id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09750v1
|
Meta-Cognitive Analysis: Evaluating Declarative and Procedural Knowledge in Datasets and Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T05:34:35 | 2024-03-14T05:34:35 |
Zhuoqun Li, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Hao Xiang, Xianpei Han, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Declarative knowledge and procedural knowledge are two key parts in
meta-cognitive theory, and these two hold significant importance in
pre-training and inference of LLMs. However, a comprehensive analysis comparing
these two types of knowledge is lacking, primarily due to challenges in
definition, probing and quantitative assessment. In this paper, we explore from
a new perspective by providing ground-truth knowledge for LLMs and evaluating
the effective score. Through extensive experiments with widely-used datasets
and models, we get conclusions: (1) In most tasks, benefits from declarative
knowledge are greater than those from procedural knowledge. (2) Profits of
procedural knowledge are larger than declarative knowledge only in reasoning
tasks with simple logic. (3) As pre-training progresses and size increases,
model ability to utilize both kinds of knowledge significantly improves, but in
different speed. We do detailed analysis for the findings and this can provide
primary guidance for evaluation and enhancement of large language models.
|
[
-0.2402598411,
-0.9866333008,
1.0612545013,
0.0447076149,
-0.2398743033,
0.1453059167,
-0.5607976317,
-0.2588990033,
-0.0372496322,
0.6477037668,
-0.5247337222,
-0.6281394958,
-0.7416294813,
-0.0256525967,
-0.2336596549,
0.7177085876,
0.2060229927,
0.215207994,
-0.6281278133,
0.048260469,
-0.5309183002,
-0.5208013654,
-0.4874532819,
-0.1803146899,
0.3958624601,
0.0527126901,
0.4893431664,
0.3468110263,
0.7897766829,
0.4173276126,
0.0631824806,
0.0850651115,
-0.4839645624,
0.0738982782,
-0.3640826046,
-0.5172359347,
-0.3977837861,
0.1768986583,
0.7476784587,
1.0439867973,
-0.2442733794,
0.2055371553,
0.0517812185,
0.7981696725,
-0.7291272879,
0.5027228594,
-0.7290300131,
-0.0355575569,
-0.1421841532,
-0.230577752,
-0.2949464917,
-0.6442373395,
0.3239763081,
-0.5653420091,
-0.0792518184,
-0.4443310201,
0.3904776275,
0.4395790696,
-0.7485116124,
-0.6034632921,
-0.8089442253,
0.9598451853,
-0.6005485058,
0.5565811992,
0.2247262895,
0.3459476233,
0.0354627073,
-0.8614398837,
-0.364433825,
-0.3539225757,
-0.082810998,
0.2854248881,
0.0809983164,
0.3195939362,
0.339261502,
0.4079952538,
-0.3392398655,
-0.0920429528,
-0.4982717633,
-0.3523727059,
0.5958597064,
0.3677733541,
0.2153625488,
-0.0633909479,
-0.2057542652,
0.0159910638,
-0.5985435247,
-0.063725166,
0.2984579802,
0.1660214365,
0.0562398396,
0.4792031944,
-0.1461274922,
1.0330414772,
0.0009866252,
-0.5524381995,
0.3188949227,
-0.572119236,
-0.1633647084,
-0.459420085,
0.8959913254,
0.1655490398,
0.5356945992,
-0.2947456837,
0.059179578,
0.1043373495,
0.2723678648,
-0.7495324612,
0.1734110117,
-0.0628988296,
-0.5930466652,
-0.253354311,
0.2168932557,
-0.7213944793,
-0.2574563026,
-0.795822382,
-0.0864320546,
-0.2972306907,
-0.4495563805,
0.2480260432,
-0.0996822938,
0.4720934331,
0.4070869684,
-0.6345254183,
0.3990959823,
1.0157094002,
0.6420150399,
-0.4000914693,
-0.1796427667,
-0.2294437438,
-0.1077313423,
-0.508349359,
0.7518632412,
-0.892637074,
-0.3371001184,
0.1144629568,
-0.0417700298,
-0.5063382387,
-0.536932826,
0.569727838,
-0.7680421472,
0.3434286416,
-0.5737941861,
-0.5340223312,
-0.4710808694,
0.3738461435,
-0.616129458,
0.6725534201,
0.0851016566,
-0.6693937182,
0.5565210581,
-0.5466908813,
-0.5400162935,
-0.0759288445,
-0.3976117671,
0.1284434795,
0.4452531636,
-0.109299235,
0.24628748,
-0.5250712633,
0.5393372178,
-0.3349386454,
-0.1327875555,
0.486308217,
-0.4427655339,
0.8311126232,
0.1373552084,
-0.1257620007,
-0.2138343602,
-0.6801748872,
0.2083565742,
-0.2742428482,
-0.5123847723,
-0.1028510779,
-0.1186363474,
-0.5261719227,
0.2609860301,
0.2623219192,
-0.2637071609,
0.0325071663,
-0.2994442284,
0.3595811427,
0.5164868236,
0.2410941571,
0.5461553335,
-0.2053563297,
0.6401529908,
-0.2455454469,
0.1690218598,
0.0535096154,
-0.3508985341,
-0.6320075393,
-0.4061746895,
0.6632075906,
0.5503419042,
-0.7727483511,
0.5378050208,
-0.3628919721,
-0.274320215,
-0.2771977484,
0.0874846652,
0.3821308017,
0.5391052365,
0.2797829509,
-0.4681739211,
-0.4667832255,
-0.7978133559,
-0.4142101705,
-0.085634619,
-0.0446280949,
0.4098708332,
0.5936186314,
-0.3592123985,
0.9017215371,
-0.5020840168,
-0.0623057932,
-0.0531850792,
0.2132017016,
0.2914077044,
0.185242787,
0.3213273585,
-0.4185124636,
-0.3680380583,
-0.2758203745,
-0.9780848622,
-0.1509655714,
-0.0830143318,
0.0622739084,
-0.0642551854,
0.4564982355,
-0.7310549021,
0.2458603531,
0.3821435273,
-0.0711756423,
0.6372801661,
-0.2338837683,
0.3044078052,
-0.4142251015,
-0.0057557938,
-0.3533038795,
-0.2632059455,
-0.7305434942,
0.1760817915,
-0.1146833897,
0.1889514774,
-0.2943056226,
0.3247647583,
-0.5358340144,
-0.2530468106,
-0.3586590886,
0.2746505141,
-0.0699777678,
0.5084481239,
0.4506286383,
0.6282331347,
0.5299515128,
-0.7344210148,
0.3293191791,
-0.0368026681,
-0.6283723116,
0.3191125393,
-0.7185606956,
0.3035386503,
-0.0038765718,
0.1436510384,
-1.0099728107,
0.03799849,
0.1246564984,
-0.3628579974,
0.1688976586,
-0.023051938,
-0.2760032117,
-0.2558930516,
-0.2667042017,
0.4486635625,
0.6059095263,
-0.0193064529,
0.7713024616,
0.2805854976,
-0.060039565,
-0.4810777307,
-0.5336864591,
-0.1180685014,
-0.2189756781,
-0.5469346642,
0.1972953677,
-0.0882618204,
-0.7054408789,
-0.0965871885,
-0.2197193205,
-0.2354164124,
0.0895601511,
0.2370094508,
0.1037381962,
-0.2192524374,
0.2171850055,
-0.1639793217,
-0.4202627242,
0.5142221451,
-0.1490195841,
0.4801422656,
-0.1645604521,
-0.6491193175,
-0.195454523,
-0.3120599687,
0.633877635,
-0.3219340742,
0.7230605483,
0.3947555721,
-0.1378702074,
0.1831829548,
-0.8518080711,
-0.2086815834,
-0.3961361051,
0.1733658314,
-0.3886985481,
-0.6183916926,
0.3429032564,
-0.3294959962,
-0.1196466461,
0.6406903863,
0.631736815,
-0.1018676087,
0.4288783669,
0.3010362685,
0.262003541,
0.3745038509,
-0.3983075619,
-0.0361688063,
-0.925999999,
-0.3468500972,
-0.3114355803,
0.0495447442,
-0.5263524055,
-0.7994651794,
0.2964532971,
-0.2126622647,
-0.2418952733,
0.0049821688,
-0.0433159806,
0.3780426979,
0.3688467145,
0.3281024396,
0.5456966162,
-0.2164609283,
0.0150486752,
-0.1341345459,
-0.4283504188,
-0.5775870681,
1.4702013731,
0.3367945254,
0.4847564101,
-0.0607843362,
0.4402718246,
0.184794277,
0.0513593964,
-0.8772735596,
0.6193931103,
-0.0859607011,
-0.7652502656,
-0.3460971713,
-0.5538499951,
-0.7631696463,
0.4233163893,
-0.320081234,
-0.1478404701,
0.156160906,
-0.4148851335,
-0.4105764627,
-0.0626324341,
-0.4640818536,
0.6800035834,
-0.4591684043,
-0.3664671779,
-0.4848109782,
-0.5824407339,
0.7675023675,
-0.2429608405,
0.4767501056,
0.1032062396,
-0.3741660416,
1.0085470676,
-0.3122741282,
0.9805390239,
-0.1792773902,
-0.2587963045,
0.5851095319,
-0.0870384723,
0.2757534683,
0.0608971082,
-0.1924905777,
0.1859983951,
0.0523085818,
-0.217075631,
-0.9230710864,
0.3234051466,
-0.6247332096,
-0.9210736752,
-0.4510160387,
-0.4156275094,
-0.3788521886,
0.2121808827,
0.056102816,
0.3780560493,
-0.4969285429,
0.3643254638,
0.9898172021,
-0.1292252988,
0.238467738,
0.8918985128,
-0.0825588554,
-0.5674019456,
0.5810821652,
0.2450885624,
0.3583079875,
0.4258526266,
0.3032730818,
-0.3996422291,
-0.6259515285,
0.1291603893,
0.4418219924,
-0.7674428225,
0.0004894151,
-0.6771691442,
-0.2010174543,
-0.2489778548,
0.194581911,
-0.2832697928,
-0.4131273627,
-0.050534647,
-0.2683939338,
-0.0115291597,
0.733478725,
-0.1770938337,
0.2799463868,
-0.7201456428,
0.3696604669,
0.7446523309,
0.0048079961,
-0.0411059707,
-0.6537205577,
-0.0635009706,
0.3052811921,
-0.2116285414,
-0.888566494,
-0.1189010739,
0.0926423818,
0.8571961522,
0.7971442938,
-0.1497239918,
0.6693785191,
-0.4218246639,
0.641522944,
0.1791171879,
-1.0018018484,
0.2956109941,
-0.2416338176,
0.096344173,
0.912712574,
0.40228194,
-0.2756745517,
-0.0756970495,
-0.7626891136,
-0.2283182144,
0.4438231587,
0.1807380468,
0.0710287467,
-0.0605412573,
0.5109233856,
0.1460364908,
0.5561631918,
-0.5338906646,
0.0536683872,
0.1333074272,
-0.1049083024,
-0.0661831871,
-0.4742852747,
-0.2625749707,
-0.3593674302,
0.3328295946,
0.0064032879,
0.1480755359,
-0.1390474588,
-0.5090383887,
0.1604796052,
0.095304884,
0.5983005166,
1.2194595337,
-0.0541055575,
0.2087115943,
0.6220418811,
-0.5905691385,
0.0236152094,
-0.4041466117,
0.1755718142,
-0.2882197201,
1.3002694845,
0.5483586788,
0.3648263216,
-0.5647460222,
0.7089524269,
0.1870463789,
-0.3880332708,
-0.2846623361,
0.1370326877,
0.123171635,
0.2131919712,
0.0212278236,
-0.0051578302,
0.2408295423,
-0.9467793703,
0.1032408997,
0.6915434599,
-0.2979292572,
-0.4620770514,
-0.0381076485,
0.3591350913,
0.0725046471,
0.8352787495,
0.0149708167,
-0.6606857181,
0.6487116218,
0.2417573482,
0.7312184572,
-0.2912334204,
0.2851034403,
0.4442238212,
0.3915798962,
-0.0623016544,
0.1181915179,
-0.3007158637,
-0.7595103979,
-0.5735938549,
-0.550295651,
-0.2628091276,
0.0555438809,
-0.6970327497,
0.119943507,
-0.3853474855,
-0.215262875,
-0.3477967381,
0.3638170362,
-0.8911280632,
0.3262198269,
-0.1456205994,
0.7652592063,
-0.9426354766,
0.628121376,
0.35962075,
-0.5011299253,
-0.3871808946,
-0.0468157046,
-0.3040757477,
-1.2112491131,
1.0470881462,
-0.0925657526,
-0.1232005283,
-0.382468313,
-0.0711492449,
-0.9814416766,
1.2174407244,
0.2557492852,
-0.6934038401,
-0.1289060414,
0.4759660065,
0.7485689521,
-0.5917952061,
0.8020038605,
0.9316368103,
0.9378179908,
0.3358959556,
-0.7920963168,
0.1052827463,
0.3687416017,
-0.0817248076,
-0.0679991096,
-0.5106206536,
0.7590460777,
-0.1330763698,
-0.3414310217,
-0.3199377358,
0.5318533778,
0.1485900879,
0.2957941592,
0.6004453301,
0.6687994599,
0.9544852376,
-0.0569427386,
0.8199228048,
-0.4460117221,
0.28846699,
1.0136349201,
-0.2475781739,
0.4892635345,
0.2790040672,
-0.5843709111,
0.810213387,
0.6902279258,
0.1468567252,
0.6195378304,
0.4141634703,
0.028672304,
-0.6032760143,
0.2064743787,
-0.5367727876,
0.4975323081,
0.4777551591,
-0.3451317847,
-0.1996038407,
-0.0855486989,
-0.050104361,
-0.0010941545,
-0.154099077,
1.1634963751,
0.2125906497,
-0.566630125,
0.480127573,
-0.2133240998,
0.2259400338,
-0.6216275692,
0.0013102639,
-0.1422577053,
-0.0682272986,
-0.2223707289,
-0.644395113,
0.6340659857,
-0.0576235875,
-0.1752665788,
-0.0659369156,
0.8879867196,
-0.3448838592,
-0.5316947699,
0.2089052051,
0.9278216362,
0.1953023672,
-0.3924038112,
-0.7010822892,
0.0986185223,
-0.13173002,
-0.2690218389,
0.0001798841,
0.7328290939,
0.1445588022,
0.540040195,
0.7046523094,
0.1223266274,
-0.0941980779,
0.0633414462,
0.8937848806,
-0.8040485978,
-0.0117731271,
-1.1444382668,
0.4570713639,
-0.1009826958,
0.0867635384,
0.8864262104,
0.5546376705,
0.3766519427,
-0.1815054715,
0.8330134153,
0.0607190467,
0.2924981415,
-0.7653891444,
0.2041060776,
-0.1526209414,
0.392822504,
-0.1217807457,
-1.1536753178,
0.0133172236,
0.5557641387,
-1.064339757,
0.3196222782,
1.1298158169,
0.4464430213,
-0.0337636545,
-0.129377231,
0.3340313435,
0.2153483629,
0.05256081,
0.6124278903,
1.2270995378,
-0.2521763146,
0.2852240801,
0.0605453625,
-0.4942706823,
-0.0785067603,
-0.9332100749,
-1.2899218798,
-0.488640219,
-0.2271206826,
-0.0213006139,
-0.0337832645,
0.3499270082,
0.6069989204,
-0.5451571345,
-0.3086590469,
-0.2681983113,
0.4262874722,
-0.1696464717,
-0.1734171957,
0.2353569567,
-0.7060531378,
-0.4720857441,
0.4227681756,
0.0314421952,
-0.2085021734,
-0.3398633599,
-0.0424590409,
-0.0241751038,
0.3603497446,
0.7182719707,
-0.1306379586,
-0.6187368631,
0.0301717818,
0.1341578513,
0.0624545999,
-0.1993695498,
1.2817463875,
-0.8161885738,
0.2944710553,
0.661862433,
0.4393641055,
0.5159243345,
0.174887374,
0.5959244967,
-0.1961490214,
-0.0346021987,
0.1186068803,
0.3154711127,
0.0779054016,
-0.2104700357,
0.7408538461,
0.3892536759,
-0.4234773815,
-0.5686550736,
0.4236650467,
-0.6944870949,
-0.4241853952,
1.2824184895,
-0.242926091,
-0.0664665624,
-0.0477561243,
-0.0096154679,
0.1951903701,
-0.0453129262,
0.6560077667,
0.9469082952,
0.0162765197,
0.0819255933,
-0.600145936,
0.6024900079,
0.059928529,
-0.929876864,
0.1018206924,
0.382948488,
0.5022366643,
0.3413212895,
0.746781528,
-0.2016231865,
0.1565842181,
-0.0463679209,
-0.2332946956,
-0.2370773405,
-0.5281713605,
-0.3318913281,
0.1735890061,
0.022658363,
-0.129988119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09113v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09113v2
|
AutoLoRA: Automatically Tuning Matrix Ranks in Low-Rank Adaptation Based on Meta Learning
| 2024-03-14T05:29:35 | 2024-03-17T17:55:47 |
Ruiyi Zhang, Rushi Qiang, Sai Ashish Somayajula, Pengtao Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large-scale pretraining followed by task-specific finetuning has achieved
great success in various NLP tasks. Since finetuning all parameters of large
pretrained models poses substantial computational and memory challenges,
several efficient finetuning methods have been developed. Among them, low-rank
adaptation (LoRA), which finetunes low-rank incremental update matrices on top
of frozen pretrained weights, has proven particularly effective. Nonetheless,
LoRA's uniform rank assignment across all layers, along with its reliance on an
exhaustive search to find the best rank, leads to high computation costs and
suboptimal finetuning performance. To address these limitations, we introduce
AutoLoRA, a meta learning based framework for automatically identifying the
optimal rank of each LoRA layer. AutoLoRA associates each rank-1 matrix in a
low-rank update matrix with a selection variable, which determines whether the
rank-1 matrix should be discarded. A meta learning based method is developed to
learn these selection variables. The optimal rank is determined by thresholding
the values of these variables. Our comprehensive experiments on natural
language understanding, generation, and sequence labeling demonstrate the
effectiveness of AutoLoRA.
|
[
-0.3851755857,
-0.5926414132,
0.2690620422,
0.2400687635,
-0.2693563402,
0.0875050053,
-0.225132063,
-0.2606193721,
0.2689064443,
0.2933256328,
-0.4821008444,
-0.5211421847,
-0.6747618914,
0.2012471557,
-0.1596543938,
1.1697614193,
0.1845189035,
-0.1095943972,
0.1991185546,
-0.2792116404,
-0.8674035072,
-0.1901371926,
-0.9006440639,
-0.1876820624,
0.8480240703,
0.7877082229,
0.5959851146,
0.7901777029,
0.4186298251,
0.3190226853,
0.173038587,
0.3518496454,
-0.830799818,
0.0891278312,
-0.4303247929,
-0.4732116461,
-0.8063008785,
0.0347132608,
0.5620096326,
0.6169294119,
-0.2328077853,
0.7125340104,
0.4897368252,
0.7468336225,
-1.0260082483,
0.0408634022,
-1.1038843393,
0.2536822557,
-0.2037467957,
-0.6748011112,
-0.3242605627,
-0.3103775084,
-0.0568281338,
-0.7058393359,
-0.0610230081,
-0.0247869864,
0.7301807404,
0.9325679541,
-0.2378572077,
-0.1676423997,
-0.7978129387,
0.5469262004,
-0.6040552258,
0.0754917562,
0.5108565688,
0.4831620157,
0.0656210482,
-0.3921783566,
-0.2362382561,
0.0357396975,
0.0486164652,
0.1517110169,
-0.2127896398,
0.0075942744,
0.0775901899,
0.3096926808,
-0.6200298667,
0.4568719566,
-0.2692938447,
0.1928993613,
0.508369565,
-0.0420902111,
0.2205584347,
-0.1275359839,
-0.1628657132,
-0.3030156493,
-0.4770850539,
-0.1678929478,
0.2681254148,
0.4221692681,
0.1967866421,
0.3019552529,
-0.0702309087,
0.8510981798,
0.5083594918,
-0.0198115874,
0.2097218782,
-0.0364801921,
-0.588714242,
0.3193918467,
0.4994309545,
0.0795924142,
0.2592652142,
-0.0777859092,
-0.0620106459,
-0.2004519552,
0.3619638979,
-0.5504083633,
-0.4464895725,
-0.0415928215,
-0.4459519088,
-0.4206743836,
-0.1734291613,
-0.8404133916,
-0.3276856244,
-0.4763166308,
1.0050886869,
-0.1017675474,
0.0500289239,
0.0906823128,
0.3277600706,
0.3154849112,
0.3580271304,
-1.2014865875,
0.3471955955,
0.3483895659,
0.7415283918,
-0.3467805088,
-0.4739069343,
-0.8968897462,
0.0740831867,
-0.3949085772,
0.8356742263,
-0.2180824727,
0.1292269826,
-0.3203492165,
-0.013884129,
-0.4938532114,
-0.583091855,
0.2210383266,
-0.4628689289,
0.2353624552,
-0.0811556801,
-0.1405134648,
-0.0285641961,
0.0150051182,
-0.7121252418,
0.9425632954,
0.2806994021,
-0.5601052642,
0.4233320355,
-0.888409853,
-0.2761990726,
-0.1587330699,
0.2580745816,
-0.3913704455,
0.1493053436,
0.1951080114,
0.2730712295,
-0.1825657189,
-0.0108666327,
-0.1455778927,
-0.2398638129,
-0.037435066,
-0.3173658252,
0.6133078337,
0.43157956,
-0.5188268423,
0.21531111,
-0.7914596796,
0.2126137912,
0.0132508911,
-0.3754003346,
-0.2517642081,
-0.0008058421,
-0.1778350025,
0.3484988809,
0.2213824093,
-0.0602899045,
0.365614444,
-0.5177237391,
0.370149225,
0.8972972035,
-0.0290967654,
0.5369092822,
-0.1123248488,
0.4461731911,
-0.1373921931,
0.3651700318,
0.3323373795,
-0.1715234667,
-1.2096333504,
-0.0461192802,
0.6484165192,
0.7617886662,
-0.6513711214,
0.733114481,
-0.2577920854,
-0.550665319,
-0.6839873791,
0.6340333223,
0.3050183952,
0.3351005912,
0.898273766,
-0.329639852,
-0.5871764421,
-0.8360902071,
-0.3373776972,
0.2029338628,
-0.0051799929,
0.1572209895,
0.3528296351,
-0.3439662457,
1.1459879875,
-0.5891572833,
-0.9516824484,
-0.0476289429,
0.245120436,
0.2386568934,
0.702639997,
0.7065833211,
-0.4323522747,
-0.781565547,
-0.1446637213,
-0.4730395675,
-0.3714594245,
-0.206881687,
-0.3261061311,
0.1549419165,
0.6118002534,
-0.1082369015,
0.2093904614,
0.7953696847,
-0.1834900081,
0.1050801128,
-0.5127806664,
-0.197515741,
-1.0180851221,
0.4047108889,
-0.2854590118,
-0.5836384892,
-0.4708565176,
-0.3045913577,
-0.1929493248,
-0.134238109,
-0.188041836,
0.3318710923,
-0.3712262213,
-0.3172703683,
-0.4875573516,
0.0811901391,
-0.0337843224,
0.7464734316,
-0.162644133,
0.6308836341,
0.194393754,
-0.7177294493,
0.0169696473,
0.2588891983,
-0.1774962991,
0.458658129,
-0.4271996617,
0.2325198501,
-0.0590248965,
0.3132825196,
-0.7389226556,
0.036013592,
0.3190557063,
-0.1730199307,
0.2534304559,
-0.3883964717,
-0.3762195408,
-0.0521894284,
-0.0731713623,
0.4595651031,
0.314740926,
-0.5803673863,
0.4276775122,
0.5128394365,
-0.1988080293,
-0.6358963847,
-0.4155783355,
0.1802065074,
-0.2784490585,
0.1259960979,
0.3600659966,
-0.2645277381,
0.1521489471,
-0.2951999009,
0.0527082086,
-0.0272417478,
0.484523803,
-0.0397622064,
-0.1112731993,
-0.2224209905,
0.1388386488,
0.1435769498,
-0.5105940104,
-0.1654381752,
-0.4929625094,
0.5334196687,
-0.1609979719,
-0.1810887605,
-0.3262538016,
-0.0293221269,
0.5115685463,
-0.2978295684,
0.6533131003,
0.918530643,
-0.284830749,
-0.5894153714,
-0.3639734685,
-0.0265122205,
-0.497908324,
0.2746809423,
-0.1790817827,
-0.3844821155,
0.3458117843,
-0.1698278338,
0.0650481656,
0.8101887107,
0.3950681984,
-0.1345061064,
1.132055521,
0.7725061774,
-0.2856769264,
0.6503260136,
-0.4089905918,
-0.12864016,
-0.7887967825,
0.1608910859,
-0.4757816195,
-0.7635008097,
-0.6068854332,
-0.4308405817,
0.5330759883,
0.0377149098,
-0.3422546983,
0.3695868552,
-0.7236591578,
0.6397146583,
0.4317855537,
0.056620378,
0.3792881966,
-0.0742185935,
0.0613009371,
0.1401190907,
-0.914242208,
-0.1633812189,
1.0594577789,
0.3128603399,
0.6729748845,
0.1936245561,
0.5694788694,
0.6748603582,
0.3252645433,
-0.570892036,
0.2046006024,
-0.4798466563,
-0.3533908427,
-0.5225883126,
-0.3178951144,
-1.0689140558,
0.3492822051,
-0.5577334166,
-0.4440342188,
0.5708592534,
0.546448946,
-0.7070976496,
0.2017612904,
-0.5226634145,
0.9985498786,
-0.2791933715,
-0.2986531556,
-0.3153963387,
-0.7424251437,
0.1181667149,
-0.2845314443,
-0.0114041343,
-0.0053000813,
0.1172007397,
0.9088089466,
-0.2800552249,
0.8476791978,
-0.2971344888,
-0.3695361316,
-0.0323469676,
0.0888900533,
0.4195315838,
0.1149402559,
-0.0593493879,
-0.1531109214,
0.2097285241,
-0.4001966715,
-0.565926671,
0.6431638598,
-0.9381194115,
-0.2551410496,
-0.4686255157,
-0.302994132,
-0.3022782207,
0.3222818077,
0.326613903,
0.2544561923,
-0.2597681284,
0.1815308481,
0.8084290028,
-0.4113484025,
0.2798017263,
0.5396887064,
-0.1173859537,
-0.5591071248,
1.219265461,
0.1636528373,
0.1699451059,
0.4127302766,
0.2387660891,
0.0959253237,
-0.5972659588,
-0.4753611684,
0.115862757,
-0.7671930194,
-0.512329936,
-0.4389723837,
-0.316776067,
-0.2043539137,
-0.2036789507,
-0.5464243293,
-0.3291030824,
-0.531909883,
0.1203252673,
0.0695265532,
0.7337781191,
-0.2916889489,
0.2867088318,
-0.4509033561,
0.5531868935,
0.6915112734,
0.3657003045,
0.0186702963,
-0.6301210523,
-0.4977802336,
-0.0287780147,
-0.223152712,
-0.646869123,
0.5721569657,
0.7149431705,
0.4304099381,
0.3612395227,
0.0927900746,
0.7585126162,
-0.6544786096,
0.2001486868,
-0.204391107,
-1.0811059475,
0.579436779,
-0.3983589113,
0.4585539401,
1.1283603907,
0.1188012809,
-0.4057685733,
-0.2043105662,
-0.4936736822,
-0.8146744967,
0.6524474621,
0.0822257847,
-0.0293991677,
0.2775592804,
0.5014057755,
0.2215764225,
0.1251256317,
-0.8793600202,
-0.3234873116,
-0.4896334708,
-0.3234725893,
-0.4917805493,
-0.1222757846,
-0.1511756927,
-0.5488246679,
0.6511623263,
-0.6805104613,
0.2985810339,
0.1985475421,
-0.8611260653,
-0.2826943398,
0.1843886226,
0.797367394,
0.9074752331,
-0.4516144991,
0.1555728912,
0.7567300797,
-0.3754638135,
0.0504330434,
-0.0444512516,
0.0028900325,
-0.1594120711,
0.2607018054,
0.8187616467,
0.6312639117,
-0.2424088269,
0.3030712903,
0.0906486362,
-0.188356638,
-0.318348825,
0.2872419953,
-0.2545606792,
0.0218197517,
0.5889108181,
0.1363051087,
0.0602649786,
-0.483163625,
0.1461765617,
0.3546894193,
-0.4320865273,
-0.2544743121,
0.5543015599,
0.2455032468,
-0.130576387,
0.2460241914,
-0.0839108676,
-0.4533618987,
0.4362010062,
0.510150671,
0.879811883,
-0.4837833941,
0.2912584245,
0.3522851467,
0.3439512551,
0.0600591078,
-0.0691823214,
-0.0701834857,
-0.3925424516,
-0.3534126878,
-0.9093385935,
-0.3301512003,
0.1734548062,
-0.671299696,
0.2866025269,
-0.5862748623,
-0.0914758295,
-0.0836748928,
0.2428804636,
-0.6721152663,
0.2647058368,
0.3920263052,
0.8484158516,
-1.0136387348,
0.9015395045,
0.3193269372,
-0.2043712288,
-0.4063956738,
-0.0542223118,
-0.2463897318,
-0.5648388267,
0.8384242654,
-0.0816709697,
-0.3661870956,
0.6826158762,
-0.36232692,
-1.269949317,
1.3530925512,
0.631989181,
-0.1691530496,
-0.2555639148,
0.1711424142,
0.7058989406,
-0.5249047279,
0.160150215,
0.4367360771,
0.6618430614,
-0.3819524944,
-1.1307444572,
-0.1098184213,
-0.1395542175,
-0.1133003384,
-0.1198324487,
-0.673905313,
0.8529364467,
0.1310807168,
-0.0528522506,
-0.1220449731,
0.6395469904,
-0.1813426167,
0.1748858094,
0.9097251296,
0.4119969606,
0.8120532632,
0.3347260058,
0.4316094518,
-0.2821160853,
0.4014205039,
1.2213642597,
-0.1424234509,
0.9119542241,
0.0266817175,
0.083235696,
0.8977406025,
0.6721779704,
-0.1536005884,
0.5943928957,
0.2376633137,
0.3122566938,
-0.3385404944,
0.2300601006,
-0.3379278779,
0.8325873017,
0.439047128,
-0.4210663438,
-0.3692745268,
0.2566840351,
-0.1362114251,
-0.201626569,
-0.4479718804,
1.1526812315,
0.0395449735,
-0.7920021415,
1.017011404,
-0.0576722957,
0.4189621508,
-0.5292513967,
-0.0111406203,
-0.1026689112,
0.3431866765,
-0.2512382269,
-0.0244913604,
0.109759219,
-0.1244769916,
-0.2135700434,
-0.3807713091,
0.6831809282,
-0.5221034884,
-0.3899763525,
0.3006246388,
0.5479925275,
-0.1442421228,
0.0043801847,
-0.9816625118,
-0.2413074523,
-0.3490585387,
-0.142148748,
0.6047484875,
0.079251647,
0.0842995495,
0.671990335,
0.6997221112,
0.027623035,
-0.0690640956,
-0.0421018898,
0.7862403989,
-0.4798605144,
-0.7516870499,
-0.6852240562,
-0.0005323173,
-0.0050101643,
-0.2211930007,
0.6304141879,
0.4204065502,
0.4909106791,
-0.0573780499,
0.4771605432,
0.2491717935,
0.3912315667,
-0.7992581725,
1.0785378218,
-0.6152919531,
0.1375101507,
-0.4105009437,
-1.3184535503,
-0.3161242008,
0.7181280255,
-0.3007295132,
0.0970377028,
0.7612165213,
0.4592832029,
-0.3974955082,
-0.57031703,
0.221664086,
0.3491458595,
0.0482405163,
0.6946031451,
0.2729612589,
-0.4262711108,
0.4623658061,
0.0001243629,
-0.2437762469,
-0.6778387427,
-1.0758767128,
-0.7078542709,
-0.6260057092,
-0.2408347577,
-0.1258338243,
0.2146679908,
1.0364570618,
0.878885448,
-0.8491036296,
-0.2197916508,
0.0552861169,
0.1033890843,
-0.4935066104,
-0.1979147643,
0.6750155687,
-0.6598039865,
-0.6819040179,
0.5765356421,
0.1348811686,
-0.1966323256,
-0.4737950265,
0.0192443021,
-0.5368350148,
0.1199849471,
0.5946131349,
0.6735494137,
-0.2338821888,
-0.2101499587,
-0.3113492131,
-0.2321808338,
0.1655641794,
0.6358998418,
-1.0202316046,
0.1845620275,
0.4792082906,
0.4794671237,
0.3688414991,
0.2326733023,
0.6371893883,
-0.6382831335,
-0.1186702102,
0.0501733683,
0.0762476772,
0.2231714875,
-0.2606811821,
0.5216708183,
-0.0471724309,
-0.6802186966,
-0.9352489114,
0.0034326937,
-0.9492459297,
-0.2960898578,
1.0244878531,
0.2435600907,
-0.2578749955,
-0.2331520021,
-0.1377458125,
0.3757838905,
0.0739368647,
1.0238887072,
0.1584435403,
0.0931400955,
-0.0436419286,
-0.7927318811,
1.1138632298,
0.7538533807,
-0.941780448,
0.1310294718,
0.0464219302,
0.2604448795,
0.2014982998,
0.4529123008,
0.3504513204,
0.3169648647,
-0.7064135671,
-0.1216239929,
-0.0735934228,
-0.4843121171,
-0.5596114993,
0.1307905167,
0.3292935491,
-0.0380395465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09097v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09097v1
|
AI on AI: Exploring the Utility of GPT as an Expert Annotator of AI Publications
| 2024-03-14T04:43:02 | 2024-03-14T04:43:02 |
Autumn Toney-Wails, Christian Schoeberl, James Dunham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Identifying scientific publications that are within a dynamic field of
research often requires costly annotation by subject-matter experts. Resources
like widely-accepted classification criteria or field taxonomies are
unavailable for a domain like artificial intelligence (AI), which spans
emerging topics and technologies. We address these challenges by inferring a
functional definition of AI research from existing expert labels, and then
evaluating state-of-the-art chatbot models on the task of expert data
annotation. Using the arXiv publication database as ground-truth, we experiment
with prompt engineering for GPT chatbot models to identify an alternative,
automated expert annotation pipeline that assigns AI labels with 94% accuracy.
For comparison, we fine-tune SPECTER, a transformer language model pre-trained
on scientific publications, that achieves 96% accuracy (only 2% higher than
GPT) on classifying AI publications. Our results indicate that with effective
prompt engineering, chatbots can be used as reliable data annotators even where
subject-area expertise is required. To evaluate the utility of
chatbot-annotated datasets on downstream classification tasks, we train a new
classifier on GPT-labeled data and compare its performance to the arXiv-trained
model. The classifier trained on GPT-labeled data outperforms the arXiv-trained
model by nine percentage points, achieving 82% accuracy.
|
[
-0.3629374206,
-0.6037429571,
0.3356221914,
-0.0669902563,
0.0678871498,
0.3991138935,
-0.0520724952,
-0.656955421,
-0.1084859371,
0.2172498405,
-0.1774630249,
-0.2699610293,
-0.7538489699,
0.2040338516,
-0.3759557605,
1.1706932783,
0.2021095753,
-0.1533311456,
-0.4305500388,
0.0318909548,
-0.3381256163,
-0.5973431468,
-0.7105758786,
-0.3215278387,
0.5869594216,
0.1092194021,
0.8874696493,
0.6916243434,
0.771684587,
0.3355776072,
0.0024697671,
0.2800473571,
-0.1849368662,
-0.1001197174,
0.0628808811,
-0.4304425418,
-0.3456636667,
0.3894169331,
0.2815469205,
0.5044510961,
0.2673759162,
0.1267065704,
-0.0575671121,
0.3697731495,
-0.2671813369,
0.6490268707,
-0.656698823,
0.0536742955,
-0.1342521757,
-0.1943926215,
-0.4855373502,
-0.3892272115,
0.2642848194,
-0.9377799034,
0.361138612,
0.235458225,
0.8945169449,
0.9035385847,
-0.1427226067,
-0.2672618032,
-0.9743826389,
0.4954899549,
-0.3648253977,
0.2577072382,
0.4956431389,
0.385153234,
0.0099255033,
-0.5733069181,
-0.6775854826,
-0.6425540447,
-0.2272013873,
0.1696218997,
-0.2357721925,
0.1563436985,
0.2801177204,
0.0283812545,
-0.5283859968,
0.0814937949,
-0.3834317923,
-0.1944642067,
0.8522279263,
-0.2100290805,
0.3573793769,
0.1977413744,
-0.0955211297,
-0.1379942,
-0.4045785367,
-0.1130580083,
0.3498665094,
0.2782436311,
0.3147564232,
0.5648506284,
-0.0728141218,
0.5391486883,
0.0650520399,
0.2418404818,
0.299264133,
-0.2397885621,
0.0351277106,
-0.0995930508,
0.95051682,
0.0668508932,
0.3055824637,
-0.4678439796,
-0.015314186,
-0.0625993162,
0.4030441046,
-0.4397746027,
-0.7061802149,
0.1218293011,
-0.1637991667,
-0.2864146233,
-0.044433631,
-0.4156962037,
-0.7071866989,
-0.2522757351,
0.3248488605,
-0.3140772283,
-0.2382090837,
-0.4207431674,
-0.2455078512,
0.0235251766,
0.5344411135,
-0.7752513289,
-0.1587333083,
0.7089331746,
0.981382072,
-0.0947372541,
-0.3523905873,
-0.2033989727,
-0.0301047079,
-0.3781554401,
1.1459091902,
-0.7660310864,
-0.5263116956,
-0.2202008516,
-0.287551105,
-0.2568002343,
-0.2815766335,
0.5840452909,
-0.5763896704,
0.1260146499,
0.0713957921,
-0.6592354774,
-0.2237960398,
0.2258313447,
-0.6951341033,
0.8610152006,
0.1667321622,
-0.6287443042,
0.5705056787,
-1.1164410114,
-0.1070870236,
0.444555819,
-0.1932546049,
-0.3455325067,
-0.3065843582,
0.1148198918,
0.3246791065,
-0.1642378271,
0.3037000895,
-0.1251459867,
-0.1670716107,
0.3891197145,
-0.4843956232,
0.583152473,
0.2588908672,
-0.2647919655,
0.2583512366,
-0.5376796126,
-0.2440456003,
-0.1663486958,
-0.2964179218,
-0.4036168456,
0.1367277205,
0.0666752458,
-0.1701136827,
0.0921279639,
-0.5017155409,
0.5391880274,
-0.2092959434,
0.5743778944,
0.6283650398,
-0.1524600238,
0.3137111962,
-0.3058235943,
0.3573506773,
-0.4275221825,
0.1089189723,
-0.0942321941,
-0.9398137927,
-0.5261414647,
-0.4001419246,
0.6633774042,
0.7605538368,
-0.7094955444,
0.4731024206,
-0.1462036222,
-0.9335315228,
-0.7726860046,
-0.1743798703,
0.2038343996,
0.6841600537,
0.4647691548,
-0.1456126571,
-0.1539855301,
-0.8476196527,
-0.3808753192,
-0.5094687939,
-0.0263473839,
0.4440210164,
0.4344367981,
-0.3011816442,
1.18503654,
-0.2486578673,
-0.1814203411,
0.1252993047,
0.815685451,
-0.047961574,
0.499427706,
0.3879615366,
-1.0527762175,
-0.5007155538,
0.1524186581,
-0.8139634728,
-0.1144566089,
-0.26192981,
0.0438776314,
0.2007329911,
0.3209190369,
-0.8739497066,
0.4975819588,
-0.112992093,
-0.2985176444,
0.3834336996,
-0.1758288592,
0.4675831795,
-0.5127263069,
0.4201853871,
0.314430654,
0.0784403533,
-0.6674429178,
-0.2111788839,
-0.1690504104,
-0.2202142924,
-0.1863064915,
0.6905909777,
-0.2525684536,
0.2347029895,
-0.4491827786,
-0.1356103867,
-0.3123781681,
0.3183795214,
0.2098506689,
0.9750296474,
0.4006915689,
-0.3846655786,
0.3925482929,
0.5869566202,
-0.0973989889,
0.1986640841,
-0.7180737257,
0.4421018362,
-0.0003409541,
0.1920554489,
-0.9645614624,
-0.2417226583,
0.5612938404,
-0.6969044209,
0.2500072122,
-0.3818108439,
-0.6255285144,
-0.4749380052,
0.1363988072,
0.1195515469,
0.5080251098,
-0.2129320502,
0.5824790597,
0.4811978936,
-0.3736012578,
-0.557933867,
-0.5173249841,
0.1249158382,
-0.1385676414,
-0.2692496479,
0.1299141794,
-0.0648712516,
-0.2485717684,
0.1813158095,
0.0599101447,
-0.2191633582,
0.2950082719,
0.2253691852,
0.2588038743,
-0.0580483228,
0.4036460519,
-0.0948801562,
-0.3570364714,
0.1624466479,
-0.1513786912,
0.1497031152,
-0.1556425393,
-0.4493371844,
-0.5039217472,
0.0981090218,
0.3754675686,
-0.22955814,
0.5577865839,
0.751984179,
-0.2938854992,
0.2059435546,
-0.4365137517,
-0.2166231871,
-0.4396210313,
0.4087633193,
-0.1193235219,
-0.6373583674,
0.2592714727,
-0.0656101704,
0.35979864,
0.7444855571,
0.2371471822,
-0.1819144934,
1.0743886232,
0.7690087557,
-0.3236788213,
0.5184832215,
-0.2044020295,
0.3762394488,
-0.3472530842,
-0.1657256484,
-0.8834517002,
-0.1562314779,
-0.559987843,
-0.2158444673,
0.3690360188,
-0.140151307,
-0.3366797268,
0.0935164616,
-1.065705657,
0.4527358711,
1.0765862465,
0.0155268712,
0.3168503046,
-0.1065470576,
0.8124170899,
0.1966149658,
-0.5567169785,
-0.8435786366,
1.1287362576,
0.2723291516,
0.5180968046,
-0.3921559751,
0.3176410794,
0.9334892035,
0.7853574753,
-0.7792608738,
0.3582683802,
0.1466973722,
-0.7121784091,
-0.4242067635,
-0.2694924772,
-0.767994523,
-0.2144040763,
-0.2640971243,
-0.6467443109,
0.150891453,
0.3083056211,
-0.3900505304,
0.2733142376,
-0.8561866879,
0.8054203391,
-0.3502053022,
0.0254150443,
-0.0522802398,
-0.6963022351,
0.0013567462,
-0.2452901006,
0.048867099,
-0.1173528135,
-0.0387211889,
0.9713240862,
-0.2344053686,
0.9119938612,
-0.2833316624,
0.2055158764,
0.4460926354,
-0.270650059,
0.377748847,
-0.0063416688,
-0.1536287367,
0.4181829095,
-0.0418106057,
-0.2324330509,
-0.5688987374,
0.1856543422,
-1.0732975006,
-0.8100045919,
-0.6451724768,
-0.6212966442,
-0.3145125508,
0.179773584,
0.1879874617,
0.0654759854,
0.0574785769,
-0.0978277996,
0.5408520103,
-0.0097090937,
0.1983744204,
0.2595482767,
0.2910111547,
-0.2796120942,
1.2191613913,
0.1917418242,
-0.1698251963,
0.4013068378,
0.0652118623,
-0.1563319564,
-0.7618978024,
-0.5299798846,
-0.1227785051,
-0.5563443899,
-0.1937143505,
-0.7951983809,
-0.4621310532,
-0.3699534237,
-0.0986045599,
-0.1799407303,
-0.4859495461,
-0.4179853499,
0.002896538,
0.6981009245,
0.796507597,
-0.1066115946,
0.3630898595,
-0.7730543017,
-0.0643437877,
0.1740089506,
0.0168361161,
-0.2214751542,
-0.3357305825,
-0.290781647,
0.2359216511,
-0.375880748,
-0.7184330225,
0.2631168067,
0.3132980466,
0.7177481055,
0.2264119238,
0.1446638852,
0.1153406277,
-0.3777484596,
0.7975819707,
-0.2339870185,
-0.6632938981,
0.6476128697,
-0.4439772367,
-0.1878740191,
0.5169771314,
0.7930966616,
-0.3599198461,
-0.4718623459,
-0.7679957151,
-0.8855837584,
0.5688457489,
0.1986846477,
0.0377036929,
0.1429253221,
0.5216856599,
0.3989463747,
0.3886862993,
-0.4299189746,
-0.2533709109,
-0.3951753676,
-0.3534525931,
-0.1502026767,
0.1839736104,
-0.2348817885,
-0.0358352363,
0.8522468209,
-0.2067370266,
0.5979882479,
0.2427489758,
-0.0334063247,
0.2057253122,
0.0762440041,
0.3587564826,
0.6387429237,
-0.1041423157,
-0.173904255,
-0.17964077,
-0.57756567,
-0.0892744884,
0.7249328494,
-0.5438411832,
-0.0369869955,
0.4505096376,
0.6466049552,
-0.4493128359,
-0.5876774788,
0.1580158621,
0.0794833899,
-0.1316076368,
-0.1948745251,
0.3920542598,
-0.1995563805,
0.3913292289,
0.7639343143,
0.4518527091,
0.312830627,
-0.2517308891,
0.1451281458,
0.4267739058,
-0.3961766362,
-0.2702755928,
0.9034419656,
0.4089523554,
-0.6383669972,
0.7310506701,
-0.1624224782,
-0.5888522863,
0.8553381562,
-0.0185705703,
0.7718244195,
-0.0081001902,
0.3015288711,
0.0391078182,
0.3277361095,
0.0194115248,
-0.2009269446,
-0.1937662214,
-0.5793879032,
-0.2819558084,
-0.1976467222,
-1.057104826,
-0.0694308951,
-0.1903606951,
0.1201210395,
-0.2293978333,
-0.3344862759,
0.3956489563,
0.0916150957,
-0.7187565565,
0.1398016661,
0.1926998496,
0.8702873588,
-0.8352096677,
0.5999019146,
0.9403061271,
-0.7530809045,
-0.6337291002,
-0.1624111533,
-0.0943684801,
-0.7803843617,
0.585268259,
0.1745388061,
0.2627791166,
0.2774496675,
-0.9016417265,
-0.6927072406,
0.9744308591,
0.221750319,
-0.4141533077,
0.0932098851,
0.0462274328,
0.8330392838,
-0.1768612564,
0.8484294415,
0.3730832934,
0.6667153835,
0.0255494509,
-1.0379246473,
-0.2367447913,
-0.6279808879,
-0.3994054794,
-0.0704801977,
-0.7923845649,
0.3634614646,
-0.1782622635,
0.0369939134,
-0.0366073027,
0.7624126673,
0.0980146974,
0.5728791356,
0.4306898117,
0.1580542922,
1.1634986401,
-0.3075899482,
0.8100293279,
-0.2944585085,
0.247573331,
0.8068900108,
-0.1467930526,
0.5102750063,
0.2015245855,
-0.2229991555,
0.1874561012,
0.9996592402,
-0.528855145,
0.5548246503,
0.0164316259,
-0.1838380098,
-0.1505287588,
-0.2948454022,
-0.4172605872,
0.1212275773,
0.3592946827,
-0.2046851963,
0.2523600459,
0.2328081429,
0.0607484579,
-0.1801336557,
-0.2650781572,
0.8318636417,
-0.2306173593,
-0.5936432481,
0.2052864432,
-0.3083458245,
0.578271389,
-0.2547426522,
-0.1205650121,
-0.1250642091,
0.0169941168,
-0.0986191556,
-0.8599944711,
0.2978487313,
0.1629148126,
-0.1329257935,
-0.1694543213,
0.7631388903,
-0.2466018647,
-0.5744366646,
-0.2682166696,
0.5292163491,
0.4296342134,
-0.11046049,
-0.7482444048,
-0.2794270217,
-0.1774336547,
-0.4874245822,
0.022044614,
0.3948459923,
0.0147401858,
0.9287512898,
0.5606023669,
0.0084982263,
-0.1049309149,
-0.1588448882,
0.8916684389,
-0.493655324,
-0.2479401082,
-0.6391543746,
0.4730432332,
-0.163447246,
-0.5450671911,
0.478274256,
0.3884742856,
0.7834054828,
-0.0141383503,
1.4020165205,
-0.3335590065,
0.4633286595,
-0.0823127925,
1.0959544182,
-0.3115959466,
0.1080925912,
0.0113603575,
-0.5744573474,
-0.432942152,
0.559987843,
-0.5934153795,
0.2009932995,
0.2848618627,
0.558057487,
0.0739960745,
0.3088056445,
-0.039834436,
0.1665601879,
0.6236690283,
0.0789560601,
0.8922417164,
-0.1527901739,
0.5542179942,
-0.1914161146,
-0.4108482003,
-0.1652683616,
-0.7540230155,
-1.0909067392,
-0.6525740027,
-0.6907841563,
-0.0773742124,
0.3875872493,
0.8679593801,
0.7045604587,
-0.8018652797,
0.2977692187,
-0.1208858192,
0.0192690175,
-0.287109673,
-0.242868796,
0.5694075823,
-0.4906369746,
-0.7887602448,
0.3248552382,
-0.0814397335,
0.042265024,
-0.2414571345,
0.1195119321,
-0.1042280868,
-0.1056075171,
0.2081037909,
0.5682817101,
-0.4763344526,
-0.4678992927,
0.0636949539,
-0.061942067,
0.103845112,
0.6026675701,
-0.8246712685,
0.3375521004,
0.3120419979,
1.0227136612,
0.1295617074,
0.1925440878,
0.4880158305,
-0.3317744434,
-0.030760482,
0.5814805627,
0.104300037,
0.3484177589,
-0.6393859982,
0.9412153959,
0.3519096375,
-1.077534318,
-0.7911213636,
-0.3215736151,
-0.8216622472,
0.005413665,
0.9723898172,
-0.3536901772,
-0.1052048281,
-0.3695814908,
-0.4355933964,
0.4570778608,
-0.7165676951,
1.1818761826,
0.7167308927,
-0.446539402,
-0.260061115,
-0.7044876814,
0.6913669109,
0.1750608981,
-0.9559634328,
0.0271986574,
0.3679316938,
-0.0779330134,
0.5035641789,
0.5188168883,
0.3740533292,
0.1370217502,
0.0384456776,
0.3367821574,
-0.4280289114,
-0.3379386961,
0.1073576733,
0.0425845832,
0.1936000884,
-0.1012964398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09092v1
|
MCFEND: A Multi-source Benchmark Dataset for Chinese Fake News Detection
| 2024-03-14T04:32:13 | 2024-03-14T04:32:13 |
Yupeng Li, Haorui He, Jin Bai, Dacheng Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The prevalence of fake news across various online sources has had a
significant influence on the public. Existing Chinese fake news detection
datasets are limited to news sourced solely from Weibo. However, fake news
originating from multiple sources exhibits diversity in various aspects,
including its content and social context. Methods trained on purely one single
news source can hardly be applicable to real-world scenarios. Our pilot
experiment demonstrates that the F1 score of the state-of-the-art method that
learns from a large Chinese fake news detection dataset, Weibo-21, drops
significantly from 0.943 to 0.470 when the test data is changed to multi-source
news data, failing to identify more than one-third of the multi-source fake
news. To address this limitation, we constructed the first multi-source
benchmark dataset for Chinese fake news detection, termed MCFEND, which is
composed of news we collected from diverse sources such as social platforms,
messaging apps, and traditional online news outlets. Notably, such news has
been fact-checked by 14 authoritative fact-checking agencies worldwide. In
addition, various existing Chinese fake news detection methods are thoroughly
evaluated on our proposed dataset in cross-source, multi-source, and unseen
source ways. MCFEND, as a benchmark dataset, aims to advance Chinese fake news
detection approaches in real-world scenarios.
|
[
-0.4993207753,
-0.7465399504,
0.3067508042,
0.2469076961,
-0.3988641202,
0.092071332,
0.1118105203,
-0.4271953106,
0.1999294609,
0.0140956203,
-0.3729956746,
-0.5326377153,
-0.4127207696,
-0.0506811142,
-0.3132910728,
0.9631086588,
-0.0418751091,
0.2671481967,
0.2948743999,
-0.49399212,
0.27708444,
-0.5103292465,
-0.5044547915,
0.1522555053,
0.6752405763,
0.4535186291,
0.367254734,
0.8148286939,
0.5100774765,
0.1236705557,
0.3463256955,
0.5818189383,
-0.2263328433,
-0.4762991965,
-0.2224271894,
0.0082714818,
-0.1511792839,
0.3242022395,
0.6018801928,
0.092848897,
-0.1367291659,
0.2987530828,
-0.1176748797,
0.2132141292,
-0.7498630285,
-0.3310099244,
-0.4641759098,
0.0721225217,
-0.6288605332,
-0.1327877492,
-0.3160601556,
-0.2649179399,
-0.4144386947,
-0.4425947964,
0.5572242737,
0.0750704184,
1.0060844421,
-0.3957734704,
-0.8639886379,
-0.1055955663,
-0.3864690363,
0.5250398517,
-0.4918642938,
0.4046946466,
-0.3089179695,
0.5056017041,
-0.0500914454,
-0.7018898726,
-0.8969436884,
-0.3416722417,
0.0287527777,
0.07410115,
0.2034644336,
-0.3528787196,
0.2663044035,
0.2441446781,
-0.6470513344,
-0.272561729,
-0.3953105807,
-0.4726119041,
0.608265996,
-0.2275028229,
0.4824055731,
-0.2154913545,
-0.6713468432,
-0.4195521772,
-0.6653264165,
0.0084494846,
0.53567487,
0.4097592533,
-0.1807365119,
0.0600438379,
-0.4319440424,
0.3396891356,
-0.0490021594,
-0.2364469171,
0.6588950157,
-0.3464020193,
-0.0436280891,
0.2401237935,
0.8142667413,
0.3838251531,
0.0507229455,
0.1214679927,
-0.1319608688,
0.226186797,
0.1562708765,
-0.7513620257,
-0.256757766,
0.0382451601,
-0.5956403613,
-0.6258370876,
0.8778997064,
-0.5237978101,
-0.4409362078,
0.0442148969,
0.2461229861,
-0.1172211915,
-0.6657320857,
-0.3499904573,
-0.5305891633,
0.1056873649,
0.2030797452,
-0.1747305393,
0.1733518094,
0.5293909311,
0.9658892751,
-0.2553295493,
-0.6007143259,
-0.8264221549,
0.0726979226,
-0.6195456386,
0.8615347147,
-0.2476186454,
-0.0420837589,
-0.3231678903,
0.289960742,
0.3158812225,
-0.5625076294,
0.8865374923,
-0.2654714584,
-0.1073670015,
-0.5063233376,
-0.0898617357,
-0.2473031431,
0.5461221933,
-0.7363396287,
0.8455356359,
-0.0116352644,
-0.9101625681,
0.5864488482,
-0.4933493435,
-0.7114142179,
-0.2710635066,
-0.0312214196,
-0.3803234994,
0.052775491,
0.5679865479,
0.4178953469,
0.1256238669,
0.4074698389,
-0.8610703945,
-0.3293344676,
0.0670507699,
-0.7340399027,
0.8369629383,
0.2832482457,
-0.2147170156,
-0.1597106755,
-0.6166532636,
-0.1817881167,
0.2492961138,
-0.1225921139,
-0.3595219553,
-0.1681664884,
0.3213370144,
0.700573504,
-0.3234306872,
-0.9440432191,
-0.0655463487,
0.120483011,
-0.0385696925,
0.8298051357,
0.1853946,
-0.1322105527,
-0.789511621,
0.1462237984,
0.6713937521,
0.0989784524,
-0.3773440421,
-0.2537739277,
-0.3522523344,
0.0201617964,
0.1858287156,
0.3872250915,
-0.9631232023,
-0.2709469199,
-0.1954816133,
-0.6185660362,
-0.3787487149,
0.1392788738,
0.4916567802,
0.3639563322,
0.3503287435,
0.0283845626,
-0.4048827291,
-0.670973897,
-0.9005090594,
0.0689631179,
0.0221173987,
0.0319616981,
0.5781995654,
0.1676022857,
0.5358784795,
-0.1773665696,
-0.3121534288,
0.1362395436,
0.0101464046,
-0.0080329524,
0.5736061931,
0.7181013227,
-1.2564536333,
-0.5337916017,
0.1110770255,
-0.5723890066,
0.0516132526,
-0.2262687236,
-0.1819276512,
0.1521400362,
0.5298051238,
-0.4447195828,
0.1691516936,
0.8139813542,
-0.1156971753,
0.9432515502,
0.157732442,
0.701115191,
-1.0965811014,
0.051240623,
0.3323649466,
-0.2884524763,
-0.5823385119,
0.2785922885,
0.4918743968,
-0.0723889023,
-0.9738101363,
0.8351060748,
-0.2848633528,
-0.0659742579,
-0.2178320289,
0.3308237791,
0.1221337467,
0.4111846387,
0.0187667776,
0.4247176051,
0.3620484769,
-0.7506715655,
0.738122046,
-0.4148430526,
-0.6127740145,
0.7190030217,
-0.4469364285,
-0.0740230531,
-0.0651286244,
0.6564624906,
-0.8445881009,
-0.3837543726,
0.5878403187,
-0.6675890088,
-0.2309433669,
0.0581590049,
-0.6756733656,
-0.3853656352,
-0.550352633,
0.1184318885,
-0.2892439067,
-1.0375159979,
0.3166540563,
0.2441973239,
0.2095179707,
-0.6564003825,
-0.7937879562,
-0.0156570468,
0.0151101574,
-0.695305407,
0.4644859433,
0.0297419131,
-0.1589596272,
0.2156741917,
-0.5318006277,
-0.0640983805,
-0.119408533,
0.0849663094,
0.0408880338,
-0.4858234525,
0.3143869042,
0.2340893149,
0.0827731714,
0.0349748917,
-0.052779261,
0.1943658292,
0.0638601556,
-0.7441903949,
-0.5399785638,
0.1651683301,
0.5116687417,
-0.1392582357,
0.7207975388,
1.0021868944,
-0.6157004833,
-0.5047491193,
-0.4170340598,
-0.1851768345,
-0.4493945241,
0.1807357818,
-0.527799964,
-0.2486474812,
0.279943943,
-0.1593035311,
0.2152471989,
0.5515767932,
0.2755423486,
0.2253744006,
1.146669507,
0.202292785,
-0.2192256749,
0.3914291859,
-0.02365008,
-0.0711621568,
-0.3893348575,
-0.0426884666,
-0.2537408173,
-0.3240566552,
-0.5476555824,
-0.3598082662,
0.1210570335,
-0.3102815449,
-0.212722525,
0.1796534061,
-0.3765912354,
0.5708271861,
0.5493327975,
0.4810857475,
0.4343595803,
-0.0175470933,
-0.3670897484,
0.2420510501,
-0.578045845,
-0.1876422018,
1.1172665358,
-0.0185127202,
0.4042521119,
0.1667878628,
0.4044934511,
0.6193140745,
0.8542398214,
-0.1995183229,
0.2032282799,
-0.2223508656,
-0.8397802114,
0.0129315956,
-0.7035387754,
-0.4520596266,
0.7180434465,
-0.0402599759,
-0.1871524006,
0.0964404345,
0.0250216238,
-0.229741618,
0.6139104962,
-0.6818688512,
0.9555983543,
-0.3733640015,
-0.1350484341,
-0.0895562991,
-0.3298927546,
1.0317714214,
-0.2790951729,
0.5956841707,
-0.3901682198,
0.0921778157,
0.4936678112,
-0.3451233804,
0.3959007263,
-0.3860466778,
0.1410696954,
0.0761004686,
-0.1738468856,
0.6688581705,
0.4094714522,
-0.1223456636,
0.3035311401,
0.0971209928,
-0.6299535632,
-0.2821675241,
1.0334293842,
-0.488835007,
-0.3233300149,
-0.7115221024,
-0.1977669448,
-0.0504504666,
0.3318210542,
0.3855708539,
0.4556981623,
-0.5344259739,
0.3159876168,
0.186891973,
-0.1986706257,
0.4487061501,
0.6293152571,
-0.3248565197,
-0.2737542689,
1.0373463631,
0.2311405689,
0.0935221389,
0.0553203933,
0.297785908,
-0.3495693803,
-0.0547168069,
-0.5561233759,
0.0731187612,
-0.6642632484,
0.0144123044,
-0.4492525756,
-0.4270667136,
-0.6440461874,
-0.0104622785,
-0.386720717,
0.0841192454,
-0.0684437975,
-0.0890400708,
-0.0481130891,
0.2073602825,
-0.3082673848,
0.1016863436,
-0.8163480759,
1.0519707203,
0.138192445,
0.378541857,
-0.0392702483,
-0.3156834245,
-0.185607478,
0.6286484003,
-0.4926436245,
-0.780492425,
0.2896825373,
0.0444176309,
0.7763853073,
0.8590940237,
0.687785387,
0.5405085683,
-0.1187668592,
0.4306427836,
0.119707182,
-0.8269937038,
0.3780577779,
-0.3902918696,
0.2339956462,
0.1250311285,
0.3958369792,
-0.6890983582,
-0.3296018541,
-0.7478941083,
-0.1495968699,
0.8901093006,
-0.0516738854,
0.2322227955,
0.1131872237,
-0.0317044593,
0.094140932,
0.1821798384,
-0.8720412254,
-0.2957430184,
-0.3706153035,
0.0051121102,
-0.1971751601,
0.1937300265,
-0.1647031605,
-0.2236815244,
0.6913076043,
-0.1075163707,
-0.0754807815,
0.2010529339,
-0.1954864264,
-0.1087232828,
-0.129714191,
0.8147217035,
0.7171936631,
-0.0237595141,
0.2262441814,
0.0840913281,
-0.5353682637,
0.0531905591,
-0.051665891,
0.0196362678,
0.3602531552,
0.0168947279,
0.459780097,
-0.0852230936,
-0.6110963225,
0.7245820761,
0.1466737986,
-0.3873793185,
-0.2275522649,
0.093218185,
-0.0312404372,
0.1411985755,
0.7209057808,
0.4591705799,
0.0671849474,
-0.7070074081,
0.7008689046,
0.2396063358,
-0.3181163669,
-0.1870932877,
0.6512568593,
0.1656061411,
-0.0845672116,
0.3721514046,
-0.3915374279,
-0.4020498097,
0.9853748679,
0.3506646156,
0.4578560591,
-0.3914276958,
0.6282408237,
0.2053968906,
0.5520345569,
-0.5065646172,
0.1248168424,
0.1720656902,
-1.0170910358,
0.0526568443,
-0.2528338134,
-0.3313888907,
0.3454042971,
-0.3947178721,
0.6083932519,
-0.5743528008,
-0.0458931886,
0.1240407601,
0.1972697526,
-0.2936907411,
0.3929372132,
0.1317199916,
0.8872765303,
-0.7853645682,
0.9593052268,
0.4222521484,
-0.054065343,
-0.4878295064,
0.4099119306,
0.7096809149,
-0.4803735912,
0.2094719559,
0.5770023465,
-0.1146102846,
-0.0630695596,
-0.6851576567,
-0.447711736,
0.7693434954,
0.5182670951,
-0.4290906489,
0.4203484654,
-0.141748175,
0.158638984,
-0.3425368667,
-0.0004825382,
0.1194034815,
0.6248511076,
0.020031888,
-0.4866499901,
0.2482813299,
-0.4741222262,
-0.2494058162,
0.1099782139,
-1.0857658386,
1.2594363689,
-0.2382877767,
-0.5239343047,
-0.433340013,
0.5056694746,
0.5764924884,
0.9226043224,
0.3889622688,
0.3240715861,
0.6045256853,
-0.1116831005,
0.9002192616,
-0.3093478084,
0.3473828137,
0.750845015,
-0.1649343222,
0.6251624227,
0.0629748106,
0.1156952828,
0.5605297089,
0.7806611061,
-0.3644105494,
0.4600405693,
0.1065515578,
-0.1122670025,
-0.1646234393,
-0.0992394015,
-0.6053335071,
0.2692030668,
0.1843252629,
-0.2674250603,
-0.5289503932,
0.2795028985,
0.1018105969,
-0.0189839955,
-0.2334560901,
0.1603271812,
0.004588847,
-0.2881249487,
0.3395608366,
0.4831750095,
0.6963426471,
-0.4209750295,
-0.0713012815,
-0.2994045019,
0.2528504729,
-0.2101860046,
-0.4345190823,
0.2029711455,
-0.2166007459,
0.0410556905,
0.0096915299,
0.7889507413,
-0.2326021641,
-0.524430275,
0.2125476301,
0.5374959111,
0.0338504054,
-0.8425027728,
-0.6306191683,
-0.0870576203,
-0.2203344852,
-0.3685178459,
0.3863486648,
0.5663838387,
-0.1763596684,
0.602837801,
1.3297864199,
0.0293805208,
0.1014890149,
-0.1310480535,
0.8236270547,
-0.6641985178,
-0.6590800881,
-0.732945919,
0.1141269282,
-0.5485172868,
-0.5039016604,
0.9547367692,
0.5750261545,
1.2066961527,
0.0743399709,
0.9788072109,
-0.0763495043,
0.6485057473,
-0.4010272026,
0.9892584085,
-0.7724795938,
0.1044439077,
-0.3084539473,
-0.7466651797,
-0.1717641056,
0.1748018563,
0.1984850466,
0.2708304524,
0.6982227564,
0.8240708113,
-0.5091135502,
0.0316450261,
0.3484784067,
-0.1066528335,
0.3085499704,
0.2540194094,
0.611148417,
-0.5838975906,
0.9560915232,
-0.4977108836,
0.0150001496,
-0.441013813,
-0.7634407282,
-0.8778492808,
-0.340103507,
-0.1265642941,
-0.1821032465,
0.1125132293,
0.5508978367,
0.9301393032,
-1.0137224197,
0.1014113054,
0.0982556194,
0.4672548473,
-0.7737389803,
-0.339972049,
0.3648349345,
-0.0968952551,
-0.5742974877,
0.1974582672,
0.0362145789,
0.0257663764,
-0.2300643921,
-0.1474641263,
-0.4073879123,
0.1882956028,
0.4203701019,
0.2958003879,
-0.6139810681,
-0.3417217731,
0.078567788,
-0.4376523793,
-0.0127914771,
0.7687827349,
-0.6720010638,
0.1712700576,
0.4814231396,
0.3120606542,
0.3267148435,
0.3671863079,
0.3584016263,
-1.0220235586,
0.2677311301,
-0.3284724355,
-0.015942743,
0.1541799605,
-0.2199375033,
0.2843882143,
0.7768996954,
-0.0951991826,
-0.9717585444,
-0.1180789545,
-0.7591147423,
-0.694999814,
1.0136554241,
-0.2337444127,
-0.0560438186,
-0.2748806179,
-0.0943908989,
0.2612746358,
-0.5704984069,
0.6977841854,
0.939455688,
0.2653056085,
-0.5774056911,
-0.6422126293,
0.5022567511,
-0.2868729234,
-0.9499216676,
-0.0716925561,
0.3987303376,
0.344452709,
0.120435454,
0.5404621959,
0.0745154917,
0.6271562576,
0.5780123472,
-0.1665268093,
-0.3796623945,
-0.5404857993,
0.1577821225,
0.3652995825,
-0.724164784,
-0.523910284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09085v1
|
Meaningful Learning: Advancing Abstract Reasoning in Large Language Models via Generic Fact Guidance
| 2024-03-14T04:06:13 | 2024-03-14T04:06:13 |
Kai Xiong, Xiao Ding, Ting Liu, Bing Qin, Dongliang Xu, Qing Yang, Hongtao Liu, Yixin Cao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have developed impressive performance and strong
explainability across various reasoning scenarios, marking a significant stride
towards mimicking human-like intelligence. Despite this, when tasked with
simple questions supported by a generic fact, LLMs often fail to provide
consistent and precise answers, indicating a deficiency in abstract reasoning
abilities. This has sparked a vigorous debate about whether LLMs are genuinely
reasoning or merely memorizing. In light of this, we design a preliminary study
to quantify and delve into the abstract reasoning abilities of existing LLMs.
