id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11996v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11996v3
|
Accelerating Scientific Discovery with Generative Knowledge Extraction, Graph-Based Representation, and Multimodal Intelligent Graph Reasoning
| 2024-03-18T17:30:27 | 2024-06-10T19:06:26 |
Markus J. Buehler
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.soft, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Leveraging generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), we have transformed a
dataset comprising 1,000 scientific papers into an ontological knowledge graph.
Through an in-depth structural analysis, we have calculated node degrees,
identified communities and connectivities, and evaluated clustering
coefficients and betweenness centrality of pivotal nodes, uncovering
fascinating knowledge architectures. The graph has an inherently scale-free
nature, is highly connected, and can be used for graph reasoning by taking
advantage of transitive and isomorphic properties that reveal unprecedented
interdisciplinary relationships that can be used to answer queries, identify
gaps in knowledge, propose never-before-seen material designs, and predict
material behaviors. We compute deep node embeddings for combinatorial node
similarity ranking for use in a path sampling strategy links dissimilar
concepts that have previously not been related. One comparison revealed
structural parallels between biological materials and Beethoven's 9th Symphony,
highlighting shared patterns of complexity through isomorphic mapping. In
another example, the algorithm proposed a hierarchical mycelium-based composite
based on integrating path sampling with principles extracted from Kandinsky's
'Composition VII' painting. The resulting material integrates an innovative set
of concepts that include a balance of chaos/order, adjustable porosity,
mechanical strength, and complex patterned chemical functionalization. We
uncover other isomorphisms across science, technology and art, revealing a
nuanced ontology of immanence that reveal a context-dependent heterarchical
interplay of constituents. Graph-based generative AI achieves a far higher
degree of novelty, explorative capacity, and technical detail, than
conventional approaches and establishes a widely useful framework for
innovation by revealing hidden connections.
|
[
-0.3541761041,
-0.7373045087,
0.9022023678,
0.0199196767,
0.1173235849,
0.6894806027,
0.0849898607,
-0.5024591684,
0.2884963751,
0.1691286117,
-0.469396621,
-0.6588528752,
-0.6603679061,
0.1476651579,
-0.291151762,
0.619666338,
0.1162958816,
-0.0899913609,
-0.7022665739,
-0.161458388,
0.076078929,
0.1936799586,
-0.1752475947,
-0.5373669863,
0.6543830633,
0.296443522,
0.5341655612,
0.8944594264,
0.5557402372,
0.3617809117,
-0.1372176111,
0.4296503365,
-0.2810141444,
-0.1121654883,
-0.1412595063,
-0.5807644725,
-0.2363314033,
0.0295871031,
0.4852337241,
0.7936413288,
0.3022161722,
0.0737348795,
-0.1992367357,
0.6287027597,
-0.2691639662,
0.736862123,
-0.5008227825,
0.3606528342,
-0.3699931204,
-0.4134506881,
-0.1894100904,
-0.3322798014,
-0.0949571803,
-0.9739165902,
0.2407830656,
0.1180475652,
0.6336216927,
0.326600194,
-0.2553905845,
-0.1093477234,
-0.6765362024,
0.420737952,
-0.1589548588,
0.3220611513,
0.0256526042,
0.3991981447,
-0.1993070543,
-1.0861004591,
-0.7157770991,
-0.2657540441,
0.0484404601,
0.3874372542,
0.0149069792,
0.1011966616,
0.2669973075,
0.3172151446,
-0.7808445692,
-0.0343066081,
-0.4500301182,
-0.3033612967,
0.5093078017,
-0.0138472328,
0.5885380507,
-0.154044807,
-0.2395084798,
-0.312715441,
-0.7633091807,
-0.0591965243,
0.0982721969,
0.1659935415,
0.2187177092,
0.7718674541,
-0.1415813714,
0.4226411879,
-0.2648053467,
0.0260893051,
0.232967183,
-0.4624799192,
0.2479590923,
0.0668693334,
0.9454836249,
0.0528943017,
-0.152193889,
-0.435347259,
0.2357959747,
0.1647054553,
0.0146601414,
-0.68712008,
-0.4136395454,
-0.000819382,
-0.510725379,
-0.2209294289,
0.1599518508,
-0.6949185729,
-0.5424007773,
-0.1229804978,
0.3731950223,
-0.5755888224,
-0.2601661682,
-0.1864445657,
-0.6063780189,
-0.3053594232,
0.4721049368,
-0.7513461113,
-0.0017490218,
0.7427785397,
1.1001397371,
0.0936631039,
-0.2980324924,
0.1555045694,
0.3565170765,
-0.4700073302,
0.8834983706,
-0.6097790003,
-0.4708096385,
-0.5390336514,
-0.0970181972,
0.1196001545,
-0.5511174798,
0.3314752877,
-0.6439109445,
-0.0618418865,
-0.1868256629,
-0.4434989989,
-0.4323276877,
0.0456831977,
-0.8276886344,
0.7287541032,
0.4193637371,
-0.6828692555,
0.3792043626,
-1.1114280224,
-0.2958852351,
0.4830544591,
-0.4760759175,
-0.2905252576,
0.0054403734,
-0.0978556722,
-0.0155303432,
-0.4464250505,
0.1427675784,
-0.5617414117,
-0.0778151825,
0.0530193858,
0.1103055999,
0.7483412623,
0.3159910142,
-0.1878181547,
0.2364037931,
-0.9024506211,
0.0530946925,
0.1564946771,
-0.0598644391,
-0.3287463188,
-0.0872742757,
-0.2061054558,
0.1560028791,
0.1847699583,
-0.8741316795,
0.4388732016,
-0.3225247264,
0.9588275552,
0.7557149529,
-0.0717581958,
0.4161605537,
-0.3811835051,
0.278288722,
-0.113061741,
-0.0863503367,
-0.2353141904,
-0.6328287721,
-0.4100431502,
-0.1612174213,
0.2393832952,
0.3830691874,
-0.7453756332,
0.4431313574,
-0.5172079802,
-0.7836116552,
-0.3695053458,
0.0773817971,
0.2057374716,
0.6597855687,
0.4363756776,
-0.4233800173,
-0.4369734824,
-0.5905098319,
0.1213267669,
-0.2255450189,
0.0355517901,
0.351652801,
0.5662687421,
-0.4320043027,
1.0959806442,
-0.7423298359,
-0.1940089315,
0.3106659651,
0.4494344592,
0.2534375191,
0.5118066669,
0.3407250047,
-0.8425261378,
-0.442076236,
0.4777623713,
-1.2467491627,
0.1471976489,
0.1465634406,
-0.1728020757,
-0.3129708469,
0.7783870101,
-0.6679641604,
0.2668899,
0.1110575795,
-0.2231119126,
0.3869921565,
-0.1184237972,
0.1766530871,
-0.7892953157,
0.0945564732,
-0.2899109125,
0.3105750382,
-0.3359425664,
-0.0159823429,
-0.237833634,
-0.3140006363,
0.0727662668,
0.4114893675,
-0.4324887991,
-0.1736276001,
-0.2247073352,
-0.1954206824,
0.2445632517,
0.2015030384,
-0.2052566558,
0.6517887712,
0.4630048275,
-0.286668092,
0.5208929181,
0.4717668891,
-0.4209490418,
0.1189141348,
-0.5763254166,
0.2511099577,
-0.3786734939,
0.2144942582,
-0.8953884244,
-0.0630928427,
0.2130060792,
-0.6363947988,
0.2298792899,
-0.0029763856,
-0.732347548,
-0.4384157658,
-0.0514785908,
0.6119841933,
0.140928939,
-0.3726884723,
0.9390932918,
0.1379063576,
-0.487771064,
-0.1705899835,
-0.3429920077,
0.2002323121,
-0.0512546264,
-0.9513684511,
0.7592164874,
-0.3293234706,
-0.363738209,
0.3458365798,
-0.0978427529,
0.1448754072,
0.1821093857,
0.3176273406,
0.1268260926,
-0.1758479178,
0.4511485398,
0.1730341762,
-0.1954970658,
0.1153482944,
-0.7052452564,
0.5726181865,
-0.2149012983,
-0.478749752,
-0.2046121359,
0.3668317795,
0.9400544763,
-0.1051095426,
0.425185293,
0.6911272407,
-0.3135828376,
0.0372049436,
-0.0398276448,
-0.3460960686,
-0.4363220334,
0.3646219969,
-0.5166972876,
-0.7391948104,
0.5724701285,
-0.4835062921,
-0.0126242349,
0.652281642,
0.210947454,
-0.2558951378,
1.1274379492,
0.4749962091,
0.1748335063,
0.4423125088,
-0.6865261197,
0.3873158097,
-0.6695849895,
-0.6995523572,
-0.5160249472,
-0.2077879161,
-0.6343444586,
-0.6158845425,
0.8206086755,
0.1378843188,
-0.3681319356,
0.0391882695,
-0.6690214276,
0.2938179374,
0.7715770006,
0.2482059896,
0.4986741543,
0.1044300497,
-0.1196849346,
0.2814126015,
-0.8000110984,
-0.3953760564,
1.1612819433,
-0.0303131826,
0.6964797378,
-0.0882388502,
0.6104007363,
0.556135118,
0.3478222191,
-0.7213892937,
0.4247444868,
-0.0996621475,
-0.4077016115,
-0.4164401293,
-0.5269522667,
-0.9823360443,
0.0012242495,
-0.3928283751,
-0.5030357242,
0.2331547141,
0.0393720753,
-0.1928225309,
0.3631283641,
-0.6392940879,
0.5746033192,
-0.3042083681,
-0.2761351466,
-0.4797078967,
-0.8975350857,
0.2155238241,
-0.0135726491,
0.4009614885,
-0.0138448458,
0.3281880617,
0.6455509067,
-0.2088993937,
0.626518786,
0.0950034112,
0.175199151,
0.4755126834,
0.0487550795,
0.2139289975,
0.0221380908,
-0.0161644127,
0.2554548383,
-0.1007064804,
-0.4394187033,
-0.9157510996,
0.6014733911,
-0.966073513,
-0.7132406831,
-0.098122783,
-0.8925917745,
-0.0441615097,
0.4791032672,
0.3395017087,
0.3086732924,
-0.1676685363,
0.2429873049,
0.6048349738,
0.0631835982,
0.199391976,
0.04997655,
-0.0047465642,
-0.3410952687,
1.3742192984,
0.3776132464,
0.0379653648,
0.6898574829,
0.4263123572,
-0.2865705788,
-0.6004599333,
-0.4153191149,
0.1097843647,
-0.662799418,
-0.2193827778,
-0.791705966,
-0.2676407099,
-0.6058315635,
-0.0824151412,
-0.1348075718,
-0.7682126164,
-0.3194462061,
-0.321777463,
0.3376895785,
0.8812260628,
-0.2790463269,
-0.1241816357,
-0.7393798828,
0.2614579499,
0.355042547,
0.1464056224,
0.0988855362,
0.1332083344,
-0.2966333628,
-0.0679940656,
-0.4569910765,
-0.5793069601,
0.1149199456,
0.3100111187,
0.6236920953,
0.717668891,
-0.1302619874,
0.3113028407,
-0.3919208348,
0.3536260426,
0.1909686476,
-0.5120730996,
0.6216620207,
-0.4322809875,
-0.0605387166,
0.2635116875,
0.6326622963,
-0.1564469635,
-0.0403769687,
-0.9081096649,
-0.8293877244,
0.206751585,
-0.0169146433,
-0.3218695521,
0.1684629172,
0.2506364584,
0.299603045,
0.1682485789,
-0.5250553489,
-0.0093868626,
-0.6607396603,
-0.2863232791,
-0.010496038,
0.2552527785,
-0.7552505136,
-0.3746239841,
0.4539320171,
-0.4421956241,
0.3696241677,
0.1191168204,
0.0933400467,
0.050946746,
-0.0408629254,
0.3779073954,
0.6475234032,
-0.1086644083,
0.3086785078,
-0.281600982,
-0.4476715028,
0.0389894918,
0.4381272197,
-0.4177803993,
-0.330734998,
0.5379167795,
0.6807618141,
-0.5631945729,
-0.7299697995,
-0.0987929553,
0.1974110007,
-0.2636954486,
-0.0081290267,
0.0813909397,
0.0169507377,
0.5170812607,
0.5024198294,
0.3491000235,
0.2988852859,
-0.8452990055,
0.0503931008,
0.4974787533,
-0.4142300487,
-0.5173872709,
0.5897938013,
-0.038847737,
-0.1996046454,
0.6139448881,
-0.2821572721,
-0.3808689415,
0.9445132017,
0.4399317205,
0.5890187025,
0.1167202145,
0.2962884009,
0.2004935443,
0.1086537391,
0.3678169847,
0.0031044646,
-0.3443117142,
-0.8652029634,
0.0534943305,
-0.5044488907,
-0.3113764822,
-0.2929706275,
-0.1522888839,
-0.0800181776,
-0.6358907223,
-0.0316763669,
0.374722898,
0.0133804251,
-0.3426567614,
0.0424702801,
-0.2528254986,
0.7984098792,
-1.103633523,
0.4430637062,
0.6752167344,
-0.6027116179,
-0.5487597585,
-0.4170185924,
0.1648938954,
-0.9769312143,
0.8551962376,
0.0928397849,
-0.1097353473,
0.2895645499,
-0.7229007483,
-1.031835556,
1.5187791586,
0.2414429635,
-0.2718935311,
0.1164024845,
-0.1418509036,
0.6267709136,
-0.3617559075,
0.2767816186,
0.3048712015,
0.6456243992,
0.4779922962,
-0.2479019612,
0.0563875102,
-0.6591451168,
-0.1742992103,
0.2226461917,
-0.7612700462,
0.9000285864,
-0.3632989526,
-0.4989198148,
0.1080479249,
0.774191618,
0.3525643349,
0.5629815459,
0.4079600573,
0.8843340278,
0.9527933598,
-0.2564437091,
0.7884970307,
-0.3049253523,
0.0642208457,
0.5835665464,
-0.1776748002,
0.133419022,
0.4571763575,
-0.2439864576,
1.0597628355,
0.5795307755,
-0.2987889051,
0.5804520845,
0.311852634,
-0.4652746916,
-0.077774182,
-0.7038426995,
-0.5163536668,
0.3617508709,
0.5977563858,
-0.2240092158,
-0.1281188577,
0.1967600435,
-0.1401835829,
0.1564940363,
-0.2182651758,
0.7093429565,
-0.0562107787,
-0.579430759,
0.1052935869,
-0.2825230658,
0.2234261334,
-0.5150856376,
-0.5005218387,
0.0704117566,
-0.1679120809,
-0.2539325356,
-0.7863999009,
0.1409157664,
-0.7211488485,
-0.5081009865,
-0.2094898224,
0.6230226755,
-0.1549113989,
-0.4192257822,
0.1993935853,
0.501414299,
-0.1290663481,
0.160255596,
-0.2681713998,
-0.0816011056,
-0.2541254461,
0.1480039805,
0.2289776951,
0.686743319,
-0.3031166196,
0.8615009189,
0.9343516827,
0.0021868844,
-0.0600235276,
0.015676517,
1.1852859259,
-0.6781525016,
-0.3251824677,
-0.5105803013,
0.2358327359,
-0.1710112542,
-0.0121337399,
0.5729961991,
0.6969617605,
0.8034418225,
-0.0457112901,
0.998521924,
-0.2820272148,
0.1296555549,
-0.4869503677,
0.6758700013,
-0.4695723653,
0.0874135047,
-0.2736265957,
-0.5461230278,
-0.3219050169,
0.3604457378,
-0.0308304373,
-0.0246203896,
0.6416187286,
0.7313677073,
0.1570415497,
0.1576239169,
-0.0604833439,
0.4482360482,
0.5725777745,
0.272592783,
0.8915398717,
-0.0008416871,
0.5636565685,
-0.0822183117,
-0.5501734614,
-0.0401815884,
-0.6435080171,
-0.4887013733,
-0.7724217772,
-0.2052635103,
-0.2912245393,
-0.0686422139,
0.5154274106,
0.663182795,
-0.5101496577,
-0.0308258273,
-0.685051918,
0.3898715675,
-0.2358047962,
-0.2707193494,
0.5926235318,
-0.1343334615,
-0.5134555697,
0.6699665785,
0.6734828949,
0.2366852164,
-0.3061816692,
0.038723316,
-0.0867805928,
-0.2224815041,
0.6714933515,
0.6238657236,
-0.3912498951,
-0.0989494026,
0.1521206647,
0.1701170206,
0.2660199106,
0.7494382262,
-0.6801344752,
0.7841685414,
1.0070397854,
0.6379722357,
0.7727355361,
-0.0270787589,
0.4274718165,
-0.3681850731,
0.0068300511,
0.540643394,
0.3111879826,
0.2515175641,
-0.3426564634,
0.6364116669,
0.8328891397,
-0.4821542799,
-0.5449043512,
0.4770540297,
-1.1452986002,
-0.5227258205,
0.3449680507,
-0.1097898558,
-0.1928020567,
-0.1751062274,
0.003308129,
0.3330236971,
-0.2212412208,
1.2311143875,
0.490252763,
-0.6530004144,
-0.2079130411,
-0.0844262689,
0.3724003136,
0.0882829949,
-1.0334004164,
-0.4043636918,
0.2658820748,
-0.0071850903,
0.966840446,
0.465765506,
-0.3165558577,
0.1436150223,
0.2241290361,
-0.0466192812,
-0.4567813575,
-0.695479095,
0.3140667975,
0.4019613564,
0.0528300405,
0.1254860163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11984v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11984v1
|
Using Generative Text Models to Create Qualitative Codebooks for Student Evaluations of Teaching
| 2024-03-18T17:21:35 | 2024-03-18T17:21:35 |
Andrew Katz, Mitchell Gerhardt, Michelle Soledad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Feedback is a critical aspect of improvement. Unfortunately, when there is a
lot of feedback from multiple sources, it can be difficult to distill the
information into actionable insights. Consider student evaluations of teaching
(SETs), which are important sources of feedback for educators. They can give
instructors insights into what worked during a semester. A collection of SETs
can also be useful to administrators as signals for courses or entire programs.
However, on a large scale as in high-enrollment courses or administrative
records over several years, the volume of SETs can render them difficult to
analyze. In this paper, we discuss a novel method for analyzing SETs using
natural language processing (NLP) and large language models (LLMs). We
demonstrate the method by applying it to a corpus of 5,000 SETs from a large
public university. We show that the method can be used to extract, embed,
cluster, and summarize the SETs to identify the themes they express. More
generally, this work illustrates how to use the combination of NLP techniques
and LLMs to generate a codebook for SETs. We conclude by discussing the
implications of this method for analyzing SETs and other types of student
writing in teaching and research settings.
|
[
-0.3261109591,
-0.5936481357,
0.234728083,
-0.0038466554,
-0.1265507489,
0.3694347143,
-0.5966348648,
-0.1107875034,
0.0067523597,
0.5253106952,
-0.2013447583,
-0.6670356989,
-0.331589222,
0.3222561777,
-0.8727862835,
1.2361872196,
0.018958034,
0.2431477457,
-0.4883084893,
-0.1797216982,
-0.7522976995,
-0.46452263,
-0.3126043975,
-0.45237571,
0.1780985743,
0.3448036909,
0.5369796753,
0.2519994974,
0.6317905188,
0.3005535305,
-0.009265786,
0.1345594078,
-0.3032380939,
0.0434809774,
-0.2379899323,
-0.4015395939,
-0.0278902985,
-0.0549956262,
1.0863115788,
0.8514939547,
-0.0958093405,
0.2258796841,
0.233672753,
0.5075827837,
-0.5384636521,
0.0036126699,
-0.2027179152,
0.3094944656,
0.0486181118,
-0.3456339836,
-0.7639463544,
-0.7674734592,
0.156400457,
-0.4282664359,
0.3373856246,
-0.4949324727,
0.5687305927,
-0.0290571228,
-0.1973181963,
-0.448004663,
-0.6935932636,
1.0381581783,
-0.91849792,
-0.0077067367,
0.3629766703,
0.0814237595,
-0.1637541503,
-0.5110185146,
-0.4814685881,
-0.2144037038,
-0.0822698548,
0.3068871796,
0.1798939854,
-0.1714333594,
0.3034892082,
0.7758331895,
-0.2838903368,
0.1743931919,
-0.345974952,
0.1779679358,
0.6311640739,
0.2792782187,
0.4569004178,
-0.4513601065,
-0.1917120367,
-0.2339866608,
-0.4747442901,
-0.0042628963,
0.3436264396,
0.344735831,
-0.0133810844,
0.6084649563,
0.0690541193,
1.0170693398,
-0.4005100429,
-0.2182038277,
-0.0944864973,
-0.3603930771,
-0.1286781728,
-0.164063856,
0.7110542655,
0.3534087539,
0.2246082574,
-0.2585661113,
-0.3645862937,
0.4312471449,
0.4511637986,
-0.6483358741,
-0.3157359064,
0.2186390162,
-0.5217815638,
-0.5497211814,
0.1614771485,
-1.0602184534,
-0.4723618031,
-0.8117517829,
0.2329394519,
-0.4637730718,
-0.3625442088,
0.0359616876,
-0.1632715464,
0.1804734915,
0.3283902705,
-0.9086443186,
0.3828772902,
0.6162139177,
0.7386432886,
-0.2060201168,
-0.3255755901,
-0.3465558887,
-0.0203432776,
-0.50241822,
0.878888607,
-0.9274744391,
-0.6944576502,
0.577157855,
-0.1964789629,
0.1239253357,
-0.6311075091,
0.2956058085,
-0.3218273222,
0.2744753361,
-0.1548929214,
-0.9881858826,
0.2300818861,
0.3508468866,
-0.6942101717,
1.3211073875,
0.2062888891,
-0.4267828763,
0.0011822723,
-0.5808815956,
-0.3769169152,
0.2223802805,
-0.506673336,
-0.2356776595,
0.2561141849,
0.2940235734,
0.6111450195,
-0.2053131908,
0.3989332318,
0.1868411154,
-0.5273626447,
0.5037561059,
-0.072151877,
0.7036848068,
0.0626724362,
-0.239239797,
0.1690681279,
-0.9047278166,
0.3795483112,
-0.077455312,
-0.6014790535,
-0.5923770666,
-0.0772156194,
0.1290499568,
-0.1776416749,
-0.1052522659,
-0.0488465577,
0.4853043556,
-0.2119452208,
0.3358493447,
0.706415832,
0.1072572917,
0.4370999038,
-0.2923013866,
0.9087069631,
-0.1763557345,
-0.1512310356,
-0.4701107442,
-0.2568350434,
-0.6913007498,
0.0816464573,
0.4246867001,
-0.1636149287,
-0.9960660934,
0.2503493428,
-0.2774147987,
-0.5792706609,
-0.4728244543,
0.2462138683,
0.5847920179,
0.1450840235,
0.1778398007,
-0.3705076277,
-0.300976336,
-0.3792081475,
-0.2503588498,
0.1286537796,
-0.1497051865,
-0.2567166984,
0.5689266324,
0.1105532199,
1.0439238548,
-0.7108210921,
0.0034654704,
-0.1976571679,
0.1092271656,
0.0921149999,
0.5747164488,
0.3645205796,
-0.4879722595,
-0.3089725673,
-0.0246718712,
-0.902369678,
0.0472062752,
-0.3259245753,
-0.3522823751,
-0.1463017762,
0.3487435579,
-0.0521832295,
0.3457022011,
0.4154841006,
-0.3794493079,
0.7921305299,
0.048897177,
0.0970023274,
-0.9742190838,
-0.0940404236,
0.1647103578,
0.1258018315,
-0.2247622758,
0.2230070829,
0.0285788178,
-0.4659244418,
0.0050499481,
0.3640027642,
-0.5425102115,
-0.1582593173,
-0.2251190394,
0.335698247,
0.2434080541,
0.3503732681,
0.0127687771,
0.6143659353,
0.2889761329,
-0.4592253864,
0.4440076947,
0.5648378134,
-0.783567369,
0.8476269841,
-0.3425987959,
0.3017429709,
0.0205482114,
0.3525384665,
-0.5399013758,
-0.0699575916,
-0.1840457618,
-0.2618061602,
0.2081935555,
-0.2409715503,
-0.4443691075,
-0.3073080182,
-0.5298424959,
0.0241769869,
0.1732477695,
-0.7594397068,
0.4454256296,
0.1946553588,
-0.1342943758,
-0.6596183777,
-0.4408065081,
0.1782116145,
-0.0119040413,
-0.13811858,
0.1262781322,
-0.1828440279,
-0.5357224941,
0.1236694157,
-0.073883146,
-0.1654033959,
0.0494609587,
0.2969012558,
0.4428779483,
-0.1599534154,
0.6345689297,
0.0260467678,
0.0145857688,
0.1361627579,
-0.3537210822,
0.4747938514,
-0.2315799594,
-0.1534900516,
-0.1924698353,
0.5628927946,
0.2725285888,
-0.4288175404,
0.5683438778,
0.4742168486,
-0.4103070199,
-0.9039339423,
-0.4247772694,
-0.2884237468,
-0.4028038979,
0.4034776092,
-0.1424871385,
-0.6383910179,
0.091838792,
0.1265855581,
0.3422161341,
0.2245059609,
0.5931049585,
0.0825309679,
0.2924270928,
0.602492094,
-0.0502187349,
0.6061931252,
-0.7720131874,
0.3109149635,
-0.7606362104,
-0.2913298011,
-0.7952665687,
-0.0496180244,
-0.2363476008,
-0.2398492545,
0.0796228796,
0.1284436285,
0.0420731977,
0.1860499084,
-0.8075414896,
0.8171981573,
0.7017115951,
0.1358344555,
0.4531233311,
0.1615300477,
0.2705873847,
0.0136954002,
-0.7284494042,
-1.0667250156,
1.3585324287,
0.1589116156,
0.6071212888,
0.1221880391,
0.6484060884,
0.3359968066,
0.7762752771,
-0.9458693862,
0.6062504649,
-0.2897064686,
-0.461458236,
-0.4964612424,
-0.4127666056,
-0.7693333626,
0.4358150065,
-0.4347572327,
-0.2966377437,
-0.0441046022,
-0.1605367362,
-0.3864741623,
0.4620808959,
-0.7217720151,
0.7636713982,
0.093771562,
-0.2525257468,
-0.0726762787,
-0.2071237862,
0.2208834589,
-0.0655573085,
0.1524645835,
0.0387882553,
0.5168025494,
1.2912716866,
-0.4683022797,
0.900464654,
0.0440855511,
-0.4392636418,
0.6928517818,
0.0431280099,
0.0866612568,
0.1800867319,
-0.2724677324,
-0.0398167931,
0.3539928794,
-0.3397496045,
-0.7529437542,
0.7666428089,
-0.7527660728,
-0.3122210205,
-0.3433921933,
-0.6147075295,
-0.3808450997,
0.0339317583,
0.0067120474,
0.9788184762,
-0.0138423461,
0.1267529875,
0.4495095909,
-0.2730908096,
0.5789095759,
0.2476252764,
-0.3550387025,
-0.2429891974,
1.0135992765,
0.2521458864,
0.3427622616,
0.1894626617,
0.2134049088,
-0.1333022714,
-0.4979163408,
-0.4447990656,
0.1236127913,
-1.0330536366,
-0.4260569513,
-0.2684263885,
-0.1471295357,
-0.4632951915,
-0.3630358875,
0.1032037809,
-0.3129484951,
-0.3216633201,
-0.3247408867,
0.1759253293,
1.0477089882,
0.2970924377,
0.4912902713,
-0.8118205667,
0.1420574784,
0.3985491395,
0.4814387262,
0.4434470534,
-0.4035559297,
-0.5080184937,
-0.1964544207,
-0.4250754416,
-0.8697408438,
0.4826003611,
0.0625928342,
0.1581573337,
0.478078872,
0.084167555,
0.3977268934,
-0.292624414,
0.8652299643,
0.2776806653,
-0.9364813566,
0.6773347259,
-0.3849195838,
0.298378706,
0.5132539272,
0.2246798873,
-0.5088205934,
-0.4739903808,
-0.5789771676,
-0.6339124441,
0.5842682719,
-0.0625040606,
0.4209932983,
-0.0748635083,
0.5349501967,
0.0890015066,
0.3865993023,
-0.7737087011,
-0.1186334863,
-0.1354712546,
-0.574760437,
-0.1208268628,
-0.6324880123,
-0.5011296868,
-0.196490109,
0.5490319133,
-0.2149349451,
0.0708725825,
-0.0527575985,
0.0175151471,
-0.0464754812,
0.7021548748,
0.3526854813,
1.1709381342,
-0.0699857175,
0.2762773335,
0.0154431975,
-0.5491785407,
0.1118353084,
-0.3013931513,
0.0006624645,
0.3070620894,
0.77980268,
0.3200001419,
0.3482506573,
-0.7474098206,
0.4327742159,
0.1763600409,
0.0780547783,
-0.5693827868,
0.0071193967,
-0.1459495127,
0.0073252646,
0.3032006025,
-0.3226289451,
0.0179123618,
-0.6741423011,
-0.0069042998,
-0.0344778299,
-0.4233537316,
-0.2189560235,
-0.0037746069,
0.4324424565,
-0.3131782413,
0.7896294594,
0.2786156535,
-0.3831961751,
0.9152175784,
0.7770004272,
0.8013598919,
-0.1591879725,
0.6124557853,
0.5050125718,
0.1256916672,
-0.3253409266,
-0.0070126182,
-0.018806152,
-0.7060685158,
-0.4731544852,
-0.7957854867,
-0.5641310811,
0.1219125986,
-1.1500506401,
0.16013515,
-0.6120132208,
-0.0530453697,
0.1704562604,
-0.0410503894,
-0.3841098547,
0.419586122,
-0.1478929669,
0.5212967992,
-1.0079081059,
0.5887995958,
1.0121879578,
-0.6410067677,
-0.8864547014,
-0.1999036819,
-0.1421751231,
-0.3747850657,
0.4703668058,
0.0879615322,
0.30420506,
-0.0885620564,
-0.5707892776,
-0.2120556682,
0.5886793733,
-0.1206764951,
-0.7607260942,
-0.0682572648,
-0.0414236672,
0.7058165073,
-0.1855057627,
0.1854732335,
0.5332701802,
0.3690046072,
-0.3975949883,
-0.4089681506,
-0.1149297878,
-0.2584758997,
0.1817553639,
0.2695307434,
-0.3145546019,
0.5364977717,
-0.043216791,
-0.09737432,
-0.1238406748,
0.562453568,
0.0374262556,
0.2395739704,
0.2661521733,
0.6067218184,
0.7585434318,
-0.2648109496,
1.1801161766,
0.0024694919,
0.5518957376,
1.2104697227,
0.071578376,
0.9376581907,
0.4719019532,
-0.6122201681,
0.5580419898,
0.3294126093,
-0.4001141787,
0.1544402093,
0.6882437468,
-0.4772897959,
-0.1962600648,
-0.1615050882,
-0.490116924,
0.1715544015,
0.200796634,
-0.2068851739,
-0.0056598191,
0.3125784695,
-0.1088925451,
0.717710197,
-0.4298011363,
0.6207434535,
0.1368713677,
-0.7066999078,
0.3091264367,
-0.1021715626,
0.5123676658,
-0.28635782,
-0.3361357749,
-0.306291014,
0.0371690206,
-0.6144796014,
-0.8639981151,
0.1683553308,
0.2478737235,
-0.4017882645,
-0.1250123531,
0.3108162582,
-0.3970886767,
-0.7694087029,
-0.0223618429,
0.098604098,
-0.0697967336,
0.3588511348,
-0.0822509155,
0.1439205557,
0.0878518149,
-0.0560992658,
0.1828655005,
0.2976317108,
0.0119453017,
0.391299963,
0.6850277781,
0.1042399406,
-0.0405585654,
0.6542548537,
0.7614148259,
-0.7745193839,
-0.3149811924,
-0.5616352558,
0.5773813128,
-0.2244832814,
-0.6293139458,
0.8339859843,
0.4592889845,
1.1224498749,
-0.2274118364,
1.0611302853,
0.0802410468,
0.4896654189,
-0.6482878923,
0.4017586708,
-0.159258306,
0.600314796,
-0.4719172418,
-0.9804705977,
-0.2490644008,
0.6683762074,
-0.4092288613,
0.0061765094,
0.7951346636,
0.2824329734,
0.3489714563,
0.3749372363,
0.2425097823,
0.007469059,
0.4910259843,
0.1700135469,
1.2511093616,
-0.4761678576,
0.3865893781,
-0.3065027893,
-0.1954507232,
0.0124644572,
-0.5272932053,
-1.1062725782,
-0.6356226802,
-0.6740262508,
-0.6883732677,
-0.0082286764,
0.7259082198,
0.2185028046,
-0.8024300933,
-0.4357818067,
0.167105332,
0.1936336309,
-0.1442362666,
-0.2998211682,
0.6923955083,
-0.4893544316,
-0.8518890142,
0.2542854548,
-0.0104954932,
-0.0713847056,
-0.4530409873,
0.1695430577,
0.0781671926,
-0.0949982405,
0.6268535852,
0.0121399425,
-0.5572422147,
-0.1762222052,
-0.4052168429,
-0.0758290291,
-0.1452956945,
1.1012885571,
-0.6080625653,
0.6065456271,
0.1786708832,
0.716170609,
0.2392910123,
-0.115345329,
0.5140874982,
-0.7540967464,
0.0172161106,
0.5446782112,
0.3209298253,
0.4661622345,
-0.0227873642,
0.75175035,
0.0730169937,
-0.4012185335,
-1.0310587883,
-0.1450947374,
-0.9420476556,
-0.4471627176,
1.0854936838,
-0.3946921825,
0.0698640496,
0.1005461589,
-0.2251067162,
0.0044637248,
0.0722595304,
1.0017223358,
0.9463219643,
0.3198138773,
0.0616568439,
-0.4676617682,
0.2645234466,
0.3983122706,
-1.0574325323,
-0.1226323098,
0.6777034402,
0.1781917214,
0.2524970472,
0.4318638146,
-0.3077714741,
0.0275334027,
0.0493317172,
0.2701157928,
0.1154024675,
-0.2670847476,
-0.5353204608,
0.394180119,
0.0173314344,
-0.049412515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15452v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15452v1
|
What Are Tools Anyway? A Survey from the Language Model Perspective
| 2024-03-18T17:20:07 | 2024-03-18T17:20:07 |
Zhiruo Wang, Zhoujun Cheng, Hao Zhu, Daniel Fried, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language models (LMs) are powerful yet mostly for text generation tasks.
Tools have substantially enhanced their performance for tasks that require
complex skills. However, many works adopt the term "tool" in different ways,
raising the question: What is a tool anyway? Subsequently, where and how do
tools help LMs? In this survey, we provide a unified definition of tools as
external programs used by LMs, and perform a systematic review of LM tooling
scenarios and approaches. Grounded on this review, we empirically study the
efficiency of various tooling methods by measuring their required compute and
performance gains on various benchmarks, and highlight some challenges and
potential future research in the field.
|
[
-0.3847862482,
-0.8195468187,
0.6127381325,
-0.0308965668,
-0.2067262977,
0.2527468503,
-0.0560788475,
-0.3725045323,
-0.0987214446,
0.5003496408,
-0.7332253456,
-0.2115665227,
-0.4831823111,
0.2233428955,
-0.6552707553,
0.8551716208,
-0.0725772604,
0.2520166337,
-0.2766770124,
-0.1124464571,
-0.4958340526,
-0.4528574646,
-0.6293210387,
-0.2906181812,
0.6716088057,
0.4105056524,
0.8733139038,
0.3593963385,
0.7982643843,
0.4982214868,
0.1578125358,
-0.0542761385,
-0.1792683154,
0.1642993838,
-0.1094795913,
-0.6228590608,
-0.316088438,
0.1868990809,
0.2876983583,
0.8314116001,
0.0003351099,
0.5839801431,
0.1012970582,
0.5199699402,
-0.567504108,
-0.4753166139,
-0.6240935326,
-0.0079553695,
-0.2089361846,
-0.061230056,
-0.254203558,
-0.7063459158,
0.0531509295,
-0.1161035746,
0.2204374224,
-0.0937347189,
0.4429091513,
0.1068109944,
-0.2187934667,
-0.5703768134,
-0.8177669644,
0.7815842628,
-0.9315958619,
0.4101121426,
0.230355069,
0.4624319673,
-0.0260724388,
-0.8717969656,
-0.4017137885,
-0.2850492895,
0.024483718,
-0.1919637918,
0.1088085026,
0.031412296,
0.4412375987,
0.4437196553,
-0.1839221418,
0.1122639775,
-0.3467019796,
-0.2255010903,
0.6894125938,
0.4793536961,
0.6168519855,
-0.041447103,
0.156310752,
-0.3739408553,
-0.8852655292,
0.0840930343,
0.727668643,
0.221719265,
0.1803534627,
0.8374307752,
0.3454943299,
0.8278349638,
-0.4853052199,
-0.4203781188,
-0.2378770858,
-0.4887657166,
-0.5486915112,
-0.1918987781,
0.7157462239,
0.3063462377,
0.025172919,
-0.3389812112,
-0.3622393906,
-0.160919711,
0.265184164,
-0.6130372882,
-0.2791255713,
0.3583671749,
-0.1108697727,
-0.2862192392,
0.0374286026,
-0.2029611915,
-0.6088261604,
-0.1232232824,
0.4296689928,
-0.2777340114,
-0.5741560459,
-0.2692229748,
-0.5135290027,
0.0705239251,
0.2909779847,
-0.2809819877,
0.2506878376,
0.6228234172,
1.0177841187,
-0.1259628832,
-0.0018704424,
-0.4152847528,
-0.2271706909,
-0.6851627231,
0.8201204538,
-0.3280567527,
-0.8681399822,
0.1941981316,
0.2401635051,
0.2490940392,
-0.3858638108,
0.3133421838,
-0.3313762844,
0.5029575825,
-0.5785722136,
-0.495152086,
-0.2969920933,
-0.054020755,
-0.7064612508,
1.3543031216,
0.1732985526,
-0.6683188081,
0.5361196399,
-0.6081777811,
-0.4410791993,
0.1360673606,
-0.0414385609,
-0.3351822793,
0.396692425,
-0.2077824175,
0.4590256214,
-0.646869421,
0.3935355246,
-0.3785249293,
-0.3885861337,
0.4686586559,
-0.3182317317,
0.6679906845,
0.2303651571,
-0.2155115157,
0.3746629357,
-0.5219909549,
0.2155908048,
0.1686100513,
-0.3055292368,
-0.4149260521,
0.2349375188,
0.201067403,
0.4880329072,
0.0388918445,
-0.5793464184,
0.2624460757,
-0.6900190711,
0.2775329947,
0.6532149911,
-0.2733519077,
0.5940400362,
-0.3290655613,
0.685356915,
-0.2538180947,
-0.1827949286,
-0.2506128252,
-0.4439836442,
-0.9230453372,
0.0801388994,
0.497635752,
0.3327166438,
-0.6163952947,
0.4179801345,
0.0113550499,
-0.9849864841,
-0.9622220397,
0.2875345349,
0.3809992671,
-0.0202242583,
-0.1499190331,
-0.2760448456,
-0.5847024322,
-0.949196279,
-0.7027612925,
-0.0523014963,
-0.0494056493,
0.1449675113,
0.4503840804,
0.055282969,
1.013761878,
-0.2915937006,
0.0483266823,
-0.7468714714,
0.1476007402,
0.1319486946,
0.1402081251,
0.3151496649,
-0.5366936326,
-0.5238553882,
-0.1379248947,
-0.4537607133,
-0.3224189281,
-0.0821866095,
0.3053573668,
0.3058727682,
0.797996819,
-0.2261431366,
0.1217724532,
0.555383563,
-0.0835979506,
0.6303114295,
-0.2216106653,
-0.1438290626,
-0.6639704704,
0.392398119,
-0.1704039574,
-0.3470593691,
-0.6641581655,
0.2523469031,
0.0490466505,
-0.1058248952,
-0.5979545712,
0.6625562906,
-0.7773758769,
-0.2624444366,
-0.5543817878,
0.2818717957,
-0.1408660114,
0.0137575427,
-0.1108317897,
0.9012454152,
0.4118793905,
-0.6229243279,
0.4858709574,
-0.2717912197,
-0.3468244076,
0.3374561965,
-0.7531457543,
0.4223448038,
-0.1106938347,
-0.0289009083,
-0.8220489621,
-0.0955286995,
0.0761579722,
-0.1293228567,
-0.0201011486,
0.0554381348,
-0.8220474124,
-0.5584642887,
-0.4820627868,
-0.1872110367,
0.5354850888,
-0.2187050283,
0.3896397054,
0.6360211968,
-0.2691497207,
-0.4676422179,
-0.6141588092,
0.1110795289,
-0.1953488141,
-0.5173341632,
-0.1485334635,
-0.2357817739,
-0.5660889745,
0.0013938859,
-0.0258522369,
0.0107831806,
0.2241111547,
0.446882695,
0.0620957538,
-0.1770519018,
0.5058720112,
-0.1131657586,
0.1381644905,
0.2097957134,
0.2605762482,
0.5442615151,
0.0111362748,
-0.7668860555,
0.1615402251,
0.3715630472,
0.174426049,
-0.1137149185,
0.6648882031,
0.7459025979,
-0.088155292,
-0.3113045096,
-0.66926229,
-0.2336239517,
-0.5510697365,
0.3537922502,
-0.4286111593,
-0.590285778,
0.1908228844,
-0.3603391647,
0.6195774078,
0.2688010335,
0.6869209409,
0.2237361372,
1.2649570704,
0.8643301725,
-0.0763582215,
0.2871652842,
-0.0938401669,
0.4049276412,
-0.6456243992,
0.0640783086,
-0.5107324719,
-0.3794370592,
-0.3842184544,
-0.415230751,
0.1467585266,
0.2011702061,
0.1401210874,
0.3905754685,
-0.55545187,
0.2623799741,
0.7374289036,
-0.4449255466,
0.3079448938,
-0.3748162389,
-0.1846707165,
0.0434404574,
-0.9546948671,
-0.7591551542,
1.0874692202,
0.2885597944,
0.6129151583,
-0.1398720294,
0.4767712951,
-0.0345299877,
0.6260756254,
-0.886095345,
0.7691607475,
0.2832335234,
-0.7027703524,
-0.4247272909,
0.0146927359,
-0.8670781851,
0.2586214542,
-0.037353009,
-0.6240450144,
-0.2838092744,
0.0525862649,
-0.0770912692,
0.5524369478,
-0.8823695183,
0.713344276,
-0.253374815,
-0.2807551324,
0.0644400939,
-0.3416848779,
0.2839812934,
-0.1572843343,
0.5246828198,
-0.206332162,
-0.1060351357,
0.6679784656,
-0.4645847976,
0.5390871167,
-0.1864018887,
-0.480178535,
0.5188326836,
0.287776798,
0.4914600849,
-0.291092813,
-0.0675274208,
-0.1133281812,
0.4035488367,
0.0740404427,
-0.4655961096,
0.8037326932,
-0.3619782925,
-0.5334660411,
-0.3446557522,
-0.6269358993,
-0.2711387873,
0.253269583,
0.2032457143,
0.5318706632,
-0.3624390066,
0.0378066972,
0.0396811664,
-0.2797313035,
0.8492210507,
0.5091993213,
-0.5648968816,
0.4433656037,
0.9757391214,
0.3337584436,
0.2106605619,
0.0448121764,
0.0004875158,
-0.2201645225,
-0.3519380093,
-0.3042624295,
0.0647693425,
-0.7500604391,
0.0064370367,
-0.5553691983,
-0.2060361505,
-0.2999813259,
-0.2371819168,
-0.3607443571,
-0.4417838156,
0.0927935243,
-0.0618798621,
0.2169638425,
1.0236501694,
0.0452425331,
0.4293873906,
-0.8069577217,
0.052102223,
0.1942856163,
0.3544726074,
-0.1539903432,
0.1194741204,
-0.220377624,
-0.0616281517,
-0.290466398,
-0.9533436298,
0.3635067046,
-0.0518630631,
0.3800064921,
0.052066844,
-0.1675624549,
0.473577112,
-0.5458852649,
1.0198221207,
0.0335555486,
-0.7117012143,
0.4258720875,
0.1255851239,
0.5669267774,
0.2272300273,
0.4079691768,
-0.958878994,
-0.680224359,
-0.6158932447,
-0.806830585,
0.6902454495,
0.1314553618,
0.1186507344,
0.2548968792,
-0.1292888671,
0.170644477,
0.3305105269,
-0.6464519501,
-0.1828057468,
0.2717340887,
-0.1413198113,
-0.342612505,
0.106021516,
-0.2379529029,
0.0429068357,
0.5604959726,
-0.005479231,
0.1237132922,
0.1828200519,
-0.3696371615,
-0.2729006708,
0.5771477818,
-0.0407352932,
0.795173347,
0.1057575718,
0.0754802153,
0.265181154,
-0.2431281805,
0.0772923678,
-0.1650168449,
0.0909478217,
0.2399061918,
0.2137510926,
0.4986691773,
0.1198664308,
-0.9945756793,
0.3879987597,
0.0133877872,
0.0195471551,
-0.1968818009,
0.315851599,
0.4884571135,
0.0058561596,
0.0975808501,
-0.1256164312,
0.2566832602,
-0.5191381574,
-0.310896188,
0.7675533891,
-0.5398763418,
-0.3759943247,
0.2692317665,
0.2582778931,
-0.6883558035,
0.1065092981,
-0.1538125575,
-0.0810639262,
0.4442054927,
0.3314987719,
0.8649331927,
-0.1260129511,
0.1741871536,
0.1683220565,
0.5338388085,
-0.0180644244,
0.3210747242,
0.005981585,
-0.5231189728,
-0.4293656051,
-0.5489529371,
-0.4002328217,
0.4461993277,
-0.1596918702,
0.3816416264,
-0.1102306247,
-0.3684574962,
0.0864409804,
-0.0969086662,
-0.9687861204,
0.1099798828,
-0.263438791,
1.1368175745,
-0.6018028855,
0.739588201,
1.1181429625,
-0.3069012165,
-0.7364284992,
-0.4179454744,
0.2216139883,
-0.5549677014,
0.4550957978,
0.0241501164,
-0.4007052481,
0.0239546988,
-0.4632939696,
-0.5379238725,
0.6453430653,
0.1684837788,
-0.569409132,
-0.3288297951,
0.2718883157,
0.3815515637,
-0.0192891043,
0.4095214605,
0.6533563137,
0.4984778464,
-0.4938760102,
-1.056784749,
0.0117795831,
-0.382676512,
0.1936873347,
0.3571128547,
0.0999674946,
0.5187004209,
-0.0931010619,
-0.4898925126,
0.2044240981,
0.1893748492,
-0.04654691,
0.0985807106,
0.4818136692,
0.0902671963,
0.2587490976,
-0.1046480536,
1.1283601522,
-0.4966296256,
-0.0382700413,
0.8342929482,
-0.0616388135,
0.6809786558,
0.6132039428,
-0.3754443824,
0.3981873393,
0.4350019693,
0.1047300696,
0.0283544697,
0.3095784485,
-0.0429623239,
-0.2331751734,
-0.031443771,
-0.3419868648,
0.1913089901,
0.2722771168,
-0.2990915775,
-0.2515116334,
-0.0456947461,
-0.0668373108,
0.04642158,
-0.1731383204,
0.9393916726,
0.2245370448,
-0.7971162796,
-0.0080097159,
0.3375270069,
0.6810624003,
-0.9328472614,
0.0561119206,
0.2115834355,
0.0515881479,
-0.0327575617,
-0.9468901753,
0.3494612575,
-0.1061877683,
0.2306661606,
-0.235874936,
1.1197385788,
-0.213574633,
-0.6616311073,
-0.0068250252,
1.2084316015,
0.1251083463,
-0.1687314659,
-0.6944366097,
0.0274863113,
-0.3756694794,
-0.1798236221,
0.335333854,
0.3715273142,
0.2070470005,
0.8327106833,
0.7166679502,
0.4285868704,
0.1243074909,
0.0055049737,
0.535379231,
-0.7547900677,
-0.271265924,
-0.7973881364,
0.6060155034,
-0.2549232543,
-0.4684161246,
1.0709795952,
0.3728601635,
0.7428146601,
-0.1032379419,
0.8848341107,
-0.2423057556,
0.8387239575,
-0.2091255486,
0.5952308774,
-0.6131995916,
0.1565401852,
-0.5247529745,
-0.8927317262,
-0.0269428138,
0.3242299557,
-0.2561157048,
0.1262505651,
0.550981164,
0.7989443541,
-0.0145242391,
0.0275260657,
0.3368211687,
-0.081224829,
0.2337741405,
-0.0039119986,
0.8514448404,
-0.1786599606,
0.3929544389,
-0.3385290205,
0.0850922242,
-0.0946408063,
-0.8873586059,
-0.8746246696,
-0.8582832217,
0.0511701405,
0.0292635504,
-0.0280609168,
0.8153509498,
0.6518499255,
-0.4956504405,
-0.6631817818,
-0.1812234968,
0.3011261821,
-0.1025377735,
-0.1694658697,
0.1306267232,
-0.5219028592,
-0.7734869719,
0.4168483913,
0.2043025345,
-0.1564004719,
-0.8165292144,
0.1531057358,
0.0296617001,
0.0819656998,
0.6553473473,
0.2541642487,
-0.6644539833,
-0.1427367926,
0.1430359632,
-0.1085842773,
-0.3237935007,
1.2470247746,
-0.7377380133,
0.4910613,
0.5048744678,
0.4295027852,
-0.0123381913,
-0.4011231661,
0.9279309511,
-0.9458271861,
0.1685177833,
0.1985393018,
0.2699035406,
0.5343327522,
0.0358667858,
0.4653829336,
-0.1721076667,
-0.6097759604,
-1.0983635187,
0.3232959807,
-0.3420519233,
-0.6085742712,
1.0786606073,
0.2506026328,
0.0212183241,
-0.3847254813,
-0.6625148654,
0.2805050015,
-0.0572814047,
0.423990339,
0.6920921803,
0.0422383212,
-0.0888094753,
-0.7433398366,
0.8160752058,
0.1240726635,
-0.8692591786,
-0.1086021066,
0.3673667312,
0.2444629669,
0.2789319754,
0.7884941101,
-0.0709885657,
0.1921329051,
-0.0573988892,
0.0207035597,
0.0679100975,
-0.0820032433,
-0.1225081012,
0.1761650294,
0.4846643507,
0.4866186082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11958v1
|
Language Evolution with Deep Learning
| 2024-03-18T16:52:54 | 2024-03-18T16:52:54 |
Mathieu Rita, Paul Michel, Rahma Chaabouni, Olivier Pietquin, Emmanuel Dupoux, Florian Strub
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MA
|
Computational modeling plays an essential role in the study of language
emergence. It aims to simulate the conditions and learning processes that could
trigger the emergence of a structured language within a simulated controlled
environment. Several methods have been used to investigate the origin of our
language, including agent-based systems, Bayesian agents, genetic algorithms,
and rule-based systems. This chapter explores another class of computational
models that have recently revolutionized the field of machine learning: deep
learning models. The chapter introduces the basic concepts of deep and
reinforcement learning methods and summarizes their helpfulness for simulating
language emergence. It also discusses the key findings, limitations, and recent
attempts to build realistic simulations. This chapter targets linguists and
cognitive scientists seeking an introduction to deep learning as a tool to
investigate language evolution.
|
[
-0.3982743621,
-1.3403632641,
0.5676410198,
0.0548367798,
0.1009403467,
0.5507634878,
-0.3641409576,
-0.4322582483,
-0.2632105052,
0.6502219439,
-0.6412690282,
-0.004063183,
-0.4133855402,
-0.0496056154,
-0.2746242881,
0.7591401935,
0.2298320979,
0.1363098025,
0.0463997722,
0.2238405049,
-0.2372083962,
-0.5736348033,
-1.0024921894,
-0.612082839,
0.2747560441,
0.3409453034,
0.942943275,
0.5297922492,
0.2859792113,
0.3834123909,
-0.0799510852,
0.0176674835,
-0.3112630546,
0.3883311749,
0.0733840838,
-0.4205693603,
0.1828352362,
0.0757536069,
0.7298510671,
1.2066676617,
-0.2155620307,
-0.2733069658,
-0.2265694588,
0.5585439801,
-0.3515450656,
0.2565359771,
-0.4641381204,
0.2570022047,
-0.088329494,
-0.2049965709,
-0.2766212821,
-0.4677761495,
0.4092976153,
-0.3668612242,
0.1841353178,
-0.2017263025,
0.5206857324,
-0.0034126043,
-0.4653806388,
-0.452067107,
-1.1777858734,
0.753487885,
-0.7492831349,
0.5084531903,
0.1169363782,
0.5301164389,
-0.6297436357,
-0.7939622402,
-0.6365321279,
-0.7586231828,
0.2126620263,
-0.135233134,
0.0057507926,
0.2258038819,
0.2784184813,
0.276725769,
-0.4801277518,
0.4535661042,
-0.5643180013,
0.2660422325,
0.6648045778,
0.182275489,
0.6068837047,
0.221852228,
-0.0169948507,
-0.4309525788,
-0.5722292662,
0.1625489891,
0.4333894849,
0.5674693584,
-0.0124497674,
0.3117910624,
0.0333989188,
0.5014598966,
-0.0468848459,
0.0174142383,
0.2601897418,
-0.0270505827,
-0.3085103035,
0.2241347432,
0.5818525553,
-0.2258354723,
0.602604568,
0.0698466897,
-0.0855249166,
0.1884759218,
0.3058852255,
-0.6908441782,
-0.2975708544,
-0.0286723692,
-0.3035864532,
-0.6668640971,
-0.2441579252,
-0.5286218524,
-0.563968122,
-0.4937953353,
-0.1131819636,
-0.419208169,
-0.6462661028,
0.3391215205,
-0.1877138913,
0.5103695393,
0.3087449372,
-1.0486215353,
0.7671622634,
0.8037182689,
0.1444649398,
-0.0675216541,
-0.4883869886,
-0.0909751356,
-0.1512980163,
-0.8804137111,
0.5689641237,
-0.6767000556,
-0.3134697378,
0.2448603958,
0.048373118,
0.3087140024,
-0.5140747428,
0.2395503521,
-0.7226388454,
0.2084455788,
0.0903053284,
-0.6001051068,
-0.4886448681,
-0.0613528565,
-0.6485726833,
0.8560634851,
0.1826848388,
-0.3545105457,
0.3656947315,
-0.8409330845,
-0.6460425854,
0.527746439,
-0.3018940687,
-0.3282861412,
0.4083841741,
-0.0889549628,
0.5394118428,
-0.3780843616,
0.3487018645,
-0.4144108593,
-0.0801085234,
0.5080727339,
-0.39153862,
1.0708186626,
0.5439187288,
-0.371160388,
-0.124896571,
-0.4783676863,
0.1895841956,
0.37080127,
-0.1596938074,
-0.2845642269,
0.3403453231,
-0.1272834986,
0.1212420091,
-0.082711339,
-0.2364147007,
0.4384405911,
-0.72434479,
0.6274675727,
0.28088817,
0.2270577401,
0.612716794,
0.0214730203,
0.658993125,
0.002658261,
0.0896070078,
-0.1295032203,
-0.3715967536,
-0.6158571243,
0.169663161,
0.3867097199,
0.550023973,
-0.470009774,
0.0515590757,
-0.0566677451,
-0.5799285769,
-0.5011541843,
0.0843161717,
0.2039443702,
-0.2329705805,
0.0679662451,
-0.1267777085,
-0.6239683628,
-0.7877779007,
-0.0317816883,
0.0901675671,
0.2652542591,
0.3999030292,
0.405038923,
-0.5824719667,
0.6117694378,
-0.3232599497,
0.6739634871,
-0.5442394018,
0.2680234313,
0.1357753277,
0.6209523082,
0.7306553125,
-0.6942493916,
-0.2575466335,
0.237308085,
-0.6562363505,
0.1302715093,
-0.1829879433,
0.2865265906,
0.0364103951,
0.8266409636,
-0.3672024012,
0.2189330757,
0.5744229555,
-0.0274905227,
0.4406037629,
-0.2215723246,
-0.0396224894,
-1.0581742525,
-0.1407291293,
-0.2030915916,
-0.1145256534,
-1.1105253696,
0.3880944252,
-0.3112302423,
-0.350248009,
-0.5023213029,
0.4875361621,
-0.6173334122,
-0.0709363297,
-0.6476144195,
-0.0493828505,
-0.3409254551,
0.2451645881,
0.2634089291,
0.3919532597,
0.7420114279,
-0.8043951392,
0.3319209814,
-0.2788870931,
-0.3190518916,
-0.2135286778,
-0.4956371486,
0.1474386305,
-0.2745603621,
0.023414053,
-0.7103369832,
-0.2129041851,
0.1042284146,
-0.5442973375,
0.603349328,
-0.1586869806,
-0.2629311979,
-0.3758030236,
-0.0270153601,
0.4904921055,
0.6880355477,
-0.2751657367,
0.2747254372,
0.3993940055,
-0.2636812627,
-0.4532956481,
-0.4701035619,
-0.0621664748,
-0.220658794,
-0.2748054266,
0.1871532649,
-0.1278679818,
-0.6381411552,
-0.2133963704,
0.418296814,
-0.2824064493,
0.6398479342,
0.1999845505,
-0.1901493371,
-0.4650301039,
0.1966079175,
0.312063694,
0.0205570366,
0.2572827339,
-0.4849051535,
0.7100350857,
-0.1194592565,
0.0253480822,
-0.2919994891,
0.3844749629,
0.5471594334,
-0.0790752992,
0.6479608417,
0.2086265385,
-0.438203305,
-0.5155573487,
-0.3476266861,
-0.3487375677,
-0.49129951,
0.4797717631,
-0.4281705618,
-0.9217067957,
0.3307558,
-0.5070384145,
-0.2210645378,
0.3716411591,
0.6396481395,
-0.0877432823,
1.0111316442,
1.026755929,
0.0451274924,
0.6392928958,
-0.1858943403,
0.0513557941,
-0.4118241966,
-0.1026474237,
-0.6546805501,
0.0429063477,
-0.9324653149,
-0.3545412719,
-0.1625697017,
0.5184748769,
-0.505925715,
0.3650062978,
-0.2297173887,
0.5074326396,
0.5296320319,
-0.1896561831,
-0.1706268489,
0.1603125334,
-0.3431894481,
0.1554382741,
-0.6628758907,
-0.3607619405,
0.8823940754,
0.389967978,
0.7337140441,
-0.1396101117,
0.7049538493,
0.3221149445,
0.0675387383,
-0.4907657206,
0.2070165426,
0.0444156528,
-0.5763810277,
-0.4148291647,
-0.2511278093,
-1.2968935966,
-0.0139589496,
-0.3542740047,
-0.4979018271,
0.3229887486,
0.0364193991,
-0.1829705983,
0.1169664115,
-0.4394842982,
0.7306481004,
-0.5162588954,
0.0396955311,
-0.3625453115,
-0.6182426214,
0.4184877276,
-0.1151333749,
0.4043595493,
-0.0105886208,
0.1050069854,
0.6307812333,
-0.1971384585,
0.8556868434,
-0.1084842682,
-0.1231655031,
0.5108402371,
0.3770441413,
0.3493438661,
0.055301439,
0.0830495358,
-0.0299370661,
-0.066614151,
-0.4086333513,
-0.629455924,
0.4516403377,
-0.933508873,
-0.439078778,
-0.3526036441,
-0.4484809339,
-0.0724874437,
0.2063832134,
-0.0487647876,
0.0158996787,
-0.3854573369,
0.2170381844,
0.7654641867,
-0.3880724311,
0.541118443,
0.5294678211,
-0.5562112927,
-0.2948698699,
0.8272500634,
-0.0683856085,
0.2069319785,
0.3328166008,
0.632989347,
-0.00143455,
-0.8201644421,
-0.1150498241,
0.0755374059,
-0.4282360971,
0.1664555669,
-0.4756693542,
-0.5561473966,
-0.2813928723,
-0.3304027319,
-0.2990782261,
-0.3072128892,
-0.2043074667,
-0.2682931125,
0.2130294442,
1.0244742632,
-0.1027276143,
0.5112148523,
-0.4824202061,
-0.0530497842,
0.505361259,
0.1074849814,
0.0192702636,
-0.1874107122,
-0.1429098696,
0.3260828257,
-0.1444836557,
-0.9589218497,
0.4890815914,
0.1885051727,
0.8344477415,
0.5707741976,
-0.286973238,
0.2224916071,
-0.5599957108,
0.8360984325,
0.0653197691,
-0.7560800314,
0.6407254934,
-0.5619640946,
-0.022157846,
0.233196497,
0.6105158925,
-0.5145313144,
-0.1962798685,
-0.6988569498,
-0.5613192916,
0.2968775034,
0.0600616075,
0.4095260203,
-0.0745916814,
0.6378185153,
0.2096414119,
0.2383566648,
-0.7285251617,
-0.0463154651,
-0.1674764156,
-0.0070708934,
-0.4421317279,
-0.3299144208,
0.1737502664,
-0.4056242406,
0.3599574864,
-0.2586093545,
0.1157613844,
-0.2888649106,
-0.1823280454,
-0.124031812,
0.1930541992,
0.9449576139,
0.4619431794,
0.1664090604,
-0.1383618414,
0.2061187029,
-0.2803663909,
0.1832502633,
-0.0568349808,
-0.0889638811,
-0.2969491184,
0.4035639465,
0.9670526385,
0.1887587756,
-0.7033586502,
0.2660729289,
0.0447264165,
-0.3498584926,
-0.4924028516,
0.301155895,
0.1837025434,
0.508192122,
0.2364788949,
-0.1648853421,
0.1750463694,
-0.8220663071,
0.1598770618,
0.5860782862,
-0.4393007159,
-0.273244828,
0.2711352706,
-0.0591537654,
-0.6680193543,
0.8450183272,
-0.1039193422,
-0.6062251329,
0.8181825876,
0.7021486163,
1.0311510563,
-0.4562323987,
0.1750264615,
0.0210095141,
0.340803802,
0.0670614243,
0.4275837839,
-0.1395866722,
-0.7632198334,
-0.4767807722,
-0.8243805766,
-0.4709572196,
0.2635946274,
-0.1970860362,
0.2126981616,
-0.5435681343,
-0.0685872138,
0.3594307899,
0.2351927459,
-0.6057550311,
0.305423975,
0.707221806,
0.9093121886,
-0.8830884695,
0.9162094593,
0.6333679557,
-0.2253036201,
-0.5790612698,
-0.3128873706,
-0.2133412063,
-0.7364982963,
0.9144827724,
-0.0383420512,
-0.2318262756,
0.0354867205,
-1.0138255358,
-0.8939678073,
0.5243677497,
0.270991534,
-0.4106959701,
0.1125891879,
0.2015318573,
0.8431652188,
-0.5898129344,
0.0786657929,
0.5149687529,
0.3138911426,
-0.2680587173,
-0.4001855254,
-0.1314994246,
-0.2060694993,
0.2037644684,
0.3042426407,
-0.1301839352,
1.100420475,
-0.2869440019,
-0.168601796,
0.0821583346,
0.6928167343,
-0.0413921326,
-0.0712001473,
0.1066957414,
0.3039994836,
0.6071538925,
0.0189693365,
0.9998756051,
-0.2986430824,
0.1787332743,
0.9870532751,
-0.271792978,
0.6897835135,
0.1064217985,
-0.1683181524,
0.8318961263,
0.7113776207,
-0.2114550024,
0.3433766365,
0.7680995464,
-0.0419148952,
-0.1995299757,
0.2212543935,
-0.3234018385,
0.5624196529,
0.8279604316,
-0.5181075335,
-0.0315969065,
0.1688226312,
-0.0544890426,
0.0509368144,
-0.2972692251,
1.0140581131,
-0.0276891161,
-0.6250890493,
0.3693845272,
-0.0596904978,
0.2143212706,
-0.4411962926,
-0.2132867277,
-0.0728250742,
0.2007223964,
0.1124141961,
-0.5694509149,
0.0874297321,
-0.4912374914,
-0.2132671624,
-0.0862341523,
0.6361886263,
-0.4075212181,
-0.5073941946,
0.3867934942,
0.4505423605,
0.244538188,
0.2890598774,
-0.7658005953,
0.0277110711,
-0.3677969873,
-0.3410666287,
0.2842078507,
0.448391974,
-0.2668712437,
0.7673492432,
0.825481236,
-0.0380590931,
0.466276437,
-0.0682280958,
0.6994767189,
-0.8960257769,
-0.3085326254,
-1.0524483919,
0.1622418314,
-0.0611729398,
-0.1566973627,
0.4756821394,
0.3693087101,
0.6970356703,
-0.2717920244,
0.8917672038,
0.1405869275,
0.2435075939,
-0.2644599378,
0.8007799387,
-0.3389218748,
-0.263417691,
-0.4347954392,
-0.8109538555,
-0.3663617969,
0.433316499,
-0.078784883,
0.2038299292,
0.6974887252,
0.4828396738,
0.1496258825,
-0.0174566396,
0.2122405618,
0.3198572099,
0.2493063509,
0.3062176704,
1.1447620392,
-0.1422161758,
0.1000703052,
-0.3074537516,
-0.1904254854,
-0.2716013491,
-0.7734314799,
-0.7874547243,
-0.5245770216,
-0.3923406899,
-0.1846067458,
0.2860574126,
0.9100174308,
0.9671670198,
-0.943182528,
-0.6000953913,
-0.637300849,
0.0730395317,
-0.4979552329,
-0.2266967148,
0.0529659912,
-0.7988548279,
-0.631983757,
0.6564571857,
0.0907374099,
0.5633147359,
-0.4383183122,
-0.2777638733,
-0.1743956953,
0.407981813,
0.6167003512,
0.8093366027,
-0.5923463702,
0.0341427661,
-0.1561361104,
-0.1559175402,
-0.1672974825,
0.9120536447,
-0.9855175614,
0.3073009253,
0.4651663303,
0.75132972,
0.5613254905,
-0.5564069748,
0.899941206,
-0.4167265594,
0.1420612931,
0.421212256,
0.0126760816,
0.2123656869,
-0.1851333827,
0.3389073014,
0.198589772,
-0.5013044477,
-1.0052486658,
0.5069193244,
-0.756955564,
-0.5939908624,
0.7675688267,
0.2423754185,
-0.2720088661,
0.0019401769,
-0.1068175733,
0.2956147194,
-0.1172149256,
0.5699883699,
0.4384363592,
-0.1395414919,
-0.5159493089,
-0.6568800211,
0.9265986085,
-0.1023361981,
-0.8277196884,
-0.0631686151,
0.1336267442,
0.2534886897,
0.1730171591,
0.055076275,
0.1984100789,
0.3853970766,
0.0954310596,
0.0864639953,
0.1119449064,
-0.4788047969,
-0.5034762025,
0.3144229949,
0.333401233,
0.137086004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15451v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15451v1
|
Towards Enabling FAIR Dataspaces Using Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T16:46:00 | 2024-03-18T16:46:00 |
Benedikt T. Arnold, Johannes Theissen-Lipp, Diego Collarana, Christoph Lange, Sandra Geisler, Edward Curry, Stefan Decker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dataspaces have recently gained adoption across various sectors, including
traditionally less digitized domains such as culture. Leveraging Semantic Web
technologies helps to make dataspaces FAIR, but their complexity poses a
significant challenge to the adoption of dataspaces and increases their cost.
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) raises the question of how these
models can support the adoption of FAIR dataspaces. In this work, we
demonstrate the potential of LLMs in dataspaces with a concrete example. We
also derive a research agenda for exploring this emerging field.
|
[
-0.2901858687,
-0.6419787407,
0.9580169916,
0.3477690518,
0.1347813755,
-0.02859159,
-0.5243177414,
-0.5374129415,
-0.1431047469,
0.630995214,
-0.6306338906,
-0.6130402684,
-0.6309927702,
0.1351961941,
-0.7953754663,
0.6408795118,
-0.0359684564,
0.0125960773,
-0.5166200399,
0.0116211055,
-0.6224078536,
-0.6691349149,
-0.4046892822,
-0.2582956254,
0.4336839914,
0.5432811379,
1.1395395994,
0.964866221,
0.5735216141,
0.3439003229,
-0.0758040398,
-0.1078334972,
-0.5298098326,
-0.070216842,
-0.2503548265,
-0.8290190697,
-0.5137051344,
0.3005153239,
0.7603396177,
1.3055448532,
-0.555405736,
-0.0242688842,
-0.001297493,
0.6891940832,
-0.384683311,
0.2257806212,
-0.8244763017,
0.1913184673,
-0.3801892102,
0.2118148059,
-0.5370954871,
-0.4254927933,
-0.0787720233,
-0.9164808989,
-0.126093179,
0.3341376185,
0.4920691848,
-0.0633162186,
-0.4732085168,
-0.5062632561,
-0.8220013976,
1.2611483335,
-0.5227076411,
0.7069407105,
0.2327491641,
0.606592536,
-0.738922298,
-1.0008606911,
-1.2386535406,
0.10414996,
0.1945944279,
-0.2929776311,
-0.5402275324,
-0.3032919765,
0.3605248034,
0.3803001642,
-0.5364996195,
0.5090473294,
-0.2612771988,
0.0521359034,
0.4536507428,
0.6608008146,
0.2729930282,
-0.0036671294,
-0.3080793321,
0.1451091319,
-0.8113583326,
-0.1759609729,
0.3121258616,
0.6743434668,
-0.3253436983,
0.6967170238,
-0.2665736675,
0.8171729445,
-0.3114708066,
-0.112624228,
0.4914006889,
-0.2316471189,
-0.2204446644,
-0.2989041209,
0.3753790259,
0.3881793618,
0.4879048467,
-0.2710275352,
-0.1520084143,
0.3910285532,
0.1527122259,
-0.780828476,
0.3192359507,
0.4181940854,
-0.7941845655,
-0.1603512913,
-0.1689089388,
-0.7208184004,
-0.7836325765,
-0.6273329854,
0.1051520929,
0.046936661,
-0.3320518136,
0.7858436704,
-0.1433728188,
0.4774910212,
0.6431822777,
-0.6384034753,
0.7060242891,
1.0494370461,
0.6184903383,
-0.1748462915,
-0.1210655645,
-0.2149992734,
0.1828111708,
-0.3648139238,
0.3425084054,
-0.6967437863,
-0.4016158581,
0.2090360671,
-0.0014458494,
0.3299812675,
-0.708304584,
0.4806561768,
-0.8523144722,
0.300432086,
-0.2360549271,
-0.7992548347,
-0.0980691239,
0.3045557737,
-0.7888966203,
0.4240078032,
0.2006011307,
-0.5904760957,
0.6986962557,
-0.7394251227,
-0.2326698154,
0.1782292128,
-0.3025993109,
-0.1002207473,
-0.0427102819,
-0.0635333881,
0.6867610216,
-0.5233765244,
0.6406064034,
-0.6847357154,
-0.3736002445,
0.5694037676,
-0.5301840305,
0.8541383147,
0.6020265222,
-0.0567327961,
-0.3146579564,
-0.6370006204,
-0.0509198979,
0.3293343782,
-0.2982160151,
-0.2073630244,
0.2045708746,
0.2228673398,
0.4494042993,
0.2211571932,
-0.6065715551,
0.2522168756,
-0.2608180642,
0.204852879,
0.7097321749,
-0.7333100438,
0.5175282955,
-0.4375107288,
0.4001933932,
0.1911880225,
0.3000116944,
0.3459269106,
-0.3414937854,
-0.4993694127,
-0.5426425934,
0.3334054351,
0.3109989762,
-0.7882621884,
0.3165411949,
-0.5033462644,
-0.3221901357,
-0.5762159228,
0.3483807445,
-0.1450503916,
0.2495199293,
0.0584661886,
-0.1302774101,
-0.3577310741,
-0.9446766376,
-0.0394279361,
0.1557693481,
-0.1076754704,
0.6853061318,
0.2902052104,
-0.4639059007,
1.2413454056,
-0.4052974284,
-0.2425894737,
-0.3785685003,
-0.2346370965,
0.6444128156,
0.2792432904,
0.6243518591,
-1.402453661,
-0.2962305844,
-0.182019785,
-0.8496907353,
-0.2194966078,
0.4223445952,
0.0681719705,
0.1953541189,
0.3743638992,
-0.6566494107,
0.4473117292,
0.753652215,
-0.6401364803,
0.2210454643,
-0.0393274687,
0.1642226279,
-0.9094598293,
0.1475669295,
-0.1913241595,
-0.603456676,
-0.616640985,
0.0369170681,
-0.0569403321,
-0.2019037753,
-0.6706696749,
0.7098530531,
-0.0308401939,
-0.2987982631,
-0.5397818685,
0.4228248298,
0.1629483253,
-0.0732136741,
0.005255179,
0.6417185068,
0.5224117637,
-0.6006945372,
0.2718973458,
0.2994657159,
-0.4446385801,
0.5561612844,
-0.5770186782,
-0.2497041076,
-0.3395406902,
0.7527496219,
-0.7372686863,
-0.2917348742,
-0.1139437705,
-0.1973202229,
-0.1248978898,
-0.0127231432,
-0.9719782472,
-0.3451208472,
-0.2237670869,
0.5481036901,
0.4918296039,
-0.8256372213,
0.5251721144,
0.7512346506,
-0.239270106,
-0.5950831771,
-0.651686728,
0.2877428532,
-0.4885994792,
-0.8583372831,
0.260726124,
-0.3211423457,
-0.6113129854,
-0.0139245261,
0.4433914125,
-0.1269499809,
0.4592474699,
0.2503460944,
0.2885042727,
0.0024890327,
0.0293990485,
-0.3491510749,
-0.0055111246,
-0.0839853808,
-0.6003826857,
0.6935887933,
-0.245754391,
-0.3367066681,
-0.3627759814,
0.4091022909,
0.5951868892,
0.1397397816,
0.9606185555,
0.3756135702,
-0.589438796,
-0.4166392684,
-0.5771937966,
0.2493355274,
-0.5593510866,
0.3067318797,
-0.1201486513,
-1.3755395412,
0.6230044365,
-0.2947509289,
0.1279144138,
0.1586107761,
0.672319591,
-0.0312281922,
0.9880887866,
0.9892756939,
-0.0200924259,
0.3012216389,
-0.0369284526,
0.2538009286,
-0.3946840465,
-0.0915225819,
-0.7820577025,
-0.1221963167,
-0.8212605119,
-0.7754735351,
0.1324237436,
0.0224436615,
-0.3216556311,
-0.0765157342,
0.1191620603,
0.523925662,
0.264230758,
-0.0681700557,
0.5830509067,
0.039132379,
0.1982243955,
-0.109989062,
-0.6950517297,
-0.7856256366,
0.9712572098,
0.6434476972,
1.0197890997,
0.4076313376,
0.3412044346,
0.506852746,
0.2954740226,
-0.7100530267,
0.5358134508,
-0.7898181081,
-0.5961959362,
-0.2701061368,
-0.5896660089,
-1.1489048004,
-0.005635187,
-0.2504755259,
-0.8268204331,
0.4025915563,
-0.1005473882,
0.0999200568,
0.2033195496,
-0.4545027912,
0.6015549302,
0.0834966153,
-0.4618393481,
-0.5254962444,
-0.2816035151,
0.0937385708,
-0.3063089848,
0.770445168,
-0.198066473,
0.0420589298,
0.7088198066,
-0.2666760385,
0.8660741448,
-0.386154741,
-0.1410434544,
0.3458790183,
0.3418009579,
0.4148317873,
-0.0397814773,
-0.3957056701,
0.2946455777,
-0.2946009636,
-0.4847809076,
-0.6085109711,
0.6879025698,
-0.6302592754,
-0.6556148529,
-0.0689885989,
-0.8270925879,
-0.41269508,
0.1580123305,
-0.6041632891,
0.150457412,
-0.0764544532,
0.5243424177,
0.6917313337,
-0.5102394819,
0.4063980877,
0.9266732931,
-0.5948649049,
0.2391753495,
0.4873998165,
-0.0294736996,
0.2668872774,
-0.0297162626,
0.1725468785,
-0.4275046885,
-0.4634438455,
-0.1931171566,
-0.0660533458,
-0.7116336823,
-0.2646243572,
-0.7627382278,
0.0415173098,
-0.192048803,
-0.4029524028,
-0.2804582715,
-0.586653173,
-0.024438452,
-0.1024781093,
0.5112848282,
0.8991082907,
-0.2151092142,
0.3892530799,
-0.6069536209,
0.2860317528,
0.1587974429,
0.8508116603,
0.1698171496,
-0.4207644165,
-0.003187069,
0.0342024006,
0.0594087392,
-0.1129245535,
0.1674058586,
-0.3010232151,
0.5637930632,
-0.0605374239,
-0.40139696,
0.5083246231,
-0.6777813435,
0.7910399437,
0.1218237281,
-1.0120198727,
0.1838078052,
-0.5335520506,
-0.0744872615,
0.3188640773,
0.4666392207,
-0.787252903,
-0.3846844435,
-0.439014852,
-0.8519082069,
0.5787876248,
-0.0478666052,
0.6148036122,
0.1571975946,
0.2607995868,
0.4713817835,
0.3936950862,
-1.0172467232,
0.0455802009,
0.1652787179,
-0.4008424282,
0.0824036747,
0.0472936481,
-0.0089889551,
0.1090062559,
0.4650074542,
-0.0151019376,
0.1009922177,
-0.210656926,
0.0085545862,
0.065343,
0.4879250228,
-0.0009121408,
0.6737927794,
0.1423678547,
-0.1626819074,
-0.0177942384,
-0.283431083,
0.0645625889,
0.0509065762,
-0.0391785763,
-0.3496409953,
0.0844664425,
0.5464289784,
-0.2021774501,
-0.808840096,
0.9543479085,
-0.4023905694,
-0.1810666472,
-0.2439583391,
0.1841511279,
0.1871398389,
0.4441773593,
0.2141800225,
-0.5527256131,
0.1920302212,
-0.5052626133,
0.3679938614,
0.5657786131,
-0.1754002869,
0.1877533495,
0.5964685082,
0.0633697659,
-0.0237616692,
0.8130167723,
-0.0399655402,
-0.2921594679,
0.5839313865,
0.7963067889,
0.4023384452,
0.2889929712,
0.0366025083,
-0.289409548,
-0.0131903542,
-0.1832967997,
0.535597682,
0.3441579938,
-1.0062263012,
-0.4537655711,
-0.9154779911,
-0.4117577374,
0.0051600095,
-0.2595307827,
0.3761219382,
-0.4376434684,
-0.1746932417,
0.0798651427,
0.058021605,
-1.1511374712,
0.2931219935,
0.4575469494,
1.3005603552,
-0.7189007401,
0.6403777003,
0.3408975303,
0.0300592221,
-0.7779162526,
-0.2352243662,
0.0459591225,
-0.8037276864,
0.8241425157,
-0.0660393238,
0.0411081761,
-0.3001565635,
-0.7830053568,
-0.7510353923,
1.076485157,
0.3616273701,
-0.654504776,
0.2818790674,
0.5195998549,
0.6068100333,
-0.5421192646,
-0.1661075205,
0.319721967,
0.5843455195,
-0.0995403454,
-0.8844194412,
0.0717773065,
0.0121564409,
-0.0657920539,
-0.0609222502,
-0.6591582894,
0.988178134,
0.0401051976,
-0.1054891646,
0.051555071,
0.6980050802,
0.3785803914,
0.2969478071,
0.8032910228,
0.3831900656,
0.9525649548,
0.0055129081,
1.0350962877,
-0.0720805228,
0.2633510828,
0.8905360103,
-0.9942747355,
0.766385138,
0.4059130251,
-0.3952251077,
0.5853570104,
0.024444079,
-0.0833577365,
0.2183176428,
0.6443914771,
-0.2482368201,
-0.1090640724,
-0.7177523375,
-0.0875819325,
0.8606699705,
0.7404770255,
-0.1345839351,
-0.2302581668,
0.1243020445,
0.2471694648,
0.4719665349,
-0.516335845,
0.6422867179,
0.1674006879,
-0.2256005108,
0.0006340161,
0.3340564072,
0.6886175871,
-0.5369036794,
-0.0885014459,
0.0039209784,
0.0750714466,
-0.2216167003,
-1.2041971684,
0.2223361582,
0.3451919556,
-0.4355944991,
-0.32377249,
0.6676004529,
-0.2338559777,
-0.4674513042,
0.7519451976,
0.7943832874,
0.0250124987,
0.377903223,
-0.4147902131,
0.3023447394,
-0.3783197403,
-0.1989369243,
0.3841445446,
0.5918734074,
-0.3213107884,
0.7888066173,
0.6923784018,
0.0580251254,
-0.1410408914,
0.2425470203,
0.8379477859,
-0.7586528659,
-0.63812536,
-0.7594869137,
0.3287661076,
-0.0421025269,
0.2962051332,
0.5947167873,
0.4427187443,
0.7719324827,
0.250190109,
0.8410972953,
-0.3230231702,
0.7128565907,
-0.5556966662,
0.7331362367,
-0.6433168054,
0.3556096554,
-0.3492852449,
-0.7121195197,
-0.4040214419,
0.244041726,
-0.2776896954,
0.1228772625,
0.1289831549,
0.8142953515,
-0.1616388261,
0.3729688227,
0.3468642533,
0.3692655861,
0.4659588039,
0.5611143708,
1.1290307045,
-0.0437532328,
0.2331798822,
0.0540303588,
-0.3730997443,
0.1303079575,
-1.1805281639,
-0.6044268608,
-0.41655761,
0.0599533841,
-0.5377027392,
0.0465025902,
1.0355839729,
0.646923542,
-0.6046543121,
-0.4657613337,
0.2484027147,
0.3191090226,
0.3820423484,
-0.2510915995,
0.0933290422,
-0.0769021809,
-0.7979351878,
0.1562480181,
0.2507047355,
0.0666209459,
-0.2477763742,
0.0235708691,
0.1777973622,
0.18965289,
0.6105833054,
-0.1739364266,
-0.2981574237,
-0.1858750284,
-0.2257542014,
-0.4536008239,
-0.0858704746,
0.8058321476,
-0.9943676591,
0.0344743393,
0.1968514472,
0.9075904489,
0.1381363571,
-0.2183713019,
0.6952354312,
-0.6736998558,
0.3000827134,
0.0974241942,
0.432729423,
0.4978288412,
-0.4077796638,
0.4863871336,
-0.0359115563,
-0.4573075175,
-0.8425682187,
0.1413698643,
-0.8496569395,
-0.4537109435,
1.1628553867,
0.0269272048,
-0.1796141714,
-0.2153946757,
0.2577838004,
-0.050801117,
-0.2593776584,
0.8352581859,
0.8115689754,
0.1830070913,
0.5605753064,
-0.8987591267,
0.2947920561,
0.285993427,
-0.9628244042,
0.5231384635,
0.6157150865,
0.1842575073,
-0.0451865569,
0.754057467,
-0.5991005898,
0.2794372141,
-0.2574647963,
-0.1146803722,
0.2431492507,
-0.4112672806,
-0.4464021027,
0.0085943099,
0.3977548778,
0.3839313686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11921v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11921v1
|
Adaptative Bilingual Aligning Using Multilingual Sentence Embedding
| 2024-03-18T16:19:41 | 2024-03-18T16:19:41 |
Olivier Kraif
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present an adaptive bitextual alignment system called
AIlign. This aligner relies on sentence embeddings to extract reliable anchor
points that can guide the alignment path, even for texts whose parallelism is
fragmentary and not strictly monotonic. In an experiment on several datasets,
we show that AIlign achieves results equivalent to the state of the art, with
quasi-linear complexity. In addition, AIlign is able to handle texts whose
parallelism and monotonicity properties are only satisfied locally, unlike
recent systems such as Vecalign or Bertalign.
|
[
-0.0607648306,
-0.6370539665,
0.2876784205,
0.8153551221,
-0.1994013637,
0.0378974117,
-0.3715213835,
-0.3164773583,
0.5982269049,
-0.0420204177,
-0.5242893696,
-0.4009200633,
-0.4837690592,
0.3215028346,
-0.1532112062,
0.7810305953,
-0.3795315921,
0.2727498114,
-0.4148922563,
-0.8203962445,
-0.8010744452,
0.0502697974,
-0.4284086525,
-0.1371899545,
0.2561005056,
0.8118695617,
1.0591309071,
1.0144568682,
0.3430384696,
0.2563907802,
0.2228710651,
0.2633119226,
-0.1466402858,
0.2689385414,
-0.3918354511,
-0.6397712827,
-0.3012168705,
-0.570474565,
0.9881599545,
0.5367705226,
-0.2128976434,
-0.0908968821,
0.1001884341,
0.4967835546,
-0.2870218158,
0.1156307757,
-0.5569016933,
0.0910150781,
-0.4091731012,
0.0420944653,
-0.2388157099,
-0.5007837415,
0.1075531542,
-0.8862017393,
-0.3705401123,
0.4654664695,
0.7574367523,
0.4403583705,
-0.5912227035,
-0.5034824014,
-0.5341618061,
0.7787625194,
-0.688555181,
0.5779364705,
0.1462299377,
0.0804891512,
0.2013261318,
-0.4297395945,
-0.4480520487,
0.2212456018,
-0.2313165069,
0.4559753239,
-0.1275024712,
-0.2384642214,
-0.1031028107,
0.233962357,
-0.9261806011,
0.5218527317,
-0.0497237891,
-0.3581704199,
0.4961902201,
0.2824075818,
0.8529832959,
-0.2627168298,
-0.8526887894,
-0.1067413166,
-0.6440588832,
0.3299955428,
0.2861891687,
0.2572864592,
-0.323718816,
0.463013351,
0.2979208827,
0.6620642543,
0.0253575537,
-0.223111093,
0.2929280996,
-0.5584661365,
0.0765243024,
0.5760490298,
1.0464508533,
0.4125032127,
0.4222108722,
-0.1225800365,
0.0123475539,
-0.1635272503,
-0.0610268861,
-0.384642452,
0.0409024693,
0.1176093519,
-0.3517714739,
0.0961311609,
0.244211033,
-0.8418141007,
-0.227062121,
-0.1351626664,
0.2390809506,
-0.6347315311,
-0.1129559278,
0.031235313,
0.1203257143,
0.3153193593,
0.1037862897,
-1.2135938406,
0.1731543839,
0.6482385993,
1.1745346785,
-0.2479929477,
-0.8042823076,
-0.5351074338,
0.3053955734,
-0.1380635202,
0.8137131929,
-0.4235334992,
-0.2726636231,
0.1107833609,
0.1725899577,
-0.495592773,
-0.4926150739,
0.7118449807,
-0.3595091701,
0.3475967348,
-0.2283507884,
-0.5990382433,
0.0025877196,
0.4957078099,
-0.5511202216,
0.8350967169,
-0.0679888725,
-0.9102116227,
0.186814636,
-0.503860116,
-0.8268814087,
-0.076412335,
-0.0075046145,
-0.3994342387,
-0.1949207336,
0.838114202,
-0.1358204633,
-0.0047766687,
0.3191128075,
-0.3619247973,
-0.1556071639,
-0.0618182309,
-0.4145202041,
1.0361874104,
0.1760104895,
-0.2568709552,
0.1919669658,
-0.5608944893,
-0.1685608178,
-0.0932409987,
-0.5282780528,
-0.5571367741,
0.2024079114,
0.0938010067,
-0.1232102662,
0.4157107472,
-0.5749798417,
0.517490983,
-0.5816886425,
0.2763906121,
0.829176724,
-0.1759475172,
0.6779636741,
-0.3637453616,
0.8828955889,
0.2025701404,
0.0256237648,
-0.5859899521,
-0.6243079305,
-0.9104252458,
-0.3836468458,
0.6048815846,
1.2599021196,
-0.9826276302,
0.3784679174,
-0.6131095886,
-0.1680933833,
-0.9017465711,
0.3938448727,
0.4113338888,
0.5498101115,
0.4279351234,
-0.1716146469,
-0.4536345303,
-0.951995194,
-0.6322142482,
-0.2305487841,
0.3718977273,
0.0405655168,
0.0390016213,
0.015411091,
0.77762115,
-0.1390606016,
-0.4427283704,
0.4034922421,
0.2472492009,
0.1181721315,
0.560002327,
0.730822742,
-0.811544776,
-1.0068233013,
0.3277747035,
-1.0245025158,
-0.1579377949,
-0.2464033663,
-0.1690990776,
0.0726180226,
0.9411064386,
-0.3152703941,
0.1128019467,
0.683381021,
-0.5419225097,
0.134448871,
-0.5020003319,
-0.0539421961,
-1.4225410223,
-0.1308872253,
-0.0762325451,
-0.9115925431,
-0.3530701101,
-0.045543272,
0.4728031158,
0.0041132774,
-0.1994015574,
0.6101035476,
-0.6515707374,
-0.0229513235,
-0.0871933103,
0.2273280919,
0.0066130408,
0.0728941485,
-0.2090386599,
0.9103112817,
0.6276586652,
-0.1743565947,
0.4795143604,
0.6146277785,
-0.4074747264,
0.9724673629,
-0.4368282259,
-0.1633642167,
-0.4024297297,
0.1705582887,
-0.9502187371,
-0.2110440731,
0.2459541559,
-0.270968467,
0.2179679126,
0.1336025,
-0.4356066883,
-0.3095519543,
-0.3362894058,
0.7487152815,
0.1026798412,
-0.7956427336,
0.4302152693,
0.2398556918,
-0.6967787147,
-0.7392596006,
-0.7904316783,
0.0918018445,
-0.3898703456,
-0.7544139028,
0.4730763137,
-0.1590785682,
-0.2728813291,
0.3012169003,
0.3198632896,
0.1808400005,
-0.078030847,
-0.0903227106,
0.27564466,
-0.7366030812,
0.4689910412,
0.5385125875,
-0.0819210485,
-0.3367421925,
-0.5335890651,
0.1688255966,
-0.2589562535,
-0.4339956045,
-0.3997397125,
0.5970438719,
0.7653102279,
-0.2996122241,
0.6684580445,
0.8147593737,
-0.497245729,
0.1250162572,
-0.3090690076,
0.3087485433,
-0.4068591595,
0.151651755,
-0.2993825674,
-0.8837372065,
0.6321067214,
0.1709745377,
0.0525852889,
0.443002224,
0.7798584104,
-0.0562237203,
1.012996316,
0.606611371,
-0.2374139279,
0.4112627208,
0.614615202,
0.3596187234,
-0.5636374354,
-0.1364590526,
-0.2428090721,
-0.5221047401,
-0.7907813787,
-0.1289676875,
0.5662823319,
0.3342999518,
0.0579801835,
0.5376102328,
-0.1924536079,
0.4458790421,
0.6325684786,
-0.0230899062,
0.3434248865,
-0.1557179838,
-0.5667678118,
-0.3469904363,
-0.6820927262,
-0.2522542775,
0.8229057193,
0.222145319,
0.7847238183,
0.5511648059,
0.6134795547,
0.1773779094,
0.3665679991,
-0.8138697147,
-0.0006789028,
-0.4025742412,
-0.4667812884,
-0.2044115365,
-0.0862640366,
-0.8596799374,
0.2638764381,
-0.3174256682,
-1.0237725973,
0.5573657155,
0.2570134699,
-0.4450055659,
0.1225380599,
-0.945507586,
0.9567741156,
-0.3262784481,
-0.3277689219,
0.0476881191,
-0.4950295687,
0.1501627564,
-0.0977128819,
0.4837792516,
-0.0994072556,
-0.2458322495,
0.6763118505,
-0.4247462153,
0.5339069963,
-0.1659587324,
-0.0051325811,
0.1085049137,
0.0378914066,
0.5117393732,
0.2860106826,
-0.2046571672,
-0.2670029104,
0.1486871988,
-0.468572557,
-0.5268108845,
1.2262939215,
-0.60271281,
-0.6043173671,
-0.3678150773,
-1.1315996647,
-0.4252540171,
0.4495945573,
0.2007049769,
0.2882146239,
-0.1419718713,
0.0729034841,
0.197203204,
-0.1819778085,
0.8578542471,
0.3077889681,
-0.3499589562,
-0.8210856915,
1.1252686977,
0.1092097983,
-0.1086571366,
0.4553288221,
0.2105440944,
-0.5114959478,
-0.2322930247,
-0.8670070171,
0.3909484446,
-0.8053430319,
-0.3478259444,
-0.5036513805,
0.154842943,
-0.7134221792,
-0.3009197414,
-0.2952144742,
-0.5648981929,
-0.3619351387,
-0.0071145706,
0.1238163933,
0.6983000636,
-0.287666589,
0.2624237239,
-1.0181684494,
0.1328125,
0.2046993971,
0.1971367449,
-0.3653446436,
-0.3618079722,
-0.2692426443,
-0.1210200191,
-0.3609316051,
-0.8235943317,
0.2810722888,
0.4751494229,
0.5934023261,
0.4437400997,
-0.0700164214,
0.9278883934,
-0.659324944,
0.5954840779,
0.323841095,
-1.0755112171,
0.3361474574,
-0.3768779635,
0.789036572,
0.5958126783,
0.7411181331,
-0.5431134701,
-0.2058202773,
-0.1366843134,
-0.7389073968,
0.5847762227,
-0.1288360953,
0.1712911874,
0.0729917362,
0.2574824095,
0.1264200211,
-0.1865448803,
-1.0105085373,
-0.1491843015,
-0.2807070613,
-0.9991402626,
-0.1008149385,
-0.1592401117,
-0.0967369899,
-0.3857064843,
0.5819798708,
-0.4117062092,
0.0265555885,
0.2587333024,
-0.5357359052,
-0.064131707,
0.2025999576,
0.6624199748,
0.7164697647,
0.2350343466,
0.0901562423,
0.1139879599,
-0.1454377472,
0.2234604359,
0.5222358108,
-0.2634153664,
-0.0959141031,
0.653226912,
0.925029099,
0.2572127879,
-0.6034542918,
0.6897677183,
-0.0178893916,
-0.1185159311,
-0.1103976518,
-0.3761255443,
0.3851627409,
0.661975503,
-0.0638021529,
0.0829173476,
-0.1051215827,
-0.433817476,
0.1018483266,
0.379091531,
-0.7779974937,
-0.3609498739,
0.9021072388,
0.0352904052,
-0.5061910152,
0.7435231805,
-0.0746595562,
-0.5836826563,
0.3026541173,
0.9925590754,
0.6212416291,
-0.5977627635,
0.1840758324,
0.4244624674,
0.3167656362,
0.0346318521,
0.262879163,
-0.0475977734,
-0.8617153764,
-0.2868455648,
-0.5999777913,
-0.3171212077,
-0.493463397,
-0.7928440571,
0.3786046505,
-0.2509689927,
0.1552774906,
0.1134035066,
-0.8325643539,
-0.3791875541,
-0.113535881,
0.2545305192,
0.7538866997,
-1.0342935324,
0.9635862112,
1.1517837048,
-0.0745316222,
-0.3814649284,
0.2469955236,
0.2467079461,
-1.168159008,
0.2064601481,
0.1679120511,
0.1586877406,
0.1299873143,
0.0222811177,
-0.887955904,
1.1892776489,
0.6222311854,
-0.5837422609,
-0.3135479391,
0.3484657407,
0.4493458569,
-0.4131561816,
0.0100278528,
0.4547519684,
0.6258271933,
-0.3987766206,
-1.2091879845,
-0.0093520274,
-0.3746293187,
0.0652635545,
0.0745053664,
-0.7309724092,
0.765016377,
0.0571745522,
-0.2825882733,
0.1794151962,
0.6693206429,
-0.1536435187,
0.0220849048,
0.6881965399,
0.7827708721,
0.7845631242,
-0.1295979917,
0.7917090058,
-0.4543181062,
0.3574416339,
1.2218961716,
-0.0325620808,
0.9035093188,
0.7499284148,
0.0490448028,
0.8430566788,
0.4306831658,
0.3074690104,
0.410608232,
-0.2560738027,
-0.2589425445,
-0.2286630124,
-0.313126266,
0.0346716866,
0.6006730795,
0.4618299305,
-0.2375588864,
-0.3416389227,
0.6109195352,
0.2094301283,
0.4208272696,
-0.1030296311,
0.7895240784,
0.1365033984,
-1.1521434784,
0.4377225935,
0.0523003079,
0.66948843,
-0.482401818,
0.1477473676,
-0.3086755872,
0.5491864085,
-0.1086210683,
-0.8454259634,
0.4036600888,
-0.3070262372,
-0.1345083714,
-0.5046120286,
0.5971204638,
-0.8894103169,
-0.5353861451,
0.4457799792,
0.4063207209,
-0.4116674066,
0.4375742376,
-0.7886276841,
-0.0169475302,
0.1577273458,
-0.0377315804,
-0.0179029219,
0.277284503,
-0.2518919408,
0.454703629,
0.1201284826,
-0.0560192838,
0.3340605497,
-0.079452917,
0.5300674438,
-0.5636692643,
-0.766730845,
-0.9764759541,
0.5795881152,
0.0761140957,
-0.3481626511,
0.9074873924,
0.4760705233,
0.8967205882,
0.1295737624,
0.5126055479,
0.1343141496,
0.4794459641,
-0.7486770153,
0.3753883243,
-0.822935462,
0.0409764946,
0.037079718,
-0.9911743999,
-0.6040232778,
0.3433783948,
-0.1214488819,
-0.507109642,
0.9523441792,
0.7072603703,
-0.5741615295,
0.0848617405,
0.0198107269,
0.1685849875,
0.2184434682,
0.4355320632,
0.6052112579,
-0.4632829428,
0.6127054691,
-0.2290662527,
-0.2480288297,
0.0161525644,
-0.8634359241,
-0.4820246994,
-0.6157360077,
-0.2381871641,
-0.1909745932,
-0.0204050578,
0.8167348504,
0.3747648001,
-0.9822309017,
-0.3250285983,
-0.0253512822,
0.1230605543,
-0.0750225782,
-0.2966441512,
0.4225528836,
-0.544742167,
-0.9766881466,
0.5031354427,
0.5801541209,
0.0471438803,
-0.0892922133,
-0.1208746359,
-0.5663732886,
-0.0962035432,
0.3031044006,
0.5357573032,
-0.7461444139,
-0.4902152419,
0.1277973503,
-0.0161643382,
0.3740196824,
0.78901577,
-0.3236483932,
1.0785653591,
0.4642647803,
0.8020572066,
0.3811589479,
0.1029717475,
0.7904652953,
-0.783455193,
0.5103651285,
-0.0615310483,
0.7317387462,
0.551005125,
-0.2364851534,
0.0232275929,
0.2127683908,
-0.4987094402,
-0.4961336553,
0.0476141423,
-0.8019920588,
0.0725929663,
0.8851220012,
-0.6267673373,
-0.2466387004,
0.0360296331,
-0.1375401765,
0.1656292379,
0.133580178,
0.2979272306,
1.0483748913,
-0.0673506036,
-0.272036314,
-0.1102185696,
0.1273915619,
0.7936719656,
-0.9470818639,
-0.2936116755,
0.2132893652,
0.2388617694,
0.311188221,
0.6636241078,
-0.1660847962,
0.2941420972,
-0.1078684404,
-0.3614691198,
0.3217598498,
-0.2693296075,
-0.5589243174,
-0.253331989,
0.3151923418,
-0.0719901621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11905v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11905v2
|
Tur[k]ingBench: A Challenge Benchmark for Web Agents
| 2024-03-18T16:06:30 | 2024-03-21T21:57:13 |
Kevin Xu, Yeganeh Kordi, Kate Sanders, Yizhong Wang, Adam Byerly, Jack Zhang, Benjamin Van Durme, Daniel Khashabi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC
|
Recent chatbots have demonstrated impressive ability to understand and
communicate in raw-text form. However, there is more to the world than raw
text. For example, humans spend long hours of their time on web pages, where
text is intertwined with other modalities and tasks are accomplished in the
form of various complex interactions. Can state-of-the-art multi-modal models
generalize to such complex domains?
To address this question, we introduce TurkingBench, a benchmark of tasks
formulated as web pages containing textual instructions with multi-modal
context. Unlike existing work which employs artificially synthesized web pages,
here we use natural HTML pages that were originally designed for crowdsourcing
workers for various annotation purposes. The HTML instructions of each task are
also instantiated with various values (obtained from the crowdsourcing tasks)
to form new instances of the task. This benchmark contains 32.2K instances
distributed across 158 tasks.
Additionally, to facilitate the evaluation on TurkingBench, we develop an
evaluation framework that connects the responses of chatbots to modifications
on web pages (modifying a text box, checking a radio, etc.). We evaluate the
performance of state-of-the-art models, including language-only, vision-only,
and layout-only models, and their combinations, on this benchmark. Our findings
reveal that these models perform significantly better than random chance, yet
considerable room exists for improvement. We hope this benchmark will help
facilitate the evaluation and development of web-based agents.
|
[
-0.4363114238,
-0.7885895371,
0.2047198713,
0.2072110176,
-0.1251798719,
0.1237839311,
-0.3645904958,
-0.6730371714,
-0.2633112073,
0.1492761821,
-0.5894610286,
-0.2775240541,
-0.3364331722,
0.1909111738,
-0.3112600744,
0.7219115496,
0.1840199828,
0.0192590952,
-0.6850393414,
-0.0624141991,
-0.2374700904,
-0.5203365088,
-0.4177734852,
-0.1066044345,
0.4783654213,
0.294881314,
0.7569094896,
0.5142841339,
0.7193145156,
0.470232904,
0.1850260943,
0.3222355545,
-0.4137723446,
0.4925054908,
-0.2778963745,
-0.4478042126,
-0.3194628656,
0.2726331651,
0.4063956141,
0.7298980355,
-0.0565876737,
0.264746964,
0.1089694202,
0.4919598699,
-0.8112283945,
0.3622351587,
-0.5787326097,
-0.1265629381,
-0.1306852847,
0.1199259534,
-0.4454762042,
-0.2069901824,
0.2210592628,
-0.7193264961,
0.3310413063,
0.0724486187,
0.8825487494,
0.3243845701,
-0.4934607446,
-0.006032919,
-0.709346056,
0.7275488377,
-0.5354255438,
0.7106798291,
0.5094915032,
0.6336289048,
-0.4287375808,
-0.6854762435,
-0.7699952722,
-0.6671431065,
0.0962136984,
0.1440756023,
-0.3814845383,
0.0647511929,
0.1852126867,
0.1367285401,
-0.506315589,
-0.1693965495,
-0.2285364568,
-0.3317282796,
0.4825794399,
0.1705527157,
0.2330714762,
-0.1864647716,
-0.2506408095,
-0.6296656728,
0.0407335758,
0.1358910799,
0.2458977997,
0.383148104,
-0.2869863808,
0.6367172003,
-0.4413297772,
0.7024197578,
0.0312001351,
-0.042501431,
0.2126109004,
-0.160025537,
-0.1334956735,
-0.5302838683,
0.7420472503,
0.5352668762,
0.0305325612,
-0.3652896881,
-0.0325738676,
0.2070276737,
0.5626384616,
-0.6044681072,
-0.1518820077,
0.2548315227,
-0.5826237798,
-0.2052022666,
0.0808994696,
-0.6791459918,
-0.7027586102,
-0.178613022,
0.4590687454,
-0.4231466055,
-0.2677313685,
-0.1552821696,
-0.372484982,
0.2622842491,
0.5885011554,
-0.2802945673,
0.378682673,
0.7843076587,
0.772053659,
-0.2438014746,
-0.3747226596,
-0.588267982,
-0.0664086342,
-0.3042963147,
0.9763375521,
-0.7743928432,
-0.2805376649,
0.0825867057,
-0.044538632,
-0.12207257,
-0.3432007432,
0.5401636362,
-0.4748700261,
0.3450130224,
-0.022147188,
-0.6073334217,
-0.3584076166,
0.6114257574,
-1.0246095657,
0.995290339,
0.1334706098,
-0.4894677401,
0.2311400473,
-0.8201147318,
-0.4108428061,
-0.0651432052,
0.0709505305,
-0.2594404519,
0.0922467411,
-0.2204050422,
0.4372323453,
-0.6800806522,
-0.2431606948,
-0.4827496707,
-0.1100084335,
0.6885522604,
-0.4940761924,
0.4091755748,
0.1926249266,
-0.4865917265,
0.2879651189,
-0.9347976446,
0.2286943346,
-0.0362727642,
-0.4718683362,
-0.1047884896,
0.1945420504,
0.4650508761,
0.2968567014,
0.1642658561,
-0.5260767341,
0.018455185,
-0.0598485097,
0.1215910912,
0.6438853741,
-0.2185029984,
0.2522493005,
-0.6519432068,
0.4955029786,
-0.3266507089,
0.2907526195,
-0.0633510649,
-0.3344798386,
-0.9089316726,
-0.2485458553,
0.2853482962,
0.4033942223,
-0.6209435463,
0.1545653045,
-0.3316432536,
-0.9525539279,
-0.3615460098,
-0.1073291674,
0.6268297434,
0.156046927,
0.2382179052,
-0.4809753299,
-0.2800095677,
-0.9320041537,
-0.4207755923,
-0.1920733601,
-0.2370056361,
0.3187718689,
0.2833493054,
-0.1145723611,
0.81986624,
0.1808753759,
-0.0754434764,
-0.0664767399,
0.3999764621,
-0.2085645944,
0.5924905539,
0.2622844875,
-0.9356655478,
-0.6937667727,
0.2343452722,
-0.630420506,
-0.0473939143,
-0.1967318207,
-0.1529503018,
0.3962887228,
0.3295811415,
-0.7102025747,
0.4455088675,
0.5865908861,
-0.2590850592,
0.5381810665,
-0.1214649156,
0.4062628746,
-0.7861827016,
0.2460749447,
0.1124831513,
-0.5451889038,
-0.6738728285,
0.2855316103,
0.1550201625,
-0.2155416459,
-0.3816712201,
0.5459609628,
-0.5140137672,
0.007693897,
-0.3905721605,
0.1467308104,
0.0305479318,
0.7288347483,
-0.3035030663,
0.7347103953,
0.1858706474,
-0.6381751299,
0.5942708254,
0.0646271259,
-0.2682626247,
0.8029729128,
-0.6327763796,
0.5131655335,
0.0434118956,
0.3125171363,
-0.9348316193,
-0.300655365,
0.229058966,
-0.578395009,
-0.0648377612,
-0.0675417706,
-0.7670289278,
-0.2639137506,
-0.309453696,
0.1915600598,
0.2240307331,
-0.1469443142,
0.9166992903,
0.3920839429,
0.0238867067,
-0.2530380189,
-0.1918883026,
0.2746039629,
0.0105482228,
-0.6464511156,
0.431770891,
-0.1040629596,
-0.3787102401,
-0.0095340461,
-0.1313277632,
-0.3967561424,
0.1855081618,
0.4101940989,
0.0279167965,
-0.0202491358,
0.1732918322,
-0.3624407053,
-0.1596534848,
-0.0811618939,
-0.0366429947,
0.6674655676,
-0.2474020422,
-0.6844061017,
-0.936981678,
0.4217891693,
0.728846252,
-0.4816619754,
0.6204369068,
0.6022856832,
-0.3988133073,
0.0909173563,
-0.9439083338,
-0.0411831215,
-0.4904416502,
0.3535177112,
-0.5020067692,
-0.6109704375,
0.5387140512,
-0.2271826714,
0.2560873032,
0.4435861409,
0.5476629138,
-0.2109098881,
1.104772687,
0.8504601121,
0.0106349494,
0.5919662714,
0.0971482843,
-0.2976634204,
-0.3082685769,
-0.3008178473,
-0.7396692634,
-0.3480165899,
-0.5893104672,
-0.7836288214,
0.4962512255,
-0.0229711104,
-0.0992388204,
0.2511920631,
-0.4214399755,
0.3030005693,
0.95170784,
0.1301541477,
0.1642977148,
-0.1466766745,
0.0888272747,
0.2247502804,
-0.4233135581,
-0.6208081841,
1.1071461439,
-0.0968452767,
0.4570806623,
0.1972530335,
0.0876537263,
0.6982575059,
0.249909848,
-0.4068145156,
0.521003902,
0.2371460646,
-0.7638247609,
-0.4184459746,
-0.2460131049,
-1.213971138,
0.5432131886,
-0.4701809585,
-0.7561218143,
-0.1469451487,
0.0174554046,
-0.0038264845,
0.1723416895,
-0.6547937393,
1.1595513821,
-0.129471451,
-0.6267451048,
-0.7678995132,
-0.6612753272,
-0.1839776784,
0.2636333406,
0.2580641806,
-0.3351532221,
0.0052603874,
0.4607721567,
-0.4859615564,
0.9657461047,
-0.1797463149,
0.1875699908,
0.2694236338,
0.3109586835,
0.5972753167,
-0.3198527992,
-0.1529640406,
-0.0503038019,
0.2394093871,
-0.6404611468,
-0.5257863998,
0.2131562084,
-0.7619095445,
-0.3835585713,
-0.349530071,
-0.4350585341,
-0.4330745041,
0.1474599987,
-0.1605982184,
0.5322798491,
-0.5815110207,
0.4095652103,
0.1566681862,
-0.1570557952,
0.3795096278,
0.5970244408,
0.0303090326,
-0.1745477021,
0.7638172507,
-0.4242085218,
0.2342490852,
0.5392439365,
0.1066295728,
-0.2192392051,
-0.2466808259,
-0.6709058285,
-0.1789553016,
-0.6403018236,
-0.1955874413,
-0.593886435,
0.0935288891,
-0.2428346127,
0.0688285455,
-0.5034919977,
-0.4583795667,
0.0777892023,
0.2343370169,
0.3146221638,
0.5712076426,
-0.2140421271,
0.2065480351,
-0.9879078269,
0.4289512932,
0.4751583636,
0.4774262011,
0.1748094559,
-0.0217936281,
-0.2974464297,
0.241341725,
-0.4381505549,
-0.8994470835,
-0.0196951553,
0.1659697145,
0.8201131821,
0.3246737123,
0.1302939057,
0.6641800404,
-0.291302532,
0.5480192304,
0.0478232764,
-0.953322947,
0.2581884265,
-0.4642618001,
0.2792009115,
0.6107878685,
0.076895088,
-0.9705021381,
-0.4969207346,
-0.4313524961,
-0.465700537,
0.6867466569,
0.4648518562,
0.3058510423,
0.0775459632,
0.0334388614,
0.2786695659,
0.2517009974,
-0.5841019154,
-0.072538957,
-0.3236261606,
-0.1160317138,
0.2366258055,
-0.0509541258,
-0.0058130859,
-0.0168808047,
0.420938164,
-0.1195832416,
0.1864028424,
0.046342589,
-0.549726963,
-0.1513929367,
0.2623905838,
0.438158989,
0.6709974408,
0.0318097882,
0.0710669011,
0.0784245878,
-0.2827175558,
-0.1209364012,
0.4702185392,
0.2375112623,
-0.1235156879,
0.4413333237,
0.5353199244,
0.2532443702,
-1.1378455162,
0.5790575743,
-0.2243561,
0.1314899325,
-0.2277386934,
0.1713209003,
-0.0953358933,
0.5802804828,
0.5599862933,
-0.0843641534,
0.2755733728,
-0.5837682486,
0.0649919286,
0.5499014854,
-0.5186995268,
-0.3928106427,
0.6758338213,
0.5212671757,
-0.6473361254,
0.4234229922,
-0.4348127842,
-0.4882937968,
0.6439850926,
0.1987799257,
0.8338317871,
-0.0646092147,
0.2467676252,
0.1858998239,
0.1371447444,
0.2263547331,
0.2305030525,
-0.2977147996,
-0.5132223964,
-0.2518589795,
-0.3895823359,
-0.8761625886,
-0.1144650057,
-0.5821031928,
-0.0551720709,
-0.3763153851,
-0.271956712,
0.1862346679,
0.1330617815,
-0.9910256863,
0.0498025194,
0.1320755631,
0.5939856768,
-0.3595866561,
0.4097121358,
0.9146819115,
-0.3748520315,
-0.3408562839,
-0.1033041477,
0.2745552957,
-0.5023566484,
0.1766045988,
0.3697285652,
-0.2215604335,
-0.3142637908,
-0.500669539,
-0.7292556763,
0.6546880007,
0.1199996844,
-0.2449164242,
0.1912830919,
0.4217035174,
0.6064860821,
0.0865502432,
0.4382031858,
0.1938278377,
0.6726170182,
-0.3216998577,
-1.430847168,
0.0526009537,
-0.7801292539,
-0.1520310193,
-0.0846937299,
-0.8861583471,
0.9339662194,
0.2524047196,
-0.4169120789,
0.2360873967,
0.6303668618,
-0.0073850248,
0.1760876477,
0.836096108,
0.1714773327,
0.6854434013,
0.1656994373,
0.9683647752,
-0.3526190519,
0.161175251,
0.9513003826,
-0.154341042,
0.7778613567,
0.2159798145,
-0.3604886234,
0.6362413764,
0.4922983348,
-0.0336323194,
0.196132943,
0.1961367279,
-0.1802131236,
-0.4872324169,
-0.3485200107,
-0.1791873425,
0.8402649164,
0.0725410581,
0.2998103499,
-0.3955032825,
0.0510375015,
-0.0087979743,
0.3753251433,
0.0712767392,
0.9696523547,
-0.3640996516,
-0.6690874696,
0.4707276821,
0.32205531,
0.4779565334,
-0.5664857626,
-0.1088538989,
-0.0801049098,
0.2691553235,
0.1799661219,
-0.2427168489,
-0.0905445069,
0.1072030738,
-0.2280413508,
-0.0263149999,
0.6090646386,
-0.0520113967,
-0.5508729219,
0.0651055649,
0.7774173021,
0.1520694345,
-0.5434573889,
-0.6875341535,
0.1131382957,
-0.2185820192,
-0.3243609667,
0.266859442,
0.5877743363,
-0.3056121171,
0.860789597,
0.8414509296,
-0.4827014208,
0.2264126539,
0.015416964,
0.8877242804,
-0.6633968353,
-0.5331878662,
-0.6794666052,
0.4950253665,
-0.4030803144,
-0.3229756057,
0.692306459,
0.8270408511,
0.7322413921,
0.139152959,
0.92627877,
-0.2028611004,
0.5740841627,
-0.132070303,
0.7326357961,
-0.6447048783,
-0.4422734678,
-0.2805519998,
-0.8111499548,
-0.1402608007,
0.6026446819,
0.1826970279,
-0.0822411999,
0.5803976655,
0.6647799015,
-0.0791204721,
0.0832737908,
0.1986741871,
-0.0892177969,
0.438828975,
0.3651301265,
1.0794395208,
-0.1243462265,
0.9595023394,
-0.471526444,
-0.2272831202,
-0.4337362051,
-0.715252459,
-1.0930088758,
-0.8690146804,
-0.0535123758,
-0.1716994047,
0.0812066421,
1.0971788168,
0.9875692725,
-0.5936601162,
-0.3673726022,
0.0896747708,
0.032047078,
-0.5876405239,
-0.1519963443,
0.2117257416,
-0.4135674536,
-0.8780692816,
0.3162531853,
0.1366965622,
0.0399475656,
-0.2757040858,
0.1934410632,
-0.0943389237,
0.0901290998,
0.5047098398,
0.2093459964,
-0.7826674581,
-0.4979022145,
0.1434942484,
-0.3491185009,
0.1264341623,
0.7676897645,
-0.7661898732,
0.6437875032,
0.3538190424,
0.7436150312,
0.6491824389,
0.0482308306,
0.6447225809,
-0.5020747185,
0.3324852288,
0.2694707215,
0.0864719003,
0.3405041099,
0.1590167135,
0.5337468386,
-0.0659795478,
-0.1955995858,
-0.7074087262,
0.029006552,
-1.0626598597,
-0.3985646367,
0.8810382485,
0.0140221203,
-0.2166241854,
-0.2876747251,
-0.2339639366,
0.5082405806,
-0.4511908293,
1.187100172,
0.6616738439,
-0.0117824804,
-0.0516563319,
-0.6001030207,
0.3503345847,
0.3662828803,
-1.0418651104,
0.2188845575,
0.8410396576,
-0.0644961223,
0.1283688247,
0.5491257906,
0.2399341017,
0.5701479912,
0.1884466708,
0.4269792736,
-0.1577422619,
-0.1400241703,
0.2705073655,
0.2313746959,
-0.0318020135,
-0.4112092853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11904v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11904v3
|
CICLe: Conformal In-Context Learning for Largescale Multi-Class Food Risk Classification
| 2024-03-18T16:04:55 | 2024-05-30T08:37:45 |
Korbinian Randl, John Pavlopoulos, Aron Henriksson, Tony Lindgren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Contaminated or adulterated food poses a substantial risk to human health.
Given sets of labeled web texts for training, Machine Learning and Natural
Language Processing can be applied to automatically detect such risks. We
publish a dataset of 7,546 short texts describing public food recall
announcements. Each text is manually labeled, on two granularity levels (coarse
and fine), for food products and hazards that the recall corresponds to. We
describe the dataset and benchmark naive, traditional, and Transformer models.
Based on our analysis, Logistic Regression based on a tf-idf representation
outperforms RoBERTa and XLM-R on classes with low support. Finally, we discuss
different prompting strategies and present an LLM-in-the-loop framework, based
on Conformal Prediction, which boosts the performance of the base classifier
while reducing energy consumption compared to normal prompting.
|
[
-0.1023660302,
-0.5225520134,
0.4112238288,
-0.1747164577,
0.3682105541,
-0.3219614923,
-0.3205244541,
-0.6855338216,
-0.2879513204,
0.4944193959,
-0.0955717936,
-0.6282603741,
-0.6116065383,
0.2028523684,
-0.5117146969,
0.9854744077,
0.0193724241,
-0.0505117513,
-0.3302996457,
0.1153830737,
-0.2946429849,
-0.7483494282,
-0.6024765968,
0.0307484921,
0.6172829866,
0.8817882538,
0.3147290349,
0.2428175509,
0.2976589501,
0.2656992376,
-0.1314167082,
-0.1120049283,
-0.07504116,
0.22615619,
-0.275414288,
-0.4207612574,
-0.292862922,
-0.0822981447,
0.4335561693,
0.563865006,
-0.2358477414,
0.3513453603,
0.2105377764,
1.0803494453,
-0.803663373,
0.4015934169,
-0.7416728139,
0.0122499075,
0.0359589048,
0.0479466729,
-0.7070540786,
-0.5837856531,
0.3052046895,
-0.5859860182,
0.0784163922,
0.072538279,
0.4988063574,
0.2224048972,
-0.7193335295,
-0.7133467793,
-0.8177032471,
0.6859178543,
-0.3638154268,
0.3727189898,
0.5514576435,
0.4108146131,
-0.4353983998,
-0.8279902935,
-0.2712856531,
-0.0734886602,
0.070173718,
-0.0226724353,
-0.1637379229,
0.0456984341,
0.1285793483,
0.1596238166,
-0.3926486671,
0.0650068671,
-0.7254166603,
-0.0682308674,
0.4543876946,
0.0429370329,
0.1180124506,
0.0539525226,
-0.6398460865,
-0.529184103,
-0.5909531116,
0.2788613141,
0.1282151639,
0.312538594,
-0.0597453564,
0.3904440403,
-0.1931927502,
0.7408543229,
0.275621295,
-0.299145788,
0.3246471584,
-0.0709177554,
-0.2323703319,
0.4531055093,
0.5398621559,
0.5641530156,
0.2676244378,
0.1395948976,
-0.0888486132,
-0.2958137393,
0.3016217947,
-0.6586140394,
-0.3813619912,
0.1971796304,
-0.2686378956,
-0.2177125216,
0.3466835916,
-0.9155402184,
-0.4406582713,
-0.167002812,
0.236446023,
-0.4222847223,
0.1591917872,
0.1669040471,
-0.161971733,
0.1239161864,
0.2595019937,
-0.8128631711,
0.259257853,
0.3113754988,
0.6241706014,
0.0539847985,
0.2165903449,
-0.4562915564,
0.7398149371,
0.097353816,
1.061275363,
-0.7040342689,
-0.3931691647,
0.0297027901,
0.2356752157,
-0.0605795383,
-0.8344202042,
0.7904421687,
-0.3346390426,
-0.050700184,
-0.3514609933,
-0.5691289306,
-0.65433079,
0.4694598019,
-0.7701897621,
0.662976265,
0.1092248857,
-0.8227558732,
0.6029828191,
-0.3492131531,
-0.6762502789,
-0.0132377511,
-0.05940824,
-0.8283188939,
-0.1158550978,
0.1661195159,
0.7481881976,
-0.2130786628,
0.2614466846,
-0.4823402762,
-0.1079388633,
0.1735491306,
-0.4344594479,
0.2596711218,
0.1556690037,
-0.106145516,
0.4382097125,
-0.5671560764,
0.071852766,
-0.1187993363,
-0.7071946263,
-0.4445127547,
0.08308696,
0.3013498783,
0.2357249856,
-0.0967575312,
-0.219516173,
0.231151402,
-0.0294793863,
0.6207832098,
0.576618731,
0.3821981847,
0.5229311585,
-0.6259456873,
0.1364702135,
0.2834139168,
0.2499230951,
-0.2317542136,
-0.4659478366,
-0.1626634002,
-0.4281311035,
0.2802285552,
0.7040878534,
-0.2808942795,
0.6230452061,
-0.1467499137,
-0.3496671915,
0.2411841452,
-0.340565294,
0.1510492712,
0.5099651217,
0.4657799006,
0.1458003372,
-0.4470202625,
-0.7320950627,
-0.0967483297,
-0.1098110378,
-0.4652304053,
0.1007412449,
0.3449157178,
-0.4885323048,
0.7287413478,
-0.5161215663,
-0.4976563454,
-0.1661583632,
0.0789635256,
-0.0006648859,
0.4319432378,
0.3049402535,
-1.0879148245,
-0.757972002,
0.0763465837,
-0.570833981,
0.4390052259,
0.0459704027,
0.2228465974,
0.3395384252,
0.7075202465,
0.0393250547,
0.4588261247,
0.5590791702,
-0.0597917102,
0.3619396985,
-0.2308506966,
0.0933447704,
-1.0460581779,
-0.0559254363,
0.5257300138,
-0.076127395,
-0.6756973863,
-0.4132915437,
0.43672809,
-0.0455953814,
-0.5686247349,
0.4503960609,
-0.3688346148,
0.2710036933,
0.0654576346,
-0.2593044043,
-0.03993975,
0.2385151684,
0.1949233264,
0.7450863719,
0.1989290565,
-0.9630196095,
0.0285932403,
0.0070755132,
-0.3734873235,
0.532315433,
-0.357093662,
-0.1523025483,
-0.2125740945,
0.7587082386,
-1.221783638,
-0.5786553621,
0.4304712117,
0.0237811822,
0.4765824378,
-0.0431669801,
-0.6465162635,
-0.5990273952,
-0.3345417082,
0.4504548013,
0.1487734467,
-0.5669023991,
0.4396864474,
0.5784435272,
0.0042002895,
-0.0156827923,
-0.4762465954,
-0.3435127735,
-0.5286236405,
-0.2936003208,
-0.0292217545,
-0.2859962285,
-0.0632485151,
-0.3729573786,
-0.3830066323,
-0.3270436525,
0.1915040463,
0.5862956643,
0.1232551113,
0.2655579448,
0.273892045,
0.0875392258,
0.0472075008,
0.2037950903,
-0.4588848352,
0.2316907495,
-0.5971791148,
0.0635247156,
-0.4445319176,
0.1344615966,
0.3554225266,
0.255787164,
0.6409605145,
0.4901027679,
-0.681404233,
0.3365100026,
-0.3038584888,
-0.0814776719,
-0.4470526576,
0.1687505096,
-0.1247148961,
-0.5511772633,
0.09220846,
-0.2924177051,
-0.0071854577,
0.3854255378,
0.3092342019,
-0.3176829219,
0.581662178,
0.450873524,
-0.1336670518,
0.4625617564,
-0.1722604334,
-0.18258591,
-0.6850647926,
-0.5463581681,
-0.5649623275,
-0.0527319871,
-0.475697428,
-0.3654071391,
1.0162261724,
-0.1473853588,
-0.4503832459,
0.1937365532,
-0.6684259176,
0.6755390167,
0.3555706441,
0.3555778265,
0.3372820616,
-0.0440557003,
-0.2117179185,
0.2366884947,
-0.6566081047,
-0.5443790555,
1.0209496021,
0.4014371037,
1.0151894093,
-0.0528874695,
0.5951853395,
0.2952404022,
0.7003368735,
-0.8305544257,
0.0943863615,
-0.1310620904,
-0.9039358497,
-0.4823780954,
-0.3527710736,
-0.8585727811,
-0.0277458634,
-0.3285831511,
-0.8356308937,
-0.0058384039,
0.2693764269,
-0.4243445992,
0.413000524,
-1.047315836,
0.5208630562,
-0.312859118,
-0.0882820636,
0.0923591107,
-0.9218260646,
0.5249921083,
-0.1860814691,
0.5135848522,
-0.0814472958,
0.1483586431,
0.5572499037,
0.1617543548,
1.2373464108,
0.1258958727,
-0.127890408,
0.2078791261,
-0.1034678966,
0.6174874902,
0.2154522687,
-0.1446778625,
-0.014659347,
0.2912075222,
-0.2581433952,
-0.1450962871,
0.5891435742,
-0.3787607849,
-0.1827567816,
-0.7002242804,
-0.2630999088,
-0.2190932482,
0.1845473498,
0.4111397862,
0.2007536739,
-0.1964485943,
0.3172297776,
1.0764089823,
-0.2996833622,
0.3919712305,
0.1704232991,
0.0904990956,
-0.5160582066,
0.7973706126,
0.0681078956,
0.24608621,
0.7508758903,
0.5087569952,
-0.1607300639,
0.0124231847,
-0.2439034581,
-0.2511688769,
-0.76629287,
-0.7572197914,
-0.5610317588,
-0.2492257059,
-0.2127242982,
-0.4611709118,
-0.1786327511,
-0.0139868734,
-0.4452866912,
-0.0476614758,
0.0900570974,
0.899091959,
0.0657580644,
0.2223326713,
-1.0743260384,
0.1127832532,
0.2235552222,
0.3340640366,
0.2998788059,
-0.1539426297,
-0.3065897524,
-0.0270123091,
-0.5769198537,
-0.7988856435,
0.3455155194,
0.2018044442,
0.483140409,
0.716252923,
0.4440895617,
0.3284534216,
-0.3369934857,
0.5127958655,
0.6179551482,
-0.7315778136,
0.4416120648,
-0.1662350446,
0.5690502524,
0.5678366423,
0.9998242259,
-0.785993576,
-0.2491027415,
-0.4269919991,
-1.0303183794,
0.2453970909,
-0.2877280712,
-0.367613107,
-0.4166687131,
0.2413536906,
0.4359331727,
0.0688441321,
-0.7299220562,
-0.1203351021,
-0.1351304799,
-0.3165738285,
0.2155787796,
-0.4939478338,
-0.0604664125,
-0.4190679193,
0.5845507383,
-0.234581843,
0.1802005917,
0.20942837,
-0.171360746,
-0.2365105748,
0.5557673573,
0.8294805288,
0.5084471107,
-0.3077099323,
0.330296725,
0.3925275803,
-0.5146589875,
0.2023526132,
-0.3052619696,
0.1747552305,
-0.6175370216,
0.3908454478,
0.1127638444,
0.6884497404,
-0.6433374882,
0.3825547993,
-0.3051212132,
-0.4205293655,
-0.8063639998,
-0.0002139645,
0.0175472833,
0.1625157595,
0.4395026565,
0.0330024697,
0.4202375114,
-0.5833363533,
0.5494422913,
0.1298364699,
-0.5412862897,
-0.2648542821,
0.5046164393,
0.178817898,
0.2069199979,
0.6682667136,
0.0104972059,
-0.3773837388,
0.477071166,
0.5051136613,
0.5977797508,
-0.3639530838,
0.1775918156,
0.7232581377,
0.2021613568,
-0.2923048735,
-0.0215463638,
0.1082828641,
-0.38050735,
0.1956021041,
-0.5416442156,
-0.3228576481,
0.3172960281,
-0.9351172447,
0.2171707898,
-0.6025145054,
-0.0484695733,
0.1996264607,
-0.2823892832,
-0.6165710688,
0.1433495581,
0.4190172851,
0.9884439707,
-1.1083016396,
0.8434023261,
0.7743109465,
-0.3083282709,
-0.4433858991,
0.5856152773,
0.2786487043,
-0.3347548246,
0.5344434381,
0.5064083338,
0.0799278468,
-0.3274038136,
-0.6926537156,
-0.9533414841,
0.9309102893,
-0.1727037281,
-0.8483775258,
-0.2048840225,
-0.0772398412,
0.2199612856,
-0.3283245265,
0.0659763142,
0.4596331418,
0.82407552,
0.3382456303,
-0.6609425545,
0.0081183231,
0.4944629073,
0.0026020377,
0.2575020492,
-0.5952822566,
0.4839155376,
-0.3308235705,
-0.3055145442,
-0.2132218182,
0.8772800565,
0.104758434,
0.6161521673,
0.6888583302,
0.184726119,
1.0237920284,
0.0519421771,
0.8727936745,
0.0461066179,
0.2404115051,
1.1211081743,
-0.192682445,
0.861397922,
0.3830994964,
-0.0381853767,
0.4698069692,
0.9913472533,
0.1302736551,
0.7287519574,
0.2927759588,
-0.3417145312,
-0.0817919821,
0.2555272579,
-0.0492488518,
0.134784922,
0.8835096359,
-0.3649965227,
-0.3723533154,
0.4451537132,
-0.1059331968,
0.1400268376,
-0.4551720023,
0.9193089008,
0.0646052212,
-0.1827747971,
0.5273718238,
0.0059407116,
0.3922784626,
-0.1696818322,
-0.1846633554,
0.1611905098,
0.3302577734,
-0.329413861,
-0.8188476562,
0.4335818589,
-0.5868056417,
-0.5185269117,
-0.0389803313,
0.5139049888,
-0.5372492075,
-0.5247104764,
0.1853229702,
-0.1769146919,
-0.0326686762,
-0.2201235145,
-0.5232500434,
0.010569362,
-0.15211007,
-0.1579564214,
0.3441860974,
0.4096996784,
-0.5598601699,
0.7231856585,
0.2834432125,
-0.5625299215,
0.0664464757,
-0.3836538792,
0.9808823466,
-0.7227950096,
-0.3541293442,
-0.4318916798,
0.2672350109,
0.1486058384,
0.026728753,
0.2634405494,
0.7111393213,
1.171167016,
-0.2991907597,
0.9074782133,
-0.0421408936,
0.3244537413,
-0.5979169011,
0.3929209411,
-0.2913876772,
0.1811567098,
0.1216549575,
-0.5320756435,
-0.3466151357,
0.4673421383,
-0.4339902997,
-0.1772827506,
0.9403237104,
0.3338506222,
-0.1367980689,
0.0385981128,
0.2806896865,
0.0801023394,
0.2392836511,
0.6518322825,
0.4729399681,
-0.2577277422,
0.4647154808,
-0.0519620702,
-0.2898416221,
-0.6844833493,
-0.8036339283,
-0.9019414783,
-1.0275899172,
-0.1880265027,
-0.3923512995,
0.0387395509,
1.0089212656,
0.8178762197,
-0.8476182222,
-0.2042316645,
0.0943210647,
0.2593296766,
-0.4921577573,
-0.1976926178,
0.2316030562,
-0.3485423625,
-0.4399000108,
0.2181160748,
0.1084997654,
0.2331431061,
0.1157088131,
0.2308431119,
-0.3625303805,
-0.0542208999,
0.6613051891,
0.4874472618,
-0.6307822466,
-0.4545854628,
-0.4604828656,
-0.2135849148,
0.1961890757,
0.7114326954,
-0.4343239367,
0.2378035188,
0.1204798147,
0.2927099764,
0.6583403945,
0.0769039094,
0.4029889107,
-0.8605991006,
0.036351461,
0.1268054843,
0.102535978,
0.2161034495,
-0.8236432672,
0.339356035,
-0.0441243313,
-0.5784310699,
-0.3243204355,
0.2431202829,
-0.9707100987,
-0.4716614485,
1.2816536427,
-0.0974081978,
-0.7262562513,
-0.1788915098,
0.1114448458,
0.2039454132,
-0.5572823286,
0.9404165149,
0.559843719,
-0.0844173506,
0.0539438352,
-0.5558359623,
0.5454372764,
-0.5145772696,
-1.0483825207,
0.0533201024,
0.4842886627,
0.725446403,
0.1077490747,
0.1555411667,
-0.0779170543,
0.1346129626,
-0.340755105,
0.3387232721,
0.1972068101,
-0.8889020681,
-0.2203982919,
0.3451086581,
-0.1160073206,
-0.1492174268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11903v1
|
A Closer Look at Claim Decomposition
| 2024-03-18T16:03:45 | 2024-03-18T16:03:45 |
Miriam Wanner, Seth Ebner, Zhengping Jiang, Mark Dredze, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As generated text becomes more commonplace, it is increasingly important to
evaluate how well-supported such text is by external knowledge sources. Many
approaches for evaluating textual support rely on some method for decomposing
text into its individual subclaims which are scored against a trusted
reference. We investigate how various methods of claim decomposition --
especially LLM-based methods -- affect the result of an evaluation approach
such as the recently proposed FActScore, finding that it is sensitive to the
decomposition method used. This sensitivity arises because such metrics
attribute overall textual support to the model that generated the text even
though error can also come from the metric's decomposition step. To measure
decomposition quality, we introduce an adaptation of FActScore, which we call
DecompScore. We then propose an LLM-based approach to generating decompositions
inspired by Bertrand Russell's theory of logical atomism and neo-Davidsonian
semantics and demonstrate its improved decomposition quality over previous
methods.
|
[
-0.2182265222,
-0.4684484899,
0.8364602327,
-0.0521374717,
0.0195806157,
0.1089522764,
-0.1899470836,
-0.3715328872,
0.0612824969,
0.2668288052,
-0.3850784302,
-0.4860048592,
-0.4259950221,
0.2069375515,
-0.234321937,
1.0754039288,
-0.0035712654,
-0.1319390535,
-0.886143446,
-0.1129342243,
-0.0957731232,
-0.5044920444,
-0.3210401535,
-0.5062849522,
0.3437547684,
0.2386090904,
0.6245169044,
0.5324043632,
0.5092062354,
0.2632958293,
-0.2130817771,
0.2171865106,
-0.3687258065,
0.1179597974,
-0.4184476137,
-0.7761017084,
-0.4404051602,
0.1660308242,
0.6540107131,
0.4029611647,
-0.4000291824,
0.5201874375,
0.0463261195,
0.6170685887,
-0.9588906765,
0.2494134903,
-0.8077735901,
0.0593659244,
0.0715727136,
-0.2160030305,
-0.7357398272,
-0.3719439209,
0.0481852256,
-0.4243620336,
0.5614531636,
0.0593934953,
0.6410970092,
0.1592110544,
-0.4516480267,
-0.4570455849,
-0.6016973853,
0.9043317437,
-0.627466619,
0.0832290649,
0.3108718991,
0.294462353,
-0.0024351464,
-0.6808040738,
-0.510697782,
-0.2748206854,
-0.2448448241,
0.4796783328,
-0.3614186049,
0.027557347,
0.1944483072,
0.5782416463,
-0.1984957606,
-0.0807715282,
-0.3304699361,
-0.6939516068,
0.7982032299,
0.211829856,
0.4970064461,
-0.5689544082,
-0.7791059613,
0.1319301873,
-0.8294484615,
-0.0610729381,
0.3377360404,
0.2606060207,
0.1651701778,
0.7365058661,
-0.1048954055,
0.3577200472,
-0.3204323649,
-0.505762279,
-0.1119471192,
-0.3794418275,
-0.3210913539,
0.4656749666,
0.6358050704,
0.604670465,
-0.0956767872,
-0.1505865902,
-0.2907281518,
0.467304945,
0.1814745069,
-0.7456197143,
-0.1998696625,
0.1705688834,
-0.801261723,
-0.2109333575,
-0.2281237245,
-0.0335397795,
-0.6060986519,
-0.3730240166,
0.1734423637,
-0.5498046279,
-0.3548735678,
0.0559909344,
-0.358856976,
0.1588727683,
0.3896790445,
-0.5474599004,
0.6826193333,
0.7563904524,
0.6339072585,
-0.1478553265,
0.1787304878,
-0.446900934,
0.2308489233,
-0.5371473432,
1.161883235,
-0.2676066756,
-0.2997226119,
-0.0796708614,
-0.4862411618,
0.0089157037,
-1.0467661619,
0.8402699232,
-0.5193979144,
0.2298911363,
-0.4216023088,
-0.7249185443,
-0.4134624302,
0.6146492362,
-0.732331574,
0.9381066561,
0.2345327586,
-0.892470181,
0.3900980651,
-0.5080866814,
-0.2133529633,
-0.0400653593,
-0.099299103,
-0.3319457471,
0.6603708863,
0.0088610929,
0.4076910019,
-0.5835636258,
0.1020173207,
-0.2959140241,
0.1208599284,
0.4843874276,
-0.1753167063,
0.8843967319,
0.2633592486,
0.1152396351,
-0.2040312439,
-1.0414859056,
0.0796778947,
0.0580006205,
-0.3918942809,
-0.4456578493,
0.3760385215,
-0.3062575161,
-0.115246512,
0.1761756241,
-0.7764052749,
-0.0688467845,
-0.4573006928,
0.1924418956,
0.8411329985,
0.2005504817,
0.1062828526,
-0.3528023064,
0.4042244852,
-0.0321306735,
-0.1672851592,
-0.0059850789,
0.0782662854,
-0.7348644137,
-0.2183719873,
0.3369877934,
0.5282702446,
-0.3613272011,
-0.0292039607,
-0.3164142668,
-0.3931527138,
-0.3085209131,
-0.0023642539,
0.4354735017,
0.7801190019,
0.457103312,
-0.1515199989,
-0.3941346705,
-1.2575062513,
-0.7072592974,
-0.4773054123,
-0.0845524967,
-0.0173248015,
0.1296034604,
-0.1413315684,
1.0609306097,
-0.7779596448,
-0.3701669574,
-0.1158913448,
-0.0568293296,
-0.1097556651,
0.0456911102,
0.7202900052,
-0.5590814352,
-0.1997881383,
-0.1105932221,
-0.58377105,
-0.0053437846,
-0.0379524454,
-0.0176065825,
0.2249887288,
0.2719072998,
-0.599306345,
0.3577584624,
0.3297342956,
-0.1100734323,
0.8711727262,
0.0094757993,
0.0706782192,
-1.1631948948,
-0.2844683528,
0.0610121787,
-0.4193865061,
-0.037751127,
0.2162500173,
-0.1393043697,
0.1100128964,
-0.3670964837,
0.0956280082,
-0.5548674464,
-0.1806095988,
-0.3681603968,
0.2152628303,
0.0738215819,
0.0172025524,
-0.1086639315,
0.5343809128,
0.4898544848,
-0.7036496401,
0.5093384385,
0.2768921256,
-0.5280432701,
0.7851579189,
-0.4239690602,
-0.1064878479,
-0.2696996629,
0.3018915057,
-1.3319199085,
0.043252293,
0.1681506634,
-0.5152864456,
0.1373143792,
-0.197946772,
-0.6348505616,
0.1803306639,
-0.5751968622,
0.2763566375,
0.3836493492,
-0.4396841526,
0.7922823429,
0.3666979969,
-0.2514508963,
-0.4168376923,
-0.881167233,
0.2251904011,
-0.3663612902,
-0.4508501291,
0.5727896094,
-0.1553391367,
-0.7929543853,
0.4388021231,
-0.3958529234,
0.2528953254,
0.0796958879,
0.099400878,
-0.0661378279,
-0.2964743972,
0.1598050743,
0.191704452,
-0.4956545532,
0.6943978667,
0.0949270129,
-0.0057082446,
0.3016234338,
-0.1845135689,
-0.2287493795,
0.4969419539,
0.2117266208,
-0.1433967352,
0.659504056,
0.2416750789,
-0.4521177709,
-0.7137402296,
-0.4307747483,
0.0994601548,
-0.4249059856,
-0.0089078154,
-0.3031881452,
-0.5770301819,
0.5116775036,
-0.3792420626,
0.1972950846,
0.9604387283,
0.651443243,
-0.1220860779,
0.8037902117,
0.5883689523,
0.3676092923,
-0.0186072718,
-0.208151415,
0.1398777217,
-0.9337687492,
-0.3149470687,
-0.6809290051,
-0.1875987649,
-0.4703509212,
-0.3203926384,
0.3285428882,
-0.0720679387,
-0.0632361025,
0.1474360228,
-0.2864480317,
0.4898900688,
0.2716630995,
0.3338671327,
0.5567026734,
0.3772819042,
-0.0969990939,
-0.0831356943,
-0.6845721602,
-0.5968892574,
0.8971300125,
0.344733268,
0.6134877205,
0.3742901087,
0.9532648325,
0.5921837687,
0.7394948006,
-1.1341423988,
0.6176101565,
0.0927684307,
-0.7397078872,
0.3222985268,
-0.6265924573,
-0.4149377644,
0.2825248241,
-0.1883836091,
-0.6544397473,
-0.1316331178,
0.1006840095,
-0.3416601717,
0.1109789163,
-0.8410992622,
0.3422979116,
0.0741828233,
-0.1508455276,
-0.610262394,
-0.3675958812,
0.527495563,
0.2582294643,
0.2541594505,
-0.3416775763,
-0.0597211085,
1.1138403416,
-0.7779921293,
0.8864870071,
-0.204467088,
-0.64082551,
0.9136008024,
0.6077724695,
0.3881708682,
0.2757653296,
-0.370704025,
-0.1299179047,
0.3812944293,
-0.4026223719,
-0.7705953121,
0.5677473545,
-0.6847914457,
-0.6825796962,
-0.5322662592,
-0.3073170483,
-0.2270661145,
0.2365286052,
0.2797164917,
0.6908992529,
-0.3110168278,
-0.0574149787,
0.5979697704,
-0.1852497458,
0.4518040419,
0.2999165356,
-0.0301664155,
-0.6656699777,
0.7645495534,
0.2896617055,
0.3484500945,
0.4404347241,
0.5200855732,
-0.6241701841,
-0.7119470835,
0.1798737943,
0.0829088539,
-1.2248562574,
-0.5662321448,
-0.4140274227,
-0.0123223346,
-0.2246442884,
-0.003643753,
-0.5469338298,
-0.4613730907,
0.0301667079,
-0.6469854712,
0.2626762986,
0.6632252336,
-0.04271302,
0.0883372203,
-0.9174566865,
0.5937952995,
0.1799435318,
0.3792995811,
-0.3045379817,
-0.2079339325,
-0.2174516171,
-0.1940755397,
-0.0592235886,
-0.8227062225,
-0.0888450369,
0.2068878412,
0.6503785849,
-0.0166233294,
0.5780567527,
0.5163549781,
-0.4849912524,
0.9289456606,
0.3241334856,
-1.0135637522,
0.4077017009,
-0.082862623,
-0.2059119344,
0.5604941249,
0.4492892027,
-0.2066557109,
-0.2233862579,
-0.8103327155,
-0.7232205868,
0.4342459738,
-0.0593171008,
0.3266308308,
-0.140187487,
0.381621331,
0.2545436025,
-0.13547571,
-0.7769511342,
-0.2871887982,
0.1532325,
-0.1413725913,
0.100581862,
-0.7760808468,
-0.4944830239,
0.1376605034,
0.5384358764,
-0.1878145337,
0.2482426763,
0.4651606679,
-0.4578298032,
0.0990241915,
0.3689181209,
0.3572102785,
1.0996474028,
0.0875176266,
0.6185677052,
0.0184215941,
-0.1276018471,
0.267919004,
-0.2674735487,
-0.2546557486,
0.0076351813,
0.8462147117,
0.3304374218,
-0.0548063107,
-0.3614291847,
0.2916463614,
-0.0625695214,
-0.2505339384,
-0.175102815,
0.1599785388,
0.0175735168,
0.1584930569,
0.4340547621,
0.3206554651,
0.2929251492,
-0.722502768,
0.3200929165,
0.2358792126,
-0.2774044871,
-0.4528332353,
0.3569973409,
0.0250466596,
-0.0900384262,
0.3394962847,
-0.2308294624,
-0.5877056718,
0.3938723505,
0.7522322536,
0.8347275853,
-0.0499727353,
0.4057486951,
0.3496491611,
0.2635005116,
0.1298661679,
0.1455613524,
-0.1823057681,
-0.9256205559,
-0.7782156467,
-0.48380512,
-0.2325365394,
-0.3042381108,
-0.6110398769,
-0.0437763743,
-0.5082708597,
-0.1889934391,
-0.0905177817,
0.1110661924,
-0.4139091372,
0.2867836356,
0.2217564434,
0.8900824785,
-0.924873054,
0.0650690645,
0.8025144935,
-0.2838217318,
-0.8895083666,
0.3255374432,
0.1687964797,
-0.7821078897,
0.8118433356,
-0.013876237,
-0.537250638,
-0.0304452609,
-0.5447461009,
-0.6259243488,
0.847985208,
0.7976559401,
0.0833661184,
0.3164460957,
0.0708995908,
0.4308781326,
-0.0937392488,
0.2414324582,
0.2870402038,
0.3847113848,
-0.1397738755,
-0.7008746862,
0.4843485355,
0.0773573369,
0.015287525,
0.0614942946,
-0.8257015347,
0.5359470844,
-0.1707475781,
-0.6843355298,
-0.1914863437,
0.8350153565,
0.1121627986,
0.2872260511,
0.3132734001,
0.7574768662,
0.7640067935,
0.1403730363,
1.1423265934,
0.1348421872,
0.7041486502,
0.8319666386,
-0.2166449726,
0.7762387395,
0.2684228122,
-0.5236973763,
0.9332701564,
0.5045716166,
0.4548708797,
0.3673426807,
0.4707222581,
-0.3109541833,
-0.3220193386,
-0.364993602,
-0.2047296911,
0.6383453012,
0.3748267591,
-0.2705280781,
-0.7238358259,
-0.5300527811,
0.1820501983,
0.3541956246,
-0.3934651315,
0.960398674,
0.2150427252,
-0.7376224399,
0.571958065,
0.2489232272,
0.1611369848,
-0.4683374465,
-0.1253908277,
-0.2282128632,
0.2928765714,
-0.7150816321,
-0.6903753281,
0.5411431193,
-0.0888181031,
-0.3705271184,
-0.2323752195,
0.9124798775,
-0.1410254687,
-0.5286998153,
0.1717786342,
0.2298196703,
-0.1969256699,
-0.0787621588,
-0.4927191138,
0.1878884435,
-0.0825683549,
-0.4653315842,
0.2106750458,
0.604811728,
0.0353809707,
0.4752017558,
0.5837606788,
-0.0659312755,
-0.1414033324,
-0.2411134541,
0.8067768216,
-0.6273959279,
-0.3816535175,
-1.0877922773,
0.5454967022,
-0.0362575278,
0.1143797114,
1.1615953445,
0.8023417592,
0.5659316182,
0.1667783707,
0.9941784739,
-0.0814328566,
0.5610585809,
-0.8539612889,
0.5179003477,
-0.4077616036,
0.2383973598,
-0.3539479971,
-1.0588333607,
-0.4896005988,
0.3187564015,
-0.1812184602,
-0.1958432943,
0.7877007723,
0.5102117062,
-0.1132942215,
-0.1589654088,
-0.0857946277,
0.0836339816,
0.4171854258,
0.3728614748,
1.0962320566,
-0.3815334141,
0.4376292825,
0.0033029718,
-0.3562234938,
-0.0303569064,
-1.2457683086,
-0.4523349106,
-0.3858856261,
-0.8487840295,
-0.6191802025,
-0.4979408979,
0.5775263309,
0.3787154853,
-0.5476005077,
-0.0325709395,
0.2155106515,
0.1865858883,
-0.3060983121,
-0.2265006155,
0.5834968686,
-0.3591217995,
-0.207694456,
0.4443589449,
0.3095059097,
-0.4432334006,
-0.1809065193,
0.1234710664,
0.155576095,
0.167551592,
0.9644146562,
-0.0432125852,
-0.380435437,
-0.5115423799,
-0.1639573127,
0.1117109954,
0.1507105082,
1.1355142593,
-0.8973873854,
0.4431266189,
0.8618274331,
0.8438182473,
0.4101523459,
0.3719266057,
0.5849071741,
-0.7691190839,
-0.1590860784,
0.2345875055,
0.243228361,
0.2812044919,
-0.4036437273,
0.3564345837,
0.487990886,
-0.0625143647,
-0.8357658982,
0.6240984797,
-0.8647723198,
-0.4867468476,
1.1402975321,
-0.1226088852,
-0.5348327756,
0.2306046635,
-0.1877420843,
0.0746097118,
0.0887579545,
0.6470033526,
0.8043981194,
-0.4620004892,
-0.0905849934,
-0.1945035607,
0.4673421979,
0.2762787342,
-0.5759330392,
0.430598259,
0.8630647063,
0.6435348988,
0.5228863358,
0.7358795404,
-0.3416830003,
-0.0437227897,
0.1866168678,
-0.033285372,
-0.068528004,
-0.1109153405,
0.0428398736,
0.4816498458,
0.3352515399,
-0.1158377081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11896v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11896v2
|
Investigating Markers and Drivers of Gender Bias in Machine Translations
| 2024-03-18T15:54:46 | 2024-04-02T10:07:39 |
Peter J Barclay, Ashkan Sami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SE
|
Implicit gender bias in Large Language Models (LLMs) is a well-documented
problem, and implications of gender introduced into automatic translations can
perpetuate real-world biases. However, some LLMs use heuristics or
post-processing to mask such bias, making investigation difficult. Here, we
examine bias in LLMss via back-translation, using the DeepL translation API to
investigate the bias evinced when repeatedly translating a set of 56 Software
Engineering tasks used in a previous study. Each statement starts with 'she',
and is translated first into a 'genderless' intermediate language then back
into English; we then examine pronoun-choice in the back-translated texts. We
expand prior research in the following ways: (1) by comparing results across
five intermediate languages, namely Finnish, Indonesian, Estonian, Turkish and
Hungarian; (2) by proposing a novel metric for assessing the variation in
gender implied in the repeated translations, avoiding the over-interpretation
of individual pronouns, apparent in earlier work; (3) by investigating sentence
features that drive bias; (4) and by comparing results from three time-lapsed
datasets to establish the reproducibility of the approach. We found that some
languages display similar patterns of pronoun use, falling into three loose
groups, but that patterns vary between groups; this underlines the need to work
with multiple languages. We also identify the main verb appearing in a sentence
as a likely significant driver of implied gender in the translations. Moreover,
we see a good level of replicability in the results, and establish that our
variation metric proves robust despite an obvious change in the behaviour of
the DeepL translation API during the course of the study. These results show
that the back-translation method can provide further insights into bias in
language models.
|
[
-0.1564306319,
-0.4310690761,
0.6321973801,
0.3526112139,
0.0646812022,
0.0511607081,
-0.1313175708,
-0.3973965347,
-0.4000632167,
0.5777357817,
-0.9074255824,
-0.5213143826,
-0.8227751851,
0.4559297264,
-0.5867815018,
0.987841785,
-0.512122333,
0.4926483333,
0.0967051089,
-0.1537281871,
-0.8239328265,
-0.5258609653,
-0.0760219172,
-0.4481214881,
0.3336100876,
0.1259922981,
0.7644463181,
0.4715562463,
0.2955021858,
0.1912791282,
-0.3010880053,
0.0612057038,
-0.1843083352,
0.2322926819,
-0.1095193774,
-0.804746449,
-0.3663212657,
0.3535891473,
0.7459570169,
0.8828570843,
0.350214541,
0.5024484992,
0.2548108697,
0.7406218648,
-0.6737931967,
0.1692229062,
-0.4922189713,
0.3043171763,
-0.2935645878,
0.0490031801,
-0.3298262656,
-0.1640681177,
0.0223231521,
-0.2381310016,
0.4942505658,
0.0847253054,
0.7102615833,
0.3631417751,
-0.6166574359,
-0.2837254405,
-0.7726293802,
1.0011533499,
-0.6139540672,
0.7399110198,
0.1938989758,
0.1287235022,
-0.3341984451,
-0.0293323305,
-0.4170446992,
-0.3154033422,
-0.2112540305,
-0.0476947874,
-0.0259865783,
-0.3265220225,
0.4112485349,
0.1861003935,
-0.3173048198,
0.2353920639,
-0.3104554713,
-0.0866645798,
0.6382420659,
0.034745492,
0.5260021687,
0.0431227237,
0.0364073887,
0.0206255,
-1.0063685179,
-0.1163710356,
0.7217911482,
0.3627367318,
-0.0381262824,
0.8321148157,
0.0640000179,
0.2802083492,
0.0619100593,
0.1656841338,
0.5423030257,
-0.4433228076,
0.0557353124,
0.132808581,
0.7535237074,
0.2139878869,
0.458252728,
0.0941997692,
-0.2212691158,
-0.1118567958,
0.1502218395,
-0.4530623555,
0.2624509633,
0.1037233099,
-0.5160970092,
-0.1883820295,
-0.1445049644,
-0.4787709117,
-0.3223590553,
-0.2344988883,
-0.0929154381,
0.0844408795,
-0.3271947801,
0.0237578899,
-0.0872208923,
0.1728290617,
0.1804639697,
-0.6199406385,
0.0498517938,
0.7993436456,
0.7034686804,
-0.1844425648,
-0.5231938958,
-0.3734201789,
0.0491065271,
-0.8535079956,
0.2898435891,
-0.4242354929,
-0.3906589746,
0.1707559377,
0.1178827211,
0.0933685303,
-0.5338808894,
0.4200259149,
-0.1724094152,
0.5772787333,
-0.3939418197,
-0.3904947042,
-0.0508153811,
0.0361988358,
-0.5821303129,
1.180018425,
-0.2866764665,
-0.748501718,
0.7655031085,
-0.2576620579,
-0.3367167413,
-0.3357879221,
-0.6884065866,
-0.5185387731,
0.3624648452,
0.2794744968,
0.372739166,
-0.4339461625,
0.4888926446,
-0.0710657835,
-0.3444278538,
0.4748509526,
-0.3300324976,
0.6785113811,
-0.1888798922,
-0.6637819409,
0.1585050225,
-0.2076341063,
-0.6349320412,
0.0088455668,
-0.1130768657,
-0.3253039122,
0.1243967116,
-0.2121956497,
0.535622716,
0.1317313462,
-0.5497536659,
0.0808522999,
-0.2881878912,
0.2554680705,
0.7907420397,
-0.4925423563,
0.6754404306,
0.0489705876,
0.4944774508,
0.111271657,
0.1639354229,
-0.057803791,
-0.7670185566,
-0.6341407299,
-0.1864127964,
0.1552787125,
0.5769195557,
-0.3200225532,
0.2965990603,
-0.2113927454,
0.0732058138,
-0.9858242273,
0.3631102145,
0.6066460013,
0.2166126072,
0.2546855509,
-0.0379058868,
-0.4400291443,
-1.3532260656,
-0.7222028971,
-0.237689957,
-0.0833164528,
0.2966429889,
0.7944179773,
-0.4195443094,
0.7919160128,
-0.4450666308,
-0.4896013141,
-0.2013993859,
0.2969596386,
0.3355939686,
0.495895654,
0.4476138651,
-0.6638926864,
-0.1791610569,
-0.011239497,
-0.744802773,
-0.4468132555,
-0.1329826564,
-0.4525380433,
0.4039556384,
0.62959373,
-0.5877192616,
0.4947281182,
0.6330592036,
-0.412807703,
0.5373170972,
-0.0338908061,
0.069349274,
-0.7299283147,
0.0358454436,
0.0124135586,
-0.1650560051,
-0.2877354622,
0.1358978003,
-0.0462476164,
0.218344897,
-0.4259463251,
0.6441663504,
-0.7372304201,
-0.5690006614,
-0.2393076569,
-0.0495364219,
-0.1906006783,
0.1719385982,
-0.0998504236,
0.9873431921,
-0.0144326426,
-0.3132704794,
-0.0568515994,
0.262560308,
0.0268283207,
0.3439493775,
-0.5067099929,
0.290838331,
-0.3027333617,
0.3213382065,
-1.1878685951,
0.1857447773,
0.51752913,
-0.4670529366,
0.2274462581,
-0.3257946968,
-0.5653091669,
-0.3819125593,
-0.2015747577,
0.2803574204,
0.4554614723,
-0.2447365373,
0.4990296066,
0.1511855274,
-0.1608163416,
-0.7765245438,
-0.9198789001,
0.1410862207,
0.0533216186,
-0.3733745217,
0.1352004558,
-0.0269408189,
-0.4144228995,
-0.1577386111,
-0.246369347,
0.005225101,
0.2313039154,
0.2594153881,
0.2242292315,
-0.1465702951,
-0.0281615984,
0.3081681132,
-0.0854192674,
0.2061558962,
-0.4147582054,
0.438659817,
-0.1106424928,
-0.2964723706,
-0.3439702988,
0.5993912816,
0.484305352,
0.0427935608,
0.7370159626,
0.6992172003,
-0.2812585831,
0.0485077463,
-0.6549452543,
-0.2178205252,
-0.3710236847,
0.3955093026,
-0.6219125986,
-0.8407860398,
0.6288365126,
0.0660269931,
0.3528190255,
0.5312559009,
0.607327044,
-0.2500635087,
1.433062911,
0.5306768417,
-0.16284284,
0.3296232522,
-0.003532182,
-0.0457338318,
-0.870621264,
0.0445075817,
-0.7370536923,
-0.4024918377,
-0.9693707228,
-0.3300355077,
0.0848416239,
-0.062672846,
-0.3118100464,
-0.0221943799,
-0.2576371729,
0.2609088123,
0.4853844941,
-0.073165372,
0.2975139916,
-0.0904168636,
-0.0463616028,
-0.510850966,
-0.4531427026,
-0.6544556618,
1.1009635925,
0.4660024643,
0.4584094584,
0.0796015412,
0.485560447,
0.4666361511,
0.3553447425,
-0.2452256531,
0.6013188958,
-0.4521874189,
-0.9054397345,
-0.0462224968,
-0.4041558802,
-0.9568403959,
0.32042858,
-0.1418891698,
-0.5000870228,
0.2346619815,
0.1777287126,
0.3061023951,
0.0173387565,
-0.3531754911,
0.737390995,
-0.387009114,
-0.5067129731,
-0.0608832724,
-0.5469436646,
0.450601548,
-0.0779018328,
0.3371653855,
-0.242010802,
-0.1653262228,
0.5538282394,
-0.0761188641,
1.0126777887,
-0.0225937553,
-0.7425321341,
-0.267124474,
0.2617139518,
0.5090069175,
-0.0531422794,
0.0237909593,
0.5830155611,
-0.3677692711,
-0.481826067,
-0.3027957678,
0.427354604,
-0.966321528,
-0.7804262042,
-0.4998458922,
-0.5939835906,
0.053509973,
0.2711014152,
0.29237023,
-0.1466777027,
-0.0772552714,
-0.1765239388,
0.5550794601,
-0.5001448393,
0.0346326046,
0.4520199299,
-0.4900947213,
0.1670053303,
0.4471835792,
0.2429864556,
0.1571753174,
0.2599264979,
0.2030249089,
-0.1385979205,
-0.352876097,
-0.8345998526,
0.2882508337,
-0.5039287806,
0.343709141,
-0.6579897404,
0.0542688444,
-0.4762346148,
-0.1108796597,
-0.7095708847,
-0.1452325135,
-0.2015829384,
-0.0749444962,
0.0331455283,
0.6019448042,
0.3560048938,
0.2416452765,
-0.4601320028,
0.375655055,
0.0161073357,
-0.0941079557,
-0.3619196713,
-0.5039458275,
0.0696409121,
0.0596528351,
0.1465203464,
-1.2345676422,
0.4537262619,
-0.1195991337,
0.6759331226,
-0.220090583,
-0.4056179821,
0.2976002395,
-0.6081215143,
0.8923730254,
-0.0902023837,
-1.0749264956,
0.5938929319,
-0.4677519798,
0.4046979845,
0.3766816854,
0.3019099832,
-0.5550411344,
-0.6288362145,
-0.3087011278,
-0.9340533614,
0.525333643,
0.3672845364,
0.1459174007,
0.1452605128,
0.5803500414,
0.4359512031,
0.6974442005,
-0.6241856217,
-0.4350312948,
0.2825833857,
-0.12288744,
-0.0922552645,
-0.3625070453,
-0.0096465116,
-0.0217032917,
0.6194053292,
-0.2349247783,
0.3605599105,
0.0551183075,
-0.597769618,
0.0117616802,
0.400780201,
0.6456221342,
0.5848693848,
-0.1397070438,
0.0767049268,
0.2708539665,
-0.4949678183,
0.2320040762,
0.0230031852,
-0.7087423205,
0.3435550928,
0.3830783069,
0.669131875,
-0.0520817898,
-0.3425376415,
0.4725912809,
0.035034623,
0.0961886272,
-0.4726580083,
-0.294493556,
-0.2182050496,
0.3602131605,
0.4889228344,
-0.0347362421,
0.3122115433,
-0.5236544013,
-0.1923879236,
0.2983705699,
-0.5690493584,
-0.4332514405,
0.6590512991,
0.2456906587,
-0.2499728501,
0.5279775858,
-0.0246607102,
-0.6844299436,
0.4956010282,
0.2936418056,
1.3455199003,
-0.3075350821,
0.089552626,
0.0528941453,
0.7999453545,
-0.2912261486,
0.5337775946,
0.2652557194,
-0.6763235331,
-0.6809257865,
-0.0365608186,
-0.1314938366,
-0.1466889232,
-0.5162431598,
0.2957743406,
0.0314289294,
-0.2602352202,
-0.2241523415,
-0.3229911029,
-0.9140409231,
-0.0757528245,
0.4194038808,
0.5290655494,
-1.1362104416,
0.4491805732,
0.764384985,
-0.4389470816,
-0.1535651386,
0.2008863539,
0.2682570517,
-0.6697025299,
1.2582585812,
0.1098926142,
-0.2449232191,
-0.3799545467,
-0.4852622747,
-0.5957513452,
0.7021424174,
0.5213124156,
-0.868080318,
-0.0246344768,
0.5250955224,
0.3885091841,
-0.3592031598,
0.3919496536,
0.6826212406,
0.4123536646,
-0.6672020555,
-1.1927978992,
0.2259786576,
-0.1293899715,
0.2009354681,
0.2772969007,
-0.4773665369,
0.9814831614,
0.0358619727,
0.0898620859,
-0.2505491674,
0.6497354507,
0.3168733418,
0.276178807,
0.4411299825,
-0.0585525781,
0.7182736397,
-0.0721194074,
0.9270014763,
-0.0628634989,
0.073507376,
1.2080286741,
-0.5009754896,
0.5272105932,
0.735470593,
-0.1433949471,
0.4247618616,
0.3110254407,
0.1403751969,
0.0987875238,
0.3623598516,
0.0116418069,
-0.1019289419,
-0.2545623779,
-0.4872235358,
0.2228098065,
0.3063207865,
-0.800201118,
0.1566199958,
0.1353379339,
0.4450897872,
-0.0043387315,
-0.0746272355,
0.4644450843,
0.2719626427,
-0.580968976,
0.2518401444,
0.0826577619,
0.7811066508,
-0.287199229,
-0.0505295321,
-0.5410441756,
0.3065293133,
-0.1026382223,
-0.923483789,
0.1863614023,
0.0683721155,
-0.3664697409,
-0.6304051876,
0.6236143708,
-0.4637391269,
-0.653601706,
0.3478085101,
0.865553081,
0.2107242048,
-0.1313728392,
-0.6681017876,
0.2165959328,
0.0359074995,
-0.2099099904,
0.183106795,
0.3137190938,
-0.4817374051,
0.7398037314,
0.4608933628,
0.1876570433,
0.3639165759,
0.1681226194,
0.3975239992,
-0.6598185897,
-0.3558405936,
-1.091070056,
0.2523106933,
0.0601558723,
-0.5028665066,
1.0202372074,
0.6740181446,
0.8783714175,
0.0158444475,
0.8271786571,
0.5707646012,
0.3055754602,
-0.5382984281,
0.5215938687,
-0.390781939,
0.3978506327,
-0.5340849757,
-0.9463953376,
-0.214195475,
0.4923264682,
-0.5400814414,
0.0500480197,
0.4969800413,
0.4208602607,
0.1012442484,
-0.0255369376,
-0.0746112168,
0.3507694006,
0.3582539856,
0.3447437882,
1.0699876547,
-0.6033498645,
0.4927076697,
0.0622635894,
-0.0052287146,
-0.2488373071,
-0.8300670981,
-0.8710168004,
-0.2821343243,
-0.6519755125,
-0.5006238222,
0.5464817286,
0.8536321521,
0.6396794915,
-0.6293689013,
-0.4527657032,
-0.1124661714,
0.2744283676,
-0.3564243019,
-0.0826269686,
0.1903108805,
-0.22260575,
-0.884732604,
0.1630550772,
-0.0669627711,
-0.1811228395,
-0.6560834646,
-0.0415762253,
-0.2042103708,
-0.2484820336,
0.4619012475,
-0.1201793402,
-0.904296875,
-0.1907345057,
0.2287617028,
-0.2480282784,
-0.1394744515,
0.888918817,
-0.5804772377,
0.2141458988,
0.6423321962,
0.5489955544,
0.5783422589,
-0.4387463033,
1.1118553877,
-1.0733437538,
0.1681699753,
0.0318503641,
0.3486534953,
0.4047018886,
-0.4171303511,
0.5725918412,
0.3835004866,
-0.3201934993,
-0.9668905139,
0.2494889647,
-0.1663780659,
-0.5134620667,
1.4800344706,
0.0861260816,
-0.1610070616,
-0.2298106849,
-0.4054859281,
0.3954620063,
-0.3966397047,
0.5284676552,
0.8598700166,
0.1927143931,
-0.1905195564,
-1.1122652292,
0.3401447833,
0.7648279071,
-0.3850224018,
0.034139473,
0.5040219426,
0.2906428277,
0.1256561279,
0.4495638311,
-0.0595407151,
0.1253095716,
-0.2189557254,
0.2742578387,
0.3124749959,
-0.2135021389,
-0.3360866904,
-0.2884981632,
0.0383070596,
-0.208457008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11894v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11894v3
|
From Explainable to Interpretable Deep Learning for Natural Language Processing in Healthcare: How Far from Reality?
| 2024-03-18T15:53:33 | 2024-05-09T19:36:59 |
Guangming Huang, Yingya Li, Shoaib Jameel, Yunfei Long, Giorgos Papanastasiou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Deep learning (DL) has substantially enhanced natural language processing
(NLP) in healthcare research. However, the increasing complexity of DL-based
NLP necessitates transparent model interpretability, or at least
explainability, for reliable decision-making. This work presents a thorough
scoping review of explainable and interpretable DL in healthcare NLP. The term
"eXplainable and Interpretable Artificial Intelligence" (XIAI) is introduced to
distinguish XAI from IAI. Different models are further categorized based on
their functionality (model-, input-, output-based) and scope (local, global).
Our analysis shows that attention mechanisms are the most prevalent emerging
IAI technique. The use of IAI is growing, distinguishing it from XAI. The major
challenges identified are that most XIAI does not explore "global" modelling
processes, the lack of best practices, and the lack of systematic evaluation
and benchmarks. One important opportunity is to use attention mechanisms to
enhance multi-modal XIAI for personalized medicine. Additionally, combining DL
with causal logic holds promise. Our discussion encourages the integration of
XIAI in Large Language Models (LLMs) and domain-specific smaller models. In
conclusion, XIAI adoption in healthcare requires dedicated in-house expertise.
Collaboration with domain experts, end-users, and policymakers can lead to
ready-to-use XIAI methods across NLP and medical tasks. While challenges exist,
XIAI techniques offer a valuable foundation for interpretable NLP algorithms in
healthcare.
|
[
-0.0417883694,
-0.3684058487,
0.8066948056,
0.20360443,
-0.0443913415,
-0.1954730004,
-0.2140389979,
-0.8828184605,
-0.0782576576,
0.3937544823,
-0.6574805975,
-0.0733095407,
-0.759482801,
-0.0383108258,
-0.3546288311,
1.0335022211,
-0.0124207642,
0.1792619228,
-0.1306459904,
-0.5544713736,
-0.2580119669,
-0.3615077436,
-0.9382324219,
-0.665284574,
0.6203466058,
0.216833055,
0.7133024931,
0.7576074004,
0.665394485,
0.2731203437,
-0.1535773873,
0.0266600549,
-0.0614220425,
0.0470801108,
0.017234832,
-0.4411675036,
-0.611898005,
-0.1771667898,
0.6185717583,
1.0536832809,
-0.0063396827,
-0.2357807308,
0.064568609,
0.8393466473,
-0.3890654445,
0.2633028328,
-0.2374666482,
0.3125873208,
0.1437879652,
-0.0517413206,
-0.1157190353,
0.0071942974,
0.8102513552,
-0.5224958658,
-0.0377583131,
-0.139607206,
0.5733104944,
0.5305061936,
-0.3500316441,
-0.5203485489,
-0.8594300747,
0.6883226037,
-1.0713742971,
0.4402650297,
0.2610591948,
0.4168699682,
0.2354419529,
-1.0214569569,
-0.4785702527,
-0.2883024812,
-0.3312800229,
0.2001179457,
-0.3925423622,
0.2858450413,
0.2187176049,
0.6064406037,
-0.458738625,
0.3812048435,
-0.1601930261,
0.3806011975,
0.5735477209,
0.1724193096,
0.4065484107,
-0.0360036269,
-0.1837104112,
0.4799261093,
-0.3798581958,
0.1269691885,
-0.237739116,
0.1159167662,
-0.2058502436,
0.1643760949,
-0.402005285,
0.4216443002,
-0.0247220267,
-0.0658087805,
0.1982943714,
-0.4007767737,
-0.6166960001,
0.166991964,
0.5819246769,
0.1038225666,
0.0182601847,
-0.3826911151,
0.0203616191,
-0.0390673019,
0.6316765547,
-0.5647924542,
-0.1209789589,
0.6411877871,
-0.7457947731,
-0.4306122065,
-0.1941396445,
-0.2594741285,
-0.4460737705,
-0.5430961847,
-0.0126409326,
-0.3085098565,
-0.2492855787,
0.1964993477,
0.2147004306,
0.2838317156,
0.1489937454,
-0.8025357127,
0.3913455606,
0.8132817745,
0.7419043183,
-0.2723231316,
-0.1383639127,
-0.2494452596,
-0.0008479505,
-0.1333022714,
0.4497128725,
-0.3478492498,
0.0371008217,
0.0840811431,
0.0405998863,
-0.1145401672,
-0.444519043,
0.6548709869,
-0.2852706313,
0.1416086555,
0.022077119,
-0.5191768408,
-0.2590683997,
0.2685574293,
-0.6427877545,
0.0248583406,
0.1640336961,
-0.6501476169,
0.4996965826,
-1.024695158,
-0.65963763,
0.2179917842,
-0.1137882024,
-0.4843094051,
0.2682708204,
0.3950761259,
0.6239806414,
-0.2666134834,
0.5838062167,
-0.1948641986,
-0.1430017948,
0.2410472184,
-0.6440867186,
0.8872025013,
0.2649061084,
-0.6517363787,
0.4942741394,
-0.9997974038,
-0.0198023021,
-0.0784688592,
-0.0351646617,
-0.0412811935,
0.0661837533,
-0.0449074917,
0.1715981662,
-0.1284627467,
-0.0175340306,
-0.2057060152,
-0.9956133366,
0.920229733,
0.5081717968,
-0.12708655,
0.5780964494,
-0.2984390259,
0.4415645897,
-0.1083569974,
0.5102806687,
-0.276404351,
-0.5644577742,
-0.6065880656,
-0.1698855162,
0.0487440228,
0.4338908494,
-0.4760786593,
0.0888679773,
-0.1568965465,
-0.3419085443,
-0.956856966,
-0.2717161775,
0.3980247676,
0.881953001,
0.3197158873,
-0.0398713015,
-0.3860139251,
-1.0259240866,
-0.3225456476,
-0.2011442333,
0.0447429828,
0.5516126156,
0.3048232198,
-0.7121862769,
0.4548091292,
-0.1731776297,
-0.514964819,
-0.4998849928,
0.1309617311,
0.2572628856,
0.3435342014,
0.2480707169,
-0.9154253006,
-0.2176940888,
0.4009701014,
-1.0751862526,
-0.0258564558,
-0.5074917674,
0.3208531737,
0.1110618711,
0.3671373129,
-0.4588094652,
0.7101967335,
0.3564534187,
-0.1155181825,
0.2974481881,
-0.4043017328,
0.0092407465,
-0.773901403,
0.3703081608,
0.065460138,
-0.2059753835,
-0.9669159055,
0.4973871708,
-0.1129143313,
0.0048539676,
-0.3630244136,
0.7403680682,
-0.2963448465,
0.088745147,
-0.4544845521,
-0.0970398262,
0.1617951095,
0.2053336501,
-0.0119312005,
0.2460953444,
0.6193702817,
-0.6823970079,
0.3228677809,
0.2044072747,
-0.4130162895,
0.4282221794,
-0.927290082,
-0.1436452717,
-0.0880317837,
0.0641249791,
-0.5339007974,
-0.352822274,
0.5601551533,
-0.3565689325,
0.2604044974,
0.2713037133,
0.1060518324,
-0.1986003518,
0.022281155,
0.5068824291,
0.2529803514,
-0.448980689,
0.4509957135,
0.4052192569,
-0.1559975743,
-0.5442973971,
-0.816624701,
0.3706759512,
-0.1580474079,
-0.4255133569,
0.4881813526,
-0.0110678505,
-0.6022742391,
0.1931896508,
-0.2085894942,
-0.3660609424,
0.3328716755,
0.3976569474,
-0.0401928574,
-0.3723652065,
0.2342808992,
0.131161496,
-0.4104230106,
0.4135955572,
-0.3785483837,
-0.053571973,
-0.1831293851,
-0.2726921737,
-0.9091735482,
0.7565611601,
0.6561416388,
-0.188928023,
0.6234216094,
0.5809306502,
-0.61687392,
0.0119536249,
-0.2022781074,
-0.1474110782,
-0.3197365105,
0.3702870309,
-0.0572088771,
-0.7850110531,
0.3637749255,
0.0783443153,
0.3224349022,
0.3928850591,
0.6451771259,
-0.2344899327,
1.2787802219,
0.9263216853,
-0.0682485327,
0.1740865856,
-0.260935396,
0.5267675519,
-0.6850037575,
-0.2998443544,
-0.3439184427,
-0.2424806803,
-0.6104012132,
-0.0106283687,
0.2957563698,
-0.3810084462,
-0.0033401081,
-0.1199814379,
-0.5846233964,
-0.009120998,
0.5924496055,
0.2616153955,
0.2978164852,
-0.4017769098,
0.2836563587,
0.0306113232,
-0.6548002958,
-0.1588759869,
0.7839038372,
0.669703126,
0.493614316,
-0.1359556466,
0.4336976409,
0.2140918523,
0.2113841623,
-0.9984046221,
-0.0053442172,
-0.1867692918,
-0.4049429297,
-0.4009870589,
-0.2448913455,
-0.9348101616,
-0.0583778769,
-0.2042333335,
-0.4613096416,
0.2614973485,
0.1563404351,
-0.7055841684,
0.1841204017,
-0.7410948873,
0.8712351322,
-0.3459994495,
-0.0151036922,
-0.2205309123,
-0.9656339884,
0.2932941914,
0.0753654465,
0.2500633001,
0.1355124861,
0.0781215206,
0.4673233628,
-0.1627273262,
0.7287095189,
0.1283634901,
-0.0756386146,
-0.1906653643,
-0.48137936,
0.0882401317,
0.2799683213,
-0.1077076271,
0.3646794558,
0.001871867,
-0.3117379546,
-0.9610584378,
0.7013471127,
-0.7096772194,
-0.6958583593,
-0.4813441038,
-0.5450772047,
-0.1875294447,
0.2772127092,
0.2533801198,
0.4554405212,
-0.1018895432,
-0.0374573432,
0.6864387989,
-0.195087254,
0.178398788,
0.1858767718,
0.1187406033,
0.0198845491,
0.9848786592,
0.2139382362,
-0.0270862933,
0.4357665181,
0.4758514166,
-0.0242921691,
-0.9653158188,
-0.2738198042,
0.1049198359,
-0.6213774085,
0.2234707922,
-0.8291165829,
-0.7016089559,
-0.4414467514,
-0.1873054653,
-0.0057008658,
-0.127724573,
-0.5770756602,
-0.0251547713,
-0.2292588055,
0.8728502393,
0.0510062464,
0.3241677284,
-0.6081372499,
0.6060220599,
0.3236160874,
0.5236867666,
0.2148442566,
-0.3878340423,
-0.3281072974,
0.0268496424,
0.3313668668,
-0.7687225938,
0.4432846606,
0.2195039839,
0.6852378249,
0.9017868042,
0.0418994874,
0.5401048064,
-0.4910950363,
0.5191484094,
0.0867901444,
-0.7790154219,
0.6042906046,
0.0183313824,
0.4767690599,
0.4979741573,
0.5191764235,
-0.5820547938,
-0.260392338,
-0.585508287,
-1.1270817518,
0.7054572105,
0.0415658616,
0.0278051291,
0.1252620369,
0.5841922164,
0.378085345,
0.1177587062,
-0.7091220021,
-0.3513468802,
0.0345069207,
-0.2167732716,
-0.0393760242,
-0.3225597739,
-0.2582302094,
-0.1721074283,
0.5804642439,
-0.3411654532,
0.4205579162,
0.4124089479,
-0.0852561891,
-0.0460532121,
0.3413917422,
0.4986222088,
0.8939582705,
-0.0953059047,
-0.0051082899,
-0.171304509,
-0.3174644411,
-0.2728133202,
0.1675544083,
-0.2051853538,
-0.0658330023,
0.7356666923,
0.9816475511,
0.1844352335,
-0.7152346373,
0.3674202859,
-0.2531643212,
-0.1300396919,
-0.3697528243,
0.0402051657,
-0.1941589713,
0.3940012753,
-0.0024197733,
0.2623024881,
0.6210741401,
-0.5943703055,
0.1782036871,
0.2296125442,
-1.0793911219,
-0.2275391519,
0.8263236284,
0.2056107521,
-0.3158248663,
0.6842265725,
0.2420618534,
-0.0318178348,
0.5694102049,
0.2482800037,
0.8686705232,
0.0900583565,
0.1865739375,
-0.0893318355,
0.2365335375,
0.2306286693,
0.0247889441,
-0.1858799905,
-0.4854803085,
-0.5340394378,
-0.074115999,
-0.583753407,
0.3364986777,
-0.8898868561,
-0.1079778597,
-0.4057788849,
0.1084137857,
0.6388878226,
-0.1628524065,
-0.6846041083,
0.6102997065,
0.3353730142,
0.7905643582,
-0.5242233276,
0.6864236593,
0.6764631867,
-0.2111537158,
-0.458900243,
0.2906083167,
0.1322373748,
-1.019200325,
0.2923547924,
0.2733264565,
0.0926084518,
-0.3728508949,
-0.5023196936,
-0.3552273512,
0.7512023449,
0.1572782993,
-0.5000916719,
-0.4607357979,
0.051694233,
0.7361844182,
-0.2921257615,
0.3159318864,
0.8216882944,
0.3523375988,
-0.3308829963,
-0.6046704054,
-0.0012576529,
-0.1640125513,
-0.2817897499,
-0.3165281713,
-0.3550331295,
0.3942948878,
-0.5402291417,
-0.1670502275,
0.0570832342,
0.6637628675,
-0.1022905186,
0.8162711263,
0.3609390855,
0.5038765073,
0.8025516272,
0.004929963,
1.2129449844,
-0.1049122065,
-0.1397092789,
1.0025360584,
-0.3513621092,
0.5122340322,
0.4490559697,
-0.0038990439,
0.2896932662,
0.4100894034,
0.2436483949,
0.4730446339,
-0.0875148326,
-0.3797047138,
0.0437223725,
-0.3307784498,
-0.3149757683,
0.4654901028,
0.4916333556,
-0.6689068079,
0.0258174185,
0.3715858757,
-0.0262554213,
0.0126406979,
-0.3314215839,
1.1272823811,
0.3793388605,
-0.6715057492,
0.1209204793,
-0.1683833897,
0.3003488481,
-0.6048961282,
-0.2378610969,
-0.0456961021,
0.2301875949,
-0.4066514969,
-0.7244485021,
0.6371828914,
-0.1831361204,
-0.5892153382,
-0.4767526984,
0.7014642954,
-0.1082401946,
-0.3993720412,
0.3282250464,
0.5086455345,
0.0521932803,
-0.1093323305,
-0.9041531086,
-0.1029030234,
0.103634052,
-0.1707463413,
0.4050147235,
0.4987533689,
-0.0454900153,
0.91606462,
0.6020134687,
0.2461344302,
-0.2636154592,
0.2056415826,
0.6492816806,
-0.6130787134,
-0.5307327509,
-0.8486318588,
0.4405724108,
0.1041008309,
-0.3431180716,
0.2786808312,
-0.1502899379,
0.3828004897,
0.233780399,
0.9534223676,
0.1968887895,
0.4631157517,
-0.4260997474,
1.0206404924,
-0.6460832357,
0.1354169697,
-0.0232388712,
-0.2872940898,
-0.7415192127,
0.5820057392,
-0.1137814149,
-0.0192326102,
0.648542881,
0.0568412505,
0.1739804149,
0.1691620946,
0.4564365745,
0.5502813458,
0.395976603,
0.474100858,
0.5803480744,
-0.3054690361,
0.3035328388,
-0.5193969607,
-0.2858630717,
-0.2044602633,
-0.7513991594,
-0.5153640509,
-0.5069651604,
-0.5418902636,
-0.153898716,
0.1892534047,
0.6824643016,
0.9959970117,
-0.9152919054,
0.3096815646,
-0.2096857429,
0.4791202247,
-0.7091727853,
-0.1770043224,
0.5083705187,
-0.3975220323,
-0.6364532113,
0.440895468,
0.6786698699,
-0.3140211105,
-0.3594792187,
-0.0201628432,
-0.0505641177,
-0.1047154441,
0.5796982646,
0.50875175,
-0.9930848479,
0.0288696345,
0.1208069026,
-0.0550581589,
0.2856048644,
0.7570326924,
-0.871047914,
0.6504616141,
0.2481029481,
0.92202878,
-0.0266033858,
-0.3461052477,
0.6465744376,
-0.2339170277,
-0.1600849479,
0.5539422631,
0.4072186649,
0.1518032849,
-0.5393696427,
0.4741456807,
-0.0110973977,
-0.6559137106,
-0.7951430082,
0.183228001,
-0.9509184361,
-0.2873099744,
0.765640378,
-0.4028059542,
-0.2385075837,
-0.4939851761,
-0.1793302149,
0.1930660307,
-0.0718756989,
0.7756376863,
0.2902353406,
-0.4175996184,
-0.4725182354,
-0.8428184986,
0.6430879235,
0.4580655992,
-0.9039763212,
-0.060812328,
-0.0760101005,
-0.1315945387,
-0.0101753082,
0.511895299,
-0.169895947,
0.4548127949,
-0.3120882809,
-0.1432543099,
0.0522170216,
-0.4460481703,
-0.7778902054,
0.0674434155,
0.0537081435,
0.0294165798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11886v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11886v2
|
QueryAgent: A Reliable and Efficient Reasoning Framework with Environmental Feedback-based Self-Correction
| 2024-03-18T15:39:14 | 2024-06-13T13:18:43 |
Xiang Huang, Sitao Cheng, Shanshan Huang, Jiayu Shen, Yong Xu, Chaoyun Zhang, Yuzhong Qu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Employing Large Language Models (LLMs) for semantic parsing has achieved
remarkable success. However, we find existing methods fall short in terms of
reliability and efficiency when hallucinations are encountered. In this paper,
we address these challenges with a framework called QueryAgent, which solves a
question step-by-step and performs step-wise self-correction. We introduce an
environmental feedback-based self-correction method called ERASER. Unlike
traditional approaches, ERASER leverages rich environmental feedback in the
intermediate steps to perform selective and differentiated self-correction only
when necessary. Experimental results demonstrate that QueryAgent notably
outperforms all previous few-shot methods using only one example on GrailQA and
GraphQ by 7.0 and 15.0 F1. Moreover, our approach exhibits superiority in terms
of efficiency, including runtime, query overhead, and API invocation costs. By
leveraging ERASER, we further improve another baseline (i.e., AgentBench) by
approximately 10 points, revealing the strong transferability of our approach.
|
[
-0.2160305679,
-0.874452889,
0.8282762766,
0.2157730758,
0.0461565368,
-0.0425820574,
-0.0764424428,
-0.5120017529,
0.0371129438,
0.8396376967,
-0.7453933358,
-0.5105494261,
-0.3773801625,
0.2945187092,
-0.3221962154,
0.5813094378,
0.1963562369,
-0.1579733789,
-0.12717399,
-0.1369183958,
-0.624920249,
-0.3823496401,
-0.9335638881,
-0.2775165439,
0.4958001077,
0.3761270642,
0.5941376686,
0.7492085695,
0.3684383631,
0.5450407863,
-0.2530442476,
0.4060133994,
-0.5955206752,
0.5772162676,
-0.689548254,
-0.4122106135,
-0.0491487943,
-0.4814426601,
0.2110651881,
0.4348930418,
-0.3942849338,
-0.064246729,
-0.0618302077,
0.5811442733,
-0.8150424361,
0.0659310445,
-0.9326686859,
-0.045655746,
0.1733029783,
-0.254971832,
-0.4988766015,
0.0107980575,
-0.3465270996,
-0.7285263538,
0.3444519639,
0.1453531086,
0.6290035248,
0.6905396581,
-0.3870787919,
-0.1512556821,
-0.6482117176,
0.6881003976,
-0.6204450727,
0.3832746744,
0.4637418389,
0.3946444094,
-0.4108436108,
-0.7995360494,
-0.5034396648,
-0.058803577,
-0.1568331569,
0.1429148018,
-0.1885872036,
-0.1188090444,
0.1359270662,
-0.0199476499,
-0.360733062,
-0.0647187531,
-0.3319457173,
-0.4386532605,
0.4428685308,
0.4697555304,
0.3313368857,
-0.5034726262,
-0.2449112982,
0.0766986012,
-0.464361459,
-0.0835410431,
0.1523455232,
0.4388326108,
0.6823948026,
0.5068416595,
-0.5699581504,
0.6287331581,
0.2109890431,
-0.0962380022,
-0.2042699009,
-0.1894690096,
0.1578852832,
0.2010709047,
0.4633958042,
0.4046196342,
-0.2131201029,
-0.253439635,
-0.4656324983,
-0.0490543209,
0.372345835,
-0.8966715932,
-0.5934545398,
0.4030289352,
-0.1297225654,
0.1437222362,
-0.2386071235,
-0.7075086832,
-0.5706304312,
-0.4777034521,
0.4304929972,
-0.4901198745,
0.1216589957,
0.2281538397,
0.0396118127,
0.2626424432,
0.9734182954,
-0.6872451305,
0.3449486196,
0.7183912992,
0.6931867599,
0.0523373261,
-0.3346753716,
-0.7178656459,
0.2660796642,
-0.3649038672,
1.218200326,
-0.5768411756,
-0.4217542708,
-0.3331338167,
0.1425976753,
-0.1584712863,
-0.7430623174,
0.2960630059,
-0.6380889416,
0.1737201959,
-0.3905975819,
-0.7345923185,
-0.1133268327,
0.3691714704,
-0.6179203391,
1.2594704628,
-0.0073901103,
-0.6040353775,
0.1774923354,
-0.3949266076,
-0.0729050934,
0.2531752288,
0.1086627319,
-0.1473525763,
-0.2506404221,
0.5318048596,
-0.0787245631,
0.2201711684,
0.0937701166,
-0.2194153219,
-0.408294946,
-0.0698511526,
-0.1392357647,
0.6813744903,
0.1721959114,
-0.7245178223,
0.34952268,
-0.9468446374,
0.2506037056,
0.068406865,
-0.1528554708,
-0.2532679141,
0.0239205137,
-0.2082252949,
0.3749750555,
0.0366093442,
-0.6790570021,
-0.0752866343,
-0.2503362,
0.4368832707,
0.9633222222,
0.1511644423,
0.103089802,
-0.1160544157,
0.4640761018,
-0.1860498637,
-0.1704851091,
-0.4567707777,
-0.0270983353,
-1.1279512644,
-0.4312161207,
-0.1155113727,
0.5556448698,
-0.6259794235,
0.5537256002,
-0.111564368,
-0.4909912944,
-0.4219641387,
0.2619002163,
0.3671177626,
0.7505453825,
0.6270044446,
0.4812578857,
-0.2246374637,
-0.6609748602,
-0.5682660937,
-0.2698185444,
0.1146758273,
0.2559807301,
0.5099254251,
-0.2885370255,
1.0525233746,
-0.4847189486,
-0.3806670308,
-0.0318944529,
-0.0820335075,
-0.0330291279,
0.5106136799,
0.1054267064,
-0.3111307621,
-0.1140565798,
-0.0760274082,
-0.7031350732,
-0.4361676276,
0.0113944774,
-0.4734570682,
0.3314996064,
0.8635974526,
-0.6484989524,
0.4672700465,
0.0391220599,
-0.6468159556,
0.3251358271,
-0.214831531,
0.2591480017,
-0.5884222388,
0.0693079382,
-0.2969754636,
-0.5140842795,
-0.3964283466,
0.2471012175,
0.1109121591,
-0.0392113142,
-0.4404533803,
0.7890828252,
-0.2493011355,
0.2606324553,
-0.5137990117,
0.2136437446,
0.4158744216,
0.202712059,
-0.1573677063,
0.8273460865,
0.1260667294,
-0.5282709599,
0.4018758535,
0.4908576906,
0.1127478331,
0.5590008497,
-0.7270892859,
0.5626553297,
-0.3272925913,
0.2660285532,
-1.0931206942,
-0.1557101458,
0.3464445472,
-0.0621229187,
-0.0609511212,
-0.178274259,
-0.5717785954,
-0.2613352537,
-0.2095127702,
0.119224444,
0.1462816596,
-1.1169242859,
0.7008600831,
0.017820362,
-0.2485455573,
-0.3479865491,
-0.5935108662,
0.147914201,
-0.2552450895,
-0.758659482,
0.1424507946,
0.0560801253,
-0.2490938753,
0.0367717668,
-0.4082867205,
0.0931179523,
-0.0141105717,
0.1295046359,
0.0401090123,
-0.0041290997,
0.2863796353,
-0.1131071225,
-0.3043472767,
0.3165187538,
-0.1396851987,
0.4509445727,
-0.408539623,
-0.6785954833,
-0.2255687565,
0.2159272581,
0.1654998362,
-0.3073827922,
0.533639431,
0.1417415142,
-0.2764599323,
-0.5602311492,
-0.852312386,
-0.3336520791,
-0.5411577225,
0.3925550282,
-0.5933333635,
-1.0326037407,
0.8659693003,
-0.0657962039,
-0.3439718187,
0.4710783958,
0.3036179245,
0.1924543232,
1.0165810585,
0.1609583646,
0.3072814941,
0.1505728662,
-0.1218043938,
0.3136911392,
-0.7362812757,
-0.4902583957,
-0.6205407381,
0.0707639903,
-0.3488218188,
-0.2496163845,
0.1963520348,
0.0511059314,
-0.5298340917,
0.1166824326,
-0.6336233616,
0.723048985,
0.5342330933,
0.2518240511,
0.4959827662,
-0.1734085083,
-0.0417451002,
-0.1459801197,
-0.5077402592,
-0.5581083298,
0.4271800518,
0.0230152719,
0.9655416608,
0.1181327626,
0.8655017018,
-0.0039608162,
0.0042998223,
-0.7622237206,
0.7634265423,
0.2723059356,
-0.6482272744,
-0.5892727971,
-0.3671431839,
-0.9617547393,
1.0887744427,
0.2351588905,
-0.9284293652,
0.1255462915,
0.0898041055,
-0.1931991279,
0.4039075375,
-0.5531084538,
1.027982831,
-0.1940538436,
-0.9126383662,
-0.0753388107,
-0.6815346479,
0.1302574724,
-0.1308961064,
0.165771246,
-0.4033681154,
-0.1669314206,
0.2223805487,
-0.9138758779,
0.6531280279,
-0.3550634384,
-0.1280783266,
0.3773032129,
0.3963492811,
0.5838724971,
0.1132964268,
-0.1725828946,
-0.1950514615,
0.233581081,
-0.3638450801,
-0.9214128852,
0.625823319,
-0.5709858537,
-1.0081464052,
-0.4927022159,
-0.3594625592,
-0.2101571709,
0.4500675797,
0.0920789763,
0.2558612227,
0.0650130808,
0.100725323,
0.2948535681,
-0.1557267457,
0.4011650681,
0.6582946181,
-0.5266413093,
-0.4323733747,
0.7692384124,
0.0142886359,
0.1406759173,
0.0824021921,
0.3035590053,
-0.3916561007,
-0.235941872,
-0.3138594031,
0.1885356605,
-1.2740492821,
-0.3864642978,
-0.9424690008,
-0.1105019301,
-0.2655921876,
-0.129008919,
-0.4775978625,
-0.1929454207,
-0.0128535405,
-0.1039936468,
0.3713623285,
0.5086585283,
0.02209826,
0.3566585481,
-0.6520410776,
0.3134877384,
0.3369221687,
0.24237293,
-0.0876470432,
-0.443210721,
0.182532832,
-0.0467963554,
-0.2650283277,
-0.7083274722,
0.5044401288,
0.1262571514,
0.7121243477,
0.1557628363,
0.1911697686,
1.0569444895,
-0.4763406217,
0.727940619,
-0.3371462226,
-1.1335904598,
0.8519319892,
-0.3361126184,
0.4304964244,
1.00023067,
-0.1164507568,
-0.5198948383,
-0.6986301541,
-0.4634833038,
-1.0663553476,
0.7109440565,
0.1831900477,
0.0867065638,
-0.2483864576,
0.4269370437,
0.0337559693,
-0.119857654,
-0.4839198291,
-0.0539632477,
-0.5042287707,
0.0703046918,
0.2100669891,
-0.0561439358,
0.0164261386,
-0.3715070188,
0.8210735917,
-0.3931421638,
-0.1442665458,
0.5739574432,
-0.3874539137,
-0.0642099753,
0.4672276974,
0.0542683937,
0.8523820639,
-0.1703089178,
0.3610171974,
0.3643669784,
-0.124462828,
0.4032047987,
0.041034624,
-0.2613238692,
-0.1655377895,
0.3912325799,
0.4677222967,
0.2171766162,
-0.7334402204,
0.3241894543,
-0.1096645221,
0.0015105802,
-0.068593286,
0.1673960239,
0.0943901315,
0.2662064135,
0.1567314714,
-0.1312285364,
0.5803499222,
-0.0880913213,
0.1498872787,
0.1892929673,
-0.4193793833,
0.003706068,
0.7518169284,
-0.0345568918,
-0.0170236602,
0.9084870219,
-0.3289964795,
-0.5881519914,
0.6245236397,
0.8496106863,
0.7116401792,
-0.2654035389,
0.0761758015,
0.3221960664,
0.1915322542,
-0.0769378766,
0.3140083551,
0.0815312117,
-0.7351452112,
-0.4851725101,
-0.5121636391,
-0.5042461753,
0.0052426136,
-0.5367645025,
0.0209300444,
-0.4003957212,
0.0377358571,
0.0275819432,
-0.2031108737,
-0.3423276544,
0.221334219,
-0.1979344636,
0.6967215538,
-0.3907023668,
0.3010980785,
0.7442081571,
-0.4546993971,
-1.0439628363,
-0.0570835881,
0.3342938125,
-0.6421920657,
0.6752717495,
0.5413814187,
-0.7018623948,
0.0550211184,
-0.5787988305,
-0.9068664312,
0.8620704412,
0.5785201788,
-0.3994795382,
0.2874847651,
-0.0851977691,
0.6559744477,
-0.0528691337,
0.32798329,
0.5780768394,
0.5574617386,
0.4610237777,
-0.3803658783,
0.2769891918,
-0.4570805728,
0.1398250014,
0.1546573788,
-0.7678572536,
0.5430251956,
-0.2065497637,
-0.2133097947,
0.2707983851,
0.6716294289,
0.5316620469,
0.154891938,
0.5189080834,
0.6859328747,
0.9457130432,
0.0534774102,
0.965672493,
-0.4403979778,
0.4584791362,
1.3985946178,
-0.5692638755,
0.7265598774,
0.4410022497,
-0.2435876727,
0.5703258514,
0.4690253735,
-0.0410018191,
0.4685306847,
0.3668675125,
-0.2323145568,
-0.4950467944,
-0.0490533896,
-0.0775722265,
0.6843730211,
0.0658382922,
0.1712860763,
-0.5181390047,
-0.1238825619,
0.2278500944,
0.2931929529,
-0.1860555261,
0.9007959366,
-0.1844583452,
-0.8269520998,
0.2475616187,
-0.1124717966,
0.3222690225,
-0.3529374003,
-0.2348676324,
-0.4275157154,
0.5659223199,
-0.3280455768,
-0.5299061537,
0.3105525076,
-0.3138702214,
0.0978359208,
-0.0214410704,
1.0429041386,
-0.2942326069,
-0.4365436733,
0.6224475503,
0.5937903523,
-0.0593356527,
-0.4237996936,
-0.5086997747,
-0.0052111251,
-0.2639698386,
-0.3964211643,
-0.0650440454,
0.7215473652,
-0.0025458336,
0.915620029,
0.5867052674,
-0.0141736502,
0.2662216723,
0.2315980047,
0.9559239149,
-0.9793159962,
-0.5432977676,
-0.8846039772,
0.3767754436,
-0.1604098082,
-0.1192683876,
0.9004737735,
0.7137743235,
0.7521373034,
0.1095622554,
0.6293325424,
0.3591645062,
0.6297544837,
-0.5746577978,
0.4532910883,
-0.3050311804,
0.5076249242,
-0.1236936226,
-1.0857594013,
-0.3670958281,
0.7779867053,
-0.3984775841,
0.2904917896,
0.8776123524,
1.1487070322,
0.0557441451,
0.1334598213,
0.1297591329,
0.1455259472,
0.6096588969,
0.1539768428,
1.2989339828,
-0.2087384015,
0.4986544251,
-0.3892248571,
0.0992605537,
-0.0390656851,
-0.7515093088,
-0.7466152906,
0.0720806941,
-0.3436722755,
-0.5493272543,
0.423741281,
0.8125963807,
0.5788396597,
-0.8160970211,
0.054487817,
-0.2168617994,
0.0182246212,
-0.0588266887,
-0.2560606003,
0.3877485096,
-0.9397526979,
-0.4691939354,
0.4536802173,
0.4565793872,
-0.4062566459,
-0.0739918128,
-0.0443965718,
-0.0055325604,
0.1631480157,
0.4706941843,
0.1508541703,
-1.1330569983,
-0.6274038553,
0.0923946574,
-0.2189006954,
0.2864177525,
0.5102740526,
-0.8204586506,
0.7082962394,
0.3607333004,
0.7226343751,
0.7268541455,
0.2446076572,
0.1208381131,
-0.3728912175,
-0.1306175888,
0.1079644486,
0.5098829269,
0.5808873177,
-0.5433880687,
0.7059560418,
0.1168739125,
-0.8220792413,
-0.3914864361,
-0.0884038657,
-0.7586019635,
-0.4060564041,
1.2666953802,
-0.0522337258,
-0.4678882062,
-0.1392176896,
-0.7257065773,
-0.1526729912,
-0.4152235985,
0.755967319,
0.5860701203,
-0.4889029264,
-0.3325028121,
-0.1780813634,
0.1576849371,
0.5535941124,
-1.1304309368,
0.1867185235,
1.0021539927,
0.4725989103,
0.1973198801,
0.6927242875,
-0.2418345511,
0.0417114571,
0.2518478036,
0.1014436483,
-0.0987104177,
-0.2875778973,
-0.4131498635,
0.1108569726,
0.0565367527,
0.0855861232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11873v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11873v1
|
CO3: Low-resource Contrastive Co-training for Generative Conversational Query Rewrite
| 2024-03-18T15:26:32 | 2024-03-18T15:26:32 |
Yifei Yuan, Chen Shi, Runze Wang, Liyi Chen, Renjun Hu, Zengming Zhang, Feijun Jiang, Wai Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generative query rewrite generates reconstructed query rewrites using the
conversation history while rely heavily on gold rewrite pairs that are
expensive to obtain. Recently, few-shot learning is gaining increasing
popularity for this task, whereas these methods are sensitive to the inherent
noise due to limited data size. Besides, both attempts face performance
degradation when there exists language style shift between training and testing
cases. To this end, we study low-resource generative conversational query
rewrite that is robust to both noise and language style shift. The core idea is
to utilize massive unlabeled data to make further improvements via a
contrastive co-training paradigm. Specifically, we co-train two dual models
(namely Rewriter and Simplifier) such that each of them provides extra guidance
through pseudo-labeling for enhancing the other in an iterative manner. We also
leverage contrastive learning with data augmentation, which enables our model
pay more attention on the truly valuable information than the noise. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the superiority of our model under both few-shot and
zero-shot scenarios. We also verify the better generalization ability of our
model when encountering language style shift.
|
[
-0.1283127666,
-1.1051943302,
0.0401447788,
-0.1417616308,
-0.4281519055,
0.2243704796,
-0.203027606,
-0.393456161,
0.3495174944,
0.6062672734,
-0.9330743551,
-0.5772430301,
-0.1823837906,
0.051669471,
-0.2803530693,
0.9921947718,
0.2667498887,
-0.0296761077,
-0.1046695262,
-0.1210532337,
-0.3047989607,
-0.5166299939,
-1.1199047565,
-0.2552622855,
0.5202099085,
0.6580438018,
0.7234147787,
0.3380511999,
0.4941181839,
0.1843564808,
0.0371360183,
0.106599614,
-1.0327091217,
0.1888111383,
0.1115054786,
-0.7565079927,
-0.5016878247,
-0.1896913499,
0.1902248561,
0.9760895967,
-0.3112986684,
-0.0954941958,
0.0782415271,
0.6057162881,
-0.6737889647,
0.1142002493,
-1.17276299,
0.1911796331,
-0.0094000828,
-0.2840794921,
-0.4617674351,
-0.0486407466,
0.0322319716,
-0.9798446894,
0.9352080822,
0.4490876794,
0.7927780151,
0.2992509902,
-0.1692201197,
-0.0798734203,
-0.6362176538,
0.9111814499,
-0.355242461,
0.4824224114,
0.4588515162,
0.3346921802,
-0.1488740146,
-0.7715046406,
-0.6296771765,
-0.1705329418,
-0.169902876,
0.4445717335,
-0.3322998881,
0.0039441311,
-0.0183339175,
0.6119269133,
-0.5042307377,
0.1738065332,
-0.3072350621,
-0.2022681087,
0.5667142868,
0.255307436,
0.0591686405,
0.094372794,
-0.1539468765,
-0.1477369815,
-0.8395332098,
-0.2994466424,
0.4160333276,
0.5319284797,
-0.4090403616,
0.1926265955,
-0.5339119434,
0.7749953866,
0.4170466065,
-0.1259097755,
0.0745819509,
-0.6914573312,
-0.3141430616,
-0.0425952077,
0.923189044,
0.357694447,
-0.064451769,
-0.3544082046,
0.2430928051,
-0.10634204,
0.1886372715,
-0.98470819,
-0.4114872217,
-0.0310817286,
-0.2829523981,
-0.3563888669,
-0.3808577657,
-0.8433603048,
-0.1708340794,
-0.2573053539,
0.1258077323,
-0.4860257208,
-0.1025605053,
0.2676142454,
0.0154425316,
0.329624474,
0.5175259113,
-1.2166129351,
0.3546136618,
0.6259334087,
0.7640710473,
-0.1669535935,
0.0222397279,
-0.5393723845,
0.0883001685,
-0.4276612103,
0.6484776139,
-0.6603355408,
-0.5927557349,
-0.0193881448,
0.0121909156,
-0.1049906015,
-0.6990154982,
0.5121728182,
-0.8567324877,
0.3447804451,
-0.1235551685,
-0.2507041693,
0.0609677099,
0.2028604448,
-0.726413846,
0.6996287704,
0.1941371262,
-0.5964090824,
0.4830068648,
-0.4814678431,
-0.5500053763,
-0.0063663544,
-0.1234993637,
-0.9185146093,
-0.0271783397,
0.1076874286,
-0.0462900996,
-0.4070869684,
-0.0567139909,
-0.3026387691,
-0.6326012611,
-0.0073766867,
-0.569152832,
0.4840330482,
0.1713065207,
-0.127717495,
-0.0486748219,
-0.8214526176,
-0.0502280369,
0.2788223922,
-0.3853156567,
-0.0884431675,
-0.3368685246,
-0.1887937784,
-0.0278177969,
-0.0265638772,
-0.3895042837,
0.0656211674,
-0.4800289273,
0.155036658,
0.2587954104,
0.1361162812,
0.5333672166,
-0.2283140272,
0.6040447354,
0.0292493924,
0.0110139763,
0.0003348365,
-0.1704563797,
-1.2286345959,
-0.2650017738,
0.1359056681,
0.383995235,
-0.9786916971,
0.2212492526,
-0.3181883991,
-0.3924900889,
-0.9626854062,
0.3844301701,
0.5628061891,
0.7500747442,
0.6640447974,
-0.3037093878,
-0.6622667909,
-0.8759658933,
-0.3580465615,
-0.0761652589,
0.0697073787,
0.3967187405,
0.3323566318,
-0.0377318524,
0.6072970033,
-0.7274000645,
-0.304699719,
-0.466506809,
0.442782402,
0.0408260413,
0.4387157559,
0.2117469311,
-0.6632531881,
-0.7979700565,
-0.2362747639,
-0.5744187236,
-0.056672778,
-0.1266375482,
-0.3867735565,
0.2986062169,
0.8270850778,
-0.0928327739,
0.3707657158,
0.5177598596,
0.1079463661,
0.1070535183,
-0.0586992875,
0.2179481536,
-1.1502399445,
-0.1594572961,
-0.1078066528,
-0.0541315749,
-0.5289059877,
-0.1283583641,
-0.3986164927,
-0.3268995881,
-0.4185945392,
0.2389371395,
-0.6087251902,
0.023747582,
-0.2975282073,
-0.0689344257,
0.2143508792,
0.7022817731,
0.3386042714,
0.960059166,
0.4468509555,
-0.4707635343,
0.2366127223,
0.3778572679,
-0.2521572113,
0.7502933741,
-0.6888283491,
0.6786751151,
-0.0185378511,
0.4677038789,
-1.0914273262,
-0.1436865181,
0.2472884357,
-0.2222453058,
0.2763226628,
-0.6234084368,
-0.5861792564,
0.120010078,
-0.283033222,
0.37896806,
0.4123873115,
-0.6202498078,
0.0861495137,
0.0138143217,
0.0226407405,
-0.3343587518,
-0.8699243665,
0.1053041294,
-0.2087096274,
-0.6408494711,
0.6958249807,
0.007026379,
-0.0871694237,
-0.2808463275,
-0.0841087177,
-0.2076235116,
0.0385393053,
0.0692548081,
0.2220834196,
-0.3192721009,
0.0456342809,
-0.173266992,
-0.16626665,
-0.2275422812,
0.1780629158,
0.777671814,
0.0015190123,
-0.4442520142,
-0.799716115,
0.5337891579,
0.1164515615,
-0.0637578964,
1.0118252039,
0.6989630461,
0.1373656988,
-0.0391732231,
-0.374946177,
-0.3749751449,
-0.4224020243,
0.4903507531,
-0.5076088309,
-1.0160005093,
0.2784152031,
0.0341140404,
-0.2581391335,
0.3433771729,
0.4686136544,
-0.2476183772,
0.6330263615,
0.60493505,
0.0702256337,
0.7017118931,
-0.3348447084,
0.2463142276,
-0.6851045489,
-0.2041624486,
-0.3292705417,
-0.2329078168,
-0.80392766,
-0.5167988539,
0.4397267103,
0.0536418743,
-0.1080905125,
0.1712350249,
-0.2433552295,
0.5624665022,
0.5264306068,
0.3108802736,
0.5033419132,
0.2836470008,
0.4436985254,
-0.2602097392,
-0.8583370447,
-0.1381338388,
1.1462299824,
-0.1984220147,
1.1749950647,
0.2805105448,
0.7168322206,
0.0253250524,
0.0101500163,
-0.8338159919,
0.4649101496,
-0.3302366436,
-0.4490797222,
-0.2842252851,
-0.2813737392,
-1.1374151707,
0.4640136957,
-0.3383647799,
-0.2380919307,
0.1247255355,
0.5390741825,
-0.465785414,
0.1639965177,
-1.0123450756,
0.8107501268,
-0.0870516598,
-0.9465992451,
-0.409232676,
-0.7104296684,
0.2314586639,
0.0900000185,
-0.1984564662,
0.2142407298,
0.0388935208,
0.5759570003,
-0.5465530157,
1.2675526142,
0.1394050717,
0.0056350259,
0.4350295663,
0.1313705742,
0.5627555847,
-0.1046731398,
-0.1836522669,
-0.01983325,
-0.4437167645,
-0.4368902445,
-0.6060965657,
0.505662322,
-0.658390522,
-0.6736439466,
-0.1322860718,
-0.4664789438,
-0.27851367,
-0.0939090326,
0.4469335973,
0.2492419481,
-0.5344622731,
0.4888802171,
0.6336051822,
-0.1535692513,
0.1515869498,
0.7438139915,
0.2903155684,
-0.2110191584,
0.7131381631,
-0.1152496934,
0.7073355913,
0.5929431319,
-0.0639459565,
-0.3031130731,
-0.5748459697,
-0.2105916739,
0.0895489454,
-0.5877260566,
-0.0470981225,
-0.6416357756,
0.0408212617,
-0.5399621129,
-0.341562748,
-0.4675916433,
-0.1677865386,
-0.3845222294,
0.0922553986,
0.3365525007,
0.0445150174,
0.1414851993,
0.6654561162,
-0.1904793233,
0.5851362944,
0.4757035375,
0.3050135374,
-0.2112940997,
-0.800360918,
-0.172301814,
-0.0998213142,
-0.3108859062,
-0.4837290645,
0.3930802643,
0.3554835916,
0.212579906,
0.1396589428,
0.1359851062,
0.9998328686,
-0.3204302788,
0.537686944,
0.3145748973,
-0.5524398088,
0.6542999148,
-0.1736471355,
0.2882254124,
1.1345669031,
0.1705434918,
-0.4701698422,
-0.1539973617,
-0.770142138,
-0.7311519384,
0.7852124572,
0.0946715251,
0.2399577647,
0.0083991634,
0.2008740455,
0.2817659676,
0.1340784431,
-0.4004265368,
-0.1576026082,
-0.3445543647,
0.0749910921,
0.1087324992,
-0.3327255845,
-0.160538435,
-0.1448380053,
0.5445284843,
-0.3449059725,
0.2333995253,
-0.1121667624,
-0.13157323,
-0.1026559025,
0.6653885841,
0.2815518379,
0.1143469959,
-0.4426864088,
0.1688661724,
0.2913125157,
-0.2109322548,
-0.0459112898,
-0.0467207879,
-0.13339369,
-0.06423112,
0.3861700892,
1.0718793869,
0.4026030302,
-0.2199158669,
0.4854605198,
-0.0751694366,
-0.1866776049,
-0.1309847683,
0.3164587915,
0.1235675514,
-0.1621244848,
-0.2414288819,
0.0021523237,
0.177791208,
-0.9215529561,
-0.0176024064,
0.5039796829,
-0.3747958541,
-0.412545085,
0.5870311856,
0.4598478675,
-0.1474260986,
0.6731898785,
-0.3355086744,
-0.0935303494,
0.2182711959,
0.9006739855,
0.6691862941,
0.0090386439,
0.186166048,
0.5864024162,
0.0080570262,
0.1796344966,
0.118063122,
-0.2906976044,
-0.7534831762,
-0.140244782,
-0.3514736593,
-0.7014661431,
0.3897647858,
-0.7925262451,
0.3969641328,
-0.308285594,
0.242639184,
0.014926861,
0.0147849601,
-0.6499840617,
0.3685020804,
-0.1852981746,
0.4252799749,
-0.848723948,
0.7184385061,
0.370056659,
-0.6797053218,
-0.3302964568,
0.2160882503,
0.1342881471,
-1.1575572491,
0.6966738701,
-0.1703205705,
-0.7077522278,
-0.0220528375,
-0.8388684988,
-0.6146219969,
1.1639838219,
0.5906931162,
-0.7823076248,
0.0845096484,
0.2520620823,
0.7854263783,
-0.3164508343,
0.0893392414,
0.591540575,
-0.0736156404,
0.8427962065,
-0.624768734,
-0.1138636917,
0.136000514,
-0.1218064278,
-0.1197753996,
-1.0978622437,
0.6064278483,
-0.3015012145,
-0.3920080364,
0.0370141044,
0.679799974,
0.2893128693,
0.3257778883,
0.4257348478,
0.6069622636,
0.650364399,
-0.1491208225,
1.1863021851,
-0.1818757057,
0.1623155922,
1.6104958057,
-0.4096631408,
0.9316301346,
0.5339741707,
-0.235071063,
0.4961723685,
0.3869468868,
0.0644579232,
0.7388136387,
0.2067525238,
-0.4160438776,
-0.5011434555,
-0.3904935718,
-0.254080832,
0.6248575449,
0.0425667241,
-0.310013026,
-0.2798974514,
-0.4728487134,
0.4433635175,
0.0714628547,
0.026218731,
1.1132891178,
-0.0609577596,
-0.8260221481,
0.92419523,
-0.1670565307,
0.8996447325,
-0.496766746,
-0.0539061129,
-0.7011547685,
0.1725803912,
-0.2798890471,
-0.4288961589,
0.501162827,
0.0833506435,
-0.2512790561,
-0.241744414,
0.5165935755,
-0.646298945,
-0.276886642,
0.0803520232,
0.4838130474,
0.0729374513,
0.0115698958,
-0.7414782643,
0.0381718799,
0.190678075,
0.2249975204,
0.5093640089,
0.3532564938,
0.0740405247,
0.4496468604,
0.5969209671,
-0.0817532763,
-0.1502965391,
0.5734525919,
0.7954463959,
-0.6048488617,
-0.3961859643,
-0.6801496744,
0.0770625323,
-0.1622378528,
-0.1172537506,
0.4751257002,
0.8471726775,
0.8387010098,
-0.0673143268,
0.6761974096,
0.281299293,
0.4503346384,
-0.7601183653,
0.4935724139,
-0.4515795112,
0.4207228422,
0.0156228617,
-0.4235213995,
-0.3873853981,
0.2111292332,
-0.4584971666,
0.0534915663,
0.6058446169,
1.3322975636,
-0.1465763599,
-0.0095755178,
0.4585923553,
-0.082350485,
0.3768826425,
0.7002572417,
0.7326985002,
-0.5460451245,
0.9226723313,
-0.1940761209,
0.1523040831,
-0.5178455114,
-0.5789654255,
-0.8913404942,
-0.4176854789,
-0.7757060528,
-0.3632200956,
0.1792640984,
0.5593224764,
0.9116877317,
-0.7131513357,
-0.0816060603,
-0.3486672938,
-0.0784363002,
0.0084695602,
-0.2389001548,
0.4799716771,
-0.5143117905,
-0.8298846483,
0.5962614417,
0.3248932064,
0.2712560892,
0.1157858372,
0.0753444508,
-0.1359137297,
-0.0889623314,
0.5178993344,
0.3378654122,
-0.5855866671,
-0.0718639344,
-0.1065554619,
-0.2067337036,
0.4997332692,
0.8319064379,
-0.7053462267,
0.6478036642,
0.2846994996,
0.4680555761,
0.8229075074,
0.088113375,
0.413603574,
-1.1165546179,
0.2951694131,
0.0484053046,
0.077358529,
0.6772812605,
-0.260718286,
0.6301465034,
0.4954235256,
-0.1884762645,
-0.4424670935,
0.3795394301,
-1.1054275036,
0.0499960929,
1.2078994513,
0.0935835689,
-0.0078775929,
-0.215031758,
-0.2632559538,
0.3757247329,
-0.3858124614,
0.8328428864,
0.2818763554,
-0.4752909541,
-0.4555384517,
-0.1915251315,
0.6928090453,
0.5183739662,
-0.8942403197,
0.1026631594,
0.5099601746,
0.3103767037,
0.0364044867,
0.954105258,
-0.1069799662,
0.1361988634,
0.3721565604,
-0.1057151258,
0.0704575479,
0.1005990803,
-0.2657055557,
0.2522785664,
0.0952382684,
-0.4476953149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15450v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15450v1
|
Loops On Retrieval Augmented Generation (LoRAG)
| 2024-03-18T15:19:17 | 2024-03-18T15:19:17 |
Ayush Thakur, Rashmi Vashisth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper presents Loops On Retrieval Augmented Generation (LoRAG), a new
framework designed to enhance the quality of retrieval-augmented text
generation through the incorporation of an iterative loop mechanism. The
architecture integrates a generative model, a retrieval mechanism, and a
dynamic loop module, allowing for iterative refinement of the generated text
through interactions with relevant information retrieved from the input
context. Experimental evaluations on benchmark datasets demonstrate that LoRAG
surpasses existing state-of-the-art models in terms of BLEU score, ROUGE score,
and perplexity, showcasing its effectiveness in achieving both coherence and
relevance in generated text. The qualitative assessment further illustrates
LoRAG's capability to produce contextually rich and coherent outputs. This
research contributes valuable insights into the potential of iterative loops in
mitigating challenges in text generation, positioning LoRAG as a promising
advancement in the field.
|
[
-0.3166603446,
-1.0823259354,
0.3489409387,
0.1544528008,
-0.447314918,
0.2340770364,
-0.0163769145,
-0.3354482949,
0.5185265541,
0.5089657903,
-0.2812547982,
-0.5362353325,
-0.3092333376,
0.0984423533,
-1.0663017035,
1.2297143936,
-0.137836948,
-0.5914306045,
-0.0028862713,
-0.1076893732,
-0.4715044796,
-0.3212636709,
-0.3225786686,
-0.6564286351,
0.6592785716,
0.3480020165,
0.3631155193,
0.4484427869,
0.600615859,
0.2458352298,
-0.1130168587,
0.173215881,
-0.8303576112,
0.7517004609,
-0.2999826074,
0.0375218503,
-0.4518467188,
-0.2256267667,
0.783863306,
0.4322302043,
-0.3363370597,
0.3039073646,
0.1747711599,
0.7035980225,
-0.9810379148,
-0.5524381399,
-0.8555597067,
0.0166776273,
-0.4743298888,
-0.7357994318,
-0.2935077548,
-0.4693552554,
-0.1901172847,
-0.7856822014,
0.1298422366,
0.10206604,
0.8440719843,
0.3242391944,
-0.2461130023,
-0.6406536698,
-0.6625670791,
0.4874523282,
-0.2930959463,
0.1388894618,
0.3210900128,
0.5220813155,
0.0096035032,
-1.0374814272,
-0.6965846419,
0.050318934,
0.3284995556,
0.24458462,
-0.1141079813,
-0.2559640408,
0.2734176517,
0.8880900741,
-0.2152338773,
-0.2020547241,
-0.6498008966,
0.163658753,
0.7363002896,
0.2743454278,
0.1323216408,
-0.3227774799,
-0.3990747631,
0.0510134734,
-0.887203455,
-0.1002191454,
0.5717835426,
0.2737020254,
-0.0523882806,
1.0645965338,
-0.3558574021,
0.7191751599,
0.4625122547,
-0.2241860777,
0.2206853777,
-0.5715796947,
-0.1318709552,
0.325994283,
0.6775855422,
-0.013709465,
-0.2843405306,
0.031567283,
-0.4416993558,
0.193165347,
0.5911682844,
-0.7124032378,
0.0367238112,
0.147879824,
-0.3441640139,
-0.5925619602,
0.0977145433,
-0.82930547,
-0.3786011636,
0.0122400951,
0.5996496677,
-0.4986951053,
0.1119481474,
0.1041728258,
-0.2749136984,
0.0555469319,
0.3138604164,
-0.6531096101,
0.0412463695,
0.6102353334,
0.8195253015,
-0.540528357,
-0.3077166378,
-1.0097448826,
0.3526006639,
-0.3447002172,
1.0350989103,
-0.798801899,
-0.6395317912,
0.2948876619,
-0.4533267617,
0.1599622369,
-0.67798841,
0.6012145281,
-0.797721386,
0.2628670931,
-0.2232414186,
-0.4162554443,
0.1425405592,
0.3397821486,
-0.7731837034,
1.3237890005,
0.3169850707,
-0.9961980581,
0.4526290596,
-0.6285239458,
-0.5568923354,
0.2552179396,
-0.1951311231,
-0.5103901029,
0.3025630116,
-0.1733386219,
-0.1958843172,
-0.5006135106,
0.2642964125,
-0.0855601057,
-0.7883027792,
0.1045629978,
-0.327203095,
0.4722219408,
0.4116845727,
-0.2785430551,
0.1149344966,
-0.9971838593,
0.2545202374,
-0.1813060492,
-1.0942482948,
-0.1389609128,
-0.1986969262,
0.0126569858,
-0.1483388245,
0.2086465359,
-0.3899651468,
0.464785248,
-0.352224797,
0.1886643767,
0.4851712584,
0.2790849805,
0.5283014178,
-0.2818697393,
0.6499973536,
-0.0715540797,
-0.3113947213,
-0.6156104803,
-0.2934222221,
-0.7421478033,
-0.1397837847,
0.449972868,
0.3019373119,
-1.123010993,
0.3643285036,
-0.1584773362,
-0.2284205854,
-0.6425127983,
0.2822897732,
0.3969935775,
0.5202527642,
0.3142010868,
-0.3560246527,
-0.5455131531,
-0.3184829354,
-0.4076862335,
-0.0744044259,
0.2351643741,
-0.0813556761,
0.7372235656,
-0.7025970221,
0.869887948,
-0.2418720424,
-0.0582968444,
-0.2083991766,
0.2996855378,
0.3330818415,
0.4464099109,
0.2978795171,
-0.8042973876,
-0.3938459158,
0.1730463058,
-0.910338521,
-0.332852304,
0.2350222766,
-0.2524444461,
0.2446089834,
0.3432630897,
-0.4787007272,
0.7457098961,
0.362496376,
-0.3529168963,
0.7880193591,
-0.231531173,
0.4223879278,
-1.0532816648,
0.6343234181,
-0.6064454317,
-0.0892376751,
-0.4016504586,
0.5131350756,
-0.2933663726,
-0.3694776893,
-0.036791198,
0.8596988916,
-0.2153995484,
-0.1707043648,
-0.3723458052,
0.532928884,
0.4343717992,
0.0017481671,
-0.5244801044,
1.0014152527,
0.2064482719,
-0.7077175975,
0.4427586496,
0.4796014428,
-0.6721579432,
0.8805019259,
-0.8018707633,
0.1341663301,
-0.0814929008,
0.1544513255,
-0.6426219344,
-0.6671028137,
0.0294086318,
-0.4813531041,
0.1726484448,
0.2705419064,
-0.3308828771,
-0.484395653,
-0.5629347563,
0.5949633718,
0.4478436112,
-0.7301448584,
0.2307282835,
0.1772418916,
-0.035481941,
-0.7145778537,
-0.5836291313,
0.0175758358,
-0.3537392616,
-0.4366461337,
0.7011563182,
-0.1078884453,
-0.5163440704,
-0.0781464055,
0.0867562443,
-0.0009686024,
-0.0851711854,
0.1272446662,
-0.0680281967,
-0.1578491032,
0.3268199861,
0.4260520041,
-0.1836206764,
-0.4165945351,
-0.1854390502,
0.635153234,
0.1889176518,
-0.6388763785,
-0.1238694414,
0.7444018722,
0.3883695006,
-0.261251986,
0.464739114,
0.6549350023,
-0.2891411781,
-0.2690733671,
-0.3528296649,
0.1026439965,
-0.5048322082,
0.115289107,
-0.6173989177,
-0.9364580512,
0.5081339478,
-0.051512856,
-0.1412408501,
0.3933553398,
0.7903021574,
-0.2818136811,
0.7696485519,
0.5799476504,
0.0279711746,
0.5222274661,
-0.4274768829,
0.382925868,
-1.0342539549,
-0.1493643224,
-0.572411716,
-0.1630229801,
-0.5753442049,
-0.4806722105,
0.5661766529,
0.9080370665,
-0.5990536213,
0.0439219289,
-0.638608098,
0.1976728141,
0.6264849305,
0.0280546155,
0.6515942812,
0.3855133355,
-0.2471270114,
0.2368214726,
-0.7492401004,
-0.5737971663,
0.7172706127,
-0.1315314919,
0.9610898495,
0.1305326074,
0.9801509976,
0.8271197677,
0.2290976793,
-0.6537236571,
0.3741083145,
0.0927122608,
-0.4847649932,
-0.070362784,
-0.3501913548,
-1.1037641764,
0.0459154211,
-0.2041728497,
-0.8535405397,
0.0551170856,
0.4427101612,
-0.3570487201,
0.0086874254,
-0.1094866842,
0.3820416331,
0.0105407601,
-1.0259165764,
-0.1267643571,
-0.2544153035,
0.3799410462,
-0.1380915493,
-0.2142326683,
0.2713271081,
0.0998072997,
0.4353038073,
-0.5748108029,
0.292340368,
0.0224374551,
-0.6830902696,
0.8735809922,
0.0589284524,
0.640643239,
0.1189195812,
-0.6355686188,
-0.2899216712,
-0.349837482,
-0.3726726174,
-0.4587527215,
0.9013786912,
-0.3501421809,
-0.6566456556,
-0.0834236816,
-0.2922545373,
0.1147681549,
0.4420978129,
0.8207475543,
0.563906014,
-0.1887021065,
0.161393553,
0.3810119629,
-0.5600051284,
0.3781818748,
0.0051665334,
-0.5755705237,
-0.7280145288,
1.0070968866,
-0.0021066582,
0.1315795481,
0.2379256189,
-0.0742825866,
-0.2561819851,
-0.3911845982,
-0.6779490113,
0.130751133,
-0.8683412075,
-0.4669853747,
-0.4702719748,
-0.1272957325,
-0.2732441127,
-0.4952838719,
-0.1668595374,
-0.3847218156,
-0.241596207,
0.0306541622,
0.3682741821,
0.8774605989,
0.0723557994,
0.3933438957,
-0.6152747273,
0.5357878208,
0.1813257933,
0.425429672,
-0.0400439948,
-0.5225191116,
-0.3034127355,
0.0412509367,
-0.7766116858,
-0.7332248688,
0.4279690087,
0.2272012979,
0.2495034039,
0.2374563962,
0.0593765005,
0.924139142,
-0.4718911946,
0.9147127271,
0.1970609725,
-1.0750267506,
0.7828449607,
-0.7863505483,
0.4870391488,
0.6176865101,
-0.0376356579,
-0.326903522,
-0.0683124885,
-0.3717325628,
-0.837400198,
0.2812472284,
0.3120640814,
0.159319073,
-0.1684777737,
0.5260528326,
0.2927744091,
0.7280511856,
-0.459246099,
0.0628121942,
-0.2151529491,
-0.2182601988,
0.3757025898,
-0.4276385903,
-0.0439411066,
-0.023940824,
0.5593607426,
-0.2669745088,
0.5938737392,
0.1915471852,
-0.0246784799,
-0.2944701016,
0.311404556,
0.7245132923,
0.6707710624,
0.1088954881,
0.0763569176,
-0.0267951135,
-0.3212724626,
0.111321643,
-0.2204612643,
-0.4305146039,
0.0702579543,
0.5429686308,
0.92017138,
0.0472459979,
-0.7119289637,
0.2835806012,
0.3227709532,
0.0134572154,
-0.2441146523,
0.3559234142,
-0.2854009271,
0.3903655112,
0.5452222824,
-0.1160043329,
0.3531177342,
-0.7725487947,
0.2658462226,
0.2906177342,
-0.2533974051,
-0.3683365881,
0.7333981395,
0.2810420394,
-0.6709872484,
0.4831615686,
-0.2407359183,
-0.4553390443,
0.1250590831,
0.9074490666,
0.586073935,
-0.0251270942,
0.1659191996,
0.5763539672,
-0.3103083372,
-0.1379032433,
0.5951786041,
-0.5265612006,
-0.4405322373,
-0.2543611825,
-0.9984847307,
-0.2164497972,
-0.131379962,
-0.7484313846,
0.358042717,
-0.0521915965,
-0.2932693362,
-0.5023120046,
-0.0488965772,
-0.2177004665,
0.0916948915,
-0.2852857113,
0.8589083552,
-0.207682848,
0.7237645388,
0.6620438099,
-0.4067495465,
-0.2288229465,
0.1139112413,
-0.2087236345,
-0.5729708076,
0.7425712943,
0.0491510853,
-0.4470936358,
0.0730615184,
-0.5295376182,
-0.7048442364,
1.140666008,
0.2255281657,
-0.4680918753,
-0.075545013,
-0.0040516746,
0.6539748311,
-0.4304029644,
-0.0886294693,
0.4572888017,
0.4439458847,
0.1816588789,
-0.6665441394,
-0.2481927127,
-0.7297778726,
0.1174941882,
0.2564093173,
-0.4128572345,
0.9612793326,
-0.3935295343,
-0.4602690637,
0.6953165531,
0.5094721317,
0.8227966428,
0.6624132395,
-0.1407555491,
0.8044371009,
0.9429656267,
-0.0169390067,
1.3031685352,
-0.3687011003,
0.4315868616,
1.2836296558,
-0.4903161824,
0.9599124193,
0.6089030504,
0.1676606238,
0.7353638411,
0.2255572528,
0.3328154981,
0.5742459893,
0.2884860039,
-0.6156615615,
0.0957818702,
-0.3232868016,
-0.5022233129,
0.5663514137,
0.2734411359,
-0.5475617647,
-0.0939957872,
0.2247105539,
-0.2102766782,
0.3260146379,
-0.3263033032,
0.6743308306,
-0.1465579122,
-0.9224923253,
1.0205200911,
-0.0687513426,
0.6737962365,
-0.2580624521,
-0.3303221464,
-0.3666643202,
0.2749572098,
-0.2667201161,
-0.6453207135,
0.360784024,
0.3746802807,
-0.3260582387,
-0.162670061,
1.1083878279,
-0.4098207951,
-0.3734927475,
0.2269552052,
0.4288454652,
-0.1246371418,
0.0942458734,
-0.3979673088,
0.6503750682,
-0.0418888181,
-0.2778829932,
-0.0999622047,
0.6467247605,
0.0501164831,
0.5837023854,
0.2477826774,
0.0092045348,
0.0834039152,
0.0066832849,
1.033646822,
-0.8838849068,
-0.3463323414,
-0.5863490701,
0.6152819991,
-0.2609582245,
-0.4469853044,
0.7381561995,
0.6210460663,
0.7210715413,
0.0760662258,
0.8628796339,
-0.2722266018,
0.5784312487,
-0.594484508,
0.7037913203,
-0.6746130586,
0.574508965,
-0.4152204394,
-1.0138889551,
-0.0102653708,
0.6260522604,
-0.1523173004,
0.163346827,
0.6401267052,
0.5915170312,
-0.0906255171,
-0.1058479324,
0.3472794294,
0.0924168527,
0.2018452138,
0.1619585901,
1.0825763941,
-0.9338402152,
0.1717997044,
0.1790630221,
0.1717556119,
-0.4169585705,
-0.6993767023,
-0.7291936874,
-0.7759990096,
-0.0828310549,
-0.5752776861,
0.2704098225,
0.5208789706,
0.2543975711,
-0.4795196652,
-0.2103679627,
-0.2375813723,
0.2214158475,
0.2104174048,
-0.2935221791,
0.1110506952,
-0.4740996361,
-0.6102057695,
0.3608549535,
0.5378650427,
-0.2265785635,
-0.2282099873,
-0.1553230733,
-0.1783659607,
0.0764218941,
0.942225039,
0.1515169591,
-0.4926434159,
-0.2026614398,
-0.0893388465,
-0.1789261848,
0.2434139103,
1.1490498781,
-1.0888292789,
0.4772422314,
0.7950073481,
0.6565794945,
0.5908751488,
0.2718855143,
0.5351850986,
-0.7687934041,
-0.0096983546,
0.0798570067,
0.1134600788,
0.4344802201,
-0.1381684542,
0.6388352513,
0.0909866989,
-0.5135375261,
-1.1760555506,
0.4078994393,
-0.7319095731,
0.0303734653,
1.1097763777,
-0.0619712621,
-0.1826638281,
-0.0220389292,
-0.40820086,
0.2519720495,
-0.3346460164,
1.1023750305,
0.2292679101,
-0.1697189063,
-0.0241657663,
-0.177899614,
0.3761805594,
0.1521063447,
-1.1003373861,
-0.0601504631,
0.5870867968,
-0.2821445465,
0.5549408197,
0.6780275702,
-0.2199552953,
0.4457290173,
0.1841915995,
-0.1829611808,
0.2291805297,
-0.3406359553,
-0.1844451427,
0.4886188507,
-0.0394201092,
0.2949792743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11858v1
|
GPT-4 as Evaluator: Evaluating Large Language Models on Pest Management in Agriculture
| 2024-03-18T15:08:01 | 2024-03-18T15:08:01 |
Shanglong Yang, Zhipeng Yuan, Shunbao Li, Ruoling Peng, Kang Liu, Po Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence (AI), the
application of large language models (LLMs) in agriculture, particularly in
pest management, remains nascent. We aimed to prove the feasibility by
evaluating the content of the pest management advice generated by LLMs,
including the Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT) series from OpenAI and
the FLAN series from Google. Considering the context-specific properties of
agricultural advice, automatically measuring or quantifying the quality of text
generated by LLMs becomes a significant challenge. We proposed an innovative
approach, using GPT-4 as an evaluator, to score the generated content on
Coherence, Logical Consistency, Fluency, Relevance, Comprehensibility, and
Exhaustiveness. Additionally, we integrated an expert system based on crop
threshold data as a baseline to obtain scores for Factual Accuracy on whether
pests found in crop fields should take management action. Each model's score
was weighted by percentage to obtain a final score. The results showed that
GPT-3.4 and GPT-4 outperform the FLAN models in most evaluation categories.
