,
-0.1789558828,
-0.7729052901,
-0.1537691206,
-0.5273791552,
0.0581901744,
-0.2914333045,
-1.0375277996,
0.1883219033,
-0.1853149086,
0.1605220437,
0.1397976279,
0.5270990729,
-0.4084357321,
0.6395640373,
0.698123455,
-0.1681797802,
0.5851947069,
0.3686204255,
0.0650521293,
-0.5188843012,
0.0151039595,
-0.8635684252,
0.0447194502,
-0.4016683102,
-0.2681256831,
0.0978687033,
0.1089679748,
-0.4320220947,
0.4803753495,
-0.3372816145,
0.6310327053,
0.4491581619,
0.1252303571,
0.3755477071,
0.1484881639,
-0.1479404122,
-0.0850859806,
-0.2436205894,
-0.945704639,
1.1801564693,
0.1974925101,
0.8997449875,
0.307474494,
0.5320183635,
0.3976302445,
0.3174327612,
-0.5680693388,
0.3214475214,
0.0708741546,
-0.8928067088,
-0.2818304896,
-0.2417766899,
-0.6120224595,
-0.0214420799,
-0.3184451163,
-0.6841307282,
-0.0106901564,
0.4541960657,
-0.1655922532,
-0.1477336735,
-0.6786749363,
0.8262785077,
-0.3104221523,
-0.4191744626,
-0.3296664953,
-0.7260994315,
0.2711365819,
-0.2428653389,
-0.0024000076,
-0.2417329103,
0.1764579862,
0.494215399,
-0.6181211472,
0.757522583,
0.0343475007,
-0.1898495257,
-0.0463913046,
-0.1307256371,
0.7913077474,
0.1291027218,
-0.368228972,
-0.0198676307,
0.0256311297,
-0.4252928793,
-0.7804733515,
0.7266466618,
-0.8234078288,
-0.8683600426,
-0.316282481,
-0.3520133197,
-0.5840631723,
0.2417577207,
0.3337754011,
-0.0239439122,
-0.2789560258,
0.3406834006,
0.7307603955,
0.204011485,
0.2240736187,
0.5265145302,
0.0139984349,
-0.5042296052,
0.7395579815,
-0.0707552433,
0.3853250146,
0.5202940106,
0.0826155394,
-0.5095211864,
-0.5502897501,
-0.2997153997,
0.3142867684,
-0.8430814743,
-0.2519460618,
-0.2962101996,
-0.1304930449,
-0.3708857894,
-0.209511444,
-0.678324759,
-0.2191448957,
-0.1662344635,
-0.3497724533,
0.3745413125,
0.3406631649,
0.0960858837,
0.4379453957,
-0.5533716679,
-0.0842285231,
0.2488409281,
0.3586068153,
-0.4778368771,
-0.7433081269,
-0.5620315075,
0.0714122951,
-0.1362708956,
-0.4633869827,
0.0755031556,
0.2596358657,
0.6624535322,
0.2139750123,
0.2280576825,
0.6411951184,
-0.6188052893,
0.6068372726,
0.1322823018,
-1.1639070511,
0.6692076325,
-0.0738597512,
-0.2452708483,
0.9542719126,
0.3543314636,
-0.222932741,
-0.2675048113,
-0.3981624246,
-0.6390942335,
0.5053926706,
0.321339488,
0.3730283976,
0.1205912679,
0.4999811649,
0.1889950633,
0.3121592999,
-0.6007269621,
-0.1379161328,
-0.557785511,
-0.4054654539,
-0.3357805908,
-0.419008106,
-0.4622916281,
0.0045679091,
0.7286267281,
-0.3059931993,
0.0968959555,
0.0548418574,
-0.2756928504,
-0.0939926058,
0.3483285606,
0.7305697799,
0.7039126754,
-0.2457605451,
0.3734099567,
-0.161122486,
-0.1973420978,
0.3347185552,
-0.125320822,
-0.0817897096,
-0.0720896125,
0.2153085917,
0.9027781487,
0.1714800298,
-0.3285295963,
0.4368754327,
-0.1903170645,
-0.0234389473,
-0.3993802965,
0.2416849732,
0.2057781518,
0.1971312165,
0.2712342739,
0.0911955461,
-0.4661655724,
-0.2660594285,
0.2866361439,
0.7094512582,
-0.317153275,
-0.3177759945,
0.6927427053,
0.0172089934,
-0.2061997354,
0.5591323376,
0.2900928855,
-0.1022950485,
0.1845266223,
0.5284141898,
0.9423912764,
-0.0611114502,
0.2028506249,
0.2797715664,
0.3789414167,
-0.1977063417,
0.0662429407,
-0.1843830198,
-1.0902456045,
-0.3772108257,
-0.7830454111,
-0.6107977629,
0.0166026503,
-0.7546367645,
0.3103400171,
-0.5148056149,
-0.3399146795,
0.0991676599,
-0.1791449785,
-0.5586044192,
0.2942822874,
0.0494454205,
0.8455023766,
-0.9463925362,
1.2923344374,
0.4566831589,
-0.6793090701,
-0.7981911302,
0.2117318958,
-0.175473243,
-1.061062336,
0.6968617439,
-0.1135906875,
-0.228062138,
0.1296961755,
-0.8558283448,
-0.8938605785,
0.9506732225,
1.1265935898,
-0.3995404541,
0.0845002085,
0.1071578786,
0.4198245406,
-0.3131383359,
0.1891315877,
0.3029333055,
0.3507979512,
0.3785197735,
-0.6920803189,
0.2155829966,
-0.1669355631,
0.0980124623,
-0.1420339495,
-0.5107300878,
0.5034903288,
0.1594329923,
-0.2260462791,
-0.0513982326,
0.8403812051,
0.2975928485,
-0.1529407203,
0.3822124898,
0.4344973266,
1.186263442,
-0.0485768206,
0.9914249182,
-0.4203971922,
0.2746771872,
1.456949234,
-0.5051527023,
0.8044119477,
0.7374184132,
-0.2505890131,
0.5277789235,
0.496730566,
0.1214154735,
0.6510891318,
0.1353320032,
-0.3498640358,
-0.6098961234,
-0.1773846895,
-0.5080999136,
0.2449728251,
0.0859527588,
-0.5331913829,
-0.1073342636,
-0.3999969363,
0.0562280416,
0.3425394595,
0.1236292571,
0.6603458524,
0.098810792,
-0.7258540988,
0.6314404011,
-0.1616435051,
0.5609461069,
-0.8223600984,
0.2728370726,
-0.2033814639,
0.1376828104,
-0.0731290877,
-0.4640098512,
0.3717660606,
0.1024855152,
-0.4525612593,
-0.4400770664,
0.5454929471,
-0.3470250666,
-0.4768391848,
-0.1907707453,
0.3737380505,
0.0005092071,
0.0565833598,
-0.5450649261,
0.243488133,
-0.0156076141,
-0.2117497474,
0.463178426,
0.3860466182,
0.1040117443,
0.6317501664,
0.8042023182,
0.1192930266,
-0.0899652839,
0.1441425681,
0.8167226315,
-0.5648368001,
-0.4540244043,
-1.1183238029,
0.4097702801,
-0.4037478864,
-0.1628846675,
0.9173920155,
0.5444288254,
0.932051301,
-0.2113804221,
1.0025910139,
0.3226743937,
0.5202357173,
-0.7817625403,
0.8117723465,
-0.3918913007,
0.3624898493,
-0.2743801773,
-0.6290722489,
-0.2998863161,
0.761664331,
-0.3262417018,
0.0546290167,
0.5944325924,
1.1474778652,
0.061978247,
0.0080420189,
0.3660622835,
-0.0572970733,
0.5829483271,
0.3397597671,
0.8356086016,
-0.2075770348,
0.4452284873,
-0.0402586237,
0.0336604044,
-0.1343932748,
-1.3082588911,
-0.8489722013,
-0.4760937095,
-0.5614184737,
-0.3795567751,
0.0420621894,
1.044154644,
0.7720494866,
-0.7797574997,
-0.0845264867,
-0.2914790809,
0.216984123,
-0.1014153808,
-0.1148522496,
0.2738367021,
-0.7340242267,
-0.6700894237,
0.5400970578,
0.1377970427,
0.2235073894,
-0.1753631979,
-0.1281607002,
-0.1453125328,
0.423378557,
0.1852214783,
0.3993022442,
-0.6501168013,
-0.5925810337,
-0.1724370718,
-0.5087116957,
0.2304431498,
0.8720420003,
-0.5806431174,
0.3169387579,
0.3252131045,
0.8082827926,
0.407260716,
0.1881086975,
0.8841530681,
-0.8820481896,
-0.1443554908,
-0.0280449875,
0.4431487918,
0.4823420942,
-0.4234646857,
0.4501923621,
0.1323838681,
-0.6648418903,
-1.0972568989,
0.3776863813,
-0.9442800283,
0.0468255728,
0.7272079587,
-0.4526917338,
-0.170853734,
-0.0605965592,
-0.220923692,
0.3397675157,
-0.2090307474,
0.7806591392,
0.9556596279,
0.1431719065,
0.0306944642,
-0.1603126228,
0.8312430978,
0.7020161748,
-0.771276474,
0.4498668313,
0.4199685156,
0.3637129068,
0.0924963877,
0.5226264,
-0.0166577399,
-0.0590279177,
-0.2499020398,
-0.037869826,
-0.1708702445,
-0.020667702,
-0.137212351,
0.1485260129,
0.67471385,
-0.1727143377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03854v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03854v2
|
Align as Ideal: Cross-Modal Alignment Binding for Federated Medical Vision-Language Pre-training
| 2024-04-05T01:17:25 | 2024-05-24T15:08:38 |
Zitao Shuai, Liyue Shen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Vision-language pre-training (VLP) has arised as an efficient scheme for
multimodal representation learning, but it requires large-scale multimodal data
for pre-training, making it an obstacle especially for medical applications. To
overcome the data limitation, federated learning (FL) can be a promising
strategy to scale up the dataset for medical VLP while protecting data privacy.
However, client data are often heterogeneous in real-world scenarios, and we
observe that local training on heterogeneous client data would distort the
multimodal representation learning and lead to biased cross-modal alignment. To
address this challenge, we propose a Federated Align as IDeal (FedAID)
framework for federated VLP with robustness to data heterogeneity, to bind
local clients with an ideal crossmodal alignment. Specifically, to reduce
distortions on global-aggregated features while learning diverse semantics from
client datasets during local training, we propose to bind the cross-model
aligned representation space learned by local models with an unbiased one via
guidance-based regularization. Moreover, we employ a distribution-based min-max
optimization to learn the unbiased cross-modal alignment at each communication
turn of federated pre-training. The experiments on real-world datasets
demonstrate our method successfully promotes efficient federated multimodal
learning for medical VLP with data heterogeneity.
|
[
-0.0715011135,
-0.3215838671,
0.3161275089,
0.0207070112,
-0.308840394,
-0.1393835992,
-0.2329756021,
-0.4122087955,
0.3805811107,
0.3247215748,
-0.6641962528,
-0.4523527026,
-0.34051615,
-0.0745234564,
0.197630316,
0.7577528954,
-0.1914520711,
0.5851128697,
-0.5412690043,
-0.5488427877,
-0.2617521584,
-0.2018016577,
0.0186567716,
-0.2479686886,
0.2455223799,
0.3086446524,
0.9180567265,
0.8250022531,
0.6729553342,
0.3106558025,
0.7043206096,
0.1279239953,
-0.5353981853,
0.010401601,
-0.3827815056,
-0.5384241343,
-0.672505796,
0.2116218954,
0.7247451544,
0.8326817155,
-0.2622101903,
0.0842303783,
-0.351465553,
0.464918226,
-0.6625436544,
0.240168497,
-0.4241121411,
0.4477922022,
-0.3102134466,
-0.2399139404,
-0.2831046581,
-0.2191646546,
0.3279434741,
-0.922719121,
-0.0113164112,
0.194547832,
1.2408376932,
0.5281040668,
-0.2580957115,
0.2240812182,
-0.3501259089,
0.7631710768,
-0.2697558999,
0.9143161178,
0.3381525576,
0.693579495,
0.2087476701,
-0.7685056329,
-0.4474747777,
0.3159199953,
-0.2381250858,
0.2035266757,
-0.2516093254,
0.2414031178,
-0.1077322811,
0.3207133412,
-0.547866106,
0.1614356488,
-0.0813970938,
-0.341838479,
0.6125363708,
0.1178467721,
0.2304940075,
0.2040496916,
-0.7869814634,
-0.1341416091,
-0.6551433206,
-0.040597938,
0.0111123258,
0.4736699462,
-0.4122804701,
0.5887469649,
-0.2094796151,
0.8634635806,
0.6342045069,
-0.4481359124,
0.7045688033,
-0.6758163571,
-0.5818426609,
0.0511874557,
0.8071321845,
0.3780440986,
0.0517935492,
-0.2192912549,
-0.2617735267,
0.0208732337,
0.3614355624,
-0.5645859241,
0.2244947851,
0.0895134509,
-0.4974671304,
-0.2701257765,
0.1282324046,
-0.587490797,
0.052172713,
-0.5770118237,
0.5275489688,
-0.236548081,
-0.0406055078,
0.1580524743,
0.5357441306,
0.2903413177,
0.3482193053,
-0.8932278156,
0.0470290296,
0.5321373343,
0.5472612977,
0.0625890717,
-0.4820854962,
-0.8888540268,
0.2798398435,
0.0264720656,
0.3483516872,
-0.7464624047,
0.0396775827,
0.2507172823,
0.1703525782,
-0.2853915989,
-0.2033709586,
0.2151003182,
-0.3248780072,
0.661250174,
-0.0548694767,
-0.4851971567,
0.0578160323,
0.2657826543,
-0.3548367321,
0.0111928424,
0.2029418498,
-0.754760325,
0.6610176563,
-0.3300445974,
-0.3935309947,
-0.0602754429,
-0.7528060675,
-0.7293596268,
0.126190275,
0.5023060441,
0.5151720643,
-0.2901797891,
0.2302346826,
-0.3805647492,
-0.10559576,
-0.2097465694,
-0.1924555004,
0.6959117055,
0.1492706388,
-0.3206279874,
0.3013792336,
-0.5764422417,
0.0422566608,
-0.1207900345,
0.0099367127,
-0.3641262054,
-0.302194804,
0.0487276763,
0.2230055779,
0.19512707,
-0.6987841129,
0.3297230005,
-0.3564347029,
-0.1027588248,
0.7429870963,
-0.4037332535,
0.7215079069,
-0.3268838227,
0.7562744617,
0.1322159916,
0.5495591164,
0.173856467,
-0.2358278036,
-0.2459091991,
-0.6756622791,
0.147724703,
0.212462157,
-1.0169063807,
0.1374263912,
-0.6155275106,
-0.2780801654,
-0.9025852084,
0.0976056084,
0.823212266,
0.7959380746,
0.2903010249,
-0.5256915092,
-0.4288371801,
-0.9567751884,
-0.0137638384,
0.0972733423,
0.1702370942,
0.4363711476,
-0.0970827118,
-0.8389915824,
1.0055221319,
-0.3635191619,
-0.9778850079,
0.1174243242,
-0.0480086245,
-0.0564903505,
0.5955117941,
0.7375018597,
-1.1012910604,
-0.5373743176,
0.3379964828,
-0.5195558667,
-0.1712292284,
-0.096201241,
-0.1726224273,
0.3126337826,
0.102773115,
-0.320771575,
0.2833632529,
0.8922800422,
-0.5945870876,
0.2254557163,
-0.3478116691,
0.1323950738,
-1.1185500622,
0.0418011099,
-0.0839180127,
-0.5261329412,
-0.4465939105,
-0.0503070168,
0.0602257811,
-0.2144811153,
-0.2535357773,
0.2866520286,
-0.632589817,
-0.2294235528,
0.1421482861,
-0.1649544239,
-0.0271283966,
0.2367650121,
0.4151985645,
0.5294314027,
0.7556310892,
0.172658816,
0.2094234526,
0.5682632327,
-0.078605175,
0.9168182015,
-0.245152846,
-0.25451684,
-0.1240461692,
0.2752276957,
-0.4248691797,
-0.4363720119,
0.1437377036,
-0.361351639,
0.4151633978,
0.0503790043,
-0.1363339275,
0.1569930911,
-0.0259081889,
0.6630398035,
0.2121323943,
-0.6345774531,
0.8538635969,
0.5278716087,
0.4031389952,
-1.0678806305,
-0.6615213156,
-0.5376631021,
0.213722378,
-0.6773101091,
0.4686966836,
0.2570132017,
0.1112222224,
0.0745871887,
-0.2628394067,
-0.2244204432,
-0.3277927935,
0.6253992319,
0.3836518526,
-0.5005601645,
0.0287216473,
0.0498043709,
-0.295188427,
-0.2429665178,
-0.3266623318,
0.4987998903,
-0.2778778672,
-0.8203738928,
-0.5414038897,
0.4154986441,
0.6519842744,
-0.497836709,
0.6148249507,
0.7453927994,
-0.3991369605,
0.1815040559,
-0.4892469645,
-0.0263724905,
-0.4652361572,
0.2260082364,
-0.2427016944,
-0.9058979154,
0.3043445945,
0.1369049549,
0.0555465668,
-0.0269307792,
0.6515068412,
-0.1286464632,
0.8149293065,
0.9794614911,
-0.1283398569,
0.5858555436,
0.0154401837,
0.1456198096,
-0.2272171378,
-0.3911016583,
0.0056635537,
-0.3722956777,
-0.2524626553,
-0.6246772408,
0.2090652585,
-0.1494915336,
-0.0206844565,
0.0711678267,
-0.3416799307,
0.4500987828,
0.2750412226,
0.10247235,
0.1016137972,
0.2645659447,
-0.2878549397,
-0.2852362096,
-0.5848247409,
0.147953257,
1.021225214,
0.33651039,
1.0551501513,
-0.0081813661,
0.8028622866,
-0.1178633869,
0.3295378089,
-0.3851934075,
0.1371911764,
-0.2288319767,
-0.3614732325,
-0.0026513294,
-0.4586527944,
-0.7618392706,
0.2352163941,
-0.5518384576,
-0.5355567336,
0.7315919995,
0.4448013902,
-0.4318661392,
0.1745072007,
-0.6417409182,
1.0573501587,
-0.3254241049,
-0.3892277181,
-0.0416267291,
-1.1633524895,
0.1932392716,
-0.1152346358,
-0.0050543007,
0.2192650139,
-0.0230382551,
0.1714363545,
-0.5431389809,
0.9209129214,
-0.3270885944,
0.0290975235,
-0.4415631592,
-0.3803075552,
0.2499060184,
0.080464907,
0.4114021957,
0.141906321,
-0.1132454425,
-0.4057060182,
-0.4155932665,
0.5812267065,
-0.8519442677,
-0.3695265949,
-0.4219929576,
-0.7304938436,
-0.5065318942,
0.205765292,
0.435975939,
0.5484519005,
-0.0061981697,
0.1898668855,
0.6051765084,
0.0926416591,
0.0266015995,
0.6235916615,
-0.4218393862,
-0.5979669094,
0.9740001559,
0.0203773342,
0.6180269718,
0.7296668291,
0.013233602,
-0.1857964545,
-0.3479084671,
-0.4468110204,
0.3582569361,
-0.5390468836,
-0.3767980039,
-0.4134274721,
0.0231298674,
-0.5754247904,
-0.7346500754,
-0.6931880116,
-0.0923112556,
-0.278773576,
0.1440025121,
-0.0630393475,
-0.0495806895,
-0.3928371072,
0.3253144622,
-0.7400892377,
0.2538346648,
0.1874208301,
0.5510793328,
-0.5505198836,
-0.0176398288,
-0.2506381869,
0.1622690111,
0.2243126035,
-0.4838730991,
0.2925760746,
0.4465855658,
0.6202967167,
1.0736711025,
0.0266748592,
1.0062084198,
-0.5591276884,
0.283136189,
0.6339819431,
-0.7427697182,
0.34670344,
-0.0936253145,
0.3143613636,
0.8563814163,
0.5515216589,
-0.3223492503,
-0.2152324617,
-0.5047829151,
-0.3991076052,
0.6005157828,
-0.1184658408,
-0.1221025586,
0.3994769454,
0.033772476,
0.2732849121,
0.2078994215,
-0.6361911893,
-0.3300415277,
-0.542810142,
-0.5300999284,
-0.0160059351,
0.2282007337,
-0.5220147371,
-0.4115616381,
0.4196078181,
-0.3937024474,
0.269287765,
0.319037348,
-0.2066872567,
-0.3892773986,
-0.1806217134,
0.6978462338,
0.5315254927,
-0.1959125549,
0.0390929468,
-0.4378449917,
-0.7430275083,
0.1460191756,
0.49295035,
-0.0182973184,
0.0701454505,
0.5083163977,
0.8423271775,
0.1237104386,
-0.7605426908,
1.0210607052,
-0.2572709918,
-0.1614270061,
0.0909971669,
-0.1888733804,
-0.2231511474,
0.4390424788,
0.0243493095,
0.3326345384,
-0.2530564666,
-0.3984715939,
0.5640055537,
0.6672059298,
-0.7690674663,
-0.4467456639,
0.7983849645,
0.1847157031,
0.0862551332,
0.265039444,
0.1778124124,
-0.499925971,
-0.0430381559,
0.5322666764,
0.5744825602,
-0.4054692686,
0.408598423,
-0.1098368317,
0.1428676397,
0.147432968,
0.2240898013,
-0.3263057172,
-0.8896443248,
-0.259875536,
-0.6501239538,
-0.1270022094,
-0.4495909214,
-0.698223114,
0.1638426185,
-0.4572541714,
-0.0541643165,
-0.0429176465,
-0.0694887117,
-0.7818064094,
0.3418697417,
0.07868395,
0.5231944919,
-0.9703156352,
1.1771636009,
0.9302151203,
-0.6468714476,
-0.9452276826,
-0.0091865258,
0.2704174519,
-1.0846098661,
0.6723096967,
0.056646239,
-0.0093806926,
-0.2759436071,
-0.312895298,
-0.7691353559,
1.2015265226,
0.5553787351,
-0.7135774493,
-0.1990527511,
0.3898284137,
0.3999608755,
-0.8765743375,
-0.117985867,
0.0774026811,
0.1588389575,
0.0981106311,
-1.2105857134,
0.085371092,
-0.179685995,
-0.2084857523,
0.1889601946,
-0.5530073047,
0.7217026949,
-0.2502059937,
-0.2601413429,
-0.4269438088,
0.609323442,
-0.1880578101,
0.2557611167,
0.5522403717,
0.7572305799,
0.57669276,
0.0278413109,
0.8592683077,
-0.1024160907,
0.3871451914,
1.260468483,
-0.4373318255,
0.4601465762,
0.869705081,
0.2503907681,
0.0516821779,
0.2965655923,
0.123114787,
0.852165103,
-0.3963218927,
-0.178582415,
-0.4141260386,
-0.192055285,
-0.5707076192,
0.6929895282,
0.0689721331,
-0.6441554427,
-0.4617370963,
0.4010544419,
-0.2102709562,
0.1544893682,
-0.1997255385,
0.6175073385,
-0.1719401181,
-0.2144615054,
0.5946414471,
-0.4632381201,
0.6261285543,
-0.7413486242,
0.1573800594,
-0.1247084737,
0.3188076019,
-0.3163183331,
-0.2154819369,
0.2551862895,
-0.4584674835,
-0.2613340318,
-0.3584783673,
0.5284821987,
-0.6855270863,
-0.2458461374,
0.1312792748,
0.4919686615,
-0.3249090314,
0.4813182056,
-0.5417585969,
0.0860320181,
0.2780320346,
-0.0527589172,
0.5320366621,
0.3708470762,
0.1027012691,
0.6209009886,
0.5216510892,
0.249085173,
-0.0291046519,
-0.0554188304,
0.8762351871,
-0.0499577075,
-0.4237140119,
-0.3784850836,
0.3984747827,
-0.1261391491,
-0.403888762,
0.5976536274,
0.3875611424,
1.1286325455,
0.0104610501,
0.213782981,
-0.141023621,
0.0734394491,
-0.4724106789,
0.9107512236,
-0.8576042056,
-0.0775523633,
-0.1951123476,
-0.699641943,
-0.6126468778,
0.76471138,
-0.3211905062,
-0.4891774058,
0.3513734043,
0.6846448779,
-0.4714795947,
-0.0501438715,
0.5573421717,
-0.0459887721,
0.1851738989,
0.480787456,
0.1540844291,
-0.1921550035,
0.0547669977,
-0.5272326469,
-0.2634417117,
-0.3675095141,
-0.6878848672,
-0.6321651936,
-0.7615749836,
-0.3714646101,
-0.0803487971,
0.0609003343,
1.2725707293,
0.8885156512,
-0.5747681856,
0.101485692,
0.2642320693,
-0.070742622,
-0.3251776099,
-0.1296541244,
0.3497995734,
-0.3844375014,
-0.6154476404,
0.2729589641,
0.4245169759,
0.1829319894,
-0.305986166,
-0.3038682342,
-0.3136215806,
-0.3179817498,
0.2700678408,
0.4153312743,
-0.686899364,
-0.4499728084,
-0.1274741739,
-0.3711431921,
0.338940084,
0.7286919355,
-0.7960979342,
0.901275456,
0.3187405467,
1.0766569376,
0.04816778,
0.1277446449,
0.9982883334,
-0.8685753942,
0.5248291492,
0.4241593182,
0.5426330566,
0.0696294978,
-0.3508149981,
0.3734228611,
0.1595426351,
-0.396974951,
-0.9440042973,
0.2995817661,
-1.1293094158,
0.0017617019,
0.6438429952,
-0.4316020906,
-0.2691062689,
0.1766578108,
0.0570831001,
0.191999197,
-0.1443575323,
0.3361721039,
0.138919428,
-0.0981201306,
-0.0352933258,
-0.0072157262,
0.6226527095,
0.6709966063,
-0.7067474723,
-0.1079326123,
0.8744758368,
0.1389950514,
0.3220461607,
0.6382002831,
-0.1844748259,
0.3792393506,
-0.1475382149,
0.0515615605,
-0.2109407187,
-0.3905152678,
-0.3217042983,
0.2014727741,
-0.4003706574,
-0.5040849447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03823v1
|
An Investigation into Misuse of Java Security APIs by Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T22:52:41 | 2024-04-04T22:52:41 |
Zahra Mousavi, Chadni Islam, Kristen Moore, Alsharif Abuadbba, Muhammad Ali Babar
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The increasing trend of using Large Language Models (LLMs) for code
generation raises the question of their capability to generate trustworthy
code. While many researchers are exploring the utility of code generation for
uncovering software vulnerabilities, one crucial but often overlooked aspect is
the security Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). APIs play an integral
role in upholding software security, yet effectively integrating security APIs
presents substantial challenges. This leads to inadvertent misuse by
developers, thereby exposing software to vulnerabilities. To overcome these
challenges, developers may seek assistance from LLMs. In this paper, we
systematically assess ChatGPT's trustworthiness in code generation for security
API use cases in Java. To conduct a thorough evaluation, we compile an
extensive collection of 48 programming tasks for 5 widely used security APIs.
We employ both automated and manual approaches to effectively detect security
API misuse in the code generated by ChatGPT for these tasks. Our findings are
concerning: around 70% of the code instances across 30 attempts per task
contain security API misuse, with 20 distinct misuse types identified.
Moreover, for roughly half of the tasks, this rate reaches 100%, indicating
that there is a long way to go before developers can rely on ChatGPT to
securely implement security API code.
|
[
-0.2487271428,
-0.5216572285,
0.3476420045,
0.0361246504,
-0.0964117497,
0.1456036568,
0.1893315613,
-0.4751499891,
-0.4518463314,
0.7157053947,
-0.2344676405,
-0.4777543545,
-0.8889637589,
-0.0783013925,
-0.4903112054,
0.9678385854,
0.1272530556,
-0.1679315418,
0.0796609893,
0.2076103836,
-0.5672239661,
-0.6086579561,
-0.7645792365,
-0.1290989071,
0.0607106164,
0.2546828389,
0.6893287897,
0.133561492,
0.6908427477,
0.3289320171,
0.0498315729,
0.0920426697,
-0.3815555573,
0.1882167459,
-0.0836713761,
-0.5862762332,
-0.3669282198,
-0.0871248767,
0.0408979505,
0.1782900989,
-0.0821086764,
0.493575722,
0.1903974861,
0.3224825561,
-0.5375869274,
0.4140120149,
-1.0127391815,
-0.1395513117,
-0.4635842443,
-0.5198360085,
-0.5798066258,
-0.2963390648,
0.181430459,
-0.1778638959,
-0.3134182692,
0.2934007943,
0.3211475015,
0.0517491028,
-0.2284521312,
-0.7564994693,
-0.528411448,
0.756520927,
-0.8005307317,
0.1217109859,
0.4324150383,
0.1634802818,
-0.7496985197,
-0.5490040779,
-0.4633482695,
-0.5899918079,
0.0377105027,
-0.1493285745,
-0.3795138896,
-0.086313948,
0.4898759127,
0.1820597351,
-0.8078430295,
-0.06379053,
-0.3144482374,
-0.337641269,
0.54033494,
0.0014153457,
0.8771383762,
-0.298434943,
-0.158372432,
-0.0255502481,
-0.885613203,
0.1583969146,
0.8547890186,
0.381786257,
-0.1249125451,
0.7202758789,
0.2492735833,
0.5270830393,
-0.6055160165,
-0.3466824591,
0.0257315356,
-0.090868324,
-0.380907625,
-0.1612058133,
0.660987854,
0.2635870278,
0.5929679871,
-0.1482909471,
-0.0606588945,
0.2202461809,
0.6546809673,
-0.6226736307,
-0.3773925006,
0.4897529185,
-0.4566747844,
-0.5183061361,
-0.1273530126,
-0.4128785431,
-0.5198928118,
0.0532520227,
-0.0748752728,
-0.6829396486,
-0.372130245,
-0.112887077,
-0.1897867024,
0.4108872712,
-0.100162968,
-0.2702798545,
-0.1933023036,
0.9678484201,
0.5761579871,
0.1361286938,
-0.2912748456,
-0.3533802032,
0.0710445717,
-0.2804596722,
0.3184707463,
-0.5662901998,
-0.6854479909,
0.2647886872,
-0.3070089221,
0.2204864621,
-0.3467682004,
0.6385748982,
-0.6493234038,
-0.1153130233,
0.0585633554,
-0.5047070384,
0.203795284,
0.3239307404,
-0.3156298399,
0.8533216119,
-0.0551148057,
-0.7603806853,
0.4318237603,
-0.6239980459,
-0.1641750038,
0.2176968604,
-0.2084847093,
-0.4589267969,
-0.0188865419,
0.0937048271,
0.4198044538,
0.0837708637,
-0.1914136857,
-0.5342012048,
-0.3885903656,
0.8311805725,
-0.4146432579,
0.932764709,
0.5201414227,
-0.1876038313,
-0.3778473735,
-0.5886383653,
0.0787595734,
0.2533405423,
-0.2036907375,
-0.6750972867,
-0.125410527,
-0.3034138381,
-0.0193254575,
0.2526936829,
-0.5618439913,
-0.0416679569,
-0.3136152029,
0.3645328283,
0.8766938448,
0.2793086171,
0.2454479635,
-0.068068698,
0.4680068195,
-0.1752590984,
0.5388146043,
-0.2669844925,
-0.6209239364,
-0.2491503507,
-0.2071540058,
0.0496374406,
0.6232806444,
-0.6830018759,
0.3001390696,
0.006902399,
-0.7409604192,
-0.1220983714,
0.4136962891,
0.7420784235,
0.1644881219,
-0.0317787118,
-0.2835766971,
-0.444708854,
-0.7200866342,
-0.4905317724,
-0.4610322416,
-0.1015304998,
0.3939271867,
0.4540167153,
-0.3175572753,
0.7831078768,
-0.2230032235,
0.3479041159,
0.021027416,
0.0898130834,
-0.013562968,
0.5667633414,
0.7232685685,
-0.481282562,
-0.2672761977,
-0.1791465431,
-0.7892699838,
-0.1130376533,
-0.0702937022,
-0.3592280447,
0.2250814438,
0.4929320514,
-0.632909894,
0.3907339275,
0.8552622795,
-0.2959264219,
0.5024627447,
-0.0390789025,
0.0532286912,
-1.0814840794,
0.1601837426,
-0.092637293,
-0.2313238084,
-0.4474110603,
0.680901587,
0.1546766609,
-0.600594461,
-0.479719758,
0.0106484881,
-0.3706424236,
-0.2884106636,
-0.2725868225,
0.1463698298,
-0.3999324739,
0.2547977269,
-0.6499053836,
1.0295052528,
0.55742836,
-0.4910495877,
0.3995980918,
0.1151964143,
-0.451895386,
0.4287438989,
-0.4630646408,
0.1924538165,
0.2116635591,
0.2906441689,
-1.1515974998,
-0.3035767674,
0.5309271812,
-0.676781714,
0.1575578451,
-0.5721621513,
-0.5582391024,
-0.5547202229,
-0.2712617218,
0.1438068151,
0.7354074121,
-0.4505867362,
0.3794516325,
0.4892072678,
-0.2848375738,
-0.8101896644,
-0.9007160068,
0.0797632486,
-0.2074362785,
-0.7712427378,
-0.3725193739,
0.2075141519,
-0.3617840111,
-0.0650182441,
-0.3359670937,
0.126681909,
0.2981624305,
0.6051396728,
0.4394624829,
-0.0059376438,
-0.1550462544,
-0.0914087519,
-0.1210369095,
0.3322529793,
-0.1818042099,
0.7224602699,
-0.1034519598,
-0.9238798618,
-0.3908441961,
0.2240101695,
0.608979702,
-0.252967149,
0.557986021,
0.3354803622,
0.0003289022,
-0.1999892592,
-0.4224885404,
0.0793867484,
-0.5290241241,
0.3185989261,
-0.383258462,
-0.8146149516,
0.69943434,
-0.2556316555,
0.511094749,
0.068743512,
0.4012991786,
0.111760363,
0.5746802092,
0.4018121958,
-0.2633841336,
0.4443958998,
0.0671567097,
0.6355366707,
-0.4700406194,
-0.0793954954,
-0.5684824586,
0.1384600103,
-0.8482013345,
-0.2493468225,
0.1576444954,
-0.0360038169,
-0.2630456984,
0.5674812198,
-0.5358716846,
0.5642855167,
0.50232476,
-0.0177841429,
0.272667706,
-0.0383110307,
0.2412390262,
0.3790757656,
-0.2666344047,
-0.7540771365,
1.5312999487,
0.5147311687,
0.8663176298,
0.4539884329,
0.9395766854,
0.4905537367,
0.1621567756,
-0.3627067506,
0.692615211,
-0.026301505,
-0.5413671136,
-0.1931895763,
-0.3905221522,
-1.0134317875,
-0.0988357589,
0.0165666621,
-0.8772562742,
-0.2237655669,
0.2845336497,
-0.3574143648,
0.0614480227,
-1.2222238779,
0.6194847226,
0.1228100955,
0.0016596128,
-0.165858224,
-0.2362000197,
0.7792422175,
-0.1772138774,
0.15588063,
-0.1113761067,
0.2014524639,
0.342966944,
-0.5775219798,
0.9496925473,
-0.3496954739,
-0.4756543934,
0.6450180411,
0.4250749648,
0.8456405997,
0.3756752312,
0.1564956009,
0.2454355955,
-0.0064172246,
-0.4357164502,
-0.3937752843,
0.8185040355,
-0.6250163913,
-0.5507390499,
-0.4644278586,
-0.3678047657,
-0.4062721729,
0.0123589886,
0.17204009,
0.4947043359,
0.1065529212,
-0.0291051865,
0.5987290144,
-0.6577608585,
0.4798896611,
0.1544306129,
-0.4788645804,
0.2025440037,
0.754373014,
-0.1725945473,
0.2707772255,
-0.211260289,
-0.1969774216,
-0.0160857122,
-0.7256647944,
-0.4747120738,
-0.1812437922,
-0.3654248416,
-0.3789785802,
-0.2568978369,
-0.5250495076,
-0.4188815653,
-0.0978608429,
-0.4526493847,
-0.0471905507,
0.4130325913,
0.0202518869,
0.4631505013,
0.2551300526,
0.2571465671,
0.4882549644,
-0.9513982534,
0.0430750884,
0.2996668816,
0.3299571872,
-0.053498175,
-0.3163098693,
0.0655422583,
-0.2318268418,
-0.020941291,
-0.637399435,
0.1880860478,
-0.5064142942,
0.6209504008,
0.155206129,
-0.0631700754,
0.4530268908,
-0.2294924259,
1.1489708424,
0.0478064343,
-0.8447678089,
0.5379315019,
-0.5806376338,
0.1848129928,
0.2402704954,
0.2193153799,
-0.2714550495,
-1.0536187887,
-0.6975374818,
-0.8912909031,
0.5577005744,
0.6263011098,
0.5529459715,
0.182967633,
0.3553828001,
0.1023761705,
0.0579188205,
-0.7161987424,
-0.317979008,
0.0279779527,
0.1531294584,
0.4834661186,
-0.5617579818,
-0.3181391358,
0.6043474078,
0.6769259572,
0.2172850221,
0.4606626332,
-0.2879858315,
-0.0220703781,
0.2040270269,
0.5282933712,
0.4542841911,
0.6623156667,
-0.0817504749,
0.0595961958,
-0.0158248655,
-0.7391270995,
-0.3038099706,
0.000202964,
-0.0683241189,
-0.244472146,
0.4628157914,
0.3879560232,
-0.202038914,
-0.9083695412,
0.6548980474,
-0.2140720487,
-0.0703585669,
-0.8286440372,
0.4968926311,
-0.1125155762,
0.4182135463,
0.3808342814,
0.3500148654,
0.0712638721,
-0.5823073983,
0.2324343175,
0.5958020091,
0.1598320752,
0.0392307788,
0.0736234039,
0.2766956985,
-0.1943353117,
0.5445523262,
-0.3810025454,
-0.2911777198,
0.4233931303,
0.4961793423,
0.799582541,
-0.2288869768,
0.0030866649,
0.1894890666,
0.5873030424,
0.0989791974,
0.2455072105,
0.1595776975,
-0.6647725701,
-0.6547320485,
-0.5240117311,
-0.5776435137,
0.3281186223,
-0.3241687119,
0.0259287003,
-0.6168872118,
-0.276188761,
-0.3060895205,
-0.2926278114,
-0.5392517447,
-0.2121904194,
0.3749209046,
0.7904325724,
-0.7892414331,
0.5882367492,
0.3580991924,
-0.2785995603,
-1.1152157784,
0.2337095141,
0.1672977358,
-1.1005978584,
0.5037472844,
-0.1431997269,
0.050619971,
-0.4860625565,
-0.5792512298,
-0.7565006018,
0.873069346,
0.3178181648,
-0.3874428272,
0.1706334949,
0.5508865714,
0.3127886653,
-0.0074071293,
0.2343914509,
0.5552083254,
0.3301813006,
-0.1052205414,
-0.8876170516,
0.1204883233,
-0.2131937444,
0.2798705399,
0.1478384882,
-0.5587102771,
0.6315402389,
0.2456072867,
-0.126078099,
0.1846793145,
0.2931270599,
0.6375465393,
0.2021516562,
0.3299245536,
0.2882472873,
0.7316786647,
0.060973309,
1.1218167543,
-0.5243448019,
0.079075031,
0.9215449095,
-0.1368119866,
0.675937295,
0.4897314906,
-0.2956668139,
0.2250306159,
0.3287832439,
-0.0754544139,
0.1812989116,
0.2527400255,
-0.2667287886,
-0.1148606315,
0.1930737197,
-0.5752120614,
0.7543573976,
0.2896855772,
-0.5035831928,
-0.266005367,
-0.0785980225,
0.3470247984,
-0.2160302848,
-0.305988729,
0.467887491,
0.2916761339,
-0.5522050261,
0.1455063522,
0.0585967675,
0.5651394725,
-0.6560204029,
0.1576599628,
-0.1690447479,
0.1290555298,
-0.2327006459,
-0.8779508471,
0.5012612343,
0.5831567049,
0.2728004158,
-0.1145312637,
0.9773910046,
0.1646971107,
-0.0719106793,
0.0220332053,
0.5103998184,
0.1994764507,
-0.0976860076,
-0.582597971,
0.3047413528,
0.2313352823,
-0.3508971632,
0.5545293689,
0.5418416262,
0.0950929075,
0.713522315,
1.0122566223,
0.0871586651,
0.3059770167,
-0.0582178012,
0.7021000385,
-0.2617340088,
-0.3924617469,
-1.1452283859,
0.3749457896,
-0.4120352268,
-0.259098947,
1.0903331041,
0.5648332834,
0.8460820317,
-0.2330837995,
1.1276469231,
-0.1236324012,
0.5202344656,
-0.5366136432,
0.6332318187,
-0.0202867761,
0.6040000916,
-0.5005092621,
-0.9909631014,
-0.2645778656,
0.3010928035,
-0.4673700929,
-0.0375532806,
0.5053158998,
1.0793147087,
-0.0901466832,
0.2831437588,
0.2753720284,
-0.029450275,
0.6605155468,
0.4198764861,
0.9783862829,
-0.3945782185,
1.0680636168,
0.0217004102,
-0.3581020832,
-0.1309010983,
-0.8138498068,
-0.8927117586,
-0.1284889579,
-0.2237689197,
-0.6189156771,
0.0349987596,
0.7752471566,
0.339379251,
-0.7172246575,
0.0677807555,
-0.2395915538,
-0.1604345888,
0.0781005397,
-0.2036547512,
0.01721224,
-0.5064920783,
-0.682695508,
0.1732052416,
0.2162878364,
0.0300234128,
-0.3532054722,
0.0443036035,
0.4341742992,
0.2822555304,
0.515057981,
0.5823240876,
-0.5694254637,
-0.5223067403,
-0.2628881633,
-0.5188686848,
-0.4886761308,
0.7937889099,
-0.1853325218,
0.1065201312,
0.4686872363,
0.9912105203,
0.152899906,
-0.1220348701,
0.4318843782,
-0.9216036797,
0.1564302444,
-0.1489816606,
0.4471986294,
0.0379874036,
-0.3707935214,
0.5708758831,
-0.0250919256,
-0.8243736029,
-0.8974665403,
0.3585717976,
-1.0552411079,
-0.2189341784,
1.2343200445,
-0.4693704844,
-0.3379592896,
-0.2483710498,
-0.3557581306,
0.0551833548,
-0.5476037264,
0.9066631794,
0.7537839413,
-0.2014567703,
-0.0474628545,
-0.5796341896,
0.5335221887,
0.175297752,
-0.7393862605,
0.3471471667,
0.4028951526,
0.2981084287,
0.3368085027,
0.577685535,
-0.4186786711,
0.1637155563,
0.4823825955,
0.0910936743,
-0.1830753088,
0.1475803852,
0.1519114077,
0.2883571982,
0.4573423862,
-0.264932394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03820v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03820v2
|
CantTalkAboutThis: Aligning Language Models to Stay on Topic in Dialogues
| 2024-04-04T22:31:58 | 2024-06-21T13:57:11 |
Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Traian Rebedea, Shaona Ghosh, Jiaqi Zeng, Christopher Parisien
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in instruction-tuning datasets have predominantly focused
on specific tasks like mathematical or logical reasoning. There has been a
notable gap in data designed for aligning language models to maintain topic
relevance in conversations - a critical aspect for deploying chatbots to
production. We introduce the CantTalkAboutThis dataset to help language models
remain focused on the subject at hand during task-oriented interactions. It
consists of synthetic dialogues on a wide range of conversation topics from
different domains. These dialogues are interspersed with distractor turns that
intentionally divert the chatbot from the predefined topic. Fine-tuning
language models on this dataset helps make them resilient to deviating from the
role assigned and improves their ability to maintain topical coherence compared
to general-purpose instruction-tuned LLMs like GPT-4-turbo and
Mixtral-Instruct. Additionally, preliminary observations suggest that training
models on this dataset also enhance their performance on fine-grained
instruction following tasks, including safety alignment.
|
[
-0.01204326,
-0.8755173087,
0.3141235411,
0.0469500124,
-0.1433238536,
0.1434700936,
-0.3709037304,
0.0117181074,
-0.1181786731,
0.7593821883,
-0.7398738265,
-0.4542724192,
-0.5426903963,
-0.4284681082,
-0.4335691929,
1.1926263571,
0.2020465434,
0.1119839996,
-0.60612005,
-0.0280565266,
-0.9913643599,
-0.3738754988,
-0.6475438476,
-0.3926609457,
0.3168368936,
0.7698190808,
0.7741187215,
0.6558374166,
0.6684727669,
0.3433810472,
-0.0525058284,
0.1308932304,
-0.7315388918,
0.6559374332,
-0.3601561487,
-0.4839566648,
-0.3988947272,
-0.323115319,
0.5017474294,
0.7476280928,
-0.4381859004,
-0.0957911164,
0.2481528819,
0.4221045673,
-0.3837067187,
0.2698821723,
-0.8336141109,
-0.2019421011,
-0.0847171023,
0.0050039385,
-0.4173989892,
-0.3299442828,
0.1652356386,
-0.6099563241,
0.2840155363,
-0.0345986895,
1.0835186243,
0.541862309,
-0.2127277404,
-0.1684965491,
-0.7542482018,
1.0134683847,
-0.6353411674,
0.1925349236,
0.6822214127,
0.3469251692,
-0.4339042008,
-0.3342783451,
-0.1991194636,
-0.0619638152,
-0.1123383865,
0.1317881048,
0.0313887,
0.0739549175,
0.1609648615,
0.272141099,
-0.4172396958,
0.1366203129,
-0.2493133247,
-0.3415637016,
0.572217226,
0.4184698462,
0.3299129605,
-0.0457504131,
0.0684483796,
0.0155062461,
-0.6347749233,
-0.055131752,
0.3064373434,
0.5846877098,
-0.1838537157,
0.6069546342,
-0.4422350526,
0.729429543,
0.3082764745,
-0.1107051894,
-0.1457888782,
-0.5946936011,
0.0302031171,
0.0818068907,
0.4593602717,
0.3724636137,
0.4016204774,
-0.123338744,
0.1040158719,
0.1478157192,
0.6603619456,
-0.7673534155,
-0.4583885074,
0.1056959182,
-0.023561202,
-0.2462242246,
-0.2492160499,
-0.5458503366,
-0.1348502189,
-0.5842344165,
0.2437562197,
-0.320952028,
-0.1794641167,
-0.0081492309,
0.2114969939,
0.2549335659,
0.3974081576,
-1.2259352207,
0.508874774,
0.9707756639,
0.7097157836,
-0.2048097998,
0.1255641878,
-0.6854091883,
0.214056924,
-0.3752690256,
0.7805172205,
-0.7950705886,
-0.2044044286,
-0.013858024,
0.1677228212,
-0.1523158252,
-0.5549154282,
0.3575697541,
-0.1979320645,
0.4053506851,
-0.0847522393,
-0.6029682755,
0.0169803873,
0.3806360364,
-0.3094990849,
0.9384625554,
-0.1347159147,
-0.5005323887,
0.2003582418,
-0.4967259169,
-0.3390888572,
-0.1128576994,
-0.3725602031,
-0.701128304,
0.1064566076,
0.2036473602,
0.431379199,
-0.2792508006,
0.6253350973,
-0.2704355121,
-0.1592612267,
0.2288200557,
-0.1644843668,
0.5101144314,
0.1172591746,
-0.008498502,
0.3742541373,
-0.4673882723,
-0.0107499165,
-0.1107734293,
-0.0158015806,
-0.2126668841,
0.3108353019,
-0.1783582866,
0.024882514,
-0.0012878259,
-0.4449949265,
0.1759643406,
-0.3174108565,
0.4353117347,
0.5361218452,
0.0280456599,
0.4404473603,
-0.3967325389,
0.51085186,
0.0195357855,
-0.0306003634,
0.0449864417,
-0.6162550449,
-1.0567374229,
-0.2177173793,
0.4833997488,
0.6978328824,
-0.4631029665,
0.4766625762,
-0.4016257226,
-0.4965078533,
-0.4926116765,
0.1335489899,
0.2733929455,
0.6743343472,
0.0503214896,
-0.3381329179,
-0.2748363614,
-1.0175024271,
0.0590926819,
0.1078424677,
-0.0618358776,
0.1859851778,
0.1434783787,
-0.0006815179,
1.0712863207,
-0.4386129975,
0.0062615555,
-0.2781836092,
0.0862114727,
0.2336335778,
0.9070097804,
0.1859253049,
-0.7337287068,
-0.6091287136,
-0.044407621,
-0.6893555522,
-0.1731485873,
-0.0517897569,
-0.5487498641,
-0.0107071865,
0.550915122,
-0.7143799663,
0.4171185791,
0.3790504336,
-0.0808288977,
0.1316190362,
0.0009880344,
0.0991264582,
-1.2466443777,
-0.0622350238,
-0.1214037165,
-0.4149120748,
-0.9216681123,
-0.2628355324,
-0.0571066141,
-0.5238278508,
-0.3015511036,
0.3574186862,
-0.1516102999,
0.0268503129,
-0.4604335427,
0.2957576811,
-0.0579494536,
0.4730885923,
0.2996620238,
0.8399794698,
0.7080563903,
-0.6308864355,
0.097609818,
0.686000824,
-0.52336514,
0.6099415421,
-0.6760843992,
0.2910856009,
0.0616016798,
0.0846227184,
-1.0751963854,
-0.4625028372,
0.302188009,
-0.1701753736,
0.5568643808,
-0.2222668827,
-0.3596786559,
0.0833778605,
0.1118017137,
0.2073079646,
0.4006923139,
-0.0058379988,
0.5541695356,
0.5666013956,
-0.6772569418,
-0.5144683719,
-0.4707049131,
-0.1949683726,
-0.3099060953,
-0.6669948697,
0.4147392511,
-0.1523839831,
-0.192810595,
-0.1199598759,
-0.2886209786,
-0.1068747938,
0.2886833847,
0.3675815165,
0.4210717082,
-0.2430475056,
0.3749616742,
0.2777279913,
-0.2864496112,
-0.2989738882,
-0.0727093518,
0.564381361,
0.0927141681,
-0.3365009427,
-0.538808167,
0.3487790525,
0.2527923286,
0.0807015896,
0.8272840381,
0.2594323158,
-0.3235825896,
0.1822554767,
-0.5178559422,
-0.3830386996,
-0.5036385655,
0.5119739175,
-0.1812716275,
-0.9505102634,
0.486394912,
-0.0341341719,
0.1690565944,
0.3008769155,
0.6829311252,
-0.2129859179,
0.8749750853,
0.8258888721,
-0.1255325079,
0.6790595651,
0.0455849767,
0.4734668434,
-0.5940203667,
-0.1354487538,
-0.4525719285,
-0.2715610266,
-0.6116167903,
-0.2596703172,
-0.0034075917,
0.0893794,
-0.2586225271,
0.4475975633,
-0.4575763345,
0.7053815722,
0.316521734,
0.1437107474,
-0.0124563649,
0.0616855919,
0.2266371846,
-0.0291785803,
-0.9093584418,
-0.6869968176,
0.9838245511,
0.1982657462,
0.7354170084,
0.0288787037,
0.3992904425,
0.1608678102,
0.246626094,
-0.5797855258,
0.7125540376,
-0.2100709528,
-0.8390915394,
-0.3129392862,
-0.289537251,
-0.9248157144,
-0.0279294532,
-0.0285720453,
-0.9990428686,
-0.1843034923,
0.3130256534,
-0.3352409005,
-0.1317309588,
-0.794955194,
1.1736872196,
-0.2357597649,
-0.583363831,
-0.4918718934,
-0.6875852346,
0.0643722266,
0.067779541,
-0.0376907215,
-0.570196867,
0.1875151545,
0.5785648823,
-0.4581508338,
1.10645473,
0.0897432342,
-0.1388306618,
0.3143393993,
-0.0333855189,
0.2380468249,
-0.0330611207,
-0.0081122369,
0.0141650839,
-0.1697855592,
-0.6275712252,
-0.5815063119,
0.7776423097,
-0.7634961605,
-1.0588597059,
-0.0775564611,
-0.9102239013,
-0.3240222633,
-0.0482790507,
0.0763427317,
0.3989163041,
-0.1428294629,
0.3934521973,
0.7504169345,
-0.0574608557,
0.0463223234,
0.3095530272,
-0.1228896827,
-0.1877672523,
1.1111098528,
-0.0107318964,
0.6241342425,
0.5262855887,
0.0947081521,
-0.0705859661,
-0.4205216765,
-0.1864485592,
-0.0140555063,
-0.7975077629,
-0.3917376697,
-0.4981502593,
-0.4487227499,
-0.3368510902,
-0.0830522627,
-0.4210530519,
-0.6816783547,
-0.3037745357,
-0.0706043988,
0.5603194237,
0.4810369313,
0.1833363622,
0.5912830234,
-0.5264915228,
0.1865916252,
0.3549678326,
0.2522361577,
-0.3401512206,
-0.842856586,
-0.3429162502,
0.1506016701,
-0.6341666579,
-0.5999694467,
0.2154228836,
0.4457361102,
0.627016902,
0.1019986868,
-0.1466770619,
0.6435104609,
-0.3964354694,
0.6658120751,
0.0059209983,
-0.8945012689,
0.8609520793,
-0.5956557989,
0.6243699789,
0.6478714943,
0.4171456397,
-0.6345366836,
-0.6281996965,
-0.3245139718,
-0.7496669888,
1.0223470926,
0.5159255266,
0.3216462135,
0.1347849518,
0.2619340122,
0.2825336158,
0.3609087467,
-0.5755057335,
-0.0168185756,
-0.388260901,
-0.7095754743,
-0.0561441928,
-0.0481977388,
-0.2350502163,
-0.2802226245,
0.6601320505,
-0.145437941,
0.4483556747,
-0.4508548677,
-0.0572049506,
-0.1239578202,
0.2248795331,
0.8033169508,
0.593229115,
-0.1268161386,
-0.1301910579,
0.1001305655,
-0.3875427842,
0.1125992462,
0.0265639853,
-0.0424574874,
-0.3119870126,
0.1397273391,
0.9860396385,
0.3284766972,
-0.6814001203,
0.0960223675,
-0.0376978628,
-0.0564104542,
-0.1063133627,
0.548291266,
0.2725823224,
0.3210054934,
-0.0754279867,
0.0810871571,
-0.3254311979,
-0.6601474881,
0.1915718764,
0.3380019963,
-0.3636789918,
-0.1839837283,
0.4586746395,
0.3792486191,
-0.70592767,
0.9849260449,
0.2546992004,
-0.5107062459,
0.6476834416,
0.3703125417,
0.8095576763,
-0.1538926214,
0.0179928802,
0.2915061712,
-0.0437963866,
-0.0423636734,
0.1257576197,
-0.1359958053,
-0.9441684484,
-0.4561252594,
-0.3179197609,
-0.7164024711,
0.140543133,
-0.5647405386,
0.3978892565,
-0.3593547642,
-0.3435384035,
-0.029506404,
-0.2024932355,
-0.5772320628,
0.0425499193,
0.1282698065,
0.3475081027,
-0.8629899025,
1.0261316299,
0.3477642834,
-0.1846002936,
-0.4205351174,
0.0868751109,
-0.0023234833,
-0.5743051171,
0.6373665929,
0.3170244098,
0.0451239347,
-0.1580445021,
-0.6715408564,
-1.0317943096,
0.9396303892,
0.5180079937,
-0.8946644664,
0.1731605977,
0.3092111945,
0.5324645638,
-0.5644957423,
0.0900967792,
0.4941644967,
0.0657293126,
-0.013543278,
-0.8909059763,
-0.2203723341,
-0.3871096671,
-0.2334762067,
0.3011527061,
-0.784802556,
0.3395244777,
0.1843934655,
-0.0728730336,
0.2113558948,
0.6127560139,
0.2418129742,
0.0977146551,
0.362603873,
0.4151161909,
0.776653111,
-0.4484431148,
0.828332603,
-0.3149530292,
0.0657652766,
1.3238700628,
-0.3507824838,
0.7566473484,
0.4059452415,
0.1460498422,
0.5486719012,
0.7191826105,
0.0732631311,
0.8156149387,
0.1628500819,
0.0174579751,
-0.6922898889,
-0.2563220859,
-0.1077759713,
0.5064539909,
0.7242459655,
0.1192246974,
0.0903096795,
0.0603364184,
-0.2154315859,
0.1414458156,
-0.0837692395,
0.8731240034,
0.0129641918,
-0.9691167474,
0.4562776685,
-0.3969968855,
0.2450772077,
-0.7161177993,
-0.0102866273,
-0.3406127989,
0.3221809566,
0.0521860756,
-0.675399065,
0.5078789592,
0.032341741,
-0.2461332381,
-0.2637591362,
0.877681911,
-0.8257537484,
-0.5444986224,
-0.0642328411,
0.2113793343,
0.102238439,
0.3073733747,
-0.7879431844,
0.2550725639,
0.0019147327,
0.0162834525,
0.4240988195,
0.4443857372,
-0.1675871611,
0.8755155802,
0.16800192,
-0.3019931614,
-0.1003556848,
0.176372692,
0.8600723147,
-0.5189784169,
-0.3156590164,
-0.5642880797,
0.7412645817,
-0.2344954163,
-0.2661537528,
0.6607948542,
0.4788264036,
0.7798109651,
-0.003169199,
0.4912163913,
0.1124175638,
0.5756602287,
-0.6231440902,
0.543513298,
-0.5171119571,
0.2655837536,
-0.066783689,
-0.8772950768,
-0.0952463225,
0.7009441853,
-0.6084503531,
0.0262319762,
0.4046751559,
1.0302785635,
-0.3357582986,
0.0479447581,
0.3689020276,
-0.0559576191,
0.2357136756,
0.1744553149,
0.9493582249,
-0.357258141,
0.4886215627,
-0.2771334052,
0.1761036813,
-0.3425105512,
-0.8711583614,
-1.0311764479,
-0.4347402751,
-0.8379445076,
-0.0017406237,
0.2825727165,
0.8836040497,
0.9261170626,
-1.1643688679,
-0.5227341056,
-0.4122552276,
0.0128978146,
-0.080189921,
-0.1932757944,
0.0447906516,
-0.6955461502,
-0.6729041338,
0.3171268702,
0.2757390141,
0.013633485,
0.0158777796,
0.0585452542,
-0.3830827177,
0.2136900276,
0.2409944683,
0.0396732241,
-0.7436876893,
-0.4171395898,
0.1066537425,
-0.1013041586,
0.3302943408,
0.9126699567,
-0.3596051037,
0.4710994959,
0.3829369247,
0.7599553466,
0.5809546709,
0.0573347993,
1.0124572515,
-0.919166863,
0.3707536459,
0.2539226413,
0.1450845897,
0.6460625529,
-0.2337162793,
0.5021258593,
0.0972100496,
-0.781055212,
-0.7291153669,
0.2166212648,
-0.9775080085,
-0.162855953,
0.8097538352,
-0.062411651,
-0.0581529923,
-0.2305338085,
-0.2218544632,
0.4433627427,
-0.4834050238,
0.8716870546,
1.0287951231,
-0.0480904989,
-0.2544939518,
-0.6368656754,
0.4804679453,
1.0070463419,
-0.8961969614,
0.2903352082,
0.2971573472,
0.1616774201,
0.1142208427,
0.3307194114,
0.3116952479,
0.2064264119,
-0.0406922288,
-0.1875400245,
0.4323672056,
-0.3889696598,
-0.1392017156,
-0.2220203727,
0.0497265458,
-0.2896490693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03818v1
|
PRobELM: Plausibility Ranking Evaluation for Language Models
| 2024-04-04T21:57:11 | 2024-04-04T21:57:11 |
Zhangdie Yuan, Chenxi Whitehouse, Eric Chamoun, Rami Aly, Andreas Vlachos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces PRobELM (Plausibility Ranking Evaluation for Language
Models), a benchmark designed to assess language models' ability to discern
more plausible from less plausible scenarios through their parametric
knowledge. While benchmarks such as TruthfulQA emphasise factual accuracy or
truthfulness, and others such as COPA explore plausible scenarios without
explicitly incorporating world knowledge, PRobELM seeks to bridge this gap by
evaluating models' capabilities to prioritise plausible scenarios that leverage
world knowledge over less plausible alternatives. This design allows us to
assess the potential of language models for downstream use cases such as
literature-based discovery where the focus is on identifying information that
is likely but not yet known. Our benchmark is constructed from a dataset
curated from Wikidata edit histories, tailored to align the temporal bounds of
the training data for the evaluated models. PRobELM facilitates the evaluation
of language models across multiple prompting types, including statement, text
completion, and question-answering. Experiments with 10 models of various sizes
and architectures on the relationship between model scales, training recency,
and plausibility performance, reveal that factual accuracy does not directly
correlate with plausibility performance and that up-to-date training data
enhances plausibility assessment across different model architectures.
|
[
-0.2412265092,
-0.4654947519,
0.7496947646,
0.074810192,
0.0462891236,
0.1002628729,
-0.2531423569,
-0.0503926873,
-0.4689357877,
0.186914593,
-0.2310357541,
-0.502928257,
-0.4327590168,
-0.1126386896,
-0.6146660447,
0.8526274562,
0.1777624786,
-0.1174741536,
-0.6710895896,
-0.329548955,
-0.1954315454,
-0.4175131321,
-0.3804704249,
-0.1063581184,
0.4241472483,
0.2288983464,
0.6526744962,
0.4105042219,
0.4409866333,
0.1850390136,
-0.1763097793,
0.1092654467,
-0.6679013968,
0.2368499041,
-0.1861438602,
-0.4825988412,
-0.5156880021,
0.2793544233,
0.9378408194,
0.9109876156,
-0.1437160224,
0.3137134314,
0.0627911314,
0.4818683565,
-0.5624292493,
-0.0084431637,
-0.7575879693,
-0.3433133066,
-0.1746577919,
-0.1064284444,
-0.6320063472,
-0.6801330447,
0.4322039187,
-0.4442372322,
0.5475389957,
0.4059942961,
0.7268880606,
-0.0345164835,
-0.4538781643,
-0.0884471908,
-0.4905026555,
0.750295639,
-0.9072304368,
0.5683377385,
0.4438432157,
0.5983266234,
-0.0818379372,
-1.1050167084,
-0.5136823058,
-0.6865595579,
-0.1742731929,
0.0906916782,
-0.0685185418,
-0.0765665993,
0.586959362,
0.5260689855,
-0.7820277214,
-0.1118247584,
-0.3398275077,
-0.4238319993,
0.6060013771,
0.3192071915,
0.1550511718,
0.1710813195,
-0.3353825212,
-0.0467988066,
-0.7533566952,
0.3269663453,
0.4338260591,
0.441593647,
-0.2172840983,
0.391001761,
-0.3953200877,
0.77400738,
-0.3298407495,
-0.1750187725,
0.2764643729,
-0.2859212756,
-0.1076307297,
-0.2851796448,
0.496430248,
0.4076938927,
-0.2150712907,
-0.3619141281,
-0.2193599641,
0.0307842977,
0.2409371883,
-0.7449403405,
-0.3674969673,
0.212829262,
-0.5925915837,
-0.2741550207,
0.2062954158,
-0.8243731856,
-0.641053617,
-0.0124675082,
0.4937677085,
-0.2533524334,
-0.5869443417,
-0.0193374138,
-0.2304486185,
0.2288958281,
0.2779230177,
-0.2878031433,
0.317091018,
0.6871914268,
0.7661961317,
-0.3103866577,
-0.6028303504,
-0.7012631893,
-0.1357483268,
-0.4709683955,
0.7937156558,
-0.6895961761,
-0.4686191678,
0.0592278242,
0.0450564921,
-0.2706659734,
-0.5491533875,
1.1438196898,
-0.6419531703,
0.3704802692,
-0.4673471153,
-1.0093722343,
-0.416270256,
0.2312097102,
-0.8427641392,
1.0846441984,
0.2632638812,
-0.9233739376,
0.5252284408,
-0.6284563541,
-0.3886396587,
0.2039653361,
0.1706360281,
-0.2829510868,
0.0611724481,
-0.1585208327,
0.1993063241,
-0.6656028628,
0.666514039,
-0.3713845313,
-0.366201669,
0.3314307928,
-0.6419889331,
0.8026554585,
0.1884738803,
-0.1488277167,
0.2327561975,
-0.6886813641,
-0.0096386531,
0.1240783259,
-0.46991539,
-0.2673649788,
-0.0235108789,
-0.0573551245,
0.2099264264,
0.3319118023,
-0.4072963595,
0.0337916352,
-0.5958400369,
0.2519077063,
0.3734939098,
-0.0707614943,
0.3893582225,
-0.7196497917,
0.6578909159,
-0.2200061381,
0.2681461871,
-0.1021021232,
-0.5908073783,
-0.8890962601,
-0.1786039621,
0.4330104291,
0.3407051861,
-0.5040441751,
0.007837153,
-0.2230159342,
-0.8413202167,
-0.5498474836,
0.009652474,
0.5225550532,
0.9781184196,
0.225232169,
0.0176640674,
-0.6864318848,
-1.0229016542,
-0.5837477446,
-0.5035178065,
-0.0194991399,
0.2207567245,
0.3429023623,
0.1035724506,
0.9988574386,
-0.2538390756,
0.1953801662,
-0.2240833193,
0.2689664066,
0.283652842,
0.1885833591,
0.4769459963,
-0.9682239294,
-0.2717008591,
-0.1974015534,
-0.633002758,
-0.0952994823,
0.2641908526,
0.1953154355,
0.1850485951,
0.3158404231,
-0.408326745,
0.4851209223,
0.4290017188,
-0.3014250398,
0.8145065308,
-0.2902835011,
0.2296815962,
-0.5523648858,
0.4961010814,
-0.3048836291,
-0.2391804904,
-0.8684194684,
0.0897540525,
0.3106131554,
-0.0417405106,
-0.5407897234,
1.0465166569,
-0.367462635,
-0.1830321997,
-0.009892988,
0.1446903795,
0.2936941683,
0.0728079677,
-0.0041689337,
0.9328816533,
0.6291797757,
-0.7460207343,
0.04711188,
0.1059442386,
-0.7279702425,
0.3058304787,
-0.5560827255,
0.0940326452,
0.221725449,
0.0104793403,
-1.1086825132,
-0.0463518016,
-0.2008997947,
-0.5144102573,
-0.0045869621,
-0.0541054085,
-0.3400509357,
-0.3582417965,
-0.2634825408,
0.3008944392,
0.514442265,
-0.4182615578,
0.5626430511,
0.2569782138,
-0.0848216191,
-0.4010026753,
-0.2565999329,
-0.0968887582,
-0.4881216586,
-0.4458013773,
0.2160318047,
-0.3528909981,
-0.4237137437,
-0.1968131959,
-0.0078707132,
-0.0551053174,
0.3790935278,
0.2690967023,
0.3760559261,
-0.285043031,
0.0728947073,
-0.1667784452,
-0.0101938434,
0.1591645628,
0.0787074044,
0.3958669603,
-0.3948014975,
-0.3705468178,
-0.0465802997,
0.1160279587,
0.6070729494,
-0.2702296376,
0.7034795284,
0.4573282599,
-0.350533843,
-0.0260765553,
-0.6704846025,
-0.2251232713,
-0.4262745976,
0.1442249864,
-0.4312070608,
-0.69620502,
0.6698805094,
-0.1052647084,
0.2245071977,
0.4693707228,
0.5832747817,
0.0951040462,
0.9301376343,
0.4239227474,
0.2255699933,
0.0458244197,
-0.0490478538,
0.2234083563,
-0.8197052479,
-0.2974477112,
-0.5565191507,
0.1190863624,
-0.4024665654,
-0.5089271665,
0.1702875793,
0.0713465214,
-0.1871978343,
0.1593210846,
-0.1480600089,
0.0991366208,
0.6984787583,
-0.3062898517,
0.4592521489,
-0.2844456136,
-0.5687385201,
0.0432629511,
-0.8415184021,
-0.7532047629,
1.2142564058,
0.2758984864,
0.3026508391,
0.2346350104,
0.1330293566,
0.4483586848,
0.5822058916,
-0.5788891315,
0.5790501237,
0.1861050129,
-0.9080028534,
-0.3763893545,
-0.1920500845,
-0.8681814671,
0.1859849393,
-0.2323219925,
-0.5736291409,
0.1459557116,
-0.0719282702,
-0.3111078739,
0.0396379642,
-0.6795835495,
0.8464604616,
-0.1039249673,
-0.3900789917,
-0.0478013344,
-0.6483643651,
0.5257077217,
0.0187049229,
0.3462111652,
-0.160819307,
-0.089131102,
0.8602613807,
-0.2048925161,
0.6628144383,
-0.2533264756,
0.1130884364,
0.1338389665,
0.3384189308,
0.3980654776,
0.0934434384,
-0.4993505776,
0.0423879251,
0.2622458041,
-0.3580547571,
-0.5686678886,
0.5587145686,
-0.5307290554,
-0.7710591555,
-0.339219749,
-0.5901854038,
-0.6720527411,
0.3172565997,
0.3180431724,
0.5695085526,
-0.4124481082,
0.2309878618,
0.4242357314,
-0.3120565414,
0.2965748906,
0.8853647709,
-0.4029427171,
-0.2480734587,
0.9759200215,
0.0441494845,
0.122008197,
0.3932200074,
0.3421599269,
-0.763252914,
-0.8091692328,
-0.113778986,
0.1739889383,
-0.7626689672,
-0.0247956924,
-0.5310206413,
-0.378723532,
-0.4728862345,
0.1363619566,
-0.1703204811,
-0.2609446943,
0.0127941668,
-0.2234609276,
0.2157507837,
0.4648524225,
0.2497468591,
0.0329539999,
-0.5233519077,
0.0702767745,
0.2607056499,
0.3449878991,
0.088458091,
-0.9171356559,
-0.0493806787,
-0.0819295347,
0.0962768421,
-0.756082654,
0.4103449285,
0.2613126636,
1.0836744308,
0.2192912847,
0.5179115534,
0.3550975621,
-0.3411651552,
0.7141262293,
-0.180755496,
-0.8766798973,
0.4954009652,
-0.4378502071,
0.1347958893,
0.6069789529,
0.398088336,
-0.2822427452,
-0.462854296,
-0.817609787,
-0.6487139463,
0.4938277602,
0.1610687375,
-0.1639519483,
0.1681123972,
0.1137494072,
0.4574606121,
0.3708966076,
-0.4308792353,
-0.244072184,
-0.0973029956,
-0.1198680922,
-0.2016277611,
-0.5001260638,
-0.2168701291,
-0.2670708895,
0.6062188745,
-0.0517968126,
0.0789087564,
0.084769018,
-0.2677423656,
0.3101575375,
0.2564104795,
0.7145615816,
1.2199891806,
-0.3928505182,
0.1909032911,
0.3094423115,
-0.3883345425,
-0.0506561249,
0.2340912819,
-0.2366570681,
-0.0081652449,
0.6269874573,
0.9790173173,
0.1204384044,
-0.8960691094,
0.6212999225,
-0.3406936228,
-0.1704358011,
-0.1820130944,
0.1579717994,
0.1674367934,
0.2359994054,
0.5089304447,
-0.1862016916,
0.4221976101,
-0.2769276202,
0.2387177795,
0.3640958965,
-0.2429059148,
-0.3889255822,
0.6073492169,
0.156965211,
-0.372096777,
0.4342006743,
-0.169301644,
-0.5087273717,
0.5610980988,
0.3297896087,
0.5362250805,
-0.3209451139,
0.3602391779,
0.4796431959,
0.3290793002,
-0.0011553151,
0.1509520411,
0.0629913583,
-0.67832762,
-0.1125220805,
-0.6614017487,
-0.617847681,
0.4235083759,
-0.7676091194,
0.3953109384,
-0.315320313,
-0.0691279247,
-0.0172669366,
0.3002070189,
-0.7275363803,
0.2965612411,
-0.1882062852,
1.2932884693,
-1.0010455847,
0.9825878739,
0.7537147999,
-0.0867514685,
-0.8023700714,
0.1052943245,
-0.0052283271,
-0.6023865342,
0.4399986267,
0.1729330868,
-0.0078004482,
0.012012233,
-0.1813609749,
-0.7890288234,
1.1789910793,
0.6716194749,
-0.372577548,
0.2300296426,
-0.1882316023,
0.5776363611,
-0.3718903661,
0.4562324882,
0.7443113923,
0.5397625566,
0.1394121796,
-0.9207966328,
0.2008210868,
-0.429889977,
-0.0016101305,
-0.2982306778,
-0.4359097481,
0.7560563087,
-0.2116542459,
-0.3839004636,
0.153761819,
0.5268395543,
0.5657628775,
0.6814308763,
0.6095367074,
0.2513415813,
1.1508929729,
-0.0472396016,
1.1122374535,
-0.2506761253,
0.3917813003,
1.2416031361,
-0.543110311,
0.9318352342,
0.2501620054,
-0.4935734868,
0.3797967136,
0.7779697776,
0.1218048632,
0.7140893936,
-0.1043741554,
-0.0992432088,
-0.3420050144,
-0.1347132623,
-0.5304355621,
0.3659110963,
0.2832686603,
-0.1714493483,
-0.2522689402,
0.0268930625,
-0.1827726215,
0.0917932093,
-0.0149679091,
0.5066094995,
-0.1834235042,
-0.8116308451,
0.7415958643,
-0.152487725,
0.2885284424,
-0.4245101511,
0.0678583533,
-0.5340788364,
-0.1316572577,
-0.0829970092,
-0.793971777,
0.3058461547,
-0.0249519851,
-0.2752705514,
0.0832492933,
0.8665301204,
-0.2407247275,
-0.4469333291,
0.2673498988,
0.7052078247,
0.2420491427,
-0.034763597,
-0.7076493502,
0.1619300544,
-0.1270475835,
-0.3754068613,
0.3163050711,
0.2519232035,
-0.0890389308,
0.932418406,
0.7328460217,
0.0667889714,
-0.0116839446,
0.2225901186,
0.8215229511,
-0.4236745238,
-0.481654495,
-0.7037991881,
0.4806839228,
-0.1905836165,
-0.2456621826,
1.024273634,
0.8282582164,
0.4300037324,
0.0840998292,
0.8614803553,
-0.0268349405,
1.040645957,
-0.3795206547,
0.8510385752,
-0.5294088125,
0.4903611839,
0.0112533234,
-0.7195629478,
-0.1694130898,
0.3642968237,
-0.7259458899,
0.0994708613,
0.7463183403,
0.8722765446,
0.0338623896,
0.162493065,
0.7186319232,
0.3692902029,
0.0858739763,
0.2952276468,
1.179418087,
-0.1527774036,
0.4665239155,
-0.1228143051,
-0.234279111,
-0.4201283753,
-1.0778769255,
-1.0330848694,
-0.9435663819,
-0.2552564144,
-0.2059163898,
0.0011497433,
0.3331334293,
0.6883827448,
-0.9279038906,
-0.0801632181,
-0.0066894223,
0.2373413593,
-0.3205067217,
-0.273288846,
0.4598002434,
-0.2299341559,
-0.6159353852,
0.6300418973,
0.2118941844,
-0.1659564674,
-0.302352488,
-0.2354759276,
-0.2854734361,
0.0622027107,
0.391952455,
0.3459842205,
-0.9672967792,
-0.1946452111,
0.0730612203,
-0.0379286744,
-0.1094760969,
0.7083110809,
-1.032428503,
0.5002785325,
0.568555057,
0.4959116578,
0.3429210186,
-0.0536682941,
0.6480273008,
-0.6003683209,
0.1365984827,
0.3749731779,
0.3437544405,
0.597853303,
-0.1109780371,
0.5226890445,
0.0934396684,
-0.5274156928,
-1.3113135099,
0.0730479062,
-0.7997958064,
-0.1968071759,
1.0920200348,
-0.5237539411,
0.0185276065,
-0.3688171208,
-0.0567800663,
0.1312402189,
-0.1628890038,
0.5888752341,
0.8111454248,
0.0434923023,
-0.2536428571,
-0.9700532556,
0.6672202945,
0.3585284948,
-0.6903222203,
0.3332945108,
0.3078264594,
0.4449267983,
-0.027631579,
0.4195069969,
0.0402341709,
0.2824366391,
-0.0203256346,
-0.4113426208,
-0.1472849548,
-0.2635123134,
-0.3163124621,
0.3151368797,
0.5595667958,
0.172413066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04302v1
|
CBR-RAG: Case-Based Reasoning for Retrieval Augmented Generation in LLMs for Legal Question Answering
| 2024-04-04T21:47:43 | 2024-04-04T21:47:43 |
Nirmalie Wiratunga, Ramitha Abeyratne, Lasal Jayawardena, Kyle Martin, Stewart Massie, Ikechukwu Nkisi-Orji, Ruvan Weerasinghe, Anne Liret, Bruno Fleisch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) enhances Large Language Model (LLM)
output by providing prior knowledge as context to input. This is beneficial for
knowledge-intensive and expert reliant tasks, including legal
question-answering, which require evidence to validate generated text outputs.
We highlight that Case-Based Reasoning (CBR) presents key opportunities to
structure retrieval as part of the RAG process in an LLM. We introduce CBR-RAG,
where CBR cycle's initial retrieval stage, its indexing vocabulary, and
similarity knowledge containers are used to enhance LLM queries with
contextually relevant cases. This integration augments the original LLM query,
providing a richer prompt. We present an evaluation of CBR-RAG, and examine
different representations (i.e. general and domain-specific embeddings) and
methods of comparison (i.e. inter, intra and hybrid similarity) on the task of
legal question-answering. Our results indicate that the context provided by
CBR's case reuse enforces similarity between relevant components of the
questions and the evidence base leading to significant improvements in the
quality of generated answers.
|
[
-0.3800411522,
-0.9267850518,
0.8719218969,
-0.2519801259,
-0.5466733575,
0.2870938182,
0.0984131545,
-0.2002066523,
0.2513790429,
0.9776112437,
-0.1490579844,
-0.4093093872,
-0.2108109593,
-0.0374584273,
-0.4943636358,
1.0311242342,
0.0058228211,
0.223538518,
-0.7128432393,
-0.3998367488,
-0.7282893658,
-0.8783603907,
-0.7080523968,
-0.1812317371,
0.5741062164,
0.1779064983,
0.2926083505,
0.4477841854,
0.5126894712,
0.2212787122,
-0.4177733064,
0.2693154812,
-0.3288200796,
0.5902677178,
-0.3811371326,
-0.6000005007,
-0.3293631971,
-0.3643519282,
0.2770745158,
0.4885510802,
-0.4935274124,
0.2572868168,
-0.3042371571,
0.7925185561,
-0.6687053442,
-0.2951700985,
-0.9984359145,
-0.0690184534,
-0.2506554723,
-0.5708466172,
-0.4658722579,
-0.2049285024,
-0.3124776781,
-0.5308720469,
0.5581698418,
0.4698448777,
0.6558677554,
0.4660842419,
-0.5639443994,
-0.685608387,
-0.5297413468,
0.3784116209,
-0.6207467914,
0.341563195,
0.2054662257,
0.623021245,
-0.3360691071,
-0.9225265384,
-0.8167350888,
-0.2660425603,
-0.1329463571,
0.4316266179,
0.1285049468,
-0.0838755071,
0.3891126513,
0.2855276167,
-0.5769258142,
-0.406627208,
-0.3893000484,
-0.1601584405,
0.5316525698,
0.2252535373,
0.2089339942,
-0.3167508543,
-0.0876765549,
-0.0229477827,
-0.8732463717,
0.122080721,
0.3151795566,
0.2432066053,
0.3485295177,
0.8238531351,
-0.1088459343,
0.8428356647,
0.2645902038,
-0.2337039858,
0.0099615883,
-0.2287184447,
-0.1425668746,
0.2386273295,
0.2419936359,
0.2261663377,
-0.0779922158,
-0.0154385511,
-0.1920202076,
-0.3246763349,
0.4740297794,
-0.6947668791,
0.4290984571,
0.354626447,
-0.5145874619,
-0.0211280007,
0.2037421465,
-0.4147363305,
-0.4631968141,
-0.4724949598,
0.0825783312,
-0.1053977758,
-0.1687239408,
0.1165609062,
-0.3801235557,
0.7818644047,
0.25147596,
-0.2636959255,
0.3196752667,
1.0398108959,
0.2316938639,
-0.0212749653,
0.5486797094,
-0.9565812945,
0.3613770306,
-0.526158452,
1.0092324018,
-0.6152654886,
-0.5110396147,
0.0507345237,
-0.0470496789,
0.1586542726,
-0.9476007223,
0.725933671,
-1.0326678753,
0.2314673364,
-0.5501465797,
-0.568302989,
-0.0224402118,
0.46005252,
-0.4098617733,
1.0069128275,
-0.0997586772,
-0.7519818544,
0.6997901201,
-0.408643961,
-0.691441834,
0.3501006663,
-0.389025867,
-0.5425823331,
0.1905289441,
0.215915665,
0.2155648619,
-0.280944556,
0.324701637,
-0.2263241708,
-0.2217821628,
0.2130399048,
-0.0188753419,
0.7651417851,
0.4981869459,
-0.1324417889,
-0.0632605627,
-0.6010444164,
-0.0720623359,
0.1236508414,
-0.538112402,
-0.5942487717,
0.0842151269,
-0.4125113189,
-0.0053444612,
0.1327828765,
-0.6766064167,
-0.0131270336,
-0.3790573776,
0.0239594281,
0.2491854578,
0.4340413511,
0.2269632816,
-0.5272300243,
0.6402622461,
0.0203513727,
-0.1951171309,
-0.142696321,
-0.5041034818,
-0.6185563803,
-0.1754288822,
0.3943729997,
0.6167729497,
-0.8901265264,
-0.1013796553,
-0.1494984627,
-0.0906581357,
-0.5550861955,
-0.0348673016,
0.5013849139,
0.6070945859,
0.4557995796,
-0.2361179143,
-0.650223434,
-0.8095086813,
-0.4436871409,
-0.1089225337,
0.1553831697,
0.7148058414,
0.2556235492,
0.003850867,
1.0789586306,
-0.252641201,
-0.0548297502,
-0.4278661907,
0.1717339009,
0.3454045355,
0.0337162316,
0.3920269907,
-1.0391213894,
-0.5885488391,
0.1898772269,
-0.5326128602,
-0.3181394041,
-0.1650809795,
-0.2101746798,
0.4523130059,
0.7818636894,
-0.5232810378,
0.5478411317,
-0.0171732809,
-0.4658384025,
0.6114285588,
-0.3055234551,
0.4582937062,
-1.3367749453,
0.0414714515,
-0.5592647195,
-0.5723438263,
-0.3911705613,
0.3937887251,
-0.036473576,
-0.0327354856,
-0.4276690781,
0.6866780519,
-0.5283854008,
-0.4944494367,
-0.5883904099,
0.3426763713,
0.1697135717,
0.101560533,
-0.1976346672,
1.0718932152,
0.1096771508,
-0.4714194536,
0.310354799,
0.2919619679,
-0.2498217076,
0.8071528673,
-0.5626619458,
0.4066113532,
-0.4812431931,
0.108059302,
-0.677682817,
-0.074344255,
0.0887828767,
-0.4721351862,
0.6305159926,
-0.4650046825,
-0.5202438235,
-0.4017170966,
-0.0134944636,
0.4016658962,
0.5303226113,
-0.3562971354,
1.0072147846,
0.3864240944,
-0.3165590167,
-0.8066279292,
-0.5058482289,
0.0530896112,
-0.3652104437,
-0.2592850924,
0.486946255,
-0.0628784522,
-0.6150192022,
0.3855599761,
-0.315538615,
-0.2466326505,
-0.0621802136,
0.1294971406,
-0.0112662166,
-0.2893548012,
0.0825115889,
0.4984717965,
0.1870038509,
0.2062271684,
0.1470763832,
0.4441196322,
0.0337948091,
-0.506041646,
0.3760387301,
0.493798703,
0.2513892055,
-0.4336825907,
0.5274736285,
0.1829116195,
-0.0554549992,
-0.2317388207,
-0.9304977655,
0.0902522951,
-0.4067358375,
0.1284324974,
-0.675640285,
-1.2250012159,
0.5531330109,
0.0191609804,
-0.0346338674,
0.3790895939,
0.8092934489,
-0.3272403479,
0.6263149381,
0.2865428925,
0.2795957625,
0.2673356533,
0.0766241997,
0.1655947566,
-0.9560158849,
-0.2689768076,
-0.493155688,
0.2580711246,
-0.3516668081,
-0.7394370437,
0.4714645743,
0.2325330824,
-0.1777776927,
0.1639201194,
-0.4999325275,
0.5866172314,
0.5611450076,
0.0559473597,
0.357865721,
-0.0739837438,
-0.5493398309,
0.3550257087,
-0.7665697336,
-0.445846051,
1.0974315405,
-0.2002632618,
0.2490819395,
0.2274950147,
0.9164794087,
0.3316813111,
0.4880851805,
-0.6909754276,
0.7259467244,
-0.1414524615,
-0.9629867077,
-0.0290516205,
-0.4218869209,
-1.1580344439,
0.2604028583,
-0.2937280536,
-0.2242835611,
0.0371170416,
-0.0042808917,
-0.4147635102,
0.0518198535,
-0.263928473,
0.5397409201,
-0.2401100248,
-0.4692700207,
-0.3489811122,
-0.5932916403,
0.2637737095,
-0.1370909214,
0.3317314684,
0.1202570423,
0.099719964,
0.6291511059,
-0.597702086,
0.3113127351,
-0.2242264152,
0.170877248,
0.9567825794,
0.0990940407,
0.378470391,
0.0329327658,
-0.0125140361,
-0.4267263412,
0.3228179812,
-0.0535127446,
-0.9443187118,
0.4054214358,
-0.1016456783,
-1.2412428856,
-0.3765918911,
-0.655796349,
-0.0475754328,
0.2045405805,
-0.1933025271,
0.5528686047,
0.0606964268,
0.498503387,
0.6397252679,
-0.4457823336,
0.0802764595,
0.6749587655,
-0.3491589129,
-0.4038253427,
0.6279090047,
-0.0666403249,
-0.1329609305,
0.6677940488,
0.2073999792,
-0.4764636457,
-0.6105093956,
-0.3179282248,
0.3667978346,
-0.8070354462,
-0.5160061717,
-0.6514188647,
-0.1587690115,
-0.4112151265,
-0.0875197649,
-0.0225302652,
-0.5133829713,
0.0901622549,
-0.111263141,
0.4312409759,
0.5663132668,
0.1311884075,
-0.1366186738,
-0.573158145,
0.5999674201,
0.3975145519,
0.2106233835,
-0.4762250185,
-0.6659091115,
-0.0791728273,
-0.2162393779,
-0.2918685079,
-0.8160309196,
0.1775266528,
-0.2156108618,
0.7892818451,
-0.0421069711,
0.1961692572,
0.7891842127,
-0.852024436,
0.618434906,
-0.1887363493,
-0.5853114128,
0.5283041596,
-0.326561451,
-0.1201257631,
0.6464017034,
0.1021065041,
-0.1338431537,
-0.5849567652,
-0.5632837415,
-0.859597981,
0.2683790028,
0.1017413437,
0.1669611335,
-0.1729557365,
0.9080957174,
-0.0474843122,
0.2656240463,
-0.467292279,
-0.1999188513,
-0.1751061678,
-0.1469657272,
0.4570465684,
-0.4302428067,
-0.1514062881,
-0.3017511666,
0.5366906524,
-0.0814482868,
0.2798447013,
0.5385106802,
-0.0512129478,
0.2235507369,
0.5065155625,
0.4990695715,
0.5809233189,
-0.1916052997,
-0.0528321899,
0.4905734658,
-0.210559085,
0.1116443425,
0.1206256226,
-0.1745742857,
0.0498834662,
0.1916460246,
0.4360753596,
-0.2138619274,
-0.8645581007,
0.4655774832,
-0.1307737082,
-0.4397043288,
-0.4819218814,
-0.043107152,
0.0548204184,
0.5100024939,
0.5387855768,
-0.3906789124,
0.4282468855,
-0.7166725397,
0.4491170943,
0.7530044913,
-0.0936134383,
0.420245111,
0.7848981619,
-0.1824747622,
-0.2850322425,
0.1700048447,
-0.422185868,
-0.5615391135,
0.7119830251,
0.4291844368,
0.5725591183,
0.1685905308,
-0.0930111259,
0.392521292,
0.0705749691,
0.0460998006,
0.5053662062,
-0.3094380796,
-0.6451421976,
-0.7921586633,
-0.6185435057,
-0.550319314,
-0.1364186257,
-0.7808938622,
0.1430977881,
-0.3584712446,
-0.0954638422,
-0.4694831371,
-0.0583746508,
-0.4828562438,
0.278845638,
-0.0655458868,
0.7476046681,
-0.1885362864,
0.6930092573,
0.8803567886,
-0.5981682539,
-0.9316157103,
0.0429649577,
-0.220587045,
-0.5632287264,
0.8590301871,
-0.0464682132,
-0.1577008367,
-0.2135456055,
-0.3647057712,
-0.6252576709,
1.1911643744,
0.1871883869,
-0.4643495977,
0.1349362582,
0.291495353,
0.7344713211,
-0.3960947096,
0.1920515895,
0.4849109054,
0.2240588367,
0.528685689,
-0.5007756352,
0.2259567678,
-0.2178232521,
0.0188198518,
0.1473451704,
-0.2071062922,
0.4113027155,
-0.1349327415,
-0.3093991876,
0.1229879484,
0.6760869622,
0.8246288896,
0.5760348439,
0.3925390244,
0.6949087381,
0.645635128,
-0.1621570289,
1.3437814713,
-0.4594748616,
0.0931396931,
1.2888382673,
-0.3499445319,
0.9108039141,
0.5832039714,
0.0251333229,
0.7680889964,
0.2441171706,
0.178918004,
0.4814861715,
0.3786757886,
-0.2351890653,
-0.3614820242,
-0.1450748146,
-0.2654127479,
0.2269626111,
0.2561009824,
-0.2104043663,
-0.0161856227,
-0.1590664238,
-0.1636535972,
0.423427552,
-0.3490875661,
1.0967849493,
0.1549669504,
-0.7692810297,
0.2544632256,
-0.067598857,
0.2948478162,
-0.2405445427,
-0.2230808288,
-0.6179020405,
-0.1704525799,
0.0003747143,
-0.8839423656,
0.7433875203,
0.32712695,
-0.2850022316,
-0.2023236006,
0.9366247058,
-0.2270944566,
-0.5325239897,
0.2260524631,
0.6532763839,
0.2450797558,
-0.0349251367,
-0.7220338583,
-0.2893928587,
-0.3369475603,
-0.3206193447,
0.1528352797,
0.8530569077,
-0.1987106949,
0.6509106755,
0.7580339313,
0.1145667285,
0.2207500935,
0.3590302765,
1.023452878,
-0.730492115,
-0.1428496391,
-0.3988671303,
0.5065044165,
-0.2364641726,
0.21552746,
0.5680590868,
0.8468849063,
0.6902329326,
0.1760365963,
0.5479359627,
-0.2558060288,
1.0639561415,
-0.6794110537,
0.5724957585,
-0.762831986,
0.3282220662,
-0.1711668521,
-0.9273081422,
-0.2960418165,
0.3811501861,
-0.3996711373,
0.0998398289,
0.7617393136,
0.9694145918,
-0.0688430071,
-0.5618637204,
0.5221742988,
0.0119191492,
0.30070737,
0.2294489592,
0.8263992667,
-0.2616955936,
0.872066915,
0.1829045713,
0.1324839592,
-0.0943828151,
-0.8128209114,
-0.8592544198,
-0.3945227563,
-0.1258525103,
-0.4418883026,
0.2566713095,
0.6282722354,
0.3278202415,
-0.8269605637,
-0.0897513404,
-0.2524874508,
0.1479061693,
-0.0225959774,
-0.2815153003,
0.1628855914,
-0.5852617025,
-0.3559984863,
0.4117397964,
0.1078406423,
-0.2493205518,
0.293114543,
0.0022029027,
-0.1721678823,
0.328805238,
0.7626093626,
0.2838236094,
-0.8427079916,
-0.3062162101,
-0.0423000567,
-0.0293530524,
0.1202361435,
1.1329267025,
-0.8305743337,
0.4006023109,
0.5042898059,
1.100839138,
0.9180727005,
0.351347208,
0.4878053069,
-0.7046598196,
0.0398900434,
0.2834316194,
0.6908195019,
0.2628293633,
-0.2205931544,
0.538359344,
0.1634534299,
-0.625074923,
-0.6942093372,
0.3109787405,
-1.0976219177,
-0.5493194461,
1.2065275908,
0.016655216,
-0.1663851291,
-0.4487067759,
-0.4266456068,
0.3790188432,
-0.170607537,
0.5394199491,
0.5547780991,
-0.0178787913,
-0.370421052,
-0.626778543,
0.3020175397,
0.5275444388,
-0.8390479088,
-0.0990938842,
0.5891548395,
0.4623424411,
0.2024946064,
0.6379132867,
-0.4299690127,
0.2836256325,
-0.1557065248,
0.042950239,
-0.2582859993,
-0.1556935459,
0.0313106924,
0.3796231449,
0.0264430027,
0.2524306476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04298v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04298v1
|
SELF-[IN]CORRECT: LLMs Struggle with Refining Self-Generated Responses
| 2024-04-04T20:27:37 | 2024-04-04T20:27:37 |
Dongwei Jiang, Jingyu Zhang, Orion Weller, Nathaniel Weir, Benjamin Van Durme, Daniel Khashabi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Can LLMs continually improve their previous outputs for better results? An
affirmative answer would require LLMs to be better at discriminating among
previously-generated alternatives, than generating initial responses. We
explore the validity of this hypothesis in practice. We first introduce a
unified framework that allows us to compare the generative and discriminative
capability of any model on any task. Then, in our resulting experimental
analysis of several LLMs, we do not observe the performance of those models on
discrimination to be reliably better than generation. We hope these findings
inform the growing literature on self-improvement AI systems.
|
[
-0.133581087,
-0.6347823143,
0.8042427301,
-0.019987246,
0.1146741882,
0.3953251839,
-0.0601365566,
-0.5240649581,
-0.0343524776,
0.288085103,
-0.6221849918,
-0.0098992698,
-0.5938968062,
0.8445881605,
-0.5434864759,
0.6399152875,
0.061935097,
0.3766956925,
-0.6340212822,
-0.2060971856,
-0.7955777049,
-0.3853985369,
-0.7745268345,
-0.528332293,
0.3522383571,
0.5989545584,
0.3351616859,
0.4149746001,
0.6443682909,
0.405967921,
0.2608079016,
0.2655479014,
-0.5669679046,
0.5725399256,
-0.174238041,
-0.6382367611,
-0.234278813,
0.1972571611,
0.5103405714,
0.4409891963,
-0.1564715505,
0.310647428,
0.3949020505,
0.6591669917,
-0.4189252555,
-0.3811642826,
-0.8854105473,
0.0632364526,
-0.2168039382,
-0.1031773463,
-0.3913536072,
-0.3755694628,
-0.2204517871,
-0.375590086,
0.6255722046,
0.0059805289,
0.7560611367,
0.6777510643,
-0.2748715878,
-0.3757577538,
-0.9048668146,
0.4536075592,
-0.828551352,
0.2503844202,
0.0819781125,
0.2721202374,
-0.2406544536,
-0.8201527596,
-0.4782177508,
-0.533398211,
0.0354729071,
0.3060284853,
-0.0515591539,
-0.071948126,
0.4478995204,
0.6608610153,
-0.4683906436,
0.4377102256,
-0.3845079839,
-0.1541263908,
0.8605549335,
0.4518842399,
0.0824921504,
-0.0201472621,
-0.3687751293,
0.1544856876,
-0.9450079799,
-0.0650704131,
0.1530835032,
0.2000464201,
0.3221920431,
0.7291350365,
-0.2031446993,
0.352486372,
0.5791807175,
-0.1549356729,
0.231135726,
-0.2619563341,
-0.3541072905,
-0.09647955,
0.4913294017,
0.2115000784,
-0.1124599352,
-0.3373837471,
-0.5546674132,
0.2543374598,
0.6621354818,
-0.4727166891,
-0.1137841493,
0.2834022641,
-0.6329243779,
-0.0441365428,
-0.1608447284,
-0.3617686629,
-0.3546172678,
-0.4103622139,
0.4980704784,
-0.0886530578,
-0.2593610287,
-0.0687717646,
-0.2433222085,
0.1997819841,
0.2064602226,
-0.7112685442,
0.2647284269,
0.5369231105,
0.7189821601,
-0.4630245864,
-0.1935386062,
-0.4677596092,
-0.0708704442,
-0.5041734576,
1.0254958868,
-0.2542997003,
-0.76790905,
-0.0899300203,
-0.1564493924,
-0.0713545308,
-1.2181280851,
0.3949673474,
-0.4413153827,
0.0983041525,
-0.622662127,
-0.9080605507,
0.2979209721,
0.2409179211,
-0.2318073213,
0.9716356397,
0.3567112982,
-0.379417479,
0.648173511,
-0.817566812,
-0.2108296603,
0.211434409,
-0.349824667,
-0.5416215062,
0.4452926219,
-0.0374815278,
0.3338399529,
-0.0912783891,
0.2361376137,
-0.7770372629,
-0.3708432317,
0.4416253865,
-0.2814640999,
0.6391298771,
0.512136519,
-0.4921749234,
0.0861225277,
-0.8061634898,
-0.0039652893,
0.2927114069,
-0.4363510013,
0.0908643827,
0.1589370519,
-0.749427259,
0.1128022894,
0.2306909859,
-0.844866097,
0.345074743,
-0.2473599017,
0.2197172642,
1.1401129961,
-0.1786385924,
0.4365703166,
-0.5877396464,
0.5875768661,
-0.1868930012,
0.0510279574,
-0.074487038,
-0.178062439,
-1.2365243435,
-0.2046253681,
0.1857380122,
0.2904849052,
-0.6800453067,
0.2587418854,
-0.0248349868,
-0.1704808623,
-0.4115503132,
0.4291981459,
0.4220331609,
0.6415935159,
0.2542455196,
-0.5701315999,
-0.6397503614,
-0.6891673207,
-0.2604174912,
-0.3477675915,
-0.0969266966,
0.1097366661,
0.4783275723,
-0.2967841029,
0.6607836485,
-0.1032405272,
0.1130704358,
-0.0136936763,
0.1409965754,
0.0288107432,
0.2910439968,
0.3781756163,
-0.2636965215,
-0.4222761691,
-0.3144749105,
-1.1203022003,
-0.2785387933,
-0.0751586631,
-0.0286179241,
0.2067811638,
0.5473569036,
-0.3353532851,
0.5595673323,
0.0612255782,
-0.2135218829,
0.6608132124,
-0.2283870727,
0.208248511,
-0.6307438612,
-0.2929527462,
-0.1526679844,
-0.203134045,
-0.4272767901,
-0.0876154751,
-0.0424899459,
0.14776963,
-0.135294199,
0.4171218574,
-0.485424906,
-0.3026692271,
-0.6949605942,
0.057534676,
-0.320566833,
0.1163584962,
-0.3732174337,
0.9794315696,
0.599897027,
-1.0386433601,
0.5415773392,
0.1539219618,
-0.3239285648,
0.7899757028,
-0.7775762677,
0.3481958807,
-0.3822533786,
-0.0013086149,
-1.3754172325,
-0.4096986949,
0.3469662666,
-0.3815451562,
0.3305007517,
0.3746725917,
-0.3232115209,
-0.7376713753,
-0.0646702498,
0.2340334207,
0.6360349655,
-0.8800010681,
0.4007354081,
-0.0765815154,
-0.1032576412,
-0.3186148405,
-0.588501215,
0.0573970936,
-0.3212290406,
-0.3823467791,
0.2907283604,
-0.3910383284,
-0.5052070022,
-0.113283433,
-0.1565975398,
0.2804366648,
0.3818496764,
0.1558284909,
-0.0491969399,
-0.2100583166,
0.3038703501,
-0.1670508981,
-0.081930548,
0.2971669734,
0.1661845148,
0.2670764923,
0.1142415181,
-0.8110057116,
-0.4063918591,
0.1680371463,
0.1858036071,
-0.1665275991,
0.0300961565,
0.2891066968,
-0.0056424444,
-0.0957832411,
-0.6956596971,
-0.2356720716,
-0.4957859516,
0.172851786,
-0.6132704616,
-1.1248809099,
0.4430129528,
0.0152322305,
0.270108521,
0.7422097325,
0.5380914807,
-0.5411314964,
1.1733545065,
0.7261415124,
0.2127337605,
0.1930200905,
-0.2854661942,
-0.0922415629,
-0.9038665891,
-0.3771211207,
-0.7044994235,
-0.3508194983,
-0.6251940727,
0.2823254466,
0.2891006172,
0.0849939585,
-0.4083096385,
0.0303203557,
-0.7398910522,
0.2268907279,
0.7283778787,
0.1382218748,
0.2045041025,
-0.1722420752,
0.0709794611,
-0.1196245477,
-0.8581734896,
-0.5052489638,
1.1012899876,
0.4414026141,
0.8219642639,
0.2686756551,
1.0530241728,
0.4651755095,
1.1040810347,
-0.4143160284,
0.3856435418,
0.0902977437,
-0.6979130507,
-0.216059491,
-0.3441047072,
-1.170527935,
0.1576011628,
-0.158954367,
-0.5256363153,
0.2463252544,
0.4016728401,
-0.5056765676,
0.2611552775,
-0.4202728271,
0.646736443,
-0.7914566994,
-0.2336509228,
-0.1823547035,
-0.3744024038,
0.4018366039,
-0.1939778775,
-0.2391954958,
-0.3905638456,
0.0420670584,
0.5859146118,
-0.526039362,
0.7708230019,
-0.1527872682,
-0.296795696,
0.4996284544,
0.0769876391,
0.1730005592,
-0.068725884,
-0.1661320329,
-0.1589611024,
-0.2807967365,
-0.5913313627,
-0.8957592845,
0.3529675305,
-0.621966362,
-1.1753636599,
-0.4179386795,
-0.0723503903,
-0.1606680751,
0.1356286854,
0.4938745797,
0.3906511664,
-0.3513378203,
-0.0041638887,
0.4761465788,
0.0826026201,
0.5911659002,
0.6209210157,
-0.3447675407,
-0.326803416,
0.6024847627,
0.2279712707,
0.3202211559,
-0.0309778489,
0.0540306568,
-0.6135522723,
-0.6765496135,
-0.4890865982,
0.0516345985,
-0.6115255952,
-0.4827932119,
-0.173871994,
-0.0137833739,
-0.5978314281,
0.0607704856,
-0.1446560621,
-0.0502451323,
-0.3377018869,
-0.1703015417,
-0.029900305,
1.3922680616,
-0.4862643778,
0.1480028629,
-0.4422249496,
0.3267279267,
0.7195945382,
0.2161889821,
-0.0425395519,
-0.9231318831,
-0.1524922848,
0.2242327034,
-0.7871679664,
-0.6853439212,
0.0853475332,
0.1342792809,
0.8026548028,
0.3770017326,
-0.0680881888,
0.7368382812,
-0.2690491378,
0.9951613545,
0.1956748813,
-0.6326320767,
0.5695567727,
0.0567031093,
0.3920735717,
0.4903518558,
0.2545529902,
-0.0928359553,
-0.5369642973,
-0.7743965983,
-0.2793215811,
0.3423169851,
0.2108918726,
0.2485874444,
-0.3710378408,
0.8603192568,
0.2332078069,
0.2431714535,
-0.7655653954,
-0.364195168,
-0.2935352325,
0.0487235822,
-0.0984408483,
-0.48831743,
0.0961364806,
-0.246632278,
0.7217715383,
0.0170679484,
0.4404068589,
0.4529891014,
0.0760338828,
-0.3121863306,
0.0528983623,
0.4460695684,
0.8653891683,
-0.0217131823,
0.1359277666,
0.5011700392,
0.15972808,
0.6022588611,
-0.2280590683,
-0.1500965655,
0.0114454832,
0.380495131,
0.4386251867,
-0.3102145493,
-0.3715515137,
0.3316506445,
-0.209002763,
-0.2746011019,
-0.3596498668,
0.5773103833,
-0.4136691093,
0.3940519094,
0.4677871764,
0.1460562199,
0.2820279896,
-0.7286380529,
0.3634947538,
0.7172754407,
-0.2207051367,
-0.0016121345,
0.8506734371,
0.3991747797,
-0.78724581,
0.868113935,
-0.3696582913,
-0.3575643301,
0.7183641791,
0.7228477597,
1.0278693438,
-0.3394818008,
0.1776660383,
0.4620313346,
0.0281577539,
-0.0523299202,
0.0489043109,
-0.2342241555,
-0.9614986777,
-0.4116702378,
-0.2962736487,
-0.3030932844,
0.1920975298,
-0.6571061015,
-0.2173061967,
-0.4333161712,
-0.4645516574,
-0.1071258932,
-0.038927827,
-0.6744642854,
0.4234936237,
-0.0451824442,
0.5972605348,
-0.4905772507,
0.4748545587,
0.4895938337,
-0.5379274487,
-0.5723702908,
-0.1047511473,
-0.2332608402,
-0.832818985,
0.8167142868,
0.2716149092,
-0.2175283134,
-0.2873050272,
-0.9927642941,
-1.0356143713,
1.0817757845,
0.4194359481,
-0.4908024967,
0.1231935769,
0.120821625,
0.6684058309,
-0.4563275576,
0.254755795,
0.4708397985,
0.2918024361,
-0.1495182812,
-0.8508886695,
-0.1705647558,
-0.2105502784,
0.2186628729,
-0.0662978441,
-0.772321105,
0.743366003,
-0.4574595988,
-0.4903141558,
0.5760993958,
1.2119370699,
0.1174254119,
0.5186955929,
0.5034791231,
0.8097350001,
0.8374141455,
-0.2454521209,
0.9780321121,
-0.1871713847,
0.2707780302,
1.2567131519,
-0.2475703657,
0.4085413218,
0.0968148857,
-0.4246995151,
0.5256467462,
0.9301899672,
-0.1574992537,
0.440656513,
0.359688282,
-0.3157783151,
-0.4609563649,
0.089743562,
-0.4080485106,
0.443607837,
-0.0818450525,
-0.2994191349,
-0.0857779607,
-0.0446582176,
-0.2818679214,
0.3131912351,
-0.3944520056,
0.8571471572,
-0.0082642967,
-0.8879371881,
0.7190755606,
-0.0963480398,
0.8254758716,
-0.2703631818,
-0.129856661,
-0.6160472035,
0.1135706082,
-0.319893539,
-0.6276546121,
0.291662991,
-0.0265754219,
-0.2677584887,
-0.1579283923,
0.8829833269,
-0.2444575727,
-0.3877652287,
0.1705167294,
0.7272964716,
0.2316593975,
0.3720352054,
-0.8488468528,
-0.0309884828,
0.0268843174,
0.1524537057,
0.0601214617,
0.2174477279,
0.3712915778,
0.9942792654,
0.2835450172,
-0.0855386928,
0.2284721136,
0.1911418885,
0.4658026695,
-0.556522131,
0.0273640547,
-0.9151929617,
0.3951241672,
-0.2558234632,
-0.4857999384,
1.0605624914,
0.6076073647,
1.2507369518,
0.0766705871,
0.8108708262,
0.0202796701,
0.7522845864,
-0.5899198055,
-0.0117140561,
-0.7992700934,
0.1707015783,
-0.0577347688,
-0.7534630895,
0.0969379991,
0.7378638387,
-0.1245914996,
0.3718764186,
0.470464319,
0.9326556325,
0.1983369291,
-0.172034502,
0.4015817046,
0.2732619643,
0.3249932826,
0.1297444403,
1.3993856907,
-0.1739588827,
0.1124267951,
-0.1298184842,
-0.010597147,
0.0443802029,
-0.4978645444,
-0.6785745621,
-0.4412255883,
-0.4107802808,
-0.5846148729,
0.1712011546,
0.7649831772,
0.4368511736,
-0.6350591183,
-0.3507836759,
-0.1422195882,
0.1189274937,
-0.0430246145,
-0.14334777,
-0.0798605382,
-0.9559982419,
-0.520226717,
0.4942432344,
0.2269809544,
0.2236767113,
-0.5316260457,
-0.3852371573,
0.2670599818,
0.1004113927,
0.6181302071,
0.4215612113,
-0.8137965798,
-0.6625576615,
-0.0226596966,
-0.2076735944,
0.4321443141,
0.7541945577,
-0.6327838898,
0.5364285111,
0.0614147745,
0.7671062946,
0.3311395049,
0.1379026622,
0.5215820074,
-0.3612200916,
-0.553671062,
0.1387744993,
0.5621382594,
0.5683751702,
-0.3220817149,
0.7395785451,
0.339559406,
-0.9249885678,
-0.6995267868,
0.5190935135,
-0.2826626301,
-0.2133173645,
1.0201483965,
-0.0150217451,
-0.049072925,
-0.1207184121,
-0.1990550607,
0.2108304501,
-0.1474425942,
1.1772955656,
0.4512500763,
-0.8779526949,
-0.017975593,
0.0435597785,
0.4763800502,
0.6369997263,
-0.7140893936,
-0.2400986254,
0.6163470745,
0.4858877957,
0.1615569592,
1.1295876503,
0.0558637083,
0.3658001423,
-0.1078629196,
-0.1259515435,
0.1806464046,
-0.4110091627,
-0.4607046545,
-0.1008558795,
0.5672549009,
-0.2456172407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03746v1
|
GenQREnsemble: Zero-Shot LLM Ensemble Prompting for Generative Query Reformulation
| 2024-04-04T18:35:25 | 2024-04-04T18:35:25 |
Kaustubh Dhole, Eugene Agichtein
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Query Reformulation(QR) is a set of techniques used to transform a user's
original search query to a text that better aligns with the user's intent and
improves their search experience. Recently, zero-shot QR has been shown to be a
promising approach due to its ability to exploit knowledge inherent in large
language models. By taking inspiration from the success of ensemble prompting
strategies which have benefited many tasks, we investigate if they can help
improve query reformulation. In this context, we propose an ensemble based
prompting technique, GenQREnsemble which leverages paraphrases of a zero-shot
instruction to generate multiple sets of keywords ultimately improving
retrieval performance. We further introduce its post-retrieval variant,
GenQREnsembleRF to incorporate pseudo relevant feedback. On evaluations over
four IR benchmarks, we find that GenQREnsemble generates better reformulations
with relative nDCG@10 improvements up to 18% and MAP improvements upto 24% over
the previous zero-shot state-of-art. On the MSMarco Passage Ranking task,
GenQREnsembleRF shows relative gains of 5% MRR using pseudo-relevance feedback,
and 9% nDCG@10 using relevant feedback documents.
|
[
-0.2939261198,
-0.6690321565,
0.5494586825,
-0.2413465232,
-0.4017231464,
0.1662085354,
-0.1965662688,
0.2002542615,
0.358451277,
0.6015729308,
-0.5539425015,
-0.5301871896,
-0.0253737289,
0.2385515124,
-0.5921430588,
1.0024340153,
0.2238959074,
0.0353236496,
-0.3285837173,
0.0026006198,
-0.3784502745,
-0.4097597003,
-0.6776999831,
-0.1116817296,
0.5624052882,
0.54306674,
0.3133751154,
0.2783274949,
0.3079133034,
0.2617972195,
-0.1449898332,
0.062755473,
-0.746527195,
0.9392326474,
-0.1191605031,
-0.7358273268,
0.0133415526,
-0.251362741,
0.6902204752,
0.1560303271,
-0.5954931378,
0.1182652041,
0.2904898524,
0.5913839936,
-0.8494154215,
-0.1719486415,
-0.8885074854,
0.0588198528,
-0.2924040854,
-0.7914989591,
-0.362226218,
-0.4117305875,
-0.4133806229,
-0.6707955003,
0.5858997107,
0.156984359,
0.4910412133,
0.1913883537,
-0.1497664005,
0.0545673892,
-0.7197299004,
0.6783121228,
-0.6458240747,
0.2804237306,
0.1960149407,
0.7107253075,
-0.3508664668,
-0.9235551357,
-0.6262296438,
0.0465739109,
0.1279359907,
0.302854836,
-0.2484829128,
0.189832136,
0.1042507291,
0.4359098673,
-0.6586199403,
-0.3468675911,
-0.6236969233,
-0.1564159393,
0.7294401526,
0.3019499183,
0.2518034577,
-0.1294474453,
-0.3381420076,
-0.6090625525,
-0.7364521623,
0.031579338,
0.1356440336,
0.2428478897,
0.5429319143,
0.5498265624,
-0.7930626273,
0.7801657319,
0.5177404881,
0.1554393619,
0.0267259851,
-0.5670301914,
-0.2557447255,
0.3535148501,
0.8680163026,
0.5032193065,
-0.0822960511,
-0.2884118557,
-0.4923081994,
-0.3244445324,
0.2986890376,
-0.8228734136,
-0.4321865141,
0.2543468177,
-0.3719141781,
-0.3507947922,
0.0672801509,
-0.9421024919,
-0.0959587023,
-0.0805101916,
0.7149749994,
-0.77717489,
0.1679019332,
0.0624632426,
-0.5827762485,
0.7828296423,
0.4904108346,
-0.7397693992,
-0.0229652654,
0.7034779191,
0.6676282883,
0.303474158,
-0.1537244022,
-0.8600073457,
0.0325168334,
-0.3553161919,
1.122579217,
-0.8371464014,
-0.8175554276,
-0.239442721,
-0.0918202847,
-0.4145129919,
-0.6050420403,
0.6515136957,
-0.8451803923,
0.6321628094,
-0.3458546102,
-0.6982460022,
-0.108690545,
0.5471111536,
-0.3417738378,
1.0922676325,
-0.0369817503,
-0.4078293145,
0.3068571687,
-0.5186347365,
-0.2077207118,
0.6599761248,
-0.3019357324,
-0.1802592874,
0.1307641119,
0.5163963437,
0.1363252252,
-0.0406242795,
-0.0867255926,
-0.0893109068,
-0.69643116,
-0.0031772472,
-0.3191064894,
0.547660172,
0.2343284488,
-0.1528776288,
0.277749598,
-0.4052376449,
0.5235546827,
0.0413032733,
-0.176821664,
-0.3410277069,
-0.2374059409,
-0.2610587478,
-0.0486138463,
0.0628982261,
-0.3358259797,
0.4916388392,
-0.2798143625,
0.5362354517,
0.3254695833,
0.6060220003,
0.6218833327,
-0.6055468917,
1.1689031124,
-0.292232573,
0.1045026779,
-0.5276181102,
-0.5516525507,
-0.2647494376,
-0.2069589943,
0.5229992867,
0.6083981991,
-1.3851493597,
0.0183637273,
-0.2273860127,
-0.3356630206,
-0.9414803386,
0.1166791096,
0.4136047959,
0.6022341251,
0.537481308,
-0.005551598,
-0.4559290111,
-0.5023257732,
-0.3317012191,
-0.12667346,
-0.1857192069,
0.1276226342,
0.2094893754,
0.2727989256,
0.7207407355,
-0.4823671877,
-0.2217385322,
-0.3271854818,
0.247773245,
0.0969491377,
0.3552110791,
0.3804499209,
-0.6311289668,
-0.3465590477,
-0.3714458048,
-0.372423023,
0.0171850696,
-0.119904615,
-0.3707796037,
-0.1015556157,
0.8767754436,
-0.6539826989,
0.1672388166,
0.0261607654,
-0.045292709,
0.724981308,
-0.2171936929,
0.7220841646,
-1.1229584217,
-0.013778965,
-0.339700073,
-0.0110721793,
-0.4574375153,
0.4970679879,
0.1761541963,
-0.123268567,
-0.5576791167,
0.4834362566,
-0.5240228772,
0.297380507,
-0.1359128058,
0.0831615478,
0.1689139307,
0.0620362647,
-0.3554606438,
1.2876964808,
0.4012493193,
-0.7301068902,
0.3842955828,
0.3668172359,
-0.1874304712,
0.6787595153,
-0.7114915252,
0.3176557124,
-0.3821690977,
0.3067609668,
-1.319604516,
-0.3995569646,
0.1596180797,
-0.7040874362,
0.3529663682,
-0.3678165674,
-0.4048336446,
-0.3902546465,
-0.8895663619,
0.4739699364,
0.6388607025,
-0.4544263482,
0.2796401381,
-0.2457267642,
-0.0942392871,
-0.3998112381,
-0.5014596581,
0.2660133541,
-0.3233739734,
-0.5722708106,
0.5519781709,
0.0739786401,
-0.0602259971,
0.0582793131,
0.0443978943,
0.1749418676,
-0.0897212401,
-0.2023318708,
0.1857624352,
-0.4373418093,
0.2205799818,
0.3434224427,
0.2525246143,
-0.2501825988,
-0.3423665762,
0.7494375706,
0.1625449955,
-0.3688615561,
-0.3926586807,
0.1817152649,
0.3434276283,
-0.5637439489,
0.5188866258,
0.4590811431,
0.1592382789,
-0.1880404055,
-0.476927042,
-0.7139177322,
-0.4646513462,
-0.2483647168,
-0.4303105772,
-1.1511011124,
0.3412011862,
0.107883215,
-0.1777509004,
0.4351741672,
0.2985861599,
-0.308255434,
1.0204812288,
0.132732302,
0.1785488129,
0.5454519391,
-0.2481447309,
0.1562600136,
-1.1144200563,
-0.3964135051,
-0.6392701268,
-0.5112859607,
-0.614439249,
-0.606439054,
0.5406397581,
0.5741926432,
0.0299337432,
0.3042469323,
-0.783292532,
0.598798573,
0.8237573504,
0.1488196105,
0.1425551623,
0.2208966911,
-0.2667825222,
0.1638658643,
-0.888035655,
-0.2612311244,
1.309872508,
-0.6358368397,
0.645508647,
0.1168211475,
1.3607243299,
0.077041842,
-0.0000139488,
-0.9360235333,
0.7086960077,
0.1884228438,
-0.4327588379,
-0.5427216291,
-0.4970586598,
-1.2918037176,
0.3737052977,
-0.2328085154,
-0.6016311049,
0.2457023263,
0.2178167552,
-0.8251999617,
0.0624801442,
-0.4234078526,
0.5886663795,
-0.0103518199,
-0.1889054477,
0.0511275157,
-0.6124308109,
0.3964776993,
0.2701129019,
-0.1850244105,
0.13264139,
-0.0138975689,
0.4825631976,
-0.4199004173,
0.2257740051,
-0.1524003595,
0.2399591357,
0.4362915456,
0.190445587,
0.4847447574,
-0.1197364107,
-0.3910522461,
-0.3351767659,
0.3014411926,
-0.3777335584,
-0.9613536596,
0.5777851939,
-0.1596646756,
-1.0349317789,
-0.0814842731,
-0.2622191906,
-0.098799631,
0.1359946877,
0.6127383709,
0.339209348,
-0.2034015357,
0.4715029895,
0.8236058354,
-0.1159092411,
0.5161358714,
0.3466414213,
-0.3242449164,
-0.5836821198,
0.707701385,
0.0044761188,
0.118643418,
0.5904101133,
-0.0023881525,
-0.6269670725,
-0.5371521115,
-0.7580427527,
-0.0634750947,
-0.2959813178,
-0.5401694179,
-0.5025157928,
-0.0792243928,
-0.8050132394,
-0.002106721,
0.2672035992,
-0.5861406326,
-0.1314536929,
0.0655005947,
0.5947525501,
0.047914274,
-0.0096850134,
0.2798736095,
-1.0876992941,
0.0679769367,
0.3863891661,
-0.0916343778,
-0.0477916636,
-0.7746880651,
0.1815875024,
0.02232223,
-0.3887907565,
-1.0340826511,
0.4180749655,
0.4633195996,
0.6761213541,
0.4590058327,
0.3988064826,
0.7132617831,
-0.5625676513,
0.9654999971,
0.0487616174,
-0.6260540485,
0.8744707108,
-0.423368603,
0.517429471,
1.0085836649,
0.1522088498,
-0.4710272551,
-0.4159967303,
-0.6183363795,
-0.8894042969,
0.4415701032,
0.1920838356,
0.3611605763,
-0.3051688671,
0.6106540561,
-0.3512737453,
0.4810576439,
0.1977070421,
-0.1025843397,
-0.2142612487,
-0.1227385774,
0.0589718595,
-0.1748713553,
-0.190275684,
-0.1942288131,
0.5059910417,
-0.1730175465,
0.2692203522,
0.4569595456,
0.0397071987,
0.0247396957,
0.7319172025,
0.5252219439,
0.2591437399,
-0.2872544229,
0.0886329561,
-0.0003076118,
-0.2695182562,
0.3019904792,
0.2815510333,
-0.5893663764,
-0.0354358777,
0.1443020403,
0.6339771152,
0.2611835599,
-0.5789961219,
0.4755347967,
-0.0867875665,
-0.4409646988,
0.2187541723,
0.4760760367,
-0.1670759171,
0.3150391877,
0.6634775996,
-0.2251000851,
0.7402783632,
-0.6026195884,
0.4357093573,
0.6076247096,
-0.3576746285,
-0.0330043845,
0.8478910923,
-0.1467083842,
-0.2554647326,
0.7988176346,
-0.6597040296,
-0.5542814732,
0.4476179481,
0.4277768135,
0.8972895741,
-0.6693748236,
0.5346498489,
0.4228109121,
0.1532938629,
-0.3594195545,
0.5609180331,
-0.5430341959,
-0.6061488986,
-0.4662200212,
-0.6303768158,
-0.2763581872,
-0.0095819542,
-0.9320986271,
0.1577002853,
-0.3598895073,
0.0182803869,
-0.1367311031,
-0.2551860213,
-0.2370063961,
0.0293251257,
-0.0952477679,
0.8175737858,
-0.2232210189,
0.7270591259,
1.0342074633,
-0.6656464338,
-0.9354403019,
0.395835638,
0.1481119841,
-0.842379272,
0.3880159557,
-0.0497989133,
-0.0959893987,
0.2962441146,
-0.63650769,
-0.6302372217,
1.3409945965,
0.2778688371,
-0.6947495937,
0.0623317398,
-0.3193374276,
0.5309308171,
-0.0944258496,
0.4291659892,
0.390899092,
0.2717238367,
0.6539750099,
-0.5718213916,
0.2005314529,
-0.2485562712,
0.3017684817,
0.6915299296,
-0.5459468961,
0.7710643411,
-0.2659593225,
-0.5157187581,
0.2594937682,
0.486374557,
0.5860501528,
0.49574247,
0.2444198132,
0.7212823629,
0.8366779089,
-0.0506251156,
1.2583284378,
-0.6721680164,
0.2432307601,
1.0502308607,
-0.2300836593,
1.2152937651,
0.5549716949,
-0.1303257048,
0.3958047926,
0.5500112176,
0.0215980522,
0.7557281852,
0.2088373452,
-0.5975311995,
-0.2718640566,
0.1212289259,
-0.4267858267,
0.4129985869,
0.2482512593,
-0.2610557675,
-0.4747029245,
-0.0542332754,
-0.0073504569,
-0.0576382987,
-0.489267379,
0.9345789552,
0.0123783993,
-0.807274282,
0.7582126856,
-0.1563035846,
0.6185215116,
-0.2554384768,
-0.2243958563,
-0.5759826303,
-0.1279695183,
-0.2721916139,
-0.8375402093,
0.198101908,
-0.3373962939,
-0.1350100636,
-0.2224037051,
0.8279538155,
-0.6789597869,
-0.4451265037,
-0.0216560718,
0.6236650944,
0.2747838795,
-0.4919533134,
-0.8037599325,
-0.3018462062,
0.2425052524,
-0.1689999402,
0.353707552,
0.5902910829,
-0.0745552704,
0.3519384265,
0.7318220735,
-0.1295837909,
0.0953665003,
0.2317479998,
0.743051827,
-0.7708765268,
-0.193682611,
-0.6711210608,
0.2175302058,
-0.1132911071,
-0.1116061583,
0.9467459321,
0.5529085398,
0.7929381728,
0.1449687481,
0.5440436602,
0.1662988812,
0.4129285812,
-0.6734968424,
0.773871839,
-0.6419758201,
0.3727903962,
0.1129044816,
-1.0144314766,
-0.245796293,
0.2517959476,
-0.4064633548,
0.091555953,
0.3412324786,
1.1816499233,
0.0326057971,
-0.0214848351,
0.4799311459,
0.0129812937,
-0.0320607759,
0.2496530563,
0.8941946626,
-0.4959366918,
0.7673553824,
0.0704804584,
0.007551048,
-0.5716241598,
-0.3826102912,
-0.3154893517,
-0.4005509019,
-0.3103696704,
-0.3848005235,
0.3466419876,
0.6946635246,
0.4224326611,
-0.7944389582,
0.0800780058,
-0.0643100366,
-0.026554605,
-0.2346898466,
-0.326041013,
0.0676302835,
-0.7820596099,
-0.4075791538,
0.8137493134,
0.4256804883,
-0.1097897515,
0.0173684023,
0.1232450306,
-0.1318401694,
0.2442348897,
0.5427566171,
0.3663392663,
-0.4309266806,
-0.0088808108,
0.3812707961,
0.0505313799,
0.1713315994,
0.7972456217,
-1.0984157324,
0.4889341593,
0.794003129,
0.5242952108,
0.7188066244,
0.3369602859,
0.5519472361,
-0.6593369246,
-0.2185438424,
0.4213173687,
0.1155761778,
0.3898549676,
-0.5128341913,
0.3687860668,
0.0432788879,
-0.4856974781,
-0.7059064507,
0.0179133117,
-0.7400211692,
-0.3208155334,
1.0915224552,
0.1356413811,
-0.3357931674,
0.1805975139,
-0.2145992815,
0.0159423947,
-0.8406933546,
0.7189087868,
0.3030990362,
-0.3952801228,
-0.7030102015,
-0.3376714587,
0.4334138036,
0.5924289823,
-0.450653553,
-0.6143241525,
0.4695891142,
0.3621757925,
-0.0146799367,
0.7058059573,
-0.3625158668,
0.4072462916,
-0.0771678165,
0.0722527727,
0.1651900113,
0.0608569235,
-0.5829570293,
0.4161089063,
-0.07456927,
-0.462257117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03745v1
|
Fakes of Varying Shades: How Warning Affects Human Perception and Engagement Regarding LLM Hallucinations
| 2024-04-04T18:34:32 | 2024-04-04T18:34:32 |
Mahjabin Nahar, Haeseung Seo, Eun-Ju Lee, Aiping Xiong, Dongwon Lee
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The widespread adoption and transformative effects of large language models
(LLMs) have sparked concerns regarding their capacity to produce inaccurate and
fictitious content, referred to as `hallucinations'. Given the potential risks
associated with hallucinations, humans should be able to identify them. This
research aims to understand the human perception of LLM hallucinations by
systematically varying the degree of hallucination (genuine, minor
hallucination, major hallucination) and examining its interaction with warning
(i.e., a warning of potential inaccuracies: absent vs. present). Participants
(N=419) from Prolific rated the perceived accuracy and engaged with content
(e.g., like, dislike, share) in a Q/A format. Results indicate that humans rank
content as truthful in the order genuine > minor hallucination > major
hallucination and user engagement behaviors mirror this pattern. More
importantly, we observed that warning improves hallucination detection without
significantly affecting the perceived truthfulness of genuine content. We
conclude by offering insights for future tools to aid human detection of
hallucinations.
|
[
-0.4131193161,
-0.7374336123,
0.8030853271,
0.5111407638,
-0.2082464546,
0.0467196703,
-0.065399617,
-1.0229098797,
0.5791661143,
0.4180419147,
-0.4587286711,
-0.4677124023,
-0.6321434379,
0.4175734222,
-0.5919647813,
0.6859729886,
-0.056206923,
0.1249098703,
-0.1578037143,
-0.0410727262,
-0.6018099785,
-0.5833399296,
-0.2911638319,
-0.2951710522,
1.0253205299,
0.0520017445,
1.0244761705,
0.1731070578,
0.2669196129,
0.2359549403,
0.038891755,
0.1465299875,
-0.6419014335,
0.1360347271,
-0.1503528804,
-0.745983541,
-0.0888860524,
0.355165422,
0.2409774214,
0.6137699485,
-0.1775763482,
-0.1330914199,
0.1452149302,
0.7045156956,
-0.4530340135,
-0.0611707158,
-0.6789085269,
0.5225117207,
0.0393504277,
-0.496180445,
-0.6110278964,
-0.2046671063,
0.1721574366,
-0.558832407,
0.3768630624,
0.2909161747,
0.7428561449,
0.3451326787,
-0.480474472,
-0.6471672654,
-0.9664358497,
0.701035738,
-0.3859801292,
0.5047769547,
0.5029700994,
0.3544563949,
-0.130302608,
-0.3010501564,
-0.8771560192,
-0.3737955391,
-0.214522168,
0.1611267626,
-0.1913950592,
0.0514406748,
0.4672996402,
0.3295891583,
-0.5066936016,
0.0743116289,
-0.4236314595,
-0.6239170432,
0.65715307,
0.3086786568,
0.3543185294,
-0.1838557422,
-0.2270065546,
0.011250183,
-0.6921500564,
-0.2263201773,
0.7823398709,
-0.0246392488,
-0.2125225663,
0.6796081662,
-0.0675946251,
0.4270581603,
0.0596822165,
-0.0137899779,
0.2863339782,
-0.0203030705,
-0.2720255256,
0.2177040279,
0.5428379178,
0.6908843517,
0.1679718643,
-0.2105749995,
-0.2447352558,
0.5529607534,
0.7443293929,
-0.5466538668,
-0.2773483098,
0.2235737741,
-0.4936053455,
-0.4644544423,
0.2936618626,
-0.8755034804,
-1.1402437687,
-0.3690747619,
0.7451457381,
-0.3872812688,
-0.2522252798,
0.3535972834,
-0.0352262706,
0.1438948512,
0.5759615898,
-0.5858520865,
0.2556911409,
0.2388607711,
0.7133196592,
-0.6130256057,
-0.2045074403,
-0.0842719227,
-0.1449866295,
-0.5260813832,
0.6527305245,
-0.2086025923,
-0.4877254367,
0.1034373716,
0.1436437964,
0.118642807,
-0.7000781894,
0.6642566919,
-0.2350285351,
0.2784725428,
-0.5678694844,
-0.2187892646,
-0.408511579,
0.1879056692,
-0.7293440104,
0.8385306001,
0.2217050791,
-0.696562469,
0.4469731748,
-0.0041402206,
-0.31272313,
-0.0432442278,
-0.3962827921,
-0.2795981467,
0.2424836457,
-0.1315463185,
0.2255939692,
0.1909511387,
0.0129688876,
-0.0852667615,
-0.8017734885,
0.7696868181,
-0.6653265357,
0.4403874874,
0.151159212,
-0.8337647319,
0.2043423355,
-0.3438668251,
-0.587431252,
0.1355486661,
-0.0272042304,
-0.1608904302,
-0.0104045374,
-0.0693617314,
0.1831118315,
0.0309338775,
-0.3651109338,
-0.2562620342,
-0.3279257715,
-0.0811275542,
0.8799660802,
0.2644627392,
0.2634215951,
-0.8839674592,
0.6392154694,
0.5499992967,
0.5007182956,
0.1678491384,
-0.6882268786,
-0.9374473691,
0.1178609952,
-0.1714982837,
0.4381361902,
-0.4828333557,
0.4305413663,
-0.0272191782,
-0.4494924843,
-0.4477908015,
-0.0056130881,
0.3261151612,
0.3690910637,
0.2487360984,
-0.0864124522,
-0.7825292945,
-0.8625684977,
-0.2330360264,
-0.2676024735,
0.0645120889,
0.5407027006,
0.4802580178,
-0.5393809676,
0.5945445299,
-0.4651167989,
-0.454318583,
-0.0245571025,
0.1692488492,
-0.2008434087,
0.0031108556,
0.4664304852,
-0.9909292459,
-0.5719843507,
-0.0965839475,
-0.8191369176,
0.0078161368,
-0.4982360005,
0.0746932477,
0.5232233405,
0.3001128137,
-0.3795081973,
0.6122939587,
0.7020365,
-0.3020473719,
0.9318515062,
0.0325914547,
0.4366315901,
-0.6058720946,
-0.3808710575,
-0.0152304713,
0.0531600676,
-0.4252146482,
-0.4498224556,
-0.1337119788,
0.283765316,
-0.4432493448,
0.4725435674,
-0.5362138748,
-0.0960083902,
0.0120345578,
0.1718787998,
0.1352618188,
0.1603936404,
0.0317003317,
0.7866348028,
0.5960562229,
-0.4439080656,
0.2501412928,
-0.1101806238,
-0.604563117,
0.283325702,
-0.2846815884,
0.103757374,
-0.2298789471,
0.0131234368,
-1.0864804983,
-0.4973472655,
0.4422461092,
-0.3962973058,
-0.0692845061,
0.2546155751,
-0.6027593613,
-0.3052303791,
-0.431086868,
0.2363609225,
0.5987581611,
-0.3694794476,
0.7293513417,
0.2145224512,
0.1787126064,
-0.4062250257,
-0.9012761116,
0.1318533123,
-0.4255643487,
-0.3171078861,
0.2168070227,
-0.3354074061,
-0.5599272847,
-0.2826318741,
-0.4661873281,
0.3115136623,
0.0176849142,
0.8413693905,
0.2697781324,
0.1772386134,
-0.0005585002,
-0.0302654598,
0.2359389961,
0.3709739745,
0.2954645157,
0.5727469921,
0.0289035421,
-0.6192175746,
-0.625682652,
0.1543090641,
0.4416230917,
0.5858818889,
0.7144537568,
0.5086112618,
-0.6276052594,
-0.1963132173,
-0.8651654124,
-0.5331326723,
-0.5180609822,
-0.010480023,
-0.1799217612,
-0.6685247421,
0.7670351267,
0.2159290016,
-0.5815374851,
0.2002198696,
0.5390723348,
-0.2291879654,
1.1989810467,
0.5854735374,
0.0621077791,
0.4780924022,
0.1480269879,
0.2869254649,
-0.531709373,
-0.4920898974,
-0.318353802,
-0.2190725654,
-0.73972857,
-0.5061457753,
0.3580062687,
-0.1001142412,
0.1378092915,
-0.0126374895,
-0.6709538698,
0.560153842,
0.02026839,
0.4454069436,
0.3533525169,
0.1513606459,
0.0847376212,
-0.5241273642,
-0.2767727375,
-0.6508111358,
0.9244466424,
0.3121883571,
0.7562877536,
0.1820596308,
0.5531261563,
0.7228047848,
0.4376958311,
-0.7973085046,
0.5172129273,
0.4158832431,
-0.5250492692,
-0.1660131067,
-0.3646469712,
-0.6920740604,
0.0834163725,
-0.4088173211,
-0.7655050159,
0.2662484646,
0.0261665173,
-0.3248080015,
0.2286321521,
-0.5308549404,
0.310290575,
-0.2806442678,
-0.2485821694,
-0.2452347875,
-0.5292630792,
0.4927081168,
-0.1060976014,
0.4320893288,
-0.2182065994,
0.1066416875,
0.7047531605,
0.3073966503,
1.3426501751,
0.0361428931,
-0.2562518418,
0.2168637216,
0.4914966524,
0.5624643564,
0.0161849558,
-0.0883963555,
0.2256476283,
-0.3676835299,
-0.1744509488,
-0.4614855051,
0.6486496329,
-0.756677866,
-0.8271363974,
-0.6656627655,
-0.5540781617,
-0.206696108,
-0.0386920869,
0.4272208214,
-0.017620774,
-0.3104940057,
-0.0986304432,
1.0039414167,
-0.3385805786,
-0.0195685718,
0.1384371221,
-0.5330160856,
-0.2566498816,
0.6900936961,
-0.0017234883,
0.3851541579,
0.0498557277,
0.2687833607,
-0.3268359005,
-0.6506537795,
-0.0006361341,
0.4427844286,
-0.8485547304,
0.0889024436,
-0.7127069831,
-0.1929583251,
-0.626588881,
-0.2898491025,
-0.0399505384,
0.0178264044,
-0.5794484019,
-0.3927075267,
0.3138384521,
0.9007517695,
-0.0725978091,
0.2066280097,
-0.3254272938,
0.3384600282,
0.3222271502,
0.2919653356,
-0.1099271551,
-0.5967906117,
-0.0439012535,
0.1570106447,
-0.2460280955,
-1.0744986534,
0.4176772833,
-0.2480791956,
0.6887935996,
0.9243314266,
0.2771392763,
0.5491607785,
-0.0020635682,
0.9670477509,
0.3272210956,
-0.756090939,
0.2254024893,
-0.2782990336,
-0.1955960095,
0.4305712879,
0.6851574779,
-0.8228998184,
-0.6294831038,
-0.4316437244,
-0.4829185903,
0.3971121609,
0.0707603619,
0.3619823754,
-0.058082141,
0.0667274818,
0.5701493025,
0.2904829383,
-1.158223629,
-0.367706269,
-0.3104542792,
0.1210351586,
-0.0538050644,
-0.7268797159,
-0.4055395722,
-0.1739775687,
0.3417699337,
0.0891271457,
0.3345195949,
0.3549517393,
-0.1255012006,
-0.4775075912,
0.0174482241,
0.9094893336,
0.7578073144,
-0.3922368884,
0.498914808,
0.0328747258,
-0.6444892287,
-0.1066790745,
-0.5399511456,
-0.0860195756,
0.1924030185,
0.3649970889,
0.8660432696,
0.1074699834,
-0.7050718665,
0.5321038961,
0.0512332767,
-0.3039183617,
-0.5108889341,
0.042467963,
-0.0795496926,
0.0616547912,
0.4882888496,
0.0879792497,
0.2505133152,
-0.8409860134,
0.09475521,
0.2141460478,
-0.6803914309,
-0.4237087667,
0.545896709,
-0.1195181906,
-0.373660177,
0.4149107933,
-0.27287063,
-0.6960378885,
0.3071474433,
0.5089828968,
0.7885077596,
-0.0964482874,
0.4565505385,
0.115674071,
0.5927740335,
-0.0449154824,
0.3555520773,
0.1687884033,
-1.1514408588,
-0.0541332439,
-0.6966400743,
-0.5416849852,
0.2060159594,
-0.6484366059,
0.2325082123,
-0.3702668846,
-0.2320889831,
-0.1258410513,
-0.2623258233,
-0.3985470831,
0.166781038,
0.2614245713,
0.6503263116,
-1.1401126385,
0.4438857436,
0.2730844915,
-0.4656512737,
-0.5723053813,
0.4818667471,
0.3070183396,
-0.4556665719,
0.3555737734,
0.496271193,
-0.2415792793,
-0.4220264852,
-0.544885993,
-0.4365530312,
0.815669477,
0.1788139045,
-0.3560313284,
0.0075512426,
0.5509713888,
0.6921317577,
-0.3830544651,
-0.0116169415,
0.5610551834,
0.6754999161,
0.3398628831,
-0.6180621386,
0.2167852372,
0.133543998,
-0.0752228349,
-0.2079848498,
-0.3166084588,
0.7155126929,
-0.3015596867,
-0.5497239828,
-0.1836213619,
0.3648372889,
0.273357749,
0.5744464993,
0.6444693208,
0.1780223697,
0.7405354381,
-0.1458318681,
0.9742460251,
0.0861762688,
-0.1062798873,
0.875838697,
-0.4584923089,
0.5465957522,
0.7712061405,
-0.092810221,
0.7273511291,
0.7012764215,
0.0568514355,
0.4603993297,
0.3115423918,
-0.5036762357,
-0.1834738106,
-0.1252829731,
-0.3660711944,
0.1451315284,
0.5322586894,
-0.2581714392,
0.1915466934,
0.2495374084,
-0.0815652832,
0.3101647198,
-0.0569549277,
0.6848765016,
0.0920251459,
-0.3871665597,
0.5032482743,
-0.2944373488,
0.9499049783,
-0.2599739432,
-0.1744952798,
-0.2913473248,
-0.2082543522,
-0.513823092,
-0.6920362711,
0.5182387829,
-0.3365754783,
-0.1897073388,
-0.2289007157,
0.7063000798,
-0.108092621,
-0.320581615,
0.5997650027,
0.3404043913,
0.5164233446,
-0.4180293381,
-0.468002826,
0.3779127002,
0.2152475566,
-0.123371318,
0.3229294717,
0.4548490047,
-0.1532381475,
0.7145130038,
0.6956837773,
0.3122282624,
0.343986541,
0.0838114992,
0.600353837,
-0.637234211,
-0.3364147246,
-0.583478868,
0.3508070707,
-0.0093889153,
-0.1636431515,
0.7738116384,
0.4487449527,
0.8510584235,
-0.2859099209,
0.595220387,
0.1222785711,
0.2563528419,
-0.3758502305,
0.8609747887,
-0.5048566461,
0.3944812119,
-0.1628023535,
-0.8882812858,
-0.2156074941,
0.5800155997,
-0.410051167,
0.0432147533,
0.8156993389,
0.9604714513,
0.2517159879,
0.1916908175,
0.6843550801,
0.5074157119,
-0.0666518733,
0.0534559079,
1.1303095818,
-0.0898213238,
0.3353680968,
-0.5323678255,
-0.0232289117,
-0.5213495493,
-0.8061126471,
-0.8401589394,
-0.6789834499,
-0.2646488845,
-0.6188387871,
-0.0853341371,
0.5375269651,
0.3462663293,
-0.9172914624,
-0.1817065179,
-0.0641413629,
0.1998986602,
-0.1832157969,
-0.3378044367,
0.0991227478,
0.0229336899,
-0.6611379981,
0.1917313188,
0.3833277822,
0.5235145092,
-0.6690759063,
-0.2650019526,
0.1998601109,
0.2558515966,
0.461800158,
0.0056687803,
-1.0484169722,
-0.5835746527,
0.0685365647,
-0.4201478064,
0.2215967029,
0.6860824823,
-0.7287160158,
0.3332310915,
0.2479283959,
0.0603402518,
0.4347956479,
-0.1098176166,
0.3173691034,
-0.520160377,
0.2051744312,
0.2996074259,
0.2376517802,
0.5077877045,
-0.8657128811,
0.3677754998,
0.4344808459,
-0.2366456538,
-1.0852572918,
0.3115256429,
-1.2690409422,
-0.164601475,
1.2642983198,
0.1635512114,
-0.0927826911,
-0.3260937333,
-0.4309056103,
0.2134482861,
-0.2246082723,
1.4561600685,
0.775858283,
-0.281475842,
0.0878494978,
-0.6509487629,
0.7450083494,
0.364062041,
-0.8079924583,
0.1213812754,
0.6386157274,
0.1832686514,
0.4324845672,
0.2318653017,
-0.201376915,
0.2441702187,
0.1542491168,
0.0649799034,
0.1242949814,
-0.4913880527,
-0.3478044868,
-0.0261013955,
-0.0279498324,
0.1926610917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03732v1
|
SHROOM-INDElab at SemEval-2024 Task 6: Zero- and Few-Shot LLM-Based Classification for Hallucination Detection
| 2024-04-04T18:01:21 | 2024-04-04T18:01:21 |
Bradley P. Allen, Fina Polat, Paul Groth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We describe the University of Amsterdam Intelligent Data Engineering Lab
team's entry for the SemEval-2024 Task 6 competition. The SHROOM-INDElab system
builds on previous work on using prompt programming and in-context learning
with large language models (LLMs) to build classifiers for hallucination
detection, and extends that work through the incorporation of context-specific
definition of task, role, and target concept, and automated generation of
examples for use in a few-shot prompting approach. The resulting system
achieved fourth-best and sixth-best performance in the model-agnostic track and
model-aware tracks for Task 6, respectively, and evaluation using the
validation sets showed that the system's classification decisions were
consistent with those of the crowd-sourced human labellers. We further found
that a zero-shot approach provided better accuracy than a few-shot approach
using automatically generated examples. Code for the system described in this
paper is available on Github.
|
[
-0.3193792701,
-0.6472916603,
0.8146976829,
0.2235406488,
-0.2042210549,
-0.3689759076,
-0.0968791842,
-0.5786509514,
0.1972544938,
0.3955585361,
-0.5601260066,
-0.721924305,
-0.5973359942,
0.5104008317,
-0.5411747694,
0.3134639263,
0.0263651479,
0.2913165092,
-0.4143390656,
-0.2037966549,
-0.8553893566,
-0.6202731729,
-0.0313820429,
-0.4890967607,
0.5158545375,
0.7369522452,
-0.0580863506,
0.3249676824,
0.4542309046,
0.2202926576,
0.1837255955,
0.0191723499,
-0.1202725843,
0.4814554453,
-0.1147547066,
-0.2652297318,
-0.1448262334,
-0.2466511428,
0.0487185344,
0.3993027508,
-0.1327839345,
0.159845233,
0.0295895543,
0.2467563897,
-0.6141240001,
0.1549049169,
-0.5939577222,
0.2828478217,
-0.2975482345,
-0.5165912509,
-0.6267576814,
-0.0997039005,
-0.2822702527,
-0.0356519483,
0.1912810057,
-0.1445529014,
0.4286928475,
0.7218831778,
-0.1557969302,
-0.3854650259,
-0.342194587,
0.616559267,
-0.6982529759,
0.4460191131,
0.4004755616,
0.3529793322,
-0.3015359044,
-0.5784226656,
-0.4343384206,
0.0357385986,
0.1790252924,
-0.0056303446,
0.1384901702,
0.0715105608,
0.3976235092,
-0.023476813,
-0.714425385,
0.3364769518,
-0.5313560367,
-0.3237039745,
0.5061504245,
0.1973205954,
0.0459129363,
-0.247495532,
-0.2325352728,
0.3431452215,
-0.4852761328,
-0.311852932,
-0.127293542,
0.4804677069,
0.1370120794,
0.6251841187,
-0.4290728867,
0.5263970494,
-0.0051003513,
0.0902220309,
0.4330840409,
0.0337451994,
-0.1766184419,
0.516102612,
0.4547019601,
0.0329347327,
-0.2223919928,
-0.082772702,
-0.4064644575,
0.4307982326,
0.2052115947,
-0.7998395562,
-0.2710376084,
0.3065700829,
-0.4180333316,
-0.4767204523,
-0.2345971018,
-0.6115333438,
-0.7022066116,
-0.5200145245,
0.9946608543,
-0.276819557,
0.1476304829,
0.1819619089,
0.0248526409,
0.5832625031,
0.5304072499,
-0.6369228363,
0.0507062376,
0.5952101946,
0.7879661322,
-0.6640848517,
-0.4018631279,
-0.744030118,
-0.0631136522,
-0.1904426366,
1.0785365105,
-0.5356822014,
-0.2852041721,
-0.0580964535,
-0.0166612584,
0.1088987291,
-0.6628975272,
0.7743399739,
-0.0966604352,
0.3609209061,
-0.2730465233,
-0.7621201277,
-0.3026119173,
0.2254284769,
-0.2490799129,
0.8986708522,
0.1670137197,
-0.4357227683,
0.44682616,
-0.5951223373,
-0.3814121187,
0.7515647411,
-0.6041350365,
-0.2699180841,
0.2279707342,
0.0636031404,
0.7390096188,
0.041147586,
0.33979249,
-0.3568370938,
-0.8273082972,
-0.0211576335,
-0.2776823938,
0.7273775339,
0.1444424093,
-0.7299607992,
0.2554367781,
-0.7825978994,
-0.2007047683,
-0.0153296469,
-0.2239117026,
-0.0086581362,
-0.34008798,
0.0364999473,
0.4070329666,
0.070104979,
-0.458761096,
0.3156240284,
-0.1090184227,
0.2921784818,
0.8830637932,
0.200808093,
0.3261751533,
-0.0808512866,
0.4903198183,
-0.0314760916,
0.224996686,
-0.3074250221,
-0.4260300994,
-0.8381231427,
-0.3745419085,
0.2123189718,
0.5187135935,
-0.5865812302,
0.7557679415,
0.1778542995,
-0.3130248785,
-0.1697461307,
0.026002828,
-0.0410786681,
0.5921211839,
0.4285703599,
-0.2436098158,
-0.6687963009,
-0.9345936179,
0.2066247165,
0.0394917019,
-0.0140050258,
0.19123514,
0.9260062575,
-0.6375768185,
0.4213122129,
-0.3254122138,
-0.8004840612,
-0.163406834,
0.1686071157,
0.3777202368,
0.3998028636,
0.3363794088,
-0.3066214025,
-0.2060475498,
-0.0923361853,
-1.1715352535,
-0.5491917133,
0.0790361539,
-0.1461176425,
0.4889812171,
0.5943731666,
-0.3597469926,
0.5791777372,
0.1262373924,
-0.308901906,
0.4994310439,
0.217786625,
0.2153289914,
-0.858507812,
-0.2113477439,
-0.3155956566,
-0.1597882658,
-0.753978014,
-0.2632198334,
0.056575004,
-0.0672834516,
-0.6607698798,
0.3909740448,
-0.1159927547,
-0.1559649408,
-0.498960346,
-0.2850563526,
-0.2526218295,
0.7881650925,
0.2760454416,
0.3922347724,
0.54347229,
-0.6248413324,
0.2401747406,
0.3211536407,
-0.4163299799,
0.6010630131,
-0.283396244,
0.3147307932,
0.0400559939,
0.12677899,
-0.83805722,
-0.6369780302,
0.389852047,
-0.6318906546,
0.1430961341,
0.1339748353,
-0.4564222097,
-0.2714203298,
-0.2634040117,
0.2446587831,
0.4653579891,
-0.682927072,
0.594022572,
0.3729360998,
0.0573232137,
-0.3523209095,
-0.704305172,
0.1186174005,
-0.3662618697,
-0.3775774837,
0.2637432814,
-0.0449468233,
0.0589831956,
-0.2402633131,
-0.3775646985,
-0.0766417459,
0.0920992568,
0.5194946527,
0.2265402824,
0.1096720845,
0.157725215,
-0.0898618549,
-0.1153897867,
0.2185430229,
-0.2753614187,
0.5693002939,
-0.1716880798,
-0.6002708673,
-0.6129036546,
0.230276227,
0.4239008427,
0.3638122678,
0.2848933637,
0.5458426476,
-0.8252539635,
-0.6067484021,
-0.6599906087,
-0.5704473853,
-0.4670064747,
0.1449304223,
-0.4512131214,
-0.9089857936,
0.4136460125,
0.192961365,
-0.0038336366,
0.2503239214,
0.7711802721,
-0.2279622406,
0.9906935096,
0.5795816779,
0.1511893868,
0.2743246555,
-0.15223746,
0.1988043636,
-0.4511629641,
-0.431216538,
-0.5937170982,
-0.5309990644,
-0.1000046805,
-0.4919347763,
0.3954086602,
-0.1514071524,
-0.2350478023,
0.4820122123,
-0.9132845402,
0.4391358197,
0.5063441992,
0.0825497657,
0.2444729954,
0.0113789979,
-0.0218553431,
-0.2447504997,
-0.7058903575,
-0.3743696213,
0.8274979591,
0.2665756047,
0.8220970631,
-0.2157612443,
1.168304801,
0.6796270013,
0.2180590332,
-1.0742045641,
0.7628609538,
0.2438249141,
-0.3371051252,
-0.4303917289,
-0.0082693892,
-0.5583902597,
0.3491764665,
0.071419917,
-0.7122501731,
0.5177161694,
-0.1780811101,
-0.36943537,
-0.0381404385,
-0.407515496,
0.8007121682,
-0.3565500677,
-0.2988912761,
0.0039428002,
-0.4919466674,
0.4277254641,
-0.2018076926,
-0.0067588589,
-0.2383452207,
0.132933557,
0.7035167217,
-0.2304477096,
0.7800787091,
-0.4716770649,
-0.0187823121,
0.2062487602,
0.1723162979,
0.4279970825,
-0.1080618873,
0.0154261589,
0.2301421762,
-0.0797151029,
-0.0869534239,
-0.440484941,
0.5969823599,
-0.3514913619,
-0.4016323984,
-0.6793009639,
-0.3074997365,
-0.1860642135,
0.1613162756,
0.6253925562,
0.4260987639,
0.0775012523,
0.5574336648,
0.8151983023,
-0.2824603915,
0.2135593146,
0.2779013813,
-0.2981136739,
-0.2515277565,
0.8348404765,
0.0968755111,
-0.2917945385,
0.2405698746,
0.0712232292,
-0.4172261655,
-0.7377699614,
-0.160731554,
0.2153370529,
-1.0448685884,
-0.5458710194,
-0.7775040269,
-0.3400655091,
-0.6270467043,
-0.3654642105,
-0.1927887052,
-0.309106946,
-0.3421123624,
-0.1512438804,
-0.007748194,
0.5706166029,
-0.1606637537,
0.0075906706,
-0.583999455,
0.189664498,
0.3295861483,
0.0887770057,
-0.399902761,
-0.9193121791,
-0.1595590711,
-0.5187564492,
-0.300342977,
-0.87107867,
0.5232434273,
-0.0507343598,
0.7800984383,
0.3901053369,
0.1782984287,
0.6172218323,
-0.2423737049,
0.6935798526,
0.1072876453,
-0.8901388049,
0.8220639825,
-0.1524585932,
0.2943178713,
0.8723804951,
0.2102702707,
-0.5189951062,
-0.4069025517,
-0.3796173036,
-0.7342271805,
0.8269036412,
0.2399979681,
-0.1994544715,
0.0726633295,
0.1723528057,
0.4780798256,
0.182257846,
-0.8048748374,
0.1491024643,
0.0130263139,
-0.2927189171,
0.3609046042,
-0.2869590223,
0.0598753132,
-0.3711856902,
0.9095908403,
-0.2780846357,
0.3433722258,
0.2803743184,
-0.5311709046,
0.0335259177,
0.2610380948,
0.6499464512,
0.5031892657,
-0.2845748961,
0.1258776039,
0.507740736,
-0.3257154226,
0.2030922025,
-0.2423011959,
-0.4347659051,
0.1455002725,
0.3513256907,
0.6219496727,
0.2320099324,
-0.7298593521,
0.5017407537,
-0.018332459,
-0.6521276832,
-0.5724480152,
0.1138807833,
-0.3239018917,
0.4754691422,
0.3060008883,
-0.0345960259,
0.611415267,
-0.1851559877,
0.4537439346,
0.1069249287,
-0.6061451435,
-0.4230048954,
0.8071336746,
0.2164329588,
-0.3770119846,
0.4675576985,
-0.4949011207,
-0.6192100644,
0.5256190896,
0.3796776831,
1.2255616188,
-0.2706550062,
0.1453567296,
0.4307797849,
0.1456339508,
-0.2701214552,
0.5564464331,
-0.298227042,
-0.6568624377,
-0.0974897593,
-0.7305366993,
-0.3807305992,
0.501668334,
-0.4062950313,
0.8056157231,
-0.2513872683,
0.1089417711,
-0.0552683622,
-0.2050868124,
-0.5925840139,
-0.2507529557,
0.5683192015,
0.7999577522,
-0.9394179583,
0.8332800865,
0.4762389958,
-0.2128340453,
-0.4298974276,
-0.2364802808,
0.3896969259,
-0.3023906648,
0.6640031934,
0.7146348953,
-0.1174199954,
-0.1001408398,
-0.7942198515,
-0.4122605622,
1.2002470493,
0.1103906855,
-0.5056811571,
-0.0198457018,
-0.127691865,
0.3609166741,
-0.412009865,
-0.1131077334,
0.6306377053,
0.4300692379,
0.4326471686,
-0.6127923727,
-0.2015348971,
-0.157770887,
-0.2182854861,
-0.0351249054,
-0.2260746509,
0.4424225092,
0.0213740412,
-0.2177622467,
0.0584680401,
0.7893614769,
0.6131439209,
0.6412431002,
0.4385999143,
0.5949053168,
0.6721431613,
-0.1706207544,
0.5005318522,
-0.0959634185,
0.1652967185,
1.3817249537,
-0.8011992574,
0.739977479,
0.5242132545,
-0.0237305425,
0.2289381772,
0.7711035013,
-0.2472088188,
0.6179301143,
0.124176383,
-0.3097312748,
-0.413317591,
-0.2223883271,
-0.2972387075,
0.6225909591,
0.6014670134,
-0.0259533823,
-0.1800976694,
0.4969953299,
-0.5863001943,
-0.1334667057,
-0.0811337754,
0.6751924157,
0.256693542,
-0.5439339876,
0.3949604034,
-0.2617155015,
0.9856647849,
-0.2585436106,
-0.2068754882,
-0.2512367666,
0.2560758889,
-0.4170098603,
-0.5629785657,
0.2161087543,
-0.0172045212,
0.158651486,
-0.2085520476,
1.007214427,
-0.357855767,
-0.2639580667,
0.2588104904,
0.3697452843,
0.5292801857,
-0.1727439016,
-0.446432054,
0.1351546049,
-0.0639039576,
-0.1577011645,
0.1297208667,
0.4574658871,
-0.2019803524,
0.5296649933,
0.2069329917,
-0.20325014,
0.1009195,
0.5155206919,
0.4099867642,
-0.8352553844,
-0.3575161994,
-0.7314392328,
0.2114641666,
0.0600349307,
-0.0423671082,
0.7193744779,
0.7516901493,
0.8239982724,
-0.2990564704,
0.7895960212,
-0.0804778486,
0.3695870936,
-0.292732209,
0.2976329923,
-0.4719753265,
0.2949298322,
-0.1533807963,
-1.0343952179,
-0.4893684685,
0.7710205317,
0.0231725387,
-0.2238682061,
0.8360057473,
1.0271472931,
0.1611035466,
0.0760941654,
0.6150780916,
0.112943545,
0.2284792215,
0.7391144633,
1.1550369263,
-0.3543309569,
0.3477511108,
-0.4467897713,
-0.0701327249,
-0.5478850603,
-0.6220280528,
-0.8416669369,
-0.8113932014,
-0.4919168651,
-0.2412756085,
-0.1575995237,
1.1957495213,
0.4975133836,
-1.1172020435,
-0.1857970804,
-0.0913652852,
-0.0053705131,
-0.0240480788,
-0.2491461337,
0.1014677584,
-0.5508671403,
-0.683439374,
0.663446188,
0.7640277743,
0.0205182862,
-0.1795615256,
-0.1776939183,
-0.1687657386,
-0.1515917778,
0.8590387702,
0.0753284618,
-0.7593392134,
-0.376563549,
0.1854896694,
-0.2115779668,
0.0798831061,
0.5937069058,
-0.8165025711,
0.3496483862,
1.0335421562,
0.6696478724,
0.4249378443,
-0.0878214315,
0.1796744168,
-0.4924277961,
0.2021048069,
0.6859163642,
0.4162757397,
0.0619365387,
-0.472099334,
0.9678837061,
0.3722268045,
-0.8448864222,
-1.1803286076,
-0.1538376957,
-1.0093472004,
-0.4717157483,
1.1164596081,
0.482847929,
-0.3159327209,
-0.3563560247,
-0.1631742865,
0.0214373264,
-0.3145978749,
1.0428837538,
0.8465440273,
-0.533164084,
-0.175380528,
-0.7705866098,
0.408369422,
0.2626142502,
-1.1243495941,
-0.2301065028,
0.7978412509,
0.0054253973,
0.0726725161,
0.8784972429,
-0.268910557,
0.5692240596,
-0.2086547911,
0.3817139864,
0.0124371871,
-0.6893277764,
-0.7965424061,
0.2180492878,
-0.1509005576,
-0.3409682214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03653v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03653v2
|
CoMat: Aligning Text-to-Image Diffusion Model with Image-to-Text Concept Matching
| 2024-04-04T17:59:46 | 2024-06-03T06:02:34 |
Dongzhi Jiang, Guanglu Song, Xiaoshi Wu, Renrui Zhang, Dazhong Shen, Zhuofan Zong, Yu Liu, Hongsheng Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Diffusion models have demonstrated great success in the field of
text-to-image generation. However, alleviating the misalignment between the
text prompts and images is still challenging. The root reason behind the
misalignment has not been extensively investigated. We observe that the
misalignment is caused by inadequate token attention activation. We further
attribute this phenomenon to the diffusion model's insufficient condition
utilization, which is caused by its training paradigm. To address the issue, we
propose CoMat, an end-to-end diffusion model fine-tuning strategy with an
image-to-text concept matching mechanism. We leverage an image captioning model
to measure image-to-text alignment and guide the diffusion model to revisit
ignored tokens. A novel attribute concentration module is also proposed to
address the attribute binding problem. Without any image or human preference
data, we use only 20K text prompts to fine-tune SDXL to obtain CoMat-SDXL.
Extensive experiments show that CoMat-SDXL significantly outperforms the
baseline model SDXL in two text-to-image alignment benchmarks and achieves
start-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.3408862054,
-0.5768995881,
0.6470195055,
0.1651231945,
-0.5782971382,
0.0071343533,
-0.0794964954,
-0.2953386903,
-0.0699255988,
0.3136573136,
-0.589528501,
-0.4770964682,
-0.7240159512,
0.0405346118,
-0.3592042625,
0.8886054754,
-0.1243933886,
-0.0580506921,
-0.5090780854,
-0.1670571566,
-0.8365107179,
0.1294535547,
-1.1721414328,
-0.0884249285,
0.4480569661,
0.3967331946,
0.6465083957,
0.8133306503,
0.6545129418,
0.1733556986,
-0.0615062863,
0.2627338171,
-0.3072553277,
-0.032335002,
-0.3871124387,
-0.3218001425,
-0.0948254168,
-0.1551176012,
0.4830058515,
0.4230778515,
-0.0407239534,
-0.1659529656,
0.0066978144,
0.8402765989,
-0.7674293518,
-0.211241737,
-0.612934649,
0.126833424,
0.0313706361,
-0.1465460807,
-0.5909668207,
-0.0741987452,
0.267942071,
-0.7372172475,
0.5189033747,
0.367346704,
1.0876042843,
0.8894863129,
-0.4182626903,
-0.0686103106,
-0.4211071134,
0.7083889246,
-0.554118216,
0.3240453303,
0.0538392253,
0.0146151548,
0.1305204332,
-0.5865055323,
-0.6734619737,
0.0209657997,
-0.1213137135,
0.4058291912,
-0.2470211834,
-0.0244901851,
-0.0782149434,
-0.0267408993,
-0.5434931517,
0.2284239084,
-0.0696183369,
-0.00870232,
0.340597719,
0.0722439662,
0.2236990631,
0.0886712745,
-0.89646703,
0.0605372004,
-0.5258209109,
-0.129841432,
0.0151162054,
0.1598972827,
-0.1907321364,
0.6171687841,
0.0548455715,
0.7208620906,
0.6122815013,
0.3671732843,
-0.0271798149,
-0.3693186045,
-0.3486440182,
0.2869473696,
0.7793823481,
0.7156852484,
-0.0233780034,
-0.22460033,
-0.2244562358,
0.1486009657,
0.2410796881,
-0.9606335163,
-0.1050185785,
0.2146190852,
-0.3285440505,
-0.4731089771,
-0.1550122201,
-0.6177894473,
-0.4071812332,
-0.2812578678,
0.5911290646,
-0.3196884394,
-0.0925706923,
0.1945066005,
-0.2794695497,
0.284632057,
0.4481789768,
-0.7130912542,
0.0706732869,
0.3827146888,
1.2694870234,
-0.8250938654,
0.0714142695,
-0.282082051,
0.2326794863,
-0.5508770347,
1.1738620996,
-0.4594641626,
-0.1643434614,
-0.0987755582,
-0.0582280494,
-0.2073309869,
-0.4021176398,
0.6516777277,
-0.6239485145,
0.2925047874,
-0.1418068707,
-0.7248514295,
0.2792412341,
0.2624973059,
-0.6034864187,
0.8177588582,
0.0701184794,
-0.8831089139,
0.2558602989,
-0.9986888766,
-0.356318295,
0.0312516838,
-0.0182571784,
-0.6586201191,
0.0182814542,
0.1275660247,
0.5337611437,
-0.4009381533,
0.1738418043,
-0.0058926228,
-0.2690272629,
0.3806088865,
-0.3522431552,
0.5302579403,
0.262806505,
-0.1002304107,
0.1573219001,
-0.4617011845,
-0.2570667565,
0.0784368217,
0.0348086618,
-0.3662196994,
0.0393845625,
0.2447006106,
0.2964064479,
0.3779814541,
-0.4964219928,
-0.0321307816,
-0.2414239943,
0.5559706092,
0.7773413062,
0.2093470693,
0.7891331315,
-0.179147929,
0.2624192238,
0.5181804299,
0.0776103139,
-0.3776394129,
-0.4135996699,
-0.793106854,
-0.2924296856,
0.4236775935,
0.4516891837,
-0.5628761649,
0.4519979656,
-0.2833823264,
-0.2961765826,
-0.6894218922,
-0.1706469655,
0.2491698265,
0.9411553144,
0.4099211991,
-0.6115235686,
-0.0440716073,
-1.067299962,
0.1748396754,
0.3132821321,
0.0912441164,
0.1686839014,
0.344168067,
-0.2238064259,
1.1210584641,
-0.7520360351,
-0.6235484481,
0.2799800634,
0.1270434856,
-0.2887952924,
0.6787800193,
0.5000380874,
-0.8850415349,
-0.5836653113,
0.212518245,
-0.3823131621,
-0.0451596566,
-0.3500702679,
-0.4618969262,
0.4437747598,
0.7538611889,
-0.7124685645,
0.3693703115,
0.2502744198,
-0.568766892,
0.3022339344,
-0.2220308185,
0.2393132895,
-1.3661409616,
0.2311404496,
0.5417941213,
-0.2601810396,
-0.4228568971,
0.1181432381,
0.3931374252,
-0.1704195589,
-0.4962527752,
0.5517860651,
-0.3281920254,
0.3202781975,
-0.4375997186,
0.3738201857,
0.2287196964,
0.4264901578,
0.4142626524,
0.8584900498,
0.6538424492,
-0.5758044124,
0.0411585905,
0.4067241549,
-0.0930038989,
1.340462923,
-0.6975211501,
0.058366999,
-0.2570302486,
0.1870960444,
-1.4164113998,
-0.0849494785,
0.356125325,
-0.3924643695,
0.4723903537,
0.0609354451,
-0.3663776815,
0.0454481803,
-0.2014958411,
0.661680758,
0.4800162017,
-0.4320545495,
0.3280692995,
-0.0958182812,
0.029113695,
-0.6933105588,
-0.5115513802,
0.3092393279,
-0.3952154815,
-0.570094049,
0.7832904458,
-0.1857090145,
0.382096529,
0.1551163793,
-0.184223637,
-0.2471633554,
-0.1765771806,
-0.0737682953,
0.2466541678,
-0.2040047944,
0.1723189503,
0.2770730555,
-0.3310337663,
-0.1533676088,
-0.4474826753,
0.3646077514,
0.4455587864,
-0.1966891438,
-0.7710652947,
0.3940800428,
0.5625850558,
-0.323343426,
0.7112849951,
0.6762579679,
-0.3585000932,
0.0916368887,
-0.4786750078,
0.0108668674,
-0.442771852,
0.430896461,
-0.0524860471,
-0.5590385795,
0.37748155,
-0.2595739663,
0.084504582,
0.3799117208,
0.3936368227,
-0.4176044762,
1.0262420177,
0.8014958501,
0.1783157736,
0.6268658042,
-0.1068868935,
0.2248063087,
-1.0716860294,
-0.1240142286,
-0.4376783967,
-0.5825695395,
-0.0015783072,
-0.4793764949,
0.1341333538,
-0.1299584657,
-0.3019245863,
0.4087055326,
-0.8439030647,
0.7330624461,
0.2681558132,
0.2886047363,
0.3048255146,
-0.0202702824,
0.0834654123,
-0.2090694755,
-0.5168335438,
-0.2744853199,
0.7084880471,
0.0215933584,
0.727841258,
0.0456660427,
0.4946367145,
0.3314496875,
0.2773391008,
-0.6885222197,
0.4768593609,
-0.2968439162,
-0.2252092063,
-0.2151159346,
-0.0939781368,
-1.005374074,
-0.1196527183,
-0.0089345481,
-0.4563240707,
0.3744091094,
0.1769680232,
-0.4128414094,
-0.1644212753,
-0.9148265123,
1.112267971,
0.0170803424,
-0.538787365,
-0.0963226706,
-0.8183116317,
0.2692504525,
-0.2858729661,
-0.0794516057,
0.0565537177,
-0.4757111371,
0.5465080142,
-0.372436583,
0.9678103924,
-0.0415342934,
-0.4262374938,
-0.0340420306,
-0.0929821655,
0.4056364894,
-0.2151756436,
0.2047038078,
-0.1463385522,
-0.1295920014,
-0.5330560803,
-0.6757953763,
0.6938599944,
-0.6720536351,
-0.445148319,
-0.1466248631,
-0.5471036434,
-0.0258368403,
0.1155832782,
0.8252097964,
0.0280791409,
-0.1956776977,
-0.0478331298,
1.0356566906,
0.0361046195,
0.5886741281,
0.307346493,
0.3086473346,
-0.3162302077,
0.9822963476,
-0.1830132902,
0.6520210505,
0.5903071165,
0.0313048139,
-0.5644066334,
-0.3454967439,
-0.6871894598,
0.0731093884,
-0.6693238616,
-0.6040732265,
-0.4956368506,
-0.1291737258,
-0.1763082296,
-0.6299759746,
-0.3618202209,
-0.3376543224,
-0.8242439032,
0.3273062706,
0.3422524035,
0.1799925864,
0.2441580594,
0.7265917063,
-0.3476769924,
0.2634195983,
0.0136100454,
0.4137643576,
0.1752643138,
-0.7083244324,
-0.2309666127,
-0.0370771363,
-0.611813724,
-0.8749184012,
0.0591514111,
0.3434207439,
0.0995869115,
0.6710955501,
0.087019138,
0.8396461606,
-0.5295473933,
0.7534147501,
0.6272654533,
-0.9344067574,
0.6549658775,
-0.0993122756,
0.3040136397,
0.2750876844,
0.1739521772,
-0.6768119931,
-0.4823802412,
-0.6069201827,
-0.8924014568,
0.5427755713,
0.2857369483,
0.2254167497,
-0.0552770682,
0.4631102085,
-0.0511576198,
0.029134253,
-0.7067694664,
-0.0127222445,
-0.1506282389,
-0.6327987313,
0.2409502715,
0.1896032244,
-0.0918518081,
-0.1474975497,
0.6772720218,
-0.2107344866,
0.2653620541,
0.3646926284,
-0.1795827597,
-0.3473985791,
0.0030496623,
0.7194931507,
0.1024876758,
0.2392992079,
-0.0451789387,
-0.1387450695,
-0.3533361852,
0.3644147813,
0.1301235855,
-0.456933409,
-0.1328618675,
-0.09226235,
0.7364600897,
0.2324337214,
-0.4760302007,
0.6999015212,
-0.1121431962,
-0.3084999025,
0.0768855363,
0.1452392936,
0.2017130703,
0.178288132,
0.3257134259,
0.6008589864,
0.0451108813,
0.0520582981,
0.1958785355,
0.8297527432,
-0.6196499467,
0.1252013743,
1.0923652649,
0.3073222041,
-0.2563785911,
0.4101252854,
-0.1729858816,
-0.1600132585,
0.8299288154,
0.6771009564,
0.9357821941,
-0.0028213002,
0.4248102605,
0.2288364172,
0.2180871367,
-0.2342797667,
-0.1644196361,
-0.1834145039,
-0.7237408161,
-0.4089533389,
-0.2611349523,
-0.1495926976,
-0.1999411285,
-0.5110937953,
0.5269046426,
-0.2245638818,
-0.2412991673,
0.1585937738,
-0.1775807291,
-0.5716823339,
0.3198763728,
-0.1437618583,
0.8598335385,
-0.9724784493,
0.5159162879,
0.5944368839,
-0.5063414574,
-0.3712918758,
0.0728505328,
-0.4138338268,
-0.6747348309,
0.3437477648,
0.186995998,
0.0709488019,
0.6072430015,
-0.9576477408,
-0.7048590183,
1.2596002817,
0.3312726915,
-0.5966953039,
0.1258683205,
0.0886853561,
0.4563099444,
-0.5540500879,
-0.1336553544,
0.4861215651,
0.322006762,
0.4664850235,
-0.3777745664,
0.2632002831,
-0.065061897,
0.1545768678,
0.2565635741,
-0.8848263025,
0.3732219636,
-0.4799280763,
-0.425626874,
0.3552643657,
0.6382239461,
0.0926448032,
0.3698392212,
0.4407396615,
0.9502570629,
0.5146357417,
-0.0975820497,
0.5629782081,
-0.1567229331,
0.3377422392,
0.8517115116,
-0.3434766233,
0.7211309075,
0.6881468892,
0.19193919,
0.2041365355,
1.0127090216,
-0.1537740082,
0.9605973363,
-0.1662487388,
-0.3559345901,
-0.2342064381,
-0.2540670633,
-0.1948814094,
-0.174436152,
0.3083678782,
-0.5547841191,
-0.3469358087,
0.0691687688,
-0.3832150102,
0.0731632411,
-0.1983661503,
0.8868903518,
-0.1254327744,
-0.7240107059,
0.4921919703,
0.0028396156,
0.8214448094,
-0.2184622288,
0.1485632658,
-0.2934774458,
-0.0446846411,
-0.2074463814,
-0.8720482588,
0.1361071318,
-0.1131125167,
-0.4131329656,
-0.026339937,
0.567422688,
-0.6460480094,
-0.3752020299,
-0.1978319138,
0.3100548089,
-0.0880065411,
-0.0333089605,
-0.6816471219,
-0.1150035188,
-0.0418247283,
0.0249132998,
0.2761400938,
0.632156074,
-0.1423133761,
0.4683772922,
0.4597227275,
-0.2636676431,
-0.1405624747,
-0.0028579512,
0.4927826524,
-0.3153466582,
-0.4838237464,
-1.0766029358,
0.6906394362,
-0.2011133134,
-0.4727271795,
0.0568120889,
0.6660602093,
0.5172522068,
-0.255679518,
0.6776324511,
-0.026496239,
-0.2375294417,
-0.5910000205,
0.8075459599,
-0.7668932676,
-0.009526792,
-0.337857455,
-0.9929904938,
-0.3819817603,
0.5667126179,
0.1921079904,
-0.2678065598,
0.8117261529,
0.9172029495,
-0.2615208924,
-0.1489534229,
0.3003118932,
-0.1374372989,
0.2709981501,
0.6313166022,
0.5605410933,
-0.5781341791,
0.508706212,
0.0885776579,
-0.2622447312,
-0.0860305578,
-1.1486705542,
-0.6164408922,
-1.060693264,
-0.886194706,
-0.1941509843,
-0.1083467156,
0.6161860228,
0.7582016587,
-0.399520427,
0.283542186,
-0.3956497908,
0.06960769,
-0.3006328642,
-0.2164693773,
0.637688756,
-0.504770875,
-0.7579474449,
-0.3221982718,
0.4634745717,
0.5432909131,
-0.0406721123,
-0.0445791483,
-0.078934446,
0.2231746018,
0.5665541291,
0.0473962426,
-0.6764665246,
-0.1349442303,
0.2032065541,
-0.254524529,
0.4234092236,
0.6151811481,
-0.6225263476,
0.1771570742,
0.0129855536,
0.7519865632,
0.2735694051,
0.1933144331,
0.3557923138,
-1.2975019217,
0.0084650796,
-0.0084515447,
0.1892692,
0.5203109384,
-0.5773695707,
0.4291126132,
0.2307596505,
-0.5383763313,
-0.7312214971,
0.2573606968,
-1.3964285851,
-0.274454385,
0.8985676169,
0.2676571012,
-0.2327353358,
0.0813169181,
-0.7366797924,
0.4003745615,
-0.5217865705,
1.0175594091,
0.874194324,
-0.0051430245,
-0.5240200162,
-0.2495781779,
0.379139781,
0.552369535,
-0.8087548018,
0.0541208163,
0.4464621544,
0.260890156,
0.2555061579,
0.5437283516,
0.056031663,
0.5206533074,
-0.4060457051,
0.0204330795,
0.2487475127,
0.0053633898,
-0.149053961,
-0.2424497604,
-0.0383971147,
-0.5194615126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03648v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03648v1
|
AutoWebGLM: Bootstrap And Reinforce A Large Language Model-based Web Navigating Agent
| 2024-04-04T17:58:40 | 2024-04-04T17:58:40 |
Hanyu Lai, Xiao Liu, Iat Long Iong, Shuntian Yao, Yuxuan Chen, Pengbo Shen, Hao Yu, Hanchen Zhang, Xiaohan Zhang, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have fueled many intelligent agent tasks, such
as web navigation -- but most existing agents perform far from satisfying in
real-world webpages due to three factors: (1) the versatility of actions on
webpages, (2) HTML text exceeding model processing capacity, and (3) the
complexity of decision-making due to the open-domain nature of web. In light of
the challenge, we develop AutoWebGLM, a GPT-4-outperforming automated web
navigation agent built upon ChatGLM3-6B. Inspired by human browsing patterns,
we design an HTML simplification algorithm to represent webpages, preserving
vital information succinctly. We employ a hybrid human-AI method to build web
browsing data for curriculum training. Then, we bootstrap the model by
reinforcement learning and rejection sampling to further facilitate webpage
comprehension, browser operations, and efficient task decomposition by itself.
For testing, we establish a bilingual benchmark -- AutoWebBench -- for
real-world web browsing tasks. We evaluate AutoWebGLM across diverse web
navigation benchmarks, revealing its improvements but also underlying
challenges to tackle real environments. Related code, model, and data will be
released at \url{https://github.com/THUDM/AutoWebGLM}.
|
[
-0.5798106194,
-0.8030288219,
0.2195982635,
0.3851876557,
0.0438842662,
0.3432500362,
-0.301651299,
-0.5283178091,
-0.1114926338,
0.0663862079,
-0.3773649931,
-0.4879100919,
-0.2478244901,
-0.1053971872,
-0.4820319712,
0.6651642919,
0.0271682609,
0.119996503,
-0.4012926221,
0.1425122023,
-0.0501720458,
-0.422465086,
-0.6647182107,
-0.425091058,
0.4350798726,
0.3930906057,
0.9119606018,
0.5959073305,
0.2980442345,
0.3991925418,
0.2701043487,
0.0879369155,
-0.4253968,
-0.0034812493,
-0.3286516368,
-0.4311801195,
-0.6815844178,
0.1110684052,
0.4117329717,
0.7244022489,
-0.4591276348,
-0.046441935,
0.0992988274,
0.5101256371,
-0.6608557105,
0.359941572,
-0.3155721426,
-0.1369555444,
0.1402446032,
-0.0521052368,
-0.4588337839,
-0.3241764307,
0.113202475,
-0.8403622508,
0.1759549826,
0.352186352,
0.7732073665,
0.2854173779,
-0.605999887,
-0.1271590889,
-0.6250687838,
0.6228377819,
-0.432377845,
0.5808639526,
0.5307067633,
0.2878432274,
-0.3971707225,
-0.6332532167,
-0.4734344482,
-0.3304571807,
0.205673337,
0.232448101,
-0.2424675077,
0.0026905914,
-0.0507145561,
0.2168201804,
-1.0135630369,
0.3877828121,
-0.2802690864,
-0.4246857464,
0.5290858746,
0.1596228927,
0.6006097794,
0.3554111123,
-0.3753107488,
-0.4042445421,
-0.6720340848,
-0.1618046314,
0.33799389,
0.0848718137,
-0.0070920871,
0.1350379884,
-0.3781687617,
0.7933392525,
0.0190168992,
-0.0502646565,
0.2971246243,
0.1100419238,
-0.1346400529,
-0.20537135,
0.590610981,
0.5749819875,
0.4085760117,
-0.3690515161,
-0.3157635033,
-0.0255094301,
0.5492644906,
-0.7536531091,
-0.3845612109,
0.1290406883,
-0.3921916187,
-0.0363795348,
0.0665023178,
-0.5814418197,
-0.1994493306,
-0.1911058873,
0.3479523659,
-0.4647665322,
-0.1860549897,
0.0998231024,
0.0111512635,
0.628505826,
0.5622456074,
-0.7090077996,
0.4876637459,
0.4207045436,
0.6976679564,
-0.5549339056,
-0.5589251518,
-0.4912019074,
0.230673179,
-0.2630236447,
0.6200782061,
-0.5414670706,
-0.2918840647,
0.267136991,
-0.0272021517,
0.0796049312,
-0.5109891891,
0.028491741,
-0.777426362,
0.1631405354,
0.0420206152,
-0.5323401093,
-0.4141888916,
0.396909833,
-0.59868294,
0.698077023,
-0.0487814397,
-0.0313682631,
0.1397823542,
-0.4604095817,
-0.640309155,
0.2577901781,
0.1057113335,
-0.0638398752,
-0.1493835896,
0.1280917972,
0.2251718938,
-0.4951951504,
-0.0337140374,
-0.1872578412,
-0.3468436599,
-0.0836342648,
-0.38837111,
0.7305988073,
0.1310778856,
-0.3768363297,
-0.0413960218,
-0.7167329192,
0.1667917073,
0.2839887738,
-0.6140520573,
-0.1607509255,
0.1423849761,
0.3367087841,
0.2983440757,
0.3521271646,
-0.1850181669,
0.4515624344,
-0.1371887028,
0.0545396842,
0.6640031338,
-0.2358120233,
0.5144023299,
-0.3641966879,
0.8189439178,
-0.1739571691,
0.2394637018,
-0.0387967154,
-0.5403474569,
-1.0748279095,
-0.0048045623,
0.299559474,
0.5959852338,
-0.8325067759,
0.3645583689,
-0.1445254534,
-0.5978472233,
-0.1809806526,
0.2344326526,
0.440893054,
0.1851277351,
0.6712180972,
-0.4380109608,
-0.0466267467,
-0.759583652,
-0.1574195474,
-0.395516336,
-0.0571800657,
-0.0964754075,
0.4822815061,
-0.562615335,
0.8660399914,
-0.5329316258,
-0.2711798847,
-0.315041095,
0.3229089081,
-0.3829679191,
0.5332810283,
0.3619094193,
-0.8802530169,
-0.5942527652,
-0.1962085068,
-0.6186861992,
-0.3219778538,
-0.0655676499,
-0.0466619544,
0.1400451064,
0.5594245195,
-0.5964258909,
0.3778472543,
0.304142803,
-0.1312230527,
0.506457448,
-0.332120657,
-0.1096255183,
-0.5779775381,
-0.1939331889,
0.3309904039,
-0.4844530523,
-0.4976679087,
0.383790642,
0.2114842087,
0.0980134085,
-0.2776990831,
0.7735489607,
-0.8648335338,
-0.0410685018,
-0.5176659226,
0.2492674291,
-0.1609856635,
0.6376940608,
-0.1592969,
0.7262075543,
0.5539188981,
-0.7696784139,
0.6022296548,
0.1449666172,
0.0734110922,
0.3840176761,
-0.333779186,
0.0444947779,
0.1154631078,
0.5271609426,
-0.9242462516,
-0.2760342062,
0.0253663193,
-0.2425810099,
0.3530160487,
-0.1881303638,
-0.7713317275,
-0.3946822584,
-0.2095467001,
0.3092038929,
0.6871117353,
-0.5521850586,
0.6149379015,
0.5768868327,
-0.2131320685,
-0.1990367472,
-0.3518781364,
0.328220129,
0.0858855695,
-0.5059907436,
0.4248037934,
-0.3999856412,
-0.2317290157,
-0.2177485079,
-0.1386579722,
-0.1017153636,
0.21820876,
0.1742229313,
0.257471472,
-0.0101551125,
0.0344684198,
-0.1842861921,
-0.1175111607,
0.1982322335,
-0.4574518204,
0.6232939363,
-0.5784477592,
-0.6048046947,
-0.1986186355,
0.0330558009,
0.4065760672,
-0.2077444941,
0.2086906731,
0.7621251941,
-0.1853895783,
-0.305824548,
-0.6442081332,
0.0039031007,
-0.5671640635,
0.1866218299,
-0.1010329723,
-0.6468917727,
0.4823061824,
-0.3326228857,
-0.0211539976,
0.1936466545,
0.5600546598,
-0.224387899,
1.0031733513,
0.6393579841,
-0.2865841389,
0.3615189195,
-0.1990170926,
-0.1615535617,
-0.3761844635,
-0.2958488166,
-0.1377034485,
-0.4093033969,
-0.7562116385,
-0.4648119509,
0.2693173587,
-0.1121958122,
-0.1418799758,
0.1864023209,
-0.2292995453,
0.3571358323,
0.752981782,
-0.1051256508,
0.3550295234,
-0.0642957538,
-0.3240998089,
0.4302593768,
-0.91431427,
-0.4218098819,
0.9035377502,
0.1679775566,
1.1197880507,
0.3000196517,
0.4459290206,
0.4804077744,
0.2528118789,
-0.6465747356,
0.9332946539,
0.3088418543,
-0.5010599494,
-0.272806108,
-0.2334609181,
-1.0189906359,
0.3878498077,
-0.115591839,
-0.609077394,
-0.0350742452,
0.3114132285,
-0.0700725392,
0.1337548643,
-0.6000955701,
0.7548191547,
-0.4594636261,
-0.7452612519,
-0.3815087676,
-0.7600844502,
0.0242102016,
0.0851159692,
0.2552648783,
0.1512526274,
-0.3334165514,
0.2776752114,
-0.5098453164,
0.9212078452,
-0.1405550539,
-0.2393120825,
0.2047456652,
0.302136302,
0.586063385,
-0.2563545108,
0.381575942,
0.0876976773,
-0.4922986925,
-0.5223548412,
-0.4389855564,
0.6656217575,
-0.6027084589,
-0.8617216349,
-0.6566025019,
-0.2480459958,
-0.6027069688,
0.2028035372,
0.0567815788,
0.4192598164,
-0.4746018648,
0.1296600699,
0.5402050018,
-0.3075716496,
0.6849144101,
0.7981541157,
-0.5998747349,
-0.0284858476,
1.1597770452,
-0.1376904696,
0.2337241173,
0.3350580037,
-0.0338387825,
-0.336299479,
-0.7055017352,
-0.6914863586,
0.0119879944,
-0.6555194259,
-0.1084588319,
-0.2927545905,
-0.3055092096,
-0.1619208008,
-0.2095700949,
-0.1852454245,
-0.1954769194,
-0.1469751447,
0.120237574,
-0.0355836451,
0.8106971979,
-0.2040409148,
0.3783219159,
-0.6250675917,
0.3215742111,
0.5441943407,
0.2531238794,
0.2009706646,
-0.239285484,
-0.4957613349,
-0.1127526611,
-0.3572779596,
-0.6366410255,
0.3955247998,
0.0356805846,
0.7263909578,
0.4395537078,
-0.1076047495,
0.587877214,
-0.5769566894,
0.6479142904,
0.1403944343,
-0.5911580324,
0.1364790499,
-0.5900589228,
0.6775980592,
0.3936038613,
0.4801406562,
-0.3646980524,
-0.497682333,
-0.3995692134,
-0.9238524437,
0.4653312564,
0.2551091015,
-0.1522115767,
0.0512969643,
0.1736003458,
-0.0469827875,
0.166625604,
-0.6781032085,
-0.3405827284,
-0.3005777299,
-0.0285142083,
-0.0165054966,
0.0408172347,
0.2292468697,
-0.2378289253,
0.9932773113,
-0.3576943874,
0.0312994085,
-0.1375486404,
-0.8731282353,
0.0284868963,
0.0947637558,
0.4647020102,
0.744576931,
-0.0984116271,
0.1401092708,
0.1294485033,
-0.647385776,
0.4120834768,
0.274266094,
-0.2972285151,
-0.2929138839,
0.3265492618,
0.333594501,
0.14435938,
-0.8176640272,
0.4800043702,
-0.1335388869,
0.16233778,
-0.381532371,
0.4770747125,
0.1232247055,
0.2461423278,
0.7350432277,
-0.3411614895,
0.3435670435,
-0.5467480421,
0.0510174036,
0.508494854,
-0.2313993126,
-0.2661709189,
0.7101109028,
0.5484783053,
-0.4096031785,
0.6182758212,
-0.5070725083,
-0.6096012592,
0.6079793572,
0.6491481662,
0.7944712043,
-0.3754740357,
0.1695550382,
0.1021579579,
0.4443080723,
-0.2389712334,
0.0399981998,
0.0047320714,
-0.4461496174,
-0.1621712595,
-0.5482644439,
-0.5017747283,
0.0797894374,
-0.5090944767,
-0.1156262234,
-0.3643992841,
-0.0506018251,
-0.3216419816,
-0.1832337528,
-0.693310678,
0.587079823,
0.2752072811,
0.8989664912,
-0.3173728883,
0.8124512434,
0.7448471189,
-0.4987837672,
-0.2036757171,
0.4806452394,
0.3650434017,
-0.7376280427,
0.5268668532,
0.1159481183,
-0.6376795173,
0.1928323358,
-0.5531876087,
-0.830745399,
1.0159776211,
0.0811788067,
-0.6526873708,
-0.2733729184,
0.1701818854,
0.4562163055,
-0.1968533397,
0.3060430288,
0.0949603617,
0.5749831796,
-0.3041810393,
-0.9433827996,
0.0719101503,
-0.3673251867,
0.0047630537,
0.0098831858,
-1.1224251986,
0.581627965,
0.0329537876,
-0.0925350264,
0.0403470621,
0.7052234411,
-0.1182605699,
-0.0336147435,
0.7743512392,
0.4602369666,
0.6465502977,
0.0643285513,
0.8794906735,
-0.4224128723,
0.1676379442,
1.1300703287,
-0.3780349791,
0.6946473122,
0.1179888844,
-0.0120166941,
0.6400008798,
0.6107937098,
-0.0792271048,
0.3341557682,
0.2780997157,
-0.1944419742,
-0.4978039265,
0.2208398134,
-0.1859940439,
0.7618579865,
0.3423572183,
0.0733175352,
-0.4144571722,
0.0932025835,
-0.1775852591,
-0.0430824086,
-0.361238569,
0.6869696975,
0.0832309201,
-0.8099573255,
0.5335378647,
0.2679204047,
0.4161995053,
-0.7278302312,
-0.009976563,
-0.3049179912,
0.0576790869,
0.0423490629,
-0.4776632786,
-0.2882782817,
0.0339870676,
0.0755249262,
-0.4446690679,
0.7716416717,
-0.3452045918,
-0.182612747,
0.520426333,
0.8381944299,
0.1016262919,
-0.0214840472,
-0.7289386392,
-0.0209171623,
-0.0629803836,
-0.3614068627,
0.6813607812,
0.1919421703,
-0.0954488516,
1.1452291012,
0.6006381512,
-0.1226086169,
0.1312218755,
-0.0106003201,
0.7800321579,
-0.8092857599,
-0.5625225306,
-0.791737318,
0.1453039199,
-0.0803593472,
-0.0676883981,
0.8362482786,
1.0090004206,
0.8530990481,
0.1679201424,
0.9038552046,
0.1743249893,
0.0051297029,
-0.5752713084,
0.8458505869,
-0.6834531426,
0.0386331826,
0.0419464111,
-1.0019994974,
-0.0879681259,
0.6928498745,
0.0214131624,
0.3638170362,
0.5732734203,
0.7382001281,
-0.3491466045,
-0.2164656222,
0.4074375331,
0.2588021159,
0.2357547134,
0.4563606381,
0.8275191784,
-0.0837295353,
0.7483320236,
0.0730369017,
-0.2193429768,
-0.6529849172,
-0.8416649103,
-0.8413609862,
-0.5852152109,
-0.2937169075,
-0.3390251696,
0.1702369004,
0.9739750624,
0.8280776143,
-0.486468643,
-0.5003106594,
-0.1300223768,
0.0117983362,
-0.1340782642,
-0.1584431082,
0.0280343443,
-0.4736177027,
-0.7757505774,
0.6864583492,
0.4007997513,
0.2195119113,
-0.6692673564,
-0.2102576941,
-0.3680291772,
0.1018601507,
0.4932469428,
0.4632396698,
-0.6292268038,
-0.1137934998,
-0.1514524221,
-0.3543950319,
0.2564986646,
0.4812714458,
-0.8503322601,
0.4863238931,
0.1137612537,
0.6680834889,
0.7671176791,
0.1036873981,
0.7449610829,
-0.409881115,
0.0116547067,
0.1493788809,
0.4651891589,
0.3725605607,
0.0002019704,
0.637044251,
0.1298141778,
-0.4196580946,
-0.3451551199,
0.2305957228,
-0.9467343688,
-0.5954483151,
1.3811582327,
-0.0295936,
-0.1895800829,
-0.3147145808,
0.0611313879,
0.1178862974,
-0.4665436149,
0.7862946391,
0.6868730187,
-0.1180751622,
0.1295627952,
-0.5988371968,
0.4850831926,
0.2210448086,
-0.9549428821,
-0.158996433,
0.8306424618,
0.2797496915,
0.088876389,
0.4501745105,
0.456163317,
0.44863078,
-0.1703863591,
0.2965273857,
-0.1953411251,
-0.5084144473,
-0.2495055646,
0.2144108564,
-0.0337965302,
-0.0105738873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03646v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03646v1
|
Locating and Editing Factual Associations in Mamba
| 2024-04-04T17:58:31 | 2024-04-04T17:58:31 |
Arnab Sen Sharma, David Atkinson, David Bau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate the mechanisms of factual recall in the Mamba state space
model. Our work is inspired by previous findings in autoregressive transformer
language models suggesting that their knowledge recall is localized to
particular modules at specific token locations; we therefore ask whether
factual recall in Mamba can be similarly localized. To investigate this, we
conduct four lines of experiments on Mamba. First, we apply causal tracing or
interchange interventions to localize key components inside Mamba that are
responsible for recalling facts, revealing that specific components within
middle layers show strong causal effects at the last token of the subject,
while the causal effect of intervening on later layers is most pronounced at
the last token of the prompt, matching previous findings on autoregressive
transformers. Second, we show that rank-one model editing methods can
successfully insert facts at specific locations, again resembling findings on
transformer models. Third, we examine the linearity of Mamba's representations
of factual relations. Finally we adapt attention-knockout techniques to Mamba
to dissect information flow during factual recall. We compare Mamba directly to
a similar-sized transformer and conclude that despite significant differences
in architectural approach, when it comes to factual recall, the two
architectures share many similarities.
|
[
-0.4236458242,
-1.0230846405,
0.8362877965,
-0.0416548476,
0.1196713448,
-0.0323270224,
0.1417350918,
-0.2626931071,
0.4899907708,
0.4987437427,
-0.202210173,
-0.2968168259,
-0.5512772202,
0.0261761565,
-0.3437696695,
0.7140897512,
-0.1226254776,
-0.3584990799,
-0.2666602135,
-0.4970582724,
-0.8585286736,
-0.9589256644,
-0.513209641,
-0.1459466368,
0.6729141474,
0.412163049,
0.8383693099,
0.8499322534,
0.2912574708,
0.3052011132,
-0.3782029152,
0.0374691337,
-0.5132693052,
-0.1948068589,
-0.4674399197,
-0.7782183886,
-0.3456067741,
-0.0205044933,
0.8017032146,
0.728756249,
-0.2387897819,
0.2761455476,
-0.2877862155,
0.6337350607,
-0.9082643986,
0.3022218347,
-0.5575679541,
0.1783026159,
-0.0967051983,
-0.1038718671,
-0.6711186171,
-0.653100729,
0.0609136634,
-0.4570105076,
0.4872462749,
0.3372527361,
1.0240960121,
0.395704776,
-0.7925863862,
-0.3747564852,
-0.9052879214,
0.2505456209,
-0.5146752596,
0.2263966352,
0.5260617733,
0.2912700772,
-0.1030049846,
-0.4785913825,
-0.7938348651,
-0.0643668324,
-0.6076576114,
0.2399002761,
-0.3546477556,
-0.1374860555,
0.5777621865,
0.2500518262,
-0.1861433238,
-0.1211405471,
-0.6400929689,
-0.6395454407,
0.3185562193,
0.2310428917,
0.108138673,
-0.5608456135,
-0.2186733037,
0.0586151667,
-0.887234509,
0.1734396666,
0.2217132896,
0.128370747,
0.1996948123,
0.8992294073,
-0.0863331184,
0.7008329034,
0.2738439441,
-0.2278229147,
0.13597624,
-0.4015683532,
-0.1809287965,
0.4783041775,
0.5195721984,
0.1776855439,
-0.2788184285,
-0.1204106957,
0.0610267557,
-0.1588076353,
0.6305419207,
-0.3781416118,
-0.3564950526,
-0.2581465542,
-0.6182520986,
-0.1137796864,
0.0090913698,
-0.5639448762,
-0.5667640567,
-0.3686199486,
0.8455808759,
-0.4341772199,
-0.1341264248,
-0.0155936982,
0.0738012493,
0.1876839399,
-0.0145837879,
-0.8642930984,
0.2553085089,
0.3624761105,
0.7226342559,
0.2308872789,
-0.1998379081,
-0.3030579388,
0.4412609637,
-0.5492348075,
0.7576096654,
-0.6814661622,
-0.5375466943,
-0.0008701333,
0.1501726806,
-0.2572901845,
-0.580632031,
0.5967131853,
-0.6396112442,
0.2402533293,
-1.0649418831,
-0.6932154298,
-0.7338417172,
0.1054796055,
-0.8572095037,
1.0157351494,
-0.2207544893,
-0.6671183705,
0.4152811766,
-0.5652351379,
-0.7597039342,
-0.8694632053,
0.2265522778,
-0.5822950006,
0.1010481492,
0.1643440574,
0.3917568624,
0.0960855335,
0.3634386361,
-0.113230817,
-0.3428504467,
0.4171227813,
-0.1419284046,
0.539949894,
-0.0771190301,
-0.2887357771,
-0.0308448095,
-1.1707649231,
-0.9593062997,
0.2424641699,
-0.3189184964,
-0.5342268348,
0.1397795677,
-0.8059632182,
0.2303533405,
0.0974440128,
-0.6653998494,
0.3354793191,
0.045302704,
-0.1180000603,
0.5644673705,
0.6637341976,
0.6162260175,
-0.1377696544,
0.2369957119,
0.3979931176,
0.0619178936,
-0.3990532458,
-0.3152699769,
-1.2193977833,
-0.1752519608,
0.2374539971,
0.5117657781,
-0.5872086287,
0.3015922904,
0.0478046127,
-0.3913717568,
-0.500890255,
-0.3288407028,
0.1973322481,
1.0445096493,
0.4999165237,
-0.1183378696,
-0.4685882926,
-1.2581267357,
0.0038576829,
-0.1165028885,
0.2484855205,
0.3817785978,
0.3011623919,
0.052356001,
1.2716538906,
-0.8430555463,
-0.2432423234,
0.1846964806,
0.3742831945,
0.1544411033,
0.2017384022,
1.0016953945,
-0.6726746559,
0.0207792763,
-0.2525997162,
-0.9774394631,
-0.0205177981,
-0.3868940771,
-0.2602690458,
0.2560202777,
0.5348719358,
-0.7541320324,
0.7177878022,
-0.0678587109,
-0.3552595675,
0.3059709072,
-0.2498679012,
0.4563756585,
-0.9403848052,
0.2340727895,
-0.4251264632,
0.0089204721,
-0.5415867567,
-0.4141777158,
0.2181915045,
-0.1038915515,
-0.089261286,
0.3126155138,
-0.4843128026,
-0.4421767592,
-0.2813633084,
0.4398171604,
0.1515641809,
0.7122423053,
-0.143193379,
0.7416219711,
0.4679544866,
-0.9528126121,
0.0466675945,
0.5091516972,
-0.3522698283,
0.2685951889,
-0.4162613451,
0.0617270619,
-0.3778158426,
0.2949059904,
-1.2971285582,
-0.0478365794,
0.4290535152,
-0.117727682,
0.396058172,
-0.2239980549,
-0.6796432137,
-0.2884322405,
0.1911422908,
0.1303453892,
0.4813210666,
-0.5772035718,
0.9150868058,
0.6553490758,
-0.3463544846,
-0.6399782896,
-0.4800558984,
-0.0375357009,
-0.2164658904,
-0.0375396572,
-0.1957792342,
0.2884758115,
-0.077621989,
0.101859279,
-0.2556319833,
0.0449917018,
0.2057669014,
0.4631524086,
0.4776777029,
-0.333399117,
0.2740648091,
0.2782284319,
-0.1189748794,
0.366047442,
0.0903692544,
0.0688250288,
0.1419765502,
-0.3563644886,
-0.2110813111,
0.0165215619,
0.5612365603,
-0.3323841989,
1.0211766958,
0.2468794882,
-0.3512520492,
0.4410633445,
-0.800521791,
0.0950340778,
-0.3940509856,
0.1601412594,
-0.6212352514,
-0.6478847861,
0.9042012095,
-0.2106535882,
0.0275247861,
0.5295904875,
0.5081024766,
-0.0189644992,
0.743984282,
0.7288153768,
-0.1387671828,
0.2457917035,
-0.115140833,
0.3638205826,
-0.8877485394,
-0.4208071232,
-0.5194521546,
-0.3195080459,
-0.0660573319,
-0.3073329926,
0.4741617143,
0.0882622004,
-0.0066381474,
0.4729386568,
-0.0417691432,
0.5899652243,
0.2750293911,
0.0050759665,
0.2818949819,
-0.4002065659,
-0.4679622054,
-0.1300257891,
-1.1218876839,
-0.3503288329,
0.8222862482,
0.1506234854,
0.4045317173,
0.2778855562,
0.3887242377,
0.0533266813,
0.4391698241,
-0.5276061893,
0.5286073685,
0.1938972622,
-0.7300783992,
-0.0060629337,
-0.0845319629,
-0.8136017919,
0.1475811601,
-0.412084192,
-0.6692093611,
0.549022913,
0.2933470905,
-0.5085065961,
0.5464774966,
-0.7290727496,
0.6319503784,
0.4089788795,
-0.208247304,
-0.4301813841,
-0.9361388683,
0.6138939857,
-0.0995316654,
0.3278466165,
0.1366073787,
0.3461537361,
0.5768068433,
-0.1134601533,
1.050313592,
-0.3347141743,
-0.1816656291,
0.46470505,
0.4689780772,
0.42465204,
-0.1109292805,
-0.1228965968,
-0.0095993588,
-0.3733513355,
-0.3443916142,
-0.8974157572,
0.4413613379,
-0.6240830421,
-0.648250401,
-0.311327368,
-0.5739969611,
-0.1572434902,
0.0993468314,
-0.0009197549,
0.7813446522,
-0.3498331606,
0.1147411987,
0.7711196542,
-0.3662111163,
0.386105746,
0.8553548455,
-0.3615835011,
0.0964571759,
0.947868824,
0.4387156665,
0.139854908,
0.6787446737,
0.1073337421,
-0.2487071007,
-0.0996736512,
-0.2755457759,
0.2881624699,
-1.0826474428,
-0.2491459697,
-0.9332344532,
-0.0153309684,
-0.0579923652,
-0.2119815499,
-0.5251597166,
-0.8635370135,
-0.0587725155,
-0.4690377414,
0.3547481298,
0.9591155052,
-0.3675636649,
0.0892342031,
-0.7722826004,
0.6402151585,
0.1622737348,
0.066119723,
0.2801704705,
-0.574213922,
-0.3641480207,
-0.1425455958,
-0.1401163489,
-0.850291431,
-0.2111899853,
-0.2435675412,
0.6896216273,
0.2593570948,
-0.0470855497,
0.7973366976,
-0.7586544752,
0.8509227633,
-0.0992118418,
-0.9621546865,
0.6849986315,
0.0188120827,
0.2691372633,
0.3834353685,
0.5833166242,
-0.3151823878,
-0.5392732024,
-0.6037569642,
-0.4068952203,
0.6210462451,
0.1316567063,
-0.0365160145,
-0.2161262929,
0.7502945662,
0.2244921327,
0.0781954303,
-0.4985926151,
-0.6465348005,
-0.4725153148,
0.1102949828,
0.1360921115,
-0.5216110349,
-0.2955146432,
-0.172201395,
0.5671403408,
0.2076900154,
0.2917821407,
0.4629327655,
-0.2882699072,
0.0307640024,
0.1028202549,
0.7057510614,
0.8431689739,
-0.0457861423,
0.1962186396,
0.3957676888,
-0.2441986054,
0.1649792939,
-0.2154080123,
-0.4795722961,
0.241953522,
0.3210844398,
1.0120244026,
0.8012639284,
-0.065583989,
0.2430705279,
0.0194488801,
0.0366508812,
-0.0126598645,
0.1906816363,
0.0798857957,
0.3054054677,
0.2654521167,
0.5268970728,
0.3612684309,
-0.8626523018,
0.0972345844,
-0.0800199211,
-0.1628373265,
-0.4223358929,
0.8088927269,
-0.1149347126,
-0.098352924,
0.5171052814,
-0.1422762126,
-0.5898596644,
0.5708041191,
0.5312469006,
0.4904085696,
-0.2996285856,
0.1955331415,
0.8538810015,
0.3008952737,
0.1317572892,
-0.1944112629,
-0.1515816599,
-0.7034046054,
-0.329515934,
-0.2729593217,
-0.4024106264,
-0.4149919152,
-0.9750907421,
0.0808204189,
-0.39889732,
-0.1996649206,
0.0129850963,
-0.2897002399,
-0.3237790763,
0.2591990829,
0.2005683929,
0.7305831909,
-0.8835528493,
0.8269607425,
0.4759655297,
-0.5190202594,
-0.9532885551,
0.0149378795,
0.2910700142,
-0.5568817258,
0.5755774975,
-0.2415508628,
-0.3478498161,
-0.2138491124,
-0.4955416322,
-1.1744009256,
1.2970651388,
0.1259200722,
-0.3802775145,
0.2111215442,
-0.2001648694,
0.3703229725,
-0.0602698401,
-0.1663424969,
0.7690419555,
0.4546054304,
0.2214136273,
-0.7027297616,
0.2468612492,
0.1578962654,
-0.2960904241,
0.3075312376,
-1.009888649,
0.6260800958,
-0.4209253788,
-0.3215422034,
0.0314471424,
0.9364765286,
0.1736388355,
0.1362262666,
0.4418652356,
0.3885900974,
1.1258072853,
0.0343107767,
1.1942971945,
-0.1034211293,
0.4001409411,
1.1845097542,
-0.5659665465,
0.5840765238,
0.1775269508,
-0.0619499311,
0.7304631472,
0.3630104363,
-0.0478793345,
0.6521677971,
-0.361266911,
-0.1225512996,
0.0751276687,
-0.0538641587,
-0.1247552484,
0.4183541238,
0.2997120917,
-0.0069353282,
-0.0120378723,
0.1427429765,
0.539548099,
0.0072358702,
-0.2639466226,
0.7335505486,
-0.1904134303,
-0.6643411517,
0.2728425264,
-0.0967547074,
-0.190264672,
-0.6801286936,
-0.0760787502,
-0.4944049418,
-0.0131548187,
0.0751897767,
-0.7002316117,
0.6385746598,
-0.2217287421,
-0.4879236221,
0.1543166041,
0.7887271643,
-0.3850112259,
-0.3768361211,
0.0951467901,
0.1329238713,
-0.0374954045,
0.4703402817,
-0.3293746412,
0.0305638984,
-0.0301471818,
-0.3689828515,
0.1660112739,
0.7267183661,
0.0114798527,
0.5807929039,
0.4855791628,
-0.3049135506,
0.3369917572,
0.1379380077,
0.6809187531,
-0.9728236794,
-0.4965571165,
-0.7036035657,
0.3547672629,
-0.07250797,
-0.1398872435,
0.9288398027,
0.7116984725,
0.4851753414,
-0.1995707601,
0.5273967385,
-0.145745948,
0.5971823335,
-0.9175918102,
0.6495639682,
-0.2661779821,
0.0123697529,
-0.2640816867,
-0.957354188,
-0.269708842,
0.541539669,
-0.1915137321,
-0.4094586074,
0.9276915789,
0.764947474,
-0.2447659075,
0.1076044366,
0.224606961,
1.0822800398,
0.1457472742,
0.2387664169,
0.7676960826,
-0.5899467468,
0.4231228828,
-0.2736320198,
0.0039615114,
-0.2505803108,
-0.6990609169,
-0.7941849828,
-0.7216268778,
-0.3781704307,
-0.1623403579,
-0.24199301,
0.4620652199,
0.3771128953,
-0.6729011536,
0.0835313201,
0.5232596993,
0.4227045178,
-0.0962496772,
-0.2479389012,
0.5392612815,
-0.0157248843,
-0.2683756649,
0.5719053745,
0.5626067519,
0.0650017411,
0.048963096,
0.295054704,
-0.6555219293,
0.3053129911,
0.7674819827,
0.4423361123,
-0.7081480026,
-0.842558682,
-0.0159696769,
-0.0215176884,
0.2330430746,
1.0667114258,
-0.9765420556,
0.5537549257,
0.3048259914,
0.6522420049,
0.6762465835,
0.183303535,
0.5463978052,
-0.8097829223,
0.370046556,
-0.3245100081,
0.7322298884,
0.3652825952,
-0.3495799303,
0.5125639439,
0.367651403,
-0.5535964966,
-0.5206560493,
0.0532936268,
-1.0040667057,
-0.2488052845,
0.8184637427,
-0.1359950751,
-0.1589605361,
-0.2362821549,
-0.6488000751,
0.560185492,
0.1580542326,
0.9990802407,
1.0561944246,
-0.1723595709,
0.0941326767,
-0.5276516676,
0.1182971895,
0.252053678,
-0.4142974019,
0.0139539484,
0.7215582132,
0.3176353574,
0.6118596792,
0.5134433508,
-0.0403567925,
0.3043478429,
0.2313462198,
0.0175512973,
-0.0334316306,
-0.480425328,
-0.1915436089,
0.1294165701,
-0.3989061117,
-0.1182700843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04125v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04125v2
|
No "Zero-Shot" Without Exponential Data: Pretraining Concept Frequency Determines Multimodal Model Performance
| 2024-04-04T17:58:02 | 2024-04-08T21:14:43 |
Vishaal Udandarao, Ameya Prabhu, Adhiraj Ghosh, Yash Sharma, Philip H. S. Torr, Adel Bibi, Samuel Albanie, Matthias Bethge
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Web-crawled pretraining datasets underlie the impressive "zero-shot"
evaluation performance of multimodal models, such as CLIP for
classification/retrieval and Stable-Diffusion for image generation. However, it
is unclear how meaningful the notion of "zero-shot" generalization is for such
multimodal models, as it is not known to what extent their pretraining datasets
encompass the downstream concepts targeted for during "zero-shot" evaluation.