Our findings reveal a substantial discrepancy between their general reasoning
and abstract reasoning performances. To relieve this problem, we tailor an
abstract reasoning dataset (AbsR) together with a meaningful learning paradigm
to teach LLMs how to leverage generic facts for reasoning purposes. The results
show that our approach not only boosts the general reasoning performance of
LLMs but also makes considerable strides towards their capacity for abstract
reasoning, moving beyond simple memorization or imitation to a more nuanced
understanding and application of generic facts.
|
[
-0.0455096625,
-0.6513956189,
1.1837825775,
-0.3652592897,
-0.3550961614,
0.2092715502,
-0.1662672162,
-0.5443964601,
-0.2493550032,
0.3794141114,
-0.2196341455,
-0.8534538746,
-0.6073553562,
0.0906642079,
-0.2902752161,
0.8842892051,
0.2146763355,
-0.0223714877,
-0.4352854192,
-0.3714460135,
-0.3819297552,
-0.5610384345,
-0.7201849818,
-0.5590378046,
0.659858346,
0.4485233426,
0.5516152978,
0.7563341856,
0.256917417,
0.2803432643,
-0.1576607674,
0.3901824355,
-0.453176111,
0.1339210868,
-0.6451388001,
-0.7727086544,
-0.309733361,
-0.2757634521,
0.7391378284,
1.0621688366,
0.0035282336,
0.1392294466,
-0.0811543688,
0.637575388,
-0.5269476175,
0.4895129502,
-0.8068199158,
-0.0857264772,
-0.05671864,
-0.011992543,
-0.5381826758,
-0.6277157068,
0.1404791474,
-0.5808401704,
0.145360738,
0.1214975193,
0.5526625514,
0.2528105676,
-0.529315412,
-0.4443140924,
-0.6210249066,
1.0873709917,
-0.8612598777,
0.1501939297,
0.146651715,
0.255756408,
-0.1651716232,
-0.8947843909,
-0.4626038671,
-0.311096102,
-0.0683020949,
-0.244787693,
-0.1215942502,
0.1511097699,
0.5156050324,
0.3292064965,
-0.3942751884,
-0.0162633769,
-0.3157783747,
-0.2121308893,
0.6991323829,
0.2973976433,
0.2183330208,
0.156932652,
-0.1277196556,
0.0368394032,
-1.0006356239,
0.1964050233,
0.0181968082,
0.21081689,
-0.0545085631,
0.4533587694,
0.0390817747,
0.8417221904,
-0.2510234714,
-0.555556953,
0.0968278423,
-0.0506821312,
0.2107664347,
0.1450510472,
0.2291378081,
0.1299188882,
0.5459329486,
-0.2401174009,
-0.3762769699,
0.1336647719,
0.0879266411,
-0.6844395995,
-0.3812832534,
0.0046655643,
-0.4203403592,
0.171887055,
0.0352775119,
-0.2580875456,
-0.0105764624,
-0.7773893476,
0.4752307832,
-0.5104435086,
-0.154578194,
0.331412077,
-0.2613894343,
0.3097961843,
0.6573752165,
-0.852946341,
0.1593808234,
0.8730841875,
0.7362242937,
-0.2229581922,
-0.0070506036,
-0.1891139448,
0.2992289662,
-0.4883956313,
1.0112593174,
-0.894282043,
-0.2069891989,
0.0088899126,
-0.2804973423,
-0.0278052073,
-0.7080696225,
0.584359169,
-0.6198933125,
-0.0901685208,
-0.6199206114,
-0.7761893868,
-0.7571610808,
0.5634736419,
-0.5325441957,
0.6657043099,
0.0476617366,
-0.5656552315,
0.372934252,
-0.4822904766,
-0.543654263,
0.032009434,
-0.5034357905,
-0.1185820773,
0.2305080444,
-0.1865122765,
0.5001775026,
-0.2375040203,
0.2118556648,
-0.4580702484,
-0.4679711759,
0.4475698471,
-0.2716539502,
0.2963808477,
0.1729611754,
-0.1241706535,
-0.0449250825,
-0.8996625543,
0.071310617,
0.0867140964,
-0.4361114502,
-0.4578842819,
0.2129283398,
-0.4389924407,
0.226274088,
0.1826296151,
-0.4707536399,
0.3853844702,
-0.2569190562,
0.4422937334,
0.7201929688,
0.0581337959,
0.3979030848,
-0.7147752047,
0.3213008642,
-0.1894829422,
-0.2518334985,
-0.0875977278,
-0.5068045259,
-0.6174018979,
-0.3831020594,
0.3804056644,
0.2777580917,
-0.6596823335,
0.3681148291,
-0.3079496026,
-0.025339786,
-0.3111508489,
0.1574126929,
0.4077107906,
0.7391504049,
0.424051702,
-0.1124422476,
-0.492256999,
-0.8441727161,
-0.4831909537,
-0.2308903188,
-0.2410908639,
0.0990807638,
0.7214254141,
-0.2050118446,
0.9840214252,
-0.4613672197,
-0.0388568267,
-0.5039774179,
0.0747422799,
0.1410086155,
0.1127127409,
0.2984125316,
-0.5910024643,
-0.1132861674,
-0.1185076386,
-1.0602837801,
-0.0157410633,
-0.0515040271,
0.2050935179,
0.1331162602,
0.5780024529,
-0.4046726823,
0.0907451659,
0.3197072744,
-0.2737564445,
0.6531940699,
-0.1126926765,
-0.082066521,
-0.6064699888,
0.0938031748,
-0.167368114,
-0.272891134,
-0.4136267304,
-0.0908388719,
-0.1833481491,
0.2854131162,
-0.5228109956,
0.8153108358,
-0.3979546726,
-0.1280700117,
-0.5237429142,
0.0673303679,
0.0940991864,
0.3234215081,
0.1823381633,
0.6067338586,
0.4461602867,
-0.9017498493,
0.007746052,
0.0033300768,
-0.6208003163,
0.2773773372,
-0.6715674996,
0.0010435602,
-0.2000142783,
0.30867818,
-0.815849483,
-0.1849469841,
0.0593686588,
-0.2906887233,
0.1708114445,
-0.180671826,
-0.585496366,
0.1903880537,
0.0183077101,
0.6868773699,
0.7140483856,
-0.5933097005,
0.7868690491,
0.2685102522,
-0.2705267966,
-0.3797623515,
-0.5146879554,
0.0407541171,
-0.158738777,
-0.5799304247,
0.2815701663,
0.1271535158,
-0.6494394541,
0.1252756566,
-0.2747575045,
0.0276433211,
-0.0569713786,
-0.0249841642,
0.1102811992,
-0.2244936377,
0.4794379175,
0.1542648822,
-0.2328500897,
0.3942755759,
-0.209800303,
0.239020735,
-0.2887769938,
-0.5905683041,
-0.1511037201,
0.1314138025,
0.4060349166,
-0.0337536931,
0.7614099383,
0.2673819959,
-0.2999588847,
-0.4112013876,
-0.5246321559,
-0.3017670214,
-0.4198275805,
0.3109498024,
-0.467726469,
-1.0384325981,
0.5015171766,
-0.4285814762,
0.4000849128,
0.4137959182,
0.3393901289,
0.0396891758,
1.2729455233,
0.3869556189,
0.3841877282,
0.0313233174,
-0.3429223597,
0.1550319195,
-0.7173514962,
-0.7455519438,
-0.2952124476,
-0.2128586769,
-0.1781475246,
-0.5299668312,
0.2806153595,
-0.025958607,
-0.4220855832,
-0.3619599342,
-0.2502302527,
0.5846315026,
0.2630629838,
0.0933215246,
0.7302731276,
-0.0251221955,
-0.2198403329,
0.0138273127,
-0.7625300884,
-0.9620706439,
1.0680065155,
0.3034347594,
0.8913733959,
0.2016525567,
0.4122237265,
0.3432200849,
0.4672770798,
-0.8780001402,
0.7732995152,
-0.1840935946,
-0.4378087521,
-0.1506891698,
-0.6795627475,
-0.8991459608,
0.4733143449,
-0.0249440335,
-0.33294788,
-0.0755440518,
0.3344368637,
-0.1863879114,
0.5112631321,
-0.5334886312,
0.4825690687,
-0.3281405866,
-0.0535677597,
-0.4035621583,
-0.4985433221,
0.6732730865,
0.0888033658,
0.3361892402,
-0.2702384293,
-0.2904269397,
0.6248970628,
-0.177477479,
0.9145333171,
-0.1399392188,
-0.1654173732,
0.3054178357,
0.0263860356,
0.2496150583,
0.0357210673,
-0.2411128879,
0.2036125511,
-0.1611576974,
-0.7088819742,
-0.7898932099,
0.5670258403,
-0.4482384026,
-0.7325968742,
-0.5237724781,
-0.6558454037,
-0.2812616527,
-0.0879431963,
0.0497059897,
0.4937683046,
-0.2320454568,
0.2180877179,
1.1636993885,
-0.0229116008,
0.1258612871,
0.6346157789,
-0.0612955652,
-0.1685281098,
0.8890962005,
0.1141403243,
0.4707686305,
0.6037001014,
0.2215611488,
-0.7619873881,
-0.8140903711,
-0.2163300514,
0.4356762767,
-1.0144642591,
-0.1018826514,
-0.6068171263,
-0.0495563336,
-0.1167029068,
-0.055616986,
-0.1345280111,
-0.6041642427,
-0.0611822009,
-0.1657166481,
0.3125358522,
0.8182791471,
-0.0887031481,
-0.179888159,
-0.8362047076,
0.3339362741,
0.5485183001,
0.1075051799,
0.2857122421,
-0.9818529487,
-0.040850345,
0.1347337961,
-0.2816116214,
-0.4661989808,
0.0012218026,
0.3317210078,
0.761380136,
0.7034441829,
0.1790330708,
0.3955636919,
-0.5111700296,
0.531983912,
0.1027986258,
-0.7774766088,
0.4621037245,
-0.1803232431,
0.4992416799,
0.4578248262,
0.4859045446,
-0.3203489482,
-0.29387936,
-0.5485869646,
-0.6454440355,
0.3007237315,
-0.0867649093,
0.1246196628,
-0.1389172971,
0.5363795161,
0.2974277735,
0.1509292871,
-0.6667484045,
-0.1862462163,
-0.0538412966,
-0.3062174022,
-0.005091338,
-0.2277052402,
-0.1443088204,
-0.4917331934,
0.528025806,
-0.202286914,
-0.0478950217,
0.0886726081,
-0.1816294044,
0.2837596238,
0.3965730667,
0.5943886042,
1.0595757961,
-0.1257142425,
0.3758974671,
0.4264033735,
-0.1622054577,
0.2420742065,
-0.1521489024,
-0.1022934392,
-0.0165550187,
0.6411157846,
0.492986083,
0.4452063441,
-1.1363447905,
0.2733969092,
0.0273448993,
-0.4743731618,
-0.3293668926,
0.3875651062,
0.2713956833,
0.1021077484,
0.4768294394,
-0.0635203868,
0.0774921253,
-0.8857932687,
0.0987976938,
0.3813836277,
-0.102014713,
-0.4153344631,
0.3782114685,
0.1648990512,
-0.0804458484,
0.7044208646,
-0.2701264024,
-0.5691868663,
0.4634951353,
0.5911074281,
0.5180854201,
-0.0886481702,
0.0306762122,
0.3812811971,
0.1343870461,
-0.3141347468,
0.1705253869,
-0.0535796396,
-0.758174181,
-0.8667357564,
-0.5461608171,
-0.596842289,
0.2433407605,
-0.5620407462,
-0.0836587176,
-0.5711818933,
0.1415123045,
-0.1393824071,
-0.0732981414,
-0.4303819537,
0.2189259529,
0.0000133952,
1.0570994616,
-0.9071050286,
0.7344281077,
0.8464616537,
-0.3597897887,
-0.7168312669,
-0.1267387122,
-0.1311027855,
-0.757840395,
0.6870686412,
0.2656968534,
-0.325363934,
-0.1956269741,
-0.6752601862,
-0.6255868673,
0.9219412804,
0.6409558058,
-0.5553976297,
-0.0335749425,
0.1879800409,
0.594863236,
-0.4654667377,
0.1356894374,
0.6098767519,
0.5376340747,
0.5213724375,
-0.3573015034,
0.2112084925,
-0.0166459084,
-0.2014081478,
0.1361325085,
-0.4155523181,
0.6595283747,
-0.5573556423,
-0.2212492377,
-0.0073640337,
0.7526997328,
0.7326509953,
0.5303486586,
0.4657450914,
0.8391332626,
0.8957498074,
-0.0763026327,
1.1103616953,
-0.0054943548,
-0.0938061029,
1.0029112101,
-0.2560980022,
0.8078941107,
0.2351774871,
-0.0696937218,
0.9413663149,
0.4833434522,
0.2129001915,
0.3565495908,
0.3382728398,
-0.7868831158,
-0.7452603579,
0.0335822143,
-0.5001621246,
0.3640121818,
0.6580326557,
-0.3349481523,
-0.3992394805,
-0.1154263243,
0.0259065963,
0.4395817816,
-0.5262101889,
0.772632122,
0.4260941446,
-0.7107899785,
0.636254847,
0.057264246,
0.4812603295,
-0.6112789512,
-0.6373758912,
-0.1076965556,
0.2440998107,
-0.2682167888,
-0.8302267194,
0.3968756199,
-0.0273338445,
-0.4031538069,
-0.0838369355,
0.5691437721,
-0.3411209285,
-0.4000630081,
0.1321180761,
0.4355264902,
0.3921132684,
0.0024405953,
-0.6538962722,
0.0364589356,
0.0197651591,
0.2107959241,
0.5959445238,
0.5962508321,
0.0557793044,
1.0210440159,
0.7691767812,
0.0996526033,
-0.2144871652,
0.1446793526,
0.7868608236,
-0.8274840713,
-0.2587615848,
-0.8511531353,
0.4585885406,
-0.0378584303,
-0.2024083585,
0.7213585377,
0.6260906458,
0.8935649395,
-0.0695325807,
0.9218502045,
0.2220760137,
0.760548234,
-0.8631802201,
0.3240786195,
-0.3190686405,
0.7259973288,
0.2192352116,
-0.9133620858,
-0.3021937907,
0.7639617324,
-0.5123526454,
0.1388078779,
0.6030897498,
0.650785327,
-0.1500016898,
0.0351853222,
0.4934977889,
0.3362386227,
0.332534045,
0.6240425706,
1.1894295216,
-0.0292311795,
0.5726374388,
0.1288737953,
-0.225865975,
-0.0112308376,
-0.8993322849,
-1.0923852921,
-0.2977148592,
-0.3076538146,
-0.080517821,
0.4047547281,
0.9109554291,
0.5468894839,
-0.7832859755,
-0.0030449312,
-0.2916635275,
0.487631321,
-0.0256272797,
-0.2542037666,
0.345728755,
-0.5675246716,
-0.5249865055,
0.388453424,
0.1925414652,
-0.1095527411,
-0.0612603649,
-0.3180585206,
-0.0891723111,
0.2078208625,
0.9523459077,
0.5900626779,
-0.9313337803,
-0.4259321094,
-0.3120450974,
0.1346703768,
-0.0366330594,
0.9138669968,
-0.9779192805,
0.0644335449,
0.4385640025,
0.6860250235,
0.1914693564,
0.1791274548,
0.522918582,
-0.5585739613,
-0.1001084,
0.5881822705,
0.3984106183,
0.3991838396,
0.1548607647,
0.2850133181,
0.2089701444,
-0.6501632929,
-0.7695876956,
0.4162337482,
-0.8068097234,
-0.6770032644,
1.2897334099,
-0.2642332911,
-0.0046517276,
-0.6944701076,
-0.0765331686,
-0.1015044004,
-0.384609431,
0.9923583269,
0.4780987501,
-0.4305617511,
-0.1380711496,
-0.4004770517,
0.4667445719,
0.3687553108,
-0.8230063915,
-0.183296293,
0.5232851505,
0.6037744284,
-0.0546529479,
0.4494993389,
-0.1535568833,
0.4185762405,
-0.1200608015,
-0.0758543909,
-0.0397455767,
-0.4499197006,
-0.2957388461,
0.1758080125,
0.5290385485,
0.0929372534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09077v1
|
Information Extraction: An application to the domain of hyper-local financial data on developing countries
| 2024-03-14T03:49:36 | 2024-03-14T03:49:36 |
Abuzar Royesh, Olamide Oladeji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the need for financial data on company activities in developing
countries for development research and economic analysis, such data does not
exist. In this project, we develop and evaluate two Natural Language Processing
(NLP) based techniques to address this issue. First, we curate a custom dataset
specific to the domain of financial text data on developing countries and
explore multiple approaches for information extraction. We then explore a
text-to-text approach with the transformer-based T5 model with the goal of
undertaking simultaneous NER and relation extraction. We find that this model
is able to learn the custom text structure output data corresponding to the
entities and their relations, resulting in an accuracy of 92.44\%, a precision
of 68.25\% and a recall of 54.20\% from our best T5 model on the combined task.
Secondly, we explore an approach with sequential NER and relation extration.
For the NER, we run pre-trained and fine-tuned models using SpaCy, and we
develop a custom relation extraction model using SpaCy's Dependency Parser
output and some heuristics to determine entity relationships \cite{spacy}. We
obtain an accuracy of 84.72\%, a precision of 6.06\% and a recall of 5.57\% on
this sequential task.
|
[
-0.3050219417,
-0.9394125938,
0.146973297,
0.3034275472,
0.0111892242,
0.2081206888,
-0.2986818254,
-0.9346914291,
0.1373542398,
0.8689625263,
-0.2152093202,
-0.5772291422,
-0.5960707664,
0.2802333236,
-0.3480023444,
1.3026739359,
0.1770502329,
-0.2215538621,
0.1590223759,
0.1428084522,
-0.1999049783,
-0.5275589824,
-0.8781223893,
-0.1944484115,
-0.0630391687,
0.5779618621,
0.626834631,
0.6133287549,
0.8573609591,
0.3083230257,
-0.0674457476,
0.1009708792,
-0.174966529,
-0.095520243,
-0.2801632285,
-0.3281668425,
-0.6159306765,
-0.1426525563,
0.2702024281,
0.4500817955,
-0.2364739478,
0.5664846301,
-0.0428326763,
0.6874272823,
-0.5310173035,
0.7879789472,
-0.526088953,
0.092149362,
-0.202162236,
-0.1663610488,
-0.3399343491,
-0.2996662557,
0.8231226802,
-0.6780305505,
0.4596607387,
-0.0277614798,
1.3575332165,
0.0407494493,
-0.4284426272,
-0.5580744147,
-1.0205897093,
0.9044341445,
-0.5993628502,
0.2778477669,
0.4929489493,
0.3169310391,
0.1257611364,
-0.8514568806,
-0.2932372689,
0.1447633505,
-0.2556161582,
0.172158882,
-0.277151227,
-0.1021583229,
0.3569029868,
0.5267858505,
-0.1141155437,
-0.1719836891,
-0.5048105717,
-0.0571493804,
0.5982318521,
-0.0877059996,
0.0640348122,
-0.5301772356,
-0.5032723546,
-0.0274026431,
-0.5842112899,
-0.0726018921,
0.2273561656,
0.4745698869,
-0.2917483151,
0.6993999481,
-0.0151917646,
0.6476658583,
0.2231988907,
-0.414245069,
0.1979019046,
-0.5460144877,
-0.3776842058,
0.0024385352,
0.5689605474,
0.0546116754,
0.5730503201,
-0.3063510358,
-0.409183383,
-0.3239876926,
0.0392803214,
-0.3798041344,
-0.2725466192,
-0.005885751,
-0.6867391467,
-0.3690052927,
0.1759044826,
-1.2627788782,
-0.1037909091,
-0.465444237,
0.204647392,
-0.1922405064,
-0.3707328141,
-0.2596875429,
-0.3328354359,
0.4215271175,
-0.1181533188,
-1.1716336012,
0.7675241232,
0.6032875776,
0.7721326351,
-0.2752839327,
0.2575442791,
-0.4621999264,
0.4732488096,
0.2203503251,
0.7496968508,
-0.6152694225,
-0.2801527679,
-0.1778620034,
-0.0950418636,
-0.1430484802,
-0.9559022188,
0.5143857598,
-0.6469284296,
0.2473376244,
-0.1609608382,
-0.5422813296,
-0.1290306449,
0.1533496231,
-0.946619153,
1.0729249716,
0.4377167821,
-0.9669959545,
0.519515872,
-0.94994241,
-0.4715122581,
0.0311960671,
-0.0722753406,
-0.3896751106,
-0.0847768784,
0.4868416488,
0.2822943628,
-0.7269399166,
0.4836359322,
-0.0606184453,
-0.0788807347,
-0.0353952572,
-0.3429459333,
0.6663954854,
-0.0204426609,
-0.4753537178,
-0.2282894403,
-1.1672414541,
-0.2004989535,
0.2414693832,
-0.3027883768,
-0.63933146,
-0.0537769087,
0.3436769545,
0.3734377921,
0.6470745802,
-0.5377714038,
0.2449847758,
-0.7177681327,
0.3423894942,
0.6262494922,
0.3368702531,
0.5069536567,
0.1363081932,
0.4197458327,
0.0826779529,
0.0596117079,
0.0671444908,
-0.3251131773,
-0.6913697124,
-0.0310033653,
0.6622848511,
0.7790157199,
-0.7103844881,
0.3001851141,
-0.1253509521,
-0.2069002539,
-0.3841127455,
0.0355811045,
0.1434491128,
0.9274215102,
0.4772789776,
-0.1933628619,
-0.9454936981,
-0.9859104753,
-0.1946904063,
0.0292395391,
0.0752478316,
0.1205340028,
0.5559990406,
-0.0229813755,
1.2584211826,
-0.8514477015,
-0.3903599381,
-0.4864167869,
0.1804504395,
0.5673379302,
0.3994462192,
0.4409779012,
-1.2839866877,
-0.3645012677,
0.2850064337,
-0.8388115168,
0.1011670008,
-0.1519791782,
0.038612958,
0.2151352018,
0.0549941026,
-0.6513343453,
0.7460041642,
0.2976121604,
-0.2402467281,
0.4033394158,
-0.3510668576,
-0.2038630247,
-1.2522758245,
0.3883633614,
0.5051179528,
-0.1098520085,
-0.6520130038,
-0.2179844528,
-0.0504033193,
-0.0467432998,
0.0716739148,
0.7263146639,
-0.5292184949,
-0.4543630779,
-0.1848274916,
0.2576214671,
0.0300220661,
0.4437842071,
0.2494750768,
0.7215564847,
0.3171257973,
-0.6352453232,
0.346699059,
0.3296890557,
-0.33244434,
0.2602940798,
-0.744202733,
-0.0119803781,
0.1515222043,
-0.2883995175,
-0.4241727293,
0.0024221463,
0.1020068377,
-0.1591067761,
0.3972387016,
-0.288675338,
-0.5018314719,
-0.1293811798,
0.1803247482,
-0.1254311502,
0.3178437054,
-0.4811534882,
0.4783482552,
0.7563679218,
-0.6026682258,
-0.7620283365,
-0.490086019,
0.1457181275,
-0.3934269249,
-0.4537757933,
0.4103472233,
0.5088057518,
-0.5471004248,
0.1492871642,
-0.3211527169,
-0.5647936463,
0.09821444,
-0.0080706356,
0.6575903296,
-0.3327979445,
-0.0265500862,
-0.1608690619,
-0.444979012,
0.0944601968,
-0.1839631051,
0.2405057847,
0.039011959,
0.1943870932,
-0.3301315606,
0.2965833843,
0.227336213,
-0.405541867,
0.833213985,
0.4969480336,
-0.7265024185,
0.1307445019,
-0.5377721786,
0.1347552836,
-0.4814737141,
0.1764801145,
-0.3783321083,
-0.4852930605,
0.6801491976,
-0.2064282298,
0.1390822381,
0.8830435276,
0.3431622088,
0.2666575015,
0.7574599385,
1.3538930416,
-0.2854330838,
0.505343616,
-0.634100318,
0.5589458346,
-0.6031445861,
-0.4793848991,
-0.7683724761,
-0.0584099591,
-0.6600304246,
0.121447064,
0.2408747673,
0.124936685,
0.084319979,
0.7890604138,
-0.0606317967,
0.3908553123,
0.2983186245,
-0.2437196672,
0.52938658,
0.3045427501,
0.1093436405,
-0.5195088387,
-0.4271028936,
-0.5735807419,
0.9862339497,
0.2065698504,
0.6659066081,
-0.0537285767,
0.8244822025,
0.2828157544,
0.4370980561,
-0.6891157627,
0.127354309,
-0.2914814651,
-0.384068042,
-0.2551878691,
-0.7665005922,
-0.9809474349,
-0.1534182727,
-0.1589387208,
-0.9091051221,
0.4665009975,
-0.2264020741,
-0.3250849545,
0.1913478225,
-0.8311978579,
0.7624106407,
-0.0352039486,
-0.2689448595,
0.0935851261,
-0.5063092709,
0.3767054081,
-0.2345698327,
0.3769167364,
0.0920844972,
0.0192395672,
0.6963720322,
-0.3080091178,
0.5157493949,
-0.2784616351,
-0.1312013268,
0.2884263694,
-0.1003816724,
0.4845756292,
0.2535832822,
-0.535828054,
0.0697022453,
-0.1427016109,
-0.2572665811,
-0.7342137694,
0.5314210057,
-0.5000787377,
-0.2577154338,
-0.3578960001,
-0.6101648808,
-0.2340042442,
0.2497413903,
-0.0177320689,
0.3718571663,
-0.2205781937,
-0.0563214757,
0.318920821,
-0.0901936889,
0.7291333079,
0.3434423506,
0.1169734299,
-0.5577121973,
0.8812327385,
0.2361859381,
0.0726230815,
0.5427704453,
0.0718552917,
-0.4099705815,
-0.2263255417,
-0.3921543956,
0.3213218451,
-0.555021286,
-0.3917118609,
-0.6146960855,
-0.3008079231,
-0.5820851326,
0.1532857269,
-0.280610621,
-0.575062871,
-0.1889520437,
-0.2752672732,
0.2179626971,
0.9489988685,
-0.066688858,
0.1078742221,
-1.2310061455,
0.5433439612,
-0.1084397212,
-0.0403080769,
-0.0670583919,
-0.1942309588,
-0.639627099,
-0.1994701475,
-0.2325918823,
-0.8792643547,
0.9538678527,
0.112834774,
0.3648307323,
0.4718259275,
-0.0784945562,
1.1384068727,
0.0844983533,
0.3711943924,
-0.005869925,
-0.984354496,
0.7195045948,
-0.0178010743,
0.0698012933,
0.6127671599,
0.4696815908,
-0.4028486907,
-0.1767658889,
-1.1451538801,
-1.1153029203,
0.7902603745,
0.3386757374,
-0.3239364922,
0.0900251716,
0.6530711055,
0.126850307,
0.3940015137,
-0.7014235854,
-0.3213224411,
0.4014086723,
-0.2275474072,
0.1656962335,
-0.0956102088,
0.222596854,
-0.1762780845,
0.5906099677,
0.1195793152,
-0.0365750156,
0.4954718351,
-0.148017168,
-0.0860532895,
0.0222622454,
0.1085297093,
1.1278202534,
-0.158778578,
-0.0528025888,
0.1658682972,
-0.5892167687,
-0.1838137954,
0.3092924058,
-0.3295622766,
0.1694874763,
0.4886340499,
0.3034844398,
0.2114475816,
-0.5710469484,
0.4376282692,
-0.2048186064,
0.1176436916,
-0.4796585143,
-0.2156095207,
-0.0266467892,
0.2641116381,
0.563778758,
0.2938664258,
0.3024758399,
-0.4935609102,
0.3677132726,
-0.1162025705,
-0.3881764114,
-0.4602539837,
0.425147593,
0.1357300729,
-0.1533551663,
0.9445189238,
-0.211987704,
-0.3110264838,
1.0040538311,
0.9941371679,
0.7553631663,
0.0263410676,
0.1620603502,
0.5485871434,
0.2286648303,
-0.0698642954,
0.5479863882,
-0.1664836258,
-0.5845811963,
-0.7224709392,
-0.6201016903,
-0.4480956793,
0.2150680125,
-0.8889789581,
0.4595165849,
-0.3968255818,
-0.1442908645,
0.2101054788,
0.3660855591,
-0.7725824714,
0.288849622,
-0.1694474518,
0.835526526,
-0.560518682,
0.8481616378,
0.5070413351,
-0.4456401169,
-0.7415308356,
-0.0838915408,
-0.2767855823,
-0.5214522481,
1.024112463,
0.0236500744,
0.1510184407,
-0.1161708385,
-0.2870123684,
-1.056776762,
0.8800212145,
0.2924332023,
-0.6337680221,
-0.3327981532,
-0.0001682022,
0.4726057649,
-0.4853897989,
0.1001555845,
0.9430488944,
0.6227455735,
-0.0501856431,
-0.8967385292,
-0.182019949,
-0.306961447,
-0.358029753,
0.6225453019,
-0.3685777485,
0.7428271174,
-0.314365685,
-0.2692029476,
-0.316090554,
0.7766209245,
-0.0385070257,
0.4581423402,
0.2839814425,
0.3536933064,
0.8551567793,
-0.0629739463,
0.8756665587,
-0.3883883059,
0.6092008948,
1.2326831818,
-0.4397180974,
0.7582800984,
0.4892919064,
-0.0819766447,
0.4214574099,
0.5100234747,
-0.302852571,
0.3503017724,
-0.0202007424,
-0.1374216229,
0.2062897235,
-0.2162773311,
-0.0614396855,
0.5848904848,
0.4334309399,
-0.3888721168,
-0.1186217964,
-0.365332514,
0.0847577676,
-0.124654144,
-0.1051272228,
0.8842266202,
0.3716699481,
-0.4791385531,
-0.1696117669,
0.4347406626,
0.529486537,
-0.5745079517,
-0.3245646358,
-0.081393443,
0.2293524891,
-0.3881470561,
-0.3808765411,
0.8576729894,
0.554392159,
-0.3053734303,
-0.2375262231,
1.0637888908,
-0.3267927766,
-0.5116347075,
0.3942019641,
0.7770882845,
-0.0512629077,
-0.0170702748,
-0.5616274476,
-0.6537151933,
-0.0119519345,
-0.2939509153,
0.155280441,
0.7556305528,
-0.1239238083,
0.3221973181,
0.7298383117,
0.3703968227,
-0.2093875855,
0.1863439828,
0.560962081,
-1.246846199,
-0.4270263314,
-1.0435158014,
0.0501144826,
-0.5132044554,
-0.5378560424,
0.6347577572,
0.9500799775,
0.730446279,
0.0836954117,
0.7674331665,
-0.1851070821,
0.2807996273,
-0.4128136039,
0.3839056492,
-0.0066707721,
0.2829455435,
-0.4408183098,
-1.1433806419,
-0.2250793874,
0.4799144566,
-0.4329764247,
-0.2607481182,
0.596521914,
0.4116808772,
-0.1834820509,
0.2232812792,
-0.0629118457,
0.1511208266,
0.2051149458,
0.2989432514,
0.4029316008,
-0.6971282959,
0.6795346141,
-0.5207521319,
0.0575789362,
0.1663532406,
-0.7586804032,
-0.5524032116,
-0.2810407579,
-0.4007697403,
-0.219968453,
-0.3296664059,
0.9116947055,
0.5015400648,
-0.796656549,
-0.7172656059,
0.0398876108,
0.3076323271,
-0.2567541599,
-0.392595619,
0.5434526801,
-0.2420849949,
-0.7396427393,
0.4078220725,
0.5954983234,
0.2503873706,
0.0054506189,
0.2377963215,
-0.2712456584,
-0.320073843,
0.5773743987,
0.1306769848,
-0.0470807441,
-0.1407369077,
0.1844715178,
0.0290198307,
0.2594665289,
0.9377632737,
-0.5882315636,
0.1212001294,
0.4037421644,
0.6728543043,
0.7750329971,
0.2330606282,
0.8695251942,
-0.5933995247,
0.0331235528,
0.1347619593,
0.1964804381,
0.2155185193,
-0.6317836642,
0.7010938525,
0.3023133576,
-0.4612498581,
-0.3786889315,
-0.0749255344,
-0.8057505488,
0.1350952983,
0.7315133214,
-0.2037906051,
-0.5229302049,
-0.5126644969,
-0.2176753134,
0.4371234775,
-0.5977505445,
0.7626291513,
0.7867575884,
-0.2702941895,
0.1437698752,
-0.8141408563,
0.4463538527,
-0.0276450217,
-1.0209029913,
-0.0027017512,
0.0617728978,
0.2193595171,
0.3246560693,
0.6171236038,
-0.3300890923,
0.0231520776,
-0.088049598,
0.1422513872,
0.2891609371,
-0.3307120204,
-0.3123024106,
0.5499047041,
-0.3200523853,
0.1391647458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09073v1
|
Large Language Models are Parallel Multilingual Learners
| 2024-03-14T03:33:46 | 2024-03-14T03:33:46 |
Yongyu Mu, Peinan Feng, Zhiquan Cao, Yuzhang Wu, Bei Li, Chenglong Wang, Tong Xiao, Kai Song, Tongran Liu, Chunliang Zhang, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we reveal an in-context learning (ICL) capability of
multilingual large language models (LLMs): by translating the input to several
languages, we provide Parallel Input in Multiple Languages (PiM) to LLMs, which
significantly enhances their comprehension abilities. To test this capability,
we design extensive experiments encompassing 8 typical datasets, 7 languages
and 8 state-of-the-art multilingual LLMs. Experimental results show that (1)
incorporating more languages help PiM surpass the conventional ICL further; (2)
even combining with the translations that are inferior to baseline performance
can also help. Moreover, by examining the activated neurons in LLMs, we
discover a counterintuitive but interesting phenomenon. Contrary to the common
thought that PiM would activate more neurons than monolingual input to leverage
knowledge learned from diverse languages, PiM actually inhibits neurons and
promotes more precise neuron activation especially when more languages are
added. This phenomenon aligns with the neuroscience insight about synaptic
pruning, which removes less used neural connections, strengthens remainders,
and then enhances brain intelligence.
|
[
-0.5456322432,
-0.7188087702,
0.709582746,
0.435524255,
-0.2106024623,
0.1870317161,
-0.8268838525,
-0.4391071796,
-0.1710922569,
0.0983191729,
-0.326844126,
-0.2799927592,
-0.5780756474,
0.306268096,
-0.1624550968,
0.8654683232,
0.0274071321,
0.5309001207,
-0.3301754892,
-0.4009151161,
-0.5301824808,
-0.6188949347,
-0.6696212292,
-0.6396070719,
0.9356821775,
0.3856272101,
0.3098063767,
0.1534363776,
0.3342880905,
0.3064371347,
-0.2377638221,
0.1433467567,
-0.3277742267,
0.057543736,
-0.1698448211,
-0.7393820882,
-0.2639681399,
-0.2936309874,
0.9867390394,
0.9343153834,
-0.0061835223,
0.0093161874,
0.3552699983,
0.5978559256,
-0.549854517,
0.2424636632,
-0.8039870858,
-0.0578943118,
-0.0743672699,
-0.0544188283,
-0.7699372172,
0.1389440596,
0.0705220327,
-0.3487821817,
-0.1145532727,
-0.1960395724,
0.3917995095,
0.077068463,
-0.5847722292,
-0.0988347679,
-0.5021192431,
0.7000313997,
-0.6111782789,
0.4819039702,
0.2217268199,
0.1670452356,
-0.0659950078,
-0.443354696,
-0.7078236938,
-0.3710283637,
-0.2645468116,
-0.0909215808,
0.237529695,
0.0643263608,
0.5384582281,
0.1368916482,
-0.5068906546,
0.2835119069,
-0.5053372383,
0.0246382654,
0.3326797485,
-0.0386722088,
0.6504612565,
0.2205085605,
-0.3693073094,
-0.1241761371,
-0.9101696014,
0.3036294878,
0.1437298954,
0.345195353,
-0.1896097511,
0.3289492726,
0.1089413688,
0.8844841123,
-0.3304522038,
-0.3846132755,
0.3295812011,
-0.2321037203,
-0.0724763647,
0.11158292,
0.730632782,
0.0812261254,
0.4751451015,
-0.2186984569,
-0.1233029813,
-0.2550208271,
-0.1527336985,
-0.7507253289,
0.0591686182,
0.1206453666,
-0.2681002021,
0.2397058308,
-0.1268680841,
-0.4087450504,
-0.1186519861,
-0.3632726669,
0.2480043024,
-0.691811204,
-0.3519798517,
0.1368890703,
-0.1473224312,
0.2360367924,
0.1703518033,
-1.0265425444,
0.2457972616,
0.6057390571,
0.8362421989,
-0.3401790261,
-0.9917047024,
-0.3555817604,
0.2032313794,
-0.4301167727,
0.5927528143,
-0.6145217419,
-0.1488702595,
-0.0980163291,
0.0853120908,
-0.3568610251,
-0.6553205252,
0.062783353,
-0.6840417981,
-0.1363895237,
-0.4559992552,
-0.1828854084,
-0.4693885744,
0.3031051755,
-0.5345836282,
0.6149320602,
-0.2770069242,
-0.5738537908,
0.3962176442,
-0.454228431,
-0.6629024744,
0.0990465283,
-0.2187840939,
-0.0099371951,
0.3156298995,
0.240519926,
0.4770731032,
-0.2585167289,
0.5443466306,
-0.3939244449,
-0.3304805756,
0.4892681837,
-0.4818817079,
0.8723937869,
-0.0543230958,
-0.1581368297,
0.2192657143,
-0.2365570962,
0.0167356227,
0.1369254291,
-0.5058019161,
-0.379889667,
-0.0358521938,
-0.0287232604,
0.4898569584,
0.0824174136,
-0.52849406,
0.0657997653,
-0.4102779329,
0.6278139949,
0.4172359407,
-0.2076848298,
0.4955465496,
-0.3125920594,
0.3517239988,
0.1301569045,
-0.2887619436,
-0.5335431695,
-0.3300041854,
-0.7173967361,
-0.3636638522,
0.1465511471,
0.4063962996,
-0.8047119379,
0.0402017236,
-0.2716142237,
-0.177293852,
-0.1029949859,
0.3995216787,
0.2719001472,
0.4466038942,
0.3061938286,
-0.0854113996,
-0.1030429155,
-0.8397347331,
-0.2872569263,
0.153057307,
0.0721195266,
0.2600387037,
0.5464295745,
0.0873787776,
0.5842631459,
0.0513289347,
-0.0996494666,
-0.5373259783,
-0.1526254714,
0.197496742,
0.4015873075,
0.5503223538,
-0.8361428976,
-0.7917978764,
0.2200921625,
-0.8776755929,
0.3335404396,
-0.1925749332,
0.1741278321,
-0.0291522518,
0.6703159213,
-0.6143740416,
0.0436801314,
0.5093729496,
-0.0300834924,
0.3610919118,
-0.5579685569,
-0.0894039571,
-0.8544660211,
-0.0369038731,
-0.0982719064,
0.0295115914,
-0.6023464203,
0.1484370381,
0.5807088614,
-0.2568575144,
-0.6606667638,
0.7389182448,
-0.6223090291,
-0.1703273803,
-0.4181861281,
0.1023282558,
-0.0607550405,
0.6089925766,
0.2448572218,
0.7633333206,
0.9149736166,
-0.6018356681,
0.1494444609,
-0.0335277021,
-0.6478958726,
0.2439335585,
-0.6897979379,
-0.0480475463,
-0.3628341854,
0.3406371474,
-0.9822371602,
-0.405757606,
-0.2649356723,
-0.2637757659,
0.4991257191,
0.1312349439,
-0.6794276237,
-0.1091051325,
0.1423997283,
0.7183657289,
0.3012270033,
-0.9110713005,
0.4356740415,
0.2712914944,
-0.2660892904,
-0.5007870197,
-0.9151385427,
0.1133828387,
-0.3900221586,
-0.466911763,
0.1832649857,
-0.1180010214,
-0.3985774517,
-0.2429210991,
0.2527790964,
-0.0933353528,
0.2552520037,
-0.0723964721,
0.119464688,
-0.2661262453,
0.4681076407,
0.0744274035,
0.0387144201,
0.0763101801,
-0.2465480268,
0.7689819336,
-0.2469633818,
-0.5023789406,
-0.4396649301,
0.4668220878,
0.8858605027,
-0.640722692,
0.9361255765,
0.3758610487,
-0.2266901731,
-0.3795996904,
-0.2736318707,
-0.3765220046,
-0.442827493,
0.6200099587,
-0.703695178,
-0.9049847126,
0.5741481781,
-0.2537721694,
-0.0313091017,
0.2489674091,
0.5934541225,
0.0728664473,
1.0731407404,
0.4897004962,
-0.0968184099,
0.5339571238,
-0.1624083817,
0.290546149,
-0.9731644988,
-0.2322797328,
-0.2190014869,
-0.4734176099,
-0.313777864,
-0.3358349204,
0.5092724562,
0.4029450417,
-0.147604838,
-0.0416690893,
-0.0348903723,
0.7920797467,
0.3627486825,
0.160162732,
0.2224609703,
0.2522546649,
-0.4701651037,
0.0244786721,
-0.8841695786,
-0.2163227051,
1.0131140947,
0.4052196443,
0.5100298524,
0.132809937,
0.3593273163,
-0.4177663326,
0.439542383,
-0.8809684515,
0.3642469049,
-0.2186028957,
-0.6493689418,
-0.2504301965,
-0.2397189289,
-0.6257354021,
0.6636499166,
-0.1246647164,
-0.822401166,
0.1883687526,
-0.079451248,
-0.3081459999,
0.4833723605,
-0.7454659343,
0.6782057285,
-0.6908262968,
-0.552061975,
-0.5475307107,
-0.2935346961,
0.4801534116,
-0.3184586763,
0.303619206,
-0.0652200282,
-0.1310107112,
0.3427246213,
0.0726361722,
0.7826673985,
0.0724964067,
-0.0294074193,
0.0066465777,
-0.0313531645,
0.2628785968,
0.3245314062,
-0.1992861629,
0.3203927279,
-0.3892291486,
-0.5063104033,
-0.5285723209,
1.001183629,
-0.7141881585,
-0.7154350281,
-0.3147831261,
-1.1388542652,
-0.4088471532,
0.2966304719,
0.1912431419,
0.3599197865,
0.0019749943,
0.4817863405,
0.7658604383,
-0.3702535629,
0.7783353925,
0.5055089593,
-0.2712277174,
-0.2957665622,
0.7260867953,
0.1532503068,
0.5995422006,
0.2857251167,
0.1715233624,
-0.1323416382,
-0.6962433457,
-0.4883386493,
0.4140259922,
-0.7209926248,
0.2176769376,
-0.7496406436,
-0.1126666889,
-0.1855038106,
-0.1230169162,
-0.1036839113,
-0.0855539292,
0.1481189877,
-0.09225972,
0.0331031345,
0.6925096512,
0.0261922702,
0.4655424356,
-0.7636173368,
0.2455030978,
0.336184144,
0.2798480988,
0.3212940991,
-0.4316060543,
-0.3174741268,
0.1311267763,
-0.0354779288,
-0.7217642665,
0.4505994916,
0.4078353047,
0.807765007,
0.3425027728,
-0.367490381,
0.6454997063,
-0.7539986372,
0.5100476146,
0.3489673734,
-0.7579686046,
0.0587341301,
-0.4250327647,
0.8266395926,
0.4473022819,
0.6731203794,
-0.583108604,
-0.246407181,
-0.238043651,
-0.6991588473,
0.7875477672,
-0.3757339418,
0.308213532,
-0.0859236717,
0.3422293067,
0.143197909,
0.1604886651,
-0.9927453399,
-0.2456709296,
0.3225449026,
0.0878702626,
-0.5253608823,
-0.3323571086,
-0.1199934855,
-0.4651268721,
0.4121759534,
-0.2312496305,
-0.0355665088,
0.0078232624,
-0.3142519891,
0.1029895768,
0.1993048191,
0.5780273676,
1.0428640842,
0.1801222414,
0.2870927751,
0.6072543263,
-0.1184412763,
0.0162575711,
-0.2141319513,
-0.1425719261,
-0.0925242826,
0.5477542877,
0.8871567249,
0.2010020465,
-0.7317121625,
0.3393917084,
-0.284920156,
-0.1327515244,
-0.1867653131,
0.0023416695,
0.4305608273,
0.2803231478,
0.4542011321,
0.21817334,
-0.2420883924,
-0.6102468967,
0.2261884958,
0.5352036953,
-0.3538531959,
-0.2465279549,
0.4048099816,
0.0425874293,
-0.3064050674,
0.5985614061,
-0.1086461097,
-0.7162027955,
0.7597171664,
0.9254402518,
0.5773886442,
-0.1753468663,
-0.1208454221,
0.5870215297,
0.3918749392,
-0.2332888544,
0.0495293215,
-0.2463143319,
-0.7949925661,
-0.8020010591,
-0.5488875508,
-0.0294782836,
0.2460912615,
-0.4356743097,
0.2850876153,
-0.367170006,
0.1362579167,
-0.0441393107,
-0.351237148,
-0.5836645961,
-0.10336411,
0.2794556916,
0.9818955064,
-0.9543428421,
1.4753851891,
0.7716785669,
-0.0994223058,
-0.7160846591,
0.1591378003,
-0.2747083306,
-0.4970393479,
1.0502184629,
0.4214960039,
0.0951125249,
-0.0213886686,
-0.3330026865,
-0.8561975956,
0.6583436131,
0.6553536654,
-0.6783038974,
0.0902580246,
0.2566740215,
0.4306889176,
-0.4915148616,
0.4099985063,
0.3593887091,
0.4029081762,
-0.1712390035,
-0.9961115718,
-0.1837245375,
-0.2305423617,
-0.1223938763,
0.1138553545,
-0.6446529031,
1.1014267206,
-0.3516399264,
-0.0389153026,
-0.1708045453,
0.5576472282,
0.3989120722,
0.1216490939,
0.5583832264,
0.3164427578,
0.7384281158,
0.0373435728,
1.1815935373,
-0.5257846117,
0.0316484794,
1.2002062798,
-0.2508865595,
0.9439589977,
0.7590506673,
0.1550197899,
0.4062847793,
0.5502249599,
0.2981162667,
0.4092361033,
0.1359016597,
-0.4718959033,
-0.6112964749,
-0.1535556763,
-0.2243320048,
0.38681373,
0.6636856794,
-0.2063564062,
-0.2118240148,
0.6080306172,
-0.036998339,
0.2672196925,
-0.3100390434,
0.5674290061,
0.4125704765,
-0.8805858493,
0.6063196063,
-0.1109727472,
0.6973378658,
-0.6690064669,
0.0753979757,
-0.1621217281,
0.3617013097,
-0.0778493956,
-0.6258609891,
0.1797517091,
-0.1985386312,
-0.2485004067,
-0.3364482522,
0.4841939807,
-0.6866174936,
-0.5052947402,
0.8394173384,
0.4778862894,
-0.025818998,
-0.1750427186,
-0.5589203238,
0.0623374432,
-0.0038811124,
-0.1428105831,
0.6698518991,
0.3301647007,
-0.2307527512,
0.8099104762,
0.5756956935,
0.2566624284,
0.137455225,
-0.0586734936,
0.7365945578,
-0.5169378519,
-0.389667362,
-1.0669101477,
0.4280090332,
0.0206668191,
-0.1546811461,
0.8353686333,
0.4579753876,
1.227627039,
-0.0452318378,
0.8011667132,
0.0657360628,
0.1911023855,
-0.4264261723,
0.7368875742,
-0.654542923,
0.1670752317,
0.2379704863,
-0.8492509723,
-0.4042271972,
0.3653281927,
-0.7026008368,
-0.0641154125,
1.0083265305,
0.6680890322,
-0.2060706019,
-0.0892276913,
0.5544069409,
0.1402868629,
0.1563217342,
0.7109722495,
0.9407014847,
-0.1403041333,
0.2981022298,
-0.4311664701,
-0.1504210383,
0.1888597608,
-0.5386511087,
-1.3111201525,
-0.4848611951,
-0.0240115188,
-0.0082568768,
-0.1204513237,
0.7616418004,
0.7272977829,
-0.8489988446,
-0.634149909,
-0.1126240417,
0.2879839838,
-0.1479605585,
-0.1073136628,
0.2512726486,
-0.7855588198,
-1.0255577564,
0.7777099013,
0.2828904688,
-0.270650506,
-0.2471396625,
-0.1939944476,
-0.4589865506,
-0.39638412,
0.7019107938,
0.1943276525,
-0.6667851806,
0.0760724694,
0.019949954,
-0.1686548591,
0.0218050275,
0.9259250164,
-0.5958183408,
0.4546855688,
0.7014979124,
0.706874311,
0.3751420379,
-0.3657017946,
0.7411468029,
-0.498287499,
0.7392019033,
0.0399363823,
0.6675565839,
0.2332765609,
-0.2274178714,
-0.044073917,
-0.0889046043,
-0.3136709332,
-0.6601616144,
0.1446607858,
-0.5123354793,
-0.658859551,
1.2700581551,
-0.2694033384,
-0.381298095,
0.014697155,
-0.0725373477,
0.0874741748,
-0.0484508798,
0.4224008918,
0.8726843596,
-0.0223278739,
-0.2154191285,
-0.8193502426,
0.3205873966,
0.7595092058,
-0.5479655266,
-0.0403587483,
0.170518443,
0.2242903411,
0.106283851,
0.2889150083,
-0.1494774669,
0.4433689117,
-0.3153405786,
0.0191863663,
0.003487766,
-0.6539737582,
-0.7453507185,
0.3074353039,
0.3260405362,
0.0903339162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09072v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09072v1
|
UniCode: Learning a Unified Codebook for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-03-14T03:29:58 | 2024-03-14T03:29:58 |
Sipeng Zheng, Bohan Zhou, Yicheng Feng, Ye Wang, Zongqing Lu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we propose \textbf{UniCode}, a novel approach within the
domain of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) that learns a unified
codebook to efficiently tokenize visual, text, and potentially other types of
signals. This innovation addresses a critical limitation in existing MLLMs:
their reliance on a text-only codebook, which restricts MLLM's ability to
generate images and texts in a multimodal context. Towards this end, we propose
a language-driven iterative training paradigm, coupled with an in-context
pre-training task we term ``image decompression'', enabling our model to
interpret compressed visual data and generate high-quality images.The unified
codebook empowers our model to extend visual instruction tuning to
non-linguistic generation tasks. Moreover, UniCode is adaptable to diverse
stacked quantization approaches in order to compress visual signals into a more
compact token representation. Despite using significantly fewer parameters and
less data during training, Unicode demonstrates promising capabilities in
visual reconstruction and generation. It also achieves performances comparable
to leading MLLMs across a spectrum of VQA benchmarks.
|
[
-0.2798648775,
-0.5333563685,
-0.0125972535,
0.2182675749,
-0.364118576,
0.1779622287,
-0.5028939843,
-0.1617144346,
0.1851539463,
0.5372778177,
-0.4209983349,
-0.6551301479,
-0.4628326595,
0.2196146995,
-0.298778832,
0.7417920828,
0.1323647946,
0.0923418179,
-0.3581179976,
-0.1982817799,
-0.6977053285,
-0.8004161119,
-0.2633340061,
0.286660105,
0.4481605887,
0.4377098382,
0.6591726542,
0.4824121594,
0.3868187666,
0.3880651891,
0.4860869348,
0.2407778054,
-0.5296384692,
0.1001529545,
0.1266244352,
-0.2723595202,
-0.0992593318,
-0.4344619215,
0.9403393269,
0.7146461606,
0.0144217592,
0.0963759646,
0.0721543804,
0.5843085647,
-0.6507351995,
0.3854998648,
-0.6247481108,
0.0519735292,
-0.262604773,
-0.2221787423,
-0.8382406235,
0.0354087241,
-0.528028667,
-0.7225030661,
-0.0767768249,
0.017419152,
0.7590073943,
0.1411903203,
-0.7884094715,
-0.0673594996,
-0.416244477,
1.0003324747,
-0.1331402808,
0.7962647676,
0.1694654673,
0.1604772806,
-0.0818687752,
-0.9806103706,
-0.3500716984,
-0.0456853621,
0.1132213175,
0.1139889061,
-0.1660401821,
-0.0006278148,
0.1826324463,
0.1609899104,
-0.7167344093,
0.0537548549,
-0.4043934941,
-0.429556191,
0.4826906621,
0.0561300553,
0.7342397571,
-0.1497229338,
-0.4223798215,
-0.2187122703,
-0.6291030645,
0.0767497569,
0.0112441061,
0.4153682888,
-0.0758933127,
0.3514943123,
0.0569663346,
0.7084442377,
-0.4924418628,
-0.0240130406,
0.2709327638,
-0.1324475557,
-0.3140098155,
-0.0343190394,
0.7807043195,
0.2424882799,
0.308978498,
-0.0355398841,
-0.241514504,
0.1077858806,
0.2654899955,
-1.002440691,
-0.2691243291,
-0.096670799,
-0.6996329427,
-0.0465205498,
0.0636821017,
-0.7345712781,
-0.3930976391,
-0.4012386501,
0.3684037924,
-0.5124621987,
-0.5428230762,
-0.2530395985,
-0.029011162,
0.030222958,
0.4107123017,
-1.0999497175,
-0.0599629022,
0.3272219598,
0.6572387218,
0.1725456566,
-0.3072668314,
-0.8290114403,
-0.0418232046,
-0.6313250661,
0.7193233967,
-0.8642639518,
-0.5471026897,
0.2276734263,
-0.1102156416,
-0.1222244278,
-0.2653757334,
0.2727386355,
-0.3389209509,
-0.2714183331,
-0.2443261892,
-0.4104531109,
-0.1689017862,
-0.0895392448,
-0.8787270188,
0.6741883755,
0.1574402899,
-0.5826104879,
0.5284618139,
-0.5699141026,
-0.4514592588,
0.4367842376,
-0.4607099891,
-0.246702522,
0.3290374279,
0.2981363833,
0.4952445328,
-0.0932056308,
0.1575241089,
-0.4271439016,
-0.4604794681,
0.1599619985,
-0.6075211167,
0.6517677307,
0.5446822047,
0.1600819975,
0.3498539925,
-0.7032732368,
0.2913950384,
0.2135991007,
-0.3699392378,
-0.4199450016,
-0.134580493,
0.6601336002,
0.0829791874,
0.0831790715,
-0.4169042408,
0.6260613203,
0.0128334789,
0.4918503761,
0.6540741324,
-0.336658299,
0.5198869109,
0.1274428666,
0.3496955037,
0.1576582938,
0.2089435607,
-0.8104735017,
-0.3358590305,
-0.6529021859,
-0.5768633485,
0.4860893786,
0.0934077725,
-1.1997556686,
0.0155352205,
-0.460185796,
-0.2177338302,
-0.4146442711,
0.4168103933,
0.4028476775,
0.1221217811,
0.2615045309,
-0.3388558626,
-0.7061983347,
-0.581774354,
-0.1572025567,
0.0904692113,
0.1983073801,
0.0766192526,
0.5886064768,
-0.4631203413,
0.5627602935,
-0.0302857123,
-0.4269091189,
-0.4388890266,
0.3091071546,
-0.0599181913,
0.627276957,
0.4203375578,
-1.1930180788,
-0.4724138677,
0.0643856749,
-1.001609087,
0.3741870821,
-0.2226750404,
-0.0713487789,
0.6630110741,
0.7171261311,
-0.2163279951,
0.3909340501,
0.6077169776,
-0.4060966372,
0.3627000749,
-0.2588905096,
0.1762398332,
-1.2403745651,
-0.0030896324,
0.0532206111,
-0.1881276816,
-0.5307959318,
0.2995610833,
0.5984206796,
-0.380360961,
-0.3361359239,
0.5961402059,
-0.710110724,
-0.0635833964,
-0.1048490703,
-0.2961463928,
-0.0400475338,
0.5559334755,
0.3501756489,
0.6571016908,
0.8343297839,
-0.3874119222,
0.2354122698,
0.4179814458,
-0.5006551743,
0.5015414953,
-0.1418519467,
-0.0129750976,
-0.3268072903,
0.2101550996,
-0.8096389174,
-0.3468437791,
-0.2689338028,
-0.4726490378,
0.5922356844,
-0.1945323944,
-0.5779871941,
-0.3667612672,
-0.1281825155,
0.509398222,
0.59370327,
-0.6945530772,
0.6917108297,
0.2520786524,
-0.0710098222,
-0.7204188704,
-0.6637238264,
0.3915558755,
0.094854787,
-0.4060036838,
-0.0681236461,
-0.2418120503,
-0.0661332831,
-0.0023629756,
-0.0079921102,
-0.1553189605,
0.1760359406,
0.4399901628,
0.3317203224,
-0.3741908669,
0.503881216,
0.1134495363,
-0.0330740288,
-0.3196018934,
-0.4929625392,
0.4444674551,
-0.4041351974,
-0.2116107643,
-0.2569230199,
0.5546540618,
0.476901561,
-0.6191623211,
0.5778562427,
0.737318635,
-0.3414468169,
-0.2319486141,
-0.0952086002,
0.0529457554,
-0.4683763981,
0.6480892897,
-0.7084050179,
-0.6429136992,
0.1053545326,
-0.0914909616,
0.1230482981,
0.2948521376,
0.7046676874,
-0.0132393967,
1.12680161,
0.9204800725,
0.0385660827,
0.611936152,
-0.394418031,
-0.0407447852,
-0.5231487155,
-0.1773409396,
-0.401851356,
-0.1131259799,
-0.4554884434,
-0.2705115676,
0.2288243473,
0.2373789549,
-0.3069630563,
0.2556951046,
-0.3829136789,
0.610357523,
0.6566434503,
-0.0115766693,
0.2023509294,
0.324888736,
-0.2340484858,
0.0430441201,
-0.727704227,
-0.3204023838,
1.278142333,
0.0267154258,
0.9537335634,
0.1050552353,
0.7805633545,
0.3647503257,
0.4537698328,
-0.7011159062,
0.348382324,
-0.2739807069,
-0.2328131199,
-0.1506867856,
-0.5744886994,
-1.010548234,
0.3017013669,
-0.3551542163,
-0.8371748924,
-0.0048761577,
0.0314106531,
-0.0437936112,
0.3251700699,
-0.8559898734,
1.1139268875,
-0.1625430435,
-0.3220751286,
-0.0251644384,
-0.6046422124,
0.2836371362,
-0.2027523965,
0.4020334184,
0.1774529815,
0.0187145881,
0.6203888655,
-0.2140410841,
0.760697782,
-0.1969529688,
-0.1857770085,
0.1570671648,
0.3547465503,
0.1279205531,
-0.0186607856,
0.1524346173,
0.3663854897,
0.0709581971,
-0.5400064588,
-0.4623190165,
0.7560804486,
-0.7986860275,
-0.1959367543,
-0.1758601367,
-0.8101708889,
-0.2158908546,
0.4298385084,
0.219456166,
1.2211904526,
-0.0521840677,
0.4864798784,
0.346457839,
-0.4475985467,
0.661018908,
0.2013460547,
-0.3644317687,
-0.473215431,
1.4050616026,
-0.0702131391,
0.0516081154,
0.7186936736,
-0.1729774475,
-0.4957565963,
-0.3141118288,
-0.7593101859,
-0.0412902944,
-1.0476222038,
-0.3021952212,
-0.420384109,
-0.0381251164,
-0.5304362774,
-0.2528579831,
-0.3255974948,
-0.1063865051,
-0.3069190383,
0.2260174453,
0.074076876,
0.706389308,
0.0206196047,
0.0416337028,
-1.1291942596,
0.3533573449,
0.0619344488,
0.3412690759,
-0.0623569377,
-0.2680805027,
-0.436322242,
0.2022591829,
-0.2541492879,
-0.5313351154,
0.5784392357,
0.4920915365,
0.4438149035,
0.5060526133,
0.098724246,
0.7252459526,
-0.4240620732,
0.7847313285,
0.6151458621,
-1.0054621696,
0.3178678453,
-0.1616720259,
0.4259451926,
0.1460651457,
0.4173130989,
-0.6150894165,
-0.3152231574,
-0.3063634038,
-0.6931618452,
0.4521841109,
0.1391006261,
0.3805046678,
0.0255475007,
-0.0898347124,
0.1760966033,
0.2198047489,
-0.8546801209,
-0.0862255692,
-0.6001894474,
-0.6472620368,
-0.2040733546,
-0.2398627549,
0.1738494635,
-0.2581340075,
0.2664420605,
-0.6052390337,
0.3154862523,
-0.0096129971,
-0.75048244,
0.0092567187,
0.1436150819,
0.5361099243,
0.5727396011,
0.1474045217,
0.1714457721,
-0.4166351855,
-0.4414825439,
-0.0090254685,
-0.1168713048,
0.1690825671,
-0.1856728643,
0.5744608641,
0.9841427207,
0.2693481147,
-0.8638029099,
0.5502871871,
-0.3873932958,
-0.3025330603,
-0.1401137114,
-0.1806212962,
-0.2311312407,
0.176064536,
0.4542635083,
0.179971844,
-0.0321831107,
-0.5953837633,
0.4001126587,
0.4837629199,
-0.4039330184,
-0.257185787,
0.8586680293,
0.4197869599,
-0.090807721,
0.8627386689,
-0.1043739468,
-0.2930573225,
0.5586599708,
0.7836540341,
0.6585066319,
-0.0271556191,
0.3481389582,
0.4463253915,
0.1789261401,
0.2390093356,
0.3794421554,
-0.4558519125,
-0.6278586984,
-0.407284528,
-0.7854328752,
-0.0808631778,
-0.0580909513,
-0.6070342064,
0.2604153454,
-0.2555036247,
0.2366038412,
-0.0326713398,
-0.2070370764,
-0.6592483521,
0.1941522062,
0.6097152829,
0.8672897816,
-0.5538900495,
1.0418230295,
0.7189825177,
-0.7126726508,
-0.7554482222,
-0.2663391232,
-0.0919345468,
-0.9117903113,
0.932719171,
0.4971370697,
0.2853133082,
0.3839223981,
-0.6098659635,
-0.6538255215,
0.7058375478,
0.4733786285,
-0.6514285803,
0.1800275147,
0.1364441067,
0.0931370482,
-0.1633184105,
0.3684631288,
0.1017553359,
0.3916802108,
0.0935429409,
-0.8010658622,
-0.04936013,
-0.627941072,
0.3562714159,
0.3062612116,
-0.4665058553,
0.8812505007,
-0.4401726723,
-0.3890059292,
0.379794389,
0.8138712049,
-0.1557747126,
-0.0166601054,
0.2892438471,
0.380533725,
0.7260226011,
-0.1608488858,
1.1771959066,
-0.3079769015,
0.3544591069,
0.6475948691,
-0.1879814118,
0.838081181,
0.4351438582,
0.2590403557,
0.4965036213,
0.529777348,
-0.0287343189,
0.3906978965,
0.0349495783,
-0.1304592192,
-0.5468986034,
-0.104249157,
-0.2188027948,
0.5634073019,
0.3673917949,
-0.159091711,
-0.3586486876,
0.6687863469,
-0.2179608494,
0.1729837507,
-0.6413950324,
0.7589740157,
0.0452809036,
-0.4790054262,
1.0086040497,
-0.1583994776,
0.4391880035,
-0.6913385391,
-0.2363474518,
-0.2972058952,
0.2714802325,
-0.0674571842,
-0.5514647365,
-0.0691753551,
-0.0181410294,
0.0060856743,
-0.3532925844,
0.6770472527,
-0.5551266074,
-0.6590382457,
0.0061529721,
0.2214239538,
0.0664380118,
-0.3202779293,
-0.5551261902,
0.5358877182,
0.0074831774,
-0.1976619661,
0.4036729038,
0.430429548,
-0.2036817521,
0.7212542295,
0.6121656299,
-0.3061060905,
0.0814233348,
0.2736901641,
0.6890935898,
-0.7679443359,
-0.5359057188,
-0.6761346459,
0.6389613152,
0.0461689532,
-0.058461234,
0.8111693263,
0.6203932762,
0.8580411673,
-0.3470771015,
0.9672477245,
-0.0101683261,
-0.3912836611,
-0.7250725627,
0.7128158808,
-1.0105633736,
-0.2689193487,
-0.2227445096,
-0.6854879856,
-0.5590308309,
0.3805824518,
0.2207423896,
-0.0226994604,
0.7620291114,
0.6809732318,
-0.0439231806,
0.01563593,
0.7431805134,
0.2459719777,
0.3649072051,
0.7013685107,
0.8013243675,
-0.4329866171,
0.7115235329,
0.145157218,
-0.2134126127,
-0.2805003822,
-0.7115801573,
-0.9328349233,
-1.0512706041,
-0.1485055983,
-0.1501602978,
-0.2232773155,
1.0140455961,
0.8147491217,
-0.5971873999,
-0.2267424464,
-0.1339714974,
0.0605153851,
-0.1983231306,
-0.1850310713,
0.2545507848,
-0.6967576146,
-0.9107505083,
0.2301915139,
0.3434211314,
0.0321454778,
-0.1823235601,
-0.1445390731,
0.2042212337,
-0.132278651,
0.7885696292,
0.4250295758,
-0.4840657711,
0.0403406918,
-0.110222213,
-0.1118478999,
-0.0082605565,
0.8678252697,
-0.7931959629,
0.8238865137,
0.1295701563,
0.6906266809,
0.1918755472,
-0.3546555042,
0.3948362768,
-0.8521426916,
0.5081564188,
0.020233294,
0.7149934769,
0.2836320698,
-0.0662249029,
0.089511551,
0.2231854647,
-0.2524651289,
-0.933180809,
0.2433701456,
-1.0583113432,
-0.56698066,
1.2436469793,
0.0126036759,
-0.5340002179,
0.1893044859,
-0.502599597,
0.1065568775,
-0.3865622878,
0.4154790342,
0.2702921331,
0.4801824689,
-0.25666821,
-0.2628306746,
0.2668869495,
-0.019218944,
-0.761815846,
0.1979276538,
0.6396605372,
0.0566386133,
0.020091841,
0.565833509,
-0.0713637918,
0.4284353852,
0.2755504847,
0.4812406003,
-0.3644750118,
-0.7293951511,
-0.2943101823,
0.2622333765,
-0.0567124821,
-0.2033549547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09059v1
|
LAMP: A Language Model on the Map
| 2024-03-14T02:56:38 | 2024-03-14T02:56:38 |
Pasquale Balsebre, Weiming Huang, Gao Cong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are poised to play an increasingly important
role in our lives, providing assistance across a wide array of tasks. In the
geospatial domain, LLMs have demonstrated the ability to answer generic
questions, such as identifying a country's capital; nonetheless, their utility
is hindered when it comes to answering fine-grained questions about specific
places, such as grocery stores or restaurants, which constitute essential
aspects of people's everyday lives. This is mainly because the places in our
cities haven't been systematically fed into LLMs, so as to understand and
memorize them. This study introduces a novel framework for fine-tuning a
pre-trained model on city-specific data, to enable it to provide accurate
recommendations, while minimizing hallucinations. We share our model, LAMP, and
the data used to train it. We conduct experiments to analyze its ability to
correctly retrieving spatial objects, and compare it to well-known open- and
closed- source language models, such as GPT-4. Finally, we explore its emerging
capabilities through a case study on day planning.
|
[
-0.3769144714,
-0.9248994589,
1.0146948099,
0.1829576343,
0.07258261,
-0.2260154784,
-0.5299366713,
-0.6749848723,
0.0097156577,
0.4616774619,
-0.3885298967,
-0.8479530811,
-0.3730739951,
-0.0174585544,
-0.5901689529,
0.6584436893,
-0.0594844185,
0.0426102392,
0.0556524172,
0.0825431347,
-0.537047267,
-0.4515486062,
-0.4737155139,
-0.4809527099,
0.5321638584,
0.7863026261,
0.9417756796,
0.4741678238,
0.6298404336,
0.2094206512,
0.2464986295,
0.1020393372,
-0.6551215053,
-0.3158204257,
-0.2610158324,
-0.3322656155,
-0.3190578818,
-0.0479741432,
0.2571688294,
0.9845773578,
-0.2569670677,
0.2369417846,
-0.323220849,
0.4960276186,
-0.3410929143,
0.1966862828,
-0.8005568385,
0.0268573705,
-0.2821307778,
-0.0976809189,
-0.1575833559,
-0.4866982698,
0.3431732953,
-0.4824854136,
0.3747349679,
0.2945093811,
0.9514020681,
0.2356257737,
-0.1696098149,
-0.2894663811,
-0.9548498392,
0.6480049491,
-0.3595080376,
0.3093262911,
0.7124066949,
0.5088528991,
-0.1003846675,
-0.4954048395,
-0.5406703353,
-0.2986452878,
-0.2033054978,
-0.2201772183,
0.1096795723,
-0.1244830564,
0.2656573355,
0.2287270427,
-0.5414533019,
-0.087772578,
-0.4440037906,
0.276263684,
0.3683168292,
0.1839558482,
0.4614698291,
-0.2838663459,
-0.3498674333,
0.1819144785,
-0.968408823,
-0.2027836293,
0.0026279883,
0.2996173799,
-0.0294089299,
0.4789322615,
-0.1529531777,
0.805958271,
-0.1939665824,
0.1908928901,
-0.0303058457,
-0.0063811885,
-0.2464098483,
-0.2316409349,
0.506479919,
0.3895027041,
0.7276994586,
-0.2722416818,
-0.2297120839,
-0.0122870086,
0.169275865,
-0.5540800691,
-0.8181993961,
0.2382021099,
-0.1693273336,
-0.0757018179,
-0.0609750189,
-0.6135091782,
-0.5251096487,
-0.3873625696,
0.1007625312,
-0.3787661195,
-0.3186598122,
0.3983332515,
0.3228132725,
0.2621919513,
0.3334673047,
-1.2357568741,
0.2151915431,
0.6279694438,
0.7763535976,
-0.341450423,
-0.4914167225,
-0.0381212831,
0.3513449132,
-0.5317879915,
0.9074145555,
-0.6671935916,
-0.4655335248,
0.0965997577,
-0.0912850201,
0.1390316039,
-0.5654944777,
0.2831457853,
-0.4678165913,
0.0819033384,
-0.5016372204,
-0.2286525518,
-0.0035702125,
0.3811989129,
-0.5507264137,
1.1978958845,
0.2402783632,
-0.5357209444,
0.3636484742,
-0.6270691752,
-0.3847790658,
0.0200341512,
-0.3576611578,
-0.1628513485,
0.3399359584,
0.5951763988,
0.4010551274,
-0.1905107349,
0.4902733266,
-0.0995445028,
-0.4588557184,
0.1400259882,
-0.1642005891,
0.5584617257,
0.259729594,
-0.1545584649,
0.2535172403,
-0.91196841,
-0.0139965266,
0.0683996975,
-0.2768578231,
-0.3273300231,
0.1725372225,
0.468678683,
-0.0565065369,
0.5335376263,
-0.3783926368,
0.2728161812,
-0.4667237103,
0.3000146747,
0.6931570768,
-0.4017416537,
0.5867613554,
-0.1583015472,
0.498865366,
-0.2338643074,
0.1577507555,
-0.1298844516,
-0.3056994379,
-0.7849977612,
-0.0840680972,
-0.0208876934,
0.4908103645,
-0.6119581461,
0.164110139,
-0.4213126004,
-0.6726648808,
-0.089074783,
-0.0008394948,
0.0080782883,
0.3765252531,
0.3896849751,
-0.0181703046,
-0.7465846539,
-0.4546813369,
-0.0573200583,
0.0710048303,
-0.0025471244,
0.5746037364,
0.2638941109,
-0.4213682115,
1.270378232,
-0.9515953064,
-0.2112288624,
-0.4725463688,
-0.2692040503,
0.3897601664,
0.1779222935,
0.6878679395,
-0.6726160049,
-0.3950743675,
-0.1372866631,
-0.7295275331,
-0.4010546505,
-0.0249572713,
-0.2355341613,
-0.2068207562,
0.5463272333,
-0.7903009653,
0.2809627056,
0.6624798179,
-0.4637504816,
0.4914540648,
-0.5178763866,
-0.0984042212,
-0.8455119133,
-0.0600276515,
-0.2593191862,
-0.249544099,
-0.6509791613,
0.1652892977,
0.0152960708,
-0.4994962811,
-0.1887901425,
0.6557068825,
-0.498994261,
-0.3716495037,
-0.3891757131,
0.1643446237,
-0.155082196,
0.3250297606,
0.2673271596,
0.8568181992,
0.606862843,
-0.448141098,
0.3812707663,
0.1065361649,
-0.6654523611,
0.2633777857,
-0.5112162828,
0.1723964512,
-0.0961933956,
-0.0364626125,
-0.8693086505,
-0.3126211464,
-0.0893850103,
0.1901896,
-0.0905497745,
0.064362593,
-0.6693196893,
-0.4287268221,
0.1771724224,
0.5185713768,
0.2188720852,
-0.6831198931,
0.66218853,
0.5862799883,
0.0266770311,
-0.0999788865,
-0.5243652463,
0.2100066394,
-0.2318614125,
-0.3736688495,
0.0597105473,
-0.1367026567,
-0.376180917,
-0.1610131264,
0.1370965093,
-0.3184957206,
0.1520297527,
0.4418652952,
0.1496989876,
0.0583787896,
0.2579081357,
-0.8309649229,
-0.3323549926,
-0.0692249611,
-0.4058844149,
0.8487125039,
-0.123743929,
-0.6112915874,
-0.0687101707,
0.2177120149,
0.4461386502,
-0.3495138586,
0.3312544525,
0.560305953,
-0.4055273235,
-0.3349941373,
-0.5445613265,
-0.0861190856,
-0.5513017178,
0.4650231898,
-0.4505562782,
-0.6876423359,
0.4673026502,
-0.1484287232,
-0.0671828389,
-0.072614193,
0.4592445493,
-0.1749147624,
0.5384250283,
1.0042752028,
-0.2743268013,
0.6602499485,
-0.0968790427,
0.6526085734,
-0.2952286601,
-0.1279373765,
-0.3464516103,
-0.3987974524,
-0.409978658,
-0.6674006581,
0.3139971495,
-0.0207699258,
-0.1671309322,
0.3836745322,
-0.3747582734,
0.8555564284,
0.4380331635,
-0.047551088,
0.3561136425,
-0.0338809602,
0.1034271196,
-0.0792775899,
-0.6139948964,
-0.5317787528,
0.9525383711,
0.2092465907,
1.1572630405,
-0.0488625914,
0.5088089108,
0.0014078657,
0.2255608737,
-0.4706358314,
0.7533085346,
-0.1452099383,
-0.5830578804,
-0.4003350735,
-0.1647055596,
-0.981121242,
0.1655987203,
0.0669441968,
-0.6342303753,
0.1264654845,
0.1071091145,
-0.5647890568,
0.3108375072,
-0.7512938976,
0.7506603003,
-0.6762248874,
-0.0864078924,
-0.2055130899,
-0.0695243254,
-0.0215360038,
-0.0872912183,
0.4918704033,
-0.5639895797,
0.3063059449,
0.07500121,
-0.0191814583,
0.7981117964,
-0.1805347353,
-0.2634964287,
0.079966709,
0.1805027872,
0.4503036141,
-0.0130716395,
-0.1144226715,
0.4015461504,
-0.1260248721,
-0.3062956631,
-0.4444189966,
0.8738418818,
-0.8723703623,
-0.5535296202,
-0.1858282089,
-0.8598940372,
-0.2565948069,
0.134835884,
0.1236639768,
0.354020983,
-0.2593080103,
-0.2431512922,
0.6937388778,
-0.3991565704,
0.338000387,
0.6726088524,
-0.9380339384,
0.0246569775,
0.7835205793,
0.1829433143,
-0.1128359362,
0.3902207315,
0.1671641171,
-0.0982848182,
-0.5285909772,
-0.098869361,
0.0930177867,
-0.8070292473,
0.0450158715,
-0.3676254153,
0.0740837976,
-0.1143323332,
-0.4720531404,
-0.349345535,
-0.2237752527,
-0.2182298601,
-0.4182987511,
0.3847772181,
1.1948223114,
0.1334188581,
0.2475616634,
-0.3133752942,
0.3911989033,
0.2081997544,
0.5691667795,
-0.1313264221,
-0.0461087562,
-0.5634073615,
-0.218162939,
0.0841903612,
-0.786455214,
0.490912199,
0.0477463342,
0.17965886,
0.4353776276,
-0.1168244183,
0.9701479077,
-1.0111373663,
0.7732024193,
-0.0982670709,
-0.7200917006,
0.7394863963,
-0.6534233093,
0.5326293111,
0.3360889852,
0.1360653192,
-0.510594666,
-0.3249711692,
-0.2629954517,
-1.0379636288,
0.2693523169,
-0.1089045629,
0.3237857521,
-0.1969150603,
0.5050650835,
-0.1092236117,
0.2566041648,
-1.1218801737,
-0.0077228122,
-0.070007354,
-0.2385381907,
-0.3207558393,
-0.5242670774,
-0.2050718367,
-0.4313580096,
0.2170151323,
0.1113573164,
0.0525948666,
0.1039406359,
-0.2938883007,
-0.2921082973,
0.1923641711,
0.4388328791,
1.2026718855,
-0.1605021805,
0.3971293867,
0.4738377035,
-0.3479243815,
-0.1327641904,
-0.1018398702,
-0.2813520133,
0.0657016784,
0.1992576271,
0.518034637,
0.5517938733,
-0.7489382625,
0.3429259956,
0.2049685568,
0.2973923385,
-0.7010319233,
0.0903266594,
0.0376797616,
0.3400891721,
0.4138688743,
-0.0774689913,
-0.0844674334,
-0.558847487,
0.1415017098,
0.4547335207,
-0.3160789609,
-0.3148854077,
0.5758283138,
0.2021379918,
-0.2528697848,
0.4113495648,
-0.0065260548,
-0.4525816739,
0.3233157098,
0.4378410876,
0.7680537701,
-0.0421144143,
0.0272448733,
0.1873677522,
0.4349555671,
-0.1859098971,
0.5227832198,
0.1351721287,
-0.7885402441,
-0.3201717138,
-0.7804647684,
-0.2874037623,
0.0855147839,
-0.3545327485,
0.2826517522,
-0.5744119287,
-0.1460856944,
-0.6122873425,
0.0986956432,
-0.9312041402,
0.1443063766,
0.2487408668,
1.0479986668,
-0.8805374503,
1.080745101,
0.6699698567,
-0.1805223972,
-0.7804187536,
0.2123627961,
-0.4903347492,
-0.9308744073,
0.7075454593,
0.1459065676,
-0.3637375236,
0.0243825465,
-0.6618036628,
-1.2119746208,
1.0119988918,
0.4406690896,
-0.7692930102,
-0.2616153657,
0.3937806189,
0.6995338202,
-0.3320329189,
0.2154887021,
0.6089344025,
0.4714437127,
-0.2882058918,
-1.0720655918,
-0.1453902572,
0.2367088348,
0.2898703814,
-0.0519964062,
-0.4547335804,
1.0000281334,
-0.5274422765,
-0.1302831471,
0.1179583073,
0.4904353917,
0.0654546767,
0.0850107595,
0.3037566543,
0.6192082763,
0.9678200483,
-0.3905719519,
1.0945991278,
-0.511697948,
0.3815419674,
1.2827334404,
-0.5050675273,
1.1720142365,
0.4080274999,
-0.1397649795,
0.7094935775,
0.6315749288,
-0.1460499763,
0.8379036784,
0.3581081331,
-0.0438975021,
-0.3237091899,
0.1254249662,
-0.3267902136,
0.5542351007,
0.28842026,
0.0258866865,
-0.4514830112,
0.2296947986,
-0.182372883,
0.261964947,
-0.317350179,
0.6214264035,
0.0197132137,
-0.4829062521,
0.2797407806,
-0.0951067656,
0.3811764121,
-0.5793821216,
0.1099912524,
-0.2692377567,
0.3169366419,
-0.313944608,
-0.7049999833,
0.2319825888,
-0.0062610325,
-0.4206740558,
-0.4066375494,
0.5305829048,
-0.6377215981,
-0.6284301281,
0.4225823879,
0.4027008116,
0.1628106087,
-0.0758480728,
-0.346013993,
0.2631085515,
-0.1850163043,
-0.1579743475,
0.0245473962,
0.6646216512,
0.07869111,
0.9433570504,
0.6375235915,
0.4707448184,
0.0468332618,
0.35026443,
0.6157593131,
-0.8432338834,
-0.6338617802,
-0.8213991523,
0.1671193391,
0.0605145395,
-0.1046520621,
0.9291716218,
0.542925179,
0.8780092597,
-0.1209060922,
0.6425232291,
0.1444490701,
0.5851398706,
-0.4861358404,
0.667601943,
-0.1993852407,
0.8041142821,
-0.0914968848,
-0.95546031,
-0.3722684085,
1.0628634691,
-0.9678364396,
0.0375114679,
0.5482035279,
0.8797003627,
-0.0880016536,
-0.191143021,
0.443811059,
0.2697152495,
0.4662184417,
0.5813837051,
0.8740156889,
-0.0580175966,
0.6084157825,
0.0224680621,
-0.0284256358,
-0.2005923092,
-0.7905647755,
-0.9763581753,
-0.4481242597,
0.0817623362,
0.1246119887,
0.1919379085,
0.8248898983,
0.8679394722,
-0.8891987801,
-0.5849509835,
-0.2659809887,
0.0612324625,
0.1271248162,
-0.1629601568,
0.446582377,
-0.3946846724,
-0.6560303569,
0.4825957119,
0.4148407876,
0.0344590507,
-0.5227888227,
0.0754148737,
0.0113160862,
-0.0875720903,
0.518907547,
-0.0117798392,
-0.8014649749,
-0.5013026595,
-0.0611775704,
-0.2737519741,
0.1432771981,
0.9068659544,
-0.8346056938,
0.4580103159,
0.0604541115,
0.4380000234,
0.3563108444,
-0.0474887826,
0.7403184175,
-0.9672919512,
0.3768603504,
0.0086319279,
0.537782073,
0.6404069662,
-0.302572906,
0.575519383,
-0.0847540796,
-0.6924594045,
-0.557096839,
0.5014147758,
-0.5312098265,
-0.4043386579,
1.3869273663,
0.1466104984,
0.019755451,
-0.2011633664,
-0.3791462183,
-0.1124835536,
-0.0660725534,
1.2372832298,
0.745459497,
0.0066151409,
-0.3447860479,
-0.8657784462,
0.7172519565,
0.2606886923,
-0.8065833449,
0.2754555643,
0.6635689735,
0.4814073443,
0.139388293,
0.9177272916,
0.2589690089,
-0.0064545814,
-0.3787303567,
-0.0002263889,
0.1127219126,
-0.5349707603,
-0.1605312973,
0.3207478523,
0.4204883575,
0.028751621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09057v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09057v3
|
A Continued Pretrained LLM Approach for Automatic Medical Note Generation
| 2024-03-14T02:55:37 | 2024-04-03T18:08:30 |
Dong Yuan, Eti Rastogi, Gautam Naik, Sree Prasanna Rajagopal, Sagar Goyal, Fen Zhao, Bharath Chintagunta, Jeff Ward
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
LLMs are revolutionizing NLP tasks. However, the use of the most advanced
LLMs, such as GPT-4, is often prohibitively expensive for most specialized
fields. We introduce HEAL, the first continuously trained 13B LLaMA2-based LLM
that is purpose-built for medical conversations and measured on automated
scribing. Our results demonstrate that HEAL outperforms GPT-4 and PMC-LLaMA in
PubMedQA, with an accuracy of 78.4\%. It also achieves parity with GPT-4 in
generating medical notes. Remarkably, HEAL surpasses GPT-4 and Med-PaLM 2 in
identifying more correct medical concepts and exceeds the performance of human
scribes and other comparable models in correctness and completeness.