Furthermore, the use of instruction-based prompting containing domain-specific
knowledge proved the feasibility of LLMs as an effective tool in agriculture,
with an accuracy rate of 72%, demonstrating LLMs' effectiveness in providing
pest management suggestions.
|
[
-0.3139005303,
-0.7524269819,
0.7474927902,
0.1230243891,
-0.1636227965,
-0.0908633471,
-0.5474393964,
-0.4169556499,
0.0434681885,
0.0730430856,
0.0263632126,
-0.6972374916,
-0.7710728049,
0.4608586729,
-0.6111430526,
1.1925258636,
-0.1742345244,
-0.0356069691,
-0.3585063815,
0.0926044881,
-0.426961422,
-0.5585027337,
-0.7447767854,
-0.2154389918,
0.4690638483,
0.1749419123,
0.8051882386,
0.1046988443,
0.8560248017,
0.3899550438,
-0.2031795084,
0.0569842048,
-0.3462368846,
-0.2524890304,
-0.3868203163,
-0.3757100105,
-0.4771283567,
0.4823333025,
0.2531528771,
0.3272586167,
-0.2057514936,
0.1462817341,
0.2741446793,
0.1691179127,
-0.2664034665,
0.3439490199,
-0.6899006963,
0.1631993949,
0.0110551557,
-0.3740820587,
-0.3690396249,
-0.4631722569,
0.2191614956,
-0.73497051,
0.1148788631,
-0.1202117428,
0.9811751842,
0.2950060666,
-0.0966645628,
-0.4640262127,
-0.928334415,
0.5897775888,
-0.7874282598,
-0.2474618852,
0.5010740757,
0.4486362934,
-0.1986857504,
-0.6651870608,
-0.5277955532,
-0.4731952548,
0.0947931409,
0.3368092477,
-0.353245765,
0.0145294648,
-0.018646054,
0.4231664836,
-0.4586744606,
0.0973099098,
-0.3214577734,
-0.3760355711,
0.3789669573,
0.1086117402,
0.1974592507,
-0.0142554976,
-0.3134479523,
0.1071017161,
-0.3675522804,
0.1323258579,
0.185045898,
0.1313133538,
0.1647668034,
0.6284405589,
0.0866734535,
0.6230670214,
0.1579963863,
-0.1240479648,
-0.00627553,
-0.5917703509,
-0.1637670696,
-0.4500439763,
0.9097032547,
0.4785611033,
0.1992814839,
0.0109038623,
-0.4325452149,
0.2719525397,
0.4954824746,
-0.5348806977,
-0.3457461298,
0.1313312948,
-0.3055384755,
-0.6274299622,
0.1091919169,
-1.0491405725,
-0.2635068893,
-0.1799751073,
0.5710452199,
-0.5482797623,
-0.181095466,
-0.0800635964,
-0.1239333525,
0.5523592234,
0.3502715826,
-0.6382768154,
0.2294585556,
0.8667827249,
0.9610924721,
-0.3567526639,
-0.2384661287,
-0.2804123759,
-0.067015864,
-0.4531817138,
0.8938890696,
-0.8327860236,
-0.3264470994,
-0.1597600132,
-0.1592416465,
-0.2429265529,
-0.6291614175,
0.5956658721,
-0.6547725797,
0.286735177,
-0.0033497342,
-0.5468407869,
-0.4796101749,
0.7105497122,
-0.5578811765,
0.7847651243,
0.6382542253,
-0.4759972692,
0.5532167554,
-0.7639898062,
-0.3136475086,
0.3947919309,
-0.293664217,
-0.5985212326,
-0.1738667041,
0.271992594,
0.2655598521,
-0.3002997637,
0.2171437591,
-0.1072233617,
-0.1500041336,
0.2312374413,
-0.6464707851,
0.3259901106,
0.0963375494,
-0.4796976745,
0.4720889926,
-0.3310247958,
0.0079121944,
0.2476178706,
-0.5460405946,
-0.0764329731,
-0.1731034219,
-0.2155639231,
-0.1334149987,
0.1874632984,
-0.3224469721,
0.2022941113,
-0.6509978175,
0.4780716896,
0.5862798691,
0.1007780358,
0.2289739549,
-0.4252661765,
0.8828405142,
-0.1053507924,
0.2327168882,
-0.057680916,
-0.7090620995,
-0.5658470988,
-0.1338401437,
0.3708264828,
0.5460288525,
-0.9058507681,
0.5036044717,
-0.3697793782,
-0.4444261491,
0.0409855843,
0.0142365713,
0.0887626633,
0.4094053805,
0.401817888,
-0.2657275796,
-0.1055667028,
-0.4860402644,
-0.3425765038,
0.210555926,
0.0665165335,
-0.0872426853,
0.7323340178,
-0.204234615,
1.1549869776,
-0.5742342472,
-0.2649888694,
-0.4239237905,
0.2139457166,
0.3366056979,
0.1062627584,
0.9501790404,
-0.7671148181,
-0.7127244473,
0.2747959495,
-0.5684846044,
-0.0413730182,
0.252176851,
0.0657596365,
0.0833782777,
-0.1730645448,
-0.8782849908,
0.6547409296,
0.5898345709,
-0.3886556625,
0.8948648572,
-0.2769702673,
0.3418166637,
-0.8368936181,
-0.032511875,
0.2332098931,
-0.4420283139,
-0.5447057486,
0.0471042395,
-0.2504636347,
-0.205696255,
-0.3638998866,
0.2425799966,
-0.1795164347,
-0.0854705796,
-0.4277505577,
0.1971182674,
0.029785784,
0.4167048335,
-0.4134160578,
1.1991666555,
0.4479942322,
-0.5287550092,
0.7439855337,
0.2162817121,
-0.2724125385,
0.6697851419,
-0.4037075937,
-0.0486506,
0.0906753913,
0.2142008841,
-0.7373052835,
-0.2595177591,
0.7413546443,
-0.3176642358,
0.2840138376,
0.0585539602,
-0.1968951076,
-0.7490560412,
-0.2884401679,
0.1736389697,
0.4907120466,
-0.3470519185,
0.9824529886,
-0.0168248862,
-0.4653242528,
0.069505401,
-0.1952622831,
0.2248155773,
-0.5326206088,
-0.3965031803,
-0.1572119445,
0.0069826762,
-0.1800028384,
0.1951509714,
-0.2978799045,
-0.1349227428,
-0.0459500179,
0.0113442037,
-0.0446512885,
-0.220523119,
-0.1025082618,
-0.1280325502,
-0.1718288362,
0.3090976477,
-0.6404453516,
0.4015949965,
-0.1648470461,
-0.3954865634,
-0.5339861512,
0.0212163366,
0.5463128686,
-0.4878088534,
0.3417775333,
0.4282226264,
-0.1809501201,
-0.1060697436,
-0.2820028961,
0.049609907,
-0.4827578366,
0.3289763927,
-0.3210529089,
-0.5556833744,
0.0214555059,
-0.4827446938,
-0.0607467741,
0.7975159883,
0.2575659752,
-0.0189074762,
0.7671878338,
0.5669784546,
-0.3563469648,
0.2096712142,
-0.5396786332,
0.1942764968,
-0.4855206609,
-0.3190226555,
-0.4600043297,
-0.1307332814,
-0.0851344019,
-0.6969501376,
0.6405892372,
-0.0890083835,
-0.2248138785,
0.1084531844,
-0.4913039207,
0.5020952225,
0.4571900368,
0.0925064161,
0.2544980943,
0.146597147,
-0.0572403297,
0.4012072682,
-0.5387827158,
-0.9201238751,
0.9531285167,
0.3995673656,
0.5421953201,
0.0388821922,
0.255849272,
0.606949687,
0.794252038,
-1.1631484032,
0.5845518708,
-0.2406009436,
-0.0977079123,
-0.4886524677,
-0.5732243657,
-1.0355098248,
0.2672047019,
0.0414425358,
-0.6740551591,
-0.2922391891,
0.2235247344,
-0.4791961312,
0.2624017,
-0.6149545312,
0.8448600769,
-0.6418865919,
0.075371854,
-0.2433504611,
-0.0987795889,
0.2870307267,
-0.4919451177,
0.3535060883,
-0.133313641,
-0.0745847151,
0.8246363401,
-0.7329912186,
0.8144855499,
-0.2703291774,
-0.4250914752,
0.6576887965,
0.0343487263,
0.6673966646,
-0.0990987122,
-0.2861390412,
0.4497222006,
0.0101486975,
0.0004581281,
-0.6414701343,
0.6491684914,
-0.8914349675,
-0.7274079919,
-0.6254121065,
-0.2560509741,
-0.0938873142,
0.2524040937,
0.2800107896,
0.2981804609,
-0.1272069812,
0.0318683013,
0.2382050008,
-0.2827611268,
0.3412739635,
0.4577839971,
-0.374923408,
-0.6780988574,
1.0022563934,
0.0345624164,
-0.0659443289,
0.3156234026,
0.6708331108,
-0.2535587847,
-0.5551156402,
-0.4049162865,
-0.0871188864,
-0.6932089329,
-0.5887351036,
-0.4467085302,
-0.3351878226,
-0.116305992,
0.0538843982,
0.0698865205,
0.0473406501,
-0.4593722224,
-0.1839430332,
0.5485681295,
1.2498670816,
0.35244295,
0.6013650894,
-0.8658567667,
0.2988800108,
0.0835468173,
0.5056186318,
-0.0395168662,
-0.5289992094,
-0.2654278278,
0.2915017009,
-0.6665052772,
-1.2127132416,
0.5687215328,
0.3069146574,
0.5050265193,
0.4310609996,
-0.2569069266,
0.1927547157,
-0.3832529187,
1.0827412605,
0.129711777,
-1.091109395,
0.4100628197,
-0.4056884646,
0.2603339255,
0.1189846769,
0.5989843607,
-0.0452054888,
-0.5441556573,
-0.0191237461,
-0.8094911575,
0.6090216637,
0.3438702524,
-0.1472262293,
0.2014436573,
0.4002739489,
0.2261714935,
0.1832973063,
-0.6143233776,
0.1266615093,
-0.4572301209,
-0.5564512014,
-0.1860398054,
-0.3507909477,
-0.1453233957,
-0.3806251585,
0.557493329,
0.0036047797,
0.1221717149,
0.0231304783,
0.0374212973,
-0.1531882435,
0.4555158317,
0.5902860761,
0.9668574929,
0.2286554873,
0.170148477,
0.2941098511,
-0.6903538108,
0.3992665708,
0.1593692303,
-0.4343982339,
-0.2535207272,
0.3293631971,
0.5287615061,
0.1393059343,
-0.1494151205,
0.700689435,
0.0995315984,
-0.524496913,
-0.382889837,
0.0829256922,
-0.2513046563,
0.1379828304,
0.3353453875,
0.1459242105,
0.170140028,
-0.0385322347,
0.1761417538,
0.3597679734,
-0.1293308735,
-0.4538355768,
0.5104846358,
0.4623964131,
-0.2414530963,
0.4645801187,
-0.3756377399,
-0.9064671397,
0.7614423633,
0.5492830873,
0.6989600062,
-0.2156817466,
0.3318919539,
0.1490760446,
0.4249294698,
0.0435363874,
0.4363040924,
0.2875327468,
-0.5499731898,
-0.572827816,
-0.8747986555,
-0.3471929133,
0.4698097706,
-0.236691758,
0.0852321908,
-0.3305082917,
-0.4841711223,
0.0318799429,
-0.0987451151,
-0.7056753039,
0.2455137372,
-0.1998452097,
1.0283827782,
-0.733602047,
0.4504740536,
0.9274991155,
-0.5387200713,
-1.0488468409,
0.2737902999,
-0.1175975278,
-0.4331349432,
0.4126750231,
0.2979300916,
-0.1585352868,
0.0970042199,
-0.717990756,
-1.0414967537,
0.8293069601,
-0.0907295644,
-0.5474376082,
0.2659495771,
0.3584468365,
0.6206567287,
-0.0238010585,
0.4195828736,
0.5725976825,
0.9535294771,
0.0435086377,
-0.9880994558,
-0.1081715673,
-0.0762292817,
-0.0087602735,
0.2695435286,
-0.5473871231,
0.6103121042,
0.0781438947,
-0.3358335197,
0.290490061,
0.8878909945,
-0.2734028697,
0.5327253342,
0.5652945638,
0.4205524921,
0.6463609934,
-0.2830446064,
0.9507330656,
-0.5361179709,
0.4336340725,
0.9604063034,
-0.3296469748,
0.6977266073,
0.0818915069,
-0.4479367137,
0.4410369396,
0.52594769,
-0.3651927114,
0.2960439622,
0.384226799,
-0.2740275562,
0.023630945,
0.0612670742,
-0.2869468927,
0.6301698685,
0.5275007486,
-0.1515367925,
-0.2967711985,
0.3954217732,
-0.1286842525,
0.2711255848,
-0.5219166875,
0.8906573653,
0.060742747,
-0.6416558027,
0.2000280619,
0.1494818032,
0.6346704364,
-0.7015649676,
-0.2509694993,
-0.0582825169,
0.1506942511,
-0.2482426167,
-0.9547374845,
0.4952605069,
0.2699015141,
-0.1166364402,
0.0203055926,
0.5891352296,
-0.3665314615,
-0.541251123,
0.070373714,
0.1479936838,
0.3738202155,
-0.2997332513,
-0.3940794766,
0.0344455838,
-0.351018995,
-0.2099925131,
-0.1411456019,
0.3776207864,
-0.1177595854,
0.5053857565,
0.5101573467,
0.3139425218,
-0.0434283391,
0.0169387683,
1.0549389124,
-0.6124723554,
-0.3106449246,
-0.8682944775,
0.0908693075,
-0.0916780531,
0.0280899033,
1.0397398472,
0.5647562146,
0.7934106588,
-0.1804734915,
1.0715653896,
-0.004152935,
0.2793633938,
-0.3186745644,
0.5996860862,
-0.2206362337,
0.1467793286,
-0.0287292004,
-0.9143938422,
-0.0786737129,
0.3799141049,
-0.7931211591,
0.3935268521,
0.7133131623,
0.5129072666,
0.030981686,
0.024318872,
0.3728471994,
0.4223556519,
0.5900411606,
0.3406695426,
1.2209763527,
0.0973074883,
0.747128129,
0.1109334305,
-0.5651687384,
-0.1502507478,
-0.9065482616,
-0.6540158987,
0.0160254426,
-0.088204518,
-0.0366171896,
0.1223619208,
0.8805681467,
0.4123663008,
-0.8896130919,
0.0614451319,
-0.0898319036,
-0.1351151615,
-0.3411049247,
-0.3249191344,
0.4178583324,
-0.3875664771,
-0.4521028697,
0.4547787607,
0.4587267339,
0.1493660957,
-0.3946765065,
-0.0429572463,
0.1683097333,
0.1023438722,
0.6829019785,
0.0920921937,
-0.9083033204,
-0.2960557044,
-0.2296286672,
-0.0574713349,
-0.0128210075,
0.6326519251,
-0.5209400058,
0.2768807113,
0.3278486431,
0.511967659,
-0.0937088132,
0.4162778556,
0.7881242633,
-0.3451945484,
-0.2714313269,
0.3683878183,
0.1571756601,
0.2596925795,
-0.676140964,
0.3866687417,
0.1374155581,
-0.6779991984,
-0.1014355421,
0.0722973645,
-0.6861202121,
-0.1809767783,
1.3269939423,
-0.5146888494,
-0.2443413138,
-0.05078936,
-0.4734573364,
0.1758802086,
-0.3608094156,
0.6117787957,
0.5473430753,
0.0549748912,
-0.0754701346,
-0.2990265489,
0.4942842424,
0.1359587759,
-1.0695784092,
-0.4541943073,
0.4633484781,
0.2726860344,
0.185700655,
0.5787336826,
0.1213620156,
-0.0543856509,
-0.2286323607,
0.0281587653,
-0.158148244,
-0.5694928169,
-0.3838296831,
0.1993544102,
0.3197081387,
-0.0669605136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11838v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11838v2
|
Ensuring Safe and High-Quality Outputs: A Guideline Library Approach for Language Models
| 2024-03-18T14:48:29 | 2024-03-23T06:26:41 |
Yi Luo, Zhenghao Lin, Yuhao Zhang, Jiashuo Sun, Chen Lin, Chengjin Xu, Xiangdong Su, Yelong Shen, Jian Guo, Yeyun Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit impressive capabilities but also present
risks such as biased content generation and privacy issues. One of the current
alignment techniques includes principle-driven integration, but it faces
challenges arising from the imprecision of manually crafted rules and
inadequate risk perception in models without safety training. To address these,
we introduce Guide-Align, a two-stage approach. Initially, a safety-trained
model identifies potential risks and formulates specific guidelines for various
inputs, establishing a comprehensive library of guidelines and a model for
input-guidelines retrieval. Subsequently, the retrieval model correlates new
inputs with relevant guidelines, which guide LLMs in response generation to
ensure safe and high-quality outputs, thereby aligning with human values. An
additional optional stage involves fine-tuning a model with well-aligned
datasets generated through the process implemented in the second stage. Our
method customizes guidelines to accommodate diverse inputs, thereby enhancing
the fine-grainedness and comprehensiveness of the guideline library.
Furthermore, it incorporates safety expertise from a safety-trained LLM through
a lightweight retrieval model. We evaluate our approach on three benchmarks,
demonstrating significant improvements in LLM security and quality. Notably,
our fine-tuned model, Labrador, even at 13 billion parameters, outperforms
GPT-3.5-turbo and surpasses GPT-4 in alignment capabilities.
|
[
-0.128622368,
-0.3730236292,
0.5959150195,
-0.1739307344,
-0.2731698453,
-0.0570846498,
-0.1235803664,
-0.3488670588,
-0.395121038,
0.8109191656,
-0.4812401533,
-0.6923497319,
-0.5273373723,
-0.2806351185,
-0.4653169811,
1.1202279329,
-0.0653089657,
0.2244660854,
0.0165056307,
-0.0143902628,
-0.4885565341,
-0.3603278995,
-0.6085623503,
-0.3451460898,
0.7090108395,
0.2730620503,
0.9486098289,
1.0878676176,
0.7733595371,
0.0943215564,
-0.1685852706,
0.2916865945,
-0.5121062994,
0.1217465401,
-0.408176899,
0.0886049271,
-0.7368513346,
0.0170435105,
0.5105867982,
0.6343196034,
-0.3451245427,
0.0074517713,
0.51016891,
0.6343027949,
-0.5683320165,
-0.1280182302,
-0.4312321246,
-0.2875840366,
-0.1412192881,
-0.1753567755,
-0.5557242632,
-0.7328074574,
0.0938607156,
-0.5502711535,
-0.137903735,
0.2125042081,
1.039476037,
0.4029203951,
-0.4054190516,
-0.2793528438,
-0.6909988523,
0.6828894615,
-0.8615213633,
0.5015441179,
0.2736881375,
0.2170940638,
-0.4270864427,
-0.4049730003,
-0.1869089007,
0.1456643492,
-0.105444625,
-0.2162196636,
0.1853864193,
0.1774093509,
0.0997590348,
0.0121441931,
-0.7942877412,
0.3007826805,
-0.1348093599,
-0.363253206,
0.7918230891,
0.0454986021,
0.1441091001,
-0.0025235796,
-0.3392188549,
-0.2306985408,
-1.0177465677,
-0.1572005302,
0.7157310843,
0.6616093516,
0.1081053838,
0.4963831007,
-0.1459475011,
0.6830694675,
0.2181802243,
-0.44963485,
0.0306410082,
-0.7012720108,
-0.089163661,
0.2999866009,
0.9374009371,
0.5117888451,
0.2521263957,
-0.1764968336,
-0.2928887308,
-0.3039943576,
0.3119797707,
-0.6249524951,
0.0107382089,
0.1655991971,
-0.2744534016,
-0.478107661,
-0.0285029933,
-0.5711150765,
-0.6676673889,
-0.5330190659,
0.4886442721,
-0.4106225967,
-0.1507683843,
0.1328582466,
0.32377249,
0.5694108009,
0.2837753892,
-0.9392552972,
0.3711321652,
0.9894180298,
0.6585015059,
-0.1980513781,
0.0553666577,
-0.7098594904,
0.5141378641,
-0.3452178836,
0.4843513966,
-0.2572422028,
-0.2013578415,
0.2146580219,
0.088104032,
0.3182198107,
-0.1709428281,
0.923866868,
-0.6211007833,
0.0752681643,
-0.2105619907,
-0.4986136556,
0.0201303028,
0.1660448611,
-0.4516468048,
0.9277257323,
-0.1570003331,
-0.7440919876,
0.3482346237,
-0.1060108542,
-0.5080021024,
-0.1244273409,
-0.1521398276,
-0.370298177,
-0.2003685534,
0.2600823045,
0.2342208177,
-0.3502261341,
0.6922067404,
-0.3276023865,
-0.1358713508,
0.0121631017,
-0.3042513132,
0.6723658442,
0.2421201169,
-0.1234884262,
0.2621975541,
-0.7378576398,
0.141518876,
-0.2105351537,
-0.5458013415,
-0.3703247607,
0.164748475,
0.0493380763,
0.2952784896,
0.4987254739,
-0.4114908278,
-0.0384690724,
-0.293527931,
0.1560758054,
0.9255797863,
-0.1466520727,
0.6671667099,
-0.2480190843,
0.3024705052,
-0.1884851158,
0.3984335661,
0.0012995005,
-0.242854923,
-0.5007085204,
0.0656766817,
0.3338484764,
0.6334802508,
-0.2003786415,
0.8696859479,
-0.2172878087,
-0.3671484292,
-0.5494886637,
0.4918987155,
0.5679392815,
0.6850759387,
0.1729997545,
-0.3160345256,
-0.6166056991,
-0.9149523377,
-0.0787822306,
-0.2682504952,
0.0702155381,
0.0080753472,
0.0538136065,
-0.2110764831,
1.0035734177,
-0.3951348066,
-0.1431149393,
-0.1021540314,
0.0134537937,
0.1275416464,
0.729835391,
0.1383811384,
-0.5010827184,
-0.389210701,
0.1875024289,
-0.8176491261,
-0.3168051541,
0.1955117583,
-0.6707651019,
0.2216048092,
0.4840052724,
-0.2022564411,
0.0461618304,
0.6641373038,
-0.1654671878,
0.214259252,
-0.1000903025,
-0.1771578044,
-1.3424700499,
0.0260957833,
0.1671324819,
-0.359562546,
-0.6656210423,
-0.0788677782,
0.2298117429,
-0.0683266148,
-0.303514719,
0.5971440673,
-0.3197647035,
0.1057849079,
-0.2366599292,
0.1198182255,
0.181731984,
0.1393570006,
0.0186769925,
0.6529017091,
0.5052847862,
-0.4470230341,
0.2950681746,
0.2155439854,
-0.2118504792,
0.6021405458,
-0.5382544994,
0.1442458928,
-0.1731310487,
0.0206147749,
-0.8520221114,
-0.3214586079,
0.2426346391,
-0.0681132525,
0.7165544629,
-0.2973831892,
-0.59352988,
0.0024738214,
-0.3758898973,
0.1808480024,
0.6913927197,
-0.3831768036,
0.576256752,
0.5386688113,
-0.4436702132,
-0.9196616411,
-0.3953062892,
-0.0191206504,
-0.3127725124,
-0.6758856773,
0.1282318532,
-0.1499007493,
-0.0822775066,
-0.0419902466,
-0.1996862143,
0.0141380318,
0.1722875834,
0.2074893117,
0.3429260552,
-0.100625515,
-0.0675408915,
0.1017270982,
-0.1269067079,
-0.0237525012,
-0.3789237142,
0.4036187232,
0.0262860321,
-0.4201890528,
-0.3868987858,
0.3404195011,
0.4670498967,
-0.2156410813,
0.6371769309,
0.4199032784,
-0.4538096786,
0.0776500702,
-0.7026309967,
-0.1476659775,
-0.4829105735,
0.2251570672,
0.0938910916,
-0.7091377974,
0.3244396448,
0.1084958911,
0.3621701002,
0.1195204705,
0.3922917545,
-0.2611370385,
1.3192173243,
0.9640652537,
0.0166511592,
0.4949970841,
0.3839201331,
0.4314776659,
-0.8632707596,
-0.312258631,
-0.5591329336,
-0.0178262331,
-0.489408195,
-0.1647735536,
0.2456203401,
0.3260362446,
-0.4730753601,
0.4484439492,
-0.4406879544,
0.4173623621,
0.5209357142,
0.0717905536,
0.3433240354,
-0.0487588048,
-0.1561288089,
-0.0518310256,
-0.5490121841,
-1.0343803167,
1.2293870449,
0.6213182211,
1.4582167864,
0.3907346129,
0.8906666636,
-0.0329531804,
0.3224295676,
-0.6700515747,
0.5287397504,
-0.2381544411,
-0.6490207314,
-0.2622684836,
-0.2855213881,
-0.597925365,
-0.0465539768,
-0.1768499911,
-0.7630190253,
0.0261269864,
0.2481185794,
-0.4890797138,
-0.0366435908,
-0.5854720473,
0.7618310452,
-0.6377805471,
-0.7570647597,
0.1915928423,
-0.7298935652,
0.5591593981,
-0.4172213674,
0.3882733285,
-0.2339373678,
0.0868102536,
0.7582845688,
-0.2766258121,
0.8332098722,
0.0712242499,
-0.5237884521,
0.0103047499,
0.0082149608,
0.6911568642,
-0.0789335594,
-0.1708507538,
-0.2380906641,
0.052727446,
-0.1506361067,
-0.3444379568,
0.8477908373,
-0.7427337766,
-0.7043934464,
-0.3630305529,
-0.8136247396,
-0.285360992,
0.4420495033,
-0.0080144843,
0.3681779802,
-0.1515419185,
0.0687167048,
1.0627564192,
-0.2159902304,
0.2999221087,
0.7134268284,
-0.1172074005,
-0.501584053,
0.7418273687,
0.0027746833,
0.4461005032,
0.148530215,
0.1785840243,
-0.5862012506,
-0.7252061367,
-0.4179568887,
0.4016740918,
-1.0011429787,
-0.3155558705,
-0.4033823311,
-0.4139906764,
-0.6927591562,
-0.1350268871,
-0.2389522791,
-0.0443373062,
-0.2145202011,
-0.0895449147,
0.3120643497,
0.7349592447,
-0.0647080168,
0.3389240801,
-0.9108896255,
-0.0786556527,
0.2007618994,
0.4855863154,
-0.3817451298,
-0.6763144135,
-0.2682552338,
-0.2407874763,
-0.3888070881,
-0.7347060442,
0.1840242893,
0.097045593,
0.7692942619,
0.549978137,
0.1648600399,
0.5441309214,
-0.7068061829,
0.520893693,
0.2250216901,
-0.7129820585,
0.5942690969,
-0.5537391901,
0.0194520373,
0.7062352896,
0.3217724264,
-0.3757130504,
-0.3851204813,
-0.2995251715,
-0.8827391863,
0.5785528421,
-0.0493767522,
0.0421249606,
0.2212822437,
0.4473104775,
-0.0056556882,
0.2360485196,
-0.7310934067,
0.091252543,
0.0796769857,
-0.7197082043,
0.1164589152,
-0.2126883119,
-0.6219783425,
0.0866838545,
0.9111458063,
-0.2945970595,
-0.3603364527,
-0.2172861099,
-0.0192742366,
-0.2808108926,
0.3636056781,
0.5224364996,
0.7115163803,
-0.4012961686,
0.1519593447,
-0.1206037179,
-0.3109458089,
0.2842682898,
0.270355612,
-0.3480172157,
-0.26892066,
0.3072327077,
0.4338203669,
0.2239697725,
-0.5027889609,
0.3589328229,
-0.1464754194,
-0.1167796627,
-0.003632576,
0.230774641,
0.1941818297,
0.1378211528,
0.0369878262,
-0.1272847503,
-0.1008269042,
-0.3794226646,
0.384416312,
0.6070259809,
-0.4594994485,
-0.0649130046,
0.7371020913,
0.4015164673,
-0.2661512494,
0.2783454061,
-0.017093813,
-0.1585132033,
0.307189852,
0.412764281,
0.8058666587,
-0.2082380801,
-0.1195674464,
0.478800863,
0.5111113787,
-0.5325487256,
0.2498614341,
0.3666560054,
-0.7126716375,
-0.438413769,
-0.8363164663,
-0.3515742421,
0.0460849442,
-0.8604338765,
0.4743133783,
-0.6495046616,
-0.1318534464,
-0.2862448692,
-0.1739650369,
-0.4334573448,
0.0209877808,
0.3687623143,
0.9339597821,
-1.0133774281,
1.0523166656,
0.5644714832,
-0.4284361005,
-1.1493440866,
0.0171678923,
0.2306523919,
-0.711620748,
0.4246253073,
0.0615827441,
-0.217902422,
-0.0695495754,
-0.5225275159,
-1.1819261312,
1.1984359026,
0.529899478,
-0.9001002908,
-0.2024632543,
-0.0107790744,
0.4082134962,
-0.4034442902,
-0.1429574788,
0.8084774613,
0.3809859157,
0.2182962,
-0.9922801852,
0.2280673534,
0.0797785521,
0.0489173047,
0.3042153418,
-0.349524796,
0.5628566146,
-0.0853632614,
-0.2105598599,
0.1424322277,
0.3229506016,
0.4057891071,
-0.0225288682,
0.2621817589,
0.6584858894,
0.8699554205,
-0.196582973,
0.890517652,
-0.5194805264,
0.2374775857,
1.3104068041,
-0.5953332782,
0.8560444117,
0.6288737059,
0.208513394,
0.1993415803,
0.7775636911,
0.2904230952,
0.8686653376,
0.0065079792,
-0.13991642,
-0.2583174706,
-0.4133238494,
-0.2209002972,
-0.0459422246,
0.2262814492,
-0.4385518134,
-0.2463049442,
-0.3726612329,
0.1512401998,
0.1390868723,
-0.2816387415,
0.9145724177,
0.0247070007,
-0.811630249,
0.4100179374,
-0.1649720222,
0.550365746,
-0.7719436288,
0.0487452075,
-0.2079329044,
0.3301467001,
-0.3200557828,
-1.0384037495,
0.1960876733,
0.1680330783,
-0.1292055398,
-0.3288544714,
0.4712871909,
-0.641037941,
-0.5564546585,
0.3491788507,
0.1539064646,
-0.0645784065,
0.5164391994,
-0.5587541461,
0.2315166891,
-0.159745574,
-0.0305720884,
0.5472357273,
0.2957677245,
-0.163694635,
0.5010743141,
0.5125073195,
0.0510439351,
0.0632911921,
0.221579805,
0.9162968993,
-0.3468506038,
-0.2321425229,
-0.8129746914,
0.6321513057,
-0.0305937752,
-0.0300996955,
0.472164005,
0.4940857887,
0.7398447394,
0.370596081,
0.8658789396,
0.1609752029,
0.3413053751,
-0.7403051257,
0.576307416,
-0.5292598605,
0.4315439761,
-0.2773049772,
-0.9311224222,
-0.4150093198,
0.5670073032,
-0.1788322926,
-0.2008840591,
0.6073967814,
1.1799440384,
-0.0613720305,
-0.383036077,
0.1699322015,
-0.1135417819,
0.6679766774,
0.4061883092,
0.6035847068,
-0.4443736672,
0.8162700534,
-0.1239735782,
-0.2180933505,
-0.0980588943,
-1.3240857124,
-0.6831963062,
-0.2590231597,
-0.4285767674,
-0.584171474,
0.1897193938,
0.9767841697,
0.8597416282,
-0.815597713,
-0.3333194256,
-0.0119027412,
0.0602003634,
-0.0917211771,
-0.1361166537,
0.2296160907,
-0.3455429077,
-0.5829264522,
0.3095403314,
0.2743880153,
0.2456289828,
-0.3679740727,
-0.4448906779,
-0.1796903908,
0.1290368289,
0.1430792063,
0.1454865038,
-0.8746399879,
-0.5023534894,
-0.1213043183,
-0.6182029247,
-0.0850048885,
0.5140351057,
-0.1905262172,
0.426006645,
0.484556973,
0.8240958452,
0.0391442068,
0.2452659607,
0.9412897229,
-0.811142385,
-0.0603937283,
0.1053878441,
0.5102992654,
0.5673081875,
-0.503333509,
0.4924382269,
-0.3723763227,
-0.7501828671,
-0.8198037744,
0.477570504,
-1.1389069557,
0.1097355038,
1.3480049372,
-0.2233404517,
-0.1965622455,
-0.0969407335,
-0.2904424369,
0.3869003654,
-0.4532930553,
0.5400902033,
0.8447458148,
-0.0091551151,
-0.2591379285,
-0.6067879796,
0.6479948759,
0.2469376177,
-0.7472778559,
0.3429282308,
0.5124444962,
0.484765172,
0.1254738271,
0.275077194,
-0.23523058,
0.1224109307,
-0.5411007404,
0.1674553603,
0.1261452287,
-0.3347974718,
-0.5597186685,
-0.0100349095,
0.6497867703,
-0.0218990799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11834v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11834v1
|
Towards Understanding the Relationship between In-context Learning and Compositional Generalization
| 2024-03-18T14:45:52 | 2024-03-18T14:45:52 |
Sungjun Han, Sebastian Padó
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
According to the principle of compositional generalization, the meaning of a
complex expression can be understood as a function of the meaning of its parts
and of how they are combined. This principle is crucial for human language
processing and also, arguably, for NLP models in the face of
out-of-distribution data. However, many neural network models, including
Transformers, have been shown to struggle with compositional generalization. In
this paper, we hypothesize that forcing models to in-context learn can provide
an inductive bias to promote compositional generalization. To test this
hypothesis, we train a causal Transformer in a setting that renders ordinary
learning very difficult: we present it with different orderings of the training
instance and shuffle instance labels. This corresponds to training the model on
all possible few-shot learning problems attainable from the dataset. The model
can solve the task, however, by utilizing earlier examples to generalize to
later ones (i.e. in-context learning). In evaluations on the datasets, SCAN,
COGS, and GeoQuery, models trained in this manner indeed show improved
compositional generalization. This indicates the usefulness of in-context
learning problems as an inductive bias for generalization.
|
[
-0.2551292479,
-0.4416542649,
0.4970011711,
0.4278409183,
-0.2113942057,
-0.4339850545,
-0.4876030982,
-0.2265767753,
-0.3661210239,
0.3487165272,
-0.5632141829,
-0.3625286222,
-0.5531769991,
0.1096510589,
-0.495716095,
1.0857721567,
0.0588937514,
0.208679527,
-0.4722254574,
-0.1545599401,
-0.8280589581,
-0.3012370169,
-0.4936629534,
-0.7961094975,
0.4818277359,
0.1747761071,
0.4767789543,
0.3589362502,
0.4320119917,
0.2406225652,
0.0373762846,
0.0019722977,
-0.4521414936,
0.2825576067,
-0.4158493578,
-0.8685023189,
0.470304966,
0.0617259443,
0.4143698812,
1.0885051489,
0.0329884738,
-0.0319056474,
0.2744129896,
0.4513987601,
-0.6491924524,
0.3199313283,
-0.8359413743,
0.3003148735,
0.2506542504,
-0.1953128129,
-0.7121221423,
-0.0731370226,
0.6167554259,
-0.6228916645,
0.5365901589,
-0.1692014784,
0.7063011527,
0.5681545734,
-0.5967998505,
-0.2081795186,
-0.9589750767,
0.6144152284,
-0.4003077149,
0.1351299286,
0.268918097,
0.4514840543,
-0.068254523,
-0.7363581061,
-0.5810830593,
0.0121665522,
-0.6344592571,
0.2758165598,
0.0304611754,
-0.0688310117,
0.3853230476,
0.1763247102,
-0.2642935216,
0.0866698176,
-0.3528279662,
0.3101945221,
0.3266925514,
0.2391049415,
0.3576438427,
-0.0606423877,
-0.3774311244,
-0.2119541168,
-0.785161376,
0.210543558,
0.1000059992,
0.4470481873,
-0.3601967692,
0.3212374151,
-0.1324897259,
0.7436342239,
0.2277720571,
0.1053270921,
0.0346872695,
0.0096124448,
-0.3808041513,
0.0191903785,
0.6444054842,
0.0617582276,
0.0865832567,
-0.6123052239,
-0.0613827221,
0.1104303971,
0.4986046255,
-0.7393128276,
-0.1165521517,
-0.1018934101,
-0.2507870793,
-0.1288664192,
0.4517007172,
-0.3573630154,
-0.0435421132,
-0.5986726284,
0.6582645774,
-0.2415148914,
0.2256176472,
0.1510251462,
-0.1641806811,
0.5160737634,
0.0293045174,
-1.2942076921,
0.0937578008,
0.7071169019,
0.6604216099,
-0.2072101235,
-0.4558340311,
-0.10957513,
0.2691406906,
-0.1849575937,
0.7116235495,
-0.5606231093,
-0.3152527213,
0.0994140059,
0.1454736888,
-0.5555587411,
-0.7771422863,
0.5307120681,
-0.495736748,
0.3454610705,
-0.3642499745,
-0.5189440846,
-0.2033022493,
-0.0375932716,
-0.5444574952,
0.7981603742,
0.3522583544,
-0.7385758758,
0.7516870499,
-0.5343213081,
-0.7347829342,
-0.1024474129,
-0.3094224036,
-0.4798687696,
0.4065494537,
0.2534389198,
0.5870774388,
-0.2444238812,
0.5043244958,
-0.2215216011,
-0.5362074375,
0.2839057148,
-0.2415784001,
0.77121979,
-0.0614098161,
-0.8038918376,
-0.0570737682,
-0.3873328865,
-0.4790948629,
0.1712508947,
-0.5328398943,
-0.4545515776,
0.1522284597,
-0.2227368504,
0.3595086634,
-0.3615936339,
-0.3239184022,
0.1501435935,
-0.6253547668,
0.3125346601,
0.626124382,
0.0859288126,
1.141166091,
-0.2178164721,
0.1799758375,
0.0908061191,
0.1058489978,
-0.2645936012,
-0.3485841453,
-0.8862342238,
0.1416249275,
0.115805082,
0.2683605254,
-0.62148422,
0.5455439687,
-0.3954545557,
-0.204651922,
-0.1114511415,
0.1027885154,
0.1751216501,
1.0050086975,
0.5568881035,
0.0603738874,
-0.3668945134,
-0.8449311852,
-0.1927712411,
0.3743106127,
-0.366647929,
0.3519443572,
0.5048964024,
-0.3757628202,
1.2328708172,
-0.4606060088,
-0.426761359,
-0.1388421357,
0.0124401907,
0.1117585823,
0.5449428558,
0.5257875323,
-0.8232124448,
-0.624473989,
0.1342950165,
-1.1042413712,
-0.0595156029,
-0.2560146749,
-0.3373873532,
-0.1325181276,
0.6137418747,
-0.4860108495,
0.3858219385,
0.2567333281,
-0.1415902972,
0.1038375571,
-0.004117657,
-0.4955953062,
-0.9233739972,
-0.2141674459,
0.2029684335,
0.1493686438,
-0.5695038438,
0.1511811912,
0.0854001418,
-0.0185832046,
-0.4148773253,
0.2167535871,
-0.0203667022,
0.1998649389,
-0.2716234326,
-0.2049828023,
0.0491157472,
0.5388092399,
0.0559219159,
0.5309511423,
0.5650262833,
-0.83888942,
-0.0123376856,
0.3358112574,
-0.420434922,
0.5252506733,
-0.7729746699,
-0.1243129969,
-0.5107365251,
0.6305466294,
-0.8679540157,
-0.2388124466,
0.0886528045,
0.0289391223,
0.3115696609,
-0.0198969971,
-0.3313057721,
0.0132739395,
0.2137252688,
0.4370279312,
0.2363409102,
-0.9704230428,
0.7599159479,
0.0052202432,
0.5919329524,
-0.5078185201,
-0.8566131592,
-0.4327413142,
-0.5719093084,
-0.5199296474,
0.6580596566,
0.1539158523,
-0.0957999378,
-0.0926870108,
-0.0832524523,
0.1249224469,
0.1275787652,
0.290525943,
0.0292522665,
-0.0875361934,
0.3844850361,
0.2082079947,
-0.0956575423,
0.4045032263,
-0.3531947434,
0.481861949,
0.1069858596,
-0.2976585627,
-0.198930636,
0.2670780122,
0.2016830444,
0.0209951326,
0.793541491,
0.5609645844,
-0.1427632272,
-0.6845141649,
-0.1761329025,
-0.5333420038,
-0.4597882926,
0.0435724556,
-0.207747817,
-0.8190298676,
0.4692531526,
-0.1972219944,
-0.22436212,
0.5429289341,
0.3422802091,
-0.2326754481,
0.8341526389,
0.6300670505,
-0.1220058948,
0.5651381016,
-0.7607126832,
0.1935512722,
-0.8992848992,
-0.4719643295,
-0.3859483898,
-0.631939292,
-0.6946303248,
-0.0034212861,
0.526597023,
-0.2479613721,
-0.4652345181,
0.3334203362,
-0.4787714779,
0.7180168629,
0.644123137,
0.5250678062,
-0.0275337175,
0.0929164663,
-0.3026477695,
0.0176390372,
-0.7349713445,
-0.0474490412,
1.1080101728,
0.0239361711,
0.7697426677,
0.1035134345,
0.5140862465,
-0.0892375037,
0.4474616647,
-0.9050594568,
0.0263986755,
-0.1055987254,
-0.6184684038,
-0.1955073476,
-0.2129708827,
-1.0554516315,
0.5783768892,
-0.2620167434,
-0.5023198724,
0.5212936401,
-0.1468150169,
-0.3204589188,
0.076975584,
-0.7074780464,
0.8546773791,
0.0607117116,
-0.3650126457,
0.079834722,
-0.9500934482,
0.3973749578,
0.0765137374,
-0.1492428631,
0.2410495281,
0.3616343439,
0.3023570776,
-0.3743969798,
1.1886742115,
-0.14664267,
0.1137431711,
0.2838636339,
-0.0051096836,
0.4776818752,
0.0477123447,
0.2747488618,
-0.1562854052,
-0.5722205639,
-0.2885727286,
-1.0071451664,
0.4381807745,
-0.9543153048,
-0.5309101939,
-0.1071986929,
-0.4939919114,
-0.163409546,
-0.286450088,
0.8435968757,
0.4050498903,
-0.0550794415,
0.5594118237,
0.8872529864,
0.0728443488,
0.6408662796,
0.1222571358,
0.1538996696,
0.1343007982,
0.5847852826,
-0.0334518142,
0.3342691958,
0.6457631588,
0.5753688812,
-0.1586024314,
-0.2135159075,
-0.1440557241,
0.10324011,
-1.0232335329,
-0.2374556065,
-0.7163356543,
-0.0702962279,
0.0216958951,
-0.444386214,
0.04677568,
-0.1271226108,
-0.6368944645,
-0.2784947157,
-0.2656595409,
0.6757622361,
0.3017769456,
0.8336760998,
-0.2792876661,
0.0637809187,
0.7723583579,
0.0710595697,
0.2402366996,
-0.8143449426,
-0.3945376873,
-0.1973811239,
-0.5841509104,
-0.6713270545,
0.1845772713,
0.3478030562,
0.5617009997,
0.6611867547,
-0.1425407529,
0.4372472465,
-0.373940438,
0.5744687915,
-0.1330096722,
-0.8880474567,
0.4489035606,
-0.4595798552,
0.4634497166,
0.694540143,
0.5546147227,
-0.5776327252,
-0.2260694206,
-0.5377141237,
-0.8463928699,
0.541819334,
-0.0486780927,
0.6406534314,
-0.2128122002,
0.4495917261,
0.2390542328,
0.0434048921,
-1.1889635324,
-0.3100605905,
-0.3149813414,
-0.002177377,
-0.0582229532,
-0.0889272988,
-0.221065715,
-0.5343692899,
0.5393175483,
-0.2807811797,
0.23634471,
0.1303862631,
-0.4298905134,
0.0388677754,
0.1081355289,
0.6356920004,
0.5814126134,
-0.0446709134,
0.2479602545,
0.1626297832,
0.0024401015,
0.2310259789,
-0.1567569524,
-0.548147738,
-0.1801957786,
0.4364527762,
0.8703609705,
0.6188465953,
-0.1514011174,
0.8085172176,
0.0550123602,
-0.0892387703,
-0.2004203945,
0.076015912,
0.0006941587,
0.1738007367,
0.5791863799,
0.2534704208,
0.2411525697,
-0.4505229592,
0.1136428192,
0.4282803535,
-0.5735839605,
-0.388864547,
0.7382360697,
-0.0293401722,
0.0966068134,
0.6967005134,
-0.1328389645,
-0.4833898842,
0.5551049113,
1.0897023678,
0.9978986979,
-0.0783167928,
0.2305435389,
0.474848181,
0.2796592712,
-0.2626190186,
-0.41408059,
-0.293977648,
-0.9892534614,
-0.4584998786,
-0.4763919413,
-0.1963031292,
-0.0891030431,
-0.5309467316,
0.2309244573,
-0.3338816166,
0.1048399061,
-0.1387272179,
-0.7518985271,
-0.9318771958,
0.373750329,
-0.0586610325,
0.3630697727,
-1.2152838707,
0.5975041986,
0.3612218499,
-0.5229351521,
-0.9694666862,
0.1144891605,
-0.4275565445,
-0.4557597935,
1.0027658939,
0.4461430013,
0.1666582376,
-0.1734585017,
-0.8180825114,
-0.685585022,
1.1187626123,
0.4830819368,
-0.0926198363,
-0.1957269311,
0.2334081978,
0.581843853,
-0.7598953247,
0.1909998059,
0.6480035782,
0.3337520659,
0.0924866721,
-0.4304662049,
0.046379827,
0.0491920821,
0.0822348744,
-0.0236881897,
-0.5286628604,
1.0166099072,
0.0661177486,
-0.3577188849,
-0.5019707084,
0.618378222,
-0.2397506088,
0.2778785229,
0.2497086674,
0.7204985023,
0.3485980928,
-0.3139579296,
1.1856323481,
0.1823376268,
0.4051389992,
1.3017715216,
0.096267283,
0.4004766345,
0.519161582,
-0.1727710962,
0.8904947042,
0.4087924659,
0.0033630163,
0.8888540864,
0.2398756891,
-0.474407196,
-0.0570078567,
-0.0100846598,
-0.1809702069,
0.7826243043,
0.2923764288,
-0.7173771262,
-0.4451577961,
0.2687373459,
-0.0221436415,
0.1632048786,
-0.1987488568,
0.8874557614,
-0.0063662617,
-0.7005082369,
0.3018914461,
-0.1595184952,
0.7946754098,
-0.4826214015,
0.1773560196,
-0.2124457359,
0.0489283055,
-0.342682302,
-0.2168888152,
0.4814761579,
-0.7157714963,
-0.3082439005,
0.0261638258,
0.4646938741,
-0.400446564,
-0.3600659072,
0.3350145519,
0.3661268055,
-0.3740294278,
-0.3844639361,
-0.2450510412,
-0.406324029,
-0.1643265784,
-0.1701841205,
0.3737981617,
0.283218652,
-0.0595858544,
0.4553282857,
0.4858842194,
-0.4088546038,
0.2642302513,
0.2279997468,
0.8726165295,
-0.308073163,
-0.4237762392,
-1.0380753279,
0.5864656568,
0.1566428095,
-0.1855390519,
0.626978457,
0.4570458829,
1.2933027744,
-0.3558791876,
0.7778699398,
0.2072056979,
-0.0305644199,
-0.4474360347,
0.4628458619,
-0.2093883753,
0.0174719132,
-0.059064921,
-1.1808613539,
-0.6413229108,
0.6927057505,
-0.5274276733,
-0.0521385968,
0.920953095,
0.5748866796,
-0.3001978397,
0.0504990257,
0.2783150971,
-0.3480765522,
0.3276501596,
0.3935765922,
0.8182365298,
-0.5249463916,
0.2847893238,
-0.6465008259,
0.0746319965,
-0.0823941156,
-0.6963040829,
-1.0532644987,
-0.7375826836,
0.1083233356,
-0.3062493205,
-0.5363926291,
0.9683851004,
0.6807205081,
-0.6334695816,
-0.2768316567,
-0.4285158515,
0.2133632302,
-0.2489866018,
-0.301186353,
0.3206250966,
-0.7992224693,
-0.848305881,
0.4410486817,
0.1585028768,
0.1358224601,
-0.149678424,
0.1688261777,
-0.0178317036,
-0.0554539301,
0.7608752847,
0.1061014459,
-0.5282350779,
-0.2956756055,
-0.1762277931,
-0.065540053,
0.3002137244,
1.3196593523,
-0.8451650143,
0.5242317319,
0.3177300692,
0.825758636,
0.7748639584,
-0.0205169022,
0.4302852154,
-1.0298446417,
0.3014798164,
0.0176210161,
0.4550304115,
0.4119865,
-0.4890942872,
0.5839298368,
0.3509446979,
-0.5658552647,
-0.3217154741,
0.4237455726,
-0.6942489147,
-0.2472108006,
1.0199811459,
0.1227054,
-0.2612721026,
-0.0527659208,
0.1094293594,
0.3036988974,
-0.1485397667,
0.9740638137,
0.5145888329,
-0.1236773804,
0.1744565517,
-0.3038933575,
0.454916805,
0.3618211746,
-0.646826148,
-0.3664116859,
0.2322728187,
0.2882572412,
0.0458711535,
0.0806476399,
0.2233912349,
0.0806564391,
-0.251303345,
-0.0989872441,
0.1750894338,
-0.376347214,
-0.5463033319,
0.3089467585,
-0.3491542637,
0.0238825027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11833v1
|
SSCAE -- Semantic, Syntactic, and Context-aware natural language Adversarial Examples generator
| 2024-03-18T14:45:20 | 2024-03-18T14:45:20 |
Javad Rafiei Asl, Mohammad H. Rafiei, Manar Alohaly, Daniel Takabi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Machine learning models are vulnerable to maliciously crafted Adversarial
Examples (AEs). Training a machine learning model with AEs improves its
robustness and stability against adversarial attacks. It is essential to
develop models that produce high-quality AEs. Developing such models has been
much slower in natural language processing (NLP) than in areas such as computer
vision. This paper introduces a practical and efficient adversarial attack
model called SSCAE for \textbf{S}emantic, \textbf{S}yntactic, and
\textbf{C}ontext-aware natural language \textbf{AE}s generator. SSCAE
identifies important words and uses a masked language model to generate an
early set of substitutions. Next, two well-known language models are employed
to evaluate the initial set in terms of semantic and syntactic characteristics.
We introduce (1) a dynamic threshold to capture more efficient perturbations
and (2) a local greedy search to generate high-quality AEs. As a black-box
method, SSCAE generates humanly imperceptible and context-aware AEs that
preserve semantic consistency and the source language's syntactical and
grammatical requirements. The effectiveness and superiority of the proposed
SSCAE model are illustrated with fifteen comparative experiments and extensive
sensitivity analysis for parameter optimization. SSCAE outperforms the existing
models in all experiments while maintaining a higher semantic consistency with
a lower query number and a comparable perturbation rate.
|
[
-0.355458349,
-1.2932305336,
0.3712262511,
0.0537613742,
-0.2728036046,
-0.1463178545,
-0.0729539394,
-0.3331026137,
0.3285117745,
0.6501104832,
-0.3774306178,
-0.4566856027,
-0.6975823641,
0.087882705,
-0.6771594286,
0.9480484724,
0.0878336728,
0.0847951397,
0.2749095559,
0.049494639,
-0.2339511514,
-0.6001467705,
-0.9921400547,
0.2500576973,
0.2968922853,
-0.2041170448,
0.9033921361,
0.6104470491,
0.3747385442,
0.3345588446,
-0.187165767,
-0.0454155356,
-0.3383110464,
0.4132522941,
-0.2295646518,
-0.4806019068,
-0.0923896655,
-0.0353269055,
0.4530061185,
0.5180442333,
-0.0808873698,
-0.1253336668,
-0.0314731635,
0.2918204367,
-0.8345854282,
-0.1073877141,
-1.12940979,
0.0484068319,
-0.2168590575,
-0.1416867077,
-0.5489269495,
-0.1966415197,
0.1358452588,
-0.4978580177,
0.2027000934,
-0.1970558017,
0.8649789095,
0.4225130677,
-0.2461269647,
-0.4248273373,
-0.3254337013,
0.6282088161,
-0.7456315756,
0.3669101894,
0.186788708,
0.509326756,
-0.6220864654,
-0.9017987251,
-0.5287622213,
-0.6210795045,
0.3418823779,
0.1691685617,
-0.375564307,
0.0596087053,
0.018514147,
0.1248988733,
-0.3919937909,
0.1015510708,
-0.0736156181,
-0.2764817774,
0.4961217344,
0.0532096103,
0.6733776331,
-0.1953684986,
-0.5816676617,
0.0248967055,
-0.7926599979,
-0.1334204227,
0.4912605286,
0.3306823671,
0.0970896855,
0.5143360496,
-0.138016969,
0.6486569643,
0.0092206793,
0.1168293208,
-0.5013515353,
-0.3792083263,
-0.3274047375,
-0.0317041278,
0.562718749,
-0.0548398755,
-0.0015889853,
-0.5252372026,
-0.0056309742,
0.7147903442,
0.720315218,
-0.7075304985,
-0.0274606347,
0.0108193085,
-0.1414508224,
-0.6430501938,
-0.1512613446,
-0.5404288769,
-0.2487201542,
-0.3022948802,
0.3856558502,
-0.5436771512,
0.1611785442,
0.1388111562,
-0.2526939511,
0.0520406812,
0.1375462115,
-0.7160021663,
0.4998846352,
0.4519357979,
0.5007534027,
-0.0692160204,
-0.2656100988,
-0.5718424916,
0.0885683522,
-0.3303262293,
0.5979442596,
-0.4562835097,
-0.2297569364,
-0.1093727052,
-0.0813919157,
-0.1129756272,
-0.0554638766,
0.6661822796,
-0.7809224725,
0.1340739131,
-0.0854780376,
-0.5441167951,
-0.1943634897,
0.1933027506,
-0.6945599914,
0.8338048458,
-0.1941361725,
-0.8159560561,
0.2750139236,
-0.7405818701,
-0.3200007975,
0.2168395072,
-0.2064672559,
-0.2784334719,
0.1735139787,
0.1474531293,
0.3792799413,
-0.1677865535,
0.1981884688,
-0.3078799546,
-0.2201041877,
0.1034658104,
-0.7582309842,
1.0937255621,
0.3225187361,
-0.4281268418,
-0.0495769382,
-0.6092083454,
-0.0513835065,
0.6297627091,
-0.2101660073,
-0.5051811337,
0.0917240307,
-0.0179402176,
0.0788624883,
0.3050855696,
-0.6199376583,
-0.066770263,
-0.8862117529,
0.4994952083,
0.5612776279,
0.2480321974,
0.3151685894,
0.0760914311,
0.6065195799,
-0.2545979917,
0.2273581624,
0.0223978311,
-0.3632594049,
-0.5152016282,
-0.257671088,
0.5237716436,
0.539711535,
-1.0328894854,
0.5877563357,
0.1325826943,
-0.6337170005,
-0.5507304668,
0.0876243636,
0.4207192957,
0.2087026983,
0.2445252389,
-0.2407384515,
-0.4062687755,
-0.9253785014,
-0.4947991967,
0.1535917521,
0.0834909901,
-0.0577126518,
0.4852764904,
-0.16736269,
0.7212358713,
-0.358802259,
0.1092784852,
-0.3095026016,
-0.1089783162,
-0.415789485,
0.228439644,
0.6530485153,
-0.7908557653,
-0.3442729712,
-0.3108081818,
-0.7260565758,
-0.0483753122,
-0.0025056023,
-0.4320279956,
0.255112052,
0.4238950908,
-0.5827693939,
0.6188412309,
0.5247840285,
-0.3142598569,
0.407835871,
-0.13656497,
0.0029044559,
-1.2805361748,
-0.0453237183,
0.0396637768,
-0.0739558935,
-0.9377707839,
0.8901894689,
0.011130631,
-0.516838491,
-0.7362425327,
0.4361384213,
-0.241046384,
0.0582313426,
-0.339641422,
0.4211246669,
0.0455019586,
0.5022678971,
0.0510216281,
0.5640765429,
0.4904101789,
-0.622766912,
0.293962419,
0.0974318162,
-0.142596066,
0.4002175033,
-0.6951159835,
0.1487416923,
-0.1063058898,
0.2025393397,
-0.497777164,
0.0743535906,
0.165939033,
-0.4471281171,
0.384611249,
-0.0183509532,
-0.3667528629,
-0.031611599,
-0.3487160504,
0.2410664111,
0.0453782491,
-0.6381790042,
0.5833136439,
0.512599051,
-0.2031243294,
-0.6437370181,
-0.6466122866,
0.592132926,
-0.2321304083,
-0.7110806108,
0.5113778114,
-0.0196981523,
-0.1205387637,
-0.0201259833,
0.0325070322,
-0.0051518613,
0.5696625113,
-0.0774051622,
0.2646887302,
-0.1060197204,
-0.2233845592,
0.0214025751,
-0.0185507797,
0.0742042437,
-0.0980109796,
0.6286622882,
-0.1047754958,
-0.3810768723,
-0.4402661026,
0.4613102973,
0.3889020085,
-0.2332753092,
0.8399271369,
0.308599323,
-0.8465248346,
-0.3522591293,
-0.2204302847,
-0.2422035486,
-0.4529410005,
0.5612443686,
-0.4213647842,
-0.4503143132,
0.3614327908,
0.325381428,
0.1633480489,
0.5487611294,
0.3595359921,
0.3049737215,
1.2460206747,
0.2897478044,
-0.1156881973,
0.4478434026,
-0.3083172143,
0.3270923197,
-0.5436241031,
0.1194901615,
-0.6505655646,
0.224084571,
-0.6183154583,
-0.0818607509,
0.3237582743,
0.1090784892,
-0.1927483976,
0.8319053054,
-0.3721629083,
0.4324467778,
0.393751651,
0.0836566836,
-0.1895923018,
0.0594694763,
-0.2739951015,
-0.1118547991,
-0.8189194798,
-0.8482856154,
0.9619484544,
0.4232599437,
0.5227005482,
0.2640586495,
0.6642068624,
0.5391772985,
0.0303698815,
-0.5724211335,
0.613112092,
-0.4522540271,
-0.5737574697,
-0.2129524648,
-0.2207926512,
-1.0318850279,
0.3078308702,
-0.414496094,
-0.6737723351,
-0.1444390267,
0.0203273818,
-0.1719053239,
0.2931314111,
-0.6766229868,
0.9487236142,
-0.1913870722,
-0.3550704718,
-0.1801134795,
-0.4612208903,
0.339992702,
-0.0448011532,
-0.1538097262,
0.3174025118,
0.045195803,
0.5615630746,
-0.3709670305,
0.8907706738,
-0.17296049,
-0.0915385187,
0.3781547546,
0.3752670884,
0.8669546247,
-0.0655474588,
-0.1012585536,
0.1890059859,
-0.1115626246,
-0.5523434877,
-0.6649506688,
0.7840855122,
-0.4340108335,
-0.6712374687,
-0.4064392745,
-0.1988779902,
0.0185733382,
0.0822469071,
0.2760458887,
0.6644757986,
-0.5883828998,
0.0981946513,
0.4366677403,
-0.3242761493,
0.2628394067,
0.3891758323,
0.3199364245,
-0.1942189485,
0.8418834805,
0.0555393547,
0.5041702986,
0.2419987619,
0.0254205763,
-0.3775917292,
-0.6022973657,
-0.6379582882,
-0.0251973867,
-0.7666089535,
-0.2568813562,
-0.6474970579,
-0.4910785258,
-0.4041434824,
-0.5105744004,
-0.2436304688,
-0.5095713139,
-0.129673332,
-0.0527255759,
0.0259027872,
0.5506796837,
0.4219878912,
0.3890087008,
-0.3469850123,
0.3540120721,
0.2917547226,
-0.0245235767,
-0.1067329124,
-0.4275401831,
-0.0565747172,
0.2975091934,
-0.5112773776,
-1.2444708347,
0.4530834556,
-0.0439520516,
0.7707736492,
0.3889331222,
0.0878113136,
0.268445313,
-0.3768473268,
0.9875064492,
0.0788312107,
-1.0048090219,
0.7295402288,
-0.2038829476,
0.1447625607,
0.5518131852,
0.1225525364,
-0.2827115655,
-0.968347311,
-1.0009313822,
-0.7147291899,
0.4193380773,
0.4966738522,
-0.0131430672,
-0.386292845,
0.3029742539,
-0.1530768871,
0.0122629227,
-0.6826432943,
-0.1052471176,
-0.3173723817,
-0.3191218078,
0.2561491132,
0.0431876332,
0.0817218274,
0.4153219461,
1.0064958334,
-0.0849667415,
0.1084607095,
-0.0062585273,
-0.2527112365,
0.1770684272,
0.3821290135,
0.4128417969,
0.0635674745,
0.0301534329,
0.2258081138,
0.5190467238,
-0.4461396337,
-0.0508485548,
0.1741491556,
-0.576511085,
-0.1269032359,
0.1127083376,
0.6314449906,
0.3358225822,
-0.5539764762,
0.6073288918,
-0.2290714979,
0.1392840296,
-0.4918070138,
0.2012171596,
-0.0010132483,
-0.0461351462,
-0.0193669572,
0.2875775099,
0.3418569267,
-0.4933159351,
0.1100711748,
0.8545739055,
-0.2570225,
-0.1078036577,
0.8385913372,
0.1193280593,
-0.3698906898,
0.1371932775,
-0.3017787933,
-0.7591730952,
0.8435047865,
0.7443783283,
0.8391922712,
-0.3084776402,
0.1491288096,
0.097325258,
0.464487046,
0.1621672213,
0.059964668,
-0.0243031606,
-0.7030436993,
-0.106892474,
-0.7234662771,
-0.2358221561,
0.1691934764,
-0.5716440678,
0.4486207664,
-0.6617474556,
-0.2125463188,
0.4211467505,
0.1165442318,
-0.6798117161,
0.4019062817,
-0.072462298,
0.9679448605,
-0.8474817872,
0.6594104767,
0.5115481019,
-0.5486928225,
-0.4840041995,
-0.0547206625,
-0.0815650821,
-0.8054409623,
0.4928692281,
-0.0329171158,
-0.3814136386,
-0.2283530384,
-0.4074171484,
-0.7338250279,
0.8151733279,
0.4363439679,
-0.1094999388,
0.0127119301,
-0.1068393439,
0.6229881644,
-0.5457205176,
0.1468685269,
0.5451341867,
0.2347100824,
-0.2683387697,
-0.3770827651,
0.2568606138,
-0.3206205666,
0.248563379,
0.2963242531,
-0.5068609118,
0.33602947,
0.0381906144,
-0.515324235,
0.1649397463,
0.6630297303,
0.2473208904,
0.148837328,
0.5294632316,
0.6340560913,
0.4322692156,
0.0932812095,
1.2008517981,
-0.4369649589,
-0.2700152099,
0.8897132277,
-0.3271028399,
0.9239657521,
0.156537503,
0.000060137,
0.2960396409,
0.3522063494,
-0.0019666397,
0.454288274,
0.2478810549,
-0.4456008077,
-0.0790618286,
-0.1066651121,
-0.2327451408,
0.7381147742,
0.3714731336,
-0.5284741521,
-0.2225575894,
-0.0181499012,
0.1884721071,
0.4737913311,
-0.0898641422,
0.7418013215,
-0.0880069584,
-0.5326641798,
0.523064971,
0.4905643165,
0.4310102761,
-0.8755805492,
0.1305744499,
0.0551612824,
-0.0419665687,
0.1369468719,
-0.1251391619,
0.3505033553,
0.2052500248,
-0.0114007732,
0.2286655158,
0.781699419,
-0.3477112651,
-0.5725597739,
0.3747504652,
0.0364619903,
0.1439724714,
0.02998087,
-0.7726193666,
-0.2415074259,
-0.0474904366,
-0.2108615488,
0.4254540205,
0.0941012129,
-0.051969219,
0.5401182175,
0.7240105271,
0.4658394754,
0.1305591315,
0.1647865772,
0.6210384965,
-0.6021521688,
-0.8338432312,
-0.5823165178,
0.1232394129,
-0.3657591641,
-0.2093458623,
0.874268949,
0.4477930665,
0.5802569985,
0.0961106569,
0.8680419922,
0.2380811274,
0.2372003943,
-0.7295946479,
0.72694695,
-0.3908280134,
0.3483707011,
-0.1736589968,
-0.75615412,
-0.1774751395,
0.4638074934,
-0.1087944657,
-0.0086079054,
0.7532252073,
0.9959721565,
0.0211834069,
0.4486184716,
0.309599787,
0.1611594856,
0.2925584614,
0.5168298483,
0.6173014641,
-0.7363240719,
0.4593786299,
-0.1215936914,
-0.2967762053,
-0.030982662,
-0.8064636588,
-0.8344829082,
-0.3989093602,
-0.3368332684,
-0.4981206954,
0.3889351785,
0.9182927608,
0.5556514859,
-0.819503665,
0.3065798879,
-0.2886406183,
-0.0761978105,
-0.2225119472,
-0.2373570353,
0.4641305506,
-0.4265567362,
-0.6916087866,
0.8148685694,
0.1033281311,
0.2471332848,
-0.5143637657,
0.0186935328,
-0.1566692889,
0.6314263344,
0.4681144357,
0.2659959793,
-0.9047185183,
-0.1831524819,
-0.1387558579,
-0.2442212403,
-0.5818219781,
0.6920869946,
-0.4139935374,
0.4378238916,
0.2466760576,
0.9716117382,
0.2897123396,
-0.1323359162,
0.5271857381,
-0.7382346988,
0.243775025,
0.1887347251,
0.6533817649,
0.2693383098,
-0.6019460559,
0.2668536901,
0.1473861486,
-0.3235702515,
-0.6445573568,
0.4525390565,
-0.8168626428,
-0.686380744,
1.0569679737,
-0.198990494,
-0.3441769779,
-0.2101808637,
-0.2034860998,
0.3757801056,
-0.1946874112,
1.0153477192,
0.5256294608,
0.4448254406,
0.4167484939,
-0.4964822531,
0.4431542456,
0.5499022007,
-0.8626107574,
-0.0843262374,
0.3856852949,
0.1026979387,
0.1214437559,
0.2135837525,
-0.1201663092,
0.3946458399,
0.4364939928,
-0.0198752135,
-0.0631026775,
-0.383503288,
-0.3896218836,
0.5053726435,
-0.0748134926,
-0.1761503369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11810v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11810v1
|
Metaphor Understanding Challenge Dataset for LLMs
| 2024-03-18T14:08:59 | 2024-03-18T14:08:59 |
Xiaoyu Tong, Rochelle Choenni, Martha Lewis, Ekaterina Shutova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Metaphors in natural language are a reflection of fundamental cognitive
processes such as analogical reasoning and categorisation, and are deeply
rooted in everyday communication. Metaphor understanding is therefore an
essential task for large language models (LLMs). We release the Metaphor
Understanding Challenge Dataset (MUNCH), designed to evaluate the metaphor
understanding capabilities of LLMs. The dataset provides over 10k paraphrases
for sentences containing metaphor use, as well as 1.5k instances containing
inapt paraphrases. The inapt paraphrases were carefully selected to serve as
control to determine whether the model indeed performs full metaphor
interpretation or rather resorts to lexical similarity. All apt and inapt
paraphrases were manually annotated. The metaphorical sentences cover natural
metaphor uses across 4 genres (academic, news, fiction, and conversation), and
they exhibit different levels of novelty. Experiments with LLaMA and GPT-3.5
demonstrate that MUNCH presents a challenging task for LLMs. The dataset is
freely accessible at
https://github.com/xiaoyuisrain/metaphor-understanding-challenge.
|
[
0.0017987038,
-0.5299437642,
0.7464824915,
0.2441718876,
-0.5607154965,
-0.0415936075,
0.029990511,
-0.5049160719,
0.1556764394,
0.5640880466,
-0.5933371782,
-0.2904190123,
-0.548841536,
0.3335723877,
-0.4068199992,
1.1912848949,
-0.150601089,
-0.1236313581,
-0.3750609756,
-0.389819622,
-0.6717894673,
-0.5256273746,
-0.3775058389,
-0.3210820854,
0.7527747154,
0.4406023026,
0.6821309328,
0.8779036999,
0.7071859241,
0.2567573488,
-0.1658414304,
-0.0309207328,
-0.5747150183,
0.2076332122,
-0.1193545684,
-0.5478309393,
-0.0236443132,
0.0638635829,
0.6524854302,
0.6816670895,
-0.3967553973,
0.2804159522,
0.1353119463,
0.5778460503,
-0.5835048556,
0.3688127398,
-1.2165369987,
0.0273307394,
-0.2919767499,
-0.1934928149,
-0.1084202603,
-0.1925860941,
0.2138291597,
-0.7413602471,
0.0663604811,
0.4277019799,
0.8018844128,
0.3240637183,
-0.4860758185,
-0.4939773977,
-0.2505884767,
0.6619797945,
-0.4301717877,
0.1212186292,
0.2852735519,
0.4800526798,
-0.2388764024,
-0.8458145261,
-0.7245044112,
-0.2173532844,
-0.1630419791,
-0.0945920721,
-0.3099339008,
-0.1034402251,
0.2287041992,
0.6430370212,
-0.6919528246,
0.0157271139,
-0.4081614912,
-0.1845861971,
0.146328643,
0.4932555556,
0.1816411614,
-0.4737894237,
-0.6894008517,
-0.0555737577,
-0.6095237732,
-0.1984470189,
0.0369893648,
-0.0261892751,
-0.2113822997,
0.582588613,
0.0163429361,
0.71869874,
-0.5839437842,
-0.1468665153,
0.5474152565,
-0.2338363379,
-0.4906283915,
-0.0307773352,
0.5173788667,
0.3998027444,
0.3432857692,
-0.2030148059,
-0.2778348923,
0.1527752876,
0.1229920536,
-0.3514626026,
-0.2776114941,
0.0157337971,
-0.2243962586,
-0.2579934001,
-0.07767234,
-0.7106775641,
-0.7551264763,
-0.396956414,
0.4818084538,
-0.5956818461,
0.0392451808,
0.4619783759,
-0.5037568212,
0.2544927001,
0.3842763901,
-0.7534953356,
0.1692254692,
0.739154458,
1.0039019585,
-0.253809005,
-0.7176860571,
-0.4325109124,
0.3801104426,
-0.088362895,
0.8046635389,
-0.4665493965,
-0.047207322,
-0.4219398201,
-0.1990117878,
-0.4003131688,
-0.8710033894,
0.8480678201,
-0.163495481,
0.0468756594,
-0.2441783696,
-0.6297309399,
-0.3145187497,
0.5932104588,
-0.7689599395,
0.9300557971,
0.0564176105,
-1.0243359804,
0.1195005774,
-0.6915765405,
-0.0718718842,
-0.0366268568,
-0.3760439456,
0.0969591513,
0.49842906,
0.3943154216,
0.4863194525,
-0.7459082603,
0.3019213378,
-0.3200065196,
-0.3123194575,
0.5025140643,
-0.4400315881,
0.7604398727,
0.4186306,
-0.0520314127,
-0.0669535771,
-0.5277849436,
-0.1730144471,
0.6147586107,
0.0920657665,
-0.5106528401,
-0.3239572644,
0.1967461705,
0.3011679351,
0.0866032988,
-0.3439373076,
0.1743949801,
-0.057287287,
0.7704561949,
0.7975189686,
0.0745986998,
-0.126957953,
-0.79516536,
0.5503960252,
-0.0068108053,
0.0021803428,
-0.4201124609,
-0.3713442981,
-0.4579666853,
-0.6472615004,
0.1868622601,
0.5018008947,
-0.7226815224,
0.0979953557,
-0.6165422201,
-0.5315223932,
-0.6262471676,
0.1518605798,
0.1515051425,
0.6638838053,
0.3006282151,
-0.0698411018,
-0.3189331889,
-1.1693856716,
-0.3207500577,
-0.1605727971,
-0.2808376551,
0.2767118514,
0.7602453232,
-0.1163595319,
0.8043160439,
-0.5508927107,
-0.2341668606,
-0.324855417,
0.3737181723,
0.1537092179,
0.1437732726,
0.7030072212,
-0.92176193,
-0.1133791506,
-0.2158156633,
-0.885068059,
-0.119915165,
-0.23090294,
-0.0458121188,
-0.3319221735,
0.3949659169,
-0.71875453,
0.1454942822,
0.5910527706,
-0.220099017,
0.7346282005,
-0.0402465314,
0.1239613667,
-0.8835496902,
0.1289180219,
-0.1019506156,
-0.0510360971,
-0.2479685247,
0.2013485432,
-0.0557083748,
-0.0466914438,
-0.6055961847,
0.7135000229,
-0.3226871789,
0.0993847772,
-0.0028487232,
0.1355622262,
0.1788753718,
0.3227540255,
-0.092495054,
0.7688747048,
0.5862089992,
-0.526370585,
0.6481022835,
0.1409454942,
-0.8054849505,
0.5002494454,
-0.5304923058,
0.1502297372,
-0.2707391679,
0.3990365565,
-0.9228653908,
-0.3196633458,
0.3551499546,
-0.1545694321,
-0.162285015,
0.3857558072,
-0.9925678968,
-0.2567811012,
-0.4433437884,
0.4241722226,
0.1330733597,
-0.5717648864,
0.3645928204,
0.3513815701,
0.0279941596,
-0.4414472282,
-0.7136762738,
0.3735088408,
-0.8468860388,
-0.2666783631,
0.2137858719,
-0.1964057684,
-0.225072816,
-0.0772311762,
-0.1889223754,
-0.0881628841,
0.1963150054,
-0.0753416717,
0.0992971659,
-0.0887053832,
0.2747679949,
-0.2703098655,
0.0456098877,
0.2504524291,
-0.0427181311,
0.5204412341,
-0.1341686547,
-0.3315975964,
-0.3181838691,
0.1248758286,
0.973942697,
0.0163095966,
0.7370429635,
0.3515079319,
-0.5711554289,
0.1831769943,
-0.5747321248,
-0.1054435074,
-0.4054070711,
0.3278487623,
-0.5527222753,
-0.7831717134,
0.6232594252,
0.1193368062,
0.0000684997,
0.3824921548,
0.4641716182,
-0.3059258461,
0.3460951746,
0.2791054547,
-0.4070535898,
0.1043051258,
0.0950591341,
-0.1555851698,
-0.7298693061,
-0.3245832324,
-0.5898725986,
-0.490963608,
-0.3004935384,
-0.5423341393,
0.2257493585,
-0.1420767158,
-0.2343925983,
0.1317323148,
-0.2648486495,
0.4984719157,
0.3770522475,
-0.0838734061,
0.5046340823,
0.292416811,
-0.369912833,
-0.4278979599,
-0.5945211649,
-0.5556845069,
0.8045256138,
0.522713542,
0.8876764178,
0.0387493223,
0.4855879843,
0.172831133,
0.3554483652,
-0.7194660902,
0.5904536843,
0.0532599092,
-0.6456007957,
0.0043845787,
-0.591563046,
-0.9762221575,
0.2751651406,
-0.0172178205,
-1.0826963186,
-0.3536128998,
0.059907984,
0.0362315886,
0.4173921645,
-0.6503304839,
1.0487087965,
-0.4304232895,
0.2762634456,
-0.0742067993,
-0.8372003436,
0.5433512926,
-0.3163023293,
0.2819298804,
-0.1907148361,
-0.1999850273,
0.9851587415,
0.1295175403,
0.5646166205,
0.2590672076,
0.0058654794,
0.2797065377,
0.0974110663,
0.3338892162,
-0.118714273,
-0.2932215035,
0.2159555405,
0.2023682445,
-0.3448163569,
-0.8099029064,
0.5140985847,
-0.4282622337,
-0.5496324897,
-0.7157649398,
-0.8897612095,
-0.2507119775,
0.0208230279,
0.313896507,
-0.0778940096,
-0.0814134851,
0.6209768057,
0.2685661018,
-0.1141676456,
-0.1582413316,
0.220189631,
-0.1921616048,
-0.3394559622,
0.8717219234,
-0.0374297872,
0.2973332107,
0.4980918765,
0.4123447239,
-0.3845024705,
-0.4239655733,
-0.2257322073,
0.4916284382,
-0.8634693623,
-0.2509925961,
-0.6960858107,
-0.1889202595,
-0.1061227918,
0.1707238406,
-0.0005059605,
-0.2563651204,
-0.1177552417,
-0.1713341475,
0.4473397732,
0.8087233305,
0.0806249753,
0.3235771358,
-0.7621482611,
0.4505470097,
0.2066774219,
0.0479138754,
-0.0176595803,
-0.7517294884,
-0.1047091484,
0.0031981899,
-0.5567659736,
-1.1273318529,
0.25002864,
0.230234161,
0.5339688063,
0.4353664815,
0.1743363738,
0.83385849,
-0.3800854981,
0.7052240968,
0.2008277625,
-1.0142968893,
0.3959827721,
-0.4009844661,
0.2705702484,
0.5386185646,
0.4281010032,
-0.888034761,
-0.5761725307,
-0.6188997626,
-0.7626773715,
0.4990227818,
0.5458469391,
0.3270856142,
-0.0313199908,
0.468198061,
0.2965295017,
0.5866230726,
-0.9744178653,
-0.3620099425,
0.1108491197,
-0.4039582908,
-0.2264158875,
-0.2264001071,
-0.1764609814,
-0.4022750556,
0.214614287,
0.0594506375,
0.2259823233,
-0.1605832726,
-0.154623732,
0.1833575368,
0.268181622,
0.3974367678,
0.761975348,
-0.2786697447,
0.4133346379,
0.4140284657,
-0.4963238835,
0.0435375795,
-0.0232375078,
0.2229472697,
0.01218413,
0.6068823934,
0.8598523736,
0.3752545118,
-1.0253734589,
0.2045392543,
-0.0989440233,
-0.1406561732,
0.0043248669,
0.0658428743,
0.2596241534,
0.1040760279,
0.5877498984,
-0.3664378226,
0.2501625121,
-0.5357533693,
0.0732606724,
0.3349938095,
0.0324659124,
-0.1480156481,
0.4928562939,
-0.3166637421,
0.1701485366,
0.8102331758,
-0.1580893695,
-0.5675579906,
0.8308727145,
0.7407209873,
0.6846431494,
0.0822580233,
0.0821053088,
-0.0090605346,
0.6276193857,
-0.0523370355,
0.0278499983,
0.1345793754,
-0.7318769693,
-0.0282572322,
-0.6410729289,
-0.6109243035,
0.9778492451,
-0.6829613447,
0.4168009758,
-0.1239476651,
0.2787823975,
0.108264029,
-0.3016379178,
-0.8543918729,
0.2826369703,
0.1479735821,
1.0111967325,
-1.152381897,
0.771831274,
1.0368105173,
-0.1105600446,
-0.7572196126,
0.360014677,
0.1496502608,
-0.8801939487,
0.6437442899,
0.5540133715,
-0.0033785277,
-0.080304563,
-0.4855838418,
-0.5978654623,
1.0982371569,
1.0082740784,
-0.2311350405,
-0.0759092718,
0.1333528459,
0.4168334901,
-0.515003264,
0.114692986,
0.656029582,
0.4650250971,
0.2547521889,
-1.0191489458,
-0.0340790898,
-0.0529889874,
-0.1090856418,
-0.083663553,
-0.2997137308,
1.0747276545,
-0.0661443025,
-0.2252364457,
-0.0103259999,
0.6113043427,
0.5702207685,
0.5916765332,
0.7598299384,
0.7409722805,
0.7643319368,
0.2249833941,
0.9335744381,
0.1375384182,
0.524184525,
1.381459713,
-0.2360513061,
0.6640877724,
0.714885354,
-0.117163375,
0.1220747009,
0.9161993861,
0.1196218133,
0.4810759723,
0.4575737417,
-0.1732631773,
-0.0872394517,
-0.2688131332,
-0.4841886163,
0.7136000395,
0.4801772535,
-0.379132688,
-0.6331287622,
0.1317859888,
-0.0173247363,
-0.0435642265,
-0.0634986237,
0.5649700761,
0.212738052,
-0.4100153148,
0.6589497328,
-0.0409290791,
0.4647042155,
-0.597299695,
-0.1373294294,
-0.1333921403,
-0.0922448263,
0.1503866315,
-0.9274072051,
0.3992105424,
0.0424496531,
0.0162762143,
-0.0020789485,
0.2922791243,
-0.2874723077,
-0.509852469,
0.3069887757,
0.6376734972,
0.5137175322,
-0.2980811894,
-0.950982213,
0.287027061,
-0.0972408876,
-0.2226387113,
0.3222897351,
0.933024466,
-0.1329998076,
0.9632377625,
0.326831162,
0.0693993419,
-0.0993082821,
-0.367049098,
0.9945620894,
-0.6926763058,
-0.6632017493,
-1.0465544462,
0.1167438775,
0.0193784423,
-0.4207771719,
0.7110145688,
0.6252869368,
0.6959722042,
-0.2875594497,
0.6551240087,
0.0016413799,
0.3779488504,
-0.7022033334,
0.6659534574,
-0.9260217547,
0.1813952923,
-0.4021410048,
-0.9256302714,
-0.3514238596,
0.7433015108,
-0.3283310831,
-0.0996334702,
1.0061269999,
0.5986147523,
-0.3919554353,
0.09809196,
0.2263640612,
0.1243226454,
0.0809933394,
0.7714813352,
0.9885698557,
-0.0889650807,
0.5550386906,
-0.1515251696,
-0.04773774,
-0.140444845,
-1.3295642138,
-0.7772838473,
-0.7412228584,
-0.2277479768,
-0.1527033001,
0.0421220735,
1.0935169458,
0.2455952615,
-0.6962161064,
-0.2169742137,
-0.05065329,
0.2911331058,
-0.2163292468,
-0.2390334904,
0.3241205513,
-0.2986522317,
-0.6070413589,
0.1903656274,
0.2486685067,
0.0473545305,
-0.0066711372,
0.0347751714,
-0.3843452334,
0.0573257618,
0.2537709773,
0.0938120857,
-0.8315796256,
-0.4065185189,
-0.1660100371,
-0.2567426562,
0.1695099473,
0.9036676884,
-0.6183038354,
0.3589836955,
0.2408687025,
0.8221583962,
0.2860509157,
-0.1770707369,
0.2265764177,
-0.730559051,
0.3063335121,
0.2163380682,
0.4491711557,
0.4086790085,
-0.2022204846,
0.5678002834,
0.4410478771,
-0.2477850914,
-1.1091862917,
0.291862011,
-0.9444599748,
-0.2538062632,
1.0110521317,
-0.2330497503,
-0.2010426372,
0.002534776,
-0.3009662032,
0.1190384775,
-0.2165842652,
0.8478925824,
1.0605843067,
-0.0883550867,
-0.2851020098,
-0.9884241223,
0.2484664023,
0.6330497265,
-0.9503084421,
0.2549068928,
0.4451400042,
0.3888821304,
-0.0505769737,
0.4559159875,
0.0908392146,
0.0514600761,
-0.3803951442,
-0.1309960186,
-0.0925744176,
-0.3561876416,
-0.3401854038,
0.0737493038,
0.0818984061,
-0.5192141533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11807v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11807v2
|
How Far Are We on the Decision-Making of LLMs? Evaluating LLMs' Gaming Ability in Multi-Agent Environments
| 2024-03-18T14:04:47 | 2024-04-25T15:04:41 |
Jen-tse Huang, Eric John Li, Man Ho Lam, Tian Liang, Wenxuan Wang, Youliang Yuan, Wenxiang Jiao, Xing Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Michael R. Lyu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Decision-making, a complicated task requiring various types of abilities,
presents an excellent framework for assessing Large Language Models (LLMs). Our
research investigates LLMs' decision-making capabilities through the lens of a
well-established field, Game Theory. We focus specifically on games that
support the participation of more than two agents simultaneously. Subsequently,
we introduce our framework, GAMA-Bench, including eight classical multi-agent
games. We design a scoring scheme to assess a model's performance in these
games quantitatively. Through GAMA-Bench, we investigate LLMs' robustness,
generalizability, and enhancement strategies. Results reveal that while GPT-3.5
shows satisfying robustness, its generalizability is relatively limited.
However, its performance can be improved through approaches such as
Chain-of-Thought. Additionally, we conduct evaluations across various LLMs and
find that GPT-4 outperforms other models on GAMA-Bench, achieving a score of
60.5. Moreover, Gemini-1.0-Pro and GPT-3.5 (0613, 1106, 0125) demonstrate
similar intelligence on GAMA-Bench. The code and experimental results are made
publicly available via https://github.com/CUHK-ARISE/GAMABench.
|
[
-0.6660974026,
-0.8979877234,
1.144598484,
0.2937793136,
0.001102325,
0.2573079765,
-0.4723227918,
-0.4941802323,
-0.0808909908,
0.216842398,
-0.4984038174,
-0.6106222272,
-0.5947133303,
-0.0395809785,
-0.0092184572,
0.6718081832,
0.0041186772,
0.247583732,
-0.5566698909,
-0.2044579387,
-0.4359997213,
-0.6089929342,
-0.8870760798,
-0.5531998277,
0.2679325342,
0.2923428416,
0.7917864919,
0.4799576998,
0.6559332609,
0.3434231579,
-0.0405300893,
0.2276042849,
-0.4590317011,
0.3826657832,
-0.3036246896,
-0.5723950267,
-0.7713822722,
0.2546612918,
0.4847973883,
0.209699899,
-0.1829469651,
0.3062125742,
-0.0118457694,
0.4636425078,
-0.4449341893,
0.3463504612,
-0.5382226706,
0.081709899,
0.0965227708,
0.0710277259,
-0.3154022098,
-0.0609856434,
0.2102500349,
-0.3306919932,
0.0433943085,
0.1559870839,
0.6310780644,
0.1970890611,
-0.2011037469,
-0.3885594308,
-0.771282196,
0.575450778,
-0.541841805,
0.1339321136,
0.5830926299,
0.7350033522,
-0.2685928941,
-0.4549993575,
-0.3382331133,
-0.4505232871,
0.381739825,
0.3978798687,
-0.2663350701,
0.2305965424,
0.3062963784,
0.1184706837,
-0.3195703924,
0.1459179074,
-0.1016565859,
0.0054373359,
0.713347137,
0.2444788069,
0.1461038589,
0.1892688125,
-0.3179063797,
0.1376410276,
-0.636062324,
0.0020884667,
0.3073874116,
0.1936948895,
0.0303903483,
0.5451954603,
0.0202129334,
0.4556014836,
0.0128576914,
-0.0254361425,
-0.0799386576,
-0.3423259556,
-0.312759757,
-0.42610237,
0.8153668642,
0.5922940373,
0.0948532075,
-0.3362059891,
-0.4145182967,
0.3171364963,
0.2032883912,
-0.5008561611,
-0.0285318661,
0.2797597349,
-0.3253649175,
-0.0664360449,
-0.0985340104,
-0.7368144393,
-0.768201232,
-0.084855482,
0.5526286364,
-0.2181318402,
-0.1669877172,
0.104209736,
-0.1644288599,
0.2717982829,
0.2730581462,
-0.7929773331,
0.513618052,
0.6592419744,
0.9936661124,
-0.3006845117,
-0.5398182273,
-0.3980896473,
0.1336771697,
-0.502374649,
0.954657793,
-0.6397174597,
-0.7165275216,
-0.2025831491,
-0.2365590036,
0.0124565316,
-0.5082116723,
0.6516177058,
-0.3672751784,
-0.0052494761,
-0.5395486355,
-0.5167617798,
-0.2256878316,
0.7575576901,
-0.7037508488,
0.6899693012,
-0.0113969659,
-0.1463247985,
0.5741423965,
-0.6672690511,
-0.3556982577,
-0.0598633066,
-0.3054167032,
-0.3811275065,
0.2378364205,
0.1783181727,
0.4054748416,
-0.5616817474,
0.0121330088,
-0.7290766835,
-0.4534054399,
0.2538568079,
-0.282420516,
0.197951138,
0.185087055,
-0.3309321702,
0.2760676146,
-0.3571194708,
0.2234761417,
0.0270492416,
-0.4428671598,
0.035841547,
0.4472869337,
-0.384901911,
0.570051074,
-0.0819331929,
-0.1202666461,
0.3231514692,
0.017501628,
0.5932098627,
0.7354498506,
-0.0801731944,
0.5599533916,
-0.6015777588,
0.7611712813,
-0.4452927411,
0.396309793,
0.4313611984,
-0.6560340524,
-0.7225219607,
-0.2657372952,
0.3646429479,
0.4978421032,
-0.7189532518,
0.1955359727,
-0.1059455574,
-0.4322849512,
-0.469922483,
-0.1235857978,
0.256870985,
-0.0793073773,
0.192843914,
-0.2955825627,
-0.3799448311,
-0.6894443035,
-0.0533845499,
-0.2335797101,
0.1557568312,
0.5412413478,
0.6889255047,
-0.4008779228,
0.764765203,
-0.0784504861,
-0.1868376434,
-0.2383415103,
-0.1522303373,
0.1604850441,
0.1113208085,
0.6544642448,
-0.287452817,
-0.2845175862,
0.152305454,
-0.7555184364,
0.037940301,
0.0288821533,
-0.0916761532,
0.1076041982,
0.2181734741,
-0.8861920834,
0.2503210008,
0.5833954215,
-0.3378212154,
0.6691963673,
-0.4752566516,
0.3403395414,
-0.6182880998,
-0.1835754365,
-0.1205871329,
-0.1576434672,
-0.691327095,
0.3399059772,
-0.1439485252,
0.3313893378,
-0.1090749204,
0.5222010612,
-0.6950299144,
-0.4949096739,
-0.4200955629,
0.2934786379,
-0.1499022841,
0.3564173281,
-0.1516208649,
0.8258837461,
0.7286944985,
-0.7130204439,
0.4168129861,
-0.0790440515,
-0.5865085125,
0.4740495086,
-0.4100216627,
0.3428824544,
0.0348802842,
0.1766904145,
-0.976211369,
0.0301833004,
0.2347901911,
-0.4779340327,
0.0262292121,
-0.1511886269,
-0.443605274,
-0.3476257026,
-0.4089615047,
0.0459784158,
0.187275365,
-0.2651835382,
0.8124911785,
0.7259411812,
-0.3187327087,
-0.3911925852,
-0.7150595784,
0.2423332036,
-0.2402148694,
-0.5704110861,
0.0893350989,
-0.28042382,
-0.6473986506,
-0.151910454,
-0.1341466308,
0.0913238898,
0.2056539655,
0.2531664968,
0.1615362167,
0.0288465917,
0.189819023,
-0.2385321409,
-0.0949152783,
0.2334962189,
-0.0994459763,
0.4784815907,
-0.5320978761,
-0.4834051132,
0.489788264,
0.1490181983,
0.6137706637,
-0.3187375963,
0.2649491131,
0.3582113385,
-0.11291527,
-0.4303714037,
-0.5716217756,
0.1136192605,
-0.3920592368,
0.4699659348,
-0.5471350551,
-0.9388378263,
0.9323182106,
-0.0601066463,
0.0422759056,
0.2656005025,
0.9522141218,
0.1944212317,
1.3612508774,
0.4305499196,
-0.059170559,
0.1641820818,
-0.1967035383,
-0.0217424333,
-0.5722864866,
-0.1452003568,
-0.4026817083,
-0.3672522008,
-0.6270965934,
-0.7976781726,
0.2694555819,
-0.2026458383,
-0.2361885011,
-0.1440519243,
-0.1823227257,
0.7798750401,
0.3027947545,
0.0079773627,
0.181508705,
-0.3097321093,
-0.4519138038,
0.3683137596,
-0.562300086,
-0.562161386,
1.0573090315,
0.4010483027,
0.5374342203,
0.5158765912,
0.5803720355,
0.30317837,
0.3639360964,
-0.9070604444,
0.6639559865,
0.1376227438,
-0.8127958775,
-0.3422977626,
-0.4989353418,
-0.8268477321,
0.7641435862,
-0.4843454063,
-0.6002606153,
-0.1501952857,
-0.4359135032,
-0.6023609042,
0.2608082592,
-0.8010119796,
0.5465868115,
-0.4721308947,
-0.584718585,
-0.3488777876,
-0.4045156837,
0.4176961482,
-0.0013094861,
0.4459910393,
-0.3381988406,
-0.3737034202,
0.4117961228,
0.0281390101,
0.2337260395,
-0.0763756633,
-0.02367156,
0.3761069179,
0.1850304306,
0.2569476664,
0.2819860578,
-0.4030246437,
-0.0205884818,
0.0580042675,
-0.2043501437,
-0.5386241674,
0.7312883735,
-0.8489844203,
-0.846316874,
-0.6416104436,
-0.5207641721,
-0.7192816734,
0.1823990643,
-0.0087991636,
0.0104093272,
-0.525806725,
-0.0507549122,
0.2686627507,
-0.05194721,
0.5194084644,
0.6576743126,
-0.5603792667,
-0.4550367594,
0.8775713444,
0.2403602749,
0.3336487114,
0.0336921476,
0.2055708319,
-0.5463123322,
-0.8804035783,
-0.3284103572,
0.0421338342,
-0.6908692122,
0.0468672588,
0.019384766,
-0.0004328675,
-0.0852856934,
0.1687392741,
-0.0007586847,
-0.0907909274,
0.0335734747,
-0.2849981189,
-0.1841296405,
1.1660290956,
-0.1285724491,
0.1730887443,
-0.6129227877,
0.0439122356,
0.4545689523,
0.64601928,
-0.0788116604,
-0.1827742308,
-0.1743798405,
-0.018820744,
-0.1520133317,
-0.878467083,
0.1461388022,
0.0405161642,
0.9771015644,
0.2028395832,
-0.3173689842,
0.52013129,
-0.38482517,
0.7335271239,
-0.0539245531,
-0.8471525311,
0.1253893077,
-0.5074980259,
0.3492530882,
0.6755571365,
-0.0360899344,
-0.2348906398,
-0.4348675311,
-0.5843446851,
-0.3704474568,
0.7882184386,
0.1654652804,
-0.1689584255,
0.0474947579,
0.1141008958,
-0.0314701386,
0.248752147,
-0.5449503064,
-0.2385153323,
0.2624551356,
0.4218437076,
-0.4082351923,
-0.192448318,
-0.1434179097,
-0.2254353166,
0.5011849999,
-0.1104210392,
0.324554503,
-0.1626137942,
0.0059349705,
-0.088479057,
0.4134976268,
0.6813017726,
0.8896836042,
-0.2275887728,
0.0396831818,
0.4659253061,
-0.3660455346,
0.2874077857,
0.1876951158,
-0.0184118841,
-0.284707576,
0.2454041839,
0.698461473,
-0.023398431,
-0.4735470414,
0.3918516636,
-0.4876171052,
-0.4641264975,
0.2297654003,
0.0897072628,
0.1652642339,
0.6639865041,
0.0798620954,
-0.0002789592,
0.1331323385,
-0.7360829711,
0.0887145028,
0.6636301875,
-0.1345611513,
-0.1098435447,
0.3361661732,
0.2486871183,
-0.121421583,
0.3484528065,
-0.5569685698,
-0.4959801733,
0.7077301741,
0.3520839214,
0.8518346548,
-0.1499611735,
0.3538125157,
0.0668170452,
0.4576202929,
-0.2945933938,
0.3614411652,
0.0225664098,
-0.6687150598,
-0.487036556,
-0.372956425,
-0.7570282817,
0.0139589291,
-0.3150517642,
0.0990142226,
-0.7228114009,
-0.8704252839,
-0.2000136971,
0.4747316539,
-0.648900032,
-0.0340360031,
0.4413670301,
0.6608505845,
-0.4783385098,
0.7075471878,
0.8661230803,
-0.3444950283,
-0.5643661022,
-0.2507156134,
0.1804413497,
-0.8181834817,
-0.0069765914,
0.0340768881,
-0.2857829928,
-0.2357026935,
-0.5257348418,
-0.8017939329,
1.2718932629,
0.4801572263,
-0.4858976603,
-0.015320044,
-0.0043472718,
0.5539338589,
-0.3093173206,
0.7184048891,
0.9310361743,
0.6642378569,
0.1147383898,
-0.920093894,
-0.1872874051,
-0.1447299421,
-0.2137226015,
0.1714459211,
-0.8899056315,
0.9895957708,
-0.4546373188,
-0.336096853,
0.1724529266,
0.4973324537,
0.5365127921,
0.1969660223,
0.4199521244,
0.5678464174,
0.9528800249,
-0.255600661,
0.9912254214,
-0.1418377161,
0.5469010472,
0.8719472289,
-0.5295718908,
0.7150853872,
0.1456881464,
-0.4939068258,
0.273252219,
0.7312045097,
-0.1164830998,
0.368624419,
0.4835314751,
-0.2025761604,
-0.5355214477,
0.1249567866,
-0.3183214664,
0.6107776165,
0.5127625465,
-0.1649743915,
-0.3361503184,
-0.3256255984,
-0.0088799587,
-0.2401276082,
-0.4081590772,
0.6420756578,
0.1301015764,
-0.825912118,
0.2064095289,
0.0482575223,
0.5039694309,
-0.691247642,
0.0825087354,
-0.1563623846,
0.4086382687,
0.0141991973,
-1.016682148,
-0.1888627112,
-0.0889628157,
-0.2104474902,
-0.0298327003,
0.7087419033,
-0.3447287977,
-0.3720450699,
0.5400394797,
1.0654582977,
0.0520494767,
-0.1521418244,
-0.9009884596,
0.3335294425,
-0.2822576761,
-0.1613091677,
0.6322258115,
0.3253635764,
0.0399604812,
0.7397729158,
0.4653933644,
0.1580388248,
-0.2411537617,
0.2660659552,
0.5448371768,
-0.5055696964,
-0.5059161186,
-1.1429111958,
-0.1232451722,
-0.0441739932,
-0.4270801842,
0.9601926804,
0.457567215,
0.4886237681,
0.0857334882,
1.0456399918,
0.0529345647,
0.0479919575,
-0.4366212487,
0.7999190092,
-0.3153059483,
0.2716709077,
-0.1842777282,
-0.9106343985,
-0.2906724811,
0.5294277668,
-0.6433774829,
0.274625212,
0.515071094,
0.804692924,
0.3328972757,
0.0949089751,
0.536444068,
0.0206320062,
0.5208973885,
0.9559835196,
1.2918080091,
0.0270590428,
0.4778001606,
0.0836976618,
-0.4098265469,
0.0158952624,
-0.8628777862,
-1.0462204218,
-0.362940371,
0.1614212245,
-0.2698855996,
0.1426446885,
0.8588295579,
0.6396579742,
-0.5254369378,
-0.5584792495,
0.2540501952,
0.3462533355,
-0.3988064528,
-0.0815623105,
0.1212816685,
-0.3213357329,
-0.5410835147,
0.5523256063,
0.2993533909,
-0.1222277135,
-0.4004699588,
-0.5245013833,
-0.3942223787,
0.2759027481,
0.7776402831,
0.1021777764,
-0.7265647054,
-0.2489795238,
0.0254240707,
-0.2699865103,
-0.0652118325,
0.6224184632,
-0.4401571453,
0.6287169456,
0.4699136913,
0.5412245989,
0.3798136711,
-0.0495502539,
0.6331964135,
-0.2354177684,
-0.3022320867,
0.2582858503,
0.5084056258,
0.233235836,
0.2032849342,
0.6811846495,
-0.0010112043,
-0.9153653383,
-0.4697596729,
0.0340317376,
-0.8055968285,
-0.2569880486,
1.5217609406,
0.0183017328,
-0.2327755243,
-0.0784656554,
-0.329364568,
-0.0698491782,
-0.3773144782,
0.6375926733,
1.3560782671,
-0.2473978847,
-0.0705895796,
-0.7680208087,
0.5111963153,
0.1062478647,
-0.8492438793,
-0.0713876113,
0.7478235364,
0.0474816486,
0.2017460763,
0.7314489484,
0.0902360678,
0.5093898177,
0.1845514774,
-0.2056007236,
-0.226176098,
-0.3259387612,
-0.4619410634,
0.1782737821,
0.47414428,
-0.129471913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11802v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11802v3
|
Counting-Stars: A Multi-evidence, Position-aware, and Scalable Benchmark for Evaluating Long-Context Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T14:01:45 | 2024-05-17T16:58:23 |
Mingyang Song, Mao Zheng, Xuan Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While recent research endeavors have focused on developing Large Language
Models (LLMs) with robust long-context capabilities, due to the lack of
long-context benchmarks, relatively little is known about how well the
performance of long-context LLMs. To address this gap, we propose a
multi-evidence, position-aware, and scalable benchmark for evaluating
long-context LLMs, named Counting-Stars, which evaluates long-context LLMs by
using two tasks: multi-evidence acquisition and multi-evidence reasoning. Based
on the Counting-Stars test, we conduct experiments to evaluate long-context
LLMs (i.e., GPT-4 Turbo, Gemini 1.5 Pro, Claude3 Opus, GLM-4, and Moonshot-v1).
Experimental results demonstrate that Gemini 1.5 Pro achieves the best overall
results, while the performance of GPT-4 Turbo is the most stable across various
tasks. Furthermore, our analysis of these LLMs, which are extended to handle
long-context scenarios, indicates that there is potential for improvement as
the length of the input context and the intricacy of the tasks are increasing.
|
[
-0.5829879045,
-0.6201387048,
0.9372260571,
0.5068312287,
-0.2389109582,
-0.0707336292,
-0.6862064004,
-0.6323443651,
0.159144491,
0.3852760792,
-0.2728113234,
-0.5083776116,
-0.8668305874,
0.1603066772,
-0.575779736,
0.8999130726,
0.0820801333,
-0.0441102423,
-0.3614988923,
-0.229620561,
-0.5609023571,
-0.4999575615,
-0.3742123842,
0.1333568394,
0.7999517322,
0.4271536767,
0.5057662129,
0.5696529746,
0.5213542581,
0.3402982652,
0.1213176548,
0.0756080002,
-0.2892281711,
0.1689504981,
-0.1866261214,
-0.0943002254,
-0.4330333173,
-0.0368117392,
0.8852753043,
0.5213655829,
0.0618835725,
0.2438318729,
0.056995973,
0.4629910886,
-0.8449305892,
0.2956258655,
-0.4226365387,
-0.3472716808,
-0.5285307169,
0.0889610574,
-0.4714004993,
-0.0846202523,
0.1860774308,
-0.4097731709,
-0.1924482882,
-0.1399798691,
0.3158662915,
0.129887417,
-0.5936340094,
-0.4077848494,
-0.5994869471,
1.0188590288,
-0.7897706032,
0.7564207315,
0.3728354573,
0.3905421793,
-0.0546968691,
-0.7562428713,
-0.5331821442,
-0.397783339,
0.0155407926,
0.1046375334,
0.1381337196,
-0.2947770059,
0.2549647987,
0.1647419482,
-0.4548157156,
0.3327150047,
-0.1712997407,
-0.2100464106,
0.4321025014,
-0.1363242418,
-0.1365438849,
0.1400016844,
-0.3829083145,
0.0817018002,
-0.7370622754,
0.0509157069,
-0.0485696644,
0.3442591727,
-0.2230219841,
0.409917444,
-0.3614007831,
0.7814647555,
-0.2434807569,
-0.258135736,
0.2534272969,
-0.4598109126,
-0.0231084321,
0.0037025362,
0.7710421085,
0.3414735496,
0.0577273183,
-0.2200821787,
-0.3134398162,
0.2784047127,
-0.0374397561,
-1.2363253832,
0.1930151433,
0.2388866246,
-0.083602041,
-0.0262504146,
-0.0311696716,
-0.6430171132,
-0.3283584416,
-0.0925381184,
0.5133829117,
-0.4085834324,
-0.1712064147,
0.1891802847,
0.0528754964,
-0.0138906464,
0.1805813611,
-0.8809356689,
0.2396864891,
1.3361804485,
0.7514659166,
-0.2034375221,
-0.6930488944,
-0.9923316836,
-0.0397134311,
-0.3659285009,
0.7760035396,
-0.6827261448,
-0.1986916959,
0.0924206302,
0.0524166897,
-0.0279511046,
-0.3711972833,
0.925293088,
-0.4089256525,
0.3807629943,
-0.5532017946,
-0.9080938697,
-0.1511708349,
0.3245660067,
-0.5231953263,
1.0168795586,
-0.0571552925,
-0.4141252041,
0.7038911581,
-0.6023238897,
-0.4660018086,
0.1775362194,
-0.411857605,
-0.2461325079,
0.331389457,
0.2353457212,
0.636578083,
-0.4882748127,
0.3631680608,
-0.4498623312,
-0.5472784042,
0.2630025446,
-0.2472801059,
0.3326935172,
0.1973112226,
-0.4070340097,
0.3833367825,
-0.4779728651,
0.0116835209,
-0.0507923178,
-0.3417639434,
-0.3925964236,
0.4297086298,
-0.0097192088,
0.3275560439,
0.283439219,
-0.691229403,
0.1320767999,
0.0146256136,
0.398198843,
0.3921865523,
-0.2456699908,
0.1101329476,
-0.1560318321,
0.1518187225,
0.1782194674,
0.0459175408,
-0.3788291216,
-0.6052682996,
-0.6585620046,
-0.514393568,
0.0772329867,
0.1932403743,
-0.7377141714,
0.6599915624,
-0.5334406495,
-0.4672278166,
-0.0826721191,
0.1065073013,
0.4180955291,
0.4001827538,
0.3919112086,
-0.2977540791,
-0.215696007,
-0.9187602401,
-0.3088865876,
-0.0831976086,
0.0456809774,
0.2469673008,
0.6838029027,
-0.2439172715,
0.8588599563,
-0.3320015371,
-0.0168391094,
0.0571328923,
-0.0343643725,
0.4516283572,
0.2595447898,
0.636719346,
-0.4152941406,
-0.4792442918,
-0.0626213923,
-0.7567199469,
-0.0186416321,
0.1226960272,
0.2679906189,
0.2911567092,
0.3610533178,
-0.8276994228,
-0.048329711,
0.9285065532,
-0.7242744565,
0.7651043534,
0.0451483317,
0.3312242031,
-0.9033395052,
0.1549633145,
0.0424956828,
-0.3335532248,
-0.6821101308,
0.0331249647,
0.5155714154,
0.0487585776,
-0.2407064289,
0.666922152,
-0.43398422,
-0.353068471,
-0.4536096156,
0.1040861681,
-0.164632827,
0.2459677011,
0.2209451944,
0.9718709588,
0.8840894103,
-0.5751897693,
0.1557400376,
-0.1959781051,
-1.0531680584,
0.631677568,
-0.3990006745,
0.0181961209,
0.1557592154,
0.3786185086,
-0.7749405503,
-0.0590411983,
-0.1217725351,
-0.203090474,
0.0098619768,
-0.1656621397,
-0.5371078849,
-0.4423950016,
-0.1761395484,
0.5297518373,
0.2486978769,
-0.7313428521,
0.2263901979,
0.2934626043,
-0.434256196,
-0.8178371191,
-0.1208551377,
0.3658823669,
-0.4932990372,
-0.5329009295,
0.4113158286,
-0.0118760122,
-0.2155159116,
-0.1759602576,
-0.112016283,
0.301703155,
0.1231345087,
0.1163378283,
0.0318646841,
-0.3845357001,
0.308481127,
-0.3306201994,
-0.2718193233,
0.1634195894,
-0.5300316215,
0.5684543848,
-0.6093540192,
-0.4643626809,
0.1083927304,
0.3197936714,
1.0824972391,
-0.4373862743,
0.7686725259,
0.6922361255,
-0.4506423771,
-0.2733088136,
-0.8549393415,
-0.1157373115,
-0.4455612898,
0.6478521228,
-0.3659982383,
-1.1717687845,
0.4941568673,
-0.0194226988,
0.2952173054,
0.4175797403,
0.7323777676,
0.0944418162,
0.6879221797,
0.408143878,
-0.4016334713,
0.3564255536,
0.0677431896,
-0.0127554992,
-0.7764317989,
0.1394027621,
-0.4333223403,
-0.1505179703,
-0.3273296654,
-0.8618652821,
0.4007665813,
0.195240438,
-0.3747439682,
0.4617341757,
-0.2591712177,
0.487177968,
0.2125364989,
-0.2454997003,
0.2752738595,
-0.4010694325,
-0.0479669496,
0.1157265306,
-0.4397254884,
-0.2779411376,
0.9819130898,
0.4876474142,
0.4570925832,
0.3894355297,
0.4878249764,
-0.0281554237,
0.7320958376,
-0.9606948495,
0.6172369123,
-0.2501860559,
-0.7077633739,
-0.4169533253,
-0.4718231857,
-0.7214877009,
0.4738798738,
-0.2456957847,
-0.7137862444,
0.0203001946,
-0.1502666473,
-0.2688076496,
0.1668819189,
-0.5347489119,
0.973169148,
-0.7568320036,
-0.5726881623,
-0.4545583427,
-0.1922197193,
0.4593055546,
-0.3943041563,
0.2634103894,
-0.2770330608,
-0.1882573664,
0.799747169,
-0.3672601879,
0.5582240224,
-0.2945010066,
-0.3140304387,
0.2660612166,
-0.0788300037,
0.7905371189,
0.1228246316,
-0.157324478,
0.377679348,
0.0556992479,
-0.2828475535,
-0.3102074265,
1.2080212831,
-0.5107903481,
-0.3614466488,
-0.5981267095,
-0.5308458209,
-0.4058865905,
0.4188044667,
-0.016678201,
0.5002752542,
-0.2251562178,
0.6578971148,
0.0468968228,
-0.2634918094,
0.7504813671,
0.8281316757,
-0.6003679633,
-0.4653350115,
0.7866154313,
0.0432357639,
0.1552334875,
0.3128038049,
0.2969549,
-0.6197568774,
-0.7771846652,
-0.5291900635,
0.2034109086,
-0.570856452,
0.1338041276,
-0.4406222403,
0.1316507906,
-0.1822977662,
0.051315859,
-0.7150316834,
-0.1944380552,
0.4206420481,
0.2215238661,
0.2878670096,
0.6484417915,
0.3048763275,
0.2174402177,
-0.8392574787,
0.1569559574,
0.3433158994,
0.9831978083,
-0.129202649,
-0.3978496194,
-0.6575469971,
-0.3593271375,
-0.0607509539,
-0.5196459293,
0.1871884465,
0.1153190061,
0.5069023967,
0.5054815412,
-0.3382563293,
0.77646631,
-0.5378306508,
0.7204809785,
0.2930609286,
-0.8965902328,
-0.068655327,
-0.625336349,
0.5092489123,
0.6629692912,
0.1549495608,
-0.7534018755,
-0.1461270303,
-0.227240324,
-0.6331008673,
0.4285644591,
0.1117608547,
-0.2924149632,
-0.3481360078,
0.1087594628,
0.1152094975,
0.2855375409,
-0.533305645,
0.0316538364,
0.0087592462,
0.0858778358,
-0.6473388672,
-0.2794668376,
-0.0147520751,
-0.1024764851,
0.4659944475,
-0.2626811862,
0.080969356,
-0.0474885963,
-0.1777023226,
0.1620099992,
0.460555315,
0.8622354269,
1.08665061,
-0.2656305134,
0.3019401729,
0.2424977124,
-0.3763694465,
-0.2195682526,
0.23157233,
0.0988679156,
-0.1371037513,
0.4994327724,
0.6596576571,
0.5239085555,
-0.5712674856,
0.48781991,
-0.0711125806,
0.0282144174,
-0.4458703995,
-0.1613569856,
0.6505548358,
0.1511730701,
0.2330199033,
-0.084320426,
-0.1422968209,
-0.7633445859,
0.4094814062,
0.536775887,
-0.4327941537,
-0.2336491495,
0.4481414557,
0.4374463558,
-0.1990919411,
0.6025505662,
-0.0609889701,
-0.4134277701,
0.6058297753,
0.6147884727,
0.8412685394,
-0.1621452123,
-0.1624194235,
0.5775080323,
0.0937884673,
-0.3839973807,
0.1988606006,
-0.2169006616,
-0.7487592697,
-0.8324323893,
-0.6411135197,
-0.4596599936,
0.3544440269,
-0.4663231373,
0.1318662465,
-0.2823451757,
-0.3357841372,
0.2572079003,
0.0506477244,
-0.6553207636,
0.0112675633,
0.4218623936,
0.9152855277,
-0.65540874,
1.081690073,
0.4001044035,
0.232569322,
-0.4305435419,
-0.1374182999,
0.1254539341,
-0.5742539167,
0.5245807767,
0.6633230448,
-0.3379563689,
-0.287345618,
-0.2218885273,
-0.9698073864,
1.1210097075,
0.0843962207,
-0.9199963212,
0.6502615213,
-0.0411558077,
0.5459635258,
-0.5591726899,
0.424909085,
0.6006289124,
0.670681417,
-0.0535065867,
-1.1950377226,
0.0034927805,
-0.3689927459,
-0.3629319966,
0.4859546125,
-0.7409339547,
0.8677692413,
-0.1491008252,
-0.2197771519,
0.1479536146,
0.7047062516,
0.6151427031,
0.33702299,
0.8663425446,
0.5137574673,
0.5956327915,
-0.1694722027,
1.108721137,
-0.7084054947,
0.3164573908,
1.1958925724,
-0.6307559609,
1.1020009518,
0.3723005652,
-0.1237131953,
0.3938211799,
0.396410346,
0.0310207084,
0.2313229293,
0.128738746,
-0.4412416816,
-0.4554415047,
0.0531367287,
-0.3766253293,
0.6093494892,
0.5350664854,
-0.2027794421,
-0.1226662099,
-0.4285456836,
0.0471266322,
-0.2270120233,
-0.0760573819,
0.4057021141,
0.1994677335,
-1.3521560431,
0.4996342361,
0.1997130066,
0.8432147503,
-0.7997336984,
0.1690597087,
-0.0507138744,
0.4861214161,
-0.1062428877,
-0.9651982188,
0.00087041,
0.1756064147,
-0.0497545861,
-0.0807111859,
0.4768761992,
-0.4852802753,
-0.6848444939,
0.5234498978,
0.4732189476,
0.1370055228,
-0.3229486942,
-0.433365941,
0.2117056549,
-0.3666192591,
-0.3549899757,
0.6043965816,
0.1874156743,
-0.244938463,
0.7681501508,
0.7694795728,
0.0851818472,
-0.2191509306,
0.359808296,
0.6791204214,
-1.0114328861,
-0.62128824,
-1.0321279764,
0.2260327041,
-0.0546412952,
-0.4591036439,
0.9647135735,
0.9691162109,
0.4617193937,
-0.0909444466,
0.5696937442,
-0.0935273096,
0.4752300978,
-0.3935406506,
0.722284615,
-0.4066210389,
0.4586415887,
-0.2170784771,
-1.1585315466,
-0.234373495,
0.3063055873,
-0.4190066457,
0.2550083101,
0.8457902074,
0.7015808821,
-0.0823078901,
0.1131929234,
0.3147827089,
0.2806332111,
0.5899090171,
0.8521131873,
1.0366572142,
-0.3137194812,
0.3540040553,
-0.1913100332,
-0.3678989112,
-0.0445841923,
-1.250423789,
-0.7175446153,
-0.5182096958,
-0.142434001,
0.0148063898,
-0.221980378,
0.6394463181,
0.8984336853,
-0.8325612545,
-0.5510471463,
0.3401847482,
-0.0185574964,
-0.5272396207,
-0.1122919843,
0.4681003094,
-0.1627105176,
-0.6140094399,
0.9477756619,
0.5060675144,
-0.497508496,
-0.3185217083,
-0.3526480794,
-0.0701611787,
-0.2058074176,
1.0777434111,
0.3404164016,
-0.8110817671,
-0.7578829527,
-0.0574164167,
-0.1139937043,
-0.1798224747,
0.703053236,
-0.8075020909,
0.3750469983,
0.5198638439,
0.5247895718,
0.599512279,
0.181914404,
0.4185480773,
-0.6124535203,
-0.0375218876,
0.0649432391,
0.5887289047,
0.2510977983,
0.0620934702,
0.4830435216,
0.0370963924,
-0.8273070455,
-0.7054132223,
0.1985513717,
-1.2470697165,
-0.2525812089,
1.215356946,
-0.0849720538,
0.1596408486,
-0.0962515026,
0.3957638443,
-0.1977229565,
-0.3304534853,
0.7458820939,
0.8305677772,
-0.0555732325,
-0.2108944803,
-0.667865932,
0.3634384871,
0.5424720645,
-0.9165734053,
0.3628270924,
0.5689633489,
0.4758104384,
0.3444087803,
0.6316665411,
-0.1818090677,
0.2178455591,
-0.0855396166,
-0.1304425299,
-0.3125992715,
-0.6576467752,
-0.1578865349,
0.1752745956,
0.1143479422,
-0.0286673382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11793v1
|
Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models: In-Depth Analysis on the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus
| 2024-03-18T13:50:50 | 2024-03-18T13:50:50 |
Seungpil Lee, Woochang Sim, Donghyeon Shin, Sanha Hwang, Wongyu Seo, Jiwon Park, Seokki Lee, Sejin Kim, Sundong Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.SC
|
The existing methods for evaluating the inference abilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) have been results-centric, making it difficult to assess the
inference process. We introduce a new approach using the Abstract and Reasoning
Corpus (ARC) dataset to evaluate the inference and contextual understanding
abilities of large language models in a process-centric manner. ARC demands
rigorous logical structures for problem-solving, making it a benchmark that
facilitates the comparison of model inference abilities with humans.
Experimental results confirm that while large language models possess weak
inference abilities, they still lag in terms of logical coherence,
compositionality, and productivity. Our experiments highlight the reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, proposing development paths for achieving human-level
reasoning.
|
[
-0.472610116,
-0.9416399002,
0.8584622145,
0.0257204175,
0.059336029,
0.2281455547,
-0.3573589325,
-0.6384425759,
-0.1356468648,
0.7488915324,
-0.3490143716,
-0.555844605,
-0.5520297289,
0.2085746676,
-0.7160989046,
0.4421418905,
0.0484671816,
0.006472067,
-0.5749098063,
0.0215063728,
-0.3361574709,
-0.5083854198,
-0.7669866681,
-0.3977232873,
0.3828329146,
0.5308163166,
0.6402702928,
0.4831961095,
0.5006222725,
0.3468409479,
-0.3503779173,
0.0586475879,
-0.1259151101,
0.3334333301,
-0.4578997195,
-0.5013848543,
-0.5093308091,
-0.3735111654,
0.6388030052,
1.2489115,
0.288176924,
0.2043850422,
-0.2765958905,
0.6596003175,
-0.6903242469,
0.282412231,
-0.6303115487,
-0.0648435205,
0.0274670087,
0.1578038186,
-0.7129921317,
-0.1746456921,
0.2648366094,
-0.4086374342,
0.1100989804,
0.2600853145,
0.4175205529,
0.2482498288,
-0.1598914266,
-0.2168096453,
-0.7630114555,
0.9155538082,
-0.9547556639,
0.2334541827,
0.4749725461,
0.264487654,
-0.1436293125,
-0.7354519367,
-0.5344090462,
-0.3089385629,
-0.058320418,
-0.2552755475,
-0.2616501749,
0.0982685462,
0.4237620234,
0.3144082129,
-0.3945328593,
0.315954566,
-0.2233497202,
-0.1381013244,
0.8103082776,
0.1052322611,
0.2888659835,
-0.1461496204,
-0.092559956,
0.0369975418,
-0.5214391351,
0.0043964242,
0.1957399249,
0.0386170447,
0.0501339287,
0.7468319535,
-0.3962545693,
0.6679634452,
-0.1397558749,
-0.1742884219,
0.1370201111,
-0.1573220491,
-0.2905843854,
0.0470187292,
0.5172154903,
-0.0643639639,
0.3415254653,
-0.3250439167,
-0.3371808529,
0.1357117146,
-0.0090340832,
-0.5999653935,
0.0319579095,
0.5772764087,
-0.4211695194,
0.1510446668,
-0.1208599061,
-0.4825912714,
-0.4544015825,
-0.5733243823,
0.1280256361,
-0.486833334,
-0.5150776505,
0.3001112938,
-0.1858345866,
0.3574931026,
0.4425005615,
-0.8065816164,
0.4804390669,
1.0083366632,
0.5944489837,
-0.3257746696,
-0.3617044389,
-0.2566970587,
0.0151716517,
-0.4223558009,
1.0328874588,
-0.7385610342,
-0.1137877926,
-0.2966039181,
-0.1694980115,
-0.0309972074,
-0.735768497,
0.8090203404,
-0.6164364815,
-0.2802278996,
-0.1979421079,
-0.8277996182,
-0.3357242346,
0.2040300518,
-0.7787884474,
0.8784308434,
0.069032602,
-0.7629007697,
0.1749676168,
-0.6409923434,
-0.4215467572,
-0.0771492049,
-0.1133611202,
-0.1644388735,
0.2719576359,
0.315387696,
0.5642579198,
-0.4414535761,
0.3772486448,
-0.5101516843,
-0.2779797614,
0.4110846519,
-0.3008699119,
0.7174715996,
0.3018943071,
-0.1475273818,
0.3611446619,
-0.8192250729,
0.0835200995,
-0.0253178552,
-0.0399766304,
-0.3266299069,
0.3401319087,
-0.3704483211,
0.0848256275,
0.1612585485,
-0.3037582636,
0.1897914112,
-0.3910962343,
0.6161578298,
0.4309096634,
-0.0553620458,
0.6467607021,
-0.0075934865,
0.3815431297,
-0.072902441,
-0.1695750207,
-0.1897007078,
-0.3757894039,
-0.8345620036,
-0.437667191,
0.1575680524,
0.4113285542,
-0.501519978,
0.6866195798,
-0.1504540145,
-0.4445062578,
-0.3084775507,
0.0512799658,
0.3666485846,
0.691742003,
0.3171910048,
-0.3023284674,
-0.554064095,
-0.8542429209,
-0.1486221254,
-0.3429916203,
-0.1228908598,
0.1758933216,
0.8992183805,
-0.102566272,
1.0537590981,
-0.243040517,
0.5062656403,
-0.5954611897,
0.2527295947,
0.2129714489,
0.2377694398,
0.1180330515,
-0.5802261233,
0.1353659183,
0.0185402352,
-1.0373543501,
-0.3895711303,
0.1547501832,
-0.2099892497,
0.1848003864,
0.6778414249,
-0.7072020173,
0.4002425075,
0.3593804836,
-0.5846277475,
0.9082863927,
-0.1873846352,
-0.061876107,
-0.4165790975,
0.1934150755,
-0.1107758582,
-0.0873702466,
-0.5760525465,
0.1481666565,
-0.1221532226,
-0.1092614308,
-0.3946729898,
0.7216637135,
-0.6543827057,
-0.7318210602,
-0.3363901675,
0.0479776785,
0.2431179136,
0.3654701412,
0.580575943,
0.5689473748,
0.7508262992,
-0.6251621246,
0.3981907368,
0.0257246718,
-0.835754931,
0.4689084589,
-0.7451112866,
0.0933943689,
-0.2117754966,
0.3652884364,
-0.8868240714,
-0.3586024642,
-0.1428693235,
-0.2320321798,
0.0497067906,
0.1238779277,
-0.5492697358,
-0.4053087831,
0.0816536173,
0.550983727,
0.2448649108,
-0.2437007129,
0.7304035425,
0.2988333404,
-0.2937592566,
-0.5377113819,
-0.7199565768,
0.1586845368,
-0.2990665138,
-0.9817309976,
0.0696521774,
0.140343979,
-0.9817052484,
-0.0879127234,
-0.0132736331,
-0.3082223535,
0.2519570887,
0.0685693324,
0.0893195421,
-0.320287168,
0.1540828645,
0.1615882069,
-0.1880233735,
0.3255006373,
0.0205471944,
0.41047135,
-0.3573773503,
-0.7025153041,
-0.5328999758,
0.3669501245,
0.7006139159,
-0.4870117307,
0.7681221366,
0.0210943073,
-0.3970884681,
-0.1930630207,
-0.5546245575,
-0.3381274939,
-0.2884904444,
0.4565354288,
-0.5279660821,
-0.7439469099,
0.7822848558,
-0.2181323022,
-0.0087178163,
0.4973735511,
0.7412859201,
0.057566274,
0.9999428391,
0.1623918861,
0.0638137162,
0.0633522496,
-0.4697697759,
0.1989257336,
-0.8651280999,
-0.2900664508,
-0.6007890701,
-0.2348728478,
0.0631061196,
-0.4429341555,
0.0950362906,
0.4954769313,
-0.6837767363,
0.1328667402,
-0.3288545012,
0.5254886746,
0.2770465314,
-0.0484209284,
0.7941666842,
-0.2250531167,
0.0738942474,
0.2710736394,
-0.4552994668,
-0.7458215952,
0.8261240721,
0.6042067409,
0.7704544663,
0.0561660752,
0.20268704,
0.2007915378,
0.2414565533,
-0.8408986926,
0.6517305374,
0.1707499623,
-0.7528065443,
-0.5241141915,
-0.3200350106,
-0.6937825084,
0.4569207132,
-0.1310996264,
-0.8833233714,
0.1571897417,
-0.1150865182,
-0.253918767,
0.4401423037,
-0.952061832,
0.8512232304,
-0.2846738994,
-0.2880353928,
-0.3631815016,
-0.5715991855,
0.5207064748,
0.035199143,
0.3433923125,
-0.4193818867,
-0.1459090859,
0.4331722856,
-0.4379624128,
0.7921829224,
0.0641066283,
-0.1974911243,
0.6210737228,
0.1672844887,
0.3428680599,
0.0499589592,
-0.537756145,
0.2547838688,
-0.1967821866,
-0.3966450095,
-0.679862082,
0.4663853049,
-0.6260305643,
-0.671677947,
-0.2073567808,
-0.8225535154,
-0.3296593726,
0.1305587441,
-0.0032392151,
0.2941245139,
-0.1827739328,
0.1363787651,
0.6330779791,
-0.264952153,
0.48921296,
0.4393473566,
-0.3116083145,
0.0005226344,
0.4378218055,
-0.1688645631,
0.4800845087,
0.2604681253,
0.1605109423,
-0.3903378546,
-0.7926572561,
-0.4464434981,
0.2200552225,
-0.7888411283,
0.1479371935,
-0.4391670823,
-0.2354714721,
-0.1422451735,
-0.0963331014,
-0.3662397563,
-0.3919326663,
-0.118805021,
-0.037828967,
0.234852016,
0.7148458362,
0.2530086339,
-0.0096450467,
-0.43488729,
0.2049005777,
0.1818191856,
0.1154396459,
0.3508707285,
-0.4900050461,
-0.0595865957,
-0.1343276501,
-0.1369914263,
-0.6607136726,
0.238959074,
-0.0323626846,
0.440249145,
0.481459111,
-0.0803373829,
0.3621470332,
-0.2526723444,
0.6188913584,
-0.0261665247,
-1.1067187786,
0.4297669232,
-0.19896999,
0.3569594324,
0.3301397264,
0.1036691293,
-0.2890877426,
-0.4819886684,
-0.4506659806,
-0.7459561229,
0.5063631535,
0.2332113534,
-0.2083624154,
0.0596447922,
0.3469753563,
0.1472298801,
0.0429354794,
-0.4328978062,
-0.0720093995,
0.1927310228,
0.0650306717,
0.1537821144,
-0.1812722236,
0.1611706614,
-0.6068857908,
0.309805721,
-0.1498529315,
0.0940787271,
0.2033831626,
-0.2006289512,
0.0784378797,
0.5348537564,
0.3859804571,
1.2551851273,
0.0036594337,
0.3763008714,
0.4309718013,
-0.0268581342,
0.1425377578,
-0.0565806143,
0.1322333962,
-0.3012334406,
0.8903440237,
0.7321673632,
0.2078766227,
-1.0541759729,
0.3937899172,
-0.0177085306,
-0.2502490878,
-0.4526461065,
0.1877881438,
0.5071331859,
0.4057643712,
0.356847316,
-0.0338513739,
0.1700095683,
-0.6375072002,
-0.0411231406,
0.3468693793,
-0.0642845109,
-0.1470235735,
0.4084900022,
0.1069157943,
-0.162526533,
0.6974490881,
-0.0924706981,
-0.2677587867,
0.8972437382,
0.5292366743,
0.6074359417,
-0.0514061078,
-0.0636602342,
0.2986856401,
-0.0057906946,
-0.4366904497,
0.1288286895,
0.0181164164,
-0.8938876987,
-1.1431430578,
-0.5261395574,
-0.6650523543,
0.1969691366,
-0.5324925184,
0.1764183491,
-0.2889955938,
0.0723501593,
0.2821955383,
-0.1486225575,
-0.3604387939,
0.1551544815,
0.2685884535,
1.1273961067,
-0.7390063405,
0.8011484742,
0.4791580439,
-0.3347943723,
-0.5962113142,
-0.3649029136,
-0.2251193523,
-0.6284464002,
0.8701024652,
0.174596563,
-0.3146577775,
-0.1990702301,
-0.7201353312,
-0.7623816729,
0.9539113641,
0.8106462359,
-0.6111435294,
-0.0771882087,
0.0848658085,
0.6804075837,
-0.5663155913,
0.5121378899,
1.0931879282,
0.6464518309,
0.2468463928,
-0.8791254163,
-0.1293590665,
-0.0032662526,
-0.0805906877,
0.1184200719,
-0.247950539,
0.8820917606,
-0.3097852767,
-0.2369919717,
0.2005188465,
1.008364439,
0.3937714398,
0.3896646202,
0.5383844972,
0.8787680268,
0.886325717,
-0.073937878,
1.201074481,
-0.1618795544,
0.180741623,
1.0734215975,
-0.3579907715,
0.9952864051,
0.3306341767,
-0.156470418,
0.9128572345,
0.4346327186,
0.374866426,
0.0869955868,
0.4541481733,
-0.5444378853,
-0.5210690498,
0.0067848428,
-0.1918626279,
0.5991196036,
0.5698572397,
-0.3409546018,
-0.1925761849,
-0.2383302003,
0.0513119139,
0.1972100288,
-0.6164161563,
0.5868744254,
0.2647202313,
-0.8453109264,
0.4867377579,
-0.029242117,
0.3275786042,
-0.2125131786,
-0.0401284397,
0.0084467046,
0.2516443729,
-0.3873029053,
-1.186098814,
0.6525586247,
0.1660838574,
-0.2589949071,
0.0383325443,
0.775095582,
-0.1008664668,
-0.5386704803,
0.3386349082,
0.6886711717,
0.4253082275,
-0.1817898005,
-0.5602371097,
0.1170671061,
-0.4010361731,
-0.3615734279,
0.0251168236,
0.5179026127,
-0.3445154727,
0.9601787925,
0.3793554306,
0.1168642864,
-0.2873980403,
0.2648174167,
0.6337750554,
-0.7311964631,
-0.163109377,
-0.9959021211,
0.4223588109,
-0.1350530535,
-0.2017505616,
0.6317943335,
0.5306587815,
0.6061914563,
0.0973457918,
0.8786240816,
-0.0870774686,
0.6193365455,
-0.5080991387,
0.4043290019,
-0.2582343519,
0.4753490686,
-0.2448088378,
-0.8308134675,
-0.4225119054,
0.6792642474,
-0.8029358387,
0.0187879335,
0.8551670909,
0.660249114,
-0.1249445006,
0.1751181632,
0.2423241585,
0.3249936998,
0.1480049193,
0.697375536,
1.0941593647,
0.1308319122,
0.2277687192,
-0.0724268556,
-0.2878178358,
0.0542076528,
-1.0516036749,
-0.9925413132,
-0.3541906476,
-0.0636176616,
-0.2647527754,
-0.2353933603,
0.6408931613,
0.6270992756,
-0.8736516833,
-0.3770009577,
-0.3772761226,
0.4182843268,
-0.3082811236,
-0.2217365354,
0.5440309644,
-0.2587520778,
-0.764292717,
0.3667397201,
0.3224417269,
-0.4109286964,
-0.6360884905,
-0.1896921098,
-0.1059473827,
0.1000322551,
0.7785705328,
0.3943529129,
-0.9017154574,
-0.2677528262,
-0.0777537078,
0.0040784944,
0.0231508743,
0.8819412589,
-0.7507137656,
0.3303092122,
0.7147567868,
0.6554288268,
0.4902521074,
-0.0024098489,
0.5614237785,
-0.2895083725,
0.2701008916,
0.3816875517,
0.6587482095,
0.3427494168,
0.0361249633,
0.4444478154,
-0.0397328399,
-0.6570848823,
-0.6716775298,
0.3884360194,
-0.8951510787,
-0.6196606159,
1.1955566406,
-0.1905584037,
-0.291863203,
-0.462325871,
-0.223456502,
0.1245976612,
-0.2752042115,
0.5262111425,
0.827167213,
-0.6830583811,
-0.2201862633,
-0.5209369659,
0.1648074985,
0.3714710474,
-1.1390391588,
0.1936838478,
0.5045170784,
0.0612378456,
0.148110196,
0.4253773093,
-0.1236605793,
0.1566785425,
-0.0601223074,
0.1494820863,
0.031329073,
-0.3562130332,
-0.273566246,
0.2240799665,
0.4174595177,
0.4524753988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11786v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11786v1
|
Construction of Hyper-Relational Knowledge Graphs Using Pre-Trained Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T13:44:48 | 2024-03-18T13:44:48 |
Preetha Datta, Fedor Vitiugin, Anastasiia Chizhikova, Nitin Sawhney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Extracting hyper-relations is crucial for constructing comprehensive
knowledge graphs, but there are limited supervised methods available for this
task. To address this gap, we introduce a zero-shot prompt-based method using
OpenAI's GPT-3.5 model for extracting hyper-relational knowledge from text.
Comparing our model with a baseline, we achieved promising results, with a
recall of 0.77. Although our precision is currently lower, a detailed analysis
of the model outputs has uncovered potential pathways for future research in
this area.
|
[
-0.2092473656,
-1.1940944195,
0.9971739054,
-0.2424305826,
-0.0977851301,
-0.5574787855,
-0.0712347552,
-0.4666089416,
0.1178041622,
0.5904435515,
-0.5527021289,
-0.6537091136,
-0.5413841605,
0.1146482155,
-0.2013142854,
1.1578614712,
0.0563403405,
-0.5214524269,
-0.0268483311,
0.1422184855,
-0.4300309718,
-0.5575022101,
-0.2390594184,
-0.2178519964,
0.7093412876,
0.3622778952,
0.8158780336,
0.8539404869,
0.2481882572,
0.1999109089,
-0.0454805791,
-0.0403180234,
-0.3898491859,
0.1802212894,
-0.1995100379,
-0.1990808249,
-0.5171173811,
0.1940015703,
0.7834662199,
0.6687982082,
0.2647947073,
0.2226780355,
-0.1669126153,
0.4265706241,
-0.7844011188,
0.6600691676,
-0.5569751263,
0.010225174,
-0.3634893596,
-0.2163977623,
-0.5651970506,
-0.296536088,
0.230721578,
-1.0467325449,
0.0253296252,
-0.0800267383,
1.3693629503,
-0.1450481862,
-0.5066438317,
0.0407481156,
-0.9979558587,
0.634069562,
-0.5218164325,
0.2729838192,
0.5722955465,
0.4949846268,
0.0835012645,
-0.8916448951,
-0.8918673992,
-0.1401143521,
-0.19633919,
0.1086102277,
-0.060780216,
-0.0347319283,
0.6001145244,
0.2649782896,
-0.7031903267,
-0.1430037618,
-0.1112713069,
0.0845426098,
0.2642575502,
0.2751150131,
0.4876614809,
-0.5130252242,
-0.1219810173,
0.1468703002,
-0.9220048785,
-0.5358523726,
0.1544170231,
0.6203566194,
0.1647336334,
0.7949861288,
-0.4197529852,
0.9897313118,
-0.456148982,
-0.2927391231,
0.1096422747,
-0.4156764746,
-0.2730801702,
-0.1591749042,
1.1929748058,
0.1536711901,
0.8196147084,
-0.1772997081,
0.0435239933,
-0.1994335502,
-0.2730364501,
-0.8260458112,
-0.2339852452,
-0.1066066623,
-0.3306012154,
-0.2931362391,
-0.1494261175,
-0.5103232861,
-0.0830443427,
-0.3123982549,
0.447647959,
-0.5730631948,
-0.3265483081,
-0.1849015057,
-0.1472920924,
0.2337245047,
0.2386807054,
-0.7503933907,
0.0513427891,
0.3624968231,
0.9551023841,
0.1797628999,
-0.4258161187,
-0.4355011582,
0.8324984908,
-0.2096354067,
0.6062494516,
-0.5661013126,
-0.0833608285,
0.1830667257,
-0.164478898,
0.0051329308,
-0.2021281272,
0.2839584053,
-0.644608736,
0.4700101614,
-0.4699188471,
-0.7597615123,
0.0512764119,
0.5432936549,
-0.6560614109,
0.8713464737,
0.34861359,
-1.0930680037,
0.2507237196,
-0.6626189947,
-0.3923348486,
0.4233887792,
-0.2023532093,
-0.1468591839,
-0.5231667161,
0.6117532253,
0.6125317812,
-0.4783815742,
0.3173860908,
-0.3875490427,
-0.3706225157,
-0.1208495423,
-0.2279558629,
1.0562263727,
0.0352250226,
-0.2419289052,
-0.1147673726,
-0.7322031856,
-0.0589701347,
0.3863334358,
-0.1001345366,
-0.5510605574,
-0.3169424236,
-0.2541363537,
0.2375422567,
0.1958990395,
-0.7322344184,
0.4598816335,
-0.4689666331,
0.1515122652,
0.4733470082,
0.4128039479,
0.153770268,
0.1722443551,
0.4105187356,
0.0464430191,
-0.0107945306,
-0.5122365355,
-0.718467772,
-0.4881524742,
-0.0948329866,
0.3076868951,
0.6265794635,
-1.1951237917,
0.5754842162,
-0.3141371012,
-0.5117653608,
-0.059265025,
0.1318494529,
0.5649990439,
0.8823557496,
0.4676175714,
0.0180993453,
-0.2562777102,
-0.5343196392,
-0.2028537542,
-0.4899815023,
0.0671899766,
0.2652564943,
0.6054108739,
-0.0894433707,
1.0468479395,
-1.112896204,
-0.3528000712,
-0.4067652524,
0.324380964,
0.3228012025,
0.3653297722,
0.6140241027,
-0.383351773,
-0.7244842052,
0.2237102836,
-1.4025323391,
0.252440989,
0.1787789315,
-0.3630586267,
-0.0373506695,
0.5914555788,
-1.2066059113,
0.5528811216,
-0.0157735273,
-0.2578445673,
0.8676984906,
0.1734644026,
-0.0450434722,
-1.2024476528,
0.3650396764,
0.3478247225,
-0.246475935,
-0.7571903467,
0.0705272928,
0.0130240042,
-0.4588336647,
-0.3781107962,
0.7174070477,
-0.4721888602,
0.0529351532,
-0.059634909,
0.1847797632,
-0.2713476121,
0.6733164787,
0.3296071589,
0.5421898961,
0.5506068468,
-0.5882893801,
0.3511250317,
0.5425305963,
-0.2076435834,
0.4158801436,
-0.8043262362,
0.148880139,
-0.1494364738,
0.1433200687,
-0.80947119,
-0.4109276235,
0.3755656481,
-0.6140888333,
0.2262430936,
-0.5705806017,
-0.6460695267,
-0.4805113971,
0.0640744492,
0.3474029303,
0.4757029116,
-0.2699008286,
0.2751394212,
0.3019248545,
-0.3741546571,
-0.6382371783,
-0.2220496982,
-0.0394361839,
0.1574873328,
-0.3482072651,
-0.0833590403,
0.3488939404,
-0.0340886787,
0.1327204555,
0.2880990207,
-0.2859335244,
-0.1940767616,
0.1269710362,
0.4153918028,
-0.3688156605,
0.2532873452,
-0.1790766865,
-0.2889145315,
0.0973964632,
-0.4752461612,
0.4936281741,
0.0925987884,
-0.1925213337,
-0.713085413,
0.2306681126,
0.6069452763,
-0.4569424987,
0.890342474,
0.529815197,
-0.6200833917,
0.2840626538,
-0.2602249384,
0.0257644989,
-0.4024215937,
0.2385047078,
-0.3975872397,
-0.8407744169,
0.2329865694,
0.041225113,
-0.1408487707,
0.5853968859,
0.493799597,
0.0819848701,
1.0898253918,
0.7487308979,
-0.2849622965,
0.4497220218,
-0.1774392724,
0.2720655203,
-0.5002343059,
-0.1367998719,
-0.7089599967,
0.3239177167,
-0.3816358447,
0.1484064609,
0.4713667631,
0.0142747881,
-0.6623883843,
0.4194341898,
-0.2011766583,
0.6609647274,
0.7021641731,
0.1871825904,
0.5005604625,
0.0687179565,
-0.0488913916,
0.0367740951,
-0.5743877292,
-0.3084505796,
1.1728016138,
0.1252806038,
0.4219787717,
-0.0373903401,
0.6705806255,
-0.1377263814,
0.325168401,
-0.8013985157,
0.5952589512,
0.2445114553,
-0.7690310478,
-0.7740314603,
-0.9076990485,
-1.0426105261,
-0.1296960562,
-0.1945270747,
-0.9436097741,
-0.3235127628,
0.1282198876,
-0.4022776783,
0.4128586948,
-0.7031690478,
1.0489370823,
0.2421957552,
-0.2897194326,
0.4493457377,
-0.8280746341,
0.6424061656,
0.1494770348,
-0.0401747935,
-0.0642228201,
0.3824449778,
0.9333116412,
-0.5801557899,
0.645760119,
-0.5944455266,
0.098844476,
0.493493855,
0.2562668622,
0.4783580601,
-0.0721087903,
0.129202038,
-0.2005330622,
-0.1318123937,
-0.5639551282,
-0.782011807,
0.5233801007,
-0.9986373782,
-0.3607397377,
-0.3482505977,
-0.7255564332,
-0.532736063,
0.7183986902,
0.1270997524,
0.5188617706,
-0.232674703,
-0.1303517669,
0.6082223058,
-0.2329814583,
0.5117672086,
0.3709120452,
-0.3759631515,
-0.2920684218,
0.956314981,
0.3431060016,
0.0864354745,
0.5254660249,
0.2517511845,
-0.3141091764,
-0.3399781883,
-0.521702528,
0.5356451273,
-0.5415391326,
-0.425570935,
-0.8770145178,
-0.289055109,
-0.7223241925,
0.1382638812,
-0.1322135925,
-0.3876119554,
-0.1883356273,
-0.1918498129,
0.5184981227,
1.0310133696,
0.2574923337,
0.5920093656,
-1.170891881,
0.3740565479,
0.554125905,
0.2671720982,
0.1459610462,
-0.1775716245,
-0.3892007768,
-0.1776986122,
-0.2336380184,
-1.2194424868,
0.5143555999,
0.0096323332,
0.4052439928,
0.3909536004,
0.0620027445,
0.615444839,
-0.2839413881,
0.9207057953,
0.3184271157,
-0.8654758334,
0.9037545323,
-0.9520107508,
0.4685582221,
0.3969677985,
1.0815050602,
-0.2390336692,
-0.0909120217,
-0.7154865861,
-0.6786337495,
0.6705248356,
0.2808584571,
-0.0823098943,
-0.3029151261,
0.5008493066,
-0.2577196956,
0.0160916373,
-0.7810990214,
-0.2314396948,
-0.0862689167,
-0.2043272108,
-0.0749291852,
-0.3407058716,
-0.0230032932,
-0.482754916,
0.6567342877,
-0.2356678993,
0.3345000446,
0.1369129717,
-0.2809840739,
-0.0379549526,
0.1017395481,
-0.0241896752,
0.7904245257,
-0.3133705258,
0.0573481657,
-0.1240348741,
-0.52187711,
0.1763495803,
0.1123857573,
-0.4217087328,
-0.135055691,
0.5285781026,
0.6180119514,
-0.135170415,
-0.2882504463,
0.9069080949,
0.0703923404,
-0.1236597225,
0.0604733862,
-0.3710080981,
0.0980823562,
-0.1464944482,
0.1624483466,
-0.445712477,
-0.0458161011,
-0.77363199,
0.3192242384,
0.0205626599,
-0.6852831244,
-0.3546667397,
0.5102655292,
0.0230426826,
0.0600731075,
1.2545765638,
-0.230339393,
-0.4010841548,
0.2240723372,
0.8701150417,
0.6965586543,
-0.1177053675,
0.4552696347,
0.6488125324,
0.1144107878,
0.1073403284,
0.2470004112,
-0.0429126844,
-0.7277507186,
-0.8341548443,
-0.5082202554,
-0.3572636545,
0.0880851299,
-0.6413955092,
0.1105605215,
-0.4733818173,
-0.0212624706,
0.2032871991,
0.1001085937,
-0.7353859544,
0.2951881588,
-0.1622719169,
0.7484879494,
-1.1089869738,
1.1544651985,
0.4838517904,
-0.9181883335,
-1.1137983799,
0.0698018819,
-0.1823254377,
-0.7710562944,
0.691818893,
0.0877795368,
0.2013218254,
0.2513791323,
-0.8331521153,
-0.6879817247,
0.98536098,
0.5392689109,
-0.3500295579,
-0.3007904887,
0.1305224448,
0.4602844119,
-0.1462787837,
0.6185854673,
0.5749666095,
0.4880734682,
0.175102964,
-0.8469337821,
0.2344065309,
-0.3421906233,
-0.1325728148,
0.3379986286,
-0.2476943135,
0.9709774256,
-0.0556887425,
-0.211421594,
-0.0283048134,
0.8895941973,
0.1839547455,
0.0762433112,
0.1276129931,
0.7904062867,
0.7438858747,
0.0750957206,
1.229937315,
-0.1749511957,
0.3347904384,
1.3047524691,
-0.4907388985,
0.7166013718,
0.1779028177,
-0.0503169969,
0.5895193219,
0.2741541266,
0.2637204528,
0.3213061094,
-0.2637098432,
-0.1168957278,
-0.4029310346,
-0.3442990184,
-0.5160956979,
0.2751907408,
0.285589397,
-0.3488082886,
-0.346740067,
-0.2616764605,
0.4263844192,
-0.2134397924,
-0.2852017879,
0.8976768851,
-0.0803869441,
-0.705106616,
0.4778081477,
-0.1974338442,
0.1943962574,
-0.5664036274,
-0.2334934026,
-0.0817805976,
-0.0607245602,
-0.0176474601,
-1.0367577076,
0.1058107242,
0.0846213475,
-0.0902426317,
0.0163602997,
1.1019181013,
-0.3756377697,
-0.3170282245,
0.1393049359,
1.1472251415,
0.1972512901,
-0.4990369081,
-0.2989656329,
-0.3511430323,
-0.1727632284,
-0.380115658,
0.3091514111,
0.7601774335,
-0.1166722998,
0.2799755633,
0.7309289575,
-0.0498257689,
-0.0841310769,
0.0968297496,
0.9527111053,
-1.0099269152,
-0.3240021467,
-1.049731493,
0.1960509717,
-0.1691194326,
-0.4247362614,
0.841113925,
0.443634063,
0.7544705868,
-0.1335092187,
1.0892202854,
-0.1368702501,
0.5186282396,
-0.3592209518,
0.7851229906,
-0.2163606435,
-0.3176999986,
-0.7108365297,
-0.9745396376,
-0.5157892108,
0.2962363064,
-0.3826027215,
-0.0019677246,
0.8115110397,
0.7682144642,
-0.0992744789,
0.085218899,
0.3763281703,
0.2068668157,
0.28681916,
0.6679372787,
0.8170294762,
-0.5171256065,
0.7779077291,
-0.1105563045,
-0.4228619039,
0.2779999375,
-0.8314753175,
-1.0789145231,
-0.521147728,
-0.1796296686,
-0.3374049366,
0.1338631511,
0.6771512032,
0.7596850395,
-0.4570561945,
-0.1117944345,
-0.1395636499,
0.2206085026,
-0.0349795409,
-0.235723421,
0.5568024516,
-0.3303425014,
-0.4033960998,
0.1529391855,
0.1397556961,
0.2646230757,
-0.0176582858,
-0.0731220245,
-0.5759002566,
-0.1388535798,
0.7607812881,
0.5175192356,
-0.0709112212,
-0.3611350656,
0.0456074625,
-0.1016410291,
-0.0890934989,
0.8536996245,
-0.9082458019,
0.2780241668,
0.6591523886,
0.4438673258,
0.8851422668,
-0.0794586241,
0.7514606714,
-0.937435925,
0.0579195097,
0.0445754603,
0.2320795953,
0.2254429758,
-0.3336583078,
0.4520400763,
0.6463159323,
-0.4716655314,
-0.6475870609,
0.3738565147,
-0.7967919111,
-0.1693086773,
1.2056269646,
-0.4494576156,
-0.4584896863,
-0.290599227,
-0.1085002944,
0.546096921,
-0.2064930946,
0.3068908453,
0.5176592469,
-0.0370221883,
-0.0948266163,
-0.4817414284,
0.3739816844,
-0.0122491103,
-1.004029274,
0.2113666683,
0.4290418625,
0.0926975608,
0.1957523823,
1.0889012814,
-0.3473774791,
0.1520878524,
0.1221539006,
0.0463051386,
-0.3254255652,
-0.8023583889,
0.2218473554,
0.4990904331,
0.1048287749,
0.1603082418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11771v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11771v1
|
Modality-Agnostic fMRI Decoding of Vision and Language
| 2024-03-18T13:30:03 | 2024-03-18T13:30:03 |
Mitja Nikolaus, Milad Mozafari, Nicholas Asher, Leila Reddy, Rufin VanRullen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Previous studies have shown that it is possible to map brain activation data
of subjects viewing images onto the feature representation space of not only
vision models (modality-specific decoding) but also language models
(cross-modal decoding). In this work, we introduce and use a new large-scale
fMRI dataset (~8,500 trials per subject) of people watching both images and
text descriptions of such images. This novel dataset enables the development of
modality-agnostic decoders: a single decoder that can predict which stimulus a
subject is seeing, irrespective of the modality (image or text) in which the
stimulus is presented. We train and evaluate such decoders to map brain signals
onto stimulus representations from a large range of publicly available vision,
language and multimodal (vision+language) models. Our findings reveal that (1)
modality-agnostic decoders perform as well as (and sometimes even better than)
modality-specific decoders (2) modality-agnostic decoders mapping brain data
onto representations from unimodal models perform as well as decoders relying
on multimodal representations (3) while language and low-level visual
(occipital) brain regions are best at decoding text and image stimuli,
respectively, high-level visual (temporal) regions perform well on both
stimulus types.
|
[
-0.3341656923,
-0.459048003,
0.5784764886,
0.2357399613,
-0.4130189717,
-0.3643252552,
-0.2308499366,
-0.5283076167,
0.2354490906,
0.0383846574,
-0.3139609993,
-0.1073767021,
-0.5422729254,
0.2397849858,
-0.2471692413,
0.45524773,
0.0414757356,
0.5655247569,
-0.2164649367,
-0.2588742077,
-0.2244138271,
-0.649692893,
-0.4853667617,
-0.2737374604,
0.5587462187,
-0.4117141962,
0.6897702217,
0.5334562659,
0.4208260179,
0.2032165378,
0.0525485203,
0.0407053046,
-0.2200775146,
-0.2649939656,
-0.2532251477,
-0.3808918595,
-0.3716287017,
-0.0503881611,
0.5255919099,
0.8096067309,
-0.0076054749,
0.0747715086,
0.0457131937,
0.3652723432,
-0.756986618,
0.3329445422,
-0.4483681917,
0.1693775952,
0.0217514336,
-0.5841057301,
-0.5921536684,
0.0256589092,
0.0227954779,
-0.6488695741,
0.0758283958,
-0.0166507065,
0.7326020598,
0.2042097449,
-0.7643808126,
-0.1966292262,
-0.6610773802,
0.6692920327,
-0.2612277567,
0.7707697749,
0.5967100263,
0.1841123104,
0.1064102948,
-0.257956624,
-0.6060092449,
-0.1232677922,
-0.3087336123,
0.3118090034,
-0.2275060564,
0.0564787127,
0.2256775945,
0.5272381306,
-0.4121043682,
-0.3479027152,
-0.3567847311,
-0.2480021864,
0.4219995439,
0.2186389416,
0.2212460041,
-0.1044617072,
-0.5498968363,
0.011011553,
-0.3211644888,
-0.0047376156,
0.1623908281,
-0.1183309034,
-0.0599743091,
0.6149321198,
-0.0560564995,
1.0006848574,
0.1124609113,
-0.0855456963,
0.4865352809,
-0.4170922935,
-0.2834126949,
-0.1545517594,
0.7146256566,
0.3985669017,
0.1836826354,
-0.4327709079,
-0.4306269288,
0.7647650242,
-0.0028929145,
-0.5302165747,
-0.2048055381,
-0.1440606862,
-0.8629224896,
-0.1841291785,
-0.1041209623,
-0.3764777184,
-0.5807247162,
-0.3668961227,
0.6621624231,
-0.5967535973,
-0.5325421095,
0.5248295069,
-0.1078767553,
0.3761219978,
0.2614498734,
-1.0027769804,
0.1371529549,
0.1713311374,
0.5174934268,
-0.0572927296,
-0.3990586996,
-0.3995656669,
0.2526244819,
-0.2586064935,
0.8727183342,
-0.7959355712,
-0.2499129027,
-0.1691841185,
0.1046924368,
-0.3261747062,
-0.3509812057,
0.4523974359,
-0.6032200456,
0.3141877055,
-0.4498131573,
-0.2272788584,
-0.4227384031,
0.2588864863,
-0.9058511257,
0.427182436,
0.2581459582,
-0.5912767053,
0.4266022146,
-0.7566803098,
-0.6783375144,
-0.072657451,
-0.7396029234,
0.0285361912,
0.5451577902,
0.2010487169,
0.3749608994,
-0.4703691304,
0.3011474907,
-0.1290554702,
-0.3664455116,
0.636151433,
-0.7313591242,
0.6508344412,
0.3196022809,
-0.2280247509,
-0.1032986268,
-0.7094469666,
0.0097637428,
0.1890433878,
-0.6774801016,
-0.3872012496,
0.2202086896,
0.3695824146,
0.3053025007,
0.0631458014,
-0.7307730913,
0.0389560461,
0.0286725257,
0.6287494302,
0.4331352413,
-0.2284301519,
0.3501087725,
-0.3502790034,
0.3041136563,
0.4276154637,
0.173166424,
-0.5630102158,
-0.420458734,
-0.6008458734,
-0.5937975645,
0.2032668144,
0.3592279851,
-0.9559725523,
0.2837288082,
-0.6448096633,
0.210411787,
-0.6953166127,
-0.387223959,
0.3208621144,
0.4212423563,
0.3448802233,
-0.4709424973,
-0.3699514568,
-1.0472378731,
-0.2327594608,
-0.185030371,
-0.3311302662,
0.2716225386,
0.3197221458,
-0.4277579486,
0.7659104466,
-0.3232694566,
-0.6040816903,
-0.0493532903,
0.1960667819,
-0.0791623667,
0.2541092038,
0.6763973236,
-1.0644427538,
-0.121922642,
0.2733957767,
-0.7466621995,
0.3459150195,
-0.3055036366,
0.2004410028,
0.3368099332,
0.3756548166,
-0.0303732213,
0.4860821366,
0.5128097534,
-0.8411064744,
0.0413865075,
-0.1194000915,
0.5097137094,
-1.0440745354,
0.4691152275,
-0.0291434396,
-0.3189630806,
-0.5669946671,
-0.2184342444,
0.260728538,
0.0856976584,
0.0184368417,
0.356012851,
-0.7379800081,
-0.0906328857,
-0.2147777975,
-0.393108964,
0.0494718365,
0.6916540861,
0.4977862239,
0.6665053368,
0.9476439357,
-0.1678302884,
0.1026819944,
0.3276649415,
-0.4374906421,
0.5260953903,
-0.4455996752,
-0.1098450348,
-0.5601904392,
0.0634885877,
-0.9786559939,
-0.4427495301,
0.2411950529,
-0.482586056,
0.2461817861,
0.1104108393,
-0.2133155614,
-0.073308304,
-0.0276637487,
0.8707683086,
0.4497092962,
-0.4006526172,
1.1562398672,
0.3920440674,
0.3792426288,
-0.4969149232,
-1.2168086767,
0.0251285359,
0.2969744802,
-0.367921114,
0.1194237769,
0.0214806702,
0.1988506466,
0.3260191977,
-0.1233346984,
-0.2426930368,
-0.1069035158,
0.4302476048,
0.1436932087,
-0.2211343348,
-0.1093688309,
-0.3395161629,
-0.1118951663,
0.1643539369,
-0.0147452336,
0.4733074605,
-0.1505011618,
-0.5989322066,
-0.2344529033,
0.6711975932,
0.8172544837,
-0.4512642622,
0.4626874626,
0.7027065754,
-0.5369061232,
0.2813385129,
-0.3790106177,
-0.140954569,
-0.4425701201,
0.4772130549,
-0.6057289243,
-0.8313625455,
0.4527121782,
0.067551218,
-0.4104805589,
0.1222344637,
0.5746305585,
0.2129607946,
1.2421989441,
0.7507842779,
0.0019175902,
0.5148648024,
-0.2625434399,
0.2209068686,
-1.0254940987,
-0.4342654347,
0.113560386,
-0.5030115247,
0.1661859006,
-0.523286283,
0.4800290763,
-0.3945548236,
0.1777040213,
-0.1018192396,
-0.4620553255,
0.7182623148,
0.3935548365,
0.4200520515,
0.4826571643,
0.4173671305,
-0.2310460955,
-0.0142977331,
-0.6320224404,
-0.1520692408,
1.1516907215,
0.2209624201,
0.9667587876,
-0.0870942175,
0.0727959871,
0.2995189726,
0.3886021078,
-1.0482165813,
0.6392538548,
-0.186918214,
-0.8253696561,
0.1318839937,
-0.3533253372,
-0.8077617288,
0.3274337649,
-0.4777489603,
-0.3842539191,
0.9256930947,
0.0845249668,
-0.2659431696,
0.282399416,
-0.6462651491,
0.7022765875,
-0.1975297183,
-0.0581699498,
-0.2855436802,
-0.5576280355,
0.371238023,
-0.0327820964,
0.1064446718,
0.0529965162,
-0.2874421477,
0.3342992365,
0.2149755806,
0.7890222669,
0.0003389148,
-0.0984904021,
-0.1368805468,
0.0824597925,
-0.1593292803,
-0.0017632807,
-0.0071349903,
0.3261143565,
0.0591389984,
-0.4020044208,
-0.4950422347,
0.5386448503,
-0.8661984205,
-0.304340899,
-0.7068719864,
-0.6304626465,
-0.2292860597,
0.3172913492,
0.526366055,
0.9764349461,
-0.2353353202,
0.3440538645,
0.648188889,
0.2206457108,
0.4162160456,
0.6267333031,
-0.1570328474,
-0.7155862451,
0.8399063945,
-0.0940672159,
0.1968130767,
0.5516536236,
-0.2944850624,
-0.237208426,
-0.6834813356,
-0.4239761829,
0.1759837568,
-0.7927441001,
-0.1743119359,
-0.5798341632,
-0.0837171078,
-0.0248071663,
-0.1291375607,
-0.1628402919,
-0.2295971364,
-0.1826005876,
0.1477298588,
0.0369453095,
0.3813664913,
-0.1104373187,
-0.0015070043,
-0.5377386808,
0.7055818439,
0.3768451214,
0.5844896436,
-0.0493432134,
-0.2373830974,
-0.4159463048,
0.2060495168,
0.1170057133,
-0.8707950115,
0.1893628836,
0.395437479,
0.5330885053,
0.6623573899,
0.0075244792,
0.4121218026,
-0.4734122455,
0.6440185308,
0.6057704091,
-0.7728129625,
0.2281864434,
-0.4374879003,
0.556163609,
0.5303451419,
0.4905323684,
-0.5128721595,
-0.016521344,
-0.0923737064,
-0.5144480467,
0.7888084054,
0.1425513029,
0.1859456748,
-0.1770662963,
0.2761415243,
0.2264245749,
0.090535678,
-0.9150435328,
-0.1779767126,
-0.4707645774,
-0.3912650943,
-0.1585059613,
-0.1947359443,
-0.6393765807,
-0.3794368505,
-0.0192819405,
-0.4292201698,
0.8649597764,
0.4354487956,
-0.1922891885,
-0.3487654328,
0.2294112444,
0.4819186926,
0.6635172963,
-0.0312994793,
0.4021633267,
-0.0775137693,
-0.8097598553,
0.2582496405,
0.0913537219,
-0.1292271763,
0.0483966358,
0.1987258196,
1.0303326845,
0.0135030877,
-0.7344004512,
0.7578594685,
-0.475052774,
-0.3499373198,
-0.2147727162,
-0.018883992,
-0.0400344767,
0.320782423,
0.5844220519,
0.5889989138,
0.3703638017,
-0.7546411753,
0.0348073877,
0.5160177946,
-0.3801753819,
-0.7251630425,
0.8587726951,
0.1463629454,
0.0807253271,
0.2308316231,
0.0712351948,
-0.2413084656,
0.1759291589,
0.634847641,
1.0102791786,
-0.0860184953,
0.0312478151,
0.1877378076,
0.240472883,
-0.2142918855,
0.7644569278,
-0.2474312931,
-0.9609658718,
-0.353459388,
-0.6692944169,
-0.1096196845,
0.2185027599,
-0.9151019454,
0.0416363813,
-0.3386853635,
-0.4166847765,
0.1625795215,
-0.536164701,
-0.6139397025,
0.3861660063,
0.5043160915,
0.7817793489,
-0.932448566,
1.0108270645,
1.2386658192,
-0.2832512856,
-0.440877825,
0.1226628423,
-0.3352090716,
-0.7525500059,
0.3520011008,
0.2373865098,
-0.4102359712,
0.2024075538,
-0.2895396948,
-0.7771975994,
1.104368329,
0.5681104064,
-0.295032382,
-0.1753840744,
0.2579941452,
0.4174679816,
-0.6197652817,
0.2021210492,
0.2956331372,
0.3915042281,
0.0945204347,
-0.7475670576,
0.2877524495,
-0.5772773623,
0.2081291527,
0.1745683253,
-0.5361620188,
0.7377227545,
0.0674673989,
-0.4958717525,
-0.1312213391,
0.5160267353,
-0.1798882186,
0.2434006482,
0.616743803,
0.3994953334,
0.2437580973,
-0.1634781212,
0.9173932672,
-0.4538092613,
0.1594064683,
0.651679039,
0.0526607074,
0.7142058015,
0.6526125669,
0.2085944712,
0.2727060616,
0.2500505447,
0.0476740412,
0.7963006496,
-0.3662583828,
-0.3131226599,
-0.8033264875,
-0.1577406228,
-0.4144264758,
0.413185358,
0.2545380592,
-0.5473929048,
-0.2676168084,
0.5031090379,
-0.2722613811,
0.0713794604,
-0.2956238687,
0.6285347342,
0.0217164047,
-0.4329627752,
1.0398486853,
-0.1078357473,
0.7561839819,
-0.7622733712,
0.1791686565,
-0.0037285842,
0.2342550009,
-0.1496718973,
-0.6699676514,
0.2997250259,
-0.1637274623,
-0.4738517702,
-0.216645062,
0.6732309461,
-0.5413206816,
-0.3505300879,
0.3215845227,
0.3291943371,
-0.1225329936,
-0.0658333823,
-0.3232223988,
0.3409868777,
-0.0033648047,
-0.3752181232,
0.3846957386,
0.3650701344,
-0.0288709775,
0.530931294,
0.3570228815,
-0.201614663,
-0.0443074293,
-0.1987808347,
1.2237634659,
-0.9163284302,
-0.5038662553,
-0.6601079106,
0.4839243889,
0.163632676,
-0.303886354,
0.4232590795,
0.6105378866,
0.7426176667,
-0.4273995459,
0.7248913646,
-0.2587348521,
-0.0067561455,
-0.4789342284,
0.6529481411,
-0.9177040458,
-0.198375389,
0.1809676141,
-0.7060948014,
-0.4383455813,
0.744042635,
-0.3776268363,
-0.0860979334,
0.8800989389,
0.641053617,
-0.4162658155,
0.2459295988,
0.494248718,
0.0345788598,
-0.0240180474,
0.7386094928,
0.9291775227,
-0.3029529154,
0.535587132,
0.1744888276,
-0.3469237387,
-0.3019636273,
-0.6797896624,
-0.8967188001,
-0.8463619947,
-0.2337254435,
-0.0973657444,
-0.2486893237,
0.6464444399,
0.5824645758,
-0.6870306134,
-0.119451493,
0.1800876707,
-0.5021109581,
-0.3191938698,
-0.1292021126,
0.1014965102,
-0.096593447,
-0.5476092696,
0.4758013785,
0.4884943962,
0.0113656046,
-0.498357445,
-0.049631197,
-0.0825659335,
0.2816125453,
0.6154498458,
0.2513173223,
-0.6674275398,
-0.180072844,
0.3345722258,
-0.274730891,
0.2464927584,
1.0251380205,
-1.0000455379,
0.5453956723,
0.7299313545,
0.5423339009,
0.3535633683,
-0.2187036574,
0.572755754,
-0.2131159306,
0.3484013081,
0.3325963318,
0.4756755233,
0.2848165929,
-0.2397352606,
0.4513034523,
0.2450031638,
-0.2687006593,
-0.786488831,
0.5514903665,
-1.3968365192,
-0.3302773535,
1.2020713091,
-0.093023099,
-0.6324659586,
-0.191239804,
-0.3311087489,
-0.140820384,
-0.2316621393,
0.7826708555,
0.6097559929,
-0.0189576782,
-0.0376968831,
-0.1242602617,
0.4057142735,
0.5119529366,
-0.4396631718,
0.014658805,
0.9384000897,
0.3322266042,
0.2131888121,
0.7653939128,
-0.3223245144,
0.5733750463,
-0.0285614878,
-0.0704991147,
-0.3555537462,
-0.3855853081,
-0.6920149326,
0.3233878016,
-0.1942710727,
-0.3052583039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11752v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11752v2
|
Revisiting The Classics: A Study on Identifying and Rectifying Gender Stereotypes in Rhymes and Poems
| 2024-03-18T13:02:02 | 2024-03-25T16:33:12 |
Aditya Narayan Sankaran, Vigneshwaran Shankaran, Sampath Lonka, Rajesh Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rhymes and poems are a powerful medium for transmitting cultural norms and
societal roles. However, the pervasive existence of gender stereotypes in these
works perpetuates biased perceptions and limits the scope of individuals'
identities. Past works have shown that stereotyping and prejudice emerge in
early childhood, and developmental research on causal mechanisms is critical
for understanding and controlling stereotyping and prejudice. This work
contributes by gathering a dataset of rhymes and poems to identify gender
stereotypes and propose a model with 97% accuracy to identify gender bias.
Gender stereotypes were rectified using a Large Language Model (LLM) and its
effectiveness was evaluated in a comparative survey against human educator
rectifications. To summarize, this work highlights the pervasive nature of
gender stereotypes in literary works and reveals the potential of LLMs to
rectify gender stereotypes. This study raises awareness and promotes
inclusivity within artistic expressions, making a significant contribution to
the discourse on gender equality.
|
[
0.0011223891,
-0.2794568837,
0.2263273001,
0.1225229129,
-0.0435943417,
0.1249963269,
0.0434558466,
-0.4307011068,
0.2843696177,
0.5961146355,
-0.516636312,
-0.2640916109,
-0.8901997209,
0.2703106999,
-0.7151526809,
0.7346302867,
-0.0624642037,
0.099748835,
-0.2531873286,
0.0621893816,
-0.8644285798,
-0.4247314334,
-0.3742563426,
-0.3236062229,
0.562498033,
0.3195260465,
0.2050304562,
0.1818290353,
0.3302558661,
0.3404545188,
-0.3158475459,
-0.0173997954,
-0.931653142,
0.886606276,
-0.07430733,
-0.7201256752,
-0.0085807573,
0.4365347028,
0.7593286037,
0.6230137348,
0.0458478779,
0.2690202892,
0.156408295,
0.9505988359,
-0.3999925554,
0.1161299869,
-0.7873526812,
0.2464050651,
-0.5063983202,
-0.197388649,
-0.1164322793,
-0.6569085121,
-0.1064243317,
-0.2780721188,
0.6493633389,
0.1367378682,
0.9473151565,
-0.2593026757,
-0.5238475204,
-0.4603666961,
-0.7523953915,
0.9315761924,
-0.325266093,
0.2586931288,
-0.0061555076,
0.2666083872,
-0.2304960936,
-0.8353586793,
-0.3297629058,
-0.2484026104,
-0.1526792645,
-0.1651251763,
-0.4948308766,
-0.6400969028,
0.3975303769,
0.4693494737,
-0.3479217887,
-0.4360093772,
-0.654714644,
-0.0880124643,
0.4059921205,
0.0767008439,
0.7865765691,
-0.281529218,
-0.1994731575,
0.2065770328,
-0.7409074306,
0.186186254,
0.6581884027,
0.3466894329,
0.1267040074,
0.574714303,
0.0431464575,
0.3623762727,
0.0752315,
-0.2454829812,
0.5392552018,
-0.0784760565,
0.2157651037,
0.0801430419,
0.3824992776,
0.369620651,
0.7585524321,
-0.2742259502,
-0.1167977378,
-0.0040528532,
0.4648063779,
-0.3182909191,
-0.1221645251,
-0.2648411095,
-0.4177970886,
-0.3127168715,
-0.0392750204,
-0.6136608124,
-0.6733596325,
-0.3115694821,
0.1318985969,
-0.4497638345,
-0.191206798,
0.1633668244,
-0.7034473419,
0.1204932556,
0.3144895136,
-0.6984280348,
-0.2008583248,
0.853012085,
0.8515722752,
0.58137393,
-0.2034599632,
0.121583879,
0.0534931906,
-0.5973625183,
0.3363915682,
-0.4457334578,
-0.3223668933,
-0.0571024083,
0.3779441118,
-0.0622330643,
-0.455994159,
0.8672073483,
-0.1399147362,
0.0826538056,
-0.2336923033,
-0.2496979684,
-0.1284146011,
0.2131861597,
-0.8102651238,
0.6576933861,
-0.0427566841,
-1.1145570278,
0.281837672,
0.0505194031,
0.0255811904,
-0.34246099,
-0.3431306779,
-0.353499651,
0.3469992876,
0.0937829167,
0.1296131909,
-0.3893075883,
0.1046783999,
-0.1934076399,
-0.4687627256,
0.2330690622,
-0.3302369714,
1.0094943047,
0.3490253687,
-0.175092563,
-0.086755842,
-0.3665466905,
-0.4679365456,
0.5954348445,
0.1312190592,
-0.6658784151,
-0.1760815233,
-0.0336319618,
-0.2512443364,
0.0746993721,
-0.7411537766,
0.2088941336,
-0.3057052791,
0.3968048692,
0.6396613717,
-0.2394995838,
0.1636026651,
-0.8430857658,
0.7268128991,
-0.2776831985,
0.0239891391,
-0.0904911086,
-0.6049917936,
-0.3438073993,
-0.4805748165,
0.253360033,
0.1582857817,
-0.5122901797,
0.1835550964,
-0.3724846244,
-0.5811190605,
-0.8606841564,
0.3135714829,
0.1894787848,
0.4311128557,
-0.1340860128,
-0.6045731902,
-0.7468354702,
-0.9214638472,
-0.7935220003,
-0.3371514082,
0.0817280933,
0.0985894576,
0.2194574922,
0.0013323084,
1.0350857973,
-0.3246795833,
-0.4202598631,
-0.2312102616,
0.4651204646,
0.2416626364,
0.575697422,
0.9011773467,
-0.4575072527,
-0.0067397142,
-0.5075051785,
-0.6414362788,
-0.4341398478,
0.250187695,
-0.2433762252,
-0.2807623446,
0.6543169618,
-0.183055371,
0.3138730228,
0.2364932001,
-0.4342680275,
0.5555215478,
0.2198116481,
0.5343039632,
-0.4467568099,
-0.2060585022,
0.0299844649,
-0.064664863,
-0.3155140281,
0.3820132911,
-0.1750181764,
-0.1062398776,
-0.1100847274,
0.3976114094,
-0.4809258878,
0.1833382398,
-0.0625167936,
-0.0730926692,
0.1891691387,
-0.4840810597,
-0.0387610905,
0.4971746206,
0.4429948032,
-0.0569118224,
0.2504768074,
-0.0378163829,
-0.1018818468,
0.8343094587,
-0.499833554,
0.1985804737,
-0.7885534763,
0.4456823766,
-1.7644705772,
0.1411032975,
0.384327203,
-0.7243792415,
0.2561442554,
-0.60055089,
-0.4520234764,
-0.4691104591,
-0.3624460995,
0.7217543721,
0.6239274144,
-0.4896315932,
0.4314278364,
0.2508704066,
-0.1505068094,
-0.8382469416,
-0.4310073256,
0.0981183425,
-0.3218789995,
-0.5875068307,
-0.3997679949,
0.1502674222,
-0.5288273096,
-0.3635948896,
-0.0388773419,
0.0914803594,
-0.0635794252,
0.3161455691,
-0.0172531698,
0.0176081974,
0.2305736542,
0.0023036103,
-0.0495623499,
-0.0129651986,
-0.007511511,
0.6383303404,
-0.0230944734,
-0.2813694775,
-0.0435954854,
0.2839228809,
0.7114272118,
0.0347033963,
0.3646126986,
0.7402275801,
-0.2591860294,
0.1024134979,
-0.5296031833,
-0.0265233126,
-0.3953796327,
0.1664258391,
-0.3613069952,
-0.5626661777,
0.0332676023,
0.0400239192,
0.0990426689,
0.416529268,
0.1383330971,
-0.6223797202,
0.3204801381,
0.607583344,
-0.1725324988,
0.2943990827,
-0.2126935124,
0.0954335332,
-0.9239467978,
0.1102854088,
-0.909419477,
-0.7976139784,
-0.5828158259,
-0.3878053427,
0.3287749887,
0.0801310614,
-0.4562194049,
-0.0910215527,
-0.5013747811,
0.3007804751,
0.4653289616,
0.139377296,
0.5609993935,
0.1274790615,
0.0647089332,
-0.5169849992,
-0.2955130041,
-0.7645078301,
1.521248579,
0.687757194,
0.6520144343,
0.5224963427,
0.8321170211,
0.3679339886,
0.6212136745,
-0.552857399,
0.4492849112,
-0.5222278833,
-1.0684918165,
-0.1054249853,
-0.2706385851,
-1.2124671936,
0.069492355,
-0.1383173317,
-0.6939009428,
0.4444566369,
0.023684619,
0.2545241117,
0.6656838655,
-0.3147735298,
0.2790430784,
0.2642838657,
-0.118377082,
0.0195283014,
-0.3935859799,
1.0269896984,
0.1362766027,
0.5853564739,
-0.1482034922,
0.088961564,
0.5771971941,
-0.0278273243,
1.1857647896,
0.1911770552,
-0.4193643034,
0.1073648036,
0.4352253079,
0.1064772606,
-0.4069475532,
0.0895002484,
0.2819247842,
-0.0025169104,
-0.5915650129,
-0.1668578237,
0.782984674,
-0.7760291696,
-0.445410341,
-0.5877608657,
-0.7020895481,
0.0587224439,
-0.1858868897,
0.1199466214,
0.3879174888,
-0.0638997257,
0.2003403753,
0.4850353003,
-0.4891808927,
0.1205417588,
0.294716388,
-0.7089290619,
-0.1920407265,
0.2677163482,
0.3577650189,
0.3806597292,
0.0190416556,
0.1815242469,
-0.1689325571,
-0.2156365067,
-0.0954928771,
0.4946135879,
-0.7075825334,
0.2360962033,
-0.4209232032,
-0.1510242671,
-0.7989950776,
-0.2896664441,
-0.3224656582,
-0.2175301462,
0.0084509654,
0.0051061725,
0.6088139415,
0.9077219367,
-0.2323468924,
0.1597801447,
-0.4706439674,
0.4624923468,
0.5211645961,
0.2136388123,
0.4062471688,
-0.7843828797,
0.4148992002,
-0.5366623998,
-0.2204910517,
-1.0711236,
0.2854811251,
-0.2725612223,
0.3103812039,
0.2793354094,
-0.104764618,
0.3490872085,
-0.6452693343,
0.7341099381,
0.417547226,
-0.6458243728,
0.3849069476,
-0.4512450695,
-0.1657675356,
0.2179867476,
0.3011229336,
-0.9106597304,
-0.6121372581,
-0.8079006076,
-1.1435930729,
0.2625238895,
0.2930578589,
0.5901541114,
-0.0987157375,
0.6457611322,
0.2085305154,
0.4402800798,
-0.5821677446,
-0.697134316,
-0.210789606,
-0.1256415397,
-0.3421940506,
-0.3352229893,
-0.2549803555,
-0.3744623065,
0.3334554136,
0.5004568696,
0.0145646753,
0.2236445993,
-0.0477373786,
-0.2258031666,
0.5349528193,
0.155681774,
0.4827497303,
-0.389487803,
0.2699436247,
-0.3062043488,
-0.8281276822,
0.3509788513,
-0.2502840459,
-0.6118530035,
0.353212595,
0.5466644764,
0.4153283834,
-0.0902730599,
-0.4596152902,
0.1367068142,
0.0595927462,
0.1739323288,
-0.6931117773,
0.0488374867,
0.0944016501,
0.4015481174,
0.2248702645,
0.1209308952,
0.1803054214,
-1.2304079533,
0.144617945,
0.5220775008,
-0.4555149078,
0.2040881068,
0.5451931953,
0.0909950659,
-0.2616516352,
0.3291782439,
0.0600719452,
-0.3398664296,
0.7563407421,
0.568228066,
0.9720355868,
0.0571213029,
0.2560615242,
0.7034133673,
0.8000851274,
0.0676536411,
0.0628987625,
0.6337014437,
-0.8588591814,
0.1897013336,
-0.4721893072,
0.0448437259,
-0.0169097744,
-0.4220569134,
0.151128605,
-0.4042415023,
-0.2712247372,
-0.2401568443,
-0.2294834405,
-0.779532671,
-0.0452524014,
0.4613315463,
0.7489396334,
-1.3460255861,
0.3396026492,
0.5459712148,
-0.7523416877,
-0.5686135292,
0.4027291834,
0.4449166954,
-0.6187047362,
1.175386548,
-0.1762336046,
-0.2727086544,
0.221231997,
-0.6564080119,
-0.6236948371,
1.0207585096,
0.2717480958,
-0.9017425776,
0.2512807846,
-0.2490298003,
0.4647364914,
-0.4891642034,
0.6096668243,
0.7296997309,
0.5247835517,
0.2231151015,
-1.0529834032,
-0.1739928275,
-0.1281062514,
0.1638697386,
-0.0988174975,
-0.3978267908,
1.2121825218,
-0.0916555896,
-0.1629156768,
0.5078697205,
0.6674439907,
0.7226569653,
0.401016742,
0.5504119396,
0.5022673607,
0.7588889599,
-0.219517529,
0.8730299473,
0.2346546799,
0.2677721083,
0.8105605841,
-0.0148830079,
0.5406340361,
0.5173871517,
-0.3630875349,
0.4930766821,
0.3304179609,
0.3139731884,
0.1273360103,
0.8335761428,
-0.2638839185,
0.0482486337,
-0.2760108113,
-0.6509806514,
0.1595582366,
-0.0779067352,
-0.5943898559,
-0.3666687012,
-0.0846286938,
0.3341461718,
0.5647054911,
-0.6532641053,
0.313649714,
0.1796405166,
-0.0225862302,
0.4920657575,
-0.1914482117,
0.9987873435,
-0.4281470776,
-0.1357671022,
-0.1751384735,
-0.076358445,
-0.1080768183,
-0.8229780793,
-0.084833093,
0.026882574,
-0.49127388,
-0.0516730212,
0.8918219209,
-0.564532876,
-0.7934986949,
-0.0452811942,
0.4985103011,
0.3446342349,
0.2250850797,
-0.5346187949,
0.0585868135,
0.1807406396,
0.2775048018,
0.0868228078,
0.7605740428,
0.0876966864,
0.7205128074,
0.2831084728,
0.5580722094,
0.070686087,
0.3263867795,
0.3477254808,
-0.6254731417,
-0.1509700716,
-0.4628283083,
0.4784563184,
0.0197858345,
-0.1889327019,
0.6235019565,
0.1655450761,
0.6467342377,
-0.2921405137,
0.8064898849,
0.0471345335,
0.7828296423,
-0.3733584881,
1.0409990549,
-0.5447644591,
0.3907953799,
-0.5487102866,
-0.5777214766,
-0.1683939844,
0.5280067325,
-0.5793150663,
0.206161499,
0.373539567,
0.6354233623,
-0.0409373939,
0.0546143688,
-0.0272447616,
0.4559210241,
0.1774312854,
0.0646028891,
1.1752524376,
-0.3710550368,
0.1397874802,
-0.0321850143,
-0.2259481698,
-0.1516603082,
-1.0149655342,
-0.5262383819,
-0.5575962663,
-0.3704431653,
-0.4613737166,
0.2383357137,
1.0053949356,
0.1549773812,
-0.3565265834,
-0.3389400542,
0.5041111112,
0.3540003598,
-0.2129882574,
-0.2296490073,
0.0680181384,
-0.5340699553,
-0.9359412789,
-0.2868451774,
-0.2288842797,
-0.1464389414,
-0.4226117432,
0.0445687436,
-0.0010391474,
0.454536438,
0.3993333578,
0.0778369531,
-0.7446501255,
-0.4069562852,
-0.5808804631,
-0.1284555644,
-0.107997939,
1.1065436602,
-0.4677819014,
0.6865828037,
0.8089039922,
0.1069747806,
-0.2021948844,
-0.0909877643,
0.5503777266,
-0.9396020174,
-0.030212881,
0.1516536325,
0.7269995809,
0.3766905963,
-0.1861228198,
0.5618962646,
0.7159981728,
-0.1757309586,
-0.9103581309,
0.4849968553,
-0.7768349051,
-0.5527918339,
0.9582355618,
-0.062214233,
-0.0360242575,
-0.3085618615,
-0.5362345576,
0.2761699557,
-0.2554543018,
0.9321922064,
0.9523434043,
0.1689765304,
-0.3494184017,
-0.8960266113,
0.2887330353,
0.2510799766,
-0.0848935097,
0.0249796174,
0.6627637148,
0.7168309689,
0.1390269399,
0.6388691068,
-0.5988715887,
-0.130193904,
-0.1104357168,
0.6200386286,
0.2588892281,
-0.2556337416,
-0.1762579829,
0.3954839408,
0.3103635013,
-0.2727130055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11747v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11747v1
|
Embedded Named Entity Recognition using Probing Classifiers
| 2024-03-18T12:58:16 | 2024-03-18T12:58:16 |
Nicholas Popovič, Michael Färber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extracting semantic information from generated text is a useful tool for
applications such as automated fact checking or retrieval augmented generation.