In this work, we ask: How is the performance of multimodal models on downstream
concepts influenced by the frequency of these concepts in their pretraining
datasets? We comprehensively investigate this question across 34 models and
five standard pretraining datasets (CC-3M, CC-12M, YFCC-15M, LAION-400M,
LAION-Aesthetics), generating over 300GB of data artifacts. We consistently
find that, far from exhibiting "zero-shot" generalization, multimodal models
require exponentially more data to achieve linear improvements in downstream
"zero-shot" performance, following a sample inefficient log-linear scaling
trend. This trend persists even when controlling for sample-level similarity
between pretraining and downstream datasets, and testing on purely synthetic
data distributions. Furthermore, upon benchmarking models on long-tailed data
sampled based on our analysis, we demonstrate that multimodal models across the
board perform poorly. We contribute this long-tail test set as the "Let it
Wag!" benchmark to further research in this direction. Taken together, our
study reveals an exponential need for training data which implies that the key
to "zero-shot" generalization capabilities under large-scale training paradigms
remains to be found.
|
[
-0.5013365149,
-0.680365026,
0.5934817791,
0.0985424593,
-0.3411104381,
-0.0434139669,
-0.1134662703,
-0.5571591258,
0.1641923934,
0.0623028837,
-0.8293426037,
-0.3232322037,
-0.5856602192,
0.0220333915,
-0.5577497482,
0.865368247,
0.1033259779,
-0.0265497509,
-0.2614409626,
-0.2494372725,
-0.4001355171,
-0.4593855143,
-0.2950922549,
-0.1665541828,
0.9895136952,
0.0989280939,
0.4365238249,
0.7193225622,
0.410060823,
0.1475472003,
0.3995190263,
-0.2902513742,
-0.5438384414,
0.0873610005,
0.0432532318,
-0.5792458057,
-0.3662735522,
-0.0229146741,
0.794018805,
0.7633192539,
0.046211578,
0.351859659,
-0.3468170464,
0.5184486508,
-1.0393214226,
-0.0228470769,
-0.5935800076,
0.0859598145,
-0.4281155765,
-0.4449652433,
-0.4191496372,
0.070678629,
-0.0203480851,
-0.9799719453,
0.5027908683,
-0.1148627922,
0.9685134292,
0.1257366687,
-0.9812064767,
0.0232381113,
-1.0097801685,
0.7788066864,
-0.4014600813,
0.6344245672,
0.1605887413,
0.115496181,
0.1326211393,
-0.7087717652,
-0.8288503289,
-0.2620640695,
0.4648452997,
0.2652431726,
-0.2541502416,
0.2462180704,
0.660151422,
0.0551053435,
-0.7054201961,
0.0210139994,
-0.2967610657,
0.062170852,
0.604393065,
0.1852299124,
-0.0319075212,
0.110791482,
-0.5530830026,
-0.5135489106,
-0.6585739851,
0.2571258247,
0.3731743097,
0.1148879156,
-0.0509099625,
0.4605872929,
-0.5042968988,
0.6150491238,
-0.0710667372,
-0.14119564,
0.515516758,
-0.4843273759,
-0.1738193184,
-0.1156920269,
0.6510723829,
0.5201166868,
0.3521483243,
-0.0878524557,
-0.214199692,
0.2837299407,
0.4096711576,
-0.9381520748,
0.0865702853,
0.1394225359,
-0.1506194621,
-0.1290391088,
0.0259877145,
-0.5234966278,
0.1693445891,
-0.4513716102,
0.8995203376,
-0.3157634139,
-0.4696779549,
0.0828844234,
-0.5092337132,
0.1363908648,
0.2037883252,
-0.7914741635,
-0.0510386638,
0.4117077589,
0.9502285123,
0.0575719774,
-0.1850208044,
-0.0340843536,
0.2997435033,
-0.6597056985,
0.8559826016,
-0.62832129,
-0.4046723843,
-0.0079795318,
0.0717064887,
-0.3589134812,
-0.1254945099,
0.317520231,
-0.6406928301,
-0.2286887318,
-0.1129991561,
-0.5011443496,
-0.1865843534,
0.0816935077,
-0.62590909,
0.7087514997,
-0.1385852844,
-0.3913595378,
1.0590919256,
-0.6694885492,
-0.4436589479,
0.1095549539,
-0.188355267,
-0.2639363706,
0.4202214181,
-0.0495337993,
0.389277786,
-0.0456229411,
0.1331730634,
-0.8351719379,
-0.5080243349,
0.0320133865,
-0.6754593849,
0.3172809184,
0.1869152337,
-0.2990767956,
0.0653834343,
-1.0826128721,
0.2488369793,
0.0348616429,
0.1366282254,
-0.3093092442,
-0.0374140367,
0.1063760445,
0.4618725777,
-0.2448778003,
-0.6854470372,
0.082079336,
0.108216241,
0.1791650802,
0.7779939175,
-0.0899364278,
0.2907316089,
-0.5110672116,
0.693872571,
0.0301946662,
0.1718450785,
-0.8764147162,
-0.3010794818,
-0.7219826579,
-0.3094784319,
0.3450476229,
-0.027758779,
-0.791708231,
0.0269076563,
-0.5993855596,
-0.6618022919,
-0.1662580073,
-0.1958051771,
0.1599592865,
0.4184322655,
0.37138623,
-0.6104924083,
-0.2911501527,
-0.8450929523,
0.1534337252,
0.121874243,
-0.2041367292,
0.148420155,
0.5812003613,
0.0549610779,
0.9955092669,
-0.3939338028,
-0.1270374358,
0.0745380074,
0.6370913982,
-0.0803009272,
0.4824062288,
0.773707509,
-0.712215662,
-0.3062616885,
-0.3426243961,
-0.8600647449,
0.1657185555,
-0.2406178564,
0.0994374305,
0.0534360409,
0.2334370762,
-0.8362237215,
0.465407759,
0.4649867117,
0.0056533492,
0.5684801936,
-0.1344560385,
0.1515503377,
-0.5491015911,
0.2260610312,
0.2582533956,
-0.0389967524,
-0.7618889213,
0.1655831784,
0.3260682821,
-0.2293449193,
-0.4596362114,
0.4247962832,
-0.3035110831,
-0.0613037832,
-0.1287788302,
-0.2255584151,
0.1519120336,
0.6167789698,
0.2349150479,
0.6686537266,
0.6737829447,
-0.8914211988,
0.0812738314,
-0.2164561301,
-0.2410756052,
0.6681423783,
-0.8225248456,
0.1587510854,
-0.3369066119,
0.5571058989,
-0.8819698095,
-0.3766759038,
-0.2553754151,
-0.4950518906,
0.3352045119,
-0.1249791905,
-0.3398525417,
-0.3387304544,
-0.5134747624,
0.6079323292,
0.3800500929,
0.0066363583,
0.301556915,
-0.0410964862,
0.0407185555,
-0.7850430012,
-0.4744419754,
-0.1740470529,
-0.1514023244,
-0.6447067857,
0.2939749956,
-0.144119069,
0.2297474444,
-0.1943983138,
-0.2981830239,
-0.1267351508,
0.0103948237,
0.5140336156,
0.3481710553,
-0.306887567,
0.6156722903,
-0.064533703,
0.0028648044,
0.0300653614,
-0.2879043221,
0.5398792028,
0.2727463841,
-0.6348167062,
-0.520309329,
0.1810740829,
0.6020748615,
-0.1045742407,
0.693783462,
0.9287818074,
-0.0349512808,
0.0197849181,
-0.5610315204,
-0.1829667985,
-0.3934500515,
0.4281289279,
-0.4460189641,
-0.6711899042,
0.1891353726,
0.0068358816,
-0.108171694,
0.5719313622,
0.3705943525,
-0.277228266,
1.167667985,
0.8993204832,
0.4630891979,
0.6018267274,
-0.3800123632,
-0.1232855171,
-0.5508674383,
-0.276065141,
-0.3124850988,
-0.3891507685,
-0.7054339051,
-0.2154723704,
0.50476408,
0.0562480912,
-0.3886663616,
0.0613476858,
0.0049355375,
0.2728940547,
0.3508984447,
0.0279345904,
0.2497587353,
0.2108431011,
0.0494811758,
0.1677460968,
-0.6157544255,
-0.0982479453,
1.6426285505,
0.2829039693,
0.8354785442,
-0.113030158,
0.3236010969,
0.3329096437,
0.1610580385,
-0.794298172,
0.2368060499,
-0.0021800206,
-0.8437893987,
-0.180737257,
-0.4478089511,
-1.15677917,
0.2482669055,
-0.3202458918,
-0.3502210379,
0.4508143663,
0.2534595728,
-0.49337098,
0.0805275217,
-0.7797403932,
0.8223161101,
-0.2974915206,
-0.4583185613,
-0.4081206918,
-0.6098626256,
0.3543282151,
-0.5223007202,
0.2715376914,
-0.4693057835,
-0.0270720776,
0.6733742356,
-0.2059997767,
0.5417612195,
-0.2967090607,
0.1094017848,
0.1605988294,
-0.1423650682,
0.0105697112,
-0.2086396068,
0.2721380889,
0.5915705562,
0.2438685149,
-0.6112498045,
-0.5265185833,
0.327708751,
-0.7604345083,
-0.2847465873,
-0.4125514328,
-0.5642685294,
-0.4390337765,
0.2751086354,
0.409275502,
0.8009825945,
-0.0277225096,
0.7394192815,
0.4683389664,
0.121260792,
0.7268599272,
0.5203108191,
-0.171072349,
0.0416160226,
0.9380989671,
0.5284224153,
0.6268239021,
0.173186928,
-0.2881663442,
-0.4404293001,
-0.3947869837,
-0.5549178123,
-0.0735702738,
-0.4653430283,
-0.1703493595,
-0.6376721859,
0.0090354681,
-0.3700744212,
0.0432344638,
-0.3075054586,
-0.5349199176,
0.0003571938,
-0.0443520844,
0.0809330791,
0.6484144926,
-0.1230851412,
0.5441617966,
-0.8111483455,
0.3542247713,
0.323952347,
0.3467227817,
0.2651390433,
-0.5405472517,
-0.313970983,
0.405174464,
-0.5168061256,
-0.493095845,
0.2480652034,
0.5189985633,
0.5286607742,
0.5391663313,
-0.1455324143,
1.0394285917,
-0.5770668387,
0.7851215005,
0.637306571,
-0.7782885432,
0.3924959302,
-0.5051413774,
0.4107380509,
0.285490483,
0.9768967628,
-0.4449036717,
0.0218300167,
-0.6093042493,
-0.9473757148,
0.675394237,
0.0173768476,
0.5970829725,
-0.1017716005,
0.062386781,
0.0562301315,
0.5902619362,
-0.7402502894,
-0.0513008274,
-0.5531802773,
0.090441376,
-0.2171455771,
-0.1316954195,
0.0265404955,
-0.2166154683,
0.1226675957,
-0.2810972631,
0.2248778492,
0.0032094165,
-0.3465521038,
-0.3903373182,
0.1818482876,
0.6171972752,
0.8547164798,
-0.4908256531,
0.0034411156,
-0.1623984724,
-0.4563608468,
0.3579017222,
-0.2111728489,
-0.1993267834,
0.0284466296,
0.6154885888,
0.9921858311,
0.2055774033,
-0.6956284642,
0.7430810332,
0.1002463773,
-0.118486762,
-0.4376478195,
0.2347932309,
-0.4151517749,
-0.018814005,
0.9002477527,
0.2444882244,
-0.1168670058,
-0.698905468,
0.2200247347,
0.5127101541,
-0.3168826699,
-0.7541186213,
0.669993937,
0.0500355065,
0.2894849181,
0.6933002472,
-0.0458069593,
0.1353723258,
0.7319380641,
0.4305441678,
0.6395694017,
-0.1432508975,
0.1676693708,
0.4304281771,
0.0788218454,
0.0150131034,
-0.0153700728,
-0.282353431,
-0.8005189896,
-0.6527829766,
-0.772002995,
-0.045679424,
0.176437676,
-0.8628530502,
0.3159626424,
-0.5385581255,
-0.6045790315,
0.3399939835,
-0.4557919502,
-0.9891845584,
0.4487954974,
0.3766078651,
0.6950492859,
-0.743142426,
0.8338447809,
0.3205661476,
-0.7937622666,
-0.6507071853,
-0.0503965653,
0.082278356,
-0.793921411,
1.0734823942,
0.4000658095,
-0.0993042961,
0.1917566508,
-0.6471526623,
-0.9603366852,
1.2094335556,
0.3837735951,
-0.7124431729,
-0.2460028529,
0.3016715646,
0.5535756946,
-0.3774716556,
0.824852109,
0.1028969735,
0.2863095403,
0.4996718764,
-1.1374613047,
-0.4360383153,
-0.1515470743,
0.1345817745,
0.0420088768,
-0.7271946073,
1.2383810282,
-0.1700295508,
-0.3550283313,
-0.2740948498,
0.1586184204,
-0.1311308593,
0.488186419,
0.4801231921,
0.8507376313,
0.2155168653,
-0.0656147227,
1.2712310553,
-0.3245732486,
0.4376283884,
0.7947268486,
-0.5301338434,
1.0263416767,
0.2550261319,
-0.2726044953,
0.4265656471,
0.5036705732,
-0.0664999411,
0.4797429144,
-0.1732995808,
-0.2755793631,
-0.4109946489,
-0.4365435541,
-0.5493761301,
0.690369904,
0.253079921,
-0.1292435825,
-0.372056067,
0.1931257844,
-0.1511638761,
-0.5120519996,
-0.4061617851,
0.6000022888,
-0.100785926,
-0.3215186894,
0.7982136607,
-0.1885774583,
0.7952330709,
-1.1476045847,
0.0457380638,
-0.1229418367,
-0.0741726607,
-0.2327591479,
-0.4676353633,
0.1107808575,
-0.1546035111,
-0.1766307354,
-0.1959843338,
0.4734249413,
-0.2136889547,
-0.4312301278,
0.3015405536,
0.5109880567,
-0.0553329736,
-0.3257827461,
-0.3546963334,
0.1104862094,
-0.2970754206,
-0.2703696191,
0.5654601455,
0.2753069401,
-0.0975608155,
0.660154283,
1.0720691681,
-0.0572905578,
0.3678013086,
0.1569869369,
0.8158360124,
-0.5663462281,
-0.1891041845,
-0.6783144474,
0.6060546041,
0.0945806205,
-0.2801297903,
0.686296463,
0.4115858078,
1.2449163198,
-0.2019258589,
0.6052934527,
-0.0786539689,
0.1093235761,
-0.4811096191,
0.5639989972,
-0.8384191394,
-0.2635315359,
-0.157193616,
-1.0473653078,
-0.0403576791,
0.3491479158,
-0.3372482955,
0.3762181699,
0.5914580226,
0.6616424918,
-0.157672435,
-0.1413526684,
0.7034419775,
-0.034034647,
0.2656766176,
0.4200610518,
0.7786856294,
-0.393676877,
0.4186234176,
-0.2503144741,
-0.1564283669,
-0.06642095,
-0.8310675621,
-0.4210404456,
-0.5665736794,
-0.1321575195,
0.2812377214,
0.0091009373,
0.7718004584,
1.125697732,
-0.5104127526,
-0.2035296857,
0.1745077968,
-0.4620276093,
-0.0455003381,
-0.21375826,
-0.003205817,
-0.5660508275,
-0.5107421875,
0.271597594,
0.3303202689,
0.1020299643,
-0.1574269831,
0.324329555,
-0.3253537714,
0.1388162971,
0.8602728844,
0.3192157149,
-0.4297395945,
-0.3273444474,
0.0698065385,
0.2171137184,
0.053410992,
0.9634397626,
-0.8834424019,
0.7593374252,
0.0478443354,
0.3030328155,
0.8447882533,
0.0750145167,
0.3759661615,
-1.0727540255,
0.6239934564,
0.0793248639,
0.1509846896,
-0.0619565174,
0.1225472689,
0.3645674884,
0.7197297215,
-0.3430446982,
-0.8423078656,
0.1698533297,
-0.8335898519,
-0.1837983876,
0.8499065042,
-0.2500148118,
-0.1522597522,
-0.0418096296,
0.3507218063,
0.214179188,
-0.3484995067,
0.5189146399,
0.7515952587,
-0.2305843532,
-0.2241072953,
-0.914126873,
0.2283180952,
0.3331694007,
-0.4265613854,
-0.274910599,
0.6797092557,
0.4598042965,
0.3419157863,
0.5802255869,
0.0422869734,
0.2996708155,
0.4027678072,
0.2612003386,
-0.2453201264,
-0.4543970823,
-0.4308622181,
0.4320704341,
-0.0812512264,
-0.1256919354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03715v1
|
Direct Nash Optimization: Teaching Language Models to Self-Improve with General Preferences
| 2024-04-04T17:56:41 | 2024-04-04T17:56:41 |
Corby Rosset, Ching-An Cheng, Arindam Mitra, Michael Santacroce, Ahmed Awadallah, Tengyang Xie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper studies post-training large language models (LLMs) using
preference feedback from a powerful oracle to help a model iteratively improve
over itself. The typical approach for post-training LLMs involves Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), which traditionally separates reward
learning and subsequent policy optimization. However, such a reward
maximization approach is limited by the nature of "point-wise" rewards (such as
Bradley-Terry model), which fails to express complex intransitive or cyclic
preference relations. While advances on RLHF show reward learning and policy
optimization can be merged into a single contrastive objective for stability,
they yet still remain tethered to the reward maximization framework. Recently,
a new wave of research sidesteps the reward maximization presumptions in favor
of directly optimizing over "pair-wise" or general preferences. In this paper,
we introduce Direct Nash Optimization (DNO), a provable and scalable algorithm
that marries the simplicity and stability of contrastive learning with
theoretical generality from optimizing general preferences. Because DNO is a
batched on-policy algorithm using a regression-based objective, its
implementation is straightforward and efficient. Moreover, DNO enjoys monotonic
improvement across iterations that help it improve even over a strong teacher
(such as GPT-4). In our experiments, a resulting 7B parameter Orca-2.5 model
aligned by DNO achieves the state-of-the-art win-rate against GPT-4-Turbo of
33% on AlpacaEval 2.0 (even after controlling for response length), an absolute
gain of 26% (7% to 33%) over the initializing model. It outperforms models with
far more parameters, including Mistral Large, Self-Rewarding LM (70B
parameters), and older versions of GPT-4.
|
[
-0.2258474678,
-0.6373744607,
0.5473322868,
0.1252834648,
-0.1816193312,
0.0236836318,
-0.5610432625,
-0.0117706042,
0.0970296487,
0.4850239754,
-0.5515387058,
-0.4119143784,
-0.6218309999,
-0.0312385652,
-0.0060048634,
1.2317185402,
-0.0140339397,
0.2400678843,
0.0461407043,
0.0510418527,
-0.3678579032,
-0.5506476164,
-1.1145358086,
-0.4263030589,
0.6177188158,
0.4042551219,
0.6955147982,
0.7028061748,
0.30259642,
0.2848002613,
0.0272954851,
0.1350236237,
-0.7075263262,
0.2664552033,
-0.0283881947,
-0.4522346556,
-0.3870705962,
0.0831115469,
0.7042729855,
0.46876508,
-0.5109869242,
-0.3324194252,
0.1822710037,
0.862967968,
-0.5743559003,
0.1640194803,
-0.773126483,
0.019157635,
0.0108622406,
-0.273614645,
-0.4099070132,
-0.6221095324,
0.2033908814,
-0.6526277661,
-0.1075484902,
-0.254899323,
0.7967486382,
0.4159865379,
-0.2960797548,
-0.3492803574,
-0.762881279,
0.953474462,
-0.6383112073,
0.0861840323,
0.3891592324,
0.3256059885,
-0.2046126872,
-0.3242764473,
-0.2249206305,
-0.6844617128,
0.152506277,
0.2567387521,
0.1649514139,
0.2701517344,
-0.0353015587,
0.3531700969,
-0.4109817147,
0.321754396,
0.025406355,
0.066505149,
0.6011886001,
0.1497816443,
0.0548401177,
0.1901405901,
-0.3682772815,
-0.3075481057,
-0.9127475619,
0.272668153,
0.4606413245,
0.409350574,
0.1289530098,
0.2193020135,
-0.0929317772,
0.6695995331,
0.2802107632,
-0.265145272,
-0.0446611606,
-0.0880240351,
0.0107075041,
-0.1421030909,
0.5653304458,
0.1357408315,
0.2743086815,
-0.108405605,
-0.4633334577,
0.1610293388,
0.1703309715,
-0.654553473,
-0.1822439283,
-0.0329845175,
-0.2150338292,
-0.4788826108,
-0.2885990739,
-0.5865566134,
-0.3277891278,
-0.5969542861,
0.62266922,
-0.1151101515,
-0.2920838892,
0.232624948,
0.3698744774,
0.3136228621,
0.4465014935,
-1.2028342485,
0.6025129557,
0.8308802843,
0.6444045305,
-0.2716956437,
-0.3848824501,
-0.7252321839,
0.0122228106,
-0.4840177,
0.5570913553,
-0.5123336911,
-0.5726446509,
0.1074202061,
-0.2955591381,
-0.0374522656,
-0.6260516047,
0.4521433711,
-0.5117740035,
0.2915906608,
-0.3873523474,
-0.4468576014,
0.1531340927,
0.3123607635,
-0.4389978647,
0.9574033022,
-0.120441474,
-0.5426555276,
0.3962806463,
-0.6410951614,
-0.1701377034,
-0.1861375868,
-0.333356142,
-0.3917444646,
0.010291894,
-0.0024667794,
0.1859443784,
-0.3924560547,
0.5453334451,
-0.1980140209,
-0.3845523894,
-0.1922945082,
-0.0620571896,
0.3803283572,
-0.0041389214,
-0.6041320562,
0.5055193305,
-0.4566351175,
-0.0437233448,
0.3549251258,
-0.5718914866,
-0.4261114001,
0.0612006709,
-0.4724030495,
0.0540400781,
0.2015980482,
-0.3587232232,
0.5039814115,
-0.6204392314,
0.1479859799,
1.0827949047,
-0.3123282194,
0.6567828059,
-0.1478401572,
0.5735034347,
-0.2674303055,
0.4387342036,
0.2141200006,
-0.1541341841,
-0.8970911503,
-0.0476446189,
0.2220406532,
0.2233880907,
-0.6989585757,
0.1965735108,
-0.1880765706,
-0.2482965291,
-0.4711353481,
0.2129995376,
0.5295906067,
0.4868736863,
0.2920954823,
-0.3841736019,
-0.324578166,
-0.9003306627,
-0.0719379634,
-0.1265010089,
0.2815580666,
0.4636331201,
0.1953971386,
-0.1128236577,
0.7877309918,
-0.6013732553,
-0.1777626425,
-0.2781480551,
0.0383156426,
0.4241855741,
0.3283082545,
0.44239375,
-0.5518097281,
-0.803242147,
0.0457974263,
-0.3897935152,
0.1328023523,
0.1983386874,
-0.1140130535,
0.4128002524,
0.0705141947,
-0.2796503007,
0.1521712393,
0.5001480579,
-0.1647477895,
0.672252059,
-0.4865166247,
-0.030988263,
-0.5611807108,
-0.0826230049,
-0.1278629154,
-0.0874504,
-0.5706641674,
-0.1587186009,
-0.2316821963,
-0.003062288,
-0.2208833694,
0.5514506698,
-0.4475055635,
-0.1748151034,
-0.6131173372,
0.0263903141,
-0.3178091645,
0.6922296882,
0.3203873932,
0.7081157565,
0.6811643243,
-0.6270016432,
0.413710475,
-0.027200887,
-0.0347230025,
0.2604144812,
-0.7210718989,
0.2679314911,
-0.2548041642,
0.1972083449,
-0.7494259477,
-0.0282571334,
0.2947651148,
-0.2490784228,
0.5572637916,
-0.0991546512,
0.0099265734,
-0.3267842531,
-0.5316060781,
0.1629866213,
0.4808110297,
-0.770947516,
0.320371747,
0.1516059637,
-0.1250487417,
-1.0245798826,
-0.1273613125,
-0.1331487745,
-0.0504622497,
-0.3049460351,
0.2638177276,
-0.2019165009,
-0.2136422843,
0.0325747654,
-0.1968584806,
-0.0346891545,
0.1616794467,
-0.0541457012,
0.3100697696,
0.0249613542,
0.1917194724,
-0.0383687951,
-0.4000368714,
0.0079710558,
-0.4168939292,
0.6608397365,
-0.389033705,
-0.1010461226,
-0.0740059763,
0.1577702165,
0.1097647175,
-0.116127193,
0.5917816758,
0.4043012857,
0.0854149461,
-0.4396240413,
-0.4320110381,
-0.4773600698,
-0.4762812853,
0.4826306105,
-0.5200922489,
-0.9213423133,
0.0803064257,
0.0164426863,
0.1098974943,
0.3968751132,
0.5147945285,
0.2515055537,
1.0001305342,
0.5986940861,
-0.2861806452,
0.4607355595,
-0.46777156,
-0.1818852723,
-0.5293902159,
-0.1739852875,
-0.4119672775,
-0.0761387348,
-0.4667372704,
-0.0682517514,
0.2104529887,
-0.0941909105,
-0.6073898077,
0.0379280038,
-0.6773040295,
0.714358151,
0.7615365386,
0.2218134105,
0.1628149599,
-0.1575863957,
-0.199369207,
-0.159789294,
-0.62202245,
-0.1519228965,
1.2317267656,
0.3008224666,
0.9671317935,
0.0020369443,
1.0021402836,
0.2759569287,
0.413749218,
-0.7454807162,
0.4418445528,
-0.3322837949,
-0.3477398157,
-0.5090156198,
-0.535209775,
-1.0759000778,
0.255718112,
-0.0902237445,
-0.3285722733,
0.1221916154,
0.3793269694,
-0.2263030112,
0.2878063023,
-0.4161112607,
0.8971171379,
-0.6001378298,
-0.6011797786,
-0.4139499068,
-0.6884455085,
0.3861134946,
0.1418429911,
0.0705979913,
-0.0494502485,
-0.1388677806,
0.6405442953,
-0.4586229324,
0.6603347063,
-0.5057381392,
-0.2532470524,
0.1194173098,
0.1921181977,
0.6452592611,
-0.2214058042,
-0.0223969202,
-0.3809889555,
-0.2408126593,
-0.4838279784,
-0.7947317958,
0.9370495081,
-1.1515409946,
-0.9748750329,
-0.448833704,
-0.306009531,
-0.3796840012,
-0.0285813026,
-0.1004543528,
0.5146466494,
-0.1061769724,
0.0601001903,
0.589438796,
-0.1592459381,
0.3375198543,
0.5436342359,
-0.357857585,
-0.5717794299,
0.8985128403,
-0.1287738532,
0.5207021236,
0.4193221331,
0.5188714266,
-0.5863146782,
-0.5660734177,
-0.2142646611,
0.4944294691,
-0.774540782,
-0.0842202604,
-0.2251978368,
-0.093829371,
-0.2023185641,
-0.1752488166,
-0.5426638126,
-0.176135391,
-0.157260254,
-0.0597574487,
0.1159801185,
1.0271581411,
-0.2916286588,
0.2515896261,
-0.2008127272,
-0.1358491629,
0.6903005838,
0.4406803548,
0.114129886,
-0.542149961,
-0.220444724,
-0.0266547687,
-0.2749006152,
-0.6202223897,
0.4199043214,
0.188695997,
0.5474213958,
0.3495461941,
-0.1104250997,
0.2989990413,
-0.2906453609,
0.5204102993,
0.3404390216,
-0.8096423149,
0.6731271744,
-0.5195377469,
0.0190243069,
0.6574341655,
0.5468578339,
-0.4119989872,
0.108637698,
-0.4626514316,
-0.7478475571,
0.9090582728,
-0.2474259734,
0.1031594798,
-0.0208723582,
0.6952895522,
0.1307777911,
0.2274097353,
-0.9793612957,
-0.4453270435,
-0.2598631084,
-0.0347261466,
-0.2585430741,
-0.5031639934,
-0.2015329748,
-0.1696012467,
0.9293570518,
-0.2437810153,
0.0460670292,
0.0580503568,
0.1366367787,
0.038001813,
0.3000539541,
0.6543952227,
0.5072317123,
-0.3765859306,
0.1442220062,
0.105175972,
-0.2346250266,
0.5618025661,
-0.1391646415,
-0.1544460356,
-0.2625288665,
-0.0614562929,
0.981051147,
0.3459826708,
-0.3411438465,
0.6359895468,
-0.1010871381,
-0.2486691326,
-0.0962057263,
0.1959456056,
-0.1087898239,
0.003264474,
0.2151056975,
-0.1887658536,
0.107885994,
-0.5355517268,
0.0371596068,
0.5625098348,
-0.4276777208,
-0.3021298647,
0.5141881108,
0.3758279979,
-0.1733477861,
0.1636001319,
-0.2057274282,
-0.5276710987,
0.560487926,
0.6940325499,
0.9017583132,
-0.5228717923,
0.4249335825,
0.4825542867,
0.0029483966,
-0.3115722835,
-0.0294519458,
-0.2381362021,
-0.7434306741,
-0.3423785567,
-0.5043852925,
-0.7407224774,
-0.0191805176,
-0.6133892536,
0.1635930985,
-0.7349092364,
-0.1111504361,
-0.2746961117,
0.41183272,
-0.5190711617,
0.2595964968,
0.0026846507,
0.4038229585,
-0.5670204163,
1.0526505709,
0.6147512794,
-0.4301307797,
-0.8792201281,
-0.1946815848,
-0.046824988,
-1.0523160696,
0.9545378089,
-0.0555875339,
-0.1613179743,
0.1369844973,
-0.4342037141,
-1.0032291412,
0.9586988688,
0.4763538241,
-0.6363300681,
-0.0316978619,
-0.0831257552,
0.4493210912,
-0.4148328602,
0.5037249327,
0.5796260238,
0.4483889341,
0.3366757035,
-0.8384085894,
-0.0628475472,
0.024646217,
0.1330675185,
0.3021786511,
-0.7893726826,
0.786200583,
-0.2255545706,
0.0326945931,
-0.1132937893,
0.4541392922,
0.1543833315,
-0.0419266261,
0.7014274597,
0.6318548322,
0.6259353757,
-0.0929325595,
1.2264956236,
-0.1499980837,
0.4453344941,
1.1971820593,
-0.2737209797,
0.7404669523,
0.2342889607,
-0.3947959244,
0.4804197848,
0.665055573,
0.2817373872,
0.8045555949,
0.5083432198,
-0.3591026664,
-0.3137905002,
-0.13548702,
-0.4462184906,
0.2745482028,
-0.0170960482,
-0.1088463962,
-0.2596548498,
-0.2119385451,
0.2369971424,
0.2950177491,
-0.4080784023,
0.906714201,
-0.0455681942,
-0.9322436452,
0.7936003804,
-0.046698723,
0.8324404955,
-0.8800240755,
0.1904863566,
-0.4844703674,
0.4018152058,
0.0096873874,
-0.4995193183,
0.1446951479,
-0.2361533493,
-0.0506203212,
-0.1394277662,
0.6933709383,
-0.695757091,
0.0240509976,
0.6062055826,
0.2057054043,
-0.0030801254,
0.116913572,
-0.7621123791,
0.1684025228,
0.1180699021,
-0.2902767658,
0.4857826829,
-0.0354103073,
0.352555722,
0.7324139476,
0.497015655,
0.2756940424,
-0.2454459965,
0.2086496055,
0.9030656815,
-0.5939944386,
-0.4037618339,
-0.9094268084,
0.1659047157,
0.0759003609,
-0.2795056403,
0.5844192505,
0.337677747,
0.7375261188,
-0.0788750872,
0.5658537745,
0.3708642721,
0.4032109976,
-0.4566085041,
0.3545953333,
-0.6109505296,
0.1908271909,
-0.0487860739,
-1.0622755289,
-0.2641066611,
0.4951944053,
-0.6398346424,
0.1256837994,
0.5399885178,
0.6829085946,
0.4051805437,
-0.2292956859,
0.4094961882,
0.211599201,
0.3636233211,
0.771011591,
0.8634916544,
-0.0086866803,
0.4705037475,
-0.2919670045,
-0.4013072848,
-0.0933579206,
-0.6276529431,
-0.7100288868,
-0.4011037648,
-0.270860672,
-0.2539001703,
0.5123829246,
1.079661727,
0.7199590206,
-0.6833512783,
-0.5512458086,
-0.217062071,
0.1687767208,
0.0795251131,
-0.1876442432,
0.4936376512,
-0.8440679312,
-0.7219614983,
0.3951792717,
0.3142100573,
0.0279004686,
-0.3680917919,
-0.6428716779,
-0.0637751892,
0.0468789004,
0.4334693253,
0.4821520448,
-0.7273339033,
-0.1832935214,
-0.0626777783,
-0.1420659423,
0.0726598129,
0.689456284,
-0.6079601645,
0.5676795244,
0.0021678733,
0.7977020741,
0.782328546,
0.0344919451,
0.6114486456,
-0.4647404552,
0.0693957657,
0.3028104305,
0.2443707138,
0.285463661,
-0.1130320504,
0.5958544612,
0.3313179016,
-0.869032681,
-0.6086211205,
0.2245457172,
-0.7504045963,
-0.1626828611,
1.197802186,
-0.1624021828,
-0.2325050682,
0.3313135207,
-0.4444052279,
-0.0647797287,
-0.5604690909,
0.8297243118,
0.4270989001,
-0.0659436807,
-0.094460018,
-0.0663169622,
0.9396705031,
0.748439014,
-0.799649179,
-0.0240265615,
0.4839573801,
0.2944290638,
-0.3217034936,
0.9366941452,
0.0936082676,
0.2538683712,
-0.0905751288,
0.219947353,
-0.1617704332,
-0.5204907656,
-0.5856025815,
-0.0374734811,
0.5671102405,
-0.1900100559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03635v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03635v4
|
WorDepth: Variational Language Prior for Monocular Depth Estimation
| 2024-04-04T17:54:33 | 2024-06-02T04:56:32 |
Ziyao Zeng, Daniel Wang, Fengyu Yang, Hyoungseob Park, Yangchao Wu, Stefano Soatto, Byung-Woo Hong, Dong Lao, Alex Wong
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction from a single image is an ill-posed
problem with inherent ambiguities, i.e. scale. Predicting a 3D scene from text
description(s) is similarly ill-posed, i.e. spatial arrangements of objects
described. We investigate the question of whether two inherently ambiguous
modalities can be used in conjunction to produce metric-scaled reconstructions.
To test this, we focus on monocular depth estimation, the problem of predicting
a dense depth map from a single image, but with an additional text caption
describing the scene. To this end, we begin by encoding the text caption as a
mean and standard deviation; using a variational framework, we learn the
distribution of the plausible metric reconstructions of 3D scenes corresponding
to the text captions as a prior. To "select" a specific reconstruction or depth
map, we encode the given image through a conditional sampler that samples from
the latent space of the variational text encoder, which is then decoded to the
output depth map. Our approach is trained alternatingly between the text and
image branches: in one optimization step, we predict the mean and standard
deviation from the text description and sample from a standard Gaussian, and in
the other, we sample using a (image) conditional sampler. Once trained, we
directly predict depth from the encoded text using the conditional sampler. We
demonstrate our approach on indoor (NYUv2) and outdoor (KITTI) scenarios, where
we show that language can consistently improve performance in both.
|
[
-0.4384114742,
-0.6802338958,
0.5791361928,
0.1099577621,
-0.5835062861,
-0.1901300102,
-0.1670487821,
-0.452758044,
0.2124718428,
0.6464999318,
-0.5035467148,
-0.3232624233,
-0.3694857955,
0.1157020628,
-0.168272078,
0.7585864067,
-0.0879138634,
0.1915920079,
-0.303680867,
-0.1661809236,
-0.3049829006,
-0.1851097196,
-0.3990151286,
-0.0586384572,
0.2444759905,
0.5197662115,
0.9970270991,
0.4877055585,
0.7288680673,
0.3454976976,
0.0339653976,
0.095042944,
-0.2519717515,
-0.1629464626,
0.1545953453,
-0.5029711723,
-0.0158579238,
-0.1535788178,
0.8731513619,
0.9589241743,
-0.1438331306,
-0.3756336272,
-0.1239816621,
0.8351611495,
-0.6721547842,
-0.2812209725,
-0.4089924395,
0.4135319889,
0.1285166442,
-0.3025295436,
0.1046168804,
-0.0475980937,
0.5708653331,
-0.9118055701,
0.5120568275,
0.0630892068,
0.8640056849,
0.4559756219,
-0.3154582381,
-0.1858229637,
-0.845312655,
0.620387435,
-0.8441208005,
0.3173180223,
0.3915472329,
0.5795253515,
0.1975664794,
-0.4566010535,
-0.7251845598,
-0.1915819198,
-0.384856075,
0.562946558,
0.1762549877,
0.2268803418,
0.1807211041,
0.9958952665,
-0.7585048676,
-0.011742007,
-0.6292629242,
-0.2087005973,
0.4994913936,
0.1733140647,
0.1246560812,
-0.2708422542,
-0.7081814408,
-0.3549841344,
-0.4397621155,
0.1113351136,
0.3004797995,
0.2087511271,
-0.4761109054,
0.6560078263,
-0.1286976337,
0.9012147784,
-0.215030849,
-0.1915317029,
0.2477875054,
-0.4420532882,
-0.4179210365,
-0.2005216926,
0.863817811,
0.3765117526,
0.1428512633,
-0.0192861911,
-0.1169946715,
0.0094388407,
0.1983406991,
-0.6035329103,
-0.1289516091,
0.1149824932,
-0.114024654,
-0.0250384659,
0.3643825948,
-1.0799210072,
-0.6583387852,
-0.1956858784,
0.3829722703,
-0.3934158385,
-0.2381953895,
0.7316942811,
-0.1027121395,
0.1026019379,
0.291982621,
-0.7558326721,
0.4946651161,
0.0540830009,
0.8304042816,
0.004975454,
-0.4742197692,
0.0005820975,
0.1004188359,
-0.5468269587,
0.541410625,
-0.1502255797,
-0.5475335717,
0.078489691,
-0.2010770887,
0.2804966867,
-0.4667584896,
0.2327858955,
-0.2355617881,
0.4553171098,
0.130956322,
-0.3513565958,
-0.2688080072,
0.4180745184,
-0.96800524,
0.5010873079,
0.3379296362,
-1.0501565933,
0.3869206607,
-0.3023557663,
-0.4574950933,
-0.1669591814,
-0.4037463963,
-0.4249055386,
0.2562077641,
0.5963617563,
0.2655429542,
-0.3330649734,
-0.1369555593,
-0.0685369223,
-0.2023885846,
0.0613757223,
-0.3862688541,
0.25248155,
-0.010092319,
-0.104194656,
-0.0857333243,
-0.7202550769,
-0.2855090499,
0.0278834198,
-0.3709347844,
-0.2947944701,
0.1372337788,
-0.0435077064,
-0.1386355013,
0.2787267864,
-0.5628193021,
-0.0964967236,
-0.9451114535,
-0.1531043053,
0.5810605884,
0.158826828,
0.8941896558,
-0.1862760633,
0.8217839599,
0.2664193809,
-0.1746916026,
-0.4645443559,
-0.1603236794,
-0.6132835746,
-0.4122093022,
0.0898829177,
0.5226901174,
-0.8962329626,
0.0572725274,
-0.478379339,
-0.2905168831,
-0.2105968595,
-0.2284469903,
0.2751562595,
0.3774140477,
0.3237912655,
-0.2319606692,
-0.7168918848,
-1.0031636953,
-0.0140440892,
-0.3743528426,
-0.265183866,
0.4006655514,
0.1508917361,
0.1527619213,
0.8493676186,
-0.8379869461,
-0.4168011844,
-0.1137033254,
0.1702379733,
0.3335812688,
0.5074173212,
0.5829253793,
-1.1004323959,
-0.4116938114,
0.2988097966,
-0.7518475056,
0.3604105413,
-0.2230865806,
0.1205878183,
-0.0162876267,
0.4697679281,
-0.3095362186,
0.6187443733,
0.7475925684,
-0.1205656901,
0.4452754557,
-0.5352615714,
0.2365444154,
-1.0692772865,
-0.4030902684,
0.1744342893,
-0.2564465702,
-0.5832904577,
0.0313628018,
-0.0865380093,
-0.0389277227,
-0.1459943205,
0.4839672446,
-0.7248624563,
0.0040931082,
-0.0301974248,
0.123177819,
-0.1188290939,
0.4407504797,
0.4029481709,
0.720271945,
0.8243412971,
-0.4872734249,
-0.0392340869,
-0.0467993878,
-0.6030521393,
0.5186389089,
-0.6453860402,
0.0397476703,
-0.2449598163,
0.0345216617,
-1.2128859758,
-0.4263281226,
0.1361683011,
-0.4309162796,
0.3067680299,
0.2335621864,
-0.3872674704,
-0.4718299806,
-0.1111949533,
0.6048392653,
0.199180603,
-0.3160476685,
0.6007077098,
0.412193656,
0.0223396663,
-0.4489610195,
-1.1142245531,
-0.1668710113,
-0.1109356955,
-0.4419913292,
0.190906018,
-0.1070518941,
-0.0756981298,
-0.0350745581,
-0.3404575288,
-0.3912864625,
-0.2569184005,
0.1840476543,
0.3342992365,
-0.4486221075,
-0.0865364298,
-0.0124330549,
0.1743048728,
-0.1220115274,
-0.1525844485,
0.1590701193,
-0.1910409629,
-0.3369493186,
-0.0867504999,
0.366966635,
0.4268914759,
0.0316776931,
0.2944173813,
0.2670591176,
-0.5917875767,
0.1055217981,
-0.3913274705,
-0.1513457,
-0.4339944422,
0.4891486466,
-0.5786121488,
-0.8860685825,
0.4017218053,
0.2433006614,
-0.2587376833,
0.1423235089,
0.1528238207,
-0.0867162049,
0.8636891246,
0.8763136268,
-0.0580198802,
0.3328809142,
-0.4220751226,
0.0466772206,
-0.6754930019,
-0.0602976084,
-0.2726660967,
-0.2440113425,
-0.5124323964,
-0.6421999931,
0.6163012385,
0.0755843595,
0.073802948,
0.244035691,
-0.2965641618,
0.6448783278,
0.3985073268,
0.3602234423,
0.2348582298,
0.2375116497,
-0.1763643026,
-0.2740111351,
-0.6737591624,
-0.3827656806,
0.8872461915,
0.1979843527,
0.783675611,
0.0266773291,
0.6024894714,
-0.2059490979,
0.2059060484,
-0.8683635592,
0.4621625245,
-0.1576304734,
-0.7980002761,
-0.5376722217,
-0.523034215,
-0.9248465896,
0.5916683674,
0.0085773105,
-0.7600826025,
0.4334038794,
0.1288189441,
-0.4871356487,
0.3316234052,
-0.5670437813,
0.6593792439,
0.0100596901,
-0.1261725575,
-0.0303695314,
-0.9341967702,
0.4807409346,
-0.1152680442,
0.4819156229,
0.1212876067,
-0.4195535481,
0.2437382489,
-0.1353677213,
0.7450016737,
-0.0583621264,
-0.1032585949,
0.1606720537,
0.4581465721,
0.030897364,
0.4213748574,
0.1358327717,
0.052647233,
0.1428430378,
-0.2791773677,
-0.7514214516,
0.2633972466,
-0.8252188563,
-0.6780616045,
-0.2862714231,
-0.7750739455,
-0.3006098568,
0.1987355202,
0.5774484873,
0.4665257037,
-0.4783887863,
0.1457007825,
0.3680515289,
-0.2676877975,
0.3489249945,
0.4229645431,
-0.342225343,
-0.5901353359,
0.6535224915,
-0.1717569232,
0.3864231706,
0.9611663818,
0.3387372494,
-0.1520120353,
-0.6132211089,
-0.325265795,
0.1062494516,
-0.6128570437,
-0.2887000442,
-0.1913921237,
-0.1486331969,
-0.2352562845,
-0.3948357403,
-0.333789736,
-0.4239193499,
-0.3455165029,
-0.0852754414,
-0.2571359873,
0.6316856742,
-0.383050561,
0.3927873373,
-0.4833549559,
0.4689430892,
0.2983292937,
0.0547961481,
-0.5076819658,
-0.4550573528,
-0.3186662197,
0.2824941576,
0.0634386465,
-0.8724405766,
0.3546072841,
0.1262079775,
0.2573883235,
0.5049453378,
-0.2052863687,
0.7004072666,
-0.5556810498,
0.8186439872,
0.4956855178,
-0.5920271277,
0.5992438793,
-0.2881891131,
0.8291522861,
0.4941390753,
0.2984059453,
-0.3567149639,
-0.5909528136,
-0.5335456133,
-0.7884596586,
0.7724358439,
0.2653615475,
0.2612607777,
0.0827424005,
0.1463436633,
0.2967459857,
0.1594223976,
-0.9249541759,
-0.1698335856,
-0.544179678,
-0.1016283929,
-0.4668706357,
-0.1713312268,
-0.1366007477,
-0.3073260784,
0.2400942892,
-0.0685326084,
0.1979765594,
0.5553985834,
-0.0137425242,
-0.1719009876,
0.0062641795,
0.65462327,
0.7704414725,
-0.4021264613,
0.4934488237,
0.1734762043,
-0.4371669292,
0.0523651727,
0.2419221252,
-0.0335120708,
0.2833887041,
0.3899289668,
0.7777239084,
0.3096274734,
-0.5144406557,
0.7427594066,
0.0628851429,
-0.3963621259,
-0.1892076582,
-0.4464558661,
-0.1761821061,
0.0491175838,
0.3148056865,
0.2500982285,
0.3184219003,
-0.0983583182,
0.0568347834,
0.2175134569,
-0.4411380589,
-0.35927701,
0.3575282991,
-0.2495743632,
-0.0802412406,
0.1583082378,
-0.0762797222,
-0.3973298669,
0.7264893055,
0.448338598,
0.6853508353,
-0.2619959116,
0.4007080197,
0.8047665358,
0.5045410395,
0.0430745706,
0.1505113393,
-0.0531379506,
-1.0314747095,
-0.1662123352,
-0.4980228841,
-0.2062441409,
0.1286332309,
-0.5835216641,
0.128183946,
-0.4703159928,
0.2654623985,
-0.0418843701,
-0.3815232217,
-0.7163450122,
0.4945493042,
0.1291356534,
0.6888982654,
-0.5502598882,
0.4333479404,
0.9083353281,
-0.6225192547,
-0.7029932141,
0.2970602214,
-0.0324925818,
-0.5792558789,
0.1193998381,
0.0560324565,
-0.4508234859,
-0.1443248838,
-0.6539896131,
-0.7174904346,
0.8287311196,
0.4197191894,
-0.4336413741,
-0.0872979015,
0.3537681997,
0.5934506059,
-0.3623576462,
-0.0509337001,
0.2099307477,
0.2277654111,
0.2277219146,
-0.6396798491,
-0.0196050704,
0.0981577709,
0.4069476426,
0.0785052925,
-0.1652729809,
0.7171141505,
-0.2873307467,
-0.5142870545,
0.5182903409,
0.8666383624,
0.0605189987,
-0.0690421239,
0.8380171061,
0.5323710442,
0.3295382261,
0.0439457595,
1.3375716209,
-0.0191427339,
0.2743837237,
1.2512620687,
0.2148608416,
0.6434414387,
0.7359890938,
-0.2287929654,
0.4539241493,
0.6719822884,
0.3000307977,
0.8554664254,
0.2131177336,
-0.184944272,
-0.1077225134,
0.3321911395,
-0.4691212177,
0.4757403731,
0.3005171716,
-0.130373612,
-0.3435651958,
0.1443790942,
-0.3222707808,
0.3242018521,
-0.0183268748,
0.7279479504,
-0.035880588,
-0.6462458372,
0.5381546021,
-0.0819511488,
0.4812743068,
-0.5807135701,
0.1154837757,
-0.5557988286,
0.0744198635,
0.1183576211,
-0.7698919773,
0.223946169,
-0.5650330782,
-0.1048438549,
0.0437977575,
0.3610519171,
-0.6385613084,
-0.6739316583,
-0.0233730394,
0.4344125688,
0.1767895818,
-0.1071298867,
-0.3546343744,
-0.3375496864,
-0.0766775087,
-0.1312473416,
-0.2461913675,
0.7866670489,
0.4516282976,
0.3275684118,
0.2767261267,
0.2497659177,
0.1498233378,
0.0474773385,
0.9369601607,
-0.2405098677,
-0.6041463614,
-0.5619157553,
0.6904568672,
-0.0892745778,
-0.36454916,
0.4261128604,
0.736675024,
1.067103982,
-0.3405096531,
0.6575939059,
0.051986549,
0.3677275181,
-0.7452328205,
0.1332036257,
-1.0154967308,
0.2093592882,
-0.3188559711,
-0.9570879936,
-0.5340433717,
0.7703436017,
-0.27153337,
-0.2014924437,
1.0205571651,
1.077219367,
-0.3424579203,
0.0294486061,
0.4966638386,
0.0202649925,
-0.1057651043,
0.4067141116,
0.9897894859,
-0.3826610148,
0.5710802078,
-0.4583160281,
-0.2501997948,
0.238096714,
-0.6114558578,
-0.6392218471,
-0.8098064661,
-0.1294009984,
-0.0433183201,
-0.1268003881,
0.2640801072,
0.7756059766,
-0.6234900951,
-0.4634273052,
-0.4099647701,
0.163837418,
-0.0693565756,
-0.2324209809,
0.0595929436,
-0.1635253429,
-0.8551501632,
0.288613528,
0.4446543157,
0.5448297858,
-0.4975162148,
-0.0539930761,
-0.2532088459,
0.0364036039,
0.2298357934,
0.1788432747,
-0.8647927642,
-0.3515952826,
-0.1644284278,
-0.1906805485,
0.3128198683,
0.9961317778,
-0.5394487381,
0.9550848603,
0.4996442795,
0.5352906585,
0.8495408893,
-0.1972210854,
0.7452868819,
-1.0198380947,
0.5576651692,
0.3247199953,
0.3712252378,
0.6476936936,
-0.2786839008,
0.6255987883,
-0.0034885514,
-0.1290169805,
-0.573577702,
0.4906660318,
-1.0139843225,
-0.4918221235,
1.1434886456,
-0.1881617159,
-0.1148196906,
0.1942725331,
-0.376164943,
-0.0017321222,
0.125144884,
0.5881661773,
0.7881593108,
0.4001561403,
-0.489289254,
-0.470861882,
0.3370634019,
0.3316049874,
-0.6506029367,
-0.3361647725,
0.6686069369,
-0.016693214,
0.3995337784,
0.7871090174,
-0.0957216099,
0.2129743397,
0.3131410778,
-0.0485257357,
0.3447097838,
-0.4090961218,
-0.3466890752,
0.0547756292,
-0.2737020254,
-0.4131908119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03626v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03626v1
|
Training LLMs over Neurally Compressed Text
| 2024-04-04T17:48:28 | 2024-04-04T17:48:28 |
Brian Lester, Jaehoon Lee, Alex Alemi, Jeffrey Pennington, Adam Roberts, Jascha Sohl-Dickstein, Noah Constant
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we explore the idea of training large language models (LLMs)
over highly compressed text. While standard subword tokenizers compress text by
a small factor, neural text compressors can achieve much higher rates of
compression. If it were possible to train LLMs directly over neurally
compressed text, this would confer advantages in training and serving
efficiency, as well as easier handling of long text spans. The main obstacle to
this goal is that strong compression tends to produce opaque outputs that are
not well-suited for learning. In particular, we find that text na\"ively
compressed via Arithmetic Coding is not readily learnable by LLMs. To overcome
this, we propose Equal-Info Windows, a novel compression technique whereby text
is segmented into blocks that each compress to the same bit length. Using this
method, we demonstrate effective learning over neurally compressed text that
improves with scale, and outperforms byte-level baselines by a wide margin on
perplexity and inference speed benchmarks. While our method delivers worse
perplexity than subword tokenizers for models trained with the same parameter
count, it has the benefit of shorter sequence lengths. Shorter sequence lengths
require fewer autoregressive generation steps, and reduce latency. Finally, we
provide extensive analysis of the properties that contribute to learnability,
and offer concrete suggestions for how to further improve the performance of
high-compression tokenizers.
|
[
-0.0311223492,
-0.5695180297,
0.448165983,
0.1003054678,
-0.3695371747,
0.040476758,
-0.5213276744,
-0.4881546199,
0.3008298874,
0.140493542,
-0.3304584324,
-0.2714532912,
-0.9428747296,
0.2437624633,
-0.3128012419,
0.9260685444,
0.1160540581,
0.1994719058,
-0.1826080978,
0.1183208451,
-0.1388580948,
-0.8699701428,
-0.7870545983,
-0.0641630888,
0.4941580594,
0.1444308609,
0.5561823845,
0.9556177258,
0.4227071106,
0.3981398642,
-0.2385888994,
0.2440287173,
-0.65738976,
0.1209958345,
0.2846446633,
-0.6621055603,
-0.3093073666,
0.0117340563,
0.8532589674,
0.7464696169,
-0.1266183406,
0.0353169031,
0.2058678418,
0.7076789737,
-0.5770128369,
0.244757995,
-0.9224155545,
0.3875717223,
-0.1059463546,
-0.3632670641,
-0.5267254114,
-0.2468570918,
-0.3506926,
-0.5739318132,
0.2000492215,
0.2852909863,
0.7989656329,
0.3990999758,
-0.311344564,
-0.1335820854,
-0.4652315974,
0.672553122,
-0.7938861251,
0.3244891167,
0.2049855143,
0.1873939931,
-0.169724673,
-0.6754666567,
-0.4506958127,
0.093133837,
0.0425499156,
0.00073193,
-0.394467473,
0.3549745679,
0.466706723,
0.4507666528,
-0.4623900056,
0.3005459011,
-0.4608636796,
-0.3318308592,
0.3764905035,
0.1858838052,
0.2197941393,
0.0516157262,
-0.4704663754,
-0.0573680066,
-0.8857818246,
0.0764048994,
0.6798886061,
0.3652088046,
0.1414792836,
0.534032166,
-0.1477755904,
0.8547567129,
-0.1550168693,
-0.0774524137,
0.1651387066,
-0.0723731816,
-0.2693582177,
0.1161095798,
0.7144645452,
0.12060754,
0.2487217039,
-0.4593853951,
-0.505127728,
-0.0885777026,
0.1664026082,
-1.1715631485,
0.0260195918,
-0.0645476505,
-0.5870532393,
-0.144743681,
0.0537950993,
-0.5152165294,
-0.404668957,
-0.533511579,
0.4716876149,
-0.3515187502,
0.0433316901,
0.2484360933,
-0.2045383155,
-0.1480573118,
0.3258063793,
-1.0914237499,
0.417963773,
0.682869792,
0.7958731651,
-0.1271210164,
-0.2271873504,
-0.6645054221,
-0.1269639134,
-0.2363055348,
0.5254654884,
-0.4837253392,
0.1359998435,
0.0399431698,
-0.3302733004,
0.0078358604,
-0.6527832747,
0.4262819588,
-0.6506028175,
0.0344629996,
0.0493157133,
-0.8283495903,
0.0996373519,
0.2978853285,
-0.6198601127,
0.7975881696,
0.0633984655,
-0.8887272477,
0.0670869574,
-0.2067651898,
-0.3570007384,
-0.1192723438,
-0.373445183,
-0.3165130615,
0.4808100462,
0.1782684773,
0.5699375272,
-0.325763911,
0.1306774169,
-0.0052337917,
-0.5031764507,
0.2379811257,
-0.8402377963,
0.545093596,
0.102584891,
-0.1411151439,
-0.0137998061,
-0.8251433969,
0.1355652511,
0.0524438843,
-1.0056824684,
-0.2660649121,
-0.2240700573,
-0.0048917113,
0.0687691197,
0.3860885501,
-0.6897432208,
0.4138641953,
-0.5646407604,
0.5086048245,
0.9102361798,
-0.4848592877,
0.3662010729,
-0.1856552213,
0.45411551,
0.1132082269,
0.0494854823,
-0.240253374,
-0.158670634,
-0.9398450255,
-0.3262445331,
0.6228393316,
0.3353009224,
-0.8159563541,
0.6548768878,
-0.4884163439,
-0.1065383926,
-0.57926929,
0.1892994791,
0.430993855,
0.3901399672,
0.2334646732,
-0.3342140913,
-0.6705129743,
-0.7894404531,
-0.4790236056,
0.0086780405,
0.0229503457,
0.1311371475,
0.1313107014,
0.071861878,
0.7355369925,
-0.4762388766,
-0.0586884357,
-0.1740219742,
0.2018062323,
0.2885244489,
0.4515928626,
0.1499154419,
-0.786721468,
-0.3924849927,
-0.3874275386,
-0.5552057028,
-0.0937661529,
-0.0392653942,
0.1347874701,
0.1482657641,
0.9065418243,
-0.6908839345,
0.4609100521,
0.6146114469,
-0.4186896682,
0.3015195429,
-0.4160609841,
-0.1363488436,
-1.0854402781,
-0.2974841893,
-0.0908437222,
-0.3969683349,
-0.6989673376,
-0.0770799518,
0.2463542074,
-0.1117223129,
-0.4112386405,
0.2542074621,
-0.7098481655,
-0.1051166803,
-0.4730933011,
-0.0012447692,
-0.0818492696,
0.6482964158,
-0.1009823158,
0.9129133224,
0.3794713318,
-0.4314706624,
0.2272593528,
-0.1407082528,
-0.5441762805,
0.204714343,
-0.5101681948,
0.1951160282,
-0.552492559,
0.1857141703,
-0.862118423,
0.1156626344,
-0.149670735,
-0.615154922,
0.719811976,
-0.0542460307,
-0.6221283674,
0.0869320482,
-0.242827937,
0.4686508179,
0.6191516519,
-0.8488340974,
0.4805876315,
0.3194351792,
-0.0799805075,
-0.790017128,
-0.6893460155,
0.2821853459,
-0.1108455658,
-0.5585555434,
0.4525859356,
-0.1387305856,
-0.0287761372,
-0.075891681,
-0.1757399142,
-0.146726951,
0.1149857864,
0.2961969078,
0.1640447378,
-0.3075557649,
0.5336474776,
0.0090372935,
-0.1394663602,
-0.0987702832,
-0.6027466655,
0.6524966955,
-0.1803288311,
-0.1542128026,
-0.2092152834,
0.2689009905,
0.3099260032,
0.1252053976,
0.9243934155,
0.4378830791,
-0.4759261906,
-0.2141462713,
-0.5174016953,
-0.2221924514,
-0.488124758,
0.5494694114,
-0.3150841296,
-1.0984787941,
0.1892761141,
-0.1474762708,
-0.0343223028,
0.3401099145,
0.2404165715,
-0.0022713344,
0.8698706031,
0.8269114494,
-0.2679145336,
0.4670425951,
-0.2081986666,
0.2071337849,
-0.6954113245,
-0.1557656229,
-0.5569109321,
-0.4274111092,
-0.2214475721,
-0.5141424537,
0.2940340042,
0.3564742506,
-0.219604522,
0.1779179871,
-0.4680542052,
0.7816262245,
0.3834526837,
0.26366207,
0.2660268545,
0.3174919486,
0.0702435076,
-0.251856178,
-0.9793843627,
-0.3404634297,
0.833117187,
0.4703906775,
0.9205938578,
0.0896521658,
0.6240378022,
0.1154379174,
0.1801021248,
-0.9126147628,
0.3886026442,
-0.4141842425,
-0.2525322735,
-0.3372348249,
-0.9730027318,
-1.0852922201,
0.237370953,
-0.3214321434,
-0.5620461702,
-0.0247762036,
0.0228659306,
-0.251060158,
0.61415869,
-0.7406680584,
0.517916739,
-0.2408346981,
-0.0346749648,
-0.0411675051,
-0.5744099021,
0.0331901796,
-0.0525372662,
0.1772768795,
0.0644496903,
-0.4459116459,
0.8585736752,
-0.729462862,
0.9661303163,
-0.0267158188,
0.0497842431,
-0.0893116966,
-0.1667943448,
0.5324947238,
-0.2642149329,
0.0164048374,
0.3053112626,
-0.4630437195,
-0.4891187549,
-0.8483908176,
0.5106654167,
-0.8776994944,
-0.5717048645,
-0.26409024,
-0.6871397495,
-0.145364657,
0.0853857547,
0.48272416,
0.7885150313,
0.1530269235,
0.2480404526,
0.8235508204,
-0.0617870688,
0.5669932365,
0.4032284915,
0.049713891,
-0.4002155066,
0.7847507596,
0.2514130175,
0.3243018985,
0.7353577614,
0.2366384864,
-0.2329241484,
-0.7869297862,
-0.4179872572,
-0.0824912712,
-0.8710051179,
-0.4573062062,
-0.6286045313,
-0.5486261249,
-0.426361084,
0.0768679529,
-0.3606951833,
-0.7042610049,
-0.3696085513,
-0.1268726587,
0.2543568313,
0.7576637268,
-0.1138349399,
0.4528386295,
-0.8354389071,
0.1220882013,
0.2989833355,
0.3354156315,
0.1452158689,
-0.8323917985,
-0.4699598253,
-0.1618393958,
-0.0240933951,
-0.5820773244,
0.3906884193,
0.2623849809,
0.4093973935,
0.3309906125,
0.0107669057,
0.5017673373,
-0.6656998992,
0.5462097526,
0.5716787577,
-0.8859523535,
0.0765793398,
0.100011684,
0.2984670997,
0.6200307012,
0.5336039662,
-0.4144220054,
-0.1784576774,
-0.4700730145,
-0.9525614381,
0.5479259491,
0.1985281408,
0.4681695998,
0.0534581244,
0.5194571614,
0.169757247,
0.3165430725,
-0.8644307852,
-0.34748891,
0.0791497752,
-0.6062618494,
-0.1180206686,
-0.3862158656,
0.0261017065,
-0.2511015534,
0.6157185435,
-0.1722295582,
0.3249992132,
0.2125760466,
-0.1902399957,
0.1986614764,
0.3750518858,
0.2588855624,
0.44250983,
0.0223818738,
0.6178418994,
0.1583485603,
-0.6714752316,
0.2433437854,
0.1456113309,
-0.1034832001,
0.0179632828,
0.3743401468,
1.1243884563,
0.057348676,
-0.6302833557,
0.8161145449,
-0.4198707044,
-0.0827392191,
-0.1220979989,
-0.0180581324,
-0.0153156351,
0.2595487833,
0.2892669141,
0.1531460434,
-0.0106167151,
-0.6568964124,
-0.0968209729,
0.3534061313,
-0.618668735,
-0.0676208362,
0.3951554298,
0.1564737856,
-0.5316132307,
0.7766622305,
-0.1042006686,
-0.6768014431,
0.6023756862,
0.7300622463,
0.656673789,
0.0722561032,
-0.3733428717,
0.2009890229,
0.4531745017,
-0.1421947777,
0.1392916739,
-0.2336164564,
-0.6472055912,
-0.5671281815,
-0.643868506,
-0.1842668504,
0.129667446,
-0.3949301243,
0.0435984656,
-0.4804654121,
-0.0877427608,
-0.1163193658,
-0.1164841279,
-0.4780685604,
0.1786955595,
0.1616990119,
1.3136568069,
-0.651871562,
0.7827314138,
0.429030925,
-0.2234891355,
-0.9110202193,
-0.0579602569,
-0.2538711727,
-0.7849102616,
0.8351735473,
0.4917517602,
0.0802866966,
-0.0437237918,
-0.6506509185,
-0.7749348879,
0.7931596637,
0.6189118624,
-0.8061028123,
-0.1816964746,
0.2414109409,
0.5184640288,
-0.3816933036,
0.3481591344,
0.3811538815,
0.1668985933,
-0.1267526895,
-0.6661724448,
0.1301998794,
-0.4663799405,
-0.0576739013,
0.3274841905,
-0.55420506,
0.9136211872,
0.0312074479,
-0.2376182824,
0.1446812898,
0.7910025716,
-0.0796928629,
0.0730304867,
0.548188448,
0.7918232679,
0.9021555781,
-0.0539449342,
1.0039200783,
-0.3709893525,
0.1780628711,
1.0951962471,
0.2879689336,
0.8990208507,
0.5924336314,
-0.1298476011,
0.2798192501,
0.4410297275,
0.2485304624,
0.3400858045,
0.6510896683,
-0.3497729301,
-0.3891833127,
-0.0096011031,
-0.1888541132,
0.2360733002,
0.2378817648,
-0.4282305837,
-0.1074055433,
-0.0792534798,
0.0091594309,
0.2274591327,
-0.3757377863,
0.6853444576,
0.2463269234,
-0.4760360122,
0.7079654932,
0.1979475021,
1.1351314783,
-0.6558581591,
0.1152555421,
-0.1291317046,
0.0816455856,
-0.18427746,
-0.4797453582,
0.1134150699,
0.1235009506,
-0.3377857506,
-0.2590598464,
0.8398463726,
-0.6225072742,
-0.3076139987,
0.034288507,
0.2916438878,
0.5036042333,
-0.2475276142,
-0.4500775933,
0.005991084,
-0.0815226287,
-0.2160114199,
0.5465857983,
0.5476287603,
0.3768958151,
0.397482276,
0.5211787224,
0.4101365507,
0.3880373836,
0.0919558182,
0.8907357454,
-0.64494133,
-0.4108503759,
-1.0120075941,
0.1654129922,
-0.3244788349,
-0.2587320805,
0.6744403839,
0.8234180212,
0.7952950001,
0.0685398132,
0.7129622698,
0.2187153697,
0.2862088978,
-0.9024603367,
0.6517130136,
-0.5482752323,
0.3743267357,
0.3325824738,
-0.908085525,
-0.2549718022,
0.4797493517,
-0.0375440978,
0.0057471162,
0.5827438235,
0.6922729611,
-0.1049361825,
0.0600806847,
0.4909425378,
0.2519840002,
0.0935403928,
0.9092949033,
1.053968668,
-0.6091365218,
0.8129854202,
-0.0407360457,
-0.2049354464,
-0.0362782441,
-0.8602204919,
-1.0753760338,
-0.4049746692,
-0.1329670399,
-0.4612906873,
0.107850723,
1.1151072979,
0.8432043195,
-0.380346179,
-0.0656539872,
-0.2257316262,
0.1532913595,
0.2363654673,
-0.1544882357,
0.3421055675,
-0.483535707,
-0.7825049162,
0.4664531052,
0.3124862313,
0.285231024,
-0.2586758733,
-0.0337354466,
0.1947893798,
0.2705537677,
0.538823545,
0.1496970803,
-0.1961415261,
-0.0885380358,
-0.2167064548,
-0.3891775906,
0.3548623919,
0.9900209308,
-0.758244276,
0.2940701544,
0.7209550142,
0.9675670862,
0.5146182179,
-0.1492774636,
0.3676080406,
-1.0663920641,
0.297976315,
0.1737496108,
0.5705654025,
0.5035767555,
-0.5232465267,
0.4023999572,
0.1225464419,
-0.5062497258,
-0.7330543399,
0.1189953387,
-0.6977958679,
-0.550186038,
1.3537783623,
-0.334061265,
-0.3243750334,
0.0299769528,
-0.2392218113,
0.314049989,
-0.3882099688,
0.8290124536,
0.5346009731,
0.0968933478,
0.093475692,
-0.2453590035,
0.5032830238,
0.5011154413,
-0.8625835776,
0.0744579211,
0.2804912925,
0.1152754799,
0.1685584933,
0.6220011115,
-0.1112562492,
-0.0107546123,
0.1926047951,
0.0836985633,
-0.3396077454,
-0.4945844412,
-0.833122015,
0.3287742436,
0.0645895377,
-0.0220243037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03623v1
|
Unveiling LLMs: The Evolution of Latent Representations in a Temporal Knowledge Graph
| 2024-04-04T17:45:59 | 2024-04-04T17:45:59 |
Marco Bronzini, Carlo Nicolini, Bruno Lepri, Jacopo Staiano, Andrea Passerini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate an impressive capacity to recall a
vast range of common factual knowledge information. However, unravelling the
underlying reasoning of LLMs and explaining their internal mechanisms of
exploiting this factual knowledge remain active areas of investigation. Our
work analyzes the factual knowledge encoded in the latent representation of
LLMs when prompted to assess the truthfulness of factual claims. We propose an
end-to-end framework that jointly decodes the factual knowledge embedded in the
latent space of LLMs from a vector space to a set of ground predicates and
represents its evolution across the layers using a temporal knowledge graph.
Our framework relies on the technique of activation patching which intervenes
in the inference computation of a model by dynamically altering its latent
representations. Consequently, we neither rely on external models nor training
processes. We showcase our framework with local and global interpretability
analyses using two claim verification datasets: FEVER and CLIMATE-FEVER. The
local interpretability analysis exposes different latent errors from
representation to multi-hop reasoning errors. On the other hand, the global
analysis uncovered patterns in the underlying evolution of the model's factual
knowledge (e.g., store-and-seek factual information). By enabling graph-based
analyses of the latent representations, this work represents a step towards the
mechanistic interpretability of LLMs.
|
[
0.1191648245,
-0.8875154853,
0.8085098267,
0.0179255735,
-0.1679533273,
0.5880910158,
-0.2286515683,
-0.3353594244,
0.0450538993,
0.5002382994,
-0.5165670514,
-0.4670161605,
-0.6449661851,
0.0095795216,
-0.1928764582,
0.8724740148,
-0.1942507178,
-0.4124600291,
-0.4551745057,
-0.0433812551,
-0.0084925145,
-0.5877968073,
-0.2421112508,
-0.6618193984,
0.4710078239,
0.1389827728,
0.5437834859,
0.5108889937,
0.1315572858,
0.2262694985,
-0.3398011625,
0.3374543488,
-0.7038788199,
0.0852219313,
-0.2471357137,
-0.5802627802,
-0.4460045993,
0.1867917329,
0.7943155169,
0.8225238323,
-0.0254947506,
0.2355442792,
0.0140355816,
0.2302935123,
-0.5120764375,
0.427164793,
-0.8283472657,
-0.0398376212,
-0.2300089598,
-0.4694363773,
-0.5309519172,
-0.0856394693,
0.0618467219,
-0.331254065,
0.1596980393,
-0.0001901252,
0.7247316241,
0.2416690588,
-0.6422898173,
-0.1693035513,
-0.6628339887,
0.5559309125,
-0.6395402551,
0.2739107609,
0.0641468465,
0.350548327,
-0.5497784615,
-0.9350033402,
-0.6617324352,
-0.1596463621,
-0.2193616331,
0.0345129967,
-0.402210474,
-0.189440459,
0.1874212921,
0.3755087852,
-0.4993491769,
-0.0057417564,
-0.2064663321,
-0.4808910787,
0.3651600182,
-0.0381256826,
0.4568227232,
-0.2470349073,
-0.4395504296,
0.4662057459,
-0.988699019,
0.1280677915,
0.1761371046,
0.2773972154,
-0.3881777525,
0.6131495833,
-0.0575937927,
0.5560567975,
-0.2699821591,
-0.1924390495,
0.2503506839,
-0.207245782,
-0.2728722692,
0.0620294549,
0.5431720018,
0.2681301534,
-0.1996881515,
-0.4349576533,
-0.1233623251,
0.0327296853,
-0.0826677307,
-0.6274479032,
-0.0096482588,
0.1754884869,
-0.38650316,
-0.4186731577,
-0.1285134107,
-0.6112463474,
-0.3902439475,
-0.2709578872,
0.2490399331,
-0.2138940245,
-0.4105710685,
0.1113836244,
0.0009076043,
0.1513710916,
0.1973843575,
-0.4959358573,
0.1668780744,
0.5998668671,
0.830625236,
0.0578271896,
-0.0402791239,
-0.3487065434,
0.4850363135,
-0.3629521728,
0.7779597044,
-0.6898400187,
-0.150544703,
-0.0488282964,
0.2861613333,
-0.2118574679,
-0.4050295651,
0.3225361109,
-0.9710810781,
0.0821585581,
-0.3750463426,
-0.5103651285,
-0.3640010357,
0.4202221632,
-0.5326777697,
0.9090328813,
0.1849557608,
-0.8343623281,
0.1756879538,
-0.6313439608,
-0.0270162318,
-0.1259993166,
-0.2537876368,
-0.3663304448,
0.121212326,
0.2926045954,
0.4471429884,
-0.3977349401,
0.4506146014,
-0.403947264,
-0.0690033808,
0.5648569465,
-0.5590858459,
0.8908255696,
0.0996418744,
-0.2856661677,
-0.1594631821,
-0.8700335622,
-0.3411249518,
0.386398375,
-0.3503841162,
0.0545118451,
0.1675263494,
-0.6133099794,
0.0811513886,
0.4427993298,
-0.5722463727,
0.3670187891,
-0.3204197586,
0.5770507455,
0.6909788847,
0.446136266,
0.240917787,
-0.2657591701,
0.3448261023,
0.3590994179,
0.1125411242,
-0.4728575051,
-0.3881241381,
-0.5099509358,
-0.1290674657,
0.1560389698,
0.4743284881,
-0.686362505,
0.1916880906,
-0.5095695853,
-0.2499255538,
-0.0074266391,
0.0909566879,
0.2810154259,
0.6592324972,
0.2567328215,
0.073255524,
-0.4188684523,
-0.7215194702,
-0.1306366771,
-0.3656840324,
0.1748363525,
0.1629897803,
0.5159267783,
-0.4304825068,
1.1357393265,
-0.4905005991,
0.1422211528,
-0.1781862378,
0.3372642398,
0.409976393,
0.2432186007,
0.6496813297,
-0.63163203,
-0.0203725249,
0.0505138934,
-0.9693778157,
-0.3341407776,
-0.1102739573,
0.0730171949,
0.1996290386,
0.6998590827,
-0.2935868204,
0.4731635451,
0.6576509476,
-0.4985040128,
0.6735901237,
-0.2805576921,
0.1236299202,
-0.7723891735,
0.0180741604,
-0.3996249735,
-0.3721275926,
-0.4055722952,
-0.0055281427,
-0.15768525,
0.0540273525,
-0.1601803154,
0.6082473993,
-0.6494732499,
-0.2205029577,
-0.1239998266,
0.0923519731,
0.1968222558,
0.4278641641,
-0.3023408949,
0.5834824443,
0.5749636292,
-0.4781702757,
0.3699129522,
-0.1127710789,
-0.2771520317,
0.1221313477,
-0.3975595236,
0.1443947703,
-0.3127749562,
0.3070188165,
-1.0343955755,
-0.1859871,
0.434117645,
-0.4828317165,
0.4462399483,
-0.5708637834,
-0.7431610823,
-0.1602562815,
0.0799888074,
0.384973079,
0.5314081311,
-0.6484104991,
0.9710352421,
0.2724057734,
-0.2020104676,
-0.5049960613,
-0.4428743422,
0.1124992371,
-0.1767696589,
-0.7336334586,
0.2842724621,
0.0848376825,
-0.574483633,
0.3195864856,
-0.211409986,
0.1067416593,
0.1077329069,
0.176416114,
0.2191911489,
-0.3724380434,
0.0778008923,
0.0371766798,
-0.2829274833,
0.3325381875,
-0.5100713372,
0.464078337,
-0.0241395496,
-0.5501868725,
0.0079917675,
-0.0727963224,
0.6395851374,
-0.1735675633,
0.9949248433,
0.4157555997,
-0.5017230511,
-0.1050527692,
-0.4875591993,
0.1136796772,
-0.4095133841,
0.1451217979,
-0.3987294734,
-0.7975353599,
0.8838123083,
-0.5620734096,
0.1017932072,
0.6215036511,
0.5356629491,
-0.0107912356,
0.6024341583,
0.6381083131,
0.2303127199,
0.1199581251,
-0.2648924291,
0.1535576284,
-0.9195200205,
-0.6824602485,
-0.2107538581,
0.0111729605,
-0.2710272372,
-1.0365761518,
0.4897060096,
0.3452626765,
-0.1398562789,
-0.3525388241,
-0.017579658,
0.5499984622,
-0.0806344301,
0.25546211,
0.3673735261,
0.1550119072,
-0.5181831717,
-0.0339870341,
-0.5188959241,
-0.6619690061,
1.1793562174,
0.5033048391,
0.5138750076,
0.397706002,
0.3779182732,
0.4858255684,
0.3492304683,
-0.3884114027,
0.3417928219,
-0.0166022405,
-0.4969462752,
-0.1427768767,
-0.481939137,
-0.8137413859,
0.1555682421,
-0.2685087323,
-1.03624928,
0.0976978242,
0.1548122615,
-0.1729741395,
0.6181871891,
-0.5026332736,
0.7063368559,
-0.3052449226,
-0.4765409827,
-0.3319380879,
-0.7223346829,
0.4700724185,
-0.1402869523,
0.5717265606,
-0.3360017836,
0.0554552898,
0.7290492058,
-0.3396808207,
1.2747554779,
-0.2390815914,
-0.3092366457,
0.4660755396,
0.1706314087,
0.5637023449,
0.2006993443,
-0.1133751497,
0.1707646698,
-0.02064679,
-0.5945343375,
-0.8312634826,
0.2998899817,
-0.7705148458,
-0.6313357353,
-0.4351732731,
-0.388204515,
-0.2895720601,
0.1368051618,
-0.0580630004,
0.8412448168,
-0.4075694978,
-0.0789913163,
0.8665899634,
-0.4119343758,
0.0915725306,
0.6007852554,
-0.6566264629,
-0.0221037455,
0.9605852365,
0.0661324635,
0.2532029152,
0.5393913984,
0.4256375134,
-0.3852657974,
-0.7286624312,
-0.1857410818,
0.5288072228,
-0.98906672,
-0.0014115311,
-0.6695333719,
-0.2518239021,
-0.4873706996,
0.0082374681,
-0.0997107625,
-0.2971090674,
-0.2987208366,
-0.1715969443,
0.3772258162,
1.0316114426,
-0.3250136971,
0.3845581114,
-0.7739346027,
0.3074626923,
0.2275275588,
0.2053112984,
-0.1240017787,
-0.6422839761,
-0.212462306,
0.0391660593,
-0.0885460228,
-1.0497885942,
0.1753077656,
-0.0065236762,
0.8430873752,
0.5427911878,
0.0517037772,
0.4251668751,
-0.3868972957,
0.8844005466,
0.0410866737,
-0.8837406635,
0.4480138719,
-0.3597631454,
0.0056284536,
-0.0834171921,
0.2773343623,
-0.4220063686,
-0.3326479197,
-0.8364132643,
-0.8535335064,
0.4806409776,
0.0597910881,
-0.0220327973,
0.1790731996,
0.6055738926,
0.1433504224,
-0.0268421117,
-0.6574303508,
-0.2598474622,
-0.1493677795,
0.1037333459,
-0.1163102388,
-0.6685698032,
-0.4624263942,
-0.1015365198,
0.6057343483,
-0.2686612904,
0.3255824447,
0.0782893896,
-0.3960925639,
0.0523404256,
0.3826068342,
0.4402645528,
0.8713564873,
-0.23846443,
0.5251150131,
0.1067917719,
-0.29586941,
-0.0559124015,
0.1638348997,
-0.0181960315,
-0.0353721417,
0.8698647022,
0.7455192804,
0.3175234497,
-0.478030175,
0.4741183817,
0.0539410636,
0.2023297697,
-0.2763385773,
-0.1477131993,
0.2029501945,
0.4638139606,
0.4474350512,
-0.0359291583,
-0.1167086437,
-0.7845352292,
0.3059347272,
0.2202892154,
-0.2057030648,
-0.6715999246,
0.4398747087,
-0.0678533614,
0.2493565381,
0.4834928811,
-0.3193641007,
-0.7523259521,
0.4611203969,
0.6258330345,
0.4179494083,
-0.0510989167,
0.3654717803,
0.2630930543,
0.4536617696,
0.4490446746,
0.1851721406,
0.049291335,
-0.861467123,
-0.6774327159,
-0.6908544898,
-0.2759185731,
0.1337733418,
-0.413982749,
0.0278087072,
-0.2421475351,
0.0789796859,
-0.1010188758,
-0.1161808819,
-0.4700807631,
0.0980409086,
0.246841222,
0.8147583008,
-1.0939390659,
0.5937966704,
0.5619668961,
-0.3386045992,
-0.657638073,
0.1417738646,
0.3341704607,
-1.2949210405,
0.8927588463,
-0.0852106512,
-0.1505324543,
-0.1208795011,
-0.7332205772,
-0.8917129636,
1.0925878286,
0.5728270411,
-0.3877900541,
-0.047500398,
0.1942818314,
0.2872047424,
-0.5393199921,
0.1639764905,
0.606313169,
0.4377966523,
0.5502579808,
-0.5047699809,
0.2159512192,
-0.0797904208,
-0.3565566838,
-0.1223975793,
-0.408986181,
0.7953674197,
-0.5159307122,
-0.3907695711,
-0.4156826437,
0.8368672132,
0.2164339721,
0.3164514601,
0.4017861485,
0.4067276418,
1.0845885277,
-0.2242421359,
0.9988580942,
-0.3915455639,
0.2704808414,
1.0030468702,
-0.1533437669,
0.5285605788,
0.3353542686,
-0.2736400068,
0.7647442818,
0.6989392638,
0.1339674145,
0.3565581739,
0.3629586697,
-0.4148906469,
-0.3662569225,
-0.2899290919,
-0.2835242748,
0.3616113067,
0.7537716627,
-0.2523261011,
-0.5454311371,
-0.1944760829,
0.3737561405,
-0.1446828544,
-0.2430281937,
0.6446687579,
0.0589516908,
-0.3377996981,
0.4270360768,
-0.046225898,
0.1344783455,
-0.5169991851,
-0.225181967,
-0.1476375759,
-0.0759701878,
-0.3149492145,
-0.868653357,
0.3150915802,
0.0476722121,
-0.3290094435,
-0.151285544,
0.6741241813,
-0.3149151504,
-0.4575191736,
0.3087337911,
0.7272818685,
0.2949177027,
0.1419139504,
-0.5191168189,
0.302895695,
0.0156034697,
-0.2726136744,
0.0325485766,
0.9590265155,
-0.1630360335,
0.6680010557,
0.7586512566,
0.2863251567,
0.1425466537,
0.1634940505,
1.0851479769,
-0.4957512617,
-0.3893252909,
-0.987085402,
0.6013281345,
-0.0287499353,
0.3572467268,
0.5388212204,
0.5409729481,
0.2774112523,
0.4384694695,
0.8775101304,
-0.0173081458,
0.4823506773,
-1.015766263,
0.6333626509,
-0.4176379442,
0.6417018771,
0.1406297684,
-0.5793656111,
-0.1275451332,
0.2141091675,
-0.4774893224,
-0.1875129193,
0.7407656312,
0.561606586,
0.0411795042,
-0.0834437907,
0.1992384791,
0.8061543703,
0.4830347896,
0.3944224715,
1.050227046,
-0.0172032733,
0.3883117437,
0.1214670986,
-0.5349167585,
-0.1035955623,
-1.2681757212,
-0.8903929591,
-0.5591317415,
-0.4210623205,
-0.6809082031,
0.0779025182,
0.7546830773,
0.2623955309,
-0.5531119108,
0.1698009074,
0.333764255,
0.3462582529,
0.0529143326,
-0.2024498582,
0.610548377,
-0.3735144138,
-0.2379548848,
0.4516239762,
0.4263513684,
0.1998133063,
-0.3421344757,
-0.0549176224,
0.0044985996,
0.1127437726,
0.6607864499,
0.3159937561,
-0.6992622614,
-0.2894574702,
-0.1379240155,
0.2068481892,
0.1276520938,
1.0421085358,
-0.9275957346,
0.5232483149,
0.2795549333,
0.5669716001,
0.4913519025,
-0.3388663232,
0.6442533731,
-0.8027148247,
0.0247951727,
-0.0275214072,
0.6600633264,
0.4101759195,
-0.1723166555,
0.4132991433,
0.6767759919,
-0.3368448913,
-0.9886906147,
0.3963636756,
-0.935143888,
-0.438765645,
1.1619112492,
-0.4282914698,
-0.4458452761,
-0.4332719743,
0.2160500884,
0.4878071547,
-0.1298090816,
0.6910638213,
0.6883772612,
-0.1668913364,
-0.1422786713,
-0.4772406816,
0.3705940843,
-0.1964996755,
-0.7455672622,
0.3335936368,
0.4336875677,
0.5521009564,
0.3194688857,
0.7499753237,
-0.3611645401,
-0.1222489774,
0.0636557117,
-0.2954373956,
-0.2075130939,
-0.316151917,
-0.1739195287,
0.1890889704,
0.0937623978,
0.2299983203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03622v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03622v2
|
Mind's Eye of LLMs: Visualization-of-Thought Elicits Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T17:45:08 | 2024-05-24T04:07:44 |
Wenshan Wu, Shaoguang Mao, Yadong Zhang, Yan Xia, Li Dong, Lei Cui, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive performance in
language comprehension and various reasoning tasks. However, their abilities in
spatial reasoning, a crucial aspect of human cognition, remain relatively
unexplored. Human possess a remarkable ability to create mental images of
unseen objects and actions through a process known as the Mind's Eye, enabling
the imagination of the unseen world. Inspired by this cognitive capacity, we
propose Visualization-of-Thought (VoT) prompting. VoT aims to elicit spatial
reasoning of LLMs by visualizing their reasoning traces, thereby guiding
subsequent reasoning steps. We employed VoT for multi-hop spatial reasoning
tasks, including natural language navigation, visual navigation, and visual
tiling in 2D grid worlds. Experimental results demonstrated that VoT
significantly enhances the spatial reasoning abilities of LLMs. Notably, VoT
outperformed existing multimodal large language models (MLLMs) in these tasks.
While VoT works surprisingly well on LLMs, the ability to generate mental
images to facilitate spatial reasoning resembles the mind's eye process,
suggesting its potential viability in MLLMs.
|
[
-0.6024090648,
-0.8994850516,
1.2251015902,
0.1563713849,
-0.3719246089,
-0.1889049262,
-0.0136533063,
-0.2190099806,
0.1527397782,
0.5396640897,
-0.6818594933,
-0.5442355275,
-0.2365611196,
0.0625980571,
-0.1548480242,
0.4074614346,
0.0042404141,
-0.0360686593,
-0.2868717909,
0.2783150971,
-0.8278839588,
-0.2946532369,
-0.5802605748,
-0.2933783531,
0.7910416722,
0.2017477006,
0.5191815495,
0.4952072501,
0.482023716,
0.3271128833,
0.067068018,
0.4629630744,
-0.3517821431,
0.1225950569,
-0.2792951763,
-0.7052126527,
-0.4449976385,
-0.1574018896,
0.5092715621,
0.5389999747,
-0.0527238436,
-0.1329842806,
0.0009447398,
1.0389806032,
-0.390925318,
0.2298373431,
-0.6927416921,
0.163312301,
0.0372778662,
-0.4840734005,
-0.312266767,
-0.3465491533,
0.4642467201,
-0.8255479336,
-0.1579239219,
0.420981735,
0.4613445699,
0.5599064827,
-0.3444394171,
0.0552416518,
-0.5569390059,
0.4941326976,
-0.1914672554,
0.6064596772,
0.3218150735,
0.5009056926,
-0.1968984753,
-0.3814412951,
-0.679557085,
-0.1434101313,
0.1766119003,
0.4611812532,
-0.2879478931,
-0.0356087796,
0.6233161688,
-0.1298998892,
-0.6593543887,
-0.4133530855,
-0.3646611869,
0.1111188456,
0.2797124088,
0.208199963,
0.548995316,
-0.1238752753,
-0.7739710212,
-0.0895858407,
-0.8204545379,
-0.0499918126,
-0.2118168622,
0.0576457679,
0.023297986,
0.7250745893,
-0.109742932,
0.8552850485,
-0.1913242936,
0.1168020964,
-0.2354299575,
-0.1623815447,
-0.3366669714,
-0.1210787594,
0.4107368886,
0.7765837312,
0.6082154512,
-0.0901381448,
-0.1685076505,
0.3154641986,
0.4037247598,
-0.3460402787,
-0.4048224986,
0.2255890965,
-0.2866927683,
0.0732024759,
-0.0134660993,
-0.7728687525,
-0.626294136,
-0.4481461644,
0.3023916185,
-0.6936152577,
-0.3478418589,
0.4697320461,
-0.448020786,
0.1599017233,
0.7641766071,
-0.6584873199,
-0.1625500917,
0.5265139937,
0.6772719026,
-0.0795639157,
-0.7243831158,
-0.1556396335,
0.4319341779,
-0.601847887,
1.3865218163,
-0.5865162015,
-0.3987993896,
-0.1511764228,
-0.3073952496,
-0.0308879185,
-0.4818254113,
0.2597585917,
-0.489562571,
-0.0782160014,
-1.001896739,
-0.3488516212,
-0.2705716491,
0.6179388762,
-0.4521228075,
0.9079786539,
-0.1631702185,
-0.6894112825,
0.6641945243,
-0.8639247417,
-0.0145474132,
0.5085021853,
-0.523681879,
0.0768459439,
0.1151700839,
0.6182436347,
0.3843111992,
0.052774664,
-0.0921267197,
-0.2383081019,
-0.4551971555,
0.4179279506,
-0.2644486427,
0.6742914319,
0.0949624553,
-0.2826858461,
0.2020040154,
-0.270599544,
0.1837842762,
0.4052364826,
-0.1977995336,
-0.5100323558,
0.1050587744,
-0.3700381517,
0.0778767169,
0.1284932494,
-0.3640641868,
0.5135133266,
-0.3395976722,
0.3076907396,
0.7117859125,
0.0259840991,
0.5064646602,
-0.1231320426,
0.5034689903,
0.1597617567,
0.0754405335,
-0.2054953426,
-0.8061770201,
-0.8726027012,
-0.3787563741,
-0.3788967729,
0.7480250001,
-1.3250302076,
0.1532056481,
-0.3888206184,
-0.3985765278,
-0.2349469662,
-0.1957109571,
0.160823524,
0.3370477855,
0.2243291587,
0.245497629,
-0.5808693767,
-0.7611860037,
-0.3384291828,
-0.1238561049,
0.070731096,
0.4667365551,
0.6629109979,
-0.4766350389,
0.8251271248,
-0.6691725254,
-0.1677343845,
-0.3860317469,
-0.0883505046,
0.0383722335,
0.0146949515,
0.3870542943,
-0.5651915073,
-0.3124657571,
0.3309504092,
-0.9039776325,
-0.1234150603,
-0.1347795725,
-0.6034419537,
-0.0858206153,
0.6195172071,
-0.8663949966,
0.8254808187,
0.1160686836,
-0.5744200349,
0.5905867219,
-0.4172337353,
0.2249994129,
-0.6034115553,
-0.1914658248,
-0.1183627322,
-0.0192533284,
-0.4331620634,
-0.0604047105,
0.0661074817,
-0.2644793689,
-0.3646318018,
0.7736694217,
-0.6208382845,
-0.2582426667,
-0.2968479991,
0.5492352843,
0.1085098088,
0.5572603345,
0.326171279,
0.8430091739,
0.8516643643,
-0.5683504343,
0.4662281573,
0.2243815064,
-0.5318310261,
0.6432263255,
-0.3990897834,
0.1706814319,
-0.3277214468,
0.2705918849,
-1.0187951326,
-0.0017555986,
0.1678953916,
-0.1415103078,
-0.1893872023,
0.0500306264,
-0.4046092629,
-0.598677814,
-0.1640413851,
0.3942328691,
0.2046450675,
-0.8082766533,
0.7353403568,
0.2097543925,
0.0419309251,
-0.3500782549,
-0.7480927706,
0.2842975557,
-0.253090173,
-0.5098502636,
-0.1044628844,
0.011070013,
-0.4175815582,
-0.0689554513,
0.1484742463,
0.234312579,
-0.2635258436,
0.2293851376,
0.5965646505,
-0.0706274286,
0.0581754334,
-0.2122762054,
-0.1875987798,
0.2590986788,
-0.6076615453,
0.28682217,
-0.4072397053,
-0.7595853209,
-0.3739544451,
0.3974527717,
0.6728177667,
-0.2605759501,
0.1536613405,
0.2979890704,
-0.3260482848,
-0.452765286,
-0.6318796277,
-0.2218116373,
-0.4450022876,
0.4053445756,
-0.5749351382,
-0.7554032207,
0.3515805602,
-0.2904153466,
-0.1701408178,
-0.1798448712,
0.5763828158,
-0.5252425075,
1.004273653,
0.4267500937,
0.1394066066,
0.5338779688,
-0.3906887174,
0.4846323431,
-1.0341482162,
-0.3245763779,
-0.0015977056,
-0.3577478826,
-0.1888296157,
-0.979039371,
0.7206429243,
-0.0951008722,
-0.0349059887,
0.0177624505,
-0.6913405061,
0.8917898536,
0.6237232685,
0.3075974882,
0.0957372412,
0.1977137178,
-0.5710655451,
-0.2311109304,
-0.8634525537,
-0.5063006282,
0.7384973764,
0.115958266,
0.6068672538,
-0.0652419403,
0.5607914329,
0.0603097491,
0.1362323016,
-0.7656776905,
1.0438101292,
0.1453877538,
-0.2833948731,
-0.5019615889,
-0.0864393413,
-0.985003233,
0.5994426012,
-0.2215931267,
-0.9183803797,
0.0713551864,
0.2728691697,
-0.4105220437,
0.5397974253,
-0.8020943999,
0.6011475325,
-0.4813171625,
-0.3470581472,
-0.3674546182,
-0.0644035712,
0.249285996,
0.3246885538,
0.0091314726,
0.2350644916,
-0.0526791811,
0.2946204543,
-0.0422883406,
0.7975597382,
-0.303198278,
-0.1531853825,
0.4286134839,
0.2781996727,
0.5992122889,
-0.0967109054,
0.512142837,
0.1610360891,
-0.4051122963,
-0.1884700954,
-0.8363032341,
0.6738710999,
-0.3236096799,
-0.8569653034,
-0.2872923017,
-0.7164168954,
-0.326774478,
0.2534008026,
0.1997793615,
0.1092353165,
-0.0958144963,
-0.1517282873,
0.8475086689,
-0.3147530258,
0.1555221081,
0.0503383093,
-0.8547039628,
-0.3280262947,
0.936060071,
-0.0087965643,
-0.029281931,
0.4478361011,
0.1600567997,
-0.5045204163,
-0.4921214283,
-0.4440688789,
0.4007714987,
-0.7844977379,
0.0573462062,
-0.5322076678,
-0.0774993747,
0.1306357384,
-0.4494923353,
-0.0828475505,
-0.1002061069,
0.1268194318,
-0.233058989,
0.235506922,
0.9755008221,
0.2108818889,
-0.1011164933,
-0.5134791136,
0.4341603816,
0.8425627351,
0.3434976637,
0.3075459003,
-0.0428527445,
-0.1482320279,
0.1699561328,
-0.1109142825,
-0.7395738959,
0.2487678677,
-0.4324401617,
0.5259734392,
0.5044648647,
-0.5443397164,
0.9574708939,
-0.809748888,
0.7396974564,
0.2837560475,
-0.590624094,
0.9241028428,
-0.7225352526,
0.775331974,
-0.1064164415,
-0.1641640067,
-0.458283186,
-0.4659533799,
-0.1428495497,
-0.6478505731,
0.2970964015,
0.0533228107,
-0.296507597,
-0.2569191754,
0.0877896175,
-0.0186360888,
-0.0616535433,
-0.6852087379,
0.1346453428,
-0.3655498326,
0.2860071361,
0.1493063867,
-0.1572701633,
-0.2571289539,
-0.3934953511,
0.2640312016,
-0.1749006659,
0.580471158,
0.5188689828,
0.052300144,
-0.1450830251,
0.2309274524,
0.6856475472,
0.7956165075,
0.072083056,
0.2917716801,
0.3440281153,
-0.3498604,
-0.1601900458,
-0.4648516774,
-0.1923298687,
-0.3061161935,
0.2161711603,
1.0367791653,
0.1976482868,
-0.7561271787,
0.487143904,
-0.1215475425,
-0.3717264533,
-0.2110081166,
0.1169908047,
0.4628978372,
0.8234670162,
0.3073900938,
0.1701247692,
0.0795393288,
-0.1925278604,
-0.2044733912,
0.6891483068,
-0.1598784924,
-0.214882046,
0.7370841503,
0.0756272376,
-0.1484970152,
0.6872707009,
-0.0696899816,
-0.6348127723,
0.4602673948,
0.5651326776,
0.9703723192,
0.2774050534,
0.0435035601,
0.268194139,
0.4919793606,
0.0143443095,
0.7256953716,
-0.2568461001,
-0.8590583801,
-0.3982690275,
-0.2804848254,
-0.257442832,
0.0906550512,
-0.2983545363,
0.0142449876,
-0.4065974355,
-0.377759248,
-0.3726151288,
-0.4742867947,
-0.8262413144,
0.2472857833,
0.6689850688,
0.9092525244,
-0.6628298759,
0.7808719873,
1.025087595,
-0.0415679887,
-0.6062523723,
0.0112547129,
-0.0371044241,
-0.9402633309,
0.9575436115,
0.1126552001,
-0.6670868397,
-0.1211068779,
-0.6618480682,
-0.7476523519,
1.1120530367,
0.3372870684,
-0.6730338335,
0.0423839949,
0.1461782753,
0.5459085703,
-0.4380311966,
-0.0640653297,
0.3754913211,
0.709125638,
-0.0602715202,
-0.5342078805,
0.0761248246,
-0.1992794573,
0.3494195342,
0.1393863112,
-0.6077558994,
0.6327790618,
-0.8023913503,
-0.3404077291,
-0.2572059929,
0.6303228736,
0.7914429903,
0.1983825862,
0.7048196197,
0.7243791223,
0.8383936286,
-0.1433240324,
1.0770889521,
-0.0002261092,
-0.2135111839,
0.7976691723,
-0.313803494,
0.8913322687,
0.8152173162,
-0.2292277068,
0.4602192938,
0.2338058949,
0.1425310373,
0.5176855922,
-0.0391621515,
-0.1209315583,
-0.3971112967,
0.084968254,
-0.2020726353,
0.3886395097,
0.5041799545,
0.1505977809,
-0.0626954585,
0.07535889,
-0.4266259074,
0.0626199841,
-0.4209709466,
0.5934925675,
0.1474360079,
-0.7608880997,
0.4258131981,
-0.8202266693,
0.461275667,
-0.4381229281,
-0.375249058,
-0.1458014697,
0.0242736619,
0.0093261451,
-1.1015608311,
0.0493883006,
-0.0890403092,
-0.2050296068,
-0.5822324753,
0.7870847583,
-0.4589757621,
-0.4496391714,
0.4611914754,
0.8802449703,
0.4020661712,
-0.3168151975,
-0.6135546565,
0.0145393172,
0.1310079992,
-0.3163692057,
0.2763660252,
0.9864910841,
-0.2688020468,
1.2266799212,
0.7090005279,
0.4532720447,
0.0909230486,
0.4379683435,
0.8504962325,
-0.9376118779,
-0.6343221664,
-0.8889808059,
0.5310841799,
-0.0505053028,
-0.0995338708,
0.6894177198,
0.399166584,
0.7041753531,
-0.4758031964,
0.8654509187,
0.3143001795,
0.38607952,
-0.6204715967,
0.7299475074,
-0.6981703043,
0.0946345255,
-0.2182479203,
-0.875800252,
-0.1738518775,
0.7987751365,
-0.6220061183,
-0.0092204129,
1.0978498459,
0.6979985237,
0.0110957799,
0.0447362438,
0.6745440364,
0.1394850016,
0.0715270489,
0.6500191092,
1.2722095251,
0.0483457334,
0.3843834996,
-0.0606553219,
-0.2959701121,
-0.0374520123,
-0.8311552405,
-1.0963253975,
-0.6573244333,
-0.0099760732,
0.1224571168,
-0.1592218429,
0.5772724748,
0.5733115673,
-0.2919510305,
-0.2276626229,
-0.2968226373,
-0.0392299145,
-0.2951296568,
-0.2353206128,
0.3238458335,
-0.1771769673,
-0.4801604152,
0.6021126509,
0.9674739242,
0.2784555852,
-0.4205612838,
-0.0204717554,
-0.1736953855,
0.0940345973,
0.8674635887,
-0.064551577,
-1.1966391802,
-0.2709952295,
0.1564789116,
-0.0850518942,
0.0635690242,
0.9687465429,
-0.855452776,
0.6622623801,
0.4550885856,
0.4156221449,
0.3937574327,
-0.0791732669,
0.5044230819,
-0.2843068838,
0.3070239723,
0.1451774389,
0.6894084811,
0.2664833963,
-0.4593714476,
0.362136364,
0.081215553,
-0.551626265,
-0.5235126615,
0.3409312665,
-1.1400591135,
-0.2935391665,
1.0689098835,
0.0880566016,
-0.613424778,
-0.0741583109,
-0.909755528,
-0.0948397294,
-0.3282001913,
0.9009767175,
0.8055996299,
-0.4069697261,
-0.4124026299,
-0.6134765148,
0.4234144986,
0.4829629958,
-1.0172549486,
0.3342487812,
0.5174050927,
-0.1704908162,
0.1273853183,
0.7138331532,
0.0828388631,
0.5184512734,
0.1971666515,
0.1144630089,
-0.0388578922,
-0.4639226198,
0.0373487845,
-0.1214489862,
-0.0239179023,
-0.121577926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03608v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03608v1
|
Sailor: Open Language Models for South-East Asia
| 2024-04-04T17:31:32 | 2024-04-04T17:31:32 |
Longxu Dou, Qian Liu, Guangtao Zeng, Jia Guo, Jiahui Zhou, Wei Lu, Min Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Sailor, a family of open language models ranging from 0.5B to 7B
parameters, tailored for South-East Asian (SEA) languages. These models are
continually pre-trained from Qwen1.5, a great language model for multilingual
use cases. From Qwen1.5, Sailor models accept 200B to 400B tokens, primarily
covering the languages of English, Chinese, Vietnamese, Thai, Indonesian,
Malay, and Lao. The training leverages several techniques, including BPE
dropout for improving the model robustness, aggressive data cleaning and
deduplication, and small proxy models to optimize data mixture. Experimental
results on four typical tasks indicate that Sailor models demonstrate strong
performance across different benchmarks, including commonsense reasoning,
question answering, reading comprehension and examination. Embracing the
open-source spirit, we share our insights through this report to spark a wider
interest in developing large language models for multilingual use cases.
|
[
-0.4380545318,
-0.3321240544,
0.5796548724,
0.4835631251,
-0.4641167819,
-0.2183590233,
-0.3984658122,
-0.5987285972,
0.067180559,
0.9095375538,
-0.3043635488,
-0.6001761556,
-0.2807552516,
0.0239043664,
-0.0070060859,
0.8903272152,
0.0247454233,
0.1310921013,
0.327014029,
-0.4225589633,
-0.4346552491,
-0.4474354386,
-0.8854989409,
0.0306702666,
0.4004220366,
0.8119726181,
0.5624374747,
0.6398373842,
0.4585065842,
0.1149636209,
-0.0179732908,
-0.0280883182,
-0.556507349,
0.3946569264,
-0.4674745798,
-0.7593117952,
-0.7291648388,
0.2422110438,
0.1930002868,
0.4910608828,
-0.2045264244,
0.7052151561,
-0.3213564157,
0.6726015806,
-0.5550862551,
0.5406143665,
-0.5452817082,
-0.3725202382,
-0.6209119558,
0.4403603971,
-0.3798841238,
-0.2902453244,
0.2012723535,
-0.595985651,
0.1297957003,
0.1209523529,
0.8863713741,
-0.1181559116,
-0.6502818465,
-0.1203817129,
-0.6474050283,
0.7926333547,
-0.7804640532,
0.5792817473,
0.7012832165,
0.764421761,
0.1497804523,
-0.6356055737,
-0.4501610398,
-0.1723240763,
0.06081824,
0.3954795003,
0.1945080757,
0.1269920617,
-0.1881482452,
0.3986651003,
-0.6315156221,
0.0585046262,
-0.535184145,
0.4815520644,
0.9049540758,
0.1324898899,
0.2146304548,
-0.1164133102,
-0.1220279485,
0.2067819387,
-0.9528491497,
-0.1402527541,
0.5183512568,
0.6524047852,
-0.3940979242,
0.6667521596,
-0.107376352,
0.6153193712,
-0.1571979225,
-0.1612819284,
-0.3492133319,
-0.274105221,
0.0506598689,
-0.2013143003,
0.4985575378,
0.3289300799,
0.3936311603,
-0.0281808078,
-0.2116792798,
-0.1493442655,
0.1638128012,
-0.5723070502,
-0.2888428569,
0.2569707334,
-0.7493514419,
-0.1810375601,
0.3002563715,
-1.0144155025,
-0.4746211469,
-0.2184847295,
0.1724658757,
0.1304527819,
-0.8357455134,
0.3307270706,
-0.1987567246,
0.1278316081,
0.0107901627,
-0.8179011941,
0.0885197595,
0.5193949342,
0.6909278631,
0.1306869686,
-0.3860300481,
-0.3643766642,
0.4297596514,
-0.3473715484,
0.3682227433,
-0.576759994,
-0.5116840005,
-0.0127201974,
0.1785852015,
-0.1919812858,
-0.5060356855,
0.4716240168,
-0.3957287669,
0.2705752254,
-0.0425016321,
-0.1656645387,
-0.35462448,
-0.0314433314,
-0.8058453798,
1.2702362537,
0.4902657866,
-0.5642986894,
0.2611580193,
-0.8574225903,
-0.3269678354,
0.0012535522,
0.319459945,
-0.3436452448,
0.4614238739,
0.3025805354,
0.5598809719,
-0.7778781652,
0.2905942798,
-0.4923375845,
-0.3297788501,
-0.071244128,
-0.0515925214,
0.8435240388,
0.3878411949,
-0.3449102938,
0.3113585114,
-0.8161101937,
-0.0301987138,
0.2269040793,
-0.1811516434,
-0.716370821,
-0.1185903028,
0.2333835512,
0.2952419519,
0.1743333489,
-0.6893533468,
0.1358041167,
-0.3203201592,
0.4994564652,
0.4405198395,
-0.0184088722,
0.2269130498,
-0.2043347508,
0.8743644357,
0.2109042704,
0.3443697393,
-0.5838564634,
-0.582665801,
-0.7699969411,
-0.6123225093,
0.0563967302,
0.6230450869,
-0.6189870834,
0.0902199373,
0.0131586799,
-1.0075719357,
-1.098382473,
-0.0037595688,
0.4934589565,
0.2163525671,
0.3066995442,
0.0501109958,
-0.8502454758,
-0.6780380011,
-0.3927720487,
-0.5883030295,
-0.0666704252,
0.3508304358,
0.4225956798,
-0.1750391126,
0.7464962006,
-0.3142285645,
0.0561451465,
-0.5438363552,
-0.3159405589,
0.3443029821,
0.3313369453,
0.8082025051,
-0.7516887188,
-0.753649652,
0.4120702446,
-0.6945360899,
-0.2521400452,
0.1742459685,
-0.2305886,
0.4093634784,
0.8067399263,
-0.7578831911,
0.4388223886,
0.7560697794,
-0.2356185317,
0.9720035195,
-0.1385634542,
-0.0247804299,
-1.3837128878,
0.424480021,
-0.011653862,
-0.1890757978,
-0.5519264936,
0.6329393387,
0.2094342113,
-0.459837079,
-0.426653713,
1.0060187578,
-0.6275411248,
0.0168949831,
-0.2290545255,
0.4238193333,
-0.1412988007,
0.1438664347,
0.2298472673,
0.6705688238,
0.4439739883,
-0.595294714,
0.4170245528,
0.08368586,
-0.061828021,
0.8651195765,
-0.9474830627,
0.0617868081,
-0.3408611715,
-0.0674400851,
-0.9931652546,
-0.1770086586,
0.0391885452,
-0.2025940567,
0.0414349809,
-0.5467020273,
-0.1667635292,
-0.6060335636,
-0.2503873706,
0.2641549706,
0.0776250809,
-0.7610436678,
0.406244874,
0.501362443,
-0.4601033628,
-0.5436797738,
-0.3793143928,
-0.1144068241,
-0.4994912148,
-0.3738272488,
-0.1160165146,
0.1653138995,
-0.2414106578,
0.0493957922,
0.0010808326,
-0.1438588053,
0.0630040094,
0.2850694358,
0.4938106239,
-0.7508167624,
-0.0905663595,
-0.03557254,
-0.237617746,
-0.2120672762,
-0.6048355699,
0.5641409755,
-0.36977005,
-0.2424157262,
-0.0534501225,
0.2108988464,
0.6788977385,
-0.7876076102,
0.9715001583,
0.5878589153,
-0.1931410879,
0.125616461,
-0.3029904366,
0.0513641238,
-0.4497799575,
0.530305326,
-0.8415079713,
-0.7618799806,
0.7168203592,
0.1834786832,
0.4000397027,
0.2228013873,
0.217542246,
0.0712174028,
1.0563112497,
0.8992064595,
-0.3784170747,
0.2323258668,
0.0463158078,
0.29924649,
-0.6226243377,
0.0928400829,
-0.8179742098,
0.0970067978,
-0.7840231657,
-0.3519839644,
0.329120189,
0.4518535733,
-0.5882579088,
0.3984111547,
0.067558758,
0.5599915385,
0.556129396,
-0.2254787982,
0.3809124827,
-0.4364380836,
-0.0507078543,
-0.0879138038,
-0.7446680069,
-0.7409245968,
1.4253190756,
0.2400832474,
0.7666468024,
0.2908787131,
0.5114929676,
-0.344363153,
0.6079671383,
-0.425537914,
0.5667439103,
-0.2759914696,
-0.9797552824,
-0.3348205984,
-0.3390461504,
-1.0562329292,
0.4934722185,
0.1416631043,
-0.4655604661,
-0.4462202489,
0.0268947799,
0.2476304919,
0.4068986475,
-0.5331993699,
1.1579194069,
-0.1419717222,
-0.0243710056,
-0.3198834956,
-0.7502501607,
0.6391767859,
0.0335335732,
0.1260601729,
-0.1144310907,
-0.2279966623,
0.1723588109,
-0.1822715104,
0.7352696657,
-0.3660375774,
-0.0365329236,
0.2665402889,
-0.0368441343,
0.0800025612,
0.3615689874,
-0.2252391726,
0.267208308,
0.0991737098,
-0.8888434768,
-0.340092212,
0.3757893145,
-0.6975244284,
-0.3583914936,
-0.2255272269,
-0.1997288913,
-0.2657013535,
0.4697542191,
0.2078248858,
0.0391576104,
-0.2356518805,
-0.0384658203,
0.2891137302,
-0.3366644979,
0.3564235866,
1.0032801628,
-0.8950673342,
-0.7393680811,
0.8299960494,
-0.2456060201,
0.3822984397,
0.1517177522,
0.0707434043,
-0.325143069,
-0.2410530746,
-0.886762619,
0.8187465668,
-0.2331869453,
0.1430083215,
-0.1590545475,
-0.0036171691,
-0.2879886329,
-0.0545562059,
-0.6648105383,
-0.5789623857,
0.0303943288,
-0.1441881061,
0.0175412241,
0.9618968964,
0.1998655647,
0.7368503213,
-0.9563363194,
0.2279114425,
-0.0621388108,
0.6297101378,
0.0625449866,
-0.2904845476,
-0.5621060133,
0.0164770223,
-0.0723079592,
-0.8860164285,
0.2204685211,
0.2745144665,
0.7589664459,
0.6452956796,
-0.0551716723,
0.7304322124,
-0.1665378213,
0.9630445838,
-0.1466376483,
-0.9100755453,
0.6592367887,
-0.7153038383,
0.3687818944,
0.4284289479,
0.7019097209,
-1.0584868193,
-0.6641572714,
-0.4691933095,
-0.7996799946,
0.5250451565,
-0.352945596,
-0.2044884264,
0.0317030139,
0.5605401397,
0.4077587724,
0.6128550768,
-0.5341418982,
-0.2090412974,
-0.1858971864,
-0.3786997497,
-0.5241746306,
-0.0060074995,
0.4423484206,
-0.0433251858,
0.8626289368,
-0.1836297661,
-0.1002959087,
-0.2711423635,
-0.1595050991,
-0.0889336914,
0.0452708006,
0.4394150376,
0.5353958607,
0.0117182154,
-0.0667167008,
-0.2884448767,
-0.7968232036,
0.1330917031,
0.087378107,
-0.2755653858,
0.0306149311,
0.1820521355,
0.7374902964,
0.0712706298,
-0.888720572,
0.1109388024,
-0.1505053639,
0.3353754878,
-0.0814965218,
-0.0956290886,
0.3047013283,
0.1288785487,
0.0101325503,
-0.2708200812,
-0.436960578,
-0.5494801998,
-0.2704421282,
0.0761055872,
-0.3754472733,
-0.6620902419,
1.0930658579,
0.3122654557,
0.1013295203,
0.7930285335,
-0.2131484151,
-0.5652959347,
0.3097016215,
0.7651692629,
0.7971946001,
-0.6891711354,
0.4739714861,
0.5031884313,
0.5413953066,
-0.2432022095,
0.9266600013,
0.2522663474,
-0.3048994839,
-0.2613278925,
-0.4509339631,
-0.6043131948,
0.2750530541,
-0.7301613688,
0.4094337225,
-0.3744017184,
-0.2251303494,
-0.3374121487,
0.1403512806,
-0.5236235261,
-0.0165109374,
-0.3304337263,
1.0482270718,
-1.0006887913,
0.685015142,
1.2596838474,
-0.7688837051,
-0.7107625604,
-0.2383353412,
0.0020377303,
-0.4436335266,
0.3181820512,
0.335157454,
0.1653313786,
-0.0128590306,
-0.2666576207,
-0.8941249251,
0.6051741838,
0.4148674309,
-0.2321118712,
-0.0410339385,
0.3316362202,
0.6122308969,
-0.4284473658,
0.2831059098,
0.6601539254,
0.5949151516,
-0.8287639618,
-1.2906012535,
-0.1830972582,
-0.4305781722,
0.1503377557,
0.4802493453,
-1.0111006498,
0.9672817588,
-0.4033072293,
0.1698233187,
0.4879118204,
0.6564468741,
0.56327492,
0.5437955856,
0.2272520661,
0.2834020257,
0.7237845063,
-0.0132259959,
0.6809437275,
-0.4538883567,
-0.0902658328,
1.1041572094,
-0.5403171182,
1.0605537891,
0.1762376875,
-0.3166373968,
0.456119746,
0.5427065492,
0.3056763411,
0.0845558643,
-0.0611146614,
-0.2559904754,
0.25300318,
-0.0039263228,
-0.1639195085,
0.7317304015,
0.2663634419,
-0.039707046,
0.0746639073,
0.2766292691,
0.4113677144,
0.1844742894,
-0.4781585038,
0.4811636209,
0.1148339584,
-0.8910599947,
0.4368855059,
0.3543357253,
0.4441919029,
-0.5713586211,
0.2291660607,
-0.5491043329,
0.3340741694,
0.0482579544,
-0.5400442481,
0.085279502,
0.089145273,
-0.2202233225,
0.0924689025,
0.7086945772,
-0.8024013042,
-0.1580921113,
0.0767907202,
0.7417036295,
0.3925005198,
-0.4365876019,
-0.339228332,
-0.133013472,
-0.2211959064,
-0.1553963572,
0.1425548494,
0.4840811193,
-0.4165755808,
0.7758209705,
0.592468977,
0.4977232218,
0.2975075841,
-0.0390154086,
0.3003052175,
-0.9041773081,
-0.972896874,
-0.5015707016,
0.4346466064,
-0.0420168415,
-0.6450959444,
1.1066600084,
0.888253212,
1.0495789051,
-0.472953856,
1.0455819368,
0.2160329521,
0.9834191799,
-0.1799540371,
0.9025481343,
-0.5395181179,
0.035460338,
-0.2423459589,
-1.0617369413,
-0.0901244134,
0.3782946467,
-0.113602072,
0.1547491401,
0.4532255828,
0.672039032,
-0.1997915357,
0.6386196613,
0.0173809249,
0.0169102829,
0.5411811471,
0.4844970703,
0.7447681427,
-0.3236229122,
0.4115810394,
-0.1773428172,
-0.1075981781,
-0.3385106623,
-0.686363101,
-1.1606858969,
-0.6322150826,
0.0440238789,
-0.1342235506,
0.1256743819,
0.7587692738,
0.8900575638,
-0.6790921092,
-0.7778949142,
0.127764836,
-0.1201101542,
-0.4245407283,
-0.2094976753,
0.2081647217,
-0.2634985149,
-0.677852273,
0.5596333742,
0.2779997289,
0.1929276884,
-0.4908238053,
-0.1998135,
-0.1249224097,
0.1515934765,
0.7582008839,
0.4664091766,
-0.3647039831,
0.0976526588,
0.1288741678,
-0.1868827492,
-0.3415706754,
0.8097025156,
-0.4917483628,
0.43484056,
0.2246446013,
0.5275913477,
0.6774281859,
0.0142294168,
0.806835413,
-0.7050480247,
0.480342716,
0.0201762915,
0.1208389848,
0.2376076579,
0.1694071889,
0.9020359516,
0.2003064156,
-0.5412567854,
-1.0885397196,
0.3005140126,
-0.5097801685,
-0.2517972589,
0.7079359293,
-0.5177134275,
-0.1696587503,
-0.3226211965,
-0.4894444048,
0.167654261,
-0.0518702827,
0.5404687524,
0.7536143661,
0.17632173,
-0.1452365667,
-1.0002822876,
0.1534738839,
0.3196257055,
-0.9128036499,
0.3487745523,
0.4778467715,
0.1739674211,
-0.2928322852,
0.5360736847,
-0.2514545321,
0.4880568683,
0.1981939971,
-0.023944864,
0.0262221172,
-0.5780342817,
-0.2100358903,
0.0008207606,
0.3594889641,
-0.0588110685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03605v1
|
Mitigating the Impact of Outlier Channels for Language Model Quantization with Activation Regularization
| 2024-04-04T17:25:30 | 2024-04-04T17:25:30 |
Aniruddha Nrusimha, Mayank Mishra, Naigang Wang, Dan Alistarh, Rameswar Panda, Yoon Kim
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We consider the problem of accurate quantization for language models, where
both the weights and activations are uniformly quantized to 4 bits per
parameter, the lowest bitwidth format natively supported by GPU hardware. In
this context, the key challenge is activation quantization: it is known that
language models contain outlier channels whose values on average are orders of
magnitude higher than than other channels, which prevents accurate low-bitwidth
quantization with known techniques. We systematically study this phenomena and
find that these outlier channels emerge early in training, and that they occur
more frequently in layers with residual streams. We then propose a simple
strategy which regularizes a layer's inputs via quantization-aware training
(QAT) and its outputs via activation kurtosis regularization. We show that
regularizing both the inputs and outputs is crucial for preventing a model's
"migrating" the difficulty in input quantization to the weights, which makes
post-training quantization (PTQ) of weights more difficult. When combined with
weight PTQ, we show that our approach can obtain a W4A4 model that performs
competitively to the standard-precision W16A16 baseline.
|
[
-0.3653611243,
-0.753513515,
0.4885500968,
-0.0460316241,
-0.3045724332,
0.0397279859,
-0.1704670489,
-0.1697102189,
-0.1239913851,
0.3558801711,
-0.2959997654,
-0.2488528043,
-0.7304876447,
-0.3902629316,
-0.4107643962,
0.8862294555,
0.0827977359,
0.0558128729,
-0.0534521416,
-0.202361241,
-0.3611186445,
-0.4830122292,
-0.8455991745,
-0.310405761,
0.290636152,
0.3574862182,
0.8518759012,
0.4985563457,
0.4777434766,
0.2549397051,
-0.0670786202,
-0.2308336645,
-0.3986978233,
0.0105208121,
0.4907678664,
-0.3410834074,
-0.4057360888,
-0.0300702304,
1.0380669832,
0.9265727997,
-0.1819571853,
0.1322977245,
0.2138284296,
0.7414551973,
-0.6019080877,
0.0286239497,
-0.3616565764,
-0.1271557659,
-0.3800522387,
-0.1791294515,
-0.4128330052,
-0.2799244821,
-0.130359903,
-0.4390388131,
0.0492578112,
-0.2773995996,
1.0228036642,
0.3067067266,
-0.4205782413,
0.2027056813,
-0.9518537521,
0.9278770685,
-1.0609647036,
0.6737321019,
0.4975834787,
0.195918113,
-0.1842263341,
-0.7025097609,
-0.2398107946,
-0.1466560662,
0.2258888781,
-0.099277623,
-0.4907115102,
0.1664527953,
0.4394364953,
0.1330144107,
-0.7297785878,
0.0756836012,
-0.2867131531,
-0.2243006527,
0.3900390267,
-0.2949149907,
0.4097273052,
0.3574669659,
-0.1344483346,
-0.226947099,
-0.7492216825,
0.1951368302,
0.8631976843,
0.1889103502,
0.1709417552,
0.2424903065,
-0.2198855877,
0.7200841308,
0.0442237481,
0.2096618116,
0.1162120327,
-0.4165019691,
-0.241264537,
0.0504835099,
0.6118606925,
-0.0971485004,
0.2187743634,
-0.1051696613,
-0.4103920162,
0.0882305205,
0.2334440202,
-1.0059901476,
-0.456363827,
0.3134724498,
-0.4215723276,
-0.2147652358,
-0.160486564,
-0.4355529249,
0.0441627689,
-0.1829014421,
0.8974133134,
-0.5037882328,
-0.3130400181,
0.0353354141,
-0.1500523984,
0.156886518,
0.1226640269,
-0.9669311047,
0.5352699161,
0.3486450315,
0.6543174982,
0.1273910105,
-0.0824734718,
-0.7821871638,
-0.0268612504,
-0.504027307,
0.5284566879,
-0.3901396096,
0.0262739677,
-0.1866669059,
-0.3734332919,
0.0123359738,
-0.2771060467,
0.3541460037,
-1.0183404684,
0.2777758837,
-0.1353978217,
-0.5559513569,
-0.3298516273,
-0.0837297142,
-0.7608657479,
1.0801999569,
0.2717394829,
-0.6033069491,
0.2419214398,
-0.5573202968,
-0.1482190043,
0.2895299494,
0.1040624306,
-0.642649591,
0.3449026048,
0.1119032875,
0.1584224701,
-0.1981798559,
0.3098550141,
-0.1913453043,
-0.6751229763,
0.1176250502,
-0.5951684713,
0.8936020136,
0.0782000646,
-0.4994221032,
0.2181108743,
-0.8605755568,
0.3765578568,
0.0673528239,
-0.3539721966,
-0.4855944514,
-0.0806283131,
-0.015219247,
0.2139018923,
0.0616131611,
-0.4000405967,
-0.0379995927,
-0.3871750236,
0.5694573522,
0.6832354069,
0.0423511826,
0.7331832647,
-0.1352166533,
0.5377835035,
0.1548872739,
0.2388752848,
-0.0031992393,
-0.6250995398,
-0.5009607077,
-0.365986824,
0.7523825765,
0.2426659912,
-0.7964041233,
0.5686272383,
-0.4572677314,
-0.478602916,
-0.4811035693,
0.3750728667,
0.2474755198,
0.4534077346,
0.3743834496,
-0.5596445799,
-0.195613265,
-0.7349838614,
-0.1888081878,
0.0851056799,
0.049100291,
-0.3147155941,
0.284108907,
-0.2725727856,
1.0654953718,
-0.1741144508,
-0.3683935702,
-0.2818595469,
0.4482786357,
-0.0563381128,
0.8025780916,
0.4509449303,
-0.7944008112,
-0.4547370076,
-0.0910062194,
-0.2557033002,
-0.0716555044,
0.0481507778,
-0.0497663729,
0.1855944991,
0.60930866,
-0.3964391649,
0.4196596146,
0.8946360946,
-0.2526322901,
0.1264891922,
-0.1728011519,
-0.1111035645,
-0.9384008646,
-0.0066827629,
0.0593557209,
-0.3833444417,
-0.9977437258,
-0.1702992171,
0.2928389013,
-0.1364896446,
-0.2471276522,
0.3009705544,
-0.2823260725,
-0.064153403,
-0.1696736813,
-0.1759513468,
0.1504420638,
0.6647372246,
-0.0520227849,
0.5369170904,
0.5095255375,
-0.2867854536,
0.1455381066,
-0.1441368908,
-0.2422701716,
0.1923639625,
-0.6695652604,
0.1405237764,
-0.1713541299,
0.1523191184,
-1.1297914982,
0.0439355597,
0.0946662948,
-0.4982360303,
0.4349763989,
-0.5646722317,
-0.5340023041,
0.2208832949,
-0.4974671602,
0.8840170503,
0.7801597714,
-0.3330926001,
0.3990896344,
0.2082169801,
-0.0693801045,
-0.3424737453,
-0.5706080198,
-0.113791652,
-0.4054739177,
-0.5881587863,
0.2667140663,
-0.1921616197,
0.0765307248,
0.0948909223,
-0.0268832371,
-0.1834499091,
0.30562374,
-0.0600476637,
-0.0552070625,
-0.1847397238,
-0.0988017991,
0.1270243526,
-0.1680338979,
0.065037474,
-0.4889391959,
0.6556984186,
-0.0955363438,
-0.2312576771,
-0.5853217244,
0.4008800387,
0.499297291,
-0.4335221648,
0.5938730836,
0.8681964278,
-0.6371195912,
-0.0901334509,
-0.3411888778,
-0.4625892043,
-0.4685524106,
0.4035930932,
-0.2714924514,
-0.6406821012,
0.5039067268,
-0.0251952875,
-0.1188278273,
0.2321010828,
0.4395959079,
-0.0231139697,
1.6320772171,
0.736181736,
0.0349635668,
0.8829686046,
-0.5160453916,
0.3041214049,
-0.8550012112,
0.3382535279,
-0.2582681179,
-0.4080581665,
-0.4346859455,
-0.213607356,
0.3848853707,
0.2316273302,
-0.1383937299,
0.2412969172,
-0.1196601093,
0.2812073529,
0.8973004222,
-0.0087115113,
0.1529534757,
0.2372214198,
0.0977035314,
-0.1615999639,
-0.9439935684,
-0.2560684979,
1.0141421556,
0.5722959638,
0.5695515275,
0.3409982026,
0.780749321,
0.2865499258,
0.2520522475,
-0.8196869493,
0.1206985861,
0.0615509301,
-0.3179263473,
-0.6990619302,
-0.7391409278,
-1.0351550579,
0.0391287394,
-0.0841729492,
-0.540384829,
0.4850906134,
0.144109726,
-0.6339883804,
0.1351601332,
-0.8866320848,
1.1123207808,
0.0642904937,
-0.2101195008,
0.0381311923,
-0.5749729872,
0.3642286062,
-0.1552267522,
0.4744023681,
-0.0787355676,
0.0887570009,
0.7996493578,
-0.5487181544,
0.771071732,
-0.2122079879,
-0.1776825637,
0.2651054263,
0.2484206855,
0.5822684169,
-0.136714831,
0.4667146504,
0.2066503465,
-0.0035730333,
-0.7245547175,
-0.7516362667,
0.5780793428,
-0.916656673,
-0.2316813469,
-0.3749655485,
-0.5782824159,
-0.3843852878,
0.1978206635,
0.3883680403,
0.8165772557,
0.2019990832,
0.2211073935,
0.7452887297,
0.2487811744,
0.7163183689,
0.228960827,
0.1979453564,
-0.5272861719,
1.3338425159,
0.4149917364,
0.5718117356,
0.0691124052,
0.2581409812,
-0.166786924,
-0.8939371705,
-0.5062156916,
0.1103685871,
-0.7872985601,
-0.3827973008,
-0.3829770088,
-0.3501375318,
-0.44114393,
0.1545133591,
-0.6064684391,
-0.4597789049,
-0.2744032443,
0.150544852,
0.1308836937,
0.3674565256,
-0.0806022361,
0.6121774316,
-0.9618428946,
0.0736375526,
0.5499774218,
0.3353490233,
-0.092858389,
-1.0423324108,
-0.6403999329,
0.0590353049,
-0.2825083435,
-0.900398016,
0.5280373693,
0.3715268672,
0.3629798889,
0.53001827,
-0.1614726335,
0.61593014,
-0.4738247693,
0.5312857628,
-0.0083808601,
-1.1791844368,
0.3239459097,
-0.2466581613,
0.3832567632,
0.3305701017,
0.464425832,
-0.3930814266,
-0.4116538465,
-0.9116654396,
-0.9000916481,
0.5739525557,
0.4343035817,
0.2605394423,
0.2452247739,
0.2371814549,
-0.3683486283,
0.1289235801,
-0.9463646412,
-0.0042275628,
-0.1256490797,
-0.3101221323,
-0.1325722635,
-0.4893649518,
-0.1808698326,
-0.0786337331,
0.6173521876,
-0.2717616558,
0.0331916511,
-0.0996120647,
-0.3724249601,
-0.509267211,
0.1492087543,
0.6671566963,
0.666800797,
-0.3833275735,
0.2406069636,
-0.1609796286,
-0.5396832228,
0.2094260603,
0.1843947172,
-0.3135014176,
-0.0455942228,
0.2772318423,
0.7286304235,
0.3213428557,
-0.4868208468,
0.7056108117,
-0.198476851,
-0.1447721869,
-0.0936439857,
-0.1612449437,
-0.1400809288,
0.1735804677,
0.5078303218,
0.1542622298,
0.2666230798,
-0.353038758,
0.0501674414,
0.6726441979,
-0.4651155472,
-0.5350573659,
0.6873176694,
-0.0214063749,
-0.0502812117,
0.5863574743,
-0.4376924932,
-0.4356164038,
0.4287776649,
0.523383081,
0.8055872917,
-0.3000631332,
0.0546601415,
0.2034710199,
0.4720459282,
-0.289791137,
0.2431209087,
-0.0243717693,
-0.9720510244,
-0.7612736821,
-0.4353630543,
-0.2057193369,
0.0748709813,
-0.7704617381,
0.3027946055,
-0.3720380068,
-0.3277914226,
-0.1477115005,
0.004572331,
-0.3948170245,
0.2245936692,
0.2608287632,
0.4902215004,
-1.1536878347,
1.1270974874,
0.6005072594,
-0.4322488606,
-0.7125440836,
-0.1416153908,
-0.3658594191,
-0.4151043296,
0.6225918531,
-0.0515770577,
0.1927631199,
0.700632453,
-0.4499204457,
-1.1931631565,
0.9605894089,
0.527125001,
-0.3941238821,
0.0519436561,
-0.0048921038,
0.4085994661,
0.0211232342,
0.1717782021,
0.7831690907,
0.2654749751,
-0.0346005745,
-0.6019867659,
0.0869032964,
-0.1337658763,
0.2378749847,
0.5245024562,
-0.4659398794,
0.8482710719,
0.1142231822,
-0.1530032158,
-0.1792201102,
0.6919913888,
0.181729719,
-0.0725492612,
0.6354219913,
0.7279021144,
0.4241404235,
-0.1179737821,
0.8804917336,
-0.2196904123,
0.3331303,
0.7778502107,
0.0140520455,
0.7467885613,
0.5372971296,
-0.0581004582,
0.4361321032,
0.5765483379,
0.2649566829,
0.5991501212,
0.2429144531,
-0.1563251615,
-0.2734458148,
0.1454680264,
-0.2181476802,
0.3680284321,
0.3968163729,
0.0766535774,
-0.2578874528,
0.1360422373,
0.1021892503,
-0.1367125958,
-0.2786920965,
0.7395014763,
-0.1111495495,
-0.3738200366,
0.6907631755,
0.1419127285,
0.4007630944,
-0.6856532097,
-0.1553699225,
-0.5062614679,
0.017783029,
-0.077156052,
-0.1595097482,
0.1959741265,
-0.3417144716,
-0.1008869186,
-0.3460311592,
0.4946429133,
-0.7120829225,
-0.5102665424,
0.0805743784,
0.5489592552,
-0.0895319432,
-0.4605368376,
-0.4243498147,
0.3387106061,
-0.1827684194,
-0.3983922005,
0.6878638268,
0.4279866517,
-0.414767921,
0.4067951143,
0.7595311999,
0.2827808261,
0.3642384708,
0.2347846031,
0.943768084,
-0.4432175457,
-0.4869223535,
-0.8128798604,
0.5394461155,
0.1337468773,
-0.0627398565,
0.6937494874,
0.4208542109,
0.6838720441,
0.1469147801,
0.4471685886,
0.2663532197,
-0.0279983208,
-0.5253916383,
0.6313723922,
-0.5252260566,
0.261074394,
-0.0989644602,
-1.0326495171,
-0.5597769618,
0.4578226805,
-0.1203083619,
0.2616498172,
0.5772795081,
0.723942101,
0.0352953225,
-0.42716977,
0.5509164333,
0.057749927,
0.4797518849,
0.5319982171,
0.7264146805,
-0.7931510806,
0.7313395143,
-0.4645688832,
-0.5227789879,
-0.2163045108,
-0.963482976,
-0.6797814965,
-0.6050534844,
-0.6627148986,
-0.3874833882,
-0.0811478049,
0.7298981547,
0.9116566181,
-0.8438329101,
-0.2946464717,
-0.2289338857,
0.1574114263,
-0.4924036264,
-0.2574094534,
0.5051300526,
-0.7383924127,
-0.8594679832,
0.3187443614,
0.243756026,
0.411907196,
-0.3536733389,
0.0546645559,
-0.0532370396,
0.0921515301,
0.4433249831,
0.3027754128,
-0.3191449642,
-0.3396439254,
-0.206720382,
-0.1153791398,
0.0974289179,
0.8650196195,
-0.8269600272,
0.4353086352,
0.4603539705,
0.7008407712,
0.3773903251,
0.0802708939,
0.6716880798,
-1.1435859203,
0.2402175218,
0.3429397345,
0.2368508875,
0.3624503911,
-0.267796874,
0.227372095,
0.3351186514,
-0.5956118703,
-1.0785285234,
0.1169096008,
-0.694855392,
-0.1360690892,
1.0074301958,
0.0168048199,
-0.1029739976,
-0.0813598037,
0.0225436483,
0.1568620801,
-0.1952868253,
0.6721146107,
0.7043506503,
-0.0742540061,
-0.3860150576,
-0.6996360421,
1.0544490814,
0.63045156,
-0.5074410439,
-0.1094743535,
0.2557891309,
0.2398424298,
0.1093996838,
0.5564724207,
-0.1304739565,
0.4849216938,
-0.0912529454,
0.1295195818,
0.0716728121,
-0.3123690188,
-0.791623652,
0.0495355874,
0.4707072973,
-0.1803047061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03602v1
|
Evaluating LLMs at Detecting Errors in LLM Responses
| 2024-04-04T17:19:47 | 2024-04-04T17:19:47 |
Ryo Kamoi, Sarkar Snigdha Sarathi Das, Renze Lou, Jihyun Janice Ahn, Yilun Zhao, Xiaoxin Lu, Nan Zhang, Yusen Zhang, Ranran Haoran Zhang, Sujeeth Reddy Vummanthala, Salika Dave, Shaobo Qin, Arman Cohan, Wenpeng Yin, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With Large Language Models (LLMs) being widely used across various tasks,
detecting errors in their responses is increasingly crucial. However, little
research has been conducted on error detection of LLM responses. Collecting
error annotations on LLM responses is challenging due to the subjective nature
of many NLP tasks, and thus previous research focuses on tasks of little
practical value (e.g., word sorting) or limited error types (e.g., faithfulness
in summarization). This work introduces ReaLMistake, the first error detection
benchmark consisting of objective, realistic, and diverse errors made by LLMs.
ReaLMistake contains three challenging and meaningful tasks that introduce
objectively assessable errors in four categories (reasoning correctness,
instruction-following, context-faithfulness, and parameterized knowledge),
eliciting naturally observed and diverse errors in responses of GPT-4 and Llama
2 70B annotated by experts. We use ReaLMistake to evaluate error detectors
based on 12 LLMs. Our findings show: 1) Top LLMs like GPT-4 and Claude 3 detect
errors made by LLMs at very low recall, and all LLM-based error detectors
perform much worse than humans. 2) Explanations by LLM-based error detectors
lack reliability. 3) LLMs-based error detection is sensitive to small changes
in prompts but remains challenging to improve. 4) Popular approaches to
improving LLMs, including self-consistency and majority vote, do not improve
the error detection performance. Our benchmark and code are provided at
https://github.com/psunlpgroup/ReaLMistake.
|
[
-0.1998758763,
-0.5965519547,
0.5672392845,
0.2879111469,
-0.0588315614,
-0.066952385,
-0.1577070653,
-0.2032964975,
-0.0606659241,
0.3286114335,
-0.7110100985,
-0.6371559501,
-0.6172909737,
0.4736582637,
-0.0591863468,
0.658090353,
-0.1142471656,
-0.0758785456,
-0.3285290599,
-0.3847732246,
-0.6716859341,
-0.5500469804,
-0.3128448725,
-0.2051019073,
0.4464825392,
0.4642650485,
0.165354684,
0.1311789602,
0.5868576765,
0.3405461609,
-0.0626600012,
0.7370300889,
-0.3848305047,
0.2985418737,
0.0367412232,
-0.5876532793,
-0.8414577842,
-0.0938044116,
0.7176924944,
0.5264500976,
-0.1903332174,
0.1423449814,
0.2834990621,
0.6977587938,
-0.5914658308,
0.3552753329,
-0.5946681499,
0.1121283174,
-0.413764596,
-0.4071098268,
-0.4825963676,
-0.3550828099,
-0.150740698,
-0.5520513654,
0.069109939,
0.3812032938,
0.4539381266,
0.4888299108,
-0.1937246919,
-0.3486314118,
-0.2954593003,
0.9487317204,
-1.069627285,
0.4918211102,
0.5324348807,
0.037531767,
-0.3757819533,
-0.258739382,
-0.7467338443,
-0.0914015546,
0.0473611727,
0.2971888483,
-0.4277821183,
-0.0286585353,
0.3970774114,
0.0815283731,
-0.7040287852,
0.3459882736,
0.1517007351,
-0.5299713612,
0.2970238328,
0.4622383416,
-0.0167478062,
-0.4159567654,
-0.102995649,
-0.1668785959,
-0.7483520508,
-0.0959005952,
0.4334449172,
0.0266823918,
-0.0529977567,
0.3973553479,
-0.134926483,
0.7111610174,
-0.0101137813,
-0.404632926,
0.3517539203,
-0.1167761385,
-0.2762180865,
-0.3135203421,
0.7751451731,
0.618501842,
-0.0842317492,
-0.1220310926,
-0.5173558593,
-0.0972552225,
0.1361480802,
-0.6042755246,
-0.1115345806,
0.2288367599,
-0.1851621866,
-0.1667347401,
-0.286516279,
-0.6260867119,
-0.5561371446,
-0.1338317096,
0.2358673066,
-0.0773121491,
-0.1605814844,
0.0158360936,
0.2371078134,
0.1467879415,
0.7499262691,
-0.702077508,
0.3269232512,
0.8382183313,
0.7483968139,
-0.4584953189,
-0.3467860222,
-0.7123858333,
-0.3034749627,
-0.4524742961,
1.2328662872,
0.1263288558,
-0.3722690344,
0.060776867,
-0.0013550264,
-0.0491828471,
-0.8806934953,
0.755360961,
-0.632599771,
-0.0814836249,
-0.5964061618,
-0.8519657254,
-0.0526118502,
0.6350607276,
-0.553902328,
0.9020519257,
0.2322543412,
-0.8628206253,
0.3874226511,
-0.4675360322,
-0.078598544,
0.2152345777,
-0.1731516868,
-0.4177552164,
0.1644678861,
0.219887808,
0.5259306431,
-0.2909493744,
0.2432755679,
-0.2859227657,
-0.3350175023,
0.4589199424,
-0.4822888374,
0.6698795557,
-0.1692330986,
-0.2671747208,
0.164609462,
-0.651055038,
0.0309960581,
0.0597182997,
-0.5712408423,
-0.0531706512,
-0.0579282641,
-0.0920316353,
-0.1082534567,
0.0898503214,
-0.6012965441,
0.0773798525,
-0.1785392463,
0.0525544547,
1.0979756117,
-0.1046272442,
0.0587602407,
-0.3558602333,
0.5148462653,
0.0467400104,
-0.0455579795,
-0.0352299958,
-0.505014658,
-0.6291468143,
0.1540592462,
0.2065171748,
0.556083858,
-0.8211786151,
0.558675468,
-0.3600191772,
-0.1494327933,
-0.2860925794,
0.4895078242,
0.3044599593,
0.6749461889,
0.2177363783,
-0.1354087591,
-0.6976824999,
-0.8781066537,
-0.2773535252,
-0.5352342725,
-0.0552664101,
0.3014451265,
0.5293563604,
-0.4663694203,
0.8535903692,
-0.3879505694,
-0.3168486655,
-0.2072675228,
0.0297825597,
0.1871688813,
0.207361564,
0.2870934308,
-0.4371323884,
-0.1364639252,
-0.1157885641,
-0.7738346457,
-0.5589730144,
0.2764630616,
0.2787846029,
0.3250531554,
0.2137278467,
-0.3234886527,
0.0997498706,
0.852144897,
0.0198432356,
0.6045142412,
-0.0259876903,
0.3784992099,
-0.7476896644,
-0.0957081988,
0.0449399315,
-0.3525940478,
-0.4720725715,
-0.0702265203,
0.2553780973,
0.6296948195,
-0.3979176879,
0.4445636272,
-0.1464076489,
-0.2153095603,
-0.430996865,
0.2518833876,
-0.025840465,
0.6799063683,
-0.0461377464,
0.8458233476,
0.0501844622,
-0.3620862663,
0.5975925922,
0.2391659468,
-0.2540783286,
0.9684222937,
-0.5834973454,
0.338291049,
-0.069067739,
0.2506279349,
-1.0616439581,
-0.4781330228,
0.334681958,
-0.537959218,
0.1080096886,
-0.1231007427,
-0.6796011329,
-0.404854238,
-0.5101133585,
0.1440302283,
0.4373114705,
-0.7053271532,
0.4708063006,
0.4290671945,
0.0304320473,
-0.6362666488,
-0.6471358538,
0.1688948125,
-0.0945723131,
-0.4585932791,
-0.2135577947,
-0.213862747,
-0.2942774296,
-0.2961130142,
-0.4815914333,
-0.0357388817,
0.2831250429,
0.5146269798,
0.2605676055,
-0.1190356165,
0.0381085761,
-0.203591153,
-0.1319788247,
0.2486242652,
-0.0928238556,
0.272090584,
-0.4867176712,
-0.5493002534,
-0.3342274129,
-0.14997904,
0.3521934748,
0.2119921893,
0.2267221659,
0.3624404073,
-0.4861117601,
-0.3717109561,
-0.8815881014,
-0.1279385239,
-0.4551226199,
0.3132460415,
-0.211637482,
-0.9887462854,
0.4464885294,
-0.0406885184,
0.3070355356,
0.4088173807,
0.6127108335,
-0.3320038021,
0.569930613,
0.2901133299,
0.047319334,
-0.0448700711,
-0.1832692772,
0.0549663678,
-1.1906306744,
-0.1141760871,
-0.5085763931,
-0.0397610962,
-0.4354864657,
-0.5659064054,
0.573907733,
-0.0925471559,
0.0219016634,
0.2389308214,
-0.2089716047,
0.2792685628,
0.3243772984,
-0.0097375466,
0.4615174234,
-0.0804667845,
0.0852233395,
-0.471198678,
-0.7146402001,
-0.6338370442,
1.1538307667,
0.4970127344,
0.9050788879,
0.232378155,
0.8234322071,
0.3810327649,
0.9211664796,
-0.8108919859,
0.6239150763,
0.0976846665,
-0.2826545835,
-0.1920488477,
-0.4815265536,
-0.6837510467,
0.5376399159,
-0.0179789253,
-0.5666178465,
0.0447329618,
0.3620229363,
-0.3938765526,
0.3447225094,
-0.2679591477,
0.8327206373,
-0.0080878846,
-0.4218230546,
0.190854311,
-0.3763998151,
0.5138592124,
-0.1791593879,
0.2920785248,
-0.244919464,
-0.1034193859,
0.9525940418,
-0.1596663594,
0.9889833927,
-0.1760683954,
-0.3938212097,
0.3127232492,
0.3066748977,
0.6397787929,
0.0119215278,
-0.0342041701,
0.3178362846,
-0.1964717358,
-0.1210861877,
-0.482542634,
0.708686769,
-0.6874230504,
-0.6742576361,
-0.5176301599,
-0.4697585702,
-0.5308880806,
-0.0806021169,
0.2260755748,
0.3957274258,
-0.1745656878,
0.124879986,
0.6374228597,
-0.0214029793,
0.2434029728,
0.8570285439,
-0.1216752678,
-0.312389195,
0.7011857629,
0.0827129632,
0.0013062831,
0.1797805578,
0.1707183719,
-0.3321888745,
-0.7924752831,
-0.638068676,
-0.0319771916,
-1.0082048178,
-0.4926964045,
-0.8761422038,
0.1627593935,
-0.2649346292,
0.2720477283,
-0.3287723362,
-0.0208588392,
-0.1665816456,
-0.1629170328,
0.1503289491,
0.6295145154,
-0.2489190698,
0.3484122753,
-0.8556947112,
0.1800502092,
0.4039118588,
0.0990924314,
-0.025239436,
-0.7247257829,
-0.1059772745,
-0.1493329555,
-0.2663927972,
-0.8756052852,
0.3089725077,
-0.0750135407,
0.546215117,
0.0369187072,
-0.1180651188,
0.5142717957,
-0.4396103919,
0.796458602,
0.0342648625,
-0.9548327327,
0.5145530105,
-0.2757232487,
0.2246065289,
0.4693850577,
0.0420140214,
-0.6782402396,
-0.3826793134,
-0.516099751,
-0.5780535936,
0.6165622473,
0.0890541002,
-0.0342620909,
-0.1818915159,
0.3814071119,
0.1302006096,
0.2983911633,
-0.7940608859,
-0.1304172873,
0.1511916667,
-0.0655572414,
0.0590416379,
-0.3789453506,
-0.1861801594,
0.031448964,
0.5801737905,
-0.5662320852,
0.1287831813,
0.2602042556,
-0.4733552635,
-0.452572614,
0.3447897434,
0.6760863662,
0.6897628307,
-0.2178266943,
0.2694779336,
0.534498632,
-0.3243995905,
0.2792785764,
-0.2196512669,
0.0040850197,
0.0060068709,
0.9103454947,
0.5979579687,
0.2985959053,
-0.8834816813,
0.7604289651,
-0.1141730472,
-0.0443635695,
-0.2432720065,
0.1189002916,
0.1661851704,
0.0992482826,
0.3128421009,
0.1277871579,
0.3848363757,
-0.1958053261,
0.0282987356,
0.3152494431,
-0.1393458694,
-0.4639700055,
0.5593919158,
0.2500700951,
-0.1114010066,
0.3911826313,
-0.5080679059,
-0.7279623747,
0.5857459307,
0.3756689429,
0.8539631367,
-0.1721304506,
0.0355957747,
0.2850654423,
0.455839932,
-0.1213182956,
0.1085411236,
-0.0606650524,
-1.0842692852,
-0.5303830504,
-0.5426595807,
-0.8202816248,
0.1352189332,
-0.4593814015,
-0.3135408461,
-0.5001693368,
-0.2882086337,
-0.1388507783,
-0.0176634975,
-0.7244672775,
-0.0677474812,
-0.0091328509,
0.6443972588,
-0.7949265838,
0.4444075525,
0.7610531449,
-0.0091951294,
-0.6407796144,
0.0474218912,
0.4229831994,
-0.9934215546,
1.0534319878,
0.1414025426,
-0.1769073308,
-0.3268806934,
-0.5322527885,
-0.4601090252,
0.9203953743,
0.068211101,
-0.7967787385,
0.3387938738,
-0.1005902886,
0.5424085259,
-0.1469380558,
0.2671810389,
0.7410298586,
0.5702744722,
-0.1302892119,
-0.9846039414,
-0.0590175241,
0.0149071924,
0.0303451661,
0.030264616,
-0.5632623434,
0.8144090772,
-0.062290106,
-0.1267186105,
-0.024765173,
0.6068810225,
0.4539730549,
0.3344388902,
0.6251719594,
0.6383280754,
0.833290875,
-0.2100034803,
0.9482759237,
0.0172309261,
0.5420657992,
1.0554311275,
-0.57480371,
0.8373343349,
0.3997364342,
-0.5670537353,
0.2077943236,
0.6509926915,
0.1146522686,
0.208022967,
0.3338997662,
-0.1819031537,
-0.2265191674,
0.0224085227,
-0.0076810974,
0.0068983976,
0.467040658,
0.2772890925,
-0.3285111785,
-0.0125514884,
-0.0838481858,
0.030534476,
-0.1894482672,
0.7220122814,
0.0968807638,
-0.593046248,
0.6362651587,
-0.0015372765,
0.9807420373,
-0.2089950442,
-0.1279408783,
-0.5455191731,
0.2688977122,
-0.3117902577,
-0.8233554959,
0.1921723634,
0.1716550589,
-0.0087623792,
-0.000817274,
0.6853860617,
-0.1203496531,
-0.0913993046,
0.2581058145,
0.6999816298,
0.1093663648,
-0.0393848643,
-0.5984710455,
0.5270341039,
-0.0013962776,
-0.4288690388,
0.0931390449,
0.2277197689,
0.0760291591,
0.6205434799,
0.5416066647,
-0.0603093579,
0.0118636321,
0.0649797246,
0.5564442277,
-0.3702611327,
-0.1835441291,
-0.8296750784,
0.3011979163,
-0.0557894111,
-0.3426965177,
0.8759881258,
0.3256728947,
0.7216342092,
-0.0868341699,
0.6998853683,
0.2353200018,
0.5211222768,
-0.4965265989,
0.0878050327,
-0.4370886981,
0.5806285143,
-0.0771332905,
-0.9835229516,
-0.4338306189,
0.6490518451,
-0.2900326252,
0.0093894862,
0.7283654809,
0.8410843611,
0.2048004121,
0.0370900743,
0.4889369905,
0.4425729513,
0.4229568541,
0.6094070673,
1.0234326124,
-0.506215632,
0.1555101126,
-0.1613178551,
-0.2991895676,
-0.4690254927,
-0.8414943218,
-0.8325695395,
-0.3367528915,
-0.3972901702,
-0.5470941067,
0.030102158,
1.0015939474,
0.501719594,
-0.9675934911,
-0.2070792615,
0.0599601641,
0.251116693,
-0.0181381814,
-0.1639858037,
0.3639201224,
-0.3795263171,
-0.6526443958,
0.4824727178,
0.5560410619,
-0.133585915,
-0.3246023655,
-0.2319891006,
0.3359719217,
-0.1254966259,
0.6241813898,
0.1757768393,
-0.9001547098,
-0.3306485116,
0.1031923294,
-0.2626127601,
0.1516602933,
0.6422095299,
-0.4429714382,
0.2605482936,
0.4497116804,
0.7947192788,
0.0832328871,
-0.2940253615,
0.1224923879,
-0.7031190395,
-0.1565191746,
0.441814959,
0.6132055521,
0.6062645912,
-0.2209646851,
0.675366044,
0.4680068195,
-0.7495864034,
-0.9082025886,
-0.0235539116,
-0.9984195828,
0.0812805891,
1.0800070763,
-0.3611039817,
-0.4488272667,
-0.0292528588,
-0.2188642472,
-0.3367193341,
-0.2205337882,
0.5112375021,
0.919438839,
-0.2416660339,
-0.067986019,
-0.9704402685,
0.4767696857,
0.4416744709,
-1.0566619635,
0.2782615423,
0.7561324835,
0.4821738899,
0.2085455805,
0.7775163651,
0.0334756449,
0.6590771079,
-0.0648963675,
0.0644994229,
0.0883010253,
-0.0125970487,
-0.4827024043,
-0.0084607787,
0.3593659699,
-0.029608991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03598v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03598v1
|
Intent Detection and Entity Extraction from BioMedical Literature
| 2024-04-04T17:09:52 | 2024-04-04T17:09:52 |
Ankan Mullick, Mukur Gupta, Pawan Goyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Biomedical queries have become increasingly prevalent in web searches,
reflecting the growing interest in accessing biomedical literature. Despite
recent research on large-language models (LLMs) motivated by endeavours to
attain generalized intelligence, their efficacy in replacing task and
domain-specific natural language understanding approaches remains questionable.
In this paper, we address this question by conducting a comprehensive empirical
evaluation of intent detection and named entity recognition (NER) tasks from
biomedical text. We show that Supervised Fine Tuned approaches are still
relevant and more effective than general-purpose LLMs. Biomedical transformer
models such as PubMedBERT can surpass ChatGPT on NER task with only 5
supervised examples.
|
[
-0.0089332582,
-0.9226486683,
1.1660665274,
-0.1651515216,
-0.0671883002,
-0.3501313925,
-0.3500509262,
-0.7513916492,
0.1275705397,
0.7396128774,
-0.4102498293,
-0.6004021168,
-0.7532387972,
0.4339897335,
-0.4511182606,
1.1035549641,
0.1144585907,
0.2086583972,
-0.4316210151,
-0.0597937554,
-0.1863406748,
-0.2541151345,
-0.8108488321,
-0.4633534253,
0.7218500972,
0.1013624817,
0.2868376374,
0.2815023065,
0.9304741621,
0.2474286556,
-0.1859889627,
0.2463280559,
-0.4553895593,
0.2133096606,
-0.5490000248,
-0.3990164697,
-0.4425166845,
0.0272654463,
0.6300144196,
0.8804481626,
0.2093360722,
0.0535649396,
-0.047869727,
0.6450753808,
-0.5108317137,
0.005323315,
-0.5676245093,
-0.2449684441,
-0.0481987074,
-0.2831431031,
-0.9031791687,
-0.125585556,
0.4663608372,
-0.6179644465,
0.2953394055,
0.1872987896,
0.9071174264,
0.2842593789,
-0.5564976931,
-0.6688269377,
-0.8069806099,
0.9013949633,
-0.5778992176,
0.6153099537,
0.3701895475,
0.0139059061,
-0.5765640736,
-1.1339743137,
-0.3008032143,
-0.5005195141,
-0.3606974781,
0.0305081941,
-0.3955343068,
0.3024159968,
0.2672161162,
0.1848581135,
-0.5830327272,
0.2677206397,
-0.3464334309,
0.0709609687,
0.5674507618,
0.0665871575,
0.7123212814,
-0.3709905446,
-0.1183732077,
0.2896362543,
-0.664385736,
0.2315513343,
-0.0266454108,
0.1083691791,
0.3241830468,
0.8436059952,
-0.2309593558,
0.6906498075,
0.3178636134,
-0.1635771841,
-0.0072937012,
-0.469244957,
-0.2537101507,
0.1245505512,
0.8484699726,
0.1304256618,
0.2316554934,
-0.6338070035,
-0.0047416519,
-0.2705790997,
0.6063739061,
-0.9350916743,
-0.1452234238,
0.5736233592,
-0.7277548313,
-0.0146629363,
-0.3130715191,
-0.4430713952,
-0.3135891855,
-0.4067231715,
0.3785345256,
-0.772371769,
0.0568035319,
0.3835825026,
-0.2631069422,
0.582803607,
0.3370115459,
-0.8250100017,
0.2374512553,
0.9065842032,
0.6469198465,
-0.5764065385,
0.1897333264,
-0.5980066657,
0.2649407685,
-0.1478296369,
0.9698896408,
-0.6698599458,
-0.4111858606,
-0.2961090803,
0.4207779467,
-0.3479091227,
-0.3326987624,
0.875385344,
-0.7608571053,
0.2332938015,
-0.1078671291,
-0.8279430866,
-0.3285856247,
0.233244732,
-0.6681878567,
0.4852086306,
-0.1012852713,
-0.7616292834,
0.4923887253,
-0.9533804655,
-0.5505820513,
0.1732985675,
-0.1472933888,
-0.4053449035,
0.2236182988,
0.2543147504,
0.6261385083,
-0.3181606233,
0.5634179711,
-0.3213360012,
-0.25820297,
0.5517671108,
-0.3682345152,
0.8261924386,
-0.1613986194,
-0.3798366487,
0.0682706982,
-0.617184341,
-0.0675227493,
0.0610303096,
-0.2758979797,
-0.7862986326,
0.1827511489,
-0.0081738299,
-0.2118641436,
0.1516710669,
-0.7040250301,
0.3227284253,
-0.5579817295,
0.460021615,
0.1705345958,
0.274328053,
0.6332005262,
-0.089981474,
0.3363967538,
-0.4463340342,
-0.0094700558,
0.1177161261,
-0.6309423447,
-0.4032084644,
-0.6171099544,
0.4665403962,
0.3941290677,
-0.5356457233,
0.4141556621,
-0.3471623361,
-0.4038082659,
-0.369394809,
-0.1590514034,
0.241773501,
0.4027959406,
0.6448799968,
0.0917490572,
-0.3006157875,
-0.9101833701,
-0.4846218824,
0.0317635685,
-0.2182680219,
0.631598115,
0.5783894658,
-0.7062014341,
1.0272841454,
-0.4649823904,
-0.1852349937,
-0.2963842154,
0.1434258372,
0.3913852274,
0.3397976756,
0.5382664204,
-1.0935063362,
-0.2355119437,
0.1826602966,
-0.8889873028,
-0.1714919657,
-0.0018761506,
-0.0476505086,
-0.0856495425,
0.7366473079,
-0.7893143892,
0.3683763742,
0.2393863946,
-0.204116106,
0.5158285499,
-0.1432179958,
0.2053051591,
-0.83066535,
0.262981534,
0.2535315752,
-0.2704209089,
-0.9709537029,
-0.2300982475,
0.205403775,
0.2805355787,
-0.341352731,
0.7147290111,
-0.6714279652,
0.0784319863,
-0.3265420198,
-0.0712781623,
0.1328849047,
-0.0595221519,
0.322692275,
0.4886310399,
0.3462025821,
-0.7877872586,
-0.1106603816,
0.386313796,
-0.1961430162,
0.4142916501,
-0.9407141209,
0.0519684702,
-0.4869224727,
0.1089784279,
-0.9863578081,
-0.671779871,
0.2938631177,
-0.3860236704,
0.6393342614,
-0.2425826639,
-0.1806953549,
-0.2928780913,
0.0245767664,
0.3579900563,
0.4279872179,
-0.5087755322,
0.7766689658,
0.5226328373,
-0.2795454562,
-0.5468389988,
-0.5699899197,
0.0588995069,
-0.2141281068,
-0.2323420793,
0.6213268042,
0.2012364119,
-0.2038534582,
0.1327632815,
-0.0644164756,
-0.2724499702,
0.0527044274,
0.3054395318,
0.4233649075,
-0.2073302865,
0.3753094375,
0.1947339922,
0.083238326,
0.1335059851,
-0.0622189716,
0.3394118249,
0.122685276,
-0.5045400262,
-0.4912624359,
0.2787607014,
0.5126630068,
-0.26094836,
0.5799176097,
0.6479924917,
-0.3575685322,
0.1387907565,
-0.5897119641,
-0.3238687515,
-0.4209882021,
0.5324420929,
-0.1315749288,
-1.0116229057,
0.176174134,
-0.3528022468,
-0.0028992081,
0.5339897871,
0.4886563718,
-0.1464699805,
1.0106779337,
0.5368773341,
0.2367956638,
0.3476518989,
-0.0732525066,
0.4057077169,
-1.0541474819,
-0.2989356816,
-0.5564926267,
-0.1928685308,
-0.6603982449,
-0.2218743861,
0.3516629636,
-0.008170044,
0.2391838282,
0.3173262179,
-0.7329993844,
0.3562263846,
0.247206524,
0.3094018698,
0.4291043878,
-0.0496997647,
0.1131635755,
0.0520238876,
-0.4203677177,
-0.7452620268,
1.2979410887,
0.3545935452,
0.6149758101,
0.0640463382,
0.8221111298,
-0.0189411864,
0.6409516335,
-1.1152883768,
0.459295392,
-0.2140601277,
-0.8197219968,
-0.4269331694,
-0.2293719202,
-1.5645349026,
0.0332836285,
-0.2745939195,
-1.0156232119,
0.4257110059,
-0.3494738042,
-0.3138220012,
0.062640585,
-0.6705777049,
0.754200995,
-0.2291961759,
-0.2300644517,
0.049708195,
-0.4014085531,
0.3556363881,
-0.1820563078,
0.1750829816,
-0.1168310791,
-0.2014794201,
0.7485746741,
0.2624178231,
0.6035891771,
0.0778963044,
0.0303575657,
0.15033108,
-0.3257471919,
0.3862484694,
0.2150665373,
-0.1324807554,
0.1474223882,
-0.088177681,
-0.1429794133,
-0.3109204471,
0.5216414928,
-0.316693306,
-0.5524364114,
-0.142049253,
-0.6282880306,
-0.1625932008,
0.5192397833,
0.4391136169,
0.4656772614,
-0.4784733057,
0.5237502456,
0.9303388596,
-0.3945154846,
0.3011896312,
0.689365685,
-0.2764498889,
-0.0047601815,
0.4646604955,
-0.1311028898,
0.0686093941,
0.5294461846,
-0.0931593478,
-0.4184258878,
-0.9583210349,
-0.1991075873,
0.4232652783,
-0.4256476164,
-0.0953558385,
-1.2711410522,
-0.1617824137,
-0.5113056898,
-0.0132504785,
-0.1973648071,
-0.0557845682,
-0.5080442429,
0.1575327963,
0.3779052198,
0.8419803977,
0.1930709481,
0.1925914139,
-0.9567778111,
0.5941154361,
0.1544843018,
0.138483867,
-0.5346013904,
-0.3567370474,
0.0878540948,
-0.0562763065,
0.0269409437,
-1.0859405994,
0.4114018083,
0.2819713056,
0.8514357805,
0.3669072986,
-0.1328141838,
0.1720056832,
-0.6816980839,
0.5242797136,
0.0043303724,
-0.4967364073,
0.6475296021,
-0.3498395383,
0.1012951359,
0.6039202809,
0.9300639033,
-0.190264076,
-0.2475197613,
-0.5632956028,
-0.7656420469,
0.5543339849,
0.1627088338,
-0.0912019014,
-0.1608030796,
0.6279028654,
0.1438502967,
-0.1424185783,
-0.64394629,
-0.0997646451,
0.5267806649,
-0.3184790611,
-0.0543414243,
-0.208885029,
0.1208422482,
-0.2186141312,
0.553750515,
-0.1179365292,
0.4390911162,
0.6995899677,
-0.3755553067,
0.2148693651,
0.5463027954,
0.2262524962,
0.2504592538,
-0.2626904845,
-0.158209011,
-0.0075097703,
-0.7084143758,
0.0462504625,
0.3420213163,
-0.3472309411,
0.1874854118,
0.376029253,
0.4253451228,
0.4368574321,
-0.8008680344,
0.4991720915,
-0.2049396038,
-0.2593500912,
-0.0091611864,
0.2442340106,
0.2591429055,
0.3158561885,
0.2832064927,
-0.1071770266,
0.8863304853,
-0.320830971,
0.2806480825,
0.7730596662,
-0.5749536157,
-0.1550979912,
0.4721267521,
-0.1522832215,
-0.1802617908,
0.3665105104,
-0.3042901754,
-0.2776771784,
0.5825745463,
0.5866639018,
0.838424027,
-0.0697418153,
0.1263186187,
0.3319580853,
0.1325981915,
-0.2511382997,
0.069785744,
0.1223350093,
-0.7115480304,
-0.8062242866,
-0.7097670436,
-0.5282944441,
0.2003142387,
-0.6339023113,
0.2821469903,
0.1363880634,
-0.3648746014,
0.8326516151,
-0.213660717,
-0.718942821,
0.0969473124,
-0.0519431755,
0.5041171908,
-0.5338435769,
0.7764046788,
1.0250332355,
-0.3069644868,
-0.6075717211,
-0.0617255382,
-0.2740447223,
-0.5205891132,
0.8966222405,
0.3190703392,
0.0868785754,
0.1238360703,
-0.7662287354,
-0.8468386531,
0.8576004505,
0.1065195948,
-0.4624631703,
-0.3305165172,
0.0857072175,
0.5750357509,
-0.3006440699,
0.3850568235,
0.7199653387,
0.5513759255,
-0.0676706731,
-0.8709532619,
-0.0463846065,
-0.086049512,
-0.4360994697,
0.2591331899,
-0.0493071526,
0.6638945937,
-0.2479270548,
-0.2326306999,
0.0499714725,
0.4213062823,
0.2183116823,
0.6066277623,
0.3133403063,
0.2540035248,
1.0325379372,
-0.0669170991,
1.1072340012,
-0.0436209776,
0.3216749728,
0.7485470176,
-0.3220620751,
0.7026376128,
0.4733550847,
-0.1686102897,
0.5355370045,
0.4707840681,
0.0950005129,
0.4086205661,
-0.1305715591,
-0.1402356029,
-0.2336210608,
-0.2328304648,
-0.2094075233,
0.7102639675,
0.8862637877,
-0.5600722432,
-0.1047922373,
0.3247496188,
-0.0296159312,
-0.2259972841,
-0.4440926313,
1.0070693493,
0.1638878137,
-0.7358984351,
0.2813795507,
-0.2765280604,
0.7188953757,
-0.3148244619,
0.0184330754,
0.3044480681,
0.0969386324,
-0.2262828946,
-0.7199348807,
0.1597357839,
0.0582546145,
-0.3519078791,
0.10274259,
1.4720313549,
-0.2453403175,
-0.3711049259,
0.2707255185,
0.5611726642,
0.3981757462,
-0.1705418676,
-0.5109083652,
-0.411126703,
0.0181893688,
-0.4822921753,
0.3175045252,
0.5969577432,
0.1533830613,
0.5464560986,
0.8355815411,
0.1442719102,
-0.2058156133,
-0.17818515,
0.5994845033,
-0.7661793232,
-0.0187000036,
-0.9102123976,
0.1155552045,
-0.3453502059,
0.0421984047,
0.5720276237,
0.4091953039,
0.3050865829,
-0.1432955861,
0.717746675,
0.0867116749,
0.6016615629,
-0.5359408855,
0.6620771885,
-0.6152613163,
0.1113213673,
-0.1354684234,
-0.7537640929,
-0.4283517599,
0.421256423,
-0.8132697344,
-0.057248123,
0.8424013853,
0.4605094194,
-0.1321449131,
0.2095057964,
0.1791610867,
0.039905414,
0.3617134988,
0.4591889977,
0.668138504,
-0.3815410733,
0.2677154541,
0.1119701564,
-0.282032162,
-0.4594748318,
-0.8689520359,
-0.9909343719,
-0.197170049,
-0.294775486,
-0.1385220885,
0.0906889513,
0.8222854137,
0.4985235035,
-0.9132910967,
0.5071364641,
-0.235512808,
0.1282279491,
0.0138721569,
-0.2296152711,
0.4868629873,
-0.7548797131,
-0.9420312047,
0.4659770429,
0.4825176597,
0.0149051649,
0.0695770681,
0.2085322142,
-0.4834063947,
0.1178482398,
0.6239151955,
0.2827916443,
-0.5915715098,
-0.247509107,
0.5108652115,
-0.5345828533,
0.002313019,
0.6298055649,
-0.7803493142,
0.1392994374,
0.526031673,
0.9429859519,
0.4395387173,
-0.1092466116,
0.3118379414,
-0.258410722,
-0.1687369198,
0.4081681967,
0.4079652429,
0.1822090149,
-0.5802788138,
0.7309866548,
-0.0291641988,
-1.0033245087,
-0.6773616076,
-0.1187793538,
-1.3179196119,
-0.499976784,
1.5674881935,
0.0370100662,
-0.5612360239,
-0.4941966832,
-0.3171970844,
0.3546830416,
-0.2880227268,
0.4788930118,
0.3483609855,
-0.4829311371,
0.2861367762,
-0.9420544505,
0.5280189514,
0.4459258318,
-0.962736547,
-0.1968037188,
0.3942110837,
0.1691222638,
0.335313201,
0.7367851734,
-0.2371613681,
0.2800490558,
-0.476123333,
0.134394303,
0.3728634417,
-0.1292711049,
-0.1433111578,
0.1347694099,
0.0226657651,
0.0287037194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04295v1
|
Transducers with Pronunciation-aware Embeddings for Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-04-04T17:03:47 | 2024-04-04T17:03:47 |
Hainan Xu, Zhehuai Chen, Fei Jia, Boris Ginsburg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper proposes Transducers with Pronunciation-aware Embeddings (PET).
Unlike conventional Transducers where the decoder embeddings for different
tokens are trained independently, the PET model's decoder embedding
incorporates shared components for text tokens with the same or similar
pronunciations. With experiments conducted in multiple datasets in Mandarin
Chinese and Korean, we show that PET models consistently improve speech
recognition accuracy compared to conventional Transducers. Our investigation
also uncovers a phenomenon that we call error chain reactions. Instead of
recognition errors being evenly spread throughout an utterance, they tend to
group together, with subsequent errors often following earlier ones. Our
analysis shows that PET models effectively mitigate this issue by substantially
reducing the likelihood of the model generating additional errors following a
prior one. Our implementation will be open-sourced with the NeMo toolkit.
|
[
-0.0416374207,
-0.2906202972,
0.329146564,
0.0151619911,
-0.2520003617,
0.0179103296,
-0.0647398233,
-0.4355638623,
0.1711573601,
0.1476680189,
0.0785240307,
-0.2889371812,
-0.4621699154,
0.1835670918,
-0.148600176,
0.2950004339,
0.1599970758,
0.6078532338,
0.3519543707,
-0.2615265846,
-0.2729816139,
-0.4926392436,
-0.7420648932,
-0.196577251,
0.4654485285,
0.1036433801,
0.8741509318,
0.9240399003,
0.3201271594,
0.2279402614,
-0.1111190617,
0.1419070214,
0.2986212373,
0.1527895033,
-0.0684963837,
-0.0106779663,
-0.714343369,
-0.0666567013,
0.833183527,
0.5663040876,
-0.1658970565,
-0.5477203727,
-0.0409476943,
0.1836772114,
-0.6773182154,
-0.0327035002,
-0.397893548,
0.2901039422,
0.1213401854,
-0.229761973,
-0.5056895018,
-0.3417319059,
0.4744234979,
-0.7726073861,
0.1077164933,
-0.2426716536,
0.3002073467,
0.2655684352,
-0.4033202231,
-0.5251806378,
-0.968590498,
0.5818231106,
-0.8562995195,
0.7552653551,
0.3930087984,
0.2612130046,
-0.1631794572,
-0.698536396,
-0.6458290815,
-0.178346917,
-0.0159631278,
0.0982539654,
0.0707631335,
0.3646198511,
0.1342199743,
0.3229365349,
-0.5364077687,
0.0318819359,
0.0506102815,
-0.5421090126,
0.4722848833,
0.006361003,
0.4734157622,
-0.0163358953,
-0.0865842924,
-0.4412863255,
-0.3946616948,
-0.0467798188,
0.325588882,
0.769022882,
-0.1622942984,
0.2005123049,
0.2378770411,
0.7986767888,
0.1106179953,
-0.1932115406,
0.6810186505,
-0.2945208848,
-0.1580530852,
0.7079328895,
0.8119638562,
-0.034928225,
0.218601644,
0.1021325439,
-0.2825290263,
-0.05884289,
0.0825426131,
-0.5696145892,
-0.2244876176,
0.1726349741,
-0.5087874532,
-0.1625967771,
0.1222222224,
-0.2522761822,
-0.4671070576,
0.0244229734,
0.7615182996,
-0.3889502287,
-0.6343122125,
0.2184804678,
-0.4674153328,
0.3143928945,
0.2088406533,
-0.776907742,
0.3464369476,
0.5332525373,
0.9189835191,
0.3637887239,
-0.2224680632,
-0.8711857796,
0.2432517558,
-0.4754355848,
0.6808081865,
-0.6538858414,
-0.8254444599,
-0.1707965434,
0.1728026718,
-0.1084547937,
-0.7383422852,
0.3791655302,
-0.0278614406,
0.0353346094,
-0.239373371,
-0.6160518527,
-0.2668137848,
0.0189935658,
-0.8941345215,
0.7928135395,
-0.0439367816,
-0.5163021684,
0.0667437091,
-0.6305482388,
-0.5605241656,
-0.1605312079,
0.1186976582,
-0.4579033852,
0.1744012684,
0.0744839609,
0.2967545986,
-0.002592813,
-0.1427732557,
-0.2165046781,
-0.3353668451,
0.2529864013,
-0.4681376517,
0.6538649201,
-0.0259746742,
-0.291695267,
-0.146236971,
-0.9619540572,
0.2917510867,
-0.0851757377,
-0.4071497619,
-0.6878477335,
-0.013641119,
-0.0276556034,
0.2127782106,
-0.0739364102,
-0.7158221602,
0.0430137999,
-0.4064036608,
0.8132068515,
0.4828524292,
0.0328934565,
0.4030224681,
-0.2653977275,
0.2809682786,
0.1091762483,
0.2366907597,
-0.1722580045,
-0.4646269381,
-0.5302448273,
-0.1426726133,
0.4899795949,
0.5650878549,
-0.2481275946,
0.2331963331,
0.0485200733,
-0.5105006099,
-0.7098045945,
-0.1065306887,
0.5187554359,
0.5914498568,
0.2384274602,
-0.5397986174,
-0.7671289444,
-0.519226253,
-0.3550797999,
-0.4313003421,
0.0280932318,
0.3749382794,
0.1297192276,
-0.1373086125,
0.4920446575,
0.0703454241,
-0.0746523514,
0.147813186,
0.0769285858,
-0.0537303723,
0.8075804114,
0.1204863191,
-0.8415743113,
-0.5543676615,
0.20616211,
-0.3385981619,
0.0964083299,
0.0596963353,
0.1353242248,
0.1515947431,
0.4348288774,
-0.3735230565,
0.4011952579,
0.6199645996,
-0.066321142,
0.4182292223,
-0.1376344562,
-0.1088034213,
-1.0665125847,
-0.0665501654,
-0.3978794813,
-0.4541902542,
-0.810022831,
-0.6100521088,
0.2304981351,
0.0469337702,
-0.7368947268,
0.4505244195,
-0.4422053695,
-0.6004869342,
-0.3279795051,
0.1835913658,
0.0597506277,
0.1212551594,
0.5875689387,
0.7074569464,
0.4673055708,
-0.9108517766,
0.4659834504,
0.2126568258,
0.0542824306,
0.6133356094,
-0.9592410922,
0.5072915554,
0.2168242335,
0.3312408328,
-0.8149168491,
-0.1842589527,
0.2223629355,
-0.7845664024,
0.3402069807,
-0.1059800908,
-0.2393188328,
-0.2845100164,
-0.2339443117,
0.3544478118,
0.4142290354,
-0.6938433647,
0.7609249949,
0.4040250778,
0.0825962499,
-0.6445584297,
-0.8033592105,
-0.2080855072,
-0.0165939108,
-0.3015288115,
0.3364159167,
-0.0476364493,
0.104691036,
0.2072040737,
-0.0846551433,
-0.2300635129,
-0.0178395137,
0.3131677508,
-0.2922787964,
-0.1919749528,
0.5929449797,
-0.3811255097,
-0.3115226328,
-0.1722657979,
-0.5133669376,
0.4347319305,
-0.25218606,
-0.3246210217,
-0.7667033672,
0.2265488058,
0.6357138753,
-0.2135533392,
0.285243541,
0.6813513041,
-0.6136746407,
-0.1550900638,
-0.2666890621,
-0.1293589622,
-0.511780262,
0.246388793,
-0.3965348899,
-0.4792692363,
0.6478952765,
-0.0858107805,
-0.204581663,
0.2736128867,
0.4490345716,
-0.251637578,
1.2034245729,
0.3807916343,
-0.0675924122,
0.7303957939,
-0.1513818055,
0.211669609,
-1.230379343,
-0.0958332121,
-0.5999547839,
-0.1126486063,
-0.8937340379,
-0.5622907877,
0.3836632073,
-0.2921071649,
-0.4990591705,
0.3348476887,
-0.6569568515,
0.3147125542,
0.7768846154,
0.0104016028,
0.1828948855,
-0.0319027156,
-0.3592909873,
0.0593186207,
-0.6357862949,
-0.3303113878,
0.9730111957,
0.2213493884,
0.9368875027,
-0.1118467376,
0.6823077202,
0.1609716415,
-0.3218933344,
-0.976313293,
0.1864882261,
-0.2800120413,
-0.5270990729,
-0.4194515944,
-0.1542864293,
-0.7478393912,
0.2058311552,
0.1639360785,
-0.3410869539,
0.5243253708,
0.3751425743,
-0.4569019377,
0.424461782,
-0.5401486754,
0.6512242556,
-0.2180113494,
0.0024267326,
-0.0257184766,
-0.6456881166,
-0.1122958139,
0.1104619354,
-0.0347220786,
0.0847692788,
-0.0370438099,
0.6865593791,
-0.7037299275,
0.7019169331,
-0.5096949339,
-0.0065347794,
0.6048224568,
0.0116911111,
0.7996091843,
-0.258187294,
-0.3723600507,
-0.0075725196,
-0.2233166546,
-0.0874681398,
-0.6647061706,
0.3197171092,
-0.6892108321,
-0.13364546,
-0.3822802007,
-0.3428845704,
-0.2548882365,
0.1027707607,
0.2382700741,
0.5665020943,
-0.1251161546,
0.1054586619,
0.6629638076,
-0.3244731128,
0.5841498971,
0.7819250226,
0.2190458179,
-0.8515501022,
0.9726660848,
0.345520556,
0.4361982644,
0.2496952415,
0.5285159945,
-0.2998695374,
-0.2600772083,
-0.2659989297,
0.1836590171,
-0.6472089291,
-0.0877708867,
-0.7462093234,
-0.4079180658,
-0.4397881925,
-0.1994370222,
-0.8584637046,
-0.6318526268,
-0.2799779773,
-0.1982245743,
0.4720940292,
0.8323767781,
-0.7916269302,
0.4773279428,
-0.9327763915,
0.2664606273,
0.6314073205,
0.3910149336,
0.0941956043,
-0.5018880963,
-0.3521980941,
0.2124999017,
-0.0903931558,
-0.9146201611,
0.5753661394,
0.5729390979,
0.4921331704,
0.1771355867,
-0.0226976126,
0.7554665804,
-0.3642609715,
0.7008443475,
-0.0255948268,
-1.5117255449,
0.7896823883,
-0.2975060046,
0.2916826606,
0.2110992223,
0.1980129927,
-1.0028290749,
-0.2577466369,
-0.5405835509,
-0.6646862626,
0.5395901799,
-0.2931447923,
0.1777846664,
0.0361337252,
0.1364693046,
0.0704524219,
0.1978921443,
-0.538406074,
0.0478427298,
-0.3983028829,
-0.1907888651,
0.0686284453,
-0.1939543933,
0.2439424098,
-0.324826777,
0.9693945646,
-0.0892169848,
0.4891370833,
0.6083638072,
-0.2862361968,
-0.320948571,
0.0709914491,
0.6224579811,
0.0799586773,
-0.3003022075,
0.3432442248,
0.084987618,
-0.8421735764,
0.447006613,
-0.2216559947,
0.0632179305,
0.5061087608,
0.2516308129,
0.7307430506,
0.1692853272,
-0.4289720654,
0.5112598538,
-0.164057523,
-0.001874601,
-0.4668568373,
-0.1562571228,
0.23187159,
0.2033994198,
0.2085642815,
-0.1078887209,
0.3394296765,
-0.2723610699,
0.1731829941,
0.3570263088,
-0.57611233,
-0.4993994236,
0.4677055478,
0.4346755147,
-0.5225206017,
0.702747941,
-0.1319140941,
-0.7348338962,
0.7565553188,
0.6517466307,
1.1817388535,
-1.1162542105,
0.1373381466,
0.5225791931,
0.3380388319,
-0.0670917481,
0.6143953204,
-0.1650180668,
-0.734806478,
-0.1845217198,
-0.1981611103,
-0.9460948706,
-0.0359900445,
-0.6636736393,
0.3290456831,
-0.7393019795,
-0.2800863385,
-0.04851228,
-0.1988684982,
-0.5653237104,
0.3989931345,
0.266713798,
0.4761880934,
-0.7462071776,
0.8927093744,
0.7483413219,
-0.0179330092,
-1.147621274,
-0.1699357778,
-0.0412459821,
-0.7629975677,
0.6015094519,
0.2346053421,
-0.2551348805,
-0.0310241859,
-0.1371558458,
-1.0828974247,
0.8695498109,
0.3471844494,
-0.8457651138,
0.136741519,
0.2743847072,
0.477222681,
-0.3113380075,
0.349219352,
0.4640520513,
0.5470010042,
-0.2388952672,
-1.5412061214,
-0.0681196377,
-0.1305348873,
0.1013319641,
-0.0371490419,
-0.6642376184,
1.1121567488,
-0.1437458694,
-0.122980617,
-0.24480775,
0.1652558297,
-0.0021011734,
0.3631503284,
0.6012058258,
0.6184802651,
0.9821064472,
0.175579384,
0.6213100553,
-0.316521585,
0.1055909395,
1.2747827768,
-0.2649999261,
1.030223012,
0.1413981915,
-0.1187166721,
0.6770772934,
0.5552633405,
0.2351308316,
0.7578392625,
0.0293630566,
-0.4342285991,
-0.2319399863,
-0.3370790482,
-0.6220445633,
0.7143890858,
0.6218041182,
-0.7550314069,
0.0194069613,
0.2791265547,
-0.3501944542,
-0.323233813,
-0.2824977934,
0.8153960109,
0.2455251813,
0.0043278248,
0.6610916853,
-0.3485266864,
0.6023270488,
-0.3831976056,
-0.1127973795,
0.0729380697,
0.1394022852,
-0.314723134,
-0.4007808864,
0.2331400812,
-0.2334794253,
-0.3044887185,
-0.0755077079,
0.7785963416,
-0.5106190443,
-0.1481133401,
0.4445856214,
0.1584252864,
0.2993272245,
-0.0313599817,
-0.4985081553,
0.3650196791,
-0.2452787906,
-0.1939262003,
-0.1740005612,
0.2778225243,
0.0500494242,
0.5535434484,
0.4357467294,
0.1476659179,
0.366653204,
0.1486368775,
0.3946692646,
-0.7790646553,
-0.7272444367,
-0.5823556185,
0.5712067485,
0.199106276,
-0.0672353804,
0.6000949144,
0.3531066477,
0.8661412597,
-0.01447568,
1.1575226784,
0.3026204407,
0.7971343994,
-0.2642793655,
0.4714438021,
-0.4613800049,
0.0621369407,
-0.3445756435,
-0.7805331349,
-0.2483761311,
1.0129561424,
-0.0485191979,
0.1659110934,
0.5950930119,
0.9015991688,
0.0863187611,
0.1545017511,
0.4630980492,
0.2136667222,
0.278439343,
0.733815372,
0.7983250618,
-0.8308252096,
0.4425129294,
-0.4531698823,
0.3823937178,
-0.47463274,
-0.7758370638,
-0.3418093622,
-0.7242541313,
-0.5356653333,
-0.4426269531,
0.2392745316,
0.915435791,
0.9577698112,
-0.7888580561,
-0.1459931582,
-0.2939206064,
0.2216968089,
-0.3586119115,
-0.1506554037,
0.3993952572,
-0.0908969417,
-0.9943475723,
0.5460203886,
0.2095556557,
0.5644145608,
-0.151495412,
-0.4805839956,
0.1068975255,
0.2205429822,
0.1692826301,
0.7192467451,
-0.5631876588,
-0.4411664307,
-0.1726956218,
-0.234321177,
0.2541407645,
0.7852423787,
-0.9255916476,
1.0699068308,
0.7386609316,
0.4551958442,
0.180515483,
-0.2399901897,
0.8523974419,
-0.6031768918,
0.3334718049,
0.455519557,
0.2316786647,
0.7669655681,
-0.362790823,
0.4620792866,
0.2667629421,
-0.4069777131,
-1.0885734558,
-0.0810976475,
-0.8993052244,
0.0905795246,
0.8765913248,
-0.3339134753,
-0.3458512425,
0.01630795,
0.0239725132,
0.6294247508,
-0.4239621758,
0.1656922251,
0.5410488248,
-0.123713553,
-0.0891817585,
-0.3356158435,
0.5188611746,
0.4198246598,
-0.333832562,
-0.0381788574,
0.3230212033,
0.5473781228,
0.178098008,
0.6601051688,
-0.2242242694,
0.6958322525,
0.3554440141,
0.3731015623,
-0.1948051602,
-0.255807966,
-0.7003041506,
-0.1910051852,
0.1923309267,
-0.6721183658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03592v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03592v3
|
ReFT: Representation Finetuning for Language Models
| 2024-04-04T17:00:37 | 2024-05-22T17:52:31 |
Zhengxuan Wu, Aryaman Arora, Zheng Wang, Atticus Geiger, Dan Jurafsky, Christopher D. Manning, Christopher Potts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT) methods seek to adapt large neural
models via updates to a small number of weights. However, much prior
interpretability work has shown that representations encode rich semantic
information, suggesting that editing representations might be a more powerful
alternative. We pursue this hypothesis by developing a family of Representation
Finetuning (ReFT) methods. ReFT methods operate on a frozen base model and
learn task-specific interventions on hidden representations. We define a strong
instance of the ReFT family, Low-rank Linear Subspace ReFT (LoReFT), and we
identify an ablation of this method that trades some performance for increased
efficiency. Both are drop-in replacements for existing PEFTs and learn
interventions that are 15x--65x more parameter-efficient than LoRA. We showcase
LoReFT on eight commonsense reasoning tasks, four arithmetic reasoning tasks,
instruction-tuning, and GLUE. In all these evaluations, our ReFTs deliver the
best balance of efficiency and performance, and almost always outperform
state-of-the-art PEFTs. We release a generic ReFT training library publicly at
https://github.com/stanfordnlp/pyreft.
|
[
-0.2652978599,
-0.5633460283,
0.4575107098,
-0.0122664515,
-0.190983668,
0.0262280703,
-0.5814417005,
-0.1264178455,
-0.0296462402,
0.4697360694,
-0.4065692127,
-0.2511129677,
-0.4637684226,
-0.0274546817,
-0.3810964227,
0.9313495159,
-0.216280371,
-0.0103096729,
-0.0319625102,
-0.1929104924,
-0.3226823807,
-0.4502083063,
-0.5667557716,
-0.5556636453,
0.5351279378,
0.5229228735,
0.7644920945,
0.7503387928,
0.4780120254,
0.2888588905,
-0.029760655,
0.1566167325,
-0.9478849173,
0.0214143693,
-0.3501571715,
-0.575396359,
-0.176256001,
-0.014869486,
0.65387851,
0.957279861,
-0.1501523405,
0.0510367975,
0.1950903386,
0.7627985477,
-0.6570976973,
0.2443289757,
-0.8272459507,
0.0036162091,
-0.2323200554,
-0.0536291152,
-0.6602673531,
-0.3381553888,
0.2633173466,
-0.6459553242,
0.3515396714,
-0.1060492694,
0.8136501312,
0.5595787764,
-0.1203383952,
0.1674445421,
-0.7158171535,
0.7952706814,
-0.6733581424,
0.8561099768,
0.354187876,
0.0885677338,
-0.0200759042,
-1.0364841223,
-0.2122062147,
-0.3052142262,
-0.2092742622,
0.0054539707,
-0.465913564,
0.3885279894,
0.4815311134,
0.498267591,
-0.289940238,
-0.0779230371,
-0.3570055962,
-0.2900266647,
0.3978758156,
-0.1417134702,
-0.1442572474,
0.056919191,
-0.3142980337,
-0.0672870055,
-0.8532354832,
-0.2445355505,
0.0963368788,
0.3035044372,
-0.0053921253,
0.3921636343,
-0.2540926039,
0.7654871941,
0.5050872564,
0.100598,
0.0727151781,
-0.0367460363,
-0.2767415941,
-0.1683808416,
0.5030443668,
0.1017927974,
0.1674595326,
-0.2569328249,
-0.28345716,
-0.3400748372,
0.140162468,
-0.7728111744,
-0.6248071194,
-0.3030824661,
-0.5573922396,
-0.239024654,
-0.1069437563,
-0.4813346267,
-0.2891468108,
-0.6361029744,
0.433657378,
-0.7147547603,
-0.131551668,
0.1058259755,
-0.1174490973,
0.1346277446,
0.5209118724,
-1.0265111923,
0.5731679797,
0.5136171579,
0.5736215711,
-0.0868255794,
-0.1654355526,
-0.6712265611,
-0.0545415767,
-0.4092337191,
0.7417637706,
-0.5981971622,
0.0304512866,
-0.1803210676,
-0.090394631,
-0.095457837,
-0.5484464169,
0.4710879028,
-0.4518704712,
-0.1481532902,
-0.5137612224,
-0.5880316496,
-0.2833867073,
-0.1561038196,
-0.7685399055,
1.0133037567,
0.3454333246,
-0.4507693946,
0.2423472553,
-0.6287402511,
-0.1901571006,
-0.0015291817,
0.0667412952,
-0.0156535339,
0.4193258286,
0.2127841711,
0.6378847957,
-0.1944239289,
-0.008493728,
-0.0770492777,
-0.5544989109,
0.0528610572,
-0.7230595946,
0.250297755,
0.3569571674,
-0.3068554103,
0.0242425278,
-0.5744042397,
-0.0130359996,
0.1299336255,
-0.4325427115,
-0.5573969483,
-0.1614899933,
0.104900524,
-0.2242768258,
0.3088906109,
-0.4105744064,
0.3309900463,
-0.5841842294,
0.6164452434,
0.7310521007,
-0.0924729928,
0.6102693081,
-0.1583494842,
0.3293364048,
-0.2917897403,
-0.1060840487,
-0.14172104,
-0.3366579115,
-0.8643310666,
-0.2092309892,
0.7094860673,
0.2424419671,
-0.9935435653,
0.0210377201,
-0.1227288395,
-0.3597516119,
-0.544152379,
0.1927877814,
0.5879936814,
0.428542465,
0.4015351236,
0.0009733552,
-0.3594156504,
-1.0058041811,
-0.3267910182,
0.0590761453,
0.2099301219,
-0.0118241645,
0.1660970449,
-0.0866813213,
0.9113906026,
-0.6005460024,
0.0459312312,
-0.0713983774,
0.4048621953,
0.1263626814,
0.5445913672,
0.6928506494,
-0.6240616441,
-0.5209380984,
0.0713883489,
-0.3029414117,
-0.1487750858,
-0.1423115581,
0.0573443361,
0.2882888913,
0.7020127177,
-0.3677934706,
0.1702373177,
0.5121334791,
-0.3107380569,
0.3715791106,
-0.2316020578,
0.0192995407,
-0.5623956919,
-0.0149410646,
-0.1235563979,
-0.5326737165,
-0.8062639236,
0.3015984297,
0.1691018045,
-0.2103584707,
-0.3868067265,
0.3983826339,
-0.4250643253,
0.1417262703,
-0.0025720287,
-0.119197771,
-0.0804119259,
0.77970469,
0.0025439609,
0.764513433,
0.1431410015,
-0.1408901066,
0.128269434,
-0.0863196328,
-0.0317395926,
0.3519755304,
-0.4555767179,
0.4650245011,
-0.1215860918,
-0.0370329097,
-0.934592545,
-0.1282945871,
0.1995394677,
-0.0734626427,
0.4402377307,
-0.3293868005,
-0.4792350233,
-0.0510269627,
-0.269972235,
0.2798925638,
0.5484748483,
-0.7642657757,
0.5531421304,
0.0196451806,
-0.1479608268,
-0.5980010033,
-0.7703701258,
-0.2589571178,
-0.0717069283,
-0.3862077892,
0.5294440985,
0.0362128094,
-0.0643691421,
0.280066818,
-0.3371300697,
-0.1893064976,
0.0143940337,
-0.0403379165,
-0.1137011349,
-0.4491877854,
0.2928059697,
0.3043705821,
-0.2846304178,
-0.27341187,
-0.3000495434,
0.5327466726,
-0.5401133299,
-0.3653184772,
-0.2832978666,
0.3145419061,
0.3051375449,
-0.304243058,
0.3491626978,
0.7790983915,
-0.6173439026,
-0.2604522407,
-0.6746010184,
-0.25742957,
-0.4986011982,
0.3481753469,
-0.4337978065,
-1.0467692614,
0.40178743,
-0.290440321,
0.2721075416,
0.5275608301,
0.2689546049,
-0.073096849,
0.7462576032,
0.7415507436,
0.1806938499,
0.6321248412,
-0.4569407105,
0.086467132,
-0.607609272,
0.1480633914,
-0.3669025898,
-0.3765198886,
-0.3281322718,
-0.7613286376,
-0.0147156864,
0.5009111762,
-0.3369484246,
0.4227329791,
-0.6791144609,
0.6724674702,
0.7012053132,
0.2063300759,
0.4334742725,
0.3158231974,
-0.1557616889,
-0.4559700191,
-0.8976843357,
-0.3889511228,
1.0665236712,
0.4804462194,
0.9312297702,
-0.1605113447,
1.0218193531,
0.1059465036,
0.5312755108,
-0.9920819402,
0.4125920832,
-0.6982115507,
-0.2086099535,
-0.304251045,
-0.388463974,
-0.7530429959,
0.0605364703,
-0.2340409309,
-0.6772575974,
0.5733340383,
0.3974452317,
-0.4891948998,
0.387345165,
-0.9932797551,
0.776940167,
0.0325290076,
-0.3848012686,
-0.4325267971,
-0.257240802,
0.260833621,
-0.130352959,
-0.1424937993,
0.1250484735,
-0.0481340885,
0.8399969339,
-0.4863129556,
0.8137724996,
-0.3750243485,
0.0099477042,
0.2094716132,
0.2718730271,
0.6178684235,
-0.0563725829,
-0.1927218586,
0.1595825851,
0.2285467386,
-0.1262732893,
-0.88288939,
0.7612158656,
-0.6148030758,
-0.4955136776,
-0.1744143367,
-0.6490455866,
-0.3774201572,
0.2916499972,
0.1408602297,
0.4832453728,
-0.1364735663,
0.4309572577,
0.8513017297,
0.0456567705,
0.1632145196,
0.1804430485,
-0.1327574104,
-0.3714571893,
1.1248629093,
0.23301889,
0.3743837774,
0.5504494905,
0.4076449573,
-0.0307393409,
-0.674490571,
-0.1218205839,
0.2932641506,
-0.9148190618,
-0.270056963,
-0.2057900429,
-0.248176977,
0.0181516837,
-0.3430741727,
-0.646727562,
-0.6231564879,
-0.1336373836,
-0.0060249101,
0.6630460024,
0.7984778881,
-0.3660025299,
0.4155344963,
-0.4789520204,
0.4310583472,
0.603490293,
0.600256145,
-0.0794803426,
-0.2733335197,
-0.2299542725,
0.0004804193,
-0.245680362,
-0.6615926027,
0.0724469572,
0.2306219488,
0.5460566282,
0.3096282184,
0.0310549047,
0.8121829629,
-0.5833261609,
0.5570172668,
0.283826828,
-1.0664607286,
0.1467137188,
-0.4377000034,
0.229635492,
0.6746426225,
0.1446614563,
-0.511519134,
-0.1794126928,
-0.7082409263,
-0.6941338181,
0.7421187162,
0.0772141963,
0.3014352322,
0.2568557858,
0.6227266788,
0.2083886117,
0.0441598669,
-0.5084127188,
-0.3062800765,
-0.3454241455,
-0.4233568609,
0.1689010113,
-0.3592556715,
-0.0588017665,
-0.4857112765,
0.4336805344,
-0.3732901216,
0.5969306827,
0.3293326199,
-0.0589227155,
-0.2208689153,
0.2024467736,
0.3830570579,
0.5037546158,
-0.2518066168,
0.1369788796,
0.2740342021,
-0.4959121644,
-0.1656186581,
0.3725499213,
-0.0476030633,
0.0921260044,
0.4792677462,
0.896589458,
0.6820827127,
-0.4442325532,
0.3079847991,
0.0139132328,
-0.5181910396,
-0.0051121702,
0.0962759107,
0.0791703686,
0.2998407781,
0.3360610306,
0.4549940825,
0.2467202693,
-0.3730916083,
0.3473850191,
0.150521785,
-0.5848425627,
-0.0581562296,
0.5347414613,
0.1683794409,
-0.1431499869,
0.5254988074,
-0.1647914499,
-0.2965449691,
0.2239131033,
0.3571445644,
0.8332588077,
-0.1517940164,
0.1456198394,
0.1854651421,
0.2966769934,
-0.1411426067,
0.18152152,
-0.0580404438,
-0.7102024555,
-0.6284513474,
-0.4597411454,
-0.382787168,
0.3079243302,
-0.5277004242,
0.1460954249,
-0.5807954669,
0.0126220565,
-0.0032393222,
-0.1339577734,
-0.7483416796,
-0.208818391,
0.1576267034,
0.9659720659,
-0.5932917595,
0.8470413685,
0.729057312,
-0.334955126,
-1.1115748882,
0.1511171162,
-0.123392947,
-0.6719853282,
0.7160986066,
-0.276935041,
-0.0652689338,
0.213177368,
-0.6866494417,
-1.0972520113,
0.8828815818,
1.078158617,
-0.7307107449,
-0.2068108767,
-0.1709754914,
0.4605984092,
-0.1842625588,
-0.0806031972,
0.8211051226,
0.4266578555,
-0.0135483127,
-0.9170981646,
0.1913207322,
-0.1389236599,
0.0728015751,
0.1248597279,
-0.5022896528,
0.6642235518,
-0.0371531136,
-0.049991414,
0.190226391,
0.5598951578,
0.2229741216,
-0.0496190712,
0.5473825336,
0.4783475101,
0.8598438501,
-0.4900777042,
0.9327176809,
-0.1111980006,
0.4354433119,
1.093485713,
0.2345986217,
0.9031527638,
0.5758730173,
-0.1073144153,
0.3506791294,
0.4259619415,
0.0237721354,
0.6816927791,
0.1830248982,
-0.0059427922,
-0.3567972481,
0.0826961845,
-0.1656669378,
0.2497037351,
0.4986058474,
-0.3260007203,
-0.4007900655,
0.1864076257,
0.1053873599,
0.31785357,
-0.3227668405,
0.6340953112,
0.2838594317,
-0.5152002573,
1.0437580347,
-0.0150134051,
0.6102833152,
-0.585773468,
-0.5067995191,
-0.1137242317,
0.2383320332,
-0.2612441182,
-0.7158209682,
0.3077958226,
-0.1654399037,
-0.1894888282,
-0.538818121,
0.8050558567,
-0.5563152432,
-0.2715289295,
0.1696105301,
0.3215576708,
0.0153418574,
0.057824295,
-0.8759559393,
0.1267572939,
0.0719972104,
-0.2947764397,
-0.0055440823,
0.3561136425,
-0.1876913011,
0.379429251,
0.6131181717,
0.1376266181,
0.0070915357,
0.2303912491,
0.8518387675,
-0.4252999127,
-0.178359583,
-0.5521767735,
0.5481468439,
0.0106895287,
-0.2045627683,
0.3375535905,
0.2995221615,
0.8236237764,
-0.1750565916,
0.597333014,
-0.0176769812,
0.3496739566,
-0.7908167839,
0.7654723525,
-0.3895307779,
0.0666676462,
-0.4795773327,
-0.8084002137,
-0.4202442765,
0.8049824834,
-0.5276073813,
-0.0541048422,
0.8689023852,
0.561827004,
-0.3488114476,
0.0805564001,
0.4581552744,
0.4084163904,
0.0688724965,
0.5713641047,
0.6896796227,
-0.5127326846,
0.3683584929,
-0.6033909917,
-0.2092505544,
-0.1080485135,
-0.8076840639,
-0.8175646663,
-0.7689439654,
-0.3308532834,
0.0895354599,
0.1841209382,
1.028998971,
1.0593049526,
-0.7969642282,
-0.0878131837,
-0.1239300221,
0.1081633419,
-0.4325993955,
-0.2171870172,
0.6002377272,
-0.5028725266,
-0.6697078943,
0.4455972612,
0.0549152009,
-0.1714078784,
-0.2084883749,
-0.1010746956,
-0.0102979466,
-0.1267444193,
0.6655528545,
0.2400010526,
-0.7769348025,
-0.4868790805,
-0.0740677863,
0.202631101,
0.0325725824,
0.8877804875,
-0.8175034523,
0.3875412941,
0.6019740105,
0.8359634876,
0.7475097775,
-0.1227167845,
0.7729113698,
-0.6682630777,
0.193938002,
0.2870690525,
0.6070252657,
0.2957105637,
-0.3327645063,
0.588993907,
0.2540231347,
-0.2729903758,
-0.7837935686,
0.1215075329,
-0.9866142273,
-0.1965721697,
1.0054887533,
-0.1142114773,
-0.1015572101,
-0.053104911,
-0.4650520682,
0.1230500191,
-0.6441227198,
0.3198765218,
0.573394537,
-0.1109098494,
-0.5120974183,
-0.5501381755,
0.7033578157,
0.3897687495,
-0.4813020825,
0.3987911344,
0.3726084232,
0.397364825,
0.2844486237,
0.5578283668,
-0.141789332,
0.3688348532,
-0.2550894916,
0.0151326256,
-0.2442216873,
-0.2118768543,
-0.5285876989,
0.1384999752,
0.5292542577,
0.2864355743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03577v1
|
Untangle the KNOT: Interweaving Conflicting Knowledge and Reasoning Skills in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T16:40:11 | 2024-04-04T16:40:11 |
Yantao Liu, Zijun Yao, Xin Lv, Yuchen Fan, Shulin Cao, Jifan Yu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Providing knowledge documents for large language models (LLMs) has emerged as
a promising solution to update the static knowledge inherent in their
parameters. However, knowledge in the document may conflict with the memory of
LLMs due to outdated or incorrect knowledge in the LLMs' parameters. This leads
to the necessity of examining the capability of LLMs to assimilate supplemental
external knowledge that conflicts with their memory. While previous studies
have explained to what extent LLMs extract conflicting knowledge from the
provided text, they neglect the necessity to reason with conflicting knowledge.