|
[
0.2064759135,
-0.6041235328,
0.9258192778,
0.4402952492,
-0.3770231307,
0.2383864522,
-0.0683681518,
-0.6516750455,
0.587225318,
0.4727831483,
-0.4670715034,
-0.7123003006,
-0.55516994,
0.3859352469,
-0.0923845097,
1.4213694334,
0.007423501,
0.3298857212,
-0.096637018,
-0.2903737128,
-0.2625456154,
-0.4554458559,
-0.7743697762,
-0.5009422898,
0.7899668813,
0.1790466905,
0.3384091258,
0.8774352074,
0.8882094622,
0.2719692886,
0.1574419439,
0.5403709412,
-0.1717264056,
0.2160485834,
-0.0396747552,
-0.6302899122,
-1.0140223503,
0.2816388905,
0.4759535491,
0.2929264307,
-0.4281231165,
0.0817094296,
-0.2360450029,
0.9038860202,
-0.0272491351,
-0.1747021079,
-0.7450158596,
0.1138976142,
-0.5881572366,
-0.4399153292,
-0.4674403667,
-0.5485379696,
-0.0453836359,
-0.7516679168,
0.1353389025,
-0.0956207812,
1.0183262825,
0.5365083814,
-0.1603488028,
-0.414277643,
-0.3671002984,
0.3486815393,
-0.7533003688,
0.0175623316,
0.425826937,
0.3409919739,
-0.2061526924,
-1.3240383863,
-0.1255992502,
-0.2682368755,
0.2526614964,
0.4783953726,
0.1578264683,
0.1914077103,
0.1107146144,
0.5382323265,
-0.2631482482,
0.2118460089,
-0.2979289591,
0.1083463058,
0.5091406107,
0.3514917493,
0.3492004275,
0.0456529148,
-0.577499032,
0.299803853,
-0.9485086203,
-0.3237385452,
-0.2233317345,
-0.199020952,
0.066463992,
0.4104795754,
0.2666578889,
0.5935233235,
0.1645339131,
-0.7596853971,
0.3081944883,
-0.4206556082,
-0.3692678511,
0.100438796,
0.9179896712,
0.6080830693,
0.1561678648,
0.0588802621,
-0.0160463359,
0.1673264503,
0.6649183035,
-0.7853947878,
-0.5410608053,
0.1137727052,
-0.3379476368,
-0.5292346478,
-0.4210915565,
-0.3144160807,
-0.4989079833,
-0.1543214768,
0.0624071173,
-0.3632016778,
-0.0060593933,
0.0980157927,
0.3659445643,
0.0271103829,
0.6063452363,
-1.0130354166,
0.3706765175,
0.5982069373,
0.9538041353,
-0.2493670285,
0.0315783806,
-0.3934560716,
0.2610354125,
-0.6140241623,
1.2887964249,
-0.0720608607,
-0.1684710234,
-0.3420135081,
-0.2831501961,
0.0181147195,
-0.8582553267,
0.4865474999,
-0.1513857543,
0.2111689597,
-0.1127844676,
-0.7027240992,
0.0629197881,
0.4159573913,
-0.3848629296,
1.0651509762,
0.3779677153,
-0.8124653101,
0.5017836094,
-0.6199970245,
-0.4511589706,
0.2696887851,
-0.2188749909,
-0.7777493,
0.0162924062,
0.0348336548,
0.395786494,
-0.5714107156,
0.4323536456,
0.0769812465,
-0.2933581471,
0.1293517351,
-0.3382070363,
0.4636954963,
0.0068793502,
-0.3430103362,
0.0784678459,
-0.8717478514,
0.0824149773,
0.1558561772,
-0.918418169,
-0.0668044761,
-0.1720226109,
-0.3228669167,
0.1991901696,
0.0252687242,
-0.6404994726,
0.4673700035,
-0.738091886,
0.4924589694,
0.6407564878,
0.1077707559,
0.1793510765,
-0.6021696329,
0.5861638784,
-0.2152124643,
-0.0417192616,
-0.2761080861,
-0.6299726367,
-0.6863621473,
-0.6967924237,
0.27762115,
0.933136344,
-0.3300136924,
0.2550082803,
0.0119082844,
-0.9022114873,
-0.988942802,
0.1993771642,
0.5806308389,
0.8625481129,
0.6496542096,
-0.4564238489,
-0.6973788738,
-0.7208061218,
-0.3146910667,
-0.3008006513,
-0.0410570651,
0.381845355,
-0.0688694045,
-0.5265775919,
0.4281928241,
-0.3364050388,
-0.5185478926,
-0.0840725526,
-0.1447049826,
0.285239011,
0.3555494547,
0.4496707618,
0.0207814425,
-0.5977090001,
-0.2232854068,
-0.8142496347,
-0.4871051013,
-0.427608043,
-0.2063187957,
0.3650713265,
0.1922620684,
-0.6776733994,
0.2381315678,
0.345344156,
-0.2033469677,
0.3416377902,
-0.4964570105,
0.0792746618,
-1.2788126469,
0.15873909,
-0.1341366768,
-0.4787440598,
-0.4614554346,
-0.6054474115,
0.1548409313,
0.3154846132,
-0.199019596,
0.503372252,
-0.4787290692,
0.0456574559,
-0.3832882643,
0.1138369292,
-0.0552420355,
0.0935128108,
0.040426068,
0.4243815541,
0.1892405748,
-0.3913162649,
0.4501983225,
0.4525157809,
-0.1558521539,
0.7960820794,
-0.6375776529,
0.2884536684,
0.3275157511,
0.5027678609,
-0.7262074351,
-0.243241623,
0.2864538729,
-0.3849489391,
0.4272420704,
0.1300693899,
-0.2903355658,
-0.5690168738,
-0.0950488523,
-0.0262675006,
0.6105959415,
-0.4868258238,
0.335403651,
0.3482080102,
-0.2910209596,
-0.5683376789,
-0.6535065174,
0.2871570289,
-0.175655663,
-0.4729782045,
0.397320956,
-0.079176724,
-0.1880793571,
-0.5044997931,
-0.3097400069,
0.0217666961,
0.2156345099,
0.5063169003,
0.461420536,
-0.247546345,
0.1028515399,
0.1518333852,
-0.4731560349,
0.1933191121,
-0.1488012373,
0.3607023954,
-0.0801306516,
-0.4936159551,
-0.6028134823,
0.0466299541,
0.3723663688,
-0.1382321566,
0.3087947667,
0.3025488257,
-0.215345636,
0.0680096522,
-0.833856225,
-0.0145138986,
-0.4524784982,
0.1357905418,
0.0301239341,
-0.6098495722,
0.2432142794,
-0.3624934256,
0.3924534023,
0.4763258696,
0.7732689381,
-0.3929075897,
0.6620550752,
0.3058008552,
0.0600789897,
0.1075016484,
0.0508023016,
-0.0500164889,
-0.6010993719,
-0.4632415473,
-0.1365382969,
-0.2743172944,
-0.4950644374,
-0.3833085299,
0.5419481993,
0.0104372324,
-0.2598267794,
0.1184495687,
-0.8603362441,
0.3775469661,
0.7363530397,
0.3773572743,
0.4074625075,
-0.2589853704,
-0.0166322794,
0.0049560382,
-0.5530623794,
-0.6747178435,
1.2839163542,
0.4266605079,
0.5824046731,
-0.2912151515,
1.1260008812,
-0.0955766067,
1.11452353,
-0.5844314098,
0.3310982883,
-0.1126249284,
-0.4773618877,
-0.0693237558,
-0.0386532359,
-0.8110197186,
0.0385964364,
-0.2254269868,
-0.1072888002,
-0.6592476368,
0.6200714111,
-0.5336433649,
0.3598055542,
-0.3989139199,
0.5661966205,
-0.4121288955,
-0.2614537776,
-0.0133331437,
-1.0305794477,
0.3609423041,
-0.3878080547,
0.0249883626,
-0.271024406,
-0.2529867589,
0.5529459715,
-0.7249512672,
0.7426970601,
-0.2804288268,
-0.1521653682,
0.2835623622,
-0.0185972489,
0.2861713469,
0.2334372997,
0.1198818311,
-0.0008580153,
-0.1007885858,
-0.2537176609,
-0.304066062,
0.5237901211,
-0.4007402658,
-0.6786254644,
-0.5180700421,
-0.3986079693,
-0.1673751771,
0.0318081602,
0.397601068,
0.2843709588,
-0.0969598964,
-0.2407847196,
0.5141695738,
-0.2844538093,
0.3407843411,
0.8734036684,
0.0415808968,
-0.8829603791,
0.5139674544,
-0.0218053162,
0.0756588429,
0.1635254323,
0.2105804831,
-0.1557933688,
-0.5378696918,
-0.6916612983,
0.535150826,
-0.3508666456,
-0.6668189764,
-0.8793764114,
-0.2993477583,
-0.0502876677,
-0.4113855958,
-0.4909081161,
-0.2493076622,
-0.5007287264,
-0.487128377,
0.7113755345,
0.8647853136,
-0.4739281833,
0.2973491549,
-1.0354501009,
0.3887769282,
0.0876310319,
0.304893136,
-0.4716424942,
-0.3875398934,
-0.1604193151,
-0.3538680673,
-0.4702676833,
-0.9004558325,
0.4026335776,
0.3646387458,
0.3720909655,
0.5196005106,
-0.3284300566,
0.5487881303,
-1.0533702374,
0.7936780453,
0.5304841995,
-0.4755289257,
0.8505403996,
-0.3792475164,
0.1132624149,
0.7182351947,
0.1451212317,
-0.4602148533,
-0.6043578386,
-0.812674582,
-0.7967299223,
0.3068278134,
-0.2886832058,
0.0168654751,
-0.5088121891,
0.712030828,
0.2844950259,
0.0491642207,
-0.5544922948,
-0.1938091815,
-0.0817239061,
-0.5989114046,
0.0448291823,
-0.4522126615,
-0.1594710201,
-0.2460630983,
0.5412867665,
0.0341904797,
0.3212500811,
0.4163222015,
0.0494589284,
-0.0220778026,
-0.1040112302,
0.7288113236,
0.5440122485,
-0.0055279527,
0.024276508,
0.2780537307,
-0.8557454348,
0.4953122437,
0.092498824,
0.0142334029,
0.1743643582,
0.4973845482,
0.746765554,
0.1946062744,
-0.7171528935,
0.4861034155,
0.2086895704,
-0.3403131068,
-0.3165173233,
0.126610592,
0.4131127894,
0.203480348,
-0.124695152,
0.0658670068,
-0.0156077016,
-0.189411819,
0.3717191815,
0.1254975945,
-0.3335774243,
-0.3296361268,
1.0079251528,
0.3197293878,
-0.4193568528,
0.6220705509,
0.3459833264,
-0.321952641,
0.3418045342,
0.8847874403,
0.5751257539,
-0.603282094,
0.1207336411,
0.3604032695,
0.1795072556,
-0.3457286358,
0.5074391365,
-0.0618520454,
-0.4132191539,
-0.5115958452,
-0.5727257133,
-0.5505834222,
-0.0610508621,
-0.5825281739,
0.0501265451,
-0.6978793144,
-0.3825596869,
0.0179487728,
0.0247507207,
-0.3301808536,
0.5195508599,
-0.1551027,
0.8422266245,
-0.6278663874,
0.9553360343,
0.7046473622,
-0.3588043749,
-0.9783140421,
-0.5161197186,
0.0723168477,
-1.1181094646,
0.546903789,
0.2059984952,
-0.013161256,
-0.0415029302,
-0.4140479863,
-0.5265862346,
1.3083820343,
0.3562010825,
-0.7478749156,
-0.0442368649,
-0.0574531928,
0.7997539639,
-0.1328573525,
0.3403396904,
0.7032002807,
0.2426176071,
-0.173241064,
-1.1358090639,
-0.0538979024,
-0.3950346112,
-0.2974815667,
0.2661755979,
-0.6782488823,
0.5060807467,
-0.6371307373,
0.0428671725,
0.2733491659,
0.3697631359,
0.7751662135,
0.4971170425,
0.1987253428,
0.8055740595,
1.2509889603,
-0.0736537203,
1.0183615685,
-0.3298151493,
-0.2129645199,
1.2848812342,
-0.374841392,
0.5777398944,
0.2843150496,
-0.2011306733,
0.529266715,
0.8835524321,
-0.1434571743,
0.423142612,
0.5864646435,
-0.5682734847,
-0.1487500817,
0.2154918164,
-0.4392312169,
0.2514494658,
0.374214828,
-0.8402103186,
0.1907173544,
0.0153134922,
0.4952397048,
0.1749773026,
-0.1879506111,
1.2241795063,
0.4291221499,
-0.6460238695,
0.6085377932,
-0.207476154,
0.541865468,
-0.659702301,
-0.0251275357,
-0.4618569613,
0.2516677082,
-0.2929412723,
-0.5700003505,
0.2491833717,
0.2522594035,
-0.1713938415,
-0.3867813647,
0.8211879134,
-0.3991717994,
-0.2687374353,
0.0303240344,
0.503424108,
0.5022655725,
0.1529468596,
-0.4350276887,
-0.3142227232,
0.0222892743,
-0.3391718268,
0.3188853264,
0.4897016287,
0.1648855656,
0.6876072288,
0.4976188838,
0.4109734595,
0.104686223,
0.1236892492,
0.8318737745,
-0.6163291931,
-0.2770607769,
-0.9192817211,
0.384334147,
0.0330887102,
-0.4381384254,
0.3286133707,
0.6420073509,
0.3325117528,
0.0701199993,
0.7361620069,
0.451105386,
1.0656626225,
-0.6557426453,
0.9141386151,
-0.3120862246,
0.1459696591,
-0.3266553283,
-0.6962823272,
-0.58943367,
0.7408227324,
0.1581598073,
-0.2289756984,
0.7746390104,
0.4049103558,
0.3005107343,
-0.0077894893,
-0.0131748952,
0.1329083145,
0.2817647755,
0.800976932,
0.6745246053,
-0.3029008508,
0.391792655,
-0.0801149458,
-0.3599597514,
0.1331516206,
-0.7271229625,
-0.7915477753,
-0.0397730321,
-0.2848846018,
-0.6140340567,
0.0588221103,
0.9799190164,
0.4376265109,
-0.5683010221,
0.1404115707,
-0.1003730223,
-0.4848750532,
-0.1005061343,
-0.0378048718,
0.6132441163,
-0.2814969718,
-0.2982150614,
0.7637540102,
0.6179694533,
0.1633854806,
0.1102191582,
-0.1017607972,
0.0590522811,
0.0045014312,
0.4105030596,
0.1596446931,
-0.6936522722,
-0.1075093597,
0.0631835163,
-0.5108909011,
0.6796499491,
0.7404091358,
-0.7527192831,
0.263936311,
-0.0101851914,
0.8391070366,
0.6018360257,
0.0384018086,
0.6149924994,
-0.4091798067,
-0.1745825708,
0.4433865845,
0.1994021237,
0.4755134881,
-0.4128270149,
0.9433580637,
0.3950199783,
-0.7558271289,
-0.7461877465,
-0.037679635,
-0.9808477163,
0.2094369084,
0.9419010878,
-0.3767986298,
0.0230799317,
0.0720207468,
-0.6409791112,
0.496581763,
-0.0731692463,
0.7498877048,
0.1922037601,
-0.4670778513,
-0.0172650181,
-0.5235859156,
0.7086967826,
0.4447126985,
-1.2820080519,
-0.267377615,
0.48359707,
0.5487571359,
-0.1172095388,
1.4603224993,
-0.3530365825,
0.3457989693,
-0.092280753,
0.1194271743,
-0.1590453833,
-0.2336298972,
0.0933094546,
-0.0621220507,
0.1308416128,
-0.1189625785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09054v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09054v2
|
Keyformer: KV Cache Reduction through Key Tokens Selection for Efficient Generative Inference
| 2024-03-14T02:42:42 | 2024-04-06T00:22:37 |
Muhammad Adnan, Akhil Arunkumar, Gaurav Jain, Prashant J. Nair, Ilya Soloveychik, Purushotham Kamath
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.AR, cs.CL, 68U35, I.2.7; C.0
|
Transformers have emerged as the underpinning architecture for Large Language
Models (LLMs). In generative language models, the inference process involves
two primary phases: prompt processing and token generation. Token generation,
which constitutes the majority of the computational workload, primarily entails
vector-matrix multiplications and interactions with the Key-Value (KV) Cache.
This phase is constrained by memory bandwidth due to the overhead of
transferring weights and KV cache values from the memory system to the
computing units. This memory bottleneck becomes particularly pronounced in
applications that require long-context and extensive text generation, both of
which are increasingly crucial for LLMs.
This paper introduces "Keyformer", an innovative inference-time approach, to
mitigate the challenges associated with KV cache size and memory bandwidth
utilization. Keyformer leverages the observation that approximately 90% of the
attention weight in generative inference focuses on a specific subset of
tokens, referred to as "key" tokens. Keyformer retains only the key tokens in
the KV cache by identifying these crucial tokens using a novel score function.
This approach effectively reduces both the KV cache size and memory bandwidth
usage without compromising model accuracy. We evaluate Keyformer's performance
across three foundational models: GPT-J, Cerebras-GPT, and MPT, which employ
various positional embedding algorithms. Our assessment encompasses a variety
of tasks, with a particular emphasis on summarization and conversation tasks
involving extended contexts. Keyformer's reduction of KV cache reduces
inference latency by 2.1x and improves token generation throughput by 2.4x,
while preserving the model's accuracy.
|
[
-0.2367799729,
-0.5658327341,
0.509560883,
0.3638058901,
-0.4032261372,
0.0659938529,
-0.2570358217,
0.0098587815,
-0.0587748885,
0.4281695783,
-0.3616497815,
-0.5225035548,
-0.5781412125,
-0.2726581991,
-0.3667830825,
0.5891141295,
-0.0361897089,
0.0488009453,
-0.5157571435,
0.0256371666,
-0.3996126354,
-0.444045037,
-0.814222157,
-0.143168658,
0.2109941393,
0.2116951346,
0.4764528275,
0.4498619735,
0.3599597514,
0.3021809161,
-0.4208632708,
-0.1470494121,
-0.4843650162,
0.6789254546,
0.1770288199,
-0.8950694203,
-0.3994909823,
-0.2583522201,
0.60892272,
0.417514801,
0.0728264526,
0.1530337632,
-0.2280129492,
0.6933788657,
-1.025072217,
0.5499693751,
-0.7729910016,
0.2043889016,
-0.3364523649,
0.2366063297,
-0.713401556,
-0.2184727192,
-0.1917959154,
-0.5904797912,
0.5526500344,
-0.0558185317,
0.5053027868,
0.4784885347,
-0.2445372492,
0.0274345074,
-0.7751386166,
0.5971729755,
-0.7497780919,
0.5290235877,
0.2288122177,
0.4176720381,
-0.1987537742,
-0.8935132623,
-0.8884417415,
-0.1300149858,
0.0327103026,
0.4065523148,
-0.2212375253,
0.4797753096,
0.2995742559,
0.4997301102,
-0.4707508981,
0.1697135419,
-0.3899871409,
-0.281383872,
0.1576369554,
0.1045465097,
0.0250355806,
-0.3381652832,
0.1749562472,
-0.3594804108,
-0.8204873204,
-0.0051493831,
0.2575965822,
0.0598099194,
0.0462185219,
0.4709944427,
-0.0886256471,
0.520822823,
0.2207012177,
-0.119832091,
0.0149357691,
-0.0148092518,
-0.4675801396,
0.0045529418,
0.6421713233,
0.301532954,
-0.0385021828,
-0.3286028504,
-0.1247103065,
0.4450902641,
0.3126383126,
-1.0400931835,
-0.3201362491,
0.1943098605,
-0.6689962149,
-0.4409944713,
0.0012540222,
-0.861829102,
-0.2010569423,
-0.0165177416,
0.2735142112,
-0.1988149881,
0.040916957,
-0.2163658738,
-0.214723587,
0.3515452445,
0.3593446612,
-0.8643536568,
0.4151744843,
0.7032202482,
0.9650324583,
-0.4781226218,
0.3619274795,
-0.6974024773,
0.2330035269,
-0.2617861629,
0.5962778926,
-0.7013648152,
-0.667627275,
-0.1905908138,
-0.0762424916,
-0.2048051506,
-0.5586064458,
0.5537332296,
-0.9695993066,
0.1465546638,
-0.1050887406,
-0.6386781931,
-0.0781622604,
-0.0323000886,
-1.2163542509,
1.2015547752,
0.1362780035,
-0.325214684,
0.5136216283,
-0.6906421185,
-0.5354306698,
0.0690191388,
-0.2023946047,
-0.6586778164,
0.4738253057,
0.4302132726,
0.3822188973,
-0.4518447816,
0.2682961822,
-0.1201530024,
-0.3982537091,
-0.052789811,
-0.7041199207,
0.2716910541,
0.2102758586,
-0.5243831873,
0.2410082221,
-0.8437449932,
-0.0908747539,
0.013501606,
-0.310405314,
-0.121703133,
0.1301674694,
0.3241348565,
0.2132257223,
-0.1203414649,
-0.5295146108,
0.2781534791,
-0.4450811148,
0.7352323532,
0.6152639985,
-0.0120666958,
0.6557423472,
-0.0548956916,
0.7463530898,
0.1537469178,
0.2735973299,
-0.2166568339,
-0.4963935912,
-1.0359339714,
-0.2744571865,
0.4886650443,
0.3477594256,
-0.4712206423,
0.3778316975,
-0.4810061455,
-0.4889081717,
-0.6541992426,
-0.0056749084,
0.3757536709,
0.2721594572,
0.325802505,
-0.2531953454,
-0.4128849506,
-0.7774791121,
-0.0367811732,
-0.3540471494,
-0.166388154,
0.1791108847,
0.3345645368,
0.0281488094,
0.9624251723,
-0.4805026352,
-0.0247531012,
-0.1884340346,
0.0658681542,
0.0555389822,
0.5113515258,
0.3550445437,
-0.9644312859,
-0.4089465439,
-0.3651643693,
-0.1126023829,
-0.1486283392,
-0.2191606313,
0.0849821493,
0.3339599371,
0.8319599628,
-0.9681583047,
0.5761436224,
0.6561965346,
-0.1069710255,
0.4220122993,
0.0539757796,
0.0027563549,
-1.0476322174,
0.2019158751,
-0.5999762416,
-0.2174163163,
-0.4575207233,
-0.1570791155,
0.1158691794,
-0.1262661666,
-0.2142826468,
0.6621376276,
-0.4154930115,
0.0155155333,
-0.0392585769,
0.0184135735,
0.2043382227,
0.4246241152,
-0.1189220995,
1.1107004881,
0.1559234411,
-0.4171915352,
-0.0419942737,
0.3194745183,
-0.3023487628,
0.1631432772,
-0.691819191,
0.2311837077,
-0.2526322603,
0.3771586716,
-1.4411406517,
-0.0210429765,
0.0666133538,
-0.3551374972,
0.4280921817,
-0.3173719645,
-0.5906359553,
-0.3963821828,
-0.1795168817,
0.5360645652,
0.6498478055,
-0.3948173225,
0.8870150447,
0.1781285405,
-0.1330719441,
-0.2975134552,
-0.5289950967,
0.0987515822,
-0.0071959496,
-0.5045678616,
0.7571821809,
0.0699260235,
-0.0233201552,
0.0006064051,
-0.4547101259,
0.1205644086,
0.0503958985,
0.5105528831,
0.2227944881,
-0.3223564029,
0.4755807817,
0.4157576561,
-0.2504461706,
0.024945626,
-0.3272495568,
0.6499965787,
0.063720189,
-0.5675766468,
-0.210544914,
0.2667720616,
1.1138617992,
-0.3360747993,
0.946898222,
0.5374464989,
-0.1520576328,
-0.1010556445,
-0.8879597187,
-0.1383127123,
-0.4408800006,
0.361446768,
-0.5127383471,
-1.0463688374,
0.6206140518,
-0.1297594458,
0.0407095626,
0.7042094469,
0.6635305882,
0.3754583597,
0.9988526702,
0.2781949043,
-0.3968299627,
0.6241550446,
-0.2600061595,
0.3809565902,
-0.8502258062,
-0.1192956045,
-0.3114407063,
-0.3148393631,
-0.416606158,
-0.8538567424,
0.3934931159,
0.2559594214,
-0.1926125437,
-0.0636881366,
-0.3932147324,
0.4367007911,
0.4501585364,
-0.0742838755,
0.2485895604,
-0.1212617755,
-0.3720654845,
0.0171936564,
-0.6699120402,
-0.4021469355,
1.2225520611,
0.1818276644,
0.6961935163,
0.0927712321,
0.3331478834,
0.1799049675,
0.4509394765,
-0.8323386312,
0.4071718752,
-0.1930457503,
-0.5286288857,
-0.2278286368,
-0.2100503296,
-0.5928903818,
0.369051367,
-0.0169189107,
-0.6685238481,
-0.1892078221,
0.2839051187,
-0.383500576,
0.3353210688,
-0.5921483636,
0.9211977124,
0.1017532125,
-0.2178065181,
-0.3102043271,
-0.7242081761,
0.3194905519,
-0.0101453206,
-0.2500348687,
0.1194479913,
0.0108902054,
0.7822926641,
-0.4829643071,
0.9653191566,
-0.3624691665,
0.0957013518,
0.1888510585,
0.0564631,
0.8212012053,
-0.028679708,
-0.0338771269,
-0.1277695298,
-0.1727399528,
-0.1104686484,
-0.8895560503,
0.4466080964,
-0.6259241104,
-0.5907699466,
0.1693145633,
-0.3091059923,
-0.2535764277,
0.0962033048,
0.3336388469,
0.330114007,
-0.232422784,
0.3275188208,
0.7631168365,
-0.1950053424,
0.3624976873,
0.1652655303,
-0.033498954,
-0.4189372957,
0.4746831357,
-0.1239791587,
0.5578007102,
0.7870681286,
0.1215034574,
-0.3694803715,
-0.5793677568,
-0.2396247387,
0.1008123904,
-0.7652225494,
-0.349986583,
-0.8718116879,
-0.3305814564,
-0.4356082082,
-0.1069681495,
-0.538244307,
-0.7547510266,
-0.2656815648,
-0.1678550988,
0.5338298082,
0.3557090163,
0.3166643083,
0.9487197399,
-0.684863925,
0.369446218,
0.3057638109,
0.3236927092,
0.2769916654,
-0.3411628604,
0.0891569853,
-0.4239400625,
-0.3796242177,
-0.686049521,
0.1822661459,
0.3206550479,
0.5500171185,
0.5862799287,
-0.1371225417,
0.7933060527,
-0.5139617324,
0.8493518829,
0.0005631301,
-1.1629152298,
0.4023898244,
0.0516268872,
0.4423181415,
0.5926896334,
-0.0639086515,
-0.7671331167,
-0.4504324794,
-0.4618968666,
-1.0856511593,
0.3657991588,
0.4585151672,
0.0070880298,
-0.171003595,
0.4165361226,
0.0092985053,
0.2854374051,
-0.4239169359,
-0.3826767206,
-0.1978679895,
-0.36778301,
-0.0374314897,
-0.369214803,
0.3163407743,
-0.3187622428,
0.4953029156,
-0.1653016061,
0.4453341961,
0.0356649831,
-0.4132206738,
-0.075448148,
0.3577902019,
0.6715260148,
0.319446981,
-0.0311540663,
0.1297248304,
0.2390058041,
-0.7722629309,
0.0897560343,
0.0634959564,
-0.2381894439,
0.1376563162,
0.2716569602,
1.0124536753,
0.5306005478,
-0.5029883385,
0.5894898772,
-0.2521240115,
-0.0268262066,
-0.2492030561,
0.0708274096,
0.2209888548,
0.1819239408,
0.1897498518,
0.0056485753,
0.0635316148,
0.1331256926,
0.0978653207,
0.4692830741,
-0.3590106964,
-0.3959676325,
1.0131669044,
0.1558477581,
-0.0748001784,
0.8018705845,
-0.1312079877,
-0.8048807383,
0.5930352211,
0.6466389894,
1.1850714684,
-0.2513603568,
-0.0036401504,
0.2172187269,
0.1135411561,
0.0302574225,
0.1588958502,
-0.5415429473,
-0.6315539479,
-0.73408705,
-0.8595290184,
-0.189181596,
0.4482814968,
-0.6365388632,
-0.0614346974,
-0.2565947473,
-0.2400086224,
-0.0217625406,
-0.2189483494,
-0.7661265731,
-0.0888293684,
0.1233987957,
1.0274670124,
-0.8120109439,
0.6919122338,
0.3541923463,
-0.1973921061,
-0.5451261997,
-0.0355626643,
0.0030900447,
-0.7865757942,
1.0058774948,
0.2599550784,
-0.0738295391,
0.1075361073,
-0.1767341495,
-0.8086640239,
1.1180912256,
0.2143386006,
-0.7341325283,
-0.3534055054,
0.0838885754,
0.3200502992,
-0.1005691364,
0.2554868758,
0.6978290677,
0.5891547203,
0.2679052055,
-0.7070290446,
0.1641993374,
-0.3535592854,
0.3332904875,
0.5325244069,
-0.5547295809,
0.6968188882,
0.0563543849,
-0.2495501339,
0.2881195843,
0.7522168756,
0.2931477726,
-0.1847539693,
0.5944576263,
0.7225451469,
0.6385510564,
-0.0587494448,
0.7294820547,
-0.5713966489,
0.2042138726,
0.8879780769,
-0.0880060196,
0.8134199381,
0.7592427731,
-0.3734124005,
0.3945717514,
0.2648908794,
-0.066309832,
0.5179997087,
0.3922102153,
-0.5704525113,
-0.2474115789,
0.3521747887,
-0.1510466635,
0.5978727341,
0.4238035977,
-0.5330593586,
-0.2066955119,
-0.0796051845,
0.0962120965,
-0.4093493521,
-0.1814466566,
0.7472445965,
0.0023241709,
-0.7873846292,
0.1297495812,
-0.0219436735,
0.4704212844,
-0.5079461336,
-0.108160153,
-0.0740261748,
0.3985105455,
0.1926015913,
-0.2041397095,
0.1033930704,
-0.1765514314,
-0.4619891644,
-0.2081746906,
0.7052503824,
-0.3152146339,
-0.5708591342,
0.0457931161,
0.3066674173,
-0.1361531466,
-0.4089483619,
-0.3457256556,
0.1795262843,
-0.3324450552,
-0.470929265,
0.0578940958,
0.2864682674,
-0.170429647,
0.5151376724,
0.7211831212,
0.1824774444,
0.1739674658,
0.4158956707,
0.9779850841,
-0.5710871816,
-0.5951393247,
-0.885399282,
0.3741070926,
-0.0735307857,
-0.2865211666,
0.550930202,
0.7165498734,
0.4962390661,
-0.2528505325,
0.8709577918,
0.0565274954,
0.0483534224,
-0.7597862482,
0.8351913095,
-0.181467995,
0.0558558293,
-0.2309220582,
-0.9075009823,
-0.4100165665,
0.5367189646,
-0.362003684,
0.0426201634,
0.5681553483,
0.8626642823,
-0.0154478094,
-0.0288702585,
0.3513577878,
0.1003862172,
0.7188817263,
0.4606147408,
0.6589916945,
-0.5979505181,
0.5459031463,
-0.0274237897,
-0.0525381565,
-0.3223740757,
-0.8997099996,
-0.9705330133,
-0.7000946999,
-0.0232285634,
-0.1410122961,
-0.0118431132,
0.6278963685,
0.7646926641,
-0.9612212181,
0.0782413036,
-0.4564574957,
0.0481023453,
-0.0916615501,
-0.3428377807,
0.5954872966,
-0.5242105126,
-0.4846101701,
0.2382184863,
0.459392041,
0.036372602,
-0.3703330159,
0.0776939988,
0.3671653569,
-0.0711393729,
0.8305715919,
0.0162678696,
-1.0024636984,
-0.1103855893,
0.1821593344,
0.0289565101,
0.1825879365,
1.1491862535,
-1.0063924789,
0.5742163658,
0.4773248434,
0.7750685215,
1.0016976595,
-0.1292606294,
0.7054948211,
-0.6836295724,
0.1679758281,
0.3196152747,
0.3107833266,
0.1543906331,
-0.3056563139,
0.1066013426,
0.2402681857,
-0.4210559726,
-0.6235408187,
0.1106584743,
-1.0359760523,
-0.1648732573,
0.9903551936,
0.2170944065,
-0.3921673596,
-0.040290162,
-0.1164363921,
0.4290753007,
-0.4531199634,
0.7814555168,
0.6997355819,
0.1286431998,
-0.2449043691,
-0.5245873332,
0.7127505541,
0.3585807681,
-0.6410374045,
0.1799635589,
0.3085249662,
0.1482998133,
0.1540696025,
0.5607199073,
-0.2088719904,
0.2833379507,
0.1382548362,
0.1159216464,
0.022947168,
-0.166745916,
-0.2000491023,
0.2586806118,
0.0185517501,
-0.2047964036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09040v1
|
RAGGED: Towards Informed Design of Retrieval Augmented Generation Systems
| 2024-03-14T02:26:31 | 2024-03-14T02:26:31 |
Jennifer Hsia, Afreen Shaikh, Zhiruo Wang, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) greatly benefits language models (LMs)
by providing additional context for tasks such as document-based question
answering (DBQA). Despite its potential, the power of RAG is highly dependent
on its configuration, raising the question: What is the optimal RAG
configuration? To answer this, we introduce the RAGGED framework to analyze and
optimize RAG systems. On a set of representative DBQA tasks, we study two
classic sparse and dense retrievers, and four top-performing LMs in
encoder-decoder and decoder-only architectures. Through RAGGED, we uncover that
different models suit substantially varied RAG setups. While encoder-decoder
models monotonically improve with more documents, we find decoder-only models
can only effectively use < 5 documents, despite often having a longer context
window. RAGGED offers further insights into LMs' context utilization habits,
where we find that encoder-decoder models rely more on contexts and are thus
more sensitive to retrieval quality, while decoder-only models tend to rely on
knowledge memorized during training.
|
[
-0.7447075844,
-0.5599207878,
0.5622620583,
-0.011651095,
-0.2419588119,
0.1878214478,
-0.1126777381,
-0.4124179482,
0.1882499307,
0.6219787598,
-0.5569213629,
0.0348637439,
-0.4223751426,
0.1216417849,
-0.4738542438,
1.1030677557,
0.1126742512,
-0.2721878886,
-0.3958026171,
-0.1367039233,
-0.5647648573,
-0.3376285136,
-0.5489379764,
-0.2936762571,
0.3217624128,
0.3135415316,
0.8758153915,
0.773855865,
0.1968237013,
0.2354989946,
-0.233890295,
0.5137374997,
-0.7794021964,
0.5041560531,
-0.1744494587,
-0.2686015964,
-0.203600958,
-0.2656689882,
0.5388915539,
0.7438568473,
-0.2383676469,
0.4960020185,
0.2514687777,
0.6604435444,
-1.0544866323,
-0.6168510318,
-0.6964060068,
-0.0817468762,
-0.1171389744,
-0.3236047328,
-0.4420949221,
-0.1852825284,
-0.0496513918,
-0.7803735137,
0.4277115762,
0.2784284949,
1.0145226717,
0.5426707864,
-0.4035113156,
-0.3984202147,
-0.800870955,
0.7860793471,
-0.2853173912,
0.8511258364,
0.5613691807,
0.1506722718,
-0.1734247208,
-0.7233477831,
-0.3950346112,
0.1326841116,
-0.2384648025,
0.2232022136,
0.0470174477,
0.1066211537,
0.2350997329,
0.4842735231,
-0.6406565309,
-0.2020992935,
-0.3439403772,
0.0477672033,
0.4915799797,
0.1434874386,
0.0450153947,
-0.4220437407,
-0.5526804328,
0.0606226064,
-0.5479156375,
-0.0185802113,
0.3874905109,
0.086164169,
0.2839160264,
0.4903945923,
-0.0783794969,
1.0354737043,
0.4074932039,
0.0262487344,
-0.1408474296,
0.013042029,
-0.3405854404,
-0.251547575,
0.3371926546,
0.0750815943,
-0.0508396812,
-0.5153413415,
-0.8902624846,
-0.1728766412,
0.8741393089,
-0.4428381622,
-0.0291500781,
0.2915332317,
-0.3220132291,
-0.1110580415,
-0.1969778687,
-0.685578227,
-0.469895184,
-0.5392375588,
0.4685057998,
-0.5734996796,
-0.1243388131,
0.1677449644,
-0.4818181694,
0.2109785676,
-0.0868182704,
-0.795212388,
0.5673303008,
0.742651999,
0.5203369856,
0.1379498094,
0.1496059299,
-0.5571021438,
0.1198601872,
-0.5997851491,
0.8879291415,
-0.4210483134,
-0.5893746614,
0.2286682725,
-0.2560887039,
-0.1450215578,
-0.5851172805,
1.1474735737,
-1.0368164778,
0.1821894199,
-0.4592394531,
-0.6790132523,
0.1492670923,
0.2101989239,
-0.8851462603,
1.3530646563,
0.4163800478,
-0.7275232077,
0.4456087351,
-0.3904467821,
-0.2629775703,
0.1605281532,
0.0867051184,
-0.1690012962,
0.4944837987,
0.1116632894,
0.2710302174,
-0.245914191,
0.1799113452,
-0.0615291893,
-0.628641367,
0.1034530476,
-0.1872085333,
0.5006092787,
0.7992168665,
-0.0498509966,
-0.3133961558,
-0.8690675497,
0.2495393455,
0.0998813286,
-0.7010311484,
-0.6466585398,
0.092928417,
0.0776615515,
-0.0517045185,
0.3075112104,
-0.5991749167,
0.0699405074,
-0.5486543179,
-0.050541725,
0.7261650562,
0.1305671632,
0.7536208034,
-0.6478459239,
0.5802568793,
-0.4585831463,
0.280392766,
0.0886555836,
0.1553060114,
-1.0099942684,
-0.1894153804,
0.4153138697,
0.3143571317,
-0.9232270718,
0.0482831523,
-0.2100291103,
-0.1150194034,
-0.5385719538,
-0.1702505797,
0.5213691592,
0.4048663378,
0.2606090903,
-0.0865950584,
-0.7063404322,
-0.8271386027,
-0.4986773431,
0.169249624,
0.0503144898,
0.5501363873,
0.1546696872,
-0.153217271,
0.9958577156,
-0.4698293209,
0.128868863,
-0.0647062734,
-0.4345783591,
0.2891508639,
0.219135657,
0.4169908464,
-0.9967597127,
-0.2394797057,
-0.1197221652,
-0.3772978783,
-0.2233983576,
-0.1191300824,
-0.5540530682,
0.3754281998,
0.2747530639,
-0.6216712594,
0.2755788863,
0.4438616931,
-0.3028399646,
0.6415201426,
-0.3248398304,
-0.004589309,
-0.8908682466,
0.3055873811,
-0.2797123194,
-0.2015196085,
-0.7029951215,
0.2747763395,
0.2984626889,
0.0766851231,
0.1317040175,
0.7306938171,
-0.7548391819,
-0.1955261528,
-0.2188800722,
0.1720609963,
0.4571400881,
0.4261259437,
-0.2430150509,
0.8335477114,
-0.1886507422,
-0.6346371174,
-0.158100009,
0.1274045557,
-0.2495039254,
0.4428845644,
-0.6627964973,
0.4490805864,
-0.4049815834,
-0.0570049249,
-0.8883999586,
-0.4189251661,
-0.2060580403,
-0.4020532668,
0.7486345768,
-0.274849087,
-0.353181988,
-0.2416739464,
-0.1901957691,
0.397824347,
0.5531506538,
-0.6763242483,
0.6954099536,
0.6647763848,
0.122837238,
-1.0218443871,
-0.1399465948,
-0.1549183577,
-0.1250260919,
-0.6156672239,
0.4915976822,
0.0952240154,
-0.2645964921,
0.1347037703,
-0.2793042064,
-0.1877117902,
0.0248058401,
0.3091250956,
0.2173706144,
-0.1033601388,
0.4243348539,
0.30979231,
0.2280001491,
-0.2026432008,
-0.3553634882,
0.607080102,
0.0597649291,
-0.1237384304,
0.5546734929,
0.711900115,
0.2857133448,
-0.4658816159,
0.7227902412,
0.4073374271,
-0.3671084642,
-0.5854024291,
-0.7945789695,
0.2136785388,
-0.5170821548,
0.0776873156,
-0.642634213,
-0.7858054638,
0.5129600167,
-0.0325851627,
0.3574757576,
0.4066901207,
0.2761494517,
-0.0355070494,
0.9091838002,
0.8193463683,
0.2202725261,
0.4751453102,
-0.360858202,
0.0144027071,
-1.2068308592,
-0.2331086546,
-0.528765738,
-0.0784586221,
-0.4042523801,
-0.3171714842,
0.5528728366,
0.3952210546,
-0.5961233974,
0.0259099752,
-0.8105753064,
0.594468236,
0.5478859544,
0.1850727946,
-0.0656798556,
0.0140994424,
-0.2798299789,
0.3846812248,
-1.1189678907,
-0.6329667568,
0.8010085225,
0.1428093612,
0.6929423213,
0.1032019481,
0.9080732465,
0.1024352387,
-0.0229662117,
-0.7475717068,
0.2254200876,
-0.2900198102,
-0.7587016225,
-0.0916019976,
-0.1872397512,
-1.1795157194,
0.1117525846,
-0.1588179469,
-0.297162354,
0.4529203773,
0.1095948741,
-0.4883471131,
0.0032299375,
-0.6537769437,
0.4588578641,
-0.0290671159,
-0.5085775256,
0.3172169626,
-0.616151154,
0.3537048995,
0.073978357,
0.3439798355,
0.3111709952,
-0.205997318,
0.5444526672,
-0.2297873497,
0.3913232386,
-0.2244035751,
0.0657980517,
0.402233392,
0.370415926,
0.5116437078,
-0.1583553255,
-0.2555820346,
-0.3726317883,
0.2975236475,
-0.4556649625,
-0.5381942987,
0.647893846,
-0.9248597622,
-0.5298464298,
-0.1490718722,
-0.5239152908,
-0.4211128354,
0.2236289531,
0.496876508,
0.7763453722,
-0.211969927,
0.0097205164,
1.1098694801,
-0.1336365491,
0.1656961441,
0.0478099696,
-0.1436441243,
-0.2372732311,
0.6784812212,
0.2430044562,
0.2816409767,
0.2879579365,
-0.0502000563,
-0.4031957388,
-0.3024237156,
-0.7062265277,
0.1537721455,
-0.9053620696,
-0.437074095,
-0.7494919896,
-0.2977252305,
-0.4007261395,
-0.2131382972,
-0.3689762652,
-0.5255146027,
-0.4291861355,
0.074989289,
0.1993527561,
0.9396330118,
-0.0364695564,
0.1049918085,
-0.7544485927,
0.351329565,
0.061266087,
0.6079725027,
-0.0018640847,
-0.6420823336,
-0.4146495461,
0.0496190265,
-0.2518471777,
-0.9050044417,
0.3569939435,
0.2618280351,
0.6276957393,
0.0754282549,
0.3550592959,
0.6876052022,
-0.7426586151,
0.7356280088,
-0.3765639365,
-0.6417798996,
0.1665157974,
-0.4207149744,
0.2346803397,
0.3496721983,
0.288544327,
-0.5123119354,
-0.1108941957,
-0.6417870522,
-1.0297847986,
0.5294569135,
-0.0630921125,
0.1607861668,
-0.1237105206,
0.7330089808,
0.2431154996,
-0.128174454,
-0.2223988324,
-0.0765609145,
-0.2546945512,
-0.2223324776,
0.2663211823,
-0.6281460524,
-0.2207224518,
0.2712465823,
0.7128818631,
-0.040892452,
0.3899834752,
0.3839722276,
-0.0689615682,
-0.2787980139,
0.2713153362,
0.4278898537,
0.5733124018,
-0.0665199161,
0.1428556293,
0.2324886918,
-0.4183650315,
0.0914955437,
0.0736405551,
-0.1336253881,
0.2114011347,
0.2269529551,
0.8514965773,
0.0527673699,
-0.4811483026,
0.0938946381,
-0.1221976429,
-0.0005467461,
-0.4089365005,
0.2541362643,
-0.1365180463,
0.3124581277,
0.4775389433,
0.012789702,
0.4306565821,
-0.1006283313,
0.1615774781,
0.6205276251,
-0.1268619597,
-0.0583393164,
0.480604738,
-0.0717867538,
-0.4161560535,
0.3870452642,
-0.1032591984,
-0.5883594751,
0.3353300393,
0.5575664639,
0.7593804598,
-0.1055397317,
-0.0479840823,
0.3895809352,
0.1659118384,
0.0707407743,
0.2252233028,
-0.3344205022,
-0.623991251,
-0.3873373568,
-1.2035022974,
-0.1206221506,
-0.0839911327,
-0.8675431013,
0.0403911024,
-0.1030544341,
-0.2472222596,
-0.1649592221,
0.252033025,
-0.8419178128,
0.3805263937,
-0.139029488,
0.9821004272,
-0.2685466409,
0.4533934891,
0.6767576933,
0.0312470198,
-1.182363987,
-0.1278486252,
-0.2850438952,
-0.7521039248,
0.4343015552,
-0.3021070957,
-0.2590796351,
0.0227504503,
-0.476232022,
-1.194732666,
0.8848285675,
0.218693316,
-0.3241760433,
-0.224363625,
-0.2265026867,
0.4910575449,
-0.021180883,
0.1330804974,
0.5709066391,
0.1655691564,
0.1711842567,
-0.9139888287,
-0.0820758864,
-0.3428109586,
0.2107517868,
0.7049979568,
-0.5084033012,
0.8135761619,
0.0731962994,
-0.6436560154,
0.3347303271,
0.2702442408,
0.1787101626,
0.2062350214,
0.3925431073,
0.6469444036,
0.6550139189,
0.018537106,
1.5769076347,
-0.3615508378,
0.2747643888,
0.9082307816,
-0.017849125,
0.7722783685,
0.5081034303,
0.0659341887,
0.3097242415,
0.7655873895,
0.6151684523,
0.5683236718,
0.1056671813,
-0.375883013,
-0.1400095969,
-0.1612676829,
-0.2597057223,
0.3312858343,
0.4725151956,
-0.3656247258,
-0.0536593497,
-0.1395346075,
-0.109927617,
0.1352101266,
-0.1629348844,
1.0582901239,
-0.0716051832,
-1.1121772528,
1.0763071775,
0.0470201299,
0.3166478276,
-0.3773784935,
0.1151859984,
-0.5008746982,
0.22026214,
-0.2705476582,
-0.6657746434,
0.39911443,
0.0481990352,
-0.5732106566,
-0.1388170719,
1.1808950901,
-0.3815888464,
-0.2684687674,
-0.0921498016,
0.6924983859,
-0.0418134034,
0.1266236454,
-0.3400191367,
0.347357899,
-0.2211284488,
-0.52798599,
0.3416405618,
0.7749265432,
0.0053118612,
0.320820421,
0.6385605931,
-0.0088811684,
0.3491241336,
-0.0206997804,
1.1276535988,
-0.4093898535,
-0.3608050644,
-0.3881698549,
0.6213504076,
-0.1391505003,
-0.1475108713,
0.6666647792,
0.5612744093,
0.7229815125,
0.0595835336,
0.5739036798,
-0.1097796783,
0.7674046159,
-0.5592483878,
0.6989735365,
-0.7826607227,
0.2704946101,
-0.0999592617,
-0.8793197274,
0.0109639065,
0.4607563913,
-0.0811811015,
0.1392286718,
0.2041931152,
0.7190181017,
-0.0759884939,
0.0737814605,
0.3440908492,
-0.2557955384,
0.1868781149,
0.4476518631,
1.073040843,
-0.3973139226,
0.3402286172,
-0.2591174543,
-0.2085208595,
-0.0238411091,
-0.5716720223,
-0.5157465339,
-0.7711901665,
0.3927473128,
-0.3578647375,
0.2040386945,
0.7997525334,
0.6406453848,
-0.2160620987,
-0.1241686717,
0.0851501301,
-0.0259131957,
0.1823723018,
-0.2289850414,
0.3522868752,
-0.7551448941,
-0.5572777987,
0.1710499078,
0.1023018137,
-0.2569274902,
0.019657081,
-0.1071729511,
-0.3150884807,
0.4313439429,
0.7278200984,
0.1901925206,
-0.6372426152,
-0.4277650714,
0.4805268049,
-0.247732386,
-0.1714657843,
0.7777932286,
-1.1107569933,
0.5811655521,
0.4472617507,
0.9260475636,
0.4387568235,
0.2675078809,
0.3876156807,
-1.1928626299,
-0.0476772375,
0.6081585884,
0.2580063939,
0.2401960045,
-0.599747777,
0.5563173294,
-0.2128672898,
-1.0328207016,
-1.0447875261,
0.1101362631,
-0.590580225,
-0.4960652888,
1.2495121956,
0.0382554978,
-0.3741475642,
-0.1970323026,
-0.3997842669,
0.321424216,
-0.0761111155,
0.5676347017,
0.5678902864,
-0.1876189411,
-0.0387228727,
-0.655754447,
0.7567045689,
0.5202898979,
-0.305808723,
-0.0071694879,
0.7655294538,
0.0998968929,
0.2902927995,
0.5892148614,
0.1330537051,
0.2939382195,
0.0922258645,
-0.1707466245,
-0.0930183679,
-0.338334173,
-0.1687420905,
0.2923145592,
0.1211459339,
-0.0333433077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09037v1
|
The First to Know: How Token Distributions Reveal Hidden Knowledge in Large Vision-Language Models?
| 2024-03-14T02:25:35 | 2024-03-14T02:25:35 |
Qinyu Zhao, Ming Xu, Kartik Gupta, Akshay Asthana, Liang Zheng, Stephen Gould
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Large vision-language models (LVLMs), designed to interpret and respond to
human instructions, occasionally generate hallucinated or harmful content due
to inappropriate instructions. This study uses linear probing to shed light on
the hidden knowledge at the output layer of LVLMs. We demonstrate that the
logit distributions of the first tokens contain sufficient information to
determine whether to respond to the instructions, including recognizing
unanswerable visual questions, defending against multi-modal jailbreaking
attack, and identifying deceptive questions. Such hidden knowledge is gradually
lost in logits of subsequent tokens during response generation. Then, we
illustrate a simple decoding strategy at the generation of the first token,
effectively improving the generated content. In experiments, we find a few
interesting insights: First, the CLIP model already contains a strong signal
for solving these tasks, indicating potential bias in the existing datasets.
Second, we observe performance improvement by utilizing the first logit
distributions on three additional tasks, including indicting uncertainty in
math solving, mitigating hallucination, and image classification. Last, with
the same training data, simply finetuning LVLMs improve models' performance but
is still inferior to linear probing on these tasks.
|
[
-0.3984747529,
-0.6772540212,
0.4729607999,
-0.1422369927,
-0.4905046523,
-0.1171734035,
-0.0090778917,
-0.4196753204,
0.1673820913,
0.5989647508,
-0.666471839,
-0.4479494691,
-0.6038894057,
-0.388907373,
-0.6041317582,
0.8431323171,
0.376427561,
0.1419532746,
-0.1363333613,
-0.0613171048,
-0.3848429322,
-0.7167413831,
-0.6583165526,
-0.09504693,
0.6968657374,
-0.0497901179,
0.4597711265,
0.6120363474,
0.5765596032,
0.1863120645,
-0.2622825503,
0.1426175982,
-0.7582215667,
-0.1955170929,
-0.1348742694,
-0.7594472766,
-0.12267261,
-0.3568219543,
0.4847684503,
0.5545297265,
0.1273437142,
0.3949420154,
0.0291898511,
0.7020320296,
-0.6282843351,
0.1187984869,
-0.7050294876,
0.2371825576,
-0.1625297815,
-0.4003240168,
-0.8152714968,
-0.0166332871,
0.1570630819,
-0.4322499037,
0.3586539924,
0.0919889957,
0.6803743839,
0.4208315611,
-0.4210444987,
-0.2227619737,
-0.5754948854,
0.7122020125,
-0.5506415963,
0.4295269847,
0.2922280431,
0.1733693331,
0.0112217087,
-0.7177932858,
-0.383207947,
-0.121505484,
-0.230703339,
-0.2762670815,
-0.3116072118,
0.1729202718,
0.290341109,
0.0568929166,
-0.2655987144,
0.1281891465,
-0.7091617584,
-0.6477973461,
0.420691222,
0.2611612678,
0.0099437209,
-0.2156845033,
-0.57116431,
-0.4646209776,
-0.722358644,
0.3357040286,
0.2527316511,
0.0639069378,
0.1547004431,
0.6734495163,
0.1884685457,
0.5883088708,
-0.0912253708,
-0.0572615713,
0.0228210948,
-0.4840263426,
-0.2517463565,
-0.037426509,
0.4834275544,
0.335650444,
0.1430606246,
0.0128883943,
-0.4803622067,
0.0688360557,
0.258161366,
-0.7273483872,
-0.3723324835,
0.0196611285,
-0.6152359247,
-0.5557277799,
0.0965887606,
-0.5318769217,
-0.53727144,
-0.1152420342,
0.6731259823,
-0.3591766953,
-0.3006993532,
0.2495433092,
-0.2004994601,
0.3934456706,
0.3453117609,
-0.9662426114,
0.4855131507,
0.8074705005,
0.6408911347,
-0.1810897589,
-0.0555189811,
-0.912344873,
-0.2045052797,
-0.5337449908,
0.3962056935,
-0.1139379442,
0.0404077359,
0.0127531234,
-0.0803622231,
0.0904011428,
-0.5920964479,
0.2775911689,
-0.5865835547,
-0.164756909,
-0.4281076193,
-0.4610649049,
-0.1033298895,
0.074544996,
-0.8000196815,
0.9380376935,
-0.0763556957,
-1.022166729,
0.4442901015,
-0.5787622929,
-0.1578529328,
0.083490476,
-0.3527211249,
-0.2205538303,
0.4949876964,
0.2618724704,
0.537047565,
0.2672062814,
-0.0187467691,
-0.0318589546,
-0.3881669939,
0.4865229428,
-0.5915362835,
0.6625011563,
0.1447023451,
-0.396964252,
0.1148367152,
-0.7215298414,
0.0769029632,
0.2857165039,
-0.1931655109,
-0.4343643486,
-0.0154297557,
-0.1227731034,
-0.11715056,
0.0333419219,
-0.4639466107,
0.0487047173,
-0.2726319432,
0.3385046721,
1.1682109833,
0.0106607256,
0.3108650148,
0.0109015843,
0.3738180697,
0.3930684328,
0.4456547797,
-0.4418898523,
-0.5058048964,
-0.8851966262,
-0.0063182157,
0.1236568913,
0.4619118571,
-0.8627150655,
-0.1232400462,
-0.0996712372,
-0.192058593,
-0.5406196713,
0.1281536818,
0.5747555494,
0.4566596746,
0.1257792711,
-0.2628802061,
-0.3406140506,
-1.0144189596,
-0.1730407178,
-0.2440829724,
0.0121388389,
0.3126268089,
0.6053065658,
-0.0861044452,
0.7066172361,
-0.6418244243,
-0.0931208432,
-0.1399944276,
0.1199595854,
0.0269175302,
0.170225352,
0.5579106808,
-0.8188159466,
0.012871691,
0.077259019,
-0.6274181008,
0.2736412585,
-0.1013473719,
-0.247089535,
0.1543372124,
0.4707424343,
-0.5445602536,
0.7082544565,
0.3818768263,
-0.4985541999,
0.5309408903,
-0.1544487923,
-0.3183656335,
-0.7111830115,
0.0556832179,
-0.3425447643,
-0.4585561752,
-0.7648181319,
0.2227609009,
0.163657859,
0.0489915535,
-0.5965130329,
0.5410919785,
-0.4123626053,
-0.1701521426,
-0.0188299697,
0.0894919336,
0.0170781277,
0.5862247348,
-0.1087422073,
0.8052271605,
0.5817185044,
-0.6659244299,
0.228592664,
0.1175214946,
-0.6357200146,
-0.1339240819,
-0.6532139778,
0.3169807494,
-0.4832018316,
-0.2676514983,
-1.1750782728,
-0.1279443651,
0.213282764,
-0.6449355483,
0.2468641251,
-0.1109809875,
-0.4613413215,
-0.4371107221,
-0.2920214236,
0.5386244655,
0.6324691772,
-0.5136874318,
0.3595112562,
0.2757114172,
0.158467263,
-0.8664505482,
-0.7924656272,
-0.1519960016,
-0.0921348482,
-0.5061121583,
-0.2315101177,
-0.0890831575,
-0.3507306278,
-0.0781594291,
-0.1908991933,
0.022174675,
0.1457440108,
0.2391153574,
0.2750938237,
-0.4167845249,
0.3161728084,
-0.1874019653,
0.1225397065,
0.4209519029,
-0.5312553048,
0.7695706487,
-0.1453350037,
-0.602071166,
-0.3638160825,
0.2550361454,
0.5667361021,
-0.3579024673,
0.8131379485,
0.6890313625,
-0.2191126794,
-0.1846749634,
-0.5572525859,
-0.6040948033,
-0.492231071,
0.4644315243,
-0.4175656736,
-0.6574374437,
0.5932861567,
0.103848286,
-0.0646769181,
0.191548422,
0.4303010106,
0.069286786,
1.0521922112,
0.9091348052,
0.0195859652,
0.5095891953,
-0.3791000247,
0.2945660949,
-0.427246362,
-0.4594894946,
-0.0587300099,
-0.2732060552,
-0.2326681018,
-0.5956637263,
0.5185471177,
0.0792716071,
0.0929369181,
-0.0557901524,
-0.5278834105,
0.6344884038,
0.7408121824,
0.5105267763,
0.1791465431,
0.2290596664,
-0.2588166595,
0.0603158101,
-0.742847681,
-0.1979323924,
1.1013928652,
0.6934366226,
0.9385534525,
-0.0347849503,
0.741717577,
0.167106837,
0.0368005112,
-0.7684376836,
0.5415331721,
0.0087117935,
-0.5182982087,
-0.4063260257,
-0.2643806338,
-0.739477694,
0.1793552935,
-0.1131755933,
-0.7069494128,
0.1789142787,
0.3546129167,
-0.3327525854,
0.4292636812,
-0.8058943152,
0.6787205338,
-0.2528338432,
-0.3307021558,
0.0008392382,
-0.6750202179,
0.547606647,
-0.0554352216,
0.2261426598,
0.3291276991,
0.0504373275,
0.8130730391,
-0.2314642966,
1.0220574141,
-0.3435178101,
-0.2403064519,
0.2677654624,
0.3009405434,
0.6319112778,
0.0712971836,
0.3201371729,
-0.1596391946,
0.0780903995,
-0.427569747,
-0.7799970508,
0.2445044667,
-0.5609198213,
-0.7210526466,
0.0326061174,
-0.4628469944,
0.261951685,
0.2546176016,
0.4089781642,
0.5952020884,
0.0465521142,
0.2917316854,
1.278608799,
-0.248014167,
0.2484187186,
0.0638897866,
-0.4954820573,
-0.0890767723,
0.7158643603,
-0.1972097456,
0.600867033,
0.4487105608,
0.193908602,
-0.2686121166,
-0.5643676519,
-0.4876594245,
0.2325936258,
-1.2093758583,
-0.0625525638,
-0.4035629332,
-0.2471044362,
-0.2582939863,
0.1488880813,
-0.4449041486,
-0.3242684007,
-0.1601856202,
-0.3868302405,
0.3183032274,
0.9774016738,
0.0204978883,
0.0442008227,
-0.5920990109,
0.2146796584,
0.4122828543,
0.1647387296,
0.1988353729,
-0.3961625993,
-0.3066200614,
0.1865117252,
0.1123890653,
-0.9391578436,
0.2621743381,
-0.0034835616,
0.5917451382,
0.716268301,
0.010801658,
0.5293658376,
-0.4237232506,
0.8495566845,
0.2700451612,
-0.8310137987,
0.5500494242,
-0.1454730183,
0.1904519796,
0.1993834525,
0.0455546156,
-0.270275116,
-0.3434656858,
-0.2176390141,
-0.6579387188,
0.602093935,
0.192603305,
0.4982480109,
0.0121952482,
0.3339422643,
0.2004180551,
0.230679065,
-0.9045591354,
-0.3871887922,
-0.245801717,
-0.0132978251,
-0.0033591888,
-0.4232169688,
-0.4499674439,
-0.4243956208,
-0.0075932816,
-0.1894066781,
0.5760769844,
0.2628492415,
-0.2365044802,
0.048629377,
-0.0066916016,
0.976983428,
0.8123458624,
-0.1275440753,
0.524792254,
0.0045221616,
-0.6908288002,
-0.0255462155,
-0.427454263,
-0.2001381069,
0.1617683917,
0.5291199684,
1.283018589,
0.0130262896,
-0.7956643105,
0.8455958366,
-0.2007449716,
-0.3229880333,
-0.3104740977,
0.1357105672,
-0.1494493634,
0.3010500371,
0.7038084865,
0.0994054154,
-0.0303396769,
-0.5371794701,
0.3651661873,
0.6106292009,
-0.2050922811,
-0.3395459354,
0.7636700273,
-0.219349876,
-0.3308880031,
0.4464815557,
-0.0801537186,
-0.708970964,
0.5637717843,
0.4730083942,
0.4347941577,
0.0552745499,
0.3753014505,
0.2047905773,
0.5144728422,
0.1129624546,
0.2292537987,
-0.2709648907,
-0.5904341936,
-0.3298167884,
-0.5669825673,
0.0595541522,
0.1752760559,
-0.9789108634,
0.2117340267,
-0.510104239,
0.0041786311,
-0.0635603145,
-0.4002882242,
-1.0109739304,
-0.0322173722,
0.3386845887,
0.992706418,
-0.7030028105,
0.7317041159,
0.2035650462,
-0.2708744705,
-0.8821546435,
-0.0845929012,
-0.3075762689,
-1.1452219486,
1.123339653,
0.1329368651,
-0.2452889532,
-0.053509105,
-0.8208509088,
-0.7738413811,
0.969238162,
0.37305215,
-0.4055319726,
-0.2390067726,
0.301356405,
0.4076328576,
-0.1700001061,
0.0774368793,
0.3862359822,
0.2121107131,
0.1565134525,
-0.8742675781,
0.0293957796,
-0.2468425333,
-0.1374551356,
0.3738823533,
-0.2911721468,
1.1165915728,
-0.5836695433,
-0.3260821104,
-0.0921081454,
0.4858734012,
0.0318629257,
0.422714293,
0.5368176699,
0.2426835746,
0.8543354869,
0.0643087327,
1.111577034,
-0.1643189639,
0.2163554728,
0.6987684369,
0.2231197357,
1.0000470877,
0.8571581244,
0.063308537,
0.3415181041,
0.4507668614,
-0.0049011535,
0.7695913911,
0.3962465823,
-0.2303951532,
-0.1782365739,
0.0401982181,
-0.2709895968,
0.3600753844,
0.3401488662,
-0.4826958477,
-0.0179605894,
0.4029458761,
-0.1601082236,
-0.2521662116,
-0.468678087,
0.8949776292,
-0.0399465375,
-0.60160923,
0.9701497555,
-0.3003915846,
0.4277418852,
-0.5180082917,
-0.0377343185,
-0.4039850533,
0.2790202498,
-0.0162856467,
-0.8213649392,
0.0047670044,
-0.2081850916,
-0.1467930079,
-0.0271823145,
0.7578461766,
-0.2573490441,
-0.4711412787,
0.3322148621,
0.3474463522,
0.325284183,
-0.1326702684,
-0.2025228739,
0.2218607217,
0.1854982376,
-0.2407460213,
0.2831079066,
0.4086441696,
-0.0803697556,
0.8351740837,
0.5983579159,
0.0710377693,
0.8670384288,
-0.0288352165,
1.14780581,
-0.5026029944,
-0.399184972,
-0.9322407246,
0.7062461376,
-0.0709798858,
-0.0447878838,
0.5755785108,
0.4900308847,
0.9371216297,
-0.3716073036,
0.5377320647,
0.3069794178,
0.1801153123,
-0.8338583708,
0.5332556367,
-0.5585799217,
0.2650277019,
-0.0443815067,
-0.6115599871,
-0.2732330263,
0.4567757845,
0.0501212031,
-0.4276946783,
0.7328911424,
0.9084939957,
-0.2201049924,
-0.3883536458,
0.5435490608,
0.1835447401,
0.3311282098,
0.7162638307,
0.8031445146,
-0.4976357222,
0.8033483624,
-0.2498842329,
-0.058795549,
-0.2155675143,
-0.468367517,
-1.2546657324,
-0.6727367043,
0.1922256351,
-0.2052354962,
0.0002693197,
0.4944443405,
0.7924599648,
-0.5939161181,
0.1239435151,
-0.1142950058,
0.0557253174,
-0.0833337829,
-0.2045574635,
0.3936029971,
-0.1849650741,
-0.3335686028,
0.2572847009,
0.1652399451,
0.1663839817,
-0.5827929974,
-0.0760422349,
0.309027195,
0.1409766823,
0.7464294434,
-0.0307604633,
-1.0587331057,
-0.4767275751,
0.5068764687,
-0.0522299781,
0.0069303317,
1.030685544,
-0.865213275,
0.4751396477,
0.5214975476,
0.6454166174,
0.6410637498,
-0.1289420277,
0.2993504107,
-0.9825394154,
0.404553175,
0.2064124793,
0.1459779739,
0.0037099589,
-0.6097390056,
0.2054286301,
0.0767563358,
-0.2953283489,
-1.210431695,
0.4227871001,
-0.8478046656,
-0.276738584,
1.0113706589,
-0.0477592871,
-0.4898478389,
0.1036243066,
-0.4750328064,
-0.0088430662,
-0.0140850581,
0.6735451221,
0.7086541057,
0.0205925237,
-0.6255586743,
-0.7212614417,
0.6263286471,
0.5538762212,
-0.4228096604,
0.2122743875,
0.282397002,
0.23954162,
0.2269919962,
0.584553659,
0.0094391434,
0.3306141794,
0.2059535086,
-0.2982441187,
-0.2364702374,
-0.4478046894,
-0.2493266761,
0.289948523,
0.1347569525,
-0.4607012868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09032v1
|
CodeUltraFeedback: An LLM-as-a-Judge Dataset for Aligning Large Language Models to Coding Preferences
| 2024-03-14T01:51:35 | 2024-03-14T01:51:35 |
Martin Weyssow, Aton Kamanda, Houari Sahraoui
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Evaluating the alignment of large language models (LLMs) with user-defined
coding preferences is a challenging endeavour that requires assessing intricate
textual LLMs' outputs. By relying on automated metrics and static analysis
tools, existing benchmarks fail to assess nuances in user instructions and LLM
outputs, highlighting the need for large-scale datasets and benchmarks for LLM
preference alignment. In this paper, we introduce CodeUltraFeedback, a
preference dataset of 10,000 complex instructions to tune and align LLMs to
coding preferences through AI feedback. We generate responses to the
instructions using a pool of 14 diverse LLMs, which we then annotate according
to their alignment with five coding preferences using the LLM-as-a-Judge
approach with GPT-3.5, producing both numerical and textual feedback. We also
present CODAL-Bench, a benchmark for assessing LLM alignment with these coding
preferences. Our results show that CodeLlama-7B-Instruct, aligned through
reinforcement learning from AI feedback (RLAIF) with direct preference
optimization (DPO) using CodeUltraFeedback's AI feedback data, outperforms 34B
LLMs on CODAL-Bench, validating the utility of CodeUltraFeedback for preference
tuning. Furthermore, we show our DPO-aligned CodeLlama model improves
functional correctness on HumanEval+ compared to the unaligned base model.