Currently, this requires either separate models during inference, which
increases computational cost, or destructive fine-tuning of the language model.
Instead, we propose directly embedding information extraction capabilities into
pre-trained language models using probing classifiers, enabling efficient
simultaneous text generation and information extraction. For this, we introduce
an approach called EMBER and show that it enables named entity recognition in
decoder-only language models without fine-tuning them and while incurring
minimal additional computational cost at inference time. Specifically, our
experiments using GPT-2 show that EMBER maintains high token generation rates
during streaming text generation, with only a negligible decrease in speed of
around 1% compared to a 43.64% slowdown measured for a baseline using a
separate NER model. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/nicpopovic/EMBER.
|
[
-0.4939439893,
-1.0341941118,
0.7828390002,
-0.3107022047,
-0.3576632142,
0.0499125794,
-0.1786212176,
-0.5993453264,
0.3924594522,
0.3907249868,
-0.1897147745,
-0.3989545703,
-0.7661333084,
0.0305272583,
-0.5210020542,
0.8927235603,
0.0160038229,
-0.149748221,
0.0303017516,
0.2034199536,
-0.1192025319,
-0.2797724307,
-0.9696874022,
-0.0509326942,
0.5186977983,
0.3364977539,
0.3167521656,
0.7809299827,
0.385346204,
0.2198131979,
0.0780145898,
0.2296174616,
-0.033919964,
0.6213701367,
-0.261236608,
-0.3877227306,
-0.2410903275,
-0.0673545226,
0.7107631564,
0.1357523054,
0.1151104346,
0.2225365192,
-0.0530620962,
0.0545117557,
-0.9937161207,
0.1826980114,
-0.8396145701,
0.0188066494,
-0.3688516319,
-0.4806305766,
-0.6010693312,
-0.1735083759,
0.2346015126,
-0.3203141689,
0.5955592394,
0.2696347833,
1.0181658268,
0.3029791415,
-0.4392273128,
-0.4319025576,
-0.7279957533,
0.5532134771,
-0.5610385537,
0.7041090727,
0.1826279163,
0.1143805832,
0.1281520724,
-1.0152856112,
-0.7087117434,
-0.0349171795,
-0.1294647753,
0.2213822454,
-0.3237604499,
0.0191377793,
0.4070655406,
0.2048890442,
-0.3043489158,
0.1178574115,
-0.0850797147,
-0.1424963325,
0.4404454529,
0.1879972816,
0.4038558006,
-0.2528932393,
-0.1622333825,
-0.1728596836,
-0.8983266354,
0.0188517161,
0.3841429651,
0.3271275759,
0.1467139721,
0.6656868458,
0.1839837283,
0.3532409072,
0.1216312647,
0.1531950682,
0.0414907485,
-0.0947606042,
-0.2158097327,
0.5118449926,
0.7153798342,
-0.0554216504,
0.0542866178,
-0.3981026113,
-0.2694176137,
0.0713485852,
0.2640371025,
-1.1834441423,
-0.4334706068,
0.329749912,
-0.1482360363,
-0.4106831849,
0.2131189108,
-0.9714890122,
-0.2694486678,
0.0825750977,
0.3223831654,
-0.3841623664,
-0.4309310317,
-0.1539878547,
-0.463688612,
0.522110045,
0.31519714,
-1.088305831,
0.1803463995,
0.8005668521,
0.8321045637,
-0.0434579477,
0.0284735654,
-0.8377289772,
0.4667463601,
-0.0779555365,
0.9433051348,
-0.7425642014,
-0.3730396032,
-0.1707223803,
0.0566332936,
-0.1508632898,
-0.3224413097,
0.2599324584,
-0.6767290235,
-0.0905597582,
0.0966762677,
-0.9869201183,
-0.0138371959,
0.3509348035,
-0.7466635108,
1.0120934248,
-0.2435941845,
-1.1582903862,
0.517006278,
-0.6757209301,
-0.3733534217,
0.2978223264,
-0.4971822202,
-0.3691855967,
0.2452814579,
0.3432745636,
0.6020404696,
-0.3991011083,
0.1750289649,
-0.119283542,
-0.2574845552,
0.0948159844,
-0.3271493018,
0.4423552454,
0.1533378065,
-0.6266293526,
-0.3049985766,
-0.7213596702,
0.2933192253,
0.3556343317,
-0.4776353538,
-0.5430113077,
0.2076311409,
0.2502263188,
-0.2951901853,
-0.0610214099,
-1.0028213263,
0.1193571687,
-0.4334791005,
0.418808192,
0.5017951131,
0.3222612739,
0.3878344297,
0.0709043369,
0.4842996001,
0.0691172257,
-0.3926157057,
-0.4195809662,
-0.4567055702,
-1.1324996948,
-0.4547540843,
0.8263127804,
0.4684243202,
-0.575992465,
0.2988502681,
-0.4919296205,
-0.6465392113,
-0.7131750584,
-0.2128482461,
0.3719834983,
0.218166098,
0.3281289637,
-0.0470531844,
-0.5508087873,
-0.615624249,
-0.5257222652,
-0.1130308956,
-0.1324427128,
0.5384393334,
0.4749459326,
-0.2462930828,
1.071305275,
-0.5563710332,
0.0945559442,
-0.2508672476,
0.3441596925,
-0.3243726194,
0.6818110347,
0.2558774352,
-1.0330808163,
-0.3012540638,
0.0309727341,
-0.5702519417,
-0.0933318883,
-0.0800086334,
0.1012591794,
-0.021411797,
0.5094290972,
-0.6313070655,
0.4525732994,
0.5790413618,
-0.4388904274,
0.0343209133,
0.0304472204,
-0.000309004,
-1.2581248283,
-0.0597433597,
-0.0811236501,
-0.4294868112,
-0.4805178344,
0.1889763921,
0.2811036408,
-0.209661752,
-0.3274247646,
0.8743636608,
-0.8872189522,
-0.1987017691,
-0.2817751169,
0.5059149861,
0.2109086961,
-0.0534742773,
0.0876259357,
0.6816456914,
0.4397339821,
-0.85707587,
0.2216814458,
0.121398218,
-0.35618186,
0.1342495829,
-0.6689071655,
0.3798398376,
-0.0380648933,
-0.0441783853,
-0.6359812617,
-0.3570053279,
0.2166310996,
-0.7163920999,
0.7966085672,
-0.448112309,
-0.6624498963,
0.1830751151,
-0.0692621246,
0.3494394422,
0.5516046286,
-0.8944054246,
1.0630688667,
0.5824516416,
-0.1407995969,
-0.2292016,
-0.7944287062,
-0.0215679053,
-0.1178979352,
-0.422352463,
0.6300231218,
0.4570026398,
-0.1453924328,
0.2728062868,
-0.0408128574,
-0.0489584953,
0.264414072,
0.4139863551,
0.0149569502,
-0.370023489,
0.5643433332,
0.4525832534,
-0.2143796831,
-0.0284807906,
-0.170153603,
0.5731014609,
-0.0183627177,
-0.5979495645,
-0.4813519716,
0.3337298632,
0.3369069993,
-0.5993859768,
0.8224904537,
0.6112462282,
-0.4387997091,
-0.206205979,
-0.6971073747,
-0.3073043227,
-0.4737932384,
0.2999175191,
-0.7300595641,
-0.9465577006,
0.3394998014,
-0.2315080762,
0.1060625985,
0.5441503525,
0.2812916338,
0.0528731719,
1.1862552166,
0.5964381099,
0.3021143675,
0.5596973896,
0.0198838674,
0.5541486144,
-0.9239818454,
-0.3091389537,
-0.6058313847,
-0.0176809914,
-0.9251782894,
-0.2276473492,
-0.0256104209,
0.0926659852,
-0.1672947407,
0.3633193672,
-0.4722048342,
0.3527518809,
0.5664116144,
0.0198853668,
0.2610416114,
-0.1817300171,
-0.1393519938,
-0.096014671,
-0.4006164074,
-0.6596352458,
0.9115641713,
0.3524856567,
0.8099931479,
0.2363525629,
1.0723092556,
0.1458282918,
0.2800001502,
-1.0095152855,
0.4591096938,
0.2247289568,
-0.7270762324,
-0.1240884438,
-0.3929046988,
-0.9011348486,
0.2237506062,
-0.1551967412,
-0.7842501998,
-0.0149511006,
0.1389815062,
-0.173274532,
0.5402340889,
-0.6574397683,
0.4694808125,
-0.1777013391,
-0.233211264,
0.0151285687,
-0.1377749145,
-0.0456778407,
-0.2735076249,
-0.1689385474,
-0.0991174653,
-0.2209959179,
0.7900272608,
-0.0847750902,
0.5667434335,
-0.3795580566,
0.1360126734,
0.3549084067,
0.185367614,
0.7553995848,
0.3966204226,
0.1265445948,
0.0437781774,
-0.0306005981,
-0.2151588649,
-0.7477501631,
0.6672174931,
-0.3751242161,
-0.6912131906,
-0.4125280082,
-0.1226100847,
0.0310824178,
0.3081233799,
0.279307127,
0.4387540221,
-0.1189544946,
0.3038427234,
0.6068212986,
-0.1773508042,
0.4502629042,
0.5587714911,
-0.1586408019,
-0.188851729,
0.6848731637,
0.0898059607,
0.0882153362,
0.5662258863,
0.0008041842,
-0.1667951196,
-0.5810378194,
-0.6922980547,
0.1279611886,
-0.5582328439,
-0.2338266075,
-1.3293179274,
-0.2977762818,
-0.5291107893,
-0.0251633078,
-0.7284147739,
-0.423304826,
-0.3419704437,
-0.3715811372,
0.4513556957,
0.6782132983,
0.253665626,
0.3409085572,
-1.2100178003,
-0.1716679633,
0.1336889863,
0.0575095788,
-0.0106577883,
-0.4121791124,
-0.0242218673,
-0.1082982123,
-0.163906619,
-0.9840298295,
0.3192261755,
0.2011193186,
0.5337334275,
0.6060513854,
0.1359783858,
0.581466794,
-0.5525252819,
0.7207341194,
-0.2065522969,
-1.1153854132,
0.7965368629,
-0.0347517915,
-0.0660668164,
0.4332289696,
0.3324150443,
-0.2841964364,
-0.3671782911,
-0.7535951734,
-0.9028321505,
0.4689849615,
0.1525737792,
0.3909562528,
-0.3984075487,
0.3755215406,
-0.1155183464,
0.0385223441,
-0.5786650777,
-0.1410594136,
0.2208634913,
-0.1542292237,
0.2288494408,
-0.390571177,
0.1705648303,
-0.0272098668,
0.7192031145,
0.0122681633,
0.5324273705,
0.2123892456,
-0.2909184098,
0.2290625125,
0.3591660857,
-0.1146331653,
0.0716086999,
-0.1733816266,
0.3766593337,
0.2521958947,
-0.4912165403,
0.0528488792,
0.2476152778,
-0.3048094511,
0.3141153753,
0.2977585793,
0.7466381788,
0.5426944494,
-0.6034258604,
0.5729215145,
-0.2914028764,
0.0441452786,
-0.4384640455,
0.2570345104,
0.0149867805,
0.5699862242,
0.1779986322,
-0.2821693718,
0.0967163891,
-0.2652462721,
0.2743228972,
0.3780336082,
-0.322388202,
-0.4233731627,
0.6254969835,
0.1703572422,
-0.3557935357,
0.9492279887,
-0.3245429397,
-0.5274815559,
0.6376546025,
0.8922963142,
1.0721340179,
-0.2397604734,
0.0120243579,
0.420568943,
0.1697829217,
0.1159610823,
0.2362034321,
-0.3895152211,
-0.9807126522,
0.0377985388,
-0.6958149076,
-0.4827839136,
-0.2067068964,
-0.8324956894,
0.469535172,
-0.4661086798,
-0.318687737,
0.4209098816,
-0.1041273326,
-0.8590992093,
0.20201388,
0.2482735366,
0.820599556,
-0.7029256821,
0.842141211,
0.8037264943,
-0.5256451368,
-0.9145129919,
0.2227058113,
-0.1684345752,
-0.4236827791,
0.7911151052,
0.6088707447,
-0.2815801203,
0.605427444,
-0.3268307447,
-0.918309629,
1.2754594088,
0.1177872643,
-0.4439421594,
-0.2888813615,
-0.3995786607,
0.2777915895,
-0.4705997109,
0.5844569802,
0.3503531814,
0.4383048415,
-0.051402308,
-0.5504704714,
0.1565376967,
-0.263987124,
-0.1458150595,
0.6478907466,
-0.4270121753,
0.9087839723,
-0.3348228633,
-0.8995515108,
-0.1296690702,
0.4891504645,
0.0682451949,
0.3230261505,
0.3557436466,
0.719129324,
0.8580991626,
-0.0933504179,
0.9204950929,
-0.332808286,
0.5228242874,
1.209166646,
-0.3668590784,
1.0511502028,
0.5461238623,
0.1067504361,
0.3512684703,
0.5577939749,
-0.3372527659,
0.6863750219,
0.0054296628,
-0.4181233644,
-0.0689062998,
-0.168894276,
-0.2893421352,
0.8297598362,
0.4519311786,
-0.8325186968,
-0.2098830044,
-0.0580884553,
0.1552683264,
-0.4487261474,
0.0057597016,
0.8812980056,
-0.0429709479,
-0.5894382,
-0.006785484,
0.2422172576,
0.5818234086,
-0.242307052,
-0.142769143,
0.1450695246,
0.2441095561,
-0.1607179791,
-0.4833850265,
0.2820951641,
0.3590995371,
-0.1038613915,
0.0166398846,
0.7851955295,
-0.2361208498,
-0.2729439139,
0.5362353325,
0.6892848611,
0.4844906628,
-0.1611175835,
-0.2613305449,
-0.1838455945,
-0.0481147319,
-0.7500357628,
0.2782070339,
0.4296153188,
0.3523024023,
0.3702633679,
0.7034395933,
0.0648427829,
0.3174121678,
0.0345942788,
0.991263032,
-0.839243114,
-0.4076333046,
-1.1844431162,
0.3392891288,
-0.0997764096,
-0.1906413734,
0.7712596655,
0.7109173536,
1.0210162401,
0.217034027,
0.8582000732,
-0.38372159,
0.4387984872,
-0.6764202714,
0.7811385989,
-0.5139069557,
0.0782473832,
-0.144958213,
-1.0131363869,
-0.092241466,
0.4662102163,
-0.3072851598,
-0.0218795277,
0.753202498,
0.8661532998,
-0.2375770807,
0.2825277746,
0.2495131195,
-0.1380762756,
0.6294704676,
0.1768626273,
0.7505838871,
-0.6265902519,
0.2498077303,
-0.1369781196,
0.0956740081,
-0.0844194666,
-0.8315201998,
-1.0000805855,
-0.4680031836,
-0.3408272862,
-0.263921231,
0.0861669928,
0.8993079066,
0.6318189502,
-0.8003948927,
0.6153027415,
-0.3320575655,
-0.2751468122,
0.3926145434,
-0.292021662,
0.4159734547,
-0.3867895603,
-1.066067934,
0.3706046343,
0.1032959372,
0.1781361848,
-0.010595263,
0.2281388938,
-0.095996432,
0.0666426644,
0.1837146133,
0.0628609732,
-0.6605602503,
-0.520139873,
-0.1740593761,
-0.1438428611,
-0.1005032733,
0.9362081885,
-0.6491951942,
0.6008858681,
0.4966737032,
1.2379567623,
0.8531926274,
0.0954825729,
0.3186053038,
-0.6706601381,
0.0390074253,
0.3989468813,
0.4237988889,
0.318564564,
-0.5793013573,
0.4626065791,
0.0547211319,
-0.4622087181,
-0.8351052999,
0.1540908068,
-0.4969575405,
0.1299694628,
1.0360548496,
-0.5233597755,
-0.2680523992,
0.0209681746,
0.0899126455,
0.7203327417,
-0.4433359504,
0.3814019859,
0.4926672876,
-0.1094691157,
-0.3440581858,
-0.6290863156,
0.2679874003,
0.291315645,
-0.8340702653,
-0.1955330819,
0.2502044737,
0.4617830217,
0.3021866679,
0.3405177295,
-0.1268087626,
-0.1165272519,
0.5174435377,
0.2864827216,
-0.183729291,
-0.4166951478,
-0.0794216841,
0.0902350619,
-0.1023809835,
-0.4622660875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11621v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11621v1
|
Let's Focus on Neuron: Neuron-Level Supervised Fine-tuning for Large Language Model
| 2024-03-18T09:55:01 | 2024-03-18T09:55:01 |
Haoyun Xu, Runzhe Zhan, Derek F. Wong, Lidia S. Chao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are composed of neurons that exhibit various
behaviors and roles, which become increasingly diversified as models scale.
Recent studies have revealed that not all neurons are active across different
datasets, and this sparsity correlates positively with the task-specific
ability, leading to advancements in model pruning and training efficiency.
Traditional fine-tuning methods engage all parameters of LLMs, which is
computationally expensive and may not be necessary. In contrast,
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) approaches aim to minimize the number of
trainable parameters, yet they still operate at a relatively macro scale (e.g.,
layer-level). We introduce Neuron-Level Fine-Tuning (NeFT), a novel approach
that refines the granularity of parameter training down to the individual
neuron, enabling more precise and computationally efficient model updates. The
experimental results show that NeFT not only exceeded the performance of
full-parameter fine-tuning and PEFT but also provided insights into the
analysis of neurons.
|
[
-0.4747271836,
-1.1394222975,
0.277215004,
0.0754509047,
0.000399249,
-0.0944378674,
-0.6174441576,
-0.3420063257,
-0.0704051629,
0.4250502586,
-0.5031140447,
-0.387299031,
-0.534016192,
-0.1115695462,
-0.5031594634,
0.9796894789,
0.3346026838,
0.0841014385,
-0.1408096254,
-0.004945063,
-0.0577314571,
-0.4456193447,
-1.2863796949,
-0.7408030629,
0.8267944455,
0.3793841898,
0.5406063795,
0.4680762887,
0.2889935672,
0.2849930525,
-0.5514286757,
0.4135944545,
-0.4618992805,
-0.0476718172,
-0.2430222631,
-0.3775862753,
-0.7814770341,
-0.1874798089,
0.5961427093,
1.0014659166,
-0.3113505542,
0.0560994484,
0.1901065111,
0.5997927785,
-0.6158446074,
-0.0203794818,
-0.8612869978,
-0.1105556563,
0.1415929347,
-0.0854468495,
-0.3455317318,
-0.1150344238,
0.0734847113,
-0.4340669513,
0.5640038848,
-0.1054825708,
1.0265523195,
0.3105610907,
-0.3810189366,
0.3382306397,
-0.5507717729,
0.6976013184,
-1.0731420517,
0.0482981801,
0.51811409,
0.024375964,
-0.3710331619,
-0.5679143667,
-0.3003770709,
-0.4438246191,
-0.0119801192,
-0.4385292828,
-0.0803056583,
0.4215162694,
0.4469306171,
0.1913448423,
-0.2400367558,
0.5632436275,
-0.0925930887,
-0.1877337694,
0.5957820415,
0.2340666652,
0.2965545356,
0.2715177238,
0.1419861913,
-0.0364660881,
-0.7487274408,
-0.1019242033,
0.4317834377,
0.6088905334,
-0.014195241,
0.2607697248,
-0.5097759366,
0.9309023619,
0.3871407509,
0.1405696571,
0.0567896217,
-0.0538567938,
-0.2553323805,
-0.0274647251,
0.7691218853,
0.32755512,
0.5785652399,
-0.298350662,
-0.3961922228,
-0.4189149141,
0.2960295081,
-0.9615205526,
-0.3662266731,
-0.1130400896,
-0.4570266008,
-0.377695024,
-0.6714841723,
-0.6345864534,
-0.4422531128,
-0.601559937,
0.5988014936,
-0.4383382797,
-0.3261517584,
0.1969201416,
0.2393632382,
0.1097360253,
0.5863845944,
-1.5205965042,
0.4514540434,
0.8566249609,
0.8215157986,
-0.1009580716,
-0.5429944992,
-0.6655724049,
-0.0433047935,
-0.5003277659,
0.6303949952,
-0.6095733047,
0.1397230327,
-0.255092144,
0.0492321402,
-0.1161666289,
-0.6936140656,
0.2538402975,
-0.4282546639,
-0.4471783936,
-0.1860792786,
-0.290317744,
-0.1665899456,
0.3353806734,
-0.5011413097,
0.9276246428,
0.119308278,
-0.4440889955,
0.5109046698,
-0.4262059629,
-0.6953491569,
-0.2370542586,
-0.023173308,
-0.3007668853,
0.6617717743,
0.4459505379,
0.7287937999,
-0.4354890585,
0.4410091937,
-0.344368726,
-0.3732076287,
-0.0900836736,
-0.4403718114,
0.2449680269,
-0.0756220967,
-0.2069482952,
0.3114410341,
-0.9400018454,
0.0604195558,
-0.1289693564,
-0.3274150491,
-0.2314834297,
0.149309203,
0.1196198091,
0.1606752723,
0.3639432788,
-0.4920326471,
0.3096346855,
-0.6773649454,
1.0552309752,
0.7492988706,
-0.1432370543,
0.6796105504,
-0.0682830513,
0.1627336144,
-0.2008061111,
0.2004618645,
0.0979453549,
-0.1463758647,
-0.7250694633,
-0.0337189697,
0.5964077115,
0.0586398393,
-0.1558001935,
0.331567347,
0.0054530022,
-0.5372415185,
-0.2344722897,
0.0656885952,
0.0226493534,
0.4477924705,
0.4105430543,
-0.1277557313,
0.0781834945,
-1.135833025,
-0.263864398,
0.1922549158,
0.0360876359,
0.3514540195,
0.4784046412,
0.0440862477,
0.5687083602,
-0.3021102846,
-0.1555953473,
-0.2057548612,
0.2471528798,
0.4441001415,
0.7822415233,
0.3656663299,
-0.4567736387,
-0.4791409075,
0.4577730596,
-0.3224654496,
0.0867140293,
-0.2965815961,
0.1485061646,
0.0548213348,
0.9241863489,
-0.5691883564,
0.2664032876,
0.4379030764,
-0.1460908651,
0.2259069234,
-0.7383975387,
-0.0480768867,
-0.5686332583,
-0.1398449689,
-0.0206272025,
0.0168991555,
-0.6834608912,
-0.1152138934,
0.2962982953,
0.0816757604,
-0.1109618992,
0.4134394825,
-0.466799289,
0.0664645359,
-0.6323820353,
-0.1641128957,
-0.1617054641,
0.6215337515,
-0.0522482023,
0.669298768,
0.9604067206,
-0.6182826757,
-0.0429485328,
-0.2142388225,
-0.3997324407,
0.292707473,
-0.9445563555,
0.1232120395,
-0.1200018525,
-0.1931287497,
-0.6798648238,
-0.1857396066,
-0.1983662099,
-0.2591249347,
0.6452349424,
-0.2429282218,
-0.8998780847,
0.2513223588,
0.1333938986,
0.3876451552,
0.3862192631,
-0.5684758425,
0.8040308952,
0.2971375287,
-0.0472247079,
-0.4485020041,
-0.5894647837,
0.1139243916,
-0.0183231179,
-0.531644702,
0.6042528152,
0.1837148964,
0.0563669801,
-0.2974155545,
-0.3856374919,
-0.1926840842,
0.2175926566,
0.089833051,
-0.1475477964,
-0.2302659005,
0.3299347758,
0.3848102987,
-0.1031964794,
-0.0440974496,
-0.0022306715,
0.8444070816,
-0.1597630233,
-0.2157672346,
-0.4027909636,
0.235365659,
0.4859538674,
-0.4717882574,
0.7432995439,
0.6701273918,
-0.4842039943,
-0.6631712914,
-0.4604922831,
-0.604018569,
-0.5520172715,
0.6112229824,
-0.2874568403,
-1.071591258,
0.3342421055,
-0.3853523433,
-0.0819432512,
0.3247769475,
0.3855893314,
0.0631154031,
1.2742756605,
0.9345702529,
-0.1113075837,
0.6382185817,
-0.1674618572,
0.3816944361,
-0.9155000448,
-0.2194687277,
-0.4946614206,
-0.8178990483,
-0.4614098072,
-0.0890627652,
0.1233779788,
0.4255131781,
-0.5286986232,
0.3926974833,
-0.7644491196,
0.6601387262,
0.4900043011,
0.1823658049,
0.1366046965,
0.2039506733,
-0.0199478865,
0.1531244069,
-0.8253102303,
-0.3613668382,
0.9857245088,
0.2389120013,
0.8311997652,
-0.4160708785,
0.5192654133,
-0.1395198703,
-0.0910251364,
-0.8434323072,
0.8048215508,
-0.409312129,
-0.5596826077,
-0.3945788145,
-0.3290085793,
-0.8820599318,
0.3378192186,
-0.303170085,
-1.1109261513,
0.4126925468,
0.2181277573,
-0.5815225244,
0.4797255099,
-0.7329581976,
0.8880497217,
-0.2409838885,
-0.4658457041,
-0.6820417047,
-0.3688025475,
-0.1597946882,
-0.1129697859,
-0.151865229,
-0.4564374685,
-0.2996697128,
0.4471049905,
-0.2949644327,
0.9733861685,
-0.1028772816,
-0.1493437737,
-0.1321712434,
0.1584798694,
0.5108633041,
0.2811430097,
-0.1993302256,
0.275346458,
-0.0693226308,
-0.2897649407,
-0.5537385941,
1.148960948,
-0.7194873095,
-0.4970669746,
-0.1400759369,
-0.9130575657,
-0.4530060291,
0.2438013405,
0.0861723721,
0.4877497554,
0.0355529636,
0.4191007614,
0.9790964723,
-0.4252905548,
0.5784115195,
0.3746371567,
0.0407430604,
-0.1748113632,
0.8493713737,
0.2370699346,
0.2765118182,
0.4657239914,
0.0566553436,
0.2691140771,
-1.244628787,
-0.0554399304,
0.2409370095,
-0.4649762809,
0.0610968955,
-0.6411498785,
-0.1610285342,
-0.1665422022,
-0.1534874439,
-0.5024225712,
-0.2183666676,
-0.5099437833,
0.0510426275,
0.5349451303,
0.4715917706,
-0.1760578007,
0.6179566383,
-0.536983788,
0.3947846591,
0.3264230788,
0.6616288424,
0.1642336994,
-0.60341537,
-0.3009285629,
-0.0176862758,
-0.1502346396,
-0.4307747781,
0.388654232,
0.5285733938,
0.5594694614,
0.1286727041,
-0.4597502947,
0.7227765322,
-0.6298797131,
0.6415253282,
0.1534566432,
-0.9052426219,
0.4974412918,
-0.412853688,
0.3843332231,
0.6379442215,
0.0628542677,
-0.3099776208,
-0.0047309729,
-0.5274809003,
-1.1377168894,
0.9275223613,
-0.0771045908,
0.541462481,
0.0909774601,
0.7021325827,
0.03836824,
0.1743259579,
-0.3679558933,
-0.0810429156,
0.2065351158,
0.0429489128,
-0.2934424281,
0.0018562491,
0.001734955,
-0.7933976054,
0.4585879743,
-0.3555935919,
0.0538625829,
-0.0338804275,
0.0332194157,
-0.159919098,
0.1098897755,
0.5191811323,
0.6473668218,
-0.2039018124,
0.0061210091,
0.5609967709,
-0.3378234208,
-0.1441922933,
-0.0868512541,
-0.2475012541,
-0.1168559566,
0.2209929824,
0.873732686,
0.1840836555,
-0.5735599995,
0.3124553859,
0.0277633015,
-0.5847594142,
0.0389926992,
0.4246423542,
0.3433839083,
0.3999861181,
0.1484102458,
0.3321245909,
-0.007486057,
-0.3583667874,
0.0827128738,
0.4935078323,
-0.4853580296,
-0.2571795583,
0.5375624895,
-0.1054435745,
-0.4155870974,
0.7036569118,
0.1755364984,
0.0467512533,
0.943862021,
0.4833227992,
0.8727635145,
0.1279677749,
0.0797786489,
0.5339866281,
0.521926403,
-0.3880580366,
0.1713216305,
0.0089245401,
-0.5934130549,
-0.7632646561,
-0.809789598,
-0.1329521984,
0.4629276991,
-0.5937392712,
0.1195554808,
-0.8932962418,
-0.3384476006,
0.3482634425,
-0.3267516196,
-0.3014526963,
0.2999057174,
0.1193582565,
1.0696458817,
-0.5117280483,
1.1766705513,
0.6289072633,
-0.1248895377,
-0.7920581102,
0.0052531241,
-0.5336034298,
-0.5360261202,
0.7796682119,
-0.0068326639,
-0.0499026291,
0.1365530342,
-0.8882595897,
-0.9418570399,
0.8123857975,
0.7668715119,
-0.935393393,
-0.2208850682,
-0.0810319334,
0.7540991306,
-0.230812192,
0.1602250785,
0.7823376656,
0.3409352303,
-0.2761358619,
-0.9335383773,
-0.0880804285,
-0.2388136536,
0.100239791,
0.6240984797,
-0.6447232366,
1.0679303408,
-0.1353402436,
0.2247407585,
-0.0780821964,
0.5783672333,
-0.119912222,
-0.0836611912,
0.4291763902,
0.5956616402,
0.6873784065,
-0.2094522119,
0.7784006,
-0.4117894471,
0.2989640832,
1.2325258255,
0.0042710686,
0.8858819008,
0.6834087372,
0.0419011712,
0.1545787007,
0.6294316649,
-0.3191569149,
0.5576996207,
0.4907840192,
-0.0802695751,
-0.7181566358,
-0.0210506879,
-0.1229557246,
0.1825273335,
0.4979819357,
-0.3369736671,
-0.4322237968,
-0.0687062964,
-0.205091998,
0.120054163,
-0.6701352596,
0.7266804576,
0.2646452487,
-0.4715920091,
0.8024250269,
0.0737808347,
0.9119141102,
-0.5729496479,
0.0047415369,
-0.146690011,
0.2201904356,
-0.2777918875,
-0.4862208068,
0.1785208285,
-0.1683831513,
-0.251098156,
-0.1463525295,
0.7457604408,
-0.3186447322,
-0.2005258948,
0.4115294814,
0.1731378883,
-0.100872606,
-0.5136528611,
-0.7491954565,
-0.1904866993,
-0.2371614575,
-0.4093732834,
0.748016715,
0.450953722,
-0.0064730695,
0.6983298659,
0.4865913689,
0.2396356165,
-0.0131849758,
0.3128032386,
0.8145548105,
-0.6986691952,
0.0568176024,
-1.0165581703,
0.2582360208,
-0.1763300896,
-0.6882118583,
0.4450187087,
0.3067162037,
0.8626695871,
-0.015797982,
0.4636620879,
-0.0416028537,
0.0659049377,
-0.3219982982,
0.8482409716,
-0.8761370778,
0.0319703072,
-0.02904821,
-0.8112042546,
-0.4501584768,
0.5915590525,
-0.5474473238,
0.1134026125,
0.6280132532,
1.2022815943,
-0.2474349439,
0.0657145977,
0.5439928174,
0.2255445123,
0.0491848886,
0.6095145941,
0.7957325578,
-0.2287390381,
0.3059537411,
-0.387213558,
-0.0023362597,
-0.0255240873,
-0.8784284592,
-1.1372300386,
-0.2962270379,
-0.481978476,
0.1194827408,
-0.0255102552,
0.7763506174,
0.9883100986,
-0.9070193768,
-0.1895438284,
-0.5328652859,
-0.171016112,
-0.4063962102,
-0.1038694531,
0.3507529199,
-0.6678634882,
-0.8411884308,
0.5360341668,
0.3941010535,
-0.2289138734,
-0.022724783,
0.1914340407,
-0.2569000125,
0.0381034501,
0.5641794205,
0.0499728546,
-0.612831831,
-0.0767221376,
-0.0089109205,
-0.1467710137,
0.1340127587,
0.6433009505,
-0.4694811404,
0.1311741173,
0.6754236817,
0.7450143695,
0.8055840731,
-0.4512439966,
0.6945046186,
-0.4328409433,
-0.0476498157,
0.4044517279,
0.2808625698,
0.1774570197,
-0.2936637402,
0.2509012222,
-0.2701749802,
-0.744979322,
-0.8846497536,
0.1275432706,
-1.0688755512,
-0.5533127189,
1.0871948004,
0.1959710568,
-0.2901312411,
0.1092739701,
-0.3340456486,
0.1720981151,
-0.4186058342,
0.5749358535,
0.6279159784,
-0.0806496292,
-0.2802366614,
-0.7948195338,
0.5427937508,
0.790125668,
-0.6354038715,
0.1787203699,
0.2670398355,
0.4032074511,
-0.1414556652,
0.2447939366,
0.0471582264,
0.1013530791,
-0.078797847,
0.039298363,
-0.1012655497,
-0.524081707,
-0.6444557905,
0.4819921851,
0.3002746105,
0.1469355673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11585v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11585v2
|
Linguacodus: A Synergistic Framework for Transformative Code Generation in Machine Learning Pipelines
| 2024-03-18T08:58:47 | 2024-04-30T17:56:33 |
Ekaterina Trofimova, Emil Sataev, Andrey E. Ustyuzhanin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE
|
In the ever-evolving landscape of machine learning, seamless translation of
natural language descriptions into executable code remains a formidable
challenge. This paper introduces Linguacodus, an innovative framework designed
to tackle this challenge by deploying a dynamic pipeline that iteratively
transforms natural language task descriptions into code through high-level
data-shaping instructions. The core of Linguacodus is a fine-tuned large
language model (LLM), empowered to evaluate diverse solutions for various
problems and select the most fitting one for a given task. This paper details
the fine-tuning process, and sheds light on how natural language descriptions
can be translated into functional code. Linguacodus represents a substantial
leap towards automated code generation, effectively bridging the gap between
task descriptions and executable code. It holds great promise for advancing
machine learning applications across diverse domains. Additionally, we propose
an algorithm capable of transforming a natural description of an ML task into
code with minimal human interaction. In extensive experiments on a vast machine
learning code dataset originating from Kaggle, we showcase the effectiveness of
Linguacodus. The investigations highlight its potential applications across
diverse domains, emphasizing its impact on applied machine learning in various
scientific fields.
|
[
-0.2802689075,
-0.6411607862,
-0.2116049528,
0.2751898766,
-0.2838070691,
0.3657993972,
-0.4087318182,
-0.3955567181,
0.391692996,
0.6084039211,
-0.4808144569,
-0.4686416388,
-0.5950005651,
0.3915616572,
-0.5035877228,
1.1084986925,
0.0941857323,
-0.1342375129,
-0.2131887972,
-0.0646341145,
-0.5146149397,
-0.3002852499,
-0.5474804044,
-0.278014034,
0.4769247472,
0.56124264,
0.7777466178,
0.6604194045,
0.2238904238,
0.273797363,
0.1551543027,
0.5851815939,
-0.6474196911,
0.2713429034,
-0.0521288365,
-0.6364278197,
-0.2729198337,
-0.4931613207,
0.5863497257,
0.9083600044,
-0.0690904334,
0.1600817293,
0.3632424176,
0.4512079656,
-0.6017805934,
0.5340923667,
-0.699257493,
0.2670802176,
-0.3426991105,
-0.6966122389,
-0.5359819531,
-0.1503567249,
-0.2244012058,
-0.8121033311,
0.0249543265,
0.2170167267,
0.8707723022,
0.4878625572,
-0.3902366459,
-0.4069145024,
-0.4449326098,
0.7513870001,
-0.5901963115,
0.109986946,
0.1506693512,
0.3265187144,
-0.4839895368,
-0.945767045,
-0.5585552454,
0.003013795,
-0.1307046413,
-0.1702552587,
-0.4267602563,
-0.1263387203,
0.0437190942,
0.6931348443,
-0.5549331903,
0.4549910128,
-0.452039808,
-0.2498444766,
0.4526413679,
0.3036969602,
0.44570297,
-0.2415095717,
0.0032671471,
-0.1292719692,
-0.7982347608,
0.1290358603,
0.328392148,
0.5463146567,
-0.0780626088,
0.3503421843,
-0.2343372107,
0.7615779042,
-0.160203293,
-0.0614554845,
0.1930913329,
0.2296149433,
-0.5834046602,
0.2998159528,
0.7702181339,
0.0963991955,
-0.0793093815,
-0.429385215,
-0.1187008843,
0.2423247993,
0.7019378543,
-1.0985405445,
-0.0890054777,
0.3663011789,
-0.1242363453,
-0.6610146165,
0.0113428459,
-0.723292768,
-0.3505481184,
-0.3728263378,
-0.1008394733,
-0.332493335,
-0.0850536823,
0.218707189,
0.3534899652,
0.0739962235,
-0.0536076427,
-0.9890090227,
0.3655305505,
1.0904865265,
0.6881588697,
-0.3240746856,
-0.3445737958,
-1.0430992842,
0.0573011599,
-0.5776984096,
0.315733552,
-0.4027295411,
-0.5326014161,
0.1465329081,
0.2860844135,
0.1157654598,
-0.5526547432,
0.5533647537,
-0.6131331325,
0.0983944833,
0.0088937655,
-0.4285059273,
-0.3522152901,
0.1505378038,
-0.7854925394,
0.8124922514,
0.2494044006,
-0.7334220409,
0.2630653679,
-1.0123013258,
-0.8386306763,
0.6117569804,
-0.106448099,
-0.4642901123,
-0.115812473,
0.0991237164,
0.5129138231,
-0.4796657264,
0.3510134816,
-0.1275482923,
-0.2152462453,
0.3581441045,
-0.0579102635,
1.168438673,
0.5600426793,
-0.6861895323,
0.2692536116,
-0.4230680168,
0.0500421152,
0.1287256926,
-0.1881339252,
-0.3167164922,
-0.1723713875,
0.1192937195,
-0.088823773,
0.0418208167,
-0.244600296,
0.3709259629,
-0.5106080174,
0.6623277664,
0.4373722374,
-0.3124160171,
0.5563165545,
-0.1916277409,
0.9084176421,
-0.210190326,
0.1975441277,
-0.3762362003,
-0.3924423158,
-0.7493148446,
-0.4096184969,
0.4282917976,
0.4615474641,
-1.1134474277,
0.1941572726,
-0.495159328,
-0.5746988058,
-0.6392832398,
0.5626347661,
0.2926626205,
0.5440714955,
0.266451627,
-0.4496142566,
-0.593830049,
-0.6737759709,
0.0092619481,
-0.0243043341,
0.0626638755,
0.2484265566,
0.4326839745,
-0.7710509896,
0.5333493948,
-0.3550641537,
-0.1904150844,
-0.1125205681,
0.2740614414,
0.0835921019,
0.3218490481,
0.5290474892,
-0.9879191518,
-0.1781483293,
0.3858123124,
-0.7821970582,
-0.2579648197,
-0.1079099178,
-0.4565519094,
0.322327137,
0.3755567074,
-0.3113183677,
-0.1114930585,
0.8132061362,
-0.2857266963,
0.4975082576,
-0.0977239162,
0.1947102547,
-1.0935689211,
0.4100625813,
-0.3383752406,
-0.0918899029,
-0.3055816293,
0.8441933393,
0.0587258115,
-0.1929268688,
-0.388212204,
0.5212708712,
-0.4169475138,
-0.053219419,
-0.215374276,
-0.1843227744,
0.1086756438,
0.4152283072,
-0.0531504229,
0.3589947224,
1.0435165167,
-0.7762322426,
0.7718067765,
0.211827606,
-0.2778738141,
0.4596298635,
-0.3999886215,
0.0187931396,
0.2228325158,
0.1163205281,
-0.3126743734,
-0.4966266155,
0.2374328971,
-0.2328420132,
0.3539839089,
-0.160951674,
-0.6598528028,
-0.3713673949,
-0.0021541074,
0.431551367,
0.4215255976,
-0.5860275626,
0.36346668,
0.5189329982,
-0.3584161997,
-0.6112565398,
-0.7356515527,
0.5542075038,
-0.2596427202,
-0.3881810308,
0.6146267653,
-0.0341996774,
-0.0607190505,
-0.0239992775,
0.0935515389,
-0.0554911196,
0.2989937663,
0.4877520204,
0.444799155,
-0.2147243023,
0.1094392911,
0.3590146005,
0.0063131023,
0.0778466538,
-0.7721917033,
0.403103441,
-0.3037658632,
-0.153449893,
-0.0787354335,
0.0152911535,
0.6628661752,
-0.489959836,
0.266707778,
0.5605792999,
-0.3822240829,
-0.7830497622,
0.0540819019,
0.0640289038,
-0.5092109442,
0.3118359149,
-0.308120966,
-0.9308475256,
0.2753066421,
-0.1046931148,
0.3109189272,
0.2497762442,
0.7865744233,
0.2615811229,
0.4357564151,
0.7516579628,
0.0942657664,
0.1386177987,
-0.4376504719,
0.2230265141,
-0.3490085006,
-0.3073329329,
-0.2749478221,
-0.3728730977,
-0.6040859818,
-0.5579462647,
0.2967272103,
-0.1851717085,
0.1062262952,
0.5649567842,
-0.703912437,
0.3264139593,
0.3295598626,
-0.2862502038,
0.0985649005,
0.0407025702,
-0.256488651,
0.0703467503,
-0.9157834053,
-0.4389926195,
1.0228258371,
0.2655104995,
0.4967225492,
0.0761521086,
0.7112903595,
0.4343228638,
0.3802710474,
-0.9508732557,
0.4453694224,
-0.3242375255,
-0.2895158231,
-0.2794412673,
-0.6738222241,
-1.2639738321,
-0.0334154591,
-0.2499380559,
-0.1578605324,
-0.0682161227,
0.2443578392,
-0.3581299484,
0.3635392189,
-0.4858853221,
1.1837111712,
-0.5877406597,
-0.5036619902,
-0.2437900454,
-0.2770512998,
0.3187025487,
-0.2978332937,
0.5000807643,
0.2824584246,
-0.0963152125,
0.5345561504,
-0.4644619524,
0.8123666048,
-0.0195700265,
-0.520190537,
0.353197068,
0.5828314424,
0.096502535,
0.213832289,
0.0074896226,
0.1322157383,
0.0523615554,
-0.6438292265,
-0.5270978808,
0.8952371478,
-0.3472303748,
-0.0668003708,
-0.0866923854,
-0.7776350379,
-0.171000123,
0.2515350878,
0.158455357,
0.5963253975,
-0.2893925607,
0.1177081764,
0.5291494131,
-0.4430007935,
0.219047904,
0.2618163526,
-0.3993190229,
-0.2189160436,
1.0864261389,
-0.2448660433,
-0.0206083432,
0.5978175998,
-0.2031769603,
0.0178899094,
-0.3141007125,
-0.7110020518,
-0.2130251229,
-0.6771446466,
-0.439480722,
-0.456114471,
0.2220086902,
-0.4255730808,
-0.3792372644,
-0.3475229144,
-0.3253906965,
-0.116112791,
-0.0605692379,
0.1553807557,
0.5328243971,
0.1603720337,
0.0552962944,
-0.6027173996,
0.4193283319,
0.3950772583,
0.2248431891,
-0.2343061715,
-0.1815094948,
-0.4917877614,
0.1702979952,
-0.214242503,
-0.469604969,
0.8315983415,
0.2158833891,
0.4040541649,
0.4084339738,
0.3093367815,
0.4089078903,
-0.3854526579,
0.5515454412,
0.2306911647,
-0.7825172544,
0.4408463538,
-0.0311632585,
0.3389051557,
0.1425252855,
0.356374234,
-0.560950458,
-0.606710732,
-0.4754222035,
-0.9670162201,
0.3546063006,
0.2371078134,
0.2078126967,
0.0410741195,
0.0575209223,
0.5064305663,
0.2063130289,
-0.4387607574,
-0.054695569,
-0.4800586998,
-0.2245071381,
-0.2807709277,
0.111947,
-0.3191054761,
-0.1211389005,
0.598898828,
-0.6102108955,
0.2894932628,
-0.2956132591,
-0.4201777875,
-0.063842833,
0.3726755977,
0.423640728,
0.3325735629,
0.2655988634,
0.1759561896,
0.0421365015,
-0.3556364179,
-0.3453369737,
0.2630193532,
-0.2032607049,
0.1333961338,
0.3825098872,
0.9614428878,
0.5405917764,
-0.8935927153,
0.1906929612,
-0.0474210791,
-0.2312893867,
-0.2541895807,
0.3267204165,
0.1249046922,
0.0167847816,
0.4212989211,
0.1372818202,
0.2759447098,
-0.7432412505,
0.0950738639,
0.2911124527,
-0.1378024369,
-0.2590248883,
0.8492874503,
0.4644551575,
-0.2346311361,
0.3437594473,
-0.5053479671,
-0.609490931,
0.6524530053,
0.3299864531,
0.9387943745,
0.0433770008,
0.4367500544,
0.2596541941,
0.1092379987,
0.2413602769,
-0.0566863082,
-0.3733231127,
-0.4356454313,
-0.5611825585,
-1.0738627911,
-0.3891126812,
-0.1898012012,
-0.6513626575,
0.4258651137,
-0.3670416176,
0.0847473741,
0.1484995782,
-0.1346297711,
-0.5324680209,
0.1438834369,
0.5625650287,
0.8107165098,
-0.640666306,
0.9921419621,
0.8653387427,
-0.160324946,
-0.6681099534,
-0.2601464093,
0.0020603894,
-0.6142622828,
0.7527136803,
0.1166402623,
-0.2368094772,
-0.0046547339,
-0.6077452898,
-0.2145356387,
1.009606719,
0.7661794424,
-0.4415774047,
-0.1476705819,
0.3585903645,
0.5207368731,
-0.6024758816,
-0.169990927,
0.3611700237,
0.3409160972,
0.1597556621,
-1.0927882195,
0.0110459886,
-0.630620718,
-0.1049957722,
0.1590969265,
-0.3226817846,
0.5489856005,
-0.313044548,
-0.245961234,
-0.0964956731,
0.5619244576,
0.0203510318,
0.1852746755,
0.3673333824,
0.369610697,
1.006888032,
-0.1374674141,
1.1525191069,
-0.5634154677,
0.1318739802,
0.8242809772,
-0.0050847852,
0.6512539983,
0.512549758,
0.0638025552,
0.8206409216,
0.5000476837,
-0.116267696,
0.2533544004,
0.2921330631,
-0.1323539317,
-0.140006423,
-0.0405441672,
-0.19023633,
0.5001059771,
0.4019695222,
-0.2226226479,
0.0595422313,
0.2644246221,
0.1471926868,
0.1259981692,
-0.4853311777,
0.404288739,
0.1952306479,
-0.9910549521,
1.0896034241,
0.2666974664,
0.8851036429,
-0.541035533,
-0.0324859172,
-0.2026546746,
0.149754256,
-0.5289270282,
-0.4490161538,
0.4530647993,
0.166308254,
0.1971039325,
-0.6345581412,
0.4754957259,
-0.3756456375,
-0.3755224347,
0.2070722133,
0.0765065625,
0.0950269103,
0.2767454088,
-0.65556705,
0.0909318253,
0.0837802067,
0.1322227865,
0.1518308371,
0.7477869987,
0.0730211139,
0.826228261,
0.6077972651,
0.1597775221,
0.2170318812,
-0.1698548645,
0.7791656852,
-0.2535749972,
-0.8827058077,
-0.4413672388,
0.5268321037,
0.1382372528,
-0.2570140958,
0.5552482009,
0.6671187282,
1.0103338957,
-0.2383689284,
0.7446277738,
-0.3629890978,
0.0797209963,
-0.551692903,
0.7730665207,
-0.5948925614,
0.391900897,
-0.1229955181,
-0.7182489634,
-0.3771604598,
0.3632675409,
-0.0854334384,
-0.4456730485,
0.6686564088,
0.8380034566,
-0.2713491917,
-0.0231908858,
0.2325008363,
0.2564029992,
0.1180479825,
0.6548320651,
0.3077224195,
-0.2131835818,
0.7880230546,
-0.3510587811,
-0.1536495984,
-0.398470819,
-0.8321465254,
-0.616358459,
-0.6584561467,
-0.7103385925,
-0.2896155119,
0.0284163356,
0.674693346,
0.6462978721,
-0.9179097414,
-0.5545125604,
-0.2705579698,
-0.0786531568,
-0.4798592031,
-0.2339279801,
0.0333820321,
-0.6374477148,
-0.9711822867,
0.3187645376,
0.2829776108,
-0.3158001006,
-0.4863778353,
-0.5989530087,
0.4778713286,
-0.2575536072,
0.8128708601,
0.672865808,
-0.4728394151,
0.356416285,
0.1791757345,
-0.2879728675,
-0.1862593591,
0.8350977302,
-0.8490129113,
0.6127740741,
0.1181032956,
0.9476490021,
0.4644963443,
-0.6313567758,
0.6634877324,
-0.6701663733,
0.3521709144,
0.3596981168,
0.3701689541,
0.5365186334,
-0.3047848344,
0.533093214,
0.0982867554,
-0.2790046334,
-1.1322096586,
0.2418968678,
-1.1099852324,
-0.5240293145,
1.1695597172,
-0.1661688387,
-0.2892968953,
0.1361748874,
-0.1944125146,
0.2867918909,
0.0448684096,
0.9044180512,
0.4124462605,
0.1721898764,
0.0517135374,
-0.7508202195,
0.5228373408,
0.510874927,
-0.8127126098,
0.1002875939,
0.5543728471,
0.0533935726,
0.2385365069,
0.0495900735,
-0.108818382,
0.4431496859,
-0.0113565819,
0.2676892281,
-0.3169085979,
-0.1757116616,
-0.1504694968,
0.3968190551,
0.1661022455,
0.0205106977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11558v1
|
Reinforcement Learning with Token-level Feedback for Controllable Text Generation
| 2024-03-18T08:18:37 | 2024-03-18T08:18:37 |
Wendi Li, Wei Wei, Kaihe Xu, Wenfeng Xie, Dangyang Chen, Yu Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To meet the requirements of real-world applications, it is essential to
control generations of large language models (LLMs). Prior research has tried
to introduce reinforcement learning (RL) into controllable text generation
while most existing methods suffer from overfitting issues (finetuning-based
methods) or semantic collapse (post-processing methods). However, current RL
methods are generally guided by coarse-grained (sentence/paragraph-level)
feedback, which may lead to suboptimal performance owing to semantic twists or
progressions within sentences. To tackle that, we propose a novel reinforcement
learning algorithm named TOLE which formulates TOken-LEvel rewards for
controllable text generation, and employs a "first-quantize-then-noise"
paradigm to enhance the robustness of the RL algorithm.Furthermore, TOLE can be
flexibly extended to multiple constraints with little computational expense.
Experimental results show that our algorithm can achieve superior performance
on both single-attribute and multi-attribute control tasks. We have released
our codes at https://github.com/WindyLee0822/CTG
|
[
-0.0391641594,
-0.9264393449,
0.2187672108,
0.6406731606,
-0.2786978185,
0.275249511,
-0.4264854193,
-0.2228066325,
-0.0403821431,
0.34922719,
-0.8353227377,
-0.7805554271,
-0.6701886058,
0.0114486525,
-0.3984662294,
1.2632914782,
-0.0372467376,
-0.3249282241,
-0.0799103081,
0.0293432903,
-0.4476588666,
-0.5268497467,
-1.1220787764,
-0.2459641397,
0.8995064497,
0.4770573676,
0.2682546079,
0.5511635542,
0.0150091564,
0.2951878607,
-0.2197319716,
0.3691097498,
-0.599636972,
0.1923549324,
-0.2704127133,
-0.2608019412,
-0.262516588,
-0.105414927,
0.7770696878,
0.2218841314,
-0.2527553141,
-0.1295157373,
0.1412522644,
0.485965997,
-0.5166119933,
0.3148445785,
-0.3932554722,
0.2765408158,
-0.1216061264,
-0.5201940536,
-0.8447970152,
-0.469830811,
-0.2637429535,
-0.7084231377,
-0.199059844,
0.2597426176,
0.7107594013,
0.3413807154,
-0.3231422901,
-0.3583847284,
-0.6503440142,
0.9672974348,
-0.6908698082,
0.288259238,
0.2537309229,
-0.0462087281,
-0.36050421,
-0.6883529425,
-0.4194200337,
-0.6825497746,
-0.095280394,
0.2339323461,
0.036749322,
0.0878403559,
0.1889724433,
0.10281609,
-0.3437108994,
0.4869700372,
-0.1240900829,
-0.2277876586,
0.5244524479,
0.0165205617,
0.0654832423,
-0.1066362038,
-0.6837567687,
-0.283390373,
-0.4672690928,
0.4600095153,
0.2803560495,
0.4031951427,
0.0142493257,
0.4926224053,
-0.2930037081,
0.3656178415,
0.4226132035,
-0.2292586863,
0.0998040885,
-0.2360194027,
0.0505097844,
0.2205523401,
0.8665471673,
0.0023744134,
0.0368563049,
-0.3661275804,
-0.5576956868,
-0.0156894978,
0.140549019,
-0.8129346967,
0.0435495786,
0.1939384043,
-0.3870897293,
-0.8198291659,
-0.0307271164,
-0.6430465579,
-0.3465060592,
-0.1352797151,
0.5628535151,
-0.5405701399,
-0.2530970275,
-0.1113528758,
0.076316677,
0.0368633196,
0.1277702749,
-0.9210826755,
0.3712258339,
0.6272757649,
0.7462090254,
-0.4642857909,
-0.4468746781,
-1.0874284506,
0.2986949682,
-0.4741431475,
0.6408047676,
-0.3243209422,
-0.4622865617,
0.2105341107,
-0.3525384665,
0.190013051,
-0.5054960847,
0.2260742188,
-0.4410559833,
0.3704615533,
0.1659872681,
-0.5546289682,
0.3666368127,
0.2987706363,
-0.6228619814,
1.1477842331,
0.1777719855,
-0.5636749864,
0.6977063417,
-0.6374630332,
-0.7509408593,
0.0301350467,
-0.2102724463,
-0.8357213736,
0.1618088931,
0.2039669454,
0.2581270635,
0.0622358024,
0.3461464047,
0.0323381685,
-0.1441403031,
0.3896252513,
-0.5659425855,
0.2919817567,
0.0522206649,
-0.3696930408,
0.7101925611,
-0.9759572148,
0.1915273517,
-0.037905436,
-0.6778936982,
-0.028047096,
0.0597193502,
0.1755821556,
0.2918818593,
0.3396407366,
-0.4609988332,
0.2920738161,
-0.2670790553,
0.4520391524,
0.9021184444,
0.07968086,
0.5787351131,
-0.474286586,
0.5771999359,
0.1461781412,
0.1982665658,
-0.1218032464,
0.0531726778,
-0.7675486803,
-0.3667304814,
0.5045948029,
0.4158898294,
-0.9135782719,
0.5816164017,
-0.0558223166,
-0.2000653893,
-0.0603700392,
0.0732370019,
0.6516208053,
0.1878611296,
0.309327215,
-0.1505237371,
-0.1428150088,
-0.3806093335,
-0.1483210474,
-0.2025066614,
-0.0529928356,
0.216033712,
0.3093791306,
0.1324656755,
0.8401876688,
-0.3140715957,
-0.4692366123,
-0.4530558288,
0.4269427359,
-0.4162898362,
0.6321433187,
0.1623679698,
-0.561765492,
-0.1288833022,
-0.0096505312,
-0.2304759771,
-0.3407615125,
-0.4962607622,
-0.0990229398,
0.3777531683,
0.8519812822,
-0.3339197338,
0.3872156143,
0.6709385514,
-0.6297789216,
0.5361629725,
-0.3607407212,
-0.2223692089,
-1.06866014,
-0.0224918071,
-0.0609389693,
-0.5601505637,
-0.3424364626,
-0.1630860269,
0.0305464398,
-0.0613281205,
-0.3918143213,
0.5989747047,
-0.0218389537,
0.2131432146,
-0.383860141,
0.0572161712,
-0.0909932777,
0.8855283856,
0.037293829,
0.884177506,
0.1637225151,
-0.7761782408,
0.21288836,
0.1608785242,
-0.2510046065,
0.5558179617,
-0.4759553373,
-0.164292559,
-0.0663893297,
0.3274023235,
-0.6905581951,
-0.0410684869,
0.1303687841,
-0.6092782617,
0.4294905663,
0.2601234913,
-0.5396082401,
-0.0205997303,
-0.2403011471,
0.4374955893,
0.3744506836,
-0.6395315528,
0.5142962337,
0.1699900329,
-0.2926184535,
-0.3929068148,
-0.5378602147,
-0.034535639,
-0.1084790751,
0.0036065346,
0.3938229084,
-0.0169641525,
0.1981133223,
-0.0175346006,
-0.1240730509,
-0.0817392617,
0.114841789,
0.1731047183,
0.0457096994,
0.2775686681,
0.5430153608,
0.2447386086,
-0.4255660176,
0.0748207495,
-0.6992952824,
0.5656192303,
-0.0146672893,
0.0231544822,
-0.4025687277,
0.2017125487,
0.2292746753,
-0.40801543,
0.623693943,
0.5006219149,
0.0055272034,
-0.9062179923,
-0.0294416249,
-0.1801602691,
-0.5163956285,
0.6951375604,
-0.2807740569,
-1.1918439865,
0.2737956345,
-0.4778555334,
0.1153214499,
0.2618817389,
0.4853699803,
-0.0117633082,
0.9709295034,
0.7308351994,
-0.0463633165,
0.908371985,
-0.0675383955,
0.0035788135,
-0.3130729496,
-0.472109884,
-0.3905726373,
-0.3605074286,
-0.7863949537,
-0.2505141795,
0.1919637918,
0.4185054302,
-0.4468241334,
0.0667491555,
-0.3970720768,
0.3853974938,
0.7585396171,
0.3065252602,
0.3504377604,
-0.0765381008,
-0.3272294998,
0.2490314394,
-1.0410761833,
-0.0848997906,
0.6956276298,
0.2842942774,
0.8837843537,
-0.0366973169,
0.9007959366,
0.3711438477,
0.2260207236,
-0.7347528934,
0.5594009161,
-0.3204126656,
-0.0088054417,
-0.6720312834,
-0.6606494188,
-0.9313338399,
-0.082620874,
-0.371127516,
-0.6373600364,
-0.2049326152,
0.2972616851,
-0.202374056,
0.1322891265,
-0.2418909222,
0.6871254444,
-0.3123737872,
-0.5459803343,
-0.3711397052,
-0.4037715495,
0.1604209542,
0.0645712912,
0.1773409098,
0.1565975398,
-0.1215997264,
0.7172436118,
-0.5732875466,
0.8492518663,
-0.1453867704,
-0.4051602483,
0.1869627237,
0.1252287775,
0.852670908,
0.2389970869,
0.2362971902,
-0.2334103733,
-0.1275059283,
-0.4748739898,
-0.5680134892,
0.6749961376,
-0.6678076386,
-0.2256599367,
-0.3815410435,
-0.5685628057,
-0.2181813866,
0.2596595883,
0.3756437302,
0.5064924359,
-0.0699251667,
0.0411498211,
0.8716227412,
-0.5475292206,
0.5071806908,
0.1505611092,
-0.6299242377,
-0.7732517719,
1.3447329998,
-0.1716269702,
0.3730374873,
0.6118609309,
0.3566887677,
-0.44955948,
-0.4352112114,
-0.2584804296,
-0.0844240263,
-0.3257382512,
-0.2506406009,
-0.225038588,
-0.3862420321,
-0.0564483628,
-0.1472476721,
-0.3383249938,
-0.5283255577,
-0.1973384768,
-0.1521135718,
0.3621456325,
0.748821497,
-0.0744935349,
0.5632805824,
-0.6143783927,
0.2654209435,
0.3254252672,
0.7375872731,
-0.0364840366,
-0.3051876724,
-0.3752611279,
-0.3525002897,
-0.3683802783,
-0.5959759951,
0.2204094082,
0.1978942901,
0.145842135,
0.259283632,
0.1902863085,
0.3834486604,
-0.4190084338,
0.5620889068,
0.3961474299,
-0.9997347593,
0.4846924543,
-0.3074038923,
0.4900240898,
0.3967855275,
-0.2085189223,
-0.6073563695,
-0.8069381118,
-0.5405255556,
-0.9183501005,
0.7119635344,
0.182777524,
0.0465030037,
-0.1007187441,
0.2751763165,
0.0427530892,
0.4708424807,
-1.0066254139,
0.0637674555,
-0.2140866816,
-0.3183870316,
0.0259365849,
-0.1938474327,
0.0187995136,
0.0528930724,
0.6057426929,
-0.1945866495,
0.2452892959,
0.0096997954,
-0.1345392317,
-0.1188131943,
0.454382658,
0.8052746654,
0.1175810546,
0.1752681583,
-0.0077205799,
0.1684136391,
-0.2499116659,
0.1343687922,
-0.013083363,
-0.3722932339,
-0.2048207074,
0.2984720767,
0.9971652031,
0.2693157792,
-0.5988225937,
0.5959526896,
-0.0648548007,
-0.5844630599,
-0.2708170116,
0.0538399778,
-0.3467918336,
0.4233882129,
0.2027174234,
-0.1596005559,
-0.2961117029,
-0.2852580845,
0.3278313577,
0.424397409,
-0.5406638384,
-0.0422705524,
0.81197685,
0.323841244,
-0.3064247668,
0.4851595759,
-0.3794975281,
-0.5698468089,
0.4443374574,
0.7177659273,
0.8452599049,
0.1553423554,
0.4879665077,
0.2254457176,
0.1684051454,
-0.0443528891,
0.3620375395,
-0.1522217095,
-0.3977978528,
-0.8499420285,
-0.6792754531,
-0.3242950439,
0.1760079563,
-0.4554613531,
0.1269025058,
-0.8646036386,
-0.0903403237,
-0.4123643041,
0.0049372264,
-0.1442925632,
0.3327061236,
0.1429831684,
0.9469983578,
-0.5161002278,
0.8497211337,
0.3254844248,
-0.4625205696,
-0.8394346237,
0.1154668704,
-0.3999267817,
-0.3881031871,
0.8020928502,
0.1234059408,
-0.1515590101,
0.3361244202,
-0.6505370736,
-0.602427125,
0.9155012965,
-0.1006333083,
-0.5277860165,
-0.1826790571,
0.2738166749,
0.4519624114,
-0.0986280665,
-0.0345365331,
0.3437550664,
0.5150485635,
0.0754066855,
-0.7727773786,
0.0102907419,
0.0263482351,
0.2054333836,
0.5013026595,
-0.940279901,
0.541402936,
-0.0523837656,
-0.2056026012,
0.2524424195,
1.0427355766,
0.4809443653,
0.2019884735,
0.5878146887,
0.5715630054,
0.8201190829,
-0.132033512,
0.8962733746,
-0.3634598851,
0.2908878624,
1.119767189,
0.0373310968,
0.9017440677,
0.4854764342,
0.0585883707,
0.516074121,
0.4630196393,
0.125187695,
0.722451508,
0.6012913585,
-0.3838762641,
-0.197635591,
-0.2807243764,
0.1671375781,
0.0737281293,
0.2103392184,
-0.0666144416,
-0.1853085458,
0.3246816695,
-0.0277913958,
0.318446368,
-0.5677087903,
1.0610152483,
-0.1217218563,
-0.5403929949,
0.3522353768,
0.110685505,
0.8633704185,
-0.7588153481,
-0.0875018984,
-0.2352356017,
0.3099171817,
-0.0937080532,
-0.505453825,
-0.0175184458,
-0.0961368009,
-0.1155712977,
-0.5189821124,
0.6079615951,
-0.7448826432,
-0.339992106,
0.0798442289,
0.1134296283,
-0.4039136469,
0.2562682927,
-0.3589870632,
-0.0640502572,
-0.115978688,
-0.3615529537,
0.494037509,
0.5836799145,
-0.3197383583,
0.7614881396,
0.5475621819,
0.2667474449,
0.3263829052,
-0.1386009604,
0.8557145,
-0.6410440207,
-0.8226460218,
-0.6291260719,
0.4462477565,
-0.0171937719,
-0.5270804763,
0.3570384383,
0.4977933168,
1.0750154257,
0.1541750282,
0.9019998908,
-0.0543572195,
0.3810682893,
-0.8615142107,
0.5563839078,
-0.4786533117,
0.1011945605,
0.0712428167,
-0.7269162536,
-0.402916193,
0.5574602485,
0.1162446514,
0.1016686857,
0.9059866071,
0.6518079638,
0.3944554627,
-0.3437573314,
0.3024429083,
0.1641735286,
0.5036413074,
0.63333112,
0.9352017641,
-0.0576520562,
0.7265192866,
-0.18196778,
-0.2042885721,
-0.0348525643,
-1.0080496073,
-0.7435259223,
-0.3972051442,
-0.3693334162,
-0.7205670476,
0.2695139349,
1.1116569042,
0.5304995775,
-0.7518690228,
-0.1711460948,
-0.5331745744,
0.0740927905,
-0.399798125,
-0.2005399615,
0.3193825781,
-0.9300890565,
-0.7550276518,
0.3207344711,
0.2921620905,
0.0217115879,
-0.27342695,
-0.4524964094,
0.1464738995,
0.2229002416,
0.6983187199,
0.4446177781,
-0.4433780909,
-0.1855643392,
-0.2344985753,
-0.3958603144,
-0.039209187,
1.0517479181,
-0.8460590243,
0.0612480752,
0.3890327513,
0.6511453986,
0.5388171077,
0.0890050009,
0.5095657706,
-1.2626645565,
0.2647648156,
0.2040916234,
-0.1781255901,
-0.1486133784,
-0.2263717055,
0.0799656808,
-0.0505673848,
-0.6199166179,
-0.5203982592,
0.381698966,
-0.9677621722,
-0.4576618373,
1.2149040699,
0.0246477742,
-0.1931064576,
0.4171332419,
-0.3994123638,
0.5361095071,
-0.7348349094,
0.8859709501,
0.5560667515,
0.061130479,
-0.4725264907,
-0.1034056619,
0.8533562422,
0.4805850685,
-0.9621585011,
0.1646048874,
0.5727354288,
-0.131997928,
-0.2293204665,
0.4426018596,
-0.0629759133,
0.3077687025,
-0.1401587576,
0.098731488,
-0.2777307332,
-0.593528688,
-0.3900185525,
0.3185575008,
0.4941286445,
-0.1279032528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15449v1
|
Hatred Stems from Ignorance! Distillation of the Persuasion Modes in Countering Conversational Hate Speech
| 2024-03-18T07:20:35 | 2024-03-18T07:20:35 |
Ghadi Alyahya, Abeer Aldayel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Examining the factors that the counter-speech uses is at the core of
understanding the optimal methods for confronting hate speech online. Various
studies assess the emotional base factor used in counter speech, such as
emotion-empathy, offensiveness, and level of hostility. To better understand
the counter-speech used in conversational interactions, this study distills
persuasion modes into reason, emotion, and credibility and then evaluates their
use in two types of conversation interactions: closed (multi-turn) and open
(single-turn) conversation interactions concerning racism, sexism, and
religion. The evaluation covers the distinct behaviors of human versus
generated counter-speech. We also assess the interplay between the replies'
stance and each mode of persuasion in the counter-speech. Notably, we observe
nuanced differences in the counter-speech persuasion modes for open and closed
interactions -- especially on the topic level -- with a general tendency to use
reason as a persuasion mode to express the counterpoint to hate comments. The
generated counter-speech tends to exhibit an emotional persuasion mode, while
human counters lean towards using reasoning. Furthermore, our study shows that
reason as a persuasion mode tends to obtain more supportive replies than do
other persuasion types. The findings highlight the potential of incorporating
persuasion modes into studies about countering hate speech, as these modes can
serve as an optimal means of explainability and paves the way for the further
adoption of the reply's stance and the role it plays in assessing what
comprises the optimal counter-speech.
|
[
-0.9285966754,
-1.0922876596,
0.3895320594,
-0.0343124084,
-0.3688185215,
-0.0326165333,
-0.2066658437,
-0.312782228,
0.3871917427,
0.3250439167,
-0.623988986,
-0.1167355627,
-0.6512030959,
0.0712434277,
-0.3243552744,
1.2493983507,
0.4580143094,
0.2039953172,
-0.1706068218,
-0.3326814473,
-0.1547391415,
-0.7722350359,
-0.5253152251,
-0.3484493792,
0.6320722699,
0.2935114503,
0.5777844787,
0.292378366,
0.110727109,
0.3426496089,
0.3004800677,
-0.3650395572,
-0.8306512833,
0.475420177,
-0.2745540142,
-0.3273249567,
-0.1136286929,
0.1976709217,
-0.030613808,
0.2043125778,
0.0276469626,
-0.0146460533,
-0.039197892,
0.4582886398,
-0.5130221248,
-0.257358253,
-0.9279711843,
-0.0093167964,
-0.4156324565,
-0.0506860465,
-0.3386591375,
-0.3393889666,
0.4368042052,
-0.4678377807,
0.2080232054,
-0.0196710099,
0.5462508798,
0.1767921895,
-0.6488747001,
-0.6012151241,
-0.8025944233,
0.8877587914,
-0.580489397,
0.4023844302,
0.4415468872,
0.2286464572,
0.132705763,
-0.1693291664,
-0.7525885105,
-0.2088927031,
-0.0712363496,
0.3825764954,
-0.8328149319,
0.2646046281,
0.3957189023,
0.1267825365,
-0.4236598015,
-0.0601624846,
-0.5964033604,
-0.0849035308,
0.6241073608,
0.0028778801,
0.44192186,
-0.1937544197,
-0.3324424922,
0.1154520512,
-0.5858494043,
-0.1514325291,
0.5769807696,
0.0204899963,
-0.1119563952,
0.4609889686,
-0.0162243843,
0.6532179117,
0.1975943446,
-0.2641869187,
-0.2241013199,
-0.0225515105,
-0.288957864,
0.3228007555,
0.6001068354,
0.7431368232,
0.4984724224,
-0.1100741699,
0.2175786793,
0.5263997316,
0.4725401103,
-0.7878084779,
-0.2330591232,
-0.0884927362,
-0.3865830898,
-0.2880846858,
-0.3583950698,
-1.340927124,
-0.6605871916,
-0.1934392899,
0.2470570356,
-0.2607429028,
-0.3492979407,
-0.528446734,
-0.530246377,
0.0035284213,
0.1868691593,
-0.7098520398,
0.4930396974,
0.4216272831,
0.6663164496,
-0.2450233698,
0.3360286653,
-0.3955312669,
-0.1937361211,
-0.2285052687,
0.6280944943,
-0.7637025118,
-0.5627679825,
-0.117786929,
-0.3470441401,
0.1337965578,
-0.5483282804,
0.7338472605,
-0.369849205,
0.4842054248,
-0.5044755936,
-0.3669230938,
-0.5778411031,
0.2896876931,
-0.3276809454,
0.4353342056,
-0.0074962392,
-0.6801332235,
0.3742083013,
-0.5622227192,
-0.5115510821,
0.072593078,
-0.3027321994,
-0.1599451005,
0.2721693814,
-0.3186806142,
-0.1904523224,
-0.3736312687,
-0.1185665578,
-0.3684244156,
0.1417304575,
0.3300330639,
-0.5203805566,
0.8945915103,
0.4699937403,
-0.8634949923,
0.2591004074,
-0.5055379272,
-0.3633473516,
0.2420329303,
0.1195004582,
-0.843944788,
0.3373114467,
-0.159052521,
0.3102834821,
-0.2740706503,
-0.8322775364,
-0.3865124881,
-0.5322566628,
0.3011435866,
0.91507864,
0.0824439228,
0.1460313648,
-0.429774344,
0.6020330787,
0.1903583407,
0.1767089814,
0.3772516251,
-0.6269822121,
-0.7927004695,
0.1032733321,
-0.6327062249,
0.5171141624,
-0.4397785664,
-0.0780483559,
0.3558944166,
-0.8800478578,
-0.2925190926,
-0.0797124356,
0.6723977923,
1.0085245371,
0.7143310905,
0.0197333917,
-1.0496096611,
-0.9785943031,
-0.3894226551,
-0.4292399883,
0.38111642,
0.2843705118,
0.2751271427,
0.1961416751,
0.8945706487,
-0.3196289241,
0.2218165994,
-0.4304481447,
0.2757926881,
-0.3517472446,
0.1946018189,
0.8666163087,
-1.0355045795,
-0.7408377528,
-0.4145277143,
-0.443387866,
-0.2712872326,
0.0334053971,
-0.1428882033,
0.2540324628,
0.22397919,
-0.0914073661,
0.6534864306,
0.6047347188,
-0.4948731065,
0.5013333559,
0.7475469112,
0.4861465693,
-0.8571980596,
-0.4204809368,
0.2525352836,
0.1757667214,
-1.0289174318,
-0.1730014831,
-0.7033400536,
0.0731707588,
-0.4920558333,
0.2046958357,
-0.1225820705,
0.2128545046,
-0.235149473,
0.3246488571,
0.0117464811,
0.1141482964,
0.1902287155,
0.4791512787,
0.3837563396,
-0.67210114,
0.5737241507,
0.0385304019,
-0.0962779075,
0.9813938737,
-0.6065404415,
0.0474421605,
-0.1890399307,
0.052554559,
-0.9002165794,
0.1594325751,
0.6534305215,
-0.4645953774,
-0.2584080994,
-0.3866362572,
0.209561035,
-0.3097518981,
-0.1447837353,
0.2138054222,
0.4863837957,
-0.2219666392,
0.5943709016,
0.4570554495,
-0.1327080131,
-0.4313295186,
-0.574936986,
-0.0566520616,
-0.6686714292,
-0.3638731837,
0.220966056,
-0.3275565505,
-1.151288271,
-0.2240756005,
-0.1574608833,
0.0490367189,
0.016815342,
0.6171909571,
0.1436177194,
-0.1244202331,
0.02644342,
0.2279179841,
0.2563973069,
0.4766502976,
0.0690703541,
0.5995223522,
0.0280247126,
-0.2692655325,
-0.1147118285,
0.5732169151,
0.6815888286,
0.1853956729,
0.8009153605,
0.2606332898,
-0.3207900822,
0.070278883,
-0.6673881412,
-0.4342248738,
-0.3871496618,
0.2905659974,
-0.3682749569,
-0.6637475491,
0.3001922071,
0.3514711261,
0.1222729236,
0.545116365,
0.5730775595,
-0.0411966071,
1.0348474979,
0.0780439377,
-0.0537380651,
0.3658124804,
0.5013386011,
0.3035309017,
-0.2815193236,
-0.2976700068,
-0.8584164977,
-0.2226838022,
-0.4108646512,
-0.1198369861,
0.4359689355,
-0.0284895934,
-0.3013585508,
0.2124473155,
-0.4965210557,
0.1943785101,
0.2877780795,
-0.1842788011,
0.2312904,
0.277600348,
-0.0515152663,
-0.6124703884,
-0.3957566619,
-0.0636848137,
0.7298918962,
0.2485001236,
0.4924690723,
0.4918677211,
0.4532902241,
0.3107649684,
0.4819959402,
-0.7479827404,
0.6593877673,
0.0249261186,
-0.8292624354,
-0.1494334936,
-0.4250898361,
-0.6290421486,
0.277600944,
-0.4371113777,
-0.7161018848,
-0.0989706218,
0.3133441508,
-0.0854799449,
0.5028796792,
-0.5625600815,
0.7371826172,
-0.2527536452,
-0.2452012002,
-0.4732254446,
-0.4206951261,
0.4976018667,
0.2045801878,
0.3164365888,
0.161434263,
0.3298389316,
0.9942500591,
-0.2979616523,
0.7727600336,
-0.245140776,
-0.1487708837,
0.3699917793,
0.2600794733,
0.1039134338,
-0.3388652205,
-0.0810203329,
0.2124619931,
-0.3046044111,
-0.0606018752,
-0.4725211859,
0.6671674848,
-0.6992592812,
-0.8504401445,
-0.4088816345,
-0.3044559658,
-0.1642129421,
0.0586120188,
0.5793711543,
0.462274611,
-0.6085407734,
0.2058435678,
0.9197970033,
-0.3476681709,
0.3199954927,
0.5575547218,
-0.3081611991,
-0.39648664,
0.91452384,
0.1560561508,
0.714613378,
0.2482184917,
0.5411222577,
-0.507201314,
-0.3152266741,
-0.6115111113,
-0.0680021271,
-0.6174241304,
0.0817157254,
-0.9047924876,
-0.0240836553,
-0.7887486815,
-0.290191263,
-0.0999326259,
-0.2329944372,
0.0239874348,
-0.21151568,
0.6402940154,
0.8880488276,
-0.3366355896,
0.205175519,
-0.267980814,
0.4243901968,
0.6808618903,
-0.2177974135,
0.0373071693,
-0.6256245971,
0.2842234969,
0.2255604565,
-0.2462812364,
-1.5793651342,
0.2821237147,
-0.2143378556,
0.5033496022,
0.9080859423,
0.535092175,
0.6730092168,
-0.1791872531,
0.8053104877,
0.3802221715,
-0.7840652466,
0.6566590667,
-0.2184961289,
-0.1728959382,
0.3404633701,
0.9123520255,
-0.6175735593,
-0.6976746917,
-0.6798070073,
-0.5043281317,
0.3377373815,
0.0536225624,
-0.1037077457,
-0.2858701646,
-0.4056093097,
0.0148523506,
0.1793655157,
-0.8620656133,
-0.9026216269,
-0.7313376665,
0.0152157741,
0.0473957397,
-0.5371625423,
-0.9167177081,
-0.1310594678,
0.5545384288,
0.3183472157,
-0.0843488127,
0.0726547614,
-0.1007123664,
-0.264801532,
0.5484543443,
0.9465648532,
0.7161610126,
-0.053925585,
0.4890233874,
0.0202718601,
-0.5493202806,
0.0885757506,
0.0305311177,
-0.4037336707,
0.121924825,
0.0792275518,
0.8182582259,
-0.1577685475,
-0.3518874347,
0.2530012131,
0.0965752304,
-0.1803204119,
-0.2245372236,
-0.023347659,
0.023889171,
0.0649143532,
0.258811146,
0.1817557067,
0.1454228908,
-0.6587244868,
0.1043467,
0.6186069846,
-0.5611849427,
-0.2129692286,
0.6237969398,
0.3582047224,
-0.3171105385,
0.4239210486,
-0.2608052492,
-0.875651896,
0.3711451292,
0.8589985967,
0.7794904113,
-0.2152076513,
0.5424646735,
0.5039976239,
0.318510443,
0.7773438096,
-0.0651326478,
-0.1070928946,
-0.7417550087,
0.0280172564,
-0.6122294068,
-0.3969273567,
0.2996985912,
-0.6889407039,
-0.3473797143,
-0.5726485848,
-0.0732502937,
-0.0229354016,
-0.1665167361,
-0.2363932282,
0.1808356196,
0.3465876579,
0.7550736666,
-0.9918214083,
0.2569230497,
0.4048386514,
-0.6042208076,
-0.4484460056,
0.0181543715,
0.798628509,
-0.5895811915,
0.6369001865,
0.0238273107,
-0.6514741778,
-0.1422873437,
-0.5714533925,
-0.4167863429,
0.247693941,
0.0127013763,
-0.5489946604,
0.4445762038,
0.1725378335,
0.4080484509,
-0.2950490415,
0.2395539433,
0.4029622376,
0.5427934527,
-0.0003899468,
-0.7009885311,
0.305650413,
-0.1206010431,
-0.4201331437,
-0.0336976759,
-0.5508333445,
0.7284218669,
0.1143067479,
-0.2949745655,
-0.3359261155,
0.5669902563,
0.2650564313,
0.4815995991,
0.935716629,
0.5797469616,
0.2306949943,
-0.0691024065,
0.5340301394,
-0.120194003,
-0.3690864146,
0.9405542016,
-0.1362127066,
0.3533119559,
0.4478144348,
-0.1027846634,
0.8561493754,
0.0306398477,
0.27048859,
0.1859929413,
0.4720654488,
-0.7338156104,
-0.1832739264,
-0.5003086925,
-0.4660604894,
0.5494504571,
0.5634750724,
-0.0729044303,
-0.3484220803,
0.2973961532,
0.4820026755,
0.5976971388,
-0.3477490544,
0.7933571935,
-0.1492353678,
-0.7749655247,
0.2788048685,
0.0289647542,
0.7695351839,
-0.5569033027,
-0.0389997885,
-0.1405886561,
-0.1916070879,
-0.3312752247,
-0.465313226,
0.521787107,
0.3282209933,
-0.3021776676,
-0.1797599941,
0.7541239262,
-0.3824934065,
0.1222302467,
0.324426949,
0.1922345757,
0.2678338587,
-0.1823050827,
-0.800671041,
0.1834178567,
0.239819333,
-0.0603505373,
0.5629731417,
0.1837212443,
0.0739645064,
0.4868509173,
0.608355701,
0.1394668818,
0.2040375173,
0.1316124648,
0.9611921906,
-0.5146339536,
-0.2549750805,
-1.1004593372,
0.3116763532,
-0.2362476587,
-0.4558112025,
0.9913603067,
0.5684654713,
0.8373104334,
0.0554571375,
0.8556169868,
-0.462100178,
0.7769384384,
-0.2097368091,
0.8114631772,
-0.3613007963,
-0.3837769032,
-0.5894957185,
-0.7245007753,
0.2164064795,
0.6678857803,
-0.6598386168,
-0.1025167778,
0.5197591186,
0.8772701025,
0.3172490597,
0.2992272079,
0.3812296689,
0.491353482,
0.471431464,
0.3550965488,
0.7730432153,
-0.0924267918,
0.757375896,
-0.3749379218,
-0.3664375544,
-0.023806043,
-0.5447158813,
-0.7871138453,
-0.5699525476,
-0.3054355681,
-0.7599560022,
0.0115341563,
0.673240006,
0.4394643307,
-0.7807710767,
-0.2592871487,
-0.0259300694,
0.4754671752,
-0.1414173692,
-0.3383324146,
-0.3044016659,
0.1110376865,
-0.9310963154,
0.5839630365,
0.3690695465,
-0.0367259048,
-0.29731673,
-0.0992451981,
-0.4166328907,
0.2908195853,
0.753555119,
0.7786373496,
-0.9062240124,
-0.2417229265,
0.013570874,
0.0007080649,
-0.1896193475,
0.7930058837,
-0.64565593,
0.6327183843,
0.409915179,
0.1839483976,
0.0466668755,
0.3331834674,
0.504348278,
-0.3063280582,
0.2938984036,
0.3782998323,
0.038555298,
-0.0007542751,
-0.0115268407,
0.0886285082,
0.6931532621,
-0.3565738201,
-0.7276885509,
0.8128221035,
-0.9029507041,
-0.2617292702,
0.9459426403,
0.0177209917,
0.2300197631,
-0.592402041,
-0.2387814671,
0.2778499126,
-0.6115063429,
0.5877839923,
0.6384244561,
-0.3865220249,
-0.3237996399,
-0.1923602521,
0.7889640927,
0.4148536026,
-0.6996988654,
-0.0555522814,
0.8629056215,
0.0145073617,
0.3381586075,
0.5510758162,
0.0731023476,
0.0425570793,
0.3514942229,
-0.1945123971,
0.1911723316,
-0.3271305859,
0.0865966901,
0.4138841629,
-0.2854986191,
-0.0304036662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16852v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16852v1
|
A Disease Labeler for Chinese Chest X-Ray Report Generation
| 2024-03-18T07:10:33 | 2024-03-18T07:10:33 |
Mengwei Wang, Ruixin Yan, Zeyi Hou, Ning Lang, Xiuzhuang Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.IV
|
In the field of medical image analysis, the scarcity of Chinese chest X-ray
report datasets has hindered the development of technology for generating
Chinese chest X-ray reports. On one hand, the construction of a Chinese chest
X-ray report dataset is limited by the time-consuming and costly process of
accurate expert disease annotation. On the other hand, a single natural
language generation metric is commonly used to evaluate the similarity between
generated and ground-truth reports, while the clinical accuracy and
effectiveness of the generated reports rely on an accurate disease labeler
(classifier). To address the issues, this study proposes a disease labeler
tailored for the generation of Chinese chest X-ray reports. This labeler
leverages a dual BERT architecture to handle diagnostic reports and clinical
information separately and constructs a hierarchical label learning algorithm
based on the affiliation between diseases and body parts to enhance text
classification performance. Utilizing this disease labeler, a Chinese chest
X-ray report dataset comprising 51,262 report samples was established. Finally,
experiments and analyses were conducted on a subset of expert-annotated Chinese
chest X-ray reports, validating the effectiveness of the proposed disease
labeler.
|
[
0.0150233842,
-0.1585508883,
0.1574025303,
0.0978834629,
-0.5467176437,
-0.1196835637,
0.210630998,
-0.7820894718,
0.2967745066,
0.3996428549,
-0.2385466546,
-0.7833958268,
-0.5262393951,
-0.1792482585,
-0.0321634077,
1.2368716002,
0.3551809192,
-0.0294138454,
0.1182132065,
0.0034013521,
-0.5861036777,
-0.3848968744,
-1.0787540674,
-0.2999618053,
0.6080709696,
-0.0996904895,
1.0370569229,
0.956414938,
0.6795405149,
0.1666393876,
0.2503696382,
0.2806424797,
-0.1008727401,
-0.0695744902,
0.1525745541,
-0.3233165145,
-0.7088155746,
-0.3768963516,
0.2392537147,
0.2027233392,
0.3823631108,
0.131788075,
-0.4050010443,
0.648750782,
-0.1188962907,
0.355825454,
-0.098629117,
0.6030187607,
-0.6263955832,
-0.4464413524,
-0.2998150885,
-0.2598433495,
0.4476400614,
-0.5443009138,
0.2905192375,
0.0905342549,
0.9407832623,
0.1497837156,
-0.3326349854,
-0.3042291701,
-0.1916247457,
0.497086674,
-0.5441074371,
0.2510843277,
0.153039217,
0.5947734714,
0.2874554396,
-0.9100365043,
0.2791191936,
-0.1335978359,
-0.467577219,
0.2341902852,
-0.225134626,
-0.113208726,
-0.3700419366,
0.375092119,
-1.1007320881,
0.3902287483,
-0.445468545,
-0.4000085294,
1.0225155354,
0.0199581608,
0.7125519514,
-0.4895741642,
-0.6268844008,
-0.0633565858,
-0.5286576748,
-0.1473968625,
-0.4261404276,
0.3331692815,
0.1440175176,
-0.173020646,
0.0012542391,
0.7428853512,
0.0656843334,
-0.7060614824,
0.5738016963,
-0.1049070358,
-0.3508322835,
0.7699577808,
0.696926415,
0.5200978518,
-0.5411249399,
-0.2838968337,
-0.260836184,
-0.1585201025,
0.1441596746,
-0.8742829561,
-0.6549013257,
0.3629500866,
-0.7750422359,
-0.5661725998,
0.0805776641,
-0.4120617509,
-0.6694018841,
0.2088257372,
0.3695851564,
-0.3439642787,
-0.0940662324,
-0.2064012885,
-0.3100624681,
-0.1279025078,
0.0920514613,
-0.5227632523,
-0.0346782133,
0.2461543381,
0.6520350575,
0.0668884963,
0.3254367411,
-0.7229590416,
0.3897483945,
-0.3798500896,
0.8696818352,
-0.2874168158,
-0.5072795153,
-0.2212784439,
-0.0566722602,
0.0782236457,
-0.5305226445,
0.4425832331,
-0.3868034482,
-0.0685479641,
-0.1119928136,
-0.2952567339,
-0.2010722756,
0.3109990954,
-0.8338772655,
0.7979727983,
0.1996062398,
-0.8010087013,
0.6421604156,
-0.2364903092,
-0.5116350055,
0.5680130124,
-0.543661356,
-0.6302329302,
-0.0485647842,
0.2878357172,
0.6386256814,
-0.3492116332,
0.4546560049,
0.3761371076,
-0.1097405106,
0.157209456,
-0.1527982801,
0.7176055908,
0.0943641663,
-0.415037334,
0.0141871367,
-0.8680539131,
0.2202282548,
0.293148458,
-0.14632155,
-0.4526253343,
0.4080777764,
-0.1258393228,
0.3107053936,
0.1428013146,
-0.8016792536,
0.2727368474,
-0.2541854978,
-0.0391717851,
0.5382778645,
0.0007654373,
-0.4394754767,
-0.9396549463,
0.279715389,
0.1171130836,
0.1727457941,
-0.2456196249,
-0.7673761845,
-0.4511751533,
-0.4479329884,
0.2390996367,
0.5266839862,
-0.6709982753,
0.5882116556,
-0.3265237808,
-0.8419824839,
-0.7254194617,
-0.1393693686,
0.7634570599,
0.557728827,
0.4118942618,
-0.2882598341,
-0.577144146,
-0.8623671532,
0.1519974768,
-0.1440333128,
-0.1320264935,
0.4579982162,
-0.0581919514,
-0.1616511047,
0.5033378601,
-0.864821732,
-0.9327341914,
-0.1090295985,
0.2795378566,
-0.0474764779,
0.2902733088,
0.8378230333,
-0.6943590641,
-0.7022498846,
0.6268222332,
-0.7905594707,
-0.2192068398,
-0.3059052825,
-0.1916823387,
0.5062554479,
0.2265618742,
0.1382011473,
0.5156747103,
0.5617899299,
0.0262705125,
0.5563879013,
-0.5067260265,
0.0522058085,
-0.6708215475,
0.0806115046,
0.3719281554,
-0.2012226284,
-0.583604455,
-0.0065200715,
0.0035070493,
-0.1098666787,
-0.2499197125,
0.2813817859,
-0.3329119384,
0.5436868668,
-0.0262159184,
0.1629012823,
0.1757377684,
0.144521758,
0.5159062743,
-0.0504963957,
0.7057937384,
-0.4417927265,
0.2391874194,
0.2508782148,
-0.278911829,
0.3012414575,
-0.665588975,
0.0576904304,
-0.1136677191,
0.3617486954,
-0.898568809,
-0.1144541875,
0.4362000823,
-0.4101628661,
0.5529053211,
0.0599597655,
-0.50332582,
-0.6718049049,
-0.400259614,
0.0959189981,
0.5599960089,
-0.7700785398,
0.1495353281,
0.3243266046,
-0.1458061188,
-0.3513602614,
-1.0882315636,
-0.1600770205,
0.1891311854,
-0.7392174006,
0.5785623789,
-0.116403386,
0.1736326218,
0.0945177674,
-0.2873529196,
-0.4498466849,
-0.1570230126,
0.1868071258,
0.4129348397,
-0.5183534622,
0.2890516818,
0.1233817339,
-0.3598260283,
0.0769100934,
-0.3334208727,
-0.2317412198,
0.2622167468,
-0.2791025341,
-0.527182281,
0.3056980371,
0.19567734,
-0.2667615414,
0.2574882507,
0.4113186002,
-0.3950976729,
-0.250402391,
-0.12486168,
0.3140894771,
-0.4332382679,
0.4952173233,
-0.3418436646,
-0.2768512964,
0.0005817115,
0.3181337714,
0.2614829242,
0.3899850547,
0.3495035172,
0.109810181,
1.0920920372,
0.409152627,
-0.2556942701,
-0.2424461693,
0.0161038376,
0.4533898532,
-0.4858937562,
-0.341293335,
-0.3404248357,
-0.3204739392,
-0.3939734101,
-0.1867302209,
0.6134220362,
-0.5940481424,
0.2071224898,
-0.1726529598,
-1.2602308989,
0.1433497816,
0.3685550094,
0.6347123384,
0.3149913549,
-0.0839048252,
0.5461944938,
-0.2184858769,
-0.9362925291,
-0.3553656936,
0.8490297794,
0.0641720593,
0.4741986692,
0.0704060793,
0.9203646779,
0.4673036635,
0.6280223131,
-0.6241197586,
-0.0513244197,
-0.93115592,
-0.6734930873,
-0.0564325601,
-0.2475173771,
-1.2438322306,
0.2565008402,
0.0716562271,
-0.649238646,
0.0620246381,
0.3886815608,
-0.6421147585,
0.5024043322,
-0.54776752,
0.8431432247,
-0.7366488576,
0.1030425578,
0.2698255777,
-0.8980247974,
0.6366667747,
-0.5044573545,
0.384588182,
0.0433854535,
0.2545256317,
0.8844807744,
-0.573166132,
1.0962018967,
-0.2211616635,
-0.3521718979,
0.2154039443,
-0.0311820954,
-0.0868813396,
0.172140345,
-0.0330985747,
-0.0009288476,
0.1290028989,
-0.3366472721,
-0.259785831,
0.461255759,
-0.7662537694,
-0.6019640565,
-0.5016908646,
-0.4855790138,
0.1262328923,
0.4905286431,
0.5681374669,
0.8641383648,
-0.2907954454,
-0.2020076811,
0.7229065895,
-0.4779877663,
-0.0648077503,
0.5411313772,
-0.0772988945,
-0.3435832262,
1.4979064465,
0.6916587949,
0.0760713592,
0.8174815774,
0.4064164758,
0.229978025,
-0.3203760982,
-0.4683688283,
0.0994573385,
-0.2976730466,
-0.5505311489,
-0.245204255,
-0.5085719228,
-0.1786795855,
-0.4080928266,
-0.0338611007,
0.0509976111,
-0.1756010652,
0.2031494528,
0.1223332733,
0.821543932,
-0.0978844762,
0.2477056384,
-1.0251598358,
0.3876481652,
-0.0048827864,
0.0218701381,
0.1824222058,
-0.2525407076,
-0.4621427953,
0.0989310443,
-0.2984452248,
-0.7087542415,
0.4986453056,
0.2548145354,
0.5076668262,
0.6722304821,
0.6210061312,
0.387655437,
-0.0873487145,
0.6297267079,
0.2561246753,
-0.5967821479,
0.8579027057,
-0.0463080779,
0.2552301884,
-0.126616925,
0.3238573372,
-0.4285973907,
-0.6716365814,
-0.5143662095,
-0.8039621711,
0.7804164886,
-0.0198934581,
-0.2313195616,
-0.0232390612,
0.0484086946,
0.5013397932,
-0.2737598717,
-0.449059844,
-0.5671477318,
-0.271386981,
-0.0496837869,
0.0971486568,
-0.2032133937,
-0.101067245,
-0.0994835496,
0.8119130135,
0.0071684327,
0.1340203583,
0.5634181499,
-0.2536941171,
-0.1301456541,
-0.0165741444,
0.0506678633,
0.3452157378,
-0.4927440882,
0.0748878196,
-0.4965412617,
-0.1913196146,
-0.128990829,
0.3094339967,
-0.2062096894,
0.3993271291,
0.3829447627,
0.59399575,
0.0885109976,
-0.531863451,
0.5319576263,
0.0203059763,
-0.4468770325,
-0.1012206972,
0.0031186603,
0.0067954352,
0.0272745583,
0.2330416292,
0.2140862048,
0.2176934034,
-0.2208070606,
0.469129771,
-0.0185185205,
-0.7436234355,
-0.1750723124,
0.8180806041,
0.4149062335,
0.0078639975,
0.9352596402,
-0.3650485575,
-0.2132290304,
0.9218945503,
0.5299042463,
0.4591955543,
-0.2962136269,
0.5200108886,
0.0990650505,
0.3952613473,
0.4387007952,
-0.0367183574,
0.0469843298,
-0.4532959461,
-0.3037922382,
0.0067281378,
-0.0699611157,
0.0251684748,
-0.9409867525,
0.2621122897,
-0.2593197525,
-0.0239724144,
0.4835993052,
0.1430573463,
-0.1637836695,
0.6910668612,
0.7808545828,
0.9477799535,
-0.7750280499,
1.0449696779,
0.749841392,
-0.4752024412,
-0.6439692974,
-0.1334458143,
0.3347910941,
-0.9554356337,
0.6954126358,
0.48659724,
0.2945804894,
-0.2237007618,
-0.0200588927,
-0.6871029735,
1.3529634476,
0.1172238588,
-0.402495265,
0.2151553929,
-0.0186170917,
0.5712764859,
-0.1532087624,
0.0316302776,
0.4847057462,
0.4846095443,
0.0478174463,
-1.0024420023,
0.4470724463,
-0.4933921397,
0.0119092213,
0.179543674,
-1.1282842159,
0.3895328939,
-0.4020001888,
-0.1373372972,
0.2628738582,
0.5742227435,
0.3754211664,
0.4537524581,
0.2932733595,
0.4097557664,
0.9933724999,
0.0263777617,
1.1311510801,
-0.1526272446,
0.0781308562,
0.8349414468,
-0.1409817338,
0.2317941189,
-0.302123636,
0.0045531625,
0.4699790478,
0.6469860077,
-0.3636655211,
0.4138401151,
0.3419294655,
-0.1912337393,
-0.0027471913,
-0.1694243699,
-0.6833234429,
0.1733389497,
0.394169718,
-0.661662221,
-0.2780793905,
0.0828342363,
0.1651109457,
-0.5005110502,
-0.19165802,
0.5217300653,
-0.3891745508,
-0.1063656285,
0.6363557577,
-0.1168770939,
0.5172997713,
-0.7823585868,
0.1359895915,
-0.0713533014,
0.2134005278,
-0.5084559917,
-0.6823977232,
0.3120129108,
-0.3413128257,
-0.3517751098,
0.0356908999,
0.7344405651,
-0.3862663507,
-0.4834842682,
0.2035617232,
0.3099272549,
0.4303575754,
0.1429349184,
-0.546146214,
0.2307374775,
0.2916454673,
-0.0069742166,
0.4416221976,
0.5203934312,
-0.2224656194,
0.5475106239,
0.1035947576,
0.1758159399,
-0.0304477401,
-0.1062372923,
0.7334961891,
-0.2724299431,
-0.4076063931,
-0.2188352644,
0.5501976609,
-0.1171094552,
-0.3850341737,
0.3915891647,
0.6834409237,
0.539121747,
-0.0379385687,
1.3865163326,
-0.3526689112,
0.1659992039,
-0.2009265274,
0.960799098,
-0.7058498263,
0.1105089933,
-0.0436125621,
0.1095537394,
-0.8919782043,
0.2125518769,
0.1238980517,
-0.2026215345,
0.6645038724,
0.645901978,
0.198194176,
-0.2498063147,
0.3692744076,
0.4138298333,
0.421553582,
0.7564609051,
0.0916137844,
-0.5337126255,
0.7890802622,
-0.6778305769,
-0.6500607729,
-0.2441649288,
-0.4873056412,
-0.7999016047,
-0.2390204668,
-0.9712413549,
-0.0371008813,
0.3954877257,
0.2862358689,
1.1284703016,
-0.7275285721,
-0.0662392303,
0.516700983,
-0.0102469735,
-0.5388435125,
-0.2265124023,
1.0453187227,
-0.3864139318,
-0.5006580949,
0.0932901502,
0.2924503982,
-0.1952142119,
0.1461786628,
0.0343487263,
0.2203381211,
-0.3225486577,
0.8047701716,
0.4477777481,
-0.6528007984,
-0.2223035246,
-0.2288035452,
-0.2813552022,
0.2952063084,
0.5519300103,
-0.8752381206,
0.8995059729,
0.1545689702,
0.5687849522,
0.0188704561,
-0.2224867493,
0.4109048843,
-0.988416791,
-0.2378602326,
-0.0896417052,
0.1775706559,
0.0945366323,
-0.795255959,
0.3429539502,
0.1420378983,
-0.5387399793,
-0.6037218571,
-0.2410475165,
-1.1431773901,
-0.4996218681,
0.5043849945,
-0.2616236806,
-0.4222214222,
-0.1261546016,
-0.5952141285,
0.2117086798,
-0.2701102793,
0.7826077342,
0.0227401648,
-0.6703270078,
0.0943442434,
-0.0446801558,
0.2262064517,
0.1220239028,
-0.6406527162,
-0.0864915252,
0.2655264437,
0.0871983543,
0.2122525573,
0.6982264519,
-0.226873368,
0.5830395222,
-0.0146655161,
0.1782576442,
-0.2008464336,
0.1285727024,
0.3145598769,
0.0354240164,
0.0286722016,
-0.5891090631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11509v1
|
DEE: Dual-stage Explainable Evaluation Method for Text Generation
| 2024-03-18T06:30:41 | 2024-03-18T06:30:41 |
Shenyu Zhang, Yu Li, Rui Wu, Xiutian Huang, Yongrui Chen, Wenhao Xu, Guilin Qi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic methods for evaluating machine-generated texts hold significant
importance due to the expanding applications of generative systems.
Conventional methods tend to grapple with a lack of explainability, issuing a
solitary numerical score to signify the assessment outcome. Recent advancements
have sought to mitigate this limitation by incorporating large language models
(LLMs) to offer more detailed error analyses, yet their applicability remains
constrained, particularly in industrial contexts where comprehensive error
coverage and swift detection are paramount. To alleviate these challenges, we
introduce DEE, a Dual-stage Explainable Evaluation method for estimating the
quality of text generation. Built upon Llama 2, DEE follows a dual-stage
principle guided by stage-specific instructions to perform efficient
identification of errors in generated texts in the initial stage and
subsequently delves into providing comprehensive diagnostic reports in the
second stage. DEE is fine-tuned on our elaborately assembled dataset AntEval,
which encompasses 15K examples from 4 real-world applications of Alipay that
employ generative systems. The dataset concerns newly emerged issues like
hallucination and toxicity, thereby broadening the scope of DEE's evaluation
criteria. Experimental results affirm that DEE's superiority over existing
evaluation methods, achieving significant improvements in both human
correlation as well as efficiency.
|
[
-0.2096816897,
-0.9060713053,
0.7374134064,
0.4067638814,
-0.3247587383,
0.0269504935,
-0.062624611,
-0.3618850708,
-0.0492018163,
0.341496408,
-0.7016880512,
-0.5129591227,
-0.5644608736,
0.3164802194,
-0.5576458573,
1.0786952972,
-0.2125901133,
-0.2216506749,
-0.364898324,
0.1958254278,
-0.5994049311,
-0.1643504202,
-0.9438297153,
-0.1286085099,
0.4391037226,
0.3589446247,
0.5541743636,
0.3900426626,
0.4433869123,
0.2949160039,
-0.1315072626,
0.3860322237,
-0.3907278478,
0.5102097392,
0.062730588,
-0.3015912771,
-0.4028765559,
-0.1595930755,
0.5273497105,
0.6063762307,
-0.036054235,
0.2105110735,
0.1528980583,
0.9078529477,
-0.6285012364,
0.1914700866,
-0.3739697039,
0.0780297816,
-0.1346671432,
-0.2784683704,
-0.328912735,
-0.5635249615,
-0.0865431726,
-0.519590795,
-0.0021863126,
-0.3297279477,
0.5225374103,
0.6772671938,
-0.7790365815,
-0.6894096136,
-0.8041802049,
0.6426255703,
-0.6530091763,
0.0600478575,
0.2365915626,
0.3142031431,
-0.1543698907,
-0.862729311,
-0.8187476397,
-0.2092162073,
0.0623727851,
0.3238871694,
-0.0892778933,
0.0026789696,
0.2743443847,
0.5648422837,
-0.4783105254,
0.3917141259,
-0.1333727241,
-0.1620011479,
0.7683999538,
0.2830300629,
0.5094257593,
-0.3110371828,
-0.4739237428,
-0.0809795707,
-0.4611550868,
-0.0385848656,
0.5501745939,
-0.0817054883,
-0.0534231402,
0.5967690945,
-0.0818927214,
0.4545094371,
0.1342408359,
-0.0522438474,
0.1719992459,
-0.5600379109,
-0.2396303266,
-0.0818886235,
0.8167214394,
0.5737223029,
-0.0080468655,
0.0036481142,
-0.3620076776,
0.3658911884,
0.377509743,
-0.9429145455,
-0.153343305,
0.4189504087,
-0.5873268247,
-0.5711865425,
-0.099316597,
-1.189106822,
-0.9293456078,
-0.1691132784,
0.4237432778,
-0.0813224912,
-0.5975209475,
-0.0449598655,
-0.0958427116,
0.0319123678,
0.0982470065,
-0.8310021758,
-0.0169789623,
0.5630592704,
0.7177574039,
-0.1090782732,
-0.0931059793,
-0.601549983,
-0.1072528288,
-0.6628329158,
0.9810715318,
-0.2554354072,
-0.3350951672,
-0.0301582329,
-0.3881254494,
0.0610183291,
-0.6731418371,
0.9473675489,
-0.5067648888,
0.2752175331,
-0.0655950829,
-0.3274886608,
-0.3434834778,
-0.1280520558,
-0.7137460113,
1.1527222395,
0.2226168662,
-1.0070940256,
0.6786292195,
-0.7277037501,
-0.5104731917,
-0.0421039648,
0.014407983,
-0.4601024091,
0.3729754388,
0.1077185199,
0.3878239989,
-0.4597453177,
0.4137654006,
0.0087363422,
-0.3058806658,
0.2908710241,
-0.8555551171,
0.9049583077,
0.1914233416,
-0.5604280233,
0.2241224796,
-1.0691437721,
0.1268610209,
0.0950377434,
-0.2965285778,
-0.4361508787,
0.0713626295,
-0.1710769087,
0.1766624153,
0.2836613357,
-0.306430161,
-0.2917270362,
-0.6228762269,
0.247658059,
0.6141480803,
0.2634717524,
0.1218459532,
-0.3424183726,
0.7097466588,
-0.0401888452,
0.008769487,
-0.2716458738,
-0.5184622407,
-0.8456425071,
-0.1920753866,
0.3021488786,
0.4781418443,
-0.8483944535,
0.6104449034,
-0.0239732321,
-0.3090174794,
-0.523478806,
-0.0013003526,
0.5283838511,
0.5768287778,
0.1463404,
-0.4223770797,
-0.5964061022,
-0.937243402,
-0.0640917048,
-0.417319417,
-0.2307599038,
0.0435520671,
0.2886221409,
-0.6329194307,
0.7748068571,
-0.2711412013,
0.2085065097,
-0.0570023544,
0.4390203953,
0.0281218681,
0.0272046868,
0.2686644197,
-0.7108291984,
-0.4609767795,
-0.0870362297,
-0.9997514486,
-0.629632771,
-0.5739269257,
-0.2553744614,
0.3470377624,
0.1980782747,
-0.1719613075,
0.6088899374,
0.7205235362,
-0.569989562,
0.888055861,
-0.5300967693,
0.2985228598,
-0.7738139033,
-0.1620364785,
-0.0580785833,
-0.1143575236,
-0.5565960407,
0.0147350514,
0.0858603269,
0.1152455956,
-0.0063408827,
0.4226871133,
-0.4304792285,
-0.1344609857,
-0.5598586798,
0.2230565995,
0.4295835495,
0.115813233,
-0.3681161404,
1.0029152632,
0.4536688328,
-0.875990212,
0.4904700518,
0.2263395935,
-0.5750514269,
0.9268282056,
-0.7677567005,
0.0668848157,
-0.2237070948,
0.0975235701,
-1.2544771433,
-0.1604732722,
0.2736811936,
-0.2432227284,
0.4375923574,
0.2641818523,
-0.4838894308,
-0.5952787995,
-0.2785920203,
0.188597694,
0.628698349,
-0.8784430027,
0.1876450479,
0.3797913194,
-0.366004169,
-0.2830353677,
-0.5301271677,
0.4092268646,
-0.6256871819,
-0.835249722,
0.2268613726,
-0.4438223243,
-0.5548002124,
-0.3582205176,
-0.2593434751,
-0.1887444854,
0.4208306074,
0.3628292978,
0.0725395754,
0.0045492384,
0.1878801882,
0.6141397953,
-0.5154087543,
0.5338389874,
0.0245838463,
0.1440041214,
0.2864757776,
-0.1052204967,
-0.8393099308,
0.4280427098,
0.6582669616,
0.0171308219,
0.5438921452,
0.5033786297,
-0.2661940455,
-0.5899564624,
-0.2165635824,
0.0515929125,
-0.4334222674,
0.4026970267,
-0.5425639153,
-0.0166418497,
0.3677218258,
-0.3211590946,
0.0115506351,
0.7716447115,
0.7936370373,
-0.0080325138,
0.9813586473,
0.5432766676,
0.7590707541,
0.0646228343,
-0.1196946725,
0.1851755828,
-0.8800046444,
-0.3222270906,
-0.4502402842,
-0.1656410992,
-0.3666371107,
-0.3732054532,
0.4051301181,
0.3744440675,
-0.279371649,
0.0047803079,
-0.6163685918,
0.3822009563,
0.4897230864,
0.001720191,
0.594643116,
-0.0405024774,
-0.1246478185,
-0.1180879995,
-0.2834142148,
-1.0014687777,
1.1598792076,
0.4637091756,
0.5644680858,
0.1280167401,
0.7643335462,
0.5196669102,
0.3831841946,
-0.8412296772,
0.3706010282,
-0.2464587241,
-0.3786292374,
-0.1442352384,
-0.5315062404,
-0.6827471256,
0.2720997334,
-0.1251200438,
-0.356610775,
0.0895759985,
0.0010160666,
-0.3340883553,
0.0754470527,
-0.9297976494,
0.8013446331,
-0.508476615,
-0.1850150824,
-0.1083785743,
-0.4863953888,
0.6635355353,
-0.6421265006,
0.3430295587,
0.0327206515,
-0.2150654197,
0.9156188369,
-0.5211549401,
0.737641871,
-0.2273101211,
-0.7572156191,
0.3230166435,
0.1402672678,
0.425072521,
0.1731555462,
-0.4735226035,
0.1876326054,
0.01588035,
0.1450034976,
-0.6635907888,
0.7647593021,
-0.5078846216,
-0.3861569166,
-0.2988063693,
-0.5046527386,
-0.101588957,
0.0673996806,
0.3968963623,
0.4840885997,
-0.1372066885,
-0.2702293098,
0.4215047061,
-0.660628736,
0.4483133852,
0.2235837877,
-0.2015093267,
-0.4126423597,
0.6334832311,
-0.1910159588,
0.2430324703,
0.0996947363,
0.2567607164,
-0.5169918537,
-0.568111062,
-0.789029181,
0.0506525673,
-0.6199964881,
-0.2771487832,
-0.6283493042,
-0.107505478,
0.1085584164,
-0.0560912974,
-0.1601610035,
-0.5997262597,
-0.399099946,
-0.2450746,
0.2003501058,
1.029725194,
-0.275647372,
0.2097847909,
-0.4129115045,
0.8336207867,
0.4777111411,
0.5692842603,
0.0576084815,
-0.5157448053,
-0.0471812934,
0.3853552938,
-0.3569064736,
-1.1526546478,
0.3178673983,
0.1957764179,
0.3985845447,
0.4458419681,
0.3177875876,
0.4995714426,
-0.4348739684,
0.7361856103,
0.3311625421,
-0.9975868464,
0.666331768,
-0.0497976914,
-0.149090752,
0.4486949444,
0.2034137249,
-0.2890246809,
-0.2581289709,
-0.3654239178,
-0.9338676333,
0.6107576489,
0.2774913609,
0.1476834714,
-0.1401463002,
0.3953611553,
0.6133763194,
-0.0166696496,
-0.5108058453,
-0.4388059378,
-0.1266253889,
-0.2952642441,
0.0209564716,
-0.8270983696,
-0.0896746591,
0.1326995492,
0.6546090841,
0.1727903336,
0.2004043609,
0.0522872023,
-0.0808956847,
-0.2885562778,
0.3596097529,
0.4256720543,
0.9711381793,
-0.1282598972,
0.1848677248,
-0.1433063298,
-0.4063871801,
0.3365148008,
0.2552745342,
-0.3172379136,
0.0688054413,
0.2208349705,
0.7297760248,
-0.1131498143,
-0.6548879743,
0.4103060663,
-0.2313172072,
-0.2107760906,
-0.2461107373,
0.0199912488,
-0.2157384604,
0.3026506305,
0.3606833518,
-0.1296139657,
0.4281629622,
-0.3629938662,
0.1691461504,
0.2012739331,
-0.2434163988,
-0.2508850992,
0.9683724642,
0.4763687551,
-0.2859497964,
0.4871740341,
-0.5104910731,
-0.3138140738,
0.9268758297,
0.6962733269,
1.0856126547,
-0.0177514926,
0.6348640919,
0.4740272462,
0.2910787761,
0.0855071023,
0.2605660856,
0.0800698623,
-0.4214654565,
-0.5879568458,
-0.8992206454,
-0.3041193783,
0.0100068338,
-0.6702777743,
0.1144319177,
-0.1101703942,
-0.1777702123,
0.1087143868,
0.0551822074,
-0.4584638178,
0.230715245,
0.1427317262,
0.5493634343,
-0.8774183393,
0.2979542315,
0.5639551878,
-0.5055038929,
-0.3887194693,
0.3225007355,
0.0407086872,
-0.6795542836,
0.7879993916,
0.3920882046,
-0.0692967176,
0.1092967764,
0.0135488966,
-0.4667798579,
1.0536205769,
0.1047127917,
-0.5506185889,
0.0639056936,
-0.2058675736,
0.63508147,
-0.0557944477,
0.5866731405,
0.6877270937,
0.6892812252,
0.039163135,
-0.79657197,
0.1787686199,
-0.1116424054,
0.2930223942,
0.2342209667,
-0.2448565513,
0.3719512224,
-0.5424836874,
-0.7389928699,
0.323045969,
0.5729800463,
0.2263016254,
0.7695528269,
0.5958795547,
0.5841970444,
1.1126075983,
-0.0088441949,
1.2474426031,
-0.1006456837,
0.2401136607,
0.8485822678,
-0.2536794841,
0.5057902336,
0.1814660877,
-0.3763809204,
0.9057552218,
0.6081596017,
0.3159353733,
0.4932836592,
0.4919857979,
-0.4449507892,
0.0165576432,
0.002732228,
-0.3623231947,
0.4192407727,
0.4124037921,
-0.3329921365,
-0.1564708352,
0.1868583709,
-0.086056985,
0.2989802957,
-0.1984649599,
0.8260481954,
-0.0489186235,
-0.5553888679,
0.7656111717,
0.1224445477,
0.6732391119,
-0.2357648462,
-0.1380796134,
-0.4514229298,
0.0108577432,
-0.2551665306,
-0.7311334014,
0.5713276267,
0.4085453451,
-0.4503884614,
-0.3084152639,
0.4417749047,
-0.2568061352,
-0.5403475165,
0.1771202534,
0.3806917071,
0.2619137168,
-0.0019780362,
-0.4900461733,
0.0807905048,
0.0863303691,
-0.1604960412,
-0.1832572967,
0.8082080483,
0.0368983746,
0.4681090415,
0.3850423098,
-0.0141499927,
-0.12961483,
0.200774312,
0.5902512074,
-0.5252267122,
-0.3068391681,
-0.6279230118,
0.902262032,
-0.0069339159,
-0.1908884943,
0.6720827222,
0.3462612629,
0.3152717948,
0.0813058689,
0.9887182117,
-0.167304337,
0.6382104158,
-0.6305750608,
0.6274998188,
-0.4793220758,
0.6201319695,
-0.2151467204,
-1.1400797367,
-0.3396829963,
0.6307500005,
-0.1627289653,
0.1907937527,
1.0013802052,
0.6067410111,
0.0811336786,
-0.0240987353,
0.254768759,
0.5606073141,
0.1708732545,
0.5116241574,
1.1574946642,
-0.5080887079,
0.6066710353,
-0.2937532663,
-0.7083526254,
0.0197266787,
-1.0300308466,
-0.7545838952,
-0.5778764486,
-0.6234326363,
-0.484251231,
-0.0082042478,
0.1524750441,
0.3190726042,
-0.544632256,
0.1526666135,
-0.2450467497,
0.2879971564,
-0.2461704612,
-0.2734130323,
0.4359970987,
-0.480091244,
-0.8651760817,
0.6301762462,
0.3294912875,
-0.1352721006,
-0.4011493027,
0.0177895948,
0.1746852398,
0.1093614772,
0.6931848526,
0.0255584531,
-0.6553763151,
-0.0753734335,
-0.4066172838,
-0.0923557952,
-0.1974157691,
0.5422099829,
-0.8936017156,
0.8493707776,
0.4431699812,
0.5237537622,
0.1125295758,
0.1357776076,
0.6093752384,
-0.5548937917,
-0.1826096177,
0.0097817825,
-0.028784398,
0.4948012829,
-0.5217737556,
0.5763302445,
0.0138311079,
-0.7453232408,
-0.8072332144,
0.3005509079,
-0.8208386302,
-0.2552529275,
1.1719009876,
0.0501980521,
0.2409662008,
-0.1829447895,
-0.3215157986,
0.3655345142,
-0.0508980379,
1.1179841757,
0.4018959105,
0.0074213874,
0.1638268381,
-0.7161437869,
0.4625839889,
0.1628379822,
-1.1505134106,
0.1214210242,
0.8914677501,
0.0410059169,
-0.0630287081,
0.5234543681,
-0.1271720678,
0.190690279,
0.2319734693,
-0.0561949648,
-0.1195485741,
-0.4002897441,
-0.5189538002,
-0.063186422,
0.1048821509,
-0.1965962201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11473v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11473v1
|
Word Order's Impacts: Insights from Reordering and Generation Analysis
| 2024-03-18T04:45:44 | 2024-03-18T04:45:44 |
Qinghua Zhao, Jiaang Li, Lei Li, Zenghui Zhou, Junfeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing works have studied the impacts of the order of words within natural
text. They usually analyze it by destroying the original order of words to
create a scrambled sequence, and then comparing the models' performance between
the original and scrambled sequences. The experimental results demonstrate
marginal drops. Considering this findings, different hypothesis about word
order is proposed, including ``the order of words is redundant with lexical
semantics'', and ``models do not rely on word order''. In this paper, we
revisit the aforementioned hypotheses by adding a order reconstruction
perspective, and selecting datasets of different spectrum. Specifically, we
first select four different datasets, and then design order reconstruction and
continuing generation tasks. Empirical findings support that ChatGPT relies on
word order to infer, but cannot support or negate the redundancy relations
between word order lexical semantics.
|
[
-0.2930645943,
-0.6335623264,
0.1737630218,
-0.0967379808,
-0.2203692347,
-0.0484318323,
0.1890141368,
-0.7603892088,
0.3740013242,
0.7896338701,
-0.4995878637,
-0.0594131649,
-0.8837475777,
0.2803395689,
-0.6625084281,
1.1681756973,
0.377915591,
-0.2175105512,
0.0429717638,
-0.2581916153,
-0.7273589373,
-0.445333302,
-0.5131976604,
-0.298799783,
0.5941811204,
0.4319926202,
1.2972654104,
0.6892259121,
0.4479135871,
0.4014320672,
-0.2460861057,
0.1008085757,
-0.8770093322,
0.0348142497,
-0.0009598267,
-0.3709401786,
-0.0529530607,
0.407361865,
0.429054141,
0.9662095308,
-0.2513142526,
-0.1115380302,
0.1076733842,
0.7188230753,
-0.7842610478,
0.1998609751,
-0.9258447886,
0.0274931192,
-0.0227317046,
-0.3665258884,
-0.5378167629,
-0.3648910522,
0.6730182171,
-0.2698585689,
0.432043463,
0.1477939337,
0.9385999441,
-0.1176461428,
-0.2927074432,
-0.2578703761,
-0.8303077817,
0.6020664573,
-0.5306769013,
0.5055239201,
0.4470151365,
-0.1289895475,
-0.6360427141,
-0.8728269935,
-0.5601004362,
0.0994442478,
-0.1224003509,
0.5949827433,
-0.0588968992,
0.2324845195,
0.1882336736,
0.6026189327,
-0.2910890579,
-0.014427972,
-0.6006788611,
-0.0447387844,
0.5350366831,
0.3025572896,
0.5607709885,
-0.5203121901,
-0.2656467557,
-0.3412699401,
-0.8273948431,
-0.1143199056,
0.2135118991,
0.4290271103,
0.1436059475,
0.7637900114,
-0.135942772,
0.498700887,
-0.2516433895,
0.0427689329,
0.285633713,
-0.344252497,
-0.4106112421,
0.132221356,
0.8125428557,
0.4499367774,
-0.0063737137,
-0.2163491696,
-0.0283360351,
0.0473386124,
0.4388541877,
-0.5708978772,
-0.2757295966,
-0.0187919829,
-0.3336148858,
-0.1106236354,
0.1417087168,
-0.6097183824,
-0.3566331863,
-0.2240763754,
0.5338273048,
-0.6279720068,
-0.1312337667,
0.1901766658,
-0.3500973284,
0.3905665874,
0.2180657238,
-0.939288497,
0.2269429117,
0.9121921062,
0.6074486971,
0.142344743,
-0.4848027825,
-0.0043468862,
-0.1729842871,
-0.4500126839,
0.804209888,
-0.604580164,
-0.8576210141,
0.2062142789,
0.1125944182,
-0.0867073908,
-0.3606653214,
0.7466140985,
-0.6384308338,
0.7308197618,
-0.6069645286,
-0.8620381951,
-0.4926103652,
-0.2068867236,
-0.3715293705,
0.7537804246,
-0.2960283458,
-1.0031151772,
0.7083975077,
-0.0519228131,
-0.6363216639,
0.1732619852,
-0.2839384377,
-0.1609764397,
0.5075997114,
-0.1207103804,
0.3076132238,
0.0072530825,
-0.1858205944,
-0.2155823559,
-0.2745663524,
-0.120016776,
-0.358751893,
0.6927620769,
0.1907503605,
-0.1472111195,
-0.4373286963,
-0.8529595137,
0.129653573,
0.204031378,
-0.5980532169,
-0.3228952587,
0.8018158078,
-0.0573553219,
0.0462658703,
-0.2332434654,
-0.7604600191,
0.0932121873,
-0.6894884706,
0.4787144661,
0.548653841,
0.2081743926,
0.4839037061,
-0.3061818779,
0.3101743162,
-0.2899896801,
0.0457524471,
0.2114326656,
-0.797367692,
-0.6217364669,
-0.0432820357,
0.2021082938,
0.6332644224,
-0.7107766271,
0.0478570983,
-0.6840181947,
-0.3694885671,
-0.2070325166,
-0.5890800357,
0.4355436265,
0.3007701039,
0.1411138326,
-0.3185107708,
-0.6647664309,
-0.8723223805,
-0.4805257022,
-0.3841606081,
0.0106886765,
0.2264632434,
0.2477165014,
-0.1196440458,
0.9613850713,
-0.7963377833,
0.283113271,
-0.2501936853,
0.2585889697,
-0.0014487853,
0.1640708148,
0.3345130384,
-0.514557302,
0.1164057106,
-0.1542755514,
-0.4938272238,
-0.0994990543,
0.1189743429,
-0.4092079401,
0.2033797801,
0.3404977918,
-0.480109036,
0.6266731024,
0.4684314728,
-0.2419907749,
0.4963034689,
-0.3520086706,
0.0749887526,
-1.3391968012,
-0.3562238216,
-0.6031230688,
0.1561306417,
-0.9051353931,
-0.3411968052,
-0.1313489527,
-0.1744715124,
-0.2583836019,
0.1148407385,
-0.532443583,
-0.335175395,
-0.4431401193,
0.1376202554,
0.1073232889,
0.138449356,
0.0401041992,
0.3689613938,
-0.2146726996,
-0.4936259985,
-0.3094136417,
0.553108871,
-0.6093512774,
0.0555836707,
-0.5578798056,
-0.020829007,
-0.2936947942,
-0.0532667413,
-1.3364242315,
-0.0783948749,
0.2426494509,
-0.5179322958,
0.3985141218,
-0.0729244128,
-0.6959519386,
-0.2511294186,
-0.1687315106,
0.1859751344,
0.5777970552,
-0.3848133087,
-0.0405330211,
0.5038807392,
0.0473322123,
-0.4800066054,
-0.6520891786,
0.1517108381,
0.0015185833,
-0.5233204961,
0.3891143501,
0.1342353374,
-0.288164109,
-0.2482508272,
-0.1159675121,
0.047058586,
0.0099938894,
0.3034752607,
0.3785164952,
0.0024867083,
0.300717622,
-0.0779654458,
0.1502961516,
0.1436360329,
0.0318242311,
0.3835993409,
0.3183199465,
-0.0252821334,
0.1754727513,
0.3335847557,
0.6209571362,
-0.0554851741,
0.814212501,
0.052641008,
-0.2814638317,
0.0255895108,
-0.5452654958,
0.24034217,
-0.5568417907,
0.4595143199,
-0.1502146572,
-0.4198597074,
0.343737632,
0.5342165232,
0.5549560785,
0.4206905365,
0.3620696366,
-0.1463982761,
0.6473702192,
0.6350051165,
-0.1740106493,
0.8950877786,
-0.2044151574,
0.1493964791,
-0.638971746,
-0.0064652083,
-0.3767062724,
-0.203894183,
-0.9766870737,
0.0312261824,
-0.1817891896,
-0.017372366,
-0.163832888,
0.4949148595,
-0.6765706539,
0.6606585979,
0.3037085533,
0.2194627821,
0.2561934888,
0.3790815175,
0.1517039686,
0.0871782973,
-0.731875062,
-0.3104465306,
0.8069809079,
-0.1750991195,
0.3336578906,
0.0900551826,
0.8496338725,
0.0274579804,
0.1180021018,
-0.8990902901,
0.6265510321,
-0.3833128214,
-0.3481808305,
-0.1086800396,
-0.3143740892,
-1.8460928202,
0.6687412262,
-0.1952914149,
-0.7420179844,
0.3511176407,
-0.3884862363,
-0.3876125216,
-0.0605523735,
-1.0285382271,
0.4656349123,
0.1038766131,
-0.0987073779,
-0.1200706959,
-0.4995325804,
0.3780592382,
0.403528899,
0.2886309028,
-0.1614860892,
0.2034822255,
1.0208218098,
-1.0539615154,
0.7850189209,
0.0919815525,
-0.2407977581,
0.4677177966,
0.2738066912,
0.4008835256,
-0.4701839387,
0.0289139971,
0.040181946,
0.167129159,
-0.2804661393,
-0.2892345786,
0.6348145008,
-0.8137161732,
-0.5601723194,
-0.4005143642,
-0.5272054672,
-0.2420902997,
0.3120465875,
0.8328467607,
0.8902165294,
-0.0229594354,
-0.2756386697,
0.0808934942,
-0.2987719476,
0.6627142429,
0.2435422391,
-0.1903134286,
-0.6857545376,
0.9127406478,
0.8829311132,
0.5106905699,
0.1805902719,
0.2152626812,
-0.21626845,
-0.7372061014,
0.1653524786,
0.1908436716,
-0.6746190786,
0.1421842575,
-0.5826744437,
-0.2079880983,
-0.3524348438,
-0.2492650896,
-0.3446549177,
-0.3010137975,
-0.0672569796,
-0.070791021,
0.4622664154,
1.0504977703,
0.2221554816,
0.2232774943,
-0.8877638578,
0.1929111332,
0.0985734314,
0.2995240688,
0.1037037298,
-0.4564290345,
0.027022697,
0.0659527108,
-0.3646440506,
-0.9722635746,
0.535793364,
0.1633011103,
0.3982805014,
0.2506825626,
0.0135248527,
0.9842942357,
-0.7646009326,
0.7015014887,
0.1912725717,
-0.5497305989,
0.3916398287,
-0.5743417144,
0.448147893,
0.4546583593,
-0.0163035765,
-0.7977731824,
-0.439383328,
-0.9491397142,
-1.2425335646,
0.7553249002,
0.6391801834,
0.1005124375,
-0.6696947813,
0.5900090337,
0.2119532824,
0.0863851085,
-0.2411477119,
-0.2343921363,
-0.1353283376,
0.1041583493,
-0.1938128024,
-0.3590473533,
0.3264209032,
-0.1337624341,
0.3645046055,
0.4710913897,
0.4303482473,
0.1773465276,
-0.1703987867,
0.3514308035,
0.1376858652,
0.5178455114,
0.4120702744,
-0.0269315969,
-0.0267636329,
0.0725223795,
-0.8387104273,
-0.213958621,
-0.3724642694,
-0.2592483461,
0.0994074121,
0.5735988021,
0.5504238009,
0.6114481091,
-0.3818815053,
0.1454304457,
-0.046121411,
-0.169985801,
-0.1935168803,
-0.1910272688,
-0.0241372623,
0.0450190082,
0.063373141,
0.0154430997,
0.1968510151,
-0.7879468799,
0.2683487833,
0.438805908,
-0.0572151169,
-0.4695869684,
0.2585751116,
-0.0911908448,
-0.43364048,
0.9825721383,
0.0103198783,
-0.5317294598,
0.727109611,
0.4643828273,
0.9776889682,
0.0600772575,
0.1183793843,
0.314879179,
0.3017521799,
-0.3632565141,
0.5266061425,
0.2481469959,
-0.8986282945,
-0.2908817828,
-0.4423734546,
-0.271140337,
0.0141823301,
-0.6172091365,
0.1957345456,
-0.7130715251,
-0.2181000859,
0.114013359,
-0.1043239906,
-0.3984183371,
-0.0412762761,
0.1821387261,
0.5493507385,
-0.4913080335,
0.4583745003,
0.2871423662,
-0.4152154326,
-0.7839339972,
0.1974991411,
0.13470833,
-0.9437306523,
0.5998544693,
0.2812627256,
-0.204706043,
-0.0403225124,
-0.32742697,
-1.2742934227,
0.8774864674,
0.1321143359,
-0.0785011798,
0.1850886047,
0.2824266851,
0.7727590799,
-0.0091571491,
0.2339075655,
0.3768485785,
0.0639918968,
0.3909188211,
-0.8147951365,
-0.1149163842,
-0.1168287322,
0.1910263002,
0.8045601249,
-0.4799771011,
0.69661057,
-0.1285891086,
-1.0258978605,
0.1903547198,
0.4702722132,
-0.2934150398,
-0.0809224918,
0.3338395357,
0.5685270429,
0.5113140345,
-0.0109973419,
1.2341064215,
-0.2083540261,
0.4705770314,
1.1803082228,
-0.1318004727,
1.1887608767,
0.2884866893,
-0.5554370284,
0.2457434684,
0.8885160685,
0.024093125,
0.6412758231,
0.2605479062,
-0.0096308822,
0.1817447692,
0.0905802324,
-0.3682360947,
0.6850778461,
0.3970369399,
-0.3278928399,
-0.3935309649,
-0.2297811657,
0.1232744157,
-0.4715961218,
-0.2337065637,
0.8339366913,
0.0603444017,
-0.7474499941,
0.8853898048,
-0.3864896297,
0.3697017431,
-0.2614192963,
0.0888232142,
-0.4249982834,
0.2269773036,
-0.3087266684,
-0.5668836832,
0.4599310458,
-0.5331035256,
-0.2858258784,
-0.0820889175,
0.4694549441,
-0.2430358529,
-0.5401964188,
0.252740711,
0.4622612298,
0.1701631993,
0.3472238481,
-0.3085201979,
-0.1937083751,
-0.2114069164,
-0.5696017742,
0.3967403769,
0.4001752734,
0.1725735664,
0.5122573972,
0.4900836647,
-0.223443076,
0.398044318,
-0.1091338396,
0.4160102308,
-0.5890957713,
-0.3047628105,
-0.8540364504,
0.0874129459,
0.077206783,
-0.3154946268,
0.8073055744,
0.3299998045,
0.8254012465,
0.0831599683,
0.6284469962,
-0.2125384361,
0.2381492555,
-0.3002212644,
0.6467965245,
-0.4284124374,
0.2952535152,
-0.6218739152,
-0.7644450068,
-0.3362376988,
0.1932294667,
-0.5708653927,
-0.0018503384,
0.7807992697,
0.8074143529,
0.1640188396,
0.4407155216,
0.3347016275,
0.2592007518,
0.1554347873,
0.2303295285,
0.8109462857,
-0.7163956165,
0.5587968826,
-0.3176046312,
-0.076848723,
0.089227654,
-0.4937334359,
-0.4926238656,
-0.5318566561,
-0.1897660047,
-0.4821180999,
0.0471428372,
0.8492409587,
0.0069804108,
-0.4049177766,
-0.1128169298,
-0.2489061654,
0.0351456217,
-0.1955576241,
-0.2520590425,
0.6273698211,
-0.4137599766,
-0.6521446109,
0.179246515,
0.0835902169,
0.0786894262,
0.3866153955,
0.36285761,
-0.319881469,
0.3330420852,
1.1451947689,
0.4353699386,
-0.8755531311,
-0.8863716125,
-0.0851143375,
-0.030424837,
0.2736239135,
0.6998271942,
-0.7837839127,
0.3076728582,
1.1318023205,
0.498647362,
-0.0576281212,
-0.1614928693,
0.6547259688,
-0.5172913074,
-0.2042276859,
-0.2385073304,
0.7024553418,
-0.1774653941,
-0.2654657662,
0.5316780806,
0.5154166222,
-0.5668607354,
-0.6152377129,
0.5077589154,
-0.8269300461,
-0.4567511976,
1.2045263052,
0.0025082026,
-0.1296949983,
-0.2415249497,
-0.3421883881,
0.3719754219,
-0.1758574694,
1.088819623,
0.8403567672,
-0.2154172063,
-0.1234118938,
-0.5208665729,
0.2742030621,
0.6526345015,
-0.3937875926,
0.3997771442,
0.7517975569,
0.2719391584,
0.2806318998,
0.5597589016,
-0.2053272277,
-0.0628338307,
0.2051319182,
0.0215676967,
0.29679811,
0.1858269125,
-0.1624326408,
0.35269925,
-0.0862301439,
-0.5446655154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11456v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11456v3
|
HateCOT: An Explanation-Enhanced Dataset for Generalizable Offensive Speech Detection via Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T04:12:35 | 2024-06-16T20:55:25 |
Huy Nghiem, Hal Daumé III
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
The widespread use of social media necessitates reliable and efficient
detection of offensive content to mitigate harmful effects. Although
sophisticated models perform well on individual datasets, they often fail to
generalize due to varying definitions and labeling of "offensive content." In
this paper, we introduce HateCOT, an English dataset with over 52,000 samples
from diverse sources, featuring explanations generated by GPT-3.5Turbo and
curated by humans. We demonstrate that pretraining on HateCOT significantly
enhances the performance of open-source Large Language Models on three
benchmark datasets for offensive content detection in both zero-shot and
few-shot settings, despite differences in domain and task. Additionally,
HateCOT facilitates effective K-shot fine-tuning of LLMs with limited data and
improves the quality of their explanations, as confirmed by our human
evaluation.
|
[
-0.3487215042,
-0.8287535906,
0.1498353779,
-0.1518675238,
-0.560590446,
0.0115519464,
-0.4202040136,
-0.6054658294,
-0.0076546092,
0.4503497481,
-0.4715023637,
-0.7249042392,
-1.0009329319,
0.0723291188,
-0.6806338429,
1.2279090881,
0.2011374682,
-0.1440455765,
0.3887571096,
-0.1408771574,
-0.0608083643,
-0.3911980391,
-0.8490314484,
-0.0770043284,
0.8823109865,
0.4966775179,
0.7474380732,
0.6632183194,
0.4465969503,
0.2087244391,
0.0346092172,
0.3906554282,
-0.9109828472,
0.3009449244,
-0.3536888361,
-0.2617072463,
-0.2037049532,
-0.0074893008,
0.1838837266,
0.1405238956,
-0.0393430628,
-0.0284094755,
-0.028192183,
0.1025136337,
-0.6839892268,
-0.3057419658,
-0.9810548425,
-0.0202656444,
-0.3653059006,
-0.1020724252,
-0.3220055997,
-0.0651907772,
-0.0663326755,
-0.7209392786,
0.6119518876,
0.0325105824,
0.4607149661,
0.1329601407,
-0.3699372709,
-0.3425525725,
-0.7213327289,
0.8040034771,
-0.6517682076,
0.5085388422,
0.441236347,
0.3549256623,
-0.0484360531,
-0.6154569387,
-0.7223316431,
-0.0274592452,
-0.074125886,
0.0348438397,
-0.4897698164,
0.1960913092,
0.3165139258,
0.1505166441,
-0.643465817,
0.5775396824,
-0.2112464458,
-0.4667624533,
0.6125208735,
0.0749382451,
0.569891572,
-0.0453913435,
-0.0119621968,
0.1473800987,
-0.6609838605,
-0.4373410642,
0.6303919554,
0.600243032,
-0.3957444131,
0.2603676021,
0.0754285455,
0.557212472,
-0.2105384618,
0.2086269855,
0.0249533542,
0.1334470809,
-0.2510175705,
-0.1132589206,
0.8907852769,
0.4616071582,
0.7964544296,
-0.24466075,
-0.1157553568,
0.3046782315,
0.1931390911,
-0.969646275,
-0.3409516811,
0.2955610156,
-0.1510831863,
-0.5664560199,
-0.32436046,
-0.8570383191,
-0.6966552138,
-0.3080560565,
-0.0950228646,
-0.4563972354,
-0.39284724,
-0.0990469381,
-0.3310373127,
0.0990673676,
0.4398759902,
-0.9843939543,
0.3499264121,
0.6724950671,
0.7503785491,
-0.5947735906,
-0.1517606378,
-0.752908349,
0.0657847151,
-0.4506004155,
0.7627105117,
-0.6949542165,
-0.1016528234,
0.035110984,
0.0900483578,
0.3351136744,
-0.6391488314,
0.6861432195,
-0.5505226851,
0.2069432735,
-0.0036588949,
-0.2314007282,
0.1234641001,
0.0818278641,
-0.3412351608,
0.7133593559,
0.2032455802,
-0.9929260612,
0.707101047,
-0.875567019,
-0.6139208674,
0.2824749351,
-0.0221468415,
-0.4584379196,
0.0649349988,
0.5294932127,
0.4126161635,
-0.1757149696,
0.2829262614,
-0.4930262566,
-0.3687158823,
-0.0591275766,
-0.5359433293,
1.0262018442,
0.5646060705,
-0.4268954098,
0.1584452391,
-0.5200786591,
-0.2109789252,
0.4625875354,
0.12430235,
-0.4496881962,
0.0106572453,
0.12562114,
-0.0290135182,
-0.1758251041,
-0.8230522871,
-0.37121737,
-0.3226782978,
0.5169106126,
0.8588548303,
-0.0765843913,
-0.0488332435,
-0.3110434711,
0.7752494216,
0.423684597,
0.2858313322,
0.0196441468,
-0.514003098,
-0.2282776833,
-0.3057152033,
-0.101031065,
0.4531568587,
-0.6026251912,
-0.0421759486,
-0.1610585302,
-0.3714831471,
-0.5110669136,
0.1307474524,
0.2820125818,
0.5381817222,
0.5077168345,
-0.0028147337,
-0.8913998604,
-0.9074967504,
-0.6119943261,
-0.046412833,
-0.2969755232,
0.6085236669,
0.4470610917,
-0.1035463139,
0.7672203183,
-0.3018245697,
-0.052080255,
-0.1853348166,
0.2066446096,
0.2362207323,
0.0885169134,
0.6314633489,
-0.8363472819,
-0.6976515055,
0.0251219589,
-0.362821281,
-0.6214058399,
0.3352510929,
-0.0162817873,
-0.0892323181,
0.3388748169,
-0.2258563787,
0.2237719595,
0.5339639187,
-0.2493093312,
0.7291622162,
0.2299239039,
0.3688943982,
-0.9144736528,
-0.237910822,
-0.0624885075,
-0.5669029951,
-0.88218081,
-0.0125749353,
-0.0547409542,
-0.2288698852,
-0.8054571152,
0.3278289139,
-0.0116259195,
0.3293595612,
-0.1990931481,
0.473957628,
-0.1076793969,
0.3203364313,
-0.2010249943,
0.7886291146,
0.5399228334,
-0.4057449698,
0.5156684518,
0.0358224548,
-0.1314899027,
0.7336905599,
-0.5274621248,
0.4278748333,
-0.2751411796,
-0.000072826,
-1.2557766438,
-0.5089008212,
0.4937007427,
-0.6153274179,
0.0944050327,
-0.4790273309,
-0.2160782069,
-0.5601933599,
-0.2775264382,
0.414909333,
0.3672373891,
-0.8108754754,
0.3472313881,
0.5816924572,
0.0817076266,
-0.5495133996,
-0.8078138828,
0.0870385244,
-0.5125656724,
-0.3930544257,
0.1830568761,
-0.1352265626,
-0.2807561457,
-0.1937038898,
-0.0062325951,
-0.2731006145,
0.108686313,
0.3133098483,
0.0059595578,
-0.280279845,
0.2704939842,
-0.0566984527,
0.3788816035,
0.0015237669,
-0.3876204491,
0.4444819689,
0.3844228387,
-0.1755481809,
-0.3092361987,
0.3347494602,
0.5124552846,
0.1293054521,
0.5419579148,
0.6281482577,
-0.3074491918,
-0.577044487,
-0.3630618155,
-0.03037351,
-0.4872280955,
0.373590678,
-0.1051060557,
-1.1150341034,
0.3780658543,
0.4735743999,
0.14753218,
0.4353548288,
0.4785676301,
-0.0205855966,
0.9732634425,
0.1044350043,
-0.2111103684,
0.4360821247,
0.1789734513,
0.1791433096,
-0.4370788336,
0.1667120755,
-0.6394253969,
-0.1662343144,
-0.5849285126,
-0.5196889043,
-0.0478193797,
-0.43495965,
-0.4859666228,
0.3132141531,
-0.8049179912,
0.9103890061,
0.1135929152,
0.1529554278,
0.2420367301,
0.2460108697,
0.0134335337,
-0.1556441039,
-0.4775912464,
-0.2400731146,
1.1699208021,
0.384162277,
0.7100908756,
0.2172748297,
0.4013291299,
0.806396842,
0.5872926116,
-0.8590088487,
0.2291113734,
-0.7820850611,
-0.8511397243,
-0.2482399046,
-0.6305307746,
-0.8935163021,
0.1817952543,
0.0602123477,
-0.7567254305,
-0.1071188748,
0.5219746828,
-0.1800111681,
0.4356819391,
-0.8618652821,
0.5489513278,
-0.2786645591,
-0.325247556,
-0.1034536734,
-0.0971435681,
0.4464834929,
-0.2392110676,
0.5481046438,
-0.2130081505,
-0.1540872157,
1.0540052652,
-0.2706360221,
0.9166154265,
-0.5486065745,
-0.2785536647,
0.298386693,
0.0581542403,
0.5111254454,
-0.3626177311,
-0.1878165454,
0.3543209136,
-0.3909106255,
-0.1644481122,
-0.5803259611,
0.6278284192,
-0.7821561098,
-0.7247721553,
0.229824841,
-0.5579259992,
-0.3296969533,
0.2781682014,
0.4666227996,
0.4056217968,
-0.2132044286,
0.2828129232,
0.4721538126,
-0.3259029984,
-0.1494404525,
0.6274088621,
-0.4893883467,
-0.3574602604,
0.7410875559,
0.1306473166,
0.2274634987,
0.2559971809,
0.4005684555,
-0.2799769938,
-0.9220517874,
-0.1300278902,
0.127349779,
-0.6065386534,
-0.1449741721,
-0.8645353913,
-0.1333176643,
-0.6433159113,
-0.0395924151,
-0.0988375172,
-0.2203820348,
-0.1914816797,
-0.2006773353,
0.5096806884,
0.9296193719,
-0.2931655049,
0.9117099643,
-0.1058765203,
0.7802329063,
0.4029162526,
0.624584794,
-0.0670372769,
-1.1513078213,
-0.1885175556,
0.3704188168,
-0.2630847692,
-0.8493287563,
0.2833958268,
0.2302854657,
0.3454239964,
0.699598372,
0.0121804671,
0.6373947859,
-0.4282764494,
0.6653932333,
0.1539560556,
-0.7459396124,
0.5823351741,
-0.6444637179,
0.201056391,
0.1542311907,
0.7313566804,
-0.784101367,
-0.7179660201,
-0.5124392509,
-0.6431414485,
0.9209500551,
0.1961915195,
0.3277953267,
-0.3498903513,
-0.0752145723,
0.1574394107,
-0.0962388143,
-0.620616734,
-0.1725586057,
-0.3322029114,
-0.1608509421,
-0.0178729557,
-0.4744586647,
-0.250043124,
-0.1619097441,
0.7030124664,
0.1344375014,
0.1560862064,
-0.0397328548,
-0.3269020319,
-0.3736459613,
0.2372293025,
0.5211759806,
0.6114322543,
-0.1547341347,
0.2533155084,
0.2625261843,
-0.7293035388,
0.1655889601,
-0.0690079182,
0.1368426979,
0.050358925,
0.5580365062,
0.8142492175,
-0.0105555588,
-0.4957980514,
0.6403077841,
-0.1596701592,
-0.2986100614,
-0.0012770012,
0.3801318109,
-0.0489356704,
-0.1322281957,
0.2007727325,
-0.4039424062,
0.0476140529,
-0.1747416556,
0.5194039345,
0.4112662077,
-0.5199558139,
-0.220968917,
0.8168787956,
0.2105971277,
-0.4983583391,
0.4679005444,
0.0269968249,
-0.591848731,
0.7198399305,
0.7201511264,
0.7110723853,
-0.4429134727,
0.3713466823,
0.3466325998,
0.4033887982,
0.6850922704,
-0.0105577046,
-0.1363117099,
-1.0846356153,
-0.3903011084,
-0.5755053163,
-0.4158705771,
0.7878260612,
-0.2555927634,
0.2834484279,
-0.6753582358,
0.0531049632,
0.4914681017,
-0.4160357416,
-0.788003087,
0.2649069726,
0.4641358256,
0.9254823923,
-1.1346739531,
0.4813944995,
0.1605556011,
-0.0059062075,
-0.83229357,
-0.0626282617,
0.2672875822,
-1.2469459772,
0.5672186017,
0.1606577635,
-0.3249265254,
0.0590609983,
-0.9916449785,
-0.2790055573,
0.2824308276,
0.4700632691,
-0.8380944133,
0.1865833551,
0.3813431561,
0.6499091387,
-0.4776311517,
0.4563151002,
0.6519244313,
0.2803197205,
0.1248020381,
-0.4654313624,
-0.0913871825,
-0.0661865547,
-0.3498880267,
0.293373853,
-0.1651137024,
0.506949544,
0.0353259556,
-0.2712664604,
-0.5118908286,
0.2881086469,
-0.005511126,
0.1761845648,
0.7590600252,
0.4098784328,
0.8505250812,
0.0841468647,
0.9654558897,
0.0539235137,
0.0999763981,
1.5026667118,
-0.0146082025,
0.3305703998,
0.1046983525,
-0.3525609076,
0.3448808491,
0.5931195021,
-0.0108616687,
0.1447209865,
0.3990998566,
-0.3143830597,
-0.22503905,
-0.5250891447,
-0.1199476197,
0.5767142773,
0.5257915854,
-0.5703326464,
-0.4828028679,
0.2113169879,
0.3069681823,
-0.0108764572,
-0.4665443003,
0.7080935836,
0.0336647667,
-0.4913659096,
0.8697949052,
-0.3443588614,
0.745575428,
-0.5262269378,
0.1266917288,
-0.231924966,
-0.1476125121,
-0.3426785767,
-0.8141593337,
0.306492269,
0.5245056748,
0.0637741834,
-0.1131130531,
0.825109601,
-0.4372361004,
-0.0279154684,
0.5528103113,
0.1289636046,
0.4374265671,
-0.2744345665,
-0.7075360417,
0.0397763178,
0.0973241776,
-0.0536353625,
-0.0195218362,
0.6876751184,
-0.1525644511,
0.404098928,
0.79544276,
0.4121275544,
-0.0447670333,
0.4884602726,
0.8347283602,
-0.438701123,
-0.4097308517,
-1.1553424597,
0.3721234798,
-0.2645097375,
-0.2179090083,
0.4198162854,
0.4894322157,
0.8607023358,
0.073726587,
1.0446856022,
-0.0194501895,
0.8174019456,
-0.1587150395,
0.7839218974,
-0.4347328544,
0.0209701583,
-0.3351353109,
-0.6269581318,
-0.5886200666,
0.2158291787,
-0.6334385872,
-0.0304828491,
0.5470770001,
0.9795352817,
-0.5976938009,
0.1422075629,
0.7473328114,
0.7565078735,
0.6809816957,
0.298561424,
0.7346548438,
0.0462373085,
0.7313363552,
-0.2063608319,
-0.3038018644,
-0.1086031422,
-0.9363806844,
-0.9596344829,
-0.2973896265,
-0.1524629742,
-0.1801324338,
0.3387253881,
0.8189123869,
0.8112229109,
-1.2160637379,
0.0470873602,
-0.0747851133,
0.2140637785,
0.3448458612,
-0.2513698936,
0.2002291828,
-0.2221922278,
-0.695243001,
0.2393875569,
0.2253958583,
0.0023385745,
0.1510440558,
0.1169352606,
-0.1356523782,
0.1773580313,
0.6193447113,
0.1827034056,
-0.5066201687,
-0.6573301554,
-0.327644825,
0.1501894146,
0.1807488203,
0.8469588161,
-0.4132884741,
0.499248594,
0.2086609751,
0.5244434476,
0.2755536139,
0.1593687385,
0.4287928045,
-0.69214046,
0.4403134882,
0.3385880291,
0.208630845,
0.4872377813,
-0.5364883542,
0.4534734786,
0.328032434,
-0.5772792697,
-0.7299755216,
0.3400632441,
-0.5743784904,
-0.2077508718,
1.1534725428,
-0.2154164314,
-0.3223595917,
-0.5805521607,
-0.1996330917,
0.5243108273,
-0.5891671777,
0.732899189,
0.8158589602,
0.1805047542,
-0.3451038003,
-0.4971482158,
0.69047153,
0.2377660275,
-0.7237759829,
0.5306580663,
0.5098181963,
0.3644085228,
-0.310546577,
0.6341174841,
-0.0663133413,
0.2976306379,
-0.2240369618,
-0.2184987664,
-0.157181412,
-0.2959316969,
-0.2082134187,
0.0635411441,
-0.0903529078,
-0.1602715999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11439v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11439v1
|
StyleChat: Learning Recitation-Augmented Memory in LLMs for Stylized Dialogue Generation
| 2024-03-18T03:26:18 | 2024-03-18T03:26:18 |
Jinpeng Li, Zekai Zhang, Quan Tu, Xin Cheng, Dongyan Zhao, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate superior performance in generative
scenarios and have attracted widespread attention. Among them, stylized
dialogue generation is essential in the context of LLMs for building
intelligent and engaging dialogue agent. However the ability of LLMs is
data-driven and limited by data bias, leading to poor performance on specific
tasks. In particular, stylized dialogue generation suffers from a severe lack
of supervised data. Furthermore, although many prompt-based methods have been
proposed to accomplish specific tasks, their performance in complex real-world
scenarios involving a wide variety of dialog styles further enhancement. In
this work, we first introduce a stylized dialogue dataset StyleEval with 38
styles by leveraging the generative power of LLMs comprehensively, which has
been carefully constructed with rigorous human-led quality control. Based on
this, we propose the stylized dialogue framework StyleChat via
recitation-augmented memory strategy and multi-task style learning strategy to
promote generalization ability. To evaluate the effectiveness of our approach,
we created a test benchmark that included both a generation task and a choice
task to comprehensively evaluate trained models and assess whether styles and
preferences are remembered and understood. Experimental results show that our
proposed framework StyleChat outperforms all the baselines and helps to break
the style boundary of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2112729549,
-0.8721864223,
0.3313993514,
0.2495053858,
-0.2653042078,
0.5091544986,
-0.3109600246,
-0.0698229894,
0.4671628177,
0.7045911551,
-0.786984086,
-0.7144603133,
-0.0497327633,
0.1414085925,
-0.1119378805,
0.7891857028,
-0.0744881853,
0.1558797807,
-0.1527786851,
0.0470884964,
-0.7777019739,
-0.6176467538,
-0.8817458153,
-0.2631816864,
0.2804977596,
0.3833029568,
0.3965647519,
0.3416804373,
0.0333948322,
0.3318805695,
0.1060229093,
0.7068430781,
-0.8442903161,
0.7397950292,
0.0736793652,
-0.4609590471,
-0.4697501063,
-0.1190985814,
0.6503940821,
0.3940210938,
-0.4224266112,
-0.1016261727,
0.0626445338,
0.6073951125,
-0.2684260607,
0.504344523,
-0.8663850427,
0.083269909,
0.0063476521,
-0.5663043261,
-0.4476161897,
-0.3179194629,
-0.0299835168,
-0.5640676618,
0.1736008823,
0.2673460543,
0.464620322,
0.0117456792,
-0.289586395,
-0.1724488884,
-0.8621739745,
0.9100947976,
-0.506682992,
0.4504278004,
0.236857146,
0.3948898315,
-0.3027800024,
-0.7060049176,
-0.3523144424,
-0.1732466668,
0.1733458489,
0.0893414915,
0.0159505066,
0.1160662249,
0.1895420402,
0.2715596557,
-0.4371694028,
-0.2224114537,
-0.1092142686,
-0.2787707746,
0.4565500021,
0.5158876181,
0.1719767451,
-0.0745103657,
-0.2830321491,
-0.083091408,
-0.5762834549,
-0.0981279165,
0.207027927,
0.4131479859,
0.0487056822,
-0.0109839542,
-0.2442882955,
0.4150380492,
0.4055181742,
-0.4576156437,
0.3518690169,
-0.6390505433,
-0.098468028,
-0.1650123447,
0.7939106822,
0.5394608974,
0.311088264,
-0.1883049607,
-0.2270165533,
-0.5440368652,
0.5276563764,
-0.8961824775,
-0.1254170686,
-0.1204494014,
-0.3669935167,
-0.3040634692,
-0.3030898869,
-0.9021862745,
-0.1953396946,
-0.5347361565,
0.047405947,
-0.5767508149,
-0.1732331514,
-0.1640818119,
0.1161974892,
0.2137849927,
0.6560112238,
-1.0868395567,
0.2660101056,
0.3801124394,
0.8575001955,
-0.295666188,
0.041257143,
-0.3130686879,
0.0083204191,
-0.5825221539,
0.457692951,
-0.7714184523,
-0.6881369948,
0.1716097295,
-0.0803867206,
-0.057155367,
-0.6008501649,
0.2459573895,
-0.5091755986,
-0.1059390381,
-0.3280896842,
-0.3646865189,
-0.0568599887,
0.2214788049,
-0.510628581,
0.9407294393,
0.2521468699,
-0.4607794881,
0.2793376148,
-0.4154218435,
-0.2861615419,
0.252502501,
-0.4912060797,
-0.3623494208,
-0.1815771759,
0.2219472975,
0.6688954234,
-0.2740139663,
0.3860788643,
-0.0705164075,
-0.4798387587,
0.3182246983,
-0.6951020956,
0.2660085559,
0.4187128544,
-0.0824835896,
0.1793546677,
-0.5832879543,
0.1164716929,
0.2785359323,
-0.3144619465,
-0.0493018553,
-0.3009269536,
0.1484580934,
-0.0137036992,
0.1840489209,
-0.4431690276,
0.3926297724,
-0.2536277473,
0.4518834651,
0.7804484367,
0.2929060459,
0.3332464397,
-0.6436088085,
0.6234142184,
0.0009778142,
-0.1220613569,
-0.5099930167,
-0.1781655699,
-0.7076579332,
-0.3055908978,
-0.0849823132,
0.6385177374,
-1.1240231991,
0.1803537458,
-0.1274546534,
-0.4716045856,
-0.3921919465,
0.3615526259,
0.4388232529,
0.4298378527,
0.2434137166,
-0.4757961929,
-0.5733225942,
-0.7906340957,
0.0074974089,
-0.1146334112,
0.0744090602,
0.5619260669,
0.1337167323,
-0.2586434484,
0.9113917947,
-0.416995883,
0.1585613489,
-0.5873832107,
0.1101087332,
-0.0357627906,
0.3412180245,
0.6030464768,
-0.5888708234,
-0.2848158479,
-0.4294559658,
-0.480496943,
-0.0341486149,
-0.3408429623,
-0.2786684036,
0.2468975931,
0.4807013571,
-0.4256015122,
0.2074903697,
0.2181474864,
0.1973395944,
0.7521610856,
-0.0427660532,
0.4811345041,
-1.4719883204,
-0.1329513937,
0.1450993121,
-0.2777942717,
-0.8575311303,
-0.3764594495,
-0.2929072082,
-0.2449667156,
-0.422653079,
0.6097028255,
-0.2071286291,
0.0598452538,
-0.0971066803,
-0.1776680201,
0.1386241466,
0.9034312367,
0.2796082795,
1.0004329681,
0.1987597942,
-0.433721751,
0.5433573723,
0.1715727597,
-0.4174325168,
0.6416791677,
-0.4716396034,
0.3677588999,
-0.0579107553,
0.5439040065,
-1.3893517256,
-0.2727029622,
0.2584549487,
-0.06766361,
0.6997196674,
-0.1478562057,
-0.6525755525,
0.0362022705,
-0.2611742616,
0.3876547813,
0.6118654609,
-0.5584831238,
0.4939420521,
0.1799538136,
-0.4919440746,
-0.429078877,
-0.2893069685,
-0.0222781412,
-0.4143473506,
-0.5540443063,
0.1549576521,
-0.2497068644,
-0.1539766937,
-0.6895901561,
-0.0575089827,
-0.0253583528,
-0.0526959412,
0.2591881156,
0.3370161653,
-0.0089330627,
0.2033400834,
0.0687247738,
0.1657407284,
-0.0812259987,
0.00540523,
0.90348804,
-0.1342003196,
-0.368832469,
-0.7172579169,
0.416264385,
0.5915619135,
0.0479149036,
0.4196989536,
0.4598608315,
0.0876229852,
-0.270611912,
-0.7725803852,
-0.2539473474,
-0.5004603863,
0.4162234068,
-0.260579586,
-0.9616953731,
0.4174408913,
-0.4488729239,
0.5215373039,
-0.112918824,
0.5849409699,
-0.1398936808,
0.8601917028,
0.2224520892,
-0.1751090437,
0.9069589376,
-0.1807954013,
-0.0032680864,
-0.7052630782,
-0.1830604225,
-0.0445651747,
-0.2328860164,
-0.5601639152,
-0.4903264642,
0.2870711684,
-0.0221459884,
-0.3125071824,
0.108913213,
-0.5079766512,
0.259514302,
0.5043748617,
0.1829065979,
0.3376580775,
0.3803859055,
-0.1398853809,
-0.2368867546,
-0.5284415483,
-0.5671087503,
1.1063147783,
0.3482172489,
1.0908168554,
-0.1269379407,
0.941095531,
0.2512186468,
-0.0128500089,
-0.8705218434,
0.6748472452,
0.1758409888,
-0.0917896479,
-0.19282493,
-0.5030235052,
-0.793558836,
0.1404744983,
0.0009540015,
-0.6503388286,
-0.038337633,
0.4267643094,
-0.3572247326,
0.1290553063,
-0.5283691287,
0.4217005372,
-0.0757852197,
-0.2269640416,
-0.1118783653,
-0.5084903836,
0.3574513793,
0.0207207464,
-0.0338411964,
0.0732371509,
0.1561573446,
0.7693232298,
-0.3489196599,
1.225258708,
0.1134191081,
-0.0246815924,
0.4477370381,
0.2855783999,
0.5331113935,
-0.0591494292,
0.040657796,
0.1606249511,
-0.0301456358,
-0.1707898825,
-0.870426178,
0.5823608041,
-0.650290668,
-0.6937085986,
-0.0346785672,
-0.6930203438,
-0.6157126427,
-0.0967342854,
0.1304739267,
0.6833444238,
-0.3449259102,
0.0672974065,
0.7523255944,
-0.1354984939,
0.1836048514,
0.4012315273,
-0.3186676204,
-0.5182596445,
1.0820727348,
0.1440854967,
0.5696960688,
0.214640826,
-0.0741098598,
-0.1643826813,
-0.4272025228,
-0.4763047099,
0.1384696364,
-0.621322155,
-0.0989832655,
-0.5689741373,
-0.3672731519,
-0.4138531387,
-0.2277604789,
-0.2867121696,
-0.2698731124,
-0.3201578259,
-0.0319405347,
0.6572640538,
0.6393764019,
0.2891605496,
0.2266604006,
-0.556858182,
0.088418439,
0.4384708107,
0.0785792768,
0.1686738878,
-0.5076845288,
0.0039479691,
0.1011168659,
-0.5989320278,
-0.517413497,
0.5395339131,
0.0094175451,
0.4753896296,
0.3511849344,
-0.0919962227,
0.653798461,
-0.6816602349,
0.8037440777,
0.22354424,
-0.4668435752,
0.5049122572,
-0.4341390133,
0.2271790951,
0.5642669797,
0.1855738014,
-0.765683651,
-0.4246824682,
-0.6860057712,
-0.7136782408,
0.6150621772,
0.1232182235,
0.4306437671,
-0.2493257523,
0.5059342384,
0.110037446,
0.5555487275,
-0.0109886974,
-0.3713753819,
-0.5369330049,
-0.0876485035,
0.0546172112,
-0.2965649664,
-0.1243017465,
-0.1056277603,
0.472530514,
-0.2094232291,
0.450427115,
-0.0735720843,
0.3631668687,
-0.0356603228,
0.5593389273,
0.7302735448,
0.3466434181,
-0.2192309946,
-0.2627456486,
0.1363350153,
-0.4489510953,
0.087574482,
-0.3123007417,
-0.1509974152,
0.0704188794,
0.1418210119,
0.9922498465,
0.4565032423,
-0.6385785937,
0.2049626857,
-0.1302147359,
-0.0827064589,
-0.2850058675,
0.3357456326,
0.1686003655,
0.1915276498,
0.3121489882,
-0.1516934186,
0.1104336753,
-0.7874174714,
0.3863667846,
0.6063975096,
-0.1651409864,
-0.1234078407,
0.1987645626,
0.5075139403,
-0.2835157216,
0.5503004193,
-0.2735163867,
-0.3871563077,
0.4305364788,
0.6220132709,
0.7584708929,
-0.3602073491,
0.2110407054,
0.390034169,
-0.2124888152,
-0.1620870084,
0.3853751719,
-0.3193690479,
-0.8929100037,
-0.2975189984,
-0.6647431254,
-0.5995087028,
0.3516016603,
-0.6113107204,
0.0199791286,
-0.6397326589,
-0.2478153408,
-0.3956951201,
0.0671554878,
-0.5566738248,
-0.0723250806,
-0.0614051484,
0.63089782,
-0.6275042892,
0.5605865717,
0.3768634796,
-0.2734861374,
-0.829097867,
0.1051024348,
0.2881673276,
-1.0382039547,
0.9034779072,
0.0709174797,
-0.2856969535,
0.0838261023,
-0.6838539243,
-0.6369614005,
1.2216364145,
0.3116647005,
-0.7452537417,
-0.2320194691,
-0.1466317624,
0.4743945003,
-0.7063065171,
0.28181988,
0.613096118,
0.0808344036,
0.9726495147,
-0.9665918946,
-0.052186247,
-0.1769609898,
0.358507067,
0.0679317787,
-0.9086217284,
0.5482023358,
-0.0921750814,
-0.378015995,
0.3022727072,
0.7101931572,
0.537281692,
0.0809669122,
0.3038726747,
0.1447293758,
0.6822459102,
-0.0606767908,
0.9024735093,
-0.1946893185,
0.1285408437,
1.2817151546,
-0.3617140949,
0.5642188191,
0.201995343,
-0.0239817407,
0.3993840516,
0.5535991788,
0.1362804174,
0.4777725935,
0.197897613,
-0.3419726193,
-0.601753056,
-0.4445000887,
-0.1212825254,
0.369863838,
0.4830320179,
-0.4538185298,
-0.2111513466,
-0.1321525723,
0.1905456036,
0.0825967044,
-0.1946600825,
1.035597086,
0.0710092634,
-0.4907556772,
0.7973225713,
-0.364089489,
0.6808221936,
-0.6471577287,
-0.6131919622,
-0.2116562873,
-0.1785583794,
0.031675797,
-0.7082036138,
-0.192493245,
-0.1541941315,
-0.1370307803,
-0.4674479067,
0.5853016973,
-0.8119523525,
-0.3425221145,
-0.2034785748,
0.3829052448,
0.1697598696,
0.2652056813,
-0.6579198241,
0.1916922778,
0.1129535362,
-0.2233127505,
0.5611466169,
0.3960601687,
-0.0813492164,
0.8826749921,
0.4965751469,
0.0689362064,
-0.2291392386,
0.2580541074,
0.8813695312,
-0.4298102558,
-0.2178373337,
-0.6949113011,
0.1806839854,
-0.0993826315,
-0.0799367353,
0.6512264013,
0.3737535775,
0.6275495291,
0.0142310811,
0.8813949227,
0.4256928265,
0.5575503111,
-0.6665645838,
0.5081045032,
-0.2085349113,
0.1727748662,
-0.3913804591,
-0.6789187193,
0.1066590697,
0.6350631714,
-0.1928295046,
0.4369786978,
0.2897106111,
0.9365833998,
0.1676175594,
0.1776055396,
0.521635592,
-0.0717453957,
0.4189969897,
0.5077496171,
0.7924134731,
-0.025632225,
0.429910481,
-0.1691108942,
-0.1560115963,
-0.4232694507,
-0.5358536243,
-1.1138064861,
-0.7451463342,
-0.1260467917,
-0.2788210511,
0.062259011,
1.3898829222,
0.7648319006,
-0.5740348697,
-0.2197992802,
0.1469432265,
-0.1358346194,
-0.1132682115,
-0.2768670619,
0.1030880585,
-0.6435990334,
-0.8471417427,
0.5765568018,
0.3504940569,
0.1845233291,
-0.3271811604,
-0.1329267621,
0.1807116717,
0.2541007102,
0.6153488755,
0.2970157266,
-0.8066827059,
-0.2706597447,
-0.1749187708,
-0.1215306297,
0.1643690318,
1.0787012577,
-0.6756635308,
0.763875246,
0.3194054663,
0.6001187563,
0.2379052788,
0.3051884472,
0.7523248792,
-0.9664415121,
-0.1880403906,
0.1720861048,
0.4091025889,
0.2573977411,
-0.3601275086,
0.2341687381,
0.2640394568,
-0.5588074327,
-0.4839847088,
0.4412596822,
-0.9707102776,
0.0552795008,
1.3319704533,
-0.0497879796,
0.0550309531,
-0.2972594202,
-0.7035442591,
0.1634535491,
-1.0849401951,
0.6167476177,
0.6841096282,
-0.4812958539,
-0.2272193283,
-0.5446922183,
0.6730872989,
0.1730243564,
-0.5266464353,
0.4271954894,
0.7137303948,
0.4137040079,
0.2534324229,
0.8814544082,
0.1616568118,
0.2587904334,
-0.2492816448,
-0.002855374,
-0.1918913424,
-0.3189968467,
-0.0505669042,
0.1286082715,
0.1038654447,
-0.0294230208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11435v1
|
InsCL: A Data-efficient Continual Learning Paradigm for Fine-tuning Large Language Models with Instructions
| 2024-03-18T03:10:36 | 2024-03-18T03:10:36 |
Yifan Wang, Yafei Liu, Chufan Shi, Haoling Li, Chen Chen, Haonan Lu, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning effectively optimizes Large Language Models (LLMs) for
downstream tasks. Due to the changing environment in real-life applications,
LLMs necessitate continual task-specific adaptation without catastrophic
forgetting. Considering the heavy computational cost, replay-based Continual
Learning (CL) methods are the simplest and most widely used for LLMs to address
the forgetting issue. However, traditional replay-based methods do not fully
utilize instructions to customize the replay strategy. In this work, we propose
a novel paradigm called Instruction-based Continual Learning (InsCL). InsCL
dynamically replays previous data based on task similarity, calculated by
Wasserstein Distance with instructions. Moreover, we further introduce an
Instruction Information Metric (InsInfo) to quantify the complexity and
diversity of instructions. According to InsInfo, InsCL guides the replay
process more inclined to high-quality data. We conduct extensive experiments
over 16 tasks with different training orders, observing consistent performance
improvements of InsCL. When all tasks have been trained, InsCL achieves
performance gains of 3.0 Relative Gain compared with Random Replay, and 27.96
Relative Gain compared with No Replay.
|
[
0.0133687546,
-0.5798137188,
0.326023519,
0.3260255158,
-0.2262978405,
0.4898797572,
-0.6756857634,
-0.1458439231,
-0.368521452,
0.5582791567,
-0.4849520326,
-0.5736628175,
-0.4317946732,
-0.0732547492,
-0.3696906269,
0.999258697,
-0.0042369417,
0.2297037989,
-0.45366925,
-0.079475835,
-0.5367648602,
-0.2138819546,
-0.8576245904,
-0.4671551883,
0.1801119,
0.938372016,
0.0904743001,
0.6387631893,
0.2714743018,
0.1964363307,
0.182286486,
0.701674819,
-0.9831892252,
0.1496058255,
-0.2362644374,
-0.4232926369,
-0.1049587205,
-0.3993905485,
1.0637102127,
0.6823143363,
-0.3090817928,
0.3095543385,
0.6026216149,
0.8641782403,
-0.5422940254,
0.1255572587,
-0.7860215306,
-0.0678965598,
-0.1762078404,
-0.502558887,
-0.6572645903,
-0.4252200723,
-0.0790661052,
-0.3255366385,
-0.0546085499,
0.2614356577,
0.5675359368,
0.2647146881,
0.1332039386,
-0.5044730902,
-0.7748872638,
0.8748514652,
-1.0384927988,
0.4125326574,
0.113197729,
-0.0387309343,
-0.459898293,
-0.5498070717,
-0.3142681718,
-0.445315361,
0.1191874519,
0.156394124,
0.0148989288,
0.0565890372,
0.1263720691,
0.2433878034,
-0.5539265871,
0.3590140939,
-0.1806669235,
0.1840561628,
0.440553844,
0.351347506,
0.1529760361,
0.6062196493,
-0.5288544297,
0.1858166605,
-1.0432072878,
0.1209415942,
0.1709081084,
0.2040955424,
-0.1691122651,
0.0138973715,
-0.2486104816,
0.6827774644,
0.3779754639,
-0.503677845,
0.037898697,
-0.1286607534,
-0.1031303108,
0.5370945334,
0.4137032926,
0.1595836282,
0.0682385042,
-0.5608663559,
-0.406331867,
-0.3687247336,
0.4289511144,
-0.7646375299,
-0.1552792788,
-0.2405698001,
-0.3576605022,
0.084867239,
0.0279423054,
-0.5269278884,
0.0960461497,
-0.6197170019,
0.406776756,
-0.6471575499,
0.1711573899,
0.1208896562,
0.1963127404,
0.0656199679,
0.357793957,
-0.9185579419,
0.5225607753,
0.8596227765,
0.8936582208,
-0.5530560017,
-0.2791152596,
-0.7394738793,
0.2528493106,
-0.4901297688,
0.5659810901,
-0.7369856238,
-0.3174346983,
-0.0432227142,
-0.0109125748,
-0.1514912546,
-0.8123432994,
-0.0671955198,
-0.6531076431,
-0.0302652325,
-0.0236219857,
-1.0464161634,
-0.39005512,
0.2626543939,
-0.1890889555,
1.0983639956,
0.1545927674,
-0.2482260913,
0.3632614613,
-0.5263280272,
-0.325393945,
0.3610560894,
0.2021205276,
-0.4093982279,
-0.0182332918,
-0.2036697119,
0.4841033816,
-0.5376192331,
0.1998763382,
-0.3196366429,
-0.8760502934,
0.0776501894,
-0.5897445083,
0.2508812249,
0.0889178142,
-0.5978949666,
0.0621618219,
-0.7068114281,
0.0403410383,
-0.3276572526,
-0.6733387709,
-0.3667019606,
0.1581397653,
-0.4779476821,
-0.0075799399,
0.3565461934,
-0.6848165989,
0.183487922,
-0.4301070571,
0.2768544555,
0.7174236178,
0.2502857447,
0.330676049,
-0.4751280546,
0.3770039976,
-0.0773096308,
0.1430830061,
-0.3624308705,
-0.0445868857,
-0.8111803532,
-0.171355769,
0.0050759111,
0.6416419744,
-0.5541115999,
0.1827292889,
-0.5369677544,
-0.5023159385,
-0.3420079947,
0.4549640715,
0.8802140951,
0.665961504,
0.298435837,
-0.2703818977,
-0.283266902,
-0.5426889062,
-0.1020841226,
0.1050780714,
0.176594153,
0.2899228036,
0.3978072703,
-0.1839521229,
0.5357899666,
-0.0072107585,
-0.0321985856,
-0.1633933783,
0.0541695319,
0.2995873392,
0.6354395151,
0.2591439188,
-0.3283641636,
-0.8107097149,
0.3021365404,
-0.7771564722,
0.0919232666,
-0.5641186833,
-0.0473324284,
0.4047662318,
0.8625566363,
0.0372893326,
0.1406076103,
0.4632213712,
0.1427277923,
0.4823327661,
-0.6467914581,
0.251976639,
-0.4437259436,
-0.1895019412,
-0.3390619159,
-0.2520560622,
-0.2734148204,
-0.0879771337,
0.3666032255,
0.1815467477,
-0.4152506888,
0.497867167,
-0.4335139096,
0.158951059,
-0.3825133741,
-0.0804251954,
-0.3655385375,
0.8669170141,
-0.5255752802,
0.8889673948,
0.5823763013,
-0.9887939692,
0.3849404752,
-0.2715161443,
-0.5349219441,
0.5582090616,
-0.4597325921,
0.2379034311,
-0.2195371687,
0.0101614464,
-0.9567601085,
-0.0042789103,
0.1778142601,
-0.1129473522,
0.7517772913,
-0.1323317289,
-0.83491081,
-0.1501315981,
-0.0309727322,
0.2117157578,
0.533288002,
-0.8749511838,
0.2086304575,
0.1348591447,
0.036081288,
-0.3488864601,
-0.4555762708,
-0.0382216796,
-0.3183827698,
-0.1894089878,
0.5028010011,
-0.3269483745,
-0.0803844482,
0.0406706184,
-0.1268916428,
0.0624779202,
0.0150246955,
0.2847147882,
0.0898494124,
-0.2351281941,
0.5710530281,
0.3553710282,
0.0631744787,
-0.1369126141,
-0.8080860376,
0.4919534624,
-0.3360412717,
-0.286372602,
-0.6091976166,
0.3151028454,
0.6011568904,
-0.0911116377,
0.6258496642,
0.1735255271,
-0.1888658404,
-0.5401443839,
-0.570271194,
-0.098113656,
-0.4746361375,
0.4125170112,
-0.0047025606,
-0.8881883025,
0.2239105254,
-0.4025703669,
0.3750522435,
-0.0132801607,
0.4148361981,
-0.4090950191,
0.7805478573,
0.5985404253,
-0.178864181,
0.5158711672,
-0.1526889652,
-0.0755191445,
-0.7400246263,
-0.2780354321,
-0.1187540591,
-0.4277304113,
-0.1698544323,
-0.0380133055,
0.4898546338,
0.139138639,
-0.7309653759,
0.2595509291,
-0.4896364808,
0.4796759188,
0.6082824469,
0.4176693261,
0.2381890118,
-0.0237690713,
0.2028920501,
-0.0430427492,
-1.0025190115,
-0.3298642635,
1.0067294836,
0.0223611575,
0.8791640401,
-0.1933360547,
0.6912682056,
0.4350871444,
0.466448009,
-0.27394858,
0.4660083055,
-0.373380959,
-0.1069674343,
-0.2382138073,
-0.3322744966,
-0.8079530001,
-0.1022629738,
0.0287307445,
-0.5845053196,
-0.1428298205,
0.6855182052,
-0.287486136,
0.5706352592,
-0.4432866573,
0.6037177444,
-0.4439837337,
-0.3890229762,
-0.6748321056,
-0.5473387241,
0.178829357,
-0.1634142697,
0.0655504018,
0.1124419421,
0.020453196,
0.5993762016,
-0.2885038257,
0.9123362899,
-0.0110536283,
0.1690164506,
0.2343708724,
0.0467775948,
0.682148397,
0.0950533226,
0.0303474944,
0.0366220511,
-0.0566784516,
-0.2773893774,
-0.7645158172,
1.0193629265,
-0.2887608409,
-0.2769384682,
-0.1085310876,
-0.6910110712,
-0.175577119,
0.1022559851,
0.2363877147,
0.8306908011,
-0.0039494382,
0.4116392434,
1.1944624186,
-0.2914399803,
0.4627420902,
0.5666260719,
0.1957786083,
-0.2895121276,
1.1348326206,
0.180319041,
0.5717781782,
0.7591037154,
0.0929430649,
-0.0205720942,
-0.5603371263,
-0.4613361359,
0.3859294951,
-0.5973674655,
-0.3826218247,
-0.3892547488,
-0.0768684447,
0.202988863,
-0.3606518805,
-0.5562887788,
0.1935139745,
-0.4398578703,
0.2685546577,
0.4087631404,
0.6116189361,
0.1266330779,
0.3256593347,
-0.7996791601,
-0.1942875832,
0.11629159,
0.5487680435,
0.3187345862,
-0.8813174367,
-0.6704679728,
0.2695944309,
-0.2294565886,
-0.4457511604,
0.2642965317,
0.5721384287,
0.5424107909,
0.2880394459,
-0.0792497993,
0.9188690782,
-0.6342647672,
0.5190057158,
-0.034557309,
-0.8006002903,
0.2084466666,
-0.0058528534,
0.6613317728,
0.6132577658,
0.3473911881,
-0.5791871548,
-0.4530426562,
-0.4700315595,
-0.7507297993,
0.5359769464,
-0.4778258204,
0.265280962,
-0.0995869488,
0.6052358747,
0.3953363299,
0.2543132305,
-0.199210912,
-0.1733013242,
0.1667635143,
-0.302536726,
0.0330795348,
-0.2010748088,
0.1407853067,
-0.2372839749,
0.8817452192,
-0.0750779361,
0.2291340232,
-0.0988265276,
-0.3340780437,
0.0101145012,
0.0439404063,
0.7905718684,
0.7340488434,
-0.1270951033,
0.0070098694,
0.6892833114,
-0.3695967197,
0.0621934123,
-0.392056644,
-0.2372019589,
-0.0357838273,
0.3383712173,
0.856816411,
0.9298185706,
-0.9150882959,
0.2062251121,
0.2619425058,
0.0145136081,
-0.7118366957,
0.4145522118,
-0.0905699357,
0.4148537517,
0.194142133,
0.1310765743,
-0.0896058604,
-0.5026526451,
0.4228032231,
0.3286416829,
-0.7546505928,
-0.1416014731,
0.5295736194,
-0.2532412708,
-0.2841786444,
0.7910189629,
-0.3861783445,
-0.2696685195,
0.4109044373,
0.8790636063,
0.5261673331,
-0.0738710016,
0.0297842696,
0.5854501724,
-0.0167132262,
-0.4748121798,
0.169465661,
-0.2145880759,
-0.2257107794,
-0.3571850657,
-0.4846008122,
-0.2766575813,
-0.0313825421,
-0.5890896916,
-0.0326876976,
-0.65792346,
0.4079619646,
-0.5712137222,
-0.295658797,
-0.4637809694,
0.130690217,
0.001745914,
0.8692953587,
-0.2205519676,
1.0507999659,
0.2599981427,
-0.0924492478,
-0.6351163387,
-0.1265664995,
0.0071077608,
-0.5131249428,
0.7668333054,
0.0558817312,
-0.4403241277,
0.2661815882,
-0.8032996058,
-1.0173020363,
1.1728931665,
0.4224700928,
-0.8067445159,
0.1242228299,
-0.2993351817,
0.4512874484,
-0.5944970846,
-0.0553770848,
0.5235096812,
0.1555697769,
-0.0506824553,
-0.6239147782,
-0.1326328069,
-0.0895790532,
0.0486365966,
0.3916704357,
-0.6444747448,
0.6485505104,
-0.1663626283,
-0.3271592557,
0.0702441931,
0.8864936233,
0.1664939672,
0.18574211,
0.3858209848,
0.4172070622,
0.8017601967,
-0.0050727124,
0.9929887056,
-0.4160917997,
0.3439734876,
1.3394709826,
0.039887324,
0.7502648234,
0.1555635333,
0.0152146537,
0.614680469,
0.3719638586,
-0.0981870443,
0.6587377191,
0.2676985264,
-0.3292514682,
-0.2626079619,
0.0666214898,
-0.1350703537,
0.2511891127,
0.6582655907,
-0.1883095354,
-0.2681309581,
0.2837419212,
0.3292007148,
0.266010046,
-0.4651389718,
0.7028635144,
-0.037520688,
-0.7270867229,
0.8795211315,
-0.2882916033,
0.7746171355,
-0.8688774705,
-0.3505199254,
-0.2688144147,
0.4628790021,
0.0562039204,
-0.5119062066,
0.1030855328,
-0.1972770095,
-0.281983912,
-0.3239498734,
0.1303183436,
-0.8062656522,
-0.2213072628,
0.1661427468,
-0.2933180928,
0.1460106075,
0.107076101,
-0.4823715687,
0.1038397774,
0.0755042434,
0.2141982466,
0.4876711965,
0.2902561426,
-0.1494631022,
1.0035378933,
0.4688683748,
0.1466284096,
0.1833447963,
-0.2753145099,
0.6342032552,
-0.3742937744,
-0.443795234,
-0.8758961558,
0.4016511142,
-0.0200858861,
-0.4373274148,
0.7385976315,
0.5376045704,
1.272746563,
-0.1346933246,
0.5560238957,
0.2975946665,
0.6455405354,
-0.8402115703,
0.6111904383,
-0.7328227758,
0.3197322488,
-0.1250128895,
-0.622715652,
-0.3078220189,
0.1997850984,
-0.0769436061,
-0.2317789495,
0.5266026855,
0.9562575221,
-0.1884091944,
-0.1741283685,
0.2141137868,
0.1746752709,
0.1962243319,
0.8533434272,
0.555490911,
-0.1421883702,
0.3487201631,
-0.2781913579,
-0.297604084,
-0.3166135252,
-0.6224393845,
-0.6848401427,
-0.6232692599,
-0.2638984919,
0.033900056,
0.487635076,
1.2129414082,
0.6616360545,
-0.8182020187,
-0.4738131762,
-0.1771309525,
-0.0714847073,
-0.7161030173,
-0.1447922438,
0.3693683147,
-0.9526240826,
-0.6250244379,
0.6206726432,
0.8215017915,
-0.2565412223,
-0.0700257272,
-0.3840334415,
-0.0568532906,
-0.0817558169,
0.6181535125,
0.5517762303,
-0.6338540316,
-0.3871872723,
-0.0617399588,
-0.1091485247,
0.1266408265,
0.7396748066,
-0.719643414,
0.7769913673,
0.2006688267,
0.929820478,
0.5037067533,
-0.0957454741,
0.4973442852,
-0.6338499784,
0.0040702824,
0.2177114487,
0.1959525347,
0.2873013914,
-0.4599970877,
0.1320997775,
0.0702983066,
-0.8547333479,
-0.753651619,
0.1091441289,
-0.7583104968,
-0.1882620156,
0.8848019242,
-0.2884131968,
-0.1001536772,
-0.1355490237,
-0.0794755891,
0.1846770495,
-0.4344691932,
0.8301810622,
0.367107302,
-0.1878108382,
-0.2234993279,
-0.6274169087,
0.4476217926,
0.2884530127,
-0.5877771974,
-0.0482326895,
0.2257625461,
0.3309009075,
-0.3321661651,
0.2869205773,
-0.152308628,
0.4480147958,
-0.2630777359,
-0.1014060229,
-0.2412132472,
-0.6153743267,
-0.1466465592,
-0.005847035,
-0.0082181972,
-0.2399520725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11430v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11430v2
|
A Novel Paradigm Boosting Translation Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-18T02:53:49 | 2024-04-15T06:34:04 |
Jiaxin Guo, Hao Yang, Zongyao Li, Daimeng Wei, Hengchao Shang, Xiaoyu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a study on strategies to enhance the translation
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in the context of machine
translation (MT) tasks. The paper proposes a novel paradigm consisting of three
stages: Secondary Pre-training using Extensive Monolingual Data, Continual
Pre-training with Interlinear Text Format Documents, and Leveraging
Source-Language Consistent Instruction for Supervised Fine-Tuning. Previous
research on LLMs focused on various strategies for supervised fine-tuning
(SFT), but their effectiveness has been limited. While traditional machine
translation approaches rely on vast amounts of parallel bilingual data, our
paradigm highlights the importance of using smaller sets of high-quality
bilingual data. We argue that the focus should be on augmenting LLMs'
cross-lingual alignment abilities during pre-training rather than solely
relying on extensive bilingual data during SFT. Experimental results conducted
using the Llama2 model, particularly on Chinese-Llama2 after monolingual
augmentation, demonstrate the improved translation capabilities of LLMs. A
significant contribution of our approach lies in Stage2: Continual Pre-training
with Interlinear Text Format Documents, which requires less than 1B training
data, making our method highly efficient. Additionally, in Stage3, we observed
that setting instructions consistent with the source language benefits the
supervised fine-tuning process. Experimental results demonstrate that our
approach surpasses previous work and achieves superior performance compared to
models such as NLLB-54B and GPT3.5-text-davinci-003, despite having a
significantly smaller parameter count of only 7B or 13B. This achievement
establishes our method as a pioneering strategy in the field of machine
translation.
|
[
-0.2705770731,
-0.7021012306,
0.4547723532,
0.382175684,
-0.5450055599,
0.1653295159,
-0.5093988776,
-0.3634690642,
0.0072000208,
0.6724561453,
-0.5567009449,
-0.3966290951,
-0.7366628647,
0.3289801478,
-0.4169630408,
1.1142686605,
-0.345677048,
0.4038468003,
0.1174595505,
-0.0175569654,
-0.6001203656,
-0.437554419,
-0.5865906477,
-0.3691153824,
0.673126936,
0.390345037,
0.8373957872,
1.1140458584,
0.5538729429,
0.2085422128,
-0.0943265185,
0.6204300523,
-0.5386710763,
-0.0790539235,
-0.0729174614,
-0.647988379,
-0.8048730493,
-0.054191418,
0.8577905893,
0.6755532026,
0.0772354603,
0.1767093092,
0.389662087,
0.5131363273,
-0.266409725,
0.0444679894,
-0.8524671197,
0.1287077814,
-0.5371728539,
-0.5476064086,
-0.4784111977,
-0.07402578,
-0.1973364651,
-0.7989881635,
0.0106870132,
0.0860148519,
0.7730538249,
0.2900175452,
-0.5137515068,
0.0100518614,
-0.6187967062,
0.7247889638,
-0.9009395838,
0.2208352089,
0.2948545814,
0.0974917337,
-0.0566704609,
-0.4235789776,
-0.4747686982,
-0.1391445398,
-0.1332565397,
-0.1443727612,
0.2244603485,
-0.098347649,
0.3366746902,
0.3340930939,
-0.4571059346,
0.6751628518,
-0.2384576946,
-0.0485045463,
0.5396823883,
0.222009182,
0.2148224413,
0.1317663044,
-0.4671692252,
-0.0965942517,
-0.9183372855,
-0.008585861,
0.2838285267,
0.6423609257,
-0.1941183209,
0.5919609666,
-0.2434666604,
0.6701003313,
0.177668795,
-0.3230325282,
0.2685061395,
-0.8163699508,
-0.0392709337,
0.0975863785,
0.5754778981,
0.175625205,
0.294444561,
-0.1477199495,
-0.4223539531,
-0.238955915,
0.2413973957,
-0.7391523123,
0.1972239763,
-0.1651386172,
-0.3299122155,
-0.2559156716,
-0.1688832045,
-0.3363536298,
-0.1649937034,
-0.8460907936,
0.4987386763,
-0.3965943754,
-0.0524852239,
0.0848269388,
0.3763397932,
0.3218440115,
0.4296986461,
-1.1162813902,
0.1007628515,
0.8962993622,
0.7926766872,
-0.271943301,
-0.5540563464,
-0.6598963141,
0.3105145991,
-0.6118677855,
0.4920299947,
-0.2935029268,
-0.0995957479,
0.0546851233,
0.1091166288,
0.093829222,
-0.4933536947,
0.5517372489,
-0.5635774732,
0.0294022541,
-0.2984807193,
-0.2862743437,
-0.1057724133,
0.2944788635,
-0.4312352538,
0.9838602543,
-0.0602145642,
-0.5859184861,
0.474999547,
-0.4447336197,
-0.7325171232,
0.0111797703,
-0.0001672474,
-0.2722907066,
0.1278669089,
0.4634172022,
0.6293199062,
-0.4514027536,
0.2551449537,
-0.1693648249,
-0.3282363415,
-0.0710554793,
-0.4123696685,
0.563000083,
0.1265605837,
-0.2069659084,
0.1733447313,
-0.4943020642,
-0.0341632441,
0.1397914439,
-0.4525970519,
-0.386402607,
-0.2479962111,
-0.0475695953,
0.2690108418,
0.5107170939,
-0.2427699864,
0.4569572806,
-0.3783708811,
0.2799121141,
0.7509209514,
-0.3405421972,
0.5481896996,
-0.290047586,
0.4710401893,
0.0260253511,
0.1059817374,
-0.5460516214,
-0.10581173,
-0.8069694638,
-0.2307757586,
0.3607021272,
0.6886034608,
-0.8367040753,
0.5212845206,
-0.578925848,
-0.3780282736,
-0.5678468347,
0.5869827271,
0.5117489696,
0.5067461729,
0.6120740175,
-0.2623915672,
-0.4617683887,
-0.9112032056,
-0.1738449186,
0.2005599737,
0.056039501,
-0.1923770607,
0.246087268,
-0.3522511423,
0.3606933951,
-0.052996099,
-0.4053211212,
-0.2598039806,
0.1794366837,
0.380240649,
0.711943686,
0.2209888548,
-0.8385779262,
-0.6013498902,
0.4674750566,
-0.7733228803,
-0.1460054964,
-0.2454691827,
-0.2055917382,
0.2753954232,
0.6083073616,
-0.3463876247,
-0.0573977605,
0.5355471373,
0.075888291,
0.3058470488,
-0.4747320414,
0.096184358,
-1.1152544022,
-0.0956581607,
-0.0938927084,
-0.3035910428,
-0.754041791,
0.1240854636,
0.3025998473,
0.2591931522,
-0.4121833742,
0.3449904323,
-0.5731956959,
0.0810903311,
-0.3790369332,
0.0725862086,
-0.159089148,
0.3342249691,
0.0172910839,
0.7272060513,
0.2628274262,
-0.481109798,
0.11591997,
0.2420018464,
-0.3182522058,
0.4567966163,
-0.4497674704,
0.1979972869,
-0.1222268119,
0.2168718278,
-0.6645216346,
-0.0607946999,
-0.0056054182,
-0.2326630354,
0.6998515725,
0.0863277018,
-0.9181432724,
-0.1880566627,
-0.0989523828,
0.4902123213,
0.3285239637,
-0.4751988053,
0.376830548,
0.1233778,
-0.3945629299,
-0.5646015406,
-0.7530919313,
0.3132990003,
-0.2056268305,
-0.6737161875,
0.5391437411,
0.1018136144,
0.1512817442,
-0.267642051,
-0.1160159633,
0.1349904388,
0.1414609104,
-0.181011498,
0.4227271676,
-0.314109385,
0.0435105413,
0.3526892364,
-0.2612915337,
-0.3307236731,
-0.5240964293,
0.6027983427,
0.0908035636,
-0.0775421113,
-0.5227082968,
0.2743218243,
0.466340661,
-0.5164441466,
0.7247473598,
0.7354627252,
-0.2610675395,
-0.1876813769,
-0.6002713442,
-0.1880910695,
-0.4177473485,
0.6033943295,
-0.5471601486,
-0.9059455395,
0.1969221979,
-0.1434072256,
0.2306582481,
0.2517971694,
0.7524836659,
-0.089334622,
1.2110078335,
0.8092814088,
-0.2553531229,
0.5382527113,
-0.0629196614,
0.10570658,
-0.8615588546,
-0.0726508796,
-0.3562755287,
-0.3303790987,
-0.5438160896,
-0.7303071022,
0.4195278585,
0.4397160113,
-0.1964764744,
0.559863925,
-0.1287680566,
0.2901259959,
0.4166517258,
0.0138298003,
0.5760467649,
0.1619065851,
-0.2252430469,
-0.1867951155,
-0.8305457234,
-0.6283633113,
1.2278370857,
0.4732252657,
0.5310916901,
-0.1283373088,
0.6046468616,
0.0277800951,
0.4940432906,
-0.5108528733,
0.4580658972,
-0.3221365213,
-0.4783320725,
-0.4049660265,
-0.3203857243,
-0.8089978099,
0.4952470362,
-0.3365595341,
-0.3472363651,
-0.2559678853,
0.2028322667,
-0.1225481629,
0.1500577182,
-0.4374431968,
0.8110620379,
-0.7206526995,
-0.5591503978,
-0.3539561331,
-0.7007372975,
0.3559260368,
-0.5627085567,
0.2555107474,
0.1054140925,
-0.3322063982,
0.3645841181,
-0.1725474298,
0.5915098786,
0.0676574409,
-0.5402597189,
-0.2451294214,
-0.072319299,
0.8720862865,
-0.1106204391,
-0.0205251947,
0.2128600925,
-0.0399622247,
-0.5317810774,
-0.5753541589,
0.4691491425,
-0.6072868109,
-0.6884458065,
-0.0330452025,
-0.9717334509,
-0.3772242367,
0.4162559211,
0.1343454719,
0.0645178258,
0.0282324497,
0.4297259748,
0.6113815308,
-0.0735447258,
0.1062220037,
0.6378020048,
-0.3313961625,
-0.2914716303,
0.760948956,
0.2241926789,
0.5580434799,
0.7466090322,
0.0113958772,
-0.1801383048,
-0.8916681409,
-0.5950677991,
0.3956020474,
-0.439208895,
-0.0981460661,
-0.5179794431,
0.0179321095,
-0.5262873173,
-0.0597997382,
-0.4241223335,
-0.1238360107,
-0.1332821548,
-0.0177324358,
-0.1286071539,
0.3667292297,
-0.0408318304,
0.3965171278,
-0.867298305,
0.3322706521,
-0.0207190141,
-0.0613194443,
-0.191991359,
-0.7508713603,
-0.7018883228,
0.1907788217,
-0.2599767447,
-0.4749106169,
0.4632104635,
-0.0880742744,
0.5755767822,
0.3603404462,
-0.2815228999,
0.8621822,
-0.7273765206,
0.3861961961,
0.1111476868,
-0.862565577,
0.3961848617,
-0.6643912792,
0.3055644333,
0.5531848669,
0.4339154959,
-0.4091350436,
-0.299220711,
-0.0719905794,
-0.7803219557,
0.6874620318,
0.0240657683,
0.2093671411,
0.3982237577,
0.3860166669,
0.2404095232,
0.3761487305,
-0.8279055953,
0.0066208225,
0.1998955011,
-0.0890834928,
-0.5335268974,
-0.1026830897,
-0.2199254036,
-0.4106863737,
0.6962607503,
-0.3262721896,
-0.2895455658,
-0.0332804359,
-0.1800808161,
-0.1141477674,
0.1978349537,
0.5840237737,
0.5933631063,
0.0510651693,
-0.0428469591,
0.3804338276,
-0.1449364573,
0.1873062551,
0.1684261113,
-0.3833709657,
-0.2579348385,
0.4637939632,
0.8788147569,
0.1884765029,
-0.3774332702,
0.2106379867,
0.42939201,
-0.1172743216,
-0.1114856154,
-0.1752692461,
-0.0353320464,
0.3457842469,
0.3400324285,
-0.0776643753,
-0.2331054062,
-0.5947765112,
0.0118495533,
0.4461936951,
-0.1944200844,
-0.2469983399,
0.6611331701,
0.0464343429,
-0.0799375325,
0.2301507592,
-0.0051562954,
-0.4356726706,
0.2882861495,
0.7357655764,
0.5253093243,
-0.2407181859,
0.038798742,
0.2797906995,
0.6921319366,
-0.5267927647,
-0.1032139361,
-0.1579742432,
-0.6454774737,
-0.7120648026,
-0.6549521089,
-0.1475142837,
0.0539113991,
-0.5973772407,
0.5162986517,
-0.1470499486,
0.073045142,
-0.1987969726,
0.012094792,
-0.6023983359,
0.0253606699,
0.2848337889,
0.9355034828,
-0.665217042,
1.2583135366,
0.5438165665,
-0.2653978169,
-0.8326550126,
-0.0151026715,
0.0102857398,
-0.7562097907,
0.7942842245,
0.1367188245,
-0.0562515631,
0.1382510215,
-0.3363658786,
-0.8528474569,
1.165341258,
0.5320031643,
-0.7939919829,
-0.3069474399,
0.388420254,
0.6156128049,
-0.5416493416,
-0.2403978109,
0.6614904404,
0.6411722898,
-0.2019568235,
-1.0828028917,
0.126673609,
-0.1750645787,
0.3524589539,
0.1687752455,
-0.5391088128,
0.8398347497,
-0.1532569826,
-0.1225839555,
0.4102289677,
0.6958153844,
0.113017574,
0.0970798507,
0.4688403308,
0.5203832388,
0.6439583302,
0.044479344,
1.1247035265,
-0.2891848385,
0.0264297649,
1.1158159971,
-0.2742989957,
0.9194954038,
0.7836142778,
-0.0174463782,
0.219681263,
0.5287032127,
-0.0434639268,
0.4344846308,
0.1812567711,
0.0800317153,
-0.4650259614,
-0.1810975075,
-0.5508615375,
0.4555128515,
0.2315578312,
-0.4928116798,
-0.049378477,
0.1638073772,
0.2481802702,
0.3162885308,
-0.3076927066,
0.6169694066,
0.1028864086,
-0.8459361196,
0.7383762598,
0.238805905,
0.8131466508,
-0.7491272092,
0.1160748973,
-0.2269551158,
0.33559376,
-0.016752813,
-0.4037826955,
0.0368807204,
0.0588381626,
-0.2361811996,
-0.6350970864,
0.3016656041,
-0.6551666856,
-0.6559492946,
0.3559934795,
0.522482872,
-0.0975527242,
-0.008519317,
-0.4518486261,
0.0605064332,
0.0181960259,
-0.1321091056,
0.5522075891,
0.6012692451,
-0.1698925942,
0.4812781215,
0.8339238763,
0.3924570084,
0.0295619555,
-0.1083025858,
0.7382280231,
-0.4394447505,
-0.4174863994,
-0.8045469522,
0.4560979903,
0.0228764638,
-0.1634095013,
1.0104113817,
0.582326591,
1.1551086903,
0.0449174829,
0.5761153102,
0.3387851119,
0.4390483201,
-0.7318203449,
0.4365530908,
-0.7177736163,
0.4179691076,
-0.1921801865,
-1.0628757477,
-0.3968932033,
0.2201596051,
-0.3330722749,
-0.1153297499,
0.5646311641,
0.9345206022,
-0.0344617479,
-0.163574934,
0.2862453163,
0.2750323117,
0.2494009584,
0.5587639809,
0.6722360849,
-0.4322393835,
0.5853033662,
-0.1519917995,
-0.2916010022,
-0.116422683,
-0.7472983599,
-0.7685849667,
-0.4312552214,
-0.0222529713,
-0.1626103967,
0.0618748814,
0.9392287135,
0.7073102593,
-0.6138100624,
-0.3485456109,
-0.0247373153,
-0.089442037,
-0.3382333815,
-0.0949551165,
0.023779029,
-0.7658054829,
-0.9686102271,
0.5614741445,
0.4130218625,
0.0639322177,
-0.3300507069,
-0.2295373976,
-0.2004002035,
-0.1405326426,
0.7029137015,
0.08615347,
-0.7489004135,
0.0021035194,
-0.0111031309,
-0.3841151595,
0.0646612942,
0.7727279663,
-0.3520099819,
0.4187762141,
0.3778558075,
0.9521027803,
0.5781918168,
0.1049553528,
0.8429935575,
-0.4939320683,
0.3452914059,
0.0667271018,
0.2445011586,
0.4017047882,
-0.2751936913,
0.4764081836,
-0.0176149458,
-0.3829058111,
-0.9188149571,
0.0956593901,
-0.9194799066,
-0.1416898966,
1.1274752617,
-0.1084143668,
0.0843149051,
0.1968015879,
-0.3139633238,
0.3856520951,
-0.0142076425,
0.6173201799,
0.6212672591,
0.1917857379,
-0.0347957127,
-0.7530594468,
0.2945471406,
0.7732622027,
-0.7669274211,
0.0372908339,
0.2623620331,
-0.0490722694,
0.0908837244,
0.3878272474,
-0.3525526226,
0.019508427,
-0.2471731007,
-0.2319028229,
-0.2767787874,
-0.4146752656,
-0.4400411844,
-0.0679579899,
0.0471025743,
0.0866792798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11425v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11425v1
|
Narrative Feature or Structured Feature? A Study of Large Language Models to Identify Cancer Patients at Risk of Heart Failure
| 2024-03-18T02:42:01 | 2024-03-18T02:42:01 |
Ziyi Chen, Mengyuan Zhang, Mustafa Mohammed Ahmed, Yi Guo, Thomas J. George, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Cancer treatments are known to introduce cardiotoxicity, negatively impacting
outcomes and survivorship. Identifying cancer patients at risk of heart failure
(HF) is critical to improving cancer treatment outcomes and safety. This study
examined machine learning (ML) models to identify cancer patients at risk of HF
using electronic health records (EHRs), including traditional ML, Time-Aware
long short-term memory (T-LSTM), and large language models (LLMs) using novel
narrative features derived from the structured medical codes. We identified a
cancer cohort of 12,806 patients from the University of Florida Health,
diagnosed with lung, breast, and colorectal cancers, among which 1,602
individuals developed HF after cancer. The LLM, GatorTron-3.9B, achieved the
best F1 scores, outperforming the traditional support vector machines by 39%,
the T-LSTM deep learning model by 7%, and a widely used transformer model,
BERT, by 5.6%. The analysis shows that the proposed narrative features
remarkably increased feature density and improved performance.