Furthermore, there lack a detailed analysis on strategies to enable LLMs to
resolve conflicting knowledge via prompting, decoding strategy, and supervised
fine-tuning. To address these limitations, we construct a new dataset, dubbed
KNOT, for knowledge conflict resolution examination in the form of question
answering. KNOT facilitates in-depth analysis by dividing reasoning with
conflicting knowledge into three levels: (1) Direct Extraction, which directly
extracts conflicting knowledge to answer questions. (2) Explicit Reasoning,
which reasons with conflicting knowledge when the reasoning path is explicitly
provided in the question. (3) Implicit Reasoning, where reasoning with
conflicting knowledge requires LLMs to infer the reasoning path independently
to answer questions. We also conduct extensive experiments on KNOT to establish
empirical guidelines for LLMs to utilize conflicting knowledge in complex
circumstances. Dataset and associated codes can be accessed at
https://github.com/THU-KEG/KNOT .
|
[
-0.580961287,
-1.0109032393,
0.6671606898,
-0.0584258176,
-0.5803697109,
0.3847056031,
-0.2921440899,
-0.4665960073,
-0.0634503514,
0.5325536728,
-0.2031050026,
-0.3045128584,
-0.8342216611,
0.0220599398,
-0.2535280883,
0.7979186177,
-0.3408074677,
0.1186469421,
-0.6681694388,
-0.1127117574,
-0.4405153692,
-0.273878932,
-0.6891517043,
-0.6498152614,
0.5992864966,
0.6641644835,
0.5809172392,
0.5817132592,
0.5402579904,
0.2856685519,
-0.6126625538,
0.5405534506,
-0.5664467216,
0.1052689701,
-0.5149470568,
-0.4852236211,
-0.1696517467,
0.0238041598,
0.5695562363,
0.8813353181,
-0.084581852,
0.2478132248,
0.1950653344,
0.7064893842,
-0.4127683342,
-0.0002577397,
-0.9509498477,
-0.2789254785,
-0.4791557491,
-0.3428626359,
-0.0440368392,
-0.3524938226,
0.2181248516,
-0.4939044118,
0.114396587,
0.027083097,
0.8753407598,
0.3516089022,
-0.96587497,
-0.5342078805,
-0.511094749,
0.4919266403,
-0.9383636713,
0.2546392679,
0.5143836737,
-0.0363376662,
-0.4299320281,
-0.4275681973,
-0.5527745485,
0.1490943879,
-0.0566032007,
-0.0197993238,
0.1744090766,
-0.0099674398,
0.4314483106,
0.4191834033,
-0.3504748046,
0.2395339906,
-0.6052169204,
0.1730058491,
0.9148251414,
0.2326849848,
0.2663321793,
-0.0998161137,
-0.1319363862,
0.1528811157,
-0.7937525511,
0.4742070735,
0.5065479279,
0.0021504271,
0.0049905083,
0.6398579478,
-0.0404540114,
0.7702177167,
0.3069544435,
-0.2457105219,
-0.1350653917,
0.1740567386,
-0.1391317099,
0.1612137705,
0.7498745918,
0.3569188118,
0.148592785,
-0.0654654652,
-0.0429910459,
-0.4621193707,
0.3337263167,
-0.3791252673,
-0.104175888,
0.2086087316,
-0.3002717495,
-0.1673800945,
-0.1392136812,
-0.8896664381,
-0.6924478412,
-0.496892184,
0.3065454662,
-0.3741357625,
-0.476441443,
0.2958953977,
-0.0952197164,
0.3372750282,
0.3100112081,
-0.7669833302,
0.0103960251,
0.7914585471,
0.452521801,
-0.1025587618,
-0.1373282522,
-0.2153928727,
0.272921145,
-0.4817918539,
0.5178652406,
-0.7703451514,
-0.3500121236,
-0.067144528,
-0.1326595247,
-0.1597186774,
-0.4066327512,
0.6179966927,
-0.8092923164,
0.1898667812,
-0.4921763539,
-0.953276813,
-0.5657183528,
0.2480939031,
-0.6533436179,
0.8217918277,
-0.048380848,
-0.8166552186,
0.1237183809,
-0.4012481868,
-0.4337794483,
-0.0789557323,
-0.2899822891,
-0.4085423052,
0.1075851619,
0.0641711429,
0.3035800457,
-0.8030439615,
0.5909184217,
-0.5880298615,
-0.3599181473,
0.1928713322,
-0.1203193143,
0.8773312569,
0.2458856553,
0.0021724005,
-0.0878950283,
-0.5622549057,
-0.0771203861,
0.3784552813,
-0.5589903593,
-0.5635631084,
-0.0909243897,
-0.8302899003,
0.171912998,
0.337462604,
-0.4570483565,
0.5571702719,
-0.1364007741,
0.2792425752,
0.6877376437,
0.2050439417,
0.4183426499,
-0.3182539344,
0.4555012584,
0.2573954463,
0.0558303855,
0.2405110151,
-0.5955861807,
-0.9793345332,
0.381850034,
0.32558465,
0.3351534903,
-0.7181937099,
0.2253128886,
0.0402919874,
-0.5469617248,
-0.7205206156,
0.3669640422,
0.4205696881,
0.4634693861,
0.3258918822,
-0.1047498137,
-0.5762180686,
-0.4235494435,
-0.6285086274,
-0.1932621002,
0.169234097,
0.1860635728,
0.4575039744,
0.0407630987,
0.8552536368,
-0.557012856,
-0.2560069263,
0.0393893309,
0.3679753542,
0.3540673852,
0.4773017764,
-0.0586351566,
-0.864210248,
-0.3598683774,
0.2357316613,
-1.0686994791,
-0.0833905637,
-0.1169266552,
0.0209599547,
0.0900040641,
0.8841316104,
-0.5584850311,
0.1068149731,
0.5059808493,
-0.4066079557,
0.6833596826,
-0.4130522907,
0.2320828587,
-0.9202138186,
-0.0159571506,
-0.1170158014,
0.1769092977,
-0.4728427827,
0.1714485437,
0.1605120152,
0.242463693,
-0.1166901961,
0.4611219764,
-0.7355486751,
0.2692017257,
-0.0282737724,
0.2500814199,
0.1241284907,
0.6259013414,
-0.0925124511,
0.4713342488,
0.4998011589,
-0.3464512527,
0.4115990996,
0.2623353004,
-0.3556370735,
0.4206774831,
-0.3286690116,
0.3688067496,
-0.0802032053,
-0.2035557628,
-0.7232807875,
-0.2587479353,
0.0057662139,
-0.3507846296,
0.4932208061,
-0.3708994687,
-0.2659556866,
-0.3075390756,
-0.0532081202,
0.5631724,
0.5024381876,
-0.4647963941,
0.7818387747,
0.5512530208,
-0.1826187074,
-0.6049787998,
-0.2704150081,
0.0726794079,
-0.6702749729,
-0.6782178879,
-0.162680164,
-0.001225028,
-0.3263162076,
0.1067931578,
-0.4927464426,
-0.261660099,
0.0483800769,
0.1261583865,
0.0720595792,
-0.2341653407,
0.3589849174,
0.2814455926,
0.0399913006,
0.3096295893,
-0.1983501166,
0.1632587165,
-0.092590183,
-0.6982579231,
0.2452038974,
0.4466889203,
0.6389567852,
-0.4868037999,
0.691304028,
0.4097292125,
-0.2477111518,
-0.1032803878,
-0.9218985438,
0.162161991,
-0.4543304443,
0.0997259542,
-0.5537162423,
-1.2866690159,
0.6402055025,
-0.6952683926,
-0.0641749352,
0.3235433102,
0.2951096892,
-0.3266552389,
0.9755021334,
0.4020071924,
0.0205952134,
0.0227399338,
-0.0482782908,
0.5682065487,
-1.1917700768,
-0.5182398558,
-0.3968884051,
-0.1959307492,
-0.3324027359,
-0.5858196616,
0.3437268734,
1.1640655994,
-0.2869946659,
0.0712643489,
-0.1838788092,
0.6970224977,
0.5137028694,
-0.068276152,
0.6096699834,
-0.3988643885,
-0.6414654851,
0.1176469475,
-0.8476451039,
-0.5406707525,
1.0391800404,
0.2264180481,
0.9138717651,
0.2468555421,
0.5357400775,
-0.0299549159,
-0.1496676952,
-0.5090563893,
0.4928178191,
-0.0739548355,
-0.3382141888,
-0.3747126758,
-0.5114371181,
-1.1890940666,
0.3176641464,
-0.2580444217,
-0.894985497,
0.0716819987,
0.0508674532,
-0.0496865548,
0.724822402,
-0.6846785545,
0.7284873724,
-0.3627969623,
-0.2859098911,
-0.0994615257,
-0.6304899454,
0.8741955757,
-0.4514572918,
0.1543939114,
-0.0683467388,
0.2162907124,
0.8186956644,
-0.247398749,
0.7841005921,
0.2187813073,
-0.5270107985,
0.3042984903,
0.3460665345,
0.7307318449,
0.1637078822,
-0.0064695617,
0.2718426585,
0.0603961535,
-0.1301184744,
-0.6200794578,
0.6230381131,
-0.617451787,
-1.2189978361,
-0.2773918808,
-0.8192563057,
-0.5223738551,
0.213763535,
0.1348918676,
0.1913408935,
0.1372712553,
0.1384500116,
1.0409706831,
-0.2499793172,
0.1569549143,
0.7794132233,
-0.2271652669,
0.0226217434,
0.8545550108,
0.241876483,
0.1406085491,
0.1129659042,
0.2876278758,
-0.291978389,
-0.7496966124,
-0.2009293288,
0.3844587803,
-0.722546339,
-0.3524794579,
-0.4525243342,
-0.4481248558,
-0.2285076827,
-0.1247017682,
-0.1450232714,
-0.0168398637,
-0.2160878032,
-0.0008612336,
0.5642371774,
0.9418919683,
-0.1656003296,
-0.041200608,
-1.026009798,
0.2704693377,
0.5163196921,
0.5087066889,
0.0630905107,
-0.4170999825,
-0.3319242895,
-0.0143983858,
-0.1186177805,
-0.9234077334,
-0.1168558672,
-0.1858658642,
0.7098924518,
0.5668545961,
0.2774724662,
0.8843284845,
-0.1456369758,
0.5656137466,
0.2355811745,
-1.0231823921,
0.44178918,
-0.5326509476,
0.4688234627,
0.1416801363,
0.4403840601,
-0.815572381,
-0.8772042394,
-0.695466876,
-0.8273704648,
0.7877236605,
-0.1070128456,
-0.4777652621,
0.199114427,
0.3688147068,
-0.0384652726,
0.0025640314,
-0.2342814952,
0.0745129734,
0.4774620831,
-0.0279615913,
0.1548224986,
-0.4332866073,
-0.4754594266,
-0.3647074699,
0.6892866492,
-0.1125417575,
-0.1921085864,
0.0327058025,
-0.2123271078,
-0.5287643075,
0.1998113543,
0.4053860307,
0.7089987993,
-0.0392872393,
0.4264138937,
0.5070548654,
-0.2600152791,
0.1065299809,
-0.0030899041,
-0.0447921827,
-0.3136486113,
0.6333107352,
0.5602735281,
-0.0228067264,
-0.6064483523,
0.3954746127,
-0.0283396617,
-0.4123291075,
-0.014386788,
0.1215873882,
0.6581422091,
0.5978767872,
0.0643989518,
-0.0231133886,
-0.2668617666,
-0.0977447703,
0.1983128488,
0.4480610788,
-0.2903846502,
0.1156026497,
0.4122676253,
0.3381293714,
-0.2119495124,
0.6349146366,
-0.3939929903,
-0.5076360703,
0.4524868131,
0.2846413851,
0.4291816652,
-0.3094363809,
-0.0219195634,
0.3711535633,
0.375249505,
-0.1067713946,
0.1874780357,
0.0540407114,
-0.8459587097,
-0.5755845308,
-0.4242468178,
-0.2088633329,
0.404395014,
-0.7713899612,
-0.0343310758,
-0.2065667659,
0.1313399523,
-0.444475919,
0.1857679784,
-0.4068227708,
0.0542600155,
0.0546755493,
0.9078259468,
-0.5844190121,
0.9941523671,
0.5098074079,
-0.4797118604,
-1.1088792086,
0.0334770195,
0.3811882138,
-0.6999297738,
0.2876265645,
-0.3661015928,
-0.1587280184,
-0.2110516429,
-0.5202409029,
-0.9634891152,
1.0172326565,
0.4684777856,
-0.6059471369,
-0.0160865486,
0.2895959914,
0.3140514493,
-0.0899485722,
-0.0327840447,
0.8849069476,
0.4715053737,
0.3373808265,
-1.0398436785,
0.181363076,
-0.2330284566,
-0.1471807957,
0.5493193269,
-0.4530650377,
0.8558541536,
-0.3783812821,
-0.2191920131,
-0.2092656046,
0.424054563,
0.2744674683,
0.1753083915,
0.4853916764,
0.8004114628,
1.1458599567,
-0.1210028231,
0.4171637595,
-0.0952454209,
0.4881049395,
1.5175336599,
-0.2570806444,
0.6575348973,
0.662653625,
0.0571265481,
0.3032450676,
0.7430853844,
0.0956155732,
0.0437624939,
0.4303452075,
-0.2833579183,
-0.485551089,
-0.1128143668,
-0.4421475828,
0.5936018229,
0.3787995577,
-0.0935494676,
-0.4777063727,
-0.1493192613,
0.175920859,
0.0685255155,
-0.2978174388,
1.0331234932,
0.238844946,
-0.8526269197,
0.6628521681,
-0.131835714,
0.3043566346,
-0.7372613549,
-0.2328866273,
-0.2761547863,
0.0835924298,
-0.2891963422,
-1.1992855072,
0.2749566436,
0.1625417918,
0.1590253562,
-0.1055455804,
0.8723635674,
-0.9208626151,
-0.2156756222,
0.5648265481,
0.6683170795,
0.1959770471,
0.0855253637,
-0.7047540545,
0.0087682921,
0.077879332,
-0.2405682653,
0.3690722883,
1.0805305243,
-0.0981298983,
0.7628877759,
0.6179045439,
0.1109380871,
0.0663620606,
0.0005146242,
1.0193115473,
-0.6733099818,
-0.1569684595,
-0.6762728691,
0.6573441029,
-0.1907893717,
-0.3532016575,
0.8435377479,
0.4449381828,
0.9193657041,
0.1159747168,
0.5280073285,
0.0104594892,
0.3257921636,
-0.842250526,
0.6170138717,
-0.7269312739,
0.4104833305,
-0.1906356215,
-0.3920825422,
-0.089048177,
0.1909270138,
-0.3499836028,
-0.1552410573,
0.9099577069,
0.7187290192,
0.0333866775,
0.2005374581,
0.3720169961,
0.2081886232,
0.2802227139,
0.8546469212,
0.9960800409,
-0.1299476326,
0.6677321792,
0.0918346271,
-0.0538241379,
-0.0688039586,
-0.8907824755,
-0.9802376032,
-0.7466303706,
-0.3276191652,
-0.1749827564,
-0.1140197143,
0.7117431164,
0.3236155808,
-0.4898540378,
-0.4693650603,
-0.0659055337,
0.6440804601,
-0.2025759965,
-0.1533253938,
0.347417891,
-0.4832410216,
-0.4365908206,
0.3005438149,
0.2002264559,
-0.1260229945,
-0.0589515492,
-0.256118983,
-0.70356673,
0.0580177307,
0.3696713448,
0.2097090185,
-0.8590977788,
-0.2023557723,
-0.4330291748,
0.0774728209,
-0.0118221883,
1.0785632133,
-0.3159334362,
0.6404055357,
0.5706467032,
0.7491468787,
0.4962451756,
-0.1023314148,
0.7290461659,
-0.6079691648,
-0.2970141768,
0.0071865735,
0.4759396315,
0.060177777,
-0.4665252566,
0.5857136846,
-0.0137791941,
-0.64088732,
-0.52734375,
0.2572248876,
-0.9477787614,
-0.6810982823,
1.1723188162,
-0.3270272911,
-0.0122747822,
-0.5297617912,
-0.3065196872,
0.6488320231,
-0.1446889788,
0.851308763,
0.918851614,
-0.1615502089,
-0.144093588,
-0.3043049276,
0.7455902696,
0.2937873304,
-0.7972954512,
0.2834860981,
0.0782221407,
0.2318824828,
0.0187604297,
0.4125770032,
-0.1046481729,
-0.037015669,
-0.0789975524,
-0.1838779002,
-0.1577862501,
-0.1403886527,
-0.5446602106,
0.1525361538,
0.2937891781,
0.2028101236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03565v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03565v2
|
Personalized LLM Response Generation with Parameterized Memory Injection
| 2024-04-04T16:20:34 | 2024-06-11T10:47:02 |
Kai Zhang, Lizhi Qing, Yangyang Kang, Xiaozhong Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable proficiency in
comprehending and generating natural language. On the other hand, personalized
LLM response generation holds the potential to offer substantial benefits for
individuals in critical areas such as medical. Existing research has explored
memory-augmented methods to prompt the LLM with pre-stored user-specific
knowledge for personalized response generation in terms of new queries. We
contend that such paradigm is unable to perceive fine-granularity information.
In this study, we propose a novel \textbf{M}emory-\textbf{i}njected approach
using parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) and along with a Bayesian
Optimisation searching strategy to achieve \textbf{L}LM
\textbf{P}ersonalization(\textbf{MiLP}).
|
[
-0.583470583,
-1.2584731579,
0.8270198107,
-0.1019422933,
-0.1139412671,
-0.0600406714,
-0.3165123761,
-0.1873519868,
0.4805587828,
0.588973999,
-0.3866036832,
-0.4257060587,
-0.2207586467,
0.0371349603,
0.0407619029,
0.8029478192,
0.0564603843,
0.1369540989,
0.1269558966,
0.2054225355,
-0.2464470267,
-0.6607009172,
-0.7560995817,
-0.3333842754,
0.8513066173,
0.3489825726,
0.1320809722,
0.3694264591,
0.5218871236,
0.2047741711,
-0.1956633329,
0.5161814094,
-0.3016110659,
0.100112088,
-0.3331483603,
-0.2363444418,
-0.6116023064,
-0.2545423806,
0.6847788692,
1.0378195047,
-0.2935633361,
0.0928059742,
0.1228472739,
0.6822149158,
-0.7766842246,
-0.2684999704,
-0.8038473129,
0.1598962098,
-0.0730220452,
-0.6561382413,
-0.532402277,
-0.2248817533,
0.3085054457,
-0.3376493454,
0.2443744391,
0.3818010986,
0.8000420332,
-0.0916339681,
-0.2403626442,
-0.1907820404,
-0.8878750205,
0.6490611434,
-0.7951378822,
0.2492771298,
0.4236126244,
0.2517304122,
-0.488191992,
-0.6291923523,
-0.4058327973,
-0.3573881388,
0.0227665827,
0.1539658159,
0.0137166362,
0.3900995851,
-0.0370707922,
0.1031786948,
-0.4682242572,
0.0715584457,
-0.0161549877,
0.0033203051,
0.3155017495,
0.4937467575,
0.0561125837,
-0.1647465974,
-0.2494326085,
0.3573881388,
-0.5912082195,
-0.0732127279,
0.4043430686,
0.5215885639,
0.1556229442,
0.560485661,
-0.5382681489,
0.9360449314,
0.5358955264,
-0.1530146748,
-0.0573370606,
-0.1201274991,
-0.4971977174,
-0.098981522,
0.9296118021,
0.070602484,
0.2013647258,
-0.1851669401,
-0.1295240968,
-0.6118399501,
0.2570405304,
-0.9322039485,
-0.1255276948,
0.3540797234,
-0.533968091,
-0.4083753824,
0.0301231071,
-0.5983033776,
-0.1570022106,
-0.1179922,
0.5025773644,
-0.5820206404,
0.0735322237,
0.3935459256,
0.2255467027,
-0.0624606535,
0.2333682925,
-1.1790707111,
0.1309020966,
0.1846369207,
0.5580114722,
0.0219161008,
-0.138189137,
-0.5486292839,
0.6216192245,
-0.0982646421,
1.007951498,
-0.7150637507,
-0.2152620554,
0.0816904455,
-0.2904815674,
0.0575812384,
-0.8970248699,
0.1687121093,
-0.4304479957,
0.0173828788,
-0.3519920409,
-0.3080002964,
0.1030735299,
0.2922581434,
-0.1394379884,
0.5796673894,
0.1811834276,
-0.6440433264,
0.4142760038,
-0.4301863611,
-0.2696673274,
0.1989096552,
-0.545412302,
-0.4177439511,
0.3710112274,
0.5418151021,
0.8336783051,
-0.2939698398,
0.3870621026,
-0.5353419781,
-0.2841535211,
0.485770613,
-0.3223189414,
0.0126505187,
0.3634428084,
-0.0266772024,
-0.0322548226,
-0.8240855932,
0.2127969712,
0.2032495737,
-0.8553287983,
-0.3186737001,
0.0479815267,
-0.2588524222,
-0.2231340855,
0.4858821929,
-0.3655779064,
0.24177894,
-0.628207922,
0.219496578,
0.7561954856,
0.2912865281,
0.3781301677,
-0.4091244936,
0.3692472875,
0.2995536923,
-0.1269225925,
-0.1998604387,
-0.0893742368,
-0.4440399706,
-0.2684306204,
0.1891137958,
0.4830796421,
-0.3845065534,
0.5816991329,
-0.0963446572,
-0.0421596654,
-0.2268888056,
-0.0025461626,
0.3677973151,
0.8630921841,
0.4428656995,
-0.0054003759,
-0.5319187045,
-1.1516802311,
-0.4734010696,
-0.2663410902,
-0.4599702358,
1.0131013393,
-0.0768414587,
-0.3221315742,
0.7193368673,
-0.8196112514,
-0.2225931287,
-0.2727424204,
0.0750111565,
0.324378103,
0.3823764324,
0.19492805,
-0.3175576031,
-0.3310557604,
0.1870764643,
-0.4531596899,
-0.4845856428,
-0.3326480985,
-0.1943668574,
-0.0514267385,
0.2432271242,
-0.4030790627,
0.1989837438,
0.0698288754,
-0.2455975115,
0.4298120737,
-0.575124383,
0.483563751,
-1.2516471148,
0.2003746033,
-0.0126869306,
-0.1418356597,
-0.5823757648,
0.2061095983,
0.0913759843,
0.0254945401,
-0.4739816487,
0.5038757324,
-0.4981087148,
0.1376767009,
-0.2643285394,
-0.0578343607,
-0.2328044027,
0.281904459,
-0.1536707282,
0.6385531425,
0.2064041048,
-0.7930069566,
-0.0910123438,
0.1957276464,
-0.0163311157,
0.6226897836,
-0.6236314178,
0.2339721918,
-0.3616664708,
0.1339602023,
-0.780862987,
-0.5501235723,
0.3232246339,
-0.3059232533,
0.361136198,
-0.1732293665,
-0.3402442038,
-0.1540480703,
-0.1302895844,
0.441486299,
0.5305914879,
-0.5604807138,
0.6947287321,
0.2456898242,
-0.2052094787,
-0.2178514004,
-0.5517123938,
0.0512199551,
-0.3469266891,
-0.6138327122,
0.4130520225,
-0.314658016,
-0.1885793805,
-0.4514572918,
0.0573680811,
-0.0229468886,
-0.0955798328,
0.0427192152,
0.0179736651,
-0.1395216584,
-0.0079046413,
0.5594284534,
0.0328929015,
-0.1969497949,
0.0231965743,
0.8667556047,
0.0265405439,
-0.3215362728,
-0.4453943372,
0.5701718926,
0.105437316,
-0.093632251,
0.6273262501,
0.5957828164,
-0.3892553747,
-0.063221246,
-0.7999345064,
-0.4362252355,
-0.5124469399,
0.3385977447,
-0.5507878065,
-0.984139204,
0.500297308,
-0.4051051736,
-0.2948136032,
-0.057889387,
0.8672057986,
-0.2337280363,
1.3287103176,
0.1309686303,
0.2302768081,
0.4732536972,
0.0262135342,
0.1931631714,
-1.1052132845,
-0.2514317334,
-0.331948787,
-0.4527815878,
-0.252006501,
-0.228448391,
0.4861716628,
0.2766496539,
-0.3526530862,
-0.1672805995,
-0.5380956531,
0.4448508322,
0.3976956904,
0.5147233605,
0.1849306077,
0.222958073,
-0.3581922054,
-0.12909244,
-0.4374148548,
-0.462431401,
1.2115322351,
0.3155777752,
1.1452587843,
0.0847184509,
1.0316457748,
-0.2021349669,
-0.1236281171,
-0.6712294221,
0.7555239201,
-0.1935921162,
-0.2656198144,
-0.0472387895,
-0.493553251,
-1.1343626976,
0.080784373,
-0.2773525119,
-1.0272083282,
0.0339674465,
0.3226903677,
-0.9546380043,
0.1480637789,
-0.7164596319,
0.1092215851,
-0.1012293547,
-0.4031668603,
-0.0402165651,
-0.4470344484,
0.17739968,
-0.2344129384,
-0.1057280898,
-0.2112498432,
-0.334785074,
0.450691849,
-0.3359804749,
0.5662729144,
-0.2142823189,
0.2606053948,
-0.2266646475,
0.1009813845,
0.6845216155,
0.5466623306,
0.0356324688,
-0.2105154693,
-0.1093342304,
-0.4285589755,
-0.4179168046,
1.005241394,
-0.4434143007,
-0.7664144635,
-0.1134488657,
-0.7302700877,
-0.4828109443,
0.3162710071,
0.2360631824,
0.1764980406,
-0.0942599252,
-0.0526009537,
0.918451488,
-0.5740932226,
0.2449377924,
0.8662341833,
-0.2670714855,
-0.4504454434,
0.5896495581,
0.131847918,
0.0447228476,
0.6298902631,
0.5436721444,
0.0701521635,
-1.1138801575,
-0.2136015445,
0.3171855211,
-0.0557644479,
-0.178339079,
-0.8293717504,
0.0350010172,
-0.3635479808,
-0.3289442658,
-0.1340040565,
0.0772243217,
-0.6280287504,
0.1292916983,
0.1664040983,
0.3634139299,
0.0600991286,
0.5339855552,
-0.7993833423,
0.5232650042,
0.2935731709,
0.3735131919,
-0.2251596302,
-0.4793897867,
-0.1645799875,
0.1321338713,
-0.261819452,
-0.9284537435,
0.5681480765,
0.2649496496,
0.394587785,
0.4713788331,
-0.0376117863,
1.0932935476,
-0.8455737233,
0.5324752927,
0.0604702868,
-0.5036703348,
0.9325460196,
-0.4876461625,
0.4636739194,
0.5195220113,
0.2776975036,
-0.1108388007,
-0.4262066185,
-0.4834513068,
-1.1053105593,
0.3709607422,
-0.1959562302,
0.4213185906,
-0.3397782445,
0.9016361237,
0.0734296814,
0.130194217,
-0.1105184332,
-0.1049373001,
0.7414198518,
-0.0831236616,
0.283451438,
-0.5097632408,
-0.1289562285,
-0.2957128882,
0.5100951791,
-0.2895965874,
0.512169838,
0.4425752163,
0.1933580637,
-0.2694454491,
0.2650839984,
0.4520174265,
0.684414804,
-0.5953678489,
0.02431692,
0.2492614537,
-0.4285576046,
-0.015181181,
0.0589207336,
-0.2364926487,
-0.1136994585,
-0.0926868841,
0.4463388324,
0.1001086235,
-0.7566910386,
0.1904604137,
-0.1299258322,
-0.1896940768,
-0.5133499503,
0.1379951984,
0.0920727029,
0.3975358903,
0.4447744787,
-0.2424709648,
0.2946622372,
-0.2677366436,
0.250675261,
0.7666404247,
-0.0009213903,
-0.2138387561,
0.8178107142,
-0.031123748,
-0.3504694998,
0.3495505452,
0.0947339088,
0.1291987747,
-0.0632133856,
0.7867509723,
0.7678127885,
-0.2692308128,
-0.011592011,
0.3936499953,
-0.2506513,
0.1791595221,
0.647677362,
0.2089227736,
-0.6832770109,
-0.3135935068,
-0.811668098,
-0.0767895579,
0.4514466822,
-0.7228013873,
0.2513700128,
-0.9218418598,
-0.3309068978,
0.1109473258,
-0.1518758088,
-0.5539494753,
0.2291131318,
-0.0363220684,
0.656701982,
-0.403075695,
0.9053623676,
0.8885261416,
-0.3889517486,
-0.8929536939,
0.235659346,
-0.4320379198,
-0.8790320158,
0.6156609058,
-0.2666604817,
0.1342088431,
0.0977508202,
-0.3930460811,
-0.55231601,
1.0195879936,
0.5995944738,
-0.8208981156,
-0.2275190353,
0.1020292789,
0.3126516938,
-0.4780756533,
0.2835178971,
0.6598017216,
0.2308830172,
0.0091365548,
-0.7664054036,
0.0599267483,
0.0584555753,
0.3650538027,
0.5394448042,
-0.5831953883,
0.7936167121,
-0.316554755,
0.1345815361,
0.2236932367,
0.5190107226,
0.5847251415,
0.1693501472,
0.1806204468,
0.5930733085,
0.6210222244,
0.2207169086,
0.8990440369,
-0.371571064,
0.275225848,
1.0896525383,
-0.0121479593,
0.9970298409,
0.955996573,
-0.3469873071,
0.190039739,
0.5414135456,
0.2841405272,
0.5306042433,
0.3097900748,
-0.6361202598,
-0.2494821399,
-0.0752022415,
-0.2883986533,
0.179586947,
0.3157434165,
-0.8372075558,
-0.0185576435,
-0.1110058129,
0.1280436516,
0.1097470224,
-0.2667026222,
0.9019576311,
0.0089269346,
-0.5204735994,
0.7486050129,
0.1221806109,
0.7819641232,
-0.6476821303,
0.0428802632,
-0.4051168561,
0.1095972955,
-0.1854172349,
-0.451487422,
0.149036631,
-0.1973699033,
-0.2898489237,
-0.1016502157,
0.7957399487,
-0.496724695,
-0.3700323999,
0.009034507,
0.6082131863,
0.1238514632,
-0.0966036394,
-0.6339710951,
-0.1037136838,
-0.0110082477,
-0.5603487492,
0.834140718,
0.1432381123,
0.3387798071,
0.7743990421,
0.720366776,
0.4976889193,
-0.0545531549,
0.0576633401,
0.7512083054,
-0.6833513379,
-0.3569319248,
-0.9412018657,
0.3475221097,
0.2023605853,
-0.1723392159,
0.3878890276,
0.5149488449,
0.5170145035,
-0.285947144,
0.7800008059,
-0.0369440578,
0.6143947244,
-0.6853843331,
0.6568371654,
-0.6010289192,
0.5313423276,
-0.2927811444,
-0.6740050912,
-0.3030641973,
0.553303957,
-0.3160378337,
0.210744068,
0.5614656806,
0.9373354912,
-0.1446330249,
-0.4726374149,
0.6830856204,
0.2466499805,
0.4036294818,
0.8367835283,
0.573941648,
-0.0561866239,
0.3249092996,
-0.2006073147,
-0.2876136601,
-0.3485820293,
-0.7963950634,
-0.9127982259,
-0.5203180313,
-0.1185387373,
-0.3515975177,
0.1863612235,
1.1206042767,
0.5244938731,
-0.776473105,
-0.0977268219,
-0.1101129726,
-0.4199428558,
0.1962294281,
-0.2088669091,
0.1976984441,
-0.3588418663,
-0.7946614027,
0.4390654862,
0.579138577,
0.263731122,
-0.3524609804,
-0.1159935594,
-0.1737687886,
0.3590213656,
0.5168981552,
0.1260892004,
-0.8028212786,
-0.4124988317,
-0.0393018462,
0.0640103966,
0.1986726224,
0.8602348566,
-0.9259223938,
0.3715986311,
0.5901380181,
0.7347147465,
0.3856791556,
-0.0087347096,
0.6673944592,
-0.683251977,
0.0482926071,
0.4803782701,
0.4828590751,
-0.0317196809,
-0.7318318486,
0.149717316,
-0.0610367991,
-0.7781790495,
-0.7945953012,
0.4605905116,
-1.0957063437,
-0.2344554216,
1.2399519682,
-0.1224471927,
-0.168886885,
-0.0133745577,
-0.4355685711,
-0.0056266147,
-0.5257271528,
0.8296681046,
0.2636921704,
-0.7097840309,
-0.0765352696,
-0.5088629723,
0.1002266183,
0.667910099,
-0.794834733,
-0.1394917667,
0.4739144742,
0.4665936232,
-0.2348431945,
0.8236066103,
0.0806832239,
0.1055577919,
-0.4243091941,
-0.256118685,
-0.1660729647,
-0.0692051873,
-0.1897729039,
0.3232957423,
0.4305979609,
0.0148884626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03563v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03563v2
|
EASSE-DE: Easier Automatic Sentence Simplification Evaluation for German
| 2024-04-04T16:18:37 | 2024-04-05T08:55:20 |
Regina Stodden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we propose EASSE-multi, a framework for easier automatic
sentence evaluation for languages other than English. Compared to the original
EASSE framework, EASSE-multi does not focus only on English. It contains
tokenizers and versions of text simplification evaluation metrics which are
suitable for multiple languages. In this paper, we exemplify the usage of
EASSE-multi for German TS, resulting in EASSE-DE. Further, we compare text
simplification results when evaluating with different language or tokenization
settings of the metrics. Based on this, we formulate recommendations on how to
make the evaluation of (German) TS models more transparent and better
comparable. The code of EASSE-multi and its German specialisation (EASSE-DE)
can be found at https://github.com/rstodden/easse-de.
|
[
-0.3161413968,
-0.9234433174,
0.7578562498,
0.56555444,
-0.2894048095,
-0.0281656478,
-0.1988198757,
-0.3843532503,
0.2235879451,
-0.173289448,
-0.6466498971,
-0.5820189118,
-0.8202009201,
0.7554903626,
-0.4097676873,
0.7949692011,
-0.4914135337,
0.3206688762,
0.0232598782,
-0.2297006398,
0.0156396423,
-0.3894456029,
-0.8038480878,
-0.0387198217,
0.3920910358,
0.387643218,
0.4548565745,
0.4816001356,
0.6215494275,
0.4782807231,
-0.2063738853,
0.2209190577,
-0.1057992801,
0.0322574712,
0.1389670968,
0.1787231266,
-0.6068788767,
-0.3822745979,
0.2889108658,
0.6506803632,
0.0555228479,
0.1724259853,
-0.0890330896,
0.6566249728,
-0.6580482125,
0.3298346102,
0.0685974881,
-0.0842732191,
0.181947127,
0.0921497717,
-0.3359516561,
-0.4162482023,
0.0587119572,
-0.4384782314,
-0.0050308127,
-0.1711965203,
0.7448095679,
0.1238848567,
-1.1099491119,
-0.2077574283,
-0.6002973318,
0.6445609331,
-0.4467302263,
0.8286350369,
-0.125528574,
0.2212676555,
0.397636503,
-0.9652612209,
-0.2543228567,
-0.32495749,
-0.3736662567,
0.0613426715,
-0.5026111603,
0.2234290093,
0.2899029553,
0.2325377017,
-0.5747234225,
-0.0737729073,
-0.5047883391,
-0.4561865926,
0.611394465,
0.0081207706,
0.26620996,
-0.2208760232,
-0.2057087421,
0.0899773017,
-0.3648370206,
-0.1128268689,
0.3221005797,
0.141073972,
-0.1733543724,
0.4767386615,
-0.5329713821,
0.4969721437,
-0.0318402387,
0.0995859057,
0.6940865517,
-0.3655838966,
-0.2295610458,
-0.0547826588,
0.7159349322,
0.4261498749,
0.3269596398,
-0.2660016716,
-0.2440154552,
0.1597767174,
-0.2300471812,
-0.9695331454,
-0.1114658713,
0.1024813205,
-0.6172818542,
0.023090167,
0.5249552131,
-0.3837378025,
0.3094840646,
-0.3172367513,
0.3024331927,
-0.3856292963,
0.0011974019,
0.455226779,
-0.2880572677,
-0.1302759945,
0.5126141906,
-0.2077911794,
0.4110933244,
0.5469062328,
0.735008955,
-0.1653381735,
-0.6779853702,
-0.8180029988,
0.2769287229,
-0.0253686924,
0.8340401649,
-0.4106458127,
-0.3575741947,
-0.2439411432,
0.1710947156,
0.126757741,
0.0090231178,
0.9716746211,
-0.113624841,
0.5182961822,
-0.2212456912,
-0.6603643298,
-0.4319631457,
-0.1166777164,
-0.9166170955,
0.9521142244,
0.0155883711,
-0.8290398121,
0.4652673006,
-1.1326687336,
-0.7824226022,
-0.0995069072,
0.1059945151,
-0.3397260308,
0.3475878239,
0.6000063419,
0.3203023076,
-0.1194786206,
0.2079918087,
-0.1917651445,
-0.4379118979,
-0.3532373905,
-0.5524091721,
1.0188888311,
0.3765628338,
-0.4925758243,
0.1982698739,
-0.6478279829,
0.4038739204,
-0.2243598849,
-0.2274249345,
-0.4766634405,
-0.4378076494,
0.4502417147,
0.3179268837,
0.1398143023,
-0.5502281785,
-0.2003915757,
-0.4101191759,
0.486897707,
0.4886521995,
0.1990763396,
0.497829169,
-0.1826674789,
0.6425764561,
-0.023945149,
0.1495117098,
-0.3775494099,
-0.3809707463,
-0.872525692,
-0.6921178699,
0.6969709396,
0.6622447968,
-0.4283876121,
0.6813187003,
-0.3032402694,
-0.4959298968,
-0.6953682899,
0.0784344226,
0.4438064992,
0.0940320939,
0.3043211102,
0.0007975659,
-0.6883273721,
-1.2636328936,
-0.5313420296,
-0.1450771838,
0.0642070025,
-0.1834184229,
0.6855561137,
-0.259074837,
0.6254827976,
-0.3817101717,
-0.1545894891,
-0.4153955579,
0.2084787488,
-0.3213230371,
0.2400646359,
0.6281960011,
-0.7681123614,
-0.8731068373,
-0.2095609754,
-0.6526500583,
-0.4947105646,
0.1072780639,
0.1235998347,
0.3438089788,
0.7592867613,
-0.4688512981,
0.4630883038,
0.4401265085,
-0.618996501,
0.2101663947,
-0.3070488274,
0.6560127139,
-0.8966374397,
0.1061599255,
-0.0101422407,
-0.6666574478,
-0.5981072187,
0.3784033954,
0.4742596149,
0.0980817899,
-0.7677627206,
0.7542238832,
-0.6164807677,
0.1953970343,
0.2847933471,
0.0774433538,
0.4030365646,
0.1890474707,
-0.0314838476,
0.6546846628,
0.5826156139,
-0.554024756,
0.2003930211,
0.2507237196,
-0.3523021638,
0.52044487,
-0.7925135493,
0.0010768534,
-0.2469172627,
0.3028894663,
-0.6774725318,
0.0996807143,
-0.1609844416,
-0.0622654743,
0.0184696466,
0.286200732,
-0.6512378454,
-0.2539016604,
-0.5837399364,
0.3581803441,
0.1516682059,
-0.5279099941,
0.7399107218,
0.1923374534,
-0.3093457818,
-0.3291995823,
-0.972631216,
0.248940289,
-0.4514775574,
-0.9107567668,
0.4923590422,
-0.353510201,
-0.5890310407,
0.1114187539,
-0.0656372011,
-0.0721850246,
0.2036862373,
-0.1554953307,
-0.1061283648,
-0.1337525696,
0.1112211496,
0.5055416226,
-0.3860096335,
-0.3849045634,
0.1641471237,
0.2714733183,
-0.5973777175,
-0.6261670589,
-0.5301216841,
0.9821608067,
0.3667448163,
-0.1482553333,
0.4374473691,
0.6631772518,
-0.279689759,
-0.1629384309,
-0.5925268531,
-0.2204430252,
-0.493001312,
0.5007748008,
-0.7764492631,
-0.8220419884,
0.3899421394,
-0.1447934806,
0.0950807631,
0.8172088265,
0.4594564736,
0.0684957802,
1.285427928,
0.9755946994,
0.2449399382,
0.1810038239,
-0.0628359467,
0.3758099973,
-0.1993483901,
-0.0848240107,
-0.6491037011,
-0.0935268626,
-0.3693716228,
0.0349362344,
0.4331848919,
0.1597323567,
-0.3627991378,
0.4948854148,
-0.2348771542,
0.5796115398,
0.2702237666,
-0.0587020926,
0.8286401033,
0.0779560059,
-0.2426219285,
-0.2540311217,
-0.6888362169,
-0.7866284251,
0.7715811133,
0.3586985171,
0.3882724345,
0.3043916523,
1.1886488199,
0.3476347625,
0.1035601124,
-0.7609057426,
0.5851386189,
-0.3962876201,
-0.2275668383,
-0.2875635028,
-0.5736974478,
-0.7070733309,
0.2740660906,
0.0923888087,
-0.53170228,
-0.0757358521,
-0.2575287819,
-0.238074705,
0.0437340513,
-1.3917015791,
0.8672615886,
-0.2732096314,
0.2047464848,
-0.1856647432,
-0.3558164537,
0.1462086141,
-0.2744812965,
0.5437431931,
0.0553126447,
-0.475571692,
0.6467479467,
-0.5829788446,
0.5781886578,
-0.0172793716,
-0.1580336541,
0.0655003041,
0.2296520919,
0.4537574947,
0.1769859195,
-0.2681539655,
0.1530789435,
0.1093983874,
-0.0705721155,
-0.4221212268,
0.7753537297,
-0.4261060357,
-0.5332047343,
-0.2168107033,
-0.3254781365,
-0.0539766885,
0.3557296097,
0.2589688301,
0.3823035657,
-0.6830454469,
-0.0056572142,
0.06465514,
-0.176325053,
0.673220098,
0.7826709151,
-0.3040000796,
-0.3124164641,
0.3726028204,
0.0282322671,
0.1583533883,
0.3121893108,
0.1754619181,
-0.4660426378,
-0.0125004668,
-0.6490687132,
0.1282761246,
-1.1123936176,
-0.2656243742,
-1.0769212246,
0.0005676,
-0.4530239701,
-0.3838360012,
-0.0336704887,
-1.1205832958,
0.1592162848,
-0.566888988,
0.5226588249,
0.7419679165,
-0.2530709207,
0.2069673687,
-0.7607345581,
0.4691323936,
0.0628904253,
0.3216445744,
-0.3620760441,
-0.3732589483,
0.0380119495,
-0.0610682853,
-0.1791700572,
-1.0372736454,
0.0899226293,
0.5343731046,
0.5753074288,
0.2193660587,
-0.0547556207,
0.8642683029,
-0.7241124511,
0.4863115847,
0.2717778087,
-1.5227944851,
0.3270136416,
0.0906604826,
0.5839549899,
0.7823594213,
0.1914311051,
-0.7242336273,
-0.7674424052,
-0.8846110106,
-1.1773350239,
0.5955322981,
0.3087468147,
0.2098554969,
-0.1389906704,
-0.0262550209,
0.3575285375,
0.2366461307,
-0.9143115878,
-0.6091520786,
0.0688448399,
-0.3429366946,
-0.1086487994,
-0.2195077688,
-0.0124646397,
-0.3105515838,
0.7432006001,
0.1675569415,
0.158341065,
0.1238020658,
-0.4150567353,
-0.0474623963,
0.5560252666,
0.2092698663,
0.5887246728,
0.2451643944,
0.0364145301,
0.5796720982,
-0.0639293566,
0.2660804987,
0.2593385577,
-0.5432866216,
0.6553939581,
0.5534205437,
0.7140737176,
0.1163257062,
-0.6211579442,
0.7590290308,
-0.1479369402,
-0.4514509141,
-0.0755356699,
-0.3452472985,
0.0760871544,
0.1470953226,
0.1591055244,
0.0460118391,
0.6244962811,
-0.4622215629,
0.5417894125,
0.0626172274,
-0.0453431681,
-0.0247512497,
0.4376595318,
0.4031767547,
-0.4587006271,
0.0722109601,
-0.5427604914,
-0.7238259315,
0.5872404575,
0.3562330902,
1.1186438799,
-0.4517816901,
0.4578451216,
0.3973223865,
0.5435627103,
-0.2315745056,
0.7504706979,
0.1515058279,
-0.1180749387,
-0.6540935636,
-0.4111663401,
-0.0489212573,
-0.2288708091,
-0.4751080871,
0.7819890976,
0.0228169933,
-0.1033506617,
-0.0216012634,
-0.2759020925,
-0.964030087,
0.0955896005,
-0.0286297034,
1.1623984575,
-1.1713478565,
0.5897657275,
0.8467407227,
-0.3543505371,
-0.7136561275,
0.1298927963,
0.1160384417,
-0.2328404933,
0.7408744097,
0.3657427728,
-0.4505745173,
-0.0658672601,
0.1048867404,
-0.800224483,
0.859056592,
0.5862218142,
-0.4704767764,
-0.1625581086,
0.1123546064,
0.6877888441,
-0.340267837,
0.6292343736,
0.4327222407,
0.9586902857,
-0.459122926,
-1.3270074129,
0.04515725,
-0.2227430642,
-0.2899697423,
0.3694117367,
-0.5475588441,
0.6818732023,
-0.1683561504,
-0.4721102417,
-0.0951693952,
0.4196676314,
-0.155358538,
0.1469434053,
0.6697537303,
0.4979746938,
0.6390919685,
-0.2157317698,
0.8419561386,
-0.3534945846,
0.4191399813,
1.074996829,
-0.1641427279,
0.6357643604,
0.483438015,
-0.107051976,
0.5671275258,
0.3609812558,
0.0829502642,
0.5938947201,
0.0227502193,
-0.058127135,
-0.1575425863,
0.2678347826,
-0.236982733,
0.5792446136,
-0.0180908386,
-0.244042173,
-0.8157618642,
0.1887981594,
0.0773278996,
0.1689186543,
-0.2281683385,
0.8947843313,
0.157201767,
-0.3675116301,
0.28919819,
0.6024141908,
0.6244372129,
-0.5996004939,
0.1662750691,
-0.1762375832,
0.0509552509,
-0.3976442814,
-0.4927551448,
0.6675999165,
0.3551574051,
0.0735453293,
-0.4834105074,
0.382012248,
-0.5147376657,
-0.9322623014,
0.6260460019,
1.3036160469,
0.0820522904,
0.0945165604,
-0.9297759533,
-0.0614523925,
0.1381729245,
-0.4726016819,
-0.2072739005,
0.8466482162,
-0.2321898788,
0.6859736443,
0.1106761098,
-0.1085078865,
-0.1288942695,
0.432806164,
0.6093612909,
-0.5150185823,
-0.9743044376,
-1.0130478144,
0.5701552033,
-0.2197056413,
-0.1350539178,
1.0621227026,
0.9930220842,
0.934886992,
-0.1015904322,
0.895780921,
-0.2448349744,
0.5882472992,
-0.4632444382,
0.557908237,
-0.7280404568,
0.3258167207,
-0.6510577798,
-1.0259032249,
-0.4481776059,
0.7316207886,
-0.1710782498,
0.3412742317,
1.3489222527,
0.631529808,
-0.4680521786,
-0.0075050923,
0.2863985598,
0.0339997262,
-0.0048944862,
0.2913864851,
0.5315557122,
-0.5575367808,
0.791683495,
-0.4001289904,
-0.1093294546,
0.2096210271,
-1.2388677597,
-0.7862095833,
-0.7002878189,
-0.6043556929,
-0.055662103,
-0.0095151393,
1.128029108,
0.4484137297,
-0.9233937263,
-0.1192809418,
0.0535290129,
-0.0786719844,
-0.3456770778,
-0.1737996042,
0.690725863,
-0.2821249962,
-1.1145218611,
0.3549066484,
0.3416142464,
0.0623622462,
0.0209057909,
-0.118608892,
0.0583762005,
0.0506067164,
0.7089296579,
-0.3448940217,
-0.6711848974,
-0.2232944816,
-0.048184555,
-0.2444644272,
-0.0370859988,
0.9762984514,
-0.5132570267,
0.2414721102,
0.4055718184,
0.2417249382,
0.4047950506,
-0.1293404698,
0.7820416093,
-0.7722806334,
0.4384827614,
0.0400991142,
0.8142460585,
0.3865742981,
-0.294659555,
0.6306074262,
-0.2424494028,
-0.1016815454,
-0.6870208383,
0.3514797986,
-0.5636275411,
-0.5466672182,
1.3739106655,
-0.2090250105,
0.1047919318,
-0.3518958688,
-0.5162594318,
0.1128316522,
-0.5774248838,
0.5937973857,
0.8711547256,
0.1828480214,
-0.111035645,
-0.4502517879,
0.7200114727,
0.5378136039,
-0.8767052293,
0.0048420578,
0.7015391588,
0.3284572959,
-0.1919203103,
0.6476806998,
-0.1268688589,
0.4266676605,
-0.3225943446,
-0.1871390492,
-0.3455909491,
-0.3471705914,
-0.5960499048,
0.1042796448,
-0.0816346854,
0.345216006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03561v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03561v1
|
Select and Summarize: Scene Saliency for Movie Script Summarization
| 2024-04-04T16:16:53 | 2024-04-04T16:16:53 |
Rohit Saxena, Frank Keller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Abstractive summarization for long-form narrative texts such as movie scripts
is challenging due to the computational and memory constraints of current
language models. A movie script typically comprises a large number of scenes;
however, only a fraction of these scenes are salient, i.e., important for
understanding the overall narrative. The salience of a scene can be
operationalized by considering it as salient if it is mentioned in the summary.
Automatically identifying salient scenes is difficult due to the lack of
suitable datasets. In this work, we introduce a scene saliency dataset that
consists of human-annotated salient scenes for 100 movies. We propose a
two-stage abstractive summarization approach which first identifies the salient
scenes in script and then generates a summary using only those scenes. Using
QA-based evaluation, we show that our model outperforms previous
state-of-the-art summarization methods and reflects the information content of
a movie more accurately than a model that takes the whole movie script as
input.
|
[
-0.3615728319,
-0.3205120862,
0.7074094415,
0.2336654067,
-0.6291235685,
-0.0485407189,
0.0812318027,
-0.6221393943,
0.3059917092,
0.5313750505,
-0.597882092,
-0.6327069402,
-0.4728487134,
0.1938113272,
-0.8333930969,
1.291703701,
0.2391983569,
-0.3063471317,
-0.2726689577,
-0.0214548316,
-0.0951856002,
-0.2424457371,
-0.3339598477,
0.2655442953,
0.5573818684,
0.3536679447,
0.5847148895,
0.6327024102,
0.6683536172,
0.2260585725,
-0.0414042845,
0.0601609163,
-0.2184064537,
0.3166725039,
-0.1482872516,
-0.1680453271,
-0.1510522813,
-0.2854651213,
0.6047733426,
0.7587052584,
0.4851480424,
0.4877150953,
-0.3436352313,
0.846755743,
-0.8708110452,
0.4271425903,
-0.2101628631,
0.2136653662,
-0.0552450009,
0.2345398366,
-0.02593516,
-0.6594997644,
0.3584534228,
-0.2886895239,
0.370062232,
-0.1341280341,
0.6638075709,
0.3500807881,
-0.178787291,
0.0584459044,
-0.5254881382,
0.7410975099,
-0.4096599221,
-0.0161299668,
0.4281868339,
0.3892657161,
0.3302094042,
-0.5040479302,
-0.2886965573,
-0.3485071361,
-0.1777041256,
0.2025377452,
-0.0848590732,
-0.0405271798,
0.2098339349,
0.6536284089,
-0.3232192397,
-0.2021946013,
-0.4369160533,
-0.1011483893,
0.4885153174,
0.1655454934,
0.2981060743,
-0.346116513,
-0.6058884859,
-0.1501164734,
-0.1331030279,
0.2061030567,
0.0453947,
-0.118414022,
-0.0052580144,
0.6317516565,
-0.4720594585,
0.4665597677,
-0.0677001849,
-0.1963341832,
0.0153418286,
-0.5977116823,
-0.1062776595,
0.1777995825,
0.4824493527,
1.0454624891,
0.2020919025,
0.0380815603,
-0.1922366172,
0.0198266692,
0.0933696255,
-0.757417798,
-0.2652204633,
0.5135393739,
-0.2625246346,
-0.3483204246,
0.0890330523,
-0.9707152247,
-0.5692381263,
-0.0646536946,
0.2005488575,
-0.4091099501,
0.1285296082,
-0.5301600695,
-0.5554350019,
0.3015363216,
0.6260408759,
-1.0034024715,
0.0851798058,
0.2894460559,
0.8786355257,
-0.337521553,
-0.4313537478,
-0.42764768,
0.4987846315,
-0.5019125342,
1.0526165962,
-0.4731113911,
-0.2241652757,
0.0031783879,
-0.1635031253,
0.0690883249,
-0.418245703,
0.2835358977,
-0.3140358329,
0.3662540615,
-0.068887867,
0.0165323652,
-0.3021289706,
0.055860851,
-0.8380050659,
0.7816619873,
0.46355775,
-0.6727830172,
0.3845862746,
-0.5958845615,
-0.5035865307,
-0.5125336051,
-0.0186405554,
-0.5000500083,
0.3564379811,
0.5244392157,
0.2923134565,
0.2359150946,
0.1734825522,
0.098249048,
-0.4173552394,
0.5482019782,
0.0112675428,
-0.0226584207,
0.2214531004,
-0.0217821244,
0.3821241558,
-0.7974094748,
-0.1372264773,
-0.0760644898,
-0.0128580937,
-0.0854821205,
-0.2157427371,
0.2495268434,
0.3540115356,
0.3294621706,
-0.0371626951,
-0.2364334911,
-0.5860291123,
-0.1234703809,
0.3928463757,
0.3697017431,
0.5343466401,
-0.1409944594,
0.5547935963,
0.1045717373,
0.0794387013,
-0.909635365,
-0.1927080154,
-0.7499042153,
-0.5139334202,
0.0459596626,
0.3996475339,
-0.3381710351,
0.3940848112,
0.1213573515,
-0.0972456634,
-0.2690779865,
-0.2213283777,
0.6300367117,
0.2431094348,
0.2696478963,
-0.5218729973,
-0.6092892289,
-1.1960412264,
0.0152717503,
-0.2244881094,
-0.5367268324,
-0.0469125099,
0.2827774882,
0.2050599456,
0.9678968191,
-0.8066217899,
-0.5128786564,
-0.6845459938,
-0.1009300351,
0.1293784827,
0.4017941058,
0.3056619465,
-0.5250532031,
-0.2415977418,
-0.0582538731,
-0.8304035664,
-0.0372522846,
-0.0159209892,
-0.1348834634,
0.0557581708,
0.5092875957,
-0.5772332549,
0.6003779769,
0.0433527678,
-0.2829226553,
0.5415572524,
-0.2751561105,
0.4685764015,
-1.0860087872,
0.2410703152,
0.0560093261,
-0.2242698669,
-0.4654937387,
-0.136379838,
-0.0345735401,
-0.5189669728,
-0.4095743001,
0.5093874335,
-0.2989098132,
-0.6342507005,
-0.3435063064,
0.4162605405,
0.3093216419,
0.8835430741,
0.1488339156,
0.6098192334,
0.2129597962,
-0.478771776,
0.2788188756,
0.2521122992,
-0.2870538533,
0.4120979905,
-0.513877511,
-0.3672879338,
-0.5381180048,
0.3121749163,
-1.2754967213,
-1.0561527014,
0.0192841329,
-0.2594518065,
-0.127028957,
-0.2401190847,
-0.3249644041,
0.2197604179,
-0.6002364159,
0.4087436199,
0.5921954513,
-0.2648619115,
0.4738833904,
0.452922225,
-0.6342304349,
-0.4627738595,
-0.3208916783,
0.0283069983,
-0.2227514833,
-0.2871347964,
0.3682133555,
0.409119606,
-0.313849777,
-0.3437716961,
-0.2737380862,
-0.2808499932,
-0.1482824087,
0.4430950284,
0.3076326549,
0.2129097283,
0.0522186272,
0.2749674916,
-0.3227461874,
0.0116489688,
0.0248706583,
0.2865438759,
0.1980158091,
-0.0704442039,
-0.5543588996,
0.7094079256,
0.7385386825,
-0.4390373826,
0.0357227474,
0.6756189466,
-0.3173522055,
0.1015221402,
-0.4188783467,
-0.0516211465,
-0.2701066136,
0.9208296537,
-0.0321699381,
-0.4132598937,
0.6038705111,
-0.0278046373,
0.0223733056,
0.5436106324,
0.318451643,
-0.2755486667,
0.9867269397,
0.8225618601,
0.1084716246,
0.8493855,
-0.1159912795,
-0.0720527396,
-0.879417479,
-0.4573330581,
-0.319806397,
-0.2072588801,
-0.0694343597,
-0.4141217172,
0.5914803147,
0.1492884606,
0.2637587786,
0.2536569536,
-0.1399586052,
1.0980112553,
0.5002247095,
0.1284490526,
0.4628182352,
0.0521267727,
0.1653280258,
0.1674227417,
-0.0619870536,
-0.6040569544,
0.5793363452,
0.344653219,
0.4937411249,
0.3096441627,
0.5543240309,
0.1815061122,
-0.2947140932,
-0.432523638,
0.7305864692,
-0.268494606,
-0.3540018797,
-0.3486690819,
0.1346849352,
-0.6105659604,
0.3632530272,
-0.0557254851,
-0.9623203874,
0.444298178,
0.0151734222,
-0.6805816293,
-0.1082804278,
-0.9638453126,
0.8934183717,
0.0823807716,
-0.3898359835,
-0.3429164588,
-1.1026949883,
0.4865301847,
0.0361307301,
0.0548191741,
-0.3789951801,
-0.2428737879,
0.5265977383,
-0.3224429488,
0.8629245162,
0.0857305527,
0.1006014347,
0.1845468581,
0.0728416592,
0.3674649298,
0.1891715378,
0.1418261975,
-0.142364338,
-0.0389523283,
-0.4941785634,
-0.6156959534,
0.4845479727,
-0.3114378452,
-0.2531177402,
-0.611192584,
-0.5820991397,
0.021750411,
0.1966816783,
0.0636941344,
0.620231986,
-0.4735273719,
-0.4260519743,
0.5072216392,
-0.3033948541,
0.9676662087,
0.0291906185,
-0.6349124312,
-0.7721526027,
0.8573153019,
-0.1642823666,
0.4064315856,
0.3419801593,
-0.2347066551,
-0.5381219983,
-0.6642336249,
-0.6526868343,
-0.1184140518,
-0.8919754028,
0.1164609939,
-0.7949039936,
-0.0883718207,
-0.0123907151,
-0.3707265854,
-0.2042430937,
-0.7680440545,
0.0293697901,
-0.1742587239,
0.3339181542,
0.6892055273,
0.2864377201,
0.0605983809,
-0.7132514715,
0.5416746736,
0.6193396449,
0.2965277433,
-0.1322248131,
-0.3706319928,
-0.6399104595,
-0.6130351424,
-0.0943286121,
-0.6248505712,
0.4680682123,
0.2322241813,
0.0850517303,
0.4022315443,
0.0578001104,
0.5991865993,
-0.1244765446,
1.0663069487,
0.3940273225,
-0.7250643969,
0.9725874662,
-0.4601374567,
0.889402926,
0.8981452584,
0.0223300885,
-0.2006168067,
-0.5378292799,
-0.4624506831,
-1.1382561922,
0.9258551598,
0.4348997474,
0.0311878845,
0.0929570496,
-0.0362902805,
0.2447055578,
0.4408621192,
-0.41808182,
-0.0087749306,
-0.2975013554,
-0.2525775135,
-0.0344038457,
-0.3862505853,
-0.0486326627,
-0.0251702406,
0.1249401644,
0.0261729024,
-0.1501418203,
0.4283111691,
-0.2215086818,
-0.1037098318,
0.4395854175,
0.5820337534,
0.9250071049,
-0.7704651952,
0.2671058476,
0.0930235982,
-0.5723404288,
-0.1253083199,
0.1043746024,
-0.3319515288,
0.3510082364,
0.4407993555,
0.5889892578,
0.5839473009,
-1.0158498287,
0.5532326698,
0.1227519736,
0.3337835073,
-0.4095989168,
0.1489120722,
-0.3074097335,
0.3702890277,
0.5348010063,
0.2504955232,
0.5246449709,
-0.7827519178,
0.1191615909,
0.0052312491,
-0.3318438232,
-0.2266874611,
0.4079837799,
0.3374815881,
-0.0246968213,
0.3714148998,
-0.1165356189,
-0.3727117777,
0.5871410966,
0.2163707465,
1.1743127108,
-0.0114378361,
0.2878597081,
0.5619977713,
-0.1510570198,
0.1599905342,
-0.0986195505,
-0.1567530781,
-0.044287812,
-0.4602563381,
-0.7194600701,
-0.6442831755,
-0.3099935353,
-0.4402995706,
0.0615977719,
-0.6321244836,
-0.0441920385,
0.1332484186,
-0.2772041857,
0.0528641008,
0.4249424636,
0.1184803471,
0.2913122773,
-0.6713045835,
0.4508348405,
0.4823713601,
-0.9814370871,
-0.1289441288,
0.1456454098,
-0.3255329728,
-0.4032186866,
0.5122036934,
0.3943806887,
-0.0417934246,
-0.0642640516,
-0.229589358,
-0.7671127319,
1.0174520016,
0.1639438868,
-0.202381134,
-0.2700921893,
-0.2194481194,
0.5101361275,
-0.5591222048,
0.2995170653,
0.7992089391,
0.2146330923,
0.4918315411,
-0.709687531,
-0.253035903,
-0.350440979,
0.1442886889,
0.3202468753,
-0.3910889924,
0.5336681604,
-0.7868310809,
-0.2975158691,
0.0912803933,
0.7417678237,
0.460847646,
0.7913953662,
0.3782733381,
0.1743309945,
0.3379520476,
-0.0293746628,
1.1131302118,
-0.0266558714,
-0.0810162798,
1.1622927189,
-0.124316439,
0.6791347861,
0.5990948081,
-0.366966933,
0.4024388492,
0.5750949979,
-0.1062177643,
0.8081626296,
0.0199245289,
-0.4890040159,
-0.1400642991,
-0.3934890628,
-0.0994230956,
0.2466172576,
0.0089326715,
-0.5990313888,
-0.5033885241,
-0.1196916103,
-0.1907914877,
0.0634641349,
-0.542573452,
1.2626609802,
0.0012914492,
-0.7875039577,
0.1579674333,
-0.1907746196,
0.199535951,
-0.6647655964,
-0.4130071998,
-0.4335472584,
-0.1044434384,
-0.475870043,
-0.6360732913,
0.1971533,
0.4243805408,
-0.7082620859,
0.1587063372,
0.3163867295,
-0.7950000763,
-0.6906434894,
-0.457441777,
0.1179815456,
0.5301479101,
-0.2218139917,
-0.1803355366,
0.1169346422,
0.1435700506,
0.331140399,
0.6350318789,
0.3093735278,
-0.2999235094,
0.4552893937,
0.5268078446,
-0.2137977779,
-0.3394205868,
0.3719259202,
0.7694456577,
-0.9581283927,
-0.6972298622,
-0.6923387647,
0.9540538788,
-0.4004023969,
-0.3344206214,
0.5998708606,
0.71850878,
0.3801428676,
-0.5863324404,
0.8101201653,
0.0062904847,
0.4246298373,
-0.7355290055,
0.3449164331,
-0.0258291923,
0.5301353931,
-0.5509402752,
-1.1402896643,
-0.4156855643,
0.5370482802,
-0.1801199913,
-0.0259425882,
0.9068552256,
0.5863819122,
0.2164384276,
-0.2296609879,
0.4337667525,
-0.0792919248,
0.0398313999,
0.5253025889,
1.0522425175,
-0.3873329163,
0.4908242822,
-0.2130858302,
-0.2631681263,
-0.4676228166,
-0.9286979437,
-0.9167698026,
-0.4942337573,
-0.6110583544,
-0.0826036483,
0.1342940032,
0.9322624803,
0.3937996924,
-0.9483146667,
-0.1256734431,
0.3463293016,
0.4506609738,
-0.315757215,
-0.1685466766,
0.8046326637,
-0.2995449603,
-1.0379873514,
0.3669987321,
0.8428965807,
0.3783617616,
-0.3549742401,
0.4349533617,
0.0133610349,
0.1252380013,
0.6999974847,
0.0895746797,
-0.659550786,
-0.1235700995,
-0.2709523439,
0.0118746003,
-0.1205644086,
0.6196138859,
-0.6619527936,
0.5715492964,
0.4323790967,
0.0395306014,
0.6330637932,
0.4225133359,
0.7797751427,
-1.0261899233,
0.1504526734,
0.0413410552,
0.1966414452,
0.2143163085,
-0.3541664183,
0.4373602271,
-0.1391081363,
-0.3164387941,
-0.7215827703,
0.3303696811,
-1.4083707333,
-0.086698167,
0.8146477342,
-0.0706337094,
-0.2820466757,
-0.2536641061,
-0.6151236296,
-0.0469975732,
-0.6395512223,
0.8223590255,
0.4392980933,
-0.2602753043,
-0.2830924988,
-0.2218143791,
0.7987131476,
0.0077029476,
-0.8659202456,
0.3038941622,
1.0076550245,
0.0957190543,
0.2967757881,
0.4800719023,
-0.3379050195,
0.4917437732,
-0.0099760108,
0.1408932656,
-0.2407777458,
-0.4881969094,
-0.3979811966,
0.489379108,
0.0038683615,
-0.2759503424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03558v1
|
How does Multi-Task Training Affect Transformer In-Context Capabilities? Investigations with Function Classes
| 2024-04-04T16:15:23 | 2024-04-04T16:15:23 |
Harmon Bhasin, Timothy Ossowski, Yiqiao Zhong, Junjie Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLM) have recently shown the extraordinary ability to
perform unseen tasks based on few-shot examples provided as text, also known as
in-context learning (ICL). While recent works have attempted to understand the
mechanisms driving ICL, few have explored training strategies that incentivize
these models to generalize to multiple tasks. Multi-task learning (MTL) for
generalist models is a promising direction that offers transfer learning
potential, enabling large parameterized models to be trained from simpler,
related tasks. In this work, we investigate the combination of MTL with ICL to
build models that efficiently learn tasks while being robust to
out-of-distribution examples. We propose several effective curriculum learning
strategies that allow ICL models to achieve higher data efficiency and more
stable convergence. Our experiments reveal that ICL models can effectively
learn difficult tasks by training on progressively harder tasks while mixing in
prior tasks, denoted as mixed curriculum in this work. Our code and models are
available at https://github.com/harmonbhasin/curriculum_learning_icl .
|
[
-0.3766796589,
-0.3509770632,
0.3603802323,
0.0319399312,
-0.110144116,
0.0660585314,
-0.3967556357,
-0.3167688549,
-0.7068760395,
0.6157582402,
-0.5456264019,
-0.1872838289,
-0.8208944798,
0.0197092798,
-0.3849948049,
1.462430954,
-0.0711890459,
0.0544421151,
-0.3285755217,
-0.2195836902,
-0.7133041024,
-0.6809542179,
-0.4522942901,
-0.6226555705,
0.2369579673,
0.6275123954,
0.1757430583,
0.249286294,
0.5637750626,
0.1977889389,
0.2225213498,
0.1311961263,
-0.4815756381,
0.2236715555,
-0.0938457623,
-0.5100439787,
-0.119586736,
-0.0906797349,
0.6604120135,
0.6922932267,
-0.0371639095,
0.2385504097,
0.7666007876,
0.3902239203,
-0.7906081676,
0.4484949708,
-0.8045857549,
-0.1061454415,
-0.2102398872,
-0.0354845822,
-0.8235985637,
0.2931065857,
0.1953288764,
-0.3906212151,
0.3578768671,
-0.1392674595,
0.6093314886,
0.2558008134,
-0.726289928,
-0.4626922607,
-0.8277390003,
1.1523560286,
-0.3185718954,
0.5179432034,
0.3624053299,
0.40740785,
0.1226038635,
-0.7728312016,
-0.3112864196,
-0.2193225771,
-0.2206006944,
0.1703870595,
0.0696964189,
-0.0717471391,
0.4830927849,
0.1173434779,
-0.1365649104,
0.1453390718,
-0.255022943,
0.2354777604,
0.1473227441,
0.2663125098,
0.09907455,
0.135548085,
-0.4344107509,
-0.4506030679,
-0.8039355874,
0.5194719434,
0.2701906562,
0.4161958992,
-0.2961109877,
0.4462936521,
0.1789852828,
0.6181327105,
0.2328931987,
-0.3337653279,
0.0636287257,
-0.3396410346,
-0.2494435906,
-0.3739685118,
0.2806392014,
-0.1727404594,
-0.0418288633,
-0.2214431316,
-0.3685874045,
-0.2400627881,
0.7322220206,
-0.7585305572,
-0.0548405387,
-0.1236213967,
-0.3659699559,
0.021380214,
0.194446221,
-0.5061401129,
-0.000192554,
-0.6430411935,
0.5891079307,
-0.5289275646,
0.0060325032,
-0.1010299325,
-0.0713998973,
0.2117880881,
0.2865729034,
-1.0578812361,
0.3580939472,
0.5486494899,
0.6863205433,
-0.4038847387,
-0.4074036181,
-0.6050166488,
0.2819367051,
0.1262092143,
0.5504772067,
-0.4824840128,
-0.3504696786,
0.0915655196,
0.0289161168,
-0.6912879348,
-0.5720075369,
0.4768082201,
-0.5673815608,
0.0441808105,
-0.0899932683,
-0.3430905342,
-0.3548609018,
0.1454442888,
-0.6700299382,
1.0787534714,
0.3177270889,
-0.8082860708,
0.5100185275,
-0.8703615069,
-0.6371163726,
-0.0118157016,
-0.0751758292,
-0.5003238916,
0.0284673776,
0.1854702681,
0.9642589688,
-0.3490966856,
0.3822229207,
-0.143040359,
-0.4977296591,
0.2487100065,
-0.4664942324,
0.7732086778,
0.0765546858,
-0.5745435953,
0.1677290201,
-0.391670078,
-0.2201569527,
-0.0773909688,
-0.508479774,
-0.414101243,
-0.061429549,
0.2291576117,
0.3952746987,
-0.1840552986,
-0.2380054593,
0.2552447021,
-0.3053676188,
0.3463238478,
0.5787033439,
-0.2535762489,
0.6080003977,
-0.5617664456,
0.4117349088,
0.2589006722,
0.0214250386,
-0.2907969058,
-0.4102101624,
-0.8198052049,
-0.4445649981,
-0.1517676115,
0.5395501256,
-0.9914880395,
0.2438352406,
-0.2021530569,
-0.5277805924,
-0.4001302719,
0.2320497036,
0.4343880415,
0.5710173845,
0.7328474522,
-0.1411074996,
-0.18166475,
-0.6280183196,
-0.0926808491,
0.3402695656,
-0.1023974791,
0.1964091212,
0.8910652995,
-0.1912764907,
0.8767130375,
-0.3784615397,
-0.5652212501,
-0.6520888209,
0.2034388036,
0.1752092838,
0.5503115654,
0.5671056509,
-0.9674458504,
-0.6701248288,
0.0324573293,
-0.5430953503,
0.2226321995,
-0.277505517,
0.1097183004,
0.0652654767,
0.4457442164,
-0.5598537922,
0.3223564327,
0.4308104515,
0.0803988725,
0.4123115838,
-0.3602563441,
0.0735818818,
-1.1259367466,
-0.0881207809,
0.1817858964,
0.0384146757,
-0.9290967584,
0.3345800042,
0.4557598531,
-0.085462302,
-0.6357080936,
0.3513352573,
-0.4702236652,
0.1419116557,
-0.3345304132,
-0.3412646949,
-0.1649375409,
0.7073220611,
-0.0386346951,
0.9152778983,
0.785346508,
-0.7314988971,
-0.0259673409,
0.1621865481,
-0.1563964337,
0.7916010022,
-0.2890007496,
0.0933396891,
-0.2596139312,
0.3419716656,
-0.9975337386,
-0.1177030653,
0.075710319,
0.296112746,
0.6863072515,
0.0754890442,
-0.531152904,
-0.3572610915,
-0.1851267517,
0.545447588,
0.2584432065,
-0.7423510551,
0.8549863696,
0.2487576753,
0.3635464609,
-0.6415849328,
-0.7856699824,
-0.2957245409,
-0.5157336593,
-0.2666621804,
0.6023164988,
-0.3231127262,
0.0580288507,
-0.2706229687,
-0.0170155447,
-0.3320804536,
0.2178309262,
0.4313180447,
0.3455108702,
-0.0732686147,
0.1526503861,
0.1285605878,
-0.0033862281,
-0.1511427164,
-0.3539641201,
0.4683116078,
-0.1350394338,
-0.7542176843,
-0.3020902276,
0.3501967192,
0.7124351263,
-0.1796210706,
0.8273245692,
0.6705854535,
-0.2612302303,
-0.3943271339,
-0.5251787305,
-0.3583095372,
-0.4384573996,
0.4470185935,
-0.4518384635,
-0.9981876016,
0.3838184178,
-0.0299201161,
0.3099332154,
0.3405643106,
0.5949806571,
0.0609322898,
0.7571542263,
0.7897307277,
-0.1181398556,
0.4927081466,
-0.437638849,
0.1602790505,
-1.0388813019,
-0.2158595622,
-0.5286839008,
-0.2757556438,
-0.2520033121,
-0.498007834,
0.464918077,
-0.1280479729,
-0.3302518725,
0.6959474087,
-0.415861845,
0.4125574827,
0.6494983435,
0.3357771933,
0.2076925188,
-0.0056078373,
0.0235949382,
-0.0006309107,
-0.7903189063,
-0.1851560622,
1.3404785395,
0.281781733,
0.7963853478,
-0.0601735972,
0.5104337931,
0.0767920762,
0.6321882606,
-0.6650589108,
0.3245194852,
-0.4153992236,
-0.496549964,
-0.1092651784,
-0.1250452101,
-0.7498157024,
0.4870328605,
-0.2540163696,
-0.5716793537,
0.0027584764,
-0.0082062455,
-0.182304427,
0.4212191999,
-0.5690870285,
0.8612388372,
-0.142778784,
-0.2256322503,
-0.31688115,
-0.8131979704,
0.328620851,
-0.4108164012,
0.2812172771,
0.2728082836,
0.1877443641,
0.4498182237,
0.2340634912,
1.1905742884,
-0.0346012153,
0.0062435293,
0.1549144089,
-0.160156101,
0.5128624439,
-0.1822837889,
0.0351295695,
0.0511495359,
-0.2047457099,
-0.20198147,
-0.3160899282,
0.4484903514,
-0.7592710257,
-0.4534306824,
-0.2052726448,
-1.128077507,
-0.2715895474,
-0.1095075235,
0.5017110705,
0.6373114586,
0.1933902651,
0.5432087779,
0.7207849622,
0.1655833125,
0.6787706017,
0.252838254,
0.4303351045,
-0.0990036577,
0.6974009275,
0.2695408463,
0.6079058647,
0.6132287979,
-0.0981885046,
-0.1492944509,
-0.4603908956,
-0.297172904,
-0.0870966539,
-1.0450814962,
-0.2704980373,
-0.711196661,
-0.3786374927,
-0.120268628,
-0.4506111443,
-0.1179350987,
0.0616136342,
-0.5883920193,
0.1566248834,
-0.1952313632,
0.7116366029,
0.4905807972,
0.6942431927,
-0.7723126411,
0.06784641,
0.3210418522,
0.0620096251,
0.2719988227,
-0.7996687293,
-0.5156072378,
-0.0203210376,
-0.8371447921,
-0.6323593855,
0.1122357249,
0.3762401938,
0.7505096793,
0.2435557842,
-0.0081066312,
0.6504650116,
-0.4559287131,
0.5899460912,
0.1577853411,
-0.9728111625,
0.0713669807,
-0.0780995861,
0.4922534525,
0.446344018,
0.5175304413,
-0.2546221018,
-0.8078529835,
-0.5115469098,
-0.7516686916,
0.8596593738,
0.0316855982,
0.4313528538,
0.2219990492,
0.2208938599,
0.460627526,
0.1830660403,
-1.0229926109,
-0.1588368118,
-0.2010688782,
-0.3228597045,
0.0068243435,
-0.0665060952,
-0.1497891694,
-0.3327904046,
0.5392794609,
-0.5367407799,
0.1126312241,
-0.2463846803,
-0.4588216245,
0.0509300008,
0.4468630552,
0.6837517619,
0.5721517801,
0.1704711318,
0.2263520807,
0.5443431735,
-0.5256306529,
0.2615916133,
0.067601189,
-0.0065815477,
-0.4758953154,
0.5247396827,
0.9429989457,
0.6810967326,
-0.5305433273,
0.6642623544,
0.0737276152,
-0.2572280765,
-0.0830210596,
0.2240995467,
-0.0363921747,
0.6003548503,
0.6157149673,
0.2805237174,
-0.0302097313,
-0.3609584868,
0.308694452,
0.6494143605,
-0.3936817944,
-0.3587369621,
0.801615119,
-0.2585285008,
0.0556092672,
0.5713043213,
0.0116388472,
-0.4031157196,
0.5828656554,
1.0237653255,
0.7641806006,
-0.2447529286,
0.1034080237,
0.0795903057,
0.2530677319,
-0.330986172,
-0.2586363554,
-0.2547774315,
-0.6084866524,
-0.5597108006,
-0.4507335424,
-0.3920127153,
-0.0094615351,
-0.5492433906,
0.4843972325,
-0.0656989366,
-0.0113923075,
-0.2817667127,
-0.4455005825,
-0.9580251575,
0.1596075743,
-0.0432034619,
0.5406199694,
-0.9735663533,
1.1558886766,
0.7008577585,
-0.2809066176,
-0.9952363372,
0.2066073865,
-0.2590508163,
-0.5534881949,
1.0982532501,
0.5038235188,
0.008426467,
0.1619719565,
-0.1886637658,
-0.7107852697,
1.2648869753,
0.4335099459,
-0.4262445271,
-0.306628406,
0.2769074738,
0.3335597515,
-0.6682603359,
0.4858812392,
0.2680898607,
0.1608345658,
0.209301278,
-0.9633561969,
-0.0487840921,
0.1670192778,
-0.0251340196,
0.3165353537,
-0.3642002344,
1.064355731,
-0.1702254862,
-0.1163658723,
-0.2713939548,
0.5684427023,
0.0915634036,
0.3004920185,
0.6627870798,
0.4497942924,
0.5138719678,
-0.0474525206,
0.964558363,
-0.2063869387,
0.6257383823,
0.9186010361,
-0.2457036078,
0.6881702542,
0.5482964516,
-0.0222839043,
0.4503766596,
0.2732315063,
-0.1418404728,
0.6508353353,
-0.1447583288,
-0.2879104912,
-0.1977384537,
-0.0254869089,
-0.1141773462,
0.4070971608,
0.2844768465,
-0.1663703024,
-0.4634581506,
0.8357291222,
-0.0728924349,
-0.1732239872,
-0.2476069927,
0.5550857186,
0.0891656429,
-0.6858849525,
0.3639547229,
-0.2513211071,
0.7232414484,
-0.7181143761,
-0.0376097411,
0.2288316935,
0.3560148478,
-0.0334200338,
-0.839748919,
0.4193398952,
-0.3292255998,
-0.2376125604,
-0.4545740783,
0.6897318363,
-0.644518137,
-0.1912727952,
0.3655911982,
0.4163620472,
-0.3004330695,
-0.201142773,
-0.5542199016,
-0.2511464953,
-0.2270041853,
-0.1689194441,
0.7785351872,
0.2441892773,
-0.2535788119,
0.6903569102,
0.5895278454,
-0.218377769,
-0.0358802155,
-0.1916457862,
0.9578100443,
-0.1275896728,
-0.4331197143,
-0.9641731381,
0.819000423,
0.2447691262,
-0.2027502507,
0.6475993991,
0.3895142674,
1.1955205202,
-0.4428100288,
0.4974253774,
-0.0776724145,
0.0725504234,
-0.4718080759,
0.4744653702,
-0.6625612378,
0.131324783,
-0.0899640247,
-0.9239910245,
-0.5013462901,
0.140487358,
-0.2657923996,
0.0217598602,
0.9689686894,
0.433328867,
-0.5100627542,
0.0230611954,
0.3294948339,
-0.4607949257,
0.4425202906,
0.7532657981,
0.6637099981,
-0.2116648704,
0.4768682122,
-0.4730181992,
-0.162238881,
-0.2620012462,
-0.7900220156,
-1.1812999249,
-0.9334226847,
-0.0104340678,
-0.070837073,
-0.1713690162,
0.985609293,
0.8932102323,
-0.7785435319,
-0.5497740507,
-0.0191107318,
-0.0468424112,
-0.5534991026,
-0.2226838619,
0.4211777449,
-0.6725450158,
-0.7226647139,
0.3539099693,
0.3262658119,
-0.0384299047,
0.0499608368,
0.0865808278,
-0.092307128,
-0.2622970939,
0.755130589,
-0.1177018285,
-0.6005830169,
-0.3418067694,
0.0587125123,
-0.2959800065,
0.1336401701,
1.2005861998,
-0.5686748028,
0.2463323474,
0.1813413799,
0.9713625312,
0.5311201215,
-0.1645933986,
0.1600503474,
-0.9112287164,
0.2757710516,
0.0919097215,
0.3705984652,
0.2077583373,
-0.4090383351,
0.354714036,
0.2626475692,
-0.8008508682,
-0.6159718633,
0.2884790599,
-0.7598230839,
-0.2462661117,
0.87006706,
-0.1402350515,
0.171382606,
-0.2814364433,
-0.2680083215,
0.3382135332,
-0.1288917512,
0.6374543905,
0.794622004,
-0.2477023453,
-0.1155133545,
-0.9221596122,
0.3901729882,
0.4554777145,
-0.93794173,
-0.0411571711,
0.070717454,
0.1958173066,
0.1325711161,
0.2328071594,
0.3056853414,
0.0817285627,
-0.5330969691,
-0.2193076611,
-0.0914529338,
-0.6690223813,
-0.216846481,
0.5179668665,
0.0135214087,
-0.0770193934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03555v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03555v2
|
From News to Summaries: Building a Hungarian Corpus for Extractive and Abstractive Summarization
| 2024-04-04T16:07:06 | 2024-04-12T08:05:13 |
Botond Barta, Dorina Lakatos, Attila Nagy, Milán Konor Nyist, Judit Ács
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Training summarization models requires substantial amounts of training data.
However for less resourceful languages like Hungarian, openly available models
and datasets are notably scarce. To address this gap our paper introduces
HunSum-2 an open-source Hungarian corpus suitable for training abstractive and
extractive summarization models. The dataset is assembled from segments of the
Common Crawl corpus undergoing thorough cleaning, preprocessing and
deduplication. In addition to abstractive summarization we generate
sentence-level labels for extractive summarization using sentence similarity.
We train baseline models for both extractive and abstractive summarization
using the collected dataset. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the trained
models, we perform both quantitative and qualitative evaluation. Our dataset,
models and code are publicly available, encouraging replication, further
research, and real-world applications across various domains.
|
[
-0.0633663237,
-0.5013656616,
0.3354200125,
0.0164951831,
-0.2179709971,
-0.2349615544,
-0.4604554772,
-0.5229241848,
0.2341427952,
0.6190991998,
-0.1073465422,
-0.7574779987,
-0.7828088403,
0.123614043,
-0.5364742875,
1.6561803818,
-0.1796366274,
-0.1087063402,
-0.3753207922,
-0.1713885814,
0.1824438125,
-0.4138701558,
0.058411587,
-0.0833945274,
0.7565794587,
0.6328162551,
0.4121044278,
0.6540383101,
0.5431702733,
0.1615060866,
-0.2533681095,
0.0495490357,
-0.5144944191,
0.2565719783,
-0.2407433689,
-0.3100627959,
-0.4583259523,
0.0086072572,
0.5914691687,
0.7283096313,
-0.138011843,
0.6728290319,
0.0687194988,
0.930231452,
-0.8745686412,
0.3280213177,
-0.5378847718,
-0.2583445609,
-0.0860036835,
-0.0114586381,
-0.3038119972,
-0.6205397844,
0.1849430054,
-0.6892417073,
0.1878385544,
-0.3955641091,
1.0384498835,
0.0612352267,
-0.2641353309,
-0.6033784151,
-0.7324850559,
0.5829761028,
-0.9414961338,
-0.1659822911,
0.3575340509,
0.2752978802,
0.4683377147,
-0.9396504164,
0.1034935415,
-0.107670404,
-0.4415749609,
0.2116430998,
-0.2422290742,
-0.2046884,
0.1602898836,
0.3952485025,
-0.840803206,
-0.1760207415,
-0.8550014496,
0.1397946775,
0.4713925123,
0.2068019062,
0.0402419679,
-0.1574701667,
-0.2815216184,
0.2115743458,
-0.6922653913,
-0.0070630037,
0.6375465393,
0.5187336802,
-0.3412745595,
0.8415712714,
-0.5195335746,
0.5444316864,
-0.3259483278,
-0.1464708745,
0.3002455235,
-0.3938139379,
-0.0256099533,
0.1632015556,
0.4164901376,
0.1867991239,
0.3522242606,
-0.3194678724,
-0.3168575466,
0.214459613,
0.3251027763,
-0.9272902012,
-0.3024858832,
0.1479226053,
-0.5321859121,
-0.5101290941,
0.5258156657,
-0.8788380623,
0.0860519186,
-0.3860294819,
0.158155784,
-0.0578098111,
-0.4485670328,
0.1421086639,
-0.5984062552,
-0.0001062351,
0.1484555155,
-0.9938639998,
0.4091789126,
0.7718082666,
1.0678112507,
-0.2791959345,
-0.1819387972,
-0.5379090309,
0.267054677,
-0.1892384291,
0.8490847945,
-0.1704875529,
-0.0295122769,
0.2228887528,
0.0859776214,
-0.0978747904,
-0.7762387991,
0.1783419102,
-0.3130734265,
0.2519383729,
0.1115046889,
-0.4153589904,
-0.184443295,
0.3251743317,
-0.7908790112,
1.1504172087,
0.7373605371,
-1.2455203533,
-0.1190778911,
-0.7628198266,
-0.6611776948,
-0.1442197859,
0.1021759957,
-0.4623319209,
0.2169762105,
0.0026244873,
0.2547865212,
0.3450158834,
0.160476163,
-0.0761017576,
-0.3968380094,
-0.0507546142,
0.1890681386,
0.7906059027,
0.4914082289,
-0.148450762,
-0.0223151445,
-0.7544721961,
-0.2293805331,
-0.0503554493,
-0.7125530839,
-0.5868189335,
0.0771997049,
0.2843930125,
0.2087360322,
0.4659811258,
-0.4520878196,
-0.0144503415,
-0.7634204626,
0.3591750264,
0.0405676588,
-0.1172739565,
0.63238132,
-0.3689109683,
0.5288526416,
0.0497289225,
-0.2392893583,
-0.6526417732,
-0.2724638283,
-0.6742733717,
-0.1343389004,
0.3200867772,
0.6768903136,
-0.446749121,
0.4283025265,
-0.4494033754,
-0.638771832,
-0.4803878665,
0.2022532672,
0.3305954635,
0.5440606475,
0.2585498989,
0.0940399766,
-0.9786942005,
-0.9158504009,
-0.1676519364,
0.0444679037,
-0.227430895,
-0.139845252,
0.7021871805,
-0.0697949529,
1.295591116,
-0.3446576297,
-0.1649410427,
-0.6670794487,
0.4015576541,
0.2865233123,
0.3553033471,
0.5504184365,
-0.5997588038,
-0.2636818886,
0.1696728915,
-1.1294898987,
0.0028222322,
0.3117915988,
-0.1281950772,
0.274892211,
0.4220529795,
-0.4421821535,
0.467339009,
0.5877938271,
-0.1252435148,
0.7209693193,
-0.1612786651,
-0.2709841132,
-1.37520051,
0.677783072,
-0.1440176517,
-0.439754039,
-0.3478859961,
0.1928920895,
-0.1176783592,
-0.2953861058,
-0.6821287274,
0.5704621673,
-0.4996957481,
-0.4592670202,
-0.5456236005,
0.304444015,
0.2040490359,
0.3989968896,
0.3056398034,
0.6755641699,
0.2623496354,
-0.6010293365,
0.0600816719,
0.4375941157,
-0.7437208295,
-0.0115996944,
-0.7467593551,
-0.1715163589,
-0.2640560567,
0.1903058439,
-0.6388838291,
-0.3866387904,
0.2068357319,
-0.5267080665,
0.0208352208,
-0.2409035563,
-0.2460925877,
-0.2681908607,
-0.4851813018,
0.0477085598,
0.5363292694,
-0.4297116101,
0.3290369511,
0.7138822675,
-0.756808877,
-0.5520684123,
-0.7305839658,
0.0719923228,
-0.1646258235,
-0.4137861729,
0.1161443964,
0.2688223124,
-0.6416039467,
0.1525137126,
0.0281648282,
-0.165053457,
0.0659750775,
0.2587372065,
0.3672969937,
-0.4161564708,
-0.1016185358,
0.251310885,
-0.2705796063,
0.0784965307,
-0.3368729353,
0.1438041925,
-0.1653818339,
0.2254083753,
-0.2133736759,
0.7759407163,
0.3816492558,
-0.3524475098,
0.2614041269,
0.6181861758,
-0.414637655,
0.0660247952,
-0.0597299114,
0.0159631353,
-0.3487154245,
0.6786463857,
-0.0475467257,
-0.7801764011,
0.260935694,
0.0568040572,
0.6306866407,
0.5143716335,
0.9697843194,
-0.2690398693,
0.9263631701,
0.6524090767,
-0.0198268928,
0.4468017519,
-0.4504447877,
-0.0794147402,
-0.4575450122,
-0.1500514895,
-0.7230604291,
-0.0893623456,
-0.382686615,
0.1278205514,
0.2801468074,
0.0424512662,
0.1080627143,
0.6943318844,
-0.5346881151,
0.4278379679,
0.5207870007,
-0.0156243751,
0.3742265999,
0.2561973929,
0.3564761877,
0.2127756923,
-0.6288143992,
-1.010627389,
0.7845451832,
0.2820869088,
0.6962507367,
-0.0757723451,
0.730481565,
0.3573221266,
0.3903568983,
-0.7694138885,
0.2300686389,
-0.2330768555,
-0.6531096101,
-0.2990397513,
-0.3214713931,
-1.0409889221,
0.2102659792,
-0.0481744483,
-0.5480571985,
-0.2388155311,
0.0738933608,
-0.4336600602,
0.1709652394,
-0.5563122034,
0.736299336,
0.2118932307,
0.0875868723,
-0.2281975299,
-0.9609947205,
0.5511496067,
0.2594879568,
0.3465718925,
-0.3407957554,
0.0437166505,
1.1706451178,
-0.3746097684,
0.7013943195,
-0.011567113,
-0.1767594218,
0.5707358718,
-0.0283454582,
0.3733972609,
0.1495961547,
-0.0470184423,
0.2449507117,
0.2595022023,
-0.5965842605,
-0.4384348691,
0.4001531899,
-0.6959847808,
-0.0325188078,
-0.3725111485,
-0.6741197109,
0.0409218967,
0.0351465829,
0.5391092896,
0.6868590713,
-0.4105528593,
-0.0440786853,
0.3001136482,
0.0895597041,
0.5390485525,
0.4305402339,
-0.0142866299,
-0.5432800055,
0.9221196771,
-0.0816745386,
0.0203065127,
0.4928637743,
0.0433667079,
-0.0174229108,
-0.3239878714,
-0.4477243721,
0.2095717639,
-0.5226895809,
-0.1495202631,
-0.8824580312,
-0.4873673618,
-0.7663239837,
-0.1288167983,
-0.278650105,
-0.8617652059,
-0.3623314202,
-0.4010781944,
0.221525386,
1.0050815344,
-0.2944540083,
0.3804771304,
-1.0917048454,
0.2545036972,
-0.0113277519,
-0.1175379753,
-0.1508746296,
-0.4818560779,
-1.0220324993,
0.0310242362,
-0.1993778944,
-0.7368596792,
0.5319525003,
0.0714752004,
0.2653935254,
0.6662382483,
0.080713369,
0.1237995699,
-0.312458545,
0.7117064595,
0.142914474,
-0.4009482563,
0.7403667569,
-0.6928673387,
0.3011186719,
0.9383989573,
0.2968496978,
-0.4161972702,
-0.5821302533,
-0.4529094398,
-0.9684287906,
0.7136256695,
0.1733217984,
0.0231748205,
0.0243085548,
0.0956512764,
0.6540104151,
0.2221784145,
-0.4751555622,
0.0147488462,
-0.2180033326,
-0.3983450234,
-0.0373051167,
-0.4836710393,
-0.036577791,
-0.2398261279,
0.780297339,
0.0623534881,
0.1056919992,
-0.1932771504,
-0.4982756674,
0.0735508427,
0.2240303159,
0.7042244077,
0.7679105997,
-0.4673237503,
0.342615366,
-0.0957623273,
-0.5834153891,
-0.0668685436,
0.0870468915,
-0.4426433444,
0.5913693309,
0.449249357,
0.7271989584,
0.4693512619,
-0.9697993398,
0.6840918064,
0.1919947863,
-0.4507100582,
-0.6005578041,
0.0267273542,
0.1148278639,
0.0505251847,
0.0891628861,
-0.0549008809,
0.2951570749,
-0.4178987145,
0.4017675817,
-0.1475928426,
-0.4118199944,
-0.6116058826,
0.502702415,
0.2469750196,
-0.2048553824,
0.6202513576,
-0.0102252793,
-0.2302719504,
0.4838822484,
0.3674411774,
0.6017124653,
0.2194648385,
0.3940536082,
0.8806593418,
-0.0172443222,
-0.2352104634,
0.1467766017,
-0.2779684365,
-0.2738514245,
-0.3776416481,
-0.5115939975,
-0.4227342606,
0.1018925011,
-1.2871756554,
0.2940725386,
0.1249805242,
0.1091710627,
-0.0101145841,
-0.014342213,
-0.1401717514,
-0.0955388471,
0.2471418381,
1.0406842232,
-0.8501668572,
0.8144670129,
0.6552326083,
-0.4586882889,
-0.1294512004,
-0.5004540086,
-0.2499764264,
-0.4732400179,
0.2800350487,
0.442602694,
0.1515550762,
-0.0838309601,
-0.7812246084,
-0.6821593642,
0.9681439996,
0.3995469213,
-0.4364054799,
-0.7387588024,
-0.0497642718,
0.2913624644,
-0.4504887462,
0.2507913113,
0.8129591346,
0.5398738384,
-0.1678023785,
-0.4935995042,
-0.5221601725,
-0.5147124529,
-0.3877048492,
-0.0062196744,
-0.1232625395,
0.839957118,
-0.5469220877,
-0.2649138272,
0.5105961561,
0.8641855121,
0.3259973824,
0.5956581831,
0.2071056217,
0.5470789075,
0.4128414392,
0.0931295976,
0.8049687147,
-0.4014665484,
0.3493716121,
1.6125497818,
-0.154353112,
1.0141122341,
0.3869036734,
0.226389423,
0.728515029,
0.7291471362,
-0.0250176042,
0.6648982167,
0.117281571,
-0.1290556788,
0.0097542712,
0.0611524396,
-0.3373319209,
0.5021001697,
0.27968961,
-0.3819395006,
-1.0390855074,
-0.0414901078,
0.3019896746,
0.2213155031,
-0.1744337082,
1.0060772896,
0.0518641174,
-0.7824925184,
0.276789099,
0.215817973,
0.5664459467,
-0.6862218976,
-0.0140174031,
-0.2038261741,
0.1553634852,
-0.2597854435,
-0.4357561767,
0.6898416281,
0.4219390452,
-0.4752841294,
-0.0731277019,
0.6971492171,
-0.7461143732,
-0.5191532373,
0.1233226508,
0.7825108171,
0.5756770372,
-0.1463329643,
-0.2392757386,
-0.4646783471,
-0.3526946604,
-0.3851142824,
0.5040860176,
0.2058499157,
0.0991179273,
0.0397217125,
0.5006860495,
0.3345729113,
-0.0897885859,
-0.0056554009,
0.7959541082,
-0.4927117825,
-0.8227033019,
-0.768687129,
0.4259900749,
0.0150987422,
-0.3483350277,
0.6631864309,
1.1647850275,
0.722905755,
-0.2339186668,
1.1999768019,
0.0102659408,
0.8696822524,
-0.3418867588,
0.8552255034,
-0.2855740488,
-0.3677270412,
0.1914331019,
-0.8160488009,
0.0316326916,
0.5284292698,
0.0225584507,
-0.4730600715,
0.4948835075,
0.7921153307,
-0.040664088,
-0.0085496167,
0.1890684962,
0.045569621,
-0.1453141719,
0.5149294138,
0.8971489072,
-0.3214600384,
0.6272021532,
-0.0281996075,
-0.2539592385,
-0.4029635489,
-0.6562643647,
-0.9974209666,
-0.7103000879,
-0.1228633821,
-0.494235009,
0.3122667074,
0.8400856853,
0.7366046309,
-0.9006741047,
-0.3992601335,
0.0156869609,
-0.0267595313,
-0.274279803,
-0.2420096546,
0.4118039012,
-0.4535500705,
-0.6659427881,
0.3201161325,
0.2869241238,
-0.0265991427,
-0.2178784162,
-0.1015263572,
-0.1564139277,
-0.09649463,
0.6145090461,
0.4853839874,
-0.2808067799,
0.1992187053,
-0.0937484577,
-0.4480965436,
0.2759755254,
1.2083244324,
-0.7680537701,
-0.0943941623,
0.7027915716,
0.3817306459,
0.6706624627,
0.200079307,
0.4555389881,
-0.7366749644,
0.3057529628,
0.0518539809,
0.2584598064,
0.2703919411,
-0.1979905367,
0.6364049315,
0.0614266098,
-0.2095075995,
-0.7500978112,
-0.1001985744,
-0.9526777864,
-0.2750887275,
1.5400942564,
-0.3792024255,
-0.5037248135,
-0.3032274246,
-0.1001633331,
0.4953603745,
-0.312063396,
0.7610576153,
0.4757286012,
0.2660877109,
0.3646768332,
-0.5337172151,
0.4529326558,
-0.1387995183,
-1.0534566641,
0.3864926994,
0.3964448273,
0.3623065948,
-0.0053161983,
0.6904054284,
-0.346619308,
0.3703450859,
0.1194324046,
0.3290013075,
-0.5062869787,
-0.6418742537,
-0.3916837275,
0.2844603658,
-0.3107819855,
-0.2580596507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03543v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03543v2
|
CodeEditorBench: Evaluating Code Editing Capability of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T15:49:49 | 2024-04-06T04:29:25 |
Jiawei Guo, Ziming Li, Xueling Liu, Kaijing Ma, Tianyu Zheng, Zhouliang Yu, Ding Pan, Yizhi LI, Ruibo Liu, Yue Wang, Shuyue Guo, Xingwei Qu, Xiang Yue, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen, Jie Fu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) for code are rapidly evolving, with code editing
emerging as a critical capability. We introduce CodeEditorBench, an evaluation
framework designed to rigorously assess the performance of LLMs in code editing
tasks, including debugging, translating, polishing, and requirement switching.
Unlike existing benchmarks focusing solely on code generation, CodeEditorBench
emphasizes real-world scenarios and practical aspects of software development.
We curate diverse coding challenges and scenarios from five sources, covering
various programming languages, complexity levels, and editing tasks. Evaluation
of 19 LLMs reveals that closed-source models (particularly Gemini-Ultra and
GPT-4), outperform open-source models in CodeEditorBench, highlighting
differences in model performance based on problem types and prompt
sensitivities. CodeEditorBench aims to catalyze advancements in LLMs by
providing a robust platform for assessing code editing capabilities. We will
release all prompts and datasets to enable the community to expand the dataset
and benchmark emerging LLMs. By introducing CodeEditorBench, we contribute to
the advancement of LLMs in code editing and provide a valuable resource for
researchers and practitioners.
|
[
-0.1709555835,
-0.6566810608,
0.5290101767,
0.5743443966,
-0.0483433455,
0.4136512578,
-0.6664643288,
-0.2601317763,
-0.2082044333,
0.5380403399,
-0.3817559183,
-0.7768045068,
-0.3435162902,
0.2491216063,
-0.6343223453,
0.8781711459,
-0.413536042,
0.1142699346,
-0.5007548332,
0.1210519746,
-0.6659284234,
-0.4774813652,
-0.3396361172,
0.0379077718,
0.3084616959,
0.2519801855,
0.7280001044,
0.4164069295,
0.7318298221,
0.3584136367,
-0.2840795517,
-0.0705505162,
-0.5035808086,
0.1260420084,
-0.2520958483,
-0.3579273522,
-0.8373808861,
-0.052503977,
0.4189535379,
0.5399580598,
-0.1152862757,
0.3585113287,
-0.0009222031,
0.602186501,
-0.5760893822,
0.2683612108,
-0.5760242343,
0.0443700664,
-0.1785022467,
0.0557312965,
-0.1978238821,
-0.5665257573,
-0.402348727,
-0.3519241214,
0.0389177948,
-0.2913339436,
0.3040949106,
0.3585037291,
-0.0648621097,
-0.1595847607,
-0.4903425276,
0.3117584884,
-0.6419332027,
0.416190207,
0.0069673206,
0.2154974639,
-0.1295536906,
-1.0403723717,
-0.5653108358,
-0.4107438028,
0.2320604473,
-0.0005347257,
-0.3598123789,
0.2633360922,
0.5890635252,
0.5963897109,
-0.7125815153,
0.0881491974,
-0.4951545596,
-0.2295652628,
0.5754321218,
0.2692889571,
0.3975988328,
-0.2040174752,
0.0467713363,
0.0794412121,
-0.5602923036,
-0.1751255691,
0.5136004686,
-0.0572837256,
0.0152401198,
0.5719726086,
-0.2233410925,
0.7856405973,
-0.2180590034,
0.2029064298,
0.3236629367,
-0.2023947388,
-0.2001063675,
-0.1125330776,
0.5812477469,
0.6903740764,
0.0906910226,
-0.1727936417,
-0.4239499569,
0.2135544717,
0.2922390103,
-0.897970438,
-0.2396985739,
0.2367381454,
-0.5851591229,
-0.6056118011,
0.0516919047,
-0.9923544526,
-0.5162960291,
0.0254969541,
-0.0410701334,
0.0895531923,
-0.2600080371,
0.1711100787,
-0.1844734997,
-0.1996667087,
0.3643322587,
-0.5809518099,
0.1832702756,
0.9406408668,
0.786783278,
-0.3390836418,
-0.3568374813,
-0.5490307212,
-0.2729923427,
-0.5663411617,
0.519195199,
-0.7836790085,
-0.5747436881,
0.0982703269,
-0.0653953105,
0.1700306535,
-0.6492837667,
0.5784343481,
-0.7447050214,
-0.3057934642,
0.1897734702,
-0.5682498217,
0.0855403692,
0.3091905713,
-0.8840143681,
1.2105288506,
0.399325937,
-0.4643930197,
0.0634752586,
-0.6974831223,
-0.0636675656,
0.0443595946,
-0.1305909604,
-0.0760732666,
0.311191529,
0.1013930589,
0.2508992255,
-0.2750444114,
0.5535302758,
-0.3560376167,
-0.4285411835,
0.4195542932,
-0.3562183976,
0.535730958,
0.3386406898,
-0.0631906167,
0.637252748,
-0.9035394192,
0.1756078899,
-0.1176122874,
-0.5477915406,
-0.009585334,
-0.1031861976,
0.2854637504,
0.3278381228,
0.418463707,
-0.5592191815,
0.6267367601,
-0.1899595857,
0.5231053829,
0.7596217394,
0.0992089882,
-0.0114183538,
0.0254465938,
1.0668629408,
-0.3386754394,
0.273483783,
-0.1035628989,
-0.1151205823,
-0.4679951072,
-0.1296146363,
0.4871535003,
0.5403421521,
-0.6324334741,
0.405905962,
-0.24538517,
-0.6294398904,
-0.4364001155,
0.4870804548,
0.5137134194,
0.0412729196,
0.1587409526,
-0.3252683878,
-0.5669439435,
-0.7125840783,
-0.5091840029,
-0.0175274201,
-0.0359940194,
0.0505720787,
0.5290834904,
-0.5580736995,
0.7446427345,
-0.5008845329,
0.1979843229,
-0.6156205535,
-0.0662027225,
0.3077652454,
0.4762907922,
0.5710662007,
-0.4164226353,
-0.30286479,
-0.0972954556,
-0.5467098951,
-0.5166912675,
-0.1570276767,
-0.0725001544,
0.252762109,
0.835504353,
-0.4427793026,
0.3490414321,
1.003189683,
-0.3192473352,
0.5997424126,
-0.0160379484,
0.2780460715,
-0.6885525584,
0.2434441745,
-0.3553895056,
-0.278102845,
-0.2015247643,
0.3680341244,
0.4225412309,
-0.4628396928,
-0.2543354034,
0.3606372774,
-0.4475720525,
-0.3546354473,
-0.2677104473,
0.194949165,
0.1111852527,
0.1694216579,
-0.3320372999,
0.9557241201,
0.4016090333,
-0.1727695465,
0.7836774588,
0.2206071317,
-0.8287068009,
0.0304769073,
-0.7283841372,
0.457810849,
0.2436144054,
0.2629182339,
-0.6359862089,
-0.136037305,
-0.146372214,
-0.1845838279,
0.2590129673,
-0.1666728854,
-0.6537311077,
-0.5231027603,
-0.4194085896,
0.2119755596,
0.2586856186,
-0.6254598498,
0.4085763991,
0.0711695775,
-0.4012169838,
-0.4556459486,
-0.4896806479,
0.3954044282,
0.1327266395,
-0.6504111886,
0.2243323326,
-0.3732543588,
-0.4648118019,
0.0347007997,
-0.3360155523,
-0.2078231722,
0.3183510602,
0.3463237584,
0.4105066657,
0.0117052235,
0.2056605816,
0.0005034711,
-0.127879709,
0.125290364,
0.0666982532,
0.3893305957,
-0.1551464349,
-0.3642985523,
-0.0475591756,
0.0979423225,
0.5553267598,
-0.6458662152,
0.3469014764,
0.2066158056,
-0.1449954659,
-0.329325974,
-0.4846256375,
0.1938199252,
-0.4617560804,
0.8294202685,
-0.4800378978,
-1.0762075186,
0.6729747057,
-0.3890282214,
0.0583271794,
0.356164664,
0.6393033862,
0.6169598103,
0.8267636895,
0.7088193893,
-0.1227516457,
0.5216956735,
-0.0490201823,
0.1802520454,
-0.7360730767,
0.0119452868,
-0.6553767323,
-0.0659422055,
-0.4148520231,
-0.7510643005,
0.2549692094,
0.3034104705,
0.152760461,
0.144497335,
-0.3346267641,
0.8604356647,
-0.0403962247,
-0.0341333896,
0.5497599244,
-0.5015481114,
-0.011016828,
0.0748503953,
-0.5066037774,
-0.6025408506,
1.1783512831,
0.43794927,
0.9599834681,
0.0411895774,
0.4297207296,
0.446018517,
0.4895631075,
-0.6516003013,
0.5778968334,
0.0528605357,
-0.6392037868,
0.0405277498,
-0.4020693302,
-0.3209031224,
0.135392189,
0.0741129071,
-0.5330968499,
0.0197293479,
0.2484876961,
-0.2363687158,
0.3419428766,
-0.4818633795,
1.3197407722,
-0.3977946937,
-0.5584905744,
-0.4975536764,
-0.1714186966,
0.3452661335,
-0.2697878778,
0.2686028481,
0.1106028035,
-0.1523767114,
0.5543140769,
-0.3361636698,
0.6793136597,
-0.1578800231,
-0.2541700602,
0.1937019378,
0.4921866953,
0.4869469404,
0.1789696068,
-0.5233107805,
0.2790445089,
0.1260630786,
0.0017978774,
-0.7429351211,
0.8995364904,
-0.4549378455,
-0.5646708012,
-0.3012462556,
-0.4581567645,
-0.1570339799,
0.1752396375,
-0.093669787,
0.4870635569,
-0.7354263067,
0.15326868,
0.2296006531,
-0.5100905895,
0.3666977584,
0.5075558424,
-0.7460068464,
-0.3495261371,
0.597107172,
-0.2070874125,
0.2302610278,
0.0609317087,
-0.0088824034,
0.1094788089,
-0.8744357228,
-0.5709528923,
-0.2570827603,
-0.9858189821,
-0.2964148223,
-0.463699162,
0.0195050016,
-0.1183162108,
-0.2567701638,
-0.4757573307,
-0.4619413912,
-0.0251247287,
-0.3307865858,
0.4641345441,
0.8825004697,
0.0999602675,
0.068720527,
-1.1216899157,
0.1877830178,
-0.0263794437,
0.9249093533,
-0.2249787003,
-0.3992307186,
-0.3841228187,
-0.5095121861,
-0.2065494955,
-0.8603360057,
0.1609696448,
-0.0617563389,
0.4723822773,
0.084179759,
-0.075456813,
0.5858985186,
-0.4060715139,
0.8882029653,
-0.175400272,
-1.395547986,
0.3910043836,
-0.3191761374,
0.2895509005,
0.7449709773,
-0.0945661739,
-0.6248832941,
-0.3879901469,
-0.3431685865,
-0.6678043008,
0.5130304098,
-0.0453792922,
0.1954374015,
-0.0248549934,
0.3827248514,
0.0011014313,
0.4259558022,
-0.6805710196,
0.1558062285,
-0.1541795135,
-0.208122164,
-0.0421520956,
-0.4430651963,
0.0076511796,
-0.2501872182,
0.4714606702,
-0.1071546003,
-0.0576833412,
0.1390424371,
-0.3942520916,
-0.3274975419,
0.5982419252,
0.5338599086,
1.1350537539,
-0.3068659008,
-0.1856941283,
0.2097122222,
-0.2557361424,
-0.2031185329,
0.1167518273,
0.1601627171,
-0.0283028334,
0.5421795845,
0.815302968,
0.295434922,
-1.1675796509,
0.5275540948,
-0.1752541214,
-0.0315785557,
-0.2394446433,
0.2690497339,
0.0929429755,
0.2999819517,
-0.1201288179,
-0.0583363585,
0.3337751925,
-0.4867658019,
-0.0252831969,
0.1201596707,
-0.2202106416,
-0.145184055,
0.5096181631,
0.4090009034,
-0.1749541163,
0.6184530854,
-0.0271679442,
-0.6308982372,
0.71771878,
0.3168400824,
1.1196659803,
-0.0617429204,
-0.2286998332,
0.3293893933,
0.4669365287,
0.0812924653,
0.2170327753,
0.1061813757,
-0.3352714479,
-0.5187321901,
-0.6250352859,
-0.4903543591,
-0.0319571421,
-0.6556071639,
0.2896266282,
-0.4741402268,
-0.0015036121,
-0.1281075776,
-0.1875330508,
-0.4089886844,
-0.2747318745,
-0.1602325737,
1.3863896132,
-0.470962286,
0.7983433008,
0.74170506,
-0.2059773803,
-0.605196476,
-0.0012096706,
0.097570397,
-0.5581101179,
0.6585102677,
0.22387743,
-0.0041110502,
-0.0781392306,
-0.5659722686,
-0.4129500091,
0.787666142,
0.3523159325,
-0.9407671094,
0.143420279,
-0.1470267773,
0.5638070107,
-0.2968427539,
0.3395803273,
0.8370043635,
0.5565757751,
-0.4259250462,
-1.0677163601,
-0.0517803207,
-0.5740836859,
0.2873786688,
0.1340111792,
-0.5556681156,
0.744348228,
-0.1458266824,
0.1016146317,
0.392796278,
0.2579918206,
-0.0835481659,
0.088993527,
0.3620274365,
0.3736076057,
0.4628067911,
-0.0115250694,
1.1612884998,
-0.6572468877,
0.4644985497,
1.0503968,
-0.5458203554,
0.7866618037,
0.2900056243,
-0.2146937698,
0.4937695265,
0.3896027505,
-0.2641443014,
0.0743663386,
0.5547429919,
-0.16848737,
-0.1546154767,
0.2006501108,
-0.3730990589,
0.5445289612,
0.1545666456,
-0.4426425695,
-0.1521218568,
0.0072853896,
0.1189001203,
0.3153241575,
-0.280177176,
0.6721030474,
-0.2230454236,
-0.6162863374,
0.5151122212,
0.2776215971,
0.4707321227,
-0.6837787032,
-0.1834139228,
-0.2539158165,
0.3605225682,
-0.3606460094,
-0.7950142622,
0.4149895608,
0.6431846023,
-0.207064271,
-0.2811835408,
0.5675560832,
-0.1385791302,
-0.4799676538,
0.5082349777,
0.3335450292,
0.0708056986,
-0.2559484839,
-0.7557154894,
0.9034620523,
0.1755590737,
-0.515009582,
0.282530874,
0.2514622211,
-0.0212018285,
0.4005049765,
0.639101088,
0.1326168925,
-0.1243498325,
0.2414397746,
1.0455271006,
-0.714594245,
-0.3491141796,
-0.8170441985,
0.4555382729,
-0.0545346104,
-0.2729821801,
0.7807393074,
0.7608351111,
0.8925934434,
-0.3501271904,
0.8069924712,
-0.1644268334,
0.317653507,
-0.6196134686,
0.6574622393,
-0.2987381816,
0.4353830814,
-0.478951931,
-1.0460734367,
-0.2840106785,
0.4983065724,
-0.306104064,
0.1067324579,
0.6804400086,
0.9575584531,
0.1653094292,
0.0175544396,
0.3045743108,
0.4155624509,
0.42968449,
0.3380798101,
0.9142033458,
-0.0131357303,
0.5301769376,
-0.1907726079,
-0.445641458,
-0.1666707247,
-0.9719551802,
-1.0518493652,
-0.0909376368,
-0.287366569,
-0.2795928717,
0.0790903792,
1.0130587816,
0.25422737,
-0.6881887317,
-0.3485008776,
-0.1646119803,
0.0878828391,
-0.2475559562,
-0.2512590289,
0.0802745298,
-0.2673899233,
-0.6967113614,
0.6782040596,
0.3748547733,
-0.4087082446,
-0.4092155695,
0.0335477963,
0.275274992,
-0.150664106,
0.5937078595,
0.1000903696,
-0.4453520775,
-0.1011217758,
-0.0974141806,
-0.1990397424,
-0.1497491449,
1.0516960621,
-0.5279497504,
0.665487349,
0.5997163653,
0.7386388779,
0.210410893,
-0.1179268286,
0.5446020961,
-0.5691921711,
0.2221535295,
0.1643511355,
0.3957330585,
0.2324208021,
-0.2962294221,
0.5651572347,
-0.0191942882,
-0.6465477347,
-0.9952052832,
0.0121431658,
-0.9062649608,
-0.3445297778,
0.9747770429,
-0.1709346771,
0.1253210455,
0.1295691133,
-0.4802517891,
0.0862232894,
-0.2919587493,
0.6025899649,
0.8150354028,
0.0295121595,
-0.1339128166,
-1.0202668905,
0.3956760764,
0.2726334333,
-1.1128236055,
0.4583374262,
0.9876077771,
0.3039726615,
-0.0643411577,
0.4310078621,
-0.3090106249,
0.5583058596,
-0.07465294,
0.5802492499,
-0.3592532277,
-0.274965018,
-0.8203778267,
0.0808678642,
0.4763945937,
0.2841747701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03532v1
|
Evaluating Generative Language Models in Information Extraction as Subjective Question Correction
| 2024-04-04T15:36:53 | 2024-04-04T15:36:53 |
Yuchen Fan, Yantao Liu, Zijun Yao, Jifan Yu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable prowess in
various tasks necessitating sophisticated cognitive behaviors. Nevertheless, a
paradoxical performance discrepancy is observed, where these models
underperform in seemingly elementary tasks like relation extraction and event
extraction due to two issues in conventional evaluation. (1) The imprecision of
existing evaluation metrics that struggle to effectively gauge semantic
consistency between model outputs and ground truth, and (2) The inherent
incompleteness of evaluation benchmarks, primarily due to restrictive human
annotation schemas, resulting in underestimated LLM performances. Inspired by
the principles in subjective question correction, we propose a new evaluation
method, SQC-Score. This method innovatively utilizes LLMs, fine-tuned through
subjective question correction data, to refine matching between model outputs
and golden labels. Additionally, by incorporating a Natural Language Inference
(NLI) model, SQC-Score enriches golden labels, addressing benchmark
incompleteness by acknowledging correct yet previously omitted answers. Results
on three information extraction tasks show that SQC-Score is more preferred by
human annotators than the baseline metrics. Utilizing SQC-Score, we conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of the state-of-the-art LLMs and provide insights for
future research for information extraction. Dataset and associated codes can be
accessed at https://github.com/THU-KEG/SQC-Score.
|
[
-0.4557544589,
-0.9432606697,
0.529335916,
0.0968000516,
-0.1932576895,
-0.0305089988,
-0.4909245968,
-0.5254907012,
-0.1123381257,
0.3468948007,
-0.4940933585,
-0.7034605145,
-0.528382659,
0.2397025973,
-0.2145127654,
1.040068984,
0.1301266849,
-0.0058924751,
-0.6067208648,
-0.0639908314,
-0.3998828828,
-0.516446054,
-0.3817591965,
-0.2059319913,
0.4475420713,
0.542927146,
0.7932431102,
0.4216352105,
0.4634844363,
0.2970989645,
-0.0311577599,
0.3316245377,
-0.3271311224,
0.0032846308,
-0.1329900026,
-0.6304645538,
-0.3822744787,
0.265411526,
0.5751799345,
0.5920767784,
-0.1525184363,
0.2738952339,
-0.0389285199,
0.6028334498,
-0.7166544199,
0.2057249397,
-0.6288163066,
0.1301615387,
-0.0413003415,
-0.4618698657,
-0.4060367346,
-0.7086526155,
0.1635192633,
-0.5991258025,
0.3216759861,
0.1248833016,
0.9758595228,
0.2101745605,
-0.153536886,
-0.4881007671,
-0.7577902079,
0.7515001297,
-0.7930674553,
0.2021147609,
0.4792616069,
0.3353893161,
0.1042262763,
-0.5707316399,
-0.7374867797,
-0.4382079542,
0.1483553052,
0.2466514111,
-0.4445131421,
-0.0510482341,
0.3942978978,
0.6562668681,
-0.5135200024,
0.0349707119,
-0.3376704156,
-0.0633547157,
0.6634178758,
0.3035732806,
0.1812318265,
-0.5836189389,
-0.2987466156,
-0.0089380117,
-0.5245973468,
-0.105877839,
0.5042726398,
0.1497526467,
0.1714642495,
0.7448974252,
-0.2588894367,
0.5379954576,
0.1650604308,
0.1780027598,
0.3282120824,
-0.2253277302,
-0.1810096204,
-0.1673677564,
0.978953898,
0.3514209092,
0.4211710691,
-0.4924694002,
-0.1998239309,
-0.1698051989,
0.4613644481,
-0.5519576669,
-0.1349397898,
0.1411950439,
-0.2752731144,
-0.3888088167,
0.305975914,
-0.8323440552,
-0.2066220194,
-0.488579005,
0.5175899863,
-0.3139301538,
-0.2881740332,
0.1360845268,
-0.1069176421,
0.3092328906,
0.4529626966,
-0.5410138965,
0.2311608493,
0.838976562,
0.6519578695,
-0.3618477881,
0.1072605178,
-0.4236059785,
-0.3341743648,
-0.4027836919,
0.7813134789,
-0.677400291,
-0.4415006638,
-0.2215421796,
-0.1529340446,
0.0313227884,
-0.860963583,
0.8673478365,
-0.7670763731,
0.5545555353,
-0.4991199374,
-0.7405837178,
-0.0612533987,
0.3184644878,
-0.6682679653,
1.4202443361,
0.1786474288,
-0.9261237979,
0.1516276747,
-0.4360994697,
-0.1243244484,
0.2407499105,
-0.1579532921,
-0.3113757968,
0.0772400647,
0.1303680539,
0.2896930873,
-0.5928801298,
0.4384142458,
-0.4026693404,
-0.3293887675,
0.4603532553,
-0.5364927053,
0.7199422717,
0.1860855222,
-0.373021245,
0.0751306713,
-0.7602950335,
0.2605908513,
0.0243299976,
-0.4439685345,
-0.2853474319,
-0.1136624813,
-0.1227551624,
0.3326654434,
0.1918729097,
-0.4879658818,
0.1466160566,
-0.4002597332,
0.0752848908,
0.8735898733,
0.075307928,
0.4238105416,
-0.148785159,
0.6603574157,
-0.1382107735,
0.2364653051,
0.3108402193,
-0.4728340507,
-1.0082498789,
-0.1700249314,
0.6378150582,
0.5364406705,
-0.6738116741,
0.8290421367,
-0.505882442,
-0.517410934,
-0.813444078,
0.0518900491,
0.1897523254,
0.5380458236,
0.2413754165,
-0.5712895393,
-0.616239965,
-0.7569211125,
-0.4273065329,
-0.4541934729,
-0.203866601,
0.4459526241,
0.315400362,
0.0311521795,
1.1342530251,
-0.5490724444,
0.0300068986,
-0.1717085093,
0.5481553674,
0.2310553491,
0.2631268799,
-0.04916998,
-0.7949926257,
-0.0603696518,
-0.190990895,
-0.9854784012,
-0.2453849167,
-0.0561510138,
-0.1247319654,
-0.1187611893,
0.2330396026,
-0.8513208628,
0.3711097538,
0.2019807696,
-0.0459342338,
0.9679844975,
-0.0248440709,
0.3715797663,
-0.6186409593,
0.1725364178,
0.1247729659,
-0.3189768791,
-0.4663179517,
0.0930416882,
0.1030988097,
0.2024949789,
-0.2035740167,
0.4039667547,
-0.3559904099,
-0.2910258174,
-0.297414273,
0.5409464836,
0.2414512634,
0.3778706193,
-0.1648465246,
0.6294379234,
0.206540525,
-0.5218173265,
0.4180888534,
0.0252488367,
-0.5335010886,
0.3671664,
-0.5620537996,
0.5395848751,
-0.3213023543,
-0.01900387,
-0.8162789345,
0.0078519005,
0.4387153387,
-0.5568150282,
0.3350337744,
0.0314486623,
-0.6582535505,
-0.2470506132,
-0.2570746541,
0.2469045669,
0.331727922,
-0.3678863943,
0.6395742297,
0.4268352091,
-0.2481731623,
-0.4859722257,
-0.4231038392,
0.1844173074,
-0.1238098666,
-0.4918593466,
0.077932708,
-0.2151558101,
-0.2808921039,
-0.008008033,
-0.2048523426,
0.0447161645,
0.1110516936,
0.3509085476,
0.5575896502,
-0.3982776105,
0.2183528244,
-0.2886846364,
-0.0604586229,
0.2389702201,
0.0394978262,
0.2815055251,
-0.3763216138,
-0.40770787,
-0.2937368751,
0.1616700739,
0.2849686742,
-0.2335348278,
0.4424391985,
0.5200947523,
-0.4862626195,
0.1333723962,
-0.8101875186,
-0.0482009575,
-0.3913231194,
0.4868609309,
-0.4655512571,
-0.91539675,
0.1179713234,
-0.1438361406,
-0.1323746592,
0.7016795874,
0.5139135122,
-0.1144338548,
0.8515992761,
0.3502374589,
-0.1689340472,
0.1709198207,
-0.0709468722,
0.2413363308,
-0.8016303182,
-0.3389551342,
-0.6879657507,
0.1476326287,
-0.4503740966,
-0.6085568666,
0.3269640803,
0.5638309121,
0.2434245497,
0.1306279749,
-0.3096164763,
0.4168829918,
0.3358789682,
0.0603246875,
0.4492550492,
-0.165608272,
0.0341864936,
-0.2196180224,
-0.6658611298,
-0.8664233685,
1.0074174404,
0.3820624948,
0.4481026828,
-0.0670477524,
0.4764498472,
0.5006664395,
0.6233231425,
-0.7471095324,
0.4555584192,
-0.0179890394,
-0.6918968558,
-0.2887120545,
-0.6851215959,
-0.5762761831,
0.45183146,
-0.2769296169,
-0.7305042148,
0.1896045804,
-0.1859094501,
-0.3775017262,
0.0570979305,
-0.652769506,
0.8853957653,
-0.3343849182,
-0.3850790262,
-0.1140693054,
-0.5809448361,
0.473574847,
-0.072178632,
0.2764664292,
-0.361889869,
0.1273843646,
0.7463662028,
-0.0893001705,
0.6731284261,
-0.1300171763,
-0.056339547,
0.3939811289,
0.0130009716,
0.5454807281,
0.046051845,
-0.4079519808,
0.3294164836,
-0.1160134152,
-0.0841062441,
-0.8352099061,
0.4726480246,
-0.6676441431,
-0.6925270557,
-0.414685607,
-0.2281310856,
-0.3049206734,
-0.0035639328,
0.1567471027,
0.084171243,
-0.4913013875,
-0.1147884503,
0.596308887,
-0.2831262648,
0.1530963778,
0.579264164,
-0.0861413032,
-0.4002972245,
0.8073225021,
-0.1722133458,
0.0962200537,
0.4490364492,
0.1372635812,
-0.4676192701,
-0.2002568543,
-0.4468149543,
0.1093918532,
-0.8285809755,
-0.369510293,
-0.8744114637,
-0.3622129261,
-0.3583889306,
0.4838391542,
-0.2799131274,
-0.464589715,
-0.6037046313,
-0.2571116388,
-0.0282482486,
0.5110577941,
-0.0600612983,
-0.0973023996,
-0.7478021383,
0.4604126513,
0.2666017115,
-0.0154086351,
0.0797033906,
-0.702624023,
-0.0139381904,
0.0139834089,
-0.3911597133,
-0.85988307,
0.0813724697,
0.2120345682,
0.4661788344,
0.3702746034,
-0.0316677354,
0.9021035433,
-0.2682110071,
0.6631321311,
0.1594302654,
-0.9569565654,
0.3886356652,
0.1343487352,
0.3043848574,
0.6215634942,
0.4567563832,
-0.6103476286,
-0.333367914,
-0.6624392271,
-0.7419447899,
0.6326844692,
0.2443565279,
-0.0222458318,
-0.1134406403,
0.5632639527,
0.2743484676,
0.1788391471,
-0.6995480657,
-0.1885161251,
-0.0564689152,
-0.3378595114,
0.0718524083,
-0.4858196378,
0.307644546,
-0.2163808793,
0.6437153816,
0.0464122742,
0.0819979981,
0.3270322978,
-0.2168916166,
-0.3235237896,
0.5089297295,
0.166016832,
0.6238792539,
-0.2482724339,
0.1815519929,
0.1869822741,
-0.1130884215,
-0.1791198999,
0.0730697215,
-0.1845362782,
0.1012545526,
0.4571118951,
0.7376635671,
0.2726550996,
-0.752681911,
0.8143364787,
-0.2918172181,
0.0278103389,
-0.3224574924,
0.094171457,
0.0147789596,
0.2338789701,
0.4080090821,
0.180644244,
0.3299185634,
-0.4474080205,
0.260310322,
0.466055721,
-0.5680553317,
-0.4464532435,
0.4482818246,
-0.1962037683,
-0.2435269505,
0.6758269072,
-0.1419876963,
-0.5838217735,
0.3616050482,
0.1846701652,
0.8979904652,
-0.2039250582,
0.3971682191,
0.5297039747,
0.4390535355,
-0.0631432384,
0.1477613747,
-0.3250620067,
-0.7007003427,
-0.4720462859,
-0.8208229542,
-0.161549449,
0.1961499155,
-0.8651666045,
0.1909428537,
-0.1979079843,
-0.2035289109,
0.1449189335,
0.0877329484,
-0.7705397606,
0.5030198693,
0.1965612471,
0.7411931753,
-0.6361610889,
0.7169499397,
0.3240688443,
-0.4799866974,
-0.6653187871,
-0.0969992802,
-0.1712787002,
-0.4924755394,
0.5713029504,
0.1227096617,
-0.0462786332,
-0.2113530338,
-0.4613577127,
-0.6243636608,
0.7279472947,
0.3316844702,
-0.7892433405,
-0.1391204149,
0.4274894297,
0.7833874226,
-0.4112283587,
0.6291519403,
0.7190764546,
0.4546079636,
0.013381226,
-0.5547006726,
0.1576643437,
-0.2667950988,
-0.13360174,
-0.143209964,
-0.2616847754,
0.4852472842,
-0.2364651263,
-0.4575415254,
0.2012504041,
0.6502866745,
0.2033182085,
0.2534555793,
0.6127002239,
0.600785017,
0.8193084002,
-0.0441882201,
0.9798679352,
0.1191497147,
0.4490055144,
1.2217441797,
-0.2397478819,
0.8938590884,
0.3994838297,
-0.307354629,
0.3777740896,
0.5946070552,
-0.0865466446,
0.3836802244,
0.3251140118,
-0.2263032794,
-0.4604692459,
0.0418159962,
-0.1842858046,
0.6138935685,
0.0843444914,
-0.2967713475,
-0.1238628998,
-0.4105108082,
-0.1821335703,
-0.158195883,
0.0479066372,
0.9290266037,
0.1138868108,
-0.7205449939,
0.6241050959,
0.2653454244,
0.3575205803,
-0.4138541222,
-0.1188346595,
-0.289480567,
-0.136785537,
-0.1733565331,
-0.4928897619,
0.1470481008,
0.3533699811,
-0.3011344373,
0.209782809,
0.6611986756,
-0.426959902,
-0.402807653,
0.1282747686,
0.4655590355,
0.3619099259,
-0.376611501,
-0.863263309,
0.0175997,
0.1549195051,
-0.1418471336,
0.0286539216,
0.5924550891,
0.0143772783,
0.4813528061,
0.6733377576,
0.1795005649,
0.176231876,
0.2873092592,
0.776630044,
-0.7636033297,
-0.0492234789,
-0.8869539499,
0.4793419242,
-0.2747250199,
-0.4815461338,
0.7690781355,
0.8855487704,
0.7676126957,
-0.0262119621,
0.8821179271,
-0.026599668,
0.3858087361,
-0.4148260951,
0.3364306092,
-0.4783804119,
0.479655385,
-0.4963911474,
-1.0574736595,
-0.1073642448,
0.3704113066,
-0.4616864622,
0.0137882633,
0.6081780791,
0.8364349008,
0.1478566527,
0.5247408152,
0.3270591497,
0.2463637441,
0.1679178029,
0.4418065846,
1.3101040125,
-0.6771848202,
0.3897931874,
-0.1459607482,
-0.3707199991,
-0.1317750067,
-0.7051025033,
-0.5440436006,
-0.4888701141,
-0.5471770167,
-0.260434866,
0.1324587613,
0.5427387953,
0.4927197695,
-0.8710624576,
-0.0019756469,
-0.0217964519,
0.1307461113,
0.019276591,
-0.3488330245,
0.3680885136,
-0.2854943275,
-0.5423371792,
0.308424443,
0.4100134671,
-0.2853674293,
-0.1472001821,
-0.10515026,
-0.161093533,
-0.124733068,
0.438341558,
0.1393560618,
-0.8198242784,
-0.235067293,
-0.0758263618,
-0.2464368194,
0.3335367441,
0.827773571,
-0.6402748227,
0.5537801385,
0.2706300318,
0.6402024031,
0.6020174623,
0.3443084359,
0.3520459533,
-0.724455297,
-0.2783873975,
0.485527426,
0.0309104547,
0.697460115,
-0.3504979908,
0.3901818991,
0.2490974963,
-0.384888798,
-0.6560325027,
-0.127219364,
-0.9026613832,
-0.2548805475,
1.2149096727,
-0.2155269831,
-0.2512491345,
-0.092018038,
-0.230342418,
0.4122444391,
-0.0315171331,
1.1267071962,
0.7348700166,
0.1492862403,
-0.1340727508,
-0.5378411412,
0.2885756493,
0.4984017015,
-0.8798588514,
0.1774708033,
0.5811330676,
0.4180018008,
0.153781414,
0.5774664879,
-0.5610309243,
0.2257761061,
-0.2618798018,
0.3441573679,
0.1770783514,
-0.1163100079,
-0.2687158883,
0.3654833734,
0.2881340086,
-0.0664371625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03528v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03528v3
|
BanglaAutoKG: Automatic Bangla Knowledge Graph Construction with Semantic Neural Graph Filtering
| 2024-04-04T15:31:21 | 2024-06-05T13:39:56 |
Azmine Toushik Wasi, Taki Hasan Rafi, Raima Islam, Dong-Kyu Chae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.NE, cs.SI
|
Knowledge Graphs (KGs) have proven essential in information processing and
reasoning applications because they link related entities and give context-rich
information, supporting efficient information retrieval and knowledge
discovery; presenting information flow in a very effective manner. Despite
being widely used globally, Bangla is relatively underrepresented in KGs due to
a lack of comprehensive datasets, encoders, NER (named entity recognition)
models, POS (part-of-speech) taggers, and lemmatizers, hindering efficient
information processing and reasoning applications in the language. Addressing
the KG scarcity in Bengali, we propose BanglaAutoKG, a pioneering framework
that is able to automatically construct Bengali KGs from any Bangla text. We
utilize multilingual LLMs to understand various languages and correlate
entities and relations universally. By employing a translation dictionary to
identify English equivalents and extracting word features from pre-trained BERT
models, we construct the foundational KG. To reduce noise and align word
embeddings with our goal, we employ graph-based polynomial filters. Lastly, we
implement a GNN-based semantic filter, which elevates contextual understanding
and trims unnecessary edges, culminating in the formation of the definitive KG.
Empirical findings and case studies demonstrate the universal effectiveness of
our model, capable of autonomously constructing semantically enriched KGs from
any text.
|
[
-0.3833217323,
-0.7523695827,
0.1449727863,
0.21182473,
-0.4030673802,
0.1125755161,
0.2007814199,
-0.5646194816,
0.4470230639,
0.4474104941,
-0.3118953705,
-0.7221189141,
-0.7201009393,
0.2541730106,
-0.1909208149,
0.8271995187,
0.0575024039,
-0.12111862,
-0.232186228,
0.0252258498,
-0.5392795205,
-0.0051600803,
-0.5355618,
-0.8915553689,
0.6248375177,
-0.0069692573,
0.7261054516,
0.7360557914,
-0.0095795868,
0.2697759867,
-0.1304608732,
0.7026229501,
-0.3453475833,
0.237603426,
-0.1314501315,
-0.2081081569,
-0.2730407715,
-0.4471850693,
0.5383257866,
0.9926963449,
0.3484776616,
0.0590340532,
-0.051474791,
0.7820267081,
-0.6147504449,
0.5771282911,
-0.6920784712,
0.0512465648,
-0.056984406,
-0.0892686099,
-0.1925192475,
-0.7415821552,
-0.2253095061,
-0.5184069872,
-0.2838783264,
0.2437147051,
0.9657731056,
0.3672368824,
-0.8097218871,
-0.5042848587,
-0.159143582,
0.2867896259,
-0.597364068,
0.5833101273,
0.8036983609,
0.285022825,
-0.4392598569,
-0.8068140745,
-0.4805855453,
0.0721932128,
-0.4328015149,
0.0978469625,
0.0507556759,
0.1355870515,
-0.2084652036,
0.0331831686,
-0.6555571556,
-0.1673904657,
-0.5890362263,
-0.3746720254,
0.6297869086,
0.0003733683,
0.2248605341,
-0.8700397015,
-0.0837150738,
0.4233361781,
-0.8195940256,
-0.2561862767,
0.5179653168,
0.5018802881,
0.2289647907,
0.5849493146,
-0.3890216649,
1.3313810825,
-0.1299450099,
-0.3666308224,
0.0309570637,
-0.2697084248,
-0.2875129282,
0.3963462412,
0.6228554249,
0.2635235488,
0.4225013852,
-0.4207467735,
0.1437868178,
-0.1022966802,
0.1025396734,
-0.8369706273,
-0.5360135436,
-0.0049174521,
-0.5030348897,
-0.1506891698,
-0.3935802579,
-0.5146387815,
-0.6548557281,
-0.3199506104,
0.2764929235,
-0.6018489599,
-0.2454115599,
-0.2439498454,
0.0190112237,
-0.0324851573,
0.0612383522,
-0.7409818769,
-0.2628129721,
0.2724705935,
0.8334659934,
0.1765872985,
-0.0741943717,
-0.1654792279,
0.5449764729,
-0.4981353879,
0.9233172536,
-0.4340459108,
-0.4159970284,
0.0528653152,
-0.2268428355,
-0.0967946127,
-0.4691295326,
0.2892330289,
-0.8782377243,
-0.3039296269,
-0.1524638832,
-0.9153069854,
-0.5439975262,
0.4905985594,
-0.363398701,
0.89795959,
0.2962196171,
-0.7547976971,
0.4997008741,
-0.5371854901,
-0.7344743609,
0.4107944369,
-0.1188479736,
-0.0839648023,
-0.3297598362,
0.4119979143,
0.6072918177,
-0.2494210601,
0.4157623649,
-0.2856669426,
-0.2581293881,
-0.1002557352,
0.0337099507,
0.893286109,
0.4716641307,
0.058061745,
0.0804674253,
-0.9769594073,
0.3258265555,
0.003566517,
-0.3581226468,
-0.4094006121,
0.0355897434,
-0.2075236291,
-0.0057698139,
0.2427763939,
-0.3794256747,
0.2008091211,
-0.5886595845,
0.3870664537,
0.6182991266,
0.1164226159,
0.2718532979,
-0.1088899449,
0.3039173484,
-0.1904473305,
-0.129676491,
-0.2056094557,
-0.8888086677,
-0.4877237082,
-0.3693578541,
0.4929494262,
0.4664416015,
-0.7689865828,
0.7177863121,
-0.3812925816,
-0.5495145917,
-0.4972799718,
0.5687596202,
0.1204861179,
0.7542253137,
0.120606333,
0.0274145603,
-0.6468098164,
-0.8998906612,
-0.1073808819,
-0.3384887576,
0.1808656901,
0.1324381828,
0.4143305719,
-0.4289708436,
1.4924520254,
-0.5961759686,
-0.3409120739,
-0.2374042273,
0.0411161631,
0.1074080914,
0.2110970616,
0.4801389575,
-1.2084298134,
-0.6563034654,
0.1704730242,
-0.987211287,
-0.4127912819,
0.2922641933,
-0.2330552936,
0.199483335,
0.5388973355,
-0.4632427394,
0.7066716552,
0.3029553592,
-0.4997851551,
0.6062981486,
-0.0507524163,
0.000432384,
-1.1368107796,
0.0325193852,
-0.3943189979,
-0.4686584473,
-0.5175023675,
-0.0609927438,
-0.0735688955,
-0.1359721869,
-0.062364649,
0.9497516155,
-0.259734273,
0.0089238612,
-0.5020142794,
0.4469749928,
0.096498929,
0.4483528733,
-0.2149585932,
0.3085304499,
0.2802691162,
-0.7223260403,
0.6367019415,
0.5660017133,
-0.3771240115,
0.5880947709,
-0.3387693167,
-0.1412820965,
-0.0871552676,
0.2671993077,
-1.2050116062,
-0.4936435819,
0.5302081108,
-0.5676724315,
0.3367943764,
-0.5496709943,
-0.6880576611,
-0.5857646465,
0.2367338538,
0.2053685188,
0.355745554,
-0.6044197679,
0.7895873189,
0.4085639715,
-0.2093028277,
-0.5404644608,
-0.8240531683,
0.2472318709,
0.0939665362,
-0.8284669518,
0.0694128424,
0.0267888103,
0.0047279312,
0.3921138644,
-0.0513205528,
-0.3985782266,
-0.1355502009,
0.439822495,
0.01551273,
0.1954139024,
0.4144718051,
0.274645716,
-0.0506006405,
-0.0329085365,
-0.7366400361,
0.5202229023,
0.0091342283,
-0.4550598264,
0.0011176681,
0.1996704638,
0.3519084156,
0.0231205709,
0.8345502019,
1.0084896088,
-0.5058410168,
-0.1178358197,
-0.5694869161,
0.0917020291,
-0.4680327475,
0.4518889487,
-0.3059414625,
-0.9765921831,
0.6239967942,
-0.2806488872,
-0.3566679358,
0.2905649543,
0.5326989293,
0.2570568323,
0.8603524566,
0.4431183338,
-0.0288757514,
0.0801441371,
-0.1321871877,
0.7810588479,
-0.6210918427,
-0.4710561037,
-0.1781543493,
-0.2015176415,
-0.6213386655,
-0.084151268,
0.2918533981,
0.4687230885,
-0.2945529819,
0.1150356829,
-0.7307217121,
0.4832502306,
0.4596159458,
-0.0262911469,
0.1981143951,
-0.0771048963,
-0.3893237114,
0.049222827,
-1.0408889055,
-0.3707992435,
1.0578774214,
-0.3100576103,
0.4229584634,
-0.2040442973,
0.795676887,
0.3595437706,
0.44496876,
-0.7128832936,
0.5836141706,
0.0262288675,
-0.7626247406,
-0.1399291456,
-0.6324282289,
-0.9610507488,
0.19933559,
-0.1186030209,
-0.9457631707,
-0.015222365,
0.139199093,
-0.1519452035,
0.6010639668,
-0.890462935,
0.7512686849,
-0.0251099989,
-0.2945085764,
0.002814658,
-0.6186213493,
0.5643203855,
-0.1897578239,
0.3945799172,
-0.1918013841,
0.2695984244,
0.7210464478,
-0.5096594095,
0.927513957,
-0.3102034032,
0.0538136475,
0.7085405588,
0.1299501508,
0.4289977551,
0.0061457688,
-0.0954332128,
0.1277189106,
-0.0569304265,
-0.5091683269,
-0.6007342339,
0.7038135529,
-0.5972389579,
-0.2613069117,
-0.1512704492,
-0.9561338425,
-0.2159026265,
0.5847407579,
0.0562574826,
0.3601616025,
0.2393018603,
0.0139546711,
0.1590746343,
-0.2367798388,
0.2380057275,
0.1793148369,
-0.6837939024,
-0.6723179221,
1.1154093742,
0.5191426873,
-0.1967020631,
0.2825777829,
0.2053060085,
-0.5503386259,
-0.6693184972,
-0.396500349,
0.1049028933,
-1.0366879702,
-0.5235417485,
-0.6296582818,
-0.4929122329,
-0.7177781463,
-0.3842073083,
-0.0691683292,
-0.4446639121,
0.0697289929,
-0.0580869168,
0.6808192134,
1.0075110197,
-0.4311979115,
0.4024572968,
-0.7671434879,
0.3788949847,
0.4803916514,
0.376441896,
0.1903317571,
-0.2093176842,
-0.521826148,
-0.097899802,
-0.2011863291,
-0.782189846,
0.5834221244,
0.2197810113,
0.3848336339,
0.4917119741,
0.2700866163,
0.711019516,
-0.3177649975,
0.6570563912,
0.2001202106,
-0.727471292,
0.5480167866,
-0.4453940392,
0.331201762,
0.3163284361,
0.5271444321,
-0.3563485742,
-0.2541194856,
-0.2232622504,
-1.1727616787,
0.4504822195,
0.2548180521,
-0.2535791695,
-0.2184751332,
0.7140324712,
0.045678623,
0.4297103286,
-0.76423347,
-0.3197003305,
-0.5206664801,
-0.3949979842,
0.4202104211,
-0.2763601542,
-0.0137312664,
-0.4746323526,
0.8574778438,
-0.2512509227,
0.0983256921,
0.1431514025,
-0.2712650597,
0.0753794163,
0.0337947085,
0.1500209272,
0.8348591924,
-0.3454638124,
0.1443553418,
-0.0065715853,
-0.3474187851,
0.1699061394,
0.2607932687,
-0.5591686964,
-0.0587246567,
0.2725488245,
0.7240567803,
0.1797036678,
-0.5866149068,
0.0425678603,
0.3722755015,
-0.0242405199,
-0.1836344898,
0.0025979409,
0.5087445378,
0.2465308607,
0.4397993088,
-0.1293350458,
-0.152645275,
-0.1948412508,
0.2366722673,
0.2540844679,
-0.2541697323,
0.0911832824,
0.5781015754,
0.0167414807,
-0.3334009647,
0.5174321532,
-0.858422637,
-0.7645455599,
0.2955360115,
0.6761929989,
0.538345933,
-0.0446950346,
0.3150091171,
0.5086891651,
0.3516635597,
0.4081419408,
0.0663274378,
-0.3311894834,
-0.8309481144,
-0.6521270871,
-1.0963687897,
-0.1628660262,
-0.0870885253,
-0.1812500507,
-0.1275876015,
-0.3452964127,
-0.142269522,
-0.1709006429,
0.2735641897,
-0.3995974362,
0.3330206871,
0.0200932622,
0.7498253584,
-0.6791969538,
0.7656989694,
0.8084337115,
-0.3435177505,
-0.8086393476,
-0.5664700866,
-0.092518881,
-0.9730085135,
1.182008028,
0.1449207962,
-0.0425776467,
0.1589247137,
-0.346219331,
-0.8631270528,
1.0456713438,
0.4323531091,
-0.0986835063,
-0.1117948815,
0.3371887803,
0.2436580956,
-0.329164058,
0.178823486,
0.4762504101,
0.9799520969,
0.4315965176,
-0.4898202419,
-0.02640629,
-0.4257457852,
-0.1806536466,
0.2350154668,
-0.5575018525,
0.4716403186,
0.1726349443,
0.115617089,
-0.0036918409,
0.6262857914,
0.0883485675,
0.3349251449,
0.3026854992,
0.7986139059,
0.997568965,
-0.1767632365,
0.9048617482,
-0.58463341,
0.0160082038,
0.9169021845,
-0.1395148039,
0.293017894,
0.2019256502,
-0.1201009378,
0.5022484064,
0.8342298269,
0.007716272,
0.513181746,
0.2454235554,
-0.1873841882,
-0.3749195933,
-0.4135956168,
-0.2436956763,
0.4686043262,
0.4477377236,
-0.0874525234,
-0.5533390641,
0.0607842207,
0.0531794168,
-0.0457352251,
-0.5351580977,
0.4927989244,
0.1353311986,
-0.3415168226,
0.7338882685,
-0.1500045508,
0.5294924378,
-1.2141635418,
0.1575495601,
-0.0615324639,
0.0274151731,
-0.4047658741,
-0.4721342921,
0.637199223,
-0.1379819959,
-0.2360697985,
-0.0373297743,
1.2335122824,
-0.5526453853,
-0.5635313988,
0.5630514622,
0.5041364431,
0.165590629,
-0.014617186,
-0.4387692809,
-0.148371622,
0.0001974066,
-0.1540965289,
0.4213890731,
0.4673407376,
0.0965763256,
0.8596128225,
0.6045822501,
0.4229830801,
0.3197523654,
-0.0433835424,
0.7416066527,
-0.3167728484,
-0.6874290109,
-0.6483120322,
0.2340676636,
-0.1845004708,
0.0088578286,
0.8880670071,
0.4694946408,
0.7188431025,
0.2019505501,
0.9670282006,
-0.302433461,
0.1047231406,
-0.3886584342,
1.3653380871,
-0.6409648657,
-0.1840754449,
-0.1635398865,
-0.9918548465,
-0.593988061,
0.761836946,
-0.2863295078,
0.0094771842,
0.4106605649,
0.8093264699,
0.110819295,
0.1325105727,
0.4505711496,
0.3673946261,
0.2748190463,
0.2924120724,
0.4401631653,
-0.4083714783,
0.8215965629,
-0.0171445459,
-0.036476396,
-0.1676144451,
-1.0294574499,
-1.0996603966,
-0.6145319343,
-0.2211551368,
-0.2464055866,
0.1468059272,
0.9875251055,
0.9960135818,
-0.7931904793,
-0.0855803266,
-0.1433592588,
0.7438370585,
0.2174924761,
-0.2407836467,
0.7350738645,
-0.4781980515,
-0.3424400985,
0.5567520261,
0.4093747735,
-0.126448229,
-0.0609433614,
-0.136582002,
-0.5196714997,
0.0228437893,
0.678948462,
0.3375525475,
-0.3902699649,
-0.2863180041,
-0.48555094,
0.3677865267,
-0.0257158633,
0.4738195837,
-0.8966146111,
0.8066820502,
0.4093434513,
0.9411594868,
0.5208293796,
-0.3035623133,
0.2672189772,
-0.8569026589,
0.2642590106,
0.0515756384,
0.4615924954,
0.6063091755,
-0.162844494,
0.5869866014,
0.5602802634,
-0.5673408508,
-0.8668162227,
0.4403124452,
-0.6043292284,
-0.4245402813,
0.9205631614,
-0.1361811012,
-0.4569216967,
-0.5175901055,
-0.0748240054,
0.6406995654,
-0.0718503147,
0.8630424142,
0.7913922071,
-0.1640921235,
0.2595457733,
-0.318729043,
0.2088897228,
-0.0557993762,
-0.5166574717,
-0.1341388524,
0.3997930884,
0.0956702009,
0.3756726682,
0.6943898201,
0.1890651137,
-0.1224260479,
0.1934203357,
-0.0563293956,
-0.6709574461,
-0.2288482934,
0.3110595942,
0.5547674298,
-0.1906386614,
0.2378649861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03514v1
|
Learn When (not) to Trust Language Models: A Privacy-Centric Adaptive Model-Aware Approach
| 2024-04-04T15:21:22 | 2024-04-04T15:21:22 |
Chengkai Huang, Rui Wang, Kaige Xie, Tong Yu, Lina Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented large language models (LLMs) have been remarkably
competent in various NLP tasks. Despite their great success, the knowledge
provided by the retrieval process is not always useful for improving the model
prediction, since in some samples LLMs may already be quite knowledgeable and
thus be able to answer the question correctly without retrieval. Aiming to save
the cost of retrieval, previous work has proposed to determine when to do/skip
the retrieval in a data-aware manner by analyzing the LLMs' pretraining data.
However, these data-aware methods pose privacy risks and memory limitations,
especially when requiring access to sensitive or extensive pretraining data.
Moreover, these methods offer limited adaptability under fine-tuning or
continual learning settings. We hypothesize that token embeddings are able to
capture the model's intrinsic knowledge, which offers a safer and more
straightforward way to judge the need for retrieval without the privacy risks
associated with accessing pre-training data. Moreover, it alleviates the need
to retain all the data utilized during model pre-training, necessitating only
the upkeep of the token embeddings. Extensive experiments and in-depth analyses
demonstrate the superiority of our model-aware approach.
|
[
-0.1078706086,
-0.4013258815,
0.5620089769,
0.039597854,
-0.1554628909,
0.2087458372,
-0.1190489903,
-0.5160087347,
-0.1167156249,
0.4472545683,
-0.2129736394,
-0.5633522272,
-0.789521277,
-0.2638083696,
-0.6159225106,
0.7586231232,
0.1389091611,
-0.0520079248,
-0.2728685141,
-0.1283902526,
-0.1655469388,
-0.8245890141,
-0.5787380338,
-0.1320814192,
0.4486438334,
0.1172901765,
0.6437487602,
0.8059750795,
0.1809130907,
0.1939851493,
-0.2428412735,
0.0827388614,
-0.3657826781,
0.0592759103,
-0.4714919329,
-0.635725677,
-0.4383812249,
0.0390255414,
0.4940770268,
0.6285766363,
-0.3314383328,
0.1286450028,
0.1409447342,
0.6802617908,
-0.9579402804,
0.1632034481,
-1.0960723162,
0.2686648965,
-0.0537007712,
-0.2715192139,
-0.6136320233,
-0.4316033125,
0.3542832136,
-0.5851243138,
-0.0010592745,
0.2772067487,
0.504119575,
0.1178699508,
-0.2273278087,
-0.1622304171,
-0.5322058201,
0.7639244199,
-0.6506741047,
0.721975565,
0.9190297127,
0.0218400806,
0.0191215631,
-0.6870283484,
-0.4350250065,
-0.3596329987,
-0.0692173615,
-0.1920796782,
-0.0640558973,
-0.063608028,
0.1858717501,
0.2983587384,
-0.450119406,
0.2342711687,
-0.1446210146,
-0.5129387379,
0.3340395391,
-0.163611263,
0.0190638658,
-0.0465945341,
-0.4942824841,
0.0407319963,
-0.8752086759,
-0.0185161904,
0.3454168439,
0.3189873993,
-0.1915671974,
0.5659013391,
0.0179458149,
0.5103743076,
0.1538511962,
0.0850938559,
0.2919785082,
-0.2520868182,
-0.2571772635,
0.0617061444,
0.6946249008,
-0.0641568974,
0.4950954318,
-0.4836299419,
-0.143116951,
-0.1614967585,
0.2997256815,
-0.6400505304,
-0.1274334043,
0.2903704941,
-0.3506376445,
-0.2522118688,
-0.1294659227,
-0.4381965101,
-0.4292594194,
-0.2118381411,
0.538538754,
-0.4383112192,
-0.2510530353,
0.1280215234,
0.2855924368,
0.0973152742,
0.1145846993,
-0.9168772697,
0.3354854882,
0.7916637659,
0.7998635769,
-0.1742198467,
-0.3180339932,
-0.6213272214,
0.3025657535,
-0.4216611981,
0.1347851455,
-0.4936212599,
-0.6025967002,
0.0303716343,
0.084535718,
-0.1127508804,
-0.380556643,
0.2056156099,
-0.8351026177,
0.2160614133,
-0.2741062641,
-0.7941252589,
-0.1601916552,
0.3678666949,
-0.5022804141,
0.7194157839,
-0.0478649214,
-0.9453680515,
0.2733534276,
-0.5037947297,
-0.2627415955,
-0.2566750646,
-0.0663355067,
-0.4083754122,
0.1851429641,
0.3182636201,
0.6305246949,
0.2676909566,
0.2887283862,
-0.5373399854,
-0.1431758404,
0.3458120823,
-0.2912191749,
0.7978973985,
0.17229186,
-0.2454605401,
0.027604837,
-0.681355238,
-0.0556763746,
0.0358979069,
-0.055594407,
-0.506403625,
0.0015246973,
-0.4125254452,
0.0348051675,
0.5961465836,
-0.5489037037,
-0.2594884038,
-0.4558797479,
0.2507510185,
1.2409260273,
-0.187450394,
0.830978334,
-0.3368747234,
0.4249888062,
0.1619981825,
0.5571151972,
-0.2261815816,
-0.2610008121,
-0.6205120087,
-0.1336329877,
0.4700319767,
0.4994657636,
-0.519574821,
0.4442723095,
-0.225559026,
-0.4547923505,
-0.3962618113,
0.267825067,
0.5177899599,
0.558008194,
0.2863814831,
-0.4760439694,
-0.4394404888,
-0.7035431862,
-0.4585292041,
-0.3554335237,
0.2101229131,
0.6443557739,
0.3413189352,
-0.0221507177,
0.8640006781,
-0.3338331282,
-0.0900751203,
0.0977606773,
-0.2672213018,
-0.1007464081,
0.6798797846,
0.3823307455,
-0.8285606503,
-0.4709713459,
0.0309373494,
-0.7003653646,
0.2799105644,
0.1435770094,
-0.1466501802,
0.1533113569,
0.525349915,
-0.5998361707,
0.4380474389,
0.8018345237,
-0.3415007889,
0.2413585782,
-0.4968651831,
-0.311909765,
-1.0678637028,
0.2049185485,
-0.366848439,
-0.7194281816,
-0.4006762803,
0.1256727725,
0.2729276419,
-0.0197002925,
-0.5184834003,
0.810529232,
-0.4950236082,
-0.2005168051,
-0.2874741256,
0.0481808707,
0.0639496818,
0.3107456267,
0.083991833,
0.7612192035,
0.8353513479,
-0.7956762314,
-0.2387159318,
0.1726685166,
-0.2886922061,
0.1634171754,
-0.4556918442,
0.6865372062,
-0.0798476189,
-0.0823401734,
-0.5583100319,
0.1002595499,
0.3800350726,
-0.6340883374,
0.5206220746,
-0.2096990496,
-0.5542967916,
0.1111237407,
-0.3094782531,
0.2272783518,
0.4665364623,
-0.7494237423,
0.9532358646,
0.6316957474,
-0.1433645934,
-1.0469241142,
-0.6392759085,
-0.1355193108,
-0.2143761665,
-0.0670922101,
0.2798868716,
-0.1264487952,
0.0283292625,
0.1453092694,
-0.2495230883,
-0.1357070506,
0.5713483095,
0.3642764688,
0.2395915836,
0.1032187641,
0.1252890676,
-0.0673275217,
-0.1857121438,
0.1682661474,
-0.5110720396,
0.4813046157,
-0.0144191906,
-0.5559763908,
-0.3974844217,
0.1136399433,
0.3167248368,
-0.4530996382,
1.1189625263,
0.369691819,
-0.5254973769,
-0.1760311127,
-0.7164772749,
-0.2741199136,
-0.5229153633,
0.231003046,
0.0053844769,
-1.2261428833,
0.6405320168,
0.0993163064,
0.2106429935,
0.0494743176,
0.4770418406,
-0.0085851355,
0.6894814968,
0.8909079432,
-0.3549242914,
0.7055891156,
0.1752201468,
0.2725312114,
-0.8434457183,
-0.4668571949,
-0.5556957126,
-0.0338180698,
-0.7235366106,
-0.3862225413,
0.0506220087,
-0.0414729677,
-0.4453914762,
0.2129436433,
-0.2091002911,
0.4729728699,
0.4432932436,
0.3209719956,
0.4345068038,
-0.0744531676,
0.1676077694,
0.0374299325,
-0.4715819955,
-0.1990178972,
1.6345795393,
0.4262165427,
0.7533721328,
0.1239986345,
0.7776225805,
0.1772980392,
0.3119488358,
-0.6017329693,
0.5037545562,
-0.097566992,
-0.7823964357,
-0.1878428757,
-0.5869631767,
-0.924548924,
0.0865458697,
-0.1313955784,
-0.940207243,
0.3427705169,
0.2925145328,
-0.3971075714,
0.3308814764,
-0.7165729403,
0.5184919238,
-0.2320784777,
-0.469840914,
-0.2033398598,
-0.6631144285,
0.2555214465,
-0.493506074,
0.4011217952,
-0.038280081,
-0.200891152,
0.7369217277,
-0.0190281607,
0.9437111616,
-0.4093395174,
0.1892955154,
0.1473463774,
0.3300366998,
0.6478135586,
0.030111149,
-0.1539844573,
0.1590674222,
-0.0101052336,
-0.2871135771,
-0.5920533538,
0.775888741,
-0.6461452246,
-0.8237275481,
-0.3776372969,
-0.3878658116,
-0.5413119793,
0.3490778506,
-0.1599647552,
-0.0667194724,
0.0257233847,
0.4690567851,
0.9495259523,
-0.2801005542,
0.3568180203,
0.5905528069,
-0.5680839419,
-0.1484029293,
0.7026273012,
0.129805997,
0.2829547226,
0.3242575824,
0.4217737913,
-0.5265068412,
-0.866065681,
0.0561045781,
0.1754297465,
-0.7220866084,
-0.1690503955,
-0.7452507615,
-0.1988951564,
-0.3721594512,
0.1288837045,
-0.5684638619,
-0.4076513946,
-0.5299800038,
-0.5288202167,
0.5286471248,
0.3221343756,
-0.1465464532,
0.3419734538,
-0.9192093015,
-0.0222164653,
0.2587592304,
0.6619763374,
0.1372240335,
-0.7518090606,
-0.2452822328,
-0.1076445356,
-0.0953551605,
-0.503281951,
0.3431877196,
0.2130893022,
0.6982716918,
0.2790198624,
0.0123154093,
0.4972544909,
-0.4773598611,
0.7375705242,
-0.0937783942,
-1.1146199703,
0.3985669315,
-0.1653026193,
-0.2201101333,
0.7153402567,
0.5419072509,
-0.0669593364,
-0.1041491851,
-0.7564565539,
-0.8179755807,
0.4767888784,
-0.0486536846,
0.5992993712,
0.0292754564,
0.688051641,
0.199917838,
0.4982984066,
-0.8756563067,
-0.154253751,
-0.2493366599,
-0.0967142284,
-0.0632084012,
-0.3228878677,
-0.0757274702,
-0.1230495572,
0.6189495325,
-0.1110323519,
0.1193346307,
-0.0533772223,
-0.2354628444,
0.2442432493,
0.2042970806,
0.1787112206,
0.844694376,
-0.3203440309,
0.1015436351,
0.1063274369,
-0.513122201,
-0.0648029447,
0.0364758447,
-0.2117437422,
-0.0986555219,
0.0199660622,
0.7113125324,
0.3367443979,
-0.6539102793,
0.7398840189,
-0.0393534489,
-0.0638469905,
-0.4528647661,
0.0350900292,
0.2718590796,
0.227670759,
0.1254921854,
-0.0318549648,
0.0005237148,
-0.4327276349,
0.3974516392,
0.4896229506,
-0.4742263854,
-0.3551861942,
0.6086999178,
-0.2026966959,
-0.22195445,
0.5193235278,
0.0555293672,
-0.3043988645,
0.1141711399,
0.4625941217,
0.8315793276,
-0.5228971839,
0.095899187,
0.1352460533,
0.2750323117,
-0.2991378307,
0.3184585273,
-0.0634048134,
-0.8666356206,
-0.3209841251,
-0.4787990153,
-0.4667226374,
0.0662655309,
-1.0011326075,
-0.0876723602,
-0.9587342143,
-0.2313124388,
-0.537326932,
-0.2422982752,
-0.7831694484,
0.17178303,
0.0550131463,
1.080561161,
-0.5863739848,
1.0323081017,
0.1650591642,
0.0142615717,
-0.8637236953,
-0.0390259102,
-0.1837630272,
-1.1329723597,
0.3819492459,
-0.0372056998,
-0.0123223886,
0.0196597986,
-0.5698247552,
-0.8317734599,
1.0954658985,
0.630027771,
-0.6161598563,
-0.1487928331,
-0.1497839093,
0.3733403683,
-0.2626859546,
-0.0985505134,
0.2795630991,
0.2930924296,
-0.0935390592,
-0.9465953708,
0.0382119976,
0.1367576867,
-0.0728531629,
-0.2713774741,
-0.487470299,
0.9679743052,
-0.144450143,
-0.1177870631,
-0.1175483763,
0.6881740689,
0.3020647466,
0.3141799271,
0.6224108338,
0.4288653731,
1.0604865551,
0.3077172935,
1.2526158094,
-0.5177645683,
0.3121261299,
1.4013625383,
-0.2743938267,
1.1530772448,
0.6005504131,
-0.0386965908,
0.2360028774,
0.4096388519,
0.3620562553,
0.8107934594,
0.005159067,
-0.1453923881,
-0.3185701966,
-0.2204894125,
-0.4240839779,
0.5464152098,
0.371140033,
-0.7462931871,
-0.0471485481,
-0.1284276545,
0.1140346304,
0.1529151499,
-0.4202660024,
0.911239922,
0.4633579254,
-0.2335420847,
0.1908171326,
-0.1372144073,
0.6011550426,
-0.7607844472,
0.4117866457,
-0.1628588438,
0.1311602741,
-0.0936637148,
-0.5513780713,
0.3796590269,
0.0168905966,
-0.0529795364,
-0.1947052777,
0.5488684177,
-0.2161531299,
-0.339400351,
0.489972353,
0.7524219751,
-0.0829973221,
-0.152237922,
-0.8053238988,
-0.0148378676,
-0.0878923312,
-0.4386432767,
0.7636398077,
0.2668934762,
0.1035278216,
0.9445140958,
0.8555157185,
0.2278801203,
0.1379532218,
-0.0095862821,
0.874227345,
-0.4371898472,
-0.6386629343,
-1.0560079813,
0.312425822,
0.1206917241,
0.0957287848,
0.7904582024,
0.5066898465,
0.9743198752,
0.2032437623,
0.8465786576,
0.4689615071,
0.714566648,
-0.7611720562,
0.9754148126,
-0.462805599,
0.4056614041,
-0.025195254,
-0.7772359848,
-0.3763719797,
0.7639340162,
-0.3893445432,
0.1101998165,
0.4322011769,
0.9486114383,
-0.0917643309,
0.0790272579,
0.2556558549,
0.1925988048,
0.4181216061,
0.3372263014,
0.7316380739,
-0.2715451717,
0.1902505755,
-0.3049788177,
-0.0170649756,
0.1078607291,
-1.2054293156,
-0.9108617902,
-0.4538319111,
-0.1364738643,
-0.4105090201,
0.1598580629,
0.9724288583,
0.739497304,
-0.806682229,
0.0894129723,
0.0959082022,
0.2790235579,
0.1096381322,
-0.0796796903,
0.5276457667,
-0.0594731495,
-0.5657177567,
0.4564764798,
0.1190162525,
0.2819198072,
-0.3491232097,
-0.0115995407,
-0.0863662586,
0.0516044088,
0.3045261502,
0.3575752079,
-0.5144639015,
-0.4769510627,
0.1994252652,
0.1217655838,
0.0277125854,
0.7438008785,
-0.7517595291,
0.6056320667,
0.3005755544,
1.0632462502,
0.3987980485,
-0.0629837364,
0.4815373123,
-0.7034769058,
0.319803983,
0.3622509837,
0.4259916842,
0.5867655873,
-0.5328074694,
0.1158316508,
-0.0178566836,
-0.458863169,
-1.0281019211,
0.090346761,
-0.9034333229,
-0.0643335134,
0.9619594216,
-0.7181133032,
-0.3471037447,
-0.2243224829,
0.26195997,
0.1159997433,
-0.3046636283,
0.9763767123,
0.5217177868,
0.2611677349,
-0.2624374032,
-0.4032008648,
0.5114017129,
0.430539459,
-0.5245321989,
0.3409215212,
0.0578951165,
0.5791239142,
0.0513130166,
0.7661947608,
-0.4913273752,
-0.0448646955,
-0.2278424054,
-0.3842300475,
-0.4390257597,
-0.4254503548,
-0.3831050694,
0.1342921853,
0.4665090144,
-0.2927003503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03491v1
|
A Cause-Effect Look at Alleviating Hallucination of Knowledge-grounded Dialogue Generation
| 2024-04-04T14:45:26 | 2024-04-04T14:45:26 |
Jifan Yu, Xiaohan Zhang, Yifan Xu, Xuanyu Lei, Zijun Yao, Jing Zhang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Empowered by the large-scale pretrained language models, existing dialogue
systems have demonstrated impressive performance conducting fluent and
natural-sounding conversations. However, they are still plagued by the
hallucination problem, causing unpredictable factual errors in the generated
responses. Recently, knowledge-grounded dialogue generation models, that
intentionally invoke external knowledge resources to more informative
responses, are also proven to be effective in reducing hallucination. Following
the idea of getting high-quality knowledge, a few efforts have achieved pretty
good performance on this issue. As some inevitable knowledge noises may also
lead to hallucinations, it is emergent to investigate the reason and future
directions for building noise-tolerant methods in KGD tasks. In this paper, we
analyze the causal story behind this problem with counterfactual reasoning
methods. Based on the causal effect analysis, we propose a possible solution
for alleviating the hallucination in KGD by exploiting the dialogue-knowledge
interaction. Experimental results of our example implementation show that this
method can reduce hallucination without disrupting other dialogue performance,
while keeping adaptive to different generation models. We hope our efforts can
support and call for more attention to developing lightweight techniques
towards robust and trusty dialogue systems.
|
[
-0.6501252055,
-1.0469679832,
0.8671396971,
0.0509763509,
-0.2157515883,
-0.4421221614,
0.0962903574,
-0.2897495329,
0.259480685,
0.8009438515,
-0.6277552843,
-0.2596169114,
-0.6505167484,
-0.1685570329,
-0.2448587567,
0.8156250119,
0.1819488257,
0.0187876057,
-0.257704109,
-0.1447952837,
-0.9791683555,
-0.5127316713,
-0.4866135418,
-0.4389058948,
0.4011341929,
0.2239139527,
0.8404365778,
0.1718089134,
0.0385501087,
0.2316361368,
0.081534259,
0.1122926176,
-0.7559930086,
0.3051573038,
-0.1248926595,
-0.3357174993,
-0.0858874545,
-0.1640886962,
0.2909495533,
0.7692596912,
-0.2875287235,
-0.3707954288,
0.062824145,
0.613312304,
-0.5742356777,
0.0532470718,
-0.6443538666,
0.232304886,
0.3171240985,
-0.5231333375,
-0.3304687142,
-0.3541893661,
0.013403371,
-0.7140009403,
0.1623041779,
-0.0363701135,
0.5407375693,
0.6955187917,
-0.2503318787,
-0.53384161,
-0.8763486147,
0.5036449432,
-0.7215679288,
0.7397760749,
0.5633965731,
0.0988968164,
-0.5113267303,
-0.3006684482,
-0.8365118504,
-0.1480012536,
-0.1714305282,
0.1604097933,
-0.0095834071,
0.1770527214,
0.5241863728,
-0.0107497573,
-0.4111413956,
-0.1961625367,
-0.2996122241,
-0.2803537548,
0.1659326702,
-0.0459116176,
0.2318601459,
-0.2832824588,
0.1137327999,
-0.0257280748,
-0.8764472008,
-0.1971031427,
0.3061768115,
0.0175709594,
0.2423741817,
0.4208461344,
-0.4056822658,
0.5663716197,
0.160707742,
-0.1763908565,
-0.1594042778,
-0.2396200001,
-0.3835369647,
0.5207514167,
0.4422529042,
0.5584414601,
0.3437127471,
-0.4420996904,
0.0866716579,
0.1247093827,
0.6256967783,
-1.1145410538,
-0.4235438704,
0.1070263907,
-0.4534238875,
-0.4866395891,
-0.306594044,
-0.8001697659,
-0.6136801839,
-0.5744937658,
0.8540697694,
-0.3291045725,
-0.6000365019,
0.0712425485,
-0.1418137252,
-0.1437951773,
0.1926984489,
-0.6901979446,
0.1175189316,
0.3620647192,
0.5712966919,
0.2502693534,
-0.0639809966,
-0.7106760144,
0.1875536889,
-0.519487679,
0.618296206,
-0.2477526963,
-0.6119722128,
-0.2347085178,
-0.0813012496,
-0.1245938241,
-0.7753283381,
0.4567683637,
-0.1771060526,
0.2380503118,
-0.7683452368,
-0.1390075386,
-0.299551785,
0.2664909959,
-0.2051632404,
0.6819740534,
0.1448157132,
-0.7511479855,
0.5989769101,
-0.3699828386,
-0.4958517253,
-0.2583572268,
-0.2435700446,
-0.4156157672,
0.3425852954,
0.2901048958,
0.2975574434,
-0.3407855332,
0.8071576953,
-0.212900728,
-0.2589898407,
0.1373618096,
-0.3977313638,
0.5902789831,
0.3315092325,
-0.7260326147,
0.1175903007,
-0.8862629533,
-0.195893541,
-0.048419673,
0.359703809,
-0.4375907481,
0.0548176579,
-0.537499845,
0.4005900323,
-0.483322531,
-0.1261945814,
-0.1828293949,
-0.3372204006,
-0.1120254397,
0.8432354331,
0.2642071247,
0.2248490006,
-0.4122417867,
0.2793576121,
0.4788619876,
0.2372606993,
0.0117193358,
-0.3495863974,
-0.9725466371,
-0.207901597,
-0.3388822675,
0.2516793013,
-1.039961338,
0.2936863601,
0.025611192,
-0.3466023803,
-0.3408001065,
0.1392595917,
0.3472964764,
0.9880561829,
0.3495570719,
-0.2832954228,
-0.5340790153,
-0.6450179219,
-0.0491314866,
-0.3637400568,
0.039118655,
0.5530767441,
0.204335466,
-0.3748050928,
0.9977138042,
-0.5298914313,
-0.1351440847,
0.0376288816,
0.4455026388,
-0.0088139204,
0.5632157326,
0.4706209004,
-0.6272749901,
-0.1055939868,
-0.1278384775,
-1.0222996473,
-0.5607134104,
-0.3541652858,
-0.3753708899,
0.284447819,
0.6598068476,
-1.0021264553,
0.4885929525,
0.2792535722,
-0.2087179273,
0.917784214,
0.1722642779,
0.4439742267,
-1.1140238047,
0.1185420081,
-0.4490540922,
0.27453354,
-0.6661826968,
-0.4173094332,
-0.6141694784,
-0.2171868831,
-0.1206945926,
0.2398487329,
0.0843721852,
-0.1013969257,
-0.3610295355,
0.3098758757,
-0.0794348493,
0.5163507462,
0.1573113948,
0.6317077875,
0.6233664751,
-0.9047100544,
0.2734530568,
0.328880161,
-0.351814419,
0.7799419761,
-0.461063385,
-0.0586748198,
-0.3762600124,
0.120913431,
-0.98096174,
-0.1876614243,
0.6489326954,
-0.3987570107,
0.0599277653,
0.2505450845,
-0.4474753141,
-0.0746962801,
0.0412281677,
0.3660182357,
0.517195344,
-0.8725199103,
0.681296587,
-0.0029053935,
-0.2697476745,
-0.3061796427,
-0.1112237275,
0.090696454,
-0.441298306,
-0.7632328272,
-0.1367571503,
-0.2902991772,
-0.4236550629,
-0.1422128975,
-0.4710544646,
0.1930456758,
0.2872881293,
0.3365426362,
-0.0071472954,
-0.1115184799,
0.3085630536,
0.0948266536,
-0.2005105019,
0.5101133585,
-0.363658011,
0.5364593267,
0.4466660321,
-0.4291213751,
-0.3060237467,
0.1270848662,
0.77727741,
0.3767791092,
0.7897179723,
0.4669199884,
-0.1895133853,
-0.0870984271,
-0.9911446571,
-0.7458407879,
-0.4414708316,
0.2045429796,
-0.4722870588,
-0.6594073772,
0.5690130591,
-0.4720886052,
-0.4098537564,
0.2127508372,
0.4741333127,
0.0630281717,
0.9127438664,
0.1337129474,
0.015333211,
0.1820417792,
0.3261517882,
0.8146278858,
-0.5148689151,
-0.2834802866,
-0.5812211037,
0.0807224065,
-0.3781861067,
-0.2023274004,
0.3046092093,
0.4535610378,
-0.1781747341,
0.1011287943,
-0.4576534331,
0.22327438,
0.4244704247,
-0.0246294439,
0.3293423355,
-0.059045691,
-0.2694797516,
-0.1270800382,
-0.760964632,
-0.0685595572,
0.8159471154,
-0.0761658475,
0.7389793992,
0.0375235863,
0.4625112116,
0.0909962878,
0.0747345313,
-0.5304064751,
0.5789465904,
0.5754856467,
-0.3904108703,
-0.4117676914,
-0.6522458196,
-0.478480041,
0.3528835773,
-0.269887805,
-0.8503773808,
0.2469884753,
0.0417257212,
-0.1891682893,
0.0905640125,
-0.6379207969,
0.7242524028,
0.0825698525,
-0.5390121937,
-0.3892332911,
-0.6170676947,
0.7462950945,
-0.3882713616,
0.3381434083,
0.3132280111,
1.2143831253,
0.6119956374,
-0.4675686657,
0.9070983529,
-0.4749709964,
-0.4596833587,
0.2859913707,
0.2643157244,
0.7928679585,
0.0682344809,
0.3595017493,
-0.0166343506,
-0.2755774558,
-0.0388954096,
-0.9730144739,
0.6904122233,
-0.8259348869,
-0.9557902217,
-0.1094120964,
-0.8272017241,
-0.3022602201,
-0.0045284247,
0.3508572876,
0.3708627522,
-0.266972065,
0.2261863649,
1.0468722582,
-0.4573635757,
0.2364296764,
0.4710089862,
-0.431319952,
-0.3607282937,
0.9559010863,
0.3448324502,
0.3862460852,
-0.0822755769,
0.2961246967,
-0.1926001161,
-0.1478442997,
-0.2827930152,
0.0098860795,
-0.7658423781,
-0.0418337099,
-1.0442324877,
-0.2101609856,
-0.5937550068,
-0.4015244544,
-0.2772996724,
-0.4458584487,
-0.1218331009,
-0.3358580172,
0.1810029596,
0.5476366878,
-0.2661769986,
0.3438284993,
-0.4558685422,
0.7246028185,
0.6071722507,
0.1822454035,
0.3423955739,
-0.2780599594,
-0.1813214421,
0.016234288,
-0.4566799104,
-0.6095076799,
0.2272038311,
-0.3549680412,
0.6289462447,
0.7585653663,
0.5159084797,
0.8567785025,
-0.155741483,
0.7449985743,
0.4126622975,
-0.9263169765,
0.5145887733,
-0.3164073825,
0.2038353682,
0.2071759552,
0.2726658881,
-0.5760831833,
-0.698892653,
-0.7403663993,
-0.5294268131,
0.6683811545,
0.4417887926,
-0.2687933445,
-0.1100123227,
0.0615455844,
0.2922768295,
0.2983908653,
-0.7092247605,
0.034555845,
-0.7259238958,
0.1595838219,
-0.0723968223,
-0.4688751698,
-0.4524701834,
-0.2337343246,
1.0436024666,
-0.0527482368,
0.2131489962,
0.2620473504,
-0.2388887554,
-0.3541401625,
0.3719635904,
0.9094697833,
0.6799060106,
-0.1356845796,
0.2146854401,
0.186076954,
-0.1799010038,
0.1003090218,
-0.0853261948,
-0.3086155951,
-0.0164691824,
0.0856748894,
0.9937974811,
0.1731502861,
-0.4524220526,
0.2689261436,
0.245320037,
-0.410391748,
-0.0968177766,
0.1216981038,
0.0380466543,
0.2429754138,
0.2708783746,
0.2092073113,
0.1401150823,
-0.4095696211,
0.2898419797,
0.445620209,
-0.501204133,
-0.1878292412,
0.6393557191,
0.2197466046,
-0.1194401458,
0.6974791288,
-0.1879156977,
-0.631192565,
0.3960282803,
0.7142485976,
0.9584662914,
-0.2483099848,
0.4404607117,
0.350210011,
0.3293462098,
-0.0581171587,
0.0283103157,
-0.4795010388,
-1.0087584257,
-0.5082143545,
-0.4529084861,
-0.2228741795,
0.1518810987,
-0.4768014252,
0.0897392258,
-0.2225454152,
0.0760025531,
-0.5150851011,
-0.4937157333,
-0.2813688815,
0.2173707634,
-0.2244233787,
0.1052731723,
-1.1604106426,
0.5205408335,
0.0045723291,
-0.2742011845,
-0.5354853868,
0.2404209077,
0.058702793,
-0.6123075485,
0.9252518415,
0.196438536,
-0.3513025343,
0.1025058478,
-0.440780282,
-0.5138678551,
0.7869915962,
0.2650437355,
-0.3893721998,
0.3282533586,
0.4171400368,
0.2551828325,
-0.1143806055,
0.0198917389,
0.6324054599,
0.6977183223,
0.4687434137,
-0.8401950598,
0.4257914722,
-0.0797936469,
-0.2140360624,
0.1483417153,
-0.4007822573,
0.2890060246,
-0.1521995366,
-0.0203439556,
-0.0778409764,
0.3039290011,
0.57037431,
0.5783252716,
0.5992540121,
0.8306393027,
0.6993356943,
-0.0724674165,
0.5861244202,
-0.2618120909,
-0.1650148928,
0.8514752388,
-0.4496780038,
-0.0121949064,
0.8126407266,
0.1791921109,
0.202351138,
-0.0009232143,
0.2757650316,
0.800334096,
0.3464539945,
-0.5880455971,
-0.4081148803,
-0.5641693473,
-0.5787495971,
0.2043792158,
0.3059013486,
-0.0788305327,
-0.2091587335,
0.3931706548,
0.0281363707,
-0.040883217,
-0.1124599651,
0.9474747777,
0.0675686076,
-0.846013248,
0.6916233301,
-0.5895218849,
0.3049008846,
-0.410749346,
-0.2407674342,
-0.2181220502,
0.0181793291,
-0.1291010827,
0.0570872501,
0.4111797512,
-0.5005763173,
-0.2118365467,
-0.2217314392,
0.8296623826,
-0.3028568327,
-0.241481021,
0.3765031397,
0.5168712139,
0.1930378526,
-0.3214499354,
0.0889405385,
0.0805030465,
0.0760624483,
-0.0682485476,
0.4632490575,
0.8922450542,
0.0231291484,
0.5417515635,
0.7181439996,
-0.0961626694,
-0.0607458837,
0.2813731134,
1.12208426,
-0.6801631451,
-0.439248383,
-0.5501165986,
0.4302476645,
0.0531866737,
0.0422329344,
0.6356243491,
0.2627083659,
0.6313107014,
-0.1805637926,
0.8590732813,
-0.0570841245,
0.2514618635,
-0.6662676334,
0.9915751815,
-0.4152837694,
0.2336618751,
-0.7667518854,
-1.0371596813,
-0.1954709888,
0.6849903464,
-0.1221874952,
0.0077760871,
0.9105112553,
1.2292528152,
0.2510157526,
0.2877759337,
0.7808541656,
0.6443021894,
0.418217957,
0.1892088056,
0.9570746422,
-0.2296331078,
0.605009973,
-0.1421479136,
-0.1149428412,
-0.2857466042,
-0.7492668629,
-1.0447340012,
-0.6030729413,
-0.3125511706,
-0.5451247096,
0.4465808272,
0.620477438,
0.3895689249,
-0.7255659699,
0.1723421961,
-0.6924236417,
0.2886490226,
-0.2667015791,
-0.3034063578,
0.2392237782,
-0.6011860967,
-0.2673842609,
0.4012278914,
0.193111375,
0.0374851711,
-0.0062871943,
-0.3626323044,
0.1904014796,
0.0688646361,
0.7314367294,
0.2472955436,
-0.8006420135,
-0.5170564651,
-0.117068775,
0.2563999593,
-0.1742684692,
0.9819880128,
-1.0225553513,
0.6850976944,
0.3532455266,
0.5030681491,
0.5376058817,
-0.0052882927,
0.7410684228,
-0.5118864775,
0.2592535913,
-0.1605328918,
-0.0026768013,
0.0792877674,
-0.4723881185,
0.3504645228,
0.5561000109,
-0.5995224118,
-0.8126298785,
0.3604650497,
-0.6757001877,
-0.351896137,
0.9892154932,
0.1890130043,
0.4944508374,
-0.4900078475,
-0.5870187879,
0.4517176449,
-0.1521095335,
1.4726928473,
1.1149532795,
-0.0562676787,
-0.4055948555,
-0.5548321009,
0.637588203,
0.7858580351,
-0.7646094561,
0.2622344494,
0.7483873963,
-0.196461916,
0.3193617165,
0.7216881514,
-0.0532284416,
0.2302078903,
0.2950983047,
0.2057368606,
0.0057891468,
-0.5826725364,
0.2095974684,
0.124428995,
0.0214584582,
0.2291973531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03486v1
|
Generative AI and Teachers -- For Us or Against Us? A Case Study
| 2024-04-04T14:40:07 | 2024-04-04T14:40:07 |
Jenny Pettersson, Elias Hult, Tim Eriksson, Tosin Adewumi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present insightful results of a survey on the adoption of generative
artificial intelligence (GenAI) by university teachers in their teaching
activities. The transformation of education by GenAI, particularly large
language models (LLMs), has been presenting both opportunities and challenges,
including cheating by students. We prepared the online survey according to best
practices and the questions were created by the authors, who have pedagogy
experience. The survey contained 12 questions and a pilot study was first
conducted. The survey was then sent to all teachers in multiple departments
across different campuses of the university of interest in Sweden: Lule{\aa}
University of Technology. The survey was available in both Swedish and English.
The results show that 35 teachers (more than half) use GenAI out of 67
respondents. Preparation is the teaching activity with the most frequency that
GenAI is used for and ChatGPT is the most commonly used GenAI. 59% say it has
impacted their teaching, however, 55% say there should be legislation around
the use of GenAI, especially as inaccuracies and cheating are the biggest
concerns.
|
[
-0.2465797663,
-0.5901773572,
0.5190452933,
0.1366413534,
-0.3598100543,
0.1913940907,
0.0018399839,
-0.172737658,
-0.0910316333,
0.302285403,
0.0167984143,
-0.3939263225,
-0.5188621283,
0.1693744808,
-0.873210609,
0.7763303518,
-0.2045779526,
0.7511594296,
-0.78441751,
-0.0804859921,
-0.5429891944,
-0.4980874956,
-0.7639808059,
-0.7640995979,
0.4370504916,
0.5434182286,
0.4570869207,
0.0225641318,
0.3906994164,
0.3264507651,
0.0870259255,
-0.1252015233,
-0.2853970826,
0.141100511,
-0.2645177841,
-0.8940671682,
-0.111639604,
0.2147174478,
0.5704824924,
0.610054493,
-0.2662093639,
0.0769985393,
0.1774469018,
0.6251116395,
-0.3530816436,
-0.0164911989,
-0.2237906158,
0.4048355222,
-0.246653378,
0.0930310711,
-0.3729768097,
-0.4684872627,
-0.0700189024,
-0.6095932126,
0.2681793272,
-0.4745138586,
0.5053032637,
0.3642810285,
-0.3987825811,
-0.566144526,
-1.0351501703,
0.6894381642,
-0.3102430105,
0.2746970654,
0.5415218472,
0.2420517504,
-0.3123384714,
-0.7532305121,
-0.684566021,
0.031372726,
0.1546483487,
0.5046508908,
0.1243336201,
0.1690388918,
0.4056338668,
0.6252977252,
-0.3678753376,
0.4607740939,
-0.5167477727,
0.064779982,
0.7022684813,
0.1755991131,
0.7507431507,
0.0682719648,
-0.3296473622,
-0.1625678986,
-0.7775476575,
-0.0989122465,
0.7135766149,
-0.0377759188,
-0.0726972371,
0.5422518253,
0.2132347673,
0.7116590142,
-0.4239049256,
0.1765984893,
-0.1285250187,
-0.3867820501,
-0.1684913337,
-0.110710144,
0.9130856991,
-0.0019180262,
0.5033072829,
-0.1543408334,
-0.0586776212,
0.4335202277,
0.2048353702,
-0.6699085236,
-0.363250047,
0.1403884888,
-0.0583992302,
-0.4080601931,
0.0254696384,
-1.0759439468,
-0.5180134177,
-0.2006165981,
0.2531604469,
-0.2967487574,
-0.254712224,
-0.3448848128,
-0.2620177567,
0.6264867187,
0.3773132265,
-1.1001549959,
-0.0497240275,
0.8397305012,
0.5393218994,
0.0868281201,
-0.4662057757,
0.0251904074,
-0.098373808,
-0.3734481335,
0.7037560344,
-0.5722324848,
-1.1560600996,
0.1397795081,
-0.5311830044,
-0.1744412482,
-0.4864621758,
0.285472393,
-0.3981365561,
0.7081649899,
-0.2907630205,
-0.8293529153,
0.0871185586,
0.2876451313,
-0.5098825097,
1.0009932518,
0.1716344655,
-0.3392992318,
0.4855805635,
-0.7631873488,
-0.4132362604,
0.5609258413,
-0.7557837367,
-0.5012654662,
-0.1868098229,
0.1156110391,
0.2501249313,
-0.1920281351,
0.4651778936,
0.1786109805,
-0.6919569373,
0.5445461869,
-0.818318069,
1.1856783628,
0.3249373734,
-0.388523072,
-0.0092070214,
-0.3576284945,
-0.1377339512,
0.095121555,
-0.5060669184,
-0.3852773607,
-0.1072857454,
-0.1398392022,
-0.0343969613,
-0.0475574508,
-0.5447477102,
0.4476471543,
-0.1368565559,
0.3514890373,
0.8880133033,
-0.0536906943,
0.4587259293,
-0.4028872252,
0.9309789538,
-0.2441070974,
0.4347172379,
0.1477576345,
-0.8947333097,
-0.6189342141,
-0.153668806,
0.731444478,
0.5071790218,
-1.0853890181,
0.1286206841,
-0.1529584527,
-0.4545324445,
-0.7597877383,
0.3404467106,
0.2591108382,
0.253916204,
-0.1614058763,
-0.0108501296,
-0.4081628919,
-0.3024626672,
-0.2180451751,
-0.3616206348,
-0.1975035518,
0.3257852793,
0.5446951389,
-0.1724710763,
0.9700687528,
0.0045603095,
-0.3333538175,
-0.2630912066,
0.1883596927,
-0.0088376459,
0.5852142572,
0.5627449155,
-1.1281288862,
-0.6920469999,
-0.3526014984,
-1.1016350985,
0.2284585238,
-0.3775418997,
-0.1629959941,
0.3480773568,
0.2251183987,
-0.5772988796,
0.4463426173,
0.4524577558,
-0.4976828098,
0.2398065627,
-0.1916369349,
0.2327385396,
-1.2745383978,
0.0436028875,
-0.3215375543,
0.0701736584,
-0.5611239076,
0.3430669904,
-0.2142268866,
-0.1672909111,
-0.4264523089,
0.2034754455,
-0.250151813,
-0.0651283339,
-0.0913977176,
0.062725313,
-0.2589859068,
-0.024607325,
-0.4158401787,
1.3081721067,
0.4863330722,
-0.5880455375,
0.685680449,
0.5782738328,
-0.3933009505,
0.7917506099,
-0.4937341809,
0.4926544726,
0.0138314292,
0.2649702728,
-0.6820148826,
-0.1490070522,
0.5855230093,
-0.6536722779,
0.0699208751,
-0.0532900207,
-0.5180860758,
-0.4126774073,
-0.3012657166,
0.386482358,
0.7301986217,
-0.7304307818,
0.9319551587,
0.109158121,
0.3456496,
-0.4803246856,
-0.9295538068,
0.4574313462,
-0.0948827267,
-0.2281108499,
0.087414071,
-0.2782540321,
-0.3800728619,
0.1907518208,
0.2260889411,
-0.1264297962,
0.3253568411,
0.370295763,
0.2361493111,
-0.0289000701,
-0.1118747368,
-0.1918278039,
-0.031250447,
0.2253790647,
0.1396788657,
0.7561714649,
0.2580357194,
-0.5827072859,
-0.5526080728,
0.3845057487,
0.738435328,
0.0508089811,
0.7181998491,
0.5791097879,
-0.0984886736,
-0.2002644986,
-0.3214540184,
-0.2336099744,
-0.5103654861,
0.0363188311,
-0.1575299799,
-0.5687077045,
0.495791465,
-0.0564182997,
-0.0641819462,
0.2944801152,
0.2881353199,
-0.3325792551,
0.8083458543,
0.5799084306,
-0.3613464534,
0.6935904622,
-0.8147960305,
0.2464597672,
-0.6401849985,
-0.6207273006,
-0.4904133081,
-0.2056479603,
-0.7630519867,
0.0364181101,
0.3506498635,
-0.1532450765,
0.1037722155,
-0.0528986715,
-0.4688154459,
0.3942206204,
0.7635452151,
0.0583453551,
0.1491345763,
-0.0553335063,
0.250271678,
0.0652169585,
-0.863722682,
-0.3143898845,
1.3282357454,
0.1221247017,
0.6154138446,
0.1977536827,
1.0226033926,
0.3934915662,
0.6080773473,
-0.7666000724,
0.7636057138,
-0.3767616153,
-0.6952713728,
-0.6052119136,
-0.5632247329,
-1.1445014477,
0.262241751,
0.1646322161,
-0.0924896449,
-0.0086572617,
-0.068054378,
-0.1668174118,
0.6439343691,
-0.7990246415,
0.6920483112,
-0.4224898815,
-0.0275329165,
-0.2390597314,
-0.2525525987,
0.1623429209,
0.1397542059,
0.1086440012,
0.1508384943,
0.2543814778,
1.0145639181,
-0.2826888561,
1.1029975414,
-0.3125514388,
-0.2244757116,
0.5363929868,
-0.3931313455,
0.1755426228,
-0.1033308357,
-0.0434435606,
0.1657835543,
-0.0804887116,
-0.5117236972,
-0.6100346446,
0.629740417,
-1.0758908987,
-0.792963922,
-0.8965594172,
-0.3950484693,
0.0537517667,
0.0020318031,
0.5159426928,
0.2359241843,
-0.2486613244,
-0.0591999628,
0.7669584751,
0.1424710602,
0.4983608723,
0.5287475586,
-0.3567047119,
-0.2186523378,
1.1767333746,
0.4302408695,
0.1652685404,
0.0079449033,
0.2470952123,
-0.0863761306,
-0.3506244421,
-0.7955230474,
0.1236700565,
-0.6934319735,
-0.0347215831,
-0.3819084466,
-0.4497454762,
-0.6961712837,
-0.2698880136,
-0.1016642302,
0.0477796271,
-0.7068318129,
-0.164390415,
0.2020500153,
1.1396628618,
0.143741712,
0.1537064761,
-0.3581800461,
0.0372005254,
0.8294357061,
0.3097664118,
-0.1700279862,
-0.2993684113,
0.277474016,
0.1327155828,
-0.2350332141,
-0.8006588221,
-0.0501937233,
0.145740062,
0.652200222,
0.327717036,
0.0129381884,
0.307920754,
-0.0098007498,
1.0978244543,
-0.073712483,
-0.7204005718,
0.38523224,
-0.195105657,
0.3659471273,
0.4951635301,
0.5312087536,
-0.7743470669,
-0.4932059944,
-0.6954861283,
-0.8058037162,
0.2738338113,
0.0284112114,
0.8074555397,
0.5184308887,
0.3889521658,
0.2784551084,
0.1958752573,
-0.7149471641,
-0.3813884258,
-0.2269554436,
-0.2984852791,
-0.0100159738,
-0.5203092694,
-0.3201268315,
-0.4655472636,
0.4934082627,
0.2794998884,
0.421150744,
-0.0164051112,
0.0522282645,
-0.0155410506,
0.4373581707,
0.5488374233,
0.9377835989,
0.333889991,
0.1041040346,
0.2688774467,
-0.8825237155,
0.2492580414,
0.0137367584,
-0.7203609943,
0.0412335806,
0.2566283941,
0.4315960407,
-0.0917254537,
-0.350890398,
0.5516590476,
-0.061861828,
-0.2805372477,
-0.961438179,
0.2345355898,
-0.2350347787,
0.010805889,
0.2827671766,
-0.0957519859,
-0.03045086,
-0.618960917,
-0.0362634435,
0.383003056,
-0.1590941548,
-0.3028193712,
0.4556483924,
0.4720707834,
-0.6041380167,
1.0300924778,
-0.1745561361,
-0.7687352896,
0.6820940971,
0.6783017516,
0.8252459168,
-0.5738930702,
0.836299181,
-0.1268347204,
0.1987484097,
-0.0487684235,
0.5875892043,
-0.2639969587,
-0.9382809997,
-0.078694053,
-0.1627919078,
-0.8914743662,
0.0757964402,
-0.5013766289,
0.0731970742,
-0.4607274532,
0.0501659364,
-0.3084446192,
-0.2333910763,
-0.6124750376,
0.0039176792,
0.0810473412,
0.6101144552,
-1.0683990717,
0.9621888399,
0.9675267339,
-0.6088405252,
-0.6588507295,
-0.0091328258,
-0.3156043291,
-0.757347405,
0.2678896189,
-0.1427960843,
0.0889524668,
0.1993349195,
-0.7273578048,
-0.3633086383,
1.1102745533,
0.1682336181,
-0.3839311302,
0.1318024993,
0.6572615504,
0.7823515534,
0.013176634,
0.1889595687,
0.5558365583,
0.4963715971,
-0.1365201026,
-0.4700009823,
-0.2954696119,
-0.1045101583,
-0.038512852,
0.3665332496,
-0.6337887049,
0.6388983727,
0.0143345632,
-0.3021674156,
0.1194145754,
0.5557746291,
-0.0805503353,
0.7869876027,
0.2834864259,
0.6756699681,
0.575489521,
-0.1277870536,
0.9715330005,
0.0121580064,
0.14807567,
0.4889939427,
-0.0672535598,
0.5719311237,
0.6157987118,
-0.5320056081,
0.5380570889,
0.3758600056,
-0.4073344171,
0.276053369,
0.2088966817,
-0.680591166,
-0.0794508308,
-0.194736734,
-0.45551759,
0.5972818136,
0.3929861188,
-0.1269126534,
-0.0763629377,
0.5639003515,
0.2790192366,
0.3558828831,
-0.3379679918,
0.7717700005,
0.133071363,
-0.7273218036,
0.0182569679,
-0.240112409,
0.7747387886,
-0.3183908463,
-0.1973700821,
-0.4451561272,
-0.0053651463,
-0.1739694625,
-0.8976972103,
0.034770146,
0.0413400009,
0.209631741,
-0.5242788196,
0.4295385182,
-0.6408295035,
-0.3729331493,
-0.048791144,
0.3922767043,
0.3169214725,
0.183047682,
-0.4459727407,
-0.0344173871,
0.007186986,
0.3246992826,
0.3793919981,
-0.0633101836,
0.0662790909,
0.5514851809,
0.5270826221,
-0.026040554,
-0.0399310738,
0.2853218317,
0.681882143,
-0.3223969042,
-0.4210430086,
-0.7579988837,
0.3749595881,
-0.1692370772,
-0.6419587135,
0.9356454611,
0.4657783806,
1.1502349377,
0.1379353255,
0.7793743014,
0.0062768646,
0.1199570149,
-0.4687737823,
0.8658383489,
-0.0151876872,
0.2259631604,
0.0126201781,
-0.8229183555,
0.022782594,
0.2025767118,
-0.4755733907,
0.258895576,
0.3916594386,
0.1648403704,
0.3789652884,
0.2828105688,
0.5465191007,
-0.171312511,
0.5988793373,
0.268081516,
1.1510794163,
-0.49854514,
0.416906476,
-0.4208901227,
-0.1866514087,
0.0474024676,
-0.1968636513,
-0.8725705743,
-0.5603026152,
-0.5716637373,
-0.1217537224,
0.2826956511,
0.5921817422,
-0.0055499086,
-1.0040532351,
-0.2918670774,
-0.3086777329,
0.3504897058,
-0.0498463698,
-0.2566500008,
0.199965775,
-0.2059237063,
-0.8200222254,
0.2736763954,
-0.4509050846,
0.3575184643,
-0.6318877935,
-0.0488386825,
-0.1486032009,
-0.0994335338,
0.4231863618,
0.5254635215,
-0.5523560643,
-0.3627713323,
-0.1607513726,
-0.3049555123,
-0.1957826912,
0.931532681,
-0.597404182,
0.7136602402,
0.5398355126,
0.7103068233,
0.2095990777,
-0.0936637744,
0.5881522298,
-0.5163247585,
0.0651267171,
0.435477525,
0.1077314988,
0.4246768653,
-0.535109818,
0.634893775,
0.5410166979,
-0.8519352674,
-0.9622749686,
0.0206240639,
-0.3948218226,
-0.1282501966,
1.0025321245,
-0.2346566468,
-0.0134286936,
-0.042143736,
0.1052546054,
0.2302509844,
-0.1358277202,
1.0688527822,
0.7522671223,
-0.1498326063,
-0.1586571932,
-0.6156301498,
0.45176211,
0.5956946611,
-0.728032887,
-0.7219095826,
0.1556533724,
0.2677361369,
0.0031496317,
0.4766127467,
-0.0879929066,
0.479581207,
0.1480077952,
0.2223542929,
-0.115472734,
-0.3002816737,
-0.6710315943,
-0.0438199081,
0.1351409405,
-0.7139053345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03471v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03471v2
|
The Impact of Unstated Norms in Bias Analysis of Language Models
| 2024-04-04T14:24:06 | 2024-04-07T21:55:38 |
Farnaz Kohankhaki, Jacob-Junqi Tian, David Emerson, Laleh Seyyed-Kalantari, Faiza Khan Khattak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs), trained on vast datasets, can carry biases that
manifest in various forms, from overt discrimination to implicit stereotypes.