Therefore, our contributions bridge the gap in preference tuning of LLMs for
code and set the stage for further advancements in model alignment and RLAIF
for code intelligence. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/martin-wey/CodeUltraFeedback.
|
[
-0.1454176605,
-0.1350491494,
0.28537637,
0.333001852,
-0.012111363,
0.1746447831,
-0.6971672773,
-0.0234943479,
0.0374317802,
0.4900524616,
-0.5830668211,
-0.7057936192,
-0.460559994,
0.093333967,
-0.2111544013,
1.1007492542,
-0.3578527868,
0.0736201108,
-0.409692347,
-0.2257132381,
-0.7175068259,
-0.624943614,
-0.033680737,
-0.4524379671,
0.3473039865,
0.6991195083,
0.9033200145,
0.7042474151,
0.5948784947,
0.1912142336,
0.3291918635,
0.1183756515,
-0.3481206894,
-0.1692693979,
-0.0618262216,
-0.4028892219,
-0.4979440868,
0.0115811666,
0.2120504677,
0.2086170912,
-0.094250381,
0.2399073243,
0.063989982,
0.7590806484,
-0.4916106164,
0.1369926035,
-0.3256694973,
0.0921919569,
0.0550030656,
-0.4368824661,
-0.5860368013,
-0.9399813414,
-0.1294696927,
-0.3916474879,
-0.2008369416,
0.029270893,
0.7169128656,
0.6817120314,
-0.3760326803,
-0.4032966793,
-0.4197531641,
0.7834867239,
-0.8187009692,
0.103077814,
0.283793509,
0.2268182635,
-0.0850321203,
-0.2886474133,
-0.5017044544,
-0.3721933365,
-0.0336488336,
0.1654789299,
-0.0524580106,
-0.0334743038,
0.2570396662,
0.3620281219,
-0.7583320737,
0.3999149799,
0.0193649605,
-0.2689321339,
0.7416436672,
0.1687221229,
0.1395727247,
-0.0663146153,
-0.4629210532,
-0.2131376565,
-0.7626863122,
0.1921176463,
0.6038432717,
0.1643710583,
-0.2044617087,
0.5884767175,
-0.061390873,
0.8529495597,
0.1828981936,
-0.0408161916,
0.4764954746,
-0.0918472484,
-0.1611808687,
0.1875155419,
0.7660725117,
0.753829658,
0.5125753284,
-0.0435052998,
-0.3098114431,
0.2023019791,
0.5101330876,
-0.6941991448,
-0.0594265759,
0.3000882864,
-0.4312757254,
-0.494333148,
0.1608723402,
-0.6360033751,
-0.4306556284,
-0.5308413506,
0.1395258904,
-0.2110747099,
-0.015192966,
0.3575785458,
0.1727291346,
0.4282460511,
0.3728051782,
-1.0158506632,
-0.0451449044,
0.8758932352,
0.6688809395,
-0.5493192077,
-0.3941985667,
-0.6535081267,
-0.1695669889,
-0.2709043324,
0.6660779119,
-0.7658156157,
-0.2383012176,
0.261297822,
0.0779733211,
-0.0387445651,
-0.4794600308,
0.6524909139,
-0.590726614,
-0.1022728533,
-0.0369782336,
-0.6042130589,
-0.0502909422,
0.3558645248,
-0.4561164081,
0.8091099262,
0.1461743861,
-0.4668676853,
0.3747701645,
-0.3317329288,
-0.3894152343,
-0.0537025593,
-0.5017258525,
-0.4176532626,
0.0273098424,
0.1505919397,
0.2646639645,
-0.2036318779,
0.6495773792,
-0.5103351474,
-0.6677907109,
0.3115208745,
-0.3589746058,
0.5091226697,
0.0937177762,
-0.5476257801,
0.4136122465,
-0.6571515799,
0.1171068922,
-0.1168022752,
-0.6062013507,
0.0238465406,
0.0997100174,
0.0378630981,
0.070230417,
0.2442394495,
-0.4390315115,
0.7674595714,
-0.1471832395,
0.6184474826,
0.9670550823,
-0.5180744529,
0.4251018763,
-0.4107811749,
0.7968252301,
-0.3232135177,
0.099638015,
0.0811308324,
-0.0729866102,
-0.4669264257,
-0.1882568896,
0.3257333338,
0.4205320179,
-0.3073871434,
0.7556459308,
-0.5214537978,
-0.0975541547,
-0.7218217254,
0.1770837009,
0.5386302471,
0.3312555254,
0.218589887,
-0.2881129384,
-0.550224483,
-1.0321501493,
-0.1843682528,
-0.2412713468,
0.0141072599,
0.4009607434,
0.286500752,
-0.4286316335,
0.8910322189,
-0.4035973549,
-0.0808149502,
-0.0370730683,
-0.0817665085,
0.3477193713,
0.5565716028,
0.35097453,
-0.6131289601,
-0.2939274311,
0.0270876363,
-0.4387810528,
-0.3698399365,
0.0269980058,
-0.0901348665,
0.2860675752,
0.2085695565,
-0.2627383471,
0.2320553809,
0.8305000067,
-0.2417369485,
0.5400536656,
-0.0296832211,
0.5125357509,
-0.7888956666,
0.1310454905,
-0.2898438871,
-0.2917679548,
-0.0516868867,
0.073016569,
0.3923918307,
0.1402561367,
-0.2112226188,
0.4054467976,
-0.2177290171,
-0.3896024227,
-0.3633200824,
-0.0241853148,
0.0606646873,
0.7700305581,
0.2743903697,
0.9745534658,
0.0899296328,
-0.2312661558,
0.4430432618,
0.4763971567,
-0.1992285699,
0.3721935451,
-0.4547189474,
0.472266078,
0.3045941591,
0.2965036035,
-0.9998356104,
-0.0995438173,
0.0809778273,
-0.4056307375,
0.3388838172,
-0.4299120009,
-0.2431755513,
-0.4038865566,
-0.5553572774,
0.3688542545,
0.4906462729,
-0.7633725405,
0.3906417787,
0.1597446054,
0.0102913203,
-0.7780185938,
-0.4508424103,
-0.0197697114,
-0.1374900937,
-0.4118129015,
0.3059527278,
-0.366042614,
-0.1871141791,
-0.30157426,
-0.3005085588,
0.3199056387,
0.0183127914,
0.5882323384,
0.4998602271,
-0.1437747478,
0.1530829519,
-0.1061646417,
-0.2526809871,
0.0393315665,
-0.3982875347,
0.5860663056,
-0.3365466595,
-0.3654703796,
-0.1201477647,
0.0031045503,
0.5490316749,
-0.1867560744,
0.0532721691,
0.2146348059,
0.1594856679,
-0.0898945257,
-0.5425692797,
0.0666127056,
-0.3746883273,
0.1898550093,
-0.0902989954,
-0.9787105322,
0.1155617386,
0.0548615269,
0.2026702762,
0.2861513793,
0.8346978426,
0.0045439182,
0.8715227246,
0.4942523837,
-0.4929783642,
0.3422958553,
-0.0454232767,
-0.0014697707,
-0.6866207719,
-0.1246511638,
-0.6254293919,
-0.5216526985,
-0.5183374882,
-0.2102993429,
-0.0210620575,
-0.0540765598,
-0.505081892,
0.4582060874,
-0.6600349545,
0.4120020866,
0.4604884386,
0.0790385157,
0.4518044293,
-0.1958853006,
0.0777612925,
0.0330769718,
-0.5237987638,
-0.7509401441,
1.1226841211,
0.23552984,
1.2172174454,
0.0369464979,
0.6251513362,
0.5381790996,
0.4524032772,
-0.9283800125,
0.2678213418,
-0.0958074033,
-0.0605014116,
0.061799895,
-0.1759696752,
-0.4402978718,
-0.152967304,
-0.111195147,
-0.4734164476,
0.2175418437,
0.3929613233,
-0.4604933262,
-0.054801356,
-0.7400637269,
0.867995441,
-0.5298891664,
-0.4969674051,
-0.1295507103,
-0.7301573157,
0.324000001,
0.0464765877,
0.1131930053,
-0.1302189082,
-0.0414322615,
0.5563395619,
-0.4508373737,
0.8186807036,
0.0480618738,
-0.2648278177,
-0.180949226,
0.0989003479,
0.4402515292,
0.1712998748,
-0.1861097366,
0.1521488428,
0.028202638,
-0.180208981,
-0.447178334,
1.032140851,
-0.9642472267,
-0.6609965563,
-0.3353955448,
-0.6285897493,
-0.3291625082,
0.0022918603,
0.0744093284,
0.5718346834,
0.1092215851,
0.1723015606,
0.5828936696,
-0.3080555499,
0.4275662005,
0.6367223263,
-0.3642860055,
-0.3946636915,
0.8397494555,
-0.4036821425,
0.132857278,
0.4966673553,
0.1689913273,
-0.2606391311,
-0.4843172431,
-0.7655037045,
-0.1491024941,
-0.5543728471,
-0.6175832748,
-0.4104862809,
-0.0475800484,
-0.2165187001,
-0.5020818114,
-0.3367613852,
-0.2450267673,
-0.0760827661,
-0.0733591169,
0.5221959352,
0.5901399255,
0.1727660447,
0.0131918918,
-0.8939678073,
0.0116394181,
0.0027234466,
0.6246800423,
-0.098893851,
-0.6150684357,
-0.152380228,
-0.0587096773,
-0.249633044,
-0.5091779828,
0.2045076191,
-0.1134610623,
0.2276242971,
0.2138505876,
0.0037573706,
0.5553697348,
-0.3807700872,
0.6138507724,
0.0076442566,
-1.0548901558,
0.5458979607,
-0.1822249144,
0.3292866349,
0.8384953141,
0.2085588425,
-0.3607691526,
-0.0570940264,
-0.2416596711,
-0.5115840435,
0.6910640597,
0.0339729562,
-0.0538500138,
0.1175578237,
0.4050088525,
0.3421351314,
0.3520995975,
-0.6049144864,
0.0219681226,
-0.2699905336,
-0.5056752563,
-0.2086869329,
-0.0815843716,
-0.21811001,
-0.0727049634,
0.5223044753,
-0.484233886,
0.1445075423,
0.0069490164,
-0.301057905,
-0.1257324964,
0.3893118799,
0.6992764473,
0.6200525761,
-0.2441194952,
0.0371727273,
-0.2003815323,
-0.2750992179,
0.3936406374,
0.1000829339,
-0.09419626,
-0.3859679997,
0.5225381255,
0.680077374,
0.3922401965,
-0.9063917994,
0.7220479846,
-0.2148907185,
-0.1976510882,
-0.0729555637,
0.1456134617,
-0.0322576575,
0.2685519457,
0.0738729984,
0.2250826955,
-0.0076086759,
-0.3480006158,
0.2462270856,
0.4635335803,
-0.4732129276,
-0.1754854172,
0.5730788708,
0.2290169299,
-0.4442124963,
0.6055537462,
0.2763210833,
-0.5019087195,
0.7153933048,
0.3906949162,
0.8895421028,
0.0968521088,
0.1025828049,
0.2383810729,
0.0770791173,
-0.0862958208,
0.139224112,
-0.2981131077,
-0.7456575632,
-0.3272370398,
-0.664753437,
-0.4814071357,
-0.2678671181,
-0.8550697565,
0.2798627615,
-0.4027644098,
-0.0369939059,
-0.3148883879,
0.0138099734,
-0.5924088955,
-0.0036028437,
0.0094167124,
0.9482504725,
-0.5529352427,
0.9496417046,
0.5307468772,
-0.4042626917,
-0.9384721518,
0.1596474499,
0.2016452104,
-1.3472284079,
0.5250267982,
0.2934340239,
-0.2983936965,
-0.040993005,
-0.7012884617,
-0.6509512663,
1.017088294,
0.453039676,
-1.0979981422,
0.1857869476,
-0.1146291494,
0.4687317014,
-0.4305467904,
0.4202131629,
0.7132726312,
0.5071477294,
0.0542981066,
-0.6955382824,
0.0764130577,
-0.3306597471,
-0.0152218556,
0.326439172,
-0.8079723716,
0.1097842678,
-0.2620189786,
0.224569723,
0.0148496116,
0.3376147747,
0.2219555378,
-0.0892597437,
0.434717536,
0.4554126859,
0.3522680402,
-0.0817108899,
1.0754197836,
-0.4704172313,
0.3548211753,
1.0860477686,
-0.449308455,
0.8516963124,
0.5702527165,
-0.1591504961,
0.3866378367,
0.6245025992,
-0.0780744329,
0.4277387559,
0.4262566566,
0.3556515872,
-0.1940254718,
-0.0669522211,
-0.3679227233,
0.3899751008,
-0.2230407149,
-0.2148007303,
0.1037126109,
-0.1830153614,
-0.1467928141,
0.2052510083,
-0.2264784575,
0.8320831656,
-0.0486677028,
-1.0220788717,
0.6913539767,
-0.2313032299,
0.8023523688,
-0.6161011457,
-0.117246829,
-0.5207082033,
0.3839876354,
-0.4878938794,
-0.9340441823,
0.0755673721,
0.1733230501,
-0.3213659823,
-0.2786615491,
0.2776097357,
-0.4805450439,
-0.1179106161,
0.4757364392,
-0.0496142581,
-0.28176561,
0.3305559456,
-0.5693116784,
0.5948411226,
0.2769626677,
-0.186130181,
0.5196467042,
-0.0918894261,
-0.0442777611,
0.5227785707,
0.4114114642,
-0.0954172388,
-0.2649892867,
0.2725980878,
0.7920114398,
-0.6838203073,
-0.3455427885,
-0.9222539067,
0.3032057285,
0.129536733,
-0.4169750512,
0.6374005079,
0.6328108907,
0.8673591018,
-0.1288468689,
0.7575113773,
0.0670242757,
0.1236730143,
-0.828324616,
0.3142903149,
-0.3615692258,
0.4554862678,
-0.2175804228,
-0.8214338422,
-0.1868873537,
0.3699432611,
-0.3805406988,
-0.0429683849,
0.457993418,
0.9610112906,
0.0732041523,
0.0849271715,
0.1379006058,
-0.0048398511,
0.2858527601,
0.8035351634,
0.8560577035,
-0.2018999606,
0.4805908203,
0.0002544426,
-0.4129107296,
-0.4333943725,
-1.0180971622,
-0.662714839,
-0.3062752187,
-0.2833767235,
-0.4262938201,
0.2185118496,
1.4011956453,
0.5999061465,
-0.9604897499,
-0.400963515,
-0.0035638297,
0.0933373719,
-0.3556878865,
-0.2070054114,
0.4003871977,
-0.2525268197,
-0.5662143826,
0.2845327556,
0.5886451602,
-0.2356600761,
-0.1191825569,
-0.4419601262,
0.0314252973,
-0.1904487014,
0.3486655653,
0.2363698483,
-0.7916266322,
-0.4321677387,
-0.0086493026,
-0.367092669,
0.4102579951,
1.1856204271,
-0.5842416286,
0.3004196286,
0.329903096,
1.0176950693,
0.2555012703,
0.2109940648,
0.9639744163,
-0.4889889359,
-0.0545295589,
0.2435313314,
0.4047003984,
0.1643133461,
-0.4732269347,
0.4953322411,
-0.1448496133,
-0.7812069654,
-0.5183312893,
0.1373293698,
-1.0619188547,
-0.0008203531,
1.2069624662,
-0.1217604801,
-0.0621262752,
0.2655284703,
-0.4604717493,
-0.2043422908,
-0.6665939093,
0.7284536958,
0.6804713011,
0.0021928304,
-0.054431051,
-0.1941545904,
0.6457505822,
0.5065826774,
-0.7354823947,
0.4431762397,
0.7104038596,
0.1707299948,
-0.2470472306,
0.5566251278,
-0.1061964408,
0.405417949,
-0.5519031286,
0.3647115529,
-0.1606076807,
-0.1968509555,
-0.8285093307,
-0.0329991244,
0.3242977262,
-0.115718402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09028v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09028v1
|
ChartInstruct: Instruction Tuning for Chart Comprehension and Reasoning
| 2024-03-14T01:40:23 | 2024-03-14T01:40:23 |
Ahmed Masry, Mehrad Shahmohammadi, Md Rizwan Parvez, Enamul Hoque, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Charts provide visual representations of data and are widely used for
analyzing information, addressing queries, and conveying insights to others.
Various chart-related downstream tasks have emerged recently, such as
question-answering and summarization. A common strategy to solve these tasks is
to fine-tune various models originally trained on vision tasks language.
However, such task-specific models are not capable of solving a wide range of
chart-related tasks, constraining their real-world applicability. To overcome
these challenges, we introduce ChartInstruct: a novel chart-specific
vision-language Instruction-following dataset comprising 191K instructions
generated with 71K charts. We then present two distinct systems for instruction
tuning on such datasets: (1) an end-to-end model that connects a vision encoder
for chart understanding with a LLM; and (2) a pipeline model that employs a
two-step approach to extract chart data tables and input them into the LLM. In
experiments on four downstream tasks, we first show the effectiveness of our
model--achieving a new set of state-of-the-art results. Further evaluation
shows that our instruction-tuning approach supports a wide array of real-world
chart comprehension and reasoning scenarios, thereby expanding the scope and
applicability of our models to new kinds of tasks.
|
[
-0.1332534552,
-0.6941549182,
0.4864924252,
-0.2125178427,
-0.3909502029,
0.187494114,
-0.0218104012,
-0.3381692171,
-0.1099055111,
1.0309312344,
-0.7668118477,
-0.8228223324,
-0.6265864968,
-0.3272920549,
-0.5288000107,
0.8493413925,
-0.2217917442,
0.0818255469,
-0.2370572388,
0.1265632957,
-0.894524157,
-0.1235963777,
-0.6773835421,
0.0373037308,
0.351131469,
1.1533299685,
0.4305028915,
0.9106591344,
0.6694810987,
0.230530113,
0.4749616086,
0.6891908646,
-0.7718362808,
0.2811951041,
0.0925228298,
-0.6505700946,
-0.3584952056,
0.035147652,
0.3401129842,
0.8529370427,
0.1718692183,
0.4514184892,
0.220727846,
1.0482414961,
-0.8506458998,
0.7613115311,
-0.297172606,
0.0083951484,
0.075221844,
-0.4422709048,
-0.8954035044,
-0.4753576517,
0.2277044654,
-0.938783586,
0.2158316374,
0.2082728297,
0.8832997084,
0.5183321238,
-0.5523908138,
-0.4244179428,
-0.39522174,
0.4874331057,
-0.5268988013,
0.3759431839,
0.4162787199,
0.6066002846,
0.2377597094,
-1.0846232176,
0.0106835803,
0.0946105793,
-0.1191573068,
0.5198822021,
-0.0035186619,
0.1846530885,
0.2016742378,
0.1634687185,
-0.417027235,
0.318705529,
-0.613273263,
0.0386909693,
0.5656888485,
0.5918191075,
0.2918461561,
-0.0490842462,
-0.1746608615,
-0.3631854057,
-0.7180351615,
0.2605170012,
0.2708920538,
0.2672727108,
-0.2056911141,
0.4296290874,
-0.2080488205,
1.0111986399,
0.3802609444,
0.1101541966,
-0.140140146,
-0.0733066201,
-0.3846482337,
0.1465172023,
0.1581251323,
0.7084309459,
0.571926415,
-0.1406601816,
-0.2100218385,
0.1228111014,
0.555929184,
-0.6700605154,
-0.6054984927,
-0.0666494444,
-0.2108879834,
-0.2059794515,
0.0135897556,
-0.5020121336,
-0.5566625595,
-0.8728522658,
0.5147204399,
-0.6316193342,
0.356423527,
0.0509931073,
-0.134483844,
0.3183244169,
0.4028886557,
-1.0067863464,
0.1526987106,
0.8784940243,
0.5885231495,
-0.0104402853,
-0.1972494572,
-0.7771704197,
0.2514016628,
-0.8110389709,
0.9077592492,
-0.848616004,
-0.0121919392,
-0.1228126436,
0.2537339032,
-0.4079789221,
-0.5509235263,
0.2970593274,
-0.5814184546,
-0.061062932,
-0.2053804547,
-1.2781378031,
-0.5968308449,
0.0399012417,
-0.5825453997,
0.6128454804,
0.2675680518,
-0.477468729,
0.3953696787,
-0.6209096313,
-0.5929967165,
0.1818835586,
-0.3340858817,
-0.3768174648,
-0.0705489889,
0.5187743306,
0.5727859139,
-0.1896883398,
-0.3775267303,
0.1694181263,
-0.7357568741,
-0.2153175175,
-0.1982271522,
0.7224066257,
0.0773856565,
-0.4263825715,
0.232739836,
-0.5730959177,
0.313726753,
-0.0153575717,
-0.0038170966,
-0.1309625059,
0.2127020359,
-0.282471031,
-0.4157613814,
0.0755917877,
-0.218469575,
0.0619850308,
-0.4752508998,
0.4331493378,
0.7882143855,
0.1834273338,
0.5510866642,
-0.1364611983,
0.7806504965,
0.0178549718,
0.4242815673,
-0.5351902843,
-0.5600680709,
-1.1571496725,
-0.0754864886,
0.0186998751,
0.8044362068,
-0.8088517785,
0.0319654755,
-0.2995811701,
-0.6207856536,
-0.3791833222,
0.0020592473,
0.4562158585,
0.9316393137,
0.4253992438,
-0.2394479513,
-0.4713517725,
-0.7684650421,
0.0024611983,
0.3114328384,
0.0370541215,
0.3154475391,
0.1525301784,
0.2408658415,
0.5754813552,
-0.8489195108,
-0.1138873845,
-0.2844803929,
-0.0223701838,
0.232777074,
0.3305850029,
0.5040896535,
-0.5089681745,
-0.8664475083,
0.0408688858,
-0.7983136773,
-0.0151833845,
-0.160307467,
-0.4821844101,
-0.0478796959,
0.7675774693,
-0.0501393676,
0.7219938636,
0.3575055301,
-0.5157192349,
0.5061323643,
-0.2440501451,
0.2962320745,
-0.7350161672,
-0.4752481878,
-0.1933151037,
-0.074531205,
-0.536777854,
0.3052936196,
0.367503792,
-0.2881870568,
-0.0978483483,
0.0972000435,
-0.5790910125,
0.0392015502,
-0.3446500897,
0.1110632941,
0.2442245185,
0.5200361609,
-0.1486304849,
0.6500952244,
0.9260357022,
-0.6888565421,
0.6194841266,
0.312715739,
-0.6601777673,
0.6750468016,
-0.4076241553,
0.2832225859,
-0.3044553399,
-0.0064126635,
-0.983089149,
-0.2972711921,
0.4385151863,
-0.1076497361,
0.5637994409,
-0.5457336307,
-0.3176461458,
-0.2626652122,
0.0882157162,
-0.0485037789,
0.5621278882,
-0.6725284457,
0.5797134042,
0.1776961237,
0.0879261866,
-0.4681908488,
-0.7415307164,
-0.041227065,
-0.1728426367,
-0.6245866418,
-0.0140117472,
0.0536631756,
0.0674060211,
-0.029990783,
-0.1425138414,
-0.1310581118,
-0.0790202096,
0.3668633103,
0.5034689903,
-0.4381415546,
0.1076414362,
0.3206178546,
-0.3351467252,
-0.0489755906,
-0.4509716928,
0.1424726546,
0.127385214,
-0.7326681614,
-0.5596072078,
0.1815926135,
0.4134756923,
-0.4809576869,
0.4021037519,
0.3198861778,
-0.0311757345,
-0.4165990055,
-0.2025928497,
-0.4348424971,
-0.5720675588,
0.5793348551,
-0.0555862971,
-0.4724364579,
0.1088705435,
-0.0446807966,
0.5237841606,
-0.0422053747,
0.2072049379,
-0.68751055,
0.9552208185,
0.4550969303,
0.3119425178,
0.5547305942,
-0.688344717,
0.3222542107,
-0.6048304439,
-0.0716118738,
-0.0295842737,
-0.8365162015,
-0.3127551079,
-0.4704063237,
0.5143610835,
-0.1648866236,
-0.4719442427,
0.2799440324,
-0.7408620119,
0.8015666008,
0.7865832448,
0.5131297112,
0.114197582,
0.1312761754,
0.2711113095,
-0.0903905928,
-0.8583517075,
-0.5174316764,
1.2707182169,
-0.2279877216,
0.7741729617,
-0.3275856376,
0.4651542902,
0.0923168659,
0.2011181414,
-0.7726201415,
0.5871359706,
-0.7940863967,
-0.4498885572,
-0.4541157484,
-0.2144825906,
-1.0524299145,
-0.0007588175,
0.0271204561,
-0.7197886705,
-0.0232544336,
0.542193532,
-0.1178841516,
0.3936095536,
-1.3551946878,
1.0981308222,
-0.4316993356,
-0.139151752,
-0.2793619335,
-0.6434901357,
0.2532668412,
0.2603758276,
0.1281183064,
-0.048934143,
0.0837625712,
0.482180208,
-0.470205605,
1.0533477068,
-0.2765173018,
-0.06803523,
0.5347732306,
0.0974327624,
0.5763151646,
-0.4156909883,
0.1744340658,
-0.4438062012,
0.1259696335,
-0.4087775648,
-1.0440818071,
0.4674880207,
-0.4953261912,
-0.5544318557,
0.2209412009,
-0.8740860224,
-0.442061305,
0.0068690358,
0.3606323302,
0.910812676,
0.3484021425,
0.183679074,
0.5250931382,
-0.0776172057,
0.023728447,
0.4043019116,
0.0862336606,
-0.0899319425,
1.1370782852,
0.2387014031,
0.4548000693,
0.5873193741,
-0.0319662802,
0.042376291,
-0.4413230717,
-0.6276828647,
-0.1331492513,
-1.1680458784,
-0.1357166618,
0.1723598689,
-0.2199204266,
-0.0624341443,
-0.3247073591,
-0.3634806871,
-0.3724711537,
-0.4086404443,
-0.1734070629,
0.5597017407,
0.7385581136,
0.1723744571,
0.2336556911,
-0.7204571366,
0.2669556439,
0.4347799122,
0.3540244401,
0.2265643775,
-0.6460514069,
-0.6834165454,
0.2052787244,
-0.3861013055,
-0.845698297,
-0.0439119413,
0.2660298049,
0.4259539843,
0.6585068107,
0.2750636339,
0.821764648,
-0.5546790957,
0.3429436088,
-0.0056968112,
-0.6246469021,
0.5834854841,
0.1210605204,
0.4169448018,
0.2625371516,
0.2675633729,
-0.3784467578,
-0.6740942001,
-0.1912955046,
-0.8274675608,
0.8557727337,
0.0784248188,
0.1062317267,
0.2840613127,
0.5601232052,
0.1939305514,
-0.213615641,
-0.0140233645,
-0.4002697468,
-0.4986794591,
-0.6339516044,
-0.1427081823,
0.1170965955,
-0.0923298821,
-0.4622455239,
0.4631808698,
-0.2919979692,
-0.1622058004,
-0.1994670331,
-0.2828069627,
-0.0161602441,
-0.1087601185,
0.1751668751,
0.8693875074,
0.0814831927,
0.1434961706,
0.0766257867,
-0.7298301458,
-0.0419070199,
-0.0042051529,
-0.4967078567,
-0.341401875,
0.6541748643,
1.2386270761,
0.6479228139,
-0.8186339736,
0.1154344454,
0.1181768253,
-0.0811670721,
-0.0182578564,
0.5540067554,
0.3302386999,
0.4275095463,
0.2862694561,
-0.0725201517,
0.0329880789,
-0.2314528376,
0.1042266935,
0.106239222,
-0.4657158256,
-0.1021143794,
0.7474930286,
0.162240833,
-0.1818419248,
0.9589864016,
-0.0205564406,
-0.2620370388,
1.1111997366,
0.2450439334,
0.606715858,
0.1882577091,
0.3906491995,
0.4703079462,
0.4392881691,
0.580437243,
0.3622214198,
-0.0762984529,
-0.5879167318,
-0.4779182673,
-0.0460770242,
-0.5962910056,
-0.1683861762,
-0.8328684568,
0.1935163885,
-0.2956904173,
0.0830738842,
-0.0153740961,
-0.2584493458,
-0.7258616686,
0.3299150467,
0.2758291662,
0.6641999483,
-0.4940708876,
0.4047766626,
0.6484196782,
-0.4211035073,
-1.0847871304,
-0.147656396,
-0.0026350277,
-1.0707973242,
0.5783779621,
0.1822081059,
-0.0521679111,
0.2476026714,
-0.8269864321,
-0.657541275,
1.2555782795,
0.7162970304,
-0.7514656782,
-0.0827028975,
0.17596744,
0.3625217676,
-0.3997812569,
0.0371971466,
0.6078450084,
0.4983509183,
0.0997484326,
-0.545042336,
-0.0616730452,
0.0709349811,
-0.4597463012,
0.1275884807,
-0.5497236848,
0.6018806696,
-0.5719842315,
-0.3259986639,
-0.1730478257,
0.430716604,
0.1819724292,
0.4819558263,
0.5110402703,
0.4216695428,
0.7566894293,
-0.0991236195,
0.9569172263,
-0.6274831295,
0.0870671347,
1.4078913927,
0.1420395374,
0.6966456175,
0.1703204066,
0.0445240252,
0.553530097,
0.8139883876,
-0.1026191562,
0.4712552428,
-0.0930561572,
0.235153839,
-0.4055674374,
0.2199198306,
-0.1636584252,
0.6055373549,
0.4453214109,
-0.4356648326,
-0.1326745152,
-0.1595080942,
-0.234067753,
0.1868171394,
-0.5267602205,
0.5506598949,
-0.0328644179,
-0.7205351591,
0.6152711511,
-0.4077065289,
-0.0949288085,
-0.5866609812,
-0.2206439525,
-0.3262239993,
0.1180291772,
-0.2001121193,
-0.9903128147,
0.1455257833,
-0.0023984665,
-0.0063393554,
-0.2118444592,
0.2220139205,
-0.2310289145,
-0.6917371154,
-0.0672966987,
0.2983740568,
0.0005518433,
0.0734921396,
-0.4362148643,
-0.2487874031,
0.1418072283,
-0.0413527675,
0.0108721172,
0.5659118295,
0.1131746769,
0.9650329947,
0.2468741834,
-0.2113347501,
0.2661632895,
0.4899231791,
0.6585623026,
-0.4160095751,
-0.6473838687,
-0.2709406316,
0.4990229607,
-0.0075370721,
-0.2188884914,
0.6692834496,
0.6703754067,
0.7480697036,
-0.3292070329,
0.6026608944,
0.3374773562,
0.474521786,
-0.8996250629,
0.7195245624,
-0.62595433,
0.154370442,
-0.2267696559,
-0.6003708243,
-0.1191425323,
0.2896889448,
-0.5540544391,
-0.2594673932,
0.779432714,
0.7794203162,
-0.288099438,
0.2566887736,
0.1628385484,
0.0278987754,
0.0455383472,
0.8127980828,
0.7295196056,
-0.2699792385,
0.8920837045,
-0.5528501868,
-0.2294050604,
0.0239774976,
-0.4061298966,
-0.7945840359,
-0.6517304182,
-0.4968917072,
0.1920571178,
0.0400264822,
0.260705471,
0.9415411949,
-0.88035357,
-0.3523569703,
-0.2492245138,
0.0333236791,
-0.5834997296,
-0.2332811803,
0.7504534721,
-0.5784920454,
-0.7500683069,
0.4131132364,
0.4854179621,
-0.1211500689,
-0.0623801313,
-0.1495893747,
0.2184815258,
0.0635518879,
0.4895151556,
0.0941121802,
-0.5321490765,
-0.5008143187,
0.1621112227,
0.0961472616,
0.2604750395,
0.8366949558,
-0.5325859785,
0.8239136934,
0.2474666685,
0.4965211451,
0.7844123244,
-0.067622304,
0.480332166,
-0.5872145891,
0.0556037612,
0.1192729995,
0.3382274508,
0.3427998126,
-0.36951226,
0.6615648866,
-0.0494313352,
-0.3008007407,
-0.5085334778,
0.4933579564,
-0.6387681365,
-0.2902278304,
0.3889853954,
-0.1241322532,
-0.0161121432,
-0.0257780105,
-0.3252122402,
0.4236787558,
0.006705605,
0.7918100953,
0.5540124774,
-0.4863939285,
-0.4734973609,
-0.6331028342,
0.0954914466,
0.3026092947,
-0.8180621266,
0.1197759882,
0.5333381295,
0.0666980594,
-0.2999289632,
0.0350825265,
0.2873784006,
0.5984016657,
0.281190902,
-0.3740845919,
-0.2346840203,
-0.1639791876,
0.4809691608,
0.0519634597,
-0.1080278903,
-0.6333187222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09024v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09024v1
|
Semiparametric Token-Sequence Co-Supervision
| 2024-03-14T01:28:13 | 2024-03-14T01:28:13 |
Hyunji Lee, Doyoung Kim, Jihoon Jun, Sejune Joo, Joel Jang, Kyoung-Woon On, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we introduce a semiparametric token-sequence co-supervision
training method. It trains a language model by simultaneously leveraging
supervision from the traditional next token prediction loss which is calculated
over the parametric token embedding space and the next sequence prediction loss
which is calculated over the nonparametric sequence embedding space. The
nonparametric sequence embedding space is constructed by a separate language
model tasked to condense an input text into a single representative embedding.
Our experiments demonstrate that a model trained via both supervisions
consistently surpasses models trained via each supervision independently.
Analysis suggests that this co-supervision encourages a broader generalization
capability across the model. Especially, the robustness of parametric token
space which is established during the pretraining step tends to effectively
enhance the stability of nonparametric sequence embedding space, a new space
established by another language model.
|
[
-0.048223339,
-0.5374253988,
0.2493266612,
0.1751872003,
-0.2146372497,
0.1483044475,
-0.0448979735,
-0.1241270825,
0.1065668836,
0.4056445658,
-0.2419748157,
-0.7566084862,
-0.5275537372,
-0.082062602,
-0.600432694,
0.9854763746,
0.0393751711,
0.466222316,
-0.495002985,
-0.1521792263,
-0.6344209909,
-0.8508612514,
-0.7308516502,
-0.073994346,
0.2282497883,
0.19946675,
0.6049514413,
0.4557635188,
0.3490522206,
0.2704451978,
0.1018410698,
-0.0303401463,
-0.2250246257,
-0.2175630033,
-0.0094130859,
-0.6817228794,
-0.3735183179,
0.0156764537,
0.7156763077,
0.9790501595,
-0.3405056298,
0.1975225061,
0.214804858,
0.0428552143,
-0.449155122,
0.3838025033,
-0.282892406,
0.3588653505,
-0.0570463054,
-0.2679905593,
-0.6909917593,
-0.1117547601,
0.2039365619,
-0.4796704948,
0.541118741,
0.4623173475,
0.6130880117,
0.1144722253,
-0.4359034598,
0.1830196232,
-0.4881608784,
0.9795049429,
-0.7001262307,
0.5669784546,
0.3835708797,
0.3376477361,
0.110936217,
-0.7148777246,
-0.3277697265,
-0.1274652183,
-0.1301734149,
0.0328688286,
0.2947480083,
0.3525356948,
-0.0201846305,
0.4035769701,
-0.1567356884,
0.1509379596,
-0.2964625359,
-0.6173224449,
0.4145853221,
0.1706875116,
0.3911926448,
-0.1203737482,
-0.8183859587,
-0.1452829689,
-0.6134197712,
0.1777662039,
0.2435754836,
0.5246899128,
-0.5068911314,
0.4911748469,
0.2108511776,
0.4973194003,
0.167967841,
0.0425312258,
0.1682290584,
-0.5349562168,
-0.1498123109,
0.1921016276,
0.795369029,
0.4116047323,
0.0433815047,
-0.5669142604,
-0.0172985177,
0.0632432997,
0.1084394231,
-0.3256980181,
-0.1921904832,
-0.0829990208,
-0.4020126164,
-0.2342639863,
0.2290635854,
-0.6659538746,
-0.1162446961,
-0.344681114,
0.1781144738,
-0.3531216383,
-0.0021973148,
0.0185941644,
-0.279763341,
0.1206183508,
0.047218997,
-1.0971462727,
0.592599988,
0.7441223264,
1.1582292318,
-0.211812377,
-0.4271451831,
-0.7569342256,
0.4896322787,
-0.4882794321,
0.2753917575,
-0.623475194,
-0.2157360017,
0.2908754349,
-0.0896480978,
0.0258037485,
-0.2719546556,
0.3137574792,
-0.5991914868,
0.3185893595,
0.0628090426,
-0.8405540586,
0.0390435308,
0.2522644401,
-0.6690589786,
1.1680430174,
0.1347860694,
-1.0440649986,
0.7044850588,
-0.2785285413,
-0.2473868877,
-0.1060148627,
-0.3119032979,
-0.8477231264,
0.1038498208,
0.325201422,
0.5899957418,
-0.0287758484,
0.7659216523,
-0.8027029634,
-0.3392032087,
-0.2835935354,
-0.1466032714,
0.6468634605,
-0.3068698943,
-0.1854549944,
0.1204933971,
-0.7689673305,
-0.1895492375,
-0.2087193877,
-0.4323304296,
-0.6229122877,
-0.2041068375,
0.096411109,
0.1462837607,
0.3110145926,
-0.5527019501,
-0.0407312475,
-0.5438479185,
0.3735821247,
0.7364313006,
0.2335045636,
0.8779307604,
-0.0757401884,
0.5580983758,
0.2163008004,
0.1426646709,
-0.1678173393,
-0.3556524813,
-0.647846818,
-0.11557284,
0.3671538234,
0.4347600341,
-0.757792294,
0.6406123042,
0.0024996824,
-0.2609469891,
-0.1364175826,
0.1665733755,
0.7116558552,
0.5852137804,
0.393730402,
-0.3703442216,
-0.9541680217,
-0.6645130515,
-0.3570908308,
-0.2566376626,
0.2634856105,
-0.0903502107,
0.2885136604,
0.1288335323,
0.8539497256,
-0.1564793885,
-0.2312894166,
-0.4751480222,
0.2530774474,
0.249742806,
0.6278439164,
0.5355343819,
-0.5539415479,
-0.5229408145,
-0.2737803459,
-0.8011743426,
0.0447355248,
-0.1574129462,
-0.1262339205,
0.0613589883,
0.772846818,
-0.2853088677,
0.4830859601,
0.6749325991,
-0.328035593,
0.3007671237,
-0.3712521493,
-0.3670010865,
-1.6047891378,
-0.1168625727,
-0.0979626477,
-0.4489519894,
-0.65841043,
-0.0796952918,
0.1004687622,
-0.1022986174,
-0.3061178029,
0.3814165294,
-0.52712816,
-0.286221087,
0.2153907716,
-0.3509121239,
0.0212687664,
0.6016016006,
0.2498384118,
0.9101784229,
0.8171921372,
-0.5896136761,
0.2037914097,
0.612279892,
-0.3015120924,
-0.0649158359,
-0.7126165032,
0.1841905117,
0.1389941126,
0.3097661138,
-1.1206934452,
0.0515760928,
0.0396863036,
-0.2532403171,
0.394942224,
-0.1071690395,
-0.5974244475,
-0.2681719959,
-0.3938119709,
0.6347998381,
0.269037962,
-0.5739338994,
0.24616611,
0.3830410242,
-0.164091289,
-0.702994287,
-0.8909951448,
0.2195661515,
-0.2960053682,
-0.3064414263,
0.2867287397,
0.4592596889,
0.1401635557,
-0.2015984952,
-0.1201536059,
0.0227881856,
-0.1258268505,
0.2292437553,
0.4227527678,
-0.0048452504,
0.1001803577,
0.2406118959,
-0.2477541715,
0.0241003204,
-0.7162134051,
0.7801043987,
0.1089413613,
-0.4789200723,
-0.7319123745,
0.5228062868,
0.0526110753,
-0.2564434409,
1.0261992216,
0.3095196486,
-0.1347975582,
-0.226305142,
-0.1768884212,
-0.0145598315,
-0.4716165662,
0.4759197533,
-0.2128925174,
-1.1029897928,
0.5168723464,
0.0358839743,
-0.1449836195,
0.2118450254,
0.7529987693,
-0.0216335189,
0.9620351791,
1.0347124338,
-0.4115874767,
0.7513304949,
-0.4418129623,
0.3119183481,
-0.6101045012,
-0.5454844236,
-0.2307131588,
-0.1152082235,
-0.4495229125,
-0.5701853037,
0.3260717094,
0.0415476188,
-0.3845623732,
0.6345258355,
-0.1811994612,
0.1784613281,
0.871339798,
0.0666263252,
0.0376485102,
0.0864080042,
-0.614033401,
0.0727273971,
-0.7391189337,
-0.4628114104,
1.2480039597,
0.4913777709,
0.967081368,
-0.0797485113,
1.1053519249,
0.5190192461,
-0.2139796615,
-0.404386431,
0.3792400062,
0.0337116905,
-0.68057096,
-0.3908531666,
-0.2879547775,
-0.5622389317,
-0.1033227369,
0.1176462546,
-0.7099024057,
0.2977822721,
0.3381901383,
-0.4539403617,
0.3542863429,
-0.7838738561,
0.8251921535,
0.0028772515,
-0.4353047013,
0.0303643383,
-0.903945744,
0.0988657475,
-0.074435845,
0.0292273089,
0.36979267,
-0.2392218262,
0.793628335,
-0.6946675181,
1.349058032,
-0.5868300796,
0.0241357386,
0.3802433908,
-0.1941871792,
0.4808873832,
0.3603736758,
0.1362150908,
0.2261924148,
0.1234840602,
-0.7393446565,
-0.4502708912,
0.0334312357,
-0.9118249416,
-0.4115437865,
-0.367090553,
-0.5271865726,
-0.6133375168,
0.2762124836,
0.3056024015,
0.5711435676,
-0.2236816138,
0.079847306,
0.2523202002,
-0.3253934383,
0.6026670933,
-0.0657917187,
-0.2528653145,
-0.4860033691,
0.4306453466,
-0.1793818176,
0.3627614379,
0.7822996378,
0.0815413892,
-0.6769453287,
-0.6621076465,
-0.1769164503,
0.010916288,
-0.604368329,
-0.1498237699,
-0.6228031516,
-0.0413696356,
-0.6893718243,
0.0014838681,
-0.1186241731,
-0.4300710857,
-0.0606468692,
-0.3735736907,
0.0028586909,
0.538997829,
0.006412202,
0.4957258105,
-0.9196872711,
0.0501064807,
0.1603790075,
0.3285014033,
0.031967584,
-0.5529637933,
-0.4513420463,
-0.2772230208,
-0.059212897,
-0.7605910301,
0.3313900232,
0.4651024342,
0.4988919199,
0.5435395241,
-0.0377094559,
0.7990045547,
-0.7139860988,
0.8386362791,
0.59437567,
-1.012866497,
0.2954544723,
-0.4980157316,
0.0335894562,
0.6512448192,
-0.0249844212,
-0.4686233997,
-0.5253364444,
-0.4925833344,
-0.67208004,
1.0035758018,
-0.0813510716,
0.4901836812,
-0.1901898533,
0.3019159436,
0.2669488192,
0.377156496,
-0.4762671292,
-0.0925131962,
-0.3290388286,
-0.3505078256,
-0.3523947597,
-0.2737931609,
-0.0634731352,
-0.4673571289,
0.509876132,
-0.1755879819,
0.6275555491,
-0.1564240903,
0.0222840067,
0.1185755655,
0.0192959551,
0.1074528024,
0.3122643828,
-0.040696308,
0.2241885364,
0.4072637558,
-0.2562437654,
0.3110965788,
-0.0820103288,
0.0608382486,
0.0969549939,
0.8836366534,
0.9653387666,
0.5248121023,
-0.1498121172,
0.9615229964,
0.0746833906,
-0.2193354964,
-0.3027758002,
-0.2448469549,
0.1514988542,
0.2055846751,
0.0653206408,
0.1361863464,
0.1067396253,
-0.6046783328,
0.6030384898,
0.1757473052,
-0.4209495485,
-0.6211500764,
0.9495649338,
-0.0319424532,
-0.1797759086,
0.4651237428,
-0.0378623642,
-0.4826725423,
0.5645528436,
0.9119473696,
0.7898290753,
-0.0681177154,
0.3277995586,
0.2444511652,
-0.1903630644,
-0.1454146653,
0.3164187968,
-0.3347105384,
-0.4762609005,
-0.4806072712,
-0.9050632119,
-0.4539453089,
-0.3348063827,
-0.8944344521,
0.5260645151,
-0.8072621226,
-0.1738159359,
-0.1993806362,
-0.2496353984,
-0.4542672038,
0.3999437988,
0.1047494709,
1.0090615749,
-1.1154732704,
1.042583704,
0.895258069,
-0.5719016194,
-1.1132171154,
0.1557117105,
-0.2861803174,
-1.1242241859,
0.5402919054,
0.2890722454,
0.129188329,
-0.0540506579,
-0.415856123,
-0.8025635481,
1.0726742744,
0.6121892929,
-0.6027169228,
-0.7422337532,
0.5306894183,
0.7437489033,
-0.2738903761,
-0.2307564914,
0.1799610108,
-0.0301851239,
0.1243783161,
-0.6254284382,
-0.0276139956,
-0.1043668762,
0.2324107885,
0.3979597092,
-0.8180198073,
0.805775106,
0.0532760583,
-0.1983310878,
0.3127263784,
0.9075597525,
-0.0070987362,
0.4044106007,
0.4886803329,
0.7655828595,
0.5973533392,
0.1158591583,
1.0137022734,
-0.5535093546,
0.6776884198,
1.3643764257,
0.1476874053,
0.7623355389,
0.6651332378,
-0.3608706295,
0.4792079329,
0.7168729901,
-0.1551769823,
0.9737061262,
-0.1790941805,
-0.1932424754,
-0.4144974649,
-0.0437197424,
-0.1131198332,
0.4353565276,
-0.1011572182,
-0.6922280788,
-0.3586695194,
0.080667682,
-0.0815556794,
0.1332662851,
-0.1571377963,
0.7163105011,
0.2977201045,
-0.5719513297,
0.2670547366,
0.0374261066,
0.4074367285,
-0.3810032308,
0.1713407189,
-0.1053780317,
0.3177340925,
-0.1106847376,
-0.2592020035,
0.5173950791,
-0.1072838604,
0.0916508436,
-0.2959322333,
0.3800979257,
-0.4606260359,
-0.6240411997,
0.4928198755,
0.3995510042,
-0.1047717035,
0.3457027376,
-0.509883821,
-0.478312552,
-0.3269992173,
0.0009989609,
0.2451364547,
0.3819565773,
-0.4101794958,
0.2511308193,
0.4564474523,
0.0197076835,
0.6411625743,
0.3888370097,
0.7552844286,
-0.6639482379,
-0.8377759457,
-1.0404930115,
0.31100896,
-0.1463488191,
-0.2180724442,
0.8247215748,
0.7522398829,
0.8729354143,
-0.0564339124,
0.8775649071,
-0.07048852,
0.434943676,
-0.4432514906,
0.3882471323,
-0.4787187576,
-0.0237466879,
-0.3487712443,
-0.7809420824,
-0.5249210596,
0.1096626744,
-0.4490775168,
0.1380816251,
0.7236394286,
0.6137487888,
-0.1703678071,
-0.0152382962,
0.4484646916,
-0.3156504333,
0.2615575492,
0.5891994834,
0.8319565058,
-0.3469531238,
0.2922530472,
-0.1921729445,
-0.0843616724,
0.079317376,
-0.6733386517,
-1.4506527185,
-0.621573627,
0.0379799902,
-0.0115948301,
0.0286806785,
0.740404129,
0.7122961879,
-1.1795419455,
-0.1107139364,
-0.6110246181,
-0.4239723682,
-0.1550215632,
-0.1312425286,
0.6301933527,
-0.8137393594,
-0.9505625963,
0.0962705612,
0.4400237203,
-0.0074876011,
-0.3242971599,
-0.1571098566,
-0.3760478199,
0.0473435968,
0.2318534702,
-0.1422961354,
-0.5429947972,
-0.3686414957,
-0.1102264747,
-0.0211411901,
0.133101508,
0.7483542562,
-0.4543704689,
0.5240454674,
0.5563558936,
1.0129292011,
0.4477445781,
0.0881943628,
0.860842526,
-1.4044386148,
0.361037612,
-0.0368491113,
0.511719048,
0.3253574073,
-0.3354550898,
0.3315996826,
0.3523572981,
-0.1916359961,
-0.8047167063,
0.119614847,
-0.8127503395,
0.3343549967,
0.912530005,
-0.4776262045,
-0.211009562,
-0.2523293197,
-0.1379219592,
0.9142028689,
-0.4159816802,
0.7141045928,
0.7592910528,
0.0096558379,
-0.1898613721,
-0.1008938849,
0.3388114274,
0.7463082671,
-0.4943934083,
-0.1911603957,
0.0463870056,
0.0657179654,
0.2504450679,
0.4749373496,
-0.2731905282,
0.1535316855,
0.2080451697,
-0.1119849011,
-0.2414608151,
-0.3240162134,
-0.4624133408,
0.3464361429,
0.1730720252,
-0.714140296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09017v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09017v2
|
AraTrust: An Evaluation of Trustworthiness for LLMs in Arabic
| 2024-03-14T00:45:24 | 2024-03-15T23:52:18 |
Emad A. Alghamdi, Reem I. Masoud, Deema Alnuhait, Afnan Y. Alomairi, Ahmed Ashraf, Mohamed Zaytoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The swift progress and widespread acceptance of artificial intelligence (AI)
systems highlight a pressing requirement to comprehend both the capabilities
and potential risks associated with AI. Given the linguistic complexity,
cultural richness, and underrepresented status of Arabic in AI research, there
is a pressing need to focus on Large Language Models (LLMs) performance and
safety for Arabic related tasks. Despite some progress in their development,
there is a lack of comprehensive trustworthiness evaluation benchmarks which
presents a major challenge in accurately assessing and improving the safety of
LLMs when prompted in Arabic. In this paper, we introduce AraTrust, the first
comprehensive trustworthiness benchmark for LLMs in Arabic. AraTrust comprises
516 human-written multiple-choice questions addressing diverse dimensions
related to truthfulness, ethics, safety, physical health, mental health,
unfairness, illegal activities, privacy, and offensive language. We evaluated a
set of LLMs against our benchmark to assess their trustworthiness. GPT-4 was
the most trustworthy LLM, while open-source models, particularly AceGPT 7B and
Jais 13B, struggled to achieve a score of 60% in our benchmark.
|
[
-0.2941653728,
-0.582298398,
0.6783988476,
0.159730956,
-0.2341740876,
0.277834475,
0.1748280376,
-0.8234515786,
-0.3757036626,
0.3504909873,
0.0198289659,
-0.6926814318,
-1.1037127972,
0.1418024451,
-0.5148406625,
1.136274457,
-0.5238696933,
0.0298668649,
-0.1490161717,
-0.4369850755,
0.082149893,
-0.5153464079,
-0.8778047562,
-0.224705264,
0.1851581633,
0.2122377902,
1.037481308,
0.5418884158,
0.7152808309,
0.3603871167,
-0.1285641789,
0.2130684108,
0.0411413908,
0.0485530719,
-0.1431686431,
-0.2442703545,
-0.4406599104,
0.3360977471,
0.5178354383,
0.2323560715,
-0.2483375072,
0.4944981635,
0.0566448644,
0.8370797038,
-0.7885653973,
0.0841539279,
-0.5112555623,
-0.1141567975,
-0.1005200222,
0.0261484329,
0.0228116214,
-0.6889868975,
0.2064190805,
-0.320315659,
-0.5463141203,
0.4205978811,
0.8324631453,
0.3578772247,
-0.5771198273,
-0.5099089742,
-0.4563343823,
0.8021863699,
-0.4733813405,
0.2911388278,
0.8124076128,
0.3096079528,
-0.146693781,
-0.6153301597,
-0.4572692215,
-0.8677430153,
0.2366441637,
-0.0756802186,
-0.4245432019,
-0.2371191829,
-0.1541988552,
0.1252771914,
-0.5205097198,
-0.1038090736,
-0.0038122244,
-0.6007101536,
0.6629668474,
0.0552519821,
0.4475877583,
0.4214101136,
-0.5753019452,
-0.238269344,
-0.8193496466,
0.125949949,
0.6071209311,
-0.2422067821,
-0.3304602206,
0.4515785575,
-0.1517959535,
0.2694113255,
-0.2211012095,
-0.4099294841,
0.0982311666,
-0.3076711297,
-0.0748218745,
0.2962366343,
0.8607137203,
0.3460276723,
0.7190390229,
-0.286901027,
-0.1283394694,
0.3330407143,
0.3280225098,
-0.6732112169,
0.1431864947,
0.3835092485,
-0.4825911224,
-0.4530044198,
-0.0229859855,
-0.2295002341,
-0.4806341231,
0.1059308946,
0.367764771,
-0.6084259748,
-0.0827963352,
0.0546574704,
0.2790933251,
0.229630813,
0.2825312614,
-0.2294198275,
0.41352126,
0.6824685335,
0.84102422,
-0.3530787826,
-0.6681069136,
-0.4455632567,
0.3912644982,
-0.464879781,
0.6336951256,
-0.6646335721,
-0.3412304819,
0.1332994848,
-0.5420899391,
0.2710565329,
-0.4949974716,
0.9191006422,
-0.8156975508,
-0.4066982567,
0.2159405649,
-0.4773842096,
-0.3237085044,
0.613201201,
-0.6885608435,
0.7321426868,
-0.0167579539,
-0.6050570607,
0.2866531014,
-0.6383018494,
-0.5030798316,
-0.0086286301,
-0.2082845867,
-0.5330283046,
-0.3149348199,
0.2599102855,
0.1426977068,
-0.4084016085,
0.1665401161,
-0.3278220594,
-0.4492848814,
0.7591999173,
-0.8164306879,
0.5562371612,
0.2291878313,
-0.5084789395,
0.1515035927,
-0.574265182,
0.1214340404,
-0.0951439738,
-0.2183570117,
-0.2627145648,
-0.1725003123,
0.125884369,
0.2178758681,
0.7137207389,
-0.4827323854,
-0.3513257802,
-0.2863446474,
0.2414627075,
0.9846230745,
-0.1412501186,
0.2822235525,
-0.6493902206,
0.7222140431,
0.2919651568,
0.2683186233,
0.4309594333,
-0.5006170869,
-0.5627362132,
-0.1607201993,
0.4077676237,
0.5184897184,
-0.3959348202,
0.4217843413,
-0.0306866188,
-0.7857340574,
-0.724473238,
0.1920961887,
0.6422198415,
0.1075368971,
0.2493587136,
-0.4605107903,
-0.1360258013,
-1.1445156336,
-0.5468229651,
-0.3934011161,
0.3456785381,
0.4932413697,
0.6245996952,
-0.3920504153,
0.5587837696,
-0.0662970915,
-0.3725364208,
0.0167572629,
0.0194800403,
-0.0654657111,
0.4166842699,
0.5333129764,
-0.718035996,
-0.7540442348,
0.0649625212,
-0.5492935777,
0.3276785016,
0.3412776589,
-0.1889160722,
0.5409585238,
0.3102303743,
-0.7970725298,
0.5212672949,
0.9190731049,
-0.6185036302,
0.6133208871,
-0.0428990722,
0.2198559046,
-0.913534224,
0.2856378853,
-0.0706623495,
-0.2675468028,
-0.1795315593,
0.3379963636,
-0.206086129,
0.164402768,
-0.5945985913,
0.6789988875,
-0.2276094705,
-0.1481120586,
-0.2181790769,
-0.0557257868,
-0.3210321963,
-0.0774838701,
-0.4531375766,
1.395126462,
0.7680923939,
-0.5961741805,
0.1646209359,
0.2922737598,
-0.7090367079,
0.3770741224,
-0.7316992283,
0.3155752122,
0.2644760907,
0.1982091963,
-0.6466757059,
0.019300472,
0.3737404048,
-0.4689154029,
-0.1164944544,
0.012822629,
-0.5677091479,
0.2256958634,
-0.2433965802,
0.6482202411,
0.5726549029,
-0.3031253219,
0.8098386526,
0.5605493784,
-0.1537271887,
-0.8839993477,
-0.3297827542,
0.2324977815,
-0.4040639102,
-0.6504042149,
0.0873744562,
-0.1528784037,
-0.5451598167,
0.1342494488,
-0.3158983886,
-0.1845425516,
0.5363250971,
0.5553943515,
0.1110497266,
0.0383163951,
-0.3872885406,
0.0488414094,
-0.4334445,
0.38417992,
-0.1339617819,
0.442876637,
-0.6722159982,
-0.3812167048,
-0.4981160164,
0.3806937933,
0.6246498823,
-0.453676641,
1.1049773693,
0.6109526157,
-0.2772602141,
0.0153955268,
-0.5309848189,
0.0334973708,
-0.5316517949,
0.3228149414,
-0.2399809957,
-1.1643215418,
0.3419731557,
-0.3751030564,
-0.1274838597,
0.4116832912,
0.6550397873,
-0.0155767743,
1.0157505274,
0.4388177693,
-0.6661079526,
-0.252905041,
0.3199014664,
0.2137950957,
-0.4536830485,
-0.1682462543,
-0.5539896488,
-0.1388015151,
-0.827876687,
-0.1231276542,
0.6412727833,
-0.1134433076,
-0.5443049073,
0.0245874878,
0.0299472809,
0.4788018167,
0.6382490396,
0.0550563596,
0.5486215353,
0.0877401382,
-0.2101849467,
0.3153233528,
-0.2103369236,
-1.1311706305,
1.2504789829,
0.5037097335,
0.6873149872,
0.6399790049,
0.8316082954,
0.6969182491,
0.3471891582,
-0.3305674195,
0.6472831368,
0.0038520421,
-0.5461452007,
-0.3637237549,
-0.317861706,
-0.9351004362,
-0.2295543849,
-0.2204372287,
-0.692645967,
-0.4997732043,
0.0807279572,
-0.374586612,
0.0557493903,
-0.3388290107,
0.5064530969,
-0.3271708786,
-0.3420902491,
-0.5273444653,
-0.5499679446,
0.2790705264,
-0.2216021717,
0.2645225823,
-0.2626725733,
-0.396528393,
0.7707182765,
-0.2096612453,
0.4280970991,
0.2027140856,
-0.0536166988,
0.2961517274,
0.3993361294,
0.5746830106,
0.1318430603,
-0.1665607095,
0.7105461359,
0.0142379627,
-0.3294096589,
-0.3822919428,
0.9352809787,
-1.3287591934,
-0.68005687,
-0.9382781386,
-0.4995807111,
-0.513520956,
0.2649917006,
-0.1583249569,
-0.0803989917,
-0.3379805684,
-0.0203782097,
0.4180781841,
-0.180440411,
0.3126356602,
0.6424536705,
-0.0235446449,
-0.2996526659,
0.6047635078,
-0.3376467824,
-0.0923479274,
-0.0567481555,
0.0836571604,
-0.3525272608,
-0.9353510141,
-0.5452284813,
-0.0292579774,
-0.5103634,
-0.2883449495,
-0.2153092921,
-0.4779088497,
-0.1053369269,
0.0043845586,
-0.4928428233,
-0.1776125729,
0.1267616451,
-0.1360029429,
0.4766522944,
0.8554540277,
0.0281009935,
0.0533427298,
-1.0266001225,
0.1475424021,
0.0626464114,
0.7325660586,
0.0566596091,
-0.4305459857,
-0.3929212391,
-0.1807612926,
-0.2462752759,
-0.5783734322,
0.0701175183,
-0.0372689664,
0.5196807384,
0.465100199,
0.0766142905,
0.3195893764,
-0.7462690473,
0.6668146849,
0.0040654093,
-1.0434869528,
0.1661292017,
-0.0649421811,
-0.1380010545,
0.800440371,
0.7987191081,
-0.1761565059,
-0.3150343299,
-0.5525182486,
-0.8689983487,
0.2808754444,
0.6255625486,
-0.1130898073,
0.0881763697,
0.333119303,
0.1916937977,
0.2302893549,
-0.6124979854,
-0.5745873451,
0.087839283,
-0.1830095053,
-0.1262635142,
-0.4466778934,
-0.3730973899,
0.1847491413,
0.8647996783,
0.2229151726,
0.0212754961,
0.0100335134,
-0.1126790792,
-0.1477981508,
0.4687433243,
0.4994585216,
0.6834664345,
-0.1105257049,
0.1808935106,
0.084224239,
-0.7755500078,
0.5357844234,
0.2477249056,
-0.2400924861,
-0.4913736284,
0.4836307764,
0.3685353398,
-0.2995720506,
-0.8503193259,
0.4763329923,
-0.0635227114,
-0.0992686674,
-0.8183755875,
0.2541618049,
0.0410188995,
0.3425533473,
0.2264840901,
0.0885740668,
0.3428934813,
-0.446292907,
0.2862252295,
0.4963808656,
-0.2968152463,
0.2171114683,
0.4396959841,
0.1680661142,
-0.2873572707,
0.6391916871,
-0.0318528712,
-0.5007577538,
0.5265036821,
0.2670137882,
0.930177629,
-0.277955085,
0.0612575039,
0.1099633723,
0.6556332111,
0.1312411726,
0.3343585134,
0.1780701131,
-0.9094715118,
-0.1092455834,
-0.6594801545,
-0.7949184179,
0.0380842909,
-0.5264927149,
-0.4400769472,
-0.648039341,
-0.3476497829,
-0.4674325883,
0.2651126087,
-0.5997974277,
0.2838038206,
0.1179873198,
1.0294148922,
-0.6574149132,
0.6995594501,
0.8634904623,
-0.2387442738,
-0.8747720122,
0.1069446653,
-0.2300370485,
-1.1876531839,
0.3932064772,
0.2413837314,
-0.6407113671,
-0.2122496963,
-0.644564271,
-0.9817959666,
1.1811816692,
0.3583628237,
-0.4962317944,
0.3657027781,
0.6018418074,
0.3840551972,
-0.2128583938,
0.3385838568,
0.6057494283,
0.6367791891,
-0.3166832328,
-0.9070115089,
0.2272326052,
-0.3176887631,
-0.0977228805,
0.0045970078,
-0.8894135356,
0.630938828,
-0.0102857696,
0.0884412602,
0.4573637843,
0.620152235,
0.8299220204,
0.4886330068,
0.5793722272,
0.6764567494,
0.4859892726,
0.2320377082,
1.1845183372,
-0.8230082393,
-0.0644439608,
0.9166409373,
-0.5202869773,
0.9863782525,
0.4091180563,
-0.2263812721,
0.6781207323,
0.3233785033,
0.2786030173,
0.5263845325,
0.1764608324,
-0.3828866184,
-0.403807044,
-0.3656733036,
-0.4266239405,
0.7719713449,
0.0798365846,
-0.3452995718,
0.0132378237,
-0.4456483722,
0.2529189885,
0.1661296189,
-0.2777580917,
0.6012023091,
0.3016044497,
-0.5898020267,
0.0616653897,
0.4286901653,
0.3281777203,
-0.7993139625,
-0.1379194558,
-0.1417895705,
0.2749243677,
0.0189361926,
-0.8805750608,
0.1022908837,
0.1964445561,
0.2251202166,
0.1293996423,
0.5176922679,
-0.0100696469,
-0.5647671819,
0.4180344045,
0.5060879588,
0.255551964,
-0.1671872735,
-0.8080464602,
0.3147890568,
-0.3044856787,
-0.052109722,
0.6033773422,
0.1439399272,
-0.1342741251,
1.0379565954,
0.7836018205,
0.141826883,
-0.2891018987,
-0.1867244989,
0.6932179928,
-0.6456519961,
-0.5216193199,
-1.0859365463,
0.1340520382,
0.0995115712,
-0.4627699256,
0.9719599485,
0.5088967681,
0.6679018736,
0.2245269418,
0.9107474685,
0.4446259141,
0.232835114,
-0.5139511824,
1.26712358,
-0.4235705137,
0.1415846646,
-0.2491506636,
-0.8429085016,
0.0697705522,
0.6789523363,
-0.0513541363,
0.3633396626,
0.6337836385,
0.6096977592,
0.2011796683,
0.0885852873,
0.3177061677,
0.2497713715,
0.1393650621,
0.6639742255,
1.0052815676,
-0.4352498353,
0.6901373267,
-0.2053492516,
-0.2296082675,
0.0740904212,
-1.0189297199,
-0.9471469522,
-0.286605984,
-0.2979997694,
-0.5527074337,
0.439943701,
0.9006783366,
0.4724271595,
-0.9856572151,
-0.3481860459,
0.09224049,
-0.0204478186,
-0.1595432162,
-0.054739669,
0.662335217,
0.2688184679,
-0.3626061678,
0.2582912147,
0.2003064603,
0.0831959173,
-0.2869567871,
-0.5524291396,
0.0115669407,
0.2566824257,
0.3459904194,
-0.0393938906,
-0.7551516294,
-0.3407626152,
-0.2666065991,
-0.2418334186,
-0.2423834354,
0.3362955153,
-0.6501976848,
-0.1754969507,
-0.2306802571,
0.9423988461,
0.0458641052,
-0.0625165775,
0.4259770215,
0.0034832458,
-0.0568735823,
0.3029721379,
0.3977387547,
0.157848835,
-0.2473630011,
0.4943324327,
-0.4185342789,
-0.7120352983,
-0.4170747101,
0.3832084239,
-0.9590311646,
0.0703104213,
1.1105970144,
-0.3464727104,
-0.1378017813,
-0.3239452541,
-0.0950771198,
0.1245697066,
-0.6305077672,
1.1076340675,
0.8435249925,
0.1081927568,
0.0709115118,
-0.2358733714,
0.4991250336,
0.6890684962,
-0.7216622233,
-0.344070673,
0.2177544087,
0.2221487314,
0.0721494928,
0.4401920438,
-0.155560568,
0.5779846907,
0.0337440819,
-0.2581109405,
-0.2440480292,
-0.4165363312,
-0.0565013811,
0.3501035273,
0.740855217,
-0.0610691309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09747v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09747v1
|
Re-Search for The Truth: Multi-round Retrieval-augmented Large Language Models are Strong Fake News Detectors
| 2024-03-14T00:35:39 | 2024-03-14T00:35:39 |
Guanghua Li, Wensheng Lu, Wei Zhang, Defu Lian, Kezhong Lu, Rui Mao, Kai Shu, Hao Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The proliferation of fake news has had far-reaching implications on politics,
the economy, and society at large. While Fake news detection methods have been
employed to mitigate this issue, they primarily depend on two essential
elements: the quality and relevance of the evidence, and the effectiveness of
the verdict prediction mechanism. Traditional methods, which often source
information from static repositories like Wikipedia, are limited by outdated or
incomplete data, particularly for emerging or rare claims. Large Language
Models (LLMs), known for their remarkable reasoning and generative
capabilities, introduce a new frontier for fake news detection. However, like
traditional methods, LLM-based solutions also grapple with the limitations of
stale and long-tail knowledge. Additionally, retrieval-enhanced LLMs frequently
struggle with issues such as low-quality evidence retrieval and context length
constraints. To address these challenges, we introduce a novel,
retrieval-augmented LLMs framework--the first of its kind to automatically and
strategically extract key evidence from web sources for claim verification.
Employing a multi-round retrieval strategy, our framework ensures the
acquisition of sufficient, relevant evidence, thereby enhancing performance.