|
[
0.0564609952,
-0.6871602535,
0.9951936603,
-0.1739114672,
-0.0704560131,
0.2033722848,
0.0507882461,
-0.4379500747,
0.0667048767,
0.7940174937,
-0.5529983044,
-0.930944562,
-0.7819286585,
-0.1154824942,
-0.4124125242,
1.2714682817,
-0.1759459972,
0.0393201895,
-0.2482476979,
-0.1869441718,
-0.3954786956,
-0.7209967375,
-0.6107257605,
-0.5446093678,
0.9462153912,
0.1523716152,
0.8923993707,
0.95737499,
0.8010283113,
0.2168571204,
0.1261514574,
-0.229229033,
-0.3429801762,
0.1068318337,
0.3089528084,
-0.5076153278,
-0.2777737677,
-0.2777965963,
0.2222604305,
0.8237814307,
0.0153083717,
0.0159906521,
0.0874389187,
0.8154227138,
-0.2948220968,
0.1510860473,
-0.0974223688,
0.5447545052,
-0.1142742634,
-0.1481338739,
-0.2603910267,
-0.8107914329,
0.4083705842,
-0.3981725276,
0.3368678689,
0.1180621535,
0.6152297854,
0.370614022,
-0.4471492171,
-0.6938887239,
-0.8313738704,
0.4467593729,
-0.2961491942,
0.2044829577,
0.3696719408,
0.5127046108,
-0.2712086141,
-0.557333231,
-0.112365976,
-0.3457798362,
-0.3405168951,
0.0164943356,
-0.1988545656,
0.4119455814,
0.2550308704,
0.7570061088,
-0.8949242234,
0.2378250211,
-0.479875803,
-0.4614016414,
0.540686667,
0.3812634349,
0.3267911971,
-0.3303642869,
-0.2698929906,
-0.0842195898,
-0.374083668,
0.2746326625,
0.1392070204,
0.2844413221,
-0.1607315689,
0.6051110029,
-0.0006963189,
0.2236809134,
-0.1938767731,
-0.3246918321,
0.4280096292,
-0.020696098,
-0.4934313595,
0.462698102,
0.7820166945,
0.0630666837,
0.2142999172,
0.0393188223,
0.1629457772,
0.1413600743,
0.3387055099,
-0.7227737904,
-0.3842443824,
0.6630507112,
-0.8475111127,
-0.3555532992,
0.1078062207,
-0.4182404578,
-0.5939186215,
0.3710264862,
0.3380786777,
-0.5709193945,
0.0257220622,
0.1509572566,
-0.1559863985,
-0.2135318667,
0.0755893588,
-0.4902994037,
0.0831229463,
0.6840186119,
0.9003709555,
-0.0935013518,
-0.0315901898,
-0.6031811237,
-0.0617003217,
-0.0867159963,
0.5755271316,
-0.5824125409,
-0.5814911127,
0.2082646936,
0.1600978523,
-0.1151479036,
-0.3782236874,
0.9262907505,
0.0674311295,
0.4655185044,
-0.2088119388,
-0.602150023,
-0.3540762365,
0.1379566938,
-1.0165321827,
0.7948665619,
0.3875730038,
-0.5322218537,
0.246332854,
-0.375341028,
-0.5091010928,
-0.0162380394,
-0.1261727512,
-0.9758471251,
0.2161367387,
0.1521188915,
0.8711909056,
-0.1289073378,
0.1576832533,
-0.4115514457,
-0.2964224219,
0.3723554611,
-0.1755553931,
0.2685712874,
0.1990759671,
0.0076512913,
0.1469465345,
-0.7498967648,
0.0458517112,
0.1785491705,
-0.4748480022,
-0.142316699,
0.0575951971,
-0.054913599,
0.4201859832,
-0.3376938403,
-0.3221071959,
-0.0516736843,
-0.4695089757,
0.4874501824,
0.1578873545,
0.3295859098,
0.0910840556,
-0.8116337061,
0.5355026126,
0.0997785628,
0.0965729356,
-0.5191636682,
-0.4799583256,
-0.3926482797,
-0.3706187904,
0.0861970335,
0.5797218084,
-0.3042507172,
0.4398750365,
-0.1142059416,
-0.641995132,
-0.6062250733,
-0.079818964,
0.6108158231,
0.7561812997,
0.4061225057,
-0.2375538647,
-0.4326813519,
-0.9901673794,
-0.0805902705,
-0.2512555718,
-0.253264308,
0.6527119279,
0.2961569428,
-0.2257418483,
0.2853209674,
-0.4820803702,
-0.3904040754,
-0.4035813212,
-0.048334606,
0.2393203676,
0.2428625673,
0.1956942677,
-0.5879150033,
-0.2017709762,
0.1984322965,
-0.6471784711,
0.0830695629,
-0.1988132,
0.0462334305,
0.0198173374,
0.048757527,
-0.4582558274,
0.512231648,
0.5510246158,
-0.2828450501,
0.1832268387,
-0.3600345254,
0.1744977385,
-0.9262762666,
0.1477411836,
0.2046349496,
-0.1667827815,
-0.7654705048,
-0.480309844,
-0.1466663927,
-0.2226385474,
-0.1351213753,
0.2812440991,
-0.3036597371,
0.0338517204,
-0.2165587991,
-0.1863249242,
0.0931634009,
0.3397672772,
0.0754318684,
-0.1042218283,
0.166257441,
-0.3795400858,
0.1562786996,
0.1998225302,
-0.2388307452,
0.4252780378,
-0.6570606828,
-0.018865807,
-0.1489408314,
0.3975144029,
-0.8881385922,
-0.49779284,
0.11204274,
-0.5364355445,
0.1606705487,
-0.0999192074,
-0.1516619325,
-0.8500829339,
-0.1489183903,
0.0343753137,
0.5958476067,
0.0622923784,
0.5464463234,
0.1318906546,
-0.222400263,
-0.1686838865,
-0.9268903732,
-0.2775140703,
-0.4316123128,
-0.6692865491,
0.2513438463,
0.078206718,
0.0718593225,
0.0613238625,
0.1128184348,
-0.0551835075,
0.3422864079,
0.7048598528,
0.0543519594,
-0.2255557477,
0.5295985341,
-0.0971604139,
-0.0952011272,
0.1178115681,
-0.0437742472,
0.6189852357,
-0.097268261,
-0.5140007734,
-0.6456589699,
0.6070589423,
0.6168195009,
-0.1129752323,
0.6348009109,
0.5481607318,
-0.5959308743,
-0.0917598829,
-0.4282689989,
-0.0593511872,
-0.2941556275,
0.5580971241,
0.0433834158,
-1.1899449825,
0.5342263579,
-0.0748869777,
-0.2238529772,
0.6944109797,
0.7870346904,
-0.3365733922,
0.7596469522,
0.7074689269,
-0.2394857258,
0.1711553484,
-0.0018927811,
0.0160060171,
-0.4457815289,
-0.4920229018,
-0.6246496439,
-0.5899964571,
-0.6762707233,
-0.4334917068,
0.7429531813,
-0.206738919,
-0.3623618484,
0.0064810878,
-0.5977568626,
0.0255361423,
0.243445605,
0.4897056818,
0.328294307,
-0.1283988655,
-0.0779623091,
0.1295587271,
-0.6605897546,
-0.3920547366,
1.2973860502,
0.6865703464,
0.2572487593,
-0.0881787315,
0.7974230051,
0.3453720808,
0.0559158251,
-0.750600338,
-0.003399031,
-0.2162127048,
-0.4657603502,
-0.3514086902,
-0.3736528754,
-1.0360165834,
-0.3597680628,
-0.5541447997,
-0.3401100934,
0.0303335153,
0.2300227135,
-0.7888949513,
0.1210287288,
-0.42076388,
0.8801375628,
-0.5837058425,
0.065569222,
0.1043555364,
-0.816133976,
0.2994646132,
-0.2428500056,
0.1408899277,
-0.0472692214,
0.1926916093,
0.391962111,
-0.5295017362,
0.6216852069,
0.0224150401,
0.3952661455,
0.0362082087,
-0.0740833208,
0.6253774762,
-0.1342269778,
-0.2875860035,
0.0881414339,
-0.08925955,
-0.3755725622,
-0.5750024319,
0.448974967,
-0.5426770449,
-0.2512650788,
-0.3889530599,
-0.3467588127,
-0.2000641227,
0.0407929309,
0.3968541622,
0.2469202578,
-0.5279032588,
0.3895605505,
0.6602671742,
-0.4555018842,
0.4405736029,
0.0822251216,
0.0235426594,
-0.4193959534,
0.5597323179,
-0.0111887008,
0.2284140289,
0.4503233433,
0.6186663508,
0.0742417425,
-0.8062243462,
-0.1974911243,
0.1200175136,
-0.2667336166,
-0.0574793145,
-0.9695560932,
-0.6433766484,
0.198158592,
-0.3493572772,
-0.1660252064,
-0.100245513,
-0.3805427253,
-0.3485325277,
0.3670404255,
0.4805301428,
0.4585290849,
0.1935199946,
-1.1174460649,
0.032674823,
0.0088153211,
0.1090359539,
-0.0725449547,
-0.3216566443,
-0.3735001087,
-0.297493279,
-0.2128083557,
-0.8797969222,
0.4072059989,
0.4941876233,
0.7317015529,
0.3823292553,
-0.049846936,
0.3266402185,
-0.3522449136,
0.6749460101,
0.3024285138,
-0.5437830091,
0.8395860195,
-0.469732374,
0.2354130298,
0.4713631868,
0.7370100021,
-0.7343094349,
-0.2736434042,
-0.7764570713,
-0.4557366073,
0.3446007073,
0.2433430254,
-0.0768186525,
0.0000408327,
0.6053452492,
0.2646867037,
0.1800714731,
-0.6424323916,
-0.2296421975,
-0.246263057,
-0.7435387373,
-0.2486546338,
-0.4245907068,
-0.1992188692,
0.1225895137,
0.3286931515,
-0.1496128887,
0.2149716765,
0.5243028402,
-0.0911528394,
-0.2453009486,
0.4040451944,
0.4667693079,
0.089831084,
-0.1540884078,
-0.0738045648,
0.012328295,
-0.5228205323,
-0.0665475726,
0.2914090455,
0.0579041652,
-0.2706229389,
0.9562973976,
1.0659723282,
0.3805109859,
-0.6794726253,
0.4616171122,
0.1740812659,
-0.3188959956,
-0.2144681513,
0.3548661172,
0.1965349168,
0.5220160484,
0.0788513497,
-0.1060109586,
0.2113113403,
-0.741695106,
0.2196435332,
0.212294504,
-0.8345604539,
-0.2012720555,
0.4161391258,
0.1873465925,
-0.3398158252,
0.4208011329,
0.3557988107,
-0.4488264322,
0.6797630191,
0.3879103959,
0.920143187,
-0.3576324284,
0.3937661946,
0.3497292697,
0.2514893413,
-0.3155691624,
0.2686248422,
0.3534159362,
-0.3988049626,
0.0912194476,
-0.6798471808,
-0.4880896509,
-0.0569511466,
-0.450962007,
0.2429115921,
-0.5679420233,
-0.0342654213,
0.008838919,
0.3147979081,
-0.690736115,
0.4026173651,
0.48277542,
0.4790717363,
-0.9042197466,
0.8628837466,
0.4751677513,
-0.2564918101,
-0.9371542931,
-0.1436905265,
0.4475952685,
-0.5253567696,
0.1674493849,
0.4009441137,
0.421053648,
-0.3123393059,
0.1518557519,
-0.874956429,
1.5219467878,
0.2607284188,
-0.7449005842,
-0.0530602373,
0.3527090251,
0.8843327165,
-0.8313029408,
0.264339596,
0.5050759912,
0.3548058867,
0.2825907767,
-0.8931977749,
0.0691607594,
-0.0617220625,
0.0459090732,
0.292234689,
-0.6776869893,
0.7428699136,
-0.494281292,
-0.2660759091,
0.0578063503,
0.3682104051,
0.3030631244,
0.878460288,
0.165735364,
0.7218879461,
1.2312138081,
-0.2097326219,
1.3506644964,
0.1447241008,
0.0707977638,
0.7236765027,
-0.1023828983,
0.6923624277,
-0.1561434269,
-0.1968427896,
0.7293077111,
0.7793828845,
-0.0635484532,
0.2669833601,
0.3437651098,
-0.0285010394,
-0.2236109823,
0.1822675765,
-0.3700428009,
0.4003938437,
0.4411685169,
-1.1308530569,
0.029915994,
0.319957763,
0.3463638425,
0.089464657,
-0.4034646451,
0.6544965506,
0.2005954832,
-0.387470305,
0.2939607203,
-0.2081380188,
0.2323141545,
-0.5864720941,
0.1326163858,
-0.2381791174,
0.1427403837,
-0.5372540355,
-0.6457158327,
0.4474899769,
-0.1231826395,
-0.5644314885,
0.0290589985,
0.7522304654,
-0.4335356653,
-1.0217376947,
0.2765369117,
0.523984015,
0.1047819555,
-0.3318199515,
-0.7277265787,
0.3441980481,
-0.0697005466,
-0.2894044518,
0.2374438345,
0.3399595618,
-0.1751563102,
0.6678180695,
0.6070380211,
0.1740859151,
-0.4303330779,
-0.2175346315,
0.6932675242,
-1.0368794203,
-0.3740568161,
-0.8751240969,
0.4430154562,
0.0705901459,
-0.4178043008,
0.6280914545,
0.3905536532,
0.3782228231,
0.1906204373,
0.8776596189,
0.4277414978,
0.7644267082,
-0.7148587108,
1.027772069,
-0.4573146403,
0.2407401949,
-0.273432374,
-0.5091405511,
-0.6183740497,
0.029926287,
-0.4364649355,
0.1905699819,
0.9416404963,
0.4148672819,
0.3300418258,
0.0175944827,
0.4129741788,
0.4642100036,
0.4401704669,
1.1952182055,
0.383292228,
-0.4382514656,
0.5445320606,
-0.2614740431,
-0.215353474,
-0.4987267554,
-0.8394115567,
-1.0084042549,
-0.4783902466,
-0.2911182046,
-0.3320603073,
0.1445357352,
0.8697915077,
0.533187747,
-0.6569042802,
0.1539962143,
0.3334082067,
0.2635023296,
-0.111237675,
-0.02357441,
0.6695358753,
0.2494502962,
-0.1607750207,
0.3884279728,
0.5574035048,
0.0033745982,
-0.1259649694,
-0.1574680805,
0.3220668435,
-0.001127456,
0.3659184575,
0.4103166461,
-0.7335305214,
-0.2847854197,
-0.0987763554,
-0.3813515306,
0.2211372405,
0.8561637998,
-0.9255973101,
0.3150368929,
0.1722762585,
0.6334550977,
0.2426461875,
-0.0364238285,
0.3808647096,
-0.2965459526,
-0.1947887838,
0.5181359053,
0.3822965622,
0.3905931413,
-0.9095107913,
0.1059449092,
0.3518785834,
-0.5709126592,
-0.6050804853,
-0.0352695435,
-1.1254142523,
-0.1192424223,
1.015719533,
-0.0162021201,
-0.29879421,
-0.2316648215,
0.0421524607,
0.0919007808,
-0.199578017,
0.7416176796,
0.6637148857,
-0.4435279369,
-0.2116153985,
-0.6724787951,
0.7154408097,
0.1099749506,
-0.8756035566,
-0.3475597203,
0.4937728047,
0.2431917191,
-0.0886202604,
0.5659294128,
-0.2318836302,
0.3706700504,
-0.3546508551,
-0.0326207057,
-0.3813044131,
-0.2807144225,
-0.432279855,
0.6980646253,
-0.3454161584,
0.1629010886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11413v1
|
Dynamic Contexts for Generating Suggestion Questions in RAG Based Conversational Systems
| 2024-03-18T02:01:58 | 2024-03-18T02:01:58 |
Anuja Tayal, Aman Tyagi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
When interacting with Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)-based
conversational agents, the users must carefully craft their queries to be
understood correctly. Yet, understanding the system's capabilities can be
challenging for the users, leading to ambiguous questions that necessitate
further clarification. This work aims to bridge the gap by developing a
suggestion question generator. To generate suggestion questions, our approach
involves utilizing dynamic context, which includes both dynamic few-shot
examples and dynamically retrieved contexts. Through experiments, we show that
the dynamic contexts approach can generate better suggestion questions as
compared to other prompting approaches.
|
[
-0.8052744865,
-1.1054638624,
0.8070760965,
-0.1336467117,
-0.3101800978,
0.1921710968,
-0.0908588395,
-0.6586485505,
0.4654446542,
0.4917103648,
-1.0807697773,
0.2632044256,
-0.2108678371,
0.1137654185,
-0.3756007254,
1.1040062904,
0.1360346079,
-0.5222786069,
-0.2003908008,
-0.2709196806,
-1.1065553427,
-0.0742386654,
-0.8220008612,
-0.2920555174,
0.683539629,
0.6218258142,
0.5823379159,
-0.0959689617,
0.2547034621,
0.3515912592,
-0.3413151801,
0.5707938075,
-0.5535786748,
1.103092432,
-0.164119184,
-0.4273017347,
-0.2985560596,
-0.2083338499,
0.6374304295,
0.5549449921,
-0.0456049964,
0.2175339311,
0.0222205296,
0.3870773017,
-0.6850953102,
-0.2793190777,
-1.032443881,
0.2316528112,
-0.1415577978,
-0.6477231383,
-0.1564202309,
-0.1872244924,
0.392124474,
-0.5524175167,
0.101478219,
0.0930134058,
0.7004830837,
0.1672522128,
-0.5077526569,
-0.5310105085,
-1.0177739859,
0.5355535746,
-0.2587761581,
0.0835400447,
0.3155001104,
0.8522292376,
-0.4556974769,
-0.8033619523,
-0.6089497805,
-0.3851220906,
-0.2248432338,
0.0817593262,
0.0050459611,
-0.3483507037,
0.3793020248,
0.1445005685,
-0.4022444487,
-0.5408675671,
0.0646961182,
0.224028483,
0.3819765449,
0.4786739051,
-0.0332824886,
-0.4154605567,
-0.2522117496,
0.0178965311,
-0.5158827901,
0.1783591658,
0.1532827616,
0.3492949903,
0.1088075191,
0.2388779372,
-0.2664501667,
0.981926322,
0.5211155415,
-0.0332448334,
-0.1386393756,
-0.3641094267,
0.0568450913,
-0.2419492006,
0.3270020783,
0.3819682002,
-0.0180829559,
-0.1597311646,
-0.2240168899,
-0.447686106,
0.5419877172,
-0.6192063689,
0.2025106251,
0.3197767735,
-0.3135284781,
-0.632968843,
0.1550787687,
-0.933752358,
-0.5648639798,
-0.0964049697,
0.1981624812,
-0.2447014153,
-0.4528603554,
-0.4760764837,
-0.4768366218,
-0.0069058412,
0.5082657337,
-0.9121589661,
0.1349978447,
0.2831912637,
0.3038546145,
-0.1536423564,
0.0010388413,
-0.5173143744,
0.4252094626,
-0.2342573255,
1.1740158796,
-0.7750849128,
-0.7232949734,
-0.0272224043,
0.0646109655,
0.1824374348,
-0.7712160349,
-0.0544570722,
-0.8446471095,
0.2037034333,
-0.4726138413,
-0.3622166514,
0.1811058819,
0.6406208873,
-0.3434127569,
1.1892520189,
0.1379240453,
-0.6785235405,
0.5952547193,
-0.5735530853,
-0.0900209323,
0.6489262581,
-0.4972654879,
-0.1092073098,
-0.0248875022,
-0.0180560946,
0.2609107494,
-0.209465459,
0.5562174916,
-0.0046634125,
-0.2537273765,
0.5763349533,
-0.4622014165,
0.2764683366,
0.4718860388,
-0.5238742828,
0.1093227565,
-0.7605361342,
0.3564381301,
0.2221095562,
-0.2905212641,
-0.3826556504,
-0.1159899682,
-0.1115705371,
-0.326064378,
0.2414516956,
-0.0487838872,
0.3792922497,
-0.3265015781,
-0.0469128974,
0.5569280386,
0.4801263809,
0.4015339613,
-0.5387329459,
0.8876594901,
-0.2042468637,
-0.2148468196,
-0.4041708708,
-0.599726975,
-0.5275105834,
0.2409739196,
0.1391153187,
0.5776782036,
-1.34108603,
0.0412788019,
0.2655037045,
-0.5268474817,
0.167780742,
-0.1260786504,
0.425173074,
0.5871343017,
0.2094554603,
0.0562785156,
-0.635835886,
-0.5994597077,
-0.3703629076,
-0.3677350581,
-0.0198673513,
1.1170938015,
0.3627603948,
-0.2286088765,
1.5061658621,
-0.6921456456,
0.0967015401,
-0.3796836138,
0.2414021045,
0.0728477985,
0.30109182,
0.7702021599,
-1.1015675068,
-0.4932525456,
-0.1135435179,
-0.4265030921,
-0.3053912222,
-0.1627803892,
-0.1061735451,
0.058265619,
0.4205527902,
-0.5695325732,
0.2259785086,
0.3315013349,
-0.2746138573,
0.6502077579,
-0.1606992483,
0.1718766838,
-1.5698702335,
0.2288717628,
-0.5014838576,
-0.4289476275,
-0.6324239373,
0.0998430699,
-0.2969350517,
-0.3306476176,
-0.3315086365,
0.9897098541,
-0.336488992,
-0.0261080004,
-0.5335079432,
0.2266249657,
-0.1467575878,
0.176487416,
-0.0311487466,
0.9114357233,
0.2422992885,
-0.9535883665,
0.5406944156,
0.1739642769,
-0.2331314683,
0.714872241,
-0.5875477195,
0.3884442449,
-0.0790500417,
0.6410865188,
-1.0556727648,
-0.5457192659,
0.1933929175,
-0.3766825795,
0.2146489173,
-0.2400612831,
-0.1351595521,
-0.3949073553,
-0.1261123121,
0.6887102723,
0.3894433677,
-0.4562433362,
0.3113200665,
0.4924470186,
-0.1220662147,
-0.5184023976,
-0.4564649463,
0.0632170364,
-0.3124604821,
-0.5372084975,
0.642203927,
-0.268584758,
-0.3856314719,
0.1575751156,
0.0763453469,
0.0411571264,
0.0802777112,
0.1704177856,
0.0086126542,
0.0710704774,
0.1793044955,
0.1309111267,
0.0147440434,
-0.293564111,
-0.0181948449,
0.6756923199,
-0.2050338537,
-0.3081181049,
-0.1271008849,
0.4552427232,
0.3250344992,
-0.1834511459,
0.4063963592,
0.5856478214,
-0.2165264487,
-0.4404504597,
-0.6007900834,
-0.582110405,
-0.6031019092,
0.0127406586,
-0.6045407057,
-1.1617467403,
0.8516241908,
-0.344997555,
-0.0961861834,
0.0751602799,
0.8319128156,
-0.2492194623,
1.1068040133,
0.5007317662,
0.4097968042,
0.7588521242,
-0.3788504004,
-0.0744038671,
-0.7696514726,
-0.170538947,
-0.3202473521,
-0.4406523705,
-0.6774503589,
-0.3018897474,
0.6440246701,
-0.0865983516,
0.1917778999,
0.2886497378,
-0.5565119386,
0.3977966309,
0.5613393188,
-0.1986504048,
-0.0148330219,
-0.1978240162,
-0.4327178001,
0.1697525978,
-0.7509768009,
-0.5780613422,
0.442117393,
-0.1604932845,
0.6621685028,
0.3624634743,
0.8367548585,
0.3045470417,
0.0954901576,
-0.797450304,
0.6743254066,
0.4444334805,
-1.0290317535,
-0.3270816505,
-0.1057502627,
-1.6089986563,
0.0800987855,
-0.5197208524,
-0.9164119363,
0.2400140911,
0.2941611409,
-0.8110978007,
0.0819402561,
-0.2960473895,
0.5295381546,
0.081163682,
-0.338383764,
-0.0171797071,
-0.5729449987,
0.1682657599,
0.0934159234,
-0.1107107848,
-0.0104967654,
0.2155008763,
0.3844576478,
-0.4084148705,
0.7269872427,
-0.3496127427,
-0.0524405427,
0.8415513635,
0.4282133281,
0.6053662896,
0.4518924654,
-0.0601956248,
-0.6236357093,
0.1814802438,
0.162354216,
-0.8381451964,
0.5719505548,
-0.2052357793,
-0.9439634681,
-0.3234699965,
-0.8670880795,
-0.4838386774,
0.2133465409,
0.2379257083,
0.6210549474,
-0.1578889191,
0.2479820549,
0.3992715776,
-0.3132452071,
0.4325959086,
0.5750604272,
-0.2550451458,
-0.1980338097,
0.5988025069,
0.0217327066,
0.0185879003,
0.0157425497,
0.1477273107,
-0.1553619951,
-0.3164090514,
-0.7482286096,
-0.0600620098,
-0.3333647549,
-0.3471731544,
-0.4332939684,
-0.1082897037,
-0.4191821516,
-0.3250132501,
-0.116546236,
-0.3130299747,
-0.2041612864,
0.1210506633,
0.5929629207,
0.8621179461,
0.2203309685,
0.2318719029,
-0.9786174297,
0.3924493492,
0.6815871,
0.3394872844,
0.2361187935,
-0.3972877264,
-0.1500696242,
0.1108222976,
-0.6875255108,
-1.1307448149,
0.4089797437,
0.0210741386,
0.6903513074,
0.4114281833,
0.196251139,
0.8019078374,
-0.928971827,
1.1703267097,
-0.1554729939,
-0.32801494,
0.9901473522,
-0.686568141,
0.4835808575,
0.6907895803,
0.0016003866,
-0.7395922542,
-0.5507856011,
-0.8014903069,
-0.7928649187,
0.825024724,
0.286323607,
0.5091372728,
-0.2509568632,
0.6045415998,
0.1412335038,
0.1660421789,
-0.156525597,
-0.3368172646,
0.2495544702,
0.1866665632,
0.3167320788,
-0.3949426115,
-0.2920535207,
-0.0856640488,
0.3028644025,
-0.2854627967,
0.5782089233,
0.1252174973,
0.3150008023,
-0.4820821881,
0.3972924948,
0.9562653303,
0.8124863505,
-0.3662147522,
-0.1036416218,
0.5686022043,
-0.1362746358,
0.2592538595,
-0.0992932096,
-0.2543107271,
0.0840422958,
-0.1056139395,
0.8411328197,
0.0892869532,
-0.6886569858,
0.2239439189,
-0.3720166981,
0.0036185037,
-0.6178531647,
0.4066197872,
0.0245862193,
0.6251173615,
0.5441041589,
-0.0024008653,
0.1824884117,
-0.7824097872,
0.2894600928,
0.8704815507,
-0.2999998927,
-0.0874964297,
0.5631176829,
0.3296020329,
-0.7624010444,
0.0376239456,
-0.4694621265,
-0.6240826249,
0.6194143295,
0.7351680994,
0.8521404266,
-0.0927699059,
0.2497328818,
0.1168871224,
-0.2699957192,
0.1210488528,
0.4603830874,
-0.6695033312,
-0.850777328,
-0.1504398584,
-0.5122470856,
-0.7772414684,
0.2222662121,
-0.5633333325,
0.4361612797,
-0.2392838001,
-0.5402141809,
-0.1166161373,
0.0049192281,
-0.3335195184,
0.1351802349,
0.1048151106,
0.4984555542,
-0.0796582699,
0.7586138844,
1.1599903107,
-0.2509885728,
-0.9624572396,
0.1882894635,
0.0558719225,
-0.4135577083,
0.8131377697,
-0.1607558727,
-0.489418596,
-0.2462497503,
-0.4726696312,
-1.0340918303,
1.2623594999,
0.0687785372,
-0.1890871674,
-0.0398641117,
-0.1277382374,
0.5708433986,
-0.4540699422,
0.4692203701,
0.3051646352,
0.5626333952,
0.551548183,
-1.1668212414,
-0.0118565708,
-0.4083870351,
0.0730973035,
0.2148252726,
-0.666977942,
0.815379262,
-0.0951321125,
-0.1305054724,
0.4383616149,
0.5428224206,
0.6751167178,
0.768483758,
0.6743357182,
0.1835791469,
0.82741642,
0.1184930205,
1.2411564589,
-0.3386501372,
0.0662576109,
1.2331408262,
-0.2691113055,
0.6373268366,
0.4235352576,
0.0993626788,
0.8221924901,
0.6708730459,
0.2349071801,
0.4332450628,
-0.2073374242,
-0.3279147446,
0.0560571253,
-0.1822826564,
-0.5321167111,
0.5861353874,
0.478056848,
-0.216408968,
-0.1943430305,
0.1457251608,
-0.0688192844,
-0.1395931095,
0.1128139049,
1.1768352985,
-0.0852631852,
-1.2174813747,
0.7334157825,
-0.105215162,
0.7113339901,
-0.5299798846,
-0.2444030493,
-0.377001524,
-0.10429281,
-0.0285758786,
-0.7672536373,
0.4028305113,
0.2340768874,
-0.2133362144,
-0.395147413,
1.1682530642,
-0.5669217706,
-0.0089507215,
-0.1960150003,
0.6661201119,
0.3097246885,
0.2553365827,
-0.779651463,
-0.2117883116,
-0.1215301901,
-0.4480623305,
0.3389854133,
0.5685833097,
-0.1337416321,
0.698284328,
0.5207659006,
0.1931284815,
-0.1923544407,
0.0181869287,
0.9861133695,
-0.5470957756,
-0.5458650589,
-0.5196902156,
0.5361372828,
-0.2095303088,
-0.1888991594,
0.7413276434,
0.1209481955,
0.5682103038,
0.0531165078,
0.4899829924,
-0.4574265182,
0.7505123019,
-0.2376773655,
0.7598567605,
-0.9195925593,
0.4061312973,
-0.3740873039,
-1.1414239407,
0.0193542372,
0.5639075637,
-0.061256934,
0.4194314182,
0.5745785236,
0.8783804774,
-0.0305480454,
0.1202373803,
0.3327222764,
-0.0912776142,
0.5130825043,
0.0933851004,
1.0634099245,
-0.0106204702,
0.5505350232,
-0.0251668468,
0.0182639956,
-0.5030361414,
-0.9911004901,
-0.577678442,
-0.8564241529,
0.0759914666,
-0.2913706899,
-0.0101428572,
1.1025547981,
0.780338347,
-0.6385148168,
-0.2687660754,
-0.0138217481,
0.0873772204,
0.0404811539,
-0.3391839564,
0.0399097055,
-0.5155830979,
-0.8629466891,
0.7167522311,
0.0706192702,
0.2410591692,
-0.3348866105,
0.1000823677,
-0.2668619156,
0.2112750113,
0.7506642342,
0.2814372778,
-0.6098293662,
-0.5051396489,
-0.0555716269,
0.1091730073,
-0.3514295518,
1.1090172529,
-1.3567311764,
0.5587835312,
0.5836253762,
0.6391988397,
0.5558584929,
0.2201445848,
0.6004645228,
-1.121945262,
0.481017828,
0.556474328,
0.0058985665,
0.0775228441,
-0.5248097777,
0.3719581962,
0.2181179225,
-0.6772814393,
-0.9931486845,
0.5225512981,
-0.9558289051,
-0.4179635048,
1.4012123346,
0.1227028668,
-0.1073225364,
-0.1137821823,
-0.6270429492,
0.0911339894,
-0.4613362253,
0.6762706637,
0.5712093711,
-0.6384738684,
-0.1241606921,
-0.475348711,
0.9171143174,
0.6430606842,
-0.6187366247,
-0.1345819682,
0.4892140329,
-0.0378812887,
0.2136630267,
0.758439064,
0.284039557,
0.2956838012,
-0.2167792022,
-0.3962967098,
0.0628798753,
-0.3005670607,
0.1941077113,
0.2563854456,
0.1557991505,
0.1644216776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15447v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15447v3
|
Decoding Compressed Trust: Scrutinizing the Trustworthiness of Efficient LLMs Under Compression
| 2024-03-18T01:38:19 | 2024-06-04T05:40:12 |
Junyuan Hong, Jinhao Duan, Chenhui Zhang, Zhangheng Li, Chulin Xie, Kelsey Lieberman, James Diffenderfer, Brian Bartoldson, Ajay Jaiswal, Kaidi Xu, Bhavya Kailkhura, Dan Hendrycks, Dawn Song, Zhangyang Wang, Bo Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Compressing high-capability Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged as a
favored strategy for resource-efficient inferences. While state-of-the-art
(SoTA) compression methods boast impressive advancements in preserving benign
task performance, the potential risks of compression in terms of safety and
trustworthiness have been largely neglected. This study conducts the first,
thorough evaluation of three (3) leading LLMs using five (5) SoTA compression
techniques across eight (8) trustworthiness dimensions. Our experiments
highlight the intricate interplay between compression and trustworthiness,
revealing some interesting patterns. We find that quantization is currently a
more effective approach than pruning in achieving efficiency and
trustworthiness simultaneously. For instance, a 4-bit quantized model retains
the trustworthiness of its original counterpart, but model pruning
significantly degrades trustworthiness, even at 50% sparsity. Moreover,
employing quantization within a moderate bit range could unexpectedly improve
certain trustworthiness dimensions such as ethics and fairness. Conversely,
extreme quantization to very low bit levels (3 bits) tends to reduce
trustworthiness significantly. This increased risk cannot be uncovered by
looking at benign performance alone, in turn, mandating comprehensive
trustworthiness evaluation in practice. These findings culminate in practical
recommendations for simultaneously achieving high utility, efficiency, and
trustworthiness in LLMs. Code and models are available at
https://decoding-comp-trust.github.io.
|
[
-0.1054480821,
-0.5031648874,
0.6628814936,
0.2474271059,
-0.3919468224,
0.1590877771,
-0.0554530881,
-0.6263358593,
-0.069560267,
0.2548425496,
-0.3519266248,
-0.2384802103,
-1.01945436,
0.1482075602,
-0.5350553393,
0.6108196974,
0.2206161022,
0.1614138633,
-0.3167221248,
0.0559262037,
-0.129550308,
-0.8670839071,
-0.7724782825,
-0.2826545238,
0.0430409126,
0.2640773952,
0.9783659577,
0.7123973966,
0.5391513705,
0.2802689373,
-0.2381715029,
0.1730159223,
-0.6671649814,
0.324028343,
0.2384378761,
-0.5975455046,
-0.5991224051,
0.2040106952,
0.5924599767,
0.2813269496,
-0.2930553257,
0.2423313558,
0.3284595907,
0.5854551196,
-0.6607279181,
0.0884217322,
-0.5096606612,
-0.0718121827,
-0.016628664,
-0.6272009611,
-0.5259523392,
-0.6877683401,
-0.0937114209,
-0.5442917943,
-0.1301835626,
0.3280892074,
0.8135582805,
0.4230206907,
-0.1976941824,
-0.1378668547,
-0.6067815423,
0.7913574576,
-0.4025087357,
0.5476744771,
0.6027494669,
0.0967714489,
0.0309039373,
-0.7998355627,
-0.3909708858,
-0.1936528832,
0.2200445384,
-0.0020396619,
-0.6192768216,
0.0417908058,
0.3700326085,
0.6371263862,
-0.3403857052,
0.0061589833,
-0.037477348,
-0.595190227,
0.4724110961,
-0.0696494058,
0.216942966,
-0.0545318313,
-0.482637614,
-0.4797985554,
-0.9419606924,
-0.0275412668,
0.7279557586,
-0.2604111135,
0.0156880375,
0.3860549033,
-0.0127548063,
0.2943729162,
-0.089268297,
-0.2178546488,
-0.1743409336,
-0.4090072513,
-0.3715870678,
-0.0655613169,
0.8299878836,
0.404042542,
0.3846850693,
-0.2159973681,
-0.2440779656,
0.2938004136,
0.2045611143,
-0.7426730394,
-0.1294093579,
0.21483922,
-0.7179606557,
-0.5515324473,
0.0178502332,
-0.412694186,
-0.5797917843,
0.0184919536,
0.462046802,
-0.7737824917,
-0.1736439466,
0.4965145588,
-0.1021923646,
0.0076613296,
0.1553355306,
-0.5692613721,
0.3715656996,
0.8540953398,
0.835024178,
0.0106924139,
-0.1703724861,
-0.6241775751,
0.055112768,
-0.1830548495,
0.566463232,
-0.4103898108,
-0.4099648297,
0.033247631,
-0.2625058591,
0.3264142573,
-0.4400824904,
0.8654366732,
-0.6413176656,
-0.3573512435,
-0.0884289891,
-0.5141752958,
0.019431293,
0.3689746559,
-0.8899188638,
0.9592107534,
0.0637435764,
-0.5119838715,
0.2229083031,
-0.1540010124,
-0.1723849475,
-0.1312628835,
0.0746143386,
-0.307235837,
0.4213320613,
0.1133036986,
0.6888844371,
-0.4441250861,
0.0633774176,
-0.3657810092,
-0.5370548368,
0.6550804377,
-0.7538120151,
0.8116229177,
0.3394564092,
-0.1111750752,
-0.1722832322,
-0.6946050525,
0.1265413463,
0.0201215651,
-0.3189853728,
-0.3485426903,
-0.3219550252,
-0.1460603625,
-0.0676569566,
0.3072796464,
-0.3744117916,
-0.1126475185,
-0.2680472732,
0.6988762617,
0.8617013097,
-0.0218888894,
0.4042885005,
-0.3938841224,
0.5260272026,
-0.0013467692,
0.5284936428,
0.1835692674,
-0.1705916375,
-0.7307820916,
-0.2023259401,
0.4574005902,
0.2015003711,
-0.7799002528,
0.3838483095,
-0.5423317552,
-0.3197784424,
-0.5897142291,
-0.2410906106,
0.6082684398,
-0.1039583907,
0.1802973151,
-0.3914365172,
-0.4282150269,
-0.7434297204,
-0.6444289684,
-0.170163691,
-0.0256608371,
0.0182090104,
0.2764833272,
0.0420591757,
0.4880484939,
-0.232198596,
0.1271288544,
0.0815296546,
0.125695169,
-0.1177075133,
0.6374406219,
0.305678159,
-0.5495325327,
-0.286444366,
-0.3548244238,
-0.314583391,
0.1508098692,
0.0489062406,
-0.0556689873,
0.2826604247,
0.4388835728,
-0.7399117351,
0.2392148823,
1.0252848864,
-0.40443784,
0.6999284029,
-0.2051027119,
0.2749197483,
-0.9161570072,
-0.102924116,
-0.1220667288,
-0.5780925751,
-0.5214733481,
0.5140399337,
0.1015280262,
0.1296280622,
-0.2418423444,
0.0546905622,
-0.5990549326,
-0.2359387726,
0.0378192887,
-0.1090105101,
0.0492262952,
0.1396271884,
-0.2623801529,
0.9395584464,
0.5251224041,
-0.4620131552,
0.1044218913,
-0.0407857709,
-0.5039318204,
0.4743896723,
-0.5686782598,
0.4993728697,
0.1401231587,
0.2058931589,
-0.5964975953,
0.0123428078,
0.1363938153,
-0.6144275069,
0.395956099,
-0.1179574579,
-0.9426205158,
0.1671016812,
-0.6432583332,
0.4253206849,
0.7072831392,
-0.4127757847,
0.5063441396,
0.3431410491,
0.2068261802,
-0.6667681932,
-0.8481447101,
0.1634203941,
-0.3300988078,
-0.5553292036,
0.1786332428,
-0.3232461512,
-0.2497393787,
0.009981161,
-0.6495010853,
-0.1375182569,
0.3798607588,
0.4340949953,
0.1175477132,
0.2468525022,
-0.3213454187,
-0.0144871147,
-0.3192533553,
0.2917932272,
-0.4141156375,
0.6064865589,
-0.3855039775,
-0.0988584086,
-0.4551473558,
0.2457934618,
0.3892638385,
0.0625174791,
0.7562333345,
0.5313759446,
-0.3447600305,
-0.1626869887,
-0.6349760294,
-0.4370372593,
-0.518604815,
-0.1201344207,
-0.4961466491,
-1.3722066879,
0.253657043,
-0.3143341243,
-0.2612579167,
0.0652215108,
0.291030556,
-0.0211511813,
0.7571924329,
0.6260946989,
0.0382859558,
0.2034962028,
-0.181246683,
0.4908341467,
-0.4991231263,
-0.1131050363,
-0.6832709908,
-0.0429859236,
-0.6817703247,
-0.6030876637,
0.4886016846,
0.2188504189,
0.013536524,
0.2334561646,
-0.376953274,
0.4692517817,
0.5222844481,
0.3257470727,
0.6088373065,
0.1010104641,
0.273873955,
0.0531737879,
-0.7235636711,
-0.7198241949,
1.0341521502,
0.6610686183,
0.7733550668,
0.237882942,
0.8789926767,
0.1573972255,
-0.0065191379,
-0.8830814362,
0.6417862773,
-0.1236854941,
-0.3638376892,
-0.2490370423,
-0.5172151327,
-0.8805744052,
-0.1381075531,
-0.4148912132,
-0.611321032,
0.0928232893,
0.2719513178,
-0.6048480868,
0.0658280849,
-0.5588768721,
0.3008623421,
0.2031230927,
-0.3657236695,
-0.4955948889,
-0.7048571706,
0.5308661461,
-0.0362685286,
0.1191557422,
0.0321447663,
-0.137607947,
0.6779257655,
-0.1538210511,
0.6318920851,
0.2320078611,
-0.1297005117,
0.0218826495,
0.5058304071,
0.6605645418,
0.1245221943,
-0.096585609,
0.5708414316,
0.5439518094,
-0.3470059037,
-0.897608757,
0.751031816,
-0.7081136107,
-0.6348810792,
-0.5188695192,
-0.6413373351,
-0.4375533462,
0.1616151929,
0.1669431031,
0.4662012756,
-0.0880233943,
0.4539178908,
1.0663827658,
-0.0603250265,
0.335555613,
0.1482403129,
0.4030730426,
-0.2817009687,
0.6428728104,
-0.1441435069,
0.3763144016,
0.3616770208,
0.2275341898,
-0.293726325,
-0.7565129995,
0.0941292793,
0.0909426734,
-0.6036379933,
-0.5082423091,
-0.3103219867,
-0.2054252177,
-0.5578813553,
0.1310491413,
-0.4790014327,
-0.6027155519,
-0.1965423673,
-0.1642719656,
0.2500451505,
0.5759910345,
-0.1590027809,
0.2892914712,
-1.0347577333,
0.0542341359,
0.0768026933,
0.4032237828,
-0.0811188444,
-0.271925807,
-0.3057181537,
-0.2106057405,
-0.086725764,
-0.8488709927,
0.288353622,
-0.0990333706,
0.283945471,
0.4547052383,
0.2965978086,
0.7598335743,
-0.3299020231,
0.8674739003,
0.2309937924,
-1.2111959457,
0.0128607592,
0.0082870685,
-0.2094754577,
0.5160963535,
0.5301738977,
-0.0895702615,
-0.2988509536,
-0.9520614147,
-0.608987093,
0.3852287531,
0.3330600262,
0.0441307463,
0.1263684928,
0.4691994786,
0.2057581544,
0.1430636644,
-0.6393400431,
-0.2589640915,
-0.0676070824,
-0.1658487767,
-0.0299999751,
-0.9153342843,
-0.5217904449,
0.2039483786,
0.5288355947,
-0.0204767473,
0.4755711854,
0.2785544693,
-0.0757175609,
0.056694489,
0.4669232666,
0.2868075967,
0.360324204,
-0.0511074588,
0.5914386511,
-0.0816565976,
-0.6185749173,
0.2861895859,
-0.0870838985,
0.0685810149,
-0.3590495884,
0.3768297434,
0.5925637484,
0.2329722047,
-0.3842244744,
0.5867722034,
-0.3214779496,
-0.326733917,
-0.1805453897,
0.0807106048,
-0.1277589202,
0.4163493514,
0.0456099063,
0.1198083609,
0.3391618431,
-0.6343451142,
-0.0451051369,
0.4942598045,
-0.0981977955,
-0.2733857036,
0.3726020753,
0.1195339039,
-0.135600403,
0.2971558273,
-0.0627078563,
-0.406688869,
0.0723421946,
0.4598513544,
0.8134692907,
-0.1648709625,
-0.0509329475,
0.1821343601,
0.6205304861,
-0.6101068258,
0.3745702803,
-0.2229677737,
-0.7844209075,
-0.5839571953,
-0.4695649743,
-0.4532183111,
0.0477296971,
-1.0021586418,
-0.2550569475,
-0.3785260022,
-0.3526062071,
-0.6624695063,
0.3602961004,
-0.560575366,
0.1461043507,
-0.0345783941,
1.2276990414,
-0.6836922765,
0.9683519602,
0.3382893801,
0.0226759408,
-1.0984961987,
0.3016220331,
-0.1828270257,
-0.9774800539,
0.2916851044,
-0.0740357265,
-0.4142393172,
0.1809867918,
-0.6674779654,
-0.8221769929,
1.3905084133,
0.7577664256,
-0.6082485914,
0.0617369153,
0.0264024567,
0.2832241654,
0.0475612395,
0.1479518116,
0.9625633955,
0.4692158401,
-0.1697387248,
-0.9071734548,
0.6158932447,
-0.0142699983,
0.1275500804,
-0.0763645023,
-0.7755399942,
0.4333811402,
0.1356717795,
-0.4729157388,
0.2737257779,
0.600264132,
0.6796276569,
0.2276607901,
0.6677388549,
0.7367572188,
0.8012109995,
-0.0791018382,
1.2343484163,
-0.6480067372,
0.2397423089,
0.6368862987,
0.1049078032,
0.8123733401,
0.7478513122,
-0.1079135463,
0.2835708857,
0.4796124101,
0.2952356339,
0.450701803,
0.0500653088,
-0.1592070311,
-0.466501534,
-0.1815276742,
-0.1958589405,
0.3115527034,
0.1740403771,
-0.1797008365,
0.2347580045,
-0.4703146815,
0.2663981318,
-0.0027663424,
-0.1353922933,
0.3265862465,
0.3451411426,
-0.5035246015,
0.4799678624,
-0.1189211905,
0.7025514841,
-0.5028013587,
0.0722794458,
-0.0487142913,
-0.0898702368,
-0.2185655087,
-0.7416356206,
0.2036993206,
-0.067981109,
0.1057870612,
-0.6762784123,
0.8296365142,
-0.0302108806,
0.1490419507,
0.1247289255,
0.4745097756,
0.2528829575,
-0.2106167674,
-0.4480741024,
0.745116055,
-0.177786842,
-0.2393785715,
0.5200389028,
0.442900598,
0.2462898642,
0.7850511074,
0.7124447227,
0.3473199904,
-0.0860727802,
0.0513156466,
0.8692681193,
-0.4810833633,
-0.4938381612,
-0.9297120571,
0.2321685404,
-0.149583146,
0.0879575461,
1.1094014645,
0.4173831344,
0.8468558192,
0.0790943354,
0.6045939326,
0.3185057938,
-0.0040716366,
-0.9177381992,
0.6683943272,
-0.3903130293,
0.3635846674,
-0.0439692102,
-0.6984502077,
-0.335932672,
0.5203858614,
0.1161641255,
-0.0613522828,
1.0297942162,
0.7842801809,
0.1666382998,
0.1272703707,
0.5754004717,
0.2789727151,
0.1682470888,
0.7310816646,
1.0966514349,
-0.5245158076,
0.7938225269,
-0.3474554121,
-0.2864582241,
-0.0444706902,
-1.1612000465,
-0.6601503491,
-0.4260642827,
-0.23386769,
-0.7579196095,
0.1079325154,
0.689565897,
0.9150283337,
-0.3363489807,
-0.0161348991,
-0.1108620316,
0.0032938963,
-0.4413369298,
-0.1664584577,
0.2335415632,
0.1096387655,
-0.8522231579,
0.5079529285,
0.2496020347,
0.1229770631,
-0.3840649724,
-0.2262174785,
0.5863124728,
0.2225282937,
0.5620961785,
-0.1205786243,
-0.6367607713,
-0.386069417,
0.0591195114,
-0.0795047134,
-0.2552243471,
1.0342084169,
-0.5784361362,
0.0530486517,
0.523375988,
0.566729188,
0.3014138937,
0.0916313007,
0.5971693993,
-0.6068981886,
-0.0355314575,
0.3263054788,
0.3894743919,
0.1966135353,
-0.6461194754,
0.5986979604,
0.0010572909,
-0.7866021395,
-1.1787828207,
0.2674307823,
-1.1392301321,
-0.1759424359,
1.345512867,
-0.4058793783,
-0.2917080522,
0.0800480694,
0.0216060467,
0.3355224431,
-0.4651630223,
0.7821577787,
0.7876686454,
-0.1753090769,
-0.3607952595,
-0.4179287553,
0.6967095733,
0.4441671669,
-0.6094717383,
0.0537004545,
0.4144609869,
0.2415875196,
0.1363531202,
0.6785427928,
-0.2046758384,
0.2696228027,
0.2574950457,
-0.2791621983,
-0.3790863156,
-0.3965089619,
-0.7404870987,
0.4115481973,
0.3965480626,
-0.0729976669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11399v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11399v3
|
X-LLaVA: Optimizing Bilingual Large Vision-Language Alignment
| 2024-03-18T01:14:47 | 2024-04-01T06:57:20 |
Dongjae Shin, Hyeonseok Lim, Inho Won, Changsu Choi, Minjun Kim, Seungwoo Song, Hangyeol Yoo, Sangmin Kim, Kyungtae Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The impressive development of large language models (LLMs) is expanding into
the realm of large multimodal models (LMMs), which incorporate multiple types
of data beyond text. However, the nature of multimodal models leads to
significant expenses in the creation of training data. Furthermore,
constructing multilingual data for LMMs presents its own set of challenges due
to language diversity and complexity. Therefore, in this study, we propose two
cost-effective methods to solve this problem: (1) vocabulary expansion and
pretraining of multilingual LLM for specific languages, and (2) automatic and
elaborate construction of multimodal datasets using GPT4-V. Based on015 these
methods, we constructed a 91K English-Korean-Chinese multilingual, multimodal
training dataset. Additionally, we developed a bilingual multimodal model that
exhibits excellent performance in both Korean and English, surpassing existing
approaches.
|
[
-0.243625626,
-0.2225544006,
0.411360383,
0.2681476176,
-0.203884691,
0.3076930344,
-0.2952438891,
-0.4456655681,
0.3360353708,
0.4137871265,
-0.5128455758,
-0.436766237,
-0.3652688861,
0.0893335119,
0.036745023,
0.7909440994,
-0.3221752644,
0.3622928262,
0.0349462926,
-0.2870410383,
-0.4219871461,
-0.3151081502,
-0.2969945967,
-0.1257670969,
0.7859905362,
0.4064470232,
0.6781893373,
0.8474456668,
0.5166328549,
0.4245329499,
0.3698938489,
0.6034021974,
-0.3085906208,
0.0134025076,
-0.1992065609,
-0.6337580085,
-0.7681030631,
-0.2634104788,
0.8735185266,
0.4813599885,
-0.042885717,
0.0440932177,
-0.1838884503,
0.5333228111,
-0.4761243761,
0.2953376174,
-0.5481452942,
0.048493363,
-0.6544681787,
-0.1563300937,
-0.0446808599,
-0.2133242637,
0.0688087717,
-0.8553631306,
-0.3423010707,
-0.0882343128,
1.0017508268,
0.1000214368,
-0.6991871595,
-0.1130347475,
-0.3537216783,
1.1029914618,
-0.3940187991,
0.7940108776,
0.1672234088,
0.2821953297,
0.2364130765,
-0.3493703902,
-0.523809731,
0.0208072569,
0.1768521816,
0.3681381941,
0.2190587968,
-0.0397646204,
0.0110013094,
0.2271695137,
-0.7820051908,
0.2995910347,
-0.1874013543,
-0.1816144139,
0.7110693455,
0.3540290296,
0.4390980601,
-0.1540096402,
-0.4869846106,
-0.1366667747,
-0.6531361938,
-0.1574449837,
0.5908440948,
0.4101254344,
-0.1821439415,
0.8145446181,
-0.1901580542,
0.6314560175,
-0.1456656903,
-0.8940925598,
0.6799465418,
-1.0167107582,
-0.1047741771,
-0.1054159477,
0.5212119222,
0.5261522532,
0.4936143756,
-0.0818937272,
-0.2536582351,
0.0964754298,
0.0873267055,
-0.3306663632,
0.052281931,
0.1030905172,
-0.0181954708,
-0.1202399358,
-0.3673127592,
-0.695081234,
-0.0684557036,
-0.7447580695,
0.4140652716,
-0.366872251,
-0.3837564588,
0.0043930407,
0.2675009072,
0.3462071717,
0.3591610789,
-0.9377065301,
-0.2668938935,
0.3600359857,
0.6524661183,
-0.1951399744,
-0.4515213072,
-0.3255364895,
0.4013435841,
-0.373696208,
0.4873225987,
-0.2620219588,
-0.1034259722,
0.0354627483,
0.0945846736,
-0.1013177037,
-0.3016527295,
0.3297166526,
-0.567106843,
0.2192177624,
-0.2660586834,
-0.3638487756,
-0.0479363315,
0.5402699113,
-0.7254949808,
0.8435848355,
0.2017344981,
-0.7596452832,
0.4089668989,
-0.4501255751,
-0.3603934348,
0.3000042439,
-0.4688595235,
-0.2420489788,
-0.1641512811,
0.5292892456,
0.2386327386,
-0.3939341605,
0.2835307121,
0.0816236883,
0.1853580326,
-0.0965171978,
-0.2493014485,
0.8167361617,
0.1195455864,
-0.3808590174,
0.0181056503,
-0.7093525529,
0.1310121119,
0.0582970828,
-0.5246965885,
-0.3840563893,
-0.2582957149,
0.0580910146,
0.3518801928,
0.5534726381,
-0.4314429462,
0.2515601814,
-0.4386253655,
-0.1746966392,
0.8422538638,
-0.6658114195,
0.5891565681,
-0.1062020659,
0.8820822835,
0.1387176812,
0.2347770929,
-0.4079428613,
-0.6173247695,
-0.6922492981,
-0.5049003959,
0.2335628718,
0.9374074936,
-1.2873803377,
0.1169314012,
-0.6456250548,
-0.3566310108,
-0.6295374632,
0.6193522811,
0.6632881761,
0.4977847338,
0.2226660401,
-0.24445346,
-0.661121726,
-1.0313566923,
-0.0446725972,
0.0339656174,
0.2824236453,
0.0999114662,
0.2891497016,
-0.4906331599,
0.9055879712,
-0.3636184633,
-0.3546631634,
-0.2659436166,
-0.1820740551,
0.0748174936,
0.3611271381,
0.6152982116,
-0.9650914073,
-0.7867561579,
0.6464760303,
-0.7634243965,
-0.154385671,
0.0822577924,
-0.1377994269,
0.4029587805,
0.2486340851,
-0.5451207757,
0.1353159696,
0.965970099,
0.0747785345,
0.620302856,
-0.316095531,
0.1530970484,
-1.1761884689,
-0.2225026935,
-0.0247145891,
-0.2870824039,
-0.7188811898,
0.2248838097,
0.3358544111,
0.1520799994,
-0.5808795094,
0.6615461707,
-0.7795894742,
0.0831431448,
-0.1985261142,
0.311270088,
-0.0637330785,
0.4951802194,
0.0977124199,
0.5907578468,
0.6638085842,
-0.1233069524,
0.6455032229,
0.2690775394,
-0.5497952104,
0.555265069,
-0.2944079638,
-0.1658725291,
-0.2612438202,
0.0820948333,
-0.8868378997,
-0.3605769277,
0.2993883789,
-0.1000485197,
0.5321635008,
-0.0833853409,
-0.4750258625,
-0.1429804862,
-0.3104834259,
0.9491596222,
0.2259885222,
-0.709893167,
0.8161154389,
0.4931019545,
-0.4044572711,
-0.8837084174,
-0.7142475843,
0.3449014127,
-0.2507325411,
-0.8722657561,
0.3024071157,
-0.0413343012,
-0.2547509968,
-0.215371564,
0.2112778276,
0.0635472611,
-0.466248095,
-0.1214342266,
0.3773326278,
-0.3974486589,
0.01126609,
-0.0104982657,
-0.1925774962,
-0.3042631149,
-0.3186005354,
0.5068939328,
0.0048886966,
-0.3473234177,
-0.2478441298,
0.4132484496,
0.463831991,
-0.5639740825,
0.4114397168,
0.5640630126,
-0.0815159902,
0.0927310586,
-0.6838781834,
0.4924798012,
-0.4796358943,
0.7753399014,
-0.5128532648,
-0.753472209,
0.3482297957,
0.1546630114,
0.0690846667,
0.0170974303,
0.8491604924,
0.0229397323,
1.1716567278,
0.6157268882,
-0.1333333105,
0.4814911187,
0.0203607548,
0.1422422528,
-0.5148516297,
-0.2502178252,
0.0161166862,
-0.1906721145,
-0.7088699937,
-0.9072775245,
0.3257613182,
-0.413099736,
0.0245824847,
0.3339191675,
-0.0262505691,
0.5503724813,
0.5379592776,
-0.0481402874,
0.280436784,
0.248660624,
-0.2598372698,
-0.3605693579,
-0.7391734123,
-0.2449839413,
1.41038692,
0.2986418307,
0.7940738201,
0.3659817576,
0.6315255165,
-0.5347492099,
0.0823036283,
-0.5493343472,
0.448063612,
-0.2860568166,
-0.519902885,
-0.3321303129,
-0.4054024518,
-0.9216688871,
0.5747083426,
-0.1712110937,
-0.5184472799,
0.1155536324,
0.1955957413,
-0.0688760951,
0.2588220537,
-0.7455512881,
0.7353395224,
-0.9340704083,
-0.3598011434,
-0.0561213009,
-0.6778255701,
0.6141671538,
-0.7273030281,
0.3719110191,
0.0366828889,
-0.4412492216,
0.5052244067,
-0.3009699285,
0.7110683918,
-0.0493367538,
-0.5927078128,
-0.0179819111,
-0.4438702762,
0.548345387,
-0.0169290695,
0.3830808103,
0.1860402673,
-0.222141102,
-0.5083140135,
-0.3698070347,
0.6327781677,
-0.8216021061,
-0.5414546132,
-0.2638376653,
-1.098724246,
-0.3426238298,
0.2699497044,
0.1913418621,
0.379365474,
0.0705342218,
-0.1594716161,
0.578913033,
-0.465267241,
0.2520252466,
0.358189404,
-0.6166905761,
-0.834179163,
1.128380537,
0.3997083008,
0.5048655272,
0.5311775208,
0.0289925486,
-0.3589976132,
-0.4687787294,
-0.4593240917,
0.5100859404,
-0.7323341966,
-0.1344796419,
-0.5352133512,
0.0386057496,
-0.6666538715,
-0.0582397059,
-0.46228984,
-0.3389260471,
0.0961716771,
0.0258684196,
0.029046854,
0.2535226345,
-0.1569078863,
0.4431966245,
-0.8634061813,
0.3977564871,
0.3313471675,
0.1160120964,
-0.2401918769,
-0.3326687217,
-0.5374456048,
0.1649937481,
-0.1957681775,
-0.5623770356,
0.6414197683,
0.2100998014,
0.560115099,
0.5140138865,
-0.4243330657,
0.8852093816,
-0.6870219111,
0.5805107951,
0.4848004282,
-0.6702128053,
0.2354770154,
-0.4603691697,
0.5814127326,
0.3071890771,
0.5202006698,
-0.2166755646,
-0.2099286616,
-0.1415611506,
-0.9511443973,
0.5421795249,
0.1713309586,
0.053136263,
0.1696147025,
0.1599036157,
0.1199115068,
0.0630328655,
-0.8407472968,
-0.0742784739,
-0.1795017868,
-0.4508605897,
-0.4939851761,
-0.1341144741,
-0.2381687611,
-0.4526357651,
0.5063789487,
-0.311139673,
-0.2335604131,
-0.2156472057,
-0.4028089643,
0.1251081824,
-0.1073087305,
0.8616482615,
0.6978529096,
0.0789923519,
-0.0255126785,
0.1719282269,
-0.428021431,
0.4085694849,
-0.1076327041,
0.0911444277,
0.0326160267,
0.3790646195,
0.8326043487,
0.1444534361,
-0.9707272053,
0.5569668412,
0.1288649291,
-0.2977885902,
-0.3152706027,
-0.2887999415,
0.3055354953,
0.5222104788,
-0.0340290442,
-0.4477210045,
-0.3599979877,
-0.3533941507,
-0.0114208907,
0.5529301763,
0.153476879,
-0.3273273706,
0.605068326,
0.1876166612,
0.1527788341,
0.6473226547,
0.1877292693,
-0.6245016456,
0.3392422199,
0.5075560808,
0.5525308847,
-0.5199489594,
0.0960330293,
0.2374235094,
0.395057559,
-0.11407049,
0.4261155427,
0.0498347133,
-0.9967589974,
-0.8062011003,
-0.5317714214,
-0.1815463901,
-0.2112554461,
-0.3923460245,
0.5484030247,
0.0229210276,
-0.1959600151,
-0.1539676189,
-0.0182824377,
-0.654589355,
0.4044843614,
0.3924435079,
0.686654985,
-0.8600876927,
1.2360019684,
0.6911298633,
-0.3161418736,
-0.7131271958,
-0.4841080904,
0.1237357631,
-1.2429596186,
1.1125948429,
-0.0102147646,
-0.1536002606,
-0.1473397017,
-0.1331407875,
-1.2173404694,
1.0974644423,
0.5502799153,
-0.9385428429,
-0.2737670839,
0.5963718295,
0.3356995881,
-0.3610287309,
0.0172339994,
0.418427825,
0.7087315917,
-0.0343061872,
-1.1529769897,
-0.3645107746,
-0.2862379551,
0.0518226475,
0.422813803,
-0.5824803114,
0.8390841484,
-0.0983086526,
0.0050101401,
0.1145717502,
0.5158621073,
0.1669242233,
0.0348343626,
0.5839916468,
0.7392377853,
0.6554298997,
0.0698728338,
0.8358161449,
-0.2974523604,
0.1268510371,
1.0774257183,
-0.4284427166,
0.5382540822,
0.7157142162,
-0.0063493685,
0.0597848557,
0.6123976111,
-0.1426617354,
0.5468558073,
-0.0245004576,
-0.2485999465,
-0.2515733242,
0.0924004391,
-0.392768085,
0.6030698419,
0.2894243002,
-0.2288620472,
-0.2585856616,
0.2453477085,
0.0424760692,
-0.2502447367,
-0.3283649683,
0.5465347171,
-0.0448205657,
-0.6026880741,
0.5022987127,
-0.1040199026,
0.8170650601,
-0.8642638922,
0.4279249907,
-0.3841139376,
0.2682266533,
-0.1890896708,
-0.5797796845,
0.0762724504,
-0.0700400695,
-0.0645398796,
-0.2558986545,
0.2406143844,
-0.9566932917,
-0.5964072347,
0.4074715078,
0.5359525681,
0.0900343955,
0.2513424754,
-0.6682606936,
0.1134031415,
0.2876309156,
-0.1266458035,
0.560567379,
0.329111129,
-0.4053142369,
0.5983534455,
0.4997527897,
0.3665415347,
0.4274039865,
0.0707486197,
0.7168131471,
-0.490544945,
-0.4505445957,
-0.8087188005,
0.6521206498,
0.0614588335,
-0.2693135142,
0.854622364,
0.6123697758,
1.0230907202,
-0.096728459,
0.8053844571,
0.3258699775,
0.2302153409,
-0.6758317947,
0.26996696,
-1.0452904701,
0.0706419274,
-0.4376764596,
-1.1243780851,
-0.6061026454,
0.3288563192,
-0.1375226229,
-0.0235712659,
0.4520681202,
1.0229285955,
-0.1410363615,
-0.3763709664,
0.4624668062,
-0.0189066473,
0.4199495316,
0.6521528959,
0.8211901188,
-0.2647477984,
0.6018452048,
-0.2809102535,
-0.4355606735,
-0.070318073,
-0.8549454212,
-0.6290727258,
-0.4981175363,
-0.3963063359,
0.0113258855,
-0.1740859598,
0.8479509354,
0.6012399197,
-0.4961981475,
-0.5248779655,
0.4097822905,
-0.2345653027,
-0.0056278054,
-0.0658512488,
0.3343463838,
-0.4804133475,
-1.0727089643,
0.44962731,
0.5039349794,
0.1809072495,
-0.2789052427,
-0.295263648,
-0.4040018916,
0.0385305136,
0.7908614278,
0.3090568781,
-0.8316602111,
-0.0332916677,
0.0397305563,
-0.1156080067,
0.2546240389,
0.4918341339,
-0.3194179535,
0.7930474281,
0.4399692118,
0.8291541934,
0.3964264095,
0.0161751173,
0.8487776518,
-0.6524358988,
0.3572077453,
-0.090800494,
0.5451843143,
0.4543585479,
-0.0647630543,
0.431918174,
0.1098733917,
-0.5188726187,
-0.8025969863,
0.2419208586,
-1.1430516243,
-0.0204712376,
1.0097346306,
-0.050505355,
-0.2729740739,
-0.0439159349,
-0.389308691,
0.1078828946,
0.2211833,
0.401963532,
0.6269985437,
-0.1457418054,
-0.239618808,
-0.5194665194,
0.1665980518,
0.4662677944,
-0.7114620209,
-0.1309499443,
0.4405259192,
0.21737957,
0.2868160009,
0.4524771273,
-0.2345323861,
0.153896749,
-0.1384168267,
0.2731547058,
0.2050453424,
-0.3349682391,
-0.3112248778,
0.0211816709,
-0.0781188458,
-0.2719846368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11381v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11381v2
|
Can LLM-Augmented autonomous agents cooperate?, An evaluation of their cooperative capabilities through Melting Pot
| 2024-03-18T00:13:43 | 2024-06-19T16:23:05 |
Manuel Mosquera, Juan Sebastian Pinzon, Manuel Rios, Yesid Fonseca, Luis Felipe Giraldo, Nicanor Quijano, Ruben Manrique
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As the field of AI continues to evolve, a significant dimension of this
progression is the development of Large Language Models and their potential to
enhance multi-agent artificial intelligence systems. This paper explores the
cooperative capabilities of Large Language Model-augmented Autonomous Agents
(LAAs) using the well-known Meltin Pot environments along with reference models
such as GPT4 and GPT3.5. Preliminary results suggest that while these agents
demonstrate a propensity for cooperation, they still struggle with effective
collaboration in given environments, emphasizing the need for more robust
architectures. The study's contributions include an abstraction layer to adapt
Melting Pot game scenarios for LLMs, the implementation of a reusable
architecture for LLM-mediated agent development - which includes short and
long-term memories and different cognitive modules, and the evaluation of
cooperation capabilities using a set of metrics tied to the Melting Pot's
"Commons Harvest" game. The paper closes, by discussing the limitations of the
current architectural framework and the potential of a new set of modules that
fosters better cooperation among LAAs.
|
[
-0.5911269188,
-0.7126135826,
0.8114983439,
0.1116404608,
0.164382875,
0.5038352609,
-0.1803978235,
-0.8585065007,
0.4126459956,
0.5004868507,
-0.3233247399,
-0.1136034355,
-0.4373688102,
0.2579779625,
-0.0742942691,
0.5193321705,
-0.0275986027,
-0.1317014247,
-0.5300992727,
-0.1840069592,
-0.5622595549,
-0.50704211,
-0.49934268,
-0.7177816629,
0.5764941573,
0.423198849,
0.9179267883,
0.4520180225,
0.4566072524,
0.5826895237,
0.1570006758,
0.2407723218,
-0.3327903152,
0.1865803748,
-0.0767901242,
-0.4855596423,
-0.8107974529,
0.2846097648,
0.4944495857,
0.2939155996,
0.1545283496,
-0.0836573839,
-0.0044313413,
0.3743212819,
-0.5970417857,
0.3993216753,
-0.5658388138,
-0.0646568984,
0.0401858762,
-0.2008299381,
-0.5751804113,
0.0342821255,
0.053048566,
-0.5606355071,
-0.3752507865,
-0.0568430908,
0.3739573061,
0.3315899074,
-0.348944366,
-0.5051352382,
-0.9211141467,
0.8641809225,
-0.6670065522,
-0.1354578435,
0.5381581783,
0.3630982637,
-0.4017637372,
-0.5987958312,
-0.590824306,
-0.4674343467,
-0.0553811379,
0.3235547245,
-0.1381781548,
-0.1165081933,
-0.3923484087,
0.4614816308,
-0.2560713589,
0.4216658175,
-0.2095991671,
0.0261592604,
0.8178365827,
0.4059379995,
0.514918983,
0.148803398,
-0.382004559,
0.1422027946,
-0.4205997586,
0.0368888266,
0.257709682,
0.3828259706,
-0.335640192,
0.7091431618,
0.1572331041,
0.5058649778,
0.058231201,
-0.0707436949,
0.1831555814,
-0.2063984424,
-0.1689747423,
-0.1790913194,
0.7102358341,
0.2735106647,
-0.0766751543,
-0.459258765,
-0.4072223902,
0.2894988954,
0.1958849132,
-0.2391198426,
-0.3452289999,
0.471884191,
-0.1755477935,
-0.1797922701,
0.0040361965,
-0.5527354479,
-0.5097103715,
-0.2740933001,
0.4554503262,
-0.0855394974,
-0.4779175818,
-0.2026601285,
-0.0261234287,
0.6536303759,
0.179013148,
-0.8959358335,
0.5411455631,
1.04152143,
0.9242060184,
-0.4191544056,
-0.9241309762,
-0.479741931,
0.2398986667,
-0.2394780368,
1.0833312273,
-0.5304604769,
-0.3732593954,
-0.0427322611,
-0.0390958004,
-0.0207475293,
-0.6597365141,
-0.1428184956,
-0.7390642762,
-0.0716433302,
-0.3156297803,
-0.432393223,
0.026395306,
0.5618780851,
-1.0176407099,
0.4229251444,
0.2347958088,
-0.3395622671,
0.0804416984,
-0.7767945528,
-0.34369874,
0.3903490901,
-0.310102731,
-0.2000778764,
-0.2057390362,
-0.0871086419,
0.3136391938,
-0.3563917875,
-0.1498194784,
-0.3424991071,
-0.5042561889,
0.4081281424,
-0.2323049903,
0.8895118833,
0.0009289864,
-0.3247460127,
0.5150721073,
-0.1949903369,
-0.2096655071,
0.1819802076,
-0.3815833032,
-0.0575128756,
-0.0442440286,
-0.3052630126,
-0.088449344,
0.482458055,
-0.0662040338,
0.2767488956,
-0.1201993152,
0.2334407717,
1.0362049341,
0.0011976887,
0.9146132469,
-0.7457890511,
0.4866976142,
-0.1801910996,
0.1544139683,
0.0668286905,
-0.4435851872,
-0.7285913229,
-0.6414787769,
0.033842098,
0.8260804415,
-1.1006423235,
0.745405674,
-0.0539208092,
-0.446441263,
-0.3540865779,
0.179539144,
0.0728012323,
-0.1462715268,
0.0423479863,
-0.4842552841,
-0.3203012943,
-0.5991414189,
0.3762274086,
0.0088391965,
0.1144818589,
0.3769049644,
0.5761696696,
-0.3717541993,
0.9075580239,
0.0643147379,
-0.2955106199,
-0.3058955073,
0.016395878,
0.0072550685,
0.2919407785,
0.5257527232,
-0.7069901824,
-0.7715860009,
0.453260988,
-1.0261946917,
0.2267258763,
0.0706581473,
-0.097651422,
0.2129389197,
0.2283611447,
-0.7659026384,
0.225926891,
0.707259655,
-0.4980103076,
0.6427776217,
-0.2335976958,
0.1420784742,
-0.9086490273,
-0.2576405704,
-0.4302588999,
-0.1272898465,
-0.7218998075,
0.3074944615,
-0.6729829311,
0.4059936702,
-0.5760384798,
0.6536287069,
-0.6917257905,
-0.4545461833,
-0.7348399162,
0.4976423681,
-0.3016618788,
0.3412553072,
-0.0524827875,
0.8037504554,
0.8740741611,
-0.5973550677,
1.0769238472,
0.0607405379,
-0.1640195996,
0.661632061,
-0.3809261322,
0.3126828671,
0.3658638895,
0.4313491583,
-0.2783851922,
-0.3159065843,
0.4243771434,
-0.2352789193,
-0.0665149763,
0.3606541753,
-0.6560832858,
0.0312958285,
-0.3985715508,
0.6854439378,
0.3760166466,
-0.412953645,
1.1767754555,
0.560732305,
0.0123004504,
-0.5604462028,
-0.5140683055,
0.2271214128,
-0.3303186297,
-0.701883316,
-0.0111368252,
-0.3859282434,
-0.9001033902,
0.2241770476,
0.48871544,
0.0074504185,
0.0243216716,
0.333017081,
0.2305285782,
-0.1071120203,
-0.2601841986,
-0.3963669837,
-0.1197960749,
-0.0940957367,
0.2480579913,
0.7369787097,
-0.6827478409,
-0.2516432703,
-0.2494208813,
0.3578692675,
0.7972946763,
-0.2459544539,
0.9677679539,
0.4376648962,
-0.2759057283,
0.0055054957,
-0.4671807885,
-0.1219302565,
-0.5229228735,
0.0583010316,
-0.3655967116,
-0.9063631892,
1.0483906269,
-0.0424587056,
0.2791640759,
0.310600251,
0.9503234625,
0.1276597828,
0.2639596164,
0.49094221,
-0.2859503627,
0.2048270851,
-0.2762959599,
-0.0404568613,
-0.8344134092,
-0.2884889841,
-0.1752062142,
-0.3604709804,
-0.6886386871,
-0.6990368962,
0.2481905818,
-0.4975819588,
-0.2652855814,
0.1604545712,
-0.2144150883,
0.8426888585,
0.5061014891,
0.1270931363,
0.4830604196,
-0.2897682786,
0.4360044599,
0.3876754045,
-0.6805735826,
-0.5140699148,
0.6376440525,
0.3404248357,
0.2908019722,
0.35608989,
0.7447361946,
0.6315908432,
0.6286094189,
-0.8565714955,
0.7509590387,
0.016791217,
-0.4871627688,
-0.5618118644,
-0.3603308499,
-1.1166268587,
0.2826407254,
-0.3917157054,
-0.6568502784,
0.0409191586,
-0.3082399666,
-0.3470651507,
0.5731671453,
-0.6482496262,
0.4958873987,
-0.3834756315,
-0.4854188561,
-0.2465571612,
-0.3831678927,
0.524107933,
-0.0341303311,
0.409940511,
-0.0845144317,
-0.213311255,
0.1997978985,
-0.0237170868,
0.8750719428,
0.0014694179,
-0.3985401392,
0.7143564224,
0.3099256754,
0.3732729256,
-0.1585554928,
-0.2800006568,
0.0205667987,
-0.2798669934,
-0.6500566006,
-0.5669598579,
1.023008585,
-1.1244773865,
-0.7098057866,
-0.5662496686,
-0.989361465,
-0.1107297838,
0.0607100688,
-0.0571968332,
-0.0206234567,
-0.2878973186,
0.1850781441,
0.2306597084,
-0.1317126155,
0.5686090589,
0.1726717353,
-0.1177800521,
-0.4075379074,
0.9158747196,
-0.0816053376,
0.3713649213,
0.0913883969,
0.0693057925,
0.1885937005,
-0.3954232335,
-0.0907749236,
0.0079138298,
-0.6663133502,
-0.2913868725,
-0.0971277431,
-0.353651017,
-0.2123785168,
-0.6870678663,
-0.3415615857,
0.1159951016,
-0.222944364,
0.0064495327,
0.2087213099,
1.1369034052,
-0.4035086334,
0.3851204813,
-0.5679453015,
0.1769116819,
0.5511056185,
0.2962504923,
0.2648000717,
-0.1401222795,
-0.358022958,
-0.0751026496,
0.0054768156,
-0.8516767025,
0.0957984477,
-0.2769066095,
0.5933300257,
0.1416471452,
0.1876197159,
0.2868821621,
-0.2074863464,
0.9885818958,
-0.0004345838,
-0.8034602404,
-0.1102207974,
-0.4156950116,
0.3669908643,
0.2784207761,
-0.0627475753,
0.0755989701,
-0.5174136758,
-0.4293870926,
-0.8885988593,
0.5216895342,
0.3076156676,
0.2083401829,
0.1152704433,
0.2471272051,
0.1448224038,
-0.1122385487,
-1.3093287945,
-0.2683876753,
0.157439813,
0.2211159766,
-0.1583838463,
-0.0359210968,
-0.3952714503,
-0.0146388272,
0.7381988764,
0.2200510353,
0.1703460962,
-0.1717077345,
0.1989747435,
-0.2335226387,
0.2538481355,
0.5387554765,
0.5742903352,
0.0065506324,
0.2760185003,
0.3992073834,
-0.1264155954,
0.2780497372,
-0.1030957848,
-0.0272928793,
-0.5554069281,
0.621306479,
0.4425809383,
-0.2017115206,
-0.5485883355,
0.2295073271,
-0.1140176803,
-0.2413683534,
-0.4988999963,
0.1168823168,
0.1829456389,
0.8913556933,
0.2735204697,
-0.1207048446,
-0.1039168015,
-1.0576699972,
0.1948860586,
0.8149719238,
0.01287976,
-0.1917993128,
-0.1301592588,
0.3638188243,
-0.709418416,
0.5464223027,
-0.5267931819,
-0.5272766948,
0.5778408051,
0.4716991186,
0.983927846,
-0.4074500501,
0.163406536,
-0.1698213071,
0.5186868906,
0.1327230036,
-0.1603330821,
-0.0319594778,
-0.8252936602,
-0.5171194673,
-0.2314148396,
-0.5664485097,
0.1030667126,
-0.1686480194,
0.0034108385,
-0.3513987064,
-0.1299839765,
-0.520460248,
0.2456388324,
-0.4426937103,
-0.2851628959,
0.0349050201,
0.3862992227,
-0.6597573161,
0.5901755095,
0.5858490467,
-0.1520544291,
-0.5934534669,
-0.145873785,
-0.1377411783,
-0.5293112993,
0.0854556784,
-0.1602741331,
-0.5342912078,
-0.3013712168,
-0.6289786696,
-0.4852556288,
1.5309108496,
0.277921468,
-0.1568700522,
0.0818191916,
0.238936156,
0.6313561201,
-0.796246767,
0.0112640653,
0.744351089,
0.6791783571,
0.348996371,
-1.1336530447,
-0.107172817,
-0.2150316983,
-0.5837734342,
-0.2230535746,
-0.8968227506,
0.9863889217,
-0.1093355045,
0.0328627676,
0.4213691056,
0.972099185,
0.5593533516,
0.6565645337,
0.6397458315,
0.3069780469,
0.4120643437,
0.0508685671,
0.888476789,
-0.1783376783,
0.1067190245,
1.1875388622,
-0.5620138049,
0.9035036564,
0.4092785418,
0.0085661625,
0.685608387,
0.3399151564,
-0.1188595816,
0.3456975818,
0.1835366935,
-0.8554847836,
-0.2201281637,
-0.2758862376,
-0.2197717428,
0.7049824595,
0.2990629375,
0.007441049,
0.0981035009,
-0.0308932085,
-0.2300963253,
0.2312868536,
-0.4651869237,
0.8675913215,
0.1316391826,
-0.6272103786,
0.0367586315,
-0.2133244425,
0.7075446248,
-0.2995420396,
-0.0113718556,
-0.1226666868,
0.175538063,
-0.2440611124,
-0.7133928537,
0.2164493054,
-0.1503374726,
0.0798287243,
0.224650681,
0.5578707457,
-0.2453737259,
-0.2207327783,
0.5360584855,
0.872569263,
0.1517879218,
0.2314409614,
-0.5379558802,
0.4063645303,
-0.3968002796,
-0.0704063401,
0.4198920727,
0.4422463179,
0.2489793003,
0.6920137405,
0.4393773377,
0.1450255215,
-0.1470780671,
-0.3400531113,
0.8790077567,
-0.3669649661,
-0.2350658178,
-0.9238366485,
0.4019824862,
0.217684418,
0.479831934,
0.7417050004,
0.4009269178,
0.573325634,
-0.110093534,
0.6884638071,
-0.1984728426,
-0.1061930731,
-0.3160033524,
0.6205343604,
-0.3204177022,
0.438898474,
-0.0691019595,
-1.0415383577,
-0.3045324683,
0.4700563252,
-0.2546222806,
0.2795555592,
0.3620069027,
0.5287789106,
-0.0353521444,
-0.3238960505,
0.5639939308,
0.2288357764,
0.4767205715,
0.6129264832,
0.9834065437,
-0.035952501,
0.2723223269,
-0.2552992702,
-0.5427385569,
0.1006116718,
-0.7925286293,
-1.0128136873,
-0.6400794387,
-0.0584259443,
-0.2674390972,
-0.075978823,
1.0368260145,
0.4095938504,
-0.4725198746,
-0.7427015305,
0.1425788701,
0.3796349168,
-0.1894133091,
-0.2535960376,
0.2554159462,
0.0426380821,
-0.9081462026,
0.5680174828,
0.4505421519,
0.1980577558,
-0.8682339191,
-0.6217991114,
-0.2933519781,
0.3513871729,
0.7783908248,
0.5143350363,
-0.7275551558,
-0.1979033649,
-0.0068520536,
0.0225311909,
-0.0507357754,
0.7289091945,
-0.6949259639,
0.3904900551,
0.0600246564,
0.5218197107,
-0.0096836435,
0.0003046034,
0.5922219157,
-0.2951868176,
0.2592306137,
0.3572496772,
0.2017946988,
0.3542138338,
-0.3258367479,
0.3222754002,
-0.099285014,
-1.0333834887,
-0.6591044068,
0.3426088095,
-1.0536845922,
-0.0763514414,
1.1124331951,
-0.2825084329,
-0.3113673627,
-0.3193275332,
-0.1495735496,
0.3010736108,
-0.2918393612,
1.1248486042,
0.8388871551,
-0.5308662653,
-0.3993395567,
-0.2280446887,
0.3315235972,
0.0805797726,
-1.2287473679,
0.0679384321,
0.6253911853,
-0.2568561137,
0.6136371493,
0.7582427859,
0.218637228,
0.3114080727,
0.2353818566,
-0.172477439,
-0.0753311142,
-0.476727128,
-0.1175964549,
0.0046043526,
0.4961560667,
0.0906686857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15445v1
|
Decoding Multilingual Topic Dynamics and Trend Identification through ARIMA Time Series Analysis on Social Networks: A Novel Data Translation Framework Enhanced by LDA/HDP Models
| 2024-03-18T00:01:10 | 2024-03-18T00:01:10 |
Samawel Jaballi, Azer Mahjoubi, Manar Joundy Hazar, Salah Zrigui, Henri Nicolas, Mounir Zrigui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
In this study, the authors present a novel methodology adept at decoding
multilingual topic dynamics and identifying communication trends during crises.
We focus on dialogues within Tunisian social networks during the Coronavirus
Pandemic and other notable themes like sports and politics. We start by
aggregating a varied multilingual corpus of comments relevant to these
subjects. This dataset undergoes rigorous refinement during data preprocessing.
We then introduce our No-English-to-English Machine Translation approach to
handle linguistic differences. Empirical tests of this method showed high
accuracy and F1 scores, highlighting its suitability for linguistically
coherent tasks. Delving deeper, advanced modeling techniques, specifically LDA
and HDP models are employed to extract pertinent topics from the translated
content. This leads to applying ARIMA time series analysis to decode evolving
topic trends. Applying our method to a multilingual Tunisian dataset, we
effectively identified key topics mirroring public sentiment. Such insights
prove vital for organizations and governments striving to understand public
perspectives during crises. Compared to standard approaches, our model
outperforms, as confirmed by metrics like Coherence Score, U-mass, and Topic
Coherence. Additionally, an in-depth assessment of the identified topics
revealed notable thematic shifts in discussions, with our trends identification
indicating impressive accuracy, backed by RMSE-based analysis.
|
[
-0.5147570372,
-0.9277877808,
0.2305134535,
0.4704384208,
-0.4615194499,
0.3153730631,
-0.1504406631,
-0.2508581579,
0.4984381199,
0.3492527902,
-0.6346870661,
-0.6410743594,
-0.8553852439,
-0.0412050672,
-0.7201581597,
1.288238287,
0.0613041222,
-0.028949691,
0.2557689846,
-0.1196351349,
0.0452935249,
-0.5048117638,
-0.706469059,
-0.1244865209,
0.522724092,
0.3279916942,
0.7064647675,
0.3739635944,
0.3831360936,
0.2831223309,
-0.2176829129,
0.3056159317,
-0.5671215653,
0.1972495317,
-0.2481716871,
0.1959787607,
-0.2820805609,
-0.185880959,
0.5015633702,
0.4225983918,
-0.3005776703,
0.3233112395,
0.2262231559,
0.7352018356,
-0.3297941089,
0.4002377093,
-0.5706455708,
-0.0944412053,
-0.2770571113,
-0.4004515707,
-0.0856475309,
-0.2148139477,
0.1230427995,
0.043170087,
0.2180500776,
-0.4006895125,
0.7906479836,
-0.1375107616,
-0.6448091269,
-0.1666255146,
-0.970184207,
0.6743735671,
-0.5492601991,
-0.0225195121,
0.1269551814,
0.3504623473,
-0.2323534042,
-0.5791725516,
-0.446516335,
0.4359996319,
0.5241777301,
-0.0777802691,
-0.1341206878,
-0.4074933827,
-0.1940035075,
0.2997530699,
-0.4959360063,
-0.2792740464,
-0.2065588385,
0.0836448446,
0.8136864305,
0.1788684428,
0.4410462677,
-0.4661858976,
-0.1827494502,
-0.0479995087,
-0.5736284852,
0.0532970503,
0.4194399714,
0.4965608418,
-0.3979770541,
0.3363390267,
-0.1759472638,
0.1970053166,
-0.4213473797,
-0.098864004,
0.1309738755,
-0.4684464335,
0.0271858852,
0.0600878373,
0.8242576122,
0.3326966166,
0.1578585058,
0.1864383817,
0.049488239,
-0.3724104464,
0.0543863587,
-1.0369366407,
-0.2132403553,
0.2701917887,
-0.6894210577,
-0.2966463268,
0.0578543842,
-1.1870473623,
-0.6825336814,
-0.129956156,
-0.1318711191,
-0.1014301255,
-0.4056816995,
0.2250098288,
0.2164128721,
0.1856522709,
0.600851059,
-0.5068637133,
0.0467755422,
0.6544339657,
1.2025500536,
0.0748949945,
0.08902096,
-0.1786900014,
-0.0549828261,
-0.2565938532,
0.6516371369,
-0.3984493911,
-0.3134539425,
0.248513028,
0.0756871849,
-0.0396191962,
0.0224570315,
0.3547367752,
-0.7845737934,
-0.0705117136,
-0.3858033717,
-0.1318754405,
-0.2032645345,
0.213739872,
-0.6805805564,
0.6333563924,
-0.562921524,
-0.8876799941,
-0.0871036723,
-0.706651926,
-0.35973683,
-0.3643692434,
-0.1841840446,
-0.4792425632,
-0.171762526,
0.612342,
0.7497426271,
-0.640640974,
0.5745590329,
-0.3607738316,
0.1474393606,
0.4519917369,
-0.5799658298,
0.8675166368,
0.51692909,
-0.1217943206,
0.0819054991,
-0.6453089118,
-0.3971751928,
0.0718042329,
0.1377097815,
-0.1169199347,
0.5920838118,
0.4144028127,
0.422270447,
0.2365827858,
-0.4207062125,
0.2337666154,
-0.3420014679,
0.7745760679,
0.6258773804,
0.6834124923,
0.0964019895,
-0.3433021009,
0.4677098393,
0.3940352201,
0.0924165845,
-0.3905883431,
-0.9445312023,
-0.385879755,
-0.1818540692,
-0.1255805343,
0.9146354795,
-0.7468596697,
0.1272127777,
-0.2322485894,
-0.5502340794,
-0.2437431067,
0.1357734948,
-0.0973570496,
0.1634244472,
0.4066256285,
-0.0355723575,
-0.4067949951,
-0.6260303259,
-0.190574497,
-0.273276329,
0.3543096781,
0.1632290632,
0.4551075697,
-0.2468968034,
0.5780982971,
-0.2884910107,
-0.0255818199,
-0.4539663494,
0.6419981718,
0.5349720716,
0.2734859884,
0.4955190122,
-0.8955767155,
-0.4472658336,
0.4080992639,
-0.4087745547,
0.1739504635,
-0.4487851858,
-0.0273422562,
-0.0361415595,
0.3221062124,
-0.1589122713,
0.6080459356,
0.44007653,
-0.3927991986,
0.1577009708,
0.0607425272,
0.4653759003,
-1.7568759918,
0.0234030373,
0.458244741,
-0.1662580818,
-0.749938786,
-0.2394486666,
-0.2481313646,
-0.6623333097,
-0.4284304976,
0.4314022362,
-0.2821518481,
0.1698372215,
-0.3327942491,
-0.031956248,
-0.1758754998,
0.2261461914,
-0.1511000544,
0.7107209563,
0.5391263962,
-0.3533958495,
0.6340541244,
0.3941029608,
-0.6516075134,
0.110429354,
-0.6138326526,
0.0976434499,
-0.2658591866,
0.0692434385,
-0.9947133064,
0.0209109262,
0.2903537154,
-0.2708547413,
0.0743952841,
-0.2577095628,
-0.418159306,
-0.1696640104,
-0.1030883789,
0.2638958395,
0.2893188,
-0.2246168852,
0.3702419102,
0.4713118076,
-0.6769993305,
-0.7191557288,
-0.3366240561,
0.3924619555,
-0.3643238544,
-0.7326605916,
0.2447147369,
0.1718568057,
-0.4470286071,
-0.2477275133,
-0.1390800178,
-0.4692054093,
0.295445919,
0.2041074038,
0.0880468637,
-0.3487932384,
-0.0844124258,
0.2031191289,
0.0471774973,
0.1084341556,
-0.1630877107,
0.5866616368,
-0.353107959,
-0.1206613854,
-0.8651732206,
0.6249698997,
0.8168186545,
-0.3575811684,
1.1119006872,
0.7403851151,
-0.3446688354,
0.0865741,
-0.3765842319,
-0.0921527594,
-0.4210328758,
0.3557745218,
-0.2304517776,
-0.3355416954,
0.9880167842,
-0.2137873173,
-0.0909953639,
0.3451624811,
0.743319571,
0.0600171834,
1.0080420971,
0.6332626343,
-0.5101614594,
0.6209077835,
-0.5281811357,
0.4025619924,
-0.2939858139,
-0.2703737617,
-0.7817204595,
-0.3132058382,
-0.5749088526,
-0.3622483015,
0.351601243,
0.0602464527,
0.0729840249,
0.0815897286,
0.0323642343,
0.3372778296,
-0.0063432008,
0.0274548121,
0.1021116003,
0.2929467261,
0.373986274,
-0.2165427208,
-0.4128152132,
-0.6908714771,
0.8074881434,
0.3465898633,
0.7035021782,
0.348085165,
0.55242908,
0.7352465391,
0.2858317494,
-0.6120368242,
0.3836141527,
-0.13693735,
-0.2466799319,
-0.273396343,
-0.3107054532,
-0.9121925831,
0.25444296,
-0.3081981242,
-0.9232426882,
0.6206380129,
-0.3156803548,
-0.2705400884,
0.4258626997,
-0.0071076364,
1.0084674358,
-0.0058934246,
-0.2421388775,
-0.6342275739,
-0.5315233469,
0.1198993325,
-0.0077469633,
0.3546993732,
-0.6191259027,
0.0227365196,
0.6585047841,
-0.3078817129,
0.9075160623,
-0.0058415378,
-0.2913395464,
0.1410182267,
-0.1932217628,
0.4543130696,
0.567478776,
-0.3395046592,
0.3065361083,
0.3030063212,
-0.7718874812,
-0.5512294769,
0.8724852204,
-1.2709276676,
-0.6366535425,
-0.466121763,
-0.6285349131,
-0.1008456573,
0.0453284793,
-0.0586637221,
0.7059926391,
-0.741163373,
0.131742835,
0.5533789396,
-0.2089382112,
0.5745003819,
0.5365566611,
-0.1593782306,
-0.4375801086,
0.9962639809,
0.0818588436,
-0.2731311321,
0.4931613207,
-0.0110842185,
-0.0142205693,
-0.5674483776,
-0.5972200632,
0.3304055333,
-0.6112411022,
-0.0752285868,
-0.648653388,
-0.2540040612,
-0.4637655318,
0.0468658544,
-0.5025863647,
-0.361733377,
-0.5526797175,
0.0867791697,
0.3928723633,
0.6905800104,
0.1416626722,
0.1429927349,
-0.8684628606,
0.2355566025,
-0.1698303819,
-0.2869478464,
-0.1528253555,
-0.3388883173,
-0.4033115804,
0.1713769585,
-0.4488742352,
-1.4772675037,
0.9406114221,
0.5448049307,
0.1757812649,
0.8407062888,
0.3006963134,
0.7663089037,
-0.4672399163,
0.7521516085,
-0.0482077487,
-0.9698981047,
0.8100104332,
-0.5371014476,
0.0793446079,
0.2276350856,
0.6416858435,
-0.8290426731,
-0.4042444825,
-0.4095353782,
-1.0415810347,
0.5587470531,
0.2252914608,
0.5048339963,
-0.2169303745,
0.4512840211,
-0.081434682,
0.3955929875,
-0.2556886971,
-0.5342540741,
-0.4530439079,
-0.0717619136,
-0.2963175178,
-0.4079199731,
-0.3362427652,
-0.2243033201,
0.651501894,
-0.0099841096,
0.227241829,
-0.0191652793,
0.0605648756,
-0.0508142784,
0.4360815287,
0.7151673436,
0.8491870165,
-0.1343990564,
-0.1086896583,
-0.3813824058,
-0.3887063563,
0.2302310914,
0.3859397769,
-0.0184800215,
0.1875741184,
0.2752678692,
0.7224546671,
-0.0421008207,
-0.4132338762,
0.5829843879,
-0.1108562946,
0.2576579154,
-0.4478205442,
-0.2896848321,
-0.0981811956,
0.4932721555,
0.5858932734,
0.1808594167,
0.162533015,
-0.7710636258,
0.2712706625,
0.1832541376,
-0.2374154776,
-0.6988444924,
0.512018919,
0.5440394878,
-0.0698959902,
0.5251256824,
-0.0606031008,
-0.2836079895,
0.8860268593,
0.35358724,
1.0016021729,
-0.5044235587,
0.8658184409,
0.3302389085,
0.3103069067,
-0.033684276,
0.6217039824,
-0.0524422824,
-0.999435544,
-0.6428773999,
-0.3487967849,
-0.1362512112,
0.3183544278,
-1.1659367085,
0.0773428306,
-0.4061568975,
-0.2949201763,
0.06933254,
0.2072941363,
-0.4451445937,
-0.2498188019,
0.0682777911,
0.7924559116,
-1.2298548222,
1.1671825647,
0.7955237627,
-0.2351750135,
-0.197853893,
0.2121251822,
0.2141632587,
-0.5249340534,
0.5353803635,
0.1004574746,
-0.0129676675,
-0.0141130341,
-0.217944622,
-0.8986700773,
0.8254995346,
0.2583262324,
-0.3699930012,
0.18069233,
0.1079602987,
0.5644461513,
-0.5317578316,
-0.0398324244,
0.2732302248,
0.2860664427,
0.0048726564,
-0.5832397938,
-0.2006176114,
-0.7005854845,
0.0890917331,
0.290896982,
-0.5803079009,
0.6457027197,
-0.1775045395,
-0.3450548053,
0.1831663847,
0.9770764112,
-0.4208539426,
0.6563467383,
-0.0039035066,
0.1043089107,
0.7141196132,
0.0021832772,
1.0115908384,
-0.8488590717,
0.4539313614,
0.7461301684,
-0.2988118827,
0.8245112896,
0.4838472605,
0.0019331726,
0.7452579737,
0.6541416645,
0.2735250294,
0.6192680001,
-0.1075292155,
-0.2829777598,
-0.2689761817,
-0.2254513502,
-0.4704663455,
0.2282972485,
0.8209908009,
-0.3064458072,
-0.3669512272,
0.3575187325,
0.1441915631,
0.0640468523,
-0.3707877994,
0.6086737514,
0.1000611112,
-0.2080103457,
0.4405544102,
0.390045315,
0.0285463613,
-0.385417968,
0.0461957268,
-0.4262855351,
0.135566026,
0.046343483,
-0.5558308959,
0.5979521275,
0.0710888579,
-0.3326584697,
-0.3011400104,
0.3427936137,
-0.5405094624,
-0.5389512777,
0.0581027828,
0.7403099537,
0.1494837403,
0.0164078046,
-1.1122236252,
0.1883574575,
-0.007971257,
-0.2684329748,
0.1530602276,
0.5386406183,
-0.1587361097,
0.7925251126,
0.4189031124,
0.1701890826,
-0.1796978712,
0.1673157066,
0.6766886115,
-0.6341580749,
-0.6263796687,
-0.8748493791,
0.2442683131,
-0.145352602,
-0.2404602915,
1.0032404661,
0.3307561278,
0.4730144739,
0.0546442494,
0.6015607119,
0.1275055856,
0.2621041834,
-0.4782330692,
0.7800191045,
-0.346293509,
0.584412396,
-0.2175817937,
-0.6489232779,
-0.0888825357,
0.5239415169,
-0.5060250163,
-0.3452834785,
0.4168493152,
0.7438877225,
-0.043543376,
0.2920690179,
0.0306679606,
0.4298196733,
0.416131407,
0.2152197212,
0.7194339037,
-0.2680051625,
0.4424355626,
-0.2717609107,
-0.0432558134,
-0.3576857746,
-0.779961884,
-1.0550596714,
-0.8913183808,
-0.622025311,
-0.5502699018,
0.2442936003,
0.9761399627,
0.557005167,
-1.1765770912,
-0.5357154608,
0.117468521,
0.3482806385,
-0.4828713536,
-0.2197435647,
0.4625271559,
-0.0398111008,
-0.648334682,
0.3988512456,
0.3073563576,
-0.0371109359,
-0.5097628236,
0.1838637292,
-0.3297488093,
0.399133563,
0.5185854435,
0.4586035311,
-0.6172384024,
0.0757355541,
-0.328574568,
0.019879844,
-0.0411932208,
1.1689420938,
-0.4037102163,
0.4027369916,
0.7029803395,
0.7933369279,
0.5092090368,
0.0754776746,
0.6464364529,
-0.6670824885,
0.466324389,
0.0681427717,
0.4345196784,
0.30948475,
-0.2999176383,
0.1006454676,
0.3372989297,
-0.3900049925,
-0.8178318143,
0.470895499,
-0.7137510777,
-0.332734853,
1.078545332,
-0.2571279705,
-0.2929294407,
-0.4488547444,
-0.0170433633,
0.2078117579,
-0.7023519278,
1.2216681242,
0.712669909,
0.1086611226,
-0.3434667289,
-0.5473340154,
0.3548391461,
0.1868282109,
-0.6836292744,
-0.1453523487,
0.2480300516,
0.0243131202,
0.0366966128,
0.4646126628,
-0.0343370065,
0.1740553081,
-0.5421156287,
-0.2299306244,
0.1816098094,
-0.6296348572,
-0.3318938017,
0.3124443591,
-0.2328852117,
0.0163970031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11369v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11369v2
|
What Makes Math Word Problems Challenging for LLMs?
| 2024-03-17T23:18:40 | 2024-04-01T13:58:34 |
KV Aditya Srivatsa, Ekaterina Kochmar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper investigates the question of what makes math word problems (MWPs)
in English challenging for large language models (LLMs). We conduct an in-depth
analysis of the key linguistic and mathematical characteristics of MWPs. In
addition, we train feature-based classifiers to better understand the impact of
each feature on the overall difficulty of MWPs for prominent LLMs and
investigate whether this helps predict how well LLMs fare against specific
categories of MWPs.
|
[
-0.3257746696,
-0.6246342063,
0.565656662,
0.3791741133,
-0.1153222322,
0.3885753751,
-0.0682307035,
-0.5761331916,
-0.1636104733,
0.5232865214,
-0.723598361,
-0.2389801443,
-1.1186950207,
0.4440071881,
-0.1338044107,
0.7478289604,
-0.4740051329,
0.2814765573,
-0.7601781487,
-0.2790258229,
-0.9412607551,
-0.9721096754,
-0.4096674621,
-0.52966398,
0.4612891078,
0.2802446783,
0.9570966363,
0.2587127686,
1.1667855978,
0.4272669852,
-0.3434757888,
0.1742652506,
-0.3827802241,
0.1598556042,
-0.0455833375,
-0.8158071041,
0.0038172358,
-0.0023470868,
0.2221671641,
1.3597370386,
-0.0206896532,
0.106871441,
0.102021426,
0.7966637611,
-0.3733573258,
0.3998681605,
-0.8782067299,
0.3561807573,
-0.4946590662,
-0.1614910364,
-0.0618809238,
-0.2113100886,
0.4596602023,
-0.3616012931,
0.233308807,
0.143811211,
0.8006263971,
0.1896516383,
-0.6086201072,
-0.8217052817,
-0.6738826036,
0.8696114421,
-0.4043329656,
0.2030715644,
0.4202975929,
0.1092743576,
-0.3809220195,
-0.2990556657,
-0.2896638513,
-0.202261135,
0.0651133358,
-0.1655165106,
-0.26325652,
-0.1248590276,
0.4830700755,
0.4923117459,
-0.2979336381,
0.4115126133,
-0.3598707318,
-0.0921759233,
0.7667961717,
0.7527516484,
0.2482379675,
-0.1659109592,
0.0804919824,
0.1485005915,
-0.8765063882,
0.1666308045,
0.4429477751,
0.0030605895,
0.0848855153,
1.090035677,
0.3450607061,
0.6278156042,
-0.7072088122,
-0.5177321434,
0.0539164916,
0.3659619689,
0.1938378066,
-0.3260620832,
0.3472935855,
0.2058564126,
0.7099654675,
0.0913773552,
-0.5627237558,
0.3044347167,
-0.0627096295,
-0.4410531819,
0.1441658884,
0.0089965016,
-0.1642441005,
-0.4604636133,
-0.253765136,
-0.0718680024,
-0.4006393552,
-0.3130574524,
0.7234247327,
-0.526824832,
0.0683102757,
0.2437564731,
-0.3323942721,
0.0212379992,
0.2964351177,
-0.9137049913,
0.3068231344,
1.0961773396,
0.7617523074,
-0.2188597322,
-0.3025461733,
-0.22502321,
-0.0224911328,
-0.4012801349,
0.7233675718,
-0.6911345124,
-0.6354205012,
0.0533078387,
-0.0933902189,
-0.0101396767,
-0.9960472584,
0.2020417154,
-0.2600644827,
0.2628626227,
-0.4372783005,
-0.9097057581,
-0.0707907379,
0.4623810053,
-0.3745370805,
0.710177958,
0.4187039435,
-0.7458410263,
0.1208292544,
-0.5812442303,
-0.5068839788,
0.1554525495,
-0.2639572024,
-0.106915392,
0.8459163308,
0.0704263821,
0.4060877562,
-0.3186739385,
0.0373323262,
-0.3026208878,
-0.0206677318,
0.6397082806,
-0.3437384069,
0.2850161791,
0.2132104635,
-0.0528697111,
-0.0091747763,
-0.7876893282,
-0.059863776,
0.5760833621,
-0.3332804143,
-0.3591466248,
0.5266155601,
-0.2003117353,
0.0771869272,
0.2076679021,
-0.4022782147,
0.3880061209,
-0.3005754948,
0.4804688096,
0.8704966307,
-0.1572793573,
-0.0031801246,
-0.589597702,
0.8115510345,
-0.0555693619,
-0.0941498056,
0.0093258554,
-0.8532193899,
-0.5969242454,
0.0051260712,
0.4797053039,
1.0083392859,
-0.7919170856,
0.1772048771,
-0.1827666312,
-0.4492641687,
-0.3222874701,
0.3893386722,
0.3487810493,
0.4017635882,
-0.0333930664,
-0.0514945388,
-0.0828671977,
-0.8185112476,
-0.2353402674,
0.2620614469,
-0.2404864877,
0.4597893953,
0.7094562054,
-0.0784517899,
0.7056948543,
-1.0189961195,
-0.6224814057,
-0.3639769554,
0.2351742536,
0.0577400401,
0.1176469922,
0.4017363787,
-0.6914865971,
-0.2704930902,
-0.2707796991,
-0.5567187071,
-0.5778932571,
0.3277692199,
0.4842854142,
0.2012351304,
0.4653398395,
-0.4569768906,
0.5291783214,
0.6065314412,
-0.3628347218,
0.4642509222,
-0.3334008455,
-0.2288080901,
-0.9005451202,
-0.491563946,
0.1794461906,
0.1345729679,
-0.3377305865,
0.2827284634,
-0.222914055,
-0.6426580548,
-0.5022292137,
0.1055975258,
-0.4792499244,
-0.1287546307,
-0.1471160799,
0.1571272314,
-0.065348126,
0.138539657,
-0.0825766325,
0.6671730876,
0.3529417515,
-0.6744323969,
0.6402203441,
0.0355761349,
-0.2614223957,
0.4340312183,
-0.6938031912,
-0.1053405926,
-0.1404997259,
-0.2600680292,
-1.0186755657,
0.1688923091,
-0.5781109929,
-0.2610137463,
0.3188734055,
0.1739431173,
-0.6422909498,
-0.6238367558,
-0.2110595703,
0.3944588006,
0.5626431704,
-0.2709079087,
0.2577363849,
0.5324413776,
-0.2290847749,
-0.223127678,
-0.5701788068,
0.0732737333,
-0.2583589256,
-0.7734283209,
0.3985423148,
-0.1100214273,
-0.5845285058,
0.0337326825,
0.0181606188,
0.1264605969,
0.3493529856,
0.1831712276,
0.1885302663,
-0.0086561497,
0.2907753289,
-0.4127503037,
-0.2016814053,
0.4483277798,
0.1927244216,
0.721458137,
-0.1158472225,
-0.5940881968,
0.0143362433,
0.5113542676,
0.5521745682,
-0.1165066436,
0.4411233664,
0.0904135779,
-0.5743532777,
-0.2762345076,
-0.6298709512,
0.1572483033,
-0.553791225,
0.6591094136,
-0.7054360509,
-1.2098964453,
0.6976947784,
-0.0817450508,
0.0635319725,
0.5562076569,
0.4591390193,
-0.2215532959,
1.3994541168,
0.670303762,
-0.1346333027,
-0.0261135213,
-0.1874043941,
-0.0394338146,
-0.6682360172,
-0.5363951325,
-0.6980600953,
-0.6758046746,
-0.6140349507,
-0.3504575491,
0.3527626991,
-0.0005197537,
0.1628634483,
0.0855226591,
-0.4336037636,
0.4392034709,
0.0754391104,
-0.284658581,
0.1582542658,
0.057271231,
-0.3107632101,
-0.9230929613,
-0.5725517273,
-0.2616585493,
0.8424127698,
0.52590698,
1.1477582455,
0.5110397935,
0.4719610214,
-0.1237204224,
0.2351684868,
-1.3303699493,
0.6618454456,
-0.2768650353,
-0.7277769446,
-0.1965036243,
-0.8143826723,
-1.2453824282,
0.0497822985,
-0.5287665129,
-0.6415056586,
-0.3367620111,
-0.2738416493,
0.1112955809,
0.5259455442,
-0.6155975461,
0.3322060108,
-0.4405545294,
0.1568651646,
-0.101833649,
-0.1600078344,
0.3612230122,
-0.1922769845,
0.657269001,
-0.3433721662,
-0.2828945816,
0.6183942556,
-0.8630647063,
0.5421543121,
0.2629794776,
-0.4646616578,
0.2137532234,
0.4616844654,
0.3218189776,
-0.259493947,
0.3702696264,
0.1168189794,
-0.094402276,
-0.2216217518,
-0.6309592724,
0.6209756136,
-0.6114621758,
-0.9656332731,
-0.6532924175,
-1.0737811327,
-0.6621800065,
-0.2223198712,
0.3811459541,
0.5281235576,
0.1999877691,
0.1769936681,
0.6949856877,
-0.4493502676,
0.6257666945,
0.4136905372,
-0.5274434686,
-0.2525011003,
1.1729178429,
0.9157373309,
0.285592556,
0.3314278424,
0.5928938389,
-0.2226676941,
-0.8038429022,
-0.100699842,
0.1987552047,
-0.7242827415,
-0.251827538,
-0.3675015867,
-0.6031730175,
-0.2026246786,
-0.2155949473,
-0.0549235754,
-0.54993999,
-0.4557538331,
0.1282865107,
0.4281551242,
1.2447463274,
0.294708848,
0.192188412,
-1.0424468517,
0.3430887163,
0.6758936048,
0.3785675764,
-0.1651340723,
-0.8818700314,
0.228444159,
-0.6138840318,
-0.5846299529,
-0.922858417,
0.3534215391,
0.0734945163,
0.2980988324,
0.4157961607,
-0.2186384946,
0.7531088591,
-0.8633019328,
0.8098577857,
0.2813430727,
-1.1712169647,
0.3523370922,
0.0354577377,
0.2560119331,
0.1091109142,
0.6035531759,
-0.4862086773,
-0.3658213317,
-0.6279407144,
-0.6844297647,
0.2207856327,
0.3386068046,
0.6381629705,
-0.1237751171,
0.7752436399,
-0.1557571441,
0.2509173751,
-0.6942018867,
-0.2736916542,
0.3933838904,
-0.2997553945,
-0.1095316038,
-0.5214939713,
-0.1056518033,
-0.4540047646,
0.2873883545,
0.1729383916,
-0.1818656623,
-0.021078445,
-0.09619046,
-0.2749321759,
0.3436792791,
0.9100004435,
0.8464015126,
-0.0791206062,
-0.006375087,
0.691499114,
-0.5452792645,
0.2780032158,
0.0004460267,
0.1751249433,
0.1802561283,
0.8367308378,
0.6557173729,
0.4639467597,
-0.6561793685,
0.6274735928,
0.0763669312,
-0.6861403584,
-0.2350627333,
0.1242561489,
0.2972411513,
-0.0911130011,
0.7107493877,
-0.3294175565,
-0.1730839312,
-0.7439990044,
-0.2431842089,
0.8422832489,
-0.3413716555,
-0.0947912112,
0.3939774632,
0.2474351823,
-0.9920550585,
0.2954459786,
-0.2434434444,
-1.1011509895,
0.7774421573,
0.9171593189,
0.3957407773,
-0.0589998141,
-0.2685727775,
-0.2175988108,
0.6250037551,
0.0386729017,
0.6158124804,
0.5137094259,
-0.6744018793,
-0.5936867595,
-0.4973274469,
-0.8263827562,
0.2910645902,
-0.3700858951,
0.449752152,
-0.8258668184,
-0.1813302338,
-0.0158871897,
0.1769553721,
-0.6354621649,
0.3319178522,
0.3716115654,
0.8929604888,
-0.499294579,
0.3421826363,
0.6854367256,
0.2176899463,
-1.0042022467,
-0.5877347589,
0.161927104,
-1.0710952282,
0.7189842463,
0.2461105287,
-0.0213908628,
-0.0120963845,
-0.5127151608,
-0.6104815006,
0.7036547065,
0.4323035181,
-0.7550513744,
-0.1942631602,
0.6220266223,
0.4686611295,
-0.4525821507,
-0.0673541501,
0.2009342313,
0.3475827277,
0.2140137106,
-0.9053614736,
-0.1989431083,
-0.0172555223,
0.2480456978,
0.640384078,
-0.5732811093,
0.9541230798,
-0.3956562579,
0.0485055931,
-0.2008259892,
0.535446763,
0.2467627823,
0.4274577796,
0.6640064716,
1.0012245178,
0.5446811318,
-0.4634948671,
0.9609704614,
0.0880132765,
0.4298199713,
0.6834608316,
-0.4443447292,
0.8702030778,
0.4101545811,
-0.6284551024,
0.2977688015,
0.4977153838,
-0.2073831856,
0.0026287783,
1.1526215076,
-0.1857578754,
-0.2232385874,
0.1133778319,
-0.8047940135,
0.8329843283,
0.6923334002,
0.0516555794,
-0.2423885167,
0.1900481582,
0.0972500965,
0.2658409476,
-0.5508911014,
0.5025040507,
0.37325418,
-0.1587827206,
0.2036083043,
0.2085135281,
0.9074744582,
-0.8924425244,
-0.0044311807,
-0.035362903,
-0.1047874093,
-0.1682996303,
-0.8408814669,
0.5331671834,
0.0156486724,
-0.0635209754,
0.2724977434,
0.5511017442,
-0.1225851327,
-0.9737482667,
0.1224225387,
0.659481585,
0.0226693153,
-0.10988231,
-0.7715108991,
0.1707356274,
-0.3535903096,
-0.2919533849,
0.49355492,
0.9916491508,
-0.0504532456,
1.0490182638,
0.7383025885,
0.2313163429,
-0.1866368949,
0.0174976047,
0.6450176239,
-1.0060924292,
-0.281820327,
-1.1167097092,
0.1621263176,
0.1781385541,
-0.7083056569,
0.5769851804,
0.4265983999,
0.4926605225,
-0.0419061519,
0.2889882028,
0.2384877205,
0.4432128668,
-0.5810557604,
0.6277252436,
-0.7103605866,
0.6618816853,
-0.3078245521,
-1.0025116205,
-0.468455106,
0.4932559133,
-0.2059361935,
-0.0344077982,
0.9748668075,
0.3335134685,
0.2975108325,
-0.2779646516,
0.6791594625,
-0.1491856277,
0.3443584144,
0.9270603061,
1.0943412781,
-0.0909709409,
0.7926171422,
-0.3783620894,
0.0005758172,
-0.0017563493,
-0.9699231982,
-1.056497097,
-0.4548904002,
-0.4090263844,
-0.4554959238,
-0.5610075593,
0.9517607093,
0.1850782186,
-0.601090014,
-0.3428160846,
0.1795450151,
0.5004556179,
0.1680685878,
-0.3188967705,
0.1545663178,
-0.6224102378,
-0.7139927745,
-0.0359152444,
0.3782988787,
0.4559004307,
-0.4161244035,
0.4257867038,
0.2075957209,
0.2903710604,
0.8277227283,
-0.1901119351,
-0.459723264,
-0.6197117567,
-0.0902522132,
-0.3126358986,
-0.2282687575,
1.1300126314,
-0.412211597,
0.0768167228,
0.1906942427,
0.7350023985,
0.0570848696,
-0.4455129802,
0.3542918861,
-0.7055862546,
0.240584448,
0.3665218651,
0.5770704746,
0.3416342735,
-0.4339945018,
0.4844954014,
0.8634617329,
-0.3174216449,
-0.9922956824,
0.4511347711,
-0.7151752114,
-0.5550172329,
1.1524070501,
0.0378779806,
-0.1599204689,
-0.1367389858,
-0.2457467914,
-0.4884914458,
0.399278909,
0.6996703148,
1.5467436314,
-0.1390648484,
-0.1681628972,
-0.678740859,
0.4135169983,
0.772307694,
-0.4521992505,
-0.2835842073,
0.3211791217,
0.4356747568,
0.2444932908,
0.0058167586,
-0.0528009795,
-0.1706109047,
-0.1409323812,
-0.2444022298,
-0.217288062,
-0.0276989173,
-0.3225442171,
0.5334914327,
0.3978812099,
0.214407891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11366v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11366v2
|
JORA: JAX Tensor-Parallel LoRA Library for Retrieval Augmented Fine-Tuning
| 2024-03-17T23:02:04 | 2024-03-19T16:19:49 |
Anique Tahir, Lu Cheng, Huan Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC
|
The scaling of Large Language Models (LLMs) for retrieval-based tasks,
particularly in Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG), faces significant memory
constraints, especially when fine-tuning extensive prompt sequences. Current
open-source libraries support full-model inference and fine-tuning across
multiple GPUs but fall short of accommodating the efficient parameter
distribution required for retrieved context. Addressing this gap, we introduce
a novel framework for PEFT-compatible fine-tuning of Llama-2 models, leveraging
distributed training. Our framework uniquely utilizes JAX's just-in-time (JIT)
compilation and tensor-sharding for efficient resource management, thereby
enabling accelerated fine-tuning with reduced memory requirements. This
advancement significantly improves the scalability and feasibility of
fine-tuning LLMs for complex RAG applications, even on systems with limited GPU
resources. Our experiments show more than 12x improvement in runtime compared
to Hugging Face/DeepSpeed implementation with four GPUs while consuming less
than half the VRAM per GPU.
|
[
-0.4008266628,
-1.0375797749,
0.4829781055,
0.4679357409,
-0.3185690045,
0.1329994053,
-0.3948464096,
-0.4491612017,
0.1677526683,
0.6566277146,
-0.4044629335,
-0.2955311835,
-0.5924455523,
-0.026482312,
-0.1604961455,
0.9287325144,
-0.2733221352,
-0.1234158874,
-0.1692541242,
-0.4218725562,
-0.3707259297,
-0.0560080111,
-0.792681694,
-0.4242112935,
0.6232008338,
0.2710131705,
0.6971029043,
0.9051615,
0.7646356225,
0.2372812182,
-0.259552747,
0.5430080295,
-0.6920482516,
0.3085312843,
-0.3285171688,
-0.652436018,
-0.6383928061,
-0.1982814074,
0.7427846193,
0.643883884,
-0.0944218263,
0.5080772638,
-0.014565696,
0.8033051491,
-1.0146948099,
-0.0318526514,
-0.55100137,
-0.0823183879,
-0.7031787038,
-0.145713225,
-0.2768140435,
-0.1786394417,
-0.0084058773,
-0.8606748581,
0.1521249264,
0.0207526945,
0.8453732133,
0.7143051028,
-0.3142489791,
0.1222163513,
-0.6860376,
0.8369153738,
-0.3558680117,
0.4574148357,
0.3513844013,
0.2007740736,
-0.2198550999,
-0.7755259275,
-0.3844897449,
0.2012407929,
0.1447689384,
-0.0344480947,
0.049328357,
0.1575892568,
0.4495830834,
0.5551543236,
-0.4259805977,
-0.0031003531,
0.0123156207,
0.283711493,
0.3735188246,
0.1985679716,
-0.0109711839,
0.1128724515,
-0.405646801,
-0.0910013169,
-0.9292443991,
-0.3723604381,
0.1566156596,
0.4697291851,
-0.2406830192,
0.3888114691,
-0.324136436,
0.6843978167,
0.098137483,
-0.4213464558,
0.239441514,
-0.0156033421,
-0.4102551639,
-0.2811410725,
0.4604733288,
-0.0299719125,
-0.3011073172,
-0.0793145746,
-0.2548274398,
0.0702283084,
0.0470998846,
-0.8803224564,
-0.1609890461,
-0.0926935971,
-0.4141031504,
-0.2112526,
-0.4600150585,
-0.718881011,
-0.4127477407,
-0.4464129806,
0.6419937015,
-0.0969596505,
-0.382191658,
0.0952850357,
-0.1261188537,
-0.0664383993,
0.4204611182,
-0.7493367195,
0.3018871844,
0.7819604278,
0.7526343465,
-0.2730792761,
-0.1270274222,
-0.7601439953,
0.4671112299,
-0.128813833,
0.6911098957,
-0.5976227522,
-0.1926475018,
-0.2701188028,
-0.2199849486,
-0.0323837958,
-0.7249307632,
0.6246837378,
-0.6750845909,
-0.1565446705,
-0.4815003276,
-0.399081856,
-0.0092251673,
0.2689085007,
-0.5677055717,
1.2167015076,
0.3067843616,
-0.6434623003,
0.1498310119,
-0.6220830679,
-0.4689890742,
0.2427916676,
-0.2292490602,
-0.5301148295,
0.1980532259,
0.3887274265,
0.4145095348,
-0.790315032,
0.1795046329,
-0.4667184353,
-0.7401575446,
-0.4332941175,
-0.2158341259,
0.6401462555,
0.5688074231,
-0.3709516227,
-0.1764705479,
-0.7329220176,
0.0295918845,
0.3033668697,
-0.6166654825,
-0.5907859206,
-0.2305379957,
0.0640967712,
-0.3285360038,
0.6668741107,
-0.5197712779,
0.4056015611,
-0.1676553935,
0.2482990175,
0.5944795609,
-0.3755656481,
0.4822875261,
-0.1828356683,
0.4123055935,
-0.1931004673,
0.2664372623,
-0.0893632397,
-0.1896465123,
-0.7864675522,
-0.8175174594,
0.0893783644,
0.3210866451,
-0.7503769994,
-0.1894252747,
-0.1942008585,
-0.4415098429,
-0.6130873561,
0.3223956227,
0.7781350017,
0.3674248159,
0.334389329,
-0.0257190224,
-0.6166603565,
-0.7867192626,
-0.3156093061,
-0.0063436772,
0.0651771799,
0.8375100493,
0.0749512762,
-0.5519528389,
0.4950574338,
-0.3482741714,
-0.3332479298,
-0.0218390897,
0.1028647497,
0.3429973125,
0.344466567,
0.5656421185,
-0.6992864609,
-0.5532051921,
0.1915381849,
-0.6539423466,
-0.3704560399,
0.1066426635,
-0.3488874733,
0.1380760521,
0.3627977669,
-0.6664046049,
0.1417192668,
0.7358910441,
-0.1300973296,
0.1201219335,
-0.1417296529,
0.1519558281,
-1.0950610638,
0.2106540352,
-0.2980040908,
-0.4542646706,
-0.062992774,
0.5164602995,
0.1549118012,
0.023229545,
-0.0826822072,
0.5125402808,
-0.2047804743,
-0.3632194102,
-0.5308861136,
-0.0257354844,
0.2304580808,
0.2827285528,
-0.1660591364,
1.1339164972,
0.2858219743,
-0.6508382559,
0.1532087773,
0.2875469029,
-0.063287124,
0.6814978719,
-0.6751306653,
0.143895492,
-0.0614766069,
0.2722775042,
-0.4212246239,
-0.4540973008,
-0.2076925784,
0.0045193615,
0.3479010463,
-0.4196060896,
-0.5221292973,
-0.1811353415,
-0.0374466144,
0.6328192353,
0.4569856226,
-1.1135329008,
0.7352898717,
0.5634884834,
0.0692913085,
-0.7327705026,
-0.3450752199,
-0.2815402448,
-0.2246098518,
-0.4549728334,
0.5868439078,
-0.0312068406,
-0.1942356378,
-0.1409885585,
0.0475996956,
-0.0445090868,
0.3148749769,
0.3804965317,
0.0512072183,
-0.2300519794,
0.0154829584,
0.3521912098,
-0.0338191986,
-0.352050513,
-0.1322833598,
0.6293980479,
-0.2136801183,
-0.3542020321,
-0.3231859207,
0.1865436882,
0.4144490957,
-0.3437788188,
0.6574027538,
0.9738887548,
-0.2091377676,
-0.273116678,
-0.6503822803,
0.1342348307,
-0.5028306842,
0.2252568007,
-0.6105560064,
-1.3001089096,
0.5501604676,
-0.6757810712,
0.0797555149,
0.3875481188,
0.8527759314,
-0.1614770442,
1.0120524168,
0.7596660852,
-0.1560428739,
0.7382631302,
-0.1573449671,
-0.0672219172,
-1.0009993315,
0.0052289204,
-0.4058012366,
-0.4826698005,
-0.5983108878,
-0.4748628438,
0.5201960206,
0.490937978,
-0.5640572309,
0.3424483538,
-0.5146867633,
0.8524384499,
0.5149062872,
0.1098680422,
0.3671788573,
0.0832782239,
-0.0575319901,
0.1676996499,
-0.4973803163,
-0.1135788411,
1.0280305147,
0.261258781,
0.8464470506,
0.2458876073,
0.862382412,
0.0801728442,
0.1958998442,
-0.3093153834,
0.4257666469,
-0.3505254984,
-0.7451125979,
0.0174937453,
-0.5229412913,
-0.7923031449,
0.1929229796,
-0.1380510777,
-0.5276954174,
0.0175374355,
0.1573942602,
-0.4931671619,
0.405578047,
-0.4426688552,
0.4612879157,
0.2391091585,
-0.6382055879,
-0.69535923,
-0.275983572,
0.3598949015,
-0.1309614182,
-0.2334854901,
-0.4502609372,
0.0019544079,
0.6658061743,
-0.2751262188,
0.5201250315,
-0.2371232361,
0.1305806935,
0.259652853,
0.1730356812,
0.7621440887,
0.4362618923,
-0.0716764852,
0.2135642469,
0.1176604629,
-0.5668994188,
-0.3598568141,
1.1346017122,
-1.0603252649,
-0.4752378166,
-0.1082047671,
-0.7655408978,
-0.242165938,
0.2347282767,
-0.0024840748,
0.0548766218,
0.0853871033,
0.198412329,
0.8990023732,
-0.1240183413,
0.1960299611,
0.7362052202,
-0.2945030034,
-0.4897869527,
0.7423561811,
-0.2029592693,
-0.0054028309,
0.3436949849,
-0.0024693522,
0.067394875,
-0.5882567763,
-0.6774948239,
0.4451444447,
-0.3100228012,
-0.5159696937,
-0.4469025135,
0.0602280088,
-0.0925210714,
-0.1444035321,
-0.961376369,
-0.3088615835,
-0.4359469712,
0.3263311386,
0.8871873021,
0.8175843954,
-0.0229981262,
0.5859197974,
-0.7059909701,
0.3966629207,
0.0834395364,
0.7449400425,
-0.1461790353,
-0.5079660416,
-0.4190560281,
-0.1336486638,
-0.3351547718,
-0.1407500654,
0.1453535706,
0.1410414577,
0.1640639156,
0.1471211314,
-0.091000177,
1.318965435,
-0.4305328727,
0.5220708251,
-0.1146988496,
-0.7241970897,
0.4519366324,
-0.6551504135,
0.2044035643,
0.6640188694,
0.2514550686,
-0.0819306821,
-0.0121013066,
-0.309139818,
-0.7027639151,
0.5938956141,
-0.012502878,
0.0965829939,
-0.0893080756,
0.7451924086,
0.1615747362,
-0.0799194872,
-0.1558025628,
-0.170904696,
0.3520604372,
-0.2073939741,
0.1407857686,
-0.3843518794,
-0.3011953235,
-0.3116639853,
0.7401201129,
-0.2623673379,
0.3261925578,
0.0846411511,
-0.0785210207,
-0.5830153823,
-0.1313900501,
0.2611271143,
0.4359920323,
-0.3687141538,
-0.118519716,
0.2903083265,
-0.5491653681,
-0.2132432461,
0.2893753052,
-0.3070670664,
-0.1736785173,
-0.1047012359,
0.94758147,
0.1263848841,
-0.739064157,
0.2975110114,
-0.2530276477,
0.1028058603,
-0.315944016,
0.2110377997,
0.018134186,
0.836855948,
0.1230038479,
0.0392650068,
0.0052769436,
-0.0899079889,
0.1287675947,
0.6027060151,
0.1449716836,
-0.2652018666,
0.9414970875,
0.1963214129,
0.0092237229,
0.6561824679,
-0.0821756124,
-0.0189083442,
0.2046391964,
0.7066020966,
0.6396512985,
0.0157971028,
-0.2074154764,
0.4096802473,
-0.1812646985,
-0.3960528076,
0.5786127448,
-0.2471257299,
-0.4807502925,
-0.659960866,
-1.1769708395,
-0.4527493119,
0.1819253117,
-0.7334567904,
0.2785164714,
-0.7755771279,
-0.3388809264,
-0.2341910154,
0.1256235987,
-0.8043205738,
-0.1203232855,
0.3029879928,
0.6515415311,
-0.6064246297,
1.0568215847,
0.6979079843,
-0.1361198872,
-0.8860862255,
-0.3081356585,
-0.1565538943,
-0.6873595715,
0.5275205374,
-0.1305401772,
-0.0660809278,
0.1661472768,
-0.3318552971,
-1.3298459053,
1.36627388,
0.813821733,
-0.6893390417,
-0.0430826843,
0.091497153,
0.4651102722,
-0.0929952264,
0.2846415639,
0.7823587656,
0.0844316632,
0.0335792229,
-1.2946815491,
-0.1740569323,
0.0216748659,
0.2502317131,
0.5643762946,
-1.0428514481,
1.0619831085,
0.0119562596,
0.08516597,
0.2647632957,
0.7575281262,
0.6221136451,
0.2824867368,
0.306186676,
1.0871880054,
0.9246160388,
-0.0289165508,
1.0738940239,
-0.3109990358,
0.4881540537,
1.0321087837,
-0.260728389,
0.9850406051,
0.4558631778,
-0.2804818451,
0.2913345098,
0.4364157617,
0.3468756974,
0.5344290137,
-0.3174377084,
-0.5372656584,
-0.3712966442,
-0.4579259753,
-0.270698607,
0.5155175924,
0.4465918839,
-0.431301564,
-0.3458555043,
0.0436535962,
-0.0301134996,
-0.0140468413,
-0.6627684832,
0.5857765675,
0.1618041992,
-0.3650797904,
0.8482438922,
0.1006335989,
0.7597335577,
-0.2708600163,
0.0321304314,
-0.3642091453,
0.5719217062,
-0.1162150577,
-0.4346569479,
0.2668928206,
0.1097206324,
-0.3360331059,
-0.1874430627,
0.7420343161,
-0.2493170053,
-0.1272402555,
0.2568568289,
0.4617129862,
0.0734784082,
-0.0801471472,
-0.7625516653,
0.5477711558,
-0.1209234446,
-0.5678650737,
0.7514066696,
0.2608554363,
-0.2653900683,
0.6540420055,
0.649620235,
-0.1400916129,
0.1854972392,
0.2524822652,
1.0403826237,
-0.3548669815,
-0.2112817317,
-0.7106079459,
0.0215935837,
0.2044861913,
-0.258806318,
0.6258713007,
0.4892497063,
0.9704956412,
0.1056904048,
0.4675360918,
-0.1542980522,
0.7820576429,
-0.197812885,
0.6731438041,
-0.7475394011,
0.2520376146,
-0.0680461004,
-0.9822131395,
-0.3780368268,
0.6607573628,
-0.0377385654,
-0.2089619488,
0.2064421028,
0.7063375711,
-0.2921134531,
-0.1423156559,
0.2490605861,
0.1151719838,
0.258867383,
0.5897114277,
0.2997637987,
-0.5933882594,
0.3129921556,
-0.2711497843,
0.0064746323,
-0.3587451279,
-0.6059195399,
-0.9142720699,
-0.4241026342,
-0.244005248,
-0.2859606743,
0.2422603965,
1.0986648798,
0.6475279331,
-0.5441544056,
0.0704549402,
-0.1035623997,
-0.2092609853,
0.0102794664,
-0.1310774982,
0.3547836542,
-0.392634511,
-0.9488627315,
0.550850749,
0.2588949502,
-0.2468429953,
-0.134293288,
-0.2821931243,
0.0571385287,
-0.0041049747,
0.5695179701,
0.3253825903,
-0.5978867412,
-0.072777532,
-0.252712667,
-0.2844829857,
-0.0085280361,
0.5322594643,
-1.0753778219,
0.3504781723,
0.5676370859,
1.0615222454,
0.8739249706,
-0.0851630792,
0.2524039745,
-0.8734185696,
0.4960286319,
0.2146930546,
0.3209924698,
0.135702908,
-0.3616536856,
0.6575367451,
0.2263013721,
-0.7796689868,
-0.9803325534,
0.1990888417,
-1.0772339106,
0.0193795785,
1.0510776043,
-0.1306376159,
-0.4176448584,
0.3468512595,
-0.0927057266,
0.434851259,
-0.1764581054,
0.7226892114,
0.1911127269,
-0.0441183671,
-0.1432107389,
-0.5368432403,
0.5736548901,
0.6180618405,
-0.5198310018,
0.1666903049,
0.2067412883,
0.3177970052,
-0.048663646,
0.5819576979,
-0.0264617056,
0.2652981281,
-0.1310110688,
0.0569578558,
-0.2665096819,
-0.2500101328,
-0.1430193037,
-0.0437464118,
0.234868899,
0.1506694406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11346v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11346v3
|
CantonMT: Cantonese to English NMT Platform with Fine-Tuned Models Using Synthetic Back-Translation Data
| 2024-03-17T21:16:17 | 2024-06-09T22:10:04 |
Kung Yin Hong, Lifeng Han, Riza Batista-Navarro, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) for low-resource languages is still a
challenging task in front of NLP researchers. In this work, we deploy a
standard data augmentation methodology by back-translation to a new language
translation direction Cantonese-to-English. We present the models we fine-tuned
using the limited amount of real data and the synthetic data we generated using
back-translation including OpusMT, NLLB, and mBART. We carried out automatic
evaluation using a range of different metrics including lexical-based and
embedding-based. Furthermore. we create a user-friendly interface for the
models we included in this\textsc{ CantonMT} research project and make it
available to facilitate Cantonese-to-English MT research. Researchers can add
more models into this platform via our open-source\textsc{ CantonMT} toolkit
\url{https://github.com/kenrickkung/CantoneseTranslation}.
|
[
-0.15679878,
-0.7219241261,
0.3648690879,
0.3645887673,
-0.5654190779,
0.0618564002,
-0.2479845732,
-0.2345764786,
0.3776176274,
0.7878060341,
-0.3158977032,
-0.4389276206,
-0.4315582514,
0.3240102232,
-0.1980392337,
0.6407642365,
-0.1591102034,
0.4488698542,
0.2394354939,
-0.078527011,
-0.5121112466,
-0.6277039647,
-0.8383761644,
-0.5296940804,
0.2707510591,
0.4039672315,
0.7672409415,
0.7301603556,
0.4813368618,
0.2204815447,
-0.061411418,
0.3589014411,
-0.2617953122,
-0.2167790681,
-0.2682092786,
-0.2608081698,
-0.9196857214,
-0.0722815394,
0.5726222992,
0.6743033528,
-0.0464617126,
0.0548800044,
0.0000381717,
0.6124702692,
0.0357811339,
0.1142584309,
-0.6307518482,
0.2263558507,
0.0933859125,
-0.5968647599,
-0.4795011282,
-0.3307455182,
-0.0551040806,
-0.44577232,
-0.0611262694,
0.1353548914,
0.8286643028,
0.2350592464,
-0.7603032589,
0.0260185301,
-0.6571550965,
0.8660775423,
-0.9890597463,
0.5116842389,
0.3575990796,
0.5374506116,
0.0077052312,
-0.8378807306,
-0.1597099602,
-0.6521992683,
-0.0452046655,
0.4914860129,
0.2701490819,
-0.0527886488,
-0.0568460487,
0.5188970566,
-0.5963525176,
0.0662020743,
-0.3553723097,
-0.0342291854,
0.48319754,
0.4018153846,
0.3640419245,
-0.5420072675,
-0.6865609884,
-0.0832971632,
-0.6818990707,
-0.3908500075,
0.1638676226,
0.6144089103,
-0.2942554057,
0.9256246686,
-0.2692604661,
0.6223621368,
0.096404843,
0.5070099831,
0.325879544,
-0.6048207879,
-0.2547325194,
0.0873866007,
0.8050197363,
0.4614872336,
-0.0528677218,
-0.2072538435,
-0.5964511633,
-0.5758777261,
0.0997519642,
-0.9708964825,
-0.1777962893,
0.0304292571,
-0.5802076459,
-0.3339353204,
0.0466392376,
-0.3967233002,
-0.1054743677,
-0.5465185642,
0.4256696701,
-0.759726882,
-0.5373915434,
0.371496588,
-0.0110067958,
-0.0096424595,
0.3376446366,
-0.701382339,
0.1528146565,
0.7845240831,
1.2130602598,
-0.1442273408,
-0.32804811,
-0.3092783391,
0.1116221026,
-0.4382072091,
0.4856672883,
-0.0452723466,
-0.1964631975,
-0.2455877215,
0.2534296513,
-0.0606278516,
-0.6201858521,
0.463116765,
-0.4083303213,
0.2921266258,
-0.028654255,
-0.4144681394,
-0.3540922403,
0.6422765255,
-0.6940542459,
0.8984760046,
0.3714255393,
-0.5935750008,
-0.2257781625,
-0.7575774193,
-0.5612552762,
0.2629419863,
0.1507896334,
-0.0077512101,
0.262152344,
0.13853167,
0.4655592144,
-0.5953551531,
0.4644895792,
0.2522298396,
-0.3487811387,
0.3324316144,
-0.6442434192,
1.0793111324,
0.3124071658,
-0.0953131989,
0.1226961985,
-1.0392816067,
-0.0427800529,
0.0284391269,
-0.4338899553,
-0.3409243822,
-0.1409343481,
0.3499865532,
0.538443923,
0.573253274,
-0.4727987945,
0.0236197468,
-0.7789876461,
0.8610254526,
0.5331925154,
-0.1875003725,
0.4580742717,
-0.3711908758,
0.5922927856,
0.1235552877,
0.0204744041,
0.0081824055,
-0.4473257065,
-0.3524463475,
-0.0807542056,
0.5315701365,
0.7485281229,
-1.128174901,
0.4734532237,
-0.3800885379,
-0.4501830637,
-0.7479419708,
-0.1694781482,
0.0037119742,
0.7435585856,
0.6826161146,
-0.458306849,
-0.6482059956,
-0.8587662578,
0.2953784466,
-0.092171073,
-0.3660428822,
0.3598282337,
0.1718849987,
-0.6164527535,
0.7143277526,
-0.2028981,
-0.1959315836,
-0.24480322,
0.1944810301,
0.2043633014,
0.6878402233,
0.5496092439,
-0.7364403605,
-0.6392266154,
0.5197845101,
-0.6404018998,
-0.2180321813,
-0.2205404043,
-0.1909641623,
0.1623303741,
0.5971782207,
-0.3836301565,
-0.0333676338,
0.8647022247,
0.0032986982,
0.6442691684,
-0.1893440783,
0.2064236999,
-1.7100185156,
0.1104632765,
-0.2900331616,
-0.3416872323,
-0.4938712716,
0.3800851405,
0.2399031222,
-0.1308351159,
-0.6479116678,
0.6665390134,
-0.2133872509,
0.1111413687,
-0.3473783135,
0.1106312275,
0.0319195502,
0.3566234112,
0.1255826205,
0.8073290586,
0.2413699925,
-0.3808541298,
0.5815666914,
0.211134702,
0.0034815038,
0.2501175106,
-0.7901645899,
0.1389343143,
0.5653586984,
0.0267939698,
-0.7900903225,
-0.0529224128,
0.4760309458,
-0.6303203702,
0.023771707,
-0.4017210305,
-0.6226073503,
0.1005055681,
-0.2861104012,
0.4504206181,
0.4977863729,
-0.6394782662,
0.6758514047,
0.003456322,
-0.1467819959,
-0.2156314403,
-0.8909623623,
0.5510755181,
-0.1028133482,
-0.7857587934,
0.4607867002,
-0.0726078674,
0.0362117253,
0.017789619,
0.3638332784,
-0.4382708371,
0.019031262,
-0.0457108542,
0.2158762962,
-0.6779444814,
-0.0802525133,
0.1639283001,
-0.2169656456,
0.0843667388,
-0.444621563,
0.832361877,
-0.1276018023,
-0.0177407097,
-0.2978981733,
0.2882935107,
0.3783228993,
-0.2394161373,
0.7822520137,
0.9113631845,
-0.346953392,
-0.04243901,
-0.1416321844,
-0.3872272968,
-0.4992426336,
0.5539707541,
-0.4937797785,
-0.8096083999,
0.5806819201,
-0.1691756546,
-0.0569231585,
0.3680558205,
0.6582117677,
0.3193208277,
1.3587752581,
0.5413929224,
0.1378712058,
0.2688661814,
-0.1072540507,
0.1596363038,
-1.1307250261,
0.2049646527,
-0.2088986188,
-0.110294804,
-0.8036549687,
-0.3253785074,
-0.0168446396,
0.0402068794,
-0.1261844933,
0.7195237875,
-0.5316480994,
0.0818696246,
0.5953321457,
0.198066622,
0.403539151,
-0.2171039134,
-0.1735347509,
-0.2652893066,
-0.7090304494,
-0.3908108473,
0.8701817989,
0.2598639429,
0.4969210923,
0.1223715544,
0.6387910843,
-0.2158749253,
0.146524623,
-0.9373004436,
0.6401466131,
-0.4716157913,
-0.3218022883,
-0.067294836,
-0.8384979367,
-0.7819985151,
0.1479642093,
-0.0411390103,
0.0165929496,
-0.1306132376,
0.0363545902,
-0.2753258348,
0.2475307584,
-0.6753473878,
0.7997661233,
-0.5222252607,
-0.2422589809,
-0.0761544779,
-0.5912348032,
0.5019444823,
-0.2761017382,
-0.2018416524,
-0.0070548547,
-0.0455355197,
0.3470835388,
-0.3840403557,
0.7610524297,
0.0128012523,
-0.2196163833,
-0.0822367221,
0.1467549652,
0.3359047174,
0.2503345311,
-0.3387387991,
0.4960846305,
0.0096895723,
-0.3439531028,
-0.4530479908,
0.558170259,
-0.5165173411,
-0.3551317155,
-0.2317458838,
-0.9501594901,
-0.0213727262,
0.4546666145,
0.3573406935,
0.2768074572,
-0.1237684563,
0.3650632203,
0.097459361,
-0.6081966162,
-0.0827420577,
0.7143253088,
-0.4537473917,
-0.5112096071,
0.9285712838,
0.2270062119,
0.3880341053,
0.5207545161,
0.4577042758,
-0.2776188254,
-0.7616437078,
-0.5738571882,
0.127926141,
-0.2658013999,
-0.1554111689,
-0.4342316091,
-0.5958189964,
-0.6539281011,
-0.1021481305,
-0.6495423913,
-0.7798442841,
-0.2393452078,
-0.0272927005,
0.2607083917,
0.3720452189,
-0.3507075906,
0.5726719499,
-1.0557140112,
0.3118385077,
-0.065475896,
0.1476935148,
-0.0770551562,
-0.8507882953,
-0.6984625459,
0.4420709312,
-0.1128806323,
-0.4691385627,
1.0824073553,
-0.1057830527,
-0.0102448175,
0.0423873402,
0.0308499224,
0.5915153623,
-0.8307466507,
0.7460372448,
0.0323863551,
-0.6802585125,
0.3902636468,
-0.4770318568,
0.2046658993,
0.4050050974,
0.120411925,
-0.7758789659,
-0.2320276797,
-0.4278588593,
-1.0838245153,
0.5112125874,
0.0523120649,
0.2149867862,
-0.0077808602,
0.3311963379,
0.0522234179,
0.2746269405,
-0.610302031,
0.0786931291,
-0.4633551836,
-0.2977395356,
-0.0537022501,
-0.0785388798,
0.0283711329,
-0.338981986,
0.8123596311,
-0.1160858274,
0.1132481918,
0.0146776419,
-0.0912734568,
-0.0214190446,
0.0886748284,
0.6522321105,
0.5104249716,
-0.6321578622,
0.0865790248,
-0.0310138948,
-0.4993809462,
-0.0956341848,
0.3569155633,
-0.4764224291,
0.2193496674,
0.0828954354,
0.6261585951,
0.1693117917,
-0.4744838774,
0.21388942,
-0.1038754433,
-0.1313126534,
-0.3979596198,
-0.2327648252,
0.1512171775,
0.1292842776,
0.1337596923,
0.2329652458,
0.1788451076,
-0.3700558841,
0.3563014567,
0.1770864278,
-0.4697026312,
-0.6525626183,
0.7571058273,
0.329565227,
-0.4125704169,
0.6915445924,
-0.2324496061,
-0.5866347551,
0.5479767323,
0.7010395527,
1.0683233738,
-0.3638803661,
0.2413330823,
0.4600206614,
0.714761436,
-0.2844727039,
0.0704460815,
0.4377185106,
-0.8391524553,
-0.7947597504,
-0.3344940245,
-0.5377110243,
0.2814157903,
-0.7473829389,
0.3199653029,
-0.3706761897,
-0.0090363426,
-0.4331427515,
-0.0229848828,
-0.1488905847,
0.0013254537,
-0.3794337809,
0.9566207528,
-0.6112115979,
1.1825580597,
0.7112824321,
-0.4487277269,
-0.9132105708,
-0.2078613788,
-0.2540423274,
-1.0128697157,
0.6226447821,
0.0507909842,
-0.1187945008,
0.4148823619,
-0.3087095022,
-0.4915242195,
1.0253740549,
0.5359330177,
-0.4125342965,
0.0377445593,
0.5473837852,
0.6422053576,
-0.2160535008,
0.0246147364,
0.3993125558,
0.5047681928,
-0.0014249446,
-0.7207434177,
-0.0463013947,
-0.2514779866,
0.0181095842,
0.0649080276,
-0.4550309777,
1.1647707224,
0.3321508765,
-0.0892692804,
0.2821082175,
0.4338488877,
0.1140083,
0.2601299882,
0.1626771092,
0.4416012466,
0.2413906455,
0.00654301,
0.8576138616,
-0.5480296016,
0.3648926318,
1.2378487587,
-0.3345439434,
0.881746769,
0.570664227,
0.2544369698,
-0.0898058265,
0.6195296645,
-0.1072005332,
0.5050117373,
-0.1001788154,
0.0546676219,
-0.0042744069,
-0.2704597116,
-0.3731558919,
0.2861527503,
0.2384832054,
-0.2538590431,
-0.1138826832,
0.0291200131,
-0.1819911599,
0.1145038083,
-0.2267321199,
0.4442550242,
0.4059605598,
-0.2667210102,
0.854095459,
0.4686516523,
0.9708587527,
-0.4761051834,
-0.1326976418,
-0.4589079916,
0.1303971559,
-0.1501673311,
-0.6119049788,
0.5226967335,
-0.1521738172,
0.0065473523,
-0.3241603971,
0.5772867799,
-0.7951063514,
-0.5389223099,
0.3751938343,
0.70624578,
0.0866449252,
-0.2182697654,
-0.8542013168,
-0.4184586704,
0.1726244539,
-0.1668649167,
0.2911461294,
0.7138020396,
0.0347091667,
0.4266854227,
0.6672256589,
0.5268843174,
0.0721344426,
0.2499458045,
0.4708328247,
-0.7563476562,
-0.399265945,
-0.8220399022,
0.291675508,
0.1028457209,
-0.1924055964,
0.9600306749,
0.7995501161,
0.9243935347,
-0.2222555727,
0.6050186157,
0.0836994946,
0.6930368543,
-0.8174126148,
0.8663137555,
-0.6626318693,
0.2286551893,
0.0193028748,
-0.8544595838,
-0.3828645051,
0.5333912373,
0.0140203452,
-0.1780646443,
0.6497214437,
0.9231395721,
-0.3766028583,
-0.1617179066,
0.4772610664,
0.4530141652,
0.3149193227,
0.7184079885,
0.8413624763,
-0.6847547293,
0.3586042225,
-0.6084292531,
0.0443909205,
-0.3970789909,
-0.8556745648,
-0.7529714704,
-0.5818688869,
-0.1265971959,
-0.2648005486,
-0.1126587689,
1.1090509892,
0.4747852981,
-0.6730912924,
-0.4755182564,
-0.0964115262,
-0.1692832261,
-0.4492735565,
-0.2595642805,
0.4749854803,
-0.1464585513,
-0.9233902693,
0.7348223329,
0.2674158812,
0.2349594533,
-0.1036537811,
-0.3201124072,
-0.1685379595,
-0.0275867991,
0.8944645524,
0.0534880608,
-0.358802259,
-0.2700355351,
0.2627227604,
-0.2812838256,
0.315820992,
0.5098295212,
-0.467436105,
0.2008757144,
0.5374770761,
0.9712309241,
0.1729132682,
0.1464781612,
0.8408446312,
-1.0473519564,
0.3468140662,
0.4069744945,
0.2920095623,
0.5722292066,
-0.2634522319,
0.8565680981,
0.185045734,
-0.4193078876,
-0.9967695475,
0.1426923722,
-1.102542758,
-0.2024700344,
1.1111850739,
0.1229978651,
-0.1926012188,
-0.0269688126,
-0.3667651415,
0.3802111745,
-0.215768829,
0.8469318151,
0.5966382623,
0.2013754249,
-0.2316739708,
-0.9472924471,
0.1798807383,
0.5846527815,
-0.6243286133,
0.0253883135,
0.3104068339,
0.0109875649,
0.0773667023,
0.3793623745,
-0.1799637973,
0.1362364292,
-0.3893712163,
-0.0054333876,
-0.4790008366,
-0.0166004244,
-0.4646460414,
-0.203145206,
-0.0388922803,
-0.197669223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11335v1
|
ConvSDG: Session Data Generation for Conversational Search
| 2024-03-17T20:34:40 | 2024-03-17T20:34:40 |
Fengran Mo, Bole Yi, Kelong Mao, Chen Qu, Kaiyu Huang, Jian-Yun Nie
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Conversational search provides a more convenient interface for users to
search by allowing multi-turn interaction with the search engine. However, the
effectiveness of the conversational dense retrieval methods is limited by the
scarcity of training data required for their fine-tuning. Thus, generating more
training conversational sessions with relevant labels could potentially improve
search performance. Based on the promising capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) on text generation, we propose ConvSDG, a simple yet effective
framework to explore the feasibility of boosting conversational search by using
LLM for session data generation. Within this framework, we design
dialogue/session-level and query-level data generation with unsupervised and
semi-supervised learning, according to the availability of relevance judgments.
The generated data are used to fine-tune the conversational dense retriever.
Extensive experiments on four widely used datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness and broad applicability of our ConvSDG framework compared with
several strong baselines.
|
[
-0.4464547038,
-0.9629539847,
0.5849936008,
-0.217986092,
-0.3455372155,
0.0692803636,
-0.4579750001,
-0.0570861325,
0.1706197113,
0.572064817,
-0.7047178745,
-0.6781591773,
-0.0601086617,
-0.1824869365,
-0.4641266465,
0.6918728352,
0.5845507979,
0.0591292419,
-0.442396313,
0.0831532329,
-0.7430887818,
-0.5833113194,
-0.9248440266,
-0.1903482974,
0.2450796813,
0.8373684287,
0.7107987404,
0.4485236108,
0.411264509,
0.2169955373,
-0.0822760239,
0.5208441019,
-0.9908682108,
0.546259582,
-0.0350801833,
-0.454829067,
-0.0470621027,
-0.2592717111,
0.5158212185,
0.8223103285,
-0.6210839152,
-0.2323560268,
0.043572031,
0.6451567411,
-0.2977047861,
0.0877343118,
-1.0951385498,
-0.0461728536,
-0.2485872358,
-0.4890861809,
-0.4397478104,
-0.1895389706,
0.4095801711,
-0.4934796393,
0.7298778892,
0.2344352901,
0.5169728398,
0.113609314,
-0.6104252338,
-0.2423449755,
-0.6220698953,
0.6919779778,
-0.6685442328,
0.4188197553,
0.2074178606,
0.2947972715,
-0.5897681713,
-0.9064770937,
-0.4395248592,
-0.2802970409,
-0.1681395918,
-0.0420031957,
0.0003435656,
0.4222342968,
0.3609583378,
0.4069703817,
-0.7035525441,
0.1898175776,
-0.1848690212,
0.1528258622,
0.7765997052,
0.3111067414,
0.1838606298,
-0.1180007756,
-0.356362462,
-0.0924466401,
-0.874505043,
0.0629960299,
0.0422880389,
0.6477530599,
0.1155668795,
0.5121676326,
-0.50507617,
0.876439631,
0.3054694533,
-0.0597166382,
-0.0541013516,
-0.5058300495,
-0.0348602198,
0.2853143513,
0.7791267633,
0.7723754644,
0.0485329367,
-0.3535961509,
-0.2001135945,
-0.2346329391,
0.4316271544,
-1.128552556,
-0.1091695428,
-0.0155001935,
-0.4122002721,
-0.3971543014,
0.0333690159,
-0.718693912,
-0.2756316364,
-0.5307312012,
-0.0551524311,
-0.2231544405,
0.0023927689,
0.2384364754,
-0.0214799941,
0.0764602423,
0.1715507805,
-1.0556393862,
0.2149188966,
0.4420524538,
0.6679132581,
-0.5874411464,
0.3955135047,
-0.8770458698,
0.131763503,
-0.2202933431,
0.5495743155,
-0.8896712661,
-0.7587485909,
0.3723855317,
0.0024122512,
0.1283021867,
-0.698245585,
0.3787733316,
-0.6185944676,
0.2453784645,
-0.253228724,
-0.7469753623,
-0.0321750008,
0.245955959,
-0.4191647768,
1.2000124454,
0.0111103924,
-0.489254117,
0.5451088548,
-0.3341205418,
-0.4821066558,
0.6146705151,
-0.5785425305,
-0.6193248034,
0.1475310624,
0.304394871,
0.7214984894,
-0.5369822383,
0.844548583,
-0.3990402818,
-0.4427535236,
0.3142101169,
-0.2268418223,
0.1502413303,
0.2181111872,
-0.1464060992,
-0.1104537696,
-0.8226110339,
0.1184189543,
-0.0289794821,
-0.5523406267,
-0.3940035999,
0.2717541754,
0.1347044408,
-0.060317412,
0.1671087146,
-0.5298244953,
0.2603731155,
-0.4219828844,
0.3921453059,
0.3792062104,
0.4087671936,
0.3979340196,
-0.1294190139,
0.5111906528,
-0.0422281474,
-0.1880693585,
-0.3395379186,
-0.1119432375,
-0.7112320662,
0.157001853,
0.2870236635,
0.1745999008,
-1.0522930622,
0.5131617785,
-0.2827005386,
-0.6119654179,
-0.088883996,
0.0719851777,
0.3967573345,
0.4352093339,
0.1146961972,
-0.3880546391,
-0.5974090695,
-0.7753998041,
-0.0001918933,
0.1480156928,
-0.134320572,
1.0207761526,
-0.0330436379,
-0.3247377276,
0.8900935054,
-0.7230772376,
-0.1860089451,
-0.1426511854,
-0.0103938356,
0.0373872593,
0.4830500484,
0.4999720454,
-0.9643045664,
-0.4728205204,
0.0072061704,
-0.6676881313,
0.0736991689,
-0.1296891868,
-0.1542241424,
-0.0456836559,
0.8441534042,
-0.5327137113,
0.1217682287,
0.3090229928,
0.071623832,
0.1036462337,
-0.3199791312,
0.0829550922,
-1.1601114273,
-0.0417949781,
0.2061009556,
-0.5008500814,
-0.611231029,
-0.1640254557,
-0.2416995168,
-0.5859816074,
-0.4342880249,
0.4555547833,
-0.1925120801,
0.1745811105,
-0.2361421734,
0.4423600733,
-0.2575309873,
0.4872114956,
0.1003216505,
0.8944647312,
0.7466945052,
-1.0300052166,
0.446290344,
0.3726891577,
-0.3532369137,
0.4424529672,
-0.7447655201,
0.2551705241,
-0.0377746522,
0.207300663,
-1.1492707729,
-0.3449227214,
-0.4581172764,
-0.2384632677,
0.4352214932,
-0.2027022839,
-0.4049313366,
-0.2575719655,
-0.1819353402,
0.4849695861,
0.2788563669,
-0.8859975934,
0.0043497621,
0.7242515683,
-0.1072826758,
-0.1374708265,
-0.2052901834,
0.1476765275,
-0.4144837558,
-0.6400074959,
0.577113986,
-0.0076675666,
0.0384092703,
-0.6165822148,
-0.0780949891,
0.2801123857,
0.0465328544,
0.0341036282,
-0.0430965684,
-0.1154482812,
0.450869292,
-0.0445071496,
-0.0234019142,
-0.1373613179,
-0.2858385742,
0.7936842442,
0.1053429171,
-0.2029065937,
-0.0487791859,
0.3194941878,
0.2891435325,
-0.1063104793,
0.3773435056,
0.3673751056,
-0.2847217023,
-0.3237651885,
-0.5098324418,
-0.4966321588,
-0.5263602734,
0.2510201931,
-0.1629588902,
-1.3354166746,
0.1537207961,
-0.3720750213,
-0.1869973391,
-0.0494182706,
0.6806917787,
-0.1758250296,
1.3742288351,
0.6910617352,
0.289596945,
0.7066440582,
-0.1171527728,
0.3701744378,
-0.4661765993,
-0.4566196799,
-0.4839973748,
-0.3029883206,
-1.2402923107,
-0.1656992137,
0.472928524,
-0.0173559394,
0.1017788202,
0.1385268569,
-0.7652254105,
0.3637856543,
0.6808837652,
0.3461746871,
0.132421419,
0.1810026765,
0.0510799773,
-0.3826473057,
-0.8063797951,
-0.4084039032,
1.0745892525,
-0.2029752284,
0.8521380424,
-0.1212988719,
0.46043396,
0.4370478094,
-0.2193412781,
-0.7053397894,
0.7056073546,
-0.2201658636,
-0.5742661953,
-0.2229115665,
-0.5525293946,
-1.3853282928,
0.0929552391,
-0.2289391309,
-0.6793415546,
0.1025400981,
0.0882043764,
-0.3030030429,
-0.1411896348,
-0.5954849124,
0.712721765,
-0.364269942,
-0.3947288394,
-0.3305803835,
-0.4751846492,
0.3378083706,
0.0472478867,
-0.266515702,
-0.0242409501,
0.2866406739,
0.7929680943,
-0.3883672059,
0.6043587327,
-0.2396899015,
0.1496098638,
0.4389986992,
0.1625536233,
0.6233019233,
0.5023691654,
0.1187414527,
-0.2447538972,
-0.0543968603,
-0.1502804905,
-0.5012334585,
0.8717315793,
-0.3546971977,
-0.5913975835,
-0.1312961727,
-0.4145086706,
-0.4509516656,
0.1945276409,
0.2044455558,
0.4669214487,
-0.4897139966,
0.8446481228,
1.0008356571,
-0.3245339692,
0.1779790372,
0.6891551614,
-0.3601048589,
-0.0387671366,
0.9664466381,
-0.1671214253,
0.0180025008,
0.5357505679,
0.0403063372,
-0.3540451229,
-0.5464682579,
-0.1194487885,
0.0056442814,
-0.2475522161,
-0.4585807323,
-0.5621510148,
-0.1687187552,
-0.198415935,
-0.1082348973,
-0.2743399143,
-0.1359099895,
-0.3986051083,
-0.2172771543,
0.4823850095,
0.3655081391,
0.2759252787,
0.8305623531,
-0.5842753053,
0.2441593111,
0.4203142226,
0.2471866459,
-0.3187015653,
-0.1868787706,
-0.3546453416,
0.3219893873,
-0.6159749031,
-0.3547346294,
0.4782822132,
0.1340738833,
0.4492243528,
0.5222867131,
0.0217980221,
0.5714932084,
-0.3113358319,
0.8887936473,
0.3267184794,
-0.4406132102,
0.772238493,
-0.6109335423,
-0.001278533,
0.6460036635,
0.1111326814,
-0.7144553065,
-0.1609274596,
-0.8941255212,
-0.946850419,
0.8953546286,
0.2605917156,
0.3065696657,
-0.16581662,
0.5741719007,
0.1460175067,
0.476590991,
-0.2901153564,
-0.1318593919,
0.2325699776,
0.0632424206,
-0.0407547019,
-0.2946124077,
0.0056372848,
-0.1507633924,
0.5651381016,
-0.3892505467,
0.1062079817,
-0.1316048503,
0.2668353915,
0.0041961758,
0.114195548,
0.2055007517,
0.5011191964,
-0.2782920003,
0.0389172286,
0.1279681772,
-0.1262672693,
-0.0063930843,
0.0959097221,
-0.3618940413,
0.0849603489,
-0.2834433317,
0.8759351969,
0.3286459148,
-0.9855598807,
0.5027522445,
-0.5351880789,
-0.0837278366,
-0.1179524809,
0.516669035,
0.0738718435,
0.0671794936,
0.285862267,
-0.2940210998,
0.3091848791,
-0.3949991465,
0.3790533245,
0.8756688237,
-0.3961777091,
0.0785006881,
0.7013424039,
0.3702204823,
-0.3957074881,
0.6915211678,
-0.1422878057,
-0.1278200448,
0.3350150287,
0.4336480498,
0.5954427123,
0.0196123384,
0.1341937482,
0.5196464658,
-0.213169679,
-0.2605542243,
0.1063596606,
-0.3894887865,
-0.5711591244,
-0.1762964875,
-0.5501898527,
-0.4824177027,
0.5429607034,
-0.6539714336,
0.5185905695,
-0.0566792525,
-0.2552272379,
-0.0427600481,
0.1977280974,
-0.8683340549,
0.3436420858,
0.1533540338,
0.5227701664,
-0.304580003,
0.5877510905,
0.47694695,
-0.2076948583,
-0.4511924088,
-0.1090792716,
-0.3451732397,
-0.7537901402,
0.1515164971,
0.2684133649,
-0.019148143,
-0.0169344302,
-0.973113656,
-0.7336544394,
1.1254858971,
0.470544517,
-0.9879671335,
-0.2008611411,
0.2175095826,
0.5841426253,
-0.4623283446,
0.0199692007,
0.7265524268,
0.0935558677,
0.2551075816,
-0.6699509621,
0.0467930026,
-0.0110646039,
0.5269008279,
0.0248100776,
-0.7375653982,
0.2951904237,
0.16855748,
-0.3329912722,
-0.1027799398,
0.6201578975,
0.3275279701,
0.3328438103,
0.2156817317,
0.495172739,
0.8877229095,
-0.2819118202,
0.903439343,
-0.3342659771,
0.3381308317,
0.9051039219,
-0.2183701694,
0.453127712,
0.3317415416,
0.0215392523,
-0.0439690314,
0.7883384824,
0.0169301797,
0.6738561392,
0.2830402553,
-0.3531151414,
-0.5984199047,
-0.3855678439,
-0.2278271317,
0.6026734114,
0.5133817196,
-0.3823598623,
-0.2898712754,
0.1275070012,
0.0177558064,
0.2042564005,
-0.0436744168,
1.0672515631,
0.0201348141,
-1.0166466236,
0.748762846,
0.1122200713,
0.690916419,
-0.3912564516,
-0.046871271,
-0.4370223284,
0.350530684,
-0.1501276195,
-0.703338623,
-0.1849661916,
-0.1377056986,
-0.025661312,
-0.3514847755,
0.8256233335,
-0.7354800701,
-0.3395438492,
0.0268082935,
0.6295612454,
0.2783721983,
-0.1324351132,
-0.5218942165,
-0.1603527665,
0.3264383972,
-0.1453987658,
0.4576463699,
0.6653878689,
0.0238709748,
0.586691916,
0.6229772568,
-0.1897197068,
-0.052837003,
0.1017374843,
0.9092250466,
-0.5288799405,
-0.2603993416,
-0.6492381096,
0.1170824021,
-0.1442352384,
-0.1994232088,
0.6438074112,
1.0110434294,
1.0015295744,
0.321167767,
0.9597850442,
-0.0053969519,
0.4875764251,
-0.6648253202,
0.4166288972,
-0.5359818935,
0.2541916668,
0.0291676838,
-0.8754741549,
-0.1040524095,
0.4153650701,
-0.0293156188,
0.1170122698,
0.3379732668,
1.1857566833,
-0.3044435084,
0.1135220602,
0.3089514077,
-0.0399091132,
0.8412476778,
0.5127977133,
0.5977070332,
-0.3307953477,
0.621573925,
0.0949370489,
0.0143890744,
-0.5869957209,
-0.5518320799,
-1.0615867376,
-0.7058967948,
-0.3116174042,
-0.389627248,
-0.0583905131,
0.7605069876,
0.8171238899,
-0.4891342819,
-0.181759879,
-0.4516389072,
-0.1252738386,
0.2091268748,
-0.232902348,
0.2297759056,
-0.5934661031,
-0.7009642124,
0.6324445009,
0.0891742706,
-0.0274472646,
-0.2345276624,
-0.1665348858,
-0.1644309014,
-0.0801623613,
0.5505299568,
0.1194562763,
-0.1718213409,
-0.1756462604,
0.031402003,
-0.2980691493,
0.2095605433,
1.0974932909,
-0.9620294571,
0.79797405,
0.2738465667,
0.6337518692,
1.218557477,
0.1594534516,
0.7613168359,
-1.2969332933,
0.044028759,
0.258613795,
0.1259638816,
0.5012360215,
-0.4423775971,
0.4376703799,
0.0516630821,
-0.6475685239,
-0.9038347006,
0.1157212332,
-1.0901483297,
-0.097831212,
1.4452437162,
0.4385948777,
0.205600366,
0.1146094054,
-0.5169412494,
0.2518345118,
-0.6972362995,
0.9681268334,
0.5408990979,
-0.2508310974,
-0.0042513865,
-0.5154007673,
0.8468348384,
0.2455930561,
-0.7553328872,
0.29577443,
0.6148639321,
0.0292222928,
-0.0765791461,
0.6489986777,
0.1186524853,
0.2310336083,
-0.2809178829,
-0.1530142576,
0.2230140418,
-0.0683083683,
0.0753056556,
0.1084664389,
0.0325493403,
-0.1356336921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11330v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11330v2
|
Improving Dialogue Agents by Decomposing One Global Explicit Annotation with Local Implicit Multimodal Feedback
| 2024-03-17T20:21:26 | 2024-04-23T03:17:07 |
Dong Won Lee, Hae Won Park, Yoon Kim, Cynthia Breazeal, Louis-Philippe Morency
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
We describe an approach for aligning an LLM-based dialogue agent based on
global (i.e., dialogue-level) rewards, while also taking into account
naturally-occurring multimodal signals. At a high level, our approach (dubbed
GELI) learns a local, turn-level reward model by decomposing the human-provided
Global Explicit (GE) session-level reward, using Local Implicit (LI) multimodal
reward signals to crossmodally shape the reward decomposition step. This
decomposed reward model is then used as part of the standard RHLF pipeline
improve an LLM-based dialog agent. We run quantitative and qualitative human
studies to evaluate the performance of our GELI approach, and find that it
shows consistent improvements across various conversational metrics compared to
baseline methods.
|
[
-0.3825119138,
-0.6902243495,
0.4607940316,
-0.1588829458,
0.09664689,
0.3796545565,
-0.2729911506,
-0.4807040989,
0.2491986156,
0.2780168056,
-0.8974483013,
-0.4923281372,
-0.315926671,
0.0885897949,
0.3112964034,
1.0118274689,
0.0459658243,
0.2613010406,
-0.2597100139,
-0.3538940251,
-0.5353188515,
-0.3826594353,
-0.895958364,
-0.4667056501,
0.9626139402,
0.5402947664,
0.6336773634,
0.164558664,
0.1824540943,
0.4123406112,
-0.0973635763,
0.4834082127,
-0.9269512892,
0.3591836989,
0.1656365842,
-0.5304091573,
-0.69921875,
0.0205203779,
0.6490501761,
0.4420989752,
-0.495706439,
-0.0937319547,
-0.0742861331,
0.3557851911,
-0.6295983791,
0.4749718606,
-0.3069852293,
0.1264580786,
0.4005842805,
-0.4652785063,
-0.578093946,
-0.393481791,
0.1014869064,
-0.6359578967,
0.1125643849,
-0.0610051267,
0.534909606,
0.1557549685,
-0.5350765586,
-0.1248760894,
-0.7307450175,
0.7879095674,
-0.7157000899,
0.0489046499,
0.0998075232,
0.3720917106,
-0.1443020552,
-0.256546706,
-0.3390373588,
-0.4681436718,
-0.2612147927,
0.2385823876,
0.0238556881,
0.3220044076,
0.1393327117,
0.3460389376,
-0.2553119063,
0.1215111092,
-0.2357141376,
-0.3933744133,
0.6212254167,
0.4270158112,
0.3968316913,
0.1877346337,
-0.5365890265,
-0.27664271,
-0.803606689,
0.4407016039,
0.3824679255,
0.4534787834,
-0.2020404041,
0.2538039386,
-0.2043854296,
0.4994657934,
0.0812258497,
-0.5571283698,
0.3777573705,
-0.6041009426,
0.0976740271,
0.2923382521,
0.4565025568,
0.6419062614,
0.1907104552,
-0.1968074292,
-0.3779948354,
-0.0848174393,
0.276943773,
-0.7531459332,
0.2260611504,
0.1648295522,
-0.382658422,
-0.3408023119,
-0.0400487743,
-0.4155417979,
-0.6429029107,
-0.3791650236,
0.4645288587,
-0.1788155138,
-0.3391678035,
-0.2204482853,
-0.105540432,
0.4023739994,
0.6243946552,
-1.0551716089,
0.2553046346,
0.6309715509,
0.7242560983,
0.0854049698,
-0.1803412139,
-0.8255034685,
0.304721266,
-0.2994937599,
0.9036098123,
-0.5735744238,
-0.504768312,
0.2233541459,
0.0562703311,
-0.2571952045,
-0.6378263831,
0.4244705141,
-0.1329915524,
0.4046534598,
-0.2869160175,
-0.3274647295,
-0.0634189919,
0.4056505263,
-0.651448369,
0.7537736893,
0.1437023282,
-0.6067489982,
0.2150665671,
-0.8921837807,
-0.1279862821,
-0.1342913657,
-0.0167508237,
-0.1109146997,
-0.0012260819,
0.5340465307,
0.1975647956,
-0.1053235233,
0.3385693729,
-0.1118452698,
-0.6414343715,
0.2783438563,
-0.5350721478,
0.3538097739,
0.0931980237,
-0.3248259723,
0.7335284352,
-0.546630621,
0.0032566679,
-0.189136371,
-0.3513777852,
0.1967761666,
-0.1386535615,
-0.0471849293,
-0.0144960647,
-0.0293582939,
-0.7222905755,
0.3711891472,
-0.5410901904,
0.3986978531,
1.0315647125,
0.0459425151,
0.6033586264,
-0.5247923136,
0.5856679082,
0.1087499708,
0.2913891077,
-0.4089597464,
-0.3697035909,
-0.9283990264,
-0.509875536,
0.1585914642,
0.58498317,
-0.7035419345,
-0.0083870841,
-0.4258219898,
-0.3992627561,
-0.7528271675,
0.1054662466,
0.4216543436,
0.376992017,
0.090644978,
-0.3498910367,
-0.0692085326,
-1.0555922985,
0.0589098297,
-0.2531071901,
-0.0855167061,
0.5341798663,
0.1156321391,
-0.3706522584,
0.7880196571,
-0.2154075503,
-0.2953442633,
-0.4455218017,
0.6234763861,
0.0759082586,
0.3518741429,
0.0309631396,
-0.5649868846,
-0.3757913709,
0.0965312645,
-0.5810275078,
-0.1033864841,
-0.1872674376,
-0.0248612184,
0.4530571699,
0.3692774475,
-0.7380047441,
0.398951292,
0.1729421616,
-0.3881936669,
0.2246863097,
-0.2739048898,
0.5980702043,
-0.7166939974,
-0.1397088468,
-0.0551023036,
-0.3782633841,
-0.6918759942,
-0.38238585,
-0.237391144,
-0.1914436221,
-0.5335221887,
0.6643565893,
-0.4996621907,
-0.0646298826,
-0.34207955,
0.2175272554,
-0.2270092815,
1.0281834602,
0.0353074856,
0.9120596647,
0.3470647633,
-0.3072149754,
0.6139228344,
0.1605689973,
-0.2179393023,
0.6094096899,
-0.6177592874,
0.2654917538,
-0.4045253694,
0.5432642698,
-1.2127487659,
-0.1815327108,
0.5908643603,
-0.3014397323,
0.3975240588,
-0.0296254549,
-0.1843791008,
0.177323848,
-0.5537717342,
0.4359287024,
0.2254103571,
-0.514336288,
0.8708366752,
0.2326174378,
-0.5321918726,
-0.7106234431,
-0.1819377691,
0.0809456035,
-0.1758577377,
-0.781537652,
0.3546386957,
-0.2457225919,
-0.2300017178,
-0.2662105262,
-0.1319041997,
0.2409639955,
-0.1104587317,
0.3574188352,
0.1845887899,
-0.1745534241,
0.1141441092,
-0.2155305147,
-0.4600757658,
0.0328292288,
0.2120521963,
0.4173868001,
-0.4457437396,
-0.4058299363,
-0.564389348,
0.5085920691,
0.4479845464,
-0.0820130855,
0.5617204309,
0.991907239,
0.022045996,
0.0263491105,
-0.6143003702,
-0.4001866579,
-0.4730035663,
0.1324059069,
-0.2765618861,
-1.0502374172,
0.4679733217,
-0.1325477213,
-0.0094174454,
-0.0314313062,
0.6192635894,
0.067121692,
1.2880680561,
0.5742021799,
-0.1901674569,
0.5691666007,
-0.3599737287,
0.2321677506,
-0.7375121713,
-0.5248629451,
-0.1618584394,
-0.4839678407,
-0.3093432784,
-0.3644332588,
0.3868255615,
-0.1312434077,
-0.2634952366,
-0.1504915804,
-0.2013732791,
0.3952158988,
0.7582900524,
0.3021039367,
0.1892041266,
0.0128206387,
0.053115841,
0.1442621648,
-0.7767221928,
-0.5408234596,
0.6747546792,
0.5098551512,
0.9140433073,
0.2213288099,
0.64421767,
0.4287591875,
0.5525186658,
-0.5620671511,
0.4811375141,
0.6060459018,
-0.2760579884,
-0.5622001886,
-0.4563641846,
-1.0786145926,
0.3621968329,
-0.2702699006,
-1.0510652065,
0.1645141542,
0.0675459877,
-0.3349559903,
0.0898691267,
-0.9911628366,
1.114585638,
-0.1299058199,
-0.3939720988,
-0.4678078294,
-0.7939208746,
0.2052614242,
0.5885891914,
0.2631061673,
-0.3742459714,
0.1134415492,
0.4230420887,
-0.4234205782,
1.1490550041,
-0.4693329036,
-0.5245615244,
0.3465387523,
-0.0523196608,
0.4628992081,
0.3133720756,
0.2613544464,
-0.0574208312,
-0.1175347194,
-0.5681881309,
-1.1177905798,
0.4907454252,
-0.7637748718,
-0.8943626881,
-0.1552484483,
-0.7935243845,
-0.3576964438,
-0.3806398511,
-0.1095934734,
0.8235020041,
-0.2818593979,
-0.2364231199,
0.6662852764,
-0.1898250878,
0.4259228408,
0.4937952161,
-0.0264451299,
-0.6725289822,
0.8948411942,
-0.4419583678,
0.4795594513,
0.6186475754,
-0.0197289344,
-0.378231138,
-0.0307337679,
-0.3135884106,
0.203936398,
-0.988764286,
-0.1921935976,
-0.111184448,
-0.0432469919,
-0.4646371603,
-0.0956505612,
-0.0780125558,
-0.2237604409,
0.0510777943,
-0.2347707748,
0.1574960053,
0.8606895208,
-0.1762863696,
0.3760810196,
-0.8031083941,
0.178776443,
0.5688118339,
0.1518705487,
0.052358184,
-0.305855602,
-0.3317261636,
0.372091651,
-0.1328303218,
-0.6911437511,
0.2917445004,
0.1543433964,
0.851770103,
0.3498679399,
-0.0701351985,
0.5914633274,
-0.2439895421,
0.7991621494,
0.3944928944,
-0.815538764,
0.5466496944,
-0.3629293442,
0.3747408092,
0.3571323156,
0.1116319001,
-0.6795497537,
-0.4136712849,
-0.345380187,
-0.7763277888,
0.9050734043,
0.060333956,
0.238650471,
0.1637020707,
0.2336561531,
0.0447121449,
0.1153391525,
-1.0413950682,
-0.2014417797,
-0.1008872688,
-0.2796925008,
-0.154968828,
-0.4422626495,
-0.6527824998,
-0.1189479306,
0.6897699833,
-0.4581274092,
0.5602234006,
0.319367677,
-0.3093460202,
-0.1311500371,
0.5682002306,
0.8719863296,
0.7002251744,
-0.3297905326,
0.0166903585,
0.2131517828,
0.0643720403,
0.3436039984,
-0.2102383077,
0.2256625295,
-0.1766474843,
0.4758758247,
1.1278847456,
0.3926578462,
-0.7906329036,
0.5237051845,
-0.3136130273,
-0.0218473934,
0.0221202206,
0.3114412427,
-0.0069378153,
0.6064270139,
0.2817759514,
-0.2432733476,
0.1188084334,
-0.7840787768,
-0.0051994072,
0.4689102173,
-0.5699192882,
-0.1035064608,
0.2795227468,
0.5806360841,
-0.5084860921,
0.6726868153,
-0.0457447693,
-0.5077345967,
0.3521031737,
0.4454988837,
0.7473031282,
-0.0610643551,
0.6494652033,
0.2984051406,
0.0328092277,
0.2264953703,
0.0643129274,
-0.5362601876,
-0.8365347385,
-0.5231381655,
-0.1538295001,
-0.5367947221,
-0.2333368957,
-0.4265149236,
-0.0449782833,
-0.0692142546,
-0.1086960137,
-0.0333153382,
-0.1482650042,
-0.4872171283,
-0.0713228881,
0.5197917223,
0.4169051945,
-0.5905649066,
0.6475848556,
0.5554801822,
-0.6479438543,
-0.723847568,
-0.194925338,
-0.0114040226,
-0.9353471398,
0.8966677785,
0.4638963938,
-0.4678633511,
-0.1491737217,
-0.5877209306,
-0.7939579487,
1.2040157318,
0.4535685778,
-0.2966648638,
-0.0541704074,
0.229140237,
0.4912405014,
-0.636828661,
0.8652275205,
0.3091295958,
0.5250689387,
0.1171984076,
-1.040953517,
0.0487490781,
-0.5522225499,
0.1773193181,
0.1602330357,
-0.6303854585,
0.3135813475,
-0.3014071882,
-0.3837718964,
0.1851360798,
0.5820601583,
0.0828472227,
0.2964600325,
0.8051886559,
0.4119123816,
0.6995832324,
-0.1263911724,
0.9616144896,
-0.2493355572,
0.186657846,
0.9268621206,
-0.280903548,
0.5604184866,
0.4184886813,
0.1860376596,
0.8145498037,
0.586405158,
0.2045670748,
0.5575429201,
0.2153771222,
-0.5700467825,
-0.4703062475,
-0.3489297926,
-0.1490106881,
0.2295756936,
0.1994979233,
0.0982980654,
-0.3201614022,
0.1047510654,
-0.2114115357,
-0.077036716,
-0.3406420946,
1.0244518518,
-0.1238522977,
-0.9964247346,
0.7833571434,
-0.0859649628,
0.4898115993,
-0.5442355275,
-0.3312245011,
-0.5562300682,
0.0933957398,
-0.1749484241,
-0.4054024518,
-0.1666598469,
-0.3433364034,
-0.0393794626,
-0.3694004118,
0.7364299893,
-0.8268293738,
-0.1871404052,
0.2987045348,
0.4336795509,
0.0583124012,
0.2256806046,
-0.5921543241,
0.0249188263,
-0.0263593774,
-0.2653306723,
0.2401233912,
0.2412860096,
0.0863702372,
1.0221740007,
0.486446172,
-0.2991361022,
-0.1380601227,
0.6101238728,
0.7805258632,
-0.8711231351,
-0.2397240996,
-0.5867279172,
0.811961472,
-0.1496830583,
-0.2022520155,
0.5196906924,
0.334794879,
0.6500797868,
0.0119470973,
0.3828599453,
0.3543672264,
0.3159524202,
-0.6834079027,
0.2015429735,
-0.4124618471,
0.3580290377,
-0.1645939648,
-0.9336990714,
0.0837867931,
0.6249611974,
0.0390165225,
0.1542537063,
0.578807354,
1.1823642254,
0.2709858418,
0.0993258655,
0.3102712035,
0.0497216843,
0.2644088566,
0.6176285744,
1.4109407663,
-0.0602375232,
0.578620851,
-0.0490196422,
-0.1587669402,
0.0486346036,
-0.6443584561,
-0.8188269138,
-0.3632294834,
-0.4350040555,
-0.1572726816,
0.1581189483,
0.9444768429,
0.8198863864,
-0.7074734569,
-0.4728924036,
0.2017154396,
0.3448088169,
-0.1915251315,
-0.2418863624,
0.0365008749,
-0.8464064598,
-0.8280326724,
0.7014423013,
0.4730675519,
-0.0889772847,
-0.4257858694,
-0.4999085367,
-0.1214862242,
0.0673568919,
0.5396660566,
0.0272820108,
-0.9321787357,
-0.5133857131,
-0.1417056769,
-0.0411607884,
0.4530822933,
1.06039536,
-0.8455860019,
0.4115756452,
0.2462202162,
0.3807519376,
0.6504345536,
0.21323663,
1.0416561365,
-0.8379749656,
0.196988523,
0.0072837826,
0.3760369718,
0.4590687454,
-0.2748147249,
0.6735290289,
0.1622523367,
-0.5696443319,
-0.7857193351,
0.3012787998,
-1.0150061846,
-0.2228388488,
1.0928356647,
-0.2085034847,
-0.2379202098,
0.1085160524,
-0.689469099,
0.1521341056,
-0.6753972769,
0.7616416812,
0.5775826573,
-0.2605044842,
-0.3255203068,
-0.065469712,
0.498093605,
0.5404338837,
-0.7751657367,
0.1018803194,
0.6993377805,
0.076865688,
0.2693444788,
0.9952500463,
0.0030737109,
0.2159179747,
-0.001149068,
0.215655908,
-0.0041683801,
-0.4275252223,
-0.4548403621,
0.0798811167,
0.2244983166,
-0.0123413159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11322v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11322v3
|
StateFlow: Enhancing LLM Task-Solving through State-Driven Workflows
| 2024-03-17T19:54:16 | 2024-04-10T23:04:48 |
Yiran Wu, Tianwei Yue, Shaokun Zhang, Chi Wang, Qingyun Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
It is a notable trend to use Large Language Models (LLMs) to tackle complex
tasks, e.g., tasks that require a sequence of actions and dynamic interaction
with tools and external environments. In this paper, we propose StateFlow, a
novel LLM-based task-solving paradigm that conceptualizes complex task-solving
processes as state machines. In StateFlow, we distinguish between "process
grounding" (via state and state transitions) and "sub-task solving" (through
actions within a state), enhancing control and interpretability of the
task-solving procedure. A state represents the status of a running process. The
transitions between states are controlled by heuristic rules or decisions made
by the LLM, allowing for a dynamic and adaptive progression. Upon entering a
state, a series of actions is executed, involving not only calling LLMs guided
by different prompts, but also the utilization of external tools as needed. Our
results show that StateFlow significantly enhances LLMs' efficiency. For
instance, StateFlow achieves 13% and 28% higher success rates compared to ReAct
in InterCode SQL and ALFWorld benchmark, with 5x and 3x less cost respectively.
We also show that StateFlow can be combined with iterative refining methods
like Reflexion to further improve performance.
|
[
0.0693039522,
-0.6666561365,
0.8098549843,
0.1545658857,
-0.1504297704,
0.4340502918,
-0.1235371754,
-0.2246922255,
0.1751865894,
0.4076755941,
-0.8146612048,
-0.1870405972,
-0.5754440427,
0.0931186974,
-0.4278777242,
0.5589382052,
-0.5470425487,
-0.0860533491,
-0.4120518565,
0.1940786093,
-0.5240914226,
-0.4261168838,
-0.56439358,
-0.8280370235,
0.3466562033,
0.277055949,
0.2894685864,
0.4198972881,
0.5432278514,
0.3168385029,
-0.2596827447,
0.2378412485,
-0.6488726735,
0.7328194976,
-0.471288383,
-0.8325545192,
-0.3222472668,
-0.4919524789,
0.2900125086,
0.4405143261,
-0.4776429832,
0.1431125849,
0.1512861103,
0.8673591018,
-0.7496891022,
0.5761740208,
-0.5031155348,
0.220046103,
-0.3237039149,
-0.2775978446,
-0.2210199684,
-0.0396694392,
-0.3018254638,
-0.5646775961,
-0.2442922145,
-0.027841568,
0.3633540273,
0.7519301176,
0.0077596731,
-0.0816937238,
-1.1079548597,
0.3110978603,
-0.7149031758,
0.2565941513,
-0.285702765,
0.1120516136,
-0.5644442439,
-0.685720861,
-0.6305190325,
0.0957236066,
0.2705400884,
0.1777326912,
-0.3711603284,
0.173531726,
0.530827105,
0.4997358322,
-0.232944116,
0.0708990321,
-0.1412162036,
-0.2806555331,
0.2576315403,
0.6849077344,
0.2210137099,
0.2785190344,
-0.2793915868,
0.3050934374,
-0.6593040824,
0.3763500452,
-0.1880409271,
0.5639197826,
0.2201656848,
0.7496119142,
-0.5740596652,
0.6752625108,
-0.0564212948,
-0.4528034329,
0.0925850272,
-0.0720383301,
-0.4233767986,
-0.118535459,
0.3760040998,
-0.0108217979,
-0.0862621367,
-0.2105666399,
-0.5764895678,
0.1543459296,
0.3516257703,
-0.8770422339,
0.2749741375,
0.3964588344,
-0.2293412834,
-0.179332912,
-0.2535493672,
0.0340041295,
-0.683604002,
-0.600045085,
0.6368845701,
-0.1726851016,
-0.4239741564,
-0.0997477695,
0.0039595529,
0.1015487686,
0.6409518719,
-0.2873657346,
0.4268395901,
1.1694134474,
1.0611945391,
-0.7218200564,
-0.0257910024,
-0.7090456486,
0.0052709952,
-0.5806789398,
0.591452837,
-0.6000646949,
-0.2821691334,
0.1662748307,
0.0289088003,
0.013835662,
-0.9414117932,
0.1987677962,
-0.7304326296,
-0.4041687846,
-0.3648163676,
-0.6966480613,
-0.1673495322,
0.3666771054,
-0.7480700016,
1.2080390453,
-0.1290163398,
-0.3363015056,
0.2393429875,
-0.9645777941,
-0.5512759686,
0.318986237,
-0.0103291078,
0.0174891073,
0.2831831276,
-0.2606939077,
0.7474027872,
-0.4038433433,
0.3182343841,
-0.0984134302,
-0.4418825805,
-0.0939298049,
0.1913672537,
0.3356012702,
0.3785305321,
-0.478187412,
0.4821504653,
-0.4387863576,
-0.1467335969,
0.0759670287,
-0.4489685297,
0.0384092852,
0.105717957,
-0.3186891079,
0.4488662183,
0.4435354769,
-0.6720921993,
0.0609693974,
-0.2875790894,
0.593716681,
0.5776597261,
-0.0527822375,
0.4610233009,
-0.4089179337,
0.7518486381,
0.4608007073,
-0.1263860762,
-0.3572144508,
-0.2659257948,
-0.7329584956,
-0.3297236264,
-0.2584667504,
0.9504312277,
-0.9487444758,
0.049617175,
-0.1079624295,
-0.5848236084,
-0.3740642369,
0.2342015058,
0.2302182764,
0.754209578,
0.3143659234,
-0.1189394221,
-0.2607727647,
-0.7594023347,
-0.3162381053,
0.0990777388,
0.4296888113,
0.0368187912,
0.6218844652,
-0.0155403418,
0.8986529112,
-0.6319131255,
-0.463124603,
-0.3732905388,
0.0510125011,
0.515709579,
0.3135360777,
-0.3541705012,
-0.5990386605,
-0.3052180409,
-0.1288648397,
-0.6388640404,
-0.0658959001,
-0.0301537942,
-0.099210754,
0.5438343287,
0.6350641847,
-0.6499066949,
0.366204679,
0.3998480141,
-0.2652597725,
0.5141004324,
-0.2456053048,
-0.0527647845,
-0.9762084484,
0.136772573,
0.0792131945,
-0.3535686731,
-0.6187027097,
0.3491211534,
-0.0056106271,
-0.5957934856,
-0.646641016,
0.3864502609,
-0.5436115861,
-0.1060549244,
-0.6375079751,
-0.1281382889,
-0.2508668602,
0.6037518382,
0.1542163193,
0.9202954769,
0.8262584805,
-0.4175280333,
0.5898483396,
-0.3042500317,
-0.2680192888,
0.6242361069,
-0.4146455526,
0.1626549661,
-0.1013338491,
0.3437952697,
-0.8385475278,
0.1476937234,
0.055732999,
0.1315033734,
0.1346443444,
-0.0580824651,
-0.7965992093,
-0.3560948074,
0.0781871527,
0.0270379931,
0.5839248896,
-0.2548392117,
0.890601337,
0.2714706659,
-0.0891536996,
-0.4777106047,
-0.4898384213,
0.2116763592,
0.0947377682,
-0.3829512,
0.4478072822,
0.0065985424,
-0.177880913,
0.1398403645,
-0.6963239312,
-0.1494634002,
0.2701085806,
0.4327602684,
0.0412790813,
0.0585536137,
0.017605599,
0.1297437251,
-0.0705979839,
0.1721340418,
-0.4954020083,
0.568862021,
-0.0280536711,
-0.3537208438,
-0.7235110998,
0.4021571279,
0.8628538847,
-0.4501484931,
0.6494973302,
0.1843177229,
-0.7309992909,
-0.4609309733,
-0.2861292958,
-0.2887185514,
-0.4718144238,
0.2474650294,
-0.6682777405,
-1.0607322454,
0.4552563429,
-0.6522196531,
0.3624560535,
-0.126134932,
0.9135977626,
-0.3083512485,
0.6123078465,
0.6961011887,
-0.111783579,
0.399684608,
-0.2025092393,
0.2471496463,
-0.6046575904,
-0.4055295885,
-0.2655025721,
-0.5847560167,
-0.3113016188,
-0.982978344,
0.3912698925,
0.0541915223,
-0.1005766913,
0.2735342979,
-0.3204646111,
0.3164498806,
0.3633238971,
0.0766497776,
0.4308458865,
-0.2379404008,
-0.1926914155,
0.0402349085,
-0.7902783155,
-0.3017644286,
0.5997526646,
0.1616643965,
0.9215353727,
-0.0335228853,
0.9019473195,
0.5484582186,
0.280955106,
-0.9859889746,
0.8339690566,
-0.0599153042,
-0.5172719955,
-0.4100073576,
-0.1582411379,
-0.8334794641,
0.3934266269,
-0.3545544147,
-0.6069760323,
-0.2598706484,
0.404982239,
-0.1598106474,
0.4308680296,
-0.1671112031,
0.6460874677,
0.0726628825,
-0.3915417492,
-0.6653492451,
-0.1182996556,
-0.0060145776,
0.0711897388,
0.1842411011,
-0.4033007026,
-0.3444385529,
0.5400722027,
-0.8193599582,
0.7361673117,
-0.4163212776,
-0.5911486149,
0.1658083349,
0.3851363957,
0.8491122723,
-0.4883975685,
0.0014678919,
-0.1321108192,
-0.0849621221,
-0.2075776756,
-0.7810838223,
0.8179664612,
-0.1647907197,
-0.8666422963,
-0.3457017243,
-0.8069704771,
-0.205512166,
0.4214139879,
-0.2828590274,
0.5992466211,
0.185532406,
-0.1545669734,
0.7923467755,
0.3104958236,
0.5651542544,
0.5325189233,
-0.2621102631,
0.1339179724,
0.8112750649,
0.104075253,
0.133970201,
0.6295826435,
0.1116442829,
-0.3345158398,
-0.530348897,
-0.2274280488,
0.1478803903,
-0.8178142905,
-0.1486050636,
-0.281531781,
0.103274174,
0.0145148076,
0.0435414761,
-0.3427625,
-0.2896410525,
-0.2668506205,
0.1286161393,
0.22181651,
0.5160573125,
0.1839057207,
-0.0526554286,
-0.5321833491,
0.3734753132,
0.1134589389,
0.3743052483,
-0.0194226671,
-0.288416028,
-0.1681407839,
-0.5050597191,
-0.1526077092,
-0.9307324886,
0.0643111765,
0.1294888854,
0.51846385,
0.0307350252,
0.0997433513,
0.7278140187,
-0.7984403372,
0.6247454286,
0.0608970746,
-1.0837461948,
0.5899777412,
-0.1419506669,
0.4356133044,
0.2377825975,
0.396830678,
-0.6332021356,
-0.696804285,
-0.1971118599,
-0.8352875113,
0.7135501504,
0.036555849,
0.0104309991,
0.3731498718,
0.536228478,
-0.2620270252,
0.2509820759,
-0.3386876285,
-0.3688952327,
0.2829451263,
-0.2677867711,
0.0389349461,
0.0864878893,
-0.4098161161,
-0.0469459072,
0.6811923385,
-0.2499797493,
0.3483318985,
0.1357709914,
-0.4990365803,
-0.1242311671,
0.3729679883,
0.5520201921,
0.7509722114,
0.3784468174,
0.0290137865,
0.0827979222,
-0.1914465278,
0.5338055491,
0.0165201649,
-0.2188913971,
-0.2664982677,
0.1504558921,
0.7747927904,
0.1136550531,
-0.8968159556,
0.2048208117,
0.3101651371,
-0.2041772604,
-0.0872916207,
0.5792809725,
0.3891769946,
0.8108124137,
0.5314002037,
-0.0318673141,
0.2643913627,
-0.4205906689,
-0.1066093668,
0.2885706127,
-0.4326061606,
-0.0442944877,
0.6823853254,
0.458114177,
-0.5611526966,
0.329456538,
-0.158717528,
-0.4729560912,
0.5526130795,
0.8289054632,
0.7818495631,
0.261172533,
-0.0933771878,
0.1648009419,
0.207762599,
-0.2971425056,
0.9368054867,
-0.2217334509,
-0.6734036207,
-0.9479318261,
-0.4454434216,
-0.6329174042,
0.0765715688,
-0.6255514622,
-0.0687173456,
-0.5031359792,
-0.1135011092,
-0.4163954258,
-0.0182892028,
-0.4429951608,
0.1592491716,
0.534342587,
1.3064410686,
-0.7928384542,
0.7003657818,
1.2344481945,
0.1004760265,
-0.6816111803,
0.0950624049,
0.2612724304,
-0.5165999532,
0.8348215222,
0.1129646525,
-0.5163232088,
0.1479352564,
-0.1316117197,
-0.9392589331,
1.2729223967,
0.4519889653,
-0.7401898503,
0.2981838286,
-0.0918409377,
0.3695406318,
-0.1980759948,
-0.2419548482,
0.5634812713,
0.2428255677,
-0.0253698267,
-0.9796596766,
0.5018626451,
-0.2796014547,
0.3249796629,
0.5381630659,
-0.4343156815,
0.4703832865,
-0.2663293481,
-0.2600797117,
-0.2323800623,
1.0892450809,
0.4764220119,
0.2295398861,
0.9173049927,
0.8584197164,
0.8811197877,
-0.2470814735,
0.5750915408,
-0.4562467635,
0.192707777,
0.8473749757,
-0.6532355547,
0.9720906615,
0.5060471296,
-0.1614708751,
0.7717027664,
0.3771838546,
0.4648762345,
0.3502137363,
0.4988620579,
-0.4208204746,
-0.4604317248,
-0.0667725727,
0.3347819149,
0.1899083704,
0.2050531805,
0.2387086302,
-0.3219495714,
0.2722871602,
0.2162780017,
0.2383601516,
-0.681410253,
0.6021196246,
0.0059552742,
-0.897116363,
0.2864507139,
-0.1591066718,
0.6694292426,
-0.413759619,
-0.0884695575,
-0.1310900897,
0.2389484495,
-0.3741847277,
-0.8909396529,
0.3182250261,
0.215993613,
-0.37130481,
-0.6336542964,
0.8329095244,
-0.2509321868,
-0.0709450096,
0.1875165552,
0.5999825001,
0.1298491955,
-0.1402989924,
-0.7987054586,
0.1428307593,
-0.4201747477,
-0.1829484254,
0.178241387,
0.2164596021,
-0.2421100438,
1.1004890203,
0.628251493,
0.192220062,
0.0385033078,
0.0438217185,
0.8090484142,
-0.5473167896,
-0.6205456257,
-0.8297807574,
0.4804871082,
0.0449321643,
0.1058620065,
0.1552251875,
0.5671023726,
0.6547598839,
0.0177813563,
0.6241760254,
-0.4429362416,
0.4581770301,
-0.6200595498,
0.4269078076,
-0.6365471482,
-0.0149073927,
0.0259658378,
-0.6908986568,
-0.0542031042,
0.1805585474,
-0.085737817,
-0.2724938393,
0.6619151831,
0.8525558114,
0.2096091509,
-0.1675840169,
0.2058627307,
0.084664233,
0.5291051865,
0.5271598697,
0.7817607522,
0.2343407571,
0.3387263417,
-0.3883437812,
-0.3294348121,
-0.1643522829,
-1.0949828625,
-0.5031006336,
-0.7576124668,
-0.4125601053,
-0.2317231745,
-0.0936732069,
1.1492487192,
0.8310319781,
-0.6007477641,
-0.4632333815,
-0.1767623723,
0.0631198436,
-0.6709926724,
-0.1580709666,
-0.295337081,
-0.9124664664,
-0.6200156808,
0.6920817494,
0.552591145,
-0.4302610159,
-0.4670602381,
0.0042442665,
0.1505860239,
0.057339631,
0.7202641964,
0.3933477998,
-0.8566873074,
0.2922137976,
0.0500257239,
-0.0325348116,
0.0598692968,
1.3284670115,
-0.6964418292,
0.3224985003,
0.5922143459,
0.8349711299,
0.6364170313,
-0.1020455137,
0.5341218114,
-0.3723390102,
-0.0152725596,
0.2794071436,
0.4127778113,
0.0893179625,
-0.369941026,
0.3415554464,
0.3459248841,
-0.2972798049,
-0.7438417077,
0.3682416379,
-0.8414408565,
-0.4096556306,
0.8870419264,
-0.1954047382,
-0.2803417444,
0.0275481697,
-0.021003468,
0.2433756739,
-0.4930987954,
0.3885408044,
0.5680586696,
-0.6992294192,
-0.0587413013,
-0.4131322503,
0.3439769745,
0.5281348228,
-1.0996341705,
0.1376146525,
0.3002477884,
0.4001699388,
0.1168188453,
0.7492314577,
0.1097257733,
0.1321309954,
-0.5610710979,
0.0935345143,
-0.3635187149,
-0.5095757842,
-0.4673959911,
0.1157574207,
0.1191293299,
-0.1095001474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11317v1
|
Few-Shot VQA with Frozen LLMs: A Tale of Two Approaches
| 2024-03-17T19:44:05 | 2024-03-17T19:44:05 |
Igor Sterner, Weizhe Lin, Jinghong Chen, Bill Byrne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Two approaches have emerged to input images into large language models
(LLMs). The first is to caption images into natural language. The second is to
map image feature embeddings into the domain of the LLM and pass the mapped
embeddings directly to the LLM. The majority of recent few-shot multimodal work
reports performance using architectures that employ variations of one of these
two approaches. But they overlook an important comparison between them. We
design a controlled and focused experiment to compare these two approaches to
few-shot visual question answering (VQA) with LLMs. Our findings indicate that
for Flan-T5 XL, a 3B parameter LLM, connecting visual embeddings directly to
the LLM embedding space does not guarantee improved performance over using
image captions. In the zero-shot regime, we find using textual image captions
is better. In the few-shot regimes, how the in-context examples are selected
determines which is better.
|
[
-0.5737258196,
-0.8906651139,
0.8598740697,
-0.1755800694,
-0.5546048284,
0.1765152961,
-0.0092058703,
-0.5638090372,
0.0854486004,
0.6141047478,
-0.4259376228,
-0.2907232344,
-0.5012472868,
0.2267445326,
-0.2064529061,
0.3723341227,
-0.2814518809,
0.2369702756,
-0.6318935156,
-0.2945307493,
-0.3417215347,
-0.2491927892,
-0.4365398288,
-0.2083563358,
0.6276603937,
0.4249091446,
0.8473972678,
0.5873431563,
0.62172997,
0.3161487579,
0.0467626341,
0.1262522191,
-0.3907392025,
-0.0629785582,
0.1743450761,
-0.7454262972,
0.0639956146,
-0.1690593958,
0.4271066189,
0.2431244999,
0.1964329034,
0.1061478704,
-0.3656333685,
0.3734630942,
-0.6916617155,
0.0666680336,
-0.5723254085,
0.1990336776,
-0.1265312284,
-0.3051545918,
-0.2786174715,
-0.1394568682,
0.2434663177,
-0.4928923845,
-0.0541690923,
0.2516735196,
1.0057276487,
0.4602425396,
-0.3666030169,
-0.0841629207,
-0.675303936,
0.8527271152,
-0.7148120999,
0.0543856807,
0.1457001418,
0.495881021,
-0.0071868417,
-0.6197814941,
-0.8064799309,
-0.1940377057,
-0.0568445921,
0.2736192644,
-0.4027187228,
0.0161309503,
0.2929396927,
0.1217514798,
-0.5831021667,
0.3757700026,
-0.4574816823,
-0.2071640939,
0.502720952,
0.3124823868,
0.1974661946,
-0.3156035841,
-0.6708229184,
-0.0869962797,
-0.7424511909,
0.0516278669,
-0.1867007911,
0.3268393874,
-0.2005283087,
0.9263114929,
-0.2130631357,
0.7672559619,
-0.1393414736,
-0.3278332055,
-0.038990885,
-0.2742522657,
-0.378292352,
-0.3723915815,
0.8499627709,
0.6097630262,
0.4044139981,
-0.0001677979,
-0.1178775281,
-0.10387972,
-0.0042320741,
-0.6871023178,
-0.0342363343,
0.2899314463,
-0.1920018196,
-0.022259891,
-0.2024715543,
-0.7438797951,
-0.3348965943,
-0.0845757946,
0.7314606905,
-0.2575541139,
0.2025308013,
-0.1787713468,
-0.2108781189,
0.8074505925,
0.6020608544,
-0.4736984372,
0.3380956948,
0.2964449525,
0.8664310575,
-0.2056741267,
-0.1463686973,
-0.7317151427,
-0.0354719236,
-0.4684486687,
1.0116672516,
-0.4625276029,
-0.1050464585,
0.3661959171,
-0.177695334,
0.0138218999,
-0.5222034454,
0.0716719404,
-0.9991883039,
0.3350810707,
-0.4274277985,
-0.5436728001,
-0.2631077766,
0.2866230309,
-0.6806833744,
0.7811471224,
-0.0482244231,
-0.5902472734,
0.4771291912,
-0.5440246463,
-0.1059322581,
0.1983130276,
-0.4906672835,
-0.2318093479,
0.0649801865,
0.4642765224,
0.6339977384,
-0.1993492395,
-0.4116228521,
-0.3906587064,
-0.5327988863,
0.5683745146,
-0.3630458415,
0.2869068384,
0.0531009994,
-0.1357857734,
-0.1633882076,
-0.2081095427,
0.2473389357,
0.4730450511,
-0.3629682064,
-0.1320652515,
-0.2308483571,
0.0832062289,
0.2511026859,
-0.025943201,
-0.4240421355,
0.2689231038,
-0.3069271445,
0.5072776675,
0.3659960032,
0.1009180918,
0.6272673011,
-0.4062099755,
0.7827823758,
0.2552561164,
-0.1911658943,
-0.3319934905,
-0.5644275546,
-0.8038268089,
-0.454954952,
0.3381964862,
0.6756420732,
-1.3707168102,
-0.5612964034,
-0.2051952183,
-0.0689852238,
-0.493422091,
0.4327284992,
0.4153354764,
0.2028561383,
0.3742498457,
-0.4254646897,
-0.0762309134,
-1.0997799635,
0.0167700611,
-0.2316424102,
0.0287776999,
0.4657886922,
0.6790924668,
0.216727078,
0.780970633,
-0.5892115831,
-0.2866893709,
-0.3627896309,
0.0916657969,
-0.0388349295,
0.0694884732,
0.9087290168,
-0.6268458962,
-0.412984103,
-0.2009120286,
-0.6301524043,
0.335691452,
-0.2294177711,
-0.0181075744,
0.4383596778,
0.4163380563,
-0.7774785757,
0.5013616085,
0.3959891796,
0.1831759512,
0.2494398057,
0.1562891454,
0.345703572,
-0.7106797099,
-0.3158830404,
-0.0967236161,
-0.5523331761,
-0.6757127643,
0.2028335333,
0.0979740694,
0.0522130691,
-1.1235361099,
0.6132711768,
-0.6301917434,
-0.2459012568,
-0.2034792602,
0.3880732059,
0.0540058762,
0.6021715999,
0.1581056416,
0.8337058425,
0.7328421474,
-0.3496028781,
0.3891006112,
0.2687119544,
-0.2616457343,
0.4113111198,
-0.7184235454,
0.4045683444,
-0.442252934,
-0.0297845304,
-1.3893129826,
-0.4411588907,
0.3294196725,
-0.319155246,
0.5411784053,
-0.3337772489,
-0.586101532,
-0.4291321039,
-0.5474082232,
0.3977469206,
0.5542528033,
-0.3166183531,
0.3838810921,
-0.1191186309,
-0.0629895255,
-0.4804758728,
-1.1879771948,
0.3059241474,
-0.3099014163,
-0.5700176954,
0.1214825884,
-0.0125582563,
-0.269333303,
0.0176366828,
0.1042824537,
-0.3888248801,
-0.0936710909,
0.1715067923,
0.2414021939,
-0.605289042,
0.0615465418,
-0.0905207396,
0.079782173,
-0.2900597453,
0.1458455473,
0.2241300642,
-0.2546332777,
-0.3243195117,
-0.5516192913,
0.6535131931,
0.7269282937,
-0.1119062752,
0.803743124,
0.4126931727,
-0.2309073508,
-0.0184348151,
-0.5932158232,
-0.169726029,
-0.407061398,
0.1439634413,
-0.4206349552,
-1.0855634212,
0.4097697735,
0.0862964988,
0.1252608448,
0.1292018443,
0.6018747091,
-0.7382596135,
0.5853219032,
0.780218184,
0.1161985248,
0.3649382293,
-0.2749264538,
-0.0054715099,
-0.5150851011,
0.1450160593,
-0.3376563489,
-0.3012543023,
-0.4478144646,
-0.7326970696,
0.487403214,
0.1166762188,
0.046627894,
0.1939873099,
0.0992642641,
0.5830390453,
0.4294039011,
0.0831000134,
0.219931975,
0.2177966088,
-0.1283718497,
-0.2277264893,
-1.1702685356,
-0.6521940827,
0.8540893793,
0.2814481258,
0.7920498848,
0.2615738809,
0.8075057268,
-0.200039193,
0.3526833653,
-1.0863506794,
0.5077648759,
-0.1289956123,
-0.684715867,
-0.334281534,
0.0071505751,
-0.8177716732,
0.4789798558,
-0.4058802724,
-0.6124925017,
-0.0065043913,
0.2303814739,
-0.5348481536,
0.1314072758,
-0.6539114714,
0.7174760103,
-0.36731112,
-0.542773366,
0.188696593,
-0.6168131828,
0.5870081186,
0.112774916,
0.1358470768,
0.1361421049,
-0.3326342106,
0.4825914502,
-0.1566689909,
0.8961133957,
0.042997852,
0.1771945804,
0.4973667264,
0.2309995294,
0.239837274,
-0.0410070941,
0.1486932188,
0.1015697569,
0.2001660019,
-0.6140342951,
-0.6884537935,
0.5573818684,
-0.6807851791,
-0.7324915528,
-0.4252344966,
-0.4025939405,
-0.2500038743,
0.0330114886,
0.3071712255,
0.5077456236,
0.0585400835,
0.3072978258,
0.668787241,
-0.4153278172,
0.8125532866,
0.2748548687,
-0.3078038692,
-0.3592495322,
0.2466193885,
0.2354999334,
0.6302381158,
0.5260646343,
0.0226485617,
-0.1955830902,
-0.5362460613,
-0.6895919442,
0.4443648756,
-0.9935837388,
-0.396879524,
-0.3586758673,
-0.1018834263,
-0.2004677653,
-0.3293419182,
-0.3778830469,
-0.2245144546,
-0.4850806296,
-0.0442791432,
0.5200240016,
0.4458203316,
0.2118754685,
0.2585648894,
-0.8193002939,
0.7039729953,
0.5991415381,
0.0863189176,
-0.1888643503,
-0.5929431319,
-0.0119566387,
-0.0674460381,
-0.1853511333,
-1.0377402306,
0.2090035528,
0.3540355265,
0.4358254075,
0.3003480732,
-0.0632880405,
0.9175367951,
-0.48780635,
1.0924241543,
0.2321641296,
-0.5650217533,
0.3655705452,
-0.1252309233,
0.6654781699,
0.5244668126,
0.4700181484,
-0.1490466148,
-0.4227154851,
-0.2109375447,
-0.5982018113,
0.3979083896,
0.2286304832,
0.5442423224,
0.1226451173,
0.2994299829,
0.0262905415,
0.3016144037,
-0.7245759368,
-0.2488734424,
-0.0084054535,
0.1676166207,
-0.0493165925,
-0.4235844612,
-0.392524451,
-0.028274281,
0.0352009945,
-0.3388605118,
0.5075638294,
0.3934364021,
-0.3568154573,
-0.231419906,
0.3246692717,
0.7777326107,
0.5979548097,
0.0231393371,
0.3220129907,
0.349494338,
-0.1477286965,
-0.0858481228,
-0.4878219664,
-0.2128391862,
0.1581363231,
0.7773777246,
0.8755971193,
0.1788603216,
-0.6408420801,
0.6507085562,
0.0354809575,
-0.5004384518,
-0.2081144154,
-0.0211669095,
0.2027794719,
0.4771694541,
0.3215579093,
-0.135916993,
-0.1034285575,
-0.6866992116,
0.047270827,
0.522561729,
-0.3566074967,
-0.0407247655,
0.453738749,
-0.0224288385,
-0.0563655272,
0.4337310195,
0.0105928406,
-0.5006898046,
0.6114094853,
0.2720345259,
0.7018975019,
0.376714915,
0.430190742,
0.1780304611,
0.6195036769,
0.1341172159,
0.5404912233,
0.0054481528,
-0.7765393257,
-0.5178506374,
-0.3071952164,
-0.5045896173,
0.0261356812,
-0.5212445259,
0.0752252713,
-0.4462471604,
-0.0879555643,
-0.0941524059,
-0.0836516693,
-1.0956540108,
0.048525285,
0.4970427752,
0.751419127,
-0.8804528713,
0.5397847891,
0.9596226811,
-0.6455552578,
-0.6663627625,
-0.0481262542,
0.1593321413,
-0.7635436058,
0.5919464231,
-0.0676454082,
-0.169054538,
-0.1413514316,
-1.1351844072,
-0.8435379863,
1.3170520067,
0.3510374725,
-0.4236243069,
0.4162617922,
0.2198803872,
0.6179081202,
-0.4565479755,
0.2800726891,
0.3384655118,
0.4178208113,
0.5632716417,
-0.8641474843,
-0.0922222361,
0.2234325856,
0.1747700572,
-0.2250437289,
-0.7084585428,
0.5339483023,
-0.542160511,
-0.3812098503,
0.3575402796,
0.708212316,
0.2075133175,
0.4703136384,
0.2621005774,
0.3084906638,
0.2584831715,
-0.012677284,
1.2401939631,
0.281334877,
0.1409377456,
0.98551476,
-0.3538095057,
1.3241400719,
1.0104956627,
-0.3312185407,
0.190186277,
0.6287317276,
0.0724822879,
0.6445793509,
0.0887510926,
-0.0349109843,
-0.5170874,
-0.0782856867,
-0.0385152921,
0.5961476564,
0.1051855683,
-0.113053754,
-0.3263340294,
0.1811257303,
0.0076845912,
0.0236775093,
-0.1500487179,
0.8351299167,
0.3757240474,
-0.2856629789,
0.7383279204,
-0.0942789987,
0.5690256953,
-0.2413959056,
-0.0128806774,
-0.4524265528,
-0.468842119,
-0.1928552836,
-0.9227429032,
0.0441073067,
0.1957310289,
-0.0173228644,
-0.0940167531,
0.5724031329,
-0.4105426073,
-0.4176583588,
-0.0594788641,
0.757470727,
0.3322105706,
0.2207991779,
-0.6768280864,
0.0986299962,
-0.3867672682,
-0.3365894258,
0.1824693233,
0.2695812583,
-0.0797137991,
0.7680677772,
0.244348228,
-0.2128081173,
0.3436449766,
0.0670889989,
0.8723105192,
-0.6335812211,
-0.0300472826,
-0.6830883622,
0.7716273665,
0.1826252639,
-0.2725039124,
0.4468628168,
0.1501191109,
0.616374433,
-0.444904238,
0.5741689801,
0.14398022,
-0.0657841489,
-1.0422174931,
0.3991325796,
-0.8287016749,
0.1487441957,
-0.2906355262,
-0.8570226431,
-0.6342254877,
0.2898750007,
-0.2882927656,
-0.0680496544,
0.8860194683,
0.9928981066,
0.0194415879,
-0.5395561457,
0.7798466086,
0.188067168,
0.0273641087,
0.7062914968,
1.1763094664,
-0.586468637,
0.5399090648,
-0.2519731522,
0.1606732607,
-0.259735465,
-0.8995170593,
-1.000428915,
-0.3394801915,
-0.6869636178,
0.2127271593,
-0.0891321823,
0.5980783701,
0.5371352434,
-0.5953973532,
0.0053936341,
0.5005212426,
0.2639542818,
0.0731372461,
-0.1697598994,
0.0650508478,
0.0228255559,
-0.6644558907,
0.2353586107,
0.5633320808,
0.2847492099,
-0.4679582119,
0.1184551194,
-0.2259475887,
0.2429341674,
0.691922307,
0.2348740846,
-1.0897954702,
-0.4999691844,
0.278134048,
-0.2837946117,
0.2347619534,
0.4122074544,
-0.7840099335,
0.4848206341,
0.6444669962,
0.699636817,
0.719594717,
0.0280222576,
0.2822958827,
-0.507404685,
0.1283197403,
0.1569356024,
0.1288415939,
0.3273028135,
-0.1257865876,
0.0878838599,
-0.0012513006,
-0.1122590676,
-0.6488286257,
0.2139798999,
-1.2830967903,
-0.3005267382,
1.1481109858,
-0.1688878089,
-0.3089608848,
0.0960322693,
-0.2196242362,
-0.2418651134,
-0.1376991719,
0.3792896569,
0.7751947045,
-0.1856113225,
-0.8221139908,
-0.9209039807,
0.1984579861,
0.3395609558,
-0.6014008522,
-0.6052408814,
0.703682065,
0.280582279,
0.0191848259,
0.5941660404,
0.0045662783,
0.5146479011,
-0.0457290448,
-0.1379684806,
-0.020988727,
-0.2844012976,
-0.5957376361,
0.4445065558,
0.3352831006,
-0.3806954324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11314v1
|
Reasoning in Transformers -- Mitigating Spurious Correlations and Reasoning Shortcuts
| 2024-03-17T19:32:12 | 2024-03-17T19:32:12 |
Daniel Enström, Viktor Kjellberg, Moa Johansson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Transformer language models are neural networks used for a wide variety of
tasks concerning natural language, including some that also require logical
reasoning. However, a transformer model may easily learn spurious patterns in
the data, short-circuiting actual reasoning. In this paper we investigate to
what extent transformers can be trained to a) approximate reasoning in
propositional logic while b) avoiding known reasoning shortcuts via spurious
correlations in the training data. To do so, we use a dataset with known
spurious correlation between truth and e.g. the number of rules in the problem.
We augment the data with proofs, and train two models: a generative
transformer, WP-BART, trained on problems and their whole proofs, and a
neuro-symbolic model, SIP-BART, trained on individual proof steps and combining
the generative transformer model BART with a symbolic proof checker. We find
that SIP-BART succeeds in avoiding reasoning shortcuts, while WP-BART does not.