One facet of bias is performance disparities in LLMs, often harming
underprivileged groups, such as racial minorities. A common approach to
quantifying bias is to use template-based bias probes, which explicitly state
group membership (e.g. White) and evaluate if the outcome of a task, sentiment
analysis for instance, is invariant to the change of group membership (e.g.
change White race to Black). This approach is widely used in bias
quantification. However, in this work, we find evidence of an unexpectedly
overlooked consequence of using template-based probes for LLM bias
quantification. We find that in doing so, text examples associated with White
ethnicities appear to be classified as exhibiting negative sentiment at
elevated rates. We hypothesize that the scenario arises artificially through a
mismatch between the pre-training text of LLMs and the templates used to
measure bias through reporting bias, unstated norms that imply group membership
without explicit statement. Our finding highlights the potential misleading
impact of varying group membership through explicit mention in bias
quantification
|
[
-0.472377032,
-0.4068937302,
0.3607038558,
0.1633608192,
-0.2645089626,
-0.1905734688,
-0.2431557924,
-0.2048547566,
0.3778555989,
0.3089702427,
-0.1640110612,
-0.5383499265,
-0.8396000266,
-0.047709804,
-0.3728840947,
1.2351474762,
0.1887089908,
0.2782050669,
-0.1878358573,
-0.4864818156,
-0.3001703024,
-0.7269818187,
0.0109052146,
-0.1988872439,
0.3453725874,
0.0720657706,
0.4659904242,
0.3948584199,
0.1103942022,
0.0803587362,
-0.3709424734,
-0.2394239008,
-0.4517698884,
-0.0383909158,
0.0172135141,
-0.543348968,
-0.5823431015,
0.6189492345,
0.6560227275,
0.9554026723,
0.0424766727,
0.3200077116,
0.267942071,
0.5618242025,
-1.0312037468,
0.1354808211,
-0.7235913873,
0.1122426987,
-0.4208999574,
-0.091330342,
-0.2410939932,
-0.1755535901,
-0.0044247513,
-0.2280376256,
0.2211984843,
-0.1038766652,
0.5649679899,
0.1875441223,
-0.7086694241,
-0.3905913234,
-0.4942327738,
0.8974266648,
-1.0787732601,
0.3580977917,
0.1565017104,
-0.1756058037,
-0.1067390665,
-0.2128956765,
-0.6912896633,
-0.0011302737,
-0.1472053081,
0.1445950568,
-0.0697720796,
0.1397752464,
0.5780962706,
0.5926802158,
-0.0545135178,
0.2948261797,
-0.602468133,
-0.101756677,
0.4856688678,
0.1531598717,
0.1169377789,
-0.2935712039,
-0.1134190261,
0.2273136675,
-0.6616771221,
0.1391357183,
0.5631808639,
0.6387634277,
-0.2787193954,
0.7442547679,
0.0841612592,
0.631791532,
0.0621592738,
-0.0254807938,
0.458596617,
-0.0774351284,
-0.2006552517,
0.054273773,
0.7557746768,
0.5483534932,
0.6108811498,
0.1580144763,
-0.193530336,
0.4608433843,
0.006621426,
-0.7228332162,
0.0829712749,
-0.127441451,
-0.5509139895,
-0.387770772,
0.0804583803,
-1.0398151875,
-0.6911583543,
0.0161840133,
0.0684903041,
0.2186173052,
-0.2920069098,
0.1128009409,
-0.2448909283,
0.1718551815,
0.3313798606,
-0.7626660466,
0.3522524834,
0.556773603,
0.7469648719,
-0.3367387354,
0.0556657948,
-0.4693436027,
-0.2161085755,
-0.2315844893,
0.3958517313,
-0.6892356277,
-0.7280718088,
0.1316789985,
-0.2510072887,
0.0894447789,
-0.5225176215,
0.5636692643,
-0.4363902211,
0.3708679676,
-0.5626667142,
-0.7830301523,
0.0258601811,
0.1086461321,
-0.5155961514,
0.9515166879,
0.0974206999,
-1.1902369261,
0.7597775459,
-0.4369218647,
-0.3629030585,
-0.1742634326,
-0.472042799,
-0.3165666461,
0.6456019282,
0.2287112921,
0.3358310759,
-0.2493687719,
0.043766588,
-0.5684529543,
-0.6240654588,
0.2400677353,
-0.3782457709,
1.04056108,
-0.0218869522,
-0.5715782642,
-0.2829822004,
-0.6338911057,
-0.1448948383,
-0.004182437,
-0.5443725586,
-0.8580153584,
0.0142598152,
-0.1483892351,
0.3217233717,
-0.1317389309,
-0.7716616392,
0.2345750183,
-0.1650171727,
-0.1253436208,
1.0606197119,
-0.0600177273,
0.3993883431,
0.0301222578,
0.6425915956,
0.2433682084,
-0.027716849,
0.2412435412,
-0.3846207857,
-0.7959262133,
-0.2359496057,
0.2168105394,
0.2074072957,
-0.1207557544,
0.2569831312,
-0.1270173043,
-0.2489654273,
-0.5578426123,
0.0962271318,
0.2858428359,
0.4237955213,
0.218742311,
-0.4719440341,
-0.5832548738,
-0.867564261,
-0.6741253138,
-0.3038911819,
-0.0327865742,
0.1335750669,
0.5113851428,
-0.3199046254,
1.023903966,
-0.5234568119,
-0.4820390344,
-0.2502169311,
0.1797144413,
0.2669042051,
0.2346669883,
0.3995015621,
-0.3017261326,
-0.437243402,
-0.3710492551,
-0.4251166284,
-0.5762625933,
0.2016869038,
0.2807261646,
0.2670122683,
0.8001512289,
-0.354736656,
0.5032312274,
0.8656225204,
-0.4089943171,
0.6739218831,
0.3120307326,
-0.0241955202,
-0.9680752158,
0.0287336186,
0.4593490362,
0.0207810849,
-0.4803958237,
-0.3972471952,
0.0764158666,
0.2141914368,
-0.4101134539,
0.5729045272,
-0.489708364,
-0.208526358,
-0.2321011722,
-0.0262825936,
0.1079594269,
0.3434157372,
-0.2898363173,
0.9193544984,
0.3606631756,
-0.5606276393,
-0.2500049472,
0.0800736323,
-0.430237174,
0.6011976004,
-0.5423267484,
0.0057408735,
-0.3397504389,
0.2447254658,
-0.6703974605,
0.2334398627,
0.1390270591,
-0.5112401843,
0.2570181489,
-0.4541119933,
-0.2954498827,
-0.0951148495,
-0.4816463292,
0.6927486062,
0.5199656487,
-0.3241681159,
0.281937629,
0.6375851631,
0.206277743,
-0.6874672771,
-0.6384482384,
-0.3057554364,
-0.5636519194,
-0.1241104975,
-0.1759698391,
0.2217620015,
-0.8334530592,
-0.1784660518,
-0.2551733255,
0.1858826578,
0.185579747,
0.2917979658,
0.1631302536,
-0.1182217672,
0.2515162528,
-0.0569097623,
0.3178436756,
0.3390999734,
-0.1737890989,
0.5141121149,
-0.1487800777,
-0.3941627145,
-0.1933627129,
0.1658862829,
0.7110109925,
-0.3580812514,
0.95081985,
0.3299348354,
-0.2345145643,
-0.2563712299,
-0.5718539953,
-0.0379900523,
-0.4674810469,
0.4383837283,
0.1047291234,
-1.1190702915,
0.7113993764,
0.1922094673,
-0.1065454334,
0.5908656716,
0.5759731531,
-0.2185695767,
1.0134561062,
0.5169332623,
-0.2751834393,
0.4787529409,
0.0415714569,
0.2325720936,
-1.1024911404,
-0.0692624971,
-0.6870606542,
-0.1335726678,
-0.9621461034,
-0.5116594434,
0.5538862944,
-0.1108956411,
-0.1029263139,
-0.4087666273,
-0.1018058509,
0.4434053898,
0.186886996,
-0.4809743166,
0.207235083,
0.0097162025,
-0.2387521267,
-0.4301834404,
-0.4672131538,
-0.3985058069,
1.3712673187,
0.3519842625,
0.8781781197,
-0.0942958668,
0.4553409219,
0.685123384,
0.555107832,
-0.9140708447,
0.3638445437,
-0.2090683579,
-0.8067927957,
-0.1330910027,
-0.5301860571,
-0.756964922,
0.4385482073,
-0.0186541732,
-0.8615235686,
0.4326262176,
0.2502847016,
0.0534397624,
0.3831358552,
-0.3210408986,
0.7072447538,
-0.0359981023,
-0.0061275796,
0.0390412733,
-0.1537776738,
0.5605900884,
-0.209262684,
0.3514209986,
-0.2807167768,
0.2807843089,
1.0958255529,
-0.4002477527,
0.9638674259,
-0.5155525804,
-0.2968841791,
0.0416238345,
0.1948259771,
0.3627912998,
0.0412505046,
-0.2430379391,
0.4150420427,
-0.2620287836,
-0.5415531993,
-0.5461156964,
0.5233823657,
-0.7324714661,
-0.7490737438,
-0.6815236211,
-0.5196095109,
-0.4461407661,
0.0370346643,
0.2725098133,
0.3581187129,
-0.2176516056,
-0.0292884819,
0.5635080934,
-0.3507706523,
0.0740827695,
0.6088218093,
-0.1248656884,
0.0468106717,
0.5723085403,
0.2208886594,
0.4295613766,
-0.1800034493,
0.0711827651,
-0.1369887739,
-0.5931235552,
-0.0786990896,
0.4536123276,
-0.7503576279,
-0.0069453502,
-0.5929797292,
0.0891484767,
-0.4982191324,
-0.0415457115,
-0.4956001937,
-0.3126376569,
-0.3380504251,
-0.1640386134,
-0.0730351433,
0.8012824059,
-0.0775360912,
0.3274706304,
-0.5577648878,
-0.2085849643,
0.1706509888,
0.3060662448,
0.0098578539,
-0.7429656386,
-0.5409077406,
-0.0607287288,
-0.027505178,
-0.9441695809,
0.2221389562,
0.044200629,
0.5225470662,
0.4991660416,
0.1973791569,
0.4427589476,
-0.3406435847,
0.7278500199,
0.1147549003,
-1.2967249155,
0.2833395302,
-0.5195616484,
0.3121422827,
0.5838305354,
0.2763421834,
-0.8618447781,
-0.7581497431,
-0.3891934454,
-0.7416584492,
0.5078008175,
-0.1789970845,
0.3261701763,
-0.326366365,
0.3147713542,
0.0541510209,
0.2752217352,
-0.8805477023,
-0.4348840117,
-0.0924091414,
0.0850297883,
-0.1342190504,
-0.6327505112,
-0.0472396612,
-0.3232008815,
0.5160884857,
-0.179371208,
0.1891548038,
0.0182187948,
-0.3283709586,
-0.0763436854,
0.523496747,
0.5551368594,
0.6029695868,
-0.3079366982,
0.1698222458,
0.2573418915,
-0.3839237988,
0.1674364209,
-0.1401910037,
-0.2731772363,
0.0728006065,
0.4453253448,
0.6917449236,
-0.1421958059,
-0.3602105677,
0.7885699272,
0.0269156676,
0.1949932277,
-0.181736201,
-0.100169763,
-0.1027546376,
-0.0138809169,
0.3816820681,
-0.0823936537,
0.1397162825,
-0.5288246274,
0.0365922488,
0.6727150679,
-0.9441637397,
-0.5166214108,
0.4033094943,
0.2075504512,
0.2902351618,
0.6890345812,
-0.1564215273,
-0.7820421457,
0.4268077314,
0.3455559015,
0.6766408086,
-0.2160708159,
0.1901283115,
0.112251766,
0.5287175179,
0.1949804127,
0.1051938832,
0.306022197,
-0.9785709381,
-0.3446096778,
-0.6826601028,
0.1014139578,
0.2573233247,
-1.0045995712,
0.1596888751,
-0.3893526793,
-0.2749657333,
-0.2179877013,
-0.149351418,
-0.520911932,
0.2519885004,
0.3235530257,
0.9158092737,
-1.2914096117,
0.5264686942,
0.7066653371,
-0.1143963411,
-0.5962136388,
0.5813285708,
0.3372271359,
-0.7325550914,
0.7188897133,
0.1462782174,
-0.0281741302,
-0.3491333127,
-0.247491166,
-0.5321788788,
0.4666166306,
0.306663543,
-0.3246875107,
0.1634725034,
0.3731938004,
0.7077209353,
-0.3691216111,
0.1619122773,
0.5675133467,
0.2000648528,
-0.2428512275,
-1.0563423634,
0.1307140291,
-0.1354403943,
0.0161920469,
0.2749736905,
-0.6507729292,
1.1865459681,
-0.0656461418,
-0.2484069765,
-0.6408343315,
0.6151048541,
0.0764915645,
0.045054473,
0.5328748822,
0.5838760138,
0.6764698625,
0.1038937792,
1.0181386471,
0.0241165794,
0.4938074052,
0.9008707404,
-0.3975643218,
0.2054429352,
0.6433619857,
-0.2244766206,
0.2619686127,
0.3519668281,
0.1684084386,
0.4068078399,
0.5752595067,
-0.4127907753,
-0.0753515363,
-0.4439235628,
-0.4702502191,
0.6160520911,
0.4970998466,
-0.3983811736,
-0.2470667362,
-0.3153681457,
0.4872971475,
0.0884827152,
-0.5436438322,
0.4416040778,
0.2419349253,
-0.2466225177,
0.3492129147,
0.1181053445,
1.0120937824,
-0.3090305924,
0.2382192463,
-0.5578690767,
0.1409722567,
-0.3272417188,
-0.5926902294,
0.1972282231,
0.1277447343,
-0.2978408933,
0.0230619702,
0.3784711957,
-0.2079382688,
-0.5484172702,
0.4260795414,
0.8563086987,
-0.1368188858,
-0.0058215717,
-0.3266352117,
0.3685974181,
0.2443347424,
-0.3459989429,
0.5913262963,
0.409248203,
-0.2531176805,
0.3596091568,
0.3017711937,
0.4142031372,
0.122952193,
0.1094108298,
1.0659860373,
-0.4384024143,
-0.3952745497,
-1.0503218174,
0.5123482943,
0.0017297415,
-0.3486700654,
0.9892419577,
0.6633144617,
1.1004855633,
0.1959587485,
1.0390012264,
0.2058782727,
0.4988938272,
-0.4134503007,
0.7772448063,
-0.7303769588,
0.5420436859,
-0.5580364466,
-1.003549695,
-0.2602640986,
0.4403829277,
-0.4450368881,
0.3196387589,
0.6003203988,
0.6809222102,
-0.1520005316,
-0.194014132,
0.2285056263,
0.37225613,
0.4579345882,
-0.1471457779,
0.8340134025,
-0.0721657574,
0.0334274955,
0.1526368409,
-0.0902314335,
0.0175911114,
-0.8010203838,
-1.1635490656,
-0.4123267829,
-0.3029744029,
-0.6010369062,
-0.0076478398,
0.885058105,
0.303838402,
-0.9354510307,
-0.4181303084,
0.4388662875,
0.0578588769,
0.4350315332,
-0.3340808451,
0.2335080057,
-0.147722289,
-0.6868181825,
0.1811055243,
0.0990755931,
0.0209617205,
-0.3446053267,
-0.0950386897,
0.0091564199,
0.2230529785,
0.3471219838,
0.2200793177,
-0.4945587218,
-0.2693203688,
-0.3220107555,
-0.1681405902,
0.0726287067,
1.1352243423,
-0.6578891277,
0.303991586,
0.2436986119,
0.3862553835,
0.3146182597,
-0.0580798388,
0.7839726806,
-1.0708867311,
0.2876245081,
0.3320637643,
0.4566450417,
0.3930365145,
-0.1780414283,
0.1171682999,
0.409779042,
-0.2603736818,
-1.1180489063,
0.4123303294,
-0.6216624379,
-0.119138889,
1.3521748781,
-0.1795974672,
0.089669019,
-0.117354244,
0.2055457532,
0.3325107694,
-0.5257869363,
0.995839715,
0.7676722407,
0.0247410033,
-0.0876136273,
-0.4486249387,
0.6392964721,
0.5109042525,
-0.6128031611,
0.142834425,
0.6930135489,
0.2454381138,
-0.1731468737,
0.7431311607,
-0.2069745213,
-0.0937216058,
-0.3417651653,
0.1998176426,
0.0345415957,
0.203251332,
-0.5792177916,
-0.1097623482,
0.1719540805,
0.0290859714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03441v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03441v2
|
Benchmarking ChatGPT on Algorithmic Reasoning
| 2024-04-04T13:39:06 | 2024-04-16T21:32:47 |
Sean McLeish, Avi Schwarzschild, Tom Goldstein
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We evaluate ChatGPT's ability to solve algorithm problems from the CLRS
benchmark suite that is designed for GNNs. The benchmark requires the use of a
specified classical algorithm to solve a given problem. We find that ChatGPT
outperforms specialist GNN models, using Python to successfully solve these
problems. This raises new points in the discussion about learning algorithms
with neural networks and how we think about what out of distribution testing
looks like with web scale training data.
|
[
-0.473099947,
-0.6604214907,
0.403957814,
0.0381853208,
-0.1551831961,
-0.0762882307,
-0.388039887,
-0.4153625071,
-0.2448916137,
0.2900130153,
-0.6314456463,
-0.0452571958,
-0.4602786005,
0.0206757076,
-0.5446010232,
0.8818987608,
0.0224325955,
0.3590477109,
-0.1129751205,
-0.2618356049,
-0.3441781402,
-0.5117816329,
-1.1304907799,
-0.5647455454,
0.299116075,
0.4202899635,
0.7982724905,
0.5362312794,
0.9283509254,
0.3200935125,
-0.1870986968,
-0.096472159,
-0.4580653012,
0.101513721,
-0.0585282855,
-0.5702280998,
0.159661442,
-0.1448136866,
0.4365636706,
0.634427011,
-0.4013127387,
0.2702563405,
-0.204461813,
0.8895574808,
-0.4520284534,
0.2010603249,
-0.8181737661,
0.1477667689,
-0.0586353466,
-0.0242348593,
-0.269579947,
-0.6551178098,
0.4946000278,
-0.6098172069,
0.6639959216,
0.1124779582,
0.6759023666,
0.3381348252,
-0.2538235486,
-0.5663912892,
-0.6650978923,
0.6221784949,
-0.577254951,
0.3651998341,
0.1443484724,
0.9317170382,
-0.2825441957,
-0.9579089284,
-0.179196775,
-0.3818707466,
0.1668913215,
0.0755102709,
-0.1065671816,
-0.0751152933,
0.6455621719,
0.6462392211,
-0.9364115596,
-0.0984996259,
-0.6558309793,
-0.0198423602,
0.723598361,
0.1054421216,
0.0839254931,
0.3678606153,
-0.2892359495,
-0.4300740361,
-0.6951369047,
0.0226395149,
0.4588104188,
0.0356267877,
0.2163484991,
0.2453198135,
-0.3313717246,
0.7107233405,
-0.2770490944,
0.4043273926,
0.241964519,
-0.0407197662,
-0.1386565417,
0.2590192556,
0.6675215364,
0.387422502,
0.6624231935,
-0.1234364286,
-0.2487580925,
0.122901693,
0.1863606572,
-0.8376262188,
-0.6896800399,
0.0553849488,
-0.395655036,
-0.050658945,
-0.2326003909,
-0.7750238776,
-0.52408427,
-0.3448688388,
0.5081272721,
-0.3142386377,
-0.2784243226,
0.2284607589,
-0.6256917119,
0.2183147073,
0.1953208297,
-0.8298421502,
0.6455731392,
0.8086255193,
0.8240434527,
0.0208175555,
-0.024414422,
-0.3416700661,
-0.4899289906,
-0.3480232954,
0.8762338161,
-0.3707190156,
-0.2785801589,
0.0053310501,
-0.4087321162,
-0.293394953,
-0.8375229836,
0.4188380539,
-0.4133665562,
-0.1095430404,
-0.4876042902,
-0.893972218,
-0.179069832,
0.4574530125,
-0.5634071231,
0.832457304,
-0.1176807806,
-0.8012473583,
0.2682682872,
-0.9266662002,
-0.070263952,
0.1139022857,
-0.0487059578,
-0.3863299191,
-0.0013255851,
0.2799749076,
0.0817781091,
-0.3470247686,
-0.0419356264,
-0.3760997653,
-0.6214704514,
0.4499275088,
-0.5299214721,
0.6001901627,
0.4707650244,
-0.4944580197,
0.0839647129,
-0.5476017594,
0.5484507084,
0.2087708563,
-0.0192421786,
0.0646621212,
0.4107843637,
-0.1606951952,
-0.0538436547,
-0.0555508398,
-0.423589617,
0.1521069854,
-0.2614300251,
1.0496755838,
0.5143722296,
-0.0394793302,
-0.0713763684,
-0.4214882553,
0.1345841438,
-0.3745969236,
0.260406673,
0.193226859,
-0.7921493649,
-0.7774047852,
0.0906916857,
0.4170065224,
0.6527556777,
-0.5389504433,
-0.0632544756,
-0.0610118955,
-0.6842082739,
-0.2614458203,
0.0299120229,
0.3242108524,
0.3213165998,
0.2914442718,
-0.6278816462,
-0.4510957897,
-0.97790277,
-0.4347008467,
-0.1229165792,
-0.1216252297,
0.4029380679,
0.648837924,
0.041080337,
0.7590298653,
-0.4308829308,
-0.0819192901,
-0.2222991884,
0.4421329498,
0.2960521281,
0.4331169426,
0.2820263803,
-0.9568359256,
-0.544267714,
0.0872330889,
-0.7385359406,
-0.0454053879,
0.1412391067,
0.318736136,
-0.1787694693,
0.5899502635,
-0.5111471415,
0.5759553909,
0.4586164653,
-0.1058591828,
0.865319252,
-0.3669211268,
0.0596534312,
-0.4870970845,
0.0578101166,
0.316373229,
-0.2150401026,
-0.6858879328,
0.0806610733,
-0.0918062329,
-0.436263144,
-0.4309726059,
0.3190560341,
-0.357242018,
-0.5484781265,
-0.3073113263,
0.0920428708,
-0.2876307666,
0.3315383792,
0.2592651248,
0.9654689431,
0.5064914227,
-0.5273228884,
0.607862711,
0.0875897855,
-0.5269206166,
0.4445677996,
-1.1295620203,
0.263990432,
0.0623277463,
0.2012256682,
-1.0025348663,
0.0763680711,
0.2119856328,
-0.4127919972,
-0.2509482503,
-0.3802132905,
-0.5291701555,
-0.4644630551,
0.0825872943,
0.4733774364,
0.7011387944,
-0.6451516151,
0.1643120795,
0.0092273513,
0.2633143067,
-0.3245219588,
-0.5573221445,
-0.1067912877,
-0.3073795438,
-0.624859333,
0.0885807872,
-0.3020492196,
-0.467767477,
-0.0192153156,
0.0932937935,
-0.4335850179,
-0.0199825671,
-0.0913811103,
-0.3069270849,
-0.471365422,
-0.0195618719,
-0.5723041892,
-0.2570723593,
0.3447399437,
-0.2983992398,
0.655567944,
-0.5863079429,
-0.6699118614,
-0.2694248259,
0.1985099316,
0.2558302879,
-0.2744751275,
0.2622199655,
0.5907144547,
-0.087008059,
-0.2318783551,
-0.6242024302,
-0.2487069219,
-0.5245380402,
0.2749423981,
-0.2718035579,
-0.6545228958,
0.6909157634,
-0.2602590322,
-0.09109281,
0.2327367961,
0.5252372026,
0.112953715,
1.0831427574,
0.0595679991,
-0.1026934385,
0.3604540527,
-0.3536811471,
0.0801905915,
-0.6581612825,
0.3010175824,
-0.6488624811,
-0.5099162459,
-0.8428070545,
-0.0457406379,
0.524307847,
0.1840410382,
-0.5986611247,
0.3146442771,
-0.8906245828,
0.772579968,
1.0207314491,
0.3060283363,
0.1159248874,
-0.2693472803,
-0.0275765918,
0.2275405675,
-0.5801743865,
-0.0665015802,
1.0822131634,
0.1523050666,
0.4796352088,
-0.067024827,
0.5341899395,
0.1457901746,
0.2019855678,
-0.4325002432,
0.5275246501,
0.0495964326,
-0.6936089396,
-0.2051892877,
-0.5502716303,
-0.9475553632,
0.4134519994,
0.117372416,
-1.1768637896,
-0.0241549537,
0.1537452042,
0.158009991,
0.4221540987,
-0.9136305451,
1.2129056454,
-0.1339410245,
0.0237496905,
-0.4007639587,
-0.7001278996,
0.2443383485,
0.4404139519,
-0.0414041318,
-0.1664176732,
0.3712685406,
0.6669045091,
-0.6202756166,
0.6103534102,
-0.2216229886,
0.600703001,
0.5474871993,
0.0336884037,
0.3945468664,
0.0212861057,
-0.1094391197,
0.1530736536,
0.0901958346,
-0.5251162052,
-0.6042762995,
0.3879345357,
-0.8605487943,
-0.4559836984,
-0.5250976086,
-0.5043492317,
-0.3035420477,
0.0870503187,
0.3710416555,
0.7015622258,
-0.2086105794,
0.2354047745,
0.8317691684,
0.206736967,
0.7057129741,
0.2938665152,
-0.1006757542,
-0.5110652447,
0.8624655008,
0.0383673012,
0.4536198974,
0.0425215885,
0.4858326316,
-0.4121604264,
-0.6984644532,
-0.6269612908,
-0.1412265152,
-1.0062458515,
0.1263969243,
0.0716536939,
-0.6633834839,
0.1119521782,
0.0011470665,
-0.4692527652,
-0.2975235879,
0.2503469884,
0.3696924448,
0.32041803,
0.7801244855,
-0.0805512518,
0.5004488826,
-0.5358814001,
0.038954623,
0.4617258906,
0.343137145,
-0.023935739,
-0.2355296761,
0.0051231198,
0.0192814488,
-0.4684150219,
-0.6340277791,
0.0804297552,
0.1455104649,
0.7656273842,
0.4030799568,
-0.1401921064,
0.4468555748,
-0.4556758106,
0.8264716268,
0.0297485571,
-0.754717052,
0.4446562827,
-0.4191079438,
0.2466480285,
0.5575457215,
0.4346207976,
-0.702270627,
0.0087492224,
-0.7908788919,
-0.4125925303,
0.2356671095,
0.4721851647,
-0.2664245367,
0.1225433573,
0.3990975916,
-0.0941867679,
0.2153005749,
-0.3557833135,
-0.2634004354,
-0.2332772315,
-0.1245074719,
-0.2996403873,
0.0010534633,
-0.1171762794,
-0.1811956763,
0.6333121657,
-0.1822211593,
0.3238884807,
0.3296191096,
-0.0124987829,
0.184954837,
0.1662361622,
0.7275514007,
0.9791692495,
-0.167133227,
-0.0597372167,
0.2280311882,
-0.4096236527,
-0.0511564091,
0.2876728177,
-0.1791756749,
-0.0318513326,
0.1128999293,
0.6868664622,
0.0509641208,
-0.7485955954,
0.5114992857,
-0.4904097021,
-0.5018488765,
-0.3489814103,
0.2592110634,
0.1312528402,
0.3862200081,
0.3112255037,
0.2152318805,
0.3797664046,
-0.250392437,
0.3359758556,
0.5777025819,
-0.5608171821,
-0.1546747535,
0.6010970473,
-0.0786421672,
-0.6261439323,
0.9621604681,
-0.2344242036,
-0.8539683819,
0.9691188335,
0.5303455591,
0.8018966913,
0.000830575,
0.0542628244,
0.2473007441,
0.1748069972,
-0.4732657969,
0.1836140305,
-0.1046388298,
-0.6659758091,
-0.3366058469,
-0.0695836917,
-1.1150640249,
-0.0501088314,
-0.5131331682,
0.1646313965,
-0.6171887517,
0.0832832977,
0.1756535918,
0.2329275608,
-0.7104945779,
0.346704185,
0.0840488747,
1.0126252174,
-0.5814034343,
0.6506397128,
0.4110907614,
-0.1201817915,
-0.7717444897,
-0.4260337949,
0.1501785964,
-0.9115980268,
0.599840343,
0.4956632555,
0.2959806919,
-0.0192880593,
-0.5313779116,
-0.7956801057,
0.8931712508,
0.1953877211,
-0.5340136886,
0.3996887505,
0.3043028414,
0.5469911098,
-0.2238550186,
0.8195630908,
0.5703404546,
0.3047216237,
0.3210529685,
-1.1966737509,
-0.3086675406,
-0.4760300517,
-0.0680632591,
0.1604226381,
-0.6342087984,
1.106965661,
0.0781363696,
0.0832324997,
0.0189414024,
0.4854026735,
0.2857311666,
0.4828220308,
0.6531019807,
0.8088139892,
0.7986757159,
-0.3555111289,
1.0993531942,
-0.1568801999,
0.5466913581,
0.9628880024,
-0.2499691248,
0.8029195666,
0.1754183024,
-0.2185375839,
0.4444024563,
0.7687479258,
-0.1193643734,
0.544496417,
0.8214195967,
-0.2629297376,
-0.1482447535,
0.0852778032,
-0.618208468,
0.1727294475,
0.2738888562,
-0.0388583243,
-0.4385462105,
-0.2995566726,
-0.310801208,
-0.1318351626,
-0.5797865987,
0.7770958543,
0.0938773379,
-0.7044590116,
0.5858248472,
-0.2795064151,
0.357213974,
-0.6294839978,
-0.0090326462,
-0.0265338011,
0.8113251925,
0.0520084389,
-0.6863826513,
0.3025409281,
-0.487365067,
0.1730540544,
0.0947399512,
0.910102427,
-0.1428257972,
-0.4828421772,
0.0185030326,
0.4126331806,
0.4364075959,
-0.2524488568,
-0.8894850016,
0.1405956149,
-0.2828275561,
-0.2052905709,
0.4499151111,
0.3437548578,
-0.0032732596,
1.1332005262,
0.6121069193,
0.0463846363,
0.3204295635,
0.0259043425,
0.8507652879,
-0.4988884628,
-0.5828287005,
-0.8619926572,
0.1612141281,
-0.3926794529,
-0.569473207,
0.5318624377,
0.6857123375,
0.9170171618,
0.1138136685,
0.7295219302,
0.0112667698,
0.4803337455,
-0.3498121202,
0.4857516289,
-0.2537316084,
-0.0829198286,
-0.0734150484,
-0.8656625748,
-0.2564276755,
0.5841751099,
-0.5499734282,
-0.0203269236,
0.7800907493,
0.7696371078,
-0.1063896194,
0.7679966092,
0.0339177921,
-0.4485456049,
0.5093485117,
0.9496325254,
1.0414215326,
-0.5945433974,
0.7115396857,
-0.475038141,
-0.1095489711,
-0.1316790134,
-1.0987474918,
-1.1255489588,
-0.308226496,
-0.3933600783,
-0.3380300701,
0.5000403523,
0.8784742951,
0.8581622839,
-0.8458926678,
-0.2921575606,
-0.5170460343,
0.1504143178,
-0.7452906966,
-0.1993561983,
0.4600035846,
-0.6773914695,
-0.4415464997,
0.319626987,
-0.2530764043,
-0.2065847516,
-0.1979927868,
-0.1257888377,
0.1322707385,
-0.1967178732,
0.07764934,
0.4641645253,
-0.416217953,
-0.5988386869,
-0.1301181912,
0.1429494023,
0.2997614145,
1.1656634808,
-0.6861399412,
0.2916569412,
0.485260278,
0.8491335511,
0.7726132274,
0.130227685,
0.5387778878,
-0.4762861431,
0.1295331866,
0.2498359233,
0.3786171377,
0.2549083233,
-0.0444135219,
0.7330769897,
0.3306950033,
-1.1375426054,
-0.6623209119,
0.0896098688,
-0.8862420321,
-0.090646036,
0.9684502482,
-0.180162102,
-0.2126222104,
-0.1044502705,
-0.1489234418,
-0.1109244376,
-0.1716623008,
0.6860107183,
0.7060755491,
-0.3434566557,
-0.3415157795,
-0.9520335793,
0.506814301,
0.3936182261,
-0.5728845,
0.0511947162,
0.086189203,
0.4600754082,
0.0372019522,
0.6913284063,
0.1890434325,
0.4196803272,
0.304007411,
-0.1270654947,
-0.0680554062,
-0.0273934826,
0.0150078516,
0.1030175313,
0.1064567193,
-0.3344778717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03437v1
|
Knowledge Graph Representation for Political Information Sources
| 2024-04-04T13:36:01 | 2024-04-04T13:36:01 |
Tinatin Osmonova, Alexey Tikhonov, Ivan P. Yamshchikov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
With the rise of computational social science, many scholars utilize data
analysis and natural language processing tools to analyze social media, news
articles, and other accessible data sources for examining political and social
discourse. Particularly, the study of the emergence of echo-chambers due to the
dissemination of specific information has become a topic of interest in mixed
methods research areas. In this paper, we analyze data collected from two news
portals, Breitbart News (BN) and New York Times (NYT) to prove the hypothesis
that the formation of echo-chambers can be partially explained on the level of
an individual information consumption rather than a collective topology of
individuals' social networks. Our research findings are presented through
knowledge graphs, utilizing a dataset spanning 11.5 years gathered from BN and
NYT media portals. We demonstrate that the application of knowledge
representation techniques to the aforementioned news streams highlights,
contrary to common assumptions, shows relative "internal" neutrality of both
sources and polarizing attitude towards a small fraction of entities.
Additionally, we argue that such characteristics in information sources lead to
fundamental disparities in audience worldviews, potentially acting as a
catalyst for the formation of echo-chambers.
|
[
-0.6989198327,
-0.8391845822,
0.7077132463,
-0.3576694429,
-0.3671606779,
0.568469584,
-0.1590253115,
-0.2059780955,
0.6755816936,
0.3257110417,
-0.3594912589,
-0.391514957,
-0.7150913477,
-0.1349947602,
-0.4026308656,
0.9868906736,
0.3194722533,
0.0333545841,
0.0350606963,
-0.1246685013,
-0.1971977353,
-0.6092521548,
-0.4823439717,
-0.2346015126,
0.7824277878,
0.1603799164,
0.8134388924,
0.535758853,
0.0830526501,
0.1492803693,
-0.1316219121,
0.2493060231,
-0.7415830493,
-0.0303138308,
-0.1136662662,
-0.3641059101,
0.1659278572,
0.0625804514,
0.663969934,
0.7852455378,
0.0838016123,
0.1017459035,
0.4377979338,
1.0100634098,
-0.4135665894,
0.1895328611,
-0.6292034388,
-0.0482663177,
-0.3612614274,
-0.7512354851,
-0.2715708017,
-0.5285259485,
0.0290852096,
-0.560446322,
0.179947868,
0.1487084329,
0.8419732451,
-0.0787869617,
-0.7869204283,
-0.5205661058,
-0.8706440926,
0.4320356548,
-0.4007056952,
0.4241716862,
0.0044746785,
0.3645059466,
-0.0821746588,
-0.5910882354,
-0.5807850957,
0.2780995071,
-0.2901748717,
0.1497860104,
-0.5381223559,
-0.2473686337,
-0.079309307,
0.1014454514,
-0.350779593,
-0.3339447081,
-0.7990570664,
-0.238737002,
0.3420891464,
0.0939092413,
0.1027296111,
-0.6504440904,
-0.3374366164,
0.0171954054,
-0.6743062735,
0.0775206983,
0.9880083203,
0.6671159863,
-0.204121843,
0.655516088,
-0.141999349,
0.7421996593,
0.03951516,
0.0763074234,
0.0613245033,
-0.3465610445,
0.0881551951,
0.234324947,
0.7780308127,
0.4500650167,
0.1105973423,
0.0464628786,
0.3036137521,
0.0916519612,
0.4239759147,
-0.3949504793,
0.1288614869,
0.0300995801,
-0.7247896194,
-0.3742933571,
0.3308175206,
-0.9837089181,
-1.091016531,
-0.4752869904,
0.0582449473,
-0.0243909638,
-0.5325860381,
-0.1880272329,
-0.6480422616,
-0.1488963068,
0.316234529,
0.0020170291,
0.4537027776,
0.5436202288,
1.0097243786,
0.1278306395,
0.2077209651,
-0.0774999559,
0.0434504673,
-0.4281316996,
0.9741879106,
-0.4893960059,
0.151224643,
0.2494380623,
-0.2641369104,
0.2752814889,
-0.3819878399,
0.2983506918,
-0.8025615811,
0.4991939068,
-0.6239507794,
-0.7050154209,
-0.4414010346,
0.1255968064,
-0.8210186362,
0.5679079294,
-0.0022818574,
-1.3671554327,
0.1875859797,
-0.5671198964,
-0.1416098177,
-0.2463814616,
-0.5065659285,
-0.1311250627,
0.0510653891,
0.1172123551,
0.3929536343,
-0.2010505646,
0.1761487722,
-0.361394763,
-0.3226927519,
0.3349189758,
-0.3628049195,
0.9664691687,
0.1291974932,
-0.3503166437,
-0.0820937604,
-0.5304009318,
-0.469381094,
0.0003745048,
-0.1607792228,
-0.5897961259,
0.402993381,
-0.3626646996,
0.0805134848,
0.0393344238,
-0.4349211752,
-0.015404203,
-0.0256078001,
0.3367319703,
0.8738321066,
0.581464529,
0.3742583096,
-0.5439218879,
0.2279171497,
0.4376845956,
-0.0442757495,
0.2211267501,
-0.6129912734,
-0.6981446147,
0.2568179369,
-0.0144669889,
0.2848784626,
-0.6477302313,
0.2092493623,
-0.2928127944,
-0.3554642498,
-0.5470750928,
-0.1280138493,
-0.1456377953,
0.3817789853,
0.1151472777,
0.1632505953,
-0.5296853781,
-1.1619653702,
-0.5658162236,
-0.2947991788,
0.0529564768,
0.3142021894,
0.1764242649,
0.1726590395,
0.9020810127,
-0.1530673355,
-0.1139302179,
-0.0578943118,
0.3702180386,
0.4121496975,
-0.2568008304,
0.4155124724,
-0.9562318325,
-0.4097850323,
0.1035245061,
-0.5585264564,
-0.0185111631,
0.0305304471,
-0.0968773663,
0.0845880285,
0.2422278225,
-0.0090524955,
0.5280508995,
0.7420086265,
-0.5134219527,
0.336477071,
0.5166235566,
0.6154444814,
-1.2207232714,
-0.2210887223,
-0.0101451585,
-0.3070865273,
-0.6966305375,
-0.4202669263,
-0.2661049664,
-0.0629046187,
-0.1997576505,
0.3007152975,
-0.4925243855,
-0.0338738859,
-0.2825869024,
0.5238454342,
0.0238890797,
0.2731233239,
-0.1170850769,
0.2375056595,
0.5295343995,
-0.245898068,
0.2263022065,
-0.2526086569,
-0.3172497451,
0.4079992771,
-0.3342150152,
0.2003430575,
-0.3569359779,
0.2862708867,
-1.0959954262,
-0.3474047184,
0.3406867981,
-0.555677712,
-0.1469798237,
-0.3907644451,
-0.4920676947,
-0.2367801964,
-0.3477780819,
0.0534401201,
0.3577794433,
-0.343400538,
0.3162644506,
0.7864977121,
-0.2297112942,
-0.5711176991,
-0.562605679,
-0.0827290863,
-0.2692767978,
-0.6392393112,
-0.0079795597,
0.4131732285,
-0.6151997447,
0.7497204542,
-0.0155338617,
-0.0536195487,
-0.5643724799,
0.2627761066,
-0.0873911455,
-0.2737822235,
0.4790121019,
-0.0532892346,
0.1056022197,
-0.0402172618,
-0.306163013,
0.6267921329,
-0.1339107305,
-0.4797289968,
-0.6770113111,
0.5100019574,
0.6229311824,
0.0124772657,
1.1335982084,
0.2867407203,
-0.3581464887,
-0.2469682842,
-0.6594918966,
-0.4589757025,
-0.3278866112,
-0.0385557152,
0.3765850365,
-0.8498697281,
0.8854736686,
0.0238222834,
0.0734802932,
0.3621209562,
0.643809855,
0.0225553233,
0.6940218806,
0.3327307701,
-0.1011138633,
0.4419572055,
-0.2672338784,
0.4394588172,
-0.5321307778,
-0.1384086013,
-0.6641138196,
-0.4068181217,
-0.7027118802,
-0.4411505461,
0.6434975266,
-0.2130082101,
-0.2033194304,
-0.1035971269,
-0.7009242177,
0.2547166944,
0.5534332991,
0.1005477011,
0.3890092075,
0.4629671872,
0.2267624587,
0.0027085377,
-0.8722090125,
-0.5675984025,
1.0773402452,
0.2670178711,
0.6386160851,
-0.0349101722,
0.7097622156,
0.5775337815,
0.2896893322,
-0.5973909497,
0.0721145049,
0.108340688,
-0.7575461864,
-0.1844897121,
-0.7805553079,
-1.0372977257,
0.1380360872,
-0.2144393474,
-0.7085596919,
0.5501198769,
-0.1092133,
-0.0560233146,
0.7955880165,
-0.4466307461,
0.44486323,
0.0716952607,
-0.3347653449,
-0.4130291343,
-0.2997124195,
0.295642823,
0.1820774227,
0.6783035398,
-0.108652696,
0.1295875013,
0.9622017145,
-0.1029802263,
0.8382703662,
-0.351680994,
0.3276260793,
0.7943815589,
-0.0933339223,
0.4590200484,
0.082909435,
-0.0499845408,
0.3666824698,
-0.2904956043,
-0.3440356553,
-0.6026938558,
0.4605711102,
-1.026073575,
-0.4788433313,
-0.3944862187,
-0.4524146914,
0.1035273001,
0.2455449551,
0.2568231225,
0.6316595674,
0.0678364336,
0.6038621664,
0.3012176752,
0.1778818965,
0.1242713854,
0.3658040166,
-0.0840100646,
-0.4498249292,
0.4792063832,
0.875659883,
0.0831266716,
0.1087188274,
0.30858621,
-0.2182009965,
-0.4342823327,
-0.0941644236,
0.2653620839,
-0.5192347765,
-0.3994105458,
-0.2602285445,
-0.315312624,
-0.1536830515,
-0.1630027294,
-0.38343817,
-0.2850674391,
0.0561084002,
-0.1738035381,
0.2641966641,
1.2578343153,
-0.0933429524,
0.3466772139,
-0.2792353332,
0.0923489258,
0.2287754864,
0.3543077707,
0.0023017018,
-0.1890599132,
-0.4280832112,
0.2504476905,
-0.4602748752,
-1.7742602825,
-0.0891686603,
-0.4110223353,
0.6054791212,
0.5866773725,
0.3902049959,
0.4654456675,
-0.2274825722,
0.8672740459,
0.0061500315,
-0.4999862015,
0.3556135595,
-0.7398363948,
-0.2979601324,
0.3124853969,
0.5871598125,
-0.4339109361,
-0.9975413084,
-1.061434269,
-0.6225686669,
0.5190034509,
0.494514972,
0.0796607435,
0.0384892449,
0.1224604324,
0.1194815487,
0.4056392014,
-0.7786024809,
-0.2805549502,
-0.3368820548,
0.0191702265,
0.2405704707,
-0.1287858039,
-0.4978670776,
-0.0085096434,
0.5334066749,
-0.0753196999,
0.3815841675,
0.3879018128,
0.5136625171,
-0.3154584765,
0.3102426231,
0.2548690736,
0.8670310974,
-0.2670191824,
0.4435167909,
-0.4662124217,
0.0012523915,
-0.0286345463,
-0.0765955225,
-0.2445639223,
0.3212421834,
0.4958743751,
0.6797792912,
-0.1824967265,
-0.0387475193,
0.4879993498,
0.0047218078,
-0.0810271874,
-0.4091672003,
-0.2703745961,
0.5654824972,
0.3991200924,
0.6453294158,
0.1487073451,
0.2561522722,
-1.0709160566,
0.2146402448,
0.4914768338,
-0.3965047002,
-0.2686091661,
0.349817872,
0.1216949075,
-0.241994828,
0.3680762053,
-0.2292665094,
-0.3735298514,
0.4009467959,
0.1783129573,
0.6394424438,
0.1424465477,
0.4849609137,
0.3299973309,
0.4671180248,
0.3612531424,
-0.0005589245,
0.0881775245,
-0.8542795181,
-0.0840908736,
-0.3032084703,
-0.2576451302,
0.2909255624,
-0.7193941474,
0.1925272346,
-0.4298705459,
-0.565767765,
0.2342136353,
0.3943754435,
-0.7103335261,
-0.2947023809,
0.1582006365,
0.5465574265,
-1.1599510908,
0.1774681956,
0.6740660071,
-0.1629168093,
-0.7511038184,
0.3502057791,
0.5523450375,
-0.5105594397,
0.120008558,
-0.1434040964,
-0.1136563346,
-0.3576542735,
-0.4258701205,
-0.6495690346,
0.7638091445,
0.5141186118,
-0.4643618762,
0.06643112,
0.106266357,
0.5201181173,
-0.5270693302,
-0.0384762883,
0.1969765723,
0.7078059912,
-0.2501265705,
-0.5109841824,
0.0796319544,
-0.2339579016,
-0.3712635934,
0.4188741446,
-0.8627265096,
1.0074279308,
0.302822113,
-0.632245779,
-0.7669920325,
0.3937029541,
0.0557904392,
0.6139960289,
0.5968229175,
0.189846918,
0.8335301876,
-0.134405911,
0.9682549834,
-0.4364944398,
0.3148208857,
0.6781805158,
0.1698277891,
0.5650642514,
0.5507213473,
-0.2328485698,
0.8751364946,
0.4979497492,
0.1725886017,
0.4316591322,
0.087463975,
0.0217223931,
0.1536811739,
-0.3483206332,
-0.2897140682,
0.1657741964,
0.5118561387,
-0.3942125738,
-0.4432366788,
-0.2162870765,
0.2835276723,
0.1971619278,
-0.2326971889,
0.8030133843,
-0.0639532879,
-0.4957412779,
0.2703745365,
-0.4660283029,
0.1161724627,
-0.5325486064,
-0.0265556537,
-0.192282632,
-0.4145923555,
-0.4304693043,
-1.1139968634,
0.4250257909,
-0.0536032878,
-0.1313822716,
-0.0283951052,
0.8744511604,
-0.2346895933,
-0.3811758757,
0.7371165156,
0.9385771751,
0.076406166,
-0.0750995055,
-0.3633327782,
0.2333529145,
0.1135954112,
-0.5088865757,
0.0261215754,
0.6899287701,
-0.0037255492,
0.2463586777,
0.6396041512,
0.5190346241,
0.2076410353,
0.118340753,
1.2091970444,
-0.3687005043,
-0.5013190508,
-0.6259652376,
0.6487654448,
-0.5971474648,
-0.0411903672,
0.733835876,
0.507324338,
0.7831929326,
0.3032765687,
1.1905652285,
-0.2994842231,
0.8914732337,
-0.4194230139,
0.7793679237,
-0.5654284358,
0.2249837965,
-0.0938310176,
-0.8187424541,
0.0289786644,
0.4016531706,
-0.2914179265,
0.0540221967,
0.5867869854,
0.8488324285,
-0.2512293756,
0.1243148893,
-0.0071431636,
0.5160007477,
0.1823682487,
0.1644886583,
1.0547692776,
0.0793456882,
0.5870915651,
-0.5137910843,
-0.3040684164,
-0.3995209634,
-0.4681341946,
-0.9902060032,
-0.9208983779,
-0.0602556355,
-0.4811626077,
0.1781231016,
0.4691197872,
0.7213181853,
-0.3808290362,
-0.3499487936,
0.142822668,
0.5381323099,
-0.1060349271,
-0.3632821739,
0.637046814,
-0.1868054867,
-0.4546303749,
-0.0337449498,
0.1958588064,
-0.2804905176,
-0.5991598368,
0.1481369585,
0.0021931031,
0.4304945469,
0.2151629627,
0.0417016596,
-0.6233535409,
-0.6310964227,
-0.1266475916,
0.091755271,
0.2101708651,
1.0396564007,
-0.7673378587,
0.5803024173,
0.7265136838,
0.2969914377,
0.2747665644,
0.3235370517,
0.3189600408,
-0.7908948064,
0.2624897063,
0.2460860312,
0.180397898,
0.5050983429,
-0.3307261169,
0.3503756225,
0.3227079809,
-0.5523304939,
-0.8144214749,
0.1352654994,
-0.9329970479,
-0.3109955788,
1.0016944408,
0.3571454287,
-0.2183983475,
-0.4122649133,
-0.1093554646,
0.6031850576,
-0.7731539607,
1.0328896046,
0.9400013089,
-0.5789707303,
-0.1878901124,
-0.9287617803,
0.3834688663,
-0.4121136069,
-0.7506330013,
0.0016454956,
0.4051153958,
0.2378909141,
0.6917577982,
0.9017905593,
-0.148057282,
-0.1255954653,
0.2922958732,
-0.3877472281,
0.0912949443,
-0.4394345582,
0.2315092832,
0.5649735332,
-0.4213916659,
-0.0216549765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03429v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03429v1
|
Scaffolding Language Learning via Multi-modal Tutoring Systems with Pedagogical Instructions
| 2024-04-04T13:22:28 | 2024-04-04T13:22:28 |
Zhengyuan Liu, Stella Xin Yin, Carolyn Lee, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs) that imitate human tutors and aim to
provide immediate and customized instructions or feedback to learners have
shown their effectiveness in education. With the emergence of generative
artificial intelligence, large language models (LLMs) further entitle the
systems to complex and coherent conversational interactions. These systems
would be of great help in language education as it involves developing skills
in communication, which, however, drew relatively less attention. Additionally,
due to the complicated cognitive development at younger ages, more endeavors
are needed for practical uses. Scaffolding refers to a teaching technique where
teachers provide support and guidance to students for learning and developing
new concepts or skills. It is an effective way to support diverse learning
needs, goals, processes, and outcomes. In this work, we investigate how
pedagogical instructions facilitate the scaffolding in ITSs, by conducting a
case study on guiding children to describe images for language learning. We
construct different types of scaffolding tutoring systems grounded in four
fundamental learning theories: knowledge construction, inquiry-based learning,
dialogic teaching, and zone of proximal development. For qualitative and
quantitative analyses, we build and refine a seven-dimension rubric to evaluate
the scaffolding process. In our experiment on GPT-4V, we observe that LLMs
demonstrate strong potential to follow pedagogical instructions and achieve
self-paced learning in different student groups. Moreover, we extend our
evaluation framework from a manual to an automated approach, paving the way to
benchmark various conversational tutoring systems.
|
[
-0.146205619,
-0.8890464902,
0.4686325788,
0.4282217026,
-0.2003992647,
0.48103562,
-0.2823205292,
-0.0456782654,
-0.068225652,
0.2196193188,
-0.3711158633,
-0.3425920606,
-0.3743976057,
0.02683842,
-0.3906143606,
0.9553297758,
-0.2166568786,
0.4354299605,
-0.3280046582,
0.0492881536,
-0.5036255121,
-0.4394366145,
-0.4065130353,
-0.3339039683,
0.3180105388,
0.6624810696,
0.4155584872,
0.9821527004,
0.0990705267,
0.4017800391,
0.220131889,
-0.2379787862,
-0.0556966849,
0.3418397903,
-0.1798120886,
-0.4504255354,
0.0908279568,
-0.0178932119,
0.6658047438,
0.8026756048,
-0.4006859064,
0.0846146941,
0.3288703859,
0.5920282006,
-0.2333800048,
0.5787495971,
-0.3063985109,
0.1383313686,
-0.137701869,
-0.2053292394,
-0.3071266413,
-0.5977476239,
0.3303338587,
-0.380222708,
0.0523958392,
-0.1408744454,
0.5812527537,
-0.0636722669,
-0.385807246,
-0.6631466746,
-0.4805312753,
0.7929322124,
-0.5200415254,
0.3865393996,
0.5820264816,
0.5468857288,
-0.0245910566,
-0.474403888,
-0.3220576346,
-0.3749771416,
0.0221941583,
0.0718396008,
0.3039022684,
0.1210660487,
0.1745752245,
0.3937317133,
-0.4523918629,
0.144580543,
-0.7780523896,
-0.3524214327,
0.3501073122,
0.08703769,
0.2209721208,
-0.2198397219,
-0.6079565883,
-0.0580434762,
-0.7265936732,
0.1293200999,
0.675227344,
0.3352305889,
-0.2966498435,
0.4533681571,
-0.1819830984,
0.53974998,
0.0352808796,
-0.5693891048,
0.3979817033,
-0.3209061623,
0.131131798,
-0.0275720507,
0.522995472,
0.2139990777,
0.4633948505,
-0.1243075281,
-0.0845986009,
0.1363891512,
0.1014404073,
-0.6526013017,
-0.1556610167,
-0.1493469775,
-0.2789607644,
-0.1616777182,
-0.392409116,
-0.7173108459,
-0.0037890896,
-0.5361399651,
0.4261204302,
-0.8683032393,
-0.0906114131,
0.0831903294,
0.2060845047,
0.4227769375,
0.3141176999,
-0.9742010832,
0.2928323746,
0.2637449801,
0.6697530746,
-0.2486768663,
-0.4118058681,
-0.1715636402,
0.4200791121,
-0.1498703212,
0.8413769603,
-0.6311721802,
-0.2960622013,
0.2904468477,
-0.0336035751,
-0.2870388925,
-0.0171766002,
0.2482223809,
-0.250012964,
0.6677510142,
0.0976181701,
-0.4481136799,
-0.3898069263,
0.3342605531,
-0.368652761,
0.90372473,
0.0805601329,
-0.3496360481,
-0.0903097838,
-0.531943202,
-0.5378409028,
0.2327187657,
-0.5998880863,
-0.1300417334,
-0.1085824296,
0.0292076822,
0.6229116321,
-0.2103054076,
0.3448639512,
0.0959013626,
-0.3526123464,
0.0282991026,
-0.538736999,
0.4949017763,
0.1518816501,
-0.6084694266,
0.136921078,
-0.5612246394,
0.0929609537,
0.2715142965,
-0.6773619056,
0.0019092357,
-0.1398192644,
-0.1279775053,
0.135181278,
0.1205238253,
-0.1816383302,
0.3310213685,
-0.2902462482,
0.5019336939,
0.8655912876,
-0.0162915085,
0.4053477049,
-0.3077597618,
0.6648343801,
-0.1362995505,
0.2018584758,
-0.9567171335,
-0.3751158416,
-0.8684126735,
-0.2074120492,
0.2173646986,
0.3328555822,
-1.0198488235,
-0.1459548324,
-0.0667175651,
-0.3142078817,
-0.2922939062,
0.3094931543,
0.7258204818,
0.3650769889,
0.1575830579,
-0.1722949892,
-0.2812859416,
-1.0412210226,
-0.0359515697,
-0.1759241521,
0.0680383816,
0.0285011046,
0.4383846521,
0.08387959,
0.4118577242,
-0.0252981149,
-0.3039827645,
-0.0446513221,
-0.0636553168,
-0.0461575165,
0.5488509536,
0.558549881,
-0.464204222,
-0.6388558149,
-0.1392296553,
-0.6990321875,
-0.0716598853,
-0.082006596,
0.2867417932,
0.3416979909,
0.6181486845,
-0.3025427759,
0.3665382862,
0.4529908597,
-0.1370556802,
0.7963942289,
-0.2273200303,
0.2051761895,
-0.7969169021,
-0.3083262146,
-0.0931800678,
-0.1019823849,
-0.4230318069,
0.1498247534,
-0.092339389,
-0.0084789991,
-0.442352742,
0.0707580373,
-0.6481869221,
-0.0287424494,
-0.0834028348,
0.3135463595,
-0.078561075,
0.9524183273,
-0.1725351065,
0.8036032915,
0.7291323543,
-0.2373128533,
0.3377383053,
-0.1512384117,
-0.295242548,
0.7372202277,
-0.6230367422,
0.2638017833,
-0.034987893,
0.0885925665,
-1.0510041714,
-0.1036446542,
0.445404321,
-0.0381763205,
0.1978670955,
-0.1451627463,
-0.6018651724,
-0.0925690904,
-0.3449588716,
0.3158412278,
0.0572431013,
-0.2713945806,
0.850971818,
0.2775726914,
-0.3529894948,
-0.3073226511,
-0.369314909,
0.0643725097,
-0.2491215616,
-0.3024248481,
0.348536253,
-0.3185828924,
-0.0828407481,
-0.04195375,
-0.1279154867,
-0.0279633701,
-0.1022436172,
0.5074656606,
0.1475686431,
-0.1102566421,
0.2578257918,
0.191463396,
-0.2471140921,
0.0358867869,
-0.006231592,
0.7451964617,
-0.5445165634,
-0.7769675851,
-0.6182338595,
0.5199189782,
0.7431722879,
-0.1362141371,
0.4712167382,
0.2317674011,
-0.23998788,
-0.0689368695,
-0.5431166291,
-0.1720202565,
-0.5351614356,
0.1485685259,
-0.5627384782,
-0.7977398634,
0.451209873,
-0.3418782651,
-0.0438667573,
-0.1109653264,
0.5150617957,
-0.2689802647,
1.149612546,
0.5984957814,
0.241644308,
0.7198508978,
-0.4282112122,
0.1834310293,
-0.5089161396,
-0.6108133793,
-0.3865738511,
0.0317968093,
-0.2433424443,
-0.4246831238,
0.3078754246,
0.1976520568,
-0.1875983328,
0.24113594,
-0.3528502882,
0.5493757129,
0.5551810861,
0.1285103261,
0.225558728,
0.3307186365,
-0.7945124507,
-0.0129068773,
-0.8259935379,
-0.8003806472,
0.8445036411,
0.3896735311,
0.5647889376,
-0.0644709691,
0.4073309898,
0.2450786978,
0.3402728736,
-0.725569427,
0.6210010648,
0.2885828912,
-0.5059674978,
-0.23403503,
0.1555416584,
-0.7535189986,
0.4333619475,
-0.2684337199,
-0.7415046692,
-0.2025725096,
-0.1611641198,
-0.0217718482,
-0.0328927822,
-0.9454312325,
0.5094730258,
-0.4076658487,
-0.4153743982,
-0.6187058687,
-0.5588045716,
0.0323520899,
-0.0569437854,
0.4539599717,
0.205301553,
0.2482582629,
0.7082382441,
-0.2521013021,
1.1714029312,
-0.1634904295,
-0.1520275921,
0.3469598889,
0.1896537244,
0.1088864282,
-0.2656874359,
-0.1814336032,
-0.0010401749,
0.3450604379,
-0.6239684224,
-0.624801755,
0.87692523,
-0.6763120294,
-1.0562726259,
-0.4508468211,
-0.5892432332,
-0.1552000344,
0.2014937848,
-0.3144449294,
0.4944733679,
0.1360066533,
0.3363910913,
0.4105375707,
-0.0392188616,
0.6073876619,
0.6474974155,
-0.3538490236,
-0.3145000339,
0.9330427051,
0.3501622379,
0.318920821,
-0.2162897587,
0.2832555175,
-0.2702165842,
-0.7085216641,
-0.560729146,
0.357246995,
-1.0533889532,
-0.1040660143,
-0.2104767859,
-0.1964843422,
-0.2426334918,
-0.2086361349,
-0.0781648979,
-0.4216370285,
0.1072602049,
-0.3582316637,
0.139488712,
0.820766747,
0.0885870382,
0.633451581,
-0.5017673969,
-0.036728017,
0.448076278,
0.3835571706,
0.1106998995,
-0.2269113213,
-0.4551718235,
0.1533033997,
-0.5209800601,
-0.956359148,
-0.1279955506,
0.3148529828,
0.9205523729,
0.5508803129,
-0.2465229183,
0.6330416799,
-0.5893882513,
0.7962109447,
0.1984765083,
-0.9694960117,
0.6329243779,
-0.4447765648,
0.1699133515,
0.3127865195,
0.3083434105,
-0.3101689816,
-0.2038207352,
-0.4392453134,
-0.7946947217,
0.5399186015,
-0.0596781746,
0.3858130276,
0.1751024872,
0.4520511627,
0.3628547788,
0.3951331973,
-0.7825198174,
-0.1683639139,
-0.3683745861,
-0.3230132163,
0.3493651748,
-0.1721538454,
-0.4553119838,
-0.0300782509,
0.4843452871,
-0.5012347102,
0.0804291368,
-0.1863842458,
-0.2140846103,
0.0136986058,
0.1621854603,
0.324944824,
0.6539474726,
0.4277934432,
0.104149133,
0.1064695865,
-0.1279958487,
0.0678272918,
-0.1548527777,
0.0116624711,
-0.2960189879,
0.538392365,
0.7683059573,
0.4926806688,
-0.6375413537,
0.5946289897,
0.0814339444,
-0.2157767713,
-0.3127976954,
0.2206273228,
0.1137627289,
0.4260151386,
0.546993494,
-0.2215372622,
-0.155414328,
-0.7361856699,
0.1118391603,
0.2706699371,
-0.2462211698,
-0.6465883851,
0.1593775749,
0.1996047348,
-0.7336807251,
0.2583469748,
0.1896576434,
-0.6124241352,
0.3491249681,
0.8778665066,
0.5041899681,
-0.5869821906,
0.5833235979,
-0.0836367235,
0.2004582882,
0.1258958578,
0.3106635511,
-0.5882898569,
-0.4618089199,
-0.4917924702,
-0.4294583499,
-0.3802870214,
-0.1288838089,
-0.497233361,
0.1210105345,
-0.5885952115,
0.2578136325,
-0.1161637083,
-0.1968204081,
-0.7947447896,
0.0627101809,
0.0222228747,
0.6356420517,
-1.020681262,
0.9009535313,
0.8096817136,
-0.5967022777,
-0.8729101419,
-0.0663719699,
0.0191929974,
-0.8573157191,
0.7679114938,
0.2166196108,
-0.3479093313,
0.0873706266,
-0.5815765262,
-0.8469232917,
1.0535260439,
0.552152276,
-0.209508121,
-0.1746027023,
0.2945315838,
0.664193809,
-0.6090377569,
0.3036102951,
0.1744748652,
0.3504331708,
0.1354676932,
-0.7857592702,
0.0696928501,
-0.2146107107,
-0.114291437,
-0.415307492,
-0.7284588218,
0.4908409119,
-0.0842269436,
-0.4781804383,
0.0962360501,
0.3999455571,
0.3642154634,
0.1587265283,
0.767090559,
0.1302107573,
0.4453686476,
-0.1493210346,
0.5877336264,
-0.5307788253,
-0.0592196733,
0.7336532474,
0.0823215023,
0.5468031168,
0.9032639265,
-0.2048947662,
0.9819402099,
0.5026834011,
0.2847072482,
0.4232308269,
0.261831671,
-0.0964146256,
-0.2069485337,
-0.2957327068,
-0.2847158015,
0.5383447409,
0.686258018,
-0.1677269638,
-0.3310627341,
0.366561085,
-0.1046921983,
0.3991964161,
-0.0687919259,
0.5275102854,
-0.023073487,
-0.5709269643,
0.4869714081,
-0.2961886823,
0.3878364563,
-0.6624646783,
-0.3478802443,
-0.0048937532,
-0.105408743,
-0.1648370326,
-0.6776725054,
-0.0444331132,
-0.205186367,
-0.0113572283,
-0.6657170057,
0.454875052,
-0.5320839286,
-0.2946300507,
0.3049990833,
0.7131963968,
0.2395334095,
0.5420354605,
-0.7309747338,
0.2124884874,
-0.0291724913,
-0.4395080805,
0.4144619703,
0.3568770289,
-0.4055027366,
1.1398290396,
0.7459113002,
-0.0485927425,
0.0010384206,
0.1401937753,
1.0482991934,
-0.3104538321,
-0.4626226723,
-0.5205386281,
0.6523342729,
0.1730003506,
-0.1754754186,
0.962384522,
0.2771031559,
0.7988418341,
-0.0238588303,
0.6865379214,
0.1151031554,
0.253929466,
-0.4712528586,
0.2419709265,
-0.0917605311,
0.3910428882,
-0.212867856,
-0.9330717921,
-0.3734101057,
0.868072629,
-0.3523443341,
0.0425322913,
0.7365964055,
0.6317304969,
0.1903816313,
0.2575716376,
0.1677155495,
-0.0353179201,
0.4605967104,
0.0689994097,
1.0401924849,
-0.2748087645,
0.5855455995,
-0.2972619236,
-0.3518877625,
-0.1584410965,
-0.7706691623,
-1.0095893145,
-0.8891425133,
-0.2667478919,
-0.1246133149,
0.4189469814,
0.9004697204,
0.6398941875,
-0.5996909738,
-0.3857702017,
0.009175756,
0.0801101997,
-0.2777561545,
-0.2480459064,
0.5195794106,
-0.4320251048,
-0.9049099088,
0.6056345701,
0.2940820158,
0.0436527207,
-0.8018602133,
-0.0125750359,
-0.306265384,
-0.0459350459,
0.5180863738,
0.1450556815,
-0.7765191197,
-0.5767677426,
0.1111780778,
-0.0506750531,
-0.1293246001,
0.7386784554,
-0.9377783537,
0.5199898481,
0.2618432939,
0.4726070166,
0.63402915,
-0.3315947354,
0.6931149364,
-0.4968533218,
0.1802421063,
-0.0307858884,
0.3817084134,
0.4662485123,
0.0088415798,
0.2880837321,
0.1500394791,
-0.5158091784,
-0.8488969803,
0.2775878906,
-0.4409829378,
-0.1238468215,
0.9417260289,
-0.3744187355,
-0.1279404461,
-0.293163538,
-0.5765382051,
0.2779558897,
-0.2382268608,
1.0231328011,
0.7580602169,
-0.3113622665,
-0.3249477744,
-0.3965211511,
0.1785130203,
0.4318826497,
-0.4430824816,
-0.1969843954,
0.4009842277,
0.3472788632,
0.3014281392,
0.3961503804,
-0.1549200863,
0.0195137355,
-0.1989039034,
-0.1036992148,
-0.1572382152,
-0.4168331623,
-0.3202909231,
0.4061273038,
-0.1809335798,
-0.3412187397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03428v1
|
Edisum: Summarizing and Explaining Wikipedia Edits at Scale
| 2024-04-04T13:15:28 | 2024-04-04T13:15:28 |
Marija Šakota, Isaac Johnson, Guosheng Feng, Robert West
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An edit summary is a succinct comment written by a Wikipedia editor
explaining the nature of, and reasons for, an edit to a Wikipedia page. Edit
summaries are crucial for maintaining the encyclopedia: they are the first
thing seen by content moderators and help them decide whether to accept or
reject an edit. Additionally, edit summaries constitute a valuable data source
for researchers. Unfortunately, as we show, for many edits, summaries are
either missing or incomplete. To overcome this problem and help editors write
useful edit summaries, we propose a model for recommending edit summaries
generated by a language model trained to produce good edit summaries given the
representation of an edit diff. This is a challenging task for multiple
reasons, including mixed-quality training data, the need to understand not only
what was changed in the article but also why it was changed, and efficiency
requirements imposed by the scale of Wikipedia. We address these challenges by
curating a mix of human and synthetically generated training data and
fine-tuning a generative language model sufficiently small to be used on
Wikipedia at scale. Our model performs on par with human editors. Commercial
large language models are able to solve this task better than human editors,
but would be too expensive to run on Wikipedia at scale. More broadly, this
paper showcases how language modeling technology can be used to support humans
in maintaining one of the largest and most visible projects on the Web.
|
[
-0.7917699814,
-0.5485526919,
0.3205617368,
-0.0321443975,
-0.2404530644,
-0.2111690491,
-0.4559035897,
-0.3926335275,
0.4487246871,
0.4142552912,
-0.3605366349,
-0.1982590854,
-0.5296943188,
0.3425176144,
-0.653249383,
1.1809309721,
-0.1441109627,
0.0199494753,
-0.3439738154,
-0.0728382841,
-0.2762536705,
-0.0251718704,
-0.7239465117,
-0.3087897897,
0.7537132502,
0.705082953,
0.8634285331,
1.013320446,
0.4120595753,
0.3482263386,
-0.5141628981,
0.3075332642,
-0.6566221118,
-0.1265745759,
-0.4491792321,
-0.2736424804,
-0.9226691723,
0.0931250229,
0.6163112521,
0.99308604,
-0.1840126514,
0.1840283126,
-0.0662065372,
0.6828294396,
-0.3867673576,
-0.0873103067,
-0.4956099987,
-0.102665849,
0.1287610382,
0.227350384,
-0.2039864063,
-0.2257916033,
-0.0464295112,
-0.8171364069,
0.443041563,
-0.1530135125,
0.5085882545,
0.1654754877,
-0.2735722065,
-0.2566286922,
-0.78551054,
0.3142589629,
-0.8124414086,
0.2866001427,
0.4185777307,
0.0564217307,
-0.0397256836,
-0.6795087457,
-0.8435718417,
-0.2183942646,
-0.1194641367,
0.006104291,
-0.0499011576,
0.1476608366,
0.3871896863,
0.6787953973,
-0.2525862157,
0.3515363336,
-0.6426775455,
0.09050221,
0.6175502539,
0.2304852009,
0.5695983768,
-0.1638947278,
0.2466182262,
0.0553937145,
-0.6030859947,
-0.1723324955,
0.5552951097,
0.1432514936,
-0.0348518379,
0.7557538748,
-0.514025867,
0.8127626181,
0.2741660178,
-0.0514035821,
-0.0288331788,
-0.2175099105,
-0.0222551078,
-0.1826283485,
0.5985415578,
0.8792845011,
0.3719108999,
-0.1845065355,
-0.2988491058,
-0.2822765112,
0.3349612951,
-0.8852282166,
-0.5150800347,
0.0620262921,
-0.4916577339,
-0.4956740737,
-0.0195768755,
-0.7104494572,
-0.4548750222,
-0.5392795801,
0.1297498345,
-0.3055663109,
-0.421187669,
-0.0436870866,
-0.4253533483,
-0.467266649,
0.6014173031,
-1.3494013548,
0.0935554653,
0.4968134761,
0.7659513354,
0.2085511088,
-0.5515663028,
-0.1827953458,
0.0665689111,
-0.5015152097,
0.8267500997,
-0.373799324,
-0.5353971124,
-0.2284022421,
-0.1487388313,
0.2865844667,
-0.4653870463,
0.2925263345,
-0.5910996795,
0.090872027,
-0.2980948091,
-0.9074093699,
-0.1387967616,
0.0660415143,
-0.9492627978,
0.7464502454,
0.2738400698,
-0.8135368228,
0.3871335387,
-0.6368682981,
-0.3858325183,
0.0570587963,
0.3627322912,
-0.1675029844,
0.4286469519,
0.2809168696,
0.2436482906,
0.0458352342,
0.1616731584,
-0.2189965397,
-0.1780613512,
0.1501016915,
-0.1001847312,
0.5554150939,
0.1200123727,
0.1772603691,
0.1313497275,
-0.8313699365,
-0.1776580811,
-0.2149230838,
-0.5450520515,
-0.3478700817,
0.2319109291,
0.1662479043,
-0.0293451641,
0.3058500886,
-0.2850996554,
0.363637358,
-0.5223805308,
0.3889470696,
0.6442261934,
0.0607213899,
0.7067112327,
-0.1957027018,
0.290810585,
-0.3489134014,
0.1397827119,
-0.3311912715,
-0.2804931998,
-0.7489401698,
-0.2712890506,
0.4906468987,
0.2767593265,
-0.6656680107,
0.3242154121,
-0.3574196398,
-0.8330151439,
-0.6260951757,
0.4492872357,
0.0345289633,
0.5062151551,
0.3312292397,
-0.1395304948,
-0.4082508683,
-0.9050796628,
-0.5131941438,
-0.3017526865,
-0.4708417952,
-0.0325893089,
0.5569166541,
-0.3494077921,
1.0117292404,
-0.4643785655,
0.0421065912,
-0.4157218039,
0.1802070141,
-0.0519268326,
0.3005561233,
0.4606670737,
-0.8894478679,
-0.5086598992,
0.018273849,
-0.692964673,
-0.3365023136,
-0.2071221173,
-0.0398347117,
-0.4067838192,
0.4600066245,
-0.5742936134,
0.1328635812,
0.3333504796,
-0.3318048418,
0.4590331018,
-0.7326840758,
0.2371088117,
-1.1816093922,
-0.0427967384,
-0.031332925,
-0.3763056397,
-0.5968563557,
0.2563500404,
0.3698528409,
-0.0693852305,
-0.1601320803,
0.2938934267,
-0.2864241898,
0.1884881407,
-0.3703228235,
0.3872893751,
0.0603650212,
0.2769002616,
-0.1630469561,
0.6421894431,
0.2555493712,
-0.5948773026,
0.6828808188,
0.3396596014,
-0.3002480567,
0.7623577714,
-0.7569047809,
0.0178446192,
-0.363008678,
0.1031963304,
-0.7175446749,
-0.5275913477,
-0.282268405,
-0.3757798374,
0.4122818708,
0.0577806644,
-0.4881387353,
-0.2499285936,
-0.4760422111,
0.0967474133,
0.0839079171,
-0.5475767851,
0.5760739446,
0.7311864495,
-0.4135546684,
-0.1253153235,
-0.3990098238,
0.2801131904,
-0.0511485487,
-0.5298242569,
0.4995980263,
-0.3119157851,
-0.437079668,
0.2437857687,
0.0938509926,
-0.1800112277,
0.2430722415,
0.2229760885,
0.2694106102,
0.1492974311,
0.2832640111,
0.1294899583,
-0.0739842355,
-0.0216298327,
-0.0044517238,
0.0338839032,
0.117635116,
0.0250764694,
-0.3793033361,
0.4147140384,
0.9009766579,
-0.2267948836,
0.7974575162,
0.4020582438,
-0.4603589475,
-0.0913293138,
-0.409852773,
-0.004716312,
-0.3856184483,
0.6487870812,
-0.0947256982,
-0.63116467,
0.5580844283,
-0.0737065896,
0.3917094469,
0.897289753,
0.7032690048,
-0.4142251015,
0.9267229438,
0.9868884087,
-0.1503366828,
0.7359812856,
-0.2762265503,
0.022878848,
-0.9377390742,
-0.07129962,
-0.416913271,
-0.4671050608,
-0.5256701112,
-0.1790045202,
0.3065560162,
0.419929862,
0.0852111578,
0.43072173,
-0.2589275837,
0.8511793017,
0.4735661447,
0.1116597429,
0.3271833956,
-0.0578893088,
0.0842507109,
0.1300609857,
-0.6180588603,
-0.5901301503,
1.0521730185,
0.1664039642,
0.8119254708,
0.1244614869,
0.4556036294,
0.5452711582,
0.4878613055,
-0.5342529416,
0.4087488949,
-0.1260502189,
-0.6609250903,
-0.6659056544,
-0.3353634477,
-0.476184696,
0.2185300142,
-0.3335116804,
-0.3081096709,
-0.0933686718,
0.3780811429,
-0.3204822838,
0.5326985717,
-0.6804304719,
0.8483619094,
0.2109644115,
0.040093489,
-0.7247555256,
-0.3517085016,
0.1835329831,
-0.1710464209,
0.5026768446,
0.1038683951,
-0.0397275425,
0.8236112595,
-0.7038715482,
0.7668293118,
0.0609680973,
0.0704521239,
0.1858231276,
0.1726860255,
0.4514808953,
0.1269302815,
-0.0865529403,
0.0412188657,
-0.2439131737,
-0.2716181874,
-0.4456247985,
0.8184404969,
-0.8736932874,
-0.5019543171,
0.2174957246,
-0.6147774458,
0.0350275785,
0.1274352521,
0.4307128489,
0.4740975797,
-0.3261552155,
0.105338864,
0.6887913942,
-0.1783906072,
0.332526356,
0.3687274158,
-0.2651792765,
-0.4671224058,
0.8101381063,
0.3808612525,
0.2911549509,
0.3233427703,
0.06262815,
0.0919666961,
-0.4379548132,
-0.9530911446,
0.1441737115,
-0.8247658014,
-0.0526542291,
-0.6407649517,
0.052417051,
-0.2001055777,
-0.4432448745,
-0.3221153915,
-0.8445088863,
-0.395654887,
-0.4136801064,
0.5486756563,
1.1157422066,
-0.2454928011,
0.3183424771,
-0.5009373426,
0.5951701999,
0.5135813355,
0.4593728483,
0.1548970044,
-0.7260216475,
-0.6997217536,
0.0893316045,
-0.2428912371,
-1.0004991293,
0.2594923079,
0.3289505243,
0.4350921214,
0.3447976112,
-0.0721725151,
0.6290529966,
-0.7394062281,
0.7835218906,
0.1535760462,
-0.7960496545,
0.632868886,
-0.3243535161,
0.3946104646,
0.4649229944,
0.1717024595,
-0.8546593785,
-0.6696469188,
-0.4225026369,
-0.808347106,
0.4430094063,
0.0518411919,
0.3271591067,
-0.0973792672,
0.517544508,
0.0619487502,
0.1894438416,
-0.5299146175,
-0.2503551841,
-0.1367033273,
-0.1995820403,
-0.1356247962,
-0.5772957802,
0.0650061667,
-0.3508346677,
0.8100405931,
0.1742663532,
-0.2275270671,
0.0636505708,
-0.4008236229,
-0.6032704115,
0.194772765,
0.5550532341,
0.978607893,
-0.0310269482,
0.0453900397,
0.5814774632,
-0.4811499119,
-0.1884761155,
0.0174981207,
-0.3753793836,
0.1873619109,
0.6180754304,
0.7228043675,
0.3636747599,
-0.5464729667,
0.2298420966,
-0.0296736322,
0.0061347485,
-0.0311623663,
0.1178162694,
0.3691343665,
0.2335633636,
0.1489430964,
0.1392027587,
0.2112994194,
-0.3855548799,
0.0190965049,
0.093912296,
-0.0604198836,
-0.3998850584,
0.7732669115,
0.4545830786,
-0.4897700846,
0.7179051638,
-0.0475873575,
-0.6457352638,
0.5034539104,
0.0524663217,
0.7012578249,
-0.3803571165,
0.1952182651,
0.5266039968,
0.4497268796,
-0.1480391473,
-0.1682909876,
-0.0105531421,
-0.4956035018,
-0.3479188979,
-0.6464772224,
-0.4352304339,
-0.2037218362,
-0.567393899,
0.3028110862,
-0.378883183,
-0.1117797643,
0.4792805314,
-0.2411153316,
-0.538495779,
0.3340487778,
0.0816031918,
1.1161167622,
-0.8735634089,
0.561191678,
0.5731824636,
-0.5315015912,
-0.668976903,
-0.2677987218,
-0.136463806,
-0.2650386095,
0.2536394298,
-0.2372414768,
0.185965687,
0.0367558673,
-0.362498343,
-0.5261324048,
0.9181919694,
0.3173320889,
-0.6175132394,
-0.3463253081,
-0.1648340374,
0.7504730225,
-0.2415417433,
0.2442491949,
0.3377045989,
0.1998784095,
-0.2203379273,
-1.0718188286,
-0.3149237335,
-0.1328120083,
0.1511171758,
0.2175430804,
-0.3089159429,
1.0853353739,
-0.4712435603,
0.0959351584,
-0.0035793574,
0.5998579264,
-0.3304406703,
-0.0196004864,
0.530890584,
0.7135058045,
0.736225307,
0.1129733846,
1.2114251852,
-0.3959096372,
0.4730015695,
1.2399185896,
0.1697961241,
0.8902488351,
0.3401938975,
-0.2300208062,
0.5351089239,
0.8232148886,
0.1108588427,
0.3602866232,
-0.0186541285,
-0.3771843016,
-0.1288947463,
0.0518601052,
-0.2482144535,
0.1469566673,
0.2552565634,
-0.6373012662,
-0.3579955399,
0.133809045,
-0.0424831323,
0.1754839271,
-0.6726546288,
0.9941228628,
-0.1902969778,
-0.6055253744,
0.1956195831,
0.3018817902,
0.203703016,
-0.3042815328,
-0.1148900911,
-0.3875008225,
0.0579074249,
-0.3259462714,
-0.7168867588,
0.3034718931,
0.4846135974,
-0.7236756682,
-0.3496943116,
0.4525403678,
-0.7528435588,
-0.6565912366,
-0.0276618823,
0.2854223251,
0.1303065568,
-0.0485395491,
-0.2268659472,
-0.1874521226,
0.0190685149,
-0.425298512,
0.1308505088,
0.6289590001,
-0.0006442317,
0.5692639947,
0.5776669979,
0.4150111973,
-0.2033905238,
0.1143259332,
0.9296950102,
-0.4070491791,
-0.7205400467,
-1.0126649141,
0.6704108715,
-0.2885630727,
-0.1627410948,
0.6985071898,
0.6234398484,
0.853480041,
-0.161305964,
0.635836482,
-0.1357471049,
0.4429536164,
-0.1358519644,
0.9955611229,
-0.5395552516,
0.086139515,
-0.0996301621,
-0.9063134789,
-0.1080835685,
0.6711323857,
-0.1125902981,
-0.0357178003,
0.2804576755,
0.725661397,
-0.0012954755,
0.0217439383,
0.3330896497,
0.3882255554,
0.212094605,
0.0926370919,
0.4544226527,
-0.1277343482,
0.3224580288,
-0.2771119177,
-0.411839813,
-0.4560765028,
-0.7233299613,
-0.9372412562,
-0.7124695778,
-0.3426451087,
-0.124594532,
-0.2392221838,
1.0001729727,
0.6308673024,
-0.6369379759,
-0.1744128466,
-0.0549726449,
0.2839516401,
-0.1651318818,
-0.1525833756,
0.1281239241,
-0.0722362772,
-0.9798104167,
0.2047039419,
0.3589773476,
0.0677739605,
-0.3879735768,
-0.046055302,
0.0036454047,
0.1001563594,
0.5813330412,
0.0969279781,
-0.7159258127,
-0.284311384,
-0.3471634388,
-0.222550869,
-0.3854955733,
0.7110768557,
-0.5417642593,
0.9823468328,
0.4294170737,
0.4357785583,
0.4006780684,
-0.3030941784,
0.7413755655,
-0.6155068874,
-0.0688712597,
-0.0881090164,
0.5963966846,
0.5239731073,
-0.4132160842,
0.495797962,
0.0992589295,
-0.4754878581,
-0.7502452731,
-0.0335969888,
-0.5518731475,
-0.2623282969,
0.8673945069,
-0.1885396093,
0.0615415163,
0.2857623398,
-0.3612237871,
0.58105582,
-0.0311039742,
1.1368998289,
0.9944250584,
0.248019442,
-0.1091474295,
-0.5145103931,
0.5263976455,
-0.1669769585,
-0.7374150753,
0.2465483993,
0.7546832561,
0.406114459,
0.1366522014,
0.3258124888,
0.3360299766,
0.4316851199,
0.0605284609,
0.1663336605,
-0.2539364696,
-0.3008833528,
-0.277097851,
0.0663419217,
0.2489330024,
0.1616164297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03414v1
|
Can Small Language Models Help Large Language Models Reason Better?: LM-Guided Chain-of-Thought
| 2024-04-04T12:46:37 | 2024-04-04T12:46:37 |
Jooyoung Lee, Fan Yang, Thanh Tran, Qian Hu, Emre Barut, Kai-Wei Chang, Chengwei Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce a novel framework, LM-Guided CoT, that leverages a lightweight
(i.e., <1B) language model (LM) for guiding a black-box large (i.e., >10B) LM
in reasoning tasks. Specifically, the lightweight LM first generates a
rationale for each input instance. The Frozen large LM is then prompted to
predict a task output based on the rationale generated by the lightweight LM.
Our approach is resource-efficient in the sense that it only requires training
the lightweight LM. We optimize the model through 1) knowledge distillation and
2) reinforcement learning from rationale-oriented and task-oriented reward
signals. We assess our method with multi-hop extractive question answering (QA)
benchmarks, HotpotQA, and 2WikiMultiHopQA. Experimental results show that our
approach outperforms all baselines regarding answer prediction accuracy. We
also find that reinforcement learning helps the model to produce higher-quality
rationales with improved QA performance.
|
[
-0.3197170794,
-1.023481369,
1.1358135939,
-0.1092603877,
-0.2710609734,
-0.0089971721,
-0.55626899,
-0.2845092714,
-0.1570784152,
0.6167583466,
-0.4815934598,
-0.2135029435,
-0.4974221587,
-0.059142448,
-0.1300546825,
0.8585736752,
0.0124722458,
0.0948349312,
-0.0731799677,
-0.1211000308,
-0.6355745792,
-0.3637625277,
-1.0399477482,
-0.5117155313,
0.8498891592,
0.4326944649,
0.722928226,
0.5939350128,
0.0246374812,
0.2572714984,
-0.4784760773,
0.3904727399,
-0.3879240155,
-0.0076571894,
-0.5971062779,
-0.7308241725,
-0.2069962472,
-0.2438517362,
0.1552620083,
0.7629311085,
-0.2416255176,
0.1455479264,
0.0138799269,
0.7512314916,
-0.6041589379,
0.0350169763,
-0.7169824839,
-0.364806056,
0.1629149318,
-0.0697019771,
-0.8055878282,
-0.222434774,
-0.0150141316,
-0.3183422089,
-0.1776068807,
0.4671877921,
0.5460965037,
0.3014755845,
-0.5591258407,
-0.3785099983,
-0.774753511,
1.0009473562,
-0.776022613,
0.3021379411,
0.322976172,
0.41018489,
-0.2822461426,
-0.5759652257,
-0.5908811092,
-0.1967885941,
0.0620236956,
-0.2265774459,
-0.0110919653,
0.0700221285,
0.3986917734,
0.1874600351,
-0.437507689,
0.1467187703,
-0.3441124856,
-0.0345336273,
0.5105459094,
0.0487677641,
0.1449169219,
0.059853863,
-0.2727638781,
-0.0665509999,
-0.7112641931,
0.2081860602,
-0.1012828574,
0.3352411389,
0.1096709892,
0.4534145594,
-0.183949545,
0.9444889426,
0.2365202457,
-0.3812204599,
-0.2545724809,
-0.1379533708,
-0.2874663472,
0.135020256,
0.6440602541,
0.0083548333,
0.2542525828,
-0.150654003,
-0.403832525,
0.1114015952,
0.1190412119,
-0.7981216311,
-0.3856161833,
0.1982835084,
-0.506076932,
-0.2846845686,
-0.3277213275,
-0.4854972959,
-0.5835496187,
-0.6000945568,
0.332361877,
-0.4326875508,
-0.3123416603,
0.3728144765,
-0.0932792798,
0.2617083788,
0.5350461602,
-0.8641552329,
0.2722294629,
0.6664773226,
0.6592302322,
-0.0622009784,
0.0093206828,
-1.0152353048,
0.1121140867,
-0.640003562,
0.7343015075,
-0.3967933655,
0.0807927176,
-0.2723517418,
-0.0961066112,
0.0615265891,
-0.5221203566,
0.3581701815,
-0.6378175616,
0.2216419578,
-0.4928513169,
-0.4511522353,
-0.1918960512,
0.4305754006,
-0.7586162686,
0.7624661922,
-0.01105907,
-0.4445819855,
0.2779293954,
-0.3516637981,
-0.2473615259,
-0.0346748047,
-0.3790367246,
0.072725296,
0.2414384782,
0.3627314568,
0.3152208924,
-0.7714628577,
0.4341005981,
-0.370428741,
-0.1996689439,
0.2772427201,
-0.3784822226,
0.6721166372,
0.4056271911,
-0.4176914394,
0.2703572214,
-0.659403801,
0.2483886033,
0.1933255196,
-0.3079380393,
-0.4655757844,
0.0352676325,
-0.2703745663,
0.5524462461,
0.0897223726,
-0.3347608447,
0.1622124612,
-0.4426012039,
0.4146237075,
0.8380674124,
-0.0012708867,
0.6024962068,
-0.2235515863,
0.5247946978,
0.0697784573,
-0.0412335731,
0.0589671619,
-0.3742085695,
-0.7643127441,
-0.2027974427,
0.3078156114,
0.2679068744,
-1.0621238947,
0.1810341477,
0.1781617105,
-0.4157710969,
-0.4949640334,
0.3320398331,
0.3696146309,
0.3878066242,
0.3961879313,
0.1117354855,
-0.2941087186,
-0.7173457742,
-0.2541884482,
-0.1914487481,
0.0889756903,
0.114127554,
0.3466718793,
-0.185513258,
0.7812006474,
-0.5256745219,
0.0745284632,
-0.7708348036,
0.1340822428,
0.3615677655,
0.3207010627,
0.2478980124,
-0.7939275503,
-0.276125282,
0.0383284502,
-0.5470712185,
0.0175803695,
-0.149023816,
-0.3390537798,
0.2111674398,
0.6103327274,
-0.7584332824,
0.1080420539,
0.3119443357,
-0.4986260235,
0.5120968223,
-0.2225353718,
-0.1947195679,
-1.0965430737,
-0.1151033789,
-0.0199212506,
-0.460226953,
-0.3676700592,
0.1609927863,
0.0159804951,
-0.0738758519,
-0.2972961962,
0.5957278609,
-0.4154945314,
0.1161883548,
-0.6446720362,
0.3130708039,
0.1440107524,
0.720302999,
0.156797573,
0.5750024319,
0.3615649641,
-0.6413357854,
0.3722818196,
-0.1154961735,
-0.4994336665,
0.1676808,
-0.7254305482,
0.1734259874,
-0.324293077,
0.2746687531,
-0.6438336968,
0.05597369,
0.0489656925,
-0.0237977542,
0.1303921789,
-0.1800807118,
-0.556854248,
-0.2270850986,
-0.0318934768,
0.5326717496,
0.6461899281,
-0.816804111,
0.629237473,
0.1982937008,
-0.1601694971,
-0.4226150513,
-0.6580765843,
-0.3387185335,
-0.1494659036,
-0.3268989623,
-0.07269568,
-0.1072652638,
-0.4732873142,
0.0204631127,
-0.2793131769,
-0.037277773,
0.2127809376,
-0.0574514978,
0.2322443426,
-0.3410277069,
0.4736904204,
-0.0782919228,
-0.1014300585,
0.2082857937,
-0.6360206604,
0.613476038,
-0.352219224,
-0.1102460995,
-0.0374104418,
0.3360185623,
0.5434864163,
-0.1746320724,
0.8906758428,
0.4014913142,
-0.3227550089,
-0.70080477,
-0.3984413147,
-0.3052627444,
-0.4516906738,
0.1451675296,
-0.4000124931,
-0.9610940218,
0.2264640033,
-0.3108382523,
-0.1281570196,
0.329272002,
0.6343473196,
0.0303614456,
1.3507403135,
0.7515085936,
-0.097602576,
0.3537190259,
-0.2322805673,
0.5362922549,
-0.5888140798,
-0.2060448378,
-0.3615793884,
-0.1995455772,
-0.5026743412,
-0.6173014045,
0.0956116542,
0.5575278997,
-0.2715649903,
0.1434590071,
-0.5228391886,
0.7465869784,
0.469119668,
0.0681011602,
0.2288900912,
-0.4499713778,
-0.4778365195,
0.478410542,
-1.1221880913,
-0.7583272457,
0.8120266199,
0.4073449969,
0.9042974114,
0.0919314101,
0.6586036682,
0.1062109321,
0.2470879108,
-0.9139713049,
0.6474984884,
0.1514672637,
-0.6093087792,
-0.3661792874,
-0.6361910105,
-0.7092430592,
0.3998447657,
-0.1027221456,
-0.8947248459,
0.0549980551,
0.317153424,
-0.3921076953,
0.3322095275,
-0.8702017069,
1.0067200661,
-0.5902377367,
-0.5333479643,
-0.3915090263,
-0.3808721006,
0.5634064078,
0.0609469973,
0.3684001565,
-0.156348452,
0.1549184173,
0.6648065448,
-0.5581914186,
0.629309833,
-0.1681110114,
-0.2108354867,
0.4710764289,
0.1213098243,
0.7481743693,
0.1322190166,
-0.0972746611,
-0.4129551947,
0.2452276796,
-0.5346390605,
-0.8145860434,
0.7120104432,
-0.5768260956,
-0.7329940796,
-0.4054515064,
-0.5673418045,
-0.312921226,
0.1706805229,
0.0514037646,
0.5493519902,
0.1844673753,
0.2624673247,
0.9043929577,
-0.15808779,
0.3536800444,
0.3933976293,
-0.4027161896,
-0.2313039005,
0.7582123876,
-0.2250290811,
0.4673621953,
0.4712128937,
0.5343046784,
-0.4451274574,
-0.489391923,
-0.5115562677,
0.2011752725,
-1.0083241463,
-0.1765153259,
-0.4566802979,
-0.0436706543,
0.0258436259,
-0.1390010267,
-0.3307035565,
-0.4045984447,
-0.0179737043,
-0.1065532044,
0.2870589495,
0.7068482637,
0.2946317792,
0.1557508409,
-0.539008975,
0.4222244322,
0.4554745853,
0.1580446512,
0.2278508097,
-0.3284547627,
-0.4209252298,
0.2686101794,
-0.220934853,
-0.6632826328,
0.2349338382,
-0.3571838439,
0.4838403761,
0.2407158017,
0.350784421,
0.5993754864,
-0.3617502153,
0.7392346859,
0.4396916628,
-0.8653508425,
0.6810212731,
-0.0952983052,
0.5758682489,
0.6208811402,
0.2130168825,
-0.2953130603,
-0.5087468028,
-0.5845219493,
-0.7663367987,
0.6685156226,
-0.071594283,
-0.3744286895,
-0.1652231216,
0.2758191526,
0.1474905312,
0.1698321849,
-0.847158432,
0.0534237809,
0.179841131,
-0.38142398,
-0.1868552566,
-0.2518574893,
-0.204227984,
-0.1688075513,
0.8191123605,
-0.4946919382,
0.1208024994,
0.0613494404,
-0.2693563402,
-0.1721960604,
0.5267244577,
0.4421540499,
0.7930338979,
-0.0962203667,
0.4621901214,
0.2909513712,
0.1549255103,
0.1775106639,
-0.1938858926,
-0.0578918383,
-0.1898273081,
0.2869197428,
0.9402853847,
0.0941905528,
-0.8953257203,
0.3635339737,
-0.1667798907,
-0.1512827724,
-0.0413982607,
0.2748649716,
0.3205070496,
0.5925808549,
0.219486624,
-0.0071358164,
-0.0357167982,
-0.808518827,
-0.0344707929,
0.4145516455,
-0.1624974757,
0.0228432901,
0.5896837711,
0.1626575589,
-0.2312684953,
0.3166039884,
-0.2156320214,
-0.4563972652,
0.5742977262,
0.5622001886,
0.7605533004,
0.2445093989,
0.1417411417,
0.2554648221,
0.2688150704,
-0.5360049605,
0.321115613,
-0.3797100186,
-0.6640612483,
-0.6726415753,
-0.6292449832,
-0.4734138846,
0.3299904764,
-0.5446717739,
0.1998340636,
-0.5159865618,
0.066241242,
0.0661231279,
0.0914095715,
-0.6408557296,
0.3637662232,
0.2671070099,
0.9602620602,
-0.5936049223,
1.1165570021,
0.6423317194,
-0.4641334116,
-1.2969092131,
0.0263467785,
-0.2527161241,
-0.5054710507,
0.6379244924,
0.2125785798,
-0.4446741045,
-0.1651668102,
-0.6278403997,
-0.8332813382,
1.026279211,
0.4567179084,
-0.8287637234,
-0.0238072984,
-0.191945523,
0.4701593518,
-0.5442094207,
0.263754487,
0.579507947,
0.2531816363,
0.1197839901,
-0.7331703901,
0.2148946077,
-0.0501365438,
0.035556484,
0.3725630343,
-0.5056855679,
0.6482579708,
-0.4415527582,
0.0026572342,
0.0513482504,
0.554066658,
0.7256156802,
0.4847202897,
0.6476598382,
0.3088220954,
0.962695837,
0.0231652502,
1.0811668634,
-0.1812717915,
0.1704741865,
1.3014528751,
-0.2787831724,
0.8925061822,
0.660415411,
0.266132772,
0.7782411575,
0.56710428,
0.5268312693,
0.6428394318,
0.2965427339,
-0.1288455427,
-0.5803044438,
0.0251377542,
-0.106479153,
0.1692539155,
0.2134659141,
-0.3383103013,
-0.07223811,
0.0126496535,
-0.0426326543,
0.3402742743,
-0.580509007,
0.8870284557,
0.4009634256,
-0.9873466492,
0.8421800733,
0.2045128495,
0.3099273741,
-0.5625021458,
0.1341954619,
-0.106920436,
0.5270192623,
0.0073710969,
-0.5893406272,
0.0655115545,
0.1340702623,
-0.4288782775,
-0.4412160218,
0.812130332,
-0.6801140904,
-0.4264369309,
0.3457674682,
0.7652956843,
-0.1065656021,
-0.0077734846,
-0.6413687468,
0.0174539052,
-0.0854343846,
-0.3176493943,
0.4824441969,
0.8404979706,
-0.2513023019,
0.8705351353,
0.605278194,
0.1617010534,
-0.1286069155,
0.0653181821,
1.033262372,
-0.8830244541,
-0.6737183928,
-0.8474026918,
0.3364247978,
-0.2295980453,
-0.0064540128,
0.4940416217,
0.3911913037,
0.768461585,
-0.0645929426,
0.7157077193,
-0.0250877272,
0.3490403891,
-0.8375023007,
0.2812344134,
-0.5119259357,
0.4771727622,
0.0024837712,
-0.8582140803,
0.106871888,
0.6398405433,
-0.6163291335,
-0.033473555,
1.1007552147,
0.7488771677,
0.0703884885,
0.0845304355,
0.3365089595,
0.1016226262,
0.3477902114,
0.9599736333,
1.0653009415,
-0.10665714,
0.5719492435,
-0.269615382,
-0.1684386283,
-0.1167420596,
-0.8130276799,
-1.0984699726,
-0.3461346328,
-0.2961114049,
-0.3830429018,
-0.0730191246,
1.3003863096,
0.7320562601,
-0.7445734739,
-0.2268366218,
-0.4988436401,
0.5516833067,
-0.4809647202,
-0.2123949379,
0.1127022728,
-0.6178548336,
-0.3516138196,
0.5146132112,
0.1966726333,
-0.2815128863,
-0.1430864632,
-0.4344606102,
-0.216056183,
0.3444335163,
0.8072331548,
0.1102155373,
-0.8652688265,
-0.330239743,
-0.0973270237,
-0.1958272308,
-0.3347698152,
1.0417721272,
-0.8951572776,
0.3091723621,
0.3367724717,
0.7079996467,
0.5499544144,
-0.0668094009,
0.7629440427,
-0.4278562665,
0.2475599647,
0.4799415469,
0.4509723783,
0.0900103077,
-0.3180475235,
0.3733164668,
0.0015602112,
-0.5999828577,
-0.8575369716,
0.4254830778,
-1.0106010437,
-0.7576108575,
1.5368522406,
0.037860997,
-0.4749708772,
-0.048462376,
-0.4180012345,
0.0556937084,
-0.3546766937,
0.7038900852,
0.708910346,
-0.025453506,
-0.6370545626,
-0.3614640236,
0.6557529569,
0.507434845,
-0.9500649571,
0.2617482543,
0.5957218409,
0.206647113,
0.0220948067,
0.6186286807,
0.1051527485,
0.3992338479,
-0.0924876183,
-0.1588637829,
-0.0887030289,
-0.4734534025,
-0.2358444333,
0.3044673204,
0.7160412073,
-0.0405870639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03411v1
|
Red Teaming GPT-4V: Are GPT-4V Safe Against Uni/Multi-Modal Jailbreak Attacks?
| 2024-04-04T12:38:14 | 2024-04-04T12:38:14 |
Shuo Chen, Zhen Han, Bailan He, Zifeng Ding, Wenqian Yu, Philip Torr, Volker Tresp, Jindong Gu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Various jailbreak attacks have been proposed to red-team Large Language
Models (LLMs) and revealed the vulnerable safeguards of LLMs. Besides, some
methods are not limited to the textual modality and extend the jailbreak attack
to Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) by perturbing the visual input.
However, the absence of a universal evaluation benchmark complicates the
performance reproduction and fair comparison. Besides, there is a lack of
comprehensive evaluation of closed-source state-of-the-art (SOTA) models,
especially MLLMs, such as GPT-4V. To address these issues, this work first
builds a comprehensive jailbreak evaluation dataset with 1445 harmful questions
covering 11 different safety policies. Based on this dataset, extensive
red-teaming experiments are conducted on 11 different LLMs and MLLMs, including
both SOTA proprietary models and open-source models. We then conduct a deep
analysis of the evaluated results and find that (1) GPT4 and GPT-4V demonstrate
better robustness against jailbreak attacks compared to open-source LLMs and
MLLMs. (2) Llama2 and Qwen-VL-Chat are more robust compared to other
open-source models. (3) The transferability of visual jailbreak methods is
relatively limited compared to textual jailbreak methods. The dataset and code
can be found here
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/red_teaming_gpt4-C1CE/README.md .
|
[
-0.2572634518,
-0.7633401155,
0.5041148663,
0.2547342181,
-0.1245713234,
0.2760763466,
-0.1651266813,
-0.6561229825,
-0.1696697325,
0.5100886226,
-0.5020645261,
-0.4686459601,
-0.4059636593,
0.2649262249,
-0.2455918342,
1.2610969543,
-0.185286507,
0.0036438131,
0.1440196782,
-0.3145875931,
-0.8209654093,
-0.8307644725,
-0.1158847436,
0.2068016231,
0.1654803753,
0.2094080299,
0.3924477994,
0.0923246667,
0.8171044588,
0.3288096786,
0.0854236782,
-0.3204178512,
-0.6177566648,
0.2925510108,
0.0497042015,
-0.3477454484,
-0.4124190509,
0.1909993142,
0.3164163828,
-0.2747030556,
-0.1742890477,
-0.0318652205,
-0.2739278078,
0.6174999475,
-0.5940039754,
-0.0551843233,
-0.8783124089,
-0.1470350027,
-0.3724007308,
0.1388119459,
-0.2821618617,
-0.2595468462,
0.0152140558,
-0.2881563604,
-0.1121597216,
0.0252430029,
0.6459801197,
0.2146197259,
-0.3224095106,
0.0625931919,
-0.4480555058,
0.699080348,
-0.7855731845,
0.1965566874,
0.3224504888,
0.5481641889,
-0.0546016097,
-0.6684633493,
-0.4016824365,
-0.4512545466,
0.223214224,
0.258102119,
-0.3517719507,
0.3117064238,
0.1496937722,
0.0257755443,
-0.5301703811,
0.1967156678,
-0.5226311088,
-0.2885318696,
0.490563482,
0.1894259006,
0.5550562143,
-0.1575544477,
-0.8140010834,
0.2218812108,
-0.8480641246,
-0.1776509285,
0.4123180807,
0.0509083234,
-0.3960447609,
0.510692358,
-0.0016875364,
0.6499953866,
-0.2553045154,
-0.1468393654,
0.2683293819,
-1.1295795441,
-0.3137812018,
-0.2809205055,
1.0238413811,
0.7564710379,
0.3622735441,
-0.382920593,
-0.2061897069,
0.137580514,
0.4190366566,
-0.8457682729,
-0.4158472121,
0.2416206002,
-0.3194463253,
-0.537905097,
0.0722553059,
-0.8300052881,
-0.3150249422,
0.232032761,
0.4084255993,
-0.438106209,
-0.3334082663,
-0.1555147916,
-0.2070968598,
0.1870508939,
0.1977095753,
-0.9528784156,
0.3396607935,
0.420127362,
0.8990158439,
-0.460103333,
-0.4264146388,
-0.3469833136,
0.1550194621,
0.0693781003,
0.5610945225,
-0.3459637165,
-0.1639080495,
-0.3256500661,
-0.1800032109,
-0.1611710191,
-0.375523597,
0.1761108488,
-0.6906145811,
0.0180725195,
-0.2339476943,
-0.3596195877,
-0.1290668398,
0.6597675085,
-0.8488783836,
0.4664041102,
-0.1311717331,
-1.067666173,
0.3642596602,
-0.9180671573,
-0.2043513358,
0.0536915511,
-0.2659591436,
-0.6135157347,
-0.3575636148,
0.1683345288,
0.4320219755,
-0.1877205074,
0.129179284,
-0.4179469049,
-0.2204778492,
0.28718701,
-0.4414503872,
0.7080663443,
0.2969155908,
-0.724932611,
0.5370261073,
-0.2996896207,
0.1527107954,
0.1846017689,
-0.2991456687,
-0.3078095019,
-0.2583678067,
0.1668117046,
0.176509589,
0.2114532441,
-0.8027521372,
0.1332740188,
-0.1332028061,
0.9264798164,
0.7083937526,
0.1455531418,
0.3261801004,
0.0807764307,
0.5951170325,
-0.2113729864,
0.5627328157,
0.0142336646,
-0.548761785,
0.019164484,
-0.4953582585,
0.3124882281,
0.6955519915,
-0.7248027325,
-0.0801759958,
0.3359514475,
-0.3877135217,
-0.1531259269,
0.0539568253,
0.6238709092,
0.1632651985,
0.4423092008,
-0.2161414027,
-0.5874818563,
-0.8185602427,
-0.2525418401,
-0.0658503026,
0.3960669041,
0.170535773,
0.8010209799,
-0.3673584163,
0.7059016824,
-0.0601517856,
-0.1619375646,
-0.4404309094,
-0.106267333,
-0.0241182689,
0.4045582116,
0.8179430366,
-0.8546640277,
-0.3816680908,
-0.1389582455,
-0.8395862579,
0.0096707176,
0.0446750857,
0.2292945683,
0.3758198917,
0.3983853459,
-0.430159241,
0.5342164636,
0.9764258265,
-0.5634909868,
0.8359297514,
-0.124811478,
0.3920605481,
-0.8422061801,
-0.0203651991,
0.091058746,
-0.3050481379,
-0.8738828301,
0.3988336921,
0.2242063582,
0.046521157,
-0.6450184584,
0.1672837436,
-0.4847935736,
-0.2937770784,
-0.074659884,
0.1238657013,
-0.2514924109,
0.2145987749,
-0.3603374362,
1.1316412687,
0.3250137568,
-0.1169588566,
0.5333948135,
0.0428523757,
-0.3723418117,
0.0884053558,
-0.8344103694,
0.2053133845,
0.4571842849,
0.1070484221,
-0.7278783321,
-0.0844121799,
0.2658602297,
-0.2251382917,
0.216740936,
-0.2352103591,
-0.5274487734,
-0.1367511302,
-0.6392906904,
0.5662934184,
0.2569062114,
-0.3323331773,
-0.0313825347,
0.77684623,
-0.0967096761,
-0.6857153773,
-0.5158157945,
0.4306509495,
-0.596365273,
-0.8038875461,
0.2551852763,
-0.1276738197,
-0.5145030022,
-0.1722674668,
-0.135086149,
-0.422893554,
0.3608927429,
0.2396578789,
0.7062592506,
0.1432608515,
-0.4395025373,
-0.4547225237,
-0.1534589827,
0.1022886336,
0.0454679802,
0.3870967925,
-0.7881408334,
-0.1624122709,
-0.41192469,
0.2466904074,
0.8531640172,
-0.3453324437,
0.6865154505,
0.4134298861,
-0.0058436003,
0.3349672854,
-0.6002374291,
-0.2718820572,
-0.4054971635,
0.4054422379,
-0.2997610569,
-1.2515102625,
0.4007356465,
0.1418790519,
0.0820266083,
0.0897723064,
0.7275901437,
-0.1473718733,
0.6348625422,
0.7271741033,
-0.2522138953,
0.425544709,
-0.0340647437,
0.0450465158,
-0.5961077809,
-0.3287987709,
-0.1933310181,
-0.083450526,
-0.5284258723,
-0.2429110408,
0.4920236468,
0.0385852531,
-0.4249894321,
0.5740853548,
-0.4182394445,
0.612649262,
0.3786187172,
-0.0975836292,
0.406334877,
-0.2449026406,
-0.2611609101,
-0.1671440303,
-0.5300034881,
-0.3038316071,
1.2699631453,
0.562194109,
0.9165035486,
0.4332475364,
0.7158095241,
0.2646393776,
0.1652697623,
-0.3619370162,
0.4024015367,
0.1611727476,
-0.854993999,
-0.3976290822,
-0.4898319244,
-0.8421022296,
0.2806250453,
-0.3805897236,
-0.8068152666,
-0.3177489936,
0.0612099618,
-0.3803519309,
0.378108561,
-0.9055709839,
1.1491236687,
-0.600666821,
-0.3962953687,
-0.1377080381,
-0.9580829144,
0.8928280473,
-0.3520970047,
0.1892278492,
-0.015741555,
0.1496922225,
0.7733138204,
-0.6361789703,
0.828155756,
-0.2095430791,
0.179475233,
0.2066907883,
0.0001796068,
0.486985743,
0.1937663555,
0.3096423745,
0.5234898925,
-0.0246541854,
-0.0930390134,
-0.33766523,
0.7860094905,
-0.8695993423,
-0.6387346387,
-0.3966351151,
-0.575453341,
-0.0408831239,
0.3004790843,
0.1817438155,
0.2933737338,
0.0091961809,
0.139694348,
0.4036578536,
-0.2001373172,
0.610044241,
0.4054750204,
-0.2196678817,
-0.5851911306,
0.5776979327,
-0.0768566728,
0.5126461387,
-0.038206134,
0.0059317001,
-0.2737267911,
-0.9198946953,
-0.5651181936,
0.1973771155,
-0.3449171484,
-0.3728799522,
-0.3223968744,
-0.1438839734,
-0.3109896481,
0.0346207321,
-0.4913185537,
-0.2526893914,
0.1648929119,
-0.3130010664,
0.6378344297,
0.913764298,
-0.0698141903,
-0.0568340197,
-0.8574547768,
0.3205663264,
0.3631263375,
0.3378455937,
-0.4856567383,
-0.1738161892,
-0.0071892985,
-0.2458701879,
-0.2045930922,
-1.1556584835,
0.3291775882,
-0.4065631926,
0.5690932274,
0.0309524927,
0.0749698505,
0.5415527821,
-0.638440907,
0.7275871038,
0.6325048804,
-0.8836649656,
0.5413463712,
-0.5664685369,
-0.1626807302,
0.8165342808,
0.0075516398,
-0.0121819545,
-0.3275265694,
-0.5291644931,
-0.7784619331,
0.514413774,
0.6222581863,
-0.1903687865,
0.1736218929,
0.2407381386,
-0.096384339,
0.2796464562,
-1.1383360624,
-0.2603777051,
-0.5430784822,
0.0651773363,
0.3205569983,
-0.316483736,
-0.2827429473,
-0.0802674666,
0.1435559243,
0.2700169683,
0.1466649026,
-0.0546870828,
0.0183094572,
0.2655439675,
0.4914937317,
0.9203336239,
0.5351457596,
-0.369864881,
0.0464618243,
0.3682067692,
-0.6677079201,
0.3561764061,
-0.0280943625,
0.0257193819,
-0.3964433372,
0.2879007757,
0.6291180849,
0.208880201,
-0.7189953327,
0.9331727624,
-0.3448313475,
-0.2990987897,
-0.3411444724,
0.0308486838,
-0.1130194068,
0.5105214119,
-0.0554342456,
0.3525730968,
-0.1189274415,
-0.6239215732,
0.2379267812,
0.6151106954,
-0.2719426751,
-0.5058168173,
0.8728796244,
0.5538544059,
-0.0455079824,
0.5573353171,
0.0126970094,
-0.7028703094,
0.5173731446,
0.7261183262,
0.7065122724,
-0.2226512432,
-0.0262666922,
0.0321055427,
0.7436298132,
-0.050876651,
0.1669811308,
0.0866603553,
-0.8642245531,
-0.6800552607,
-0.1315370202,
-0.4244879484,
0.3363730907,
-0.5427208543,
-0.0308772735,
-0.4817133844,
-0.2688656747,
-0.4747209847,
-0.2452356368,
-0.2783543468,
-0.0764725134,
0.1752845496,
0.8978289366,
-0.8360292912,
1.0015530586,
0.6569117904,
-0.3682467639,
-0.7494724989,
-0.0207616109,
0.2668391466,
-0.7467633486,
0.7596541047,
0.2868209183,
-0.1638808846,
-0.1708399504,
-0.4586721063,
-0.7877686024,
1.1947348118,
0.3869389594,
-0.705176115,
-0.0306390543,
-0.2938102186,
0.1410679668,
-0.0225618165,
0.2300948501,
0.8186849356,
0.688323915,
-0.2396305799,
-1.257973671,
0.1142605916,
-0.1999779493,
-0.2906524837,
0.3268757761,
-0.625080049,
0.7910746336,
-0.6724376678,
-0.1059600189,
0.0149989557,
0.1753772497,
0.6353606582,
0.2139295191,
0.468708843,
0.6692364216,
0.443015337,
-0.0856125876,
1.1214665174,
-0.2023955286,
0.3112605214,
0.9215121269,
-0.3397966027,
0.7459895611,
0.4946166277,
-0.1104320809,
0.2010684013,
0.1558362693,
-0.3162311614,
0.884639442,
0.1558597535,
-0.2157722861,
-0.0655290484,
0.5991097689,
-0.3246427774,
0.4551045895,
0.0695163906,
-0.0036820974,
-0.1705955416,
0.1188965589,
0.3085210919,
-0.1320015937,
-0.2488285005,
0.7385296226,
-0.0467104353,
-0.4266834855,
0.5859745741,
0.128572762,
0.9162279367,
-0.572008729,
0.1018415317,
-0.0191602837,
0.0340475552,
-0.2572430372,
-0.8702815771,
0.2283198535,
0.5773385763,
-0.0040478245,
-0.0126862954,
0.8072926402,
-0.0311635267,
0.1251035035,
0.4441976547,
0.4184898436,
0.1962270141,
-0.0539012104,
-0.8586882949,
0.4080099463,
0.3025807738,
-0.2214980274,
0.6597168446,
-0.1183061823,
-0.1080435812,
0.7071884274,
0.6038925052,
0.0626442954,
0.2802106738,
0.1016600877,
1.0335657597,
-0.9088206887,
-0.2286554128,
-1.2489008904,
0.4361225665,
-0.1956061721,
-0.1101981252,
1.0489592552,
0.2730668485,
0.54223001,
0.1237123013,
1.0179063082,
0.0082178516,
0.0648464561,
-0.7427606583,
0.9409604669,
-0.0368454605,
0.4648686051,
-0.6123340726,
-0.647020638,
-0.4510578513,
0.5960694551,
-0.3161716163,
0.0437043682,
0.7989225984,
0.5495195389,
0.3142081797,
0.170124352,
0.3997370005,
0.3698465824,
0.5859779716,
0.5187440515,
1.0260597467,
-0.1885710359,
0.7911815643,
-0.0006983778,
-0.4381155968,
-0.036440298,
-0.8907232285,
-1.0938130617,
-0.2358613908,
-0.1396699995,
-0.2250761092,
0.3111169934,
0.4837169051,
0.5960965157,
-0.6088323593,
-0.0393873863,
-0.2250557244,
-0.112498261,
0.094873324,
-0.2039469332,
-0.0136753768,
-0.2944171429,
-0.2559018433,
0.798453629,
0.564407289,
0.0265483577,
-0.1574953943,
-0.0936953723,
-0.0583910532,
-0.4647743106,
0.5498743653,
0.3071373105,
-0.8078075051,
-0.4171503186,
-0.1170555651,
-0.1057237089,
-0.025152823,
0.6446930766,
-0.6779386997,
0.3991636038,
0.165889293,
0.592433691,
0.4358092546,
0.1066177562,
0.6130802631,
-0.4777254164,
0.0692992806,
0.1834538281,
0.5460510254,
0.1326546073,
-0.0917701796,
0.5834947824,
0.3139616251,
-0.8711180091,
-0.8679423332,
0.2610012889,
-0.9313097,
-0.322412461,
1.3411470652,
-0.3092449605,
-0.0465805642,
-0.5327892303,
-0.1503585726,
-0.150017634,
-0.4137810767,
0.5822605491,
0.3011155427,
-0.2537336051,
-0.1917071193,
-0.8971897364,
0.4137870371,
0.1002558693,
-0.9157100916,
0.1162011102,
0.4653049409,
0.7179302573,
-0.0421250761,
0.6139317751,
-0.4095064104,
0.4557316601,
-0.182656154,
0.0783076435,
-0.5086420178,
-0.4356793165,
-0.2710573673,
0.3570157886,
0.0055886544,
-0.2901236117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01563v1
|
Mitigating LLM Hallucinations via Conformal Abstention
| 2024-04-04T11:32:03 | 2024-04-04T11:32:03 |
Yasin Abbasi Yadkori, Ilja Kuzborskij, David Stutz, András György, Adam Fisch, Arnaud Doucet, Iuliya Beloshapka, Wei-Hung Weng, Yao-Yuan Yang, Csaba Szepesvári, Ali Taylan Cemgil, Nenad Tomasev
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We develop a principled procedure for determining when a large language model
(LLM) should abstain from responding (e.g., by saying "I don't know") in a
general domain, instead of resorting to possibly "hallucinating" a non-sensical
or incorrect answer. Building on earlier approaches that use self-consistency
as a more reliable measure of model confidence, we propose using the LLM itself
to self-evaluate the similarity between each of its sampled responses for a
given query. We then further leverage conformal prediction techniques to
develop an abstention procedure that benefits from rigorous theoretical
guarantees on the hallucination rate (error rate). Experimentally, our
resulting conformal abstention method reliably bounds the hallucination rate on
various closed-book, open-domain generative question answering datasets, while
also maintaining a significantly less conservative abstention rate on a dataset
with long responses (Temporal Sequences) compared to baselines using
log-probability scores to quantify uncertainty, while achieveing comparable
performance on a dataset with short answers (TriviaQA). To evaluate the
experiments automatically, one needs to determine if two responses are
equivalent given a question. Following standard practice, we use a thresholded
similarity function to determine if two responses match, but also provide a
method for calibrating the threshold based on conformal prediction, with
theoretical guarantees on the accuracy of the match prediction, which might be
of independent interest.
|
[
-0.6014299989,
-0.9775878191,
0.7820248604,
0.3501995802,
-0.2491771281,
-0.2646242678,
-0.3027635813,
-0.4736035466,
0.3066675663,
0.5901226997,
-0.6765303016,
-0.4177456796,
-0.302447468,
0.3776132762,
-0.4844807684,
0.562754333,
0.0945408866,
0.1494828463,
-0.5201671124,
0.0702177659,
-0.5002811551,
-0.4443747103,
-0.4187354743,
-0.304410547,
0.3288219273,
0.1921221018,
0.5271469355,
0.5424926877,
0.5918772817,
0.1733632833,
-0.1080567464,
-0.0312948152,
-0.6388899088,
0.3228248358,
-0.1687224209,
-0.511913538,
-0.2760762274,
-0.3114998937,
0.4922550619,
0.6414803863,
-0.2719151676,
0.0485743284,
0.1729353666,
0.5941387415,
-0.5993022323,
0.0350409932,
-1.0040636063,
0.1232140288,
0.0904383361,
-0.2304275334,
-0.4754042625,
-0.4278602302,
-0.1135464683,
-0.5148832798,
0.3848554492,
0.0558288097,
0.5864079595,
0.5578867793,
0.0111607444,
-0.3285603523,
-0.7892016768,
0.5702137351,
-0.7630569935,
0.4995918572,
0.8386694193,
0.2457183301,
-0.140081495,
-0.3808252215,
-0.6377055049,
-0.5524715185,
-0.189225316,
0.1540730745,
-0.045073349,
0.1169963926,
0.2328792959,
0.4046393335,
-0.9491583109,
-0.0277145077,
-0.5212991834,
-0.2791723013,
0.5074167252,
0.1481618583,
-0.0536977015,
-0.0194275249,
-0.334774822,
-0.0137396101,
-0.8309022188,
-0.3393167853,
0.3051645458,
0.2678118646,
0.2464353889,
0.7078383565,
-0.266074121,
0.5120434165,
0.2658478022,
0.1883434802,
0.022053238,
0.0379876457,
-0.2957600057,
0.1494384855,
0.6675531864,
0.4737406671,
0.5863271952,
-0.2888034284,
-0.3259392083,
0.1946810633,
0.5757398605,
-0.7563576102,
-0.2554110289,
0.4193676114,
-0.302490145,
0.0502624698,
0.1459629834,
-0.790314734,
-0.3596009016,
-0.3468495905,
0.5812324286,
-0.4053164721,
-0.0812671259,
0.1665597111,
0.2787863016,
0.2757307887,
0.2711834311,
-0.9254236817,
0.611803472,
0.7633541226,
0.9039871097,
-0.4256860614,
0.0174473748,
-0.322771579,
0.0952633768,
-0.5035886168,
0.7271174788,
-0.3134169281,
-0.6791458726,
-0.1614896655,
0.0272263847,
0.0000651824,
-0.8155641556,
0.3011161387,
-0.4667507112,
-0.0602105632,
-0.1498048007,
-0.8075636625,
-0.2847285271,
0.3338074982,
-0.764302671,
0.6647114158,
-0.0673715174,
-0.5772310495,
-0.0490793623,
-0.2624270916,
-0.3343640566,
-0.0346813612,
-0.2460611016,
-0.5026878715,
0.2584792972,
0.1346103698,
0.2660806477,
-0.1740828156,
0.0102705872,
-0.4985511005,
-0.5186831951,
0.2513913214,
-0.2955549657,
0.4287314713,
0.2651990652,
-0.364838928,
0.1483559459,
-0.371639818,
0.241564244,
-0.0292722564,
0.1747445017,
-0.3163738251,
-0.1924720407,
-0.2551207542,
-0.0828014463,
0.1392066479,
-0.4650926888,
0.0662176609,
-0.5187071562,
0.0604014322,
0.9023718834,
0.279691577,
0.0853261203,
-0.7461772561,
0.5421732068,
-0.1611371487,
0.0991389081,
0.0721459761,
-0.503655076,
-0.6313740015,
-0.0573292263,
0.0174859092,
0.5716586113,
-0.258038044,
0.7045298815,
-0.155918777,
-0.4636135995,
-0.6753817201,
0.1147961169,
0.4851274192,
0.5944190025,
0.6544516683,
-0.3191782236,
-0.5518802404,
-0.9698348045,
-0.0946843624,
-0.4403993487,
-0.2677584887,
0.213200748,
0.4804263413,
-0.0028091415,
0.7474521399,
-0.6531499028,
-0.4856721461,
0.1099105477,
0.0784738287,
-0.0085406657,
0.3508733511,
0.2349192798,
-0.7689361572,
-0.4697346687,
-0.1577505618,
-0.8234772086,
-0.121996589,
-0.1305721253,
0.1383427531,
0.3596641421,
0.6136732697,
-0.5253939629,
0.6641542912,
0.4247086346,
-0.102193892,
0.5722231865,
-0.1626474559,
0.318595618,
-0.8985192776,
0.0586215332,
-0.1459175944,
-0.1195699573,
-0.5235812664,
0.0121953338,
0.071943447,
0.4345114827,
-0.2479571402,
0.5952450037,
-0.3211584985,
0.023602033,
-0.3929092586,
0.2332727909,
-0.169596523,
0.3803005517,
0.2214928418,
0.8403341174,
0.4323867261,
-0.7688244581,
0.1828461587,
0.4109258056,
-0.249879986,
0.5143950582,
-0.7811243534,
0.3823640347,
-0.2961089313,
-0.0646569356,
-1.0895676613,
0.0135646183,
0.3847758472,
-0.6768921614,
0.1057732552,
0.0609389357,
-0.1233519316,
-0.2377213836,
-0.3985288143,
0.3658073843,
0.5995932817,
-0.3180667758,
0.3675707579,
0.059380386,
-0.168231681,
-0.5664463639,
-0.7291340232,
-0.1553570926,
-0.2574969232,
-0.302572757,
0.3652362823,
-0.666662991,
-0.4522686899,
-0.1113520786,
-0.4187668264,
0.0113363033,
0.1328527033,
0.4068543613,
0.2510457635,
-0.127831921,
0.2508369982,
-0.059024822,
0.0608233698,
0.2503733039,
-0.2223697454,
0.6993173957,
-0.1908205599,
-0.6174042225,
-0.4133692384,
0.2098729908,
0.4241333902,
0.0950627923,
0.689098835,
0.2093044668,
-0.566719532,
-0.091833882,
-0.8180587888,
-0.7931410074,
-0.4521577358,
0.1689947844,
-0.7463878393,
-0.780359149,
0.7545516491,
0.3572641313,
-0.2637209296,
0.2999642193,
0.7899138927,
0.0069649001,
0.5407546163,
0.5432154536,
0.1275245696,
0.0055997972,
0.0559860207,
0.196813032,
-0.8542351127,
-0.3226503432,
-0.5098822117,
-0.0363275371,
-0.4312259555,
-0.4081615806,
0.2754166126,
0.0909914598,
0.0441206582,
0.31717816,
-0.5103536248,
0.5164213181,
0.2829115391,
0.1732340455,
0.4282560647,
-0.1164684147,
-0.0590719245,
-0.0899426714,
-0.0856184363,
-0.4250072241,
1.1046774387,
0.2148946822,
1.0794018507,
0.1256201863,
0.7552249432,
0.3451902866,
0.5575695038,
-0.9292610288,
0.583044827,
0.186382398,
-0.6416428089,
-0.6954799891,
-0.5239064693,
-0.7733525634,
0.2303405404,
-0.003037404,
-0.8848771453,
0.0474747606,
0.0471679717,
-0.3257851899,
0.2664985359,
-0.2144562304,
0.4317514598,
0.029912591,
-0.2385324687,
-0.1292508841,
-0.5445816517,
0.4994812012,
-0.521220386,
-0.1374038309,
-0.1456594765,
0.0522867367,
0.6525500417,
-0.0554031283,
0.8511036038,
0.138163805,
-0.2573284507,
0.2874089777,
0.5505959988,
0.3666245937,
0.0453615561,
-0.2511283457,
0.2765687406,
0.3019424677,
-0.0421933718,
-0.8572142124,
0.6660215855,
-0.5334777832,
-1.0279043913,
-0.1425404847,
-0.6107318997,
-0.2058663815,
-0.0151533447,
0.354429096,
-0.0942158401,
-0.4654142857,
0.2195018828,
0.8320826888,
0.1512589902,
0.1251624376,
0.566185832,
-0.3895495534,
-0.4704662859,
0.4076534808,
-0.0399858877,
0.4744667113,
0.4479702115,
0.2511261702,
-0.6695550084,
-0.5450327396,
-0.0932822898,
0.4199997187,
-0.8027005792,
-0.334669441,
-0.5417218208,
-0.4026161134,
-0.8449209929,
0.0558349453,
-0.1977462769,
-0.4605290592,
-0.1521085501,
-0.2345697582,
0.2640897334,
0.7788284421,
-0.1518873721,
0.0560731217,
-0.4230735302,
0.5176620483,
0.1195503548,
0.2733481526,
-0.0664496422,
-0.8784176111,
0.1541839987,
0.1625022739,
-0.2617453933,
-0.9913773537,
0.5018228292,
0.2171956897,
0.7717602253,
0.5537258387,
0.5630994439,
0.6924413443,
-0.4778149128,
0.4880293012,
0.1372886747,
-0.9782941341,
0.5944725275,
0.1400718838,
-0.0506918989,
0.5742801428,
0.6685056686,
-0.6417329907,
-0.803450346,
-0.3854605854,
-0.570112884,
0.1889757663,
0.3677497208,
0.1103082597,
-0.180490315,
0.6367956996,
0.2159255445,
0.1856628209,
-0.8181307912,
-0.2459718734,
-0.0601808429,
-0.2363439053,
-0.140369907,
-0.2529744506,
-0.4422204792,
-0.2038425058,
0.6419654489,
-0.2777824104,
0.2532626092,
0.5285169482,
-0.0876246616,
-0.3332206011,
0.1777457744,
0.8583990335,
0.8694912791,
-0.4768183529,
0.3388519287,
0.3189656138,
-0.6441902518,
0.237311691,
-0.167985633,
-0.331946373,
-0.1615967602,
0.2626209259,
0.3062602282,
-0.4026588202,
-0.5884050727,
0.2727527618,
-0.0065257791,
-0.3531705737,
-0.4962188005,
-0.0089179911,
0.0861691535,
0.0274972375,
0.304903239,
-0.3093320131,
0.1294784248,
-0.3389976323,
0.7105286121,
0.5966001749,
-0.6814310551,
-0.2761422992,
0.7707001567,
-0.2983005047,
-0.5332967639,
0.7088857889,
-0.0492504835,
-0.4133814573,
0.7486642003,
0.9460532665,
1.1632393599,
-0.6584998369,
0.0101787914,
0.4893011749,
0.5400288701,
-0.1135773808,
0.2448514253,
0.0827939957,
-0.7331006527,
-0.1159347817,
-0.6614362001,
-0.3557939231,
0.3483371437,
-0.9124621749,
0.0799571499,
-0.5338119864,
-0.0650528893,
-0.1940772533,
-0.1933639646,
-0.1871939301,
0.1727650762,
0.1165076792,
0.8146364093,
-0.8263104558,
0.8642845154,
0.2224993706,
-0.4716347754,
-0.4571189582,
0.5540098548,
0.1066501513,
-0.7598701715,
0.4343747795,
0.2506810427,
-0.4770588279,
-0.1271922737,
-0.5018299818,
-0.6331096292,
1.049529314,
0.2222861052,
-0.7277140021,
0.2491458952,
0.1631392837,
0.4937310815,
-0.3846223354,
0.0926912278,
0.5813131928,
0.4975584149,
0.4426563084,
-0.979993403,
0.4409688413,
0.042220138,
-0.1481403559,
-0.0396420509,
-0.3808198869,
0.641392529,
-0.4924597442,
-0.1920688301,
0.3344840407,
0.7898888588,
0.3869172037,
0.2978895307,
0.6477293372,
0.4554439187,
0.906177938,
0.0521837287,
0.6420962811,
-0.5113925338,
0.4307315648,
1.1563183069,
-0.4692521989,
0.9358344674,
0.7782608867,
-0.0452598743,
0.0727799013,
0.5685046911,
-0.1282294244,
0.6192883849,
0.6993420124,
-0.2930378914,
-0.3172427416,
0.0196758881,
-0.3621399701,
0.1646655053,
0.3982598782,
-0.002293797,
-0.1236862093,
-0.0265361834,
-0.1067340448,
0.4210666716,
-0.0511464775,
0.7029402852,
0.2979871929,
-0.727281034,
0.9380184412,
-0.1950297505,
0.3170020878,
-0.5918996334,
-0.0486793146,
-0.5019554496,
0.1709782034,
-0.0345527343,
-0.7237491012,
0.6796425581,
-0.346925199,
-0.1928507686,
0.1569822133,
0.3657755852,
-0.5390843153,
-0.3669032156,
0.437976867,
0.4230076969,
0.4273307323,
-0.2538635135,
-0.5135403275,
0.0986237675,
-0.0283211339,
-0.1413263828,
0.0884739384,
0.2067739666,
-0.0712044388,
1.0599241257,
0.3621585667,
0.184640184,
-0.0986782759,
0.0765028447,
0.7551047802,
-0.5890318751,
-0.3736587167,
-0.8655263186,
0.0501711816,
0.1028451845,
0.0234205909,
0.6757534146,
0.6471101046,
0.6763912439,
-0.2175819874,
0.660913825,
0.1884616464,
0.3608546853,
-0.7204961181,
0.6799435616,
-0.5646720529,
0.5713688135,
-0.0948144272,
-1.1132514477,
-0.5243929625,
0.8563553095,
-0.3068754971,
0.1361405849,
0.9363005161,
1.2902467251,
0.1109295636,
-0.0508644581,
0.8245687485,
0.3671458364,
0.2330371141,
0.5967336297,
0.8164058924,
-0.2092249691,
0.5981782079,
-0.3521136343,
-0.0708961338,
-0.2480117083,
-0.6581889391,
-1.0523096323,
-0.808216989,
-0.3216448128,
-0.6458985806,
0.2212058902,
0.6582376957,
0.579931438,
-1.1125862598,
-0.3336353898,
0.0262701288,
0.1824776679,
-0.3682298958,
-0.2298600227,
0.3971228898,
-0.4025647044,
-0.6852573752,
0.3102024496,
0.2393555492,
0.3789711297,
-0.5079360008,
-0.085613355,
0.0156563353,
0.5001099706,
0.1945503056,
0.1698470861,
-1.050183177,
-0.4939081073,
0.3310427964,
-0.2364337891,
0.1507914811,
0.6942024231,
-0.6207839847,
0.3726446331,
0.3022598624,
0.4228345752,
0.4833673835,
0.3605720699,
0.4691067934,
-0.5556431413,
0.0031846319,
0.4576700032,
-0.0326568447,
0.3317033648,
-0.6560314894,
0.587985456,
0.0633632392,
-0.5400310159,
-0.7592588067,
0.46904549,
-1.0415387154,
-0.4517800212,
1.0824189186,
-0.1066065952,
-0.3485241234,
-0.3293343782,
0.0345611162,
0.00758674,
-0.1537072957,
1.3021397591,
0.7774049044,
-0.2824958563,
-0.1598155648,
-0.390933305,
0.6516284347,
0.4092375636,
-0.6869589686,
0.4204405844,
0.3739429116,
0.3953095973,
0.2555141449,
0.6514613032,
-0.0834905282,
0.0921244919,
-0.0509667136,
0.221175909,
0.070743382,
-0.533346951,
-0.4712257981,
0.1545924991,
-0.013450617,
-0.1188973337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03381v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03381v2
|
Learning to Plan and Generate Text with Citations
| 2024-04-04T11:27:54 | 2024-05-13T15:47:57 |
Constanza Fierro, Reinald Kim Amplayo, Fantine Huot, Nicola De Cao, Joshua Maynez, Shashi Narayan, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The increasing demand for the deployment of LLMs in information-seeking
scenarios has spurred efforts in creating verifiable systems, which generate
responses to queries along with supporting evidence. In this paper, we explore
the attribution capabilities of plan-based models which have been recently
shown to improve the faithfulness, grounding, and controllability of generated
text. We conceptualize plans as a sequence of questions which serve as
blueprints of the generated content and its organization. We propose two
attribution models that utilize different variants of blueprints, an
abstractive model where questions are generated from scratch, and an extractive
model where questions are copied from the input. Experiments on long-form
question-answering show that planning consistently improves attribution
quality. Moreover, the citations generated by blueprint models are more
accurate compared to those obtained from LLM-based pipelines lacking a planning
component.
|
[
0.0916332752,
-0.4007575512,
1.1092786789,
0.2705215812,
-0.0511169881,
-0.1597586423,
0.1563655585,
-0.2789965868,
0.4284815788,
0.7714497447,
-0.6008141041,
-0.2495440096,
-0.115386039,
0.010850437,
-0.6128222346,
0.9487631321,
-0.4052430689,
-0.3178119063,
-0.3530510068,
0.2198505253,
-0.1956766993,
-0.4710610807,
-0.6059383154,
-0.5914136767,
1.1478862762,
0.5390089154,
0.3979068696,
0.9663844705,
0.3895520568,
0.1626603007,
0.1761563122,
0.3997389078,
-0.4241920412,
0.5052128434,
-0.4470434189,
-0.6776474714,
-0.2027437985,
0.1254520118,
0.5918120742,
0.4684909284,
-0.1834015399,
0.3839373589,
-0.0980189741,
0.5525135398,
-0.8709667921,
0.1859624535,
-1.0305000544,
-0.2930632532,
-0.022506237,
-0.8504824042,
-0.6608028412,
-0.723323226,
-0.1984108984,
-0.5418884158,
0.0579866171,
-0.0208228081,
0.7714635134,
0.0453876406,
-0.3909972012,
-0.8845853806,
-0.7674558759,
0.7070319653,
-0.4344500601,
0.0189689398,
0.5189819932,
0.2848939896,
-0.1285092682,
-1.0417523384,
-0.3222846985,
0.3124733865,
-0.0825811476,
0.2157007605,
0.0832451656,
-0.321271807,
0.0985353589,
0.011514022,
-0.3495690525,
-0.1265622973,
-0.4567928612,
-0.0846222565,
0.7344539165,
0.2168433368,
0.0120866196,
-0.5461332798,
-0.5219193101,
-0.1670740098,
-0.9534094334,
0.0150051033,
0.3576981127,
0.4454116821,
0.2923538089,
1.1262919903,
-0.1906259656,
0.4423451424,
-0.1611378491,
-0.1592078209,
-0.403495878,
-0.5852234364,
-0.1871944666,
0.1031487659,
0.3587688208,
0.3668184876,
0.467402935,
-0.4552743733,
-0.3954235315,
-0.071440354,
0.6059459448,
-0.6027295589,
-0.3113433123,
0.309437871,
-0.3784351051,
-0.5285368562,
-0.0011361567,
-0.1845035404,
-0.384041369,
-0.4908467233,
0.1809886992,
-0.5116638541,
-0.074994199,
-0.1241681203,
-0.2171271741,
0.4498773813,
0.4750372469,
-0.7260778546,
-0.1598619819,
0.3910165429,
0.7688735723,
-0.2439818382,
-0.2079066187,
-0.3631846309,
0.9610180259,
-0.6383009553,
1.3175035715,
-0.2051929235,
-0.3513751328,
0.4016076624,
-0.2687511742,
0.0139648728,
-0.5937978625,
0.3435136378,
-0.829770267,
0.1112489998,
-0.6785234213,
-0.5449893475,
0.1550185084,
0.6925130486,
-0.5720751882,
0.7854509354,
-0.1358530819,
-0.644771874,
0.5667253137,
-0.5447877049,
-0.2043743283,
0.137667045,
-0.4093395174,
-0.1733691096,
0.0321784355,
-0.0053361189,
0.4239130616,
-0.0939630494,
0.4466537535,
0.0768498406,
-0.081556417,
0.568459928,
-0.2855793834,
0.8257801533,
0.4213244915,
-0.095343858,
0.3222593069,
-0.9634483457,
0.5678145289,
0.2747792602,
-1.1458785534,
-0.1993115544,
0.4668470025,
-0.0949764252,
-0.1049938425,
0.0648775622,
-0.3721713126,
0.1692938656,
-0.1642831415,
0.2067839205,
0.653191328,
0.3152272403,
0.5323508978,
-0.6710337996,
0.4000309408,
-0.1783239096,
-0.362868011,
-0.5835598707,
-0.1251759231,
-0.7575931549,
-0.0398893468,
-0.2527855039,
0.5349648595,
-0.7812490463,
-0.1901108623,
-0.5265210271,
-0.7665284276,
0.2212216109,
-0.0331934988,
0.3906600773,
0.4918868542,
0.3597574234,
0.1320828497,
-0.5362209678,
-0.6488074064,
-0.4677688777,
-0.6865239739,
-0.217565313,
0.2572963834,
0.4045855403,
0.1768235117,
1.1262646914,
-0.534956634,
0.0985298678,
-0.3358856738,
0.3694448471,
-0.1626009792,
0.3908581436,
0.3162193298,
-0.7754378915,
-0.3919905126,
-0.3609347045,
-0.9523045421,
-0.1179517731,
-0.3915502131,
-0.2851447761,
0.0352990292,
0.6447814107,
-0.6076498628,
0.3989883959,
-0.018599458,
-0.4000726938,
0.7461590171,
0.1003464982,
0.0122675654,
-1.2521309853,
0.1638207585,
-0.307176739,
-0.3338192701,
-0.4330550432,
0.266523838,
0.294785291,
-0.2862456441,
-0.5493582487,
0.580555141,
-0.5881938934,
-0.0805658549,
-0.2172333598,
-0.0495858006,
0.3482792675,
0.2590770125,
-0.0026891637,
0.8056845665,
-0.0887783468,
-0.7906304002,
0.3700431287,
0.4465945065,
-0.387737155,
0.4668597579,
-0.5425515771,
0.0933860242,
-0.1529853642,
0.2592195868,
-1.0320583582,
-0.3336963058,
0.0909390301,
-0.4567421079,
0.2898924649,
-0.364067167,
-0.634891212,
-0.099516958,
-0.289593339,
0.2054375261,
0.1285718977,
-0.5804898739,
0.6560411453,
-0.0151124764,
-0.608530283,
-0.2165288031,
-0.9183248878,
0.0628115088,
-0.3260840178,
-0.5898035765,
0.6453011036,
0.1681207865,
-0.5594391823,
-0.0848642513,
0.0962667167,
-0.1449000984,
-0.1241695881,
0.2959294319,
0.1150527745,
-0.2404681295,
0.3138762414,
-0.0654878542,
-0.0018018128,
0.4641616642,
-0.1997539252,
0.5040324926,
0.3910212517,
-0.5141182542,
0.0307449549,
0.6829681396,
0.3412625492,
-0.2745408416,
0.6246672869,
-0.1807499975,
-0.3113079965,
-0.2067041248,
-0.6600955129,
-0.2468937784,
-0.472078234,
-0.0306724031,
-0.298917383,
-0.2376720756,
0.6644602418,
-0.1058943346,
0.4604666531,
0.3274686038,
0.5089942813,
-0.4366488755,
0.4925849438,
0.5510810614,
0.3693050146,
0.399156034,
-0.1710363328,
-0.2653411925,
-0.4085920751,
-0.5586771965,
-0.6842921972,
-0.1641583443,
-0.3255600035,
-0.5079607368,
0.0712670013,
0.1218957976,
-0.2841556072,
0.0706524178,
-0.3122664988,
0.4342883527,
0.7168341279,
0.0581113435,
0.4518660009,
0.4399208128,
0.0067692702,
0.0464217998,
-0.5562838316,
-1.1714427471,
1.3741788864,
0.1780969054,
0.7572667003,
0.1786961555,
0.8596715331,
0.1091440171,
0.3099114001,
-0.4919796884,
0.5614376068,
0.5580913424,
-0.9192246795,
-0.441131562,
-0.1846378297,
-0.7735250592,
-0.0382844061,
-0.2659238875,
-0.6894765496,
0.2213163078,
0.2350935936,
-0.1441996396,
0.3136101961,
-0.5519897342,
0.328017503,
-0.1983026564,
-0.6012715101,
0.013590673,
-0.2483960539,
0.0897536352,
-0.1976947933,
-0.1357265562,
0.0940600112,
-0.0458451845,
0.8787094355,
-0.3411196768,
0.6881369948,
-0.1779765934,
-0.223204568,
0.8227831721,
0.1079791561,
1.0679666996,
0.0359699242,
-0.4077990055,
-0.4790154696,
-0.2296431214,
-0.4319838583,
-0.4342386425,
0.4418988526,
-0.2707372308,
-0.3868137598,
-0.0554887354,
-0.7468101382,
-0.1232684255,
0.4140134156,
0.4731580913,
0.4110813737,
-0.0540038943,
0.000309412,
0.6937317252,
-0.3162367046,
0.5042615533,
0.3992561996,
-0.3222780824,
-0.229278177,
0.809094429,
0.2047205269,
0.4175951183,
0.2129618824,
-0.2016616911,
-0.2979713082,
-0.8870882392,
-0.2478429675,
0.4078490138,
-1.0428351164,
-0.2760531306,
-0.5692688823,
-0.3291692734,
-0.3365148902,
-0.4791211486,
-0.4103635848,
-0.3577878475,
-0.3456894457,
-0.3968261182,
0.0208215546,
0.6463081241,
0.2621459067,
0.33393538,
-0.4245634079,
-0.0920446515,
0.2282304466,
-0.0268619545,
-0.2323877066,
-0.2534692585,
-0.1962270439,
0.1151101217,
-0.6279841661,
-1.0440163612,
0.3790116906,
-0.1746905148,
0.5225379467,
0.1449137628,
0.2094352692,
0.729555428,
-0.5015944839,
0.6722579598,
0.0546547398,
-0.2359080315,
0.7911287546,
-0.6631464958,
0.1575129926,
0.6084082723,
0.6030551791,
0.1227961108,
-0.4571197033,
-0.5567048192,
-0.9338849783,
0.5025946498,
0.3225570321,
0.2863224745,
-0.1100105569,
0.7807870507,
-0.1469844133,
0.1925295442,
-1.0089908838,
-0.1862598509,
-0.1143750474,
0.0018968874,
0.1519965678,
-0.7747967839,
-0.2031472623,
0.2856949568,
0.5116746426,
-0.1561702788,
0.5375503898,
0.270935148,
-0.0594403781,
-0.2572373152,
0.2949442565,
0.5522476435,
1.051881671,
-0.2547253072,
0.4100461304,
-0.1592948586,
-0.0920376256,
0.1933032423,
0.0029072675,
-0.5804562569,
0.0429379269,
0.5279092789,
0.3393986225,
-0.1110992953,
-0.5165001154,
0.1780439913,
0.1857942641,
-0.5335329771,
-0.5214262009,
0.0156539511,
0.4304987788,
0.4361383915,
0.5597279072,
-0.2596970797,
-0.0483497009,
-0.6498085856,
0.0646873862,
0.4110530317,
-0.3111855388,
-0.1160328835,
0.5766298175,
-0.0528186858,
-0.2316123694,
0.5700885653,
0.0549301356,
-0.3015506566,
0.471275568,
0.8553084731,
0.3348282576,
0.0195661876,
0.2352560312,
0.4532904923,
0.3192634881,
0.0976099893,
0.5780837536,
-0.0570916049,
-0.6507043839,
-0.3540189266,
-0.5406631231,
-0.3286533058,
0.1161432266,
-0.5552439094,
0.3013523817,
-0.3188487291,
-0.055306863,
-0.1260242313,
-0.0903329924,
-0.4080022573,
0.3229904175,
-0.0567040406,
0.9216556549,
-0.6490182877,
0.6120023727,
0.9758555889,
-0.7180805802,
-1.3321743011,
-0.1082878709,
-0.272957325,
-0.7958764434,
0.7634776831,
0.1068419814,
0.0303028636,
0.1708192527,
-0.6583414674,
-1.2208836079,
1.5063722134,
0.4691311419,
-0.1153864115,
-0.5771785378,
0.2909486294,
0.03963973,
-0.3580028415,
-0.0541056506,
-0.0345513858,
0.4324915409,
0.4457479119,
-0.4498578012,
0.0848276988,
-0.0564600378,
-0.2798565328,
0.0256714039,
0.0284365527,
0.8882913589,
-0.3400759101,
-0.4665609896,
-0.0792699009,
0.7989277244,
0.709209621,
0.4563773274,
0.2182180434,
0.1170311272,
0.940648675,
-0.035883192,
1.0864076614,
0.1062281877,
-0.1248830259,
1.3980857134,
-0.093434602,
0.9355547428,
0.9371393919,
-0.0044931732,
0.734560132,
0.5563207269,
0.1719052643,
0.7387951612,
0.1656223238,
-0.0775018111,
-0.092214644,
-0.0712661743,
-0.2361101806,
0.1594600081,
0.2054813057,
-0.8475567698,
-0.3126832247,
-0.2872802019,
0.1135143414,
0.3498768508,
-0.3693089187,
0.8754989505,
-0.0453187712,
-0.9928786159,
0.267339319,
0.0694569424,
0.3059689999,
-0.6954671144,
0.1821364611,
-0.3021705151,
0.0701824501,
-0.2490236312,
-0.676641643,
0.6701293588,
0.1602029502,
-0.6413574815,
-0.6143900156,
0.9994155765,
-0.3246627748,
-0.5278787017,
-0.0681237727,
0.5699731112,
0.2822142243,
-0.3574654758,
-0.2916523218,
-0.2631161511,
0.0751550272,
-0.6557133198,
0.1628762931,
0.465952754,
-0.1965265423,
0.7738598585,
0.75402987,
0.3508863449,
0.5085040927,
-0.4686619043,
0.9533499479,
-0.7448375225,
-0.3284716606,
-0.8331621885,
0.7098991275,
-0.1822795272,
-0.0149461646,
0.6362241507,
0.751137197,
0.7500118613,
0.007056592,
0.7717400193,
0.1261869073,
0.605948925,
-0.7530387044,
0.6763881445,
-0.5640957355,
0.3864282966,
-0.2208747119,
-1.0779693127,
-0.0883016959,
0.4973685145,
-0.2870804965,
-0.1523922682,
0.5266261697,
0.605720818,
0.0049805813,
-0.3139534593,
0.0508269668,
-0.4202226102,
0.9087007642,
0.3478994071,
0.8743559718,
-0.2903271019,
0.7875894904,
0.0412066728,
-0.0245830528,
-0.0346358307,
-1.109336257,
-0.7204372883,
-0.5843245387,
-0.1461491734,
-0.1642142832,
-0.0779204145,
0.4091089666,
0.5009937882,
-0.3982141912,
-0.2914705276,
-0.443449676,
0.0416728854,
0.3194060624,
-0.1980538964,
0.3008337915,
-0.5301086903,
-0.1887555867,
0.4511551261,
0.1051813215,
0.2921041548,
-0.2709436417,
-0.1183944941,
-0.4563147128,
0.4100157619,
0.4983840585,
0.2091667652,
-0.5475094914,
-0.228733182,
0.0776333362,
-0.3933106661,
-0.1588316411,
0.9911366701,
-0.6430578232,
0.1510149986,
0.3437690735,
0.4685283601,
0.6325707436,
0.2531706691,
0.821696341,
-0.713223815,
-0.2123476863,
0.2776213288,
0.1847952604,
0.3703365624,
-0.2930786014,
0.6402335167,
-0.1795282811,
-0.6179154515,
-0.8401117921,
0.4492598176,
-0.6876875162,
-0.2315937728,
1.2788729668,
-0.2187730521,
0.0281723831,
-0.0650178567,
-0.049093321,
0.3405196071,
0.0636967644,
0.6003739834,
0.7065981627,
-0.137684226,
0.1267683655,
-0.2795115113,
0.3774880171,
0.3846614063,
-1.024314642,
0.360177815,
0.7200376987,
0.2636928856,
0.6363968849,
1.0308681726,
-0.1799636781,
0.012546055,
0.0145921083,
0.0662061572,
-0.3258731961,
-0.4063247144,
0.5534834862,
0.4715429842,
0.4132791758,
0.0045070979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03361v1
|
nicolay-r at SemEval-2024 Task 3: Using Flan-T5 for Reasoning Emotion Cause in Conversations with Chain-of-Thought on Emotion States
| 2024-04-04T11:03:33 | 2024-04-04T11:03:33 |
Nicolay Rusnachenko, Huizhi Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotion expression is one of the essential traits of conversations. It may be
self-related or caused by another speaker. The variety of reasons may serve as
a source of the further emotion causes: conversation history, speaker's
emotional state, etc. Inspired by the most recent advances in Chain-of-Thought,
in this work, we exploit the existing three-hop reasoning approach (THOR) to
perform large language model instruction-tuning for answering: emotion states
(THOR-state), and emotion caused by one speaker to the other (THOR-cause). We
equip THOR-cause with the reasoning revision (rr) for devising a reasoning path
in fine-tuning. In particular, we rely on the annotated speaker emotion states
to revise reasoning path. Our final submission, based on Flan-T5-base (250M)
and the rule-based span correction technique, preliminary tuned with THOR-state
and fine-tuned with THOR-cause-rr on competition training data, results in 3rd
and 4th places (F1-proportional) and 5th place (F1-strict) among 15
participating teams. Our THOR implementation fork is publicly available:
https://github.com/nicolay-r/THOR-ECAC
|
[
-0.5123106241,
-0.9419150352,
0.5594670773,
0.0287519228,
-0.1322609484,
-0.2130191177,
0.0433677174,
-0.6579052806,
0.428797096,
0.3699855506,
-0.7050939798,
-0.1978429258,
-0.3534311354,
0.3239305019,
-0.1333683133,
0.8313982487,
-0.3417040706,
-0.2491288632,
0.3903837204,
-0.1904975474,
-0.4717452228,
-0.5282957554,
-0.7444552183,
-0.166226998,
0.9189956784,
0.7901171446,
0.3178956211,
0.2306562662,
0.3960199356,
0.2026808262,
-0.1898003966,
0.1987926811,
-0.5673547983,
0.4355159104,
-0.4483073652,
-0.4385677576,
-0.8195040822,
-0.3382878304,
0.3786109984,
0.1064698324,
-0.0941047966,
0.0460253358,
-0.1655405313,
0.8499510288,
-0.7774327993,
-0.0930680335,
-0.6257116199,
0.126722604,
-0.3734443188,
-0.527186811,
-0.4930660427,
-0.1785909534,
-0.046272926,
-0.3883219957,
-0.0379719585,
0.318666786,
0.8486948609,
0.1823063493,
-0.6916339397,
-0.2206859887,
-0.4716324508,
0.4739025533,
-0.6468911171,
0.3355326653,
0.2272383869,
-0.0514027439,
-0.1061885059,
-0.346593976,
-0.628017664,
0.4276896417,
0.2577701211,
0.2928673327,
-0.247324124,
0.259516269,
0.4426317513,
0.3755363822,
-0.3583554327,
-0.0825755671,
-0.4255079925,
0.025740739,
0.6584339142,
0.1106654927,
0.2119761556,
0.0107153673,
-0.2029748857,
-0.1459101886,
-0.8418699503,
-0.1854677051,
0.4070611596,
0.2569525838,
0.0626154467,
0.3844997883,
-0.168161124,
0.4919964373,
0.0707871318,
0.3654691279,
0.1848927587,
-0.0524005294,
-0.2246259898,
0.1568702012,
0.5921664834,
0.368702352,
0.1599107981,
0.323889792,
-0.1064974889,
-0.054700572,
0.2307368815,
-0.5822244883,
0.0175991245,
0.4168564379,
-0.0915116072,
-0.384816885,
-0.1598047018,
-0.9252430201,
-0.3600519896,
-0.112364009,
0.7943055034,
-0.4001642168,
-0.6460687518,
0.0906877816,
0.0005661094,
0.2291119248,
0.4488088489,
-0.8961697817,
0.1989703923,
0.7174031138,
0.5855664611,
0.1892426759,
-0.4093686044,
-0.7279133201,
-0.0036655832,
-0.5125702024,
0.567812562,
-0.4710377753,
-0.0284460727,
-0.0428717546,
-0.0737025365,
-0.2425265312,
-0.1002050191,
0.8776543736,
-0.3733364046,
0.4901073873,
-0.6659883261,
-0.7036910653,
-0.3241760135,
0.2849764824,
-0.462141335,
0.9166596532,
0.0323780142,
-1.0875502825,
-0.0507770889,
-0.7515749931,
-0.6284908056,
-0.084370479,
0.0902110189,
-0.0947123989,
0.2658999264,
0.1483717561,
0.4217093587,
-0.2846330702,
0.1245403439,
-0.3272356093,
-0.3222679198,
-0.0892784521,
0.0015249155,
0.2668138146,
0.2865232229,
-0.7346016765,
0.3884767592,
-0.3897666037,
-0.1065126359,
-0.0485506915,
0.0183574278,
-0.2452473044,
0.100085251,
-0.3420267403,
0.5601240993,
-0.1185272709,
-0.4766326249,
0.0143140573,
-0.5599943995,
0.2273257226,
0.9269579649,
0.466584295,
0.0306973252,
-0.3086669743,
0.7102544308,
0.2319151461,
0.13739115,
-0.2510074973,
-0.4836223125,
-1.0453362465,
0.2074654996,
-0.025398206,
0.3852888048,
-0.7390350103,
0.0410211571,
0.1093659699,
-0.3572191298,
-0.4686394334,
-0.4006926119,
0.1791514307,
0.7233838439,
0.4460985363,
0.1864013076,
-0.6732920408,
-0.6448276639,
-0.6288055182,
-0.1619664133,
0.4633451998,
0.276168704,
0.6992800832,
-0.0726135969,
0.3634081781,
-0.2974826992,
-0.0034791615,
-0.3266096413,
0.3494492769,
0.0987261757,
0.469387114,
0.271328181,
-0.4562221169,
-0.2850360572,
0.1268337816,
-0.4582456946,
-0.2709347904,
-0.1102091223,
-0.4995197654,
0.5972840786,
0.297347337,
-0.2344740033,
0.5137289762,
0.5831506848,
-0.5277394056,
0.4173288941,
0.0717947111,
0.6055609584,
-1.2975301743,
-0.0677981451,
0.1040318534,
-0.1737027317,
-0.5539516211,
0.0702615976,
-0.1519320309,
-0.0950305909,
-0.3474753797,
0.5301760435,
-0.0880824849,
0.0644433424,
-0.181055963,
0.296561271,
0.0307040289,
0.5646008849,
0.1072887927,
0.479642272,
0.5369824171,
-0.5226593018,
0.3681334853,
0.1606812626,
0.0436913557,
0.5433595181,
-0.4004624486,
0.3080396652,
0.108758308,
0.2802413106,
-0.7125819921,
-0.3443931043,
0.312695086,
-0.2752440274,
0.121259138,
0.1184703112,
-0.4888839126,
-0.4449289441,
-0.1143060848,
0.3822595179,
0.3341134787,
-0.5814097524,
0.7066200972,
0.1422949731,
-0.192085892,
-0.375728488,
-0.4806030393,
-0.021448208,
-0.5541700125,
-0.7148704529,
0.2062170506,
0.0213180277,
-0.1728481799,
-0.3559061885,
-0.4253081381,
0.1471835673,
0.1125651076,
0.0434198976,
-0.1527601331,
-0.0237514228,
0.3246303201,
0.182412371,
0.0435884483,
0.2901453376,
-0.2086326182,
0.3416404724,
-0.6297546029,
-0.2419792563,
-0.6433985233,
0.3657184243,
0.6183406115,
-0.2329150885,
0.5673392415,
0.5098515749,
-0.2896000445,
-0.2455588877,
-0.5617019534,
-0.3959420621,
-0.3881064057,
0.1028587818,
-0.6094109416,
-1.2670942545,
0.4116975069,
-0.3012381196,
-0.1884473264,
0.5917120576,
0.5378540158,
-0.4088770151,
1.0408799648,
0.2063182294,
-0.0454450995,
0.3099996448,
0.0552895218,
0.3837527037,
-0.9238263369,
-0.0634595156,
-0.5063098073,
-0.3658615649,
-0.7383872867,
-0.2865900993,
0.5782051086,
0.0237683859,
-0.401453346,
0.2149545699,
-0.1800997853,
0.2951459885,
0.3608137071,
0.1221826375,
-0.2358645648,
-0.2540339231,
-0.3144474328,
0.1546995044,
-0.8222715259,
-0.1905660033,
0.5311810374,
0.5651353002,
0.632378459,
0.3660755455,
0.9930482507,
0.1194841191,
-0.0634553283,
-0.6306939125,
0.5411564112,
0.2587008774,
-0.7824064493,
-0.1858185828,
-0.5243524909,
-0.6546266079,
0.2274762541,
-0.0654572397,
-1.1956170797,
0.0668823496,
0.4900714457,
-0.1566713005,
0.3234075308,
-0.4882339537,
1.0067456961,
-0.3332427144,
-0.6320986748,
-0.5138329268,
-0.8394761682,
0.559625864,
-0.0300936904,
0.3118324876,
-0.0274390187,
0.638066411,
0.7111340761,
-0.775935173,
0.5779702067,
-0.1870153695,
-0.3372752964,
0.5432894826,
0.3642811775,
0.7926443219,
-0.196597442,
-0.3348771334,
-0.3702912927,
0.2216546535,
-0.1304885745,
-0.6605430841,
0.4582489133,
-0.4357447028,
-0.6171376705,
-0.525491178,
-0.2819136083,
-0.3261907101,
-0.0457652695,
0.274307996,
0.5929601192,
0.1882381737,
0.2084324807,
0.6013172269,
-0.176764518,
0.3725549877,
0.1713308543,
-0.4605490863,
-0.4366253316,
0.9104822278,
-0.4038092196,
0.3590755165,
0.5533316731,
0.6523984075,
-0.224948436,
0.1215799898,
-0.0409202725,
0.2086259574,
-0.7331688404,
-0.2253839225,
-0.2863584459,
0.1690764278,
-0.3045490682,
-0.1282334179,
-0.4068970978,
-0.5471758842,
-0.3117597103,
-0.0676662624,
0.504964292,
0.804428339,
-0.1765027642,
0.1180491745,
-0.7604262233,
0.0862609074,
0.2324574888,
0.1870079637,
-0.0117191449,
-0.6370589137,
-0.1784404367,
-0.0411359854,
-0.5279673934,
-1.2394753695,
0.2312874943,
0.2165654898,
0.1177329123,
0.375293225,
0.1617123634,
0.8744350672,
-0.2398208678,
0.8034226894,
0.2237012982,
-1.359066844,
1.2259379625,
-0.7871852517,
0.2789813578,
0.3593790233,
0.2910114527,
-0.7802056074,
-0.5004711747,
-0.972211957,
-0.7134753466,
0.8164432645,
0.4038464725,
-0.2278453559,
-0.2071379423,
0.2257813811,
-0.2855194807,
-0.0676510036,
-0.4301341474,
0.0918344185,
-0.1640256792,
-0.1139464602,
0.3099364936,
-0.3854195178,
-0.1093429476,
-0.2425422072,
1.1986969709,
-0.3126200438,
0.2182201296,
0.2921037674,
0.1323762685,
-0.4573763013,
0.6978845596,
0.9773304462,
0.4745823443,
-0.2247714698,
0.2536599338,
0.4402440786,
0.133406058,
-0.041716937,
-0.1894966513,
0.361325264,
-0.3374109566,
0.3322832286,
1.088956356,
0.2553934157,
-0.3257824183,
0.5683386326,
0.0106246173,
-0.3175789714,
0.0484000444,
0.0627142861,
-0.0199491959,
0.3691900969,
0.0068053636,
0.1081600189,
0.1485223919,
-0.5430236459,
0.1834639907,
-0.1872587055,
-0.4477663338,
-0.6164519191,
0.5904521346,
0.535564959,
-0.1186473295,
0.4628119171,
-0.3511301577,
-0.9982225895,
0.3165748417,
0.6489853263,
0.9396455288,
-0.3890887499,
0.1180461496,
0.5424825549,
0.1747564226,
-0.06897524,
1.0681191683,
-0.0919379666,
-0.7905852199,
-0.3972020745,
-0.4014888406,
-0.4682637155,
-0.0208816323,
-0.8065745234,
0.3681896031,
-0.278414309,
-0.1111911908,
-0.4186783731,
-0.2063551694,
-0.5029961467,
0.4443293512,
0.4086090326,
0.9472700953,
-0.9795818329,
0.5549997091,
0.7582352757,
-0.3112221062,
-1.3081711531,
0.132690534,
0.3549212217,
-0.3276403844,
0.7547559142,
0.1729984581,
-0.5651138425,
0.0985876471,
-0.4591955543,
-0.6327648163,
0.8648315072,
0.1099630892,
-0.714224577,
0.2232741714,
-0.2648945451,
0.4785650969,
-0.3398143649,
0.3177551925,
0.5394546986,
0.3433401585,
0.3772454858,
-0.9865440726,
0.0114785042,
-0.2885912061,
-0.1723944396,
0.3711974323,
-0.8343889713,
0.4868322015,
-0.1407659352,
0.1208657324,
-0.3189766109,
0.6500831246,
0.6260755062,
0.1594302356,
0.6167253256,
0.7414181828,
0.872086823,
-0.146403417,
0.7570949197,
-0.4202163517,
0.4749078751,
1.2340453863,
-0.5539608002,
0.9934391379,
0.5434401035,
-0.0051091095,
0.6916421056,
0.7166225314,
0.4956288934,
0.2031722665,
0.1875602305,
-0.4110628963,
-0.3852660656,
-0.0593704842,
-0.3156379759,
0.7754196525,
0.4772561491,
-0.2108379453,
0.0357671753,
-0.0371852964,
0.3272161186,
-0.2533048391,
-0.3071187139,
0.5925347209,
0.0781349614,
-0.8402225971,
0.4796406031,
-0.2057558894,
0.1370566636,
-0.2671838999,
-0.0415828042,
-0.295232743,
0.0726650432,
-0.2981224358,
-0.6795820594,
0.3228552938,
0.2449226379,
0.229196623,
-0.3955733478,
0.6450137496,
-0.285769105,
-0.2485261112,
0.1678696722,
0.2285999954,
0.3240601122,
-0.0783294216,
-0.472099185,
0.3411820531,
-0.0047432501,
-0.3933561742,
-0.1342470944,
0.7876358032,
-0.0622610264,
0.408531189,
-0.045273874,
-0.0237097442,
-0.1072045863,
0.5770431757,
0.703764379,
-0.7827532291,
-0.6643775702,
-0.7642071843,
0.6363027692,
0.0448985808,
-0.3752830327,
0.2571613193,
0.4747524559,
0.4450184107,
0.1295762062,
0.7477173209,
-0.2874038219,
0.5700075626,
-0.6975100636,
0.3266713321,
-0.8266358376,
0.1730009913,
-0.7566885948,
-0.6216992736,
-0.0179257505,
0.6861906052,
-0.358743906,
-0.0035968088,
1.2353963852,
0.606902957,
0.209847495,
0.7066665292,
0.2396254092,
0.4220250845,
0.376195699,
0.8841799498,
1.0327347517,
-0.5769507885,
0.1549961567,
-0.090601787,
-0.1585804075,
-0.2670103908,
-1.1106938124,
-0.6295933127,
-0.856375277,
-0.6386811733,
-0.4217305481,
0.107735604,
1.057187438,
0.4330345094,
-0.7540279031,
-0.1315070689,
-0.5487674475,
0.2274389118,
-0.2179644108,
-0.199777469,
0.1311172545,
-0.5601710677,
-0.2313604951,
0.5196938515,
0.2858549058,
-0.1624184251,
0.3061560094,
-0.1077990308,
-0.4824926257,
0.0245190095,
0.6485188007,
0.2944538295,
-0.9587053061,
-0.8300971985,
-0.1166709512,
0.3131999671,
-0.061277166,
0.7383033037,
-0.3482910097,
0.6111436486,
0.6492612362,
0.4684045911,
0.6034035683,
0.2202025652,
0.8116156459,
-0.8282827139,
-0.2289049029,
0.2808654606,
0.4592460692,
0.1496886909,
-0.2769218981,
0.6687259674,
0.2727551758,
-0.901119709,
-0.5665202737,
0.4602267742,
-0.8456671238,
-0.0099809254,
1.1611741781,
-0.1520994455,
-0.1849402189,
0.4903572798,
-0.2763186395,
0.4616083503,
-0.2956674993,
0.5577735305,
0.8608486652,
-0.6401335001,
-0.6267556548,
-0.3280459046,
0.5066212416,
0.6795745492,
-1.1829481125,
0.0613722354,
0.5185467601,
-0.0100979311,
-0.2023531646,
0.5822883844,
0.124665089,
0.3334326446,
-0.2050193101,
0.0683574304,
0.3864486516,
-0.5925706029,
-0.292515099,
0.0040531233,
0.0292690452,
0.0025038698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03353v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03353v1
|
Towards Pareto Optimal Throughput in Small Language Model Serving
| 2024-04-04T10:45:07 | 2024-04-04T10:45:07 |
Pol G. Recasens, Yue Zhu, Chen Wang, Eun Kyung Lee, Olivier Tardieu, Alaa Youssef, Jordi Torres, Josep Ll. Berral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the state-of-the-art of many
different natural language processing tasks. Although serving LLMs is
computationally and memory demanding, the rise of Small Language Models (SLMs)
offers new opportunities for resource-constrained users, who now are able to
serve small models with cutting-edge performance. In this paper, we present a
set of experiments designed to benchmark SLM inference at performance and
energy levels. Our analysis provides a new perspective in serving, highlighting
that the small memory footprint of SLMs allows for reaching the Pareto-optimal
throughput within the resource capacity of a single accelerator. In this
regard, we present an initial set of findings demonstrating how model
replication can effectively improve resource utilization for serving SLMs.
|
[
-0.2819354832,
-0.6476324201,
1.1014610529,
0.0030565853,
-0.0208048783,
-0.081883356,
-0.3550881743,
-0.3229165077,
0.0975844935,
0.9143660665,
-0.423230052,
0.0171927959,
-0.455583781,
0.0894816741,
-0.2233814448,
0.4342202544,
0.2672899663,
0.2873193026,
-0.5902411938,
-0.1715293229,
-0.4742387533,
-0.365530163,
-0.9332075119,
-0.5954166651,
0.3322836161,
0.6302596927,
1.0674010515,
1.0036361217,
0.3768278956,
0.2483859062,
-0.053629078,
0.0071281907,
-0.6021277905,
-0.0448528379,
-0.249679774,
-0.6412036419,
-0.3718447983,
-0.0959332511,
0.9248738289,
1.0893845558,
-0.3468882442,
0.3870190382,
0.1147477403,
0.6236001849,
-0.7096359134,
-0.3711314797,
-0.8338785768,
-0.0789212808,
-0.3386500776,
0.2560537457,
-0.8123701811,
-0.3929910958,
-0.1893957853,
-0.4204726219,
0.0684286729,
0.4113031924,
0.6110873222,
0.1569986045,
-0.0885123312,
-0.0040430501,
-0.7835074067,
1.0871624947,
-0.8999297619,
0.5155095458,
0.4205563366,
0.4288487136,
-0.1910582483,
-1.0003519058,
-0.30256778,
-0.3148626685,
-0.3328178227,
-0.5401906371,
-0.4929436743,
0.0450381488,
0.4183135629,
0.3654070199,
-0.3453510106,
0.3800390959,
0.0781540498,
0.0626870692,
0.2429799885,
0.4477998316,
0.2876955867,
0.0341422521,
-0.2973623872,
0.0655239448,
-0.7636222243,
0.0990942791,
0.0678141117,
0.4753857255,
0.1287146062,
0.6974711418,
-0.1582219303,
0.7528386116,
-0.2395389676,
-0.0906082615,
-0.1195831522,
-0.4874681234,
-0.5340192914,
-0.1013262123,
0.6888231039,
0.1208128184,
-0.048754923,
-0.1232174635,
-0.3880628347,
-0.0769612417,
0.2151954174,
-0.9199362397,
-0.1062615067,
-0.1950080693,
-0.4150559604,
0.1685983986,
-0.3247196674,
-0.9431967735,
-0.6344605684,
-0.2903310657,
0.4057385921,
-0.3102207184,
0.1106493548,
0.2729812264,
0.0946166888,
-0.1477460265,
-0.0041004722,
-1.0551416874,
0.9537016749,
0.6995043159,
1.0488520861,
-0.0355066508,
-0.0751543641,
-0.910866797,
0.2955063283,
-0.1056448445,
0.7468119264,
-0.6471229792,
-0.3053931594,
-0.0775426179,
-0.2618792057,
-0.3139923513,
-0.7297358513,
0.5407976508,
-0.2953589559,
-0.2677534521,
-0.6651765108,
-0.7685566545,
0.483199358,
-0.196533829,
-0.8159476519,
1.0739921331,
-0.1693082005,
-0.4213158488,
0.1222649068,
-0.5492941737,
-0.5131585002,
0.0823732689,
-0.2749916613,
-0.2786571681,
0.6305666566,
0.2691417038,
0.2756651342,
-0.7461444736,
-0.048610609,
-0.4056298137,
-0.2799171209,
0.214899227,
-0.1527015567,
0.4338835776,
0.3343505263,
-0.1293556094,
0.2219929844,
-0.6783248782,
0.0312017035,
0.3212975562,
-0.1092566624,
-0.3451351225,
0.4229751825,
-0.3136557639,
-0.0191706512,
0.3354919255,
-0.6244403124,
0.2040071189,
-0.4494075775,
0.5301419497,
0.6820589304,
-0.1758108586,
0.7470904589,
-0.4429966509,
0.5719810724,
-0.3833232522,
0.2868248522,
-0.0101075331,
-0.2143505067,
-0.8560343385,
-0.4127978384,
0.1083859876,
0.1213487014,
-0.7610370517,
-0.2252686471,
-0.3367903531,
-0.3315466046,
-0.8686817884,
0.2180948704,
0.321855247,
0.4480839968,
0.3004510999,
0.1436335146,
-0.4791315794,
-1.4548672438,
-0.4415497184,
0.1875831783,
-0.0693898872,
0.6311640143,
0.2394338101,
-0.0748492554,
0.8663552403,
-0.5576598048,
-0.0945133641,
-0.6566309929,
-0.1705929488,
0.5126137137,
0.3149676919,
0.5085365176,
-0.4539803565,
-0.6471830606,
-0.0553273633,
-0.474339962,
-0.3253902793,
-0.0571217947,
-0.1234561726,
0.209667176,
0.3306845725,
-0.3978396952,
0.1043866649,
0.6298558712,
-0.1442814022,
0.3151114583,
-0.4990584254,
0.0125873256,
-0.5520005822,
-0.1154510304,
-0.1634112895,
-0.5496726632,
-0.7615296841,
-0.029110508,
-0.1158347726,
-0.3388676941,
-0.4322485924,
0.6991510391,
-0.6623065472,
-0.6048910022,
-0.3911662698,
0.1295829713,
0.0451939404,
0.1893691123,
-0.1876856089,
1.2263088226,
0.5085742474,
-0.3748654723,
-0.1877869815,
-0.2445020974,
-0.3650149703,
0.2388539463,
-0.787558198,
0.186829403,
0.0914646834,
-0.1280469298,
-1.0033738613,
-0.0711346269,
-0.142737627,
0.2195839137,
0.0682197884,
-0.0277492087,
-0.8547624946,
-0.180912137,
-0.2653644085,
0.4246879518,
0.7750184536,
-0.5640330911,
0.6791520715,
0.6771424413,
0.0636296794,
-0.0954293013,
-0.5661017895,
-0.0458230861,
-0.1841124743,
-0.7443163991,
0.2356267571,
0.0510879196,
-0.387937963,
-0.1429979801,
-0.0258793123,
0.165130496,
0.1918550283,
0.0961393192,
-0.0433190204,
-0.2925415635,
-0.1032111719,
-0.2426032722,
-0.0097626429,
-0.0846101344,
-0.2813985646,
0.8932759762,
-0.4705357254,
-0.3859153688,
-0.446437031,
0.3711032867,
0.3251987994,
0.0119956573,
1.0295264721,
0.1185456142,
-0.3810094893,
-0.3255291581,
-0.5912598372,
-0.0986184776,
-0.4913963974,
0.0768758431,
-0.5129796267,
-0.9019049406,
0.5564451218,
-0.0511701629,
-0.0815163031,
0.3438473344,
0.480871439,
-0.1143592596,
0.9749158025,
0.5705233216,
-0.0841707736,
0.5627749562,
-0.0559383184,
0.0391605645,
-0.6954548955,
0.2124506682,
-0.7309305668,
-0.2497859448,
-0.509677887,
-0.6129288673,
0.5006305575,
0.1844938546,
-0.4332120419,
0.3058359325,
-0.1880734563,
0.745822072,
0.7073044777,
0.1567392796,
0.391571492,
-0.0648040548,
-0.3149843514,
-0.2242639959,
-1.1094167233,
-0.8194020987,
0.7583809495,
0.4167704284,
0.8140535951,
-0.0093491962,
0.6672202945,
0.3033991158,
0.1360570192,
-0.3193241656,
0.7827020288,
-0.496991396,
-0.340195328,
-0.3474492729,
-0.5568787456,
-0.8515646458,
0.4469183683,
0.0773324892,
-1.1143022776,
-0.167442143,
0.433927536,
-0.2966100574,
0.5520703793,
-0.7809314728,
1.0573970079,
-0.2190525979,
-0.7194271684,
-0.4760489762,
-0.3260737658,
0.1759058535,
0.225271076,
0.3318061233,
-0.1979999393,
-0.1811270416,
0.6000081301,
-0.2946766615,
0.844179213,
-0.2282675058,
0.2750790715,
0.0660099834,
0.0914615914,
0.6890403032,
0.0976024568,
-0.413621068,
0.1204830632,
-0.087682195,
-0.5900993347,
-0.3694456816,
0.8945987821,
-0.5442695618,
-0.7002319694,
-0.3451049626,
-0.3198359311,
-0.3270698786,
0.3802848756,
-0.0001237244,
0.1951925904,
-0.2893000841,
0.2175696045,
0.8224371076,
-0.2765434682,
0.5825892091,
0.3253424466,
-0.5080260038,
-0.134084627,
0.7772597075,
0.0846196041,
0.654253602,
0.4373447001,
0.3870396316,
-0.1259279549,
-0.7624350786,
-0.3449182212,
0.2568134964,
-0.4202097952,
-0.0689399019,
-0.582211256,
0.0501976348,
-0.2814064324,
-0.1607282907,
-0.8102861047,
-0.1680084318,
-0.4626128972,
0.2578267753,
-0.0936966836,
0.6062610149,
0.0167718474,
0.6642799973,
-0.4432543814,
0.2817318738,
0.2435379475,
0.4807272851,
0.1608804166,
-0.3892101645,
-0.385114193,
0.1693602204,
-0.1713539213,
-0.621748507,
0.2112641186,
0.1487507224,
0.8153312802,
0.0807524323,
-0.2412144095,
0.5489928722,
-0.8188234568,
0.7747594118,
0.0672209114,
-0.9823525548,
0.4461416304,
-0.2605981231,
0.4271509349,
0.6841052771,
0.2655397058,
-0.3997905552,
-0.1289062947,
-0.5181000829,
-0.6740308404,
0.8530522585,
0.3227040768,
-0.0868185386,
-0.0529800057,
0.3381261826,
0.1520572603,
0.3195622265,
-0.7025173306,
-0.1815130413,
0.223444283,
0.1126623228,
-0.2613150775,
-0.426502645,
0.1052894145,
-0.1844301671,
0.8568496108,
-0.2112948149,
0.3304717243,
-0.2641473711,
-0.1207590029,
-0.0667035058,
0.2350085974,
0.6629980206,
0.7630236149,
-0.3073867261,
0.4178840518,
0.2944494784,
0.0018091031,
0.0353440605,
-0.1012146622,
-0.289118737,
-0.0715545937,
0.2238834053,
1.1616410017,
0.5031104088,
-0.8300766945,
0.1910298616,
-0.1788944304,
0.4078037739,
-0.0499215275,
0.3054288626,
0.3525527418,
0.3295631409,
0.1768488586,
-0.2063149512,
0.042638056,
-0.4582787156,
0.1364410967,
0.6809859276,
0.0089206705,
-0.0986105651,
0.7665471435,
-0.0921526775,
-0.60736835,
0.4152131975,
-0.0915345401,
-0.1825122535,
0.3099546731,
0.6845992804,
0.6870128512,
0.1894931942,
0.0105490796,
0.0374386236,
0.3216313422,
-0.408393681,
0.1942714751,
0.0327224955,
-0.7429897189,
-0.1705023199,
-0.9659575224,
-0.4770421982,
0.0138787217,
-0.8387374282,
0.0232420191,
-0.3916043639,
-0.3056919277,
0.2803816497,
0.1722197384,
-0.7098622322,
-0.2691757083,
0.2978484929,
0.9771347642,
-0.7395243645,
1.1428923607,
0.5793253779,
-0.1272665262,
-0.3014091253,
-0.4046672285,
-0.2539762557,
-1.0410788059,
0.3134556115,
-0.068341963,
-0.2091280222,
-0.0210473742,
-0.2383082509,
-1.0077888966,
0.8942124248,
0.9399583936,
-0.7404605746,
-0.0444346704,
0.6093729138,
0.514939189,
-0.6157147288,
0.1533290744,
0.9293893576,
0.3289809525,
-0.1627835184,
-0.787630856,
0.0009494942,
0.3459154963,
0.6155968308,
0.4347835779,
-0.5724682808,
0.9150099754,
-0.0616366714,
-0.0858208835,
0.1957112402,
0.8999612331,
0.4283419847,
0.3011674881,
0.5753402114,
0.6317442656,
0.7458071113,
0.1451632529,
1.4822605848,
-0.0479407944,
0.4417323768,
1.4101873636,
-0.6919363141,
0.9222854376,
0.8991305828,
-0.3686057627,
0.1882319897,
0.4242502153,
0.0644847378,
0.5808398724,
0.2660218179,
-0.2171958536,
-0.3899135292,
-0.488969624,
0.0182501823,
0.0371043794,
0.1376246661,
-0.3541566432,
-0.3633413613,
0.3250328004,
0.0187580381,
0.4540165067,
-0.5244366527,
0.6873760223,
0.109879002,
-0.5952599049,
0.3083306551,
0.0014944965,
0.34790501,
-0.4570567012,
0.2516001761,
-0.4305660427,
0.3661766946,
0.3493189514,
-0.6318980455,
0.2470196635,
-0.0941230804,
-0.583471179,
-0.5898060799,
0.823954761,
-0.1625778973,
-0.5920442939,
0.4542353153,
0.3997431695,
-0.0062040635,
0.1819807589,
-0.4893366396,
0.4565366805,
-0.029207116,
-0.2163101286,
0.8542985916,
0.156808123,
0.1917026192,
0.6613143086,
0.3524791002,
0.2685531378,
0.3609059751,
0.0682381764,
0.7046666741,
-0.4979383945,
-0.5115353465,
-1.1688126326,
0.1175245717,
-0.2176194787,
-0.0901606381,
0.7660220861,
0.7681657076,
0.8255515695,
-0.0435272679,
0.4448688328,
0.1104390845,
0.5610381961,
-0.6648535132,
0.4257427752,
-0.6204059124,
0.5181118846,
0.1158420071,
-0.598734498,
0.1306266338,
0.3849610984,
-0.3994643092,
-0.1974229515,
0.4188264906,
0.6265856624,
-0.2406709939,
0.0959445089,
0.6038911343,
0.2776582837,
0.3339373469,
0.756226778,
0.5597955585,
-0.3275041282,
0.0779228583,
-0.6126422882,
-0.0270278491,
-0.1316780597,
-1.0442301035,
-0.861900568,
-0.2011921853,
0.0418716408,
-0.0927817747,
0.0866046697,
1.1473894119,
0.5895392895,
-0.7591643929,
-0.7333553433,
-0.0458506756,
0.2193747312,
-0.3238498271,
-0.1544767171,
0.2179391831,
-0.4598677456,
-0.7415844798,
0.5926064849,
0.2334677577,
-0.1847676337,
-0.0788375661,
-0.0256123394,
-0.5709081292,
0.2315677404,
0.5433342457,
0.2711951137,
-0.6616222858,
-0.3618212938,
-0.0353490226,
-0.3073971868,
0.1901192069,
1.0497541428,
-0.6901786327,
0.2166441083,
0.2626251876,
1.1374342442,
0.7497874498,
-0.0935468078,
0.5353182554,
-0.7615107894,
0.1628176272,
0.3246557117,
0.6493884325,
0.1588566154,
-0.2501271367,
0.4015679061,
0.1128951758,
-0.7274618745,
-1.2833224535,
0.2065855414,
-0.7940797806,
-0.3554569483,
1.0775660276,
0.0437361896,
-0.1929400712,
0.5596984029,
0.1097208932,
0.0322345831,
-0.3590215147,
0.3499877155,
0.5221047401,
-0.5957508087,
-0.2559050024,
-0.892619133,
0.4645717144,
0.6440743804,
-0.822774291,
0.2952160835,
0.426564157,
0.150966078,
-0.147576943,
0.8255241513,
0.4504938126,
-0.1338932663,
-0.0171916895,
-0.3511156142,
0.0213688593,
-0.466291517,
-0.413030684,
0.4227996469,
0.2853638828,
-0.0806648284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03344v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03344v2
|
Schroedinger's Threshold: When the AUC doesn't predict Accuracy
| 2024-04-04T10:18:03 | 2024-05-27T10:33:40 |
Juri Opitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Area Under Curve measure (AUC) seems apt to evaluate and compare diverse
models, possibly without calibration. An important example of AUC application
is the evaluation and benchmarking of models that predict faithfulness of
generated text. But we show that the AUC yields an academic and optimistic
notion of accuracy that can misalign with the actual accuracy observed in
application, yielding significant changes in benchmark rankings. To paint a
more realistic picture of downstream model performance (and prepare a model for
actual application), we explore different calibration modes, testing
calibration data and method.
|
[
-0.3915272355,
-0.7271769047,
0.8922072649,
-0.1946711689,
-0.0245730262,
0.0026053421,
0.3794659078,
-0.4848385453,
-0.135750562,
0.4672266245,
-0.4303350151,
-0.2089366168,
-0.6934511065,
0.0319567248,
-0.7800424695,
0.8051893115,
-0.4471285939,
-0.1154865697,
-0.1638790071,
-0.36389938,
-0.4095883369,
-0.2735279202,
-0.5390465856,
-0.4608435631,
0.4605574608,
0.0451480187,
0.6463677883,
0.7997845411,
0.5028049946,
0.196030885,
0.0084934542,
-0.0147325145,
-0.2399721146,
0.1697645336,
0.1670490205,
-0.6962106824,
-0.1971412897,
0.2594082952,
0.862493813,
0.8053495288,
-0.0665476024,
-0.1385844946,
0.2334619313,
0.7727051377,
-0.9997466803,
0.1616230011,
-0.6992851496,
-0.1222427934,
-0.1853824407,
-0.4229296446,
-0.5202150345,
-0.4629038274,
0.1689074039,
-0.3424592316,
0.4163860977,
-0.1370173097,
0.8920325041,
0.5054884553,
-0.8771452904,
-0.3078284562,
-0.9151421785,
0.8900841475,
-0.7375551462,
0.4768967628,
0.6738024354,
0.2675416768,
0.0314999633,
-0.725484252,
-0.2565479279,
-0.3473435938,
0.3150349855,
0.2518829405,
-0.5793494582,
-0.0184840988,
0.4720139503,
0.4606766403,
-0.299963057,
-0.0509116985,
-0.4848117232,
-0.1261797398,
0.5831826329,
0.5517956614,
-0.2066452056,
0.1039671525,
-0.2705762684,
-0.080924958,
-0.520498991,
0.4574721158,
0.5401090384,
0.4169751704,
0.067007035,
0.5541009307,
-0.2074000537,
0.6790893674,
0.0752768889,
0.333130002,
0.1005367711,
0.0802821591,
0.0344745554,
0.2434813976,
0.3330129385,
0.2496681809,
0.0980927795,
0.0150807248,
-0.2923988402,
0.7998740673,
0.7506610155,
-0.5518393517,
-0.2517377436,
0.303244561,
-0.300614506,
-0.3983753622,
0.3672954738,
-0.3217905462,
-0.0044921348,
-0.3984946907,
0.3783869743,
-0.1089940444,
0.1032055616,
-0.1819449216,
-0.161510542,
-0.1030030772,
0.2201094329,
-0.6868676543,
0.2358608246,
0.4656003714,
0.9525458217,
-0.1778742671,
-0.2958077192,
-0.4312492609,
-0.0260848738,
-0.8781350255,
0.9766156673,
-0.5019051433,
-0.5041478872,
-0.0440239124,
-0.053412281,
-0.0860739946,
-0.2658197582,
0.6707242727,
-0.470880121,
-0.3706795573,
-0.1939316988,
-0.6792925,
-0.2675854862,
-0.1800884008,
-0.8030244112,
0.9936301112,
0.3890070915,
-0.7679111362,
0.6487113833,
-0.5748217106,
-0.2506519854,
-0.0136753628,
-0.1142223254,
-0.2055397779,
0.3058225214,
-0.0901483744,
0.1151401773,
0.0624246597,
-0.1142195836,
-0.3781048357,
-0.5692559481,
0.6582807302,
-0.7766614556,
0.7432809472,
0.4274036288,
-0.3168077767,
-0.0325108953,
-0.5109037757,
0.268927753,
-0.3840712905,
-0.2614486516,
-0.4485480189,
0.16767627,
0.1313282847,
0.03745142,
-0.1739073843,
-0.5169819593,
-0.1457899958,
-0.244757086,
0.6649370193,
0.8829224706,
0.0626598969,
0.4069374502,
-0.6380389929,
0.5834615827,
-0.2136026323,
-0.0901033133,
0.1354664713,
-0.625353694,
-0.7217847705,
0.2440497279,
0.6706466675,
0.5642293692,
-0.4574198127,
0.4936810732,
-0.184490934,
-0.9385243058,
-0.3248979747,
-0.0511850938,
0.0253808741,
0.6279122233,
0.1913119107,
-0.8639410138,
-0.0241723824,
-0.6743066907,
-0.696270287,
-0.173035875,
-0.3341985345,
0.3483689427,
0.3753403723,
-0.1979922652,
0.7822983861,
-0.1924158484,
-0.2704671025,
-0.066636838,
0.4647369385,
-0.0465044677,
0.4541523457,
0.2957832217,
-0.6725797653,
-0.283313483,
-0.2867035866,
-0.5527352691,
-0.3052768707,
0.0346721448,
-0.2231280655,
0.2286827862,
0.4202828407,
-0.3277198374,
1.000272274,
0.6907791495,
-0.3301316798,
0.493275553,
-0.3581004143,
0.6764240265,
-0.4192478657,
0.0760880485,
0.5349991918,
-0.0298342369,
-0.5796742439,
-0.0841300562,
0.3859746754,
0.156041503,
-0.2297973037,
0.3075456917,
-0.0964887366,
-0.0790580362,
-0.4459257126,
0.1007846668,
0.0369436517,
-0.0409731492,
-0.1385754943,
0.6170295477,
0.2358248234,
-0.7645204067,
-0.0209186003,
0.1383421123,
-0.5898023844,
0.6473429799,
-0.5474280119,
-0.0798772573,
0.1586959809,
0.4539402127,
-0.7471669912,
-0.2877475619,
-0.1655746847,
-0.5504536033,
0.0770839527,
-0.0958985984,
-0.1776688546,
-0.2314030826,
-0.1236022934,
0.6616519094,
0.5639559627,
-0.141448468,
0.7231068015,
0.3894146383,
0.1100434884,
-0.4563397765,
-1.2328075171,
-0.3002061546,
-0.3747503459,
-0.3591946065,
0.2420400828,
0.0148219448,
-0.2925655246,
-0.2019420713,
-0.2005917877,
-0.0521028936,
0.1727466285,
0.5724583268,
0.2592924833,
-0.1235446632,
0.0137183126,
0.2240742892,
-0.4638189077,
0.2306742221,
0.3107229769,
0.2720587254,
-0.1640271842,
-0.6217579246,
-0.7704396248,
0.2290648669,
0.3693872392,
0.002958565,
0.2156260908,
-0.0436640829,
-0.6622997522,
-0.0689302385,
-0.3136659265,
-0.3462916315,
-0.4040763974,
0.1028157473,
-0.3601168096,
-0.3670241535,
0.7591898441,
-0.0607319847,
0.0600669235,
0.8887402415,
0.1691007018,
-0.0243761744,
1.5858254433,
0.8265820146,
0.3201324642,
0.4751676321,
-0.2991195619,
0.7067996264,
-0.8778429031,
0.2692281902,
-1.0617341995,
-0.157868281,
-0.8195955753,
-0.0848892108,
0.2743265927,
0.383076489,
-0.5817079544,
0.5463519692,
-0.4587029517,
0.2363506258,
0.5406724811,
-0.0273667984,
0.5085127354,
0.048314169,
0.1095224395,
-0.4299448729,
-0.7472447753,
-0.8856287003,
1.1178153753,
0.4213884771,
0.7293673754,
-0.3314598203,
0.2027011812,
0.7307002544,
0.7086885571,
-0.7000156045,
-0.0489331819,
-0.209636718,
-0.9093840122,
-0.2206215113,
-0.644575417,
-0.8359116912,
-0.0168073401,
-0.1089197695,
-1.1576852798,
0.5523387194,
0.2232320905,
-0.5066667795,
0.4875270426,
-0.4582392573,
0.9833179116,
-0.1052518114,
-0.1522799879,
-0.206093207,
-0.1377258003,
0.0439386964,
-0.2525123656,
0.2797134817,
-0.3665651977,
-0.0014595453,
0.7601791024,
-0.3489838839,
0.3777461648,
0.0838550478,
0.0476183444,
0.5964022875,
0.5497058034,
0.319686085,
-0.2102318406,
-0.4182643592,
0.5700414181,
0.2476284504,
-0.5266776085,
-0.4302828908,
0.6357711554,
-0.5575885177,
-0.0319424458,
-0.7018620372,
-0.5204694271,
-0.3630294502,
0.0499024466,
0.5526429415,
0.5990659595,
0.0525439978,
0.0526530556,
0.0042951363,
0.3169566691,
0.2118329257,
0.1357129812,
0.1947189122,
-0.0456531234,
0.624968946,
0.3494359553,
0.2946414948,
-0.1756553352,
-0.0260599125,
-0.3951501548,
-0.4440107644,
-0.671846807,
-0.1727143526,
-0.9603762031,
-0.360384047,
-0.4219574332,
-0.5091521144,
-0.244775638,
-0.5837363005,
-0.3726428747,
-0.0960404575,
-0.0958234891,
-0.1084855869,
0.3350899518,
0.8542681932,
-0.1380423009,
0.4209105372,
-0.8107734323,
-0.1079773232,
-0.0274123419,
0.3237800896,
0.1103008017,
-0.7282854915,
-0.122640729,
0.436865449,
-0.7563221455,
-0.6485553384,
0.3491725624,
0.0407103412,
0.6945648193,
0.4651497304,
0.3373148143,
0.5479790568,
-0.1868061125,
0.6455671191,
0.1271565408,
-1.3697158098,
0.7296412587,
-0.025747221,
0.2861973643,
0.7083774209,
0.548915267,
-0.3278942406,
-0.7723101974,
-0.8427587152,
-1.0246704817,
0.3822926581,
0.3992315531,
0.2011447251,
0.2784770429,
0.4436330497,
0.1463962048,
0.0833066627,
-0.7208417654,
-0.1980464458,
-0.0670746937,
-0.2433192432,
-0.2025012374,
0.0434049405,
-0.089603059,
0.0513718873,
0.7308290005,
-0.2999694347,
0.0843245238,
0.3219794035,
0.2032555193,
-0.8025701642,
-0.0247745421,
0.1339985132,
1.0763932467,
-0.2519664466,
0.1167414412,
0.2917132676,
-0.487606585,
-0.0102521339,
0.0963827521,
-0.4931255877,
-0.1725147516,
0.6684134603,
0.5886988044,
0.0550619438,
-0.6170434356,
0.2999377847,
-0.1572476476,
-0.2576644421,
-0.1803949624,
0.3995501697,
-0.5155829191,
0.1435939372,
0.7493638396,
0.5227513909,
0.4166901708,
-0.5076439977,
0.2695229948,
0.3217802346,
-1.0193734169,
0.2203252316,
0.9337905645,
-0.1316646636,
-0.3132808208,
0.7719897032,
0.3030227721,
-0.5916894674,
0.8213427067,
0.0627888441,
0.6358292699,
-0.1753212959,
-0.0619653836,
0.4997310042,
0.3673652112,
-0.1028068438,
-0.1335400939,
-0.0073254425,
-0.6045743227,
-0.3145859838,
-0.334431529,
-0.2924705446,
-0.0959751904,
-0.9394571781,
0.0736588985,
-0.278647393,
-0.6751699448,
0.3417032063,
0.1777265221,
-0.5032067299,
0.4106217921,
-0.2496008724,
0.8583506942,
-1.2658470869,
0.6185370088,
0.1247662678,
-0.2717826366,
-1.0847365856,
0.0776498914,
-0.1895871609,
-0.3452547193,
0.0262970813,
0.5373411179,
-0.1579644829,
-0.0950450823,
-0.4746641517,
-0.6876408458,
1.0589652061,
0.0998740494,
-0.3206884563,
0.2817490101,
0.0773039833,
0.6119778156,
-0.5250333548,
0.4296167493,
0.6986989379,
0.3514608443,
-0.2336773425,
-0.9153180718,
0.00713972,
-0.09429425,
0.2622901797,
0.2058359683,
-0.4044212401,
1.0568519831,
-0.060139861,
-0.3363719881,
0.298737675,
0.3167719841,
0.4124315679,
0.6094364524,
0.7741715312,
0.5412721038,
0.3795836866,
-0.5962195992,
1.2899361849,
-0.2171037197,
0.5717102885,
0.6206232309,
-0.4541896582,
1.065623641,
0.4231772721,
-0.3489122689,
0.5509443879,
0.9711254835,
-0.0404611863,
0.6313703656,
0.0725592449,
-0.187307179,
-0.5028156638,
-0.1343545765,
-0.4285110831,
0.4087397456,
0.3116028905,
-0.4027958214,
-0.0786672011,
-0.3387955725,
-0.6080710292,
0.2497526705,
-0.4364812076,
0.3465086222,
0.3634389639,
-0.5938509107,
0.330360949,
0.0547404699,
0.3397654593,
-0.4756309092,
-0.1534759998,
-0.107005477,
0.4178282022,
-0.2722371221,
-0.822024405,
0.3321029544,
-0.0497492924,
0.0324366093,
0.043728482,
0.606654346,
0.0534923971,
-0.6602567434,
0.3987062871,
0.3765732348,
0.324786514,
-0.0377497859,
-0.6668508053,
0.0850825161,
-0.0797184184,
-0.1768922061,
-0.0219003707,
0.2801035345,
-0.1304215789,
0.7680815458,
0.6813045144,
0.1853252649,
-0.1742480397,
-0.0005124348,
0.2399490029,
-0.4141338766,
-0.7645295858,
-0.3656105399,
0.6245144606,
0.0568870492,
-0.6479609609,
0.6766855121,
0.509962678,
1.098777771,
0.2334287167,
0.6905654073,
0.1584714949,
0.4889507294,
-0.4619634449,
0.7668140531,
-0.7229225039,
0.1515458673,
-0.4403630495,
-1.1353865862,
-0.2322508097,
1.1168835163,
-0.5173906684,
0.620115459,
0.6726118922,
0.5440397859,
-0.20681113,
0.4762073457,
0.2992538214,
0.034538608,
0.0754097179,
0.5396194458,
1.0206967592,
-0.9481151104,
0.2762098312,
-0.5944904089,
-0.3905934095,
-0.2109115571,
-0.7665765285,
-0.428434521,
-0.7447832227,
-0.3945534825,
-0.8066709042,
-0.1725087613,
0.1362861842,
0.781904757,
-0.9741435647,
-0.1459855735,
-0.4956139624,
-0.1462145895,
-0.3944014609,
-0.2481018007,
0.3043487072,
0.1386180073,
-0.6904982924,
0.1035461947,
0.035729982,
0.3354387283,
-0.2439863235,
-0.0064523499,
0.2289981842,
0.3029853404,
-0.0668640435,
0.2000682354,
-0.7154430747,
-0.3952538371,
-0.3259543777,
-0.282369256,
0.1316166669,
1.0909682512,
-0.7341021895,
0.1972326487,
0.1817497015,
0.507393539,
0.473087579,
0.072771728,
0.5393422842,
0.0271274745,
-0.033301618,
0.4216420949,
0.3498618007,
0.1884431541,
-0.4496508539,
0.4603832364,
-0.0395925306,
-0.9126196504,
-1.112913847,
0.2588404119,
-0.987441361,
-0.2567159235,
0.5380032063,
-0.1594651192,
-0.2421572059,
-0.2499617487,
0.1010150537,
0.352042675,
-0.48000893,
1.0514541864,
0.7758687735,
-0.3878008127,
0.2348947227,
-1.0477505922,
0.3533424437,
0.4721735716,
-0.4543602765,
0.2100121081,
0.4320610166,
0.2189844847,
0.2445917875,
0.4099362791,
0.0706421584,
0.367297858,
0.6594491601,
-0.4614336193,
0.5181752443,
-0.1149209738,
-0.4468128681,
-0.0400996655,
0.353235662,
0.2520745993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15320v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15320v2
|
Using Large Language Models to Enrich the Documentation of Datasets for Machine Learning
| 2024-04-04T10:09:28 | 2024-05-24T11:25:49 |
Joan Giner-Miguelez, Abel Gómez, Jordi Cabot
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.4.4
|
Recent regulatory initiatives like the European AI Act and relevant voices in
the Machine Learning (ML) community stress the need to describe datasets along
several key dimensions for trustworthy AI, such as the provenance processes and
social concerns. However, this information is typically presented as
unstructured text in accompanying documentation, hampering their automated
analysis and processing. In this work, we explore using large language models
(LLM) and a set of prompting strategies to automatically extract these
dimensions from documents and enrich the dataset description with them. Our
approach could aid data publishers and practitioners in creating
machine-readable documentation to improve the discoverability of their
datasets, assess their compliance with current AI regulations, and improve the
overall quality of ML models trained on them.