Comprehensive experiments across three real-world datasets validate the
framework's superiority over existing methods. Importantly, our model not only
delivers accurate verdicts but also offers human-readable explanations to
improve result interpretability.
|
[
-0.192175597,
-0.9196628928,
0.9888371825,
-0.0474209711,
-0.2325829118,
0.1914013028,
-0.0268689003,
-0.4041145146,
0.3774339855,
0.4863522649,
-0.3499923944,
-0.4203922749,
-0.6681925058,
0.1050228179,
-0.6457111239,
0.6096575856,
0.0901706889,
-0.0165613033,
-0.1232503057,
0.0029166662,
-0.0391319245,
-0.5549680591,
-0.2211729586,
-0.2232469618,
0.602241993,
0.4247369766,
0.612823844,
0.5953993797,
0.2639128268,
0.2266777605,
0.0684948489,
0.5791600943,
-0.4907595217,
-0.1637327373,
-0.2578876615,
-0.4736218452,
-0.1407041103,
0.3181980252,
0.563195765,
0.2714327872,
-0.3601857424,
0.1314845979,
-0.4852301478,
0.5732549429,
-0.7831788659,
-0.1376382709,
-0.9888975024,
-0.0901806056,
-0.3019524515,
-0.2774222493,
-0.5952621698,
-0.4787305892,
0.0258851536,
-0.656000793,
0.4206879735,
0.2308252156,
1.0110934973,
-0.05877259,
-0.8585904837,
-0.3706311285,
-0.4174150527,
0.7141577005,
-0.8046781421,
0.5802537799,
0.182664454,
0.4581978321,
-0.4080094695,
-0.8005065918,
-0.9488840103,
-0.3420359492,
0.029330425,
-0.1345651448,
-0.0348099656,
-0.1974299848,
0.1512963325,
0.5082945824,
-0.5380735993,
-0.034358874,
-0.3291447759,
-0.7097408175,
0.4821190238,
-0.228951484,
0.3919650018,
-0.3136447668,
-0.4046323597,
0.101024881,
-0.9161016345,
-0.3768154979,
0.4874089658,
0.4112100303,
0.1030602455,
0.7130538225,
-0.5029864311,
0.7395662665,
0.1476961076,
-0.4938912392,
0.2430320382,
-0.2382184863,
-0.0250464883,
0.1368757188,
0.617218554,
0.1506620049,
-0.0061611435,
0.0028701432,
-0.4321730733,
0.069651112,
0.3660255373,
-0.670542419,
-0.0175632294,
0.0866376311,
-0.604280293,
-0.431107223,
0.1021445692,
-0.7452107072,
-0.5246526599,
-0.3932671249,
0.6397464871,
-0.2124750763,
-0.4262849391,
0.2642475367,
-0.2520159781,
0.1340012401,
0.5085046887,
-0.3111402094,
-0.0104367072,
0.6303139329,
0.7830545306,
-0.0212397203,
-0.0028681827,
-0.9848356247,
-0.0132426796,
-0.5647749901,
0.9194779396,
-0.5415182114,
0.1410489082,
0.298489958,
0.0640525222,
0.5512038469,
-0.6090276837,
0.8158375621,
-1.0339536667,
0.3982578218,
-0.3531902134,
-0.5863628387,
-0.3215353191,
0.5925422907,
-0.8917179704,
0.9609795809,
-0.1293837279,
-0.5356281996,
0.5638273358,
-0.3199578822,
-0.5171227455,
-0.1000593007,
-0.0915953368,
-0.3936831653,
0.3607419729,
0.4115963876,
0.2376061529,
-0.178649947,
0.2931784689,
-0.4586454332,
-0.2655238211,
0.0656889379,
-0.6919827461,
0.529099226,
0.1055614501,
-0.2371870577,
-0.0479205139,
-0.8396671414,
-0.121643737,
0.3333752155,
-0.5753030777,
-0.2652701437,
-0.0110848462,
-0.0973887295,
0.291615814,
0.2370708585,
-0.8028388023,
0.226008445,
-0.2849776149,
0.290237695,
0.7512389421,
-0.0992873609,
0.1285440624,
-0.3454826772,
0.2342974693,
0.1418379694,
0.0136498539,
-0.311534822,
-0.2652354836,
-0.6280946732,
-0.2434506565,
0.4675201774,
0.4679707587,
-0.9940065742,
0.2112286091,
-0.434625417,
-0.250426501,
-0.5383081436,
0.0609817393,
0.1491471827,
0.3535271287,
0.5027184486,
0.0231188815,
-0.6545112133,
-0.9497122765,
-0.7184408307,
-0.008306236,
0.0036996044,
0.0300183129,
0.7013052702,
-0.053560894,
1.062887907,
-0.3720340431,
-0.1891935915,
-0.0731254593,
0.0065841153,
0.3298033178,
-0.0171980057,
0.1778086424,
-1.2530406713,
-0.249505043,
-0.2071850002,
-0.827671349,
-0.0348086245,
-0.1307964027,
0.0996227935,
0.3723341823,
0.3884079754,
-0.8052116632,
0.5628055334,
0.4535956383,
-0.1950390935,
0.9084520936,
-0.0239506774,
0.3275628686,
-0.758257091,
-0.0901543796,
0.049412407,
-0.6546456814,
-0.415643543,
0.0474788137,
0.2601681054,
0.109621875,
-0.5108932257,
0.7836731076,
-0.548376143,
-0.1565120816,
-0.5381104946,
0.371066004,
0.3277416229,
0.1787375957,
-0.1164886653,
0.7474336624,
0.0506152511,
-0.5145392418,
0.6206525564,
-0.0441361293,
-0.5723846555,
0.6877347827,
-0.5466447473,
-0.0015043716,
-0.2141992152,
0.6710058451,
-0.7929082513,
-0.4679478705,
0.0690658689,
-0.6244687438,
0.2315718383,
-0.1789342463,
-0.9240353703,
-0.4738392234,
-0.2809936404,
0.1821482927,
0.2004066706,
-1.0652163029,
0.8230947256,
0.489043355,
0.203404963,
-0.8746687174,
-0.4727321267,
0.4017556608,
-0.033053536,
-0.5782696605,
0.419799298,
0.128902927,
-0.3014011383,
-0.0599585921,
-0.4127300382,
0.0493185259,
-0.1906740069,
-0.0818144381,
0.0879065767,
-0.1207610965,
0.1857830733,
-0.0419882163,
0.0633646697,
-0.0536636226,
-0.300593257,
0.3340306282,
-0.0118137645,
-0.5913197398,
-0.5424121022,
0.3026307225,
0.7839343548,
-0.1003255099,
0.7768833041,
0.590128541,
-0.7330781817,
-0.1849412173,
-1.2819919586,
-0.2867945135,
-0.465297997,
0.2497953773,
-0.3836363852,
-0.9250205755,
0.3011696637,
-0.2672113478,
-0.0181349702,
0.4727217257,
0.5315305591,
0.2403591275,
1.0337049961,
0.4651449621,
-0.1746422797,
0.3024438024,
0.1483665258,
0.3418998122,
-0.4721761048,
-0.2802605629,
-0.2814888358,
0.0341401696,
-0.1945033371,
-0.4825630188,
0.3322333395,
0.1623468846,
-0.1773594469,
-0.0303285867,
-0.3950721025,
0.6035417318,
0.5196250677,
0.3527055681,
0.7125177383,
0.2622277141,
-0.0886250883,
0.0014904951,
-0.5567843318,
-0.5280649662,
1.1841307878,
0.3818505704,
0.4770248532,
0.3889057636,
0.3972985744,
0.737006247,
0.5895097256,
-0.5560257435,
0.4504730701,
0.0153614255,
-1.0061664581,
-0.080736883,
-0.5767502785,
-0.6148601174,
0.5261751413,
-0.2273597419,
-0.3096688986,
0.0384845734,
0.0720701218,
-0.3145653903,
0.4860554636,
-0.5127286911,
0.4801009297,
-0.4109366536,
-0.3777633905,
-0.4813753963,
-0.3869624734,
0.6815306544,
-0.226286456,
0.4579610527,
-0.1644409001,
-0.1128235608,
0.3551040888,
-0.4045076966,
0.805482924,
-0.1896682978,
-0.2535535395,
0.3010397851,
0.1318800896,
0.8781568408,
0.2256521285,
-0.0567700788,
0.1390971839,
-0.159915641,
-0.507098496,
-0.4888292849,
0.8366481662,
-0.3659809828,
-0.7756840587,
-0.6128150225,
-0.2704277337,
-0.0109301116,
0.4243925512,
0.0893024206,
0.2473890185,
-0.3075224459,
0.198405847,
0.895582974,
-0.441819638,
0.0737864226,
0.8077600598,
-0.5784848332,
-0.4394070506,
0.8464906216,
0.1306448728,
0.0614745952,
0.2835301161,
0.1429985613,
-0.5987671614,
-0.4516657889,
-0.5967707038,
0.2669271529,
-0.6724131107,
-0.3727849126,
-0.6448767185,
-0.0539250672,
-0.5265295506,
0.1900868863,
-0.4805395305,
-0.2383571267,
-0.1126008406,
-0.1630100608,
0.3210700154,
0.5663796663,
-0.3593294322,
0.1104644313,
-0.7239031196,
0.8870012164,
0.3576649725,
0.3783690929,
-0.2402947396,
-0.6625475287,
-0.1502534449,
0.3200620115,
-0.1691219658,
-0.9767377973,
0.461932838,
0.0066830227,
0.5949332118,
0.2533695102,
0.1820898354,
0.4849387407,
-0.5625107288,
0.7220039368,
0.0846443921,
-0.7989836335,
0.4473048151,
-0.4389073253,
-0.1675796509,
0.2214920968,
0.4111732244,
-0.4083818793,
0.0971199274,
-0.5321413279,
-0.6526882052,
0.4268262386,
-0.0566428304,
0.212602675,
-0.0946928114,
0.6255191565,
0.0677783266,
0.3892273307,
-0.942761004,
-0.0645625293,
-0.1828309,
-0.1522680521,
0.292542994,
-0.4720614552,
-0.236342147,
-0.0745870322,
0.8595557213,
-0.2653379738,
0.2234051377,
0.3939426541,
-0.4339557886,
-0.1527111828,
0.1637872905,
0.6398753524,
0.7296726704,
-0.0028790694,
0.1515591443,
0.1631528288,
-0.2407997251,
0.1772098988,
0.0601167753,
-0.173150748,
0.3285816312,
0.3111015856,
0.4679094851,
0.0919479802,
-0.7631755471,
0.7771769166,
0.1035219878,
-0.1446893662,
-0.7574477792,
-0.2685851455,
-0.0233847667,
0.3045453727,
1.0046474934,
-0.1665374637,
0.2337344438,
-0.660210669,
0.5292904377,
0.6075874567,
-0.0510881469,
-0.1333976984,
0.4912225902,
0.0389372148,
-0.2668602765,
0.579462409,
-0.2627554834,
-0.7745167613,
0.3748615086,
0.4651570618,
0.3068014979,
-0.024048049,
0.315861702,
0.1925182045,
0.4889683127,
-0.63355124,
0.1503825486,
0.4090025723,
-0.8313163519,
-0.7447214723,
-0.6638627052,
-0.1700818539,
0.4058966339,
-0.3581594825,
0.2474559247,
-0.3307739198,
-0.1300274134,
-0.1400604844,
0.1353161484,
-0.3590385914,
0.2057556957,
0.3143790066,
1.0913418531,
-0.6114481091,
0.6712431908,
0.2317692041,
-0.3247396648,
-0.3973474801,
0.07912983,
0.530102253,
-0.7634213567,
0.5029878616,
0.3759101033,
-0.0447271131,
-0.0344145261,
-0.8461095691,
-0.9120813608,
0.8322382569,
0.5580259562,
-0.6660591364,
-0.1513854563,
0.04806716,
0.3183191419,
-0.369448185,
0.0474592485,
0.3956724107,
0.6368147135,
0.0987133756,
-0.7639766932,
0.1114505529,
0.0116272476,
-0.153885901,
0.1446460932,
-0.6832283139,
0.7124538422,
-0.2823704183,
-0.1934413463,
-0.0461822562,
1.0308119059,
0.516201973,
0.4848787487,
0.4935158789,
0.7907754183,
0.8465082049,
-0.1203937307,
1.0806728601,
-0.2070214599,
0.3765912056,
1.0703192949,
-0.2823982239,
0.8868374228,
0.3754509389,
-0.0839505419,
0.7937552929,
0.5721772909,
-0.0102865966,
0.3021773398,
0.3658861816,
-0.3463165164,
-0.6180467606,
-0.129659757,
-0.2126614898,
0.2666421235,
0.4643352628,
-0.32569924,
-0.2594497502,
0.0425406396,
0.0820648223,
0.2875629067,
-0.3035184443,
0.2705002427,
0.0407497063,
-0.5194517374,
0.4862492681,
0.1635930389,
0.9359154701,
-0.3685164452,
-0.3129579425,
-0.185516715,
0.1952736527,
-0.2295122147,
-0.4800417721,
0.1589876115,
-0.1508261412,
-0.4442411363,
-0.014553925,
0.8977942467,
-0.4593645036,
-0.4967651367,
0.1423437446,
0.6576797366,
-0.0072379103,
-0.5357964635,
-0.6946992874,
0.2195154727,
-0.0789153427,
-0.5085399747,
0.273314774,
0.5165367126,
-0.0728326067,
0.8338973522,
1.1378388405,
0.0488213897,
0.1221547499,
-0.1272449642,
0.7555025816,
-0.4851004183,
-0.2210380137,
-0.7352991104,
0.2674785256,
-0.416187346,
0.1134415567,
0.7538542747,
0.7415020466,
0.7521389127,
0.1075623035,
0.8231391311,
0.105375126,
0.9743061662,
-0.6584196091,
0.65525949,
-0.8369881511,
0.3125165105,
0.1468235999,
-0.7873033285,
-0.3089591265,
0.5582288504,
-0.2173314542,
0.0950310156,
0.4715623558,
0.9315610528,
-0.1419973671,
-0.1305774152,
0.2861912847,
0.376793921,
0.4790688157,
0.2490154207,
0.8063607216,
-0.5508839488,
0.7550224066,
0.2088141292,
-0.0809509829,
-0.5071323514,
-0.9968358874,
-0.6440889239,
-0.3514110446,
-0.1960832626,
-0.760853529,
0.2251376063,
0.7935864329,
0.8630770445,
-0.6647886038,
0.2426727712,
0.0661901906,
0.2691966593,
0.0564163327,
-0.2722741961,
0.2893912196,
-0.2051827163,
-0.5559258461,
0.7434819937,
0.0758937597,
-0.0999761894,
-0.4193651974,
-0.0820814222,
-0.6048002839,
0.3499461412,
0.6442915797,
0.3505896628,
-1.0370196104,
-0.4990678728,
-0.0661060065,
-0.1925623417,
-0.0673059523,
0.786133945,
-1.1450983286,
0.3333534896,
0.3610144258,
0.6055933237,
0.5080720782,
0.0566893853,
0.5535778403,
-0.7825316191,
0.0149760153,
0.0816560313,
0.3667471409,
0.4310538471,
-0.3857445419,
0.4165326953,
0.6090227365,
-0.4284928739,
-1.1604560614,
0.3077820837,
-0.6602410078,
-0.4865794182,
1.1937208176,
0.0411984548,
-0.1167680025,
-0.2477788478,
-0.0325656533,
0.2561251521,
-0.4660654962,
1.0077915192,
0.8534944057,
0.3704040647,
-0.2694933116,
-0.7090290189,
0.4065170288,
0.1571531743,
-0.6554472446,
-0.0821149126,
0.9398762584,
0.5229291916,
0.3435098827,
0.4827694297,
-0.1743439138,
0.2780226171,
-0.1835692227,
0.0305479094,
-0.1260714084,
-0.4718382657,
-0.0771910846,
0.3408819735,
-0.2785595953,
0.1541576236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08994v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08994v2
|
Ethos: Rectifying Language Models in Orthogonal Parameter Space
| 2024-03-13T23:25:30 | 2024-04-01T05:45:47 |
Lei Gao, Yue Niu, Tingting Tang, Salman Avestimehr, Murali Annavaram
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) have greatly propelled the research on natural language
processing. However, LMs also raise concerns regarding the generation of biased
or toxic content and the potential disclosure of private information from the
training dataset. In this work, we present a new efficient approach, Ethos,
that rectifies LMs to mitigate toxicity and bias in outputs and avoid privacy
leakage. Ethos is built on task arithmetic. However, unlike current task
arithmetic algorithms, Ethos distinguishes general beneficial and undesired
knowledge when reconstructing task vectors. Specifically, Ethos first obtains a
set of principal components from the pre-trained models using singular value
decomposition. Then, by projecting the task vector onto principal components,
Ethos identifies the principal components that encode general or undesired
knowledge. Ethos performs negating using the task vector with undesired
knowledge only, thereby minimizing collateral damage on general model utility.
We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach on three different tasks:
debiasing, detoxification, and memorization unlearning. Evaluations show Ethos
is more effective in removing undesired knowledge and maintaining the overall
model performance compared to current task arithmetic methods.
|
[
-0.0790969431,
-0.8012185693,
0.5976013541,
0.0607367381,
-0.2713786662,
-0.026717823,
-0.4792806804,
-0.3846239746,
-0.0129451277,
0.6337084174,
-0.1543537378,
-0.588406086,
-0.7672227025,
-0.2742704749,
-0.1974875778,
1.075865984,
0.0457237922,
-0.0466523655,
-0.0561484769,
-0.1749090701,
-0.167678535,
-0.5427387953,
-0.9823254943,
-0.2753057778,
0.3205208182,
0.5167768002,
0.520780623,
0.7168754339,
0.1490747035,
0.3485909104,
-0.1203417704,
0.4597165585,
-0.922590673,
0.2676548362,
-0.3234541118,
-0.2037749887,
-0.4514514506,
-0.1553214043,
0.4751238823,
0.9405419827,
-0.3102206886,
0.287633419,
0.4811756909,
0.6693075895,
-0.7460185885,
0.4267354906,
-0.7202130556,
0.0693590939,
-0.1242936626,
-0.5583987236,
-0.6684505939,
-0.5443674326,
-0.0819298029,
-0.6743834615,
0.1328894198,
0.1481128782,
0.5543569326,
0.2693180144,
-0.2998811901,
-0.1073645949,
-1.1562843323,
1.2155821323,
-0.518990159,
0.4167729318,
0.5987299681,
0.3482316136,
0.0402471721,
-0.3470986485,
-0.5067871809,
-0.0828702971,
0.072960645,
-0.2598791718,
-0.1867920011,
0.0891912431,
-0.0715154633,
0.5002859831,
-0.2935564518,
0.0675671622,
-0.7359203696,
-0.3251129091,
0.402305305,
0.1711065024,
0.3643897474,
-0.0647451803,
-0.3290297687,
-0.0819320083,
-0.9767990112,
0.083397992,
0.4661055803,
0.2437342554,
0.1425064206,
0.5342689753,
-0.0780416429,
0.5288091898,
0.0641167313,
-0.138986215,
0.1060564369,
0.0950746983,
-0.4172123075,
-0.1321628243,
0.4929167926,
0.2447945774,
0.1150648892,
-0.2588518858,
0.0347782187,
0.0858964622,
0.5432496667,
-0.6186095476,
-0.0791873485,
0.2153398097,
-0.4267119169,
-0.3570829928,
-0.3200655282,
-0.6537178755,
-0.2782800198,
-0.4936112165,
0.424739033,
-0.6989476085,
-0.3105169535,
0.2680104077,
0.1076751053,
-0.2080928832,
0.4393002093,
-0.7113903165,
0.5201057196,
0.9814980626,
0.3972790539,
0.0125064366,
0.0697502047,
-0.5175755024,
0.2801943123,
-0.122302331,
0.3364265561,
-0.6995272636,
-0.204503268,
-0.0057658697,
-0.1252972037,
-0.0423044972,
-0.4468998909,
0.8795086145,
-0.5398693085,
0.4470358193,
-0.3069240749,
-0.6141370535,
-0.536341846,
0.1555627286,
-0.558639884,
0.956058085,
-0.1109485254,
-0.7245906591,
-0.0379914306,
-0.3839451969,
-0.2498703301,
-0.2569952011,
-0.2785455287,
-0.4301219583,
0.092267856,
0.1492366046,
0.5039970875,
-0.2585253417,
0.3346357346,
-0.2981035411,
-0.1907679588,
-0.2714695334,
-0.3617091477,
0.8574948907,
0.5112202764,
-0.3024738133,
-0.0222259481,
-0.9047443867,
0.0717459694,
0.156969592,
-0.4011468291,
-0.9086302519,
0.1762055159,
-0.2848335207,
0.0292074978,
-0.0246602912,
-0.8415795565,
-0.2087841034,
-0.6063528061,
0.2451230586,
0.8785802722,
0.0670311898,
0.6817359924,
-0.2761143446,
0.3861875534,
0.0157166049,
0.050591331,
0.0301953945,
-0.543564558,
-0.907740593,
-0.253809005,
-0.3397368193,
0.2682654858,
-0.7725700736,
0.2837972343,
-0.2744145691,
-0.4788173139,
-0.4422233701,
0.0564183779,
0.7962048054,
0.6735357642,
0.301346451,
-0.0450543165,
-0.4247287214,
-0.7320417762,
-0.5064530969,
-0.0634700805,
-0.2052890509,
0.2425466925,
0.1194611788,
0.2288725227,
0.5488622785,
-0.6008878946,
-0.374620527,
-0.1634919196,
0.1354871392,
0.1153756306,
0.4660968781,
0.4657974243,
-0.3329808414,
-0.4483394623,
0.0639193505,
-0.6172345877,
-0.2120792717,
0.2827085853,
-0.1028797105,
0.0698631629,
0.3367510438,
-0.3907718956,
0.1532716602,
0.3562235236,
-0.2352762371,
0.0611432754,
-0.3039267361,
0.1938119531,
-0.7969312072,
0.1153334752,
-0.1231177747,
-0.5103304386,
-0.8189726472,
0.353907764,
0.0170952212,
-0.3156841397,
-0.4413353503,
0.2965317667,
-0.4775448442,
0.3170699775,
-0.3322144747,
-0.0133932233,
0.2242584676,
0.9461182356,
0.0570179112,
0.2708666027,
0.3849764764,
-0.8810713887,
-0.1719104797,
-0.0258231498,
0.1775705069,
0.6268770099,
-0.5493936539,
0.5461554527,
-0.6365334392,
-0.0000699791,
-0.9307354689,
0.2763358355,
0.6225293875,
-0.415333271,
0.347637713,
-0.0376712792,
-0.1300680786,
0.0591506176,
-0.5648854375,
0.5992974639,
0.4602912664,
-0.4208544791,
0.6627006531,
0.8500145078,
-0.3382503986,
-0.6267203689,
-0.2743736804,
-0.3568589985,
-0.2647773027,
-0.3923726678,
0.4830789864,
0.2593860328,
-0.3168665767,
0.052563902,
-0.0240902156,
-0.2490153015,
-0.1076333374,
0.3406589031,
0.0239633657,
0.0378518626,
0.1843189895,
0.2841976583,
-0.2618797421,
0.2107702196,
-0.3441387713,
0.5531440377,
0.0199142005,
-0.4054502845,
-0.1136331186,
0.5850294232,
0.2248533517,
-0.1710836291,
0.8558721542,
0.3113699257,
-0.7386173606,
-0.4620312154,
-0.3677223921,
-0.1061411425,
-0.4550354481,
0.460023284,
-0.0187965874,
-0.784971714,
0.2867628634,
-0.051083751,
0.4920130372,
0.4634998739,
0.5389626026,
0.0927209333,
0.7212966084,
0.8094741702,
-0.2142357975,
0.0098672174,
-0.1452139914,
0.5120475292,
-0.5723901987,
-0.254461199,
-0.8136124015,
-0.143542707,
-0.1378257722,
-0.7081480026,
0.5045056343,
-0.0906487331,
-0.2915577292,
0.3767662644,
-0.6260070205,
0.4356565177,
0.3732998371,
0.3918905854,
0.6196555495,
0.1959916651,
-0.1117581502,
-0.3102934062,
-0.4679047763,
-0.6229180694,
1.3321585655,
0.7051804662,
0.6522634625,
0.2615152895,
0.6330627799,
0.2250623107,
0.356503129,
-0.3353175819,
0.6297501922,
-0.1225437969,
-0.5731788278,
-0.4753946364,
-0.5149983168,
-0.6940717101,
0.4604815543,
0.0402408503,
-0.7313266993,
0.1569813788,
0.4109230936,
-0.4438609183,
0.5739687681,
-0.441149801,
0.3247937262,
0.2274394929,
-0.4962781668,
-0.6958268881,
-0.3145044744,
0.3878747821,
0.1022561118,
0.4454142153,
-0.0312260911,
0.0924327299,
0.6573761702,
-0.5709878802,
1.0399787426,
-0.2941575646,
-0.4350123405,
0.1208449453,
0.227540344,
0.6731062531,
-0.1210640892,
-0.1725168377,
0.2641774118,
-0.1990227848,
-0.1418926269,
-0.3092787266,
0.732734859,
-0.6532682776,
-0.4094227552,
-0.2851938605,
-0.4512411952,
-0.2914824188,
0.0982420892,
0.3485830724,
0.3813085556,
-0.236728549,
0.0008749426,
0.8544812799,
-0.6969191432,
0.0957241356,
0.7163715363,
-0.2451792806,
-0.3094544411,
0.959961772,
-0.1108433232,
0.3464661837,
0.4452569783,
0.0567677729,
-0.1250229776,
-0.3524425328,
-0.1395113021,
-0.0045196107,
-0.89402771,
-0.1975678056,
-0.8539159298,
-0.2014831752,
-0.2138964236,
0.1397913843,
-0.5905703902,
-0.6992415786,
0.0283826012,
-0.3565906882,
0.2327923328,
0.5976005793,
-0.1720413715,
0.1070528924,
-0.6419200897,
0.5674652457,
0.1829670817,
0.3114395738,
0.200865224,
-0.6208713055,
-0.0264761616,
0.0938122943,
-0.5339468122,
-0.9833202362,
0.5368702412,
0.4445348978,
0.4761834741,
0.4709123671,
0.2957156897,
0.5326377749,
-0.693800211,
0.4124609828,
0.0142241465,
-0.8946487308,
0.2372676134,
-0.3112962544,
-0.3245631754,
0.4595182836,
0.3699437082,
-0.4848369658,
-0.8828325272,
-0.4761997163,
-1.0697517395,
0.7494850755,
0.3937985301,
0.2873283923,
-0.0556311533,
0.1733178347,
0.3976746798,
0.4424507022,
-0.7344875336,
-0.5225037932,
0.0848853961,
-0.2170188129,
0.2760643661,
-0.5040816665,
-0.089362964,
-0.4150652885,
0.8212642074,
0.3664889038,
0.3889038265,
0.0092752697,
-0.3106897175,
-0.3768629432,
0.4644857049,
0.329336077,
0.4956825376,
-0.1282504201,
0.4143539965,
-0.043163456,
-0.3641295135,
0.1213297471,
0.013181326,
-0.1862653345,
0.1322381198,
0.0615405403,
0.5205806494,
0.4577941,
-0.2367976457,
0.3988700211,
0.1664453447,
0.0207569171,
-0.3853020966,
0.0414930359,
0.0144925658,
-0.0923412666,
0.2036041319,
0.2454242855,
0.4715939164,
-0.5357701182,
0.1378914118,
0.1266135871,
-0.1531710327,
-0.3156639934,
0.8636101484,
0.4797367454,
-0.1171269417,
0.2450538725,
-0.1535724998,
-0.4419035316,
0.2928439081,
0.4099269807,
0.7112626433,
-0.5386537313,
0.2566934824,
0.4672375321,
0.2938967049,
0.13720195,
0.5755382776,
-0.1226852462,
-0.7836815119,
-0.3920483589,
-0.5340676308,
-0.2172896266,
0.236900419,
-0.7239935994,
-0.1821079701,
-0.683370769,
0.0310264342,
0.0176094808,
-0.4390120804,
-0.7346403003,
0.0134335849,
0.1250164658,
0.4907894433,
-0.9025467634,
0.7800195813,
0.3578885794,
-0.1974326074,
-0.9477232695,
-0.2034130991,
0.1377638578,
-0.9568892121,
0.5718138814,
0.0994237363,
-0.1953416914,
-0.0286270399,
-0.1490932107,
-0.5347902775,
0.543586731,
0.7606009245,
-0.6790997982,
0.3101031184,
0.6467633247,
0.4656763673,
0.0812602714,
0.1629717052,
0.2096586078,
0.3279130757,
-0.3425139189,
-0.934232235,
0.2590878606,
-0.5020310879,
-0.0157078616,
0.2751821876,
-0.1756596565,
0.9766580462,
-0.122592628,
-0.3565995395,
-0.2611457705,
0.4648913443,
0.3028324544,
0.1803971231,
0.6720348001,
0.6588121653,
0.8443647623,
0.0339930952,
0.8416195512,
-0.2813852131,
0.424554348,
1.0029779673,
-0.2420088649,
0.6593210101,
0.6496649384,
-0.2428629994,
0.2402981967,
0.0874716491,
0.7118037939,
0.7631854415,
0.2256025672,
-0.3202430606,
-0.1440231204,
-0.0799830332,
-0.46233356,
0.1518113762,
0.1465798467,
-0.6119884849,
-0.5970252156,
0.1040714011,
0.5455466509,
0.5493512154,
-0.3857404292,
0.570030272,
0.3571942449,
-0.7059395313,
0.5282270908,
0.5045167804,
0.4065541625,
-0.5173258781,
-0.2682246864,
-0.0664228871,
0.6319832206,
-0.0805196464,
-0.4714618027,
0.7693347931,
0.0615099967,
-0.1283615977,
-0.5938200355,
0.9072306752,
-0.6895424128,
-0.4562358558,
0.3124687076,
0.2597185969,
-0.0349674188,
-0.4835632145,
-0.3276934326,
-0.0552777313,
0.013020196,
-0.0951555818,
0.2415694892,
0.4766584933,
0.073369354,
0.549382627,
0.528308928,
0.0003382723,
0.0241896138,
-0.0164504852,
1.0019141436,
-0.4641418457,
-0.705117166,
-0.8558852077,
0.5043266416,
-0.1993472129,
-0.1266299188,
0.8271321654,
0.3140342832,
0.6937761903,
-0.1551641524,
0.7103444934,
0.1177954599,
0.8432067633,
-0.4502002299,
0.6648501754,
-0.2536440194,
0.6923778057,
-0.2335185558,
-0.6726319194,
-0.0913318545,
0.6036337018,
-0.2623282671,
-0.1456657201,
0.6330049038,
0.5914591551,
-0.1749561876,
0.2293815017,
0.0761388913,
0.1659090072,
0.3145281076,
0.8534499407,
0.649854064,
-0.2966266572,
0.3828355968,
-0.5147507787,
-0.2723556459,
-0.0471034907,
-0.856320858,
-0.6486153603,
-0.408024013,
-0.221330449,
-0.0645087659,
0.2782077491,
0.833286345,
0.6712046862,
-0.9347679019,
0.0314655304,
-0.0259134732,
0.1248016059,
-0.4444601536,
-0.2115486413,
0.4311756492,
-0.1082822233,
-0.7311193347,
0.2874379456,
0.3853857815,
-0.6898018122,
-0.3559158742,
-0.197180748,
0.3578169346,
0.0760233104,
0.6606633663,
0.2878475189,
-0.422450453,
-0.4136483073,
-0.1650522202,
-0.1693346947,
-0.0498566069,
0.7014196515,
-0.5368009806,
0.2221785486,
0.58390522,
0.6854653955,
0.0645906329,
-0.2254083306,
1.0128802061,
-1.0112261772,
0.3549671173,
0.3211928308,
0.5118045807,
0.2021965981,
-0.708404243,
0.3649134636,
-0.1589998454,
-0.3770720065,
-0.748889327,
0.1794070154,
-0.8022907376,
-0.2538932264,
1.1486896276,
-0.3838966489,
-0.2199110836,
-0.441226095,
-0.2237195373,
0.3032233119,
-0.3536478877,
1.0046561956,
0.2023790926,
0.3582127988,
0.1263047159,
-0.5927559137,
0.4644937217,
0.5451121926,
-0.7543666363,
0.150446102,
0.5701783895,
0.4463773966,
-0.0208523348,
0.9454146028,
-0.4991266429,
0.0254872274,
-0.4379680455,
0.1090111285,
-0.3865608573,
-0.3610858917,
-0.1424661726,
0.3921835721,
0.0157330539,
-0.5168091655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09744v1
|
Evaluating the Application of Large Language Models to Generate Feedback in Programming Education
| 2024-03-13T23:14:35 | 2024-03-13T23:14:35 |
Sven Jacobs, Steffen Jaschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC
|
This study investigates the application of large language models,
specifically GPT-4, to enhance programming education. The research outlines the
design of a web application that uses GPT-4 to provide feedback on programming
tasks, without giving away the solution. A web application for working on
programming tasks was developed for the study and evaluated with 51 students
over the course of one semester. The results show that most of the feedback
generated by GPT-4 effectively addressed code errors. However, challenges with
incorrect suggestions and hallucinated issues indicate the need for further
improvements.
|
[
-0.3232959509,
-0.7321830392,
0.6684289575,
0.4380953312,
0.0791004524,
0.1204982996,
-0.3367636502,
-0.4036431015,
-0.181339249,
0.104612954,
-0.3289193511,
-0.5003945827,
-0.3422290087,
0.1483730376,
-0.4692098796,
1.1793683767,
-0.0902594477,
0.3113600314,
0.0886036307,
0.4793471694,
-0.7323976159,
-0.7307425141,
-0.8987687826,
-0.1193371266,
0.3409056664,
0.4064406157,
0.5259398222,
-0.0104864864,
0.7700137496,
0.335534513,
0.6047512889,
-0.5300529003,
-0.5281662345,
-0.2918044627,
-0.5186353326,
-0.3656636178,
-0.585278511,
0.0941158384,
0.5112540722,
0.7379227281,
-0.3847271204,
0.1870639026,
0.1535080969,
0.61762923,
-0.3202040195,
0.4904933572,
-0.0873249248,
0.0251721554,
-0.1684562266,
-0.1611544043,
-0.3755961061,
-0.700558424,
0.2778257132,
-0.4616053402,
0.2115411907,
-0.3725109398,
0.5047368407,
0.0019931854,
-0.2012407184,
-0.6906502843,
-0.7672952414,
0.8252117634,
-0.978015542,
0.4611101151,
0.5100566149,
0.2920256853,
-0.0919302925,
-0.5187108517,
-0.5449754596,
-0.4560908675,
0.3473063409,
0.248370409,
0.0030543241,
0.2342065871,
0.4298606515,
0.4300569594,
-0.7392013669,
-0.0137037421,
-0.638251543,
-0.1152897701,
0.4619028568,
0.0830380097,
0.5125671625,
0.1467772722,
0.1658130288,
0.0804033875,
-0.6435090899,
-0.1965573579,
0.5850449204,
0.2059520185,
0.0163239576,
0.5040596724,
-0.094621256,
0.9114120603,
-0.1908287555,
-0.1265835017,
0.3020495176,
-0.2321995646,
-0.2186845243,
-0.54320544,
0.5148105025,
0.543555975,
0.255595237,
-0.2187855095,
-0.3695996404,
0.3705807328,
0.4582319558,
-0.8543148041,
-0.5027433634,
0.1732076555,
-0.4051397741,
-0.2358159125,
0.0361317173,
-0.9779834747,
-0.192184329,
-0.4186135828,
0.434307009,
-0.3120789528,
-0.4212306738,
0.1021484584,
-0.3182727396,
0.1499901414,
0.554952085,
-1.1653585434,
0.3918983042,
0.6088514328,
0.8851701617,
-0.2607843876,
-0.3308584094,
-0.1858123094,
0.0618393086,
-0.2514270544,
0.5384091735,
-0.8988707662,
-0.4943495691,
0.1310350746,
-0.1916969419,
0.1822104901,
-0.3233168721,
0.2620529532,
-0.4287434518,
0.2214796096,
-0.0614488013,
-0.7593126893,
-0.0777924582,
0.4749106765,
-0.5087140799,
0.6743842959,
0.6457047462,
-0.4998559654,
0.0603843965,
-1.0512025356,
-0.1594152749,
0.3529344797,
-0.2561133206,
-0.1654031277,
0.1828882545,
0.0704071745,
0.1645134091,
-0.0556952842,
0.1329469085,
-0.1685608625,
-0.5697068572,
0.0378763787,
-0.1542503238,
0.4607057869,
0.0929228589,
-0.7853247523,
0.1934684515,
-0.5125121474,
0.4669136703,
0.0447631069,
-0.8166699409,
-0.0742188841,
-0.3027649224,
0.0767792761,
0.0415718406,
0.1493926197,
-0.4690340757,
0.6969151497,
-0.191429615,
0.4760629833,
0.7121261358,
0.0119311549,
0.2956489921,
-0.0157132521,
1.1102753878,
-0.3595483005,
0.1284060925,
0.151190117,
-0.4928273261,
-0.5805583,
0.2826841176,
0.2613965869,
0.3059274852,
-0.9867163301,
-0.2416711301,
0.0109309191,
-0.4132947028,
-0.0839053988,
0.354799211,
0.4621140063,
-0.0435490049,
0.1775826067,
-0.5250622034,
-0.6188544035,
-0.5298102498,
-0.1371027827,
-0.0849914402,
-0.2268988192,
0.1135650128,
0.5578584075,
-0.5972900987,
0.6078270078,
-0.6133942604,
0.0508270785,
-0.3916461468,
0.1496178955,
0.1911184341,
0.5384455323,
0.6685204506,
-0.3743341267,
-0.6215407252,
-0.1207590848,
-0.5476056933,
-0.1588352919,
0.1438285708,
0.0178994052,
0.0391496532,
-0.0909550115,
-0.4704867005,
0.3183563948,
0.9675225019,
-0.2277970612,
0.8167683482,
-0.1553787738,
0.2593187392,
-0.6339470744,
-0.0367096364,
0.0830251351,
-0.1953021735,
-0.3345088661,
0.2398725152,
0.0652765036,
-0.6220865846,
0.124499321,
0.16080226,
-0.5753647089,
-0.0875537097,
-0.582541883,
0.2465230972,
-0.1761392653,
0.2804319263,
-0.0598064102,
0.8867357969,
0.4227684736,
-0.3382644355,
0.6214197874,
-0.0845957026,
-0.1690869331,
0.4352635145,
-0.5754349828,
0.6060417891,
0.2758048475,
0.2958364487,
-0.7146863937,
-0.5395763516,
-0.0403700285,
-0.495057106,
0.3364848197,
-0.2097296715,
-0.1325792074,
-1.1027625799,
-0.4667192101,
0.0872638375,
0.3562189639,
-0.3498129249,
0.1319397837,
0.3898310065,
-0.305749774,
-0.3645626903,
-0.3679544628,
0.109914735,
0.0992173478,
-0.3821452558,
-0.1647446901,
-0.3422225416,
-0.1501772106,
0.0308615975,
-0.0931112021,
-0.3317995071,
-0.1086803675,
0.1975444108,
0.2418008298,
-0.2784704864,
0.1286875904,
-0.3968342245,
0.1438212991,
0.2120986432,
-0.5612516403,
0.6155481935,
-0.4600178897,
-0.4620473683,
-0.630632937,
0.4019263685,
0.4376537204,
0.0286673754,
0.3150756955,
0.4093194902,
-0.2233554274,
-0.317568779,
-0.6088017225,
-0.2491646409,
-0.4793136418,
0.540261209,
-0.3400797546,
-1.0299954414,
0.0798282698,
-0.2228238881,
0.0244165752,
0.0200148933,
0.7287722826,
0.1643273979,
1.1919909716,
0.8732504249,
-0.2304326445,
0.6973027587,
-0.4156244695,
0.455962956,
-0.6456182003,
-0.0045985384,
-0.5728324652,
0.0342136361,
-0.2165931314,
-0.4027048051,
-0.1019199416,
0.0909543559,
-0.3609751463,
0.2300784737,
-0.6894881725,
0.6694004536,
0.6259276271,
0.061266765,
-0.0316541791,
-0.2583408058,
0.0652149841,
-0.0033426229,
-0.4278275371,
-0.5055736899,
1.2650763988,
0.309140563,
0.967505157,
0.5486530066,
0.6151715517,
0.3355464041,
0.709123373,
-0.7493103743,
0.3630056977,
0.1900116503,
-0.6622079015,
-0.4556429982,
-0.6238953471,
-0.6645051837,
0.1221401095,
0.2334330082,
-0.8949342966,
-0.3928376436,
0.3591222167,
-0.3446151912,
-0.0074008345,
-1.2917554379,
0.9920406342,
-0.3216112852,
-0.5580427051,
-0.3776361942,
-0.2118121237,
0.3885783851,
-0.2224708945,
0.2740901411,
0.2734696865,
0.5050898194,
0.7702956796,
-0.739776969,
0.9646962285,
-0.5500055552,
-0.326451391,
0.4397569001,
0.1134395078,
0.4862646163,
0.100580208,
-0.1431589872,
-0.1321756393,
0.0135520743,
-0.3463383019,
-0.8088248968,
1.1159837246,
-0.8285819888,
-0.8674220443,
-0.4367750585,
-0.639588356,
-0.4252449572,
0.2931010127,
-0.1780043393,
0.5464977622,
0.154295221,
0.0290711205,
0.1449502409,
-0.3427314162,
0.4590497911,
0.6439079046,
-0.6416195631,
-0.2552498579,
0.9423138499,
0.0035518801,
0.3154340684,
-0.1105581969,
0.32456249,
-0.2572621107,
-0.6351543069,
-0.7504906058,
0.1303127259,
-0.8191325068,
-0.159965679,
-0.2185121626,
0.0315942913,
-0.5897651315,
-0.2478971928,
-0.2231371701,
-0.3484116197,
0.3156012595,
-0.2273542434,
0.0312638059,
1.4613074064,
0.0825621858,
0.3950873017,
-0.8243845701,
-0.0664579272,
0.3337354958,
0.7333005071,
0.2912756801,
-0.1762288958,
-0.419709444,
0.0052330499,
-0.6522058249,
-1.0700103045,
0.1801746637,
0.0077114808,
0.4915061295,
0.2335141748,
-0.4827015698,
0.5177773237,
-0.477327913,
1.1978583336,
0.4452828169,
-1.324452281,
0.7735853791,
-0.6980545521,
0.7475767136,
0.1878523976,
0.427741766,
-0.3837477565,
-0.4592838883,
-0.289637357,
-0.5619770885,
0.6101184487,
0.1372096092,
0.2970494628,
-0.0806435123,
0.4137413502,
0.044758141,
0.3309578001,
-1.1052823067,
0.2483323663,
-0.5554479361,
-0.1194342151,
0.2550498843,
-0.3481401801,
0.1531791389,
-0.3651929498,
0.7579439282,
-0.1380687356,
0.3639461398,
-0.3222508132,
0.0933560356,
-0.0945893303,
0.3951450884,
0.7297115326,
1.3662662506,
0.0480154231,
0.070190087,
-0.0532002188,
-0.8312465549,
-0.030992372,
-0.2283223122,
0.0989677235,
-0.1451898664,
0.179083541,
0.4356803,
0.1178547516,
-0.658652246,
0.6752238274,
-0.1626126766,
-0.0047668484,
-0.2221194208,
0.0872676969,
0.1516588479,
0.1299781352,
0.2191635221,
-0.3335447609,
0.4887815118,
-0.7616809011,
0.0761381164,
0.3006210029,
-0.215627715,
-0.5228021145,
0.552633822,
0.5103254318,
-0.2961319685,
0.79783988,
-0.2383865863,
-0.8676906824,
0.4854887128,
1.1926800013,
0.5237576962,
-0.5831903219,
0.3159326017,
0.5769343972,
0.1486878991,
-0.1526812911,
0.4307163656,
0.0250174608,
-0.2262218446,
-0.7823672295,
-0.7213077545,
-0.6922752857,
0.2282194048,
-0.4135143757,
0.1956868768,
-0.5627288818,
-0.3806980848,
-0.0801931471,
-0.1079360768,
-0.680947125,
0.2593463957,
0.0105134062,
0.4054674208,
-0.6337046623,
1.0873681307,
0.9277099967,
-0.8640195727,
-1.4622894526,
-0.0658465549,
0.1522703469,
-0.399294138,
0.8982757926,
0.1977227926,
-0.1791602373,
0.1179118454,
-0.5432685614,
-0.8578342795,
0.4432801008,
0.238327682,
-0.7273736,
-0.0526409671,
0.1237147748,
0.6759789586,
0.0277345981,
0.4570632577,
0.434792161,
0.4587982297,
-0.1061622128,
-1.3061434031,
-0.1359256059,
-0.4713030756,
0.1989069879,
0.3879643381,
-0.4499525726,
0.8836048245,
-0.2257459313,
0.0228763036,
-0.0449957363,
0.3428195417,
-0.0954227,
-0.0604199804,
0.1956377774,
0.4447487593,
0.8608777523,
-0.0683527142,
1.2380744219,
-0.2451402694,
0.8082223535,
1.1627839804,
-0.2646640241,
0.7130753994,
0.3478360474,
-0.5675426126,
0.5262729526,
0.4092284143,
-0.1144570783,
0.3230210543,
0.708814919,
-0.2822182477,
0.2342223078,
0.3801939189,
-0.5526137352,
0.2502684593,
0.4060264826,
-0.0770424455,
-0.1161312163,
0.3344917595,
0.0993885398,
-0.0440087803,
-0.4515319467,
0.3822043538,
0.0727495477,
-0.7488241196,
0.4706446826,
0.0925776437,
0.5132613778,
-0.5171092749,
-0.4623633325,
-0.1876421422,
0.6061172485,
-0.5246047974,
-0.7038493752,
0.3241039515,
0.3575918972,
-0.171637699,
-0.0768051893,
0.3374861479,
-0.251891762,
-0.390679121,
0.2389355451,
0.1668211222,
0.3087384701,
0.1035127118,
-0.5056537986,
0.398978889,
0.181508407,
-0.2524963021,
0.2612005174,
0.3193718195,
-0.0744747818,
0.5393905044,
0.5772556067,
0.1845677346,
0.1848954856,
0.5202118754,
0.8304434419,
-0.4887011945,
-0.4403162599,
-0.7967321277,
0.0583988838,
-0.2710725665,
-0.132583037,
1.2939292192,
0.7241098285,
1.0226421356,
-0.4695453048,
1.2701476812,
-0.3715580106,
0.4791790545,
-0.3050512373,
0.4059425592,
-0.0186394211,
0.2997608483,
-0.701879859,
-1.3207521439,
-0.4523426592,
0.8749033809,
-0.7035445571,
0.4201566875,
0.9605323672,
0.4252097607,
0.0876664594,
0.2553030252,
0.3586913347,
0.129147768,
0.7284465432,
0.6254480481,
0.9606830478,
-0.0184430853,
0.3162564337,
-0.1746746898,
-0.533451736,
-0.2358216047,
-0.5092483163,
-1.0474977493,
-0.2318931669,
-0.2699573636,
-0.4631794989,
0.3281803429,
0.7168754935,
0.6226552129,
-0.8844784498,
-0.3869592249,
-0.1947927624,
-0.3353596628,
-0.1142537445,
-0.2599888444,
0.3311327398,
-0.5166255236,
-0.8065640926,
0.3680143654,
0.1779471487,
-0.1511496156,
-0.5775393844,
-0.0414579697,
0.1117811576,
-0.2261854112,
0.7864724398,
0.1173989177,
-0.5161751509,
-0.693246007,
-0.1458246708,
-0.0392829888,
-0.1557869762,
1.0836801529,
-0.3589628339,
0.5338202119,
0.2933932543,
0.7628601789,
0.5524796844,
0.0484353565,
0.8387593627,
-0.4485011697,
0.0675138608,
0.1640122533,
0.3262380064,
0.4336329997,
-0.4395048618,
0.7715210915,
0.202934429,
-0.9366677403,
-0.4478063285,
0.0167205315,
-0.6617946029,
-0.168131277,
1.1315153837,
-0.4088486433,
0.0917948633,
-0.1950651556,
-0.4519202113,
-0.0617055148,
-0.3872976899,
0.8943816423,
1.0562185049,
-0.4374625087,
-0.1218417138,
-1.136934042,
0.3750128448,
0.0960872024,
-1.0153539181,
-0.1676484644,
0.8975387812,
0.5823328495,
0.1186092943,
0.8733193874,
-0.1503462642,
0.3729864955,
0.2237097621,
0.358305037,
0.234279573,
-0.1786019504,
-0.1405863762,
0.2803371847,
0.5425723791,
0.1274704635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08978v1
|
AutoGuide: Automated Generation and Selection of State-Aware Guidelines for Large Language Model Agents
| 2024-03-13T22:06:03 | 2024-03-13T22:06:03 |
Yao Fu, Dong-Ki Kim, Jaekyeom Kim, Sungryull Sohn, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Kyunghoon Bae, Honglak Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The primary limitation of large language models (LLMs) is their restricted
understanding of the world. This poses significant difficulties for LLM-based
agents, particularly in domains where pre-trained LLMs lack sufficient
knowledge. In this paper, we introduce a novel framework, called AutoGuide,
that bridges the knowledge gap in pre-trained LLMs by leveraging implicit
knowledge in offline experiences. Specifically, AutoGuide effectively extracts
knowledge embedded in offline data by extracting a set of state-aware
guidelines. Importantly, each state-aware guideline is expressed in concise
natural language and follows a conditional structure, clearly describing the
state where it is applicable. As such, the resulting guidelines enable a
principled way to provide helpful knowledge pertinent to an agent's current
decision-making process. We show that our approach outperforms competitive
LLM-based baselines by a large margin in sequential decision-making benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5534697175,
-0.5253990293,
0.8603375554,
-0.1570269018,
-0.0232717451,
-0.0843430087,
-0.1304367036,
-0.2734626234,
0.0340847708,
0.3686817586,
-0.7092213035,
-0.4174178839,
-0.3633013964,
0.1981926113,
-0.2832449973,
0.9027352929,
-0.2695277929,
-0.0962218344,
-0.358269155,
0.2350900918,
-0.3166913092,
-0.1118002981,
-0.6570730209,
-0.5009465814,
0.3848319054,
0.2953042686,
0.609190762,
0.7561191916,
0.0794025362,
0.3509851992,
0.1852575839,
0.5001481771,
-0.4009357691,
0.3233882189,
-0.4072396755,
-0.4285775125,
-0.5549401045,
-0.0510223135,
0.4720934033,
0.4418436587,
-0.2156846672,
0.0681577623,
0.1774294972,
0.4933469594,
-0.6922076941,
0.5013259053,
-0.6779809594,
0.1142890304,
-0.0022044338,
-0.3096509576,
-0.2510703206,
-0.5009982586,
0.4692970812,
-1.082775116,
0.0282170121,
0.2575099766,
0.8827546835,
0.7904626727,
-0.4804975688,
-0.414902091,
-0.7056259513,
0.2836909294,
-0.4749000371,
0.4196996987,
0.5348562598,
0.5997763872,
-0.3844540417,
-0.7434306741,
-0.601256609,
-0.0802338198,
-0.2571903467,
0.0504845381,
-0.1885664761,
0.2424714416,
0.1339476556,
0.1388441473,
-0.4645387828,
0.007856857,
-0.103639096,
-0.1477347016,
0.4878180325,
0.0639251694,
0.0984778851,
-0.1222391352,
-0.1688382775,
0.0758932382,
-0.8635832071,
-0.1153502688,
0.2415566593,
0.049458161,
0.0725121498,
0.3077597618,
-0.2185847163,
0.8735987544,
0.4575500488,
-0.3538341522,
-0.0122301681,
-0.3278720379,
-0.3014015555,
0.1444931924,
0.549367249,
0.3277520537,
0.2875066102,
-0.245291099,
-0.3344891071,
-0.2567730248,
0.1357366294,
-0.7359495163,
-0.2463554591,
-0.0776707903,
-0.3260098398,
-0.0788553059,
-0.1977014244,
-0.6791692972,
-0.65669626,
-0.4493467808,
0.4073550701,
-0.0571023375,
-0.2177610844,
-0.1966769844,
-0.211890772,
0.4656114876,
0.4465311468,
-0.6355929375,
0.1857458651,
0.3496359885,
0.7840941548,
0.0085693412,
-0.1421469003,
-0.4319491982,
0.446708709,
-0.3059982955,
0.9330501556,
-0.6293612123,
-0.4557196796,
-0.0496189743,
0.129820779,
0.0798834711,
-0.2916029394,
0.1306191832,
-0.6184888482,
0.1347629875,
-0.318413049,
-0.5748023391,
-0.2991251349,
0.1746248752,
-0.5913206339,
0.9690853953,
0.1686099172,
-0.3629015982,
0.7699283957,
-0.5463399887,
-0.4836189151,
0.0503834821,
-0.4412445128,
-0.1569368094,
-0.3093777001,
0.3124662638,
0.3105309606,
-0.4936105609,
0.2380570173,
-0.4431429505,
0.0120443441,
-0.310018003,
-0.1625230163,
0.4843413234,
0.1812922955,
-0.5652191639,
0.1358983815,
-0.5266463161,
0.0448187776,
-0.0147269405,
-0.2940766811,
-0.4778395295,
0.3292563558,
-0.3973557353,
0.4893296957,
0.2605911195,
-0.3062405288,
0.3071221709,
-0.5156062841,
0.4648328722,
0.8586825132,
-0.0031091315,
0.7369585037,
-0.2550481856,
0.6459058523,
-0.2902054489,
0.3923628032,
-0.1821260005,
-0.2308718115,
-1.0219168663,
-0.207177639,
-0.0628781915,
0.4722061455,
-1.0065709352,
0.7719260454,
-0.0916846469,
-0.451772213,
-0.4311539233,
0.5120597482,
0.3140795827,
0.4818580747,
0.3551712036,
0.0926034227,
-0.6727733612,
-0.5776458979,
-0.0375117622,
-0.0889276117,
0.3425923884,
0.4911294878,
0.5554881096,
-0.4097059667,
1.4155811071,
-0.6364336014,
-0.7299649715,
-0.3131701946,
-0.1008428335,
-0.1005344242,
0.1419171542,
0.3096182942,
-0.689560771,
-0.6022294164,
-0.1513490826,
-0.9395411611,
-0.2195530832,
-0.1785439402,
-0.5059176683,
0.206503287,
0.8932748437,
-0.373241365,
0.4870980084,
0.3358818591,
-0.4418570399,
0.0264615975,
-0.7003518939,
-0.3433518708,
-1.0172822475,
-0.0051677437,
0.1497115046,
-0.5405717492,
-0.1983497739,
-0.4384112656,
0.012351254,
0.1396350116,
-0.1444606036,
0.9746811986,
-0.8689952493,
-0.1512361169,
-0.4366117418,
0.4296968579,
0.1046955436,
0.4277994037,
0.3291638494,
0.4836615324,
0.5377797484,
-0.7236915827,
0.5653674603,
0.4141648114,
-0.2697277069,
0.6387429237,
-0.4939422011,
-0.1207049489,
-0.3053414822,
0.7226364017,
-0.5930941105,
-0.0417318791,
0.2072776407,
-0.1049080268,
0.1626866609,
-0.4057374001,
-0.3857494891,
-0.2086501122,
0.0720384419,
0.2310857773,
0.5564636588,
-0.4280270934,
0.9724758267,
0.8049068451,
-0.1715945601,
-0.2759430707,
-0.2457924932,
-0.0377503075,
-0.0887222961,
-0.2976431251,
0.1200127825,
-0.1895391196,
-0.2340105027,
0.0769445747,
-0.0803128108,
-0.1181466281,
0.0833049342,
0.5353773236,
0.2434084117,
0.0281646755,
0.1337310821,
0.1191667765,
-0.1585993916,
0.1679241508,
-0.7759090066,
0.3212776482,
-0.0621300451,
-0.3137826324,
-0.1116051599,
0.1285319924,
0.4565271139,
-0.3375006914,
0.4856503904,
0.3324388266,
-0.3146220446,
-0.856808424,
-0.4721406102,
-0.1640034616,
-0.5666163564,
0.1452988535,
-0.176300779,
-0.5145249367,
0.1332745403,
-0.1856572926,
0.1635861844,
0.3086518049,
0.4203033149,
0.055840224,
1.1502282619,
0.9594057202,
0.0412434526,
0.4569590986,
-0.1676915139,
0.0986285955,
-0.626952529,
-0.4637714326,
-0.2353249937,
0.0244698729,
-0.518221736,
-0.431388855,
0.6881802082,
-0.0630153418,
-0.2022379637,
0.0955764204,
-0.3184934855,
0.5270149708,
0.3602455556,
0.0267187841,
0.3438581526,
-0.2946797609,
-0.3713699579,
0.3521715701,
-0.9369313717,
-0.4750968516,
1.0982371569,
0.1671953052,
0.9510599971,
0.0761216134,
0.3802903891,
0.616235733,
0.2580757439,
-0.737110734,
0.5337805748,
0.1434118301,
-0.7643995285,
-0.3877163529,
-0.3707223833,
-0.8261478543,
0.0406140052,
-0.3611209989,
-0.2720220089,
0.2464093864,
0.4642094672,
-0.6502997875,
0.1494592279,
-0.5475220084,
0.5459831953,
-0.5480008125,
-0.2564865053,
-0.0497007146,
-0.4627102017,
0.0254097115,
-0.5353827477,
0.2490090132,
-0.120169729,
-0.2258947194,
0.6530961394,
-0.7237595916,
0.7336245775,
-0.2557875216,
-0.3284211755,
0.1975621432,
0.0173753668,
0.7930512428,
0.0498087704,
0.0819701254,
-0.1496170759,
0.0059289811,
-0.0062886802,
-0.5308033824,
0.5943696499,
-0.6966032386,
-0.544549942,
-0.4959204495,
-0.278473407,
-0.3291468322,
0.4858337939,
0.2474423498,
0.5210515261,
-0.095221743,
-0.1920254827,
0.7366064787,
-0.3323262632,
0.5037654638,
1.1414593458,
-0.3090345263,
-0.2134353667,
0.8115875125,
0.2211928964,
0.1124424934,
0.2315649539,
0.1216573566,
-0.7243487239,
-0.2440954447,
-0.6352697611,
0.1574966758,
-1.0891314745,
-0.0351784043,
-0.4141854942,
-0.117643252,
-0.3294471204,
-0.3108642399,
-0.2639310956,
0.0323846899,
-0.1139483005,
-0.0637127906,
0.3592404425,
1.2064329386,
-0.2060004473,
0.0339189433,
-0.6100965738,
0.2563774586,
0.4411428571,
0.3497962654,
-0.0366596058,
-0.3797573447,
-0.3159458935,
-0.12639983,
0.0696926787,
-0.7653675675,
0.24996683,
0.5330511928,
1.0129716396,
0.6543061733,
0.4533825815,
0.6866160035,
-0.5933007598,
0.3138873577,
-0.0989197344,
-0.834472537,
0.6918053627,
-0.3184499443,
0.2408685535,
0.5855773091,
0.5812751651,
-0.2810018063,
-0.4149979353,
-0.314687252,
-0.9719097018,
0.7098696232,
0.0367032774,
-0.2382004261,
0.1557599306,
0.3621898293,
0.0981737599,
0.3245830536,
-0.5026848912,
-0.5134875774,
-0.2617875934,
-0.1932889074,
-0.0516975187,
0.1199631616,
-0.1479371637,
-0.2764607072,
0.7508270741,
-0.3557206988,
0.1450602561,
0.2970986962,
-0.6210446358,
-0.1052373052,
-0.0997973979,
0.3153856099,
0.9043523073,
-0.0960011035,
0.061962422,
0.3331174254,
-0.3226219714,
0.2312723547,
0.3933126032,
-0.3543089032,
-0.1253157407,
0.1356256604,
0.5886080861,
0.1955282986,
-0.6074207425,
0.4697671831,
-0.2914485931,
-0.0348823555,
-0.7490909696,
0.223364681,
-0.283706516,
0.4302777052,
0.2901014388,
-0.1180742458,
-0.0123712374,
-0.3332075179,
0.4400521517,
0.4792242348,
-0.4008772075,
-0.0393743701,
0.5343291163,
0.8414658904,
0.1227737814,
0.217126742,
-0.5214009285,
-0.4239093065,
0.3434886038,
0.2098173201,
0.7817348838,
0.067478992,
0.1353970915,
0.2419336587,
0.2596067488,
-0.2460282147,
0.0864327922,
-0.3686843216,
-0.5743929148,
-0.3215657175,
-0.6864387393,
-0.272336334,
0.0305744708,
-0.5611006618,
0.3525884449,
-0.7610227466,
-0.1938967109,
-0.2475542575,
-0.0517732836,
-0.7655278444,
0.2559764385,
0.4030279219,
0.9835455418,
-0.5761919022,
1.038243413,
0.6363216043,
-0.4061073661,
-1.0340272188,
0.1046503782,
0.2687219679,
-0.7949054837,
0.6637664437,
-0.0778741613,
-0.6275871992,
0.4224633574,
-0.1531926394,
-1.0779584646,
1.2350633144,
0.2281406969,
-0.5011293888,
-0.468537271,
-0.0383645296,
0.23992531,
-0.3684884012,
0.7392063141,
0.7034935951,
0.7235034704,
0.107354328,
-1.0324532986,
0.1818691939,
-0.3117024601,
-0.2834636569,
0.2267313004,
-0.5383988619,
0.6438826919,
-0.1600892395,
-0.2694901228,
-0.2324518263,
0.3810644448,
-0.1015090197,
0.0495537594,
0.8193490505,
0.3231801987,
0.8547407985,
0.0155962594,
0.7173198462,
-0.6465416551,
0.0751094967,
1.2077118158,
-0.4423877597,
0.6062074304,
-0.0614874847,
0.2579241693,
0.7381315827,
0.7493383884,
-0.0718204752,
0.6134677529,
0.0085633388,
-0.2198821306,
-0.6726448536,
-0.1028501466,
-0.4071348608,
0.5722686648,
0.2879562974,
-0.3649796844,
-0.5595296025,
-0.0156516265,
0.3366124332,
-0.2502864301,
-0.5790022016,
1.0590826273,
0.1369329095,
-1.0499492884,
0.5648426414,
-0.0315485634,
0.5996723175,
-0.9431516528,
-0.2326291203,
-0.1778778285,
0.3820716739,
-0.3415631354,
-0.6971709728,
0.0681885406,
0.1779002994,
-0.1822891533,
-0.5753288865,
0.7216722965,
-0.459877491,
-0.2511609495,
0.5083276033,
0.6509253979,
0.0081073614,
-0.0969056934,
-0.6920107007,
-0.3791214526,
-0.1044806316,
-0.1893667579,
0.0826563239,
0.4543438554,
-0.1996255368,
0.9589912891,
0.6279342771,
0.4013925493,
-0.0984202921,
-0.2613495886,
1.0382003784,
-0.5761226416,
-0.9024528265,
-0.8731998801,
0.1797155142,
-0.1412056386,
-0.1414828748,
0.8705410361,
0.3376562893,
0.8309547305,
0.4621729553,
1.2673569918,
-0.1020995453,
0.3635483086,
-0.6490379572,
1.1439307928,
-0.7486507893,
0.4227274954,
0.1188327596,
-0.7396365404,
0.3194056451,
0.7129710913,
-0.5732433796,
0.2395519614,
0.7158377171,
0.9771514535,
0.1223656088,
-0.4023444057,
0.1406996399,
0.1775800884,
0.321842283,
0.6805738807,
0.7894408703,
0.1199312061,
0.934599638,
0.1702170223,
-0.2151705921,
-0.18645446,
-1.1377002001,
-1.1754102707,
-0.6318593025,
-0.0325963609,
-0.2068258673,
0.1005650759,
1.2206121683,
1.1237852573,
-0.3933891952,
-0.1460934281,
-0.1987151057,
0.2188583165,
0.2940479517,
-0.1120225266,
0.1567635983,
-0.2631613314,
-0.4381156564,
0.6331093311,
0.2102818489,
0.0937909558,
-0.6513578892,
-0.536631465,
-0.0828688741,
0.3025029004,
0.331017524,
0.4619718492,
-0.4660338759,
0.2211719155,
-0.2553818524,
-0.2127400041,
-0.1890411973,
0.8375303149,
-1.026524663,
0.5913837552,
0.3656974435,
0.3190275133,
0.2797471881,
-0.0812104419,
1.1087037325,
-0.5144020319,
0.0827169269,
0.0678339526,
0.3364519477,
0.2328829616,
-0.2512211204,
0.2132103592,
0.1624939442,
-0.5022756457,
-0.4832199812,
0.271500349,
-0.4473856688,
-0.4615640044,
1.5977665186,
-0.3299261332,
-0.1924887896,
-0.6638528109,
-0.1434135735,
0.4538182914,
-0.5062563419,
0.5466974378,
0.2672798336,
0.0039971694,
-0.0264472403,
-0.6481325626,
1.2344659567,
-0.0099715116,
-1.1287000179,
-0.1280956119,
0.5658448339,
0.3500235081,
-0.275208503,
0.5914799571,
0.3974969089,
0.07399299,
-0.2363024652,
-0.1313940436,
-0.5018929243,
-0.4912943542,
-0.0749204457,
-0.2487903237,
0.2295611948,
0.1912008971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09743v1
|
The Human Factor in Detecting Errors of Large Language Models: A Systematic Literature Review and Future Research Directions
| 2024-03-13T21:39:39 | 2024-03-13T21:39:39 |
Christian A. Schiller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The launch of ChatGPT by OpenAI in November 2022 marked a pivotal moment for
Artificial Intelligence, introducing Large Language Models (LLMs) to the
mainstream and setting new records in user adoption. LLMs, particularly
ChatGPT, trained on extensive internet data, demonstrate remarkable
conversational capabilities across various domains, suggesting a significant
impact on the workforce. However, these models are susceptible to errors -
"hallucinations" and omissions, generating incorrect or incomplete information.
This poses risks especially in contexts where accuracy is crucial, such as
legal compliance, medicine or fine-grained process frameworks.
There are both technical and human solutions to cope with this isse. This
paper explores the human factors that enable users to detect errors in LLM
outputs, a critical component in mitigating risks associated with their use in
professional settings. Understanding these factors is essential for
organizations aiming to leverage LLM technology efficiently, guiding targeted
training and deployment strategies to enhance error detection by users. This
approach not only aims to optimize the use of LLMs but also to prevent
potential downstream issues stemming from reliance on inaccurate model
responses. The research emphasizes the balance between technological
advancement and human insight in maximizing the benefits of LLMs while
minimizing the risks, particularly in areas where precision is paramount.
This paper performs a systematic literature research on this research topic,
analyses and synthesizes the findings, and outlines future research directions.
Literature selection cut-off date is January 11th 2024.
|
[
-0.2838316262,
-0.777117908,
0.5858598948,
0.2075333893,
0.0578818694,
0.0510996804,
-0.3161598742,
-0.6743422151,
-0.1528179049,
0.6605799198,
-0.4917174876,
-0.2106369436,
-0.5831662416,
0.224893719,
-0.437420547,
0.5381858945,
-0.2295220345,
0.2631933689,
-0.0975146517,
-0.0356221944,
-0.4450625479,
-0.8435350657,
-0.7194338441,
-0.5842334032,
0.5872701406,
0.4113718867,
0.625176549,
0.2416271716,
0.7042250633,
0.245323807,
-0.0091879806,
0.3799295127,
-0.3450222611,
-0.0344661288,
0.0517144091,
-0.5035427809,
-0.6385377049,
-0.2192388028,
0.5590577126,
0.7956284285,
-0.2604797482,
-0.1069628,
0.3571679294,
0.7035952806,
-0.322978586,
0.4022533894,
-0.2997871041,
0.0749705881,
-0.3439429402,
-0.3314266801,
-0.3155781627,
-0.3783191144,
0.1893049479,
-0.2873114645,
0.3125910163,
0.2560261786,
0.6688327789,
0.2579065263,
-0.3559730649,
-0.4042059779,
-0.9527623057,
0.667108357,
-0.9235239029,
0.3386676013,
0.47129336,
0.1652487516,
-0.7242242694,
-0.3704161942,
-0.5816178918,
-0.1245311871,
-0.0863443762,
-0.1377696991,
-0.0027807616,
0.2008320838,
0.3574874401,
0.0317384712,
-0.5385154486,
0.3560207486,
-0.433773607,
-0.3594495654,
0.7420433164,
0.2353686541,
0.5208845139,
0.020539239,
0.1573607922,
-0.1130510941,
-0.8984251022,
-0.2965593338,
0.4849124551,
0.2632516921,
-0.0084238648,
0.5949035287,
-0.2053153962,
0.3587771952,
-0.2468139678,
-0.1583420038,
0.1972432137,
-0.2848063409,
-0.2248376608,
0.1677941829,
0.8288911581,
0.1579996645,
0.5201159716,
0.1226029247,
-0.3968985975,
-0.0825068951,
0.3171223998,
-0.6002283096,
-0.1132497787,
0.2038194835,
-0.2903925478,
-0.3418727517,
0.117761448,
-0.8077126741,
-0.8643871546,
-0.3442469239,
0.1552743167,
-0.1839169562,
-0.3023422658,
0.1152914986,
0.2940291464,
0.1910138726,
0.5759436488,
-0.7104471922,
0.2161915302,
0.6995170116,
0.766797781,
-0.055873286,
-0.3321136534,
-0.3174684942,
-0.1161638945,
-0.49212116,
0.5715326071,
-0.065458104,
-0.5328383446,
0.3862481117,
-0.0934676081,
-0.0038225055,
-0.5719515085,
0.827185154,
-0.4083305299,
0.2396099567,
-0.3635934889,
-0.4272965789,
-0.3310339749,
0.2014784515,
-0.5402884483,
0.7494245768,
0.0594865084,
-0.7216652632,
0.2167114466,
-0.8909326792,
-0.3349392414,
0.0743078366,
-0.360393703,
-0.5879402161,
0.1268122196,
0.1922629774,
0.4054195881,
-0.4617280066,
0.4539501071,
-0.250923872,
-0.3848949969,
0.624532938,
-0.5650179386,
0.7312161326,
0.0923942253,
-0.4049222469,
0.3219121993,
-0.5753936172,
-0.2556422651,
0.2305241525,
-0.3364349008,
0.0114512248,
0.3856287599,
0.2536734939,
0.2182606459,
-0.1528681815,
-0.4009782672,
-0.1270667613,
-0.1734116971,
0.5922275782,
0.7655494809,
0.0218171068,
0.1614967585,
-0.3784152865,
0.564872086,
-0.0098826215,
0.3804988861,
-0.2527287602,
-0.5190922618,
-0.6416547894,
0.0193971563,
0.3163584173,
0.6248461604,
-0.5369541049,
0.6604427099,
-0.2902273536,
-0.4387039244,
-0.4498211741,
0.258282125,
0.0899136811,
0.4191046655,
-0.1499355435,
-0.4414018691,
-0.7605791092,
-0.6732107997,
-0.1528107673,
-0.5240775943,
-0.1110121384,
0.3597854972,
0.4346847534,
-0.6335298419,
0.9957701564,
-0.4122382998,
-0.4670584202,
-0.2340908051,
0.2270302474,
-0.0081533166,
0.3739654124,
0.2071695775,
-0.8096767664,
-0.1358545721,
0.0769467801,
-0.9512997866,
-0.277022928,
-0.1788731068,
0.1771558821,
0.4288238585,
0.4668880403,
-0.6450794935,
0.4437152743,
0.453291893,
-0.2064758241,
0.7116621733,
-0.3312142789,
0.1415443122,
-0.6735605001,
0.2035667449,
0.1651968956,
-0.0591855161,
-0.7135766149,
-0.2382301986,
0.0352233574,
-0.027864689,
-0.2375337631,
0.5028474927,
-0.4130166173,
-0.1772093475,
-0.2986031175,
0.131153509,
-0.2252544463,
0.3292658925,
-0.117352508,
0.8009239435,
0.1819359362,
-0.3614263535,
0.2293616235,
0.1967136413,
-0.5191534758,
0.5699301958,
-0.6984382272,
0.042246379,
-0.0372718573,
0.26157251,
-0.9636058807,
-0.8229414225,
0.4979782701,
-0.6422104836,
0.2640390992,
0.1718837917,
-0.8500579,
-0.3780044913,
-0.1194258928,
0.0055812872,
0.6182158589,
-0.2415622771,
0.6500877142,
0.5486783385,
-0.1425074786,
-0.5189808607,
-0.716247201,
0.3235523105,
-0.1037240177,
-0.8145483136,
-0.2220163643,
0.0475123003,
-0.3788119853,
-0.2439446896,
-0.0064737364,
-0.1778273582,
0.4551318288,
0.3369862735,
0.5457130671,
-0.2283381969,
0.2276150882,
-0.5073820353,
0.0048888722,
0.3959535658,
-0.1420511454,
0.4124709666,
-0.0589579269,
-0.6432747245,
-0.4729378819,
0.0801747516,
0.7467247248,
-0.0234597921,
0.5674318075,
0.8862937689,
-0.4843502641,
0.0896070451,
-0.8241588473,
-0.4504584372,
-0.4258511662,
0.6625093222,
0.2605118752,
-0.7172320485,
0.5475009084,
0.0120059885,
0.0527210236,
0.2600812316,
0.5941319466,
-0.2804708481,
0.9629094005,
0.6905398369,
-0.19886145,
0.5019366741,
0.1769715399,
0.5181179047,
-0.8143094778,
-0.1548633873,
-0.6988300085,
-0.0205492303,
-0.6537184715,
-0.3891455233,
0.6125981212,
-0.1119548902,
-0.2264505327,
-0.294324249,
-0.2234603912,
0.1566020548,
0.5099967718,
0.1224319488,
0.4009487033,
0.0422077999,
0.1467753351,
0.0705123693,
-0.6407063603,
-0.7251057625,
1.0412802696,
0.6231023669,
0.9468938708,
0.0301552303,
0.4506494403,
0.4637050629,
0.3714382648,
-0.6917630434,
0.5043058991,
0.3315443993,
-0.7962597013,
-0.5705217123,
-0.3114452958,
-0.8856164217,
0.2124718875,
-0.3325555325,
-0.6795447469,
0.0631837249,
0.3785559535,
-0.2101333141,
0.4088892043,
-0.6785398722,
0.7615556717,
-0.3747880757,
-0.3692657053,
-0.1484167129,
-0.6641397476,
0.4807500839,
-0.3504825532,
0.3752621114,
-0.1741455495,
-0.0139704552,
0.7740186453,
-0.0686114505,
1.2174590826,
-0.0478203632,
-0.1106599718,
0.2346383035,
-0.0660121441,
0.7458670735,
-0.3721718192,
0.0650353804,
0.3532483578,
-0.2291436493,
-0.3385741115,
-0.3288778365,
0.297562629,
-0.9199250937,
-0.5649928451,
-0.5740591288,
-0.3748234212,
-0.3128851354,
0.103438139,
0.1760582626,
0.2850193381,
-0.2944054008,
0.1122390628,
0.8280528188,
-0.2824706733,
0.2445999384,
0.3612581789,
-0.2800671458,
-0.1347567141,
0.7090724111,
0.1152722836,
0.0850003511,
0.0058695348,
0.2386807203,
-0.161958918,
-0.8637590408,
-0.3683659434,
0.4377368093,
-0.7176052332,
0.1378313005,
-0.6052786112,
-0.2735333145,
-0.3192568421,
0.0566127673,
-0.2147779912,
0.2117314637,
-0.5039249659,
0.1038414016,
0.1381392032,
0.846531868,
0.1123727188,
0.5069221258,
-0.9627536535,
-0.1213439107,
0.0516358912,
0.3615473509,
0.1923957616,
-0.4570275247,
-0.2501741052,
-0.0205035266,
-0.3111818135,
-0.6622474194,
0.4448273182,
-0.0717830285,
0.7132145166,
0.2687805593,
-0.1059834734,
0.4094262123,
-0.2855971456,
0.7379341125,
0.167473793,
-0.8051918745,
0.3817130625,
-0.5615641475,
0.108537659,
0.2539715171,
0.3901126981,
-1.2068799734,
-0.0296111666,
-0.3959603906,
-0.8095630407,
0.7222334743,
0.1281999648,
-0.0276459102,
0.2093482763,
0.1584681571,
-0.0663204566,
0.0843064189,
-0.4597465396,
0.1492134035,
0.4181288779,
-0.2023063153,
-0.1397611648,
-0.4546093941,
0.00549907,
0.2608614862,
0.8420217633,
-0.3474085927,
0.1332125664,
0.3821099102,
-0.2584513426,
-0.4077672958,
0.3400991857,
0.797653079,
0.9328721762,
-0.2238793671,
-0.1073486432,
0.1696213037,
-0.6148578525,
0.0674225837,
-0.2565166354,
-0.1808358133,
-0.0804097876,
0.5280763507,
0.6127467752,
0.192281276,
-1.0386531353,
0.4210903049,
0.0258657634,
-0.1206942946,
-0.7332997918,
0.0072040493,
0.0306079127,
0.1899577826,
0.4859372973,
0.2849742472,
-0.0012525022,
-0.5009544492,
-0.0218491443,
0.1155747771,
-0.4096888602,
-0.3879408538,
0.4633790851,
0.4268039763,
-0.426515758,
0.6751798987,
0.0397964902,
-0.5287426114,
0.4984079301,
0.0490014181,
1.0043218136,
-0.2811297476,
-0.0652549416,
0.1522867233,
0.4819845259,
-0.5342121124,
0.0831439272,
0.5930850506,
-0.8260076642,
-0.500839591,
-0.1906287521,
-0.7042034864,
0.0894389153,
-0.336987704,
0.4508015513,
-0.4132869244,
-0.1800168306,
-0.0977321267,
-0.1609157771,
-0.6160761714,
-0.1456435472,
0.3244103789,
0.7032364011,
-0.8632946014,
0.7241356969,
0.5310689807,
-0.3093671799,
-0.5381199718,
-0.0201354288,
0.5124554634,
-0.6425138712,
0.6647186279,
-0.0392189547,
-0.042869173,
-0.368673414,
-0.459420383,
-0.5880209208,
0.9250556827,
0.2074180394,
-0.7340895534,
-0.1293529719,
0.1605048627,
0.5965331793,
-0.2645610571,
0.2956507802,
0.671453774,
0.5270762444,
0.0069280923,
-1.1073777676,
-0.0871159583,
0.2057307661,
0.0504556783,
0.2038905919,
-0.3452623487,
0.6489106417,
-0.1680265516,
-0.199382782,
-0.0667339414,
0.4049581885,
0.1336295307,
0.2945180833,
0.3422304988,
-0.0574943721,
0.9243761301,
-0.1435420811,
1.0712454319,
-0.0000257725,
0.1801376641,
0.9654623866,
-0.5516530871,
0.8646554947,
0.4790838659,
-0.4263640344,
0.105471231,
0.6638739109,
-0.0075581982,
-0.1529557407,
0.2023361474,
-0.157527715,
-0.0462328009,
-0.0909246504,
-0.1030869484,
0.4719716907,
0.6356871128,
-0.3653580546,
-0.0065755816,
-0.0469022244,
0.1331454515,
0.1060371622,
-0.1627663076,
0.6754760742,
0.0695519,
-0.7498285174,
0.3730991781,
0.0667755455,
0.8154374361,
-0.6124264598,
0.063022539,
-0.2651705742,
0.3501106203,
-0.3590926826,
-0.7266617417,
0.2475358993,
-0.1003528237,
0.0100386227,
0.0132717518,
0.9797059298,
-0.1260546148,
-0.3554902971,
0.1686914861,
0.6577131748,
0.1955990493,
-0.2206392586,
-0.5633395314,
0.4119229317,
0.0919852108,
-0.0757064819,
0.3717078567,
0.2951869667,
-0.2983508706,
0.8778731227,
0.5493386388,
0.2536214292,
-0.0311036073,
-0.0307133086,
0.5377046466,
-0.6529360414,
-0.2249071151,
-0.9505971074,
0.2881436348,
-0.1572789401,
-0.1766136736,
0.5230839849,
0.1220969558,
0.7050423026,
-0.1201382875,
0.9245604277,
0.1870433539,
0.4248681068,
-0.3018659651,
0.731790185,
-0.2484031618,
0.4312234521,
-0.1562540978,
-0.7763638496,
-0.4091355205,
0.4227677882,
-0.4222936034,
0.1045703739,
0.5935047865,
0.9914329648,
0.184765771,
0.2608339787,
0.4203608632,
0.1269610226,
0.5905224085,
0.3508749902,
0.8422698975,
-0.3917987049,
0.4831746221,
-0.0159083046,
-0.2334260643,
-0.8446410894,
-0.9031432867,
-0.8950021863,
-0.4742870331,
-0.4425901473,
-0.3438230455,
0.0591694228,
1.1244533062,
0.6487189531,
-0.8515691757,
-0.4910797179,
-0.0290399585,
0.2226382792,
0.0414883569,
-0.181001395,
0.266711235,
-0.538259387,
-0.4763513505,
-0.1195655316,
0.2922755182,
0.1116657704,
-0.5805093646,
-0.2619169652,
-0.1166753545,
0.0426998511,
0.5706399679,
0.3578138351,
-0.9102576971,
-0.264405787,
-0.020024972,
-0.2846035063,
0.1635385454,
0.9027398825,
-0.2559361458,
0.2816325724,
0.5783075094,
0.8106342554,
0.0343098752,
-0.3626385629,
0.7414616346,
-0.4605326653,
-0.185635671,
0.2487191856,
0.5628772974,
0.6315505505,
-0.4736801982,
0.882162571,
0.4470701218,
-0.8904238939,
-0.8817006946,
-0.0918519944,
-0.7999531031,
-0.0457227863,
1.0654798746,
-0.1382815391,
-0.3539752662,
-0.394026041,
-0.5018664598,
0.1291248798,
-0.2911657691,
1.0680519342,
0.9839912653,
-0.0691962093,
-0.1112872139,
-1.0817871094,
0.4336672723,
0.3034625649,
-0.8928435445,
0.4390165806,
0.5262395144,
0.1888089776,
0.2141268253,
0.5172322989,
-0.2110644281,
0.4058336318,
-0.0371378101,
0.4152172506,
0.0610248856,
0.0434807129,
-0.4909765124,
-0.0930948853,
0.5517279506,
0.0355507806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08946v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08946v1
|
Usable XAI: 10 Strategies Towards Exploiting Explainability in the LLM Era
| 2024-03-13T20:25:27 | 2024-03-13T20:25:27 |
Xuansheng Wu, Haiyan Zhao, Yaochen Zhu, Yucheng Shi, Fan Yang, Tianming Liu, Xiaoming Zhai, Wenlin Yao, Jundong Li, Mengnan Du, Ninghao Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Explainable AI (XAI) refers to techniques that provide human-understandable
insights into the workings of AI models. Recently, the focus of XAI is being
extended towards Large Language Models (LLMs) which are often criticized for
their lack of transparency. This extension calls for a significant
transformation in XAI methodologies because of two reasons. First, many
existing XAI methods cannot be directly applied to LLMs due to their complexity
advanced capabilities. Second, as LLMs are increasingly deployed across diverse
industry applications, the role of XAI shifts from merely opening the "black
box" to actively enhancing the productivity and applicability of LLMs in
real-world settings. Meanwhile, unlike traditional machine learning models that
are passive recipients of XAI insights, the distinct abilities of LLMs can
reciprocally enhance XAI. Therefore, in this paper, we introduce Usable XAI in
the context of LLMs by analyzing (1) how XAI can benefit LLMs and AI systems,
and (2) how LLMs can contribute to the advancement of XAI. We introduce 10
strategies, introducing the key techniques for each and discussing their
associated challenges. We also provide case studies to demonstrate how to
obtain and leverage explanations. The code used in this paper can be found at:
https://github.com/JacksonWuxs/UsableXAI_LLM.