For SIP-BART, we then identify a few remaining reasoning errors, not previously
described in the literature, arising from using a pre-trained language model.
These are qualitatively analysed to create a taxonomy of four different types
of additional pitfalls.
|
[
-0.35815382,
-0.7690529823,
0.665543139,
0.1768250614,
-0.1845786721,
0.0490179099,
-0.1299713403,
-0.2523336112,
-0.0322512425,
0.7160410285,
-0.4487465024,
0.0556596555,
-0.5701182485,
0.0856255367,
-0.5781997442,
0.9330616593,
0.1105982587,
-0.0647597611,
-0.2949754298,
-0.0111998776,
-0.7848269939,
-0.653957665,
-0.6398590803,
-0.5546879172,
0.3554610908,
0.2936154008,
1.0221520662,
0.3199220896,
0.6727184653,
0.241403982,
-0.2460544109,
0.1328426152,
-0.3034154475,
0.1672893316,
-0.4220850468,
-0.8798960447,
-0.1132045984,
-0.2611402273,
0.2245868295,
0.7461670041,
0.0500776619,
-0.0744908601,
-0.110199824,
0.5963587165,
-0.5800898671,
0.0581444055,
-0.6509955525,
0.0642199367,
-0.1903303415,
-0.2406790257,
-0.7053463459,
-0.3765798211,
0.2279064357,
-0.5294528008,
0.3997649252,
0.1599766016,
0.9854125977,
0.6877371669,
-0.3834846616,
-0.2283741087,
-1.2148997784,
0.7573053241,
-0.4631367326,
0.1966663003,
0.411857307,
0.6031904221,
-0.1021675691,
-0.7364031672,
-0.6109034419,
-0.170604676,
-0.5061963797,
0.2257595509,
-0.3974432647,
0.0305225439,
0.7869567871,
-0.0134471878,
-0.3902665377,
-0.0803140104,
-0.2470196337,
-0.2677049339,
0.5275197625,
0.2074049413,
0.0835489854,
-0.2229256034,
-0.3767882288,
-0.3621637523,
-0.8834350705,
0.1361002326,
0.4278275967,
0.0130186323,
0.1720745713,
0.5090284944,
0.1719557792,
0.6219384074,
0.0419797599,
0.0393747613,
-0.1853064299,
-0.3455688059,
0.0342798159,
-0.0592912547,
0.7440027595,
0.1446836442,
0.5187626481,
-0.352576822,
-0.2604621649,
0.372325182,
0.3714570105,
-0.4989496469,
-0.3925277591,
0.0474724583,
-0.2927891314,
-0.3087174594,
-0.0682517812,
-0.540658772,
-0.0719489232,
-0.2661749125,
0.5620021224,
-0.5794568658,
-0.046983365,
0.158356905,
-0.5235368609,
0.1985338181,
0.1322315782,
-0.6067106724,
0.3709897399,
0.7690038681,
0.5303673744,
0.1868085414,
-0.3006161749,
-0.4116077721,
0.2519414425,
-0.3431611061,
0.8824253678,
-0.5408369899,
-0.5293259025,
-0.1294639558,
-0.1725477427,
-0.1910853535,
-0.6241528988,
1.025080204,
-0.495690912,
0.3522822857,
-0.2682747841,
-0.5672989488,
-0.229434967,
0.0444780923,
-0.7112396955,
0.9601527452,
-0.1123800129,
-0.9073651433,
0.2042574733,
-0.5558378696,
-0.7625949979,
-0.1584657133,
0.0503691547,
-0.3710952103,
0.0915700495,
0.1601134539,
0.1770616323,
-0.4937181771,
0.568182826,
-0.118912667,
-0.4739299715,
0.2231484056,
-0.5802672505,
0.8696146011,
0.0806389004,
-0.3404903412,
0.1426270604,
-0.5665782094,
-0.3001055419,
0.2954724431,
0.290106684,
-0.4933482111,
0.2117529064,
-0.2914302945,
0.538346529,
-0.1219741255,
-0.2526788712,
0.1525285244,
-0.4355741739,
0.4749209285,
0.5782753825,
0.1256698072,
0.484218657,
-0.5677788854,
0.3856310844,
0.3861854076,
0.4811959863,
-0.205283463,
-0.8073358536,
-1.2531917095,
0.1534795463,
0.2655548155,
0.7359646559,
-1.0646063089,
0.6334822178,
-0.2761958838,
-0.5951764584,
-0.2761015296,
-0.2222851366,
0.2265099883,
0.8864427805,
0.5751206279,
-0.0588171631,
-0.3611459136,
-0.9438682795,
-0.4981884062,
-0.1269641519,
-0.1267519593,
0.0633370578,
0.6290331483,
-0.012777226,
1.2490295172,
-0.4852067232,
-0.2218592465,
-0.257905364,
0.1909180433,
0.2702762485,
0.6040916443,
0.4955202341,
-0.8255462646,
-0.2954760492,
-0.3597511649,
-0.5886267424,
0.1559219211,
-0.5948544145,
-0.1179952472,
-0.2503462732,
0.5376448631,
-0.9724149704,
0.6066626906,
-0.1407901496,
-0.0871438459,
0.7834226489,
-0.1613850594,
-0.394089222,
-0.8653461933,
-0.1526031345,
0.0383363739,
-0.1397104561,
-0.7826814651,
-0.1485739201,
-0.033596281,
-0.0187072754,
-0.2809664905,
0.3143087029,
-0.0442479327,
0.4163687527,
-0.1767423302,
0.0030538116,
0.2805241048,
0.4942552745,
0.2741548717,
0.6603555679,
0.6430436373,
-0.6234718561,
0.3084871471,
0.4926939905,
-0.0908094794,
0.3131168783,
-0.8091472387,
0.0485687256,
-0.1433109641,
0.2925110459,
-0.5399055481,
0.110361591,
0.3177742362,
-0.2427960783,
0.2125083655,
-0.1001477093,
-0.6727145314,
-0.6009367108,
-0.0488236286,
0.3925353587,
0.6780383587,
-0.7943520546,
0.7458489537,
-0.0194871593,
0.2044986635,
-0.7869464159,
-0.5769568086,
-0.1301501989,
-0.3632215858,
-0.5596781969,
0.3356460929,
0.1860291064,
-0.256649971,
0.1012225002,
-0.1141369566,
-0.1433800161,
0.14560619,
0.0730934292,
0.2976230085,
-0.1053996384,
0.1539478004,
0.0614583008,
-0.4465251267,
0.4863487184,
-0.1105818599,
0.3660300672,
-0.3701163232,
-0.6687078476,
-0.1938987225,
0.3425774276,
0.4573731422,
-0.0521839447,
0.7306883931,
0.3769397736,
-0.3482393026,
-0.2246332616,
-0.5252563357,
-0.6309576631,
-0.4831319451,
0.1328747571,
-0.3800197244,
-0.5847060084,
0.5607858896,
-0.2447690219,
-0.1446247399,
0.5023754835,
0.2705731988,
-0.1939352602,
1.0147070885,
0.4220224619,
0.0946351215,
0.2419749349,
-0.2152667195,
0.7529585958,
-0.4644044042,
-0.1484162956,
-0.549932003,
-0.0307389833,
-0.6462150812,
-0.5431560278,
0.3117974997,
0.1683667004,
-0.2071989924,
0.5943305492,
-0.420107305,
0.7092687488,
0.7904339433,
0.0945020616,
0.3419812322,
-0.2734803855,
-0.2219152898,
0.031162031,
-1.0628371239,
-0.5077234507,
0.8639413118,
0.1672086418,
0.8591720462,
-0.0350735821,
0.3857367337,
0.0411649682,
0.1265881658,
-0.9101314545,
0.4611384273,
0.1131573021,
-0.7267179489,
-0.0512122475,
-0.6500134468,
-0.7897555828,
0.2099513412,
-0.2760157585,
-0.5585263968,
0.1884428263,
0.3525649905,
-0.2825836837,
0.56587708,
-0.882892251,
0.8510325551,
-0.3385454714,
-0.2928878367,
-0.2955456078,
-1.1394402981,
0.6527197957,
-0.0937795267,
-0.0012623685,
0.2138015628,
0.6329481006,
0.452496767,
-0.5241463184,
0.7452912927,
0.0996383578,
0.2116890699,
0.4625152051,
0.2733865678,
0.655821681,
-0.2072491646,
0.3344061077,
0.164487645,
-0.0342021808,
-0.2703827322,
-0.8792431355,
0.1554448605,
-0.5083639622,
-0.9058244824,
-0.5534256101,
-0.6175219417,
-0.4242726862,
0.0403187014,
0.4443731606,
0.3608963192,
-0.0151510276,
0.0341448151,
0.6045466661,
-0.1696234494,
0.5056326985,
0.004121922,
0.015711274,
0.0266806483,
1.0087938309,
-0.1378406286,
0.4136301279,
0.5727877021,
0.4374863207,
-0.4517975152,
-0.1444942504,
-0.0933826864,
0.2438144684,
-0.932967186,
-0.2777918279,
-0.4388169944,
-0.4059629738,
-0.0536829382,
0.0261509921,
-0.3261879086,
-0.8080099821,
-0.155915156,
0.097910963,
0.2480477691,
0.5351753235,
0.0338128582,
0.4885398746,
-0.9784454107,
0.3537520468,
0.4090679586,
0.262473911,
0.1376240253,
-0.389964968,
-0.017601043,
-0.0622280799,
-0.5012595057,
-0.9375418425,
0.1695726961,
-0.011808835,
0.5485483408,
0.65016675,
0.1414880753,
0.6193793416,
-0.679561913,
0.6465004086,
0.3263973296,
-1.0823401213,
0.6214624643,
-0.0192260724,
-0.0870310664,
0.3440814614,
0.5148535371,
-0.469140023,
-0.4558965266,
-0.9803590178,
-0.5329027176,
0.4997433126,
0.536386013,
0.0236617066,
-0.134578675,
0.1462731808,
0.0091010267,
-0.019950144,
-0.6032921076,
-0.4325512946,
-0.5455589294,
-0.0212950837,
0.2527590692,
-0.1211019233,
-0.3992148936,
-0.4586824179,
0.8105028272,
-0.1113893166,
0.1509470791,
-0.0826080218,
-0.3564027846,
0.2113584131,
0.3501925766,
0.6528500319,
0.4234871864,
-0.0613753386,
0.3045223653,
0.0332433693,
-0.2124358863,
0.1328441948,
0.0278308261,
-0.3897340298,
0.1936191022,
0.2072498798,
0.8065620661,
0.0827617273,
-0.619584024,
0.7051336169,
-0.1904530078,
-0.0409076847,
-0.3166216612,
0.0296399761,
0.0730619133,
0.0046218159,
0.1258086562,
0.8825551271,
-0.0156176668,
-0.1241913512,
0.1733910143,
0.4288404286,
-0.2526547015,
-0.4149208963,
0.6100521684,
0.1865709275,
-0.3515054286,
0.6612224579,
-0.0794937238,
-0.7292356491,
0.5714520216,
0.6669654846,
0.7021490932,
0.0778127685,
0.2099964768,
0.4007289112,
0.6926077008,
-0.2367464006,
-0.3133507967,
-0.1634095311,
-1.0718719959,
-0.5658500195,
-0.1727216244,
-0.7568383813,
-0.0335951224,
-0.7689534426,
0.3681333363,
-0.2841630876,
-0.2583355308,
0.0046161148,
-0.6576234102,
-0.7818062901,
-0.0317742117,
-0.1652268618,
0.9262800217,
-1.0773502588,
0.8585915565,
0.2730332017,
-0.5933581591,
-0.9350426793,
0.1101851687,
-0.3355371654,
-0.5836545229,
0.6674649715,
0.0891195014,
-0.2176943421,
-0.242001757,
-0.251255542,
-0.6092368364,
0.4930522442,
0.4970364571,
-0.5900694728,
-0.1775272489,
0.3946245313,
0.4341080189,
0.1758916378,
0.5018233657,
0.9502988458,
0.4621757567,
0.1023695916,
-0.7673603892,
0.096115835,
-0.0843052939,
-0.2216866612,
0.2571196556,
-0.4586806297,
0.5430952907,
-0.2582157552,
-0.1347240061,
-0.1238111928,
0.4773948193,
0.2021692842,
0.0879987404,
0.7381432652,
0.6520251632,
0.7415032983,
-0.4387734234,
1.1087839603,
-0.3293150663,
0.4107579589,
1.1933560371,
-0.3733445406,
0.473198384,
0.7208271027,
-0.1094093695,
0.6093232036,
0.2605447471,
-0.1824181825,
0.4265518785,
-0.001218886,
-0.183507368,
-0.6331780553,
-0.0210439861,
-0.3271873593,
0.484292537,
0.5283288956,
-0.0539608598,
-0.3928853571,
-0.0992282778,
-0.1400804669,
0.025860101,
0.0790629685,
0.5661002994,
0.2433944643,
-0.8867861032,
0.4767604172,
-0.254642278,
0.5791232586,
-0.4978454113,
-0.0846863911,
-0.1009853631,
0.1179271042,
-0.1296259165,
-0.7321010828,
0.7363314033,
-0.1785657406,
-0.1433694512,
-0.301345259,
1.0231702328,
-0.1206558496,
-0.4842362404,
0.2078035623,
0.6691092253,
0.002909868,
-0.0672612265,
-0.6154259443,
-0.5464310646,
-0.2097638845,
0.049388621,
-0.0425504483,
0.4635733068,
-0.3003297746,
0.9256401062,
0.6728698611,
0.0986415669,
0.1142374203,
0.4504902363,
0.9422329664,
-0.6932098269,
-0.4381744862,
-0.9082861543,
0.3094953299,
-0.13340877,
-0.1706948131,
0.6585130692,
0.4852216542,
0.7088399529,
-0.345593214,
0.5938895941,
0.2772909999,
0.3533729911,
-0.3984660506,
0.4532378018,
-0.1866037101,
0.3429884911,
-0.1475606859,
-0.8357560635,
-0.4660967588,
0.6805782318,
-0.491864115,
-0.1413222998,
1.0110864639,
0.7365062237,
-0.1818233281,
0.5070301294,
0.3116926849,
0.0342316665,
0.4069355726,
0.6920517683,
1.3536485434,
-0.4080370963,
0.78615731,
-0.6663039327,
0.1456978619,
-0.0284176003,
-0.9339200854,
-1.0112844706,
-0.374815762,
-0.2197586,
-0.4287604094,
-0.3398354053,
0.603379488,
0.6720456481,
-0.8239913583,
0.0853402168,
-0.5646567345,
0.7355571389,
-0.4632561207,
-0.2841890454,
0.2465749681,
-0.4138894677,
-0.4353547692,
0.3554662466,
0.1233551428,
0.0808514878,
-0.0775978938,
0.1717448086,
0.0409750901,
0.1123850718,
0.4597196877,
0.1819546223,
-0.8125038147,
-0.5941649079,
0.1243547052,
0.1915047467,
0.2413182408,
1.0960530043,
-0.8585757613,
0.3313257992,
0.4773585796,
0.4715180993,
0.595113039,
-0.0419606902,
0.520607233,
-0.9015548825,
0.4528207481,
0.5824153423,
0.6060864925,
0.3436743021,
-0.3701676428,
0.4150373042,
0.3870893121,
-0.4312988818,
-0.7821564674,
0.4919298589,
-0.9910058975,
-0.2054496258,
0.792604804,
0.0331248008,
-0.1023999155,
-0.2774406374,
0.0777973756,
0.2525773048,
0.0426905006,
0.8162342906,
0.7042734027,
-0.2767077684,
0.1071273386,
-0.3951716423,
0.6446382999,
0.8203365803,
-0.7775608897,
-0.0897988081,
0.1305818856,
0.2454784364,
0.5552140474,
0.0689002052,
0.0117510268,
0.3586220443,
0.1820081472,
-0.1884460151,
0.1294001341,
-0.5410011411,
-0.1613653749,
0.0843637139,
-0.0925005674,
-0.0621801801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11311v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11311v2
|
Mixture-of-Prompt-Experts for Multi-modal Semantic Understanding
| 2024-03-17T19:12:26 | 2024-03-24T06:21:27 |
Zichen Wu, Hsiu-Yuan Huang, Fanyi Qu, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Deep multimodal semantic understanding that goes beyond the mere superficial
content relation mining has received increasing attention in the realm of
artificial intelligence. The challenges of collecting and annotating
high-quality multi-modal data have underscored the significance of few-shot
learning. In this paper, we focus on two critical tasks under this context:
few-shot multi-modal sarcasm detection (MSD) and multi-modal sentiment analysis
(MSA). To address them, we propose Mixture-of-Prompt-Experts with Block-Aware
Prompt Fusion (MoPE-BAF), a novel multi-modal soft prompt framework based on
the unified vision-language model (VLM). Specifically, we design three experts
of soft prompts: a text prompt and an image prompt that extract
modality-specific features to enrich the single-modal representation, and a
unified prompt to assist multi-modal interaction. Additionally, we reorganize
Transformer layers into several blocks and introduce cross-modal prompt
attention between adjacent blocks, which smoothens the transition from
single-modal representation to multi-modal fusion. On both MSD and MSA datasets
in few-shot setting, our proposed model not only surpasses the 8.2B model
InstructBLIP with merely 2% parameters (150M), but also significantly
outperforms other widely-used prompt methods on VLMs or task-specific methods.
|
[
-0.5546610951,
-0.8107634783,
0.7106454968,
0.1436664611,
-0.4353151321,
-0.0706545487,
-0.1693080366,
-0.1823083907,
-0.0772506446,
0.1921019107,
-0.9422692657,
-0.3438962996,
-0.4436664879,
0.1326719671,
0.2804758549,
0.8126555085,
0.446493566,
0.2645971775,
-0.1300498396,
-0.1827657372,
-0.9288785458,
-0.0010193514,
-0.2605008483,
-0.0229158867,
0.623908639,
0.5425860882,
0.5655965805,
0.0852368101,
0.2593874633,
0.3408323526,
0.0052996017,
0.4932362437,
-0.2400388718,
0.2080900222,
-0.2580369115,
-0.2828322053,
-0.2204614133,
-0.0634402111,
0.376546979,
0.5568447709,
0.2200583518,
-0.147899732,
-0.0810794756,
0.3034416437,
-0.6595149636,
0.1703346074,
-0.6525056958,
-0.0252899136,
0.0225261636,
-0.1094234884,
-0.4914737642,
0.276619792,
0.0890084133,
-0.6229841709,
0.0677971914,
0.0941733196,
0.4546882808,
0.5604717731,
-0.8489155173,
0.2035850435,
-0.2477122545,
0.8922129869,
-0.5918980241,
0.2288263887,
0.1221658736,
0.5319066644,
-0.2500351071,
-0.2145519853,
-0.7349980474,
-0.0647315234,
-0.0841815621,
0.3109538853,
-0.048511032,
0.1123343557,
0.0100677069,
0.1873110086,
-0.5240505934,
0.0739881098,
-0.1786713302,
-0.3595260382,
0.3626748025,
0.3379983008,
0.0889113396,
-0.6968329549,
-0.8939187527,
0.0462572984,
-0.3004099131,
0.109946467,
-0.0804582462,
0.421292305,
-0.1253977418,
0.3587484062,
-0.2536413372,
0.8276551366,
0.1254670918,
-0.5223317742,
0.2999288142,
-0.782558918,
-0.2984280586,
-0.3453032076,
0.8992393613,
0.2953728139,
-0.0551697128,
0.0103653707,
-0.2613179386,
0.0378278904,
-0.0146487346,
-0.4927155375,
-0.0720341057,
0.0333415978,
-0.5921364427,
-0.2276258171,
0.1492246538,
-0.8285233974,
-0.8034780622,
-0.3401639462,
0.5951984525,
-0.6852719188,
-0.5090353489,
0.0083010253,
-0.2846812308,
0.1440466791,
0.6291564107,
-0.474792093,
-0.1952306181,
0.5568823218,
0.5220170021,
0.0086544305,
-0.3691867888,
-0.6964302063,
-0.009957986,
0.0526474118,
0.9481991529,
-0.6841752529,
-0.4937412441,
-0.1959381849,
-0.2582625747,
-0.3087007105,
-0.1242545024,
0.4863077402,
-0.3194361031,
0.5204994678,
-0.1763178706,
-0.2410340309,
-0.4995547235,
0.4560749233,
-0.5758711696,
0.8848516345,
0.1948429942,
-0.5574670434,
0.3915605843,
-0.3679520786,
-0.3965566456,
0.1998270452,
-0.4962029457,
0.164631784,
0.3338640034,
0.3908158243,
0.7140488029,
-0.3615817428,
0.2254612446,
-0.1174338311,
0.0513771661,
0.3956496119,
-0.7465980053,
0.5784688592,
0.1488202065,
-0.2159685344,
0.2796954513,
-0.8156615496,
-0.0930416659,
-0.2801818848,
-0.112274535,
-0.2407169342,
-0.3618047237,
0.2661493719,
0.6506181955,
0.0565894358,
-0.295278281,
0.1836858541,
-0.184427321,
0.1141179875,
0.8530066013,
0.121625483,
0.5562440157,
-0.2119026333,
0.529841423,
0.5155758858,
0.1970111877,
-0.9400216341,
-0.6581673026,
-0.4679310024,
-0.858823359,
0.1360854059,
0.5042969584,
-1.1923376322,
0.4640027285,
-0.0784026906,
-0.2981353402,
-0.5828409791,
0.3417302668,
0.4684995711,
0.8992183805,
0.4328032136,
-0.2037805766,
-0.0560080037,
-0.8367654681,
-0.1211194694,
-0.0757732913,
0.0653806329,
0.4540686309,
0.2660392821,
-0.2107899189,
1.1298902035,
-0.3260510862,
-0.4098608196,
-0.4397926033,
0.4750988185,
0.205713138,
0.5149620175,
0.6033802629,
-0.8457525373,
-0.4150873125,
-0.1140493751,
-0.5736269355,
-0.0217102412,
-0.3442901969,
-0.0376522876,
0.1065189093,
0.1386342049,
-0.8456184268,
0.2358679324,
0.0724655911,
-0.5562309027,
0.4093011618,
0.1597542465,
0.4335834682,
-1.1874396801,
-0.1879964173,
0.2703090012,
-0.4289337695,
-0.5596014857,
0.0589293353,
0.0105162067,
-0.0825805515,
-0.7397550344,
0.6037493944,
-0.382938236,
0.3103079498,
-0.4001473784,
0.104430452,
0.0985663086,
0.6268517971,
-0.0124130324,
0.5265696645,
0.7956559658,
-0.5300165415,
0.3332894444,
0.0459579378,
-0.112375401,
0.8675887585,
-0.3670173883,
0.1528054327,
-0.2884071469,
0.3260774016,
-1.3048996925,
-0.4138035476,
0.4961591363,
-0.5062558055,
0.2101556212,
-0.2775113881,
-0.4086014628,
-0.1926785409,
-0.4462779164,
0.5167238116,
0.4619601667,
-0.2923214436,
1.2170876265,
-0.0412486382,
-0.1039021835,
-0.6962672472,
-0.5200298429,
-0.166693598,
0.0576883703,
-1.040055871,
0.2634066045,
-0.1433150768,
-0.205229044,
0.0848419368,
-0.0750932842,
-0.2217742503,
0.0638221577,
0.331712842,
0.550006628,
-0.3322548568,
0.2281166613,
0.1057263315,
-0.4132436514,
-0.1543056369,
0.0207997542,
0.5390090942,
-0.1331000924,
-0.3857192695,
-0.6758292913,
0.5886746645,
0.6576730013,
-0.224510029,
0.6385185719,
0.9472336769,
-0.2583779097,
-0.1367939711,
-0.7133059502,
-0.3565838039,
-0.4369745255,
0.1701966971,
-0.5680724978,
-0.64039886,
0.4586366713,
0.0072321747,
-0.0543851443,
0.5348804593,
0.5964318514,
-0.0625960007,
1.1359933615,
0.7529305816,
-0.1494307965,
0.4862000942,
-0.0528730713,
0.0257554986,
-0.3292482495,
-0.5370482206,
-0.2316103429,
-0.3772879839,
-0.0307959113,
-0.6022577286,
0.5869137645,
-0.134501487,
0.1045245007,
-0.0428161621,
-0.1857271194,
0.5806381702,
0.554956615,
0.4196967185,
0.2229830772,
-0.1924981326,
0.0789103433,
0.138459906,
-0.7164888978,
-0.1302371472,
0.5876125693,
0.2509488463,
0.7669480443,
-0.0777438581,
0.431666553,
0.188669309,
-0.3634232879,
-1.0997698307,
0.6180884838,
0.1447294205,
-0.5558234453,
0.0269999485,
-0.3249436319,
-0.4588241875,
0.5528329015,
-0.4387907386,
-0.319365859,
0.335310787,
0.0605436303,
-0.7981669903,
-0.0443284214,
-0.8778607845,
0.9458642602,
-0.1206951067,
-0.2700114548,
-0.5376636386,
-1.0411854982,
0.5100913644,
0.2499390095,
0.4703332186,
-0.2981665134,
-0.219415471,
0.35199368,
-0.2967018783,
1.0698385239,
-0.3432832062,
0.1050394699,
0.2963283956,
0.0829371586,
0.1775334179,
0.2142914236,
0.0888323486,
-0.1651319414,
-0.2188247442,
-0.5125440955,
-0.6154700518,
0.5191242099,
-0.6659417152,
-0.439154923,
-0.3859892786,
-0.6164251566,
-0.3011209369,
0.0687041655,
0.2417507172,
0.7281746268,
0.0524533354,
0.0684597194,
0.7138260007,
0.1533232033,
0.6667724848,
0.3969413638,
0.2468512207,
-0.415050298,
0.8266237378,
-0.2664161623,
0.1457051039,
0.2527598441,
0.2634119987,
-0.0419673324,
-0.1770109832,
-0.587300837,
0.127160728,
-0.9751527905,
-0.5157200694,
-0.6239327788,
0.2303788215,
-0.4589133263,
-0.2633909881,
-0.147372514,
-0.3412200212,
-0.6210567355,
0.073033601,
0.4117753804,
0.4753772616,
0.0034222822,
0.4935810268,
-1.0449228287,
0.5884307623,
0.4083356559,
-0.2149322927,
-0.0630491972,
-0.510328114,
0.109193176,
-0.0828179792,
-0.0422169715,
-1.0755816698,
0.2205351144,
0.2229326963,
0.6583191752,
0.6944196224,
0.012296333,
0.5004965067,
-0.2236378491,
1.0411638021,
0.6971637011,
-0.896794498,
0.5648080111,
-0.3141471744,
0.4216318429,
0.8912827969,
0.2720602155,
-0.4919825494,
-0.0413919091,
-0.3243787587,
-0.6637163162,
0.8170319796,
-0.2856144607,
0.2757830024,
0.0687955618,
-0.0678240508,
0.7076640725,
0.2891713977,
-0.6127447486,
-0.2206865996,
-0.2959645092,
-0.6242489815,
0.2671886086,
-0.2392607629,
-0.2792842984,
-0.2214348614,
0.408631146,
-0.4225421846,
0.072346203,
-0.0062806779,
-0.5608702898,
0.1195319295,
0.536282599,
0.5182375312,
0.554215312,
0.1156219468,
0.3901572227,
0.0084740501,
-0.2031900138,
0.0417941399,
0.0275077634,
-0.004091775,
0.0158581939,
0.4315340519,
0.7393467426,
0.3263272047,
-0.715236187,
0.8813515306,
0.117111519,
0.2082480341,
0.1673513055,
0.13913019,
-0.4396208823,
0.3633302748,
0.6413519979,
0.6266251802,
0.2543970048,
-0.6649499536,
0.1274411082,
0.4114131927,
-0.3496834636,
-0.5305829048,
0.2181744725,
0.5761682987,
-0.0097242491,
0.3962131143,
-0.3575617373,
-0.6941851974,
0.458516717,
0.2068314254,
0.8656542301,
-0.0457089879,
0.439797014,
-0.0094579896,
0.116757907,
0.1247627139,
0.3788406849,
-0.1994181573,
-0.6707498431,
-0.3743762374,
-0.132019192,
-0.2097308189,
-0.2067189068,
-0.3086104691,
0.512196064,
-0.411408335,
-0.0869503245,
-0.0029039625,
-0.2931314707,
-0.9086357951,
0.1454162598,
0.3697171509,
0.793279469,
-1.0167486668,
0.4266189933,
0.7519343495,
-0.765750587,
-0.6289415359,
-0.0856148899,
0.3954167068,
-0.7349513173,
0.4893729687,
0.3960407972,
-0.3122253418,
-0.1397636831,
-0.6175422668,
-0.262662679,
1.0046181679,
0.2663680911,
-0.2889415026,
0.0879053697,
-0.3838668466,
0.0985012501,
-0.4754505455,
0.6786323786,
0.436819613,
0.5875819921,
0.2230999172,
-0.8566138148,
0.0110568739,
-0.250408709,
-0.3450867534,
-0.1305446029,
-0.7586781979,
0.951076746,
-0.1601344943,
-0.0558423251,
-0.1490969211,
0.855298996,
0.1745355129,
0.5736221075,
0.8066295981,
0.2401470393,
0.7517135143,
0.1066188365,
0.9123407006,
-0.1256702989,
0.0342473723,
0.8783336878,
-0.1018493921,
0.4892733693,
0.561846137,
0.2052815557,
0.647390902,
0.6644236445,
0.1900724322,
0.7297493219,
-0.55981493,
-0.5597688556,
-0.7564860582,
-0.3527317941,
-0.3227039278,
0.4335650802,
0.1901042163,
-0.2422439754,
-0.3059315979,
0.5042463541,
-0.0902601928,
-0.0236538444,
-0.4843387604,
0.9074195623,
0.0290677622,
-0.4717407227,
0.1713654697,
-0.0742637888,
1.0784497261,
-0.4863844216,
0.0968725681,
-0.0925531089,
-0.0962394327,
-0.3204499185,
-0.7430070639,
-0.3080362678,
-0.1984513104,
-0.4305516779,
-0.0752919242,
0.9858167768,
-0.4830815494,
-0.4461489618,
-0.0143847931,
0.8652274013,
-0.0877053738,
-0.2916732728,
-0.7384947538,
-0.0805193856,
-0.2322101444,
-0.2461135685,
0.1190606505,
0.6462098956,
0.2338135689,
0.5223380923,
0.3296276033,
-0.4032165408,
0.1705422103,
0.3165917397,
1.1549777985,
-0.6064867973,
-0.5387140512,
-0.9528725147,
0.9049037099,
0.0041071167,
-0.4880263209,
0.5562613606,
0.1568495929,
0.4393369555,
-0.3073110282,
0.7453077435,
-0.1861161143,
0.1918931305,
-0.6434922218,
0.3307718039,
-0.6951748729,
-0.1333767027,
-0.2006946802,
-0.6728956699,
-0.1787407994,
0.4743690491,
-0.0490982495,
0.1118288562,
0.7364736199,
0.7997881174,
-0.2405822724,
-0.0545476153,
0.3802914917,
-0.0510902591,
0.1204130128,
0.5585696101,
1.0240085125,
-0.1628686339,
0.6146495342,
-0.3582232893,
-0.3008909822,
-0.3689218163,
-0.7986434698,
-1.0436835289,
-0.6225041747,
-0.3075197637,
-0.0719652101,
-0.470230788,
1.5303497314,
0.7789973617,
-0.6799680591,
0.3803879619,
0.2076005787,
0.3896253407,
-0.1901857108,
-0.2691839933,
0.0283725765,
-0.6782464981,
-0.6573505998,
0.8240013719,
0.4422414601,
-0.1407105774,
-0.4694307745,
0.0652153715,
-0.0560033359,
0.0547883883,
0.7448102832,
-0.0552567244,
-0.9013569355,
-0.235631749,
0.2302677929,
-0.2291384786,
0.0281028897,
0.9383678436,
-1.1261262894,
0.5545842648,
0.9614665508,
0.7208081484,
-0.0187844764,
0.1565287262,
0.3859849572,
-0.9154825807,
0.4022454023,
0.3576202095,
0.4690904319,
0.3014448583,
-0.401422888,
0.1953337938,
0.6174997687,
-0.2037240118,
-0.64994663,
0.3253188729,
-1.5600521564,
-0.4881850481,
1.2156784534,
0.061751157,
-0.322516948,
-0.257399112,
-0.6915010214,
-0.0424332432,
-0.7281833291,
0.4666104317,
0.6060782075,
-0.0656169504,
-0.4926220179,
-0.0616432354,
0.1646470875,
0.5641108155,
-0.6490349174,
-0.2468325347,
0.9599098563,
0.0220733993,
0.166022718,
0.5908372402,
0.282815963,
0.6082568169,
-0.0242773276,
-0.1812208146,
-0.4325584173,
-0.6853950024,
-0.5454844832,
0.4034231603,
-0.2775559723,
-0.338175118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11299v1
|
SQ-LLaVA: Self-Questioning for Large Vision-Language Assistant
| 2024-03-17T18:42:38 | 2024-03-17T18:42:38 |
Guohao Sun, Can Qin, Jiamian Wang, Zeyuan Chen, Ran Xu, Zhiqiang Tao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in the vision-language model have shown notable
generalization in vision-language tasks after visual instruction tuning.
However, bridging the gap between the pre-trained vision encoder and the large
language models becomes the whole network's bottleneck. To improve
cross-modality alignment, existing works usually consider more visual
instruction data covering a broader range of vision tasks to fine-tune the
model for question-answering, which are costly to obtain. However, the image
contains rich contextual information that has been largely under-explored. This
paper first attempts to harness this overlooked context within visual
instruction data, training the model to self-supervised `learning' how to ask
high-quality questions. In this way, we introduce a novel framework named
SQ-LLaVA: Self-Questioning for Large Vision-Language Assistant. SQ-LLaVA
exhibits proficiency in generating flexible and meaningful image-related
questions while analyzing the visual clue and prior language knowledge,
signifying an advanced level of generalized visual understanding. Moreover,
fine-tuning SQ-LLaVA on higher-quality instruction data shows a consistent
performance improvement compared with traditional visual-instruction tuning
methods. This improvement highlights the efficacy of self-questioning
techniques in achieving a deeper and more nuanced comprehension of visual
content across various contexts.
|
[
-0.5172228813,
-1.2056994438,
0.4835298061,
-0.0694321916,
-0.1676832289,
-0.2009058446,
-0.0415372774,
-0.4760301709,
0.3530978262,
0.6032441854,
-0.611243844,
-0.1857220083,
-0.4257669449,
0.1514489502,
-0.2475773394,
0.2881211042,
-0.1443381906,
0.1655883491,
-0.3246009946,
-0.2415539324,
-0.8033798933,
-0.1656178236,
-0.5405312181,
0.3031496704,
0.5958044529,
0.6826878786,
0.63605088,
0.5427850485,
0.4494200349,
0.4164486229,
0.4619067609,
0.4525502026,
-0.4048530459,
0.415605247,
-0.2246335745,
-0.7462435961,
-0.2889903188,
-0.2693223953,
0.6382713914,
0.3367198408,
0.0948540643,
0.4247685075,
-0.1118366271,
0.5897365212,
-0.6944450736,
-0.138356477,
-0.5197852254,
0.1246237382,
-0.1204782575,
-0.3152489662,
-0.0809315145,
0.0251011979,
-0.0271784756,
-0.8292418718,
0.0258521568,
0.2561267316,
1.0255957842,
0.7263435125,
-0.4848120213,
-0.1451807767,
-0.3629842103,
0.5662218332,
-0.1339101493,
0.5251463652,
0.5054516792,
0.6323215961,
0.1699709743,
-0.6246233582,
-0.8138676286,
0.0432747081,
0.1114206612,
0.0932091847,
-0.1429427564,
-0.107205905,
0.1169891059,
0.3924173117,
-0.8236614466,
-0.0457553603,
-0.5157504678,
-0.1034010574,
0.6704242229,
0.1070107892,
0.3372112513,
-0.162806794,
-0.4295944571,
-0.1592516452,
-0.5730053186,
0.0648804083,
0.1507876813,
-0.2685347497,
0.2014772594,
0.753379643,
-0.3535699844,
0.8766453266,
0.3028488159,
0.0293909255,
0.0387196206,
-0.355443269,
-0.4346152246,
-0.2584653199,
0.6182056069,
0.5129469037,
0.5516548753,
0.3044377267,
-0.2009629011,
-0.2250717878,
0.3376664519,
-0.474781096,
-0.1446947157,
0.0626901165,
-0.1379828453,
-0.0862558261,
-0.3975730538,
-0.7627547383,
-0.066137515,
-0.4572409391,
0.8929360509,
-0.1883538663,
0.0100769661,
0.0481682047,
0.264308691,
0.700912714,
0.7495589256,
-0.9123347998,
-0.1843011975,
0.3389657736,
0.388137877,
-0.173083663,
-0.4922067821,
-0.6547282934,
0.1689336002,
-0.6052578092,
0.7214040756,
-0.531441927,
-0.0992054939,
-0.0940615088,
0.1639334112,
-0.1780419201,
-0.4847492874,
-0.1249331012,
-0.6295263171,
0.5655037761,
-0.4352426529,
-0.4380882978,
-0.0073710126,
0.7245715857,
-0.3457093239,
1.1109120846,
0.1570804864,
-0.5306277871,
0.3155201972,
-0.3148396313,
-0.0735536218,
0.2855915129,
-0.7461274862,
-0.245269388,
-0.1050095633,
0.8426741362,
0.4367426932,
-0.1790214181,
0.2129283547,
-0.1508912742,
-0.2885686755,
0.1555074304,
-0.4667930603,
0.5725927949,
0.1791874319,
-0.4382239878,
0.1968699396,
-0.5594884753,
0.171281755,
0.227831021,
0.0024493216,
-0.3964979053,
-0.6482737064,
-0.39197281,
0.0375953466,
0.5726685524,
-0.4015289843,
0.340921998,
-0.1568398476,
0.0062467707,
0.7365592122,
0.0261649434,
0.4214429855,
0.1291211993,
0.8652225733,
-0.2161408663,
0.7110788226,
-0.3270803988,
-0.5308043361,
-1.0607943535,
0.0182185415,
0.0184316449,
0.6504240036,
-1.1696619987,
0.1695094705,
0.0390109606,
-0.1347515136,
-0.8512932062,
0.4460046291,
0.5049144626,
0.808250308,
0.4947823286,
-0.2941696942,
-0.3478210568,
-1.0088992119,
0.1263777465,
-0.1057134643,
0.1686568558,
0.5726127625,
0.4326895773,
-0.2622567117,
0.7418981791,
-0.6326182485,
-0.3479267657,
-0.0942660496,
0.0241858624,
-0.2341151536,
0.433124274,
0.351896137,
-0.9068435431,
-0.4631462693,
-0.0648171753,
-1.0099936724,
-0.0269042347,
-0.2317746729,
-0.3128809631,
0.0987982005,
0.8117889166,
-0.5023830533,
0.465026021,
0.4635805786,
-0.2868288457,
0.5994121432,
-0.3275557756,
0.4263635278,
-0.9404224157,
-0.0735569,
-0.2429872602,
-0.1581825763,
-0.5150561929,
0.3517848551,
0.0896449834,
-0.1702778041,
-0.3617151976,
0.6210130453,
-0.6094909906,
-0.3579055071,
-0.2599937916,
0.0268836785,
0.2310868651,
0.5539653897,
-0.0845961347,
1.1655297279,
0.8662326932,
-0.3647184074,
0.4895658493,
0.395737648,
-0.3201513886,
0.8971038461,
-0.7881791592,
0.1712166816,
-0.2269663662,
-0.1315605044,
-1.1592732668,
-0.2698341906,
0.2538333237,
-0.463865459,
0.386774689,
-0.1754956394,
-0.1398367137,
-0.3053097427,
0.1174912825,
0.8345758319,
0.2518570423,
-0.7499024272,
0.6280969381,
0.3651716709,
-0.0805644393,
-1.0120645761,
-0.5797992349,
0.2927422225,
-0.1791295409,
-0.920286417,
-0.2253046185,
-0.1069174036,
-0.0463449024,
-0.2351750135,
-0.0536737069,
-0.2256168425,
-0.1334639341,
0.049769327,
0.2648750842,
-0.453178972,
0.2786419988,
-0.0092060529,
0.0694748312,
0.0655080974,
-0.0977936834,
0.3402080238,
-0.2904084325,
-0.5849436522,
-0.4294646382,
0.4708074033,
0.2442534417,
-0.4891367853,
0.0375521556,
0.7056388855,
0.1034958661,
-0.0904452503,
-0.8412431479,
-0.1257154197,
-0.5448932648,
0.3703694642,
-0.6877445579,
-1.078614831,
0.1174785197,
0.0821545348,
-0.2146425992,
0.138157472,
0.4528284371,
-0.5656177402,
0.8953661323,
0.6779842377,
0.1527760178,
0.4031924307,
-0.2803567946,
-0.014770411,
-0.6558055878,
-0.2986830473,
0.0562597066,
-0.3036233783,
-0.1081140041,
-0.9272648692,
0.4932878017,
-0.0472699627,
-0.1057095453,
0.2483123541,
-0.4514209926,
0.5388473272,
0.604611516,
-0.022402918,
0.1508131772,
-0.031410493,
0.1558970362,
-0.0312971435,
-0.5951761007,
-0.1711440384,
0.7890962958,
0.4242413044,
1.0495119095,
-0.2274161279,
0.7183018327,
0.009458079,
-0.3033828735,
-0.6177824736,
0.6765338778,
0.3381758928,
-0.6500607729,
-0.8777459264,
-0.180641979,
-1.0939333439,
0.5507109165,
-0.0702077001,
-0.4968257844,
0.5852895975,
0.5048645735,
-0.2188469023,
0.0329734534,
-0.6940758824,
1.1261136532,
-0.7961482406,
-0.4497478306,
-0.1576833874,
-0.7968603969,
0.4678380191,
0.183393091,
-0.0790996253,
0.0498151742,
-0.1239461228,
0.2876742184,
-0.2257530838,
0.8700054288,
-0.0788855925,
-0.4113526344,
0.4199052155,
0.152457118,
0.2418744415,
0.0929592103,
0.5776889324,
0.00179151,
0.0366588868,
-0.4507047534,
-0.870274663,
0.4943616688,
-0.6786139607,
-0.9790759087,
-0.229686439,
-0.5140860677,
-0.3471005261,
0.1748595238,
0.2086065412,
0.3301170468,
-0.0226922203,
0.0447014943,
0.9737778902,
-0.4395172596,
0.0533879101,
0.2451506406,
-0.3720441461,
-0.3428982198,
0.8795912862,
-0.0397159681,
0.3990987837,
0.5608082414,
0.1037973985,
-0.241605863,
-0.1677338034,
-0.9028343558,
0.2484316677,
-0.7601536512,
-0.1865033209,
-0.5068395734,
0.0293546524,
-0.4941720366,
-0.0903440863,
-0.4513379335,
-0.2970230281,
-0.2881563306,
0.1380054653,
0.0681082234,
0.4489487112,
0.1169724911,
0.1261273026,
-0.4362390041,
0.462023139,
1.07160151,
0.0916861296,
-0.1894737929,
-0.6068969369,
-0.0502667576,
-0.0929070339,
-0.09915483,
-0.9143202305,
0.3938143551,
0.2667481899,
0.4473709464,
0.2998281419,
-0.1970898062,
1.0491813421,
-0.4363637865,
0.7089906931,
0.2539960742,
-0.7060545683,
0.7960371971,
-0.112712428,
0.4087792635,
0.5563523173,
0.4113487601,
-0.330929637,
-0.1765255034,
-0.2939310074,
-0.7190979719,
0.2423867732,
-0.0677758455,
0.1191638187,
0.1225452721,
0.3438963294,
0.0421416461,
0.0520429648,
-0.6425055265,
-0.0595439821,
-0.5259029865,
-0.0787942931,
0.0321200043,
-0.1899804175,
-0.3680979609,
-0.5199363232,
0.3246001005,
-0.6235151291,
0.1646722257,
0.4855574369,
-0.423917979,
-0.1775560528,
0.1870797724,
0.5189288259,
0.7573403716,
0.1448053867,
0.2116258889,
0.4335664809,
-0.3203072548,
-0.0090320287,
-0.3301112354,
-0.1790337861,
-0.2405815125,
0.2879662514,
0.8964519501,
0.1092596874,
-0.7917026877,
0.8742184639,
-0.2187771797,
-0.3064395785,
-0.3383683562,
0.2085188478,
-0.1265452206,
0.4462965727,
0.3517339528,
-0.4400597513,
0.1966945678,
-0.5928233266,
0.3143614531,
0.5033397675,
-0.3210591376,
0.037121322,
0.4204810262,
0.0373370126,
0.0390007906,
0.5125362277,
0.1603548378,
-0.4216417968,
0.5978679061,
0.3616285026,
0.3864703476,
-0.3424153626,
0.3626840115,
0.333748132,
0.3752584755,
0.2586322427,
0.6212498546,
-0.4320718348,
-0.5083153248,
-0.536565125,
-0.3229278326,
-0.2947685421,
-0.0761507452,
-0.5490680933,
0.0257929582,
-0.2541708946,
0.1486574262,
-0.3956280053,
-0.1535634845,
-0.7122642994,
0.5751337409,
0.222175017,
0.7857746482,
-0.6624099612,
0.9610145688,
0.5700042248,
-0.6122047305,
-0.8967540264,
-0.1623701155,
-0.3672689497,
-1.4011698961,
0.937643528,
0.0596251488,
-0.1137550399,
-0.1672703177,
-0.8273048997,
-1.1557590961,
1.1683086157,
0.2575206459,
-0.7362020016,
-0.2500510812,
0.1510710567,
0.5232329369,
-0.3940238357,
0.2712949812,
0.3352776766,
0.4542433619,
0.4042833745,
-0.8485125899,
-0.0373289548,
-0.2650947571,
-0.1616421789,
0.0792328715,
-0.7408655286,
0.7315505743,
-0.3544978499,
-0.009003411,
0.0071142134,
0.9545757174,
-0.0112969065,
0.45321545,
0.6801607609,
0.4426723421,
0.6611856222,
0.163469702,
0.7902759314,
-0.1285880208,
-0.0397216752,
1.149911046,
0.0355550796,
0.7397706509,
0.7440043092,
0.2393697351,
0.3078295887,
0.4802135527,
-0.2489587814,
0.2632467747,
-0.0529129207,
0.1503477991,
-0.6725149751,
0.1842028797,
-0.4158994257,
0.7857557535,
0.3407149315,
-0.0816830918,
-0.0495535694,
0.1023888737,
-0.7181124091,
0.0603709929,
-0.348259151,
0.808481276,
0.0196344219,
-0.8815749884,
0.8256672025,
-0.5130673051,
0.4593496323,
-0.4522977769,
-0.1368404627,
-0.4313056171,
-0.1009313613,
0.0147506138,
-0.9596033692,
0.0911970586,
-0.235281989,
0.2646062672,
-0.0502238832,
0.6231517792,
-0.6980419159,
-0.2644367218,
-0.066492185,
0.6420930624,
0.3761311471,
0.0377438068,
-0.9983336926,
-0.0332912393,
0.0117666069,
-0.1521114707,
0.3925435841,
0.6037657261,
-0.1697069705,
0.8512811661,
0.3135548234,
-0.2081915289,
0.2848872542,
0.1791698933,
0.7857731581,
-0.6239153147,
-0.4600682855,
-0.3374106586,
0.3533760905,
-0.1327378303,
-0.6836651564,
0.7803207636,
0.3294824362,
0.7943977714,
-0.0885569751,
0.3506324887,
0.1856930256,
0.127197057,
-0.5532540679,
0.2581158876,
-1.0661091805,
-0.0168371778,
-0.0907124802,
-0.7140059471,
-0.10616301,
0.8087381721,
-0.3993305862,
-0.1106436327,
0.5182019472,
1.0949651003,
-0.0977115184,
-0.2099976242,
0.7160237432,
-0.0611660443,
0.1312057674,
0.4975195527,
1.0546617508,
-0.511636138,
0.7042130232,
-0.14501445,
-0.1653177142,
-0.3527726531,
-0.4055782855,
-0.95599401,
-0.6925416589,
-0.2378464788,
-0.0081656286,
0.2231112272,
0.5656735301,
0.6956985593,
-0.4495874941,
-0.1211206168,
0.0963271037,
-0.0854578614,
-0.0560220852,
-0.164382562,
0.4333161116,
-0.5597625971,
-0.65480721,
0.6068413258,
0.3818716109,
0.1143968329,
-0.6843303442,
-0.0808513239,
-0.2683395743,
-0.0024918662,
0.5081223845,
0.6273319721,
-0.7207974195,
-0.3111206889,
0.3580572009,
-0.2436449379,
0.2142543048,
0.5625420213,
-0.6074118614,
0.9017407298,
0.4904844761,
0.9318776727,
0.6658449173,
0.220348224,
0.6466264129,
-0.7938096523,
-0.1291250437,
0.1769804955,
0.3831896186,
0.4304802418,
-0.7375815511,
0.3907302022,
-0.0498932116,
-0.706220448,
-0.5481643677,
0.4068963528,
-0.9958666563,
-0.4032864273,
1.0781213045,
0.0251574609,
-0.4723574817,
-0.0472745821,
-0.6628324986,
0.0419232585,
0.0756190866,
0.7781449556,
0.2627514303,
-0.2556387782,
-0.6556392908,
-0.4828915894,
0.3729971051,
0.919858098,
-0.7920176387,
-0.0799703747,
0.6809261441,
0.2725638449,
-0.0452506244,
0.6675642729,
0.0656625777,
0.646707952,
-0.0643854141,
0.0828127414,
-0.1710775346,
-0.5888538361,
-0.2748862505,
0.2209031135,
-0.0159809459,
-0.4616664946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11297v1
|
A Modified Word Saliency-Based Adversarial Attack on Text Classification Models
| 2024-03-17T18:39:14 | 2024-03-17T18:39:14 |
Hetvi Waghela, Sneha Rakshit, Jaydip Sen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces a novel adversarial attack method targeting text
classification models, termed the Modified Word Saliency-based Adversarial
At-tack (MWSAA). The technique builds upon the concept of word saliency to
strategically perturb input texts, aiming to mislead classification models
while preserving semantic coherence. By refining the traditional adversarial
attack approach, MWSAA significantly enhances its efficacy in evading detection
by classification systems. The methodology involves first identifying salient
words in the input text through a saliency estimation process, which
prioritizes words most influential to the model's decision-making process.
Subsequently, these salient words are subjected to carefully crafted
modifications, guided by semantic similarity metrics to ensure that the altered
text remains coherent and retains its original meaning. Empirical evaluations
conducted on diverse text classification datasets demonstrate the effectiveness
of the proposed method in generating adversarial examples capable of
successfully deceiving state-of-the-art classification models. Comparative
analyses with existing adversarial attack techniques further indicate the
superiority of the proposed approach in terms of both attack success rate and
preservation of text coherence.
|
[
-0.4523543715,
-1.1890960932,
0.2060511112,
-0.0771007016,
-0.5833580494,
0.0878243446,
0.041744221,
-0.5228155851,
0.4493124783,
0.5184102654,
-0.4007303715,
-0.4733884931,
-0.9866484404,
0.0176204573,
-0.6740252376,
1.1589140892,
0.1688347012,
-0.1239023432,
0.0265611429,
-0.1021847725,
-0.3926898837,
-0.6237230897,
-0.6933359504,
0.0467691645,
0.8667905331,
-0.0913573503,
0.9506499767,
0.3257064223,
0.9531691074,
0.3195724785,
-0.4323766828,
-0.0306502152,
-0.439573735,
-0.0212435126,
-0.0370958298,
-0.54441154,
-0.4099065661,
0.3019019067,
0.4116173983,
0.3250819743,
0.1061978266,
-0.1547051668,
0.0352821164,
0.6153761148,
-1.1950218678,
-0.285711199,
-1.129077673,
0.0671935156,
-0.5351140499,
-0.3040483892,
-0.5956934094,
-0.2365968972,
0.2035214156,
-0.4154998064,
0.3632626235,
-0.0574872084,
1.0255790949,
0.4851392806,
-0.0385441221,
-0.2755490541,
-0.1677424312,
0.9011931419,
-0.4478781521,
0.0837120339,
0.4638817608,
0.3262905777,
-0.4801284671,
-0.6679897308,
-0.4745052755,
-0.2490252703,
0.0327068381,
0.292866081,
-0.4840016961,
0.1186280027,
0.0657939762,
0.1865635514,
-0.1915442497,
-0.1584793627,
-0.283157289,
-0.1269704252,
0.7401298285,
-0.2379520386,
0.4945183694,
-0.2390591353,
-0.947018683,
-0.1848855615,
-0.5541226864,
-0.0513631515,
0.2832113504,
0.1632722169,
0.1577208787,
0.481444031,
-0.1416719109,
0.7885363698,
0.0053330176,
0.0281927139,
-0.1671449691,
-0.1204639897,
-0.391518265,
0.3329685926,
0.7240362763,
0.2895421088,
-0.0809042901,
-0.2845005989,
-0.3128331304,
0.3925421834,
0.8167060018,
-0.3943363726,
-0.3736266494,
-0.118200101,
-0.2659433186,
-1.0670636892,
0.1541468799,
-1.0099700689,
-0.5542092919,
0.2547944188,
0.5656058192,
-0.5572696924,
0.4641614854,
-0.0588311255,
-0.340082556,
-0.1538644731,
0.4593175054,
-0.8021096587,
0.2081741691,
0.6771351099,
0.8024950624,
-0.2429249883,
-0.2962535918,
-0.4844796658,
0.2753987014,
-0.3415353298,
0.7502218485,
-0.6045904756,
-0.528232336,
-0.2551757395,
-0.2558527887,
-0.0480527766,
-0.1541117281,
0.5546039939,
-1.0507243872,
0.5391469002,
-0.0615660176,
-0.2770925462,
-0.5640165806,
0.7747694254,
-0.8210021257,
0.7255197763,
-0.0879592821,
-1.1340905428,
0.3678056598,
-0.7260514498,
-0.2938817143,
-0.0193469469,
0.3310892284,
-0.6960013509,
0.3027967215,
0.1213509664,
0.3403916657,
0.1196986288,
-0.1650338173,
-0.4732694626,
-0.5506045222,
0.3332475126,
-0.9223843813,
0.5989485979,
0.0696905479,
-0.315118283,
0.2799614966,
-0.740342319,
-0.0219688155,
0.2064639777,
-0.2737718225,
-0.9106820226,
-0.0522367693,
-0.1085383296,
-0.0349736474,
0.5057533979,
-0.4835756719,
0.1946972907,
-0.7858034968,
-0.0624702685,
0.6388205886,
0.2437119484,
0.1520645022,
-0.1915391684,
0.4077349901,
-0.3108367324,
0.3545052707,
0.0761510506,
-0.529586792,
-0.7590637207,
-0.4756489694,
0.4186304808,
0.4931978285,
-0.9656362534,
0.3417411745,
0.1208193973,
-0.528260529,
-0.5939048529,
-0.3243336082,
0.6741672754,
0.1123016998,
0.6087408662,
-0.2991782725,
-0.4116065204,
-0.694390595,
-0.7635911107,
-0.2210031152,
0.2050306052,
-0.024234755,
0.4370312393,
-0.3217471242,
0.5062587857,
-0.7116734385,
-0.272924304,
0.1737377346,
0.2219443321,
-0.6268953681,
0.2934673727,
0.7442789078,
-1.0917180777,
-0.4447669983,
-0.2360076606,
-0.4593625963,
0.0938914865,
-0.0224291477,
-0.2840653062,
0.264029175,
0.4150543511,
-0.2018631548,
0.733887732,
0.5109884143,
-0.5793972015,
0.5777447224,
-0.1393892467,
0.4958376586,
-0.959238112,
-0.2398756146,
-0.0866621882,
-0.0727631897,
-0.7964462042,
0.5102071166,
-0.0377669446,
-0.0624682531,
-0.4761658311,
0.5515129566,
-0.164711535,
0.2173048258,
-0.6202676892,
0.2223052382,
0.0806384757,
0.3734169006,
-0.3588270545,
0.6041243672,
0.2227768302,
-0.4383364916,
0.4955615699,
0.3327507973,
0.067444779,
0.577462852,
-0.4345758557,
0.2075208277,
0.0512142815,
0.0822056532,
-0.85199821,
-0.0268717892,
0.4919050336,
-0.5434245467,
0.5275642276,
0.178071335,
-0.1813359112,
-0.1239881739,
-0.7776145339,
0.0060886238,
0.1219738722,
-0.8277145028,
0.4360635579,
0.2012707591,
-0.0838619396,
-0.8625821471,
-0.7491880655,
0.6051846147,
-0.3274394572,
-0.4197521806,
0.7470757365,
0.1665174514,
-0.2145927101,
-0.1414418668,
0.1261496544,
-0.1382462233,
0.6354243159,
0.0082818894,
0.4935933948,
0.2644050717,
-0.167737335,
-0.0418323837,
-0.108545579,
-0.0153272683,
0.250013411,
0.3638585806,
0.1250716001,
-0.3918389976,
-0.7465956807,
0.2372671366,
0.7218334675,
-0.2479470521,
0.7414785624,
0.7049572468,
-0.4262143672,
-0.0113666505,
-0.2841913998,
-0.1916674823,
-0.4994838834,
0.7547799945,
-0.3244867623,
-0.4200890958,
0.1262647957,
0.1978941113,
-0.0796838701,
0.4408955276,
0.0896137804,
-0.1212718412,
1.0512731075,
0.8419161439,
-0.3103548586,
0.7543593645,
-0.0680955425,
-0.0725122541,
-0.8315752149,
-0.3250343204,
-0.5309311152,
-0.3205008209,
-0.471601069,
-0.2964293361,
0.1247598752,
0.1646260023,
0.1720546037,
0.3066052496,
-0.5759319067,
0.3789127469,
0.3704143167,
0.3680917323,
0.0027672411,
0.2479725331,
0.0220576897,
-0.2200348675,
-0.6896912456,
-0.4885092676,
0.88831985,
0.2797171474,
0.503362298,
0.2991168201,
0.6937266588,
0.5529723167,
0.5149388313,
-0.7556768656,
0.7156411409,
-0.6123091578,
-0.2459205985,
-0.1764585823,
-0.1123010069,
-0.8066675067,
0.452866137,
-0.4677654505,
-0.6242437363,
0.0574391261,
0.1955154091,
-0.0473105237,
0.6432797909,
-0.6862764955,
0.6549369693,
-0.1712524444,
-0.2668769062,
-0.3387037218,
-0.356513679,
0.390042007,
-0.2729009986,
-0.0015780499,
0.3589966893,
-0.3204764724,
0.8547437787,
-0.3964082599,
0.9871185422,
-0.2685973644,
-0.2064716518,
-0.0261519141,
0.0298969802,
0.954641819,
-0.5269732475,
-0.0947153792,
0.1146445349,
-0.3501797318,
-0.4912517667,
-0.6932654977,
0.568885982,
-0.3996757865,
-0.7251963019,
-0.5206025839,
-0.3905419707,
-0.1745123863,
0.0460013598,
0.3690610826,
0.3737642467,
-0.6024708748,
0.0498065427,
0.4158862829,
-0.0727649108,
0.4839621484,
0.3111153543,
0.2289927751,
-0.6311120391,
1.2023122311,
-0.1374202818,
0.519577384,
0.3124304116,
0.0822196007,
-0.2511278093,
-0.7438784838,
-0.2936359644,
-0.1304832697,
-0.6408872008,
-0.0937534943,
-0.549057126,
0.0485023968,
-0.2147353142,
-0.5736227036,
-0.1027865931,
-0.2345582247,
-0.4542213976,
0.4688869119,
0.4552291036,
0.68975389,
0.6129409075,
0.5136992335,
-0.7197556496,
0.2044093311,
0.2727771699,
0.1024883166,
-0.0135920774,
-0.5749770403,
-0.2592120171,
-0.0401397906,
-0.4914861321,
-1.0844579935,
0.4569883943,
-0.0013214286,
0.366374135,
0.4540117383,
0.1865248978,
0.4890337586,
-0.386344105,
0.9365249276,
0.5018763542,
-0.8366839886,
0.6847103238,
0.0110544665,
0.3627259135,
0.5128034353,
0.1267829388,
-0.234952569,
-0.6967771053,
-0.9328052998,
-0.5560381413,
0.6049813628,
0.3319035769,
-0.1377405673,
0.2261603028,
0.2113472521,
-0.128365472,
0.3122571409,
-0.3051304817,
-0.2103490978,
-0.3748162985,
-0.3711658716,
0.0147490622,
-0.5105333328,
-0.1861130446,
0.220656395,
0.9770848155,
0.0243558194,
-0.0216149837,
0.1064020619,
0.0485836491,
0.2841538489,
0.4093867242,
0.5702831149,
-0.0765396655,
0.0011959745,
0.254496485,
0.5000753999,
-0.9810091257,
0.1435573101,
0.2966635227,
-0.5590277314,
-0.0159101505,
0.2796256244,
0.8143857121,
0.4790275395,
-0.3335939944,
0.4946140647,
-0.2137896568,
-0.0002717034,
0.170729503,
0.1400039345,
-0.5502313375,
0.2655327022,
0.225914374,
0.749717176,
0.228106752,
-0.4064076841,
0.2557103932,
0.8977572322,
-0.9333679676,
-0.2262154371,
0.4489962161,
0.0997721404,
-0.3366513252,
-0.3839721084,
-0.1042996943,
-1.0943136215,
0.6011267304,
0.4467570186,
0.9916707873,
-0.4663904011,
0.0199414138,
-0.1876172274,
0.382427454,
0.0638231561,
-0.0496508777,
0.0100319097,
-0.5655754209,
0.273637414,
-0.4692123532,
-0.3845813572,
0.1931569874,
-0.5622758865,
0.3167592287,
-0.711263001,
-0.296446532,
0.1192843616,
0.0925482661,
0.268207252,
0.7051443458,
0.0841587409,
0.5397619605,
-0.4210881293,
0.5877889991,
0.916428566,
-0.1742458194,
-0.2495012134,
0.5897096992,
0.1675000489,
-0.4260385036,
0.4357345104,
-0.0635710433,
-0.5863226056,
-0.1708680391,
-0.5994470716,
-0.8316722512,
0.7580884099,
0.076595448,
-0.1915348619,
0.1395516992,
-0.4083001614,
0.4476722181,
0.0076215081,
-0.3143136501,
0.4240109622,
0.3805567622,
0.0755262896,
-0.3617047071,
0.2052672207,
-0.2066269368,
0.0286833234,
0.2551741898,
-0.8120206594,
0.5914284587,
-0.1866711974,
-0.3220116198,
0.1846693009,
0.7894300818,
0.3475297391,
0.3070134819,
0.5728847384,
0.5195905566,
0.7375066876,
-0.2598170638,
1.1332070827,
-0.1704993546,
0.3262969255,
0.7375047207,
0.0588959046,
0.9328336716,
0.521699369,
-0.1258498132,
0.4368484318,
0.453817755,
-0.3413673639,
0.8687146306,
0.0605691187,
-0.5121855736,
0.1593283862,
0.0658250898,
-0.372502178,
0.5388582945,
0.2706831694,
-0.3702873588,
-0.0839314088,
0.3168072104,
0.2570259273,
0.3485178351,
-0.4273355007,
0.7552278638,
-0.2564347386,
-0.3926088512,
0.8325867653,
0.3600877225,
1.2199056149,
-0.756052494,
0.0747952983,
0.3802865446,
0.4494103789,
-0.2087066025,
-0.3659457266,
0.3098360002,
0.2875878215,
-0.3668923378,
0.2545349598,
1.1261502504,
-0.4772039354,
-0.5073802471,
0.2354190946,
-0.2876961529,
0.0157069359,
-0.1371166855,
-0.9295234084,
-0.0762279034,
0.1834347993,
-0.2462288588,
0.448476851,
0.2414958477,
0.0104995025,
0.5317118168,
0.5663986802,
0.3102541268,
-0.1745244712,
-0.0412757397,
0.7818616629,
-0.5660860538,
-0.8776043653,
-0.8525984287,
0.043187499,
-0.3205108643,
0.0054836101,
1.0252840519,
0.2137731314,
0.5037248731,
0.0148465028,
0.8145481944,
0.3269141316,
0.2515807152,
-0.733481288,
1.2570687532,
-0.6522274017,
0.2890022993,
-0.5900937319,
-0.3211145997,
-0.3937807679,
0.2892970145,
-0.4284296334,
0.03945335,
0.7262074351,
0.6248642802,
0.1692527533,
0.3660624921,
0.432970196,
0.0974675491,
0.3206788301,
0.2005132735,
0.6278010607,
-0.8309487104,
0.534300983,
-0.0783328936,
-0.4206860662,
-0.4701934755,
-0.5980759263,
-0.9113045931,
-0.1443167627,
-0.4509035051,
-0.3717495203,
0.6014878154,
0.4751494825,
0.2985866666,
-0.8161261082,
0.645542264,
0.0763554499,
0.0361055471,
-0.1586885303,
-0.2790563405,
0.6487078667,
-0.3454102278,
-0.672055006,
0.5391564369,
0.2330809385,
0.5279586315,
-0.3461701572,
0.2421533614,
-0.4406570792,
0.3579121828,
0.6420568824,
0.0260119699,
-0.7881087661,
-0.3664500713,
-0.3740282059,
-0.2976318598,
-0.2898749411,
0.4654115736,
-0.7287240624,
0.4735926092,
0.3008854389,
0.6727030277,
-0.0585962273,
0.2678672373,
0.3048838079,
-0.9606717229,
0.462964952,
0.1091706678,
0.2688215971,
0.489757508,
-0.712338388,
0.1128708348,
0.5924981833,
0.038854707,
-0.8676074743,
0.2209007144,
-0.683218658,
-0.6433240175,
0.8531473279,
-0.2661146224,
-0.5713346601,
-0.1942312419,
-0.438750118,
0.2381998301,
-0.3806090355,
1.2392803431,
0.654106319,
0.3418744802,
0.441832304,
-0.0797127858,
0.7986882329,
0.4981727898,
-0.8142538667,
-0.0225364193,
0.2280887514,
-0.0984355733,
0.4439501464,
0.1024358943,
-0.2265271842,
0.3537766635,
0.114506878,
-0.1472903788,
-0.1396183223,
-0.4259475172,
-0.5586290359,
0.5432958007,
-0.3952830434,
-0.5640892386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11265v1
|
Forging the Forger: An Attempt to Improve Authorship Verification via Data Augmentation
| 2024-03-17T16:36:26 | 2024-03-17T16:36:26 |
Silvia Corbara, Alejandro Moreo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Authorship Verification (AV) is a text classification task concerned with
inferring whether a candidate text has been written by one specific author or
by someone else. It has been shown that many AV systems are vulnerable to
adversarial attacks, where a malicious author actively tries to fool the
classifier by either concealing their writing style, or by imitating the style
of another author. In this paper, we investigate the potential benefits of
augmenting the classifier training set with (negative) synthetic examples.
These synthetic examples are generated to imitate the style of the author of
interest. We analyze the improvements in classifier prediction that this
augmentation brings to bear in the task of AV in an adversarial setting. In
particular, we experiment with three different generator architectures (one
based on Recurrent Neural Networks, another based on small-scale transformers,
and another based on the popular GPT model) and with two training strategies
(one inspired by standard Language Models, and another inspired by Wasserstein
Generative Adversarial Networks). We evaluate our hypothesis on five datasets
(three of which have been specifically collected to represent an adversarial
setting) and using two learning algorithms for the AV classifier (Support
Vector Machines and Convolutional Neural Networks). This experimentation has
yielded negative results, revealing that, although our methodology proves
effective in many adversarial settings, its benefits are too sporadic for a
pragmatical application.
|
[
-0.207708478,
-0.9262304306,
0.5100086331,
-0.4936614931,
-0.1074475273,
0.2223341465,
-0.0109911645,
-0.4623484015,
0.0763418302,
0.5270296335,
-0.2933596969,
-0.1780472696,
-0.6818522215,
0.3791246116,
-0.6178383231,
0.8309825659,
0.1996970028,
0.0050223097,
-0.5237268209,
-0.0816731825,
-0.5902403593,
-0.7183021307,
-0.7063593864,
-0.4581140578,
0.488221705,
-0.1648771465,
0.7699004412,
0.7545617819,
0.3245495856,
0.452696234,
0.1465705633,
0.2949027717,
-0.4016767144,
0.2054177076,
-0.1434949338,
-0.5796451569,
-0.0603331439,
0.20943138,
0.4989590049,
0.30447644,
0.5134590864,
0.0165980104,
-0.1685132533,
0.4650510848,
-0.7612218857,
0.0229686871,
-0.6990014315,
-0.0581901558,
-0.4317795634,
-0.3414037228,
-0.7694602013,
-0.4141076207,
-0.1589379609,
-0.4813727438,
0.5417426825,
0.0191487055,
0.6385042667,
0.1796022356,
-0.4238026738,
-0.2620702684,
-1.007111907,
0.5826460123,
-0.4004956186,
0.0741025135,
0.1870900691,
0.3884999752,
-0.1230179667,
-0.592790246,
-0.8522373438,
-0.2903721929,
-0.2496237308,
-0.0445520654,
-0.1872884333,
0.1506232619,
0.3501724601,
0.8456169963,
-0.3935009837,
-0.0835690871,
-0.6031985283,
-0.4088799953,
0.9167796969,
-0.0789743289,
0.4261839986,
0.1422736943,
-0.3129201531,
-0.5287004113,
-0.9205190539,
0.3576313853,
0.9842648506,
0.4922191501,
0.3309707344,
0.7345822453,
0.2082211524,
0.6805127859,
0.3421615958,
0.171663478,
0.378701508,
0.0259318445,
-0.1996635944,
0.2471533716,
0.5533502698,
-0.2011817396,
0.0227170438,
-0.3668034375,
-0.309268117,
0.3634721637,
0.6362817287,
-0.5371512175,
-0.3272109926,
0.1930361539,
-0.3462862372,
-0.7881968021,
0.5804585218,
-0.3246081471,
-0.8065374494,
-0.508617878,
0.8550277948,
-0.6344584227,
-0.1882923096,
-0.3435888886,
-0.5364790559,
0.3237834573,
0.3452364504,
-0.7079341412,
-0.1154080033,
1.0047197342,
0.5348864794,
0.0198001675,
-0.3812630773,
-0.8940622211,
-0.316727221,
-0.6491318941,
0.5204547048,
-0.4806579649,
-0.1350130588,
0.2171943486,
0.0175720397,
0.0357248671,
-0.3494958878,
0.3810709119,
-0.7530665398,
0.2818762064,
-0.4281546474,
-0.5914625525,
-0.2975639403,
0.4264323115,
-0.8665319681,
0.8600260019,
0.1541980356,
-0.5112276077,
0.5796428919,
-0.2918747067,
-0.5884180069,
0.1894358397,
-0.4284830689,
-0.7998282313,
0.2561722696,
0.2193077505,
0.4482574463,
0.0925484747,
-0.1657321006,
-0.2628762722,
-0.4472637773,
0.3571838439,
-0.3651388288,
0.9574197531,
0.2108859569,
-0.326554209,
0.009160025,
-0.730488658,
-0.3224090934,
0.0025405164,
-0.1940607131,
-0.5413348079,
-0.1149127707,
-0.24842076,
-0.183521539,
-0.1884790063,
-0.8488625288,
0.2823725641,
-0.6920124888,
-0.2323272526,
1.135226965,
0.135376662,
0.3594709039,
-0.6952317953,
0.730034411,
-0.3643367589,
-0.1381650269,
-0.3146452308,
-0.3602041304,
-0.5241926312,
-0.426145494,
0.4576202035,
0.4250994325,
-1.3446354866,
0.2832448184,
-0.1707659811,
-0.4926194251,
-0.5541878343,
0.233813718,
0.5323733091,
0.2370581627,
0.3099233508,
-0.161257714,
-0.6201864481,
-0.5284875631,
-0.7147526145,
-0.3650327921,
-0.0632617399,
0.0084491242,
0.4625717103,
-0.1304239184,
0.7341862917,
-0.0738075823,
-0.3105947673,
-0.2630999982,
0.1603726,
0.0172572695,
0.472081095,
0.6421826482,
-0.7803432345,
-0.3587415814,
0.0923971981,
-0.8109313846,
0.2264234126,
-0.5856159329,
0.1342248172,
-0.0155047309,
0.5787379742,
-0.3240239024,
0.5431701541,
0.2525523603,
-0.3395034075,
0.6420171261,
0.0754051805,
0.3617832363,
-1.0781611204,
-0.1006959677,
-0.0763050392,
-0.3275468349,
-0.8166179657,
0.3095263839,
-0.3005428314,
-0.1457668841,
-0.3455190063,
0.3857171834,
-0.3944366574,
0.3578718603,
-0.2545473576,
-0.4468206763,
-0.1077183485,
0.3291007876,
-0.2846265733,
0.9456855655,
0.5595604777,
-0.5382984877,
0.7247600555,
0.2289957106,
-0.140279144,
0.6050174236,
-0.6062660813,
0.3450476229,
-0.4415658116,
0.0713437349,
-1.027982235,
-0.2950891554,
0.2269388884,
-0.8379457593,
0.7282040119,
-0.2462367713,
-0.4199126363,
-0.1914743483,
-0.5659596324,
0.327287972,
0.4749642313,
-0.9141813517,
1.0431566238,
0.0612494722,
0.0996833369,
-0.7356621623,
-0.6339098215,
0.2544532418,
-0.1129171848,
-0.7033940554,
0.4997211397,
0.3544943333,
-0.4722988009,
-0.1019873247,
0.067365624,
0.2199993134,
-0.0095257014,
0.3460968137,
0.254493773,
-0.1246627122,
0.2104607075,
-0.0321012475,
-0.0698111802,
0.1775117517,
-0.1493764222,
0.1748531461,
-0.1237007156,
-0.5086812377,
-0.5600835681,
0.2994515896,
0.5659129024,
-0.21215038,
0.8673619032,
0.6593714356,
-0.2260612249,
-0.3705379963,
-0.6516044736,
-0.3722805977,
-0.5359772444,
0.0170666296,
-0.3684494495,
-0.7001017332,
0.4653573036,
0.0662498251,
0.1960240901,
0.667901814,
0.3898662031,
0.1293153763,
0.8769391775,
0.4288769364,
-0.1516836733,
0.6961388588,
-0.5510845184,
0.1791202575,
-0.6131434441,
-0.2671546638,
-0.3942086697,
-0.3186826706,
-0.6810907125,
-0.1311527044,
0.4042356908,
-0.6427539587,
-0.0135946367,
0.4688791633,
-0.6887730956,
0.5405184031,
0.7744346261,
0.3787013888,
-0.0547028892,
0.1657409966,
0.2007542551,
0.1751715392,
-0.338465035,
-0.485881418,
1.3052015305,
0.1783443391,
0.7261317968,
0.2102997303,
0.7815480232,
0.8730614781,
0.2480752915,
-0.5089002848,
0.3297242522,
-0.2221553326,
-0.8889901042,
-0.2448079139,
-0.2977859378,
-0.8168695569,
0.206742242,
-0.364667803,
-0.4281547666,
0.4681429267,
0.6317969561,
-0.3675683141,
0.4434469342,
-0.5301434398,
0.5520099401,
-0.1419345886,
-0.6361681223,
0.1106315404,
-0.5282731056,
0.3112978041,
0.208339721,
-0.084506236,
0.6604834795,
0.5073272586,
0.3866763115,
-0.7701228261,
0.8035401106,
-0.3882340491,
0.1481319368,
0.3985924721,
0.0613271371,
0.8932765722,
-0.0160280596,
-0.3683327138,
-0.1899141371,
-0.303458035,
-0.2223706245,
-0.6757645607,
0.4692969322,
-0.8374291658,
-0.6107026935,
-0.7421454191,
-0.0469971821,
0.0098889042,
-0.0146716181,
0.6049434543,
0.5783867836,
-0.2562320232,
0.5445739627,
0.7033703327,
-0.1287584007,
-0.0087042768,
-0.2260480225,
0.3410183787,
-0.561573863,
1.0042482615,
-0.1091712937,
0.1639744639,
0.4942662716,
0.0730617493,
-0.2037509382,
-0.572596252,
-0.617003262,
-0.1250414848,
-0.6505300403,
-0.3245385289,
-0.5350648761,
-0.2617982328,
-0.5443682671,
-0.4392414093,
-0.2025696337,
-0.480222404,
-0.3076883256,
-0.2229207456,
0.3692985475,
0.5174047351,
0.1472540349,
0.2607228756,
-0.205364421,
0.2592107654,
0.4813952446,
-0.0928865224,
-0.1213209182,
-0.5843935013,
-0.111413978,
0.1364691556,
-0.4984954,
-0.7707449198,
0.1512983739,
0.2092866898,
0.5949597359,
0.5174896121,
0.0653428212,
0.550737381,
-0.2683449686,
1.0039627552,
-0.0309315175,
-0.790805459,
0.4598557353,
-0.307261169,
-0.1731418073,
0.9105750322,
-0.0889148116,
-0.1739895642,
-0.66500175,
-0.6872482896,
-0.7107387781,
0.5702873468,
0.4758142531,
0.3371583819,
0.2248192281,
0.6148276329,
0.3199581802,
0.1013264507,
-0.8692349195,
-0.1389138997,
-0.4285435677,
-0.000557328,
-0.1136066914,
-0.0442274287,
-0.0760660917,
-0.2404414117,
1.1627829075,
0.0423089378,
0.3497016728,
0.3478422761,
-0.1641130596,
0.0852473602,
0.035182368,
0.4255810678,
0.3117666245,
0.0180846546,
0.3382612765,
0.1719232351,
-0.251786679,
0.2401171029,
0.3391751945,
-0.3701801896,
0.1228918582,
0.8787235022,
0.7337542772,
-0.6486440301,
-0.163249284,
0.8199502826,
0.0856785476,
-0.327432543,
-0.7091611624,
0.3836582005,
-0.6239992976,
0.1970432848,
0.4131940901,
0.4989670217,
0.3110358119,
-0.654247582,
0.1730830371,
0.705183506,
-0.3693817258,
-0.5182493329,
0.7110271454,
0.0749729425,
-0.5204168558,
0.4624157846,
-0.3330158293,
-0.6049587131,
0.6147159934,
0.4631675184,
1.0613269806,
-0.2964700162,
0.0646534339,
0.2798759341,
0.5526525378,
-0.117036581,
-0.014518206,
-0.206187278,
-0.4924813211,
-0.3651001453,
-0.2664977014,
-0.3594537973,
0.1685214341,
-0.3549657762,
0.3000688553,
-0.5050654411,
-0.0559173226,
0.2339950055,
-0.0821609646,
-0.6274203062,
0.1013715714,
-0.0493215546,
0.504769206,
-1.1742196083,
0.297275126,
0.7737921476,
-0.4289553761,
-0.654088676,
-0.1106074303,
0.4076550007,
-0.5608484745,
0.3025256693,
0.3042885363,
-0.244939968,
-0.298977077,
-0.5378049612,
-0.3678995371,
1.0058715343,
0.3814130425,
-0.0593426526,
0.1194139272,
0.0889179483,
0.6798042655,
-0.2715259492,
-0.174577713,
0.0510340855,
0.2966538966,
0.3092851043,
-0.1904086322,
0.2706638575,
-0.6107724905,
0.0727668554,
0.1155655831,
-0.2588691115,
0.9467570186,
-0.0181121547,
-0.190855369,
0.2630223334,
0.6726192236,
0.0233227722,
0.4107901156,
0.5425053835,
0.5315126181,
0.6138681769,
-0.1391913593,
1.437014699,
0.0941797122,
-0.0092715742,
0.8587042689,
0.0735264271,
0.191592738,
0.4042833447,
-0.1358392984,
0.6304635406,
0.3178268075,
-0.4448292851,
0.3844843805,
0.1348132938,
-0.5145468712,
-0.159359768,
0.2292450666,
-0.5909677744,
0.5601931214,
-0.0287706498,
-0.8864883184,
0.2171369046,
0.2221363336,
0.0822103396,
0.3883725405,
-0.0269283839,
0.9052470922,
-0.2547205389,
-0.8388828039,
0.3105041385,
0.0158909708,
0.4554403722,
-0.3545414805,
-0.1852986515,
0.2370585948,
0.6191265583,
-0.3667483926,
-0.1258129776,
0.3971847594,
-0.1297421753,
-0.075391531,
-0.3195827603,
0.8897827268,
-0.262511313,
-0.8841106296,
-0.3551414013,
0.1420004368,
-0.1608369201,
-0.2721528411,
-0.1254505664,
0.0075341039,
-0.0698389187,
-0.0853763446,
-0.0745567903,
0.3716822863,
0.1480534822,
0.2188184708,
1.0712931156,
0.2339645624,
-0.231700182,
-0.0842046291,
0.940454483,
-0.1304936707,
-0.3449791074,
-1.2762851715,
0.5380958319,
-0.4147650599,
-0.297387898,
1.1321268082,
0.7952782512,
0.837207675,
-0.1522755921,
0.9883209467,
-0.1566185057,
0.3766437471,
-0.4263970256,
0.6149955392,
-0.4827604294,
0.4246733785,
-0.5109065771,
-0.4907585979,
-0.454395622,
0.5427260399,
-0.3374723792,
0.1835135221,
0.2934816778,
0.8450738788,
-0.0374165587,
-0.0253812131,
0.2325756252,
-0.1827867478,
0.7845571637,
0.0521660224,
0.8178933263,
-0.7695580721,
0.4066264033,
-0.3622523546,
-0.3334609866,
-0.2350408733,
-0.6924845576,
-1.2553155422,
-0.6690036654,
-0.3401640356,
-0.7510831952,
0.4413354993,
0.9649726748,
0.6326633692,
-0.7214103937,
0.3226212859,
-0.2700681686,
0.2366876602,
-0.598637104,
-0.2165569067,
0.3356550336,
-0.1964704543,
-0.4931222498,
0.2932998538,
-0.0125315282,
0.0160746165,
-0.198051706,
0.0253544953,
0.020696491,
0.2025557011,
0.5383819342,
0.4387481213,
-0.6584464908,
-0.4689248204,
0.02927793,
0.3539098799,
-0.0797122121,
1.037304163,
-0.7886969447,
0.9868720174,
0.5266777277,
1.0136725903,
0.2402499169,
0.4697536528,
0.7233859301,
-0.9986173511,
-0.04520135,
0.4169655442,
0.241164282,
0.3780619204,
-0.9062415957,
0.2532740831,
0.2677102387,
-0.5056561232,
-0.9046743512,
0.2243246138,
-0.633364439,
-0.0659499615,
1.0342816114,
0.0231785011,
-0.1437223256,
-0.1805677712,
-0.1585297585,
0.2093896568,
-0.3175564706,
1.1694768667,
0.5746250153,
0.0134691028,
0.1311391294,
0.022675721,
0.6847703457,
0.0121885566,
-0.637558639,
0.0408061035,
0.5366322398,
-0.0117315156,
0.4524520934,
0.5267971158,
-0.2212157547,
0.6239794493,
0.2181573361,
-0.0668086559,
-0.7221873403,
-0.2825582623,
-0.3077358902,
0.2937799096,
-0.0017710685,
-0.3440583646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11236v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11236v2
|
ChartThinker: A Contextual Chain-of-Thought Approach to Optimized Chart Summarization
| 2024-03-17T14:49:09 | 2024-04-25T03:04:14 |
Mengsha Liu, Daoyuan Chen, Yaliang Li, Guian Fang, Ying Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data visualization serves as a critical means for presenting data and mining
its valuable insights. The task of chart summarization, through natural
language processing techniques, facilitates in-depth data analysis of charts.
However, there still are notable deficiencies in terms of visual-language
matching and reasoning ability for existing approaches. To address these
limitations, this study constructs a large-scale dataset of comprehensive
chart-caption pairs and fine-tuning instructions on each chart. Thanks to the
broad coverage of various topics and visual styles within this dataset, better
matching degree can be achieved from the view of training data. Moreover, we
propose an innovative chart summarization method, ChartThinker, which
synthesizes deep analysis based on chains of thought and strategies of context
retrieval, aiming to improve the logical coherence and accuracy of the
generated summaries. Built upon the curated datasets, our trained model
consistently exhibits superior performance in chart summarization tasks,
surpassing 8 state-of-the-art models over 7 evaluation metrics. Our dataset and
codes are publicly accessible.
|
[
-0.4886566103,
-0.572299242,
0.3154365718,
-0.1682558209,
-0.7120223045,
0.4505753219,
-0.0899660736,
-0.2833574116,
0.4725984633,
0.5145388842,
-0.475194484,
-0.7003694773,
-0.4045341909,
-0.089935489,
-0.3226806521,
1.0019519329,
-0.1624788493,
-0.122291401,
-0.1317276061,
-0.1884547025,
-0.9850910902,
-0.1766384244,
-0.4357274175,
-0.0468946174,
0.2943993509,
0.7331376672,
0.5157530308,
0.5564208031,
0.7226512432,
0.290594846,
0.224367395,
0.4788270891,
-1.0814716816,
0.2446448803,
-0.1442332566,
-0.2336408049,
-0.5935208201,
-0.1890859157,
0.1940374076,
0.7815291882,
0.2002401203,
0.4133301973,
-0.1434727907,
1.1895338297,
-0.5184982419,
0.5804399848,
-0.4220671952,
0.1533163339,
-0.0246061217,
-0.6343048811,
-0.2567265034,
-0.5487783551,
0.4233821332,
-0.7477918863,
0.0072827195,
0.3155245781,
0.5358321071,
0.2826600075,
-0.5969637036,
-0.2250260711,
-0.5681387186,
0.4772123992,
-0.6093040705,
0.0867278129,
0.1735603213,
0.7645686269,
0.3221632838,
-1.0095573664,
-0.2116585225,
0.2501341105,
-0.2161202133,
0.4099685252,
-0.2061474174,
-0.2527704835,
0.0557906404,
0.5524960756,
-0.6604014039,
-0.202355653,
-0.6461194158,
0.043352019,
0.8091585636,
0.5163325071,
0.3860932291,
-0.147001788,
-0.1820894182,
-0.2113283873,
-0.308391273,
-0.0715022013,
-0.05264543,
0.429081887,
-0.4655611813,
0.5297836661,
-0.4194264114,
0.6647955179,
0.0388985686,
-0.0167901535,
0.1280406415,
-0.47949633,
-0.2799194455,
0.1970059723,
0.6081872582,
1.0673027039,
0.6640893817,
-0.2579458356,
0.0466993637,
-0.1210167781,
0.4239364266,
-0.8216784596,
-0.6622411609,
0.189204976,
-0.3365356922,
-0.501162231,
0.1068748757,
-0.4573741555,
-0.5072271824,
-0.8202238083,
0.0605234355,
-0.3866042197,
0.0228649601,
-0.0960074589,
-0.5740295649,
-0.2537127435,
0.3129303455,
-0.5400905013,
0.0372336395,
0.6505963802,
0.862398982,
-0.0563717298,
-0.0731970891,
-0.3283233643,
0.5366309881,
-0.6905322671,
0.7901107073,
-0.3859871924,
-0.0412419848,
-0.236829266,
-0.1883393973,
-0.1122573242,
-0.1781794429,
0.1999800354,
-0.5369812846,
0.1794211119,
-0.4971711338,
-0.9260510206,
-0.4020811617,
0.3005557954,
-0.7104426026,
0.4366589785,
0.1109039485,
-1.0548927784,
0.69478935,
-0.7336189151,
-0.6286768317,
0.3260750473,
-0.4063503444,
-0.4110282958,
-0.0609127916,
0.5260447264,
0.5535891056,
-0.0042809835,
0.4033152163,
-0.2310621887,
-0.5205668211,
0.0347299613,
0.1709331572,
0.4512138665,
0.2643762827,
-0.3876910806,
0.540763557,
-0.5270476937,
0.1257965267,
0.2498792261,
0.2701075077,
-0.3095132709,
0.0815160424,
0.3132650554,
0.1023128331,
-0.0608169101,
0.2149983793,
0.1097100824,
-0.5189628005,
0.6258776188,
0.5727037191,
0.3399988413,
0.4972094893,
-0.273044914,
0.5161447525,
-0.15798527,
-0.0835038945,
-0.2445001453,
-0.3369886577,
-0.4730387926,
-0.1825452149,
0.0092899455,
0.3760264814,
-0.6896401048,
0.6365343928,
-0.7565587759,
-0.8585935235,
0.0941293538,
0.0010999388,
0.1776685566,
0.9143962264,
0.3034207225,
-0.4299275279,
-0.7036929727,
-0.9065935612,
-0.2749061286,
0.2867397964,
0.0502913184,
0.0864651352,
0.4890708327,
-0.0538473651,
0.9773362875,
-0.9759144187,
-0.287756294,
-0.7203446627,
0.0758198127,
0.3146300614,
0.3404500484,
0.749352932,
-0.6892622113,
-0.5690693855,
-0.0186010394,
-0.993466258,
0.3091091812,
-0.1023387089,
-0.4675457776,
-0.3390708268,
0.6904036403,
-0.1368660629,
0.5920772552,
0.0233267918,
-0.4224485755,
0.3085600734,
-0.2643535137,
0.203355819,
-1.2013121843,
0.351885438,
-0.1866807938,
-0.2205166966,
-0.5605649352,
-0.0317459702,
0.0378897972,
-0.4527956545,
0.0494943485,
0.3399752975,
-0.2906668484,
0.1160937622,
-0.4406844676,
0.4280016422,
0.0965558812,
0.5132719874,
-0.0558359884,
0.4766131938,
0.6511679888,
-0.3913648725,
0.4393971264,
0.6121884584,
-0.469902426,
0.6963511109,
-0.5542958379,
0.0408693776,
-0.3355790079,
0.5260936618,
-1.2033172846,
-0.3846059442,
0.2091511041,
0.0136455279,
0.0758575201,
-0.0779482052,
-0.3936890364,
-0.5272225738,
-0.442050606,
0.3057581484,
0.0705280229,
-0.3766318858,
0.3282707334,
0.5425162315,
-0.1138009056,
-0.2910066247,
-0.715852201,
0.3256577849,
-0.4630194306,
-0.5594425201,
0.2117763311,
-0.1001378223,
-0.116752699,
-0.3582434058,
-0.3615538478,
0.1019920483,
0.0076092281,
0.1722022593,
0.3553293645,
0.0925017968,
0.127248913,
-0.0290872697,
-0.3787197769,
0.0776310936,
-0.408726275,
0.3111899793,
-0.1856640577,
-0.1866953969,
-0.4133602977,
0.1511580497,
0.5448797345,
-0.3354941905,
0.3647350073,
0.4682217836,
-0.2879413068,
-0.0509198457,
-0.1462827623,
-0.0473622084,
-0.4543593526,
0.3920772672,
-0.1445940286,
-0.5649688244,
0.3818657994,
0.0819061249,
0.2108455747,
0.1363351047,
0.4845074713,
-0.4114419222,
0.6829614639,
0.3641805947,
-0.4557507634,
0.3804633021,
-0.6849917769,
0.5810297728,
-0.3295709193,
-0.0533122271,
0.0949584991,
-0.7673897743,
-0.58355546,
-0.172906965,
0.542132318,
-0.0745623931,
-0.3150732517,
0.3455732763,
-0.6128912568,
0.6592816114,
0.3616192341,
0.2443401068,
0.2929964364,
-0.0658563673,
0.0932026282,
-0.0268647689,
-0.7249572873,
-0.5557860136,
1.2903721333,
-0.1276976466,
0.5380433202,
-0.1086795479,
0.31384781,
0.3111519814,
0.1252693236,
-0.6585569382,
0.404753685,
0.1048640683,
-0.4393516481,
-0.4281176925,
-0.353995502,
-0.9097108245,
0.1975027174,
-0.2218690664,
-0.6255970597,
-0.0007234739,
0.3994767666,
0.0635322928,
0.2984635532,
-0.7872005701,
1.0383195877,
-0.24825041,
-0.044210121,
-0.3381579816,
-0.8851891756,
0.3050146401,
0.0643674582,
0.347876519,
0.1104996055,
0.3501418829,
0.7653067708,
-0.5548813343,
0.6266198158,
0.1239301339,
-0.0758902282,
0.1991407573,
0.0277756471,
0.4940268397,
-0.000154865,
0.3792420924,
-0.3174943626,
-0.2251413763,
-0.5989328623,
-0.6009837389,
0.5546407104,
-0.3364056051,
-0.1495844126,
-0.0399939083,
-0.8005616665,
-0.4197203219,
0.3183240294,
0.3345322013,
0.7591449618,
-0.1508979946,
0.2071044892,
0.0291291419,
0.1401936114,
0.3262145519,
-0.046792306,
-0.1366207898,
-0.666030407,
1.0300228596,
0.2428954989,
0.039014034,
0.497516185,
0.0914945677,
-0.1085232943,
-0.43808797,
-0.2657662034,
0.0346441045,
-0.988055408,
-0.1514439881,
-0.3284440637,
0.0988924801,
-0.0269926842,
-0.5183680654,
-0.1008572504,
-0.554231286,
0.0689810738,
-0.4429447949,
0.4844789207,
0.5804124475,
0.2892500758,
0.1648706198,
-0.3125901818,
0.5493152738,
0.4595347643,
0.4106919169,
0.4046228826,
-0.0474696718,
-0.5816881061,
-0.0239406507,
-0.3997223377,
-0.7291504145,
0.2013706118,
-0.161747545,
0.1630953848,
0.6622666717,
0.127597481,
0.960303843,
-0.2426938415,
0.3451458812,
0.326046288,
-0.6764222383,
0.7970163822,
-0.5349708796,
0.5158423781,
0.667403996,
0.1930307448,
-0.4810598493,
-0.6822222471,
-0.5652326345,
-1.14686203,
0.5516030788,
0.5420808792,
-0.2842450738,
0.2300391197,
0.0101154959,
0.0333955586,
0.3990314603,
-0.2686398923,
-0.3656291366,
-0.6347227097,
-0.5030245781,
-0.4726912379,
0.3404898942,
-0.3058471382,
-0.6246539354,
0.3254388869,
-0.4125664532,
-0.2005279362,
-0.062560536,
-0.4048144817,
-0.1954153478,
0.0706016421,
0.4040594697,
1.4703402519,
-0.3144101501,
0.1363603622,
0.2018855214,
-0.3827405274,
-0.236106053,
0.0415936224,
-0.152966246,
-0.2098928094,
0.7757059932,
0.8862307072,
0.5601454377,
-0.9568896294,
0.4013936222,
-0.1029697061,
0.1095305756,
-0.1229476258,
0.0947646126,
0.427056253,
0.2887058556,
0.4392680824,
0.1717078984,
0.3690637052,
-0.381842047,
0.0913412124,
0.2366158366,
-0.4276917577,
-0.1948348433,
0.7565206885,
0.1246152967,
0.0740012154,
0.4286106527,
0.231666103,
-0.4581497312,
0.7033640146,
0.0681613088,
0.6497715116,
0.5391280055,
0.1316953897,
0.4328474402,
0.1408370435,
0.3656105399,
0.2945630252,
-0.255900681,
-0.2282638997,
-0.3580042124,
0.1008375138,
-0.4933320582,
-0.0510887206,
-0.6859195232,
0.2345291376,
-0.2637456656,
-0.1152278185,
-0.0370302722,
0.0125465356,
-0.8292077184,
0.4260674119,
0.1605127752,
0.7134065032,
-0.6928064823,
0.1613841206,
0.5909015536,
-0.5348035693,
-0.650888145,
-0.1184818372,
-0.0512094907,
-0.5793235898,
0.3752980828,
0.2781083286,
0.0660240799,
-0.0443564877,
-0.5877529383,
-0.5930600762,
1.3276820183,
0.2975495756,
-0.6047244668,
0.1292916834,
0.0677261204,
0.6501942873,
-0.3694329858,
0.2689870596,
0.6159675717,
0.5110640526,
-0.062098518,
-0.6296194792,
0.2600044906,
-0.4397222698,
-0.1001709998,
0.0620810464,
-0.5549075603,
0.3182028532,
-0.3901259303,
-0.1593544185,
-0.3390520513,
0.572206974,
0.3796344995,
0.5991584659,
0.2678502798,
0.4299147725,
0.9066420197,
-0.0030677118,
0.9439124465,
-0.4378620386,
0.3164905906,
1.3282938004,
0.0713919178,
0.5260030031,
0.3424504995,
0.0888277143,
0.4660122395,
0.5404546261,
-0.0753617734,
0.7070645094,
0.1201905087,
0.6438919902,
-0.1654561013,
0.2334184051,
-0.4598722458,
0.2265150398,
-0.0573925823,
-0.3469503522,
-0.3175421655,
-0.1933765262,
-0.1926997155,
0.2429494262,
-0.2438931763,
0.7860934138,
-0.0520856194,
-0.3363024592,
0.6721233726,
-0.5532019734,
0.1608874351,
-0.3291947842,
0.2190151364,
-0.2949078083,
-0.0860896707,
-0.1572783738,
-0.7806714773,
0.0747189224,
-0.0883939862,
-0.0454929434,
-0.2702994347,
0.4976901412,
-0.1544148773,
-0.5181253552,
0.0684576705,
0.5557652116,
-0.1650054157,
-0.174025327,
-0.4322231412,
-0.2167383432,
-0.1225658059,
0.0653077736,
-0.0970896855,
0.4554586411,
-0.1361163408,
0.8960615993,
0.4503112733,
-0.1955399215,
-0.4025713801,
0.5507944822,
0.9778889418,
-0.8676401377,
-1.1934306622,
-0.6317299604,
0.6204912663,
-0.502412796,
-0.2676546276,
0.7015648484,
1.0888361931,
0.6136507988,
-0.3078684211,
0.854598701,
0.3028402925,
0.3482250869,
-0.2833788395,
0.9467674494,
-0.4141505957,
0.0565932058,
-0.8109208345,
-0.7418761253,
-0.149810791,
0.2967513502,
-0.5836812258,
-0.1443512589,
0.7122224569,
0.3257111609,
-0.2966476679,
0.4203028381,
-0.2160087079,
0.092638433,
0.3345824778,
0.5526412725,
0.6252346635,
-0.5023131371,
0.6444721818,
-0.338794142,
-0.1478639543,
-0.3708072007,
-0.7289675474,
-1.2082829475,
-0.7167126536,
-0.370521754,
0.2114007473,
-0.2490409315,
0.5942014456,
0.8362975121,
-0.9206761122,
-0.4442126751,
-0.3141989708,
0.0642795116,
-0.482262671,
-0.2505921125,
0.8420287967,
-0.144890368,
-0.3015427589,
0.2978237569,
0.4036169648,
0.0707897097,
0.0200571436,
-0.1636464894,
0.1782447398,
-0.1605829,
0.7005439401,
-0.0870810524,
-0.4327975512,
-0.0612402968,
-0.2550659478,
0.1244015619,
0.2075027823,
0.8729848266,
-0.59446311,
0.8359830379,
0.5779289603,
0.3462746143,
0.7942590714,
0.2020705491,
0.6725453734,
-0.6009126902,
0.0571208261,
-0.0158995762,
0.4403102994,
0.3123961687,
-0.175435096,
0.7246235013,
0.0066124625,
-0.0335632972,
-0.7267377377,
-0.0355147459,
-1.2056907415,
-0.3519839942,
0.289498955,
0.3609985411,
0.1114767119,
-0.0398143493,
-0.4726198018,
0.4932329357,
-0.3196360469,
1.0454674959,
0.4232443273,
-0.2564325035,
0.0974503979,
-0.2389095724,
0.3278037012,
-0.0336957052,
-1.1012701988,
0.1576504409,
0.4739282429,
0.1172537059,
0.0507610664,
0.427298367,
0.3530835211,
0.2358573377,
-0.2277354151,
-0.4806627631,
-0.1792031974,
-0.085449636,
0.3205699623,
0.3668394387,
-0.263997227,
0.0322393253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11227v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11227v1
|
Cheap Ways of Extracting Clinical Markers from Texts
| 2024-03-17T14:21:42 | 2024-03-17T14:21:42 |
Anastasia Sandu, Teodor Mihailescu, Sergiu Nisioi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper describes the work of the UniBuc Archaeology team for CLPsych's
2024 Shared Task, which involved finding evidence within the text supporting
the assigned suicide risk level. Two types of evidence were required:
highlights (extracting relevant spans within the text) and summaries
(aggregating evidence into a synthesis). Our work focuses on evaluating Large
Language Models (LLM) as opposed to an alternative method that is much more
memory and resource efficient. The first approach employs a good old-fashioned
machine learning (GOML) pipeline consisting of a tf-idf vectorizer with a
logistic regression classifier, whose representative features are used to
extract relevant highlights. The second, more resource intensive, uses an LLM
for generating the summaries and is guided by chain-of-thought to provide
sequences of text indicating clinical markers.
|
[
0.0462642089,
-0.4657241404,
0.8682795167,
-0.0622869767,
-0.3158197999,
-0.2244053632,
-0.0515121035,
-0.568126142,
0.1936443001,
0.6207035184,
-0.4961139262,
-0.9017863274,
-0.7374010086,
0.1981870085,
-0.3111220002,
1.261957407,
-0.034565445,
0.3246204257,
0.1000903398,
-0.3313194215,
-0.1277265698,
-0.4720034301,
-0.7407191992,
-0.1180982664,
0.5737833977,
0.3836270571,
0.6062226295,
0.9147148132,
0.6740041971,
0.1541113704,
-0.0859608054,
0.0126108648,
-0.4650391042,
-0.0076149064,
0.0614743829,
-0.3783839047,
-0.5780587792,
0.2526845932,
-0.0230418053,
0.7579738498,
0.0648618042,
0.4018325508,
-0.103873238,
0.6089158058,
-0.6479915977,
0.2153130472,
-0.3718828261,
-0.0395956933,
-0.315010488,
-0.2403722405,
-0.6564238667,
-0.3696992993,
0.459066689,
-0.5089703798,
0.4642878771,
-0.3419944644,
0.5738602877,
0.2065258324,
-0.4411484301,
-0.934034586,
-0.407871604,
0.9605302215,
-0.8402853608,
0.0341373235,
0.5798077583,
-0.0218649302,
-0.2585966289,
-1.0012993813,
0.0333323032,
-0.0381036028,
-0.4013720453,
0.2852700651,
0.1168911979,
0.221214503,
0.1993344426,
0.5230738521,
-0.4542024732,
0.2120343149,
-0.5196546316,
-0.596558094,
0.8246098757,
0.4889396727,
0.5444477201,
-0.202693671,
-0.3783336878,
0.2210591882,
-0.8848404288,
0.1285266429,
0.0483800024,
0.2173120677,
-0.0184250101,
0.4426327348,
-0.1124754623,
0.5349777341,
-0.3631972075,
-0.5921137333,
0.284114033,
-0.4921679199,
-0.0113702687,
0.2244955897,
0.9663105607,
0.7374429107,
0.1187645197,
-0.0620961487,
0.016696848,
0.1412048042,
0.1870994717,
-0.9666802287,
-0.6556521654,
0.5242883563,
-0.9828948379,
-0.2531122267,
-0.6287410259,
-1.0097442865,
-0.2786272466,
-0.0094678467,
0.3268648088,
-0.511131525,
0.1905373633,
0.0889552981,
-0.4068526924,
-0.2422637939,
0.5957189798,
-0.759072125,
0.1679540128,
0.3245708942,
0.9705277681,
-0.4332621694,
0.1017168909,
-0.5043676496,
0.2114465237,
-0.2208775729,
0.9653144479,
-0.3229187131,
-0.5203090906,
0.2570967078,
0.2012927979,
0.201355353,
-0.5782250762,
0.8251355886,
-0.0435474291,
0.6094119549,
-0.3346806765,
-0.6536682844,
-0.0631644875,
-0.2674746513,
-0.9881913662,
1.1655731201,
0.2503533959,
-0.9774547815,
0.7213329673,
-0.5376257896,
-0.4173098505,
0.398884505,
-0.2976698875,
-0.4608720243,
0.0058043087,
0.2838101387,
0.7133802176,
-0.1252827793,
0.3297083378,
-0.1415445209,
-0.3222414851,
0.0505273044,
-0.1516872644,
1.0168144703,
0.1749733388,
-0.324814558,
-0.120939739,
-0.8134595752,
-0.2232802957,
-0.0128630707,
-0.6244952083,
-0.5363904238,
0.2930907607,
0.2233355194,
0.1955507696,
0.259784162,
-0.6507509947,
0.0633063838,
-0.213776648,
0.2146769762,
0.2789759934,
0.2995040715,
0.2198853344,
-0.5859535933,
0.3360633552,
-0.1837462932,
0.168050468,
-0.1466949433,
-0.8388018608,
-0.3605208099,
-0.9460174441,
0.0879058614,
0.3663748205,
-0.3207054734,
0.2072242051,
-0.0167600606,
-0.5702188015,
-0.6910071969,
0.1296185851,
0.5201199055,
0.5564691424,
0.7121807933,
-0.263520062,
-0.7300617099,
-0.7390674353,
-0.236883387,
-0.1516867727,
-0.0986124426,
-0.0776334926,
0.6017664075,
0.0187757332,
0.7986239791,
-0.7635947466,
-0.6024935842,
-0.326066792,
0.3630273044,
0.3423252404,
0.4003098905,
0.4829379916,
-0.6889109612,
-0.5699993968,
-0.1862170398,
-0.7882053852,
-0.2825392187,
-0.1092306077,
0.0756216422,
-0.0023529672,
0.6276587844,
-0.4711724222,
1.0589852333,
0.2216062546,
0.0237608962,
0.586787641,
-0.3024072945,
0.0070395167,
-0.8111623526,
0.3482567072,
-0.1819377244,
-0.2359416932,
-0.9489799142,
-0.2586757243,
-0.0455985293,
0.00942598,
-0.3371665478,
0.4930328429,
-0.5158272386,
0.3195317388,
-0.4584759772,
0.1733562946,
-0.224163413,
0.2447110713,
0.4173208177,
0.7368980646,
0.0983896926,
-0.4306870401,
-0.0041018678,
0.479437083,
-0.2401307821,
0.3716436028,
-0.3044409156,
-0.3086145222,
-0.0161108226,
0.2117048055,
-0.8912035823,
-0.3748095632,
-0.1720075607,
-0.3703173399,
0.009924721,
-0.2384893745,
-0.258882761,
-0.2954395413,
-0.5649656653,
0.3546673059,
0.6368799806,
-0.1683293879,
0.4663769007,
0.6438276768,
-0.4942340255,
-0.463389039,
-0.6164250374,
-0.0397576056,
-0.5746185184,
-0.1060850173,
0.2886539698,
-0.2182826698,
-0.2266419083,
-0.1663983464,
0.0581699871,
-0.3162045479,
0.3083486557,
0.5006299615,
0.2937462628,
-0.1513138413,
0.0774213374,
-0.0538536236,
-0.2335661203,
0.2458764166,
0.2318091691,
0.4408962429,
0.307831049,
-0.0456247367,
-0.5680363178,
0.7818281651,
0.3378466964,
0.1886915267,
0.69301337,
0.2785399854,
-0.4509353936,
-0.1679996401,
-0.5206006169,
0.0696946308,
-0.3921070099,
0.2190542668,
0.1933172643,
-0.9500882626,
0.6899584532,
-0.4316760004,
0.2467165291,
0.6127404571,
1.0712542534,
-0.2712975442,
0.877200067,
0.5338039398,
0.0209623277,
0.0255731642,
-0.0581791438,
0.1378702372,
-0.587795496,
-0.3011676967,
-0.5862848163,
0.0372175574,
-0.4808981717,
-0.3551702499,
0.5956824422,
0.1263080388,
-0.0737166107,
0.3992214203,
-0.5698356628,
0.24682495,
0.5682330132,
0.4493674636,
0.491832763,
-0.0978111476,
0.0878699049,
-0.1813373864,
-0.434825331,
-0.8467774987,
1.3784403801,
0.2260382622,
0.2055399865,
0.0148079768,
0.8459423184,
0.2952980697,
0.7287760377,
-0.4623840451,
0.5385510325,
-0.2524911761,
-0.8385514617,
-0.2591224611,
-0.0766459182,
-1.0010908842,
-0.0086644394,
-0.2307126075,
-0.998218298,
0.0683339164,
-0.0343077779,
-0.470842272,
0.0212638676,
-0.402972579,
0.6165090203,
-0.1117411256,
0.0411148965,
0.0063394425,
-0.8249640465,
0.1477688551,
-0.4425054193,
0.3986172378,
-0.1337726116,
-0.0954596624,
1.0530477762,
-0.4789245129,
0.8875862956,
-0.1000130102,
-0.1795981079,
0.417273432,
0.190301314,
0.3103656769,
-0.0003320707,
-0.2404699624,
0.0440201014,
0.2508954406,
-0.6248602867,
-0.0940866247,
0.3818148971,
-0.5305700302,
-0.3801968098,
-0.2469312102,
-0.7536509633,
0.0126091456,
0.2701512575,
0.5855859518,
0.6238555312,
-0.4948316514,
-0.1929851174,
0.3943665326,
-0.3040226698,
0.6689350605,
0.3498919606,
0.0887683854,
-0.6214603186,
0.4488670528,
-0.0478554219,
0.3646063805,
0.3143865764,
0.2979643643,
-0.0195833836,
-1.1055315733,
-0.1290196329,
0.3694241941,
-0.8911579847,
-0.1370684654,
-0.7990114689,
-0.107619144,
-0.4310761392,
-0.3796729743,
-0.3114618361,
-0.2965239584,
-0.5849320889,
-0.3103345335,
0.4766149223,
0.8370774388,
-0.2592475712,
0.5269355774,
-0.8932313919,
0.1352972537,
-0.0824794471,
-0.2599797547,
-0.196650967,
-0.178053692,
-0.4664765596,
-0.1892396808,
-0.0911472663,
-0.9496505857,
0.6030417085,
0.0146319186,
0.4959474206,
0.8040807843,
0.3074667454,
0.7603626847,
-0.4838779867,
0.916467309,
0.3591258228,
-0.6613870263,
0.4981944859,
-0.5319778323,
-0.0582297035,
1.0043863058,
1.0046925545,
-0.3784123957,
-0.418119967,
-0.6064304113,
-0.8030784726,
0.3832061887,
0.2436561137,
-0.4252219498,
-0.3268636465,
0.2868272662,
0.4868643284,
0.0718393102,
-0.7585445642,
-0.1914599091,
0.2880535722,
-0.708522737,
-0.0657908022,
-0.6110557914,
-0.4922304451,
-0.0486653671,
0.2359768152,
-0.2171979696,
0.1880594641,
0.5387841463,
-0.2718148828,
-0.0405125581,
0.0286095757,
0.4622552097,
0.8615067005,
-0.5075338483,
0.352451086,
0.3473651707,
-0.7663851976,
0.038381055,
-0.105988197,
-0.2851299942,
0.2335910648,
1.0652698278,
0.3490665257,
0.1342798322,
-0.9965072274,
0.8514506817,
0.0984965861,
-0.4452315867,
-0.5318057537,
-0.1747916937,
0.1553994417,
0.2079174966,
0.2687034011,
-0.3790515661,
0.359202534,
-0.4566194415,
0.2671861947,
0.3689351678,
-0.4140763581,
-0.4782548249,
0.4291468859,
0.0634167641,
-0.1764797568,
0.417401731,
0.1704584211,
-0.4560454488,
0.3510363102,
0.3468663692,
0.6206407547,
-0.1281980127,
0.4091632664,
0.3682922721,
0.0350029655,
-0.2789090574,
0.4253588021,
0.1515156776,
-0.1126056388,
-0.655139327,
-0.5815445185,
-0.2745272815,
0.1330682486,
-0.7654643059,
0.1269246042,
-0.2961997092,
-0.0871279314,
0.0018947279,
-0.0626012012,
-0.548224926,
0.5079743862,
0.0770173967,
0.9025851488,
-0.907604754,
0.4919475615,
0.2634957135,
-0.4138486385,
-0.5488864183,
-0.3104891777,
0.1111032963,
-0.7832811475,
0.9237639308,
0.3561346829,
0.2317960113,
-0.4256733656,
-0.6383213401,
-0.6299371123,
1.1177760363,
-0.0413277932,
-0.2897011936,
-0.5523987412,
0.2800556421,
0.7342638373,
-0.5341356993,
0.6038336754,
0.4754033685,
0.209626317,
-0.2653573751,
-0.7553465366,
0.2698270082,
0.006128686,
-0.5326434374,
0.3651432395,
-0.335832417,
0.7761496305,
-0.1902848184,
-0.4058991373,
0.406891644,
0.3855208158,
-0.037676461,
0.5865507126,
0.2360265404,
0.683285296,
0.9174871445,
0.2234165072,
0.7414996028,
-0.1330859065,
0.4849100411,
1.0540271997,
-0.361842066,
0.6933423877,
0.4692874253,
-0.0898367986,
0.6492980123,
0.5523789525,
0.1315734237,
0.831936717,
0.0871234983,
-0.4198116064,
-0.3649829328,
-0.1391040385,
-0.0965049714,
0.2626186013,
0.448247999,
-0.6594015956,
-0.3746023178,
-0.058881253,
0.5095208287,
-0.0639735311,
-0.2416160852,
0.9584615231,
0.2149963528,
-0.6770399213,
0.2937184572,
-0.306273073,
0.1924300492,
-0.4575398564,
-0.2604586184,
-0.1907923073,
0.3925480545,
-0.185003534,
-0.5778893828,
0.3612927496,
0.0330985412,
-0.0000389943,
-0.2044441849,
0.6668890715,
-0.2854527235,
-0.2928450704,
0.3919478059,
0.5327656269,
0.3816269338,
0.1265533417,
-0.4601437151,
-0.2941825986,
0.1337875426,
-0.1299026012,
0.4958133996,
0.6402001977,
-0.1801816374,
0.5636179447,
0.8565830588,
0.4806123078,
-0.1967493594,
-0.3091757894,
0.9051707387,
-0.9271634221,
-0.2643167078,
-0.9890159965,
0.3428319991,
-0.1885175705,
-0.5072546601,
0.7236390114,
0.6232069135,
0.5503923297,
-0.002412372,
0.5882068276,
0.1493940055,
0.8092755079,
-0.6300418973,
0.7736734748,
-0.3036861122,
-0.1009509042,
-0.3197339773,
-0.331046164,
-0.5361897945,
0.3309962153,
-0.0855917558,
-0.5218392611,
1.2862251997,
0.4338988364,
0.3478573263,
0.2521724403,
0.1418737918,
0.0164909847,
0.382928133,
0.7914513946,
0.5365561247,
-0.2361842841,
0.4312697947,
-0.2535024285,
-0.5148867965,
-0.092760697,
-1.0035903454,
-1.2722278833,
-0.5882579684,
-0.4271673262,
-0.5028478503,
0.088768214,
0.7144031525,
0.2771602869,
-0.8731070757,
-0.1525148898,
0.1602765024,
-0.4421459436,
-0.108076185,
-0.0647574887,
0.9968979359,
-0.064592205,
-0.4444084466,
0.3114437759,
0.4079646468,
-0.1768097728,
0.0369500741,
0.1740609705,
-0.4928782582,
-0.2843183279,
0.3801853359,
-0.0395490602,
-0.4246234894,
-0.285978049,
-0.2234829515,
-0.2001517266,
0.2243584543,
1.0216224194,
-0.8092182875,
0.2328243405,
0.527862668,
0.4156707823,
0.4958510101,
-0.019583866,
0.4162735045,
-0.2937167883,
0.2067845464,
0.435223639,
0.4559413493,
0.1077175364,
-0.4191726148,
0.7166060209,
0.4549182057,
-0.7255644798,
-0.7937270999,
0.139018923,
-1.090004921,
-0.3521768451,
1.0011764765,
-0.5730928183,
-0.360653609,
-0.7163539529,
-0.31484887,
0.3690585196,
-0.3401528299,
0.7404067516,
0.5097500682,
-0.1608899236,
0.0293976832,
-0.6777185202,
0.950425446,
0.2292321473,
-0.7761430144,
0.1850133091,
0.4565249085,
0.3640736341,
0.3106273413,
0.9962168336,
-0.3460283875,
0.2945024371,
-0.2248409986,
0.2636225224,
0.31009987,
-0.0592560805,
0.031648837,
0.2807167768,
-0.2040415108,
0.2055770904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11209v1
|
Creating an African American-Sounding TTS: Guidelines, Technical Challenges,and Surprising Evaluations
| 2024-03-17T13:21:33 | 2024-03-17T13:21:33 |
Claudio Pinhanez, Raul Fernandez, Marcelo Grave, Julio Nogima, Ron Hoory
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Representations of AI agents in user interfaces and robotics are
predominantly White, not only in terms of facial and skin features, but also in
the synthetic voices they use. In this paper we explore some unexpected
challenges in the representation of race we found in the process of developing
an U.S. English Text-to-Speech (TTS) system aimed to sound like an educated,
professional, regional accent-free African American woman. The paper starts by
presenting the results of focus groups with African American IT professionals
where guidelines and challenges for the creation of a representative and
appropriate TTS system were discussed and gathered, followed by a discussion
about some of the technical difficulties faced by the TTS system developers. We
then describe two studies with U.S. English speakers where the participants
were not able to attribute the correct race to the African American TTS voice
while overwhelmingly correctly recognizing the race of a White TTS system of
similar quality. A focus group with African American IT workers not only
confirmed the representativeness of the African American voice we built, but
also suggested that the surprising recognition results may have been caused by
the inability or the latent prejudice from non-African Americans to associate
educated, non-vernacular, professionally-sounding voices to African American
people.
|
[
-0.5463719964,
-0.2754323184,
0.378063947,
0.1134627908,
-0.1808181554,
0.7952256203,
-0.115792878,
-0.7998508811,
0.7018840909,
-0.0068377042,
-0.4679390788,
-0.2643641531,
-0.6592853069,
0.4682502747,
-0.6083858609,
0.9061510563,
0.0071419785,
-0.16078493,
0.4060562253,
-0.2091142237,
-0.6696373224,
-0.6703573465,
-0.6674221754,
-0.1125802621,
0.4556980431,
0.3601177633,
1.0621682405,
0.5641434193,
-0.0955606028,
0.2908596396,
-0.0249316674,
0.1487867385,
-0.0813357681,
0.0382670276,
0.0558771826,
-0.3001177609,
-0.0263984203,
0.1719796956,
0.0217273459,
0.7111023664,
-0.0186782852,
0.3064989746,
-0.1244425401,
0.4737724364,
-0.660410881,
-0.1651824564,
-0.5803261995,
0.2699461877,
-0.4291126132,
-0.0485326536,
-0.3708043993,
-0.2695227265,
0.186686039,
-0.6435106397,
0.3106569648,
0.1838305593,
0.873993516,
0.2276995331,
-0.7827582955,
-0.3661770225,
-1.4233790636,
0.4302305877,
-0.3889743388,
0.3807937801,
0.0569616556,
0.6486571431,
0.0537010022,
-0.6000055075,
-0.767280519,
-0.5277792215,
0.1483564526,
0.1036060154,
-0.2541184425,
-0.0712620765,
0.3133620322,
0.1429626793,
-0.4933582842,
0.0629949942,
-0.7818292379,
-0.4690321386,
0.887884438,
0.273014158,
0.2604825795,
0.0665605217,
-0.0271254405,
-0.0694304407,
-0.319732517,
-0.0512051508,
0.7785021067,
0.8681833744,
-0.2513101101,
0.7581828237,
0.0130841443,
0.3707912266,
-0.3112882674,
0.1600247025,
0.2744556963,
0.1554666907,
0.1674539,
0.2019966692,
0.6766987443,
0.249577865,
0.8744648695,
-0.2359844297,
-0.3579116166,
0.4939629138,
0.791439712,
-0.1779751927,
0.241603151,
0.2565931976,
-0.4842128754,
0.2401256114,
0.2389107198,
-0.3824597597,
-0.6035118103,
-0.5133099556,
0.3799216151,
-0.2711080015,
-0.3147617579,
-0.4048587084,
-0.5329318643,
-0.0642532557,
0.3151698411,
-0.9505518079,
0.3574849665,
0.4855130017,
0.8282965422,
-0.0788770318,
-0.1396827102,
0.1625695676,
0.0978506729,
-0.2663633227,
0.3356446624,
-0.3859054446,
-0.7278167009,
0.1395267546,
-0.2634250522,
0.2299165428,
-0.5506165624,
0.1751027107,
-0.255297333,
-0.1313415468,
-0.2921119332,
-0.203158915,
0.090748176,
-0.1967078,
-0.2983566821,
0.8045168519,
0.2320317328,
-0.3889109194,
0.3030981123,
-0.6294573545,
-0.6724076271,
0.230311349,
-0.5562907457,
-0.078144297,
0.4409385622,
-0.1900544316,
-0.0986258462,
-0.1549075693,
-0.0338542126,
-0.0308464617,
-0.7648089528,
0.0238073412,
-0.2389776558,
1.0805203915,
0.454144448,
-0.8553265333,
-0.249843955,
-0.8914467692,
-0.20706366,
0.2735589445,
0.2661845982,
-0.1853305399,
0.0319141634,
-0.0069182352,
-0.2207630277,
0.0963407084,
-0.8099544048,
-0.1799329519,
0.0302748661,
0.2884507179,
0.8415819407,
-0.4552936852,
0.1724999845,
-0.212642625,
0.7374558449,
-0.45935601,
0.0847357139,
-0.0443237387,
-0.6291760206,
-0.812061429,
0.1398740411,
0.2539519668,
0.6592678428,
-0.7103151083,
0.2963416576,
0.1207906753,
-0.4645259678,
-0.6989669204,
-0.4580726624,
-0.0433864892,
0.5906915665,
0.2859852612,
-0.2066409886,
-0.521527946,
-1.1937325001,
-0.0181487165,
-0.5594787598,
-0.314817965,
0.3755316734,
0.4848208427,
-0.412561506,
0.9506243467,
-0.1807735413,
-0.1273887306,
0.1757122725,
0.357829392,
-0.1722976267,
0.3744449615,
0.5293259025,
-0.4909084737,
-0.5716186166,
0.1877947748,
-0.5509260297,
-0.2874486148,
0.1031334177,
0.1169844419,
0.1712857783,
0.509971559,
-0.2640346885,
0.73368752,
0.3797960281,
-0.510712564,
0.7423902154,
-0.0514646061,
0.2371354401,
-0.8862090111,
0.2213443518,
0.1429346353,
-0.0767282024,
-0.4575072825,
-0.1365451217,
-0.2912204564,
-0.4550702572,
-0.0913041681,
0.6785872579,
-0.5162193775,
-0.4919925928,
-0.3752976656,
0.1952439845,
-0.1681120992,
0.2695607841,
-0.1707122624,
1.2034281492,
0.1175811142,
-0.522280395,
0.4266821742,
0.4029571116,
0.0154117579,
0.7807708383,
-0.7284956574,
0.470205158,
-0.1285527349,
-0.1150932163,
-0.7615804672,
0.1736822277,
0.0469873399,
-0.6177841425,
0.0771257728,
0.0961205512,
-0.1870276034,
-0.8600468636,
0.1465276331,
0.3791156113,
0.5745500326,
-0.4093882442,
0.5727344155,
0.6913895607,
-0.5433777571,
-0.4231390953,
-0.7990086079,
0.5438036323,
-0.0647947192,
-0.6549986005,
0.469535619,
0.1877662838,
-0.4239799976,
-0.1108024418,
-0.0214009546,
-0.2197019011,
0.3248394728,
0.1355835646,
0.0272440091,
-0.0892156437,
0.0887213051,
-0.0240696166,
0.0412830561,
0.0944967568,
-0.1920449138,
0.0583178215,
0.1818090081,
-0.3837093115,
-0.5444524288,
0.8633699417,
0.4671644866,
-0.1800044179,
0.4293045998,
0.4730796814,
-0.3424521387,
-0.3342986405,
-0.4104454219,
-0.3069106042,
-0.4971790016,
0.3676884174,
-0.2123858929,
-0.9741533995,
0.7361204028,
0.190335691,
0.2857867479,
0.2784697711,
0.3331565857,
-0.3885031343,
1.1322402954,
0.9090334773,
0.2681431174,
0.7541027069,
-0.0993103981,
0.212015003,
-0.4280060828,
-0.4661841393,
-1.14846766,
-0.6439070702,
-0.7630061507,
-0.0027519078,
0.5275210738,
-0.9021830559,
-0.5518208742,
0.2222012281,
-0.6820549965,
-0.0188370179,
1.0180510283,
0.0662910044,
-0.0450559556,
0.1840290576,
-0.168402344,
-0.1801589876,
-0.3855866492,
-0.8622576594,
0.9963461757,
0.4277111292,
0.3268475235,
0.1118940786,
0.7665176988,
0.9524679184,
0.2198155075,
-0.5513605475,
0.4118927419,
-0.3907141984,
-0.6650183201,
-0.3501204252,
-0.3037180007,
-0.9883436561,
-0.213310197,
-0.2947366834,
-1.0435240269,
0.1775816232,
0.2827965617,
-0.3250363171,
-0.0862342045,
-0.8518663049,
0.6509832144,
-0.3435694575,
0.1058913767,
0.0262404364,
-0.7813950777,
0.0208886284,
0.1966253817,
0.1742489636,
-0.0114252688,
0.1880713552,
0.8837028742,
-0.832932353,
0.4780778885,
-0.3777745366,
0.0559654124,
0.5831011534,
0.0890206993,
0.2314121872,
-0.3245380223,
-0.2390385717,
0.2961542606,
-0.3517405987,
-0.4402379692,
-0.6165657043,
-0.031843733,
-1.0291951895,
-0.8452324271,
-0.4807763696,
-0.445676446,
-0.5253048539,
0.1070169508,
0.1701938361,
0.3176699877,
-0.1872105747,
-0.2195180953,
0.0067840801,
-0.0648107007,
0.2946388125,
0.2219614983,
0.1323021054,
-0.3233613372,
0.9311012626,
0.1352936327,
-0.0839173421,
-0.1343671679,
-0.0420441665,
-0.238172397,
-0.8240983486,
-0.668233335,
0.2987912893,
-0.4751302302,
0.1374288052,
-0.3650377691,
-0.4104524553,
-0.2273240685,
-0.1884757578,
-0.314853698,
-0.621516645,
-0.5869547725,
-0.1764382869,
0.1258138418,
1.2128272057,
0.1763422787,
0.5245348811,
-0.7008551359,
0.4100220501,
0.420956254,
0.2889423072,
0.0486574881,
-0.7303471565,
-0.5527543426,
0.1519236565,
-0.3587789834,
-0.9562189579,
0.0577296242,
-0.2723281085,
0.6036236286,
0.0695549324,
0.1402755827,
0.4887352586,
-0.676038146,
1.0815382004,
-0.0111029744,
-1.1471966505,
0.3689257205,
-0.076008752,
0.0792728141,
0.6661997437,
0.2150403708,
-0.4650957286,
-0.9722155929,
-0.4115918875,
-0.7727743387,
0.6741899252,
0.4785298705,
0.557476759,
0.0041305698,
0.4114828408,
0.1689116061,
0.3601434529,
-0.7166244984,
-0.8436220288,
-0.5357173085,
-0.3894232213,
0.0838404149,
-0.1682423353,
-0.0817757919,
0.2836821377,
0.5030439496,
-0.1153228655,
0.3471146524,
0.2635587752,
0.0490686931,
0.0229180735,
0.2530016005,
0.7239332199,
0.4988241792,
-0.0735090896,
-0.0660861805,
-0.3864252567,
-0.3986813426,
0.5221967101,
0.5492445827,
-0.3891890645,
0.337200135,
0.3779305518,
1.128380537,
-0.6135151386,
-0.368886739,
0.0324434973,
-0.23866947,
-0.0945203602,
-0.1775269359,
-0.0085983817,
-0.2182740718,
0.1599743366,
1.031037569,
0.0410318039,
0.2151645571,
-0.6294276714,
-0.0620737188,
0.7223340273,
-0.3666245937,
-0.3805926144,
1.0063188076,
0.9515453577,
-0.9580174685,
0.3767766058,
-0.2062051892,
-0.6114628911,
0.8213261366,
0.4662303925,
1.1660621166,
-0.2866298854,
0.3734019995,
0.0763090774,
0.7254782319,
0.3566140532,
0.4701787531,
-0.0021945243,
-0.6228601933,
0.0607667938,
-0.2213674188,
-0.7989354134,
-0.3958820403,
-0.3760070205,
0.352203548,
-0.5321352482,
-0.857945323,
0.075670056,
-0.1121803895,
-0.5275995135,
0.4692103267,
0.4856848717,
1.0284651518,
-0.908383131,
-0.1131219938,
0.9271469712,
-0.1073963493,
-0.9781289697,
0.0540018603,
0.0195919257,
-0.5431055427,
0.4948944747,
-0.0529897287,
-0.0630654544,
-0.1855754852,
0.0543923751,
-0.5688975453,
0.8028659821,
0.8673083186,
-0.4769041538,
-0.1223779544,
0.4156037271,
0.6521699429,
-0.3897807896,
0.5697283745,
0.4139268696,
0.4570281208,
-0.1453698874,
-1.4899098873,
-0.1255443543,
-0.2180150151,
0.1072803661,
-0.0350973569,
-0.8252538443,
0.8991804123,
-0.41688326,
-0.4624449015,
-0.0584865548,
0.6855376959,
0.2396855652,
0.7062100172,
0.5664163828,
0.0535967797,
0.9257423878,
-0.1968190372,
1.0624090433,
-0.0644349754,
-0.1824183464,
0.731384635,
-0.4296512306,
0.0819739178,
0.3229976594,
-0.4978330731,
0.7629029155,
0.596557498,
0.2514743805,
0.0440037102,
0.2096424103,
-0.4504412115,
0.3985207677,
-0.4137797952,
-0.5338822007,
0.7389155626,
0.0761326551,
-0.1808165014,
0.2436979711,
0.0099331737,
-0.4343601763,
0.5078586936,
-0.2513727248,
0.6918746829,
0.0596510321,
-0.4462242126,
0.2892266512,
-0.0581525974,
0.4591329694,
-0.4760430157,
-0.1364655197,
-0.2137116045,
-0.5110872388,
-0.1370205432,
-0.4192959666,
0.4651486874,
0.2071852386,
-0.2383576035,
0.0389663614,
0.0496039577,
-0.2383930534,
-0.4751439691,
0.3490133286,
0.4684714377,
-0.0545166098,
0.1819510162,
-0.4009564519,
0.369685024,
0.1922618002,
0.1730939746,
-0.2686344981,
0.4447411895,
-0.2900339067,
0.5839933157,
0.297241509,
0.6011722684,
0.0080279326,
0.3570658267,
0.2545375228,
-0.8949095607,
-1.1106669903,
-0.5079437494,
0.7551215291,
-0.0321930498,
-0.2657513916,
0.5218163729,
0.3607499599,
0.7251784205,
0.1617219597,
1.1408778429,
-0.0375454687,
0.6960842609,
-0.2224413007,
0.6099199057,
-0.6030709743,
0.2321279347,
-0.4286282361,
-1.0274971724,
0.0970778391,
0.4453920126,
0.4277986288,
0.5842391849,
0.5924033523,
0.4853442907,
0.2057206184,
0.2314399928,
0.3958349824,
0.1021087691,
0.3232976496,
0.0974321365,
0.9554291368,
-0.2989366949,
0.66436553,
-0.2965165079,
-0.2287094295,
-0.1501680166,
-0.7071295977,
-0.482706517,
-0.5555298328,
-0.4150461853,
-0.5058181286,
0.0843770728,
1.0661580563,
0.8055642247,
-0.993008852,
-0.5591050982,
0.3440669477,
0.2857678533,
0.0604424402,
-0.2454587221,
-0.135959208,
0.182998687,
-1.0096702576,
0.3564539254,
0.1995984465,
0.5175495744,
-0.1145261154,
-0.0895599574,
0.3418113589,
0.0303790867,
0.3399039507,
0.7907101512,
-0.6068508625,
-0.6029552221,
-0.1310134679,
-0.1788710356,
-0.1116910875,
0.9794129729,
-0.6923601031,
0.635756731,
-0.3515653014,
0.7818744183,
0.2794173956,
-0.0054176431,
1.0789538622,
-1.0523284674,
0.4999434948,
0.5122647882,
0.428984195,
0.5151059628,
-0.3591370583,
0.4388433993,
0.2111737877,
-0.3156598806,
-1.0651581287,
0.1349886209,
-0.7737119198,
-0.0466740541,
0.8174459934,
0.1710160077,
0.1812217385,
-0.4814095795,
-0.4953072071,
0.5026078224,
-0.6550018191,
0.9699259996,
0.4221084714,
-0.2278736234,
-0.0107715242,
-0.3275409639,
0.3471295238,
0.3881010711,
-0.663012445,
-0.1063679159,
0.6622764468,
-0.2402991503,
0.5425356627,
0.7066413164,
0.4063598812,
0.6827875972,
0.0594606884,
0.2753152251,
-0.3159245551,
-0.3941466212,
-0.3464627266,
0.0648665503,
0.2611186504,
-0.243063435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00017v1
|
Psittacines of Innovation? Assessing the True Novelty of AI Creations
| 2024-03-17T13:08:11 | 2024-03-17T13:08:11 |
Anirban Mukherjee
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
We examine whether Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems generate truly novel
ideas rather than merely regurgitating patterns learned during training.
Utilizing a novel experimental design, we task an AI with generating project
titles for hypothetical crowdfunding campaigns. We compare within AI-generated
project titles, measuring repetition and complexity. We compare between the
AI-generated titles and actual observed field data using an extension of
maximum mean discrepancy--a metric derived from the application of kernel mean
embeddings of statistical distributions to high-dimensional machine learning
(large language) embedding vectors--yielding a structured analysis of AI output
novelty. Results suggest that (1) the AI generates unique content even under
increasing task complexity, and at the limits of its computational
capabilities, (2) the generated content has face validity, being consistent
with both inputs to other generative AI and in qualitative comparison to field
data, and (3) exhibits divergence from field data, mitigating concerns relating
to intellectual property rights. We discuss implications for copyright and
trademark law.
|
[
-0.4739631414,
-0.6480436921,
0.4922983348,
0.1972619742,
-0.1820542365,
0.3834773302,
0.1410101503,
-0.4447811842,
0.3082535863,
0.2611992061,
-0.4656062126,
-0.1100513861,
-0.7380251288,
0.0143525014,
-0.8196558952,
1.1797918081,
0.1157455668,
-0.2420316339,
-0.1770161986,
-0.2700997293,
-0.0878275484,
-0.3477646708,
-0.3350446522,
-0.1292098463,
0.4425150454,
0.2640295625,
0.5790621042,
0.5531270504,
0.4889433086,
0.4630379677,
0.1831682771,
0.2952311933,
-0.2758051455,
-0.1600572318,
-0.0916626155,
-0.2878453135,
0.2273384631,
0.2005275786,
0.5961405039,
0.4405655563,
0.0696635991,
0.2135484964,
0.0281836819,
0.5088866949,
-0.5598157048,
0.0239705704,
-0.5923389792,
0.280156374,
-0.1823111027,
-0.1636480987,
-0.1131559536,
-0.5575102568,
0.084915258,
-0.7948130369,
0.558000505,
-0.0701038316,
1.0978219509,
0.2518089116,
0.1227888614,
-0.7005891204,
-1.1822075844,
0.5354560018,
-0.6947179437,
-0.3438314497,
-0.1825238764,
0.4317282438,
-0.2237293124,
-0.9578613043,
-1.0341531038,
-0.3507604003,
0.4998826683,
-0.1020094529,
-0.6220300198,
-0.3395583928,
0.1998968571,
0.5717962384,
-0.5455732942,
0.167282477,
-0.5143172145,
0.1043127701,
0.9020372629,
0.1811816543,
0.3663959801,
0.0237539224,
-0.379527837,
-0.3343555927,
-0.3978026509,
0.4222137034,
0.7276965976,
-0.1334209144,
0.0027586562,
0.7046713829,
-0.4858786464,
0.198426649,
0.1756150424,
0.0371614546,
0.4201972783,
-0.0121146692,
-0.2118329555,
-0.0295591243,
0.9597619176,
0.011623173,
0.1982390583,
-0.2507313192,
-0.2097429931,
-0.0547680631,
0.3944034874,
-0.2860472202,
-0.329985112,
0.2367119044,
-0.4589096904,
-0.7783138752,
0.5983359218,
-0.0572251193,
-0.588904798,
-0.005439613,
0.6923229694,
-0.4118185341,
-0.2136740088,
0.050624609,
-0.9131458402,
0.2153418064,
0.1235097349,
-0.5115404725,
-0.1429223567,
0.8520529866,
0.543571949,
-0.0108614285,
-0.4939904511,
-0.1720326096,
-0.0342744291,
-0.6077609062,
0.9498812556,
-0.29077214,
-0.5646856427,
-0.2723470628,
-0.0794594586,
0.2460517287,
-0.6248885989,
0.124831669,
-0.3086418808,
-0.1072678417,
-0.167861551,
-0.4474467933,
0.0168421771,
0.0739718974,
-0.5447987914,
0.7017960548,
0.0300670303,
-0.6342006326,
0.8512981534,
-0.6643645763,
-0.3893043101,
0.5969493985,
-0.6500796676,
-0.3997685909,
0.3977909684,
-0.2499115914,
0.1023978516,
-0.1275434345,
0.3810109794,
-0.1451684386,
-0.2268707752,
0.8958451152,
-0.4180337191,
0.6429640651,
0.2120599598,
-0.6546260118,
-0.0413192436,
-0.8702784777,
-0.0377308428,
0.2030758262,
-0.0112622119,
-0.3598768711,
0.0677644014,
-0.135029763,
0.0098729506,
0.2638972998,
-0.7253229022,
0.1929816604,
-0.1160955131,
0.620341897,
0.7509331703,
0.2214286178,
0.142528668,
-0.8005333543,
0.4049884975,
0.1222060025,
0.1193521619,
-0.0439697765,
-0.9568881392,
-0.6036525965,
-0.4175246358,
0.1786653548,
0.3325740099,
-0.6877454519,
0.289812535,
-0.0262120329,
-0.8452465534,
-0.5122285485,
0.0248170067,
0.124684751,
0.2714527845,
-0.1949921697,
-0.594966352,
-0.3312895298,
-1.3053623438,
-0.5324754119,
-0.1599351317,
-0.3080811203,
0.3738588691,
0.6247720122,
-0.1131828278,
0.8825343847,
-0.3314514756,
0.0214097369,
-0.1725488603,
1.034670949,
0.1442278475,
0.6103717089,
0.5437186956,
-0.8901583552,
-0.123655349,
-0.161407277,
-0.8715794086,
0.3345358372,
-0.4464989305,
0.2754393816,
-0.1571853012,
-0.0215897486,
-0.9790701866,
0.5626587272,
-0.1244014949,
-0.0430850871,
0.5775110722,
-0.3088237643,
0.4141329825,
-0.8804185987,
0.2390397787,
-0.1302746534,
0.4361544251,
-0.3583163619,
-0.0122137228,
-0.3573778272,
-0.215718165,
-0.4851014614,
0.2215457708,
-0.0416841619,
-0.0295590665,
-0.4222342372,
0.0065518883,
-0.0390528366,
0.0877816156,
-0.2629971206,
0.6335375309,
0.3897735775,
-0.6558057666,
0.6713784337,
0.0403695144,
-0.6380952001,
0.308716327,
-0.6668437719,
0.0985464156,
-0.238323912,
0.1742170751,
-1.0200270414,
-0.347669214,
-0.0098638646,
-0.9050260782,
-0.3715214729,
0.371915102,
-0.3982246816,
-0.7271156907,
-0.2050133795,
0.2615114748,
0.6436608434,
-0.2283015102,
0.1429356039,
0.3128915727,
-0.2618715763,
-0.496358484,
-0.9337440729,
0.2068492472,
-0.3742727637,
-0.3311156631,
0.2661537528,
0.0008806667,
-0.5797206759,
0.3050247133,
0.3228184283,
-0.1097573116,
0.2245093435,
0.4915770888,
-0.2202154845,
-0.4250482619,
-0.0050231782,
0.1160940379,
0.0077267243,
0.1398582011,
-0.5798126459,
0.2187577933,
-0.0421756878,
-0.3766334355,
-0.5943611264,
0.3788384497,
0.6012534499,
-0.0406391062,
0.4993227124,
0.6755620241,
-0.4413837194,
-0.3549380302,
-0.3504623175,
0.0506008975,
-0.5186167359,
0.3406754434,
-0.2784334421,
-0.6037495732,
0.3920682669,
0.0605094656,
0.3868784308,
0.7387382388,
0.6820223331,
-0.2871666253,
0.8434888124,
0.778635323,
0.0414771438,
0.1567729861,
-0.60568887,
0.4955492616,
-0.2872402072,
-0.4536889195,
-0.6012815237,
-0.7172404528,
-0.8196961284,
-0.147102803,
0.1362768859,
-0.0010820125,
-0.1950177252,
0.2050125003,
-0.6644870043,
0.3571351171,
1.1130539179,
-0.2689041495,
0.2309200168,
-0.0078638047,
0.2131085545,
0.0685974732,
-0.6481300592,
-0.6817510128,
1.3098607063,
0.1125587821,
0.382456094,
-0.0862872005,
0.9860552549,
0.9324516058,
0.5239567161,
-0.6393548846,
0.1970076114,
-0.062136475,
-0.3478032351,
-0.4184882045,
-0.2284613103,
-0.9198855758,
-0.2746779919,
-0.3663906157,
-0.6643375754,
0.4076223671,
0.0161268152,
-0.5144766569,
0.4868268669,
-0.3827520907,
0.4447908998,
-0.2493086308,
-0.1593828052,
-0.361812681,
-0.2651067078,
0.4057641327,
-0.1381280422,
0.2435306013,
0.0545419566,
0.140994668,
0.8667868972,
-0.2653606236,
0.3976133168,
-0.0365499742,
-0.0363661014,
0.7996198535,
-0.0341197699,
0.1516158283,
0.3306497037,
0.0597056933,
-0.1649050415,
-0.355522424,
-0.5634789467,
-0.6731427908,
0.7798681855,
-0.9446884394,
-0.8633833528,
-0.372159332,
-0.8064786196,
0.0173835717,
0.1957292408,
0.7303604484,
0.3623041809,
-0.5570533276,
0.4085352123,
0.5039865375,
-0.3142842352,
0.3639046848,
0.3576641083,
0.4898697734,
-0.3089482486,
1.2242854834,
0.2094440311,
-0.1729192883,
0.2452516407,
0.1639213264,
0.0634074286,
-0.5239986777,
-0.7346099019,
-0.1709050983,
-0.2530072629,
0.1149508506,
-0.5249016285,
-0.3030074835,
-0.4277263582,
-0.2267583013,
-0.271893084,
-0.8517820239,
0.0333142914,
0.0099368375,
0.2619322836,
1.3439952135,
-0.3346925676,
0.1226764619,
-0.5858946443,
0.284665674,
0.5000736117,
-0.1291004419,
0.098803468,
-0.2163764238,
-0.3231414557,
0.2282468528,
-0.8602443337,
-0.6161906719,
0.1261455119,
0.098883152,
0.6100769043,
0.8095998168,
-0.0238439422,
0.007303582,
-0.3627881408,
1.1951133013,
0.2627821267,
-0.5510889888,
0.4389908016,
-0.4411846101,
0.2915154696,
0.3283268511,
0.4010402262,
-0.0508812256,
-0.7858948708,
-1.2626385689,
-0.660215795,
0.1639608741,
0.4537079036,
0.3148153126,
-0.0019991058,
0.2687885761,
0.2674232125,
0.6023665071,
-0.3313226998,
-0.1004716828,
-0.285910964,
-0.1888774633,
0.0259343423,
0.2525024414,
-0.2211909145,
-0.0135750854,
0.425236851,
0.2587400973,
0.2172634751,
0.2726927698,
0.2458542883,
0.0162477121,
0.0693289489,
0.7551044822,
0.8600852489,
0.2347875535,
-0.0110137258,
-0.0812197253,
-0.4627277255,
0.2457814515,
0.125437513,
-0.1993142813,
0.1866115034,
0.3789048195,
0.5823624134,
-0.1474509835,
-0.8926321268,
0.253965199,
-0.0480881147,
-0.5051637292,
-0.4900769591,
0.3629814386,
0.004171886,
0.5552451611,
0.8463849425,
0.3700898886,
0.4932806492,
-0.6332235932,
0.3793841004,
0.4299769402,
0.0693332329,
-0.2781021595,
0.5348848104,
0.12116009,
-0.8576769233,
0.574354887,
-0.3294656277,
-0.274092257,
1.2325197458,
0.2755044401,
0.9916851521,
0.0276922509,
0.5111573935,
0.018816011,
0.4343512058,
0.1333487928,
0.1474004984,
-0.3170548081,
-0.4528505504,
0.2207636684,
-0.3397059441,
-0.4992967248,
0.5602246523,
-0.4064908028,
0.0673570409,
-0.723295927,
-0.3078032136,
0.2581451833,
-0.211403355,
-0.6880312562,
0.2746667266,
0.0961038172,
0.7076983452,
-0.8093568087,
0.4850000143,
0.7420648932,
-0.6090658903,
-0.5194348693,
0.0135004437,
-0.1218039393,
-0.6142725348,
0.6025476456,
0.0223953221,
-0.073299624,
-0.1532864869,
-0.7265172601,
-0.7554965615,
0.9144094586,
-0.0441764332,
-0.3462418616,
-0.2708961666,
0.5250533223,
0.5504109859,
-0.5323383212,
-0.3330677748,
0.2864477336,
0.248872757,
-0.1741550416,
-0.4733515978,
-0.361500442,
-0.703353703,
-0.1079953685,
-0.0330234654,
-0.4870626926,
0.8672989011,
-0.4432032704,
-0.0738658309,
0.5146610141,
0.7655761242,
0.5474094152,
0.7484664321,
0.2138820142,
0.7100359201,
0.7078168988,
0.0750541389,
0.9825146198,
-0.3563888967,
0.1440100074,
0.6033661366,
0.0463095047,
0.6321595907,
0.4373093843,
0.0304551702,
0.6242278218,
0.4946743548,
-0.4607275128,
0.3209453523,
0.4293667376,
-0.1055398062,
0.0327915773,
-0.0801269487,
-0.4434137046,
0.3761352003,
0.202845633,
-0.4775023162,
0.0811540708,
0.3415070176,
-0.2329692245,
0.103633523,
0.1322545707,
0.7981839776,
0.1532654911,
-0.4883662462,
0.3043635786,
0.0476340577,
0.4527760446,
-0.4153592885,
-0.0905748308,
-0.3235453367,
0.2710096836,
0.0022132262,
-0.6044210196,
0.1567102075,
0.2058743238,
-0.1697015911,
0.2068935931,
0.180380702,
0.1003368348,
-0.6502572894,
-0.4366219938,
0.3370279968,
0.2285453826,
0.2899782658,
-0.6365292072,
-0.0727304742,
-0.3526343405,
-0.1097864881,
0.0690128654,
0.8361089826,
-0.0098060966,
0.6765162945,
0.4934853911,
0.2116487771,
-0.0049469755,
-0.2817697227,
0.6881704926,
-0.5444049835,
-0.8359484673,
-0.4450048506,
0.4169419408,
-0.2371093631,
-0.9302792549,
0.8434251547,
0.711555481,
0.8575174212,
-0.2797388434,
1.197422266,
-0.2861001492,
0.0859722644,
-0.1002393886,
0.8869639635,
-0.5541188717,
0.0519837849,
-0.370011121,
-0.6959288716,
0.2462253422,
0.2439474463,
-0.1641677022,
-0.2196951807,
0.2354455292,
0.5104306936,
-0.1435275823,
0.2527239323,
0.0205210261,
0.1892783195,
0.2370966822,
0.5246619582,
1.1685856581,
-0.3429941535,
0.2481187284,
-0.2180414498,
-0.5382388234,
-0.1277396232,
-0.4094105065,
-0.4043003619,
-0.9100961685,
-0.3298016489,
-0.2796974182,
0.1490671635,
0.4703682661,
0.5377932787,
-0.8507016897,
-0.3238196671,
-0.2528651357,
-0.0095569324,
-0.4187235236,
-0.3179866076,
0.1899153739,
-0.274759233,
-0.5382542014,
0.3537477255,
0.1548780799,
0.0245955326,
-0.5414723754,
0.1108381376,
0.0906307772,
0.5307794809,
0.3509433568,
0.6091998816,
-0.73288095,
-0.0939117745,
-0.0492632091,
-0.0732459724,
-0.1548659205,
1.2263555527,
-0.8908080459,
0.2021971643,
0.6041260958,
0.7692630291,
0.1473005563,
0.0910671055,
0.5773383975,
-0.2141620219,
0.4084810913,
0.4155930579,
-0.0120826168,
0.1931629479,
-0.4149720669,
-0.0585520342,
0.4327957332,
-0.3046040535,
-0.933398664,
0.2610417604,
-0.3730381727,
-0.3761624396,
0.5471239686,
-0.1572017372,
-0.2432192713,
0.0637046099,
0.0382851288,
0.2165005803,
-0.2151808143,
1.4681477547,
0.4391322136,
-0.43020311,
0.2383881509,
-0.300920397,
0.7035515904,
0.1571718305,
-0.5731242895,
-0.4422648847,
0.2203826904,
0.2023597807,
0.5119001269,
0.3425296843,
-0.1409330517,
0.6430931091,
0.3257410824,
-0.0732364729,
-0.2386693805,
-0.4677774608,
0.0237273965,
0.4456920028,
0.1936962903,
-0.3192661405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11203v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11203v1
|
TRELM: Towards Robust and Efficient Pre-training for Knowledge-Enhanced Language Models
| 2024-03-17T13:04:35 | 2024-03-17T13:04:35 |
Junbing Yan, Chengyu Wang, Taolin Zhang, Xiaofeng He, Jun Huang, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue, Wei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
KEPLMs are pre-trained models that utilize external knowledge to enhance
language understanding. Previous language models facilitated knowledge
acquisition by incorporating knowledge-related pre-training tasks learned from
relation triples in knowledge graphs. However, these models do not prioritize
learning embeddings for entity-related tokens. Moreover, updating the entire
set of parameters in KEPLMs is computationally demanding. This paper introduces
TRELM, a Robust and Efficient Pre-training framework for Knowledge-Enhanced
Language Models. We observe that entities in text corpora usually follow the
long-tail distribution, where the representations of some entities are
suboptimally optimized and hinder the pre-training process for KEPLMs. To
tackle this, we employ a robust approach to inject knowledge triples and employ
a knowledge-augmented memory bank to capture valuable information. Furthermore,
updating a small subset of neurons in the feed-forward networks (FFNs) that
store factual knowledge is both sufficient and efficient. Specifically, we
utilize dynamic knowledge routing to identify knowledge paths in FFNs and
selectively update parameters during pre-training. Experimental results show
that TRELM reduces pre-training time by at least 50% and outperforms other
KEPLMs in knowledge probing tasks and multiple knowledge-aware language
understanding tasks.
|
[
-0.1909107119,
-0.6887063384,
0.6191003323,
0.1284999102,
-0.3362669647,
0.5335920453,
-0.3687317669,
-0.1525777727,
-0.1133397967,
0.546054244,
-0.363810122,
-0.6298953891,
-0.538957119,
-0.1535632014,
-0.1721553057,
0.7634704709,
0.0907005519,
-0.0865372792,
-0.2971241176,
-0.1432657242,
-0.2124211937,
-0.6856957078,
-0.6855477691,
-0.2163065821,
0.5258814692,
0.0729746521,
0.3488356769,
0.3979276419,
0.3527824581,
0.3033246994,
-0.0351875573,
0.4538490474,
-0.4452803135,
0.359408021,
-0.1683432162,
-0.4530788958,
-0.485574156,
-0.320192486,
0.6782419682,
0.8560085297,
0.0076116822,
0.0879925191,
0.3465030193,
0.5568574667,
-0.7624773979,
0.1846407652,
-0.8247508407,
-0.0819582939,
-0.4459677339,
-0.1673277915,
-0.5673591495,
-0.5110795498,
0.3157043457,
-0.69825387,
0.0522865467,
0.157865569,
0.7684153914,
0.2792976797,
-0.2609913647,
-0.2326367944,
-0.4855802953,
0.8289429545,
-0.5616750717,
0.8114020228,
0.4316823483,
0.0700362027,
-0.021752974,
-1.0614093542,
-0.4395254254,
-0.2920708358,
-0.3045272231,
-0.1624364108,
-0.0356402956,
0.2608197033,
0.1416591853,
0.002357532,
-0.398259908,
-0.0414845347,
-0.1219291687,
-0.3294095397,
0.0928043723,
-0.0196781456,
0.1009098887,
0.1471769661,
-0.4707638919,
-0.1068926975,
-0.6427702308,
-0.1401164085,
0.2824669182,
0.4298159778,
0.1047707275,
0.2453955859,
0.1025710106,
0.9655837417,
0.0058141295,
-0.1931981146,
0.4465756714,
-0.2896211147,
-0.2436259985,
-0.0829302073,
0.7414960265,
-0.3660348058,
0.304990083,
-0.2806952596,
-0.2503353357,
-0.315058291,
0.3318122029,
-0.5932807922,
-0.2922021747,
0.0235138945,
-0.2083016485,
-0.4911191165,
-0.3431327641,
-0.9173193574,
0.0030406113,
-0.1450885683,
0.6104270816,
-0.7931017876,
-0.3022151291,
0.067255713,
0.1867370158,
-0.0751611963,
0.1901318729,
-0.7489333153,
0.2327345759,
0.4734083712,
0.6439734697,
-0.1301178932,
-0.3766725063,
-0.5914831758,
0.6086401939,
-0.2769754827,
0.647203505,
-0.6614035368,
-0.160716638,
0.0770653933,
-0.2500431836,
-0.2060993761,
-0.3115684986,
0.2592422664,
-0.9772200584,
0.2376510352,
-0.3004624248,
-0.6363271475,
-0.139675498,
0.435248673,
-0.526499331,
1.0130529404,
0.1798220128,
-0.9224261642,
0.38883847,
-0.8860653043,
-0.6901662946,
0.0041272067,
0.1793777198,
-0.303894639,
-0.095150426,
0.2878499627,
0.5575549603,
0.0470716245,
0.3684543073,
-0.4233239889,
0.004384201,
-0.138382405,
-0.240057379,
0.7699875236,
0.2325769216,
-0.1304584891,
0.1239117831,
-0.706746757,
0.1136597991,
-0.0222076718,
-0.3882879615,
-0.7121156454,
-0.1906234622,
-0.493478328,
0.0726509765,
0.2938857973,
-0.2100943476,
0.0511379167,
-0.4399973154,
0.4016911983,
0.8127943277,
0.002234797,
0.5043104291,
-0.0015036713,
0.4287931323,
0.187580213,
0.1174138263,
-0.1859812886,
-0.0725858286,
-0.8217446804,
-0.1657269597,
0.5545239449,
0.3340658545,
-1.0406512022,
0.3635031581,
-0.3603768349,
-0.3791161478,
-0.3915788829,
0.2605949044,
0.3401370347,
0.8228866458,
0.5011778474,
0.0608459376,
-0.4780031145,
-0.6436017752,
-0.337759912,
-0.3308495581,
0.0447222888,
0.1152647957,
0.2954273224,
-0.0542721786,
0.7931901217,
-0.45597893,
-0.210427478,
-0.3184259236,
0.1731874943,
-0.0402029455,
0.6033363342,
0.5059816241,
-0.7022672296,
-0.5043545961,
-0.1947917193,
-0.4230326116,
-0.1044445485,
-0.0028843128,
-0.3309904635,
0.1126312986,
0.5392291546,
-0.728428483,
-0.0052389023,
0.3495725095,
-0.2455949187,
0.3178530335,
-0.3128368855,
-0.0763355792,
-0.9957624674,
0.2210025936,
-0.3190539181,
-0.5302961469,
-0.7186239958,
-0.0550366789,
0.2768140733,
-0.0009726455,
-0.5144942403,
0.6127225161,
-0.4656794071,
-0.0284789093,
0.0867711455,
0.0491024517,
0.3098498285,
0.7988114953,
0.3216016591,
0.5662298203,
0.6030064225,
-0.8152145743,
0.2045942247,
0.1621748954,
-0.3355162144,
0.3401311636,
-0.3165123165,
0.3801625073,
-0.0620070845,
-0.0619052723,
-0.629727602,
0.1843479276,
0.3096993268,
-0.2647887766,
0.6801091433,
0.0540788919,
-0.5338659286,
-0.3367041945,
-0.0733790249,
0.3317552805,
0.4543274641,
-0.520430088,
1.0647388697,
0.370896399,
0.0053183492,
-0.7306150794,
-0.6821151972,
-0.2561306357,
-0.1845971197,
-0.4404176176,
0.3498284221,
0.1602290571,
-0.0922772139,
0.2707110941,
-0.0181902293,
-0.1764809042,
0.1108277589,
-0.2825087905,
0.0133402143,
-0.1491265595,
0.6061697602,
0.0329555199,
-0.0007875278,
-0.0054210383,
-0.8589482903,
0.8274154663,
-0.1791592091,
-0.3506650031,
-0.1589950919,
0.132950604,
0.6691632867,
-0.4638898075,
0.8056679368,
0.6378808618,
-0.3714917004,
-0.234588027,
-0.7064458132,
-0.1783094555,
-0.497903496,
0.5790439844,
-0.5383678675,
-0.7926511765,
0.3180253506,
-0.2352671027,
0.1086228937,
0.353167057,
0.3865400851,
-0.3005393445,
0.7236127853,
0.7019518018,
0.0216488652,
0.3357806802,
-0.1302015781,
0.1226988733,
-0.6172321439,
-0.5831112862,
-0.4722791016,
0.0662914738,
-0.1290945709,
-0.5022287369,
0.0762749836,
0.1186650321,
-0.4033649862,
0.2359068096,
-0.1339235753,
0.1872146577,
0.6469864845,
0.1942737401,
0.1896321476,
-0.0236200914,
-0.5706529617,
0.0631144941,
-1.1112693548,
-0.2742666006,
1.0827182531,
0.2841536105,
0.654456079,
-0.258105278,
0.5093932748,
0.2303112149,
0.2650384009,
-0.4394957125,
0.5969638228,
-0.1559649408,
-0.4740538895,
-0.3526358604,
-0.5261201262,
-0.7106207609,
-0.0668010116,
-0.2268212289,
-0.3828921616,
0.1939199418,
0.5314203501,
-0.5416626334,
0.7554457188,
-0.680986762,
0.840444386,
-0.5467547774,
-0.4633653164,
-0.2574938238,
-0.6659394503,
0.1575423479,
-0.4997020662,
0.1203042194,
0.1836197376,
-0.2649018168,
0.6997456551,
-0.4863224924,
0.6744948626,
-0.4203995466,
0.061159689,
0.266780436,
0.1310923696,
0.7635625601,
-0.1600304693,
-0.1408208162,
-0.0083977301,
-0.2277899981,
-0.5311587453,
-0.6562474966,
0.3562114537,
-0.6212136745,
-0.6948973536,
-0.1769033223,
-0.5168506503,
-0.7420446277,
0.2812020183,
0.2302654833,
0.4761899114,
0.0094141653,
0.3057405651,
0.8351863027,
-0.4491678476,
0.3862094879,
0.3926331103,
-0.201389119,
-0.3765844107,
0.7562260032,
0.0273668934,
0.4907594621,
0.8340645432,
0.1136164442,
-0.7327229381,
-0.6934422851,
-0.0550766438,
0.0592502281,
-0.682710588,
-0.2360338867,
-1.0135458708,
-0.1638897061,
-0.443924129,
0.0152948406,
-0.4426205158,
-0.1891598254,
-0.1870679408,
-0.2103575021,
0.3290086091,
0.3595623672,
-0.1211517006,
0.3183917403,
-0.8575942516,
0.1653108746,
0.6404110193,
0.5845235586,
0.129616484,
-0.3866707683,
-0.246086061,
-0.0058649667,
0.1303074062,
-0.7867127061,
0.3576331437,
0.2561419308,
0.6958162189,
0.3917108178,
0.1033663005,
0.7681356668,
-0.3712014556,
0.6385368109,
0.1580488682,
-1.0851668119,
0.6724606752,
-0.1421096772,
0.3412441909,
0.6624338031,
0.4642556906,
-0.1710982919,
-0.372415632,
-0.613096714,
-0.5892745256,
0.7391482592,
0.1448856443,
0.1684883535,
0.0519537888,
0.1905652136,
0.153799668,
0.5215902925,
-0.6489644051,
-0.1665440798,
-0.3893665969,
-0.3320808709,
0.1095952094,
-0.508975327,
0.1079402193,
-0.3302843273,
0.8371700048,
0.0535104424,
0.11598441,
-0.0296928026,
-0.4137724936,
0.1872951388,
0.0465080924,
0.460931778,
0.7007254362,
-0.2869519591,
0.5170139074,
0.5561766624,
-0.6599545479,
0.095724538,
0.0321083739,
-0.090559043,
0.1430301517,
0.4493716657,
0.8711955547,
0.2928624451,
-0.5183950663,
0.3921084702,
0.0425962247,
-0.2011848688,
-0.0725835189,
-0.0967729092,
0.1616615206,
0.165143311,
0.2709854245,
0.3238156736,
-0.3419528604,
-0.2961277664,
0.3248527944,
0.3346243799,
-0.3749521971,
-0.3461511433,
0.4986956418,
0.3530818224,
-0.2550798059,
0.5501053333,
-0.1408382505,
-0.8082054853,
0.11509718,
0.4373061359,
0.7196208835,
-0.437963903,
0.1826545298,
0.1335951686,
0.2947714925,
0.0917712376,
0.273512125,
-0.2353930324,
-0.8286135793,
-0.5368942618,
-0.8505910039,
-0.0644449443,
0.4281095862,
-0.3617636263,
0.3013139665,
-0.4213521183,
-0.1445727199,
-0.4051472545,
0.0673630089,
-0.9892226458,
0.1695618927,
-0.0428547189,
1.1236770153,
-0.5753840804,
1.3571436405,
0.6411718726,
-0.1153276712,
-0.9500914216,
-0.0461192802,
-0.5109342337,
-0.8419929743,
0.7957080603,
-0.2083227336,
-0.0319091976,
0.3348914087,
-0.2896472514,
-0.9411992431,
0.8179004192,
0.6128799915,
-0.6046465039,
-0.224029243,
0.2816603184,
0.4339850545,
-0.261207521,
0.0898255184,
0.3722678125,
0.6097000837,
0.0755545571,
-0.4688266218,
-0.0287987422,
-0.0363105498,
-0.1098568663,
0.3120438457,
-0.4244660139,
0.5831605792,
-0.1038943082,
-0.1860818565,
-0.3570269942,
0.6909146309,
0.2745989859,
0.0210967306,
0.9221102595,
0.5423413515,
1.0170012712,
-0.0326291248,
0.8192275167,
-0.5642731786,
0.068360351,
1.1652632952,
-0.1500210166,
0.5746175051,
0.5161261559,
-0.0931470171,
0.5096067786,
0.6098216772,
0.1718126237,
0.8754968047,
0.023255378,
-0.2395430803,
-0.6184939146,
0.0413090326,
-0.3410465121,
0.2476537377,
0.4608967006,
-0.3978339732,
-0.2558733225,
0.1803159565,
-0.0561011322,
0.0226878598,
-0.3418162465,
0.6532109976,
0.2003510296,
-0.5033677816,
0.3841767311,
-0.290171355,
0.5737490654,
-0.9894001484,
0.1888671368,
-0.1382793635,
0.0463578328,
0.1059456989,
-0.6738212109,
0.362949878,
0.0481990911,
0.0302061029,
-0.467048794,
1.1342772245,
-0.7216731906,
-0.4389687777,
0.3809413612,
0.811783731,
-0.1208270192,
-0.0563397296,
-0.6661069393,
-0.1849965304,
-0.0317137614,
-0.5027433038,
0.0747067034,
0.6414724588,
0.1501613706,
0.825576365,
0.6991164088,
0.3331585228,
0.0841434523,
0.1793781072,
0.8402557373,
-0.4108233452,
-0.645616591,
-1.0573911667,
0.5128216743,
-0.1777564883,
0.0263859667,
0.4777701199,
0.3582081795,
0.7702943087,
-0.1270364523,
0.7417678237,
0.1032849327,
0.6067296863,
-0.6181873083,
0.8547636867,
-0.4869531393,
0.3979585469,
-0.1547537446,
-0.8983616233,
-0.2367338091,
0.28245911,
-0.4283388257,
0.0066190846,
0.6374733448,
0.6801849008,
-0.1479001194,
-0.1017375365,
0.3862438202,
0.3247502148,
0.1187321395,
0.6136431098,
0.9795573354,
0.1402606517,
0.9013462067,
-0.4414377809,
0.1160541996,
0.0994331241,
-0.9799514413,
-1.0304963589,
-0.6458969712,
-0.1722577959,
-0.0093073966,
0.3603551388,
0.8921175599,
1.0010100603,
-0.7046841979,
0.129171446,
-0.2653463781,
0.2871985435,
-0.1090587899,
-0.1788892597,
0.7130504847,
-0.7915869355,
-0.5350152254,
0.3048772514,
0.2712074816,
0.1311652809,
-0.2373406738,
-0.0279866271,
-0.2622899711,
-0.1968861073,
0.5804199576,
-0.0028589123,
-0.369261086,
-0.4128501415,
0.0617785901,
-0.0189434756,
-0.0452954732,
0.7184998989,
-1.1113138199,
0.3658721745,
0.5721830726,
0.8880572915,
0.5447252393,
-0.2086668164,
0.9263256788,
-0.9228699803,
0.2033830136,
0.479611814,
0.3442390859,
0.3427476585,
-0.3216487765,
0.3771218956,
0.2801619768,
-0.1431813687,
-0.9644197226,
0.0452434458,
-0.6977191567,
-0.3703633249,
0.9046707153,
-0.4351904988,
-0.1890328377,
-0.2530900538,
0.2318490446,
0.4264076352,
-0.1760003716,
0.5265846848,
0.5500901341,
0.2660862803,
-0.2514646947,
-0.3266847432,
0.895334065,
0.451385498,
-0.7876158357,
-0.0319424607,
0.0065239863,
0.2555871308,
0.097290203,
0.5649458766,
-0.0926873535,
-0.1775632501,
-0.2011525184,
-0.0663902462,
-0.448916018,
-0.4344079196,
0.0418794304,
0.4799650908,
-0.0152029824,
-0.2686412036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14705v1
|
Concept-Best-Matching: Evaluating Compositionality in Emergent Communication
| 2024-03-17T12:47:02 | 2024-03-17T12:47:02 |
Boaz Carmeli, Yonatan Belinkov, Ron Meir
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Artificial agents that learn to communicate in order to accomplish a given
task acquire communication protocols that are typically opaque to a human. A
large body of work has attempted to evaluate the emergent communication via
various evaluation measures, with \emph{compositionality} featuring as a
prominent desired trait. However, current evaluation procedures do not directly
expose the compositionality of the emergent communication. We propose a
procedure to assess the compositionality of emergent communication by finding
the best-match between emerged words and natural language concepts. The
best-match algorithm provides both a global score and a translation-map from
emergent words to natural language concepts. To the best of our knowledge, it
is the first time that such direct and interpretable mapping between emergent
words and human concepts is provided.
|
[
-0.3727289736,
-0.8120048642,
0.5650503635,
0.4494928718,
-0.4569885135,
0.7372519374,
-0.2099320292,
-0.8491650224,
0.2773125768,
0.0375836678,
-0.3239993751,
-0.2722258568,
-0.4270401895,
0.2927065492,
-0.4048936665,
0.6469346285,
-0.0642162114,
-0.4693609774,
-0.3619452715,
0.0584193207,
-0.4496684968,
0.1613261104,
-0.9413330555,
-0.7319964767,
0.1134554669,
0.1476302147,
0.6140325665,
0.8880062103,
0.676246047,
0.5430662632,
-0.3565259576,
0.4061653614,
-0.5336165428,
0.2774843872,
-0.5214215517,
-0.3652390838,
-0.0872042999,
0.117334418,
0.5454636216,
0.4106261432,
-0.1280295402,
0.2931647003,
-0.025706375,
0.5427533388,
-0.4579994678,
0.2260110825,
-0.637930572,
0.2918641865,
0.0758754089,
-0.6139727831,
-0.3571242094,
-0.3136906922,
0.3777306974,
-0.7056369185,
-0.0058497568,
0.2361183316,
0.8497375846,
0.2165199816,
-0.4847754836,
-0.4860977232,
-0.9742182493,
0.3737980723,
-0.134422496,
0.1738509387,
0.1466449052,
0.4288052619,
-0.2142349333,
-0.4861898124,
-0.7647290826,
-0.2966244221,
0.0391142555,
0.4180946052,
-0.2477058321,
0.1801763177,
-0.3291040063,
0.5091335177,
-0.6821086407,
-0.1369827688,
-0.1931383908,
-0.2290390432,
0.774969697,
0.137365669,
0.5598086715,
-0.0546585396,
-0.6397612095,
-0.1391676068,
-0.0800780132,
-0.3971745074,
0.2192996293,
0.3710102141,
-0.2588405013,
0.4322954714,
-0.1052064747,
0.9188902378,
0.2378920615,
-0.0984346494,
0.1660855114,
-0.7222576737,
-0.1597997695,
0.0640668124,
0.8114202619,
0.5341798663,
0.1214274019,
-0.5223870277,
-0.2140346766,
0.3631331921,
0.2628929317,
-0.4486442804,
-0.0652690679,
0.1006800458,
-0.2986548841,
-0.5886460543,
0.1480263621,
-0.3496299386,
-0.2966384888,
-0.3345764279,
0.6427668333,
-0.2128029317,
-0.5389338136,
-0.2736896276,
-0.3011382222,
0.550442338,
0.050398089,
-0.8617555499,
0.234970808,
0.8137039542,
1.1864528656,
-0.359259367,
-0.0633796677,
0.0885381326,
-0.0039052183,
-0.7468281388,
1.1575206518,
-0.3896844983,
-0.3382910192,
-0.2848311663,
-0.3936556876,
-0.2679000199,
-0.654166162,
0.6715612411,
-0.5539737344,
0.1428647786,
-0.0641814843,
-0.8880236745,
0.1420295238,
0.1901313215,
-0.5701552033,
0.7241799235,
0.3809945583,
-0.6916065216,
0.4249885976,
-1.0913176537,
-0.3446351886,
0.5758234859,
0.0798158571,
0.0377550833,
-0.1096385717,
-0.385586381,
0.1799157113,
-0.1725270897,
0.0001386627,
-0.031968005,
-0.3620106578,
0.3868072629,
0.204662323,
0.6589618921,
0.503090322,
-0.3180345595,
0.3651545942,
-0.6415519714,
0.1849061251,
0.4268242121,
-0.2002737224,
-0.4980765581,
0.1894076616,
0.0107091945,
0.2704615593,
0.3506929278,
-0.6169871092,
-0.2535549402,
-0.6337119937,
0.6180734038,
0.9599143863,
0.0958589613,
0.8176209927,
-0.6627485156,
0.2569046319,
-0.1437178999,
0.1991073191,
-0.0427507982,
-0.4296291471,
-0.6151821613,
-0.1433146894,
0.0466693901,
0.6713483334,
-0.5793308616,
0.9101518989,
-0.2832545638,
-0.8938702345,
-0.8974835873,
0.0174685996,
0.4184624255,
0.4021766484,
0.0781631395,
-0.4574971795,
-0.6093466282,
-0.8396895528,
-0.1335953772,
-0.4456591308,
0.1600548029,
0.2063218206,
0.3200117052,
-0.276062429,
1.0042806864,
-0.3807600737,
-0.2420773357,
-0.2974121273,
0.1803491265,
-0.1308821142,
0.4444970787,
0.3976239264,
-0.9517745376,
-0.7546405196,
0.2968002856,
-0.6886969805,
0.0170093328,
-0.0008942432,
-0.3721907735,
-0.2412615716,
0.3374372721,
-0.5338283777,
-0.1152689531,
0.6203220487,
-0.6202329397,
0.2491772026,
-0.0987099558,
0.2449077964,
-1.4249190092,
0.1377207935,
-0.0829509497,
-0.1632026583,
-0.6702656746,
0.800286293,
-0.2404147983,
0.1944647431,
-0.3385595083,
0.7105476856,
-0.4165079296,
-0.1899514496,
-0.3350037634,
0.6095166802,
-0.0442105271,
-0.1350524575,
0.0317374989,
0.8755584955,
0.5339354873,
-0.821365416,
0.5682888031,
0.5745534897,
-0.2340087742,
0.9764086604,
-0.7374504209,
0.5059884787,
-0.1831224561,
0.211300537,
-0.9788836241,
-0.1033387184,
0.157822594,
-0.6652680039,
0.0205042884,
0.0588920377,
-0.4801388681,
-0.2321748734,
-0.1728868484,
0.3241669536,
0.2890999615,
-0.2046395838,
0.484193325,
0.2713135183,
0.1224995106,
-0.2118980438,
-0.3833034933,
0.3387556374,
-0.1704328954,
-0.7399070859,
0.6235092282,
-0.6170380116,
-0.160521552,
-0.1710436791,
-0.1083106101,
-0.1343235821,
0.4354438186,
-0.0951511785,
0.151960969,
-0.320471406,
-0.3293368518,
-0.2056726217,
-0.1536166519,
0.0910350978,
-0.3247313797,
0.422677815,
-0.2559908628,
-0.1792757809,
-0.2376716733,
0.4422136247,
0.4792788327,
-0.1697670221,
0.7593142986,
0.795658052,
-0.3371714652,
-0.1770973653,
-0.3084375858,
-0.1805000454,
-0.5421831608,
0.3599420786,
-0.333627522,
-0.5343236923,
0.4644504189,
-0.1062991917,
-0.0102145923,
0.4773206711,
0.3837775588,
-0.1590412259,
0.7832913995,
0.741866827,
0.1061155498,
0.5548727512,
-0.271610558,
0.1555417478,
-0.9338352084,
-0.5135563016,
-0.6021207571,
-0.2331961691,
-0.8042951226,
-0.2977578342,
0.135694012,
-0.3801174164,
-0.0989777669,
0.6024879217,
-0.7288627625,
0.7775751352,
0.4279425442,
0.101327844,
0.4571691155,
-0.3903324008,
-0.3798424006,
0.1527009904,
-0.3671656251,
-0.5586580038,
0.9203311205,
0.0419293717,
0.4642938077,
0.3705287278,
0.9210490584,
0.4447339475,
0.2368042022,
-1.030420661,
0.6994889975,
0.1600884795,
-0.3686546087,
-0.2008392215,
-0.6745412946,
-1.3222857714,
0.2674366534,
-0.5105487108,
-0.7224330902,
-0.2692970634,
-0.1275012642,
-0.0479954183,
-0.0134958774,
-0.7193371654,
0.8331864476,
-0.219523564,
0.1073902175,
-0.1142531633,
-0.8734007478,
0.2735490799,
-0.1406013072,
0.0902701244,
-0.0556312464,
-0.2209935337,
0.7310150266,
0.3395762742,
0.3623463213,
0.2955770791,
-0.2211682796,
0.310788542,
0.2633126676,
0.0755511224,
-0.4096840322,
0.1182397082,
-0.3434327543,
-0.0582892112,
-0.431202054,
-0.6096193194,
0.2049774528,
-0.9451852441,
-0.1603112817,
-0.5013145804,
-0.1299427748,
0.0335244201,
0.3116559088,
0.2963729203,
0.0165146086,
-0.8394168615,
-0.0558106117,
0.7970369458,
0.2824038565,
0.4843458235,
0.8100374341,
0.0784275755,
-0.2184635699,
1.1061176062,
-0.5282843113,
0.5745097399,
0.8358947635,
0.3870081007,
-0.5347673893,
-0.5832122564,
-0.3150128424,
-0.0526456237,
-0.6467591524,
-0.3092437088,
-0.4450776279,
-0.5792235732,
0.0083334455,
-0.0373935476,
-0.2611264288,
0.045997262,
-0.2638249099,
-0.1746695638,
-0.3207041025,
0.9161542058,
-0.1116835028,
0.1736704558,
-0.845058322,
0.3074328601,
0.481955111,
0.0817617103,
-0.165879488,
-0.5500193834,
-0.2015474141,
-0.0006464929,
-0.5472531915,
-1.0557990074,
-0.1597329676,
0.7804060578,
0.7714565396,
0.6613563299,
-0.0511573553,
0.4803951383,
-0.210305512,
0.5681245923,
0.0814679489,
-1.0913746357,
0.8517814875,
-0.1582636088,
0.1925117075,
0.4858697355,
0.286124289,
-0.7115504146,
-0.6028620005,
-0.7806888819,
-0.805313468,
0.34858495,
0.4883201122,
0.2753160298,
-0.197977677,
0.0379672796,
-0.1437475383,
0.1437939703,
-0.5581554174,
-0.2178156823,
0.202648893,
-0.3823879659,
-0.2160741389,
0.2411470413,
-0.3683168292,
-0.0168412421,
0.1799450666,
-0.1936414391,
0.9199081063,
0.0765995979,
-0.2622103393,
-0.5111031532,
0.2753039598,
0.7674632072,
0.7779713273,
-0.0347911492,
0.1469628215,
-0.2836399972,
-0.5640543699,
0.5383072495,
0.031059932,
-0.3721691072,
-0.0816394761,
0.5423569083,
0.6483072042,
0.2449329197,
-0.5556702614,
0.6063606739,
-0.0957397744,
-0.0174646396,
-0.1040935442,
0.349329561,
0.1864602268,
0.2599159181,
0.4886910617,
0.3886666596,
0.3402336836,
-0.9287138581,
0.4035131931,
0.5348299146,
-0.2440876663,
-0.5669770837,
0.4134129882,
0.3969051838,
-0.6001269221,
0.3215788603,
-0.5714273453,
-0.6983143091,
0.5432807207,
0.8045232296,
0.9988731742,
-0.7177066207,
0.6313438416,
0.2956743836,
0.4346166253,
0.0598832518,
0.2872340083,
-0.1728195399,
-1.0857410431,
-0.2869869173,
-0.6262138486,
-0.3365956843,
-0.2130025476,
-0.4643634856,
-0.1452193111,
-0.2024526596,
-0.2348408848,
0.0819787681,
0.1254990995,
-0.645935297,
0.1250718385,
0.1855200976,
0.8701403737,
-1.2053172588,
0.137628451,
0.9693676829,
-0.4138144851,
-0.6054046154,
-0.0881972164,
-0.1719682664,
-0.8122885227,
0.3491519988,
-0.1062500849,
-0.1896261722,
0.221016109,
-0.4224573374,
-0.9035423398,
1.2117702961,
0.5013237,
0.1399823725,
-0.0153307859,
-0.0040279701,
0.7263289094,
-0.557023108,
0.7599169016,
0.6051273346,
0.5061364174,
0.5151829123,
-1.1336796284,
0.1722201705,
-0.3468077183,
-0.0269856509,
0.1002195254,
-0.727152288,
0.4963842034,
-0.2173218727,
-0.6241108179,
0.2008405477,
0.7761946321,
0.0345509537,
0.4207111299,
0.5131255984,
0.4410197735,
0.7082023621,
-0.0256761983,
0.4019297659,
-0.2858161628,
0.3244090676,
0.9904488921,
-0.0896074846,
0.8372113705,
0.1792884171,
-0.23584342,
0.4905102253,
0.8399479985,
0.2674573958,
0.5728361011,
0.3752994537,
-0.2642959356,
-0.1050207466,
-0.3919773102,
-0.1082951054,
0.7948569059,
0.2867126167,
-0.0655874237,
-0.0564727336,
-0.4229102731,
-0.3620010614,
0.3622882366,
0.0723043457,
1.4788229465,
-0.0276300032,
-0.6132100224,
0.5315115452,
0.0514177978,
0.5912286043,
-0.4429818392,
-0.0492584221,
-0.2675668001,
-0.2319562882,
-0.2302820683,
-0.7025364041,
0.1736043245,
-0.4722245038,
0.3232299089,
0.1017454043,
0.5649551749,
-0.6373462677,
0.042896498,
0.4270841777,
0.7045704722,
-0.043365784,
0.0609771758,
-0.9384862185,
-0.0999924392,
-0.5077636242,
0.3398701847,
0.0670424476,
0.3137360513,
0.3104605377,
0.8866614699,
0.5189077854,
0.2275338024,
-0.0440627374,
-0.1678263992,
0.6176278591,
-0.445271939,
-0.8348807096,
-0.802631855,
0.3622370362,
-0.4547620118,
-0.4154331982,
0.4110921323,
0.5774755478,
0.7477238774,
0.0844160616,
0.6564924717,
-0.151322633,
-0.0238403305,
-0.2919313312,
0.5487521291,
-0.2361160666,
-0.1982497275,
-0.6504305601,
-1.4060593843,
0.3657072783,
0.8854258657,
0.5723817348,
0.1122822911,
0.9092656374,
0.4513934255,
-0.2659831047,
0.0928965285,
0.19458884,
0.0455628335,
0.1723149866,
0.6648058891,
1.020121932,
-0.3632242382,
0.3431115746,
0.1213718876,
-0.555414319,
-0.2319272608,
-0.9010519981,
-0.6380992532,
-0.9986616969,
-0.4163165689,
-0.2352432758,
0.1291171461,
1.1939283609,
0.8072186708,
-0.5773735642,
-0.2866237164,
-0.2711608708,
0.1852162629,
-0.5999777913,
-0.2679186761,
0.091470018,
-0.1628101021,
-0.4752344191,
0.6170307994,
0.2885858715,
0.5021166205,
-0.4494685233,
-0.2365466058,
-0.1009701714,
0.4082495272,
0.7045673728,
0.2488232404,
-0.4810368419,
-0.4048427641,
0.0361032486,
-0.1031311899,
0.0297922064,
0.7860793471,
-0.2563569248,
0.8055225611,
0.3410944343,
0.7853502631,
0.2411212176,
0.0217763837,
0.6473439932,
-0.768031776,
-0.0902011171,
0.4380327165,
-0.1320092678,
0.7029810548,
-0.2742267251,
0.4849784672,
0.3678488433,
-0.3605722189,
-0.5662971735,
0.3444876373,
-1.1400139332,
0.2301068604,
0.9424989223,
0.0138487909,
-0.1003024429,
-0.2919864357,
-0.1067821681,
0.4542422891,
-0.3303170204,
0.9269561172,
0.5777340531,
0.1544115543,
-0.0109536955,
-0.188890934,
0.6059690118,
-0.0994534642,
-0.9157002568,
-0.5291780829,
-0.1291709393,
0.2362589687,
0.3952823281,
0.8695659041,
0.3003477454,
0.1535548568,
-0.0325455144,
-0.3552435637,
0.2133087069,
-0.2179478854,
0.2364823222,
-0.2528366745,
0.269392997,
-0.370924294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11183v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11183v2
|
Decoding Continuous Character-based Language from Non-invasive Brain Recordings
| 2024-03-17T12:12:33 | 2024-03-19T10:09:20 |
Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Ruicheng Yin, Shujie Geng, Jianhan Xu, Xuan Gao, Changze Lv, Zixuan Ling, Xuanjing Huang, Miao Cao, Jianfeng Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deciphering natural language from brain activity through non-invasive devices
remains a formidable challenge. Previous non-invasive decoders either require
multiple experiments with identical stimuli to pinpoint cortical regions and
enhance signal-to-noise ratios in brain activity, or they are limited to
discerning basic linguistic elements such as letters and words. We propose a
novel approach to decoding continuous language from single-trial non-invasive
fMRI recordings, in which a three-dimensional convolutional network augmented
with information bottleneck is developed to automatically identify responsive
voxels to stimuli, and a character-based decoder is designed for the semantic
reconstruction of continuous language characterized by inherent character
structures. The resulting decoder can produce intelligible textual sequences
that faithfully capture the meaning of perceived speech both within and across
subjects, while existing decoders exhibit significantly inferior performance in
cross-subject contexts. The ability to decode continuous language from single
trials across subjects demonstrates the promising applications of non-invasive
language brain-computer interfaces in both healthcare and neuroscience.
|
[
-0.1772090793,
-0.9702970386,
0.436098069,
0.3607901633,
-0.5066416264,
0.0930129513,
-0.3407239318,
-0.402720958,
0.5274426341,
0.6501105428,
-0.6702507734,
-0.5409266353,
-0.3817726672,
0.4460600019,
-0.3292089701,
0.7037799954,
0.0090590585,
0.0415540598,
-0.243331641,
-0.3523927033,
-0.5860484242,
-0.5824440122,
-0.8157811165,
-0.3528065085,
0.5223641396,
0.0984885693,
0.4385679364,
0.3599835932,
0.1950698048,
0.2461826205,
0.0082028927,
0.1718967557,
-0.3895563483,
-0.105542846,
0.1670002639,
-0.2237433344,
-0.0322912149,
-0.395922333,
0.7662305832,
0.9862646461,
-0.0499169156,
-0.2855238318,
0.254565239,
0.555642128,
-0.5505000353,
0.3824073076,
-0.222947225,
-0.1386060715,
-0.2197569758,
-0.1634472609,
-0.8219665289,
-0.3986818194,
-0.2129467726,
-0.6812247038,
0.2249612063,
-0.198730275,
0.6178650856,
0.0027069917,
-0.2372850329,
-0.5201601386,
-0.4735524058,
0.5669540167,
-0.4563665688,
0.434070915,
0.5493022799,
-0.0173099823,
-0.3060523272,
-0.5702417493,
-0.7228914499,
-0.338665098,
-0.4136480987,
-0.0393823907,
-0.1791186929,
0.1816546768,
0.0399515331,
0.1313831359,
-0.7616456151,
-0.037504632,
-0.1571054757,
-0.3559970856,
0.420062691,
0.1154100001,
0.6668291688,
-0.0905913115,
-0.0511030816,
-0.1204450503,
-0.3603377938,
0.0542042889,
-0.1032254025,
0.3462633491,
-0.3159175217,
0.5297268629,
0.182611689,
0.5417978764,
0.0155571038,
-0.060887441,
0.2999480665,
-0.2259089947,
-0.1023631021,
0.2531799972,
0.9318961501,
0.1879544407,
0.1446391344,
-0.5495126247,
0.0225636717,
0.2145561725,
0.0068079033,
-0.5733977556,
-0.3680297732,
0.1983396709,
-0.4621015191,
0.0957127884,
-0.324288547,
-0.736525178,
-0.3895397186,
-0.0154841784,
0.2178550959,
-0.8763347864,
-0.4822360575,
0.3496244848,
-0.2556750774,
-0.000534011,
-0.1993540823,
-1.0082167387,
0.3333207071,
0.3169066608,
0.956671536,
-0.0740816146,
-0.0765806437,
-0.4174191654,
0.1260126382,
-0.5119835138,
0.775711,
-0.2447502613,
-0.5786931515,
-0.1229614913,
0.0498362146,
-0.2180705965,
-0.5040714741,
0.4864493906,
-0.4218252003,
-0.1511909515,
-0.2350245118,
-0.4034899771,
-0.0212611854,
0.0553631298,
-0.9078811407,
0.3821412027,
0.1763744503,
-0.5553967357,
0.0811264515,
-0.8075833321,
-0.8346760869,
0.471357137,
-0.3210669756,
-0.4515305161,
0.3996284604,
0.1969425827,
0.1986229271,
0.1072844937,
0.1646430939,
-0.2842467725,
-0.4434426427,
0.5330579877,
-0.620914638,
0.677793026,
0.1070599705,
-0.0603791811,
-0.2653016448,
-0.9443828464,
0.2192434967,
0.1209037751,
-0.3638855517,
-0.41849944,
0.1665629894,
0.2255870402,
-0.119329378,
0.3271298409,
-0.9451951981,
-0.1076240018,
-0.2691674531,
0.5770148635,
0.0538405776,
0.1915136725,
0.2554209828,
-0.2189001441,
0.2039830685,
-0.0820092112,
-0.232104525,
-0.1190966889,
-0.2826079726,
-0.6826286912,
-0.7474873066,
0.0813555419,
0.3340833187,
-1.2503471375,
0.2400826663,
-0.5258603096,
-0.180317685,
-0.5804803967,
-0.3915474415,
0.4013576508,
0.7012827992,
0.5764046311,
-0.3703196347,
-0.5258406401,
-0.8701328635,
-0.1329705268,
-0.207802102,
-0.4478144646,
0.0546177551,
0.055050768,
-0.1122545674,
0.7762697339,
-0.2332248986,
-0.2675198317,
-0.3102506995,
0.5581623912,
0.355935365,
0.3387618661,
-0.0417460799,
-0.3451982737,
-0.3266791105,
0.3407715857,
-0.9357944131,
0.0586534031,
-0.4689843059,
0.126010552,
0.2023992687,
0.5146951675,
-0.3919869661,
0.1477627754,
0.4638483226,
-0.3770655394,
0.0863772258,
-0.4364192784,
0.0562894233,
-0.7021760941,
0.3896276951,
-0.035819374,
0.0287915468,
-0.9091340303,
-0.2623439431,
0.3792839348,
-0.0557301864,
0.015020675,
0.3090215623,
-0.7502440214,
0.3424072862,
-0.4181670845,
0.0646829382,
0.1244682297,
0.657387495,
0.6407991052,
0.8151108027,
0.1547464132,
-0.5312321782,
-0.1396151781,
0.4137723744,
-0.4085268378,
0.7148940563,
-0.3590043783,
0.4095374942,
-0.4327587783,
0.1262505203,
-0.7111045718,
-0.167841047,
0.0620036051,
-0.4308803082,
0.346567452,
0.0182404574,
-0.3566301167,
0.0365229994,
0.1639293581,
0.4836010635,
0.4660534561,
-0.2914157808,
0.446075052,
0.5124095082,
0.0023131371,
-0.246529907,
-1.1555192471,
0.3010917604,
0.1865494847,
-0.5753412247,
0.071258463,
0.0403817669,
0.1636877507,
-0.2134246975,
-0.1080223098,
-0.4211241901,
-0.1430061311,
0.1152011901,
0.0804629698,
-0.2346191555,
-0.0381533653,
0.1350882351,
0.0541265458,
0.0683217347,
-0.1670962423,
0.3451323211,
0.0754012391,
-0.1524632424,
-0.6588386893,
0.7901930213,
0.785523057,
-0.1181186438,
0.4946044385,
0.2998662889,
-0.5850009322,
0.0764577761,
-0.1281162798,
-0.0195270702,
-0.5029610991,
0.5544496775,
-0.6719102263,
-0.9057385921,
0.0881098434,
-0.0548853911,
-0.2490936071,
0.1123938486,
0.2856081128,
-0.2528741062,
0.6842672825,
0.5313711762,
0.2042938471,
0.3342427909,
0.0092492439,
0.3382723629,
-1.0227880478,
-0.4155884683,
-0.1384905726,
-0.2786349058,
-0.286983937,
-0.1810624599,
0.4142775536,
-0.0167001728,
0.1285202056,
0.6047834158,
-0.4543034434,
0.4486473799,
0.002481268,
0.4841509461,
0.2458164692,
0.1886226386,
-0.3159897625,
-0.1371222138,
-0.5313931108,
-0.4419578016,
0.7365373969,
0.2568703294,
0.6192750931,
0.0114442129,
0.4283787012,
0.0633499473,
0.4148832262,
-0.7112410665,
0.4868372977,
-0.3440686166,
-0.3883420229,
-0.2698616087,
-0.5071732402,
-1.0561637878,
0.1648539901,
-0.0731304958,
-0.7144040465,
0.6152390838,
0.0517950803,
-0.4684798121,
0.1756644398,
-0.7648522854,
0.6986191273,
-0.0976336822,
-0.3683574796,
0.1183497161,
-0.4547002017,
0.3850195408,
-0.0770436972,
0.2542056739,
0.1516465992,
-0.1145236045,
0.3439992666,
-0.1688670218,
0.6790485978,
-0.1675220877,
-0.002661366,
0.1038103327,
0.2418129146,
0.2840231657,
0.1150346547,
-0.2246876657,
0.5450063348,
0.2463335544,
-0.3571936786,
-0.5963845253,
0.5732748508,
-0.6239581704,
0.1458304971,
-0.3550768793,
-0.5932659507,
-0.3567243516,
0.2506271899,
0.333406955,
0.5508129597,
-0.8200682402,
0.2691825032,
0.778404355,
0.0143023981,
0.6038384438,
0.3967723548,
0.2879537046,
-0.6320187449,
1.1320233345,
-0.0739297047,
0.0557603166,
0.9279134274,
-0.141196534,
-0.4810382724,
-0.8100384474,
-0.2265783399,
0.2931200266,
-0.4031631947,
0.1491646618,
-0.730165422,
-0.0472048,
0.0596486703,
-0.1462216228,
-0.3186902106,
-0.0359044634,
-0.3390868604,
0.2134333253,
-0.0012730937,
0.3738076985,
-0.0543965921,
0.4684207439,
-0.6872355342,
0.5301288962,
-0.0387004241,
0.3749684691,
-0.4138833284,
0.0359941199,
-0.3808487952,
0.2014373839,
0.1614445448,
-0.8561094999,
0.6497910023,
0.1815539151,
0.2226054072,
0.3064297438,
0.1739703417,
0.6340522766,
-0.5458295941,
0.6428571939,
0.5159501433,
-0.846080184,
0.0174134169,
-0.1424005032,
0.743347168,
0.8008927703,
0.1374771893,
-0.9389134645,
-0.2703642845,
-0.0204225555,
-0.6724988222,
0.676512599,
0.4913185239,
0.061868608,
-0.612205267,
0.2273485512,
-0.002370897,
-0.018606877,
-0.512139678,
0.0410382859,
-0.3278602362,
-0.5481835008,
-0.1357189715,
-0.0412992164,
-0.218283698,
0.1691943407,
0.2416125387,
-0.3139771819,
0.7228677869,
0.4237131774,
-0.3310162723,
0.2932899892,
0.3427684903,
0.6805012822,
0.2089629471,
-0.1952597052,
0.2212404311,
0.2143325657,
-0.819670558,
0.094216004,
0.0367118977,
0.1221381649,
0.3947460353,
0.2999370694,
0.9239761233,
0.1071058288,
-0.4981371462,
0.4564370811,
-0.6810617447,
-0.2041972727,
-0.4228218794,
-0.3706811666,
0.2007018179,
0.018442113,
0.1345248073,
0.1732732803,
0.0876456797,
-0.3190517724,
0.3785260916,
0.3552752733,
-0.4213884771,
-0.392863214,
0.4089278281,
0.3158468902,
-0.4819363952,
0.7812548876,
0.1331142485,
0.316126138,
0.4773006141,
0.7240232825,
1.1104192734,
0.0740200579,
-0.0146001633,
0.4069645107,
0.2865482867,
-0.0810948685,
0.5095201135,
-0.2625537515,
-0.6280825734,
-0.3377296627,
-0.4721782804,
-0.2431387901,
0.325350821,
-0.6391450763,
0.1339529306,
-0.7990244627,
-0.0263353027,
-0.2115757763,
-0.4313832819,
-0.3160619438,
0.2434149534,
0.2968584597,
0.6959795356,
-0.2762107551,
1.1341332197,
0.1176872775,
-0.2934683561,
-0.4484297633,
0.1159284785,
-0.2889937758,
-0.4722207189,
0.0363533087,
0.1538189352,
-0.3841219842,
0.1166803837,
-0.2763901353,
-0.5852584243,
0.851821363,
0.5375666022,
-0.631890893,
-0.148918733,
0.3093748391,
0.5564893484,
-0.2877192497,
0.4836457968,
0.5083277822,
0.3122140765,
0.0267699342,
-0.7128407955,
0.2097097933,
-0.4554480016,
0.2276680619,
0.2971405685,
-0.408216089,
0.4867836535,
0.3148280084,
-0.7738122344,
0.2024008185,
0.8537943959,
0.1831207275,
0.2141177058,
0.274523735,
0.1209273636,
0.6903163791,
-0.0090485225,
0.9202900529,
-0.4007549286,
0.1819609404,
0.933939755,
0.0469806716,
0.823004365,
0.7085424066,
0.1853770316,
0.6083216667,
0.3089173734,
0.3363388777,
0.7622842193,
0.217618838,
-0.8250342607,
-0.1236938536,
-0.0151570402,
-0.0577933528,
0.2543722391,
0.6153523922,
-0.1152210683,
-0.3694379032,
0.2534980178,
0.064247489,
0.1833580881,
0.0448943451,
0.6273398995,
0.2039499283,
-0.7502231598,
0.9503545761,
0.1304374486,
0.7427511811,
-1.0467188358,
-0.1461097896,
-0.2732236683,
0.0195124894,
0.0263203178,
-0.4607781768,
0.6471173763,
-0.1330251843,
-0.008002379,
-0.3258906603,
0.2606498897,
-0.6576373577,
-0.3297416866,
0.1095635444,
-0.0511840209,
0.3133416772,
-0.0688083172,
-0.259822011,
0.279774189,
-0.1988800019,
0.0818662122,
0.1202002317,
0.3220233917,
-0.0672267079,
0.2717055976,
0.5024277568,
-0.2351155579,
-0.0889219046,
-0.1251710951,
0.6435906291,
-0.6697673798,
-0.4982182682,
-0.6934750676,
0.640877068,
0.0024517186,
-0.2572660148,
0.3490627706,
0.4578564167,
0.6379535198,
-0.105067648,
0.8011590838,
-0.1862816513,
0.1892728508,
-0.5631272793,
1.0465054512,
-0.3600268662,
-0.1256381869,
0.0954877809,
-0.0133612398,
-0.3572814465,
0.5670681,
0.0382441729,
-0.2966704071,
1.2510219812,
0.8455016017,
0.0225101765,
0.2854677439,
0.6277164817,
0.0677946061,
0.1528186649,
0.8126630187,
0.2738848627,
-0.2593798041,
0.7586387396,
0.1571089923,
-0.4853239357,
0.1306814104,
-0.6005646586,
-0.8893505931,
-0.5051970482,
-0.2626739442,
-0.2993435562,
-0.0017864029,
0.5178384781,
0.3362033963,
-0.7797548175,
-0.5252437592,
-0.4363481402,
-0.0399833843,
-0.5071812868,
-0.1526315361,
0.3308388889,
-0.2975023091,
-0.8424518108,
0.9354583025,
0.4376856089,
-0.1990839988,
-0.1644840389,
0.0085391654,
-0.2400772721,
0.2462499887,
0.6054627299,
0.726272881,
-0.4605873227,
-0.2546138465,
0.2144673467,
-0.305023402,
0.274228096,
0.8886421323,
-0.6453115344,
0.7071056366,
0.6377148628,
0.7640506029,
0.7882699966,
-0.4367927015,
0.7230486274,
-0.7480249405,
0.0778969526,
0.2890768349,
0.1767307818,
0.4051262736,
-0.584489882,
-0.0440839529,
0.2002155036,
-0.113102302,
-0.4227136374,
0.456690073,
-1.0857219696,
-0.3684952259,
0.8746777177,
-0.3242641985,
-0.6342723966,
-0.5276662111,
-0.1638804972,
0.2875292897,
-0.2377891093,
0.5995651484,
0.7783191204,
-0.3864769936,
-0.4708352387,
-0.2616177499,
0.2909540534,
0.2834057808,
-0.6419730783,
0.0090397513,
0.6192701459,
0.3676173091,
0.2133441567,
0.93982023,
-0.4798484147,
0.1272891164,
0.3124212027,
0.2626805305,
-0.1117671952,
-0.1283095032,
-0.5314890146,
0.5427295566,
-0.292244792,
-0.5453901291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11176v1
|
Quality-Aware Image-Text Alignment for Real-World Image Quality Assessment
| 2024-03-17T11:32:18 | 2024-03-17T11:32:18 |
Lorenzo Agnolucci, Leonardo Galteri, Marco Bertini
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
No-Reference Image Quality Assessment (NR-IQA) focuses on designing methods
to measure image quality in alignment with human perception when a high-quality
reference image is unavailable. The reliance on annotated Mean Opinion Scores
(MOS) in the majority of state-of-the-art NR-IQA approaches limits their
scalability and broader applicability to real-world scenarios. To overcome this
limitation, we propose QualiCLIP (Quality-aware CLIP), a CLIP-based
self-supervised opinion-unaware method that does not require labeled MOS. In
particular, we introduce a quality-aware image-text alignment strategy to make
CLIP generate representations that correlate with the inherent quality of the
images. Starting from pristine images, we synthetically degrade them with
increasing levels of intensity. Then, we train CLIP to rank these degraded
images based on their similarity to quality-related antonym text prompts, while
guaranteeing consistent representations for images with comparable quality. Our
method achieves state-of-the-art performance on several datasets with authentic
distortions. Moreover, despite not requiring MOS, QualiCLIP outperforms
supervised methods when their training dataset differs from the testing one,
thus proving to be more suitable for real-world scenarios. Furthermore, our
approach demonstrates greater robustness and improved explainability than
competing methods. The code and the model are publicly available at
https://github.com/miccunifi/QualiCLIP.