In this paper, we evaluate the approach on 12 scientific dataset papers
published in two scientific journals (Nature's Scientific Data and Elsevier's
Data in Brief) using two different LLMs (GPT3.5 and Flan-UL2). Results show
good accuracy with our prompt extraction strategies. Concrete results vary
depending on the dimensions, but overall, GPT3.5 shows slightly better accuracy
(81,21%) than FLAN-UL2 (69,13%) although it is more prone to hallucinations. We
have released an open-source tool implementing our approach and a replication
package, including the experiments' code and results, in an open-source
repository.
|
[
-0.2288247794,
-0.5961937308,
0.6136543155,
0.075401105,
-0.1192525253,
-0.1572014689,
-0.4805455208,
-0.4688777924,
-0.0491489097,
0.6530996561,
-0.2404336631,
-0.6751044989,
-0.653159678,
0.3816884756,
-0.4028619528,
0.9621738791,
-0.3163543344,
0.1428095698,
-0.5414205194,
-0.1000847444,
-0.1385702044,
-0.3870954812,
-0.2612610459,
-0.4651925266,
0.6792868972,
0.1246768683,
0.4840445518,
0.9400038123,
0.510121882,
0.2700147927,
-0.0670208856,
0.516533196,
-0.2110563517,
0.2912963033,
-0.157777369,
-0.3481391668,
-0.3347002268,
0.0963429511,
0.6844569445,
0.652618885,
0.1305190772,
0.1616233587,
0.2762210369,
0.564994812,
-0.2966765165,
0.7947029471,
-0.3962893188,
-0.0343022943,
0.0583531335,
-0.3130145967,
-0.600476563,
-0.0935257822,
0.1403504908,
-0.8150792718,
0.3249778152,
-0.0840760842,
0.7088286877,
0.4381757081,
-0.2044368386,
-0.4089879692,
-0.6866490245,
0.6859760284,
-0.6766281724,
0.1711525619,
0.5074110031,
0.2260048985,
-0.1915705055,
-0.7404435277,
-0.5087873936,
-0.5009635091,
-0.3811783195,
-0.0705105513,
-0.1384360492,
-0.0624913052,
0.6420278549,
0.1314895153,
-0.5709943771,
0.5388461947,
-0.4845743477,
-0.1766497195,
0.7462283969,
0.0122098289,
0.0328444839,
-0.1033523083,
0.1773566157,
-0.3472335935,
-0.7648231387,
-0.128260538,
0.4125178158,
0.5571718812,
0.015732225,
0.6853937507,
-0.0351283848,
0.6406610608,
-0.2824245691,
-0.031419076,
0.3385353088,
-0.2760199606,
-0.1699883789,
-0.055486843,
0.7712782025,
0.1236682832,
0.2116400301,
-0.0960625783,
-0.1872028857,
-0.2601035833,
0.2272460759,
-0.8568772078,
-0.3448501825,
0.3516894877,
-0.6909250617,
-0.2722139657,
0.2509050667,
-0.7792246938,
-0.7551572323,
-0.8655769229,
0.2287374139,
-0.3002840281,
-0.0125906197,
-0.1570931673,
-0.0491745472,
0.1419183016,
0.5114033222,
-0.6908428669,
-0.1734115481,
0.8797389269,
0.8065322042,
-0.0596839041,
-0.2644287348,
-0.5296353102,
0.0756530017,
-0.2153046876,
0.6012686491,
-0.6338677406,
-0.4180024564,
0.0062231761,
0.2811063826,
0.1404561847,
-0.3356215954,
0.5011023283,
-0.3698291481,
0.4139570892,
-0.2809257209,
-0.6365328431,
-0.4022165835,
0.2154262513,
-0.8646038771,
0.8199453354,
0.1227840707,
-0.7192516327,
0.4876412451,
-0.9659563303,
-0.4030307233,
0.1404226571,
-0.3000437319,
-0.4888087809,
-0.0169113036,
0.6492792368,
0.7377612591,
-0.3086393774,
0.3782922328,
-0.3593641818,
-0.1726703644,
0.2356886119,
-0.5279504657,
0.8885771036,
0.1437434107,
-0.1561043859,
0.2870119512,
-0.7354900241,
-0.0978029966,
0.0118748955,
-0.2922008336,
-0.1782581508,
-0.0810981393,
-0.061855074,
0.1046403795,
0.1128249168,
-0.2730731666,
0.484111011,
-0.184654355,
0.6037386656,
0.6866562963,
-0.0189641919,
0.2713471055,
-0.3109950423,
0.4247714579,
0.0255549364,
0.129243657,
-0.676348865,
-0.3783529997,
-0.6272183657,
-0.5115559697,
0.4758771658,
0.4073995054,
-0.6894494295,
0.8195232153,
-0.4442752004,
-0.5314631462,
-0.8029860854,
0.2869918644,
0.2373259068,
0.6452826858,
0.384572506,
0.2240221798,
-0.6212043166,
-0.6925227046,
0.0857113823,
-0.1951593757,
-0.3664268255,
0.4133719206,
0.842212975,
-0.4129029214,
0.7792448401,
-0.1622172147,
-0.1285981983,
-0.0990954936,
0.3562310934,
0.208775118,
0.3675774932,
0.2849296331,
-0.7320440412,
-0.3905106485,
0.1021459177,
-1.1452276707,
-0.0543052778,
-0.2348237485,
0.1794402152,
0.4133723676,
0.4436951578,
-0.6246863008,
0.2577547729,
0.1068263799,
-0.0703854859,
0.4593012333,
-0.4250944555,
0.0874946862,
-1.0644756556,
0.5094667673,
0.1474897265,
-0.0703236461,
-0.4723293781,
0.1008086428,
0.1367054582,
-0.0448640473,
-0.1791279912,
0.5117086768,
-0.4782866836,
-0.0644961074,
-0.0897359028,
0.0456263945,
0.2018536478,
0.074085407,
0.1193157136,
0.6191800833,
0.7344764471,
-0.5867815018,
0.4696523547,
0.4294218421,
-0.3421513438,
0.4362596869,
-0.6283559203,
0.1700593382,
-0.4260779917,
0.6855900884,
-0.3799542487,
-0.4652702212,
0.2022881508,
-0.3814069331,
0.4808582962,
-0.2378005981,
-0.9067319036,
-0.5311790109,
-0.1923742592,
-0.2622914016,
0.4719434977,
-0.6897020936,
0.6437774897,
0.2075441331,
-0.0894360244,
-0.4304279983,
-0.4787977338,
0.2518579662,
-0.3450463712,
-0.5866243839,
0.0702559426,
-0.0357956402,
-0.3472980261,
-0.1181145534,
0.2773397565,
0.1813391298,
0.1801262796,
0.3854075968,
0.3739130497,
-0.2532525659,
0.3709007204,
-0.1593237072,
-0.1365907639,
0.206092909,
-0.5421932936,
0.2856339216,
-0.0121395094,
-0.3024922311,
-0.5594665408,
0.324226737,
0.5693595409,
-0.2568838,
0.7632582188,
0.7523934841,
-0.3955614269,
-0.3606496453,
-0.2484023273,
-0.3520441353,
-0.4438262582,
0.105366163,
-0.1253184378,
-0.7185493708,
0.4446493387,
0.0015989243,
0.2573705912,
0.5601668358,
0.5140317082,
-0.3039219379,
1.0085860491,
0.6792575121,
-0.2558989525,
0.2328487337,
-0.3681657016,
0.2249818295,
-0.5739196539,
-0.5358968973,
-0.845635891,
-0.1810083091,
-0.5044397116,
-0.4564906657,
0.2625798583,
-0.1116601378,
-0.1762904823,
0.0818048418,
-0.4866783917,
0.5108919144,
0.5575789213,
0.0604782104,
0.2404201627,
0.2306049913,
0.0761688128,
0.1358792186,
-0.5015310049,
-0.8736389875,
1.2368311882,
0.6510081887,
0.6622734666,
-0.4102500379,
0.5984638333,
0.3525165021,
0.3890276849,
-0.6949234009,
0.3130681217,
-0.1665810496,
-0.2328671962,
-0.3599703312,
-0.5837177634,
-0.9220086932,
-0.1185724661,
-0.1193012074,
-0.6283462048,
0.1535750031,
0.0881639868,
-0.0841307491,
0.164879337,
-0.3677394688,
0.5379601121,
-0.3536832631,
-0.1104630977,
-0.0177144818,
-0.6837139726,
0.1172305048,
-0.2513927519,
0.2001971006,
0.1630326509,
0.1095537096,
0.6803961992,
-0.3672046363,
0.8007411361,
-0.2590507269,
-0.3841495216,
0.1881922781,
-0.1569922417,
0.855030477,
-0.0066209822,
-0.3099669814,
0.2537728548,
-0.0569098219,
-0.2249370217,
-0.7880398631,
0.5400663614,
-0.6019904017,
-0.3304251134,
-0.0795921311,
-0.7422363162,
-0.1322970986,
0.1277598292,
0.1549908668,
0.3142878711,
0.0001447553,
0.4906868637,
0.9634669423,
-0.315907836,
0.159346506,
0.6515781879,
-0.1148523465,
-0.1142263263,
0.8995268345,
0.1039796621,
-0.1488932818,
0.3567425311,
0.249644056,
-0.4408699274,
-0.4582154751,
-0.2955799699,
0.2818393409,
-0.8218574524,
-0.2181617916,
-0.8179610968,
-0.2287872583,
-0.6196422577,
-0.0366846956,
0.2408455312,
-0.430193454,
-0.6666523218,
-0.2910455465,
0.5731565356,
0.7350507975,
-0.0739153698,
0.0886401609,
-0.8055077791,
0.1276915222,
-0.148917228,
0.1075955108,
-0.0860479772,
-0.5492759943,
-0.2708581984,
0.1469848305,
0.0944190398,
-0.4449177682,
0.39605546,
0.0960382223,
0.7108860612,
0.4647515118,
-0.0698154494,
0.379229784,
-0.2863973081,
0.7580175996,
-0.1027676687,
-0.5519249439,
0.7459744215,
-0.485604614,
-0.0513860732,
0.4827874005,
0.6163047552,
-0.2326275557,
-0.3268097937,
-0.5470448136,
-0.73379457,
0.4874874651,
0.0282072499,
0.0719265267,
0.3346691132,
0.3987022638,
0.4041055739,
0.2106942832,
-0.3657177985,
-0.0930076987,
-0.1895069629,
-0.4620508552,
-0.2908004522,
-0.0701302066,
-0.4773531556,
-0.1333102137,
0.7426130176,
-0.3076195717,
0.0649934337,
-0.0926198885,
-0.2045838386,
0.1744433939,
0.1269413084,
0.2864119411,
0.7415497303,
0.0010038656,
0.1316923797,
-0.1567864567,
-0.3160691559,
-0.1066506058,
0.4309539795,
-0.4319793284,
0.0173515603,
0.6624279022,
0.6472116709,
-0.3252241611,
-0.6821745634,
0.2090425938,
0.0100716501,
-0.407938391,
-0.0536918715,
0.141437158,
-0.1039289311,
0.2538807392,
0.2450061589,
-0.3198731542,
0.050801564,
-0.3275106847,
0.2421878874,
0.2638841271,
-0.1501417309,
-0.0294420905,
0.3098442554,
0.0668391362,
-0.1239436045,
0.7525146604,
-0.1179729179,
-0.3601828814,
0.651221931,
0.3873257041,
0.6263574362,
0.1130345389,
0.4803836942,
0.3486474752,
0.3072148263,
-0.3619205356,
0.1679767519,
-0.1382585019,
-0.2883635163,
-0.3846904039,
-0.5977419615,
-0.3925842643,
0.3199867904,
-0.6202002168,
0.2491824627,
-0.3134281337,
0.1879649311,
0.2017064244,
0.2563509941,
-0.7653965354,
-0.0622642227,
0.1908751875,
0.9737392068,
-1.0019606352,
0.7683364153,
0.408216387,
-0.5943548679,
-0.730946064,
-0.1856821924,
0.0906699449,
-0.5695326328,
0.5877327323,
0.2268773615,
0.388928622,
-0.19059439,
-0.8848034143,
-0.6754783988,
1.1546646357,
0.2773315012,
-0.5815550685,
0.022783028,
0.1142916456,
0.7884631157,
-0.4322917759,
0.0830445439,
0.5669541359,
0.9592236876,
0.0472225435,
-0.612403512,
0.1452364624,
-0.4330587089,
-0.1539728791,
-0.1636237055,
-0.1919507682,
0.5325942636,
-0.1534642875,
0.0023852803,
-0.0565427877,
0.6952602863,
0.2330106497,
0.2575042844,
0.2165599465,
0.2997736335,
1.4322383404,
0.0132147186,
0.9503288269,
-0.1775985062,
0.095295541,
1.1684393883,
-0.3740904927,
0.6478596926,
0.3325052857,
-0.0581629127,
0.4129019678,
0.7803221941,
-0.7598595619,
0.1223087981,
0.2966450453,
0.0219570938,
0.0078573572,
-0.2851565778,
-0.3232416511,
0.3710329235,
0.6081028581,
-0.8321028352,
-0.2008429319,
0.2870945036,
0.1188202053,
-0.0231763944,
-0.3171873689,
0.703638792,
0.039462585,
-0.6493484974,
0.3313041627,
-0.047993131,
0.2585202157,
-0.3806487918,
-0.204672575,
-0.2163413167,
0.0061968877,
-0.3091819882,
-0.8748201728,
0.1644634902,
0.3563511372,
-0.3755907118,
-0.4520032108,
0.5569506884,
-0.3921659589,
-0.7300625443,
0.0993481129,
0.2898640037,
0.4491378963,
0.0800761059,
-0.7819701433,
-0.0338196047,
-0.072294347,
-0.1888003349,
0.2509346008,
0.5349235535,
-0.1808342487,
0.7079423666,
0.8213378191,
0.1681877822,
-0.3246823847,
0.3016853929,
0.8623213768,
-0.1823886335,
-0.365837425,
-0.7700708508,
0.4079588354,
-0.283959657,
0.0761328414,
0.7751860619,
0.4651077986,
0.6012793183,
0.0849227607,
1.1114372015,
0.0361048058,
0.4575842619,
-0.7478324771,
0.9388170242,
-0.2687360048,
0.4423869848,
0.1303680092,
-0.88910079,
-0.4439333975,
0.4886051118,
-0.1672788411,
0.1182600483,
0.502720356,
0.8777353168,
0.0354182199,
-0.0158010777,
-0.0241989344,
0.405338645,
0.6567463279,
0.0762162134,
0.5713438988,
0.0455282629,
0.3875489235,
-0.0979404449,
-0.2093346417,
-0.2235223651,
-1.1366069317,
-1.0329518318,
-0.6394484639,
-0.3636716306,
-0.5190125704,
-0.0233097449,
0.8053141832,
0.5542401075,
-0.7898332477,
0.1980485767,
0.0380103886,
0.031474933,
-0.0594112277,
-0.1652064025,
0.6707291007,
-0.3707672656,
-0.4932364225,
0.4552206397,
0.1262711287,
0.1883446723,
-0.6927811503,
-0.0909748524,
0.2330480963,
-0.1344730854,
0.4057825804,
0.3584827781,
-0.5754083395,
-0.0346143655,
-0.1172217503,
-0.0974644125,
-0.0603949055,
0.803628087,
-0.7887988687,
0.4694055915,
0.4566482902,
0.6539747715,
0.3293645382,
-0.104167223,
0.6411244273,
-0.6086723804,
-0.0613494329,
0.2672797441,
0.3632254899,
0.5694028735,
-0.5999221206,
0.5861081481,
-0.0151841147,
-0.5822972655,
-0.9697449803,
-0.1568119228,
-0.7341790199,
-0.4263863564,
1.2053627968,
-0.4239893258,
-0.2793520391,
-0.0507666022,
-0.0182057153,
0.2553232312,
-0.1891673803,
0.9652791619,
0.6877625585,
0.1407630295,
0.0348022841,
-0.7177966833,
0.4972991347,
-0.2192914635,
-1.0964169502,
0.4655540884,
0.5588687658,
0.0073828646,
0.1176128834,
0.0834743306,
-0.2300958335,
0.0224704202,
-0.0991419107,
-0.1604370177,
-0.5735708475,
-0.6017917395,
-0.6220369935,
-0.0687469691,
-0.1904729009,
0.3187974691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03324v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03324v1
|
A Comparative Analysis of Word-Level Metric Differential Privacy: Benchmarking The Privacy-Utility Trade-off
| 2024-04-04T09:48:14 | 2024-04-04T09:48:14 |
Stephen Meisenbacher, Nihildev Nandakumar, Alexandra Klymenko, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The application of Differential Privacy to Natural Language Processing
techniques has emerged in relevance in recent years, with an increasing number
of studies published in established NLP outlets. In particular, the adaptation
of Differential Privacy for use in NLP tasks has first focused on the
$\textit{word-level}$, where calibrated noise is added to word embedding
vectors to achieve "noisy" representations. To this end, several
implementations have appeared in the literature, each presenting an alternative
method of achieving word-level Differential Privacy. Although each of these
includes its own evaluation, no comparative analysis has been performed to
investigate the performance of such methods relative to each other. In this
work, we conduct such an analysis, comparing seven different algorithms on two
NLP tasks with varying hyperparameters, including the $\textit{epsilon
($\varepsilon$)}$ parameter, or privacy budget. In addition, we provide an
in-depth analysis of the results with a focus on the privacy-utility trade-off,
as well as open-source our implementation code for further reproduction. As a
result of our analysis, we give insight into the benefits and challenges of
word-level Differential Privacy, and accordingly, we suggest concrete steps
forward for the research field.
|
[
-0.5206232071,
-0.4119863808,
0.3862264454,
0.1513295621,
-0.2104261965,
0.1193285882,
-0.0971166417,
-0.7012431622,
0.1052028909,
0.3154093921,
-0.4107198417,
-0.7505699396,
-0.8195787072,
0.0800048858,
-0.5525083542,
0.6901646256,
0.2339434326,
-0.0164546464,
0.0515610687,
-0.1105202585,
-0.0852152035,
-0.5689817667,
-0.4892975688,
0.2036477029,
0.5025099516,
-0.2568296492,
0.7782689333,
0.6115965247,
0.6713944077,
0.349214524,
-0.4247963428,
-0.0732686445,
-0.3948397636,
-0.0324156955,
-0.251218915,
-0.1961931586,
-0.6083519459,
0.2471798956,
0.6980465651,
0.6177323461,
0.1474145651,
0.4032160044,
0.2495170087,
0.7903735638,
-1.2505459785,
0.1203092784,
-0.4830288589,
0.4627897739,
-0.210149765,
-0.1548588425,
-0.1050263271,
-0.7052194476,
0.219751358,
-0.2260871679,
0.213426888,
-0.0682110339,
0.6373068094,
0.434525907,
-0.0212906748,
-0.1706043333,
-0.7321902514,
0.8816487789,
-0.9082429409,
0.6597432494,
0.4969629049,
-0.0275236536,
0.1123486832,
-0.4653980136,
-0.2704508007,
-0.5044071078,
-0.0711508989,
0.1413695216,
-0.5695468187,
0.0096571017,
0.5281033516,
0.6686932445,
-0.3710137606,
0.4999953806,
-0.1373710483,
-0.2138383836,
0.5814944506,
0.1263509691,
-0.0315019786,
0.0368378609,
-0.1167920753,
-0.0887000337,
-0.3459030986,
0.1200224832,
0.8817672133,
-0.1006362438,
-0.1467113048,
0.4843371511,
-0.5055593848,
0.5514652133,
-0.1388379782,
-0.0441694781,
0.2603124976,
-0.0479474999,
-0.0369824395,
-0.128917709,
0.7680758834,
0.6154087782,
0.0032873964,
-0.6337708831,
-0.1774903387,
0.2461579293,
0.2053715587,
-0.4583827257,
0.0028833023,
0.1751481295,
-0.5157834291,
-0.4867978394,
-0.07323201,
-1.1232397556,
-0.5418671966,
-0.2815627754,
0.4521371722,
-0.1243315041,
-0.2054814845,
0.3634550571,
-0.4618914723,
0.2051121742,
-0.0648060814,
-0.7840245366,
0.9675812125,
1.039331913,
1.0713838339,
-0.4190348983,
-0.1952370554,
-0.5370699763,
-0.011495363,
-0.2338129729,
0.2586097121,
-0.5713866353,
-0.4465025961,
0.038465932,
-0.3806703985,
0.0961326435,
-0.4673326612,
0.5607067943,
-0.3965581059,
0.4614607096,
-0.373966217,
-0.5619676113,
-0.0809332728,
0.1090530306,
-0.5912606716,
0.9242824316,
-0.0363063999,
-1.2703692913,
0.5474702716,
-0.7673806548,
-0.0501554422,
0.0186054427,
0.0731158853,
-0.2986375093,
0.2698712349,
0.0880931318,
0.5842125416,
-0.1940575093,
-0.2972098887,
-0.312202841,
-0.5975906253,
0.4147953987,
-0.4289301038,
0.7484616041,
0.1504161805,
-0.6831979752,
-0.374180764,
-1.2053797245,
-0.0914061368,
-0.0305633545,
-0.035166204,
-0.7581865191,
0.0095110703,
-0.480897516,
-0.0893271938,
0.6356406808,
-0.840826273,
-0.5087944865,
-0.5759105682,
0.2892409861,
0.7300115824,
-0.2488387227,
0.6068445444,
-0.2130072862,
0.5236880779,
-0.1984235048,
0.4865684509,
0.5634055734,
-0.4702847302,
-0.3305310011,
-0.3764155209,
0.6382360458,
0.4741497636,
0.0589678288,
0.6071123481,
-0.0830225572,
-0.4278416038,
-0.4762851298,
-0.1561497599,
0.5063418746,
0.3546333313,
0.2983500659,
-0.6750594974,
0.1282338798,
-0.8267266154,
-0.6344010234,
0.0180325862,
-0.0662986785,
0.386275202,
0.0139064686,
0.0050303577,
0.7595338225,
-0.5772022009,
-0.2798863053,
0.1616306752,
-0.0336825661,
-0.0921046808,
0.2847176492,
0.7194244266,
-0.4639582932,
-0.372682333,
-0.2570397258,
-0.4458348155,
-0.3703554571,
0.3513401747,
-0.149925366,
0.1467686445,
0.2134889364,
-0.3228105009,
0.6586871743,
0.9732068777,
-0.2393127084,
0.3884972036,
-0.4905620217,
0.0470179468,
-0.807723701,
0.0415422358,
0.2179248631,
-0.2461128086,
-0.6639361978,
0.2072566003,
0.1757982224,
-0.0134015772,
-0.5496159196,
0.1956586242,
-0.478661418,
-0.4080300331,
-0.2092524022,
0.1402058899,
-0.0972973034,
0.4035221934,
-0.1516849399,
0.8480312228,
0.6636050344,
-0.723711133,
0.1874556392,
-0.0087740291,
-0.1075717136,
0.2779830098,
-0.5749299526,
0.3914057016,
0.093844004,
-0.1917618215,
-0.8242543936,
0.3353743255,
0.4832434058,
-0.3404483199,
0.1660505086,
0.034735281,
-0.7007802129,
-0.1029895395,
-0.9568115473,
0.1393187642,
0.7413079143,
-0.4981259406,
-0.0421127826,
0.6655675173,
-0.190640375,
-0.8468370438,
-0.7639123201,
0.3046811223,
-0.5012868643,
-0.2076868266,
0.4562358856,
0.2133337408,
-0.55388695,
0.32091254,
-0.2508352697,
-0.2129360139,
0.135489732,
0.0507446788,
0.0005503443,
0.1158260182,
-0.3301303089,
0.2600407302,
-0.5229346156,
0.352542758,
-0.094343476,
0.4486182928,
-0.0545131788,
-0.1341267377,
-0.6349586844,
0.3465751112,
0.1302332282,
-0.2691448331,
0.7733018994,
0.4599603415,
-0.2814739347,
-0.027119102,
-0.6461052299,
0.0580262691,
-0.5010842085,
-0.0379421785,
-0.1271132529,
-0.7378488183,
0.4553802013,
-0.1004436016,
0.4339616597,
0.2686065137,
0.451970607,
0.2722589076,
0.9373905063,
0.7307760715,
-0.3505040109,
0.3971849084,
-0.1047818065,
0.4055726528,
-0.8065007925,
0.2291692793,
-0.728592813,
-0.5088319778,
-1.1332008839,
-0.2080823928,
0.1828263849,
-0.3386220634,
0.043508023,
0.6074125767,
-0.7398319244,
0.4040637612,
0.5420945287,
-0.0342800245,
0.6554366946,
-0.0673535615,
0.1052090079,
-0.1353626251,
-0.363108784,
-0.6431921124,
1.0074849129,
0.4133625925,
0.7591019869,
0.1551304609,
1.1241966486,
0.1833791733,
-0.1331272721,
-0.4560398161,
0.8012855053,
-0.7132766247,
-0.2875510752,
-0.4337138236,
-0.7174834609,
-1.0090987682,
0.4719516337,
-0.1286046654,
-1.2955112457,
0.2679569423,
-0.1379851699,
-0.2251734436,
0.332960844,
-0.7435986996,
0.4458962083,
0.1530603468,
-0.4552729726,
-0.2565389574,
-0.5433670878,
0.2432412803,
-0.1654480696,
0.1986117363,
-0.3892053962,
-0.3508791625,
0.8874623179,
-0.057830587,
0.6191954017,
-0.4387266338,
-0.2631405294,
-0.390470624,
0.1123460904,
0.0770300552,
0.2704668045,
-0.1210980266,
0.5555170774,
0.4121365249,
-0.0918828174,
-0.2483414561,
1.0262631178,
-0.6872740984,
-0.5335041881,
-0.5628051162,
-0.5986065269,
-0.4043848515,
0.1611975729,
0.2528877556,
0.3803091347,
-0.2495069951,
0.1763619035,
0.7404707074,
-0.520570457,
0.5645920038,
0.4756061435,
0.0402206108,
0.0195307788,
0.6228652,
0.3343454599,
0.0915133804,
0.6258836985,
0.6306559443,
-0.653908968,
-0.5157179832,
-0.0751858354,
0.161806345,
-0.3932559788,
0.0481565855,
-0.8662959933,
-0.3036314845,
-0.3651103675,
-0.0010622175,
-0.5739305019,
-0.4764521718,
-0.0772507042,
0.0929114819,
0.3335782588,
0.4623245895,
-0.4850630462,
-0.1361285001,
-0.5742534399,
0.7121437788,
0.1515909433,
0.6696437001,
-0.111941725,
-0.2750610709,
0.1325765401,
-0.043461144,
-0.0994599387,
-0.8616387844,
0.203429088,
0.0154639985,
0.4600688219,
0.1706332564,
0.3796374798,
0.4341179729,
-0.4582234025,
0.8382117748,
0.1556111276,
-1.1245770454,
0.1562061757,
0.0385190547,
0.1514593661,
0.656712532,
0.2586799562,
-0.3071838915,
-0.862842381,
-0.7470287085,
-0.9387829304,
0.4473342896,
0.4623393416,
0.4095119834,
0.3666564226,
0.3257746696,
0.5376087427,
0.2916699052,
-0.4563431442,
-0.3604345918,
0.189111203,
0.1621661484,
-0.1485604346,
-0.1424622536,
-0.3619685173,
-0.2573231757,
0.1498912424,
0.3118387759,
0.3530312479,
-0.0078533012,
0.1892345101,
0.3416400254,
0.413503468,
0.2502677739,
0.7672937512,
-0.3840509951,
0.0949320793,
0.3372466564,
-0.770365119,
0.0143678281,
0.3338820636,
-0.4127241373,
0.415247649,
-0.0351301208,
0.4328026175,
0.1213143244,
-0.1948548704,
0.7027113438,
-0.3869481981,
-0.566811502,
-0.1008550748,
0.2787849307,
-0.0802976787,
0.0947976708,
-0.2570605278,
-0.1711282134,
0.6265742183,
-0.1396377385,
-0.0994078219,
0.4524073601,
-0.2442716509,
-0.225303635,
0.7651306987,
0.0154158147,
-0.5243648887,
-0.0517208688,
-0.3502382636,
-0.0191048216,
0.2104065716,
0.1577445269,
1.2245256901,
0.2235444337,
0.3116358519,
-0.1618005931,
0.2053542286,
0.0335796103,
0.3364767134,
-0.3362385631,
-0.4760476053,
-0.3467477262,
-0.5317804217,
-0.7597869635,
0.2110421956,
-1.0515152216,
-0.2349070013,
-0.5962518454,
-0.3209609687,
0.0849221423,
0.2676468194,
-0.8503520489,
-0.0424563028,
-0.0075982404,
0.8156198263,
-0.3924851716,
0.3961298764,
0.4732797444,
0.2955865562,
-0.3142813742,
0.5516383648,
0.0804699957,
-0.6184681654,
0.2863832712,
0.067262724,
-0.60759902,
-0.1405748576,
-0.132199645,
-0.6117867827,
0.8862269521,
0.4573839307,
-0.8747904301,
0.2966603041,
0.454728812,
0.8356209397,
0.3817192912,
-0.1698490977,
0.6935978532,
0.2970243692,
-0.4232223928,
-0.9784206152,
0.1557714492,
0.2704564035,
0.0848036557,
0.2709480822,
-0.679120481,
0.4651481509,
0.4030060768,
-0.3273683786,
-0.058595296,
0.2558749616,
-0.0875014365,
0.5005260706,
0.7236037254,
0.6485116482,
0.5862471461,
0.159873575,
0.8848273158,
-0.6095632315,
0.4025328755,
0.7582783103,
-0.502548337,
0.7457540631,
0.4235426188,
-0.5497761369,
0.0207800977,
0.1932239383,
0.1933394223,
0.8402870893,
0.3794544339,
-0.3339880109,
0.5995696783,
-0.039780356,
-0.5559697151,
0.3365508318,
0.0226518828,
-0.1748547256,
-0.4366848767,
-0.3544758558,
0.0265652407,
0.0897747502,
-0.1951722652,
1.1200661659,
0.2637637854,
-0.1203257218,
0.2160527259,
0.2941953242,
0.916955471,
-0.5867094398,
0.4948378503,
-0.1300420612,
0.1819692552,
-0.1725669056,
-0.7189352512,
0.6202085614,
0.5395216942,
0.3793671131,
-0.3144822717,
0.6564217806,
0.1361363381,
-0.1144779101,
0.5767298937,
0.5726681948,
0.2181446105,
-0.0138738966,
-0.8998941183,
-0.0299021434,
-0.5248188376,
-0.2276482731,
0.6777290702,
0.4240671396,
0.4399555326,
0.22086972,
0.6308675408,
0.4999127984,
0.2903439999,
0.3964526057,
0.9497334361,
-0.5680449605,
-0.9793542624,
-1.0049761534,
0.0517809801,
-0.3797627091,
-0.6053347588,
0.8785718679,
0.4728982747,
0.9512090087,
0.1502960324,
0.6165423393,
0.0106454249,
0.7540602684,
-0.5886636972,
0.5763577819,
-0.4409449697,
0.3615662456,
-0.5801817179,
-1.2162593603,
-0.4005070925,
0.6073592901,
-0.4082866013,
-0.4217629731,
0.7115827203,
0.9266487956,
-0.0777515769,
0.1091254279,
0.4774400294,
-0.3354557753,
0.1179705188,
0.1302500367,
0.850428462,
-0.1716804206,
0.1095951498,
-0.8002513051,
-0.4724692404,
0.2894363105,
-0.9004684091,
-0.7053995728,
-0.4170692563,
-0.484308809,
-0.1620180458,
0.2503261864,
0.4723066688,
0.6026605964,
-0.503808856,
-0.0876448452,
-0.1473462731,
-0.0937868059,
-0.4194526672,
-0.1884516031,
0.2758020759,
-0.1105837375,
-0.8312625885,
0.1891811788,
0.6061615348,
-0.1805114001,
-0.4296439588,
0.2487605065,
0.3478512466,
0.2212800682,
0.377270937,
0.0698976442,
-0.39297387,
-0.1943199486,
-0.221536532,
-0.1654984951,
-0.0854008868,
0.9569941163,
-0.19050394,
0.1689626426,
0.723815918,
0.8223162293,
0.4498943388,
-0.0733486414,
0.3525663316,
-0.6637808681,
0.3122807443,
0.3588339686,
0.0550462082,
0.0247198064,
-0.6113615632,
0.3871282935,
-0.1429585069,
-0.6755810976,
-0.8492402434,
0.1462788731,
-0.9368012547,
-0.2355151176,
1.174374938,
-0.2713949978,
0.0135395769,
-0.1787009537,
-0.0555649437,
0.0609838553,
-0.4823601842,
1.2476043701,
0.6160981059,
-0.1211821362,
0.0040837852,
-0.6395794153,
0.6570265889,
0.3388428986,
-0.5296157002,
0.1257225275,
0.0467011482,
0.0781703144,
0.0390218608,
0.5948845148,
-0.5058803558,
-0.0738581568,
0.0255884435,
-0.5045768619,
0.0336555913,
-0.0047348286,
-0.6199549437,
0.1822770536,
-0.040774934,
-0.7419768572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03312v1
|
M3TCM: Multi-modal Multi-task Context Model for Utterance Classification in Motivational Interviews
| 2024-04-04T09:17:22 | 2024-04-04T09:17:22 |
Sayed Muddashir Hossain, Jan Alexandersson, Philipp Müller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Accurate utterance classification in motivational interviews is crucial to
automatically understand the quality and dynamics of client-therapist
interaction, and it can serve as a key input for systems mediating such
interactions. Motivational interviews exhibit three important characteristics.
First, there are two distinct roles, namely client and therapist. Second, they
are often highly emotionally charged, which can be expressed both in text and
in prosody. Finally, context is of central importance to classify any given
utterance. Previous works did not adequately incorporate all of these
characteristics into utterance classification approaches for mental health
dialogues. In contrast, we present M3TCM, a Multi-modal, Multi-task Context
Model for utterance classification. Our approach for the first time employs
multi-task learning to effectively model both joint and individual components
of therapist and client behaviour. Furthermore, M3TCM integrates information
from the text and speech modality as well as the conversation context. With our
novel approach, we outperform the state of the art for utterance classification
on the recently introduced AnnoMI dataset with a relative improvement of 20%
for the client- and by 15% for therapist utterance classification. In extensive
ablation studies, we quantify the improvement resulting from each contribution.
|
[
-0.4608587027,
-0.6387373805,
0.7493909001,
0.2216330767,
-0.0264606792,
-0.1880790889,
-0.2044346184,
-0.3932216763,
-0.2037370205,
0.4297103584,
-0.7652503252,
-0.5943021774,
-0.7776609659,
0.1289846003,
-0.0662730113,
0.8478668928,
-0.0701364428,
0.5571603775,
-0.3297352493,
-0.3684562445,
-0.8824525476,
-0.7137141228,
-0.8221863508,
-0.2982526124,
0.5103272796,
0.4134646654,
0.1145100892,
0.1616361886,
0.2184826881,
0.3640812337,
0.0677102804,
0.2481669337,
-0.2322724611,
0.4007173181,
0.0749004781,
-0.3669019341,
-0.2076041251,
0.2138377875,
0.1856040061,
0.6193708181,
-0.4984090626,
0.1137291938,
0.0430880524,
0.2956365645,
-0.6155123115,
0.4143582582,
-0.3512127101,
0.0187744815,
0.0859103128,
-0.6996623874,
-0.6645570993,
-0.0561716259,
0.1744818091,
-0.1001757011,
0.1705646366,
-0.0454281867,
0.1183536276,
0.2501402497,
-1.0946253538,
-0.2441215217,
-0.7221133709,
0.761887908,
-0.3513929844,
0.4801280499,
0.4129231572,
0.3069904745,
0.0177535843,
-0.2927949429,
-0.2623569667,
-0.1715279371,
-0.0492152758,
0.1509464383,
-0.2390652746,
0.4408959746,
0.2315950543,
0.1077480018,
-0.4529176354,
0.0461300984,
-0.1994645596,
-0.2256142944,
0.2562337816,
0.4500062168,
0.2672269642,
-0.0131194089,
-0.4281332493,
0.0798843503,
-0.3334002495,
0.1148812622,
-0.1579224914,
0.2181539536,
-0.0436121263,
0.3646024466,
-0.1497491002,
0.5281676054,
0.0450778566,
-0.6769093871,
-0.0533383004,
-0.2283728868,
-0.051313784,
0.5652809143,
0.6764600873,
0.5029919147,
-0.4289955497,
-0.0926909596,
-0.0133081283,
-0.09426523,
0.4616131186,
-1.1573495865,
0.1339379996,
0.4775565565,
-0.4788651168,
-0.179798454,
-0.0793827921,
-0.2871363759,
-0.3151803017,
-0.6160828471,
0.3828513026,
-0.5968962908,
-0.2577730715,
-0.0492372476,
-0.0037407505,
0.2000324279,
0.5566515326,
-0.7640485764,
0.3815573752,
0.6337652802,
1.0281507969,
-0.1038539484,
-0.1946758032,
-0.5576553941,
0.1794306338,
-0.0573459938,
0.6214058399,
-0.3656439781,
-0.3042442203,
-0.1118449345,
0.0633736774,
-0.3915767074,
-0.4588393867,
0.5612653494,
-0.2809453607,
0.53155756,
-0.2136339992,
-0.486576438,
-0.547426343,
0.4390451312,
-0.3204070628,
0.3498242795,
0.5034582615,
-0.6662840247,
0.2882250547,
-1.002045989,
-0.4953566492,
-0.0519923642,
-0.1931642443,
-0.1997396201,
0.2169599831,
-0.043712575,
0.425257802,
-0.4478236139,
0.3826161027,
-0.2401771843,
-0.3308953941,
0.62105757,
-0.5355098248,
0.8057358265,
0.3275792897,
-0.2550555468,
0.3424633741,
-0.4852114618,
-0.0474490523,
-0.2639690936,
-0.2860691547,
-0.1836530566,
-0.126519233,
0.3805285692,
0.5957249403,
-0.1556754261,
-0.6273562908,
-0.2012839615,
-0.1346219778,
0.4874341786,
0.4874595106,
0.1316273659,
-0.0413200855,
-0.5233064294,
0.5454736352,
0.3334667385,
0.0879600197,
-0.1655904651,
-0.3555331826,
-0.2416555583,
-0.6756517291,
-0.0802856758,
0.6576803327,
-0.4075443447,
0.5146888494,
0.0630389974,
-0.5375514627,
-0.4728602469,
-0.0227306858,
0.4341165721,
0.8104131222,
0.4501278698,
-0.2887329459,
-0.6967260838,
-0.6963006258,
0.0770679787,
-0.2380198687,
0.0139175085,
0.472664535,
0.240683347,
-0.4400766492,
0.9449619651,
-0.2650155723,
-0.5488762856,
-0.3887524903,
0.5424407125,
0.0557934195,
0.7396275997,
0.4909987748,
-0.8209936619,
-0.33435902,
-0.0546678044,
-0.6126778722,
-0.1737496853,
-0.0890242308,
0.0054852599,
0.0694005415,
0.3895751536,
-0.8557579517,
0.0590305403,
0.3921053112,
-0.349901706,
0.5824623704,
0.0110015403,
0.4571138322,
-1.0692454576,
0.0847816393,
-0.1146977842,
-0.237278074,
-0.8347439766,
-0.3225468397,
-0.1419716775,
-0.0938296318,
-0.7347818613,
0.1886536777,
-0.2593031526,
0.2203528434,
-0.436386466,
-0.281123966,
-0.0509387478,
0.7347332835,
0.0298185553,
0.7724611759,
0.60823071,
-0.7636303902,
0.4614007771,
0.3480714262,
-0.4183737636,
1.0844293833,
-0.4074887931,
0.2650574148,
-0.1302237958,
0.3069665134,
-1.0857970715,
-0.2641213238,
0.1635042578,
-0.3632588089,
0.3895097673,
-0.1160733402,
-0.3167313635,
0.0041110506,
0.0018118019,
0.5185521245,
0.1647618711,
-0.1827164739,
0.6390378475,
0.3539973497,
-0.2482484132,
-0.4433458149,
-0.4162078202,
-0.0010438043,
-0.545386374,
-0.3004312813,
0.4028360546,
-0.3015657961,
-0.1214875802,
-0.3988159001,
-0.3319326937,
-0.0751237646,
0.3956340849,
0.492104739,
0.2555487156,
-0.1609005928,
0.02381346,
0.1002987474,
-0.3702639639,
0.3774391115,
-0.2110420913,
0.6172799468,
-0.2306513041,
-0.4119721055,
-0.9447122812,
0.6983055472,
0.7857834101,
0.0973099545,
0.9688119292,
1.15388906,
-0.350578934,
0.4816507399,
-0.7542059422,
-0.2748630941,
-0.3415237665,
0.6175361872,
-0.4467112422,
-1.161241889,
0.2906817794,
-0.1614502072,
-0.0882385969,
0.1706749648,
0.6770036817,
-0.1682188064,
1.8045346737,
0.5163309574,
-0.0252113417,
0.6801903248,
-0.0320988968,
0.0008255026,
-0.9175258875,
-0.2010573447,
-0.5145274997,
-0.237093091,
-0.3731537461,
-0.0513255596,
0.6016529799,
0.1490252763,
-0.2014983296,
0.1530684233,
-0.4080781639,
0.0372976139,
0.3574563563,
0.2639375031,
0.1002729088,
-0.3403134048,
-0.0337071531,
-0.1446544677,
-0.4870912731,
-0.4184860885,
0.8868319392,
0.3562224805,
0.2556151748,
0.5398617387,
0.5265878439,
0.0859817043,
0.7489131093,
-1.1043967009,
0.4900915325,
0.2828688025,
-0.6367430091,
-0.0812101141,
-0.5490778089,
-0.9460062981,
0.5815346241,
-0.1039785817,
-1.0413360596,
0.0779007152,
-0.0142051186,
-0.4621630609,
-0.054022491,
-0.7077519298,
1.2059831619,
-0.2632773221,
-0.0458076447,
-0.3777138293,
-0.6054888964,
0.4984554052,
-0.0319611244,
0.3564535975,
-0.4709801674,
0.052387327,
0.7715473175,
-0.5132068992,
0.6445901394,
-0.4903322756,
0.1058882698,
0.2040006965,
0.1618927121,
0.1138080731,
0.205463931,
0.0331691541,
0.0362412743,
0.573558867,
-0.2202121764,
-0.7077299356,
0.2644797564,
-0.7562198639,
-0.5757674575,
-0.2022909224,
-0.6508806348,
-0.509436667,
0.2366547734,
0.2025228292,
0.7657038569,
-0.4320342243,
0.4712792337,
0.5601525307,
0.1024459302,
0.1610702127,
0.5945063233,
0.0459458344,
-0.5033052564,
0.6253370047,
-0.1300475001,
0.1785787344,
0.40462026,
0.2214555889,
-0.3685470223,
-0.6125586033,
-0.181692645,
0.1372077018,
-0.6349143386,
-0.2722102702,
-1.0007644892,
0.0644328147,
-0.6316044927,
0.0950033665,
-0.1407983452,
-0.1171864271,
-0.2884260118,
-0.0449923016,
0.1519566327,
0.4210196137,
-0.099965699,
0.6051303744,
-0.9677425027,
0.1443586946,
0.383084923,
0.0381800868,
-0.1880954057,
-0.3403922915,
-0.3145174086,
-0.0054983217,
-0.6453951597,
-1.2247340679,
0.6242491007,
0.1286399215,
0.5828866363,
0.7368842363,
0.2145682573,
0.5738987327,
-0.1438375413,
0.4999670386,
0.5191963315,
-0.9797229767,
0.5097982883,
-0.18378295,
0.2669556439,
0.8485931158,
0.4745551348,
-0.9564650059,
-0.2362129539,
-0.4173197448,
-0.7046105862,
1.1717609167,
0.0105688246,
-0.0629467964,
-0.068441987,
0.0136600323,
0.1986472607,
0.4869995713,
-0.530136168,
-0.2371411026,
-0.0249445569,
-0.5463761091,
-0.0494744964,
-0.3840357065,
-0.6997544765,
-0.2815130055,
0.4921530783,
-0.3978734016,
0.7083761692,
0.3160642684,
-0.302537322,
-0.0587502643,
0.5221290588,
0.8063411117,
0.5137119889,
-0.511537075,
0.4220997691,
0.3194471896,
-0.3173792064,
0.2938337028,
0.1487099528,
0.4059398174,
0.1157436445,
0.141237691,
0.9892493486,
0.1853312403,
-0.7140585184,
0.710370779,
-0.2936741412,
-0.4269976616,
-0.2738761604,
0.0896388516,
-0.0836962089,
0.3457973003,
0.1512810141,
0.2172846794,
0.5834604502,
-0.6642793417,
0.1489745826,
0.3422817588,
-0.7996771336,
-0.1537503153,
0.5303900242,
-0.0015909306,
-0.241335541,
0.480620563,
-0.2724490166,
-0.5545445085,
0.3332435489,
0.6050099134,
1.1567049026,
-0.3429385722,
0.0144221513,
0.1700698286,
-0.263912797,
0.0438703485,
0.1892168671,
-0.6213530302,
-0.7730689645,
-0.2622554898,
-0.2804800868,
-0.7012684941,
0.0182018522,
-0.9319892526,
0.0355774239,
-0.2596192062,
-0.4262496233,
-0.0719563439,
-0.1783555746,
-0.657785356,
0.0507023856,
0.3602671325,
0.4125474095,
-0.678578496,
0.6583173275,
0.7529566288,
-0.3573440909,
-0.4768556356,
-0.3524437249,
0.3963784277,
-0.4738348424,
0.5916506648,
0.849596262,
-0.2515711486,
0.1907274276,
-0.3646202087,
-0.8025473952,
1.2038081884,
0.3561098576,
-0.0728982836,
-0.0280725565,
-0.0574366897,
0.3484953344,
-0.7341698408,
0.7144483328,
0.3948410749,
0.422657162,
0.1859338582,
-1.0761235952,
0.1084377766,
-0.1769019514,
0.0197902173,
-0.0035727764,
-0.4450618029,
0.4901070595,
-0.1814532131,
-0.3558569551,
-0.0754775181,
0.426471144,
0.4338871837,
0.4507727027,
0.8550825119,
0.1769111454,
0.738737762,
-0.2890365422,
0.7947447896,
-0.5154203773,
0.2542899549,
0.890868485,
-0.1851681024,
0.565955162,
0.4080515504,
-0.1187109947,
0.4114330411,
0.7258021235,
0.2870746553,
0.4221140444,
-0.0293058902,
-0.4731988907,
-0.3085124195,
-0.4133703709,
-0.1912015676,
0.6349576116,
0.5420041084,
-0.1379093677,
0.0200707112,
0.5529968739,
0.111031875,
-0.4778131545,
-0.1794239879,
0.9013266563,
0.2756336033,
-0.6488343477,
0.5041360259,
0.1005885303,
0.6122731566,
-0.3788640201,
0.2091523558,
0.2231602073,
0.1760924906,
-0.2900791168,
-0.3164587319,
0.4221590459,
-0.3087882698,
-0.2171905786,
-0.6312645674,
0.4398158789,
-0.633066237,
0.0343987122,
0.1118580624,
0.6347916722,
0.30178231,
-0.4211682081,
-0.8333837986,
-0.2039873749,
-0.2476798296,
-0.2910251617,
0.3502907157,
0.369830668,
0.3212464154,
0.5662133694,
0.6447485685,
-0.1778727472,
-0.3925200105,
0.338719964,
0.4898491204,
-0.8720477223,
-0.5340132117,
-0.7929065228,
0.3346740305,
0.0927369818,
-0.3568267226,
0.4130182266,
0.511920929,
0.4545426071,
0.1693695784,
0.4847657681,
0.0257114153,
0.6558944583,
-0.5406709313,
0.4481664002,
-0.5110864043,
-0.0368429311,
-0.2351639122,
-0.6907384396,
-0.1568227857,
0.4692115486,
-0.1675012261,
0.2225318402,
0.8866356611,
0.6038885713,
0.3349711895,
0.3296060264,
0.2692259848,
-0.0665717497,
0.4594993591,
0.7090464234,
1.065279603,
-0.1479734331,
0.4564441144,
-0.3501786888,
-0.1882862449,
-0.4214869142,
-0.5039496422,
-0.5832285881,
-0.6701949835,
-0.4744992852,
-0.3098300695,
-0.3118430972,
1.4092161655,
0.9984070659,
-0.8186969757,
-0.3687810302,
0.0217846539,
0.054914616,
-0.7022236586,
-0.2793801725,
-0.0233349465,
-0.4400081635,
-0.7522829771,
0.5557393432,
0.4444996119,
0.088628903,
-0.1782844365,
-0.1162497699,
-0.0966494232,
-0.2055125535,
0.7948776484,
0.0288607795,
-0.7572930455,
-0.1720616072,
-0.0802844241,
-0.3205814362,
0.3415505588,
1.0638539791,
-0.5095667839,
0.3065178394,
0.1172693223,
0.6601897478,
0.5118075013,
0.0482008979,
0.610465169,
-0.5632781386,
-0.0525294617,
0.3069382012,
0.4473816156,
0.2210201323,
-0.3521863818,
0.2975732088,
0.4138186872,
-0.5863416791,
-0.9630004168,
0.1339414567,
-1.3655779362,
-0.2841640711,
0.9771542549,
-0.0376320146,
-0.1043339446,
-0.6286693811,
-0.6611770391,
0.4847982228,
-0.3630324602,
0.5698552728,
0.6944728494,
-0.6911709309,
-0.4020872712,
-0.5916568637,
0.4566704631,
0.6353807449,
-0.6448153257,
-0.0914378986,
0.6591226459,
0.1910768002,
0.1759407222,
0.7818796039,
-0.0153371328,
0.340077579,
-0.3084120154,
0.1973868608,
-0.1967865676,
-0.178373158,
-0.3229281604,
0.5729486942,
0.1720204353,
-0.2620797753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03304v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03304v3
|
Concept -- An Evaluation Protocol on Conversational Recommender Systems with System-centric and User-centric Factors
| 2024-04-04T08:56:48 | 2024-05-06T12:44:34 |
Chen Huang, Peixin Qin, Yang Deng, Wenqiang Lei, Jiancheng Lv, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The conversational recommendation system (CRS) has been criticized regarding
its user experience in real-world scenarios, despite recent significant
progress achieved in academia. Existing evaluation protocols for CRS may
prioritize system-centric factors such as effectiveness and fluency in
conversation while neglecting user-centric aspects. Thus, we propose a new and
inclusive evaluation protocol, Concept, which integrates both system- and
user-centric factors. We conceptualise three key characteristics in
representing such factors and further divide them into six primary abilities.
To implement Concept, we adopt a LLM-based user simulator and evaluator with
scoring rubrics that are tailored for each primary ability. Our protocol,
Concept, serves a dual purpose. First, it provides an overview of the pros and
cons in current CRS models. Second, it pinpoints the problem of low usability
in the "omnipotent" ChatGPT and offers a comprehensive reference guide for
evaluating CRS, thereby setting the foundation for CRS improvement.
|
[
-0.4782582819,
-0.5723888278,
0.3632313013,
0.4062016904,
-0.3966639638,
0.1898918301,
-0.3595071733,
-0.3839266598,
0.4607548118,
0.3302426338,
-0.4463408887,
-0.2357845753,
-0.2046430856,
-0.0112077873,
-0.2042339742,
1.2419023514,
0.3447155058,
0.3526495993,
-0.3619263768,
0.1256434023,
-0.7836130857,
-0.6251072288,
-0.5677717328,
-0.6896344423,
0.5199137926,
0.8185172081,
0.6526801586,
0.191829294,
0.7852342129,
0.228984043,
-0.0868136063,
-0.1296045482,
-0.6408088803,
0.2964464724,
-0.2471572459,
-0.1102409363,
-0.6267831922,
-0.0907334089,
0.2615222335,
0.522815764,
-0.5211192369,
0.0246540699,
0.3258499503,
0.6136714816,
-0.6685843468,
-0.0466785096,
-0.3835955262,
0.1371806711,
0.2291398644,
-0.5654276013,
-0.3089679778,
-0.2457332313,
0.7216228843,
-0.6299270391,
0.0845952183,
0.1315148175,
0.2440645993,
-0.4273529053,
-0.1071331427,
-0.1886720955,
-0.8324067593,
0.4883824289,
-0.3483110368,
0.4636285305,
0.0440374762,
0.5944881439,
-0.0375708081,
-0.2487415075,
-0.4850192368,
-0.6124650836,
-0.0103072552,
-0.0447208956,
0.0505278334,
0.123628363,
0.0275468957,
0.4819158018,
-0.3326399028,
-0.2243225873,
-0.2661003172,
-0.4073512554,
0.3771288097,
0.4219484925,
0.0930007249,
-0.2739146948,
-0.7220160365,
0.1569675654,
-0.3958043754,
0.12491218,
0.1666872352,
0.6167028546,
-0.2962845564,
0.5859442353,
-0.5987824202,
0.2646642625,
0.0663632378,
-0.0802007392,
0.3067994118,
-0.6282696724,
-0.2723434567,
-0.16476053,
0.7433306575,
0.816285491,
0.2143092006,
-0.2976890504,
-0.0813625678,
0.3133863807,
0.2945565581,
-0.6747794151,
-0.2285405993,
-0.0238454156,
-0.4703061283,
-0.4457856119,
0.1036950275,
-0.5962722898,
-0.569301486,
-0.1871509403,
0.2522753477,
-0.4973280132,
-0.1477399617,
0.1847240776,
-0.376495719,
-0.1310369223,
0.3886534274,
-0.81728971,
0.6457234025,
0.7065788507,
0.5984828472,
-0.3491821289,
-0.1991562098,
-0.3565157652,
-0.1295062006,
0.2098999619,
1.0242443085,
-0.7791370749,
-0.9191201925,
0.0298119225,
-0.1958413422,
0.0685875714,
-0.2636448443,
0.7743217349,
-0.2263154238,
0.218155399,
-0.4204280972,
-0.2729305923,
0.1555140018,
0.1685424894,
0.1917825043,
0.7433744073,
0.0774820819,
-0.5388581157,
0.6205018163,
-1.0055627823,
-0.2970758975,
0.3908624053,
-0.045185972,
0.262745142,
-0.1475289762,
-0.2852881551,
0.2795527279,
-0.4075531065,
0.1840714961,
-0.4816003144,
-0.736314714,
0.390781045,
-0.2770343125,
0.3017443419,
0.3521236777,
0.1458655149,
0.2560243905,
-0.5784128308,
0.314910084,
-0.1009399444,
-0.3075933158,
-0.101811029,
-0.2248665839,
0.2572526336,
-0.1127173379,
0.2885316312,
-0.5687443614,
0.2093396634,
-0.1608281881,
0.6647439003,
0.4560029209,
0.1015476957,
0.6625378132,
-0.3308710456,
0.5006424189,
-0.148115471,
0.5659632683,
-0.3226989806,
-0.3943901658,
-1.0356200933,
-0.0710989311,
0.0374072865,
0.460837394,
-0.4258194268,
0.601674974,
-0.2262325734,
-0.7640074492,
-0.0335330442,
0.0732527301,
0.9319214225,
0.2589221895,
0.1767061949,
-0.8915558457,
-0.5387951732,
-1.0199455023,
-0.1462999582,
-0.5303579569,
-0.0009798127,
0.4778138399,
0.1660870314,
-0.2830699682,
0.7599539757,
-0.3161412477,
-0.337748915,
-0.3516798615,
-0.1027587354,
-0.2020948529,
0.3449906111,
0.0278194901,
-0.2195283324,
-0.2081890404,
-0.2212990522,
-0.4108401239,
-0.2321502864,
0.3296474516,
-0.1395087391,
-0.1478386521,
0.0383891985,
-0.3204368651,
0.5690620542,
0.0562883429,
-0.7018287778,
0.6588118076,
-0.3266712129,
0.4687463343,
-0.4944807887,
-0.1746647507,
0.3937776387,
0.0452431813,
-0.4614374638,
-0.0306380652,
-0.1657826602,
-0.3124823868,
-0.3492012322,
0.3280247152,
0.0958439559,
-0.2152764946,
-0.1844387501,
0.4897288084,
0.3314228654,
0.2802217007,
-0.0426856466,
0.5779941678,
0.3239167333,
-0.6834629774,
0.315381825,
0.4639364183,
-0.1895495355,
1.2695169449,
-0.6667975783,
0.2407487631,
0.4336064756,
0.4281814396,
-0.8621137738,
0.3239845932,
0.4514833987,
-0.3767295778,
-0.2622945607,
-0.0022991213,
-0.1289404333,
-0.3688875437,
-0.2751045823,
0.1888478994,
0.1928099543,
-0.1817386448,
0.2020540982,
0.3439102471,
-0.080998458,
-0.3431901932,
-0.169549942,
0.5582062602,
-0.0936977863,
-0.8125326037,
0.2984265685,
-0.3933507204,
-0.2020321041,
-0.3510484099,
0.0459542386,
0.1644898504,
0.1672865897,
0.5548562407,
0.2867041826,
-0.1574204266,
0.0454674698,
-0.3277560771,
-0.4585227668,
-0.1426185668,
-0.1652089357,
0.5820540786,
-0.5453360677,
-0.5479450822,
-0.7863020897,
0.108843565,
0.5016450286,
-0.0915418491,
0.0118165733,
0.5313352346,
0.068909809,
-0.0035567142,
-0.6890733242,
-0.5888211727,
-0.4227020442,
0.3455528915,
-0.455270499,
-0.7539070249,
0.3247620761,
0.199667111,
0.0022946228,
0.0483658537,
0.4490316808,
-0.1305402219,
0.7298005223,
0.7597475648,
0.1248693243,
0.5251199603,
-0.018713275,
0.5621803403,
-1.1166408062,
-0.4553393126,
-0.8058443069,
-0.1764730215,
-0.1214922369,
-0.2500417531,
0.2650983632,
0.1644049585,
-0.3948791027,
0.4918376505,
-0.5280252695,
0.0678206459,
0.5119023919,
0.2142001092,
0.626713872,
0.0514532253,
-0.430221349,
-0.0758834258,
-0.631706059,
-0.8331645131,
0.8880982995,
0.5042855144,
0.6496719718,
-0.0460931845,
0.414969027,
0.8261793256,
0.4252233207,
-0.8488869667,
0.807240665,
0.2964142263,
-0.3257945478,
-0.4683635235,
-0.1021644026,
-0.4794137478,
0.2933034003,
-0.6009414792,
-1.0700598955,
0.0973772556,
0.096700184,
-0.4176773727,
-0.1349519342,
-0.839859426,
0.6830776334,
-0.0746967793,
-0.3844840825,
-0.6423768401,
-0.2916139662,
0.1428985596,
0.3898009062,
0.0400179848,
-0.1062713861,
0.2222896367,
0.7065781355,
-0.3588642478,
0.7022808194,
-0.2799145877,
0.1163517386,
0.3651480675,
0.4418751001,
0.0885380358,
0.2261172235,
-0.2388967872,
0.2288239598,
0.3812977076,
-0.0585936271,
-0.7845826745,
0.7240041494,
-0.5656739473,
-0.6607413888,
-0.2017755061,
-0.0405422859,
-0.2967945337,
-0.0230392534,
-0.2114826441,
0.5467049479,
-0.7379376888,
0.3739089072,
-0.0331169181,
-0.0159687772,
0.1058158726,
1.0013079643,
-0.4843129218,
-0.531185627,
0.8410826325,
-0.3918988407,
0.1759512126,
-0.0021658626,
0.3055797517,
-0.2507018447,
-0.4695065618,
-0.471213311,
-0.0453136154,
-0.6039408445,
-0.0137200132,
-0.4734358788,
-0.0848905072,
-0.2159487754,
-0.1611733139,
-0.095687598,
-0.3452477455,
0.0217407625,
-0.1212993488,
0.1459386498,
0.5436762571,
0.1713698506,
0.602460146,
-0.5958117247,
0.0763245448,
0.05464641,
0.7411956787,
-0.0284701977,
-0.7948346138,
-0.4569289982,
0.0747449175,
-0.6662660837,
-0.175017491,
-0.0739112496,
0.0120529775,
0.6469994783,
0.8533718586,
-0.1072732583,
0.5664698482,
-0.2857414782,
0.8633700609,
0.6081745625,
-0.8068686128,
0.2832871079,
-0.3605334163,
-0.1337891519,
0.7776164412,
-0.3243626058,
-0.938124001,
-0.1075111479,
-0.6754447818,
-0.3941509426,
0.5323514938,
0.2302606255,
0.2815310061,
-0.124827303,
0.2628058195,
0.1874633133,
0.2908083498,
-0.4003921151,
-0.1377025694,
-0.1303242743,
0.3261630833,
-0.1712136865,
-0.6026889682,
-0.2523474693,
0.0531187132,
0.6715859771,
0.0405134186,
0.2725796103,
0.341042161,
0.0559491105,
-0.4119864106,
0.4685790837,
0.3089731932,
0.8392218947,
-0.4419995844,
-0.2095154673,
-0.0834381059,
-0.2959960103,
0.0745039359,
-0.2181805372,
-0.1011452153,
-0.5470280647,
-0.0406477116,
0.5224853754,
0.4266832769,
-0.5684584975,
0.6015589833,
-0.4220514596,
0.0191176236,
-0.3332608342,
0.4390979707,
-0.0677529424,
0.1119019762,
0.3801489174,
0.3895500302,
0.2793161869,
-0.5524278283,
0.2178060114,
0.4674846828,
-1.0370056629,
-0.3625867069,
-0.0509452,
0.9938589334,
-0.9411081076,
0.0671728626,
-0.1236625761,
-0.2621866465,
0.3144514263,
0.4180613458,
0.8074522018,
-0.1258045137,
0.5134912133,
0.066230841,
0.0828291029,
0.0965260342,
0.2274281681,
-0.1896004975,
-0.8403529525,
0.1646786928,
-0.4570431709,
-0.525428772,
-0.0756681114,
-0.5536155105,
0.6614236236,
-0.5675907731,
-0.3488919735,
0.04886657,
0.0633068532,
-0.7861382365,
0.1263520122,
0.0634871125,
0.9539072514,
-0.6233812571,
0.4348986149,
0.6297138929,
-0.2886009514,
-0.3162922859,
-0.3234271407,
-0.1097775176,
-0.6512250304,
0.5374600887,
-0.0414279513,
-0.4398748279,
-0.4013373256,
-0.1828936338,
-0.3098396957,
1.0586411953,
0.0149850845,
-0.5112543106,
0.3187685609,
-0.0441421941,
0.7612907887,
-0.8728961349,
0.8995863199,
0.5379758477,
0.4746492803,
-0.0011825195,
-1.279605031,
-0.0140426587,
-0.3762823343,
0.0148886992,
-0.2808264494,
-0.762840867,
0.0298638474,
-0.4201979935,
-0.1472468525,
0.3950585127,
0.3271658719,
0.2613918781,
0.677799046,
0.7608600855,
0.4277176857,
0.3491608202,
0.1869013608,
0.7761278152,
-0.4592194557,
0.0184429158,
0.9534412622,
-0.6457425356,
0.6845897436,
0.5586306453,
-0.3746695817,
0.5500514507,
0.4223244786,
0.2251653075,
0.3402392864,
0.4541620612,
-0.1855544746,
-0.3816830516,
-0.4579994082,
-0.3886747658,
0.5843014121,
0.4605486989,
-0.182326749,
-0.1595482975,
-0.1221761107,
-0.234271124,
0.1540498137,
0.1250479221,
0.7824855447,
0.1036376134,
-0.5666268468,
0.4440969527,
0.173047781,
0.5719686747,
-0.4703801572,
-0.2220045775,
-0.1270169616,
-0.1325822771,
-0.2831768692,
-0.5863439441,
-0.3181431293,
-0.1068937853,
-0.2864452004,
-0.0839891508,
0.7801771164,
0.1097337306,
-0.1726170182,
0.4155373573,
0.768470943,
0.2696672082,
0.0861481726,
-0.696903646,
0.0362106822,
-0.0204331726,
-0.16313155,
0.3158483803,
0.4263874292,
-0.0192387942,
1.2460005283,
0.7866479754,
0.0942855254,
-0.6649438739,
0.5165995955,
0.8659607172,
-0.5761178136,
-0.6979281902,
-0.4197016656,
0.3216382563,
-0.0029746955,
-0.4448732436,
0.6909217238,
0.5307576656,
0.3964619339,
0.2954842746,
0.9855281711,
0.025925681,
0.5096735358,
0.069883287,
0.443957597,
0.0695830956,
0.9587008357,
-0.546226263,
-1.1653220654,
0.0384525433,
0.4240446389,
-0.4664829373,
0.1735928059,
0.7320690155,
0.7776181698,
-0.0647139624,
0.5845195055,
0.4720533192,
-0.1371400356,
0.3471179903,
0.20358859,
1.0835149288,
-0.1218003631,
0.6250452399,
-0.2183581591,
-0.5975191593,
-0.7612074018,
-0.8909564018,
-0.75538975,
-0.4154815078,
-0.1847108752,
-0.4816246033,
0.3442421257,
0.9235988259,
0.7880113125,
-0.4868929982,
-0.4311137497,
0.1128950119,
0.0172855426,
-0.1754781902,
-0.2582480013,
-0.1393491626,
-0.2387384176,
-0.1333808303,
0.4206153154,
0.5381420851,
-0.2230416983,
-0.7168475389,
-0.2228001058,
0.4431524277,
-0.0073049497,
0.5177683234,
0.0938410237,
-0.5498199463,
-0.6464375257,
-0.0698803812,
-0.1317417622,
0.0602014214,
1.1545023918,
-0.8936676979,
0.4563319683,
0.2772631049,
-0.0889544338,
-0.0213492792,
0.1496359408,
0.6691901684,
0.0511228666,
-0.0211336464,
0.1022466496,
0.3644316792,
0.3461254835,
-0.2317329347,
0.3032137752,
0.3503620327,
-0.6224681735,
-0.7321150303,
0.2478503436,
-1.2099007368,
0.2546975017,
1.2041547298,
-0.2907663584,
0.337341845,
-0.4744213223,
-0.5315580368,
-0.1335504204,
-1.1568176746,
0.9661121368,
0.518520236,
-0.0759887695,
0.3080143631,
-0.2907184064,
0.1446307153,
0.41192168,
-0.1888463646,
0.2655534446,
0.3757303953,
0.2761723697,
0.3353209198,
0.7434462905,
-0.20865722,
0.1272590607,
-0.2829400599,
0.3095325828,
-0.1346923262,
-0.4319680929,
-0.0986517742,
0.1054845229,
0.2975348234,
0.1052699462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03302v1
|
How Easily do Irrelevant Inputs Skew the Responses of Large Language Models?
| 2024-04-04T08:52:30 | 2024-04-04T08:52:30 |
Siye Wu, Jian Xie, Jiangjie Chen, Tinghui Zhu, Kai Zhang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
By leveraging the retrieval of information from external knowledge databases,
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit enhanced capabilities for accomplishing
many knowledge-intensive tasks. However, due to the inherent flaws of current
retrieval systems, there might exist irrelevant information within those
retrieving top-ranked passages. In this work, we present a comprehensive
investigation into the robustness of LLMs to different types of irrelevant
information under various conditions. We initially introduce a framework to
construct high-quality irrelevant information that ranges from semantically
unrelated, partially related, and related to questions. Furthermore, our
analysis demonstrates that the constructed irrelevant information not only
scores highly on similarity metrics, being highly retrieved by existing
systems, but also bears semantic connections to the context. Our investigation
reveals that current LLMs still face challenges in discriminating highly
semantically related information and can be easily distracted by these
irrelevant yet misleading contents. Besides, we also find that current
solutions for handling irrelevant information have limitations in improving the
robustness of LLMs to such distractions. Resources are available at
https://github.com/Di-viner/LLM-Robustness-to-Irrelevant-Information.
|
[
-0.3746702969,
-0.9622232914,
0.8301244974,
-0.1972937137,
0.006026994,
-0.3112137616,
-0.2535429597,
-0.4201339185,
-0.1094415635,
0.3770048618,
-0.4031468332,
-0.2537695169,
-0.7413951159,
-0.2275347412,
-0.7045959234,
0.9961946011,
0.3122135401,
-0.097039476,
-0.4532182515,
-0.5112265944,
-0.3992206156,
-0.7959788442,
-0.225844264,
-0.0868927464,
0.7360994816,
0.2547436655,
0.8000568151,
0.5973401666,
0.6013129354,
0.2949558198,
-0.293958813,
-0.1805351228,
-0.7391980886,
0.5009775162,
-0.6084476113,
-0.6017431021,
-0.1781199127,
-0.3301835954,
0.6373231411,
0.7556322217,
0.0531716049,
0.5125509501,
0.2682307959,
0.5716379881,
-0.8947854638,
0.2541245818,
-1.2308499813,
-0.4755013585,
-0.478987962,
-0.2296236455,
-0.5267026424,
-0.1691037118,
0.0898576453,
-0.4316855073,
0.0164469089,
-0.0341871418,
1.034081459,
0.3189358711,
-0.3673066795,
-0.6713983417,
-0.8673013449,
0.6509641409,
-0.7941047549,
0.2425403297,
0.8558297753,
0.1427118778,
-0.0565210134,
-0.31453529,
-0.3402842879,
-0.2409770787,
-0.1142439768,
-0.1136259064,
-0.010613557,
-0.1212760285,
0.3162411451,
0.2263367921,
-0.3533682525,
0.0741363838,
-0.0844310969,
-0.1670359969,
0.1806171983,
0.1918958873,
0.243419826,
-0.1446207166,
0.0807041749,
0.0473691188,
-1.0175458193,
0.0390991494,
0.4559397697,
0.3455250561,
0.2371248305,
0.9708037376,
-0.1283371896,
0.8615067601,
0.2555980384,
-0.3387040496,
-0.054972887,
-0.2922130823,
0.16214329,
-0.4168717861,
0.583337903,
0.1033320799,
0.0347766727,
-0.3152057827,
-0.3181684613,
-0.0864424035,
0.2801737189,
-0.5630138516,
0.0466950722,
0.3774221539,
-0.1589096785,
-0.1408684105,
-0.1656511724,
-0.5702091455,
-0.3465950191,
-0.1115262061,
0.6401674747,
-0.3988709152,
-0.1682894826,
-0.5011860728,
0.1153997555,
0.2276192307,
0.2728840113,
-0.7482472062,
0.0058262697,
0.6056896448,
0.6821556687,
-0.3250837922,
-0.0058418494,
-0.7047695518,
0.3671396673,
-0.254218936,
0.5992850065,
-0.6125730276,
0.0251276158,
0.1118137687,
0.02077947,
0.0704315454,
-0.5747541785,
0.4730025828,
-1.0752915144,
-0.0275522564,
-0.4966761768,
-0.5189707875,
-0.0595473982,
0.4245289266,
-0.7431416512,
0.8800667524,
0.1410599053,
-1.1966155767,
0.1412740648,
-0.0135435089,
-0.4938139915,
-0.0974863917,
-0.1984916329,
-0.117882207,
0.0985909328,
-0.1928471178,
0.5720741749,
-0.3791928887,
0.4966506362,
-0.7907556891,
-0.2575097382,
0.5790632367,
-0.5432385802,
0.4288967252,
0.1682599932,
-0.071826987,
-0.1700787991,
-1.0491245985,
-0.1834944785,
0.1169198081,
-0.5782627463,
-0.6470578909,
0.2846308053,
-0.3035109341,
0.4976376891,
0.2154993862,
-0.3821053207,
-0.2559726834,
-0.3686996102,
0.4425007105,
0.8551809192,
-0.1210003644,
0.444101423,
-0.4766146839,
0.3690710366,
0.2001492083,
-0.2842516303,
-0.0340038724,
-0.213371858,
-0.7646222711,
-0.0220913403,
0.1342747211,
0.5806638598,
-1.0600738525,
0.2664290071,
-0.5729811192,
-0.2987268269,
-0.2767088711,
0.3440477252,
0.2156159878,
0.7812536359,
0.1090313122,
0.1177946031,
-0.2284162194,
-0.8374820948,
-0.3502432108,
-0.3326783478,
-0.0679153278,
0.2682741582,
0.355810225,
0.1056339592,
0.9196095467,
-0.2980744541,
-0.0911294445,
-0.1275129169,
-0.3505136371,
0.3040894568,
0.2259230465,
0.3206673265,
-0.6435843706,
-0.2935732901,
0.0300971121,
-0.6940633655,
-0.0314750299,
0.0492613278,
0.0714806914,
0.0276858658,
0.5838810802,
-0.8507937193,
0.3481369019,
0.3208394051,
-0.1204303876,
0.333017379,
0.0545925051,
-0.1313311905,
-0.9770726562,
0.5018357635,
-0.1380302459,
-0.2068789005,
-0.6105895638,
0.1410257518,
-0.0463940986,
0.0927858949,
-0.4290247262,
0.5992282033,
-0.38599509,
0.1006640494,
-0.2675184309,
0.3251975179,
-0.0733181611,
0.4429742992,
-0.1501714438,
0.5511805415,
0.4029271603,
-0.977709949,
0.2422530949,
0.0741099492,
-0.3533765376,
0.5882392526,
-0.4330697656,
0.0319441222,
-0.4408598244,
0.0497738086,
-0.9769954085,
-0.678101778,
0.2019579858,
-0.4182243943,
0.4059281647,
-0.2890656888,
-0.5085289478,
-0.1195363253,
-0.2332044095,
0.50970155,
0.2980464101,
-0.4175209403,
0.5689135194,
0.6503627896,
-0.5872096419,
-0.6670084,
-0.6691116095,
-0.1880692691,
-0.3763421178,
-0.3411020041,
-0.1468883604,
-0.0420010313,
-0.3998287618,
0.1162014231,
-0.3192538023,
-0.4001784623,
0.2086942941,
0.288333416,
0.3780039251,
-0.3456385732,
0.4760742784,
-0.1880939007,
0.2283365577,
0.1787252277,
-0.1260062605,
0.3571922481,
0.2637465298,
-0.6742111444,
-0.0680032074,
0.3034675717,
0.8975755572,
0.2363669723,
0.9195485711,
0.4867100716,
-0.4876659513,
-0.0062997723,
-0.7969279289,
-0.0107754162,
-0.4238076806,
0.6667233706,
-0.3895508349,
-1.1167508364,
0.6022513509,
0.3533836603,
0.1594479233,
0.5214214921,
0.6899565458,
0.0161770936,
0.9089664817,
0.4234844446,
-0.1819536388,
0.2834908962,
0.344114989,
0.2588919997,
-0.7476812005,
-0.2123214751,
-0.7192664742,
0.1358433366,
-0.4043030441,
-0.2341701239,
0.093646057,
0.120077014,
-0.2028270364,
0.2423545271,
-0.2703873813,
0.3341289759,
0.4404241741,
-0.0054223309,
0.3382993937,
-0.0984114856,
-0.126212731,
-0.1418295056,
-0.8408733606,
-0.5347097516,
1.1358681917,
0.5047437549,
1.1848015785,
0.3335805535,
-0.0193790141,
0.0430864543,
0.4554003179,
-0.8329868913,
0.40429914,
-0.0347645991,
-0.8817586303,
-0.3284911811,
-0.5595964789,
-0.7231089473,
0.3309737444,
-0.1630296856,
-0.9807668924,
0.2030659765,
0.2696141899,
-0.4035831392,
0.3718073666,
-0.6768094897,
0.2894827425,
-0.2128859907,
-0.7217383981,
0.1986408532,
-0.5531046987,
0.4278759062,
-0.5626910329,
0.5233337879,
-0.1764303148,
-0.159410432,
0.5022012591,
-0.3252491653,
0.7889252901,
-0.0056713321,
-0.4895813763,
0.2609828711,
0.3707009852,
0.5414239764,
0.179905057,
-0.4144935012,
-0.0378062613,
0.1647057831,
-0.3542841971,
-0.5595290661,
0.9501526952,
-0.5122870803,
-0.8723983169,
-0.3563335836,
-0.8359678984,
-0.5953310728,
0.248405844,
0.3528427184,
0.4301390052,
0.0634181574,
0.4867319763,
0.7735570669,
-0.2905217707,
0.3797900975,
0.5803582072,
0.0685068965,
-0.0174891651,
1.1532233953,
0.3828393519,
0.5382758379,
0.6274420023,
-0.0727414787,
-0.4113272429,
-0.5027092099,
-0.3528440595,
0.0500914603,
-0.9618690014,
-0.2879674435,
-0.6729486585,
-0.3508381248,
-0.3625769317,
0.3081504107,
-0.2735878527,
-0.3547535539,
-0.4010253847,
0.0731303617,
0.0314024277,
0.9264218807,
0.3002445698,
0.0696898177,
-0.7397867441,
0.2580834627,
0.2721133232,
0.393243432,
0.2357848138,
-0.8582437634,
-0.1770282984,
-0.0105548985,
-0.0873823389,
-0.6713609099,
0.0430669002,
0.1711751521,
0.675608933,
0.525141418,
0.2076735198,
0.4892285168,
-0.3208810091,
0.7515457273,
-0.1166416779,
-0.6734874845,
0.3321895897,
-0.4601359665,
0.5159260035,
0.6802660227,
0.5077578425,
-0.0466761775,
-0.7153997421,
-0.3296559751,
-1.1137882471,
0.8436792493,
0.1618954688,
0.2279984802,
-0.0402674824,
0.5011918545,
0.1690273881,
0.1619180143,
-1.1916275024,
-0.17332986,
0.0443030559,
-0.3336600661,
0.1444302201,
-0.3857968152,
-0.0537000075,
0.0717349425,
0.7628949881,
0.0058193444,
0.0749523193,
-0.05608299,
-0.3666165769,
0.1414497942,
0.4754900336,
0.5084596872,
0.6743791699,
-0.1182088032,
0.3582758605,
0.3443463743,
-0.5123212337,
0.2536094785,
-0.1539049447,
-0.3807846904,
0.009731858,
0.5148794055,
0.52238065,
0.014622245,
-0.7641451359,
0.6192755103,
0.0694332868,
0.1053673252,
-0.1691862643,
0.0878458172,
0.2536999583,
-0.1454781741,
0.3336689472,
0.04706892,
-0.1033862606,
-0.5627922416,
-0.0000190451,
0.6707932353,
-0.598976016,
-0.3818147779,
0.5483556986,
-0.1028335169,
0.0048633968,
0.3118820488,
0.0418343507,
-0.2192227989,
0.2722507119,
0.5047215819,
0.2648655176,
-0.0660315752,
-0.189230144,
0.3082630336,
0.3825254142,
-0.0172928926,
-0.1840758175,
-0.0586999618,
-0.5348870158,
-0.5625203252,
-0.5020971298,
-0.0845563337,
0.6709846854,
-0.7041139007,
0.0050193528,
-0.5029188991,
-0.3760916591,
-0.1376207769,
-0.630816102,
-0.7102758884,
0.0928644761,
-0.1357789487,
0.707775712,
-0.6158261895,
0.8232550621,
0.6420128345,
-0.4118851125,
-0.7264475822,
0.3531475365,
0.0393136628,
-0.7777381539,
0.7307388186,
-0.1243914738,
-0.2172823995,
-0.4124164879,
-0.4699483812,
-1.3897221088,
0.6213871837,
0.5927795768,
-0.4628524184,
-0.3725228906,
0.2041568458,
0.4757662117,
0.0989123434,
0.2573091686,
0.327472657,
0.3097547293,
0.28527686,
-0.6959335804,
0.305175364,
-0.2120501846,
-0.0846594423,
0.1074949503,
-0.5845888853,
0.739703238,
0.0238493066,
-0.2978066206,
0.2366956472,
0.3666418791,
0.0160719212,
-0.0028399152,
0.2781397402,
0.4192627966,
0.5071150661,
-0.1143388003,
0.9171379209,
-0.298476994,
0.2128588408,
1.463909626,
-0.3544199467,
1.0024218559,
0.7203343511,
-0.0647442043,
0.0801161081,
0.3605989814,
0.2933703661,
0.4230736494,
0.229013592,
-0.1555118859,
-0.2841945887,
-0.0961506888,
-0.3579447865,
0.2887634635,
0.6915817857,
-0.1584848315,
-0.2668721676,
-0.1812234968,
-0.12457899,
-0.1676861644,
-0.1017845273,
0.9217221141,
0.1458476186,
-0.8709260225,
0.451672852,
-0.0796617195,
0.6385439634,
-0.7680715919,
0.0349008106,
-0.1085369959,
0.1816856414,
-0.2625421882,
-0.7987678051,
0.3699190617,
-0.0001937922,
-0.3483417332,
0.265635699,
0.9032406807,
-0.2175370753,
-0.3868962228,
0.2551796734,
0.6718753576,
-0.0264293123,
0.0227768403,
-0.318318069,
0.1690647751,
-0.0823167041,
-0.2984011769,
0.6288115978,
0.6129900813,
-0.1148341149,
1.1125617027,
0.5167436004,
0.2866006494,
0.141707167,
-0.2354164422,
0.826218307,
-0.5256755948,
-0.1806786209,
-0.9492551088,
0.1335964501,
0.0823032483,
-0.2152377814,
0.8945230842,
0.2628252506,
0.8011670709,
-0.0150901321,
0.7705281377,
-0.1063894853,
0.784645021,
-0.5360321999,
0.7253706455,
-0.5032922029,
0.7268473506,
-0.3429033756,
-0.9215926528,
-0.2075709701,
0.3210091889,
-0.2320608497,
0.1615245491,
0.5608365536,
0.9446793199,
-0.1521686912,
-0.3726737499,
0.4763019383,
0.4090175927,
0.1082207635,
0.401745379,
1.1040524244,
-0.154988572,
0.9328913093,
0.1053322032,
0.0787402987,
-0.196052447,
-0.6527363658,
-0.8956005573,
-0.6788641214,
-0.101788722,
-0.6407589912,
0.0891623423,
0.5652142763,
0.7247153521,
-1.0314311981,
0.0260846801,
0.1697518826,
0.2963414788,
0.4706015885,
-0.2629764974,
0.3735936582,
-0.2816353738,
-0.4004238248,
0.0545166247,
0.3613286912,
-0.009225985,
-0.2954447865,
0.147594735,
-0.2858750522,
0.1489607245,
0.7014747262,
0.3096452057,
-0.851323843,
-0.5556226373,
0.013441084,
-0.4117224514,
-0.0775397941,
0.6475872397,
-0.5410388112,
0.1466079652,
0.6220037341,
0.9469825625,
0.1693621725,
0.1710785776,
0.439027518,
-0.6415612102,
0.1101128235,
0.2255161852,
0.3154760003,
0.4378593266,
-0.4919438958,
0.1201111898,
0.0721571967,
-0.4932594597,
-0.7246329784,
0.234428376,
-0.7853880525,
-0.3751134574,
1.5047613382,
-0.2261579037,
-0.2318194807,
-0.5142896175,
-0.1226104125,
-0.1269378215,
-0.1621344686,
0.7363067269,
1.30654037,
0.1047482714,
0.0645833611,
-0.7559866309,
0.2684135139,
0.6005802751,
-0.694183588,
-0.0079277037,
0.6018755436,
0.6676068902,
0.2165294886,
0.5943731666,
-0.3568333685,
0.0671743527,
-0.0832514539,
-0.5730741024,
0.3074433506,
-0.1512511671,
-0.223599866,
0.5468322635,
0.6283322573,
0.0811471194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03301v1
|
Probing Large Language Models for Scalar Adjective Lexical Semantics and Scalar Diversity Pragmatics
| 2024-04-04T08:52:25 | 2024-04-04T08:52:25 |
Fangru Lin, Daniel Altshuler, Janet B. Pierrehumbert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scalar adjectives pertain to various domain scales and vary in intensity
within each scale (e.g. certain is more intense than likely on the likelihood
scale). Scalar implicatures arise from the consideration of alternative
statements which could have been made. They can be triggered by scalar
adjectives and require listeners to reason pragmatically about them. Some
scalar adjectives are more likely to trigger scalar implicatures than others.
This phenomenon is referred to as scalar diversity. In this study, we probe
different families of Large Language Models such as GPT-4 for their knowledge
of the lexical semantics of scalar adjectives and one specific aspect of their
pragmatics, namely scalar diversity. We find that they encode rich
lexical-semantic information about scalar adjectives. However, the rich
lexical-semantic knowledge does not entail a good understanding of scalar
diversity. We also compare current models of different sizes and complexities
and find that larger models are not always better. Finally, we explain our
probing results by leveraging linguistic intuitions and model training
objectives.
|
[
-0.7603594661,
-0.7979405522,
0.2082367837,
0.016763214,
0.0310976952,
-0.0146603798,
-0.1897727251,
-0.4617998004,
0.0244758185,
0.2898342013,
-0.3951260149,
-0.0649504587,
-0.8643501997,
0.1565807313,
-0.3547306359,
1.4555504322,
0.1437162608,
-0.0318499282,
-0.0156693384,
-0.2831104994,
-0.1912072152,
-0.7328317165,
-0.2913763523,
-0.0468999185,
0.7593842745,
0.2594586015,
1.0464465618,
0.4900430143,
0.7782643437,
0.3688245714,
-0.4981316328,
-0.048838187,
-0.6429623365,
0.2502870858,
-0.3522378802,
-0.4511229098,
-0.1575719267,
-0.1019961312,
0.8082991838,
0.8246369958,
0.0382873677,
0.186241135,
-0.136966154,
0.4242610335,
-0.7515300512,
0.0770546272,
-0.6307430267,
-0.0606441125,
-0.0897203982,
0.0855104402,
0.0366148576,
-0.1160156205,
0.4197434485,
-0.3408338726,
0.4063840806,
-0.0862936676,
1.1991099119,
0.0946732908,
-0.7610525489,
-0.2586729825,
-0.7740251422,
0.8246032596,
-0.7431507707,
0.4231441319,
0.3406077027,
0.2976617813,
0.0340838619,
-0.7404693961,
-0.7990258932,
-0.3920376003,
-0.1614403427,
-0.0286891498,
-0.2803342044,
0.0822852701,
0.3304119706,
0.753100872,
-0.4343495071,
0.0394181572,
-0.1285938174,
-0.034993656,
0.2830282748,
0.2669560313,
0.2932471931,
-0.2144133151,
-0.1849883348,
-0.0195047855,
-0.5923861265,
-0.0525652058,
0.3483599424,
0.105968304,
0.0077185058,
0.6255525351,
-0.154668197,
0.7335464954,
0.0267929453,
-0.0636279806,
0.2825523913,
-0.795055747,
-0.0310459211,
-0.423352778,
0.580249548,
0.1513867825,
0.0728304908,
-0.1633212864,
-0.3585706651,
0.1237518862,
-0.0216026492,
-0.9397639632,
-0.0657722726,
-0.0950877294,
-0.1937072128,
-0.148429051,
-0.0520393997,
-0.8576450944,
-0.3059698641,
-0.1587391496,
0.5413886309,
-0.4755714238,
-0.4451474845,
0.1346356422,
-0.274207145,
0.62571913,
0.0771041587,
-1.1377886534,
0.2047066987,
1.0395015478,
0.4807184339,
0.1749484837,
-0.4397545457,
-0.4540922642,
-0.2099173814,
-0.2029629052,
0.7286450863,
-0.897569716,
-0.3177137673,
-0.0907572657,
0.0625322834,
-0.0761677697,
-0.360396117,
0.7056196928,
-0.576402247,
0.3434800804,
-0.4889601469,
-0.671400249,
-0.5392407775,
0.2612887025,
-0.5950171947,
0.7132049203,
0.4225444794,
-0.9141746759,
0.8679702282,
-0.3355026543,
-0.2141301185,
0.4259179533,
-0.0650570914,
-0.4713791311,
0.3489678204,
0.1637721509,
0.3080004752,
-0.3538736105,
0.1351074427,
-0.3416938186,
-0.162899822,
0.5223897696,
-0.1955316663,
0.426666826,
0.2456813306,
-0.2447042763,
0.1167386174,
-0.4919017553,
-0.1736759096,
0.0005816493,
-0.1533923894,
-0.6036084294,
-0.0594006814,
-0.1490700394,
0.1761059612,
0.1909610033,
-0.327547431,
0.0143101299,
-0.4735298753,
0.2714288533,
0.3705696464,
0.1649848521,
0.3979507685,
-0.3862799406,
0.66370821,
0.1725023389,
-0.1524766684,
-0.1484416276,
-0.6028757691,
-0.894530952,
-0.6749401689,
0.1648504436,
0.192919299,
-0.4665417075,
0.3062238395,
-0.431455195,
-0.3475841284,
-0.4717813134,
-0.0110691264,
0.3625186384,
0.3264560699,
0.0733454227,
-0.1758601815,
-0.3005774021,
-1.0190247297,
-0.5845698714,
-0.0494592302,
0.0681765378,
0.4992752075,
0.9925714135,
-0.3927794993,
0.9502566457,
-0.2780642211,
0.0622288287,
-0.3272191584,
0.4442561865,
0.1236437336,
0.0606348887,
0.7476194501,
-1.0964964628,
-0.1626209766,
0.2902954519,
-0.5486183167,
0.0843535364,
0.1153253391,
0.1391900629,
-0.2555118799,
0.0002368958,
-0.4886474609,
0.0945961401,
0.5344583988,
-0.5783435702,
0.5981379747,
-0.1351206601,
0.1095858961,
-0.9574293494,
-0.3126752973,
0.3270002902,
-0.017569419,
-0.8475739956,
0.5951183438,
0.0611251965,
0.1262886077,
-0.1791167408,
0.3613159359,
-0.4613420367,
-0.1028952897,
-0.1780332476,
-0.2373011559,
-0.1025322154,
0.3459020257,
-0.0155604193,
0.8270964026,
0.612909019,
-0.7321720719,
0.4742645323,
0.0054042926,
-0.376668632,
0.445147872,
-0.527105689,
-0.2726257741,
-0.3603385091,
0.0300594959,
-0.9051606655,
-0.5022274256,
-0.1747250706,
-0.2732922137,
0.3071757257,
-0.18388699,
-0.5054442286,
-0.4378208518,
-0.1593939513,
0.7177577019,
0.425472945,
-0.5848781466,
0.4941677749,
0.5610329509,
-0.2989563346,
-0.5473704338,
-0.6152787209,
0.0634175614,
-0.601141572,
-0.6454557776,
-0.0330698155,
0.0671259239,
-0.6475263834,
-0.0772633255,
-0.0120646143,
-0.3083333969,
-0.0434078723,
0.0704083219,
0.2745337188,
-0.5281094909,
0.0273602735,
-0.2025921494,
0.2513059676,
0.0592466481,
-0.4769304991,
0.1838046312,
-0.8620435596,
-0.254691124,
-0.0313194431,
0.2457906753,
0.7766014338,
-0.4517030716,
0.9700922966,
0.5713060498,
-0.1072480828,
-0.0487332121,
-0.6396006942,
-0.1558041722,
-0.4206807613,
0.5907480121,
-0.4487352669,
-1.3695429564,
0.7253188491,
0.1410540044,
-0.0876576304,
0.375916332,
0.9650458097,
0.3445827365,
1.0253287554,
0.644903481,
0.141083926,
0.4347825646,
-0.247217536,
0.3466425836,
-0.7473840117,
-0.0313831829,
-0.4651400745,
-0.1233362854,
-1.1758695841,
-0.5098655224,
0.1499075741,
-0.3618627787,
-0.2563542724,
0.2066227049,
-0.3024743795,
0.5109964013,
0.1980937421,
-0.311118722,
0.1156951487,
-0.0023043666,
0.0149921086,
-0.3380561173,
-0.5845919251,
-0.1604878455,
0.9138711095,
0.5148900747,
0.7107883692,
0.3828186691,
0.3240100443,
-0.2256326973,
0.1457827836,
-0.9782783985,
0.4864889979,
-0.1808073223,
-0.7917973995,
-0.1292123795,
-0.6913821697,
-0.8982505798,
0.7024998069,
-0.1564476639,
-0.4192199707,
0.5876565576,
-0.1483320296,
-0.0192198996,
0.1417476833,
-0.6302160621,
0.8806539774,
-0.2098360509,
-0.3202552497,
-0.1225774437,
-0.5075653791,
0.5961564183,
-0.3725835085,
0.5118181109,
0.030307997,
-0.1691597998,
0.3940833211,
-0.5767823458,
0.5447428226,
0.1696868986,
-0.2533692122,
0.2235239446,
0.0495067723,
0.4822362065,
-0.1871045977,
-0.0079233926,
0.1118041053,
-0.2533400655,
-0.3759857416,
-0.502150774,
0.7684369087,
-0.799093008,
-0.4057599306,
-0.4546976089,
-0.8518993258,
-0.2151895314,
0.004188559,
0.468490541,
0.4569512308,
-0.1272934973,
0.449978888,
0.65564996,
-0.1390642673,
0.0486986563,
0.5990735888,
-0.2078757733,
-0.0781741589,
1.101837635,
0.2522392869,
0.4074450433,
0.4980745018,
0.3597605228,
-0.1937906444,
-0.3846327662,
0.086051017,
0.3947518766,
-0.6209689975,
0.160632655,
-0.5789039135,
0.0027489739,
-0.3919160962,
0.0149411205,
-0.0705370978,
-0.6416183114,
0.0393679552,
-0.1785749346,
0.6488590837,
0.7609633207,
0.0508616753,
0.2432004213,
-0.5057804585,
0.294590354,
0.5933457017,
0.2823780477,
-0.1938921362,
-1.020742774,
-0.2300344557,
0.0278334618,
-0.0175457057,
-0.898116529,
0.6014574766,
0.4467236102,
0.5502304435,
0.5470237136,
-0.2946017385,
0.4558141232,
-0.3358332813,
0.8552535176,
0.0419718921,
-0.7061511874,
0.1634088308,
-0.8683475256,
0.3426162004,
0.2515108287,
0.4506095946,
-0.3810724318,
-0.8692412972,
-0.5093163848,
-1.0324773788,
0.4361825287,
0.1534704119,
0.1576229781,
-0.1940720528,
0.2780962884,
0.1199827939,
0.2195372283,
-0.9170575142,
-0.0551515184,
-0.56949687,
0.0445929877,
-0.1044103429,
-0.5120968223,
-0.111958012,
-0.1748845875,
0.3653025329,
0.0488860384,
0.0251969527,
-0.2651707232,
-0.1271291971,
0.1025804207,
0.56333673,
0.5434696078,
0.5076872706,
0.1303680539,
0.3522203863,
0.2207449377,
-0.6634835601,
0.0340927728,
0.0320977196,
-0.0026286957,
-0.0797770396,
0.3517113328,
1.1200294495,
0.5068031549,
-0.5389999747,
0.6109347939,
-0.1418325454,
-0.1837066561,
-0.0701497048,
-0.0462362543,
0.0864545926,
0.0141066667,
0.1751194,
-0.1792297065,
0.2807566822,
-0.5964952111,
0.1474501789,
0.6573774219,
-0.0489107519,
-0.38525635,
0.4069758058,
-0.0680212677,
0.0982001945,
0.3892346621,
-0.5525273681,
-0.7361153364,
0.613812089,
0.5898306966,
0.8641345501,
-0.2010867894,
-0.0721591562,
0.33911255,
0.3370283544,
-0.0069766543,
0.0143006369,
-0.0394551605,
-0.7978428006,
-0.5275757909,
-0.9003350139,
-0.4218981266,
0.2513224483,
-0.6296348572,
0.1491311938,
-0.3360125721,
-0.2344277054,
0.0786814913,
-0.3503140211,
-0.5567185283,
0.2173805684,
0.0719782934,
0.4256635606,
-0.8444753289,
0.4860362113,
0.9981379509,
-0.6550237536,
-1.1678179502,
0.1961614192,
0.1028892696,
-0.6448634863,
1.1394363642,
-0.0362150706,
-0.1200314164,
-0.0735155642,
-0.3837093115,
-0.9778677821,
0.5292944312,
0.0283443537,
-0.3012480438,
-0.1325082183,
0.2192185074,
0.7798495293,
-0.3596728444,
0.4110941291,
0.6673110127,
0.4610134959,
0.3918986022,
-0.9406229854,
-0.1345865875,
-0.2841948569,
0.1694144607,
0.4639685154,
-0.3678997457,
1.2318196297,
-0.2145659178,
-0.0344497524,
0.0069131111,
0.7880386114,
0.0397672877,
-0.0889183357,
0.232570067,
0.6800667048,
0.5434871912,
-0.0969537646,
1.2505289316,
-0.3749780655,
0.5278881788,
0.7150194645,
-0.1348069459,
0.5243329406,
0.1717559993,
-0.2513383031,
0.5582869053,
0.5226388574,
-0.2515913844,
0.2215694636,
0.1372588128,
-0.7635579705,
-0.1101668626,
-0.0604054369,
-0.3004749119,
0.7513967752,
0.8122692108,
-0.1670449823,
-0.360149473,
0.1329905242,
0.1365757436,
-0.3283031583,
-0.5217452645,
0.8535446525,
-0.0088072577,
-0.8232597709,
0.7692812085,
-0.1035516337,
0.7219176888,
-0.6409007311,
0.2270485163,
-0.2668685317,
0.3090375364,
-0.1977539957,
-0.8184573054,
0.2150092274,
0.1354986876,
-0.098759003,
0.074118413,
0.648535192,
-0.4398904741,
-0.4514920115,
0.0892987773,
0.3151879609,
0.2156057954,
0.1310138702,
-0.5176845789,
-0.376175344,
-0.1960968077,
-0.2865135968,
0.5474019051,
1.0131802559,
-0.1265444607,
0.6848058105,
0.4849074483,
0.4444095194,
0.314317286,
0.1218371168,
0.7661287785,
-0.5024034977,
-0.5182517171,
-0.7915822864,
0.2818867862,
0.2245028764,
-0.3078101575,
1.0799845457,
0.4251427948,
0.5501838326,
-0.031581074,
0.6907230616,
0.1316445619,
0.4372787774,
-0.073069416,
0.4893138707,
-0.5832704306,
0.1694265902,
-0.3978601396,
-0.8233130574,
-0.2146029323,
0.7875513434,
-0.643663764,
0.2640604675,
0.6839988232,
0.8444591761,
-0.0886626542,
0.1769594848,
0.2696288228,
0.5004666448,
0.199715063,
0.3465811312,
1.1071455479,
0.0630459711,
0.3919541836,
0.1672521979,
-0.4756126106,
-0.3643650413,
-0.7657592297,
-0.5139647722,
-0.5401831865,
-0.1663537771,
-0.315307647,
-0.1071558818,
0.5033760667,
0.48753196,
-0.6529538631,
-0.2156220526,
-0.3396343589,
0.0637816489,
-0.0674274266,
-0.2673377395,
-0.1523441225,
-0.3961232007,
-0.6280181408,
0.0423486382,
0.2459867299,
0.0199695956,
-0.2138953358,
0.0764123872,
0.0163727477,
0.3134144843,
0.6397650838,
0.4001649916,
-0.7361010909,
-0.3712795973,
-0.1420221031,
-0.1668967307,
-0.159348622,
0.7652422786,
-0.6511898637,
0.4729765654,
0.7491207719,
0.6182098985,
0.3005153835,
-0.1146282628,
0.5388210416,
-0.6112357378,
0.2427072674,
0.4186938405,
0.537360549,
0.3826792836,
-0.21986866,
0.2103803307,
0.4393253028,
-0.8833450675,
-0.7676415443,
0.6978037357,
-0.6588542461,
-0.288136214,
1.4697682858,
-0.0526743792,
0.0426609516,
-0.1328550279,
0.0460565016,
-0.0437762775,
-0.1535011828,
0.4733991027,
0.8874732256,
-0.0661806166,
-0.1888502985,
-0.5827574134,
0.4965230227,
0.4703812003,
-0.6529117823,
0.1433695555,
0.7651563883,
0.3395785391,
0.1447796971,
0.1674636751,
-0.173459515,
0.4100349844,
0.1735104322,
-0.2125789523,
0.3307284713,
-0.0440382287,
-0.523804307,
0.2517311573,
0.2460604757,
0.1864040047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04293v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04293v1
|
Reason from Fallacy: Enhancing Large Language Models' Logical Reasoning through Logical Fallacy Understanding
| 2024-04-04T08:38:03 | 2024-04-04T08:38:03 |
Yanda Li, Dixuan Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Guochao Jiang, Qianyu He, Yanghua Xiao, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated good performance in many
reasoning tasks, but they still struggle with some complicated reasoning tasks
including logical reasoning. One non-negligible reason for LLMs' suboptimal
performance on logical reasoning is their overlooking of understanding logical
fallacies correctly. To evaluate LLMs' capability of logical fallacy
understanding (LFU), we propose five concrete tasks from three cognitive
dimensions of WHAT, WHY, and HOW in this paper. Towards these LFU tasks, we
have successfully constructed a new dataset LFUD based on GPT-4 accompanied by
a little human effort. Our extensive experiments justify that our LFUD can be
used not only to evaluate LLMs' LFU capability, but also to fine-tune LLMs to
obtain significantly enhanced performance on logical reasoning.
|
[
-0.3708443046,
-0.8272198439,
0.9174633622,
0.0799889341,
-0.2855874002,
-0.0465309843,
-0.0580514781,
-0.2689996064,
-0.2684403658,
0.7496005893,
-0.6648940444,
-0.4124564826,
-0.6311855912,
0.1693898886,
-0.2960703969,
1.0356514454,
-0.0513034388,
0.0273817237,
-0.4812522531,
-0.1151759028,
-0.4889486432,
-0.5696007013,
-0.4391398728,
-0.831484437,
0.2230724096,
0.520753324,
0.7019437551,
0.2862633765,
0.657269299,
0.3677101135,
0.0642445162,
0.3129088283,
-0.7960463762,
-0.4608880877,
-0.3186499178,
-0.7471018434,
-0.3750721514,
0.0371508151,
0.377674073,
0.6432470083,
-0.2823623419,
0.053546641,
-0.2268786281,
0.7879691124,
-0.391631335,
0.3557620943,
-0.609234333,
0.1116642728,
0.0152941812,
0.0670218989,
-0.4724835157,
-0.4486194253,
0.044133015,
-0.6134227514,
0.316483885,
-0.0675732121,
0.5685231686,
0.5505643487,
-0.4936142862,
-0.1146240458,
-0.5915675163,
0.9307489991,
-0.9421688318,
0.5771134496,
0.1980986446,
0.1505843252,
-0.2895932794,
-0.4677992761,
-0.693136394,
-0.2338795513,
-0.127572,
-0.063870199,
0.0559075251,
0.0777638406,
0.6780754924,
0.3760394156,
-0.3377909362,
-0.1029399037,
-0.154608652,
-0.204716742,
0.603007257,
0.1743624657,
0.2413987219,
-0.0568168461,
-0.3035750687,
0.288100332,
-0.7819719911,
-0.1141544208,
0.2077372521,
0.041648034,
0.0041120024,
0.4038057625,
-0.0436987877,
0.8198043108,
-0.0244316198,
-0.4636575878,
0.24210383,
-0.4397738874,
-0.483640641,
-0.1773781627,
0.4123138785,
0.3760168552,
0.5593633056,
-0.0209856965,
-0.2632189095,
0.2654154599,
0.1085194275,
-0.6274598241,
-0.2343677878,
0.0241289977,
-0.5436686277,
-0.3501934409,
-0.2395327985,
-0.3200857937,
-0.6004394889,
-0.6261387467,
0.3102157116,
-0.7250641584,
-0.3404903114,
0.4902237058,
-0.1270221621,
0.0969170108,
0.7350722551,
-0.7480066419,
0.3920078278,
0.7868961692,
0.4079390764,
-0.3426625133,
-0.3312320113,
-0.5231303573,
0.112166509,
-0.3813611865,
0.7786802053,
-0.4682573974,
-0.1268900633,
-0.2633097768,
-0.0320257843,
-0.1543979049,
-0.6731298566,
0.9246361852,
-0.3783287406,
0.2391888201,
-0.7220726013,
-0.6151829362,
-0.652872622,
0.3754087389,
-0.698928833,
0.690744698,
0.1249735877,
-0.749552846,
0.4503594339,
-0.9243284464,
-0.5706089139,
0.1027504131,
-0.3513638079,
-0.0388133116,
0.3930389285,
0.5155753493,
0.3736651838,
-0.4909433722,
0.2281002849,
-0.1944363266,
-0.3117416203,
0.2787285745,
-0.5207737684,
0.8030990958,
0.1049374714,
-0.2866332531,
-0.0271015745,
-0.6146776676,
-0.079147093,
0.1664285213,
-0.5415945649,
-0.2982163727,
0.4230937064,
-0.3032507002,
0.1832844764,
0.2627595067,
-0.306871444,
-0.0416224599,
-0.6168694496,
0.5619234443,
0.7170625925,
-0.060031414,
0.0593025535,
-0.2662708163,
0.3640640378,
0.2795580029,
0.1063397229,
0.2872106731,
-0.3767572343,
-0.7974864244,
-0.2115806639,
-0.0315559469,
0.6004397869,
-0.9078857303,
0.1945415586,
-0.2817783058,
-0.1496520936,
-0.2398573607,
0.5649544001,
0.2316779494,
0.8985101581,
0.3623158038,
0.0823915228,
-0.2036486715,
-1.0297621489,
-0.3331661224,
-0.3057834506,
0.0524338,
0.1359566748,
0.8200209141,
-0.1616295874,
0.8481858969,
-0.5145216584,
-0.1495193243,
-0.7000764012,
-0.059192244,
0.6308278441,
0.1242955774,
0.6112861633,
-0.7843495011,
0.1355482638,
-0.0508584566,
-0.9141598344,
-0.2552726269,
-0.0287879631,
0.0384326391,
0.3059301376,
0.3377252221,
-0.8459802866,
0.2395796627,
0.1900736839,
-0.4432082474,
0.6479600668,
-0.0638634562,
0.1084835529,
-0.7158461809,
-0.3029833138,
0.225595966,
-0.3826718032,
-0.5172378421,
0.2799757123,
-0.0570558161,
0.1776291877,
-0.5111878514,
0.0960255116,
-0.3292844296,
-0.0441896878,
-0.0324609913,
0.436188072,
0.0710562095,
0.2002772838,
-0.0126552582,
0.3834220171,
0.17866081,
-0.4397158325,
0.740380168,
0.0325902738,
-0.4294061959,
0.7395392656,
-0.5404435992,
-0.0033401095,
-0.2673829198,
0.3029031754,
-0.6916319132,
-0.1773264855,
0.1123086065,
-0.2636553645,
-0.0521568321,
-0.0033812367,
-0.5887800455,
-0.3845196664,
-0.1836669147,
0.2881390154,
0.3535048366,
-0.6701576114,
0.677851975,
0.2844280899,
0.2905507386,
-0.6337601542,
-0.8275632262,
-0.0636344552,
-0.4958521724,
-0.757748723,
-0.0928062648,
-0.1405824423,
-0.4782925844,
-0.2402149439,
-0.2009786367,
0.2557734549,
-0.0138567258,
-0.0617328733,
0.1181683987,
-0.2783368528,
0.1665939093,
-0.3238557875,
0.0458816551,
0.423925817,
-0.1811188012,
0.2508187592,
-0.2938424051,
-0.5391650796,
-0.4686178267,
0.0527136959,
0.5458310843,
0.0076525654,
0.4347432256,
0.2547430396,
-0.5782201886,
-0.3625532687,
-0.6534017324,
-0.228280738,
-0.4354953766,
0.4670204818,
-0.4359204769,
-0.7393266559,
0.3258251846,
-0.0298256818,
0.1376782954,
0.4182237685,
0.666098237,
-0.0969591737,
0.8887911439,
0.36469239,
-0.2506989539,
-0.0178882461,
-0.1179595515,
0.2740108967,
-0.386082232,
-0.2033351809,
-0.3796688616,
-0.1935853362,
-0.3180504739,
-0.709017396,
0.1436955184,
0.0429463275,
-0.2523011863,
-0.0902298018,
-0.2550581992,
0.6479059458,
0.1448298544,
0.0765548572,
0.5021230578,
0.1329077631,
-0.1695662737,
-0.2423500419,
-0.5570201278,
-0.4805931449,
0.8313649297,
0.6521458626,
0.9328235984,
0.4094138741,
0.4839693904,
0.3411788642,
0.2803055644,
-0.9075353146,
0.8630250096,
-0.24197869,
-0.6935839057,
-0.2904333472,
-0.7005290389,
-0.3742509186,
0.4055246711,
0.0076398822,
-0.6951858401,
-0.2031606138,
0.3231887519,
-0.0233817343,
0.0515560806,
-0.8205738664,
0.8817290664,
-0.3092189133,
-0.0327140912,
-0.4948402345,
-0.2901418507,
0.8615972996,
-0.1012417972,
0.5062168837,
-0.0781521201,
-0.0638171285,
0.8003903031,
-0.7071056366,
0.8091005087,
-0.2719655633,
-0.5008041263,
0.1796034127,
0.012155897,
0.5285915136,
0.2156996727,
-0.2255251557,
0.0750055909,
-0.0013666969,
-0.3174823225,
-0.8350777626,
0.8123596311,
-0.6370023489,
-0.8816994429,
-0.4007919133,
-0.5828174949,
-0.3327289224,
0.1306827515,
-0.0048575816,
0.2510666847,
-0.1360954344,
0.12847808,
0.6792307496,
-0.0159659926,
0.4066519439,
0.3473613262,
-0.2861717045,
-0.2385221571,
0.7802880406,
0.028270252,
0.2685277462,
0.4425930083,
0.284293741,
-0.5661203265,
-0.7057370543,
-0.3283534646,
0.4126181901,
-1.2137746811,
-0.0435370319,
-0.2110099345,
-0.137517184,
-0.2346438766,
0.0553260148,
-0.0674789026,
-0.3014727533,
-0.1184658483,
-0.3283420205,
0.3081738949,
0.7223205566,
0.0436437912,
0.2513695955,
-0.6946758032,
0.6352188587,
0.3589018881,
0.0326528363,
-0.1954351068,
-0.6070867181,
0.0728085786,
-0.0884135589,
-0.3413732648,
-0.872068584,
0.0311043728,
0.0527585372,
0.8434726,
0.6630200744,
0.0057485374,
0.5556349754,
-0.3702271581,
0.6448661089,
0.1736612767,
-1.1343135834,
0.6687341928,
-0.2556727529,
0.1856975555,
0.2821311951,
0.3255372345,
-0.101843603,
-0.0770952925,
-0.5268673301,
-0.3802517056,
0.7756143808,
0.3220202029,
-0.1283587962,
0.1345218718,
0.3933256269,
0.12440072,
0.1306331456,
-0.9533568621,
0.0233730339,
-0.1354461014,
-0.2485096604,
-0.2717245817,
-0.1060282439,
-0.3544256091,
-0.3705825806,
0.5916683078,
-0.3398595452,
-0.0250119362,
0.0681091547,
-0.3405382335,
-0.0824769065,
0.1391750425,
0.6847283244,
1.0425685644,
-0.0895752311,
0.227952227,
0.5956964493,
-0.4047692418,
0.1550403833,
0.1098127589,
-0.1482123584,
-0.3122390807,
0.803807795,
0.7584846616,
-0.0796659514,
-0.5930703878,
0.3883018494,
-0.0096200863,
-0.3818181455,
-0.3051078916,
0.3543429077,
0.5010080934,
0.1809148341,
0.1946799457,
-0.1003424004,
0.0115238037,
-0.5907902122,
0.0436265767,
0.4484800398,
-0.0123998616,
-0.1538413912,
0.4273442924,
0.227824524,
-0.1600658745,
0.6272889972,
0.0444206409,
-0.5907999873,
0.4883382618,
0.6151263118,
0.3137822449,
-0.1714018285,
0.2632349133,
0.059669286,
0.7263101339,
-0.1356144845,
0.571303308,
0.1564154178,
-1.1127926111,
-0.8159626126,
-0.6715569496,
-0.2642711997,
0.6047136188,
-0.1836851388,
0.4177769721,
-0.6023079157,
0.1299208105,
-0.000011825,
-0.0023572133,
-0.5334405303,
0.5194067955,
0.1280157715,
1.0507129431,
-0.8884529471,
0.5791625977,
0.6834799051,
-0.3083841205,
-0.5488125086,
0.1105800271,
0.1027132496,
-0.7944640517,
0.757848978,
0.1455994099,
-0.4138509631,
-0.1329736114,
-0.5607258081,
-0.5760970712,
0.663985014,
0.8153190613,
-0.626598835,
-0.029563779,
0.3675730824,
0.3685121536,
-0.4968391061,
0.1317321658,
1.0353957415,
0.6344944239,
0.1591473222,
-0.54098171,
0.4806662798,
0.1128241941,
-0.11404147,
0.1694871932,
-0.5611453056,
0.5986829996,
-0.4866087437,
0.165166229,
-0.4342446625,
0.5866459012,
0.6610916257,
0.2798772752,
0.9184724689,
0.8857824802,
0.7193036079,
-0.1442984641,
0.8066152334,
0.2307845056,
0.3030649722,
0.8925209045,
-0.3573983312,
0.7159400582,
0.4601795375,
-0.3167611063,
0.3868403733,
0.7132133842,
0.1127498895,
0.3109162748,
0.3504547179,
-0.2986013293,
-0.7998273969,
0.2800179422,
-0.2717187703,
0.5032584071,
0.743722856,
-0.3025571108,
-0.3151225746,
-0.1730793715,
0.044187855,
0.1145270616,
-0.2347655296,
0.3944129944,
0.1989031434,
-0.5797988176,
0.7567844391,
0.0404637828,
0.3386201859,
-0.222584784,
-0.1803016663,
-0.2422540933,
0.3045790792,
-0.4867654443,
-0.6601358652,
0.1999539882,
-0.0496835485,
-0.1348333508,
0.0389094092,
0.7056825161,
0.1482546031,
-0.7656576037,
0.4172489643,
0.5357447863,
0.3939189017,
0.1184220538,
-0.8498135209,
0.0983613878,
0.2295295894,
-0.2562696934,
0.1008388028,
0.7189858556,
-0.2071306407,
0.6743884087,
0.7409754395,
0.1674024612,
-0.3865152299,
0.4477272332,
0.7240481377,
-0.8841164708,
-0.3938764036,
-1.1736980677,
0.169347018,
-0.1725935489,
-0.0730400532,
0.3823524117,
0.3671025038,
0.6794736385,
-0.1818318218,
1.0702000856,
-0.0408362523,
0.5267783999,
-0.8438987732,
0.6208207607,
-0.6980836987,
0.4230113626,
-0.245436132,
-0.9493010044,
-0.1836333126,
0.8067978024,
-0.5272191167,
0.1877990663,
0.9255055189,
0.6481721997,
-0.2465848923,
0.2806880474,
0.5805096626,
0.5568675399,
0.4624815881,
0.9003721476,
0.9455632567,
-0.1310671866,
0.5999576449,
0.0156157305,
-0.3279644251,
-0.1680543572,
-1.2831171751,
-1.074704051,
-0.2149516046,
-0.3608783185,
-0.1728697419,
-0.1794070154,
0.7487758994,
0.561999619,
-0.750761807,
-0.1096883044,
-0.3323332965,
0.4855305254,
-0.0440071039,
-0.2415992916,
0.103577964,
-0.3084252477,
-0.6507979035,
0.6353589296,
0.1126345322,
-0.2496666908,
-0.2855252028,
-0.1327588707,
-0.1589062363,
0.2294702083,
0.7044457793,
-0.0916703716,
-0.9649336338,
-0.5177029967,
-0.459320724,
0.3150240779,
-0.0350339152,
0.7386252284,
-0.7238661051,
-0.0804417208,
0.7409693003,
0.5781213045,
0.2541556954,
0.1119306162,
0.6613824964,
-0.3424311578,
-0.0273403879,
0.0440316349,
0.5331214666,
0.5320068002,
-0.3572963178,
0.5927618146,
0.5976093411,
-0.5046081543,
-0.695515275,
0.4390693307,
-0.6921213269,
-0.2314939648,
1.0260218382,
-0.2251887918,
-0.108225368,
-0.171422869,
-0.201661095,
-0.02779066,
-0.2886424363,
0.6682694554,
1.0315611362,
-0.5647476315,
-0.3735343814,
-0.9463883042,
0.5661905408,
0.5362257957,
-1.1529760361,
0.1109429449,
0.8278979659,
0.653375268,
0.1251778752,
0.5945812464,
-0.0809028745,
0.2799595594,
-0.2793389559,
-0.3273440301,
0.0872202367,
-0.1834511608,
-0.1170113608,
0.2288210094,
0.1743988991,
-0.0081002377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03278v1
|
Evaluating Document Simplification: On the Importance of Separately Assessing Simplicity and Meaning Preservation
| 2024-04-04T08:04:24 | 2024-04-04T08:04:24 |
Liam Cripwell, Joël Legrand, Claire Gardent
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text simplification intends to make a text easier to read while preserving
its core meaning. Intuitively and as shown in previous works, these two
dimensions (simplification and meaning preservation) are often-times inversely
correlated. An overly conservative text will fail to simplify sufficiently,
whereas extreme simplification will degrade meaning preservation. Yet, popular
evaluation metrics either aggregate meaning preservation and simplification
into a single score (SARI, LENS), or target meaning preservation alone
(BERTScore, QuestEval). Moreover, these metrics usually require a set of
references and most previous work has only focused on sentence-level
simplification. In this paper, we focus on the evaluation of document-level
text simplification and compare existing models using distinct metrics for
meaning preservation and simplification. We leverage existing metrics from
similar tasks and introduce a reference-less metric variant for simplicity,
showing that models are mostly biased towards either simplification or meaning
preservation, seldom performing well on both dimensions. Making use of the fact
that the metrics we use are all reference-less, we also investigate the
performance of existing models when applied to unseen data (where reference
simplifications are unavailable).
|
[
-0.0872435197,
-0.53317976,
0.7345539331,
0.2709679902,
-0.7121529579,
-0.4970707595,
-0.1728016883,
-0.329059422,
0.0086789466,
0.1061120406,
-0.6197193265,
-0.3844807744,
-0.7133604288,
0.228588447,
-0.4182073772,
1.2801046371,
-0.1181988195,
0.2487262338,
-0.668533802,
-0.4076633751,
-0.2406174988,
-0.1552514285,
-0.4476640522,
-0.4997166991,
0.3805313706,
0.2689936757,
0.8486385345,
1.0461188555,
1.0131896734,
0.2032047361,
-0.4997786283,
-0.0828273967,
-0.6412576437,
0.004468482,
-0.0598838776,
-0.3413105011,
-0.5337801576,
0.2238324285,
0.6341663599,
1.1767250299,
0.0961385146,
0.2956751287,
-0.0345961414,
0.7813852429,
-0.8541381359,
0.2352616638,
-0.4178297818,
-0.287960887,
0.0900664106,
-0.1441397667,
-0.1267532706,
-0.5910865664,
0.0639096275,
-0.6896080971,
0.3173182905,
-0.0415767431,
0.9511703253,
0.416626215,
-0.4291401803,
-0.5212862492,
-0.8543543816,
0.9634711146,
-0.3652173281,
0.1360592097,
0.1030569077,
-0.0068037217,
0.3312775195,
-0.702465415,
-0.5642683506,
-0.1059563607,
-0.1645210534,
0.4371433556,
-0.3899672329,
0.0272379983,
0.4680522084,
0.5564278364,
-0.2141494453,
-0.1819570214,
-0.7124342322,
-0.1863651574,
0.6904715896,
0.1963564754,
0.1223450527,
-0.4995664358,
-0.6988587379,
-0.4108133912,
-0.4999330342,
0.029708866,
0.2324192971,
0.1426302493,
0.1556222141,
0.5120889544,
-0.1917971373,
-0.0542227589,
-0.352873832,
-0.4910705388,
0.407661736,
-0.8469812274,
-0.3406832218,
-0.3865736723,
0.6919493079,
0.5620202422,
0.1530935019,
-0.2373941839,
-0.1531988978,
0.1099279225,
0.2498899698,
-0.7375199199,
0.2008726448,
0.0327002406,
-0.8546375632,
-0.0581610575,
0.3651925027,
-0.374166131,
-0.2806266546,
-0.3204945326,
0.4718027115,
-0.5901153684,
0.1979853213,
0.2546977103,
-0.7010227442,
0.1287803352,
0.9559238553,
-0.4001694918,
0.2869744599,
0.8763715625,
0.6177014112,
-0.1832086146,
-0.4184477329,
-0.0260327403,
0.0676506609,
-0.3004653752,
0.7197304964,
-0.3954902887,
-0.682390511,
-0.3118020296,
-0.3034166694,
0.1707671732,
-0.4490027726,
1.6090666056,
0.0779795572,
0.2447371483,
-0.4786087573,
-0.6843919754,
-0.2428675145,
0.2258399278,
-0.8320339918,
1.0560669899,
-0.0978026539,
-0.8871588707,
0.5087441802,
-0.4442842603,
-0.2648141682,
-0.0892159417,
0.1883547455,
-0.6451292038,
0.6504362822,
-0.0653631985,
0.054958757,
-0.5737648606,
-0.1508969963,
-0.3093269467,
-0.4990827739,
-0.1371090114,
-0.7754465342,
0.5245891809,
0.230842337,
-0.0391397774,
-0.2590028942,
-0.6848697662,
0.0865281373,
-0.150900051,
-0.4416592121,
-0.8409251571,
-0.0074932897,
0.1247032657,
0.2572166622,
0.6221119761,
-0.7114056349,
0.1309598982,
-0.192171976,
-0.0395430587,
0.2410445958,
0.1236035377,
0.6021463275,
-0.4688152671,
0.5259391665,
0.1760033518,
0.4238077998,
-0.23733145,
-0.1892507672,
-0.9174110293,
-0.3178264499,
0.5362474918,
0.3634233773,
-0.1321876645,
0.0414580852,
-0.8790987134,
-0.5967288613,
-0.7518459558,
0.3386861086,
0.4256721437,
0.1988271475,
0.3343201876,
-0.2637090683,
-0.2141730636,
-1.2170726061,
-0.5921216607,
-0.1526975781,
-0.1688400358,
0.1481488347,
0.34361884,
-0.1966876239,
0.7162482142,
-0.5364940166,
-0.376029104,
-0.2530858219,
0.376719147,
0.0118672848,
0.3483449519,
0.4748417735,
-0.8935380578,
-0.3328303695,
-0.2523808181,
-0.779897213,
-0.267282635,
-0.1768466085,
0.1765980124,
-0.2167154551,
0.5570104122,
-0.6732769608,
0.7406927943,
0.2223618925,
0.1027937531,
0.1810039431,
-0.3490623236,
0.2445268482,
-0.7622938156,
0.2593981326,
-0.1960055381,
-0.0555340573,
-0.8036383986,
0.2138187438,
0.3658151329,
-0.1160316989,
-0.3198897541,
0.6729508042,
-0.7254599333,
0.1176060736,
-0.2247412056,
0.4981186092,
0.4871305227,
0.038091924,
-0.265463084,
0.302449882,
0.0224579219,
-0.2394503653,
-0.1086515561,
0.1913924664,
-0.1268530637,
0.5651960969,
-0.5390679836,
0.1668196321,
-0.4985122681,
0.1868007779,
-0.9411529899,
0.2006590664,
-0.1541014165,
-0.224640429,
0.0506915636,
0.2948355675,
-0.5741829872,
-0.1531224102,
-0.9479819536,
0.4303946495,
0.3051745296,
-0.1671849787,
0.6859320402,
-0.0976373926,
-0.1890202016,
-0.4555721879,
-0.7743663788,
-0.1280311793,
-0.337372005,
-0.6193863153,
0.2006642073,
-0.3599494696,
-0.5047942996,
0.1172384173,
-0.6009786725,
0.0117458543,
0.1816648096,
0.4721662998,
0.0546861179,
0.0178934764,
0.5647473931,
0.380069077,
-0.1156632453,
-0.1847106665,
0.1698022783,
-0.01255373,
0.0693681911,
-0.3374513686,
-0.3424806595,
0.8360916376,
0.6212203503,
0.0157711264,
0.8075174093,
0.4127741456,
-0.3119987249,
-0.171030581,
-0.6080803871,
0.1975477487,
-0.3316141963,
0.0340682715,
-0.5142678618,
-0.3902600706,
0.372299403,
-0.4459214807,
-0.0262016077,
0.7387250662,
0.1667530537,
-0.1325444728,
0.5658921599,
0.7658176422,
0.2455972433,
0.3041379452,
-0.1584800333,
0.3861425221,
-0.6375055909,
-0.3317651153,
-0.8300876617,
-0.0714361221,
-0.4640676975,
-0.2752474844,
0.4544862211,
0.5963551998,
0.3482178748,
0.1852647364,
-0.1752046943,
0.5704481602,
0.3328141272,
0.0114395088,
0.5621890426,
0.0209420472,
0.1419575512,
-0.1458574235,
-0.3794454336,
-0.973438561,
1.1407901049,
0.3560063839,
0.7918668389,
0.027250547,
0.9766749144,
0.0427389294,
0.3856033087,
-1.0245751143,
0.5224046707,
-0.5372375846,
-0.2563777566,
-0.2264661342,
-0.5713430643,
-0.8644835353,
0.2751838863,
-0.2594917715,
-0.3797098994,
0.1248973161,
-0.0429153852,
-0.1784880608,
-0.2081323862,
-0.9379799366,
0.6353289485,
0.058380384,
-0.0996968448,
-0.2458975464,
-0.3027129769,
0.2370674759,
-0.3645252287,
0.3696759641,
-0.0782852471,
-0.3652995825,
0.4805090725,
-0.4508915544,
0.3256718516,
0.1910646856,
0.0905153751,
-0.0123063521,
0.0429942943,
0.3657192886,
-0.1771443039,
-0.4699839056,
-0.0183460303,
0.1913629323,
-0.3655177355,
-1.064004302,
0.5894616842,
-0.6874213219,
-0.8584269285,
-0.1261053681,
-0.6926015019,
0.1940143555,
0.5488536358,
0.0767063871,
0.2672727406,
-0.6748939753,
0.5612133741,
0.5054351687,
0.0963491872,
0.4931653142,
0.2596194446,
0.1835005879,
-0.2214947194,
0.3589000404,
0.1739091277,
0.4641109705,
0.5257056952,
0.4730917513,
-0.3191650212,
-0.5952839851,
0.0693506151,
0.2131113708,
-1.1120989323,
-0.1456936747,
-0.7352108955,
0.0267634988,
-0.292552948,
-0.0572015606,
0.0332806818,
-0.9986823797,
-0.1860644519,
-0.0999896005,
-0.0970734358,
0.8234335184,
-0.1082999706,
0.1456066519,
-0.4974082708,
0.3908470273,
0.1907784194,
0.0589594245,
-0.0883086324,
-0.2612615228,
0.0041573928,
-0.0056105354,
-0.2444198728,
-0.8071096539,
0.0521600991,
0.37816149,
0.6591489315,
0.4651079774,
0.204194352,
0.6234683394,
-0.3126110137,
0.597507,
0.2132740617,
-1.2570821047,
0.6250988245,
-0.1267237365,
0.678096652,
1.0285916328,
0.4114709795,
-0.430055052,
-0.272367835,
-0.9580534697,
-0.8575787544,
0.7539191246,
0.3614724278,
0.3689097464,
0.2023105025,
0.5075811148,
0.1533104926,
0.4473882318,
-0.8041226864,
-0.3756276071,
-0.2413278818,
-0.375020653,
-0.0139933424,
-0.3767383695,
-0.4089571834,
-0.1030151471,
0.4214995801,
0.0465042368,
-0.0148827732,
0.1076778695,
-0.1150780469,
0.1198016629,
0.6417889595,
0.5518376231,
0.3651483953,
-0.143951714,
0.2011323869,
0.3603742123,
-0.5155673623,
0.0224490426,
-0.0260529127,
-0.4801794589,
0.2132903188,
0.6023111939,
0.77748698,
0.1731432974,
-0.3506181836,
0.8895663619,
-0.2112953663,
-0.1627330184,
0.0720186979,
-0.0791413859,
0.1632488966,
-0.2593945861,
0.2633592784,
0.3578541279,
0.3824093342,
-0.9112577438,
-0.1814659387,
0.35227108,
-0.1959553361,
-0.0637126788,
0.1790158004,
-0.0709962025,
-0.1960099041,
0.2434951961,
-0.1208052859,
-0.2493583858,
0.4433745146,
0.1234627515,
1.0036437511,
-0.0100621711,
0.0218312554,
0.2338670492,
0.5831163526,
-0.1712202281,
0.1361832619,
-0.39201805,
-0.3599001169,
0.3070512712,
-0.7530976534,
-0.3248013556,
-0.028423965,
-0.8557940722,
0.3948661387,
-0.5146222711,
-0.1427324116,
0.4298029244,
0.1959555447,
-0.8341065645,
0.4014291465,
-0.127942577,
1.2486997843,
-1.054125905,
0.5422757268,
0.6642510295,
-0.6242328882,
-0.8771657348,
0.4155422151,
0.0731816068,
-0.2390481234,
0.6625849605,
0.1404971182,
-0.3640235066,
-0.3892582655,
-0.2497012019,
-0.7619481087,
1.2051296234,
0.5392832756,
-0.3028544784,
-0.131342575,
0.2149141282,
1.0638360977,
-0.1973388642,
0.436833024,
0.4050448239,
0.6726021171,
0.1007017866,
-0.8902107477,
0.089897655,
-0.3250443041,
0.3304549754,
0.1332489252,
-0.6094836593,
0.7773655057,
0.084225893,
-0.7940171361,
0.2187442482,
0.2145553678,
-0.2409500033,
0.3348649144,
0.4607596695,
0.6917937994,
0.6429635882,
-0.3278617263,
1.2118288279,
0.0064317533,
0.4906374812,
0.8853853345,
0.1049849242,
0.8351146579,
0.5633856654,
0.0666803792,
0.2787434161,
0.0657038316,
-0.0387616009,
0.4897345901,
0.1426145583,
-0.2449590266,
-0.2390208691,
-0.2868027687,
0.1227235645,
0.6337839365,
0.1311017722,
-0.4945011437,
-0.5928868651,
-0.1745425612,
0.1979006827,
0.3220827281,
-0.2488296777,
0.8748589158,
0.2700307071,
-0.7865691185,
0.2827821672,
0.1479477733,
0.2176858485,
-0.6339706182,
0.1335717738,
-0.4755330682,
0.3855983615,
-0.2892890573,
-0.4777700007,
0.4346193075,
-0.0335584879,
-0.7051357627,
-0.3707914352,
0.5534903407,
-0.4649482369,
-0.578690052,
0.5256266594,
0.5893880129,
0.1564883292,
0.3998170495,
-0.6770928502,
0.321071893,
-0.0678239092,
-0.0053097075,
0.0558231845,
0.7022562027,
-0.1128464565,
0.6336022019,
0.3703073561,
0.1122709662,
-0.1138371825,
0.3347882032,
0.8116402626,
-0.4762148559,
-0.2438788861,
-0.6236577034,
0.3310984373,
-0.2102270871,
-0.5448850393,
1.1073930264,
0.6841754913,
0.574996531,
-0.0638317168,
0.605434835,
0.3440438509,
0.3510176837,
-0.4653998613,
0.570204258,
-0.7745687366,
0.2675343454,
-0.7460030317,
-1.0296560526,
-0.4044859707,
0.1503236145,
-0.4280851781,
0.0955452994,
0.9997549653,
0.5645560622,
-0.3355806172,
0.0460606813,
0.5148205757,
-0.0315818004,
-0.1609663814,
0.2756389081,
0.7100211978,
-0.7882715464,
0.7143107057,
-0.1768254787,
-0.237528041,
0.0164425578,
-0.9928202629,
-0.6714558601,
-0.533495605,
-0.5144533515,
0.0768070817,
0.0360066332,
0.3239797354,
0.4285711646,
-0.4872678518,
0.1012016684,
0.1793047935,
-0.0156272445,
-0.2469406724,
-0.1651021242,
0.4207848608,
-0.1407489181,
-0.8294052482,
0.2603929937,
0.4676402807,
0.1627967358,
-0.231626451,
0.1928516924,
0.1064968929,
0.6840207577,
0.3556612432,
-0.1366948485,
-0.6562377214,
-0.1992957294,
-0.2083407491,
-0.3550844193,
0.0172346868,
0.7171064615,
-0.3725112081,
0.6070175767,
0.8791128993,
0.3273355663,
0.5726140738,
0.5139129162,
0.4034900367,
-0.7758834362,
-0.0509232469,
-0.0465105437,
0.5029261708,
0.6623029709,
-0.1833284348,
0.5726057887,
0.1415700763,
-0.2166944444,
-0.8282196522,
0.2150925249,
-1.0612808466,
-0.328763485,
0.9909068942,
-0.5316787958,
-0.0780578628,
0.1437439173,
-0.1218104586,
0.0872512311,
-0.1452731788,
0.5564084053,
0.8417935967,
0.0511102192,
-0.2195710987,
-0.2031095773,
0.6450142264,
0.5052221417,
-0.8545629978,
0.1063167751,
0.5045083165,
0.3257199228,
0.8074872494,
0.4926559031,
-0.263831526,
0.2862301171,
0.3137053549,
-0.155138284,
-0.0019235816,
-0.1450178325,
-0.8509168625,
0.4105468392,
0.0083345463,
0.1441046298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03259v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03259v2
|
Enhancing the Performance of Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis Systems
| 2024-04-04T07:31:56 | 2024-04-19T07:30:23 |
Chen Li, Huidong Tang, Peng Ju, Debo Cheng, Yasuhiko Morimoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect-based sentiment analysis aims to predict sentiment polarity with fine
granularity. While Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs) are widely utilized for
sentimental feature extraction, their naive application for syntactic feature
extraction can compromise information preservation. This study introduces an
innovative edge-enhanced GCN, named SentiSys, to navigate the syntactic graph
while preserving intact feature information, leading to enhanced performance.
Specifically,we first integrate a bidirectional long short-term memory
(Bi-LSTM) network and a self-attention-based transformer. This combination
facilitates effective text encoding, preventing the loss of information and
predicting long dependency text. A bidirectional GCN (Bi-GCN) with message
passing is then employed to encode relationships between entities.
Additionally, unnecessary information is filtered out using an aspect-specific
masking technique. To validate the effectiveness of our proposed model, we
conduct extensive evaluation experiments and ablation studies on four benchmark
datasets. The results consistently demonstrate improved performance in
aspect-based sentiment analysis when employing SentiSys. This approach
successfully addresses the challenges associated with syntactic feature
extraction, highlighting its potential for advancing sentiment analysis
methodologies.
|
[
-0.3648739457,
-0.7018315792,
0.507538259,
0.375838995,
-0.6256017089,
0.2338272929,
-0.325725317,
-0.4826178551,
0.7108537555,
0.7047911882,
-0.5202789903,
-0.5159671903,
-0.5579593778,
0.1306315958,
-0.1574553549,
1.2564692497,
0.1577845812,
-0.1490045339,
-0.2709479332,
-0.3695825636,
0.056188859,
-0.6703950167,
-0.713201046,
-0.3396768272,
0.7442178726,
0.1223361716,
0.9674309492,
0.2486690134,
0.723361969,
0.2834862173,
-0.6491518021,
0.2932706475,
-0.0444619693,
0.4949854612,
-0.1399927586,
-0.2950414717,
-0.8639355302,
-0.1947391927,
0.5481290817,
0.785717845,
0.160083577,
-0.017408289,
0.4986796379,
1.051733613,
-0.5040048361,
0.270529002,
-0.3054753244,
0.1170055643,
-0.1990246624,
-0.0340800062,
-0.2126679271,
-0.425839752,
0.2640069127,
-0.1800612509,
0.0582637787,
-0.2493577749,
0.804104805,
0.0148439463,
-0.0650942698,
-0.2137351185,
-0.6134127975,
0.4686388671,
-0.7448968887,
0.4813625216,
0.0655949116,
-0.0458138138,
-0.1772231162,
-0.8880413771,
-0.3994025588,
0.2256317288,
-0.3453073204,
0.3954337239,
-0.3552881181,
0.3948456645,
0.0597412772,
0.6019417048,
-0.4670205712,
-0.0505054109,
-0.2031156421,
-0.3293103278,
0.4572776258,
0.0801835731,
0.010564669,
-0.8419977427,
-0.1146339625,
0.1339698881,
-0.5508483648,
0.5243771076,
0.4922128022,
0.6727285385,
-0.0823242888,
0.3823716044,
-0.4014008939,
0.3020333946,
0.1555669606,
0.1721415073,
0.5797617435,
-0.2119392902,
-0.1551228017,
-0.1596788913,
1.0297093391,
0.2701544464,
-0.0579484254,
-0.162822485,
-0.3310052752,
-0.1130520776,
0.2155444175,
-0.8645677567,
-0.4800132513,
0.3237740099,
-0.6661345363,
-0.3344202638,
-0.2896547616,
-0.7221855521,
-0.2348664105,
-0.3625330627,
0.0576931909,
-0.5158593655,
-0.4199908078,
-0.33555758,
-0.1128686965,
-0.4455386698,
0.2731455266,
-0.5787183046,
0.2099251002,
0.8997821808,
1.1891784668,
-0.1367475688,
-0.0184426364,
-0.4531547129,
-0.2703309953,
-0.1359364688,
0.7477225065,
-0.664254725,
-0.2201217115,
-0.0112756109,
0.2262850851,
0.0326696895,
-0.4500777423,
0.3459734023,
-0.5413736105,
0.1052815095,
-0.1897378117,
-0.184083879,
-0.531340301,
0.5859861374,
-0.7803316712,
1.017388463,
0.0703111067,
-0.9216266274,
0.082335256,
-0.5834010243,
-0.6414778829,
0.0822908059,
-0.0590943284,
-0.7303397655,
0.3346957564,
0.4464954138,
0.5889502764,
0.0761835352,
0.2172074914,
-0.4650638103,
-0.2087453455,
0.4292362034,
-0.5379405022,
0.3637751937,
0.1468289793,
-0.088585481,
0.3221335411,
-0.4349127114,
0.0014476334,
-0.1884784251,
-0.2967443764,
-0.3508963585,
0.0484111384,
-0.1489240825,
0.2510088682,
0.3877477646,
-0.8102637529,
-0.0858273655,
-0.7528393865,
0.511379838,
0.532243073,
0.0472895131,
0.3656381369,
0.0915701315,
0.4166806638,
0.5533650517,
0.3287044168,
-0.1171656251,
-0.1882119328,
-0.7559205294,
-0.185460493,
0.1439256072,
0.3269827962,
-1.0658097267,
0.5463619828,
-0.5241897106,
-0.3319151402,
-0.4155627191,
0.0650468171,
0.2839102447,
0.2680849135,
0.2986912727,
-0.6700023413,
-0.2417853624,
-1.0708407164,
-0.16954647,
-0.1484707296,
0.246052742,
0.4947333336,
-0.0645196512,
0.0366282538,
0.9609511495,
-0.2958758473,
-0.1260492206,
-0.713994801,
0.0613177419,
0.4179322422,
0.1465061903,
0.2161366194,
-0.7051483989,
-0.1350792944,
0.1295696944,
-0.7601745725,
0.2777142525,
0.1143215671,
-0.0453237481,
0.1852802336,
0.2005221099,
-0.6450019479,
0.289034307,
0.603012979,
-0.1905047894,
0.3271888196,
-0.1511290073,
0.1693629026,
-1.0689734221,
-0.0655766726,
0.3487506509,
-0.503497839,
-0.3865531683,
-0.3061983585,
0.1676378846,
-0.4992000759,
-0.5174179077,
0.0124209905,
-0.4330018461,
-0.1646731049,
-0.4544941783,
0.2470867783,
0.3685899973,
0.6767667532,
-0.0655686185,
0.5744849443,
0.5561010242,
-0.3013979495,
0.3371897936,
-0.0303865448,
0.3423887789,
0.5853739381,
-0.4252533913,
0.4075163305,
-0.2583317161,
0.2700857222,
-0.660861671,
0.3069281876,
0.4882665575,
-0.2935237288,
0.5362051725,
-0.5000491142,
-0.2888656259,
-0.5459514856,
-0.5031826496,
0.2451912314,
0.1597768068,
-0.3868638873,
0.8624737263,
0.1705472916,
-0.5382754803,
-0.4223774374,
-0.3973994851,
0.3719174862,
-0.2709609568,
-0.5752680302,
0.0853849873,
0.3049471974,
0.1417909116,
0.2380665094,
0.1034381688,
0.2458140403,
0.0714425445,
0.483053565,
0.1338188648,
-0.247836262,
0.1867613196,
0.3341839015,
-0.2732016742,
0.1153254882,
-0.3128111064,
0.6348350644,
-0.4859627783,
0.0186997261,
-0.5500323176,
0.4181910455,
0.5508470535,
-0.4521702826,
0.4492059648,
0.3906385899,
-0.2597061992,
-0.1577192694,
-0.3349507153,
0.0023616336,
-0.4842911661,
0.7225337029,
-0.4272609353,
-0.8444427848,
0.5885583162,
-0.3121420145,
-0.346038729,
0.3882722259,
0.0677024871,
-0.3334420919,
0.8594366312,
0.6223218441,
-0.3507947624,
0.6228325963,
-0.4596768618,
0.4333869517,
-1.3220864534,
-0.1676784456,
-0.2344654053,
-0.4472200572,
-0.6207210422,
-0.0085643111,
0.3186717927,
0.1325920671,
0.1110173166,
0.2316852957,
-0.7001835108,
0.1123950183,
0.1782012284,
0.6696964502,
0.0476365276,
0.0029367665,
0.347802043,
-0.0895550773,
-0.4699301422,
-0.4151949584,
0.9222021103,
0.6239897609,
0.5959559083,
-0.0836895332,
0.639354229,
0.4075019062,
0.2878805101,
-0.7943595052,
0.691198349,
-0.7256081104,
0.0460096747,
-0.2244798839,
-0.4166405499,
-0.7127087712,
0.1862223148,
0.0146396598,
-0.7629000545,
0.1256225109,
0.0710444972,
-0.3037263155,
0.3285040855,
-0.3971666396,
0.6639713049,
-0.1219393089,
-0.4467634857,
-0.3561932445,
-0.4782717228,
-0.248143658,
0.3571287394,
-0.0573835708,
-0.2007398903,
0.2824623883,
0.8673570752,
-0.2333534509,
0.8676072359,
-0.3254656196,
0.3087483644,
0.31089136,
0.19715482,
0.5044874549,
-0.0045459168,
-0.1829152554,
0.548371613,
-0.2780702114,
-0.0718877241,
-0.8517298698,
0.9352139235,
-0.6049807072,
-0.6334137321,
-0.0701828077,
-0.4209133983,
-0.1023322865,
0.0609718077,
0.1020650417,
0.8773683906,
0.0273038186,
0.1099050939,
0.2945738137,
0.2695768476,
0.9031149745,
-0.0739161819,
-0.098980844,
-0.8658016324,
1.0214381218,
0.3351335227,
0.0529466085,
0.0457884483,
0.2336554378,
-0.2219172567,
-0.751609683,
-0.704949677,
0.1825478077,
-0.7333323956,
-0.478559643,
-0.8701330423,
-0.4829053283,
-0.2866697013,
0.0856389478,
-0.6313180923,
-0.369241178,
-0.310169965,
-0.0581244789,
0.370559603,
0.6200898886,
0.210481599,
0.4498399794,
-0.8124602437,
-0.1495069712,
-0.2406260967,
0.4366316199,
0.0421097726,
-0.216885969,
-0.4532971382,
0.008129267,
-0.4388907254,
-0.8371855617,
0.3935286701,
0.0750535727,
0.2242514938,
0.3576464355,
-0.1487588286,
0.4074799716,
-0.0006287206,
0.8522520065,
0.2680642009,
-0.8844929338,
0.7124242187,
-0.2536907792,
0.2626556158,
0.5488801599,
0.0452591926,
-0.6044481993,
-0.6912367344,
-0.6349276304,
-0.9200052619,
0.6973276138,
0.2659616172,
0.2884761989,
-0.0868843868,
0.6582629681,
0.2009884566,
0.212473169,
-0.6998992562,
-0.0388862938,
-0.4144306481,
-0.6061892509,
0.0575627238,
-0.3107742369,
0.1869302094,
-0.0449426249,
0.5990823507,
-0.3465727568,
0.0970461518,
0.5312830806,
-0.1008332521,
0.0319941714,
0.2863862514,
0.0456685014,
0.3474415243,
0.0018537143,
0.3186303675,
0.0746771917,
-0.5508845448,
-0.1368937343,
0.3631720543,
-0.2720354497,
-0.0509070158,
0.2509800196,
0.9476599097,
-0.0340897404,
0.1389721185,
0.6326696873,
0.008602757,
0.3668572009,
-0.2150942534,
-0.1097418442,
0.0032485176,
0.571674943,
0.1377568096,
0.1054913029,
0.4534972608,
-0.4218372703,
0.104864873,
0.4913376272,
-0.9372230172,
-0.7376195788,
0.0145809893,
0.4189391136,
-0.425703764,
0.6019791365,
-0.1679098755,
-0.8431253433,
0.5135158896,
0.3418622315,
1.2314784527,
0.0802061334,
0.3003841937,
0.1501028985,
0.1066107005,
0.316295743,
0.16770266,
-0.247987628,
-0.4899627268,
-0.2543824911,
-0.5859163404,
-0.3049738705,
-0.1160880625,
-0.5574558973,
0.0027644688,
-0.5024336576,
-0.4456250072,
0.0180536956,
-0.0180736836,
-0.6826400757,
0.4271443784,
0.1972574294,
0.4261611998,
-0.7926189899,
0.4823183715,
0.7314822078,
-0.3603335619,
-0.6720271111,
0.1245630011,
-0.4473754466,
-0.2775569558,
0.3998354673,
0.5427317619,
-0.2016881555,
-0.3821661472,
-0.240032658,
-0.6947149038,
0.9393369555,
-0.1790774614,
-0.4791413546,
0.2638716698,
0.263537854,
0.6720694304,
-0.5033012629,
0.5896664262,
0.5668250918,
-0.0153484726,
0.0140593881,
-0.7355391979,
0.2493251413,
-0.4104368985,
-0.0039801202,
0.5079294443,
-0.7229518294,
0.6377221346,
0.0825958923,
-0.1549951434,
-0.3615380228,
1.1153203249,
-0.3227011263,
0.5239347816,
0.6083955765,
0.4900724292,
0.5922321081,
-0.1734039336,
0.7338841558,
-0.2238947302,
0.4098048508,
0.7898443937,
-0.0653301701,
0.8057691455,
0.4573273957,
0.0356810801,
0.8845020533,
0.6094214916,
0.4873607457,
0.6188405156,
-0.0410747826,
-0.2644432485,
-0.2438381612,
-0.263106972,
-0.0907214805,
0.3361748159,
0.3968320191,
-0.5468820333,
-0.2629891038,
0.31623891,
0.3076696396,
-0.1743559986,
-0.450106144,
1.048766613,
0.2149966508,
-0.5239030123,
-0.0458075739,
-0.3447364569,
0.6585903764,
-0.3779191077,
0.2368074358,
-0.4416196048,
0.2844768763,
-0.4306178689,
-1.2849891186,
0.5244498253,
-0.2369053215,
-0.2432484478,
0.070468992,
1.0654877424,
-0.423342675,
-0.5970463753,
0.4352476299,
0.41974172,
-0.0314782672,
-0.3184941411,
-0.5065538883,
-0.0071759983,
-0.0455386452,
-0.5384960175,
0.1612943262,
0.6541367769,
-0.0312826745,
0.5951173902,
0.4590418041,
0.3861455321,
-0.6539415121,
0.4281100333,
1.2460011244,
-0.794344306,
-0.8908590674,
-0.9313614964,
0.5105648637,
-0.3942876756,
-0.2838011682,
0.5276484489,
0.6989015341,
0.1920059025,
0.4628297985,
0.6483432651,
0.3081646264,
0.2636863291,
-0.4740209877,
0.7211444974,
-0.3738486171,
0.0297539551,
-0.3002826273,
-0.970713079,
-0.2506332397,
-0.0866755694,
-0.5030354857,
-0.0890647098,
0.5696148872,
0.6695813537,
-0.1661112159,
0.4406815767,
0.1018176153,
0.0387580842,
0.615868628,
0.3745898306,
0.8239987493,
-0.3015262783,
0.4138725996,
-0.6145563126,
-0.2501104176,
0.0596481077,
-0.7228044271,
-0.9231478572,
-0.4021570683,
-0.4750836194,
-0.6226486564,
0.2671179175,
0.6121505499,
0.468061924,
-0.4884976447,
0.1739011258,
0.1043248251,
-0.0108283246,
-0.0199302137,
-0.2299332172,
0.7590590715,
-0.3932317793,
-0.3417838514,
0.2886112928,
0.7644024491,
-0.1474600732,
-0.2846218646,
0.151300624,
0.4128369987,
-0.0301098786,
0.5356004834,
-0.1950681359,
-0.5493465662,
-0.7283520699,
-0.0677111149,
-0.0519689061,
0.3855515122,
0.82359308,
-0.7654337883,
0.3815897107,
0.4037533998,
0.282258302,
0.4528605044,
0.1698091626,
0.2246687561,
-0.6451177001,
0.2167984396,
0.4197390974,
0.4443882108,
0.7421316504,
-0.7365394235,
0.0494456068,
0.3133217692,
-0.3927125037,
-0.2495992482,
0.0733102262,
-1.051641345,
-0.1524801701,
1.0572670698,
-0.2845738828,
-0.5227677226,
-0.0789958313,
-0.0337031037,
0.2684985101,
-0.5650116801,
0.5006532073,
0.3974324465,
-0.364621371,
-0.1328959316,
0.1217030063,
0.3493896723,
0.4499040544,
-0.7954386473,
0.3611027598,
0.4356453121,
0.1678163111,
0.3475910425,
0.5099733472,
-0.1840913296,
0.0681699812,
-0.2083236128,
0.1951788217,
-0.2019153535,
-0.5144987106,
-0.4651686251,
0.3485430479,
-0.0460555293,
-0.4857804179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04292v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04292v5
|
Conversational Disease Diagnosis via External Planner-Controlled Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T06:16:35 | 2024-05-20T00:45:40 |
Zhoujian Sun, Cheng Luo, Ziyi Liu, Zhengxing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The development of large language models (LLMs) has brought unprecedented
possibilities for artificial intelligence (AI) based medical diagnosis.
However, the application perspective of LLMs in real diagnostic scenarios is
still unclear because they are not adept at collecting patient data
proactively. This study presents a LLM-based diagnostic system that enhances
planning capabilities by emulating doctors. Our system involves two external
planners to handle planning tasks. The first planner employs a reinforcement
learning approach to formulate disease screening questions and conduct initial
diagnoses. The second planner uses LLMs to parse medical guidelines and conduct
differential diagnoses. By utilizing real patient electronic medical record
data, we constructed simulated dialogues between virtual patients and doctors
and evaluated the diagnostic abilities of our system. We demonstrated that our
system obtained impressive performance in both disease screening and
differential diagnoses tasks. This research represents a step towards more
seamlessly integrating AI into clinical settings, potentially enhancing the
accuracy and accessibility of medical diagnostics.
|
[
-0.3739262521,
-0.9800171256,
1.1182291508,
0.1175649092,
-0.0869480222,
-0.0094329948,
-0.4344285727,
-0.746994555,
0.6153640151,
0.462531656,
-0.5539681315,
-0.6294619441,
-0.4172363877,
0.2215374708,
-0.2746948004,
0.7051502466,
0.0279195085,
0.4177328646,
-0.4068002403,
0.1202499717,
-0.4245451391,
-0.4415183067,
-1.3663072586,
-0.6027303934,
0.3191195726,
0.2649934888,
0.8173525929,
0.5689128637,
0.4108747244,
0.3773698807,
0.1880291849,
0.5197277665,
-0.1254954636,
0.4582450092,
-0.0143134529,
-0.3464786112,
-0.3751423955,
-0.3114297092,
0.3694603443,
0.6926392317,
-0.1796964556,
-0.3277465701,
-0.2880861163,
0.3208754659,
0.1059109643,
0.4683644772,
-0.053769026,
0.3639270067,
0.1594689041,
-0.3146061599,
-0.4413951635,
-0.2836380303,
0.0955568999,
-0.6769021749,
-0.094552882,
-0.1046092808,
0.5492619276,
0.28082636,
-0.3309764266,
-0.4710629582,
-1.054172039,
0.1505162567,
-0.4567500651,
0.3333269656,
0.4666642249,
0.5811460018,
-0.2502827644,
-0.5815654993,
-0.5023933053,
-0.5898668766,
-0.0853359997,
0.2243475318,
-0.1957597733,
0.2237965018,
0.2377270907,
0.1051840708,
-0.665096879,
0.5580169559,
-0.0813399628,
-0.0262926724,
0.6632639766,
0.5664412379,
0.4997013509,
0.0834609345,
0.0084586414,
0.0734535307,
-0.6086287498,
-0.1899265051,
-0.2435735166,
0.2292859554,
-0.3565807939,
0.4619193077,
-0.2253832221,
0.5755472779,
0.066188857,
-0.4506624341,
-0.032237187,
-0.0872860774,
-0.2892233431,
0.2227517068,
0.7137081623,
0.2611167133,
0.1592573673,
-0.0899555981,
-0.1290361732,
0.0830363855,
0.2342781574,
-0.5414331555,
-0.6105809808,
0.4803857505,
-0.5286320448,
-0.2372813374,
-0.7162877917,
-0.6354013681,
-0.6934548616,
-0.3567918837,
0.3200041056,
-0.5799971819,
-0.2470084429,
-0.0535648428,
0.1124516204,
-0.2259581387,
0.4513149858,
-0.7976088524,
0.4226507843,
0.4546739459,
0.5807244778,
0.0346206203,
0.3221747279,
-0.6209051013,
0.2200509012,
-0.4685169458,
0.847637713,
-0.6660933495,
-0.7887398005,
0.0318486281,
-0.1511737853,
-0.16965653,
-0.7663878202,
0.2127912939,
-0.2507160306,
0.0064485837,
0.0584744252,
-0.3761611581,
0.047426708,
0.5532496572,
-0.3762886822,
0.7442452908,
0.2708806396,
-0.2291493565,
0.2971502542,
-0.5595889091,
-0.3245655298,
0.4234553576,
-0.7037480474,
-0.4284709692,
-0.3403773308,
0.2532036901,
0.566724062,
-0.3454405069,
0.5079144239,
-0.1850439012,
-0.1795822978,
-0.043358881,
-0.2411761731,
0.3727207184,
0.0171955377,
-0.0704714656,
0.3701211214,
-0.4639156759,
0.184580788,
0.193622604,
-0.2810488939,
-0.1383761168,
0.3841713667,
-0.4689282775,
0.0803737938,
0.0383273773,
-0.1853734851,
0.6235287786,
-0.6161978245,
-0.0658116415,
0.3894487619,
0.1289670169,
-0.0391703025,
-0.8603152037,
0.8361706138,
0.3032391667,
0.0662654415,
-0.2280787379,
-0.8777103424,
-0.7800078392,
-0.3936365545,
-0.0811527446,
0.8921813369,
-0.7363245487,
0.4616059065,
-0.2985489666,
-0.34341833,
-0.3356214762,
-0.1338394731,
0.3491220474,
0.509141922,
0.3553671539,
-0.0257922541,
-0.3205349147,
-0.7465225458,
0.189443633,
-0.2674279809,
-0.0813429281,
0.6993644834,
0.1564996839,
-0.5687606931,
0.4265201688,
-0.4463131428,
-0.5263276696,
-0.6510313749,
-0.2514893115,
0.3404336274,
0.2997982204,
0.4539218247,
-0.3160094917,
-0.3886565864,
0.4025503695,
-0.6879558563,
-0.1540629566,
-0.1524633616,
0.2190247327,
0.1110215783,
0.5857000947,
-0.4715258479,
0.5720084906,
0.7148696184,
-0.5146431923,
0.4577716291,
-0.8288373947,
0.0502299815,
-1.0043720007,
-0.1207299307,
0.2503788769,
-0.6290066242,
-0.2844736576,
-0.1105490327,
-0.1938498169,
-0.2983380258,
0.038082622,
0.4700872898,
-0.1497962475,
0.0441871732,
-0.0444576554,
0.0983506441,
-0.0332686864,
-0.0091043524,
0.1514902562,
0.301038444,
0.5143854022,
-1.0083044767,
0.582567513,
0.3322491944,
-0.1208300963,
0.6279683709,
-0.5364753604,
-0.2199036479,
-0.0292366743,
0.379280895,
-0.742015183,
-0.1896907091,
0.4617637098,
-0.2161045969,
0.4246387482,
-0.0230602939,
-0.5440582633,
-0.4029444754,
0.0836016387,
0.2127761841,
0.5966671109,
-0.5578513741,
0.6661173701,
0.3756939471,
-0.3772271872,
0.2119384706,
-0.5684576631,
-0.0341987386,
-0.0375516787,
-0.6755647659,
0.4186744988,
0.1143892258,
-0.5467486382,
-0.1000833809,
0.5047711134,
-0.1160930991,
-0.0547410473,
0.3486357331,
0.3015215695,
-0.3007169664,
0.4910921752,
0.2007377297,
-0.1516394764,
0.1008747071,
0.0622912273,
0.7412661314,
0.2889194787,
-0.7548584342,
-0.7535965443,
0.5230273604,
0.4128859937,
0.0567455143,
0.4437175095,
0.1691137105,
-0.5035202503,
-0.3925395012,
-0.2990810275,
-0.1631665081,
-0.4435131252,
0.220957756,
-0.4175246358,
-0.3120259643,
0.4793034494,
-0.3938927948,
-0.1114749983,
0.3272038102,
0.7205294371,
-0.1398754716,
1.5509152412,
0.5458468199,
0.0442787781,
0.1046336591,
-0.2300986499,
0.4277587533,
-0.7220130563,
-0.5233169794,
-0.4131650031,
-0.1028981656,
-0.6288721561,
-0.6008070111,
0.9564797282,
-0.1727959365,
-0.1375444084,
-0.2538946867,
-0.5735669136,
0.1481630057,
0.2975942194,
0.4442829788,
0.3816762567,
-0.3500125408,
-0.4715107083,
-0.2605613768,
-0.6411204338,
-0.5515230298,
0.9560631514,
0.2703297138,
0.4975807965,
0.1137483343,
0.5808077455,
0.3788694143,
0.4792901874,
-1.0026077032,
0.4126190543,
-0.2872537971,
-0.0810203403,
-0.122963652,
-0.3412086368,
-0.9587478042,
0.1309874654,
-0.1779709756,
-0.8999493718,
-0.0299176015,
0.3361326456,
-0.5957634449,
0.26750651,
-0.7274932265,
0.84041363,
-0.4937585592,
-0.0075872131,
-0.535944283,
-0.1649538279,
0.3444171846,
0.0338828415,
0.2747096419,
-0.1313117892,
0.0928033963,
0.5033841133,
-0.1546587348,
0.8492399454,
-0.2234788537,
-0.0949517787,
-0.288212508,
0.3469782174,
0.4450109005,
0.4931726456,
-0.1875653416,
-0.2738987803,
0.1294154227,
0.0325231478,
-0.5229586959,
0.838113904,
-0.5853923559,
-0.6339617372,
-0.5207979679,
-0.2656837106,
-0.7067131996,
0.0906789973,
-0.2906137109,
0.6253502369,
-0.4042950571,
-0.4419441819,
0.5155023932,
-0.715520978,
0.1652663052,
0.8024519086,
-0.5053430796,
0.1465713084,
0.8151642084,
-0.1300778687,
0.1160675585,
0.2284685522,
0.4687846899,
-0.1905357838,
-0.58875525,
-0.5389903784,
0.3408819437,
-0.576782763,
-0.2060043067,
-0.8042374253,
-0.3812260926,
-0.3864411116,
-0.1762140691,
-0.2105070055,
0.0944418684,
-0.3884167969,
0.1715724915,
0.530713439,
1.0326468945,
-0.0894695967,
0.1105031073,
-0.6372207403,
0.6033420563,
-0.0672669038,
0.2427621484,
-0.1806748062,
-0.275917232,
-0.0719459876,
0.2611893415,
-0.3318689466,
-0.7614677548,
0.8477731943,
0.2244247943,
0.7073425055,
0.859303534,
0.1078752801,
0.7768282294,
-0.346208185,
0.5508022904,
0.0597397201,
-0.5473021865,
0.7737004161,
-0.2803262472,
0.2014576346,
0.3349120915,
0.6056087017,
-0.731090188,
-0.5246769786,
-0.4722747207,
-0.6047520041,
0.6314748526,
-0.4396943152,
-0.2113816291,
-0.2604338825,
0.3015851974,
0.0042574792,
-0.3175421953,
-0.2366779894,
-0.2317340821,
0.2580860257,
-0.4619447291,
-0.3207579851,
-0.0913042501,
-0.3983066082,
-0.7030854225,
0.4355066717,
-0.1413755715,
0.6451306343,
0.4915317297,
0.2513589561,
0.0210650843,
-0.0525943898,
0.5179433227,
0.5041620135,
0.1978939176,
-0.1714954674,
0.1594382077,
-0.2565893531,
-0.1665303707,
0.2664869428,
0.0829824731,
0.0978714898,
0.1401241422,
0.5117012262,
0.2691699266,
-1.1155984402,
0.546723485,
-0.0589759946,
-0.0827456564,
-0.7678668499,
0.2002770752,
0.2383487523,
0.5757648349,
-0.0811747313,
-0.1093226895,
-0.0112253688,
-0.5960893631,
0.2090548873,
0.5677345395,
-0.4434158206,
-0.2805602551,
0.4740874469,
0.368808955,
-0.6634379625,
0.9717946649,
-0.4186021388,
-0.4028962851,
0.937253058,
0.8288536072,
0.2235933095,
-0.0845873505,
0.3035496175,
0.0696214586,
0.1093989983,
-0.0544885956,
0.4671723247,
0.0891147703,
-0.8109337687,
-0.3979723752,
-0.2789932191,
-0.6054801941,
0.5253555775,
-0.2255263478,
0.5028013587,
-0.5727168322,
0.0152034741,
0.0621418282,
0.108363457,
-0.5601455569,
0.3533809185,
0.3289275765,
0.6260959506,
-0.549836278,
0.9642788172,
0.4677912593,
-0.1443938613,
-0.7923038006,
-0.0338083468,
0.1119709983,
-1.0364576578,
0.5139852166,
0.2693727016,
0.2340345681,
-0.0721081272,
0.0392829739,
-0.6596373916,
0.9371182919,
0.250207901,
-0.5836645365,
-0.1629632413,
-0.0979232863,
0.8299384117,
-0.5352104306,
0.4949584603,
0.5409932733,
0.5479927659,
0.0204111263,
-1.52916646,
0.0595969893,
-0.128472954,
-0.4601591229,
0.4802666605,
-0.2754838467,
0.6110057831,
-0.4970727861,
-0.228036046,
0.1610181034,
-0.021256607,
0.1565452069,
0.3463257551,
0.1715008616,
0.6698166132,
0.8259114623,
0.0406590775,
1.3504695892,
-0.6435891986,
-0.3150946498,
0.7498922944,
-0.5118066072,
0.8512946963,
0.0516816005,
-0.0933276191,
0.3301042616,
0.5621855855,
0.1469923556,
0.1403874755,
0.2986390591,
-0.6295028925,
-0.2755062282,
-0.30457142,
-0.5028374195,
0.5648393631,
0.9906201959,
-0.6466057897,
-0.2286996841,
0.0305758361,
-0.1916525066,
0.1751257479,
-0.2707845867,
0.8834174275,
-0.1541596502,
-0.6055291891,
0.3353313804,
0.0876398608,
0.4554318488,
-0.7546778321,
-0.3226589859,
0.0513597876,
0.4120093584,
-0.0687951595,
-0.5886901021,
0.4927322268,
-0.2571866512,
0.1594252586,
-0.416402936,
0.4186244905,
-0.385506928,
-0.5549451113,
0.4383980036,
0.6953179836,
0.3961556256,
0.0392572135,
-0.4250259697,
-0.0323940441,
-0.2091949135,
0.1094197258,
0.2353696674,
0.2795183063,
-0.2416654825,
1.0305685997,
0.4673872292,
0.5684645772,
-0.2912591696,
0.1350706518,
0.9383835793,
-0.6306101084,
-0.5670723319,
-0.7081269622,
0.0412775353,
-0.1423273385,
-0.2611093819,
0.1133265868,
0.5555658937,
0.4556935728,
0.1550772935,
0.7423073649,
0.1681067199,
0.7027427554,
-0.3672071993,
0.6560847163,
-0.3708707094,
0.2242157012,
0.102826573,
-0.0432045646,
-0.3031464815,
0.558178544,
-0.3246564269,
0.016264176,
0.7482404113,
0.6868659258,
0.0473394245,
-0.191140756,
0.5400851965,
0.256215632,
0.6109716892,
0.7487211227,
0.7297521234,
0.2926562428,
0.2935624123,
-0.3249212503,
-0.2797182798,
-0.5265291929,
-0.4240483046,
-0.8471646309,
-0.3695691824,
-0.1649377793,
-0.0798914358,
0.2849519849,
1.0669608116,
0.8336883783,
-0.5090091228,
0.0224669129,
-0.0179169253,
-0.0087025333,
-0.1583674997,
-0.2403040677,
0.2162229568,
-0.0191895571,
-0.585236907,
0.8891401291,
0.3501346111,
0.1713293046,
-0.4656458497,
0.0084723141,
0.1885611415,
-0.2093219906,
0.5796818137,
0.3760640025,
-0.5922788382,
-0.1337423772,
-0.3229029179,
-0.1954923272,
0.0534807444,
0.7872639894,
-1.2532515526,
0.5004846454,
0.1327635348,
0.630073607,
0.3449593186,
-0.0373490974,
0.7760870457,
-0.0380966775,
0.287553668,
0.7947225571,
0.1874275059,
0.0231456216,
-0.8847929835,
-0.0010833329,
-0.0529732145,
-0.4702635109,
-0.5060326457,
0.3192954063,
-0.8905109763,
-0.0857662037,
1.0345742702,
-0.1100968271,
-0.0154056912,
-0.6413710713,
-0.2526867092,
0.189513579,
-0.4189783037,
0.9519757032,
0.0845307186,
-1.0820964575,
0.1285955459,
-0.6318694353,
0.6300572753,
0.2030359358,
-1.0904222727,
-0.4861252606,
0.4496518373,
0.2149491012,
-0.1839620769,
1.034194231,
-0.0553244725,
0.3508405685,
-0.1353764087,
-0.2190334946,
-0.140358761,
-0.0927653313,
-0.0109516187,
-0.0784729794,
0.1375225037,
-0.174150452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03204v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03204v3
|
RALL-E: Robust Codec Language Modeling with Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Text-to-Speech Synthesis
| 2024-04-04T05:15:07 | 2024-05-19T21:34:28 |
Detai Xin, Xu Tan, Kai Shen, Zeqian Ju, Dongchao Yang, Yuancheng Wang, Shinnosuke Takamichi, Hiroshi Saruwatari, Shujie Liu, Jinyu Li, Sheng Zhao
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
We present RALL-E, a robust language modeling method for text-to-speech (TTS)
synthesis. While previous work based on large language models (LLMs) shows
impressive performance on zero-shot TTS, such methods often suffer from poor
robustness, such as unstable prosody (weird pitch and rhythm/duration) and a
high word error rate (WER), due to the autoregressive prediction style of
language models. The core idea behind RALL-E is chain-of-thought (CoT)
prompting, which decomposes the task into simpler steps to enhance the
robustness of LLM-based TTS. To accomplish this idea, RALL-E first predicts
prosody features (pitch and duration) of the input text and uses them as
intermediate conditions to predict speech tokens in a CoT style. Second, RALL-E
utilizes the predicted duration prompt to guide the computing of self-attention
weights in Transformer to enforce the model to focus on the corresponding
phonemes and prosody features when predicting speech tokens. Results of
comprehensive objective and subjective evaluations demonstrate that, compared
to a powerful baseline method VALL-E, RALL-E significantly improves the WER of
zero-shot TTS from $5.6\%$ (without reranking) and $1.7\%$ (with reranking) to
$2.5\%$ and $1.0\%$, respectively. Furthermore, we demonstrate that RALL-E
correctly synthesizes sentences that are hard for VALL-E and reduces the error
rate from $68\%$ to $4\%$.
|
[
-0.5010676384,
-1.213647604,
0.3964719772,
0.2178530991,
-0.1153898761,
0.345846355,
-0.2976608872,
-0.403510958,
0.3006307483,
0.3307792544,
-0.6784431934,
-0.7136202455,
-0.3109496236,
0.343406111,
-0.3867091238,
1.0561294556,
0.1762980521,
-0.3012821972,
0.0462336801,
0.0306136198,
-0.559443295,
-0.3684949577,
-0.3908345103,
-0.1793486327,
0.6628981829,
0.5275415182,
0.5417553186,
0.5186389685,
0.1536123455,
0.1430227458,
-0.0393706448,
0.080939509,
-0.2721948922,
0.843614459,
0.0799519867,
-0.2764189243,
-0.95362854,
-0.2427106202,
0.4039410055,
0.4776531756,
-0.351013273,
0.2165075541,
0.1284188926,
0.8043166995,
-0.7783475518,
-0.0259386189,
-0.7704443336,
-0.031412147,
-0.0820015073,
-0.2899129391,
-0.8043877482,
-0.2211475968,
0.0008510294,
-0.3858950138,
0.2289151847,
0.4519864917,
0.5841392279,
0.4730103314,
-0.0082327221,
-0.2765218616,
-0.8588444591,
0.7971313596,
-0.6482827663,
0.5053508878,
0.5895338058,
0.1245770603,
-0.0639947429,
-0.6935439706,
-0.4343300164,
-0.4332264662,
0.1776034385,
0.2729382217,
-0.2930363119,
0.3502758443,
0.3162226081,
0.2716591656,
-0.8269073367,
-0.1160655692,
-0.1297152489,
-0.2040437311,
0.3541657925,
0.2065665126,
0.3020024598,
0.0772640705,
-0.2459732741,
-0.1813729554,
-0.8543602824,
-0.0611306168,
0.2274297327,
0.3650562763,
-0.0773602575,
0.6701558232,
-0.0664744005,
0.908647418,
0.2800947428,
0.0456870794,
0.1146687046,
-0.1875703633,
-0.2886963785,
0.2168088257,
0.9844886065,
0.1174051836,
0.1580927819,
0.1370034218,
-0.3147016466,
0.1486319005,
0.2308432907,
-0.7425094843,
-0.1040338501,
0.3755625188,
-0.240664199,
-0.3954927921,
-0.0034373435,
-0.927724123,
0.275465548,
0.0690082163,
0.3774792254,
-0.302100271,
-0.2147064209,
0.2641140521,
0.4860475659,
0.062603876,
0.1294789761,
-0.8251355886,
0.3145707548,
0.2832739651,
0.8552191257,
-0.33089903,
-0.2689588666,
-0.9801104069,
0.1195146888,
-0.3125922382,
0.8411952257,
-0.6842976213,
-0.4629405141,
-0.013754583,
-0.3006873727,
-0.064185597,
-0.3572480679,
0.5282484889,
-0.3590587378,
0.106398575,
0.1717840582,
-0.5694501996,
0.1804850549,
0.0819596723,
-0.7748894691,
1.311653018,
-0.1415220052,
-0.9141511917,
0.0526975803,
-0.6683439612,
-0.596783936,
-0.0224168729,
-0.1389426142,
-0.5209245682,
0.1450972259,
0.5093227029,
0.2689688504,
-0.4090113938,
0.3519631326,
-0.214868769,
-0.2522377968,
0.4994404316,
-0.5436342955,
0.3310080171,
0.5921291709,
-0.4674765468,
0.3305691481,
-0.5383915901,
0.3835246563,
-0.1004448533,
-0.0994536355,
-0.0598268919,
-0.1377046257,
0.3840364814,
0.0392876975,
-0.1171883643,
-0.3195519447,
0.0805661827,
-0.7281651497,
0.4989319742,
0.4148809016,
0.1028123572,
0.3916364312,
-0.3465144634,
1.0414571762,
-0.4714574516,
0.0652820915,
-0.6062045097,
-0.6593028307,
-0.5866191983,
-0.3520052433,
0.3407351077,
0.5546489358,
-0.5019475222,
0.6527087092,
-0.0393328294,
-0.2299664766,
-0.4836925268,
-0.4809848964,
0.4758673906,
0.3632673919,
0.3246013224,
-0.0575837567,
-0.7049952745,
-0.5731491446,
-0.2636520267,
-0.4453101158,
-0.042027656,
-0.1169125438,
0.2097437233,
0.084525466,
1.1811072826,
-0.3742903769,
-0.297364831,
-0.5650804639,
0.352422893,
0.1737738401,
0.2930249572,
0.2281538844,
-0.4509428144,
-0.576474905,
-0.0868491828,
-0.3319458663,
-0.4691624939,
-0.1150965765,
0.2787333727,
0.3205790818,
0.6639209986,
-0.4219364524,
0.5897707343,
0.5519228578,
-0.1936639696,
0.702209115,
-0.240383029,
0.2442153543,
-1.1586747169,
0.1294566095,
-0.1916667968,
-0.2376390547,
-0.6476609707,
-0.1034669802,
-0.0685803965,
-0.2436188459,
-0.5280886292,
0.3777086139,
-0.5131142139,
-0.1608190387,
-0.3801243007,
0.0809972957,
0.0971256793,
0.3486109376,
0.0467653424,
1.1520503759,
0.6586291194,
-0.4498564899,
-0.0948511362,
0.100091584,
-0.2444311529,
0.359842658,
-0.9242686629,
0.5401866436,
0.1866106838,
0.2626375854,
-0.8451659679,
-0.0757685602,
-0.0146303792,
-0.6664326191,
0.4226896167,
0.0052531241,
-0.2666889429,
-0.2844532728,
-0.2855339944,
0.7709483504,
0.6419579983,
-0.1547899991,
0.8287035823,
0.3749427497,
-0.3169293702,
-0.5992172956,
-0.7060474753,
0.2630843818,
-0.1212130114,
-0.4946806729,
0.5653851628,
-0.2341122329,
-0.133766517,
-0.0683698058,
-0.0642316788,
-0.090020977,
-0.2771763802,
0.2045709193,
0.3534063101,
-0.0189067442,
-0.1100312695,
0.037486054,
-0.3185892403,
0.0151736066,
-0.3353452086,
0.5911692381,
-0.2999759614,
-0.2947552502,
-0.4882144034,
0.4938498735,
0.8267174363,
-0.3990798891,
0.2453071028,
0.507766664,
-0.4357891381,
-0.5418084264,
-0.5465033054,
-0.3889171779,
-0.4566568434,
0.5139552355,
-0.4290440977,
-1.0424166918,
0.5589775443,
0.16590783,
-0.0906542167,
0.1662177891,
0.6757487059,
0.0391938202,
1.0342236757,
0.6099495292,
-0.028933797,
0.4274855852,
-0.1157668009,
0.414827913,
-0.7239390612,
-0.1235696524,
-0.5499638915,
0.0729531124,
-0.3421259522,
-0.3705931604,
0.5349405408,
0.0578977615,
-0.0407886878,
0.3927084804,
-0.5731349587,
0.4821158051,
0.1833985895,
-0.0965995193,
0.202849403,
0.216180861,
-0.2969730198,
-0.3441981673,
-0.8073868155,
-0.3857999742,
1.0282071829,
0.34264189,
1.2688952684,
-0.3458460867,
0.7582067847,
0.4420947731,
0.1190282181,
-0.9160606861,
0.5265956521,
0.0851719901,
-0.3187569976,
-0.1375093758,
-0.161027953,
-0.7204783559,
-0.2427126914,
-0.3420579433,
-0.5876196623,
-0.151939407,
0.3432095945,
-0.556612134,
0.2423121929,
-0.510612309,
0.4308643937,
0.0154769449,
-0.4385763705,
-0.3107257187,
-0.4933941662,
-0.0380462892,
0.0270618219,
0.3602435887,
0.1055626422,
0.0858615264,
0.6234299541,
-0.3646337986,
0.7979332805,
0.1813812107,
-0.1302247792,
0.5738612413,
0.4241539836,
0.6494580507,
-0.029221965,
0.0083457949,
-0.0692246854,
-0.2459010035,
0.0233812332,
-0.6110366583,
0.6046394706,
-0.3048879206,
-0.4841806591,
-0.373611629,
-0.6930902004,
-0.1612245142,
-0.0252165273,
0.4604737461,
0.7036191821,
-0.3217888772,
0.204273209,
0.7333919406,
-0.2712292075,
0.5495816469,
0.2458395958,
-0.5146377683,
-0.8895168304,
0.7000689507,
-0.0983622596,
0.5128014088,
0.5069226623,
0.1859061569,
-0.4463335276,
-0.449968636,
-0.3474750817,
0.0922466218,
-0.5693712234,
-0.4651240706,
-0.7763215899,
-0.2208671421,
-0.2322691828,
-0.3266560435,
-0.6720284224,
-0.4214794934,
-0.1312132329,
-0.2090550512,
0.5309460163,
0.9295010567,
0.0701003894,
-0.0535567589,
-0.6617068052,
0.2057525814,
0.1553019285,
0.2224936932,
-0.0910139382,
-0.7648441792,
-0.2359520942,
-0.2032596767,
-0.1350583136,
-1.0889407396,
0.5513031483,
0.3247578144,
0.227512151,
0.0600951239,
0.3339290917,
0.489657402,
-0.6421767473,
0.8052105904,
0.3939296305,
-1.0757032633,
0.8860052228,
-0.2945974469,
0.385753721,
0.2965778112,
-0.1555372626,
-0.2961094081,
-0.9153974056,
-0.4393014312,
-1.1062613726,
0.4474321604,
0.505294323,
-0.20792678,
-0.4062153697,
0.3016611934,
0.0293567739,
-0.1102392003,
-0.7265666723,
-0.5149438381,
-0.1793693155,
-0.4392218292,
0.407548815,
-0.495837152,
0.3747463822,
-0.0120580085,
0.594720304,
-0.14968431,
0.3497043848,
0.4405026138,
-0.0131380996,
-0.3122319877,
0.7102693915,
0.7693244219,
0.5006186366,
-0.3288952112,
0.2758865058,
0.3600673974,
-0.6624467373,
0.2598157525,
-0.3393458128,
-0.3278881907,
0.1369727552,
0.2736673951,
0.7154988647,
0.1474631578,
-0.5508344769,
0.3860485256,
-0.0116434786,
-0.3764954507,
-0.1246793568,
-0.0621804669,
-0.0750642717,
-0.0464500301,
0.4940181077,
0.0972454697,
0.016421048,
-0.1852579415,
0.4581543207,
0.2465842515,
-0.4423369467,
-0.5610044003,
0.9852918386,
0.1382506937,
-0.5018332601,
0.0972749144,
-0.0882157534,
-0.4605875611,
0.4799838364,
0.9712122679,
1.4681316614,
-0.5131438375,
0.095508337,
0.7201241255,
0.3398195505,
-0.1646188349,
0.3631646633,
0.0089002475,
-0.4371017218,
-0.6993325949,
-0.5248439908,
-0.3197257817,
0.056060981,
-0.991766572,
0.3669945598,
-0.4152014256,
-0.4892788231,
-0.3066678941,
-0.4246711433,
-0.4290691018,
0.1405058652,
-0.0856511593,
0.811788559,
-0.8374548554,
1.1961483955,
0.58450073,
-0.3700447381,
-0.8531087041,
0.2498245835,
-0.1271102726,
-0.4921092391,
0.6520068049,
0.2213968188,
-0.8134903312,
0.312053442,
-0.2873822153,
-0.6634757519,
1.0302351713,
0.3700036108,
-1.064258337,
0.1352652609,
0.0413246229,
0.343570739,
-0.7575779557,
0.2602812946,
0.2909597158,
0.2775629163,
0.0956730247,
-0.9845421314,
0.0385062657,
-0.0887931064,
0.1110923141,
0.0271738824,
-0.0484418496,
0.5102440715,
-0.5641708374,
-0.4398440421,
0.0361591764,
0.7441567183,
0.3257579505,
0.1571852714,
0.6275085807,
0.4521371126,
0.6268574595,
0.0409029983,
0.7924154997,
-0.5591176152,
0.4894127846,
1.1335506439,
-0.5148568749,
1.0856964588,
0.5641993284,
-0.2780187726,
0.4512254596,
0.2192540467,
0.4226156175,
0.6653836966,
-0.0034722181,
-0.3698368669,
-0.3222014606,
-0.1058215499,
-0.4165361524,
0.1421270221,
0.4339780509,
-0.0464589223,
0.0094631333,
0.2606493831,
-0.0985677987,
0.3240142167,
-0.0702932179,
0.6211046576,
0.1388917565,
-0.6991651654,
0.7732115984,
-0.2287395,
0.6995099783,
-0.4944884479,
-0.1128797755,
-0.1355987489,
-0.0065490738,
-0.0911611095,
-0.7285212874,
0.4912489951,
0.2425183803,
-0.4576193392,
-0.2888673842,
0.6991786957,
-0.6896778345,
-0.4158029854,
0.3238571882,
0.5700620413,
-0.0844702646,
0.0447446406,
-0.778372705,
0.4720100462,
0.1244693249,
-0.281157136,
0.0751821995,
0.2507306337,
0.0245094895,
0.7803863883,
0.577213347,
0.0207497198,
-0.1648358554,
0.4537069201,
0.705332458,
-0.7809056044,
-0.5736985803,
-0.8674386144,
0.4350402951,
0.4109233022,
-0.1191947088,
0.4497423172,
0.422023952,
0.5155615211,
-0.0637923852,
0.7533968687,
-0.1398259252,
0.4306748509,
-0.8180407286,
0.7301709652,
-0.2567107975,
0.4764403105,
-0.3690432906,
-1.129144907,
-0.4816092551,
0.8843907714,
0.0106012318,
0.1190673858,
1.1824553013,
1.1581121683,
0.271646142,
0.1203284934,
0.530725956,
0.2452114075,
0.2321198732,
0.4901979864,
0.8926016092,
-0.3789049685,
0.7168635726,
0.0550288633,
-0.2545542121,
-0.0691913217,
-1.126116991,
-0.8977175355,
-0.6781504154,
-0.5924924016,
-0.4574447572,
0.1895463616,
1.2675857544,
0.6786194444,
-0.9500707984,
-0.3041402102,
-0.37872383,
-0.1239726171,
-0.2989681959,
-0.2123063952,
0.3766821623,
-0.5224177241,
-0.5279971957,
0.7076858878,
0.6575853229,
-0.018067535,
-0.18736054,
-0.243727535,
-0.0524843484,
0.0931182355,
0.4132961631,
0.162591055,
-1.1039584875,
-0.1743133366,
0.4472340345,
-0.0061314325,
0.098176159,
1.044736743,
-0.7744427919,
0.6165112853,
0.3324898481,
0.3433130383,
0.4994907975,
-0.1613406688,
0.7765691876,
-0.7432571054,
0.160116151,
0.2798980474,
0.2742936611,
0.2889525592,
-0.1823698431,
0.1310240179,
-0.0841294378,
-0.6918329,
-0.8154087067,
0.4947699308,
-0.9990125895,
-0.0548382215,
1.1294595003,
-0.1136377677,
-0.4346075654,
-0.2109225094,
-0.4373573065,
0.1416138411,
-0.5160008073,
0.5964157581,
0.329054296,
0.0320911594,
-0.295419991,
-0.4647040367,
0.5367704034,
0.6461478472,
-0.6478047371,
0.4675645828,
0.5012800694,
0.2182319015,
-0.1309872121,
0.7207876444,
-0.2005505562,
0.2804962397,
-0.1169443429,
0.3034006059,
-0.1937075406,
-0.5159371495,
-0.3686217964,
0.0953220427,
0.2768737078,
-0.0648188815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03196v1
|
Okay, Let's Do This! Modeling Event Coreference with Generated Rationales and Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-04-04T04:49:46 | 2024-04-04T04:49:46 |
Abhijnan Nath, Shadi Manafi, Avyakta Chelle, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In NLP, Event Coreference Resolution (ECR) is the task of connecting event
clusters that refer to the same underlying real-life event, usually via neural
systems. In this work, we investigate using abductive free-text rationales
(FTRs) generated by modern autoregressive LLMs as distant supervision of
smaller student models for cross-document coreference (CDCR) of events. We
implement novel rationale-oriented event clustering and knowledge distillation
methods for event coreference scoring that leverage enriched information from
the FTRs for improved CDCR without additional annotation or expensive document
clustering. Our model using coreference specific knowledge distillation
achieves SOTA B3 F1 on the ECB+ and GVC corpora and we establish a new baseline
on the AIDA Phase 1 corpus. Our code can be found at
https://github.com/csu-signal/llama_cdcr
|
[
-0.4996315837,
-0.7433211803,
0.7935622334,
-0.2109031081,
-0.3528217673,
-0.1273925006,
-0.4561615288,
-0.4966059625,
0.0659902245,
0.3077907562,
-0.4865348041,
-0.5605431199,
-0.5387001038,
0.2407186776,
-0.5261828899,
1.1405036449,
-0.0208970029,
0.0503092483,
-0.3724159002,
-0.0947479382,
-0.1267874688,
-0.9573164582,
-0.6024350524,
-0.5534521341,
0.5446240902,
0.6052975655,
0.110356465,
0.5538001657,
0.4489755929,
0.2283357531,
-0.2445866764,
0.1084562689,
-0.294808656,
0.0072627077,
-0.4369003177,
-0.5604609251,
-0.4137130082,
0.1170560047,
0.1249282733,
0.584636867,
-0.0822818875,
0.1666654795,
0.1259877682,
0.5644160509,
-0.5758133531,
0.123951219,
-0.8284893036,
-0.2698293626,
-0.0841190889,
-0.1836171299,
-0.4769536853,
-0.2858152986,
0.3258187175,
-0.5515657067,
0.7173321843,
0.004609081,
0.697034657,
0.1880929023,
-0.2966085672,
-0.714877069,
-0.8228936195,
0.8184328079,
-0.4415719509,
0.0996389166,
0.3193339407,
0.2478197515,
0.0222062916,
-0.6011663079,
-0.7718807459,
0.0656370521,
-0.1539714932,
-0.1294079125,
-0.2811415195,
0.067740947,
0.2987672687,
0.2363243252,
-0.1786295325,
-0.0561143458,
-0.4827281237,
0.1480042338,
0.5069422722,
0.1014554128,
-0.0547756702,
-0.2039345503,
-0.2728862762,
0.2191539258,
-0.6598556638,
-0.0701668561,
0.0614957847,
0.1220498607,
0.0116342613,
0.6676585674,
-0.281213671,
0.326441586,
0.8784017563,
-0.3018631339,
-0.1969392747,
-0.4188758433,
-0.1082857028,
0.3995780647,
0.4969048202,
0.5283716917,
0.2574770153,
-0.4678334594,
0.1380604804,
0.1845033616,
0.0348991342,
-0.8325285912,
-0.2650251985,
0.2211475968,
-0.3795520067,
-0.1399582326,
-0.3475220799,
-0.6632108092,
-0.2554189265,
-0.8517791629,
0.1038520858,
-0.6512294412,
-0.0336568989,
-0.1534188539,
-0.1463864446,
0.2433879226,
0.37115255,
-0.6852989197,
0.0548069514,
0.6910539865,
0.5746824145,
-0.2708004713,
-0.0771679655,
-0.2458303571,
0.2596737146,
0.0130440844,
0.9415354133,
-0.5324184299,
-0.5305529833,
-0.2653214931,
-0.1022640318,
0.0339780003,
-0.5453922749,
0.812310338,
-0.4421523511,
0.0502642244,
-0.4391496778,
-0.737832427,
-0.2401542664,
0.1497098505,
-0.4064492583,
0.7401685119,
-0.2018638551,
-0.7552235126,
0.4906995893,
-0.3695113957,
-0.1901020706,
-0.0292654037,
-0.3298410475,
-0.0550994091,
0.093909122,
0.2728574574,
0.5216078162,
-0.3877902329,
0.6659668088,
-0.2596396208,
0.255355835,
0.2343622297,
-0.0868987069,
0.386579752,
0.0552507117,
-0.2341884524,
0.3349765539,
-1.1187939644,
-0.3687042892,
-0.325728476,
-0.1158878207,
-0.761583209,
0.1029138714,
-0.2181710303,
0.2577601969,
0.293348372,
-0.5595262051,
0.2638212442,
0.033063449,
0.2318294644,
0.3386389911,
0.2399606258,
0.7702293992,
-0.2591181099,
0.1154499948,
0.2407229245,
-0.0658436343,
-0.0945956558,
-0.4914720654,
-0.8502107263,
-0.3815167546,
-0.1524267495,
0.4776805341,
-0.5425931811,
0.6681794524,
-0.1000847667,
-0.6719913483,
-0.0815081149,
-0.0878425688,
0.1670303643,
0.9139809608,
0.6461766958,
0.2683392465,
-0.9615537524,
-0.7375812531,
-0.0519146696,
-0.2922253609,
-0.1757359952,
-0.162496075,
0.4555453658,
-0.1380459219,
1.2228429317,
-0.3492133915,
-0.6144859195,
-0.4058119059,
0.308698833,
0.2785366476,
0.6802904606,
0.6379423141,
-0.5541486144,
-0.2687848508,
-0.0482398085,
-0.6925469637,
-0.3011421859,
-0.1264989078,
-0.1687626392,
0.278487891,
0.4770315289,
-0.4270171523,
0.5448523164,
0.2960895598,
-0.5047641397,
0.7524263859,
0.147692427,
0.2621405125,
-1.1486235857,
0.1846593618,
-0.0254515782,
-0.0404514931,
-0.5646727085,
-0.2430891246,
-0.0202947035,
0.2435457259,
-0.1477600038,
0.33474195,
-0.3848777413,
0.3836353719,
-0.5433723927,
0.3890788555,
0.1475597769,
0.3044261634,
0.4686908424,
0.424710691,
0.3088868856,
-0.7743031383,
0.258805424,
0.390082866,
-0.2507282495,
0.8443725705,
-0.5049917102,
-0.087148197,
-0.1220465973,
0.2719383836,
-0.6853416562,
0.0703051388,
-0.1103861108,
-0.3364560902,
0.1143257096,
-0.29625687,
-0.1222940907,
-0.0954404324,
0.0605994724,
0.4748739898,
0.4140678644,
-0.7348018289,
1.0378286839,
0.288169831,
-0.2825119197,
-0.4576427042,
-0.6468293071,
-0.1897818744,
-0.3649816215,
-0.4787161946,
0.3643527925,
-0.1188613474,
-0.6039247513,
0.1754605323,
-0.1426894665,
-0.1741591543,
-0.2104816139,
0.4602651,
0.5551727414,
-0.179519251,
-0.0256326366,
0.2820133865,
-0.2164855897,
0.1861722767,
-0.3198244274,
0.2445392013,
-0.0907919407,
-0.3562557995,
-0.360355854,
0.6587001085,
0.2929623425,
0.1581382453,
0.7642762065,
0.3766706586,
-0.618522346,
-0.0803202465,
-1.0020850897,
-0.4115203321,
-0.3551605642,
0.0249955729,
-0.5593215227,
-1.046328187,
0.7053058147,
0.0773477703,
0.1183393747,
0.5383348465,
0.7748756409,
0.2076314092,
0.5499971509,
0.3836685717,
0.1249945462,
0.3098567426,
-0.1149302945,
0.1494767666,
-0.9630432129,
-0.3818085492,
-0.7784391642,
-0.1972078681,
0.0206830092,
-0.7428165078,
0.1493076384,
0.880695641,
0.1324747801,
0.3943047225,
-0.4378599524,
0.7522442341,
0.5321875215,
-0.2271095514,
0.7410857081,
-0.2441197932,
-0.3041231334,
-0.1670614034,
-0.6169876456,
-0.7776292562,
0.8815051317,
0.0787155405,
0.6057229042,
-0.1974021941,
0.834412396,
-0.0011374668,
0.7724170685,
-0.638733685,
0.4560015202,
-0.0251843128,
-0.6956300735,
0.0394190177,
-0.3572181761,
-0.4847138524,
0.122795105,
-0.0651729777,
-0.9973415732,
0.653404355,
-0.0236454681,
-0.3823954165,
0.387548089,
-0.4727836549,
0.5174996853,
0.1161245927,
-0.2431895286,
-0.3996692896,
-0.2992681861,
0.4357195199,
-0.1491038352,
0.3893599808,
-0.447925806,
0.1106155291,
0.8658384085,
-0.2956669033,
0.9167434573,
0.0142168365,
-0.1132235974,
0.7846537828,
0.1805430949,
0.4644238949,
0.3178754151,
-0.2752177715,
0.2596625686,
0.2139186412,
-0.1622225195,
-0.2923544943,
0.8830807209,
-0.6556267738,
-0.5253721476,
-0.2441178411,
-0.4115483463,
0.042277772,
-0.0342662036,
0.338078469,
0.4480879307,
-0.3981857896,
0.0998422801,
0.4680700302,
0.2353796065,
0.5826850533,
0.9255783558,
-0.0806975365,
-0.5833752155,
0.4209016562,
0.1096861064,
0.0246790834,
0.4220195413,
-0.0018620061,
-0.3188588023,
-0.6075434685,
-0.3823690414,
0.2792556584,
-0.9969794154,
-0.3814082742,
-0.9440572262,
0.1016431302,
-0.5943623185,
-0.600527823,
-0.2766371369,
-0.7121367455,
-0.8323078752,
-0.4651959538,
0.4819183946,
0.5307776332,
-0.5387377143,
0.1825659275,
-1.0162417889,
0.2245636731,
-0.0414494239,
-0.0943756774,
-0.0270004347,
-0.5803688765,
-0.2228258699,
-0.2316096276,
-0.2967483401,
-0.8817949891,
0.4828107357,
0.2371401787,
0.577088654,
0.5898430347,
0.4710116088,
0.6958121657,
-0.4475480318,
0.7857465148,
0.3267758787,
-1.0766814947,
0.638104558,
-0.2098905891,
0.0852958038,
0.788300097,
0.6671360731,
-0.3860805631,
-0.4608290792,
-0.7177525163,
-0.914432168,
0.5465502739,
0.0412167832,
-0.4009611011,
-0.3732917905,
0.664729178,
0.3351349831,
0.0271964706,
-0.4934785366,
-0.3191168904,
0.1197024807,
-0.2882879376,
0.0059026149,
-0.3384416103,
-0.2800592482,
-0.0981579944,
0.8504115939,
-0.2882958651,
-0.1951964498,
0.6263122559,
-0.0331402943,
-0.1783127338,
0.5139526725,
0.34319368,
0.6188266277,
-0.1239184737,
0.3413706124,
0.4284456372,
-0.2669856548,
0.1092616618,
0.2529717982,
-0.242788747,
0.0317724086,
0.268849045,
0.3595820665,
0.2126444131,
-0.5472640395,
0.1586565822,
-0.2341153026,
-0.2256253809,
-0.3887996674,
-0.0480399467,
0.2228484899,
0.3881949484,
0.8205766082,
-0.0249030776,
0.0947625339,
-0.2651119828,
0.5863087177,
0.0899769142,
-0.4486478269,
-0.4624145925,
0.675845921,
0.5295996666,
0.2294910103,
0.268084079,
-0.2142268717,
-0.5083729029,
0.5425025821,
0.53640908,
0.9210128188,
-0.1208688021,
-0.1179443449,
0.8343778849,
0.2054971457,
0.049798999,
0.1266699433,
-0.1543621719,
-0.7384729981,
-0.5799809694,
-1.0204857588,
-0.5564371943,
0.0035975822,
-0.7942652702,
0.3484713733,
-0.2130678147,
-0.2007287443,
0.0990157872,
-0.0560089797,
-0.3652814031,
0.1383329928,
0.3079477251,
0.9478146434,
-0.6818414927,
0.9740558863,
0.6032794714,
-0.3646580875,
-0.7623748183,
-0.3265077472,
0.0867610946,
-0.0557053797,
0.6386198997,
0.0965265334,
0.0270687621,
0.0641645193,
-0.1786664128,
-0.7657697201,
1.1710569859,
0.0293065198,
-0.9260956049,
-0.2970911264,
0.0865366682,
0.4420614243,
-0.670737505,
0.2068049759,
0.7579812407,
0.350980252,
0.1199069172,
-0.8205392361,
0.1156040058,
0.0126846004,
-0.3537567556,
0.1318178624,
-0.271533221,
0.5987203121,
-0.2907701135,
-0.4052770138,
0.0936636627,
1.0613155365,
0.4036673605,
0.6641021967,
0.4042123854,
0.6082358956,
0.5986038446,
-0.2915102243,
0.7179633975,
-0.4701480567,
0.1890301257,
1.5560832024,
-0.3971273303,
0.6742640138,
0.7439275384,
0.000863318,
0.426520884,
0.2845912576,
0.3122469485,
0.2332803756,
-0.044759348,
-0.5249561667,
-0.3825159967,
-0.2789899111,
-0.2966364324,
0.0581215434,
0.6243215799,
-0.3836363256,
-0.4570382833,
0.1651701629,
0.0216279645,
0.2649998665,
-0.4359924495,
0.9839106798,
0.2452400476,
-0.807341218,
0.3529894352,
-0.0107173277,
0.7322697043,
-0.5125777125,
0.2883558869,
-0.0516490936,
0.5127514601,
-0.2120343894,
-0.4779968262,
0.8933510184,
0.2637085319,
-0.6280413866,
0.0294593554,
0.855874896,
-0.6484142542,
-0.3893947303,
0.5239294171,
0.4366557598,
-0.0111213699,
-0.095536679,
-0.2226159126,
-0.1119386256,
-0.0609697066,
-0.272331655,
0.3523850143,
0.7870568633,
0.0015951548,
0.4081305563,
0.7681524754,
-0.043438334,
0.2614627779,
0.0468471199,
0.9255226254,
-0.7108434439,
-0.2660407126,
-0.8531800508,
0.177153483,
-0.0085481685,
-0.3934551179,
0.5917441845,
0.6275318265,
0.7924363017,
-0.084207505,
0.8330354691,
-0.3582605422,
0.6789678931,
-0.254106462,
0.4761449397,
-0.1013619229,
0.0914791375,
-0.1921809465,
-0.6182079315,
-0.2054860294,
0.455719471,
-0.5145252943,
-0.5218889117,
0.6648566723,
0.5436684489,
0.2031416595,
0.3231374621,
0.2457799017,
-0.0060620941,
0.3984140456,
0.5648982525,
1.0414758921,
-0.1153621078,
0.6194571853,
-0.5558914542,
-0.4075523019,
-0.2460982502,
-1.09968853,
-1.0438745022,
-0.8487743139,
-0.6688064933,
-0.3678146899,
-0.1106634587,
1.13337183,
0.4061143696,
-1.1067816019,
0.0169998873,
-0.1851457059,
0.0924343765,
-0.1231816784,
-0.2920266986,
0.1912365705,
-0.4293982685,
-0.8573976159,
0.3933686614,
0.0218149945,
0.1280011982,
0.0678630993,
0.1541154087,
-0.3053279221,
0.189094767,
0.6843931079,
0.0578263439,
-0.6616460085,
-0.3473478258,
-0.1482330263,
-0.2021890432,
-0.1753683984,
1.1582841873,
-0.7742547989,
-0.2048849016,
0.5859428048,
0.2439973205,
0.3108118773,
0.2183766365,
0.48970294,
-0.6424922943,
0.1258074194,
0.229385376,
0.421545893,
0.2304316759,
-0.3932379186,
0.5319519043,
0.3449061215,
-0.7214898467,
-0.6292845011,
0.2862608731,
-1.35135746,
-0.1618109941,
1.139670372,
-0.2959691882,
-0.2776879668,
-0.4686543643,
-0.2984885573,
0.4198484123,
-0.4333103001,
0.8791601658,
0.6726021767,
-0.3536306322,
0.0450713895,
0.1835897416,
0.5978838801,
0.1412338167,
-0.7282425165,
0.4351493716,
0.7694755197,
0.3604522347,
0.6657633781,
0.5494262576,
-0.1677134931,
0.1497881114,
-0.0254651494,
0.3588638008,
-0.0275447536,
-0.3544368446,
-0.0088062491,
0.4603827894,
-0.1118321866,
0.2496440709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03192v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03192v2
|
Do Large Language Models Rank Fairly? An Empirical Study on the Fairness of LLMs as Rankers
| 2024-04-04T04:23:19 | 2024-06-25T20:54:16 |
Yuan Wang, Xuyang Wu, Hsin-Tai Wu, Zhiqiang Tao, Yi Fang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) in information retrieval has
raised a critical reevaluation of fairness in the text-ranking models. LLMs,
such as GPT models and Llama2, have shown effectiveness in natural language
understanding tasks, and prior works (e.g., RankGPT) have also demonstrated
that the LLMs exhibit better performance than the traditional ranking models in
the ranking task. However, their fairness remains largely unexplored. This
paper presents an empirical study evaluating these LLMs using the TREC Fair
Ranking dataset, focusing on the representation of binary protected attributes
such as gender and geographic location, which are historically underrepresented
in search outcomes. Our analysis delves into how these LLMs handle queries and
documents related to these attributes, aiming to uncover biases in their
ranking algorithms. We assess fairness from both user and content perspectives,
contributing an empirical benchmark for evaluating LLMs as the fair ranker.
|
[
-0.2057662457,
-0.4068749547,
1.0440847874,
0.0205406789,
0.0383702293,
0.2505737543,
-0.1626171619,
-0.7052750587,
-0.1751412451,
0.4366282821,
-0.1713511795,
-0.8076399565,
-0.9633871913,
0.1462182999,
-0.392054677,
0.7504556775,
0.2625972927,
0.1499004513,
-0.2242757678,
-0.2304054648,
-0.5740348697,
-0.9513412118,
-0.6333050132,
-0.3674625754,
0.3830065131,
0.0047431076,
0.9310339093,
0.6560605168,
0.6996026635,
0.3396014869,
-0.3735094965,
-0.1224338934,
-0.6598146558,
0.1130097881,
-0.3503147662,
-0.7792825103,
-0.3586519361,
0.3296162784,
0.8202525377,
0.9382616878,
-0.271214813,
0.0536648519,
0.1729620099,
0.5320504904,
-0.5546498299,
-0.0165843759,
-0.8748117685,
0.0671939179,
-0.4467055202,
0.0211338587,
-0.6201938391,
-0.874655664,
-0.0197546389,
-0.194229871,
0.5058608055,
0.4087793827,
0.6748692393,
0.1375102848,
-0.7625446916,
-0.2388911396,
-0.4059460163,
0.9730331302,
-0.6292510629,
0.3381190896,
0.4110228717,
0.5386959314,
-0.2286963463,
-0.5215097666,
-0.2898252308,
-0.1902100742,
-0.2598804832,
-0.2911158204,
-0.1945024282,
0.0288025867,
0.3791351616,
0.427739501,
-0.6360735893,
0.568531096,
-0.2102625817,
-0.2119756937,
0.5421824455,
0.0411018617,
0.2873603404,
-0.3618807495,
-0.2253561467,
0.1669102162,
-0.824637711,
0.1982226819,
0.6584072113,
0.4541471303,
-0.0438360386,
0.86765939,
-0.0718908682,
0.488263309,
-0.1801220477,
0.0005030242,
0.2598190308,
-0.1761930138,
-0.0283989776,
0.2054393291,
0.6609700322,
0.3009395897,
0.3794059157,
-0.4948499203,
-0.5858696103,
-0.1730903834,
0.1794689596,
-0.6239317656,
0.1568653136,
-0.0687004924,
-0.7536162734,
-0.209000051,
0.2420370579,
-0.4752034843,
-0.5172875524,
-0.1283624917,
0.2849996984,
0.1874269992,
-0.2057034224,
-0.0703317225,
-0.0324597694,
0.2367182076,
0.2394297868,
-0.951094389,
0.5573205352,
0.9925796986,
0.8023778796,
-0.3419109285,
-0.097791031,
-0.563285172,
0.0122376326,
-0.2282541096,
0.7271515727,
-0.6880077124,
-0.3743055463,
0.068086192,
-0.0854296237,
0.0347136557,
-0.8389897346,
0.5699568391,
-0.8320172429,
0.1852465719,
-0.5873499513,
-0.3349038959,
-0.0190159325,
0.1112593487,
-0.671259284,
1.0219663382,
-0.007966375,
-0.7952867746,
0.4436721504,
-0.6125368476,
-0.2642732859,
-0.1490060836,
-0.2265629172,
-0.1075543091,
0.168512553,
0.1788820475,
0.2897156477,
-0.4041020274,
0.4483957589,
-0.4038438797,
-0.6276962161,
0.5095453858,
-0.5360169411,
0.6629749537,
0.2538045943,
-0.4462949634,
-0.2673696578,
-0.2166179866,
-0.0037538323,
0.1403697282,
-0.3579173982,
-0.3975717127,
-0.0053268285,
-0.1452340186,
0.2404848933,
0.318741262,
-0.48177284,
0.0738523528,
-0.2590278387,
0.2772752345,
1.0491961241,
-0.4336831868,
0.7087523341,
-0.2153580487,
0.3995139599,
-0.2233180255,
-0.0093780868,
0.4958181679,
-0.4900085032,
-0.466845572,
-0.1374401003,
0.6915935874,
0.3287580609,
-0.4449978173,
0.1410617232,
-0.558599472,
-0.12417005,
-0.6921610832,
0.0787856281,
0.3757537007,
0.201680094,
0.1060390919,
-0.2316797078,
-0.0521181449,
-1.1614079475,
-0.3357726634,
-0.1464616954,
-0.3971847296,
0.5615724325,
0.4044923484,
0.1057154238,
0.9273721576,
-0.3217098415,
-0.0233365595,
-0.1824848652,
0.2705012262,
0.292255342,
0.1824357808,
0.6940687299,
-1.0139309168,
-0.0844864398,
-0.2576082349,
-0.8049424887,
-0.4444558322,
0.5671851635,
-0.3157479465,
0.3185859323,
0.1668303907,
-0.2511853576,
0.3811962008,
0.5631133914,
-0.5189490318,
0.2106913924,
0.0107322335,
0.6218925714,
-0.5715026259,
0.1168358102,
-0.1094359085,
-0.6903709173,
-0.1164500117,
0.1235278547,
-0.0553273335,
0.027722571,
-0.4957152307,
0.5187280178,
-0.2765084803,
-0.7419728637,
-0.2488491535,
0.2864470482,
-0.2118224502,
0.2033050507,
0.0407203995,
0.8823636174,
0.1810000688,
-0.4502333999,
-0.0961794928,
-0.0029711768,
-0.2789585888,
0.6473166943,
-0.6300714016,
0.3046619892,
-0.2894905806,
0.1388686597,
-0.8856696486,
0.1145325005,
-0.0938644931,
-0.3965912461,
0.1048411876,
-0.413133204,
-0.7930674553,
-0.1627004296,
-0.3773230612,
0.7229297161,
0.3317831159,
-0.6034830213,
0.2945039868,
0.687741816,
-0.2926336229,
-0.7981109023,
-0.8654392362,
0.1488539129,
-0.1633240134,
-0.5444202423,
0.3394235969,
-0.0242165681,
-0.5034618974,
0.110227637,
-0.0776903406,
-0.0698048472,
0.2725016475,
0.2677856684,
0.1208288893,
-0.1663113832,
-0.0075629698,
-0.2197267413,
-0.129396379,
-0.1500166506,
0.1060484275,
0.6500775218,
-0.2367680669,
-0.6283252835,
-0.064073287,
0.2031265795,
0.2722575366,
-0.259976089,
0.8447034359,
0.2079336792,
-0.5266453028,
0.055437699,
-0.757147491,
-0.0664426908,
-0.4710584283,
0.1721052527,
-0.1772890985,
-1.1197578907,
0.593321085,
0.2324215174,
0.0894872397,
0.6265141964,
0.2930110991,
-0.1358378083,
1.087381959,
0.6262230873,
-0.2054664493,
0.2513405085,
0.0915816352,
0.2428334206,
-0.5649114251,
-0.4761162102,
-0.9847865105,
-0.7376924753,
-1.0612486601,
-0.317351073,
0.2208279073,
-0.0279051065,
-0.4212861657,
-0.157897234,
-0.3537949026,
0.6269167066,
0.5895298123,
0.0912675187,
0.5198652148,
0.1643785536,
-0.1226565465,
-0.3580625951,
-0.4030062854,
-0.7820845246,
1.1417781115,
0.4997830093,
0.7817720771,
0.5461559892,
0.5279816389,
0.7688432932,
0.3513609469,
-0.4775542617,
0.5263931155,
-0.4672092199,
-0.6854159236,
-0.1769024879,
-0.7414965034,
-0.9731567502,
0.4020113647,
-0.1713249832,
-0.8432062864,
0.3171209395,
-0.2825462818,
0.1108212471,
0.4031032324,
-0.5263871551,
0.6872451901,
-0.4441557825,
-0.2996133566,
-0.2886884809,
-0.4356934428,
0.4250134528,
-0.0659093559,
0.3511037827,
-0.3297400475,
-0.0596141778,
0.7803814411,
-0.1245007217,
0.3599737287,
-0.2671716213,
-0.0298922583,
-0.1287581027,
0.2635734975,
0.2935614884,
0.0804324001,
-0.6678899527,
0.5269259214,
-0.178375423,
-0.5454552174,
-0.4180271029,
0.9416850805,
-0.5944983959,
-0.6503816843,
-0.6514932513,
-0.3213292062,
0.0174202602,
0.2243650258,
-0.0461040959,
0.2286895961,
0.00244301,
0.3407219052,
0.8241341114,
-0.4902914166,
0.2480454743,
0.6489700675,
-0.2143877596,
0.0084913103,
0.5907937884,
0.1952808052,
0.0807776526,
0.5557872653,
0.0215440616,
-0.653542459,
-0.6444718838,
0.0239149407,
0.2151784599,
-0.7097667456,
-0.1820593327,
-0.6255977154,
-0.3059272468,
-0.3362487853,
0.0028322642,
-0.3305665553,
-0.2791477442,
0.1099133193,
-0.1795299947,
0.0380191654,
1.0958293676,
0.0957609415,
0.2768255174,
-0.2501409352,
0.4646502435,
0.2382463217,
0.6177695394,
-0.0907610878,
-0.5496050119,
0.0912403166,
-0.0247689635,
-0.2221120596,
-0.4839962125,
0.076471284,
-0.3424973786,
0.9139716029,
-0.0472658761,
-0.0571247563,
0.2401482165,
-0.472649008,
0.8408678174,
-0.1675729007,
-0.7903356552,
0.2814114392,
-0.0850219578,
0.0648108199,
0.6275880337,
0.2400460541,
-0.4592589736,
-0.60438627,
-0.1801257133,
-0.748693347,
0.8080034852,
0.3570832014,
0.0858166367,
0.0683440864,
0.4455184937,
0.2358989865,
0.4252642691,
-1.2509526014,
-0.3435614705,
0.0901183188,
-0.3533584177,
0.0315754451,
-0.5388256907,
0.1132673621,
0.0839387551,
0.4047551751,
0.1986042112,
0.4267673194,
-0.1040475965,
-0.4434966445,
0.2237501293,
0.5248416066,
0.2341397256,
0.6925925016,
-0.3159523606,
0.3643420935,
0.1637734622,
-0.4068244994,
0.1770671904,
0.2157532722,
-0.2294332087,
-0.1057356223,
0.2592122555,
0.4420588017,
0.2013339847,
-0.4853470027,
0.5769580007,
-0.3874647021,
0.0811355338,
0.1684688032,
0.0524865091,
-0.034144152,
0.409094125,
0.5533684492,
-0.216546312,
0.4863173962,
-0.4624257684,
-0.0556736775,
0.6980926991,
-0.1282236874,
-0.0120067578,
0.888123095,
0.2376554608,
-0.1674180478,
0.7384703755,
-0.0798671767,
-0.6269099712,
0.5572870374,
0.3225362301,
0.580678761,
0.0681603402,
0.0631826669,
0.0054540392,
0.6807971001,
-0.2354015857,
0.1105592996,
0.0074735265,
-0.4342078269,
-0.0359333605,
-0.7486439347,
-0.2783106863,
-0.0953004286,
-0.3009164333,
0.0960577354,
-0.2450632155,
-0.3977702558,
-0.2256788462,
0.2402453423,
-1.1387693882,
0.0522299558,
0.3348167241,
0.8042011857,
-0.5777363777,
0.4453905225,
0.4495610595,
-0.2197621763,
-0.4846147597,
0.1258824766,
-0.0364207588,
-0.8515370488,
0.7835191488,
0.2954130471,
-0.2083833218,
-0.2298902124,
-0.4504846632,
-0.7136695981,
1.0576952696,
0.9106754661,
-0.5190649629,
-0.0403882973,
0.7580510378,
0.4164662957,
-0.0251744501,
0.6550303102,
0.3842386007,
0.4823366106,
-0.296174109,
-1.1510221958,
0.0583027601,
0.0501843877,
0.1279021353,
-0.0695425346,
-0.5710545778,
0.7032002211,
-0.0897005573,
-0.2048333138,
0.0693976879,
0.3757793605,
0.2920325398,
0.5279733539,
0.5570337772,
0.3727486134,
1.0135685205,
-0.4277454019,
1.2525275946,
0.16324763,
0.4315422177,
0.8393633366,
-0.3922973573,
0.7891353369,
0.1936047077,
-0.3723822534,
0.3927890658,
0.723271966,
0.1918048561,
0.6994324327,
0.2741445601,
-0.1887332797,
-0.2678448558,
-0.3882284462,
-0.4432933331,
0.3599905074,
-0.1153499931,
-0.5123970509,
-0.2261060476,
-0.3440802693,
-0.1815370768,
0.2395451665,
-0.4505471885,
0.6574534774,
0.2230974585,
-0.328140825,
0.0603089742,
0.3549709022,
0.9873473048,
-0.4752061665,
0.0479765348,
-0.554007113,
-0.1969683617,
-0.1898766756,
-1.33852005,
-0.0521507487,
0.3420188427,
-0.4122906029,
-0.2794911265,
0.6219161749,
-0.2091164291,
-0.5460437536,
0.3662596643,
0.4886617362,
0.3505509198,
-0.0798850507,
-0.5122845173,
0.0620990619,
-0.2991458476,
-0.2459829599,
0.4399783909,
0.4634240568,
-0.2812811732,
0.8186795712,
0.5359660387,
-0.0953737423,
-0.0238252711,
0.2732655704,
0.4128957093,
-0.724932313,
-0.4806209803,
-0.9238348007,
0.1662421823,
-0.1386434436,
0.1454545856,
0.6113334894,
0.7733563781,
0.740732789,
0.3837616444,
0.5215536952,
0.2015357316,
0.5087424517,
-0.6646934748,
1.0086210966,
-0.5990368724,
0.5892897844,
-0.0757456869,
-1.1268628836,
-0.0574465729,
0.3593018055,
-0.517632544,
0.5481272936,
0.3156636059,
0.6880432963,
-0.2599069476,
-0.2231266946,
0.2853597999,
0.154764086,
0.4486158788,
0.4401184916,
0.9141376019,
-0.1708535403,
0.3865928352,
0.1263103038,
0.0812606141,
-0.0913764462,
-0.9739305973,
-0.7177788019,
-0.029968597,
0.0694634169,
-0.1463040113,
0.3555118442,
0.8188763261,
0.5798030496,
-0.6200351715,
-0.1736592203,
0.5144324303,
0.7003106475,
0.2623419166,
-0.2560602427,
0.3027552664,
0.0367560573,
-0.9575129151,
0.0622932315,
0.0593947209,
-0.0618995056,
-0.1165761128,
-0.1848386228,
0.0349791311,
-0.2613599896,
0.5412739515,
-0.1387134641,
-0.6675201058,
-0.2902950048,
-0.1173839644,
-0.6061756611,
0.1141405553,
0.6754741669,
-0.9041869044,
0.1633441299,
0.3459807336,
0.6288398504,
0.2963481545,
0.0844827965,
0.5864706039,
-0.6922915578,
-0.0630957335,
0.1371064633,
0.427781105,
0.6107122898,
-0.4247832,
0.5962603092,
0.0911240727,
-0.6916329265,
-1.0597933531,
-0.1673331559,
-0.8513268232,
-0.1740935594,
1.1964737177,
0.2461401969,
0.0622058511,
0.0093437824,
-0.0479471013,
0.0962232426,
-0.5465423465,
0.784563005,
0.6261831522,
0.2180037796,
0.0369159915,
-0.9852787852,
0.0796663836,
0.3294963241,
-0.7224469185,
-0.0431754217,
0.4253081977,
0.481000334,
-0.3519209027,
0.5700595379,
-0.3480384946,
0.0887104794,
-0.7051712275,
-0.1310729682,
0.1046601385,
-0.0136089167,
-0.3279745877,
0.1957171708,
0.5183508992,
0.042778261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03189v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03189v2
|
The Probabilities Also Matter: A More Faithful Metric for Faithfulness of Free-Text Explanations in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-04T04:20:04 | 2024-06-07T11:54:44 |
Noah Y. Siegel, Oana-Maria Camburu, Nicolas Heess, Maria Perez-Ortiz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In order to oversee advanced AI systems, it is important to understand their
underlying decision-making process. When prompted, large language models (LLMs)
can provide natural language explanations or reasoning traces that sound
plausible and receive high ratings from human annotators. However, it is
unclear to what extent these explanations are faithful, i.e., truly capture the
factors responsible for the model's predictions. In this work, we introduce
Correlational Explanatory Faithfulness (CEF), a metric that can be used in
faithfulness tests based on input interventions. Previous metrics used in such
tests take into account only binary changes in the predictions. Our metric
accounts for the total shift in the model's predicted label distribution, more
accurately reflecting the explanations' faithfulness. We then introduce the
Correlational Counterfactual Test (CCT) by instantiating CEF on the
Counterfactual Test (CT) from Atanasova et al. (2023). We evaluate the
faithfulness of free-text explanations generated by few-shot-prompted LLMs from
the Llama2 family on three NLP tasks. We find that our metric measures aspects
of faithfulness which the CT misses.
|
[
-0.1233498231,
-1.015152216,
0.9572296739,
0.170726642,
-0.4139730334,
-0.5241761208,
-0.1418930292,
-0.3545558155,
0.1170032397,
0.2860042751,
-0.5731104612,
-0.3030867279,
-0.6611925364,
-0.0639620125,
-0.4587369263,
1.3342130184,
-0.3212237954,
0.2145208716,
-0.5299387574,
-0.0605648421,
-0.4105044901,
-0.2969723046,
-0.470928371,
-0.5740475655,
0.7822294831,
0.1817958653,
1.1956324577,
0.6277967691,
0.7683247328,
0.153049618,
0.1010039225,
0.1333941519,
-0.3183947802,
0.0371647999,
-0.4103735983,
-0.7860790491,
-0.2733563483,
0.092335701,
0.5200542808,
0.6129305959,
-0.0017177134,
0.04341463,
0.2845166326,
0.5466086268,
-0.5221812129,
0.1867129803,
-0.7666076422,
-0.0431073308,
-0.1474463046,
-0.2644230127,
-0.4491377175,
-0.3218739033,
0.0290944204,
-0.6867973208,
0.3985233009,
-0.0203912854,
0.8308517337,
0.3704117239,
-0.2593948543,
-0.2475698292,
-0.8298178911,
0.9596765041,
-0.6225136518,
0.2820299864,
0.7785757184,
0.024028996,
-0.5141460896,
-0.3558237553,
-0.5842292309,
-0.4322021008,
-0.0697998554,
0.2115754485,
-0.0580080897,
-0.021166794,
-0.0612108558,
0.2813460529,
-0.6581993699,
-0.0089824367,
0.1835863739,
-0.3639796078,
0.6342315078,
0.1419890076,
0.0457047708,
0.4275624156,
-0.2714599371,
-0.3873108029,
-0.8089119792,
-0.0287370775,
0.3874709904,
-0.0496748462,
-0.4040617347,
0.697148025,
0.2079569101,
0.6261276007,
-0.0127043165,
-0.1922012568,
-0.0824123099,
-0.732643187,
-0.1230893582,
-0.0870712772,
0.9078085423,
0.1962044984,
0.4553060532,
-0.2273249328,
0.0492477342,
0.1843415052,
0.0266950838,
-0.6382314563,
-0.2172127664,
0.3484473228,
-0.5049623251,
-0.3518474698,
0.0665076971,
-0.4580736458,
-0.1679436415,
-0.1989791393,
0.349083215,
-0.6520137787,
-0.0729719922,
-0.0399382561,
-0.1303363889,
0.2858608663,
0.3810806572,
-0.7915812731,
-0.083048299,
0.9251223803,
0.701759398,
-0.1501303613,
-0.4313560724,
-0.693965435,
0.1460460722,
-0.7085002661,
0.704120636,
-0.5955600142,
-0.2876343727,
0.0681638941,
-0.0615075156,
0.0702665672,
-0.1203433275,
0.6378394365,
-0.5705007911,
-0.0073945513,
-0.4605735242,
-0.6305971146,
-0.270654887,
0.2530505657,
-0.5027310252,
0.6508604288,
-0.2051790804,
-0.8254029751,
0.554145515,
-0.1850668639,
-0.2076145113,
-0.1591864377,
-0.1428723782,
-0.6702088118,
0.2441376746,
0.0318889953,
0.3096435666,
-0.1876908988,
0.5854321122,
-0.7678605318,
-0.3564988077,
0.9849700332,
-0.8570571542,
0.6903190017,
-0.1302960366,
-0.2789165974,
-0.2056217194,
-0.5138831139,
-0.202613771,
0.11358542,
-0.112600781,
-0.3054263592,
0.3665531874,
-0.2108467817,
-0.1202370226,
0.2904850543,
-0.46355322,
-0.1113215387,
-0.373108238,
-0.2418260425,
0.6432019472,
0.0983097106,
0.3384829164,
-0.5471009612,
0.2915562689,
0.1129391864,
0.2523727119,
-0.125853613,
-0.8830984235,
-0.4991936982,
-0.222241357,
0.2013184428,
0.4754185975,
-0.4947930872,
0.2000418305,
-0.1413762569,
-0.5062893629,
-0.3301221728,
0.2191559374,
0.707064569,
0.2390939295,
0.2501725852,
-0.1632340103,
-0.3989379406,
-0.9488227963,
-0.6890121698,
-0.608777225,
0.0032925289,
0.0691476613,
0.6328169107,
0.0102999937,
1.0622386932,
-0.1577477753,
-0.355715692,
-0.0676115379,
0.3409297168,
0.3114892542,
0.2429553419,
0.5584515333,
-0.7289118767,
-0.2392259091,
-0.2461318374,
-0.7087433338,
-0.1079218984,
-0.3198153675,
0.0807379186,
0.206143856,
0.3321278393,
-0.5384455323,
0.4963083267,
0.851472497,
-0.3424477577,
0.606017828,
-0.4105843902,
0.0588343069,
-0.6869381666,
-0.09739957,
0.0194298644,
-0.1720966995,
-0.3774320483,
0.2616000175,
-0.0824056268,
0.5890330672,
-0.3624860346,
0.4771381021,
-0.1369525641,
-0.0507929288,
-0.0878104344,
0.250525862,
-0.0641147718,
0.2497009635,
0.0290730391,
0.7492703795,
0.164757058,
-0.5349112153,
-0.0150510129,
0.3008288741,
-0.1010229141,
0.2978383303,
-0.6888659596,
0.0483599976,
-0.0753803775,
0.3544894755,
-1.2528213263,
-0.2858817577,
-0.0092996433,
-0.7208954692,
-0.1706701815,
0.0077439621,
-0.6300206184,
0.0125720948,
-0.3274284303,
0.1908196807,
0.3605012,
-0.3961605728,
0.4189545214,
-0.1065782607,
0.2396512479,
-0.6642608047,
-0.9786077142,
-0.1087829769,
0.0176002644,
-0.4747985601,
0.3055512905,
-0.2498775572,
-0.5607590079,
-0.1009901762,
0.0549457856,
-0.1026619747,
0.3277206123,
0.4202487767,
0.5385022163,
-0.1678925306,
0.1114631593,
-0.0754406527,
-0.1290078461,
0.3371612132,
-0.1031280532,
0.3556247652,
-0.088512361,
-0.6090236306,
-0.4873447716,
0.146781534,
0.3474388719,
-0.116817005,
1.1574732065,
0.7886586785,
-0.1353693604,
0.1377816498,
-0.4550085664,
-0.2901915312,
-0.3681406975,
0.2755659223,
-0.3601396084,
-0.6559996605,
0.6582336426,
0.562997818,
0.317548573,
0.5575602651,
0.5480493903,
-0.1054311469,
1.1767163277,
0.324982971,
0.134129256,
0.2831506729,
0.1961883008,
0.403097868,
-0.5489506721,
-0.1926954538,
-0.5367278457,
0.0646825805,
-0.7538253069,
-0.491191119,
0.2423054874,
0.2588970065,
-0.1129816547,
0.1906110793,
-0.0443866216,
0.4178060889,
0.5192828178,
0.1552200764,
0.4502567053,
0.0065087611,
-0.0372702032,
-0.1761433631,
-0.3132287562,
-0.5540444851,
1.2219219208,
0.348716259,
0.6585099697,
0.311218828,
0.6705551147,
0.0832211077,
0.5450131893,
-0.6214949489,
0.4110340476,
-0.3135703206,
-0.7347873449,
-0.3123521507,
-0.2568080723,
-0.9004599452,
0.0668137521,
-0.3701664805,
-0.6941150427,
0.1063444242,
0.4193943739,
-0.3363881707,
0.2087585628,
-0.2325121909,
0.3864323199,
-0.1662095934,
-0.5537410975,
-0.443796128,
-0.4085609913,
0.516079545,
-0.3729926646,
0.3447689712,
-0.0487266332,
-0.1499298513,
0.6943033934,
-0.2196343392,
0.8275625706,
0.0338546783,
-0.2845744789,
0.2858266234,
0.5326145887,
0.6995394826,
0.3355621099,
-0.2804278731,
0.4278155267,
-0.0261415094,
-0.1783845872,
-0.6100261211,
0.530798912,
-0.7379322648,
-0.6616939306,
-0.2006780654,
-0.5656088591,
-0.2061203122,
-0.2101252675,
0.3020765185,
0.2841364443,
-0.4513744116,
0.4067394733,
0.9795209169,
-0.3433806896,
0.3751972318,
0.5643620491,
-0.2956258655,
-0.3217990696,
0.6684093475,
-0.0980863646,
0.375739783,
0.5735810995,
0.5075594783,
-0.3324266076,
-0.5320217609,
-0.3801732957,
0.269842267,
-0.5683464408,
-0.0929237902,
-0.480609864,
0.0756495744,
-0.1964815408,
-0.2918774784,
-0.2788348496,
-0.2729299664,
-0.4750302732,
-0.019388793,
0.4142118096,
0.5758252144,
-0.2191465944,
0.3043774366,
-0.7240857482,
0.4909643233,
0.3688447475,
0.2206019759,
0.047289107,
-0.7639305592,
-0.0043276367,
0.4665967226,
-0.1902657002,
-1.0999786854,
0.2516717017,
0.3333208263,
0.4350233078,
0.6502780914,
-0.1903610229,
0.6739510894,
-0.2355708778,
1.0011930466,
0.3343854845,
-0.7538076043,
0.420042932,
-0.5381454825,
0.1320308447,
0.5392401814,
0.2629730999,
-0.2705699801,
-0.7550202012,
-0.6688335538,
-0.4308758378,
0.5687947273,
0.2286258191,
0.1291831732,
-0.1430521309,
0.3897692561,
0.3092499971,
-0.1351225227,
-0.7884192467,
-0.2903760076,
-0.0011984914,
-0.2999387681,
-0.0966404304,
-0.2346318364,
-0.2539049685,
0.176369831,
0.8126553297,
-0.1841485202,
0.3379432261,
0.4584185183,
-0.0816636905,
-0.2635816634,
0.2330077589,
0.628714025,
0.7048532367,
-0.1440658569,
0.2274672836,
0.2163426578,
-0.5094043612,
0.0103863273,
-0.1383785009,
-0.1458752602,
0.2624037564,
0.7405430675,
0.5670630932,
-0.0355536416,
-0.3903799057,
0.83617419,
-0.0973039865,
-0.3754138052,
-0.6052601337,
0.1682744622,
0.1824070066,
-0.0640246347,
0.2605788112,
-0.0944810957,
-0.0514002219,
-0.5981389284,
0.1639037728,
0.7347875237,
-0.7033000588,
-0.4289853573,
0.8170056939,
-0.277582556,
-0.3609437644,
0.5228488445,
-0.2998814583,
-0.367648989,
0.7591776848,
0.6157395244,
0.7878326774,
-0.1849570721,
0.4360512197,
0.2488649935,
0.3533909619,
-0.2047002912,
0.1391501576,
0.2165776789,
-0.8080180883,
-0.7382828593,
-0.6124883294,
-0.518697679,
0.2141399384,
-0.4795010984,
0.1535342485,
-0.2363601327,
0.0520540364,
0.1778967083,
-0.2624918222,
-0.7140036821,
0.1760041416,
0.104971908,
0.7401102781,
-0.9874027967,
0.6170420647,
0.3861053586,
-0.5037821531,
-0.8438639641,
0.1188303232,
0.098460637,
-0.9392587543,
0.6138594151,
-0.1758432835,
-0.1395794898,
-0.5250593424,
-0.8078042269,
-0.9797769785,
0.7635734081,
0.5992286205,
-0.6871523857,
0.2364120185,
0.3854477704,
0.6445116401,
-0.0949454159,
0.5944559574,
0.4252787828,
0.6223489642,
-0.1253107041,
-0.8466472626,
0.0431780815,
0.2092041075,
-0.1177983135,
0.0961010158,
-0.4955431819,
0.6554224491,
-0.4608992636,
0.1610553712,
0.2259820104,
0.7013267279,
0.5581648946,
0.4142680764,
0.6344121099,
0.4253005683,
0.4406485558,
-0.2054613382,
1.251236558,
-0.1406621486,
0.2579462826,
1.0739606619,
-0.0012830755,
0.8925880194,
0.7505623102,
-0.28187114,
0.7234289646,
0.6895990968,
-0.0014429189,
0.4565691948,
-0.0056412495,
-0.110414274,
-0.554256916,
-0.2548714578,
-0.1135014221,
0.5043608546,
0.3529451191,
-0.617916882,
-0.0714775994,
-0.2567021549,
0.2698908448,
-0.1068448871,
-0.0824539512,
0.7740519643,
0.2638807297,
-1.0766505003,
0.369081229,
-0.058150053,
0.3071042299,
-0.6134352088,
-0.2654765844,
-0.3114702404,
0.3813694715,
-0.2590535879,
-1.0790919065,
0.3811929822,
-0.1727251261,
-0.233531788,
-0.1268905997,
0.4084464014,
-0.4687159061,
-0.383202076,
0.3114317358,
0.4213432372,
0.3376397789,
-0.0823870599,
-0.5797891617,
-0.1953340322,
0.0769547075,
-0.2338770628,
0.2605433464,
0.2934601903,
-0.3146470487,
0.4706343114,
0.8421969414,
0.1064298898,
-0.2793199122,
0.0679148212,
0.3787665069,
-0.2236859202,
-0.373577863,
-1.1873656511,
0.2736618221,
0.2051008791,
-0.3281877637,
0.6505426764,
0.3389522731,
0.4639258683,
-0.0071201622,
0.5738741755,
0.1879156828,
0.2113660127,
-0.5284761786,
0.434060812,
-0.4952355325,
0.1505308747,
-0.2727347314,
-1.0368736982,
-0.2162099779,
0.3507332206,
-0.2536444962,
-0.185389325,
0.9704923034,
0.8173096776,
0.0138595877,
0.2611003816,
0.3637854159,
0.1114283502,
0.2383504808,
0.5246614814,
0.6494799256,
-0.4508826435,
0.7432099581,
0.0263854563,
-0.1797922254,
-0.2080489099,
-1.137498498,
-0.7546522021,
-0.4622148275,
-0.4700218439,
-0.4511010349,
0.2408675253,
0.5759187937,
0.358771503,
-0.8280720115,
0.1735169291,
-0.4449422956,
0.2122280598,
-0.3867576122,
-0.1706530452,
0.4366131723,
-0.2340936661,
-0.4251015186,
0.1029625386,
0.1408079118,
0.0804440677,
-0.3429819942,
-0.0399657972,
0.0344529115,
0.3515692651,
0.2536048293,
-0.1867759377,
-0.9259600043,
-0.4512059391,
0.1029559448,
0.0857097208,
-0.0821819827,
0.6986283064,
-0.6259570718,
0.2825559974,
0.5595377684,
0.4955473542,
0.2517967522,
-0.1586789191,
0.6985219121,
-0.57443434,
-0.0380793363,
-0.08477927,
0.398501277,
0.3357618153,
-0.3764088154,
0.5125989318,
0.0782819241,
-0.5866367221,
-0.5419053435,
0.2687608898,
-0.7567076683,
-0.161729306,
1.5543529987,
-0.4390512705,
-0.2679625154,
-0.2248805761,
0.1641613394,
0.4142540395,
-0.2632736862,
0.7925439477,
0.9813919067,
-0.0539769307,
0.0250626449,
-0.5350727439,
0.4155586362,
0.8034447432,
-0.6148546934,
0.1770050526,
0.2492425442,
0.0961109772,
0.3252845407,
0.3952806592,
-0.2751627564,
0.4547539651,
0.0754657909,
-0.2364189774,
0.1921099126,
-0.0678392649,
-0.2966438234,
-0.0941572636,
0.1935507506,
-0.0608381927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03184v1
|
The Death of Feature Engineering? BERT with Linguistic Features on SQuAD 2.0
| 2024-04-04T03:50:34 | 2024-04-04T03:50:34 |
Jiawei Li, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine reading comprehension is an essential natural language processing
task, which takes into a pair of context and query and predicts the
corresponding answer to query. In this project, we developed an end-to-end
question answering model incorporating BERT and additional linguistic features.