|
[
-0.2163158655,
-0.2633793056,
0.8113480806,
0.0416642167,
-0.0785674676,
0.0714719221,
-0.2035970241,
-0.6609535217,
-0.0887973234,
0.4723165333,
-0.6128480434,
-0.328889519,
-0.33857283,
-0.1212944612,
-0.5353329778,
0.882144928,
-0.2052332163,
-0.2123082578,
-0.1961593777,
-0.4768072069,
-0.2953315675,
-0.3176265955,
-0.8548975587,
-0.4668300748,
0.730922699,
0.6015246511,
0.9065158963,
0.882035315,
0.2102098316,
0.4087294936,
-0.1455481946,
0.1012962759,
-0.4760634005,
0.008872482,
0.0046926364,
-1.0259252787,
-0.357298702,
-0.0293130912,
0.6955632567,
0.6715819836,
-0.1909261644,
0.0318463296,
0.1609045565,
0.3494845629,
-0.4879676104,
0.259783268,
-0.5392844081,
0.0007820919,
-0.2544205785,
-0.3255002797,
-0.2305417508,
0.1027456746,
0.0931701809,
-0.9520294666,
-0.195253551,
0.0658259168,
0.5873208046,
0.1699213088,
-0.1846259385,
-0.5560598373,
-0.9253405929,
0.8624030352,
-0.7511873245,
0.1922723651,
0.0900768489,
0.6188789606,
-0.0158876218,
-0.9279227257,
-0.7537198067,
-0.3030678928,
-0.1251027584,
-0.0015299155,
-0.3588431478,
0.0432544723,
0.2772906423,
0.5332698822,
-0.2978564203,
0.4953819513,
-0.0019817506,
0.1907904595,
0.6084352732,
0.2343784273,
0.4912484288,
-0.0063303099,
-0.1820167005,
-0.1386532336,
-0.801984489,
0.2295617759,
0.2449395955,
0.1134074479,
-0.1108001992,
0.4342057109,
0.0066197803,
0.3366722465,
-0.3652192056,
-0.2920089066,
0.134200871,
-0.3521241844,
-0.1513934582,
-0.1378996819,
0.365676254,
-0.0473917834,
0.1060987636,
-0.2649304569,
-0.3011141419,
-0.2198237926,
0.4147506058,
-0.4615759552,
0.036546886,
0.3489817381,
-0.6300512552,
-0.4114246666,
-0.2548129559,
-0.5264384151,
-0.6266436577,
-0.2563570738,
0.3735131919,
-0.2840062082,
-0.3289863765,
-0.208010003,
-0.3178879619,
0.7279783487,
0.3866279125,
-0.8426713943,
0.0330969132,
0.8145990968,
0.8607416153,
-0.0585875399,
-0.2225539684,
-0.3733060658,
0.3628226519,
-0.1714537591,
0.4319992959,
-0.450969547,
-0.3996726274,
-0.037038736,
-0.2894221246,
0.0828973129,
-0.569555521,
0.4289177954,
-0.4191356897,
0.0516525023,
-0.0783946738,
-0.3380609453,
-0.4964841902,
0.4653313756,
-0.680182755,
0.3349403739,
0.1714116931,
-0.4559285343,
0.2302739471,
-1.279610157,
-0.1550954878,
0.1640009731,
-0.2953850627,
-0.4441673756,
0.2934916317,
0.0261954181,
0.4434142709,
-0.012822086,
0.093212232,
-0.39475739,
-0.1929866374,
0.5831634998,
-0.8229554892,
0.8484495878,
0.3739200234,
-0.6894467473,
0.3748517931,
-0.9662991166,
0.0544931814,
0.244129926,
-0.1112449989,
-0.2865328193,
0.0519828014,
-0.2008888572,
-0.0947539881,
-0.0816537365,
-0.2664454579,
-0.0183902886,
-0.4721447825,
0.7252443433,
0.796459496,
-0.4403042793,
0.4280226529,
-0.4712860584,
0.772075057,
-0.1606472433,
0.176393643,
-0.5841587186,
-0.2524744868,
-0.7303697467,
-0.3414354622,
0.030556092,
0.4713074863,
-0.9937754273,
-0.200374037,
-0.3349837363,
-0.4382739663,
-0.6698878407,
0.4323856831,
0.3055387437,
0.5048524737,
-0.0031407354,
0.1204299033,
-0.4066057503,
-0.6970258355,
-0.3174683452,
-0.4608708918,
-0.07967484,
0.6029493213,
0.2555065155,
-0.3516812325,
0.6003710628,
-0.168267116,
-0.0130440416,
-0.6917214394,
-0.0421338528,
0.0324412435,
0.1746221483,
0.3397764266,
-1.1028362513,
-0.1583047956,
0.3446483314,
-1.178866148,
0.0727040172,
-0.4087418318,
0.1072947159,
0.0804871246,
0.5125156641,
-0.3683062792,
0.6578919888,
0.4183415174,
-0.2746509314,
0.4746480286,
-0.2976079881,
-0.0126668466,
-0.8441898227,
0.1977304816,
-0.0212618206,
-0.5772684216,
-0.7524024248,
0.6075645685,
-0.2134944201,
-0.2438126653,
-0.5926412344,
0.7828854918,
-0.680845499,
0.0568615682,
-0.4765186906,
0.3311127424,
-0.110320501,
0.3445833623,
-0.1463009566,
0.6976415515,
0.5256801248,
-0.5981536508,
0.1023585051,
0.1815525591,
-0.3693029583,
0.2146780491,
-0.8814848065,
-0.1553488523,
-0.0953624994,
-0.0124736549,
-0.9417648315,
-0.1043752059,
0.4502324164,
-0.319250524,
0.262632519,
0.1821798682,
-0.2752386332,
-0.121594198,
-0.4409177005,
0.5352765918,
0.6284688711,
-0.9936838746,
0.9040100574,
0.2979706228,
-0.1167547628,
-0.4337075353,
-0.7772507668,
0.4253340065,
-0.7151460648,
-0.7117956281,
0.4133675694,
-0.2632811368,
-0.5493767262,
-0.1011460572,
-0.1309992671,
0.0497012995,
0.621073246,
0.4759345055,
0.0129032126,
-0.3064482808,
-0.1525105536,
-0.0134149278,
-0.457410872,
0.126665473,
-0.2063392997,
-0.0065853479,
-0.0573474206,
-0.3652924597,
-0.726659596,
0.4679183066,
0.5232331753,
0.0937140211,
0.6566919684,
0.5476571918,
-0.2203138769,
-0.1724835485,
-0.226329878,
0.0918194801,
-0.5188605785,
0.2565993667,
-0.3907468021,
-0.8919925094,
0.399900347,
-0.176867485,
0.3444756567,
0.0035995196,
0.4896739125,
-0.14502123,
1.1910605431,
1.160122633,
0.0298613962,
0.6097958684,
-0.4167094231,
0.3303043246,
-0.6908444762,
-0.2565758228,
-0.5140733719,
-0.2816689014,
-0.6510288715,
-0.1218798608,
0.3282913864,
-0.0224632695,
0.110508725,
0.1246259809,
-0.134786278,
0.4153523147,
0.7191060185,
-0.0745194256,
0.4949964583,
-0.0028286085,
0.3176600337,
0.3431681991,
-0.8159508705,
-0.8051214814,
0.9036529064,
0.7433050871,
0.812574625,
0.302513808,
0.6322431564,
0.3415605724,
0.4220133722,
-0.8114132285,
0.5277661681,
0.0278735682,
-0.3984736502,
-0.5168271065,
-0.5134099722,
-1.0660824776,
0.0447843187,
0.0110844839,
-0.7689827681,
0.073013328,
0.3998932242,
-0.3214992881,
0.4785792232,
-0.8355513215,
0.6685578823,
-0.5437191129,
-0.1501873881,
-0.4068528116,
-0.4642987549,
0.373752445,
0.0015108332,
0.1828821152,
0.1054950953,
-0.3136059642,
0.5765949488,
-0.4393596053,
1.0012284517,
-0.1531277299,
-0.3347311318,
0.1406812221,
-0.3138911724,
0.2550888956,
0.0958347246,
-0.1999278665,
0.3894590735,
0.0401267558,
-0.5614371896,
-1.1562445164,
0.7015020251,
-0.8209720254,
-0.8777332902,
-0.1575238854,
-0.6296464801,
0.0357532762,
0.3135296106,
-0.0319670811,
0.4176756442,
-0.1423416883,
-0.0483533293,
0.6982972622,
-0.235475108,
0.6227312684,
0.3697649539,
-0.1275385767,
-0.1662376672,
1.0341899395,
0.22718741,
0.0857231393,
0.4294882119,
0.1552090198,
-0.2596739531,
-0.8356971145,
-0.2979803979,
0.1936923712,
-0.7355718613,
0.0070908247,
-0.3744729161,
-0.1335916817,
-0.2168969065,
-0.1507206857,
0.1107502207,
-0.5873479843,
-0.3207536638,
-0.0745230615,
-0.036039751,
0.845279932,
-0.1825682372,
0.6377902031,
-0.5935743451,
0.3470044434,
0.2388197929,
0.4822503626,
0.3502979279,
-0.4808880687,
-0.3072940409,
0.2071717381,
-0.2535415292,
-0.6269190907,
0.2812896967,
0.0831373185,
1.0467382669,
0.7551433444,
0.0702944025,
0.5877391696,
-0.1160538495,
0.6192552447,
0.0178693011,
-0.9955435991,
0.4916812778,
-0.0606617033,
0.1590181589,
0.3397877216,
0.6358178854,
-0.3904276192,
-0.1969238818,
-0.5671625733,
-0.9873999357,
0.5637201071,
0.3660035133,
0.3258370161,
0.2443370074,
0.8197856545,
0.3891181052,
0.1376232207,
-0.8799597025,
-0.4752275646,
-0.0765110701,
-0.1583811492,
-0.1756083071,
-0.3482462466,
-0.2825448215,
0.1596649587,
0.9087190628,
-0.1438784748,
0.2966326177,
0.0205550492,
-0.355375886,
0.4893658757,
0.3728274405,
0.5825653076,
0.9279043078,
0.1533858776,
0.1592928171,
-0.0501013622,
-0.0597634837,
0.1123477817,
0.1116963625,
-0.2610861063,
-0.2330249548,
0.5596442223,
0.9650682807,
-0.0804634839,
-0.8572244644,
0.1362716705,
-0.2640479803,
-0.0389123783,
-0.4853557944,
0.4980761409,
-0.1229819581,
0.5095871687,
0.1706566215,
-0.2649820447,
0.0587618351,
-0.8727536798,
-0.0310288183,
0.4533163905,
-0.5217612982,
-0.2496307939,
0.6971237063,
0.2687627971,
-0.5860590935,
0.6405402422,
-0.108456485,
-0.0994897187,
0.3084687889,
0.538197875,
0.810198009,
0.2200096697,
0.2460434437,
-0.3334674835,
0.1505955309,
0.3693349659,
0.0915743038,
-0.4556025863,
-0.7375232577,
-0.4219723642,
0.0623286292,
-0.6834838986,
0.1768161058,
-0.6316308975,
0.1087064222,
-0.3667193353,
0.2184958905,
0.182184875,
-0.0563036166,
-0.4452053308,
0.0104488889,
0.3486889303,
1.288854599,
-0.5882142186,
0.5291602612,
0.6250959039,
-0.5300449729,
-0.7654009461,
0.0472201072,
0.1732391268,
-1.2176465988,
0.0530751906,
0.1949286312,
0.098012805,
-0.1092511863,
-0.738188386,
-0.4996171296,
1.3179829121,
0.3744287789,
-0.3539515436,
-0.1112648696,
0.2000872344,
0.407681942,
-0.3811578155,
0.3995578885,
0.7488750815,
0.6088005304,
-0.0462959446,
-0.4180620313,
0.0669773221,
-0.4505849183,
0.0400793031,
-0.0558787286,
-0.3963861763,
0.025809329,
-0.4885305464,
-0.2295838743,
0.6011525989,
0.9346342087,
0.2649449408,
0.856719017,
0.6663635969,
0.3650779128,
0.9338240623,
0.1257404834,
1.2837673426,
-0.0274596345,
-0.2432052791,
0.876845777,
-0.1605716795,
0.6814962626,
0.5168985724,
0.1311813891,
0.6089335084,
0.3062666953,
0.0727158859,
0.104854621,
0.3775633872,
-0.4826916456,
-0.028642159,
-0.1192102432,
-0.1163769662,
0.6323264241,
0.4182354808,
-0.3653086722,
-0.2780308425,
0.5026455522,
0.2933838964,
0.1160451621,
-0.5155699253,
0.9626487494,
0.1591747701,
-0.4631705284,
0.4161580205,
0.0145231644,
0.5171108842,
-0.6946634054,
-0.3156101704,
-0.2869004309,
0.1723614186,
-0.2257748693,
-0.9005647898,
0.457764715,
0.0600812621,
-0.4307321012,
-0.4187348485,
0.7497956753,
-0.0639906526,
-0.3747187257,
0.25405249,
0.5824971795,
0.4554155767,
-0.0153699275,
-0.6748173833,
0.0863619894,
0.3190131187,
0.0134976907,
0.4666312337,
0.5709699392,
-0.3298560977,
1.3032522202,
0.4550120831,
0.0493525825,
-0.2188500613,
-0.0451054722,
0.8153944016,
-0.8982275724,
-0.4012350142,
-0.7560604215,
0.7064275146,
-0.0361301079,
-0.065508388,
0.8015771508,
0.0445277318,
0.7477323413,
0.3380318582,
1.0435963869,
0.0318836756,
0.349146992,
-0.4951041937,
0.8511698246,
-0.6204987168,
0.7669516802,
-0.0619294196,
-0.5673424006,
-0.4309014678,
0.3043895066,
-0.0636574998,
0.2761876881,
0.2781004906,
0.8481814861,
-0.0620667934,
-0.0166169219,
0.6719754934,
0.3742006421,
0.6096512675,
0.2126049995,
0.9775221348,
-0.1159976274,
1.0383235216,
-0.2975221574,
-0.55621773,
0.1264946908,
-1.0848827362,
-0.5384377241,
-0.3737349212,
-0.6077758074,
-0.2713680863,
0.1696263701,
0.3979080617,
0.903372705,
-0.6083123684,
-0.2864439785,
-0.0346791148,
0.7324857712,
-0.3945313096,
-0.2044268996,
-0.0043493607,
-0.3217276335,
-0.6650082469,
0.5388686657,
0.3334771693,
0.0421536416,
-0.3674037457,
-0.2233241349,
0.289003402,
0.0756722242,
0.6880504489,
0.7908011675,
-0.6192256808,
-0.1996117085,
-0.1355970651,
0.529963851,
0.0863041207,
0.9887638688,
-0.8748540282,
0.2988273501,
0.3044551611,
0.9306743741,
0.0999380574,
-0.1828114688,
0.7902905345,
-0.4276973605,
-0.3204222023,
-0.1795999259,
0.3978621364,
0.3885776401,
-0.4313359261,
0.5605080128,
-0.1398859024,
-0.5364849567,
-0.9605634809,
0.2156075984,
-0.9247047901,
-0.3191100359,
0.9557781816,
-0.5512148142,
-0.3074165583,
-0.2023914456,
-0.1194912568,
0.030625131,
-0.0856928825,
0.7350553274,
0.2529961467,
-0.3414438367,
-0.5180302262,
-0.3779694438,
0.1570432037,
0.3422416747,
-0.8862009048,
0.0680652931,
-0.0310960617,
0.1814684421,
0.1850341111,
0.4193722904,
-0.2602730691,
0.2727496624,
-0.104937911,
-0.1533612162,
-0.2994444072,
-0.3214778006,
-0.8168272376,
0.1378421485,
0.4820559621,
-0.2745383978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08943v1
|
LMStyle Benchmark: Evaluating Text Style Transfer for Chatbots
| 2024-03-13T20:19:30 | 2024-03-13T20:19:30 |
Jianlin Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since the breakthrough of ChatGPT, large language models (LLMs) have garnered
significant attention in the research community. With the development of LLMs,
the question of text style transfer for conversational models has emerged as a
natural extension, where chatbots may possess their own styles or even
characters. However, standard evaluation metrics have not yet been established
for this new settings. This paper aims to address this issue by proposing the
LMStyle Benchmark, a novel evaluation framework applicable to chat-style text
style transfer (C-TST), that can measure the quality of style transfer for LLMs
in an automated and scalable manner. In addition to conventional style strength
metrics, LMStyle Benchmark further considers a novel aspect of metrics called
appropriateness, a high-level metrics take account of coherence, fluency and
other implicit factors without the aid of reference samples. Our experiments
demonstrate that the new evaluation methods introduced by LMStyle Benchmark
have a higher correlation with human judgments in terms of appropriateness.
Based on LMStyle Benchmark, we present a comprehensive list of evaluation
results for popular LLMs, including LLaMA, Alpaca, and Vicuna, reflecting their
stylistic properties, such as formality and sentiment strength, along with
their appropriateness.
|
[
-0.2727460861,
-0.8149079084,
0.441308707,
0.4881731868,
-0.4250400662,
0.3880270123,
-0.4970273972,
-0.5034245849,
0.3518792093,
0.2692793608,
-0.5612313151,
-0.5287317634,
-0.5718656778,
0.2729274333,
-0.5965631008,
0.9217785001,
-0.2183579057,
-0.136930421,
-0.2219425142,
-0.0915329307,
-0.4043680131,
-0.458067894,
-0.4958142638,
-0.085303925,
0.4925027192,
0.2754311562,
0.7972604036,
0.286221534,
0.8241361976,
0.2907109857,
-0.0759406313,
0.2004971802,
-0.5327341557,
0.205544129,
-0.2012529969,
-0.2379301041,
-0.7999987006,
-0.1108819544,
0.5589575171,
0.1899629831,
-0.0455283411,
0.3133580089,
0.2821482718,
0.7452707291,
-0.4741780758,
-0.0361242555,
-0.6357876658,
0.0255285986,
-0.1567988992,
-0.4364572465,
-0.4088456333,
-0.6990706325,
0.1382160336,
-0.3564406931,
-0.1075442359,
0.0056682578,
0.6914740205,
0.0600998402,
-0.2730712891,
-0.445984304,
-0.6244372725,
0.4776455462,
-0.6229265332,
0.5411654115,
0.1015841365,
0.7341002822,
0.0727118254,
-0.7931672335,
-0.5583927035,
-0.4555680156,
0.0060090073,
0.1439112872,
-0.1649232507,
-0.1831777692,
-0.0650558919,
0.1940638125,
-0.3729884028,
0.1234866083,
-0.137629807,
-0.1571532339,
0.7056598067,
0.1395462304,
0.2706162035,
-0.0562517457,
-0.5538938642,
-0.216011107,
-0.3919083774,
0.2365525663,
0.2166345268,
0.4546756744,
-0.2615097463,
0.3756172061,
-0.3260711133,
0.4126844108,
-0.2160011679,
-0.4156918824,
0.2863312364,
-0.6691498756,
-0.0355199911,
-0.1841633767,
0.8493221998,
0.8578788638,
0.5047819018,
-0.2574971616,
-0.3203664124,
-0.1568017453,
0.3046340644,
-0.9278248549,
-0.0196667686,
-0.0228018519,
-0.5655156374,
-0.4040250778,
-0.1938898861,
-1.0361708403,
-0.5419051647,
-0.2901747525,
0.5976244211,
-0.3254278898,
-0.2010303438,
0.0702818185,
-0.0803328827,
0.2850471735,
0.5078880787,
-0.6422515512,
0.282804966,
0.7172586918,
1.0553679466,
-0.7462962866,
0.0056996499,
0.0276514553,
-0.2677985132,
-0.4102883339,
0.8048557639,
-0.4087307155,
-0.3874617517,
0.0002845959,
-0.063981846,
-0.0449100211,
-0.2991522253,
0.7760756016,
-0.2414022237,
-0.1195742637,
-0.0898498595,
-0.4226563573,
0.1571888179,
0.1494027823,
-0.3422252238,
0.9405291677,
0.2176146209,
-0.4536297321,
0.3689278364,
-0.6228206158,
-0.4226152897,
0.0551574305,
0.0620820038,
-0.5139183402,
-0.2570940256,
0.1082422957,
0.6280705333,
-0.2835339308,
0.2121694237,
-0.6866346002,
-0.6348755956,
0.7231217027,
-0.5916554928,
0.3669515848,
0.4017579257,
-0.1793661863,
0.3062182367,
-0.8335185647,
0.3696700037,
0.1583831608,
-0.1664969474,
-0.1079648808,
-0.2581112981,
0.2926020324,
0.1288779676,
0.4197118878,
-0.2190300375,
0.0873195454,
0.0784392059,
0.5933220983,
0.9557418227,
-0.1533158422,
0.4381483197,
-0.4671750367,
0.5137637854,
-0.6121739745,
0.1233716756,
0.1360648423,
-0.1055342928,
-0.8857061863,
-0.6245513558,
0.0773677379,
0.6027489305,
-0.4312043488,
0.6148607731,
-0.3334060013,
-0.9614655375,
-0.4146953225,
-0.0114558563,
0.3007543087,
0.1607977599,
0.2010433078,
-0.5004826784,
-0.4871242046,
-1.024256587,
-0.6030303836,
-0.0564597137,
-0.1117124781,
0.3534100056,
0.1993026435,
-0.0745738894,
0.8976690769,
-0.1214917824,
0.1298450381,
-0.2302833945,
-0.0655251294,
0.1650775969,
0.3269359469,
0.7877191901,
-0.3010868728,
-0.438985467,
-0.0741522908,
-0.3773189187,
-0.3508833647,
-0.1040563434,
-0.3087574244,
-0.0186436493,
0.5303605795,
-0.177622512,
0.218737781,
0.7724932432,
-0.3357249796,
0.6677159071,
0.0841294676,
0.3804688454,
-1.2829092741,
0.1548192352,
0.2009210885,
-0.4676553607,
-0.4832865894,
-0.0849390775,
0.1105110943,
0.0049510943,
-0.5339133739,
0.9291619062,
-0.1087019667,
-0.3497444391,
-0.0144185834,
0.3587639928,
0.2268417478,
0.5300007463,
-0.1004249677,
1.0343482494,
0.2933630049,
-0.4449264705,
0.4561316669,
-0.0220075846,
-0.5285345912,
1.2513295412,
-0.8165064454,
0.529212594,
0.1976914406,
0.3528147042,
-1.1844307184,
0.2090818584,
0.1722742021,
-0.2008312345,
0.0678951591,
-0.0747265294,
-0.6184663773,
-0.2369680107,
-0.218509838,
0.2330191582,
0.6065719724,
-0.4813618958,
0.160108313,
0.0685014054,
-0.2876764238,
-0.2930372357,
-0.2374639213,
0.2073431015,
-0.6193276644,
-0.5712885261,
0.338211894,
-0.5380773544,
-0.1952943802,
-0.4828673899,
-0.0807661563,
-0.1386550218,
0.2512746453,
-0.0276704598,
0.354367435,
-0.3443702459,
-0.1501317173,
-0.2662005126,
0.3446337879,
-0.1112816334,
0.1890236139,
0.7265920639,
-0.5452017784,
-0.3868462145,
-0.6361752748,
-0.2695839405,
0.5884107351,
-0.0928437412,
0.3117955029,
0.7566225529,
0.0375740118,
-0.1549595743,
-0.4220788777,
-0.1111643389,
-0.5307081342,
0.6357640624,
-0.461153537,
-0.7903952003,
0.4020937681,
-0.0320145041,
0.0773850828,
0.3525460958,
0.6090586185,
-0.1047587544,
0.7570146322,
0.5353118181,
-0.0608918853,
0.7809205651,
0.2616798282,
-0.0270717237,
-0.6760190129,
-0.0819734707,
-0.7125657797,
-0.4219774604,
-0.8172149062,
-0.4478462338,
0.1240046397,
0.0292992014,
-0.3807268739,
0.6816148758,
-0.3216751814,
0.4253930151,
0.2586787641,
0.2633122504,
0.4601113796,
0.0340429693,
-0.0200744141,
-0.027772313,
-0.2612126768,
-0.7081730366,
0.9523742199,
0.6298218369,
0.7501481175,
0.2531615198,
0.5007661581,
0.586070776,
0.3563196957,
-1.0470663309,
0.7040989995,
-0.1410067379,
-0.1196207702,
-0.3216930926,
-0.4630941451,
-0.8979147673,
0.2551935911,
-0.4520435929,
-1.0569359064,
-0.1134161204,
-0.0656778738,
-0.053378772,
0.1333810091,
-0.4295011163,
0.6532946229,
-0.3602819145,
-0.2966628671,
-0.0543930493,
-0.366214335,
0.2041634768,
-0.104070656,
0.2240599096,
-0.5431688428,
-0.2148648053,
0.8751856089,
-0.0800991505,
0.6637077332,
0.3840990663,
-0.3640051186,
0.1438415349,
0.4399549663,
0.4160347283,
-0.101361528,
-0.1013820916,
0.2814570963,
0.2821575105,
-0.1823872924,
-0.7239861488,
0.4329486489,
-0.7443740964,
-0.2013206929,
-0.0545964278,
-0.5296885371,
-0.6738817692,
0.3099504709,
0.0014966357,
0.3816800416,
-0.6575459838,
0.3546076417,
0.2146910429,
-0.0415878184,
0.3238071203,
0.4555642605,
-0.433965534,
-0.4310591817,
0.7957983017,
-0.0819403678,
0.5481757522,
0.2586154044,
0.3099731803,
-0.3833070993,
-0.3710019588,
-0.5966821909,
-0.0599490367,
-0.7417688966,
-0.0427027829,
-0.2861063182,
-0.5037852526,
-0.2776926756,
-0.3282599151,
-0.544616282,
-0.4196497202,
-0.0617057048,
0.3030762076,
0.6483536363,
0.5401175022,
0.5614981651,
0.3641173244,
-0.6734601855,
0.1005535573,
0.162047267,
0.6747000813,
-0.2269067913,
-0.9483900666,
0.1713911593,
-0.2508240342,
-0.2843627334,
-0.5998438597,
0.1741561592,
0.1333304048,
0.6047745347,
0.2284121066,
-0.1232865527,
0.5571959615,
-0.3585362732,
0.4191878438,
0.3476995528,
-0.8206601739,
0.3350940347,
-0.4706173837,
0.1056230292,
0.7296040058,
0.163481459,
-1.0287376642,
-0.295853883,
-0.6086509228,
-0.649957478,
0.1938434243,
0.4335323572,
0.3850739896,
0.1789004356,
0.1662650406,
0.2060336471,
0.2722526789,
-0.5033491254,
-0.0827634335,
-0.1490268856,
-0.2222028226,
-0.2044549733,
0.038256146,
-0.0717365518,
0.0948768258,
0.2443801016,
-0.2073540092,
0.4041901231,
-0.0894555151,
-0.066779159,
0.1896661669,
0.6177276373,
0.6176310778,
0.6325945854,
-0.393945843,
-0.0481005609,
0.2883299589,
-0.4064979851,
-0.0050354414,
-0.0782098547,
-0.0202588551,
-0.1143870354,
0.2807703018,
0.7239139676,
0.2663813233,
-0.6065114737,
0.6093257666,
-0.3573645353,
0.1030581817,
0.0356189124,
0.2201642543,
0.0206958447,
0.2674153149,
0.02154091,
0.1515759528,
0.1809752584,
-0.7241268158,
0.2237093598,
0.6266520619,
-0.4892068207,
-0.1568776369,
0.1373688132,
0.4766402841,
-0.5856232047,
0.0133908289,
0.0776969939,
-0.3634855151,
0.6197311282,
0.6213759184,
0.9127416015,
0.0053929221,
0.0280548334,
0.4752499163,
0.1636767983,
-0.0540016852,
-0.0205040555,
-0.1739645153,
-0.7418643236,
-0.0311059132,
-0.7281410694,
-0.7682654858,
0.0103265271,
-0.5366147161,
0.6849424243,
-0.6347370744,
-0.2508086562,
-0.1938938498,
-0.1521444768,
-0.8621326685,
0.0705536231,
0.1323535591,
0.9075500965,
-0.6601983309,
0.4932657182,
0.2756342292,
-0.1030362844,
-0.4677579105,
0.1344661266,
0.0822413787,
-1.3248867989,
0.1784438491,
0.1349772513,
-0.3629734516,
-0.2539905012,
-0.3379996121,
-0.9698523879,
1.0697180033,
0.3208923936,
-0.8054061532,
0.1564445049,
0.0300707649,
0.6854277849,
-0.2543897629,
0.4747892916,
0.824618876,
0.3601402342,
0.3176705241,
-1.3691443205,
0.124233,
-0.2559160292,
0.0888258368,
-0.0518098697,
-0.9003764391,
0.3748541772,
0.006273604,
-0.2635704279,
0.5990374088,
0.6381271482,
0.3245779276,
0.3171229959,
0.5144526958,
0.0463662669,
0.7065039277,
-0.0461065173,
0.8633659482,
-0.3084652126,
0.2627774179,
0.9808943272,
-0.0777252167,
1.1247564554,
0.3000909388,
-0.4569620788,
0.4155694842,
0.6631378531,
0.0293999128,
0.3774992526,
0.5383372903,
0.2268826067,
0.0691042319,
-0.2349377424,
-0.4730583131,
0.7592313886,
0.1537285745,
-0.3995408118,
0.0499580242,
-0.4274922609,
0.5335828066,
0.2138926834,
-0.2405588925,
0.7300769687,
0.0731770769,
-0.5949707031,
0.6982207894,
-0.1674070954,
1.0982917547,
-0.4989752471,
0.1484592855,
-0.3284344375,
0.0696827397,
-0.1332511157,
-1.1360919476,
0.0216454435,
-0.0381440371,
0.3178478777,
-0.2174247801,
0.8314886093,
-0.1639472693,
-0.6487399936,
0.1656826288,
0.5728845596,
0.2955567539,
0.1874805689,
-0.7637201548,
0.1397885084,
-0.4275618494,
-0.1206925511,
0.4362564385,
0.4614002109,
-0.0652841777,
0.6992323399,
0.5847247243,
0.1454496086,
-0.3299846947,
0.3306189477,
0.4992514551,
-0.5105834603,
-0.3618047237,
-0.9418625832,
-0.0017583786,
-0.079402037,
-0.526838541,
0.8079157472,
0.2720257342,
0.4532916844,
0.2275476307,
0.6881924868,
0.1300528049,
0.323980093,
-0.6321145296,
0.8940446377,
-0.4979558587,
0.1474207193,
-0.8551202416,
-1.10001719,
0.045180507,
0.4898924232,
-0.0870439261,
0.4672931135,
0.44412449,
0.7125769854,
0.0470895246,
0.030227216,
0.4278906584,
-0.127950877,
0.1278946549,
0.404142648,
0.919139564,
-0.0357283913,
0.5793320537,
-0.2726687491,
-0.255176574,
-0.4829539061,
-1.2379591465,
-0.8894428611,
-0.6036213636,
-0.1118894592,
-0.5544900298,
0.2324452847,
1.0861055851,
0.7895813584,
-0.2674796283,
-0.4347557724,
0.3381845057,
-0.1059267074,
-0.3201668262,
-0.1944648921,
0.3749976158,
-0.1787344813,
-0.7142520547,
0.2897532284,
0.1837098598,
0.2847808599,
-0.2985466123,
-0.0607056096,
0.4289780259,
0.3488686681,
0.8091783524,
0.1171005592,
-0.5713223219,
-0.4922407269,
0.086597465,
-0.4557750821,
0.2185519338,
0.7190368176,
-0.3854796588,
0.318518877,
0.4046163261,
0.6205076575,
0.1557448506,
-0.0717710555,
0.3981201947,
-0.7300077081,
-0.023657361,
0.0718438402,
0.3623487651,
0.4485409558,
-0.1829636544,
0.6273196936,
-0.0098536424,
-0.4891847074,
-0.7749525309,
0.1429365128,
-1.254293561,
0.0826942697,
1.4641901255,
-0.0255728513,
-0.1417025626,
0.2505128086,
-0.4928961992,
0.1780480593,
-0.4869460464,
0.7481015325,
0.5806041956,
-0.1653024256,
-0.1263529807,
-0.5560699701,
0.5425972939,
0.3939772546,
-1.0344161987,
0.0746239349,
0.0846661031,
0.4584468603,
-0.070558399,
0.7247747779,
-0.1120376438,
0.2622364461,
-0.2686765194,
-0.0572911277,
0.2452469915,
-0.183261171,
-0.0015417141,
-0.2203724533,
0.3592621088,
0.0295804795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10557v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.10557v1
|
Second-Order Information Matters: Revisiting Machine Unlearning for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T18:57:30 | 2024-03-13T18:57:30 |
Kang Gu, Md Rafi Ur Rashid, Najrin Sultana, Shagufta Mehnaz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs), we have witnessed
intense competition among the major LLM products like ChatGPT, LLaMa, and
Gemini. However, various issues (e.g. privacy leakage and copyright violation)
of the training corpus still remain underexplored. For example, the Times sued
OpenAI and Microsoft for infringing on its copyrights by using millions of its
articles for training. From the perspective of LLM practitioners, handling such
unintended privacy violations can be challenging. Previous work addressed the
``unlearning" problem of LLMs using gradient information, while they mostly
introduced significant overheads like data preprocessing or lacked robustness.
In this paper, contrasting with the methods based on first-order information,
we revisit the unlearning problem via the perspective of second-order
information (Hessian). Our unlearning algorithms, which are inspired by classic
Newton update, are not only data-agnostic/model-agnostic but also proven to be
robust in terms of utility preservation or privacy guarantee. Through a
comprehensive evaluation with four NLP datasets as well as a case study on
real-world datasets, our methods consistently show superiority over the
first-order methods.
|
[
-0.0536992997,
-0.4131193459,
0.2188510746,
-0.143956095,
-0.2305478454,
0.2495330721,
-0.3354432285,
-0.4641841054,
-0.2497765869,
0.6353100538,
-0.3223445714,
-0.3156081438,
-0.8016712666,
-0.567324996,
-0.470405817,
1.1967360973,
0.1066986024,
0.3244066834,
-0.1894129068,
-0.4186608493,
0.1898607761,
-0.7266127467,
-0.7591007948,
-0.5156770945,
0.6060551405,
0.2766838968,
0.7430396676,
0.7911527753,
0.2943467796,
0.2781909704,
-0.4578076601,
0.1977486461,
-0.6189838052,
0.1606889814,
-0.3249897659,
-0.5560874343,
-0.0083225658,
-0.0561231934,
0.581458509,
0.8591461778,
-0.3453584313,
0.4437960982,
0.3544791639,
1.134819746,
-0.8485862017,
0.1948693991,
-0.6851554513,
0.2194875777,
-0.0761896968,
-0.1018818691,
-0.4592561126,
-0.1472962201,
0.0776342154,
-0.5277202725,
0.301949054,
-0.1150395423,
0.6511357427,
0.4233695269,
-0.1576974839,
-0.3385566771,
-0.9238491654,
0.9323883653,
-0.6339119673,
0.3994780183,
0.3352484703,
0.1750412136,
-0.5262221694,
-0.7135329247,
-0.2657913268,
0.0999817997,
-0.0540037751,
-0.0068397857,
-0.4877690375,
-0.132210806,
0.2945158482,
0.1096302643,
-0.2775276303,
0.5950559974,
-0.5179059505,
0.0576824881,
0.6330111623,
-0.1581505835,
-0.1148331612,
0.1951882094,
-0.3826526403,
-0.1658162326,
-1.0584464073,
0.0719393939,
0.631148994,
0.0928997844,
0.0753095523,
0.7651121616,
0.0396646298,
0.2723201215,
-0.0723044202,
0.061403174,
0.3125957847,
0.1575703323,
-0.2840974629,
-0.1532912254,
0.7845555544,
0.1277674288,
0.5447886586,
-0.3686197996,
-0.4107478261,
-0.3169755638,
0.1051227599,
-0.6317486167,
0.0078613516,
0.3079771996,
-0.5257236958,
-0.2443122417,
0.0251924843,
-0.9478901029,
-0.7144458294,
-0.5541113615,
0.1592161059,
-0.0650663674,
-0.2736523151,
-0.160058558,
0.2129917443,
0.0399352722,
0.2615880966,
-0.9556259513,
0.1832666695,
0.9953974485,
0.6171370745,
-0.0515918769,
-0.1717340052,
-0.5147101283,
-0.0700869486,
-0.3435575664,
0.3469137847,
-0.3736819923,
-0.4113951921,
0.323345989,
-0.0435837619,
0.2553197145,
-0.7727885246,
0.4611517787,
-0.8744431138,
0.392622292,
-0.1342426538,
-0.5313436985,
-0.1739684939,
-0.2629012167,
-0.2845690846,
0.9741111994,
-0.0362315886,
-0.9054647088,
0.2096905708,
-0.412062943,
-0.4037167132,
-0.2428629547,
-0.4614855349,
-0.5343222618,
0.4247788489,
-0.0548213683,
0.4702052474,
-0.2864283323,
0.4425584376,
-0.3203919828,
-0.2165873945,
0.3756807745,
-0.6656719446,
0.8801245093,
0.3642925918,
-0.3802580237,
-0.2123600245,
-0.8270021677,
0.0376847945,
0.3212934732,
-0.5061693192,
-0.3079603016,
0.1938800514,
-0.1623537838,
0.1337945759,
0.3050869107,
-0.5141916275,
0.0126300063,
-0.3741782904,
0.4148162901,
0.9843836427,
-0.3052004576,
0.6377185583,
-0.275213033,
0.4007228017,
0.1384275258,
0.2117665112,
0.0272583328,
-0.3855359554,
-0.8487952352,
0.1178326532,
0.4659570456,
0.5908418298,
-0.3865309656,
-0.0178433619,
-0.2450134754,
-0.4190270305,
-0.5919139385,
0.2813473642,
0.6771754026,
0.4342087507,
0.401214689,
-0.0073806439,
-0.4795760214,
-0.8749284148,
-0.4773860872,
-0.2922254503,
-0.2811443508,
0.3607610166,
0.2140941024,
-0.3810938895,
0.7653294206,
-0.4016171098,
-0.1439732015,
0.0377115235,
0.3563577235,
0.1997010261,
0.4769743681,
0.2849101722,
-0.6563587189,
-0.2196890563,
0.0999265313,
-0.8393291831,
-0.0341954976,
0.0345178656,
0.1334064007,
0.7342072725,
0.5462649465,
-0.4597094655,
0.5353491902,
0.5962533951,
0.1769219041,
0.2806762159,
-0.6764348745,
-0.3921871781,
-0.9822607636,
0.0830682963,
-0.0650872216,
-0.0664521307,
-0.7439530492,
-0.0840002596,
-0.0675016195,
0.077531077,
-0.4611783922,
0.4124630094,
-0.6263464093,
-0.3637161255,
-0.5743247271,
-0.0555660576,
-0.1530419886,
0.6168639064,
0.0175937414,
0.7254635692,
0.2561802864,
-0.5533348322,
-0.175001651,
-0.0474329926,
-0.3289456964,
0.0444334522,
-0.5916082859,
0.4536263943,
-0.6603264213,
-0.0724029168,
-0.8653752208,
0.0940941274,
0.1969630122,
-0.4797672331,
0.6667101383,
-0.4657315016,
-0.5542220473,
0.0479022823,
-0.2562447488,
0.2644371092,
0.7311604619,
-0.9271894693,
0.2995139658,
0.7417131662,
-0.1008667797,
-1.3003114462,
-0.6673088074,
-0.1364940256,
-0.1944422871,
-0.267136991,
0.2312327176,
0.0450351648,
-0.4137277901,
-0.157744959,
-0.2633776367,
-0.3475168049,
0.1707412452,
0.4016261399,
0.0496055633,
-0.0357761048,
0.119169496,
0.0310771428,
-0.2094947994,
0.1929724813,
-0.4043113291,
0.4797497988,
0.0255053584,
-0.2431433648,
-0.3729355335,
0.3181450069,
0.5347078443,
0.0532971732,
0.8297299147,
0.6497142315,
-0.5387588143,
-0.2396260649,
-0.5066180825,
-0.0575537719,
-0.4883768857,
0.3360266089,
0.1692634821,
-0.8310483098,
0.2169709951,
-0.1610545665,
0.5731264353,
0.2373645157,
0.4946109951,
-0.402412504,
0.7747529745,
0.8109176159,
-0.4234709442,
0.5558061004,
-0.2306635231,
0.182519272,
-0.6713700294,
-0.4659439027,
-0.6135633588,
-0.3611784577,
-0.7110822201,
-0.148104772,
0.1694874913,
0.4127414823,
-0.369378686,
0.2309423387,
-0.1749914736,
0.5953196883,
0.5483406782,
0.0372414142,
0.3807557523,
0.4953895807,
0.0708588883,
-0.0323404074,
-0.5962692499,
-0.5432940722,
1.3815418482,
0.407607615,
0.9248797297,
0.3373453617,
0.5816350579,
0.2286852747,
0.3341078162,
-0.7217848301,
0.3228148222,
-0.4312849045,
-0.3748378456,
-0.2127779573,
-0.5503820777,
-1.2646626234,
0.4853549004,
-0.0920487419,
-0.8812239766,
0.3066829443,
0.20416224,
-0.1111440882,
0.3895558119,
-0.6595465541,
0.367266655,
-0.2929900885,
-0.5720878243,
-0.1776945889,
-0.6927807331,
0.2210758626,
-0.3141698539,
0.4650778174,
0.0318146087,
-0.2282137424,
0.9197441339,
-0.6209985614,
0.9425674081,
-0.2712740898,
-0.3715244234,
0.1522790939,
0.0744595826,
0.6763833165,
0.1832794398,
0.0184305906,
0.3781457841,
-0.0791309997,
-0.3004371226,
-0.7084777355,
0.5514252186,
-0.9101169109,
-0.5989181995,
-0.3359032273,
-0.2579423487,
-0.271271646,
0.1451385617,
0.5344291329,
0.3787315488,
0.0913113058,
0.1036172882,
0.7395722866,
-0.1138012186,
0.7009546161,
0.8061953783,
-0.1939055473,
-0.332462281,
0.8041703701,
0.1740305126,
0.1556918472,
0.468682915,
0.1969946474,
-0.4575836957,
-0.7908469439,
-0.401096493,
0.387580812,
-0.7457515001,
-0.1234507188,
-0.5487392545,
-0.056127727,
-0.1978076398,
0.1832726449,
-0.6271483898,
-0.4957773685,
-0.6179709435,
0.2427075654,
0.0533793978,
0.9383786321,
-0.1912948787,
0.3386936188,
-0.7586666942,
0.0670173764,
0.0038290008,
0.2028682083,
-0.1118138283,
-0.869581461,
-0.1799111068,
0.2244656086,
-0.2205430567,
-0.4647985697,
0.2441234291,
-0.0189694948,
0.4549154937,
0.5504766107,
-0.130159229,
0.4139541686,
-0.5719250441,
0.4298400879,
0.3023832142,
-0.7014015317,
0.1200254709,
-0.1894302368,
-0.1020274833,
0.557926774,
0.4125835001,
-0.6019943953,
0.1567009985,
-0.8125881553,
-0.9271621704,
0.6807592511,
0.0412789211,
0.146211803,
0.470641762,
0.6802402735,
0.1138033792,
0.6301375031,
-0.5558795333,
-0.4604755342,
0.162064299,
-0.229058817,
-0.2802861035,
-0.4799509346,
-0.0711596236,
-0.035169825,
0.6922071576,
0.0300922431,
0.1446045786,
-0.2211664468,
-0.2315034568,
-0.0479690582,
0.4635850489,
0.5157586336,
0.6299881935,
0.1608454287,
0.1410134584,
0.1071156859,
-0.4130866528,
0.22302562,
-0.0897181705,
-0.4272910357,
-0.0726347119,
0.1502797753,
0.3990721107,
0.0814139694,
-0.7106986642,
0.7493367195,
0.0640791878,
-0.0701257437,
-0.4793597758,
0.0125221191,
-0.0869267583,
0.3675602973,
0.1268012673,
0.1542932987,
-0.0245322268,
-0.363936305,
0.1429876387,
0.4936411679,
-0.470585376,
-0.3223940432,
0.502069056,
-0.250700444,
-0.2993196845,
0.5249981284,
0.0042958739,
-0.2855033875,
0.339897126,
0.3588913977,
0.7203969955,
-0.2957228124,
0.2426149845,
0.0201145913,
0.3511300683,
-0.4446341991,
0.1294502616,
-0.0494276136,
-0.7223792076,
-0.3407838643,
-0.4275089502,
-0.5420655012,
0.5765519738,
-0.7351203561,
-0.0893562362,
-0.8757312894,
-0.0593310036,
-0.1164151505,
-0.0883427039,
-0.5364504457,
-0.0298635121,
0.0641855597,
0.5072738528,
-0.3338491917,
0.8241297603,
0.620634079,
-0.1144726723,
-0.3045114875,
0.0140298633,
0.1796071678,
-0.9103132486,
0.6460487247,
0.0115158986,
-0.334934026,
-0.213401556,
-0.5141609907,
-0.8627946973,
0.7934257388,
0.6698158979,
-0.815641582,
0.1546121389,
0.2821456194,
0.5721812844,
-0.1116385683,
0.1290737242,
0.4430630207,
0.1259221584,
-0.0220506266,
-0.3200482428,
-0.2934303582,
-0.1459164619,
0.0109270252,
0.2030285746,
-0.7384952903,
0.7468287349,
-0.4830860496,
-0.4391961396,
0.042557314,
0.7090365887,
-0.1659977436,
0.1963799596,
0.4218324721,
0.38742432,
1.1253021955,
0.1381209195,
0.6858149171,
-0.1271110773,
0.5022830367,
1.3768340349,
-0.2669884861,
0.958008647,
0.5211036205,
-0.3396001756,
0.2005252391,
0.6015791297,
0.1056790948,
0.4553648531,
0.574791491,
-0.2339811325,
0.1665902585,
-0.203185901,
-0.2842810452,
0.4635362327,
0.1865795255,
-0.4857282341,
-0.3093717992,
-0.3181240261,
0.5334979892,
0.0578444786,
-0.1852354258,
0.9043331146,
0.198801592,
-0.4421769083,
0.7358799577,
0.2305854559,
0.5894728899,
-0.2619235218,
0.2539230585,
-0.3770003617,
0.5540782213,
-0.2532771826,
-0.5308733582,
0.1621281654,
0.2891974151,
-0.1596677005,
-0.1473350078,
0.4570535123,
-0.4826116562,
-0.2270743996,
0.5329002738,
0.5511726737,
0.1842626035,
0.0230284929,
-0.7233487964,
-0.0873732194,
-0.1042767763,
-0.3257348537,
0.6560819745,
0.1222964972,
0.23636204,
0.6584174037,
0.5905134678,
-0.1385336816,
-0.0507054739,
0.0852720067,
0.8087720275,
-0.3893862963,
-0.1365637928,
-0.9134176373,
0.1807826161,
0.0208934564,
-0.2688058615,
0.5290611982,
0.6474278569,
0.9849162102,
0.2493385375,
0.8761584759,
0.5629229546,
0.553101778,
-0.7769884467,
0.7667734623,
-0.6137211323,
0.591701448,
0.0487242304,
-0.8088912964,
-0.3182107508,
0.255048126,
-0.0513483919,
0.1163879484,
0.5516548157,
0.7035446763,
-0.0312353373,
0.3981184065,
0.1729461402,
0.1639737785,
0.1445389539,
0.4518527091,
0.8868429661,
-0.2848059237,
0.3840122521,
-0.3768415153,
-0.2348563522,
-0.0346296132,
-0.7569053173,
-0.9177651405,
-0.3960792422,
-0.2220674306,
-0.5122817755,
0.1460850835,
0.9375481009,
0.4366866052,
-0.8811785579,
-0.3126549423,
-0.1602809876,
0.1310251802,
0.0437421352,
-0.0705233961,
0.4731088877,
-0.3086505234,
-0.6632156372,
0.5217216611,
0.0882219747,
0.3416865468,
-0.384424895,
0.022036247,
0.2803028226,
-0.0327470377,
0.5759081841,
0.5741265416,
-0.4483748972,
-0.1048696935,
-0.3169379532,
-0.0126484847,
0.2532443404,
1.051388979,
-0.6110826731,
0.0234115105,
0.3002462089,
1.0683649778,
0.463363111,
0.0581037514,
0.3122105896,
-0.7218917608,
0.1976522207,
-0.0586465038,
0.5286543965,
0.3518107235,
-0.3706598878,
0.5191274881,
0.2073189616,
-0.5368836522,
-0.8286651373,
0.3417102695,
-0.5813221931,
-0.3663119674,
1.3099179268,
-0.3294862509,
-0.2514440119,
-0.0891584828,
0.1163881123,
0.2736461163,
-0.377612114,
0.7121010423,
0.437069267,
0.0735724047,
-0.0031136926,
-0.6050761342,
0.5076990128,
0.588368535,
-0.6977095008,
0.4704782963,
0.338952601,
0.2332264632,
0.0408227444,
0.4356923997,
-0.2764962018,
-0.1012025997,
-0.3935742378,
-0.2433280498,
-0.1399192065,
-0.6172655821,
-0.9310349226,
0.2331964672,
0.0745626315,
-0.2035583854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08904v1
|
Detecting Hallucination and Coverage Errors in Retrieval Augmented Generation for Controversial Topics
| 2024-03-13T18:47:00 | 2024-03-13T18:47:00 |
Tyler A. Chang, Katrin Tomanek, Jessica Hoffmann, Nithum Thain, Erin van Liemt, Kathleen Meier-Hellstern, Lucas Dixon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore a strategy to handle controversial topics in LLM-based chatbots
based on Wikipedia's Neutral Point of View (NPOV) principle: acknowledge the
absence of a single true answer and surface multiple perspectives. We frame
this as retrieval augmented generation, where perspectives are retrieved from a
knowledge base and the LLM is tasked with generating a fluent and faithful
response from the given perspectives. As a starting point, we use a
deterministic retrieval system and then focus on common LLM failure modes that
arise during this approach to text generation, namely hallucination and
coverage errors. We propose and evaluate three methods to detect such errors
based on (1) word-overlap, (2) salience, and (3) LLM-based classifiers. Our
results demonstrate that LLM-based classifiers, even when trained only on
synthetic errors, achieve high error detection performance, with ROC AUC scores
of 95.3% for hallucination and 90.5% for coverage error detection on
unambiguous error cases. We show that when no training data is available, our
other methods still yield good results on hallucination (84.0%) and coverage
error (85.2%) detection.
|
[
-0.6481375098,
-1.1654350758,
0.6964146495,
0.2982017994,
-0.0835461691,
0.2397996038,
-0.0107213063,
-0.3472439945,
0.4753434658,
0.6003805995,
-0.4572138488,
-0.5261475444,
-0.5893216133,
0.2603022456,
-0.6909599304,
0.8793519735,
-0.1529878378,
-0.0908867568,
-0.5010452271,
-0.0040554083,
-0.5077502131,
-0.5445801616,
-0.2275851071,
-0.1494440585,
0.5909029245,
0.6038706899,
0.5227477551,
0.3789650798,
0.4071183801,
0.2806856632,
-0.2140625119,
0.7670731544,
-0.5262001157,
0.401519388,
0.0283342712,
-0.4274155498,
-0.1924536079,
-0.2419274896,
0.6228556633,
0.6592483521,
-0.0342300311,
-0.3723546565,
0.0143747786,
0.6749564409,
-0.6717404127,
-0.2300598323,
-1.0863132477,
0.2553884983,
0.0336062871,
-0.4736483097,
-0.6083076596,
-0.3944631219,
-0.007033254,
-0.5539921522,
0.5806904435,
0.0136647765,
0.7879761457,
0.4226095676,
-0.2623566687,
-0.4964303672,
-0.8593600392,
0.7922016382,
-0.5325430036,
0.1789123714,
0.5690019131,
0.2394733131,
-0.339625001,
-0.2583754361,
-1.0200045109,
-0.2689167857,
-0.0820718706,
0.1201939136,
-0.1787538677,
0.1373552084,
0.2842176259,
0.2915159166,
-0.3628512919,
-0.0895271972,
-0.3645670414,
-0.6002078652,
0.6046184897,
0.0306314137,
0.2087275237,
-0.5080204606,
-0.3045877814,
0.066965431,
-0.5920418501,
-0.3938449025,
0.7226756215,
0.0467651226,
0.185433507,
0.8856965899,
-0.4468327761,
0.7218187451,
0.1032179445,
0.0233079214,
0.3492394984,
-0.2930851281,
-0.1222862303,
0.1439516842,
0.735019505,
0.2720561624,
0.0830171406,
-0.284280479,
-0.1403868049,
0.0808032975,
0.5649415255,
-0.4777995944,
-0.0744843259,
0.4392360747,
-0.0543865599,
-0.5258678794,
0.0251897797,
-0.6979438663,
-0.6351336241,
-0.1039502844,
0.6335656047,
-0.3413149118,
-0.1946273893,
-0.0080887852,
-0.0900093019,
0.3837820292,
0.5979688168,
-0.6822001934,
0.0921287686,
0.5571054816,
0.8766712546,
-0.4543436766,
-0.3144319952,
-0.4746386111,
-0.1176358387,
-0.5370364785,
1.1172132492,
-0.0413608626,
-0.5075217485,
0.0362119414,
-0.1547717899,
0.1056612432,
-0.5984517932,
0.3527098298,
-0.5060378313,
0.3950271904,
-0.2127515227,
-0.6195989251,
-0.1790949851,
0.6932451725,
-0.6493673921,
0.875679493,
0.0486280844,
-1.119079113,
0.1836811006,
-0.2900032699,
-0.4172224104,
-0.1164552644,
-0.480804503,
-0.5377740264,
0.0390839651,
-0.1077391058,
0.3729859889,
0.0760148019,
0.3775341809,
-0.1048048511,
-0.572498858,
0.6064308882,
-0.5440412164,
0.4804135859,
-0.1259926856,
-0.6379138231,
0.2416328788,
-0.8781135678,
0.0146006932,
-0.150775224,
-0.3314603865,
-0.1865457445,
0.1331228018,
0.0061112898,
-0.0587580875,
0.0662919953,
-0.4878768623,
-0.0187912174,
-0.3587896526,
-0.0479024872,
0.7979633808,
0.1958747655,
0.2392836958,
-0.5054686666,
0.3391612768,
0.2461326867,
0.0260594245,
-0.0015616,
-0.5220138431,
-1.142895937,
0.1612298787,
-0.0098368591,
0.7234990597,
-1.1038165092,
0.4996168017,
0.0619138777,
-0.571772635,
-0.4200268388,
0.2086265385,
0.491007477,
0.8984165788,
0.5080986619,
-0.1464550942,
-0.6135477424,
-0.9801158905,
-0.2929006815,
-0.4956429005,
0.1409918219,
0.6532740593,
0.4101153612,
-0.5123519301,
0.8844503164,
-0.3858182132,
-0.1229851618,
-0.1206241921,
0.1974607855,
-0.0527171418,
0.3659088314,
0.1338398159,
-1.096360445,
-0.3822665513,
-0.1044184864,
-0.9884136319,
-0.0889277086,
-0.2117246687,
-0.1644173712,
0.6139900684,
0.4170853496,
-0.57006073,
0.5257179141,
0.2834075093,
-0.1937684268,
0.6043070555,
-0.0417063572,
0.3059215844,
-1.0219764709,
-0.2733170986,
-0.1838776171,
-0.142494306,
-0.8969973922,
-0.2845616639,
-0.115064837,
0.4987482131,
-0.5825289488,
0.2968283594,
-0.1918276548,
0.0868499577,
-0.714202404,
0.4687110782,
0.0006544798,
0.3007099628,
0.1118805781,
0.6280351877,
0.3465692103,
-0.6754076481,
0.4967106581,
0.3135929406,
-0.1779612601,
0.475015372,
-0.5964906812,
0.301363647,
-0.3568412662,
0.0195872951,
-1.1206424236,
-0.6104477048,
0.6754204631,
-0.7403843403,
0.1654352695,
0.0310904216,
-0.4419501722,
-0.0315622687,
-0.3162150085,
0.2990266383,
0.2759620547,
-0.5417378545,
0.5010313988,
0.4930996001,
0.1098931804,
-1.0034739971,
-0.7371122241,
-0.0648393556,
-0.1217110753,
-0.4975995421,
0.2796912193,
-0.1569013149,
-0.4676245749,
-0.0862538517,
-0.1652449667,
-0.0031521674,
0.2547889054,
0.4408710301,
0.2573705018,
0.0000506718,
0.186490044,
0.0741831735,
0.1175420508,
0.1871446073,
0.0859464332,
0.7646449804,
-0.1697403938,
-0.5831459165,
-0.1852013767,
0.1890005171,
0.3631916046,
0.3414420485,
0.6587885022,
0.3085754812,
-0.5558930635,
-0.1817738563,
-0.8998862505,
-0.2562141418,
-0.4367177188,
0.3548774123,
-0.1446461976,
-0.7904476523,
0.6877946854,
0.4023569822,
-0.0937080085,
0.6329202652,
0.6400390267,
-0.2069792747,
0.6987872124,
0.6309251785,
0.1366011202,
0.2709505558,
-0.067752637,
-0.0497570708,
-0.688862741,
-0.5373456478,
-0.4699330628,
-0.2172672302,
-0.8661715984,
-0.5846350789,
0.2602888942,
0.185706988,
-0.0403121598,
0.1521603763,
-0.6788842678,
0.4293909073,
0.5638182759,
0.3088775873,
0.5330460668,
0.2793408036,
0.0901550576,
-0.1777334809,
-0.4198639989,
-0.522767961,
0.9996128082,
0.1553404182,
0.6341534853,
0.0744177997,
0.8937830329,
0.3813045025,
0.4264077544,
-0.9282824397,
0.5771486759,
0.458712101,
-0.6914519668,
-0.5250408053,
-0.6517904997,
-0.6546931267,
0.3368623555,
-0.2596716285,
-0.4470724761,
0.2839922309,
0.1612246633,
-0.0343091972,
0.4942794144,
-0.4258418679,
0.5550629497,
-0.1748465747,
-0.4246639013,
-0.0011481622,
-0.6658399701,
0.6078271866,
-0.2529147267,
0.0945396125,
-0.0530629903,
0.0645051971,
0.5874031782,
-0.1305308789,
0.7875244617,
-0.1596769094,
-0.0660937577,
0.4810487032,
0.1038434431,
0.2772522867,
0.270219475,
0.0662303418,
0.1357725263,
-0.3456246257,
-0.2511467338,
-0.6275463104,
0.5890039802,
-0.8310752511,
-0.8525487185,
-0.6079810262,
-0.6645723581,
-0.2857123613,
0.1658845693,
0.4976636171,
-0.0313734114,
-0.2043982893,
0.1234835461,
1.0928047895,
-0.4396518469,
0.0132073099,
0.4441014528,
-0.4017588198,
-0.3007160127,
0.9872168303,
0.0535372384,
0.3245097101,
0.3537248969,
0.0006795247,
0.000671706,
-0.7421606779,
-0.4190643728,
0.0680453181,
-0.8757563829,
-0.3274747729,
-1.0032719374,
-0.6925446987,
-0.1983546019,
0.0984158665,
-0.3591239452,
-0.3770288527,
-0.4720849395,
-0.1514068097,
0.5126695633,
0.5303846002,
-0.1276162863,
0.1867635697,
-0.5069757104,
0.4778596461,
0.0616035834,
0.0424206443,
-0.3057351708,
-0.6358218789,
0.1504195035,
0.0977177769,
-0.4988808334,
-1.0481008291,
0.3161828816,
-0.2578439713,
0.5125365257,
0.2353036404,
0.1945381016,
0.4337807,
-0.3936526477,
0.5753678679,
0.1050282568,
-0.7618127465,
0.71798563,
-0.0779471546,
-0.1547677964,
0.6731401682,
0.5184190273,
-0.640963614,
-0.74261868,
-0.6441856027,
-0.8276389837,
0.4197983444,
0.3246701062,
0.350584805,
-0.2546238601,
0.4026549459,
0.2412149161,
0.3902778924,
-0.8244403601,
-0.3546288908,
-0.304831624,
0.020521054,
0.2222282588,
-0.422865659,
-0.2544873059,
0.0780175254,
0.7288553119,
-0.2688867748,
0.2366634905,
0.6116634607,
-0.1864745021,
-0.0650689602,
0.3212698698,
0.8265506625,
0.703106463,
-0.3120549321,
0.2388041914,
0.1183670089,
-0.615426898,
0.188087523,
0.1483954936,
-0.572037816,
0.3954056501,
0.240994975,
0.6345613599,
-0.0203377567,
-0.6757429838,
0.4474019706,
0.025223434,
-0.3210858703,
-0.5117847323,
0.1551000625,
-0.1759827882,
0.1726625711,
0.5194196105,
0.1314912289,
0.2531633377,
-0.4098632038,
0.3583809733,
0.5711426735,
-0.438554734,
0.0551229902,
0.4719137847,
-0.0612127632,
-0.3102252185,
0.6236583591,
-0.3250019848,
-0.6870857477,
0.6943827868,
0.2678747475,
0.7125692964,
-0.0145405866,
0.553606689,
0.1366247386,
0.3922565281,
-0.0787797123,
0.3290356398,
-0.0660549849,
-1.1400200129,
-0.4093442857,
-0.4084636271,
-0.8593523502,
0.1257112473,
-0.5615273118,
0.1901714355,
-0.4211854637,
0.0339045003,
-0.126753509,
0.0606283247,
-0.3280925751,
0.0764861479,
-0.0933190286,
0.7139490843,
-0.6737545729,
0.4832759798,
0.4228801727,
-0.3723737299,
-0.459864974,
0.240737468,
0.0190312304,
-0.6877322793,
0.6045364141,
0.2656030655,
-0.2261863053,
-0.2373622358,
-0.519058764,
-0.5430952311,
1.0043144226,
0.1097302288,
-0.6195212007,
-0.0860502273,
0.2003304362,
0.4719073772,
-0.0714659095,
0.1935509592,
0.3193160295,
0.3623840511,
0.3441742361,
-0.6287035346,
-0.0238582809,
0.0386378318,
-0.2232867926,
-0.0623785332,
-0.6108542085,
0.6672191024,
-0.2503668368,
-0.1495621055,
0.1070150062,
0.729331553,
0.7241332531,
0.7106294036,
0.5364688635,
0.3251548111,
0.9490616322,
-0.1558731645,
0.9485960007,
-0.0947136357,
0.2727137804,
0.8951343894,
-0.0977928564,
0.7589179277,
0.7527611256,
0.0635306165,
0.3226647377,
0.6508568525,
-0.0844636932,
0.4870339632,
0.359210223,
-0.4130868614,
-0.1219277903,
-0.100320071,
-0.4113242626,
0.2664739192,
0.3771083951,
-0.2390004098,
-0.0350515768,
0.1143017337,
-0.0405429192,
0.1753943563,
-0.1211647913,
0.696407795,
-0.0251811109,
-0.7088249922,
0.5734209418,
-0.0761191174,
0.8255887628,
-0.131090641,
-0.1805353165,
-0.6053086519,
0.0519165024,
-0.4111334085,
-0.7754020691,
0.4528772235,
-0.0451476909,
-0.3822876215,
-0.013857414,
1.0937591791,
-0.3317626119,
-0.5335316062,
0.1494178027,
0.6547879577,
0.4548741877,
-0.1536034644,
-0.3399398327,
0.3190900087,
0.1675135344,
-0.1342259198,
0.0481535532,
0.4451325834,
0.0521694385,
0.5343714952,
0.5053554177,
0.0934088975,
0.1193576008,
-0.1176059693,
0.914265573,
-0.6280046701,
-0.0007512556,
-0.9299628139,
0.3745505214,
-0.273830533,
-0.2252309471,
0.8974794745,
0.5724902749,
0.9950452447,
0.0842842832,
0.8586109281,
0.0798759162,
0.6619349718,
-0.5545148253,
0.7503685951,
-0.4506934285,
0.5303066373,
-0.3066164851,
-0.9087511897,
-0.4171364903,
0.8563673496,
-0.2104325145,
-0.0035084626,
0.3850130141,
0.8642178774,
0.0947270766,
0.0322221778,
0.4241570234,
0.3138847351,
0.3099074066,
0.3909054697,
1.2522181273,
-0.5116680264,
0.6387206912,
-0.3936683536,
-0.178695783,
-0.4225857854,
-0.6370301843,
-0.9942464232,
-0.6078347564,
-0.4251352847,
-0.9744544625,
-0.0619867556,
0.4620985389,
0.3317082524,
-0.8178160787,
0.1139447317,
-0.4219569862,
0.7047019601,
0.2638690174,
-0.3547503352,
0.2778534889,
-0.5058653951,
-0.6926470995,
0.2986580729,
0.2407089919,
0.12028566,
-0.5778429508,
-0.1555720866,
-0.0282219034,
0.0583009459,
0.4767851233,
0.3521467447,
-0.867985487,
-0.3930569291,
0.3725653291,
-0.2421973199,
0.1047976092,
0.665125668,
-0.8658207059,
0.5706983209,
0.4411132634,
0.8830685616,
0.4433662593,
-0.0263170134,
0.2510061264,
-0.5391888618,
0.0279084556,
0.4650087655,
0.0432764702,
0.5871178508,
-0.5327323675,
0.4334058166,
0.5983618498,
-0.5992060304,
-1.1971251965,
0.3404327631,
-0.9462983608,
-0.2110023648,
1.2029793262,
0.2127918303,
-0.1511233896,
-0.2311303169,
-0.2567942739,
0.3063648641,
0.0145485196,
1.3278298378,
0.9371746778,
-0.3026584685,
-0.0282427818,
-0.74270612,
0.5447469354,
0.4142687023,
-0.9797750711,
-0.1469440311,
0.6476554275,
0.193921268,
0.7002550364,
0.6270124316,
-0.01988714,
0.3945711553,
-0.0296798777,
-0.0279142354,
0.215647772,
-0.5045539737,
-0.0792875513,
0.0173677262,
-0.0867304951,
-0.1678189039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08890v1
|
From "um" to "yeah": Producing, predicting, and regulating information flow in human conversation
| 2024-03-13T18:20:24 | 2024-03-13T18:20:24 |
Claire Augusta Bergey, Simon DeDeo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT, q-bio.NC
|
Conversation demands attention. Speakers must call words to mind, listeners
must make sense of them, and both together must negotiate this flow of
information, all in fractions of a second. We used large language models to
study how this works in a large-scale dataset of English-language conversation,
the CANDOR corpus. We provide a new estimate of the information density of
unstructured conversation, of approximately 13 bits/second, and find
significant effects associated with the cognitive load of both retrieving, and
presenting, that information. We also reveal a role for backchannels -- the
brief yeahs, uh-huhs, and mhmms that listeners provide -- in regulating the
production of novelty: the lead-up to a backchannel is associated with
declining information rate, while speech downstream rebounds to previous rates.