|
[
-0.440125376,
-0.2504038215,
0.3539988697,
0.2624824941,
-0.6597406268,
0.2417307347,
0.264405489,
-0.7626473308,
0.5006504059,
0.1837654114,
-0.3382696211,
-0.5557292104,
-0.3726545572,
0.1892140806,
-0.5008584857,
0.8999339938,
-0.1412346959,
0.2202651501,
-0.5108127594,
-0.5467828512,
-0.5011175871,
-0.2764074802,
-0.1595259309,
0.4217576087,
0.1676552892,
0.4002786577,
1.283790946,
0.6513142586,
0.7442010045,
0.1521552354,
0.0413890891,
0.3286584914,
-0.4175585806,
-0.0265825205,
-0.4227154851,
-0.1847995073,
-0.46235466,
0.1791229993,
0.4114754796,
-0.2172048539,
0.1169178337,
0.219701454,
0.1688275188,
0.6813676953,
-0.8359504938,
-0.1914770901,
-0.5797470808,
0.1118506417,
0.0397901013,
-0.1480584741,
0.0402700119,
-0.7305744886,
0.1459060609,
-1.0675474405,
0.1049352139,
0.2397120893,
1.3563530445,
0.3230063319,
-0.1384571195,
-0.2868388295,
-0.3501908779,
0.7537177205,
-0.6108508706,
0.2362599373,
0.3450127244,
0.4089211524,
0.0398182869,
-0.1979256272,
-0.806096673,
0.4109851718,
0.1114700064,
0.6111983061,
-0.0151094738,
-0.0552152619,
-0.3263668716,
0.4543356895,
-0.4947472215,
0.0237686336,
-0.2399535477,
-0.4621383548,
0.3158068061,
-0.0203465316,
0.4640499949,
-0.369581461,
-0.7446828485,
-0.1324251443,
-0.574072063,
0.2106606513,
0.2236448824,
-0.2200086117,
0.1528259218,
0.4502384663,
0.0219802298,
0.3084976673,
0.2117836475,
-0.3659515381,
0.160720706,
-0.4588006139,
0.0088831838,
-0.0653518215,
1.085016489,
0.9899865389,
0.0128145637,
0.0493822023,
-0.2227350771,
0.2041566074,
0.165909946,
-0.92445755,
-0.2265941203,
0.3248458505,
-0.2635291219,
-0.4016416073,
0.1102346033,
-0.9563261271,
-0.1750163734,
-0.1562411338,
0.7530891299,
-0.7093247771,
-0.0069985376,
-0.2057604343,
-0.0788410828,
-0.0032335401,
0.481187433,
-0.6978392601,
-0.0625056028,
0.5957720876,
0.9527870417,
-0.190162614,
-0.1557651013,
-0.3662139773,
0.0440820567,
-0.6725741625,
1.1574252844,
-0.3263820112,
-0.264785409,
0.0969494209,
-0.2842759788,
0.4124451578,
-0.7285426855,
0.8360139728,
-0.4309868813,
0.4005233347,
-0.1228831559,
-0.5072391629,
-0.1685628593,
0.4815562665,
-0.5089446306,
1.2612655163,
0.1797260642,
-0.7872052193,
0.5667136312,
-0.2115164697,
-0.008956614,
-0.0869814903,
-0.2874860168,
-0.8117933273,
-0.0968572423,
0.8863605261,
0.2069747746,
-0.1858357191,
0.1776414365,
-0.4781392217,
-0.4478023946,
0.531946063,
-0.1886312217,
0.5066979527,
-0.1123279557,
-0.0802171454,
0.2178278714,
-0.4575583339,
0.3437994719,
-0.098863773,
0.2515976131,
-0.4142219424,
-0.1657042503,
-0.0292006321,
0.4418074489,
0.3176092505,
-0.6998068094,
0.0645789728,
-0.2772673965,
0.4110675454,
0.6261925697,
0.2593953311,
0.4863237739,
-0.4422107637,
0.5948503613,
0.0174946729,
0.7780357599,
-0.0383228809,
-0.2628947794,
-0.4792194366,
-0.7053136826,
0.6749681234,
0.5577533245,
-0.7639063001,
0.2770701349,
-0.387950182,
-0.5455217361,
-0.8344991803,
0.0343380645,
0.4569563866,
0.5919877887,
0.5358245373,
-0.4765143991,
-0.1233000979,
-1.0645925999,
0.0470816754,
-0.1384329051,
-0.0245802272,
0.0968001261,
0.2167681158,
0.1307689697,
1.1806674004,
-0.4059666991,
-0.863281548,
0.2720839083,
0.1189621463,
-0.0186732821,
0.5632055402,
0.8311738968,
-0.767970264,
-0.3664240539,
-0.3356081843,
-0.756249547,
-0.064300105,
-0.2354775965,
-0.6373933554,
-0.0510569811,
0.2416748703,
-0.3073208332,
0.485622108,
0.8242959976,
-0.0041852407,
0.9173365831,
-0.0335463956,
0.5569455624,
-0.9361308813,
-0.2484070808,
0.1784843355,
-0.3654387891,
-0.0587422773,
-0.1364073455,
0.3489024341,
-0.1887056082,
-0.5647284389,
0.389657557,
-0.4689639509,
-0.2084878236,
-0.3003061116,
0.3536718488,
0.7690523863,
0.3787307143,
0.0268210471,
1.2841689587,
0.4479802549,
-0.319573313,
-0.2251570523,
0.608317852,
-0.5562568903,
1.1057399511,
-0.5921909213,
0.0117037175,
0.0091664176,
0.0229495242,
-0.9178394079,
-0.0400106236,
0.3334445357,
-0.656355679,
0.0975401178,
-0.1409285069,
-0.3486437201,
0.0182459299,
-0.5721310377,
0.6053293943,
0.2823574245,
-0.6779357195,
0.382295996,
0.5011460185,
-0.1125673801,
-0.8024891019,
-0.3722031415,
0.1370775402,
-0.1929828674,
-0.4496411383,
0.7070148587,
0.0890840441,
0.3144000173,
0.1586169899,
-0.2198062837,
-0.5570293665,
-0.0362362973,
0.3327643275,
0.4648722708,
0.0339383818,
0.1491217166,
0.2947541177,
0.0786938816,
-0.0479709655,
-0.1377903521,
-0.1989159435,
-0.0170609504,
-0.1519297212,
-0.8845516443,
0.3046185374,
0.7344213724,
-0.4413022101,
0.2649139464,
0.5251526237,
-0.3078993857,
0.0411149673,
-0.2859186232,
-0.0264649335,
-0.4335488379,
0.1642528027,
-0.0905478522,
-0.6796692014,
0.4932595193,
-0.0325757787,
0.1549208909,
0.2033407986,
-0.0766837746,
-0.7724272013,
0.9098337293,
0.3857627809,
0.1515012085,
0.6841395497,
-0.3446225226,
0.2528068423,
-1.1292812824,
0.0823596343,
-0.2223519832,
-0.1668176949,
-0.1818496883,
-0.5859878659,
0.5631788969,
0.4272759557,
-0.0008646965,
0.2181236744,
-0.7799214125,
0.6032884717,
0.4357483983,
0.3482763469,
0.3125163913,
-0.1001992449,
-0.0185451843,
-0.4233859479,
-0.6320483088,
-0.7448757291,
0.7466555834,
0.1832375973,
0.5360642672,
0.0269284435,
0.5090976357,
0.4607930183,
0.5007989407,
-0.9248582721,
0.3961443305,
-0.0627934486,
-0.558095336,
-0.2219557464,
-0.1778412759,
-0.6155201197,
0.2029557228,
-0.7753033042,
-0.284535408,
0.3909441233,
0.4313456416,
-0.4523048401,
0.1408138573,
-0.4227746129,
0.813847661,
-0.3303115666,
-0.5072939992,
-0.0429342501,
-0.394446671,
0.3670966923,
0.0009383418,
0.225875333,
-0.5714216232,
-0.1967717111,
0.6162612438,
-0.5995788574,
0.5811517239,
-0.0965665802,
0.1365644187,
0.6158159375,
0.2959062755,
0.252389729,
0.2208139896,
0.1410604119,
0.4340333045,
0.4756032825,
-0.4112058282,
-1.0208127499,
0.47621122,
-0.7665273547,
-0.3108907342,
-0.463365376,
-0.166702643,
-0.2743221223,
0.2274644822,
0.3506094813,
0.7033914328,
-0.2018228471,
-0.1473323405,
0.3022655845,
-0.0440037288,
0.1303560734,
0.1927124858,
-0.4348160625,
-1.122351408,
1.1666142941,
0.1979384869,
0.1720056534,
0.2874419093,
0.1802078187,
-0.5026427507,
-0.8432884216,
-0.6311229467,
0.0580316558,
-0.6433534622,
-0.8041286469,
-0.1826698929,
0.1783227026,
-0.2809592485,
-0.2386015654,
-0.5156515837,
-0.5512758493,
-0.4500561655,
0.0567028634,
0.286655277,
0.2496041358,
0.1856378019,
0.3052930236,
-0.958588779,
0.3032755256,
0.3104437888,
0.4612499774,
-0.2765424848,
-0.5745074153,
-0.2320308983,
-0.0500516668,
-0.5142046213,
-0.8376728296,
0.5436096191,
0.4539735913,
0.2906230092,
0.5563428998,
0.4235163629,
0.7908969522,
-0.1646220982,
0.7987426519,
0.2938927114,
-1.1254886389,
0.3955000043,
-0.1601055562,
0.1268059909,
0.9071246982,
0.4665738046,
-0.2666637897,
-0.5529594421,
-0.3494156003,
-0.727753818,
-0.1295197904,
0.1634201258,
-0.0822709352,
-0.1373766363,
0.3766739368,
0.1758043766,
-0.0333295204,
-0.4770226479,
0.2968500555,
-0.8644000888,
-0.5384277701,
0.4352782369,
-0.3300471306,
-0.0353464782,
-0.0605443344,
0.7205833197,
-0.4857144952,
0.2683297098,
0.7521511316,
-0.3170477748,
0.1796070635,
0.1719623357,
0.4294980466,
0.7375173569,
-0.2781179249,
-0.0679879859,
-0.2654389143,
-0.5297634006,
0.322532177,
-0.5244995952,
-0.4474569261,
-0.0183051266,
0.040698193,
0.3590988517,
0.2948467135,
-0.6884545684,
0.9723366499,
-0.2511482835,
-0.2461287975,
-0.2737973332,
-0.1038701758,
-0.3539897799,
-0.0794575289,
0.4488046765,
0.1800532341,
0.2928759158,
-0.2458677292,
0.2549256384,
0.4258753359,
-0.8523433805,
-0.2882849574,
0.5096319318,
0.438532263,
0.0524242297,
0.478290081,
-0.3795951903,
-0.6635814905,
0.4897314012,
0.3540083766,
0.597545743,
0.1957906783,
0.417666018,
0.6328684688,
0.2284867316,
-0.0127891246,
0.2438414544,
0.2603032887,
-0.8829024434,
-0.4643214345,
-0.2629858553,
-0.9010072947,
-0.3228100538,
-0.8422867656,
0.1029057652,
-0.8475763202,
-0.4900682569,
-0.1031000614,
-0.3766091168,
-0.1996466368,
0.3873623312,
-0.1932556033,
0.8281300664,
-0.6928526759,
0.6093248129,
0.5274968147,
-0.4257358015,
-0.6611584425,
0.0685618371,
-0.1321130246,
-0.6138181686,
0.26806584,
0.3863904476,
-0.2664486766,
-0.2977417707,
-0.5509988666,
-0.9492870569,
1.0637414455,
0.3379222751,
-0.2520534098,
0.4185830057,
-0.2326239794,
0.5547338724,
-0.2439537793,
0.2833318114,
0.1006676108,
0.0290050413,
-0.0281082541,
-0.6066609621,
-0.0514093414,
-0.1309074461,
-0.0284193698,
0.3886238635,
-0.8627422452,
0.2036798745,
-0.2172976434,
-0.6188227534,
0.219085902,
1.1897845268,
0.0118330009,
0.2653063834,
0.4530382752,
0.4168011546,
0.7158716917,
-0.0080948435,
0.6450442672,
-0.422141552,
0.2455479652,
1.2344388962,
-0.0927556008,
1.1091609001,
0.5256123543,
-0.0357222855,
0.4946276248,
0.6155544519,
-0.0343534276,
0.5972671509,
-0.2564663291,
-0.0388746113,
-0.2662037015,
-0.4323750436,
-0.0156319309,
0.6171374321,
0.2377379239,
-0.1210610271,
0.0572432168,
0.041361291,
-0.2525729239,
0.4846189618,
-0.311080873,
0.6110960245,
-0.2624608278,
-0.5043999553,
0.6255725622,
-0.4864932597,
0.9453376532,
-0.0474513732,
-0.202747941,
-0.1668983251,
-0.2711727023,
-0.33643049,
-1.171552062,
0.5013920665,
-0.0845731944,
-0.3307727277,
0.0941405669,
0.390591383,
-0.2647707462,
-0.4565294385,
-0.1525405496,
0.0309741702,
0.1731285453,
-0.094209969,
-0.88272506,
-0.1155621558,
-0.1613277495,
0.3618272841,
0.3980852664,
0.3190153241,
-0.3210383952,
0.5961976051,
0.4950532317,
-0.1276911795,
-0.1509138048,
-0.2276467532,
0.5348353982,
-0.4708423615,
-0.5241740346,
-0.2747793198,
0.1215116009,
-0.2486791164,
-0.6088033915,
0.4948363304,
0.6494274735,
0.6583460569,
0.1000044122,
0.5006850362,
0.4179623723,
0.617384553,
-0.596274972,
0.6049726605,
-0.4352217615,
-0.1846347153,
-0.3901088834,
-0.7316509485,
-0.3692299724,
0.6518825293,
-0.2491458654,
-0.5839132071,
0.668559432,
0.9415714145,
0.07995525,
-0.0835522264,
0.2441394776,
-0.1336513013,
0.4188331962,
0.2182850391,
0.792850852,
-0.7365630865,
0.9132651091,
-0.4341543615,
-0.2866225839,
-0.0880005211,
-1.2045706511,
-0.5175498724,
-0.4456837773,
-0.7330438495,
-0.3118764758,
-0.1416051835,
0.7457167506,
0.6975072026,
-0.6433259249,
0.3666243851,
0.2663908899,
0.1328276545,
-0.5182989836,
-0.254350245,
0.6054712534,
0.0614502206,
-0.6178866625,
0.0307918675,
0.6177768707,
0.4009235501,
-0.2212411463,
0.3161905706,
0.1487616301,
0.1895567477,
0.3141539097,
0.5066235662,
-0.5326247215,
-0.4358283877,
-0.0157381874,
-0.3163006306,
0.7156007886,
0.4147207141,
-0.5587729216,
0.5960925817,
0.5170637369,
0.4939865172,
0.0275580082,
0.5289652944,
0.3564406931,
-0.4415716529,
0.0543762669,
0.4777686596,
0.3246777654,
0.7139649391,
-0.4702122808,
0.2180058062,
-0.0494993106,
-0.6936243773,
-0.5210756063,
-0.0765900016,
-1.3199421167,
-0.0750172883,
0.641237855,
-0.4514229894,
-0.601108551,
0.0565926544,
-0.6091829538,
-0.0224910583,
-0.5850406885,
1.1578645706,
0.4217279553,
-0.0827713981,
-0.2831344008,
-0.1656167954,
0.4215566516,
0.5324087143,
-0.8238887787,
-0.2135030478,
0.6096917987,
0.3410356343,
0.2155341357,
0.4287997186,
-0.4686927795,
0.4849988818,
-0.3231043816,
0.3682982028,
-0.1984935552,
-0.2860181928,
-0.1329931021,
0.1446026713,
0.1687567234,
-0.6108730435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11169v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11169v3
|
Correcting misinformation on social media with a large language model
| 2024-03-17T10:59:09 | 2024-04-30T20:03:13 |
Xinyi Zhou, Ashish Sharma, Amy X. Zhang, Tim Althoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Real-world misinformation can be partially correct and even factual but
misleading. It undermines public trust in science and democracy, particularly
on social media, where it can spread rapidly. High-quality and timely
correction of misinformation that identifies and explains its (in)accuracies
has been shown to effectively reduce false beliefs. Despite the wide acceptance
of manual correction, it is difficult to be timely and scalable, a concern as
technologies like large language models (LLMs) make misinformation easier to
produce. LLMs also have versatile capabilities that could accelerate
misinformation correction-however, they struggle due to a lack of recent
information, a tendency to produce false content, and limitations in addressing
multimodal information. We propose MUSE, an LLM augmented with access to and
credibility evaluation of up-to-date information. By retrieving evidence as
refutations or contexts, MUSE identifies and explains (in)accuracies in a piece
of content-not presupposed to be misinformation-with references. It also
describes images and conducts multimodal searches to verify and correct
multimodal content. Fact-checking experts evaluate responses to social media
content that are not presupposed to be (non-)misinformation but broadly include
incorrect, partially correct, and correct posts, that may or may not be
misleading. We propose and evaluate 13 dimensions of misinformation correction
quality, ranging from the accuracy of identifications and factuality of
explanations to the relevance and credibility of references. The results
demonstrate MUSE's ability to promptly write high-quality responses to
potential misinformation on social media-overall, MUSE outperforms GPT-4 by 37%
and even high-quality responses from laypeople by 29%. This work reveals LLMs'
potential to help combat real-world misinformation effectively and efficiently.
|
[
-0.1316500604,
-0.9497298002,
0.6562359929,
0.6099943519,
-0.0848245695,
0.3549205959,
-0.4204933345,
-0.659691751,
0.3067055643,
0.1089384705,
-0.7315093875,
-0.4465661645,
-0.8157269359,
0.0495072268,
-0.4363241196,
0.5875906348,
-0.0791593194,
0.2528673708,
-0.3046836257,
-0.1121268496,
-0.4217920303,
-0.2038886547,
-0.5850507021,
-0.1997368187,
0.900225997,
0.5794737935,
0.6579406261,
0.4913212061,
0.5495320559,
0.2839096189,
-0.1856967062,
0.5851494074,
-0.8521047831,
-0.1478195041,
-0.4010516107,
-0.5583649874,
-0.3062236607,
0.4032894969,
0.6490718126,
0.3584852815,
0.0004615189,
0.3923022747,
0.0059161284,
0.3091714978,
-0.4574763775,
0.1054809391,
-0.7108011246,
-0.0577681772,
-0.2350332141,
-0.2997179329,
-0.4045120776,
-0.4035469592,
-0.0614415593,
-0.7198602557,
0.2956832647,
0.1139080152,
0.9996116161,
0.2977589071,
-0.2368357778,
-0.2514529526,
-1.0495567322,
0.6243574023,
-0.5542151928,
0.4424203634,
0.4820978642,
0.4056425095,
-0.2290786356,
-0.7008193731,
-0.9021626711,
0.2057876438,
0.0926430374,
0.1866738051,
-0.1985368878,
-0.3799333274,
0.3815653622,
0.2537047565,
-0.3619773686,
0.1303078681,
-0.3623716235,
-0.5969842672,
0.5678493381,
-0.1208341494,
0.240817681,
-0.2821426988,
-0.1023587137,
-0.1432709843,
-0.9873797297,
-0.2697327137,
0.359721154,
0.166684255,
-0.0029487964,
0.7967981696,
-0.0394553319,
0.3598885536,
0.2837677002,
-0.6451111436,
0.0635565594,
-0.2200586349,
-0.2069733441,
0.0522881337,
0.5230473876,
0.6935158968,
-0.1151682884,
-0.1899101287,
-0.1362712681,
0.3697718382,
0.3230183125,
-0.5324496627,
0.1562816352,
0.1254494637,
-0.3537189364,
-0.0553940386,
-0.1243602484,
-0.6079578996,
-0.8575757146,
-0.5311461687,
0.7733311653,
-0.4145858586,
0.0040421225,
0.0744583607,
0.0308413077,
-0.3629585803,
0.8577800989,
-0.1172936633,
-0.25435251,
0.498236239,
0.9671418071,
0.1251003742,
-0.2910541594,
-0.4109010994,
0.2736994922,
-0.3042435348,
0.9474453926,
-0.3524510264,
-0.0145198936,
0.1385546476,
0.2611314952,
-0.0176660921,
-0.3493106067,
0.8809199333,
-0.5936726928,
0.1969495565,
-0.6540547013,
-0.4453272223,
-0.2091458142,
0.2625062466,
-0.799580574,
0.8020670414,
-0.1345608234,
-0.7100813389,
0.4195584059,
-0.4860686362,
-0.4233626425,
-0.2518685758,
0.1976314336,
-0.3017821312,
-0.0911458731,
0.3646535873,
0.4731451571,
-0.1748558134,
0.4120573103,
-0.3514436781,
-0.2741628885,
0.3200194538,
-0.6314278245,
0.4743130207,
0.1496127397,
-0.4017902017,
0.2103786319,
-0.9190281034,
-0.4984385967,
0.0839485899,
-0.5564860702,
-0.1009733826,
-0.0119296266,
-0.0083554378,
0.4325095713,
0.120702073,
-0.7724161148,
0.0978625268,
0.1159292907,
0.6506146193,
0.7982742786,
-0.1532851458,
0.3305422664,
-0.6484024525,
0.077989921,
0.180895105,
0.2247497439,
-0.2000399381,
-0.5837105513,
-0.7202519178,
-0.1535925567,
0.3671694398,
0.5092405081,
-0.7881954908,
0.0972049609,
-0.5672909617,
-0.7460907102,
-0.8192471862,
0.2075690776,
0.049160704,
0.6766349673,
0.3972932696,
0.0751822218,
-0.5957459807,
-0.79613024,
-0.4783363938,
-0.1772444993,
0.0377405696,
0.1956084073,
0.2718719244,
-0.314673841,
0.8578040004,
-0.2181425542,
-0.350228548,
0.12888062,
0.4931143224,
-0.0031204612,
0.12599805,
0.3534481823,
-0.8501911163,
-0.1919726729,
-0.3107640147,
-0.5097942352,
-0.1019508839,
-0.296423614,
-0.0658449978,
0.1275124997,
0.1865922362,
-1.0751625299,
0.3537029922,
0.5532934666,
-0.0909951851,
0.5229181051,
-0.0701966062,
0.5781494975,
-0.9740282893,
-0.0578019172,
0.273973465,
-0.3811889589,
-0.3994442523,
-0.1840128601,
0.2643964291,
0.0337795429,
-0.3183012903,
0.349422127,
-0.4724160731,
0.0435481854,
-0.1835715771,
0.4137375057,
-0.0061016097,
0.0531450585,
-0.254863739,
0.7398741841,
0.2838793397,
-0.5145575404,
0.5176215172,
0.2052860409,
-0.5689435005,
0.7592279911,
-0.3636596203,
0.0407053195,
-0.3636552095,
0.4697083235,
-1.1349326372,
-0.6270645261,
0.1926266104,
-0.6562637091,
0.2618058622,
-0.0752502456,
-0.9834811091,
-0.6039543152,
-0.0589504987,
-0.1342791021,
-0.0207672454,
-0.6217570305,
0.612760067,
0.3834747076,
-0.1422553807,
-0.6483870745,
-0.7531674504,
0.4001112878,
0.0621724352,
-1.0117112398,
0.3015578985,
-0.1817659736,
-0.250980109,
0.1629621685,
-0.2524628043,
0.1443655193,
-0.1917204708,
0.2168350667,
0.0652957112,
-0.1005223766,
0.4711384475,
-0.2472932041,
0.2608641386,
-0.2056571245,
-0.0583188273,
0.5401825309,
0.1437493712,
-0.5178735852,
-0.484071821,
0.0501478612,
0.8561558127,
-0.0462912321,
0.8032348156,
0.8476631641,
-0.7493055463,
0.0354525335,
-1.1236259937,
-0.2251410037,
-0.3887319565,
0.1893791705,
0.056950435,
-0.9225461483,
0.5807721019,
-0.1411606073,
0.1145361736,
0.5155587196,
0.4367983639,
-0.1661608964,
0.8910828233,
0.610209167,
-0.2127930969,
0.3134936988,
-0.1398342997,
0.4409253597,
-0.4228440225,
-0.3790187538,
-0.539173305,
-0.4964431822,
-0.1454307884,
-0.7717174888,
0.1886665672,
-0.002702879,
0.0083396332,
0.2990725935,
-0.1149373353,
0.2437205911,
0.647516489,
0.2473200411,
0.4537217021,
0.1266825944,
0.0822697356,
-0.2984731495,
-0.8484185338,
-0.5288054347,
0.7633264661,
0.4985292554,
1.0526977777,
0.2538487613,
0.0472441837,
0.5588974357,
0.634950459,
-0.7126458883,
0.3626917303,
0.2129311115,
-0.8085909486,
-0.1634458601,
-0.432436496,
-0.3696044981,
0.0188290291,
-0.672783494,
-0.5740649104,
0.2666281164,
0.3023359776,
-0.3988910317,
0.5710891485,
-0.6870331168,
0.5391557813,
-0.1990412623,
-0.5486023426,
-0.4791184366,
-0.6454526782,
0.4171371758,
-0.3317484558,
0.4688506424,
-0.1292968988,
0.1956968009,
0.3880218863,
-0.074957706,
1.1579799652,
-0.0001785402,
-0.1942079216,
0.1340727061,
0.033566203,
0.7494840026,
0.0619576722,
0.0408456437,
0.084856227,
-0.3360047638,
-0.1013965085,
-0.5993804932,
0.9275432825,
-0.7847839594,
-0.6332611442,
-0.2027201951,
-0.5789919496,
-0.4352345765,
0.0279992372,
0.2951431572,
0.3104274869,
-0.2094994485,
0.3616774678,
0.8375960588,
-0.1735730916,
0.2529712915,
0.6305243969,
-0.0859262422,
-0.3139964938,
0.7024813294,
0.5307552218,
0.0098504489,
0.3418344855,
0.1511051655,
-0.5148844123,
-0.2349864841,
-0.5904654264,
0.4929227829,
-0.7956199646,
-0.2932740748,
-0.8200474381,
-0.1515950859,
-0.5620046258,
0.018769132,
-0.2967402637,
-0.5297399759,
-0.3827731609,
-0.1783464402,
0.2920552492,
0.596942544,
-0.3450910747,
0.5834254622,
-0.7939368486,
0.3576854467,
0.287376225,
0.3560870588,
-0.0644611791,
-0.5752441287,
-0.2334562391,
0.4469891191,
-0.3942793608,
-1.0264160633,
0.0080677932,
0.0801473185,
0.5499239564,
0.5775907636,
-0.2843060791,
1.0897961855,
-0.5082245469,
0.7700254917,
0.2480843812,
-0.8339891434,
0.4034067094,
-0.4426735938,
0.0013895453,
0.1923677623,
0.4926105142,
-1.0108412504,
-0.3828053474,
-0.619099915,
-0.6609409451,
0.5324961543,
0.0355405062,
0.1465237588,
-0.0030512928,
0.2563327253,
-0.1184994802,
0.3105768859,
-0.8182570338,
-0.0997050554,
-0.3427270949,
0.0120364986,
-0.1557401717,
-0.5679498315,
-0.4146520197,
-0.1885659248,
1.0537272692,
0.0184034575,
0.2817551196,
0.299777329,
-0.4448979497,
-0.644133687,
0.2041791379,
0.9452850819,
1.0449748039,
0.0157975201,
0.151797384,
0.0084481072,
-0.4021396935,
-0.04258864,
0.0479365028,
-0.3073285818,
0.2357252389,
0.283434689,
0.6536595225,
0.1794975698,
-0.4994387329,
0.5552547574,
0.0452670678,
-0.0825315043,
-0.1755115837,
-0.3076546788,
0.502862215,
0.2988269329,
0.5249609351,
0.4633981287,
-0.2103669792,
-0.661457479,
0.0003220853,
0.1970812827,
-0.3084123433,
-0.3413972855,
0.7480515242,
0.1661054194,
-0.2001665235,
0.2844218016,
0.060317941,
-0.3612871468,
0.1630294621,
0.6826246381,
0.4483794868,
-0.3449760675,
0.5329981446,
0.3946661949,
0.7272899747,
-0.4954344332,
0.0054118028,
0.4577944279,
-0.8916952014,
-0.8078563809,
-0.5831388235,
-0.2449954003,
0.6690636277,
-0.0402932167,
0.1642598659,
-0.5705132484,
-0.5244240165,
0.1707337052,
-0.1489774138,
-0.5579282641,
0.3179470003,
-0.0196755249,
1.1787978411,
-0.86949265,
0.3478789926,
0.7611133456,
-0.4464385509,
-0.9209486246,
0.1399965882,
0.5440202355,
-0.6109323502,
0.4312676191,
0.0219110399,
-0.3108486235,
-0.2667377591,
-1.0111814737,
-1.006192565,
1.1511045694,
0.57398206,
-0.7528740764,
0.2187434584,
0.102418907,
0.5772143602,
-0.3023872375,
-0.0567905679,
0.0592520721,
0.787050128,
0.3228152692,
-0.8894652724,
-0.1250324547,
-0.0667940751,
-0.1233735383,
-0.1701239347,
-0.7205269337,
0.7761188745,
-0.1092668027,
-0.40593642,
-0.0106679182,
0.7125965357,
-0.0466594361,
0.3260841668,
0.4008386731,
0.7424447536,
1.1285905838,
-0.3787276149,
0.8310851455,
-0.3245387375,
0.2793084681,
1.0881632566,
-0.1813219637,
0.6671180129,
0.3836862445,
0.1394434273,
0.3268513381,
0.8953200579,
-0.022459127,
0.1360006779,
0.0083306935,
-0.3046740592,
-0.4863992929,
-0.170301035,
-0.1567227244,
0.2505189478,
0.4565941989,
-0.304463625,
-0.2332487851,
0.1213297173,
0.3082904816,
0.2023854554,
-0.4153523147,
0.3448582888,
-0.1530701816,
-0.5212225318,
0.2425361574,
0.2794549167,
0.6525334716,
-0.3163189888,
0.0174139664,
-0.1414920688,
0.2043218166,
-0.3145008683,
-0.721213758,
0.2685104311,
0.0611725338,
-0.4727123976,
-0.1271551847,
1.0741758347,
-0.5756774545,
-0.5388256907,
0.154152438,
0.4998266399,
-0.0981061235,
-0.3088342547,
-0.6260601878,
0.0884200707,
-0.2060607523,
0.1012552306,
-0.1040081978,
0.5389865637,
-0.0979187638,
1.0088248253,
0.8555285931,
0.1972133368,
0.0837251171,
0.2389111221,
0.7729368806,
-0.2698661089,
-0.2746021152,
-0.5780908465,
0.3316593468,
-0.3826933801,
-0.1235982999,
0.9909317493,
0.5605717301,
0.8285531402,
-0.1260800809,
0.8536339402,
0.0528657995,
0.9447558522,
-0.3575728834,
0.829347074,
-0.6658521295,
0.1947169602,
-0.3664164543,
-1.0156441927,
-0.3693739176,
0.5608268976,
-0.2830879986,
-0.1863847524,
0.5593191385,
1.0013087988,
-0.2528276742,
0.1316016465,
0.2903993726,
0.8405249119,
0.1586843431,
-0.1130148992,
1.0211805105,
-0.1843660027,
0.4463810027,
-0.1213487685,
-0.2491022944,
-0.4103768766,
-0.8143088222,
-0.7283739448,
-0.4672853947,
-0.1236132234,
-0.7226464748,
0.2436998487,
0.9633845091,
0.6078303456,
-0.5337093472,
0.2147931159,
0.4873522222,
0.2733216286,
-0.1118112281,
-0.2167070955,
0.156361565,
-0.017236365,
-0.6389627457,
0.4910496771,
0.4052953124,
0.0225902982,
-0.4646001458,
0.0785317346,
-0.3750041425,
0.3751404583,
0.7782192826,
0.0636127517,
-0.8182780147,
-0.6728118062,
0.1998402029,
-0.2244769037,
0.1694315225,
0.7798778415,
-0.283521235,
0.3581471145,
0.3568574786,
0.5528157353,
0.5192907453,
0.0768543854,
0.3425962031,
-0.7170079947,
-0.2070647031,
0.0911616758,
0.5023210049,
0.8116945624,
-0.4838767648,
0.2921828926,
0.6776992679,
-0.5358733535,
-0.61523664,
0.0884138346,
-0.9854909778,
-0.1352678388,
1.2383707762,
-0.0465814583,
-0.3815219104,
-0.148787111,
-0.3864165843,
0.31131199,
-0.3457962871,
1.2141399384,
1.3235089779,
0.4338594079,
-0.1842807531,
-0.5038707852,
0.3768853843,
0.0188257433,
-0.6011865735,
-0.0149484826,
0.8828704953,
0.5863190293,
0.5989391804,
0.4236035645,
-0.1993548721,
0.3563227057,
-0.1846735477,
0.0024285638,
-0.0517174043,
-0.4936533868,
0.0215732902,
-0.0273910612,
-0.2661858201,
0.2098405212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11152v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11152v1
|
Evaluation Ethics of LLMs in Legal Domain
| 2024-03-17T09:05:13 | 2024-03-17T09:05:13 |
Ruizhe Zhang, Haitao Li, Yueyue Wu, Qingyao Ai, Yiqun Liu, Min Zhang, Shaoping Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, the utilization of large language models for natural
language dialogue has gained momentum, leading to their widespread adoption
across various domains. However, their universal competence in addressing
challenges specific to specialized fields such as law remains a subject of
scrutiny. The incorporation of legal ethics into the model has been overlooked
by researchers. We asserts that rigorous ethic evaluation is essential to
ensure the effective integration of large language models in legal domains,
emphasizing the need to assess domain-specific proficiency and domain-specific
ethic. To address this, we propose a novelty evaluation methodology, utilizing
authentic legal cases to evaluate the fundamental language abilities,
specialized legal knowledge and legal robustness of large language models
(LLMs). The findings from our comprehensive evaluation contribute significantly
to the academic discourse surrounding the suitability and performance of large
language models in legal domains.
|
[
-0.0418009423,
-0.8505405784,
1.0302716494,
0.0512445085,
-0.4232342541,
0.2030042112,
-0.3939856887,
-0.5436161757,
-0.0729675964,
0.6646032333,
-0.2382167876,
-0.4653597474,
-0.5049484372,
-0.0365690999,
-0.2786605358,
0.9814681411,
0.2335608155,
0.4625662565,
-0.2990003824,
-0.6181604862,
-0.400257051,
-0.6643195152,
-0.5169109106,
-0.2385781407,
-0.0209935345,
-0.1417913437,
0.577311933,
0.4127157032,
0.3953528404,
0.3999049962,
-0.3698893487,
-0.0112709701,
-0.6630820632,
0.00405571,
-0.5462725163,
-0.1844725311,
-0.5986437201,
0.1628490984,
0.6408773065,
0.6476530433,
-0.451800853,
0.2325542718,
-0.1770853251,
0.3708693981,
-0.5008996725,
-0.1230310723,
-0.7380539179,
0.0206352323,
0.0079354215,
-0.4331660569,
-0.3290160596,
-0.6207777858,
0.3128482997,
-0.5227073431,
-0.2182713598,
0.0437601469,
0.6076897979,
-0.0511844903,
-0.4536619782,
-0.6263873577,
-0.8346151114,
0.8343605399,
-0.9643449783,
0.2727592885,
-0.0249256752,
0.5577791333,
-0.0561297461,
-0.692301929,
-0.8259769082,
-0.7222056389,
0.4074406624,
0.0558964796,
-0.2196300775,
0.117422156,
0.1388989091,
0.508562386,
-0.2674261928,
0.5985718369,
-0.0575817265,
-0.0157322958,
0.7805967331,
0.4838376641,
0.39921543,
0.0052532698,
-0.1334607601,
0.4835576117,
-0.6829960346,
0.2644873857,
0.8563268781,
0.2102470994,
0.0040548132,
0.5424508452,
-0.0658170208,
0.4542983472,
-0.201008752,
-0.2621696591,
0.2596871853,
-0.4581991136,
-0.321174264,
-0.0720938519,
0.7951970696,
0.5853804946,
0.5743877292,
-0.0929949954,
-0.3408245444,
-0.282854259,
0.4374513328,
-0.6214200258,
0.4966810048,
0.4465528131,
-0.7678610682,
-0.5359832048,
-0.0425493829,
-0.45729357,
-0.4314537346,
-0.4658841491,
0.3223229647,
-0.3326356411,
-0.3691806793,
0.3842333257,
-0.0969989672,
0.4688077569,
0.4845414162,
-0.4849025309,
0.3431713581,
1.1487773657,
0.2797392607,
-0.2442136109,
-0.1123975888,
-0.6675769091,
0.0160147902,
-0.174561128,
0.4307399988,
-1.0630534887,
-0.5853853226,
0.3030926585,
0.0609314032,
-0.0098516559,
-0.5368046761,
1.0251091719,
-0.7431150675,
-0.2539125383,
-0.1301130652,
-0.5926535726,
-0.2269126028,
0.2361220866,
-0.3388226628,
0.5569478273,
0.1112878174,
-0.5541625023,
0.6562799215,
-0.7878108621,
-0.5257874727,
0.7615181804,
-0.3198683262,
-0.42581442,
0.0866244957,
-0.364071399,
0.4362948239,
-0.4289636314,
0.7574580312,
-0.509367764,
-0.4548615813,
0.5528198481,
-0.5386554599,
1.2450420856,
0.262938112,
-0.2245280296,
0.1240653992,
-0.6129354239,
0.1659057587,
0.0881018117,
-0.2981784642,
-0.5900897384,
-0.1695185602,
0.1890137345,
-0.0040970175,
0.1784319431,
-0.4772785008,
-0.0215224642,
-0.4119237065,
0.6110630631,
0.6456650496,
0.2692819536,
0.3082382977,
-0.271653831,
0.7509624958,
-0.4402726591,
0.2018708438,
0.3046968877,
-0.5253913403,
-0.420927614,
-0.3156696558,
0.3059834838,
0.5199050307,
-0.2668785751,
0.5519331694,
-0.6097143888,
-0.301689893,
-0.6793868542,
0.1504562348,
0.3365848958,
0.0141648948,
-0.0188130382,
-0.3076672256,
-0.3127145469,
-1.0957388878,
-0.6759694219,
0.0555644892,
0.0752829313,
0.5746910572,
0.728348732,
-0.3174468875,
0.898252666,
0.2910082936,
0.1361000687,
-0.5341456532,
0.1648838222,
0.3842632174,
0.4442209005,
0.6952387094,
-0.7489253283,
-0.3807402551,
0.356441915,
-0.8386999369,
0.0712089464,
-0.0664412528,
0.1456830204,
0.0477245934,
0.1576152742,
-0.7093732357,
0.3834162354,
0.0552706793,
-0.3436527252,
0.7920820713,
-0.2404332459,
0.4873875976,
-0.7445014119,
0.0342078507,
-0.0776509121,
-0.3480132222,
-0.7048906088,
0.5140649676,
-0.1335190535,
0.0976101458,
-0.801007688,
0.4673117995,
-0.3409280479,
-0.0979223847,
-0.1357397437,
0.089718692,
-0.0164213646,
-0.0541648418,
-0.1938589066,
0.5387300253,
0.5727094412,
-0.7472428083,
0.378321439,
0.11326994,
-0.7194960117,
1.0900813341,
-0.5835998654,
0.0744537264,
-0.0280513484,
0.0131863691,
-0.3081387281,
-0.1308372468,
0.1593919545,
-0.2171121687,
0.378647238,
-0.300278455,
-0.5372120738,
-0.310477227,
-0.4145508707,
0.3266227841,
0.6480733156,
-0.1114469692,
0.6443871856,
0.6026899815,
-0.1968355924,
-0.7173668146,
-0.5464038849,
0.2534308434,
-0.4971335828,
-0.5620328784,
0.0554911084,
-0.0217206255,
-0.8260654807,
0.1197031811,
0.0338199958,
-0.1715673655,
0.3549788296,
0.1205851734,
0.0824550763,
-0.3210304976,
-0.345279485,
0.1939881295,
0.340939343,
0.3768956661,
-0.1240024492,
0.3317216337,
-0.3592585623,
-0.5494940281,
-0.4224263728,
0.3991489112,
0.7507973909,
-0.1994960904,
0.3763522804,
0.1537608355,
-0.3760408759,
-0.2077595741,
-0.8661953211,
0.1770058572,
-0.4743753076,
0.5509945154,
-0.4520754516,
-1.1771119833,
0.4373288751,
-0.0830158964,
0.112168096,
0.5176721811,
0.8995776176,
0.0636629164,
0.3846032321,
0.6887628436,
0.2338337302,
-0.0814835057,
-0.0098618343,
0.5917418599,
-0.8318279982,
-0.2511535883,
-0.4716420174,
0.3087668419,
-0.6409794688,
-0.4426882565,
0.1799873412,
-0.1156769246,
-0.0635719523,
0.0764766857,
-0.1631389558,
0.7449689507,
0.0586249642,
-0.0771727636,
0.7973320484,
0.0439585894,
-0.3890642524,
-0.0982762352,
-0.4782315195,
-1.1512852907,
1.1087788343,
0.768296361,
0.4276105464,
0.1662050784,
0.4879713953,
0.4551329613,
0.4101846814,
-1.1396474838,
0.7057011724,
-0.1377771795,
-0.430542469,
-0.4349633455,
-0.4912458062,
-0.9467304945,
0.2142762095,
-0.1534225941,
-1.1232779026,
0.026890615,
-0.4240047038,
-0.5784668326,
0.3738336563,
-0.25001508,
0.5825120211,
-0.2224446386,
-0.4488414526,
-0.4669880867,
-0.5487599373,
0.6385002136,
-0.3185372055,
0.4727200866,
-0.1637538671,
0.1360307485,
0.7405657172,
-0.4367100596,
0.5627474189,
0.117623508,
-0.3301403522,
0.5144619346,
0.2145386189,
0.2657532096,
0.4116947651,
-0.303693682,
0.2312067449,
0.0703789145,
0.0302046034,
-0.4394458532,
0.866448462,
-0.4359885156,
-0.9429396391,
-0.4937557876,
-0.5813399553,
-0.4892883599,
0.1627868861,
-0.058775831,
0.0910702497,
-0.5850341916,
0.1614539474,
0.7126811147,
-0.4705963135,
0.3090723157,
1.0244789124,
-0.0155216502,
-0.2098331153,
0.7778409123,
-0.0421847627,
0.1816872954,
-0.0565438718,
0.2947182953,
-0.4124879241,
-0.7027872205,
-0.4316711128,
0.2587538362,
-0.989236176,
0.1353943795,
-0.9206426144,
-0.2262446582,
-0.1160951033,
-0.1563958973,
-0.1951430887,
-0.348292321,
0.1034828201,
-0.0412425697,
0.2616343796,
0.8167308569,
0.3136085272,
-0.2524440289,
-0.7991338968,
0.2063515782,
0.3010711968,
0.4633375704,
-0.0668057352,
-1.0302751064,
0.2369108796,
-0.0185350329,
-0.0861148164,
-0.3157689273,
-0.0684246942,
0.0530794635,
1.1989655495,
0.3953343034,
-0.2165011615,
0.298460722,
-0.8610009551,
0.699467361,
0.1552862823,
-1.0788267851,
0.1877731085,
-0.4969229698,
-0.1984213293,
0.768804729,
0.4920760691,
-0.1632238775,
-0.6766889095,
-0.6929818392,
-0.8044267893,
0.377607733,
0.4694142044,
0.7268393636,
0.2145793438,
0.4007237852,
0.338419944,
0.4861086309,
-0.825688839,
0.0129251843,
0.2561967671,
0.0511815958,
0.4487923384,
-0.4053328931,
-0.4594358206,
-0.3277188241,
0.2968403697,
0.149289459,
0.1165421158,
-0.1193359792,
-0.14633663,
0.0343043618,
0.7401397824,
0.7556514144,
1.079235673,
-0.0784092993,
-0.2589136362,
0.2839381695,
-0.4890874922,
0.2572323084,
-0.1424522996,
0.0270989165,
0.021853203,
0.273011148,
0.4424198568,
0.2191930711,
-0.916672349,
0.801890254,
0.0503543541,
-0.3418350518,
-0.3628178239,
-0.1537517905,
0.101188831,
0.2109710276,
0.3710862398,
-0.0393827371,
0.5318130255,
-0.8981178403,
0.2324011624,
0.7271284461,
-0.0194430836,
-0.0489693992,
0.4825085402,
0.1901867241,
-0.3309294581,
0.2278240919,
-0.3645450175,
-0.6838946342,
0.7874317169,
0.2313605845,
1.0178101063,
-0.091534622,
0.1458970159,
0.0878566727,
0.5285620689,
-0.1658447534,
0.279512316,
0.0933751985,
-0.555554688,
-0.6025120616,
-0.8625090718,
-0.5686130524,
0.2632504702,
-0.5032231212,
0.1922347546,
-0.6004082561,
-0.0730524808,
-0.2186599076,
-0.1655674726,
-0.667703867,
0.0824127495,
-0.0334795043,
0.7708408237,
-0.4670328498,
0.9288004637,
0.5323287249,
-0.1758953482,
-0.3829670548,
0.064850755,
-0.1940765381,
-0.9133547544,
0.8378986716,
0.2035558671,
-0.3189167976,
-0.37892735,
-0.5113781095,
-0.1350607425,
0.9215027094,
0.3292608559,
-0.6993598938,
0.2622986734,
0.445484519,
0.7685015202,
-0.5991348028,
0.1415761858,
0.6432629228,
0.5018772483,
-0.0064398386,
-1.069553256,
0.3619269133,
-0.250941813,
0.140533179,
-0.2807731926,
-0.5386819243,
0.522981286,
-0.2984430194,
-0.1668071449,
0.1601396352,
0.3778600991,
0.5168327689,
0.4579737186,
0.4078297615,
0.4904600382,
0.8429347277,
0.1074370667,
1.2043757439,
-0.3377960324,
0.473613888,
0.9587677121,
-0.7442104816,
0.5297578573,
0.4878482521,
-0.198556304,
0.2329480052,
0.2575197816,
-0.2154939771,
0.1646143943,
0.545342803,
-0.2851938605,
-0.4360630512,
-0.3572623432,
-0.2283346057,
0.4148796797,
0.441868037,
-0.3276709914,
-0.008682224,
-0.234050706,
0.0233188197,
0.2929879427,
-0.3556772768,
0.4493220448,
0.2844569981,
-0.3934457302,
0.2841611207,
0.2640628815,
0.6857070327,
-0.3357314765,
-0.1277521253,
0.0826498717,
-0.3483382463,
-0.1865588874,
-0.982555449,
0.3115668893,
0.2594871819,
0.3073739409,
-0.0428947806,
0.4683618248,
0.0313459933,
-0.4084884226,
0.2848339081,
0.469340831,
0.2414875329,
0.2400358319,
-0.7051299214,
0.151946336,
-0.393858254,
-0.2705450356,
0.3233473301,
0.6913146973,
-0.1715266258,
0.8302932382,
0.6590801477,
0.0494857579,
-0.1576191485,
0.2904528975,
0.7813487053,
-0.5789996982,
-0.4109356105,
-0.9370062351,
0.5374162197,
-0.2758955657,
-0.3845556676,
0.6928463578,
0.5434146523,
0.4682689905,
-0.1118330359,
0.895219624,
-0.0072532492,
0.1409028322,
-0.8620371819,
0.8665863276,
-0.4354025722,
0.5923845768,
-0.3289935291,
-0.8812787533,
-0.0922001004,
0.5760620236,
-0.4063571692,
0.2480120212,
0.7915604711,
0.3867825866,
-0.2245271951,
0.1162362024,
0.778290689,
0.1190908179,
0.100655213,
0.3881627619,
0.995752275,
-0.1504843086,
0.3859889507,
0.1993427426,
-0.2780629098,
-0.4256675541,
-1.1066995859,
-1.0668181181,
-0.0928650871,
-0.2575136423,
-0.3816293776,
0.1290973723,
0.9377867579,
0.2801944911,
-0.7757917047,
-0.3173824549,
0.1020700857,
-0.0073606875,
-0.018648481,
-0.3147454262,
-0.0743903592,
-0.140786469,
-0.8065316081,
0.5184186101,
0.5844538212,
-0.0207730681,
-0.3209395409,
-0.2320208997,
-0.1253822744,
0.4049636424,
0.6536900997,
0.2428929955,
-0.9491013885,
-0.1975831836,
-0.354089886,
-0.3679089844,
-0.0796994641,
1.0678555965,
-0.1772142947,
0.3114494681,
0.0922772214,
0.9541409016,
-0.0514245406,
-0.127280429,
0.7324276567,
-0.1220565587,
0.184332639,
0.659227252,
0.648126483,
0.1613420844,
-0.5395795703,
0.5051194429,
0.132296294,
-0.4847839475,
-1.0514421463,
0.3722885549,
-1.1437214613,
-0.141915068,
1.3706096411,
-0.4721362889,
-0.0672900826,
-0.4822021425,
0.0644761845,
-0.1403099,
-0.2213905603,
0.6391222477,
0.7697122693,
0.1916962117,
0.1143560931,
-1.0061962605,
0.325555861,
0.4499207437,
-0.6888131499,
-0.2259205133,
0.2352989912,
0.6574575901,
-0.1346706897,
0.464227438,
-0.519187212,
0.3752603531,
-0.2832439244,
-0.2038976997,
0.0348141268,
0.1431888193,
-0.5265305638,
0.1236329898,
0.2947385907,
0.4811599255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11145v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11145v2
|
A Challenge Dataset and Effective Models for Conversational Stance Detection
| 2024-03-17T08:51:01 | 2024-03-21T06:22:56 |
Fuqiang Niu, Min Yang, Ang Li, Baoquan Zhang, Xiaojiang Peng, Bowen Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous stance detection studies typically concentrate on evaluating stances
within individual instances, thereby exhibiting limitations in effectively
modeling multi-party discussions concerning the same specific topic, as
naturally transpire in authentic social media interactions. This constraint
arises primarily due to the scarcity of datasets that authentically replicate
real social media contexts, hindering the research progress of conversational
stance detection. In this paper, we introduce a new multi-turn conversation
stance detection dataset (called \textbf{MT-CSD}), which encompasses multiple
targets for conversational stance detection. To derive stances from this
challenging dataset, we propose a global-local attention network
(\textbf{GLAN}) to address both long and short-range dependencies inherent in
conversational data. Notably, even state-of-the-art stance detection methods,
exemplified by GLAN, exhibit an accuracy of only 50.47\%, highlighting the
persistent challenges in conversational stance detection. Furthermore, our
MT-CSD dataset serves as a valuable resource to catalyze advancements in
cross-domain stance detection, where a classifier is adapted from a different
yet related target. We believe that MT-CSD will contribute to advancing
real-world applications of stance detection research. Our source code, data,
and models are available at \url{https://github.com/nfq729/MT-CSD}.
|
[
-0.4565073848,
-0.8673225641,
0.3592118025,
0.2062371969,
-0.200734213,
0.1365722567,
-0.1659925431,
-0.1375636011,
0.665671289,
0.4378010035,
-0.7765827179,
-0.6660122871,
-0.6658056378,
-0.4085460603,
-0.1032505259,
1.1047106981,
0.1662745476,
-0.0151062617,
-0.0705215782,
-0.8184559345,
-0.3985020816,
-0.5991145372,
-0.7367908359,
-0.0870049521,
0.5722720027,
0.651347816,
0.7854566574,
0.1971169263,
0.3474977016,
0.2280166298,
-0.1275554746,
0.1776091903,
-0.3903484344,
0.1579052359,
0.1130311713,
-0.0376467146,
-0.8557055593,
-0.0782016143,
0.7173831463,
0.6091298461,
-0.3075850904,
0.0580362082,
0.0004329837,
0.6582166553,
-0.3805677593,
-0.160286516,
-0.6983065009,
0.1901873797,
-0.3363983333,
0.112313509,
-0.3525444865,
-0.1861020476,
0.0492112488,
-0.3179007471,
0.4508779943,
-0.1579472274,
0.8810140491,
-0.1237709224,
-0.5993633866,
-0.145957455,
-0.4648248553,
0.6797065139,
-0.6072033644,
0.5028155446,
0.2034427375,
0.3084007502,
-0.1094240323,
-0.3332668543,
-0.6847646236,
-0.0805441067,
0.2194374204,
0.1000022739,
-0.4083310664,
-0.1548781693,
0.1514852643,
0.2602163255,
-0.5873044133,
-0.1164639741,
-0.1133547574,
0.0649839118,
0.3531896174,
0.2227635384,
0.1957595795,
-0.4261336327,
-0.516735673,
-0.0542637259,
-0.5062347054,
0.2225107998,
0.5357369184,
0.5796459913,
-0.5829511285,
0.4577851295,
-0.4215034246,
0.4882557392,
0.43934834,
0.082004644,
0.4466566741,
-0.3048254848,
-0.1422493905,
-0.2740673721,
0.9592748284,
0.4929281771,
0.0225426704,
0.0248941164,
0.3305760026,
0.0122119505,
0.2361777276,
-0.6098636389,
-0.1628427058,
0.3932532966,
-0.5436643958,
-0.397076726,
0.0643831044,
-0.7984122038,
-0.8054939508,
-0.6014920473,
-0.1922841519,
-0.3291044533,
-0.7098486423,
0.0946725979,
0.0849677697,
0.6359751821,
0.269715935,
-0.7654933929,
0.11828731,
0.8450233936,
1.206541419,
-0.4887044132,
0.0830650777,
-0.3879709542,
-0.0558961704,
-0.2630473375,
0.779411912,
-0.6301796436,
-0.3974278867,
-0.066718258,
0.1712869704,
-0.0688590035,
-0.3973756433,
0.8771600723,
-0.2173765153,
-0.012157171,
-0.4139461815,
-0.2420449704,
0.042156212,
0.8640470505,
-0.7996559143,
0.9733297229,
-0.198060751,
-1.0784146786,
0.35334903,
-0.7829360962,
-0.4907751381,
-0.2543558478,
-0.2480407804,
-0.6513525844,
-0.0809379071,
0.4525426924,
0.6767578125,
-0.0606617741,
0.3653236926,
-0.8962475061,
0.1018389687,
0.2568355501,
-0.4217333496,
1.0295656919,
-0.1094416007,
-0.2398191392,
0.3243072331,
-0.6705697179,
-0.0690158457,
0.1550744623,
-0.1807927489,
-0.2828873694,
0.2143151313,
-0.1965344399,
0.4302241802,
-0.0780191869,
-0.4949729443,
0.2746334374,
-0.0774602219,
0.3056778908,
0.8009827137,
0.1772716194,
0.2832650244,
-0.147053197,
0.6077973247,
0.2551018596,
0.3061615825,
0.0703983754,
-0.4594145417,
-0.8425361514,
-0.3276024163,
-0.0904706866,
0.3970805705,
-0.6927838326,
0.3917820454,
-0.4911302626,
-0.4470237792,
-0.5000062585,
0.1022762805,
0.3309314847,
0.3463826478,
0.3597534001,
-0.348187983,
-0.4073487818,
-0.9008783102,
-0.3408310115,
-0.0939671546,
0.1861542761,
0.2271233052,
0.3506549299,
0.0653005615,
1.041105628,
-0.1684501171,
-0.5637899041,
-0.406593889,
0.2916956842,
0.096686773,
0.2753219306,
0.6201430559,
-0.8685737252,
-0.6294954419,
0.0897598863,
-0.6176597476,
0.1574675292,
-0.207627207,
-0.3031005263,
0.0971293524,
0.5704658031,
-0.7418549657,
0.2786731422,
0.6364681721,
-0.2424498349,
0.4092444479,
0.2811096907,
0.2444908321,
-1.2523864508,
-0.1141270697,
0.4331276715,
-0.1212331802,
-0.9706783891,
-0.2345075011,
-0.044750113,
-0.0665115938,
-0.6570703983,
0.3336183131,
-0.3067110181,
-0.0475388542,
-0.025623465,
0.2525976598,
-0.0494907312,
0.7664817572,
0.2963544428,
0.2869103551,
0.592792511,
-0.4689148068,
0.3890038729,
0.38204965,
-0.0988515392,
1.3123365641,
-0.733317852,
0.4809086323,
-0.1126201525,
0.5215423107,
-1.1690620184,
-0.2517404854,
0.7046058774,
-0.5503877997,
0.2919113636,
-0.590793252,
-0.1971998513,
-0.3865117431,
-0.5725371838,
0.2487518787,
-0.3010627031,
-0.6941008568,
0.7113038898,
0.5727400184,
-0.2570810616,
-0.7887257934,
-0.4627381265,
0.2159865201,
-0.3332912326,
-0.7209194899,
0.2234332114,
0.0384691022,
-0.0648294911,
-0.3711669743,
-0.0021591194,
0.1996399313,
-0.3329927325,
0.3769385517,
0.1063100323,
-0.1422842741,
-0.0918586552,
-0.2995343506,
0.0042474652,
0.1682713181,
-0.2292588353,
0.5874447823,
-0.3018383682,
-0.6720244288,
-0.7430528998,
0.5178521872,
0.9467805028,
-0.1769453883,
0.4628466964,
0.7642070055,
-0.3123143017,
-0.1359381229,
-0.3587337136,
0.1131621599,
-0.4954105318,
0.4196365178,
-0.2177718431,
-0.6800717115,
0.644392848,
0.1606068313,
-0.0514056459,
-0.0392156541,
0.6758984327,
-0.1513109356,
1.1057498455,
0.3023076057,
-0.5273807645,
0.568518281,
-0.3512216508,
0.2636313438,
-0.9165090919,
-0.0932632312,
-0.5549544692,
-0.5006830096,
-0.4376405478,
-0.6114662886,
0.1866243333,
-0.4319039881,
-0.0470012091,
0.2975202501,
-0.463199079,
0.3557971418,
0.2757539451,
0.2611761391,
0.1383528113,
-0.0629173145,
0.0754800588,
-0.3302856982,
-0.3494768143,
-0.2919116914,
1.0725290775,
0.3308854103,
0.3575682044,
0.2278254777,
0.3475156426,
0.5261412859,
0.4883837402,
-1.0447715521,
0.739212513,
0.0405076705,
-0.5085818172,
-0.1128818467,
-0.3440749943,
-0.9886782765,
0.4555968344,
-0.1634845138,
-0.6727891564,
0.1903623492,
0.2178035378,
-0.1052918583,
0.5253430605,
-0.4977595806,
1.2706408501,
-0.1706212163,
-0.3909235597,
-0.1596741527,
-0.7397111654,
0.4013400376,
0.3949454129,
0.2228301913,
-0.2701294422,
0.5682368279,
0.6614592075,
-0.1199891046,
1.1841577291,
-0.7242124081,
-0.2055970281,
0.4290640354,
-0.1145783439,
0.5444461107,
0.072920315,
0.1015790403,
0.0378590897,
-0.4485868216,
-0.3119594455,
-0.2190250605,
0.7016144991,
-0.4289401174,
-0.3163122237,
-0.3209417164,
-0.3392135799,
-0.5609155893,
-0.0309410281,
0.023685582,
0.4292821586,
-0.8602356315,
0.4070592225,
0.6059236526,
-0.0133319274,
0.3835152388,
0.2484773993,
0.0600434281,
-0.4417429864,
1.0121287107,
-0.0805446953,
0.2802380919,
0.2286389619,
0.0567336008,
-0.4536671638,
-0.3159740269,
-0.2748614848,
-0.0178294666,
-0.8197137713,
-0.1306426674,
-0.5449898243,
0.2941461205,
-0.4374080896,
-0.1256317198,
-0.4693741202,
-0.3950538635,
-0.1392478794,
-0.2256438136,
0.1717006415,
0.3181631565,
0.0418391302,
0.3542076647,
-0.3789774776,
0.8104395866,
0.2066742629,
0.1248427927,
-0.1662665904,
-0.3109273016,
0.1439352185,
0.2523141205,
-0.6566782594,
-0.8479793072,
0.2716999948,
0.2289028168,
0.4670249224,
0.644082725,
0.2480240613,
0.4355118871,
-0.2248937935,
0.6150944829,
0.4151749909,
-0.7800687551,
0.522329092,
-0.6981797218,
0.2545055747,
0.5099464655,
0.4836201072,
-0.6753579974,
-0.5627980232,
-0.6975263953,
-0.7393732667,
0.77224195,
-0.0466066115,
0.2722992301,
-0.0458497703,
0.0490698479,
-0.1062977538,
0.023641469,
-0.8126268387,
-0.1709475368,
-0.1971417218,
-0.1695018709,
0.4380560815,
0.186064437,
-0.2190704793,
-0.2955498695,
0.6571133733,
-0.576716423,
0.3122712076,
0.0283363909,
-0.0149755245,
0.1431196928,
0.3314278126,
0.4462979138,
0.2996682525,
-0.0862094089,
-0.1338948011,
0.2488704473,
-0.4783262014,
-0.0111338608,
-0.1935625821,
-0.1045438647,
0.1502661258,
-0.1940734088,
0.7888374329,
0.0257897452,
-0.0520005301,
0.6729511619,
-0.0754465014,
-0.3129897416,
-0.3379012644,
-0.2795916498,
0.3401915729,
0.1490597278,
0.168172121,
0.3405740857,
0.1100221351,
-0.525898993,
0.2551344633,
0.8071263433,
-0.7159506083,
-0.4453713596,
0.4967043996,
0.0763121545,
-0.1692863107,
0.2108193785,
-0.415173173,
-0.6687726974,
0.6871214509,
0.2433612794,
0.7747451663,
-0.0516740456,
0.6463441253,
0.2516739368,
-0.0373501703,
0.1443284303,
0.2714038193,
-0.0862417743,
-0.9410613179,
-0.1616345644,
-0.1105028465,
-0.8160587549,
0.2550384402,
-0.892259419,
0.5816313624,
-0.6923388839,
-0.5100010037,
0.2698657513,
-0.1736649275,
-0.4755555093,
-0.0575568117,
0.1728830338,
0.2947176397,
-0.5782064199,
0.8275933862,
0.6731443405,
0.0574721619,
-0.2609779537,
0.2019678205,
0.5877622962,
-0.5915156603,
0.0773967877,
0.2562067509,
-0.6039387584,
-0.3334979415,
-0.747798264,
-0.271430254,
0.9207155108,
0.3917822242,
-0.2169696242,
0.3308589458,
0.2413071692,
0.4312182367,
-0.4033788145,
-0.0361470506,
0.5402607322,
0.4296833873,
0.1909459531,
-0.5180268884,
0.0105026197,
-0.2233332545,
-0.2723834813,
0.1361228079,
-1.1394300461,
0.6297232509,
-0.1930750757,
-0.1431229711,
-0.2487778813,
0.7753213644,
0.3577074111,
0.4112764895,
0.6257570982,
0.5427572727,
0.7621700764,
-0.2615378201,
0.6973667741,
-0.0276351497,
0.4581296444,
1.0319384336,
-0.5674312115,
0.9471048117,
0.39324072,
-0.0496092625,
0.512096107,
0.4334306121,
-0.0396370627,
0.3270409703,
0.0836736113,
-0.3505942822,
-0.3902140558,
-0.132640332,
-0.215267688,
0.4429516196,
0.6669070125,
0.0113502974,
-0.1121886298,
-0.0302718189,
0.3781324923,
0.0144546861,
-0.2360349,
0.5200502276,
-0.1514289081,
-0.5666280985,
0.4267467856,
-0.0550508015,
0.8710271716,
-0.5151898861,
0.2024577409,
-0.3005947769,
0.4416232109,
-0.2238880396,
-0.7317657471,
0.3074196577,
-0.0829047859,
-0.1076411158,
-0.188370809,
0.8435422182,
-0.4381490648,
-0.2508973479,
0.3427664936,
0.374455303,
-0.1929977834,
-0.1512642205,
-0.9043183327,
0.0899233297,
0.0372365341,
-0.4286834002,
0.4565218091,
0.642511487,
-0.2030340731,
0.5610836744,
0.7095817924,
-0.3911614716,
-0.1241582558,
0.3051122725,
0.9632633924,
-0.4195041358,
-0.6733257771,
-0.5849348903,
0.4803104401,
-0.4561312199,
-0.5467614532,
0.5919062495,
0.342987299,
0.6025820971,
0.1082562655,
0.8153625131,
-0.3114424646,
0.6261333823,
-0.3935013413,
0.5717304945,
-0.3368475735,
-0.0441202931,
-0.3629963994,
-0.5432292223,
-0.4258645475,
0.6952519417,
-0.1592084467,
-0.017953217,
0.5096929669,
0.8514103889,
-0.4048959911,
0.3554076254,
-0.1003533751,
-0.0613454953,
0.5571886301,
0.5661609173,
0.802603364,
-0.2445101142,
0.8019108176,
-0.0212698504,
0.0615546256,
-0.2481029928,
-1.064682126,
-1.0901645422,
-0.5041178465,
-0.7260501385,
-0.4814422727,
-0.1264781952,
0.9318832755,
0.874560535,
-1.084228158,
-0.0970202461,
-0.0726755932,
0.1485979408,
-0.3624552488,
-0.3195253611,
0.4228742123,
-0.1303476542,
-0.6607961655,
0.5931730866,
0.0939226076,
-0.0269590877,
-0.0510495231,
-0.2672121227,
-0.4526360333,
-0.0439432226,
0.5424700975,
0.6739874482,
-0.6159330606,
-0.5481234193,
0.2228637338,
-0.03859061,
0.5645516515,
1.0011456013,
-0.3560435772,
0.2670650482,
0.2261013836,
0.530513227,
0.5767577887,
0.2176878452,
0.3243011236,
-1.5888119936,
0.2081362903,
0.0690593943,
0.4458600879,
0.6953910589,
-0.0342472158,
0.3826324642,
0.4111137986,
-0.2958379388,
-0.6452947855,
0.2766023278,
-1.441416502,
0.0426269323,
1.235809803,
-0.0980778858,
0.0918491781,
-0.4856407344,
-0.6121484041,
0.0390094407,
-0.7038297057,
0.5124540329,
0.845073998,
-0.2179307044,
-0.1130339652,
-0.6197841763,
0.4311765432,
0.4741060436,
-0.8125327826,
0.6429294348,
0.6700332165,
0.0233073551,
0.3982397318,
0.8747942448,
-0.0994742066,
0.043989677,
-0.2759156227,
-0.033707846,
0.2703179419,
-0.4300813377,
-0.2557423711,
0.3667742312,
-0.4245043397,
-0.3799812198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11130v1
|
Exploring Tokenization Strategies and Vocabulary Sizes for Enhanced Arabic Language Models
| 2024-03-17T07:44:44 | 2024-03-17T07:44:44 |
Mohamed Taher Alrefaie, Nour Eldin Morsy, Nada Samir
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a comprehensive examination of the impact of tokenization
strategies and vocabulary sizes on the performance of Arabic language models in
downstream natural language processing tasks. Our investigation focused on the
effectiveness of four tokenizers across various tasks, including News
Classification, Hate Speech Detection, Sentiment Analysis, and Natural Language
Inference. Leveraging a diverse set of vocabulary sizes, we scrutinize the
intricate interplay between tokenization approaches and model performance. The
results reveal that Byte Pair Encoding (BPE) with Farasa outperforms other
strategies in multiple tasks, underscoring the significance of morphological
analysis in capturing the nuances of the Arabic language. However, challenges
arise in sentiment analysis, where dialect specific segmentation issues impact
model efficiency. Computational efficiency analysis demonstrates the stability
of BPE with Farasa, suggesting its practical viability. Our study uncovers
limited impacts of vocabulary size on model performance while keeping the model
size unchanged. This is challenging the established beliefs about the
relationship between vocabulary, model size, and downstream tasks, emphasizing
the need for the study of models' size and their corresponding vocabulary size
to generalize across domains and mitigate biases, particularly in dialect based
datasets. Paper's recommendations include refining tokenization strategies to
address dialect challenges, enhancing model robustness across diverse
linguistic contexts, and expanding datasets to encompass the rich dialect based
Arabic. This work not only advances our understanding of Arabic language models
but also lays the foundation for responsible and ethical developments in
natural language processing technologies tailored to the intricacies of the
Arabic language.
|
[
-0.6281949282,
-0.6901448965,
0.2190901488,
0.2940569222,
-0.4268442988,
0.0893417373,
-0.198378697,
-0.5836111307,
0.187768206,
0.3638963103,
0.0188400652,
-0.4045805037,
-0.8376322389,
0.1486018002,
-0.3659316003,
1.1375565529,
0.0980985463,
0.2381943911,
0.1406169236,
-0.1263253838,
-0.5363145471,
-0.9591002464,
-0.7702998519,
0.071410276,
0.5883142352,
0.1776896268,
0.9863033295,
0.7501477003,
0.4057284892,
0.2456754744,
-0.3112503886,
0.0662748218,
-0.2583947182,
0.0053168773,
-0.0254340898,
-0.1267587245,
-0.3696452379,
-0.2229626924,
0.9103949666,
0.7902056575,
0.0020956853,
0.3347783983,
-0.08593449,
0.6313040853,
-0.8052077889,
-0.1008651033,
-0.5704498887,
-0.2508738935,
-0.4831923246,
0.3778580427,
-0.2504443526,
0.0636399984,
-0.0740700215,
0.0521840379,
-0.0248357505,
0.2175656408,
0.728240788,
0.1034396365,
-0.5945339799,
-0.4407159388,
-0.6323279738,
0.9708640575,
-0.9250195026,
0.4090538621,
0.34421134,
0.192132771,
-0.0025960654,
-0.7246561646,
-0.6396898627,
-0.1804752499,
0.0302227102,
-0.3143622577,
-0.2981697917,
0.339179039,
0.0489073806,
0.476627022,
-0.140353635,
0.3054624498,
-0.2686184347,
-0.4605674446,
0.4622583091,
0.0862609148,
0.38731125,
-0.3169032037,
-0.1777287126,
0.1304195672,
-0.5113947988,
0.2519124746,
0.533751905,
0.6193554401,
-0.0816336498,
0.4817681313,
-0.1927906275,
0.7311130762,
-0.1922715455,
0.0615820251,
-0.0295548625,
-0.6682626605,
-0.1304781437,
0.1635403931,
0.3926500976,
0.1398901939,
-0.0177460164,
-0.3074354827,
-0.4872831702,
-0.1828426868,
0.4528925419,
-1.2543557882,
0.2343562245,
0.505132854,
-0.6789702773,
-0.2188901901,
0.0896856412,
-0.8402032852,
-0.2080604881,
-0.1795282662,
0.441367656,
-0.3884749115,
-0.2600404918,
0.178719759,
-0.1602813005,
0.3975147307,
0.1245866492,
-0.9463102818,
0.5696931481,
1.0057277679,
1.2139362097,
-0.0726545155,
-0.0135657489,
-0.6716322899,
0.0590305403,
-0.4263945222,
0.3500384688,
-0.687214911,
-0.3807377517,
0.2058060914,
-0.5293747783,
0.0194866173,
-0.4905696809,
0.7484862208,
-0.7775446177,
-0.315946728,
-0.2259041369,
-0.7015416622,
-0.3377428353,
0.0526887737,
-0.863099277,
0.8253256679,
-0.1020260826,
-0.6742243767,
0.2609643936,
-1.001928091,
-0.4218429327,
-0.0728152096,
0.0446412563,
-0.3664954901,
0.547577858,
0.2947933674,
0.5921152234,
-0.1775952131,
0.2964087725,
0.1591360718,
-0.4827732444,
0.2802574635,
-0.4085255861,
0.5426623821,
0.297837019,
-0.3600897789,
0.2056972831,
-0.7744582295,
-0.1166247353,
-0.023744965,
-0.2311802357,
-0.2641564012,
-0.0615414791,
0.4328070581,
0.1444032639,
0.3500367105,
-0.7142630816,
-0.0259112492,
-0.6703066826,
0.2647733688,
0.7360270023,
-0.0877923593,
0.346147418,
-0.3326583505,
0.4506487548,
0.2736523747,
-0.0157707091,
-0.0081105251,
-0.4705588818,
-1.0630348921,
-0.6709049344,
0.6894940734,
0.0980029032,
-0.3429723978,
0.3012988269,
-0.4047197998,
-0.5042197108,
-0.6321560144,
-0.0353108533,
0.281113714,
0.0411966704,
0.4258508682,
-0.5843418241,
-0.560928762,
-0.9810828567,
-0.4729713798,
0.041972328,
0.2155483812,
0.1570797563,
0.7737635374,
-0.2424715012,
1.0870184898,
-0.028893888,
-0.1065401733,
-0.4674428105,
0.2296376377,
0.2363306135,
0.4976980686,
0.8001499772,
-0.706268847,
-0.3705498576,
0.1004088745,
-0.0545946322,
-0.0116232745,
0.0307711326,
-0.0762408301,
0.4887041748,
0.1539675444,
-0.2748427391,
0.6507282257,
0.6565515399,
-0.496237427,
0.5479518175,
0.1844889075,
-0.0112661887,
-1.0120549202,
0.0926955119,
-0.169023186,
-0.12685664,
-1.0851070881,
0.1627082676,
-0.242484197,
0.0239457209,
-0.3317201734,
0.7598695755,
-0.4334741533,
-0.0686347038,
-0.3748062253,
-0.3679029346,
-0.1882422417,
0.3389768004,
-0.0428977609,
0.9971133471,
0.4181787074,
-0.53390944,
0.0812789202,
0.1054834574,
-0.3907937407,
0.0033959975,
-0.7323306203,
0.4243277311,
-0.2167885154,
0.0351088531,
-1.0365412235,
0.0135654127,
0.0999414399,
-0.4777321219,
0.3280215561,
-0.263441503,
-0.4491101205,
0.201161027,
-0.5149381757,
0.4711805284,
0.2849981487,
-0.355348289,
0.7711421847,
0.2748366296,
-0.2521945536,
-0.6514899135,
-0.5354255438,
0.4525045156,
-0.3753605783,
-0.6324056387,
0.4656495154,
0.2868975401,
-0.4678782225,
-0.3741128743,
-0.1873993129,
-0.2584257424,
0.3083073199,
0.266962409,
0.1897826642,
-0.2000611275,
0.2570670247,
0.1821010113,
0.1705652028,
0.1295840442,
-0.4446997046,
0.9011160135,
-0.2022596449,
-0.1196875796,
-0.5081987381,
0.5594299436,
0.4064560235,
-0.5217699409,
1.5698620081,
0.9170770645,
-0.3535582423,
0.0896939114,
-0.7087932229,
-0.1840299368,
-0.4389232993,
0.5894445777,
-0.5809941292,
-1.0236177444,
0.6771307588,
-0.0755364671,
0.1282701939,
0.3849611878,
0.6200150251,
0.3591282368,
0.9356684089,
0.6011502743,
-0.5418305397,
0.4257911146,
-0.1373662055,
0.4108682573,
-0.7073488235,
0.0353735834,
-0.7308452725,
-0.3201616406,
-0.5340300798,
-0.5871052146,
0.2139469534,
0.0567324832,
-0.3854893148,
-0.1999092251,
-0.1200136542,
0.1665744483,
0.4863988459,
-0.1684194505,
0.1767804921,
0.3294066191,
-0.1200557277,
0.0266704727,
-0.664773941,
-0.9852895737,
1.1790536642,
0.491078198,
0.1254916638,
0.587390244,
0.7792397141,
0.5751941204,
0.0808766261,
-0.9924881458,
0.3704403043,
-0.024780646,
-0.6083564162,
-0.2320686281,
-0.2418599278,
-1.0011136532,
0.2918656468,
-0.0417959541,
-0.6580883265,
-0.0068730288,
-0.1808523983,
-0.2968234122,
0.3328332901,
-0.5379211307,
0.9472171664,
-0.1186636239,
-0.3184033632,
-0.5485135913,
-0.5583851337,
-0.1004012972,
-0.1527862847,
0.2877950668,
0.1370136142,
-0.5682595372,
1.065345645,
-0.5864718556,
0.9027567506,
-0.2057267427,
-0.0735921189,
0.2882663608,
-0.0469446257,
0.4145748615,
-0.1293797195,
-0.2886567712,
0.7692440748,
0.2097986788,
-0.9239575267,
-0.3904076517,
0.4584678411,
-0.9716809988,
-0.7180351615,
-0.4151823521,
-0.4310701787,
-0.2411915511,
0.1630237997,
-0.1645314693,
0.5969412327,
-0.2673386931,
0.1227003112,
0.0992812961,
-0.1480913758,
0.5323640108,
0.2744999826,
-0.2679316401,
-0.3534302115,
0.9621585608,
0.1644400656,
0.2368421853,
0.2637838423,
0.1012761071,
-0.2188100517,
-1.178809762,
-0.4933965504,
0.1482179314,
-0.5390444994,
-0.0070059085,
-0.5037408471,
-0.1360021532,
-0.5707271099,
0.1374654919,
-0.3845488727,
-0.4841625988,
-0.1472372413,
-0.0024866089,
0.4270767868,
0.859249711,
0.0697219968,
0.4869960248,
-0.9127740264,
-0.1531555355,
0.0110000521,
0.221719414,
0.3746406138,
-0.6683655977,
-0.4376166761,
0.131002143,
-0.0814212486,
-0.8422909975,
0.3812219799,
0.124936983,
0.2381307781,
0.34916991,
-0.1973005086,
0.6178318262,
-0.4950319231,
0.9553692341,
-0.0939895064,
-1.2312076092,
0.1727702618,
-0.277602911,
0.0675045177,
0.3326532245,
0.4553746283,
-0.8110300899,
0.0487354361,
-0.3006672561,
-0.8279307485,
0.5763208866,
0.493514061,
0.4697859883,
-0.1647271961,
0.4071830809,
0.1903988719,
0.3832117617,
-0.3180292249,
-0.3379918635,
-0.2856425941,
-0.2386098355,
0.1040609479,
-0.5488322377,
0.2279080451,
-0.3183870614,
0.7118490934,
-0.1476679295,
0.2833689153,
-0.0088229803,
-0.1010617316,
0.3115083575,
0.4746184945,
0.397688657,
0.457570225,
0.0263806246,
-0.0764944926,
0.0501520708,
-0.6239852905,
-0.0908983573,
0.1370792389,
-0.0380166471,
0.1385006756,
0.3039645255,
0.7519999743,
-0.1304045469,
-0.8082508445,
0.4399566054,
0.0099186264,
0.206796363,
-0.1157618091,
-0.2499099523,
0.056962233,
0.0584283695,
0.3069665134,
0.04583285,
0.3083242178,
-0.4731063247,
-0.1516879499,
0.6858448386,
-0.1500949711,
-0.3336260021,
0.2565184832,
0.2057942599,
-0.1541753411,
0.5894025564,
-0.0830707401,
-0.5850198269,
0.6450955272,
0.4598301351,
0.5734229684,
-0.1026126891,
0.1114087626,
0.2308078408,
0.1409192085,
0.2116724849,
0.0931960419,
-0.2342534065,
-0.9845246673,
-0.3927425444,
-0.9377092123,
-0.2927134931,
0.062534973,
-0.5058601499,
-0.0747341812,
-0.6172989011,
-0.3618056476,
0.0624348037,
0.2589332461,
-0.5514088273,
0.0345310494,
0.2740636468,
0.8334138393,
-0.4944950044,
0.6362182498,
0.8429204822,
-0.5299487114,
-0.7883627415,
0.0105762193,
-0.0290770289,
-0.7347313166,
0.8024881482,
0.4108034074,
-0.2536561191,
-0.024746161,
-0.3550307155,
-0.9189394116,
0.6034250259,
0.0478359759,
-0.2423063517,
0.1035181805,
0.4228514731,
0.4942807257,
-0.3353475928,
0.1946326941,
0.6977208257,
0.3645808399,
-0.011262496,
-0.9996699691,
0.0188066345,
-0.2166503221,
0.3022408485,
0.3368279934,
-0.8062472939,
0.7648357153,
0.0303425509,
-0.115895927,
0.5416760445,
0.8423460126,
-0.2179179788,
0.1190529689,
0.3155331612,
0.3953730166,
0.6530252099,
0.1352716237,
0.9855630994,
-0.4736394882,
-0.0486050285,
0.6704314947,
-0.2006542236,
1.0010182858,
0.7661819458,
-0.2126531303,
0.536390543,
0.4417398274,
0.2658150494,
0.1973863393,
0.3780160844,
-0.5535613298,
-0.0836035535,
-0.6505749226,
-0.1591669619,
0.8376145363,
0.3475904763,
-0.3749223948,
0.0136956768,
-0.0333939344,
0.2710251212,
0.1268383861,
-0.5668135285,
0.6779952049,
-0.1722247303,
-0.4715366662,
0.5616442561,
0.526771009,
0.9045376182,
-0.5166248083,
0.1559428424,
-0.2051990628,
0.045372244,
-0.0782977417,
-0.2137301564,
0.492212981,
0.3142782748,
-0.0251331832,
-0.0806414783,
0.7591453195,
-0.0558914989,
-0.5318933129,
0.0452811718,
0.6891670823,
0.2394366413,
-0.3051236868,
-0.3817562461,
0.2915986478,
-0.0106468527,
-0.0683876202,
0.5338149071,
0.2437635511,
-0.1307289451,
0.4040651619,
0.7007195354,
0.3716151416,
0.2259149402,
0.1880142689,
0.807960093,
-0.8158406615,
-0.3500570059,
-1.119156599,
0.2483850121,
-0.1974646896,
-0.2038222849,
0.9104056358,
0.7115731835,
0.8217974305,
-0.0294207502,
0.5337572098,
0.121638149,
0.3669362366,
-0.4241726398,
0.6913072467,
-0.4237859547,
0.1307379603,
-0.0899241716,
-0.6263783574,
-0.1735284775,
0.5132075548,
-0.3473802209,
0.2744189799,
0.3483518958,
0.7865712047,
0.254917413,
0.1691578478,
0.2039702386,
0.2034745365,
0.3344556689,
0.159074232,
0.756947875,
-0.3802346289,
0.2678783238,
-0.1792401522,
0.0236379057,
-0.0430603065,
-0.7234250903,
-1.0480779409,
-0.4964233339,
-0.1012015939,
-0.1478363574,
0.1428874582,
1.084747076,
0.6596921086,
-0.9253414273,
-0.3875702024,
-0.0243320372,
-0.0331495181,
-0.1616199911,
-0.2310239822,
0.386633873,
-0.4928352237,
-0.8754479289,
0.0696818754,
0.2321798056,
0.0311797913,
-0.1649725288,
-0.0302433334,
-0.2868418097,
0.3703686893,
0.6894678473,
-0.0693095848,
-0.8283404112,
-0.2757237852,
-0.260150969,
0.0527231134,
-0.0005849455,
0.7025508285,
-0.7752266526,
0.3001881838,
0.1621259451,
1.0491204262,
0.1945416331,
-0.0787744522,
0.5085498095,
-0.7899274826,
0.3181682229,
0.3010209501,
0.3256387413,
0.4391274452,
-0.2167625129,
0.3704358935,
-0.0421580188,
-0.3161936104,
-0.7559028268,
0.1513455361,
-0.7350677252,
-0.2986762822,
1.0597602129,
0.0251019876,
-0.0517216437,
-0.2412569672,
-0.5246673822,
0.3589116037,
-0.6321285963,
0.7899551392,
1.1146236658,
0.1054530442,
0.1572969407,
-0.4906882346,
0.4797324836,
0.8463361859,
-0.5094252229,
-0.0727767572,
0.4875298738,
-0.0367525071,
0.0502821878,
0.2683310509,
0.0666902363,
0.1605150104,
-0.073888585,
-0.2927852571,
-0.0893607885,
0.0118453642,
-0.610437274,
0.2316323817,
0.4344356656,
-0.1701008081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11129v1
|
Enhancing Event Causality Identification with Rationale and Structure-Aware Causal Question Answering
| 2024-03-17T07:41:58 | 2024-03-17T07:41:58 |
Baiyan Zhang, Qin Chen, Jie Zhou, Jian Jin, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Document-level Event Causality Identification (DECI) aims to identify causal
relations between two events in documents. Recent research tends to use
pre-trained language models to generate the event causal relations. Whereas,
these methods are prone to the errors of sequential generation due to multiple
events in a document. Moreover, the potential structures such as event
coreference and related causal chain are neglected. In this paper, we propose a
multi-task learning framework to enhance event causality identification with
rationale and structure-aware causal question answering. Specifically, the DECI
task is transformed into multiple-choice question answering, and the causes and
effects of the questioned event are generated with large language models. In
addition, we generate the rationales to explain why these events have causal
relations. Moreover, we construct an event structure graph, which models the
multi-hop potential relations for causal reasoning of the current event.
Experiments on two benchmark datasets show the great advantages of our proposed
approach compared to the state-of-the-art methods. Moreover, we conduct both
quantitative and qualitative analyses, which shed light on why each component
of our approach can lead to great improvements.
|
[
-0.1235928386,
-1.0261716843,
0.9490492344,
-0.0829483047,
-0.2318040431,
-0.076991111,
0.0007453466,
-0.5772983432,
-0.0156698953,
0.2584457397,
-0.7531785369,
-0.1381078511,
-0.5139944553,
0.1309752315,
-0.0008874885,
0.7775807381,
-0.1878298372,
0.0150437513,
-0.3328919113,
-0.0516279973,
-0.6303534508,
-0.7132611871,
-1.1549733877,
-0.1641281545,
0.909997344,
0.2371227294,
-0.1028351858,
0.5494308472,
0.439561516,
0.2956845164,
0.1112133712,
0.1839830875,
-0.3604319692,
0.1414975375,
-0.2156876773,
-0.4284927845,
-0.3285164535,
0.0515605249,
0.5433092713,
0.7931451797,
0.2427758574,
0.1937475353,
-0.0275540445,
0.2984179556,
-0.7874820828,
0.436103344,
-0.5794240832,
-0.2951631844,
-0.2579484284,
-0.5318828821,
-0.561709106,
-0.1896010786,
-0.1835319549,
-0.8029116392,
0.4286350906,
-0.1076971143,
0.7544881701,
0.2790676951,
-0.9111320972,
-0.2148959488,
-0.5439831018,
0.7210580111,
-0.5829398632,
0.4325236678,
0.3002802134,
0.1019794792,
-0.1087923497,
-0.5984370112,
-0.4863730669,
-0.0356203243,
-0.2013401091,
0.206078738,
0.2652026117,
0.0369653143,
0.5765001774,
-0.1248999834,
-0.7586331964,
0.0106224231,
-0.249654606,
-0.1819734126,
0.5387994647,
0.2681217492,
0.3744729161,
-0.2076147795,
-0.2993026376,
0.1543136835,
-0.7185792327,
0.2410626262,
0.5171798468,
0.4066342711,
0.1167144775,
0.2727146149,
-0.2543504834,
0.6558312178,
0.3701427877,
-0.4853203893,
0.1192835048,
-0.7908724546,
-0.1404215842,
0.1958863288,
0.3855572641,
0.1940274835,
-0.081153892,
-0.3583236635,
0.4938873947,
0.0719879866,
0.1790008247,
-1.0581160784,
0.1625029892,
0.5235003829,
-0.4516080916,
-0.094546698,
-0.0203716364,
-0.4797417223,
-0.5710144043,
-0.6432535648,
0.1740757376,
-0.4844130874,
-0.4063675404,
-0.1080726311,
-0.4477039576,
0.4149520099,
0.5609335303,
-0.5079158545,
-0.1334606409,
0.4739488363,
0.2793175876,
-0.078256458,
-0.3485891521,
-0.6913666725,
0.5270031691,
-0.2112311721,
0.7438781857,
-0.4298575222,
0.0668671802,
-0.184692651,
0.1459910423,
-0.5464199185,
-0.1414475143,
0.6818088293,
-0.7857183814,
0.2403604984,
-0.6660672426,
-0.5498389602,
-0.2997091413,
0.4618071914,
-0.5805822015,
0.6965418458,
-0.35756284,
-1.1691613197,
0.4991634786,
-0.3933704793,
-0.643294096,
0.0055088564,
-0.252695024,
-0.3519622087,
-0.0744097307,
0.1444336772,
0.3401492238,
-0.4310007691,
0.9328789115,
-0.4364910126,
0.2364734411,
0.1981128007,
-0.4943499267,
0.7698272467,
0.0159268714,
-0.1214486733,
0.5423967838,
-1.0704772472,
-0.3578407466,
0.0400616415,
-0.0629634559,
-0.4124927223,
0.2387541234,
-0.0237445496,
0.4077918231,
0.2020275295,
-0.6828129888,
-0.1008409038,
-0.2691443563,
0.193687126,
0.5082998276,
0.5672366619,
0.4491584897,
-0.325553894,
0.3582749665,
0.3012144864,
0.2575884163,
-0.3604752123,
-0.5045703053,
-0.2474460006,
-0.2273743898,
-0.1807257086,
0.7101126909,
-0.7903259397,
0.2315799147,
0.041922804,
-0.3363910019,
0.1687219888,
-0.1987003386,
0.2192993164,
1.1264517307,
0.421735853,
0.084019646,
-0.7770375013,
-0.619746089,
-0.2784540653,
-0.4096441567,
-0.0471091792,
0.3043320179,
0.4830040634,
0.086521253,
0.8932105899,
-0.5901403427,
-0.067149654,
-0.2158903331,
0.34417817,
0.019514652,
0.5611773133,
0.5076162815,
-1.072411418,
-0.0815360248,
-0.1791031808,
-0.7808977365,
0.0546473898,
-0.6934733391,
-0.1918902248,
-0.1308081001,
0.5499457717,
-0.4522672594,
0.3245533109,
-0.1501449347,
-0.5620083809,
0.7045739293,
-0.0607539378,
0.4064309299,
-1.3784792423,
0.3648942709,
0.0357523113,
0.2625849843,
-0.9089092612,
0.0253859777,
0.2431736588,
-0.2044875026,
-0.4902579486,
0.4752366841,
-0.2230483443,
0.3429535031,
-0.2197565436,
0.2780405879,
0.1363485456,
0.6953482032,
0.0518275611,
0.4570696652,
0.4804497957,
-0.65433532,
-0.0336717516,
0.2927332819,
-0.1129998118,
0.7252619863,
-0.5208275318,
-0.1313030124,
-0.5707846284,
0.3850595951,
-1.1113703251,
-0.32738024,
0.2525628507,
-0.3869184256,
0.3127439916,
-0.2431123108,
-0.332326144,
-0.2004000694,
-0.1643600166,
0.6749622226,
-0.2317565084,
-0.5002191663,
1.0486087799,
0.3566095233,
-0.1042971089,
-0.735615015,
-0.2823452353,
0.0197726991,
-0.4413817227,
-0.6768470407,
0.2957362235,
-0.3443100452,
-0.0276935287,
-0.1987880021,
-0.3697455227,
-0.4458315074,
0.3953710496,
0.3323727548,
0.3655480146,
-0.2058709115,
0.368385613,
0.0969973505,
-0.2108412832,
0.2563087344,
-0.2366465926,
0.2311505526,
0.1217879876,
-0.3659117222,
-0.6383767724,
0.6822543144,
0.8035441041,
-0.5422670841,
0.7206265926,
0.6091244221,
-0.5693682432,
0.3216378689,
-0.7005866766,
-0.2155002952,
-0.3382811844,
0.3232362568,
-0.6207221746,
-0.8327217698,
0.774729073,
-0.1733655483,
-0.0152132576,
0.6010705829,
0.532753706,
0.1533031166,
0.9142027497,
0.2358812243,
-0.0151350312,
0.6455950141,
0.0177824069,
0.2756227553,
-0.8471948504,
-0.3537812829,
-0.7007972002,
0.1142724678,
-0.1005930156,
-0.4212373197,
0.282776773,
0.391920656,
-0.3904241025,
0.3959746659,
-0.1266730726,
0.3466322124,
0.4238403141,
0.1135483086,
0.3423341811,
-0.5051696301,
-0.0228146706,
0.3040234447,
-0.7229292393,
-0.2169875354,
0.7927506566,
-0.0920662954,
0.3980652392,
-0.0592134632,
0.6434163451,
-0.3009768724,
0.2917219996,
-0.3148721755,
0.361140132,
0.4879842401,
-0.8815799952,
-0.3373896182,
-0.573995173,
-1.020132184,
0.3058659434,
-0.2153681517,
-0.8028623462,
0.5775233507,
-0.0473047793,
-0.3006818295,
0.1618160009,
-0.726372242,
1.143261075,
-0.1160950288,
-0.3489907384,
-0.4288893938,
-0.6406129003,
0.4050997794,
-0.0791714564,
0.3477648497,
-0.1929284334,
0.2167197615,
0.9494292736,
-0.0083239963,
1.2352466583,
-0.0298719089,
-0.0000688405,
0.4142577648,
-0.2324568927,
0.6809109449,
0.4447208643,
-0.1617042869,
-0.0487346575,
0.1745409071,
-0.3762461245,
-0.5799151659,
0.7191230655,
-0.5778765082,
-0.6346184015,
-0.0226415917,
-0.7086316347,
-0.2728439271,
0.4420238733,
-0.0346543975,
0.9554699659,
-0.2014235705,
-0.0804846063,
0.5331269503,
-0.0535654314,
0.6991459727,
0.6750571132,
0.4822303057,
-0.4590998292,
0.7706628442,
0.0532650054,
-0.0595851019,
0.5471298099,
0.3394578397,
-0.3064448535,
-0.3499709666,
-0.5013478398,
0.3338761926,
-0.7675035,
-0.2348262221,
-0.9787649512,
0.1305052936,
-0.5257647038,
-0.2802517414,
0.0419176966,
-0.4321887493,
-0.4358741343,
-0.3380903304,
0.1117980406,
0.0413130596,
0.1866957545,
-0.0601624362,
-0.6402868032,
0.5695533156,
0.3424623013,
0.1321863681,
0.2654477656,
-0.2358811796,
-0.0592726618,
-0.1891892701,
-0.2659556866,
-1.2785766125,
-0.0167070907,
0.0174047779,
0.8050923347,
0.644166708,
0.4470072091,
0.7576726079,
-0.6422616839,
0.5043695569,
0.3758920729,
-0.7480412722,
0.749227941,
-0.3243581951,
0.154351756,
0.6018828154,
0.7196694613,
-0.339138329,
-0.6216433048,
-0.9071281552,
-0.7549640536,
0.6364959478,
0.221646145,
-0.3597806096,
-0.2592287958,
0.5302098393,
-0.084719874,
0.2200644016,
-0.5615750551,
-0.3355205059,
0.0513270423,
-0.0598014295,
0.0519986302,
-0.2956721485,
-0.3107898235,
-0.1057181731,
0.6578418612,
-0.3624487519,
-0.0885840803,
0.3519955575,
-0.1831360161,
-0.1756493896,
0.4071668088,
0.5780256391,
0.9493243694,
-0.1172815785,
0.2844396532,
0.3024110198,
-0.1856382787,
0.0282668304,
0.4293398857,
-0.1822572947,
-0.4196008444,
0.6268276572,
0.7676062584,
0.2159421593,
-0.6447173953,
0.478828907,
-0.0343658403,
-0.1465537101,
-0.0573972352,
-0.1579120606,
0.0748695359,
0.370706588,
0.5071314573,
-0.0201278962,
0.1735078692,
-0.4774196446,
0.3338374794,
0.4388009906,
-0.3812621534,
-0.3775732219,
0.9570617676,
0.2598345876,
0.0615954176,
0.2970435023,
-0.1049459353,
-0.5000479221,
0.9950742722,
0.5864682794,
0.8614240885,
-0.2287962437,
0.2163511664,
0.8960482478,
0.4680790305,
0.3573382497,
0.454521358,
-0.1666364074,
-0.8689196706,
-0.8808802962,
-0.4076671898,
-0.2810690403,
0.2073761821,
-0.5502542257,
-0.0691698417,
0.0067400695,
-0.0834642127,
0.1947384328,
0.0712689236,
-0.4827648103,
0.1936456263,
0.1781270504,
0.4878209531,
-1.2795058489,
0.7773067951,
0.6057183146,
-0.8046613336,
-0.7217636108,
-0.1856594384,
-0.1450310051,
-0.0872207806,
0.6497977376,
0.1601608247,
0.2511505187,
0.0682221353,
-0.0349691436,
-1.0368797779,
1.068010807,
0.2990243137,
-0.1578624099,
-0.0096796015,
-0.1120365784,
0.3460209668,
-0.3411655724,
0.3626855612,
0.230205819,
0.6080349684,
0.1102682725,
-0.494715184,
0.5036467314,
0.0711401179,
-0.202190578,
0.2846812904,
-0.2604089975,
0.4370988905,
-0.3120990396,
-0.5081976056,
-0.3732883632,
0.7339257002,
0.2566429079,
0.7172380686,
0.575137198,
0.3284239769,
1.1737112999,
0.0236566793,
1.0284193754,
-0.6106589437,
0.1106603891,
1.2470456362,
-0.3039378822,
0.4758052826,
0.5121561885,
0.214696601,
0.3762231171,
0.5101426244,
0.3795985281,
0.3377006352,
-0.0578407645,
-0.2725329399,
-0.694036305,
-0.1956852227,
-0.1365133077,
-0.0429178812,
0.2900219262,
0.0893871859,
-0.7001494169,
0.3065602183,
-0.1313699037,
-0.2566352189,
-0.1002668068,
0.7008934617,
-0.1614185572,
-0.6080635786,
0.1985682994,
0.0427774154,
-0.0121801253,
-0.7286362052,
0.0897849053,
0.023169484,
-0.0399768613,
-0.0145930648,
-0.1865578443,
0.5181301236,
-0.3208796084,
-0.5654587746,
-0.2206674963,
0.9627594948,
-0.5782479048,
-0.3946276009,
0.1238031834,
0.6567536592,
-0.3768071532,
-0.2352423966,
-0.5675398707,
-0.1197222769,
-0.3874919713,
-0.1984974146,
0.4402231872,
0.5110522509,
-0.4039631784,
0.4298977554,
0.921600759,
-0.4169306159,
-0.1115906462,
0.1491292268,
0.6854197383,
-0.4987045527,
-0.5817275047,
-0.7003004551,
0.4251849353,
-0.2917866707,
-0.3999775946,
0.8134744763,
0.643147409,
0.497618705,
-0.0874267891,
0.4299773276,
-0.1359404624,
0.2070460618,
-0.274941057,
0.3321367502,
-0.410576731,
-0.100902237,
-0.3060420156,
-0.3440847099,
-0.4162221551,
0.0571745597,
-0.5045101047,
-0.4449797273,
1.1038905382,
0.7878658772,
0.1338142306,
0.1201297268,
0.293536216,
0.0679365695,
0.4845392704,
0.6530957818,
0.7646191716,
-0.4294852018,
0.4876845777,
-0.0162160806,
-0.4266946316,
0.039078977,
-0.9575875998,
-0.9820924997,
-0.9695230722,
-0.8638120294,
0.0071425098,
-0.0752789378,
0.4863076806,
0.6323150992,
-0.8614334464,
0.0378942192,
-0.2796867788,
0.5156568289,
-0.5620146394,
-0.2545803785,
0.8070561886,
-0.733772397,
-0.4282130897,
0.6955238581,
0.3039384186,
-0.4006167352,
0.5231520534,
0.4547121525,
-0.5786286592,
0.2418127209,
0.9029758573,
0.28316921,
-0.5412631631,
-0.5209872723,
-0.1508423984,
0.1106804535,
-0.2146326154,
1.2790856361,
-0.581301868,
0.2247399837,
0.6661506891,
0.8759366274,
0.3417705297,
0.0370533392,
0.3674555123,
-0.7099014521,
0.092040658,
-0.059545517,
0.4523024261,
-0.0599479452,
-0.6248346567,
0.3121181726,
0.6074906588,
-0.3279290497,
-0.5594955683,
0.4707246721,
-1.3183579445,
-0.5143659115,
0.9532089829,
0.070454821,
-0.1792853773,
-0.5895422101,
-0.2154673338,
0.482606411,
0.0538167432,
0.5583602786,
0.4854565561,
-0.3368014395,
0.0300712623,
-0.2712029815,
0.3182351887,
0.0739205554,
-1.041326046,
0.2369036078,
0.6959375739,
0.1132797152,
0.290631026,
0.7082281709,
-0.0142693063,
0.3407309353,
-0.1310600042,
0.0081258966,
-0.2180306613,
-0.5926713943,
-0.0583863109,
0.6810756922,
-0.292253226,
-0.1352889985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11128v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11128v2
|
Beyond Static Evaluation: A Dynamic Approach to Assessing AI Assistants' API Invocation Capabilities
| 2024-03-17T07:34:12 | 2024-03-27T15:22:53 |
Honglin Mu, Yang Xu, Yunlong Feng, Xiaofeng Han, Yitong Li, Yutai Hou, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs), AI assistants' ability to
utilize tools, especially through API calls, has advanced notably. This
progress has necessitated more accurate evaluation methods. Many existing
studies adopt static evaluation, where they assess AI assistants' API call
based on pre-defined dialogue histories. However, such evaluation method can be
misleading, as an AI assistant might fail in generating API calls from
preceding human interaction in real cases. Instead of the resource-intensive
method of direct human-machine interactions, we propose Automated Dynamic
Evaluation (AutoDE) to assess an assistant's API call capability without human
involvement. In our framework, we endeavor to closely mirror genuine human
conversation patterns in human-machine interactions, using a LLM-based user
agent, equipped with a user script to ensure human alignment. Experimental
results highlight that AutoDE uncovers errors overlooked by static evaluations,
aligning more closely with human assessment. Testing four AI assistants using
our crafted benchmark, our method further mirrored human evaluation compared to
conventional static evaluations.
|
[
-0.3482481837,
-0.6864030957,
0.5258508921,
0.0765466765,
-0.0833485499,
0.7244656682,
-0.2572428584,
-0.5933727026,
0.0904571787,
0.1390113533,
-0.8188663721,
-0.1847344935,
-0.3509448469,
0.4744097292,
-0.5005689263,
0.3277527988,
-0.2157901525,
-0.0668763295,
-0.64039433,
-0.2358430475,
-0.7945613265,
-0.1419150829,
-0.5943990946,
-0.400728792,
-0.1035475507,
0.192869246,
0.8226145506,
0.6429427266,
0.3774189651,
0.5792969465,
0.1721270382,
0.623337388,
-0.0455560163,
0.1331471801,
0.0351658948,
-0.4368702471,
-0.6369457245,
0.1836274266,
0.4569970071,
0.4808496237,
0.0899334401,
0.4412226975,
0.1498469263,
0.3872059584,
-0.5105839372,
0.2390972376,
-0.6156956553,
0.032864701,
0.0155666023,
-0.2017885596,
-0.1895559877,
-0.3396012783,
0.4893716872,
-0.3478372097,
-0.3629291356,
-0.1473390311,
0.9191934466,
0.9417265058,
-0.2809408009,
-0.4382794797,
-0.8574203253,
0.6698384285,
-0.6615361571,
0.293523252,
0.3810115159,
0.3908566833,
-0.2976251543,
-0.5839003921,
-0.6116240621,
-0.9684169888,
-0.0581375398,
-0.1090958193,
-0.2070035487,
-0.0071683479,
0.1773175001,
0.2007275373,
-0.2065706998,
0.0487778336,
0.0529317893,
-0.0606307127,
0.7208167315,
0.4459415972,
0.658421874,
0.0674639344,
-0.3174746335,
-0.1252870262,
-0.3087495863,
0.04975117,
0.4844917059,
0.1290930361,
-0.262735635,
0.3424140215,
-0.0028748487,
0.5481106639,
0.355686754,
0.0833265632,
0.272913754,
-0.3724259734,
-0.209516108,
-0.1919853091,
0.7877212167,
0.3303417563,
0.3225646913,
-0.4418447018,
-0.1121943295,
-0.0767237097,
0.7467367649,
-0.4139904082,
0.0805415362,
0.3993478119,
-0.5404589772,
-0.3374812901,
0.1069751531,
-0.9191875458,
-0.574991107,
-0.5529744029,
0.3109675944,
-0.1904000491,
-0.2720378637,
-0.3931848705,
0.1122086868,
0.28878057,
0.248631686,
-0.4422807992,
0.6786304116,
0.6359658837,
0.6562319994,
-0.4820610881,
-0.6329064965,
-0.3995062113,
-0.2947438061,
-0.3687672615,
0.8827517629,
-0.495646745,
-0.4549634755,
-0.0785007402,
-0.2021093518,
0.1810407639,
-0.7472846508,
0.420897752,
-0.4309644997,
-0.2449365258,
0.0405810773,
-0.3121314645,
-0.0493249483,
0.1586480886,
-0.3775807619,
0.943543911,
0.2006080151,
-0.1452443451,
0.5302132368,
-1.078007102,
-0.2795005441,
0.2795309424,
-0.36549142,
-0.1918923259,
-0.0677011535,
0.1421374679,
0.0258212052,
-0.3647868335,
0.0481680781,
-0.4006061256,
-0.4869839847,
0.4502979219,
-0.856012404,
0.8225924373,
0.0017585072,
-0.8443161249,
0.3267717957,
-0.896749258,
0.0811828822,
-0.0676474497,
-0.1979464591,
-0.1959310472,
0.1661562771,
-0.3731782436,
-0.1439049989,
0.4126216471,
-0.236385718,
0.1520168334,
-0.539763689,
0.1511254162,
0.8655118346,
-0.2807627916,
0.4731995761,
-0.0858772993,
0.7080255747,
-0.9124509692,
0.3196861148,
-0.0905497745,
-0.2061574012,
-0.6667250395,
-0.4393100739,
0.3248791397,
0.6649555564,
-0.4298765063,
1.0291644335,
-0.2433992922,
-0.5779038668,
-0.6513533592,
0.5413905978,
0.6542034149,
0.4959582984,
0.0874301419,
-0.4276737571,
-0.4897829592,
-0.7328019142,
-0.1961101294,
-0.5078179836,
-0.146404475,
0.6206265688,
0.0856367722,
-0.6169626117,
1.0005202293,
0.0259241089,
0.0089476956,
0.1100960448,
0.5733312368,
0.02607028,
0.2068472505,
0.4814603925,
-0.3651565015,
-0.4244497716,
-0.2872194946,
-0.8193749189,
-0.6175200939,
-0.1680259407,
-0.1405336261,
0.1893083006,
0.533272028,
-0.4811789989,
0.6393327117,
0.3762815893,
-0.2614274621,
0.5321165323,
-0.2851949334,
0.200859949,
-0.500865221,
-0.0338883474,
-0.2778896987,
-0.2858737707,
-0.2533312142,
-0.0633177161,
-0.081793122,
-0.2765333652,
-0.3920040727,
0.7950102091,
-0.7899528146,
-0.4647305906,
-0.5088968277,
-0.0592980795,
-0.2113344371,
0.2184311152,
-0.3234720826,
1.0074928999,
0.4342721999,
-0.5210961103,
0.6687446833,
0.1554952264,
-0.3486838341,
0.533190608,
-0.7008871436,
0.4917918444,
0.3943517804,
0.3292222619,
-1.3810733557,
-0.0955630913,
0.1410849094,
-0.2697860003,
0.3284736276,
-0.1277519912,
-0.6749468446,
-0.5073891282,
-0.5789988041,
0.4777600169,
0.4494057596,
-0.4941938519,
0.933781445,
0.3751933873,
-0.1887927651,
-0.3854184151,
-0.3407832086,
0.3616503179,
-0.2787442803,
-0.6658895016,
0.0285025463,
-0.2113620937,
-0.5298090577,
-0.0658575669,
-0.0729072839,
-0.0594185144,
0.4953039289,
0.5022895336,
0.4636331201,
0.0022125775,
-0.1455759555,
-0.1203099564,
-0.0805056766,
0.213273719,
0.2737633884,
0.842030108,
-0.4247077703,
-0.7760552764,
-1.2201877832,
-0.0841178373,
1.03231287,
-0.1849114895,
0.0622383319,
0.4512598515,
-0.1708852351,
0.1864777952,
-0.598714292,
-0.2023872733,
-0.5582180023,
0.0720214993,
-0.2793004811,
-0.0743732303,
0.5760086775,
-0.322419703,
0.1387647688,
0.2290918082,
0.7106308341,
-0.1284922063,
1.0444937944,
0.3341419995,
-0.0423915498,
0.4875466228,
-0.1342864335,
-0.0340242572,
-0.7829868793,
0.0378916077,
-0.3041910827,
-0.3734337091,
-0.5039225221,
-0.0420503989,
0.5042265654,
-0.4292441308,
-0.3175026774,
0.26668787,
-0.447615087,
0.2843342721,
0.4372706115,
-0.0910681188,
0.0060151578,
-0.1507624388,
0.2417540401,
0.1359079033,
-0.0704151168,
-0.9230481386,
1.1799429655,
0.5736026168,
0.7077092528,
-0.0074629793,
0.4603320658,
0.6805974245,
0.4051069915,
-0.7624756694,
0.686869204,
0.1691974401,
-0.1248831376,
-0.5280560851,
-0.0489702784,
-0.9007723927,
0.0449540466,
-0.2262253165,
-0.9007851481,
0.0032247568,
0.1404355317,
-0.819617033,
-0.0692075714,
-0.9360042214,
0.4778070748,
-0.7142395973,
-0.3792541921,
-0.1916304082,
-0.4620274603,
0.2126857042,
-0.0090613747,
-0.0088884356,
-0.2754640877,
-0.2226994038,
0.4692859948,
-0.6248924732,
0.9528625011,
-0.1402413547,
-0.3031892478,
0.3030606508,
0.2468135357,
0.4345569313,
0.0246731173,
-0.2710723877,
0.2390288264,
-0.0714143589,
-0.1223107427,
-0.7865235209,
0.5747294426,
-0.9096881151,
-0.6417546868,
-0.2991814911,
-0.5264606476,
-0.4331642985,
0.1230855733,
-0.2010626048,
0.3612226546,
-0.2474471331,
-0.2349478453,
-0.0626502931,
-0.2648060918,
0.4467546046,
0.5475547314,
0.0864930078,
-0.1951576471,
0.5761579871,
-0.0345127694,
0.0237661041,
-0.1790043563,
0.3061202168,
-0.5429416299,
-0.3215894997,
-0.9306406975,
0.0103143677,
-0.3821119368,
-0.0519324243,
-0.4499977529,
0.1480425149,
-0.3161615729,
-0.1050929204,
-0.5485109091,
0.0806111917,
-0.281691879,
0.2003072947,
0.1808365881,
0.5745685101,
0.1156391278,
0.1268583834,
-0.7338192463,
0.2841807008,
0.4847691357,
0.3475067616,
0.2135120183,
-0.3838423789,
0.1866333932,
0.0098849824,
-0.3413007259,
-0.7448023558,
0.216910094,
-0.016968485,
0.7657687068,
0.4799024165,
0.0374023244,
0.8903733492,
-0.7482789159,
0.9432948232,
-0.2784388065,
-1.1160145998,
0.5124832988,
-0.0529903285,
0.0708585307,
0.8022672534,
0.0014197732,
0.134561792,
-0.357609421,
-0.6202356219,
-0.9599772096,
0.6378588676,
0.0608565956,
0.4505281746,
0.1613689065,
0.40405792,
-0.021587858,
0.1605129689,
-0.0657288209,
-0.2068749368,
0.150896281,
-0.046702411,
0.419462502,
-0.1285351664,
-0.2761525512,
-0.1678493321,
0.1639451236,
-0.075782828,
0.5553327799,
-0.0485953912,
-0.0880050212,
-0.2613374591,
0.0243123379,
0.6274344325,
1.1152830124,
-0.4328814149,
-0.0927801952,
0.5641630292,
-0.128489539,
0.1383143216,
0.2468624711,
0.1578811109,
-0.0714138523,
0.5710359216,
0.4713938832,
0.1013206765,
-1.0981673002,
0.4788613319,
-0.3666699231,
0.3028436601,
-0.6923008561,
0.1066358984,
-0.3469776511,
0.3454048634,
0.3405214548,
-0.0969910473,
0.2772579193,
-0.8568243384,
0.3810104728,
0.5745251775,
-0.2745340466,
-0.2715958953,
0.404329747,
0.4701735079,
-0.8376736641,
0.584456265,
-0.272708416,
-0.3962849975,
0.8079761863,
0.2119942158,
1.3202791214,
-0.2749421597,
-0.1615687311,
-0.1357024908,
0.0401456803,
0.1998028308,
0.1934892535,
-0.2418105006,
-0.4765303135,
-0.3112666011,
-0.3628983796,
-0.7236974835,
0.1305326223,
-0.4403403997,
0.4133036733,
-0.583971858,
-0.1956982315,
-0.0485306494,
0.1283364892,
-0.6152202487,
-0.1709037423,
0.1995177716,
0.7776955962,
-0.5752728581,
0.4787476063,
0.8049958944,
-0.3252890706,
-0.5739772916,
0.5009762049,
0.3555874527,
-0.8265611529,
0.8796676993,
-0.0208936296,
-0.6184334159,
-0.3849852979,
-0.4259790182,
-0.6626601815,
1.1044228077,
0.3761642277,
-0.1407854557,
0.2841303349,
-0.0065988069,
0.8847454786,
-0.4352937341,
0.9305157661,
0.544737339,
0.5858154297,
-0.250985086,
-1.3957331181,
0.1111585647,
-0.3364618421,
-0.0280793235,
-0.2602818906,
-0.8843003511,
0.5331692696,
0.2732968628,
-0.2673342824,
0.3254534304,
0.6955356002,
0.0043004504,
0.3242348433,
0.9480368495,
0.1633003801,
0.8885083795,
0.3446700871,
1.3033847809,
-0.5279278755,
-0.0261306092,
1.1307811737,
-0.6527652144,
0.6836224794,
0.2457216233,
-0.2547938526,
0.565961957,
0.514382422,
-0.104904972,
0.3313372135,
0.4083007872,
-0.1976204365,
0.0498352721,
-0.059921626,
0.0552548915,
0.8458894491,
0.2214593738,
-0.0601141229,
-0.3510831892,
-0.1546390355,
-0.0386138,
0.3305862248,
-0.0491545834,
0.9153344631,
-0.29526335,
-0.7997785807,
0.9419077039,
-0.1382590085,
0.6896108985,
-0.2617034614,
-0.2332284451,
-0.1273430586,
0.1388600618,
-0.0543037541,
-0.5934388041,
0.5210235119,
0.4214385748,
0.1754743755,
-0.209834516,
0.6797237992,
0.0131918881,
-0.2277915776,
0.4250207841,
0.413357228,
0.3853822947,
0.2360001951,
-0.9648869038,
0.2946650386,
-0.2515668869,
0.1256196946,
0.1613642722,
0.2376872599,
-0.2781855762,
0.8376227617,
0.5413484573,
-0.0157997496,
-0.0607683435,
0.0742081478,
0.6582987309,
-0.1601954699,
-0.1312950253,
-1.1245704889,
0.3865911365,
-0.1353296191,
-0.2772890925,
0.5587939024,
0.4025627375,
0.3643060029,
0.0913889185,
0.7737172246,
0.0883150846,
0.4744897187,
-0.2934704423,
0.6768841147,
-0.4832958877,
0.5384518504,
-0.4220761955,
-0.6097304821,
0.0081866924,
0.5671728253,
-0.2946817875,
0.0224995129,
0.2798790634,
0.7232929468,
-0.1944373101,
-0.0995837823,
0.1798699796,
0.159029752,
0.4790707827,
-0.0072703524,
1.3122060299,
-0.1396121234,
0.5805056691,
0.0032929198,
-0.7122294307,
-0.2966290414,
-0.9485561252,
-0.9442808032,
-0.3298177123,
-0.24926956,
-0.3382266462,
0.1584478766,
1.4323952198,
0.6898334622,
-0.5303304791,
-0.4574280381,
0.0452444106,
-0.0768799633,
-0.321574688,
-0.2380800247,
0.5053095818,
-0.6555610299,
-1.1658391953,
0.835747242,
0.2470308989,
-0.0248385668,
-0.6245946884,
0.0187702682,
-0.0276653655,
0.2420953959,
0.3942486942,
0.4956283867,
-0.7647234797,
-0.3213408887,
-0.2015901357,
0.0294266362,
-0.0238829665,
0.6769241095,
-0.846590817,
0.486117512,
0.4444682896,
1.1290960312,
-0.1184585318,
0.3142997921,
0.8829061985,
-0.5683403015,
0.1518071145,
0.0605838075,
0.0961819291,
0.2095659226,
-0.5466392636,
0.4711054862,
-0.0583995208,
-0.5758071542,
-0.9738584161,
0.0363880806,
-0.7858847976,
-0.0182297844,
1.1052728891,
-0.3854277432,
-0.1459234655,
-0.3661686778,
-0.3152066469,
0.2660890222,
-0.5022958517,
1.2024388313,
0.6528041959,
-0.6287437677,
0.0977396369,
-0.5943998694,
0.5785441399,
0.43953529,
-0.958818078,
0.1353885829,
0.3303414285,
0.0488283038,
0.5597475171,
0.4875427485,
-0.1200389713,
0.2080916613,
-0.3021276593,
-0.0848253369,
-0.0230894964,
-0.1905591339,
-0.3972917497,
-0.2049609572,
0.2485337853,
-0.5258446932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11124v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11124v2
|
Scaling Data Diversity for Fine-Tuning Language Models in Human Alignment
| 2024-03-17T07:08:55 | 2024-03-30T16:48:16 |
Feifan Song, Bowen Yu, Hao Lang, Haiyang Yu, Fei Huang, Houfeng Wang, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Alignment with human preference prevents large language models (LLMs) from
generating misleading or toxic content while requiring high-cost human
feedback. Assuming resources of human annotation are limited, there are two
different ways of allocating considered: more diverse PROMPTS or more diverse
RESPONSES to be labeled. Nonetheless, a straightforward comparison between
their impact is absent. In this work, we first control the diversity of both
sides according to the number of samples for fine-tuning, which can directly
reflect their influence. We find that instead of numerous prompts, more
responses but fewer prompts better trigger LLMs for human alignment.
Additionally, the concept of diversity for prompts can be more complex than
responses that are typically quantified by single digits. Consequently, a new
formulation of prompt diversity is proposed, further implying a linear
correlation with the final performance of LLMs after fine-tuning. We also
leverage it on data augmentation and conduct experiments to show its effect on
different algorithms.
|
[
-0.6544498801,
-0.5636337399,
0.2092238665,
0.2893071771,
-0.1603788286,
0.2573563755,
-0.663202107,
-0.568839252,
0.1074625254,
0.4934217036,
-0.5848007202,
-0.3077585399,
-0.5866613388,
0.39240399,
-0.0402584337,
1.0900375843,
0.2380219251,
0.0545278676,
-0.0995330289,
-0.553665638,
-0.5927125216,
-0.3554358482,
-0.5935384631,
-0.227955848,
0.9191535711,
0.8629640341,
1.2209945917,
1.0574223995,
0.496137023,
0.2745466828,
-0.3828988969,
0.3410336077,
-0.5615364313,
0.1371504366,
-0.330054611,
-0.5156958699,
-0.309581548,
-0.1362833232,
0.7353556156,
0.992523849,
0.02295807,
0.1951930076,
0.1482230574,
0.7379127741,
-0.4675314724,
-0.3625694513,
-0.5915202498,
-0.2629128695,
-0.3074207604,
0.0187926497,
-0.2131638974,
-0.3972545862,
0.1796983033,
-0.429069072,
0.1141064018,
0.2294319868,
0.711956501,
0.2805311978,
-0.3787915111,
-0.1510207057,
-0.7965987325,
1.0533056259,
-0.7014899254,
0.3001232445,
0.2043801695,
0.2176362574,
-0.1570092887,
-0.026284812,
-0.431213975,
-0.0602145046,
0.068908453,
-0.3419051468,
-0.0371974781,
-0.0492005572,
0.3137844205,
0.2858196497,
-0.4301348031,
0.7770599127,
-0.3368982971,
-0.3501037955,
0.8337491155,
0.4730576575,
0.476880908,
0.1801671684,
0.0427001417,
-0.3413820565,
-0.7267733812,
0.1806943268,
0.6715425253,
0.833992064,
-0.0579567403,
0.5445065498,
-0.4487099648,
0.852850616,
0.2392137051,
-0.1573212743,
0.3306987286,
-0.4333383143,
-0.0278435908,
-0.1073022187,
0.7589191794,
0.5176175237,
0.4213995934,
-0.0380129553,
-0.1398970634,
-0.0032523007,
0.1591316611,
-0.7453334332,
0.1000505164,
0.0099123307,
-0.3444922268,
-0.3007047474,
-0.1139274836,
-0.9486038685,
-0.7531445026,
-0.6019950509,
0.0645840988,
-0.1691315174,
-0.079051815,
0.2581428289,
0.1554233432,
0.0741280392,
0.4490536153,
-1.3299095631,
0.2653996348,
0.711245656,
0.6714571714,
-0.4332166314,
-0.3421420157,
-0.4603142738,
-0.3540569544,
-0.2127284408,
0.6868501902,
-0.8273838758,
-0.3682019413,
-0.0463429131,
-0.2430860847,
0.4419956803,
-0.753898561,
0.6902919412,
-0.4400189221,
0.3761989772,
-0.7073593736,
-0.5046178699,
0.1102568731,
-0.0185920745,
-0.7464402914,
0.8700684905,
0.242963478,
-0.6964598298,
0.6126638055,
-0.4279252589,
-0.4414377809,
0.0269339215,
-0.3001154065,
-0.4563049376,
0.04334829,
0.4233345389,
0.1961245239,
-0.3976861537,
0.2556980252,
-0.5851815939,
-0.2023821473,
0.3009206653,
-0.2200655043,
0.7960280776,
0.393989712,
-0.0983193591,
0.4708512723,
-0.6669782996,
-0.2096972764,
-0.1705821157,
-0.5409283042,
-0.3109640181,
-0.0764776394,
0.0179762747,
0.1652437598,
0.1613166034,
-0.4596525431,
0.4817501307,
-0.3832445443,
0.2700622082,
0.7771782279,
-0.2870428562,
0.8832669854,
-0.6479766965,
0.5154032111,
-0.0347545594,
0.0894909576,
-0.1034244597,
-0.6237846613,
-0.5903594494,
-0.3483676612,
0.328420788,
0.4010049999,
-0.2050226182,
0.6560459733,
-0.3293682337,
-0.4596943557,
-0.9700683355,
0.4142166972,
0.0521358624,
0.4425110519,
0.3276164532,
-0.3120585978,
-0.6235937476,
-1.0334743261,
-0.5788203478,
-0.1092791781,
-0.2598580718,
0.5423326492,
0.1128802523,
-0.2562787533,
1.2028306723,
-0.2799472213,
-0.0257797521,
-0.2155889571,
0.1495987028,
0.2277902812,
0.5153990388,
0.5650439858,
-0.6050422788,
-0.4778927863,
-0.0083596176,
-0.1988544613,
-0.4687256813,
-0.2576145232,
-0.1444153041,
0.0345427804,
0.1942421198,
-0.3179171383,
-0.0027092542,
0.5211623311,
-0.3612648249,
0.3993324637,
0.0344949327,
0.1239077821,
-1.0679172277,
-0.2207557112,
0.0489938781,
-0.061041519,
-0.6509158611,
-0.134070456,
0.1815407723,
0.1517915726,
-0.1190765351,
0.7072185874,
-0.3360445797,
0.0669255406,
-0.3221246302,
0.0668344349,
-0.0548753552,
0.2143007368,
-0.3098149598,
0.6619271636,
0.4831947982,
-0.5024321079,
0.3206919432,
0.2027239352,
-0.3105853796,
0.5982601643,
-0.5547767878,
0.0227825735,
-0.3709232807,
0.1949285418,
-1.1173932552,
-0.3844683766,
-0.0361300483,
-0.3856424987,
0.2554268539,
0.0017651638,
-0.5832582116,
-0.2420894206,
-0.4123317599,
0.5153807402,
0.5544124246,
-0.5632752776,
0.3374509513,
0.3249686956,
-0.4722671509,
-0.5053834319,
-0.6663830876,
0.0343301371,
-0.4680097401,
-0.8147639632,
0.1817315668,
-0.2690002918,
-0.4064280093,
-0.3656178117,
0.024200689,
0.1420147717,
0.3787586093,
0.1330370456,
0.3133006394,
-0.1783290654,
0.3023235202,
0.174442634,
0.1319852769,
-0.2237692028,
-0.3627240062,
0.5843083262,
-0.0185173545,
-0.4107695818,
-0.3934621811,
0.4160102904,
0.6028284431,
-0.2576352358,
0.6744324565,
0.5759449005,
-0.2053653896,
0.1133945435,
-0.5662755966,
-0.3261907399,
-0.5045585036,
0.3559438884,
-0.0653992221,
-1.4335452318,
0.8035975099,
0.0333006829,
0.3910872638,
0.3705167472,
0.9126114845,
0.0195005331,
1.266741991,
0.5603517294,
-0.4187622666,
0.7489712834,
0.3738651574,
-0.0939999446,
-0.6064094305,
0.0218089968,
-0.7637372613,
-0.8590327501,
-0.8712792993,
-0.2050867528,
0.0313827805,
0.297442019,
-0.3285910487,
0.0132505987,
-0.5625622272,
0.6318537593,
0.5256440043,
0.0559062213,
0.2684767246,
0.0565741658,
0.1205385029,
-0.2060745806,
-0.4728955925,
-0.4734772444,
1.1939328909,
0.4316376448,
0.9763535261,
0.2648247778,
0.7304366231,
0.0255412515,
0.3547427356,
-0.5476964712,
0.2228733301,
-0.2104737759,
-0.6479661465,
-0.6381318569,
-0.5455912352,
-1.0430034399,
0.3289382458,
-0.3639325798,
-0.8353390694,
0.3424873352,
0.2110043913,
-0.6347854137,
0.1881507933,
-0.7341998816,
0.4790799022,
-0.1635837555,
-0.1836908311,
-0.0274439659,
-0.7222337127,
0.0960109159,
-0.1679945737,
0.2879509032,
-0.2758122683,
-0.0640566349,
0.689994812,
-0.2670765817,
1.0601621866,
0.0551563799,
-0.3481025994,
0.0208949205,
-0.0124069853,
0.5309044123,
0.0827811658,
-0.2536424994,
-0.1001355946,
-0.4242042303,
-0.5883649588,
-0.5700696707,
0.7435058355,
-0.9684737325,
-0.6349816322,
0.0753290057,
-0.9853898287,
-0.3767316639,
0.2211208493,
0.332246542,
0.1139074117,
0.1726854891,
0.2085574865,
0.5965567231,
-0.2437081486,
0.2748556137,
0.4917655289,
-0.2606703341,
-0.4100288749,
0.7828487754,
0.1399469078,
0.5287833214,
0.2575479448,
0.3665825129,
-0.2170650363,
-0.5656370521,
-0.4937654138,
0.1825588048,
-0.549826324,
-0.0770894587,
-0.5856310725,
0.3412334919,
-0.5570315123,
-0.2751734257,
-0.2105590403,
-0.5121971965,
-0.5406457186,
-0.1149564981,
0.5690741539,
0.5761463642,
-0.1372466087,
0.4314039648,
-0.6583384275,
0.1026514694,
0.4533660412,
0.5094804764,
-0.0919494629,
-0.7997516394,
-0.2118379027,
0.1781918257,
-0.1759937108,
-0.8017573953,
0.2041935474,
0.1201711372,
0.413333416,
0.3988208473,
-0.0055186562,
0.6873636842,
-0.3078898191,
0.6929749846,
0.1391060203,
-0.8039283156,
0.3698620498,
-0.5231835246,
0.5753160715,
0.7771018147,
0.2013158947,
-0.7546685934,
-0.5458305478,
-0.3908490837,
-0.8092592955,
0.7272780538,
-0.0848217532,
0.3364103436,
0.1680702865,
0.3988062441,
0.2796164453,
-0.0218376555,
-0.4140275121,
-0.2962282598,
0.1373387128,
-0.3975615799,
-0.1387088597,
-0.2634036243,
-0.2509437799,
-0.3364797831,
0.1266940832,
-0.1519005001,
-0.3160895109,
-0.1250596792,
-0.0264767017,
-0.4683636129,
0.5608108044,
0.8461043835,
0.5171812773,
-0.0153207229,
0.2110683918,
0.3841082752,
-0.3069410026,
0.1110072508,
-0.1181383803,
-0.2513342798,
-0.2164108604,
0.4355510771,
1.030911684,
0.0164319407,
-0.5155329704,
0.1028828397,
-0.0726134777,
-0.0180405173,
0.5564263463,
0.2528628409,
0.1599445939,
0.2865874469,
0.2051130682,
0.1320109218,
0.0385743082,
-0.3374404311,
0.1789676845,
0.4183495641,
-0.2269691974,
-0.2494429201,
0.5604640841,
0.325117141,
-0.5292027593,
0.6222872138,
-0.1319712549,
-0.3501569927,
0.5751120448,
0.3796221912,
0.6849358678,
-0.4065394104,
-0.0236252882,
0.3643084168,
0.3012133241,
-0.1867898703,
0.3735921085,
0.1177287772,
-0.8558992743,
-0.4269126952,
-0.5261614919,
-0.464694798,
-0.130903095,
-0.8291504383,
0.286775142,
-0.4483897686,
-0.2132595778,
0.2262220681,
0.0250512715,
-0.59145087,
0.0714165345,
0.3814498484,
0.7516452074,
-1.0171663761,
0.7274327874,
0.7286430597,
-0.3183595538,
-0.675537169,
-0.0899082348,
0.1546203941,
-0.7307373285,
0.5733283758,
0.1106667146,
0.1847581267,
-0.0415899567,
-0.657768786,
-0.9857526422,
0.8367412686,
0.5766698122,
-0.8832056522,
0.1881420314,
0.367969811,
0.6902486086,
-0.4852372706,
0.181861788,
0.7033320665,
0.4812756479,
0.0271032918,
-1.1590410471,
0.031705983,
-0.0298809819,
0.1576664746,
0.1840895712,
-0.4626660645,
1.0603069067,
-0.4558551311,
-0.3059430718,
-0.0413878709,
0.6372905374,
0.3026484549,
-0.067527473,
0.7119227648,
0.4847561717,
1.1304113865,
-0.0570206568,
0.9605690241,
-0.0476459339,
0.3624863029,
1.306389451,
-0.2580631673,
0.5369250178,
0.5473569036,
-0.2990346551,
0.3458856344,
0.9088097215,
-0.0716225281,
0.2077155411,
0.3600063622,
-0.1676929146,
-0.3740703166,
-0.3659262657,
-0.1750291586,
0.1135074794,
0.1991201341,
-0.2559924126,
-0.201601699,
-0.045332212,
0.0033326652,
0.1201042756,
-0.2241489291,
0.8842405677,
-0.1711314768,
-0.7393015623,
0.6054076552,
-0.0172454156,
0.9035073519,
-0.195578441,
0.327863574,
-0.5085422397,
-0.1541783214,
-0.3615997434,
-1.0111449957,
0.0748590007,
-0.0551273637,
-0.5820192695,
-0.1498239934,
0.4020842016,
-0.7207686901,
-0.3310534656,
0.0529688708,
0.2637942135,
-0.2241580784,
0.0054708119,
-0.4841549695,
0.2141003907,
0.209543258,
-0.1401423365,
0.4881068766,
0.4379172325,
-0.4508992136,
0.7366608381,
0.6871091127,
0.119161807,
0.2888638675,
0.332095474,
0.9446829557,
-0.5631040931,
-0.5086308718,
-1.2212021351,
0.4938721359,
-0.1696035862,
-0.467995137,
0.5345675349,
0.3350407183,
0.7444298267,
0.1725206226,
0.722202599,
0.2797651589,
0.5146237016,
-0.1315272152,
0.3621177971,
-0.5010125041,
0.4206698537,
-0.2427295446,
-0.836771369,
-0.6456888914,
0.3024845123,
-0.2097778171,
0.0560856834,
0.131962046,
0.943413794,
0.0866018012,
0.0752175525,
0.1198515743,
0.0409689993,
0.4622886777,
0.350589931,
0.8037524819,
0.1174492985,
0.4505682588,
-0.0912827775,
-0.4164414406,
-0.4825143814,
-0.6876965761,
-0.6676037908,
-0.4178311527,
-0.2177878171,
-0.2422043085,
-0.3605384827,
1.1600564718,
0.678704679,
-0.9960989356,
-0.2411705703,
0.1071417183,
0.3115481138,
-0.0007702203,
-0.1709248722,
0.0162185524,
-0.5108059049,
-0.7277678847,
0.0230572242,
0.3238525987,
0.1771168113,
-0.3478967547,
-0.282443285,
0.1107380241,
0.0206406955,
0.3421080112,
0.3161861002,
-0.8961291909,
-0.3637528121,
0.1074765325,
-0.3369582295,
0.2202896327,
0.7721807361,
-0.4212593436,
0.5851047039,
0.7210483551,
0.8759390116,
-0.1327341944,
0.1675963998,
0.7527421713,
-0.9628647566,
0.0341482908,
0.2481055558,
0.2434020489,
0.4630775154,
-0.4597114325,
0.1672468036,
-0.056164965,
-0.6678705215,
-0.8125445843,
0.506732285,
-1.0356109142,
-0.16988267,
1.3811883926,
0.2286946028,
0.0939467996,
-0.0201094132,
-0.4547609091,
0.13918899,
-0.629273653,
0.9425189495,
0.8381665945,
-0.2174476236,
-0.1330547631,
-0.0804885253,
0.5160055161,
0.8130981326,
-0.8060837388,
0.3883373439,
0.5139114857,
0.2788716853,
0.2252957225,
0.3368443847,
0.061290402,
0.1618313789,
-0.4955165982,
0.0581029616,
0.2928519547,
-0.0208820011,
-0.8302114606,
-0.0792515799,
0.4246613979,
0.1004846543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11123v1
|
Granular Change Accuracy: A More Accurate Performance Metric for Dialogue State Tracking
| 2024-03-17T07:07:44 | 2024-03-17T07:07:44 |
Taha Aksu, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current metrics for evaluating Dialogue State Tracking (DST) systems exhibit
three primary limitations. They: i) erroneously presume a uniform distribution
of slots throughout the dialog, ii) neglect to assign partial scores for
individual turns, iii) frequently overestimate or underestimate performance by
repeatedly counting the models' successful or failed predictions. To address
these shortcomings, we introduce a novel metric: Granular Change Accuracy
(GCA). GCA focuses on evaluating the predicted changes in dialogue state over
the entire dialogue history. Benchmarking reveals that GCA effectively reduces
biases arising from distribution uniformity and the positioning of errors
across turns, resulting in a more precise evaluation. Notably, we find that
these biases are particularly pronounced when evaluating few-shot or zero-shot
trained models, becoming even more evident as the model's error rate increases.
Hence, GCA offers significant promise, particularly for assessing models
trained with limited resources. Our GCA implementation is a useful addition to
the pool of DST metrics.
|
[
-0.2711167634,
-0.6728362441,
0.770332098,
0.0112051591,
-0.1768303066,
0.1659981608,
0.0534547083,
-0.4184467196,
0.1216471046,
0.1192461923,
-0.6144585609,
-0.4463846385,
-0.7279192209,
-0.2494069189,
-0.4043216407,
1.143355608,
-0.0200837329,
0.201015383,
-0.0828181952,
-0.1178472042,
-0.6213361025,
-0.3848114014,
-0.5530734658,
-0.4165527225,
0.3077962995,
-0.1606494933,
0.9402139187,
0.2167299092,
0.3949543536,
0.2589260936,
-0.5011164546,
0.2281891257,
-0.3977594376,
-0.1575110853,
-0.15931952,
-0.4717880487,
-0.7176883817,
-0.0892034918,
0.6967838407,
0.513853848,
-0.3456654251,
0.0684248209,
0.0069533275,
0.5079625249,
-0.6405056715,
0.4004019201,
-0.7300943732,
-0.0492864065,
-0.1369403005,
-0.3317959309,
-0.1722946614,
-0.4603510499,
0.2461064607,
-0.5776662827,
0.3875119984,
-0.5374952555,
0.7412383556,
0.4509454966,
-0.3446916938,
-0.5028767586,
-0.8899763227,
0.7088612318,
-0.8459029198,
0.1195897907,
0.2291543186,
0.5865357518,
-0.2259629816,
-0.5420429111,
-0.3093420267,
-0.2880153656,
0.2005382627,
0.1414051503,
-0.086764425,
0.2680530548,
0.3142562211,
0.3904983103,
0.0603607334,
-0.2236829251,
-0.2677689195,
-0.3920632005,
0.5941451788,
0.7459475398,
0.0406495668,
0.0822528526,
-0.1209780797,
-0.1054933369,
-0.1119974256,
0.2865999937,
0.392309159,
0.4404457211,
0.0711597949,
0.0631286055,
-0.4635912776,
0.7884190679,
0.4206136763,
-0.5401243567,
0.2123150527,
-0.5216823816,
-0.1891769916,
-0.121201463,
0.4201673269,
0.3127105832,
-0.3745412529,
0.0399640873,
-0.2502511442,
0.2116427571,
0.6347402334,
-0.8275854588,
-0.2076505423,
-0.0035700947,
-0.123171851,
-0.3100661933,
0.1108004525,
-0.4826706052,
-0.3141883612,
-0.3154062629,
0.5042567849,
-0.4354954362,
-0.0468362793,
0.1624730825,
0.1438006461,
0.045869071,
0.9996623993,
-0.9638677835,
0.4959846735,
0.8439611793,
1.336348772,
-0.1643599719,
-0.0817669705,
-0.4722552299,
-0.2090075314,
-0.6380363703,
0.8497515321,
-0.6564436555,
-0.5881195068,
-0.2522147,
-0.2215962857,
-0.2232672423,
-0.5467859507,
0.4306835234,
-0.195318684,
-0.0090850703,
-0.4092527628,
-0.5433910489,
-0.127873823,
0.3206433654,
-0.3736522496,
0.9999080896,
0.2784883082,
-0.454279542,
0.6708808541,
-0.7436332703,
0.0103526944,
-0.1913427114,
-0.1092728004,
-0.4559855461,
0.4021494985,
0.13525258,
-0.0635446534,
0.0807192847,
0.4186767638,
-0.2503827214,
-0.6846398115,
0.2152038962,
-0.7890459299,
0.3370884657,
0.0912555754,
-0.1648112386,
-0.0360683091,
-0.4612602293,
0.2054665834,
-0.4556878805,
-0.3379024565,
-0.0127314227,
0.0495418645,
-0.1958387941,
0.0670595393,
0.1465536952,
-0.4344748259,
0.3366403282,
0.0002837859,
0.1058867872,
0.794207871,
0.0459968485,
0.3920163512,
-0.5021720529,
0.5393661261,
0.2126178294,
0.350260675,
-0.091363132,
-0.6445648074,
-0.4921166301,
-0.257402122,
0.3528963327,
0.3281425536,
-0.4447810948,
0.2270663828,
-0.3133379519,
-0.614300549,
-0.387286365,
-0.1209917739,
0.2518619001,
0.3367669582,
0.2841244638,
-0.9306138754,
0.0328950807,
-0.42553249,
-0.4264132679,
-0.2710745633,
-0.0012520578,
0.4206199348,
0.6090017557,
-0.1700167209,
1.1491088867,
-0.6032800078,
-0.3541031182,
0.026612727,
0.4502252936,
0.1003188714,
0.3307238221,
0.3804509044,
-0.4871284068,
-0.4662261009,
0.1185517907,
-0.3168541193,
-0.2519440353,
-0.3047883213,
0.2004736662,
0.2138186693,
0.1383365244,
-0.4192107618,
0.8663778901,
0.6336343288,
-0.3111187816,
0.8488222957,
-0.1179307699,
0.5652114153,
-0.7216569185,
-0.1366084516,
-0.2070505172,
-0.3551612198,
-0.6782594919,
-0.4632984102,
0.1427975446,
0.0633760914,
-0.5643536448,
0.4562712908,
-0.069505617,
-0.4265966117,
-0.1851675808,
0.1115535349,
-0.0571894795,
0.4352991879,
-0.2109274119,
1.1434960365,
0.4031280577,
-0.7150503993,
0.309186399,
0.4747053385,
-0.6838434339,
1.0900644064,
-0.3973511457,
0.3080232143,
0.1362323165,
0.8041572571,
-0.724758327,
-0.1735352427,
0.0049343565,
-0.3889344931,
0.079010047,
-0.429382503,
-0.0530539788,
-0.0179933384,
-0.1086703762,
0.3603506386,
0.2921642363,
-0.2814832628,
0.4053069949,
0.1805179864,
-0.1993662566,
-0.4831704795,
-0.5009024143,
0.160693109,
-0.0296525527,
-0.5221031904,
0.3275826573,
-0.0611442663,
-0.1035802141,
-0.1455034018,
-0.6156659722,
-0.3089257181,
-0.0099765472,
0.0830433145,
0.0368182026,
0.000997874,
0.3101169765,
-0.0587349795,
-0.2319406122,
-0.2206285149,
-0.228380233,
0.6956344843,
-0.2590966523,
-0.5660113096,
-0.945849359,
0.0592161492,
0.5176892281,
0.3028854132,
0.5113639235,
0.5686291456,
-0.1066137999,
0.1863451153,
-0.4445783198,
-0.0227549523,
-0.395290494,
0.5039497018,
-0.4754058123,
-0.4992688298,
0.6658173203,
0.0262524113,
0.0370883048,
0.2526810467,
0.3208883405,
0.0939489603,
1.2801185846,
0.5299915671,
0.0122244135,
0.8541432023,
-0.0992277041,
0.1701621562,
-1.0646858215,
-0.0801776201,
-0.5955432057,
-0.3005263507,
-0.4685463607,
-0.6743662953,
0.5619889498,
0.1260166466,
-0.1013396904,
0.2399170697,
-0.1589745134,
0.4032342434,
0.2645576894,
0.0604220144,
0.6026926041,
-0.2396472543,
0.3007413149,
-0.1498406231,
-0.3884862959,
-0.6471401453,
1.0194460154,
0.2771658897,
1.0491857529,
0.1175515726,
0.593906641,
0.4611033797,
0.1004011557,
-0.9194979668,
0.3763848543,
-0.0621364266,
-0.5315361619,
-0.3685827553,
-0.6717391014,
-0.5061935186,
0.3586818576,
0.1883435398,
-1.0171496868,
-0.0089399721,
0.3667418361,
-0.5767768025,
0.6095819473,
-0.4618849158,
0.7375150323,
0.0020007514,
0.0401451737,
-0.3766889572,
-0.1734287143,
-0.0320823155,
-0.1134021506,
-0.2825084329,
-0.40041399,
-0.0793709308,
0.5889055133,
-0.4873847067,
0.8460531235,
-0.3268917501,
-0.0992349759,
0.2937081158,
0.2561125755,
0.6902104616,
0.0692995861,
-0.0363429785,
0.3114804327,
0.3504860699,
-0.6178605556,
-0.7888602018,
0.4331817031,
-0.6445431113,
-0.4683345854,
-0.6876897812,
-0.858527422,
-0.4552158713,
-0.304713428,
0.1255246252,
0.7921158075,
-0.5580807328,
-0.0466541424,
0.4392198026,
-0.0544345677,
0.2609889805,
0.4019316137,
-0.1202611476,
-0.2109784335,
0.5845199823,
0.382925868,
0.8489897847,
0.0734957159,
0.0298541263,
-0.3768241704,
-0.7831126451,
-0.6698958278,
-0.1581999511,
-0.5432299972,
-0.1314534694,
-0.6066889167,
-0.1306188554,
-0.3462675512,
-0.2626136541,
-0.5009578466,
-0.4110830128,
-0.1710453928,
0.1556114256,
0.1208403036,
0.935754776,
-0.0399389975,
0.7739370465,
-0.5954256058,
0.0328994356,
0.487793535,
0.5782011747,
-0.4304400086,
-0.9105570316,
-0.2662047446,
0.3773807883,
-0.7989087701,
-0.5517434478,
0.1252096742,
0.262329489,
0.2788217068,
0.202888608,
-0.3312704265,
1.1627372503,
-0.1775462478,
1.0505473614,
0.3192591965,
-1.3344919682,
0.5857610703,
-0.4196410477,
0.8436755538,
0.6546301246,
-0.2811921537,
-0.8448845744,
-0.4086470604,
-0.8139343262,
-0.2624233663,
1.1179125309,
0.1560560912,
0.2818374336,
0.2253575623,
0.0073228846,
0.1304993182,
0.3208760619,
-0.1890928149,
0.1445628852,
-0.0313646831,
0.0581895895,
-0.0383236222,
-0.0860217437,
-0.1544276625,
-0.0169958863,
0.8432062268,
-0.5432778597,
0.2611830533,
0.2338668853,
-0.0960436985,
-0.1165830791,
0.3537570238,
0.8000892401,
1.0764502287,
-0.338178426,
-0.4118539691,
0.6979215741,
-0.6703073382,
0.0266494714,
-0.3439192474,
-0.4893145859,
0.2286913991,
0.067835778,
0.9674258828,
0.1441576481,
-0.2430127859,
0.552292645,
-0.0906117558,
-0.0099743735,
-0.1715244502,
0.2779386342,
-0.4102532268,
0.2735911608,
0.1724465638,
0.7190030813,
0.2524390519,
-0.6887060404,
0.0794594288,
0.4438815117,
-1.0020025969,
-0.3822426498,
0.1949992478,
0.27623716,
-0.403534025,
0.2370304763,
-0.3629677892,
-0.4032336473,
0.5681381822,
0.2882827222,
0.8972808123,
-0.3699384928,
0.8358203173,
0.3238085508,
0.0227154009,
-0.3920269012,
-0.0972177833,
-0.212697342,
-0.7167884707,
-0.3985627294,
-0.5147304535,
-0.8664522171,
0.1011449546,
-0.9307998419,
0.2141982317,
-0.5379570127,
-0.583260119,
-0.159205243,
0.1683683097,
-0.5812032223,
0.2336316407,
0.0445140935,
0.8392854929,
-0.8126650453,
0.5812770128,
0.3284449279,
-0.0572084822,
-0.4985868335,
0.1959187537,
0.4206349552,
-0.582347393,
0.0812680423,
0.1650555432,
-0.3906961679,
-0.4558568001,
-0.3325772285,
-0.8052636981,
1.1815177202,
0.2330822051,
-0.6168004274,
0.037939854,
-0.0186312497,
0.7259628773,
-0.4336687624,
0.7584030628,
1.0902013779,
0.2456877232,
0.1671842635,
-1.4392379522,
-0.4667412639,
0.231554389,
0.3289157152,
0.5072824359,
-0.7370217443,
0.6970659494,
-0.144718796,
-0.3678480685,
0.2573578656,
0.2835474014,
-0.0064144325,
0.5066568255,
0.5834879279,
0.5935256481,
1.0120005608,
-0.6513167024,
0.9634009004,
0.1710453629,
0.695726037,
1.1973206997,
-0.2042896897,
0.4439814687,
0.2673686147,
-0.4269129038,
0.4878475964,
0.4700093269,
0.3152396679,
0.5658682585,
-0.0533560477,
-0.5100029111,
-0.2002664059,
-0.1257113218,
-0.3987481594,
0.4624846876,
0.3626260161,
-0.0439344123,
-0.2952189744,
-0.296539247,
0.3002950251,
-0.1493000984,
-0.3313778043,
0.9770542979,
-0.1568254828,
-0.5970791578,
0.459138453,
-0.3883933127,
0.4389768839,
-0.7762333751,
0.1023167223,
-0.3444529772,
0.3027510643,
-0.14848575,
-0.6294434667,
0.40279001,
0.0299574789,
-0.0075691701,
-0.1618795395,
0.1533857882,
-0.272772342,
-0.4753445089,
0.1007460579,
0.3250229955,
0.170981586,
-0.1232626364,
-0.8264735341,
0.1766462475,
0.2030264437,
-0.0898296982,
0.3110301793,
0.2849483192,
-0.10717123,
0.606957674,
0.4992490709,
0.4475124776,
-0.0001723846,
0.2655654848,
0.6964223981,
-0.676117599,
-0.72677356,
-0.3839570582,
0.4704980552,
-0.3428015709,
-0.7499998212,
0.107309103,
0.216209203,
0.8768251538,
0.2320562303,
0.8461577296,
-0.1756755263,
0.4369075298,
-0.5407206416,
0.1759934276,
-0.2707894444,
0.2694714069,
-0.4314188957,
-1.0957713127,
0.0351692438,
0.471483767,
-0.6418913007,
0.1751769483,
0.8944997787,
1.0611057281,
-0.0895028338,
0.2979051173,
0.7287894487,
0.2720010579,
0.7339239717,
0.4489204586,
0.9296244383,
-0.695057869,
0.5584059358,
-0.2068554014,
-0.3210730553,
-0.2886175513,
-0.7041302919,
-0.494373709,
-0.4854536653,
-0.4649564624,
-0.2650220096,
0.1974348575,
0.7201558948,
0.9024794102,
-0.9725042582,
-0.1156322733,
0.0456374884,
-0.251565218,
-0.5050563216,
-0.1769381016,
0.006719429,
-0.625870347,
-0.9354003668,
0.3366089761,
0.545091331,
0.1069054902,
-0.1051441953,
-0.2262791991,
0.1476620138,
0.3198714852,
0.2701063752,
0.0880606398,
-0.8686056137,
-0.7596591115,
-0.4408648014,
-0.2524801493,
0.2171956599,
0.9200725555,
-0.7036803365,
0.7576428652,
0.3725423813,
0.3776209056,
0.7530610561,
0.3863994777,
0.4415551126,
-0.4994120002,
0.0480401553,
0.1875389665,
0.1414857805,
0.4565070271,
-0.1695942581,
0.5962383151,
0.2477155328,
-0.6985042095,
-0.7101752162,
0.4369614124,
-0.9726617336,
0.2294902056,
0.9359158874,
-0.2058204859,
0.0251277238,
-0.2657164931,
-0.5061625242,
-0.0263312515,
-0.7259175777,
1.1214127541,
0.8444414735,
-0.279648751,
0.2548655272,
-0.6200946569,
0.6755745411,
0.4144947529,
-0.8302772641,
-0.0371654034,
0.5561187267,
0.3852258027,
0.4605748951,
0.8934502602,
-0.2126675695,
0.4129772186,
0.2430303246,
-0.2801850438,
0.2217267901,
-0.4043099284,
-0.4687880576,
-0.2288255841,
-0.1563728601,
-0.1524037272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11108v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11108v1
|
HarmPot: An Annotation Framework for Evaluating Offline Harm Potential of Social Media Text
| 2024-03-17T06:23:25 | 2024-03-17T06:23:25 |
Ritesh Kumar, Ojaswee Bhalla, Madhu Vanthi, Shehlat Maknoon Wani, Siddharth Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we discuss the development of an annotation schema to build
datasets for evaluating the offline harm potential of social media texts. We
define "harm potential" as the potential for an online public post to cause
real-world physical harm (i.e., violence). Understanding that real-world
violence is often spurred by a web of triggers, often combining several online
tactics and pre-existing intersectional fissures in the social milieu, to
result in targeted physical violence, we do not focus on any single divisive
aspect (i.e., caste, gender, religion, or other identities of the victim and
perpetrators) nor do we focus on just hate speech or mis/dis-information.
Rather, our understanding of the intersectional causes of such triggers focuses
our attempt at measuring the harm potential of online content, irrespective of
whether it is hateful or not. In this paper, we discuss the development of a
framework/annotation schema that allows annotating the data with different
aspects of the text including its socio-political grounding and intent of the
speaker (as expressed through mood and modality) that together contribute to it
being a trigger for offline harm. We also give a comparative analysis and
mapping of our framework with some of the existing frameworks.
|
[
-0.2962747514,
-0.9808990359,
0.2881734371,
0.1825474948,
-0.240923956,
-0.1885100156,
-0.1433653384,
-0.5550864339,
0.4877821505,
0.3016912639,
-0.4814217687,
-0.4026643932,
-0.7081418633,
0.1109852865,
-0.358681649,
0.8908880949,
0.1166018099,
-0.0740389749,
0.0353531875,
0.1193137988,
-0.5384396911,
-0.4348242879,
-0.3817618191,
0.327311337,
0.9067918062,
0.4128436148,
0.3869444132,
0.4285355806,
1.1585690975,
0.2286592871,
-0.0531881675,
-0.2196708918,
-0.9097110629,
0.4276805222,
-0.2166150957,
-0.403765887,
-0.1036494523,
0.1419437081,
0.1388419867,
0.4781929553,
0.20721367,
0.3151534796,
-0.2305383831,
0.3436519802,
-0.8324229717,
-0.2100142986,
-0.614993155,
0.3690054417,
-0.3242248893,
-0.377810955,
-0.4052220285,
-0.6748700738,
-0.1593018919,
-0.6361029744,
-0.1758244187,
0.2049512714,
0.6874002218,
0.5126360655,
-0.4683000445,
-0.1913412213,
-0.8802059889,
0.515833497,
-0.3023894429,
0.0746235028,
0.7506492138,
0.5917695165,
0.0369461998,
-0.4433093667,
-0.644897759,
0.1838978678,
-0.066268377,
0.1311120391,
-0.217888698,
0.0424942821,
0.434325397,
0.470408529,
-0.2887838781,
-0.0093452046,
-0.4107183814,
0.0413790084,
0.8790124059,
0.2229457498,
0.6136536002,
-0.4866732955,
-0.4188246429,
0.0668722838,
-0.7264397144,
-0.0477521084,
0.8129830956,
0.545748651,
-0.174490124,
0.7085545063,
0.3091911376,
0.6459975243,
0.0916272253,
-0.191396907,
0.1019145325,
-0.3129403591,
0.0777955204,
0.3340735734,
1.0001256466,
1.0307335854,
0.1992684454,
-0.0985247344,
0.3899444044,
0.1956633925,
0.7724457383,
-1.0594314337,
-0.2171557397,
0.3865090013,
-0.5910028815,
-0.7844741344,
0.2008517832,
-1.0357499123,
-1.0285867453,
0.1376907825,
0.3939571381,
-0.3077682257,
-0.4658515155,
-0.3601803184,
-0.415201962,
-0.1783117056,
-0.0114482576,
-0.8402341604,
0.0651912466,
0.3505905867,
1.1903979778,
-0.1171215028,
-0.0448057726,
-0.2373395562,
0.082656078,
-0.2167853862,
0.9656763673,
-0.532895565,
-0.2587590814,
0.405647248,
0.052541174,
0.3028429151,
-0.2727015615,
0.9402213693,
-0.4324903488,
0.0449257344,
-0.6857903004,
-0.4871760607,
-0.508322835,
0.1936330795,
-0.8225416541,
1.0207720995,
0.0939469561,
-1.1670311689,
0.7749604583,
-1.1033444405,
-0.6746100187,
0.0983972475,
0.0721308365,
-0.4842873514,
-0.2482811213,
-0.4450984001,
0.7219243646,
-0.3005217016,
0.1579595208,
-0.73073107,
-0.4076982737,
0.2892410755,
-0.030474497,
0.8963933587,
0.0566334724,
-0.70058465,
0.4803916812,
-0.8691068888,
-0.1820881069,
0.2872561216,
0.0389706865,
-0.7724300027,
0.1771829128,
0.5540699363,
0.536031127,
-0.26789397,
-0.8704970479,
-0.0432458855,
-0.3076405823,
0.4634150565,
0.5962300301,
0.2568196356,
0.1996195912,
-0.3759215176,
0.3678319454,
-0.2144913077,
0.3955215514,
-0.026275225,
-0.4321281314,
-0.1054070592,
-0.3915634453,
0.1919388175,
0.5801773071,
-0.3760729134,
0.6177075505,
-0.1185559332,
-0.7563381791,
-0.3048388958,
-0.245289281,
0.1838234961,
0.2134087384,
0.5078820586,
-0.1777888536,
-0.9356660247,
-0.7109154463,
-0.3873449266,
-0.4034987688,
-0.0091803866,
0.1385480613,
0.2331625223,
-0.0515477359,
1.2560963631,
-0.3488764763,
-0.7669328451,
-0.2460088134,
0.2886875868,
-0.4211222231,
0.0535688438,
0.5102481842,
-1.1775465012,
-0.6639212966,
-0.2326483577,
-1.0502941608,
-0.7118042707,
-0.1572167575,
-0.2884807885,
-0.3649924099,
0.1796498001,
-0.4187318981,
0.7891107798,
0.3010563552,
-0.4041243494,
0.2515776455,
0.4912885427,
0.7305361629,
-1.2306673527,
0.1912014782,
0.0220169704,
0.0698877797,
-0.8751425743,
-0.1094343662,
-0.1927509606,
-0.1617446542,
-0.8630954623,
0.1984197795,
-0.0147092137,
0.1694418788,
-0.2357561737,
0.3787142634,
-0.0972628742,
0.1056175008,
-0.2358197868,
0.4718118012,
0.1738711447,
-0.2094226778,
0.4390276372,
0.4292525947,
-0.0990453213,
0.9147241712,
-0.4387123287,
-0.117161721,
0.0229649749,
0.0894175619,
-0.8061907887,
-0.4902850986,
0.797031939,
-0.301526159,
-0.0927841738,
-0.2632872164,
-0.6025192738,
-0.1357092261,
-0.5641002655,
0.547521472,
0.0291636121,
-0.1795596778,
0.2905550897,
1.0546170473,
-0.1461191475,
-0.1088477895,
-0.6618305445,
0.3466938138,
-0.6911558509,
-0.5688652992,
0.3828625083,
0.0554603487,
-0.7770804763,
-0.1748046428,
0.6217060089,
-0.139156118,
0.03703833,
1.0170109272,
-0.2563275695,
0.4140948951,
0.3643201888,
0.1902784556,
-0.1503342837,
0.210189864,
0.3030759394,
0.43553707,
0.2164753824,
-0.2339872569,
-0.3876652122,
0.677559793,
0.1782047749,
0.0382290706,
0.7966836691,
0.3751550317,
-0.5817981362,
0.2053805888,
-0.2375515401,
-0.0727064013,
-0.3435227275,
0.022010209,
0.0697914138,
-0.6641604304,
0.6053536534,
-0.1192538291,
0.0674752221,
0.4846022725,
0.7761573792,
0.1089413911,
0.5437116027,
0.6141252518,
0.2788386941,
0.5929385424,
-0.0653014854,
0.4191148877,
-0.3623440266,
-0.2073266506,
-0.3044326305,
-0.2578716278,
-0.4795996845,
-0.3106767833,
0.1969408989,
0.0486234389,
-0.1825411916,
0.554521203,
-0.7402214408,
0.2973792851,
0.2502620518,
0.0052830642,
0.194960922,
-0.0176422689,
0.1212117299,
-0.3650488257,
-0.5840846896,
-0.7313783169,
1.0550479889,
0.3537481725,
0.5144841075,
0.3858054578,
0.3561256528,
0.673815608,
0.6527747512,
-0.7519666553,
0.3365736902,
0.5119428039,
-1.2349488735,
-0.4462582469,
-0.2298082262,
-0.9744272828,
0.1791009158,
-0.32280159,
-0.9373163581,
0.1010372713,
0.172705248,
-0.4984722435,
0.5957568884,
-0.5724034309,
0.9501840472,
-0.3160253465,
-0.6144613028,
0.0797251686,
-0.82554245,
0.2498086095,
-0.4440874159,
0.5501876473,
-0.2020990551,
0.1710703671,
0.9242312312,
-0.552310586,
1.2261840105,
-0.22569561,
-0.0332267731,
0.5743501186,
-0.029922137,
0.0405373871,
-0.2953560352,
-0.0140806055,
0.6474841833,
0.0463128872,
-0.1372894198,
-0.3081020713,
0.4822570086,
-0.4856576622,
-0.0949397311,
-0.5556384325,
-0.3368117809,
0.0628425032,
0.4597089887,
0.4457994699,
0.0622278303,
-0.4538859129,
0.0343555287,
0.3046089411,
-0.1106265336,
0.5324539542,
0.0822526589,
-0.3416414261,
-0.5133745074,
0.9011452198,
0.358048588,
-0.0764729008,
0.3008704782,
0.1783005893,
-0.2295403332,
-0.2071737498,
-0.480738312,
-0.278208226,
-0.8249043822,
-0.4261334538,
-0.7171047926,
0.2603112459,
-0.2867477536,
-0.2894047201,
-0.2460367978,
-0.1176747233,
-0.1883583516,
-0.2141076177,
0.7718891501,
0.8130759001,
-0.3992245495,
0.5574540496,
-0.4985035956,
0.2322782427,
0.0760403946,
0.4919951856,
-0.3537093103,
-0.2540484071,
-0.2604241371,
0.1031901985,
-0.5249692202,
-1.6346827745,
0.0489567779,
-0.0378644578,
0.1318436116,
0.6788768172,
0.7259750366,
0.6210589409,
-0.6139680743,
0.8608429432,
0.316404283,
-0.6734435558,
0.7203599215,
-0.6402965188,
-0.3323673308,
0.8475611806,
0.8059536219,
-0.7870664001,
-0.295617938,
-0.6503710151,
-0.9736959338,
0.373819828,
0.4097398221,
0.0874705687,
-0.2601837516,
0.1484748721,
0.3804985881,
0.2278502733,
-0.9214642048,
-0.3404462337,
-0.4115848839,
-0.1576450765,
0.2817855775,
-0.4042004645,
-0.3564831614,
-0.0699642971,
0.6019119024,
0.1528683454,
0.5070795417,
-0.0286588725,
-0.1509417146,
-0.7971910238,
-0.0556363501,
0.3297715485,
0.5959882736,
-0.262244463,
0.2363694757,
0.0272976868,
-0.536550045,
0.2402841598,
0.1906371266,
-0.2833915353,
-0.0198525637,
0.4631280899,
0.614341855,
0.4816158116,
-0.5689288974,
0.8732408285,
-0.0375722274,
-0.0507066734,
-0.5444310904,
-0.2599619329,
-0.2103829533,
0.1646836698,
0.4518434703,
-0.1925991178,
0.3437031209,
-0.3512528837,
0.3391245604,
0.1562845707,
-0.5967444181,
-0.3519838154,
0.7026458383,
0.3360252976,
-0.7981725931,
-0.3453566134,
-0.2759587467,
-0.6965187192,
0.0466877446,
0.2544736862,
0.7854047418,
-0.3131155074,
0.3225322664,
0.2264168859,
0.4252152741,
0.537584722,
0.277618587,
0.0457406677,
-0.3399769664,
-0.2967610657,
-0.4945774078,
-0.3294953108,
0.1843078136,
-0.4874910712,
0.4532678425,
-0.5646724701,
-0.480370909,
0.164063856,
-0.1022155061,
-0.1398975998,
0.3578103185,
-0.0644172728,
0.4428175688,
-1.0315709114,
-0.0108507732,
0.5722261667,
-0.6953077912,
-0.6606323123,
0.3528242111,
0.2140259445,
-0.1820602119,
0.572935462,
0.3902426064,
0.0291121397,
-0.1758398861,
-0.3718312383,
-0.6357324123,
0.6484203935,
0.2282007039,
-0.3340188265,
0.3442558944,
0.5706939101,
0.6743144393,
-0.097552292,
0.4476445019,
-0.0453756936,
0.5628569126,
0.0080855759,
-0.6700049043,
0.3910152316,
-0.4568305314,
-0.2900479734,
0.5673555732,
-0.5525099635,
0.3205845654,
0.0510950983,
-0.3482173383,
-0.5645987391,
0.2271273285,
-0.3043889105,
0.4678884745,
0.500859797,
0.4756338,
0.164545238,
-0.1561210901,
0.8883635998,
-0.1606814265,
0.4544295073,
0.7766567469,
-0.1781346202,
0.8135282993,
0.5584533811,
-0.3117258251,
0.3615188897,
0.9470068812,
0.0001961874,
0.5475862026,
0.3167013824,
-0.0857018232,
-0.1870350987,
-0.333272934,
-0.4889868498,
0.528205514,
0.1136960089,
-0.5095723867,
-0.1424117982,
0.3211857378,
0.233114168,
0.1014462486,
-0.032749597,
0.9179549813,
0.0102226045,
-0.201315552,
0.241852358,
0.1489100158,
0.4428206384,
-0.1727049053,
-0.1025217846,
0.3878440857,
-0.1810631156,
-0.4206356406,
-0.6888802052,
0.7899505496,
0.1507506669,
-0.1901922673,
-0.1062133983,
1.0472151041,
-0.1213352904,
-0.4293694496,
0.4155493677,
0.2176123112,
0.3636319339,
-0.2638678849,
-0.5031642318,
0.3650725186,
-0.43556723,
-0.1832481772,
0.3455733061,
0.48428002,
-0.1302549541,
0.2985968888,
0.8252404928,
0.0874196887,
-0.0303469189,
0.0297819823,
0.8700915575,
-0.5171710849,
-0.6949895024,
-0.8842454553,
0.7035710216,
-0.526740253,
-0.5955001116,
0.8531252742,
0.4910163283,
0.6307718754,
0.3068060279,
0.9932509065,
-0.5928832293,
0.7043649554,
-0.0098549938,
1.0070250034,
-0.4347960055,
-0.0208251122,
-0.936763227,
-0.8857679963,
-0.7144908905,
0.8987493515,
-0.8032135963,
-0.0793429166,
0.5482177734,
0.5253944993,
0.1681137532,
0.366627723,
0.3808660805,
0.1532528996,
0.1112952083,
-0.0659442544,
0.9010990858,
-0.5867447853,
0.5847783685,
-0.4456433058,
-0.4913740456,
-0.5779262781,
-1.0256316662,
-1.257499218,
-0.7768971324,
-0.288911581,
-0.2698571384,
0.0078266338,
0.9313185811,
0.475936532,
-0.5855946541,
0.144766897,
0.0266179424,
-0.1053925753,
0.0782774016,
-0.2603492737,
0.2700692713,
0.1093260869,
-0.2862167656,
-0.1481729597,
0.546335578,
-0.2103418857,
-0.3142723739,
0.1678791493,
-0.4463319182,
-0.0316837244,
0.852560401,
0.084287934,
-0.5361568928,
-0.5029438734,
-0.2478169054,
0.0839670673,
-0.0660490841,
0.8352755308,
-0.1611427665,
0.5059079528,
0.3049466908,
0.462025106,
-0.0405132845,
-0.0075646001,
0.2247212082,
-0.6748947501,
0.1456381828,
0.2359682173,
0.1281990558,
0.5090376735,
-0.7621797919,
0.4135248065,
0.3970191777,
-0.4557743967,
-1.0769668818,
0.2676923573,
-0.7751241922,
-0.1796586066,
1.428191185,
-0.3298835456,
-0.0420644619,
-0.5017884374,
-0.6703365445,
0.6683906317,
-0.3196851313,
1.2802129984,
0.5905560851,
0.0027503869,
-0.0955256149,
-0.4676819742,
0.6340047121,
0.10263744,
-1.1844143867,
0.2137436569,
0.4987526834,
-0.187481463,
0.5210359097,
0.3965269327,
0.0971333236,
0.1186672151,
0.2350088358,
0.2892368138,
-0.0761585906,
-0.2512916923,
0.0104716374,
0.5936493874,
-0.3763416409,
0.0015573762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11103v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11103v2
|
ProgGen: Generating Named Entity Recognition Datasets Step-by-step with Self-Reflexive Large Language Models
| 2024-03-17T06:12:43 | 2024-06-09T04:48:35 |
Yuzhao Heng, Chunyuan Deng, Yitong Li, Yue Yu, Yinghao Li, Rongzhi Zhang, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable adaptability across
domains, these models often fall short in structured knowledge extraction tasks
such as named entity recognition (NER). This paper explores an innovative,
cost-efficient strategy to harness LLMs with modest NER capabilities for
producing superior NER datasets. Our approach diverges from the basic
class-conditional prompts by instructing LLMs to self-reflect on the specific
domain, thereby generating domain-relevant attributes (such as category and
emotions for movie reviews), which are utilized for creating attribute-rich
training data. Furthermore, we preemptively generate entity terms and then
develop NER context data around these entities, effectively bypassing the LLMs'
challenges with complex structures. Our experiments across both general and
niche domains reveal significant performance enhancements over conventional
data generation methods while being more cost-effective than existing
alternatives.
|
[
-0.4656558037,
-0.2536587119,
0.4361112714,
-0.1011148691,
-0.178189218,
-0.0460918695,
-0.2721180916,
-0.354362011,
0.4012083411,
0.5473818183,
-0.5120825768,
-0.3229269385,
-0.2855744958,
0.2800684571,
-0.3024675548,
1.022536397,
0.1509310156,
-0.1288249344,
-0.2262485921,
0.0436364338,
-0.1692143083,
-0.535166502,
-0.7000502944,
-0.1873230338,
0.7401973605,
0.4727799296,
0.2238538861,
0.3614438176,
0.4559352994,
0.2474559993,
0.4001453817,
0.3679927886,
-0.2936393619,
0.1767293662,
-0.2423463762,
-0.1874567568,
-0.4327132106,
0.0562437512,
0.6686665416,
0.36737746,
-0.0979151502,
0.1994049102,
0.1373501271,
0.571405828,
-0.6515802145,
0.1659567505,
-0.8164848685,
-0.0292587727,
-0.3767569661,
-0.0357318036,
-0.3602296412,
-0.2314844579,
0.310406357,
-0.6209446788,
0.4154669642,
0.0983498096,
0.9433037043,
-0.0274451599,
-0.1743858904,
-0.2405326217,
-0.5818805695,
0.6262010336,
-0.710950315,
0.5537506342,
0.0351426862,
0.2713447809,
-0.3318004608,
-0.8326353431,
-0.780328691,
-0.140393585,
-0.1533886194,
-0.0043347985,
-0.2244531065,
-0.2487603724,
0.1728785783,
0.3151471019,
-0.3112888634,
0.1971925646,
0.0131214336,
-0.0545588657,
0.6612685919,
0.0265979096,
0.205046013,
-0.3486787081,
-0.2447159737,
0.0559105948,
-1.1274670362,
-0.091617316,
0.4385256171,
0.5529175401,
0.4610240161,
0.4308147132,
-0.115404956,
0.4996185899,
0.3981090784,
-0.2415359318,
0.249575302,
0.0558003113,
-0.1283162832,
0.1494665295,
0.8557655215,
0.2203902453,
0.2262360007,
-0.635926187,
-0.4214292169,
-0.3007385731,
0.271121949,
-1.0968178511,
-0.4764899313,
0.0524646901,
-0.1499041915,
-0.1959088147,
-0.210793063,
-0.7763432264,
-0.3604144454,
-0.4626870155,
0.6620439291,
-0.2585253119,
-0.3977275193,
-0.0764911175,
0.2351927608,
0.2333017141,
0.2022039443,
-0.7794628739,
0.2245603949,
0.2752014399,
0.6239693165,
-0.339097023,
0.0815388933,
-0.6928952336,
0.2040599138,
-0.2767933309,
0.8161758184,
-0.5005354881,
-0.3647629917,
-0.1745125055,
0.1203389391,
0.0714245811,
-0.8507204652,
0.1102155298,
-0.7616448998,
0.0408262387,
-0.2964312136,
-0.7000112534,
0.0371992551,
0.2097070068,
-0.7360882759,
0.794934392,
0.1260234118,
-0.8739449978,
0.5281128883,
-0.3850390315,
-0.4017110169,
0.5771604776,
-0.4708959758,
-0.4497861862,
0.159469083,
0.1859133691,
0.7334258556,
-0.4902118146,
0.6500707269,
0.0228077751,
0.1948873997,
0.2053978145,
0.0273970626,
0.1152109876,
0.1140004396,
-0.497377485,
-0.1824541241,
-1.0363692045,
-0.0628794804,
0.4145652354,
-0.4492965937,
-0.579425633,
0.2009534091,
-0.2041867822,
0.0257407892,
-0.048900336,
-0.4425342977,
0.2509834766,
-0.2885788381,
0.1136560366,
0.6286201477,
-0.0044635935,
0.5749970078,
0.3334024549,
0.4057652652,
0.1231802031,
-0.2951755822,
0.1173928306,
-0.0028056982,
-0.9422000051,
-0.4712698162,
0.5967009664,
0.3433302641,
-1.112606883,
0.4519101679,
-0.4076027572,
-0.4374262989,
-0.3218848705,
0.0822116956,
0.4400009513,
0.7949998975,
0.351770848,
-0.40229249,
-0.5905012488,
-1.0558125973,
-0.2996741831,
-0.0073982738,
-0.1495855153,
0.6004132628,
0.4312004149,
-0.1697772145,
1.1842764616,
-0.575959146,
-0.3668095171,
-0.4105160236,
0.0788395554,
0.2382755578,
0.5080925822,
0.3400896788,
-0.7111095786,
-0.2727894783,
-0.2479012311,
-0.7288429737,
-0.1567878425,
-0.2056443691,
-0.2369057685,
-0.0544079468,
0.4163019955,
-0.6018769145,
-0.1208482683,
0.2020836025,
-0.0488501564,
0.6637433767,
0.1132739186,
-0.2328264117,
-1.0404218435,
0.128667444,
0.2173221111,
-0.2230115533,
-0.7979505062,
-0.130105406,
-0.0434971303,
-0.0389913246,
-0.5210704207,
0.8462554812,
-0.9490478635,
-0.0480595902,
-0.1175023764,
0.2222198099,
-0.0874966159,
0.3986780643,
0.4121276736,
0.8878440857,
0.6183755398,
-1.039917469,
0.1958331168,
0.1994727701,
-0.5249703526,
0.4849540889,
-0.5394433737,
0.1161866561,
-0.3064730465,
0.0790469646,
-0.3211852312,
-0.415507257,
0.2293505967,
-0.0541890971,
0.6760661602,
-0.0579028055,
-0.3347459733,
-0.3533308208,
0.0582741499,
0.3606377542,
0.5399016738,
-0.9373309016,
0.8385207653,
0.701194346,
-0.4129413068,
-0.4110676944,
-0.3986161053,
0.3683390617,
-0.396461606,
-0.1494587213,
0.4526338875,
0.1311456263,
-0.0641373023,
-0.0594084375,
-0.1690860242,
0.1773393899,
-0.0155852716,
-0.0196062233,
0.1024743617,
-0.1328607947,
0.4294854403,
-0.2162034512,
-0.0956267789,
0.093306154,
-0.6152141094,
0.317868799,
-0.0290106535,
0.0049186684,
-0.0404157974,
0.2206237614,
0.0366774797,
-0.4233175814,
0.6131061912,
0.4342529178,
-0.4722158909,
-0.5043612719,
-0.688642621,
-0.2937842906,
-0.4783029556,
0.3206076026,
-0.5726259351,
-0.9558030963,
0.308755517,
-0.3547885716,
0.0896384045,
0.3830166757,
0.3783672154,
0.1625390053,
0.72110641,
0.3940531015,
0.1565654725,
0.51093328,
-0.2295182347,
0.6467305422,
-0.8812072873,
-0.3631374836,
-0.1845715791,
-0.2837661505,
-0.4446327686,
-0.269993633,
0.3012333214,
0.1871302575,
-0.2259299308,
0.482339114,
-0.4538845122,
0.6151126623,
0.6362241507,
0.0731128156,
-0.0232865866,
0.1820976287,
0.0089201676,
-0.1476861238,
-0.6944975853,
-0.6837463379,
0.9474871159,
0.0535161085,
0.8459441662,
0.1572260112,
0.990400672,
0.1078123599,
0.6018043756,
-0.7940889001,
0.878813982,
-0.2309455276,
-0.3228435218,
-0.1269709915,
-0.5844331384,
-0.9075393081,
0.1134648025,
-0.3035097122,
-0.5641357899,
0.4750722349,
0.2778984606,
-0.3792468607,
0.3532287478,
-0.5219185948,
0.6365602016,
-0.296279043,
-0.356801182,
0.3346301615,
-0.4470707476,
0.3554959595,
-0.3923213184,
0.0453688502,
-0.1886077523,
-0.0174519699,
0.8687004447,
-0.2745704949,
0.7615103126,
-0.3735427558,
-0.2297446579,
0.590972662,
0.3585413396,
0.5801286697,
0.3043484986,
-0.0182446651,
0.1303896159,
-0.7170577049,
0.0436664671,
-0.514203608,
0.7038555145,
-0.522973597,
-0.6775209904,
-0.1865648776,
-0.3698455691,
-0.3505281508,
0.3306506574,
0.2527028918,
0.7180292606,
-0.2090791315,
-0.0348254219,
0.8827676177,
-0.2600809038,
0.4542616606,
0.6324346662,
-0.0494493656,
-0.5286402106,
1.2261865139,
0.3620747626,
-0.0073309229,
0.3207140267,
-0.0482743531,
-0.3738673031,
-0.3990539908,
-0.4175544679,
0.2992135286,
-0.6493778825,
-0.6517091393,
-1.0472581387,
-0.2109894902,
-0.3264931142,
0.116612047,
-0.3206119537,
-0.3665321767,
-0.4323663712,
-0.2059814036,
0.2850053012,
0.4990138412,
-0.1075012013,
0.3141255379,
-0.8049624562,
0.2814985812,
0.7238004208,
0.3042075038,
0.0899022818,
-0.2347700894,
-0.1630405635,
-0.348544091,
-0.1410031915,
-0.8176296353,
0.5696066022,
0.6634987593,
0.6300788522,
0.2949320376,
0.1044281572,
0.3699366748,
-0.8373709321,
0.8462648988,
0.3255674839,
-0.7829338908,
0.6130135059,
-0.1009339839,
-0.0235967748,
0.4279848337,
0.6166605353,
-0.1186179593,
-0.171189189,
-0.7436032295,
-1.0664476156,
0.4795606732,
0.1436832547,
0.1791487485,
-0.4678244889,
0.6748931408,
0.266861558,
0.3254658878,
-0.7867677212,
0.0135367624,
0.0327907242,
-0.2111069113,
-0.1566562355,
-0.3512962162,
0.0690776855,
-0.1254228204,
0.9022788405,
-0.341745764,
0.2581298053,
0.3900551498,
-0.3575971723,
0.2835977674,
0.4027910233,
0.0817962736,
0.2551503479,
0.0959067494,
0.4747353494,
0.2684451342,
-0.2301767319,
0.1772762388,
-0.0805116519,
-0.2144657075,
0.0914250836,
0.1299460083,
0.8651462197,
0.1582386345,
-0.6246387959,
0.4949001074,
-0.0774990767,
-0.219318673,
-0.1750382781,
0.1172009706,
0.1373859346,
0.4387974441,
0.2525692284,
-0.3492659926,
0.2202274799,
-0.2663729787,
0.2913560271,
0.4072037935,
-0.0281502809,
-0.4994567037,
0.6183868051,
0.2291552275,
-0.0691348463,
0.7198321223,
-0.4830732644,
-0.4898231328,
0.3032875359,
0.7845236659,
1.0519595146,
-0.254550606,
0.2406978756,
0.6001322865,
-0.1342026442,
-0.254503876,
0.3208659887,
-0.0672441795,
-0.84393996,
-0.1563576311,
-0.8760253787,
-0.2845530808,
0.2121446878,
-0.5474609137,
0.2294979244,
-0.3314613104,
-0.4253885448,
0.0146636451,
-0.2976334691,
-0.8456950188,
0.4625554383,
0.2635665834,
0.7637145519,
-0.6191654205,
0.6023502946,
0.658151567,
-0.39530617,
-0.9364183545,
-0.0957241878,
-0.3981081247,
-0.5453073382,
1.0093975067,
0.343746841,
-0.150863409,
0.380490154,
-0.5892797709,
-0.794966042,
0.9426790476,
0.4488235712,
-1.0046714544,
-0.238602519,
-0.1545132697,
0.3651831746,
-0.7123736739,
0.0228675138,
0.6667502522,
0.2741292417,
0.0165650062,
-0.4802186489,
0.1762334257,
-0.2695260644,
0.0307118725,
0.2463656962,
-0.4511161149,
0.683504045,
-0.4071362019,
-0.5281710625,
-0.428414017,
0.9254312515,
0.1737536043,
-0.0642533526,
0.6059526205,
0.5228660703,
0.8357218504,
-0.0071440777,
0.7656665444,
-0.2942312062,
0.1297573149,
1.1665768623,
-0.5764678717,
0.7981185317,
0.3801424205,
0.0032687234,
0.5223908424,
0.5443512797,
-0.2189539224,
0.7647150755,
0.4365207255,
-0.5550461411,
-0.6664531231,
-0.3342545629,
-0.1587426513,
0.3139640987,
0.2353555411,
-0.1775455028,
-0.1684805751,
0.0965123624,
-0.0107028736,
-0.3518585861,
-0.3819493651,
1.0646127462,
0.2371930331,
-0.5906060934,
0.3228878379,
-0.2847611606,
0.6900250912,
-0.4459415674,
0.0278065447,
-0.1768583357,
0.1844557375,
-0.2038354576,
-0.5056446195,
-0.0059988666,
0.3266431093,
-0.1776274294,
-0.182227686,
0.9830157161,
-0.5804700255,
-0.5428711176,
0.0968163311,
0.6183370352,
0.3428840041,
-0.058415845,
-0.2834837139,
-0.4711307883,
-0.3281205595,
-0.5736439824,
0.3936723769,
0.4193529189,
-0.0783336535,
0.5482797623,
0.4897297621,
0.2311995327,
-0.0231944099,
0.259267658,
1.0065546036,
-0.5801481009,
-0.2867527008,
-0.7785716057,
0.4504797459,
-0.1413348913,
-0.0216026343,
0.5477951765,
0.5494436026,
0.8043826818,
-0.2277947515,
0.803876996,
-0.2246306241,
0.4039923549,
-0.5534000993,
0.5275179744,
-0.6489614248,
0.1080572531,
-0.1647785306,
-0.9688052535,
-0.4140159488,
0.4762285054,
-0.3084452152,
-0.0358361267,
0.3801922202,
0.8520717025,
0.021220101,
-0.2581545711,
0.0467290133,
0.1005114466,
0.5199690461,
0.4410027564,
0.72695297,
-0.335747987,
0.2514826953,
0.1789746583,
-0.0972177833,
-0.0175512917,
-1.0844986439,
-0.9062129259,
-0.3934094608,
-0.5284829736,
-0.265756458,
-0.0014110932,
0.9656879902,
0.6644953489,
-0.9533653259,
0.213077262,
-0.1410865933,
-0.1752524823,
0.0905569494,
-0.2135201842,
0.5033972263,
-0.4566196203,
-0.6284610033,
0.5431336164,
0.0877897292,
0.1322548091,
-0.1312752068,
-0.106689617,
0.1295053661,
0.143068254,
0.5703933239,
0.1903858781,
-0.5605408549,
-0.3421690166,
0.0678929761,
0.0069096563,
-0.070834361,
0.8645151258,
-1.0028618574,
0.2882355154,
0.3518761098,
0.8340396285,
0.1832263917,
-0.0784456953,
0.5769646764,
-0.8771873116,
-0.3820769787,
0.1998263896,
0.3265311122,
0.6046923995,
-0.5164321065,
0.3848206401,
0.2501342595,
-0.5184894204,
-0.7904741764,
0.2849814296,
-0.5933086276,
-0.0471590199,
1.1818481684,
-0.1754284948,
-0.1741520762,
0.2520194352,
-0.031393908,
0.1278383881,
-0.2230526805,
0.568661809,
0.2924674153,
-0.162518248,
-0.1318536997,
-0.2218719125,
0.5908346772,
0.0863752216,
-0.849372983,
0.1376049966,
0.5077013373,
0.5988659859,
0.0841471329,
0.6596249938,
-0.0749589652,
-0.0911997333,
-0.091135636,
0.5671803355,
-0.0907711312,
-0.6987226009,
-0.1555124372,
0.1703903973,
0.0521400683,
0.0807665586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11092v1
|
Lost in Translation? Translation Errors and Challenges for Fair Assessment of Text-to-Image Models on Multilingual Concepts
| 2024-03-17T05:05:11 | 2024-03-17T05:05:11 |
Michael Saxon, Yiran Luo, Sharon Levy, Chitta Baral, Yezhou Yang, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.CY, eess.IV
|
Benchmarks of the multilingual capabilities of text-to-image (T2I) models
compare generated images prompted in a test language to an expected image
distribution over a concept set. One such benchmark, "Conceptual Coverage
Across Languages" (CoCo-CroLa), assesses the tangible noun inventory of T2I
models by prompting them to generate pictures from a concept list translated to
seven languages and comparing the output image populations. Unfortunately, we
find that this benchmark contains translation errors of varying severity in
Spanish, Japanese, and Chinese. We provide corrections for these errors and
analyze how impactful they are on the utility and validity of CoCo-CroLa as a
benchmark. We reassess multiple baseline T2I models with the revisions, compare
the outputs elicited under the new translations to those conditioned on the
old, and show that a correction's impactfulness on the image-domain benchmark
results can be predicted in the text domain with similarity scores. Our
findings will guide the future development of T2I multilinguality metrics by
providing analytical tools for practical translation decisions.
|
[
-0.0038411738,
-0.2935541868,
0.3984566331,
0.6144973636,
-0.2346806675,
0.2116097212,
-0.2247950584,
-0.8185238838,
-0.2387526184,
0.3206997812,
-0.2126003653,
-0.2265073806,
-1.0608434677,
0.297760129,
-0.4620877206,
0.7320062518,
-0.591768086,
0.2346274704,
-0.3474233449,
-0.476446718,
-0.7221742272,
-0.1007448807,
-0.4505408704,
-0.0977856442,
0.3225199282,
0.5641139746,
0.7355573177,
0.4070374072,
0.6397926807,
0.1774011701,
0.0067563583,
0.2899696827,
-0.4287447035,
-0.3569208086,
-0.2301746011,
-0.5517361164,
-0.2820922136,
0.0355557278,
0.6846982837,
0.7979915142,
0.0146116195,
0.0555925183,
0.0389384739,
0.5270594358,
-0.7798563838,
0.1976598501,
-0.5577985644,
0.1198800281,
-0.238324672,
-0.2980854213,
-0.5684676766,
-0.2794299722,
-0.0548980534,
-0.5261654258,
0.4724732637,
-0.0388679914,
0.9753710628,
0.2831692994,
-0.5727707148,
-0.5936788917,
-0.6781324148,
1.0533570051,
-0.5403758883,
0.3700446784,
0.224108845,
0.301864773,
-0.0851100758,
-0.5964595675,
-0.4906595647,
-0.0346138887,
-0.0000580219,
0.2957805097,
-0.139405489,
-0.4441530704,
0.0072057252,
0.2162858695,
-0.3886879981,
-0.172624439,
-0.3997288644,
-0.1463799477,
0.5826314092,
-0.1090785265,
0.3961728811,
0.0693169311,
-0.2465218604,
-0.3067823946,
-0.7339919806,
-0.0662230551,
0.1647978872,
0.1933426112,
-0.3502375185,
0.7898297906,
0.1261968464,
0.3026336432,
-0.4063290954,
-0.3149727285,
0.4378469288,
-0.6056807637,
0.0714689568,
-0.0015547994,
0.6732984781,
0.8022710681,
0.3715624511,
-0.2359942943,
-0.2813272774,
0.1932852864,
-0.1980829239,
-0.630882144,
0.2573015392,
0.0819084868,
-0.250169307,
-0.2266249508,
-0.0069243801,
-0.5828590989,
-0.1667682976,
0.1704787016,
-0.0032521645,
-0.0973739699,
-0.2401673794,
0.0313792974,
-0.3567959964,
0.0904964432,
0.4440828562,
-0.5040079951,
0.2269085348,
0.2587299347,
0.8737202287,
-0.1952416897,
-0.3345873952,
0.0098877242,
0.2120300829,
-0.9189770818,
0.9396356344,
-0.2555236816,
-0.6658781171,
0.24149625,
0.0525437407,
-0.3314985335,
-0.5895507336,
0.4562425613,
-0.2517289221,
0.2129850239,
-0.5340533257,
-0.3355465233,
-0.170201689,
0.4616502523,
-0.5411808491,
0.9315133095,
0.2224551588,
-0.7640876174,
0.2283893675,
-0.3397556245,
-0.5118592978,
-0.1973958611,
-0.2415225655,
-0.2954204381,
0.2180583626,
0.0115101831,
0.1405221075,
-0.5790575743,
0.2157433033,
-0.2830416858,
-0.2479819953,
0.4801508784,
-0.318333596,
0.6821297407,
0.0667968318,
-0.3805112243,
-0.2608939707,
-0.481837213,
0.122938931,
0.4565605521,
-0.1803415418,
-0.1060043797,
0.1298968494,
0.5279239416,
0.2766821086,
0.0445436686,
-0.6036505699,
-0.0697268173,
0.0430080295,
0.452750653,
0.3443126082,
-0.0826245919,
0.390406549,
-0.239529714,
0.3601027131,
0.3663583696,
0.1412926167,
-0.0470818356,
-0.8353961706,
-0.6116111279,
0.1923413277,
0.4133523107,
0.644397974,
-0.9987931252,
-0.2405617237,
-0.5430781245,
-0.5963543057,
-0.5884837508,
-0.0171203464,
0.5697650313,
0.4745640755,
0.3824135363,
-0.5330572724,
-0.0199229512,
-0.8925693035,
-0.3911031485,
-0.1000632346,
0.2089487165,
0.3586768508,
0.7153214812,
-0.4237028062,
0.5351873636,
-0.2722560167,
-0.7063972354,
-0.1987950653,
0.2191939205,
-0.2034441829,
0.5436641574,
0.7926437259,
-1.0079187155,
-0.5743905902,
0.4312964678,
-0.7467370629,
0.1003089473,
-0.1178443581,
0.1505717784,
0.3238151968,
0.3756964505,
-0.3855108023,
0.5798776746,
0.5838136673,
-0.1141482443,
0.445104897,
-0.1754419506,
0.5811090469,
-1.1272544861,
0.218684718,
0.1074684784,
-0.1285081953,
-0.3849523067,
0.2976806164,
0.5286177397,
-0.0025910987,
-0.6686094403,
0.6213344336,
-0.3215548992,
-0.3288012445,
-0.1527619511,
0.4223030508,
0.276120156,
0.1752001792,
0.006005045,
1.0470665693,
0.3132516742,
-0.4394964278,
0.1994611025,
0.4938996732,
-0.4488421381,
0.7228720784,
-0.7096743584,
0.1184244603,
-0.2156627923,
0.2946218848,
-0.9266152382,
-0.2063204795,
0.5712214112,
-0.7333233953,
0.3874459267,
0.0079717916,
-0.4779118299,
-0.2062670141,
-0.2842692137,
0.826084137,
0.2076251507,
-0.3022746444,
0.2618035674,
0.3690919876,
0.1384704709,
-0.9873105884,
-1.3524233103,
0.4454894364,
0.0273428634,
-0.3563803434,
0.474915266,
-0.261467129,
-0.0761045441,
0.2014933825,
0.0046647945,
-0.3394120038,
0.0320402831,
-0.0854026154,
-0.0735187307,
-0.1389573812,
0.0481366068,
0.1170444116,
0.0777745247,
-0.0422601886,
-0.1737751067,
0.0861166641,
-0.1364699155,
-0.1660806388,
-0.3140650392,
0.4018641114,
0.4930297136,
-0.3393594325,
0.4954770803,
0.4314651787,
-0.6253876686,
0.1762914658,
-0.5208382607,
0.5235245228,
-0.3275822401,
0.5364689827,
-0.5562248826,
-0.2932608426,
0.6767116785,
0.1059936956,
0.0497510545,
0.6881376505,
0.3900039196,
-0.1768380553,
0.8301623464,
0.6937996149,
0.2596498728,
0.2841905355,
-0.5212334991,
0.2318377346,
-0.8151522279,
-0.5183978677,
-0.8972685337,
-0.1650621593,
-0.6836226583,
-0.7968696952,
0.2520528138,
-0.041362714,
0.173984468,
0.4941452146,
-0.1659961641,
0.4825778604,
0.2519131005,
0.0303787235,
0.4332665205,
0.1299471855,
-0.1239223555,
-0.1960159987,
-0.7530240417,
-0.5370461345,
0.9439802766,
0.1869623512,
0.5528161526,
0.2009947449,
0.2780534625,
0.3583517373,
0.5491169095,
-0.9422276616,
0.1902129799,
-0.2840692997,
-0.4401579201,
0.1003542915,
-0.4830439091,
-0.72134161,
0.1664930135,
-0.1267741621,
-0.4170998931,
0.4840347767,
0.1808163077,
0.2738179862,
0.3548136353,
-0.6002585888,
1.1633697748,
-0.3279034793,
-0.1764828116,
-0.4538294077,
-0.5124206543,
0.3217302263,
-0.2223772109,
0.4980729818,
-0.2311703414,
-0.3530527055,
0.5094895959,
-0.1003319547,
0.3878011703,
0.1737038791,
-0.1431232691,
0.3421400785,
0.172155112,
0.1753328294,
-0.0407127738,
-0.1297099739,
0.5073285699,
0.2569273412,
-0.8839919567,
-0.5203312635,
0.5350902081,
-0.7580420375,
-0.15371342,
-0.5061376691,
-0.5247118473,
-0.1191088408,
0.1792100072,
0.6195227504,
0.3661858141,
-0.3746109009,
0.0372288264,
0.2288833112,
-0.376840055,
0.3463392854,
0.2319380045,
0.0399116389,
-0.3760535419,
0.8016968369,
0.1353195608,
0.4520856738,
0.3380841017,
-0.1118236706,
-0.4357942045,
-0.4724090993,
-0.9048818946,
0.3217355907,
-0.9923567772,
-0.2171212882,
-0.3415542543,
0.1976170391,
-0.2942673564,
0.0436130129,
-0.6111511588,
-0.3623515666,
-0.3002844155,
0.1872276068,
-0.2104034275,
0.7375822663,
0.2440247983,
0.2613826096,
-0.8969168663,
0.1064939648,
-0.2779531181,
0.3027893901,
0.0258968491,
-0.6226281524,
-0.4541060328,
0.1796016246,
-0.5274154544,
-0.9392281771,
0.1056394503,
0.3572726548,
0.2428438216,
0.2055946887,
-0.0646512732,
0.7954495549,
-0.6100525856,
0.6414452791,
0.4901393056,
-1.0062059164,
0.4500248432,
-0.0292236656,
0.2496163994,
0.3486396372,
0.2678876817,
-1.0145403147,
-0.5129314661,
-0.4093077183,
-0.572563827,
0.3877848685,
0.2753247619,
0.2821417749,
-0.2298305631,
0.2122523934,
-0.1740184128,
0.2147984654,
-0.8089490533,
-0.0223468076,
-0.2840713561,
-0.2318053246,
-0.2549003065,
-0.2649551332,
-0.0544678494,
0.0369592905,
0.7089775205,
-0.3117301464,
0.2343381494,
0.4530057013,
-0.431435138,
-0.4605963528,
0.2349741161,
0.7589235306,
0.7303576469,
0.0545045324,
-0.0775932223,
0.1090470925,
-0.2848767042,
0.0912601724,
-0.2060879022,
-0.2611869872,
0.2730024755,
0.474324286,
0.7100314498,
0.3233014345,
-0.8439506888,
0.6780362129,
-0.3001942039,
-0.1104308441,
-0.4071632922,
-0.4404893517,
-0.0899446309,
0.0042477408,
0.2814994156,
0.7546035051,
0.0351793356,
-0.5558378696,
-0.185106203,
0.3025579154,
-0.5423597693,
-0.2497269958,
0.7292906046,
0.222687006,
-0.1151196659,
0.6872872114,
-0.2748864889,
-0.5074285865,
0.8370488882,
0.4613359272,
0.5655147433,
-0.1100341007,
0.3170399368,
0.4618564248,
0.675835073,
-0.4815046191,
0.0126130572,
0.3786908984,
-0.9401647449,
-0.1859156191,
0.1634896249,
-0.3758533299,
-0.2661366761,
-0.6942814589,
0.2071179003,
-0.0997990221,
-0.1836295873,
-0.1508076936,
-0.1938874125,
-0.7756001353,
0.1918816864,
0.0331829265,
0.9779855013,
-1.0456871986,
0.7637469769,
0.6901590824,
-0.5649420023,
-0.5833779573,
0.0620558411,
-0.2091018409,
-0.5742112994,
0.3883526623,
0.19078058,
0.0621682331,
-0.123802267,
-0.3003808558,
-0.7746060491,
0.9276726246,
0.445930481,
-0.345045656,
0.1092486382,
0.475836128,
0.5186896324,
-0.2385497242,
0.3654945791,
0.4965833127,
0.5364171267,
0.1025452837,
-1.0183417797,
-0.1554816961,
-0.2189621776,
0.2051357627,
-0.0386410765,
-0.5892384052,
0.5654634237,
-0.6019255519,
-0.4528708756,
0.5396481156,
0.3868325949,
-0.0755869672,
0.7204802036,
0.2633031011,
0.6286228299,
0.5447516441,
-0.336676836,
1.4419109821,
-0.1014507264,
0.6353027821,
0.9550176859,
-0.2463840842,
0.9764525294,
0.5390845537,
-0.0649964139,
0.1433037519,
0.9184775352,
-0.2087955773,
0.4768659472,
-0.1364621967,
0.0081013525,
0.1606832445,
-0.5668261647,
-0.4227537513,
0.1466159374,
0.356957078,
-0.0166038144,
-0.1832073778,
0.0253676977,
-0.0988770276,
0.3920176923,
-0.2218961418,
0.342687726,
0.3534649611,
-0.6828983426,
0.6400372982,
0.41959396,
0.3620697856,
-0.1788919866,
0.1363256574,
-0.5706395507,
0.372713834,
-0.2106643766,
-0.8083951473,
0.3983803689,
0.0617631339,
-0.1201775819,
-0.1110043079,
0.286667645,
-0.6478052139,
-0.6851725578,
0.6227696538,
0.6219043136,
0.1973887831,
0.0323437862,
-0.9896976352,
0.1824845523,
-0.0903881863,
0.0615344271,
-0.0627838075,
0.2360510826,
-0.473572135,
0.6648017764,
0.1574616879,
0.0099842455,
0.1312497407,
0.1547153294,
0.369001627,
-0.3898859322,
-0.1684436351,
-0.4262394309,
0.3358317316,
0.1191504672,
-0.4583367705,
0.5234774351,
0.6877644658,
1.3939642906,
-0.3905922771,
0.6138305664,
-0.1352212727,
0.2463633567,
-0.277092725,
0.6552435756,
-1.0012428761,
-0.1514929086,
-0.3728816509,
-0.9266806841,
-0.4082992077,
0.2803395092,
-0.0436632261,
-0.139621377,
1.1391254663,
0.777833879,
-0.0836461484,
-0.3676203787,
0.2879531682,
0.1398620158,
0.2168814987,
0.6482869983,
0.6772674322,
-1.2689552307,
0.7255782485,
-0.2150000334,
-0.0251508467,
-0.0473354384,
-0.8321570158,
-0.5162841678,
-0.576988399,
-0.6434147358,
-0.4771552682,
0.0662359297,
0.6476733088,
0.4969755709,
-1.0280585289,
-0.5129367113,
0.1178345606,
0.2863417864,
-0.446662128,
-0.1496821344,
0.3779791892,
-0.2146320641,
-1.1210030317,
0.1803860962,
0.0697890446,
0.3201264739,
0.2954083979,
-0.2764767706,
0.0495254248,
-0.167726934,
0.5443341732,
0.2463214695,
-0.9397991896,
-0.1198007092,
-0.0603156351,
-0.2961866856,
0.181193307,
0.8070164919,
-0.2387071103,
0.5958193541,
0.2963282764,
0.798042357,
0.4318220615,
-0.3079276979,
0.5869731307,
-0.7638518214,
0.4982088506,
0.0233651083,
0.4673869312,
0.6775858402,
-0.0579061657,
0.7498252392,
0.6669765115,
-0.0149588268,
-0.9109091163,
0.186497584,
-1.0393246412,
-0.2889762223,
0.881341815,
-0.395575881,
-0.1699689925,
0.1885091215,
-0.0043394729,
0.4094489515,
-0.0336031355,
0.851015389,
0.8457849026,
0.5739942193,
-0.3891457915,
-0.779600203,
0.2919486165,
0.425514698,
-0.6921228766,
-0.2150399536,
0.1871328354,
0.2874006629,
0.2755761445,
0.5432024002,
-0.4975848794,
0.5898239613,
-0.1285517663,
0.2193751037,
0.371545434,
-0.3073869646,
-0.0030365961,
-0.3115485311,
0.2553803325,
-0.2351903766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11085v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11085v3
|
m&m's: A Benchmark to Evaluate Tool-Use for multi-step multi-modal Tasks
| 2024-03-17T04:36:18 | 2024-03-21T17:25:23 |
Zixian Ma, Weikai Huang, Jieyu Zhang, Tanmay Gupta, Ranjay Krishna
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Real-world multi-modal problems are rarely solved by a single machine
learning model, and often require multi-step computational plans that involve
stitching several models. Tool-augmented LLMs hold tremendous promise for
automating the generation of such computational plans. However, the lack of
standardized benchmarks for evaluating LLMs as planners for multi-step
multi-modal tasks has prevented a systematic study of planner design decisions.
Should LLMs generate a full plan in a single shot or step-by-step? Should they
invoke tools directly with Python code or through structured data formats like
JSON? Does feedback improve planning? To answer these questions and more, we
introduce m&m's: a benchmark containing 4K+ multi-step multi-modal tasks
involving 33 tools that include multi-modal models, (free) public APIs, and
image processing modules. For each of these task queries, we provide
automatically generated plans using this realistic toolset. We further provide
a high-quality subset of 1,565 task plans that are human-verified and correctly
executable. With m&m's, we evaluate 6 popular LLMs with 2 planning strategies
(multi-step vs. step-by-step planning), 2 plan formats (JSON vs. code), and 3
types of feedback (parsing/verification/execution). Finally, we summarize
takeaways from our extensive experiments. Our dataset and code are available on
HuggingFace (https://huggingface.co/datasets/zixianma/mnms) and Github
(https://github.com/RAIVNLab/mnms).
|
[
-0.4707301855,
-0.5664378405,
0.5625568032,
0.4390262067,
-0.0054050987,
0.0100660874,
0.0549534187,
-0.3635419905,
0.2844320834,
0.252183497,
-1.0647799969,
-0.2422901541,
-0.4046145976,
0.2377371341,
-0.0817875639,
0.3572105169,
-0.3229497075,
0.399012655,
-0.33679533,
0.0217404831,
-0.3202449679,
-0.4726950824,
-0.4948489368,
-0.35089764,
0.7892206311,
0.4140127897,
0.6659930348,
0.5182771087,
0.5327080488,
0.3254199326,
0.137069732,
0.6466272473,
-0.1758788228,
0.1874510795,
0.1785928458,
-0.2116841078,
-0.6448604465,
0.3440915048,
0.2806513906,
0.6516075134,
0.0252564419,
0.343888998,
-0.0008377744,
0.6366465092,
-0.9888727665,
0.0518116429,
-0.5213544965,
0.1612006873,
0.1486499459,
-0.3174462914,
-0.2330807149,
-0.0553698838,
-0.0703389868,
-0.37482512,
-0.3106009066,
0.0593997575,
0.0905721262,
0.2825226784,
-0.636680007,
-0.469186455,
-0.8250528574,
1.027695179,
-0.2892819941,
0.4578548968,
0.2253169566,
0.3885240853,
-0.4528840184,
-0.4155826271,
-0.1873781681,
-0.5349260569,
0.1254220307,
0.1306850463,
0.0369637683,
-0.0475508645,
0.6170372963,
-0.0092049092,
-0.445186317,
-0.1239042804,
-0.3732351065,
-0.2020193934,
0.8616039157,
0.6288164854,
-0.1930311322,
-0.2250736654,
-0.7991983891,
0.0284419414,
-0.7175257206,
0.1619244963,
0.3663519621,
0.0068439557,
-0.1117686853,
0.8603452444,
-0.2742132545,
0.5533161759,
-0.3981491923,
-0.5826684833,
0.0627040938,
-0.8886891007,
-0.5031135082,
-0.4635976851,
0.7055295706,
0.6708170772,
0.1609620899,
-0.2344861776,
-0.50963521,
-0.0834784731,
0.3583135009,
-0.88529706,
0.0086218165,
0.2950851619,
-0.4606734812,
-0.1143256873,
-0.3420847654,
-0.4854123592,
-0.3674896061,
-0.7956192493,
0.5474683642,
-0.2488089651,
-0.1818544567,
0.1541011333,
-0.1725026816,
-0.1234240159,
0.6787877083,
-0.3347920477,
0.1579431593,
0.6040225625,
0.8399302959,
-0.0723238513,
-0.6040242314,
-0.4074024558,
-0.0551835671,
-0.4579027593,
0.8877717853,
-0.2628356814,
-0.7797731161,
-0.1198251024,
-0.2133575529,
-0.3036245406,
-0.5304354429,
0.5385388732,
-0.0268844925,
0.1274067014,
-0.5049855113,
-0.0619290546,
-0.1571294367,
0.7322804332,
-0.5908432007,
0.9388416409,
0.1819942147,
-0.3406197131,
0.6525558829,
-0.6916245818,
-0.2958368361,
-0.5600599051,
-0.3010336757,
-0.140104875,
-0.0433732383,
0.1102157235,
0.6112562418,
-0.5614697337,
0.0760281011,
-0.5296849608,
-0.3074515462,
0.4385620952,
-0.3391875327,
0.4516130686,
0.3742321134,
-0.2264741361,
0.6099693775,
-0.7592892647,
0.1881460249,
-0.1214598566,
-0.7521647811,
0.3708498478,
0.2377826869,
0.1542073488,
0.8140936494,
0.1386915743,
-0.4697618186,
0.3068942726,
0.0687307119,
0.2827481329,
0.6543674469,
-0.1730489284,
0.2827633321,
-0.6873452067,
0.5171499252,
0.0990991369,
0.4382488132,
-0.5157017112,
-0.1632920802,
-0.6185511947,
-0.343269676,
0.0280800443,
0.5101555586,
-0.8141300678,
0.0384636223,
-0.0417144336,
-0.6426193118,
-0.0818443224,
0.2297204137,
0.4154037237,
0.1131914631,
0.139893055,
-0.3073852956,
-0.437384516,
-0.9822843075,
-0.1345144808,
0.1620509028,
-0.2194286138,
0.3840664327,
0.4604106545,
-0.2200849056,
0.5036699772,
-0.0990585983,
-0.1546202451,
-0.1565467566,
0.2351882011,
-0.0135491202,
0.2981156707,
0.3923785985,
-0.6877206564,
-0.1395060569,
-0.4882875383,
-0.6641590595,
0.0166370608,
-0.3484906554,
-0.0307071265,
-0.0153771015,
0.3688359261,
-0.6041910648,
0.184463799,
0.4680708647,
-0.2320317775,
1.0923494101,
-0.094388999,
0.5121207833,
-1.1665329933,
0.1854721159,
0.0665185899,
-0.2032656223,
-0.4067976177,
-0.0527785905,
0.1398911327,
-0.0833636224,
-0.7661963701,
0.2117116749,
-0.7317326069,
-0.3284592032,
-0.3963958919,
-0.1350032985,
-0.1393985748,
0.5733161569,
-0.3930653632,
1.0610028505,
0.3590435982,
-0.7084702849,
0.384367913,
-0.1711788177,
-0.1530873477,
0.769610405,
-0.4215878844,
0.186791122,
0.2646503747,
0.1011957005,
-0.7058457136,
0.0181690883,
0.291674763,
-0.1787953526,
0.1460835636,
-0.1664564461,
-0.8855481148,
-0.2962379158,
-0.8817046285,
0.1162397712,
-0.0530353263,
-0.2083654553,
0.9495179057,
0.2726714015,
0.0914090723,
-0.5984390974,
-0.4136082232,
0.2533079386,
0.0087534143,
-0.690595448,
0.1840215623,
-0.3752666116,
-0.1853374988,
-0.0888730139,
-0.3279767931,
0.0210261624,
0.1627839208,
0.75006634,
0.2033682466,
-0.0792434886,
-0.2312038243,
-0.1437139362,
-0.3790599704,
0.2801254094,
0.1613349468,
0.6597276926,
0.1635142416,
-0.764636755,
-0.319065243,
0.3546752036,
0.9685790539,
-0.0899671167,
0.1868208349,
0.5790641904,
-0.3165853024,
0.1248560175,
-0.6039038301,
-0.0088498741,
-0.4106935561,
0.077830337,
-0.8883345723,
-0.4993573725,
0.2156133205,
-0.7224661112,
0.632032752,
0.160450384,
0.7425660491,
-0.0928579196,
1.2248119116,
0.6052316427,
-0.1189931333,
0.3578380942,
-0.2885174751,
-0.2714506388,
-0.8819497228,
-0.3649979532,
-0.3743345439,
-0.8335344195,
-0.3388121724,
-0.7333953381,
0.4457285404,
0.1395004988,
0.0843927339,
0.4263002574,
-0.1549125463,
0.1437895596,
0.6934996247,
-0.0710058138,
0.2475194335,
-0.2884963155,
-0.4324317276,
0.0096405093,
-0.5351461768,
-0.6940966845,
1.3885048628,
0.0902244374,
0.8952894807,
-0.2186249495,
0.4798352718,
0.2007594407,
0.1512302756,
-0.9367734194,
0.6382388473,
0.36766994,
-0.3890093267,
0.0324093178,
-0.3319159746,
-1.00702703,
0.6938409805,
-0.5166268349,
-0.5672721863,
0.1895192564,
0.0671810582,
-0.1602846235,
0.3413135707,
-0.6682359576,
0.6339823008,
-0.5277667642,
-0.442147851,
-0.4435642362,
-0.4536236823,
0.3954181373,
-0.1519021541,
0.1631539315,
-0.6089348197,
-0.3665572703,
0.4621004462,
-0.1217826456,
0.4464432001,
-0.1588549763,
0.2071563303,
0.0604088344,
0.2509043813,
0.3987838924,
-0.0171411168,
-0.2581543624,
-0.0773906335,
0.3388413489,
-0.1414252073,
-0.3528179526,
0.6848156452,
-0.3381868005,
-0.2210994065,
-0.2012856305,
-0.8514177799,
-0.1857842356,
0.2243787497,
-0.2509341836,
0.6443286538,
-0.183569476,
0.1266713589,
-0.0189000592,
0.1929130554,
0.6603770256,
0.4382630885,
-0.3812026978,
-0.5826362371,
0.4712498784,
0.2851220071,
0.2136710137,
0.1336951256,
-0.0438998304,
-0.102400355,
-0.6029063463,
-0.7614181042,
-0.029456798,
-0.4091483057,
-0.1676747352,
-0.5891242623,
0.1486789137,
-0.0982307494,
-0.1176347956,
-0.4458092153,
-0.5079451799,
0.0131112086,
0.2657730579,
-0.3464268744,
0.8082854748,
-0.2000514567,
0.1150580272,
-0.6783707142,
0.3036429882,
-0.0633023828,
0.0863853619,
-0.2727678716,
0.4969950616,
-0.3245578706,
0.0738442391,
-0.7339857221,
-0.7617102861,
0.1450429261,
-0.2338963002,
0.6409454942,
0.412683934,
-0.108857803,
0.7491953373,
-0.4958083928,
0.5833537579,
0.283554107,
-0.4296790957,
0.4563727677,
-0.0234698243,
0.3042082191,
0.4979538321,
0.6411815882,
-0.4345096946,
-0.1271982044,
-0.4606007636,
-0.5070204139,
0.6868505478,
0.0806412771,
-0.2046124339,
0.3216070235,
0.1688834131,
0.1125763431,
0.5861403346,
-0.5053656101,
-0.2534199059,
0.2496733516,
0.2335490733,
-0.0496125594,
-0.4417526126,
-0.4078564048,
-0.0286860466,
0.1921228915,
-0.1408891529,
0.3423971236,
0.0401720107,
-0.2035820335,
-0.2212486714,
0.2188494653,
0.9520007372,
1.1346085072,
-0.2086717784,
0.4147969782,
0.2173299342,
-0.2653209269,
0.0746736974,
0.136132583,
0.0497470088,
0.0266757943,
0.1697580814,
0.2384889871,
0.4902745783,
-0.6806318164,
0.2371947467,
-0.0568214022,
-0.6036869884,
-0.1049706861,
0.1287973076,
0.09528061,
0.4870521724,
0.2470813245,
0.45521456,
0.1968415231,
-0.5081148744,
0.1484899074,
0.6045985222,
-0.330442518,
-0.4309196472,
0.4135888815,
0.2190988809,
-0.4064608514,
0.1512349695,
-0.252609998,
-0.2530776262,
0.3619745076,
0.2657059133,
0.7937208414,
0.0075976774,
-0.0562128201,
0.3137306571,
0.7203403115,
0.2416578829,
0.7380973101,
-0.3121965826,
-0.3409462869,
-0.4275783002,
-0.4490983486,
-0.6079134345,
0.0387613401,
-0.2634929419,
0.3750482798,
-0.5214494467,
-0.4428810775,
-0.1238986105,
0.2056762278,
-0.8950695395,
0.1948990375,
-0.1809409708,
1.1143898964,
-0.3946692348,
0.5613335967,
0.8102168441,
-0.306263119,
-0.5452013612,
-0.2759956717,
0.6037196517,
-0.8724091053,
0.4043951929,
0.2878471613,
-0.4872007966,
-0.372161448,
-0.2348599881,
-0.8311553597,
1.328015089,
0.1808712333,
-0.2884411812,
0.0674405396,
0.2120703012,
-0.0502568111,
-0.3698767424,
0.435716033,
0.3167227209,
0.5662519336,
0.2407345027,
-1.0973477364,
0.0444854423,
-0.1663419604,
-0.2928800583,
0.491851151,
-0.4064173698,
0.9399899244,
-0.3540847003,
-0.1795066893,
0.0023310152,
0.1003903747,
0.334209919,
0.7018957138,
0.7260286212,
0.5949448943,
0.2834786773,
-0.058902096,
0.8455886841,
-0.5153568983,
0.0131621538,
0.8993521333,
-0.3314610422,
0.9170079231,
0.587020278,
-0.3169416487,
-0.0519864149,
0.834392786,
0.0147461127,
0.3539454639,
0.1577566415,
-0.119454436,
-0.1912719309,
-0.0596901402,
-0.2822901607,
0.3129226267,
0.1909820884,
-0.1521091908,
-0.4313205481,
-0.0183848217,
0.0498953573,
-0.4823376238,
-0.2144180387,
0.7254273295,
0.1500393003,
-0.3620591164,
0.217723608,
0.0666837096,
0.8463778496,
-0.6109271049,
0.1645680964,
0.0559640862,
0.0524000302,
-0.2263941318,
-0.6392371655,
0.2206712216,
-0.2433894128,
-0.1834000945,
-0.4882222414,
0.7816258073,
-0.0985137448,
-0.4347522855,
0.1678691506,
1.1288807392,
0.1046051085,
-0.4396498799,
-1.0293772221,
0.0193102565,
-0.2815793157,
-0.3340411186,
0.4003722072,
0.2402028888,
0.1095246226,
0.9893556833,
0.9603381753,
0.0077057495,
0.1746948659,
-0.0283515863,
1.016027689,
-0.7265217304,
-0.0482126102,
-0.9267753959,
0.5658299327,
-0.056017749,
-0.4068392515,
0.8824023604,
0.9950746298,
0.8120765686,
0.0219970997,
0.3152447343,
0.204962492,
0.329033047,
-0.6762822866,
0.2884426415,
-0.8619840741,
0.0961575583,
0.0087378826,
-1.0791404247,
-0.0272677653,
0.1624113172,
-0.2323207706,
0.0970280841,
0.7201664448,
0.8639557362,
-0.0810698196,
-0.2105262876,
0.4630422294,
-0.5614787936,
0.401643455,
0.5160561204,
1.2131888866,
-0.0449657701,
0.58534199,
-0.4375554323,
-0.2125188559,
-0.3681627512,
-0.7897341251,
-0.645701766,
-0.4371177256,
-0.0780292973,
-0.0156248379,
-0.2687236369,
1.3235813379,
1.0768209696,
-0.3043964505,
-0.6782799959,
0.3733402789,
0.1981819421,
-0.3235097826,
-0.1018371806,
-0.0927972198,
-0.5370709896,
-0.5446494818,
0.7653058767,
0.7117916942,
0.0094619496,
-0.5345967412,
-0.0882475451,
-0.1193801314,
-0.0994108692,
0.9327275753,
-0.1353150159,
-0.7511049509,
0.0522866547,
0.2192833722,
-0.2598526776,
0.1474908441,
1.2835890055,
-0.4921128154,
0.5268628597,
0.3170752823,
0.4030539393,
0.4852999151,
-0.1647473872,
0.5687893629,
-0.5255631804,
0.0038270575,
0.1415446848,
0.5884299874,
-0.0856487527,
0.0950671062,
0.7836439013,
0.0520788096,
-0.7038885355,
-0.6101424694,
0.2463260591,
-1.0582097769,
-0.2219191641,
0.8888269663,
0.1550983042,
-0.0245686285,
-0.1407770663,
-0.5387112498,
-0.0522911921,
-0.202072531,
0.6453490257,
0.5017468929,
-0.6867124438,
-0.0999770239,
-0.7956323624,
0.3796706498,
0.2409200519,
-0.9523419142,
-0.1682624221,
0.8986927867,
0.0544281453,
0.2349547297,
0.6682930589,
0.1302790493,
0.3691793382,
0.0888916478,
-0.005168194,
-0.4911650419,
-0.5936294198,
0.0609691404,
0.329465121,
0.1342848986,
-0.4964179695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11083v1
|
Customizing Visual-Language Foundation Models for Multi-modal Anomaly Detection and Reasoning
| 2024-03-17T04:30:57 | 2024-03-17T04:30:57 |
Xiaohao Xu, Yunkang Cao, Yongqi Chen, Weiming Shen, Xiaonan Huang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Anomaly detection is vital in various industrial scenarios, including the
identification of unusual patterns in production lines and the detection of
manufacturing defects for quality control. Existing techniques tend to be
specialized in individual scenarios and lack generalization capacities. In this
study, we aim to develop a generic anomaly detection model applicable across
multiple scenarios. To achieve this, we customize generic visual-language
foundation models that possess extensive knowledge and robust reasoning
abilities into anomaly detectors and reasoners. Specifically, we introduce a
multi-modal prompting strategy that incorporates domain knowledge from experts
as conditions to guide the models. Our approach considers multi-modal prompt
types, including task descriptions, class context, normality rules, and
reference images. In addition, we unify the input representation of
multi-modality into a 2D image format, enabling multi-modal anomaly detection
and reasoning. Our preliminary studies demonstrate that combining visual and
language prompts as conditions for customizing the models enhances anomaly
detection performance. The customized models showcase the ability to detect
anomalies across different data modalities such as images and point clouds.