We conclude that the BERT base model will be improved by incorporating the
features. The EM score and F1 score are improved 2.17 and 2.14 compared with
BERT(base). Our best single model reaches EM score 76.55 and F1 score 79.97 in
the hidden test set. Our error analysis also shows that the linguistic
architecture can help model understand the context better in that it can locate
answers that BERT only model predicted "No Answer" wrongly.
|
[
-0.7864551544,
-1.0497719049,
0.5861031413,
0.24841474,
-0.1585453749,
0.214542225,
0.0006676912,
-0.984824419,
0.0844450071,
0.7249458432,
-0.9358472228,
-0.098086603,
-0.4006383717,
-0.0463712178,
-0.4404435158,
0.9656683207,
0.0103788748,
-0.018609684,
-0.1713579595,
-0.0867797136,
-0.6146225333,
-0.6491074562,
-0.5929210782,
-0.2361613661,
0.4946751595,
0.2952555418,
0.6551500559,
0.4232036173,
0.5752328634,
0.2227147222,
-0.415820539,
-0.212083146,
-0.5612384081,
0.5096811056,
-0.0211747661,
-0.4614449739,
-0.3430244029,
0.0826810002,
0.1414130777,
0.8780411482,
0.4594396651,
0.1228795722,
0.1125026047,
0.5935236812,
-0.1222116724,
0.1820004284,
-0.7086319923,
-0.1560500264,
0.4368950427,
0.0006659905,
-0.590018332,
-0.0130896801,
0.5981581807,
-0.4319963753,
0.4743730128,
0.1225264892,
1.0490746498,
0.5014217496,
-0.1684045196,
-0.3029696643,
-0.3620282114,
0.8560654521,
-0.367415756,
0.1779034436,
0.6328505874,
0.37059623,
0.0306826886,
-0.2907569706,
-0.4255003929,
-0.199084878,
0.0266754739,
0.1761643142,
0.0778557435,
0.127209425,
-0.225991413,
-0.0228999201,
-0.6591506004,
0.3148632646,
-0.615052402,
-0.3077644706,
0.8090691566,
-0.2188370675,
0.2958201468,
-0.2938480675,
-0.4048426747,
-0.0975582078,
-0.4446460307,
0.0966476277,
0.2785596251,
0.1703673303,
0.1456544697,
0.4297860265,
-0.1882941872,
0.5199995041,
-0.3029107451,
0.5541628003,
0.2156576365,
-0.1121568829,
-0.3103142679,
0.1506340802,
0.3290033638,
0.2895611227,
0.4185240269,
-0.2456576824,
-0.2682954669,
-0.1566648334,
0.3779898286,
-0.3801228404,
-0.177507177,
0.4991516769,
-0.500985682,
-0.4463934004,
-0.1203324348,
-0.4489692152,
-0.0258933064,
-0.0161140021,
0.4265572727,
-0.8430458307,
-0.2711203992,
-0.2478820086,
-0.5376235247,
0.7014703155,
0.4842927456,
-0.9356785417,
-0.1162572578,
0.7703632116,
0.8340688944,
0.1281613559,
-0.0963243172,
-0.0479880497,
-0.0722886175,
-0.3879899383,
1.0850676298,
-0.6232929826,
-0.4978973567,
-0.0508374162,
0.1815277487,
-0.152617529,
-0.3162657917,
0.2782451212,
-0.7450340986,
0.3531413972,
-0.4491398036,
-0.66167593,
-0.5229343176,
0.2853429914,
-0.7265166044,
1.1093484163,
0.316868335,
-0.1971075088,
0.2919190824,
-0.9765973091,
-0.4645569623,
0.0892780647,
0.2376519442,
-0.2304489464,
0.07648886,
0.2062590718,
0.3698682487,
0.0738729239,
-0.0506698899,
-0.5471084118,
-0.4697701633,
0.2768940926,
-0.1414065212,
0.960026741,
0.2563607693,
-0.3512506783,
-0.1890304685,
-0.4412760735,
0.4982604384,
-0.0831120759,
-0.1986841708,
-0.0888897553,
0.3158110678,
0.2690655589,
0.2174982578,
0.2454034388,
-0.664413631,
-0.0426273569,
-0.4451066554,
0.4969492853,
0.7310746312,
0.0884707421,
0.5997946858,
-0.5821900368,
0.4023964107,
-0.309222728,
0.0251537208,
-0.2233677953,
-1.1394968033,
-0.7683802247,
-0.2724734843,
0.253318429,
0.9504169226,
-0.4581770897,
0.700312376,
0.2011061013,
-0.410568893,
-0.7306802273,
0.0315152481,
0.4870086908,
0.4608008265,
0.4904070199,
0.0570537262,
-0.4280460775,
-1.1757683754,
0.0152164428,
-0.4896648824,
-0.2571315169,
0.1210066974,
0.5002080202,
-0.1184679344,
0.9970113635,
-0.3105507791,
-0.2225359529,
-0.8503739238,
0.160349682,
0.0671239495,
0.3937473297,
0.7835902572,
-0.8667345047,
-0.1941821575,
-0.0409021005,
-0.9008643031,
-0.1276286989,
0.0666389018,
-0.1565622091,
0.6146960855,
0.2855955362,
-0.5382421017,
0.3371258676,
0.4073618054,
-0.3128054142,
0.2423744202,
-0.034573067,
0.1912895441,
-0.9288505316,
-0.0085182562,
-0.0133728888,
-0.1153896675,
-0.7449278235,
0.3833395839,
0.0655623153,
-0.1996807307,
-0.3864023983,
0.4455376267,
-0.3207043111,
-0.2846868336,
-0.2434690446,
0.0754446536,
0.1349140257,
0.4480918646,
-0.0777443126,
0.8108743429,
0.381816566,
-0.5172016025,
0.3263983727,
0.3678649664,
-0.2748763263,
0.1503685862,
-0.827075541,
0.2309850305,
-0.3176354468,
-0.0594596677,
-1.5197998285,
-0.3410060704,
-0.1194245741,
-0.846204102,
0.3570429981,
0.0891989917,
-0.5338934064,
-0.3426735103,
-0.3151643574,
-0.1564951092,
0.8127530217,
-0.1646895558,
0.2277697176,
0.4799682796,
-0.55756253,
-0.1793795973,
-0.9621341228,
-0.0764336437,
0.2162261158,
-1.0442243814,
0.2022937685,
-0.0960835591,
-0.3393663466,
0.1124817953,
-0.004529112,
-0.667463243,
0.4156016409,
-0.0174425486,
0.3468959033,
-0.5537281632,
0.4866226912,
0.3974739313,
-0.0724282563,
0.0563797504,
0.1829671264,
0.5792170167,
-0.0761584714,
-0.0305180047,
-0.2211094201,
0.7823112607,
0.6725272536,
-0.3791537881,
0.7143566012,
0.4302101433,
-0.3428207338,
-0.1978323162,
-0.5062640905,
-0.2706435919,
-0.4677545726,
0.8268665075,
-0.4403344393,
-1.0966062546,
0.8722086549,
0.4850719869,
0.3473940194,
0.6815909743,
0.3609583974,
-0.9010412693,
1.288973093,
0.9583641887,
-0.1741789132,
0.4218953848,
-0.2168587893,
0.3220257461,
-0.5806520581,
-0.3255992532,
-0.5828094482,
-0.6895554066,
-0.4885605872,
-0.1245985553,
0.4104455411,
0.3570937812,
-0.0954674482,
0.354319185,
-0.7892007828,
0.3437137604,
0.8145338893,
0.5446652174,
-0.1497021019,
-0.1134257838,
-0.0034383107,
0.0825611874,
-0.3892899454,
-0.5811738968,
0.7699897289,
0.5059062839,
0.5336403847,
0.1272305548,
0.6013055444,
0.4381289184,
0.127687797,
-0.7574958801,
0.6812829375,
0.1954046935,
-1.0837404728,
-0.7638180256,
-0.045914419,
-0.5889406204,
0.0110816834,
0.0711714923,
-0.8127225041,
-0.0085649928,
-0.0019969156,
-0.1962871253,
0.0646184683,
-1.1709090471,
1.0209736824,
-0.2409428358,
0.1877732128,
-0.121442169,
-0.8815792203,
0.2231498659,
-0.1765836626,
0.0223825853,
-0.360560149,
-0.1674929112,
0.7164729238,
-0.3871485293,
0.7494593263,
-0.1775418222,
0.170439437,
0.4080077112,
0.0304685086,
0.1350199729,
-0.0776766166,
-0.5649941564,
-0.0463493466,
0.2105071545,
-0.7555462122,
-0.6111374497,
0.4471229911,
-0.8716201186,
-0.6558858156,
-0.1885623485,
-0.7381263971,
-0.2627945542,
-0.0242812522,
0.2572149932,
0.1911219656,
-0.0549974553,
0.1599764377,
1.0531814098,
-0.4229655266,
0.848805666,
0.3607108593,
0.116645813,
-0.1147515923,
0.5706422925,
-0.0262521803,
0.5567203164,
0.478536576,
-0.2179560661,
-0.47054106,
-0.4946866333,
-0.776814878,
0.0928940549,
-0.7664501071,
-0.0300162174,
-0.8251020312,
-0.6967112422,
-0.5856892467,
-0.3765952289,
0.0131576154,
-0.5198358297,
-0.4353895485,
-0.2904318869,
0.5911704302,
0.8602082729,
0.4570070207,
0.3897472024,
-0.8284015656,
-0.0018356616,
0.1104553193,
0.2178032845,
-0.5724841952,
-0.6952713132,
-0.0693424791,
0.0373688936,
-0.3823083937,
-1.1708214283,
0.2060333192,
0.3950103521,
0.7253754139,
0.0669901147,
0.0147869466,
0.3684769571,
-0.3973567486,
0.9048421979,
-0.2418841273,
-0.8262805939,
0.9047415853,
-0.2539117932,
0.4739097059,
0.6376249194,
0.2570485771,
-0.2669706047,
-0.7986600995,
-0.5310831666,
-0.496691972,
0.7091210485,
0.0994639322,
0.2756844759,
-0.0092338743,
0.3931955397,
-0.0140045648,
0.0564457029,
-0.34118402,
-0.2001140118,
-0.1701147705,
-0.3578721583,
0.0379944667,
-0.5178734064,
0.4437187016,
-0.235142231,
0.6100854874,
-0.120499827,
0.6253812909,
0.3023263812,
-0.3401782215,
-0.1479130089,
0.2063216865,
0.7235566378,
0.673538506,
-0.5334570408,
-0.329762429,
0.130758062,
-0.3500376344,
-0.016210245,
0.2099458426,
-0.2068346143,
0.1808192134,
0.6681030989,
0.4532036781,
0.2796975374,
-0.6743035913,
0.2459149063,
0.3647037446,
-0.4204313457,
-0.1119124591,
0.2590952516,
-0.0287292544,
0.2102452219,
0.6742638946,
0.1640185565,
0.1459316611,
-0.7275615931,
0.6741297841,
0.3673154414,
-0.7840033174,
-0.1824080646,
0.6444986463,
0.2018336654,
-0.2752844393,
0.5489223599,
-0.1603786349,
-0.9312599301,
1.1119478941,
0.4585709572,
0.8440145254,
-0.3571652174,
0.4089308679,
0.0761920214,
0.7623305917,
0.3434678018,
0.7508543134,
0.1492972821,
-0.6067249775,
-0.4314265251,
-0.6661782861,
-0.5049274564,
-0.1624713242,
-0.6311075687,
0.1943925619,
-0.4602515996,
0.233932063,
0.1236508414,
-0.0245599337,
-0.5231328011,
0.3961430192,
0.0606540665,
1.0416337252,
-0.5867718458,
0.9377314448,
1.0058500767,
-0.6609119773,
-0.5439083576,
-0.1141306013,
-0.0446084701,
-1.0740704536,
0.8326393366,
0.4731098413,
0.3754207492,
0.2341153473,
-0.4839420617,
-0.8266334534,
0.8814867735,
0.1860462129,
-0.3436158001,
-0.2318719476,
0.0554913655,
0.5651625395,
-0.2716296911,
0.5352259278,
0.5386482477,
0.3707241714,
0.1101294681,
-1.0344759226,
-0.1167232469,
-0.2276103795,
-0.0795189142,
0.2835762501,
-0.5179946423,
0.6551160812,
-0.3566011786,
0.0325934365,
0.3095940948,
0.5692644119,
0.0769313201,
0.2058594078,
0.457855314,
0.4665128887,
0.5823419094,
-0.2652224302,
1.175406456,
-0.2430334091,
0.4740664065,
0.6819327474,
-0.2609032691,
1.1605963707,
0.210321039,
-0.0534045659,
0.4061264992,
1.1110241413,
0.1597977579,
0.8141350746,
-0.0512692071,
-0.1783527136,
-0.4229088426,
0.111606352,
-0.2884787023,
0.4405776262,
0.3364968896,
-0.5739245415,
-0.2794901133,
0.2293944806,
-0.2670877874,
-0.1234629005,
-0.0934160873,
0.8218491673,
-0.0790160522,
-0.5716888905,
0.4911597669,
-0.1746550202,
0.326892674,
-0.4061832726,
-0.1254124194,
-0.4051148891,
0.0448184535,
0.2231690288,
-1.1873339415,
0.4611582756,
-0.1411015689,
-0.6554021239,
-0.3463962972,
0.684078455,
-0.2812390924,
-0.6492860317,
0.3893118799,
0.5038492084,
0.2984724045,
-0.3782070279,
-0.9264309406,
0.1185346097,
-0.0140814129,
-0.1888123304,
0.1406664103,
0.4316917062,
-0.0077649732,
0.8278239965,
0.4294514656,
-0.3821386695,
0.3465597332,
-0.0418223552,
0.8042506576,
-0.7682815194,
-0.5616236925,
-0.7185770273,
0.5465984344,
-0.1931889057,
-0.3644080162,
0.3490126133,
0.4629243314,
0.705614388,
-0.0231024176,
1.0419055223,
-0.2063643187,
0.7730468512,
-0.3733333945,
1.056709528,
-0.4955536127,
0.1557352692,
-0.2148033231,
-0.9789379239,
-0.3923929334,
0.512465179,
-0.1854182482,
0.1326020956,
0.7241324782,
0.7301712632,
0.1500510424,
0.3088682592,
0.5742717981,
0.1262951046,
0.341899693,
0.6006379724,
0.8021069765,
-0.5376735926,
0.6643304229,
-0.0555936843,
-0.4554763138,
-0.3501459062,
-0.3072643578,
-1.1651756763,
-0.6296066642,
0.0051444443,
-0.2712858021,
0.3033773601,
0.6938427687,
0.7304806113,
-1.0242952108,
0.1195614859,
0.0258743931,
0.2695414722,
-0.1328193545,
-0.3085874915,
0.1479415894,
-0.9456846714,
-0.5737749338,
0.3957504928,
0.5944558382,
-0.1195043027,
-0.2324475795,
-0.0167823341,
-0.4248885512,
-0.1227868125,
0.6496378183,
0.1536076665,
-0.97291857,
-0.7384294868,
0.5298008919,
-0.146522671,
-0.1195412055,
0.4486123919,
-0.7692989111,
0.3712940514,
0.6201261282,
1.056961298,
0.1012183949,
-0.0570618249,
0.7918792963,
-0.563749969,
0.0939776376,
0.4640322924,
0.3613649309,
0.0576449521,
-0.537851274,
0.352630049,
0.2729313672,
-0.6171203256,
-0.6993066072,
0.1792351902,
-1.1171017885,
-0.451374799,
0.8746853471,
-0.0276856571,
-0.555645287,
-0.5611999631,
-0.2317391634,
0.0873621628,
-0.2881419957,
0.6671288013,
0.851724565,
-0.2535015941,
-0.631079793,
-0.8337751031,
0.2602589726,
0.6884374619,
-0.8397779465,
-0.4547458887,
0.2419286668,
0.31652987,
0.0844441876,
0.351149857,
0.1789740026,
0.5869799852,
-0.1918708533,
0.0780028254,
0.0941854417,
-0.378764689,
0.028813649,
0.1819601208,
-0.062730737,
-0.5849713683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04287v1
|
CONFLARE: CONFormal LArge language model REtrieval
| 2024-04-04T02:58:21 | 2024-04-04T02:58:21 |
Pouria Rouzrokh, Shahriar Faghani, Cooper U. Gamble, Moein Shariatnia, Bradley J. Erickson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) frameworks enable large language models
(LLMs) to retrieve relevant information from a knowledge base and incorporate
it into the context for generating responses. This mitigates hallucinations and
allows for the updating of knowledge without retraining the LLM. However, RAG
does not guarantee valid responses if retrieval fails to identify the necessary
information as the context for response generation. Also, if there is
contradictory content, the RAG response will likely reflect only one of the two
possible responses. Therefore, quantifying uncertainty in the retrieval process
is crucial for ensuring RAG trustworthiness. In this report, we introduce a
four-step framework for applying conformal prediction to quantify retrieval
uncertainty in RAG frameworks. First, a calibration set of questions answerable
from the knowledge base is constructed. Each question's embedding is compared
against document embeddings to identify the most relevant document chunks
containing the answer and record their similarity scores. Given a
user-specified error rate ({\alpha}), these similarity scores are then analyzed
to determine a similarity score cutoff threshold. During inference, all chunks
with similarity exceeding this threshold are retrieved to provide context to
the LLM, ensuring the true answer is captured in the context with a
(1-{\alpha}) confidence level. We provide a Python package that enables users
to implement the entire workflow proposed in our work, only using LLMs and
without human intervention.
|
[
-0.3550220132,
-0.6178299785,
0.7119839191,
-0.0035196196,
-0.0633291379,
-0.1310373098,
-0.2004119158,
-0.5373322964,
-0.0431589298,
0.4713158011,
-0.3513020575,
-0.2371276766,
-0.7274606228,
0.0284413341,
-0.5153739452,
0.7492387891,
-0.0792870969,
0.0343039073,
-0.3878031969,
0.0619101673,
-0.2682986856,
-0.3136417866,
-0.5494259596,
-0.3425477147,
0.3126118779,
0.4074382484,
0.8033237457,
0.233553499,
0.680059135,
0.2381483614,
-0.2426261306,
0.0985346437,
-0.557377398,
0.5326073766,
-0.2793815732,
-0.5927283764,
-0.2992113829,
-0.1222453788,
0.5562124848,
0.4668637514,
-0.3128197789,
0.4380036891,
-0.0072211893,
0.6336465478,
-0.8668951392,
0.1070704311,
-1.0237444639,
-0.2057203948,
-0.2526362836,
0.031494949,
-0.4309375286,
-0.412550807,
0.3005925715,
-0.7416853905,
0.2829836011,
0.3154463172,
0.8032410741,
0.4116075337,
-0.4246703684,
-0.5711656213,
-0.666529119,
0.85710603,
-0.8197094798,
0.521997571,
0.7067877054,
0.5061439276,
-0.496222347,
-0.9424301386,
-0.636161387,
-0.1909708232,
-0.1674107462,
-0.0321853608,
0.1448348016,
-0.0985109657,
0.1674813032,
0.4172828496,
-0.6089612246,
-0.3721461594,
-0.5117823482,
-0.2465798557,
0.5433610678,
0.0025355183,
-0.2903937101,
-0.0584349148,
-0.350885272,
-0.3853035271,
-0.4881639183,
-0.0510132462,
0.2586703897,
0.2068141401,
0.0129936859,
0.5687755942,
0.0037255334,
0.7581791282,
0.4135150313,
-0.3279291987,
0.2628504634,
0.0460591987,
-0.2402679473,
-0.1582103819,
0.7274910212,
0.065124236,
0.2834076583,
-0.0796630606,
-0.4329949021,
-0.2414937466,
0.5976991057,
-0.704618156,
0.2175422311,
0.4035609663,
-0.1692475826,
-0.2935152948,
0.2787176967,
-0.8307272792,
-0.4788348675,
-0.3424726427,
0.5501763225,
-0.5995849967,
-0.1501224786,
0.0960401669,
-0.1157890707,
0.1235604361,
0.3348118365,
-0.6072981954,
0.2420532256,
0.7702789903,
0.5242154598,
-0.2501375377,
0.0221196916,
-0.5401778221,
0.2511771619,
-0.3294122815,
0.60959512,
-0.8317762613,
-0.4389924407,
0.155243814,
-0.187326625,
0.0770550966,
-0.5261239409,
0.7163197398,
-0.9978991151,
0.0587235354,
0.038907852,
-0.8998100758,
-0.3300982118,
0.5504094958,
-0.7965117693,
0.9412695765,
0.3716419041,
-0.9113370776,
0.0806776509,
-0.0099541219,
-0.1311810762,
-0.0861185417,
-0.1917410493,
-0.4761233628,
0.0927988961,
-0.2164548188,
0.4917839468,
-0.4561962187,
0.1833217442,
-0.4374340177,
-0.2682929635,
0.3254234493,
-0.2116153538,
0.2625376284,
0.3622044921,
-0.0582509227,
-0.2313563228,
-0.6072767377,
0.2913813889,
-0.3211228848,
-0.3022979796,
-0.4457398355,
-0.2113071233,
-0.0028895822,
0.0354335979,
0.4935821295,
-0.3860086501,
-0.1427350342,
-0.3786228001,
-0.0932989791,
0.5150295496,
0.3312650025,
0.5246742964,
-0.6078704596,
0.6221207976,
0.0999714509,
0.1113014445,
0.1192660555,
-0.4979426861,
-0.3104798496,
0.1788322926,
0.2058725357,
0.3677642941,
-0.5342422724,
0.0681341738,
-0.1633018404,
-0.8432967663,
-0.3911906779,
0.21208556,
0.5804555416,
0.5841389298,
0.3781414628,
0.0236536022,
-0.6307397485,
-0.7185195088,
-0.1864288002,
-0.2554020286,
-0.1427811384,
0.1527422369,
0.4214406312,
-0.3018461168,
0.7442854047,
-0.5288550258,
-0.3735441864,
0.3036717176,
0.2322110236,
0.4197117984,
0.4473720789,
0.2108682692,
-1.330083251,
-0.7097981572,
0.0952603891,
-0.4247613847,
0.1942706257,
0.1000239775,
0.0056917793,
0.3380112946,
0.7005915642,
-0.4680219293,
0.3412349522,
0.7639856935,
0.0198467486,
0.6894916296,
-0.1828685552,
0.181163758,
-1.241032362,
0.3655999005,
-0.0165109299,
-0.2639144361,
-0.3866818547,
0.1860708892,
0.2384124994,
0.2217861563,
-0.2498482019,
0.7421792746,
-0.4686798751,
-0.0045830556,
-0.0527155735,
0.2772310376,
0.1381417513,
0.1559966505,
-0.0546638519,
0.8952758908,
0.2760450244,
-0.7592132688,
0.0234349035,
0.2280474901,
-0.1480314434,
0.7187820077,
-0.5783261061,
0.136875838,
-0.2000201494,
0.1811502278,
-0.9148346186,
-0.4211254418,
-0.0747849196,
-0.6502541304,
0.6536098719,
-0.2085682452,
-0.2865404189,
-0.2478369027,
-0.1927305013,
0.3425622582,
0.372402817,
-0.1204237714,
0.7394748926,
0.6496088505,
0.0157255717,
-0.815153718,
-0.3742253482,
-0.4268334508,
-0.1831554323,
-0.5151361227,
0.3989574909,
-0.3383600712,
-0.3270995915,
-0.1699694544,
-0.4166819155,
-0.1853790879,
-0.0090122027,
0.2708578706,
0.0846579969,
-0.0776913315,
0.1413408071,
-0.0185457859,
0.018237656,
0.0018182881,
-0.2055963874,
0.4455572963,
-0.3025826216,
-0.3804846108,
0.175307557,
0.0630443767,
0.6188762784,
-0.1557696313,
0.5979344845,
0.6916965246,
-0.5101274252,
-0.0916248932,
-0.7935355306,
-0.1206525266,
-0.471519202,
0.1095421314,
-0.5400260091,
-0.83192873,
0.6026183963,
-0.0852649063,
0.0802065134,
0.3172551095,
0.5694903135,
-0.1329101622,
0.6054390073,
0.4774795175,
0.2404381931,
0.2372787148,
-0.1678187847,
-0.1285015196,
-0.9858463407,
-0.3941879869,
-0.687669456,
-0.0810581967,
-0.5504354239,
-0.706202507,
0.6106418967,
0.2641738653,
-0.3578225076,
0.3030415177,
-0.3840590417,
0.2182454169,
0.436527878,
-0.010977257,
0.3608236611,
-0.1178496182,
-0.2312710285,
-0.0162543301,
-0.1888144463,
-0.5088366866,
1.1775979996,
0.2179154158,
1.1292555332,
0.2964810729,
0.7222175598,
0.1150716916,
0.5529893041,
-0.6896662116,
0.2899847329,
-0.1738923192,
-0.794342041,
-0.4389997125,
-0.3303959072,
-0.9526671171,
0.1800115705,
-0.3582794368,
-0.7421905398,
0.1241099685,
0.1071219444,
-0.1959582865,
0.0281470586,
-0.4245676994,
0.3220228255,
0.2578297555,
-0.2384198606,
-0.0308084451,
-0.8110726476,
0.3853828907,
-0.6968922615,
0.328463763,
0.0673858821,
-0.2048453987,
0.4695925415,
-0.0812989399,
0.6713821888,
0.0073941187,
-0.1733338833,
0.2808086276,
0.5971733928,
0.6537854075,
0.1028571427,
-0.7400304079,
-0.0926257595,
0.5834329128,
0.0698846504,
-0.7679830194,
0.6519218087,
-0.6166757941,
-0.6952473521,
-0.3686764538,
-0.7330102921,
-0.5078043938,
0.414665252,
0.2841444612,
0.1227209568,
-0.1428709775,
0.2761347592,
0.7484320402,
0.1136823744,
0.0112597495,
0.6010294557,
-0.3386981785,
-0.3542950153,
0.3883482218,
0.0866384059,
0.3370564282,
0.5648766756,
0.2821077704,
-0.5303792357,
-0.3722438216,
-0.1295810491,
0.3434557617,
-0.6179606318,
-0.6347384453,
-0.3401947021,
-0.2526071668,
-0.6778603196,
-0.0392671116,
-0.2420060486,
-0.3324941397,
-0.2106686682,
0.1151733771,
0.377448976,
0.9156453609,
-0.0335349962,
0.3127307892,
-0.9478331208,
0.1635834575,
-0.0412233807,
0.3933302164,
-0.0784343109,
-0.9125170708,
-0.2711680532,
0.2105292678,
-0.3942507207,
-0.902672112,
0.3672815263,
0.2351972908,
0.6975651979,
0.2570029199,
0.3872999549,
0.7225312591,
-0.4992105961,
0.4613469541,
-0.0910046026,
-0.7947868705,
0.5096211433,
-0.1568787992,
0.0084625082,
0.7064402699,
0.6965985894,
-0.4127961695,
-0.5985518098,
-0.7963428497,
-0.7213113308,
0.3489530683,
0.062252786,
0.0623507574,
0.0483211502,
0.7889012098,
0.0571973808,
0.179964602,
-0.282392323,
-0.0967530459,
0.1606268585,
-0.4040761888,
0.02214255,
-0.2977691293,
-0.1964830756,
0.1334317178,
0.8302266598,
-0.2596996129,
0.0151651017,
0.3462277949,
-0.0316981599,
-0.4572692811,
0.1601740271,
0.5515547395,
0.8415418863,
-0.5096822977,
0.1953362972,
0.2395696491,
-0.7466260791,
0.1159259081,
0.0466342121,
-0.1678889543,
0.0842472091,
0.2140329182,
0.2591615617,
0.2196105123,
-0.5843113661,
0.5248413086,
-0.0648054183,
0.059361577,
-0.9054037929,
0.0099982852,
0.059762504,
0.3275237083,
0.459425956,
0.037261676,
0.234630689,
-0.0927353352,
0.6958161592,
0.4924481213,
-0.4856235981,
-0.0705967769,
0.5504321456,
-0.3434360027,
-0.3421584368,
0.3307635188,
-0.0863949656,
-0.2918926775,
0.4384827912,
0.6607671976,
0.616381228,
-0.4366824329,
0.1296835542,
0.6541418433,
0.1203998178,
-0.2706166208,
0.1383791417,
0.3268725872,
-0.7020187378,
-0.2950410843,
-1.0318466425,
-0.5716212988,
0.131828621,
-1.0270628929,
0.2516210377,
-0.3181925714,
-0.3992832005,
-0.2168915421,
0.1591246575,
-0.6325501204,
0.290867269,
0.120934993,
1.2546619177,
-0.4797975123,
0.7678486109,
0.7821383476,
-0.4445600212,
-1.1542541981,
0.2493680716,
0.0686519891,
-0.6894796491,
0.5566730499,
-0.0126878666,
-0.1024086103,
-0.0616023727,
-0.481975168,
-1.2141760588,
1.2907487154,
0.4380156994,
-0.5006650686,
-0.0748315826,
0.0939465836,
0.6334972382,
-0.2962110639,
0.3091124594,
0.444542259,
0.6349192262,
0.6002783179,
-1.0008246899,
0.3147682846,
0.1524517089,
0.1996147633,
0.0512991287,
-0.3538970053,
0.928384006,
-0.2261526287,
-0.1307955682,
0.1453720033,
0.8080414534,
0.5662940741,
0.1352480054,
0.4600215256,
0.4880900383,
0.9907196164,
0.1974848211,
1.0945495367,
-0.4625731409,
0.4971899688,
1.2935919762,
-0.1532864273,
1.3124473095,
0.7927024364,
-0.0488762595,
0.515250802,
0.4650629163,
0.2176184356,
0.3154810071,
0.2145883441,
-0.2421857417,
-0.1916504502,
0.0484053604,
-0.2833833098,
0.2315409333,
0.6555300355,
-0.1883137971,
-0.2781875134,
-0.2418415844,
0.1251902878,
0.2707307637,
-0.0858907178,
0.7049112916,
0.3789033294,
-0.9385822415,
0.6678606868,
-0.105993107,
0.4795610607,
-0.7487962842,
-0.2081433088,
-0.3064678311,
0.3572630584,
-0.205155775,
-1.1145131588,
0.5532490015,
-0.3819824159,
-0.3875588477,
0.1539013833,
0.6404098272,
-0.5964773297,
-0.5091431737,
0.2807862759,
0.3517531157,
0.1858881265,
-0.074310109,
-0.7371211648,
0.1394747198,
-0.0896146968,
-0.4132846594,
0.3490157127,
0.7263332009,
-0.1220267117,
0.871411562,
0.5380205512,
0.0882945731,
0.0157747045,
-0.1289838552,
0.8224202991,
-0.1157791987,
-0.094105877,
-0.4793284535,
0.470354706,
0.0637742952,
-0.0884958133,
0.5035374165,
0.4705279171,
0.8107451797,
-0.119635053,
0.5414329171,
-0.1639847159,
0.6612257957,
-0.4604453743,
0.7129728198,
-0.6335816383,
0.3149359822,
-0.2762267292,
-0.9192411304,
-0.3641234934,
0.6405386329,
-0.1570853591,
-0.0156738926,
0.6334354281,
1.2391060591,
-0.1187928319,
-0.216914326,
0.4895560741,
0.312309891,
0.2952353358,
0.2796334624,
0.3227192461,
-0.6828908324,
0.7378132939,
-0.0976149067,
-0.1398141384,
-0.130372867,
-0.8847814202,
-0.4918947816,
-1.0530275106,
0.0481053554,
-0.8069724441,
-0.074338235,
0.7111185193,
0.6987401247,
-0.9701731801,
-0.2315358073,
0.1571431905,
0.1913927495,
-0.0031787446,
-0.2382007539,
0.2770655453,
-0.6487225294,
-0.7861453295,
0.0893289894,
-0.1758449823,
0.1592917591,
-0.3952419162,
-0.2198468596,
-0.348107487,
0.118090339,
0.2136430889,
0.1727444828,
-0.6896799207,
-0.5170285106,
0.084459722,
-0.4464263916,
-0.2174874395,
0.5138337612,
-0.6319201589,
0.431094557,
0.5556361675,
0.6560539603,
0.783690691,
0.0831285119,
0.795488894,
-0.889092803,
-0.0325395912,
0.3361346424,
0.2941082716,
0.2430731803,
-0.5975757241,
0.6786568761,
-0.1385142952,
-0.7102198005,
-0.5995469093,
0.2927975059,
-1.1089493036,
-0.0919456854,
1.3081967831,
-0.3900923133,
-0.4015784264,
-0.1902626604,
-0.0768793449,
0.1010711417,
-0.2968142033,
0.7165060043,
0.5884991288,
0.1817685515,
0.0361083485,
-0.4858682454,
0.7312012911,
0.078865774,
-0.4433057606,
0.0038678087,
0.4275582731,
0.516684413,
0.6092817783,
0.4585510194,
-0.2833861709,
0.0873273239,
-0.0843996778,
0.0076237759,
0.082030192,
-0.1072335616,
-0.0436756015,
0.2768261731,
0.1958585232,
0.2306850106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03163v1
|
Uncertainty in Language Models: Assessment through Rank-Calibration
| 2024-04-04T02:31:05 | 2024-04-04T02:31:05 |
Xinmeng Huang, Shuo Li, Mengxin Yu, Matteo Sesia, Hamed Hassani, Insup Lee, Osbert Bastani, Edgar Dobriban
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Language Models (LMs) have shown promising performance in natural language
generation. However, as LMs often generate incorrect or hallucinated responses,
it is crucial to correctly quantify their uncertainty in responding to given
inputs. In addition to verbalized confidence elicited via prompting, many
uncertainty measures ($e.g.$, semantic entropy and affinity-graph-based
measures) have been proposed. However, these measures can differ greatly, and
it is unclear how to compare them, partly because they take values over
different ranges ($e.g.$, $[0,\infty)$ or $[0,1]$). In this work, we address
this issue by developing a novel and practical framework, termed
$Rank$-$Calibration$, to assess uncertainty and confidence measures for LMs.
Our key tenet is that higher uncertainty (or lower confidence) should imply
lower generation quality, on average. Rank-calibration quantifies deviations
from this ideal relationship in a principled manner, without requiring ad hoc
binary thresholding of the correctness score ($e.g.$, ROUGE or METEOR). The
broad applicability and the granular interpretability of our methods are
demonstrated empirically.
|
[
-0.2865187824,
-0.8287475705,
0.6397434473,
-0.0462934487,
-0.011589394,
0.2145961523,
-0.2836281359,
-0.1263043582,
0.0026653607,
0.1851589829,
-0.2592964172,
-0.4925588667,
-0.7627592683,
-0.0979792252,
-0.1914287806,
0.7342336774,
-0.0259286389,
0.0390324034,
-0.2715691924,
-0.0070229848,
-0.4211394191,
-0.385545969,
-0.6180900931,
-0.2477846742,
0.7287752628,
0.2727806568,
1.1071072817,
0.4004036486,
0.5126113892,
0.2059494406,
0.0087890411,
0.1123386398,
-0.6273983121,
0.3647471964,
0.1288093626,
-0.4630950391,
-0.5569778681,
0.0770891011,
0.8653467894,
1.0089826584,
-0.0034658085,
0.2311746329,
-0.0296800975,
0.6041033268,
-0.9236431122,
0.0339717902,
-0.8216312528,
-0.2059048265,
-0.0403120294,
-0.2565052509,
-0.5581048131,
-0.6575366855,
-0.1778216362,
-0.3885567188,
-0.0490839966,
0.2121188939,
0.9758534431,
0.4669524133,
-0.2820485532,
-0.1758276969,
-0.8491445184,
0.8138231635,
-1.0425417423,
0.351680994,
0.702619493,
0.5205168128,
-0.1074212566,
-0.4624421,
-0.3054813147,
-0.2057942897,
0.3025106192,
-0.011503092,
0.1823539734,
0.0647225678,
0.0133761046,
0.5871917605,
-0.4416257441,
0.2221439034,
-0.138577491,
-0.331102699,
0.6158745885,
-0.0301898085,
0.1014649868,
-0.1969804764,
-0.0230093729,
-0.4105069637,
-0.8266649842,
0.1283609718,
0.906891048,
0.7091621161,
0.1296519637,
0.5115929246,
-0.1604302078,
0.6906384826,
-0.0084295748,
-0.0566080511,
0.082224384,
-0.1620753556,
-0.2191176414,
0.0599180125,
0.7346730828,
0.402246356,
0.3251699507,
-0.1475763023,
-0.1977169961,
-0.0071741804,
0.3233509362,
-0.8228915334,
-0.1600701511,
0.5170041919,
-0.099041909,
-0.752818644,
0.1400926858,
-0.6333774924,
-0.4093024731,
-0.0471209846,
0.8361096382,
-0.3654993176,
-0.2997938693,
-0.0398131758,
0.1561226249,
0.1429799497,
0.2489522994,
-0.9548226595,
0.3627611101,
0.6661091447,
0.5035216212,
-0.1972564757,
-0.2178312987,
-0.6464483142,
-0.2092417479,
-0.7332108617,
0.5421120524,
-0.429163754,
-0.3487772644,
-0.0946068466,
-0.4888590574,
-0.2264602184,
-0.2707269192,
0.4747610688,
-0.4398683012,
0.3019616604,
-0.1530936807,
-0.7214322686,
-0.0947364047,
0.2582940459,
-0.5267004371,
1.4228802919,
0.3940632939,
-0.6476840377,
0.4884111881,
-0.0333783552,
-0.0561744459,
0.2220780402,
-0.1568127871,
-0.3828634918,
0.2070693672,
-0.0188392848,
0.3645738065,
-0.3122837842,
0.3947585523,
-0.4541945755,
-0.3715057969,
0.4907086194,
-0.7069717646,
0.4331997633,
0.2521204054,
-0.1448935121,
0.0281915292,
-0.8555189967,
0.7086071968,
-0.2683337331,
-0.1292473227,
-0.3736869693,
0.2419423461,
-0.2049448043,
0.0624697208,
0.1942640692,
-0.2392913103,
-0.1987375915,
-0.5925631523,
0.2564465106,
0.6165956855,
0.1544750184,
0.4794284105,
-0.4865280688,
0.4472081661,
-0.286991477,
0.0161788613,
0.0614248291,
-0.5470880866,
-0.7395726442,
-0.0491264798,
0.7204198837,
0.5347281694,
-0.3766793907,
0.7711941004,
-0.4564596117,
-0.6611967087,
-0.6389551759,
0.0151727619,
0.2015081942,
0.3347810805,
0.2843509316,
-0.3910602629,
-0.0561947897,
-0.483854413,
-0.3919279873,
-0.6183823347,
-0.0636607632,
0.1578470618,
0.2846544087,
0.0426473916,
1.0531318188,
-0.351296097,
0.2355622053,
-0.0427633822,
0.4650073051,
-0.1060438156,
0.4464929104,
0.2364788949,
-0.6877661347,
-0.4243054688,
-0.2113772631,
-0.47519207,
-0.1819868088,
-0.0385865197,
-0.1281279624,
0.0193363782,
0.3743797243,
-0.3949308991,
0.4540556669,
0.7020246387,
0.0388242602,
0.5155136585,
-0.2450067848,
0.3275310397,
-1.3395419121,
0.0014305991,
-0.1055055335,
-0.3712658584,
-0.8230767846,
0.2497926056,
0.0335598178,
0.1717040837,
-0.2860212922,
0.4798457325,
-0.1131113768,
-0.1621428728,
-0.1266794801,
0.2921671867,
0.0445520766,
0.1381633729,
-0.1702860892,
0.5952239037,
0.5421822071,
-0.5663880706,
0.1064485386,
-0.2991737425,
-0.2942766249,
0.7323724031,
-0.5203837752,
-0.0139959278,
-0.0312186629,
-0.057934925,
-1.1589477062,
-0.3498980999,
0.0906232148,
-0.7091864347,
0.4352141023,
-0.0111840004,
-0.5275816917,
-0.0777669176,
-0.3116128445,
0.52527982,
0.5530918241,
-0.0003076511,
0.2107852995,
0.3384661376,
-0.4151497781,
-0.528216064,
-0.3431231081,
0.0860883892,
-0.3028981984,
-0.4623410106,
0.2525074482,
-0.3973464072,
-0.5846726298,
-0.3408321738,
-0.2185503691,
-0.1287243217,
0.4392340183,
0.3947389722,
0.0781116262,
-0.1811224967,
0.1830827445,
0.2195916474,
-0.1566367447,
-0.0461096764,
-0.0076649538,
0.4986194074,
-0.2109522671,
-0.6728585362,
-0.1226808205,
0.0085634133,
0.6264264584,
-0.0349886753,
0.5625019073,
0.4193725586,
-0.6473082304,
-0.2121419311,
-0.4873319566,
-0.2983457744,
-0.4578662217,
0.1591698378,
-0.3430562615,
-0.6567084193,
0.5246459246,
-0.0350511707,
-0.0250626374,
0.5238895416,
0.631365478,
0.050275486,
1.216812253,
0.4760130048,
0.1450890601,
0.0629141703,
0.1151650771,
0.5452889204,
-0.6382245421,
0.0288069081,
-0.6839250922,
-0.1408797204,
-0.7188379765,
-0.5906766057,
0.2146069407,
0.2403123826,
-0.2587342858,
0.2484779954,
-0.390093714,
0.2981452346,
0.396165669,
-0.2441992462,
0.2268867195,
-0.1038129926,
-0.2367091477,
-0.2242067605,
-0.5132505894,
-0.8867633939,
0.934466064,
0.5237846375,
0.8619610071,
0.0881556645,
0.8373033404,
0.2443144172,
0.3020978272,
-0.8907111883,
0.2907188535,
0.0798110589,
-0.5189708471,
-0.7628602386,
-0.6568370461,
-0.700193882,
0.2857603729,
-0.120125562,
-0.9961667061,
0.219944939,
0.0672276989,
-0.6329918504,
0.1604093909,
-0.5799688697,
0.8157602549,
-0.1405938864,
-0.0836574063,
0.2493596077,
-0.7076640725,
0.1042731106,
-0.2915177643,
0.4534630179,
-0.5455915928,
0.1820918024,
0.3906547427,
-0.3861675262,
0.5986613035,
0.0620152541,
-0.2498232275,
0.1720786542,
0.4612219036,
0.3253113925,
0.2077698112,
-0.5268695951,
-0.1006694585,
0.3581164181,
-0.1804405898,
-0.533121407,
0.7096011043,
-0.6891520023,
-0.2298635244,
-0.4032241106,
-0.8972677588,
-0.5444089174,
0.2050455362,
0.600540638,
0.3500602245,
-0.285789758,
0.2475494444,
0.5899734497,
-0.1645704955,
0.1967113167,
0.1686974466,
-0.2698155642,
-0.2995074689,
1.0524293184,
0.2619307935,
0.7535166144,
0.5732770562,
0.2920069695,
-0.3009907007,
-0.4315431118,
-0.4019449353,
-0.1135365367,
-0.6749731898,
-0.209763214,
-0.2360410094,
-0.4356019497,
-0.5747289062,
-0.1416985542,
-0.4064579606,
-0.6695794463,
-0.2656491101,
-0.1902538985,
0.1811508536,
0.5401517153,
0.1024212092,
0.2934356034,
-0.3946907222,
0.090423122,
0.2835758328,
0.2877887785,
-0.3459044695,
-0.7062939405,
-0.0362537503,
0.4405955672,
-0.092487894,
-0.9856314063,
0.4912619889,
0.4177450836,
0.7034954429,
0.2095242739,
0.2899318933,
0.5158027411,
-0.3378349245,
0.9817596674,
-0.1938289255,
-1.0577629805,
0.4550147951,
-0.2211038321,
0.1868857741,
0.9670089483,
0.1969080567,
-0.5026332736,
-0.9872894287,
-0.7509404421,
-0.9108052254,
0.3405382037,
0.502394557,
0.2774974108,
0.1065910906,
0.3843897283,
0.0380676426,
0.4540004432,
-0.6960461736,
-0.3484128416,
-0.1750513464,
-0.4417649508,
-0.4032621384,
-0.2517351508,
-0.0754432678,
-0.0121809216,
0.7474008203,
-0.2289478779,
0.1238005012,
-0.2249898314,
-0.3200520575,
-0.4507170916,
0.4070422351,
0.7079983354,
0.7102116346,
-0.6702944636,
0.4643909633,
0.1598186791,
-0.4176143706,
0.1362147927,
0.0230211578,
-0.1960400343,
0.0689870492,
0.1506192237,
0.757252872,
0.4075623453,
-0.3706057072,
0.5241875648,
-0.044009313,
-0.0496099181,
-0.0653323531,
0.0797335505,
-0.0373126492,
-0.3280824423,
0.4523170888,
0.0141434614,
-0.0012861582,
-0.2832551003,
0.2509744763,
0.311086148,
-0.6754675508,
-0.1380863339,
0.6034370661,
-0.0793711171,
-0.3439585268,
0.2991265059,
-0.4778420925,
-0.2423357069,
0.6964036822,
0.3483057618,
0.867287159,
-0.3868720233,
0.4382556677,
0.3989001811,
0.5327064991,
-0.2561579049,
0.1844998002,
0.2325009108,
-0.8984503746,
-0.2424769402,
-0.8372735381,
-0.728595376,
0.040428225,
-0.9496542811,
0.0196413007,
-0.2400701493,
-0.4562200308,
-0.0674951226,
-0.0118495561,
-0.2806133926,
0.3225842118,
0.1404655427,
0.689416647,
-0.9230706692,
0.6656793952,
0.4591377974,
-0.3004796207,
-1.0100662708,
0.1469445527,
0.0335820392,
-0.6876664162,
0.4057020843,
0.2215619087,
-0.2392517477,
0.2823978662,
-0.3324954808,
-1.0184415579,
1.0772023201,
0.3970935345,
-0.0701529458,
-0.0465965532,
0.3048627079,
0.644752562,
-0.4047778547,
0.3464987278,
0.503890872,
0.4984844327,
0.1544960588,
-0.8902412653,
-0.0375931188,
0.0175463725,
0.261398375,
0.2013377249,
-0.1818224639,
1.0405949354,
-0.0972523689,
-0.2406478226,
0.3372785449,
0.4469249249,
0.3276423216,
0.1095562428,
0.3942465186,
0.4734600186,
0.9259035587,
-0.3585447371,
0.9041196108,
-0.6738577485,
0.5937030911,
1.1338847876,
-0.4156120121,
1.1593416929,
0.5104932189,
-0.190142259,
0.4791247547,
0.9138541222,
0.2522471845,
0.3354187608,
0.4091563523,
-0.2320498377,
-0.4792309999,
0.1074010804,
-0.3129309416,
0.2059787512,
0.6184436083,
-0.2514620423,
-0.2920857668,
-0.2390794158,
0.0285717417,
0.1127294898,
-0.1538780928,
0.5844784379,
0.1884205639,
-0.8139610887,
0.6790035963,
0.2018152922,
0.2762657702,
-0.569381237,
0.1433152854,
-0.0429470688,
-0.1181122586,
-0.1182072312,
-0.6660404801,
-0.0052580764,
-0.0900275111,
0.067357026,
-0.2158067971,
0.5927392244,
-0.5349138975,
-0.6934781671,
-0.0798140839,
0.6541160345,
0.2992634177,
-0.0882777274,
-0.55102247,
0.1416758597,
-0.3539202809,
-0.2252289951,
0.3960857093,
0.1303189397,
-0.0013636552,
0.5736500025,
0.333430171,
0.3296371102,
0.2050926387,
0.2507479787,
0.2329390645,
-0.0530225374,
-0.3202549815,
-0.6562163234,
0.4496462941,
0.0173844434,
-0.3927646577,
0.7786320448,
0.4295793772,
0.6144524813,
0.2926031053,
0.6475534439,
-0.0814614892,
0.3608603179,
-0.4526605308,
0.8435002565,
-0.429656446,
0.2962299287,
-0.4256204069,
-1.0553963184,
-0.5449553132,
0.9331679344,
-0.4377804995,
0.2657772005,
0.7614164948,
1.096116066,
0.2527483106,
-0.3172955215,
0.6037663817,
-0.0426623151,
0.1729669571,
0.3573792577,
0.6501948237,
-0.7610887885,
0.3464640677,
-0.2479655594,
-0.1396733969,
-0.2475721687,
-1.1133008003,
-0.4403125644,
-0.7138967514,
-0.3758724928,
-0.4714671969,
-0.0011379609,
0.8482463956,
0.8482584953,
-0.8949748874,
-0.3950164318,
-0.1208658665,
0.3446642756,
-0.3758327067,
-0.2180344015,
0.2335535735,
-0.563300848,
-0.8174254298,
0.3016506433,
0.2151643187,
0.1410818249,
-0.5096514821,
-0.2902616858,
0.0737823322,
0.5204468966,
0.3304917812,
0.2263128906,
-0.7811769843,
-0.6667919159,
-0.1408964545,
-0.5333180428,
0.0340628922,
0.3291671276,
-0.5439583659,
0.6724018455,
0.5931710601,
0.4153998792,
0.0434752554,
0.1818932295,
0.7624820471,
-1.0775319338,
-0.1700976342,
0.2825419903,
0.1236199066,
0.5762088895,
-0.2782813013,
0.2671120465,
0.0087264618,
-0.6861585975,
-1.3085976839,
0.447119832,
-0.8641057014,
-0.0953300595,
1.2832006216,
0.0779620782,
0.1156134829,
0.0819049478,
0.0290555507,
0.1729621589,
-0.1979745477,
0.7886316776,
0.9021778107,
0.1934508979,
-0.0505048186,
-0.6957058907,
0.6806057692,
0.3085300922,
-0.9337524176,
0.0406607874,
0.3860623837,
0.2221636474,
0.3326565623,
0.3964926004,
-0.136602819,
0.2345287949,
0.0784013122,
0.0214385465,
0.2708527744,
-0.3054602146,
-0.3460699916,
0.2630054951,
0.6661264896,
0.1773127615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03161v1
|
BioVL-QR: Egocentric Biochemical Video-and-Language Dataset Using Micro QR Codes
| 2024-04-04T02:22:37 | 2024-04-04T02:22:37 |
Taichi Nishimura, Koki Yamamoto, Yuto Haneji, Keiya Kajimura, Chihiro Nishiwaki, Eriko Daikoku, Natsuko Okuda, Fumihito Ono, Hirotaka Kameko, Shinsuke Mori
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
This paper introduces a biochemical vision-and-language dataset, which
consists of 24 egocentric experiment videos, corresponding protocols, and
video-and-language alignments. The key challenge in the wet-lab domain is
detecting equipment, reagents, and containers is difficult because the lab
environment is scattered by filling objects on the table and some objects are
indistinguishable. Therefore, previous studies assume that objects are manually
annotated and given for downstream tasks, but this is costly and
time-consuming. To address this issue, this study focuses on Micro QR Codes to
detect objects automatically. From our preliminary study, we found that
detecting objects only using Micro QR Codes is still difficult because the
researchers manipulate objects, causing blur and occlusion frequently. To
address this, we also propose a novel object labeling method by combining a
Micro QR Code detector and an off-the-shelf hand object detector. As one of the
applications of our dataset, we conduct the task of generating protocols from
experiment videos and find that our approach can generate accurate protocols.
|
[
-0.2805630565,
-0.5089286566,
0.727204442,
-0.440146327,
-0.3250386715,
0.1759420186,
0.2044522017,
-0.3564103544,
0.3324480355,
0.2297598273,
-0.2393794209,
-0.4127071798,
-0.2047015429,
0.4036880732,
-0.3795404136,
0.6592395902,
0.0639605522,
-0.000942623,
-0.1380046308,
-0.4823506773,
0.037423458,
-0.3490673006,
-0.3620804548,
-0.2993205786,
0.6122501493,
0.5433125496,
0.7234739661,
0.8424280286,
0.6257349253,
0.3752701581,
0.3655151725,
0.0805766135,
0.2550289631,
-0.1616470814,
-0.0615517981,
-0.1920172572,
-0.5873743296,
-0.4595761001,
0.4047069252,
0.1603899151,
0.001855687,
0.6441159844,
-0.1292929053,
0.8196108341,
-0.8474295735,
0.3392190039,
-0.2401213497,
0.4438478649,
-0.3833870888,
-0.2361189276,
0.0381276421,
-0.0796501935,
0.0875645131,
-0.494020611,
0.328502208,
0.0644882843,
0.578071475,
0.3166991174,
-0.1411995143,
-0.0249334406,
-0.866602242,
0.3687304556,
-0.3313322961,
0.6926447153,
0.3854828775,
0.640147686,
0.2199967802,
-0.8287369013,
-0.7544974685,
0.1948458999,
0.2436596602,
-0.0172785148,
0.1753962487,
-0.0650130287,
-0.026494531,
0.2441034913,
-0.5134157538,
-0.4383046031,
-0.5392717719,
-0.1979941279,
0.6562338471,
0.378334403,
0.4509226084,
0.0827778801,
-0.1180390194,
-0.2493780106,
-0.3246186376,
0.2479262501,
-0.0651111826,
0.0567215085,
0.0331554897,
0.76606673,
-0.4268841743,
0.7534965277,
0.0497576036,
-0.1246574596,
0.6006199718,
-0.7560467124,
-0.5449602604,
0.287869364,
1.0584204197,
0.3530781865,
0.25720191,
0.0311269742,
-0.1244085059,
-0.2143565714,
0.341732651,
-1.0483901501,
-0.6780693531,
0.576908946,
-0.403137207,
-0.413698405,
-0.0765229836,
-0.7153732777,
-0.2742955685,
-0.1434051841,
0.7607140541,
-0.3699293733,
-0.0271496475,
0.288413763,
-0.1487207562,
0.4109486341,
0.215813905,
-0.9235076904,
0.2668765783,
0.1085825041,
0.8847587705,
0.3726435304,
0.0255764443,
-0.6324076653,
0.5107542276,
-0.0654254258,
0.880402565,
-0.3951018453,
-0.3409455121,
-0.1028059199,
0.2925513089,
0.5132519603,
-0.6922106147,
0.2076172084,
-0.3127422035,
-0.4281788766,
-0.3773986101,
-0.154971227,
0.0726049542,
-0.082445927,
-0.5765648484,
0.8576430082,
-0.0729212463,
-0.5515480042,
0.3405309021,
-0.1872561425,
-0.2030897886,
0.574894309,
-0.93718642,
-0.5985810161,
-0.3956119418,
0.1207621843,
0.4946275949,
-0.0785700008,
0.1249375269,
-0.3281398118,
-0.0857524127,
0.460755527,
0.1794030815,
0.4151982367,
0.0245073941,
-0.3375465572,
0.2007067949,
-0.9271718264,
0.1893033534,
-0.0118351746,
-0.2614439428,
-0.2699621022,
0.3154120743,
0.177684471,
0.0851528347,
0.0594778433,
-0.9659611583,
0.1110429317,
-0.1362859011,
0.6031172872,
0.5001770854,
-0.1847637594,
0.3822845817,
0.0200658999,
0.2334723771,
-0.090058133,
0.608895421,
0.1391357332,
-0.5512353778,
-0.4911068678,
-0.3857112825,
-0.0419039913,
0.6390359402,
-1.0170046091,
0.6429527402,
-0.1073570698,
-0.4313632846,
-0.5927474499,
0.3095313013,
0.444909662,
0.666803062,
0.6725828648,
-0.4084679484,
-0.3530731797,
-1.2549545765,
-0.0591045693,
-0.0176114887,
-0.2627951801,
0.3646716774,
0.6116870642,
-0.4025712609,
0.9899474382,
-0.6622033119,
-0.6879109144,
0.300188154,
-0.2470833957,
-0.1044784114,
0.4903878272,
0.5772362351,
-0.7339359522,
-0.4658813775,
0.3320524395,
-0.8095777035,
0.0487903915,
0.5487877131,
-0.0705451369,
-0.1960647404,
0.6481397748,
-0.2001314759,
0.7529438138,
0.0142184673,
-0.0763406903,
0.5833384991,
-0.3021947443,
0.3332735002,
-0.4241513014,
0.0324880295,
0.0462603644,
-0.5246825218,
-0.6091471314,
-0.1144670546,
0.4485760629,
-0.1208946481,
-0.7341306806,
0.6172236204,
-0.4135707021,
0.0971635059,
-0.366884619,
-0.2211021632,
0.1068466753,
0.4267789125,
0.3451836407,
0.6779279709,
0.6049922109,
-0.7360928655,
0.6346253157,
0.4145274758,
-0.2299150527,
0.2386670709,
-0.875125885,
0.0647180974,
-0.0225721188,
0.1573920846,
-1.0213894844,
-0.347043246,
0.8498439193,
-0.5100756288,
-0.02397497,
0.0175602883,
-0.6601989865,
-0.2922370136,
-0.5966644287,
0.9706234932,
0.5562752485,
-0.3385606408,
0.7164909244,
0.4407040477,
0.1472831666,
-0.3510765433,
-0.9270193577,
-0.3500787616,
0.0883371681,
-0.298623383,
0.2107436806,
0.0033394694,
-0.0842306837,
-0.0710920766,
-0.3420268297,
-0.2565777302,
-0.4709079862,
0.3531760573,
-0.0213722046,
0.0322847329,
0.0536813512,
-0.0539683737,
-0.0107696075,
0.1973312497,
-0.2294555753,
0.0962196365,
-0.3904227614,
-0.3219272792,
-0.6176583171,
0.0793322176,
0.50505054,
-0.2724413574,
0.5712720156,
0.6346418858,
-0.577190578,
0.1986993104,
-0.3511572778,
-0.1862080544,
-0.6766401529,
0.1556717008,
-0.3433521688,
-0.3746960759,
0.670676589,
0.3459196687,
-0.2651520669,
-0.0344644897,
0.7048999071,
-0.2169698477,
0.9979151487,
0.4668704271,
0.0688365772,
0.3280504644,
-0.1110960096,
0.3266920447,
-0.9897307754,
-0.5495251417,
-0.4811997414,
-0.1240467802,
0.0048221787,
-0.7456938028,
0.7288720608,
-0.1745917052,
-0.4320326746,
0.2075805068,
-0.9714691043,
0.5763847232,
0.325011462,
0.7055939436,
0.3426174223,
0.0890272185,
-0.2957662344,
0.1049077734,
-0.571221292,
-0.5946258903,
1.1241905689,
0.1672926843,
0.6665788293,
0.0834390223,
0.5747635365,
0.375076741,
0.3057818711,
-0.7534983754,
0.5167576075,
0.1090393513,
-0.5553476214,
-0.3149648309,
0.1788833439,
-0.8426008821,
0.0248606764,
-0.1061198637,
-0.6905924678,
0.6017683744,
0.3467242718,
-0.6870734692,
0.3893393278,
-0.5573714375,
0.9123687744,
-0.4327009916,
-0.7207844257,
0.3703639507,
-0.9682624936,
0.1558146179,
-0.117273055,
0.6085133553,
0.0426081829,
-0.178478539,
0.6618548632,
-0.9207949042,
0.6781064868,
-0.002056936,
-0.1792291105,
0.5656615496,
0.1531772465,
0.1463758498,
0.219733268,
0.5322045684,
0.0239397325,
0.2531280518,
-0.5134157538,
-0.360078603,
0.110474959,
-0.4352645278,
-0.2260589004,
-0.4481493235,
-0.2057733685,
0.0626146346,
0.3907975852,
0.2705665231,
0.5646246076,
0.0195362568,
0.1107903793,
0.936822772,
-0.5366393924,
0.1878972948,
0.6772421002,
-0.5611326694,
-0.4419400096,
1.1408807039,
-0.0753076449,
0.1706041694,
0.4100022912,
0.1507157683,
-0.0723742917,
-0.2572503388,
-0.7203784585,
-0.0303738397,
-0.5004326701,
-0.4795554876,
-0.7562110424,
0.0340494253,
-0.4156003892,
-0.1521228999,
-0.5656606555,
0.1351488829,
-0.2522968948,
0.0256083142,
0.7367603779,
0.2220617384,
-0.0518487468,
-0.0990680158,
-1.2764457464,
0.7260465026,
0.512720108,
0.3321318328,
0.0007289423,
-0.0653047413,
-0.5055962205,
0.131012097,
-0.1181526929,
-1.0886417627,
0.3693980277,
0.3074140847,
0.2097257674,
0.388227284,
-0.2305747271,
0.4295817018,
-0.9759071469,
0.4982199073,
-0.0066204062,
-0.8775459528,
0.7883922458,
-0.4879976213,
0.091531463,
0.5884229541,
0.3529338241,
-0.3647654057,
-0.4394013882,
-0.5229972005,
-1.0666966438,
0.2984646559,
0.2576019466,
-0.3886523843,
0.013085939,
0.4793203771,
0.0809349865,
0.2254742384,
-0.5497590303,
-0.4683275819,
-0.3169248104,
-0.4291538298,
0.0899966732,
0.2777041197,
-0.1858330071,
-0.7006400824,
0.3488435149,
-0.2067292035,
0.4660752118,
0.8067958355,
-0.1832901388,
-0.1763868332,
0.0335431769,
0.2757661045,
0.2675403953,
-0.6612372994,
0.1077834591,
-0.1738025844,
-0.8946537971,
0.5142928958,
-0.0114820451,
-0.0529698767,
-0.1762242913,
-0.0086952336,
0.0281063989,
-0.1240826994,
-1.2285754681,
0.4232901633,
-0.0259819776,
-0.3802335262,
-0.5778747201,
0.164558813,
0.140289247,
0.7068571448,
0.5356543064,
0.0531105064,
0.7275310755,
-0.5279511213,
0.2889855206,
0.3644430935,
-0.3659863174,
-0.4368900955,
1.0864319801,
0.2889195979,
-0.4162353277,
0.3585101366,
-0.4454935491,
-0.348868072,
0.8924657106,
-0.1755043119,
0.9335919023,
-0.2504926026,
0.1745820343,
0.3489950001,
0.3121965528,
-0.0000921556,
0.5284153223,
-0.3553482294,
-1.0231151581,
0.1269726157,
-0.6226701736,
-0.4329831004,
0.1007486284,
-0.7960042357,
0.2670842707,
-0.800663054,
-0.0230016746,
0.4867439568,
-0.4490084648,
-0.7062628865,
0.2279788405,
0.2463115603,
0.5244121552,
-1.0561573505,
1.0028386116,
0.9209792614,
-0.5188226104,
-0.5355913043,
-0.5540753007,
0.1489202976,
-0.5466716886,
0.8791913986,
-0.0185307208,
-0.3949075043,
-0.0952029228,
-0.7081183791,
-0.6810052395,
1.1164469719,
-0.3242385089,
-0.6420091987,
0.4098105133,
0.179052636,
0.7857035398,
-0.1601293385,
0.0405324735,
0.7032345533,
0.3541156352,
-0.3916466534,
-0.8771549463,
0.2143963426,
-0.5610619187,
-0.2421690524,
0.2558318675,
-0.8690245748,
0.6187690496,
-0.1481100619,
-0.0795195848,
-0.0659586117,
0.5979238749,
0.3866980672,
0.5552334785,
0.0926628485,
0.3217797279,
0.2374388129,
0.1977748871,
0.7424958944,
0.0353920981,
0.3343431056,
0.8769680262,
-0.6271696687,
0.5628195405,
0.3524693251,
-0.4703595638,
0.2459777445,
0.574531734,
-0.3856030405,
0.5623908639,
0.2892875373,
-0.4363097548,
0.0277219713,
0.0746304765,
-0.4946360886,
0.0427635945,
0.5778987408,
-0.267942816,
0.1197385415,
0.3337278664,
-0.5537612438,
-0.31505391,
-0.3113166988,
0.4457600117,
-0.1367769241,
0.1170919687,
0.3093849421,
-0.1132652014,
0.6699760556,
-0.169048816,
-0.1289245933,
0.1179998294,
0.2483304441,
-0.4038474262,
-0.795149982,
0.2420307398,
-0.1661972553,
0.0793437958,
0.059231963,
1.0396813154,
-0.5240035057,
-0.3327075243,
0.0788195431,
0.5972864628,
0.37123546,
-0.0428737029,
-0.6468262076,
-0.1788999885,
-0.0664820224,
-0.1270221323,
0.3122429252,
0.580740273,
0.1419065148,
0.8042321205,
0.176272884,
-0.2296253741,
0.131334573,
-0.1430216581,
0.6385156512,
-0.903962791,
0.0080247736,
-0.5938922763,
0.4610744417,
0.3513790369,
0.0533217527,
0.480292201,
0.848608613,
0.9972079992,
-0.6294519305,
0.7211862206,
-0.1757908911,
0.2533904314,
-0.3918538988,
0.6080929041,
-0.8028426766,
-0.0263372734,
-0.2993195355,
-0.6381152868,
-0.1279729009,
0.7665635943,
0.2808794677,
0.0191850811,
0.7756665945,
0.6826191545,
-0.2036479861,
-0.1883269399,
0.0002640535,
-0.0044083567,
0.3566689193,
0.4537948966,
0.4062809646,
-0.8814154267,
0.478191793,
-0.6082238555,
-0.1569366455,
-0.40690732,
-0.6772483587,
-0.7576347589,
-0.6516723633,
-0.8100915551,
-0.4675704837,
-0.057023488,
0.6003572941,
0.544747591,
-0.606646657,
-0.2417811453,
-0.1637461334,
-0.207190901,
-0.1361197531,
-0.2502240539,
0.3714642227,
0.0867181346,
-0.6713923216,
0.0412395038,
0.7066586018,
0.3505250812,
-0.1931604147,
0.2035481483,
-0.4027949572,
-0.1417740732,
0.5331717134,
1.0095219612,
-0.4571886957,
-0.4043614268,
0.0271136202,
-0.1890664995,
0.2408152372,
0.7996635437,
-0.9151553512,
0.64101547,
0.7227461934,
0.4849362075,
0.4661515653,
-0.0634583682,
0.3960087597,
-0.9143623114,
0.1940183192,
0.2508639991,
0.1178324148,
0.2058838755,
-0.461402446,
0.5911710262,
0.3066777587,
-0.8266943097,
-0.6666799784,
0.0393979996,
-1.2366802692,
-0.2943183482,
0.920350492,
0.2667613924,
-0.7167463303,
-0.4516422451,
-0.0357956327,
0.3800447285,
-0.2168559879,
0.6745500565,
0.5629995465,
-0.5522674918,
-0.0486500636,
-0.8011417985,
0.8215454221,
0.240862295,
-0.792726934,
-0.0938059241,
0.516903758,
0.562838316,
0.361795187,
0.8852375746,
-0.2142179608,
0.377141118,
-0.0801739842,
0.6611921191,
-0.0328643993,
-0.3352616429,
-0.1804257929,
-0.3351028562,
-0.2218719423,
-0.5975363255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04286v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04286v1
|
Language Model Evolution: An Iterated Learning Perspective
| 2024-04-04T02:01:25 | 2024-04-04T02:01:25 |
Yi Ren, Shangmin Guo, Linlu Qiu, Bailin Wang, Danica J. Sutherland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With the widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs), the prevalence
of iterative interactions among these models is anticipated to increase.
Notably, recent advancements in multi-round self-improving methods allow LLMs
to generate new examples for training subsequent models. At the same time,
multi-agent LLM systems, involving automated interactions among agents, are
also increasing in prominence. Thus, in both short and long terms, LLMs may
actively engage in an evolutionary process. We draw parallels between the
behavior of LLMs and the evolution of human culture, as the latter has been
extensively studied by cognitive scientists for decades. Our approach involves
leveraging Iterated Learning (IL), a Bayesian framework that elucidates how
subtle biases are magnified during human cultural evolution, to explain some
behaviors of LLMs. This paper outlines key characteristics of agents' behavior
in the Bayesian-IL framework, including predictions that are supported by
experimental verification with various LLMs. This theoretical framework could
help to more effectively predict and guide the evolution of LLMs in desired
directions.
|
[
-0.0847975016,
-0.764167428,
0.6958764195,
-0.0414797068,
-0.02984225,
0.3527933061,
-0.4146943688,
-0.3179944158,
-0.0226446148,
0.7284607291,
-0.6610247493,
-0.4195477366,
-0.6033759713,
0.0668912604,
-0.4058345854,
0.8789708018,
0.2479627132,
0.1188319847,
-0.1366837025,
-0.0086185634,
-0.105281122,
-0.3834863603,
-0.8380269408,
-0.7822522521,
0.4546622932,
0.3006629348,
0.745477736,
0.7055617571,
0.2328321636,
0.4042266905,
0.0170189403,
-0.0401553176,
-0.4362409711,
0.3316307664,
-0.2045557946,
-0.3841794133,
-0.1011841595,
-0.0710220709,
0.774623096,
0.9800403714,
-0.3728117049,
-0.0196406879,
0.0570839234,
0.6531328559,
-0.3236596882,
0.3357874453,
-0.705758512,
-0.1225706935,
-0.0421421528,
-0.2648179233,
-0.4647992551,
-0.2997860014,
0.2760756016,
-0.2125089467,
0.0106262472,
-0.0111896433,
0.373604238,
0.0766878948,
-0.482013911,
-0.3645043075,
-0.9247740507,
0.7513645291,
-0.7184562683,
0.2663071752,
0.2639039159,
0.2880903184,
-0.6322749257,
-0.528791666,
-0.5104882121,
-0.5759381056,
0.2560244799,
-0.0047284747,
-0.0864096284,
-0.0448350832,
-0.0235379376,
0.0811887905,
-0.3914978504,
0.5069749355,
-0.3877735138,
0.2458282709,
0.7122561932,
0.1281814426,
0.3699874282,
0.229974255,
-0.4063041508,
-0.2261407375,
-0.7931799293,
0.045392409,
0.2934765816,
0.4357453287,
-0.0275353082,
0.3307976723,
0.0451604314,
0.551754117,
0.0748632252,
-0.4548269212,
0.2696376145,
-0.0152988518,
0.0167703535,
0.0745490491,
0.8703862429,
0.0686448142,
0.5763446093,
-0.1303421706,
-0.1181231514,
-0.0302680768,
0.2639596164,
-0.4737887084,
0.0587977804,
0.1675636917,
-0.3813401163,
-0.4470217824,
-0.1876833886,
-0.6649748087,
-0.5590652823,
-0.310141474,
0.4236736596,
-0.3393930495,
-0.6978105903,
0.1718136221,
-0.101377964,
0.1458991617,
0.2357898355,
-0.7839862704,
0.3502106667,
0.7415537834,
0.4596152306,
-0.2533792257,
-0.6750783324,
-0.1882386357,
0.246192053,
-0.6270205379,
0.7562129498,
-0.7494100928,
-0.3414337635,
0.2003711015,
-0.0977603793,
-0.1911048889,
-0.5218633413,
0.2243035138,
-0.642657578,
0.2985313237,
-0.0789639503,
-0.6234323382,
-0.3952144682,
0.1510964483,
-0.5282208323,
0.8362278938,
0.1234826744,
-0.5546243191,
0.4272567034,
-0.5987046957,
-0.2968018651,
0.0864284039,
-0.3876748383,
-0.5480653048,
0.299295038,
-0.0739066973,
0.4454652965,
-0.5820050836,
0.3913011849,
-0.7440262437,
-0.2240854055,
0.40387097,
-0.3401581943,
1.1250921488,
0.2801080048,
-0.384439379,
0.0971015394,
-0.7558409572,
-0.1996770203,
0.2516749799,
-0.43280074,
-0.3220898509,
0.3951231837,
-0.574077785,
0.2650395334,
0.028013112,
-0.145833075,
0.5725964904,
-0.3833594024,
0.4824934006,
0.8785368204,
0.2242184281,
0.8462367058,
-0.5370260477,
0.4052838981,
0.1582318246,
0.2847833931,
-0.1483859122,
-0.3308011293,
-0.6023749113,
-0.3142893016,
-0.152973935,
0.3465739489,
-0.6513286233,
0.2372282594,
-0.4161339998,
-0.4068306386,
-0.4212048948,
0.4233172536,
-0.0217487551,
0.0279939789,
0.0976282954,
-0.299934119,
-0.1654754132,
-0.5539039373,
-0.1228007525,
-0.5943146944,
0.0719981417,
0.0252322927,
0.3710170388,
-0.5757090449,
0.8531201482,
0.1777693927,
0.1151782125,
-0.5097276568,
0.226447165,
0.1835927069,
0.3680659235,
0.6548108459,
-0.3944041133,
-0.2666043937,
0.0951752961,
-0.6002371311,
-0.1965150833,
-0.2431423664,
0.1055952385,
0.2999251187,
0.5314111114,
-0.3696852922,
0.2760601342,
0.5978873968,
-0.1497890055,
0.3756574988,
-0.201383993,
-0.0675417557,
-1.1850807667,
-0.4081342518,
0.0235417243,
0.1120996326,
-0.7891815901,
-0.0574157126,
-0.1580927819,
0.3562324941,
0.0000148862,
0.7193825841,
-0.6869726181,
-0.5237546563,
-0.4822619855,
0.0735891685,
-0.3571252823,
0.3744244277,
0.2676163614,
0.3209480345,
0.8130871058,
-0.7617646456,
0.1764261127,
-0.2873264551,
-0.2978861928,
0.2758767903,
-0.2359942198,
0.0573202744,
-0.4444812238,
0.1654203683,
-0.9363985062,
0.0941138193,
0.2545073628,
-0.4221173227,
0.3420867324,
0.0571899414,
-0.7288156152,
-0.2375710309,
-0.2870128453,
0.119076021,
0.4688492715,
-0.709207952,
0.7539224625,
-0.0594226494,
-0.3001188636,
-0.5675399303,
-0.0873186737,
0.1999575645,
-0.4631426334,
-0.5919377208,
-0.0142376926,
-0.3306306899,
-0.8961649537,
-0.2827658653,
0.0993812829,
-0.0329952464,
0.4681200683,
0.1359804571,
0.1276148856,
-0.2752932012,
0.3121315837,
0.0184465814,
0.1109151095,
0.0848697126,
-0.3864741921,
0.5962951779,
0.060375087,
-0.3495768011,
-0.2849754393,
0.199377045,
0.6058727503,
-0.0130809881,
0.8078362942,
0.3661802709,
-0.127938658,
-0.3283780515,
-0.6041832566,
-0.4145458043,
-0.4750238061,
0.3335742056,
-0.4863081574,
-0.7808095217,
0.6194912195,
-0.4201671481,
0.2374203354,
0.3241691291,
0.7397377491,
-0.182444036,
1.1180204153,
1.0020648241,
-0.2680898905,
0.6986734867,
0.025640307,
-0.0578403063,
-0.4685662985,
-0.0993056968,
-0.5623593926,
0.0016999119,
-1.1269119978,
-0.3168870807,
0.2086562812,
0.3128740191,
-0.5771843195,
0.0738297105,
0.0767225325,
0.3622181118,
0.3747736514,
-0.0169520993,
0.400167644,
0.1615403295,
-0.2874539196,
0.4461048245,
-0.6368708014,
-0.5579603314,
1.0209226608,
0.4722519517,
1.0812226534,
0.3346139491,
0.7844448686,
0.3127191663,
0.5330904126,
-0.5131579638,
0.3181397021,
0.0430493653,
-0.6437134147,
-0.1888464987,
-0.1810941547,
-1.0335968733,
0.1287119836,
-0.165006265,
-1.2070345879,
0.2234954834,
-0.0382658206,
0.1001416668,
0.1519590318,
-0.4197847843,
0.455322206,
-0.4701620042,
-0.4451222718,
-0.3876233101,
-0.746134758,
0.2305818498,
-0.1917577684,
0.4408911765,
-0.0632539615,
0.0610284917,
0.4230352342,
-0.0738759711,
1.0996131897,
0.0726890638,
-0.4012508392,
0.201339379,
0.2317683697,
0.3789170682,
-0.0269884206,
-0.3571408391,
0.1563353688,
-0.1428320408,
-0.4390660822,
-0.428501308,
0.43652457,
-1.0783597231,
-0.7543778419,
-0.3930417597,
-0.5643123388,
-0.190625459,
-0.0792451426,
0.1279869378,
0.1806448102,
-0.0276672859,
-0.0436010286,
0.5649709702,
-0.2220236659,
0.733359158,
0.8529176712,
-0.4484676421,
-0.0351701565,
0.5328301787,
-0.1035880372,
0.5024023056,
0.3233225346,
0.4051708281,
-0.0258181356,
-0.6408207417,
-0.1585416645,
0.4509370923,
-0.8034647107,
0.1922395676,
-0.381513685,
-0.1299282759,
-0.5016486049,
-0.1372191012,
-0.2622800171,
-0.0394230559,
-0.2753422856,
-0.0998164341,
0.2117642611,
1.1558820009,
-0.1549202949,
0.6227504611,
-0.5671804547,
-0.2171165198,
0.1921325475,
0.1589336991,
0.0127366688,
-0.701729238,
-0.0547837839,
0.015206906,
-0.2292369902,
-1.1069908142,
0.3798439801,
0.3902333677,
0.9207690954,
0.9083639383,
-0.2124826759,
0.4299288094,
-0.4592758417,
0.6401821375,
-0.0182003863,
-0.6508310437,
0.2994115353,
-0.4140320122,
0.1302417666,
0.1412005275,
0.5056518912,
-0.4038262069,
-0.5113694072,
-0.541446507,
-0.5374304652,
0.5499433875,
-0.1779677868,
0.2523162067,
-0.0615706593,
0.5987013578,
0.4867202938,
0.2205166072,
-1.0280070305,
-0.1100616306,
-0.0094493032,
-0.1780907661,
-0.3870312572,
-0.2033981681,
-0.1067716107,
-0.2332606763,
0.6461701989,
-0.356238544,
0.3390403688,
-0.4592635334,
-0.4060153961,
-0.1824637204,
0.3235127032,
0.6764646173,
0.8702843785,
-0.0720352829,
0.0639824867,
-0.0604746155,
-0.0384870619,
0.1466452181,
-0.00352732,
0.0741072148,
-0.200668484,
0.5453729033,
0.931194365,
-0.0527094714,
-0.525426805,
0.3225495517,
-0.0611688569,
-0.0910675675,
-0.5897206068,
0.1479058266,
0.1835062504,
0.8283581138,
0.5357078314,
-0.2470377386,
-0.0605448931,
-1.0134384632,
0.2292753607,
0.4465694726,
-0.085766688,
-0.4836184382,
0.2014503032,
-0.0770907998,
-0.4244865477,
0.4729595482,
-0.2917939126,
-0.6112887263,
0.5811347961,
0.6751598716,
0.999126792,
-0.448938638,
0.3568298519,
0.2742903829,
0.4344729185,
-0.3325309157,
-0.013045013,
-0.2709996998,
-1.14635849,
-0.3946302235,
-0.7369965315,
-0.4960801005,
0.0709127709,
-0.458899498,
0.2677887678,
-0.2137914598,
0.0753736272,
-0.0635144264,
-0.070975177,
-0.6975608468,
0.0336105824,
0.4127897024,
0.6053112149,
-0.9480317831,
1.1014387608,
0.7936082482,
-0.3397864401,
-0.4530130923,
0.2507843375,
0.0700137541,
-1.2055072784,
0.9348152876,
0.1233356521,
-0.1059329361,
0.1288741976,
-0.5947532058,
-0.9752079844,
0.9685021043,
0.1741187423,
-0.6398265958,
-0.0317914598,
0.2116513252,
0.7097629905,
-0.7702112198,
0.4626335502,
0.7066406608,
0.1736204177,
0.1242879629,
-0.662778616,
-0.2519783676,
-0.0263040829,
0.2179795057,
-0.0148955472,
-0.4901464581,
0.8475696445,
-0.6684622765,
-0.0907374471,
0.1194477007,
0.5377764702,
0.2250641137,
0.1783780009,
0.5190045834,
0.2193155736,
0.4968964756,
0.0546839722,
0.7831699252,
-0.4129000902,
0.1570998579,
1.2513787746,
-0.5361296535,
0.8529311419,
0.4285053909,
-0.138446942,
0.8974756598,
0.9182456136,
0.0766217932,
0.3971039057,
0.4629110396,
-0.3389517367,
-0.216990903,
0.1425077468,
0.0111316573,
0.8021317124,
0.4783222675,
-0.5758920908,
-0.3282699287,
0.2249869853,
0.1844905168,
-0.0477604978,
-0.2919521332,
1.2618604898,
-0.1094858274,
-0.7623932362,
0.2091782391,
-0.1816962808,
0.5695335865,
-0.4480217099,
0.0013262805,
-0.3768831491,
0.1959589422,
0.0871802792,
-0.5190173388,
-0.2527592778,
-0.2370369583,
-0.1377507001,
-0.2085945308,
0.616212666,
-0.4933599532,
-0.3948690295,
0.6623071432,
0.7828546762,
0.1374248713,
0.3004337251,
-0.637131989,
0.2276277691,
-0.1333944052,
-0.461500138,
0.4856064916,
0.4141016901,
-0.2722619176,
0.9745156765,
0.2711952031,
0.1079679802,
0.2028049678,
0.2684976161,
0.5529950261,
-0.6083186269,
-0.1635665745,
-1.1560024023,
0.3970706761,
-0.0024159676,
0.1469233483,
0.4044021666,
-0.1186918095,
0.7735484242,
0.1744826436,
0.8604162335,
0.308049053,
0.3882943392,
-0.3247020543,
0.409968853,
-0.5210050344,
0.5637747645,
-0.1414083391,
-1.0413185358,
0.1726064086,
0.638517797,
-0.2355494201,
0.421819061,
0.6906847358,
0.5522359014,
0.5087407231,
0.0050197784,
0.2253549695,
0.4023347795,
0.3774258494,
0.1939824969,
0.9244688153,
0.0363039859,
0.302626133,
-0.2913869321,
-0.3371173441,
-0.1567586362,
-0.9460284114,
-0.9081382751,
-0.7620560527,
-0.5519888401,
-0.099476248,
0.1685936898,
1.2485047579,
0.4197190106,
-0.5107180476,
-0.7619827986,
-0.0837179124,
0.1612907499,
-0.3138674498,
-0.2204114944,
-0.0612647086,
-0.5865516067,
-0.7876130939,
0.2857923508,
0.3593166173,
0.1761159897,
-0.4957513809,
-0.1280832291,
-0.2130734921,
0.2723682225,
0.6833497286,
0.3796372414,
-0.8283131719,
-0.3634988964,
-0.1761578172,
-0.0454981886,
0.0870969668,
0.4754106998,
-0.7558905482,
0.6056582928,
0.2454621196,
0.566167295,
0.2889533639,
-0.3455365598,
0.7709524035,
-0.5291509032,
-0.1514288634,
0.0051883301,
0.3536485136,
0.3050432503,
0.1038724259,
0.5148555636,
0.118939288,
-0.7198628187,
-0.7554097176,
0.3342662156,
-0.6754984856,
-0.5027092695,
1.3471668959,
0.0432539359,
-0.1696246713,
-0.0031234389,
0.0883246437,
0.2724349499,
-0.3769401312,
1.2223162651,
0.6886798143,
-0.3138113618,
-0.5378183722,
-0.5571456552,
0.5140017271,
0.2090822309,
-0.9735758305,
0.026818715,
0.3257549703,
0.5661001205,
0.1533593982,
0.5057089925,
0.16517663,
0.2347263247,
-0.2448615581,
0.1293117106,
0.5276424289,
-0.311529696,
-0.3657279611,
0.010360159,
0.6667308211,
0.078053765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03150v1
|
NLP at UC Santa Cruz at SemEval-2024 Task 5: Legal Answer Validation using Few-Shot Multi-Choice QA
| 2024-04-04T01:50:20 | 2024-04-04T01:50:20 |
Anish Pahilajani, Samyak Rajesh Jain, Devasha Trivedi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents our submission to the SemEval 2024 Task 5: The Legal
Argument Reasoning Task in Civil Procedure. We present two approaches to
solving the task of legal answer validation, given an introduction to the case,
a question and an answer candidate. Firstly, we fine-tuned pre-trained
BERT-based models and found that models trained on domain knowledge perform
better. Secondly, we performed few-shot prompting on GPT models and found that
reformulating the answer validation task to be a multiple-choice QA task
remarkably improves the performance of the model. Our best submission is a
BERT-based model that achieved the 7th place out of 20.
|
[
-0.3545868099,
-0.7883800268,
1.0534473658,
0.0346227475,
-0.4378111959,
-0.3004613519,
0.1307199597,
-0.4592903852,
-0.0757301226,
0.4920751452,
-0.5243245959,
-0.2464617938,
-0.424859494,
0.2381038368,
-0.1831278503,
1.0742508173,
0.2855742276,
0.6477236152,
-0.3682644665,
-0.2718132436,
-0.5617344975,
-0.6900483966,
-0.6889766455,
-0.3806637526,
0.6458806396,
0.1997268051,
0.440299511,
0.1993622929,
0.548479557,
0.1891989261,
-0.2297894061,
-0.198406294,
-0.0620271899,
-0.0249067936,
-0.2438177466,
-0.587487936,
-0.162430346,
-0.1148185953,
0.1034557447,
0.3027994931,
-0.1648442745,
0.3002648652,
-0.2427265942,
0.4228037,
-0.403401047,
-0.1567205936,
-0.9648294449,
0.0099350726,
-0.0885445029,
-0.0606679805,
-0.4426321685,
-0.5071360469,
0.1827221364,
-0.3417008221,
0.2452008277,
-0.2916885018,
1.1064755917,
0.7161111832,
-0.3907150328,
-0.1374546587,
-0.4820971191,
0.5255477428,
-0.9751374125,
0.0947858468,
0.3520935476,
0.610635519,
-0.0782816112,
-0.6947998405,
-0.5864574313,
-0.2162123024,
0.2495960593,
0.288369149,
-0.0327429585,
0.1843064874,
0.4539994597,
-0.3798995912,
-0.8317428231,
0.0920799598,
-0.5316767097,
-0.2649249732,
0.6480675936,
-0.1491392702,
0.0681717172,
-0.1188515797,
-0.3282944262,
0.1450697184,
-0.8263040185,
0.2772069275,
0.481734097,
0.2452459484,
0.23962529,
0.5778276324,
-0.0602485873,
0.773722589,
0.0353019685,
0.1003524885,
0.0174447242,
-0.2634587288,
-0.4132740498,
0.0287172645,
0.4398801923,
-0.0307921357,
-0.0421772711,
0.4267478883,
0.0591626801,
-0.2409530431,
0.4224177301,
-0.4757992327,
-0.0033088878,
0.6118088961,
-0.6060031056,
-0.2230457664,
-0.155662328,
-0.6350929141,
-0.3505762219,
-0.2777864933,
0.5542011261,
-0.2053564042,
0.3273870349,
0.2597109079,
-0.256806165,
0.4956374466,
0.8821828365,
-0.5826051235,
0.0584074296,
0.6771067977,
0.2114255875,
0.1633781046,
-0.1462106407,
-0.7316266298,
-0.0374980494,
-0.2111411691,
1.2055302858,
-0.4541690052,
-0.0003994262,
-0.0363817997,
-0.1369291693,
0.2424887717,
-0.4872244,
0.9744798541,
-0.7945603728,
0.2404958457,
-0.578658402,
-0.5049909353,
-0.3982722759,
0.5402619243,
-0.498331368,
0.8954747319,
0.0219980348,
-0.5209280849,
0.7200630903,
-0.9837985635,
-0.3734724224,
0.2363449186,
-0.2419393808,
-0.6828380823,
0.0150478743,
0.3469547927,
0.4025780857,
-0.0221325401,
0.3591338396,
-0.5681405067,
-0.118581593,
-0.0205282327,
-0.3728858531,
1.1929739714,
0.3746314943,
-0.269333154,
0.0084134387,
-0.7450685501,
0.1723734438,
0.2116458565,
-0.6360666156,
0.0219987705,
-0.0403423533,
-0.3547966778,
0.6208643317,
0.1715225577,
-0.6747313142,
0.2575450838,
-0.3200655282,
0.3278179765,
0.7182636857,
0.2024351805,
-0.0492140539,
-0.2627458572,
0.7959781289,
-0.0141935721,
0.1697043926,
-0.0431228317,
-1.0237321854,
-0.5238828063,
0.1496659219,
0.6325365305,
0.6171625257,
-0.7194768786,
0.1255672574,
0.0671435818,
-0.3842815459,
-0.5020580292,
-0.1716092229,
-0.0265806932,
0.4273303449,
0.5875576735,
-0.0582088903,
-0.7864437103,
-0.7821228504,
-0.2555783689,
-0.4951495826,
0.1248013526,
0.4426783919,
0.9254567623,
0.0330723375,
1.0718402863,
-0.3093672991,
-0.1729052216,
-0.2005275637,
0.4682994783,
0.4513872266,
0.2501343489,
0.749635458,
-0.6516652107,
-0.3773263991,
-0.077348724,
-0.5146259069,
-0.3233683407,
-0.3614374697,
0.2485720068,
0.0678041279,
0.206613183,
-0.1959067732,
0.3827472925,
0.2998446226,
-0.227383256,
0.8030728698,
-0.1139770672,
0.198788628,
-0.805950582,
-0.1449940056,
-0.1850877702,
-0.5272679925,
-0.5685908198,
0.0461349301,
-0.2043847144,
-0.3402253985,
-0.9466574192,
0.2713354826,
-0.1241628379,
-0.1579120755,
-0.2682186067,
-0.13841708,
-0.1529242694,
0.5155593753,
0.1716786176,
0.6342399716,
0.2770684659,
-0.4165937603,
0.6065243483,
0.3086903989,
0.0053486205,
0.717325449,
-0.8126738667,
0.345186919,
-0.2710487247,
0.4088439047,
-1.037535429,
-0.2389657795,
-0.1752239764,
-0.3699352145,
-0.078702718,
-0.5356479287,
-0.4150924683,
-0.7007192969,
-0.2085998952,
0.1283067018,
0.1950651854,
-0.4309232831,
0.7687078118,
0.1862771362,
-0.388458997,
-0.7011265755,
-0.7416980863,
0.1326731741,
-0.2217874378,
-0.5647877455,
0.2166903168,
-0.1833265126,
0.0129024442,
-0.0559078045,
0.1533861458,
-0.4400101602,
0.1444030255,
0.012254646,
0.0695660859,
-0.3372069597,
0.1197349206,
0.3101996779,
0.0806592107,
0.257450819,
-0.0377232246,
0.4042139053,
-0.2265439481,
-0.6373319626,
-0.4093190432,
0.5855708718,
0.2444307506,
-0.0756738484,
0.1840054691,
0.3095403016,
-0.3954446018,
0.0762689114,
-0.7882999778,
-0.2254406959,
-0.342936337,
0.1000843495,
-0.4758956432,
-1.1287146807,
0.564285934,
-0.0297105722,
0.5084658265,
0.5683903098,
0.8091773391,
-0.3852755129,
1.0742739439,
0.2622286081,
0.1242578998,
0.1366252154,
0.0236970559,
0.2459463179,
-0.3943659365,
-0.0022896414,
-1.1341491938,
-0.0403948091,
-0.2897615433,
-0.349807024,
0.6251562238,
-0.0196977109,
-0.166394338,
0.5359587669,
-0.5327177644,
0.5993526578,
0.764863193,
-0.0618481562,
0.075353846,
-0.3961782455,
-0.5720365644,
0.1651493013,
-0.7662478089,
-0.6846706271,
1.0139681101,
0.5327666402,
0.4577971697,
0.2216043174,
1.0658935308,
0.1006745026,
-0.0670862421,
-0.742372334,
0.6771416664,
0.0092037097,
-1.0616748333,
-0.6019171476,
0.055908028,
-0.9596819282,
0.4250808954,
-0.2736535668,
-0.5132535696,
0.1381897926,
-0.0050517083,
-1.0147343874,
-0.1611587852,
-0.5693229437,
0.8404220939,
-0.3108386397,
-0.2068137228,
-0.038416598,
-0.9592829347,
0.2007751465,
0.0892453641,
-0.0935613364,
-0.1390004903,
0.2674369812,
0.60644871,
-0.478361398,
0.7508978248,
-0.3296734989,
-0.0940657556,
0.6001544595,
-0.3325532079,
0.6189459562,
0.180159986,
-0.1258557737,
-0.1470146626,
0.5066732764,
-0.2610696852,
-0.5804052353,
0.2256748527,
-0.5370744467,
-0.689258039,
-0.5773387551,
-0.2195809186,
-0.1807791442,
0.218661949,
0.1591126025,
0.0397844724,
-0.1175113246,
0.2335534245,
0.5334085822,
-0.2535009086,
0.5873088241,
0.414578706,
0.1354166269,
-0.3386678696,
0.3604826629,
0.1387918293,
-0.1622043401,
0.2585838437,
0.4840882719,
-0.695438683,
-0.735676825,
-0.5530959964,
0.2048470229,
-1.0154899359,
-0.26596573,
-0.7120441198,
-0.2636735737,
-0.7237530351,
-0.2238240689,
-0.1529716253,
-0.5350637436,
-0.3686607182,
0.0263185389,
-0.2185969949,
0.645131588,
0.1022517085,
-0.0731879547,
-0.9808496833,
0.2299193889,
0.8296058774,
-0.0218909103,
-0.6096203923,
-0.5522605777,
0.1013436243,
-0.1167921498,
-0.5284169316,
-0.9606155753,
0.04360535,
-0.0388386734,
0.7508738637,
0.2984227836,
-0.1179569885,
0.8743044138,
-0.7497321963,
1.273196578,
0.0676460639,
-0.8318362832,
1.1950801611,
-0.3681079149,
0.3288572133,
0.8431590796,
0.3464095592,
-0.0585903414,
-0.4691573381,
-0.9280399084,
-0.3739364445,
0.4635555148,
0.0503505431,
0.1472657919,
0.1291894168,
0.2803829014,
0.0335442089,
0.0972718596,
-1.1374391317,
0.1765383333,
-0.2298177034,
0.0852078274,
0.6003699303,
-0.3779949248,
-0.4233805239,
-0.2132882029,
0.859021008,
-0.5524095893,
0.3814693093,
0.1319724023,
0.0248744488,
0.1619646251,
0.7892548442,
1.1737003326,
0.7476738095,
-0.0331749618,
0.1147929877,
0.5920191407,
-0.1431501359,
0.3714549541,
0.1057274044,
-0.2374561876,
0.2653586864,
0.306681186,
0.4882203639,
-0.274971664,
-0.4149237871,
0.8356594443,
-0.0546553694,
-0.7405578494,
-0.3627744615,
-0.1757255942,
-0.133366555,
0.271520257,
0.315639019,
0.0534646995,
0.3741158843,
-0.3564370275,
0.28939569,
0.4798572659,
-0.378177464,
-0.1044564396,
0.8317950368,
0.0947854742,
0.0922117382,
0.0513385721,
-0.2551835179,
-0.6382669806,
0.7339110374,
0.4923329651,
0.6831738949,
-0.0944605842,
0.3334164619,
0.5140150785,
0.1063231975,
-0.215517208,
0.7099372745,
0.0092652859,
-0.6640633345,
-0.6770226955,
-0.3100174665,
-0.4683592618,
0.3279188275,
-0.3526382446,
0.4978186488,
-0.4468444586,
-0.2215423137,
-0.0067601101,
0.0202985685,
-0.5237751007,
0.3791308105,
0.007201443,
0.7593169808,
-1.0072245598,
0.8412901163,
0.9726356268,
-0.5997393727,
-0.887565732,
-0.2665498257,
0.2586839199,
-0.5230859518,
0.8137176037,
-0.0735696256,
-0.0296876114,
-0.1604661345,
-0.90872401,
-0.4831867516,
0.9125718474,
0.4834243059,
-0.447486043,
0.09922833,
0.109339267,
0.6325223446,
-0.059802793,
0.3230791688,
0.4110289216,
0.5036191344,
0.4686822295,
-0.8861120939,
-0.2317106426,
0.0224267766,
0.111291945,
-0.2636197507,
-0.2455039769,
0.4370646477,
-0.3998751342,
0.0876712501,
-0.001840225,
0.8189893961,
0.6116969585,
0.1947880685,
0.5952352881,
0.72476089,
0.7642028332,
-0.3548074365,
0.8819777966,
0.1275041848,
0.4875206649,
1.3739315271,
-0.619096756,
0.9671248198,
0.6662538052,
-0.4623256624,
0.4324166477,
0.8125463128,
-0.2285158187,
0.4287164509,
0.2233486474,
-0.2310369313,
-0.4642970562,
-0.0686899796,
-0.2255426347,
0.7899538875,
-0.0259984303,
-0.1134007797,
-0.4627210498,
0.0844967663,
-0.2494163513,
-0.0650727004,
-0.1519461274,
0.9628878236,
-0.0665939972,
-0.970838964,
0.2488247454,
0.01526656,
0.3076299131,
-0.3687370121,
-0.3465323746,
0.1847877502,
-0.3061780632,
-0.2207024693,
-1.0339174271,
0.3422739506,
0.2450245321,
0.0238392148,
-0.3157058954,
0.8570744991,
-0.2327783555,
-0.2038795054,
-0.1353593022,
0.3696904182,
0.2038561702,
0.0173424929,
-1.272141099,
-0.4412777722,
-0.1270984858,
-0.0520656034,
-0.02215009,
0.3965352476,
-0.1499765217,
0.5531309843,
0.8319939375,
0.2113731503,
0.3464696109,
0.5653766394,
0.7103264928,
-0.3575679362,
-0.6241705418,
-0.6903740764,
0.7127692103,
-0.0473820828,
-0.2506290376,
0.2762920856,
0.5776846409,
0.576399982,
-0.2798735201,
0.7306092978,
-0.0905392617,
0.7172119021,
-0.7094041109,
0.3020409048,
-0.2975522876,
0.1890298277,
-0.3173589408,
-0.6176437736,
-0.6388653517,
0.7741633058,
-0.3197470009,
0.0882222652,
0.8861843348,
0.6435576081,
0.15616633,
0.0685468614,
0.6367940307,
-0.2146846205,
0.5816590786,
0.7589522004,
1.0256632566,
-0.4717796147,
0.593047142,
0.011052697,
0.1649717689,
-0.338490665,
-1.2328881025,
-0.6520994902,
-0.5363938808,
-0.3304911256,
-0.4297448993,
-0.1366670579,
0.9000570178,
0.7806865573,
-1.0618481636,
0.1016078889,
-0.0976082012,
0.1194075346,
-0.2968350649,
-0.2093555331,
0.0645385981,
-0.6264294982,
-0.5210232139,
0.4529500008,
0.404086411,
0.2190357894,
-0.0103092846,
0.2033604681,
-0.6382321119,
0.220053494,
0.7202112675,
0.2962789237,
-1.0248222351,
-0.5810438395,
-0.2023655921,
-0.1314304322,
0.3945136368,
0.7763269544,
-0.6871321201,
0.3992917538,
0.7542228103,
1.1388280392,
0.4407983124,
0.2328888476,
0.5270007849,
-0.7244539857,
-0.0922293961,
0.6929558516,
0.5727428198,
-0.133499518,
-0.4211623073,
0.7633628249,
0.1322700381,
-0.8151085973,
-0.5287188888,
0.1618574113,
-1.2385704517,
-0.3627600372,
1.065415144,
-0.3977320492,
-0.0920951366,
-0.5742589831,
-0.402692616,
-0.1018616259,
-0.2112346739,
0.6333832741,
1.1604311466,
-0.3451850712,
-0.4716937542,
-0.769051373,
0.5074389577,
0.5891637206,
-1.316745162,
-0.4936614931,
0.5470254421,
0.298782289,
0.3311063945,
0.7990298867,
-0.2643082142,
0.8455072045,
-0.2854142487,
-0.0919432193,
0.1178558469,
-0.3615813553,
-0.7786868811,
0.4945280254,
0.2337997854,
-0.1160914078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03134v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03134v2
|
Robust Pronoun Fidelity with English LLMs: Are they Reasoning, Repeating, or Just Biased?
| 2024-04-04T01:07:14 | 2024-05-01T21:35:00 |
Vagrant Gautam, Eileen Bingert, Dawei Zhu, Anne Lauscher, Dietrich Klakow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Robust, faithful and harm-free pronoun use for individuals is an important
goal for language models as their use increases, but prior work tends to study
only one or two of these characteristics at a time. To measure progress towards
the combined goal, we introduce the task of pronoun fidelity: given a context
introducing a co-referring entity and pronoun, the task is to reuse the correct
pronoun later. We present RUFF, a carefully-designed dataset of over 5 million
instances to measure robust pronoun fidelity in English, and we evaluate 37
popular large language models across architectures (encoder-only, decoder-only
and encoder-decoder) and scales (11M-70B parameters). When an individual is
introduced with a pronoun, models can mostly faithfully reuse this pronoun in
the next sentence, but they are significantly worse with she/her/her, singular
they and neopronouns. Moreover, models are easily distracted by non-adversarial
sentences discussing other people; even one additional sentence with a
distractor pronoun causes accuracy to drop on average by 34%. Our results show
that pronoun fidelity is neither robust, nor due to reasoning, in a simple,
naturalistic setting where humans achieve nearly 100% accuracy. We encourage
researchers to bridge the gaps we find and to carefully evaluate reasoning in
settings where superficial repetition might inflate perceptions of model
performance.
|
[
-0.1128231809,
-0.7656891942,
0.4488360584,
0.1533133239,
-0.3604199588,
-0.082492277,
-0.0521699041,
-0.5753326416,
-0.0553647131,
0.5803323388,
-0.1951506287,
-0.1225174889,
-0.6122123599,
0.3158223629,
-0.358073324,
0.7155681849,
0.0472730175,
0.22254242,
-0.5048446655,
-0.1810066998,
-0.4523885846,
-0.5133638978,
-0.3415859342,
-0.4001876414,
0.534968853,
0.4016399086,
1.1085573435,
0.8371133804,
0.7040017843,
0.2992283404,
-0.2293358296,
0.0735713318,
-0.5322218537,
0.4084046483,
-0.1173681542,
-0.2428004146,
-0.373480618,
0.1785896868,
0.536675036,
0.8058840632,
-0.236813128,
0.0974322036,
0.3550973237,
0.2086528093,
-0.4782652557,
-0.2652350068,
-0.5996305346,
-0.2098680735,
-0.2318437845,
-0.108738184,
-0.3449736238,
-0.4442695379,
0.1270927489,
-0.6485671997,
0.1371707916,
0.1658247411,
1.0775206089,
0.3988985121,
-0.3146654069,
-0.031129377,
-0.5729278922,
0.8493348956,
-0.4117588997,
0.6977698207,
0.6382630467,
-0.2289735228,
-0.5450910926,
-0.6807041168,
-0.1603203118,
-0.6985726357,
-0.1425945312,
0.0906830058,
-0.2053068131,
-0.2029542327,
0.0638884902,
0.1721984893,
-0.36837551,
-0.0867204443,
-0.0565841645,
-0.3051469624,
0.5692225099,
0.0376572348,
-0.0292174052,
0.038792327,
-0.4133097231,
0.0477389656,
-0.5743509531,
0.1110549048,
0.7701814771,
0.1128068492,
0.2427868098,
0.5790095329,
0.2358985245,
0.3482558131,
0.1797850281,
-0.4178022146,
0.1036377177,
-0.6510296464,
-0.0163116902,
-0.4186860025,
0.9174790382,
0.2340816408,
0.791981101,
-0.3180077076,
-0.1464327127,
0.1767668724,
0.4771873653,
-0.388386637,
-0.3837210834,
0.1360316575,
-0.139370352,
-0.1646627486,
0.0702260882,
-0.3503167033,
0.0851376057,
0.0083862673,
0.2187264711,
-0.6253858805,
-0.3216124475,
0.370559603,
0.0230554547,
0.063561514,
0.0889315605,
-0.4362898469,
0.2335033119,
0.8354258537,
0.5063233376,
-0.0797301158,
-0.7604045868,
-0.6196516156,
0.1444310844,
-0.4117373228,
0.9115086198,
-0.6527181268,
-0.6128436327,
-0.0919381678,
0.066615656,
0.1237618253,
-0.6590808034,
0.8457209468,
-0.1007046849,
0.2692860365,
-0.4865282774,
-0.537797153,
0.1415894479,
0.0537522994,
-0.4655126035,
0.9929093719,
-0.1986985803,
-0.9269943237,
0.5367106199,
0.0868979916,
-0.5603890419,
-0.031367138,
0.0729533061,
-0.56359905,
0.1938649565,
-0.0111211082,
0.4662939906,
0.0550310276,
0.3844150007,
-0.4964997172,
-0.5056560636,
0.624646306,
-0.410995096,
0.417214483,
-0.167248413,
0.272272557,
-0.0520932935,
-0.4104880691,
-0.2141979337,
0.0855078027,
-0.1690143347,
-0.6006165743,
0.0779225975,
-0.04539847,
0.0069248816,
0.098784931,
-0.3184854984,
-0.2111473978,
-0.1188270673,
0.3464576006,
0.5068303943,
0.127096802,
0.434702605,
-0.7229763865,
0.4044059515,
-0.0518734418,
0.2965789735,
-0.1064382568,
-0.4944689572,
-0.382025063,
-0.6313912868,
0.4468671978,
0.4192739427,
-0.0803159401,
0.3112957776,
-0.1741575599,
-0.0861535817,
-0.6173898578,
0.21351704,
0.3640941679,
0.6370790005,
0.2554053962,
-0.2016878426,
-0.4493942857,
-1.1038298607,
-0.6307855248,
-0.4777204394,
-0.0064482717,
0.0271208603,
0.5560952425,
0.0633763671,
0.787925601,
-0.0501753017,
-0.1763442457,
-0.1232883111,
0.2094748765,
-0.2780002952,
0.3534577191,
0.2711018026,
-0.5378457308,
-0.1235259026,
-0.4184661806,
-0.6836631298,
-0.193689093,
-0.1511381119,
-0.2172135711,
0.170779258,
0.3357147276,
-0.469291538,
0.0421661139,
0.4398475885,
-0.472753346,
0.7401634455,
-0.1112137809,
0.0098124743,
-1.0337096453,
-0.0021788543,
0.1480086446,
-0.7057602406,
-0.3648850918,
0.2277747989,
-0.13848041,
0.5427060723,
-0.5506055355,
0.3916966617,
-0.6095157862,
0.0001426225,
-0.1667168438,
0.1746164709,
0.1374141276,
-0.121489957,
0.0026762551,
0.9948142767,
0.3017353117,
-0.5699877143,
0.0935537741,
0.1990811378,
-0.1786225438,
0.8707906604,
-0.8303759694,
0.2660673559,
0.0022194525,
-0.0596823096,
-0.6559004784,
-0.2832108438,
0.1542494446,
-0.4760936201,
0.0877773985,
-0.0434316099,
-0.4143126309,
-0.151720494,
-0.4127249122,
0.1211803779,
0.5578253269,
-0.1062924415,
0.2959075272,
0.4574244916,
-0.2304347008,
-0.7846158743,
-0.8471108675,
0.217463553,
-0.2550718784,
-0.7197542787,
0.2102806866,
0.0611112043,
-0.6924982667,
0.4220950305,
-0.2580735385,
-0.1699201763,
0.3124431968,
0.1415862292,
0.1757457405,
-0.0288438499,
0.0137134818,
-0.2992014587,
-0.3063717484,
0.114498727,
0.0486425124,
0.1992181093,
-0.2233870924,
-0.4236619771,
-0.5947628021,
0.576012969,
0.468916446,
0.0315216035,
0.6362053752,
0.3662668765,
-0.4207015336,
0.1099560931,
-0.7011347413,
-0.2815354764,
-0.3922918439,
0.4090024829,
-0.6987797618,
-0.9241392612,
0.7588469982,
0.2975769341,
0.1602758914,
0.162006855,
0.3315035105,
-0.5963600278,
0.7003453374,
0.6720553041,
0.1042314842,
0.2015006989,
0.1599793136,
0.074007757,
-0.6795802116,
-0.2583422065,
-0.4955867231,
-0.1365820169,
-0.3965400457,
-0.2459072471,
-0.052496586,
0.4757988155,
-0.1214281246,
0.4511343837,
-0.3413377404,
0.4195360243,
0.5926516056,
0.12809062,
0.634703815,
-0.1389927417,
-0.0711727738,
-0.4334864318,
-0.5213701129,
-0.8579668403,
0.8321105838,
0.5639759302,
0.9217207432,
0.0121182362,
0.6704396605,
0.1176620871,
0.0595524982,
-0.7706107497,
0.6185752153,
-0.1115809754,
-0.3819606006,
-0.1443444043,
-0.3908185661,
-0.9499315619,
-0.0240346938,
-0.1506177634,
-0.4040645957,
0.2521797121,
0.3212195635,
-0.3210531175,
0.0664696544,
-0.2356217057,
0.567909658,
-0.370049715,
-0.6634690166,
-0.0330104418,
-0.4159662724,
0.4334138036,
-0.1028990075,
0.0247366466,
-0.1621936709,
-0.3430937231,
0.4727163017,
-0.3521851599,
0.5028836131,
0.3007560968,
-0.1536333412,
0.3045003116,
0.3695952594,
0.6093907952,
0.2081068605,
-0.038501922,
0.4350661337,
0.0596869476,
-0.4344826341,
-0.280382961,
0.5298058987,
-0.6018004417,
-0.6095395684,
-0.6750047207,
-0.5812644958,
-0.1752216965,
-0.0362559557,
0.3891271651,
0.0608718432,
-0.4283800423,
0.4822629392,
0.6135092974,
0.1218394786,
0.1010174826,
0.3948230147,
-0.0128229344,
-0.4941367507,
0.4080846906,
0.2823752761,
0.36191836,
0.1331345439,
0.2710874975,
-0.3695243299,
-0.4338588119,
-0.0583578274,
0.3637827039,
-0.3875736594,
-0.200878799,
-0.7237267494,
0.0993772447,
-0.2465775162,
-0.2619927824,
-0.5774609447,
-0.0998291895,
-0.3244268298,
-0.0433579832,
0.2737216949,
0.541885972,
-0.1302543133,
0.0728704706,
-0.6085826755,
0.3104834259,
0.3956274688,
0.1739418358,
-0.6569259763,
-0.9367436767,
0.0601315089,
0.091983974,
-0.0538947545,
-1.0281250477,
0.2030152678,
0.1946714669,
0.7757305503,
0.2615882158,
0.1136837974,
0.6425778866,
-0.2326509506,
0.7890310884,
-0.1621542573,
-0.7907614708,
0.2653759122,
-0.3949163854,
0.1693708897,
0.7922999263,
0.3232908249,
-0.3812270761,
-0.6053539515,
-0.6371938586,
-0.7540149689,
0.1561258733,
0.0451911986,
0.1460444182,
-0.2264818698,
0.6777017713,
0.2675212324,
0.0927693769,
-0.6331112981,
-0.0908218697,
-0.1313912123,
-0.1004445106,
0.1909237057,
-0.5876703858,
-0.250818491,
-0.0645262003,
0.7354038358,
-0.0367559977,
0.1864873171,
0.1976646781,
-0.2397822142,
-0.0228532664,
0.2830737531,
0.5494967103,
0.467218101,
-0.2483961731,
0.1719609499,
0.2681391239,
-0.6342532039,
0.1889938712,
-0.0649384484,
-0.2902429998,
0.0700144768,
0.616137445,
0.3029093146,
0.4504236877,
-0.3403334022,
0.52933532,
-0.1914917827,
-0.4226060212,
-0.4346779585,
-0.1762390584,
0.3424125016,
0.0459620096,
0.0728021339,
0.3061459064,
-0.1607389003,
-0.59150213,
0.4584806561,
0.5763657093,
-0.1338363737,
-0.558914721,
0.6448335052,
0.1826894581,
-0.4976967573,
0.5170220733,
-0.3943602443,
-0.3918822408,
0.2018324286,
0.6020431519,
1.0928068161,
-0.1492844075,
0.1713781953,
0.2177220583,
0.5958009958,
-0.7098659277,
0.5339318514,
0.3092278242,
-1.0433830023,
-0.4492797256,
-0.4233491719,
-0.6310645342,
0.3516075015,
-0.767385006,
0.2303950638,
-0.2268971801,
-0.440377593,
-0.4972245395,
-0.0670577809,
-0.6076396704,
-0.1099080816,
-0.2110003531,
0.8723666072,
-0.918366015,
0.6614524126,
0.9698244929,
-0.3157749772,
-0.7109689713,
0.282726109,
-0.1304609925,
-0.4375640452,
0.2098073363,
-0.0609156303,
-0.4731435478,
-0.3230049908,
-0.4170871377,
-0.7044847012,
0.8270580173,
0.7838363051,
-0.7883779407,
0.1801598221,
0.1437250078,
0.5256633759,
-0.232670024,
0.0928118303,
0.5312340856,
0.4344389737,
0.0389878713,
-0.9119189382,
-0.1150535569,
-0.0322563387,
-0.1231620461,
-0.1061746553,
-0.7935630083,
0.7328557372,
-0.4433422387,
-0.2693282664,
0.2056239545,
0.6663384438,
0.3994624615,
0.1202062443,
0.5176451206,
0.5648189783,
0.8636348248,
-0.1886802167,
0.8999622464,
-0.3395063579,
0.0902243331,
1.3542350531,
-0.4602783918,
1.1456478834,
0.6114182472,
-0.1708187461,
0.255127281,
0.4986315966,
0.1680461466,
0.3341962695,
-0.0464024059,
-0.0772265196,
-0.6362083554,
-0.333330363,
-0.1597671807,
0.7181797624,
0.0560228787,
-0.2805588245,
0.2237118334,
0.0350703485,
0.3424060047,
0.4213535786,
0.175465554,
0.6086497307,
0.2378016561,
-0.7018469572,
0.2966587543,
-0.247205317,
0.7764938474,
-0.4102638066,
0.2449084818,
-0.4480792284,
0.2034875154,
-0.047084149,
-0.9218874574,
0.5906432271,
-0.0328581631,
-0.1534335911,
-0.352083981,
0.8231069446,
-0.4227145016,
-0.6562734246,
0.404404819,
0.8621269464,
0.3324855268,
0.0166280381,
-0.6006843448,
0.0542208515,
-0.3275237978,
-0.4410782456,
0.1847973466,
0.3644357026,
0.073955074,
0.9196308255,
0.4440378249,
0.3070442379,
-0.0114215082,
0.195924297,
0.4456456602,
-0.6220334768,
0.0260241423,
-0.8243474364,
0.4495422542,
0.0830570534,
-0.5271008015,
0.8940020204,
0.4680024683,
0.9353820682,
0.282838285,
0.5880471468,
0.4992543459,
0.527628839,
-0.2174269557,
0.4342590272,
-0.4286399186,
0.2414861321,
-0.0607576855,
-0.8705239296,
-0.2275823951,
1.0174796581,
-0.0198874865,
0.0906866714,
0.7083057165,
0.883413434,
-0.0648425296,
-0.06934046,
0.617613852,
0.2809042633,
-0.0664843321,
0.2952510715,
1.0343897343,
-0.483212322,
0.5506266952,
-0.3220942914,
0.0279849544,
-0.1330037117,
-1.0304783583,
-0.6507096291,
-0.3630636334,
-0.7843111157,
-0.3265054822,
0.4510174096,
0.8752239943,
0.5608431101,
-0.6243796349,
0.0031172619,
-0.0776862949,
0.0569454245,
-0.5166188478,
-0.1631581038,
-0.0223806649,
-0.2076773047,
-0.7161852121,
0.369817555,
0.132741183,
-0.0286134705,
-0.4928973615,
-0.1175186262,
-0.1019642055,
0.2853839993,
0.2212468833,
0.1409327239,
-0.8528737426,
-0.7038148046,
0.4286439717,
-0.355202347,
-0.0648063272,
0.4605543911,
-0.8437498212,
0.0271784868,
0.5575627685,
0.3007844388,
-0.1787355691,
0.2386208922,
0.5351205468,
-0.6232215762,
-0.1883603781,
0.3322752118,
0.6292161942,
0.5998129845,
-0.3692953885,
0.3751235902,
0.4944778383,
-0.7848354578,
-1.0638519526,
0.2435080409,
-0.7104853988,
-0.1216911301,
1.2307823896,
-0.253413409,
-0.0293892752,
-0.486130029,
0.1151728481,
0.1496074349,
-0.4592679739,
0.6099282503,
0.9171407223,
-0.1052269861,
-0.4564956427,
-0.4646660686,
0.3270120323,
0.7054120302,
-0.3656438887,
0.1051584408,
0.3531712592,
0.6902116537,
0.0950788409,
0.4876470268,
-0.1131259054,
0.204642266,
0.3808534741,
0.0113712186,
-0.37562415,
-0.5153148174,
-0.2678625584,
0.2487639934,
0.2696988285,
-0.2579747736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04285v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04285v1
|
MIMIR: A Streamlined Platform for Personalized Agent Tuning in Domain Expertise
| 2024-04-03T23:42:38 | 2024-04-03T23:42:38 |
Chunyuan Deng, Xiangru Tang, Yilun Zhao, Hanming Wang, Haoran Wang, Wangchunshu Zhou, Arman Cohan, Mark Gerstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have evolved into interactive agents,
proficient in planning, tool use, and task execution across a wide variety of
tasks. However, without specific agent tuning, open-source models like LLaMA
currently struggle to match the efficiency of GPT- 4, particularly given the
scarcity of agent-tuning datasets for fine-tuning. In response, we introduce
\textsc{Mimir}: a streamlined platform offering a customizable pipeline that
enables users to leverage both private knowledge and publicly available,
legally compliant datasets at scale for \textbf{personalized agent tuning}.
Additionally, \textsc{Mimir} supports the generation of general
instruction-tuning datasets from the same input. This dual capability ensures
that language agents developed through the platform possess both specific agent
abilities and general competencies. \textsc{Mimir} integrates these features
into a cohesive end-to-end platform, facilitating everything from the uploading
of personalized files to one-click agent fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.459788233,
-0.5971187949,
0.4854085147,
-0.0207371097,
0.2254413962,
0.4622943103,
-0.3050479591,
-0.0764082894,
0.3005132079,
0.7615596652,
-0.5936977267,
-0.6684861183,
-0.4073056281,
-0.0267424323,
-0.0631030351,
1.2636262178,
0.1771399528,
-0.2217198014,
-0.2919834256,
0.0026924021,
-0.3417622149,
-0.3608014584,
-0.7212770581,
-0.3854253292,
0.8846533298,
0.8397284746,
0.9382404089,
0.9786487818,
0.5754998326,
0.4658254683,
0.2757016718,
0.3970138729,
-0.6439530253,
0.3774427474,
-0.4711404145,
-0.414694339,
-1.0295705795,
-0.0355997197,
0.2117859423,
0.4320970774,
-0.3348912597,
0.3578988612,
-0.1407210678,
0.7594819665,
-0.6509765387,
0.2188521475,
-0.8742595911,
-0.3451304436,
-0.2901795506,
-0.5252076983,
-0.0803810731,
-0.2715622783,
-0.023752939,
-0.9837811589,
0.3978388011,
-0.0427289046,
0.8675099611,
0.6945821047,
-0.3468355536,
-0.3858746886,
-0.7211976051,
0.6897279024,
-0.3093747199,
0.0136820376,
0.6275244951,
0.6823058128,
-0.1179731041,
-0.9900635481,
-0.3658413589,
-0.2632950544,
0.1138975322,
-0.1563809216,
-0.159354791,
0.1814291775,
0.0578401089,
0.4269751012,
-0.3776934445,
0.0265938267,
-0.1089691296,
-0.2530888915,
0.5104548931,
0.4189686179,
0.1438186467,
0.5818642378,
0.0273387991,
0.0678883418,
-0.5941327214,
0.0344241112,
0.6550942659,
0.3015058637,
0.0575910881,
0.5718057752,
-0.7353124619,
0.7100712657,
0.512568295,
-0.1981126517,
0.2273534238,
0.0541320704,
-0.0316109546,
-0.2758050859,
0.5940197706,
0.1359655261,
0.4143953323,
-0.5000116825,
-0.3465996385,
-0.1465607285,
0.25965783,
-0.7790359855,
-0.5523154736,
0.1512588412,
-0.0668098405,
-0.3012221158,
-0.0691805705,
-0.4861491919,
-0.4098206162,
-0.6675194502,
0.4838108122,
-0.1475775391,
-0.0119539239,
0.1886092722,
-0.0219658818,
0.1671107709,
0.3332594633,
-1.0909209251,
0.5098401904,
1.0059745312,
0.7335412502,
-0.1218642518,
-0.2765845656,
-0.8626932502,
0.3524246216,
-0.1010549664,
1.006161809,
-1.0308357477,
-0.1156800315,
-0.0917789266,
0.0334593207,
-0.1566314995,
-0.5419400334,
0.3837172091,
-0.8335182667,
0.2418683916,
-0.2635187805,
-0.6097983122,
-0.0708681419,
0.199923262,
-0.5429825783,
0.8561273217,
0.3114587963,
-0.6535981297,
0.387683779,
-1.055011034,
-0.1869108677,
0.294370532,
-0.1276391894,
-0.4290659428,
-0.1105393395,
0.2408665568,
0.5299759507,
-0.1614445001,
0.1404156387,
-0.3799241483,
-0.4166332185,
0.146975562,
0.1042061672,
0.3159750402,
0.3289868534,
-0.2158504128,
0.5164883733,
-0.827906847,
0.1030024514,
-0.1252237856,
-0.4830177724,
-0.1821172535,
0.01345417,
-0.0181456041,
0.203097716,
0.7847486734,
-0.2942029238,
0.3784583807,
-0.1972394139,
0.3636799455,
0.964613378,
-0.1858210117,
0.5326606035,
-0.6271182895,
0.856798172,
-0.3620873094,
0.0406168103,
-0.1907564104,
-0.4272388816,
-1.0140658617,
-0.7738801837,
0.3167721331,
0.5905033946,
-0.6156983972,
0.5646791458,
-0.457799077,
-0.3246779442,
-0.8897119164,
0.4228833318,
0.2416867316,
0.4375702143,
0.1819946915,
-0.1006104872,
-0.2554867864,
-1.034909606,
-0.1852276027,
0.314589262,
-0.4193575084,
0.4890682995,
0.4051792026,
-0.460439235,
1.2838249207,
-0.5138838291,
-0.6075031161,
-0.0294803176,
-0.1033495814,
0.0637270734,
0.3064367771,
0.3964673579,
-0.6517795324,
-0.8749511242,
0.6357946396,
-0.4680365324,
-0.40174371,
0.2876763046,
-0.3767049313,
-0.0839063376,
0.4414127767,
-0.5465855002,
-0.0645113885,
0.6000696421,
-0.397595197,
0.2977697849,
-0.3185517192,
0.0193026196,
-1.1183828115,
0.2424302548,
-0.5059125423,
-0.5222365856,
-0.7095165253,
0.1110195145,
-0.0881536901,
0.1391937733,
-0.0815932155,
0.683496356,
-0.2347568423,
-0.0285209697,
-0.5323176384,
0.1767822355,
-0.1110478342,
0.4802982211,
-0.1189903989,
1.063662529,
0.6158074737,
-0.610645175,
0.2688982487,
0.2527795434,
-0.0386918746,
0.4777478576,
-0.8435499668,
0.714223206,
0.0921641439,
-0.2796136141,
-0.4673961699,
-0.5477378368,
0.2901851237,
-0.2574497461,
0.3065600693,
-0.3353510201,
-0.4397530258,
0.048433423,
-0.3299117386,
-0.1411926895,
0.4468970895,
-0.4976162612,
0.7812136412,
0.4996262491,
-0.3193039596,
-0.5899332166,
-0.1518559754,
0.1403857768,
-0.3149458468,
-0.7403724194,
0.2318736762,
-0.3333854377,
-0.1822167933,
-0.0819454938,
0.1682115048,
-0.1499220878,
0.0799936503,
0.2844935954,
-0.1258254647,
-0.2600328624,
0.071516186,
0.3477063477,
-0.4088617861,
-0.2220265418,
-0.3147331476,
0.3292679489,
-0.3282397687,
-0.3827847242,
-0.1889817715,
0.1558648199,
0.5701793432,
-0.4545544684,
0.6244388223,
0.7145788074,
0.0510408133,
-0.2748294771,
-0.7552936077,
-0.0013989561,
-0.6342899203,
0.1856604964,
-0.7712189555,
-1.3916296959,
0.5292203426,
-0.3669012189,
0.1079161987,
0.1654866189,
0.9514128566,
-0.0271536075,
1.1092851162,
1.1424022913,
-0.1851954311,
0.6136817336,
-0.1940301359,
-0.1433413625,
-0.8085559011,
-0.2311232537,
-0.4957021177,
-0.3337473571,
-0.6153124571,
-0.5366584063,
0.2664313614,
-0.2128405869,
-0.5715649128,
-0.0367281623,
-0.4860718548,
0.9024940729,
0.6458872557,
-0.0519942977,
0.6128623486,
0.0454295501,
0.0549386442,
0.0964542329,
-0.6419857144,
-0.9735353589,
1.1704626083,
0.3758117855,
0.8193622231,
0.1194492057,
0.4673718512,
0.4716494977,
0.4179818928,
-0.7452912927,
0.4921020865,
-0.0807641074,
-0.5389299989,
-0.3191668391,
-0.3129684031,
-1.0981065035,
0.2990680933,
0.0504203141,
-0.6175606847,
0.154700309,
0.3205331862,
-0.0962781832,
0.2005818486,
-0.5335553885,
0.7990540266,
-0.0146640968,
-0.4196374416,
-0.2607656419,
-0.5096893907,
0.2346335053,
-0.3790341318,
0.0012753495,
-0.4276076853,
-0.7348816395,
0.3482236564,
-0.5542752743,
0.8981534839,
-0.146530211,
-0.0165127534,
-0.0115162199,
0.2132634372,
0.7031360865,
-0.0625626221,
-0.2766726315,
0.0097910669,
-0.2582315505,
-0.5877375007,
-0.4920283854,
0.8248856068,
-0.9743812084,
-0.6516135335,
-0.014763739,
-0.6462144256,
-0.3035373986,
0.13877289,
0.1536859721,
-0.001308918,
-0.319563657,
0.0785502046,
0.6253791451,
0.14000085,
0.115446873,
1.1132695675,
-0.0411639512,
-0.3505352139,
1.0833985806,
-0.2815161049,
0.058964666,
0.5981270671,
0.1004022732,
-0.1028090492,
-0.5570537448,
-0.248160094,
0.2123377323,
-0.5523036718,
-0.3873592615,
-0.6594992876,
0.096377708,
-0.1035704017,
-0.3290948272,
-0.4289481044,
-0.3796379566,
-0.4266900122,
-0.0177448951,
0.6214447021,
0.7920805812,
-0.0125121763,
0.6023634076,
-0.5250205994,
0.2716625631,
0.5216231942,
0.5414257646,
-0.4083729386,
-0.6634094119,
-0.6223769188,
-0.0716249794,
-0.4675541222,
-0.3424744308,
0.3579701781,
0.7109155655,
0.5715161562,
0.7099280357,
-0.0426972955,
0.5202054977,
-0.5920665264,
0.4313220382,
-0.3952739239,
-0.9988151789,
0.6110845208,
-0.6667149067,
0.162187323,
0.692625463,
0.3985779583,
-0.2819568515,
-0.6014101505,
-0.2359136939,
-0.5816568732,
0.6461914778,
0.1251331419,
0.2029510587,
0.2281048596,
0.4472228289,
0.4402142167,
0.496538043,
-0.3270881176,
-0.1593308151,
-0.1533433646,
-0.2606363893,
-0.2937807739,
0.0031229903,
-0.2083430439,
-0.1853946,
0.5667426586,
-0.5510290265,
-0.0859999955,
-0.1114357635,
-0.1346677989,
-0.2708828151,
0.279181093,
0.3634857535,
0.7894172072,
-0.1974944174,
-0.0719801337,
0.0670042858,
-0.5369743705,
0.0937495381,
0.2045200467,
-0.2157871574,
-0.37421453,
0.2460963428,
0.7219493985,
0.1492027491,
-0.6833631396,
0.3279384077,
-0.1210606247,
-0.3104580939,
-0.1984597743,
0.5024123192,
0.10943304,
0.3899948895,
0.1964683682,
0.1058116034,
0.2173449397,
-0.0974562541,
0.1156114936,
0.3599956632,
-0.4220913351,
-0.5614092946,
0.7542408705,
0.4143593013,
-0.4004694819,
0.3727588654,
-0.2581281066,
-0.2581505775,
0.3132090271,
0.1896500736,
1.0493876934,
-0.3784044385,
0.3176305592,
-0.1589008123,
0.2204356939,
0.2098318785,
0.171959877,
-0.1735277474,
-0.6578565836,
-0.5632317662,
-0.534761548,
-0.6755298376,
0.0431536436,
-0.440828383,
0.268981576,
-0.4566189945,
-0.2426146418,
-0.0960230157,
0.1671356559,
-0.7777220011,
-0.2719711363,
-0.1642671078,
0.8308745027,
-0.5316150784,
1.1117273569,
0.9677887559,
-0.2918585539,
-0.4725153148,
-0.1637297422,
-0.0964973718,
-0.7913550138,
0.399353236,
-0.1369275153,
-0.5142989755,
0.189452067,
-0.5339392424,
-0.8593370914,
1.3231196404,
0.7252407074,
-0.5986623168,
0.1095888838,
0.2592989504,
0.8030279875,
-0.691231668,
0.170309037,
0.7140817642,
0.5694894791,
0.0100964997,
-0.9974650741,
-0.1256862879,
-0.332392931,
-0.1322001219,
0.0230076909,
-0.9081836939,
0.8519984484,
-0.2860122323,
0.0120290602,
0.1163733527,
0.4390340149,
-0.0099610584,
0.4839735031,
0.4061926007,
0.4074200392,
1.1697378159,
0.1191803738,
0.9566906691,
-0.6090794802,
0.2249166369,
1.1968735456,
-0.3577191234,
0.7099638581,
0.0749606788,
-0.0646809191,
0.6737630367,
0.5122851133,
-0.0021041059,
0.6312080622,
0.0288964119,
-0.4091995955,
-0.4283635616,
-0.0772332996,
-0.2145247757,
0.4520426095,
0.3842110932,
-0.0410417579,
0.0578930192,
-0.1008880436,
0.0181849636,
0.1920322925,
-0.4223229885,
1.0238643885,
-0.10399203,
-0.3472632468,
0.3053924441,
0.0665367246,
0.7766744494,
-0.7804611921,
0.0050000637,
-0.3212563694,
0.3586022854,
-0.254463017,
-0.5420196652,
0.1165966243,
0.0606757402,
-0.3127374351,
-0.2268662006,
0.9452716708,
-0.4536355138,
-0.215191856,
0.1531131268,
0.8002596498,
0.227549836,
-0.3935579956,
-0.7269629836,
-0.1343366951,
-0.2252088785,
-0.4555252492,
0.4644464254,
0.7258038521,
0.0791197121,
1.3079490662,
0.7088995576,
0.0278145913,
-0.0134752691,
0.1848692745,
1.1946854591,
-0.6215742826,
-0.4467025697,
-0.466053158,
0.5200632215,
-0.0183976758,
-0.344252497,
0.7217362523,
0.7643957138,
0.6801950932,
-0.346791774,
0.8516913056,
0.1848841906,
0.7717807889,
-0.2749972641,
0.7762180567,
-0.4412581623,
0.4621542394,
0.0185163002,
-0.8566989899,
-0.0107064247,
0.4057523906,
-0.3353959322,
0.2751480341,
0.2930591106,
1.158954978,
-0.3344430625,
-0.451770395,
0.4957122207,
0.0968362242,
0.3106645048,
0.3536875248,
0.9930154085,
0.1096931994,
0.6332542896,
-0.0768428296,
-0.3264181614,
-0.4161664248,
-0.7370371819,
-1.3040677309,
-0.515820086,
-0.4070449173,
0.204230085,
0.2661011219,
0.955246985,
0.98927176,
-0.748996079,
-0.2593161464,
0.0942521244,
0.2280682623,
-0.1044044346,
-0.1811957806,
0.1955180168,
-0.6067403555,
-0.8769090176,
0.4624317288,
0.2891109288,
-0.1839916706,
-0.2229525298,
-0.3514267802,
0.4242089689,
0.1058818474,
0.5561585426,
0.3408437073,
-0.6244693995,
-0.0689556748,
0.0520505682,
-0.1826478392,
0.0706589743,
0.9728513956,
-0.8358148336,
0.3754632473,
0.163732782,
0.5124964714,
0.5426698923,
0.0588960685,
0.7049279213,
-0.7584949732,
0.0018707885,
0.1410011649,
-0.0460280441,
0.3560192585,
-0.4823818207,
0.5992246866,
-0.162285313,
-0.9606350064,
-0.4608147144,
-0.0080758696,
-1.0363847017,
0.0446592048,
0.9284827709,
-0.1367242783,
0.0747849569,
-0.4852234721,
-0.4369567633,
-0.1390870661,
-0.8445119858,
0.8571327925,
0.438036561,
-0.2705664635,
-0.0380484536,
-0.7128981948,
0.7229590416,
-0.0180936586,
-0.9162139893,
-0.0195781533,
0.4112145603,
0.571005702,
-0.153273046,
0.8829817176,
0.3080710471,
0.1227701083,
-0.1128692701,
0.0884047002,
-0.5200148821,
-0.2430527061,
-0.2804122865,
0.2053605318,
0.4034802914,
-0.1653414071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03114v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03114v1
|
Testing the Effect of Code Documentation on Large Language Model Code Understanding
| 2024-04-03T23:33:56 | 2024-04-03T23:33:56 |
William Macke, Michael Doyle
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive abilities in recent
years with regards to code generation and understanding. However, little work
has investigated how documentation and other code properties affect an LLM's
ability to understand and generate code or documentation. We present an
empirical analysis of how underlying properties of code or documentation can
affect an LLM's capabilities. We show that providing an LLM with "incorrect"
documentation can greatly hinder code understanding, while incomplete or
missing documentation does not seem to significantly affect an LLM's ability to
understand code.
|
[
-0.3139838874,
-0.7783523202,
0.7125751376,
0.346868664,
-0.065864861,
0.0555893704,
-0.3672493696,
-0.7617340088,
0.0552120283,
0.6575859189,
-0.2498846203,
-0.3722681403,
-0.6600646377,
0.0182224996,
-0.4752611518,
0.9919638038,
-0.0940915048,
0.1074907631,
-0.5241289735,
-0.0704083741,
-0.4844627678,
-0.6434901357,
-0.4404656887,
-0.5894106627,
0.5863283873,
0.4915831685,
0.7713418007,
0.5901404619,
0.5541396141,
0.2552311122,
-0.3335703611,
-0.2942603528,
-0.748824656,
0.0502745472,
0.0881747156,
-0.9268818498,
-0.560890913,
-0.2335309833,
0.8509477973,
0.8084086776,
0.1045071259,
0.3184959292,
0.0103979828,
0.5230295062,
-0.3964095116,
0.3577772081,
-0.691062808,
-0.0869455785,
-0.0638459846,
-0.4409171045,
-0.504753232,
-0.0573219508,
-0.0329299718,
-0.3827617764,
0.3190373182,
0.1069296598,
0.7729645967,
0.1057449356,
-0.6087688804,
-0.7244388461,
-0.7920287848,
0.5996416807,
-0.7430989146,
0.2874236405,
0.5441706777,
0.1511810422,
-0.197384432,
-0.6690836549,
-0.4729653299,
-0.7570935488,
-0.1357412338,
0.0315850601,
0.0007525663,
0.2231691182,
0.7421374917,
0.5883827806,
-0.6346181035,
0.3903398812,
-0.7368463278,
-0.1290901452,
0.5469041467,
0.2715948224,
0.5335967541,
-0.2372738719,
-0.0537234768,
-0.0102657685,
-1.0198390484,
-0.0458281972,
0.5004752874,
-0.0780612677,
-0.0059748311,
0.8945307732,
0.2029882818,
0.6955756545,
-0.3850437403,
-0.277395457,
0.1399010718,
-0.3271844685,
-0.379642576,
-0.0136818485,
0.2638301551,
0.1966351569,
0.2371023595,
-0.1977034807,
-0.4606539011,
-0.0585886165,
0.2418211848,
-0.8361494541,
-0.0271576289,
0.2184097022,
-0.7433351874,
-0.0975237712,
0.0870853439,
-0.3176833987,
-0.6658906341,
-0.4554778337,
0.2653563917,
-0.2965824306,
-0.2677679658,
0.0231847037,
-0.4004113972,
0.5361514688,
0.2667371631,
-0.9116054773,
0.1921932995,
0.7830646038,
0.6082726121,
0.1433830857,
-0.5090644956,
-0.4875371158,
-0.0535509586,
-0.4276705682,
0.5667208433,
-0.5057386756,
-0.5319007039,
0.0797348619,
0.0240997095,
0.0638008863,
-0.7372019887,
0.0931449533,
-0.6670359969,
-0.2488999963,
-0.1732285917,
-0.7065021396,
-0.2229878902,
0.0452423692,
-0.7144078016,
0.5108348131,
0.3279343843,
-0.5800918937,
0.4217414856,
-0.5445040464,
-0.5042702556,
-0.0739549175,
-0.2806012034,
-0.2277761251,
0.4829697311,
-0.2095396221,
0.3754750788,
-0.0886466354,
0.2188696116,
-0.4140324295,
-0.6670541763,
0.7094929814,
-0.3669161797,
0.757641077,
0.235910356,
-0.2409246862,
0.0462496839,
-0.9157652855,
-0.3252108395,
0.240411669,
-0.5388438106,
-0.2209837437,
0.156540364,
0.0453310683,
0.1657497138,
0.2336097956,
-0.0951126069,
0.4072180986,
-0.2870077789,
0.2661568224,
0.6624257565,
0.2060995698,
0.6091026664,
-0.3210831285,
1.0418761969,
-0.192038238,
0.0146224666,
-0.5407318473,
-0.3889980316,
-0.8684819937,
0.1002279446,
0.165370971,
0.3315913379,
-0.5702065229,
-0.0449506752,
-0.085128054,
-0.1706818789,
-0.2492757887,
0.5622406006,
0.7156123519,
0.0649954528,
-0.0631975234,
-0.2277484387,
-0.5862122178,
-0.8216027021,
-0.2391116768,
-0.3580461442,
-0.117179215,
0.3858206868,
0.7482660413,
-0.4336591065,
0.6227930188,
-0.567242682,
0.0557248928,
-0.4735703468,
0.2094894946,
0.1868904084,
0.2911706269,
0.6520587802,
-0.5922657847,
-0.0655218735,
-0.125721544,
-0.5518304706,
-0.2713325024,
-0.1853135377,
0.1821264774,
0.4394676983,
0.6400195956,
-0.4722085297,
0.5233281255,
0.7520223856,
-0.3884744048,
0.6948820949,
-0.6554314494,
-0.0020350937,
-0.7198354602,
0.0961297378,
-0.0538177565,
-0.0985970125,
-0.4731062949,
0.382470876,
0.4062457085,
-0.1983352005,
-0.3040867746,
0.4777076542,
-0.7310160995,
-0.6647897363,
-0.3311148286,
0.0858744383,
0.1894847751,
0.0404014848,
-0.0113553265,
1.0036908388,
0.3228340745,
-0.6453432441,
0.113985233,
0.0134702921,
-0.5775221586,
0.2861564755,
-0.5676323175,
0.2001171708,
-0.100919947,
0.1648097336,
-0.9931686521,
-0.3975025415,
-0.2165822238,
-0.5187826157,
0.5071507692,
-0.2748680115,
-0.7997364998,
-0.4842847288,
-0.1630199403,
0.12630862,
0.6907820106,
-0.4198657572,
0.5422540903,
0.1770332307,
0.0014854514,
-0.3361250162,
-0.8228555918,
0.0685630962,
-0.2418099493,
-0.803058207,
-0.068493247,
-0.239509359,
-0.8158657551,
-0.2104695886,
-0.0964248106,
-0.3336105943,
0.5153272152,
0.5152444839,
0.2151139528,
-0.4484207034,
0.4150465429,
-0.1916967779,
0.1088528261,
0.5342690945,
-0.0626530275,
0.4598280191,
-0.1761611849,
-0.5785626173,
-0.1234281436,
0.0721289888,
0.7502797842,
-0.2971663177,
0.9944378734,
0.2571243942,
-0.0770986378,
-0.3721245527,
-0.562415719,
-0.090841338,
-0.4966568053,
0.5560470223,
-0.3290298879,
-0.9439709187,
1.0159615278,
0.1872717589,
-0.0963284373,
0.4379493594,
0.5302481651,
-0.0500115417,
0.9809101224,
0.8818682432,
-0.0712333396,
0.4812954366,
-0.2023974955,
0.2895996571,
-0.7575923204,
-0.3051789999,
-0.8189650178,
-0.0111793755,
-0.5038642883,
-0.3212164938,
-0.0229998082,
0.2472136915,
-0.0724453554,
0.0248492416,
-0.1002691239,
0.5761007667,
0.3460211754,
0.0952609107,
0.5269795656,
-0.2754074633,
0.1695159078,
0.2592794001,
-0.6662647128,
-0.6139485836,
1.2132122517,
0.6840923429,
1.1504542828,
0.1751796454,
0.4848164022,
0.2316873074,
0.3306289017,
-0.7582810521,
0.3125599027,
0.2632679939,
-0.630756557,
-0.0516948402,
-0.4764771461,
-0.8625091314,
-0.0316918194,
0.0517985784,
-0.5730341077,
0.0493996777,
0.2696288526,
-0.071985893,
0.0038904916,
-1.0966792107,
0.731082499,
-0.4427702129,
-0.0163509659,
-0.2954835594,
-0.1684097052,
0.633795619,
-0.4052858055,
0.3149691522,
0.0904372707,
-0.0876045376,
0.5786187649,
-0.2720387876,
0.9108144641,
-0.0283523351,
-0.4456234872,
0.2205045521,
0.2734248638,
0.5183485746,
0.2772041261,
-0.2174625099,
0.0281614698,
-0.1864283383,
-0.4055409431,
-0.7196953893,
0.7904344797,
-0.6040377021,
-0.8694046736,
-0.065944016,
-0.8513677716,
0.0210508276,
-0.0785863101,
0.0551907159,
0.4173926413,
-0.1281731576,
0.1151603982,
0.8468183279,
-0.7254772782,
0.2883935273,
0.8109932542,
-0.7004805803,
0.1876303107,
0.7392343879,
0.3516503572,
0.5424342155,
-0.0209028106,
0.0548056327,
-0.2197130919,
-0.8681573868,
-0.2150271833,
0.2280790359,
-1.1686495543,
0.1685890853,
-0.3613182008,
-0.1980614066,
-0.3359010518,
-0.1918407679,
0.0147229545,
-0.2363576144,
-0.5210841894,
-0.2083468288,
0.41536358,
1.4137711525,
0.3000890315,
0.3117292523,
-0.8879009485,
0.2350685745,
0.2414342463,
0.5062382817,
0.080643408,
-0.7869799733,
-0.4333030879,
-0.1999641359,
-0.0711808801,
-0.7783210278,
0.0697425902,
-0.1194889024,
0.6772820354,
0.5784140229,
-0.3089230061,
0.6311077476,
-0.3934136331,
0.872841537,
0.0140881557,
-1.1743296385,
0.5253135562,
-0.5042288899,
0.5508990288,
0.2636485994,
0.0840471834,
-0.3093243539,
-0.8356903195,
-0.6444933414,
-0.5529179573,
0.5786805153,
0.1590389311,
0.3631076217,
-0.0255816318,
0.5766784549,
-0.011242318,
0.1040977463,
-0.8301938176,
-0.2247016877,
0.1765769422,
0.2420700639,
-0.2667803764,
-0.6970068216,
0.1068426147,
-0.1644075662,
0.3549752533,
0.1035951152,
0.1242051199,
-0.0269645508,
-0.2813678384,
-0.1404878497,
0.3442428708,
1.0352671146,
1.4698894024,
-0.2470632344,
0.1787673384,
0.2343237996,
-0.3325296044,
-0.1894797385,
-0.0513817482,
0.1436300129,
-0.0019372333,
0.8180349469,
0.5847250819,
0.2091216594,
-0.9355712533,
0.5287946463,
-0.0160907228,
-0.5263081193,
-0.3961218894,
0.380274564,
0.4095547199,
0.2448141873,
0.364700973,
-0.3033160865,
-0.0743126795,
-0.7490909696,
0.0732761845,
0.3957869411,
-0.1420654356,
-0.1086381599,
0.3988249004,
0.0355356969,
-0.489621073,
0.6818034053,
-0.1538986564,
-0.5673565865,
1.2282320261,
0.8661209941,
0.4232542813,
-0.0569481887,
-0.076598376,
-0.092874147,
0.6916428208,
0.0563745871,
0.2451205105,
0.1084917337,
-0.4786000252,
-0.8357624412,
-0.4007022083,
-0.5014904141,
0.2214288265,
-0.6682751179,
0.1029380783,
-0.4281601012,
0.1657230407,
-0.1777447015,
0.0500576422,
-0.7361447811,
0.1818416268,
0.3031466901,
1.2132751942,
-0.7630521655,
0.9196084738,
0.5645560026,
-0.6823152304,
-1.0611045361,
0.0893455967,
-0.1743279397,
-0.8895272017,
0.9425902963,
0.1512630582,
-0.0527720451,
-0.0873532817,
-0.574439764,
-0.7539612055,
1.1406266689,
0.4717367291,
-0.6660932302,
0.2405370027,
0.1982429475,
0.7198274136,
-0.1654278934,
0.424896419,
0.580031991,
0.5258738995,
-0.0943249688,
-1.1070063114,
-0.0519836508,
-0.1120900214,
0.2600882947,
0.131841749,
-0.4050931334,
0.7852451205,
-0.369758755,
-0.0877839476,
-0.003062479,
0.4413632154,
0.1906801164,
0.413339287,
0.2258270532,
0.4164779782,
0.9923455715,
0.1651341617,
1.5142781734,
-0.3506373167,
0.3453044295,
1.0258779526,
-0.3751965463,
0.727401793,
0.376645267,
-0.0704101995,
0.4556533694,
0.5262559056,
-0.0696692765,
-0.0941279158,
0.6285908818,
-0.1628704071,
-0.0276190098,
0.0398544557,
-0.6305413842,
0.5128842592,
0.3040881455,
-0.9171711802,
0.0823302492,
0.0747300237,
-0.0438531302,
-0.0200838726,
-0.538880527,
0.6065142155,
0.2904313207,
-0.5639304519,
0.7280538678,
0.028180059,
0.3017990887,
-0.5684611797,
-0.1464283019,
-0.4212387204,
0.0049474863,
-0.3742006123,
-0.9644021988,
0.4390247762,
0.1607917547,
-0.2680628896,
-0.226282686,
0.9443881512,
-0.1228603125,
-0.3665902615,
0.5254801512,
0.6211963296,
0.3023796082,
-0.1239310279,
-0.4270856082,
0.3906481564,
-0.0497017764,
-0.4053319395,
0.5003162622,
0.5058490038,
0.2233747989,
0.747672081,
0.5779197812,
-0.0078104879,
-0.0109775886,
0.3611555398,
0.9803448319,
-0.6783959866,
-0.287959516,
-0.9716207981,
0.2844748795,
0.0525490493,
-0.1128683835,
0.9901562929,
0.6841514111,
0.8185636401,
-0.1412547976,
0.7399657369,
0.0922997221,
-0.0909436122,
-0.7966479063,
0.8257195354,
-0.5590435863,
0.6596480012,
-0.0740417466,
-1.0972059965,
-0.3387778699,
0.353005439,
-0.5257231593,
-0.0162426401,
0.8069084287,
0.9149922729,
0.0336849429,
-0.0759395808,
0.5097202063,
0.4552314281,
0.2345562279,
0.5480414033,
1.2454042435,
0.0205112286,
0.7261927724,
0.0462696068,
-0.0180432647,
-0.2320224494,
-0.8686705232,
-1.2244666815,
-0.2351543605,
-0.0231239647,
-0.564630568,
-0.025367165,
0.459661305,
0.3948374093,
-0.4473944306,
-0.254765749,
-0.2576479912,
0.5188187361,
0.1250195652,
-0.1935269088,
0.1896280497,
-0.4591677785,
-0.5371540785,
0.2404767573,
0.3188965619,
0.0511079058,
-0.5721003413,
-0.3184206188,
0.2242849171,
-0.0170075279,
0.5918852091,
0.1496207863,
-0.6543219686,
-0.1397225112,
-0.0191168636,
-0.2746250331,
0.1527217329,
1.0503429174,
-0.4271470904,
0.3761982322,
0.5873056054,
0.6157665849,
0.3764469624,
-0.2880519629,
0.6594788432,
-0.4307972789,
0.0313981064,
-0.0176886562,
0.5583925843,
-0.0746632814,
-0.6307033896,
0.34797135,
0.0001970851,
-0.8046629429,
-0.631595552,
0.0906361938,
-0.8145162463,
-0.5806164145,
1.5721259117,
-0.1964338124,
-0.2544331849,
-0.3598860204,
-0.2766296864,
0.0009847009,
-0.0937364027,
0.6076299548,
0.8355274796,
0.0445386805,
-0.2657663524,
-1.0424457788,
0.1197104082,
0.3133506179,
-0.7854986191,
0.0447323434,
0.6781487465,
0.4483620226,
-0.1039861217,
0.7157006264,
0.0003293052,
0.394539088,
0.0573136918,
0.0030341225,
-0.2087598145,
-0.1460586786,
-0.6912116408,
0.0933329463,
0.8352974057,
0.3572342992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03098v1
|
Exploring the Trade-off Between Model Performance and Explanation Plausibility of Text Classifiers Using Human Rationales
| 2024-04-03T22:39:33 | 2024-04-03T22:39:33 |
Lucas E. Resck, Marcos M. Raimundo, Jorge Poco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Saliency post-hoc explainability methods are important tools for
understanding increasingly complex NLP models. While these methods can reflect
the model's reasoning, they may not align with human intuition, making the
explanations not plausible. In this work, we present a methodology for
incorporating rationales, which are text annotations explaining human
decisions, into text classification models. This incorporation enhances the
plausibility of post-hoc explanations while preserving their faithfulness. Our
approach is agnostic to model architectures and explainability methods. We
introduce the rationales during model training by augmenting the standard
cross-entropy loss with a novel loss function inspired by contrastive learning.
By leveraging a multi-objective optimization algorithm, we explore the
trade-off between the two loss functions and generate a Pareto-optimal frontier
of models that balance performance and plausibility. Through extensive
experiments involving diverse models, datasets, and explainability methods, we
demonstrate that our approach significantly enhances the quality of model
explanations without causing substantial (sometimes negligible) degradation in
the original model's performance.
|
[
-0.4782689512,
-0.2133983225,
0.7957991362,
-0.1396160275,
-0.3949910998,
-0.4425410032,
-0.3168113232,
-0.281835556,
-0.2338686138,
0.3357577622,
-0.5453910828,
-0.2725942135,
-0.4089912176,
0.0527019687,
-0.2341843843,
1.1684145927,
-0.1904474944,
-0.1465467513,
-0.501778543,
-0.1410463601,
-0.2747891247,
-0.6738272309,
-0.6134258509,
-0.4262238145,
0.6123917699,
0.152269572,
0.7406951785,
0.7343808413,
0.4585746825,
0.2512986064,
0.0296135694,
-0.0151973348,
-0.2038827389,
-0.1686374843,
-0.4791488349,
-0.6192831397,
-0.0861043483,
0.1342100501,
0.4013414979,
0.7928346992,
0.0034212929,
-0.0357205719,
0.2508394122,
0.5306426287,
-0.7969197631,
0.0173680149,
-0.6692162156,
0.0968131945,
0.0622469448,
-0.5483747125,
-0.6133871078,
-0.1851063669,
0.7204051018,
-0.8298322558,
0.4828270972,
0.0613358468,
0.9587925673,
0.5137071609,
-0.0213245507,
-0.2997812033,
-0.5505478978,
1.0588356256,
-0.5803684592,
0.3079145551,
0.4825308025,
0.3459436595,
0.2138585299,
-0.6394020319,
-0.4678635895,
-0.0285420343,
-0.3782346249,
0.1168627813,
-0.0743505955,
0.1416211873,
0.2353353798,
0.3402568996,
-0.5045233965,
-0.1633034497,
-0.0640755072,
-0.1601566225,
0.6463674307,
-0.125065133,
0.2563884258,
0.0127693536,
-0.6053856611,
-0.0497532263,
-0.1267372668,
0.3937795758,
0.2037262321,
-0.0392111987,
0.03786036,
0.3219516575,
-0.0715363249,
0.5629349947,
-0.1631448418,
-0.0970687419,
-0.0993260071,
-0.2442241013,
-0.3189086616,
0.1080708578,
0.3532838225,
0.6295785904,
0.0907601714,
-0.4056233168,
-0.0526105911,
0.3989534676,
0.2827683389,
-0.7989499569,
-0.2838147879,
0.1369357854,
-0.864166379,
-0.4813104272,
-0.0621597022,
-0.7799776196,
-0.2811951041,
-0.5202830434,
0.5914000273,
-0.4945636392,
-0.1297067851,
0.3892994225,
-0.4856239855,
0.1236605346,
0.5559293628,
-0.9796907902,
0.2806153297,
0.4457826614,
0.771928668,
-0.1021260172,
-0.3936173022,
-0.1989914179,
0.156590417,
-0.1999771446,
0.817782402,
-0.5557488203,
-0.0597887412,
-0.2574809194,
-0.1948853433,
-0.3120276332,
-0.3130823374,
0.9347406626,
-0.4399679899,
0.4772178829,
-0.3411242366,
-0.5363001227,
-0.7211043239,
0.0632270053,
-0.4643979371,
0.8219274282,
-0.164146781,
-1.1853864193,
0.4110417664,
-0.7880276442,
-0.3633100688,
-0.1732548922,
0.2043388784,
-0.4701173007,
0.2827143967,
0.1232230738,
0.5241650343,
-0.4266353548,
0.3481707573,
-0.2763421535,
-0.4309550822,
0.5448060036,
-0.5498605967,
0.7437659502,
0.1625688523,
-0.4325595796,
0.3049752116,
-0.6774784923,
-0.1797853112,
0.0972919539,
-0.307374835,
-0.6155289412,
0.2131964564,
-0.1282326728,
0.2705210149,
-0.1014956236,
-0.065440543,
-0.2964103222,
-0.395594269,
0.6942773461,
0.5430710316,
-0.3090976179,
0.7065780163,
-0.6354663372,
0.4257729053,
-0.1948927492,
0.1831812263,
-0.4006448388,
-0.4274920523,
-0.7525646091,
-0.4472806454,
0.2485605031,
0.4855231941,
-0.6068968773,
0.2868558168,
-0.0207629707,
-0.3107627034,
-0.495536238,
-0.1920788139,
0.3532896042,
0.8896412849,
0.4999934435,
-0.1365622729,
-0.4940944016,
-1.0050426722,
-0.7039892077,
-0.1217863858,
-0.3356702328,
0.2621208429,
0.4628840089,
-0.2357730716,
0.9454421401,
-0.2960944772,
0.3166997731,
-0.2306979299,
0.3861739039,
-0.1276250929,
0.4092602432,
0.5146515369,
-1.0083364248,
0.1310453415,
-0.1186181679,
-0.6737163663,
-0.2339252681,
-0.5914573669,
-0.4301086962,
0.1288063079,
0.2691823542,
-0.506198585,
0.6574539542,
0.2108267993,
-0.3190954924,
0.6342057586,
-0.1194622964,
0.1078802794,
-0.6162285209,
0.0987810418,
0.3100543022,
-0.1341372281,
-0.5932484865,
-0.1256684959,
-0.1973974109,
-0.0349009186,
-0.1857062876,
0.6323239803,
-0.1715897024,
-0.2309681177,
-0.2904161811,
0.1641093791,
0.4521428943,
0.5669333935,
0.3454633951,
0.4780023992,
0.5598992705,
-0.7460882664,
-0.1414508075,
0.1566483378,
-0.1141811758,
0.6085879803,
-0.7012370229,
-0.4204797745,
-0.3898534477,
0.199998036,
-0.9888053536,
-0.4360275865,
0.3800182343,
-0.5269995928,
-0.0135725895,
-0.0518846363,
-0.0343571566,
-0.0838110596,
-0.5460554957,
0.2141408473,
0.5188424587,
-0.8533748984,
0.8063237071,
0.0481100492,
-0.2984023094,
-0.3782092035,
-0.663471818,
-0.0462657101,
-0.6607580185,
-0.6661542654,
0.682387054,
-0.1661413461,
-0.400106132,
-0.0485421643,
-0.1848206967,
-0.3000439405,
0.5817778707,
0.1047470719,
0.4473600686,
-0.1583611071,
0.3669092059,
0.2059071511,
-0.26034531,
0.2685670853,
-0.1368682534,
0.1688690782,
-0.1481560916,
-0.0499973297,
-1.0647615194,
0.2130293548,
0.3981452286,
-0.1656791866,
0.7515488267,
0.5146903992,
-0.3182234466,
-0.2819072008,
-0.4151576459,
-0.3049637079,
-0.3823381662,
0.2270009518,
-0.3910447955,
-0.5474119782,
0.4951118231,
-0.1719384342,
0.0125418678,
0.6829930544,
0.3548281789,
-0.1106763184,
1.0538668633,
0.3420835435,
0.6129867435,
0.555914402,
0.0521187708,
0.0902396515,
-0.6768954396,
-0.3961451352,
-0.5426216125,
-0.1684194803,
-0.3477396369,
-0.4001497924,
-0.0922624692,
0.4621355534,
-0.130766362,
-0.0297414027,
-0.7357338667,
0.6277040839,
0.6996098757,
0.207217142,
0.2109843791,
0.0704436377,
0.1538145691,
-0.1620028466,
-0.874770999,
-0.8002452254,
0.7329750657,
0.5144600272,
0.4857707024,
-0.1615410447,
0.4897140265,
-0.0199268963,
0.4747266173,
-0.7562248111,
0.3025533855,
-0.0310930088,
-0.4129699171,
-0.3764023781,
-0.5407359004,
-0.5986770391,
0.641364634,
-0.4439833462,
-0.4842827916,
0.259527117,
0.4448677599,
-0.363416791,
0.2074697316,
-0.9433328509,
1.251837492,
-0.3947715461,
-0.5016434789,
-0.1306586415,
-0.7577276826,
0.6166481376,
0.0243165046,
0.3787439167,
0.1031499282,
-0.071978882,
0.9182180166,
-0.4658675492,
0.717720747,
-0.0566071309,
0.2167821825,
-0.0347048901,
-0.0884986967,
0.204379186,
0.0113385245,
-0.2440367043,
0.2092148364,
-0.1650446653,
-0.5136045218,
-0.6431317925,
0.3614004254,
-0.6441432238,
-0.4648627937,
-0.292291075,
-0.5463778377,
-0.0364601053,
0.0728391483,
0.387159735,
0.3304385245,
0.1361755878,
0.1485537738,
0.7408211231,
-0.4059383869,
0.4739249647,
-0.0403709486,
0.2184874266,
-0.3667320013,
0.888672471,
-0.1131640598,
0.1416459978,
0.3383584917,
0.6154675484,
-0.453165859,
-0.7305914164,
-0.2997592986,
0.0742212534,
-0.8133117557,
0.1348878443,
-0.5911373496,
0.1201360896,
-0.0234695766,
-0.7919944525,
0.0435986109,
-0.4864053726,
-0.5255712271,
-0.0328733027,
0.1033258364,
0.2768501639,
0.0440176129,
0.4747217894,
-0.508908987,
0.2724535167,
0.4797511995,
0.3865101039,
0.2751376331,
-0.8104364872,
-0.1342780292,
0.0206480697,
-0.1716829985,
-0.8722270131,
0.3144584298,
0.1983097345,
0.7759187818,
0.565641284,
0.3589285016,
0.4373243153,
-0.2186313868,
0.4641209245,
0.3556310833,
-1.4767593145,
0.5730699301,
-0.1642470658,
-0.027713839,
0.5548466444,
0.58441782,
-0.1838036329,
-0.0892216414,
-0.5280504227,
-0.8520146012,
1.0429013968,
0.4620583653,
-0.278670013,
0.3382280767,
0.6097093225,
0.3791999519,
0.1987657994,
-0.8355602026,
-0.0333996229,
-0.6566544771,
-0.3048245907,
0.0367167778,
-0.3873508871,
-0.1715005934,
-0.0158594642,
0.7681795359,
-0.0859971493,
-0.0623415634,
0.3683408797,
-0.2840722799,
0.3188838959,
0.3681832552,
0.752440393,
0.8468955755,
-0.2613433301,
0.484821856,
0.0762439594,
-0.0154457735,
-0.1463935673,
0.3693992794,
-0.249078691,
0.1397461146,
0.6280423403,
1.0226041079,
0.3578475714,
-0.7124463916,
0.4623616934,
-0.2171851844,
-0.2782924473,
0.216972962,
-0.0067864242,
0.0199918598,
0.2317928076,
0.2898464501,
0.4670565724,
0.4886258841,
-0.3569578826,
0.1071755588,
0.3470478356,
-0.1431693286,
-0.3333281577,
0.9068608284,
0.225497067,
-0.179997772,
-0.0818916187,
-0.0845695511,
-0.6542909741,
0.5961803794,
0.2149098217,
0.8449330926,
-0.2347801179,
0.4926298261,
0.2745808363,
0.2762633562,
-0.3605130017,
-0.15941903,
-0.3625444174,
-0.6046893597,
-0.4309289455,
-0.5983365178,
-0.5258923769,
-0.1794865429,
-0.8177482486,
0.1968040615,
-0.3343143761,
-0.0630179644,
0.6335700154,
-0.3879644871,
-0.4026100338,
0.3542691767,
0.1288792491,
0.6896377802,
-0.9817175865,
0.2452302575,
0.5334033966,
-0.5242511034,
-0.4456315637,
0.3266525865,
-0.3201625943,
-0.5826541781,
0.5854805112,
0.4659555554,
-0.2032601535,
-0.3186867237,
-0.4229221344,
-0.4998689294,
0.8490693569,
0.6118205786,
-0.3557001054,
-0.0549792945,
-0.2905758619,
0.5041290522,
-0.3277427852,
0.2774558961,
0.3926440179,
0.5225686431,
0.2495580465,
-0.51559484,
0.1625699252,
0.0057094935,
0.262730509,
-0.1668981761,
-0.2684209645,
0.6671096683,
-0.38143906,
-0.2561698258,
-0.0985473543,
0.3035823405,
0.3361392319,
0.8589302897,
0.7058877349,
0.5020747781,
0.8466066718,
-0.1234035566,
1.3937608004,
-0.0617731139,
0.3172409236,
0.9392885566,
-0.0915951505,
0.6942750216,
0.4799760282,
-0.1211502254,
0.5496436954,
0.9409060478,
0.1904301196,
0.686661303,
0.2099297345,
-0.2206555158,
-0.6327542663,
-0.2425584644,
-0.17744717,
0.2993011475,
0.0456005372,
-0.6465069056,
-0.2289255261,
0.0396857411,
-0.0216859747,
0.1360292137,
-0.4078042805,
0.6794865131,
-0.2117083818,
-0.699860394,
0.5757693052,
0.0901838839,
0.6611970663,
-0.2501055002,
0.0216008089,
-0.0071083982,
0.1993326992,
-0.3118944466,
-0.4903154671,
0.510566771,
-0.1875890791,
-0.622230351,
-0.3235270381,
0.6600160599,
-0.4994911849,
-0.3506396711,
0.1258129925,
0.0457862392,
0.1854985505,
-0.1820933819,
-0.7147599459,
0.0617808066,
0.0520322844,
-0.1782924086,
0.2325139642,
0.6198621988,
0.0210601427,
0.5574484468,
0.6988377571,
-0.30564183,
-0.3476827741,
-0.2130792737,
0.7741817832,
-0.5112739801,
-0.6821206808,
-1.0608508587,
0.6340332031,
-0.1631961614,
-0.2124451995,
0.5984348655,
0.4803185165,
0.6897753477,
-0.0841165036,
1.0211305618,
0.5399298072,
0.5635114908,
-0.7217658758,
0.4883085191,
-0.6938440204,
0.4052067995,
-0.2176747024,
-0.5916166306,
-0.4929720461,
0.8419228196,
-0.5246929526,
-0.0461949408,
0.7262439132,
0.4001266956,
0.0601151697,
0.2118074596,
0.2815107703,
0.048433125,
-0.0438171215,
0.4558644593,
0.8877511621,
-0.194028005,
0.704423666,
-0.1831581742,
-0.4976319075,
-0.4956530929,
-0.887997508,
-1.1908553839,
-0.3527622223,
-0.5224839449,
-0.1498604566,
0.1259359121,
0.4844081998,
0.8422256112,
-0.6686050892,
0.2519367039,
-0.2389418632,
0.4887723327,
-0.1182932332,
-0.2752504349,
0.5065533519,
-0.4305290282,
-0.4895789921,
-0.0296066087,
0.3245847523,
0.1726721823,
0.0863115564,
-0.2078068256,
-0.0163675211,
0.3001107275,
0.7310333848,
0.1218218803,
-1.0498849154,
0.0063917469,
-0.1413240135,
0.2475208938,
-0.1369547993,
0.965895772,
-0.6542791128,
0.4596380591,
0.5134321451,
0.8917810321,
0.1662670225,
0.1942919344,
0.5474823713,
-0.4022439718,
0.1407381594,
0.193199411,
0.4165393412,
0.5257430077,
-0.276278317,
0.4568123221,
0.391410619,
-0.4844223261,
-0.9953024387,
0.0510128364,
-1.0159085989,
-0.7124278545,
0.7970284224,
-0.3494603336,
-0.1444638371,
-0.2348496169,
-0.3782642484,
0.1773722172,
-0.2897655368,
0.9161692262,
0.7707199454,
-0.3224771917,
-0.3676024079,
-0.4478177726,
0.761197269,
0.5666998625,
-1.1428464651,
0.2910803258,
0.4470528662,
0.0303166509,
0.2155678272,
0.2142470777,
0.1586288363,
0.4965426624,
0.014991275,
0.1874970645,
0.0749319345,
-0.3040808737,
-0.4930518568,
0.2093533576,
-0.1095627323,
-0.2099843919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03092v1
|
Unsupervised, Bottom-up Category Discovery for Symbol Grounding with a Curious Robot
| 2024-04-03T22:13:04 | 2024-04-03T22:13:04 |
Catherine Henry, Casey Kennington
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Towards addressing the Symbol Grounding Problem and motivated by early
childhood language development, we leverage a robot which has been equipped
with an approximate model of curiosity with particular focus on bottom-up
building of unsupervised categories grounded in the physical world. That is,
rather than starting with a top-down symbol (e.g., a word referring to an
object) and providing meaning through the application of predetermined samples,
the robot autonomously and gradually breaks up its exploration space into a
series of increasingly specific unlabeled categories at which point an external
expert may optionally provide a symbol association. We extend prior work by
using a robot that can observe the visual world, introducing a higher
dimensional sensory space, and using a more generalizable method of category
building. Our experiments show that the robot learns categories based on
actions and what it visually observes, and that those categories can be
symbolically grounded into.https://info.arxiv.org/help/prep#comments
|
[
-0.367872715,
-0.4218082428,
0.552474916,
-0.096362032,
-0.3474312425,
0.5450951457,
0.0703065544,
-0.3245899379,
0.4518956244,
0.3481238484,
-0.5850599408,
-0.4643981159,
-0.6990628839,
-0.2048184723,
-0.2433961332,
0.5324575901,
0.1970111728,
-0.3342914581,
-0.0985346064,
-0.0461873971,
-0.5629571676,
-0.7585541606,
-0.4864073396,
-0.3756685853,
0.4510776401,
0.5964797139,
0.6452286839,
0.6639993787,
0.5641500354,
0.2669779062,
-0.3057568669,
0.1659819037,
-0.2368620783,
0.0059594521,
-0.22826083,
-0.6026816964,
-0.320905149,
-0.1375666708,
0.3066824675,
1.1374726295,
0.049726896,
0.1496485323,
-0.3119410574,
0.940130055,
-0.6241543293,
0.4323613942,
-0.3455683291,
0.5329679847,
0.0702167153,
-0.3221157789,
-0.1642775834,
0.0177872423,
-0.2160340697,
-0.6231716871,
0.2530381978,
0.221974045,
0.8519083858,
0.4595106244,
-0.5654218197,
-0.221102193,
-0.7337485552,
0.7127454877,
0.1092019975,
0.7734158039,
0.6187282801,
0.0626591817,
-0.2192889005,
-0.7242922187,
-0.5790224671,
-0.5415216684,
-0.0041931975,
0.2219982892,
-0.4858088791,
-0.0910374597,
0.3659512997,
0.4270691574,
-0.3968321681,
-0.1045524403,
-0.4139957726,
-0.2275595069,
0.3118498325,
-0.0796511322,
0.7308536768,
-0.2162502557,
-0.3571850657,
-0.4008174241,
-0.8627397418,
0.4076324999,
0.1702029705,
0.422573626,
0.0479779206,
1.1590240002,
-0.4296291173,
0.3722201288,
0.2505595684,
0.3649083376,
0.3867759109,
-0.0852944404,
-0.1062770858,
-0.0156200621,
0.4130147994,
0.5387663245,
0.4304858446,
-0.2885047495,
-0.3653965294,
0.6197918057,
0.5320738554,
-0.4489847422,
-0.7950311899,
0.0783866048,
-0.511438489,
-0.2455411404,
-0.0152120432,
-0.3311889172,
-0.6967892647,
-0.3171797097,
0.4250326157,
-0.1514713168,
-0.274194926,
0.4123375118,
-0.1772904843,
-0.1396944672,
0.2967299521,
-0.8295248747,
0.2291072607,
0.2663319111,
0.6006678343,
0.1854317188,
-0.0067486968,
-0.5229301453,
0.1104941964,
-0.7283803821,
0.8698352575,
-0.7323726416,
-0.2964082956,
-0.1784249842,
0.2868694961,
0.3468851149,
-0.4203724861,
0.4001750052,
-0.4842113554,
0.4287282526,
-0.1664539874,
-0.2186697721,
-0.4115359187,
0.390735954,
-0.6995146871,
1.4156589508,
0.236869812,
-0.7548231483,
0.592112422,
-0.7233000994,
-0.3153732717,
0.3595290184,
-0.4419672191,
0.0356694795,
0.2662898004,
0.2807902396,
0.5323164463,
-0.0061530801,
0.2720067203,
-0.1816390008,
-0.162598297,
-0.0513219461,
0.1167560294,
0.6098863482,
0.0189354289,
-0.359184593,
0.4718854725,
-0.9192052484,
-0.0615321249,
0.3125476837,
0.1567270309,
-0.7295518517,
0.2866570652,
-0.1495501697,
0.2190595865,
0.3657149374,
-0.5139772296,
0.4231193364,
-0.4551915824,
0.062465433,
0.6396160722,
-0.0014851299,
0.5967401862,
-0.2160358727,
0.5277754664,
-0.0076404037,
0.0378531665,
-0.3432159424,
-0.5661578774,
-1.1903873682,
-0.118132107,
0.0385950208,
0.4422751665,
-0.8476349711,
0.9265924692,
0.0538419373,
-0.359179616,
-0.1805476397,
-0.0522660799,
0.3272997737,
0.4344179928,
0.4613083601,
-0.6547094584,
-0.6169074178,
-0.8638091087,
0.3287744224,
-0.3699271679,
-0.4179151058,
0.3509931862,
0.4939849079,
-0.4479617774,
0.8309774399,
-0.6477808952,
-0.502603054,
-0.1112119779,
0.1474496871,
0.3941919506,
0.519726336,
0.5220944881,
-0.8049184084,
0.0504617915,
0.3152855039,
-0.7445152402,
0.1528771073,
0.1492567062,
-0.2209207565,
-0.2557664514,
0.5228900909,
-0.775524497,
0.3984133601,
0.0371745415,
-0.5153705478,
-0.1141512245,
-0.2190143913,
-0.0355037265,
-0.9197482467,
0.0789459199,
-0.1056346372,
0.0722745657,
-0.7415166497,
0.3217348158,
0.0480469167,
0.0619758889,
-0.5200282335,
0.4608443081,
-0.5013590455,
-0.2206295729,
-0.4643188715,
0.0382093973,
-0.2602594793,
0.5849253535,
0.4483704269,
0.5180565715,
0.851331234,
-0.8538272977,
0.2248497754,
0.0652411729,
-0.1232659742,
-0.0348007455,
-0.5438390374,
0.195601657,
-0.1030639485,
-0.0248077698,
-1.0465531349,
-0.2529292405,
0.810236752,
-0.7077050805,
0.0298522357,
-0.076268144,
-0.8267219663,
-0.4791678488,
-0.1707377434,
0.3799871504,
0.7372714281,
-0.7814933062,
0.4723471403,
0.8169111609,
0.145046711,
-0.5096301436,
-0.2942769229,
0.0611688234,
-0.2876747847,
-0.293905884,
-0.1377318203,
-0.2086317837,
-0.2142689675,
-0.0594540685,
-0.4959787428,
-0.0500413924,
0.4759347737,
0.20942913,
-0.0417053811,
-0.156069532,
0.2517015338,
0.1436929256,
-0.1752021909,
0.4639607072,
-0.227210924,
0.7751507163,
-0.3766940236,
-0.2159743607,
-0.1115157381,
0.0799864531,
0.3953813314,
-0.1062311158,
0.0483418629,
0.2940786779,
-0.9430543184,
-0.3232545853,
0.1432320178,
-0.3560289741,
-0.5338013172,
0.1833181828,
-0.3936742544,
-0.9179027081,
0.5133523941,
-0.1191628799,
-0.3959088027,
0.4043085277,
0.6076700687,
-0.2423224002,
1.0983862877,
1.2309697866,
0.1983129829,
0.2206153423,
-0.2752081156,
0.2101296037,
-0.6720243096,
-0.7161235809,
-0.4238619804,
-0.1940604001,
-0.8034374714,
-0.7100191116,
0.0246107355,
0.3189438283,
-0.2334789038,
0.235947445,
-0.8258090615,
0.7753564715,
0.8225303292,
0.2108517438,
0.2649573684,
0.0525265075,
-0.2894811332,
0.0261660423,
-0.6783925891,
-0.725472033,
0.9996196628,
0.2271125615,
0.5978221297,
-0.0033254591,
0.6544356346,
0.4392030239,
0.3590933979,
-1.0966773033,
0.7064635158,
-0.1087471321,
-0.5388447642,
-0.2449599504,
0.173310414,
-1.2005890608,
0.3135580122,
-0.0849627107,
-0.9534573555,
0.2510598302,
0.3579702377,
0.066800341,
0.3386787176,
-0.3312116563,
0.6115387082,
-0.2253855616,
-0.0239250399,
0.1572987884,
-0.9422332048,
0.4083578289,
-0.0962756723,
0.1446829885,
0.0521216542,
-0.0599054508,
0.6445823312,
0.0792861804,
1.1047492027,
-0.0987804011,
-0.5550205708,
0.2588988543,
0.2956326604,
0.0172412917,
0.0091519989,
0.6205765605,
0.0637010038,
-0.5437334776,
-0.2605166137,
-0.7302090526,
0.1339639425,
-0.8618282676,
-0.5336564183,
-0.7485903502,
-0.3780692816,
-0.2561862171,
0.6217543483,
-0.1016742289,
-0.0625882223,
0.0157911107,
0.4034562707,
0.9001095891,
-0.0958758071,
0.1981747895,
0.4775363803,
-0.5323428512,
-0.0525157936,
0.9844891429,
-0.4337726831,
-0.2832703888,
0.8772482872,
0.4558371007,
-0.3103815615,
-0.2635332644,
-0.3533549309,
-0.2230651826,
-0.8066547513,
-0.0934821367,
-0.7292101383,
0.0475055948,
0.130367443,
-0.2351639867,
-0.5607116222,
-0.5640995502,
-0.3611364067,
-0.3102244139,
0.2625485659,
0.779925108,
-0.1708935052,
0.2755689621,
-0.6378132701,
0.757740438,
0.2027178556,
0.3962654769,
-0.1261020899,
-0.4479930401,
-0.1359465122,
0.1750398129,
-0.0439835936,
-0.5017198324,
0.2598869801,
-0.2227655947,
0.5300066471,
0.4779542983,
0.1986174583,
0.4432238638,
-0.5293677449,
0.8049904108,
0.4337843955,
-0.9281839728,
0.91755265,
-0.4525924921,
0.1139737517,
0.1719844192,
0.536888063,
-0.4051485062,
-0.5679035187,
-0.7426068187,
-0.9950671196,
0.5442718267,
0.3341827393,
0.2211343348,
-0.1713907272,
0.0649966449,
0.2609836459,
0.3213214874,
-0.8731666803,
-0.3154422343,
-0.540175736,
0.0439558774,
-0.3342965245,
0.1268797666,
-0.5197487473,
-0.2772783041,
0.0140480613,
-0.3076184988,
0.4061047733,
-0.1674890369,
-0.277197063,
-0.4040133357,
0.0103459759,
0.5430289507,
0.28977108,
-0.3969325125,
0.5115086436,
-0.3317413926,
-0.5220592022,
0.219829917,
-0.2562167346,
-0.0896905661,
-0.1831581593,
0.3834176362,
0.7106529474,
0.2467104495,
-0.7749441266,
0.0788471699,
0.0543805994,
-0.1241309792,
-0.3120636046,
0.3573620617,
-0.1445704103,
0.3397521079,
0.5695910454,
0.0551804006,
0.2682406306,
-0.6324032545,
0.4960627258,
0.3261992633,
-0.3862953782,
-0.5346888304,
0.6523821354,
0.0152937779,
-0.4258220792,
0.4270859063,
-0.289885819,
-0.6580770016,
1.062849164,
0.425934732,
1.0406407118,
0.0313113444,
0.3131277263,
0.2604799867,
0.8988582492,
-0.0258951541,
0.6938192248,
-0.4342262745,
-1.069499135,
-0.099311538,
-0.2698860765,
-0.7170186639,
0.1424330473,
-0.7662943602,
0.0240277965,
-0.4830984175,
0.1378882229,
-0.41625911,
0.0377021357,
-0.6662420034,
0.7069839835,
0.325865984,
0.357791543,
-1.0535665751,
0.6652502418,
1.3137215376,
-0.508266151,
-0.5719665289,
0.1859602481,
-0.3092884719,
-1.1175144911,
1.2345098257,
0.3996257186,
-0.6129435897,
0.1791942269,
-0.7527410984,
-1.2111355066,
0.8513672352,
-0.1885729581,
-0.1949500293,
0.3930719793,
-0.0441055559,
0.8522437811,
-0.3479148448,
0.1294905096,
0.0344695374,
0.4132886529,
0.1267644018,
-0.3039383888,
0.1464767158,
-0.553671062,
-0.256541729,
0.3462212384,
-0.6418766975,
0.7244874239,
-0.4062342942,
-0.5370566845,
-0.0206086859,
0.8315596581,
0.4951750934,
0.6227496862,
0.5641111135,
0.5508428216,
0.8094310164,
0.0017285241,
0.7360431552,
-0.3601005971,
0.3661536276,
0.8380414248,
-0.3056683242,
0.5030588508,
0.484770447,
-0.0598515645,
0.2675653994,
0.858984828,
-0.011547816,
0.7550343871,
0.3346833289,
0.1321108192,
-0.3985610306,
-0.229177922,
-0.4270801246,
0.3900309801,
0.4863201082,
-0.0895032436,
-0.1508716345,
0.0531037934,
-0.4072726667,
0.1587003917,
-0.4518145323,
0.3669361174,
-0.0626522899,
-0.360034585,
0.3976716399,
-0.1055361629,
0.2706140578,
-0.2343247831,
-0.2906016111,
-0.4343366921,
0.0304260589,
0.0658952743,
-0.8786417246,
-0.1902219504,
-0.0964737087,
-0.1150195003,
-0.4113577008,
0.9111871123,
-0.199143827,
-0.4914470613,
0.2589748204,
0.8667452931,
0.1923541129,
0.2526482344,
-0.3131465912,
-0.0423699915,
-0.260497719,
-0.4257524908,
0.2890996337,
0.7662115693,
-0.383667171,
1.0094709396,
0.8046587706,
-0.350777477,
0.0254205186,
0.231656298,
1.0843986273,
-1.0025706291,
-0.4652365446,
-0.3853824735,
0.6970045567,
0.3430131078,
-0.333733052,
0.7160615921,
0.4844641089,
1.1956657171,
-0.465703249,
0.4386410713,
-0.1064026579,
0.1999089569,
-0.5763952136,
0.598544836,
-0.8899391294,
-0.0463081263,
-0.4182192087,
-0.8873370886,
-0.8305711746,
1.1214435101,
0.36088413,
0.0182487406,
0.9514921904,
0.3712798655,
-0.1097884104,
-0.1579316705,
0.4817866385,
-0.0435826592,
0.1445054412,
0.2815235555,
1.313331008,
-0.0693738014,
-0.0510467961,
-0.6104810834,
-0.3145648241,
-0.0433177426,
-0.8304457068,
-1.317850709,
-0.5800213218,
-0.3753835857,
0.0618284941,
-0.1009161472,
0.8006340861,
0.402918309,
-0.6624318957,
-0.2238937169,
-0.5576865077,
0.2066896558,
-0.035736829,
-0.1591523588,
0.4813692868,
-0.2125529796,
-0.7357628942,
0.6801513433,
0.3113448024,
0.0188768338,
-0.2503237724,
0.1262667626,
0.0313603841,
-0.1411015391,
0.8517878056,
0.5522603989,
-0.7424352765,
-0.6096754074,
0.315793395,
0.2004729509,
0.1965346634,
0.8629768491,
-0.9926028848,
0.5028620362,
0.2109546214,
0.5209974647,
0.1695351005,
-0.0282794777,
0.2011508793,
-0.8784461021,
0.3189879656,
0.4782557786,
0.3378696144,
0.0121934153,
-0.345680058,
0.7527524233,
0.4128316343,
-0.1122733578,
-1.049949646,
0.4620081782,
-1.2305403948,
-0.1106354967,
0.9138143659,
0.3624034822,
-0.0562112555,
0.0554897673,
-0.29119578,
0.3439870775,
-0.3367557228,
1.0289473534,
0.5856637955,
-0.3202671409,
-0.2431946993,
-0.199724704,
0.0974830464,
0.4434992075,
-0.7124360204,
-0.1413467973,
0.5713493228,
-0.1178740934,
0.4813773632,
0.584838748,
0.1982487142,
0.3280017376,
0.0531890355,
0.5688129067,
0.1365459412,
-0.8919302225,
-0.1227565408,
0.2900449038,
-0.0669541731,
-0.4420063198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03086v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03086v1
|
Auditing the Use of Language Models to Guide Hiring Decisions
| 2024-04-03T22:01:26 | 2024-04-03T22:01:26 |
Johann D. Gaebler, Sharad Goel, Aziz Huq, Prasanna Tambe
|
stat.AP
|
stat.AP, cs.CL
|
Regulatory efforts to protect against algorithmic bias have taken on
increased urgency with rapid advances in large language models (LLMs), which
are machine learning models that can achieve performance rivaling human experts
on a wide array of tasks. A key theme of these initiatives is algorithmic
"auditing," but current regulations -- as well as the scientific literature --
provide little guidance on how to conduct these assessments. Here we propose
and investigate one approach for auditing algorithms: correspondence
experiments, a widely applied tool for detecting bias in human judgements. In
the employment context, correspondence experiments aim to measure the extent to
which race and gender impact decisions by experimentally manipulating elements
of submitted application materials that suggest an applicant's demographic
traits, such as their listed name. We apply this method to audit candidate
assessments produced by several state-of-the-art LLMs, using a novel corpus of
applications to K-12 teaching positions in a large public school district. We
find evidence of moderate race and gender disparities, a pattern largely robust
to varying the types of application material input to the models, as well as
the framing of the task to the LLMs. We conclude by discussing some important
limitations of correspondence experiments for auditing algorithms.
|
[
-0.1904103458,
-0.3743276298,
0.6910344362,
0.0659126267,
0.2141927183,
0.0411789306,
-0.1714226454,
-0.43149665,
0.1549612582,
0.5541910529,
-0.5825234652,
-0.3653122485,
-0.5910295248,
0.1769203246,
-0.8533185124,
0.8506823778,
-0.1374850273,
0.4853281379,
-0.402245611,
0.0832374617,
-0.8540205359,
-0.3775475919,
-0.4483324885,
-0.3926864564,
0.3019275963,
0.4329879582,
0.5572019815,
0.9510816336,
0.5223379135,
0.3342736959,
-0.0551157296,
-0.0087909866,
-0.3425981402,
-0.0828434527,
-0.2957434654,
-0.9859727621,
-0.2261536568,
0.4861795008,
0.6034157872,
1.0143122673,
-0.1754675359,
0.3512422144,
-0.0908376873,
0.7598572373,
-0.8629395962,
0.0673631877,
-0.7816686034,
-0.0235491786,
-0.3336066306,
-0.0933183283,
-0.3999958336,
-0.5736935735,
0.263096571,
-0.1765845269,
0.5387908816,
0.3034788072,
0.5834089518,
0.078788057,
-0.496799618,
-0.5501172543,
-0.7444221973,
0.8303362727,
-0.6463143229,
0.5030155182,
0.8872873187,
0.3491018116,
-0.2553060353,
-0.2655674219,
-0.5615560412,
-0.1810918599,
-0.1888546199,
-0.0192422085,
0.2117145509,
0.2550312281,
0.4352064431,
0.3918626308,
-0.4079691768,
0.3222975731,
-0.5970645547,
-0.1425494552,
0.5793525577,
0.3043090701,
0.3801959753,
0.1523051262,
0.1306785941,
-0.541864872,
-0.639303565,
-0.1047975495,
0.8854779005,
0.3768545389,
0.0740261823,
0.6292066574,
-0.1396980882,
0.6981942058,
-0.1519406885,
0.1007580534,
-0.1282177418,
-0.2778707743,
-0.0648728982,
0.2290408015,
0.5265931487,
0.447094053,
0.3686017394,
-0.0381466523,
-0.3255278766,
0.6859654784,
0.149671331,
-0.3831140399,
-0.2519973814,
0.090212211,
-0.2408931702,
-0.2920164168,
0.0756924227,
-1.0103814602,
-0.6653064489,
-0.4504413605,
0.1335658729,
0.0110477386,
0.0027229276,
0.0766125172,
-0.2597706914,
0.0739843771,
0.3858030438,
-1.1950861216,
0.3926386237,
0.8856173158,
0.4224176705,
-0.0914954171,
-0.511433363,
-0.6112812161,
-0.0720941648,
-0.4668509364,
0.3645932078,
-0.9044373631,
-0.2208993882,
0.3978835046,
-0.0616519861,
-0.0271342658,
-0.6582107544,
0.4592813253,
-0.5579416752,
0.5878965855,
-0.0972471386,
-0.7045864463,
-0.144809112,
-0.0781935379,
-0.52000916,
1.0966345072,
0.096794419,
-0.5525352359,
0.6472646594,
-0.6157075167,
-0.0426119752,
-0.2930186689,
-0.4804700911,
-0.5864812732,
0.0424288623,
-0.0003977823,
0.0818400458,
-0.2386195809,
0.5010935068,
-0.3264796138,
-0.6637504697,
0.2464863956,
-0.2452102005,
0.9713384509,
-0.0511269197,
-0.3756065667,
0.0924310461,
-0.50863415,
-0.4954753518,
-0.0875099152,
-0.2938178182,
-0.6144183278,
0.1869691312,
-0.2425840199,
-0.0864311531,
-0.119988285,
-0.5267875195,
0.067138046,
-0.0428172685,
0.1673708558,
1.0699687004,
-0.5161748528,
0.4387128055,
-0.5956786275,
0.5317079425,
-0.2582932115,
-0.156446293,
-0.2260502875,
-0.4316677153,
-0.7991839647,
-0.1825784296,
0.620685935,
0.5215530992,
-0.2173175663,
0.4601159096,
-0.1413222104,
-0.6221767664,
-0.8303253055,
0.1602157801,
0.1975818425,
0.2892793715,
-0.2876809239,
-0.286909014,
-0.697042942,
-0.8952468038,
-0.7340183258,
-0.3350271583,
-0.2845623195,
0.3480972946,
0.7337841988,
-0.3318104148,
1.0556672812,
-0.3875027895,
-0.1479833126,
0.4801155925,
0.0756389797,
0.4196690023,
0.5915328264,
0.5438448787,
-0.4744186699,
-0.2540379763,
-0.2052142769,
-0.546702981,
-0.3758701086,
-0.0863571465,
-0.2491376102,
-0.2214013785,
0.4780518711,
-0.2260846347,
0.4466110468,
0.6494868994,
-0.4531333447,
0.6649250388,
-0.0816128775,
0.0771845505,
-0.4619728923,
0.0869958475,
0.1923767626,
-0.3464297354,
-0.5710145235,
-0.001017024,
0.1482902765,
-0.0711260661,
-0.2482497841,
0.5425534248,
-0.4389900267,
-0.2728917301,
-0.0357928686,
0.0589361116,
-0.2233621776,
0.2268131077,
-0.1193094477,
0.8366039991,
0.3447450697,
-0.5290062428,
0.1425410658,
0.4467885196,
-0.6303914189,
0.7191056013,
-0.2324661613,
0.3218404949,
-0.3227259517,
0.1536611468,
-0.9822285175,
-0.2094500661,
-0.1078965962,
-0.2782126069,
0.0680900216,
0.0716588125,
-0.3079479635,
-0.2487170994,
-0.6088538766,
0.4522228539,
0.5497775674,
-0.5093976855,
0.5456084609,
0.2599787116,
-0.1514143497,
-0.4688806236,
-0.7394903898,
-0.0294229314,
-0.2819337249,
-0.38565889,
0.0662837252,
0.0046500424,
-0.4367235005,
-0.1672849804,
-0.0464841388,
-0.4646024704,
0.3834229112,
0.0785325691,
0.673181653,
-0.1370321065,
-0.3810918629,
-0.2799713016,
0.264529407,
0.2889484763,
0.2778271139,
0.1688384265,
0.3355965912,
-0.6579772234,
-0.429028213,
0.1010352597,
0.6954368949,
0.1439180821,
0.5092177391,
0.1428112537,
-0.4491762221,
-0.1427188814,
-0.8786042929,
-0.5746748447,
-0.5247486234,
0.4116853178,
0.1377608031,
-0.8107231259,
0.512560904,
-0.0992001817,
0.1264769137,
0.0624966286,
0.4305372238,
-0.2760705054,
0.824226439,
0.5973325372,
-0.2264667302,
0.8981286883,
0.1850117743,
0.2541041672,
-0.720417738,
-0.0338037573,
-0.8411379457,
-0.2305859774,
-0.6958115101,
-0.2348228693,
0.3009027243,
-0.2317144424,
-0.0598226711,
0.0562492758,
-0.3141183853,
0.6795715094,
0.8370519876,
-0.1953125298,
0.1807062626,
0.0317430981,
-0.0295719914,
-0.099853538,
-0.5306733251,
-0.6833221316,
1.2749162912,
0.534547925,
0.5740768313,
-0.1460999101,
0.536965847,
0.3773039281,
0.5907901525,
-0.2660080492,
0.4924485385,
-0.1228696778,
-0.9936231971,
-0.4058689475,
-0.3711398244,
-0.8319884539,
0.4111749828,
-0.4363459051,
-0.8153267503,
0.1894248426,
0.1622004509,
0.2205736488,
0.328715384,
-0.6528459787,
0.7172326446,
-0.2246167213,
-0.0980957299,
-0.0343960188,
-0.3581916988,
0.6735835671,
-0.5822880864,
0.421769172,
-0.1404199898,
0.3609747887,
1.048416853,
-0.2378426343,
0.8827545047,
-0.0216728393,
-0.0164077897,
-0.1392042935,
0.256141305,
0.6384177804,
-0.5617508888,
-0.3561749458,
0.3271583021,
0.1646567285,
-0.1038112789,
-0.4494168758,
0.3830953836,
-0.5959554911,
-0.5904020071,
-0.5258767009,
-0.7405685782,
-0.185866192,
0.3200585544,
-0.2938863635,
0.0348226391,
-0.1728081107,
0.0253493618,
0.2132618129,
-0.126491636,
-0.0481307544,
0.6369971037,
-0.1527478546,
0.0428633392,
0.7841622829,
-0.0730207562,
0.1643349677,
-0.0420306996,
0.3734612465,
-0.3703456819,
-0.3958241642,
-0.1082650796,
0.440948844,
-0.6011061072,
0.1121562943,
-0.162678957,
0.2510745823,
-0.5450131893,
-0.1073506251,
-0.0738912672,
-0.0428482406,
-0.1344346851,
0.0758038163,
0.0099018319,
0.8822563887,
0.1039536148,
0.1783167273,
-0.3460375667,
0.1878652722,
0.4896901846,
0.5037021637,
-0.0538040884,
-0.2949889004,
-0.0314836651,
0.2248173803,
-0.3455097079,
-0.8492044806,
0.0477578901,
-0.0142506417,
0.452855438,
0.3818159699,
-0.016226599,
0.6394099593,
-0.5554622412,
0.5535101891,
0.0861273035,
-1.0994148254,
0.3524340093,
-0.4653228223,
-0.2366705984,
0.7231374383,
0.1192164794,
-0.9153146744,
-0.8078091741,
-0.2526743114,
-0.4415665269,
1.1695777178,
0.3380095363,
0.0068622562,
0.0936148688,
0.407761544,
-0.0347453617,
0.4333917201,
-0.4628729224,
-0.257273078,
0.3646980226,
-0.4395856261,
0.0382506624,
-0.2811566889,
-0.2547853589,
-0.1320658773,
0.5072788596,
0.1103244647,
-0.1558487713,
0.0349463671,
0.0971643478,
-0.2001847774,
0.1890037507,
0.67314744,
0.9138723612,
-0.2473496944,
0.1865881532,
0.4989008904,
-0.4268737733,
0.1873933822,
-0.2145210505,
-0.2556112707,
0.0944876447,
0.51015836,
0.4827609956,
0.076351501,
-0.9088283777,
0.5781014562,
-0.1093779653,
-0.3091121018,
-0.3102257848,
0.0900247619,
-0.0269414447,
0.1137121767,
0.0850423947,
-0.1958557814,
0.1062476635,
-0.7973983884,
0.0051322584,
0.5538123846,
-0.1326757818,
-0.1236326322,
0.7677303553,
0.3015697896,
-0.6918568015,
0.8386705518,
0.2045694888,
-0.5958991647,
0.77173841,
0.42712152,
0.810921371,
-0.5856143832,
-0.2733592987,
-0.0267638862,
0.3977719843,
-0.495845288,
0.0450883657,
0.1760675311,
-0.6618186235,
-0.2603594959,
-0.3350105584,
-0.8040685654,
0.0646189898,
-0.6615464091,
0.5212208033,
-0.3130604327,
0.0864393562,
0.1028833985,
-0.3884757459,
-0.7537585497,
0.1198436022,
0.189770475,
0.8890700936,
-1.4643701315,
0.3925783038,
0.7216197848,
0.0810117275,
-0.3786413074,
-0.2724116743,
0.1916632801,
-1.0069539547,
0.7979625463,
0.1337804198,
0.2327244729,
-0.551704824,
-0.3106382489,
-0.4698279798,
0.8121238947,
0.6764886379,
-0.7214346528,
-0.2471236587,
0.3685921729,
0.3650578558,
-0.1983551383,
0.5851002336,
0.8853440881,
0.551763773,
-0.4282520413,
-1.3050246239,
-0.1057189032,
0.0249874983,
0.0737720132,
0.2952183485,
-0.1691632718,
0.8697943091,
0.1726529747,
-0.2460775822,
-0.1442041546,
0.3529410064,
0.2999480963,
0.4719306827,
0.7230088115,
0.3135505617,
1.1368018389,
-0.0572974309,
0.9139117599,
-0.3713405728,
0.5332995653,
0.9120897055,
-0.5389612317,
0.5117480755,
0.6059358716,
-0.5618117452,
0.4698366821,
0.5503380299,
-0.2153903693,
0.1908960938,
0.539237082,
-0.0721821263,
0.006877101,
-0.3687282801,
0.0196211431,
0.4802464545,
0.1540096402,
-0.34300372,
-0.1701929271,
-0.3163976669,
-0.0695678145,
0.3438789546,
-0.162376523,
0.5779613256,
-0.1666487306,
-0.8974694014,
0.0552803725,
-0.008885731,
0.6021473408,
-0.4263501167,
-0.4942628145,
-0.0421538129,
0.204229176,
-0.3363130987,
-0.7993947864,
0.1596604735,
0.0431518853,
-0.195715487,
-0.0696350932,
0.3171699941,
-0.6511923671,
-0.3858606219,
0.1254943162,
0.2514684498,
0.293648392,
0.2116288394,
-0.3576787412,
0.1723287702,
-0.0834236592,
0.2350349724,
0.3328841925,
0.080425702,
-0.1720096022,
0.6384848356,
0.7772272825,
0.4601982534,
0.0277041681,
-0.2012618035,
0.4142520726,
-0.5915029049,
-0.7740352154,
-1.0287230015,
0.0526801199,
0.0284012575,
-0.0998338461,
0.6703189611,
0.6411291957,
1.0600163937,
0.1198790222,
0.7687601447,
0.6436933279,
0.4814118147,
-0.53364712,
0.3208555877,
-0.1731416732,
0.253469944,
-0.3938022256,
-1.1265566349,
-0.0227462854,
0.6572428942,
-0.3507386744,
0.2453075498,
0.6607552767,
0.8610679507,
-0.1779156476,
0.1173164248,
0.1706836522,
-0.0295374189,
0.4880129695,
0.3396596014,
0.7314304113,
-0.3509131968,
0.1711750776,
-0.1186063737,
-0.2043103874,
-0.4716240168,
-0.9415653348,
-0.9912832975,
-0.4130928814,
-0.3833796382,
-0.3072809577,
0.0290393103,
0.7768715024,
0.60456568,
-0.6948050261,
-0.7825007439,
-0.0075127622,
0.184282586,
0.0562950075,
-0.2197603136,
0.3087395132,
-0.0199477021,
-0.8920651674,
0.2146701664,
-0.1800851822,
-0.0279393345,
-0.4288586378,
0.0783533603,
-0.1280784607,
0.1345265359,
-0.0045789867,
0.1600507796,
-0.7366888523,
-0.3258886337,
-0.4168300927,
-0.1117441878,
-0.1303803474,
1.0144488811,
-0.340375185,
0.7892575264,
0.4568091929,
0.834807694,
0.2743001878,
-0.1292440444,
0.7726719975,
-0.6678503156,
-0.0295338202,
0.1447467059,
0.526450932,
0.2499649972,
-0.2392163873,
0.6381746531,
0.0995776504,
-0.6461010575,
-1.2906796932,
-0.0077911643,
-0.4375537932,
-0.0755226612,
0.9897285104,
0.2051676065,
-0.2966432571,
0.0062872618,
-0.1593298912,
0.0909368321,
-0.2587652504,
1.1403478384,
1.1383907795,
0.1229189262,
0.2547786236,
-0.9596425295,
0.4582568407,
0.5933536291,
-0.6251411438,
0.234451592,
0.4351731539,
0.4462707937,
0.1626583189,
0.6140229702,
0.1209037155,
0.5216488242,
-0.1517788321,
0.0797474384,
0.1307798922,
0.0051382086,
-0.6547946334,
-0.3516703546,
0.226618588,
-0.2358027101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03080v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03080v2
|
Construction and Application of Materials Knowledge Graph in Multidisciplinary Materials Science via Large Language Model
| 2024-04-03T21:46:14 | 2024-06-04T10:04:05 |
Yanpeng Ye, Jie Ren, Shaozhou Wang, Yuwei Wan, Haofen Wang, Imran Razzak, Tong Xie, Wenjie Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge in materials science is widely dispersed across extensive
scientific literature, posing significant challenges for efficient discovery
and integration of new materials. Traditional methods, often reliant on costly
and time-consuming experimental approaches, further complicate rapid
innovation. Addressing these challenges, the integration of artificial
intelligence with materials science has opened avenues for accelerating the
discovery process, though it also demands precise annotation, data extraction,
and traceability of information. To tackle these issues, this article
introduces the Materials Knowledge Graph (MKG), which utilizes advanced natural
language processing techniques, integrated with large language models to
extract and systematically organize a decade's worth of high-quality research
into structured triples, contains 162,605 nodes and 731,772 edges. MKG
categorizes information into comprehensive labels such as Name, Formula, and
Application, structured around a meticulously designed ontology, thus enhancing
data usability and integration. By implementing network-based algorithms, MKG
not only facilitates efficient link prediction but also significantly reduces
reliance on traditional experimental methods. This structured approach not only
streamlines materials research but also lays the groundwork for more
sophisticated science knowledge graphs.
|
[
-0.2840146422,
-0.9550690651,
0.8200483322,
-0.0246578883,
0.0674921721,
0.4726126194,
-0.0083030583,
-0.3667029738,
0.0805334672,
0.2678176463,
-0.369407177,
-0.687561512,
-0.4423261583,
0.0211156458,
-0.0267527886,
0.6925043464,
-0.3110999465,
0.0590141937,
-0.2147166878,
-0.0291912798,
-0.1348520517,
-0.3352490962,
-0.4674680531,
-0.6957658529,
0.5649721622,
0.3528594971,
0.6597080827,
0.9561008215,
0.6063955426,
0.4021354914,
-0.1119276807,
0.5335105658,
0.0026745233,
-0.1822954267,
-0.1928097159,
-0.3633835912,
-0.756771028,
0.188550815,
0.7716579437,
1.146679163,
0.0475346148,
0.1032146439,
0.2424864024,
0.6523873806,
-0.1932152212,
0.4745702147,
-0.2935733497,
0.3063608408,
-0.360907495,
-0.5773307085,
-0.345654726,
-0.34297508,
0.2113053501,
-0.7736749649,
0.075477168,
0.2955223322,
0.5092555285,
-0.131294474,
-0.5208705664,
-0.354413867,
-0.7631160021,
0.7457840443,
-0.3036474288,
0.5711684823,
0.4225447774,
0.4980174005,
-0.3427464664,
-0.8989197016,
-0.4042887688,
-0.1890935898,
-0.1097934917,
-0.1078912914,
0.4029033184,
0.1868096739,
-0.0616409183,
0.4636986852,
-0.6325419545,
-0.0545721985,
-0.4923456311,
-0.3756768107,
0.4008178711,
0.0886790454,
0.3177403212,
-0.1534479856,
-0.5559365749,
0.0306052677,
-0.4159068763,
-0.4842370152,
0.3480945528,
0.5736329556,
0.0034778686,
0.8736073971,
-0.2697304487,
0.6075220704,
-0.5158888102,
-0.183452785,
0.5290077925,
-0.7286758423,
0.0559044071,
0.1062684208,
0.9499357939,
0.1017635465,
0.0862508118,
-0.4063516259,
0.052841112,
-0.1955058575,
-0.0553315505,
-0.7345380187,
-0.5116440058,
0.1578193903,
-0.4940212369,
-0.2596890926,
-0.1995309889,
-0.6900212765,
-0.7922699451,
-0.5299782753,
0.2866287529,
-0.4143686891,
-0.5601171255,
0.17024073,
-0.3732536435,
-0.4504951835,
0.4428969026,
-0.60255301,
0.2643440962,
0.5644122362,
1.181486249,
0.1390343606,
-0.5082858801,
-0.1920036674,
0.4652096033,
-0.1249113753,
0.7754598856,
-0.4415453672,
-0.1528650522,
-0.5187731385,
-0.1112771407,
0.1363176107,
-0.2618456483,
0.4349884093,
-0.3736294508,
0.0847810507,
-0.2680496871,
-0.3736782968,
-0.2847057581,
0.4545677006,
-0.7984753251,
1.0009890795,
0.2182350755,
-0.9352061749,
0.276597321,
-0.8404759169,
-0.3093199134,
0.1810423136,
0.0890545323,
-0.1207506508,
-0.1964868605,
-0.1900756061,
0.5366886854,
-0.5876184702,
0.3464868665,
-0.5795969963,
0.1124329045,
0.2370213419,
-0.1179011315,
0.4586972892,
0.2757859826,
-0.0894746631,
0.0489555858,
-0.8041261435,
-0.1363448501,
0.1308205277,
-0.3417754769,
-0.4707303047,
0.0000488106,
0.1354191452,
0.4026765823,
0.3482649028,
-0.7446233034,
0.3016281128,
-0.1433987916,
0.5921784043,
0.8762621284,
-0.1377622485,
0.6271211505,
-0.1369431764,
0.206268549,
-0.3060752749,
0.1210729033,
-0.0822531134,
-0.3622428179,
-0.4725919664,
0.1120775491,
0.34169209,
0.2686858177,
-0.906550765,
0.1845303774,
-0.254273653,
-0.6619306803,
-0.026267197,
0.3137751222,
0.1775483191,
0.6693444252,
0.328179419,
-0.1894481927,
-0.5852057338,
-0.6710226536,
-0.0667998344,
-0.0796066821,
0.1463699788,
0.4069111347,
0.4036299586,
-0.166188702,
1.1439058781,
-1.0160090923,
-0.3514386415,
-0.054320313,
0.4933868349,
0.2088161856,
0.3011066616,
0.035881713,
-0.9864590764,
-0.3606526852,
0.4464966655,
-1.1038603783,
0.1546332091,
0.287481755,
-0.3745733202,
-0.0003558584,
0.7247042656,
-0.3746315241,
-0.1589969099,
0.5338658094,
-0.3685622811,
0.6372232437,
-0.1724761724,
0.0530376919,
-1.2220957279,
0.4142947197,
0.2484713644,
0.0073383208,
-0.7749180198,
-0.1012679711,
-0.0768597722,
-0.272713244,
-0.2090568542,
0.7408536673,
-0.5949193835,
-0.1318247765,
-0.2082056105,
0.0784241334,
0.2844711542,
0.5711761117,
-0.0755022168,
0.3892429769,
0.33896029,
-0.6744395494,
0.5441420674,
0.1535555571,
-0.2387490422,
0.6444277167,
-0.415679127,
-0.0245668478,
0.0014078431,
0.186244756,
-0.8207069635,
-0.1034675837,
0.2775396109,
-0.3079106808,
0.4839506149,
-0.0730724111,
-1.0163593292,
-0.5618426204,
-0.3380209208,
0.5096294284,
-0.1728928238,
-0.3821599185,
1.2013795376,
0.5966848731,
-0.412397325,
-0.3661894202,
-0.3713451922,
0.0873585939,
-0.1461448371,
-0.7802200913,
0.3506627083,
-0.6294567585,
-0.09825854,
0.0925671458,
-0.3061762452,
-0.3776750863,
0.1595241427,
0.16474621,
0.0850436017,
-0.0623757392,
0.5779719949,
-0.300380975,
-0.1395801157,
0.1064689308,
-0.3484407067,
0.9713106155,
-0.0437728092,
-0.0038871272,
-0.2070541978,
0.0127055086,
0.7485468388,
-0.2272095084,
0.5389432311,
0.5701713562,
-0.523948431,
-0.2915223539,
-0.3986815214,
-0.1228456423,
-0.6042619944,
0.4600912333,
-0.448997885,
-0.5406162739,
0.5682399869,
-0.4566088915,
0.0886063352,
0.3592193127,
0.0348422304,
-0.1102914363,
1.0672672987,
0.7309194803,
-0.0063097705,
0.3202679455,
-0.2405461222,
0.3443295658,
-0.863244772,
-0.6660033464,
-0.5523641109,
-0.055993136,
-0.2874659896,
-0.4140186906,
0.439075619,
0.0937538967,
-0.2375737429,
0.3263206482,
-0.616328001,
0.3807036281,
0.2376263589,
0.2473034561,
0.626214385,
0.0406466424,
-0.0670897216,
0.3365796208,
-0.7298114896,
-0.3051693439,
1.1056089401,
0.4818762839,
0.6665053368,
-0.1338876486,
0.3352971375,
0.4156410694,
0.0942832306,
-0.8648589849,
0.5867532492,
0.1495707631,
-0.6796579361,
-0.2697941959,
-0.8314924836,
-0.7547003031,
-0.0415703356,
-0.1530362219,
-0.3518303037,
0.0081642922,
0.1445771158,
-0.0467022099,
0.588126719,
-0.7328000665,
0.6595619917,
-0.3921803236,
-0.2323191166,
-0.0604290515,
-0.3863970637,
0.3454968631,
-0.3108054996,
0.6556428671,
-0.3078629375,
0.3301922679,
0.880725503,
-0.4050260186,
0.6067943573,
-0.0320712961,
-0.2329109311,
0.4164588451,
0.1630059481,
0.3964271545,
-0.2577513456,
-0.2658391595,
0.2701447308,
-0.3727659285,
-0.2194981277,
-0.5061801672,
0.5960851908,
-0.5740884542,
-0.1436669081,
-0.2586335242,
-0.9724451303,
-0.0579367429,
0.5581780672,
-0.0534934588,
0.5767418146,
-0.0749869645,
-0.0024083694,
0.4763584137,
-0.1558960676,
0.2639850974,
0.159646973,
-0.0811351389,
-0.335047096,
1.3067317009,
0.5183819532,
0.1385801435,
0.2937043309,
0.5215992928,
-0.3442749381,
-0.5680239201,
-0.2632198632,
0.3971296549,
-0.7172250748,
-0.3427562714,
-0.8806661367,
-0.3823102117,
-0.3167846203,
-0.3671434522,
-0.3041773736,
-0.4457475543,
-0.0281757358,
-0.2139204144,
0.4790223837,
1.1007671356,
0.0519989878,
0.139891848,
-0.8307077885,
0.4447324276,
0.3001922369,
0.9295399785,
0.12476632,
0.1525212824,
-0.6120736599,
0.0413257033,
-0.0545344725,
-0.6410880089,
0.0262633376,
0.0138536505,
0.7167028189,
0.1152841747,
-0.1370919496,
0.3501401544,
-0.5472611785,
0.1664786786,
0.2199060321,
-0.7271786332,
0.4175764918,
-0.7967000008,
0.0798060969,
0.4065710008,
0.5375585556,
-0.3141607642,
0.0552321151,
-0.5221859813,
-0.9482806921,
0.9338415265,
0.057871677,
-0.4748075306,
0.4272984862,
0.039118167,
0.0181076042,
0.21398893,
-0.7735484838,
-0.3359901607,
-0.064491719,
-0.1612948179,
0.1074356139,
-0.1684474945,
-0.4787311554,
-0.0250398871,
0.7070368528,
-0.3853748441,
0.1474714875,
-0.1860506237,
-0.1924515069,
0.0059275148,
0.0698615909,
0.2841553092,
0.6534883976,
-0.6141642332,
0.2831682563,
-0.0856518596,
-0.6093099117,
-0.0025109993,
0.3570893407,
0.1386553943,
-0.3044909239,
0.0095446706,
0.3728113174,
-0.1696305573,
-0.3781557381,
-0.0240135714,
0.0881446376,
-0.2464846671,
-0.2129502445,
-0.3359466195,
0.0212615132,
0.3235911131,
0.4570689797,
0.0889753997,
0.3501080275,
-0.7175033092,
0.2313432395,
0.294914782,
-0.321769774,
-0.2338350117,
0.3020324409,
0.323663801,
-0.0973185301,
0.396115005,
-0.2872953713,
-0.7137852311,
0.7230756283,
0.3441593647,
0.3904353082,
-0.1401951909,
0.3225696683,
0.4075708389,
0.3375392258,
-0.1975891888,
0.1427985132,
-0.0820794553,
-0.708861053,
-0.2741042972,
-0.6979714632,
-0.5001294017,
-0.1883431971,
-0.1057595313,
0.2229008079,
-0.6719739437,
0.1213790923,
0.2528163195,
0.3844923377,
-0.4630397558,
0.2726003528,
0.1457469016,
0.7317736149,
-1.0109297037,
0.5362420082,
0.5686322451,
-0.3544889092,
-0.7452502251,
-0.6535126567,
0.2383846045,
-0.6804943085,
0.779769659,
0.2874758244,
-0.2686968446,
0.0705537125,
-0.2979947031,
-1.3020060062,
1.3224992752,
0.0254138485,
0.0287503377,
-0.0021681609,
0.2233828008,
0.1537652016,
-0.0667760894,
0.3597192764,
0.462639153,
0.8862160444,
0.3112322688,
-0.793295145,
0.2166004777,
-0.5914099216,
-0.4394993782,
0.7412670851,
-0.6298505068,
0.888197422,
0.2431902438,
-0.3085936606,
-0.1998584569,
0.4487004578,
0.3175043762,
0.3440692425,
0.4566907287,
0.5373846889,
0.9034717679,
-0.1989241242,
0.8037824631,
-0.2687224746,
0.1974355876,
0.8076459169,
-0.3216509521,
0.1271652281,
0.1325989217,
-0.0924692899,
0.6395770311,
0.4576690197,
-0.1869765818,
0.2805836797,
0.0475939438,
-0.1866542697,
-0.104549624,
-0.710480392,
-0.3952053189,
0.311747551,
0.5518356562,
-0.1995964348,
-0.3130146563,
-0.1705812216,
0.1637331545,
-0.1984152198,
-0.3886091709,
0.4043911099,
-0.0468706377,
-0.2075435817,
0.0688944682,
0.0896946788,
0.5428897142,
-0.6937938333,
-0.3399186432,
0.0481173843,
0.0633710176,
-0.4347307086,
-0.9580938816,
0.0897649676,
-0.4833123386,
-0.3228263855,
-0.3597893417,
0.8521493673,
-0.3143492937,
-0.4173756242,
0.2555764318,
0.5080597401,
-0.0865655243,
-0.000342492,
-0.4129940867,
-0.2121824026,
-0.2034575492,
-0.3052621484,
0.1654412746,
0.6761255264,
-0.1999759078,
0.7435723543,
1.1772282124,
-0.0275251213,
-0.1302529275,
-0.1116562337,
1.1635962725,
-0.7505791187,
-0.2833579183,
-0.7405376434,
0.769523263,
-0.3265706003,
-0.0557637662,
0.9651451111,
0.8320733905,
0.4952296317,
0.4643740058,
0.8128618002,
0.0379615426,
0.3533329964,
-0.5193513632,
0.755081296,
-0.4517782927,
0.1852984428,
-0.5680869222,
-0.9484233856,
-0.6305165291,
0.3352511823,
0.0029024619,
0.2797238231,
0.936299324,
0.5676102638,
-0.2153058052,
-0.0563682392,
-0.1256575435,
0.3396217525,
0.4040157795,
0.1815291941,
0.6304588318,
-0.183795616,
0.758045733,
-0.3373302221,
-0.2962545156,
-0.2103764713,
-1.0112040043,
-0.8307067752,
-0.5845493078,
-0.105793193,
-0.4584028125,
-0.5246918201,
0.7079074979,
0.8052197695,
-0.22866714,
-0.4510532916,
-0.3264052868,
0.2475946397,
0.1681127846,
-0.2020381987,
0.6691810489,
-0.0376601033,
-0.4957960546,
0.5644542575,
0.394536674,
0.0117111374,
-0.2378883362,
-0.0854239315,
-0.4125132859,
-0.0117599908,
0.67209059,
0.3386799097,
0.1145533621,
-0.0230958462,
0.1002872139,
-0.0507432222,
0.1387911737,
0.7128825188,
-0.5915307999,
0.5974488854,
0.8274543285,
0.5796844959,
0.5553442836,
-0.2562691569,
0.7191773653,
-0.7639752626,
-0.1577129513,
0.1348751932,
0.6172575355,
0.5293711424,
-0.3236582875,
0.8776997924,
0.3612504005,
-0.6210967302,
-0.826877296,
0.4429909587,
-1.0719158649,
-0.6359844208,
1.0544288158,
0.2365892828,
-0.2399386913,
-0.4387625456,
-0.1340967268,
0.6066322923,
-0.2657269239,
0.6626592875,
0.6524463892,
-0.0689097941,
0.0475846156,
-0.470929265,
0.2290918082,
0.1318707615,
-1.080072999,
0.1025919169,
0.4191723466,
0.1943795234,
0.6238437891,
0.5930786729,
-0.0946053714,
-0.0501534045,
-0.0489741266,
0.3773894906,
-0.5930444598,
-0.8146476746,
0.0103439037,
0.4142169058,
0.1626724005,
0.3370411396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03073v1
|
Mai Ho'omāuna i ka 'Ai: Language Models Improve Automatic Speech Recognition in Hawaiian
| 2024-04-03T21:29:40 | 2024-04-03T21:29:40 |
Kaavya Chaparala, Guido Zarrella, Bruce Torres Fischer, Larry Kimura, Oiwi Parker Jones
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In this paper we address the challenge of improving Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR) for a low-resource language, Hawaiian, by incorporating large
amounts of independent text data into an ASR foundation model, Whisper. To do
this, we train an external language model (LM) on ~1.5M words of Hawaiian text.