Our results provide new insights into long-standing theories of how we respond
to fluctuating demands on cognitive resources, and how we negotiate those
demands in partnership with others.
|
[
-0.6405364275,
-0.9606701732,
0.6096802354,
0.2124658376,
-0.0979206711,
-0.2521250844,
-0.2109107673,
-0.6325589418,
0.4517463148,
0.7017031312,
-0.6858533025,
-0.0722079501,
-0.52272892,
-0.2859296203,
-0.5312747359,
1.1110851765,
0.7043226957,
-0.0561786704,
-0.1034715325,
0.0516156256,
-0.800909996,
-0.5999522805,
-0.7346604466,
-0.3939103484,
0.7782589793,
0.4713373184,
0.7997857928,
0.7195860744,
0.389780283,
0.333425045,
-0.2135801464,
-0.3414120078,
-0.7719252706,
0.4478039742,
-0.2295512706,
-0.6606807709,
-0.0797129497,
0.0669559091,
0.6815087199,
1.1395504475,
-0.2946107388,
-0.0813566968,
0.116233252,
0.4715974629,
-0.3285173774,
0.1348358244,
-0.7037120461,
-0.1544065773,
-0.255130887,
-0.6777066588,
-0.2543849051,
-0.2663500607,
0.5095028877,
-0.4717918932,
0.0901819095,
0.1151409671,
0.7449815869,
0.3163954318,
-0.4903644919,
-0.4970797896,
-0.8738595843,
0.704205811,
-0.2906238735,
0.3417474329,
0.4564129412,
0.10819529,
-0.3721765876,
-0.8552002311,
-0.5930990577,
-0.02663959,
0.0996790379,
0.0293662213,
-0.2958966792,
-0.0521411039,
0.1193263009,
0.2822872102,
0.0316641741,
-0.1405684203,
-0.6424598694,
-0.0985316038,
0.5023880601,
0.3092483878,
0.33512187,
-0.0016129155,
-0.2317591459,
-0.0030826,
-0.3418228328,
0.2248981297,
0.3356360793,
0.0838801786,
-0.1116385609,
0.4035843015,
-0.2280785292,
0.3294058442,
0.1466799676,
0.0658691376,
-0.1179925576,
-0.2542731166,
-0.2383258641,
-0.0370616578,
0.6710855365,
0.4844285846,
0.1822314262,
-0.1775882691,
0.2661058009,
0.0662163496,
0.4274451733,
-0.5538784862,
-0.3754991889,
0.2746073008,
-0.2383803576,
-0.213885814,
0.1612196267,
-0.7692895532,
-0.3916922212,
-0.3484741747,
0.2897923291,
-0.2893004715,
-0.3369724452,
0.2922918499,
-0.4005966187,
0.2508691251,
0.3771547973,
-0.789011538,
0.4988496602,
0.3990827203,
0.6840359569,
-0.0502233543,
-0.2196767628,
-0.5748349428,
0.1665001363,
-0.4757997692,
0.9542670846,
-0.2899934649,
-0.6198488474,
-0.2521290481,
-0.2314304411,
0.1436884701,
-0.2762796581,
0.5526573062,
-0.4319795966,
0.2763133943,
-0.2749251127,
-0.3220712245,
-0.1283817142,
-0.1503205746,
-0.584785521,
0.5784025788,
-0.2037264854,
-0.7531901598,
0.2193487734,
-0.4213005006,
-0.6404010653,
0.3494595885,
-0.4341605008,
0.10805922,
0.3956211209,
-0.4170559049,
0.3738570213,
-0.3137139678,
0.1541955769,
-0.268535912,
-0.0791071877,
1.0080245733,
-0.4593238831,
0.6306132674,
0.2698861957,
-0.1658499539,
-0.2051901966,
-0.8172447085,
0.0677176788,
-0.1013384387,
-0.5961363912,
-0.2714072764,
0.2244541645,
-0.2688995898,
0.0905234814,
0.0569122955,
-0.5126098394,
-0.0503392257,
-0.2599595189,
0.6882060766,
0.5787405372,
0.3425490558,
0.3759965301,
-0.5367893577,
0.1102108955,
-0.0192857776,
-0.0553032532,
-0.3213154376,
-0.8667959571,
-0.9007204771,
-0.1290937364,
0.0130369766,
0.4253623784,
-0.3743427694,
0.123376824,
-0.2712782621,
-0.3344581723,
-0.5785008073,
-0.120586209,
0.0552529655,
0.4533924758,
0.0560872369,
-0.5906628966,
-0.4783935547,
-0.5987982154,
-0.0620296299,
-0.1865680516,
-0.2882978618,
0.2292395681,
-0.0107748182,
0.0534348078,
0.9088702202,
-0.4198077619,
-0.3195429444,
-0.108153224,
0.7454487681,
0.2303412855,
0.2717292011,
0.1093974262,
-0.7676897049,
0.0069262246,
-0.1081466302,
-0.4611301124,
-0.1433673948,
-0.2080426663,
-0.1305624098,
-0.1046094745,
0.6131714582,
-0.5602399707,
0.4693287313,
0.4408078492,
-0.2506244779,
0.152714476,
-0.4505767822,
0.1486611068,
-0.8500789404,
-0.1707513332,
-0.3156184852,
0.0501149818,
-0.7271866798,
-0.2390230745,
-0.2706741989,
-0.1388343871,
-0.5540727973,
0.265066117,
-0.6235407591,
0.1214885041,
-0.4798968732,
0.3108597696,
0.0665552989,
0.5171502233,
-0.0712858513,
0.4383579791,
0.6927314401,
-1.0622265339,
0.5080626607,
0.0996079668,
-0.5479726195,
0.9245246053,
-0.5961149931,
0.3668491244,
-0.3715924621,
0.3037825525,
-1.4510295391,
-0.6239991784,
-0.1954241842,
-0.6723858714,
0.1764781177,
-0.0847858787,
-0.1805423647,
-0.2981316447,
-0.1126372814,
0.0873456225,
0.3459956944,
0.0085373968,
0.6545299888,
0.935774684,
-0.5549393892,
-0.1123747975,
-1.408521533,
0.150409773,
-0.0427236445,
-0.8146587014,
0.3378453851,
-0.2877569497,
-0.5115482807,
-0.0217633247,
0.0354219005,
-0.1726984531,
0.2206199467,
0.4077939391,
0.0093989158,
-0.0481141098,
0.3148140907,
-0.2446440905,
-0.0240249466,
0.2821215093,
-0.4730713964,
0.5071450472,
0.0815661401,
-0.1457649916,
-0.6724597216,
0.7633460164,
0.5695659518,
0.205906108,
0.730884552,
0.3971534371,
-0.1038192734,
0.2382373065,
-0.6250528693,
-0.3907268345,
-0.4227072895,
0.3011449277,
-0.4632377625,
-0.9548173547,
0.3952149451,
0.2845445871,
0.133808881,
0.2757174671,
0.7226790786,
-0.3595534861,
0.9543403983,
0.6228841543,
0.1944700778,
0.4986961186,
0.0840400979,
0.155781135,
-0.4027872682,
-0.2532503307,
-0.5662892461,
-0.4524026513,
-0.8283101916,
-0.299756676,
0.3392764628,
0.0145400884,
0.2484713346,
0.0321765505,
-0.1368626505,
0.5062903166,
0.6730340123,
-0.2260776609,
0.3416257203,
-0.3250288963,
0.2602701783,
0.1182604209,
-0.5441203117,
-0.3710928857,
1.0189636946,
0.3534647524,
0.9886750579,
0.2443021387,
0.4935958087,
0.3118707836,
0.0393755212,
-0.8551467657,
0.6106548309,
0.2484746277,
-0.6013692617,
-0.2378390133,
-0.4690151811,
-1.3000143766,
0.0215195119,
-0.1915500462,
-1.1017923355,
0.2750987411,
0.2120071352,
-0.5481750965,
-0.0095673287,
-1.025986433,
0.5243071318,
-0.1650163829,
-0.3699018061,
-0.4872367382,
-0.8348268867,
0.1601585895,
0.2950436175,
0.4595338404,
-0.2642872632,
-0.0901428312,
0.6777902246,
-0.002076403,
0.825759232,
0.2711516023,
-0.1777241975,
0.6266380548,
0.0878555104,
0.2852045,
0.0894081593,
0.2563998401,
0.2817970812,
0.1447876543,
-0.3643067777,
-0.4211997688,
0.5728370547,
-0.8267075419,
-0.6752981544,
-0.0642361417,
-0.7518931627,
0.0897767544,
0.0473839641,
0.6783114672,
0.4378910363,
-0.3527468145,
0.5798736811,
0.8424301744,
0.1720162481,
0.2682003677,
0.4512925744,
-0.1595085412,
-0.1601604223,
0.910291791,
0.3955323994,
0.4289776385,
0.5128670931,
0.3599049747,
-0.2382832766,
-0.2762293816,
0.050154455,
0.1758837998,
-0.6987031102,
0.0957493931,
-0.9602731466,
-0.0346657559,
-0.6490413547,
0.217375353,
-0.2116304934,
-0.5039404035,
-0.3102478385,
0.0161711164,
0.1738801301,
1.0151184797,
-0.2553811073,
0.3870246112,
-0.5858232379,
0.3373999894,
0.8488566279,
0.2010654658,
-0.0921312943,
-0.5486065745,
-0.3033286929,
0.1181904748,
-0.5497974157,
-1.0177022219,
0.2183419764,
0.1841212064,
0.5305233598,
0.2294146568,
-0.0550295115,
0.2671484351,
-0.2763035595,
0.7301244736,
0.1309406459,
-0.8466632962,
0.355376929,
-0.4322987497,
0.3828365207,
0.2415933907,
0.1077515483,
-0.843167901,
-0.6399304271,
-0.810536325,
-0.9928736687,
0.6932089925,
0.1179046631,
0.4796791077,
-0.2564104199,
-0.2371907234,
-0.0232854225,
0.5074599981,
-0.4871292114,
-0.0406230129,
-0.0844971985,
0.179098025,
0.1628838778,
-0.2120782584,
-0.1857358664,
0.0526455566,
0.2545678616,
0.1355813444,
0.5492009521,
0.1799227893,
0.1009089425,
-0.4040327072,
0.6999517679,
0.6740221977,
0.406478256,
-0.1698443145,
0.3275930882,
-0.0545712374,
-0.4326009154,
-0.1866999716,
-0.1949693859,
0.0263831764,
-0.1381802261,
-0.0691410005,
0.9711251855,
0.3895378113,
-0.5184937716,
0.3218729794,
-0.1770393401,
-0.2843075097,
-0.2187991142,
0.4040592015,
0.1525683254,
0.3759818673,
0.4545049071,
0.1078420728,
0.1031330302,
-1.1362608671,
0.1954693496,
0.2198693752,
-0.3517099917,
-0.3493323624,
0.5894476771,
0.3291654289,
-0.5001451373,
0.4428474009,
0.0495814271,
-0.0232360344,
0.3622230887,
0.2322412282,
0.8182236552,
-0.01260495,
-0.0969509929,
-0.1166714355,
-0.0527595207,
-0.1057067439,
0.4369429946,
-0.1969505548,
-0.7358909845,
-0.5102104545,
-0.3404663503,
-0.5506647825,
0.2984652519,
-0.8366796374,
0.0849484131,
-0.4951530099,
-0.6291607022,
0.2749824226,
-0.2251439393,
-0.9092410803,
-0.0472687557,
0.4318871498,
0.6754751205,
-0.5255780816,
0.7227392197,
0.5004037023,
-0.4328341186,
-0.6934126616,
0.1965558082,
0.1502796859,
-0.6562816501,
0.3917164207,
0.1164866164,
-0.4384223521,
0.3182885647,
-0.716065228,
-0.932356298,
0.752807498,
0.2638816237,
-0.4367566705,
-0.0346507467,
-0.0853965506,
0.6468377113,
-0.3745120466,
0.0909376815,
0.7335447073,
0.3470924795,
0.1827846915,
-0.6047896147,
-0.4057410359,
-0.2114581019,
-0.0463724323,
0.3122363687,
-0.6712560654,
0.9265447259,
-0.4660621583,
-0.6140972972,
0.235631898,
0.8405249715,
-0.2684542537,
0.1810162067,
0.2641873956,
0.4010740221,
0.8325117826,
-0.0936304852,
1.02196455,
-0.0246366095,
-0.1229429245,
1.1038320065,
-0.0802507401,
0.9403944016,
0.7381721735,
-0.0711644068,
0.5636721849,
0.2039367855,
0.3532065749,
0.3914962411,
0.4005068243,
-0.0256240051,
-0.02315614,
-0.5355315208,
-0.1364164352,
0.438672334,
0.6755523086,
-0.1128707007,
0.1752435863,
0.161807254,
-0.0540839918,
-0.0762353167,
-0.2035107464,
0.9994624853,
0.0562430508,
-1.03424716,
0.3788332343,
-0.4075410068,
0.4664426744,
-0.6676130295,
0.2962982357,
-0.2382475585,
-0.0221017469,
0.0433365479,
-1.162494421,
0.1633642763,
-0.1605523974,
-0.2491440028,
-0.3411050439,
0.4768670499,
-0.6703647971,
0.0349750482,
0.3495880067,
0.4768902361,
0.4802719951,
0.0304735769,
-0.2903753817,
0.1996149719,
-0.1044002101,
-0.2021809816,
0.3686199784,
0.9286401868,
0.1569156945,
0.530149281,
0.6034861207,
0.3993219435,
0.3761836588,
0.2589884102,
0.6412171125,
-0.6687083244,
-0.8161706924,
-0.5367389321,
0.5060028434,
-0.083805427,
-0.5315233469,
0.3032006621,
-0.0403180197,
0.905459702,
0.2900417745,
0.7146033049,
-0.1301077455,
0.6523588896,
-0.5148050189,
0.4895652235,
-0.4338870347,
0.1396820098,
-0.046398554,
-0.5160909891,
0.1237566471,
0.3161468208,
-0.3134143353,
-0.2438602448,
0.7311441302,
0.605443418,
0.1227856502,
0.3984194696,
0.5932286382,
0.4841144979,
0.1848983467,
0.4439182878,
0.9949992895,
-0.0406915881,
1.0718156099,
-0.1609833241,
-0.1359502375,
-0.4076785147,
-0.6968423128,
-0.5435363054,
-0.764552772,
-0.2653438747,
-0.2975511551,
-0.2443258911,
0.8098040819,
0.7035999298,
-0.5195833445,
-0.6137549281,
-0.1914721727,
-0.0142189832,
-0.1604414284,
-0.2652448714,
-0.1359821856,
-0.5357230306,
-0.6124203801,
0.3202010691,
0.581404984,
0.3986458182,
-0.2613904774,
0.2145853341,
-0.2284826487,
0.3800287247,
0.392383635,
0.5457777381,
-0.6086102724,
-0.2381198853,
-0.1249998882,
-0.4943773746,
0.2505494952,
1.0720027685,
-0.542714119,
0.5404814482,
0.5988038778,
0.6855503321,
0.4325092137,
-0.2097591013,
0.7884936929,
-0.8674091697,
0.3441052437,
0.1985170841,
0.2103835642,
0.3984788358,
-0.2768789232,
0.1642657518,
0.3892694116,
-0.5687687993,
-0.4569149613,
0.4827542901,
-0.8092494607,
-0.2326727808,
0.8104718328,
0.1641685814,
-0.5270112157,
-0.5247969031,
-0.4499768317,
0.3976699412,
-0.7199584246,
1.0168517828,
1.0731184483,
-0.2822133601,
-0.2480824441,
-0.6100770235,
0.4283866882,
0.5038629174,
-0.7575514913,
0.1573260874,
0.5257359147,
-0.0971466303,
0.5404114127,
0.9440345764,
0.2118290216,
0.2406356186,
0.0637279898,
-0.337128371,
0.5153144002,
-0.5207601786,
0.0741086602,
0.2381998748,
-0.0223194528,
-0.3243317604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09738v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09738v4
|
Evaluating Large Language Models as Generative User Simulators for Conversational Recommendation
| 2024-03-13T18:16:21 | 2024-03-25T23:53:01 |
Se-eun Yoon, Zhankui He, Jessica Maria Echterhoff, Julian McAuley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Synthetic users are cost-effective proxies for real users in the evaluation
of conversational recommender systems. Large language models show promise in
simulating human-like behavior, raising the question of their ability to
represent a diverse population of users. We introduce a new protocol to measure
the degree to which language models can accurately emulate human behavior in
conversational recommendation. This protocol is comprised of five tasks, each
designed to evaluate a key property that a synthetic user should exhibit:
choosing which items to talk about, expressing binary preferences, expressing
open-ended preferences, requesting recommendations, and giving feedback.
Through evaluation of baseline simulators, we demonstrate these tasks
effectively reveal deviations of language models from human behavior, and offer
insights on how to reduce the deviations with model selection and prompting
strategies.
|
[
-0.4161353409,
-0.804335475,
0.5229936242,
0.3842785656,
0.0282225423,
0.155076772,
-0.3872480094,
-0.3772310913,
0.3235324025,
0.6232805848,
-0.5727483034,
-0.2346489578,
0.0589812137,
-0.0330160186,
-0.447309643,
0.7324909568,
0.1822042018,
0.1008266807,
-0.4682628512,
0.3166663945,
-0.5371076465,
-0.6835558414,
-0.6353657842,
-0.6077657938,
0.4115591347,
0.2540433109,
0.8426520824,
0.2098494023,
0.2204025686,
0.3813888133,
-0.0868005678,
-0.0223063231,
-0.6560216546,
0.1087154746,
-0.2649278343,
-0.2883931696,
-0.3667052686,
0.1129354537,
0.5575348139,
0.7727965713,
-0.4165348709,
0.176047653,
-0.0967992395,
0.2991960347,
-0.4490412772,
0.0381963179,
-0.3197759688,
-0.1026085913,
-0.0000215169,
-0.0406154357,
-0.6774933338,
-0.342936933,
0.4455323219,
-0.5792985559,
0.3395311534,
0.3743050694,
0.3682965934,
-0.5057829022,
-0.4410223365,
-0.0516010821,
-1.0817426443,
0.7554044724,
-0.6554746032,
0.4951779544,
0.4984035492,
0.663238585,
-0.3691365123,
-0.6909427047,
-0.7491012216,
-1.020483017,
-0.1371143013,
-0.1120504215,
-0.2209884226,
0.1682546139,
0.4940206409,
0.4170419872,
-0.4250568151,
-0.169172138,
-0.4154238403,
-0.3313520551,
0.7027276754,
0.2504911721,
0.5411655307,
-0.0158665441,
-0.1485023052,
-0.2783441544,
-0.5166648626,
-0.2717809677,
0.7072145939,
0.1641965657,
-0.2672451437,
0.6909961104,
-0.3652392626,
0.6607609987,
0.0179063585,
0.1193611994,
0.2106321007,
-0.556388557,
-0.1155979186,
-0.2661260962,
0.7363359928,
0.6170656681,
0.634944737,
-0.3382088244,
-0.1353828311,
0.1622038633,
0.4745939374,
-0.7759836912,
-0.3233088553,
0.0415412895,
-0.5200027823,
-0.2231491059,
0.0300205424,
-0.7509714365,
-0.3978118896,
-0.34094733,
0.3091609478,
-0.4131034613,
-0.3871580362,
0.2527993619,
-0.3715005517,
-0.0628262088,
0.449390769,
-1.2931729555,
0.7349780202,
0.5779091716,
0.7023209929,
-0.085322924,
-0.4430038035,
-0.3840901256,
-0.0674786121,
-0.2515605688,
0.68553406,
-0.6002230048,
-0.8479649425,
-0.0018280629,
-0.1584626287,
0.0726811811,
-0.6958051324,
0.5329172015,
-0.4205508828,
-0.0169556476,
-0.4755427837,
-0.4962339699,
0.0054826559,
0.3626975715,
-0.5370281935,
0.7694908977,
0.4227399528,
-0.3034573495,
0.2100257725,
-0.6821992993,
-0.1990826875,
0.2396704555,
0.2526169419,
0.0914836973,
0.1688901633,
0.1452708393,
0.3299528658,
-0.3225205839,
0.2196004391,
-0.478441596,
-0.4507633448,
0.556152761,
-0.3679813147,
0.6667162776,
0.2898988426,
0.2833064198,
0.4787353873,
-0.5113105774,
0.060040839,
0.1859175712,
-0.2340038568,
-0.3700927794,
0.0198832881,
0.6418277621,
-0.0107853319,
0.0714631975,
-0.6822195649,
0.4747299552,
-0.6149419546,
0.5471875668,
0.4764358103,
0.1276707202,
0.4409444332,
-0.5987939835,
0.6677883267,
-0.2794967294,
0.1956453621,
-0.1636157781,
-0.4237047136,
-0.8057999015,
-0.1078567281,
0.265030086,
0.0799837634,
-0.3787330091,
0.3911855519,
-0.0670939609,
-0.7649502754,
-0.4264552891,
0.1482190192,
0.3684541583,
-0.0046600653,
0.0464406572,
-0.4472125769,
-0.6093096733,
-0.9008193612,
-0.3544941843,
-0.487110436,
-0.2543159723,
0.3820269406,
0.596598506,
-0.5037368536,
0.8790537715,
-0.3603039384,
0.0859360397,
-0.4322495759,
0.3222029209,
-0.214308694,
0.4419484138,
0.712204814,
-0.5734043717,
-0.3293817043,
-0.0837485641,
-0.2936055362,
-0.0600881316,
-0.1960983723,
-0.1379844844,
-0.1590935588,
0.3083234429,
-0.5995251536,
0.0474925339,
0.6853402853,
-0.4772958755,
0.7422559261,
-0.5035480857,
0.1881534755,
-0.9619151354,
0.1308941692,
0.2412075847,
-0.3332362771,
-0.5620556474,
0.0671926737,
-0.177180022,
-0.2357545048,
-0.3136239052,
0.8592079282,
-0.2663942277,
-0.2153960317,
-0.0681788102,
-0.0295620728,
-0.1248814166,
0.1892716736,
-0.0436665788,
0.7479125857,
0.324357748,
-0.4171118736,
0.6759741902,
0.2173786312,
-0.6601058841,
0.4920271635,
-0.9395769238,
0.442307353,
0.0441543236,
0.4996801615,
-1.0265284777,
-0.3541873693,
0.1133596599,
-0.3194702268,
-0.3164577484,
-0.1062755063,
-0.6108044386,
-0.4483991265,
-0.1612989753,
0.3555388153,
0.7169821858,
-0.3523500264,
0.637835741,
0.3597500026,
0.1141133979,
-0.0537283756,
-0.1119642854,
0.2224617153,
-0.039920222,
-0.5272099376,
0.3753082752,
-0.39060238,
-0.4529996216,
-0.2337875962,
0.363433212,
0.1315883696,
0.1422091275,
0.3471502364,
0.1566966921,
-0.0063388599,
-0.2075728774,
-0.1628445834,
0.0153752817,
0.2135609686,
-0.2265412509,
1.0067718029,
-0.2057280838,
-0.5034980178,
-0.6935118437,
0.1917901635,
0.7029710412,
-0.1554285139,
0.4960643947,
0.5098931193,
-0.2797436416,
-0.1885179728,
-0.7001407146,
-0.548246026,
-0.4900949001,
0.4195727408,
-0.4193920493,
-0.6586020589,
0.41959548,
-0.1196869984,
0.0650992766,
0.1302546263,
0.8740098476,
-0.0070361164,
1.3928185701,
0.4888888896,
0.1040288657,
0.3528039455,
-0.1982133687,
0.2427240014,
-0.6489137411,
-0.3816126883,
-0.5270797014,
-0.1719009131,
-0.3634321094,
-0.4409790039,
0.1434810013,
0.0134039549,
-0.064785786,
0.3493493199,
-0.0115166474,
0.4402115643,
0.7949691415,
0.0838939995,
0.1865734011,
0.0453217253,
-0.2156837732,
-0.0026558754,
-0.2961890697,
-0.6073064804,
0.8352114558,
0.3479259908,
0.8139499426,
-0.0244253948,
0.2914430499,
0.5969759822,
0.3382967114,
-1.0463110209,
0.7948381901,
0.0837356374,
-0.5595204234,
-0.2291448563,
-0.3084205389,
-0.7814956307,
0.1168272197,
-0.4006756544,
-1.0371669531,
-0.0952734351,
0.5813288093,
-0.2762990892,
0.0097509837,
-0.7506305575,
0.9504246116,
-0.122246258,
-0.0624865778,
-0.647869885,
-0.2313332111,
0.3037793338,
0.0770107731,
-0.1012684926,
-0.0735919252,
0.5113982558,
0.6600552201,
-0.2279900908,
0.8844755292,
-0.1381135136,
0.1332714558,
0.1907884926,
0.5785349011,
0.3713794351,
-0.0817314684,
-0.1764745861,
0.1474778503,
0.2436487526,
-0.1432632953,
-0.8592187762,
0.7008597851,
-0.7398962379,
-0.6148608923,
-0.197699368,
-0.4805915952,
-0.2504016161,
-0.061792396,
-0.2726706862,
0.2462705374,
-0.9498324394,
0.3529321849,
0.013833194,
-0.2493274212,
-0.0550497659,
0.50233078,
-0.5966958404,
-0.2696613967,
0.8373552561,
-0.269571811,
0.3497751355,
0.134828642,
0.4896757603,
-0.3780525327,
-0.3441213667,
-0.6430285573,
0.2145116329,
-0.373436749,
0.343152076,
-0.7326036692,
0.0384045057,
-0.5308837891,
-0.1867114007,
-0.2614747584,
-0.2090450674,
0.036530368,
-0.1894629598,
0.1429343969,
0.7849068642,
0.3007048368,
0.5010419488,
-0.6212121248,
0.2707462609,
0.5268871188,
0.2422092706,
0.16878438,
-0.4116471112,
-0.0290498361,
0.4026585221,
-0.2841549218,
-0.6720172763,
0.5842938423,
0.1127440557,
0.6224647164,
0.7059952021,
-0.0214553457,
0.4940543771,
-0.4711157084,
0.8333370686,
0.2214431763,
-1.1041146517,
0.42422539,
-0.4409343898,
0.030754162,
0.297723949,
0.2336995602,
-0.9399796128,
-0.1236762777,
-0.4392392337,
-0.3733125627,
0.6889665127,
0.3125498295,
0.7268526554,
-0.1288789213,
0.319440037,
-0.0940294564,
0.0820815265,
-0.4256730378,
-0.0168876816,
-0.0193791743,
-0.0141438209,
-0.2814851701,
-0.5984129906,
-0.1399766952,
-0.2163814604,
0.2658664882,
-0.0823724195,
0.1264113039,
-0.2259801775,
0.2110233903,
-0.220889166,
0.1559506506,
0.5216403008,
0.6679567099,
-0.3711092174,
-0.0570341982,
0.178998962,
-0.3000237644,
0.1789813936,
-0.2153995335,
-0.2167821378,
-0.206246227,
0.0045579174,
0.7565173507,
0.2362088263,
-1.0655938387,
0.4345113337,
-0.3013022244,
-0.1209026426,
-0.3811213076,
0.3149894476,
0.2779703438,
0.0073272898,
-0.0881910995,
0.0759181827,
0.3747417629,
-0.9582835436,
-0.0281878915,
0.4407991171,
-0.4884804785,
-0.7342327833,
0.470713973,
0.5205376148,
-0.8371526003,
0.8246358633,
0.0418056883,
-0.3226397038,
0.4980888963,
1.0248063803,
0.8540690541,
-0.3241218925,
0.5040551424,
0.3600153625,
0.0369579606,
-0.4971934855,
0.1563313901,
-0.1211358309,
-0.9623680711,
-0.0641415268,
-0.6988716125,
-0.6378463507,
0.0393974185,
-0.5633375645,
0.4314930439,
-0.3136695623,
-0.303640455,
0.307343632,
-0.2894105017,
-0.5484637618,
-0.1221416369,
-0.0115433652,
0.7298026085,
-0.8682344556,
0.8034934998,
0.8638513088,
-0.3913799226,
-0.4421652555,
-0.032396365,
-0.0437654629,
-0.5794088244,
0.7576159835,
0.0680515394,
-0.1566856802,
-0.0352066383,
-0.3682366908,
-0.3940554261,
0.5351910591,
0.5567178726,
-0.6063703895,
-0.0690737292,
0.0290372223,
0.7857632041,
-0.4038226008,
0.5499389768,
0.5833724737,
0.3623254895,
0.2387337536,
-1.1844364405,
0.005820679,
-0.2496468723,
0.3540297151,
-0.0502001233,
-0.4675965309,
0.6452980638,
-0.4005582929,
-0.1605054736,
0.4215298593,
0.5086995363,
0.3995290399,
0.0815139338,
0.8953197598,
0.1812147051,
0.4321323931,
0.2279655188,
1.239646554,
-0.296669364,
0.21970433,
0.8247183561,
-0.689675808,
0.8883841634,
0.5113113523,
-0.2347432673,
0.4561593235,
0.4106906652,
-0.1108634546,
0.2339408249,
0.6860188246,
-0.3599738777,
-0.4164448678,
-0.3358221352,
0.0561791733,
0.6082337499,
0.3364515305,
-0.2385458797,
0.0302318428,
0.0661347508,
-0.1716904938,
0.1791318804,
0.1861119568,
0.8610241413,
-0.0470298454,
-0.9496030807,
0.4890840352,
0.2689020336,
0.4011850953,
-0.5905780196,
-0.4085030556,
-0.0681068823,
0.1124192402,
0.1449721754,
-0.4947875142,
-0.0204203092,
-0.0732036382,
-0.1598782837,
-0.2899333835,
0.5144992471,
-0.3289351463,
-0.4753080904,
0.3563183844,
0.3675628603,
0.2701233327,
-0.1873725057,
-0.5154929161,
-0.1354252249,
-0.0665594786,
-0.2013576776,
0.2947971523,
-0.0721233115,
-0.3946671784,
0.9719705582,
0.9750076532,
0.3049740493,
-0.2732062936,
0.546233952,
0.6499675512,
-0.495972693,
-0.4767402411,
-0.7799373865,
0.2250991017,
-0.215000391,
-0.3321252465,
0.7764850855,
0.5453613997,
0.9652841687,
-0.3638139069,
0.663187623,
0.0287710596,
0.3327306807,
-0.2825795114,
0.696174264,
-0.2477504611,
0.3474245369,
-0.1227871925,
-1.1441212893,
0.0239469726,
0.6312940121,
-0.1916386485,
0.3081302345,
0.3244293332,
0.9970736504,
-0.2510055602,
0.0143287368,
0.5883708596,
0.1181024313,
0.3993131816,
0.1301918924,
1.165374279,
-0.077171661,
0.2079621404,
-0.2490247041,
-0.1330411732,
-0.4761158824,
-0.6552667022,
-1.0646650791,
-0.4990588427,
-0.1939459294,
-0.3823398352,
0.1371633112,
1.3998639584,
1.0846370459,
-0.8347781897,
-0.7147743106,
-0.0274004452,
-0.2544592321,
-0.3772982061,
-0.2445892841,
-0.0506241843,
0.0036684417,
-1.0197758675,
0.4843884408,
0.0723135993,
0.2217978984,
-0.7729557753,
-0.1138084158,
0.347600311,
0.0997988805,
0.6187443137,
0.1804065108,
-0.940195322,
-0.2489627451,
0.032712318,
-0.0646097213,
-0.4020886123,
1.1516445875,
-0.7490502,
0.7863277793,
0.6005349755,
0.2499269545,
0.5038467646,
0.2264301479,
1.0639061928,
-0.5968253016,
0.2396756709,
0.2469055802,
0.3124134839,
0.2369105965,
-0.1005195826,
0.1079593971,
0.1259010285,
-0.469109416,
-0.8334723711,
0.1611712426,
-1.0784436464,
0.0276367273,
1.237475276,
-0.2319480181,
0.0872872695,
-0.1788046658,
-0.6945165396,
-0.1372064203,
-0.5981343985,
0.9834061861,
0.5511432886,
0.0112113552,
-0.0340489224,
-0.6253830791,
0.42990762,
0.1646443903,
-0.7217799425,
0.3180804551,
0.6484276652,
0.2158823013,
0.0505114757,
0.6938308477,
0.1253240556,
0.1731513888,
-0.0208545197,
0.2026359737,
0.0476636924,
-0.1896458268,
-0.00256645,
-0.0439318679,
0.2824105024,
0.1562745273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08851v1
|
PAPERCLIP: Associating Astronomical Observations and Natural Language with Multi-Modal Models
| 2024-03-13T18:00:00 | 2024-03-13T18:00:00 |
Siddharth Mishra-Sharma, Yiding Song, Jesse Thaler
|
astro-ph.IM
|
astro-ph.IM, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
We present PAPERCLIP (Proposal Abstracts Provide an Effective Representation
for Contrastive Language-Image Pre-training), a method which associates
astronomical observations imaged by telescopes with natural language using a
neural network model. The model is fine-tuned from a pre-trained Contrastive
Language-Image Pre-training (CLIP) model using successful observing proposal
abstracts and corresponding downstream observations, with the abstracts
optionally summarized via guided generation using large language models (LLMs).
Using observations from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) as an example, we show
that the fine-tuned model embodies a meaningful joint representation between
observations and natural language through tests targeting image retrieval
(i.e., finding the most relevant observations using natural language queries)
and description retrieval (i.e., querying for astrophysical object classes and
use cases most relevant to a given observation). Our study demonstrates the
potential for using generalist foundation models rather than task-specific
models for interacting with astronomical data by leveraging text as an
interface.
|
[
-0.4690871537,
-0.6087740064,
0.7095268965,
0.2036246657,
-0.399069041,
-0.1925202012,
-0.4719763398,
-0.7739773393,
0.6734261513,
0.6637321115,
-0.3951039016,
-0.4965362549,
-0.5426760912,
-0.0117196692,
-0.6436740756,
1.3816792965,
-0.0375852585,
-0.2067254484,
-0.5263513327,
0.108547546,
-0.1210977361,
-0.2160354704,
-0.2656213641,
-0.1810610294,
0.5244103074,
0.1462968439,
0.857860744,
0.8511918783,
1.0972037315,
0.3223407269,
0.0397818238,
0.2626847923,
0.0158235896,
-0.43005234,
-0.18872343,
-0.3333901465,
-0.3457991481,
0.248594746,
0.4643957615,
1.0843462944,
0.0533128418,
0.1505456418,
-0.0319921225,
0.317079246,
-0.6256045103,
0.311619848,
-0.5702549815,
-0.1628709882,
-0.2557697594,
-0.3281601965,
-0.0905004591,
-0.1082331836,
0.4314888418,
-0.9666745663,
0.2097366899,
0.057201229,
0.9234675169,
0.0849594548,
-0.3264206052,
-0.7167328,
-0.7461958528,
0.7884716988,
-0.7546189427,
0.2764832973,
0.5535626411,
0.3079644144,
0.1600705981,
-0.8297693729,
-0.6743013263,
-0.4695171714,
-0.2175958306,
0.1626683921,
0.0641159341,
0.0648611337,
-0.2054314166,
0.2006920278,
-0.442830056,
-0.2356809527,
-0.3783219457,
-0.0629994273,
0.2839407921,
0.1697634161,
0.0363048725,
-0.4688345492,
-0.2387693822,
-0.1527202725,
-0.4500643909,
-0.0906983912,
0.4161528945,
0.4623711705,
-0.4402430654,
0.654302597,
0.0015217967,
0.9502875209,
0.0439353362,
-0.1158663034,
-0.0084667299,
-0.6376309395,
-0.0166014358,
-0.4136214554,
0.7151045203,
0.5774973035,
-0.067062825,
-0.2569173574,
-0.0158222746,
0.4136411846,
0.0455248356,
-0.7424137592,
-0.3245928884,
-0.1826269776,
-0.4616952538,
-0.2787752151,
0.4738378525,
-0.8853932619,
-0.1451909691,
-0.7180295587,
0.3269337416,
-0.2089677155,
-0.1390684992,
0.2235862911,
-0.050677985,
-0.2152446806,
0.3555643559,
-1.0151547194,
0.6050943136,
0.8581334949,
0.8041270971,
0.078626588,
-0.5135629773,
-0.2714731097,
0.3658438027,
-0.0974919796,
0.9979414344,
-0.8504241109,
-0.4413203597,
-0.1400140375,
-0.0692409724,
-0.0221222956,
-0.2022625655,
0.6294105053,
-0.423512727,
0.6604803205,
-0.0081562437,
-0.4540324509,
-0.3586848378,
0.2485873252,
-0.5565497875,
0.5161436796,
-0.2670352757,
-0.8549681306,
0.345320344,
-1.0920206308,
-0.2470887154,
-0.1459065229,
-0.4117234945,
-0.1433926076,
0.0155551359,
0.3879342675,
0.2774318159,
-0.2709264755,
0.4378788173,
-0.377206713,
-0.0661862791,
0.2061372846,
-0.2403352857,
0.2287018895,
0.1998146027,
-0.076744698,
0.2193632573,
-0.5843235254,
-0.1762322336,
-0.1995527446,
-0.282502532,
-0.5674386621,
0.2590567172,
0.5257255435,
-0.0684751943,
0.4371994138,
-0.4817908704,
0.3520757258,
-0.4332585335,
0.4177338481,
0.3052099943,
-0.1534622014,
0.5660082102,
-0.2046235055,
0.2928707302,
-0.0776746124,
0.1172946915,
-0.6603374481,
-0.2220291048,
-0.6196886897,
-0.1681494117,
0.1591057479,
0.3669213355,
-0.4153689146,
0.1911613047,
-0.4013180733,
-0.467350632,
-0.3104457557,
0.1454421431,
0.5179981589,
0.8165245652,
0.3210835159,
-0.1917426437,
-0.6436392069,
-1.1515228748,
-0.2061391622,
-0.1503336579,
-0.1419613957,
0.4880225956,
0.7884359956,
-0.1910143495,
0.8953319192,
-0.5338097215,
-0.1809196621,
0.1594834924,
0.5996764302,
0.5318856835,
0.3234042227,
0.6009129882,
-1.0297830105,
-0.3705805242,
0.1409162879,
-0.7357493639,
-0.0184556637,
-0.0102018416,
0.1278989762,
-0.0566819012,
0.481007278,
-0.4569074512,
0.4232790172,
0.7260946035,
-0.3965738714,
0.450091064,
-0.1940010488,
0.222432971,
-1.1337147951,
0.4611750543,
0.0398527011,
-0.1860373169,
-0.4204933345,
-0.0435796082,
-0.0287155192,
-0.2580576539,
-0.3929112852,
0.4448077083,
-0.5444458723,
-0.2577601075,
-0.8147508502,
0.1283705533,
0.209186241,
0.168238312,
0.5360559821,
0.9108929634,
0.3724967539,
-0.4045146406,
-0.2125148922,
0.4188104272,
-0.3380172253,
0.5293198824,
-0.7957022786,
0.0110739246,
-0.2849785388,
0.1338390261,
-0.7873547077,
-0.5008146763,
0.0492017865,
-0.2511364222,
0.0305172782,
0.0256257486,
-0.2137748301,
-0.3014992177,
-0.2403808981,
0.3759691119,
-0.0901993811,
-0.4705059826,
0.6892697811,
0.4776091576,
-0.2926754057,
-0.4069165289,
-0.5573627353,
0.3627036512,
-0.171240285,
-0.5234276652,
0.8201124072,
0.0164094567,
-0.0984314829,
0.1868615896,
0.2369943708,
-0.1506268084,
-0.0744945556,
0.4937950671,
0.3931484222,
-0.1610569507,
-0.0796899199,
-0.2630790472,
-0.0330727771,
-0.030898219,
-0.1245180815,
0.4777939916,
-0.6835215092,
-0.3629538715,
-0.4722209871,
0.5279823542,
0.4476064146,
-0.1241516843,
0.2706571519,
0.3151762784,
-0.3602449596,
0.5119683743,
-0.3688870966,
-0.3308670521,
-0.4557819068,
0.435297966,
-0.2229102552,
-0.6469985247,
0.4672634304,
-0.0326172262,
0.0922100469,
0.2854831517,
0.2483186573,
-0.4132991731,
0.8921582103,
0.9410610795,
-0.0701111183,
0.6290701628,
-0.2431689203,
-0.178797394,
-1.0272057056,
-0.0569558665,
-0.6350161433,
-0.233864665,
-0.2940405905,
-0.3802827299,
0.4038001299,
0.196229741,
-0.1675320417,
0.5237231851,
-0.5470663309,
0.6893383861,
0.5522876382,
0.03515926,
0.4071806669,
-0.1667451113,
0.0473667048,
-0.4194406569,
-0.3833642006,
-0.8567371368,
1.1220794916,
-0.0278612114,
0.8652629852,
-0.1707148254,
0.4530943036,
-0.057559371,
0.5742791295,
-0.306527257,
0.4027301371,
-0.3776293099,
-0.5513994098,
0.1436038911,
-0.2128144205,
-0.8285910487,
0.1659625918,
-0.3592048287,
-0.7435731888,
0.2062426507,
0.2194381952,
-0.2117917985,
0.1200137138,
-0.5234920979,
0.8073925972,
-0.438180238,
-0.2300336063,
-0.2391593605,
-0.7281159759,
0.445602119,
-0.0085039688,
0.3594566584,
0.0791445374,
-0.1435206383,
0.9144152999,
-0.1271485239,
1.1386320591,
0.0376390405,
0.2703866065,
0.2018406242,
0.0263304487,
0.2102158517,
0.1917968094,
-0.0133427242,
0.0092723928,
0.1629316807,
-0.1287594587,
-0.4393624961,
0.6853790283,
-0.8518129587,
-0.4155083001,
-0.3276809752,
-0.8466459513,
-0.0156110339,
0.2853742838,
0.0277787857,
0.5999037027,
-0.2267448902,
0.178051278,
-0.2308306992,
-0.050132025,
0.6964970231,
0.5335977674,
-0.7325615287,
-0.6391968727,
0.6519844532,
-0.1190767139,
0.0885608345,
0.5323212743,
0.2526652813,
-0.3092021048,
-0.5468764901,
0.0337348841,
0.3789690137,
-0.5598685145,
-0.1240155697,
-0.5664082766,
0.0751930252,
-0.1663042158,
-0.4229599535,
-0.3911163509,
-0.5120576024,
-0.3140929043,
0.1340734363,
0.212258324,
0.5062516928,
-0.1327787936,
0.7660807371,
-0.6547681093,
0.3413312435,
0.0775885582,
0.3395092487,
-0.3200936913,
-0.2773781121,
-0.422831893,
0.1327617466,
-0.4937155247,
-0.6430093646,
0.3776116371,
0.6042376757,
0.3406939209,
0.5927342772,
-0.2909269929,
0.9007686973,
-0.414142251,
0.7211418152,
0.4448628724,
-0.9270210266,
0.689278841,
-0.8446641564,
0.5006747842,
0.8572437763,
0.2567983866,
-0.4392801225,
-0.4977841377,
-0.4553389847,
-0.637886405,
0.3846095204,
-0.21971488,
0.1585963666,
-0.0714322776,
0.4112666845,
0.2386728525,
0.6835397482,
-0.9411741495,
0.2451539636,
-0.4941526055,
-0.224598974,
-0.0070844442,
0.1108440906,
-0.405841589,
-0.2083256096,
0.1232767403,
-0.3955614567,
0.3290831149,
0.2737756073,
-0.0430302359,
0.0026169042,
0.0322465375,
0.8338711858,
0.9145578146,
-0.3971506953,
0.4293116927,
-0.4339745939,
-0.5945237279,
-0.4268352985,
0.3204844594,
-0.3141803741,
0.0372643843,
0.608206749,
0.8903560638,
0.480658114,
-0.5715219975,
0.506898284,
0.1339958608,
-0.3126919568,
-0.27550596,
-0.3025409281,
0.3189381957,
0.1012965068,
0.364321202,
0.4277956784,
0.3323277235,
-0.543417573,
0.3048647344,
0.5824425817,
-0.3117133975,
-0.8608414531,
1.0003659725,
0.2506782711,
-0.219178319,
0.2093937099,
0.121691443,
-0.5671974421,
0.5548590422,
0.5736436844,
0.560295701,
0.2641144395,
0.2756003439,
0.0898958668,
0.2263827622,
0.1095367745,
0.2986806035,
-0.0963428244,
-0.5341564417,
-0.6545239091,
-0.5126249194,
-0.6759063601,
0.0061459146,
-0.6438071728,
0.277936548,
-0.4529770017,
-0.2714609802,
0.3615976274,
-0.0026412916,
-0.7769903541,
-0.0255281292,
0.2154269367,
0.799895525,
-0.8229677677,
0.6260030866,
0.8630619049,
-0.4540367424,
-0.4959108829,
-0.2347051352,
-0.0445928648,
-0.4929300845,
0.8976557255,
0.3066952527,
-0.2265168875,
-0.3402017653,
-0.5517803431,
-0.8236992955,
0.7830486894,
0.3700118363,
-0.4986200333,
0.0637860373,
0.1003932729,
0.6056388617,
-0.6912972331,
0.4315549135,
0.0707241893,
0.6942286491,
-0.0325433239,
-1.1306692362,
-0.3560772836,
-0.2950235009,
-0.1390628219,
0.4658416212,
-0.4709961414,
1.010155201,
-0.1520658284,
-0.1237546206,
0.2285673469,
0.8846127987,
0.0846569762,
0.5279339552,
0.5881519318,
0.4770270586,
0.4396502376,
0.0197522156,
1.0129103661,
-0.4535979629,
0.3957418203,
1.2593791485,
-0.4409184754,
1.0272279978,
1.1556047201,
-0.0961834639,
0.3778248727,
0.3362000287,
-0.1106026396,
0.9216403961,
-0.1586023867,
-0.180068031,
-0.0411030948,
-0.4640928805,
-0.3105062246,
0.6398616433,
0.3850049376,
-0.2050920725,
-0.6185160279,
0.2454178482,
-0.0365199074,
0.5562372208,
-0.2244485617,
0.6614940166,
-0.0585600957,
-0.6965147257,
0.1909315735,
-0.0813920125,
0.9345247746,
-0.6312760711,
-0.0673653185,
0.2061130404,
0.065115124,
-0.2581856549,
-0.6878559589,
0.7442768812,
-0.0517775677,
-0.4290090799,
-0.127424255,
0.4462262392,
-0.4703072011,
-0.7673422694,
0.1143369898,
0.273789078,
0.1273689121,
0.1789720058,
-0.4656473398,
-0.0429421328,
-0.2226098776,
-0.2315881252,
0.0932111964,
-0.0536331572,
-0.0050830063,
0.3917035758,
0.8470616937,
0.2858709395,
-0.0186298937,
-0.0997319221,
1.0102499723,
-0.7708043456,
-0.6634988189,
-0.5413714647,
0.2930428088,
-0.1728625298,
-0.5115490556,
0.4910752773,
0.6719533801,
0.4983778596,
-0.1944006085,
0.6254905462,
-0.0887527019,
0.8359504938,
-0.5243174434,
0.3110129535,
-0.4211994112,
0.2025563121,
-0.3099447191,
-0.9477798939,
-0.5216681361,
0.5753961205,
-0.7099444866,
-0.1103504449,
0.6721647382,
0.6788512468,
-0.4068860114,
0.1638614088,
-0.0447313301,
-0.1856218576,
0.4013603926,
0.4548738301,
0.7926024199,
-0.4173919261,
0.7025483251,
-0.2595222592,
-0.141714707,
-0.1683521718,
-1.2880833149,
-0.8969838619,
-0.6303488016,
-0.2781171203,
0.210583955,
-0.0077364435,
0.7075765133,
0.8395590782,
-0.6215517521,
-0.4476559162,
-0.2535092533,
-0.3878804743,
0.0774016306,
-0.2081571072,
0.6399677396,
-0.0710633472,
-0.8019048572,
0.494363457,
0.3195014596,
0.1098282337,
-0.1703159511,
0.1356185824,
-0.2667295337,
-0.1936840415,
0.2989450693,
0.4255299866,
-0.6826742887,
-0.4676270485,
0.2697972655,
0.0516383424,
-0.0764364898,
0.8612400293,
-0.6409835219,
0.3976177275,
0.2374670058,
0.7122968435,
0.7380744219,
0.1059039906,
0.6038807034,
-0.6102877259,
0.6099550724,
0.248704806,
0.3370270133,
0.4331981838,
-0.0633085296,
0.3714491129,
0.0433041267,
-0.635368526,
-0.7854681611,
0.2316517085,
-1.2701877356,
-0.1572238952,
0.6506847143,
0.0686139166,
-0.271939218,
0.1411753148,
-0.2752547264,
-0.1422796398,
-0.3050325513,
0.9655187726,
0.7613787055,
-0.2127393484,
-0.3074753582,
-0.6609677076,
0.2333770543,
0.437761724,
-0.9103230834,
-0.2052598447,
0.4738634229,
0.0237215571,
0.7466604114,
0.3690991104,
-0.2388506532,
0.1927526444,
-0.1898580641,
0.1387471706,
-0.3634355664,
-0.4353391826,
-0.0583852567,
0.1598638892,
-0.0566122159,
-0.2577659786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08763v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08763v3
|
Simple and Scalable Strategies to Continually Pre-train Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T17:58:57 | 2024-03-26T17:58:48 |
Adam Ibrahim, Benjamin Thérien, Kshitij Gupta, Mats L. Richter, Quentin Anthony, Timothée Lesort, Eugene Belilovsky, Irina Rish
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are routinely pre-trained on billions of tokens,
only to start the process over again once new data becomes available. A much
more efficient solution is to continually pre-train these models, saving
significant compute compared to re-training. However, the distribution shift
induced by new data typically results in degraded performance on previous data
or poor adaptation to the new data. In this work, we show that a simple and
scalable combination of learning rate (LR) re-warming, LR re-decaying, and
replay of previous data is sufficient to match the performance of fully
re-training from scratch on all available data, as measured by the final loss
and the average score on several language model (LM) evaluation benchmarks.
Specifically, we show this for a weak but realistic distribution shift between
two commonly used LLM pre-training datasets (English$\rightarrow$English) and a
stronger distribution shift (English$\rightarrow$German) at the $405$M
parameter model scale with large dataset sizes (hundreds of billions of
tokens). Selecting the weak but realistic shift for larger-scale experiments,
we also find that our continual learning strategies match the re-training
baseline for a 10B parameter LLM. Our results demonstrate that LLMs can be
successfully updated via simple and scalable continual learning strategies,
matching the re-training baseline using only a fraction of the compute.
Finally, inspired by previous work, we propose alternatives to the cosine
learning rate schedule that help circumvent forgetting induced by LR re-warming
and that are not bound to a fixed token budget.
|
[
-0.2188988775,
-0.5576915145,
0.3577520847,
0.1422917694,
-0.3837081492,
0.0215522423,
-0.6352657676,
0.009320464,
0.1908947825,
0.4037613869,
-0.5472319126,
-0.2174041569,
-0.4094176888,
-0.029358007,
-0.2014103681,
0.8540975451,
-0.1226021349,
0.049622301,
0.0555291064,
-0.1397708356,
-0.3413019478,
-0.5660580397,
-1.1641683578,
-0.4389370978,
0.7255700231,
0.369625181,
0.5006546974,
0.6196942925,
0.4696272314,
0.173575446,
0.0255162884,
-0.0780564845,
-0.9245032072,
0.1325210035,
-0.0392986163,
-0.5343571901,
-0.2090316266,
-0.1452679634,
0.9769601822,
0.7977421284,
-0.4623185396,
0.2549080551,
0.0222520903,
0.6100363731,
-0.6411633492,
0.1171880066,
-0.9317168593,
-0.0042986716,
-0.3035460711,
-0.2620802224,
-0.7678587437,
-0.3086034954,
-0.0859180987,
-0.4644474685,
0.1152807251,
-0.1141051799,
0.7431932688,
0.2136559784,
-0.1468399912,
-0.0174819361,
-0.7278298736,
0.8477450609,
-0.6594436169,
0.7860383987,
0.1886824518,
0.2804968655,
-0.1088400707,
-0.7087208033,
-0.3948512077,
-0.4579432309,
0.2705111802,
-0.022872312,
0.0302489828,
-0.4130387008,
0.1705669165,
0.1562229842,
-0.1800899953,
0.4028756022,
-0.0644784868,
-0.1637945175,
0.5557872653,
0.2136224806,
0.0325511657,
0.4857481122,
-0.2591208518,
-0.614141643,
-1.0217547417,
0.000360934,
0.2398364842,
0.4342929721,
-0.0370709486,
0.1373668313,
0.1772003323,
0.5064841509,
0.1958732307,
-0.2706454992,
0.4667801857,
-0.3526324332,
0.0269714799,
-0.1822334677,
0.5463554263,
0.1203745306,
0.432053864,
-0.275819391,
-0.4695438147,
-0.1848084033,
0.2533033788,
-0.7164233923,
-0.236834988,
-0.2091601789,
-0.1990643442,
-0.0260207877,
-0.3368136585,
-0.5754641891,
-0.0577487983,
-0.4751125276,
0.4869252443,
-0.2860334814,
-0.3353586793,
0.2889770865,
0.2078888118,
0.4021378756,
0.3977859914,
-1.0497823954,
0.2702419162,
0.4350579083,
0.8020156026,
-0.3429104984,
-0.4394503534,
-0.6380221844,
0.0053576222,
-0.6642147899,
0.6242355108,
-0.2880709171,
-0.1809532344,
0.1056769937,
0.0989682376,
-0.1584732234,
-0.5593448281,
0.2196311206,
-0.6706848145,
0.0971752331,
-0.3190488815,
-0.4939149022,
0.3509238064,
0.2920137942,
-0.786480546,
0.9401296377,
0.0860093907,
-0.7039123774,
0.6053004861,
-0.3302705586,
-0.4666449726,
-0.1614505947,
0.2182108909,
-0.7318747044,
0.1159916297,
0.0881941617,
0.4249075949,
-0.135438934,
0.1030535847,
-0.3662766516,
-0.4026312828,
0.0376066789,
-0.5907216668,
0.5030946136,
0.1395289451,
-0.2421084791,
-0.0301664621,
-0.5891755223,
0.0576937795,
0.1752364188,
-0.6550155878,
-0.1961883605,
0.0833962113,
0.0399761945,
-0.0262118354,
0.2617867589,
-0.2081647217,
0.343184799,
-0.3970142305,
0.2918677032,
0.8496357203,
-0.0221639015,
0.5008413792,
-0.3766939342,
0.4406583905,
0.060742747,
0.0819391608,
-0.3065718114,
0.160996139,
-0.8963751197,
-0.3051061928,
0.2147563249,
0.5267820954,
-0.6593849659,
0.3549742103,
-0.6350491643,
-0.5327854753,
-0.4746569991,
0.3019645214,
0.1895113438,
0.304264605,
0.4293878675,
-0.2396887541,
-0.5259134173,
-0.5503373146,
-0.2541842163,
-0.0157190301,
0.0457698405,
0.0175745934,
0.3508662879,
-0.1503911167,
0.7472594976,
-0.3635724783,
0.1809069067,
-0.4389930665,
-0.0355046131,
0.3182359934,
0.3386816978,
0.280184865,
-0.4387556314,
-0.5420270562,
-0.0333654135,
-0.4471264482,
-0.0510515757,
-0.3371489644,
-0.0297788233,
0.3310850859,
0.8363469243,
-0.4488690495,
0.0423183814,
0.4783449769,
0.0333100334,
0.5979194045,
-0.3245322406,
-0.1223169789,
-1.0709095001,
-0.0886165276,
-0.2770777941,
-0.3502888083,
-0.6112226248,
-0.1092065498,
0.1340609789,
-0.0452809036,
-0.6051797271,
0.8602671027,
-0.6060741544,
0.1340798289,
-0.1052693948,
0.0433003493,
-0.326233983,
0.2854525745,
0.1049021855,
0.7090805769,
0.5777643919,
-0.7707240582,
0.1188220456,
-0.0621291623,
-0.3316056132,
0.2707137764,
-0.5865027308,
0.2655135393,
-0.1673564911,
0.3845852911,
-0.7293228507,
0.1443960369,
0.0229481757,
-0.0078764688,
0.5827009678,
-0.0359702371,
-0.5099313259,
-0.282258451,
-0.3090211153,
0.3302345276,
0.7716743946,
-0.7086509466,
0.5047934055,
0.0871403068,
-0.0992060527,
-0.6113182902,
-0.4684112668,
0.0514703766,
-0.4009130597,
-0.2964317799,
0.196828872,
-0.1769742668,
-0.0383384638,
-0.1928914487,
-0.0874830112,
0.2226786911,
0.2212935984,
-0.1071929038,
0.0866191015,
-0.2142732292,
0.3122334778,
-0.3860023618,
-0.2797930241,
-0.0946641192,
-0.4694179296,
0.9080625772,
-0.0496519431,
-0.3577805758,
-0.3245598376,
-0.0778824762,
0.6157671213,
-0.0362514965,
1.0310366154,
0.5920240879,
-0.2157222182,
-0.1730821133,
-0.7198398113,
-0.3177901208,
-0.4062880874,
0.6054568887,
-0.4856263995,
-0.7442630529,
0.5111772418,
-0.1701320112,
0.246691376,
0.2832895815,
0.6959802508,
-0.0580572709,
0.5885938406,
0.7895385027,
-0.4500646889,
0.7829112411,
-0.0621316768,
0.1779544204,
-0.5511364341,
0.0154530834,
-0.3338913321,
-0.0866282061,
-0.3111031651,
-0.420098424,
0.21014072,
0.2801811099,
-0.5829534531,
0.1963743865,
0.0345926322,
0.5556718707,
0.3020791411,
0.0186514147,
0.0603428446,
0.2222097665,
0.1097545251,
0.0081990566,
-0.8717526197,
-0.1969262213,
1.3644558191,
0.4880351126,
1.0069783926,
-0.0062141581,
0.9609158635,
0.023802489,
0.6409122944,
-0.446639359,
0.3813279569,
-0.176295191,
-0.125167042,
-0.6172599196,
-0.693898797,
-1.1202584505,
0.142483592,
-0.1690371931,
-0.2575867474,
-0.0785743445,
0.4370712936,
-0.0053021251,
0.479807049,
-0.6953954101,
0.7250083089,
-0.3320258856,
-0.3054407537,
-0.2604839504,
-0.367716074,
0.1867183894,
-0.4981004,
0.2542838156,
0.0317030959,
-0.0775758922,
0.7026438713,
-0.2715569437,
0.8614798188,
-0.2452062517,
-0.1018149108,
0.046338845,
-0.0009437809,
0.7863496542,
-0.0530307665,
0.0092360154,
0.1468401402,
-0.185342133,
-0.64066571,
-0.5285992026,
0.4536535144,
-0.8859113455,
-0.5189656615,
-0.1578734219,
-0.4615840316,
-0.1999611109,
0.2103136629,
0.3202184737,
0.3182608485,
-0.2820270658,
0.3115184605,
0.7529879808,
-0.151631847,
0.4085486829,
0.4918845594,
-0.3144146204,
-0.3645910919,
0.7599945664,
0.1037655547,
0.7670330405,
0.4154069126,
0.3544878662,
-0.4348249137,
-0.4998183548,
-0.165794611,
0.3296093345,
-0.6026381254,
-0.0556069165,
-0.4888512194,
-0.1233773604,
-0.3868198991,
-0.3860952258,
-0.5397763252,
-0.0078191711,
-0.0483739562,
0.0115029952,
0.3179390728,
0.2736811936,
-0.1676307023,
0.4036672413,
-0.407720536,
0.0627863705,
0.2324991822,
0.2402197719,
0.1775799245,
-0.8203531504,
-0.4120648205,
0.1113267839,
0.0915853456,
-0.4229956865,
0.3054909706,
0.3816035688,
0.6563590765,
0.1626684219,
-0.2220738679,
0.7311475873,
-0.7891969085,
0.5864112377,
0.476126343,
-0.7319501638,
0.2079175562,
-0.0632400364,
0.5774180889,
0.6540597081,
0.4923511147,
-0.6558882594,
-0.2276355922,
-0.5287334919,
-0.8934246898,
0.353666991,
-0.2886745036,
0.451521486,
-0.1191736907,
0.4906106591,
0.0666544959,
0.0971427038,
-0.820980072,
-0.1326124817,
-0.2551728189,
-0.1432245523,
-0.5815911889,
-0.2311920077,
0.0549341477,
-0.2878963351,
0.5543708205,
-0.128302604,
-0.0444671363,
-0.2079568952,
-0.2511171699,
0.0882473812,
0.2943582535,
0.3669633865,
0.7470574975,
-0.2932022512,
0.1589967757,
0.5820270181,
-0.5270921588,
0.4664764106,
-0.2219692618,
-0.1784355491,
-0.0813527629,
0.5996738076,
0.9108396769,
0.6539655924,
-0.639844358,
0.3397113979,
0.0387183428,
-0.0462417565,
-0.5383102298,
-0.0002336154,
0.3671070039,
-0.038753055,
0.2398278713,
-0.0969166756,
-0.7557111979,
-0.7170240283,
0.4183378518,
0.3668745458,
-0.1799720973,
-0.2850459814,
0.4062004685,
-0.0552192442,
-0.3144043982,
0.8218246102,
-0.1971205175,
-0.4097037613,
0.2220044881,
0.7044913173,
0.7034760714,
-0.5125879645,
0.1704106331,
0.4489706755,
0.3093385994,
-0.7270737886,
0.069180429,
0.1203025058,
-0.8993597627,
-0.5022293329,
-0.707185626,
-0.1928677857,
0.1362379491,
-0.6441431642,
0.4226845503,
-0.5567260981,
-0.0395903066,
-0.3427507877,
-0.0120439501,
-0.904791832,
0.1415930539,
0.0711126029,
1.0710362196,
-0.9817025661,
1.0177692175,
0.3066186607,
-0.3043538928,
-0.8498431444,
0.0252414905,
-0.2983664274,
-0.9838614464,
0.733098805,
-0.127444461,
-0.1195767522,
0.1646444649,
-0.5042881966,
-1.0925893784,
0.9614723921,
0.5386629105,
-1.0051381588,
-0.019179482,
-0.0557514057,
0.6143017411,
-0.370395124,
0.151326105,
0.6038860679,
0.2668362558,
0.1751804352,
-0.7185726166,
-0.1163276061,
0.0970630348,
-0.1238669232,
0.4250407815,
-0.577491641,
0.9735975266,
-0.3101089001,
-0.2586584687,
-0.2431959659,
0.5095706582,
0.2507515848,
0.1744942665,
0.7492055893,
0.7977673411,
0.8065884113,
0.0272443891,
0.956224978,
-0.2678836882,
0.4893296659,
1.0590275526,
-0.424552083,
1.3021765947,
0.4522623718,
-0.2460076213,
0.2235856503,
0.5847551823,
-0.0034843883,
0.6101677418,
0.5050395727,
-0.2173250914,
-0.5288956761,
0.281916678,
-0.4348243177,
0.0372113623,
0.0954610258,
0.0928966329,
-0.3760371208,
0.1784358472,
0.370544523,
-0.1141183451,
-0.3787623048,
0.638486445,
0.195571661,
-0.4707527161,
0.9561309218,
-0.3532291353,
0.6992996931,
-0.8931970596,
0.359898001,
-0.4436718225,
0.3644596636,
0.1301429719,
-0.3523889482,
0.1903998554,
-0.1824867725,
-0.2576275468,
-0.3820745349,
0.1825547516,
-0.5505545139,
-0.6497981548,
0.2093602419,
0.2905761003,
0.0764285028,
0.2331091017,
-0.5938479304,
0.3164325356,
0.0369579084,
-0.3525454104,
0.6380260587,
0.3418260515,
-0.1298464537,
0.9089466333,
0.8800715208,
0.3997526169,
0.1799277961,
0.2482491136,
0.7303121686,
-0.6816241145,
-0.3914824426,
-0.7918866873,
0.173225075,
0.1376701593,
-0.3304331303,
0.5950322747,
0.3678902686,
0.8970373869,
-0.0897330269,
0.5764511824,
0.3940653205,
0.3830971122,
-0.8253452182,
0.5152297616,
-0.5490466952,
0.3190194368,
-0.0101648243,
-1.1027286053,
-0.1331965476,
0.4250543714,
-0.3448086381,
0.0912528187,
0.7194637656,
0.6653363109,
0.02465236,
-0.5763795376,
0.2869816124,
0.3992767632,
0.5333276391,
0.6749129891,
0.6790981293,
-0.216248557,
0.3281268477,
0.0364572741,
-0.0915178061,
-0.1282604933,
-0.9701353312,
-0.7200238705,
-0.4769188166,
-0.4175689816,
-0.2876055539,
0.303574115,
0.8017970324,
0.6677185297,
-0.6592286825,
-0.2758758366,
-0.0178321693,
-0.2495278418,
-0.3261356056,
-0.1512640119,
0.6093696356,
-0.8338662982,
-0.40813604,
0.3242561817,
0.1399675757,
-0.0130879562,
-0.3030048311,
-0.1675119847,
-0.1368044466,
0.1318281591,
0.5067328811,
0.454995662,
-0.4959032238,
-0.404104948,
-0.0296233501,
-0.0574725531,
-0.0516988263,
0.7712855935,
-0.6816658974,
0.2564846873,
0.2708723247,
1.0339949131,
0.7305374742,
-0.1530207396,
0.5947586298,
-0.5705615282,
0.2348136157,
0.0943202451,
0.2337745875,
0.4359055758,
-0.1084125936,
0.2767266631,
0.2578042746,
-0.5943512321,
-1.0123209953,
0.1293555349,
-0.7072258592,
-0.1556535512,
1.0138545036,
-0.2254013866,
-0.1232606098,
-0.0112746367,
0.1674310565,
0.0007662949,
0.0050582159,
0.7685021162,
0.7562602758,
0.2498826385,
-0.3583715558,
-0.3950911164,
0.4638675451,
0.519233346,
-0.6486629248,
0.2807022929,
0.2050461769,
0.720882535,
-0.0764972568,
0.8390100002,
0.0715282783,
0.0396682955,
0.0836061984,
0.1144959033,
0.1160635725,
-0.4584803581,
-0.469238162,
-0.0151823442,
0.2564049959,
-0.0387614295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08755v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08755v2
|
DAM: Dynamic Adapter Merging for Continual Video QA Learning
| 2024-03-13T17:53:47 | 2024-04-22T19:17:49 |
Feng Cheng, Ziyang Wang, Yi-Lin Sung, Yan-Bo Lin, Mohit Bansal, Gedas Bertasius
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present a parameter-efficient method for continual video
question-answering (VidQA) learning. Our method, named DAM, uses the proposed
Dynamic Adapter Merging to (i) mitigate catastrophic forgetting, (ii) enable
efficient adaptation to continually arriving datasets, (iii) handle inputs from
unknown datasets during inference, and (iv) enable knowledge sharing across
similar dataset domains. Given a set of continually streaming VidQA datasets,
we sequentially train dataset-specific adapters for each dataset while freezing
the parameters of a large pretrained video-language backbone. During inference,
given a video-question sample from an unknown domain, our method first uses the
proposed non-parametric router function to compute a probability for each
adapter, reflecting how relevant that adapter is to the current video-question
input instance. Subsequently, the proposed dynamic adapter merging scheme
aggregates all the adapter weights into a new adapter instance tailored for
that particular test sample to compute the final VidQA prediction, mitigating
the impact of inaccurate router predictions and facilitating knowledge sharing
across domains. Our DAM model outperforms prior state-of-the-art continual
learning approaches by 9.1% while exhibiting 1.9% less forgetting on 6 VidQA
datasets spanning various domains. We further extend DAM to continual image
classification and image QA and outperform prior methods by a large margin. The
code is publicly available at: https://github.com/klauscc/DAM
|
[
-0.5996205211,
-0.6542361379,
0.3057600856,
0.1611162573,
-0.4571890235,
0.138893038,
0.1798589826,
0.0454837121,
-0.1716575027,
0.2855946124,
-0.407630682,
-0.0866966918,
-0.6249731779,
-0.351767838,
-0.4877452552,
0.7400871515,
-0.4070749581,
0.0493178107,
-0.568040669,
-0.3875579238,
-0.6835449934,
0.0047869161,
-0.7813090682,
-0.0458706059,
0.5557968616,
0.5572727323,
0.4348106682,
0.4434010684,
0.5528645515,
0.3144693375,
0.076982677,
0.2739824951,
-0.7716954947,
0.4163023829,
-0.1133335009,
-0.0923034623,
-0.0355365016,
-0.3650608063,
1.0669413805,
0.3999303579,
-0.3811779022,
0.4969623983,
-0.0449977815,
0.7244976759,
-0.9245035648,
0.0834635794,
-0.7421254516,
-0.0213939063,
0.2809507251,
-0.2632651329,
-0.1886510253,
-0.5595539212,
0.1992580742,
-0.526842773,
0.1535473466,
-0.0909534767,
0.9976888299,
0.9329103231,
-0.5133275986,
0.1437168717,
-0.9384562373,
0.6478960514,
-0.3263716698,
0.4970889091,
-0.0133102667,
0.7897686362,
-0.0548018552,
-0.9256538153,
-1.0284862518,
0.1297820508,
0.6129876971,
0.2480918467,
-0.2477091998,
0.0125846239,
0.2544958293,
0.5588882565,
-0.4211824834,
-0.0738596022,
-0.5154554844,
0.0173605606,
0.446487844,
0.0855349973,
0.3768265247,
0.0667219236,
-0.4438761473,
-0.1970519125,
-0.5445731282,
0.3813244104,
-0.0085639711,
-0.3460628986,
-0.0514779277,
0.3216673434,
-0.1934449673,
0.7017068863,
0.3943461478,
-0.0727502853,
0.219990328,
-0.0675432757,
-0.2655748725,
0.0053834482,
0.5277272463,
0.4338947535,
0.1533751637,
-0.156154722,
-0.0190477856,
-0.1717495024,
0.6248418093,
-0.8434127569,
-0.7437250614,
0.2081288397,
-0.2075802833,
-0.1091194302,
0.0223523024,
-0.8418037295,
-0.3183146119,
-0.1614098102,
0.8600631952,
-0.317163825,
-0.2319815606,
-0.1621421576,
-0.2618595362,
0.6368893981,
0.4300094247,
-0.5586146712,
0.3228836954,
0.1956832856,
0.7471749783,
-0.2672813535,
-0.3837259114,
-1.1798596382,
0.2501949966,
-0.3498021066,
0.7620841265,
-0.2459683567,
-0.1558720917,
0.0154845789,
-0.0033385218,
-0.1398407966,
-0.7080438137,
0.1227916628,
-1.1379153728,
0.0665666908,
-0.1861564815,
-0.5422224998,
-0.5731967688,
0.2726307809,
-0.8413920999,
0.8668019772,
0.2724299133,
-0.5350257158,
0.4445441365,
-0.4029033184,
0.0415205806,
0.1790232509,
0.0627553165,
-0.9091861844,
-0.2298657745,
-0.0333977379,
0.1428383887,
-0.0303592738,
0.4036470354,
-0.4744974673,
-0.4260774553,
0.1424224973,
-0.4538408816,
0.3393507004,
0.0247112699,
-0.339735359,
0.1352667511,
-0.6283413768,
0.018413838,
-0.2148300707,
-0.3544613421,
-0.0294735357,
-0.0199530646,
-0.1668986231,
0.4487859011,
0.1483521163,
-0.3755731285,
0.0357676148,
0.2571183145,
0.171639502,
0.7554776669,
0.4128151238,
0.3769646287,
-0.4035296738,
0.6961035728,
0.3020350933,
0.3284476101,
-0.0310178678,
-0.438467592,
-0.8809819818,
-0.2516073883,
0.481754154,
0.6440740824,
-1.037536025,
0.0833401456,
-0.4384316206,
-0.6790724993,
-0.2907231152,
0.362385422,
0.3043573797,
0.7989899516,
0.6421559453,
-0.4938796461,
-0.4381494224,
-0.4770947397,
0.1828862131,
-0.3395883739,
-0.1641098708,
0.2646860182,
0.2723539174,
-0.0375626236,
0.8601407409,
-0.4901036918,
-0.2056821138,
-0.0109814908,
0.1809506863,
-0.0478556305,
0.4568364918,
0.5469579697,
-1.20125103,
-0.6166840792,
-0.2801641524,
-0.9296213984,
0.2432370782,
-0.2616316676,
-0.182718873,
-0.2443638444,
0.3631466627,
-0.3647129536,
0.4006195664,
0.65700984,
0.0418498702,
0.6654831171,
-0.3081505001,
0.340444833,
-1.0168634653,
-0.2970305383,
-0.2347882986,
-0.0326840244,
-0.4224179387,
-0.0299910344,
0.1069979593,
-0.0903230384,
-0.6408022046,
0.5016563535,
-0.3162673116,
0.2256588042,
-0.2894070745,
0.0298842285,
-0.2538738251,
0.7248334289,
-0.2268731743,
0.8005400896,
1.055719018,
-1.175029397,
0.8110567927,
0.4435040653,
-0.2081935257,
0.4523140788,
-0.5973092914,
-0.0047992845,
-0.2054578364,
0.3073892891,
-1.0854008198,
-0.1406015754,
0.1818144321,
-0.4283238351,
0.3102021515,
-0.3581867516,
-0.0771346167,
-0.4092248082,
-0.1992532015,
0.6519127488,
0.7258458138,
-0.6907403469,
0.8682278991,
0.5497466922,
-0.1871055812,
-0.5432823896,
-0.4496847987,
0.0807307139,
-0.5029671788,
-0.528924644,
0.3361987174,
-0.3456102908,
0.0847644955,
0.2108998597,
-0.3966215551,
-0.696017921,
-0.211811915,
0.4696665108,
0.4183926582,
-0.2008667886,
0.1523025334,
0.18770051,
0.1535909176,
0.0950759873,
-0.4843891561,
0.1240131035,
0.0129107963,
-0.3240677714,
-0.4348697066,
0.4278544188,
0.7284417152,
-0.1678389162,
0.8489755392,
0.7402331829,
-0.2728133798,
-0.0156588349,
-0.8176082969,
0.0977002457,
-0.4895547628,
0.2964893579,
-0.3472816646,
-0.9258750081,
0.6588643789,
-0.2012574822,
0.1835335195,
0.1017976105,
0.4117653072,
-0.3876740336,
0.6258873343,
0.7965914607,
-0.0069166329,
0.7771908641,
-0.5469172597,
0.3291458786,
-0.7595337033,
-0.2581006885,
0.0628270656,
-0.4469024539,
-0.5374987721,
-0.5272756815,
0.5470066667,
0.0960506573,
-0.5226857066,
0.1159470528,
-0.1042942852,
0.324074626,
0.4638129473,
0.2793472111,
0.025876129,
0.0474493727,
0.0561573319,
0.1086306274,
-0.9514381886,
-0.0175800659,
0.9103998542,
0.0599232316,
0.5839150548,
0.2605286241,
0.4885390699,
0.3568480909,
0.1212125346,
-0.7717078328,
0.6081181765,
-0.0219383184,
-0.1500241607,
-0.5191989541,
-0.4712895155,
-0.890070498,
-0.034799315,
-0.0204127971,
-0.3564789891,
0.3708565235,
0.5466113687,
-0.4944572747,
0.6520959735,
-0.5360657573,
0.7984173298,
0.0046329205,
-0.6023427248,
-0.4730641544,
-0.6144360304,
0.6595627069,
-0.3842365742,
-0.0626771748,
0.2433654815,
0.0057849432,
0.7232287526,
-0.3516082466,
0.3858837485,
-0.3308795393,
0.0661484301,
0.6568074822,
0.0168687925,
0.2326847464,
0.2345970869,
0.3086381257,
-0.0670620799,
-0.0676619112,
-0.6769903898,
-0.8439171314,
0.5491482019,
-0.6544200778,
-0.4716116786,
-0.2934304774,
-0.6244825125,
-0.3192192018,
0.0422785878,
-0.1111294851,
0.6638487577,
0.1480020136,
0.364343226,
1.1357501745,
-0.2228413373,
0.2749050856,
0.6296286583,
0.1795942783,
-0.7535568476,
1.1686605215,
-0.0293407496,
0.320797205,
0.4481264651,
-0.1146009266,
-0.1942137778,
-0.655674696,
-0.3818319142,
0.2192946672,
-0.7103078961,
-0.322971195,
-0.5907883048,
-0.4883665144,
-0.1703750193,
0.1258296669,
-0.1830262095,
-0.1198599488,
0.0213295538,
-0.0513688512,
0.4756535888,
0.3020663261,
-0.2301937491,
0.4234054685,
-1.046729207,
0.8045850992,
0.9765504599,
0.4552969337,
0.0438173115,
-0.9400131702,
-0.3533486426,
-0.0718025342,
-0.5639754534,
-0.9227021337,
0.1628190428,
0.4976785481,
0.675863564,
0.5525851846,
0.3243754804,
0.9857308865,
-0.6228296757,
0.8753457069,
0.2826040387,
-0.6176538467,
0.3387334645,
-0.1473298669,
0.4044860899,
0.7197347283,
0.5946577787,
-0.3674296141,
-0.33039698,
-0.6054796576,
-0.9389265776,
0.1449417174,
0.0368776023,
0.1764391065,
0.1811846346,
0.3144720793,
-0.1281363815,
0.0921662971,
-0.3007546961,
-0.1836028248,
-0.3120031655,
-0.042017892,
0.1456984729,
-0.2491757423,
-0.1752647907,
-0.5100556612,
0.728120923,
-0.2330455929,
0.14210172,
-0.1014007926,
-0.2639091611,
-0.1640171856,
-0.0941176638,
0.2748310864,
0.8885811567,
-0.2255572528,
0.014742204,
0.5858696699,
-0.7508985996,
0.2952355444,
0.0585306212,
-0.2615167201,
0.0491438769,
-0.0268291533,
0.9129855037,
0.3995529115,
-0.8573150635,
0.3933420777,
-0.4048452675,
-0.5182431936,
-0.5161775351,
0.2695069611,
-0.0911759138,
0.3912570775,
0.3697457016,
0.2682132125,
0.0655444562,
-0.2182926536,
0.7007712722,
0.2822612524,
-0.5769379139,
-0.1045930609,
0.7805303335,
0.177002877,
-0.0797554255,
0.9051433206,
-0.2161792368,
-0.5929047465,
0.4886260927,
-0.0336628482,
0.9141631126,
-0.333183974,
0.2533556819,
0.5798230767,
-0.1529050022,
-0.1340664625,
0.2139558494,
-0.5342255831,
-0.5693198442,
-0.6877821684,
-0.5372864008,
-0.699996531,
0.0865002126,
-0.7872750163,
0.4648834169,
-0.0846450552,
0.1110885888,
-0.4647462666,
-0.0436571538,
-0.5543403625,
0.3863935173,
0.1702907383,
0.9693753123,
-0.6299889088,
0.9722800255,
0.7185308337,
-0.5818665624,
-1.0031629801,
0.2056928873,
-0.2271005511,
-0.4342419803,
0.5106527209,
-0.1403579861,
-0.1013849899,
0.1994673014,
-0.5108094215,
-0.9008883238,
1.2682042122,
0.3007637262,
-0.3018752933,
-0.0934663713,
-0.2141862512,
0.1980693936,
-0.0214518439,
0.1282536089,
0.3432728946,
0.2934809625,
0.668046236,
-0.7159302831,
-0.2258189172,
-0.3769646287,
-0.2279859632,
0.1228005365,
-0.6231473088,
0.3626859784,
-0.5063610077,
-0.0614579059,
-0.0028512059,
1.122220397,
0.3642975092,
0.569000721,
0.9146721363,
0.4829699099,
0.7858481407,
0.072213836,
0.5132817626,
-0.3025622666,
0.3144769073,
1.1240133047,
0.0526008196,
0.9090748429,
0.5478215218,
-0.1372468024,
0.8045067191,
0.694850862,
-0.1121226475,
0.6587756276,
0.1461659968,
-0.5751448274,
-0.4598352015,
0.1386603564,
-0.3355960548,
0.3156376779,
0.0666796118,
0.1712689549,
-0.2775002122,
0.1498888582,
-0.3093209863,
-0.145387128,
-0.3202248812,
0.9739867449,
-0.0472031906,
-0.8225758672,
0.8241930604,
-0.7098333836,
0.4116177559,
-0.7287493348,
-0.138322711,
-0.2516931295,
0.1888458729,
-0.0702462196,
-0.7776408792,
0.4248605371,
0.1169932857,
-0.3245826066,
-0.0295090992,
0.3215091228,
-0.7143007517,
-0.1271308661,
-0.0827630386,
0.1935535818,
0.2044381052,
-0.1064343303,
-0.5316987038,
-0.15139319,
-0.1162149459,
0.1156914905,
0.4621064067,
0.5114768147,
0.0463951267,
1.0414896011,
0.4521370232,
0.0349709988,
0.3816475272,
-0.024312716,
1.1341902018,
-0.4236707389,
-0.5117231607,
-0.2837122381,
0.6929685473,
-0.1045372486,
-0.0552815981,
0.4788992703,
0.5430460572,
0.7868211269,
-0.1754151732,
0.7729707956,
-0.0491157807,
0.0010965521,
-0.3848468661,
0.6205835342,
-0.6713408232,
0.1234046966,
-0.0395014398,
-0.8655279279,
-0.0397936851,
0.095711045,
-0.1847255826,
-0.1688471138,
0.7517977357,
0.5558385253,
-0.1989428401,
-0.2583176494,
0.3457594812,
0.0192467235,
0.4456286728,
0.6797935963,
0.7194138765,
-0.6514516473,
1.0717369318,
-0.3243998587,
-0.3560558856,
0.0667839944,
-0.8092005849,
-0.5965198278,
-0.8288396001,
-0.8364263177,
-0.3139277697,
0.2070697695,
0.3483311236,
0.6459083557,
-0.8524627686,
-0.0367903635,
-0.0912348777,
0.2535038888,
-0.6095520258,
-0.2661724687,
0.2569216788,
-0.3167783916,
-0.7108111382,
0.0738306418,
0.2913150191,
-0.1662418544,
-0.268168211,
-0.1377613395,
-0.1738160551,
0.1680192202,
0.4605603814,
0.5995669961,
-0.438223362,
-0.2388052344,
-0.056615632,
0.2548042834,
0.0880954117,
0.7222144604,
-1.1875146627,
0.6802470684,
0.6330120564,
0.9877176881,
0.5492597222,
0.1188839227,
0.5983124971,
-0.3230012059,
-0.1318619102,
0.0583598725,
0.1956594735,
0.3732747436,
-0.1690357625,
0.1614464074,
0.2459239215,
-0.7380445004,
-0.9334406257,
0.2206510305,
-1.2814127207,
0.0660395846,
0.9144859314,
-0.2956263125,
-0.227450192,
-0.2883608937,
-0.0184250753,
0.6520467401,
-0.1801818609,
1.1506605148,
0.3308149278,
-0.0568218566,
-0.7399257421,
-0.5609075427,
0.4725995958,
0.2596003115,
-0.669859767,
-0.2490342557,
0.3189639151,
0.5054367185,
-0.1579291075,
0.2775250971,
0.1130071953,
0.8748291731,
-0.0796043724,
0.0150386179,
-0.1320201457,
-0.3796917498,
-0.4051950276,
0.3027847409,
-0.1202279553,
-0.7462995648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08743v1
|
Steering LLMs Towards Unbiased Responses: A Causality-Guided Debiasing Framework
| 2024-03-13T17:46:28 | 2024-03-13T17:46:28 |
Jingling Li, Zeyu Tang, Xiaoyu Liu, Peter Spirtes, Kun Zhang, Liu Leqi, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) can easily generate biased and discriminative
responses. As LLMs tap into consequential decision-making (e.g., hiring and
healthcare), it is of crucial importance to develop strategies to mitigate
these biases. This paper focuses on social bias, tackling the association
between demographic information and LLM outputs. We propose a causality-guided
debiasing framework that utilizes causal understandings of (1) the
data-generating process of the training corpus fed to LLMs, and (2) the
internal reasoning process of LLM inference, to guide the design of prompts for
debiasing LLM outputs through selection mechanisms. Our framework unifies
existing de-biasing prompting approaches such as inhibitive instructions and
in-context contrastive examples, and sheds light on new ways of debiasing by
encouraging bias-free reasoning. Our strong empirical performance on real-world
datasets demonstrates that our framework provides principled guidelines on
debiasing LLM outputs even with only the black-box access.