Qualitative case studies further highlight the anomaly detection and reasoning
capabilities, particularly for multi-object scenes and temporal data. Our code
is available at https://github.com/Xiaohao-Xu/Customizable-VLM.
|
[
-0.3321282864,
-1.1410164833,
0.6994850636,
0.2666184902,
-0.1636905372,
-0.2386091352,
0.1026623696,
-0.3144339323,
0.0360032842,
0.3844884634,
-0.7396145463,
-0.7060034275,
-0.2816143632,
0.0870787799,
-0.3129415512,
0.5654110909,
-0.0411209092,
-0.2961752415,
-0.4558564723,
-0.1219822392,
-0.8171636462,
-0.4162213802,
-0.3402827978,
0.07002794,
0.2179911584,
0.3560877144,
0.4281991124,
0.510433197,
0.3573393524,
0.4040486813,
0.1806036383,
0.6129196286,
-0.1030599102,
0.3606621325,
-0.1007697731,
-0.272318393,
-0.6181047559,
-0.5471301079,
0.4003892541,
0.3679131269,
-0.0868461803,
-0.0866978467,
-0.3375889659,
0.0973915234,
-0.5381684303,
0.4292756319,
-0.4730222523,
0.0360683128,
-0.1362395138,
-0.3772889674,
-0.4619446993,
-0.0143700577,
-0.093974188,
-0.750865519,
0.4351116419,
0.0925498754,
0.8999225497,
0.2862189114,
-0.4271772206,
-0.0430405885,
-0.5307979584,
0.7131562829,
-0.5848266482,
0.5090988278,
0.1823630184,
0.6848379374,
-0.1212517619,
-0.8202421069,
-0.6154704094,
-0.2623420358,
-0.2181456834,
0.0464204662,
-0.3730078638,
-0.1534596831,
0.1681746989,
-0.0440891869,
-0.8412212133,
0.0401754417,
0.0777851343,
-0.2805573344,
0.3096842468,
0.588177979,
0.3649459779,
-0.3263591528,
-0.4660367966,
0.112398237,
-0.4061807096,
0.3862668276,
0.2717119157,
0.1296522915,
-0.4830820858,
0.1917215586,
-0.3875638545,
1.0065377951,
-0.1112821698,
-0.1267155111,
0.2376388907,
-0.5131475329,
-0.3289300501,
-0.376082778,
0.5646679997,
0.3434953988,
-0.0915735886,
0.2600827515,
-0.4088968337,
0.0332553871,
0.1052985117,
-0.5937228799,
-0.4506551921,
0.1262167692,
-0.6685537696,
-0.4303104281,
-0.0603492223,
-0.7502756715,
-0.6120755076,
-0.4113543034,
0.4888487458,
-0.3564561605,
-0.6201968789,
0.1406383812,
-0.4148359299,
-0.2183131874,
0.6679791808,
-0.6341748238,
-0.260989517,
0.2918558121,
0.4126815796,
-0.2203247249,
-0.2415300757,
-0.687048316,
0.2607477009,
-0.158922568,
0.9784808755,
-0.9819293618,
-0.6184545755,
-0.0286009517,
0.2542837262,
-0.2218174487,
-0.3737991452,
0.3806757033,
-0.4380443692,
0.1781695038,
-0.5351791382,
-0.1219641417,
-0.4077990353,
0.7354893684,
-0.4521722496,
0.6991384029,
0.2284231633,
-0.6869005561,
0.4738199115,
-0.8060442805,
-0.3283693492,
0.1752094477,
-0.7216243744,
-0.4573273957,
-0.1084293872,
0.5419914722,
0.4184715152,
-0.3619107306,
0.3184842467,
-0.3418586552,
-0.0071789045,
0.4027616382,
-0.6451534629,
0.566606462,
0.2780432701,
-0.3863933682,
0.4064542651,
-0.8510968685,
0.0116636297,
0.1044644043,
-0.4116156697,
-0.158307597,
0.0311985109,
0.4215709269,
0.1973825842,
0.1764811128,
-0.2293762863,
0.295947969,
0.2300264239,
0.1101976484,
0.5050753951,
0.293928951,
0.0655569062,
-0.1519023478,
0.7462251782,
0.8590254784,
0.3810777664,
-0.8208031058,
-0.659044981,
-0.6288388371,
-0.6723171473,
-0.1557438076,
0.6681381464,
-0.9967868328,
0.3331677616,
-0.1051853597,
0.0864356235,
-0.1123196706,
0.029512858,
0.2165049911,
1.0553728342,
0.4566200674,
0.0037305658,
-0.6302695274,
-0.9114712477,
-0.3855723739,
0.115800336,
0.0499645509,
0.2985593975,
0.3576550782,
-0.6306413412,
1.3063281775,
-0.4331052601,
-0.1102721468,
-0.2610087693,
0.154147476,
0.2008377761,
0.6478000283,
0.9541772604,
-1.0961396694,
-0.2031337172,
0.2877533734,
-1.148003459,
-0.1971964836,
-0.2081915289,
0.250300914,
0.232449621,
0.5234500766,
-0.3227596879,
0.5275557637,
0.2640638351,
-0.5647752285,
0.5783119202,
-0.1255756617,
0.4627042115,
-1.2053130865,
-0.0233786721,
0.2363364249,
-0.1986299902,
-0.8468011022,
0.041924078,
0.0993987173,
-0.2283006757,
-0.2841290832,
0.438180685,
-0.3680143654,
0.232335031,
-0.2501285076,
-0.1963062286,
0.3107807934,
0.3629699647,
0.0995885506,
0.3614459634,
0.9146552086,
-0.642228663,
0.4568526149,
-0.0406564586,
-0.1388405859,
0.8777351379,
-0.5925793052,
-0.1831499487,
-0.3691409826,
0.0707308352,
-0.9755300879,
-0.4835628271,
0.4216828942,
-0.3288836777,
0.1838930696,
-0.3716671765,
-0.4221985042,
-0.3305127621,
-0.0192511603,
0.3303202987,
0.1534904987,
-0.6984165907,
0.9777844548,
-0.0266632829,
0.1024172753,
-0.562594533,
-0.8404828906,
-0.0159524456,
-0.2222966254,
-0.9718009233,
-0.0685780123,
-0.2643679678,
-0.1480311006,
0.1659180075,
-0.1403879225,
-0.4373984933,
0.1647524089,
0.3298227191,
0.315810889,
-0.6633940339,
-0.053584747,
0.3233067095,
-0.1052266806,
0.0719682202,
-0.2042053193,
0.2808325589,
-0.4787458479,
-0.8312062025,
-0.5157914758,
0.6152650118,
0.8150666356,
-0.2912144661,
0.366140604,
0.976356864,
-0.6057153344,
-0.1311627626,
-0.6638422608,
-0.2720753849,
-0.5404821634,
0.4156574905,
-0.6163426042,
-0.5330765843,
0.5732999444,
-0.0853466392,
-0.1356924623,
0.0122249797,
0.5663636923,
0.1299821287,
1.4401427507,
0.7358312011,
0.2203407884,
0.342864275,
-0.3464607,
0.410255909,
-0.4420571625,
-0.6210467219,
-0.0978268012,
-0.062490508,
-0.1421886533,
-0.5396305323,
0.7807432413,
0.0818739384,
0.0212575402,
0.0574249625,
-0.3749532104,
0.4346629381,
0.3307469189,
-0.0185307991,
0.4443730414,
0.1415451765,
0.0539877899,
-0.0870150179,
-0.7043998241,
-0.2919979095,
0.4377849102,
0.2693564594,
0.6819043159,
0.4099067748,
0.3468172848,
0.4332241714,
-0.0025238509,
-0.586959064,
0.2751403749,
0.2382837981,
-0.4868811667,
-0.2016026825,
-0.3084995151,
-0.7531164289,
0.4833222628,
-0.2941426337,
-0.7816495895,
0.812027514,
0.4744920433,
-0.2999181747,
0.1955671757,
-0.9684121013,
1.1476047039,
-0.2290406972,
0.0133385481,
-0.0373629592,
-0.4758016467,
0.6466806531,
0.1324906498,
0.3807710111,
-0.0461236574,
-0.0557397269,
-0.1503512859,
-0.3077450395,
1.0319349766,
-0.2345911264,
0.1516190171,
0.2653649747,
0.2204380184,
0.4209561348,
0.4556975067,
0.0756551921,
-0.0516599379,
-0.0424050316,
-0.3389817178,
-0.5452528,
0.6524148583,
-0.3581851423,
-0.6719584465,
-0.1579163671,
-0.8382962942,
-0.1328129023,
0.3277439177,
0.4756488204,
0.6221568584,
-0.0513375252,
0.2310625613,
0.7373000383,
-0.1345003247,
0.6098265052,
0.7988262177,
-0.1218200848,
0.1121652573,
1.1263420582,
-0.1874870509,
-0.1272385418,
0.4101238251,
0.4101749659,
-0.0919585153,
-0.3567591012,
-0.8418561816,
-0.3150990009,
-0.9030352235,
-0.255607307,
-0.9092445374,
0.0499437898,
-0.5408003926,
-0.2167738676,
-0.1000576764,
-0.1639001071,
-0.4774705768,
0.2253832668,
0.4407240152,
0.5166698098,
-0.0359418578,
0.1001460254,
-0.8655127883,
0.4686639905,
0.4870380163,
-0.0433312617,
0.0267423224,
-0.3147847652,
0.1110321507,
-0.0417896546,
-0.2660219371,
-0.9022903442,
0.3640833199,
0.0188328605,
0.9065547585,
0.8564842343,
-0.0234017204,
0.4087258875,
-0.1483826041,
0.7733308077,
0.4047650099,
-0.9588797688,
0.7300839424,
-0.7545118332,
0.3205626309,
-0.0015240266,
0.2554928362,
-0.3921199143,
-0.1341384798,
-0.4379915595,
-0.6238760352,
0.6191672087,
-0.0880055204,
-0.1265673786,
-0.00192972,
-0.097835578,
0.0873774812,
0.2975600362,
-0.6452724934,
-0.2493550032,
-0.6756731272,
-0.1124406084,
0.4090801477,
-0.0781323761,
-0.440244019,
-0.1346084327,
-0.0303979702,
-0.3661643565,
0.0212899949,
0.0110624088,
-0.3782910109,
0.079079628,
0.3095195889,
1.0003023148,
0.9944741726,
0.1491488665,
0.1364483088,
0.2464737892,
-0.2214779556,
-0.0193049572,
0.1791435331,
0.0123209571,
0.2851843834,
0.3416178524,
0.8745039105,
0.1598983705,
-0.6917146444,
0.7108609676,
0.0198232755,
0.0306004621,
-0.2343545109,
0.0837714151,
-0.0363845788,
0.429707557,
0.3418520391,
0.4031891525,
0.4320228696,
-0.5513885021,
0.0529498011,
0.2426570654,
-0.047493577,
-0.4458676577,
0.7674912214,
0.2115072161,
-0.2061418891,
0.334333241,
-0.4201778471,
-0.485761255,
0.9475397468,
0.4673019052,
0.5289945006,
-0.3602852225,
0.2796694934,
-0.1343452185,
0.5533515215,
0.0602842607,
0.4390731156,
0.0301330648,
-0.7489026189,
-0.022086408,
-0.0406069458,
-0.2233577818,
0.2789104581,
-0.4036902487,
0.5477528572,
-0.4867713153,
-0.0600529052,
-0.2261867225,
-0.7640515566,
-0.8670259714,
0.203938365,
0.0994907245,
0.728815794,
-1.0923461914,
0.6143400073,
0.8466619253,
-0.5522857904,
-0.5087631941,
-0.2125262022,
0.4495390356,
-0.671693325,
0.5566612482,
0.1889164001,
-0.0214531124,
-0.3379306197,
-0.1946706176,
-0.762011826,
1.0563172102,
0.4051555991,
-0.3994895518,
0.1367005557,
-0.1069764569,
0.3882307112,
-0.5503529906,
0.0760435611,
0.6591656804,
0.7730039954,
-0.2055496275,
-0.5658035278,
0.0536933802,
-0.3924167752,
0.0937874988,
0.0791678727,
-0.2551731467,
0.9775145054,
-0.242078051,
0.043078348,
-0.2494137883,
0.4701688588,
0.4476881325,
0.7990655899,
0.691825211,
0.4668730199,
0.8084997535,
-0.0646229312,
0.9844762087,
-0.1537541747,
-0.10094174,
0.8000169992,
-0.0827649087,
0.1644505411,
0.120594278,
0.3799259067,
0.7506543994,
0.6520596743,
-0.1578667313,
0.3925616443,
-0.2596713901,
-0.2575861514,
-0.644203186,
-0.2224143744,
-0.7679110765,
0.2994250655,
0.6986848712,
-0.1946559995,
-0.2841574252,
0.3496455252,
-0.1094313338,
0.0453484543,
-0.22915335,
0.2162333429,
-0.2511755824,
-0.2677965164,
0.4529452026,
0.0268743522,
0.6235737801,
-0.4320194423,
-0.191206485,
-0.2098641992,
0.024762392,
-0.4232265949,
-0.5182540417,
0.0732640699,
-0.0690804347,
-0.5114299655,
-0.0601748899,
0.7222816348,
-0.5008872151,
-0.3482398987,
-0.1213303283,
0.6732207537,
-0.0066971052,
0.0535307825,
-0.6092969775,
0.2587977052,
-0.1220698059,
-0.2034696043,
0.0896396562,
0.6201375127,
-0.5107579231,
0.6692529321,
0.6964999437,
-0.37032336,
0.1965185851,
0.4302528203,
0.9450188279,
-0.3142105937,
-0.7959073782,
-0.4604157805,
0.836440146,
-0.4059605002,
-0.3984850347,
0.6936119199,
0.4048109353,
0.4320979118,
-0.5856705904,
0.8394549489,
-0.0522638969,
0.1306047142,
-0.5198812485,
0.5459114313,
-0.739937067,
0.4562931955,
-0.1604303569,
-0.5619897246,
-0.1779791713,
0.3821519613,
-0.0433191955,
0.1527282745,
0.7732524872,
1.0241196156,
-0.3998354673,
-0.0098403823,
0.3831857145,
0.0621075854,
0.6493184566,
0.4098936021,
0.9905923009,
-0.0511891693,
0.6408779025,
-0.0005191041,
-0.2506197691,
-0.5262841582,
-1.1818474531,
-0.956756711,
-0.6424833536,
-0.3745117188,
-0.0974937081,
-0.1178036854,
0.72216326,
0.9406091571,
-0.9046519995,
0.0624334291,
-0.014779659,
0.4111132324,
-0.291264981,
-0.3505586088,
0.0965050012,
-0.4110243917,
-0.6535092592,
0.9291961193,
0.4225324094,
0.2124301046,
-0.1863886267,
0.1629266888,
0.1368053257,
-0.0895109624,
0.6685109138,
0.4368497133,
-0.840519309,
-0.2865596414,
0.1513587534,
0.0789820626,
-0.1227169633,
1.0512975454,
-0.6216454506,
0.7814772725,
0.8271025419,
0.6089100838,
0.2046364993,
-0.1101415455,
0.6441953182,
-0.9716004729,
0.5944840908,
0.1817121059,
0.604925096,
0.4044465721,
-0.539467454,
0.1178124174,
0.6352010369,
-0.1632113904,
-1.0719422102,
0.5989593863,
-1.0562621355,
-0.4789412618,
0.7924408317,
-0.1466178596,
0.1620795429,
-0.4758481681,
-0.1086152494,
-0.1690627038,
-0.4859918356,
0.7511501908,
0.3970789909,
-0.3960227668,
-0.1491175592,
-0.4194730222,
0.3384986818,
0.3643921912,
-0.9784787297,
-0.313338995,
0.7028127313,
0.3213245869,
0.323543787,
0.2751058638,
0.1767164916,
0.7757894397,
0.025368847,
-0.1576915532,
-0.5198904276,
-0.5658966303,
-0.5280519724,
0.1188908517,
-0.2591439784,
-0.3789117932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11082v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11082v1
|
RobustSentEmbed: Robust Sentence Embeddings Using Adversarial Self-Supervised Contrastive Learning
| 2024-03-17T04:29:45 | 2024-03-17T04:29:45 |
Javad Rafiei Asl, Prajwal Panzade, Eduardo Blanco, Daniel Takabi, Zhipeng Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have consistently demonstrated outstanding
performance across a diverse spectrum of natural language processing tasks.
Nevertheless, despite their success with unseen data, current PLM-based
representations often exhibit poor robustness in adversarial settings. In this
paper, we introduce RobustSentEmbed, a self-supervised sentence embedding
framework designed to improve both generalization and robustness in diverse
text representation tasks and against a diverse set of adversarial attacks.
Through the generation of high-risk adversarial perturbations and their
utilization in a novel objective function, RobustSentEmbed adeptly learns
high-quality and robust sentence embeddings. Our experiments confirm the
superiority of RobustSentEmbed over state-of-the-art representations.
Specifically, Our framework achieves a significant reduction in the success
rate of various adversarial attacks, notably reducing the BERTAttack success
rate by almost half (from 75.51\% to 38.81\%). The framework also yields
improvements of 1.59\% and 0.23\% in semantic textual similarity tasks and
various transfer tasks, respectively.
|
[
-0.2519155145,
-0.6869699359,
0.4151983857,
0.3176297247,
-0.2041041702,
-0.1211521253,
-0.1982027739,
0.1493459344,
0.083388634,
0.4839439392,
-0.2309367657,
-0.7826789021,
-0.9251872897,
0.0234544817,
-0.2391798198,
0.9506465197,
0.0841639489,
-0.0905041918,
-0.337012291,
-0.2998817563,
-0.4118330777,
-0.5521677136,
-0.1346893609,
0.0283669867,
0.2116404921,
-0.0778355226,
0.9156450629,
0.7394390106,
0.5754327774,
0.343926549,
0.0790654197,
-0.1232986003,
-0.4710139334,
0.6334003806,
-0.2308551222,
-0.5555856824,
0.0095241796,
0.1455373615,
0.5469990373,
0.366659075,
-0.1097065732,
-0.3603546619,
0.587389648,
0.2216039896,
-0.8282533884,
-0.0612764545,
-0.6307990551,
0.2449150532,
-0.0911266357,
0.0166123249,
-0.3816926777,
-0.1530630291,
0.1269120872,
-0.483931601,
0.1158937588,
-0.2678239942,
0.7348542213,
0.6324093342,
-0.3961676955,
-0.2543478012,
-0.0466485023,
0.8924952745,
-0.6590967178,
0.2272242755,
0.363740623,
0.0542020574,
-0.2851047814,
-0.7588559389,
-0.0592994727,
-0.254098773,
-0.1257360578,
0.2328033745,
-0.40907529,
-0.0236877874,
-0.1481032372,
0.3283623159,
-0.8091123104,
0.1038472429,
0.3999134302,
-0.3431538641,
0.2210130244,
0.0005197654,
0.3676291108,
-0.1616370231,
-0.6706860065,
-0.4418626726,
-0.3772301376,
-0.0929676741,
0.5990005732,
0.3878430724,
-0.2298558801,
0.2402590066,
0.1646085232,
0.5170240998,
-0.1116722524,
0.0563995503,
0.1669548601,
-0.4145471454,
-0.2017355114,
-0.2014338523,
1.0952507257,
0.0955860317,
-0.047746174,
-0.2065836042,
-0.1579883695,
0.3433046341,
0.3377737701,
-0.6802838445,
-0.7164078355,
-0.0438292436,
-0.5103765726,
-0.5845553875,
0.2471621633,
-0.8854535818,
-0.5046144724,
0.3188454509,
0.4133783281,
-0.6591008306,
-0.0478325672,
0.0910811275,
-0.0700525492,
0.0421787985,
0.1587612033,
-0.5992074609,
0.2147076279,
0.3081542552,
0.765453279,
-0.252368629,
-0.271894902,
-0.6975120902,
0.087636739,
-0.2286726087,
0.5469300747,
-0.3573887646,
-0.4259130657,
0.175131008,
-0.2920787036,
-0.164809823,
-0.4902178943,
0.827126205,
-0.224088788,
0.5452491045,
0.1129153967,
-0.6133669019,
0.0400783159,
0.5750318766,
-0.6990137696,
0.6788125634,
-0.0137790777,
-0.9899977446,
0.0251347795,
-0.4940387309,
-0.5621324778,
-0.2652986944,
-0.0891249552,
-0.860645473,
-0.0441200845,
0.5709171295,
0.7731624246,
0.1696985215,
-0.0628053546,
-0.5534923077,
-0.089373827,
0.1760977358,
-0.6815600991,
0.8552501798,
0.3553718328,
-0.31011042,
0.0379740931,
-0.3182348907,
-0.2128456384,
0.3272958994,
-0.1811213791,
-0.719029963,
-0.2224161476,
0.0426152125,
-0.0227183048,
0.4168484211,
-0.5014998913,
-0.0488297828,
-0.5367384553,
0.4390334785,
0.6872057319,
-0.0318935253,
0.5795149803,
-0.1785361022,
0.5730384588,
0.2414485812,
0.0486190729,
-0.5278322101,
-0.1736169457,
-0.4483478367,
-0.5236231089,
0.3896460831,
0.5529536009,
-0.6765197515,
0.7598676085,
0.0401070528,
-0.071340397,
-0.6140502691,
0.587239027,
0.3813526928,
0.4773914218,
0.5846366882,
0.0297882259,
-0.3205861151,
-0.8493984342,
-0.4243452251,
0.0372301303,
-0.1677396744,
-0.3427341282,
0.2730595767,
-0.4005952477,
0.6821988821,
-0.3311095834,
-0.6169637442,
-0.3210087717,
0.2872078419,
-0.1017362475,
0.7285040617,
0.8338374496,
-0.8130154014,
-0.524004519,
-0.453114301,
-0.8277298212,
-0.0240138434,
-0.3527890146,
-0.1408791989,
-0.2035466731,
0.7049056888,
-0.4566254318,
0.2159762383,
0.7257412672,
-0.391839236,
0.0445808731,
-0.3232043684,
-0.0927533805,
-1.4378281832,
-0.2284422219,
0.0765319094,
-0.7039662004,
-0.3288906515,
0.2635422349,
0.1896433085,
-0.1891697943,
-0.3300340772,
0.0007478045,
-0.4353050888,
0.4374278188,
-0.1871639788,
0.3798414469,
0.0886177942,
0.3124628067,
-0.3159101307,
0.664599359,
0.6824200153,
-0.42299968,
0.1972786933,
0.433359772,
0.0147352107,
0.7156544328,
-0.5819813609,
0.0247514024,
-0.1794859618,
0.0580186509,
-0.8683012724,
-0.0314531811,
0.3079537749,
-0.5140374303,
0.57000494,
0.1769221723,
-0.3450190425,
-0.0470187627,
-0.7359674573,
-0.0534573197,
0.3121715784,
-0.5735387802,
0.5895084739,
0.3411765993,
-0.1777608246,
-0.5930687785,
-1.1102011204,
0.3117542565,
-0.3764685988,
-0.2842499912,
0.3671413064,
0.09217114,
-0.077429153,
0.2076536566,
0.0583796352,
0.1154697835,
0.4961988628,
0.0251287892,
-0.0494981967,
-0.1116717905,
0.1743776798,
0.1051369011,
-0.2496676445,
0.0962688401,
-0.3170497715,
0.4037142396,
-0.2733025253,
-0.4938203692,
-0.6366659403,
0.6106423736,
0.3135581911,
-0.2693213224,
0.6532273889,
0.78637743,
-0.2983584404,
-0.3620348573,
-0.222676903,
-0.1040962636,
-0.4643918276,
0.4762504101,
-0.3030129671,
-1.0731157064,
0.306671828,
-0.0448593497,
-0.0502074026,
0.4512216747,
0.1925129741,
-0.3648386002,
0.9834187031,
0.5323817134,
-0.2923097908,
0.421009928,
-0.197873801,
0.0889419839,
-0.5377110243,
0.0424986221,
-0.5955034494,
-0.1664974689,
-0.7360678911,
-0.2117817402,
0.0609194711,
0.103519544,
-0.2835597694,
0.4935654998,
-0.4157825708,
0.1937494427,
0.7133687735,
0.265727669,
-0.0270653833,
-0.1912632585,
-0.2402801514,
-0.3534409106,
-0.8330510855,
-0.5516906977,
1.0815570354,
0.4936625659,
1.0692449808,
0.21966438,
0.9097161889,
0.5941026211,
0.1912487298,
-0.4960277379,
0.370762229,
-0.6621159315,
-0.0443411954,
-0.0400042012,
-0.5096078515,
-1.0299670696,
0.2041629404,
-0.3985446692,
-0.3583224416,
0.1075246483,
0.1654341519,
-0.3054210842,
0.2740625143,
-0.6099070311,
1.1378065348,
-0.1945572346,
-0.2633105218,
-0.013160551,
-0.7209453583,
0.0537057109,
0.1822688729,
-0.1244449019,
0.1715016365,
-0.2876021266,
0.5748119354,
-0.1594851315,
0.9321572781,
-0.2086916119,
0.038905073,
0.1176415682,
0.2746674716,
0.6039999127,
0.2520652711,
0.0077450029,
-0.2424532473,
-0.2324759066,
-0.6253128648,
-0.7136377096,
1.0404071808,
-0.7184610367,
-0.7071253657,
-0.4880435169,
-0.3659790754,
-0.3503926396,
0.1997818053,
0.3791252673,
0.3412278593,
-0.4927422106,
0.7722263336,
0.9509328008,
-0.2063633502,
0.5811339021,
-0.1418213844,
0.3059525192,
-0.7964145541,
0.6971684098,
-0.3943098187,
0.0981922224,
0.5160733461,
0.1173093468,
-0.6810559034,
-0.6511262655,
-0.0307234637,
-0.1960041374,
-0.7437083125,
-0.5757169127,
-0.7309747934,
0.1000721678,
-0.6937378645,
-0.2511188388,
-0.3407480121,
-0.0676807836,
-0.6460368037,
-0.162319839,
-0.1008212417,
0.4783732593,
0.0078256857,
0.434406817,
-0.6826677322,
0.3148396909,
0.4036856592,
0.1201922819,
-0.5614899397,
-0.2849543691,
-0.058950033,
-0.1234767884,
-0.4356578588,
-0.9091919065,
0.4040603936,
0.3565671742,
0.8704020977,
0.5264639258,
0.6325016618,
0.2711694241,
0.0387339629,
0.8521324992,
0.353446126,
-0.9066830873,
0.7758980393,
-0.3069663644,
0.6460410953,
0.8390817642,
0.3544842005,
0.1598721147,
-0.7472987771,
-0.6230602264,
-0.5982884169,
0.1599697322,
0.4194950759,
0.4698662758,
-0.0325456783,
0.1054810435,
0.0506429449,
0.1383461952,
-0.968721211,
-0.0897611454,
-0.8147222996,
-0.7732064128,
-0.206407994,
-0.1531398743,
-0.0883118585,
0.3876531124,
0.3975026906,
-0.1715910882,
0.25475353,
0.4440222383,
-0.3527747989,
0.4593412578,
0.4290284514,
0.1540441066,
-0.1847943515,
0.00335324,
0.6838402152,
0.0415807776,
-0.3867358267,
0.0081355227,
0.5388926864,
-0.1248739213,
-0.0345954821,
0.6567983627,
0.4521801174,
0.1990913749,
-0.5668411255,
0.7885272503,
-0.3174849749,
-0.0987373814,
0.1058561355,
0.0139303999,
-0.1187873185,
0.1840666831,
0.1563509107,
0.3365271389,
0.294136703,
-0.4176400602,
0.4517377913,
0.5291535854,
-0.4941263199,
-0.0878831446,
0.8224718571,
0.2627921104,
-0.0036637872,
0.2746779323,
-0.1109786108,
-0.7711594701,
0.2303994745,
0.6179700494,
0.9585811496,
-0.5016604066,
0.2641460598,
-0.0411017723,
0.4413398802,
-0.0800429732,
-0.0476594754,
-0.1248137578,
-0.5939214826,
-0.0497160703,
-0.3766571283,
-0.1811773479,
0.1215270385,
-0.5941824317,
-0.0487576351,
-0.5540477037,
-0.2363678217,
-0.6033790708,
-0.0226032287,
-0.5397408009,
0.1145179272,
-0.0615110658,
0.7475210428,
-0.7801935077,
0.5977778435,
0.818302989,
-0.2872091532,
-0.2792719305,
0.3986085355,
-0.1699588299,
-0.2675785124,
0.0284408797,
0.2609479427,
-0.2473602891,
-0.144023478,
-0.4466021657,
-0.4764086604,
0.8375440836,
0.8403224945,
-0.2541774511,
0.3551821113,
0.0667527318,
0.5141172409,
-0.3384497464,
-0.2113605589,
0.121016182,
0.2438369691,
-0.2680183351,
-0.2948144078,
0.1657710075,
-0.3103581667,
0.0813291371,
-0.0890460014,
-0.5195077062,
0.6278893948,
0.1415165216,
-0.2023980916,
0.2136065364,
0.9644331932,
-0.0303125065,
0.0874003321,
0.4495135546,
0.7919182181,
0.6769874096,
-0.1602899879,
1.0614210367,
-0.2686498165,
0.1545181274,
1.2142292261,
0.0214967337,
0.7585743666,
0.351323545,
0.1519637108,
0.5010963082,
0.3904321194,
0.0294472054,
0.8846236467,
-0.0299495123,
-0.1798781455,
-0.5348051786,
-0.0232571755,
-0.3207861185,
0.5007766485,
0.3077131212,
-0.5334404111,
-0.3994161785,
0.4020833969,
0.1437767595,
0.9430198073,
0.0135356793,
0.5686465502,
0.1563137621,
-0.3254990876,
0.2515287697,
-0.0437919535,
1.0299699306,
-0.7701534629,
0.1242935061,
-0.1874192208,
0.4112416208,
0.1021714136,
-0.7336627841,
0.305306077,
-0.196854353,
0.2313370854,
-0.5694128275,
0.9186393619,
-0.4025048614,
-0.0966790691,
0.4682682753,
0.4121796787,
-0.4586910903,
-0.1207672358,
-0.8455867767,
0.0953901261,
-0.1125420704,
-0.243676275,
0.4520725012,
0.4049358964,
0.4491231441,
0.7085095048,
0.2952895463,
-0.0721784681,
-0.2595211565,
-0.0889950246,
0.9049881101,
-0.4525673985,
-0.908361733,
-0.8403468132,
0.2982248068,
-0.3197446167,
-0.2910243571,
0.9828776717,
0.4368883371,
0.6294995546,
-0.0234646108,
0.8428903222,
0.2465395927,
0.3492590189,
-0.5106784105,
0.7605695128,
-0.3833871186,
0.2373123616,
-0.1883115917,
-0.6694459319,
-0.7565274835,
0.8390102983,
-0.1863101125,
-0.084765166,
0.511308074,
0.6242572665,
-0.1074424013,
-0.1636497676,
0.4248198867,
0.1981137544,
0.4101524353,
0.527284801,
0.7098107338,
-0.4717457891,
0.908415556,
-0.1368058324,
-0.1632969379,
0.0238713175,
-0.9368544221,
-1.103656888,
-0.4026854336,
-0.4549653828,
-0.2029594481,
0.4066355824,
0.7734728456,
0.6664790511,
-0.9624049067,
0.2949672639,
-0.329234004,
0.0327627771,
-0.154027164,
-0.2354195118,
0.523429811,
-0.6905043125,
-0.6127943993,
0.6579775214,
0.2670024037,
0.3382208049,
-0.4403689504,
0.0141588571,
-0.2630489469,
-0.0930301249,
0.2305295318,
0.0567771457,
-0.2962183058,
-0.180755198,
-0.0811089203,
-0.5053179264,
-0.0618680455,
0.548517406,
-0.7903349996,
0.4292519093,
0.4280410111,
1.1777732372,
0.0886009187,
0.1506776661,
0.6831492782,
-0.8285382986,
0.2058218122,
0.5469956398,
0.5377389789,
0.6347921491,
-0.3472527266,
0.1213039309,
0.2007738501,
-0.2502878606,
-0.5680525303,
0.1886340231,
-0.8785953522,
-0.504751265,
0.7342200875,
-0.7756223083,
-0.0140560716,
-0.251019001,
-0.1151103675,
0.1242919639,
-0.3718491495,
0.6930275559,
0.4947064817,
0.1866678745,
-0.2688805759,
0.0091190357,
0.4169579446,
0.6666766405,
-0.6700593233,
-0.1582461447,
0.3056400716,
0.1591054499,
0.2236706913,
-0.0371355861,
-0.1805549264,
0.0328311771,
0.242031768,
-0.4298755825,
-0.2250810117,
-0.1902587712,
-0.4824079573,
0.8576563001,
-0.1414061636,
-0.5677830577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11069v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11069v1
|
Deep Learning-based Sentiment Analysis in Persian Language
| 2024-03-17T03:15:29 | 2024-03-17T03:15:29 |
Mohammad Heydari, Mohsen Khazeni, Mohammad Ali Soltanshahi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been a growing interest in the use of deep learning
techniques for tasks in natural language processing (NLP), with sentiment
analysis being one of the most challenging areas, particularly in the Persian
language. The vast amounts of content generated by Persian users on thousands
of websites, blogs, and social networks such as Telegram, Instagram, and
Twitter present a rich resource of information. Deep learning techniques have
become increasingly favored for extracting insights from this extensive pool of
raw data, although they face several challenges. In this study, we introduced
and implemented a hybrid deep learning-based model for sentiment analysis,
using customer review data from the Digikala Online Retailer website. We
employed a variety of deep learning networks and regularization techniques as
classifiers. Ultimately, our hybrid approach yielded an impressive performance,
achieving an F1 score of 78.3 across three sentiment categories: positive,
negative, and neutral.
|
[
-0.5318157673,
-0.737226963,
0.1790204346,
0.3733284175,
-0.6031136513,
0.7668040991,
-0.5563752055,
-0.4413625002,
0.4504354298,
0.0606914572,
-0.6341507435,
-0.7770811319,
-0.2687941492,
0.1437157393,
-0.1024550125,
1.2252970934,
-0.0000137863,
0.4117701948,
0.1754275709,
-0.0788005516,
-0.3183587193,
-0.5257732868,
-0.7045357823,
-0.0980271548,
0.3132881522,
0.7042502165,
0.7956169844,
-0.4533168077,
0.5234001875,
0.2273640931,
-0.0403849185,
0.3547831178,
-0.2167178988,
0.1610172391,
-0.0404919498,
-0.3317588568,
-0.3542838991,
0.0539782047,
0.6364113688,
0.5757969022,
-0.135289222,
0.1303090751,
0.118518047,
1.0521558523,
-0.461596489,
-0.1424024105,
-0.2255731523,
0.4427924752,
0.0666195974,
0.0869893581,
-0.0856683925,
-0.8385401964,
0.0307275001,
-0.4323531985,
0.0595227778,
-0.3268580139,
0.9836200476,
0.1055152193,
-0.3119638562,
-0.1528572887,
-1.1759126186,
0.9950774908,
-0.8848543167,
0.2872668207,
0.1031205952,
0.4019318521,
0.2325699627,
-0.3314484656,
-0.7176091671,
-0.2414256334,
0.0054450938,
0.3919631839,
-0.1357613951,
-0.3307019174,
0.0036239517,
0.8859882355,
-0.39538306,
0.2309016287,
-0.1256834865,
0.220776692,
0.9314601421,
0.3255191147,
0.1526293457,
-0.2716166377,
-0.5363999009,
-0.196545139,
-0.2300475091,
0.2672981322,
0.4570915699,
0.2941405177,
-0.1201610342,
0.3767391741,
-0.5686373711,
0.3869197965,
0.2516750395,
0.1823036075,
0.5579007864,
-0.1657537818,
-0.3534519374,
0.0529316925,
1.2611753941,
0.3762476742,
0.4751785398,
0.1539128721,
-0.2064681798,
0.3243668377,
0.2530198097,
-0.5642499328,
0.0110875266,
0.4561040699,
-0.5549548268,
-0.6030449271,
0.1603828967,
-1.1559810638,
-0.7591230869,
-0.2951880991,
-0.1368004233,
-0.3480232656,
-0.7564200759,
0.1922411174,
0.0926150382,
0.6344129443,
0.3473646641,
-0.432785511,
0.6324872375,
0.5843226314,
0.7491015792,
-0.2076164186,
0.0593076609,
0.0228455048,
-0.408490181,
-0.5560125113,
0.6817816496,
-0.7244979143,
-0.2655041814,
0.0057531912,
-0.5688531995,
-0.0217984803,
-0.5079869628,
0.8352413774,
-0.6718675494,
0.2701766193,
0.1101764441,
-0.625377655,
-0.5950037241,
0.5341780782,
-0.6451830864,
1.0396767855,
-0.0032817069,
-0.7211180329,
0.2213367075,
-0.5130340457,
-0.7851432562,
0.3061744273,
-0.0140908901,
-0.7290155888,
0.3754298687,
0.3454231024,
0.7475397587,
-0.2603567541,
0.3286784589,
-0.422406435,
-0.1718852371,
0.6119259596,
-0.2105945349,
0.721476078,
0.5010210872,
-0.6021969914,
0.0634840652,
-0.7729841471,
0.033667583,
0.176970005,
-0.3108305335,
-0.3732969761,
-0.0725267902,
0.4154320657,
0.3755292296,
0.1769573689,
-0.8048571944,
0.2118244916,
-0.6814540625,
0.0985952467,
0.5163879991,
0.1604140252,
0.3037638664,
0.1620903611,
0.8815681338,
0.2694954872,
0.2822797298,
0.4690681398,
-0.4898783565,
-1.0770739317,
0.0262820758,
0.4190255702,
0.6099358201,
-0.5626354814,
0.5330320597,
-0.2980628014,
-0.6985313892,
-0.5209764242,
0.1505172402,
0.1199699044,
0.1989827901,
0.3339234591,
-0.3369191587,
-0.4918266535,
-0.9149191976,
-0.4099400043,
0.2518748641,
0.4276593029,
0.4457277358,
0.2448787838,
-0.4653208852,
0.7764020562,
-0.5743995905,
-0.6784212589,
-0.5784572363,
0.1276631802,
0.6361167431,
0.4713972807,
0.192270726,
-0.9078171253,
-0.9956015348,
0.3958480954,
-0.6115121841,
0.3347875476,
-0.2904687524,
0.0401768759,
0.2021058202,
0.2173270434,
-0.550447762,
0.2234385759,
0.492849946,
-0.2516492009,
0.432734549,
0.2933695018,
0.1151109487,
-1.5908914804,
0.0639264658,
0.4963916242,
-0.3109220266,
-0.6939890385,
0.0767425075,
-0.0924777687,
-0.2536694705,
-0.4347711802,
0.0532908551,
-0.2436581105,
0.0654676929,
-0.1943620294,
-0.5224585533,
0.0557319969,
0.5242689252,
0.3954919279,
0.4888050556,
0.6088343859,
-0.4456906617,
0.6523968577,
0.1659681946,
-0.4556429088,
0.2516903281,
-0.5273917913,
0.131370008,
0.1577435583,
0.1736782491,
-1.0278829336,
-0.0871405751,
0.5488762856,
-0.6602064371,
0.3748993576,
0.0718400329,
-0.5610812306,
-0.1522196829,
-0.504370749,
0.2955610752,
0.5868116617,
-0.3234565556,
0.7320247293,
0.3254291415,
-0.078632988,
-0.4362538755,
-0.4832342267,
0.2359993905,
-0.2995457351,
-0.4715988338,
0.1359245479,
0.1413212121,
-0.4292635322,
-0.0362549163,
0.2361802757,
-0.2567819953,
0.3497308791,
0.2179691494,
0.0821320713,
-0.3222079873,
0.1525439769,
0.0944121927,
-0.1616159081,
0.2206399739,
-0.0704611614,
0.8719561696,
-0.610509038,
0.1096139699,
-0.8410068154,
0.478069365,
0.4933084249,
-0.3115760386,
0.8047596216,
0.7168303132,
-0.450694263,
-0.4087002873,
-0.5707145929,
-0.0152448965,
-0.4269114733,
0.1151465699,
-0.107073687,
-0.6187879443,
0.2437930703,
-0.3718979955,
-0.3227511346,
0.7844418287,
0.7828071713,
-0.3096627891,
1.104380846,
0.7423994541,
-0.4969837368,
0.2504459918,
-0.377296418,
0.4570820034,
-0.579919517,
-0.3313883543,
-0.3776517808,
-0.5734727979,
-0.50181669,
-0.0857286975,
0.0876283422,
-0.0390456244,
0.0482250191,
-0.0037234765,
-0.2579576671,
0.4032525718,
0.6349464655,
0.359485805,
0.2418680191,
0.4124436378,
-0.2157656401,
-0.0670581907,
-0.4833043516,
-0.3993473351,
0.7770359516,
0.5088043213,
0.7600983381,
0.1808845252,
0.8403426409,
0.5004429221,
-0.1341555268,
-1.0255566835,
0.4768311381,
-0.3706674576,
-0.3074077666,
0.0361528881,
-0.3516209722,
-0.6002557278,
-0.0396556593,
-0.3885303438,
-0.0671140328,
0.4268166721,
-0.1560111642,
-0.7241532207,
0.1687665135,
-0.481497407,
0.8625243902,
-0.3758675456,
-0.3036700487,
-0.730949223,
-0.4424304962,
0.398367703,
0.0855718404,
0.234468773,
-0.1051673293,
0.0718814209,
0.7106521726,
-0.3020257354,
1.0218051672,
-0.0881435052,
-0.0229934417,
0.1294658631,
0.2440781593,
0.1691361219,
0.3115053177,
0.1742943227,
0.2654127181,
-0.5336992145,
-0.2549636066,
-0.3046816587,
0.9053313136,
-1.0948978662,
-0.2206857353,
-0.859598875,
-0.1254517883,
-0.6709308624,
-0.0105465138,
-0.0133937625,
0.1681780964,
-0.2764716148,
0.1167629808,
0.7426939607,
-0.4639350474,
0.4465548694,
0.2904600203,
-0.1529218405,
-0.4275709987,
1.2360472679,
-0.4239609838,
-0.082345888,
0.3325098753,
0.5664237142,
-0.2185697854,
-0.4254243374,
-0.6456147432,
0.1817290187,
-0.4924127758,
-0.2471910715,
-0.4831925631,
-0.2250344455,
-0.3187911808,
0.0340771712,
-0.5289435387,
-0.4635926187,
-0.6365029216,
-0.2033175528,
0.2969567478,
0.8139507771,
0.0694044828,
-0.0042751324,
-0.995814085,
0.3124590516,
0.3106759489,
0.5530863404,
0.156001851,
-0.1919018775,
-0.4327491522,
-0.0482090265,
-0.0720309019,
-0.8548996449,
0.7345016599,
0.3032971323,
0.1728510112,
0.5494346619,
-0.0187712312,
0.4386980832,
-0.1130614281,
0.8485413194,
0.3014490008,
-0.8202485442,
0.6872980595,
-0.3938931525,
0.1639804244,
0.6340909004,
0.8631724119,
-0.6225259304,
-0.2076572925,
-0.3625101745,
-0.6878100038,
0.4822361469,
0.1109526232,
0.5158957243,
0.1828956008,
0.2041917294,
0.2919167578,
0.2033875585,
-0.8130406141,
-0.350227803,
-0.2607761025,
-0.4182789922,
-0.229768157,
-0.4581539929,
0.1835997552,
-0.498024106,
0.750109911,
0.0245309845,
-0.0988150686,
0.0182480905,
-0.3165007532,
-0.2003086209,
0.38817963,
0.406706661,
0.3086920679,
-0.0442366116,
-0.3149628341,
0.0407979265,
-0.4393817782,
-0.0850269943,
0.1278402507,
-0.290664047,
-0.0261801239,
0.0062603443,
0.6440935135,
-0.2365327179,
-0.6965249181,
0.6204850674,
-0.2737307847,
-0.2312937975,
-0.7898674011,
-0.2239717841,
-0.0603553876,
0.3853055239,
0.4361255765,
0.2005974799,
0.6065708995,
-0.3974008262,
-0.113035962,
0.5217282176,
-0.6914046407,
-0.3371601701,
0.1453184187,
0.3945364654,
0.134144187,
0.8279600739,
-0.0610326752,
-0.920090735,
0.3403210938,
0.139047876,
1.3198316097,
-0.1181198657,
0.7127953768,
0.3547595739,
0.0018593277,
0.3618834019,
0.5849092603,
-0.059643168,
-0.8478928804,
-0.5548493862,
-0.9659377933,
-0.4975519478,
-0.0589841865,
-0.7804054618,
0.0039609987,
-0.9543802738,
-0.1249584332,
-0.0454159342,
0.3970189989,
-0.671421349,
0.6321702003,
0.7524622679,
0.6206973195,
-1.0176916122,
0.7157321572,
0.8618730903,
-0.415045023,
-0.7132868767,
-0.0896062404,
-0.3320817649,
-0.3984958529,
0.7897421718,
0.4064202905,
-0.3453679085,
-0.1635145545,
-0.3788081408,
-0.5107361078,
0.4407466054,
-0.2872233093,
-0.7844160795,
0.6109296679,
0.3673840463,
0.8795129657,
-0.252697587,
-0.07518363,
0.4920395911,
0.2546691,
-0.3197613358,
-0.5285841227,
-0.0868311301,
-0.6886111498,
-0.199594155,
0.1442514956,
-0.6657733321,
0.9392969012,
0.1598567516,
-0.304404974,
-0.1573496014,
0.7103404999,
-0.3679419756,
0.1389163733,
0.5096196532,
1.0248529911,
0.5198031664,
0.1634237021,
1.1800320148,
-0.0522046126,
0.4048258066,
0.835965991,
-0.2901904285,
1.0504139662,
0.2547543347,
-0.2778337002,
1.1450830698,
0.6287618876,
-0.200058952,
0.4523787498,
-0.0006980308,
-0.4280434251,
-0.5564451218,
-0.3042192459,
-0.396435529,
0.360838145,
0.4085881412,
-0.3808276653,
0.0614353158,
-0.0842263103,
-0.1349089742,
0.1992964745,
-0.5552595854,
1.1842132807,
0.1529875398,
-0.4376261532,
0.2885362804,
0.2501864135,
0.5966036916,
-0.2602860034,
-0.0651585609,
-0.4143679142,
0.6629427075,
-0.4614842534,
-0.8905701041,
0.3029133081,
0.1346663982,
-0.0954177082,
-0.239678055,
0.8224778771,
0.0336587578,
-1.1067022085,
0.1720862538,
0.6259827018,
-0.1547105163,
-0.3684237003,
-1.0062322617,
-0.232888177,
0.1398067474,
-0.3735508025,
0.2209239155,
-0.0401143543,
0.0549647622,
0.4358197451,
0.8207636476,
-0.078723371,
0.0291057788,
0.4066391289,
1.0722056627,
-0.9061676264,
-0.6315247416,
-1.0203155279,
0.3477123976,
-0.5159603357,
-0.580193162,
1.1945004463,
0.5954279304,
0.806488812,
-0.1598199606,
0.7509511113,
0.1534889191,
0.8949509859,
-0.3218321204,
0.5915898681,
-0.5188010931,
0.1501642764,
-0.2866517305,
-0.9562501311,
-0.5639578104,
0.7290948033,
-0.2984243035,
-0.069260262,
0.4377882481,
0.3764998317,
0.0422499925,
0.2816411853,
-0.0942811519,
0.1727209538,
-0.0347968563,
0.5428266525,
1.3247102499,
-0.2781766355,
0.277089566,
-0.8186206222,
-0.0395293422,
-0.1933970153,
-0.536558032,
-1.0852817297,
-0.1252928078,
-0.4722344279,
-0.556188941,
-0.2866262794,
1.0366208553,
0.3314646184,
-1.2730221748,
-0.4162507653,
-0.0982562676,
0.0454483032,
-0.3081186712,
-0.2935581505,
0.4135420322,
-0.3961798847,
-0.6491166353,
0.3429893553,
0.1304966509,
-0.232878536,
-0.4633640051,
-0.101090759,
-0.2617989182,
-0.179350853,
0.4391186833,
0.1666745543,
-0.4735460877,
0.3430902064,
0.1612421572,
-0.2015580237,
0.1375427395,
0.7097921968,
-1.1253917217,
0.2418597341,
0.4994031191,
0.7413276434,
0.4703209102,
0.0336190872,
0.6010226607,
-0.5660627484,
-0.1119436175,
0.8090890646,
0.2935059667,
0.5220840573,
-0.4701550007,
0.2419208288,
0.1930243373,
-0.1393721104,
-0.4039188325,
0.1931969076,
-0.996728003,
-0.5449165702,
1.1670361757,
0.0315939337,
-0.0452899039,
0.1153342798,
-0.2256264985,
-0.0582139902,
-0.5588964224,
0.8593860865,
0.2198873907,
0.1869523376,
-0.1842264384,
-0.0578047,
0.4543912113,
0.6167190075,
-0.7704319358,
-0.4108161032,
0.5902031064,
0.1178370863,
0.1427557319,
0.2291005254,
0.2052217126,
0.4266375303,
-0.3525892198,
-0.0519121885,
0.1568711996,
-0.2907104492,
-0.7083086967,
0.3423513174,
-0.0046451301,
-0.2401210815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13050v1
|
FlowMind: Automatic Workflow Generation with LLMs
| 2024-03-17T00:36:37 | 2024-03-17T00:36:37 |
Zhen Zeng, William Watson, Nicole Cho, Saba Rahimi, Shayleen Reynolds, Tucker Balch, Manuela Veloso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapidly evolving field of Robotic Process Automation (RPA) has made
significant strides in automating repetitive processes, yet its effectiveness
diminishes in scenarios requiring spontaneous or unpredictable tasks demanded
by users. This paper introduces a novel approach, FlowMind, leveraging the
capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) such as Generative Pretrained
Transformer (GPT), to address this limitation and create an automatic workflow
generation system. In FlowMind, we propose a generic prompt recipe for a
lecture that helps ground LLM reasoning with reliable Application Programming
Interfaces (APIs). With this, FlowMind not only mitigates the common issue of
hallucinations in LLMs, but also eliminates direct interaction between LLMs and
proprietary data or code, thus ensuring the integrity and confidentiality of
information - a cornerstone in financial services. FlowMind further simplifies
user interaction by presenting high-level descriptions of auto-generated
workflows, enabling users to inspect and provide feedback effectively. We also
introduce NCEN-QA, a new dataset in finance for benchmarking question-answering
tasks from N-CEN reports on funds. We used NCEN-QA to evaluate the performance
of workflows generated by FlowMind against baseline and ablation variants of
FlowMind. We demonstrate the success of FlowMind, the importance of each
component in the proposed lecture recipe, and the effectiveness of user
interaction and feedback in FlowMind.
|
[
-0.0513058193,
-0.5654079318,
0.5168606043,
-0.0317816511,
-0.1214769483,
0.0403117202,
0.0358223878,
-0.1520085037,
0.2178736925,
0.9461259246,
-0.966096282,
-0.2947555184,
-0.4890532792,
0.0176092889,
-0.5627304316,
0.6827254295,
-0.1849595606,
-0.1329942197,
-0.0523059666,
0.2280844003,
-0.4945704937,
-0.1860972941,
-0.8678956628,
-0.702059865,
0.3213317692,
0.2003878355,
0.750890255,
0.368383497,
0.5457177162,
0.3708010614,
0.2340635359,
0.1764476597,
-0.2645918727,
0.657800138,
-0.0364480652,
-0.4354488254,
-0.3789817691,
-0.2338442653,
0.0860480368,
0.4525257945,
-0.6212217212,
0.2284044623,
-0.0917712525,
1.0429941416,
-0.4589307904,
0.2403678,
-0.506513834,
0.3549461663,
-0.1312342137,
-0.2276866287,
-0.2064812928,
-0.4014795423,
0.1081051677,
-0.4338639975,
0.0356270857,
-0.0267478339,
0.6249838471,
0.8325515389,
0.0785725191,
-0.4898540378,
-0.829626739,
0.2294819206,
-0.7177083492,
0.1911915392,
-0.1458731145,
0.6067222357,
-0.3626711369,
-1.0766766071,
-0.76492697,
-0.0084877638,
0.09866108,
0.1451679468,
-0.4496918321,
-0.0573776178,
0.3418927491,
0.2844004929,
-0.5820288658,
-0.0993553177,
-0.1918990165,
-0.1485574096,
0.6313588619,
0.5090270638,
0.1110922322,
0.1008979827,
0.0290370714,
-0.3733798862,
-0.7184726596,
-0.1366474777,
0.5163291693,
0.2648310661,
0.1040432081,
0.7229236364,
-0.3506946266,
0.7369179726,
-0.0478384085,
-0.297277689,
0.1243826523,
0.0157619808,
-0.5349676609,
-0.2155272663,
0.8682039976,
-0.0591257215,
0.3991919458,
-0.1098211333,
-0.3151461184,
-0.2344237119,
0.4795266688,
-0.7272931337,
-0.4209699631,
0.3150105178,
-0.2828274071,
-0.2540677488,
0.0475217216,
-0.5029182434,
-0.4808620512,
-0.6522974968,
0.3385671079,
-0.3088441491,
-0.2871241271,
-0.1030786186,
-0.1826668978,
0.4931886196,
0.3922080398,
-0.5687476397,
0.0800214782,
0.7345802784,
0.6069697142,
-0.284145087,
-0.2141604275,
-0.6612817049,
0.3544741869,
-0.224120602,
0.874324739,
-0.2947695851,
-0.243637681,
0.0821512714,
-0.2726091444,
-0.0121061997,
-0.8565718532,
-0.0343966968,
-0.3089569807,
0.1438832432,
0.1409402341,
-0.7062766552,
-0.0280573592,
0.0720004067,
-0.3874189258,
0.6450983882,
0.2237004638,
-0.4670437872,
0.3893901408,
-1.0645829439,
-0.5398221016,
0.4957666993,
-0.3445234299,
-0.1980931312,
-0.1919735372,
-0.0480466075,
0.6242665648,
-0.1742227674,
0.3668653071,
-0.1655431688,
-0.027743483,
0.3897562325,
-0.3072380126,
0.6005989313,
0.3106177151,
-0.4451056719,
0.4736585021,
-0.4956899285,
-0.0180313811,
0.4000740647,
0.1416278183,
0.3097163737,
-0.1361656636,
-0.3006719649,
0.1350052357,
0.0727192983,
-0.1357260793,
0.1104495004,
-0.4140019119,
0.7158344388,
0.6791055799,
0.1487725526,
0.223975122,
-0.4773479104,
0.7991229892,
-0.0617081337,
0.1498752832,
-0.2274518907,
-0.3753327131,
-0.5130140781,
-0.1973319501,
-0.0937779471,
0.8458034992,
-0.8646053076,
0.4381883442,
0.1126544997,
-0.4789377451,
-0.1938921809,
0.5446640849,
-0.0703606308,
0.6534695029,
-0.1153381541,
-0.2542550862,
-0.4415737092,
-0.7937935591,
-0.0974442512,
-0.1577459872,
-0.3600579202,
0.3041047454,
0.2113445699,
-0.4426941574,
0.7549464703,
-1.0408980846,
-0.3094439805,
-0.4813958108,
0.2035498619,
0.3090398312,
0.2847039998,
0.05266333,
-0.5870206356,
-0.2375583202,
-0.4198049605,
-0.6727158427,
-0.1082495004,
-0.1644237339,
-0.4225207865,
0.1864564568,
0.5626823902,
-0.6163102984,
0.3992990851,
0.4017274976,
-0.2721178532,
0.3134505749,
-0.0620090403,
-0.3517432511,
-1.160528183,
0.0959419459,
-0.1583511829,
-0.2245740294,
-0.4319804907,
-0.0617392287,
-0.2694251835,
-0.4904555082,
-0.4599352777,
0.6813490987,
-0.1498186141,
-0.1741242558,
-0.487724781,
0.028480256,
-0.2041295022,
0.63656497,
0.2076942325,
0.7904841304,
0.6649339795,
-0.6218090653,
0.6774297953,
0.2537306845,
-0.0892711952,
0.5273995399,
-0.5382346511,
0.0692125261,
0.1194322333,
0.2829866707,
-0.620857954,
-0.4153421521,
0.4564570785,
-0.1985218972,
0.2473284155,
0.0751668587,
-0.4547255933,
-0.4944898486,
0.2232076526,
-0.1497613192,
0.8116420507,
-0.3224695921,
0.8794679046,
0.3444878757,
-0.329408586,
-0.3113300502,
-0.4903298616,
0.3158203661,
-0.1849358529,
-0.612052083,
-0.0501606464,
-0.1704487801,
-0.2251139283,
-0.2394775003,
-0.1213506386,
-0.0798423961,
0.2593567073,
0.4592259824,
0.2686209679,
0.070938684,
-0.2223428488,
-0.1228121519,
-0.1328484714,
0.3639186621,
-0.6102110147,
0.5039638877,
-0.0013651716,
-0.5218138099,
-0.4935550392,
0.1185564399,
0.435025692,
-0.0091068363,
0.4026039243,
0.6153720617,
-0.4587730467,
-0.5235112309,
-0.3613692224,
-0.3044134676,
-0.5788291693,
-0.1292195767,
-0.083988525,
-0.8146383166,
0.4756180346,
-0.2974532545,
0.3542968631,
0.3486733735,
1.1146246195,
-0.165099293,
0.3546123505,
0.5740229487,
0.3129806221,
0.5206446052,
-0.3545395434,
0.4183100164,
-0.422894299,
-0.2496184856,
-0.139723435,
-0.1182610095,
-0.2314543128,
-0.4106142223,
0.255443275,
-0.1796801835,
-0.1400159895,
0.3925930262,
-0.494223237,
0.2849604785,
0.6465315223,
-0.2275409997,
0.1233443245,
-0.292512089,
-0.1218423396,
0.3124103248,
-0.6901779771,
-0.641958952,
1.1793612242,
0.2712475657,
0.8256009221,
-0.0553606749,
0.9315279126,
0.5065582395,
0.6096399426,
-0.6796870232,
0.4919763505,
0.1086011231,
-0.2376463264,
-0.6080688238,
-0.4977262914,
-0.7728781104,
-0.2070413381,
-0.008383113,
-0.392092824,
-0.1874482781,
0.4871182144,
-0.6290094256,
0.2387084514,
-0.6690314412,
0.7897003293,
-0.0790986419,
-0.1563103944,
0.2566501498,
-0.4394933879,
0.5641273856,
-0.130129382,
-0.0892228112,
-0.162326932,
0.1376347989,
0.6014288068,
-0.9051760435,
0.7670516968,
-0.2854980528,
-0.5818181038,
0.6142733097,
0.0613638349,
0.5879141092,
0.1957629025,
0.2784703076,
0.0201412141,
-0.2402053475,
-0.0370966829,
-0.5802827477,
0.3913533092,
-0.2687860131,
-0.5678938627,
-0.2245112062,
-0.6626501679,
-0.2874433696,
0.1843036264,
0.0854832232,
0.0866474435,
-0.0058127102,
-0.1900059879,
0.6195379496,
0.000973073,
0.5365850925,
0.4211089909,
-0.1261494309,
-0.3815299571,
0.754478395,
-0.205592066,
0.1540440172,
0.3771656454,
0.0991417915,
-0.3210824728,
-0.4217862785,
-0.5708857775,
0.0564089119,
-0.6848136187,
-0.481262207,
-0.5983044505,
-0.4196236134,
-0.561021328,
-0.1771460623,
-0.3975648582,
-0.3137005866,
-0.1718805432,
0.107411176,
0.3915226758,
0.6960570216,
-0.1704034656,
0.20381248,
-0.7069012523,
0.4431948662,
0.8443824053,
0.3770448864,
0.0539053008,
-0.2968301475,
-0.072498396,
-0.323281616,
-0.5316394567,
-0.6164990067,
0.4767551422,
-0.0603125393,
0.5055229664,
0.5376300216,
0.0569775105,
0.2736191154,
-0.5163392425,
0.5714598894,
0.2336541563,
-0.8066210151,
0.5899521112,
-0.1753642112,
0.3390087783,
0.4317549467,
0.0022645316,
-0.4839624166,
-0.8951271772,
-0.6547852159,
-0.9401731491,
0.4128309488,
0.416441381,
0.0160126481,
0.0768768266,
0.4010654986,
0.3538968861,
0.3957286775,
-0.4482260942,
-0.218241483,
-0.3699378967,
-0.3895899951,
0.1526396573,
0.1743008792,
-0.2752853334,
0.0523592681,
0.5917671919,
-0.3308337629,
0.3236211836,
0.0492872074,
0.037509378,
-0.0751876533,
0.0329998806,
0.7693824172,
0.9172454476,
0.0653672069,
-0.2901936769,
-0.0104097063,
-0.4975112677,
0.1700441837,
0.0718290657,
-0.1621581018,
0.0269071292,
0.3362882137,
0.6568850875,
-0.272809118,
-1.0254670382,
0.3791413605,
-0.3538962603,
-0.7164103389,
-0.7878121138,
0.7667635679,
0.3794733882,
0.4160470068,
0.4998446703,
0.0561934002,
0.0634043068,
-0.3074074388,
0.244185403,
0.3459812999,
-0.0994497687,
0.0597232059,
0.6631813645,
0.2654129565,
-0.5289521217,
0.5733376741,
-0.3039801419,
-0.2925111651,
0.5196541548,
0.2039249688,
1.3494467735,
0.2141615748,
0.1552428752,
0.0505434088,
0.1674424708,
-0.0632917956,
0.5702371001,
-0.1945486218,
-0.5829924941,
-0.6292478442,
-0.6676383018,
-1.0444557667,
0.1652116776,
-0.5232236981,
0.02416756,
-0.5209705234,
0.0452659987,
-0.0215285365,
-0.3607405722,
-0.8135300279,
0.0770155638,
0.3703026474,
0.8715723157,
-0.6330678463,
0.5521113873,
0.6638034582,
-0.1635064185,
-0.8532081842,
0.0857479572,
-0.0352552123,
-0.9366295934,
0.5551367402,
-0.1246161908,
-0.0569000915,
-0.1485896707,
-0.4711538255,
-0.7430375814,
1.1935021877,
0.4337830245,
-0.5691260695,
0.1499793082,
0.1991074085,
0.3642356396,
-0.4643563032,
-0.0151838651,
0.3787104189,
0.490673393,
0.6206465364,
-0.5657433867,
0.080249019,
-0.188027218,
-0.0879459679,
0.2786024213,
-0.4098477066,
0.4869585037,
-0.214898169,
-0.1596332192,
-0.1924017966,
0.8535007238,
0.394643873,
0.3172006905,
0.5478098392,
0.572227478,
0.832597971,
-0.1190677732,
0.7890224457,
-0.5710006356,
-0.1369978935,
1.0638659,
-0.6123094559,
0.5490954518,
0.4513674676,
-0.2357798964,
0.5510406494,
0.5317683816,
-0.0980230793,
0.2067614943,
0.6372420192,
-0.0128768347,
-0.1987219006,
0.2871304452,
-0.0259424988,
0.3846932948,
0.0401892029,
-0.1611219943,
-0.072771363,
0.1041862667,
0.0201872252,
0.0001300647,
-0.2117558867,
1.0709825754,
0.2510375082,
-0.8727918267,
0.2258883566,
-0.1632298082,
0.5565397739,
-0.6726001501,
-0.0215664953,
-0.4792421758,
0.0403714478,
-0.0180345234,
-0.7314447165,
0.6248350143,
0.2169941515,
-0.0039114081,
-0.6073479056,
0.6563512683,
-0.2019249946,
-0.4670082033,
-0.153749764,
0.6772127151,
0.3038685322,
-0.0489410236,
-0.6577036977,
-0.4031501412,
-0.0090048173,
-0.2721353769,
0.1041087732,
0.6119542718,
0.2513841391,
1.1005259752,
0.7780013084,
0.1827567965,
-0.0398068056,
0.2991288006,
0.6780325174,
-0.8049290776,
-0.5631051064,
-0.7528100014,
0.0705336556,
-0.0278985891,
-0.3292119503,
0.1872875243,
0.3093757331,
0.6616321206,
-0.108940348,
0.7351974249,
-0.0403984711,
0.434263438,
-0.6950210929,
0.6878556609,
-0.3089613914,
0.1873216927,
-0.2299648821,
-0.8163887858,
-0.140503034,
0.3398002386,
0.0520712882,
-0.0295122378,
0.5982030034,
0.5378060341,
0.1712891459,
0.0374715738,
0.1067772061,
-0.1338593513,
0.4209774137,
0.4947853684,
0.6476064324,
-0.0064147119,
0.7314795852,
-0.1990841031,
-0.0204363018,
-0.1063586324,
-1.1201695204,
-0.7958103418,
-0.2964735925,
-0.6240154505,
-0.1433930695,
-0.3118725121,
0.7274871469,
0.525932014,
-0.6367390156,
-0.4059014618,
-0.3414504826,
0.248588562,
-0.3328998685,
-0.2493810803,
-0.0113914926,
-0.5750816464,
-0.4461788833,
0.2847295105,
0.626588583,
0.3609199524,
-0.6668223143,
-0.3074997663,
0.4452329874,
0.1860331148,
0.2932038307,
0.4210231304,
-0.4791059494,
0.1943136007,
0.0143696582,
0.0444338731,
-0.0627467111,
0.8950392008,
-0.4724274278,
-0.0732245594,
0.3259567618,
0.730104506,
0.4909354746,
-0.1133718342,
0.9261481762,
-0.364037782,
-0.0642214492,
0.3404100537,
0.3500187397,
0.2411295772,
-0.419274956,
0.6339017153,
0.1940689385,
-0.4306810498,
-0.6109151244,
0.2989043593,
-0.7463105321,
-0.2159800828,
0.9113540053,
-0.015083001,
-0.3970376551,
0.082600981,
0.0487912185,
0.1554006338,
-0.3801268637,
0.7501529455,
0.4835209548,
-0.4868803322,
-0.051186014,
-0.5097001791,
0.6299596429,
0.300413847,
-1.0738042593,
0.2531016171,
0.2492440641,
0.2373685092,
-0.0201343484,
0.7460607886,
0.1501435339,
0.1762378961,
-0.1368041188,
0.2927722633,
-0.3411453068,
-0.1243138239,
0.0652714595,
0.2812020481,
0.0025919101,
-0.0137449615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15440v1
|
Linguistics from a topological viewpoint
| 2024-03-16T23:10:42 | 2024-03-16T23:10:42 |
Rui Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 91F20, 62R40, 55N31, 55U10
|
Typological databases in linguistics are usually categorical-valued. As a
result, it is difficult to have a clear visualization of the data. In this
paper, we describe a workflow to analyze the topological shapes of South
American languages by applying multiple correspondence analysis technique and
topological data analysis methods.
|
[
-0.3618944287,
-0.7603201866,
0.4718690217,
0.1511546969,
-0.4105346799,
0.5280115604,
-0.2180118561,
-0.4492959976,
0.8632788062,
0.8044735193,
-0.5366865396,
-0.7217764258,
-0.3537068069,
0.0320075788,
-0.5420998931,
0.670943141,
0.0990231186,
-0.144585222,
0.0019497583,
-0.2664760947,
-0.1869508475,
-0.8668234944,
-0.7175107002,
-0.1521480978,
0.176365152,
0.5499783754,
0.9264297485,
0.4774030745,
0.707339108,
0.3316396177,
-0.3051353395,
0.0055010179,
-0.5605605841,
0.3423168659,
-0.1426459551,
-0.615424633,
-0.3037935197,
-0.100571394,
0.654430151,
1.1284761429,
-0.1853873581,
0.3189280927,
-0.2771258056,
0.9588105679,
-0.0191846546,
0.52458179,
-0.3637116253,
0.2429920882,
-0.9113481641,
-0.3544600904,
-0.0751177669,
-0.9497492313,
0.3422026038,
-0.3915122151,
0.266643703,
0.4651423097,
0.8261508346,
0.0814384744,
-0.3789299428,
-0.2640688419,
-0.868257165,
0.3316794038,
-0.4365918338,
0.5965439677,
0.4458165467,
0.5440239906,
-0.2484365404,
-0.3942390978,
-0.5420966744,
0.1020874009,
-0.4016464055,
-0.1581971347,
0.2308543772,
-0.1185773388,
0.0436743982,
0.7590433955,
-0.8118892908,
-0.0637265816,
-0.9149045944,
-0.0491281636,
0.7969424129,
0.4253919721,
0.7891649008,
-0.2963638306,
0.3660824299,
-0.0341781415,
-0.7598847151,
0.0433132201,
0.6858193874,
0.4511642456,
-0.3326782286,
0.8344826698,
-0.0565962605,
1.1584966183,
-0.4111471474,
-0.2963093519,
0.1842418313,
-0.4803237915,
0.0714961886,
-0.3664171994,
0.8805724978,
-0.1300924271,
0.7325898409,
-0.3135696352,
0.334546566,
-0.2191696763,
0.2886548936,
-0.0257059261,
-0.3090728223,
0.3769204617,
-0.2854354382,
-0.3114335239,
-0.018418001,
-1.2120671272,
-0.4973132312,
-0.7102389932,
-0.3395007253,
-0.5698584914,
-0.4088412523,
0.1378475577,
-0.0647941604,
0.0418792404,
0.1002633944,
-0.8376250267,
0.5217708349,
0.6101602912,
1.1106053591,
-0.2129615098,
-0.4161450267,
0.2300561965,
0.1864206642,
-0.3864767551,
1.0863342285,
-0.7924189568,
-0.0545693301,
-0.0402159914,
-0.0787018612,
-0.2816109359,
-0.29019171,
0.2060021758,
-0.1609490961,
0.2138849199,
-0.0049864827,
-0.1656155884,
-0.5700106621,
0.1532265395,
-0.7748189569,
1.239716053,
0.3177268505,
-0.69055444,
0.3909988403,
-0.5555126071,
-0.5099418759,
0.0552060045,
-0.4503173828,
-0.0267219562,
0.1174543574,
-0.1880524904,
0.170896396,
-0.3326756656,
0.4572108984,
-0.3414942324,
-0.2506639361,
-0.028796019,
0.5613886714,
1.219522357,
0.095432438,
-0.1809141189,
0.1924651116,
-1.0229672194,
-0.0439875573,
0.0198839456,
0.048092436,
-0.4185068011,
0.07898321,
0.0485656597,
0.4599033296,
-0.245718196,
-0.31316939,
0.6694687009,
-0.516043067,
0.4677863121,
0.2880870104,
-0.0300449207,
0.4404899478,
-0.1479422152,
0.7991102934,
-0.0516796522,
-0.087165907,
0.6760397553,
-0.7125613093,
-1.083647728,
-0.2289587259,
0.1877570748,
0.7242863774,
-0.6072540283,
0.2686092556,
-0.5614409447,
-0.7669200301,
-0.4461587965,
-0.3197726011,
0.1541000307,
0.10276898,
-0.0982635617,
-0.3707758486,
-0.6749808788,
-0.8862011433,
-0.0862383991,
-0.2335191816,
0.1764931679,
0.5349704623,
0.538589716,
0.0796694532,
0.6791736484,
-0.672757566,
-0.3629021347,
0.0492828265,
0.2299690545,
0.3886153698,
0.3515495062,
0.8519836664,
-0.3011916578,
-0.3801934421,
0.2996901274,
-0.8401148319,
-0.012360923,
0.3325326443,
-0.4377651513,
0.1147637889,
0.5619695783,
-0.1703788042,
0.5079356432,
0.405130446,
-0.59959656,
0.6947321892,
0.2819466293,
0.2837384641,
-0.7910223603,
0.228417933,
-0.243506819,
0.0487514101,
-0.9236178398,
0.2442768365,
-0.4719159603,
-0.6841391325,
-0.1561683267,
0.4714690447,
-0.6244193912,
-0.4605204165,
0.2055263519,
0.1739004701,
-0.2367136031,
0.5484973788,
0.4932336211,
0.5933083296,
0.9143272638,
-0.4608178437,
0.5707845092,
0.4929442108,
-0.1348290294,
0.70764184,
-0.3262605667,
0.2036351264,
-0.3821851015,
-0.1199909225,
-1.0153411627,
-0.322894603,
0.3699242175,
-0.2785425782,
0.2219608575,
-0.5428712964,
-0.4250318408,
-0.3910439014,
-0.1749162227,
0.7693645358,
-0.1935808361,
-0.150263235,
0.3149754107,
0.8010087013,
-0.4993417263,
-0.2094364315,
-0.6157009006,
0.237757802,
-0.6067193747,
-0.9346530437,
-0.0313289501,
0.2206451297,
-0.5290827751,
-0.11283499,
0.169366613,
-0.7142019868,
-0.1833944768,
0.0707494691,
0.0540328287,
-0.2803142071,
-0.1582887918,
-0.2832765877,
0.1624270827,
-0.0802363083,
-0.562428534,
0.873201251,
-0.2106359154,
0.0171886776,
-0.3544909954,
0.4256724715,
0.8332278132,
-0.2114045173,
0.7653434873,
0.0075459611,
-0.5627743006,
0.0077926815,
-0.3015384674,
0.2204652727,
-0.3412196338,
-0.3309188783,
-0.5673044324,
-0.5554071665,
0.8303380013,
0.2775113285,
-0.2522040904,
0.097182624,
0.6047569513,
-0.1196490601,
0.104511708,
0.5356650352,
-0.0668995902,
0.2093117982,
-0.4260118306,
0.4775974154,
-0.4701645076,
-0.7078875303,
-1.1048784256,
-0.0741777495,
-0.4907719195,
-0.3117548525,
0.3654343784,
-0.1573418379,
-0.0150276916,
0.8076581359,
-0.428512454,
0.2255196571,
0.6256042719,
-0.2515222132,
0.3382418454,
0.3061429858,
-0.3117444515,
-0.1432280689,
-0.5170302987,
-0.5409282446,
1.0517611504,
-0.1328682601,
0.6846625805,
0.4791126251,
0.5485411286,
-0.1401205808,
-0.4242303967,
-0.9444277287,
0.2732846439,
0.0585868135,
-0.5220885277,
-0.5499265194,
-0.0967688411,
-1.0360996723,
0.4333139956,
-0.4152794182,
-1.374815464,
0.7601314783,
-0.0674377307,
0.1833912283,
0.292948842,
-0.4102838039,
0.7029515505,
-0.0789470971,
0.00196415,
0.0339363851,
-0.5141571164,
0.6011291146,
-0.1851378679,
0.4002854824,
0.0561620072,
0.5721487403,
0.9027192593,
-0.3373020887,
0.4950973392,
0.3750426173,
-0.1982450187,
0.23760207,
0.6736437678,
0.0771915317,
0.1349619329,
-0.2576233149,
0.3750495017,
0.3193753362,
-0.4340221584,
-0.6374878883,
0.4614627957,
-0.3931982815,
-0.2931569219,
-0.6712574959,
-0.6264090538,
-0.5740460753,
0.4591267407,
0.3754893541,
0.4327931106,
-0.077224195,
-0.1932376921,
0.0156171359,
-0.0587546155,
0.0592287555,
0.2130755186,
-0.2857801318,
-0.0493111461,
0.9297481775,
0.2793489397,
-0.0001618661,
0.0731873065,
-0.1359951645,
-0.3094194531,
-0.6760011315,
-0.1272241026,
0.5816853642,
-0.3280985057,
0.1317049712,
-0.3685685992,
-0.2348097414,
-0.5401915908,
-0.0707492083,
-0.1112922281,
-0.9166056514,
0.1806746423,
-0.0111192754,
0.2490328401,
0.9325570464,
0.1188191772,
0.5425951481,
-0.4063591063,
0.3439021111,
-0.1377996206,
0.7160971165,
-0.2064106762,
0.0745161921,
0.1567780972,
-0.0860660672,
0.015706813,
-1.22078228,
0.3556292355,
0.1782805622,
0.480265677,
0.4807447493,
-0.4395995736,
0.8155059814,
-0.4594709873,
0.4799488187,
-0.156788379,
-0.9732092619,
0.6523213387,
-0.4650377631,
-0.2479083389,
0.5626305938,
0.499058336,
-1.0389168262,
-0.7582121491,
-0.6762197018,
-0.5270257592,
0.8714134097,
0.6426052451,
-0.7544370294,
0.2617310584,
0.2953362763,
-0.0617232807,
0.1693239212,
-0.4767744839,
-0.4983982146,
-0.3724809885,
-0.1395021677,
-0.1866690814,
-0.0819039494,
-0.3116057217,
-0.5292044282,
0.3844205439,
-0.0274905358,
0.264757216,
-0.2688190937,
-0.2640743256,
0.2484341264,
0.347192198,
0.6367726326,
1.1613340378,
-0.1032166258,
0.2511034012,
-0.2419235557,
-0.5254154801,
0.1233354434,
-0.1249966174,
-0.1349430978,
0.1433692276,
0.499864012,
0.5645549893,
-0.1718806922,
-0.2778842151,
0.1149714142,
0.2092456073,
-0.0641831234,
-0.1767013222,
-0.2609411776,
0.156491369,
-0.0953142494,
-0.1108562648,
-0.2558923066,
0.6639363766,
-0.712040782,
-0.0794827491,
0.2497241944,
-0.2746663988,
-0.404121995,
0.1648484319,
0.054477863,
-0.381894052,
0.8690921664,
-0.0008431129,
-0.7074065804,
0.7476244569,
0.4341499209,
0.6116153598,
-0.0050247698,
0.449990958,
0.5326123238,
0.587500751,
0.3319659531,
0.5974095464,
0.260202229,
-0.3273591399,
-0.0652161166,
-0.6273361444,
-0.383069098,
0.0948902965,
-0.7000408173,
0.4412617385,
-0.3281531036,
0.1213944629,
0.3834100962,
-0.3095167577,
-0.6126481295,
0.1341105253,
-0.1086825728,
0.5471174121,
-1.0256090164,
0.6309141517,
0.9111399651,
-0.3611075878,
-0.5285621285,
-0.3936959505,
0.6588908434,
-0.9409140944,
0.5859092474,
-0.3556425273,
-0.228006646,
-0.292504698,
-0.2065345943,
-1.2023640871,
0.4874242842,
0.2686575651,
-0.2641337812,
-0.0660197735,
0.7076619267,
0.9442571998,
-0.2365092635,
0.1240328029,
1.0873504877,
0.6145899892,
-0.155651316,
-1.0824369192,
0.0572164059,
-0.4437558651,
-0.030986568,
0.7851840854,
-0.3477262557,
0.6336514354,
0.1215010658,
-0.6991882324,
-0.3924878836,
0.2437101752,
0.0168767609,
-0.1921170056,
0.2068077028,
0.5174373388,
1.020080924,
-0.3996896446,
0.6532036066,
-0.3850993514,
0.6364175081,
0.7098025084,
0.0018133732,
0.3378250301,
0.5086631775,
-0.3674048781,
0.705242157,
0.8207284808,
-0.0242781118,
-0.0566357002,
0.6464064121,
0.2434080392,
0.1026804447,
0.0182937905,
-0.3993597031,
0.7876061201,
0.6394175291,
0.2262348533,
-0.3053176999,
-0.2687712908,
-0.050958246,
0.1461797655,
0.0655521601,
0.6441221237,
-0.1301790476,
-0.5467081666,
0.7222315669,
-0.5086452961,
0.0786461681,
-0.1728414595,
-0.0248850547,
-0.4348356426,
-0.5470343232,
-0.4232918918,
-1.115229249,
0.8013299704,
-0.1762867868,
0.0625159442,
0.3305046558,
0.2725611329,
-0.4339980483,
-0.475300163,
0.156152308,
0.5054748654,
0.7721146941,
0.2881703675,
-0.3908958435,
-0.3042237461,
-0.3551344573,
0.173345983,
-0.2915897965,
0.4491640627,
-0.6014671326,
0.9904206395,
0.5007814765,
0.4137907028,
0.3510890901,
0.0641769618,
0.5212258101,
-1.0557556152,
-0.6011984944,
-0.6065434813,
0.0243932717,
-0.18719998,
-0.4419286847,
0.4026845396,
0.6685689092,
0.6199765801,
-0.1160204783,
0.4952287078,
-0.4495589435,
0.4121690392,
-0.5573486686,
0.7135882378,
-0.345156908,
0.0385477133,
-0.5580871701,
-1.1142060757,
-0.7137570381,
0.5648929477,
-0.0535310917,
-0.4781791568,
1.189406395,
0.5647426844,
-0.3045318723,
0.0463845581,
-0.074216567,
0.166456759,
0.1019448414,
0.4482379854,
0.7444001436,
0.0075069685,
0.3956650496,
-0.5827397704,
-0.2689945698,
-0.0737962425,
-0.5257071853,
-1.0982791185,
-0.9008406401,
-0.0100740558,
-0.5324795246,
0.1111539006,
0.2169191092,
0.8739817142,
-1.0070403814,
-0.8877743483,
0.0073647378,
0.3537985981,
-0.2195655853,
-0.2565502524,
0.7576817274,
-0.2416816056,
-0.8818158507,
0.282272011,
0.3788999021,
0.078675665,
-0.1906615943,
0.4392191768,
-0.3720878661,
-0.1479461342,
0.5596866608,
0.6042357087,
-0.7371603251,
-0.3349835873,
-0.1726721376,
-0.1507639885,
0.2673567832,
1.1972310543,
-0.254969418,
0.4983605146,
0.7305297852,
0.1855519414,
0.6225667596,
-0.0303354822,
0.8428893089,
-0.4268803298,
0.5877205729,
0.1256218106,
0.5333306789,
0.0960696563,
-0.4438110292,
0.9889587164,
0.284129858,
-0.2461309433,
-0.6407471299,
0.459780395,
-1.4054838419,
-0.1607328653,
1.1230825186,
0.1832878143,
-0.1851307601,
-0.6645989418,
-0.3152909875,
0.068394199,
0.1280015707,
0.7321790457,
1.1572523117,
-0.35978508,
-0.0380538478,
-0.4387298524,
0.7466526031,
-0.103202045,
-1.2588607073,
-0.1972838789,
0.5268377662,
0.2603929043,
0.4462532401,
0.5838370323,
-0.2740209103,
-0.0466204509,
0.0217185002,
-0.1669021994,
0.3180509508,
-0.8344549537,
-0.3076228499,
0.0389366932,
-0.1118953228,
0.0855391026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11025v1
|
Pre-Trained Language Models Represent Some Geographic Populations Better Than Others
| 2024-03-16T22:01:39 | 2024-03-16T22:01:39 |
Jonathan Dunn, Benjamin Adams, Harish Tayyar Madabushi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper measures the skew in how well two families of LLMs represent
diverse geographic populations. A spatial probing task is used with
geo-referenced corpora to measure the degree to which pre-trained language
models from the OPT and BLOOM series represent diverse populations around the
world. Results show that these models perform much better for some populations
than others. In particular, populations across the US and the UK are
represented quite well while those in South and Southeast Asia are poorly
represented. Analysis shows that both families of models largely share the same
skew across populations. At the same time, this skew cannot be fully explained
by sociolinguistic factors, economic factors, or geographic factors. The basic
conclusion from this analysis is that pre-trained models do not equally
represent the world's population: there is a strong skew towards specific
geographic populations. This finding challenges the idea that a single model
can be used for all populations.
|
[
-0.4732397199,
-0.3360022306,
0.6573138237,
0.2375562489,
-0.1149752885,
0.2991781235,
-0.4486752748,
-0.4726916254,
0.1624248475,
0.3564321399,
-0.466953814,
-0.5384231806,
-0.7540060282,
0.0766632929,
-0.2941243947,
0.5918853283,
0.3265679479,
0.3544681668,
-0.0292478632,
-0.2864135802,
0.0138446875,
-0.9107668996,
-0.1167853624,
-0.3432883322,
0.3455374241,
0.4636916816,
1.082093358,
0.2592900991,
0.6502235532,
0.2776326537,
-0.2003174573,
-0.1879940182,
-0.9460186958,
-0.0539917238,
-0.1244642064,
-0.6274312139,
-0.1361698657,
0.2010530233,
0.5194811225,
1.2073482275,
0.021649966,
0.058501076,
-0.1971316934,
0.3330882788,
-0.519110024,
-0.3496505022,
-0.7992611527,
-0.0552929081,
-0.4354736209,
-0.0456469208,
-0.2110135704,
-0.5386189222,
0.6840155125,
-0.5560485125,
0.49945876,
0.2998561263,
0.9332215786,
0.1359295696,
-0.6115779877,
-0.1409508735,
-1.0306442976,
0.9111158848,
-0.7348756194,
0.3149576187,
0.2986987829,
0.1895372421,
-0.2200452387,
-0.1194011867,
-0.2999649346,
-0.4283085763,
-0.1344176233,
0.2710853815,
0.0695715621,
-0.147209391,
0.1483965069,
0.40683043,
-0.7383052707,
0.381526947,
-0.6841695905,
-0.1200275049,
0.8013886809,
0.0996413231,
0.4831432998,
0.0411256514,
-0.2612831891,
-0.1579485387,
-0.9424839616,
0.0964443609,
0.6907383204,
0.5471499562,
-0.2331971377,
0.5751051307,
0.0846936703,
0.5394349098,
-0.2136946619,
-0.0607246682,
0.1957191825,
-0.2572337389,
0.1057870984,
-0.2496860176,
0.6920294762,
0.1365612447,
0.767344594,
-0.2248227298,
-0.0160347112,
0.0249655861,
0.1215439588,
-0.3575312793,
-0.1408205032,
-0.0639518276,
-0.1810535192,
0.1007499695,
0.1764074713,
-0.9784446955,
-0.1126897782,
-0.2448311001,
-0.2220748067,
-0.1588914543,
-0.5892044306,
0.2373099923,
0.1265948862,
0.3435584605,
0.0976743326,
-1.1064052582,
0.1674266607,
0.6978051662,
0.8009526134,
-0.4206314981,
-0.5982177258,
0.3443821073,
-0.2065093368,
-0.4017766118,
1.034096837,
-0.7715885639,
-0.5445116162,
0.2125535011,
-0.1711317897,
-0.1019729823,
-0.703435123,
-0.0577353537,
-0.6006205082,
0.0532966964,
-0.6337199211,
-0.1180595681,
0.1062661633,
0.0788199678,
-0.6414097548,
1.2507435083,
0.3575491607,
-0.6999671459,
0.9152581096,
-0.3915045857,
-0.2138052136,
0.0629594922,
-0.1454896331,
-0.19575046,
0.2945712209,
0.3369093835,
0.0940236598,
-0.0698432997,
0.1484806985,
-0.735258162,
-0.3730616271,
0.1581315398,
-0.174922049,
0.8801904321,
0.3626914322,
-0.2050158381,
0.101767689,
-0.6141735315,
0.0741532072,
0.2544613183,
-0.320709765,
-0.5084972382,
0.1377039552,
-0.07038524,
0.1172868311,
0.1198948696,
-0.4292379618,
0.2333480865,
-0.5792359114,
0.3649950922,
0.361979872,
-0.332159698,
0.9177613854,
-0.0827267468,
0.8399568796,
0.1196142286,
0.0522469319,
0.1478141993,
-0.3123536408,
-0.6116111875,
-0.2644925714,
-0.1300372183,
0.4956045449,
-0.2979899347,
0.1190200597,
-0.6223824024,
-0.7557653189,
-0.3391198814,
-0.0762777328,
0.080162771,
-0.0124615049,
-0.0641133115,
-0.297600925,
-0.6061687469,
-0.7217288017,
-0.3398450613,
-0.2928701341,
0.0850467756,
0.4567822218,
0.425000459,
-0.2288152874,
1.1116834879,
-0.3396974206,
0.2172408253,
-0.3431245089,
0.1195365712,
-0.0755516738,
0.0273919124,
0.9303823709,
-0.6494871378,
-0.4303399324,
-0.0470071808,
-0.3746001124,
-0.3298812807,
0.1081182063,
-0.4448301792,
-0.0704962313,
0.1529255509,
-0.3210537434,
0.5288543701,
0.7458046079,
-0.2181922942,
0.6109980941,
-0.1726689339,
0.1900066733,
-0.8040055633,
-0.0389094539,
0.0154299308,
-0.0147463679,
-0.5568757653,
0.0296914056,
-0.0805823505,
-0.2588968575,
-0.4734366536,
0.3604952991,
-0.6556625366,
-0.6742213368,
-0.0097332047,
0.2508508861,
-0.2386082262,
-0.0016019488,
0.305965215,
0.9936283827,
0.4271374941,
-0.5613114238,
0.1384758502,
0.1447006762,
-0.4862134159,
0.3273802102,
-0.49941504,
-0.020515576,
-0.2682541013,
-0.0148961656,
-1.1112056971,
-0.2862150073,
-0.2840250432,
-0.3367279172,
-0.0621132106,
-0.07215444,
-0.3191919923,
-0.7081118226,
0.195618093,
0.331463933,
0.4325802922,
-0.5370463729,
0.3203024268,
0.4260108173,
-0.2397020161,
-0.4112235308,
-0.6779707074,
-0.3534446657,
-0.5866525173,
-0.6849719286,
-0.0472324267,
0.1083047688,
-0.4261737764,
-0.1321621686,
-0.05172823,
-0.3154857755,
0.1146528423,
0.1449799091,
0.3031275272,
-0.5806447864,
0.0715711564,
-0.5351823568,
0.0127346432,
0.00460093,
-0.3259907961,
0.7034067512,
-0.0024851584,
-0.6383343339,
0.2398902327,
0.4114265144,
0.8145694733,
-0.4431660771,
0.8056417704,
0.1744271815,
-0.211764589,
0.0263147522,
-0.6034404039,
-0.0821918696,
-0.4751236737,
0.6558163166,
-0.2220362872,
-1.1206108332,
0.8312862515,
-0.1989928633,
0.0672440454,
0.3626302481,
0.4663665295,
-0.2037346214,
0.7416261435,
0.9940243363,
-0.3193367124,
0.4091260135,
-0.1188825071,
0.5671309829,
-0.2948747575,
-0.1038414463,
-0.7900259495,
-0.1931210309,
-0.4889970124,
-0.1194934547,
0.1958384961,
0.2571774423,
-0.5508849025,
0.2320799977,
-0.393486619,
0.5280166864,
0.7217156291,
-0.2776361406,
-0.0596688092,
0.3715030551,
-0.1769189835,
-0.5754215717,
-0.7082481384,
-0.8128354549,
1.1895647049,
0.1209634393,
0.9941819906,
0.0568349697,
0.6704469323,
-0.221664682,
0.6088863015,
-0.4484962523,
0.325168997,
-0.2940698564,
-0.7708936334,
-0.4253270328,
-0.4410914481,
-1.0883917809,
0.3617882431,
-0.2863797545,
-0.6307311058,
0.2841250896,
0.2466340661,
-0.5180785656,
0.389090836,
-0.669696331,
0.620141983,
-0.823448658,
0.0461829677,
0.102197431,
-0.3550608456,
0.3140865862,
-0.1874645948,
0.3166040778,
-0.3496089578,
0.3177200556,
0.458556354,
-0.3176072836,
0.7290249467,
-0.0419132411,
-0.115420714,
0.3144626915,
-0.0931396261,
-0.0796872154,
-0.1822278351,
-0.1731940657,
0.3424815834,
0.1096243262,
-0.6060047746,
-0.4072031677,
0.4784140289,
-1.3119806051,
-0.6288238764,
-0.4165186584,
-0.5454614162,
-0.2115758061,
0.2488422394,
0.6743311286,
0.0343738571,
-0.3197670877,
0.079344511,
0.4344777763,
-0.2771173716,
0.0894040838,
0.5599104762,
-0.4371513128,
-0.2197638154,
0.4154386222,
0.3508966863,
0.67113024,
0.1780823767,
0.2047285438,
-0.3254877925,
-0.3831035495,
0.0454887189,
0.4125199914,
-0.6312323213,
0.2801184356,
-0.5500292778,
-0.1597942263,
-0.6010402441,
-0.3824759722,
-0.3386585712,
0.1453769505,
-0.2392677367,
-0.1517581493,
0.2201916575,
1.1257725954,
-0.1020331681,
0.8217315078,
-0.4436038136,
-0.0710099861,
0.2287382483,
0.1013404429,
-0.1540690064,
-0.4256123304,
-0.0139780417,
0.3003941774,
-0.0391054004,
-1.1666833162,
0.6050711274,
0.1431893706,
0.8745638132,
0.5702953935,
-0.0805834234,
1.1033592224,
-0.6048885584,
0.9629173279,
-0.1561591327,
-0.674367547,
0.4124157429,
-0.3083688915,
0.4811644256,
0.6717776656,
0.750234127,
-0.4742026925,
-0.5307943225,
-0.4074928761,
-0.9228409529,
0.5366219282,
-0.2540400624,
0.4054883122,
-0.0945947245,
0.4257440269,
0.1628783196,
-0.0183314774,
-1.0582407713,
-0.2989876866,
-0.2002811432,
-0.2534661591,
-0.4121645689,
-0.5673607588,
0.1140621156,
0.0058173025,
0.4014772475,
0.1969839633,
0.212372601,
0.1188555658,
-0.3099916577,
-0.2661753595,
0.2499589026,
0.7576441169,
0.9551562667,
-0.0846714601,
0.2434659898,
0.2506526709,
-0.7475602627,
0.3846432865,
-0.1532631963,
-0.2326157391,
0.1256381869,
0.4800479114,
0.6398399472,
0.4254775941,
-0.4268995523,
0.3259920478,
0.0342904441,
-0.210535869,
-0.3244446516,
-0.002634573,
0.2195165604,
0.1199912727,
0.4245400131,
0.0904205963,
-0.2572390437,
-0.4495268166,
-0.0643109903,
0.5686050653,
-0.0032759923,
-0.4967985451,
0.5069923997,
0.2826696038,
-0.302631408,
0.7673509121,
-0.2644333243,
-1.0022834539,
0.6663522124,
0.6804475188,
0.2105371505,
-0.2262512743,
0.1220025644,
0.6261245608,
0.8332598209,
-0.07499291,
0.2475104928,
0.2174236178,
-0.8431144953,
-0.2738370001,
-0.4884323776,
-0.2927015424,
0.2265723348,
-0.783662796,
0.2004653364,
-0.2507018149,
-0.4063379169,
-0.394179523,
-0.0290775727,
-0.9723031521,
0.2409844548,
0.4246982336,
0.732572794,
-1.4123824835,
0.3957867324,
0.86217314,
-0.0881876722,
-0.8724925518,
0.0140254842,
-0.112963289,
-0.7943614125,
0.9805960059,
0.2486852705,
-0.1324907839,
-0.1644421071,
-0.6784754992,
-1.7331051826,
0.6942408681,
0.4182874262,
-0.5970761776,
-0.0119192349,
0.6334764361,
0.642387867,
-0.4554572999,
0.3550946712,
0.4783467054,
0.175197646,
-0.0460233577,
-0.9429974556,
-0.5990080237,
-0.0289029256,
0.2547051311,
-0.0839030147,
-0.4665747881,
0.9557116628,
-0.4762875438,
-0.6184864044,
-0.096530363,
0.8119046092,
0.4436145127,
0.0825856477,
0.5086857677,
0.3733172715,
0.7783715129,
-0.4352950156,
0.9698654413,
-0.4436745346,
0.4672825634,
1.0186113119,
-0.5916907787,
0.8805868626,
0.2886939347,
-0.7406052351,
0.2490141243,
0.9904482365,
0.2122698575,
0.6325681806,
0.3904910386,
-0.0764017105,
-0.4138075113,
0.451056242,
-0.4372526407,
0.5535739064,
0.4759178162,
0.0589822866,
-0.4384806454,
0.0966951177,
-0.0735430047,
0.1822170466,
-0.2607618272,
0.4366641939,
0.0636162683,
-0.8433409929,
0.2752273679,
-0.4235964119,
1.0022454262,
-0.6757961512,
0.4832571447,
-0.4478352368,
-0.0084638717,
-0.2442056984,
-0.6778638959,
0.36252442,
0.0503058732,
-0.2251140028,
-0.0196263604,
0.5612951517,
-0.5937756896,
-0.6380588412,
0.5014415979,
0.5170592666,
0.5552707911,
0.3422479331,
-0.5003044009,
-0.0425659306,
0.0924193189,
-0.2718272209,
-0.0223540477,
0.4205470979,
-0.1592320204,
0.7114456296,
0.6907740831,
0.4628139734,
0.9290826917,
0.1491665691,
0.2403460294,
-0.439597398,
-0.5553575754,
-0.7685413957,
0.3953641951,
-0.103997834,
-0.3894718885,
0.8921200633,
0.4563151598,
1.0448908806,
-0.0575957,
0.7608745098,
0.3218877017,
0.6398429275,
-0.1402742267,
0.7113268375,
-0.4026790559,
0.0056929276,
-0.0149657503,
-1.2347705364,
-0.2371372581,
1.0735869408,
-1.0836501122,
0.5057176352,
0.5191995502,
0.724799931,
-0.1614301801,
-0.0494579375,
0.4402668476,
0.031291686,
0.2079276294,
0.399397403,
1.0678739548,
0.1417646259,
0.3436987996,
-0.1819419265,
-0.2487825006,
-0.1263658106,
-0.7913872004,
-0.8956726193,
-0.2723938227,
-0.1396002918,
0.011488175,
-0.1413012892,
0.5550656319,
1.1664652824,
-0.8136334419,
-0.203620106,
0.2255161852,
-0.3256391585,
0.2442850918,
-0.1920677125,
0.0201885886,
-0.3376867771,
-0.661806941,
0.1473867744,
0.2610303462,
0.2952612042,
-0.611553967,
0.1019193754,
-0.0716105103,
0.0862793922,
0.2991584241,
0.3260861337,
-0.8628163934,
-0.2089378685,
0.3492895365,
-0.4735367596,
0.1014343277,
0.8221188188,
-0.4962061346,
0.2999901175,
0.1888571531,
0.361851722,
0.2054051161,
-0.0107914181,
0.5863111019,
-0.6203759313,
0.440795064,
0.0803235695,
0.4955410659,
0.6269346476,
-0.414653182,
0.4198012948,
-0.0107593657,
-0.7634025812,
-0.6177605987,
0.3946676552,
-0.5356892347,
0.1074370742,
1.324030757,
-0.3734461069,
-0.1444176137,
-0.1151075587,
0.08414983,
-0.0332395993,
0.063739799,
0.573015213,
0.9835311174,
0.2276148349,
-0.0530829243,
-0.6837123632,
0.1857636869,
0.8255648613,
-0.7040873766,
-0.1969099492,
0.4373253584,
0.5972210169,
0.3118823171,
0.7531452775,
-0.0938656405,
0.0436880775,
-0.0810672268,
0.0879195035,
0.4447598159,
-0.2148861885,
-0.3049677312,
-0.0824624225,
0.1799407899,
0.2149926126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.11009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.11009v1
|
DIALECTBENCH: A NLP Benchmark for Dialects, Varieties, and Closely-Related Languages
| 2024-03-16T20:18:36 | 2024-03-16T20:18:36 |
Fahim Faisal, Orevaoghene Ahia, Aarohi Srivastava, Kabir Ahuja, David Chiang, Yulia Tsvetkov, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language technologies should be judged on their usefulness in real-world use
cases. An often overlooked aspect in natural language processing (NLP) research
and evaluation is language variation in the form of non-standard dialects or
language varieties (hereafter, varieties). Most NLP benchmarks are limited to
standard language varieties. To fill this gap, we propose DIALECTBENCH, the
first-ever large-scale benchmark for NLP on varieties, which aggregates an
extensive set of task-varied variety datasets (10 text-level tasks covering 281
varieties). This allows for a comprehensive evaluation of NLP system
performance on different language varieties. We provide substantial evidence of
performance disparities between standard and non-standard language varieties,
and we also identify language clusters with large performance divergence across
tasks. We believe DIALECTBENCH provides a comprehensive view of the current
state of NLP for language varieties and one step towards advancing it further.
Code/data: https://github.com/ffaisal93/DialectBench
|
[
-0.8243389726,
-0.626496315,
0.1229744777,
0.5731045604,
-0.0575574301,
0.0001826933,
-0.4784072638,
-0.5527322292,
0.5761155486,
0.5937392712,
-0.3996983469,
-0.5039390922,
-0.3294710517,
0.2335169464,
-0.6086227894,
0.6609171033,
0.4515255392,
-0.1699117869,
-0.1608166397,
-0.3573470116,
-0.196772784,
-0.5891894698,
-0.5395670533,
-0.2447483838,
0.3777351081,
0.3313151896,
0.6314918399,
0.3994186223,
0.5169488788,
0.3736327887,
-0.0926091075,
-0.1447209567,
-0.3243010044,
0.47246629,
-0.3381242454,
-0.504558742,
-0.3933002651,
-0.1318396479,
0.6010257006,
1.1505972147,
-0.3399012387,
0.0728132278,
-0.0213359892,
0.9258515835,
-0.5478493571,
-0.0587297045,
-0.609998107,
0.2231759429,
-0.9222560525,
0.1980904341,
-0.19490394,
-0.3707654178,
-0.0871211439,
-0.3583700955,
0.4996754825,
0.2832914889,
0.8097557425,
0.0040738988,
-0.1728755981,
0.2582767606,
-0.4689770639,
0.7637525797,
-0.8963164091,
0.5640684366,
0.3803685009,
0.673265636,
-0.2312281281,
-0.8066812754,
-0.6169324517,
-0.2646587491,
0.0769425556,
0.0037716636,
-0.3113146126,
0.0845640004,
0.3317564726,
0.7993052006,
-0.9051402211,
0.110781312,
-0.0954299942,
0.0109008448,
0.4257034659,
0.1621429324,
0.0883751065,
-0.255169034,
-0.007784511,
-0.2255702615,
-0.4393399954,
-0.0460924208,
0.4583208859,
0.5061788559,
-0.0819944665,
0.3998368382,
-0.7886356711,
0.9024813175,
-0.0831774697,
0.3572006226,
0.5111775398,
-0.1689886898,
-0.1529200226,
-0.2486746907,
0.910900712,
0.4623780549,
0.0815947279,
-0.4343800843,
-0.225015834,
-0.2056342363,
0.4498205483,
-0.5884179473,
-0.3656220138,
0.1314299554,
-0.1906453222,
-0.1606222242,
-0.0025159263,
-1.2607470751,
-0.5253226161,
-0.0390451476,
0.0193478633,
-0.5390157104,
-0.5017463565,
0.0158975814,
-0.3643703163,
0.1367863119,
0.0239685252,
-1.111038208,
0.7878947854,
1.0604112148,
0.8770401478,
-0.3342053592,
-0.4070913792,
-0.4454313815,
-0.5487459898,
-0.3577058017,
0.8307749629,
-0.348272115,
-0.3636147976,
-0.005929803,
-0.0236599371,
0.1003283188,
-1.1418664455,
0.555393815,
-0.3862309754,
0.0473246649,
-0.282625556,
-0.5553344488,
-0.1368855387,
0.3647346795,
-1.0608799458,
1.420250535,
0.4795910716,
-0.6539596319,
0.4715608954,
-0.3299563527,
-0.3887225986,
0.2798441947,
-0.0781800225,
-0.125142619,
0.3422959149,
-0.2095943093,
0.0791372359,
-0.561291039,
0.3179242313,
-0.4397414327,
-0.1748583913,
0.1687164605,
-0.3269975185,
0.7013288736,
0.0758445635,
-0.45958516,
-0.0531450436,
-0.8472681046,
0.3815290928,
-0.0996739566,
-0.0404853672,
-0.3175181448,
0.1443919092,
0.519076407,
0.162519902,
0.2332036495,
-0.5896931291,
0.0557370037,
-0.7554430962,
0.1138089225,
0.4591650367,
-0.4152379334,
0.1293519437,
-0.3825045526,
0.4475777745,
-0.3063492179,
-0.0218388531,
0.2562286854,
-0.3962727487,
-1.0475555658,
0.0600239821,
0.5863815546,
0.2961834371,
-0.4638246298,
0.8615248203,
-0.4113185704,
-0.7745628953,
-0.3408696949,
0.243643865,
0.3090828061,
0.1806495786,
0.3590418696,
-0.8412470222,
-0.6547171474,
-1.1609959602,
-0.3524092436,
-0.1172415838,
-0.2186172307,
0.0229676571,
0.1886180788,
0.1350894272,
1.2244204283,
-0.1734383106,
0.0218032859,
-0.5578839183,
0.258084923,
0.2398983538,
0.4378796816,
0.7678712606,
-0.5716434121,
-0.543158412,
0.0954359695,
-0.4539683759,
-0.4851857126,
0.2034120411,
-0.1883028299,
0.1831693947,
0.4446608424,
-0.193021059,
-0.0464151055,
0.9975420237,
-0.1619371772,
0.7099364996,
0.1989526302,
0.0458882637,
-0.9090337753,
0.2756704688,
-0.1819367111,
-0.3878779411,
-0.5473700762,
0.3014247119,
-0.0523028933,
0.0253452361,
-0.0069385809,
0.447622031,
0.0308087431,
-0.2612746954,
-0.0362299457,
0.1849444807,
0.1533529013,
0.1324950755,
0.0249733217,
0.7691529989,
0.399004072,
-0.2550965548,
0.5800824165,
-0.1590023041,
-0.5494301319,
0.7310538888,
-0.6338310838,
0.1301516742,
0.3936065435,
0.0069759367,
-0.6474519968,
-0.2277198881,
-0.2142855823,
-0.1416570395,
0.1194573194,
0.004946386,
-0.4445724487,
-0.1796915233,
-0.1968687624,
0.1013001427,
0.3598551154,
-0.4171281457,
0.3980535269,
0.2779849172,
-0.4069263935,
-0.4008236229,
-0.7274557352,
0.3677613735,
-0.1069225371,
-0.5882330537,
0.1691475958,
0.0405282602,
-0.3891998529,
-0.084239386,
-0.2475277483,
-0.2969186306,
0.0449792705,
0.1469399333,
-0.2297701091,
-0.5165408254,
0.0848242864,
-0.0899677277,
-0.0794084966,
-0.0437654704,
-0.1840538234,
0.9491662383,
-0.350043714,
-0.5027882457,
0.0842392743,
0.5281671286,
0.1538525671,
-0.2166927904,
0.4915215671,
0.2727308869,
-0.0098889582,
-0.6046773791,
-0.7586438656,
0.0387183204,
-0.4753400385,
0.5663727522,
-0.3617066741,
-0.9000748396,
0.2980388105,
-0.3531580269,
0.1493912041,
0.5536647439,
0.3130653501,
0.0364119187,
0.1683278233,
0.7097723484,
-0.2930179834,
0.4077184498,
0.1554301977,
0.1498012245,
-0.3864436448,
0.1736140847,
-0.7388173342,
-0.4400332272,
-0.6529272795,
-0.6688750982,
0.1469310075,
0.2644837499,
-0.0322427377,
0.5408529043,
-0.1634290218,
0.529867053,
0.6875152588,
-0.3498531878,
0.3913830221,
-0.1156642362,
-0.2454522252,
-0.2028232813,
-0.4819037914,
-0.3560500145,
1.0170918703,
-0.0914376974,
0.2961576879,
0.1647232622,
0.8656309247,
0.4105815887,
0.0018526406,
-0.7079224586,
0.6852011085,
-0.5379751921,
-0.6955484152,
-0.186217621,
-0.5186003447,
-1.0100255013,
0.3842793107,
-0.089320004,
-0.8338568807,
0.1599648744,
0.0713624805,
0.0078059421,
0.3375635445,
-0.4511158764,
1.1043957472,
-0.1859382838,
-0.3420829177,
-0.3237632215,
-0.525698483,
0.1952148378,
-0.1901002228,
0.1508003026,
-0.2730156183,
0.198797971,
0.4913500845,
-0.4396119714,
0.6283296943,
-0.0543914996,
0.2279222459,
-0.1689843982,
0.4130679071,
0.0649231225,
-0.223544836,
-0.5092068911,
0.5255746245,
0.0914311484,
-0.4005545378,
-0.4407144189,
0.6330937147,
-0.4778636396,
-0.4433144927,
-0.3778513968,
-0.2499832362,
-0.649014473,
0.2886939943,
0.2552218139,
0.2869156897,
-0.921102643,
0.439617157,
0.384011209,
-0.1764430851,
0.2909780741,
0.5619103909,
-0.5789917111,
-0.1946378201,
0.9208613634,
-0.1800255626,
0.4630527794,
0.3396370113,
0.0663182959,
0.0154665243,
-0.6823705435,
-0.4947730303,
-0.2160051912,
-0.5306521058,
0.0306932721,
-0.4758123755,
-0.1014994457,
-0.2445268035,
-0.0479436815,
-0.6964477301,
-0.6808537841,
0.6273486614,
0.1705714464,
0.3172050714,
0.659599185,
-0.0668130964,
0.3661368489,
-0.6976877451,
0.3744469881,
0.2693213522,
0.6242957115,
-0.3850264251,
-0.2991158962,
-0.1679601818,
-0.2926384807,
-0.2411777377,
-0.6313163638,
0.3273430467,
0.4229156375,
0.5586768985,
0.3071023524,
-0.0099923201,
0.4357385337,
-0.4647094011,
1.037191987,
0.0957216546,
-1.0635091066,
0.2573526204,
-0.2469846159,
0.244831115,
0.9970009327,
-0.0382339992,
-1.1580212116,
-0.6159700751,
-0.5836846232,
-1.1725008488,
0.7591797709,
0.1730466038,
0.0191889573,
0.1055903062,
-0.1086653396,
0.3551752269,
0.4833621681,
-0.5394811034,
-0.2167915404,
-0.3356042504,
-0.1528791338,
-0.3668590188,
0.0670576096,
-0.2401704043,
-0.0105548305,
0.3684398234,
-0.1606815457,
-0.0927967429,
-0.1133854911,
-0.0261235274,
-0.0074030459,
0.5822740793,
0.0026056059,
0.4542189837,
-0.2410269827,
0.2634819746,
0.1391797364,
-0.4523226321,
-0.1772466898,
0.3657654524,
-0.1405431479,
0.2869368196,
0.3826213777,
0.6644051671,
0.0234138481,
-0.9256362319,
0.3841598034,
0.0816758201,
-0.0798933581,
-0.1728231758,
0.3009994328,
0.3291035593,
0.0005567124,
0.0240147803,
0.2595480382,
0.5838745236,
-0.4662232101,
0.329529196,
0.3265933096,
-0.2490793616,
-0.0956864208,
0.1281880587,
0.2566577792,
-0.2126389891,
0.5278698802,
-0.4398083389,
-0.35809201,
0.7984463573,
0.2848064005,
0.9668533802,
-0.2056907713,
0.3101260662,
0.3197335303,
0.380682081,
-0.1493064165,
0.1124527827,
-0.1448758543,
-0.570628643,
-0.1981082112,
-1.0462397337,
-0.7554568052,
0.0387353078,
-0.6591874957,
0.0410733782,
-0.532861352,
-0.2667833567,
0.0418372937,
-0.105216831,
-0.3577072918,
0.1182636097,
0.1768905222,
1.0100778341,
-0.7591562271,
0.776083231,
0.548062861,
0.0654541403,
-0.4518037438,
0.231555745,
0.2080233097,
-0.432167381,
0.4165562987,
0.1425105929,
-0.2967318296,
-0.3101228178,
-0.134455815,
-0.6445162892,
0.3674112856,
0.3305203617,
-0.7873293757,
0.3478938639,
0.6973567605,
0.6694692969,
0.0954324603,
0.3401881158,
0.8306828141,
0.4922819734,
-0.1775154322,
-1.1987185478,
-0.0949564055,
-0.6312144399,
0.1523624361,
0.4638384879,
-0.6914317012,
0.9355608225,
0.614749074,
-0.0008866289,
0.2047384828,
0.3150728643,
-0.0414935872,
0.2260836214,
0.6969488263,
0.7237810493,
0.6789581776,
-0.5104031563,
0.8934214115,
-0.3961738944,
0.2578468025,
1.2615842819,
-0.4275441766,
1.0973627567,
0.36217013,
-0.7068849802,
0.5864673257,
0.3407426476,
-0.0286103189,
0.1932007372,
0.444146663,
-0.2664707005,
-0.2665148675,
-0.0278392509,
-0.4520426095,
0.4587364793,
0.3274414539,
0.0290285069,
-0.5171849728,
-0.4948206246,
-0.1191800088,
0.2340163141,
0.20341447,
0.7254639268,
-0.0057272241,
-0.7106502056,
0.6664471626,
0.0932821631,
0.8233081102,
-1.088637352,
0.1813112646,
-0.4439952672,
0.1408866942,
-0.2453735322,
-0.7132138014,
0.5268187523,
0.0036028356,
-0.060300082,
-0.0833105668,
0.2598721981,
-0.2356120646,
-0.3316909373,
0.5824157,
0.6395029426,
0.1710702926,
-0.3165111542,
-0.6773483753,
0.1074137464,
-0.0623928159,
-0.3794029355,
0.4683378041,
0.5754408836,
0.0258422997,
0.3474866152,
0.4126159847,
0.2328616977,
0.2401692718,
0.3693327904,
0.7734751105,
-0.7714666128,
-0.4374223948,
-0.5529631376,
0.1644684672,
-0.4886977077,
-0.6175675988,
0.7913177609,
0.864675343,
0.877025187,
0.1145728976,
0.793243289,
-0.5719127059,
0.6534884572,
-0.3316009045,
0.5349333882,
-0.808821559,
-0.0204272661,
-0.1972054243,
-0.9848889112,
-0.169241488,
0.463254869,
-0.261397332,
0.1210248247,
0.9031365514,
0.8147771955,
-0.2035166621,
0.3719853461,
0.4508658051,
0.1644678265,
0.0581911765,
0.2607094049,
0.5824724436,
0.0502741449,
0.29366678,
-0.7137879729,
-0.225566119,
-0.1838737428,
-0.76179111,
-0.59546417,
-0.4297595024,
0.1034889892,
-0.1642601788,
0.1557402909,
0.8766444325,
0.7119740844,
-1.0753172636,
-0.8485441804,
-0.3513892293,
-0.2852104008,
-0.6465665102,
-0.2888682187,
-0.0709273368,
-0.6354286075,
-0.8364716768,
0.6459578276,
0.3685744107,
-0.4291676283,
-0.3515178263,
0.2348456681,
0.0723616704,
-0.1017064899,
0.3204289675,
0.379845947,
-0.5424875617,
0.1537296772,
-0.0935733542,
-0.1904890388,
0.2306608707,
0.8895494342,
-0.581010282,
0.7291594744,
0.4933320582,
0.6571128964,
0.4718044996,
-0.0980246291,
0.6648080945,
-0.936707139,
0.2896274626,
0.486627996,
0.3552083075,
0.449706912,
0.1207505018,
0.5879916549,
0.3024671078,
-0.374361068,
-0.4651479423,
0.2851829529,
-1.2441716194,
-0.1587251872,
0.8000110984,
-0.1087243259,
-0.004083931,
-0.3749300241,
-0.0326897241,
-0.127680406,
-0.471575588,
0.6941968799,
0.8590197563,
-0.0112614855,
0.0775202364,
-0.8094703555,
0.4854483604,
0.8157506585,
-0.9900988936,
0.3385910988,
0.6150640845,
0.1507426947,
0.2849407196,
0.5554885864,
0.0196993984,
0.0707904175,
0.4099588096,
0.3434379697,
0.3681268096,
-0.0320324823,
-0.2212337852,
0.3893215954,
0.3084279001,
0.1639347672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10978v1
|
Entity Alignment with Unlabeled Dangling Cases
| 2024-03-16T17:21:58 | 2024-03-16T17:21:58 |
Hang Yin, Dong Ding, Liyao Xiang, Yuheng He, Yihan Wu, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.4; H.3.3
|
We investigate the entity alignment problem with unlabeled dangling cases,
meaning that there are entities in the source or target graph having no
counterparts in the other, and those entities remain unlabeled. The problem
arises when the source and target graphs are of different scales, and it is
much cheaper to label the matchable pairs than the dangling entities. To solve
the issue, we propose a novel GNN-based dangling detection and entity alignment
framework. While the two tasks share the same GNN and are trained together, the
detected dangling entities are removed in the alignment. Our framework is
featured by a designed entity and relation attention mechanism for selective
neighborhood aggregation in representation learning, as well as a
positive-unlabeled learning loss for an unbiased estimation of dangling
entities. Experimental results have shown that each component of our design
contributes to the overall alignment performance which is comparable or
superior to baselines, even if the baselines additionally have 30\% of the
dangling entities labeled as training data.
|
[
-0.3730115592,
-0.4473206997,
0.4543846846,
-0.2205668539,
-0.3447201848,
0.31460464,
0.0955355316,
-0.7166006565,
0.8884123564,
0.3451631069,
-0.5325267315,
-0.295848906,
-0.5469753146,
-0.288357079,
-0.4190410972,
1.1727132797,
-0.0726698935,
-0.2464304119,
-0.3278051317,
-0.677865088,
-0.2870456278,
-0.1414382309,
-0.6141453981,
-0.3288083375,
0.7523167729,
0.2211851925,
0.7368508577,
0.9461472034,
0.3574988246,
0.2491234094,
-0.1711617112,
0.2762880921,
-0.4827723205,
-0.3233017921,
-0.3223949075,
-0.1161110997,
-0.5662145019,
-0.2037273645,
0.7604897618,
1.0055727959,
-0.3188813925,
0.2154383808,
0.001406674,
0.6411893368,
-0.8397902846,
-0.1363478154,
-0.5502197742,
-0.0087645026,
-0.3163536191,
0.0973950624,
-0.318931371,
-0.0943035036,
0.1517323703,
-0.7387831211,
0.4198011756,
0.1057360396,
1.367000103,
0.3708406687,
-0.6202664375,
-0.1576191336,
-0.4464709461,
0.4350723624,
-0.2448005527,
0.3583253622,
-0.1246683523,
0.0325513855,
-0.1167868674,
-0.5538738966,
-0.2358575612,
0.0164609812,
-0.179908216,
0.3058812618,
-0.1941190511,
-0.0441421457,
0.1581617147,
0.4801468849,
-0.4610329866,
0.2557616532,
-0.2583157122,
-0.2358285636,
0.4289608002,
-0.1758232713,
0.4336814284,
-0.1078757718,
-0.7100391388,
0.3684464097,
-0.900541544,
-0.3928039372,
0.7768971324,
0.3063371778,
0.0047835498,
0.5076925159,
0.051166784,
0.538692534,
0.5152629614,
0.5141988397,
0.5036495924,
-0.2543490827,
-0.2843858302,
0.530980289,
0.6158102155,
0.2884396017,
0.2589326501,
-0.5758292675,
-0.2282695174,
0.1272824556,
0.4173603952,
-0.4052654207,
-0.4755057693,
-0.0162698142,
-0.3746807873,
-0.0656679571,
-0.058300484,
-0.4096649885,
-0.2701157033,
-0.3473475873,
0.4521384835,
-0.3277350664,
-0.6081305146,
-0.2130526453,
-0.080998078,
0.0180762857,
0.094295375,
-1.0268881321,
0.2205054611,
0.6140925884,
0.8595422506,
-0.3720958829,
-0.0143357283,
-0.7120100856,
0.5364606977,
-0.4431247711,
0.6678643823,
-0.2399490476,
-0.0778359398,
-0.1832545996,
0.1351502687,
-0.2616018057,
-0.4251239002,
0.4450829327,
-0.6116726398,
0.0609347522,
-0.2861917317,
-0.9154539108,
-0.0745084286,
0.1458283663,
-0.9528117776,
0.8556767702,
0.2412040234,
-1.0296733379,
0.5621965528,
-0.2635413408,
-0.2547808588,
0.2020654082,
-0.2593572736,
-0.8886620402,
0.1947009265,
0.3438511491,
0.0481522083,
0.2635928988,
0.1795942336,
-0.4285753667,
-0.6807975769,
-0.2330214381,
-0.0167571958,
0.8955880404,
-0.1280976385,
-0.2494608611,
0.0593390502,
-0.9291359782,
-0.0457835086,
0.1536741108,
-0.3780432343,
-0.8067977428,
0.0708922073,
0.0150007466,
-0.0043483619,
0.1152599528,
-0.465275228,
0.4435547292,
-0.4870813489,
0.2563678324,
0.5961899161,
0.2445231527,
0.8341349363,
0.0684874952,
0.230140239,
0.2555615306,
-0.1335693747,
0.266867131,
-0.3074972332,
-0.8078289032,
-0.3014139533,
0.6925818324,
0.2451759428,
-0.8271481395,
0.3899163306,
-0.4960120618,
0.0083528263,
-0.4940871,
0.1163579002,
0.4576148093,
0.9753438234,
0.5105081201,
-0.3512855768,
-0.5581518412,
-0.9702739716,
-0.2641288042,
-0.2205794007,
-0.0723341256,
-0.0350536667,
0.4800114036,
-0.1010362878,
1.0473202467,
-0.396712333,
-0.5321387053,
0.1814254373,
0.0194356423,
-0.0419065654,
0.8316738009,
0.7965720892,
-1.0208437443,
-0.2816385925,
0.1105970666,
-0.8611063361,
0.2618219554,
-0.1974439621,
-0.3185711801,
0.300619781,
0.4789588451,
-0.763483882,
0.3264285624,
0.0441152863,
-0.0979235023,
0.3978027999,
0.0158088282,
-0.3301568925,
-1.235594511,
-0.0134745855,
0.3883799911,
-0.3552829325,
-0.6455656886,
0.059833061,
0.4854102433,
0.3043429255,
-0.5062963963,
0.1648307294,
-1.0119332075,
-0.3140658736,
-0.0816532001,
0.3900668025,
0.0055035832,
0.5714846849,
0.1461102068,
0.6439631581,
0.3391215801,
-0.3475386798,
0.1831889153,
0.2168384641,
-0.3192058504,
0.8708080053,
-0.5680899024,
0.2415324599,
-0.3403415084,
0.019715894,
-0.6657908559,
-0.1533839256,
0.6732078195,
-0.3004975021,
0.8009874225,
-0.7536552548,
-0.1590283066,
-0.4068256915,
-0.1301177442,
0.4057840407,
-0.0753832087,
-0.5972067118,
0.4823301733,
0.3996606469,
0.3947983086,
-0.8597166538,
-0.7930337787,
0.0711742043,
-0.572275877,
-0.2942998409,
0.4352277219,
0.3352747858,
0.1765773743,
0.7084626555,
-0.6393985152,
0.0039449297,
0.1161441728,
0.1623902619,
0.4494352341,
-0.4454634786,
0.5570908785,
0.1157808676,
-0.2263228148,
0.0722792447,
-0.9017911553,
-0.0296135582,
-0.1255152375,
-0.5707342029,
-0.0177288428,
0.3995988369,
0.0784249678,
-0.2277487516,
0.830629468,
0.4854328632,
-0.8979298472,
0.2537497878,
-0.2836156785,
0.3497711718,
-0.5035243034,
0.414657712,
-0.2957770824,
-0.8260655403,
0.606210053,
0.0656396747,
-0.071294874,
0.4246157408,
0.3135345876,
-0.0825363249,
0.9750187993,
0.7011837959,
-0.2930160761,
0.4915027022,
-0.2021371573,
0.3947558701,
-1.2401822805,
-0.1407913715,
-0.216123417,
-0.5144303441,
-0.6544196606,
-0.1135250926,
0.0889330953,
0.436999619,
-0.2815881968,
0.7035403252,
-0.8897919059,
0.7475418448,
0.5134502053,
0.1029081047,
0.2499680072,
0.0947321802,
-0.4154613912,
-0.0098767551,
-0.3728008866,
-0.2962586582,
0.817363441,
0.0390859619,
0.4347745478,
0.3919068873,
1.0038465261,
0.174530372,
0.4495864213,
-0.7589898109,
0.0847190544,
0.1085286215,
-0.5498927236,
-0.4076256156,
-0.7309613228,
-1.0132431984,
0.4709976912,
0.0273935832,
-1.4979405403,
0.5194658637,
0.3131771982,
-0.2130619884,
0.3502013981,
-0.8327952027,
0.9440733194,
-0.0990473628,
-0.2116984725,
0.3069241643,
-0.7610561252,
0.4576954842,
0.091492936,
-0.2653852999,
-0.2041606605,
-0.0212279651,
0.6235987544,
-0.5424420834,
0.4036824405,
-0.2927454412,
-0.114641197,
0.3078005016,
-0.1791050285,
0.6165364385,
0.2378319204,
0.0941172019,
0.0019234357,
-0.3485075235,
-0.587523818,
-0.6992372274,
0.8396882415,
-0.4984999895,
-0.5694261789,
-0.3213747442,
-0.3609122634,
-0.2041358054,
0.5435378551,
0.3785215616,
0.2438533455,
-0.0575948097,
-0.0403070934,
0.746812582,
0.4164808393,
0.4911451042,
0.2375984043,
0.0813357309,
-0.437852025,
1.2703819275,
0.2993968129,
0.1763782352,
0.4927605391,
-0.2659194767,
-0.4916445911,
-0.5426421762,
-0.8399130702,
0.2078239173,
-0.8786338568,
-0.2318107039,
-0.6930606365,
-0.2061798573,
-0.2115298659,
0.0894307271,
-0.560357511,
-0.4897346199,
-0.61956954,
-0.407399565,
0.1257963032,
0.246940881,
0.1089199111,
0.1725058705,
-0.5476244092,
0.1353994012,
0.1037489474,
0.3975460827,
0.1109810248,
-0.1145026311,
-0.2715901434,
0.1488858312,
-0.3442492783,
-0.8858706355,
-0.0755939782,
0.1206416115,
0.6158857942,
0.7483559251,
0.1229377538,
0.7965406179,
-0.4410429895,
0.2504624128,
0.4764440954,
-1.0231714249,
0.3182949722,
-0.320086807,
0.0358814374,
0.4304738343,
0.2911221981,
-0.4025796652,
-0.2676648498,
-0.5160165429,
-1.0775985718,
0.5620224476,
0.3627177775,
-0.1776127666,
-0.0387734473,
0.5059944391,
-0.3600000441,
0.3195479214,
-0.5948223472,
-0.4903606474,
-0.0566316172,
-0.4183101654,
0.1948055178,
0.1010856256,
-0.1117187291,
-0.0904445946,
0.5693014264,
-0.4740040004,
0.2839816213,
0.0112908445,
-0.3271405697,
-0.3531295061,
-0.1574822217,
0.3352527916,
0.56670928,
-0.0756389275,
0.1008784175,
0.0493526645,
-0.3227698207,
0.2695060968,
0.1616954207,
-0.3958738744,
-0.1206791103,
0.3181556165,
0.9144169688,
0.5237556696,
-0.0398466438,
0.4755701423,
0.070162937,
-0.219618395,
-0.1470134705,
-0.1473482996,
0.7008939385,
0.1086566523,
0.4483126402,
0.2930057645,
0.2669985592,
-0.2047342062,
0.4324379563,
0.5404211879,
-0.7353002429,
-0.1440651864,
0.9229283333,
-0.0789633393,
-0.1375083774,
0.9130808711,
-0.2570747733,
-0.4346592128,
0.9823639989,
0.3719199598,
0.7566122413,
0.1584097147,
0.3055160642,
-0.1629078835,
0.431807369,
0.0074217725,
-0.1262769997,
0.0005739843,
-0.7474460006,
-0.2676689327,
-0.3007599711,
-0.3259981573,
-0.045498684,
-1.1170099974,
0.1028754935,
-0.0767375678,
-0.0385173559,
0.2901625931,
0.0368268602,
-0.3983476162,
0.1849628687,
0.0099727279,
0.4791632295,
-0.7137396932,
0.733656168,
1.0585803986,
-0.6040982008,
-0.852309525,
0.1978486329,
0.1878108382,
-0.4312176704,
0.12672773,
0.4257982373,
0.0086690038,
0.1213185415,
-0.3459458351,
-1.3603549004,
0.927547574,
0.721426785,
-0.5598688722,
-0.2453377396,
-0.3479087055,
0.5011211038,
-0.2526299059,
-0.0925118253,
0.5022330284,
0.1119414121,
0.2373516113,
-0.4147074819,
0.0994051546,
-0.2528829873,
0.0407757573,
0.8505168557,
-0.8987674713,
0.6722769737,
-0.083896175,
-0.6629341841,
0.0932319537,
0.950879395,
0.06769526,
0.4335325658,
0.440816462,
0.975235343,
1.0834028721,
-0.2261838168,
0.6004397273,
0.1708855629,
0.7723212242,
1.3169037104,
-0.4856601357,
0.4604250491,
0.6006938815,
0.0769177079,
0.3088690639,
0.9547218084,
-0.1674387157,
0.594420135,
0.203294009,
-0.0022671625,
-0.3482112885,
0.0409559719,
-0.291821003,
0.0592852235,
0.3832496703,
-0.1438125223,
-0.3978837132,
-0.109828338,
-0.2121411711,
-0.1760532558,
-0.3805216253,
0.4462583363,
0.1256233752,
-0.5411053896,
0.5256509781,
-0.2934307158,
0.2937203944,
0.0233926512,
0.0429331623,
-0.2485400587,
0.2904438972,
-0.4212718904,
-0.4211539328,
0.3305441737,
-0.4454622269,
-0.393799603,
0.1705209464,
0.771551311,
-0.491104424,
-0.4377182722,
0.4586881995,
0.2896467149,
0.1134507433,
0.0935314968,
-0.5980327725,
-0.2229270935,
-0.2008769959,
-0.2571035326,
0.5746305585,
0.4894829392,
-0.569979012,
0.5647653937,
0.2769554853,
-0.1328360289,
0.187867865,
0.2202465236,
0.9779538512,
-0.3052259386,
-0.4868987799,
-0.5828450918,
0.3096589744,
-0.4492161572,
-0.2111789584,
0.6281306744,
0.5505747199,
0.9466058016,
0.1469985396,
0.2958889008,
0.1120288819,
0.2305842638,
-0.5634688735,
0.7725141644,
-0.827635169,
0.2371827662,
-0.4661276639,
-1.0350528955,
-0.2608313859,
0.480194062,
-0.0395464189,
0.1179895923,
0.6219437718,
0.4319986403,
-0.4215276539,
-0.0567329824,
0.0541869178,
-0.3811023831,
0.1709819734,
0.8101753592,
0.680252552,
-0.5481089354,
0.5805395842,
-0.1192220375,
0.0854478553,
-0.1395055801,
-0.9055945277,
-0.8422525525,
-0.2623576224,
-0.9669154882,
-0.1441767663,
0.1510770172,
0.576882422,
0.6276982427,
-0.7934008837,
0.4201228619,
-0.2865015864,
0.5786082745,
-0.437741071,
-0.2668519616,
0.7839841843,
0.0354162306,
-0.8496739864,
0.3278402984,
0.4555890858,
0.2613390386,
0.0272247773,
0.1217312068,
-0.5340408683,
-0.376190424,
-0.0510391854,
0.4945123792,
-0.6173042059,
-0.5648835301,
-0.2719724178,
-0.1104783714,
0.2333953381,
0.5467384458,
-0.6312553883,
0.2025419027,
0.1089473218,
0.779746592,
0.4562042654,
0.4458410442,
0.241910696,
-1.4924938679,
0.150237143,
0.0969418958,
0.4830164611,
0.4748207629,
-0.8088392019,
0.6256687641,
0.4405237436,
-0.402020812,
-0.8671922088,
0.2286750078,
-0.7798377872,
0.0394536182,
0.5949616432,
-0.4191815853,
-0.2931660712,
-0.0224163793,
0.2716089785,
0.5962045789,
-0.3842690289,
0.6398364305,
0.6263469458,
-0.0962784514,
-0.2396314442,
-0.1912192702,
0.0959930271,
0.5397396088,
-0.4363333881,
-0.2456581295,
0.5954604745,
0.3614580333,
0.6181930304,
0.4754552245,
0.0903128684,
0.3351777196,
-0.0909086093,
-0.0213846173,
0.0376179479,
-0.3518840075,
-0.3153237998,
0.2549044788,
-0.294840306,
-0.6954718232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10963v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10963v3
|
Pointer-Generator Networks for Low-Resource Machine Translation: Don't Copy That!
| 2024-03-16T16:17:47 | 2024-06-18T02:57:31 |
Niyati Bafna, Philipp Koehn, David Yarowsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Transformer-based neural machine translation (NMT) is very effective in
high-resource settings, many languages lack the necessary large parallel
corpora to benefit from it. In the context of low-resource (LR) MT between two
closely-related languages, a natural intuition is to seek benefits from
structural "shortcuts", such as copying subwords from the source to the target,
given that such language pairs often share a considerable number of identical
words, cognates, and borrowings. We test Pointer-Generator Networks for this
purpose for six language pairs over a variety of resource ranges, and find weak
improvements for most settings. However, analysis shows that the model does not
show greater improvements for closely-related vs. more distant language pairs,
or for lower resource ranges, and that the models do not exhibit the expected
usage of the mechanism for shared subwords. Our discussion of the reasons for
this behaviour highlights several general challenges for LR NMT, such as modern
tokenization strategies, noisy real-world conditions, and linguistic
complexities. We call for better scrutiny of linguistically motivated
improvements to NMT given the blackbox nature of Transformer models, as well as
for a focus on the above problems in the field.
|
[
-0.2133660316,
-0.3405251503,
0.3803833127,
0.1670140624,
-0.5506712198,
0.1482136548,
-0.245443821,
-0.320833236,
0.3150214255,
0.2448538244,
-0.3810698688,
0.1349373609,
-0.7948802114,
0.5194205046,
-0.4406509101,
1.0006905794,
-0.188995719,
-0.0266893432,
0.1671423614,
-0.4622631073,
-0.5092839599,
-0.4618411958,
-0.6874223948,
-0.555708468,
0.8952592611,
0.309165746,
0.9968027472,
0.7957507968,
0.7489497066,
0.269725889,
-0.419300437,
0.0188172366,
-0.664989233,
0.1752546579,
-0.2215088308,
-0.2826894522,
-0.2681554854,
-0.2669953704,
0.6917498112,
0.9477327466,
0.2759443521,
0.150193274,
0.2299781591,
0.6475001574,
-0.4781436622,
-0.0449706763,
-0.7425947189,
0.2132370472,
-0.3740795255,
-0.0225176793,
-0.3234939873,
-0.3018370271,
0.2549515069,
-0.3076580167,
0.3834114969,
0.3263613284,
0.6823771,
0.4037711918,
-0.3171622157,
0.031514626,
-0.6839831471,
0.8104434013,
-0.3305718601,
0.2742908001,
0.3040773273,
0.1815792769,
-0.0128863277,
-0.5176384449,
-0.3796494305,
-0.3038443327,
-0.219909355,
-0.0358166881,
-0.3431619108,
-0.0551689677,
0.441729635,
0.3329668641,
-0.4208196402,
0.069225885,
-0.7013938427,
0.0417729504,
0.0125121456,
0.0579333827,
0.0560616292,
-0.5014975071,
-0.4993751347,
-0.1704043895,
-1.0774145126,
-0.1588021815,
0.2342775911,
0.4634238183,
-0.0904982686,
0.7752972841,
-0.0318224244,
0.5344362259,
0.1561153382,
0.3738875687,
0.0407365486,
-0.6218557954,
-0.130043447,
0.079855904,
1.0556081533,
0.0844711587,
0.1548342705,
-0.5494106412,
-0.3373901844,
-0.1274405569,
0.1216121539,
-0.8272973299,
-0.2502682209,
-0.2891831696,
-0.6853640676,
-0.1615392268,
-0.2969032228,
-0.3216781914,
-0.3007293642,
-0.1834732294,
0.3269244432,
-0.5589661598,
-0.2074708641,
-0.1271125674,
-0.2530335486,
-0.0507493615,
-0.2017083913,
-0.9562188983,
0.1566062719,
0.6071308255,
1.102221489,
-0.4382960498,
-0.498131454,
-0.3558440506,
0.0342415944,
-0.0820512176,
0.5177560449,
-0.2109545469,
-0.5825397372,
-0.3008340895,
-0.0529579669,
-0.4376639426,
-0.7801813483,
0.3191487789,
-0.344520092,
0.0791934803,
-0.7375524044,
-0.1018763185,
0.1209079698,
0.0399058126,
-0.735262692,
0.863026619,
0.1460837573,
-0.7832261324,
0.0658419728,
-0.5880516768,
-0.5378078222,
-0.1295663714,
-0.0670721829,
-0.3448875546,
0.4636168182,
-0.2141572237,
0.2311988175,
-0.4978475571,
0.0717830881,
-0.1474658549,
-0.5429596305,
0.3555838764,
-0.492521435,
0.5487214923,
0.2385900915,
-0.4238985777,
-0.0695625544,
-0.4956768751,
-0.1578469872,
0.1912276447,
-0.3788455427,
-0.340903759,
-0.0791583881,
-0.0610213913,
0.3941178024,
0.1338530183,
-0.4963018596,
0.1775369346,
-0.3855964541,
0.6042548418,
0.5830516815,
-0.0769423768,
0.7859997153,
-0.5017870069,
0.589984715,
0.1462165713,
0.1392649114,
0.2139736861,
-0.5411753654,
-0.884319663,
0.075614281,
0.228207022,
0.3288804293,
-1.1594421864,
0.0034058481,
-0.4936486185,
-0.1048517525,
-0.6236142516,
0.2788586617,
0.6696969867,
0.6114830375,
0.5981066823,
-0.3494939208,
-0.3252312243,
-1.1207586527,
-0.3237769008,
0.0450438969,
0.1043532565,
0.1089963689,
0.410386771,
0.1170981005,
0.7067122459,
-0.1023868844,
-0.0962891504,
-0.5051051378,
-0.0183256865,
0.2274691463,
0.4379146397,
0.5388963223,
-0.8671156168,
-0.7734824419,
0.154153809,
-0.5191264153,
0.0521003827,
0.0748204291,
-0.02834245,
-0.1008729115,
0.3465290666,
-0.736336112,
-0.0435963646,
0.6541477442,
-0.0840061083,
0.2759058475,
-0.0851089805,
-0.2538382709,
-1.1790384054,
0.2313287854,
-0.221604377,
-0.0451079421,
-0.5509716868,
-0.0381803438,
-0.1915623248,
-0.2090049982,
-0.6863917112,
0.4108791053,
-0.4088375568,
-0.0635437071,
-0.3275520205,
-0.0191952959,
-0.1529865265,
0.4770530462,
-0.1375014186,
0.8529647589,
0.1421052366,
-0.2850498259,
0.2573364079,
0.1996976882,
0.0050087865,
0.4482493997,
-0.8191565275,
0.2740267813,
-0.006001025,
0.0359255858,
-0.2821024656,
0.1342284083,
0.4725688696,
-0.2112620175,
0.1448300034,
-0.1989210248,
-0.5230903029,
-0.2087767273,
-0.1753113568,
0.5677338243,
0.6775824428,
-0.4320719242,
0.111660257,
-0.0643789545,
-0.0171869993,
-0.8716638088,
-0.7444139123,
0.1147888005,
-0.1863604635,
-0.5491368175,
0.2631629407,
0.2742870152,
-0.163313359,
0.3428047299,
-0.2577042878,
-0.1012830734,
0.0734765604,
0.2282639891,
-0.0962004364,
-0.3708674312,
0.0688924938,
-0.1001779065,
-0.2830302715,
-0.0950569361,
-0.4885032177,
0.4927518964,
-0.3047648072,
-0.2682567835,
-0.2778699696,
0.3507129848,
0.4078619778,
-0.2171107233,
0.8845757842,
0.6681698561,
-0.1075396389,
-0.1565323174,
-0.2190051228,
-0.3060150743,
-0.4522691071,
0.3929379284,
-0.5509175062,
-0.9683408737,
0.3288370669,
-0.0785682797,
-0.2879748046,
0.4838630259,
0.537599802,
-0.2169803232,
0.5731552243,
0.5761613846,
-0.0499356911,
0.6471380591,
-0.5363675356,
0.3431048989,
-0.9499007463,
-0.0315194577,
-0.5836334229,
-0.6930564642,
-0.7113628983,
-0.5463943481,
0.2345526367,
0.1076061875,
-0.1004601195,
0.90013659,
-0.4238477647,
0.5491071343,
0.8414877653,
-0.1099757105,
0.2886078358,
0.1107941344,
-0.3258022964,
-0.1694414765,
-1.0405812263,
-0.2651175261,
0.6278004646,
0.0881560147,
0.5956763625,
0.0472946391,
0.7570239902,
0.0235793237,
0.2419801056,
-0.9718981385,
0.5311955214,
-0.5173776746,
-0.4007454813,
-0.2562525272,
-0.758202672,
-0.9681347013,
0.508831203,
-0.1768056601,
-0.3457793295,
0.2112827748,
0.3182729483,
-0.1992820054,
0.5253432989,
-0.7411815524,
0.9414990544,
-0.1211210042,
-0.4533886611,
-0.1441287249,
-0.5781495571,
0.1681474,
-0.2024096698,
-0.2812857032,
0.0184796471,
0.2202419043,
0.3259987831,
-0.5078456998,
0.6560957432,
0.0947195292,
0.2985418141,
0.2822886705,
0.1857326478,
0.6069160104,
-0.4163737595,
-0.0909359232,
0.0967870727,
-0.2626950741,
-0.3977843821,
-0.3893821239,
0.6251356006,
-0.6649363637,
-0.4080521166,
-0.124486506,
-0.6332271695,
0.0651263967,
0.4704205394,
0.655097127,
0.1559267044,
-0.0933518559,
0.5777441859,
0.4007637501,
-0.0804325938,
0.440466553,
-0.0414619446,
0.1559763849,
-0.2562406659,
1.0276455879,
0.193706885,
0.5202746391,
0.509383738,
0.3579969108,
-0.1974828243,
-0.6841567755,
-0.4975292087,
0.3230840266,
-0.3823662102,
-0.1495895982,
-0.5017424822,
-0.0899312496,
0.0124683194,
-0.0191013515,
-0.4702962637,
-0.8501166701,
-0.0079815062,
0.1088261232,
0.1495711058,
0.7535355091,
-0.0444380939,
0.6070428491,
-0.9043808579,
0.3513678908,
0.2117783874,
0.1135619953,
0.0767016485,
-0.3699973822,
-0.5595273972,
0.0134405969,
-0.4792152345,
-0.7981019616,
0.2070543319,
0.0525229424,
0.288444221,
0.0394736752,
0.1046211049,
0.3683925569,
-0.7390679717,
0.4426645637,
0.4793361127,
-0.8738539815,
0.1915436089,
-0.4001461565,
0.3017076552,
0.4586642981,
0.2863005996,
-0.7238045335,
-0.3766286969,
-0.4023452699,
-0.6405873895,
0.5850622654,
0.5301933885,
0.1679657102,
-0.132296741,
0.304980576,
-0.182301715,
0.1445289999,
-0.8518075347,
-0.2645355463,
-0.2950594425,
-0.2084252685,
0.011121776,
-0.1188033819,
-0.0055353721,
0.099536784,
0.4596515894,
-0.1647754014,
0.2007022798,
0.0734743997,
-0.2716344297,
-0.3797080517,
0.4698137939,
0.5625421405,
0.5578181148,
-0.2409488857,
0.3458621204,
0.3806628585,
-0.4257696271,
0.2641584575,
0.106687665,
-0.4027967751,
0.1935471296,
0.160925597,
1.0235408545,
0.2713369727,
-0.009582852,
0.4662652612,
-0.0271457825,
-0.0919055417,
0.0954398513,
-0.1525746286,
0.3916222751,
0.2474340498,
0.0264904834,
0.5306887627,
-0.1609698087,
-0.2545990944,
-0.0791113451,
0.3964298666,
-0.4858695865,
-0.7301681638,
0.6582829356,
0.2741551399,
-0.5420505404,
0.736635685,
-0.276954025,
-0.6418659687,
0.5197199583,
0.5608697534,
1.0123567581,
0.0118835196,
0.0235332306,
0.1349178106,
0.6540168524,
-0.2831269801,
-0.0573644787,
-0.0416781567,
-0.5337147713,
-0.571928978,
-0.4191296995,
-0.52271837,
0.0104014473,
-0.46634987,
0.1585323215,
-0.3260873556,
-0.4069418311,
-0.1724222898,
-0.180303067,
-0.6807379723,
-0.4271553457,
-0.2021190971,
0.6822678447,
-0.6456031799,
1.1879150867,
0.5249440074,
-0.4671450257,
-0.5341631174,
-0.1095913574,
-0.1995713413,
-0.6876474619,
1.1229777336,
0.0205683783,
-0.1961930096,
-0.1376523823,
0.0398710407,
-0.7129867673,
1.0519046783,
0.5610183477,
-0.6296931505,
-0.4575456083,
0.4981180429,
0.5832203031,
0.05514865,
-0.357334137,
0.1672552675,
0.3312024474,
-0.0044618803,
-1.12111938,
0.1919119805,
0.0750156119,
0.1973549277,
0.5694786906,
-0.8020251393,
1.090470314,
-0.1259955317,
-0.2872083187,
0.21244964,
0.3617697656,
-0.0183797143,
0.0575295724,
0.4909276068,
0.5890880227,
0.3385577202,
-0.0350103416,
1.1962753534,
-0.3181871772,
0.3714723587,
1.2585405111,
-0.2492382377,
0.8127726316,
0.7990282178,
0.0920277536,
0.0248261373,
0.1231320649,
-0.0832215175,
0.6363631487,
0.3257276416,
-0.2351370752,
-0.1601556093,
-0.3444782197,
-0.5091671944,
0.2063797712,
0.0356587991,
-0.6067552567,
-0.2015745789,
-0.1548467129,
-0.0352832451,
0.0013445247,
0.0234671421,
0.4538348019,
0.6510508657,
-0.5312649608,
0.5928893685,
0.0099853715,
0.6533308029,
-0.2740904093,
0.1745459139,
-0.432297945,
0.4195228517,
0.088741608,
-0.3145262599,
0.6857258081,
0.1202425957,
-0.3949465156,
-0.6030888557,
0.7236213088,
-0.3170770705,
-0.2239063829,
0.5270507932,
0.9353189468,
0.04377928,
-0.0551943555,
-0.7445914149,
-0.1665320843,
-0.1580801159,
-0.0838136524,
0.4231710434,
0.5513066053,
-0.0499639176,
0.3411813974,
0.6511406898,
0.4389952421,
0.3052924573,
0.0054250751,
0.7034518123,
-0.6971467137,
-0.1235321984,
-0.9304742813,
-0.0151585191,
0.0612986721,
-0.2089197338,
0.7625021338,
0.4917439818,
0.9216237068,
-0.1573349386,
0.4823890626,
0.0813564807,
0.2863046527,
-0.4400809407,
0.7640733123,
-0.3109079599,
0.0197161119,
0.1854423434,
-1.3025530577,
-0.1226662472,
0.4812419415,
-0.1523870528,
-0.1516639441,
1.0512596369,
0.6114040017,
-0.3072986603,
-0.2794444263,
0.3955566287,
0.1531078666,
0.1086593047,
0.8370392323,
1.1846115589,
-0.4992064238,
1.0065786839,
-0.4397409558,
0.289254576,
-0.0916590244,
-0.8171666265,
-0.9107024074,
-0.3815804124,
-0.0916572809,
-0.4203598201,
0.1371764839,
1.0404900312,
0.6019209623,
-0.5507065654,
-0.2906222343,
0.0359051041,
0.4758082926,
-0.2697002888,
-0.0758174285,
0.3559522033,
-0.1558752656,
-0.7248687148,
0.5759496689,
0.2178568095,
0.2039548606,
-0.090957053,
-0.146187976,
0.0343862623,
-0.3486964703,
0.5701848269,
0.3894436359,
-0.5636274219,
-0.2972667515,
0.3686915636,
-0.2238803506,
0.0591260605,
1.0746566057,
-0.4937906265,
0.073338218,
0.7941392064,
0.7896596789,
0.285897404,
-0.2601509094,
0.5223641396,
-0.9419561625,
0.2567301095,
0.1494197547,
0.5280214548,
0.5227150917,
-0.0010717368,
0.4675705433,
0.5355657935,
-0.3364466429,
-0.6838361621,
0.2944369316,
-0.8223831058,
0.021919895,
1.066652894,
-0.1344268322,
-0.1936233044,
-0.017913036,
0.1062409058,
0.3981699347,
-0.219990164,
0.663132906,
0.4968523681,
0.0171322376,
-0.0300325416,
-0.492582649,
0.516313374,
0.7279186249,
-0.355782479,
-0.0534842797,
0.1514817178,
0.2319268584,
0.3840461969,
0.5406939387,
-0.0095564499,
0.0279476121,
-0.169697836,
-0.2296695709,
-0.2407803088,
-0.2167541832,
-0.5718793273,
0.0780474395,
0.2583637834,
-0.3446216881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10961v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10961v1
|
Energy-Based Models with Applications to Speech and Language Processing
| 2024-03-16T16:16:31 | 2024-03-16T16:16:31 |
Zhijian Ou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Energy-Based Models (EBMs) are an important class of probabilistic models,
also known as random fields and undirected graphical models. EBMs are
un-normalized and thus radically different from other popular self-normalized
probabilistic models such as hidden Markov models (HMMs), autoregressive
models, generative adversarial nets (GANs) and variational auto-encoders
(VAEs). Over the past years, EBMs have attracted increasing interest not only
from the core machine learning community, but also from application domains
such as speech, vision, natural language processing (NLP) and so on, due to
significant theoretical and algorithmic progress. The sequential nature of
speech and language also presents special challenges and needs a different
treatment from processing fix-dimensional data (e.g., images). Therefore, the
purpose of this monograph is to present a systematic introduction to
energy-based models, including both algorithmic progress and applications in
speech and language processing. First, the basics of EBMs are introduced,
including classic models, recent models parameterized by neural networks,
sampling methods, and various learning methods from the classic learning
algorithms to the most advanced ones. Then, the application of EBMs in three
different scenarios is presented, i.e., for modeling marginal, conditional and
joint distributions, respectively. 1) EBMs for sequential data with
applications in language modeling, where the main focus is on the marginal
distribution of a sequence itself; 2) EBMs for modeling conditional
distributions of target sequences given observation sequences, with
applications in speech recognition, sequence labeling and text generation; 3)
EBMs for modeling joint distributions of both sequences of observations and
targets, and their applications in semi-supervised learning and calibrated
natural language understanding.
|
[
0.0765264034,
-0.8547933698,
0.464117825,
-0.0415184423,
0.2362128198,
0.0668240562,
-0.2250674069,
-0.2848677039,
0.3014495075,
0.3688139915,
-0.2476452887,
-0.4371269941,
-0.2968564034,
-0.0687961876,
-0.574678719,
0.4646801651,
0.1047407687,
0.1686742157,
-0.2430725545,
0.0000519015,
-0.0795155242,
-0.4300657511,
-0.5028574467,
-0.5630537868,
0.189728722,
-0.1111556962,
0.6432636976,
0.6704817414,
0.569032073,
0.2970402241,
0.1020277068,
-0.3247666359,
-0.2811952829,
0.2087239921,
-0.2490082234,
-0.7021169662,
-0.0110276118,
0.0363505632,
0.7564247251,
1.2541764975,
-0.6573426723,
0.1939176023,
-0.3846493661,
0.6338860393,
-0.6718655825,
0.5312981606,
-0.5788164139,
0.2411715537,
-0.2386728227,
-0.1903083324,
-0.4668394327,
-0.2122105509,
-0.0043974677,
-0.465475142,
0.2479113936,
0.3445894718,
0.6382299066,
0.2112982571,
-0.4080642164,
-0.3612349927,
-0.8330411911,
1.0641207695,
-0.5972813368,
0.4753262997,
0.291711092,
0.2980766892,
-0.1761188358,
-0.7795499563,
-0.4403394759,
0.0354923531,
-0.094119668,
0.2490485311,
-0.5278573036,
0.6666650176,
0.2141352743,
0.2450870872,
-0.5744293332,
0.253061682,
-0.160006851,
0.0061171344,
0.4084936678,
0.212463811,
0.2275714874,
-0.3584417105,
-0.1517483592,
-0.1220607981,
-0.5789715648,
0.0141980993,
0.4046291411,
0.2901665568,
-0.1544745266,
0.5321686268,
-0.254139483,
1.3075689077,
-0.2072541565,
-0.248996973,
0.1245886534,
0.0454573967,
-0.5016328692,
-0.0902964175,
0.577054739,
0.1098564789,
-0.0085451026,
0.0177709721,
-0.1219428852,
-0.0259371866,
-0.1962700486,
-0.5949622989,
-0.4914413989,
0.2593617737,
-0.881857574,
-0.1670227498,
-0.1774265319,
-0.8832892776,
-0.0312477294,
-0.6238535643,
0.4906933308,
-0.265791744,
-0.5935985446,
0.2954576313,
-0.0105652297,
0.0318935663,
-0.2142815292,
-1.2740767002,
0.52530545,
0.3682260811,
0.8602412343,
0.1971432865,
0.1379569173,
-0.0657080263,
0.4362894893,
-0.0324994549,
0.8499088883,
-1.0072015524,
-0.2656241059,
0.1237842515,
-0.2043975741,
-0.3027846217,
-0.5046699643,
0.3541403413,
-0.4202580452,
0.1289155334,
-0.0119913165,
-0.7750248313,
-0.3951457739,
-0.3567225635,
-0.6381009221,
0.8452067971,
-0.0513932519,
-0.4287560582,
-0.0320070311,
-1.0826528072,
-0.4030660987,
-0.1154820323,
-0.0658980906,
-0.239370212,
0.4455151856,
-0.141220063,
0.5600708723,
-0.4921490252,
0.2499110848,
-0.2200109363,
0.150358066,
-0.137274608,
-0.4971069694,
0.7243602276,
0.722341001,
-0.0387029387,
-0.0329072587,
-1.1289166212,
0.1435330957,
0.1760999113,
-0.031422589,
-0.394454062,
0.4915641844,
0.1709586829,
0.2147673965,
0.0626392961,
-0.4213303328,
-0.082020849,
-0.2761720419,
0.570507586,
0.4841908216,
-0.0689113215,
0.2376196682,
-0.18532525,
0.3177788258,
0.0659393743,
-0.0831725746,
-0.590236783,
-0.3589541912,
-0.5649263263,
-0.337182194,
0.3740954101,
0.7306783795,
-0.8766021729,
0.370929271,
0.0679926053,
-0.6061458588,
-0.6278614402,
-0.2991881669,
0.1206980124,
0.3949314058,
0.4221171737,
-0.0287287999,
-0.6761440039,
-1.0654426813,
-0.5297042727,
-0.3262909353,
-0.1599301696,
0.2810740471,
0.1109632403,
0.0689582899,
0.9218070507,
-0.6486717463,
0.2663961947,
0.1071163565,
0.3312350512,
0.2291472852,
0.5475857258,
0.4998320639,
-0.8975411654,
-0.3852334619,
-0.221765697,
-0.9269124269,
-0.313283205,
-0.1125204116,
0.2352270484,
-0.1690133661,
0.2962143421,
-0.5108770132,
0.3190072477,
0.6754405499,
0.0432207249,
0.2033071965,
-0.2187576741,
0.0665448532,
-1.0242743492,
-0.0366140381,
0.3398199975,
-0.304017812,
-0.9995262623,
-0.1663122922,
-0.3341065347,
-0.4785874486,
-0.6070714593,
0.186216414,
-0.8411607146,
-0.4381155372,
-0.5267993808,
-0.2842718363,
-0.0730689317,
0.3093328476,
0.2896391153,
0.1412795186,
1.0310367346,
-0.6364093423,
0.6773854494,
-0.2787938118,
-0.3711473644,
0.6239959598,
-0.5392063856,
0.3705229759,
-0.3525576293,
-0.0243920367,
-0.8774772882,
-0.2256300598,
-0.123445645,
-0.1018598378,
0.7932753563,
0.1395935863,
-0.4756188095,
-0.2480078191,
0.1419165581,
0.2883588374,
0.5189782381,
-0.3791457117,
0.7890323997,
0.8183163404,
-0.126249969,
-0.2636696398,
-0.6228249073,
-0.0964748561,
0.0074517406,
-0.6286408901,
0.5147374868,
0.0929013789,
-0.4767550826,
0.2435854524,
0.2033656985,
-0.0330752917,
0.0014186114,
0.2195426375,
0.0211834162,
-0.0026859958,
0.4029413462,
-0.1030392274,
-0.0649278536,
-0.1062972248,
-0.4692338109,
0.5182598233,
-0.251508534,
-0.4584653676,
-0.44831267,
0.6465222239,
0.2406744808,
0.3382174671,
1.1439986229,
0.5015605688,
-0.7954822183,
0.148753956,
-0.4620631933,
-0.0778597295,
-0.4297880232,
0.6433186531,
-0.4366633296,
-0.5555035472,
0.2829232514,
-0.3312595785,
0.1361546814,
0.6175393462,
1.015173316,
-0.312681675,
1.0519846678,
0.9737927318,
0.0778784081,
0.941932261,
-0.0769992992,
0.3742823899,
-0.6168370247,
-0.2415727675,
-0.5415223241,
-0.3867578804,
-0.8462058902,
-0.3354975879,
0.2174213082,
-0.1756162345,
0.0089246016,
0.2619728148,
-0.3625157475,
0.4921782315,
0.3081068397,
-0.155159384,
-0.1317294389,
0.2469126731,
-0.1281375736,
0.1276137978,
-0.9618159533,
-0.5290251374,
0.9952837825,
0.3577423096,
0.9606675506,
-0.1472260654,
0.4639499187,
0.2658886909,
0.2547087669,
-0.7212496996,
0.3957390785,
0.0408522524,
-0.7575435042,
-0.2578985095,
-0.619900763,
-0.9437537193,
0.4162068963,
-0.0769338384,
-0.7057211399,
0.2490684986,
0.2385212034,
-0.4186576903,
0.7521480322,
-1.0165958405,
0.5030855536,
-0.2740412056,
-0.3773380518,
-0.4186320007,
-0.712988317,
0.0089226551,
0.1561438143,
0.5979967117,
-0.290163368,
-0.0518114232,
0.9436458349,
-0.0911662728,
0.750569284,
-0.4756937027,
0.2950149775,
0.6401468515,
-0.2086192071,
0.344648838,
-0.500665307,
-0.3240457773,
0.4431779087,
0.1995104402,
-0.4755345881,
-0.496266067,
0.6012747288,
-0.5793867707,
-0.718182683,
-0.4135252833,
-0.5375952125,
-0.2161155343,
0.1572092921,
0.2392003238,
0.3134916425,
-0.1759334058,
0.2017266005,
0.4962670505,
-0.2868420184,
0.6445366144,
0.5397735834,
-0.2396921515,
-0.1828063875,
1.0700256824,
0.3379581571,
0.3818706572,
0.6735124588,
0.1401908547,
-0.2271280587,
-0.476680398,
-0.0668237358,
0.0131436158,
-0.6642253399,
-0.1197901666,
-0.6198877692,
-0.0925989524,
-0.2765723467,
0.0125049921,
-0.3510683477,
-0.6650593281,
-0.5078175664,
-0.3147423863,
0.1416065693,
0.5792962909,
-0.6859179735,
0.2081472278,
-0.5326961279,
0.3882693946,
0.2934612632,
0.1873352975,
-0.0991788283,
-0.3301165998,
-0.5300138593,
0.0817316025,
-0.4061600268,
-1.2074911594,
0.5753196478,
0.5187606215,
0.6657811403,
0.1793100983,
-0.440407753,
0.2695699036,
-0.5489270091,
0.7400146127,
0.726069808,
-0.8693855405,
0.6780887246,
-0.3521398306,
-0.097205922,
0.2103419006,
0.5825781226,
-0.6040203571,
0.3654445112,
-0.6645684242,
-0.803529799,
0.3372285962,
0.2058663964,
-0.1048052907,
-0.1255988628,
0.4220889509,
-0.084721677,
0.5663706064,
-0.5783107877,
-0.565949142,
-0.4607263803,
-0.5545592308,
0.2333938777,
-0.0386456624,
0.1762298495,
-0.2344475985,
0.7233211994,
-0.0841204226,
0.5130607486,
-0.0188424829,
-0.1536487043,
-0.4114502668,
0.3524774015,
0.341563195,
0.3012541831,
-0.3164608479,
-0.0584574677,
-0.0045922613,
-0.259717226,
0.4433036745,
-0.01934007,
-0.1077571586,
0.1589425951,
-0.0234320294,
0.9868059158,
0.3413785994,
-0.4003296793,
-0.0434571877,
0.129173696,
0.124056451,
-0.2597096264,
-0.1015780866,
0.1168716475,
0.0812670738,
0.3161297739,
0.2574951649,
0.3316522241,
-0.9638800621,
-0.0663393438,
0.5592460632,
-0.3349819779,
-0.7364462018,
0.4682587385,
0.2167490572,
-0.5631016493,
0.2578810155,
0.0354228579,
-0.2380488068,
0.5558934212,
0.7349337339,
0.6961645484,
-0.394523263,
-0.0882015601,
0.1789451689,
0.2279185206,
0.1115606651,
0.5846794844,
0.0056513073,
-0.7238308787,
-0.219691202,
-0.826443553,
-0.5925585032,
-0.1520757526,
-0.872097373,
0.1580517143,
-0.4943920672,
-0.5382378697,
0.3079405129,
-0.1283984184,
-0.9911351204,
0.2300009727,
0.5788001418,
0.6833067536,
-0.9353669286,
0.6630283594,
0.874363482,
0.0039208652,
-0.4885702133,
-0.4752126038,
0.1357651204,
-0.6619887352,
0.6074888706,
-0.0610169284,
0.0426638797,
0.5080099106,
-0.6918817759,
-1.3039921522,
0.9326974154,
0.4983542264,
-0.9497748017,
-0.0470199697,
0.0116633261,
0.4242871404,
-0.377407819,
0.4930822551,
0.6668103337,
0.342451185,
-0.1403534412,
-0.6708310843,
-0.4318194687,
-0.0621440895,
0.15861094,
0.3631231487,
-1.0440187454,
0.881062448,
-0.1301969886,
-0.2939341664,
-0.0633099303,
0.8606612086,
0.1841444373,
0.2735701501,
0.2915585041,
0.7056335807,
1.015683651,
-0.2983451486,
1.0989260674,
-0.4319105744,
0.750624299,
0.5241799951,
-0.720387876,
0.7739018798,
0.3060976267,
-0.6704919338,
0.6561685205,
0.607909739,
0.1067627594,
0.7531974912,
0.5972144008,
-0.4081052542,
-0.1160557121,
-0.2926636636,
-0.3767049015,
0.3732286394,
0.8762286305,
-0.5329723358,
-0.0560091957,
0.3013787568,
-0.4097935855,
-0.0781583712,
-0.6215932965,
0.5387491584,
0.4678089023,
-0.0551527068,
0.1725763679,
0.2457008958,
0.511464715,
-0.5507138968,
-0.0065627,
0.4972758293,
-0.1474154443,
-0.2866624892,
-0.3817599714,
0.4701321721,
-0.0787158087,
-0.6032440066,
-0.3934713006,
1.0600422621,
-0.2422103882,
-0.6342345476,
0.0710826293,
0.47376284,
0.2555086911,
0.3436805606,
-0.8317750096,
-0.0391317979,
-0.2155234367,
-0.4937426746,
0.2718481421,
0.0784135982,
0.4542393684,
0.4885804057,
0.6998007298,
0.2224076241,
0.2228599638,
0.1735144556,
0.4692064524,
-1.0088760853,
-0.4517623186,
-0.7363359332,
0.0408653654,
0.2279711813,
0.2614983618,
0.4583587646,
0.4955598116,
0.5982746482,
0.0420411974,
0.9684644341,
-0.0404670015,
0.5805533528,
-0.9709827304,
0.5487557054,
-0.2312859595,
-0.0985214561,
-0.0718496293,
-0.713627696,
-0.1373986453,
0.8257372379,
-0.5855631828,
0.2640506625,
0.7125135064,
0.4314913452,
0.2702583969,
0.3565891683,
0.7735549808,
0.213940084,
0.3823198676,
0.7069055438,
0.7241261005,
-0.3554777205,
-0.0325161703,
-0.3453248143,
-0.2297458202,
-0.130154714,
-0.9888207912,
-0.4768254459,
-0.5429514647,
-0.5481852293,
0.0816525891,
-0.0989527777,
1.1983941793,
1.0018233061,
-1.0394480228,
-0.3591677547,
-0.1081959829,
-0.1236918345,
-0.197617501,
-0.2067498267,
0.3526748121,
0.0272173472,
-0.7121752501,
0.5779557228,
0.7098071575,
0.187741071,
-0.3057524562,
0.3901003003,
-0.412478447,
0.3856389225,
0.6739361882,
0.6214745045,
-0.4658374488,
-0.0529442765,
-0.0827078,
0.2013923824,
0.134670198,
0.8441137075,
-0.9829214811,
0.5895454884,
0.5301212668,
0.4357507527,
0.5429577231,
-0.2133184224,
0.4800003767,
-0.6520392299,
0.4717043936,
0.4940244853,
0.9299799204,
0.6912042499,
-0.2856065333,
0.2094585001,
0.6888777018,
-0.5585132241,
-0.8594736457,
0.4699022472,
-0.6072917581,
-0.0644653589,
0.8357162476,
-0.0519418605,
-0.5765711069,
0.0059820069,
0.398925513,
0.5240774751,
-0.0962254852,
0.5870986581,
0.9448996186,
-0.445028156,
-0.1785069853,
-0.8862808347,
0.3221610487,
0.7016593814,
-0.9154347181,
-0.1209143028,
0.4489706755,
0.1785871387,
0.2970702648,
0.278183192,
0.0222099647,
-0.0514970645,
0.1436521113,
0.16257447,
-0.0080250846,
-0.3371457756,
-0.5674165487,
0.4159952402,
-0.4114151299,
-0.1050397307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10949v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10949v2
|
SelfIE: Self-Interpretation of Large Language Model Embeddings
| 2024-03-16T15:30:34 | 2024-03-26T01:15:09 |
Haozhe Chen, Carl Vondrick, Chengzhi Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
How do large language models (LLMs) obtain their answers? The ability to
explain and control an LLM's reasoning process is key for reliability,
transparency, and future model developments. We propose SelfIE
(Self-Interpretation of Embeddings), a framework that enables LLMs to interpret
their own embeddings in natural language by leveraging their ability to respond
to inquiries about a given passage. Capable of interpreting open-world concepts
in the hidden embeddings, SelfIE reveals LLM internal reasoning in cases such
as making ethical decisions, internalizing prompt injection, and recalling
harmful knowledge. SelfIE's text descriptions on hidden embeddings also open up
new avenues to control LLM reasoning. We propose Supervised Control, which
allows editing open-ended concepts while only requiring gradient computation of
individual layer. We extend RLHF to hidden embeddings and propose Reinforcement
Control that erases harmful knowledge in LLM without supervision targets.
|
[
-0.2075337917,
-0.836990118,
0.8489444256,
0.338411212,
-0.1264541447,
-0.0752658918,
-0.00438111,
-0.4329493642,
0.1596987695,
0.7780548334,
-0.6315459609,
-0.5125831366,
-0.6306964159,
-0.0256535392,
-0.2365685403,
0.6667941213,
-0.2984552979,
0.0572336987,
-0.4395748675,
-0.0670140237,
-0.179515332,
-0.3884067535,
-0.4014085829,
-0.4117152393,
0.682522893,
0.2599339783,
0.8220158815,
0.828353405,
0.4844803214,
0.257211417,
0.0486317798,
-0.2058435529,
-0.3584448695,
0.2890582085,
-0.4950935841,
-0.3560238779,
-0.1251293272,
0.0206490811,
0.7761100531,
0.310064584,
-0.1003395617,
0.2223676294,
-0.0028012751,
0.4072813392,
-0.6075413823,
0.2335381955,
-0.2283132076,
0.197753042,
0.1436192989,
-0.2711758614,
-0.39203462,
0.0714555606,
-0.2543981969,
-0.2722811997,
-0.1378245652,
0.0415566824,
0.4147426188,
0.44648844,
-0.3423628211,
-0.4786064029,
-0.6857827306,
0.5137816072,
-0.5202373862,
0.2995224297,
0.4056024253,
0.2968095839,
-0.365606159,
-0.5442214012,
-0.4754161537,
-0.1250053048,
-0.3287490308,
0.1332042366,
-0.1721736193,
0.0439098887,
0.0078195538,
0.2974709868,
-0.4545639157,
0.2989737689,
-0.1810543835,
-0.2801134586,
0.6458169222,
0.0352117382,
0.4502691925,
-0.2656111121,
-0.449732393,
0.2796100974,
-0.7505210638,
-0.1637938768,
0.2309343517,
-0.0044735442,
-0.0528709069,
0.684548676,
-0.1943990439,
0.4203338325,
0.011327209,
-0.1258133948,
-0.0614547245,
0.0431735255,
-0.4323561192,
0.0224342197,
0.795963645,
0.3132457435,
0.1728850901,
-0.1200846359,
-0.3475143611,
-0.2986477017,
0.0999355316,
-0.7184689641,
0.1180050373,
0.3610049188,
-0.7179736495,
-0.4072689712,
-0.2015037537,
-0.5613828897,
-0.331623286,
-0.0334126465,
0.3712225258,
-0.098685123,
-0.3708266616,
0.2292992622,
0.0962578133,
0.3974124491,
0.4625040591,
-0.8528360724,
0.3923711777,
0.5560356379,
0.6690425873,
0.0428812318,
-0.319537282,
-0.2554399669,
0.5108252168,
-0.4801988304,
0.5550326705,
-0.6032851934,
-0.2958636582,
-0.039584741,
0.0601696819,
0.0849941447,
-0.2837991118,
0.3094049692,
-0.5970872045,
0.2230524719,
-0.0203554332,
-0.7312433124,
-0.1128735244,
0.177539885,
-0.5542476177,
0.6052154303,
-0.3640893996,
-0.6791591048,
-0.01323085,
-0.6536094546,
-0.2354640365,
0.2205120325,
-0.4679286778,
-0.1432236731,
0.1289936751,
0.3903382421,
0.8078612685,
0.0825594962,
0.2115900517,
-0.6141325831,
-0.2332307994,
0.2984209061,
-0.3613777459,
0.7080151439,
0.3417690098,
-0.270750761,
0.1110277325,
-0.2916758955,
0.0257450715,
0.4983147979,
-0.142149359,
-0.3014601469,
-0.1310692132,
-0.4171677828,
0.3275309205,
0.4219389856,
-0.4822821021,
0.2218952775,
-0.0451973304,
0.6330797076,
0.7723225355,
0.1775604635,
0.553915143,
-0.0346939377,
0.6881407499,
-0.0980814546,
0.3656899035,
-0.3916382492,
-0.3861686587,
-0.4062936306,
-0.3050692976,
0.01197901,
0.4026552439,
-0.5527073145,
0.1919356138,
0.0441692062,
-0.195329532,
-0.7777103782,
0.3439492285,
0.6055333614,
0.2821061611,
0.2946488261,
-0.0883344263,
-0.0363070071,
-1.1918233633,
-0.3051800132,
0.0063004973,
0.1953335404,
0.4069943428,
0.6530566812,
-0.247946918,
0.6410324574,
-0.3994149566,
-0.3372569978,
-0.2232215405,
0.174876526,
0.0092716971,
0.6207156181,
0.3736608922,
-0.6374736428,
-0.0610389002,
-0.2690761685,
-1.1100895405,
0.0425985903,
-0.4571978152,
-0.2306691259,
0.0697404072,
0.8701697588,
-0.8294540644,
0.535884738,
0.5819173455,
-0.3594532907,
0.4240849912,
-0.3834974766,
-0.0449264795,
-0.5773230195,
-0.2412297279,
0.1183625907,
-0.7608075738,
-0.2161454856,
0.4367016852,
0.1343908161,
0.1012279913,
-0.4338132739,
0.7979822159,
-0.7339333296,
-0.3081033826,
-0.2303055227,
0.2958836854,
0.0065196604,
0.3756338954,
0.095708549,
0.6147899628,
0.6335352659,
-0.3673335612,
0.3968340755,
0.3384407163,
-0.4531182945,
0.3492762148,
-0.695597589,
0.3052777648,
-0.3616256416,
0.4252685905,
-0.8265710473,
-0.2898280323,
0.5277479887,
-0.4521690607,
0.4212352037,
-0.2104778737,
-0.5514562726,
-0.3738223612,
-0.1075607464,
0.1072162762,
0.2263841033,
-0.8061138988,
0.7005041242,
0.3695911765,
-0.088381581,
-0.7381067872,
-0.846308291,
0.2096319646,
-0.1784243584,
-0.243358016,
0.194410041,
-0.1436509192,
-0.3481242657,
0.3420322835,
-0.0678615868,
-0.1666260064,
0.1614786386,
0.4145390987,
0.0722090378,
-0.0108689414,
0.5002837181,
0.2199162245,
-0.0884849504,
0.4343486726,
-0.2417482883,
0.2103911936,
-0.1934288293,
-0.3988801539,
-0.6254304051,
0.3833353817,
0.3585569859,
-0.1100857481,
0.7569833398,
0.3884519935,
-0.2906062305,
-0.182992965,
-0.5571984053,
-0.1830025315,
-0.4862743318,
0.0189212188,
-0.6869215965,
-1.2685464621,
0.4641219378,
-0.0156425573,
-0.0911580622,
0.3460643589,
0.7539361715,
-0.4829459786,
1.1753331423,
0.6617112756,
-0.1222041994,
0.3461348116,
0.0109215407,
0.0778035074,
-0.7167901397,
-0.1888911873,
-0.1071310788,
-0.1566523314,
-0.6684929132,
-0.5259130597,
0.0497333445,
0.2272320986,
-0.3307897151,
0.0601346381,
-0.4853136241,
0.7869471908,
0.4852049351,
0.2227772772,
0.4596410692,
-0.3470916748,
-0.324251771,
0.1421243399,
-0.5510698557,
-0.7287445664,
0.8190065622,
0.8917682171,
1.2534940243,
0.055211693,
1.0379186869,
0.2409264147,
0.2895446718,
-0.6394206285,
0.511533916,
0.3262427151,
-0.8510830998,
-0.4286701083,
-0.4540699124,
-0.6045988798,
0.3003029227,
0.0065222154,
-0.8211714625,
-0.0092869811,
0.3752909303,
-0.2160276324,
0.2885482311,
-0.5917952061,
0.896661222,
-0.4655791223,
-0.3253572881,
-0.4927714467,
-0.7326589227,
0.5642104149,
0.0652001873,
0.3995158672,
-0.1345153451,
0.0164415538,
0.490636766,
0.0197669752,
1.2525976896,
-0.1921946555,
-0.2530567348,
0.4283326566,
0.5499978065,
0.3848326206,
0.2639570534,
0.1427387148,
0.2502084374,
0.186812222,
-0.3584734201,
-0.9389209151,
0.829654038,
-0.6542294025,
-0.9349951148,
-0.2028502226,
-0.3775685132,
0.0662938878,
0.243910864,
-0.0821434855,
0.2351889163,
-0.1693064719,
0.1250564754,
0.5142554641,
-0.5187742114,
0.3857851923,
0.2958244383,
-0.7896362543,
-0.120217137,
0.7072339654,
-0.1091285497,
0.4158406258,
0.4048886597,
0.3629883528,
-0.52018857,
-0.3801988661,
-0.3764029443,
0.5248601437,
-1.1627815962,
-0.0873571485,
-0.558806777,
-0.0873249099,
-0.4855672717,
0.0225985125,
-0.323066324,
-0.5729942322,
-0.3980421424,
-0.3266803622,
0.1295487732,
1.1562371254,
-0.336686641,
0.2610276937,
-0.5419924259,
0.237751022,
0.4162889719,
0.4783088565,
-0.1853159815,
-0.416007936,
-0.1291604191,
-0.1297700703,
-0.0848814473,
-0.816184938,
0.3641035855,
-0.0262126885,
0.6346631646,
0.3140473664,
-0.0760341138,
0.4440878928,
-0.3966209292,
0.438831389,
0.1111190319,
-1.1056650877,
0.6567859054,
-0.2843832374,
0.1968876719,
0.132737115,
0.6088995934,
-0.4215843379,
-0.5112942457,
-0.691427052,
-0.2410641909,
0.2328255475,
-0.0844729394,
0.4086405337,
-0.0232868828,
0.7345123887,
-0.1286969632,
0.1774561703,
-1.1526792049,
-0.0473855473,
-0.2381340414,
-0.1435710788,
0.0283372682,
-0.4714864194,
-0.43549788,
-0.2003365457,
0.4124388397,
-0.3786787391,
0.4008627534,
0.4724107981,
-0.2429084629,
-0.3632079959,
0.2234819084,
0.3578558862,
0.553447783,
-0.0330182761,
0.5014353991,
-0.0399611294,
0.0881722867,
-0.169113189,
-0.4126982987,
-0.0097418809,
-0.4003318548,
0.5763781071,
0.6156520247,
0.2541948557,
-0.5185646415,
0.688287735,
-0.0617689751,
-0.0594187193,
-0.3359979689,
0.0202236846,
0.3580981195,
0.4300870001,
-0.0168409105,
-0.3922978044,
0.078379117,
-0.6310879588,
0.269397229,
0.5355191231,
-0.4644429982,
-0.2183928341,
0.5686594844,
-0.0269730501,
-0.0633690357,
0.5505310297,
-0.2203377336,
-0.3651849031,
0.4656622708,
0.6977536082,
0.7212538719,
-0.3314158022,
0.5607392788,
0.1698238999,
0.5144658685,
0.1338482201,
0.2331705391,
-0.0765733644,
-1.1142950058,
-0.6615881324,
-0.4290772676,
-0.4929818809,
0.2077835351,
-0.7423240542,
-0.1473904997,
-0.782920897,
0.2372142524,
0.0347472541,
-0.3739026487,
-0.4977078438,
0.3240906,
0.3097408116,
0.9712874889,
-0.7036294937,
0.8876776099,
0.3340879679,
-0.4797560275,
-0.7231355906,
-0.0806684718,
0.0895957798,
-1.2243105173,
0.8757289648,
0.2264688909,
-0.3599499762,
0.0505930409,
-1.1170500517,
-0.8360269666,
0.991189599,
0.426094979,
-0.5989335179,
0.1000545472,
-0.2278189212,
0.4604434371,
-0.6582908034,
0.1568172574,
0.5328041911,
0.4648060799,
0.2103904337,
-0.717376411,
0.2109157592,
0.0914263278,
-0.3099873066,
-0.1040446833,
-0.5458418131,
0.5451864004,
-0.5488387942,
-0.2795694768,
-0.0624934733,
0.6450021863,
-0.1145223677,
0.0669552162,
0.3954850435,
0.5189648271,
0.4812342227,
0.2579963803,
1.2946760654,
-0.2059478164,
0.4550253153,
1.4625177383,
-0.1884262413,
0.8509637713,
0.379275769,
0.1793494076,
0.5928968787,
0.6117079258,
-0.0326162465,
0.5418565273,
0.0453015305,
-0.2492226958,
-0.5589353442,
-0.1473620534,
0.0805913955,
0.668277204,
0.5490595102,
-0.4859946668,
-0.1899050921,
0.1272498965,
-0.046008762,
0.0757792443,
-0.3203262687,
0.7999618649,
0.2953716218,
-0.3685557842,
0.1833800226,
-0.0627776235,
0.3287465572,
-0.2080679238,
-0.1726491153,
-0.0092470692,
-0.0167523567,
-0.3001502752,
-1.2739620209,
0.3965664506,
-0.3029883206,
0.232531473,
-0.7301505804,
1.0962928534,
-0.3630746007,
-0.3107415438,
0.6518757343,
0.7605870366,
0.3352487683,
-0.0966347381,
-1.0958461761,
-0.0989119112,
-0.1780359149,
-0.5481907725,
0.2293940932,
0.4349988699,
-0.0654957369,
1.1335282326,
0.3591391742,
0.0602831952,
-0.0006138993,
0.1346791089,
0.9177742004,
-0.8159386516,
-0.3458904624,
-0.8055902123,
0.077049166,
0.1277609766,
-0.0650569499,
0.5739905238,
0.195162639,
0.7657708526,
0.008294723,
0.7285152674,
0.1880824864,
0.4958054721,
-0.6555677056,
0.6502076387,
-0.5293275714,
-0.07251627,
-0.0305211563,
-0.4338676333,
-0.3336927891,
0.9601278305,
-0.5664640665,
-0.0487551279,
0.5421229601,
0.7458520532,
0.055895254,
-0.0338521786,
0.5818638802,
0.4025358856,
0.330824405,
0.1388719082,
1.143524766,
0.0725999773,
0.2133832574,
-0.2888269424,
-0.2466423512,
0.0368998908,
-1.098074317,
-0.9207690358,
-0.305544287,
-0.3285287917,
-0.117234081,
-0.1328390986,
0.8692728877,
0.6308541298,
-0.5489157438,
-0.1322060376,
-0.1307260543,
0.4661414623,
0.0315595008,
-0.2175133079,
0.1257794946,
-0.3322814107,
-0.4985908866,
0.632923305,
0.5967384577,
0.214531824,
-0.8593824506,
-0.1073946878,
-0.1132554263,
0.0595914908,
0.4237132967,
0.3414571285,
-0.9648587704,
-0.5514124036,
-0.2474083751,
-0.1929982007,
0.1019241288,
0.890529573,
-0.5659819245,
0.6028663516,
0.060152404,
0.5214979053,
0.6256732941,
-0.1622325927,
0.610122323,
-0.5495839119,
0.0262155831,
0.2934213281,
0.4297352135,
0.2593587637,
-0.6963511109,
0.4431228936,
0.0280498136,
-0.6142609715,
-0.5232292414,
0.4053408504,
-0.7160349488,
-0.575122416,
1.0636298656,
-0.4949302077,
-0.4767252505,
0.0148397442,
0.002942669,
0.0216015372,
-0.1479262114,
0.6993558407,
0.6577765346,
-0.227820918,
-0.7702881098,
-0.7915636301,
0.3334755301,
0.2455426306,
-0.9078344107,
0.0763325244,
0.4971267879,
0.4768840075,
0.0884510353,
0.8129896522,
-0.2405837178,
-0.0600630268,
-0.2730568051,
0.2649007142,
-0.0468025357,
-0.5655872226,
-0.5935462713,
-0.0560937002,
0.1368016303,
-0.1345478892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10943v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10943v4
|
MIntRec2.0: A Large-scale Benchmark Dataset for Multimodal Intent Recognition and Out-of-scope Detection in Conversations
| 2024-03-16T15:14:15 | 2024-06-28T02:05:59 |
Hanlei Zhang, Xin Wang, Hua Xu, Qianrui Zhou, Kai Gao, Jianhua Su, jinyue Zhao, Wenrui Li, Yanting Chen
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.CL
|
Multimodal intent recognition poses significant challenges, requiring the
incorporation of non-verbal modalities from real-world contexts to enhance the
comprehension of human intentions. Existing benchmark datasets are limited in
scale and suffer from difficulties in handling out-of-scope samples that arise
in multi-turn conversational interactions. We introduce MIntRec2.0, a
large-scale benchmark dataset for multimodal intent recognition in multi-party
conversations. It contains 1,245 dialogues with 15,040 samples, each annotated
within a new intent taxonomy of 30 fine-grained classes. Besides 9,304 in-scope
samples, it also includes 5,736 out-of-scope samples appearing in multi-turn
contexts, which naturally occur in real-world scenarios. Furthermore, we
provide comprehensive information on the speakers in each utterance, enriching
its utility for multi-party conversational research. We establish a general
framework supporting the organization of single-turn and multi-turn dialogue
data, modality feature extraction, multimodal fusion, as well as in-scope
classification and out-of-scope detection. Evaluation benchmarks are built
using classic multimodal fusion methods, ChatGPT, and human evaluators. While
existing methods incorporating nonverbal information yield improvements,
effectively leveraging context information and detecting out-of-scope samples
remains a substantial challenge. Notably, large language models exhibit a
significant performance gap compared to humans, highlighting the limitations of
machine learning methods in the cognitive intent understanding task. We believe
that MIntRec2.0 will serve as a valuable resource, providing a pioneering
foundation for research in human-machine conversational interactions, and
significantly facilitating related applications. The full dataset and codes are
available at https://github.com/thuiar/MIntRec2.0.
|
[
-0.4244508147,
-0.8274892569,
0.5585345626,
0.1160193011,
0.09710861,
-0.0349773578,
-0.4802692235,
-0.2359913886,
0.124579072,
0.4082177281,
-0.5781587362,
-0.0695318058,
-0.3991517425,
-0.3872512877,
-0.2294211835,
0.6709480882,
0.0387293398,
0.0429887511,
-0.453417331,
-0.3855329752,
-0.7897090912,
-0.2411235124,
-0.3396713138,
-0.1187879443,
0.3605754673,
1.0118597746,
0.2317258716,
-0.0034781443,
0.2204185128,
0.2940166593,
0.2121330947,
0.4533872306,
-0.6362145543,
0.2674841583,
-0.1999777704,
-0.2215940058,
-0.2863024175,
0.196878925,
0.6028851271,
0.466209054,
-0.0862688646,
0.0152758835,
-0.2613291442,
0.529138267,
-0.8519665003,
0.5564439893,
-0.4445143342,
-0.4897739887,
-0.2999525666,
-0.2251848429,
-0.613012135,
-0.1221857741,
0.1130646914,
-0.4294902384,
-0.0534552373,
0.0292382389,
0.4912837148,
-0.2595211267,
-0.5503341556,
-0.3990874887,
-0.421200037,
0.7740189433,
-0.1629424095,
0.8357345462,
0.433300674,
0.384254992,
-0.4452526569,
-0.7558419704,
-0.5550900698,
0.0736338273,
0.0574650913,
0.1537458599,
-0.4135892093,
-0.1084836051,
0.210476175,
0.1148099899,
-0.6825225353,
-0.1674170941,
-0.1611282974,
-0.1464941204,
0.1253983825,
-0.1036250815,
0.0112801082,
-0.2523186207,
-0.3942576945,
-0.5851200819,
-0.3052390516,
0.4041252136,
0.1966689378,
0.1483848989,
-0.0744645,
0.5259457231,
-0.1612695605,
0.3695017099,
0.0991080329,
0.0083836084,
0.2827236056,
-0.6370640397,
-0.0079151839,
0.098165974,
0.7982017398,
0.5047348142,
0.0706428811,
-0.0848472193,
0.165083617,
0.0410973392,
0.0054472056,
-0.99005723,
-0.1997033507,
0.3152559698,
-0.4081745446,
0.1928808987,
0.1211790815,
-0.9234615564,
-0.5369503498,
-0.2601895034,
0.0629112646,
-0.5034429431,
-0.7212733626,
-0.0305566043,
-0.5060750246,
0.4082022607,
0.2422558367,
-0.8085779548,
0.4465897083,
0.8955307007,
0.7096009851,
0.0547494963,
-0.2436112463,
-0.9193598032,
0.0393871441,
-0.3129545748,
0.8634957075,
-0.5156018734,
-0.4364336729,
-0.2979973853,
0.0697040856,
-0.0647103488,
-0.4871534109,
0.3796544075,
-0.2571760416,
0.2440725714,
-0.1845002174,
-0.3084552288,
-0.2059626281,
0.284273237,
-0.5653223395,
0.7093314528,
0.4025876224,
-0.5789948106,
0.4487501681,
-0.8041327596,
-0.5155391693,
0.0926715657,
-0.3132665753,
-0.3098642528,
0.3116438389,
0.076543197,
0.1801007986,
-0.5295182467,
0.3350121081,
-0.5445073843,
-0.1005562991,
0.9233011007,
-0.7482808232,
0.4897347391,
0.1077058688,
-0.3034912944,
0.2967146933,
-0.5283315182,
0.3717932105,
-0.2781861424,
0.1281509548,
-0.2812627256,
-0.2033258528,
0.3784232438,
0.3579720855,
0.0370728076,
-0.5447089076,
-0.0949357748,
0.0213277824,
0.850224793,
0.5348190665,
-0.0966281071,
0.4591138065,
-0.2076272666,
0.1045128033,
-0.0116353324,
0.2359558195,
-0.5830366015,
-0.5971243978,
-0.576500237,
-0.7175038457,
0.1966063827,
0.3975519836,
-0.4508879483,
0.2373645604,
-0.4734379053,
-0.2524914145,
-0.1906348467,
-0.0609037764,
0.6271098852,
0.3267180324,
0.2026352733,
-0.6037947536,
-0.6483039856,
-0.8142648339,
-0.1771350056,
-0.4408226609,
0.0411338471,
0.7178227901,
0.3161171377,
-0.3661491573,
1.2852352858,
-0.2275403738,
-0.3994384408,
-0.3333564699,
0.680847466,
-0.1649678349,
0.2966902554,
0.0870409608,
-0.9679144621,
-0.2467979938,
-0.014841482,
-0.5491452813,
0.0889774114,
-0.1461382359,
-0.1299533546,
0.2876989543,
0.5448465943,
-0.4137193561,
0.3989758193,
0.6486339569,
-0.3405455947,
0.1399215013,
-0.290922612,
0.5263047218,
-0.9829679728,
0.1215432137,
-0.0353150554,
-0.2549250126,
-0.7277354002,
-0.573613584,
0.5558060408,
-0.012194044,
-0.4896300733,
0.6573281288,
-0.3555111587,
-0.1079022735,
-0.053030096,
0.2426193058,
0.1614910066,
0.4062851965,
0.3915382922,
0.8255625367,
0.160073787,
-0.3486015499,
0.261943996,
0.415949285,
-0.4485544562,
1.123408556,
-0.1908011287,
0.2563659847,
0.0724577457,
0.4441641569,
-1.3319112062,
-0.5546875,
0.2186018974,
-0.6222347021,
0.3653910458,
-0.2471728921,
-0.5593541265,
-0.0481573492,
-0.4772392809,
0.6103868484,
0.257260561,
-0.6042883992,
0.7485429049,
0.6362876296,
-0.0996243954,
-0.142021805,
-0.7894568443,
0.4120804071,
-0.1173147336,
-0.8107178807,
0.0337992609,
-0.0396075882,
-0.1508523375,
-0.4804238975,
0.116975382,
-0.0963632986,
-0.4329608977,
0.5753045678,
0.1742390245,
0.2554821372,
0.0605719797,
-0.2401844412,
-0.1957244128,
0.0139146931,
-0.1705254465,
0.6244826317,
-0.3334876895,
-0.3513109386,
-0.5457561016,
0.3269793987,
0.7969710827,
-0.2826867104,
0.1180931553,
0.7150194049,
-0.0784227774,
0.4379017651,
-0.8626334667,
-0.1994256228,
-0.4344816506,
0.5435252786,
-0.518556118,
-0.6885895729,
0.3083885312,
-0.26036641,
-0.2671213448,
-0.1362874508,
0.570438385,
0.1776108742,
0.898090899,
0.2353218943,
0.1375484914,
0.7609983683,
-0.2639465034,
0.2131486386,
-1.1870200634,
-0.417868644,
-0.108754158,
-0.1739835292,
-0.6565818787,
-0.7780184746,
0.3077476621,
-0.1810776144,
0.0572012365,
0.5441929698,
-0.1157074124,
0.2431410849,
0.6134138107,
-0.0181306247,
0.1655175388,
-0.2233235836,
0.4115116,
-0.0984643549,
-0.409448266,
-0.016939003,
1.1377755404,
0.3370655775,
0.7611202598,
0.306805402,
0.294936955,
0.0131432926,
0.1549534053,
-0.9192456007,
0.4300926328,
0.1965795606,
-0.9278229475,
-0.2155397832,
-0.7162641883,
-0.8499051929,
0.1461866796,
0.1236616895,
-0.9262448549,
0.5427262187,
-0.2472976297,
-0.0541789196,
0.0755216256,
-1.0443410873,
1.1465725899,
-0.5467395186,
-0.6273872256,
-0.2878133357,
-0.6755540371,
0.4314940274,
0.099301137,
0.4710785151,
-0.1520005614,
0.1800077856,
0.7374138236,
0.1337470561,
0.6080629826,
-0.2248263061,
0.1310911477,
0.418558538,
0.1545014977,
0.5469812751,
0.598398149,
0.3493405581,
0.222898379,
0.1364334226,
0.0582663082,
-0.3122467399,
0.8339629173,
-0.4645752609,
0.1008443236,
-0.5584647655,
-0.7441650629,
-0.4163692892,
0.2890214622,
0.0080349734,
0.7383427024,
-0.5791561007,
0.5053786039,
0.8066478968,
0.00639513,
0.3383199275,
0.5484704375,
-0.1498945355,
-0.7184619308,
1.1892522573,
-0.198792249,
0.2016860694,
0.5235010982,
0.1618768424,
-0.7787989974,
-0.0620360114,
-0.5238247514,
0.0419898108,
-0.6091777682,
-0.1202086881,
-0.6955032349,
0.2433322668,
-0.6613932848,
0.0231090002,
-0.5128983259,
-0.2780630887,
-0.241545558,
0.4049987495,
0.3420934677,
0.3212156296,
-0.2538715601,
0.1402405202,
-0.472336024,
0.5330209732,
0.4222392142,
0.4373006821,
-0.4391250014,
-0.2648950517,
0.2036761791,
0.2660109103,
-0.1852580011,
-0.5173116922,
0.2509537339,
0.2026549727,
0.2460896969,
0.7251444459,
-0.0198090244,
0.7746246457,
-0.12897636,
0.3496844172,
0.7294912338,
-0.8956434131,
0.3695248663,
-0.2165213227,
0.3464574516,
0.7667892575,
-0.1479592919,
-0.9738252759,
0.0698915422,
-0.5430374146,
-0.6834442616,
1.1472212076,
0.1826830506,
-0.2450180203,
-0.094530426,
-0.1739260107,
0.1120487154,
0.2110868543,
-0.0991702676,
0.1244232655,
-0.3674343526,
-0.0180123709,
-0.2916531861,
-0.2582986951,
-0.2700432539,
0.0328022577,
0.2804765999,
-0.3412028253,
0.2989423275,
-0.1047909558,
-0.1414493769,
-0.1457589269,
0.540366292,
0.6406341791,
0.6692836285,
-0.5386846066,
0.0559989698,
-0.0319431946,
-0.430267036,
-0.0881579518,
0.2979510725,
0.3932169974,
-0.2989383638,
0.0574588142,
0.6413779259,
0.3975286484,
-1.1027266979,
0.7959477305,
-0.6957688332,
-0.1539235711,
-0.4678421319,
-0.2722601295,
-0.1772611737,
0.2573772967,
-0.0165345967,
0.2045276612,
0.3237966597,
-1.0073642731,
0.2825012803,
0.644931972,
-0.7110898495,
-0.2783100903,
0.2652780712,
0.0668867603,
-0.0131181665,
0.8128426075,
-0.4880674779,
-0.2139139324,
0.1890686601,
0.3090220094,
0.7976067662,
0.2880914807,
0.3006629348,
0.2548315823,
-0.0777492002,
-0.0799855664,
0.2710562646,
-0.3446791172,
-0.3852940798,
-0.1141444296,
-0.0926693976,
-0.6336421371,
0.0822477415,
-0.5517501831,
0.3743640184,
-0.332128793,
-0.1974559277,
0.0475540794,
-0.0740011185,
-0.5564699769,
-0.2969602048,
0.104504168,
0.518607378,
-0.4674760997,
0.6953883171,
0.5748450756,
-0.2082694322,
-0.314763397,
-0.3314311206,
0.3474819064,
-0.6398841143,
0.4557094276,
0.4369737804,
-0.3394545913,
-0.2665628791,
-0.1606397778,
-0.620628655,
1.0228799582,
0.083508648,
-0.4189742804,
0.2213300318,
0.2788575888,
0.0984474048,
-0.2407214642,
0.7906312346,
0.6577395797,
0.8445600867,
0.5324062109,
-0.9382773638,
-0.0496395454,
-0.0063128159,
-0.030053746,
0.504607439,
-0.7397959828,
0.7367104292,
-0.05927651,
-0.2567549348,
0.1986829042,
0.2353526801,
0.272100091,
0.5795212388,
0.4639472365,
0.4699040949,
0.5674812794,
-0.4380761087,
0.5508316755,
-0.0885940492,
0.0159510635,
1.1667560339,
-0.4807390869,
0.7646036148,
0.6099943519,
0.0817375854,
0.3235151768,
0.3639711142,
0.314566493,
0.6820563078,
-0.0600779913,
-0.1725191325,
-0.2863432467,
-0.3166532815,
-0.1692125201,
0.7522134781,
0.7834680676,
0.1638129205,
-0.0787900016,
0.1924637854,
-0.1283356249,
-0.2815406621,
0.0052210791,
1.080217123,
-0.2268326283,
-0.9187893867,
0.357119292,
-0.1587896794,
0.616782546,
-0.5656362772,
-0.0761449039,
0.0007004163,
0.7675563097,
-0.1240944043,
-0.8423655629,
-0.2010924965,
-0.3509985507,
-0.1063723117,
-0.3069532216,
0.5534399152,
-0.4332518876,
-0.1468948275,
0.1778790802,
0.2448378354,
0.1609246135,
-0.4252575934,
-0.4449232221,
0.3247063756,
-0.2338092029,
0.1024348587,
0.4024485946,
0.7018532157,
-0.259552002,
0.3804163039,
0.7744911909,
-0.3165195882,
-0.2352757007,
0.1430260688,
0.8619964123,
-0.4078420401,
-0.4757262766,
-0.4472121894,
0.2442524731,
-0.2783225477,
-0.5050032735,
0.6059226394,
0.8599060774,
0.8206497431,
0.3355787992,
0.6355919242,
-0.4512087107,
0.4730587602,
-0.1878307164,
0.1734153181,
-0.4243644774,
-0.0838317424,
0.0011029348,
-0.5311291814,
0.0474337079,
0.5014581084,
-0.3314300776,
0.1863517314,
0.6840187907,
0.8065904975,
-0.2886813879,
0.3324041367,
0.2093531489,
-0.1626167148,
0.7012130022,
0.6718169451,
0.9605200291,
-0.4338346124,
0.8593273759,
-0.1755075157,
-0.6354983449,
-0.6268472672,
-0.6107192636,
-0.9637874365,
-0.9003790617,
-0.1796459705,
-0.3974543214,
-0.0032747409,
0.899318397,
0.9961023927,
-0.7826704383,
-0.4507072866,
-0.2731665969,
-0.1243587062,
-0.3188864291,
-0.2337787598,
0.0574795417,
-0.309987843,
-0.6091349721,
0.5039716363,
0.5514371395,
-0.1702409238,
-0.3186157346,
-0.2940764725,
-0.4450422227,
-0.0700747296,
0.6522959471,
0.4541603029,
-0.5595387816,
-0.1093735546,
0.1962996423,
0.1140846536,
0.135360688,
1.2148762941,
-0.6977767944,
0.8869498372,
0.5181991458,
0.1931557506,
0.7093379498,
-0.0864216238,
0.241280511,
-0.7459865808,
0.2064621449,
0.2050966471,
0.2029943168,
0.4201247692,
0.1240676194,
0.2787984312,
0.0160380155,
-0.5822299719,
-0.7086934447,
0.3333957195,
-1.2628788948,
-0.3407345414,
1.2724113464,
0.1211374775,
-0.3151003718,
-0.3708151579,
-0.4912846088,
0.1619625092,
-0.9435294271,
0.4052169323,
0.5434257984,
-0.4125119746,
-0.2608329058,
-0.3916707635,
0.3046107292,
0.1330795139,
-0.8003927469,
0.7960889935,
0.6548416615,
0.0032947615,
0.2789642811,
0.7516580224,
-0.2693116069,
0.4620164335,
0.0152921304,
-0.0063495254,
-0.1023543477,
-0.5242059231,
-0.0489155054,
-0.02150755,
-0.1053886041,
-0.2040636241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10937v1
|
Initial Decoding with Minimally Augmented Language Model for Improved Lattice Rescoring in Low Resource ASR
| 2024-03-16T14:34:31 | 2024-03-16T14:34:31 |
Savitha Murthy, Dinkar Sitaram
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper addresses the problem of improving speech recognition accuracy
with lattice rescoring in low-resource languages where the baseline language
model is insufficient for generating inclusive lattices. We minimally augment
the baseline language model with word unigram counts that are present in a
larger text corpus of the target language but absent in the baseline. The
lattices generated after decoding with such an augmented baseline language
model are more comprehensive. We obtain 21.8% (Telugu) and 41.8% (Kannada)
relative word error reduction with our proposed method. This reduction in word
error rate is comparable to 21.5% (Telugu) and 45.9% (Kannada) relative word
error reduction obtained by decoding with full Wikipedia text augmented
language mode while our approach consumes only 1/8th the memory. We demonstrate
that our method is comparable with various text selection-based language model
augmentation and also consistent for data sets of different sizes. Our approach
is applicable for training speech recognition systems under low resource
conditions where speech data and compute resources are insufficient, while
there is a large text corpus that is available in the target language. Our
research involves addressing the issue of out-of-vocabulary words of the
baseline in general and does not focus on resolving the absence of named
entities. Our proposed method is simple and yet computationally less expensive.