We then use the LM to rescore Whisper and compute word error rates (WERs) on a
manually curated test set of labeled Hawaiian data. As a baseline, we use
Whisper without an external LM. Experimental results reveal a small but
significant improvement in WER when ASR outputs are rescored with a Hawaiian
LM. The results support leveraging all available data in the development of ASR
systems for underrepresented languages.
|
[
-0.0466892309,
-0.8548669219,
0.3059803545,
0.110941574,
-0.2411632389,
0.2076332718,
-0.373729974,
-0.6887833476,
0.309427321,
0.5506479144,
-0.1154200807,
-0.2150519639,
-0.720292747,
0.2435494065,
-0.281940788,
0.4981749058,
0.0142830713,
0.2010122687,
0.0981734097,
-0.3577035964,
-0.533503592,
-0.782951057,
-0.918854177,
-0.5017691851,
0.6365778446,
0.6852080226,
0.6843371391,
0.3793934286,
0.3374817073,
0.3064809144,
-0.1114988923,
0.3630557358,
-0.3329648376,
-0.0405422896,
0.4079349041,
-0.2799438536,
-0.3290579915,
-0.1956390887,
0.8942090869,
0.5754272342,
-0.0592618287,
0.1680514216,
0.228769213,
0.8709822297,
-0.774113059,
0.4956960082,
-0.7350567579,
-0.0461473502,
-0.4448364377,
0.0991297215,
-0.4103774726,
-0.5024418235,
0.5747571588,
-0.4390969276,
-0.1937693208,
-0.2854292989,
0.6846991777,
0.2717945874,
-0.7068873644,
-0.3670593798,
-0.9348709583,
0.5478311181,
-0.7262257934,
0.6645138264,
0.7954848409,
0.2482424527,
-0.1764726192,
-0.4486654401,
-0.7035813928,
-0.2601220012,
0.1507891715,
0.1232414693,
-0.4273850918,
0.0490976162,
-0.0281084664,
0.3862043917,
-0.1796354651,
0.1619732082,
-0.5676084161,
-0.2597692311,
0.8571825027,
0.0110356398,
0.2698910534,
0.0145110553,
0.2485126555,
-0.0879461095,
-0.6473982334,
0.324721694,
0.4296629429,
0.8154876828,
-0.2529449463,
0.9040015936,
-0.2699082494,
0.7162259221,
-0.234235391,
-0.4347968102,
0.2520402372,
0.2502001226,
-0.1734113693,
0.5776891708,
1.0577424765,
-0.0204142909,
0.372053355,
0.0306863338,
0.0296974238,
0.4704180956,
0.1778438985,
-0.3694078326,
-0.4650456607,
-0.0952780172,
-0.4497604668,
-0.0925271213,
-0.1326495707,
-0.5202207565,
-0.3522132039,
-0.2932916284,
1.0247952938,
-0.3827218115,
-0.3818622231,
-0.1169622391,
-0.07200744,
0.0566975996,
0.2284382582,
-0.5701810718,
0.4505732358,
0.2146799564,
0.835711956,
-0.003587123,
-0.2134425193,
-0.6138182282,
0.1121542379,
-0.254153192,
0.7172946334,
-0.4382789731,
-0.9954593778,
-0.0206595752,
-0.1631243676,
-0.4846003354,
-0.496212244,
0.5859872699,
-0.3160593808,
0.1544808894,
-0.2646790445,
-0.6923347116,
-0.4853329062,
-0.2150248587,
-0.7240923643,
0.8521234393,
-0.0356778949,
-0.5089059472,
-0.0465527736,
-0.8720473647,
-0.6962376833,
-0.0440580174,
0.0498203933,
-0.6523800492,
0.3540221453,
0.1319336295,
0.1417568326,
-0.0538219362,
-0.0043552015,
0.1792120934,
-0.3594977558,
0.4024806023,
-0.6422752738,
0.9359881282,
0.3579846919,
-0.4821173847,
0.018390296,
-0.8152605891,
0.1260363758,
0.100193724,
-0.8052248955,
-0.3708938658,
0.0443058461,
0.2352156043,
-0.4278393984,
0.2301788479,
-0.6961636543,
-0.1508747786,
-0.4827339649,
0.3441076577,
0.4207346737,
-0.2488674223,
0.3598269224,
-0.2064932734,
0.3199107051,
-0.0041755443,
0.0125571853,
-0.0972584784,
-0.9489660859,
-1.207018137,
-0.2001583874,
0.4555413127,
0.6336610913,
-0.6793659925,
0.4815633297,
-0.1245509759,
-0.6261307597,
-1.0544527769,
0.1611266434,
0.6967362761,
0.760441184,
0.3651674688,
-0.3041632473,
-0.7224225998,
-0.7313690782,
-0.2646552026,
-0.5592839718,
0.1227732003,
0.3423961997,
0.1017128006,
-0.5782356262,
0.9117645025,
-0.3309181929,
-0.6154812574,
-0.317858696,
0.0337146036,
0.0783009306,
0.383626163,
0.0808139816,
-0.852689445,
-0.8555582762,
0.1347569972,
-0.5773589015,
0.0321953073,
0.6926969886,
0.1631078422,
0.3974701464,
0.2297091931,
-0.6288312078,
0.6809155941,
0.6472979784,
-0.4257965982,
0.2185939848,
-0.2571333051,
0.1092022657,
-0.8352504373,
-0.1689335853,
-0.134563908,
-0.1991265118,
-0.8872308731,
0.1138514727,
-0.0288439542,
-0.4884687066,
-0.2682398558,
0.6579973698,
-0.4878274798,
-0.0080519347,
-0.500782609,
-0.2114710063,
-0.1437285691,
0.2263044268,
0.3837705255,
0.6716777086,
0.5008386374,
-1.0044829845,
0.2720636129,
0.3516990244,
-0.1888222247,
0.47007218,
-0.704547286,
0.2257488221,
-0.1056189761,
0.1409315765,
-0.8518468738,
-0.3169221282,
0.1722010672,
-0.5147297382,
0.4016506374,
-0.1145678908,
-0.3447594643,
-0.4601443112,
0.1485075057,
0.1116391271,
0.8017572761,
-0.5479844213,
0.8023132682,
0.9496420026,
-0.1728588194,
-0.0626873672,
-0.5753097534,
0.0906323045,
-0.4152746797,
-0.1947143376,
-0.0332830064,
-0.1584912688,
-0.4635527134,
-0.2124177665,
0.2032782286,
-0.2880472541,
0.0753634125,
0.3700543642,
0.0647931099,
-0.5418601632,
0.3210929036,
-0.1290088445,
-0.1305268109,
-0.1893669814,
-0.2902519107,
0.4880335629,
-0.0967131481,
-0.1784943789,
-0.937325418,
0.2187611312,
0.3576219976,
-0.1373979598,
0.7697438598,
0.3956645429,
-0.5144674778,
0.4258598089,
-0.8946200013,
0.1368299872,
-0.4193479121,
-0.0950721577,
-0.7287800312,
-0.6642850637,
0.2933816016,
0.2995263338,
0.0796486661,
0.6166667342,
0.242525965,
-0.2844424546,
0.9440278411,
0.9504104853,
-0.6711624265,
0.4669192731,
-0.1931681335,
0.008058615,
-0.8001182079,
-0.2032180876,
-0.7700994611,
-0.1481929272,
-0.58109653,
-0.3750397563,
0.6123379469,
-0.1150274202,
-0.0787082538,
0.350805372,
-0.4018027782,
0.3247089088,
0.7947072387,
0.3863860965,
0.6383082867,
0.1247052699,
0.0603258796,
-0.1093280017,
-0.8352809548,
-0.4716244638,
1.1377186775,
0.5325776339,
0.693900764,
0.1700045764,
0.6078132391,
0.2071064562,
0.2771265805,
-0.9539352655,
0.1961193234,
-0.5212090611,
-0.3290790617,
-0.6390455961,
-0.4450469613,
-0.9692297578,
0.2082313299,
-0.0177445039,
-0.5230209827,
0.2014380097,
0.3909130096,
-0.2637164295,
0.2464274019,
-0.8207823634,
0.5821077824,
-0.0156181296,
0.5177221298,
-0.2087152749,
-0.3323100507,
0.1434343308,
-0.0165642034,
0.3934984207,
-0.2294502407,
0.0979857221,
0.8872159719,
-0.730312407,
0.975951314,
-0.2739511132,
-0.2148134857,
0.8586245179,
-0.0545931607,
0.4487374127,
-0.2783228159,
-0.3013590872,
0.362454772,
-0.3476798534,
-0.2277685851,
-0.2046651095,
0.6188734174,
-1.1340419054,
-0.2266634703,
-0.1908524185,
-0.3608397543,
-0.3109929264,
-0.0874069333,
0.7459405065,
0.6648607254,
-0.1349947453,
0.1656553447,
0.6148655415,
-0.0618558712,
0.2470266819,
0.8289878368,
-0.0379642434,
-0.5583150387,
1.0908683538,
0.4457806647,
0.1371893287,
0.3293278515,
0.634078145,
-0.4843215644,
-0.2922605872,
-0.590837121,
0.0923228562,
-0.5420638919,
-0.3413122892,
-1.1163439751,
-0.5718035698,
-0.4216362238,
0.1018187255,
-0.473534137,
-0.6414787769,
-0.4434449971,
-0.0299846455,
0.9122154117,
0.7631483078,
0.1455187201,
0.8002897501,
-0.8580441475,
0.4285053313,
0.4824972451,
-0.0283851568,
0.0762338638,
-0.8814934492,
-0.1987955123,
0.3543973565,
-0.229687497,
-0.563149631,
0.405682832,
0.840644896,
0.4248645306,
0.0816446319,
0.0977691635,
1.1025978327,
-0.7480828762,
0.6267979145,
0.1866466403,
-1.1054799557,
1.1014363766,
-0.0637491345,
0.6603929996,
0.4781516194,
0.3411338925,
-0.3221992254,
-0.8319391012,
-0.790060401,
-0.4666186571,
0.2384861708,
0.3064483106,
0.4094196558,
0.0755719095,
0.2714813948,
0.1451962292,
0.1870458126,
-0.8523044586,
-0.3110713065,
-0.1657157987,
-0.5751119852,
-0.4954424798,
-0.3989568055,
0.2446647733,
-0.2425575405,
0.8674016595,
-0.3001147211,
0.1658686548,
0.343670249,
-0.2518835068,
-0.5318230391,
0.0464351326,
0.1858437806,
0.2833018601,
0.2783185542,
0.1046721637,
0.4037541151,
-0.7892452478,
0.219815895,
0.1117403284,
-0.5987014174,
0.3911645412,
0.5248726606,
0.8875082731,
0.4946017861,
-0.6570923924,
0.1273425668,
-0.1821851432,
0.2800796628,
-0.5646002889,
0.2496578693,
-0.0688195974,
0.1726393849,
0.4994472861,
-0.0565513,
0.2998124361,
-0.7936425209,
-0.1281572729,
0.5745696425,
-0.7148504257,
-0.2264259011,
0.75006181,
0.2399459034,
-0.5692782402,
0.6734696031,
0.3168749511,
-0.6146661043,
0.472489804,
0.549749732,
0.8265474439,
-0.7690485716,
0.1147781909,
0.4282471538,
0.1459831744,
-0.165412426,
0.5688541532,
-0.112302728,
-0.8605296612,
0.0194234885,
-0.7835043073,
-0.5551073551,
-0.0333727077,
-0.6281878352,
0.3857682645,
-0.3628287613,
-0.4481793344,
-0.0515412688,
0.1349356472,
-0.5603718162,
0.410143733,
0.1576961428,
0.780990243,
-0.6568753719,
1.0919138193,
0.6139107943,
-0.2106782645,
-0.868857801,
-0.0916445404,
0.1388610154,
-0.7737628222,
0.5373858809,
0.0791218951,
-0.3200577497,
0.2453790605,
-0.1218562871,
-1.0607055426,
0.8216693997,
0.1559675783,
-0.7030393481,
0.2724101841,
-0.0476600341,
0.5940995216,
-0.4608301818,
-0.1733984351,
0.574482739,
0.2705676556,
0.0035265584,
-1.6012727022,
-0.6169121265,
-0.1160542592,
0.1451968998,
0.1073476449,
-0.6929194331,
0.590433538,
-0.4734175801,
-0.2287764549,
0.4316968024,
0.9843098521,
0.2440515161,
0.5162645578,
0.5235072374,
0.3459855914,
0.8877055645,
-0.0161348563,
1.0160075426,
0.1181804538,
-0.1762583107,
1.1440194845,
-0.3042266369,
1.4320524931,
0.1312687993,
-0.3322393894,
0.4912244976,
0.3919194341,
0.4346976578,
0.4567554891,
-0.1153875589,
-0.491858542,
0.1738803536,
-0.4178417325,
-0.3047002256,
0.8531572819,
0.4528154731,
-0.1120636389,
0.4023350179,
0.4550049901,
-0.0216703229,
0.3570118248,
-0.6073465347,
1.1715914011,
0.4150020778,
-0.1922678798,
0.565790832,
-0.092744559,
0.7277227044,
-0.6853176355,
0.2007871717,
0.0500896163,
0.2714402974,
-0.1401240379,
-0.3654094338,
0.3672295213,
0.2875270247,
-0.1970641315,
0.1475974768,
0.9669470787,
-0.645260334,
-0.9583835602,
0.2943412662,
0.2782420516,
0.3327523768,
-0.0811161995,
-0.3450924158,
0.4868685007,
-0.079529345,
0.1116513908,
0.0430900492,
0.3130251467,
-0.0340401269,
0.8192147017,
0.7200427055,
0.3158672154,
0.2169625461,
0.2157581896,
0.6570752263,
-0.4641973376,
-0.8984434009,
-0.8347871304,
0.5895643234,
0.213823244,
-0.1957919151,
0.8647972345,
0.5203694701,
0.5832555294,
-0.1230170205,
0.6949301958,
0.1528961957,
0.9576705098,
-0.6415423155,
0.8478524685,
-0.2733117044,
-0.0576118864,
-0.4537214935,
-0.9719287157,
-0.1184641868,
0.9074164629,
-0.0181581881,
-0.3061273098,
0.1595234722,
0.3117868006,
0.0777729154,
0.1762666106,
0.5081835389,
0.3436177671,
0.0741988868,
0.2061584443,
0.7918252945,
-0.9837690592,
0.4038634896,
-0.4213926792,
-0.1155041307,
-0.2423288375,
-0.4230380654,
-0.7744130492,
-0.7469555736,
-0.7016658783,
-0.1730386317,
0.0884185359,
0.8319658041,
0.703306675,
-1.0091679096,
-0.7080578804,
0.1842757463,
0.0408954285,
0.0392730609,
-0.2375737131,
0.1913491338,
-0.0868393779,
-0.6542495489,
0.7994123101,
0.123641327,
0.4680399895,
-0.1278814375,
-0.475342989,
0.0468157455,
-0.0949074849,
0.8620428443,
0.5400314927,
-0.923818469,
-0.2783580422,
-0.2489524484,
0.0939594656,
-0.0883977786,
0.6604043245,
-0.9850620627,
0.5986315608,
0.0278927367,
0.3770681322,
0.3849824071,
-0.1140050292,
0.8110685945,
-0.5601890683,
0.3262472451,
0.1943664998,
0.3740498722,
0.5685673952,
-0.5729148984,
0.5639216304,
0.0821129605,
-0.3862656653,
-0.8778656125,
0.0535941832,
-0.5096229911,
0.218651548,
0.8114866018,
-0.1787960976,
-0.125797689,
-0.3154914379,
-0.4032733738,
0.1897033453,
-0.362937212,
0.7501270175,
0.3521885574,
-0.1404348165,
-0.3405564129,
-0.5104263425,
0.4923346639,
-0.0607139766,
-0.7502415776,
-0.2143821865,
0.4997397065,
0.2304094583,
0.3483686447,
1.1213737726,
-0.0747282654,
0.3188641369,
-0.0057619703,
-0.2897882164,
0.36169976,
-0.4473916292,
-0.5624624491,
-0.2864245474,
0.4136600494,
-0.2619531751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03052v1
|
GPT-DETOX: An In-Context Learning-Based Paraphraser for Text Detoxification
| 2024-04-03T20:35:36 | 2024-04-03T20:35:36 |
Ali Pesaranghader, Nikhil Verma, Manasa Bharadwaj
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Harmful and offensive communication or content is detrimental to social
bonding and the mental state of users on social media platforms. Text
detoxification is a crucial task in natural language processing (NLP), where
the goal is removing profanity and toxicity from text while preserving its
content. Supervised and unsupervised learning are common approaches for
designing text detoxification solutions. However, these methods necessitate
fine-tuning, leading to computational overhead. In this paper, we propose
GPT-DETOX as a framework for prompt-based in-context learning for text
detoxification using GPT-3.5 Turbo. We utilize zero-shot and few-shot prompting
techniques for detoxifying input sentences. To generate few-shot prompts, we
propose two methods: word-matching example selection (WMES) and
context-matching example selection (CMES). We additionally take into account
ensemble in-context learning (EICL) where the ensemble is shaped by base
prompts from zero-shot and all few-shot settings. We use ParaDetox and APPDIA
as benchmark detoxification datasets. Our experimental results show that the
zero-shot solution achieves promising performance, while our best few-shot
setting outperforms the state-of-the-art models on ParaDetox and shows
comparable results on APPDIA. Our EICL solutions obtain the greatest
performance, adding at least 10% improvement, against both datasets.
|
[
-0.1023060009,
-0.9035440683,
0.8490876555,
-0.0727578178,
-0.569341898,
-0.0084917648,
-0.117048949,
-0.0991848409,
-0.3572257459,
0.2373918742,
-0.482691288,
-0.6547610164,
-0.2725584507,
0.5214736462,
-0.3192653358,
1.3402488232,
0.1359849721,
-0.3279828429,
0.063088052,
0.037602149,
-0.6630173922,
-0.1719317883,
-1.0198808908,
-0.1655399799,
0.6406221986,
0.5705461502,
0.1642537117,
0.2037970871,
0.1109384149,
0.133401975,
-0.1609612554,
-0.1305872053,
-0.5472016931,
0.3808490038,
-0.4636961818,
-0.142840147,
0.4178191721,
-0.1444737315,
0.1585104167,
0.0780899599,
-0.1301609874,
-0.2076144367,
0.3012252748,
0.3484540582,
-0.773497045,
-0.1325646192,
-0.8237841725,
-0.1045278683,
0.0194830801,
-0.3170158863,
-0.4057788551,
-0.3238284886,
-0.0209403969,
-0.5460439324,
-0.0335345007,
-0.3369119167,
0.5850393772,
0.5057029724,
-0.3941202164,
-0.177388519,
-0.4447223842,
0.6754155159,
-0.757602334,
0.1098792702,
0.2652106285,
0.3703359663,
-0.0201398525,
-0.5998938084,
-0.3540392518,
0.0500633232,
-0.0458714776,
0.3303749561,
-0.0407355875,
0.0420161635,
0.0975666195,
-0.1039273068,
-0.9087330103,
-0.1115544811,
-0.2985150218,
-0.0187092274,
0.2566092014,
0.1392037421,
0.5343430042,
-0.3820486069,
-0.6994706988,
0.1196676418,
-0.7237382531,
-0.2088010609,
-0.0763419792,
0.4089480937,
0.0852714553,
0.1380097419,
-0.1981510073,
0.1541623771,
0.0293530822,
-0.1048913077,
0.3043705225,
-0.0833391994,
-0.3267547488,
0.1322155744,
0.9145361185,
0.399522692,
0.0460842997,
-0.3866358697,
0.0050412528,
-0.3167729378,
0.2593997419,
-1.1315089464,
-0.1500760317,
0.3970550001,
-0.2059425712,
-0.3388424814,
-0.169582203,
-1.0232094526,
-0.2584843636,
-0.1264780462,
0.6173925996,
-0.9564231634,
0.0127301374,
0.0197823327,
-0.6448286772,
0.2251102924,
0.3095071614,
-0.744381845,
-0.0262360945,
0.5118566155,
1.0901446342,
-0.2803625166,
-0.0686211139,
-0.5438022614,
0.2533768415,
0.0281035677,
0.7591549754,
-0.6458259821,
-0.4007173479,
-0.0349258818,
-0.1503461897,
-0.1082023755,
-0.5454494357,
0.8425844908,
-0.3545608222,
0.3017900288,
-0.4038065672,
-0.4313334227,
-0.2209663987,
0.2800870836,
-0.1994513124,
1.0202995539,
0.0214216001,
-0.8260676265,
0.3911262751,
-0.6332266927,
-0.3495244682,
0.5987903476,
0.004051907,
-0.1802121103,
0.0918181986,
0.1627868712,
0.5396796465,
-0.1040848568,
0.160265103,
-0.272110045,
-0.683807373,
-0.4063037038,
-0.5804755688,
0.9884557128,
0.5920062661,
-0.4411529899,
0.2596844733,
-0.4367297888,
0.0196436737,
-0.0663303584,
-0.1893786788,
-0.65586555,
-0.2625315487,
0.3923611343,
0.632286489,
-0.1543816179,
-0.3869140148,
-0.2000973225,
-0.4011655748,
0.6536386609,
0.5086709261,
0.7530770302,
0.2326892614,
-0.2849015296,
0.5224910975,
-0.0888540149,
-0.0069282809,
-0.2352935374,
-0.5257425308,
0.1793673187,
-0.4761927724,
-0.48588112,
0.9347849488,
-1.324942112,
0.4296463132,
-0.198654145,
-0.4313802421,
0.2228010893,
0.3230749369,
0.4136770368,
0.8063028455,
0.7847936749,
0.281218797,
-0.1202930659,
-0.5784974098,
-0.4541413784,
-0.105792515,
-0.4957916737,
0.0027934455,
0.7480545044,
-0.1063937843,
0.8583091497,
-0.2516205311,
-0.244610697,
-0.4524552226,
0.3480154276,
0.0456431657,
0.1625918746,
0.6013206244,
-0.6257894039,
-0.7535176873,
-0.123994574,
-0.7539191842,
-0.3946662247,
-0.2352514714,
-0.109838441,
-0.3191815317,
0.3197686374,
-0.5942252874,
0.3264231086,
-0.0857494473,
-0.0755032972,
0.5972585678,
-0.0627373159,
0.1481527537,
-1.1429883242,
0.1242506504,
0.3526408374,
-0.166458413,
-0.8752464652,
0.1495183855,
0.0781096369,
-0.2437645048,
-1.0155096054,
0.7824482322,
-0.0385208093,
0.7524319291,
-0.2896096706,
0.2231743932,
0.0929478779,
0.4985403717,
0.2453520149,
0.8583649397,
0.3772889674,
-0.6476289034,
-0.0215713419,
0.3460049629,
-0.0171921663,
0.9309079051,
-0.5393756032,
0.1881903559,
-0.2833817601,
0.5859044194,
-0.9627407789,
-0.3672942221,
0.6632199883,
0.0390003286,
-0.0007923816,
0.0056477515,
-0.4387687743,
-0.221520707,
-0.6426772475,
0.3497315347,
0.5113971233,
-0.6108623147,
0.0786851868,
-0.080024235,
-0.1552511305,
-0.4213221967,
-0.2908386886,
0.294469893,
-0.8849570155,
0.0074534942,
0.3676811457,
-0.1020542085,
-0.1419773698,
-0.3531823456,
-0.0778094977,
-0.1754061878,
0.1140180379,
-0.0586085059,
-0.0164226964,
0.3539524972,
0.3467786908,
0.4963932931,
-0.032078322,
-0.0044004023,
-0.10242448,
0.3159139454,
-0.0988317132,
0.1416332126,
-0.5875067711,
0.5389401317,
0.3939230442,
0.0413904823,
0.6489877701,
0.7499545813,
-0.4408851862,
-0.2413911521,
-0.1140928045,
-0.2720171511,
-0.4749454558,
0.2829125822,
-0.3291707635,
-0.6438894868,
0.3443095982,
-0.0783866644,
0.0432770848,
0.2499991059,
0.596306622,
-0.0366124958,
0.8574331403,
0.1295644939,
-0.1054439396,
0.6189646721,
0.0195639133,
0.1250475049,
-0.6545469165,
0.1652210802,
-0.4465668201,
-0.1996577084,
-0.2289882749,
-0.1420561522,
0.4954165816,
0.1559584439,
-0.7391166687,
0.4753388762,
-0.6669316292,
0.8128635883,
0.4149623811,
0.3207941651,
0.1596146822,
0.0162867904,
-0.1801646501,
0.0415594578,
-0.4218098819,
-0.6937307715,
0.7233693004,
0.0918208808,
0.4106601179,
-0.0620754547,
1.0584552288,
0.056453947,
0.4881335497,
-0.5565219522,
0.4410152435,
-0.043100886,
-0.8226239681,
-0.3409335911,
-0.4778816104,
-0.5302317739,
0.309404254,
0.2543328702,
-1.1299363375,
0.0360132232,
-0.202758655,
-0.5579907894,
0.3507316411,
-0.7159187198,
0.9761523604,
-0.0313354656,
-0.634126246,
0.0834679008,
-0.9183971286,
0.4930611551,
-0.2529226542,
0.2399794608,
-0.1515644044,
-0.0043748813,
0.4236305058,
-0.2975977063,
0.6821250319,
-0.4313361645,
-0.1670195907,
0.5029370785,
0.032950338,
0.4823096991,
0.329449147,
-0.2196987271,
0.0121218842,
0.2622203529,
-0.1181364357,
-0.4612891078,
0.6522388458,
-0.3299976885,
-0.346228838,
-0.04428076,
-0.3239835501,
-0.229171142,
0.2966452837,
0.6393251419,
0.2475305647,
-0.1128766313,
0.2598930001,
0.5900228024,
-0.6258910894,
0.6777795553,
-0.0283420216,
0.0949841812,
-0.3015677929,
0.993704915,
-0.467751652,
0.2005992532,
0.5818068981,
0.4508032203,
-0.4444747269,
-0.3491810262,
-0.4474133253,
0.0272120368,
-0.7746558785,
-0.3079559207,
-0.5724828839,
-0.0006256786,
-0.174654752,
-0.2885980308,
0.1522830874,
0.0941105112,
-0.5312340856,
-0.2610786855,
0.3607480228,
0.2626397312,
-0.0240156036,
0.5575264692,
-0.7606341243,
0.351213038,
0.1109461039,
0.0071012322,
-0.2623167932,
-0.5953071713,
0.0495864265,
-0.0330118574,
-0.4694546759,
-1.2624332905,
0.5499168038,
0.3475817144,
0.3849520981,
0.7249979377,
0.3005527556,
0.5189643502,
-0.6024116278,
0.952976644,
0.07529217,
-0.7414839864,
0.6561963558,
-0.643748045,
0.3900881708,
1.1582944393,
0.4832366109,
-0.8508470058,
-0.7533680201,
-0.3378777206,
-0.9377856255,
0.3763161004,
0.3388896883,
0.3745582104,
-0.7015063763,
0.5120347142,
0.359724462,
0.171931088,
-0.5688848495,
-0.1156297401,
-0.2882655263,
-0.543394208,
0.0835644156,
-0.0706921965,
-0.0089254249,
-0.3236455917,
0.8392298222,
-0.0900580063,
0.1226509064,
0.0626239702,
-0.3047068715,
0.2068365216,
0.6590503454,
0.3689562678,
0.3544487655,
-0.4124524295,
0.1529809386,
0.321791321,
-0.4783292413,
0.4469079971,
-0.1444474161,
-0.306104511,
-0.1146435216,
-0.0249973498,
0.5939696431,
0.2862430811,
-0.7431668639,
0.4598735273,
-0.0035928257,
-0.3041755557,
0.1949888766,
0.1467288435,
-0.183343038,
-0.0065478589,
0.6093859076,
-0.2365971059,
0.4663828611,
-0.391792953,
0.5048093796,
0.4376277924,
-0.5987266898,
-0.2305162102,
1.0915504694,
0.1430987269,
-0.0470589325,
0.5066898465,
-0.4782401323,
-0.4204083383,
0.3185318112,
0.6178507209,
1.397792697,
-0.0904056951,
0.5488225818,
0.5419074893,
0.1444188803,
0.0011740208,
-0.0689456761,
-0.2605059743,
-0.4184783101,
-0.2272096574,
-0.5503899455,
-0.1429712474,
0.4739135802,
-0.4077502489,
0.1516654193,
-0.5104490519,
0.1551004946,
-0.3203555942,
-0.1119627059,
-0.5177695155,
0.1594752669,
0.1670021713,
0.7734421492,
-1.2658016682,
0.6056298018,
0.5079361796,
-0.6612832546,
-0.5409753323,
0.3933089375,
0.4126371443,
-0.2296782434,
0.4230628312,
0.7288506627,
-0.182335034,
0.297141999,
-0.5125184059,
-0.2737875581,
0.9895680547,
0.4017328322,
-0.235794872,
-0.0650117695,
-0.224846527,
0.6000506878,
0.0268517341,
0.6325303316,
0.4807909131,
0.3441230655,
0.3239539862,
-0.4507043958,
0.366615504,
-0.1577841192,
0.117236726,
-0.1066839397,
-0.3776912689,
0.3664627671,
0.0967659205,
-0.5019663572,
-0.070838742,
0.2846611738,
0.2861079574,
0.2203617543,
0.4680658877,
0.5669046044,
0.6221839786,
0.3270072937,
0.8793793321,
-0.202516228,
0.282387048,
1.1661343575,
-0.4754627943,
0.699629724,
0.5253682733,
0.029927697,
0.5626986027,
0.6865774989,
0.3689011335,
0.9455003142,
-0.0853152797,
-0.7006807923,
-0.1413570046,
0.0479377881,
-0.1119723022,
0.0451558866,
0.3901748061,
-0.3249519467,
-0.9238944054,
0.247518599,
0.0858602077,
-0.1059650108,
-0.1621786356,
0.8298705816,
0.1637361795,
-0.4150477946,
0.5120962262,
-0.1230754927,
0.6542872787,
-0.410046339,
0.0088010402,
-0.2502510548,
-0.130983457,
-0.0624419153,
-0.605460465,
0.4352306724,
0.0625803769,
0.2007351518,
-0.5023864508,
0.8853325844,
-0.390471518,
-0.1705171913,
0.1483460814,
0.5134474039,
0.416225493,
-0.5922334194,
-0.8803101778,
-0.3845513761,
-0.1238549575,
-0.3012987673,
0.349060744,
0.5358038545,
-0.12667346,
0.4609520137,
0.4534883499,
-0.2346814424,
-0.1822278947,
0.1639941931,
0.6121893525,
-0.4735552371,
-0.4670936465,
-1.1690192223,
0.4733735919,
-0.0730963051,
-0.4122851491,
0.7212939262,
0.6654290557,
0.4780513346,
-0.0639054105,
0.8979567289,
-0.0083095627,
0.4132753909,
-0.2860254645,
0.7952846289,
-0.4486184418,
0.0882010907,
-0.5692152381,
-0.8602963686,
-0.4584153295,
0.6173498631,
-0.4277967811,
0.0962301716,
0.9418569803,
0.7114101648,
0.0071025044,
0.0428592488,
0.332474798,
-0.1393138468,
0.4468698502,
0.6456116438,
0.6063222885,
-0.3416755795,
0.6434293985,
-0.2501572073,
-0.2422620356,
-0.1074421555,
-0.9355796576,
-0.9185522199,
-0.5623047948,
-0.3157760501,
-0.0342283584,
0.1157928482,
0.9238707423,
0.2925617397,
-0.6004372835,
0.3597624898,
-0.4456827343,
0.2717144787,
-0.6163012981,
-0.3092962503,
0.2236095518,
-0.6654167175,
-0.7221073508,
0.5339338779,
0.3702265918,
-0.2318037748,
0.2741598487,
0.2123153508,
-0.258346051,
0.0224990398,
0.5928044319,
0.332287401,
-0.5084632039,
-0.6749333143,
-0.3844421804,
-0.1959115565,
0.115130052,
0.3319400847,
-0.7112617493,
0.1242963225,
0.5935035944,
0.5889853239,
0.353559047,
0.4023548365,
0.1987704933,
-1.081766963,
0.0102895899,
0.1150055379,
-0.022744244,
0.2305987775,
-0.4755631685,
0.3428679109,
0.2762006521,
-0.4464964271,
-0.5997967124,
0.0690362304,
-0.7569862604,
-0.5111076832,
1.4578174353,
-0.041101519,
-0.3120442033,
-0.4793305397,
-0.328571111,
0.2817711532,
-0.606122613,
0.6537736654,
0.5833440423,
0.03790861,
-0.2086596936,
-0.9003292322,
0.6432743073,
0.037177287,
-1.1150112152,
0.0701025948,
0.4727270901,
0.7097138166,
-0.1616903991,
0.5939882398,
0.0080057774,
0.0662684962,
-0.3267541826,
-0.0987380147,
0.1145161539,
-0.3313863277,
-0.5109354258,
0.1374692172,
-0.6495190263,
-0.0526748188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03049v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03049v1
|
Language, Environment, and Robotic Navigation
| 2024-04-03T20:30:38 | 2024-04-03T20:30:38 |
Johnathan E. Avery
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores the integration of linguistic inputs within robotic
navigation systems, drawing upon the symbol interdependency hypothesis to
bridge the divide between symbolic and embodied cognition. It examines previous
work incorporating language and semantics into Neural Network (NN) and
Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) approaches, highlighting how these
integrations have advanced the field. By contrasting abstract symbol
manipulation with sensory-motor grounding, we propose a unified framework where
language functions both as an abstract communicative system and as a grounded
representation of perceptual experiences. Our review of cognitive models of
distributional semantics and their application to autonomous agents underscores
the transformative potential of language-integrated systems.
|
[
-0.4406163096,
-0.5595803857,
0.9340926409,
0.0752551556,
-0.1083015427,
0.3871524036,
-0.2048077434,
-0.4079948366,
0.5223378539,
0.6180369854,
-0.6140220761,
-0.4451919496,
-0.7866618633,
-0.2351169437,
-0.3844833374,
0.4323463142,
0.0020661785,
-0.1341675669,
0.0119903302,
-0.6360758543,
-0.6089665294,
-0.6737038493,
-0.2038617879,
-0.6020454168,
0.3283312917,
0.045028951,
1.2337756157,
0.3367548883,
0.5977312922,
0.3049689531,
0.1842027307,
0.0685671717,
0.1933419108,
0.2708255053,
-0.3985644877,
-0.4666302204,
-0.1151795834,
-0.0125151509,
0.5898504853,
1.0368468761,
0.133969292,
-0.3549802005,
-0.0121216886,
0.4905234575,
-0.6021808386,
0.6081290245,
-0.0704059228,
0.0487517975,
0.2662882507,
-0.3391585052,
-0.1177147329,
-0.1169496775,
0.1229052246,
-0.9888886809,
-0.4515842199,
-0.0080719683,
0.8042131066,
0.7439233661,
-0.5122634768,
-0.5814436078,
-0.8591207862,
0.6770964265,
-0.4667909443,
0.5193712115,
0.31458956,
0.2076696903,
-0.2575325072,
-0.4663054347,
-0.8180068731,
-0.6434786916,
-0.2016422004,
0.4317417145,
-0.4234726429,
0.4730522633,
-0.0597355068,
-0.2580877841,
-0.2729833126,
0.079285495,
-0.2417772263,
0.1798813939,
0.5149971843,
0.0520820655,
1.1120576859,
0.0184776299,
-0.3273215294,
-0.4587939978,
-0.7048257589,
-0.20323129,
0.4377163351,
0.7828401327,
-0.2451741695,
0.7456067801,
-0.1979124695,
0.8545629978,
-0.4175381958,
0.0166200642,
0.1669555604,
-0.3924687207,
-0.0228973962,
0.2748389244,
0.7999144197,
0.3964318037,
0.4533469379,
-0.2985472381,
-0.1333837956,
0.538002193,
0.5296106935,
0.2359533757,
-0.2068492621,
0.1855404973,
-0.2052916437,
0.0110000996,
0.3317784667,
-0.1227786168,
-0.2822416723,
-0.5806281567,
0.3477146327,
-0.4172667861,
-0.5518173575,
0.5854961276,
-0.3349574208,
0.1653105021,
0.4226978123,
-0.8849301338,
0.575078845,
0.8719694018,
0.682256043,
0.2211924493,
-0.4150680304,
-0.0822351053,
0.2721934319,
-0.3015611172,
0.8376818895,
-0.698322773,
-0.5088156462,
-0.004361005,
0.1639424264,
-0.0582403131,
-0.5212261677,
0.1487077177,
-0.5142844915,
-0.0783750266,
-0.1336344182,
-0.0079968534,
-0.8785775304,
0.1283912212,
-0.7620067,
0.8800491095,
0.259748131,
-0.0720377788,
0.1858531684,
-0.951264143,
-0.7136618495,
0.222494483,
-0.449729979,
0.3541823328,
0.0256627519,
-0.1397726685,
0.1528478116,
-0.3451547921,
0.2433204651,
-0.0612435192,
-0.3759914637,
-0.0096851513,
-0.0138145965,
0.8464198709,
0.0750186965,
-0.5320657492,
0.1597295851,
-0.3327782452,
-0.1681443453,
-0.0194258913,
-0.1942269951,
-0.6561079025,
0.3648560047,
0.0334057771,
0.2754778564,
0.2394819707,
-0.2091442943,
0.3289526105,
-0.702662468,
0.2896177471,
0.5222681761,
-0.331981957,
1.1507250071,
0.0413562246,
0.6548721194,
0.0951174125,
-0.2057256699,
-0.2226123959,
-0.5682087541,
-0.8290569782,
0.0552894622,
-0.140816018,
0.8125366569,
-0.9249515533,
0.7501519918,
-0.3299086392,
-0.0338042974,
-0.2256896049,
-0.2941614687,
0.1818227023,
0.0606760606,
0.2565918565,
-0.2802343965,
-0.3140915334,
-0.5831670761,
0.0605733506,
-0.6302986145,
-0.1954760998,
0.2658244073,
0.4738868773,
-0.4251363873,
0.7609315515,
-0.1534347981,
-0.203661114,
-0.2328172475,
0.0805064589,
0.2622798085,
0.6475934982,
0.5511265397,
-0.85451895,
0.1307523251,
0.4890189767,
-1.2876768112,
-0.1506674439,
-0.2715965807,
-0.0600226931,
-0.1815721989,
0.5603432059,
-0.6349369287,
0.5553750992,
0.5540693402,
-0.4347465634,
-0.1249626726,
-0.4237946868,
0.2496206909,
-0.6411726475,
-0.3488641977,
-0.1657797545,
0.1702830046,
-0.3908559978,
0.519623518,
-0.2523916662,
0.2094949782,
-0.3494669795,
0.7271867394,
-0.741882503,
-0.3512898684,
-0.5535099506,
0.6492989659,
-0.1557909995,
0.1741280854,
0.2010655105,
0.3837385774,
0.62545681,
-0.8484025598,
0.7374046445,
0.1421436071,
-0.0440965109,
0.5891422629,
-0.5799483657,
-0.3033437133,
-0.2185871601,
0.300765723,
-1.0500477552,
-0.081816107,
0.6224162579,
-0.4555424154,
-0.1952187866,
-0.0210601091,
-0.7657718658,
-0.1368103921,
0.2994627059,
0.6171227098,
0.5375824571,
-0.371563673,
0.9747962356,
0.5730681419,
0.2097949535,
-0.3092897236,
-0.7841979861,
0.333856672,
-0.0409424789,
-0.6389495134,
-0.104129456,
0.3183875084,
-0.7461014986,
0.0465878472,
-0.0906262323,
0.0514330715,
0.3656174242,
0.5907638669,
0.3178490102,
-0.3622505367,
0.3324649334,
0.2578502297,
-0.4483031631,
0.1792606115,
-0.7174267173,
0.518465817,
-0.0821043402,
-0.7286352515,
-0.2916186154,
0.3950844705,
0.6278268099,
-0.1646377444,
0.7018570304,
-0.1285842061,
-0.2964178622,
0.0820942894,
-0.0234312881,
-0.349576205,
-0.4510435164,
0.1568885297,
-0.3956978619,
-0.5984005332,
0.4019603729,
-0.575396657,
-0.2303695232,
0.3321629465,
0.3133767545,
-0.3190412521,
0.41040802,
0.6999464035,
0.1263807565,
0.2700483501,
-0.3302526474,
0.6772686243,
-0.8399565816,
-0.322964102,
-0.3532633185,
-0.6608312726,
-0.7243201733,
-0.705052793,
0.442858547,
-0.0338513292,
-0.4418775141,
0.5245560408,
-0.5734035969,
0.3465393484,
0.7670312524,
-0.1118456796,
0.2049084157,
-0.4239044189,
-0.287124604,
0.2908037007,
-0.8415137529,
-0.8479114175,
0.7908661366,
0.0158923026,
0.9140517116,
0.086534813,
0.5033202171,
0.032748282,
-0.1287377477,
-0.7119107246,
0.8079821467,
-0.0861885175,
-0.268071115,
-0.3525455892,
0.1435277015,
-1.1193133593,
0.362749666,
-0.2309287935,
-0.8532834649,
0.2771110833,
-0.2387575954,
-0.3075918853,
0.3175460994,
-0.5746394992,
0.4950943887,
-0.3737872243,
0.0063590873,
-0.1247656941,
-1.040133357,
0.100079082,
0.3028523326,
0.3010162413,
-0.2902419269,
-0.2436430603,
0.4569327533,
-0.2524967194,
0.7570220828,
0.002641506,
-0.2627446055,
0.3414140642,
0.2466082424,
0.089254871,
-0.1332658678,
0.2247079909,
0.5139248371,
-0.2962801754,
-0.265054822,
-0.9352898598,
0.5867125392,
-0.7711282372,
-0.3582065701,
-0.6611804366,
-0.7216749191,
0.0247852206,
0.1484214962,
-0.201063633,
0.1365125179,
-0.0899169073,
-0.0685098022,
0.6916555166,
-0.4360776246,
0.4486303031,
0.4372889698,
-0.2954259813,
0.0745378882,
0.6249915957,
0.0944531634,
0.3613291383,
0.7326171994,
-0.1725273728,
-0.2658722103,
-0.0456014238,
-0.332937777,
0.2351079732,
-0.9556748867,
0.1250236183,
-0.698987484,
-0.2229707092,
-0.089019917,
-0.7925382853,
-0.4467187524,
-0.5235348344,
-0.2090626955,
-0.2202860266,
0.2135079503,
1.165212512,
-0.2429348677,
0.7315289974,
-0.5912285447,
0.4971536696,
-0.1020191014,
-0.0919307917,
-0.0698382407,
-0.1349389255,
-0.0970543548,
0.3326136768,
0.0188042875,
-0.753459692,
0.1349078566,
-0.3270610571,
0.738083005,
0.0675151497,
0.1050587893,
0.3022398651,
-0.3537483513,
0.9554163218,
0.282110244,
-0.844812274,
0.6804988384,
-0.4731859565,
0.6640941501,
0.1957713813,
0.3016771972,
-0.6437187791,
-0.8360341191,
-0.5366128683,
-1.0404881239,
0.3957096636,
0.1390812397,
0.1647670269,
-0.1105108485,
0.1064306423,
-0.2318210155,
0.0265130792,
-0.6274600625,
-0.4412686527,
0.0756310448,
-0.2696114182,
-0.3141387105,
0.247037977,
-0.3181072772,
-0.0919781998,
0.2033052593,
-0.2872838974,
0.418166697,
-0.0923672616,
-0.25001508,
0.2679804564,
-0.2411632985,
0.5736426115,
0.3497514129,
0.3289593458,
0.4281352162,
-0.1783316731,
-0.3701682389,
0.5537284613,
-0.2590254843,
-0.0680465549,
0.1229191199,
0.5220926404,
0.5641727448,
0.5145540833,
-0.5622617006,
0.1666864753,
0.3096814454,
0.0745104626,
-0.1246106252,
0.0793949291,
0.1977243274,
0.4977095723,
0.1613344252,
0.2724033594,
0.1240310892,
-0.6588174105,
0.066428028,
0.5285311341,
-0.4418563247,
-0.4172607362,
0.7004183531,
0.121343106,
-0.260676384,
0.6285642982,
0.1238555387,
-0.5043543577,
0.8119331598,
0.1266810894,
1.0459651947,
-0.1009619609,
0.1762432158,
0.3335543573,
0.8555877209,
-0.2014794052,
0.3288817704,
-0.436160177,
-0.9492937922,
-0.1565619707,
-0.345413059,
-0.3790640831,
-0.8878914714,
-0.343169868,
0.1002885923,
-0.4088512063,
-0.0407985635,
-0.2865888774,
-0.6457127929,
-0.5207413435,
0.4525610507,
0.2733376622,
0.3476460874,
-0.9953795075,
0.7473804951,
0.9051573873,
-0.8291006088,
-0.6506184936,
0.0873477757,
-0.052266933,
-0.8284302354,
1.526578784,
-0.2165587246,
-0.8945820332,
-0.3761918843,
-0.4461301863,
-1.0957733393,
0.828050673,
0.2887201607,
-0.0123062041,
0.0181110762,
0.3599951863,
0.4225962758,
-0.3952747881,
0.3315239251,
0.5306284428,
0.6799067259,
-0.0820994899,
-1.0466076136,
0.0167565793,
-0.0884010643,
0.1628506631,
0.3012619019,
-0.7880813479,
0.8080340028,
0.088046886,
-0.4191204906,
-0.0624905005,
0.4928667843,
0.1871245205,
0.1551781595,
0.1933911443,
0.5557027459,
0.4709790945,
-0.4809203446,
1.0197327137,
-0.4006482065,
0.0423987657,
0.9451512098,
-0.3447779715,
0.4675439894,
0.7050413489,
-0.0249164794,
0.8304995298,
0.1715695411,
0.6556262374,
0.6223438382,
0.4495684505,
-0.5846242309,
0.0109318336,
-0.045327343,
-0.2864596844,
0.6917302608,
0.5218915343,
-0.0243936926,
-0.3232321143,
0.4714778364,
-0.1300329417,
0.2857654989,
0.0132300705,
0.8465172648,
0.2120290548,
-0.5937619805,
0.2732732296,
-0.3023912311,
0.5012598634,
-0.7314808965,
-0.3188172877,
-0.0593453422,
0.0549300201,
0.0241585802,
-1.0547078848,
0.3980131149,
-0.7032473683,
0.0897552371,
-0.7033063173,
0.5692625642,
-0.1146610528,
-0.1802951843,
0.8495849967,
0.6024465561,
0.2354464382,
0.0180493835,
-0.3510057628,
0.4498140514,
-0.4872077405,
0.0308564175,
0.0686725974,
0.7141884565,
0.0055797766,
1.0490140915,
0.3989919126,
-0.0933007747,
0.1900682151,
-0.2152594477,
0.8039814234,
-1.0340315104,
-0.6452436447,
-0.6769073009,
0.5007342696,
0.4117033482,
-0.1204858348,
0.7603634596,
0.2600671053,
0.9874830246,
-0.0835338384,
0.8942956328,
-0.0863286853,
-0.2207557559,
-0.5651267171,
0.7655224204,
-0.5717111826,
0.131396994,
-0.4209340513,
-0.7402902246,
-0.5396198034,
1.0875610113,
-0.3481954336,
0.069257915,
0.7585483193,
0.5755025148,
-0.0549403727,
-0.1193304658,
0.5410563946,
-0.184864834,
0.1914605051,
0.600566268,
1.1615824699,
-0.6727587581,
-0.3029867113,
0.0464256741,
-0.1308173388,
-0.137465179,
-0.6098374724,
-0.2086045891,
-0.9061028361,
-0.2915737629,
-0.3914766312,
0.209972322,
0.7726531029,
0.7692351937,
-0.3069939613,
-0.8191313148,
-0.2988317013,
0.3886836469,
-0.2346948683,
-0.1607074291,
-0.2059902251,
-0.3230497539,
-0.8108387589,
0.6630600095,
1.068674922,
0.064737916,
-0.4892632663,
-0.291991353,
-0.4492688775,
0.083907634,
0.6768185496,
0.4480021894,
-1.0836337805,
-0.4178371727,
0.0527330078,
-0.078913115,
0.1166050211,
0.7624202371,
-1.0632886887,
0.7346341014,
0.2512644827,
0.7033124566,
0.0855144113,
-0.3331813216,
0.8559131026,
-0.2070110291,
0.7884741426,
0.3809079826,
0.2379615903,
0.0960497558,
-0.2505048513,
0.8143113256,
0.1667446643,
-0.2649896145,
-0.4596170485,
0.4096801579,
-1.3124418259,
-0.2916859686,
1.1141645908,
0.018883504,
-0.3232967257,
-0.097942017,
-0.2537972033,
0.2276510596,
-0.0562787876,
0.3314958513,
0.8129345179,
-0.2326124758,
-0.1056516245,
-0.6861836314,
-0.1943122745,
0.2460934073,
-0.7342841625,
-0.3830776811,
0.5664951801,
-0.2230381817,
0.4622101486,
0.6655849814,
0.1986405104,
0.3056115508,
0.3452072144,
0.3696122468,
0.5339996815,
-0.3992261291,
-0.2521731555,
-0.0538546704,
-0.1209531501,
-0.6263002157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03048v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03048v2
|
Decentralised Moderation for Interoperable Social Networks: A Conversation-based Approach for Pleroma and the Fediverse
| 2024-04-03T20:29:40 | 2024-04-16T23:59:51 |
Vibhor Agarwal, Aravindh Raman, Nishanth Sastry, Ahmed M. Abdelmoniem, Gareth Tyson, Ignacio Castro
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
The recent development of decentralised and interoperable social networks
(such as the "fediverse") creates new challenges for content moderators. This
is because millions of posts generated on one server can easily "spread" to
another, even if the recipient server has very different moderation policies.
An obvious solution would be to leverage moderation tools to automatically tag
(and filter) posts that contravene moderation policies, e.g. related to toxic
speech. Recent work has exploited the conversational context of a post to
improve this automatic tagging, e.g. using the replies to a post to help
classify if it contains toxic speech. This has shown particular potential in
environments with large training sets that contain complete conversations.
This, however, creates challenges in a decentralised context, as a single
conversation may be fragmented across multiple servers. Thus, each server only
has a partial view of an entire conversation because conversations are often
federated across servers in a non-synchronized fashion. To address this, we
propose a decentralised conversation-aware content moderation approach suitable
for the fediverse. Our approach employs a graph deep learning model (GraphNLI)
trained locally on each server. The model exploits local data to train a model
that combines post and conversational information captured through random walks
to detect toxicity. We evaluate our approach with data from Pleroma, a major
decentralised and interoperable micro-blogging network containing 2 million
conversations. Our model effectively detects toxicity on larger instances,
exclusively trained using their local post information (0.8837 macro-F1). Our
approach has considerable scope to improve moderation in decentralised and
interoperable social networks such as Pleroma or Mastodon.
|
[
-0.5817064047,
-1.0849449635,
0.4833970666,
0.2315354645,
-0.3618682623,
0.1276460737,
-0.3163978755,
-0.5133506656,
0.7031923532,
0.6583886147,
-0.576592207,
-0.6695011854,
-0.5813990235,
0.0021189558,
-0.340331763,
1.0373414755,
0.1036516353,
-0.0318536647,
-0.4429197907,
-0.4393046796,
-0.5688624978,
-0.2246188074,
-0.8938344717,
-0.4860778749,
0.6943743825,
0.4469621181,
0.637342751,
0.3964447081,
0.6218060255,
0.3771856725,
-0.3336221278,
0.5060528517,
-0.7327392697,
0.3680311143,
-0.462041527,
-0.1704512388,
-0.4514394104,
0.032101661,
0.3536296189,
0.7481712103,
-0.1171178147,
-0.0206987876,
0.0332510024,
0.3345458806,
-0.3737202585,
0.4476298392,
-0.4356381893,
0.2443169355,
0.1110099852,
-0.2604778111,
-0.3305236399,
-0.1767208278,
-0.0229353011,
-0.3792906404,
-0.2153334767,
-0.1169253811,
0.4608332515,
-0.1422635764,
-0.293598026,
-0.3951660097,
-0.8078380227,
0.535985589,
-0.5848557353,
0.1976641715,
0.4791092873,
0.086363025,
-0.2859070599,
-1.0548443794,
-0.3503651917,
0.0288540106,
-0.3157996535,
0.14254345,
-0.2197744548,
0.2488606274,
0.0009627076,
0.3754974604,
-0.3599976003,
0.2190607339,
-0.0681858435,
-0.2194139361,
0.6407431364,
0.2892625928,
0.2261887789,
-0.4051347375,
-0.2074642479,
0.1599883586,
-0.3624388874,
-0.0150654018,
0.6226379275,
0.314678967,
-0.0464579463,
0.200075686,
-0.4663144648,
0.6464941502,
0.20098719,
-0.0873934329,
-0.0131599912,
-0.6965389848,
-0.08249145,
0.0799355507,
1.0310012102,
0.4427307248,
-0.3287659585,
-0.1476911604,
-0.0562959053,
0.1415765584,
0.1752670258,
-0.9924461842,
-0.5587983727,
0.3437291384,
-0.3839041889,
-0.5323544145,
0.1335369498,
-0.5920909047,
-0.6572886109,
0.0004821079,
0.2669381201,
0.0085740788,
-0.4719258249,
-0.004036082,
0.1072823778,
-0.2198101878,
0.2672018409,
-0.7353647351,
0.4217528403,
1.0166056156,
1.0822741985,
0.2135712355,
0.086140655,
-0.6114525199,
0.0501194112,
-0.1159176826,
0.7342043519,
-0.5816968083,
-0.2971860766,
0.0169149376,
0.3176863194,
0.0187628679,
-0.4554799199,
0.4675935209,
-0.6511982083,
0.418153137,
-0.3729108274,
-0.6961235404,
-0.1411102712,
0.465190351,
-0.5341614485,
0.4051724076,
0.1034866273,
-1.0303993225,
0.1173363402,
-0.6628363729,
-0.6056851745,
0.2585311532,
-0.0328424945,
-0.4010104835,
-0.2756352127,
-0.036986839,
0.4596569538,
-0.1242557913,
0.6099123955,
-0.6653368473,
-0.4492169023,
0.1324240118,
-0.2864853144,
0.8410437703,
0.3947844207,
-0.2610076964,
0.6174769402,
-0.1220251173,
-0.0236840323,
-0.1122422963,
-0.0260265358,
-0.3131094277,
0.1481927335,
-0.1615532935,
0.0583591312,
0.0288440846,
-0.7641791105,
-0.1927288771,
-0.3550272882,
1.1011414528,
0.7025387883,
0.3577008843,
0.6303058267,
-0.7685526609,
0.0616434403,
0.1416817605,
0.6908190846,
-0.2118653059,
-0.4520152211,
-0.6039465666,
-0.1427324861,
0.1330652684,
0.3816629648,
-0.8395683169,
0.6691426635,
-0.1753526032,
-0.6862983704,
-0.2275565565,
0.2347353399,
0.1777559072,
0.6359869838,
-0.0365004577,
-0.6497143507,
-0.4749094248,
-0.5336623192,
0.2104216367,
-0.4037364423,
0.2224971056,
0.564686954,
0.322176218,
-0.5234963894,
0.7636521459,
-0.1142231077,
-0.616376698,
-0.0571613461,
0.0829807743,
0.0238197129,
0.590927422,
0.2847708166,
-0.8131328821,
-0.5634589791,
0.2056857049,
-0.8252899051,
-0.323728472,
0.1371002048,
-0.2039397061,
-0.1263258755,
0.5075868368,
-0.4028809369,
-0.0486558229,
0.7600989938,
-0.1711835563,
0.0933672786,
-0.122413069,
0.246577397,
-1.2301414013,
0.0372717828,
-0.189081043,
-0.61620754,
-0.5227858424,
-0.0503580421,
-0.380489409,
-0.1883637458,
-0.3314626515,
0.3429345787,
0.0151612731,
0.0624176711,
-0.1888290197,
0.2390489578,
0.2292662263,
0.2349618971,
-0.0472414158,
0.6289403439,
0.2411269993,
-0.21669586,
0.6983255744,
0.3950509727,
-0.2148007303,
0.8574383855,
-0.5337688327,
0.1704555899,
-0.2049369961,
0.5672523379,
-0.9747003913,
-0.3708528876,
0.5576661825,
-0.1293860525,
-0.1118400171,
-0.15119721,
-0.571197927,
-0.2274950594,
-0.2443640083,
0.1834234595,
0.158702448,
-0.3430095017,
0.2893112004,
0.7859959602,
-0.3181304634,
-0.1423426569,
-0.3894367218,
0.1587724984,
-0.1317330897,
-0.8306211233,
0.0900342986,
-0.2904050648,
-0.1696515381,
0.201083675,
0.0273515899,
-0.1015085578,
0.3196752667,
0.5043436289,
-0.2548932433,
-0.1159589514,
0.1575383097,
0.1976310015,
-0.0314810947,
0.1368551254,
-0.2080889642,
0.9123849869,
-0.2747693956,
-0.2918821573,
-0.8953186274,
0.4631022513,
0.5650482774,
-0.224829182,
0.6521931887,
0.6101064682,
-0.0883531645,
-0.2425411344,
-0.4317685962,
-0.4953553379,
-0.5304793119,
-0.0236734189,
0.1541449726,
-1.1485897303,
0.7248613238,
-0.2587285936,
-0.0522566102,
0.0220164936,
0.3308220506,
-0.3699112236,
1.1205251217,
0.5754784346,
0.1003918648,
0.9749556184,
-0.3673648238,
0.2497811913,
-0.4968616068,
-0.196169436,
-0.147822395,
-0.4904943407,
-0.618003428,
-0.3724903166,
0.2359229922,
-0.1581142545,
-0.2979080975,
0.1839109063,
-0.4317262769,
0.4731301069,
0.4102017581,
0.4142937362,
0.4100377262,
-0.0561796576,
0.1791910082,
0.1621343344,
-0.9409193397,
-0.2920156419,
0.5801585913,
0.365563184,
0.6340051889,
-0.0722010657,
0.7260831594,
0.5086305737,
0.8314678669,
-0.7084165812,
0.4685976803,
-0.1896448731,
-0.4773455858,
-0.0456528552,
-0.7045176029,
-0.770078063,
0.0536821559,
-0.2768686414,
-0.3834735453,
0.2256594598,
-0.1642164737,
-0.3202652335,
0.554815948,
-0.5668839812,
0.987065196,
0.0995836928,
-0.4037202299,
-0.2357643247,
-0.5998048782,
0.1603685021,
0.0054873982,
0.2392970026,
-0.2310165614,
0.4211858809,
0.7045751214,
-0.5987090468,
1.0206075907,
-0.2200307548,
0.0826253965,
0.5224651694,
0.1115710065,
0.4780905247,
0.4431454241,
0.0795217007,
0.3971711397,
0.1642704755,
-0.2219293565,
-0.362855047,
0.8512491584,
-0.806299746,
-0.5091727972,
-0.0716829225,
-0.5020043254,
-0.2041188627,
0.4298546314,
0.1962080151,
0.356105864,
-0.2278036922,
0.5621648431,
0.688085258,
-0.1060742512,
0.2756402194,
0.5067243576,
-0.2182330191,
-0.6648712754,
0.6873814464,
0.0976126492,
0.3088259995,
0.0458788611,
0.1880064607,
-0.0916425064,
-0.3653742671,
-0.0133473938,
0.1524154097,
-0.71822083,
-0.5037744641,
-0.8332024217,
-0.3204213381,
-0.2790975571,
-0.2569155097,
-0.386944741,
0.2611581087,
-0.3355325162,
-0.0979532152,
0.3513471186,
0.5628470182,
-0.2607636452,
0.7259280086,
-0.5949755907,
-0.1830508262,
0.3918341994,
0.7779964209,
-0.1966303438,
-0.198177278,
0.0923755988,
0.4619364738,
0.0066062291,
-0.7450860143,
0.2240674049,
0.071506761,
0.1748883724,
0.5597148538,
0.4154459238,
0.6875144839,
-0.0988410935,
0.3483571112,
0.100436978,
-0.7659630775,
0.5443063378,
-0.5525034666,
-0.1993881166,
0.773876071,
0.1768667251,
-1.1008070707,
-0.7979911566,
-0.6311835051,
-0.4582315087,
0.6453649998,
-0.0121437544,
0.6164149642,
-0.3226377964,
0.2426671535,
0.0882200375,
0.3355883062,
-0.46987468,
0.0208839439,
-0.1215220317,
-0.1488330513,
-0.0354539268,
-0.316565752,
-0.5868746638,
-0.4060232043,
0.5000416636,
-0.0288475025,
0.100085035,
0.2431270927,
-0.0827113166,
-0.4329452217,
0.0719223171,
0.2241532058,
0.4637163579,
-0.2014028281,
0.2686912417,
-0.2068497092,
-0.2277960181,
0.0025326519,
0.0070579909,
-0.4861813784,
-0.0488280617,
0.1831526011,
0.930855155,
0.337428242,
-0.5792388916,
0.8238922358,
-0.2735054493,
-0.1606982946,
-0.1368500888,
0.1766489893,
0.1174500287,
0.531733036,
-0.314622879,
0.0787608624,
-0.0139120677,
-0.6523436904,
0.5359368324,
0.4466787875,
-0.7134152055,
-0.3240612745,
0.6870291233,
0.4654888511,
-0.273322314,
0.4298336208,
-0.3199771345,
-0.2035244107,
0.4971651137,
0.4388614595,
0.5498852134,
-0.0713139847,
0.8176550865,
0.1345912516,
0.1300617605,
-0.0244562682,
0.2192769498,
-0.256804496,
-0.8507160544,
-0.3741606772,
-0.6082016826,
-0.4581946731,
0.073178798,
-0.4555105567,
-0.0892141685,
-0.8613615036,
-0.397256434,
0.0908593982,
0.3501149416,
-0.2011622638,
-0.2398923337,
0.1078047752,
0.5928251147,
-1.2903616428,
0.5933402181,
0.5661532283,
-0.341471374,
-0.4902389944,
-0.4037100375,
-0.47360605,
-0.4672168791,
0.1284250915,
0.2096590996,
0.1403927505,
0.1643467844,
-0.5595422387,
-0.4127340615,
1.1146126986,
0.2314431965,
-0.273945421,
0.3910832405,
0.0924947634,
0.7459291816,
-0.3022727668,
0.027364254,
0.1498621851,
0.3362050354,
0.3179115653,
-0.9602010846,
-0.0426960476,
-0.1259895712,
-0.0778735057,
0.2104092091,
-0.9030885696,
0.9383327365,
0.1590411663,
-0.4236735702,
0.0324616395,
0.4911509156,
-0.3574862182,
0.4690834582,
0.537891686,
0.4204233289,
0.8586569428,
-0.03152024,
0.667927742,
-0.4150114954,
0.6327752471,
0.9883211851,
-0.3686837256,
0.6165596247,
0.2657195628,
0.196401462,
0.6179760695,
0.7102611661,
0.090667583,
0.4868711233,
-0.3270523846,
-0.6461301446,
-0.3550142348,
-0.8187305331,
-0.1517834961,
0.4996578693,
0.4346822798,
-0.4568544924,
-0.4695028067,
0.2794919312,
0.3510449827,
0.1854468882,
-0.3555464745,
1.1807943583,
-0.021126857,
-0.7049812078,
0.1777682453,
0.1475311667,
0.5416856408,
-0.4632847309,
0.1952086091,
-0.5388361812,
0.1277310699,
-0.3723184466,
-0.8747432232,
0.5665773153,
-0.363566488,
0.1321175396,
-0.6283878088,
1.1443002224,
-0.5969066024,
-0.0611276478,
0.3310807645,
0.593054235,
-0.1590256542,
-0.0478517041,
-0.5605000854,
0.2875855267,
-0.373628974,
0.1300259084,
0.3443511724,
0.2243011296,
-0.127782926,
0.5629828572,
0.7688656449,
-0.0702674016,
-0.3002620935,
-0.0826830342,
1.0566792488,
-0.0211559515,
-0.8211029172,
-0.6226876378,
0.0217914674,
-0.3150311708,
0.2481172234,
0.6248432398,
0.2961862683,
0.9337161183,
0.3839888573,
0.4984119534,
-0.2789868712,
0.0367624089,
0.088567622,
0.9283365011,
-0.1693482101,
0.1501149237,
-0.1353741735,
-0.6509549022,
-0.3060999811,
0.815192163,
-0.5074388385,
-0.2917104959,
0.3971460164,
0.9278498888,
-0.1235986277,
0.4062585533,
0.1585019827,
0.3091346025,
0.4575455785,
0.3817738593,
0.8501051068,
-0.1612742245,
0.3386652172,
-0.727656126,
-0.0906503871,
-0.2487777025,
-0.6984111667,
-0.6939815283,
-0.5711730123,
-0.3583530486,
-0.5147371292,
0.0704010352,
0.6836787462,
0.6759100556,
-0.7532591224,
-0.0918724015,
-0.2872729599,
0.4394388199,
-0.1717666239,
-0.2275056094,
-0.1486246586,
-0.1918400675,
-0.552515626,
0.0515467376,
0.5417226553,
-0.2798163593,
-0.3898433149,
0.128547132,
-0.0775934458,
-0.0359563902,
0.740825057,
0.1977502108,
-0.2850148976,
-0.6344724894,
-0.184476763,
-0.2115767896,
0.1561438143,
0.7290394306,
-0.5749475956,
0.7093350291,
0.6931006908,
0.4179068506,
0.2771571279,
0.1072642356,
0.1321864724,
-0.8829904199,
0.4016499817,
0.415340811,
0.1762843877,
0.4074446559,
-0.1887507439,
0.2998686433,
0.5638507009,
-0.6326783895,
-0.89584589,
0.3042895794,
-0.8666653633,
-0.2789604366,
1.1315165758,
-0.3071683645,
-0.1337253153,
-0.1947367787,
-0.279032737,
0.2456438988,
-0.1473433524,
0.7370851636,
0.4374735653,
0.0800647214,
-0.1043283716,
-0.5346374512,
0.3426776528,
0.0460330062,
-0.7765240669,
0.1629481465,
0.5594802499,
0.4776699245,
0.0741569027,
1.0563867092,
-0.0342338756,
-0.0367170013,
-0.1680018604,
-0.5406181216,
-0.1037935317,
-0.3229141831,
-0.0761223137,
0.4195053875,
-0.2656467259,
0.0246241931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03036v1
|
MuLan: A Study of Fact Mutability in Language Models
| 2024-04-03T19:47:33 | 2024-04-03T19:47:33 |
Constanza Fierro, Nicolas Garneau, Emanuele Bugliarello, Yova Kementchedjhieva, Anders Søgaard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Facts are subject to contingencies and can be true or false in different
circumstances. One such contingency is time, wherein some facts mutate over a
given period, e.g., the president of a country or the winner of a championship.
Trustworthy language models ideally identify mutable facts as such and process
them accordingly. We create MuLan, a benchmark for evaluating the ability of
English language models to anticipate time-contingency, covering both 1:1 and
1:N relations. We hypothesize that mutable facts are encoded differently than
immutable ones, hence being easier to update. In a detailed evaluation of six
popular large language models, we consistently find differences in the LLMs'
confidence, representations, and update behavior, depending on the mutability
of a fact. Our findings should inform future work on the injection of and
induction of time-contingent knowledge to/from LLMs.
|
[
0.0466195904,
-0.7667957544,
0.8317220807,
0.383179903,
0.0058604181,
0.192139551,
-0.1710937768,
-0.6077671647,
0.1925316006,
0.1065457687,
-0.2197996527,
-0.0075545758,
-0.7154000401,
-0.1420315802,
-0.3689188957,
1.0357724428,
-0.0067149769,
-0.089098908,
-0.04927966,
-0.6355093718,
-0.1641424596,
-0.8148541451,
-0.6662755609,
-0.5181723833,
0.5507036448,
0.3775871992,
0.8469207883,
0.5409471393,
0.7839739323,
0.2509860992,
-0.0908751711,
0.3615208268,
-0.4063887298,
0.2821970284,
-0.4087668061,
-0.4517772198,
-0.6693372726,
0.4749723375,
0.7429760695,
0.8089456558,
-0.4328714311,
0.2803943157,
0.2909911275,
0.6598815918,
-0.655305624,
0.2113072276,
-0.7960442901,
0.0051517235,
-0.4959133863,
-0.4549659193,
-0.2126818001,
-0.5519621372,
0.060247913,
-0.4127779305,
0.2215942293,
0.2367366403,
0.7865118384,
0.0816080868,
-0.3520746529,
-0.5456542373,
-0.7221519947,
0.8471474648,
-0.5698133707,
0.5064592361,
0.3559422791,
0.3516657352,
-0.2127078921,
-0.6743755341,
-0.7877648473,
-0.6590818167,
-0.3498383164,
-0.0028069289,
0.0048947572,
-0.0011556983,
0.4625949264,
0.4822275639,
-0.5604150891,
-0.3281767368,
-0.2325153798,
-0.1419901401,
0.3662134707,
0.0474123508,
0.2253019214,
-0.0137951756,
-0.5609636307,
0.2169108689,
-0.7576596141,
0.1383778453,
0.3222753406,
0.1045795903,
-0.3106160462,
0.6389003992,
-0.2181560099,
0.2225588411,
0.0011965814,
-0.6022494435,
0.3337292373,
-0.526012361,
-0.1490077674,
-0.1925628781,
0.5161639452,
0.2331068963,
0.3161409497,
-0.1750376225,
-0.109929055,
0.0855911151,
-0.3060853481,
-0.6425833702,
-0.0009334905,
0.2777272165,
-0.5095547438,
-0.0734433904,
0.0715750232,
-0.4424809217,
-0.2422454357,
0.0550689846,
0.3681030869,
-0.3704689741,
-0.3801000416,
0.2579616606,
-0.0709337592,
-0.0787217543,
0.0361026414,
-0.7296382785,
0.1660539061,
0.5523560643,
0.8586322665,
-0.242347464,
-0.7861152887,
-0.5541040301,
0.2179828733,
-0.3639669418,
0.706694901,
-0.3530147076,
-0.1395908743,
0.0261452794,
-0.0319977999,
-0.1422905177,
-0.2711975574,
0.6018455029,
-0.4901195168,
-0.0873565301,
-0.1498594582,
-0.6451529264,
0.0503854118,
0.5745867491,
-0.840724349,
0.7661055923,
-0.1012142003,
-0.7700488567,
0.4049283862,
-0.6735900044,
-0.4275229573,
-0.2678091526,
-0.1891309619,
-0.2634049058,
0.0118695227,
-0.3329414725,
0.5609793067,
-0.2841464281,
0.5974377394,
-0.4775649309,
-0.0135130947,
0.9591012597,
-0.6400614381,
0.8643381596,
0.4332294166,
0.0320273265,
-0.5352936387,
-0.6962377429,
-0.1512347162,
-0.0037166192,
-0.816313982,
-0.1354821473,
0.2617502213,
-0.289873451,
0.0632337481,
0.175052613,
-0.8224956393,
0.3293088377,
0.0260029677,
0.1185740009,
0.4409357011,
0.1334867626,
0.2615357041,
-0.9570909142,
0.3010019064,
0.236321792,
0.1258372813,
-0.2754642367,
-0.4228795469,
-0.8375819325,
-0.1474107355,
0.2443673015,
0.3943482935,
-0.5536848903,
-0.3586105108,
-0.2850120366,
-0.3898927867,
-0.1499439478,
0.1008460447,
0.4221844077,
0.270409286,
0.2558282018,
0.067239657,
-0.5697117448,
-0.7237640023,
-0.4689459205,
-0.3422783017,
0.2930956483,
-0.0996008739,
0.5066401362,
0.0508508161,
0.7099935412,
-0.3822636604,
-0.0270424951,
-0.3273190558,
0.5157081485,
0.3241595328,
0.5299528837,
0.8193608522,
-0.5433232188,
-0.2906783223,
0.0611907989,
-0.8228591681,
0.0293440986,
-0.0815932602,
0.2520806491,
0.2436545938,
0.7068212628,
-0.5675845146,
0.510443151,
0.8593426943,
-0.2075627148,
0.6515904069,
-0.3212317228,
0.5146290064,
-0.7104399204,
0.0408391804,
-0.4337200522,
-0.4866487682,
-0.6503793597,
-0.0751795396,
0.1343565732,
0.0652679279,
-0.6387286186,
0.7706670165,
-0.474011749,
0.2312155515,
-0.028135391,
0.0304500554,
0.1385402828,
0.4281201065,
-0.3296316266,
0.6806220412,
0.176640749,
-1.1778509617,
0.2785044014,
-0.2098463178,
-0.8494933248,
0.5230900645,
-0.4554903805,
0.0688867271,
-0.1020560637,
-0.1113085002,
-0.9164159894,
-0.0972038582,
0.0783869997,
-0.3528881073,
0.2690402269,
0.0236357786,
-0.3231793046,
0.0889847055,
-0.2364552021,
0.4830605984,
-0.0330049321,
-0.4224943817,
0.5020076632,
0.5375061035,
-0.1696115881,
-0.9288801551,
-0.8600021601,
-0.2241244912,
-0.058242172,
-0.3464331031,
0.4193513393,
-0.4696499705,
-0.6795351505,
0.2437804937,
0.1328389198,
-0.2288876921,
0.333848238,
0.011845123,
-0.0280961432,
-0.2331761718,
0.3450323939,
-0.1969416589,
-0.1337786913,
-0.1719453037,
-0.0619566068,
0.1599865258,
0.1827637255,
-0.4988116622,
-0.0480613522,
0.43550843,
0.7521467209,
-0.1466874778,
0.7397601604,
0.0623334907,
-0.5833556056,
-0.3036490679,
-0.7048830986,
0.0664437041,
-0.3758259714,
0.3580705822,
-0.6544485092,
-0.6909424663,
0.591117382,
0.2080663592,
0.1507592201,
0.2513616383,
0.4621573091,
-0.338195473,
0.5537471175,
0.776284337,
0.0243419837,
0.3918502033,
-0.1275056303,
0.0283470526,
-0.4355244935,
-0.0655533224,
-0.5370941162,
-0.2411880344,
-0.6370554566,
-0.3557747006,
0.229220733,
-0.2305441648,
-0.2043661922,
0.0527018085,
0.2017059028,
0.599812448,
0.2461334765,
-0.1053840369,
0.6499439478,
-0.376955986,
-0.3159995079,
-0.0768655241,
-0.7236919403,
-0.3397278786,
1.0526599884,
0.2981468439,
1.0810087919,
0.5443614721,
0.0352707915,
0.6373115778,
0.4679227471,
-0.601797998,
0.3415586948,
-0.3137636185,
-1.0404160023,
-0.215942204,
-0.2377089113,
-0.9277647734,
-0.0962374955,
-0.4456298351,
-0.6784799099,
0.1846539378,
0.2139085084,
-0.413659811,
0.5467051864,
-0.4820393622,
0.4751017988,
-0.4715464115,
-0.136036396,
-0.3110758066,
-0.3329589367,
0.4238128066,
-0.1233024746,
0.2569432557,
-0.6258592606,
0.0740346685,
0.6962290406,
-0.2047707438,
0.5530549884,
0.0954208747,
0.106429629,
0.2831137478,
0.3378038406,
0.4304896891,
0.0016961881,
-0.2965963483,
0.1091086715,
0.1999374032,
-0.3705942631,
-0.7658623457,
0.4745117426,
-0.4908693433,
-0.5567262769,
-0.7234569192,
-0.7278030515,
-0.1771653891,
-0.2172580361,
0.216280207,
0.513800323,
-0.5359447002,
0.353961736,
0.5681880713,
-0.0469885319,
0.6525949836,
0.7338784337,
-0.6398305297,
-0.0412349328,
0.6483153701,
0.7936950326,
0.5478253365,
0.5692910552,
0.1895142943,
-0.3185580969,
-0.3402432799,
0.0494584329,
0.4010769427,
-0.6493629217,
-0.1794625968,
-0.4992142022,
-0.4155644178,
0.0331791416,
0.1291659474,
-0.5004957914,
-0.7979630232,
0.2833004892,
-0.293936193,
0.2236258686,
0.9199904203,
-0.2483463585,
0.1640001684,
-0.5819525719,
0.2320287228,
0.463657558,
0.4019829333,
-0.1779088676,
-0.7027731538,
-0.4700154364,
-0.0910360515,
-0.2675558031,
-0.8597387671,
-0.1667455286,
0.4357644022,
0.7607560754,
0.553583622,
-0.0250530466,
0.4124158323,
-0.4136957228,
0.5753796101,
-0.0062095867,
-1.0227388144,
0.2649644911,
-0.0989215523,
0.0005031133,
0.2420498282,
0.3608580232,
-0.7822621465,
-0.5815713406,
-0.7298941016,
-0.0900929421,
0.2616416514,
-0.0038952022,
0.1157630086,
-0.0067342063,
0.2242679149,
0.2362122834,
0.2794228494,
-0.7238963842,
-0.5115446448,
0.0135261975,
0.0841484591,
-0.0667853728,
-0.8205751181,
-0.05270347,
0.1210997924,
0.6042779684,
0.0622324646,
0.1975783259,
0.1910753101,
-0.2775730789,
0.1642731726,
0.5361021757,
0.7968727946,
1.2079092264,
-0.4629790783,
0.5254807472,
0.375403136,
-0.5215696096,
0.5076761246,
-0.0982688665,
-0.1054874733,
0.3130075932,
0.5544440746,
0.302413106,
0.2535057962,
-0.2194310427,
0.4859392941,
-0.0341809914,
0.0572163463,
-0.128731221,
0.005324496,
-0.0333486274,
0.2239367962,
0.5089463592,
0.0507850088,
-0.0407140292,
-0.892132163,
0.2946093976,
0.3876031637,
0.0294086765,
-0.4856226444,
0.5769032836,
0.2130204886,
-0.0584077388,
0.1239252314,
-0.6093606353,
-0.5286747813,
0.3999191821,
0.5389763117,
0.4798968732,
-0.5111391544,
0.2193008661,
0.5676032901,
0.5643623471,
0.0639869422,
0.4395985901,
0.5184258819,
-1.1509758234,
-0.4292274415,
-0.2717253566,
-0.6420506239,
0.5053705573,
-0.3678075373,
0.0506187752,
-0.4879116714,
-0.4374195635,
0.0943352506,
0.1220715493,
-0.8334095478,
0.1873701513,
-0.0442761332,
0.9549343586,
-0.792329073,
1.1003792286,
0.4103509188,
-0.3650822043,
-0.7470928431,
-0.0177670363,
0.1118744388,
-0.6398359537,
0.6218567491,
-0.1022882313,
-0.4239793718,
-0.4419361055,
-0.5951470733,
-0.9113140106,
1.0677330494,
0.7871158719,
-0.315618068,
0.2003693581,
0.1668609232,
0.1905168146,
-0.4788689017,
0.1603296548,
0.5438004136,
0.4438037276,
-0.3344631493,
-0.8923181891,
-0.0403608344,
-0.1248091906,
-0.2901200056,
-0.0978798047,
-0.8472043276,
1.3306244612,
-0.3313062787,
-0.5311431289,
-0.0057489071,
0.8325519562,
0.0775143132,
0.3626946807,
0.5906871557,
0.3711489737,
1.2717834711,
-0.0786582455,
1.0156692266,
-0.3596807718,
0.5534819961,
1.2105979919,
-0.1911126524,
0.6402261853,
0.4555822611,
-0.4024326503,
0.4597258866,
0.2132712603,
0.4010869861,
0.3398618102,
-0.0798741579,
-0.1468583196,
-0.1042794511,
-0.3717475832,
-0.5406138897,
0.5350291729,
0.3291194737,
-0.1075870097,
-0.0914485455,
-0.1228365302,
0.648417592,
-0.0424362756,
-0.1195863262,
0.1521720737,
0.0398528054,
-0.7607478499,
0.2814025879,
-0.1220717281,
0.4718381464,
-0.8617685437,
-0.0127955712,
-0.6384875774,
0.2850080729,
-0.2235118151,
-1.0669564009,
0.3984419107,
0.0220646095,
-0.5396620631,
0.0020632052,
0.5418438911,
-0.6133422852,
-0.4230361283,
0.3577264845,
0.915641427,
0.2039572001,
0.2342284173,
-0.4608385861,
0.0674947649,
-0.2039449215,
-0.1840941757,
-0.0954207256,
0.7213445902,
0.1338354796,
1.0703860521,
0.4746101499,
0.3581145704,
0.1219148114,
-0.1062561795,
0.4970617592,
-0.5255871415,
-0.1795663834,
-1.0420842171,
0.479251653,
-0.008760442,
-0.3947591484,
0.8357197642,
0.4845296443,
0.7292129397,
0.0646516681,
0.8782292604,
-0.1309792399,
0.8547356129,
-0.864464283,
0.9832299352,
-0.4076655805,
0.1882395893,
-0.0128761847,
-0.5235060453,
-0.1941617131,
0.3321355879,
0.0133549357,
-0.1989775598,
1.209703207,
0.8593518734,
-0.2122099102,
-0.2044635862,
0.573495388,
0.3539432883,
0.1787273586,
0.4743601382,
1.1798340082,
-0.0499235094,
0.7131402493,
-0.1783344746,
-0.2041875571,
-0.2747620046,
-1.328591466,
-0.761164546,
-0.8349484205,
-0.4261854291,
-0.4162910879,
0.2309829444,
0.9477522969,
0.6325028539,
-0.841706872,
-0.3753447533,
0.6288262606,
0.5726495385,
-0.4057002068,
-0.1075733602,
0.2856993079,
-0.3462870121,
-0.5042751431,
0.3391770124,
0.2160832137,
0.293728441,
-0.2444848716,
-0.1411846131,
-0.5526418686,
0.480669111,
0.4478465021,
0.386950016,
-0.364866972,
-0.6050198078,
0.01607484,
-0.4163245261,
0.2379222959,
0.9906731248,
-0.4437346756,
0.5168638229,
0.4848341048,
0.4526564777,
0.3283524215,
-0.2490394264,
0.4415391982,
-0.7516417503,
0.2777837515,
-0.1678203642,
0.7728402615,
0.3942874074,
-0.0663425922,
0.7144288421,
0.307382375,
-0.7371439934,
-0.6126835942,
0.4166739881,
-0.8034029007,
0.0275234561,
0.8869781494,
-0.492443651,
-0.0734507591,
-0.3523154557,
0.0750890151,
0.1989407539,
-0.1262947172,
0.6425058842,
1.0902197361,
-0.0011580002,
0.1268032789,
-0.6735199094,
0.6556537747,
0.1171694398,
-0.673088491,
0.0882594734,
0.017016599,
0.3561427891,
0.4385855496,
0.9493061304,
0.1240333542,
0.2813493907,
0.0576153994,
-0.2269476205,
0.0497894064,
-0.5782133341,
0.084136948,
0.1375338733,
0.2858448923,
-0.4586273134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04284v1
|
Assessing ML Classification Algorithms and NLP Techniques for Depression Detection: An Experimental Case Study
| 2024-04-03T19:45:40 | 2024-04-03T19:45:40 |
Giuliano Lorenzoni, Cristina Tavares, Nathalia Nascimento, Paulo Alencar, Donald Cowan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Depression has affected millions of people worldwide and has become one of
the most common mental disorders. Early mental disorder detection can reduce
costs for public health agencies and prevent other major comorbidities.
Additionally, the shortage of specialized personnel is very concerning since
Depression diagnosis is highly dependent on expert professionals and is
time-consuming. Recent research has evidenced that machine learning (ML) and
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tools and techniques have significantly bene
ted the diagnosis of depression. However, there are still several challenges in
the assessment of depression detection approaches in which other conditions
such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are present. These challenges
include assessing alternatives in terms of data cleaning and pre-processing
techniques, feature selection, and appropriate ML classification algorithms.
This paper tackels such an assessment based on a case study that compares
different ML classifiers, specifically in terms of data cleaning and
pre-processing, feature selection, parameter setting, and model choices. The
case study is based on the Distress Analysis Interview Corpus - Wizard-of-Oz
(DAIC-WOZ) dataset, which is designed to support the diagnosis of mental
disorders such as depression, anxiety, and PTSD. Besides the assessment of
alternative techniques, we were able to build models with accuracy levels
around 84% with Random Forest and XGBoost models, which is significantly higher
than the results from the comparable literature which presented the level of
accuracy of 72% from the SVM model.
|
[
-0.8519178629,
-0.817303896,
0.4536155164,
0.3339973986,
-0.0422508419,
-0.0772169679,
-0.173855111,
-0.4902457595,
-0.124423027,
0.1264146566,
-0.7025515437,
-0.6098803878,
-0.8000563383,
0.5045503378,
-0.3734088838,
1.0440933704,
-0.1664329469,
0.1437383741,
-0.3236508965,
-0.0823981985,
-0.3841467202,
-0.8316589594,
-1.0970538855,
-0.0702583119,
0.3720819056,
0.001631031,
0.8092067242,
-0.0670236349,
0.8947578073,
0.3720410168,
-0.3655477762,
-0.0333763622,
-0.2317161113,
-0.0552551933,
0.0327822641,
-0.4368805587,
-0.3739877641,
0.0122788064,
-0.0217854045,
0.5936211348,
-0.0147712929,
0.2456729561,
0.1787319481,
0.4090258181,
-0.7022860646,
0.0648366958,
-0.2082651109,
0.6856462359,
0.0861083642,
-0.104919605,
-0.167842865,
-0.257611692,
0.3534989059,
-0.3628434539,
0.5240585208,
-0.2626945674,
0.6968315244,
0.6717467904,
-0.1186170727,
-0.4344946146,
-0.7428947091,
0.7634085417,
-0.6713480949,
0.0538570583,
0.5599993467,
0.25516361,
-0.1322958022,
-0.5304058194,
-0.3570599556,
-0.1770536155,
-0.0132195251,
0.0812312663,
-0.2307729274,
-0.0701832548,
0.6221191287,
0.5482307673,
-0.7202447057,
0.4864494503,
-0.171406731,
-0.2296541184,
0.6522486806,
0.2276958078,
0.2839883566,
-0.3892612755,
-0.3321152329,
-0.2446139604,
0.0346974432,
0.2633590102,
0.2121248543,
0.203441456,
0.0512368791,
0.3882814348,
-0.1173759326,
0.7102090716,
-0.1244234443,
-0.1962728798,
0.2956624031,
-0.027741313,
-0.4968345761,
0.1370063871,
0.6453486681,
0.4683988988,
0.1245975867,
0.1341670156,
-0.2667953074,
0.5438609719,
0.5054454803,
-0.7101539373,
-0.4266420901,
0.4169607759,
-0.7918134332,
-0.3058527112,
-0.2872939408,
-0.9335579276,
-0.8198084831,
-0.4458818138,
0.416212827,
-0.4002318382,
-0.4628361464,
0.1671934724,
-0.1609308124,
-0.0356928036,
0.4355806112,
-0.3623008132,
0.2093557715,
0.6079755425,
0.8541789651,
-0.3331426084,
0.177412957,
-0.302950114,
-0.6633345485,
-0.4609469473,
0.7780817747,
-0.3080549836,
-0.2820161283,
-0.0238673482,
-0.1246571913,
-0.1000263169,
-0.715790689,
1.0845023394,
-0.154009223,
0.313986063,
-0.0723215863,
-0.6354338527,
-0.2249833643,
0.3103365898,
-0.7753418088,
1.0348483324,
0.5409049392,
-1.0512547493,
0.6058898568,
-0.7472884059,
-0.1093020439,
-0.1190841645,
0.1688224375,
-0.6803205609,
0.1780810207,
0.2834791541,
0.8021070957,
-0.1337898523,
0.0227240492,
-0.7140651345,
-0.3711625338,
0.3760890961,
-0.4932985604,
0.888759315,
0.4256538451,
-0.1728690863,
-0.195542708,
-0.940975368,
0.0351167284,
-0.0903294012,
-0.1924355626,
-0.5273477435,
0.0263304077,
0.1271941811,
0.3840391338,
-0.1062086821,
-0.1438274682,
-0.0636023283,
-0.1262205541,
-0.036878366,
0.5114970803,
-0.0047279317,
-0.1097855195,
-0.1973400414,
0.7052904963,
0.2448900491,
0.4534177482,
-0.0052976361,
-0.6523002982,
-0.5622962713,
-0.6873139739,
0.5445455909,
0.9269314408,
-0.3115471005,
0.9961320162,
0.1423019916,
-0.4784057438,
-0.7129355073,
-0.1795603484,
0.1182221845,
0.5439805388,
0.5655332804,
-0.4730657935,
-0.7006441355,
-0.5679609776,
-0.1992760003,
0.020066876,
-0.3708004951,
0.0848099515,
0.2611719668,
-0.496756047,
0.9507199526,
-0.4891840518,
-0.4042832851,
0.0170983486,
0.55238235,
0.1760670096,
0.2412184179,
0.5035643578,
-0.8526907563,
-0.3495201468,
-0.0470309183,
-0.929520905,
-0.1484906226,
0.1269744188,
0.3266991675,
0.260356456,
0.1733731031,
-0.589767158,
0.8308061361,
0.2914649844,
-0.4200797975,
0.665880084,
-0.1367271841,
0.3898788989,
-0.6031913757,
-0.0245087631,
0.2338827103,
-0.1691853255,
-0.5735702515,
-0.3476186991,
-0.2528572679,
-0.27756989,
-0.1886216402,
0.0161869694,
-0.1596854031,
-0.0836261362,
-0.3955167532,
0.0112451073,
-0.0417169444,
0.292558223,
0.0113894045,
0.266792506,
0.8055314422,
-0.6945144534,
0.4271758497,
0.1618421078,
-0.5986656547,
0.688190937,
-0.2718199193,
-0.1214424372,
-0.1533087492,
0.0729275718,
-0.9414328337,
0.1720731109,
0.4082454145,
-0.2728454769,
0.229881525,
0.1193820238,
-0.5128825307,
-0.6552372575,
-0.186351344,
0.06753923,
0.547772944,
-0.374130398,
0.3476021588,
0.1352219731,
-0.3005390167,
-0.5572074056,
-0.4274005294,
-0.0056645456,
-0.72743541,
-0.2695001364,
0.3212604523,
-0.0810652971,
-0.3772819638,
0.0714023039,
-0.2368464172,
-0.3395097256,
0.4933775365,
0.1610788703,
0.3080219328,
-0.2412317246,
0.1435694396,
-0.2006581873,
-0.3507184386,
0.1473050117,
0.4827757478,
0.4518274665,
-0.0862652883,
-0.236409694,
-0.6002965569,
0.2992795408,
0.3154889643,
-0.0003632934,
0.5854551792,
0.9795498848,
-0.4702355862,
-0.209458515,
-0.2840230763,
0.048164092,
-0.3930127621,
0.2740813494,
-0.2256747484,
-0.4595114887,
0.4377385676,
-0.4663775563,
-0.1881787777,
0.3289757669,
0.4928809404,
-0.263097167,
1.2525267601,
0.7216004133,
-0.2871243954,
0.3618822694,
-0.2871457338,
0.6304805279,
-0.3931903839,
0.2791379392,
-0.698380053,
-0.2732217312,
-0.6235745549,
-0.3536368012,
0.2493445575,
0.5353799462,
0.0412097275,
0.2154655755,
-0.6111143827,
0.0575662218,
0.2410111576,
0.1033667922,
0.2104536146,
-0.0684994459,
0.041967757,
-0.1162474975,
-0.4949688911,
-0.7191479802,
1.0355267525,
0.2347226441,
0.4495942891,
-0.356520623,
0.6074962616,
0.7859716415,
0.5564770699,
-0.8635041714,
0.2132484913,
-0.1668470353,
-0.2808621824,
-0.3846126497,
-0.3571105003,
-0.9231419563,
0.2622595429,
-0.4347004592,
-0.7177209854,
0.3810880184,
-0.0840958655,
-0.5972523093,
0.1251417845,
-0.9011983871,
1.1514962912,
-0.2030202746,
0.3214353025,
-0.2696044743,
-0.5435772538,
0.433935225,
-0.4725317359,
0.2149505168,
-0.1761889756,
0.2671307921,
0.7584829926,
-0.2168397456,
0.5885819793,
-0.2951292992,
-0.2046439797,
0.2467900962,
-0.2385117263,
0.1429065317,
-0.0880037323,
-0.2552796006,
0.1027722508,
0.3432425857,
-0.0999831632,
-0.9103268385,
0.181561932,
-0.7599035501,
-0.3430209458,
-0.3905390203,
-0.1947030574,
-0.3239039779,
-0.0587546565,
0.3329870701,
0.3627806902,
-0.2977441847,
-0.0230571851,
0.6117394567,
-0.4808280766,
0.4368753731,
0.377589643,
-0.239727512,
-0.261372149,
0.7347345352,
0.1817965209,
-0.22266078,
0.1934867948,
0.1344902813,
-0.1819052994,
-0.5055899024,
0.0603051931,
-0.0585732758,
-0.6918449402,
-0.323374778,
-0.5869449973,
-0.117466718,
-0.3370490074,
0.0185090024,
-0.2133351415,
-0.3725567162,
-0.4853244722,
-0.3095905483,
0.4194310009,
0.2198159695,
-0.2204284221,
0.0651077628,
-0.574740231,
0.8059307933,
0.0174604189,
0.2264381498,
-0.0531798564,
-0.0527480915,
-0.1993599087,
-0.0959810168,
-0.530415535,
-0.8408062458,
0.4409639537,
0.0486352704,
0.4117623866,
0.8704963326,
0.5438845754,
0.891520977,
-0.025692407,
0.6626234055,
0.2749808431,
-0.7909337282,
0.5671299696,
0.2765693367,
-0.2384665012,
0.5486760139,
1.0705901384,
-0.6024938822,
-0.4130531847,
-0.6941313148,
-0.7203705907,
0.7124150395,
0.2001468986,
-0.4269712269,
-0.0139059061,
0.2125212401,
0.2669184804,
0.0654095262,
-0.3480399251,
-0.3141029477,
-0.2240432799,
-0.4182474315,
-0.4700431228,
-0.090609625,
-0.1432251483,
-0.3640029728,
0.4317614138,
0.1447088569,
0.4337025285,
0.3977089524,
-0.105386205,
0.0182224084,
0.2026438713,
0.1301171631,
0.614266932,
-0.3417344987,
0.0487184413,
0.1489054859,
-0.2941288948,
0.1854016781,
0.3276711404,
0.0459018126,
0.203305006,
0.3795357645,
0.7915756702,
-0.1231396347,
-0.8655151725,
0.5325905085,
-0.3493877351,
-0.1004130989,
-0.2759335935,
0.1418452114,
-0.1803008914,
0.3122476935,
0.2132960409,
0.3425455391,
0.490273267,
-0.2924884558,
0.1856800616,
0.3024908304,
-0.3636582792,
-0.2010086328,
0.0833151713,
-0.1212243885,
-0.6743354201,
0.7711152434,
-0.3080706,
-0.411716938,
0.6978365183,
0.2178806365,
0.8875546455,
-0.4196509719,
0.458688736,
0.1419145167,
0.1628913134,
-0.2137282938,
0.1689690799,
-0.2296048403,
-0.7739266753,
-0.3101357818,
-0.6545310616,
-0.3591563404,
0.5179259181,
-1.0482230186,
0.4837827384,
-0.2524634004,
-0.6723555326,
-0.0537436567,
0.3387694955,
-0.8005158305,
0.632922709,
0.4147511125,
0.7793269753,
-1.0027291775,
0.2889395058,
0.5200868845,
-0.0828979686,
-0.2885519266,
-0.0651776642,
-0.0813963562,
-0.1685073376,
0.301109612,
0.6249551773,
0.2943457067,
-0.2660660744,
-0.1452200711,
-0.5879210234,
0.5943153501,
0.1181928068,
-0.2832520306,
0.2259184718,
0.0397384241,
0.8929396272,
-0.1509912461,
0.3483370543,
0.838080585,
0.6345434785,
-0.3573113978,
-0.9331406951,
-0.2276275903,
-0.3137440681,
0.0361507498,
0.0031419809,
-0.0442819074,
0.7189534903,
-0.0678024665,
-0.4314659238,
0.0675201416,
0.3785808384,
0.293741703,
0.683142364,
0.8132224083,
0.8872326612,
1.0962761641,
0.0905283988,
1.048107028,
-0.1433897763,
0.4773036838,
0.5952433348,
-0.4227757156,
0.7934345603,
0.0554996766,
-0.5811393261,
0.3716539443,
1.1907186508,
-0.2826200724,
0.4924195707,
0.4415982664,
-0.3713063598,
-0.1793000549,
0.0650192276,
-0.3557531238,
0.3417541385,
0.396481514,
-0.2600646913,
-0.276309669,
0.4855500162,
-0.2010868043,
-0.1658531576,
-0.3600139022,
0.7207142115,
0.0496152043,
-0.435872972,
0.6846923828,
0.0653926283,
0.7020871043,
-0.315391928,
0.1091254801,
-0.0247204695,
0.3359655738,
-0.303532511,
-0.4588216245,
0.548193574,
0.2533078194,
-0.3150368631,
-0.1293694526,
0.749063015,
-0.0341488756,
-0.575771451,
0.4847358167,
0.5750718713,
0.4452160597,
-0.3045213521,
-0.9216087461,
-0.0189123452,
-0.445078522,
-0.3168093264,
0.4599370658,
0.6576086879,
-0.0423580222,
0.6978814006,
0.3797287345,
0.0279704183,
0.0748817474,
0.0248593483,
0.3491270244,
-0.5868391395,
-0.5233445764,
-0.7598452568,
0.2828529775,
-0.0559810549,
-0.2680947185,
0.699768126,
0.3431132436,
0.6782090068,
-0.2315290868,
0.7614955306,
-0.0852668211,
0.7337669134,
-0.3014944196,
0.4212681651,
-0.4490636289,
-0.1432159096,
-0.6766986847,
-0.6715844274,
-0.4304521978,
0.9133671522,
-0.296985507,
0.1230173707,
0.7701984644,
0.6312507391,
0.1107455865,
0.3571247756,
0.2358382791,
0.1498343945,
0.1438189596,
0.284791708,
1.176582098,
-0.3065049946,
0.2853164971,
-0.4607220292,
-0.4201659262,
-0.1571757793,
-0.7764953971,
-0.7541773915,
-0.503400743,
-0.7236682177,
0.0016460904,
-0.2917723656,
0.6518733501,
0.5547620058,
-0.7790091038,
0.073908478,
0.0550975502,
0.3023343384,
-0.8714968562,
-0.3621511459,
0.5623853803,
-0.4646492898,
-0.4753399789,
0.2848010063,
0.1487039775,
0.0246995874,
-0.1275067627,
0.1803752929,
0.1850098372,
-0.2950602174,
0.8259631395,
-0.0325368717,
-0.5504227877,
0.0908404961,
-0.432870537,
0.0745793954,
0.1540600657,
0.8022893071,
-0.9499045014,
0.1547146291,
0.3753983378,
0.6663421392,
0.1891965568,
0.1560593098,
0.3752351105,
-0.2348248214,
-0.1003732458,
0.2772122324,
0.3357037902,
0.4140399992,
-0.6051603556,
0.4674449861,
0.1843022555,
-0.5672392845,
-1.0973126888,
-0.1815555841,
-0.8188206553,
-0.6733111143,
0.5174846053,
-0.3932833672,
-0.1099213958,
-0.5551503301,
-0.3604847193,
0.4021916091,
0.0714255571,
1.2242026329,
0.7634093165,
-0.5945447087,
-0.0323439613,
-0.4384228289,
0.7387387156,
0.2964573801,
-0.7600443959,
-0.1131302118,
0.1994311064,
0.048908338,
0.3573892713,
0.514899075,
0.0372968465,
0.2543752491,
-0.1973942816,
0.1544850171,
0.3087589145,
-0.2589868307,
-0.5825619102,
0.382716924,
-0.3679986,
-0.1057748049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03028v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03028v2
|
An Incomplete Loop: Deductive, Inductive, and Abductive Learning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T19:31:56 | 2024-04-10T19:03:00 |
Emmy Liu, Graham Neubig, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern language models (LMs) can learn to perform new tasks in different
ways: in instruction following, the target task is described explicitly in
natural language; in few-shot prompting, the task is specified implicitly with
a small number of examples; in instruction inference, LMs are presented with
in-context examples and are then prompted to generate a natural language task
description before making predictions. Each of these procedures may be thought
of as invoking a different form of reasoning: instruction following involves
deductive reasoning, few-shot prompting involves inductive reasoning, and
instruction inference involves abductive reasoning. How do these different
capabilities relate? Across four LMs (from the gpt and llama families) and two
learning problems (involving arithmetic functions and machine translation) we
find a strong dissociation between the different types of reasoning: LMs can
sometimes learn effectively from few-shot prompts even when they are unable to
explain their own prediction rules; conversely, they sometimes infer useful
task descriptions while completely failing to learn from human-generated
descriptions of the same task. Our results highlight the non-systematic nature
of reasoning even in some of today's largest LMs, and underscore the fact that
very different learning mechanisms may be invoked by seemingly similar
prompting procedures.
|
[
-0.2445503175,
-1.2311930656,
0.9265012741,
-0.2531105876,
-0.0967640951,
0.0005579761,
-0.2887241244,
-0.336116761,
-0.1994690001,
0.437989682,
-0.706781745,
-0.2539031804,
-0.550737679,
0.4062094986,
-0.4236795008,
0.8902791739,
-0.1069407389,
0.0939335451,
-0.3239618242,
-0.0333762541,
-0.6193700433,
-0.3842547834,
-0.4700567424,
-0.6689544916,
0.7395504713,
0.5248441696,
0.4839119017,
0.4899234772,
0.3370476365,
0.2932007909,
0.0080292672,
0.106920436,
-0.306825161,
0.2248108536,
-0.2261896729,
-0.6705688238,
0.1228859797,
-0.0915116668,
0.6036159396,
1.0461709499,
0.0266097672,
-0.0059375898,
0.129544422,
0.8494676352,
-0.6935122609,
0.0688614473,
-0.6856776476,
-0.2310892344,
0.2078483105,
0.0788388103,
-0.4373672009,
-0.4531463683,
0.1891870052,
-0.3911446035,
0.0343004242,
-0.227776289,
0.5212920308,
0.3232070804,
-0.3004835844,
-0.8238132,
-0.8189001083,
0.7351721525,
-0.5806306005,
0.1381106228,
0.4996398985,
0.2913721502,
-0.2307123989,
-0.4405155778,
-0.6105304956,
-0.4689538777,
-0.0578077734,
-0.2657362521,
-0.1389141381,
0.1171085909,
0.5716397166,
0.1373589039,
-0.5040851831,
0.2923276722,
-0.5203078985,
0.1819338053,
0.5062638521,
0.1265899837,
0.113615267,
0.0110116247,
-0.2840644717,
0.1740951836,
-1.1105839014,
-0.0153257288,
0.1855963916,
0.2590439022,
-0.2158336937,
0.5865701437,
-0.1642326415,
0.9047626853,
-0.0011213021,
-0.3313352764,
0.0339433141,
0.1022344008,
-0.4399033785,
0.0464706458,
0.643345952,
-0.2381405979,
0.4618507326,
-0.1232250109,
-0.3081769645,
0.0471852012,
0.013501389,
-0.1436730921,
-0.1637421399,
0.1221990213,
-0.3146340549,
-0.030197069,
-0.0043936451,
-0.4255546033,
-0.4163642824,
-0.5396609902,
0.6708654165,
-0.4341371953,
-0.0290354397,
0.1339387,
0.0603961349,
0.2982522249,
0.4734379351,
-0.7842124104,
0.25658077,
0.7273744941,
0.6305742264,
-0.0963431597,
-0.5603778958,
-0.4181472659,
-0.0461694784,
-0.4157199562,
0.729401648,
-0.7755604982,
-0.3182514608,
0.2349141538,
0.0779195353,
-0.2503800392,
-0.6464910507,
0.2115905732,
-0.4189772606,
0.2456352711,
-0.5361039042,
-0.5758413672,
-0.6054947376,
0.1503175795,
-0.6290956736,
0.9206359982,
0.1216576174,
-0.5686116815,
0.181173563,
-0.5891593695,
-0.5891525745,
0.0380557775,
-0.181351319,
-0.0763856694,
0.3764942586,
-0.1607387066,
0.5047682524,
-0.5103804469,
0.1385927945,
-0.4114032388,
-0.5079955459,
0.379904747,
-0.3681127727,
0.7554709315,
0.2374230474,
-0.4135572016,
0.1102878898,
-0.8517259955,
-0.2352060378,
0.3408548832,
-0.3339464366,
-0.294713378,
0.0325760767,
-0.6933710575,
0.221385181,
-0.0316987596,
-0.2148445249,
0.5758994818,
-0.2500971258,
0.5987907648,
0.6387509704,
0.0330526307,
0.6150101423,
-0.3172973692,
0.4825127721,
-0.0437731594,
-0.2690200806,
-0.6068907976,
-0.3552009165,
-0.966989994,
-0.1714065373,
0.0161430966,
0.6226103902,
-0.7073478699,
0.0671075284,
-0.0724555179,
-0.2628613412,
-0.3081330955,
0.1859619319,
0.4541437924,
0.430911094,
0.3447717428,
0.2324623615,
-0.3957458138,
-0.7031373382,
-0.0681575984,
-0.2138888389,
0.0683536232,
-0.028557105,
0.817109704,
-0.1484002173,
0.5759732127,
-0.2475249767,
0.0539864115,
-0.6100104451,
0.1604767591,
0.2507529259,
0.1840961725,
0.2464503497,
-0.3172677755,
-0.2516088486,
-0.0253458321,
-0.8613421917,
-0.0079366975,
-0.3827672303,
0.1648197174,
0.3763998449,
0.4624270201,
-0.7424265146,
0.3054415286,
0.1587469727,
0.0890644044,
0.626206398,
-0.2254177034,
-0.1018858626,
-0.6340578198,
-0.1322111934,
-0.1032611504,
-0.0610452853,
-0.5805573463,
0.159482494,
0.0392271467,
0.1300467849,
-0.3293743134,
0.4938534796,
-0.7118548751,
-0.0102454852,
-0.505274415,
0.1960200667,
0.0481325202,
0.4817201793,
0.0613221116,
0.366690129,
0.8202075362,
-0.9482149482,
0.5298395157,
-0.042451784,
-0.3922409117,
0.1936408877,
-0.643456459,
0.2865962386,
-0.4325555563,
0.208074376,
-0.9515925646,
-0.3171177506,
0.3187973797,
-0.2121377736,
0.2894434631,
-0.0638167337,
-0.4815064669,
-0.4451473355,
-0.115360558,
0.2494915277,
0.6699979901,
-0.493458122,
0.2378713638,
-0.0861719549,
-0.1477198601,
-0.617272675,
-0.7032387853,
-0.2368335724,
-0.2447241098,
-0.2720828652,
-0.1087571308,
0.130027771,
-0.6627012491,
0.0570385531,
-0.0338375494,
-0.106935367,
0.2561781704,
0.3427981734,
0.3645187318,
-0.2338691503,
0.5204834342,
-0.0125323683,
0.0447727889,
0.0087840622,
-0.2836661637,
0.4893166721,
0.0565581992,
-0.8349652886,
-0.3252447844,
0.4571833909,
0.484266758,
-0.1605986506,
0.7892614007,
0.1146441028,
-0.4328017235,
-0.3807826042,
-0.5666882396,
-0.3947015703,
-0.3622676432,
0.0680225119,
-0.5862784982,
-0.9061441422,
0.4605981112,
0.1035881862,
0.1338523924,
0.4539817572,
0.6654362679,
-0.1225051582,
0.8385618925,
0.3818409443,
0.0691000521,
0.2310315222,
-0.3106058538,
0.2343690097,
-0.5291399956,
-0.2801812887,
-0.6097418666,
-0.3159203827,
-0.414285779,
-0.3003420234,
0.0945373997,
0.4720804393,
-0.4235651493,
0.1820449531,
-0.2807495892,
0.6984969974,
0.6657418013,
-0.2290507704,
0.3673378527,
-0.0231369287,
-0.2505495846,
0.3184645772,
-0.6770547032,
-0.7061681747,
0.9250071645,
0.2994942665,
1.0935349464,
-0.0697069541,
0.8836103082,
0.1660629511,
0.1500145495,
-1.0447323322,
0.4751014709,
0.1543915272,
-0.5111726522,
-0.1029174253,
-0.2934962213,
-0.9863734841,
0.2307679355,
-0.1077390835,
-0.8161556721,
-0.0096776653,
0.1197961569,
-0.3245898783,
0.2824712694,
-0.6289652586,
0.7015582323,
-0.1906435341,
-0.3252654374,
-0.1840014309,
-0.5727665424,
0.4987368882,
0.1131639853,
0.2656748593,
-0.1329686493,
0.1963468492,
0.3230880499,
-0.0584657602,
1.0134359598,
-0.0886560678,
-0.2524640858,
0.6908874512,
0.3902721405,
0.6395349503,
-0.216653809,
0.129486382,
-0.1275117546,
-0.0253795385,
-0.2646677792,
-0.611645937,
0.6235432029,
-0.5048524141,
-0.7862206697,
-0.4197436273,
-0.3512129784,
-0.0226617716,
-0.0160854608,
0.3813350499,
0.3975372314,
-0.0335946009,
0.0207820144,
0.5997846723,
-0.2403212935,
0.4918342531,
0.4412105083,
-0.1504466832,
0.0034356117,
0.6665387154,
0.0175145939,
0.4654696286,
0.4764201641,
0.1415252686,
-0.3529481292,
-0.5840190053,
-0.2001122832,
0.5840909481,
-1.0468952656,
-0.1068249568,
-0.4965481758,
-0.0682493374,
-0.2932478786,
-0.1336015165,
-0.0844956115,
-0.4367006123,
-0.3556220233,
-0.2717099786,
0.0967951864,
1.2410362959,
-0.0595788211,
0.1377521604,
-0.9181675315,
0.2389004827,
0.3985641003,
-0.0152347069,
0.2905283868,
-0.5873494148,
-0.1974356174,
0.1633629054,
-0.543731153,
-1.1514388323,
0.1195422411,
0.230332613,
0.6504485011,
0.5109834671,
0.0615062527,
0.514752686,
-0.7663610578,
0.798186481,
0.1844946146,
-0.8103868961,
0.5028015375,
-0.1000702828,
0.4170662165,
0.3031414449,
0.6736603975,
-0.6056577563,
-0.3668366671,
-0.3940891027,
-0.4854706824,
0.5790043473,
-0.3116419017,
0.1205643937,
-0.4331388772,
0.3243153393,
0.6392726302,
0.0319833606,
-0.8910452724,
-0.2384199947,
0.1917090863,
-0.1456859857,
0.0215789378,
-0.3292995989,
-0.1973849982,
-0.2501395047,
0.5014158487,
-0.1380406618,
0.2512020171,
0.1659816802,
-0.4663551748,
-0.0357264951,
0.5480771661,
0.7899854183,
0.8718848228,
0.2113340348,
0.3134476244,
0.2401539981,
0.1290747076,
0.1908163875,
-0.2221018076,
-0.0642746314,
-0.0254935492,
0.8214451075,
1.1646428108,
0.2851543725,
-0.716986239,
0.1326480359,
0.2995754778,
-0.4655556679,
-0.3967572749,
0.2225015312,
0.0608965345,
0.4217641652,
0.4436953366,
-0.3240509331,
0.058429867,
-0.8291364312,
-0.0220260583,
0.5056684017,
-0.3055838048,
-0.5330910683,
0.476752311,
0.0417470224,
-0.2757100463,
0.5606082082,
-0.3507295549,
-0.455992341,
0.3940807283,
0.6304548979,
0.9916833043,
-0.0785920322,
0.3492394984,
0.4302258193,
0.2725044191,
-0.3384928107,
0.2113568783,
-0.2961972058,
-0.5970055461,
-0.6717224121,
-0.56748873,
-0.3809791505,
0.3772467077,
-0.5288466811,
0.1577041745,
-0.3666968346,
0.3257606924,
0.0777178183,
-0.3440665901,
-0.5575560331,
-0.0855325758,
0.3887624443,
0.6901526451,
-0.8363948464,
0.832028985,
0.7664706707,
-0.4650526941,
-0.7257677317,
-0.0420589074,
0.2365453392,
-0.8046594858,
0.9974936247,
0.3673639297,
-0.1105812341,
-0.183560282,
-0.6049731374,
-0.6758033633,
0.6776521802,
0.3574136198,
-0.6424773335,
-0.2700603306,
0.0861640796,
0.3387605548,
-0.5532830358,
0.1938272417,
0.5998717546,
0.2679316401,
0.2886083424,
-0.9728826284,
0.0090760812,
0.2620708048,
-0.2870313823,
0.308971405,
-0.0628139973,
1.0911799669,
-0.6891535521,
-0.4547991157,
0.1632371247,
0.1815045476,
0.3465822339,
0.3310093582,
0.231014967,
0.5582348704,
0.6877887249,
-0.1917270869,
1.1997177601,
0.198092401,
0.3157196641,
1.1351226568,
-0.4370654523,
0.7984703779,
0.3392278254,
-0.271476686,
0.6416306496,
0.659597218,
0.2162660956,
0.4360872805,
0.1938372403,
-0.3392367065,
-0.29929474,
0.2700274587,
-0.3523669243,
0.4611180425,
0.3768583834,
-0.4559432566,
-0.3520548642,
0.2548923492,
0.0605295785,
-0.0208061039,
-0.4094445407,
1.0873297453,
0.1542726308,
-0.9981623888,
1.0844048262,
-0.1399909705,
0.4193202555,
-0.4424592257,
-0.2502661645,
-0.0316498429,
0.153311491,
-0.1284009516,
-0.7789881229,
0.1969763041,
0.0155462176,
-0.0747878402,
0.0036003105,
0.6317097545,
-0.4341932833,
-0.3314115107,
0.2710312307,
0.6296944618,
0.3485167027,
-0.039598614,
-0.6136450171,
-0.016419163,
0.0258577447,
-0.2397226542,
0.1813059151,
0.5964641571,
-0.091237478,
0.80847013,
0.4173257649,
0.0995130688,
0.3455435038,
0.1646611691,
0.6782594919,
-0.8232249618,
-0.0512753427,
-1.1578428745,
0.4713030756,
0.2828224599,
-0.0129443277,
0.5774119496,
0.1406969577,
0.958627522,
-0.392468363,
0.9324242473,
-0.0043075569,
0.568441987,
-0.7101290822,
0.0644089431,
-0.5053379536,
0.2699172795,
0.0190627575,
-1.0900663137,
-0.1301627904,
0.7616660595,
-0.4319412708,
-0.0183053426,
1.0683305264,
0.4391004145,
0.1226614565,
0.1339649558,
0.3798944652,
0.1183569655,
0.041824203,
0.6938281655,
1.1546634436,
-0.0276503097,
0.3070516884,
-0.0732898042,
-0.0761393309,
-0.2511051297,
-0.7121102214,
-0.9465972781,
-0.6624902487,
-0.3206658959,
-0.1833204329,
-0.0348612927,
1.1231334209,
0.2379719317,
-0.8331100345,
-0.2247801572,
-0.3061699867,
0.6173670292,
-0.1996021867,
-0.1915854067,
0.118712455,
-0.6718992591,
-0.8007909656,
0.3276403546,
0.3559793234,
0.0686288998,
-0.2541781962,
-0.1408853531,
-0.2901898026,
-0.0121816788,
0.6897147298,
0.6744108796,
-1.0682531595,
-0.41695714,
-0.0298996661,
0.0007295649,
-0.0331256315,
0.9510982037,
-0.8317010999,
0.3574642837,
0.6329047084,
0.6575113535,
0.1849649549,
-0.3064487576,
0.2393376529,
-0.4750183225,
0.2622920573,
0.2121094912,
0.3465983272,
0.2613558769,
0.1005830467,
0.3303450346,
0.2152958661,
-0.6208721995,
-0.9006396532,
0.7282455564,
-0.6050770879,
-0.5639194846,
1.3247778416,
-0.1678021699,
-0.1563394964,
-0.1922315657,
-0.1589434892,
0.1162405536,
-0.1081868112,
0.6237697601,
0.9142015576,
-0.3219594061,
-0.2596002817,
-0.6660840511,
0.3875472248,
0.1901521385,
-0.571609199,
0.1604131758,
0.6742600203,
0.2396720946,
0.0808803961,
0.3689000309,
0.025481049,
0.2731702626,
-0.1474248916,
-0.1424401402,
0.0062525836,
-0.5187189579,
-0.4549482465,
0.0762384161,
0.395495832,
-0.1604405493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03027v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03027v2
|
JailBreakV-28K: A Benchmark for Assessing the Robustness of MultiModal Large Language Models against Jailbreak Attacks
| 2024-04-03T19:23:18 | 2024-04-18T17:11:53 |
Weidi Luo, Siyuan Ma, Xiaogeng Liu, Xiaoyu Guo, Chaowei Xiao
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid advancements in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs),
securing these models against malicious inputs while aligning them with human
values has emerged as a critical challenge. In this paper, we investigate an
important and unexplored question of whether techniques that successfully
jailbreak Large Language Models (LLMs) can be equally effective in jailbreaking
MLLMs. To explore this issue, we introduce JailBreakV-28K, a pioneering
benchmark designed to assess the transferability of LLM jailbreak techniques to
MLLMs, thereby evaluating the robustness of MLLMs against diverse jailbreak
attacks. Utilizing a dataset of 2, 000 malicious queries that is also proposed
in this paper, we generate 20, 000 text-based jailbreak prompts using advanced
jailbreak attacks on LLMs, alongside 8, 000 image-based jailbreak inputs from
recent MLLMs jailbreak attacks, our comprehensive dataset includes 28, 000 test
cases across a spectrum of adversarial scenarios. Our evaluation of 10
open-source MLLMs reveals a notably high Attack Success Rate (ASR) for attacks
transferred from LLMs, highlighting a critical vulnerability in MLLMs that
stems from their text-processing capabilities. Our findings underscore the
urgent need for future research to address alignment vulnerabilities in MLLMs
from both textual and visual inputs.
|
[
-0.3436038792,
-0.7396156192,
0.4093944132,
0.2660660446,
-0.1242151558,
0.2656729221,
-0.3229148388,
-0.3513735235,
-0.2060974836,
0.6178238988,
-0.3893534541,
-0.4911777675,
-0.7262618542,
0.0368580483,
-0.4582740963,
0.8242608905,
-0.0053419014,
-0.0038684676,
-0.0883510932,
-0.3974454701,
-0.6183916926,
-0.5429785848,
-0.2002152056,
0.1226650476,
0.5561209321,
0.0399852172,
0.5896268487,
0.5736240745,
0.7945679426,
0.2783722281,
-0.1124354452,
0.0782440826,
-0.4258398116,
0.2868769467,
-0.0773071125,
-0.3236930668,
-0.1892309934,
-0.1081781462,
0.3089083135,
0.0587465353,
-0.1765332371,
0.2654696703,
-0.0917610973,
0.8517274857,
-1.0011651516,
-0.2951343358,
-1.0041596889,
-0.2188040465,
-0.6047427058,
0.3429560363,
-0.7008979917,
-0.2676235437,
-0.3052040339,
-0.1340813935,
-0.1578009278,
-0.037501853,
0.7381238937,
0.1361196041,
-0.3505384326,
-0.1528163254,
-0.2847277224,
0.5548627377,
-0.9410089254,
0.3338088393,
0.3270857334,
0.5458991528,
-0.2718454599,
-0.4065367579,
-0.379602015,
-0.5009627342,
0.2616536021,
-0.2450027019,
-0.1624752879,
-0.1105100289,
0.3779799342,
0.0251521356,
-0.602645576,
0.3728730381,
-0.4174562395,
-0.2419197857,
0.5316699743,
0.1972480416,
0.5205586553,
-0.147830084,
-0.4465258121,
-0.151443705,
-0.9148727059,
0.1472357959,
0.6562094688,
0.3449400663,
-0.2036584616,
0.8102732301,
0.1618488729,
1.0109306574,
-0.3050082028,
-0.2560139298,
0.1599655896,
-0.53552562,
-0.1067957953,
-0.1171128824,
1.1483840942,
0.7168806791,
0.3877052963,
-0.3134824932,
-0.0198575333,
0.0099020703,
0.5331552625,
-0.8932931423,
-0.1044470966,
0.170050472,
-0.284953773,
-0.5409454107,
-0.017186325,
-0.9541219473,
-1.0950701237,
0.390404284,
0.1929008663,
-0.4116670191,
0.0415694155,
-0.1973402649,
-0.1069094017,
0.2632715404,
0.2432491183,
-0.9318682551,
0.1828899384,
0.5640617013,
0.7923498154,
-0.2520381808,
-0.3512829542,
-0.5445855856,
-0.0411677621,
-0.257625401,
0.5507400036,
-0.2480338812,
-0.1822819412,
-0.0107476432,
-0.1087884083,
-0.1824554503,
-0.5611332059,
0.460866034,
-0.5310356617,
-0.4623124599,
-0.0629433766,
-0.3745614886,
0.2091081738,
0.58028543,
-0.816988647,
0.6974983811,
-0.2048782408,
-0.7857593298,
0.2805973291,
-0.2585263252,
-0.3351550698,
-0.3036184907,
-0.089395836,
-0.7086239457,
-0.0816081539,
0.4153005183,
0.4133417308,
-0.2376679629,
0.3653957844,
-0.8386626244,
-0.1324857473,
0.6938881278,
-0.6223144531,
0.6835094094,
0.4026081264,
-0.3078159988,
-0.0843426138,
-0.7797062993,
-0.1455308199,
0.2934344113,
-0.3076749444,
-0.3379171193,
0.0829491168,
0.1031293795,
0.1992599666,
0.3041788042,
-0.8120685816,
0.5237336159,
-0.2544984818,
0.6108081937,
0.607763648,
-0.3002434969,
0.1590438336,
-0.123189494,
0.322799921,
-0.189582631,
0.2015760541,
-0.3188437819,
-0.3715028763,
-0.2139729112,
-0.4185639918,
0.2062838227,
0.7393898964,
-0.3784798384,
0.1440769136,
0.0109762652,
-0.7743712664,
-0.5914974213,
0.484267205,
0.532690227,
0.4473434985,
0.3652123511,
-0.07166031,
-0.5825080872,
-0.9630559087,
-0.7981545925,
-0.1573008448,
0.2302609533,
0.1922394037,
0.465780139,
-0.1721764058,
0.5261015892,
-0.2309160233,
-0.0407942832,
-0.2594816983,
-0.090364784,
0.1094429791,
0.3593809903,
0.6542149782,
-0.5206458569,
-0.4339516461,
-0.0644044951,
-0.8550999761,
-0.1094352007,
-0.0198754221,
0.2931019664,
-0.0340813361,
0.6731339693,
-0.6808992624,
0.477035284,
0.6821815968,
-0.5394463539,
0.7395029664,
-0.0636939704,
0.2639271915,
-1.0354554653,
0.0054428102,
0.0449338742,
-0.3420575857,
-0.5814172626,
0.2907850146,
0.4944880307,
-0.0874685422,
-0.6944452524,
0.3844333887,
-0.2990038097,
0.0501463935,
-0.109847948,
0.1735538542,
-0.055761084,
0.0375542305,
-0.6801633835,
0.8333925605,
0.2888807356,
0.1471708715,
0.5898693204,
0.1460161358,
-0.6148824096,
0.4263275266,
-0.5029345155,
0.2159635723,
-0.0033228567,
0.0585850887,
-1.0148205757,
-0.0115771508,
-0.0221409611,
-0.4811224043,
0.3179510534,
-0.3330362141,
-0.5116841197,
-0.1467487514,
-0.4564963579,
0.1711042076,
0.2583455741,
-0.3465690315,
0.2871902287,
0.304928273,
-0.1105876938,
-0.9722431898,
-0.6146541238,
0.5548000932,
-0.5008749962,
-0.8019786477,
0.0237455331,
0.0274044983,
-0.5242566466,
-0.14424254,
-0.0011360438,
0.1078199074,
0.4921816289,
0.3591417968,
0.5804037452,
-0.1074664071,
-0.3978563845,
-0.3628024757,
0.23956801,
0.1139536947,
-0.0357789025,
0.4754805565,
-0.2758456767,
-0.4118619561,
-0.2573350966,
0.0303192381,
1.1282117367,
-0.3043963909,
1.0628573895,
0.43479231,
-0.1693344116,
0.0404692255,
-0.7136750221,
0.2562430203,
-0.4265061021,
0.5123564601,
-0.4381817281,
-0.9543753266,
0.5862050653,
0.0895333812,
0.150836736,
0.261064738,
0.7446431518,
-0.1608491987,
0.9575560689,
0.3574999273,
-0.3932969272,
0.4627468586,
0.1975029707,
0.0417069234,
-0.8652973771,
-0.2596987188,
-0.5994190574,
-0.1677250862,
-0.4677621722,
-0.2181258649,
-0.1294258237,
0.3070299029,
-0.2833756506,
0.659268558,
-0.2512100339,
0.4181655347,
0.0537085012,
0.0158082657,
0.1913399249,
-0.3401991725,
-0.3090438843,
-0.0170295145,
-0.1465913355,
-0.4758324921,
1.4100440741,
0.4193609953,
0.9964969754,
0.3491681516,
0.5206647515,
0.423710376,
0.4590767026,
-0.4666985273,
0.3859995604,
-0.4039253592,
-0.6603350043,
-0.1707998812,
-0.2855729759,
-0.865686655,
0.3318586051,
-0.2794936597,
-1.3473705053,
-0.0604725555,
0.079772763,
-0.2890844047,
0.4631830156,
-0.7371615767,
1.2101426125,
-0.4755404592,
-0.4010226727,
0.0559777841,
-0.7410215139,
0.6697541475,
-0.3209144771,
0.6014137268,
-0.4754988551,
0.248733744,
0.6712684631,
-0.5950465798,
0.654922545,
-0.2563100159,
-0.0033831447,
0.0156711023,
0.2119361162,
0.7284621596,
0.0944191217,
0.0928197727,
-0.0689318106,
0.0102077145,
-0.2125201821,
-0.6490238309,
0.7607234716,
-0.7786164284,
-0.6061546803,
-0.1064700931,
-0.5923060179,
-0.224918142,
0.1347325891,
0.1770824343,
0.3543715775,
-0.1580732018,
0.3355895281,
0.5687704682,
-0.2684194744,
0.3797613978,
0.4113725722,
-0.4649050832,
-0.6841087341,
0.8439931273,
-0.0118583348,
0.4366159737,
0.2046046853,
0.0179877449,
-0.1048067287,
-0.8836044073,
-0.7163863778,
-0.0347222239,
-0.690357089,
-0.363283813,
-0.4712977707,
-0.2698544264,
-0.4451366663,
-0.2264145911,
-0.7269684076,
-0.1063961163,
0.0543849804,
-0.0311480556,
0.3808805048,
0.4188915491,
0.2369756848,
0.1144910231,
-0.9732388258,
0.4913901985,
0.2274760604,
0.0959811136,
-0.2612159252,
-0.4507988691,
-0.0982484147,
-0.0619443953,
-0.1998181194,
-1.1304708719,
0.312895745,
0.0130143287,
0.5306646228,
0.3563660085,
-0.0127354357,
0.7292847633,
-0.6608901024,
0.7156393528,
0.3578066528,
-0.760255754,
0.5271548033,
-0.3893528581,
0.2341707051,
0.9322582483,
-0.0885483027,
-0.4801307917,
-0.657620728,
-0.297028482,
-0.8573997021,
0.2515082657,
0.2313428372,
0.0823033974,
0.2681013942,
0.1851820201,
0.0949937254,
0.1637700796,
-0.7647234797,
-0.2714821994,
-0.2524972856,
-0.333650887,
-0.0753150359,
-0.0529519618,
-0.1616953909,
-0.1212614477,
0.1832425743,
0.1311255693,
-0.1753186584,
-0.1196269244,
-0.4380232692,
0.31462726,
0.5373943448,
0.7387111187,
0.5720894933,
-0.3687130213,
0.2880170643,
0.0467120558,
-0.8175672889,
0.4249823689,
0.3238610923,
-0.0588683449,
-0.390001297,
0.3479449749,
0.8499048948,
-0.1242813691,
-1.0368207693,
0.7299295068,
-0.35492149,
0.0288912002,
0.0049919221,
-0.0425267145,
0.1392099112,
0.3892558813,
0.1933702826,
0.2219343185,
-0.2180692554,
-0.4497585595,
0.264028728,
0.5958006382,
-0.4806168079,
-0.157889232,
0.7646661401,
-0.0554999001,
-0.3917771578,
0.8005868196,
0.195282653,
-0.3668744266,
0.6738175154,
0.600541234,
0.77819556,
-0.1137188077,
-0.0426682942,
0.0565630831,
0.8305334449,
0.0049312613,
-0.0984790772,
0.0517819114,
-0.8594963551,
-0.4882555604,
-0.6097890735,
-0.3036013842,
0.2592156827,
-0.6382956505,
0.2600279152,
-0.4474759102,
-0.2260423899,
0.0771003664,
-0.4826660752,
-0.4306953251,
0.0204024706,
0.4479212463,
0.9879612923,
-0.7950463295,
0.970328331,
0.5382539034,
0.0130322427,
-0.6026799083,
-0.3367128968,
0.3696613014,
-0.8292559385,
0.4738365412,
0.464091152,
0.1678382307,
-0.427703023,
-0.6292401552,
-0.7494507432,
0.8179969788,
0.561311245,
-0.8195976615,
0.1509678662,
0.094207108,
0.1833943725,
-0.1248734891,
-0.0481244624,
0.7891570926,
0.4385495186,
-0.1391207725,
-0.9734111428,
0.1659008712,
-0.4556216896,
-0.1879197508,
0.4394020438,
-0.4090358615,
0.7020900846,
-0.4548144042,
0.2159925401,
0.2926249802,
0.3445088267,
0.7006924748,
0.2458223403,
0.4101854861,
0.9340042472,
0.458344847,
-0.0600227341,
0.8527668715,
-0.1907350421,
0.2583698332,
1.0485280752,
-0.2866563499,
0.9392135143,
0.67157197,
-0.2440675795,
0.3198303878,
0.3162832558,
-0.456913203,
0.7802785635,
0.3783946335,
-0.0749552548,
0.0148036433,
0.3124204874,
-0.2641767561,
0.4078652859,
0.3906996548,
-0.274646461,
-0.2364878505,
0.4669386744,
0.4658398032,
0.0042126714,
-0.2528775632,
0.7692409754,
0.0927897617,
-0.5881476402,
0.5945163965,
0.1127765551,
0.6244863272,
-0.6470180154,
0.2729572356,
-0.0109762326,
0.2600483298,
-0.1318915039,
-0.8541086316,
0.2243059725,
0.4660044014,
0.0637387037,
-0.0252879933,
0.8159504533,
-0.0377426483,
-0.278111577,
0.278614819,
0.2054310888,
-0.0232870001,
-0.1166795194,
-0.601547122,
0.498087883,
-0.0139606064,
-0.2750850618,
0.7636672258,
-0.0454376601,
0.0925779864,
0.7613392472,
0.690977335,
0.2051182389,
0.3843759894,
-0.065632835,
0.911093533,
-0.6819499135,
0.0119696995,
-1.4850375652,
0.6901882291,
-0.1824532002,
-0.2943326533,
1.0287344456,
0.4443337321,
0.6491401792,
0.1735863984,
0.9263055325,
-0.1361908764,
-0.0450362749,
-0.5877522826,
0.9496980906,
-0.2435061783,
0.4655639529,
-0.4829813242,
-0.6075941324,
-0.2736366987,
0.2398419976,
-0.3674880862,
-0.4088408947,
0.5165418983,
0.6891673803,
0.3502885997,
-0.234534651,
0.37076056,
0.250477612,
0.4427485764,
0.4877634346,
1.0946296453,
-0.2905090749,
0.7502988577,
-0.0831493661,
-0.1294676661,
-0.0403150022,
-0.8427559137,
-1.0695660114,
-0.2298215777,
-0.0852970853,
-0.5503662229,
0.3561003506,
0.5704548359,
0.3669973612,
-0.6978676915,
-0.2212508619,
0.0075550755,
0.0644726902,
-0.0925466418,
-0.1543616205,
0.1723824739,
-0.2567367256,
-0.2167302072,
0.6863479614,
0.4080239236,
-0.2172140479,
-0.2993053794,
0.1813845187,
-0.2032041252,
-0.0461698286,
0.3906093836,
0.3132333457,
-0.6741791964,
-0.1195237711,
0.0185729209,
-0.4062840641,
0.1946407408,
0.7449848056,
-0.568370223,
0.6148489714,
0.2797082663,
0.8984517455,
0.4391889572,
0.0181254428,
0.4838359654,
-0.6054504514,
0.0916217491,
0.0512029119,
0.5093020797,
0.4269143343,
-0.1629345268,
0.0008774892,
0.147255525,
-0.5385588408,
-1.0506062508,
0.1576972306,
-0.8255318999,
-0.4495794475,
1.0339245796,
-0.3590061367,
-0.3478154838,
-0.1613681465,
-0.128235057,
-0.0049764756,
-0.2419512123,
0.6340820193,
0.8431993127,
0.1815228313,
-0.3688577414,
-0.8125309944,
0.2113595754,
0.0174219683,
-0.8381660581,
0.2587741613,
0.199343726,
0.391456902,
0.0560320206,
0.1652079225,
-0.4208657146,
0.1930428594,
-0.030719012,
0.0189299677,
-0.2302303463,
-0.1568612158,
-0.2691814303,
0.4900095165,
0.1893996149,
-0.0606623627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03022v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03022v2
|
BCAmirs at SemEval-2024 Task 4: Beyond Words: A Multimodal and Multilingual Exploration of Persuasion in Memes
| 2024-04-03T19:17:43 | 2024-06-11T19:34:19 |
Amirhossein Abaskohi, Amirhossein Dabiriaghdam, Lele Wang, Giuseppe Carenini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
Memes, combining text and images, frequently use metaphors to convey
persuasive messages, shaping public opinion. Motivated by this, our team
engaged in SemEval-2024 Task 4, a hierarchical multi-label classification task
designed to identify rhetorical and psychological persuasion techniques
embedded within memes. To tackle this problem, we introduced a caption
generation step to assess the modality gap and the impact of additional
semantic information from images, which improved our result. Our best model
utilizes GPT-4 generated captions alongside meme text to fine-tune RoBERTa as
the text encoder and CLIP as the image encoder. It outperforms the baseline by
a large margin in all 12 subtasks. In particular, it ranked in top-3 across all
languages in Subtask 2a, and top-4 in Subtask 2b, demonstrating quantitatively
strong performance. The improvement achieved by the introduced intermediate
step is likely attributable to the metaphorical essence of images that
challenges visual encoders. This highlights the potential for improving
abstract visual semantics encoding.
|
[
-0.6524018645,
-0.4721065164,
0.4643639922,
0.2702452242,
-0.6333543658,
0.2309017777,
-0.033438582,
-0.2728841603,
0.0466556549,
0.2590706646,
-0.6527186632,
-0.4535055161,
-0.8837013841,
0.5014752746,
0.1297676265,
1.0305997133,
-0.1295443922,
0.1014208272,
-0.4168089628,
-0.1305047572,
-0.7325253487,
-0.6631380916,
-0.5740799308,
-0.2311286628,
0.8650691509,
0.4389744401,
0.420360893,
0.1650076061,
0.3588644266,
0.3005632162,
0.2723456621,
0.1693674177,
-0.2032546401,
0.0126195513,
-0.6477150321,
-0.2946096361,
-0.1234118044,
0.2863918841,
0.3344018161,
0.1129998192,
0.1032182798,
-0.0906583369,
0.0242158342,
0.2176469713,
-0.5775244236,
0.3262848556,
-0.6953498721,
0.0446852222,
-0.4492370188,
-0.8003042936,
-0.3121986091,
-0.0721572489,
0.0598808937,
-0.153698653,
0.1064036563,
0.2167135179,
1.2026011944,
0.1142915413,
-0.7886120677,
-0.3695327342,
-0.1091378853,
1.0245469809,
-0.6706558466,
0.3276245296,
0.2348230928,
0.195472762,
-0.1385012269,
-0.9312708378,
-0.6782505512,
0.2370920926,
0.2216822654,
0.3332666159,
-0.6711274385,
0.083321698,
0.2533025742,
0.0453668907,
-0.3842299283,
-0.0601825975,
-0.6651322246,
-0.5385724902,
0.19650428,
0.0012438478,
0.4859488308,
-0.4791076481,
-0.5259977579,
-0.2911603153,
-0.7250844836,
0.0029208157,
0.2152024955,
-0.1675443202,
-0.0573718995,
0.6273989677,
-0.0104913339,
0.4622681439,
-0.0318709537,
-0.0012725095,
0.2765229642,
-0.569037199,
-0.0206731185,
0.0291781388,
0.7069945335,
0.5307792425,
-0.1531065106,
0.2037314177,
-0.0641722232,
0.4885613918,
0.1928036362,
-0.9798405766,
-0.4521206319,
-0.0767594501,
-0.3139347434,
-0.1482176036,
-0.1090980917,
-0.8978613615,
-0.2943044901,
-0.284196794,
0.816634953,
-0.481801331,
0.0571283735,
-0.0290512554,
-0.3316485584,
0.4009124637,
0.448856622,
-0.7240869999,
-0.0771789774,
0.4760088325,
0.7829713821,
-0.0102656968,
-0.1133407727,
-0.4800915718,
0.3759135604,
-0.3219601512,
1.1442624331,
-0.8020597696,
-0.0994903073,
-0.2950172722,
0.2039620876,
-0.1606428176,
-0.2662061453,
0.7653833628,
-0.4670715928,
0.2350600511,
-0.6560372114,
-0.3603609502,
-0.4955096841,
0.6337380409,
-0.6648881435,
0.2884831429,
-0.1588221639,
-0.744743228,
0.3815047741,
-0.8533046842,
-0.3086411357,
0.0414317735,
-0.6684512496,
-0.2547999024,
0.0824468881,
0.3930390775,
0.7256496549,
-0.4689000249,
-0.0548608676,
0.0493674539,
-0.0780096203,
0.52925843,
-0.6349691749,
0.231234923,
0.3703685105,
-0.5642397404,
0.1463869363,
-0.2729225755,
0.0065116105,
0.0141895367,
-0.3528591096,
-0.4239486158,
-0.0873269588,
-0.0638859645,
0.5311414003,
0.3118133247,
-0.6737616062,
-0.0461728647,
-0.0668541789,
0.7819762826,
0.8238270283,
0.2900673449,
0.2564297318,
-0.1982963234,
0.6511849165,
0.2385836989,
-0.069722347,
-0.5176103711,
-0.5993528366,
-0.5585593581,
-0.4940395057,
0.3726159632,
0.1690598428,
-1.0191681385,
-0.0943010226,
-0.3730288148,
-0.2946205437,
-0.2865327895,
-0.01703595,
0.3169746101,
0.3055225313,
0.3826285899,
-0.5482689738,
-0.5511440039,
-1.1465144157,
0.0004387174,
0.0053316643,
0.185196057,
0.1391675025,
0.7130166888,
-0.4716123343,
0.3096080124,
-0.2912485003,
-0.1579379588,
-0.2367724031,
0.7409110069,
-0.0204792731,
0.5448477864,
0.4998460412,
-0.8440744281,
-0.1414859891,
0.0069437553,
-0.5270534754,
-0.2328308523,
-0.2840812206,
-0.2123058885,
0.2718928158,
0.4820224941,
-0.470074147,
0.4141943753,
0.6774691939,
-0.4358789623,
0.619451344,
0.0376921371,
0.8748273253,
-1.113750577,
-0.3590332866,
-0.0957353115,
-0.0250871666,
-0.3620432913,
-0.1955891997,
0.0989528447,
-0.1838093549,
-0.307985425,
0.2952266335,
-0.6775356531,
0.2226055413,
-0.2556802332,
-0.2192950845,
0.3095327914,
0.3522413373,
0.0230299886,
0.9180175662,
0.5497536063,
-0.4646309018,
0.3379822969,
0.242273137,
-0.2548101842,
1.0012862682,
-0.4921141267,
0.2056556642,
-0.1962343305,
0.1907984167,
-1.2439277172,
-0.2755505443,
0.4123750329,
-0.466877073,
0.4424069524,
0.1481026262,
-0.5649186969,
-0.4847954512,
-0.3313560784,
0.5516679287,
0.2421083897,
-0.4671785235,
0.5118365884,
0.2974893153,
-0.2911781073,
-0.3521519005,
-0.6499091983,
0.5701661706,
-0.4747184217,
-0.5601143837,
0.3896948099,
-0.2052301913,
0.101446785,
-0.2356614918,
-0.1597926617,
0.0394461676,
-0.4983609915,
0.1315248162,
-0.0243532807,
0.0114328712,
-0.0165816285,
0.3844344914,
-0.1327765435,
0.1146661043,
-0.1138999984,
0.5341853499,
-0.3320837617,
-0.4265013039,
-0.4207199514,
0.4513480365,
0.5470025539,
-0.3600285053,
0.3814828098,
0.5712766647,
-0.3515071273,
0.0569044463,
-0.8036291599,
-0.2307309657,
-0.4845879376,
0.2893824279,
-0.6873107553,
-0.9588440657,
0.2881441116,
-0.3949338198,
0.0174791161,
0.1502090544,
0.455743432,
-0.1933972239,
1.1422693729,
0.380348593,
0.1761582792,
0.1969603598,
-0.2896357775,
0.1972092986,
-0.707659781,
-0.5055849552,
-0.4024709463,
-0.4163704216,
-0.3267464042,
-1.0238962173,
0.4477141798,
-0.2477401048,
-0.0218700841,
0.4867941737,
-0.4325464368,
0.2159604728,
0.486171037,
0.0846425369,
-0.0191405248,
0.3663946688,
-0.2726066113,
-0.7567650676,
-0.6978865862,
-0.6098208427,
0.5828216672,
0.3196175992,
0.6920647621,
0.2283304632,
0.5158523917,
0.3858543336,
0.0553435385,
-0.5931718946,
0.7455911636,
0.0665716678,
-0.4692600667,
0.0353279114,
-0.1310452968,
-1.2030792236,
0.4275189638,
-0.1937196851,
-0.4540139139,
0.2413916439,
-0.0315188728,
0.1664713919,
0.2265443206,
-0.2709791064,
1.1973367929,
-0.3182065785,
-0.4475187063,
-0.5681521297,
-0.578397274,
0.1805205792,
-0.0929365233,
0.3342036307,
-0.1344113052,
-0.3029006422,
0.8118424416,
-0.1957054585,
0.6627948284,
0.0116086509,
0.0129479533,
0.383643508,
-0.0404536761,
0.2125355601,
-0.4672637284,
0.0335096382,
0.2273897678,
0.2420372814,
-0.5586161017,
-0.599390626,
0.6370497346,
-0.5320146084,
-0.5282233357,
-0.6068982482,
-0.3889397979,
-0.0742445514,
0.0668491125,
0.3827829063,
0.6843681931,
-0.0928975642,
0.4585663974,
0.5236727595,
-0.4498716891,
0.3911099136,
0.2455946803,
0.4769847095,
-0.7742074132,
1.0073285103,
0.1565935612,
-0.0216288362,
0.4132484496,
0.2261499763,
-0.7427192926,
-0.5501207113,
-0.5366438031,
0.2179145068,
-1.0417108536,
-0.4804204404,
-0.599268198,
-0.0484175719,
-0.3743298948,
-0.2373829931,
-0.0651539639,
-0.3847818077,
-0.3374142349,
-0.1158111915,
0.0303324088,
0.4995755851,
-0.1189243868,
0.2794360518,
-0.7781752348,
-0.1219468638,
0.3685445189,
-0.1362967789,
-0.2377513051,
-0.5981271863,
-0.0801808238,
-0.2009621263,
-0.7748488188,
-1.2070504427,
0.3971066773,
0.1281879693,
0.7406775355,
0.7159450054,
-0.0089938883,
0.9967859387,
-0.5604069233,
0.8769486547,
0.6167653203,
-0.8510821462,
0.6858234406,
-0.4999824762,
0.3488317132,
0.3215786219,
0.4707979262,
-0.2783959806,
-0.3720699549,
-0.6624455452,
-0.807602644,
0.29518646,
0.5232816935,
0.5726565719,
-0.2939528227,
0.1127550751,
0.1528318077,
0.5100184679,
-0.8964698911,
0.1009239405,
-0.439389199,
-0.1180878282,
-0.0146870762,
-0.5057888627,
-0.2504022121,
-0.3181013465,
0.601590991,
-0.1326960921,
0.3320764899,
0.0246382765,
0.046155829,
0.1180441678,
0.6729594469,
0.5829010606,
0.6971750259,
0.2302101403,
0.5854409337,
0.1494860053,
-0.0993606076,
0.1675955951,
0.1555144489,
-0.0109629482,
-0.0064975633,
0.1723120958,
0.8672744036,
0.4539087117,
-0.6912837029,
0.4915629625,
0.0067372471,
-0.2925358415,
-0.1250855923,
-0.2790779173,
-0.063267678,
0.3592958152,
0.3355313241,
0.0977846906,
0.4956174493,
-0.6504079103,
0.35380885,
0.5226635337,
-0.3091629446,
-0.622315526,
0.7397424579,
0.3074213862,
0.3489386439,
0.0227243658,
-0.1321673095,
-0.7070648074,
0.4743821323,
0.6934396625,
0.5238368511,
-0.1467518806,
0.3200024366,
0.5339326859,
0.4139916599,
0.0882289186,
0.3909151554,
-0.2123195976,
-0.6559759378,
-0.3040757775,
-0.4848235846,
-0.3821968138,
0.3176390827,
-0.3119036853,
0.454251945,
-0.4698742926,
-0.3159231246,
0.0825759694,
-0.0950199515,
-0.6513621211,
0.4316733181,
0.2092701793,
0.6424037814,
-0.7972793579,
0.3932978213,
1.2477101088,
-0.7078847885,
-0.7699788213,
-0.1395247132,
0.1201792955,
-0.1817835271,
0.4111994207,
0.5101384521,
-0.0738993213,
0.2000216991,
-1.0413111448,
-0.6193897128,
1.1331248283,
0.2586206794,
-0.1721820533,
0.3616153896,
-0.0234464258,
0.3127126098,
-0.4971742332,
0.1874458343,
0.3179844618,
0.6920369864,
0.5601381063,
-0.5647706985,
0.2367381752,
-0.3294007778,
0.0392406732,
-0.0998315066,
-0.561180532,
0.7238669991,
-0.1017581597,
-0.3343710005,
0.0982340574,
0.9656825662,
0.5286186337,
0.549197793,
0.4135137796,
0.3174789846,
0.5962663889,
-0.1479504853,
0.8126995564,
0.0102047091,
-0.2922931314,
0.759979248,
0.0658652931,
0.6741349101,
0.6482809782,
0.0747998431,
0.8234199882,
0.940005362,
-0.1476331055,
0.7095266581,
0.2040046304,
-0.4563629031,
-0.4032276571,
-0.3453142047,
-0.3426133394,
0.521338284,
0.5349013209,
-0.2420185506,
-0.2566911876,
0.3552337885,
0.1136510149,
0.2802986801,
-0.3320843577,
0.5594408512,
0.1779387444,
-0.6595061421,
0.4352104068,
0.1890891939,
0.6843172908,
-0.5991727114,
-0.2859871089,
0.2436065376,
0.0257183518,
-0.1293910146,
-0.6947286129,
0.1837257296,
-0.2425474524,
0.0043454994,
-0.2594451904,
0.9245741367,
-0.431679219,
-0.4394589067,
0.053160239,
0.3802005947,
0.6467577219,
-0.0038579693,
-0.9138582349,
0.3260762095,
-0.0519520044,
0.0860165209,
0.2038537115,
0.798144877,
-0.4103132188,
0.4902159572,
0.6071212888,
-0.0160779096,
0.0333963148,
0.2885137498,
0.8941640854,
-0.6013746262,
-0.5474389791,
-0.8000419736,
0.4646044374,
-0.1471688449,
0.0448620208,
0.8806348443,
0.5137435794,
0.6500959396,
-0.370028168,
0.8315109015,
-0.3316830695,
-0.0319915004,
-0.4590531588,
0.4745226204,
-0.7684243321,
0.0722837523,
-0.600628376,
-0.797173202,
-0.1242549643,
0.6589075923,
-0.4326279759,
-0.0794338584,
0.7707794905,
0.8075829148,
-0.0679254904,
0.0024357331,
0.4965192676,
0.0544422418,
0.4276508093,
0.5590583682,
1.1636523008,
-0.3404310942,
0.8709088564,
0.0188512523,
-0.1574661434,
0.2020882368,
-1.0039995909,
-1.0813946724,
-0.835303247,
-0.5337228179,
-0.2847927809,
0.0240484029,
0.8774141669,
0.5736618638,
-0.8689200282,
0.0211352073,
0.1194438264,
-0.1201467961,
0.0671034977,
-0.1779535413,
0.0723608583,
-0.2448495328,
-1.0047165155,
0.2040815651,
0.5562210679,
0.140076682,
-0.0992434621,
-0.1007925197,
-0.3578723967,
0.3597648144,
0.8013861179,
0.1153690144,
-0.8427786827,
-0.4619765282,
-0.2553037405,
0.0271931551,
0.0203342848,
0.7191053033,
-0.5025296807,
0.6377893686,
0.5838608742,
0.4614173174,
0.3475147188,
0.3565956056,
0.6489206553,
-0.4151268899,
0.1163425148,
0.1067721769,
0.419208914,
0.731172204,
0.0096025914,
0.5195587873,
0.4164207578,
-0.4199010134,
-0.5792537332,
0.1600022465,
-1.0709744692,
-0.3065555394,
1.1573758125,
-0.0674723238,
-0.2099841684,
-0.2435117364,
-0.581153214,
0.0812594816,
-0.4410813451,
0.6001597643,
0.9401273131,
-0.1828838885,
-0.5890398026,
-0.5028526187,
0.405754149,
0.5272178054,
-0.8365879655,
-0.5949980021,
0.9170944095,
0.3185261488,
0.2595120966,
0.8502240777,
-0.453736037,
0.3676886857,
-0.1017312333,
0.146745801,
0.1400068402,
-0.3394892514,
-0.0802803338,
0.1013805643,
-0.0807196423,
-0.4011216164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03021v1
|
Blessing or curse? A survey on the Impact of Generative AI on Fake News
| 2024-04-03T19:14:45 | 2024-04-03T19:14:45 |
Alexander Loth, Martin Kappes, Marc-Oliver Pahl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Fake news significantly influence our society. They impact consumers, voters,
and many other societal groups. While Fake News exist for a centuries,
Generative AI brings fake news on a new level. It is now possible to automate
the creation of masses of high-quality individually targeted Fake News. On the
other end, Generative AI can also help detecting Fake News. Both fields are
young but developing fast.
This survey provides a comprehensive examination of the research and
practical use of Generative AI for Fake News detection and creation in 2024.
Following the Structured Literature Survey approach, the paper synthesizes
current results in the following topic clusters 1) enabling technologies, 2)
creation of Fake News, 3) case study social media as most relevant distribution
channel, 4) detection of Fake News, and 5) deepfakes as upcoming technology.
The article also identifies current challenges and open issues.
|
[
-0.4341668189,
-0.9305570126,
0.4659574926,
0.4481936097,
-0.3729848266,
0.2787709534,
0.2911126316,
-0.879819572,
0.420571357,
0.3477810323,
-0.2500923574,
-0.0609029122,
-0.7213376164,
0.1251485795,
-0.7102460861,
1.097243309,
0.3819380403,
0.370303452,
-0.3224063814,
0.2097895294,
-0.4012621939,
-0.4155549109,
-0.6677843928,
-0.0161729306,
0.2256542146,
0.0635512471,
0.6913976669,
0.0374027155,
0.3855623901,
0.4427929223,
0.3210020959,
0.4533605874,
-0.1953482777,
-0.0374970771,
-0.1790323853,
-0.4947789609,
-0.29471609,
0.3551886678,
0.3704700768,
0.4039820135,
0.2282817811,
0.0881629512,
-0.1256874353,
0.4453880489,
-0.4112989008,
-0.262285322,
-0.5531792641,
0.2458168268,
-0.495354861,
-0.3597470224,
-0.1327370852,
-0.6246547103,
-0.1054318994,
-0.5659787059,
0.6290704012,
0.0514868423,
0.7731668949,
0.4266027212,
-0.4971624017,
-0.4859169126,
-0.8679596782,
0.6235191822,
-0.3868355751,
0.3377826214,
0.3125925362,
0.2216414213,
-0.2357589602,
-0.7162405252,
-1.000439167,
-0.397711575,
0.2628520131,
0.359752506,
-0.1412807703,
-0.195585683,
-0.0462282635,
0.5968070626,
-0.4121321738,
0.0752293617,
-0.4833925962,
-0.3717408478,
0.6317048669,
-0.0125854537,
0.8046512008,
-0.351690799,
-0.3986305594,
0.0778451189,
-0.3571856618,
-0.3492913544,
0.7164055109,
-0.0250737853,
-0.1041958854,
0.4261071384,
-0.0148514761,
0.6361450553,
0.170209378,
-0.2941473424,
0.0784519911,
-0.5057504177,
-0.2437979281,
0.1938692927,
0.8436629772,
0.3346836269,
0.0399332643,
0.0226721931,
-0.1127473786,
0.5756690502,
0.6562728882,
-0.3876956999,
-0.1150196195,
-0.089621827,
-0.4568190277,
-0.7592709661,
0.4559330046,
-0.7626528144,
-0.9226254821,
-0.2765791416,
0.1774258316,
-0.2980398536,
-0.2953671813,
0.0503503121,
-0.6496710777,
0.2067999989,
0.6305570006,
-0.3425291479,
-0.0733886138,
0.6230528951,
0.58270365,
0.106315963,
0.0014442473,
-0.4695857763,
-0.3746127188,
-0.5587046742,
0.9882863164,
-0.0952554271,
-0.4427385032,
0.0220089201,
-0.19536452,
0.4458733797,
-0.5110785365,
0.697953999,
-0.5806857347,
0.2150263488,
-0.1018111333,
-0.3295099735,
0.0802267641,
0.3124299049,
-0.7629723549,
0.4685820043,
-0.049306754,
-0.433359623,
0.7781377435,
-0.3356563151,
-0.8727038503,
0.3680155575,
-0.1498892456,
-0.6874745488,
0.4475203454,
0.2439704835,
0.130676344,
-0.0449058525,
0.1895098984,
-0.2065208405,
-0.2261103541,
0.421421349,
-1.0609284639,
0.8719826341,
0.4337567389,
-0.6725409627,
-0.3689440489,
-0.4931016564,
-0.3492108583,
-0.1508563459,
-0.1285845339,
-0.382112205,
-0.0732539296,
0.1031013429,
0.1020616814,
0.0342856571,
-0.6594926715,
0.1651494354,
-0.3171349168,
0.0446142219,
0.7647175789,
0.1848397106,
0.2922028899,
-0.1913156658,
0.6366884112,
0.1284043193,
0.5769673586,
0.0979165658,
-0.7238453627,
-0.7667279243,
0.0029245517,
0.5259922743,
0.3925998509,
-1.2950898409,
0.4358996153,
-0.0359057449,
-0.3830702007,
-0.6809219122,
-0.1210868582,
0.485058248,
0.1746391058,
0.2797034085,
-0.3343560994,
-0.6750282645,
-0.6370049119,
-0.5601468682,
-0.2073922008,
0.0632405132,
-0.0268290509,
0.4242959619,
0.051923532,
0.8000059128,
-0.0674975961,
-0.5561637878,
-0.1352028996,
0.2599955499,
-0.1978025585,
0.2853980064,
0.6205883622,
-1.4117058516,
-0.3363776803,
-0.0903702006,
-0.9696701169,
0.0914579108,
-0.3059892356,
0.2097107619,
0.6467308998,
0.1059322059,
-0.7218292356,
0.6144638062,
0.6200885177,
-0.5447983742,
0.6894886494,
0.121243991,
0.6363883615,
-1.0553252697,
-0.2138512731,
-0.1025689989,
-0.1971700639,
-0.6447066665,
-0.0867229998,
-0.1568921357,
-0.0824855119,
-0.3270418644,
0.5900315046,
-0.4469142854,
-0.0392598584,
-0.3984061182,
-0.148230657,
-0.144430846,
-0.4391657114,
-0.2269430906,
0.7696617246,
0.4515656531,
-0.5284044147,
0.5847069621,
0.0368958674,
-0.7067754269,
0.6660728455,
-0.4211942852,
0.0854149908,
-0.1536208838,
0.7272896767,
-0.5593459606,
-0.3752567768,
0.7013711929,
-1.1692948341,
-0.0564589538,
0.2793138325,
-0.7248718739,
-0.7305880189,
-0.2399463505,
0.31899032,
0.4913374484,
-0.7375677228,
0.5976011157,
0.2068961263,
0.4031171501,
-0.5708816648,
-0.8591516614,
0.6480392814,
-0.0251488611,
-0.5846580863,
0.4220358133,
0.0932573602,
-0.5547212958,
0.1498521566,
-0.1977623105,
0.2409148365,
-0.0397002362,
0.3333634734,
-0.0978356898,
-0.0302736703,
-0.0376268961,
-0.0654309466,
0.0799522996,
-0.0462245308,
-0.271603018,
0.2199171633,
0.0661623031,
-0.2765944004,
-0.7830105424,
0.2850961089,
0.704469502,
-0.0935746804,
0.5396192074,
0.5748828053,
-0.2729915679,
-0.3940937519,
-0.869828999,
-0.1745743454,
-0.5185441971,
-0.0152016077,
0.0223920718,
-0.5956379175,
0.0977826864,
0.189157173,
-0.3355528116,
0.2222607434,
0.3670785129,
0.1937694699,
1.0242054462,
0.5924501419,
-0.3765442371,
0.3945262432,
-0.1675717533,
0.594154954,
-0.0049596392,
-0.2913448215,
-0.2735583186,
-0.1311925799,
-0.5634683967,
-0.4695064127,
0.6052999496,
0.01683628,
0.4753640592,
0.0029356261,
-0.726198256,
0.0639534369,
0.9418873787,
0.0395258516,
0.5913507938,
0.1568211317,
0.4997628629,
0.2272261083,
-0.197718516,
-0.312672019,
0.9853072166,
-0.0243943762,
0.4096613824,
0.0063026217,
0.5942178369,
1.0796042681,
0.730145812,
-0.5281018019,
0.4106314182,
-0.1965260953,
-0.7080144882,
-0.1297281981,
-0.1309555471,
-0.7969069481,
-0.1159107164,
-0.0437195189,
0.1268912703,
0.1654081196,
0.2325301468,
-0.3310417235,
0.3770259619,
-0.5251544118,
0.253498584,
-0.4066305757,
-0.0016566053,
-0.3022332788,
-0.4872354865,
0.6255593896,
-0.0493262075,
0.2997748852,
0.2507520318,
0.1443155706,
0.3669430614,
-0.4423532188,
1.0310878754,
-0.3217502236,
-0.1906457245,
0.497079134,
-0.3782871068,
0.5056054592,
0.1739415526,
-0.0510232411,
0.1701327413,
-0.5045990944,
-0.3479952216,
-0.5579220057,
0.7898961306,
-0.5313464403,
-0.7179068923,
-0.784994483,
-0.2004925013,
-0.0034201401,
0.0143136391,
0.4833202064,
0.1175777987,
-0.3960736394,
-0.1548179388,
0.3678361475,
-0.3560601771,
0.4785527289,
0.408364445,
0.0016547466,
-0.5176841021,
1.3802047968,
0.2190883458,
-0.1999612153,
0.0368000381,
-0.0016792556,
-0.0923082381,
-0.3810957372,
-0.6487449408,
-0.0319644734,
-0.2150186449,
-0.3682746887,
-0.4841661155,
-0.3327663243,
-0.9089214802,
-0.2493047565,
-0.2685806751,
-0.0767448097,
-0.4585424662,
-0.2117092311,
0.2736091316,
0.8533859253,
-0.2798036337,
-0.0809584707,
-0.4168719053,
0.7771074176,
0.4876171947,
0.1662459075,
-0.1672213078,
0.0181074459,
-0.009287307,
0.1245745644,
-0.4823750556,
-0.7621713877,
0.3712983429,
-0.0713694096,
0.223750174,
0.8111368418,
0.1619279534,
0.5495284796,
-0.2970493436,
1.2638425827,
0.3596301079,
-0.6620892882,
0.549243927,
-0.4190713465,
0.0252998173,
0.2340530157,
0.4267721772,
-0.3229812384,
-0.6186264753,
-0.8263523579,
-0.2897720337,
0.1760020703,
0.1903828233,
0.7537950873,
-0.2174380571,
0.01456529,
0.3387674689,
0.4087381065,
-0.695840776,
-0.4171891809,
-0.5159854293,
0.2434425354,
0.2183332592,
-0.1430394351,
0.279697597,
-0.4669340849,
0.4903492928,
0.2025989592,
0.4533457756,
0.1343437433,
0.2395679653,
-0.116587095,
-0.0917953774,
0.7006468773,
0.3832097352,
0.2495299578,
0.2748284638,
-0.2863016427,
-0.5065326095,
-0.0265745427,
0.1571954787,
-0.4567667246,
0.2872988284,
0.3829913735,
0.7123712301,
-0.2856894135,
-0.4337589741,
0.5937094688,
0.264051497,
-0.4722914696,
-0.9190882444,
-0.0410730094,
-0.3326207399,
0.0967108831,
0.8031315804,
0.4808995128,
0.320989579,
-0.8077275157,
0.0865922049,
0.5846672654,
-0.3612189889,
-0.5121791959,
0.7610077858,
0.2898247838,
-0.5580359697,
0.6535719037,
-0.4154757261,
-0.6465224624,
0.7339451313,
0.4667869806,
0.7089454532,
-0.4678345621,
0.6661898494,
-0.0271192323,
0.2475654185,
-0.1778973192,
0.1572729498,
-0.0221723784,
-0.9320040345,
-0.100978151,
-0.877096355,
0.0257749856,
0.4869195521,
-0.065775238,
0.1921532899,
-0.2179483175,
-0.3465003669,
0.1588534862,
0.0272443779,
-0.5152620673,
0.4774618447,
0.2072061747,
0.4812352359,
-0.6929914355,
0.4341112375,
0.624135673,
-0.5450379848,
-0.2689238489,
0.364567101,
0.2781727314,
-0.6189501882,
0.4510336816,
0.0263067558,
0.0176020283,
0.1516009122,
-0.895308435,
-0.5783526897,
0.5396471024,
0.1635983884,
-0.2122564167,
-0.085019134,
0.4098369777,
0.7142329216,
0.1244903952,
-0.206078887,
0.27817747,
0.8529881239,
-0.2585116029,
-0.6428035498,
-0.0390955582,
-0.3834804595,
0.1777386963,
0.1931589842,
-0.6158223748,
0.535222888,
-0.0986073613,
-0.4132649899,
0.3035901189,
0.891920805,
0.1287141442,
0.731097579,
0.3606556058,
0.7985827327,
0.3588602841,
0.0413183831,
1.4005331993,
-0.0952480361,
-0.0941028595,
0.4891435802,
0.1674535573,
0.024970483,
0.4484303594,
-0.184945032,
0.5555178523,
0.4108648598,
-0.5497207046,
0.2494140118,
0.3862379491,
-0.7753394246,
-0.0994252488,
-0.521745801,
-0.4866597056,
0.3845759928,
0.3527235687,
-0.5165400505,
-0.0743873343,
0.6919845343,
0.1010471135,
0.3027715385,
-0.2474890798,
0.4247871041,
0.2456887066,
-0.811283052,
0.1647757441,
0.1700934768,
0.9356600046,
-0.1683588177,
-0.284355402,
-0.3555401266,
0.0711831525,
-0.2264460325,
-0.392057389,
0.209218666,
-0.069563739,
-0.3517814279,
-0.3051581979,
0.9253496528,
-0.0684651807,
-0.5692968369,
0.0959821045,
0.4768404961,
0.0598948821,
-0.2855402827,
-0.3450492918,
0.12861301,
-0.2793842554,
-0.0687739477,
0.2370085418,
0.2778005004,
-0.232274428,
0.3656195104,
0.8277079463,
0.2037972063,
0.1866121739,
0.2894236445,
0.5839304924,
-0.3854247928,
-0.2998980582,
-0.5746651888,
0.4168407619,
-0.4522747993,
-0.6210902333,
1.1771111488,
0.4976575375,
0.7363319993,
-0.4035217166,
1.0812202692,
-0.5253518224,
0.2074970454,
-0.2298275679,
1.037108779,
-0.6147605777,
-0.175491184,
-0.3217866421,
-0.7104252577,
-0.3108027875,
0.0847725123,
-0.2036830038,
0.2234123051,
0.4046840966,
0.664534688,
0.1021751091,
0.0497590862,
0.4414138794,
0.0802820101,
0.2243596613,
-0.097732313,
1.0362480879,
-0.6105117798,
0.4052827358,
-0.1534021795,
-0.2037180662,
-0.334091723,
-0.4688673317,
-0.4777498841,
-0.5460039973,
-0.2937974036,
-0.3217741847,
0.4457823038,
0.1795621216,
0.4955167174,
-0.693739295,
0.3975274265,
-0.6006561518,
0.3350781798,
-0.3729481995,
-0.4167084694,
0.2775925696,
-0.3828449547,
-0.9412189126,
0.5122910738,
0.0637842715,
0.1371272802,
-0.5742131472,
0.1540219486,
0.084321551,
0.1470483243,
0.7788811326,
0.4156027436,
-0.9077797532,
-0.3606424928,
-0.1098011136,
-0.1259858608,
-0.4177308381,
0.856108427,
-1.0367975235,
0.4362641275,
0.4229568541,
0.4994587004,
0.0939688757,
0.2399306744,
0.6391429305,
-0.6028555036,
-0.0434137955,
0.291179359,
-0.2171092182,
0.3161618412,
-0.7751372457,
0.414003402,
0.8037875295,
-0.4522702098,
-0.9102928042,
0.1504590064,
-0.7983272076,
-0.4827502966,
0.9422445297,
0.4524225593,
-0.0305828359,
-0.4098603129,
-0.0377869494,
0.279573679,
-0.2801589072,
1.2928079367,
0.2145614028,
-0.1568906903,
-0.0869868323,
-0.410415113,
0.8381572366,
0.3946518898,
-0.8871791363,
-0.6524456739,
0.7546088696,
0.1013683751,
0.4531427622,
0.7018824816,
-0.2018022984,
0.4670963585,
0.1784145236,
0.0984283835,
-0.1003908366,
-0.5067286491,
-0.0294362642,
0.1886401623,
-0.4841600657,
-0.0172975678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02983v1
|
Towards a Fully Interpretable and More Scalable RSA Model for Metaphor Understanding
| 2024-04-03T18:09:33 | 2024-04-03T18:09:33 |
Gaia Carenini, Luca Bischetti, Walter Schaeken, Valentina Bambini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Rational Speech Act (RSA) model provides a flexible framework to model
pragmatic reasoning in computational terms. However, state-of-the-art RSA
models are still fairly distant from modern machine learning techniques and
present a number of limitations related to their interpretability and
scalability. Here, we introduce a new RSA framework for metaphor understanding
that addresses these limitations by providing an explicit formula - based on
the mutually shared information between the speaker and the listener - for the
estimation of the communicative goal and by learning the rationality parameter
using gradient-based methods. The model was tested against 24 metaphors, not
limited to the conventional $\textit{John-is-a-shark}$ type. Results suggest an
overall strong positive correlation between the distributions generated by the
model and the interpretations obtained from the human behavioral data, which
increased when the intended meaning capitalized on properties that were
inherent to the vehicle concept. Overall, findings suggest that metaphor
processing is well captured by a typicality-based Bayesian model, even when
more scalable and interpretable, opening up possible applications to other
pragmatic phenomena and novel uses for increasing Large Language Models
interpretability. Yet, results highlight that the more creative nuances of
metaphorical meaning, not strictly encoded in the lexical concepts, are a
challenging aspect for machines.
|
[
-0.2171140015,
-0.6938394904,
0.6628641486,
0.4111639261,
-0.6559614539,
-0.2217793614,
-0.2283796817,
-0.2592311203,
0.45014745,
0.2504913509,
-0.5312758684,
-0.0893394127,
-0.722838521,
0.0340117812,
-0.1749880761,
0.5324652195,
0.3070559204,
0.0143932281,
0.0275554471,
-0.3534136415,
-0.7463728189,
-0.5418816209,
-0.5695201159,
-0.2530014217,
0.6594212651,
-0.0157140009,
1.0609635115,
0.9976031184,
0.6363678575,
0.3148324192,
-0.1480677426,
-0.2104903162,
-0.3253391087,
0.2025707364,
-0.4320120811,
-0.6223479509,
-0.2125446647,
0.3968661129,
0.9264879227,
0.8922177553,
-0.5467126369,
0.1129420996,
-0.364082247,
0.5168577433,
-0.5618984103,
0.6949673295,
-1.0230969191,
-0.0184963979,
0.0212384053,
-0.4211570919,
-0.3448474705,
0.1281449348,
0.2674919367,
-1.0045480728,
-0.1547182798,
0.1293445826,
0.9517726302,
0.1689919382,
-0.2738074958,
-0.3099740148,
-0.5706905127,
1.0624443293,
-0.3791884482,
0.3098190725,
0.1292028874,
0.7570337057,
-0.2399570644,
-0.9262316823,
-1.0145304203,
-0.3331498802,
0.044766847,
-0.1146600991,
-0.4530251622,
-0.0493314527,
0.4394912124,
0.0341364443,
-0.4314603508,
-0.2773894966,
-0.3706642985,
-0.0194573011,
0.428653419,
0.4198318124,
0.486076802,
-0.3864983618,
-0.6057983041,
-0.275958389,
-0.4115478694,
0.1181950346,
-0.0970589519,
0.545178771,
-0.4587557018,
0.2708445191,
-0.0722837672,
0.9202697873,
-0.490454644,
-0.0400218926,
0.2344703227,
-0.2494998127,
-0.383374244,
-0.3262075484,
0.518445909,
0.1604618579,
0.5826635957,
-0.1577828676,
-0.1312366724,
0.4182480872,
0.291098088,
-0.650493145,
-0.1500452906,
-0.0463352352,
-0.4364641309,
-0.089542374,
0.1043997034,
-0.4353976846,
-0.4476883411,
-0.785130322,
0.3159528077,
-0.4782207608,
-0.4260817468,
0.5302423835,
-0.4326285422,
0.3830638826,
0.3516751826,
-0.754591465,
0.2417488247,
0.9395065308,
0.8767198324,
0.1723164022,
-0.3273762465,
-0.6090852022,
0.2846657932,
-0.2952205539,
0.7236161828,
-1.0672943592,
0.0262483191,
-0.3547979891,
-0.18305628,
-0.3505784869,
-0.2289665639,
0.3925736547,
-0.6233254075,
0.1415007859,
-0.1277972162,
-0.3317815065,
-0.6055813432,
0.1113410667,
-0.6130542755,
0.17490758,
0.1746784747,
-0.5455555916,
0.2775745094,
-0.510061264,
-0.2300472707,
0.1833657175,
-0.6276462078,
-0.1428833306,
0.2272794992,
-0.0421380773,
0.6024866104,
-0.7400764823,
0.6002805829,
-0.5301934481,
-0.4809551835,
0.8105077147,
-0.5048964024,
0.8931174278,
0.1770265549,
0.0464954451,
0.1603766531,
-0.7089874148,
-0.0836132914,
0.1695285887,
0.3981666267,
-0.3297947049,
-0.0308330655,
0.0310409293,
0.355961889,
0.0621555746,
-0.2297210097,
-0.1569204479,
-0.4417157471,
0.8919218183,
0.7924137115,
0.0021751097,
0.4919409156,
-0.5945604444,
0.6450398564,
0.0685814917,
-0.0341838785,
-0.2400535047,
-0.5574374795,
-0.2331530005,
-1.0294770002,
0.2413977385,
0.3915423453,
-0.310631156,
0.1442929059,
-0.4838915467,
-0.4523244202,
-0.3064706028,
-0.2606034279,
0.2066900134,
0.4856590629,
0.1983643174,
-0.4633752406,
-0.6102870107,
-1.1401342154,
-0.5350059271,
-0.3478104472,
-0.2793862224,
0.2324233651,
0.3515446484,
-0.0232505109,
0.9901884198,
-0.2397698909,
-0.2194883674,
-0.3734174669,
0.4987483621,
0.3686768413,
0.4379239976,
0.3868461251,
-0.9980471134,
-0.2257052362,
-0.1035356969,
-0.6902077794,
0.1326511949,
-0.6015741825,
-0.0804494619,
-0.554956615,
-0.0479698442,
-1.1456511021,
0.2672147751,
0.1186277047,
-0.3475575149,
0.1939389408,
0.0105003612,
-0.1489416063,
-1.0485098362,
-0.0328854956,
0.2533784211,
-0.0678798184,
-0.563916862,
0.1438346058,
-0.0571196415,
-0.0681491494,
-0.4039940834,
0.4712957144,
-0.1652065367,
-0.3998261988,
-0.1869955361,
0.4166629314,
-0.095730491,
0.4431340694,
0.3426466286,
0.7969661951,
0.5758051276,
-0.66318959,
0.2614005804,
-0.0095182797,
-0.0935833231,
0.4480805099,
-0.7193039656,
-0.1640789211,
-0.5155673623,
0.4496836364,
-0.9319098592,
-0.2578642964,
0.5193045139,
-0.699236393,
-0.0357336774,
0.0233192872,
-0.2403321415,
0.293484509,
-0.0942468345,
0.3947972357,
0.7417333722,
-0.3754455149,
1.0960608721,
0.5620100498,
-0.0226903539,
-0.5955283046,
-0.3049831688,
0.1576505154,
-0.4528145194,
-0.6503911018,
0.2508986294,
0.217140317,
-0.6214821339,
-0.3234946132,
-0.0650209561,
-0.3521048725,
0.3241859972,
0.4186339974,
0.4521008134,
-0.2284707576,
0.099219121,
-0.1080242172,
-0.253023833,
0.3587806225,
0.1225851476,
0.3518707156,
-0.2166596204,
0.1472508162,
-1.1216608286,
0.0556543767,
0.8584894538,
-0.1263694763,
0.907227397,
0.2939955592,
-0.4234609604,
-0.3057491779,
-0.0600115284,
-0.3908474445,
-0.4065746069,
0.2360556722,
-0.6209244728,
-0.6271734238,
0.5313652158,
-0.0572185367,
-0.056929864,
0.4079564214,
0.421610713,
-0.1433702856,
0.8664675355,
0.3627970219,
0.1263166517,
0.4350519776,
0.0719384551,
0.2872365117,
-0.5497963428,
-0.1382934898,
-0.5966200233,
-0.1402524859,
-0.4537142515,
-0.78100878,
-0.014584613,
-0.0043429001,
-0.3152334988,
0.3501924574,
-0.3482702076,
0.2428295165,
0.0743986219,
-0.3732727766,
0.3816166818,
0.2321219146,
0.1090574339,
-0.2893147171,
-0.5751349926,
-0.8601398468,
0.7679545879,
0.6055040359,
0.2869640589,
0.082437247,
0.148446545,
0.2091683894,
0.6928555965,
-0.6898133755,
0.7910193205,
0.215771988,
-0.6006814837,
-0.3349389732,
-0.5509563684,
-0.7841653824,
0.9248338342,
-0.2948088944,
-0.7243664861,
-0.0589567833,
0.0434126519,
-0.2062074393,
0.0455289297,
-0.5763161778,
0.8600090146,
0.2877871394,
-0.0648158267,
-0.6343919635,
-0.7088176608,
0.4687907398,
-0.086708881,
0.4484601319,
-0.430128783,
-0.3282860518,
0.6462823749,
0.0032825968,
0.8471441269,
-0.0946614817,
0.1491082162,
0.2485541701,
-0.1104608625,
0.5073781013,
0.1722492874,
-0.0753635764,
0.2506676018,
0.2505421638,
-0.5782403946,
-1.2571377754,
0.1833826452,
-0.5649894476,
-0.4896839857,
-0.6177463531,
-0.7950724363,
-0.2173034698,
-0.0861170664,
-0.3325587511,
0.2806953192,
-0.1307513714,
0.2272929549,
0.4018521309,
-0.1945054531,
-0.0050811321,
0.8253707886,
0.1247140691,
-0.2239521891,
1.0804960728,
-0.0016422995,
-0.0729678646,
0.3924534917,
0.1805016845,
-0.317925483,
-0.4338760972,
-0.4052537084,
0.4802651107,
-0.6242868304,
0.1891043633,
-0.5311070085,
0.0204486549,
0.0159627777,
0.0195331909,
-0.1694395244,
-0.7167060971,
-0.3106915355,
0.039468009,
0.1336075217,
0.406683892,
-0.0014404948,
0.4974719882,
-0.5058174729,
0.4665289223,
0.0977557749,
0.1344196796,
0.1437954456,
-0.8193763494,
0.1666432321,
0.1816132963,
-0.0000045807,
-0.9110073447,
0.425632894,
-0.0311637167,
0.3453479111,
0.3367941678,
0.0761420801,
0.6811375022,
-0.2719222009,
0.6533381939,
0.6154170632,
-0.9652796388,
0.152780965,
-0.5311754346,
-0.2183696479,
0.1511104405,
0.2333284467,
-0.6193995476,
-0.3034439981,
-0.6675376892,
-0.5692754388,
0.4156289399,
0.3846023381,
0.6079806685,
-0.0709777921,
0.4737052321,
0.0389134623,
0.1842010319,
-0.8317845464,
0.0313813686,
-0.0657248124,
-0.2753716707,
-0.0921749324,
-0.0535057858,
-0.1790928096,
-0.2490255982,
0.5743966103,
-0.009579978,
0.1724915653,
-0.2089322209,
-0.025489049,
-0.0233510416,
0.4228957295,
0.5587830544,
0.8776439428,
-0.1119592413,
0.0887538269,
-0.0617552102,
-0.3001105487,
0.0125449738,
0.0586547256,
-0.0969019383,
-0.0685127452,
0.4383529127,
0.8647295833,
0.235057503,
-1.1000105143,
0.5736218095,
-0.24155958,
-0.0447667539,
-0.4801684618,
0.109988153,
0.189630121,
0.2116748989,
0.3758499026,
0.0591128133,
0.0362060778,
-0.4786149263,
0.2747577429,
0.662591517,
-0.2918943465,
-0.3979670703,
0.4937219918,
-0.0077070384,
-0.2893097103,
0.5270888209,
-0.2370547205,
-0.1519648433,
0.7511685491,
0.5594493747,
0.7123638391,
0.067974925,
0.3573016524,
0.2853784561,
0.3355794549,
-0.1191556677,
0.3448274732,
-0.1665618569,
-0.8944746852,
-0.4618680775,
-0.5271325111,
-0.5054281354,
0.1463414878,
-0.7718365788,
-0.0554831587,
-0.6059144139,
-0.2148375809,
0.356754005,
-0.2948761582,
-0.4575555325,
0.2346445769,
-0.0961076543,
0.8011318445,
-0.8978872299,
0.7712832093,
0.8453562856,
-0.7382927537,
-1.0864462852,
-0.0784146413,
-0.2834200263,
-0.6198540926,
0.8588232994,
0.3026074767,
-0.3501546681,
-0.1405659765,
-0.4518975317,
-0.6945429444,
0.9166606665,
0.7942499518,
-0.56001544,
0.0020701664,
0.1413376033,
0.6175826192,
-0.7132530212,
0.135155648,
0.6082314253,
0.3615111113,
0.1971016824,
-0.6327854991,
0.1925420761,
-0.1188490614,
0.1847924143,
-0.0899676979,
-0.4256183505,
0.9751793146,
-0.0658145696,
-0.3736355901,
0.1528889388,
1.0757344961,
0.5361192226,
0.5273854136,
0.5709035993,
0.3439988792,
0.7938498259,
0.1677270681,
0.9653994441,
-0.2579735816,
0.2196809649,
1.0603835583,
-0.0568332411,
0.9078835845,
0.6157922149,
-0.2324888706,
0.5402261615,
0.3621513844,
0.317971319,
0.2337674201,
0.4635803401,
-0.3837779164,
-0.6376945376,
-0.1550161391,
-0.1658734381,
0.5732744336,
0.5273712873,
-0.6650944352,
-0.0375262387,
-0.117123872,
-0.2221197039,
0.4483670294,
-0.1990509331,
0.3277596533,
0.2953518331,
-0.5244131088,
0.5739770532,
0.2582847178,
0.4024852216,
-0.4345731437,
-0.2209683657,
0.2345801145,
-0.0445984453,
0.2059669644,
-0.3396710753,
0.4003142715,
-0.1776748598,
-0.1159337237,
-0.0883372426,
0.449362576,
-0.212085098,
-0.1925590336,
0.1154960096,
0.5370771289,
0.3191309571,
-0.0115831597,
-0.9242448211,
0.2798959911,
-0.3535120487,
-0.1076608598,
0.3210255206,
0.4502345026,
-0.0876833797,
0.9958336353,
0.5308097601,
0.1487977654,
-0.1757822335,
-0.1297805756,
0.707051754,
-0.7659151554,
-0.9378782511,
-0.7888563275,
0.188417837,
-0.0732225925,
-0.124633871,
0.4735590219,
0.1797323525,
0.5454847217,
-0.0244736597,
0.6114667058,
0.2641553283,
0.5137255788,
-0.3692108691,
0.5824798346,
-0.397647649,
0.4416202307,
-0.1801060736,
-0.7198573351,
-0.4184908271,
1.3157342672,
-0.4872986376,
-0.1418547779,
0.5276764035,
0.7742243409,
-0.1836326718,
0.6506175399,
0.3933673203,
0.0461445302,
0.0651508793,
0.4342765808,
1.0628826618,
-0.1066410616,
0.1560628265,
0.0157978535,
-0.1879728585,
0.2149854898,
-0.7495893836,
-0.815928936,
-0.757111907,
-0.2667900026,
-0.300329268,
0.1235435978,
1.0771805048,
0.666234374,
-0.4298755527,
-0.3596424758,
-0.3547815681,
0.267637074,
-0.4528358281,
-0.1986785084,
0.109226875,
-0.4872064292,
-0.5910030007,
0.237501353,
0.4044061899,
-0.0219102558,
-0.3881713152,
-0.1533438116,
0.1675926447,
0.7794856429,
0.5782546401,
0.3718112707,
-1.0024462938,
-0.2978158295,
-0.4053781331,
-0.0643002316,
0.0410686471,
0.9227666855,
-0.9638686776,
0.3583487272,
0.264465183,
0.6613609195,
0.077816084,
0.0098431921,
0.8164473176,
-0.1507798731,
0.3527582586,
0.3045891821,
0.2855984867,
0.2284789979,
-0.0219968129,
0.3000524044,
0.5551733971,
0.2391314656,
-1.1188153028,
0.5400472283,
-1.2104711533,
-0.3732396066,
1.0672106743,
-0.2266649008,
-0.3792638183,
-0.1399604976,
-0.069930017,
0.400988698,
-0.5273234844,
0.8466563225,
0.5670303106,
0.0390330665,
-0.1885145307,
-0.5103843808,
0.4946295917,
0.677750349,
-0.4874059558,
0.4397065341,
0.6344080567,
0.3434249461,
-0.0388696305,
0.7676814198,
-0.0232082568,
0.4969417453,
-0.0188956149,
-0.3573527038,
-0.050335601,
-0.3266066015,
-0.557657361,
0.6000809669,
-0.0405578539,
-0.1958124042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02904v1
|
ALOHa: A New Measure for Hallucination in Captioning Models
| 2024-04-03T17:59:36 | 2024-04-03T17:59:36 |
Suzanne Petryk, David M. Chan, Anish Kachinthaya, Haodi Zou, John Canny, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Trevor Darrell
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite recent advances in multimodal pre-training for visual description,
state-of-the-art models still produce captions containing errors, such as
hallucinating objects not present in a scene. The existing prominent metric for
object hallucination, CHAIR, is limited to a fixed set of MS COCO objects and
synonyms. In this work, we propose a modernized open-vocabulary metric, ALOHa,
which leverages large language models (LLMs) to measure object hallucinations.