|
[
-0.0816936493,
-0.2772824168,
-0.1008691788,
-0.0875575542,
-0.4278944731,
0.2257177085,
-0.2167405188,
-0.2372248322,
0.164422214,
0.4414307773,
-0.146743983,
-0.149999395,
-0.3138409555,
0.1729855984,
-0.3062793016,
0.4715291858,
0.1466033906,
0.3918318748,
-0.1679748595,
-0.1025554612,
-0.248266682,
-0.538192153,
-0.7686081529,
-0.5630894899,
-0.1634279788,
0.5631989837,
0.4437984228,
0.6943707466,
0.2976089418,
0.3408587277,
-0.5190748572,
0.3934625983,
-0.4517372251,
-0.4686609209,
0.1223344579,
-0.1272512525,
-0.4170631766,
-0.4079600275,
1.1195200682,
0.8295996189,
-0.4645697176,
0.1580286473,
0.3853673637,
0.6465465426,
-0.7766201496,
0.017602127,
-0.7520205975,
0.0043663634,
-0.2380711436,
-0.2816534638,
-0.5655024052,
0.1512306184,
-0.3159760535,
-0.4583467543,
0.2666498423,
0.1312316358,
0.467392385,
0.188134864,
-0.0969917178,
-0.2047058493,
-0.8918787241,
0.887436986,
-0.5834082365,
0.6598494053,
0.8101944327,
-0.0510657504,
0.1066119298,
-0.6338422298,
-0.6170989275,
-0.4259002507,
-0.108189553,
-0.0904518813,
-0.308453083,
0.3040485978,
0.4487378001,
0.6082728505,
-0.3371730149,
-0.0763246194,
-0.5381006002,
-0.5471379161,
0.2833571732,
0.2291028202,
0.3763393462,
-0.4549568295,
-0.0762853324,
0.0450015627,
-0.5734758377,
0.2654198408,
0.1337954551,
0.5849946737,
-0.4261839688,
0.6323381066,
-0.2815959752,
0.7442694902,
0.0453432538,
-0.2865172029,
0.217166841,
-0.4913731217,
-0.292301178,
0.5630759597,
0.6342919469,
0.0320688523,
-0.0266553964,
-0.0621549338,
-0.1525958329,
0.2792829275,
0.0985320956,
-0.6615498662,
-0.218217507,
-0.1508496553,
-0.4327234924,
0.0179668646,
-0.4208734632,
-0.4193531275,
-0.3742840886,
-0.3072935641,
0.0811992362,
-0.7034425735,
-0.0829878375,
-0.1850290596,
0.0399133116,
0.2819465399,
0.0746847317,
-1.0411475897,
0.7042844296,
0.3509245813,
0.8451183438,
0.0636942908,
-0.0343081132,
-0.7415041327,
0.0904281884,
-0.4245025218,
0.7073959112,
-0.4316780269,
-0.8670207262,
-0.2242509723,
-0.3006744385,
0.1647166312,
-0.5654219389,
0.7599244118,
-0.2735382318,
-0.1418838352,
-0.2972111106,
-0.3265023232,
0.1373959631,
0.0994618759,
-0.5083488822,
0.9126375318,
0.0156390369,
-0.6132987738,
0.0244933125,
-0.453121841,
-0.4048624337,
0.28955549,
-0.240159601,
-0.0490492135,
0.2688171566,
0.3143079281,
-0.1463856399,
-0.5438479781,
-0.388977319,
0.2282879949,
-0.5436939597,
0.1868116558,
-0.6456668973,
0.6974906921,
0.4398211539,
0.2127308995,
-0.1894108355,
-1.0220116377,
0.3887306154,
-0.3134411275,
-0.5621800423,
-0.3334031999,
0.0213082191,
0.3125523329,
-0.3723473549,
0.2508973479,
-0.6557461023,
-0.1659187675,
-0.8598920107,
0.2718985677,
0.4262943864,
-0.1295666248,
0.8224666715,
-0.1486851573,
0.200202018,
-0.0473484099,
-0.1066842601,
0.0944052041,
-0.2062233388,
-0.7669452429,
-0.2709738612,
0.6367319822,
0.6375069618,
-1.299094677,
0.0798930973,
-0.4143253565,
-0.096087344,
-0.829059124,
0.3882100284,
0.9360442758,
0.6517739892,
0.5436942577,
-0.382784903,
-1.0002654791,
-0.7438057661,
-0.0543763153,
-0.4138307869,
0.0535988808,
0.2417648435,
-0.0429617241,
-0.1789874285,
0.7298415303,
-0.383068949,
-0.3060799241,
-0.4852110445,
-0.0176545866,
0.2496544719,
0.6055964828,
0.1217477694,
-0.7660773993,
-0.7161184549,
0.1860841215,
-0.4464582801,
0.3000988662,
0.3751114309,
0.1648530513,
0.3152076602,
0.4199658632,
-0.3478149772,
0.4706573486,
0.3960339427,
0.0482970104,
0.1902126819,
-0.510871768,
0.2041385919,
-1.1798484325,
0.0211384203,
-0.169687435,
-0.0596529245,
-1.1786977053,
-0.2906211913,
0.0893622041,
-0.3031173646,
-0.5391921997,
0.4883755147,
-0.8141423464,
-0.2265196592,
-0.6880913973,
0.0529872552,
-0.3307943344,
0.2940803766,
0.2140480876,
0.9718278646,
0.4028509557,
-0.7996726632,
0.3375500143,
0.5143267512,
-0.3755092323,
0.3633524179,
-0.4634074271,
0.0709118396,
-0.2033949345,
-0.1054821834,
-0.7708114982,
-0.1222496405,
0.1825422198,
-0.9623508453,
0.6409463882,
-0.3008471131,
-0.2045423836,
-0.2216635644,
-0.1197429672,
0.5854967237,
0.9079554081,
-0.4871508479,
0.6390610337,
0.6769105196,
0.0556608513,
-0.6999026537,
-1.0173060894,
0.0775633976,
0.1208825931,
-0.3543160558,
0.5081639886,
-0.0375778414,
-0.1854826361,
0.0329523236,
-0.139872998,
-0.3795939088,
-0.229129076,
-0.000868193,
0.1905439049,
-0.1762842238,
0.0770905763,
-0.1710267216,
-0.2951491177,
-0.3443005383,
0.0456933603,
0.6642618179,
-0.2069848776,
-0.1736187041,
-0.5980712175,
0.2472342253,
0.1543787122,
-0.2194621563,
0.6784380078,
0.6223863959,
-0.915445745,
0.0721151531,
-0.4654728174,
-0.0074884589,
-0.4860391617,
0.3348599076,
-0.3839986622,
-0.5833165646,
0.6059013605,
0.3608355522,
-0.3792032003,
0.2571867406,
0.368534565,
0.059820652,
0.7494267821,
0.6750913858,
-0.427501291,
0.5141798854,
-0.3322685361,
0.1644926071,
-1.3580832481,
-0.0163453445,
-0.5335512757,
0.0343562402,
-0.5601953864,
-0.430927664,
0.2831378877,
0.3572222888,
0.0446279161,
0.1567023098,
-0.70452106,
0.5846508145,
0.4488064945,
0.3773914278,
0.3495872915,
0.4799625874,
-0.0310695358,
-0.2298470736,
-0.8977741003,
-0.1572121978,
0.8312513232,
-0.0454875007,
0.8106341362,
0.2235607356,
0.6846692562,
0.4344831705,
0.2781929672,
-0.9397048354,
0.4104985893,
-0.5298455358,
-0.2983427346,
-0.4305233657,
-0.6880561709,
-0.8345224261,
0.1211994365,
-0.3767246008,
-0.7597466707,
0.3126158416,
0.469735384,
-0.7353942394,
0.3071249723,
-0.6685080528,
0.4119839966,
0.0257017948,
-0.2792007029,
-0.0391062424,
-0.2794179022,
0.4117077589,
0.2041768283,
0.2464276403,
0.2324210852,
-0.055255685,
0.7792260647,
-0.684800148,
0.581789732,
-0.2520658076,
0.4214260876,
0.6606420875,
-0.1592385471,
0.4431212246,
-0.1580945253,
-0.2032861114,
-0.0716119856,
-0.0330247395,
-0.3339501917,
-0.3759180009,
0.7272620797,
-0.8139343262,
-0.2324291319,
-0.4700298905,
-0.3557092249,
-0.3034816682,
0.0456701107,
0.5370487571,
0.8672831655,
-0.1962396652,
0.3444867432,
0.7626850605,
-0.1153800786,
0.494541347,
0.6020854115,
0.0796712413,
-0.8278416395,
1.060577035,
0.270275265,
0.1289889216,
0.4201286435,
0.0480452105,
-0.4939162135,
-0.9321796894,
-0.4954922199,
0.1074581891,
-0.5950112939,
-0.3679274917,
-0.418615967,
-0.4642709494,
-0.5649809241,
0.0892603248,
-0.4981925488,
-0.2394163311,
-0.4837214351,
0.2356127501,
0.5107196569,
0.2658605278,
-0.2906748354,
0.7228525877,
-1.071194768,
0.5638593435,
0.0445240401,
0.3530648649,
0.1549344957,
-1.0501469374,
-0.5229369998,
0.2660900652,
0.138225168,
-0.7655803561,
0.5713607669,
0.424046576,
0.53220433,
0.1104507148,
0.1956217587,
1.031742692,
-0.7372339368,
0.6581900716,
0.4586456418,
-1.2354416847,
0.4762939215,
-0.0636083186,
0.38968876,
0.5912237763,
-0.0034457499,
-0.5193668008,
0.3521368206,
-0.504216969,
-0.697676599,
0.9807548523,
0.3194149733,
0.1647204012,
0.00273633,
0.4715798497,
-0.6179908514,
0.002238346,
-0.5617856979,
-0.3830886781,
0.0086592166,
-0.3017662764,
-0.3842340708,
-0.6877897382,
0.101007387,
-0.3895500302,
0.8408181667,
-0.0452079065,
0.2942081094,
0.1437566131,
-0.3034712672,
-0.2427664399,
0.4249561429,
0.6721467972,
0.147720471,
-0.1318226904,
0.0971652642,
0.9227662086,
-0.8149148822,
0.2563460469,
0.0896912068,
-0.1425083131,
0.0952398032,
0.1916274726,
0.881256938,
0.4934895933,
-0.4042574167,
0.27497226,
-0.1139936671,
0.1433857977,
-0.5362169743,
-0.2551306784,
-0.0780560076,
0.0592703,
0.3174362183,
0.0012148565,
0.3416558802,
-0.6302706003,
0.2604109347,
0.6010389924,
-0.5379418731,
-0.0712610781,
0.383767873,
0.2190919816,
-0.528681159,
0.7836732268,
-0.3430202901,
-0.2525935769,
0.3375818729,
0.6096394062,
0.6565770507,
-0.7346974015,
-0.0806402415,
0.5651190877,
0.4384932518,
-0.3626033366,
0.4690075517,
-0.2147471607,
-1.0215250254,
-0.5112725496,
-0.8992284536,
-0.5348820686,
0.1275479496,
-0.891479075,
0.278010428,
-0.5113434196,
-0.1445354521,
-0.220610261,
0.1252898127,
-0.1124636456,
0.2395405471,
0.298442781,
0.7334391475,
-0.4002656341,
1.035276413,
0.6436880827,
-0.2770698667,
-0.8135774732,
-0.308739692,
-0.0497051366,
-0.7335598469,
0.3837121427,
-0.1761244982,
-0.5227493048,
0.2576838136,
-0.2246639878,
-1.0737088919,
0.9570230842,
0.2451494336,
-0.2904409766,
-0.0135305729,
0.1249367595,
0.5900480151,
-0.2852137685,
0.1197455376,
0.5559280515,
-0.0564763956,
0.4462647736,
-1.0215572119,
-0.2013317943,
-0.4491538405,
0.346690923,
0.2380845398,
-0.3772998154,
0.8412924409,
-0.103588745,
-0.5373681188,
0.3727645576,
0.9489651918,
0.2142132372,
0.2600957453,
0.3258038163,
0.5174617171,
0.6471529007,
0.0201395787,
1.0700213909,
-0.5118802786,
0.245332256,
1.06321311,
-0.1590924114,
1.2128218412,
0.2920652926,
-0.3778474629,
0.0817807093,
0.3120782375,
0.4297912121,
0.6310943365,
0.096264042,
-0.484696269,
-0.2451512218,
-0.3150061071,
-0.5398061275,
0.5643857121,
0.5525297523,
-0.1056320444,
-0.1355367154,
0.0981379226,
-0.306073904,
0.267534405,
-0.9498920441,
0.8301614523,
0.2066749483,
-0.1348658353,
1.1513390541,
0.1128479242,
0.7600960732,
-0.6815649271,
0.0308836158,
-0.1420354694,
0.3078123927,
-0.3755946755,
-0.2552618086,
0.4690169096,
0.3354105651,
-0.4240847528,
-0.0514350943,
0.8989703655,
-0.668333292,
-0.6043325663,
-0.0590598769,
0.3186029792,
0.2928136885,
0.1194215491,
-0.4556187391,
0.1496180445,
0.2357671708,
0.3852690458,
0.2605747581,
0.0297952443,
0.2361492962,
0.423127681,
0.73696661,
0.266989857,
0.0506298207,
-0.1293321699,
0.7673276067,
-0.5690581203,
-0.6734583974,
-0.7286795378,
0.4526564777,
-0.05303628,
0.1437810212,
0.7255553603,
0.6837655306,
0.588341713,
-0.0033111179,
0.6570213437,
0.0270311646,
0.8771950006,
-0.7667557001,
0.75205791,
-0.4396703541,
0.4841293991,
-0.1084599867,
-0.6652182937,
-0.104475975,
0.7867333889,
-0.0785436109,
-0.0343169086,
0.398096025,
0.8472188115,
0.0424517989,
-0.1430413872,
0.6017760038,
0.1684993804,
-0.1532329917,
0.348500669,
0.7733258009,
-0.7058383226,
0.6693323255,
-0.3040757775,
-0.3072845042,
-0.0285445079,
-0.4563259482,
-0.5837844014,
-0.4646036327,
-0.1416424066,
-0.6050800085,
-0.060528595,
1.0707938671,
0.3127810359,
-0.8673761487,
-0.5627288222,
-0.0047890199,
0.1033402234,
0.0524944849,
-0.1303363293,
0.196293816,
-0.1771304756,
-0.61873734,
0.634970963,
0.0259683244,
0.2092446536,
0.0452141538,
-0.5086654425,
-0.1780508906,
-0.0259534139,
0.6142724156,
0.7514625788,
-0.5402620435,
-0.008138747,
-0.062912114,
-0.0036728678,
0.2039752454,
0.7210447192,
-0.6825249791,
0.4683096409,
0.5260282159,
0.5302664042,
0.5014852285,
0.160863325,
0.1885827482,
-0.9560517669,
0.4934248924,
0.2452378422,
0.4851668179,
0.6491445303,
-0.294516027,
0.247806564,
0.2935286462,
-0.1214791536,
-1.1234796047,
0.2724905014,
-0.941830337,
0.1799497008,
1.0253564119,
0.2568732798,
-0.4471853971,
-0.0342241414,
-0.2290177494,
0.3349326551,
-0.3686367869,
0.364043951,
0.4587321579,
-0.2781471312,
-0.4657030702,
-0.2360633016,
0.8986138701,
0.1322821379,
-0.5186892152,
0.1110500321,
0.5888665318,
0.1640819013,
0.5052964687,
1.1408033371,
-0.0142541667,
0.3911598325,
0.4166806638,
0.279676348,
-0.1196710393,
-0.1500798166,
-0.6744440198,
-0.105860509,
0.406722337,
-0.3255628049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10900v1
|
BEnQA: A Question Answering and Reasoning Benchmark for Bengali and English
| 2024-03-16T11:27:42 | 2024-03-16T11:27:42 |
Sheikh Shafayat, H M Quamran Hasan, Minhajur Rahman Chowdhury Mahim, Rifki Afina Putri, James Thorne, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we introduce BEnQA, a dataset comprising parallel Bengali and
English exam questions for middle and high school levels in Bangladesh. Our
dataset consists of approximately 5K questions covering several subjects in
science with different types of questions, including factual, application, and
reasoning-based questions. We benchmark several Large Language Models (LLMs)
with our parallel dataset and observe a notable performance disparity between
the models in Bengali and English. We also investigate some prompting methods,
and find that Chain-of-Thought prompting is beneficial mostly on reasoning
questions, but not so much on factual ones. We also find that appending English
translation helps to answer questions in Bengali. Our findings point to
promising future research directions for improving the performance of LLMs in
Bengali and more generally in low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.4711791277,
-0.8671726584,
0.4267937839,
0.262572974,
-0.0078812726,
0.0459326059,
0.0906890035,
-0.5015075803,
-0.0359405279,
0.4061852396,
-0.4752659202,
-0.0663533956,
-0.3656206429,
0.595733583,
-0.4456005394,
0.5199677348,
-0.1357573867,
0.4996322989,
-0.4183410704,
-0.2372679859,
-0.6733154058,
-0.3336188495,
-0.8128918409,
-0.2546090484,
0.820750773,
0.2742302716,
0.4071178138,
0.4730098248,
0.3825340271,
0.2696571052,
-0.1519278437,
0.2838754058,
-0.0364540406,
0.2982766926,
-0.8734527826,
-0.6965145469,
0.1933614463,
-0.2125069499,
0.8490678668,
1.0713971853,
0.2320363373,
0.419405818,
-0.084250398,
0.7633047104,
-0.7623718381,
-0.0696529448,
-0.4516168833,
-0.5036069155,
-0.2195614874,
-0.0850686133,
-0.1268864572,
-0.664783895,
-0.0751445517,
-0.0693712234,
-0.0212496128,
0.4271577597,
0.9303926826,
0.3404858708,
-0.5885132551,
-0.1002503261,
-0.2498947978,
0.9335556626,
-0.3116318285,
0.450517267,
0.4579899609,
0.6032006741,
0.0166803338,
-0.4391258955,
-0.6972925663,
0.0722298846,
0.0332756303,
0.2385119796,
-0.0925704613,
-0.1389077753,
0.173996374,
0.1870721877,
-0.820599556,
-0.1408192068,
-0.6835141778,
-0.0506535731,
0.5463192463,
0.3241826296,
0.1809841096,
-0.454495579,
-0.2899284661,
-0.035089802,
-0.9001942277,
0.3333026469,
0.451344043,
0.4250049591,
-0.0483804494,
0.5772859454,
-0.4807909727,
1.0353325605,
-0.2262429148,
0.3644634187,
-0.1378226876,
-0.5389671922,
-0.1073055714,
0.013535412,
0.2366696447,
0.162136063,
0.4020678997,
0.2303627282,
0.0816325247,
0.0971673876,
-0.0348804668,
-0.7192242146,
-0.1177055165,
0.5389560461,
-0.2863934338,
0.4180235267,
-0.2559463382,
-0.749894619,
-0.3658387065,
-0.4522230923,
0.5095692873,
-0.1802901775,
-0.1363271326,
0.2560273111,
-0.144105345,
0.4678345621,
0.2986640036,
-0.9569445848,
0.3596177697,
0.66253829,
0.487011224,
-0.1249588355,
-0.4775312543,
-0.4482052326,
0.0232340973,
-0.5340887308,
1.0522514582,
-0.6270747781,
-0.1221652552,
0.0922107697,
-0.0295954775,
-0.2335752547,
-0.7926730514,
0.4730066061,
-0.6688025594,
0.1881216317,
-0.9140108824,
-0.429084003,
-0.3909769654,
0.579590261,
-0.6145772934,
1.1396453381,
0.1010541469,
-0.8573234677,
-0.0498857871,
-0.4199008048,
-0.3901415467,
0.1516030431,
-0.4517557323,
0.3993774354,
-0.0445549116,
0.5728359818,
0.5546004772,
-0.972282052,
0.2749658227,
0.1403857768,
-0.7000578046,
0.3863036335,
-0.536458075,
1.0969427824,
0.2477405071,
-0.0652234927,
-0.1720301807,
-0.6855413914,
0.2540047169,
-0.1078674719,
-0.3719204664,
-0.3871339262,
-0.0610657334,
-0.0732877403,
0.1406047642,
0.233334437,
-0.6999582052,
0.0142393969,
-0.3433009386,
0.2421808839,
0.5446434617,
0.1846052408,
-0.2268641591,
-0.745818913,
0.5079995394,
0.1802891642,
-0.1317686439,
-0.0952894613,
-0.674936533,
-0.6359090805,
-0.2704851329,
0.6051431298,
0.7419446111,
-0.8305003643,
-0.0064765494,
-0.1044716835,
-0.4234069884,
-1.0102221966,
-0.047403641,
0.5883100033,
0.7094304562,
0.4985090494,
0.0242815465,
-0.4638375938,
-1.1575641632,
-0.5360787511,
-0.4137083292,
-0.0992592052,
0.1479389369,
0.7499007583,
0.1245902404,
0.7371952534,
-0.2808795571,
0.6320234537,
-0.2617607415,
-0.0209096745,
0.2759974599,
0.2464936078,
0.4011951387,
-1.1611837149,
-0.3865272403,
-0.2895241678,
-0.5957826376,
-0.4520612955,
0.0631743819,
-0.3243324459,
0.3330677152,
0.2179492563,
-0.5212014914,
0.2552876174,
0.6659732461,
-0.233779043,
0.896989584,
0.1327312738,
0.7145652175,
-1.3307616711,
0.0956221893,
-0.1152187958,
0.0561419763,
-0.3377278745,
0.1425320804,
0.2182755321,
0.0000903686,
-0.6655524373,
1.1010537148,
-0.2360127717,
-0.1678564548,
-0.0278242584,
0.1531021148,
0.1572768986,
0.2102857232,
-0.0135183455,
1.0900763273,
0.6158481836,
-0.5158099532,
0.5354197025,
0.3545168638,
-0.6817650795,
0.7147232294,
-0.8596513271,
-0.2438290417,
-0.0777841285,
0.0533204079,
-1.1929537058,
-0.3923665285,
-0.1376323551,
-0.4178932905,
-0.0483882576,
0.1054375842,
-0.6177099347,
-0.4724679589,
-0.0972804204,
0.650097847,
0.3978413045,
-0.7888613939,
0.2868005931,
-0.0305591375,
-0.5237446427,
-0.8181656599,
-0.8629499674,
-0.1823690981,
-0.0636470243,
-0.511284709,
0.0105522815,
-0.3018065691,
-0.5382329226,
0.1461214274,
-0.1208642945,
-0.3546412885,
-0.183746174,
0.1346870363,
0.3149300516,
-0.1069758981,
0.2329987884,
0.2513782382,
0.0836155862,
0.2943299115,
-0.0350976586,
0.4721764326,
-0.1927682012,
-0.4025049806,
-0.3775148988,
0.8023130894,
0.4979656339,
-0.1603348255,
0.6170571446,
0.0459804125,
-0.5286619663,
-0.2753641903,
-0.6780481339,
-0.1702964306,
-0.479224056,
0.325831145,
-0.6707400084,
-0.8723717332,
0.6779017448,
-0.0387045816,
-0.1144005209,
0.1529716104,
0.8336641192,
-0.2956421375,
0.8900239468,
0.2098618448,
-0.0875026807,
-0.138803497,
0.1005084142,
0.2525182664,
-0.5602564812,
-0.2314900458,
-0.886205554,
-0.1928178966,
-0.6844139695,
-0.4734347463,
0.2336792052,
0.2950638533,
-0.5987332463,
0.2448094189,
-0.3278087676,
0.5963789821,
0.8308634162,
-0.0462846346,
0.1479037553,
-0.2088410109,
-0.2251834869,
0.0466480628,
-0.7665566206,
-0.4479325116,
0.8489632607,
-0.126005128,
0.504592061,
0.2374848723,
0.5894414186,
0.0483322553,
-0.0653761625,
-0.3386254609,
0.8206877112,
0.1134952307,
-1.2111902237,
-0.2814599872,
-0.5859146118,
-0.9416671991,
0.2544464767,
0.0828133076,
-0.6153842211,
0.1498860717,
-0.02588569,
-0.3189175427,
0.2267064452,
-0.5909968019,
0.5383707881,
-0.1286963075,
-0.6985030174,
-0.2235533893,
-0.5927535892,
0.3542384207,
-0.1099207774,
0.1081263646,
-0.1258340031,
0.0262264814,
0.7448162436,
-0.0868392289,
0.4850327373,
0.0151876314,
0.269005537,
0.5213959813,
-0.0317658037,
0.0421769992,
0.0855774954,
-0.3810214698,
0.0815068334,
0.5939227343,
-1.0529602766,
-0.7753098607,
0.6384524107,
-0.730537951,
-0.8244149685,
-0.4971239865,
-0.9841059446,
-0.5928305984,
-0.0037356936,
-0.0202417318,
0.4367440045,
0.325314492,
0.2624351382,
0.6444937587,
-0.4055815041,
0.3947147727,
0.5042796731,
-0.0833095163,
-0.4424801171,
0.6688188314,
0.3699638247,
0.1872603893,
0.4356661439,
0.2662803531,
-0.6344915032,
-0.5810835361,
-0.5099912882,
0.4438188374,
-0.7099034786,
-0.1945219487,
-0.3847477436,
-0.37717399,
-0.4009727538,
-0.2892705202,
-0.1732856035,
-0.4079511762,
0.4206577837,
0.092179656,
0.2963284254,
0.6082676649,
0.0814540759,
-0.2432809174,
-0.8440041542,
0.230145216,
0.6131344438,
0.1636111289,
-0.14279899,
-0.4609152973,
-0.1546847224,
-0.0648557022,
-0.0527073853,
-0.9342252016,
0.0277153943,
-0.2884050012,
0.5898579359,
0.0306877885,
0.2171897888,
0.651648283,
-0.2799728215,
1.127314806,
-0.0007223169,
-0.8851594925,
0.5339441299,
-0.5186237097,
0.6845114231,
0.7586023808,
1.0374513865,
-0.5758253336,
-0.0021279335,
-0.0782504678,
-0.4545033872,
0.1744823605,
0.0445248187,
-0.0167669132,
-0.1696227789,
0.3723999858,
0.154246673,
0.4206660688,
-0.3370653093,
-0.1701851338,
0.0729751587,
-0.3573766947,
0.1404496729,
-0.1512681842,
-0.1581881493,
-0.6315711737,
0.6468023658,
-0.0412598699,
0.1357097179,
0.1352163553,
0.2987913489,
0.1003628075,
0.4242340922,
0.2879633904,
0.7305034995,
-0.065175958,
0.0382852368,
0.3488143981,
-0.3676908612,
0.1509789377,
0.1889754832,
-0.2595763505,
-0.2194487303,
0.4424700439,
0.3164668977,
0.0155940736,
-1.0803263187,
0.1883930266,
0.1308742911,
-0.3609319031,
0.1470426619,
-0.000398967,
0.2402236164,
0.5240665674,
0.5568955541,
-0.2930346131,
0.1044942215,
-0.7132337093,
0.0622462071,
0.0332508348,
0.0153914057,
-0.1397042871,
0.5605790019,
0.1897694021,
-0.2819261551,
0.5289798379,
0.0240971521,
-0.5869387984,
0.6248940825,
0.4947627485,
0.5186370611,
-0.2857965231,
0.1821008921,
0.5181441307,
0.3087993264,
0.0102298027,
1.2011077404,
-0.1376452595,
-0.6395593286,
-0.570566237,
-0.7066340446,
-0.9951766729,
0.2129477113,
-0.7180637121,
0.1153343916,
-0.2733676434,
0.087621361,
0.0406334251,
0.6014859676,
-0.6917060018,
0.499604553,
-0.1371702552,
1.2351050377,
-0.8411228657,
0.8619073033,
1.0387792587,
-0.3821702003,
-1.0253841877,
-0.0877440274,
-0.0571582578,
-0.5009874701,
0.713308692,
0.1872662902,
-0.1577190757,
0.0221849512,
-0.4829093218,
-0.8689049482,
0.7894855142,
0.3236667514,
-0.5151272416,
0.0685345083,
0.3760060966,
0.4038898051,
-0.1281027496,
0.3968672156,
0.6633443236,
0.6439558268,
-0.0081510628,
-0.6837765574,
-0.0307380259,
-0.5676073432,
-0.0794029757,
-0.0261530988,
-0.8647760153,
0.973557055,
0.1147675589,
0.0247917883,
0.2217808664,
0.573843658,
0.7409796715,
0.3689886332,
0.1217090189,
0.2653458118,
0.8015752435,
-0.3110820353,
0.9665410519,
-0.3246620297,
-0.2211337686,
1.0503964424,
-0.5935420394,
1.131925106,
0.6443426609,
-0.3574774861,
0.5420231819,
1.0284984112,
0.1498896033,
0.397036314,
0.4382458627,
-0.3041414618,
-0.2730698884,
-0.3922876716,
-0.3925200701,
0.467092216,
0.2569951713,
0.3415813446,
-0.2164776325,
0.0424494743,
-0.3066425025,
0.5699064136,
-0.5088149905,
0.0664323196,
-0.1104319692,
-0.9206638932,
0.792802453,
-0.292983681,
0.3783325553,
-0.5565520525,
-0.0829494894,
-0.5818998814,
-0.0913249552,
0.1037390903,
-0.840990901,
0.4362258017,
0.0874474421,
-0.3722886741,
0.0242025368,
0.3904153109,
-0.5126615763,
-0.4250648618,
0.3358567655,
0.6910089254,
0.4939059019,
0.2383659184,
-0.716046989,
0.1696606725,
-0.3128258586,
-0.3376462162,
0.2155148834,
0.4000273943,
-0.2624565661,
0.8388941288,
0.3932211101,
0.337243259,
0.2689477205,
0.0457028486,
0.693647027,
-0.6968969703,
-0.2808690965,
-0.3731617332,
0.4152372479,
-0.1313207,
-0.4464241862,
0.9621148705,
0.5459536314,
1.1521598101,
0.0474973731,
0.8895657659,
0.0727906823,
0.9333185554,
-0.4354112744,
0.5957512856,
-0.6165133715,
-0.0562304482,
-0.0517109819,
-0.999019444,
-0.1108658761,
0.1774199307,
-0.4095389843,
0.1733252853,
0.9692067504,
1.0251311064,
0.2853416204,
0.3197215199,
0.5818759203,
-0.018011922,
-0.2041435689,
0.8049840331,
1.1052117348,
-0.6277739406,
0.2815588117,
0.0024992591,
-0.0111273052,
0.158480078,
-0.5078794956,
-1.2269102335,
-0.8140618801,
-0.1502573937,
-0.1516118497,
0.5752590895,
0.8593214154,
0.5997138619,
-1.0218874216,
-0.2973005474,
0.0949804708,
0.0721352771,
-0.3934675455,
-0.1608965695,
0.5484008193,
-0.067606017,
-1.0200977325,
0.525924027,
0.0238114465,
-0.0908124521,
-0.3333988488,
0.0999211445,
-0.7141067386,
0.8387692571,
0.3289709389,
0.4207014441,
-0.6632289886,
-0.4288089275,
-0.0338481218,
-0.1166615784,
-0.3340530992,
0.5150029659,
-0.7986504436,
0.4283513725,
0.8567830324,
1.1863929033,
0.2577426136,
0.2229618877,
0.2948435545,
-0.5606202483,
0.0387540124,
0.258666873,
0.1893337667,
0.4104812741,
-0.0402102135,
0.5005768538,
0.1287639588,
-0.6309363842,
-0.9105250239,
0.2516250908,
-0.7068730593,
-0.5668465495,
0.8937522769,
-0.0991838574,
-0.3663280606,
-0.4412958026,
-0.0032419947,
0.1685395837,
0.0931985006,
0.7682132125,
0.9894909263,
-0.1210996434,
-0.289698422,
-0.8004891276,
0.2049701661,
0.9784371257,
-0.8427118659,
0.0275524408,
0.3929571509,
0.097288616,
-0.0643598437,
0.4820223153,
0.0831336528,
0.592247963,
0.2911394536,
-0.1357786953,
-0.0255073421,
-0.741697371,
-0.3222157657,
0.3011538684,
-0.3298083842,
-0.2407864034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10894v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10894v1
|
Towards Robustness and Diversity: Continual Learning in Dialog Generation with Text-Mixup and Batch Nuclear-Norm Maximization
| 2024-03-16T11:09:27 | 2024-03-16T11:09:27 |
Zihan Wang, Jiayu Xiao, Mengxiang Li, Zhongjiang He, Yongxiang Li, Chao Wang, Shuangyong Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In our dynamic world where data arrives in a continuous stream, continual
learning enables us to incrementally add new tasks/domains without the need to
retrain from scratch. A major challenge in continual learning of language model
is catastrophic forgetting, the tendency of models to forget knowledge from
previously trained tasks/domains when training on new ones. This paper studies
dialog generation under the continual learning setting. We propose a novel
method that 1) uses \textit{Text-Mixup} as data augmentation to avoid model
overfitting on replay memory and 2) leverages Batch-Nuclear Norm Maximization
(BNNM) to alleviate the problem of mode collapse. Experiments on a $37$-domain
task-oriented dialog dataset and DailyDialog (a $10$-domain chitchat dataset)
demonstrate that our proposed approach outperforms the state-of-the-art in
continual learning.
|
[
-0.3493023515,
-0.8551781774,
0.2968969345,
-0.0423413143,
-0.3235172629,
0.2888024449,
-0.3363893032,
-0.2655765712,
-0.2666066885,
0.4916807413,
-0.7984763384,
-0.2825216055,
-0.2942044735,
0.2364894003,
-0.0722557828,
1.0637834072,
0.2420663983,
0.1667060852,
-0.2719329298,
-0.2777513564,
-1.0908684731,
-0.4918727279,
-0.998511076,
-0.4265816212,
0.185656473,
0.2671792209,
0.7054526806,
0.3396792412,
0.0110580903,
0.311126858,
0.0364569798,
0.5597863793,
-0.7603079081,
0.7129717469,
-0.2684292197,
-0.4866222441,
-0.3030717075,
-0.2411805689,
1.024885416,
0.9165500402,
0.0040188972,
-0.3905148804,
0.3362457752,
0.4340059161,
-0.2862181365,
0.0086006504,
-1.0840958357,
0.1093959659,
0.1563300937,
-0.3692872226,
-0.4772050679,
-0.2831992805,
0.0807898566,
-0.4221849144,
0.1155249402,
0.1320497394,
0.8330669999,
0.2822528481,
-0.3905019462,
-0.357085526,
-0.8371921182,
1.1432899237,
-0.6927905083,
0.4453767836,
0.4630670249,
0.1916581988,
-0.356230855,
-0.3213607073,
-0.4384391308,
-0.1698462516,
0.3437216878,
0.2575740218,
-0.1833917201,
-0.0022994226,
-0.0076566199,
0.4705317914,
-0.5802037716,
-0.0812875107,
-0.2427666038,
-0.3261682689,
0.1987236887,
0.4672351778,
0.5734528303,
-0.1473639011,
-0.271251142,
0.1242705211,
-0.6669442654,
-0.3528633416,
0.0885900185,
0.3288163841,
0.1036089957,
0.0495222621,
0.0485014766,
0.7151358128,
0.1650068164,
-0.1794234514,
0.0714807436,
-0.7351549268,
-0.4439686537,
-0.3123599589,
0.578160584,
0.3536367714,
0.0582511313,
-0.2926436961,
-0.2454369068,
-0.0828228593,
0.554728806,
-0.5509399176,
-0.134763971,
0.1682765484,
-0.3145387471,
-0.4230929613,
-0.3087610304,
-0.6811808944,
0.086884588,
-0.4537861943,
0.3660869896,
-0.7231869102,
-0.1817716062,
-0.1919035017,
0.0745733678,
-0.2255906612,
0.4552150369,
-0.5875425935,
0.3296447098,
0.4492365122,
0.8134074211,
-0.2482029796,
-0.2295228541,
-0.6247897744,
0.0554076321,
-0.3486848772,
0.4173983335,
-0.5365103483,
-0.7126650214,
-0.147603631,
-0.1328155696,
-0.271619767,
-1.041739583,
-0.00942632,
-0.4110465944,
0.5965356231,
-0.2068367898,
-0.6105928421,
-0.1136811674,
0.4984534085,
-0.5452156067,
1.0935845375,
0.2546910942,
-0.4637837708,
0.6962686777,
-0.1812065989,
-0.2214249521,
0.2467932999,
-0.2572630644,
-0.6350591183,
-0.131263271,
-0.0894888118,
0.3168081939,
-0.1170018166,
0.6478512287,
-0.3580223918,
-0.0751820654,
0.3348729908,
-0.6516628265,
0.7091995478,
0.1658965647,
-0.319394052,
-0.0408201888,
-0.6049140096,
-0.2025225759,
-0.0294655748,
-0.4751501679,
-0.2798806131,
-0.0639431924,
0.0203221366,
0.3765551448,
0.0003170739,
-0.2065003514,
0.0652666986,
-0.1132216603,
0.3395611644,
0.8581218719,
0.3807757497,
0.3486927152,
-1.0459487438,
0.4997999966,
0.2610938251,
-0.0292590652,
-0.5978711247,
-0.4157091081,
-0.8212434053,
-0.2541970909,
0.0756424665,
0.6908877492,
-0.9686273336,
0.5753073096,
-0.1898542196,
-0.0677052513,
0.263348788,
0.6208314896,
0.2543123662,
0.5567785501,
0.2671723664,
-0.582444191,
-0.7929732203,
-0.4325602949,
0.121704191,
-0.1396096796,
-0.0998776257,
0.4365443289,
0.3987411857,
-0.543381691,
0.9549168944,
0.1151851863,
0.0661753044,
-0.5465430617,
0.1439797878,
-0.2023572475,
0.7698541284,
0.4515400529,
-0.7863567472,
-0.2672957182,
-0.0762704536,
-0.8285551667,
0.1911123693,
-0.7661793232,
-0.1131861582,
0.3567778766,
0.3695864081,
-0.3845005929,
0.0847484395,
0.297126025,
-0.0323591866,
0.6088530421,
0.0025850022,
0.0243501402,
-1.4484246969,
-0.170356825,
-0.060510803,
-0.6556116343,
-0.7116764784,
-0.250962466,
-0.2814556956,
-0.2084588408,
-0.0871819854,
0.4950884581,
-0.38759619,
0.4395483136,
-0.3576576114,
0.0815200359,
-0.1638029069,
0.4995059073,
-0.099189043,
0.6769443154,
0.4874356091,
-0.835903585,
0.0271707606,
0.2401240319,
0.0331517272,
0.6663839817,
-0.4846793413,
-0.0069031548,
-0.1520328373,
0.4076303542,
-0.9279193282,
-0.4782395661,
0.2506708205,
-0.4259517491,
0.7113269567,
-0.0032219333,
-0.2587327659,
0.1068503931,
-0.2022917867,
0.4850144088,
0.6748360395,
-0.4085492194,
0.6327009797,
0.4044117033,
-0.4168152213,
-0.4162245393,
-0.545114696,
0.2263832837,
-0.2225092798,
-0.5740691423,
0.0368909799,
-0.3061908185,
-0.2375524938,
-0.1376956105,
-0.4880127609,
-0.2137659341,
-0.026691502,
0.3129655421,
0.4743204415,
-0.0833351314,
0.1891007423,
0.1745703816,
0.1316826493,
-0.0459109433,
-0.4892521799,
0.8394554257,
-0.160970211,
-0.1240200624,
-0.3904613853,
0.550157249,
0.5107278228,
0.4043717384,
0.6860900521,
0.4099650085,
-0.4387578666,
-0.5109229684,
-0.5656065941,
-0.3145350516,
-0.4947442412,
0.2692387998,
0.0052559297,
-1.2206033468,
0.5490530133,
-0.2272305638,
0.2963496745,
0.2323525548,
0.6868319511,
-0.1562085748,
0.5009518862,
0.6249625683,
-0.0481039472,
0.6417905688,
-0.0517887771,
0.0511431247,
-0.6178160906,
-0.1098575443,
-0.1181228682,
0.0258193091,
-0.3463125229,
-0.5127593875,
0.3052414656,
0.1254005581,
-0.116771251,
0.2032574117,
-0.2404891402,
0.241460979,
0.1878956407,
0.1907602996,
0.2499281019,
0.0708681121,
-0.1809941828,
-0.2773668766,
-1.0483822823,
-0.3093081713,
1.1331572533,
0.2623714507,
0.4598394334,
-0.1471497267,
0.9149520993,
0.3837325573,
0.266958952,
-0.6024239659,
0.5013586879,
0.222483024,
-0.4039590657,
-0.1045740768,
-0.9100304842,
-0.9960070252,
0.1051638797,
-0.1578920484,
-0.6699584723,
0.1985965669,
0.4237152636,
-0.1098164916,
0.3910027146,
-0.1597052217,
0.4714224935,
0.0904714838,
-0.3680779338,
-0.2084052414,
-0.5513207912,
0.4619048536,
-0.2725875974,
0.3143795133,
0.0899693146,
0.1706088632,
0.4073936343,
-0.3655575812,
1.1107344627,
0.1190763265,
0.0499404669,
0.2039812803,
0.2283104807,
0.2990297079,
0.2733469605,
0.2740715146,
0.0130923828,
-0.4437369108,
-0.5721384883,
-0.4757566452,
0.5189404488,
-0.5674513578,
-0.2171031684,
-0.3944687843,
-0.8008638024,
-0.4441489875,
0.1920624077,
0.4005816579,
0.9133419394,
-0.2680243254,
0.3475831747,
1.1657118797,
-0.2306073606,
0.2702326179,
-0.0624887757,
-0.1375799328,
-0.6337200403,
1.1138600111,
-0.0579163656,
0.9197565913,
0.0781392604,
0.0011630964,
0.0314905159,
-0.5356110334,
-0.2519227266,
-0.0143714994,
-0.8241410255,
-0.2768256366,
-0.8866360188,
-0.3155541718,
-0.0954996422,
-0.4790486097,
-0.2147640586,
-0.3567234576,
-0.1888326555,
0.1545978785,
0.0854318067,
0.6488506198,
-0.2278576791,
0.0173724163,
-0.9848359823,
0.2604644001,
0.4881972671,
0.0229564924,
0.1187887564,
-0.515987277,
-0.1357463896,
0.1841787249,
-0.4067259431,
-0.7277870774,
0.3377655745,
0.4034146369,
0.7515375018,
0.29082793,
-0.1265025735,
0.3435867429,
-0.2581647933,
0.9598965645,
0.3255964518,
-0.9521133304,
0.4201610386,
-0.8411036134,
0.7177396417,
0.8368193507,
0.2811350226,
-0.6931990981,
-1.0503895283,
-0.7055658102,
-1.0679410696,
0.2272640169,
0.4050789177,
0.3568445444,
-0.301492244,
0.1791068166,
0.4069463015,
0.3524871767,
-0.5984200239,
-0.1435695738,
-0.4471534789,
-0.1736119837,
0.3458017409,
-0.074544847,
-0.1397025734,
-0.2413082272,
0.8390973806,
-0.1200622097,
0.2776838541,
-0.1080731377,
-0.2823022008,
0.1295030713,
0.3796681166,
0.7710340023,
0.8482235074,
-0.234536767,
-0.0658621714,
0.4225841761,
-0.68642658,
0.0384843871,
-0.5224314928,
-0.273870647,
0.2859381437,
0.2124556303,
0.6865053773,
0.5757724643,
-0.6951307654,
-0.0326778479,
-0.1082833186,
-0.3151601255,
-0.2015989125,
0.3052980602,
-0.1325644553,
-0.0781766623,
0.5157372355,
0.544674933,
0.012774799,
-0.7827740312,
0.674554348,
0.4144070745,
-0.3650705814,
-0.0017597269,
0.5809496045,
0.1680137664,
-0.0691305175,
0.7118802667,
-0.3906242251,
-0.6965376139,
0.4982714653,
0.6760305166,
0.9177076817,
-0.1289857477,
0.1633024961,
0.5372461081,
0.2186771333,
-0.2018391639,
0.1771432161,
-0.4064205587,
-0.8281067014,
-0.3104687929,
-0.332031101,
-0.7251911759,
0.2524423897,
-0.7184237242,
-0.119982481,
-0.8044785857,
-0.1949704736,
-0.3433576524,
-0.1210624278,
-0.4251728952,
0.4169817865,
-0.0840617642,
0.4511813521,
-0.6225836873,
0.7895844579,
0.2993223369,
-0.3287133873,
-0.567158699,
0.2886559963,
0.2969723046,
-0.4733065963,
0.3220579922,
0.2207171023,
-0.1267295778,
-0.3793404698,
-0.5482405424,
-0.4192029238,
0.8713208437,
0.072713457,
-0.3389925957,
0.0632434115,
-0.0080604507,
0.2112585753,
-0.4554296434,
-0.0966059491,
0.365819335,
0.3270419538,
0.2406966686,
-0.8076398373,
0.0724017248,
-0.574832499,
0.195619002,
0.1973118335,
-0.5471584797,
0.756295681,
0.2636723816,
-0.3242037296,
-0.0640018657,
0.6042971015,
0.2872384787,
0.2588106394,
0.565091908,
0.4041395783,
0.9121778011,
-0.1797228009,
0.768314302,
-0.111354813,
0.4017190635,
1.345712781,
-0.0519753918,
0.3967238665,
0.1816506535,
0.0756186023,
0.4178898931,
0.5086325407,
-0.1174329072,
0.2555858493,
-0.1771301925,
-0.5826325417,
-0.5723406672,
0.0187998582,
-0.2128278911,
0.180852592,
0.5341995955,
-0.0307175294,
-0.489505589,
0.1547438353,
0.2475029379,
0.1669085473,
-0.1725848317,
0.8898476362,
0.1672978848,
-0.5199654102,
0.9336051345,
-0.3606225848,
0.9051712155,
-0.6442778111,
0.0545231439,
-0.304205507,
-0.0447464511,
-0.0836938769,
-0.2700145543,
0.5583924055,
-0.2433392107,
-0.3735725284,
-0.2848730981,
0.6248458624,
-0.7859410048,
-0.302549988,
-0.0796571374,
0.2824587226,
-0.1416563541,
0.272855252,
-0.6516757011,
0.3053014874,
0.1018655598,
0.0766510293,
0.5382412076,
0.2650928199,
-0.0156380534,
0.8120261431,
0.5565559268,
-0.1660438031,
0.2019366175,
-0.1402446479,
0.9962071776,
-0.404546082,
-0.4695636332,
-0.6094015241,
0.5220478177,
-0.3412094414,
-0.2517280877,
0.805847764,
0.4799617231,
0.8702173829,
0.1022574529,
1.163708806,
0.0803505182,
0.2951218784,
-0.6161291003,
0.6726209521,
-0.5957437754,
0.1947758794,
-0.2237256318,
-0.8061487675,
-0.1753666103,
0.4556638002,
0.0594518445,
0.3497369289,
0.6776482463,
0.6237473488,
-0.1969536692,
0.1476462036,
0.4847726524,
-0.048291903,
0.2671187818,
0.6455894113,
0.6309211254,
-0.2718865275,
0.3176361918,
-0.0096188458,
-0.1459975988,
-0.2185460776,
-0.645173192,
-1.1218034029,
-0.6967693567,
-0.3452211916,
-0.5201725364,
0.0254713092,
1.0893006325,
0.7561620474,
-0.8605986834,
-0.1219517216,
-0.2792378962,
0.1269867122,
-0.1323938668,
-0.2531319857,
-0.3382843733,
-0.9643249512,
-0.6595785618,
0.6404618621,
0.6225942373,
0.1595860124,
-0.2442471832,
-0.0818101764,
-0.0488736778,
0.39659518,
0.3439093828,
0.5712499022,
-0.4145068824,
-0.1247263923,
-0.190101549,
-0.0370275602,
0.3101164699,
0.9409325123,
-0.5520837903,
0.7401114702,
0.2645274103,
1.0692015886,
0.3391342759,
-0.0792414173,
1.0254904032,
-0.8239063025,
0.1817721277,
0.4292501211,
0.1765393913,
0.4745968878,
-0.4107077718,
0.0497725308,
0.3863001168,
-0.7372704744,
-0.8243048191,
0.5339781642,
-1.1671313047,
-0.3399810493,
0.8428224921,
-0.0416567363,
-0.0606630854,
-0.7167232633,
0.003084844,
0.0803344771,
-0.4736789763,
0.8349413276,
0.7093149424,
0.1117635742,
-0.2789613903,
-0.6391156912,
0.6402004361,
0.6684780121,
-0.9263278842,
-0.0808162987,
0.7955714464,
0.6578296423,
0.0026642296,
0.6412253976,
-0.0562776588,
0.6258242726,
0.2592712045,
-0.3938286304,
-0.1049177572,
-0.5426958203,
-0.3040429354,
0.1825679541,
-0.1204046607,
0.0644494817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10882v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10882v2
|
Optimizing Language Augmentation for Multilingual Large Language Models: A Case Study on Korean
| 2024-03-16T10:26:38 | 2024-03-21T14:50:18 |
ChangSu Choi, Yongbin Jeong, Seoyoon Park, InHo Won, HyeonSeok Lim, SangMin Kim, Yejee Kang, Chanhyuk Yoon, Jaewan Park, Yiseul Lee, HyeJin Lee, Younggyun Hahm, Hansaem Kim, KyungTae Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) use pretraining to predict the subsequent word;
however, their expansion requires significant computing resources. Numerous big
tech companies and research institutes have developed multilingual LLMs (MLLMs)
to meet current demands, overlooking less-resourced languages (LRLs). This
study proposed three strategies to enhance the performance of LRLs based on the
publicly available MLLMs. First, the MLLM vocabularies of LRLs were expanded to
enhance expressiveness. Second, bilingual data were used for pretraining to
align the high- and less-resourced languages. Third, a high-quality small-scale
instruction dataset was constructed and instruction-tuning was performed to
augment the LRL. The experiments employed the Llama2 model and Korean was used
as the LRL, which was quantitatively evaluated against other developed LLMs
across eight tasks. Furthermore, a qualitative assessment was performed based
on human evaluation and GPT4. Experimental results showed that our proposed
Bllossom model exhibited superior performance in qualitative analyses compared
to previously proposed Korean monolingual models.
|
[
-0.255669415,
-0.6259083152,
0.3421966434,
0.4744123518,
-0.3222338557,
0.4197058976,
-0.7458940744,
-0.5436707735,
0.1230580956,
0.5521315932,
-0.548281908,
-0.3901419938,
-0.3003572822,
0.295766741,
0.2310693413,
0.7956393957,
-0.1215903684,
0.3016057312,
-0.2079028934,
-0.1570850611,
-0.5903599262,
-0.6109911203,
-0.3313153684,
-0.564357698,
0.5313848853,
0.5262250304,
0.6185221076,
0.5616433024,
0.3223398924,
0.3091886044,
-0.1318125576,
0.35036847,
-0.6643137932,
-0.0070802509,
0.051983986,
-0.3652855456,
-0.5640357137,
-0.1880451143,
0.7105343342,
0.8201486468,
-0.0990805104,
0.4003672004,
0.1844360232,
0.6937825084,
-0.7497230768,
0.1132820547,
-0.4124990106,
0.06756901,
-0.2799400985,
0.0512923934,
-0.2667096257,
-0.4356947839,
0.0708620176,
-0.5841053724,
-0.2563396692,
-0.1496958137,
0.527192235,
0.2140107304,
-0.3002083302,
-0.032182619,
-0.7174381018,
0.9238291979,
-0.7690429688,
0.7254989147,
0.2502108812,
0.0941945761,
-0.035823904,
-0.458094418,
-0.3399678767,
-0.5224084258,
-0.1702030152,
0.0841476843,
0.1234384701,
0.2443865687,
0.3203653097,
0.2940353155,
-0.6947134733,
0.6556918025,
-0.2987759113,
-0.2932294011,
0.7095748782,
0.1087517962,
0.1799725741,
-0.0857655108,
-0.2590243816,
-0.0093566375,
-0.7846094966,
0.1095834896,
0.4367730618,
0.5176529288,
-0.1687572449,
0.8293516636,
-0.256536752,
0.7443026304,
-0.0337578468,
-0.3767722249,
0.5082463622,
-0.6754351258,
-0.1269916892,
0.1716987491,
0.4877504706,
0.1530528516,
0.3724511862,
-0.2245775014,
-0.2145266235,
-0.0722613037,
0.0689359158,
-0.8554413915,
0.1154696569,
0.0911462158,
-0.4061496854,
-0.0148777319,
-0.2713480592,
-0.6337203383,
-0.4340116978,
-0.5875993967,
0.4111673534,
-0.1165638193,
-0.4337486923,
0.0122734047,
0.2945184708,
-0.1148612201,
0.1275264472,
-0.635194838,
-0.0443680771,
0.5742025375,
0.7271359563,
-0.3400155306,
-0.3856934607,
-0.3514166474,
0.1121301129,
-0.4873767197,
0.4027324915,
-0.4652935565,
-0.3797613382,
0.1568087786,
0.0310188588,
0.0515434109,
-0.6522151232,
0.5650210977,
-0.6503565311,
0.2035143524,
-0.1331207007,
-0.5144630671,
-0.1101894975,
0.1691725701,
-0.8672113419,
1.2040948868,
0.3038844168,
-0.4821096659,
0.1944084764,
-0.772020936,
-0.615537107,
0.2135353833,
0.0022419221,
-0.1520484239,
0.294700861,
0.3187749088,
0.4293757975,
-0.1649614722,
0.0721852779,
-0.0649744198,
-0.3208450973,
0.0912694857,
-0.3981345594,
0.4813410342,
0.2064130902,
-0.0507343411,
0.2340465039,
-0.7635067701,
0.4441323876,
-0.0472072922,
-0.730874598,
-0.2958533764,
-0.4617132545,
0.0146895824,
0.3449256718,
0.6603266597,
-0.3617390394,
0.0367325433,
-0.6457648277,
-0.1102225557,
0.672767818,
-0.3840771616,
0.6607676744,
-0.0463444479,
0.8887016177,
-0.0758761466,
0.0794239864,
-0.3270625472,
-0.0737981126,
-0.6337146759,
-0.4044253826,
0.5023650527,
0.6271383166,
-1.0260605812,
0.1886264533,
-0.403611958,
-0.4040421844,
-0.9335236549,
0.5647541881,
0.5786961913,
0.2205675393,
0.3996525109,
0.0041554905,
-0.7259280086,
-0.9490647316,
-0.2947563231,
0.1712122709,
-0.0628072396,
0.1726843566,
0.0341157839,
-0.1689270139,
0.6169384122,
-0.3311986327,
0.012276357,
-0.5785526037,
-0.2428183109,
0.3882523179,
0.2037372142,
0.2629577816,
-0.6481966972,
-0.7503430247,
0.3968741894,
-0.4770558774,
-0.2273336947,
0.1804827452,
0.0202987958,
0.4594551027,
0.5544286966,
-0.5988003612,
0.1828188747,
0.7922698259,
0.0424797237,
0.7785638571,
-0.2796112895,
-0.033110261,
-0.9674218893,
-0.0498384349,
-0.1253030598,
-0.218667075,
-0.8999743462,
0.1727742255,
0.1065266728,
-0.0997099057,
-0.4222249091,
0.709836483,
-0.7758997083,
-0.1566312611,
-0.5590522289,
0.3091644049,
-0.110782735,
0.4295693934,
0.0509314723,
0.8886651993,
0.3288582563,
-0.5697838664,
0.322608918,
-0.1573140025,
-0.5382813215,
0.1669622064,
-0.5226305723,
0.1218051165,
-0.2403881699,
0.0320670828,
-0.7337278128,
-0.3298363388,
-0.0004068716,
-0.0792724192,
0.41629529,
-0.1076563597,
-0.4744181931,
-0.4238333404,
-0.2573677003,
0.4141266644,
0.3679405153,
-0.6556091309,
0.5584809184,
0.2960539758,
-0.4444883466,
-0.5307812095,
-0.5303047299,
0.0793445334,
-0.2342298925,
-0.6885957718,
0.3600280583,
-0.0136256441,
-0.1382762343,
-0.1237241477,
0.0588747971,
0.0439736992,
0.0082702972,
-0.1038591713,
0.4022017419,
-0.4740478992,
0.2920898795,
0.0061378647,
0.0166072976,
-0.285161227,
-0.1940257996,
0.8542478681,
-0.0391783826,
-0.3841446638,
-0.3923223317,
0.1633598953,
0.4294493198,
-0.257345289,
0.7208889723,
0.8545435071,
-0.274371475,
-0.0248545129,
-0.6875405908,
-0.0844832361,
-0.4776587188,
0.7785332203,
-0.3009145558,
-1.0770381689,
0.3321825862,
-0.3485891223,
-0.0973048806,
0.0893355459,
0.7794729471,
0.2005678862,
1.0193618536,
0.5936102867,
-0.2942621708,
0.5465582013,
-0.0493433326,
0.1551378667,
-0.9538365006,
-0.2018469423,
-0.2852549851,
-0.3665190041,
-0.8757166862,
-0.7328264117,
0.3446297944,
0.2433377504,
-0.0179520156,
0.2201347798,
-0.007256323,
0.6747475266,
0.29524225,
-0.1034113318,
0.2681809664,
0.2881388068,
-0.2111085653,
-0.1809778363,
-0.9454147816,
-0.5769392252,
1.1415114403,
0.3942897618,
0.7829715014,
0.1618380994,
0.5613421202,
-0.1349126846,
0.2986063957,
-0.6181932092,
0.3707663119,
-0.2394267172,
-0.4383275211,
-0.5031527877,
-0.4987368584,
-0.9290608168,
0.5400366783,
-0.2844373584,
-0.6199949384,
-0.1711402237,
0.1647890955,
-0.2624485195,
-0.2285703272,
-0.8169976473,
0.763715148,
-0.6380565763,
-0.5412035584,
-0.3446780741,
-0.3428573608,
0.4279762805,
-0.3907315135,
0.2541535199,
0.1030135825,
-0.1845528334,
0.3512621224,
-0.1958474368,
0.6073203683,
-0.1893597543,
-0.2614113986,
0.0030021819,
-0.3041041493,
0.752651453,
-0.1813773066,
-0.2409280092,
0.1322845072,
-0.3500427008,
-0.4525997639,
-0.6608628631,
0.7271800041,
-0.5618909597,
-0.5807353854,
0.1555924863,
-0.6729471087,
-0.4988923967,
0.1799244583,
0.1105657294,
0.1513543278,
-0.1628499925,
0.1581594497,
0.3708778918,
-0.4082810879,
0.4378188848,
0.6541604996,
-0.5944022536,
-0.4218241274,
1.0361202955,
0.1867789626,
0.4861694872,
0.0612615831,
0.3293234408,
-0.5788852572,
-0.5767858028,
-0.5571064353,
0.3355532587,
-0.4738466144,
-0.0019579181,
-0.3599207997,
-0.1784234196,
-0.5189076662,
0.172173813,
-0.3940907419,
-0.4548480809,
-0.2790101469,
-0.11784821,
0.0822501928,
0.5163577199,
-0.0655835196,
0.5838503838,
-0.8303923607,
0.2423285544,
-0.050468605,
0.3543404937,
0.2392366827,
-0.6052393913,
-0.6877530813,
0.2409039736,
-0.1760657877,
-0.4169222116,
0.3836787045,
0.1745343804,
0.7521836758,
0.2894938886,
-0.2423291206,
1.0574151278,
-0.6202340722,
0.5327749252,
0.2053631693,
-0.6582551599,
0.2586321533,
-0.0640628114,
0.4733584821,
0.3849154413,
0.4222874641,
-0.5169733763,
-0.1475864947,
-0.2633273602,
-0.826131165,
0.7594385147,
-0.0121343052,
0.3832560182,
0.3208703399,
0.2444370687,
0.1230181456,
0.3944475055,
-0.7752293944,
-0.0646012351,
0.1012157202,
-0.2371875793,
-0.393068254,
-0.2907097936,
0.1268575639,
-0.1847653687,
0.6750768423,
-0.0929605216,
-0.29492715,
-0.2081399858,
-0.3980033398,
-0.0327198617,
0.2276013345,
0.7633733153,
0.7625128031,
0.191766277,
-0.0696097836,
0.3564307094,
-0.4131007493,
0.1892066002,
0.0592829548,
0.0137027353,
0.0133980094,
0.5479160547,
1.1109633446,
0.1362808198,
-0.8104009032,
0.153921172,
0.2770871818,
0.299241364,
-0.1018451676,
-0.0075118477,
0.2534239292,
0.4935933053,
0.2331650853,
-0.3510161042,
-0.195883587,
-0.4113351703,
-0.2037146837,
0.5232307315,
-0.1040840745,
-0.3565403223,
0.201916486,
0.186751768,
-0.2382914573,
0.3515684605,
-0.2341359556,
-0.7639380097,
0.3523918092,
0.7810314298,
0.4700730145,
-0.5384807587,
0.1479537487,
0.3776432872,
0.5085232854,
-0.1741574407,
0.2681782544,
0.1479939073,
-0.7502298951,
-0.9619101882,
-0.6882254481,
-0.1089496166,
0.4306216836,
-0.4326197207,
0.3490463197,
-0.1574502438,
-0.2665185034,
-0.3216548562,
0.3078449965,
-0.6081404686,
-0.0042150663,
0.18735677,
0.7201926708,
-0.6939601898,
0.8039989471,
0.7676414251,
-0.1315189898,
-0.806563139,
-0.0399056226,
-0.2695833445,
-0.8395550251,
0.8927154541,
0.041053772,
-0.116543673,
0.052186545,
-0.1312342137,
-1.0125027895,
0.8038954735,
0.5669876337,
-0.7171701789,
0.168306753,
0.4402251244,
0.7489190102,
-0.4132585227,
-0.0499573871,
0.566488564,
0.5636862516,
-0.0699677914,
-1.0963430405,
-0.1664015353,
0.0012146872,
0.2072474658,
0.20679304,
-0.4079783261,
0.7068204284,
-0.2401551306,
-0.2217730582,
0.0843793899,
0.6354652643,
0.3744598031,
0.2320040911,
0.3521968126,
0.4364860654,
0.9923990369,
0.2673803866,
1.0983887911,
-0.3064793348,
-0.0180178098,
1.2937645912,
-0.4795801342,
0.7433674932,
0.5147766471,
-0.1588275135,
0.1243424714,
0.6125254035,
0.1599640995,
0.3864739537,
0.3384605944,
-0.334499687,
-0.2216943204,
-0.3989476264,
-0.3989267349,
0.5977481008,
0.3124113977,
-0.160690099,
-0.1132966876,
0.2477661818,
0.0963370204,
0.0875799358,
-0.5296106339,
0.6978876591,
-0.0690272003,
-0.6967718005,
0.7220166922,
0.1885920018,
0.6689842939,
-0.4795989394,
0.186726898,
-0.3374510705,
0.1567029655,
-0.2571596801,
-0.4798765481,
-0.0452013239,
0.1350119263,
-0.1314955503,
-0.068444483,
0.7895201445,
-1.0062919855,
-0.7639769316,
0.4104865491,
0.650709033,
0.0535831973,
0.0290868822,
-0.5160778761,
0.2656814754,
-0.0481812023,
-0.1577914655,
0.5425528288,
0.4653215408,
-0.3288248479,
0.6656772494,
0.7983105183,
0.5608634353,
0.2293641716,
0.2985238731,
0.8488079906,
-0.1948159337,
-0.3577074111,
-0.9230951071,
0.3221614957,
-0.1835123599,
-0.12308608,
0.9692228436,
0.7044647932,
0.9447329044,
-0.2473844141,
0.6738695502,
0.5078220367,
0.687117815,
-0.8240067959,
0.5078121424,
-0.6117531657,
0.2514723539,
-0.3002799153,
-1.1292234659,
-0.0396314152,
0.5035749078,
-0.2536532283,
0.18014507,
0.3632565141,
0.9038976431,
-0.0568403602,
-0.2055467963,
0.4527307451,
0.2571690083,
-0.0116815213,
0.2748837173,
1.014492631,
-0.0240610391,
0.3445556462,
-0.2514294684,
-0.1209634319,
-0.2324850559,
-0.9115510583,
-0.8400777578,
-0.2664522529,
-0.1093635485,
-0.0829546824,
-0.171237886,
1.1372765303,
0.4950613379,
-0.6315941811,
-0.6094896197,
0.4333377779,
0.2376355976,
0.1132184491,
-0.1786229014,
0.2884668708,
-0.5552773476,
-0.7139946818,
0.6442265511,
0.1981123984,
-0.0056955195,
-0.3832667172,
-0.3215706348,
-0.1152972281,
-0.1047506854,
1.0553278923,
0.0804407597,
-0.657019496,
-0.0421000123,
0.1943714321,
0.0280347206,
-0.1475596726,
0.7787159681,
-0.6262660623,
0.4039766788,
0.3058917522,
0.8006737232,
0.3007730544,
0.1877591908,
0.5812282562,
-0.923615396,
0.4284665287,
0.1237545982,
-0.0134851411,
0.5184162855,
-0.2723842263,
0.4529920518,
-0.1130468547,
-0.4224921167,
-0.9718775749,
0.2446795106,
-0.4309526086,
-0.2815090418,
1.1773681641,
-0.0791890547,
-0.0414007828,
-0.0409732275,
-0.1922316253,
0.2368095219,
-0.0767691582,
0.6287290454,
0.8681567311,
-0.1317953318,
-0.1163338199,
-0.6672022343,
0.5424797535,
0.3095400333,
-0.8244044781,
0.2787570357,
0.5458317399,
0.0121915042,
0.194806233,
0.4984744191,
0.0138469776,
0.1785050035,
-0.4224984348,
-0.0322672576,
-0.1598768532,
-0.3821067512,
-0.5457857847,
-0.1109350473,
0.142137602,
-0.0027231232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10856v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10856v1
|
Zero-shot Generative Linguistic Steganography
| 2024-03-16T08:31:25 | 2024-03-16T08:31:25 |
Ke Lin, Yiyang Luo, Zijian Zhang, Ping Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Generative linguistic steganography attempts to hide secret messages into
covertext. Previous studies have generally focused on the statistical
differences between the covertext and stegotext, however, ill-formed stegotext
can readily be identified by humans. In this paper, we propose a novel
zero-shot approach based on in-context learning for linguistic steganography to
achieve better perceptual and statistical imperceptibility. We also design
several new metrics and reproducible language evaluations to measure the
imperceptibility of the stegotext. Our experimental results indicate that our
method produces $1.926\times$ more innocent and intelligible stegotext than any
other method.
|
[
-0.1685061008,
-1.1287406683,
0.4822076261,
0.0998981744,
-0.5099317431,
0.06045321,
-0.4724157751,
-0.3240446448,
0.2104873657,
0.4009557664,
-0.3352644145,
-1.0208272934,
-0.6222582459,
0.1467456669,
-0.5228282213,
0.9023609161,
-0.0419389606,
0.0741857067,
0.1527680308,
-0.2007856518,
-0.6737954617,
-0.7482314706,
-0.441662401,
0.1404823661,
0.1188153401,
0.5138289332,
0.5020842552,
0.4270476401,
0.3417458236,
0.2060579658,
0.1012773663,
-0.316686064,
-0.7669523954,
0.6291695833,
-0.1814637035,
-0.4743570387,
0.0467124097,
-0.3036848307,
0.6692380905,
0.4916093647,
0.037346337,
0.0926462933,
-0.0949875191,
0.2213949412,
-0.7236843109,
0.0908040777,
-0.6842037439,
0.2692447007,
-0.4021822214,
-0.4269040823,
-0.4791027904,
-0.2744212151,
-0.0006104285,
-0.5959262848,
0.4505847991,
-0.0237569585,
0.7448510528,
0.0172755998,
-0.1549764872,
-0.2993759215,
-0.81422019,
0.7285289168,
-0.6474045515,
0.1526850164,
0.5149544477,
0.2872822285,
0.1546337754,
-0.5858495235,
-0.5619312525,
-0.2973953784,
0.0167386066,
0.1304616481,
0.0596883148,
0.0025283499,
0.1494937837,
0.364074707,
-0.7519470453,
-0.1627869904,
-0.0712302625,
-0.1272684187,
0.4941148758,
-0.1102522835,
0.628000319,
-0.0749377757,
-0.5643208623,
-0.1622775048,
-0.6342714429,
-0.4105118513,
0.3584684432,
0.1221055835,
0.0094537633,
0.4340905249,
-0.2649729848,
0.2689986825,
-0.0355389938,
-0.0009489286,
0.1526974738,
-0.1308041811,
-0.4303941727,
0.2497331947,
0.8720944524,
-0.0601245165,
0.0778779089,
-0.4879270196,
-0.0374110155,
-0.012449488,
0.1454180032,
-0.7452411652,
0.0076070759,
-0.2271784544,
-0.2235314101,
-0.6239905357,
0.1282491982,
-0.7507831454,
-0.0262795817,
0.1369791329,
0.888592124,
-0.800232172,
-0.007313523,
0.0332669243,
-0.3319415152,
0.1459996253,
0.1530704796,
-0.8659691215,
0.2621119022,
0.4291464984,
0.9347015619,
0.1737896949,
-0.0846209377,
-0.2468530983,
0.2801073194,
-0.7756826878,
0.5418614745,
-0.4884043932,
-0.3256783187,
-0.0815821588,
0.0938995853,
0.1353840977,
-0.2691037059,
0.5023924708,
-0.5733664632,
0.3276868165,
-0.129899472,
-0.7064734101,
-0.4711455703,
-0.1847426295,
-0.4066804945,
0.7712115049,
0.0750310272,
-0.3379898965,
0.6181845069,
-0.5681340694,
-0.4425503612,
0.6084977388,
-0.2233002037,
-0.4878017008,
0.1445028782,
-0.0439549871,
0.4641999006,
0.2571232021,
0.5345857739,
-0.3387086093,
-0.6786102057,
0.3797091246,
-1.2397460938,
0.8867895603,
0.1251192242,
-0.8396292329,
-0.0543715805,
-0.4586466551,
0.0144964401,
0.2493170202,
-0.0151125612,
-0.654263258,
-0.4810073376,
-0.0670396388,
-0.2047301233,
0.0116884997,
-0.7392708063,
-0.1288796961,
-0.852381289,
0.155626446,
0.5868161321,
0.2172025889,
0.8213293552,
0.0183869656,
0.455747813,
-0.3339564204,
0.2090443671,
-0.2793325782,
-0.6232366562,
-0.5417189598,
-0.4045859575,
0.1555712223,
0.4670210183,
-0.8538528681,
0.3212036192,
-0.084269464,
-0.2217309177,
-0.3960294724,
0.3076949418,
0.8737127781,
0.6647748947,
0.2231654823,
-0.5432493687,
-0.2960401177,
-0.8032095432,
-0.4043628871,
0.1184474453,
-0.1773425043,
0.1442911476,
0.6115893722,
0.2499787956,
0.6740189791,
-0.4171952903,
-0.3956383467,
-0.0236362796,
0.4426240623,
-0.0334099233,
0.4054904282,
0.6330476403,
-0.584597528,
-0.7542363405,
-0.1007499471,
-1.1127901077,
0.0954729989,
0.0961982235,
-0.1747961491,
0.3009893596,
0.5196718574,
-0.2017368078,
0.7756992579,
0.2876789868,
-0.4112487137,
0.2741159797,
-0.2267761528,
0.1975283623,
-0.8605507016,
0.0004745586,
-0.1613566726,
-0.3387166858,
-1.0535732508,
0.1148414984,
0.1886178702,
-0.3499172926,
-0.522842288,
0.5322610736,
-0.7072787881,
0.2568249106,
0.0392063484,
0.0320359804,
-0.0249187946,
0.6011179686,
0.1467636377,
0.7539506555,
0.8198906779,
-0.2008143812,
0.2126039863,
0.2563066185,
-0.612041831,
0.4982029498,
-0.3811306953,
0.2315291464,
-0.559728086,
0.1850870103,
-1.175132513,
-0.4322030842,
0.5472434163,
-0.5624126196,
0.6566029787,
-0.1961108446,
-0.3277263939,
0.2602759302,
-0.4698514342,
0.4389081597,
0.4896964133,
-0.3655754924,
-0.1677369475,
0.242457673,
0.0294255037,
-0.6905621886,
-0.7821781635,
0.4332716763,
-0.2167820334,
-0.2580674887,
0.3701571822,
0.0005843202,
-0.0626383871,
0.0909679234,
0.0215281453,
-0.1981880367,
0.0107130148,
0.4443961978,
0.2408984005,
-0.1812111288,
0.3808904588,
0.207797721,
-0.1327703893,
-0.2648818195,
-0.1035789028,
0.4750831723,
-0.2217719108,
-0.4164050221,
-0.6728792191,
0.5751132369,
0.1519705206,
0.2143854797,
0.9687199593,
0.5645617843,
-0.3461454511,
-0.3546299934,
-0.222616002,
-0.3624533117,
-0.442351073,
0.2326660156,
-0.2921143174,
-0.715842247,
0.1734683216,
0.2976906598,
-0.2564038336,
0.0981141478,
0.3414495885,
-0.1263555288,
0.698558867,
0.4808775485,
0.1524678171,
0.5671751499,
-0.3152793348,
0.3306809068,
-0.5389066935,
-0.1732814461,
-0.2158538699,
-0.1911970377,
-0.1875438243,
-0.4488494992,
0.4053990841,
0.3782764971,
-0.1498374641,
0.5687515736,
-0.7216911912,
0.5884112716,
0.6494060755,
0.3161242008,
0.3670029044,
0.3869643509,
-0.0545298494,
-0.1498455107,
-0.5749374032,
-0.6138719916,
1.2062748671,
0.2250379026,
0.6011303663,
0.2712134719,
0.697489202,
0.1174193546,
0.7137483358,
-0.7533823848,
0.3614439666,
-0.2565899193,
-0.9942812324,
-0.7311657667,
-0.2924065888,
-0.6359531283,
0.222504288,
-0.2485050261,
-0.7463048697,
0.1054559797,
0.0022520642,
-0.1528093368,
0.3406002223,
-0.9005584717,
0.7195596099,
-0.1017774493,
-0.3216701448,
0.3412983716,
-0.6551297307,
0.4294386208,
0.066561766,
0.3170187175,
-0.0855133757,
-0.0958855897,
0.7705790997,
-0.3193132877,
1.2076072693,
-0.1879398972,
-0.0894658267,
0.1082964912,
0.3280548453,
0.2193140984,
0.2619650662,
0.1370547861,
0.4729739428,
-0.2743392587,
-0.157889396,
-0.5648278594,
0.7012048364,
-0.329415977,
-0.5021036863,
-0.3158613741,
-0.3346506357,
-0.1352614164,
0.2524750829,
0.659740746,
0.7204315662,
-0.410018146,
0.4616678357,
0.899972558,
-0.4839686155,
0.637537241,
0.3241028786,
0.1926524937,
-0.4649989903,
0.8916492462,
0.2611186206,
0.3399389386,
0.7148007751,
0.1544316858,
-0.4940214455,
-0.2860444486,
-0.5485239029,
0.216865927,
-0.7954456806,
-0.3116379976,
-0.4407499433,
-0.1735264808,
-0.4896908402,
-0.4397526979,
-0.0590535663,
-0.3539732099,
-0.3513875604,
-0.0684937909,
0.4522916973,
0.4232279956,
0.1026892811,
0.4011614919,
-0.1265795976,
0.4860049486,
0.3212853074,
0.5233438015,
-0.1385284662,
-0.6996039748,
0.2464070916,
0.039586328,
0.0261790119,
-1.3305667639,
0.6118302941,
0.3539815843,
0.4480879009,
0.6082752347,
0.0765859485,
0.7315128446,
-0.3701412976,
0.6204167604,
0.3329592049,
-1.1705675125,
0.722028017,
-0.2203540057,
0.1939420402,
0.5262542367,
0.2465631217,
-0.5227378011,
-0.6366379857,
-0.7204272151,
-0.8507742286,
0.6162074804,
0.4144359529,
0.557346642,
-0.0924516991,
0.4256707132,
0.2955755293,
0.2265482098,
-0.7297488451,
-0.3615649939,
-0.4223420322,
-0.3457320035,
-0.125028342,
-0.4418704212,
-0.3193913698,
-0.2188954949,
0.3544663489,
-0.0979708657,
0.3542905748,
0.2786564827,
-0.434907347,
-0.0064035645,
0.4035202563,
0.8340421319,
0.447894901,
-0.2606874406,
0.5077033043,
0.2994556427,
-0.6970595121,
0.2697409987,
-0.5220525265,
-0.6459153295,
0.4597558081,
0.5592694879,
0.9686553478,
0.4414699972,
-0.5010069609,
1.0863002539,
-0.0530612729,
-0.4843070209,
-0.4307991564,
-0.0536641516,
-0.2342341989,
-0.1707561761,
0.38238433,
0.1830665767,
0.0969641656,
-0.6709648967,
0.3380586207,
0.6404396892,
-0.7549684048,
-0.3884450197,
0.8311630487,
-0.0999538749,
-0.3406287432,
0.1062858701,
-0.2044530958,
-0.3865453601,
0.4508894384,
0.9780709743,
0.9756318927,
-0.4218859971,
0.7355778813,
0.3098243177,
0.316698283,
0.0214400645,
0.0635386631,
-0.4397091568,
-0.5820910335,
-0.1766462475,
-0.630040586,
-0.1034810394,
0.2385995388,
-0.4459500313,
0.0221931636,
-0.4739689827,
0.1739707887,
-0.0723806471,
-0.3223879337,
-0.4765613377,
0.1288073808,
0.0422900878,
0.4222087562,
-0.9343534112,
0.8368328214,
0.1952531785,
-0.4978337288,
-0.5098793507,
-0.0140648624,
0.018384574,
-1.0146787167,
0.7771493196,
-0.03726786,
-0.2034780234,
0.0315607302,
-0.8503671885,
-0.7218766809,
1.0657259226,
0.6806364655,
-0.4044009447,
0.2751398087,
-0.0237147156,
0.6583747864,
-0.1260485947,
0.2024292648,
0.1347907484,
0.325815022,
0.1207200885,
-0.5161717534,
0.3936417997,
0.0323460177,
0.2551595867,
0.1990297586,
-0.1722265631,
0.5660879612,
0.1144054979,
-0.9863488078,
-0.1519995034,
0.4118457735,
-0.0563954525,
0.2576818466,
0.2179015875,
0.4038148522,
0.4539893568,
0.1174027175,
0.8514695168,
-0.0215763468,
0.5432208776,
0.9585950971,
-0.0541732758,
0.8080677986,
0.4455778003,
0.2303858101,
0.4054843485,
-0.0333583243,
0.1417487711,
0.7048822641,
0.0603792816,
-0.8556493521,
0.1081110761,
0.074867405,
-0.1539611369,
0.1557106376,
0.399325788,
-0.3602665067,
-0.2328276336,
0.3652703166,
0.4668698013,
0.1708908826,
0.0974683836,
0.896099031,
0.0188177545,
-0.3454371691,
0.7810662389,
-0.1488777399,
0.7648779154,
-0.575944066,
-0.2230587751,
-0.3057951033,
-0.0033724715,
-0.2152632177,
-1.0194170475,
0.4328902066,
0.0483004116,
0.186220482,
-0.6198034883,
0.9353041053,
-0.681281507,
-0.3039559722,
0.2670713067,
0.0547432005,
0.361436069,
-0.2754117846,
-0.3157798648,
-0.2280199081,
-0.1957276762,
-0.0225158278,
0.3004200161,
0.4675568342,
-0.2496844381,
0.5005839467,
0.6961033344,
0.1871902794,
0.2013910562,
0.2155157924,
0.3712514937,
-0.5884900689,
-0.2640386522,
-0.9874358177,
0.0684548244,
-0.2661221325,
-0.234497115,
1.0179643631,
0.3507936299,
0.8635554314,
-0.3850096166,
0.85692662,
-0.2356275469,
0.2252521515,
-0.2928435504,
0.9529771209,
-0.3654799163,
0.1065873727,
-0.4439236522,
-0.5790801048,
-0.7755908966,
0.5028734803,
-0.3204498291,
-0.3352354765,
0.7256481647,
0.9994087815,
-0.0320786871,
-0.2067316771,
0.8891895413,
0.0820580274,
0.0157707259,
0.3763526082,
0.6322330236,
-0.6711976528,
0.7430759668,
-0.460044682,
-0.5299113989,
-0.346316129,
-0.6085442901,
-0.819111228,
-0.7971593142,
-0.0750319585,
0.0508173555,
0.2285387367,
0.0680738166,
0.6929396987,
-0.7534649968,
0.0261391811,
-0.352003932,
0.1473907232,
-0.2491725534,
-0.3353315294,
0.4378639758,
-0.3462366462,
-0.6017330289,
0.4984479547,
0.7528342009,
0.1140129492,
-0.2745800614,
0.0942244679,
-0.050348714,
0.1008964628,
0.6898626685,
0.3611527383,
-0.6300210357,
-0.4992720783,
-0.1028627306,
-0.1134898737,
0.135759905,
0.6301755309,
-0.482883513,
0.7403568625,
0.7131941319,
0.1168709993,
0.655343473,
0.1509933174,
0.4175845385,
-1.1461657286,
0.400675863,
0.2698195279,
-0.0685001537,
0.1734448224,
-0.5116452575,
0.1481817812,
0.3540548682,
-0.2294761091,
-0.7976517081,
0.1636949927,
-0.7954118252,
-0.5273048282,
0.9987188578,
-0.2009705156,
-0.4447888732,
-0.4150084555,
-0.221824035,
0.3332732618,
-0.3850102723,
0.6585302949,
0.4033815265,
0.1813750714,
-0.2179304957,
-0.7622277737,
0.6725876927,
0.3315928578,
-0.5756908655,
-0.1523756534,
0.1577068269,
0.6428900361,
0.1195932254,
0.8130856156,
-0.4258177578,
0.0767446011,
0.2604644895,
-0.0500671379,
0.1254427433,
-0.433291465,
-0.6137594581,
0.5684912801,
-0.391849339,
-0.4162307084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10849v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10849v2
|
RetinaQA: A Robust Knowledge Base Question Answering Model for both Answerable and Unanswerable Questions
| 2024-03-16T08:08:20 | 2024-06-15T20:42:13 |
Prayushi Faldu, Indrajit Bhattacharya, Mausam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An essential requirement for a real-world Knowledge Base Question Answering
(KBQA) system is the ability to detect answerability of questions when
generating logical forms. However, state-of-the-art KBQA models assume all
questions to be answerable. Recent research has found that such models, when
superficially adapted to detect answerability, struggle to satisfactorily
identify the different categories of unanswerable questions, and simultaneously
preserve good performance for answerable questions. Towards addressing this
issue, we propose RetinaQA, a new KBQA model that unifies two key ideas in a
single KBQA architecture: (a) discrimination over candidate logical forms,
rather than generating these, for handling schema-related unanswerability, and
(b) sketch-filling-based construction of candidate logical forms for handling
data-related unaswerability. Our results show that RetinaQA significantly
outperforms adaptations of state-of-the-art KBQA models in handling both
answerable and unanswerable questions and demonstrates robustness across all
categories of unanswerability. Notably, RetinaQA also sets a new
state-of-the-art for answerable KBQA, surpassing existing models.
|
[
-0.2731925249,
-0.9599190354,
0.7219525576,
0.0259072315,
-0.1764067709,
0.3064952493,
0.3403547406,
-0.6734089255,
0.569996953,
0.6825650334,
-0.7002665997,
-0.2081630975,
-0.2797591984,
-0.1868028045,
-0.5864315629,
0.3724692464,
-0.2631653249,
-0.2438132018,
-0.7116371393,
-0.3251938522,
-0.7409479618,
-0.3025692403,
-0.2325040251,
-0.0588049181,
0.4364821613,
0.6589748263,
0.8375439644,
0.4756911099,
0.3028833568,
0.2549228966,
0.1075078845,
0.1901592612,
0.1183095723,
0.5196793079,
-0.0725696534,
-0.6259656549,
-0.5662748218,
-0.1325291395,
0.3819024861,
0.5348850489,
-0.1604963541,
0.5316292644,
-0.3323228061,
0.7019280195,
-0.6815002561,
-0.1449967772,
-0.7229326963,
-0.0272044856,
0.0685275421,
-0.0386826508,
-0.3435520828,
-0.3087938726,
0.2037698179,
-1.0095062256,
-0.0161944721,
0.1039689109,
0.7579967976,
0.4019416273,
-0.4432764351,
0.0436330587,
-0.2878596783,
0.3304052353,
-0.5259192586,
0.5728482008,
0.119115375,
0.8737666011,
-0.1476893276,
-0.9832833409,
-0.6085171103,
-0.1612809002,
0.1994052827,
0.308044076,
-0.4171445072,
-0.2132423073,
-0.0446879305,
-0.0382166952,
-0.4881797731,
-0.1512402147,
-0.3246295452,
-0.4984247386,
0.1247539297,
0.2655975819,
0.382227391,
-0.3288406134,
-0.3902561367,
0.431655705,
-0.6153472066,
0.5031353235,
-0.0198019017,
0.0976058096,
0.230140999,
0.4709682763,
-0.693154335,
0.9906271696,
0.081576854,
0.0661673993,
-0.1424346417,
-0.0207767803,
-0.2014940381,
-0.3529338837,
0.0674908608,
0.3828704953,
0.3013445437,
-0.4329876304,
-0.2309810221,
-0.1069042012,
0.669081986,
-0.5528256297,
-0.5559947491,
0.4640367925,
-0.6159219146,
-0.6113436818,
-0.3071171343,
-0.593663156,
-0.4410145879,
-0.1380792558,
0.7796910405,
-0.1739867628,
-0.5577508807,
-0.1232840344,
-0.0855382681,
0.2280919403,
0.7854064107,
-0.6192314625,
0.1919442117,
0.5846214294,
0.4936572313,
0.0598332398,
-0.1210442856,
-0.3111003637,
-0.1204364821,
-0.43656528,
1.0581606627,
-0.4074362814,
0.3884986937,
-0.2607099414,
0.0867627859,
-0.0147528518,
-0.6332444549,
0.3725171387,
-1.1484780312,
-0.0313681066,
-0.4271690547,
-0.5244449377,
-0.4844337702,
0.6096900105,
-0.8090772033,
0.5237494111,
0.4945157468,
-0.9895247221,
0.7138563991,
-0.5096877813,
0.0120478226,
0.2001608014,
-0.1150498614,
-0.302380085,
0.0973459929,
0.2558799386,
0.2122257948,
-0.4427492619,
0.4275899231,
-0.3187345564,
-0.3167922199,
0.449753195,
-0.2686549127,
0.7013644576,
0.2694686949,
-0.1588765383,
0.1149002016,
-0.8728118539,
0.6188964844,
0.009677697,
-0.5261129141,
-0.1037247255,
-0.124261044,
0.0666511506,
0.289106518,
0.2186665535,
-0.8724313378,
-0.0634965152,
-0.2363685519,
0.534256041,
0.7086699605,
-0.0775588378,
0.2605865598,
-0.455063194,
0.6646001935,
0.3805336058,
0.2808972001,
0.3857370019,
-0.6483317614,
-0.7716316581,
-0.228482157,
0.3755918443,
0.9338556528,
-1.053000927,
-0.1724523753,
0.0561810471,
-1.0178871155,
-0.4586922228,
-0.040942464,
0.4607183337,
1.1403005123,
0.3274499476,
-0.3231594265,
-0.4666820168,
-1.3172291517,
-0.3914706409,
-0.496468693,
0.2427332997,
0.4700253904,
0.5994504094,
0.1237208918,
1.2008484602,
-0.4608462155,
0.2869976759,
-0.1951203048,
-0.2832361162,
0.3384322226,
0.1684159636,
0.5060865283,
-1.1374741793,
-0.2337590903,
-0.368498981,
-1.1168302298,
-0.1588679105,
0.1762988269,
-0.3076469898,
0.0829736218,
0.2806427479,
-0.796138823,
0.7921182513,
-0.1029068679,
-0.4822822809,
0.7176912427,
0.087289609,
0.1939747781,
-1.0673485994,
0.2918069959,
-0.5022668242,
-0.2492928803,
-0.8869422674,
0.2660500109,
0.4999063611,
-0.1342060417,
-0.6359896064,
0.4994612634,
-0.1116037369,
-0.0842449814,
-0.1259817034,
0.0302613173,
0.2856444418,
0.432249397,
0.1185643077,
0.5996629596,
0.6501082182,
-0.6733662486,
0.7886666656,
0.5859777331,
-0.7274751067,
0.5208155513,
-0.7523177266,
-0.2601138055,
-0.4117364883,
0.2148302048,
-1.0068665743,
-0.2839247286,
0.3932043612,
-0.7233591676,
-0.0189576838,
-0.1408233643,
-0.1108394489,
-0.2879845202,
0.0938512012,
0.5075092316,
0.2065341026,
-0.5355623364,
1.0099551678,
0.3012912571,
-0.1909793764,
-0.9013577104,
-0.6222482324,
-0.0185246561,
-0.2212836295,
-1.0834422112,
0.065803811,
0.1079775691,
-0.0671590567,
0.265119344,
-0.3097430766,
-0.5640194416,
0.4193755984,
0.3739895225,
0.5501748323,
-0.4762763977,
0.1297313273,
-0.093427442,
-0.1150442213,
0.2251590043,
-0.369786948,
0.0911281928,
0.181678772,
-0.2412558645,
-0.345950067,
0.5380948186,
0.8962545395,
-0.4574198723,
0.6814813614,
0.3680368066,
-0.590328455,
-0.0177227594,
-0.524409771,
-0.0236537009,
-0.378015101,
0.6278935671,
-0.5933453441,
-0.9092088342,
0.7295455933,
0.1077014133,
0.3010149598,
0.1042632461,
0.4956271946,
-0.1852963716,
0.4944746792,
0.6344673038,
0.2377316207,
0.0809614882,
0.3441936374,
0.3215197623,
-0.6966292262,
-0.5731615424,
-0.2056666911,
-0.3473405838,
-0.2454024255,
-0.1153474003,
0.3155612051,
0.0497296974,
-0.4996378422,
0.3237369955,
-0.4537341595,
0.215371415,
0.7822862864,
0.3652228117,
0.2771217227,
-0.2451535612,
-0.1724143475,
-0.0420298278,
-0.9232337475,
-0.3386061788,
1.1882228851,
0.3470877707,
0.7580314875,
0.451831162,
0.3878282011,
0.1307615936,
0.4176684022,
-0.4374066889,
0.4996270239,
0.065971598,
-1.0324507952,
-0.318497479,
-0.4301379919,
-0.2528127134,
0.3079329431,
-0.4187069237,
-0.7286417484,
0.4344473481,
0.4582624435,
-0.540578723,
0.508046031,
-0.8266834617,
1.1320486069,
-0.2490124553,
-0.1824103147,
0.2827035189,
-0.8072504401,
0.5464171767,
-0.3502518833,
-0.046514269,
0.0846447423,
-0.0792437941,
0.9498817921,
-0.3758748174,
0.5161390901,
-0.5461520553,
0.2042537034,
0.521422863,
0.294398278,
0.202283293,
0.3046654761,
0.2712390423,
-0.4181062579,
0.407258004,
-0.5607236624,
-0.9721460938,
0.4151216149,
-0.651144743,
-0.7722403407,
-0.2096496671,
-0.6204615831,
-0.5521672368,
0.2623549402,
0.2633603811,
0.6027962565,
-0.0221186485,
0.0933940932,
0.701725781,
-0.3696916103,
-0.1685801595,
0.720506072,
-0.3714318275,
-0.3532717526,
0.742785275,
0.1102363989,
0.4969930649,
0.5429314971,
-0.2236234695,
-0.4313704669,
-0.3872717321,
-0.7769892812,
-0.1653639227,
-0.882402122,
-0.407533437,
-0.5976637006,
-0.2958341837,
-0.4571495056,
0.0219816826,
-0.2676165402,
-1.0039098263,
0.1477382928,
-0.1680710912,
0.333426863,
0.5138080716,
-0.0642469749,
-0.1350007802,
-0.4752613306,
0.63584131,
0.7606916428,
0.4287396669,
0.133523941,
-0.8195024729,
0.0868728012,
0.0705388337,
-0.1930995584,
-1.1287267208,
-0.0599076897,
0.0664674118,
0.5588480234,
0.0207808092,
0.2685329616,
0.5741186142,
-0.2926186323,
0.2756652534,
0.0517427213,
-0.5302554369,
0.383258611,
-0.0783225819,
0.0837361887,
0.8317112327,
0.1527787596,
-0.5347781181,
-0.1585531235,
-0.3499184847,
-0.7211904526,
0.475674063,
-0.0030186416,
-0.1950693429,
0.423633039,
0.5971542597,
-0.0709151924,
0.3143171668,
-0.7365836501,
-0.2237719893,
-0.7755793333,
-0.0479286239,
0.5643256307,
-0.2712776661,
0.0279134326,
-0.0887912139,
0.5642347932,
0.0687704757,
0.4095309675,
0.2709027529,
-0.1955736428,
-0.0399904959,
0.3491121829,
0.0100200418,
0.6407958269,
-0.439524591,
0.1422270238,
0.1149001494,
-0.6705812216,
0.2637275159,
-0.0932194367,
-0.5871991515,
-0.298540473,
0.3872778714,
0.3701504767,
-0.0576009117,
-0.8216646314,
0.5539789796,
-0.2524514198,
-0.4696337283,
-0.3090941906,
0.097479552,
0.2721163332,
0.3871916533,
0.251285404,
0.3043289483,
-0.0060615521,
-0.5543802977,
0.4376646578,
0.3981292248,
-0.4475361407,
0.1539570987,
0.9592708349,
0.1866912544,
-0.2345399261,
0.9320104122,
0.1285883486,
-0.8170378804,
0.8240420818,
0.5873690844,
0.294508189,
0.1133128703,
0.6082738638,
0.0638533011,
0.4900456965,
0.4849036038,
0.6662459373,
-0.215726465,
-1.0097668171,
-0.132089898,
-0.4355077446,
-0.503289938,
-0.0393695198,
-0.8627651334,
-0.218533963,
-0.4594395757,
0.1127553135,
0.2037152201,
-0.1592600644,
-0.3214178979,
0.6674809456,
-0.285340488,
1.6827231646,
-0.9086729288,
0.4922362566,
0.8250992298,
-0.4122976661,
-1.1229003668,
-0.3586289585,
-0.1935583353,
-0.9156809449,
0.5856012702,
0.0347084142,
0.0986752212,
-0.1299494505,
-0.5685236454,
-0.8269647956,
1.4921272993,
0.3694970906,
-0.0061651138,
0.0550166257,
0.1658055782,
0.1341631562,
-0.2175133377,
-0.0633253008,
0.4060114324,
0.5079462528,
0.1951387972,
-0.6386369467,
0.244778648,
-0.5852453113,
-0.6024980545,
0.2236233503,
-0.5363950729,
0.732391715,
-0.3053783774,
-0.0977274328,
0.5703197122,
0.6795544028,
0.4873786867,
0.5033920407,
0.6636451483,
0.7651475072,
0.8220575452,
-0.2178078741,
0.5258215666,
-0.1449016333,
-0.0937001184,
0.8269339204,
-0.0579250865,
0.8583342433,
0.4420088828,
0.0782326534,
0.4294605851,
0.6570209265,
0.2491872609,
0.6366214752,
0.1920387298,
-0.3246640265,
-0.8874726892,
0.0614644587,
-0.3929716349,
0.605276227,
0.0781554505,
-0.0554584526,
-0.2097830921,
-0.1048696861,
-0.2679472566,
0.1016315967,
-0.3183076978,
0.2484795898,
-0.0972064137,
-0.9255151749,
0.3450994492,
0.1085840091,
0.2319006771,
-0.3843164146,
-0.059905231,
-0.4357376397,
-0.0983928517,
-0.3903667331,
-0.967371285,
0.2074531168,
0.0712923035,
-0.600147903,
0.3600705564,
1.0906403065,
-0.0452715941,
-0.6640744209,
-0.0740631074,
1.0192884207,
0.0280206297,
-0.0895540118,
-0.635432899,
-0.5285446048,
0.0315197445,
-0.1290017813,
0.1789734364,
0.5848730803,
-0.2165068686,
1.374707222,
0.4747446179,
-0.073692441,
0.2901816964,
-0.2154912949,
1.0835615396,
-0.5896369815,
-0.5959174037,
-0.1609859616,
0.4602387547,
0.1781396419,
-0.3900129795,
0.4038407505,
0.3717965484,
0.211236909,
-0.1007039994,
0.6318296194,
-0.359684974,
0.8542241454,
-0.3854728043,
0.842254281,
-0.7554936409,
0.0606664531,
-0.3595643938,
-0.7757687569,
-0.3464439213,
0.5544566512,
-0.0083804,
-0.0090976758,
0.4369188249,
0.9236647487,
-0.1391030848,
0.188529551,
0.2642647028,
0.0916162506,
0.116062656,
1.087792635,
1.1597796679,
-0.3393672109,
0.6906297803,
-0.1292303205,
-0.3989781439,
0.1033389941,
-0.6018117666,
-0.471645385,
-0.6652507782,
-0.1418275982,
-0.3745580316,
0.1208707914,
0.2341001481,
0.6679342389,
-0.7472708821,
0.3730016649,
0.0804591179,
0.1609502137,
0.0385687165,
-0.1556790024,
0.3576100469,
0.2256171405,
0.1511216462,
0.1013900638,
0.2574900389,
-0.1166167781,
-0.0356249847,
0.0820106566,
-0.0349693783,
0.0933180377,
0.2449374646,
0.5396057367,
-0.627705574,
-0.5344210267,
0.3894578815,
0.2963163555,
-0.2425141633,
0.509275496,
-1.1691358089,
0.3516945839,
0.3580858111,
0.9330047965,
0.0038988863,
0.1563938111,
0.3080880046,
-0.3888897598,
-0.2627865672,
0.2043356746,
0.3425137103,
0.0491549782,
-0.2460846305,
0.2963319123,
0.2031904608,
-0.6156538129,
-0.6820200682,
0.7167349458,
-1.0797885656,
-0.2635427713,
0.4705958664,
-0.1572246253,
-0.3255191147,
-0.6475781798,
-0.0259402618,
-0.0242203008,
0.0130185345,
0.6007170081,
0.6511523128,
-0.2991514504,
-0.3477286398,
-0.5766100287,
0.0389121212,
0.519672811,
-0.7560360432,
0.1218094528,
0.5276924968,
0.6831609607,
0.165565744,
0.8126245737,
-0.0653448477,
1.0464230776,
0.0988803878,
-0.4088221192,
-0.5004578829,
-0.6560041904,
0.2810772955,
0.4471562207,
0.3463424146,
-0.2773572505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10838v1
|
Two-step Automated Cybercrime Coded Word Detection using Multi-level Representation Learning
| 2024-03-16T07:18:29 | 2024-03-16T07:18:29 |
Yongyeon Kim, Byung-Won On, Ingyu Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In social network service platforms, crime suspects are likely to use
cybercrime coded words for communication by adding criminal meanings to
existing words or replacing them with similar words. For instance, the word
'ice' is often used to mean methamphetamine in drug crimes. To analyze the
nature of cybercrime and the behavior of criminals, quickly detecting such
words and further understanding their meaning are critical. In the automated
cybercrime coded word detection problem, it is difficult to collect a
sufficient amount of training data for supervised learning and to directly
apply language models that utilize context information to better understand
natural language. To overcome these limitations, we propose a new two-step
approach, in which a mean latent vector is constructed for each cybercrime
through one of five different AutoEncoder models in the first step, and
cybercrime coded words are detected based on multi-level latent representations
in the second step. Moreover, to deeply understand cybercrime coded words
detected through the two-step approach, we propose three novel methods: (1)
Detection of new words recently coined, (2) Detection of words frequently
appeared in both drug and sex crimes, and (3) Automatic generation of word
taxonomy. According to our experimental results, among various AutoEncoder
models, the stacked AutoEncoder model shows the best performance. Additionally,
the F1-score of the two-step approach is 0.991, which is higher than 0.987 and
0.903 of the existing dark-GloVe and dark-BERT models. By analyzing the
experimental results of the three proposed methods, we can gain a deeper
understanding of drug and sex crimes.
|
[
-0.1832381189,
-0.9714210033,
0.3039165139,
0.0672373176,
-0.4738955498,
0.4705201983,
-0.0427601971,
-0.5545040965,
0.2577228248,
0.5746953487,
-0.3012988269,
-0.6376456618,
-1.0024037361,
-0.0182552859,
-0.7307778597,
0.985159874,
-0.1219926253,
0.1913952976,
-0.0138188079,
0.1049736887,
-0.6193976998,
-0.5754843354,
-0.6502155066,
-0.2433883548,
0.3382669091,
0.2424997687,
0.3604138494,
0.6709594131,
0.7239223719,
0.3249244988,
0.3021119833,
0.2477713525,
-0.4561831951,
-0.0232015811,
0.0835387632,
-0.4229840338,
-0.2508714199,
0.0122469934,
-0.0857164636,
0.3626798093,
-0.0939394608,
0.0915358886,
0.0475221686,
0.4696297944,
-0.7375497818,
0.1500358582,
-0.6685959697,
0.0936921611,
-0.1427198499,
-0.4269572496,
-0.1834458709,
0.1180474162,
-0.1226661801,
-0.439766109,
0.1290228814,
0.0208348874,
0.4018029273,
-0.0043316144,
-0.3411316276,
-0.67477566,
-0.7339506745,
0.6344942451,
-0.4556989372,
0.2774878144,
0.5742515922,
0.222764641,
-0.0307456944,
-0.7959371209,
-0.7988439202,
-0.1390743703,
-0.1105367541,
-0.1565333605,
-0.3829731941,
0.0965334252,
-0.0155218691,
0.2246728539,
-0.6978644729,
0.1531891972,
-0.6023335457,
-0.5145722628,
0.5204502344,
0.2445399612,
0.3288897276,
-0.2680591345,
-0.4556521177,
-0.1870952547,
-0.3417241871,
0.0496274643,
0.4211076796,
0.4449857175,
-0.3701238632,
0.3117850125,
0.0764352828,
0.3904781044,
-0.0028881077,
-0.244302541,
0.476251483,
-0.4500155449,
-0.0737487152,
-0.037826132,
0.7499220967,
0.3020096123,
0.1243453473,
-0.0162194651,
-0.4202516675,
0.5066617727,
0.4220285714,
-0.640150547,
-0.4017972946,
0.3917784989,
-0.738773644,
-0.6067179441,
0.1572797745,
-0.7102332115,
-0.4119883478,
-0.5123334527,
0.6530913711,
-0.3468794525,
-0.3467145264,
0.2029728442,
-0.2257380933,
0.1981702596,
-0.0102660786,
-0.4931702912,
0.606834054,
0.6393314004,
0.9298830628,
-0.388941139,
-0.1307011247,
-0.5646182299,
-0.0315206945,
-0.3847995698,
0.6448500752,
-0.5302266479,
-0.1142266095,
0.0874015018,
-0.0201098509,
0.104582645,
-0.3766502738,
-0.1342035532,
-0.7061105371,
0.2903834879,
0.1984507293,
-0.4163934588,
-0.243331477,
0.323892355,
-0.3554297686,
0.9055095911,
0.0089836605,
-0.7785965204,
0.4266640246,
-0.6445032358,
-0.5757485032,
0.2980345488,
-0.0804245844,
-0.2828656435,
-0.0565557703,
0.2375471592,
0.6055045128,
-0.1170527861,
0.280552268,
-0.3017125428,
-0.5447806716,
0.1706539243,
-0.2483294606,
0.803178072,
0.1615929157,
-0.5008719563,
-0.0878247768,
-0.6245107055,
-0.233882755,
0.2254050672,
-0.143059954,
-0.3843140304,
0.0510424078,
0.3719397485,
0.3737048507,
0.3048267066,
-0.7514032722,
-0.0303451512,
-0.392485708,
0.3939386308,
0.5888182521,
0.18105869,
0.2216610909,
-0.0345499776,
0.5999632478,
0.3553639054,
0.1609734446,
-0.1686903536,
-0.3152816594,
-0.6187070012,
-0.2025441378,
0.2395274937,
0.9815791845,
-1.0330430269,
0.5892443657,
-0.0281954072,
-0.2221890092,
-0.2657444477,
0.1485189199,
0.3838333488,
0.1052573547,
0.7717226744,
-0.4621600807,
-0.5764445662,
-0.7195634246,
-0.3346774578,
-0.0948243067,
-0.0580263622,
0.2300038785,
1.073649168,
-0.4102523923,
0.7426214218,
-0.7158023715,
-0.645934999,
-0.2137258649,
0.755305171,
0.1280211061,
0.403196007,
0.5023338795,
-0.8462050557,
-0.4059430957,
-0.4149388373,
-0.5143149495,
0.006207529,
-0.0802271217,
0.327588737,
-0.2049056739,
0.8714902401,
0.1672260314,
0.5206568241,
0.3671274483,
-0.3425924182,
0.3516016901,
-0.3053956926,
0.1308935881,
-1.0606342554,
-0.1943968832,
0.0296646208,
-0.275986284,
-0.9702426195,
0.124693431,
0.0177920721,
-0.1803162843,
-0.4379941821,
0.1933352649,
-0.5769340396,
0.0901408866,
-0.5216382146,
0.2326844931,
-0.4034279883,
0.6042968035,
-0.0242539179,
0.6002442241,
0.7256119251,
-0.6296662688,
0.7219971418,
-0.0474316776,
-0.3011243343,
0.5428905487,
-0.6088873148,
0.3852552474,
-0.4176201224,
0.2367054373,
-1.1110881567,
-0.0871472657,
0.3682149053,
-0.6712245941,
0.3115988076,
-0.1241719946,
-0.6338999867,
-0.50457865,
-0.3275307119,
0.5510829687,
0.1889388412,
-0.2796106339,
0.3063466251,
0.9382199645,
0.1867769659,
-0.5606908202,
-1.0746018887,
0.443983525,
-0.150968194,
-0.3179147243,
0.5087519884,
0.0990060344,
0.0074283695,
-0.2096256465,
0.1949235797,
-0.3569681346,
0.1027106792,
-0.0278042015,
0.2498573065,
0.0824021995,
0.0380146578,
-0.0228910502,
-0.1843469441,
0.1921143234,
-0.5951834917,
0.8851234317,
0.1575683504,
-0.0902003571,
-0.3217969239,
0.632394433,
0.3555501997,
-0.3215394616,
0.5937871933,
0.883654654,
-0.767246902,
-0.2366504222,
-0.3312241733,
-0.3953304589,
-0.4680633545,
0.2307988107,
-0.1012683734,
-0.9811702371,
0.3497234285,
0.2244455814,
-0.1314930916,
0.1061653048,
0.5776559114,
0.0743795112,
1.0953041315,
0.6544339061,
-0.3189102709,
0.4346950054,
-0.418192327,
0.495580107,
-0.5588777661,
-0.1901463717,
-0.2686448395,
-0.1962329298,
-0.6792860627,
-0.6343771815,
0.4758795798,
-0.259232074,
-0.0633217245,
0.786034584,
-0.3935809135,
0.1187566444,
0.2472506315,
0.4622265697,
0.0587322041,
0.2890157998,
-0.368090868,
0.1049707606,
-0.4547715783,
-0.2769998908,
1.1167117357,
0.3726158142,
0.4063911438,
-0.0145323118,
0.7930784822,
0.8256570101,
-0.0515501462,
-0.8429851532,
0.453586489,
-0.3888391256,
-0.5098023415,
-0.1126096919,
-0.2771212757,
-1.0293861628,
0.0325079672,
-0.4537725151,
-0.8793329,
0.3699822128,
0.0234865453,
-0.360933125,
0.2497354001,
0.0258147065,
0.6093677282,
-0.133949101,
-0.2792569995,
-0.6274166107,
-0.6662137508,
0.3285438418,
-0.1950518936,
0.747607708,
0.0465154871,
-0.1287534088,
0.8726688623,
-0.5059168339,
0.9080026746,
-0.3374471664,
-0.1938135773,
0.2621296644,
0.1190539449,
0.4555914402,
-0.2382091582,
0.4867192805,
0.2643565834,
-0.0772250295,
-0.2376957089,
-0.3558201194,
0.353972584,
-0.4593513608,
-0.0065438091,
-0.3402349949,
-0.3744630218,
0.0204574894,
0.2621349096,
0.3112206757,
0.7613878846,
-0.0293959174,
0.1977063268,
0.5831727386,
-0.287812084,
0.3205296993,
0.3846795559,
-0.0850769877,
-0.5879209042,
0.9607021213,
-0.0830027312,
-0.0748066306,
0.5617268682,
0.1180425063,
-0.1598053575,
-0.6433897614,
-0.1173190847,
0.1507843286,
-0.5239627361,
-0.3180454075,
-0.874771297,
0.0234828163,
-0.6570555568,
-0.0421546437,
-0.0884401351,
-0.032308653,
-0.2662263811,
0.2819517851,
0.3272956014,
0.583814919,
-0.2492969781,
0.4570491314,
-0.7812177539,
0.8376662135,
0.123358041,
0.2543834746,
-0.0671661273,
-0.6337624788,
-0.3236257732,
0.0948242992,
0.0054959417,
-1.1461869478,
0.5028876662,
-0.0068569886,
0.2628604472,
0.4837070704,
-0.1245991811,
0.5529930592,
-0.3290166855,
0.8141111135,
0.2845579088,
-0.9627341628,
0.5680953264,
-0.3799743652,
-0.0221291333,
0.557392776,
0.4754493833,
-0.7680333257,
-0.2618314624,
-0.3979926705,
-0.8664132357,
0.5828262568,
0.2127344012,
0.3412097096,
-0.1865822375,
0.2073405236,
-0.1205774695,
0.507058382,
-0.7676824331,
-0.4485139847,
-0.046837762,
-0.1459798217,
0.1721581072,
-0.284326911,
0.2751438916,
-0.0509272851,
0.5861433148,
-0.2103534937,
0.6586159468,
-0.0540803,
-0.4444097877,
0.0525578633,
0.0087904129,
0.2370149791,
0.4011454284,
0.1404402405,
0.0539491959,
0.0548555627,
-0.8829928637,
0.2424079329,
-0.045706477,
-0.0395791195,
-0.2160300761,
0.5464978814,
0.5248941779,
0.0814861804,
-0.4997093976,
1.026799798,
-0.0284707472,
-0.336853981,
-0.4982923865,
0.0267184563,
-0.2827293873,
0.1481761783,
0.4508229792,
-0.0135192592,
0.4826138914,
-0.6669970155,
0.5612547994,
0.4529919028,
-0.5381426215,
0.1104214191,
0.3945315182,
-0.039735537,
-0.4125255644,
0.5544123054,
-0.451569885,
-0.9090647101,
0.6015944481,
0.6267895103,
0.8697128892,
-0.2136497945,
0.2377925813,
0.2760219574,
0.3575793207,
-0.1576959491,
0.5889880657,
-0.1522402316,
-0.9976267219,
-0.2342091203,
-0.4928661287,
0.1782420874,
0.4328986108,
-0.7326057553,
0.3708277643,
-0.5788694024,
-0.1423961967,
-0.1036650166,
-0.0883452892,
-0.6414657831,
0.2321675271,
0.3673283458,
0.5794816613,
-1.1339069605,
0.5238599777,
0.5051501989,
-0.1730973274,
-0.5098511577,
0.0432351828,
0.3140748739,
-0.7169595957,
0.5415897369,
0.3235653937,
-0.2127688974,
-0.0239570439,
-0.7041781545,
-0.8908091187,
0.9136882424,
-0.3436360061,
-0.5932216048,
-0.0096269352,
0.2280420065,
0.5946062803,
-0.6384494901,
0.0097223977,
0.6372817755,
0.3272800446,
-0.1222011596,
-0.573358655,
-0.0397044793,
-0.3001255691,
0.0758854076,
0.4198485017,
-0.0556968302,
0.8957151175,
0.0610685311,
-0.3377881348,
-0.1832633317,
0.6745980978,
0.1041052714,
0.259493053,
0.8286256194,
0.3493430614,
0.5095533729,
0.1153835952,
0.6428750157,
-0.4916972518,
0.3936671913,
0.7681749463,
0.1421281546,
0.5746389627,
0.2515165806,
-0.2463645786,
0.7713623047,
0.4921991229,
-0.4379817247,
0.4517009258,
0.5547414422,
-0.0585778914,
-0.2913707197,
0.0529234931,
0.188821435,
0.9132393599,
0.7045182586,
-0.3857836723,
-0.1678339094,
0.4531718791,
0.0019508802,
0.0681158379,
-0.3796427548,
0.8668238521,
0.0631280988,
-0.2764754593,
0.4189538956,
0.436265409,
0.860263288,
-0.4031935334,
-0.1550600082,
0.150901854,
0.0760822147,
-0.1963073164,
-0.4561914206,
0.1628202945,
0.0616090856,
0.1561635882,
-0.0569749586,
1.0086344481,
-0.5987350345,
-0.4884466827,
0.5988547802,
0.2647559643,
0.3548935652,
-0.1271385401,
-1.0500520468,
-0.30980286,
-0.2922694087,
0.2307916731,
0.0127247348,
0.096271053,
0.0599763431,
0.4746009707,
0.8440205455,
0.3653303385,
-0.137931928,
0.0611098222,
0.7112392187,
-0.3412030637,
-0.9214559197,
-0.8719725609,
0.2234878093,
-0.200609535,
-0.2018407583,
0.5123890042,
0.5027083755,
0.8511933684,
0.1466655731,
0.722019732,
-0.1553162932,
0.5367987156,
-0.5983456969,
0.3571760654,
-0.5513105989,
0.3661756217,
-0.5491755605,
-0.6794756651,
-0.3980250061,
0.7079349756,
-0.2230932862,
0.0022236512,
0.7725881338,
0.9251410961,
-0.255356133,
-0.1426200718,
0.0752973482,
0.0773818269,
0.1854030937,
0.4373170733,
0.3588120043,
-0.7115741968,
0.4096735716,
-0.2708467543,
-0.4387262762,
-0.2548146844,
-0.8285654187,
-1.0157600641,
-0.5620389581,
-0.2217289358,
-0.3295166492,
0.0392014459,
1.0954461098,
0.5950576067,
-1.0006630421,
-0.2918365598,
-0.1390743405,
-0.1436228603,
-0.3838227391,
-0.2192315459,
0.2579089105,
-0.2814829648,
-0.3539508879,
0.5193958282,
0.2685121596,
-0.066869773,
-0.5087044239,
0.3354347348,
-0.3334463835,
0.1192067936,
0.7240325212,
-0.3291722536,
-0.3583667874,
-0.1950745285,
0.0135712326,
-0.1037620604,
0.0106037678,
1.2390750647,
-0.7331573963,
0.3691959083,
0.699175179,
0.5560289621,
0.6058244109,
-0.2002935112,
0.5693938136,
-0.616538465,
-0.0789567903,
0.2351887673,
0.3670901954,
0.2529092431,
-0.5083316565,
0.0613240674,
0.5503113866,
-0.2207299173,
-0.5227536559,
0.4034743905,
-0.3906540573,
-0.7866171598,
0.9056882262,
-0.0159650929,
-0.1213024035,
-0.7254117727,
0.1948809177,
0.404401958,
-0.2227595896,
0.834359169,
0.3797951043,
0.1361827403,
0.00757819,
-0.566917181,
0.4059119821,
-0.1407234371,
-0.5223581791,
0.1833537668,
0.3892608285,
0.2610225976,
0.4022842944,
0.5693891048,
-0.2424402386,
0.2928011417,
-0.0640808642,
-0.1335301846,
-0.1153706014,
-0.5910869837,
-0.5675230026,
0.2485715449,
-0.7179240584,
-0.1404358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10829v1
|
Deciphering Hate: Identifying Hateful Memes and Their Targets
| 2024-03-16T06:39:41 | 2024-03-16T06:39:41 |
Eftekhar Hossain, Omar Sharif, Mohammed Moshiul Hoque, Sarah M. Preum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Internet memes have become a powerful means for individuals to express
emotions, thoughts, and perspectives on social media. While often considered as
a source of humor and entertainment, memes can also disseminate hateful content
targeting individuals or communities. Most existing research focuses on the
negative aspects of memes in high-resource languages, overlooking the
distinctive challenges associated with low-resource languages like Bengali
(also known as Bangla). Furthermore, while previous work on Bengali memes has
focused on detecting hateful memes, there has been no work on detecting their
targeted entities. To bridge this gap and facilitate research in this arena, we
introduce a novel multimodal dataset for Bengali, BHM (Bengali Hateful Memes).
The dataset consists of 7,148 memes with Bengali as well as code-mixed
captions, tailored for two tasks: (i) detecting hateful memes, and (ii)
detecting the social entities they target (i.e., Individual, Organization,
Community, and Society). To solve these tasks, we propose DORA (Dual cO
attention fRAmework), a multimodal deep neural network that systematically
extracts the significant modality features from the memes and jointly evaluates
them with the modality-specific features to understand the context better. Our
experiments show that DORA is generalizable on other low-resource hateful meme
datasets and outperforms several state-of-the-art rivaling baselines.
|
[
-0.5515387654,
-0.7257621884,
0.067682825,
0.4192373753,
-0.4208103716,
0.3792564869,
-0.0582964532,
-0.4329584241,
0.6424608231,
0.210618481,
-0.7618892193,
-0.2275204062,
-0.964207232,
0.211760968,
-0.2685907781,
0.8789427876,
0.2895947099,
-0.1724185646,
0.135734126,
-0.4684391916,
-0.3432866037,
-0.4886159599,
-0.5651403666,
0.2434050441,
1.1746872663,
0.4107747674,
0.5594425201,
0.2268787324,
0.6034913659,
0.2096386552,
0.0891550854,
0.1747852415,
-0.6504151225,
0.1318675131,
-0.3759010434,
-0.2303046882,
-0.0544091016,
0.2083607763,
0.1503102779,
0.3166841567,
0.2237580419,
0.3654296994,
-0.0875297338,
0.4782894254,
-0.9216517806,
-0.0230934806,
-0.8423774838,
0.0412249416,
-0.414018631,
-0.2344600409,
-0.2513547242,
-0.2057193518,
-0.1170016229,
-0.3165249825,
0.252393961,
0.1302990019,
0.609308362,
0.2916694283,
-0.7696529627,
-0.6334337592,
-0.3377521634,
1.2517485619,
-0.4446209073,
0.4349863827,
0.276647985,
0.3172130883,
0.1739606261,
-0.0454537719,
-0.718698144,
0.1108789146,
-0.0624044761,
-0.1639565378,
-0.5319926143,
-0.3426935375,
0.1103124768,
0.3966608644,
-0.8503214717,
0.0158043243,
-0.5681866407,
-0.5150668621,
0.6020671129,
0.1238429174,
0.6491500139,
-0.6589204669,
-0.6349723339,
-0.0315637179,
-0.5926888585,
-0.1639329046,
0.5315187573,
0.2456622273,
-0.2743986547,
0.60227561,
0.1517588198,
0.6516333222,
-0.0950850472,
-0.2617226839,
0.2650088966,
-0.0264967177,
-0.1251144111,
-0.0833178163,
0.6589765549,
0.6473920345,
0.4066974819,
-0.0146323582,
0.0786583796,
0.5896744728,
0.4073193669,
-0.7885798812,
-0.2662159204,
-0.1246125177,
-0.5851396918,
-0.4847513139,
-0.6062396765,
-1.1773879528,
-0.7991666198,
-0.0406523049,
0.203003332,
-0.3446910977,
-0.3297691047,
-0.4487276077,
-0.2426886111,
-0.0651755333,
0.2581815422,
-0.8446828127,
-0.0406311043,
0.4748625457,
0.9489034414,
0.0571518838,
0.0389587544,
-0.4968224168,
0.081629999,
-0.2266243547,
0.6254324913,
-0.8875352144,
0.1683749259,
-0.0500653274,
-0.0134816868,
-0.0516271666,
-0.6327322721,
0.5435418487,
-0.7773932219,
-0.1974734068,
-0.0320101567,
-0.1434793472,
-0.6847658753,
0.541472137,
-0.8865694404,
0.28111884,
0.2560021579,
-0.6266649365,
0.32042256,
-0.5112897754,
-0.56339252,
-0.1082922369,
-0.1178312823,
-0.3403185308,
0.1492625773,
0.0138188563,
0.6957640052,
-0.3290943801,
-0.0092013823,
-0.5137465596,
-0.0748458803,
0.1239022687,
-0.4507175982,
0.801405251,
0.7124194503,
-0.2972011864,
0.076309219,
-0.9092934132,
-0.465933919,
0.3893029392,
-0.1661737114,
-0.8616375923,
-0.1195709556,
0.2985845208,
0.2850789726,
0.1112639084,
-0.7872692347,
-0.1311092675,
0.0312201753,
0.4194658697,
0.8827226162,
-0.1672490686,
0.2159937769,
-0.2938940227,
0.712463975,
0.3736062646,
0.2188586593,
0.021361161,
-0.5544018745,
-0.380774051,
-0.4471348524,
-0.2733550966,
0.2115488052,
-0.6644470692,
-0.0786472112,
0.0862640664,
-0.2730071545,
-0.7736780643,
0.3449252546,
0.4083167315,
0.3335079849,
0.6663632393,
-0.2402200848,
-1.0194458961,
-1.2053340673,
-0.1416099668,
0.0696187615,
0.2648976445,
0.3362120688,
0.2974147797,
-0.5566642284,
0.2750976086,
-0.2357876003,
-0.4688554406,
-0.1304761022,
0.3130268753,
0.004427263,
0.2429183424,
0.7442942858,
-1.1996197701,
-0.7061336637,
-0.3093783855,
-0.5805710554,
-0.1731030941,
-0.034442354,
-0.0319090821,
-0.0136316307,
0.184129864,
0.2977559865,
0.339302659,
0.9864704013,
-0.4962019324,
0.4935753644,
0.5044401288,
0.6659209728,
-0.9567561746,
-0.1359837353,
0.1058578715,
-0.0528604798,
-0.3670836985,
-0.2563699484,
-0.0376981944,
-0.0894260928,
-0.3889524043,
0.499917984,
-0.4264000058,
0.1377277523,
-0.0476645641,
-0.2414649427,
-0.0822286233,
0.4712793529,
-0.3033092618,
0.6940569282,
0.2133052051,
-0.3116359711,
0.5183790922,
0.2917961478,
-0.4296077192,
0.7788013816,
-0.1827853471,
0.0638432503,
-0.1069212034,
-0.2505404353,
-1.1347030401,
-0.2432294786,
0.7012581229,
-0.4051216245,
0.1618071198,
-0.437143892,
-0.4266833663,
-0.3090916574,
-0.2906623781,
1.0616378784,
0.317576617,
-0.5836808085,
0.259709239,
0.5887281895,
-0.0710034966,
-0.7043158412,
-0.7027731538,
0.2710453868,
-0.4532285035,
-0.4748759568,
-0.00764815,
-0.2725030482,
-0.2883773446,
0.0072293598,
0.1726861,
-0.3955598176,
0.0372653231,
0.4482706785,
-0.2489438355,
-0.0942811891,
0.0052373493,
0.0101041393,
0.0016350367,
-0.083444126,
0.2494906783,
0.6916937828,
0.1247398928,
-0.2825443745,
-0.2458024472,
0.6543304324,
0.8936104774,
-0.3315300941,
0.4552136064,
0.7163140774,
-0.3036542237,
-0.3282236755,
-0.6808885932,
0.0294118319,
-0.3995114863,
0.2532336116,
-0.3901658654,
-0.8921311498,
0.435157001,
0.1034166142,
-0.2980021536,
0.2185697407,
0.5654842257,
-0.0395237505,
0.9610049725,
0.529094398,
-0.3807905614,
0.4224164486,
-0.1122127697,
0.4067739844,
-0.8586885333,
-0.1746368259,
-0.2437791228,
-0.782784164,
-0.2421665788,
-0.6843939424,
0.4560782909,
-0.2816282511,
-0.0402958691,
0.2467897683,
-0.5873810053,
0.3391286135,
0.499468714,
0.0729699954,
0.1506712288,
0.3078562617,
0.0995378345,
-0.5281484127,
-0.3873620927,
-0.3787745237,
1.1253304482,
0.2525032163,
0.8370864987,
0.467695117,
0.4097695351,
0.8404388428,
0.2983346879,
-0.778414309,
0.3496731818,
-0.3710573912,
-0.8623458147,
0.0232754182,
-0.3647141457,
-1.0270609856,
0.086180605,
-0.0039530243,
-0.2824151516,
0.0496027879,
0.109773986,
-0.0299515873,
0.5378323197,
-0.4838003218,
0.9894183874,
-0.2479739785,
-0.2951906323,
-0.7671095729,
-0.6016710401,
0.4312613308,
0.0883742645,
0.6261289716,
-0.4049428999,
-0.0898983181,
0.8285040259,
0.0731833503,
1.0097279549,
-0.1013044268,
-0.0883709341,
0.4037395418,
0.3549398184,
-0.1535713375,
-0.3798206449,
-0.0701480359,
0.2894732356,
-0.2909479737,
-0.7935245037,
-0.4914999902,
0.7574599385,
-0.4601052999,
-0.0334521942,
-0.2692669034,
-0.8048044443,
-0.0257574711,
0.1813398004,
-0.0528258421,
0.5963802338,
-0.208903268,
0.2088034749,
0.4785400331,
-0.2262849212,
0.2427989244,
0.2933537662,
-0.0434045009,
-0.4312542081,
1.3476155996,
0.2145090699,
-0.0291689914,
0.3757620454,
-0.0091970349,
-0.2787393928,
-0.5460278988,
-0.5935339928,
0.1771146506,
-0.67490381,
-0.164574489,
-0.5570600033,
0.1859351695,
-0.3385470808,
-0.3692528903,
-0.2203279287,
-0.0660245046,
-0.19230178,
0.2372108549,
0.1756935865,
1.0940932035,
-0.4415138364,
0.1556700319,
-0.6727618575,
0.5116450787,
0.5758394599,
0.2741515636,
0.2865145504,
-0.6261493564,
-0.1365471631,
0.0591923967,
-0.2215944529,
-1.2163822651,
0.4546521306,
-0.0043754363,
0.2652815878,
0.83561939,
0.1211805642,
0.6019605994,
-0.3775605559,
0.5372884274,
0.4285044074,
-0.5028005242,
0.5322992802,
-0.3369962275,
-0.2825624943,
0.3614921868,
0.9306310415,
-0.6797628999,
-0.2843661606,
-0.5068579912,
-0.4946700037,
0.375448823,
0.0057684532,
0.3815481961,
-0.4676939249,
-0.0506768264,
0.2956429124,
0.4058298767,
-0.817234695,
-0.3991057873,
-0.2268398851,
-0.358431071,
-0.1436721236,
-0.8162496686,
-0.1971873939,
-0.175861001,
0.5538353324,
0.0002396046,
0.0237043649,
-0.0988708287,
-0.5081041455,
-0.3181588054,
0.1526218653,
0.5878614783,
0.4104464948,
-0.3266230524,
0.6049726009,
-0.3312787712,
-0.400488168,
0.305709064,
-0.2632451653,
0.006670204,
-0.0056572999,
0.379502058,
0.3858467042,
0.3378970921,
-0.9388151765,
0.7365404963,
0.1243991703,
0.1211012229,
-0.0966376737,
-0.288100481,
-0.1684820056,
0.5406353474,
0.2594585121,
0.2003951818,
0.3351122737,
-0.6783524752,
0.4565147758,
0.5117477179,
-0.5820279717,
-0.6758736968,
0.490426898,
0.2687163651,
-0.1881491393,
0.2737043202,
-0.4907394648,
-0.8686834574,
0.6932607293,
0.6313506961,
0.5782430172,
-0.3829784393,
0.5001787543,
0.5672211051,
0.5078007579,
0.8034512997,
0.1843554676,
-0.1527657211,
-0.7436427474,
-0.0029008496,
-0.9466987848,
-0.1924973428,
0.5105651021,
-0.5624529123,
-0.0047138026,
-0.6776390076,
0.2112778276,
0.1852101833,
-0.0710295811,
-0.5982299447,
0.4375887215,
0.5308328867,
0.4227386713,
-0.9734058976,
0.2206010818,
0.7511008978,
-0.6220550537,
-0.3832115531,
-0.2205108404,
0.4352034032,
-1.1372939348,
0.5638255477,
0.3324769735,
-0.0233331341,
0.0635147095,
-0.7456516623,
-0.5753887892,
0.4569659531,
0.042294465,
-0.4987396896,
0.3012501299,
-0.0731733441,
0.3461305797,
-0.5053504705,
0.1276561767,
0.2431994379,
0.4516890347,
0.0491461493,
-0.5117173195,
0.1486111134,
-0.4413510561,
-0.4067901373,
0.129366681,
-0.8757207394,
1.0086010695,
-0.2457682192,
-0.1036534384,
-0.3184082508,
0.4311074018,
-0.1434513927,
0.616219759,
0.7934217453,
0.6071609259,
0.5377914906,
0.4347489476,
0.6781513095,
0.1241240799,
0.1885159314,
0.9453960657,
0.1772923917,
0.4869904816,
0.5604038239,
-0.2267919183,
0.6884539127,
0.5215032101,
-0.2850829363,
0.7054799199,
0.4027030468,
-0.4126918316,
-0.3444484174,
-0.494992286,
-0.2254694551,
0.5088976026,
0.4750270844,
-0.3576745689,
-0.6074951291,
0.4078375995,
0.1046529114,
0.3666823208,
-0.4069944322,
0.6877626777,
-0.0662870556,
-0.1218317375,
0.8263993263,
-0.1809883565,
0.9528933167,
-0.4296815693,
-0.1479035616,
0.153263554,
0.1441675127,
-0.3043511808,
-0.4395673275,
0.6269663572,
0.1821085513,
-0.6346002817,
0.0591965094,
0.5675436258,
-0.5775870085,
-0.3782999516,
0.745488584,
0.3273507953,
0.3821240067,
-0.3950065672,
-0.8918554187,
0.4441452026,
0.2029439211,
0.0131820263,
0.3928930759,
0.4079333842,
-0.047384426,
0.6241764426,
0.5274448395,
-0.0067336014,
0.4409309328,
0.2357727885,
0.7351385951,
-0.550881505,
-0.2307143062,
-0.7768253684,
0.285320729,
-0.0630738661,
-0.2721082866,
0.800111711,
0.6294664145,
0.8298529387,
-0.2196816802,
0.9942537546,
-0.2866492867,
0.8638962507,
0.0383555591,
0.724388361,
-1.1349987984,
-0.2825546861,
-0.2705373764,
-0.5100582242,
-0.3356671035,
0.6632626057,
-0.390270263,
-0.2984339595,
0.322686702,
0.9061324,
-0.3552184403,
-0.1012027264,
0.6222183108,
0.502879858,
0.3698813915,
0.7091259956,
1.1483309269,
-0.4413298666,
0.8085626364,
-0.5731446147,
-0.4385534525,
-0.554066956,
-0.4890853465,
-1.1299293041,
-0.7192336321,
-0.1472141296,
-0.2827551365,
-0.025457656,
0.8996312022,
0.6119756699,
-1.0438609123,
0.0187808573,
0.3692352474,
0.51175946,
0.0912922174,
-0.2274745256,
0.1828090698,
-0.3498796821,
-0.8653587103,
0.5778262615,
0.4437793195,
-0.1940869093,
-0.2060300261,
0.0099752713,
-0.610828042,
0.2009820044,
0.732940495,
0.1900301129,
-0.7028096914,
-0.3871230185,
-0.2740701735,
-0.1935265362,
-0.0199838951,
0.8245872855,
-0.3792810738,
0.6640691161,
0.2844166756,
0.6441117525,
-0.0079327328,
0.0742135271,
0.0250052679,
-0.6840313077,
0.3827483654,
0.551907599,
0.2029479593,
0.4261481762,
-0.2513156235,
0.4883990586,
0.5831286907,
-0.3048430979,
-0.8565094471,
0.4216347337,
-1.1160666943,
-0.3612297177,
0.9008215666,
0.062875554,
-0.3166462183,
-0.4881843925,
-0.356093049,
0.2239891291,
-0.4159612358,
1.0626606941,
0.5985255241,
0.2455657721,
-0.0998055488,
-0.247429356,
0.4727195799,
0.6420328021,
-0.3184868991,
-0.1588176787,
0.7661446929,
0.2851240337,
0.5323126912,
0.5535748005,
0.0861440524,
0.3300271332,
0.0625383407,
0.1287034452,
-0.0884251595,
-0.6943212748,
-0.0914320424,
0.6090141535,
-0.5265917182,
-0.3511554301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10827v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10827v2
|
Multi-party Response Generation with Relation Disentanglement
| 2024-03-16T06:33:44 | 2024-03-23T02:19:18 |
Tianhao Dai, Chengyu Huang, Lizi Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing neural response generation models have achieved impressive
improvements for two-party conversations, which assume that utterances are
sequentially organized. However, many real-world dialogues involve multiple
interlocutors and the structure of conversational context is much more complex,
e.g. utterances from different interlocutors can occur "in parallel". Facing
this challenge, there are works trying to model the relations among utterances
or interlocutors to facilitate response generation with clearer context.
Nonetheless, these methods rely heavily on such relations and all assume that
these are given beforehand, which is impractical and hinders the generality of
such methods. In this work, we propose to automatically infer the relations via
relational thinking on subtle clues inside the conversation context without any
human label, and leverage these relations to guide the neural response
generation. Specifically, we first apply a deep graph random process to fully
consider all possible relations among utterances in the conversational context.
Then the inferred relation graphs are integrated with a variational
auto-encoder framework to train a GAN for structure-aware response generation.
Experimental results on the Ubuntu Internet Relay Chat (IRC) channel benchmark
and the most recent Movie Dialogues show that our method outperforms various
baseline models for multi-party response generation.
|
[
-0.592771709,
-0.9392349124,
0.3712299466,
0.3137017488,
-0.2243088037,
0.1962779462,
0.0117584271,
-0.3977942169,
0.3536500037,
0.1892397851,
-0.8659798503,
0.070580475,
-0.3071700335,
0.0611158684,
-0.1245990992,
1.0697270632,
0.4229040444,
0.0827449262,
-0.357632488,
-0.2252354026,
-0.2525691986,
-0.5700292587,
-0.6632216573,
-0.6452075243,
0.5956805348,
0.1692945361,
0.5491688848,
0.2527672946,
0.5133572817,
0.3838736117,
-0.1488355994,
0.2605127096,
-0.4354653656,
0.4305502176,
-0.1440052539,
-0.2589512169,
-0.4400089681,
-0.2091013342,
0.3929337859,
0.6569731832,
-0.4300110042,
0.1395775527,
0.1739191562,
0.7946568131,
-0.6258298755,
0.2278716415,
-0.8299424648,
0.2221345305,
0.0891981423,
-0.0767989978,
-0.5216764808,
-0.0988400504,
0.1982385069,
-0.2545802593,
0.3065773845,
-0.0177314393,
0.7530359626,
0.2656788528,
-0.4741927087,
-0.3347314596,
-0.9692086577,
0.0568018928,
-0.7850118876,
0.1182895079,
0.1386524886,
0.4176769853,
-0.4326450527,
-0.7904474139,
-0.7871897221,
-0.1256935298,
-0.362267971,
0.250875175,
-0.1017479897,
0.1849210709,
0.4850984812,
0.249048844,
-0.4338110983,
-0.2908027172,
0.0682154074,
0.0993830338,
0.4615752995,
0.3805423677,
0.0519172214,
-0.3850398064,
-0.4581570029,
-0.0494432785,
-0.44085446,
-0.1607263088,
0.5712578893,
0.1887116134,
-0.0409116969,
0.3227972984,
-0.1318844557,
0.5687608123,
0.550113678,
0.3345288336,
0.0579939373,
-0.6201842427,
-0.1801410615,
-0.0415182784,
1.3414168358,
0.2807544172,
0.1769948751,
-0.1198529601,
0.2057371438,
0.1975732446,
0.0990592614,
-1.0376031399,
-0.6104269624,
0.1176097244,
-0.2744485438,
-0.0773280188,
-0.1121541262,
-0.9392756224,
-0.2655390501,
-0.0284760632,
-0.0123511562,
-0.4021057785,
-0.6389268041,
-0.3713421226,
-0.0786109194,
0.1894858032,
-0.0360874198,
-0.8581753969,
0.4326411188,
0.1606905311,
0.4303020835,
0.2127589732,
-0.1473038793,
-0.7676357627,
0.3234234154,
-0.073770225,
0.7520089149,
-0.4359199107,
-0.0560791716,
-0.3365074396,
-0.3502423167,
0.0567912497,
-0.3431167305,
0.0358377136,
-0.6519186497,
0.3793679476,
-0.1570182145,
-0.5105233788,
0.196492061,
0.3441448808,
-0.5878219008,
0.3804240227,
-0.0316302553,
-1.2308505774,
0.1252191365,
-0.5637215376,
-0.3837878704,
-0.0272200368,
-0.6361804008,
-0.6701643467,
-0.0798060894,
0.6280314922,
0.3057234585,
-0.3172392845,
0.4018760622,
-0.7270858288,
0.0735529885,
0.5500541925,
-0.3970598876,
0.7441332936,
0.1855749786,
-0.3669633269,
0.1835836321,
-0.7655159831,
0.0596862361,
0.0530453548,
-0.0290079527,
-0.1203759834,
0.1169033498,
-0.3998520076,
0.5080986023,
-0.2090681642,
-0.5905322433,
-0.0528604537,
-0.6701579094,
0.6591508389,
0.6103100777,
0.4401679337,
0.5250433087,
0.0580187179,
0.3740602136,
0.639223218,
0.0786889121,
-0.2774678767,
-0.3702144921,
-0.6812714338,
0.1343730986,
0.1891926229,
0.424547106,
-1.0738031864,
0.3857204914,
-0.2328324914,
0.0600622557,
-0.4013727009,
-0.0868713558,
0.7478474975,
0.8250607252,
0.2253699601,
-0.3422579467,
-0.4108570516,
-0.9393229485,
-0.2293513715,
-0.3673723638,
-0.0974966809,
0.5393022299,
0.1645289063,
0.1876494586,
1.0401123762,
-0.6488694549,
-0.1603083014,
-0.1108640581,
0.3185586929,
-0.0920752659,
0.2669714391,
0.3704275787,
-0.9042832255,
-0.7062051892,
-0.2012692243,
-0.8990989923,
0.45131284,
-0.0756235495,
-0.1845941693,
0.025417557,
0.5757014751,
-0.522408247,
0.423050195,
0.4751388133,
-0.1995077878,
0.0361113362,
-0.1644248813,
-0.0174738001,
-1.4776858091,
-0.2407020181,
-0.1957297623,
-0.1018152609,
-0.5469024181,
-0.1111470237,
-0.1189616472,
-0.0609619915,
-0.2922528088,
0.1260731518,
-0.8099420071,
-0.101802215,
-0.0042941412,
0.2720421851,
-0.1495369822,
0.9546818137,
-0.2176101804,
0.5620313883,
0.345841676,
-0.5502827764,
0.5383012295,
0.5053355098,
-0.1263370961,
0.7410129309,
-0.6915431619,
0.676928103,
-0.4982033074,
0.5535178185,
-1.3852977753,
-0.4924696088,
0.5018433332,
-0.7303346395,
0.3096506596,
-0.2809936106,
-0.4448296726,
-0.379357636,
0.008767562,
0.3960270584,
0.2584192753,
-0.501514554,
0.7829617262,
0.4501627982,
-0.0584285259,
-0.674239099,
-0.856572926,
0.1272629052,
-0.1907228976,
-0.8203667402,
0.1126627773,
-0.3464615047,
-0.1045776531,
0.1927396357,
0.1028659716,
-0.2793008685,
-0.2498125583,
0.3684733808,
0.0533236898,
0.0190741476,
0.1805060655,
0.064062573,
0.0685659349,
0.2915121019,
0.0811999515,
0.5254390836,
-0.2407716662,
-0.3964542747,
-0.3512763083,
0.5648275018,
0.4131121039,
-0.37650913,
0.6688333154,
0.603644073,
-0.1219752058,
-0.1369864047,
-0.3048067689,
-0.5450619459,
-0.5206115246,
0.4671008289,
-0.6640891433,
-0.7415485382,
0.8561784029,
-0.1679092646,
-0.1738591045,
-0.1367535293,
0.4947703481,
-0.1742882729,
1.184124589,
0.3659829199,
-0.0003731806,
0.4398221672,
-0.1339050233,
0.469628036,
-1.0137076378,
-0.2871353924,
-0.1183279008,
-0.5882154703,
-0.6364910603,
-0.1275157183,
0.3864161968,
0.0427357741,
-0.241749391,
0.3523529768,
-0.5282415748,
0.5173531175,
0.3339787722,
0.2243780941,
0.3248506784,
-0.0022369409,
-0.1398979127,
-0.136557132,
-0.8675804138,
0.0838885531,
0.8186014295,
0.1302761883,
0.7989042997,
0.2275651544,
0.8044584394,
-0.263302505,
0.4771817327,
-0.5635457635,
0.5354225039,
0.2989752889,
-0.5956543088,
-0.3624137342,
-0.8934653401,
-1.0370850563,
0.2380921096,
-0.109311685,
-0.7418670654,
0.2903908193,
0.2217571437,
-0.5662443042,
0.1079267859,
-0.6834291816,
0.4650859833,
0.2335932404,
-0.276402086,
0.0752721429,
-1.1407955885,
0.663746655,
0.3538384736,
-0.0483146496,
-0.1518787593,
0.5155982375,
0.4190215766,
-0.3322395682,
0.7812303901,
-0.1457733214,
0.21503824,
0.4588878751,
0.2363663316,
0.6149867177,
0.4951457381,
0.2480543703,
-0.3723643422,
-0.4187653363,
-0.0004585848,
-0.7646201849,
0.7756989598,
-0.7605673075,
-0.3751446307,
-0.0735536814,
-0.6314822435,
-0.4727166295,
-0.0381012633,
0.4421811104,
0.3547181785,
-0.3263156116,
0.0652712956,
0.6414139271,
-0.0131401364,
0.7799834013,
0.3632675707,
-0.1225023717,
-0.6712815166,
0.6629246473,
-0.0954343975,
0.2706919611,
0.3771186769,
0.0147568956,
-0.3418767452,
-0.0241830088,
-0.5613789558,
0.2108674198,
-0.425845325,
-0.3834331036,
-0.8048706055,
-0.297783047,
-0.2943392396,
0.57725811,
-0.416408658,
-0.2103138119,
-0.1149332747,
-0.2209157348,
0.1838463992,
0.5742102861,
0.04601961,
0.2710673511,
-0.7254454494,
0.6325156689,
0.8327149153,
0.241607964,
0.2133274823,
-0.1856792867,
0.0988148972,
0.3322864771,
-0.4699467719,
-1.1355414391,
0.3256748319,
0.3441055417,
0.3645433486,
0.2653710842,
0.4258266389,
0.76498878,
-0.650072217,
0.4822576642,
0.5480952859,
-0.7675388455,
0.5984963179,
-0.3103108108,
0.207082659,
0.3270651698,
0.1033917442,
-0.2267654538,
-0.4974746704,
-0.8570448756,
-0.9150071144,
0.7853674889,
0.5454781055,
0.3552730978,
-0.3181863427,
0.261310488,
-0.4461002052,
0.432007879,
-0.8508803844,
-0.5264214277,
-0.0916196182,
0.0165244061,
0.298199892,
-0.1304347366,
-0.5923662782,
-0.0629271939,
0.0871236548,
-0.2956135273,
0.5845265388,
0.249790743,
0.1234550476,
-0.4136687815,
0.2219756395,
0.425170958,
0.6396067739,
-0.16833134,
0.1773638725,
-0.0830338001,
0.0106469812,
0.320767194,
0.1703003496,
0.1855137795,
0.0384688713,
-0.0078734355,
0.8883351088,
-0.1654581428,
0.0010509529,
0.6180663705,
-0.5719408989,
-0.180930838,
-0.1492852569,
-0.0610087886,
0.6491327882,
0.3810486197,
0.094336763,
0.2417216152,
0.3266660571,
-0.629468441,
0.4833305478,
0.5030040145,
-0.3809916675,
-0.328925848,
0.7548865676,
0.2988299131,
-0.49209705,
1.009553194,
-0.4409022033,
-0.2400918007,
0.5908858776,
0.5608158112,
1.0929336548,
-0.3367186189,
0.3096097112,
0.6027286649,
-0.0769292191,
0.3624259233,
0.0448771045,
-0.2027275264,
-0.8553438187,
-0.553745091,
-0.3609884679,
-0.3279884458,
0.2240850478,
-0.9441241622,
-0.1825586557,
-0.4603836834,
-0.3960134387,
0.0756215975,
-0.4214746058,
-0.6460735798,
-0.0904809013,
0.1515970528,
0.2797047794,
-0.5880636573,
0.869110465,
0.4405300915,
-0.581738174,
-0.9766737223,
0.28191185,
-0.3899301887,
-0.374723345,
0.6962394714,
0.0128802406,
-0.3213023543,
0.0159164276,
-0.5277288556,
-0.608648479,
0.8346303701,
0.779291153,
-0.7465324402,
-0.2648729384,
0.1683163941,
0.5192716122,
-0.3960007727,
0.5337978601,
0.1498603076,
-0.0503230207,
0.3937136829,
-0.7610942125,
0.1453683972,
-0.3090423048,
0.2952179313,
0.379126817,
-0.8577966094,
0.9599091411,
-0.18258138,
-0.3157102764,
-0.3169268668,
0.98888129,
0.2389685512,
0.1276428103,
0.6209905744,
0.4304351211,
0.4099909961,
0.0521167628,
0.6651237607,
-0.4123002887,
0.2276354134,
1.8697742224,
-0.2180646658,
0.7382526398,
0.6882352829,
-0.1334328204,
0.7245125771,
0.3097047806,
0.3599026501,
0.6541401148,
0.3166437745,
-0.3322911263,
-0.1968968362,
0.0649231598,
-0.4225358367,
0.3294435143,
0.5335941911,
-0.2977507412,
-0.3676033914,
-0.1407379061,
-0.2411001772,
0.2153978348,
0.2228806466,
1.1696021557,
0.2070973217,
-0.8526725769,
0.5157059431,
-0.3677178919,
0.4546322227,
-0.5258328915,
-0.2325769067,
-0.5458234549,
0.386733681,
-0.1711079776,
-0.7257609963,
0.2974332869,
-0.2842326462,
-0.2938595116,
0.0868357718,
0.4908633232,
-0.8355938196,
-0.0465124473,
0.5487989187,
0.5102360249,
-0.1087064594,
-0.0426105671,
-0.7891446948,
-0.2607215941,
-0.0267527495,
-0.3691835403,
0.5118985176,
0.7216843963,
0.2131821364,
0.6201978922,
0.4571148455,
-0.2958425283,
0.1175641567,
0.2047947049,
1.1557768583,
-0.211419493,
-0.5704331398,
-0.9238349199,
0.6090853214,
-0.3977364302,
-0.1903340816,
0.5734030008,
0.1572082639,
0.8086897135,
-0.0256453417,
0.5049872994,
-0.1104787886,
0.1375641823,
-0.134183839,
0.5154711008,
-0.0247726757,
0.2001674622,
-0.3759396672,
-0.8599786758,
0.0276819617,
0.6432721615,
0.129555881,
0.0304129831,
0.5793270469,
0.7308139801,
-0.0814485997,
-0.1065408364,
0.1405322105,
0.1306753606,
0.6022002101,
0.9512398243,
1.020296216,
-0.5047513247,
0.9568824172,
-0.2692494988,
-0.0023632117,
0.1276630014,
-0.9015939832,
-1.120390296,
-0.6358004808,
-0.3521369994,
-0.4595893025,
-0.1109015793,
0.6263232827,
0.7331460714,
-0.6033254266,
-0.2009187192,
-0.6410403252,
-0.0287363641,
-0.1328742951,
-0.293217063,
0.1401797682,
-0.3346384168,
-0.7071810961,
0.312487483,
0.2577696741,
0.0729499534,
-0.3635923266,
-0.1286675781,
-0.4464520812,
0.0690886676,
0.3826023936,
0.1034801006,
-0.5106128454,
-0.1705365032,
-0.1397878379,
-0.1360104829,
0.2705121338,
0.7381978035,
-0.7800747156,
0.646094501,
0.5562956929,
0.4138785005,
0.7836421132,
0.0389583856,
0.7954879999,
-1.3200705051,
0.2628726661,
0.4866067469,
0.0475713313,
0.4236823022,
-0.5134593248,
0.380374223,
0.0443568453,
-0.5802348852,
-0.745696485,
0.7569971681,
-0.6646081209,
-0.1855860353,
0.7428795695,
-0.4381794035,
-0.2020182461,
0.0393376537,
-0.0846491754,
0.5344048142,
-0.4675917625,
0.6809900999,
0.5779991746,
-0.6294765472,
-0.2478027344,
-0.0900053158,
0.6104241014,
0.3218396902,
-0.8100101948,
0.3105091155,
0.464083761,
0.1821348071,
0.4427591562,
0.993203938,
0.0991226286,
-0.0198511966,
0.2110440582,
-0.1236111447,
-0.0695613474,
-0.4125601947,
0.0796158984,
0.3351486623,
-0.1891379505,
-0.3877261579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10822v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10822v3
|
Can Large Language Models abstract Medical Coded Language?
| 2024-03-16T06:18:15 | 2024-06-06T21:58:49 |
Simon A. Lee, Timothy Lindsey
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become a pivotal research area, potentially
making beneficial contributions in fields like healthcare where they can
streamline automated billing and decision support. However, the frequent use of
specialized coded languages like ICD-10, which are regularly updated and
deviate from natural language formats, presents potential challenges for LLMs
in creating accurate and meaningful latent representations. This raises
concerns among healthcare professionals about potential inaccuracies or
``hallucinations" that could result in the direct impact of a patient.
Therefore, this study evaluates whether large language models (LLMs) are aware
of medical code ontologies and can accurately generate names from these codes.
We assess the capabilities and limitations of both general and
biomedical-specific generative models, such as GPT, LLaMA-2, and Meditron,
focusing on their proficiency with domain-specific terminologies. While the
results indicate that LLMs struggle with coded language, we offer insights on
how to adapt these models to reason more effectively.
|
[
-0.0896903872,
-0.5393345356,
1.191415906,
0.0757926702,
-0.2359621972,
0.0406300314,
-0.3386771083,
-0.7339553237,
0.0903828591,
0.7586999536,
-0.1572054178,
-0.649800539,
-0.8055673838,
0.4368081093,
-0.4203631282,
0.8188683391,
-0.1301730424,
0.3747364581,
-0.0653132498,
-0.1609677821,
-0.3739132583,
-1.0141029358,
-0.501511097,
-0.4562924206,
0.394359529,
-0.1328331977,
0.7150389552,
0.5379128456,
0.7869587541,
0.2133506685,
-0.1538721919,
0.06740655,
-0.1000283435,
0.0682692081,
-0.1410223693,
-0.4532081485,
-0.6271947622,
-0.3075014949,
0.5323088765,
1.0666806698,
-0.2813225091,
-0.0996828824,
-0.381280005,
0.4144416451,
-0.2430217117,
0.211948365,
-0.707177341,
0.2390148193,
0.1154616401,
-0.1579337865,
-0.5385364294,
-0.2788298726,
0.0888235942,
-0.4533468485,
-0.0524626784,
-0.0617094263,
0.7040906549,
0.3617301583,
-0.2915538251,
-0.6922013164,
-0.8156453967,
0.4462732673,
-0.9672669172,
0.2903502285,
0.493699491,
0.3744721711,
-0.2050166279,
-0.8958329558,
-0.4958100915,
-0.4778124988,
-0.1238970682,
-0.2287587523,
-0.3351203203,
0.1429580748,
0.6100255847,
0.4358866811,
-0.5413665771,
0.5065640211,
-0.4638799727,
0.0057714381,
0.5670078397,
0.4343559146,
0.6407487392,
-0.0441221781,
-0.1005217358,
0.3794561327,
-0.8683675528,
-0.3560180664,
-0.0468463823,
0.0852115825,
-0.4566763937,
0.7486153841,
0.0714927539,
0.7440962791,
-0.1868865043,
-0.3616734445,
0.2752388418,
0.0328342617,
-0.464278549,
0.0958399996,
0.5339308381,
0.177020058,
0.3858896792,
-0.6180945635,
-0.3578101695,
0.3574846089,
0.5686461926,
-0.6348432302,
-0.4501479864,
0.5295126438,
-0.550159812,
-0.3713964522,
-0.1846978664,
-0.3576648533,
-0.6245379448,
-0.3717713952,
0.231403023,
-0.3333047032,
-0.0455885455,
0.4511576593,
0.1868130416,
0.1275767982,
0.4346217811,
-0.7899680138,
0.1654049903,
0.5691217184,
0.696457684,
-0.1701797992,
0.0072943969,
-0.2106487602,
0.0413808338,
-0.6609199047,
0.8529959321,
-0.7055183053,
-0.4711044729,
-0.0377489738,
0.0377334952,
0.0558088347,
-0.7833294272,
0.2748934925,
-0.5058416128,
-0.1276970953,
-0.0633645132,
-0.6026052833,
-0.0251930039,
0.3028690815,
-0.6094079614,
0.2358797342,
0.3072177172,
-0.5798745155,
0.1329641044,
-0.4724273682,
-0.5039589405,
0.1897010952,
-0.7819436193,
-0.3678846359,
0.3785382509,
-0.0567589216,
0.4824708104,
-0.5909758806,
0.5587405562,
0.0465890244,
-0.0960782915,
0.699059248,
-0.2483633757,
0.5199546814,
0.2408564538,
-0.1295279264,
0.1614720523,
-0.8801092505,
0.0386159681,
0.2047570646,
-0.4624970555,
-0.1942187846,
-0.0541505329,
0.0494165346,
0.3118448555,
-0.1515500396,
-0.277623713,
0.4648907185,
-0.4380239248,
0.6285178661,
0.6160156131,
-0.0423552282,
0.1049791351,
-0.4547585249,
0.829134047,
0.0735275149,
-0.2567376792,
-0.3795711398,
-0.5856378675,
-0.5176410675,
-0.1739191562,
0.4016181529,
0.2503292561,
-0.779769659,
0.3221037686,
-0.2915188074,
-0.5099598169,
-0.2250138074,
-0.0824411958,
0.4970857203,
0.4276158214,
0.1863918155,
-0.1219924092,
-0.4391790926,
-0.7112876773,
-0.0026290405,
-0.1327624172,
-0.1504511386,
0.4738706946,
0.6200063229,
-0.7059586048,
0.4950798452,
-0.5030107498,
-0.2672841251,
-0.2647761703,
-0.0490509346,
0.0958310515,
0.2787077725,
0.5601627827,
-0.6735116243,
-0.1528563946,
0.1517187953,
-0.9901826978,
-0.1944732964,
-0.3365015686,
0.3230768144,
0.225272119,
0.4281541109,
-0.441342324,
0.3898197412,
0.8097217679,
-0.4765766561,
0.7859877348,
-0.6832033396,
-0.0503052473,
-0.9899874926,
0.2104525566,
-0.093802236,
-0.0874498785,
-0.8375524282,
0.2558603287,
0.2195883244,
-0.0873099118,
-0.3147099912,
0.6961295605,
-0.5024299026,
-0.1668063551,
-0.3481386304,
-0.1461650282,
-0.067237474,
0.0934437662,
0.3435602784,
0.7562384009,
0.6874566674,
-0.6945663095,
0.2134557962,
0.3351343274,
-0.6851163507,
0.1890681684,
-0.8569101095,
0.0321476497,
-0.1195082739,
0.2864286602,
-0.4301956892,
-0.5764632225,
-0.0004247334,
-0.2813487649,
0.2904593349,
-0.035331022,
-0.6384481192,
-0.4057858288,
0.3291502297,
0.6341956854,
0.7332454324,
-0.4958875775,
0.4255875349,
0.614407599,
-0.1250256449,
-0.0385056511,
-0.9783943295,
0.3185389638,
-0.098004885,
-0.3752707839,
0.4979757965,
0.0604526661,
-0.5080788136,
-0.3127007782,
0.0436933525,
-0.1525328606,
0.0215414222,
0.4585972726,
0.2834601104,
-0.1864106357,
0.5623915792,
-0.1196261272,
-0.0708073452,
0.2243007123,
-0.1345656365,
0.7386453748,
0.1477303058,
-0.4778667986,
-0.2079991847,
0.3480954766,
0.8045030832,
-0.2079294473,
0.7064611316,
-0.0763753653,
-0.7647600174,
-0.1665523499,
-0.544003427,
-0.1557386518,
-0.3803923726,
0.5409784913,
-0.3066541851,
-0.9607951045,
0.8409056664,
-0.0648161098,
-0.2297879755,
0.4307546616,
0.9572725296,
0.2016675025,
1.1280151606,
0.5649021268,
0.2504789531,
-0.2661649585,
-0.1138963848,
0.257832706,
-0.8941830397,
-0.4254129529,
-0.6404382586,
0.1191336364,
-0.5522316098,
-0.5256645679,
0.4421578646,
-0.1811060905,
-0.2841005921,
-0.0048666573,
-0.5064684749,
0.1430825591,
-0.0498656072,
0.0004514549,
0.3983079791,
0.1739587784,
-0.1148384884,
0.0575214252,
-0.5289146304,
-0.8060288429,
1.0989472866,
0.5268186331,
1.0842819214,
0.1138557717,
0.3783392012,
0.2675050795,
0.3539773822,
-0.710365355,
0.2736449242,
-0.400975883,
-0.4362416863,
0.1435985565,
-0.4070172012,
-0.9937668443,
-0.0316521376,
-0.153723523,
-0.7719081044,
0.1644806564,
0.0792034045,
-0.4959855676,
0.4140358269,
-0.3298379779,
0.6048529148,
-0.3821210265,
0.3734295368,
0.0162381027,
-0.4516015053,
0.4059845507,
-0.6764371395,
0.3289025724,
-0.1631954908,
-0.0548798405,
0.6155203581,
-0.6399564147,
0.8017758131,
0.2379064113,
-0.530811131,
0.0278400127,
0.0230914131,
0.4053514302,
0.022227997,
-0.0697175339,
0.5301479101,
-0.0369312167,
-0.155874759,
-0.4261682034,
0.7378872037,
-0.7216544151,
-0.5881825686,
-0.4257615507,
-0.4908687174,
-0.3250411153,
0.0275118575,
0.3352715969,
0.5296287537,
0.048551403,
-0.0993653759,
0.6593033075,
-0.711469233,
0.0334897004,
0.4904849231,
-0.4601161182,
-0.1541846991,
0.5533826947,
0.1597202122,
0.409380734,
0.1559866965,
0.1036141887,
-0.0084217628,
-0.7548826933,
-0.5731626153,
0.430116713,
-0.8097472191,
-0.1967896968,
-0.9076521397,
-0.3912216425,
-0.3170360923,
-0.3015488684,
-0.1048474237,
-0.2965645492,
-0.2666518092,
0.0028799272,
0.386439383,
0.8994067907,
0.3678064942,
0.1755048335,
-1.0471082926,
0.5429291725,
0.0194854364,
0.6136585474,
-0.023091685,
-0.633153975,
-0.0489219613,
0.000062414,
0.1815664619,
-0.9274249673,
0.4594447315,
-0.1336163878,
0.5957354903,
0.4316858947,
-0.0764812529,
0.4431765974,
-0.7931835055,
0.8488690853,
0.4193798006,
-0.7150916457,
0.4084818363,
-0.2424414903,
0.3002487123,
0.0534511916,
0.3743602335,
-0.5443612933,
-0.3038166165,
-0.4936213195,
-0.4476671815,
0.4246541262,
0.0309334528,
0.362996608,
-0.3892222941,
0.5383452177,
0.2183187753,
0.0850765407,
-0.6429308057,
-0.2284753919,
0.2276107222,
-0.1736458391,
0.2012067884,
-0.4093913734,
-0.0803619847,
0.0367220566,
0.2059873194,
-0.101994887,
0.5523119569,
0.1394379586,
0.1772445142,
-0.1175687537,
0.3826047778,
0.8160459995,
0.9416337013,
0.2163808048,
0.2289873064,
0.0369842462,
-0.5265091658,
0.2169679105,
-0.1248053089,
0.0168201402,
-0.0078553585,
0.4739430845,
0.6267182827,
0.0491129532,
-1.2389777899,
0.3638557792,
0.0123940483,
-0.2375636101,
-0.4463275373,
0.0169513579,
0.0977253541,
0.2491545975,
0.1444555521,
0.043857947,
-0.0449180193,
-0.6180820465,
-0.1060459092,
0.4278752804,
-0.1844592839,
-0.2887454629,
0.7949627042,
-0.0597896986,
-0.3515724242,
0.5567074418,
-0.0088289874,
-0.4691881537,
0.8784722686,
0.7977259755,
0.7368856072,
-0.0847683921,
-0.1039853022,
0.0747940466,
0.1149860844,
-0.3461662233,
0.2772436142,
0.4338048398,
-0.8404868841,
-0.6655906439,
-0.752677381,
-0.333155483,
0.3339630663,
-0.5446462035,
0.1840212792,
-0.6673076153,
-0.4278443456,
0.3150090575,
-0.5191240311,
-0.6494137645,
0.3422495127,
0.4162203074,
0.7395498157,
-0.565943718,
1.032707572,
1.0135908127,
-0.4137431681,
-1.002812624,
-0.1257877052,
-0.2868052423,
-0.8114634752,
0.8805366158,
-0.0467506163,
0.0848068744,
-0.199388653,
-0.3748961687,
-0.6371920109,
0.7786274552,
0.3085106313,
-0.7597216964,
-0.4786126316,
0.2570761144,
0.77917099,
-0.5485135913,
-0.0235349201,
0.4733087122,
0.339148134,
0.0376630835,
-1.1629291773,
0.1229637414,
-0.2617860734,
0.2113899142,
0.0291105006,
-0.2289455086,
0.9456105828,
-0.6249809861,
-0.1427883953,
0.2010875493,
0.0598643087,
0.3766909242,
0.1108201221,
0.0098832557,
0.4513738751,
0.7321725488,
-0.0381109081,
1.4014561176,
-0.5000266433,
0.2190102786,
0.9180713296,
-0.5628919601,
0.5491374731,
0.256313771,
-0.3226030171,
0.4179923832,
0.2699274719,
-0.1999135017,
0.2824226618,
0.4163112938,
-0.199268952,
-0.4399754405,
0.1160301417,
-0.5864973068,
0.4112337232,
0.6350368857,
-0.9113724232,
0.0190238561,
0.2056973428,
0.0536259674,
0.1256351322,
-0.4875304103,
0.778286159,
0.3970403373,
-0.5664539337,
0.6484622955,
0.399489522,
0.427377969,
-0.4226329327,
-0.1829381734,
-0.0589501783,
0.150200665,
-0.2575110793,
-0.4696377516,
0.3090286851,
0.2634677887,
-0.227864027,
0.1484730393,
0.5866452456,
-0.2286885977,
-0.7260383368,
0.1024636999,
0.3935617208,
0.2730375528,
0.0277607348,
-0.3610022664,
0.295517534,
0.0349825844,
0.093579866,
0.3955940306,
0.2794870436,
-0.2576456964,
0.846786201,
0.4803662896,
0.5864269137,
-0.0452718586,
0.2380290926,
0.8364488482,
-0.6934659481,
-0.4385404885,
-0.8349017501,
0.1945458502,
0.3267151415,
-0.1704575866,
0.3886040449,
0.2912760377,
0.6727079749,
-0.3845689595,
0.9641805291,
0.2291003764,
0.3422047496,
-0.7788071632,
0.9451144934,
-0.3991590142,
0.5557255745,
-0.1411361694,
-0.621547699,
-0.7650532722,
0.7682198882,
-0.4471940994,
0.2468080521,
0.6904361844,
0.528760612,
0.2075212598,
-0.0604658052,
0.6808968782,
0.4197125137,
0.4414054155,
0.6536952853,
0.6988635659,
-0.1608380079,
0.1579326987,
0.0203517731,
0.05921828,
-0.3169921935,
-0.7075212598,
-0.9758144021,
-0.3034777045,
-0.5245440602,
-0.3508345783,
0.1613200307,
1.0048116446,
0.4736440778,
-0.8124803305,
0.1882428676,
-0.0377045721,
-0.2033096999,
0.147189334,
-0.0766042024,
0.6550835967,
-0.2481719553,
-0.372249037,
0.1166387647,
0.4786593616,
0.3329998255,
-0.3376777768,
-0.2031290084,
0.4504872561,
0.1294846535,
0.6293796897,
0.0767798349,
-1.107609868,
-0.2289761603,
0.0027596797,
-0.4464772642,
0.1245313585,
0.9751960039,
-0.8286611438,
0.431619823,
0.0863003507,
0.6055848002,
-0.1205847189,
0.0097041875,
0.3049240112,
-0.1715872288,
-0.0625282377,
0.3945139945,
0.6028667688,
0.2193601429,
-0.3047487736,
0.3681926131,
0.0667089373,
-0.524748683,
-0.8931736946,
0.2309913635,
-0.7519125938,
-0.4613134861,
1.4988969564,
-0.2894396484,
0.1524897069,
-0.3033500612,
-0.1633294523,
-0.0739652142,
0.1470028907,
0.8620360494,
0.402361393,
-0.1473848522,
-0.1040824503,
-0.6449779868,
0.5416802168,
0.1849150807,
-0.9815529585,
0.0867705643,
0.6591680646,
0.2481942922,
0.2269876003,
0.7527555823,
-0.4708638489,
0.3694659173,
-0.0345871672,
0.1511257291,
-0.0389212668,
-0.1784562916,
-0.5125129819,
0.1119397059,
0.436272651,
0.4287242889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10799v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10799v3
|
Efficient Pruning of Large Language Model with Adaptive Estimation Fusion
| 2024-03-16T04:12:50 | 2024-05-15T02:20:54 |
Jun Liu, Chao Wu, Changdi Yang, Hao Tang, Zhenglun Kong, Geng Yuan, Wei Niu, Dong Huang, Yanzhi Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become crucial for many generative
downstream tasks, leading to an inevitable trend and significant challenge to
deploy them efficiently on resource-constrained devices. Structured pruning is
a widely used method to address this challenge. However, when dealing with the
complex structure of the multiple decoder layers, general methods often employ
common estimation approaches for pruning. These approaches lead to a decline in
accuracy for specific downstream tasks. In this paper, we introduce a simple
yet efficient method that adaptively models the importance of each
substructure. Meanwhile, it can adaptively fuse coarse-grained and finegrained
estimations based on the results from complex and multilayer structures. All
aspects of our design seamlessly integrate into the endto-end pruning
framework. Our experimental results, compared with state-of-the-art methods on
mainstream datasets, demonstrate average accuracy improvements of 1.1%, 1.02%,
2.0%, and 1.2% for LLaMa-7B,Vicuna-7B, Baichuan-7B, and Bloom-7b1,
respectively.
|
[
-0.1809795201,
-0.9177142978,
0.4378749728,
0.3416480124,
-0.5028112531,
0.0697090551,
-0.4918868542,
-0.1448147595,
0.0488649011,
0.2193277478,
-0.5294271708,
-0.7238540053,
-0.407673806,
-0.1169954166,
-0.2062688619,
0.5870482326,
0.1067499518,
-0.170911327,
0.162200883,
-0.0189102646,
-0.6114200354,
-0.2533139288,
-0.3330149353,
-0.2098937333,
0.4631896317,
0.3610120416,
0.517526865,
0.6955326796,
0.2074878961,
0.428029716,
-0.3791907132,
0.5928477049,
-0.3977640271,
0.1785235703,
-0.1026453674,
-0.3583874702,
-0.5471270084,
-0.409309864,
0.8434284329,
0.7499930263,
-0.3691454828,
0.205388546,
0.2483772635,
0.6476399899,
-0.7135114074,
0.0696539357,
-0.8313542604,
-0.0127603384,
-0.2871736586,
-0.2660213709,
-0.6063246727,
-0.2209931612,
-0.1576846987,
-0.4670665562,
0.2913989425,
-0.0385740921,
0.6929610372,
0.3130123019,
-0.2918511033,
-0.0066069197,
-0.8946513534,
1.0537889004,
-0.8438422084,
0.403511703,
0.1464170218,
0.3505936563,
-0.4947961271,
-0.5608806014,
-0.2662717104,
-0.0714867935,
0.0834136084,
0.3701993525,
-0.1929973364,
0.188980341,
-0.091615364,
0.3441005945,
-0.4390768111,
0.4431825876,
-0.2889814973,
-0.3967880309,
0.6042645574,
0.0086482102,
0.1427533925,
-0.0215776972,
-0.37872082,
-0.0672608092,
-0.7064606547,
-0.2825970054,
0.4185426831,
0.2627883255,
-0.0169547778,
0.3554654419,
-0.1378343552,
1.0684238672,
0.075735949,
-0.4498104751,
0.2560691535,
-0.4420425296,
-0.4757825136,
0.0561093055,
0.7399382591,
0.2076043487,
0.1797167808,
-0.1224344745,
-0.1578814685,
0.0420804508,
0.052103024,
-0.47675246,
-0.4175447822,
0.4899083078,
-0.328987509,
-0.074153319,
-0.1019208282,
-0.6735380888,
-0.3400498331,
-0.0220346842,
0.1242087334,
-0.4047760963,
-0.4099102616,
0.2158432603,
0.0868533328,
0.3542126417,
0.4291045666,
-0.7952670455,
0.0750029385,
0.7143393159,
0.9843191504,
0.0102405399,
-0.2665257752,
-0.6162199378,
0.3084037304,
-0.371017158,
0.888800621,
-0.3084672987,
-0.1572659016,
-0.2438687235,
0.0034162621,
-0.2757383883,
-0.8034254909,
0.9473274946,
-0.3525792062,
-0.2506401241,
0.1197928414,
-0.4041797817,
-0.2671875954,
0.3501455784,
-0.6082668304,
0.8179693818,
0.1069190577,
-0.565293014,
-0.0364802256,
-0.1530089229,
-0.5447773933,
0.0058603212,
0.0996462479,
-0.7163799405,
0.469858855,
0.5589568019,
0.5695841312,
-0.4310726225,
0.4596142471,
-0.4267413318,
-0.3707125783,
0.0488457382,
-0.5844023228,
0.609175086,
0.2362046391,
-0.0652435049,
0.5240724683,
-0.8304687142,
-0.0427457206,
0.0225738082,
-0.5778122544,
-0.327796042,
0.318330884,
0.0110752396,
0.1022750363,
-0.0002720155,
-0.5792620182,
0.2334284633,
-0.499245882,
0.5623446107,
0.9431834817,
0.0375252627,
0.4541443884,
-0.3056556582,
0.4204534888,
0.2434795648,
0.0905051529,
-0.238840133,
-0.172089681,
-0.6766411066,
-0.4264366031,
0.3672728837,
0.3855188191,
-0.5544933081,
0.6333383322,
-0.6267473698,
-0.7649878263,
-0.5132404566,
0.3143113554,
0.3458753228,
0.3567738533,
0.3917055428,
-0.2234903276,
-0.4674723446,
-0.8594198823,
-0.2494343817,
-0.0601744615,
-0.3754826486,
0.1745008975,
0.0072486601,
0.1008100361,
0.7179509997,
-0.6076520681,
-0.5026763082,
-0.3711779118,
-0.0889844596,
0.2999429107,
0.487912029,
0.3160635829,
-0.7145491242,
-0.3746150434,
0.2733040154,
-0.4621790946,
-0.1492987871,
-0.3400837779,
-0.0667440072,
-0.049345959,
0.2411991209,
-0.5538622737,
-0.0986182913,
0.900000155,
-0.1518645138,
0.6398268938,
-0.1158279255,
-0.2944387496,
-1.1542263031,
-0.1993525922,
0.3083740175,
-0.2125511765,
-0.8517028093,
0.1102118641,
0.2040790021,
0.2146390229,
-0.5244181752,
0.2951454818,
-0.8586879969,
-0.2393971384,
-0.2695102692,
0.1494195163,
0.0965949371,
0.6692060232,
-0.0721809715,
0.5831469297,
0.539121151,
-0.5336635709,
0.4941210747,
-0.0516113825,
-0.7598782778,
0.101158537,
-0.6007271409,
0.0825838149,
-0.1730989516,
0.3162838817,
-0.960655272,
-0.1588647068,
0.3072462976,
-0.1130298823,
0.2408189327,
-0.3332490325,
-0.2702314556,
-0.0869506001,
-0.4127692878,
0.3055537641,
0.366409868,
-0.5349028111,
1.0381325483,
0.5285324454,
-0.2799964249,
-0.274235785,
-0.5206138492,
0.0192286652,
-0.4076897502,
-0.8983622193,
0.6232813597,
0.0470374972,
0.0500580072,
-0.1846394986,
-0.3616704047,
-0.1726041883,
0.2789177895,
0.1651912779,
0.194691062,
-0.376334697,
-0.1688490063,
0.1889378279,
-0.02774195,
-0.1984033138,
-0.1503490508,
0.8089570403,
0.1737982482,
-0.4375271499,
-0.1973035336,
0.1935733259,
0.6017409563,
-0.4116947651,
0.8085283637,
0.6829789877,
-0.2929698527,
-0.4305016696,
-0.639685452,
0.1771732271,
-0.524287343,
0.71505934,
-0.5118669868,
-0.7944694757,
0.7800835967,
-0.2019652277,
0.2348509282,
0.238335073,
0.6092358828,
0.0519379079,
1.0467436314,
0.4623268843,
-0.1286406964,
0.6192439198,
-0.0819377899,
0.2189599574,
-1.1627937555,
-0.1718273312,
-0.4340988696,
-0.2654746473,
-0.4256007671,
-0.5728452206,
0.3433182836,
0.2706472278,
0.0359666049,
0.2707404196,
-0.5152255893,
0.2934881449,
0.3944594264,
0.271584481,
0.2920753956,
0.2406349331,
0.2520948648,
0.2975113988,
-0.8219231963,
-0.1485041678,
0.592589736,
0.6332562566,
0.9220407009,
0.376872927,
0.4470069706,
-0.2029803246,
0.3222061694,
-0.8631142974,
0.4887629747,
-0.339284122,
-0.1065979823,
-0.3349397182,
-0.6098887324,
-0.6548365355,
0.6377622485,
0.0757018775,
-0.532235682,
0.3485798538,
0.3405144513,
-0.4513836503,
0.3370956481,
-0.9008139372,
0.5723984838,
-0.091296792,
-0.2716210783,
-0.1202142984,
-0.3261137605,
0.490373522,
-0.1771812588,
0.2610268891,
-0.3298110664,
0.0442196801,
0.8028791547,
-0.3578429818,
0.7986435294,
-0.2390839309,
-0.2481309772,
0.3170656264,
0.0031620078,
0.7554071546,
-0.4178881645,
-0.2251021415,
0.0829730928,
-0.1771344393,
-0.452753216,
-0.6334380507,
0.7143537402,
-0.6481618881,
-0.6774392128,
-0.1123638824,
-0.6340402961,
-0.1945848316,
-0.0104714241,
0.0698729455,
0.5031148195,
0.1179730445,
0.4305095077,
0.4018042982,
-0.3793867528,
0.5703750253,
0.3382558525,
0.2143707275,
-0.4318920672,
1.0668034554,
0.2467481345,
0.4026364386,
0.3934850097,
0.368452251,
-0.1883461773,
-1.089954257,
-0.504386425,
0.1845225096,
-0.5940623879,
-0.5387081504,
-0.572299242,
-0.2652311623,
-0.4158884585,
-0.0320351981,
-0.3394331038,
-0.0638474002,
-0.096079424,
-0.1771012992,
0.1819706559,
0.1282229573,
0.4451853931,
0.6252660751,
-1.127543211,
0.2351157963,
0.1388272792,
0.3491628766,
0.173250854,
-0.6469091773,
-0.278960079,
0.0969518647,
-0.1695419997,
-0.8169319034,
0.5197393298,
0.5510302782,
0.4997959435,
0.1144445166,
0.143694222,
1.0889210701,
-0.3913617432,
0.5007910728,
0.0699655935,
-0.7512965798,
0.3070224226,
-0.3626217544,
0.6936181188,
0.258718431,
-0.055110801,
-0.3761805594,
-0.2685335577,
-0.1848915815,
-1.1248599291,
0.5920392871,
0.0525738299,
-0.0067270999,
0.2332871109,
0.1318971813,
-0.2591690421,
-0.1022030264,
-0.7042606473,
0.0027373363,
0.0010158281,
-0.5761899948,
0.0967356637,
-0.4697227776,
-0.07708738,
-0.088378787,
0.6753618717,
-0.3402998447,
0.0390699916,
0.0661514327,
-0.4216626585,
-0.0736797154,
0.343593061,
0.5161478519,
0.8274469376,
-0.2157792896,
0.1750013381,
0.2402076423,
-0.6473772526,
0.1185235307,
0.1070010066,
-0.279352963,
-0.0296942629,
0.5246426463,
0.9828830957,
0.3227009475,
-0.6721975207,
0.2243267447,
0.0492600948,
-0.0497350655,
-0.2351478636,
0.0909943953,
0.1490926445,
0.1783218235,
0.4305006862,
-0.0140447179,
-0.1070600897,
-0.4211524427,
-0.0293859951,
0.3578079641,
-0.1373390406,
-0.3761489987,
0.2531023026,
0.282392174,
-0.0361189283,
0.5506823659,
0.2991819084,
-0.4723350108,
0.5257078409,
0.6978951097,
1.0298410654,
-0.4387989044,
0.0861122385,
0.3659412563,
0.3191859424,
-0.0650230199,
-0.1290964484,
-0.0527529456,
-1.0896211863,
-0.9134888053,
-1.1541242599,
0.0693986416,
0.0897629485,
-0.3178466856,
0.0919011459,
-0.4268630743,
0.0770649016,
0.0957688764,
0.0345753357,
-0.2040395737,
0.1960275471,
-0.0555392466,
1.1035325527,
-1.0637489557,
1.1408179998,
0.5507873893,
0.0005168838,
-0.9975485802,
-0.0941578522,
-0.135625571,
-0.5367643833,
0.0912436992,
0.0489736572,
-0.1720145643,
0.2606633902,
-0.1291791499,
-0.9837824106,
1.1587222815,
0.5032414794,
-0.9068027139,
-0.0861829147,
-0.2141310275,
0.2549245059,
-0.2304941267,
0.0626216978,
0.5531193614,
0.4796740115,
0.258659333,
-0.7533837557,
0.0257314425,
-0.298194617,
0.1981568933,
0.5234870911,
-0.6278744936,
0.6519652605,
0.0955685824,
-0.5613034964,
-0.0333620943,
0.7977510691,
0.4851051867,
-0.1313073635,
0.8630966544,
0.3440440297,
0.5328992009,
-0.2089201212,
0.8064201474,
-0.2301939875,
0.3877224624,
1.1159021854,
-0.0952969417,
0.7143477201,
0.4799990058,
-0.2428404689,
0.2114949822,
0.8174981475,
-0.0533441231,
0.5749704838,
0.0408851914,
-0.2268350422,
-0.4327313602,
-0.0718946978,
-0.1221778318,
0.3755033612,
0.4784223735,
-0.1562995017,
-0.2636089623,
-0.0806176662,
-0.1053158864,
-0.057648927,
-0.3433829546,
0.8704704046,
0.1741758287,
-0.7996188998,
0.573331058,
0.4152251482,
0.7685240507,
-0.6364736557,
0.065500021,
-0.2726562023,
0.3995171785,
-0.3702664077,
-0.5377057195,
0.2995686829,
-0.1908132732,
-0.1040794924,
-0.0566181913,
0.9167504907,
-0.6372867227,
-0.7226749659,
0.2696328461,
0.2512463629,
-0.116009526,
-0.1313614994,
-0.4688333273,
0.6653367877,
0.1541017294,
-0.3086813688,
0.4729379416,
0.0523684248,
-0.1654907316,
0.7270637155,
0.8618786931,
0.3237915039,
0.3563615978,
0.0722701326,
1.0059894323,
-0.494402945,
-0.3769983351,
-0.9712755084,
0.5673777461,
0.0072574932,
-0.0867045894,
0.6912405491,
0.4064220488,
0.7732183337,
0.0255300794,
0.4663257003,
-0.0550250784,
0.30977121,
-0.7589975595,
0.2946434319,
-0.310769707,
0.6272735,
-0.1791285574,
-1.4238044024,
-0.4284711778,
0.5305454135,
-0.2137386501,
-0.0802533254,
0.175901264,
0.9519436359,
-0.3486663401,
-0.1946776658,
0.2804129422,
0.5327427983,
0.505169332,
0.5822988749,
0.5801072717,
-0.3268712163,
0.4337784648,
-0.5201284885,
-0.3705917299,
-0.0979623944,
-0.8565502167,
-0.3626751602,
-0.40788427,
-0.2929396927,
-0.0733551085,
-0.0533714741,
0.6780230403,
0.721981883,
-0.8152447343,
-0.3066087663,
-0.033145912,
0.1727296114,
-0.3747212887,
-0.1669144183,
0.7490237951,
-0.0166289434,
-0.7993423939,
0.6160749197,
0.449433744,
-0.1805283874,
-0.2369535267,
-0.0097473916,
-0.4411684275,
-0.0945999771,
0.7997253537,
0.137758866,
-0.8722195625,
-0.382462889,
-0.1522561759,
0.1815760732,
-0.0260964856,
0.5682060719,
-0.6634424925,
0.2994639575,
0.616245687,
0.5655096769,
0.3441545069,
0.4577613473,
0.7547570467,
-0.9819147587,
0.2991893888,
0.1031927988,
0.5048131347,
0.5315377712,
-0.1106312498,
0.3460206687,
0.1264394671,
-0.324428618,
-1.0706239939,
0.3440206647,
-1.0357706547,
-0.3644443452,
1.0401052237,
-0.3292597234,
-0.5933308601,
-0.0157572366,
-0.1083573923,
0.3505446911,
-0.0682234168,
0.541390717,
0.3412249982,
0.1613651365,
-0.5025726557,
-0.195918709,
0.0721345395,
0.4414036274,
-0.6248656511,
0.2675862014,
0.5367942452,
0.2919760346,
0.183000654,
0.4965277314,
0.0686287805,
0.0018165552,
-0.1955388933,
-0.2340100706,
-0.272975266,
-0.4913186431,
-0.3869253695,
0.4361507297,
0.0646048486,
-0.3433864117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10795v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10795v1
|
From Words to Routes: Applying Large Language Models to Vehicle Routing
| 2024-03-16T03:54:38 | 2024-03-16T03:54:38 |
Zhehui Huang, Guangyao Shi, Gaurav S. Sukhatme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
LLMs have shown impressive progress in robotics (e.g., manipulation and
navigation) with natural language task descriptions. The success of LLMs in
these tasks leads us to wonder: What is the ability of LLMs to solve vehicle
routing problems (VRPs) with natural language task descriptions? In this work,
we study this question in three steps. First, we construct a dataset with 21
types of single- or multi-vehicle routing problems. Second, we evaluate the
performance of LLMs across four basic prompt paradigms of text-to-code
generation, each involving different types of text input. We find that the
basic prompt paradigm, which generates code directly from natural language task
descriptions, performs the best for GPT-4, achieving 56% feasibility, 40%
optimality, and 53% efficiency. Third, based on the observation that LLMs may
not be able to provide correct solutions at the initial attempt, we propose a
framework that enables LLMs to refine solutions through self-reflection,
including self-debugging and self-verification. With GPT-4, our proposed
framework achieves a 16% increase in feasibility, a 7% increase in optimality,
and a 15% increase in efficiency. Moreover, we examine the sensitivity of GPT-4
to task descriptions, specifically focusing on how its performance changes when
certain details are omitted from the task descriptions, yet the core meaning is
preserved. Our findings reveal that such omissions lead to a notable decrease
in performance: 4% in feasibility, 4% in optimality, and 5% in efficiency.
Website: https://sites.google.com/view/words-to-routes/
|
[
-0.1791402549,
-0.667393744,
1.1129866838,
0.3190611005,
-0.312163204,
0.0586831979,
-0.3224645555,
-0.2745988369,
-0.1927212626,
0.5758180618,
-0.818957448,
-0.3575904071,
-0.4167329073,
0.3070268631,
-0.3255801797,
0.7407525778,
-0.1893506944,
-0.1048490852,
-0.2990074456,
0.1591468453,
-0.520334363,
-0.4981682003,
-0.6978420019,
-0.24610807,
0.6806310415,
0.177039966,
0.4530012608,
0.8443576694,
0.6223361492,
0.3200730383,
0.0536623038,
0.2094100714,
-0.2593414783,
0.3137969077,
-0.3491026461,
-0.1752109081,
-0.1612402052,
-0.2724837661,
0.6888724566,
0.5686398149,
-0.1669719368,
-0.1871968806,
0.266479969,
0.7709718347,
-0.3305919766,
0.1605496109,
-0.5058099031,
-0.0707038343,
-0.2667078972,
-0.5430441499,
-0.1341547221,
-0.1074764505,
0.1931186765,
-0.6332697272,
0.4245868623,
0.2371610403,
0.8721286058,
0.4174509943,
-0.4444810748,
-0.8178674579,
-0.9266287088,
0.7568868399,
-0.635953486,
0.3639480472,
0.2615861595,
0.129735902,
-0.4075900316,
-0.6746796966,
-0.5733729601,
-0.2519245744,
-0.0175789874,
0.2325975448,
-0.2592968941,
0.2865775228,
0.3707025945,
0.2538357079,
-0.7700037956,
0.2592093349,
-0.4781159163,
-0.2988093495,
0.6309984922,
0.3350617886,
0.1334228665,
-0.2692891359,
-0.6508435607,
0.0972135514,
-0.8241776824,
0.0840209201,
0.2632804215,
0.4769056737,
0.022301605,
0.6402314305,
-0.320569247,
0.9179843664,
-0.1957231313,
-0.3682588935,
0.1555118114,
-0.5601159334,
-0.2085063905,
-0.0436480641,
0.8732054234,
0.34991467,
-0.0442683324,
-0.6187523007,
-0.3733099401,
-0.0612881742,
0.4293959141,
-0.4472070336,
-0.023367282,
-0.0106330775,
-0.402772367,
-0.0031717315,
-0.4664576948,
-0.6329247952,
-0.2700117528,
-0.5883494616,
0.5039091706,
-0.4018888772,
0.0520763658,
0.393936187,
-0.0782205015,
0.5737265944,
0.3885502219,
-0.6314226985,
0.3288933635,
0.729398489,
1.0528948307,
-0.289470613,
-0.2483955026,
-0.5483909249,
0.2925009131,
-0.1114074513,
0.8464844823,
-0.3002408445,
-0.7228823304,
0.0510046408,
-0.0124870623,
-0.1109823957,
-0.3056229651,
0.693418622,
-0.4338334203,
0.2094124854,
-0.8283755779,
-0.6128183007,
-0.2886814475,
0.3807796836,
-0.5610154271,
0.8186349869,
-0.0829095542,
-0.4223906994,
-0.1210539341,
-0.5497125387,
-0.8031050563,
0.0914741829,
-0.1225164831,
-0.0144905914,
0.1628082693,
0.0309672877,
0.5661762953,
-0.6095826626,
0.0296270549,
0.3572806418,
-0.2280742526,
-0.3664403856,
-0.4786951244,
0.5395702124,
0.0691395774,
-0.4069223702,
-0.087592639,
-0.6680566072,
-0.1117334738,
0.2757852376,
-0.6889566779,
-0.2468048036,
0.3343909085,
-0.3393349946,
0.2308487743,
0.2665417194,
-0.465252161,
0.4268574119,
-0.6039376855,
0.4389125705,
1.0973535776,
-0.0984190851,
0.5636461973,
-0.2302149981,
0.9317606091,
-0.2149990201,
-0.0753960609,
-0.3139494658,
-0.8352720737,
-0.9902792573,
0.2123911679,
-0.1014914513,
0.6214895248,
-1.0315771103,
0.0410577022,
-0.1030664146,
-0.4464877844,
-0.0621357672,
0.1308356076,
0.4926441908,
0.8378422856,
0.5135527849,
-0.2511838973,
-0.1755759567,
-0.8530407548,
-0.3171497285,
-0.2568142712,
0.0877511501,
0.1327321231,
0.3079004586,
-0.272870183,
0.8405273557,
-0.586225152,
-0.1653510034,
-0.2417976111,
0.1479790658,
-0.0000140251,
0.2960782647,
0.1563856602,
-0.4711592495,
-0.2073005736,
-0.2128933519,
-0.498090893,
-0.0217798632,
-0.2393510342,
-0.0230975468,
0.0646326393,
0.4449507594,
-0.7176429629,
0.3542782962,
0.5319795609,
-0.2985571921,
0.5768564343,
-0.4553868771,
-0.2174787223,
-0.8645274639,
-0.3017690182,
0.3827470839,
-0.1418433487,
-0.5349613428,
-0.0789886937,
-0.3282269835,
0.0662283525,
-0.3061752021,
0.5732709169,
-0.6405184269,
-0.1176241785,
-0.3094470501,
0.2709782124,
0.0094704563,
0.6048390269,
-0.0791851282,
0.8884481788,
0.7119093537,
-0.9633301497,
0.5384184718,
0.0905233249,
-0.0158999469,
0.5194313526,
-0.625703454,
0.2725734413,
-0.4280008376,
0.0666425601,
-1.2303471565,
-0.0360708088,
0.4829342365,
-0.0079440698,
0.2166094333,
-0.0232472923,
-0.7052474022,
-0.3946425021,
0.0561591834,
0.2643910646,
0.598017931,
-0.3845422864,
0.7163541317,
0.0930398181,
-0.1500362307,
-0.1472806931,
-0.4915766418,
0.2971159518,
-0.1739288419,
-0.5608392358,
0.5852555633,
-0.1790260226,
0.0406366214,
-0.2257884443,
-0.1873088628,
-0.0643856525,
0.0279307719,
0.2937251329,
0.0476408824,
-0.0558977462,
0.4540762007,
-0.1727908105,
-0.2597229779,
0.3407761753,
-0.1264294833,
0.5835114717,
-0.2498397827,
-0.4233731925,
-0.2185763121,
0.3083955348,
0.1226128563,
-0.3941659927,
0.3728705645,
0.4795406759,
-0.1364977509,
-0.2057672143,
-0.4381349385,
0.0811099634,
-0.5775426626,
0.1707854867,
-0.4668845236,
-0.9809071422,
0.2520097196,
-0.4161401987,
0.1598813832,
0.5545627475,
0.4932578504,
-0.2393981516,
0.6672319174,
0.64674896,
0.1338430196,
-0.004993978,
-0.1142629907,
0.5060051084,
-0.7655127048,
-0.5753507614,
-0.6472947598,
-0.1602538079,
-0.9070450068,
-0.8483637571,
0.5419681668,
-0.1714439392,
-0.157791391,
0.2860258818,
-0.6111470461,
0.2166473418,
0.7247020602,
-0.1283924133,
0.4492497742,
0.0499610752,
-0.1630746126,
-0.0031402379,
-0.9684049487,
-0.6425496936,
0.8563203216,
0.2064380944,
0.669077456,
0.067244783,
0.6188306212,
0.2669348121,
0.0732181817,
-0.8453326225,
0.9317692518,
-0.0019089131,
-0.4206507206,
-0.274209857,
-0.421661973,
-1.0836071968,
0.0280623659,
0.0584968664,
-0.4546473622,
-0.2345590442,
0.1368010789,
-0.3770190179,
0.2711274028,
-0.4372443259,
0.8009215593,
-0.6990340948,
-0.5101655126,
-0.018945761,
-0.7320584059,
0.1726670414,
0.0103617385,
0.2714075148,
-0.112113826,
-0.2153657526,
0.7875459194,
-0.2993568182,
0.6089428663,
-0.0440345593,
-0.4349345565,
0.3200270534,
-0.0293756668,
0.682918489,
-0.439628154,
-0.0109723927,
0.0806889459,
-0.5034266114,
-0.1157240942,
-0.6051357388,
0.8608387113,
-0.3626200855,
-0.5547226667,
-0.4046547115,
-0.2612694204,
-0.3341680467,
0.3015546203,
0.2694149315,
0.6860495806,
0.0736279115,
-0.3167566955,
0.6953297257,
-0.6453531384,
0.7956755161,
0.5213550925,
-0.0124526415,
0.0481145419,
0.9936772585,
0.1105114147,
0.096676521,
0.4830272496,
0.2322549671,
-0.6111063361,
-0.6285396814,
-0.5501913428,
0.3996545076,
-0.7480257154,
-0.1801812798,
-0.5069356561,
-0.0809593499,
-0.048101075,
-0.1741231084,
-0.5344210863,
-0.2639421523,
-0.4350268841,
-0.0304637104,
0.2802708745,
1.058598876,
-0.0346355438,
0.6140499711,
-0.6199547052,
0.3987424076,
0.4120620191,
0.3759855926,
0.0338135138,
-0.2941983938,
-0.2160828561,
-0.095303461,
-0.6029226184,
-0.8745141029,
0.3441258669,
-0.1369157583,
0.5609921217,
0.1046620831,
-0.040147163,
0.8624936342,
-0.9622787833,
1.0071011782,
0.3430636227,
-0.8023964763,
0.5753318071,
-0.4971567392,
0.1076198816,
0.19622235,
0.4136181772,
-0.1970839351,
-0.1988128275,
-0.4235183001,
-1.0184944868,
0.3135992289,
0.4223386645,
0.1212009937,
-0.2160026431,
0.5277799368,
-0.1007699221,
0.1906844079,
-0.6445599794,
-0.5327829123,
0.0221292786,
0.0133492239,
-0.2213677913,
-0.3973362744,
0.1471706331,
-0.0754316971,
0.5271639824,
0.1139419228,
0.7168584466,
0.3408817649,
0.1869468093,
0.1480795443,
0.2865671813,
0.9309360385,
0.7567148805,
0.1141438633,
0.1229260415,
-0.1144577786,
-0.0379757658,
0.3050309718,
-0.003573566,
-0.087305598,
0.1546830982,
0.3820589185,
0.7415411472,
-0.0586930402,
-0.59009552,
0.4533196986,
0.0075660059,
-0.1963865459,
-0.2769421339,
0.0541059896,
0.0572687835,
0.2163919359,
0.3943172693,
0.0137356585,
0.3909267485,
-0.2749796808,
-0.110015437,
0.5015305877,
-0.3571726978,
-0.4111433923,
0.7891312838,
0.4265279472,
-0.6492973566,
0.4763922393,
-0.4483463764,
-0.589337647,
0.4421196282,
0.3450588286,
1.0095950365,
-0.0730176121,
0.1138712913,
0.3830648959,
0.5396047831,
-0.3639820516,
0.0065540113,
-0.0181494076,
-0.5621322393,
-0.8390036821,
-0.6468119621,
-0.2838778198,
-0.0932727978,
-0.3588081896,
-0.0436810292,
-0.388281852,
-0.2813919187,
-0.5078317523,
-0.1995739192,
-0.9310199618,
0.3196315765,
0.2198875099,
0.583476007,
-0.6057876945,
0.3143180609,
0.8917723894,
-0.2139186412,
-0.9795572758,
0.0655298755,
-0.0754920244,
-0.7417067885,
0.7646080256,
0.1880635917,
-0.5441363454,
0.0415982977,
-0.285230577,
-0.8611108661,
0.9696258307,
0.2108513266,
-0.7432830334,
-0.4757191539,
0.2611888945,
0.3246123791,
-0.0422323197,
-0.0805171505,
0.2762411237,
0.4660452902,
0.1466327459,
-1.1308965683,
0.2134349197,
0.2590529621,
0.2252726406,
-0.0111616775,
-0.7181744576,
0.6054205894,
-0.089671582,
-0.1210077181,
0.1728602052,
0.501778841,
0.1921467334,
0.3385750353,
0.3750002682,
0.5964258313,
0.704425931,
-0.1102473959,
1.2437949181,
-0.1878404915,
0.2092414796,
0.9873759747,
-0.2262828499,
0.515452981,
0.611944437,
-0.1901897639,
0.5172375441,
0.3179688156,
0.3639024794,
0.7869175076,
0.5393465757,
-0.3037487268,
-0.3524075449,
0.0927115679,
-0.2423948497,
0.5756977797,
-0.062976867,
-0.2275217623,
-0.4750165939,
0.150141269,
0.1157009751,
0.0276205521,
-0.4600928128,
0.5243432522,
-0.0046232678,
-0.7343921661,
0.3446344137,
0.3430134356,
0.5508480668,
-0.5953900218,
-0.2091189921,
-0.1041632444,
-0.0471096635,
0.0578719825,
-0.7329680324,
0.2408832759,
-0.0311082657,
-0.1975193769,
-0.8324359655,
0.6918931603,
-0.0839306116,
-0.5305749774,
0.0579833128,
0.6224353909,
0.1021479294,
-0.050640177,
-0.6553669572,
0.2070881575,
0.1521177441,
-0.2263212353,
0.2122975588,
0.6240151525,
0.3508886993,
1.0785508156,
0.4444902539,
0.1569207907,
0.2593444884,
-0.2936207056,
0.9656454325,
-0.9777676463,
-0.3804316223,
-1.1206016541,
0.6258775592,
0.251785934,
-0.214505434,
1.0533541441,
0.6876623631,
0.7092155218,
-0.0676384345,
0.8587087989,
0.0913932249,
0.6094796062,
-0.8454762697,
0.0345884115,
-0.6401530504,
0.6847528815,
-0.2447655648,
-0.6843439937,
-0.0028471134,
0.730695188,
-0.2685373724,
0.1111197025,
0.5473824143,
0.7261784077,
0.1120009944,
-0.2870209515,
0.094935514,
-0.0121718692,
0.5982660651,
0.7250026464,
0.9653204083,
-0.4196352661,
0.5082394481,
-0.2052690983,
0.1919906586,
0.0721927509,
-1.1340256929,
-0.7393312454,
-0.589879334,
-0.4667788148,
-0.3260683715,
0.163021028,
0.5011666417,
0.5759421587,
-0.0392419845,
-0.3175348341,
-0.4255382121,
0.2725163996,
0.1144931614,
-0.1603566408,
0.13299945,
-0.4806085229,
-0.3547312319,
0.7102476954,
0.4116030931,
-0.031583935,
-0.4635310173,
-0.3316788673,
0.1201823279,
-0.0684024766,
0.7847030163,
0.1869386435,
-0.8671714067,
-0.2081474662,
0.0592053272,
0.0396850817,
0.0034079873,
0.8411120772,
-0.7988802195,
0.4637770057,
0.1570884138,
0.6296359301,
0.3941035271,
0.2551809549,
0.7505279779,
-0.5126489997,
-0.1159233823,
0.2979904115,
0.1743175834,
0.3992868364,
-0.0914075598,
0.4719389975,
0.3937932849,
-0.7075304389,
-0.5102736354,
0.3415691555,
-1.270457983,
-0.0453766771,
1.5871506929,
0.1581374705,
-0.1910431087,
-0.1682473421,
-0.2614630759,
0.0151319513,
-0.2964245379,
0.3129518032,
0.5380346775,
-0.3556724191,
-0.2085126787,
-0.8956905603,
0.6434103847,
0.1211734191,
-0.4485301673,
-0.0879697427,
0.6223776937,
0.3011875749,
0.0456239991,
1.0253504515,
0.4600001276,
-0.1072001308,
-0.5015999675,
-0.0977450088,
-0.1404873878,
-0.1835141927,
-0.2018385082,
0.1623529345,
0.1969026327,
-0.2760877907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10781v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10781v1
|
Exploring Chinese Humor Generation: A Study on Two-Part Allegorical Sayings
| 2024-03-16T02:58:57 | 2024-03-16T02:58:57 |
Rongwu Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Humor, a culturally nuanced aspect of human language, poses challenges for
computational understanding and generation, especially in Chinese humor, which
remains relatively unexplored in the NLP community. This paper investigates the
capability of state-of-the-art language models to comprehend and generate
Chinese humor, specifically focusing on training them to create allegorical
sayings. We employ two prominent training methods: fine-tuning a medium-sized
language model and prompting a large one. Our novel fine-tuning approach
incorporates fused Pinyin embeddings to consider homophones and employs
contrastive learning with synthetic hard negatives to distinguish humor
elements. Human-annotated results show that these models can generate humorous
allegorical sayings, with prompting proving to be a practical and effective
method. However, there is still room for improvement in generating allegorical
sayings that match human creativity.
|
[
-0.1162235513,
-0.7020234466,
0.3167313635,
0.7392656803,
-0.6640205979,
-0.273817867,
-0.1962314248,
-0.1844148636,
0.2006558627,
0.3079612553,
-0.5608665943,
-0.0737643316,
-0.1889853925,
0.2904545963,
-0.0513548069,
1.0847728252,
0.6420863271,
0.1079577804,
0.0781813785,
0.017430881,
-0.3656400442,
-0.4583759308,
-0.7767311931,
-0.4258225262,
1.0009986162,
0.4703995287,
0.83026582,
0.5884053111,
0.1002257839,
0.1386163682,
-0.1965551972,
0.1180461571,
-0.5196115375,
-0.0038202957,
-0.1156723276,
-0.5114142895,
-0.1194061041,
-0.1307726949,
0.4584337175,
0.7355947495,
-0.4753395021,
-0.0316244103,
-0.2157862335,
0.4551877081,
-0.4974260628,
-0.2232819796,
-1.0013856888,
0.4436674416,
-0.379557848,
-0.4715077579,
-0.3224700391,
-0.433889538,
-0.0442476869,
-0.4094683826,
0.2342027426,
0.0798472539,
0.6208701134,
0.28820768,
-0.39544788,
-0.3612128198,
-0.3361214697,
0.8140532374,
-1.0017126799,
-0.1227072477,
-0.0274278093,
0.2897528708,
-0.0765993074,
-0.7577560544,
-0.8063377738,
-0.2598076761,
0.1827922314,
0.0644765571,
-0.0522656329,
-0.3059546053,
0.1036016941,
0.3277150095,
-0.6083308458,
0.2094320655,
-0.3276586831,
0.1920393705,
0.812236011,
0.1801028997,
0.5998857617,
-0.5059640408,
-0.3027089536,
-0.1598329544,
-0.8391151428,
0.1309571117,
0.4639671743,
0.3646014631,
0.1061829701,
0.3897239268,
-0.129731968,
0.2693820298,
-0.422501713,
-0.0924080089,
-0.0645605624,
0.0885131359,
-0.2843004763,
0.0375695638,
0.766372025,
0.3130855858,
0.4997712374,
-0.2539048493,
-0.2398563176,
-0.1446891874,
0.1586827636,
-0.6298628449,
-0.5433521867,
0.0503700636,
-0.4390278757,
-0.8247625232,
0.0139054656,
-0.620904386,
-0.8141630292,
-0.0390514322,
0.3783101141,
-0.4798085392,
-0.4555683136,
0.3931418955,
-0.4539688826,
0.3154512644,
0.1435989141,
-1.0626240969,
-0.5367625952,
0.8312109113,
0.4003475606,
0.3396549523,
-0.3590328395,
-0.5768850446,
-0.0912351608,
-0.5833963752,
0.7805557251,
-0.2621013224,
-0.1690082997,
0.0739741847,
-0.2323270291,
0.0786495432,
-0.6366388798,
0.6320803165,
-0.0693717971,
-0.0324016698,
-0.3218924403,
-0.1251242012,
-0.0495127849,
0.2093798369,
-0.452344805,
0.8232299685,
0.2237481326,
-0.9598045945,
0.2427875549,
-0.3084565699,
-0.7206635475,
0.3750039339,
-0.153548196,
-0.2979246676,
0.4688292742,
0.0850477815,
0.1980134994,
-0.6680027843,
0.5170156956,
-0.2674557269,
-0.2985650301,
0.5139471292,
-0.3491337597,
0.9999924302,
0.5134236217,
-0.4204134643,
0.04647943,
-0.4038571119,
0.0647253171,
0.5793156624,
-0.2757797241,
-0.0562620647,
0.1048962697,
-0.0663643405,
0.613959372,
0.0797044858,
-0.614762187,
-0.0210223626,
-0.656175375,
0.7337663174,
0.6079235673,
-0.2349040657,
-0.0831057206,
-0.2910474837,
0.2670615017,
0.1898201704,
0.3741999567,
-0.4330404699,
-0.6344308257,
-0.9723070264,
0.1124468446,
0.1032862365,
0.5259293318,
-1.2334060669,
0.2859813869,
-0.1235444546,
-0.532572031,
-0.7460872531,
0.2093865424,
0.2547813356,
0.2941448092,
0.118587099,
-0.4300951958,
-0.3164361417,
-0.6740884781,
-0.3182285726,
-0.2996243536,
-0.5388333201,
0.4664257765,
0.2634479702,
0.0998893008,
0.6342810988,
-0.3766585588,
0.1035833359,
-0.459323734,
0.551464498,
-0.1216684952,
0.2799270153,
0.7627820969,
-0.6355366707,
-0.3089995384,
-0.0259919222,
-0.902774632,
0.00031994,
-0.1074464619,
-0.0703488961,
0.0915069953,
0.2113286257,
-0.307076484,
0.2153291702,
0.1071083546,
-0.2222034931,
0.6600282788,
-0.1755342484,
-0.2063891739,
-0.8214206696,
-0.0824677646,
-0.1194030121,
0.2784026265,
-0.7545802593,
0.3574725688,
-0.2308888584,
-0.3727357388,
-0.7872469425,
0.6878502965,
-0.1780126095,
0.1340678781,
-0.3582145274,
0.1548244804,
-0.0731728971,
0.3817498684,
0.0763886347,
0.1554665118,
0.7318037152,
-0.5658047795,
0.57256639,
-0.0256868955,
-0.1486753076,
0.3549774885,
-0.5269637704,
0.3009900153,
-0.3095261753,
0.1746627837,
-0.8399594426,
-0.4577023089,
-0.0009828508,
-0.5457753539,
-0.0437615514,
0.4110777378,
-0.8634843826,
-0.5188862681,
-0.4938075244,
0.3615663052,
0.76116997,
-0.6986302733,
0.1336116791,
0.095402211,
-0.4100531638,
-0.5151150823,
-0.5709888339,
0.4015370309,
-0.4718981981,
-0.9238647819,
0.0002907428,
0.0307989363,
-0.067772232,
-0.4238642752,
0.3634258807,
0.1350689083,
0.2912015915,
-0.2739731371,
-0.0973446146,
-0.4752140045,
0.0815269947,
-0.035444919,
0.2374163866,
0.1421702951,
-0.0700507164,
0.5224919915,
0.0869913399,
-0.160227105,
-0.2691873014,
0.4154714644,
-0.000491973,
-0.2338436395,
0.6155221462,
0.744407177,
-0.3213149011,
-0.3691737652,
-0.3483866751,
-0.371722132,
-0.4870085716,
0.3461382687,
0.1156064868,
-0.8474228978,
0.1482623816,
-0.1758393794,
0.1496729702,
0.2328777462,
0.4159175456,
-0.098094888,
1.1251810789,
0.7199423909,
0.2345757931,
0.3063015044,
0.3390329182,
0.6476960778,
-0.4775079191,
-0.080769144,
-0.5456914306,
-0.2713897526,
-0.6008241773,
-0.5068073869,
0.1236700341,
0.3287321031,
-0.2889993489,
-0.0902629867,
-0.3380182683,
0.4706468284,
0.5495911241,
0.0395962186,
0.0145465015,
0.1580316573,
-0.1214039624,
-0.0534386188,
-0.7270023227,
-0.3480729759,
0.5548484921,
0.385679394,
0.6607399583,
0.2042784542,
0.6071261168,
-0.0588772856,
0.3333507478,
-0.7230642438,
0.5204495788,
-0.8988790512,
-0.2148202509,
-0.261846453,
-0.481297344,
-0.633441031,
-0.020140728,
-0.3288480937,
-0.729600668,
-0.0422230177,
0.1829872578,
-0.352085948,
0.3081291616,
-0.2032417804,
0.634704411,
-0.3374797404,
-0.0699366778,
-0.087017782,
-0.862911284,
0.7630200386,
0.121322751,
0.1199041903,
0.0059001762,
0.6881898046,
0.4199261963,
0.0551174879,
0.915592134,
-0.0417731591,
-0.4274245799,
0.4761554897,
0.2442944497,
0.0591049828,
0.0272720437,
-0.309748143,
0.0158699788,
-0.3813098967,
-0.4255036116,
-0.5523034334,
0.4324297905,
-0.5468886495,
-0.5679674745,
0.0378333963,
-0.664537251,
-0.0010272115,
-0.1690709144,
0.2707374394,
0.0693195835,
-0.0241786148,
0.4810947478,
0.5272185206,
-0.8689544201,
0.3288913071,
0.2187831551,
0.1463358402,
-0.3330358863,
1.2917604446,
-0.3313453496,
0.1602776498,
0.2213241905,
0.5513339043,
-0.2725142539,
0.1229461655,
-0.5841082335,
0.2893131673,
-0.9063655734,
-0.0435351431,
-0.5193414092,
-0.5273084641,
-0.5739647746,
-0.1354266852,
-0.2687016428,
-0.5847225189,
-0.1091891527,
0.0840979815,
0.0337787829,
0.7740003467,
-0.0347397588,
0.3247101307,
-0.8010776639,
0.0371869542,
0.6480312943,
0.0818284079,
0.5075953603,
-0.2886804044,
-0.1570667624,
0.0817176029,
-0.8382020593,
-0.8138217926,
0.3289889991,
0.5324261785,
0.3165115416,
0.561211884,
0.1733517647,
0.3580961227,
-0.5484463573,
1.2577362061,
0.3604792058,
-0.7328317165,
0.6745926738,
-0.2916155457,
0.000603548,
-0.0984413028,
-0.0226851013,
-0.7916210294,
-0.4817315638,
-0.6616970897,
-0.8595082164,
0.6558600068,
0.2693851888,
0.5922843814,
-0.3592043817,
0.5408291221,
-0.0690710917,
0.4234087467,
-0.9430832863,
-0.2065683454,
-0.5292690396,
-0.2390670329,
0.2120392919,
-0.1985301226,
-0.2795897424,
-0.0994034931,
0.4219003022,
-0.2456856966,
0.10883113,
-0.1819234341,
0.0916862488,
-0.2698877752,
0.5288208127,
0.6935666203,
0.5206698775,
0.0637288168,
0.2269450873,
-0.083631672,
-0.1805791855,
-0.1928534508,
-0.1344605833,
-0.095345594,
0.0232454762,
0.2199746817,
1.2302203178,
0.1062190905,
-0.7873299122,
0.4545008838,
-0.0160355363,
-0.2810427845,
0.1302383393,
0.3046334386,
0.185018599,
0.1255163401,
0.3580091894,
-0.3555857241,
0.251850754,
-0.8357730508,
0.1388274431,
0.3508760035,
-0.2350937277,
-0.4967204034,
0.874338448,
0.2010301948,
-0.2340876311,
0.7387407422,
-0.4598964751,
-0.6439137459,
0.7264620662,
0.9551808238,
1.0709514618,
-0.2976395786,
0.6175347567,
0.5450139046,
0.2501510084,
-0.0891849026,
0.3151866198,
-0.0038502465,
-0.6104259491,
-0.2510810196,
-0.870736897,
-0.3303029239,
0.0487796627,
-0.4961065948,
0.5895513892,
-0.1873351336,
0.2477915734,
-0.0519801565,
-0.3795548677,
-0.4607409537,
0.4981274903,
0.6691532135,
0.7037553787,
-0.9058232903,
0.7164396644,
0.8151809573,
-0.2933261693,
-0.9826825261,
0.2375953645,
-0.1352661401,
-0.7239964008,
0.6297220588,
0.3904977739,
0.1400721818,
0.0393029265,
-0.8860771656,
-0.1020336375,
0.887434721,
0.4080489576,
-0.0561636798,
-0.136300683,
0.4374454021,
0.6428440213,
-0.4784409702,
0.2109903097,
0.6291561127,
0.1113134846,
0.5487287045,
-0.7044245601,
0.1769810766,
-0.4373867512,
0.3343194425,
-0.1658898741,
-0.6885725856,
1.3576655388,
-0.5819612145,
-0.2517940998,
0.1276459843,
0.7095646858,
0.8577014804,
0.5626039505,
0.7921409607,
0.3850309551,
0.5663840175,
-0.0355214812,
0.8151834607,
-0.1631748527,
0.2468863279,
0.7716438174,
-0.2747823298,
0.7021529078,
0.223741129,
0.2322645932,
0.4287539423,
0.7018591762,
0.0760168806,
0.468051672,
0.602247417,
-0.29971385,
-0.415818572,
-0.4541580975,
-0.230723843,
0.3243895769,
0.2180250287,
-0.1531191617,
-0.3688313961,
-0.0053616301,
0.1321006268,
-0.0892516151,
-0.1231845841,
0.826107502,
0.4281725883,
-0.6962170601,
0.6802390218,
0.0594035983,
0.8896780014,
-0.3241208494,
-0.1530483663,
-0.3515279591,
-0.3037616313,
-0.1484448761,
-0.8571501374,
-0.0512898155,
0.1937102526,
0.3094563484,
0.3091455698,
0.3580084741,
-0.5504651666,
-0.3527993262,
0.1472979039,
0.1997351795,
0.3290733397,
-0.051987689,
-0.4983445704,
-0.4588288069,
0.1259486526,
-0.1434637457,
0.3193520606,
1.205114603,
-0.1641788334,
0.5440881252,
0.6267316937,
0.1922640055,
0.1522359997,
0.6549804211,
0.7795918584,
-0.9820331931,
-0.6924578547,
-0.8767855763,
0.7363821864,
0.0094159553,
-0.4007337987,
0.2098948956,
-0.0328394882,
0.4283457696,
-0.190830946,
0.7958612442,
-0.1993087679,
0.0180083122,
-0.4265160561,
0.8135495186,
-1.1013740301,
0.1177968457,
-0.1186782718,
-0.7780882716,
-0.2855075896,
0.4687088728,
0.2932893336,
-0.1102185473,
0.5589609146,
0.6513649821,
0.0973800123,
0.3563198149,
0.4373430312,
0.2586233616,
0.5637626648,
0.4600537717,
0.9474765658,
-0.1612198353,
0.4852428436,
-0.5540245175,
-0.170732975,
-0.2288974524,
-1.0739736557,
-0.8885136247,
-0.3780692518,
-0.1353448182,
-0.0873294398,
-0.3417859375,
0.6578671336,
0.2857577503,
-0.4722329676,
-0.1650681496,
0.1684399843,
-0.085121654,
-0.1187925637,
-0.2651658356,
0.198537752,
-0.6348183751,
-0.5633748174,
0.1748799086,
0.2773621082,
-0.1420756131,
-0.4615808427,
0.0757525787,
0.19309856,
0.4092271328,
0.7946878076,
0.2528981864,
-0.9101188779,
-0.2564507425,
0.1255934089,
-0.0366471671,
-0.1742795706,
0.785805881,
-0.209126696,
0.4043916762,
0.5266702771,
0.4923528433,
-0.1433869153,
0.032405708,
0.6016146541,
-1.2056013346,
0.3149320185,
0.3054984212,
0.2097379416,
0.8173405528,
-0.5055118799,
0.4278932512,
0.0689742863,
-0.6274914742,
-1.1775979996,
0.3783276975,
-0.5886176229,
-0.2474560738,
0.9848144054,
-0.0646430627,
-0.4046982229,
0.2640378773,
-0.2236414701,
0.5119262338,
0.0413181409,
1.1754332781,
0.5554249287,
-0.1700513363,
-0.3007310331,
-0.6455562115,
0.628644526,
0.7141308784,
-0.7188814282,
0.1130509377,
0.0025361476,
0.2056165487,
0.2929800749,
0.5603513122,
-0.080586046,
0.6707492471,
0.0554228425,
0.4214265347,
0.4767896235,
-0.3917877674,
-0.1172112301,
-0.224969849,
0.2331138402,
0.2872852981
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.