Specifically, we use an LLM to extract groundable objects from a candidate
caption, measure their semantic similarity to reference objects from captions
and object detections, and use Hungarian matching to produce a final
hallucination score. We show that ALOHa correctly identifies 13.6% more
hallucinated objects than CHAIR on HAT, a new gold-standard subset of MS COCO
Captions annotated for hallucinations, and 30.8% more on nocaps, where objects
extend beyond MS COCO categories. Our code is available at
https://davidmchan.github.io/aloha/.
|
[
-0.6324985027,
-0.8464379311,
0.391035378,
0.0040633222,
-0.6718087792,
-0.3892484903,
-0.1746446192,
-0.6694979072,
0.7714369297,
0.6691177487,
-0.2971648574,
-0.6709808111,
-0.5168578029,
0.3066365421,
-0.5448076129,
0.6609435081,
-0.1635995507,
0.0446757749,
-0.4761084616,
-0.4902966321,
-0.746863544,
-0.5871142149,
0.0676559582,
0.0130475182,
0.7590212226,
0.346370846,
1.029946804,
0.4221634567,
0.6695546508,
0.140817374,
0.3780630529,
0.3039752543,
-0.226708129,
-0.1118865609,
0.0152314873,
-0.3577955961,
-0.576911509,
0.0552839115,
0.3352168798,
0.6813434958,
-0.1847774088,
-0.0897361487,
-0.1757686585,
0.6397079229,
-0.8861238956,
0.524774909,
-0.9116447568,
0.4429142773,
0.1793699414,
-0.5335980058,
-0.1929116994,
-0.200908497,
-0.0730609074,
-0.7559579015,
0.1975309849,
0.4484498203,
1.0136054754,
0.4820029438,
0.0061247973,
-0.7412766814,
-0.3957122862,
0.7426905632,
-0.4601984322,
0.656922102,
0.4312986135,
0.3891262412,
-0.011288723,
-0.3190516233,
-0.9849666953,
-0.6625652909,
0.0037204716,
-0.0512793884,
0.071637556,
-0.1015011966,
-0.0353716984,
0.5799391866,
-0.3707884848,
0.0724506378,
-0.5384925008,
-0.3053038418,
0.3524770141,
-0.1108396575,
0.4793446958,
-0.3011624813,
-0.3632711768,
-0.1665946692,
-0.6471497416,
-0.4630985856,
0.2108283341,
0.4601479769,
0.0181962196,
0.9013453722,
-0.1804535985,
0.4700418711,
-0.5123325586,
0.0235225074,
0.3332310915,
0.0834528506,
-0.2058482021,
0.3049983382,
0.7332702279,
0.6948561668,
0.4755333364,
-0.3779146075,
-0.0651813224,
0.3509503007,
0.2878220081,
-0.6358225346,
-0.5632410049,
0.1344061941,
-0.4654655755,
-0.1547669023,
0.3922594488,
-0.7365282178,
-0.6962321997,
-0.4149979949,
0.5945714116,
-0.197065413,
-0.1685970426,
0.3937096596,
0.1745671332,
0.5583431721,
0.2375631034,
-0.6737700105,
0.375274539,
0.53619802,
1.0976532698,
-0.5419861674,
-0.3648827672,
-0.7293040752,
-0.2295487076,
-0.832939446,
0.80758816,
-0.3216270506,
-0.1954263896,
0.1237264872,
0.2090895027,
0.1045991182,
-0.7986510396,
0.2368844002,
-0.2983165383,
0.0106333829,
-0.1239529029,
-0.2626757026,
-0.5046700239,
0.30797562,
-0.8629977703,
0.6711032987,
0.0490430705,
-0.4454435408,
0.4291723073,
-0.3501508236,
-0.2620919049,
-0.0424329676,
-0.4339818358,
-0.6012127399,
0.3664530218,
0.3484194875,
0.5885637999,
-0.1321868002,
0.2754088938,
-0.5324059129,
-0.6156494021,
0.2954205573,
-0.0228853691,
0.3854487836,
0.1163771451,
-0.147494778,
0.5009477139,
-0.5954826474,
-0.2715958953,
0.0210466068,
-0.0355693437,
-0.1782670021,
-0.0153759923,
-0.0402418151,
0.0449897423,
0.0507880338,
-0.2453661859,
0.0384704657,
-0.2227964848,
0.0934577882,
0.643910706,
-0.1245632544,
0.1834237427,
-0.3099735379,
0.4647628069,
-0.1229218915,
0.2020326704,
-0.1604239047,
-0.5137565732,
-0.9496528506,
-0.4805600047,
-0.3362058699,
0.2349166572,
-0.5327068567,
0.9461400509,
-0.2152700722,
-0.330792129,
-0.3855529726,
0.1159074455,
0.0757275075,
0.1682772934,
0.445664376,
-0.8874906301,
-0.4416284561,
-0.8708774447,
0.2200661451,
-0.138304323,
-0.1062785611,
0.4735112786,
0.6310895681,
-0.2741056383,
0.584197998,
-0.4689728916,
-1.2599045038,
0.1360304654,
-0.0465376116,
0.044573646,
0.2114186138,
0.4941559732,
-0.4904445112,
-0.1431712955,
0.26222381,
-1.1499501467,
0.1917813569,
-0.1214605868,
-0.1717510372,
0.1803315878,
0.6021845937,
-0.7907403111,
0.4724828303,
0.3250175416,
-0.2464354932,
0.6684890389,
-0.0810941607,
0.2879177332,
-0.670288682,
0.17997168,
-0.70140028,
0.1618260741,
-0.1166009307,
0.3566353917,
-0.2013247311,
-0.1971484721,
-0.6955984235,
0.41502285,
-0.7633564472,
-0.4463049769,
-0.2955414355,
0.5327543616,
-0.1176675186,
0.7888342738,
0.178326562,
0.4111351371,
0.8856451511,
-0.6176602244,
0.7283685207,
0.3878988028,
-0.6648128033,
0.4174005985,
-0.3513999283,
0.2587666512,
-0.3360013366,
0.1536979526,
-1.0623679161,
-0.4053100646,
0.5685495734,
-0.445366323,
-0.1173779145,
0.5848435163,
-0.3758997917,
-0.3244894743,
-0.5231400728,
0.4310319126,
0.224079594,
-0.6167743206,
0.8712441921,
0.1611944139,
0.1300991774,
-0.7345405817,
-0.5237890482,
0.2203750908,
-0.3182647228,
0.0331665315,
-0.0723634958,
-0.4127420783,
-0.1231781393,
-0.0715310127,
-0.270182997,
-0.0001492715,
0.0468654558,
0.4291261435,
0.3386078477,
-0.2822492123,
0.2811282873,
-0.2644326091,
0.3197043538,
0.2223835737,
0.0006702728,
0.8600022793,
-0.2209087759,
-0.4972534776,
-0.7138160467,
0.1881184727,
0.7341217995,
-0.1315594167,
0.6648166776,
0.5051771998,
-0.7471318245,
0.2014448643,
-0.6091384292,
-0.477101922,
-0.3543675542,
0.5647975802,
-0.6033239365,
-0.4391438663,
0.6995697021,
0.5340074301,
-0.1213822961,
0.2945684791,
0.3247689903,
0.2913387418,
0.7751199007,
0.3661910295,
-0.1536556333,
0.1865807176,
-0.1890735775,
0.4296040237,
-0.6543797851,
-0.4268198907,
-0.4128851891,
-0.0290035885,
-0.3082399368,
-0.7215775847,
0.0139144221,
0.3123958707,
0.0747085512,
0.1749344766,
-0.514555037,
0.6613663435,
0.2867485285,
0.1382605582,
0.5022827387,
0.2761794627,
0.2231290042,
0.1901811808,
-0.2621229291,
-0.4945782423,
1.040968895,
0.3046642244,
0.5946907997,
-0.0720600188,
0.6416573524,
0.3706499636,
0.6531139612,
-1.2692884207,
0.6484519243,
-0.0027534976,
-0.5290110707,
-0.5800629854,
-0.2653258145,
-0.7778696418,
0.3850300908,
-0.2840711474,
-0.7675762773,
0.0500420928,
0.0400415584,
-0.2970380187,
0.2928237915,
0.0262142494,
0.9906558394,
-0.1031493247,
-0.021805767,
-0.2582913935,
-0.2903716862,
0.4454683959,
-0.0286479667,
0.3304014206,
-0.4510350823,
-0.0800155923,
0.8249067664,
-0.1291881949,
0.6750080585,
0.0566570871,
-0.4203172326,
0.6354464889,
0.3832218647,
0.3206473291,
-0.2116069347,
0.3504526317,
0.49840042,
-0.2295115143,
-0.2144822031,
-0.5499693155,
0.8663352132,
-0.5424804688,
-0.4430871606,
-0.3632224202,
-0.7261115909,
-0.0201657936,
0.1050827205,
0.2312768847,
0.1560871601,
-0.2042982727,
0.4454980791,
0.4650450945,
-0.4714021087,
0.1165021062,
0.201846078,
-0.6165614128,
-0.4931434691,
0.9590761662,
0.0376928076,
-0.0020328246,
0.4919040501,
0.2105270177,
-0.379634887,
-0.4154720008,
-0.369146049,
0.4126481116,
-1.014950633,
-0.2333259583,
-0.7205660343,
-0.0029707709,
-0.4558128119,
-0.230482772,
-0.3262690306,
-0.3908121884,
-0.4449513853,
-0.4091655612,
0.1676641107,
0.6123091578,
0.1144224554,
0.0517933592,
-0.3728939295,
0.6863421798,
0.3914993107,
0.4910496771,
0.2270298153,
-0.5157670975,
-0.0907140672,
-0.3408606648,
-0.1830990016,
-0.9027268291,
0.5436477065,
0.2705301046,
0.394136399,
0.8071971536,
0.124591127,
0.6122949123,
-0.2918300033,
0.7859913707,
0.6301385164,
-0.8551846147,
0.3717991412,
-0.0759831369,
0.0093643432,
0.2255739123,
0.3629396856,
-0.4683929384,
-0.5591260195,
-0.088201493,
-0.6574912071,
0.2653347254,
0.0396915451,
0.4633508921,
-0.335832715,
0.0905794352,
0.5168488622,
0.3035670817,
-1.1870287657,
0.0640813336,
-0.3226700425,
-0.1723582149,
-0.2329215705,
-0.1373681426,
-0.0735570863,
-0.3068655431,
0.5208896399,
-0.3238075376,
0.2774554491,
0.0612511747,
-0.224689886,
-0.2920745313,
-0.0001423874,
0.5473425388,
0.6596032977,
-0.3788611293,
0.3955973387,
0.186622411,
-0.4416469932,
-0.1891980618,
-0.2264576405,
0.2152593136,
0.2074028552,
0.6074054241,
0.8362172842,
0.2038015127,
-1.0151201487,
0.5584968925,
0.308608532,
-0.2352512032,
-0.4888734519,
-0.0025617438,
-0.3174286187,
-0.1694181859,
0.1651991904,
-0.2209297717,
0.2690348327,
-0.9910337925,
0.3399522007,
0.4627784491,
-0.828292191,
-0.2256589383,
0.9385250807,
-0.0819035619,
-0.2158632725,
0.7117145061,
-0.0802934319,
-0.2409823984,
0.6703346968,
0.1546932161,
1.0586497784,
-0.2906606495,
0.1275664121,
0.5528847575,
0.3492363989,
-0.1087593362,
0.410315305,
-0.2510249019,
-0.7653276324,
0.103367053,
-0.9092413187,
-0.1176750362,
0.1481018662,
-0.774984479,
0.4700758755,
-0.3358370066,
0.2177599818,
-0.2545585632,
-0.5064313412,
-0.6318510771,
0.07163845,
0.1410853714,
0.2902288139,
-0.9940850735,
0.5270385146,
0.3165531754,
-0.6470844746,
-0.3273600638,
-0.1097469106,
-0.314032793,
-0.7358500957,
0.3214212656,
0.8083067536,
-0.2455000281,
-0.446261704,
-0.370568186,
-0.6461005807,
1.004543066,
-0.0226416886,
-0.6354624033,
-0.0257280674,
0.229184255,
0.4145302773,
-0.6290283203,
-0.0001039133,
0.5632323623,
0.2257387042,
-0.0379687659,
-0.7828752398,
0.1655319482,
0.1150007322,
-0.1892631799,
-0.2146240324,
-0.3264232874,
0.6857705116,
-0.6291581392,
-0.3531768918,
0.4935591519,
0.9837144613,
0.3090903759,
0.4561546743,
0.7518836856,
0.3535805941,
0.7520783544,
0.0730304867,
0.8649190664,
0.0162845701,
0.2320533395,
1.2913553715,
-0.2346509397,
1.0485891104,
0.7337545156,
-0.0375778824,
0.4220613241,
0.5255151987,
0.0916768312,
0.571143806,
0.6165697575,
0.0191835035,
-0.2334228158,
-0.3101031184,
-0.3356993496,
0.4496104717,
0.2091413289,
-0.2959754765,
0.2908843756,
0.6507409215,
-0.146820724,
0.2146616578,
-0.3274330497,
0.7357299328,
0.2776856124,
-0.6735629439,
1.0158087015,
-0.5013723373,
0.473687917,
-0.2328772694,
-0.2673954964,
-0.3483708501,
0.0888955072,
-0.1006028727,
-0.4082418084,
0.325677067,
-0.2396755964,
0.1047654226,
0.4401800036,
0.0322672054,
-0.5090228915,
-0.4411282241,
0.5998613238,
0.2459705472,
0.9338655472,
-0.4750333726,
-0.1066371053,
0.3721126318,
-0.2451188564,
0.0062599867,
-0.0929966643,
0.2499123514,
-0.2224595845,
0.6222506166,
0.2693122923,
-0.0593169704,
0.244107917,
0.585298121,
0.4985446632,
-0.5729829073,
-0.4446235299,
-0.5810223818,
0.0423994996,
0.2357834131,
-0.2477920502,
0.5035282373,
0.7844101787,
0.8741704226,
-0.6110519767,
0.2635701001,
0.0432204902,
0.0153127806,
-0.7102713585,
0.6635560989,
-0.8326393366,
0.264552772,
-0.2712673545,
-1.6714242697,
-0.5681104064,
0.8121978045,
0.1588704586,
-0.1960803866,
0.8663781881,
1.0659786463,
-0.0615491942,
-0.2886170149,
0.642623961,
0.2764154077,
0.1428638846,
0.4323372543,
0.9558072686,
-0.4820497334,
0.736990571,
-0.2575165033,
-0.2618882954,
-0.4031701982,
-0.6474424005,
-1.0733401775,
-0.7261040211,
-0.6110978127,
-0.1877672672,
0.0120631885,
0.7156454325,
0.6466696262,
-1.1578155756,
-0.3495517075,
-0.0972090289,
-0.0350249484,
-0.6201065779,
-0.2772715688,
0.705286026,
-0.1664728224,
-0.7269466519,
0.1931859106,
0.1746333838,
0.0768329352,
-0.5918604136,
-0.3492701352,
0.1381115764,
0.3374934793,
0.8111394048,
-0.0445333421,
-1.293358922,
-0.6015045047,
0.0843521431,
0.1693660915,
0.243595615,
0.7310069799,
-0.5079866052,
0.8245060444,
0.3178373277,
0.1487411261,
0.3018384576,
-0.2569384873,
0.1275876015,
-0.5242889524,
0.3145082593,
0.1190168336,
0.5740001202,
0.5874966383,
-0.2788255513,
0.5908163786,
0.1984049678,
-0.1359907538,
-1.0278016329,
0.112046726,
-1.2666912079,
-0.3688053787,
0.9116575718,
0.1112049967,
-0.3179368973,
0.1246364266,
-0.5334820747,
0.1537587941,
-0.0553846136,
1.4856083393,
0.8415408731,
0.0246686917,
-0.294015646,
-0.5459958315,
0.4370186031,
0.1833735555,
-0.9718476534,
0.3162273765,
0.7649127245,
-0.0644282997,
0.5309845209,
0.5499172211,
-0.3437156379,
0.4213337898,
-0.0093015498,
0.5902221203,
0.0336072072,
-0.9453107715,
-0.1170012206,
0.2352603674,
0.0145370653,
-0.6309642196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02893v1
|
ChatGLM-Math: Improving Math Problem-Solving in Large Language Models with a Self-Critique Pipeline
| 2024-04-03T17:51:18 | 2024-04-03T17:51:18 |
Yifan Xu, Xiao Liu, Xinghan Liu, Zhenyu Hou, Yueyan Li, Xiaohan Zhang, Zihan Wang, Aohan Zeng, Zhengxiao Du, Wenyi Zhao, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown excellent mastering of human
language, but still struggle in real-world applications that require
mathematical problem-solving. While many strategies and datasets to enhance
LLMs' mathematics are developed, it remains a challenge to simultaneously
maintain and improve both language and mathematical capabilities in deployed
LLM systems.In this work, we tailor the Self-Critique pipeline, which addresses
the challenge in the feedback learning stage of LLM alignment. We first train a
general Math-Critique model from the LLM itself to provide feedback signals.
Then, we sequentially employ rejective fine-tuning and direct preference
optimization over the LLM's own generations for data collection. Based on
ChatGLM3-32B, we conduct a series of experiments on both academic and our newly
created challenging dataset, MathUserEval. Results show that our pipeline
significantly enhances the LLM's mathematical problem-solving while still
improving its language ability, outperforming LLMs that could be two times
larger. Related techniques have been deployed to
ChatGLM\footnote{\url{https://chatglm.cn}}, an online serving LLM. Related
evaluation dataset and scripts are released at
\url{https://github.com/THUDM/ChatGLM-Math}.
|
[
-0.3126983047,
-0.5835800171,
0.3580622673,
0.2628466189,
0.0065235123,
0.3800436258,
-0.4819330871,
-0.1375628859,
0.1063834801,
0.5236461759,
-0.9214736819,
-0.4421253502,
-0.4100354612,
0.0609968416,
-0.2057289779,
1.2692975998,
-0.0553763583,
0.4290769398,
-0.4855053723,
0.0788975433,
-0.4676267803,
-0.6226462126,
-0.656644702,
-0.3985959888,
0.4937870204,
0.5589065552,
0.6315404773,
0.3789219856,
0.8243195415,
0.3066053689,
0.0472274497,
0.211853981,
-1.018042326,
0.4237524271,
-0.0017805354,
-0.5402615666,
-0.4941926301,
-0.1752477735,
0.7563250661,
0.7505182624,
-0.4092157781,
0.3224784732,
0.348082155,
0.8439773917,
-0.4595605433,
0.4348901808,
-0.6683329344,
0.0694072917,
-0.2103762925,
0.1228154674,
-0.3679100275,
-0.4424250722,
0.1095850244,
-0.5913159251,
0.1648851931,
0.0889571682,
0.3761303425,
0.4169457853,
-0.0002441167,
-0.3385622203,
-0.744071424,
0.8922567964,
-0.7178997993,
0.2457502931,
0.2182860821,
0.3294639289,
-0.2816951871,
-0.3402653337,
-0.3512858748,
-0.0412394628,
0.0707988515,
0.2808983326,
-0.1914814115,
-0.2223533243,
0.2221889198,
0.3882432878,
-0.553088367,
0.1538335979,
-0.5900492072,
-0.4053361118,
0.7104212642,
0.4699577391,
-0.0120910704,
-0.0973481759,
-0.0905552655,
-0.0208922159,
-0.9021824598,
-0.2323544025,
0.5465226173,
0.2012915462,
0.0757060722,
0.5346877575,
-0.0064924089,
0.4446720779,
-0.1184326187,
0.044961337,
0.347407043,
-0.1294667423,
0.0067138528,
-0.3654792905,
0.7439854145,
0.2347862422,
0.2570675015,
0.0337522738,
-0.420877248,
0.2052947134,
0.1928257048,
-0.6323634982,
-0.3395341635,
0.0504708849,
-0.186946705,
-0.3356582522,
-0.3115543723,
-0.6592210531,
-0.5067000985,
-0.7041680813,
0.4116261005,
-0.2305171043,
-0.0506112948,
0.2749735415,
0.3578488529,
0.0903823823,
0.6598870754,
-0.8746182919,
0.2816853225,
0.9750254154,
0.8016800284,
-0.3316135108,
-0.2508782446,
-0.7115849257,
-0.2649793327,
-0.2166711837,
0.7875085473,
-0.5095107555,
-0.4020368755,
0.0154874222,
-0.3825345337,
-0.0538654439,
-0.8975999355,
0.6548669338,
-0.4168158174,
0.5174870491,
-0.0870921388,
-0.769995451,
0.2245466113,
0.4171249866,
-0.4635698199,
0.9175823331,
-0.0108845653,
-0.5181891918,
-0.1679705083,
-0.6689117551,
-0.0200130474,
0.0287464168,
-0.0688178912,
-0.7109715343,
0.3204541206,
0.3411641419,
0.2057451308,
-0.3152929246,
0.2660134733,
-0.5892245173,
-0.1623877883,
0.2496294975,
-0.352712512,
0.4731973112,
0.4370595813,
0.0287584569,
0.2244654894,
-0.6016338468,
0.2396757007,
0.3028818667,
0.0335850045,
0.1901865155,
-0.0024325585,
-0.1560275257,
0.2224116027,
0.3756299019,
-0.4531853795,
0.3571723998,
-0.4420038462,
0.4401447177,
0.9673974514,
-0.2724331617,
0.1918778121,
-0.4555473626,
0.822357595,
-0.1621906161,
0.18750377,
-0.162322104,
-0.2444915324,
-0.9862275124,
-0.0757854134,
0.3622817695,
0.3722554445,
-0.5676475763,
0.1522171348,
-0.2887427509,
-0.3843772411,
-0.763222456,
0.5817524195,
0.4081820548,
0.494582355,
0.3761239052,
-0.400195837,
-0.5634274483,
-0.8398658037,
-0.2748820484,
-0.1197375581,
-0.1892714202,
0.364726752,
0.1388286799,
-0.2237647772,
0.925498724,
-0.7820848823,
-0.6379557252,
-0.0856217369,
0.0477807373,
0.3077160418,
0.3065448999,
0.0986484587,
-0.1644635946,
-0.4756426811,
-0.2936348617,
-0.6181653738,
-0.555295527,
0.2493003458,
-0.2628616691,
0.0251288358,
0.397644043,
-0.206631735,
0.120186083,
0.7693970799,
-0.1503314525,
0.7902183533,
-0.0861203149,
-0.3939288557,
-0.8345636725,
-0.1467258036,
-0.1268552393,
-0.1842734963,
-0.2300416529,
0.1009802595,
-0.2005860507,
-0.4108047187,
-0.2356065214,
0.5112083554,
-0.4313943386,
0.0064448984,
-0.2498596162,
0.4101650715,
-0.191364035,
0.5675608516,
-0.2223590314,
0.6510525942,
0.6308864951,
-0.1803837121,
0.5165393353,
0.2535082996,
-0.2260495722,
0.4978510737,
-0.7196841836,
0.4558058977,
-0.1973553598,
0.2633116841,
-1.072437048,
-0.0489608869,
0.3320919573,
-0.3454182148,
0.2461957335,
-0.3034114242,
-0.4840237796,
-0.3653540015,
-0.37696895,
0.4620230198,
0.5197565556,
-0.4809826612,
0.5066500902,
0.3551308513,
-0.3548807204,
-0.4690427184,
-0.2856737077,
0.0554241203,
-0.0688023493,
-0.7373456955,
0.1036940143,
-0.5040278435,
-0.235345751,
-0.1931177676,
-0.1336394548,
0.2918239236,
0.0406472832,
0.0887514725,
0.5726273656,
-0.0155125558,
0.2521794438,
-0.260142386,
-0.3956989348,
0.3494063914,
-0.5097377896,
0.6950955987,
-0.3605255187,
-0.5683380365,
-0.1867688745,
0.0904331878,
0.320905298,
-0.241399914,
0.3460425436,
0.3325289488,
-0.0792396218,
-0.2732903659,
-0.6540137529,
-0.2800705731,
-0.4739066958,
0.2376563549,
-0.1518004537,
-1.1592466831,
0.5513344407,
-0.0564077683,
0.3016713262,
0.4466764927,
0.8444908857,
-0.1939278543,
1.0252518654,
0.2374316603,
-0.2669115365,
0.2780375481,
-0.3814611435,
0.1569255739,
-0.9544275403,
-0.0508591309,
-0.4910092056,
-0.3979116678,
-0.3481213748,
-0.451892972,
0.394169271,
-0.0541426241,
-0.1607253253,
0.091547288,
-0.4241553545,
0.7545104027,
0.2187382579,
0.0294166356,
0.4572260976,
0.1361790746,
-0.3318072259,
-0.4055958986,
-0.6575085521,
-0.3936097324,
1.2045185566,
0.4671379328,
1.2145379782,
0.2242172211,
0.7546856999,
-0.0567755997,
0.6191692948,
-0.9293031096,
0.4462457895,
-0.132869184,
-0.4620628655,
-0.2498873174,
-0.8269340992,
-0.9980319738,
0.3190468848,
-0.0889518186,
-0.6254518628,
-0.4188728929,
0.3347387314,
-0.2092446089,
0.0895632654,
-0.7593339682,
0.7885891795,
-0.3464128971,
-0.5384132862,
-0.3456999958,
-0.2814397514,
0.1809260547,
-0.1248362213,
0.4172232747,
-0.2242377847,
0.2384608388,
0.4585964382,
-0.6293621659,
0.9435285926,
0.0213853605,
-0.6072284579,
0.2274016887,
0.4896957874,
0.4200039208,
0.170775786,
-0.0019273383,
0.0880247876,
-0.1257270277,
-0.2830803096,
-0.9817434549,
0.9243602753,
-0.9391465187,
-0.8808301091,
-0.3272072673,
-0.5280886292,
-0.4708125293,
0.0464589112,
-0.0517109334,
0.60906744,
0.0480377227,
0.1712907255,
0.3375055194,
0.1509974897,
0.2557584345,
0.3903087378,
-0.8555215001,
-0.58675313,
0.9993158579,
0.1159130558,
0.3405120671,
0.1220881715,
0.3616833687,
-0.5465677977,
-0.4256305397,
-0.3670129776,
0.3887484968,
-0.7558642626,
-0.4322581291,
-0.3212090433,
-0.4177811742,
-0.1901883781,
0.184788242,
-0.4755524099,
-0.5298261642,
-0.2418106794,
0.239714101,
0.1785786897,
0.6745160222,
-0.0216136351,
0.162959367,
-0.7547155619,
-0.0119376918,
0.3837921619,
0.6717928648,
0.1873318404,
-0.721429646,
-0.2551066279,
0.1744197756,
-0.6396623254,
-0.1594903767,
0.3506236076,
0.1804869026,
0.23242037,
0.2136006206,
-0.0687109903,
0.7039260268,
-0.5789332986,
0.4682455361,
0.1830794662,
-1.0195800066,
0.3692586422,
-0.3141538799,
0.4914392531,
0.3674040735,
0.0812717453,
-0.5900620222,
-0.4735319614,
-0.4791033268,
-0.4815468192,
0.526997447,
0.5393134952,
0.2844750881,
0.2366054356,
0.4379851222,
0.0766476467,
0.1616605967,
-0.7626013756,
-0.1828586459,
0.0144762434,
-0.3260012567,
-0.0658476874,
-0.2130689025,
-0.2188187987,
-0.2082248479,
0.6823601127,
-0.4259625673,
0.0796710625,
-0.0497267619,
-0.132107988,
-0.2668159902,
0.2595609725,
0.4408650994,
0.890781641,
0.1415896714,
0.1075376272,
0.332859695,
-0.3379665911,
0.0387016982,
0.0422120504,
-0.0229415093,
-0.2644650042,
0.28903386,
0.6111516953,
0.2920967042,
-0.7045549154,
0.3456790745,
-0.1665150076,
-0.2460128069,
-0.4044260681,
0.19593817,
0.0656817108,
0.1100319698,
0.438023597,
-0.0407570191,
0.1138701811,
-0.2855136693,
0.0026554833,
0.6254506111,
-0.2850216627,
-0.3132658601,
0.4946358502,
0.1228679568,
-0.3447115719,
0.6338415146,
-0.036437422,
-0.8618545532,
0.3467528224,
0.6625992656,
0.8022834659,
-0.0315993614,
0.1436141729,
0.3146514893,
-0.037116304,
0.0393040404,
0.0823691785,
0.1353586465,
-0.8288249373,
-0.7670409083,
-0.5349062085,
-0.6999758482,
-0.0283684041,
-0.5392646194,
0.619076252,
-0.5166432261,
-0.0015354895,
-0.1168671772,
0.160453707,
-0.5835254788,
-0.0696453899,
0.2559627295,
0.35947299,
-0.1992838234,
0.4422411919,
0.5120792389,
0.054899171,
-0.7433084846,
-0.1848315299,
0.2519637942,
-1.1262395382,
0.5697713494,
0.0959689543,
-0.3997514546,
0.1002690867,
-0.7346589565,
-0.9199256301,
0.761017561,
0.6710104942,
-1.0004401207,
0.1100446135,
0.0911667421,
0.8110784292,
-0.2923348844,
0.4860518277,
0.2307978272,
0.0800427869,
0.4195825458,
-0.9978866577,
-0.2916849852,
-0.3403074741,
-0.056468185,
0.4958528876,
-1.0039101839,
0.4424366653,
-0.1744862497,
-0.0396702476,
-0.0258395188,
0.7018441558,
0.3576108813,
0.1009031981,
0.5827151537,
0.8512667418,
0.7212530971,
-0.0931081399,
0.7605842948,
-0.254868418,
0.9449287057,
1.3143131733,
-0.3487987816,
0.7525246143,
0.3281936944,
-0.3155461252,
0.4977611899,
0.354450047,
-0.1408835351,
0.1455950588,
0.7391226292,
-0.1490993202,
-0.4243530333,
0.0252613146,
-0.389508903,
0.454662919,
0.2562774718,
0.0545418262,
-0.4065562189,
-0.2770249546,
0.0572257526,
0.0620195158,
-0.3365446925,
0.7134960294,
0.2036066651,
-0.6846032739,
0.6399623752,
-0.1978864819,
0.4199773669,
-0.4931912124,
0.0535095595,
-0.3983437717,
0.3805700839,
-0.2117318809,
-0.7215715051,
0.3403071165,
0.0072848056,
0.0381626859,
-0.2804994583,
0.496538043,
-0.6049529314,
-0.7632284164,
0.2309927791,
0.5957141519,
-0.0286097825,
0.0835786238,
-0.692019999,
0.2967597544,
-0.0617130101,
0.1183310449,
0.3844700754,
0.3749437928,
0.1665473282,
1.0212824345,
0.7774674296,
0.0802231655,
-0.1329746246,
0.4443727434,
1.0609481335,
-0.4896180034,
-0.3699581325,
-1.0065634251,
0.1669163704,
0.002169085,
-0.3614706695,
0.7698423266,
0.7419422269,
1.0562630892,
-0.0475826636,
0.5380384922,
0.3445161283,
0.5898476839,
-0.6148161292,
0.3589756191,
-0.3670541048,
0.5556415319,
-0.4295994043,
-1.1501134634,
-0.5815637112,
0.6186453104,
-0.4456600845,
-0.046387516,
0.6050555706,
0.6944438219,
0.0668495074,
0.0976908505,
0.1162495539,
0.1755377054,
0.4500077069,
0.6958076954,
1.2533373833,
-0.2478972971,
0.7304774523,
-0.2280922383,
-0.0754702613,
-0.109743759,
-0.8819457889,
-0.9983156323,
-0.2796060145,
-0.4852675498,
-0.5572907329,
-0.2837207615,
1.2431075573,
0.5339664817,
-0.8790732026,
-0.5106227398,
-0.0341622084,
0.17211923,
0.1625473052,
-0.2389830202,
0.1620129198,
-0.8488779664,
-0.7339808345,
0.1678141654,
0.3567932546,
-0.166843012,
-0.659478426,
-0.0669444576,
0.4084503651,
-0.152935192,
0.5176361203,
0.0709189922,
-0.6882246733,
-0.2401174307,
0.2708989978,
0.0165078063,
0.2807136476,
1.0869146585,
-0.609983623,
0.7575286627,
0.20599626,
0.8896439672,
0.5573341846,
0.0253858622,
0.7003296018,
-0.5357021689,
-0.2078053206,
0.3565419614,
0.5086134076,
0.3811139762,
-0.2076605856,
0.5833764672,
0.3275234699,
-0.7483870983,
-0.652066052,
0.2146600038,
-0.6489351988,
0.1759045124,
0.9540038109,
-0.0489881709,
-0.0449097864,
0.2094038874,
-0.5637523532,
-0.1928785741,
-0.444252342,
1.1494914293,
1.1147415638,
-0.0965837911,
-0.2542908192,
-0.1559715569,
0.3112576604,
0.9281255007,
-0.7198020816,
0.2420587987,
0.6764326096,
0.2327746898,
0.0658802912,
0.3599675298,
-0.296256125,
0.0148088159,
-0.618223846,
-0.0819754452,
0.021800736,
-0.3171454072,
-0.5824636221,
-0.0133872684,
0.1605548859,
0.1906175613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02882v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02882v1
|
Linear Attention Sequence Parallelism
| 2024-04-03T17:33:21 | 2024-04-03T17:33:21 |
Weigao Sun, Zhen Qin, Dong Li, Xuyang Shen, Yu Qiao, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Sequence Parallel (SP) serves as a prevalent strategy to handle long
sequences that exceed the memory limit of a single GPU. However, existing SP
methods do not take advantage of linear attention features, resulting in
sub-optimal parallelism efficiency and usability for linear attention-based
language models. In this paper, we introduce Linear Attention Sequence Parallel
(LASP), an efficient SP method tailored to linear attention-based language
models. Specifically, we design an efficient point-to-point communication
mechanism to leverage the right-product kernel trick of linear attention, which
sharply decreases the communication overhead of SP. We also enhance the
practical efficiency of LASP by performing kernel fusion and intermediate state
caching, making the implementation of LASP hardware-friendly on GPU clusters.
Furthermore, we meticulously ensure the compatibility of sequence-level LASP
with all types of batch-level data parallel methods, which is vital for
distributed training on large clusters with long sequences and large batches.
We conduct extensive experiments on two linear attention-based models with
varying sequence lengths and GPU cluster sizes. LASP scales sequence length up
to 4096K using 128 A100 80G GPUs on 1B models, which is 8 times longer than
existing SP methods while being significantly faster. The code is available at
https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/LASP.
|
[
-0.358674705,
-0.5351836085,
0.5222293735,
0.475980103,
-0.1336595714,
-0.3522886038,
-0.3437055349,
-0.4960247874,
0.3261611164,
0.1174728647,
-0.4453777373,
-0.3649471402,
-0.3298558295,
-0.210172683,
-0.5713366866,
0.9341122508,
0.1397654414,
-0.1878304631,
-0.248014912,
-0.2889060676,
-0.3227671683,
-0.5356396437,
-0.8150346875,
0.148281619,
1.0511808395,
0.2124969661,
0.5118026733,
1.1616176367,
0.9039632082,
0.1948560774,
-0.1116795689,
0.0073197247,
-1.0116958618,
-0.1130051166,
-0.1855303794,
-0.1379858106,
-0.4993366301,
-0.3505256176,
0.8727570176,
0.7786038518,
-0.0964592099,
0.5120539069,
0.1870402545,
0.8467294574,
-0.7564075589,
-0.0201924704,
-0.5233912468,
0.2393491715,
-0.2465708405,
0.0753394514,
-0.699025929,
-0.533397913,
0.0847231001,
-0.4338991344,
0.3479988575,
0.0874907523,
0.7431658506,
0.4980377257,
0.3561605513,
-0.0830259174,
-0.912446022,
0.8842059374,
-0.9375935793,
0.3380666971,
-0.0589234754,
0.3749112189,
0.1599235833,
-0.8288567662,
-0.4646654129,
0.1378004998,
0.0032786063,
-0.1428194344,
0.0488392003,
0.1452128142,
0.6646674275,
0.3993923664,
-0.7814282179,
-0.0102406004,
-0.3329084218,
0.2982828915,
0.3844853044,
0.108978197,
0.041063793,
0.2368143499,
-0.793006897,
-0.0671293288,
-0.7055444717,
0.16152744,
0.0216743462,
0.453790009,
0.0298879314,
0.3180460036,
-0.0627252162,
1.0784960985,
-0.0259328168,
-0.0357232988,
-0.0175899938,
-0.2520317733,
-0.4381357431,
-0.0226994306,
0.5471464992,
0.2397197783,
-0.0512762964,
-0.0700680688,
-0.1312766969,
0.2319358736,
0.1392642707,
-0.5721765161,
0.0151603166,
0.3790815175,
-0.3971116543,
0.1024662405,
-0.0863879696,
-0.9726296067,
0.0720755756,
-0.3387955725,
0.2658837438,
0.0210651867,
0.3125809431,
0.2610646486,
0.1961174905,
0.0367477834,
0.1173815429,
-1.2711113691,
0.5237907171,
0.8804134727,
0.7549462914,
-0.4265751541,
-0.2706002891,
-0.9556882381,
0.2777376771,
-0.0723677129,
0.6655258536,
-0.5682284236,
0.0657534972,
-0.1547828615,
-0.3231405616,
-0.3309280276,
-0.3060718775,
0.4967646599,
-0.3322419822,
0.1055893227,
-0.6060613394,
-0.5978102088,
-0.1695609987,
-0.0961980671,
-0.3525237441,
0.8344292641,
-0.5035146475,
-0.7996178269,
-0.0712992549,
-0.5507435799,
-0.2149153054,
0.0443952419,
-0.3505874872,
-0.3653755784,
-0.064441368,
0.2967938781,
0.5267249942,
-0.2528736889,
-0.0035448794,
-0.6081625223,
-0.5532665849,
-0.3339480758,
0.0108364159,
0.2241358459,
0.2409668267,
-0.2585501671,
0.4077440202,
-0.4750945568,
-0.0766747743,
0.204125151,
-0.2408200651,
-0.0477256849,
0.14939785,
0.0142968064,
0.3209471107,
0.4744787514,
-0.4987690151,
0.0897070915,
-0.5404594541,
0.2356881052,
0.8475422263,
-0.4584515393,
0.3723890781,
-0.2102092803,
0.2414678484,
-0.3167641163,
0.3848697245,
-0.402712822,
-0.7684685588,
-0.9965201616,
-0.2614177465,
0.003525974,
0.7360568643,
-0.3250766695,
0.2459359914,
-0.2438587397,
-0.2311324328,
-0.6082524657,
0.1850045621,
0.7294681072,
0.608014822,
0.3965293467,
-0.2268747389,
-0.3214941621,
-0.8902344704,
-0.2597354949,
0.1184067726,
0.0195879862,
0.6302320957,
-0.1070863679,
0.0303485263,
0.8510274291,
-0.7279526591,
-0.1730998456,
-0.2578481436,
-0.1402817369,
0.5477600694,
0.178370744,
0.4296651483,
-0.4023699164,
-0.6381117702,
0.1947803944,
-0.6951233149,
-0.0375058614,
-0.0672089681,
0.0115472535,
0.2599891126,
0.4163918793,
-0.5119957924,
0.4337498844,
0.5395304561,
-0.1637682766,
0.0140956976,
-0.2689063251,
-0.2335247397,
-1.0084946156,
0.4268760979,
0.1293428689,
-0.4264081717,
-0.8838225007,
0.2668348551,
0.0647538304,
-0.4490510225,
-0.6247363091,
0.2906258106,
-0.0920791253,
-0.6739100218,
-0.4301513135,
0.0040253554,
-0.2296215445,
0.911721766,
0.0106817959,
0.4335309267,
0.3646278381,
-0.5534026623,
0.5630045533,
-0.0412496515,
-0.0017829966,
0.2253753096,
-0.8150799274,
0.3346478045,
-0.3978925645,
0.1980462521,
-0.8742247224,
0.0770573169,
0.1832368523,
-0.2494978011,
0.2720134556,
0.3121686578,
-0.3075860739,
-0.617471993,
-0.0627678484,
0.5952391028,
0.4784693122,
-0.7951824069,
0.2742697597,
0.0912299082,
-0.4568327367,
-0.8496456742,
-0.3270617127,
-0.1816498935,
-0.3498184383,
-0.7629496455,
0.1205487698,
-0.157194525,
0.0655292049,
-0.2550935447,
0.0022014785,
0.2021355331,
-0.2760767937,
0.0246134978,
0.0911252946,
-0.309843123,
0.1375977397,
-0.2317317277,
-0.2682565749,
-0.2990482748,
-0.3662525713,
0.7913669944,
-0.383857578,
-0.2854704261,
-0.8716648221,
0.7066556215,
0.5054748654,
-0.1910703331,
0.4130747616,
0.4316195846,
-0.3657077253,
-0.2813309431,
-0.4784583449,
-0.4500449598,
-0.4204384387,
0.2657932639,
-0.0865621343,
-0.8288620114,
0.4703066051,
0.1711469144,
0.3229432404,
0.1306422353,
0.4679501057,
-0.1532457024,
0.7299874425,
0.6798481941,
-0.493642211,
0.2571630776,
0.0919023231,
0.5622437596,
-0.3545462191,
0.2093470544,
-0.3971855342,
-0.6590945125,
0.1665927619,
-0.7123646736,
0.2436404079,
0.0356871076,
-0.1228302568,
0.5877474546,
-0.5712533593,
0.5400604606,
0.5586062074,
0.0878663957,
0.0818739235,
0.2059395611,
0.0657189116,
-0.1703994423,
-0.8612115383,
0.0060453727,
0.7806404829,
0.802728951,
0.7433614135,
-0.1329967231,
0.5911082625,
0.2292984873,
-0.1674799919,
-0.4882189333,
0.851497829,
-0.3165610433,
0.0907444134,
-0.3899332881,
-0.2965097725,
-0.6095058322,
0.0247435812,
-0.0030933104,
-0.6702244282,
0.2691181302,
0.2837330997,
-0.7577530146,
0.3749377728,
-0.7063724995,
0.9242056608,
0.1682061702,
-0.4637124538,
-0.4378699064,
-0.7308236361,
0.2811523974,
-0.0331472643,
0.0250303969,
-0.0747291073,
0.2211095095,
0.6077010036,
-0.4878500402,
0.7199991345,
-0.0179301258,
-0.059688922,
-0.0632459298,
-0.4492660761,
0.8139327765,
-0.1068401784,
0.3970120549,
0.0083499514,
-0.4559724033,
-0.6834619641,
-0.5041921139,
1.0530841351,
-0.4365721643,
-0.5827517509,
-0.1903274208,
-1.0161745548,
-0.0194560718,
-0.0524377786,
-0.093440488,
0.2126368433,
0.2650981247,
-0.065937005,
0.8930863142,
-0.4324084818,
1.0000127554,
0.2337150723,
-0.369300276,
-0.2497888952,
1.2252914906,
-0.3116954565,
0.5823876262,
0.4995853305,
0.0914532021,
-0.1515202075,
-0.3110037148,
-0.4197360873,
0.4382521808,
-0.6380575895,
0.0325210653,
-0.6186391711,
-0.2945466638,
-0.383335799,
-0.262173593,
-0.6681705713,
-0.5082603097,
-0.0128529798,
0.1892914921,
0.3109397292,
0.5993054509,
0.013523085,
0.1670080274,
-0.5886583924,
0.5391656756,
0.6642193198,
0.2172390223,
0.1241940111,
-0.3167804778,
-0.3078838885,
-0.1933009028,
-0.1958792359,
-0.4645018578,
0.5420976877,
0.2847596705,
0.3103874922,
0.7441443801,
-0.143566981,
0.8303855658,
-0.7719781995,
0.4769105017,
0.3261048496,
-0.8101852536,
0.6258398294,
-0.4924262762,
0.4355432391,
0.1679275781,
0.4327049553,
-0.5392321944,
-0.3328200579,
-0.225630641,
-0.8409940004,
0.8525331616,
0.1793248206,
-0.2539899349,
-0.0283590853,
0.3028164506,
-0.1353556812,
-0.1921785176,
-0.72246629,
-0.3951815665,
0.2256440818,
-0.2687713504,
-0.2190773636,
-0.2449521273,
-0.0887952,
-0.0979377478,
0.4703631401,
0.0531440191,
0.4530844092,
0.2822398543,
0.2293139845,
-0.0725432113,
0.0170425624,
1.0342456102,
0.684971571,
-0.4996888936,
-0.0798431411,
0.0391985923,
-0.4197635353,
-0.2109999657,
0.2791393101,
-0.1298608929,
0.1754286438,
-0.1734663546,
1.0115711689,
0.2682679892,
-0.4837253392,
0.3773278892,
-0.039058283,
0.1959313154,
0.1709221005,
-0.2585267127,
0.3728509843,
0.3619910479,
0.2075639218,
-0.0011699016,
0.1001841724,
-0.0705773234,
0.3615970016,
0.1351866275,
-0.4566395581,
-0.0076575791,
0.8370713592,
0.2765399814,
-0.2828402817,
0.4624917507,
0.1417783499,
0.0966766179,
0.6449393034,
0.5384681821,
0.675234735,
-0.4971142709,
-0.0801982135,
0.4640402198,
0.0592286773,
-0.2783477306,
0.3040675521,
-0.1233012676,
-0.3408900201,
-0.7494612336,
-0.7387145162,
-0.2958463728,
-0.0456754267,
-0.6773288846,
0.2016733587,
-0.7080161572,
0.0189834032,
0.1130809337,
-0.6080173254,
-0.1505315453,
0.0090546981,
0.6786613464,
0.657156527,
-0.7389958501,
1.2090582848,
0.2568436563,
0.1918141693,
-0.3386122286,
-0.3037084341,
-0.2741245925,
-0.7288522124,
0.7608194351,
0.5036255717,
0.1584441662,
0.1015864164,
-0.1059409007,
-0.9736917019,
0.8436192274,
0.3097930849,
-1.1380802393,
-0.1913704723,
0.569473505,
0.2415558994,
-0.3758900464,
-0.1595768929,
0.2601294816,
-0.1030124873,
0.1829563379,
-1.0220270157,
-0.0401692055,
-0.124890402,
0.3497664034,
0.3602142036,
-0.5629999638,
0.811236918,
-0.409276545,
-0.1698959023,
0.081887573,
1.1165244579,
0.6331452727,
0.3834698498,
0.4059686363,
1.2501749992,
0.4909665883,
-0.0016887765,
0.8912103772,
-0.3775132298,
0.4935585856,
1.1214258671,
-0.3439800143,
1.2073589563,
0.604611814,
-0.163569212,
0.1138219759,
0.3799932599,
0.1668512225,
0.606875658,
0.458753407,
-0.5768485069,
-0.0950108469,
-0.1201603934,
-0.5385162234,
-0.1687945426,
0.5354136825,
-0.547544539,
-0.3787154853,
0.084928073,
-0.13561818,
0.2033336759,
-0.7149960399,
0.5297315717,
0.2408408523,
-0.6050015688,
0.7430809736,
-0.079197228,
0.6422836185,
-0.4674080908,
0.0917726755,
-0.3519460261,
0.6327443123,
-0.0437160097,
-0.4606242478,
0.3765957952,
-0.045822192,
-0.5335611701,
-0.3646762371,
0.4176465869,
-0.5303436518,
-0.420914948,
0.2402608991,
-0.1810364574,
0.2134010494,
-0.0733234584,
-0.6481224895,
0.2416178435,
0.1069250405,
0.0376384407,
0.4445044696,
-0.3247680068,
0.0315318815,
0.6904968023,
0.6298775673,
-0.1715064943,
0.4889811277,
0.1251434088,
0.8117063046,
-0.8144761324,
-0.5313308239,
-0.7941244841,
0.1467251182,
-0.0282401294,
0.0628915653,
0.7911193371,
0.6198071837,
0.7269470096,
-0.2360855341,
0.4104087949,
0.3451372087,
0.6880329251,
-0.3233170509,
0.4791671038,
-0.2137505114,
0.2298741341,
-0.3165561855,
-1.0599551201,
-0.3657276332,
0.4447957277,
-0.2082696855,
-0.2674738765,
0.6362270713,
0.6542613506,
-0.1081888303,
0.0545673035,
0.3629278839,
0.1604835689,
0.0924909636,
1.2986392975,
0.3021478057,
-0.4490125477,
0.3656675816,
-0.3067183793,
-0.2441285849,
-0.1129916832,
-0.7447334528,
-0.9661124349,
-0.2547146678,
-0.1743905246,
-0.1598477364,
0.282032311,
0.6289659739,
0.7058067918,
-0.79122895,
-0.4707094431,
-0.3198328912,
-0.100037761,
-0.3642237484,
-0.1740958989,
0.5801418424,
-0.7303133607,
-0.8872067332,
0.3992700875,
0.7605260015,
-0.1545975059,
-0.1273231655,
-0.107151106,
-0.2934651971,
-0.0146753248,
0.6575340033,
0.908770442,
-0.8326707482,
0.1517941654,
0.0490355305,
-0.1335422248,
0.0532104224,
0.7120485306,
-0.6097322106,
0.4583824873,
0.7716229558,
0.8971247673,
0.48512429,
0.0938613191,
0.7802308202,
-0.716484189,
0.5989216566,
0.2061369121,
0.2814798951,
0.2197414935,
-0.307790041,
0.1915141791,
0.4351902008,
-0.7362675071,
-0.7476052046,
0.2216669172,
-1.417360425,
-0.098786816,
1.0613151789,
-0.3493024409,
-0.333283186,
0.1696697325,
-0.0615777411,
-0.1488490552,
-0.3036932945,
0.666749537,
0.3516406715,
-0.0975060016,
-0.4528296888,
-0.6130026579,
0.5940838456,
0.7648180127,
-0.6919742227,
0.254150182,
0.0411738791,
-0.2540834844,
0.2079632878,
0.3930739462,
0.0396980084,
0.4268338084,
-0.4009023607,
0.237069726,
0.2675878108,
-0.5125644207,
-0.3896094561,
0.3339405656,
-0.3043328524,
-0.360475719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02837v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02837v1
|
Cherry on Top: Parameter Heterogeneity and Quantization in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T16:16:31 | 2024-04-03T16:16:31 |
Wanyun Cui, Qianle Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper reveals the phenomenon of parameter heterogeneity in large
language models (LLMs). We find that a small subset of ``cherry'' parameters
exhibit a disproportionately large influence on model performance, while the
vast majority of parameters have minimal impact. This heterogeneity is found to
be prevalent across different model families, scales, and types. Motivated by
this observation, we propose CherryQ, a novel quantization method that unifies
the optimization of mixed-precision parameters. CherryQ identifies and
preserves the critical cherry parameters in high precision while aggressively
quantizing the remaining parameters to low precision. Extensive experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of CherryQ. CherryQ outperforms existing
quantization approaches in terms of perplexity and downstream task performance.
Notably, our 3-bit quantized Vicuna-1.5 exhibits competitive performance
compared to their 16-bit counterparts. These findings highlight the potential
of CherryQ for enabling efficient deployment of LLMs by taking advantage of
parameter heterogeneity.
|
[
-0.2868026793,
-1.2072417736,
0.6945758462,
0.4343170822,
-0.488496989,
0.2320998907,
-0.3759587407,
-0.0959423855,
0.1070412844,
0.6846274734,
-0.1298777163,
-0.618031323,
-0.3749177158,
-0.1803746372,
-0.0964363068,
0.8515418768,
0.1357211173,
0.0916032121,
-0.2132981867,
-0.2906018496,
-0.2069503963,
-0.8395231962,
-0.4138736725,
-0.0105502317,
0.6193614602,
0.3470297754,
1.1109364033,
0.9270814061,
0.5359497666,
0.2682762444,
-0.3152080774,
-0.0380882919,
-0.2518683076,
0.5466223955,
0.185323894,
-0.8943234086,
-0.4745845795,
-0.153992191,
1.0495382547,
0.8855171204,
-0.2230120897,
0.0079907812,
-0.0335044898,
0.5993736386,
-0.8646867871,
-0.2056305259,
-0.8020024896,
0.0419700891,
-0.4533097744,
-0.2277950048,
-0.1907721609,
-0.6433010697,
-0.3216140568,
-0.7203400731,
0.0771250278,
0.1073694527,
0.857434094,
0.465737164,
-0.3545823395,
0.2842821479,
-1.120283246,
1.2805930376,
-0.7092452049,
0.4901611805,
0.3721748888,
0.3632908463,
0.2199459076,
-0.6216896176,
-0.0423307382,
-0.1747112274,
0.2312688529,
-0.2663199604,
0.0650055632,
0.1683740616,
0.2792678773,
0.65384233,
-0.4098117948,
-0.0026299707,
0.1465436667,
-0.2701003551,
0.2844565213,
0.2647462785,
0.0930771902,
0.147905454,
-0.1720481068,
0.1086815894,
-0.7108926177,
-0.0156472847,
0.2635282576,
0.7279510498,
0.0254042279,
0.3037182391,
-0.3763561547,
0.6291227937,
-0.0094601773,
0.0103356037,
0.0457575209,
-0.5284843445,
-0.3107970059,
-0.2201531827,
0.8216347694,
-0.0961197019,
0.1579736322,
-0.2497710586,
-0.2511669993,
-0.4013573229,
0.1564066708,
-1.0359514952,
-0.1014800519,
0.4043812454,
-0.4212304354,
-0.4102729857,
-0.3507139981,
-0.6884519458,
-0.2693532705,
-0.0636628419,
0.5843273401,
-0.2866763473,
-0.1396759599,
-0.1816607714,
0.0059808772,
0.0755849034,
0.2458144873,
-1.0583341122,
0.4238602817,
0.8735228181,
0.7654897571,
0.0544373579,
-0.1276299506,
-0.8462691903,
0.0397047251,
-0.675483048,
0.3875982463,
-0.5005335212,
-0.1330175698,
-0.0983357579,
-0.283805728,
0.37540555,
-0.6537723541,
0.3200406134,
-0.6231501102,
0.1512819231,
-0.4158889055,
-0.2014808059,
0.1627693772,
0.3073859811,
-0.8579801321,
1.1341638565,
0.2490461022,
-0.6186178923,
0.5640720725,
-0.2384019345,
-0.2551044822,
0.2774827778,
-0.3969326317,
-0.7141108513,
0.5107142925,
0.0943166986,
0.2865156829,
-0.7477090359,
0.3191868961,
-0.523840189,
-0.5646278262,
0.2504338324,
-0.6035829782,
1.0454703569,
0.1957304031,
-0.3046433628,
0.1370591223,
-0.5531448722,
0.3670578301,
-0.0200104881,
-0.383353442,
-0.721396625,
-0.2239588797,
0.1632038951,
-0.1946439147,
0.3735224605,
-0.3876174688,
0.1932156235,
-0.3836604953,
0.452417016,
0.4505156875,
0.0552994125,
0.5411826968,
-0.075560309,
0.5488162041,
-0.1697859168,
0.6605388522,
0.2043042034,
-0.5127233863,
-0.4927100539,
-0.5240668058,
0.8788456917,
0.2758769989,
-0.5111228228,
0.1576716751,
-0.0459154435,
-0.4154301882,
-0.385248065,
-0.0201481339,
0.4631541073,
-0.0921536013,
0.1494626999,
-0.1224408448,
-0.2537671328,
-1.1914217472,
-0.5150743127,
-0.10435348,
-0.0690645948,
0.2619746625,
0.1196435317,
0.1818198711,
0.8977390528,
-0.260219276,
0.0936533809,
0.2008707821,
0.3175023794,
0.3012298644,
0.569489181,
0.5936667919,
-1.0040453672,
-0.6798799634,
0.3074623644,
-0.4267497659,
0.049625054,
0.3182557523,
-0.2594934106,
0.3498083353,
0.5722736716,
-0.3126927316,
0.0982313976,
0.6285113692,
-0.2489022017,
0.4485785961,
-0.2415471226,
0.3550901115,
-1.0391843319,
-0.0566547737,
-0.150965482,
-0.2925777435,
-0.580950141,
0.2487591058,
0.3780036271,
0.1987852603,
-0.5616794229,
0.3742652833,
-0.5118948817,
-0.2452963591,
-0.0851035267,
-0.2499963492,
0.094172366,
0.3967120945,
-0.1801253706,
0.7515406609,
0.5602628589,
-0.40564695,
0.4361820817,
-0.2043870687,
-0.1215823516,
0.6331550479,
-0.735651195,
-0.1241778508,
0.2512234449,
-0.2127416283,
-0.8997505903,
0.0068758735,
-0.1785037667,
-0.4594901502,
0.1475961357,
-0.4756469131,
-0.7423565388,
0.2155131698,
-0.5299552679,
0.6912913322,
0.6264868379,
-0.0312847197,
0.7885683179,
0.2385644615,
-0.2470333278,
-0.3514018357,
-0.8250270486,
-0.0823171735,
-0.6237829328,
-0.4023567736,
0.5277228951,
-0.0957024917,
-0.4343747199,
-0.136940822,
0.0098192478,
-0.4520416856,
0.277937144,
0.0424338095,
0.2291528732,
-0.538682282,
0.2461975366,
0.1710785776,
0.0118743163,
-0.0383097306,
-0.3378506303,
0.547426641,
-0.3126513958,
0.022482153,
-0.0728802681,
0.3893287778,
0.6837157607,
-0.292906642,
0.9482489228,
0.4717264175,
-0.4934395552,
-0.2435038835,
-0.4284021556,
-0.3510936499,
-0.4756161869,
0.4137868583,
-0.7165569067,
-0.9104837775,
0.6734446287,
0.0516929142,
-0.0533447936,
0.2602773011,
0.6645926833,
-0.0085479161,
1.203981638,
0.8033146262,
0.0251460951,
0.4915532768,
0.0181403141,
0.0715228915,
-0.7269589901,
0.1766850352,
-0.8250587583,
-0.1039030105,
-1.0660116673,
-0.6186285615,
0.5037072301,
0.4226363599,
-0.6033585072,
0.0401528813,
-0.4137830436,
0.588575542,
0.784309268,
0.037370123,
0.5717689395,
0.1264275014,
-0.2009703666,
-0.1594980061,
-0.758564353,
-0.3487837315,
1.2684057951,
0.4052946866,
0.6821516156,
0.1043215916,
0.5885670185,
0.1657470763,
0.1354193538,
-0.6081022024,
0.3593996763,
-0.4873139858,
-0.7509320974,
-0.7578543425,
-0.6514101624,
-0.7658711672,
0.3472945988,
-0.1180106178,
-0.7281838655,
0.1443070024,
0.1708518714,
-0.643522203,
0.2430126518,
-0.4133960903,
0.9638498425,
-0.2950181961,
-0.642573595,
-0.0433318727,
-0.5521277785,
0.2995892167,
-0.2600564659,
0.3654167652,
-0.1357399523,
-0.4487860203,
0.5442696214,
-0.4338110089,
0.4930859208,
-0.0727661774,
-0.1876811087,
-0.1008946002,
0.2633898258,
0.6073189378,
0.1236274987,
-0.2288201749,
0.1701132953,
0.0616667755,
-0.7321756482,
-0.7571864724,
0.8448930383,
-0.7714106441,
-0.521671772,
-0.0793830752,
-0.6173169613,
-0.6736665964,
-0.0272641443,
0.3364639282,
0.3567103744,
-0.070041582,
0.6272189021,
0.865033865,
-0.1735981554,
0.4001423419,
0.308953315,
-0.320179522,
-0.6292624474,
0.9941375256,
0.1305428147,
0.6455537081,
0.613271296,
0.404941231,
-0.0593735613,
-0.8359335065,
-0.5050527453,
0.2957924604,
-0.4492873847,
-0.1033097431,
-0.427487731,
-0.1696458757,
-0.235073939,
-0.0541229658,
-0.9150211811,
-0.6159040332,
-0.1578974575,
0.3257062733,
0.5052383542,
0.3492707908,
0.1567874104,
0.3999567628,
-0.813682735,
0.2093061209,
0.4984272122,
0.6434741616,
-0.2663302124,
-0.5904999375,
-0.5827854276,
0.0469025895,
-0.0312666185,
-0.6796935797,
0.2626180351,
0.0126262764,
0.5822609067,
0.1462548077,
-0.0141514307,
0.2708776295,
-0.1406103075,
0.7195706964,
-0.1489789188,
-1.0709795952,
0.3391261995,
-0.5732597113,
0.3631626368,
0.5800912976,
0.4812587202,
-0.4349260032,
-0.6037379503,
-0.5873985291,
-0.9776964784,
0.706389904,
0.3302852809,
0.0570647866,
0.5732866526,
0.1197642609,
0.0802505463,
0.4864232242,
-0.7008661628,
-0.3237592876,
0.1021528542,
-0.0332334265,
0.0965213701,
-0.2964042127,
-0.2424866259,
-0.030697979,
0.5191300511,
-0.0986076891,
0.1010230854,
-0.3688980639,
0.1824435145,
-0.3459933996,
0.2197823524,
0.2812915444,
0.4518451989,
-0.3470814824,
0.023905199,
0.086076133,
-0.363764137,
-0.0353001133,
0.0241376739,
-0.2887735069,
-0.1351613253,
0.3212891817,
0.8118759394,
0.0801780447,
-0.3286250234,
0.4253028035,
-0.0596220493,
-0.3398106992,
0.1729173809,
-0.0086549902,
0.017664453,
0.2972033918,
0.4441538155,
-0.361587137,
0.1613171399,
-0.7968055606,
0.0886431634,
0.7333475351,
-0.3590923846,
-0.1119974107,
0.587769866,
0.2487197071,
-0.4051590562,
0.4427955747,
0.0289398152,
-0.5311603546,
0.8564790487,
0.1548679471,
0.9425456524,
-0.205173105,
0.2467151284,
0.1259964257,
0.2906171083,
0.1298830956,
0.4476920366,
-0.2235307544,
-0.639398396,
-0.4565427601,
-0.7300037146,
-0.6199778914,
0.1018577591,
-0.5969642997,
0.1255786121,
-0.5997853279,
-0.1581916213,
0.0247595273,
0.0710944533,
-0.3240821958,
0.4131572843,
0.098134093,
0.2395501733,
-0.880402863,
0.8447835445,
0.6066672206,
-0.3334410489,
-0.8934339285,
0.2552960217,
-0.1930612624,
-0.5554432869,
0.3763447404,
-0.4238434732,
0.2562418282,
0.03201022,
-0.4381388724,
-1.0376790762,
0.8109431863,
0.4078603089,
-0.516397655,
0.0767517388,
0.5372288823,
0.4991411865,
-0.1660879552,
0.596010685,
0.7132025957,
0.5345206261,
0.0391216204,
-1.1031515598,
0.1669333875,
0.0383989327,
0.5143017173,
0.5964595675,
-0.8812190294,
1.2542403936,
0.1837742627,
-0.0349383131,
0.0029911108,
0.3510560691,
0.5200064182,
-0.0166519433,
0.336519897,
0.2562458217,
0.5453595519,
-0.2372091264,
0.8558564186,
-0.3121510744,
0.4319193661,
0.851315558,
-0.0744341984,
0.8860099912,
0.686871469,
-0.6353011131,
0.2052223384,
0.7056014538,
0.3517649472,
0.4581454098,
0.2291350812,
-0.2392506748,
-0.4445146918,
0.105075784,
-0.3340530097,
0.1726273894,
0.1715877503,
-0.2004506141,
-0.0502596237,
0.1217034012,
-0.1104236543,
0.1748738438,
-0.3071566522,
0.5883387923,
-0.1759388745,
-0.5477990508,
1.0286567211,
0.0533607118,
0.7621330023,
-0.4789759815,
0.072697714,
-0.5622040033,
0.0274168663,
-0.030034706,
-0.5697579384,
0.2264730483,
-0.2308846116,
-0.3198197186,
-0.1762359291,
0.2992655635,
-0.4100818634,
-0.5016633272,
0.1276400834,
0.4989869297,
0.0297266766,
-0.7535275221,
-0.5248630643,
0.5242506862,
0.0309884977,
-0.4207723439,
0.3254989088,
0.9009304643,
-0.298514992,
0.5342618227,
0.3321642578,
0.2236229181,
0.1392708272,
0.0950319171,
0.6967328787,
-0.9371405244,
-0.4444374144,
-0.8241602182,
0.553096056,
0.1513670236,
-0.4949759841,
0.7929278612,
0.7956724763,
0.55175668,
0.0496279076,
0.703720808,
0.1791490316,
0.515748322,
-0.5014082193,
0.534529984,
-0.9751248956,
0.4515758455,
-0.2113283426,
-1.2591613531,
-0.4286569059,
0.1050346047,
-0.2610689104,
0.3837163746,
0.8717350364,
0.7770536542,
0.0618522801,
-0.0721424147,
0.7027397752,
0.2789202034,
0.0804240555,
0.4711861312,
0.8682665825,
-0.5030176044,
0.6613696814,
-0.4299911559,
-0.3827267885,
-0.5182675123,
-0.8178571463,
-0.5736783743,
-0.6309761405,
-0.423756361,
-0.1034470573,
0.3718963861,
0.5341978669,
1.0047336817,
-0.777292192,
-0.3604283929,
-0.381360352,
0.2247783393,
-0.126957193,
-0.2662323713,
0.092200771,
-0.2877775431,
-0.9463897347,
0.0383730605,
0.3739569187,
0.0140502518,
-0.5812118649,
0.0317455046,
0.003174749,
0.250022769,
0.3835223019,
0.0373737328,
-0.8018752933,
0.1396106482,
0.0659386367,
-0.4829930663,
0.1888764352,
0.7697289586,
-0.6800583601,
0.1100628152,
0.4721768796,
0.5778859258,
0.6921619773,
0.0687057376,
0.6656099558,
-0.7638105154,
0.1660659164,
0.5880024433,
-0.1394193023,
0.2678456903,
-0.4901784658,
0.2677457929,
0.1723360121,
-0.5441099405,
-1.0008801222,
0.0595990904,
-0.8388772011,
-0.560276866,
1.0554258823,
0.2103708833,
-0.2856660485,
0.1710198522,
0.1291927695,
0.1393196732,
-0.3555398285,
0.4736226797,
0.7280885577,
0.0770428777,
-0.4007711709,
-0.5036653876,
0.6118166447,
0.8396282792,
-0.9018509984,
0.2482857555,
0.3278617859,
0.2358343154,
-0.0110354703,
0.5031459928,
-0.1745728403,
0.2974408269,
0.3015879393,
0.1135289893,
0.2589108944,
-0.413436234,
-0.3302250504,
0.4101058841,
0.4212837219,
-0.2778719664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02835v1
|
Retrieving Examples from Memory for Retrieval Augmented Neural Machine Translation: A Systematic Comparison
| 2024-04-03T16:13:29 | 2024-04-03T16:13:29 |
Maxime Bouthors, Josep Crego, Francois Yvon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Neural Machine Translation (RAMT) architectures retrieve
examples from memory to guide the generation process. While most works in this
trend explore new ways to exploit the retrieved examples, the upstream
retrieval step is mostly unexplored. In this paper, we study the effect of
varying retrieval methods for several translation architectures, to better
understand the interplay between these two processes. We conduct experiments in
two language pairs in a multi-domain setting and consider several downstream
architectures based on a standard autoregressive model, an edit-based model,
and a large language model with in-context learning. Our experiments show that
the choice of the retrieval technique impacts the translation scores, with
variance across architectures. We also discuss the effects of increasing the
number and diversity of examples, which are mostly positive across the board.
|
[
-0.3684733808,
-0.9428578019,
0.5465624332,
0.1274908483,
-0.4492617249,
-0.1017883867,
-0.072630398,
-0.3815254271,
0.0853484794,
0.3621227443,
0.050605122,
-0.1361127943,
-0.7241258621,
0.0748207942,
-0.5494166017,
0.9795081615,
-0.2126639634,
0.1176909655,
0.0352090001,
-0.2354176491,
-0.870206058,
-0.4698674083,
-0.7059369683,
-0.3441405892,
0.5422315598,
0.2562319934,
0.5954173207,
0.9215894938,
0.465893358,
0.2444146872,
-0.1383411586,
-0.0069810776,
-0.2025750726,
0.5204812884,
-0.1401784867,
-0.2813075483,
-0.0704178587,
0.0165738333,
0.8001534939,
0.4098026752,
-0.0905013829,
0.082010597,
0.176524505,
0.5276160836,
-0.6228667498,
-0.119815886,
-0.6364395618,
-0.0419740416,
-0.1111424565,
-0.2733870149,
-0.5064983368,
-0.1736243069,
0.4773748219,
0.0239188783,
0.1881055981,
0.1731568575,
0.5876368284,
-0.0178721007,
-0.5598089695,
-0.6334779263,
-0.6592586637,
0.9674460292,
-0.6947616935,
0.3554077148,
0.2389154583,
0.2733125389,
0.0174960122,
-0.6907132864,
-0.1375383586,
-0.1787010878,
-0.1668177545,
0.1324111223,
-0.2105760127,
-0.2004678398,
0.0447033867,
0.6279164553,
-0.4862756729,
-0.0413304083,
-0.522826314,
0.1260442436,
0.2015127093,
-0.1391108185,
0.2320103347,
-0.3689473867,
-0.519675374,
-0.2577690184,
-0.884817481,
-0.3132493198,
0.3852111697,
0.312928915,
0.2045330703,
0.535415709,
-0.1195655912,
0.7023504376,
0.0364949889,
0.4611607194,
0.3282603323,
-0.3235650361,
-0.2491218597,
-0.0505954027,
0.5205708742,
0.0314046778,
-0.1428337246,
-0.3607022762,
-0.5701307654,
-0.4507558644,
0.4857870042,
-0.7165071368,
-0.0837118477,
-0.0017071937,
-0.6714736223,
0.140474692,
-0.007485861,
-0.5895020962,
0.1956552416,
-0.32424739,
0.8580217361,
-0.6832517982,
-0.1847535074,
-0.0822298005,
-0.559851706,
0.5201692581,
0.3545436561,
-0.7283706069,
0.4306825697,
0.6626381278,
0.931776464,
-0.4029245675,
-0.3307195306,
-0.7148516178,
-0.1970959604,
-0.2460108101,
0.8201150298,
-0.4248892367,
-0.4658446908,
-0.0478753634,
-0.4022425115,
-0.2154136598,
-1.0590670109,
0.4255348146,
-1.0029171705,
0.126828894,
-0.3825649917,
-0.5497884154,
-0.3902669847,
0.1122340709,
-0.5563981533,
0.8952351809,
0.0152194332,
-0.3003103733,
0.2915811837,
-0.4297422469,
-0.5234279633,
-0.1483497769,
-0.3574651182,
-0.1746048331,
0.5690233111,
0.0512711406,
0.4673652947,
-0.1374013722,
0.004485778,
-0.001139628,
-0.4743864536,
0.0136252809,
-0.4940668643,
0.5407476425,
0.5338967443,
-0.235984683,
-0.2883357108,
-0.2604939342,
-0.0554108582,
-0.1563273668,
-0.6375649571,
-0.6568980217,
0.0111296121,
-0.120608829,
0.4654742777,
-0.0694130212,
-0.4007211924,
0.2426861376,
0.0450969823,
0.406344682,
0.5705540776,
0.435911566,
0.3949687779,
-0.2855543196,
0.3059176505,
0.4168400168,
-0.1961677969,
-0.5156230927,
-0.6941502094,
-0.4160319567,
-0.1865594536,
0.3373702765,
0.3230629265,
-0.618560791,
-0.1527360231,
-0.1250870228,
-0.1394071281,
-0.7566035986,
0.1949878782,
0.728273809,
0.5545531511,
0.6484417319,
-0.4834030271,
-0.2616669536,
-1.1444214582,
-0.5605090261,
0.005067951,
0.2116170079,
0.5123637915,
0.3907620311,
-0.0926012322,
0.6714049578,
-0.2267704457,
0.2786638737,
-0.0694797337,
0.4686634541,
0.0657360628,
0.695284009,
0.5554525852,
-0.9673448205,
-0.3407548964,
-0.0558515377,
-0.5372872353,
0.140293777,
-0.0559715144,
-0.2158573121,
0.0728861913,
0.5098108053,
-0.7185044885,
0.4994152486,
0.2470185012,
0.080055654,
0.3449890912,
-0.3329247832,
0.6185506582,
-1.1202152967,
-0.187895,
-0.1952353418,
-0.056849584,
-0.5415117145,
0.4917158782,
0.3273137808,
0.2729649246,
-0.6530587673,
0.4071872532,
-0.7430188656,
-0.5196174383,
-0.2859224975,
0.1297863275,
0.0335243307,
0.1908793747,
0.0037603495,
1.032877326,
0.1712870002,
-0.8776350021,
-0.1474328339,
0.124187246,
-0.4506198466,
0.0391087122,
-0.5014254451,
0.4079696536,
-0.1182592064,
-0.0624514334,
-1.099408865,
0.1501336694,
-0.0545754991,
-0.5746052265,
0.4418777823,
-0.239203319,
-0.7094478607,
0.0705936179,
-0.1538073421,
0.5526397824,
0.7128296494,
-0.6686523557,
0.377641201,
0.1039060056,
-0.0323894657,
-0.6913680434,
-0.858612895,
0.0079505797,
-0.3713720143,
-0.1863236427,
0.317933619,
0.0389957726,
-0.4629486203,
0.0649917424,
-0.1666422188,
-0.0461229831,
0.0856638998,
-0.0699631199,
0.0915608332,
-0.6342379451,
0.1800993234,
0.35263291,
0.2910598516,
-0.1263278872,
-0.3547306359,
0.5441792607,
-0.2047468275,
-0.3744203448,
0.0818133727,
0.6624249816,
0.2795874774,
-0.3043547273,
0.7552367449,
0.3736687601,
-0.1796708852,
-0.1410125643,
-0.5416804552,
-0.1856024563,
-0.4293213785,
0.3965681195,
-0.5607659817,
-0.7526524067,
0.600592196,
-0.101921089,
0.2280226946,
0.5426569581,
0.7131531239,
-0.0813827217,
0.8330049515,
0.2765762508,
0.008361063,
0.5612584352,
-0.3010397553,
0.0686612949,
-1.3582223654,
0.2069707513,
-0.5421382785,
-0.5573848486,
-0.3942986727,
-0.452462405,
0.0246120468,
0.5608966947,
-0.0309596267,
0.7401133776,
-0.1828561127,
0.3872273862,
0.657202363,
0.0409442447,
0.5346161127,
0.1307460368,
-0.4857146442,
0.051817622,
-0.7671292424,
-0.5283837914,
1.0931940079,
-0.1300918311,
0.2412276268,
0.4117818177,
0.8219430447,
0.3543602824,
0.6707160473,
-0.7447619438,
0.307842344,
-0.2771144509,
-0.6928979754,
0.2880094647,
-0.4038355052,
-0.9942106605,
0.5461069345,
0.2677333355,
-0.4943418503,
0.2578726411,
0.1705635786,
-0.1655763537,
0.1916089207,
-1.0488382578,
0.7085159421,
-0.226324141,
-0.2864295244,
-0.5107023716,
-0.5815361738,
0.3262948394,
-0.1651151031,
-0.1712379754,
0.4717072546,
-0.075398542,
0.3926222622,
-0.0615577176,
0.381075263,
0.0789505094,
0.0388831869,
0.5034303665,
0.1147171333,
0.2634883523,
-0.0736559108,
-0.4868463874,
0.0133940084,
-0.406906873,
-0.4919473827,
-0.6765018106,
0.9900563359,
-0.8085466623,
-0.7750368118,
-0.1178159788,
-0.5428295135,
-0.1261208057,
0.1338677108,
0.3604577482,
0.4576576948,
0.0439824127,
0.2961225808,
0.6493128538,
-0.298328191,
0.5151864886,
0.5635141134,
-0.2297578603,
-0.1204200462,
0.5577957034,
0.2943339646,
0.6551974416,
0.5638100505,
0.0541388616,
-0.1797005385,
-0.7493379712,
-0.6135000587,
0.0753923059,
-0.7291305661,
-0.1518904269,
-0.7141063809,
-0.031710498,
-0.3169076443,
0.0420448147,
-0.2910624743,
-0.4721760154,
-0.1404384971,
-0.1766403317,
0.3654761314,
0.7975299954,
0.0435716994,
0.2834097743,
-0.8149346709,
0.1504085064,
0.1070796177,
0.181160897,
0.4022474885,
-0.6978511214,
-0.395354718,
0.0235273,
-0.4113015532,
-0.9922590256,
0.3612318933,
0.0660338253,
0.6415143609,
0.2456239909,
-0.4610599279,
0.9566683173,
-0.7813820243,
0.6580594778,
-0.3317127824,
-0.5832004547,
0.4941738546,
-0.2481657118,
0.232985422,
0.4890713394,
0.4418665171,
-0.4517115653,
-0.2389359474,
-0.5360188484,
-0.9745451212,
0.4099135101,
0.0899803415,
0.2841413319,
-0.5157390833,
0.8319388628,
0.3315798342,
0.3551920354,
-0.1418826878,
-0.2470901906,
0.1165739968,
0.205093652,
0.0635344759,
0.1256852299,
0.3432448804,
-0.0480891913,
0.5139610767,
0.3563897014,
0.3969920576,
0.2834920287,
-0.3743421435,
0.1231363863,
0.2463178486,
0.5103942752,
0.2694641352,
-0.2462562174,
0.1997830719,
-0.0434264019,
-0.5167791843,
-0.1134476587,
-0.1999958754,
-0.4292517304,
0.260859549,
0.132538721,
0.8228827119,
0.2830377817,
-0.5126877427,
0.1165349782,
0.0466092415,
-0.1591170728,
0.0502802432,
0.0140121495,
-0.0118047195,
0.4189301431,
0.5386671424,
0.4068377614,
0.4934788048,
-0.720318377,
0.5951326489,
0.4670002759,
-0.2251302302,
-0.3306788802,
0.3604994714,
-0.2910380065,
-0.5709729791,
1.0031789541,
-0.1626946032,
-0.2766245008,
0.4941487908,
0.7683059573,
1.0047110319,
-0.1727538556,
-0.1712755263,
0.1668937653,
0.1045467854,
-0.3487485647,
-0.0687607005,
-0.3274409473,
-0.6379922032,
-0.5597440004,
-0.4712228179,
-0.1590266526,
0.0523648262,
-0.8467398882,
-0.1253013164,
0.0422940627,
-0.2292849422,
-0.2099157423,
-0.1430100501,
-0.6009434462,
-0.1292516589,
-0.1097873896,
0.90920645,
-0.6378040314,
0.9595336914,
0.9792622328,
-0.6112104654,
-0.8137415648,
0.2938362956,
-0.1183356643,
-0.8069408536,
1.0162873268,
-0.153999567,
-0.1997284889,
0.184339866,
-0.1834955513,
-0.9519245028,
1.0958348513,
0.1159216687,
0.0520115606,
-0.0308174882,
-0.3324815035,
0.6452575922,
-0.469809711,
0.3024666607,
0.43672508,
0.0810670704,
-0.0691384375,
-0.5454303622,
-0.1566376835,
-0.295753926,
0.114460811,
0.3088602424,
-0.6255049706,
1.1167304516,
-0.03250264,
-0.154682979,
0.2626693249,
0.5852317214,
0.3803553283,
0.0202177987,
0.1720490009,
0.6407112479,
0.076042071,
0.2629750669,
1.299785018,
-0.1336999238,
0.1374824941,
1.1433513165,
-0.0986706391,
1.3429061174,
0.8430243134,
0.0769474283,
0.4682769477,
0.5950498581,
0.2663964033,
0.6769320369,
0.1586485952,
-0.207428813,
0.2224357426,
0.210508734,
-0.2745603025,
0.1620428264,
0.447494328,
-0.7268102765,
-0.3914849758,
-0.0542323925,
-0.0930482894,
-0.1935404241,
-0.2243510783,
0.5932684541,
0.376173377,
-1.0416395664,
0.4182500541,
0.0951590091,
0.5035386682,
-0.1983789057,
-0.3074579835,
-0.406984359,
0.1983503103,
0.1040336043,
-0.6130120754,
0.3638790548,
-0.0527300313,
-0.2890569866,
-0.600335896,
0.6959830523,
-0.2974909842,
0.0117331613,
0.456799835,
1.0438833237,
0.4621555805,
-0.0440538004,
-0.5890211463,
-0.1407373846,
-0.1227255613,
-0.6257904172,
0.7231401205,
0.458519876,
-0.2614471316,
0.2913467884,
0.4230948091,
0.0626348853,
0.5573567748,
-0.1017805114,
0.5963164568,
-0.462364614,
0.0365098529,
-0.9127994776,
0.2092011422,
0.1279744655,
-0.5740033984,
1.1022816896,
0.7862184644,
0.9219366312,
-0.2829238772,
0.4420847595,
-0.0597237423,
0.3586730957,
-0.4793561995,
0.4580175877,
-0.5074609518,
0.5687560439,
-0.2224270403,
-0.9735010862,
-0.0667029023,
0.4175077081,
-0.3829910457,
0.2634176314,
0.7602164745,
0.5600119233,
-0.3242879212,
-0.0189865921,
0.2305864692,
0.1968460083,
0.0215730462,
0.2312928885,
0.8217320442,
-0.7606212497,
0.4219983816,
-0.1139546707,
0.0546195023,
-0.1631153226,
-0.6245869994,
-0.3646019697,
-0.60851264,
-0.1338585019,
-0.053114213,
0.2695129216,
0.6916260123,
0.5249014497,
-0.6234362125,
-0.3387883008,
-0.0716878176,
0.098310411,
-0.4534806311,
-0.2276320457,
0.374017328,
-0.6024597883,
-0.6741071939,
0.4930260777,
0.3700546026,
-0.0610562302,
0.0476099737,
0.0394377969,
-0.5977697372,
-0.0612123944,
0.6589529514,
0.2844704986,
-0.5830981731,
-0.1788118035,
0.2601011992,
-0.2019863576,
0.3619555533,
0.9987092614,
-1.0014419556,
0.1306519955,
0.6465794444,
1.0981020927,
0.5994249582,
0.1522600353,
0.6621373892,
-0.6981639266,
-0.2043328285,
0.1336359978,
0.3966440558,
0.1325429082,
-0.1847278625,
0.2358258516,
0.0447024927,
-0.7040353417,
-0.5614129901,
0.3854659796,
-0.5642323494,
-0.3557312787,
0.9801877141,
-0.2096839845,
-0.0515630208,
-0.101428166,
0.0558749475,
0.3693574965,
-0.3753593266,
0.7031249404,
0.7684810162,
-0.3419207633,
-0.0804762766,
-1.0625424385,
0.2208323777,
0.7851800323,
-0.2573564947,
-0.2698940933,
0.3755116165,
0.1102335528,
0.0848387629,
0.4823802412,
-0.4175722301,
0.2070050985,
-0.164590463,
-0.212902844,
0.342920959,
-0.1167243049,
-0.6370206475,
-0.0892655998,
0.0603464805,
-0.1964951754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02823v1
|
Conifer: Improving Complex Constrained Instruction-Following Ability of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T15:55:39 | 2024-04-03T15:55:39 |
Haoran Sun, Lixin Liu, Junjie Li, Fengyu Wang, Baohua Dong, Ran Lin, Ruohui Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The ability of large language models (LLMs) to follow instructions is crucial
to real-world applications. Despite recent advances, several studies have
highlighted that LLMs struggle when faced with challenging instructions,
especially those that include complex constraints, hindering their
effectiveness in various tasks. To address this challenge, we introduce
Conifer, a novel instruction tuning dataset, designed to enhance LLMs to follow
multi-level instructions with complex constraints. Utilizing GPT-4, we curate
the dataset by a series of LLM-driven refinement processes to ensure high
quality. We also propose a progressive learning scheme that emphasizes an
easy-to-hard progression, and learning from process feedback. Models trained
with Conifer exhibit remarkable improvements in instruction-following
abilities, especially for instructions with complex constraints. On several
instruction-following benchmarks, our 7B model outperforms the state-of-the-art
open-source 7B models, even exceeds the performance of models 10 times larger
on certain metrics. All the code and Conifer dataset are available at
https://www.github.com/ConiferLM/Conifer.
|
[
-0.0672699437,
-0.707662344,
0.1716881841,
0.1869558096,
-0.2700983584,
0.1828696877,
-0.2218651474,
-0.4773593247,
-0.4067738056,
0.6699820757,
-1.1022362709,
-0.9632489085,
-0.6353077292,
0.0025804527,
-0.1238616854,
1.0035407543,
0.0907087997,
0.2494389415,
0.1441700011,
-0.1414489597,
-0.7969639897,
-0.2831096947,
-0.5228654146,
-0.2829019427,
0.3821358383,
0.6278938055,
0.7601128221,
0.9493448138,
0.4809829891,
0.2671687007,
-0.0352738127,
0.4740001857,
-0.6501867771,
0.3631628752,
-0.1113184765,
-0.4603818655,
-0.3038830459,
-0.2449935228,
0.6363996267,
0.8088752627,
-0.4149008989,
0.0182876345,
0.2575810552,
0.5345868468,
-0.2607502341,
0.5352848172,
-0.7104868889,
-0.1442271769,
-0.3200728893,
-0.1959539205,
-0.4877199233,
-0.6832774282,
0.2178819925,
-0.8644321561,
0.4408663809,
0.2087677866,
0.3918506801,
0.5923714638,
-0.2462412268,
-0.5788931251,
-0.5426557064,
0.6829923987,
-0.840419054,
0.4111890197,
0.1304516941,
0.2799195945,
-0.5585160851,
-0.6526507139,
-0.1697637439,
-0.3229247928,
-0.0640783757,
-0.1666537076,
0.0876495615,
0.4335080981,
0.5990145802,
0.2968440354,
-0.5333647132,
0.1469789445,
-0.2231709808,
-0.1458656341,
0.1468576193,
0.186439395,
0.2180300951,
0.3855137527,
-0.0904439166,
-0.0640843436,
-0.9801092744,
0.223212719,
0.3325517774,
0.2515959442,
0.0545283668,
0.4224010706,
-0.2952893674,
1.1262313128,
0.0140970452,
-0.1091571003,
0.0622893423,
-0.1740924269,
-0.317581445,
0.3012943864,
0.0781004131,
0.265072614,
0.23674649,
-0.1208056584,
-0.265929997,
0.2267632186,
-0.2142766565,
-1.2244653702,
-0.5633832812,
0.0277976897,
-0.1489232033,
0.1098357663,
-0.2748824358,
-0.4725933075,
-0.3563959301,
-0.7625965476,
0.0316719748,
-0.664709866,
-0.0244545378,
0.4035734236,
0.127441898,
0.3026737571,
0.5314618945,
-1.1981837749,
0.4288032353,
1.1758072376,
0.5541263819,
0.0265901517,
-0.0999315083,
-1.2122250795,
0.2237298489,
-0.3753774166,
0.4762468338,
-1.3534198999,
-0.2036760151,
-0.0621706769,
0.1855440736,
0.0250855368,
-0.780036211,
0.6326968074,
-0.2882629037,
-0.1008235663,
-0.060493499,
-0.727522254,
-0.3153224587,
0.2497508973,
-0.544075489,
0.7602929473,
0.1927250177,
-0.4712170959,
0.1114101186,
-0.2842291296,
-0.4769633412,
0.1498891115,
-0.2891837656,
-0.3675937355,
0.022021899,
0.0622295626,
0.3764354885,
-0.4613420069,
0.377318114,
-0.523419261,
-0.5024110079,
-0.3661186993,
-0.5043368936,
0.6514105201,
-0.1328216344,
-0.3860654533,
0.2679120302,
-0.9996413589,
0.1339360774,
-0.4603678286,
-0.3873211443,
-0.3583445847,
-0.0292845499,
-0.3801625967,
-0.2148170918,
0.1553015113,
-0.6512669921,
0.6426236033,
-0.1579284966,
0.4492750466,
0.6722533107,
0.0240298007,
0.2090631723,
-0.1489189416,
0.5528480411,
-0.2454218417,
0.2804075778,
-0.3158872724,
-0.1712452471,
-0.6618848443,
-0.0026693291,
0.2328729033,
0.578409791,
-0.5782655478,
-0.0032625075,
0.045618441,
-0.4947943091,
-0.7413897514,
0.219216451,
0.6882814169,
0.4803238213,
0.5638121367,
-0.1742396057,
-0.4678917229,
-0.5686171055,
0.0120423669,
0.3166721463,
0.0717857555,
0.2557014227,
0.2226831913,
-0.2341015637,
0.3067105412,
-0.5332267284,
-0.1479939371,
0.0646024644,
0.0740124062,
0.5200127959,
0.8393908143,
0.2161308229,
-0.5545886159,
-0.5363221765,
0.1815164834,
-0.4878924191,
-0.0977576375,
-0.0593458898,
-0.239425227,
0.0448036976,
0.6066269279,
-0.630972147,
0.1335699111,
0.7954063416,
-0.2763355076,
0.7863372564,
-0.3122420013,
-0.2707547247,
-0.796839118,
-0.2223893702,
0.0828539804,
-0.2370686978,
-0.4604576826,
0.0925264508,
-0.0082353223,
0.0096383709,
-0.2455858588,
0.083066389,
-0.7673306465,
0.1512406766,
0.0296211522,
-0.3229675591,
-0.0674516559,
0.6539160609,
0.0296623204,
0.6675257087,
0.8253676295,
-0.466416806,
0.5774514675,
0.1439466327,
-0.5822191834,
0.4722473323,
-0.8175396919,
0.1637332737,
-0.1091436818,
0.3098157346,
-0.6306284666,
-0.3147318959,
0.4057300389,
0.1508946121,
0.8269546628,
-0.6420155168,
-0.2805705667,
0.1124052778,
-0.1032731384,
0.0191377271,
0.2275668532,
-0.3973439932,
0.532323122,
-0.0763985738,
-0.1411959231,
-0.7107305527,
-0.4502415657,
-0.1518908739,
0.0396569073,
-0.4029353261,
0.500520885,
-0.3106437624,
0.0160060581,
-0.0831455365,
-0.3095810413,
0.2861531079,
-0.0101792496,
0.0829591677,
0.1385634094,
-0.2993639708,
0.1016098708,
0.1545359939,
-0.0392081998,
-0.0593891926,
-0.544568181,
0.4353542626,
-0.0250488408,
-0.2976675332,
-0.6858237982,
0.2384239733,
0.5264279842,
-0.4082813859,
0.3793650568,
0.4193567336,
-0.1723046452,
-0.5207979679,
-0.1427470446,
-0.2828086913,
-0.4625761211,
0.6310894489,
-0.4610803425,
-0.8702896237,
0.0249010138,
-0.4187262058,
0.5367779732,
-0.0892085508,
0.1216823086,
-0.0468166545,
1.0269173384,
0.7276755571,
0.0842525139,
0.6199173927,
-0.4974167645,
-0.203952685,
-1.0806450844,
-0.3289389908,
-0.5118849874,
-0.4174211919,
-0.7744502425,
-0.3545926213,
0.1293556243,
0.265894264,
-0.4611023366,
0.255090028,
-0.8267769814,
0.5402815938,
0.6673675179,
0.2325076461,
0.1827511936,
-0.1381516457,
-0.127614364,
0.0820056647,
-0.7598870993,
-0.4134022295,
0.6616215706,
0.3516792655,
1.2956223488,
0.2606903017,
0.3353782296,
0.0911005288,
0.6830667257,
-0.6105830669,
0.4496348798,
-0.6557867527,
-0.3508278131,
-0.4012094438,
-0.4932135642,
-0.8055877686,
0.105154857,
-0.0692354962,
-0.6186814904,
0.0171464812,
0.50682199,
-0.3964283168,
0.0596179962,
-0.8230239749,
0.9781855345,
-0.439340353,
-0.4285384417,
-0.19666861,
-0.7664923668,
0.2226118445,
0.238623172,
-0.076930739,
-0.411506623,
-0.0212769676,
0.196763888,
-0.5354672074,
1.0761461258,
-0.400669992,
-0.0268580988,
0.1458061635,
0.3336026967,
0.9330512881,
-0.0789864212,
-0.1549894065,
-0.3515869081,
0.083190769,
-0.368922174,
-0.7239829898,
0.9091418386,
-0.7158073783,
-0.9756353498,
-0.2253707796,
-0.6764097214,
-0.1801396608,
0.1435890645,
0.0600731671,
1.1357710361,
-0.0798276439,
0.5395765901,
0.9354590774,
-0.0042605344,
0.2274231911,
0.4359633327,
-0.0623717606,
-0.2654685378,
0.9148292542,
0.3301430047,
0.4454511106,
0.563533783,
0.1932433099,
-0.4338287413,
-0.8476740122,
-0.8872807622,
0.0952803269,
-0.56308496,
-0.3581581712,
-0.227646634,
-0.0792085975,
-0.0917962715,
0.1541188657,
-0.0335005932,
-0.1895446628,
-0.4997570813,
-0.0248617306,
0.3656695485,
0.8809671998,
0.5898787379,
0.4342910349,
-0.8200095892,
-0.1776611209,
0.2845576108,
0.5786037445,
0.0453103371,
-0.5053828359,
-0.0078459512,
0.2459995449,
-0.5083745718,
-0.6405380964,
0.063079603,
0.5969147086,
0.4669411778,
0.1534697264,
0.0764571205,
0.7829931974,
-0.4870922267,
0.1329900175,
0.0585501194,
-0.80867064,
0.2729717791,
-0.4711415768,
0.5788088441,
0.3286478817,
0.3770264089,
-0.49751544,
-0.3188639581,
-0.2387679666,
-0.4906710386,
0.6770448685,
0.1060143933,
0.129348442,
0.4126055539,
0.6000608802,
0.3403533101,
0.1982462555,
-0.4118646383,
0.0073849345,
-0.1684863716,
-0.5250582695,
0.0753355324,
-0.0320403837,
0.061598897,
-0.1781890094,
0.7490743995,
-0.3665381968,
-0.4690581858,
0.0052553862,
0.0115123214,
-0.1120729744,
0.1893845797,
0.6169674993,
0.699244678,
-0.3099177182,
0.1389089674,
0.2459957898,
-0.415240556,
0.0740438104,
0.3400712311,
-0.3578668237,
0.0102107553,
0.4178140759,
0.9634272456,
0.3579300046,
-0.5311894417,
-0.0038789904,
-0.1247061193,
0.1206232533,
-0.1807126552,
0.5209052563,
0.2302919924,
0.3228249252,
0.212173745,
0.3329252601,
0.1344784647,
-0.7258113027,
0.1341699362,
0.4179649651,
-0.5313820243,
-0.3887746632,
0.4775794744,
0.3502822816,
-0.4850078225,
0.7221438289,
-0.0737631619,
-0.356493026,
0.6853401661,
0.7621159554,
0.3703836501,
-0.3750855923,
0.1329115331,
0.3404749334,
0.2581737339,
-0.2133418173,
0.3563330472,
0.0019125055,
-0.4172475636,
-0.5488267541,
-0.6159597039,
-0.6760577559,
0.0510870442,
-0.3822198808,
0.5119690299,
-0.7950211763,
0.1955161691,
0.0375992283,
0.1744618565,
-0.6281652451,
0.2333264351,
-0.0816355646,
1.1063139439,
-0.3688104451,
1.1795328856,
0.4209699333,
-0.0697070509,
-0.9521616697,
-0.1544247121,
-0.0336651392,
-0.5677269101,
0.1174983606,
0.6423866749,
-0.3888771832,
0.4209815264,
-0.8099644184,
-0.7082382441,
1.0638039112,
0.7147408724,
-1.4322866201,
-0.0341210812,
-0.0968934968,
0.5148544908,
-0.6338834167,
0.1611907333,
0.7584986687,
0.2898237109,
0.5274943709,
-0.3646145761,
0.0470954701,
-0.0823828727,
-0.116179958,
0.5517481565,
-0.844109118,
0.5608210564,
-0.2786509097,
-0.2084488422,
0.1649936736,
0.630390048,
0.2879707515,
0.1887577474,
0.4512516558,
0.5707684159,
1.112028718,
-0.1482554376,
0.8221328855,
-0.3779917955,
0.1205135286,
1.5868917704,
-0.1855798215,
0.6618457437,
0.0351645052,
0.2473439425,
0.6467126608,
0.9292898774,
-0.0960863233,
0.5355777144,
0.5993556976,
-0.2253897488,
-0.3177410066,
-0.342990607,
-0.2661542892,
0.083606869,
0.601036489,
-0.1359570026,
-0.1315399557,
-0.2898825705,
0.2187134773,
0.0432902686,
-0.4682965875,
0.5882608891,
0.0806161538,
-1.0523233414,
0.9060219526,
-0.2637630105,
0.5466729999,
-0.7236997485,
-0.7333359122,
-0.3052527606,
0.4464316964,
-0.3289372325,
-0.8171331286,
0.1750950068,
-0.0897573009,
-0.0780749395,
-0.05127104,
0.3221047521,
-0.8960994482,
-0.4624958038,
0.2396420687,
-0.0831105188,
0.069040291,
0.2306772918,
-0.6937890649,
0.34373191,
0.3264137506,
0.0216301829,
0.0213444494,
0.8577591181,
-0.2459414005,
0.8668639064,
0.7061926126,
0.0066830385,
0.1209964231,
0.2426044345,
0.9319206476,
-0.3831310272,
0.1361509264,
-0.8526776433,
0.1902138442,
0.06933254,
-0.5433710217,
0.371306628,
0.6747881174,
1.0690261126,
0.0681159794,
0.6577358246,
0.1655450463,
0.4504899681,
-0.7230603695,
0.1465778947,
-0.1703511029,
0.4736700356,
0.1139418781,
-1.0779225826,
-0.4025541544,
0.2398548722,
-0.2150492817,
-0.179173544,
0.4091674984,
1.1422822475,
-0.2882263362,
0.1294505745,
0.1679506153,
0.4735101163,
0.524371922,
0.7884570956,
0.7043280602,
0.0760427862,
0.7206441164,
-0.0841170475,
-0.445730418,
-0.1122888476,
-0.7745398283,
-0.7763385773,
-0.132994622,
-0.2108861506,
-0.1247323453,
0.3203693628,
1.3847697973,
0.9022446275,
-1.0247892141,
-0.2538151741,
-0.4219521284,
0.1175730973,
-0.3472820222,
-0.0568570867,
0.3819998503,
-0.4277657568,
-0.8303916454,
0.2333708256,
0.2241818905,
0.149904266,
-0.3343520164,
-0.2734338343,
-0.1660667658,
-0.1491529495,
0.3693735003,
0.1278315783,
-0.5887317657,
-0.3941120207,
0.1560955942,
-0.094160907,
0.03622289,
0.7541610599,
-0.390404731,
0.6008909345,
0.2607026398,
0.5702379942,
0.6299099922,
0.1064956859,
0.5929846168,
-0.6086450219,
-0.0719500184,
0.4277712405,
0.2739265263,
0.6698606014,
-0.3640352488,
0.5149645805,
0.1119659021,
-0.5544540286,
-0.4787870944,
0.362528801,
-0.6906388402,
-0.1220688373,
0.9764814377,
-0.3689995408,
-0.1806586683,
-0.1477112919,
-0.6516095996,
0.2511834204,
-0.6342126131,
0.6634577513,
0.6376407743,
-0.1842629015,
-0.4687385261,
-0.5429299474,
0.7028193474,
0.2594798803,
-0.6663848758,
0.3901729882,
0.5952539444,
0.3909131587,
-0.3347418606,
0.0858930945,
0.240754649,
0.2254343331,
-0.3322527111,
-0.1167725995,
-0.0805302039,
-0.5829971433,
-0.0735201985,
0.0484765507,
0.1878165156,
-0.2956265807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02822v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02822v2
|
Identifying Climate Targets in National Laws and Policies using Machine Learning
| 2024-04-03T15:55:27 | 2024-04-04T11:23:59 |
Matyas Juhasz, Tina Marchand, Roshan Melwani, Kalyan Dutia, Sarah Goodenough, Harrison Pim, Henry Franks
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Quantified policy targets are a fundamental element of climate policy,
typically characterised by domain-specific and technical language. Current
methods for curating comprehensive views of global climate policy targets
entail significant manual effort. At present there are few scalable methods for
extracting climate targets from national laws or policies, which limits
policymakers' and researchers' ability to (1) assess private and public sector
alignment with global goals and (2) inform policy decisions. In this paper we
present an approach for extracting mentions of climate targets from national
laws and policies. We create an expert-annotated dataset identifying three
categories of target ('Net Zero', 'Reduction' and 'Other' (e.g. renewable
energy targets)) and train a classifier to reliably identify them in text. We
investigate bias and equity impacts related to our model and identify specific
years and country names as problematic features. Finally, we investigate the
characteristics of the dataset produced by running this classifier on the
Climate Policy Radar (CPR) dataset of global national climate laws and policies
and UNFCCC submissions, highlighting the potential of automated and scalable
data collection for existing climate policy databases and supporting further
research. Our work represents a significant upgrade in the accessibility of
these key climate policy elements for policymakers and researchers. We publish
our model at https://huggingface.co/ClimatePolicyRadar/national-climate-targets
and related dataset at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ClimatePolicyRadar/national-climate-targets.
|
[
-0.4544489086,
-0.4038818181,
0.2887959182,
-0.0222035237,
0.0244807042,
0.0942398533,
-0.1933454275,
-0.228727445,
0.0728731677,
0.8394389749,
-0.429915607,
-0.5155606866,
-0.6129649878,
-0.1207783073,
-0.480625093,
1.2885688543,
-0.0934815481,
-0.3266383708,
-0.331507653,
0.0802062452,
-0.4951230586,
-0.4129038453,
-0.2537293732,
-0.1494308263,
0.5527222753,
0.2601366341,
0.393958658,
0.6344568133,
0.3997384012,
0.2458355427,
-0.1855783165,
-0.1279623508,
-0.306301266,
-0.2698476017,
-0.0343102664,
-0.2045105696,
-0.1950824261,
0.4992443025,
0.8802725673,
0.188511014,
0.2793729007,
0.3367495239,
0.4462777078,
0.2941141427,
-1.1349346638,
0.5808551908,
-0.8239117265,
-0.0036904584,
0.1465030462,
-0.090024434,
-0.2863764465,
-0.3810777068,
0.0217581969,
-0.2255778313,
0.6337534785,
0.1711596847,
0.8404957056,
0.5071267486,
-0.5473825932,
-0.3207358122,
-0.4355570972,
1.0622657537,
-0.361237675,
0.1470680833,
0.246111095,
0.3515228629,
-0.122773774,
-0.2296803594,
-0.3639751673,
-0.3674205542,
-0.1581781358,
-0.0425448678,
-0.2350200862,
-0.4226630926,
0.2357478291,
-0.0070055281,
-0.4415939748,
-0.0849000141,
-0.3785595596,
-0.6925246119,
0.7136262059,
0.1795136333,
-0.2881993949,
-0.2897009552,
-0.3884067535,
-0.0167209208,
-0.4920764267,
-0.0301639251,
0.7602126002,
0.8818360567,
-0.5451300144,
0.4857701361,
-0.2443045378,
0.6421372294,
-0.2432179451,
-0.0082500027,
0.048503153,
-0.292591095,
0.2407155484,
0.3697752059,
0.6665793061,
0.2558450401,
0.1752019376,
-0.241026774,
-0.1094008237,
-0.2200919241,
0.0979548767,
-0.6688203216,
-0.2651886642,
-0.0208704639,
-0.0754084662,
-0.5597560406,
0.4377391934,
-0.7403977513,
-0.4514050186,
-0.5262008309,
0.1183122769,
0.2122387141,
-0.2422600836,
-0.2389811426,
-0.3603439629,
0.2820843756,
0.017795749,
-0.6597176194,
0.1935423017,
0.9374443889,
0.8661130667,
0.1175272688,
0.0148348454,
-0.2554750144,
-0.0112596843,
-0.119912371,
0.6569022536,
-0.9625169039,
-0.2211976647,
-0.075839214,
0.1054830924,
0.2556836009,
-0.3727976084,
0.2432353348,
-0.4722765088,
0.3626424074,
-0.3373385966,
-0.5382748842,
-0.2671235502,
0.2306418866,
-0.775808692,
0.7893707156,
0.2323414981,
-0.7032569051,
0.5759660602,
-0.7493422627,
-0.167083323,
-0.2331847697,
0.0181683097,
-0.6697561145,
-0.2915766239,
0.2366162091,
0.6260894537,
-0.586166501,
0.7604547143,
-0.3595719337,
0.0729977861,
-0.0004252342,
-0.7966066599,
0.9449014664,
0.1548530012,
-0.3313182294,
0.2615285814,
-0.7217410207,
-0.1787976772,
0.0320653841,
-0.2532655299,
0.080137156,
-0.1277535707,
0.4263158143,
0.0337613039,
0.5643321276,
-0.6361975074,
0.1993745416,
0.2776055336,
0.6759022474,
0.7689933181,
0.2505533397,
0.3553006649,
-0.2806006968,
0.5407273173,
-0.2311227769,
0.2228744626,
0.2327057421,
-0.4524194896,
-0.2053491175,
-0.3860219717,
0.5253420472,
0.6774038076,
-0.2727906406,
0.5699368715,
-0.1484672427,
-0.485216558,
-0.2373211384,
-0.0195238143,
0.3178748488,
0.7448157668,
0.2861203849,
0.041245617,
-0.5552971363,
-0.5540625453,
-0.4760365486,
-0.1283825785,
-0.0851598904,
0.3409386575,
0.9245032072,
0.1675464958,
1.3445206881,
-0.6668794155,
-0.1284514815,
0.0323477201,
0.2797996998,
0.0975308269,
0.585606873,
0.4278088212,
-1.1213531494,
-0.5830730796,
-0.0673136786,
-0.4756249189,
0.0005612936,
-0.130549252,
0.0366549119,
-0.1081441268,
0.3729755282,
-0.1283142716,
0.4000304043,
0.0730259791,
-0.4419973493,
0.5804306865,
0.0311397575,
0.2203467041,
-0.8002586961,
0.2712081075,
0.4954407811,
-0.0767863989,
-0.6642413735,
-0.1916539371,
-0.0382478386,
-0.100338839,
-0.6513304114,
0.9008257389,
-0.0678614452,
-0.0282308124,
-0.2879082561,
-0.5090744495,
0.1497017294,
0.223769471,
0.1135422736,
0.6130302548,
0.3417526484,
-0.3628100455,
0.2507578433,
0.1806111336,
-0.1896214485,
0.3816925287,
-0.2205536067,
0.182399258,
-0.2238403857,
0.1507371068,
-0.3254157305,
-0.3273869455,
0.474159956,
-0.2370361984,
0.1849631667,
-0.505224824,
-0.2727876306,
-0.2653255165,
0.0420589857,
0.3507041931,
0.4323358536,
-0.2310675383,
0.3942255676,
0.5787371993,
0.120625332,
-0.6030501127,
-0.4268743396,
0.1314980239,
-0.6697198153,
0.170586735,
0.2801341712,
0.2350254208,
-0.1517094821,
0.0897470564,
-0.2177511752,
-0.3689389527,
0.3814166486,
0.3182508647,
0.1429742873,
0.1497891396,
-0.3740589917,
-0.373603344,
-0.3373158872,
0.3995944262,
-0.3477805257,
0.3539567888,
-0.0571336038,
0.1174719334,
-0.516797483,
0.2971532643,
0.4325626493,
-0.2367700338,
0.7534592748,
0.5888871551,
-0.5452503562,
0.103336297,
-0.3305976093,
-0.053652361,
-0.3615169227,
0.0649411529,
-0.3762668669,
-0.7894022465,
0.338127017,
-0.2313745618,
0.0849656984,
0.6709377766,
0.2851308584,
0.1837597489,
0.6495233774,
0.9483983517,
-0.7197190523,
0.4151335955,
-0.4718247056,
0.0328581445,
-0.721785903,
-0.5426114202,
-0.8210870028,
0.2156600654,
-0.564170599,
-0.4049251974,
0.1931416988,
0.0411138348,
-0.5444051623,
0.8078860641,
-0.7268543243,
0.5593810678,
0.5700747371,
0.0465080217,
-0.1757485569,
-0.0440229252,
0.3367985785,
0.0850967169,
-0.5091018677,
-0.6024927497,
0.9957582355,
0.2620833218,
0.3823199868,
-0.1583337933,
0.6021149755,
0.8013794422,
0.2804389596,
-0.6231473684,
0.502050519,
-0.0086000394,
-0.6376158595,
-0.3447508216,
-0.7999655008,
-0.9713563919,
-0.0946045145,
-0.3177650273,
-0.4577512443,
0.3106375933,
0.1224563643,
0.0157880671,
0.3784359396,
-0.0512255132,
0.8600599766,
-0.1950719804,
-0.154684335,
-0.4077589214,
-0.454949826,
-0.0566770583,
-0.2622591555,
0.3308621347,
-0.6322255731,
0.0458843149,
0.7121121883,
-0.3106799424,
0.9759674668,
-0.7136162519,
-0.0574973561,
0.4332284927,
-0.3100937903,
0.4020121694,
-0.4040639997,
-0.3726686239,
0.5741386414,
-0.004996025,
-0.5723674297,
-0.1548216194,
0.3810905814,
-0.5667377114,
-0.2953384519,
-0.5591958761,
-0.6084581017,
0.0294115394,
0.151752457,
-0.0076220599,
0.4791127741,
-0.4163593948,
-0.0355733074,
0.2869051993,
-0.0526260063,
0.199619472,
0.5152624846,
0.2354757339,
-0.4960602224,
1.2661862373,
0.2723692954,
-0.070943892,
0.5164225101,
0.4713713527,
-0.4235220253,
-0.4508918226,
0.1985473186,
-0.1419540346,
-0.5814883709,
-0.3185804188,
-0.2215649933,
-0.4393315911,
-0.7140973806,
-0.2160945088,
0.0591188967,
0.0299639665,
-0.4794350863,
0.0723873302,
0.5321319103,
0.6975822449,
-0.2424243093,
0.1313643157,
-0.3998359144,
0.2977002859,
-0.0748230442,
-0.0131883975,
-0.3476910889,
-0.2792980671,
-0.1591156125,
0.1377123296,
-0.1218224615,
-0.5183089972,
0.7583998442,
0.3356330097,
0.5237518549,
0.3720443249,
0.3077220917,
0.6141802669,
-0.5170349479,
0.4556420147,
0.2067027986,
-0.9275771379,
0.6593490839,
-0.141133666,
0.3021397889,
0.4902993441,
0.6140554547,
-0.1478716135,
-0.3468585312,
-0.5176157355,
-0.724609673,
0.449655205,
0.1808066815,
0.1918736547,
0.0260176267,
0.6292863488,
0.1953576356,
0.5194285512,
-0.2415204644,
0.1781051457,
-0.2018733621,
-0.1061772034,
-0.1970476955,
0.0891850069,
-0.2117800266,
-0.1623595208,
0.6681034565,
-0.4226570427,
-0.0102584809,
0.0217963047,
0.1350844055,
0.2446297556,
0.2965411842,
0.274943769,
0.1951245815,
-0.324449569,
-0.1991394311,
0.0211522188,
-0.4856898189,
0.2079978883,
0.1492301375,
-0.4524624944,
-0.1819905192,
0.4164946377,
0.5414497256,
-0.0399815999,
-0.4595170021,
0.3023356497,
0.0044603897,
-0.4194144309,
-0.3618355691,
-0.0352041759,
-0.4452758431,
0.3444622159,
0.1763627976,
0.2850548327,
0.3246830106,
-0.5402763486,
0.3202610314,
0.6853428483,
-0.5947393179,
-0.0220562108,
0.9725528955,
0.1417949498,
-0.2391570508,
0.637685895,
-0.0469038896,
-0.7027438879,
0.9226837754,
0.2881683707,
0.7936715484,
0.2919603884,
0.3770864308,
0.3173567951,
0.2311912775,
0.0382058099,
0.236128822,
-0.430665344,
-0.6172628403,
-0.3086519539,
-0.5799184442,
-0.6224431396,
-0.1895032823,
-1.1208974123,
0.2277327031,
-0.5056602955,
-0.354721427,
0.066155605,
0.3153037131,
-0.9386375546,
-0.1066340208,
0.4533423781,
0.7086988688,
-1.1665972471,
0.7326757312,
0.1945380121,
-0.1511548311,
-0.5062274337,
0.0476894565,
0.3656791151,
-0.58987993,
0.3033095002,
0.3237118721,
-0.0100867432,
-0.1078362763,
-0.7258030772,
-0.8211044073,
0.9597597718,
0.6830155849,
-0.643850863,
0.087669827,
0.4730194509,
0.0500483364,
-0.3585272133,
0.0208686851,
0.8372837305,
0.8143486381,
0.1069193631,
-0.7303695679,
0.2031469494,
0.051027935,
-0.2492128462,
0.4306112826,
-0.85956949,
0.5346953869,
-0.0362863652,
0.2139233649,
-0.2299275249,
0.6935059428,
0.1192013621,
0.5193738937,
0.5673928857,
0.3754859567,
0.9516531229,
-0.2420640141,
0.9076628089,
-0.5069901943,
0.5424765348,
0.8980223536,
-0.4789961278,
0.815099597,
0.2223112136,
-0.1521080881,
0.4107427597,
0.6196297407,
-0.6830629706,
0.8394911289,
0.2897337079,
-0.2946970165,
-0.055116497,
-0.4235641062,
0.0906955972,
0.3467099965,
0.2547377944,
0.0837163031,
-0.2023630291,
0.1738326102,
0.0435214564,
0.0006218236,
-0.5331986547,
0.7765284777,
-0.0633787289,
-0.390452534,
0.2404762655,
-0.1476800293,
0.5287431479,
-0.2888875902,
-0.3101817966,
0.2672378123,
-0.1001264527,
-0.2879438996,
-0.8716234565,
0.6442745328,
0.4504306614,
-0.2439871877,
-0.4594762325,
0.4534094632,
-0.3325290978,
-0.7416910529,
0.0640780404,
-0.0512675419,
0.4751158059,
-0.3206948042,
-1.0527248383,
-0.0706548914,
0.1328795999,
0.0286595263,
0.2984034121,
0.0652657598,
-0.221347332,
0.4904414117,
0.5397173762,
-0.0136164706,
-0.0843962952,
-0.031814348,
0.5867016315,
-0.7276085615,
-0.3180198669,
-0.5769071579,
0.3615937233,
-0.1403522491,
-0.2642500699,
0.6050940156,
0.8110378981,
0.7187848687,
0.2439303994,
0.9616588354,
-0.2599956989,
0.1975684911,
-0.5196616054,
0.3900416791,
-0.2035057843,
0.20880045,
0.2569897771,
-1.0729839802,
-0.3125683069,
0.3009540141,
-0.6042114496,
-0.0629758015,
-0.0014987451,
0.7770126462,
0.2045797855,
-0.1850958169,
0.0446060486,
-0.0512215793,
0.3074498475,
0.1458322406,
0.4692236185,
-0.050778728,
0.591884613,
-0.5007253289,
0.0927362069,
-0.0540483147,
-0.9804384112,
-0.698997438,
-0.4892040491,
-0.8003239632,
-0.3701212108,
0.0911682695,
0.7530788183,
0.8182255626,
-1.3194185495,
-0.1067372486,
-0.2795936763,
0.2094050199,
-0.1513068825,
-0.2957279384,
0.6038691998,
-0.0957922712,
-0.6295948029,
0.3908444941,
0.0800352246,
-0.0363220721,
-0.6206153035,
-0.0416912101,
0.1821610332,
0.1090246812,
0.0909862742,
0.5558563471,
-0.6900997162,
-0.3990722299,
-0.6116474867,
0.1884523183,
0.0360601954,
0.7498999238,
-0.9435195923,
-0.0573296137,
0.2177638113,
0.4534582794,
0.3615249097,
-0.1310858577,
0.2684084773,
-0.8300862908,
0.0692355707,
0.4380733371,
0.2804735899,
0.315985024,
-0.4781334698,
0.4311850667,
-0.1071608737,
-0.517249465,
-0.8141251206,
-0.1300213337,
-0.786103189,
-0.3737590909,
0.8767333627,
-0.322796613,
-0.4045533836,
-0.2783833742,
-0.0433503091,
0.1871958077,
-0.4978080392,
0.7488507628,
0.5072408319,
-0.0125830248,
-0.1254540384,
-0.5811233521,
0.1219284832,
-0.0709564239,
-0.5740604997,
0.1903297305,
0.504630506,
0.3675842881,
-0.0561813042,
0.0750852153,
0.0620591342,
-0.1669728905,
0.1967259049,
0.2369490862,
0.1990328282,
-0.6960414648,
-0.5011605024,
0.3726982772,
-0.3581991494,
-0.0088679744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02800v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02800v1
|
On Few-Shot Prompting for Controllable Question-Answer Generation in Narrative Comprehension
| 2024-04-03T15:17:21 | 2024-04-03T15:17:21 |
Bernardo Leite, Henrique Lopes Cardoso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Question Generation aims to automatically generate questions based on a given
input provided as context. A controllable question generation scheme focuses on
generating questions with specific attributes, allowing better control. In this
study, we propose a few-shot prompting strategy for controlling the generation
of question-answer pairs from children's narrative texts. We aim to control two
attributes: the question's explicitness and underlying narrative elements. With
empirical evaluation, we show the effectiveness of controlling the generation
process by employing few-shot prompting side by side with a reference model.
Our experiments highlight instances where the few-shot strategy surpasses the
reference model, particularly in scenarios such as semantic closeness
evaluation and the diversity and coherency of question-answer pairs. However,
these improvements are not always statistically significant. The code is
publicly available at github.com/bernardoleite/few-shot-prompting-qg-control.
|
[
-0.5290721059,
-0.9109159112,
0.553424418,
0.0280255657,
-0.2159056216,
-0.2265713662,
0.1622045189,
-0.2934914827,
-0.2426510155,
0.4299487174,
-1.0645964146,
-0.1115572602,
-0.3255599737,
0.1806974411,
-0.2119469792,
1.0426604748,
-0.327277422,
-0.3634641171,
-0.2711298764,
-0.1296218485,
-0.286321342,
-0.0569089875,
-0.7425969243,
-0.4034722149,
0.9759415984,
0.6557360291,
0.6967966557,
0.5752426386,
0.4599993825,
0.1272341013,
0.0089220051,
0.2371607423,
-0.5384864807,
0.4932172,
-0.0435661077,
-0.5613828897,
-0.0014156057,
-0.0116187166,
0.6856238246,
0.5271695852,
0.1150897667,
0.2787692547,
0.2484928817,
0.4272595346,
-0.7542868853,
-0.2210092992,
-0.4859339893,
0.1362476945,
0.000308237,
-0.3970652223,
-0.3732513785,
-0.576790154,
0.0178911891,
-0.521474123,
0.4214723408,
0.1479190886,
0.7274065614,
0.056422051,
-0.3775399625,
-0.1429904252,
-0.7017088532,
0.6049919128,
-0.5338394046,
-0.3050926924,
0.7951856852,
0.2225863338,
-0.1266067624,
-0.5693151951,
-0.6088879108,
-0.1350563169,
-0.3080691397,
0.4373227656,
-0.3670110404,
-0.0765889362,
0.5178623199,
-0.3112709224,
-0.9300759435,
-0.0626564324,
-0.3617987335,
0.0121880462,
0.5651971698,
0.4833391309,
0.1572745442,
-0.4210873246,
-0.4193384647,
-0.0486431606,
-0.9003044963,
0.4540610909,
0.4911536574,
0.1972450614,
-0.1328413188,
0.7588170171,
-0.361066699,
0.6137607694,
0.5938257575,
-0.1449638754,
-0.4005818367,
-0.7377902865,
0.1166703627,
0.001321967,
0.6680914164,
0.5651877522,
0.2672267258,
0.1936726272,
-0.0411628559,
-0.1161033362,
0.0852322504,
-0.7736311555,
-0.0220959522,
0.3074980676,
-0.2861197293,
-0.4528770149,
-0.0931713805,
-0.6294288635,
-0.1947834641,
0.114404276,
0.4434179962,
-0.5183296204,
0.1767325252,
-0.3993527293,
-0.4764187932,
0.5444260836,
0.1156989858,
-1.043138504,
0.0811223537,
0.3246092796,
0.4817175567,
-0.2974893451,
-0.3305609822,
-0.6310998797,
0.5979180932,
-0.3804837167,
0.9092401862,
-0.5186020136,
-0.54980129,
0.1488895863,
-0.3154273331,
-0.0301788542,
-0.4841039181,
0.0235256609,
-0.6523587704,
0.4759881794,
-0.2910460234,
-0.5409081578,
0.163045004,
0.3825797737,
-0.353926301,
0.8520767689,
0.0348429717,
-0.7721307278,
0.4817381501,
-0.1173020378,
-0.2236668468,
0.1355877966,
-0.2151008397,
-0.3591775894,
-0.1152613908,
0.4037818313,
0.1600925624,
-0.0943728313,
0.1629203856,
0.0496675707,
-0.1873222739,
0.2013939172,
-0.5055967569,
0.6287666559,
0.0421372205,
-0.1423986107,
-0.1025648341,
-0.5246650577,
0.4347773194,
0.1972020715,
-0.0335538387,
-0.1619548649,
-0.3524017632,
-0.4041544199,
-0.0202044696,
-0.023927331,
-0.1890986413,
0.3155114651,
-0.2076437473,
-0.1098684296,
0.1819556803,
0.7151446939,
0.7026491165,
-0.9668394327,
1.1509472132,
-0.054481104,
0.1399500668,
-0.6346040368,
-0.5446289778,
-0.4716594815,
0.1116759181,
-0.0045876247,
0.5307561755,
-1.187268734,
0.0283430051,
0.4265328348,
-0.3546703458,
-0.3176737428,
0.3233077824,
0.657627821,
0.7313407063,
0.2597125471,
0.0669874474,
-0.2343029082,
-0.6063472033,
-0.1305030137,
-0.5491628051,
-0.2113430351,
0.4400558174,
0.5073779821,
0.4620706737,
1.2987995148,
-0.6822417974,
0.1504638344,
-0.4874878228,
0.5365588069,
-0.1181528643,
0.7316226959,
0.6433379054,
-0.7060596943,
-0.447524488,
-0.4701704085,
-0.6468088031,
-0.4631946683,
-0.3534675241,
-0.2577811778,
-0.1352774203,
0.4256731272,
-0.7177080512,
0.3944057226,
0.40551278,
-0.2306268215,
0.6910867691,
0.0383505486,
0.1722517312,
-0.8856768608,
0.0991415828,
-0.1868237257,
-0.2313190401,
-0.6021363139,
0.4128318727,
0.0587301068,
-0.0014517695,
-0.87487185,
0.5503067374,
-0.0807258561,
0.4190715849,
-0.2735350728,
0.2799386978,
0.3694861233,
0.400183171,
-0.0392843634,
0.6578863263,
0.2463201135,
-0.7314414978,
0.5276303887,
0.2960081398,
0.1358900368,
0.8775603175,
-0.8123182654,
0.4841834307,
-0.3565222323,
0.3447710574,
-1.0500568151,
-0.3343126774,
0.3814813793,
-0.5745228529,
0.3011156917,
-0.1494735181,
-0.3363771439,
-0.4063175619,
-0.5240231752,
0.3902453482,
0.5132015347,
-0.3965995014,
0.1350589097,
-0.385058552,
-0.5467428565,
-0.1649425328,
-0.7827151418,
-0.3413997591,
-0.2891159356,
-0.5688663125,
0.2280520946,
-0.4535457492,
-0.2565818429,
0.1612675339,
-0.0118550174,
-0.2686406374,
-0.3279440701,
-0.0309284516,
0.2121349722,
-0.4375849664,
0.3115010858,
0.698765099,
-0.3209716082,
-0.20252119,
-0.0960771739,
0.2683240771,
0.4216149747,
-0.2284303457,
-0.4100774825,
0.7050570846,
-0.0523518138,
-0.1282568723,
0.5144979954,
0.2957628071,
-0.0805267841,
-0.36936903,
-0.3058449924,
-0.6171422601,
-0.4522425532,
-0.1883164197,
-0.3333016336,
-0.862005055,
0.4750405252,
0.128399834,
-0.0417604037,
0.2667498589,
0.5578714609,
-0.5336818099,
1.119546771,
0.4201945066,
0.1950536966,
0.2681080401,
-0.2178892344,
-0.3741377592,
-0.4346600473,
-0.0841569006,
-0.6388460994,
-0.4244724512,
-0.3739272654,
-0.1268931031,
0.3487481475,
0.3447176218,
-0.1750733703,
0.2693733871,
-0.2281888723,
0.8526697159,
0.7726835608,
0.0389773175,
0.5849615335,
-0.386498332,
-0.2632880807,
-0.0067363372,
-1.1094141006,
-0.6375512481,
0.8227270246,
0.017162092,
0.9062684178,
-0.0774721578,
1.1093950272,
-0.1310134828,
-0.0998590961,
-0.6319952607,
0.3985888958,
0.3554338813,
-0.9716202021,
-0.5190708637,
-0.1874668896,
-1.1115831137,
0.1932795495,
-0.3001513183,
-0.6952583194,
0.2441879809,
0.375679642,
-1.048388958,
-0.1376236379,
-0.75379318,
0.5315973759,
0.0154471202,
-0.7712241411,
0.2044637948,
-0.7810665965,
0.3974946141,
-0.0223573558,
-0.5162806511,
0.2143345326,
-0.0289447624,
0.6289229393,
-0.3405494094,
0.86808002,
-0.0385360569,
0.1239995658,
0.9997508526,
0.3452852666,
0.6478387713,
0.1492475569,
0.1523860693,
-0.5982555151,
0.2304112464,
-0.6012457013,
-0.6791811585,
0.6145815253,
-0.2917961478,
-0.8050537109,
-0.2090441138,
-0.6982727051,
-0.282712549,
0.2394188792,
0.6965622902,
0.2145777792,
-0.0815546364,
0.1061445996,
0.5975934267,
-0.2385138124,
0.7443381548,
0.4053791165,
-0.2744143903,
-0.0580941141,
0.2764918804,
0.1796441227,
0.7049491405,
0.0329890363,
0.4917292893,
-0.1608977616,
-0.3622954786,
-0.5740056634,
0.1369141042,
-0.4123261571,
-0.3894814849,
-0.2188229561,
-0.1087027118,
-0.3143440485,
-0.3913508058,
0.1530109495,
-0.373286128,
-0.2909556031,
-0.37691468,
0.3822346926,
0.656996429,
0.2194457054,
0.6963990927,
-0.8385940194,
0.6975748539,
0.8313439488,
0.0039225882,
-0.1826795936,
-0.4107220769,
0.1758653224,
-0.105464533,
-0.646043241,
-1.10161376,
0.1769385934,
-0.0441679172,
0.2850752473,
0.5346969366,
0.3188076019,
0.5828134418,
-0.5141596794,
0.9754105806,
0.184023276,
-0.5560429692,
0.8970759511,
-0.5247476697,
0.9480037689,
0.6721516848,
0.3435035348,
-0.2616693377,
-0.8383235931,
-0.8028743863,
-0.2922894955,
0.9598391652,
0.4684529006,
0.5555047989,
0.1500134468,
0.3121054769,
0.2541437745,
0.1556769758,
-0.4544990361,
-0.2624166012,
-0.0143552963,
-0.0784243867,
0.3507994115,
-0.2535091341,
-0.3963092268,
-0.0111935036,
0.2982307374,
-0.2691504061,
-0.1056759804,
0.3040800691,
0.1182321459,
-0.7262949347,
0.2605533004,
0.4871016145,
0.5295158625,
0.0048083318,
0.2420097739,
0.1503079981,
-0.2970504761,
0.190275088,
-0.0159728192,
-0.9944937825,
-0.1867133975,
0.5824905038,
0.668330133,
-0.1649996042,
-0.2553738058,
0.3993626237,
0.167174235,
-0.4760225117,
0.1438593864,
0.3212314546,
0.0334331915,
0.6183436513,
0.4450403154,
-0.3541304171,
-0.2220890671,
-0.395242095,
0.1797233522,
0.2358753532,
-0.1298904568,
-0.1372021288,
0.6513004303,
0.0242027044,
-0.1732778102,
0.3640041649,
-0.3696016967,
-0.2194053978,
0.7770425081,
0.9641948342,
0.7146175504,
-0.1490869373,
0.6288722754,
0.5658914447,
0.4470127523,
0.2399805188,
0.3699164093,
-0.1919976622,
-0.8510482311,
-0.1431274861,
0.0150510808,
-0.6480697989,
0.0984890908,
-0.5584357381,
0.1398523301,
-0.5658661723,
-0.1781184077,
-0.1616816819,
-0.1477486044,
-0.470795244,
0.1842523366,
0.1821815372,
0.5066783428,
-0.829490602,
0.6788736582,
0.2725349665,
-0.8577175736,
-0.962836206,
0.2841332257,
0.014033773,
-0.5142810941,
0.4815588892,
-0.2056092471,
-0.2175027579,
0.225864619,
-1.0780081749,
-0.5069644451,
1.2066165209,
0.1389895827,
-0.4495515823,
-0.1538204402,
0.0183529053,
0.5276224017,
-0.1799666435,
0.0985876396,
0.6355748177,
0.6396478415,
0.5139839649,
-0.5728569627,
-0.1302991807,
0.0490967669,
-0.0341480598,
-0.0250086486,
-0.4949557781,
0.33449772,
-0.5435521007,
-0.1528923959,
0.2454037815,
0.7707173228,
0.6614754796,
0.8355499506,
0.2692353427,
0.1063839272,
0.6124823689,
0.0815522596,
1.2704159021,
-0.1096555516,
0.0856246203,
1.2544420958,
-0.1688373387,
0.704128325,
0.8750981092,
-0.1230518371,
0.1801915169,
0.3060609698,
0.1486447006,
0.5077664256,
-0.0564121865,
-0.3700056076,
-0.103193067,
-0.353582561,
-0.1174815893,
0.339558959,
-0.0914222896,
-0.3137631118,
-0.2326970547,
0.0092531908,
0.1749440581,
0.2253287584,
-0.2209988683,
0.9369539618,
0.1621233523,
-0.9849901795,
0.5156276226,
-0.341232866,
0.3458652198,
-0.9700362682,
-0.0426701531,
-0.535282135,
-0.4701287746,
-0.123980619,
-0.7577472329,
0.0800046399,
0.3780413866,
-0.2462831736,
-0.2864699662,
0.7598931193,
-0.838413775,
-0.373470366,
-0.3050237298,
0.7876502872,
-0.1618125439,
0.2561852336,
-0.5379403234,
-0.4753951728,
-0.1902167797,
-0.4352198243,
0.1192326173,
0.3440135717,
-0.2675238848,
0.3820652068,
0.4567875862,
0.0623971,
0.3127063215,
0.0578125082,
0.6449146271,
-0.5215761662,
-0.4360250235,
-0.6848095655,
0.5126389265,
0.225587815,
-0.5008662343,
0.7351430655,
0.2385292947,
0.6560804248,
-0.0778761506,
0.6599005461,
-0.0124913845,
0.3789631128,
-0.6280027032,
0.6301450133,
-0.2811460495,
-0.151698187,
-0.390487045,
-0.8255723715,
-0.4747710526,
0.302141428,
-0.1992145777,
0.0745861232,
1.0960519314,
1.0534975529,
0.2420664281,
-0.076261051,
0.3634048104,
-0.2009913623,
0.105694063,
0.6264178753,
1.0873599052,
-0.1045212746,
0.6359528303,
-0.3794895709,
-0.079268977,
0.0746646002,
-0.9391989708,
-0.7429842353,
-0.22437343,
-0.3163752854,
-0.300285697,
0.0635877028,
0.7691025138,
0.4314222038,
-0.7839477062,
0.0233645383,
-0.1693392396,
0.2425255924,
-0.1737079024,
-0.1572452933,
0.3399558663,
-0.3413257003,
-0.8495055437,
0.2975582182,
0.0985565409,
0.3639748991,
-0.2091132104,
-0.1120894477,
-0.1203023791,
0.2677054107,
0.3408278525,
0.3715371192,
-0.4611104727,
-0.2766844034,
0.1136220768,
-0.3484405279,
-0.1015797481,
1.0093907118,
-0.8369541764,
0.6031686068,
0.8618405461,
0.3296973705,
0.656637609,
0.4511018097,
0.5082457066,
-1.1305119991,
0.1396587193,
0.5199424028,
-0.140411377,
0.0401137024,
-0.2163365781,
0.1714627743,
0.1381581873,
-0.3371555805,
-0.3002841473,
0.3278053105,
-0.8276345134,
-0.1192579567,
1.3168007135,
-0.1037707403,
-0.1026913151,
0.0692062825,
-0.707403779,
0.27090469,
-0.4548334479,
0.3853884637,
0.774074614,
-0.3946028054,
-0.5598463416,
-0.3065483272,
0.4059020877,
0.5627919436,
-0.7908039093,
-0.1618911326,
0.6133314371,
-0.1706608683,
-0.1039565131,
0.634927094,
0.0085624289,
0.5170324445,
0.1657649428,
-0.2517081201,
-0.1217169091,
-0.3595032394,
-0.5267003775,
0.3977434039,
0.0956783965,
-0.1135536134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02772v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02772v2
|
FPT: Feature Prompt Tuning for Few-shot Readability Assessment
| 2024-04-03T14:39:47 | 2024-04-10T04:25:09 |
Ziyang Wang, Sanwoo Lee, Hsiu-Yuan Huang, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompt-based methods have achieved promising results in most few-shot text
classification tasks. However, for readability assessment tasks, traditional
prompt methods lackcrucial linguistic knowledge, which has already been proven
to be essential. Moreover, previous studies on utilizing linguistic features
have shown non-robust performance in few-shot settings and may even impair
model performance.To address these issues, we propose a novel prompt-based
tuning framework that incorporates rich linguistic knowledge, called Feature
Prompt Tuning (FPT). Specifically, we extract linguistic features from the text
and embed them into trainable soft prompts. Further, we devise a new loss
function to calibrate the similarity ranking order between categories.
Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed method FTP not only exhibits
a significant performance improvement over the prior best prompt-based tuning
approaches, but also surpasses the previous leading methods that incorporate
linguistic features. Also, our proposed model significantly outperforms the
large language model gpt-3.5-turbo-16k in most cases. Our proposed method
establishes a new architecture for prompt tuning that sheds light on how
linguistic features can be easily adapted to linguistic-related tasks.
|
[
-0.5032945275,
-0.5889103413,
0.5052784681,
0.1243399456,
-0.4663335979,
-0.027463669,
-0.4430440962,
-0.3505986333,
-0.0693726167,
0.2404681444,
-0.9041808844,
-0.4191088378,
-0.4170013368,
0.5635857582,
0.1068505943,
0.956569612,
0.2435832173,
-0.1658591479,
0.1239460185,
-0.3094409406,
-0.8037676215,
-0.106969215,
-0.5787566304,
-0.1455670595,
0.7745105028,
0.6320058107,
0.7515409589,
0.705904901,
0.4439569414,
0.2646376789,
-0.4139424562,
0.2282876223,
-0.3170418739,
0.0144268693,
-0.2162927538,
-0.4908578992,
-0.2306725085,
0.0092385737,
0.6775513887,
0.4856083989,
0.2435206026,
0.0041873776,
0.4763832688,
0.4448412657,
-0.5095614195,
0.2908572853,
-0.6342057586,
0.031124752,
-0.3473371267,
-0.5427180529,
-0.5149224997,
-0.3296604455,
0.1605871767,
-0.6655279398,
0.6599710584,
0.3631307483,
0.7211019397,
0.4321206212,
-0.0806922689,
0.0300040916,
-0.1904671192,
0.6245629191,
-0.6791504025,
0.3775194883,
0.5030264854,
0.282397449,
-0.0805584863,
-0.1777490824,
-0.6563011408,
-0.261883378,
-0.1531649679,
-0.1717529595,
-0.0499757417,
0.1181424186,
0.4571581185,
0.154032141,
-0.786919713,
0.4488567412,
0.2938665748,
-0.4206921458,
0.3313008249,
0.2648430765,
0.2665083706,
-0.3386916518,
-0.2032799721,
-0.1700846404,
-0.5469504595,
0.274165839,
0.3008138239,
1.051437974,
-0.1589465439,
0.4452033639,
-0.4065956771,
0.7353411317,
0.0088056577,
-0.2056290805,
0.1995983273,
-0.3811987936,
-0.0757293999,
0.1514161527,
0.6068693995,
0.4255526066,
0.2309709787,
0.1134958565,
-0.1807378083,
-0.2926223576,
-0.0136225037,
-0.8210836649,
-0.1502998471,
-0.0916502178,
-0.5011020899,
-0.373067975,
-0.0997997522,
-0.8496665359,
-0.7723491192,
-0.1016539559,
0.4453923702,
-0.7375710011,
-0.1542435288,
-0.1077599227,
-0.1192174107,
0.3442329168,
0.4726308584,
-1.3961535692,
-0.107740894,
0.9870012403,
1.0974830389,
-0.1089117825,
-0.4472346008,
-0.8836871982,
-0.4685129821,
-0.1296668798,
1.1091393232,
-0.6155593395,
-0.2783859372,
0.050632894,
0.059583284,
-0.1596834362,
-0.2561093271,
0.5481167436,
-0.2020159066,
0.1358048618,
-0.3110329509,
-0.4173182845,
-0.105103299,
0.3392010629,
-0.5704545975,
0.9503728747,
0.1957202703,
-0.8182465434,
0.8342064023,
-0.4250139892,
-0.3334906697,
0.3905927241,
0.0764818117,
-0.347021997,
0.2783007026,
0.3161076605,
0.4820135832,
-0.1613980532,
-0.1928223372,
-0.3884775937,
-0.6702240705,
0.1998460889,
-0.5293863416,
0.4531293809,
0.1300785393,
-0.1760645658,
0.1947824657,
-0.7689366341,
0.2120861709,
-0.1628489792,
-0.1916222274,
-0.3396388888,
-0.114792645,
0.2101223916,
-0.094417356,
0.0216575656,
-0.4018910229,
0.3647938669,
-0.8740788698,
0.2286911011,
0.6051349044,
-0.088417232,
0.5143988132,
-0.4341748059,
0.7413688898,
-0.0872405097,
0.0428521819,
-0.5909038186,
-0.7013944387,
-0.4510436654,
-0.3638510406,
0.4354757369,
0.8764781952,
-0.8987114429,
0.6056905389,
-0.0604318231,
-0.5191402435,
-0.462285459,
0.178624928,
0.4257719517,
0.7217989564,
0.3107818961,
-0.1355806887,
0.0667790771,
-0.5652304292,
-0.6041358113,
-0.3234061599,
-0.1594384015,
0.2607108355,
0.1025634855,
0.1979019046,
0.8497248888,
-0.6171789765,
-0.4288382232,
-0.5007927418,
0.2397670895,
0.5540633798,
0.3763775229,
0.5855219364,
-0.3775322437,
-0.2916583717,
0.0251492765,
-0.2517954707,
-0.346451968,
-0.1378085315,
0.1327693015,
0.2391200215,
0.0940521732,
-0.3955913782,
0.2310898602,
0.0392399505,
-0.6953184605,
0.4057113528,
-0.1345405728,
0.4805642664,
-0.6410047412,
0.0029775307,
0.1650998741,
-0.2737726867,
-0.3044250309,
-0.0547149293,
0.1843743175,
-0.2019673139,
-0.6036060452,
0.851144135,
-0.0672769621,
0.2470259219,
-0.4326252341,
0.006760261,
0.0833146721,
0.3803109229,
0.0269831419,
0.8186225891,
0.4948585927,
-0.5642532706,
0.0482043549,
0.5096039772,
-0.366022557,
0.8733036518,
-0.3992619216,
0.0315947831,
-0.1359347105,
-0.1637227237,
-1.1136379242,
-0.0978035331,
0.2361707985,
-0.5139995217,
0.5397027731,
-0.3852836788,
-0.6360251307,
-0.0347320139,
-0.4480309486,
0.2319262028,
0.4060283005,
-0.4491760731,
0.2698807418,
-0.2332255989,
-0.5327656865,
-0.3777600229,
-0.5032063127,
-0.1589182168,
-0.2963404655,
-0.5921776891,
0.1760806292,
-0.0809231997,
0.325289607,
-0.471722573,
-0.1176794171,
-0.1028748155,
0.340244472,
0.0284718368,
0.1159160361,
-0.4890467227,
0.3503460586,
0.2032111436,
-0.4817867875,
-0.4306132197,
-0.0959679633,
0.4103373289,
-0.1125444025,
0.0901424512,
-0.5887200832,
0.2745871842,
0.110252656,
-0.245795086,
0.50200665,
0.8126003742,
-0.1124585345,
-0.4681732655,
-0.2734630406,
-0.3484363258,
-0.5400823355,
0.2675406635,
-0.523969233,
-1.1520521641,
0.4319317043,
-0.1309814155,
0.0520262085,
0.481210053,
0.4338461161,
-0.2644189596,
0.9184846282,
1.0272661448,
0.1205532923,
0.8413858414,
0.155213058,
-0.0666885003,
-0.342143923,
-0.1189668328,
-1.0473860502,
-0.4834370911,
-0.6665946841,
-0.1565699428,
0.3056379855,
0.1736936122,
-0.2298942059,
0.2808038592,
-0.5350962281,
0.7202520967,
0.5425372124,
0.2647678852,
0.3440871835,
-0.0869461298,
-0.3417676389,
-0.4563839436,
-0.7658850551,
-0.4565131068,
0.5870868564,
0.2797031403,
0.6441796422,
-0.0473700054,
0.5865014195,
0.2609249055,
-0.0968712941,
-1.0804849863,
0.4625799656,
-0.378831327,
-0.1381538361,
-0.3793919086,
-0.4126486182,
-0.7834940553,
-0.0006123491,
-0.4298406243,
-0.6276620626,
0.1789155751,
0.439748913,
-0.6657640338,
-0.0245283712,
-0.8160140514,
1.0677042007,
-0.0997335166,
-0.1940166652,
0.1264806539,
-0.6584493518,
0.0624796115,
-0.0309608672,
-0.1505688131,
-0.3687026203,
-0.3165718615,
0.5866367221,
-0.4561882615,
0.83425349,
-0.3412320316,
0.0283844639,
-0.0883407444,
0.1100270525,
0.3166145682,
0.2520671785,
-0.2252125293,
0.0910137445,
0.1801098138,
-0.3164180517,
-0.7922520041,
0.6161994338,
-0.5081801414,
-0.2334908694,
-0.4970234632,
-0.2048871219,
-0.4503069818,
0.4810973406,
0.5263968706,
0.5991912484,
-0.1237843484,
-0.1140626296,
0.7617247105,
-0.3850799799,
0.712022543,
0.5942858458,
0.0864843875,
-0.4110662043,
0.8960324526,
-0.0892194882,
-0.1503955722,
0.6376070976,
0.5449683666,
-0.5171969533,
-0.6560995579,
-0.6404713392,
0.1197331622,
-0.5102702975,
-0.5268038511,
-0.3466365337,
0.1274032146,
-0.2563837171,
-0.2082350403,
-0.0925627276,
-0.473133713,
-0.6678813696,
0.127343446,
0.8191575408,
0.3284504712,
0.2780154347,
0.7196935415,
-0.9791535735,
0.3691375256,
0.0567032322,
0.8431925774,
-0.3329449296,
-0.8087816238,
-0.1182406023,
-0.4129547477,
-0.2761315107,
-0.8122932315,
0.2363865823,
0.6115024686,
0.4202553332,
0.2932926714,
0.2201252729,
0.4375344217,
-0.6662082076,
0.8387905955,
-0.0065575107,
-0.9663701057,
0.9074281454,
-0.3910173774,
0.7270062566,
1.1487754583,
0.1755398959,
-0.3906528056,
-0.2242000848,
-0.3199980855,
-0.5343198776,
0.9181140065,
-0.0944498256,
0.1703230292,
-0.0196083635,
0.3635718226,
0.3766823411,
0.150923878,
-0.2074975818,
-0.0528001226,
-0.3486304283,
-0.4504145086,
-0.2830482125,
-0.1875794828,
0.376981318,
-0.1617648304,
0.3969317675,
-0.6432360411,
0.1308719367,
0.0540283397,
-0.1274122596,
-0.0662173256,
0.5748717785,
0.6648747325,
0.3498651385,
-0.1391417384,
-0.0635962561,
0.0878216922,
-0.5708152652,
0.2080914527,
0.3282915652,
-0.4075666368,
-0.0278373696,
0.5074040294,
0.9789441824,
0.4216777384,
-0.5275416374,
0.6530560255,
-0.1406035125,
0.0070489659,
0.3906932473,
0.4225482643,
-0.5283293724,
0.3344816566,
0.2452227026,
0.3060771823,
0.1588646173,
-0.2550549507,
0.3533915281,
0.2593473196,
-0.5317845941,
-0.222245574,
0.5269734263,
0.4076869488,
-0.3665723801,
0.6417725086,
-0.2907773256,
-0.3979003727,
0.4069322646,
0.2921836078,
1.1333891153,
-0.1177613959,
0.399777621,
0.3466709554,
0.4860189855,
-0.1042302474,
0.6082885265,
-0.2128299177,
-0.5642129183,
-0.441075176,
-0.824652493,
-0.4723266363,
-0.1757062674,
-0.3371762931,
0.6340366602,
-0.6232993007,
-0.1040828675,
0.042198021,
0.2716665566,
-0.8162663579,
0.1068599895,
0.0223292392,
1.0915257931,
-0.9586660266,
0.5970028639,
0.6120342612,
-0.3118956089,
-0.775496304,
0.1007532924,
0.2331671268,
-0.6440788507,
0.1009507328,
0.5483025312,
0.1424092799,
0.270875752,
-0.3277349472,
-0.4360894561,
0.8696213961,
0.5150389671,
-0.6985907555,
0.1316154003,
0.0517474078,
0.5206394196,
-0.1580365151,
0.5106821656,
0.6205175519,
0.5477348566,
0.1247827932,
-1.1546720266,
0.1199827641,
-0.1451559514,
-0.0313205272,
0.2700076401,
-0.6323649883,
0.2486378402,
-0.2792912722,
-0.1194284558,
0.2389541864,
0.6844357252,
0.2662189901,
0.5565776229,
0.6121655107,
0.2393088937,
0.8314667344,
-0.242876336,
0.9285828471,
0.049269218,
0.3533436358,
0.9310556054,
-0.187791869,
0.9052831531,
0.2013523281,
-0.1138946414,
0.1167046502,
0.7861651182,
-0.1385950893,
0.6804679632,
0.0384141095,
-0.0959451199,
-0.3423697054,
-0.1976120174,
-0.2356872261,
0.6263047457,
0.0609409139,
-0.3111575842,
-0.2931632698,
0.2606268525,
-0.1948355585,
0.1013336629,
-0.4492624104,
0.9400217533,
0.0327434354,
-0.5350192189,
0.6633347273,
-0.0359358042,
0.9773995876,
-0.6647052169,
-0.1288809925,
-0.3479973674,
-0.1078623235,
-0.2295520604,
-0.9165115952,
0.1836239845,
0.1635253578,
-0.4020445049,
-0.3070317507,
0.6558502316,
-0.2870336175,
-0.4182191491,
-0.140449062,
0.4934743941,
0.0367526449,
-0.1982902437,
-0.7360338569,
0.0591832437,
-0.0923754424,
-0.0934219956,
0.314565599,
0.5915754437,
0.0654531419,
0.4901406467,
0.4004500806,
0.1191762313,
-0.1417875588,
0.308463484,
0.629889369,
-0.9590530992,
-0.8735036254,
-0.7703183293,
0.4832955897,
0.2752508521,
-0.8218431473,
0.4035350978,
0.2615449131,
0.4559974968,
-0.07391873,
0.5268237591,
0.0454234779,
0.6557428837,
-0.782073617,
0.9182109237,
-0.5099930167,
0.2333353758,
-0.513276279,
-0.969588995,
-0.5649894476,
0.4099995196,
0.016002465,
0.1179433689,
0.7667163014,
0.8453980684,
-0.0941819549,
0.2169672251,
0.5108602643,
0.0310200118,
0.1150990799,
0.4365124106,
0.6133583784,
-0.1806054413,
0.4823738635,
-0.1863745898,
-0.5239588022,
-0.260771811,
-1.1624177694,
-0.9695631266,
-0.5492016077,
-0.4465280473,
-0.1032953337,
-0.1279432774,
0.942222178,
0.4697886705,
-0.8030753136,
0.4713133276,
0.2027609646,
0.2311159819,
-0.3802931011,
-0.2434881777,
0.2965475023,
-0.6230891943,
-0.456448555,
0.554628849,
0.2838903964,
0.0386254117,
-0.0194461904,
0.2133427113,
0.125874579,
-0.1473478973,
0.5608774424,
0.3276441097,
-0.6191570759,
-0.5055786967,
0.1678260416,
0.055378478,
-0.0093511278,
0.9241673946,
-1.0961818695,
0.4894589186,
0.9058312178,
0.7304002643,
0.0188699644,
0.0826649591,
0.4101363122,
-1.0695875883,
0.2259767652,
0.3879445493,
0.1645032614,
0.3285663724,
-0.5601703525,
0.2057068944,
0.2797451615,
-0.5059074163,
-0.7117229104,
0.1159207076,
-1.3303837776,
0.038892176,
0.8311880231,
-0.1336120516,
-0.0860522017,
-0.1302753687,
-0.444465518,
0.1191477403,
-0.6299213767,
0.52956599,
0.6366588473,
-0.1476321071,
-0.7377441525,
-0.2294487804,
0.7932866216,
0.4658370912,
-0.6521479487,
0.0036240437,
0.4868481755,
0.2754517198,
-0.131781742,
0.4861262441,
0.2502720356,
0.5404384732,
-0.2367221564,
-0.3749808967,
-0.211966157,
-0.4570224285,
-0.8973241448,
0.2202226222,
0.3458001018,
0.0020999853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02761v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02761v3
|
AQuA -- Combining Experts' and Non-Experts' Views To Assess Deliberation Quality in Online Discussions Using LLMs
| 2024-04-03T14:07:02 | 2024-04-17T10:56:48 |
Maike Behrendt, Stefan Sylvius Wagner, Marc Ziegele, Lena Wilms, Anke Stoll, Dominique Heinbach, Stefan Harmeling
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Measuring the quality of contributions in political online discussions is
crucial in deliberation research and computer science. Research has identified
various indicators to assess online discussion quality, and with deep learning
advancements, automating these measures has become feasible. While some studies
focus on analyzing specific quality indicators, a comprehensive quality score
incorporating various deliberative aspects is often preferred. In this work, we
introduce AQuA, an additive score that calculates a unified deliberative
quality score from multiple indices for each discussion post. Unlike other
singular scores, AQuA preserves information on the deliberative aspects present
in comments, enhancing model transparency. We develop adapter models for 20
deliberative indices, and calculate correlation coefficients between experts'
annotations and the perceived deliberativeness by non-experts to weigh the
individual indices into a single deliberative score. We demonstrate that the
AQuA score can be computed easily from pre-trained adapters and aligns well
with annotations on other datasets that have not be seen during training. The
analysis of experts' vs. non-experts' annotations confirms theoretical findings
in the social science literature.
|
[
-0.9134996533,
-0.6936906576,
0.6938716769,
0.0841453522,
-0.6406260729,
0.4915926158,
0.0486208424,
-0.5319705606,
0.5970523357,
0.3053272367,
-0.1995232701,
-0.5085892081,
-0.7060386539,
0.0422202908,
-0.1264607459,
0.8739458919,
0.1955393702,
0.1169468164,
-0.122460641,
-0.2604432702,
-0.4325831532,
-0.1281711012,
-0.3612080216,
-0.2332514226,
0.5340912342,
0.3241666853,
0.6328089237,
0.3447784781,
0.5285490155,
0.4695383608,
-0.0247886255,
0.6349008679,
-0.9241263866,
0.2781746686,
-0.5012973547,
-0.5622650981,
-0.7908931971,
0.3332365751,
0.4538883269,
0.5786903501,
0.0732201934,
0.1434596181,
0.3191941679,
0.8295100331,
-0.8015065789,
0.3963414729,
-0.8280864358,
0.2663396001,
0.4359306097,
-0.685539484,
-0.0825604126,
-0.6880674958,
0.1700629741,
-0.7010359168,
-0.3052502275,
-0.3348387182,
0.3744669259,
0.5488995314,
-0.4987852573,
-0.1284751445,
-0.9083992839,
0.8041653633,
-0.8101072907,
0.0553976372,
0.220674485,
0.002168559,
-0.0335564241,
-0.5037966371,
-0.4247900844,
0.1841499656,
0.1879658252,
0.6629457474,
-0.1205877736,
0.1382206976,
-0.4540727735,
0.531565547,
0.1568361223,
0.0600236543,
-0.2532795072,
0.0047038975,
1.0483329296,
0.2586969733,
-0.2586379647,
0.3097509742,
-0.2353811562,
0.2488042265,
-0.3740689158,
0.034701582,
0.6453693509,
0.2473977357,
-0.1189642325,
0.4792877138,
-0.2894304395,
0.3931711018,
0.5275421143,
0.0475903302,
0.202773124,
-0.4608637094,
-0.003914434,
-0.1669293493,
0.9387909174,
0.7872523665,
0.2674037516,
0.4078011513,
0.0358960181,
-0.2392952442,
0.3418723941,
-0.626170218,
-0.48122859,
0.2093020827,
-0.5750291348,
-0.4403945506,
0.3332017958,
-0.661596477,
-0.7042754292,
-0.6696744561,
0.3299846649,
0.211502403,
-0.4184909463,
-0.2714754641,
-0.0734856352,
0.0164933559,
0.877889514,
-0.0657642111,
0.209699288,
0.7204520702,
0.6329594851,
-0.2950285673,
-0.0218830816,
-0.2646894157,
-0.0216322578,
-0.7175120711,
1.1863671541,
-0.7325018048,
-0.3701936901,
-0.0387542658,
-0.3290533423,
0.0316369087,
-0.3036660552,
0.3253516257,
-0.5720322728,
0.5884981155,
-0.3383615017,
-1.0341212749,
-0.462613374,
0.5276521444,
-0.6553137898,
0.4876763523,
-0.0376685113,
-0.7882526517,
0.3801031411,
-0.8033824563,
-0.1100254282,
0.3253003061,
-0.1621534675,
-0.1236559749,
0.2075005323,
0.075736165,
0.2552512884,
0.0787278786,
0.133612752,
-0.5812869668,
-0.3338949084,
0.7981107235,
-0.4044856131,
0.3518682718,
0.0854394287,
-0.1484100372,
0.5475106239,
-0.4350757003,
0.375887692,
-0.515873909,
-0.633066535,
-0.21752505,
0.2058466524,
-0.3789529204,
0.1169420108,
0.2446218133,
-0.4714601934,
-0.0312284529,
-0.3332771659,
0.551343143,
0.8075044155,
0.6174268723,
0.3439221084,
-0.3649214208,
0.1147491783,
0.0945446864,
0.4020589292,
0.0255768839,
-0.6172178984,
-0.9368701577,
-0.3589845002,
0.3744591773,
0.5516697168,
-0.480441153,
0.5963537097,
-0.3463217914,
-0.7861173749,
-0.8441895843,
0.075805217,
0.0918796882,
-0.0026245697,
0.3596037328,
-0.4602603614,
-0.1107679382,
-0.6712477207,
-0.4196253717,
-0.5266967416,
0.0545851626,
0.428455621,
0.4305643737,
-0.0278082322,
0.8280521035,
-0.2602744997,
-0.4377012253,
0.0288215894,
0.3784884512,
-0.0104385894,
0.2125381529,
0.1439087838,
-0.4442895055,
-0.677801013,
-0.1120491475,
-0.5449506044,
0.1237888485,
0.0249851774,
-0.064824298,
0.2233686,
0.2182378173,
-0.2991263866,
0.3935129046,
0.4757786095,
-0.1681366563,
0.0542040393,
-0.2406052351,
0.8121654987,
-0.8299412131,
-0.0695542097,
0.0396561958,
-0.3790663779,
-0.4584611952,
0.0233840235,
-0.3675328195,
0.3622326553,
-0.4111162722,
0.1067219898,
-0.1337743551,
0.3427700996,
-0.4350463152,
0.3925658464,
0.0856172368,
0.3309769034,
-0.0199325476,
0.4379851222,
0.103551589,
-0.5204410553,
0.4247762561,
0.1552392542,
-0.4032851756,
0.6524391174,
-0.5438501835,
0.5348479152,
0.0094345016,
0.1739863306,
-1.2592337132,
-0.1599788964,
0.0313452557,
-0.4647522569,
0.0780775547,
-0.2507763505,
-0.1366354972,
0.0397160202,
-0.8399675488,
0.1900514811,
0.0848217234,
0.0083402311,
0.7380800247,
1.1155179739,
-0.2503992319,
-0.4429407418,
-0.5788760781,
0.1715880483,
-0.059298262,
-0.3377380371,
0.2999661863,
-0.130349651,
-0.3818764985,
0.2078486532,
0.0844682008,
-0.1785562336,
0.1330566108,
0.2581799626,
0.1557089984,
-0.1746917665,
-0.2698836327,
0.0722810403,
-0.0810075849,
0.290309757,
0.1190372854,
0.1493970156,
-0.0765117854,
-0.6286068559,
-0.7091419697,
0.466176182,
0.8514307141,
-0.0692104697,
0.608109951,
0.1702041924,
-0.225286603,
-0.0947352648,
-0.8084053993,
-0.0762836486,
-0.4548728764,
0.232037276,
0.0567882806,
-1.0527203083,
0.6681132913,
-0.0439858474,
0.5315007567,
0.4832623005,
0.6377236247,
-0.2015158236,
0.9500988722,
0.6268123984,
-0.0542465374,
0.3454446793,
-0.0156534202,
0.3929817379,
-0.4623817503,
-0.3633820415,
-0.3310354054,
-0.4487799704,
-0.776094079,
-0.486169368,
0.3287796378,
-0.137102142,
-0.4332055151,
-0.3552945554,
-0.5495954752,
0.5585401058,
0.3814665079,
0.2748965919,
0.3438006341,
-0.082943812,
0.2706629634,
-0.141125381,
-0.3542096317,
-0.4814279675,
0.9158109426,
0.4711871147,
0.7726806402,
0.1575999409,
0.555154264,
0.7697229385,
0.6354435682,
-0.9046898484,
0.5292220712,
0.1179367229,
-0.6036295295,
-0.2620389462,
-0.7189731598,
-0.413950175,
0.3130386174,
-0.4657224119,
-0.3542315364,
0.2064796984,
0.1364782453,
-0.6061637402,
0.5027319789,
-0.2248985171,
0.3707505167,
-0.1780439466,
-0.5584533811,
-0.5988034606,
-0.4601979554,
0.201260224,
-0.0656390414,
0.424228251,
-0.3624856472,
-0.3283497691,
0.7855170965,
-0.230862841,
0.9505835176,
-0.4153288007,
-0.1334423572,
0.6496921778,
0.1809681356,
0.0604186952,
-0.0025639937,
-0.0122686764,
0.3848648667,
-0.1442621648,
0.1878686249,
-0.3594489098,
0.8548672795,
-1.1194446087,
-0.8277617693,
-0.2823126912,
-0.3669766784,
-0.1607818007,
-0.1202707365,
-0.2597503066,
-0.1840018481,
-0.1829340905,
0.1954114586,
0.6115165949,
-0.0596392304,
0.0676337779,
0.6127025485,
0.0372727439,
-0.9224860668,
0.6881602407,
0.4776029885,
0.1976032406,
0.4623401165,
0.2971927524,
-0.282910347,
-0.424269855,
-0.0050830781,
-0.0835234225,
-0.9995588064,
-0.6741018295,
-0.4842197895,
-0.3558891416,
0.0452608205,
0.0611038655,
-0.5695719123,
-0.6024982929,
-0.5957658291,
-0.2239931524,
0.3292782605,
0.998996079,
-0.2633344233,
-0.0024584481,
-0.8498684764,
0.0404024087,
0.5385476947,
0.640889585,
0.077991195,
-0.7083341479,
-0.0011235793,
0.2029673606,
-0.5993030667,
-0.9697079659,
0.1921165884,
0.2508764267,
0.6888258457,
0.8715584278,
0.2954055071,
0.8449521661,
-0.0775010735,
0.9057554007,
-0.0356357619,
-0.8091375828,
0.5016092062,
-0.1847217381,
-0.0556362905,
0.894038558,
0.4051553905,
0.0072571472,
-0.7328932881,
-0.2332041413,
-0.7820615172,
0.4028948545,
-0.0094290255,
0.2762176394,
0.078948155,
0.3847645521,
0.2251225412,
0.2218309343,
-0.477914542,
-0.3403265774,
-0.3412095606,
-0.0503918007,
0.2071435153,
-0.4955724478,
-0.2810264528,
-0.308508873,
0.6895248294,
-0.1182094291,
0.1333010048,
0.2718907297,
0.2669607699,
-0.4471221864,
0.2776729167,
0.4009166062,
0.7606235743,
-0.0194729473,
0.1621806622,
0.3692203164,
-0.1847258657,
-0.1125243679,
-0.1719081253,
-0.0628001392,
-0.0459460169,
0.4964860976,
0.4188334048,
0.1914954633,
0.0702072307,
0.4545432031,
-0.2981873155,
-0.3166739643,
-0.239932254,
0.4227233827,
0.2490871102,
0.3188106418,
0.3155451119,
0.3557402194,
0.1458194852,
-0.6017049551,
-0.057517413,
0.5464752316,
-0.79950279,
-0.209017545,
0.5272154808,
0.7406920195,
-0.2537584007,
0.4707120061,
0.1082849577,
-0.6195273995,
0.3107975125,
-0.2494973093,
0.667093575,
-0.4591068625,
-0.0045882068,
0.4268350005,
0.3070315719,
0.2285557836,
0.5086753964,
-0.1128837168,
-0.7192502022,
-0.7100244761,
-0.3112505376,
-0.7642236948,
0.1200285256,
-0.494556874,
-0.0036573072,
-0.4718172252,
-0.6686291695,
0.1248461977,
0.4024423063,
-0.6818846464,
-0.1857482642,
0.2727673948,
0.7484488487,
-0.9526987672,
0.1494778693,
0.6289952993,
-0.2175310403,
-0.2958292663,
-0.2386304587,
-0.1215483844,
-0.4719854891,
0.2855975628,
0.0888615176,
-0.4496544898,
-0.3163655102,
-0.7611083984,
-0.838257134,
0.7633979917,
0.498521775,
-0.5544880629,
0.5246181488,
0.4176073372,
0.6280639768,
-0.4444234669,
0.6727535129,
0.1392997056,
0.6448903084,
-0.2222438008,
-0.8478361368,
-0.1413072199,
-0.4433861375,
-0.4282438159,
-0.200565204,
-0.6454452276,
0.6908389926,
-0.1823983341,
-0.2211147547,
-0.1492236108,
0.7326668501,
0.1656007618,
0.2030038238,
0.501631856,
0.1683081537,
0.7315808535,
-0.0794596896,
0.6976960897,
-0.6753512621,
0.3394391537,
1.1585643291,
-0.3434939981,
0.8527916074,
0.4886945486,
-0.2278003842,
0.4589540362,
0.5736951828,
0.1026540473,
0.3981408179,
0.1695312709,
-0.4038574696,
-0.7212976813,
-0.3565551341,
-0.2390949577,
0.3591930568,
0.6404663324,
-0.3232707977,
0.1585305482,
-0.5016335845,
-0.1218771935,
0.1905566752,
-0.533100307,
1.3274028301,
0.2286000252,
-0.874578476,
-0.0278011262,
-0.1166843772,
0.4046251178,
-0.280960232,
-0.4506842494,
-0.2850171328,
0.1663277745,
-0.5001481771,
-1.5814040899,
0.0786515027,
-0.0678047314,
-0.1038540825,
0.0622360595,
0.4855383635,
-0.2887315452,
-0.4498897791,
0.3056133687,
0.8295516372,
0.2508559227,
-0.0387695991,
-0.6806713343,
0.0380738825,
-0.0249413364,
-0.3962155879,
0.069272548,
0.652541101,
0.2142521143,
0.5894780159,
0.6815620065,
-0.0567886382,
-0.223015964,
0.2172505111,
1.2078261375,
-0.2012702525,
-0.3180710673,
-0.9263170362,
0.5283571482,
-0.3335388303,
-0.3929437101,
0.4965408146,
0.4414686561,
0.7550772429,
0.1144437268,
0.831825316,
0.3392967582,
0.4979043305,
-0.0553371646,
1.0524983406,
-0.2528476417,
0.0543821231,
-0.0561175719,
-0.9018529654,
-0.3961081207,
0.8679234982,
-0.2470532656,
0.0220284965,
0.3075926304,
0.4492186904,
-0.0516632795,
0.2286083698,
0.1374924034,
0.2726505697,
0.4933220744,
0.2803068757,
1.1939810514,
-0.122672908,
0.2945505381,
-0.2020504773,
-0.2306048274,
-0.2326305807,
-1.0096714497,
-1.0628954172,
-0.3293109536,
-0.8348406553,
-0.0640254989,
-0.1908797622,
1.042078495,
0.5929816961,
-0.915625453,
0.0101952478,
0.1521770656,
0.2231079042,
0.138908118,
-0.2686249614,
0.2654874325,
0.0222699288,
-0.3889221847,
0.1803603917,
0.3142903745,
-0.3012830019,
-0.5741841197,
-0.0167585984,
-0.0026968413,
0.4843003154,
0.5738403797,
-0.0626541376,
-0.6055935621,
-0.4586316049,
-0.2978470623,
0.097877048,
0.1458319873,
0.4907492697,
-0.6578637958,
0.5192241073,
0.6433795691,
0.2585948408,
0.2424881756,
0.1760099828,
0.2573506534,
-0.1717786342,
-0.3958308995,
0.3267533779,
0.2838826776,
0.4414636493,
-0.1031965539,
0.3064749241,
-0.0469438471,
-0.7482036352,
-0.4707396924,
-0.0131275589,
-0.8688846231,
-0.1330454797,
0.8462692499,
-0.6182293892,
0.0744522139,
-0.1678232849,
-0.1557535231,
0.3390673399,
-0.6466330886,
1.1423746347,
0.4086510241,
-0.2533811629,
-0.0255399998,
-0.2713875473,
0.0748200342,
-0.2074191868,
-1.0003795624,
-0.0690778419,
0.3955438435,
0.3931944966,
0.3823158741,
0.480250746,
-0.0886620432,
0.0121857012,
-0.1882733852,
-0.2533942759,
-0.3027565777,
-0.2351983786,
-0.0850408152,
0.4849494994,
0.1596022099,
0.0572049543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02717v1
|
Automatic Prompt Selection for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-03T13:20:24 | 2024-04-03T13:20:24 |
Viet-Tung Do, Van-Khanh Hoang, Duy-Hung Nguyen, Shahab Sabahi, Jeff Yang, Hajime Hotta, Minh-Tien Nguyen, Hung Le
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can perform various natural language processing
tasks with suitable instruction prompts. However, designing effective prompts
manually is challenging and time-consuming. Existing methods for automatic
prompt optimization either lack flexibility or efficiency. In this paper, we
propose an effective approach to automatically select the optimal prompt for a
given input from a finite set of synthetic candidate prompts. Our approach
consists of three steps: (1) clustering the training data and generating
candidate prompts for each cluster using an LLM-based prompt generator; (2)
synthesizing a dataset of input-prompt-output tuples for training a prompt
evaluator to rank the prompts based on their relevance to the input; (3) using
the prompt evaluator to select the best prompt for a new input at test time.
Our approach balances prompt generality-specificity and eliminates the need for
resource-intensive training and inference. It demonstrates competitive
performance on zero-shot question-answering datasets: GSM8K, MultiArith, and
AQuA.
|
[
-0.5947697759,
-0.8848102093,
0.9583745599,
0.2761644125,
-0.394138664,
0.0451412536,
-0.337654978,
0.0372149535,
0.0718662962,
0.1980458498,
-0.7804551721,
-0.371388793,
-0.2173059583,
0.7680999041,
0.0016293378,
0.7839825153,
-0.0122297369,
-0.0198913347,
-0.1690697968,
0.0555166565,
-0.7574730515,
-0.1110138074,
-0.9168176055,
-0.1470435262,
0.7261910439,
0.4649482071,
0.2365122139,
0.7407989502,
-0.0527387895,
0.3585799932,
-0.1358176172,
0.3523175418,
-0.1410694867,
0.6187337637,
-0.0512164719,
-0.1905252188,
-0.00242633,
0.0002920092,
0.7193235159,
0.4255296886,
0.2162136286,
0.2677277029,
-0.1139436588,
0.2176882327,
-0.5191696882,
-0.0015767431,
-0.7371141315,
0.0583873987,
0.0870003477,
-0.2591013312,
-0.5076776147,
-0.7758280635,
0.1242045984,
-0.5055028796,
0.1491857767,
0.2099217176,
0.3585901856,
0.2111176997,
-0.3133691847,
-0.2949074209,
-0.4639292359,
0.840744853,
-0.4785745144,
0.1243022978,
0.2243864983,
0.5627118945,
-0.2259566337,
-0.2020650506,
-0.3940447569,
-0.4799231589,
0.0333904326,
0.0706160963,
-0.0457902029,
0.1790041625,
0.2995643318,
0.0896923691,
-0.9583828449,
0.3400751352,
-0.0360109843,
-0.1533639282,
0.5120862722,
0.2992681265,
0.3540018797,
-0.1733563244,
0.0581937283,
-0.1079816073,
-0.5737281442,
0.1974081844,
0.2934718728,
0.6171452403,
0.0909856036,
0.5318843126,
-0.2935734689,
1.0584216118,
0.3881260753,
-0.2357434183,
0.0329902694,
-0.0947968215,
-0.0380999297,
0.0736633539,
0.9128621817,
0.1475706995,
0.0689566433,
-0.1268534511,
-0.444955796,
-0.0852610022,
-0.0552869551,
-0.7031210661,
0.1891170591,
0.3805994391,
-0.0365003049,
-0.3603952229,
-0.1478360742,
-0.8743330836,
-0.2675600052,
-0.430935055,
0.2727503181,
-0.0112807536,
0.2227926701,
-0.1948144585,
-0.0960907191,
0.0316070132,
0.189717263,
-1.0702605247,
-0.1112483516,
0.3499898911,
0.7350157499,
-0.3394340575,
-0.0990480781,
-1.1264613867,
-0.0299521182,
-0.448854804,
0.9157394767,
-0.8232389688,
-0.6142007113,
0.0172167774,
-0.0955577791,
-0.2245069146,
-0.4446621835,
0.5346009731,
-0.5792702436,
0.4681642354,
-0.1637248695,
-0.4410866797,
0.177082032,
0.2004972845,
-0.6577947736,
0.951510787,
0.1091852412,
-0.313069433,
0.2191529423,
-0.6769515872,
-0.4220354855,
0.1409144402,
-0.1108152121,
-0.1025032103,
0.1625596732,
0.6336877346,
0.449832201,
-0.5420251489,
0.4295242429,
-0.101297617,
-0.3357084095,
0.1163158566,
-0.3254645765,
0.6647865772,
0.3282646835,
-0.1970640421,
0.3780699074,
-0.7501649857,
0.0961784273,
0.1681461483,
-0.5359022021,
-0.0269988254,
-0.2915176749,
-0.2688593268,
-0.0046681473,
0.2156296521,
-0.5420953035,
0.3527781963,
-0.5483649373,
0.3054872453,
0.8191834092,
0.172083959,
0.5484926105,
-0.1831868887,
0.8920625448,
-0.4111644924,
0.1962431222,
-0.2655099034,
-0.2238539755,
-0.4532403648,
-0.3485784233,
0.2777404487,
0.8200476766,
-0.7764797211,
0.8840447068,
0.1004603952,
-0.4194358885,
-0.4381114542,
0.0135879684,
0.188469857,
0.5638290644,
0.2834123671,
0.3852381706,
-0.4054509103,
-0.8898706436,
-0.0854751989,
-0.1474612355,
-0.1123421416,
0.3121408224,
-0.0009399916,
-0.0782959387,
1.1413084269,
-0.6832492948,
0.0757782683,
-0.5507155657,
0.0338638015,
0.5666252971,
0.1209901571,
0.488402456,
-0.465639025,
-0.6990757585,
-0.1236910522,
-0.4563215077,
-0.668966651,
-0.301294446,
-0.1320756376,
0.1116912663,
0.3802461326,
-0.7171730399,
-0.0479932427,
0.2844280005,
-0.1052045748,
0.6453505158,
-0.1681795716,
0.0869682059,
-1.0734022856,
0.248306185,
0.1034330353,
-0.2130217105,
-0.41966784,
-0.1062977463,
-0.0506224521,
-0.387545228,
-0.2466001958,
1.107924819,
-0.4481182992,
0.1651492864,
-0.0987366438,
0.2159505934,
-0.1022155881,
0.4102593362,
-0.0157875083,
0.8581873775,
0.4601452649,
-0.6881437302,
0.6298039556,
0.3435243368,
-0.2192084342,
0.3702801466,
-0.7846721411,
0.184772864,
-0.3079310954,
0.3637025654,
-1.0677300692,
-0.2017400116,
0.2089584321,
-0.3790036738,
0.1542539299,
-0.0789537802,
-0.3797538877,
-0.4514271021,
-0.3106584847,
0.2596035898,
0.5366279483,
-0.5773432255,
0.5939773917,
0.1670676321,
-0.5850667953,
-0.3685789406,
-0.1156627163,
0.0212693252,
-0.2324908674,
-0.2871349752,
-0.041745726,
-0.4050458968,
-0.1254727244,
-0.3991277218,
0.1377304494,
0.1126687005,
0.1366799325,
0.0560586154,
0.4170467556,
-0.0524431914,
0.1246056855,
0.3655008078,
-0.3525452614,
-0.0790916458,
-0.2484166026,
0.6729463339,
0.0781062394,
-0.1396609396,
-0.3916007876,
0.5947167277,
0.343005687,
-0.3840496838,
0.3791813254,
0.4417976439,
-0.0488648787,
-0.5906042457,
-0.5857333541,
-0.2383536547,
-0.5093325377,
0.202908963,
-0.2562905252,
-0.913379252,
0.2282834351,
0.1739015877,
0.4840172231,
0.2190806866,
0.6331043839,
0.2600502968,
1.3211942911,
0.2288518548,
-0.1911381036,
0.5724929571,
0.0702259541,
0.3047556877,
-0.5142721534,
0.051206626,
-0.6161900759,
-0.1052688807,
-0.2620277107,
-0.0470555238,
0.5588296652,
-0.2953534424,
-0.3284039199,
0.2160027027,
-0.5641146898,
0.7584645152,
0.6208795309,
-0.1489447206,
0.0829093382,
0.0339812078,
-0.5445139408,
0.1916167885,
-0.7192479968,
-0.5985413194,
0.6772530079,
0.095735766,
0.5025171041,
-0.1713454276,
0.6963347197,
0.1085386872,
0.0187032633,
-0.7177938223,
0.7462712526,
0.0412093922,
-0.352599889,
-0.5575293303,
-0.5244047642,
-1.1102011204,
0.1795022041,
-0.2673497796,
-0.5634866357,
-0.123108983,
0.189569056,
-0.9133701921,
-0.0101621039,
-0.5877071619,
0.7054073215,
-0.1105674803,
-0.0002206026,
0.1265654415,
-0.6088618636,
0.0895949006,
-0.2938216925,
0.1380096376,
-0.1302942038,
-0.0104525825,
0.3586726189,
-0.127504617,
0.6632460952,
-0.2391447574,
-0.0840821862,
0.3632862568,
0.191385448,
0.5561583638,
0.127638191,
-0.2123119086,
-0.4057209492,
-0.1460344493,
-0.0289932396,
-0.640165925,
0.5832503438,
-0.5965538621,
-0.6774382591,
-0.2193331718,
-0.4201682508,
-0.4931538403,
0.1983614266,
0.405207634,
0.7317509651,
-0.2567618787,
-0.1300587058,
0.5257515907,
-0.5446615815,
0.7133909464,
0.3633133471,
-0.1570684165,
-0.6325295568,
0.9341571927,
-0.1311918497,
0.195027411,
0.3673120737,
0.5453215241,
-0.5272358656,
-0.4631640017,
-0.8709935546,
0.2922794819,
-0.6351655722,
-0.2325798422,
-0.7584502697,
-0.1710443795,
-0.3718127906,
-0.3291853368,
0.142181173,
-0.2185830623,
-0.491345793,
-0.0305959638,
0.1762104034,
0.4530110359,
0.1062982157,
0.3378621042,
-0.9833413363,
0.4111328423,
0.6685002446,
0.0828388333,
0.0099265529,
-0.5065817833,
0.1004259512,
-0.1979345828,
-0.0502380431,
-0.6114963293,
0.3578744829,
0.2092042416,
0.7437394261,
0.2651235461,
0.2677457929,
0.183294937,
-0.7161324024,
0.7622071505,
0.2144765109,
-0.6702165008,
0.7967790365,
-0.5596720576,
0.7478999496,
0.737264514,
0.2937904,
-0.6257249713,
-0.4570466578,
-0.3103528321,
-0.8226159215,
0.5553169847,
-0.0379443392,
0.1225920841,
-0.3384514749,
0.2287250608,
0.3526236415,
0.2079203576,
-0.4476493895,
-0.1478161365,
0.3837598264,
-0.5667542219,
0.1212913617,
-0.2745630741,
-0.0560352877,
-0.132237494,
0.683064878,
-0.4176750481,
0.1788684428,
0.012633183,
-0.0783395022,
-0.3103923202,
0.2441852242,
0.3705735803,
0.7213073373,
0.1116082892,
-0.1567234248,
0.3298760355,
-0.2501552999,
0.4090126753,
0.0246060491,
-0.5084800124,
0.239318341,
0.257153362,
0.9492812753,
-0.0364366919,
-0.8347834945,
0.4202914238,
-0.2284391969,
0.0042281668,
-0.191022709,
0.4894713759,
-0.1846720874,
0.4121047854,
0.3722167015,
-0.278596729,
-0.011764043,
-0.3103879392,
-0.0421498381,
0.5137097239,
0.0460293442,
-0.1280558109,
0.4634106159,
0.3878553212,
-0.4965901971,
0.5220398903,
-0.3458978534,
-0.4847190976,
0.5294462442,
0.4162381589,
1.0538489819,
-0.4619009197,
0.4469868541,
0.6213093996,
-0.0937501118,
-0.1326355487,
0.1377031654,
0.1187046692,
-0.4451186359,
-0.4324567318,
-0.7128056884,
-0.3974118233,
0.1617224813,
-0.3034332097,
0.5390565395,
-0.5654737353,
-0.181096673,
-0.1348458081,
-0.0330964364,
-0.5522294044,
0.239178136,
0.224766627,
0.732998848,
-0.7517002225,
0.3764722943,
0.4973230958,
-0.0917930752,
-0.7378925085,
-0.1876427084,
-0.0133542251,
-0.8808291554,
0.3946630657,
0.1460653991,
0.1470262706,
0.2025403231,
-0.5990711451,
-0.7815133333,
0.8094282746,
0.5311351418,
-0.6860275269,
-0.1390919685,
-0.0245453659,
0.2588040829,
-0.5616192222,
0.4517006576,
0.5664623976,
0.4523104727,
0.4081784487,
-0.9061223865,
0.0359870605,
-0.0807393864,
0.0818585008,
0.1415839344,
-0.5387538075,
0.6617671847,
-0.162936151,
-0.1530591547,
0.2471422404,
0.410954237,
0.6841460466,
-0.0321916826,
0.8127867579,
0.1272953451,
0.8299289942,
0.2150139213,
0.820325613,
-0.2612587214,
-0.0089405086,
0.9060260057,
-0.217801556,
0.5592160225,
0.2982694209,
-0.0118526695,
0.1459671259,
1.0639102459,
-0.2124000639,
0.5623633265,
0.2926625609,
-0.4947910011,
-0.4533955157,
-0.2713159621,
-0.1051346064,
0.1390149444,
-0.003695315,
-0.2014945149,
-0.3544556499,
-0.0561982468,
-0.1402624249,
-0.2071902156,
-0.1934571117,
0.865907371,
0.077249296,
-1.0278277397,
0.5936897993,
-0.0065442789,
0.3936668932,
-0.7687022686,
-0.0040138252,
-0.333157748,
-0.3171551526,
0.0937822238,
-0.5684007406,
-0.1573870778,
0.3194581568,
-0.1624321789,
-0.2854951918,
0.5613520741,
-0.5573982596,
-0.4489351213,
-0.0276344139,
0.4838399291,
0.0907629281,
-0.2110579163,
-0.5329867601,
-0.0396108292,
0.0307718236,
-0.4078017473,
0.2017664909,
0.4786904156,
-0.1142488644,
0.6068235636,
0.7652459145,
0.3414665759,
-0.1550999135,
0.1221563369,
0.9321501255,
-0.5907306671,
-0.786437571,
-0.9384791255,
0.4735937119,
-0.1235945374,
-0.4277488291,
0.3788159192,
0.4176529944,
0.2062474191,
0.0075907116,
1.0441687107,
0.1219158769,
0.611174047,
-0.5789459348,
0.3311661482,
-0.3633358479,
0.1812913567,
-0.0611389801,
-1.4186770916,
-0.2064665407,
0.6362183094,
-0.357826978,
-0.0597713254,
0.6167057157,
0.8346963525,
0.210027948,
0.0695182905,
0.2367243469,
-0.110907644,
0.354085803,
0.5836303234,
0.8421730399,
0.1712685078,
0.4001895487,
0.1641313732,
-0.2503484488,
-0.27037853,
-0.9233252406,
-1.1165070534,
-0.5177771449,
-0.0960395262,
0.018570086,
-0.1573138088,
1.6333901882,
0.4023830891,
-0.7237656713,
-0.2400520444,
0.2624181807,
0.1378828436,
0.2283015698,
-0.1516808867,
0.298366338,
-0.7337153554,
-0.7595676184,
0.7694167495,
0.2026927918,
0.1753862202,
-0.2559333146,
0.1784884036,
0.0276717469,
0.1842475533,
0.6266150475,
0.2045757622,
-0.5294201374,
-0.2187447697,
0.2369288206,
-0.163825959,
-0.1026501432,
0.741333127,
-0.6587412357,
0.3412961066,
0.6037356853,
0.9159662127,
0.067296207,
0.1027435884,
0.9287282825,
-0.773614943,
-0.0443632156,
0.4602007866,
0.1880127341,
0.2702539265,
-0.4402368665,
0.3412800133,
0.0409043357,
-0.6006388068,
-0.8217568398,
0.0295955371,
-0.8211826682,
-0.3764269054,
1.568123579,
0.1616947204,
-0.3730382621,
-0.0165839251,
-0.5360846519,
0.1405837834,
-0.7154470682,
0.6066343188,
0.6489780545,
-0.146061182,
-0.1771811545,
-0.5023349524,
0.4970944226,
0.2074777931,
-0.7828333378,
0.1415301263,
0.7071146965,
0.1450468749,
-0.2108255923,
0.3547706306,
0.3818949759,
0.0821843296,
-0.4210458398,
-0.1970905811,
-0.1498714536,
-0.3847402334,
-0.5818873048,
0.1965010315,
0.063761279,
-0.1010705531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.02710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.02710v1
|
ART: The Alternating Reading Task Corpus for Speech Entrainment and Imitation
| 2024-04-03T13:08:26 | 2024-04-03T13:08:26 |
Zheng Yuan, Dorina de Jong, Štefan Beňuš, Noël Nguyen, Ruitao Feng, Róbert Sabo, Luciano Fadiga, Alessandro D`Ausilio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
We introduce the Alternating Reading Task (ART) Corpus, a collection of
dyadic sentence reading for studying the entrainment and imitation behaviour in
speech communication. The ART corpus features three experimental conditions -
solo reading, alternating reading, and deliberate imitation - as well as three
sub-corpora encompassing French-, Italian-, and Slovak-accented English. This
design allows systematic investigation of speech entrainment in a controlled
and less-spontaneous setting. Alongside detailed transcriptions, it includes
English proficiency scores, demographics, and in-experiment questionnaires for
probing linguistic, personal and interpersonal influences on entrainment. Our
presentation covers its design, collection, annotation processes, initial
analysis, and future research prospects.
|
[
-0.1248971,
-1.2719154358,
0.3197339773,
0.1684577465,
-0.1455113441,
0.3459609747,
-0.0540135689,
-0.7929055691,
0.6469518542,
0.4005915225,
-0.5624737144,
-0.4289737046,
-0.5076099038,
0.3519093692,
-0.6510257721,
0.3737431765,
-0.2681797147,
0.169007048,
-0.1556029469,
-0.1537920982,
-0.5675134659,
-0.348834306,
-0.9158661962,
-0.1476369351,
0.4532594383,
0.5679993033,
0.5338987112,
0.608769238,
0.2515441179,
0.3239763081,
0.3119907975,
0.1453656107,
-0.4213924408,
0.4729875922,
-0.0090373466,
-0.6712920666,
-0.0733709708,
0.3875606656,
0.9513034225,
0.662142694,
-0.0362402648,
-0.0459299199,
0.016920818,
0.7062882781,
-0.5962948203,
0.176193431,
-0.2571183741,
0.0560557656,
-0.5362173915,
-0.1120493114,
-0.637331605,
-0.2029733956,
0.0887467414,
-0.760763824,
0.0604187772,
0.4092743397,
0.5567342043,
0.3800200522,
-0.3704864383,
-0.5201332569,
-0.710932076,
0.4616648257,
-0.2417232096,
0.4515799284,
0.7539107203,
-0.2310948968,
0.2662043273,
-0.8960320354,
-0.8997356892,
-0.3269689381,
-0.2364570051,
0.3928141296,
-0.3281722665,
0.0937925577,
-0.1044285744,
0.269802779,
-0.4317389131,
0.0186320953,
-0.3188651204,
0.1282351911,
0.6515376568,
0.0728776604,
0.8799747229,
0.2653766572,
-0.0072289654,
-0.0318021774,
-0.5312372446,
0.1125796139,
0.8655955195,
0.0006891452,
-0.0822439119,
0.7962835431,
0.1078193858,
0.7722110152,
0.1469399184,
0.2463296056,
0.3477316201,
-0.111425519,
-0.0674276203,
0.2571571469,
0.591005981,
0.0124368407,
0.090622209,
-0.2445364594,
-0.0004748194,
0.2487763911,
0.2756634355,
-0.3069336116,
-0.2040275633,
0.1434248984,
-0.2784573734,
-0.1418768466,
-0.0670015812,
-0.5586434007,
-0.2047813535,
-0.6677987576,
0.6636836529,
-0.8012397885,
-0.2396420836,
0.0853166804,
-0.2530525923,
0.0231472459,
-0.0561369322,
-1.1409161091,
0.5309196711,
0.4078554511,
0.8251494169,
-0.6680095792,
-0.7205466032,
-0.5580242872,
0.0822670907,
-0.5286920071,
0.8812147975,
-0.8297867179,
-0.48379457,
0.1733815819,
0.2803857625,
-0.5051674843,
-0.2514355481,
0.3947339654,
-0.4842505753,
0.2075491101,
0.1333238333,
-0.7926262021,
-0.3137707412,
-0.2779892385,
-0.7712618113,
1.1208990812,
0.0334994048,
-0.6875129342,
0.2517452538,
-0.7049257755,
-0.5250625014,
0.0297451597,
-0.4650274217,
-0.0873516053,
-0.1115449518,
-0.1442469805,
0.0733341947,
0.4678119123,
-0.5023931265,
-0.0323264748,
-0.5836797357,
0.4930512011,
-0.3015913963,
0.9258077145,
0.300088793,
-0.2862184346,
0.0835397542,
-0.703722775,
-0.1137077808,
0.0359273739,
-0.0719755068,
-0.5960081816,
0.0127378749,
0.0698179156,
-0.2021169066,
0.189838022,
-0.9493311644,
0.1989037693,
-0.4892195165,
0.4617888629,
0.3691113591,
0.4426781535,
0.4000343978,
-0.6769267917,
0.6959423423,
-0.0166851077,
-0.1371826231,
0.0614547841,
-0.4462946653,
-0.7553766966,
-0.4442149997,
0.348713398,
0.7482935786,
-1.0342252254,
0.0361200757,
0.2366496176,
-0.338182956,
-1.1281241179,
0.150390923,
0.4707934558,
0.1161475852,
0.3067156076,
-0.3358098269,
-0.587123692,
-0.8852148652,
-0.243180424,
-0.0595994964,
0.3929582238,
-0.1011675298,
0.5040658712,
0.0788512677,
0.6898782849,
-0.2056830972,
-0.3194469512,
-0.3516868949,
0.4468204379,
-0.0515043586,
0.5792711973,
0.6536333561,
-0.4351633489,
-0.7967873812,
-0.4886098206,
-0.2984993458,
-0.2693014145,
-0.2297549546,
-0.5209386349,
0.2709182203,
0.7886900306,
-0.3005256057,
0.5380328298,
0.6409623027,
-0.4665696919,
0.5165120959,
-0.089395754,
0.2960855067,
-0.7623553872,
-0.0513533242,
-0.4491317868,
-0.0919252262,
-0.7906060815,
-0.1628008932,
-0.305634886,
0.1871517748,
-0.5669639111,
0.3562831879,
-0.6749501824,
0.157053113,
-0.4445092082,
0.1571140587,
0.00462237,
0.3386211395,
0.2762451172,
0.8886894584,
0.749622345,
-0.2962511182,
0.0578992404,
0.5654511452,
-0.5287290215,
0.6338260174,
-0.5943216085,
0.7220178246,
-0.4056391716,
-0.1814679503,
-1.3425966501,
-0.0398310944,
0.350205034,
-0.3076039255,
0.4573748112,
0.1932477206,
-0.3800925612,
-0.0410411358,
0.1370726675,
0.3263729513,
0.4292877614,
-0.3373253047,
0.5117721558,
0.5640457869,
-0.3331086338,
-0.560495317,
-0.9190716743,
-0.0762459785,
-0.0950848609,
-0.4209815562,
0.2977327704,
-0.139445737,
-0.6695773602,
0.17882967,
0.1576895565,
-0.0209598579,
-0.2242893577,
0.3268314004,
0.09148103,
0.1033511013,
0.1513733268,
0.0416331477,
0.22380808,
-0.1502468437,
0.0879166573,
0.3876229525,
0.0121478681,
-0.6244319677,
-0.7759013772,
0.8884502053,
0.3078836501,
-0.0124532534,
0.4782124162,
0.5644340515,
-0.0510601215,
-0.2491711974,
-0.4277777672,
0.0144423293,
-0.474655062,
0.1069295928,
-0.5785140395,
-0.4991593659,
0.1875595152,
0.4733590782,
0.2754009366,
0.2284188271,
0.553126514,
-0.4355281889,
0.822583735,
0.7715547681,
0.0543892533,
0.9677990079,
-0.3061965704,
-0.1951486021,
-0.715068996,
0.2756481767,
-0.2929439843,
-0.6701000929,
-0.1596256196,
-0.4382206202,
0.3109531403,
-0.2027975917,
0.0312788896,
0.1375191361,
-0.4251561463,
0.4766397774,
0.8287858367,
0.3798605204,
0.5893765092,
-0.1455969363,
-0.260388881,
-0.1534950584,
-0.4469994009,
-0.5499508381,
0.9865150452,
0.0270996615,
0.5478069782,
0.2795695066,
0.7766187191,
0.4086709917,
0.2658491135,
-0.9132175446,
0.3804167211,
-0.0938121602,
-0.743685782,
-0.437179625,
0.1933348477,
-1.4224414825,
0.1852736026,
-0.0362185091,
-0.6157765985,
0.4674968123,
0.0873073339,
-0.3810614347,
-0.0780535638,
-0.7556447387,
0.7121663094,
-0.0926818177,
-0.5707218051,
-0.4659127593,
-0.6049074531,
0.3645595014,
0.1181521267,
0.2986140251,
-0.0333057344,
-0.2282177806,
0.7678697109,
0.083723329,
1.2678351402,
0.0211420413,
0.079105854,
0.6601249576,
0.383381933,
0.5073075294,
-0.1885185242,
-0.1209878996,
-0.2530991435,
0.3394258618,
-0.2673070729,
-0.4042816162,
0.1471910477,
-0.9389010072,
-0.3861366808,
-0.5331857204,
-0.6025457978,
-0.4614201784,
0.1419495493,
0.3211404383,
0.4933714271,
-0.6071192026,
0.1729905158,
0.4449411035,
0.0209261887,
0.6578429341,
0.9158952236,
-0.0157746822,
-0.3084272742,
0.680424571,
0.199811995,
0.5526863933,
0.4530381262,
-0.0655326024,
-0.4397650361,
-0.6458662748,
-0.3632443249,
0.2033048272,
-0.6106387377,
0.442360431,
-0.6102544665,
-0.0895010903,
-0.4654372633,
0.0441949554,
-0.1813576221,
-0.3809317052,
-0.5020023584,
-0.2296927571,
0.5156117082,
0.9029239416,
-0.3349832296,
0.2604720592,
-0.3329118192,
0.292347312,
0.3903825283,
0.1964309365,
-0.2942325175,
-0.5684292316,
-0.2089610398,
0.087029092,
-0.4433625042,
-1.1378031969,
0.4707548022,
0.6008663774,
0.8780298233,
0.2573897541,
0.1140489876,
0.5481267571,
-0.81612885,
0.8371986151,
0.0888712779,
-0.8696802258,
0.3554905951,
-0.2268117368,
0.085061498,
0.7562568784,
0.583135426,
-0.7944729328,
-0.8572218418,
-0.7421839833,
-0.7827468514,
0.4729829431,
0.2319362164,
0.1110698804,
-0.2936021984,
0.0492101051,
0.3783722818,
0.1614796519,
-0.5428792238,
-0.2669542432,
-0.1429759115,
-0.4231541753,
-0.22313115,
-0.0982110575,
-0.4720869958,
-0.506822288,
0.8174863458,
0.1031742692,
0.4234184325,
0.5118173957,
-0.3775688112,
-0.2376046479,
0.083534807,
0.5702642798,
0.4687044919,
0.0892211795,
0.3423756063,
0.0844457671,
-0.9740688801,
0.1985195577,
-0.1423374712,
-0.1939440519,
0.2466147542,
0.3931903839,
0.9494102597,
0.0688956529,
-0.788205266,
0.3830544055,
0.069419831,
-0.3936552703,
-0.6768202782,
0.0816088021,
0.0109542655,
0.2445810288,
-0.033635661,
-0.1630583853,
0.2337477207,
-0.9239700437,
0.5001479387,
0.2618982792,
-0.4601857066,
-0.2973432243,
0.7251812816,
0.1832220554,
-0.4139327407,
0.4263231754,
-0.3911990225,
0.0331380628,
0.3783481717,
0.6742268205,
0.9557799101,
-0.1405543685,
0.078655079,
0.0007896497,
0.309460938,
0.0768091381,
0.9643708467,
0.0503486842,
-0.8941528797,
-0.3804112375,
-0.4939510226,
-0.8790898919,
-0.0907492861,
-0.8138317466,
0.1240338385,
0.2764688134,
-0.0086084735,
0.1076788381,
-0.2065933347,
-0.6715149879,
-0.3941890895,
0.1960022151,
0.6509836316,
-0.8147810698,
1.1091117859,
0.8476603627,
-0.5737833381,
-0.4566537142,
-0.0906875953,
-0.0035083466,
-1.1949800253,
0.6102709174,
-0.2930748463,
-0.2034060955,
0.5822347999,
-0.4339029491,
-0.9304727316,
0.8240251541,
0.0561766699,
-0.5742538571,
0.2640180588,
0.0997435898,
0.601739347,
-0.403863132,
0.2527515888,
0.9693447948,
0.4669121206,
-0.1679125428,
-0.9088462591,
-0.2917793691,
-0.3765354753,
-0.2498852313,
-0.0807330236,
-0.8039617538,
0.6536098719,
0.0519083105,
-0.4436537921,
0.3753388822,
0.693818748,
-0.0681813136,
0.0468845218,
0.7443816066,
0.5300442576,
0.7675017118,
-0.0087610027,
0.7433645725,
-0.5687439442,
-0.3477862179,
1.2525250912,
-0.2577031255,
1.1499397755,
0.5838578939,
-0.1376591027,
0.7562714219,
0.4934647381,
0.2142808139,
0.6228973866,
0.3481852412,
-0.5300191641,
0.1270041466,
-0.0138050709,
-0.1442406476,
0.7076904774,
0.5978083611,
-0.3878509104,
0.4177357554,
0.453332901,
-0.1918033808,
0.2007316649,
-0.0564185344,
0.7302343249,
0.0765444711,
-0.8597709537,
0.5308647156,
-0.5763385296,
0.4206717908,
-0.4205473959,
-0.0207512919,
0.113647528,
-0.005885534,
0.0624026321,
-0.9909719229,
0.5527384281,
-0.3038181365,
0.198720336,
-0.7181334496,
0.3154504597,
-0.8572050929,
-0.1983424872,
-0.0696546137,
0.6143282652,
0.6309781671,
0.2983292043,
-0.5929716825,
0.1081093624,
-0.2826547623,
-0.367138952,
0.1235461682,
0.381411016,
0.4591978192,
0.1978314817,
0.3041014373,
0.2397913784,
0.2251813263,
0.4092690349,
0.2168419212,
-0.4615261257,
-0.6642352939,
-0.6013678908,
0.516888082,
0.0063702203,
-0.6159508824,
0.7888821959,
0.5481136441,
0.5838066339,
-0.2175246328,
0.8232016563,
-0.1722618043,
0.7035906911,
-0.6842009425,
0.6182518601,
-0.397210896,
-0.3297168911,
-0.2305737883,
-0.4100239873,
0.1869250983,
0.7338850498,
-0.3138272464,
-0.5278962255,
1.243747592,
0.7119376659,
0.1364494115,
0.4529028535,
0.3930396736,
0.2430055141,
-0.1047766656,
0.3163694739,
1.1951583624,
-0.0440810621,
0.3844504952,
-0.4220213294,
-0.2485139817,
-0.0305162761,
-0.6561048031,
-0.8804289699,
-0.8689837456,
-0.4770943224,
-0.2961670458,
0.245440051,
1.0958609581,
0.3997082412,
-0.6140037775,
-0.4545394778,
-0.3517481387,
-0.258491993,
-0.8941064477,
-0.2598736882,
0.3788104057,
-0.6289345026,
-1.4057834148,
0.8454762101,
-0.0444925837,
0.4019165933,
-0.2829733193,
0.348030597,
-0.4790875912,
0.1378040165,
0.5011379719,
0.4678486884,
-0.4675693512,
-0.3265817165,
0.0682225376,
-0.0959429219,
-0.0296211969,
0.7629316449,
-0.3327394128,
0.6672973633,
0.604056716,
0.442754209,
0.7287654281,
-0.0608758852,
0.5450603962,
-0.9128699899,
0.4687591195,
0.5873956084,
0.4165646732,
-0.0530437417,
-0.3492573798,
0.5403140187,
0.5690253377,
-0.5567976236,
-0.797678113,
0.2757874727,
-1.0303717852,
-0.1818654388,
1.2815551758,
0.1709019989,
-0.2777788639,
-0.6208664775,
-0.5985327959,
0.4042995572,
-0.3586244285,
0.7111892104,
1.2262589931,
-0.798961401,
-0.1723871082,
-1.2203696966,
0.6485070586,
0.5442193151,
-0.4708896875,
-0.1741550118,
0.4396857619,
0.2721686363,
0.006267969,
0.8838602304,
0.0269692317,
0.2733812332,
0.482678175,
0.3611607552,
0.0337866172,
-0.2081394494,
-0.125770703,
-0.0231093764,
-0.043110542,
-0.7057644129
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.