|
[
-0.0981727168,
-0.6536795497,
0.8087422848,
0.2180530429,
-0.3082616627,
-0.2294099033,
-0.1729077399,
-0.037597537,
0.0362167656,
0.6930731535,
-0.625353694,
-0.5712582469,
-0.6320409179,
-0.0442620739,
-0.1052178517,
0.6824793816,
0.2773184478,
0.585287571,
-0.4059245288,
0.0539641753,
-0.439344883,
-0.606326282,
-0.9555842876,
-0.6779734492,
0.7209871411,
0.6080579758,
0.6047644615,
0.5730973482,
0.1450008154,
0.1322639734,
-0.1928827167,
0.0237070527,
-0.7338963151,
0.2963966429,
-0.2278590798,
-0.5645191669,
-0.076334171,
0.1151407957,
0.3929953277,
0.9478142262,
0.026169356,
0.3857985139,
0.3458411694,
0.9422422051,
-0.7115095854,
0.1707434356,
-0.6147491932,
-0.074273333,
-0.105549708,
-0.3074099123,
-0.610427916,
-0.528470695,
-0.1309847087,
-0.2745145261,
0.3113068938,
-0.0442410484,
0.1237440482,
0.4495122135,
-0.7385575771,
-0.0071563316,
-0.7458360195,
0.7282025814,
-0.5556994677,
0.3393233716,
0.7170087099,
0.1356318742,
-0.2077999264,
-0.126137957,
-0.201005891,
-0.1583619416,
-0.0292453971,
0.0224224385,
0.0017755042,
0.0138961682,
0.2852950692,
-0.2512300014,
-0.2963970602,
0.4736280143,
-0.5406059027,
0.1254640818,
0.6659419537,
-0.0063356911,
-0.1016900614,
-0.0029520646,
-0.2366449535,
0.0694161281,
-1.1617946625,
-0.3304805756,
0.680642426,
0.2703845203,
-0.2739973068,
0.6791487336,
-0.2378155142,
0.4372367263,
0.4778173268,
0.3165206313,
-0.0351744629,
0.1011885181,
-0.1691833586,
0.4084161222,
0.5810997486,
0.5949410796,
0.4011210501,
-0.2137231678,
-0.0226944592,
0.4888734221,
0.1638567448,
-0.6874094605,
0.3097869754,
0.3478575647,
-0.5130317807,
-0.5085365772,
-0.2194999754,
-1.0434207916,
-0.892528832,
-0.4874575436,
-0.1685609818,
0.022526959,
-0.0411390401,
0.1523549706,
-0.0755107254,
0.1066644713,
0.2999922931,
-0.8152266741,
-0.0370326377,
0.5305620432,
0.3685071468,
-0.1883563101,
0.1995725334,
-0.6664012671,
0.514593184,
-0.3102502525,
0.6322351098,
-0.6261071563,
-0.4485644996,
0.3694300354,
-0.1886445284,
0.1102824807,
-0.5711233616,
0.4745697975,
-0.5786014795,
0.0902746171,
-0.5806004405,
-0.2233017236,
-0.0176771861,
-0.0492527299,
-0.5440146923,
0.9172928929,
-0.137919724,
-0.8674001098,
0.9188596606,
-0.2231865525,
-0.0848988369,
-0.2671229243,
-0.478892982,
-0.2832695544,
0.0989015475,
0.326725632,
0.4360208809,
-0.7686142921,
0.8950976729,
-1.0357993841,
-0.2372940779,
0.1509919465,
-0.6385354996,
1.0288767815,
0.3078171611,
-0.5797625184,
0.3009023368,
-0.6756857038,
-0.5464740396,
0.0218830388,
-0.1938466728,
-0.5408516526,
0.2668973804,
-0.3514949083,
0.328772068,
-0.1582566202,
-0.4140043557,
-0.0853139013,
-0.0316996761,
0.1983771026,
1.0727243423,
0.0730198398,
0.652775228,
-0.2969366908,
0.2680761218,
0.1744914502,
0.3401802182,
0.5006793737,
-0.085301511,
-0.5408630371,
-0.1678618789,
-0.2269444913,
0.4055244625,
-0.7861600518,
0.4180639684,
0.0068427813,
-0.2298064083,
-0.2915756404,
0.3126244843,
0.2721505463,
0.5202162862,
0.1160144359,
0.0024111723,
-0.5078046322,
-0.9104622006,
-0.2151042372,
-0.4031137824,
-0.0954574868,
0.0848584697,
0.2767288983,
-0.3709822297,
0.5879572034,
-0.4245150387,
-0.1440750957,
-0.0960306749,
0.0242226552,
0.1656631529,
0.3287695348,
0.4446121752,
-0.6510006189,
0.1629522145,
-0.4850420058,
-0.9351026416,
-0.6815379858,
-0.1408729702,
-0.4554455578,
-0.065465264,
0.6942768097,
-0.4684737325,
0.3601680696,
0.1651234329,
-0.5413161516,
0.3141772449,
-0.0633444265,
-0.0073813768,
-0.9497079253,
-0.0277092736,
0.413741231,
0.0884177536,
-0.1256732643,
-0.2604188621,
-0.3255024254,
0.1030181199,
-0.3657634854,
0.7431536913,
-0.4739269614,
0.0989673734,
0.0792913884,
0.343850255,
-0.2001132071,
0.2392459512,
-0.0618052073,
0.3213612139,
0.329572618,
-0.6075100899,
0.1599031538,
0.4194868505,
-0.2905614674,
0.8144621849,
-0.6042655706,
-0.0825852007,
-0.7354038358,
0.4530814588,
-0.8341703415,
-0.1160763577,
0.1787772179,
-0.2711985111,
0.0074948156,
-0.1631987989,
-0.254371196,
-0.4332995713,
-0.4924143255,
0.4317338467,
0.2986213863,
-0.4466698766,
0.1735245287,
0.5309514403,
-0.0927032083,
-0.7443614602,
-0.8001002073,
-0.2560869157,
-0.4593972564,
-0.2874634564,
0.1166717485,
-0.0032500215,
-0.7412656546,
-0.1255654693,
-0.0092143146,
-0.002744206,
0.087875396,
0.4198504686,
0.4202166498,
0.1147968248,
0.151321739,
0.2429805398,
-0.2202401757,
0.4391807914,
-0.2857804894,
0.3919335902,
0.790405035,
-0.7499269843,
-0.0708688051,
0.2982501686,
0.6059691906,
0.0985127687,
0.6096602082,
0.3475872278,
-0.1975731701,
-0.2105402052,
-0.7528752089,
-0.5162349939,
-0.3965151608,
0.0386024602,
0.401530534,
-0.9424308538,
0.3496612608,
0.0541559905,
0.0736209825,
0.2134826332,
0.9953373075,
0.2195215225,
1.0290498734,
0.257879436,
-0.2494861782,
0.5215545893,
0.0265247338,
0.1063285172,
-0.6299722791,
-0.2831363976,
-0.5973652601,
-0.195042491,
-0.5996835828,
-0.4649528563,
0.2850647569,
0.0296310801,
-0.5864310861,
-0.3677102923,
-0.4934158027,
0.2149023712,
0.6672344208,
0.3028424084,
0.0215305518,
-0.0834236965,
-0.328933835,
0.1421836913,
-0.6087228656,
-0.590919733,
1.1267132759,
0.2539840639,
1.1895016432,
0.0362939462,
0.588968277,
0.5596757531,
0.5169453621,
-0.2518975437,
0.4748141766,
0.0067731803,
-0.8733613491,
-0.2276790887,
-0.4647774994,
-0.8272486329,
0.3459828198,
-0.3800185323,
-0.705563128,
0.5801743269,
0.3041954637,
-0.2829497159,
0.2446920127,
-0.4513554871,
0.4846360087,
-0.1869952977,
-0.9019239545,
-0.3900548816,
-0.5303016305,
0.5512512326,
-0.039047651,
0.3635684848,
-0.5086799264,
0.2717522085,
0.585062325,
-0.0099783977,
1.4474937916,
-0.5172570348,
-0.0410853066,
0.3430014253,
-0.0048128096,
0.3005349934,
0.3468765914,
-0.4624845386,
0.1342707127,
-0.0618325807,
-0.2941682935,
-0.2751216292,
0.8038843274,
-0.6611454487,
-0.7407785058,
-0.169493407,
-0.4233921468,
-0.4175514579,
0.0023320823,
0.0268753525,
0.3287341595,
-0.3818707168,
0.2286643237,
0.6799988747,
-0.3817887306,
0.0230021756,
0.5909864306,
-0.0864520743,
-0.3568314314,
0.1774481982,
0.1433319598,
0.25688079,
0.2902749479,
0.329090178,
-0.4862765968,
-0.2106313109,
-0.4176336825,
0.2119398117,
-0.6970533133,
-0.2194517255,
-0.3889386654,
0.2399006486,
-0.6294636726,
-0.2379956394,
0.1225511432,
-0.1718329638,
-0.2416891456,
-0.4364162982,
0.2175655812,
0.8424223065,
-0.2333476394,
0.2930420935,
-0.412042737,
0.3364322186,
0.3940373659,
0.0212415978,
0.1765892953,
-0.2788495123,
-0.0176536459,
0.2189830542,
-0.3339433372,
-1.0371692181,
0.1662376374,
-0.4521505833,
0.7613497972,
0.5452362299,
0.4099633992,
0.2642163932,
-0.4175275862,
0.6821947098,
0.1722997576,
-0.5006492138,
0.4635746181,
-0.5583002567,
0.0454432257,
0.5824919939,
0.4074272215,
-0.380569458,
-0.537093401,
-0.4930355549,
-0.8645915985,
0.5190138817,
-0.1417723,
-0.0337805375,
-0.423176825,
0.3688778281,
0.0061877845,
0.2661604881,
-0.5881743431,
-0.217413038,
0.2851774395,
-0.3445194364,
-0.02338803,
-0.7304132581,
-0.3891082108,
-0.1323807687,
0.6637859941,
-0.2144683301,
0.0759955794,
0.1904405951,
-0.1480184644,
-0.3231931925,
0.3497401774,
0.4312066138,
0.6991092563,
-0.1943602413,
0.3407504261,
0.0973450169,
-0.0517914146,
0.3611190617,
0.0296164788,
-0.5301383734,
-0.2223131806,
0.2460035682,
0.6160230637,
0.3342872858,
-0.2578897178,
0.4983857572,
0.1992115378,
-0.084977679,
-0.2217864692,
-0.1177680567,
0.0952771455,
0.3081776202,
0.2733286619,
-0.4704557657,
-0.0419953093,
-0.2536458969,
0.1935682148,
0.7051035166,
-0.5816050172,
-0.1722058058,
1.1185104847,
0.3987322748,
0.2370713353,
0.3330716789,
0.0897804499,
-0.0428376421,
0.5976139307,
0.6438977122,
1.007237792,
-0.2206050605,
0.3877696097,
0.3335855305,
0.2401950955,
-0.2167638987,
0.1588165313,
0.0640433356,
-0.849008441,
-0.4527900219,
-0.4958590865,
-0.3741087914,
0.1022509411,
-0.8091077805,
0.3244511485,
-0.407948643,
-0.2026135027,
-0.0864640921,
-0.4213030934,
-0.7321697474,
0.259468019,
0.2735187411,
0.7486953139,
-1.103577137,
0.6501487494,
0.3684795499,
-0.4405518174,
-0.4185207188,
-0.1428678185,
0.574097991,
-1.1652560234,
0.9975928664,
-0.0837137923,
-0.218794927,
-0.4858624935,
-0.6929372549,
-0.6127046347,
0.8616581559,
0.9023986459,
-0.4819969535,
-0.0873872936,
0.1153492481,
0.0799791068,
-0.4005686045,
0.4017892182,
0.4940265119,
0.5805263519,
-0.0880381614,
-0.3967454135,
0.2764513493,
0.1591238379,
0.0218670759,
-0.0049673845,
-0.5150170922,
0.5397641063,
-0.2822929323,
-0.0363995582,
-0.459341377,
0.3879189491,
0.3601672947,
0.3845304847,
0.5255138278,
0.2250785381,
0.6975412369,
0.1260298491,
0.9146382213,
-0.3947301805,
0.0125532774,
1.0622171164,
-0.6628472209,
0.3338195682,
0.6662529707,
-0.1119713485,
0.4036431313,
0.6884063482,
0.3280821145,
0.4308302999,
0.4791779518,
-0.3617911637,
-0.2847532332,
-0.4956816435,
-0.0587352477,
0.2027420849,
0.2712513804,
-0.7017952204,
-0.4296623468,
-0.2226206511,
0.3317019343,
0.2351750582,
-0.2616911232,
0.7168325782,
0.2838797569,
-0.6386301517,
0.3796451688,
-0.2554621398,
0.6021381617,
-0.6745157242,
-0.1103764623,
-0.3068749607,
0.1675085872,
-0.2164088041,
-0.5804121494,
0.2779452205,
-0.0423072875,
-0.5764518976,
-0.4547970593,
0.7774227262,
-0.4980053902,
-0.3970846236,
0.6060059667,
0.7941321731,
-0.1800100505,
0.0845382959,
-0.4884530902,
0.0933415219,
0.1832982898,
-0.2699889839,
0.4326236844,
0.565357089,
-0.4590533376,
0.5913321376,
0.733027339,
0.3641865849,
-0.2076240629,
0.455421865,
0.7800683975,
-0.5179725885,
-0.3765492141,
-1.0806328058,
0.2161271274,
-0.3135085702,
-0.1341736764,
0.6390761733,
0.2887307405,
0.7339509726,
0.0497805849,
0.8059692979,
0.3440232277,
0.3157287538,
-0.5601406097,
0.5362318158,
-0.2457303405,
0.2948099077,
-0.2767528296,
-0.7566382289,
-0.2230797261,
0.4951807857,
-0.6815910339,
0.0220735837,
0.3534486294,
0.9237727523,
0.2848542929,
-0.2259511799,
0.3080046177,
0.0185183678,
0.3713648021,
0.3609089851,
0.6868299842,
0.2989219427,
0.1625510752,
0.0192261543,
-0.3776778281,
-0.0803589672,
-1.0596711636,
-0.9790732861,
-0.2548805475,
-0.1488725096,
-0.437767148,
0.1195781082,
1.1611902714,
0.5306152105,
-0.6080402136,
-0.3410416543,
0.1983397454,
0.3894032538,
0.0211142916,
-0.2025320381,
0.212098524,
-0.3153110147,
-0.388178885,
0.1412837803,
0.1896069199,
-0.2598159909,
-0.4611444175,
0.0134731466,
-0.1686429381,
0.259147197,
0.5971416831,
-0.0622966588,
-0.5305611491,
-0.2686136961,
-0.4148825109,
-0.1202164814,
-0.2426770329,
1.0572267771,
-0.6844708323,
0.1469885111,
0.3767818809,
0.5786800981,
0.2704619169,
-0.1095092446,
0.79611063,
-0.5759028792,
0.4004655778,
0.0734236985,
0.5406742096,
0.4209932089,
-0.6641950011,
0.6656611562,
0.1489470005,
-0.5653158426,
-0.7400855422,
0.2984843254,
-0.5519566536,
-0.3577260077,
1.6671546698,
0.3562428951,
-0.1941875368,
-0.2138000876,
-0.2692546546,
0.4299603701,
-0.5085663199,
0.9162892699,
0.4679331779,
0.0784727782,
0.1293748021,
-0.6867936254,
0.465587914,
0.4463101625,
-0.7321400642,
0.5647118092,
0.9641558528,
0.1058807597,
-0.2659861445,
0.8611866832,
-0.2707442939,
-0.0211365353,
-0.1421620548,
0.0688049048,
0.1024392024,
-0.0462381579,
-0.2987248898,
-0.1234887317,
0.2196973413,
-0.10098508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08739v1
|
The Garden of Forking Paths: Observing Dynamic Parameters Distribution in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T17:42:32 | 2024-03-13T17:42:32 |
Carlo Nicolini, Jacopo Staiano, Bruno Lepri, Raffaele Marino
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.AI
|
A substantial gap persists in understanding the reasons behind the
exceptional performance of the Transformer architecture in NLP. A particularly
unexplored area involves the mechanistic description of how the distribution of
parameters evolves over time during training. In this work we suggest that
looking at the time evolution of the statistic distribution of model
parameters, and specifically at bifurcation effects, can help understanding the
model quality, potentially reducing training costs and evaluation efforts and
empirically showing the reasons behind the effectiveness of weights
sparsification.
|
[
-0.5533796549,
-0.8028590083,
0.6773257256,
0.2286017686,
-0.2432162464,
-0.1390140206,
0.1079314649,
-0.4983371198,
-0.0469641313,
0.3569400012,
-0.8868516088,
0.0347092189,
-0.7911006212,
-0.0681237727,
-0.8944948316,
1.0200185776,
-0.2158423066,
-0.0123327989,
0.1765948087,
-0.3459935784,
-0.1669663936,
-0.2154473066,
-0.6304396391,
-0.8028761744,
0.7799302936,
-0.2854385376,
1.1181558371,
0.9239596725,
0.1362417042,
0.3014242351,
-0.3870637119,
-0.3383310735,
-0.2306723893,
0.6244721413,
-0.314383924,
-0.6557615399,
0.3562110662,
-0.0023483764,
0.9405785799,
1.2297990322,
-0.1162699237,
0.1230459288,
0.1872922629,
0.7337009907,
-0.4296801984,
0.1710817218,
-0.3398228288,
0.3671776056,
-0.358075738,
-0.4369305372,
-0.3592015207,
-0.2535910904,
0.5343950987,
-0.2519453168,
0.349861145,
0.0160487704,
1.1132702827,
0.397452414,
-0.2803674936,
-0.3763421476,
-1.1560586691,
0.828255713,
-0.4129888713,
0.6753937602,
0.0070517585,
0.5379935503,
-0.2413584441,
-0.7119985223,
-0.4372004271,
0.0894719064,
0.1055670828,
-0.189711839,
-0.2753036022,
-0.0634532571,
0.3177827597,
0.3838392496,
-0.3278561532,
0.0572882555,
-0.1184126362,
0.2881108224,
0.4582674503,
0.2938424349,
0.2869028151,
-0.1967099458,
-0.160226956,
-0.6844496131,
-0.4041757286,
0.2754318416,
0.8073619604,
0.2208183706,
-0.0895536169,
0.3589501679,
0.1244495586,
0.5867654681,
-0.030465655,
0.3907700181,
0.1574860066,
-0.3418830335,
-0.0977485329,
-0.2092235386,
0.7592686415,
0.2379464805,
0.1422981024,
-0.5344626307,
-0.1596465856,
-0.1990180165,
0.4054405987,
-0.6399300098,
-0.613660872,
0.0316750146,
-0.6110880375,
-0.4638759196,
0.1759801656,
-0.975304842,
-0.4260022044,
-0.1380387545,
0.1491196454,
-0.4222711623,
-0.6600347757,
0.0904784799,
-0.6066842675,
0.3692271709,
0.0730238408,
-1.0277758837,
0.3792700171,
0.558842063,
1.0885466337,
-0.0628623664,
-0.5253801942,
-0.3428525031,
0.0183378272,
-0.4887383282,
0.6936299205,
-0.5579861403,
-0.0481148809,
0.103818588,
0.3532310128,
-0.0796128809,
-0.5417509675,
0.2215655893,
-0.6904026866,
-0.0328259468,
-0.2676932812,
-0.264043957,
-0.3945286274,
-0.0481226295,
-0.7914509177,
1.0745624304,
0.3787997961,
-0.8921449184,
0.5904007554,
-0.7470123768,
-0.3385060132,
0.0273186285,
-0.049578432,
-0.3851753175,
0.2117749602,
-0.1049343348,
0.4480186701,
-0.1729026139,
0.3583155274,
-0.2829111814,
-0.1261280775,
0.3412317336,
-0.9810112715,
1.1028573513,
0.2087602466,
-0.6056625247,
0.0465039574,
-0.5987452269,
-0.327675432,
0.1344683617,
-0.351757884,
-0.5036410689,
0.5141339302,
0.0899308845,
0.1500034779,
-0.3753695786,
-0.0298454035,
0.1373298615,
-0.8486126065,
0.4461901188,
0.725299418,
0.5215258002,
0.5139989853,
-0.0538304485,
0.3772908151,
0.4503923357,
0.5273859501,
-0.0465625972,
-0.4967343807,
-0.8260449171,
0.3549389243,
0.4079700708,
0.1046111435,
-0.7075852752,
0.2241752744,
-0.0796566606,
-0.6030030251,
-0.4201662838,
-0.1325525045,
0.0912695602,
0.0021004949,
0.3082691729,
-0.0997980312,
-0.2208041251,
-0.832888484,
-0.2736410499,
-0.0857472792,
-0.0671221018,
0.0077948873,
0.5788994431,
-0.3530140221,
0.8131657243,
-0.4050918818,
0.4861529171,
-0.1324072182,
0.5595322251,
0.3881281912,
0.3668811321,
0.9382770061,
-0.7493710518,
-0.3873918653,
-0.1614724249,
-0.4158881009,
-0.1587730348,
-0.2666390538,
-0.3261669576,
0.1834334433,
0.2822219133,
-0.5600127578,
0.3458065391,
0.8388800621,
-0.3251593113,
0.8869711757,
-0.2831893563,
-0.103617698,
-1.0310678482,
-0.0773213059,
0.3146080077,
-0.1805140823,
-0.470018208,
-0.0334125608,
-0.3645668328,
0.1604794264,
-0.177008301,
0.2729017735,
-0.6649202704,
-0.2061761022,
-0.0314754359,
0.0653304309,
-0.1378234625,
0.3184364736,
-0.3547435999,
0.5001915693,
0.7387700677,
-0.7523180842,
0.4880200028,
-0.0664053485,
-0.2734620273,
0.331283927,
-0.6866723299,
-0.3871490955,
-0.0545622036,
-0.151687935,
-1.0604989529,
0.0531385019,
0.3518961072,
-0.2616743445,
0.4161867499,
-0.3933064342,
-0.6340555549,
-0.3238934278,
-0.3490584791,
0.1598175466,
0.4526026249,
-0.6691014767,
0.5258672833,
0.2345731258,
0.044837676,
-0.520838201,
-0.5819779634,
-0.099147737,
-0.2878496945,
-0.5085757375,
-0.0210930128,
0.133000344,
-0.3035290837,
0.0920834243,
-0.2378002256,
0.086365059,
0.2179366201,
0.4763953984,
-0.1801244467,
-0.1569893062,
0.1199528947,
0.4108285606,
-0.1828860939,
0.5912047625,
-0.3516242206,
0.9077051878,
0.2075205594,
-0.3452852368,
-0.2556471527,
0.1941402256,
0.6412009001,
-0.0949552134,
1.1257399321,
0.2732006311,
-0.1763395667,
-0.5577030778,
-0.1567236334,
-0.0633060783,
-0.5681328177,
0.3640365899,
-0.2096141577,
-0.3605335653,
0.6217259169,
-0.3846889734,
0.1016574651,
0.5769438744,
0.5425925851,
-0.2448439747,
1.2248438597,
0.6638083458,
-0.0739255175,
0.7040653229,
-0.5727042556,
0.1884651184,
-0.7742370963,
-0.2074923366,
-0.5339961052,
-0.4972899556,
-0.9327281117,
-0.5602658987,
0.3615766466,
0.1918475926,
-0.3684254587,
0.0825665146,
-0.5690033436,
0.3253867328,
0.485203743,
-0.1555012316,
-0.0989578068,
-0.0557837263,
-0.4187258482,
0.2158423364,
-0.6806635857,
-0.4030915201,
0.5313856006,
0.6421064734,
0.6877685189,
0.0114366859,
0.3336319923,
0.2169648707,
-0.0157587379,
-0.629653573,
0.2725816369,
-0.0377016962,
-0.4825297892,
-0.5334172249,
-0.4221965075,
-1.2783294916,
0.1194447652,
-0.1956230402,
-0.8049189448,
0.2762671709,
0.209916532,
-0.0501981676,
0.5669366717,
-0.4791969359,
0.9946651459,
-0.2754329443,
-0.2729192376,
-0.0422785766,
-0.8131917119,
0.0895938575,
0.1721518189,
0.0190803707,
0.223578155,
0.2097565532,
0.9003450871,
-0.5055270195,
0.6367624402,
-0.4473732412,
0.1751579642,
0.0464950465,
0.3407781422,
0.6010553241,
-0.2111012787,
-0.1195777059,
0.1131719723,
0.3272491097,
-0.2243444175,
-0.7883614898,
0.7258765697,
-0.9852502942,
-0.4664378166,
-0.3926216364,
-0.6208199859,
-0.2454287559,
0.1055953354,
0.1817162633,
0.369910568,
0.3236806095,
0.4537580311,
0.6908900738,
-0.4365512133,
0.7542251945,
0.0350284018,
-0.2933796346,
0.0385951027,
0.4222706258,
0.5277535319,
0.353040874,
0.0471541472,
0.5342988968,
-0.3789005578,
-0.7356914878,
-0.5666720271,
0.5253863335,
-0.7203454971,
0.1707656085,
-0.6074866652,
-0.2855451405,
0.0376411788,
-0.1851196587,
-0.4178172052,
-0.0755912811,
-0.2243539393,
-0.330037266,
0.533180356,
1.0524350405,
0.3621588349,
0.6168061495,
-0.6038439274,
-0.2480525225,
-0.0235271268,
0.758477211,
0.5629481673,
-0.4444279373,
-0.3681460619,
0.0941320136,
-0.4512813985,
-1.3885540962,
0.2836386561,
-0.2454913706,
0.6147744656,
0.6919556856,
-0.1068628207,
0.6494235992,
-0.5682454705,
1.0823111534,
0.3997342587,
-0.9054601789,
0.3799328804,
-0.3728124201,
0.1653572321,
0.065211989,
0.6717732549,
-0.6944278479,
-0.4905256927,
-0.5751951933,
-1.2500098944,
0.7770358324,
0.0116570871,
0.3626835942,
0.2563562393,
0.6387196183,
0.2491306216,
-0.0971593484,
-0.7721639872,
-0.3858113587,
-0.3991850317,
-0.0484189764,
-0.045667626,
-0.3481877446,
-0.0131392889,
-0.3877126276,
0.5322583318,
0.1674612164,
0.0927089676,
-0.213012442,
0.14021869,
-0.5787140727,
-0.0851581991,
0.2874972522,
0.7451850176,
0.1206323728,
0.4066859186,
0.1249513477,
-0.2632635534,
0.0793865025,
0.0077506895,
-0.2384209633,
0.2229949236,
0.4383666515,
1.1336396933,
0.1649392545,
-0.3639701307,
0.4133836627,
0.3156956136,
-0.3667627871,
-0.2798316181,
0.425873667,
0.3106119931,
0.7315692306,
0.3468194902,
-0.0685682371,
0.3037902713,
-0.4549303055,
0.249957487,
0.3446569145,
-0.6437855959,
-0.6769282222,
0.5786972046,
-0.1638224274,
-0.5740682483,
0.7415695786,
-0.0935637653,
-0.4980253875,
0.3033802211,
0.3777578473,
0.758680284,
-0.3600570261,
0.4676715136,
0.1296767294,
0.3602672219,
-0.2003123015,
-0.0547293983,
0.0663155243,
-0.4555964172,
-0.3451693058,
-0.9632351398,
-0.1737725735,
0.1119099036,
-0.6272313595,
0.2510327697,
-0.2169608921,
-0.1820106357,
0.3021481335,
-0.2834472358,
-0.5529813766,
0.06673529,
-0.0804284737,
0.8939214945,
-1.3097519875,
0.566144824,
0.6339850426,
-0.6927648187,
-1.0112746954,
0.2726025581,
-0.3804617822,
-0.3966019452,
0.7696124911,
-0.1547629237,
-0.184084028,
-0.1879104674,
-0.4525888562,
-0.866946578,
1.044477582,
0.2183717638,
-0.5356679559,
-0.3661103845,
0.4876101613,
0.7442613244,
0.2064565867,
0.1242077202,
0.4858648181,
0.470287472,
0.1263068914,
-0.5607415438,
-0.0525850728,
-0.1417813152,
0.477763921,
0.8014655113,
-0.3558978736,
0.9865297675,
0.2799085975,
-0.3181680739,
-0.2325472087,
0.2425831705,
-0.1380259246,
0.1364976764,
0.7881354094,
0.3652048111,
0.4579252601,
-0.344994694,
1.1693576574,
-0.4171853065,
0.5009204745,
0.6072023511,
0.106360212,
0.8182165623,
0.9160317183,
-0.5782723427,
0.7281198502,
0.8002104163,
-0.198779732,
0.5608113408,
0.5379263759,
0.0731744543,
0.1767818481,
0.290648371,
-0.0429659449,
0.1168616042,
0.0963227004,
-0.5794689059,
-0.4312430918,
0.0605066717,
-0.0591800287,
-0.2650113404,
0.0677378252,
0.4801513851,
-0.1106076762,
-0.5553081632,
0.3497506082,
-0.1808921695,
0.4473347962,
-0.6633586287,
-0.0924389362,
-0.0751800686,
0.2140498012,
-0.0442983024,
-1.0073348284,
0.68943578,
-0.2037958056,
-0.3365016282,
-0.2569636703,
0.2324505299,
-0.0865962505,
-0.2671664357,
0.7618838549,
0.3117889762,
0.2149900347,
0.0062718373,
-0.8467709422,
0.2428372651,
-0.4098981023,
-0.8618197441,
0.1377002448,
0.8153961897,
0.0845905393,
0.7133538723,
0.5401174426,
0.1768194735,
0.4251579642,
0.1790962219,
0.9375725985,
-0.5464069247,
-0.3709692955,
-0.9901297688,
0.7311262488,
-0.0365902968,
-0.2826543748,
0.6662403941,
0.4253651202,
0.7286302447,
-0.0707244202,
0.5332841277,
0.0583388917,
0.328346014,
-0.4264221489,
0.9027131796,
-0.7083890438,
0.2987809479,
-0.3117221296,
-0.9968165159,
-0.0892343,
0.4993218482,
-0.4017920792,
0.1448464543,
0.734318316,
0.586219728,
-0.1175329611,
-0.0616381764,
0.2434807569,
0.3461501002,
0.4684315622,
0.0403922051,
1.0217727423,
-0.4558814168,
0.3387384117,
-0.2218996733,
-0.1234095469,
-0.2899651825,
-0.8407269716,
-0.6715567708,
-0.9785856605,
-0.2087596506,
-0.438819319,
0.158135578,
0.709004581,
0.7047710419,
-0.6934375763,
-0.4565313756,
-0.375859648,
0.0966048837,
-0.6595200896,
-0.2893987298,
0.3054441512,
-0.4449780881,
-0.5290201306,
-0.1613139063,
0.4460966885,
-0.0120200934,
-0.8102712035,
-0.1464310884,
-0.4099998176,
0.3019979596,
0.4551818669,
-0.0986336768,
-0.7292271852,
-0.4789957106,
0.0693027154,
0.3831311762,
-0.0161195956,
0.5851400495,
-0.1901944429,
0.4927771091,
0.5555050373,
0.5381625295,
0.5876660943,
-0.2859538496,
0.6106492281,
-0.634277463,
-0.1010092422,
-0.0065542217,
0.3052789867,
0.1073835269,
-0.1089780256,
0.4170309007,
0.3594068885,
-0.6304653883,
-1.1309206486,
0.1954320222,
-0.7718567252,
-0.3343983293,
1.0016124249,
-0.0102280863,
-0.4831742048,
-0.1340438128,
0.1006324366,
0.8063996434,
0.1127650216,
0.9310210347,
1.0764436722,
-0.4202720523,
-0.5363255739,
-0.6863286495,
0.5462139249,
0.115467906,
-0.642731607,
0.3184737861,
0.3234342337,
0.4564261138,
0.3727355599,
-0.1661568731,
-0.0449480563,
-0.0887292251,
0.2145196199,
-0.1510871351,
0.1632445455,
-0.4610569179,
-0.1209476739,
0.2124496698,
0.3419508338,
-0.1806181073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08738v1
|
Improving Acoustic Word Embeddings through Correspondence Training of Self-supervised Speech Representations
| 2024-03-13T17:42:03 | 2024-03-13T17:42:03 |
Amit Meghanani, Thomas Hain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Acoustic word embeddings (AWEs) are vector representations of spoken words.
An effective method for obtaining AWEs is the Correspondence Auto-Encoder
(CAE). In the past, the CAE method has been associated with traditional MFCC
features. Representations obtained from self-supervised learning (SSL)-based
speech models such as HuBERT, Wav2vec2, etc., are outperforming MFCC in many
downstream tasks. However, they have not been well studied in the context of
learning AWEs. This work explores the effectiveness of CAE with SSL-based
speech representations to obtain improved AWEs. Additionally, the capabilities
of SSL-based speech models are explored in cross-lingual scenarios for
obtaining AWEs. Experiments are conducted on five languages: Polish,
Portuguese, Spanish, French, and English. HuBERT-based CAE model achieves the
best results for word discrimination in all languages, despite Hu-BERT being
pre-trained on English only. Also, the HuBERT-based CAE model works well in
cross-lingual settings. It outperforms MFCC-based CAE models trained on the
target languages when trained on one source language and tested on target
languages.
|
[
-0.3617309034,
-0.5183341503,
0.3001162708,
0.231231004,
-0.1740722656,
0.1117739305,
-0.1569945067,
-0.7289435267,
0.5719792843,
0.2233169526,
-0.4249686301,
-0.6067153811,
-0.657874465,
0.2417937517,
-0.3597049117,
0.3767436445,
-0.1185840964,
0.3635241985,
0.0573160537,
-0.2193641067,
-0.5716018081,
-0.6348260641,
-0.4674685299,
-0.2498115599,
0.2945593596,
-0.0081674838,
0.4810869694,
0.8264561892,
0.1146729067,
0.3521273136,
0.2007602304,
0.117683582,
-0.508648634,
0.0632615238,
0.0532925837,
-0.3665499985,
0.0211908054,
0.1750961244,
0.5848652124,
0.6695255041,
-0.4124361575,
-0.1862873733,
0.3648923337,
0.3194025755,
-0.7128615975,
0.4087910652,
-0.7005668879,
0.3762326539,
-0.0475101098,
-0.1838217229,
-0.4200094044,
0.05709102,
0.2926238775,
-0.7119371891,
0.0166081395,
0.1056525111,
0.6863722801,
0.1362564117,
-0.1589103937,
-0.5748748183,
-0.6033640504,
0.763854146,
-0.8264447451,
1.2323424816,
0.5286208391,
0.1364305615,
-0.1245604679,
-0.3660876453,
-0.3567158282,
-0.3356161416,
0.0397716351,
0.3480843306,
-0.1172772869,
0.1111839414,
-0.0970761478,
0.4496203363,
-0.3646213412,
0.3019313812,
-0.2119696885,
-0.5149376988,
0.6226114035,
-0.1571973562,
0.2868721783,
-0.0970812663,
-0.3792437017,
-0.2910781801,
-0.5812025666,
0.0348049887,
0.4072959125,
0.4108684361,
-0.3465627134,
0.3592030108,
0.111981295,
0.6345256567,
0.2258258462,
-0.1955973655,
0.3211424649,
-0.1390715837,
-0.0854091421,
0.3758705854,
0.7418812513,
-0.2298812866,
0.3583318889,
-0.3155709505,
-0.1681224406,
0.1121493131,
-0.0878758878,
-0.161341086,
-0.312043041,
-0.2049568146,
-0.3491469324,
-0.023930911,
0.0941148698,
-0.203285411,
0.1878647208,
-0.6261318326,
0.6147010922,
-0.4068650603,
-0.1809975207,
0.0919421017,
-0.1104223132,
0.3889181614,
0.0177198965,
-1.1414632797,
0.2656900287,
0.3594694138,
0.6967570782,
-0.0440427177,
-0.3132834733,
-0.6338214874,
0.4631302655,
-0.5452144742,
0.6424040198,
-0.4836964309,
-0.6796900034,
0.3113192618,
-0.2057415545,
-0.2787619829,
-0.5008574128,
0.3851377666,
-0.1730583757,
0.3986791074,
-0.1876403391,
-0.9514250159,
0.0346895941,
-0.2325514555,
-0.5388468504,
1.1060256958,
0.0174603295,
-0.5500223041,
0.2180168182,
-0.3791653216,
-0.482899487,
-0.2067961991,
-0.5260309577,
-0.1697076857,
0.1330274045,
0.500285387,
0.4752503633,
0.0708957091,
-0.1377408057,
-0.2610296309,
-0.2645690441,
-0.0276956838,
-0.4138075411,
0.6318281889,
0.1910590529,
-0.4170432985,
-0.2784490585,
-0.452388078,
-0.2571623921,
0.0552690923,
-0.2662598789,
-0.6066581607,
-0.1884118617,
-0.0025000414,
0.2207134515,
0.1711486429,
-0.8958593607,
-0.3268027008,
-0.7273505926,
0.3352747262,
0.6679049134,
-0.1758025438,
0.2378294617,
-0.1084295437,
0.3999409974,
0.1540099531,
0.0378137119,
-0.2078172266,
-0.4959724545,
-0.5842038393,
-0.1799194366,
0.576467514,
0.6224881411,
-0.7058027983,
0.5749970675,
0.0257162936,
-0.2706617415,
-1.1252355576,
0.3272985816,
0.5500712395,
0.3670670986,
0.6132696867,
-0.4463646412,
-0.4335399568,
-0.9584946632,
-0.2266393453,
-0.2953946292,
-0.037914183,
0.449999243,
0.0621569864,
0.0381827652,
0.8660924435,
-0.3081884384,
-0.6602262259,
0.0866613388,
0.2273507863,
-0.1447391808,
0.505543232,
0.591620028,
-0.5082734227,
-0.6351310611,
-0.1358896643,
-0.7279925346,
-0.2311409712,
-0.027249841,
0.0564213358,
0.1906222999,
0.7447274327,
0.0040175281,
0.4425790906,
0.8799262643,
-0.0291922241,
0.4381254315,
-0.2830058336,
0.1031656414,
-0.9266476631,
-0.5181334019,
0.1257888079,
-0.3545158207,
-0.4871203601,
-0.1662746668,
-0.0208538026,
-0.182666868,
-0.6049687862,
0.406051904,
-0.7144224644,
-0.0796854496,
-0.2946415544,
0.414819628,
-0.0833498016,
0.4767036438,
0.3628827333,
0.8336413503,
0.8752765059,
-0.5719927549,
0.2178094834,
0.4376046658,
-0.1606105715,
0.4716793597,
-0.5959151983,
0.2186346352,
0.004174009,
0.164289251,
-0.9727518559,
0.2508791685,
-0.1016179547,
-0.430554688,
0.6627462506,
0.099109523,
-0.2390045822,
-0.2243927717,
-0.1153116226,
0.39437747,
0.2981902659,
-1.0177658796,
0.7534506917,
0.7183579206,
-0.0340999067,
-0.4114608467,
-0.9587903619,
0.1410370171,
-0.0894782022,
-0.577976346,
0.4245021939,
0.0100346366,
0.07392288,
-0.1301167607,
-0.0242406484,
0.1135972142,
-0.2657664716,
0.082030423,
-0.0520788655,
-0.3333739638,
0.1721083969,
0.0971927568,
-0.034162432,
0.0092503438,
-0.2376339287,
0.4074585736,
0.0329938829,
-0.5892958045,
-0.6581542492,
0.6275177002,
0.1263185441,
-0.4591461718,
0.4541685283,
0.7426466942,
-0.4039702713,
-0.312543869,
-0.9182302356,
-0.3496537507,
-0.5061663985,
0.1713374853,
-0.5755000114,
-1.0167847872,
0.5875659585,
-0.131130293,
0.1418139189,
0.5002323389,
0.2771868408,
-0.297545433,
0.9209319949,
0.5869011879,
-0.591981411,
0.5878594518,
-0.3488320708,
0.019591257,
-0.9986740351,
-0.0954006985,
-0.4991928041,
0.0845386386,
-0.6147114038,
-0.4413206875,
0.2705015838,
-0.0925612822,
0.3350442052,
0.6561507583,
-0.162861675,
0.1898754388,
0.3710774183,
-0.0060822675,
0.0243476517,
0.184512347,
-0.6500415802,
-0.2228206545,
-0.9412774444,
-0.0781936646,
0.7395774126,
0.6671639681,
0.8514959812,
-0.1487980485,
1.1434168816,
0.3910195231,
-0.0497797169,
-0.7372130156,
0.2345910668,
-0.3873876035,
-0.3645969331,
-0.4549461305,
-0.365773648,
-0.9686629176,
0.4222016037,
-0.3553502262,
-0.5120132565,
0.6244505644,
0.1247415841,
-0.1036869511,
0.2117082775,
-0.399841249,
0.5073412061,
-0.1278999299,
-0.2295387536,
-0.5266937613,
-0.3903311491,
-0.1593812406,
-0.0937791318,
0.4384027123,
0.0263027754,
0.2325807065,
0.8667013645,
-0.2813951075,
0.7653541565,
-0.2087724954,
-0.7404758334,
0.4310786426,
-0.0165317897,
0.6025007963,
-0.2108642012,
-0.1900947094,
0.6394073367,
-0.2120770812,
-0.1927265823,
-0.5366835594,
0.7496051192,
-0.7913770676,
-0.555500865,
-0.2104833275,
-0.2853897512,
-0.4992395937,
-0.2108306289,
0.2265749276,
0.7732666135,
-0.4902816713,
0.0567514114,
0.4521072507,
-0.1959516257,
0.4769017696,
0.7632188201,
-0.0655659363,
-0.4113607109,
0.8213831782,
0.3233109415,
0.2089184374,
0.4525458813,
0.2861455977,
-0.6732762456,
-0.4304163456,
-0.4525212049,
0.4654539227,
-0.772228241,
0.0025788997,
-0.5270341039,
-0.2873077989,
-0.7144893408,
-0.1915971488,
-0.560049355,
-0.3723851442,
-0.3746356368,
-0.1419213414,
0.0563460514,
0.6812829375,
-0.6115267277,
0.2583747208,
-0.6445326805,
0.3691369891,
0.4929198623,
0.1546514779,
-0.0999511406,
-0.8451014757,
-0.5233587027,
0.2271006852,
-0.1296256334,
-0.931963563,
0.3704706728,
0.6408955455,
0.8072624803,
0.4119689167,
-0.0529085733,
0.9113758206,
-0.6625737548,
0.6685813069,
0.2627266049,
-1.1610715389,
0.6087654233,
-0.3188124597,
0.174100861,
0.5063920617,
0.3027682006,
-0.5363452435,
-0.8071801662,
-0.5946257114,
-0.6028954387,
0.3458830714,
0.3315719068,
0.2501927018,
-0.2652022839,
0.2559358478,
-0.0610358864,
-0.0690781474,
-0.5553871393,
-0.3972175121,
-0.3941742778,
-0.2099494934,
-0.08039435,
-0.006523971,
0.244900316,
-0.2250588387,
0.9223093987,
-0.0799204409,
0.2749034464,
0.568389535,
-0.1922800392,
-0.1997562796,
0.0277540646,
0.2668020129,
0.1655609161,
0.0933677703,
-0.0364049748,
0.4825895429,
-0.3299091458,
0.0038582876,
0.0574044622,
0.16413486,
0.3405745029,
0.5483300686,
0.8303630948,
0.5847142935,
-0.1810549349,
0.5824352503,
0.0130889984,
-0.1508597434,
-0.4176656306,
0.0844562873,
0.1349878907,
-0.0112639274,
0.1924826503,
-0.3617676198,
0.4778772295,
-0.5456518531,
0.3379448056,
0.6798366308,
-0.5753123164,
-0.1189941913,
0.617978096,
0.294929117,
-0.1601257473,
0.5379056334,
0.2480800897,
-0.4456059933,
0.3651378155,
0.9324230552,
0.8622813225,
-1.0082117319,
-0.0794367939,
0.4447714984,
0.2892480791,
0.1568591297,
0.2698403597,
-0.3156937957,
-0.7070871592,
-0.4056536257,
-0.6844642758,
-0.3346969187,
-0.1247392148,
-0.8321011662,
0.1459045708,
-0.0600126348,
-0.1409283578,
-0.1469649076,
-0.2337568849,
-0.8483015895,
0.1661468744,
0.4704144895,
0.7848467827,
-1.0184756517,
1.0283077955,
0.3572855592,
-0.0483392179,
-1.1800041199,
-0.1839636564,
-0.1218253598,
-0.9511308074,
0.512347281,
0.0764698908,
-0.5674850345,
0.1391164809,
-0.2020541579,
-1.0133581161,
0.8735664487,
0.3663958609,
-0.9691938758,
0.1793697029,
0.5371611714,
0.5730202198,
-0.6647775173,
0.0509273596,
0.286816895,
0.3826134801,
-0.1669487655,
-1.3524233103,
-0.391120851,
-0.0305774566,
0.0905581787,
-0.0012406632,
-0.4787216187,
0.3817062974,
0.0201256163,
-0.2924554944,
-0.1389029175,
1.1736810207,
0.1012017429,
-0.0159858093,
0.7581617236,
0.6733962297,
0.6123007536,
-0.0066599268,
0.7868661284,
-0.5233092308,
0.1751945168,
1.1482007504,
-0.1193290353,
1.1418625116,
0.2537212968,
-0.1781557053,
0.6765088439,
0.4321018159,
-0.096840173,
0.6306833625,
0.1902837455,
-0.2156257331,
-0.3419430256,
-0.317548126,
-0.5750969052,
0.9486359954,
0.4816839695,
-0.4694578648,
-0.0709038675,
0.3420629203,
-0.3715617955,
0.2061845362,
-0.2511525452,
1.0313626528,
0.5885904431,
-0.2029965967,
0.6948225498,
-0.0997295231,
0.7841889858,
-0.7554659247,
-0.1437718868,
-0.0183970984,
-0.2281114608,
-0.1147909164,
-0.4076133668,
0.1144831702,
-0.3716838956,
0.1414878517,
-0.0609307922,
0.6569944024,
-1.0189806223,
-0.4324150383,
0.9104409218,
0.4872322083,
0.2081188262,
0.2339150161,
-0.7957703471,
0.0001827513,
-0.0982421041,
0.0822760165,
0.2066826522,
0.3130269051,
0.2841308117,
0.4844124615,
0.623909533,
0.283428967,
0.2171807587,
0.4247325957,
0.5506038666,
-0.4188711047,
-1.007740736,
-0.5939123631,
0.051178623,
0.3017345369,
0.0075230878,
0.9861091375,
0.6875452995,
0.8693736792,
-0.2346775979,
0.6376476288,
0.5289289355,
0.4645359516,
-0.7528662682,
0.5562677383,
-0.5392562747,
0.1168113351,
-0.4512351751,
-0.844158709,
0.0295347013,
1.0778641701,
-0.0314819515,
0.0418151617,
0.5673936009,
0.7211312652,
-0.1624434143,
0.2515180409,
0.5916683674,
0.1309193224,
0.1967916191,
0.3769596815,
0.6591895819,
-0.5809855461,
0.2652038336,
-0.4347678721,
-0.1567327231,
0.1067867875,
-0.6795323491,
-0.872374177,
-0.766325891,
-0.5545172691,
-0.1146628633,
0.2378888726,
0.9560365081,
0.8670841455,
-0.8640477657,
-0.5167184472,
0.1311157644,
-0.3049730062,
-0.256551981,
-0.1732848585,
0.6901420951,
-0.3546005189,
-0.6141812801,
1.0103725195,
0.2820058167,
0.3365714848,
-0.5191575289,
-0.2106439024,
-0.1535573304,
0.2840389311,
0.6635197997,
0.3180317581,
-0.7664536834,
-0.3112749755,
-0.1948823631,
0.0106729344,
0.2502403855,
0.6482034326,
-0.8033926487,
0.5689993501,
0.2153673172,
0.5343487859,
0.3357698321,
-0.1611852348,
0.772477448,
-0.8190553188,
0.1061208472,
0.0320750251,
0.795634985,
0.575285852,
-0.3894133866,
0.2987583876,
0.0644513592,
-0.4221705496,
-0.3817325532,
0.1162732467,
-0.7822645307,
-0.1847814918,
1.1533026695,
-0.2511643171,
-0.1263321936,
-0.4679217935,
-0.1124865785,
0.4644912779,
-0.4302207828,
0.790094614,
0.6903269291,
-0.0485661253,
0.0314145423,
-0.2785949111,
0.5044050813,
0.6113705635,
-0.4269436002,
0.0566187203,
0.2907443345,
0.1715548635,
0.3395019174,
0.4713004529,
-0.3021048307,
0.1181484684,
-0.0865412131,
0.0071875514,
-0.0693345368,
-0.3211040497,
-0.3704397082,
-0.0443608463,
0.0479185283,
-0.2445140779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08737v1
|
ILCiteR: Evidence-grounded Interpretable Local Citation Recommendation
| 2024-03-13T17:38:05 | 2024-03-13T17:38:05 |
Sayar Ghosh Roy, Jiawei Han
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Existing Machine Learning approaches for local citation recommendation
directly map or translate a query, which is typically a claim or an entity
mention, to citation-worthy research papers. Within such a formulation, it is
challenging to pinpoint why one should cite a specific research paper for a
particular query, leading to limited recommendation interpretability. To
alleviate this, we introduce the evidence-grounded local citation
recommendation task, where the target latent space comprises evidence spans for
recommending specific papers. Using a distantly-supervised evidence retrieval
and multi-step re-ranking framework, our proposed system, ILCiteR, recommends
papers to cite for a query grounded on similar evidence spans extracted from
the existing research literature. Unlike past formulations that simply output
recommendations, ILCiteR retrieves ranked lists of evidence span and
recommended paper pairs. Secondly, previously proposed neural models for
citation recommendation require expensive training on massive labeled data,
ideally after every significant update to the pool of candidate papers. In
contrast, ILCiteR relies solely on distant supervision from a dynamic evidence
database and pre-trained Transformer-based Language Models without any model
training. We contribute a novel dataset for the evidence-grounded local
citation recommendation task and demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed
conditional neural rank-ensembling approach for re-ranking evidence spans.
|
[
-0.0468770601,
-0.437220186,
0.7224978209,
0.0945904627,
-0.1368052661,
-0.1274194866,
-0.018554436,
-0.4850200117,
0.4707549512,
0.4316158593,
-0.0443891399,
-0.2591337264,
-0.6655587554,
0.0079001943,
-0.3160954714,
1.1683988571,
-0.0887610167,
0.3234462738,
-0.5649286509,
-0.2113102376,
-0.3060592115,
-0.3878599107,
-0.5891366601,
-0.5478986502,
1.0687063932,
0.3038507402,
0.4018633068,
0.2356448323,
0.5518038869,
0.1352470666,
-0.1375421584,
0.1424485445,
-0.2808052599,
0.1818820536,
-0.409670651,
-0.4921731949,
-0.3069589436,
0.0030660983,
0.383030653,
0.8135360479,
0.0960247889,
-0.0136968456,
-0.0007253793,
0.5253121257,
-0.7473073006,
-0.0743288621,
-0.8199789524,
0.0604463369,
-0.2363468707,
-0.2603386045,
-0.5099073648,
-0.7686089873,
0.1277191192,
-0.3757615983,
0.2819638848,
0.1744436771,
0.6738698483,
0.1352358311,
-0.5647805929,
-0.0659840927,
-0.4596427381,
0.5073142648,
-0.5081507564,
0.1068016887,
0.6715002656,
0.2007009983,
-0.0121862646,
-0.9705709815,
-0.0530845709,
-0.2997817695,
-0.5417610407,
0.0687969774,
-0.1350929439,
-0.1374059916,
0.0869043544,
0.2818484306,
-0.4071441293,
-0.3369659781,
-0.3551521599,
-0.110794872,
0.2280900627,
-0.2297570109,
-0.0924037024,
-0.0816135034,
-0.3019368649,
0.2538540959,
-0.8167877793,
-0.0149341943,
0.2146173865,
0.49565956,
0.3659411967,
0.5089448094,
-0.2831344903,
0.6494864225,
0.5058788657,
0.2351481616,
0.1144956723,
-0.2039758265,
-0.0194471292,
0.4373426735,
0.4935509562,
0.0963558257,
-0.2592135668,
-0.5876274705,
-0.0372875705,
-0.4124593735,
0.3789881468,
-1.0479960442,
-0.1939640492,
0.0033123957,
-0.7674959898,
-0.2815406322,
0.0241146237,
-0.422657311,
-0.5483513474,
-0.3949964941,
0.5137496591,
-0.3877122998,
-0.3307114542,
-0.198093757,
0.0017705957,
-0.1814636886,
0.343704313,
-0.6954818368,
0.0676511526,
0.3906948864,
0.998621881,
-0.1504284889,
-0.2418945432,
-0.5963228941,
-0.0548602194,
-0.0377796069,
1.1068872213,
-0.9018037319,
-0.1604001671,
0.1620587409,
0.2605058849,
-0.3457265496,
-0.653288722,
1.0575244427,
-0.6257477999,
0.2470662594,
-0.3284612298,
-0.6093252301,
-0.0832004398,
0.2398213744,
-0.4104168713,
0.8301302791,
-0.0882336646,
-1.1292228699,
0.7483261228,
-0.6657483578,
-0.5294853449,
-0.1031930521,
-0.0581312478,
-0.228564024,
0.175777033,
0.282122761,
0.2569498718,
-0.1604469121,
0.7931392193,
-0.4169662595,
-0.4264780581,
-0.3395274878,
-0.2285247594,
0.644895494,
0.5582142472,
-0.371871829,
0.3508087397,
-0.8376357555,
-0.0356064737,
-0.2039530873,
-0.276735872,
-0.7190394998,
0.2741429806,
0.0937928408,
-0.0680451691,
0.2030849755,
-0.4808530807,
0.3584635556,
-0.2582431138,
0.2494280487,
0.2802821398,
0.0731734559,
0.5994650126,
-0.4074544013,
0.3816117048,
-0.1888018996,
-0.3583244979,
-0.3158824146,
-0.3239313066,
-0.6648923755,
-0.3036780357,
0.3726945221,
0.2007397115,
-0.4702122808,
0.4514760971,
-0.5715112686,
-0.3685707748,
-0.3162735403,
-0.1945685297,
-0.0090577407,
0.5426864624,
0.6073429585,
0.2116107792,
-0.6639211774,
-0.9097037315,
-0.559191823,
-0.0909692049,
-0.1363296807,
0.2584989667,
0.5371574163,
-0.0099352989,
1.1832741499,
-0.1699293405,
-0.4387174547,
0.1721604019,
0.5625603199,
0.5705182552,
0.5800651908,
0.3703179061,
-0.7179929018,
-0.3618119061,
-0.0406440049,
-0.9226997495,
-0.077450566,
-0.2888031006,
-0.2183885723,
-0.4218931198,
0.7062677741,
-0.3972806334,
0.4792806804,
0.0779880732,
-0.5714030862,
0.0844412148,
-0.2374131233,
0.2230836302,
-0.9455724955,
0.2835776508,
-0.2649693191,
-0.1112611964,
-0.1108129472,
-0.1328549236,
0.0385843702,
-0.0529233702,
0.0425527804,
0.5815931559,
-0.4161300361,
0.1000641882,
-0.4571224451,
-0.2675271034,
0.1117841601,
0.0468502566,
0.2862020433,
0.52903229,
0.2902395427,
-0.0863700733,
-0.2022116333,
0.1634699553,
-0.4667115808,
0.8335578442,
-0.6731786728,
0.0666558743,
-0.0394150279,
0.4459766746,
-0.6275251508,
0.0349614769,
-0.0489619672,
-0.0821785107,
0.3142020404,
-0.7477012873,
-0.2371309102,
0.1650788933,
0.0548043437,
0.5786277652,
-0.0055422992,
-0.9138979316,
0.7485120296,
0.0243737977,
-0.1541154236,
-0.5432897806,
-0.3753502369,
0.2193618864,
-0.3860970736,
-0.5941621661,
0.8109279275,
0.1277673393,
-0.3009775877,
0.3293791413,
-0.1237309501,
-0.0332131349,
0.0041676853,
0.6572940946,
-0.1468480378,
-0.3889291584,
0.1995870322,
0.0839642733,
0.0530441068,
0.2060763985,
-0.4562084079,
0.0714390129,
-0.1292995512,
-0.4019096494,
0.0077600181,
0.4714832306,
0.6142837405,
-0.0252723359,
0.7284933329,
0.6790043712,
-0.4052389264,
0.292748034,
-0.5482456088,
-0.1770516485,
-0.3447813988,
0.0762684345,
-0.3700546026,
-0.7310776711,
0.2602644265,
-0.2511020303,
-0.0184004586,
0.4092368484,
0.4950285554,
-0.0502844416,
0.6507398486,
0.3416680992,
-0.2835665047,
0.6186047196,
-0.0924591273,
0.2872406244,
-0.6947901845,
-0.3770849109,
-0.8023961186,
-0.3018145859,
-0.2084960043,
-0.2831970453,
0.1083782837,
0.3266005218,
-0.4588681459,
0.0564014576,
-0.6371165514,
0.4229867756,
0.6231843233,
0.0498286039,
0.2946178317,
0.4125228226,
-0.4849084318,
-0.1870973855,
-0.5616372228,
-0.4043093026,
0.8490039706,
-0.0376464911,
0.7607001662,
-0.1553557068,
0.8198029995,
0.6022075415,
0.6796230674,
-0.5412044525,
0.0777858421,
0.2881678045,
-0.9052435756,
0.1960816681,
-0.1250646561,
-1.2332347631,
0.4699057043,
-0.389000386,
-0.7884936333,
0.572429955,
-0.255320698,
-0.1061719954,
0.361215502,
-0.5455121994,
0.7139387131,
-0.2915505171,
-0.7737685442,
-0.1869060844,
-0.42414096,
0.176725328,
0.0715372413,
0.1180498153,
0.0534716062,
0.4470092952,
0.7134849429,
-0.3778374493,
0.6868006587,
-0.6470323205,
0.2439620793,
0.1227012351,
0.0114651723,
0.747469604,
0.3643494248,
-0.5055530071,
0.1538658589,
-0.1382376403,
-0.3402685523,
-0.4923460782,
1.0575239658,
-0.4910584092,
-0.5876268744,
-0.7937680483,
-0.4988864958,
-0.1845950484,
0.3725336492,
0.327213347,
0.1884794086,
-0.0790518895,
0.5870146155,
0.2954623699,
0.0395184979,
0.1773382276,
0.281855315,
-0.1477835029,
-0.8009328246,
0.7920686603,
-0.0384900086,
-0.4927803576,
0.6091578007,
-0.0777842179,
-0.2990891039,
-0.8955585361,
-0.0876002312,
0.0506691299,
-0.7267144322,
-0.2553156912,
-0.7155656219,
0.0502967909,
-0.2760537267,
-0.2436634898,
-0.3217087984,
-0.4448008537,
-0.256965965,
-0.0478785671,
0.2908016443,
0.5131067634,
-0.0642584935,
-0.0456875004,
-0.3177667856,
0.0801165104,
-0.0211025085,
0.417173624,
-0.1228187308,
-0.628623426,
-0.4555851221,
-0.1244726777,
-0.0650079101,
-0.4768405259,
0.3021866381,
0.1222395599,
0.7078658938,
0.6284988523,
0.3071393073,
0.8417756557,
-0.6450140476,
0.4700153172,
0.0122301476,
-0.3892790079,
0.7529207468,
-0.5137581825,
0.0227446165,
0.9428189993,
0.678720355,
0.0990853086,
-0.1099128351,
-0.4803637862,
-1.1201536655,
0.4742503166,
0.2815370858,
-0.087200895,
0.0487142168,
0.6000970006,
0.1516050398,
-0.0536826812,
-0.8420835137,
-0.2097428143,
-0.4318801463,
-0.0697892681,
0.0330751464,
-0.2551625073,
-0.3439493477,
-0.3628822267,
0.5968670249,
-0.2730338275,
0.5114924908,
0.5713878274,
-0.2039228231,
-0.0449376516,
0.2371323109,
0.4693725407,
0.7898204327,
-0.7628756166,
0.2975527942,
-0.0730569586,
-0.1714813411,
0.0736533254,
0.5119079351,
-0.5702025294,
0.2436950803,
0.3099328279,
0.523842752,
0.3202326298,
-0.1827403158,
0.2391540259,
-0.1850418001,
-0.2443326712,
-0.5792890191,
-0.3125412762,
0.1828163266,
0.2719387412,
0.7407591343,
0.567907989,
0.2279117703,
-0.2973878086,
0.1491540074,
0.3811340928,
-0.7024756074,
-0.205908373,
0.8500984311,
0.0845301673,
-0.0829009414,
0.4460271001,
0.1136222705,
-0.1374583095,
0.2698695362,
0.5954837799,
0.7677862644,
0.4078053832,
-0.033701621,
0.6663232446,
0.1353331357,
-0.1182907149,
-0.0993593633,
-0.3269115388,
-0.5170123577,
-0.2976421714,
-0.6137422323,
-0.3095611334,
0.1534598172,
-0.9054376483,
0.0627772883,
-0.2977451384,
-0.2405361384,
0.1217402071,
-0.1102482155,
-0.3350486755,
0.0850797221,
-0.0698096231,
0.8877577782,
-0.6093013883,
1.0473706722,
0.8468616605,
-0.5854700804,
-0.4177865386,
-0.0099090971,
-0.2630756497,
-0.2674821615,
1.0127987862,
0.1113457829,
-0.2364004999,
-0.3496589363,
-0.4260788262,
-0.9869980812,
1.05552423,
0.5584081411,
-0.1241342425,
0.1249521002,
-0.5130398273,
0.3912444115,
-0.6614027023,
0.7720009685,
-0.0232655425,
0.43347767,
0.1222676113,
-0.4191789329,
0.2768842876,
-0.5948194861,
-0.2656691968,
0.0253036059,
-0.3693602979,
0.6185725331,
-0.1890878081,
0.1952819824,
0.2409778088,
0.878937304,
0.2849024832,
0.7043653131,
0.4463735223,
0.4054371715,
0.8597138524,
-0.0739815757,
0.9475281239,
-0.2472378761,
0.1796697527,
1.481277585,
-0.5524903536,
0.9764332771,
0.7127375603,
-0.12107265,
0.9139508605,
0.6882092357,
-0.1873787194,
0.814236939,
0.0091874208,
-0.2929809391,
-0.331497699,
-0.4937204719,
-0.6758249998,
0.1656636596,
0.0425941981,
-0.7356747389,
-0.2908779085,
-0.1719127893,
0.0618594438,
0.048441574,
-0.0178651195,
0.3614265025,
-0.0329574756,
-1.0058746338,
0.6199654937,
-0.2110134065,
0.7619812489,
-0.546420157,
-0.1752212495,
-0.5876469612,
0.2861760855,
-0.499166131,
-0.0255321003,
0.2712689936,
0.0551075749,
-0.6475538611,
-0.410402298,
0.8082298636,
-0.0486705415,
-0.5883647799,
0.2414288968,
0.3841089904,
0.143769294,
-0.1690087616,
-0.4954659641,
-0.5014629364,
-0.049948439,
-0.2510979474,
0.742169857,
0.5015442371,
0.0072408793,
0.5364625454,
0.9058905244,
0.1396722496,
-0.1700692624,
0.1697047949,
0.8154595494,
-0.6977317333,
-0.2223040611,
-0.4425882399,
0.2461162806,
-0.233871147,
-0.1041627005,
0.8189623356,
0.7313431501,
0.531306088,
0.1786870211,
0.6651081443,
-0.2851089537,
0.4865124524,
-0.3789861202,
0.7953798771,
-0.6268908381,
0.471691817,
-0.0180273335,
-0.7106137276,
-0.4428500235,
0.9961963892,
-0.6292886734,
0.1652915478,
0.8393620849,
0.6680446267,
-0.1349387467,
0.1193415448,
0.0838090107,
0.1584011465,
0.1616084576,
0.225490585,
1.0139551163,
-0.3510405123,
0.6331762671,
0.0189150833,
0.2265020162,
-0.3099448383,
-1.1679881811,
-0.851722002,
-0.3485837281,
-0.4319011867,
-0.5329352617,
0.1505860835,
0.8663316965,
0.9771239161,
-1.0356246233,
0.1254482865,
-0.2709587812,
0.2385024726,
-0.2227693349,
-0.2857069671,
0.6507105827,
-0.423771888,
-0.5372923017,
0.8169118762,
0.0479262508,
-0.4730580747,
0.1820190251,
-0.0757680163,
-0.6220060587,
-0.43704018,
0.2864156663,
0.2424873412,
-0.7684394121,
-0.1304920167,
-0.0088460101,
0.0167098399,
0.2055380046,
1.219840765,
-1.2406036854,
0.4830204844,
0.4388848543,
0.594522357,
0.9114320874,
-0.1133452356,
0.4654863477,
-0.4118810594,
0.1455803365,
0.3073824048,
0.8322886229,
0.2104896605,
-0.3353079855,
0.7852085829,
0.1061305031,
-0.7871900797,
-0.8224404454,
-0.2410709262,
-0.8174863458,
-0.2032379508,
0.9813421369,
-0.6785520315,
0.2432411462,
-0.3561985791,
-0.1617117524,
-0.0043211235,
-0.4821377099,
0.7978804111,
0.4478991032,
-0.0878529251,
-0.0467644781,
-0.2128331363,
0.1884924024,
0.5767136812,
-0.5643390417,
-0.0437042192,
0.4810595512,
0.3973509073,
0.4111433029,
0.4490811229,
-0.0711062849,
0.0634687915,
0.2383449674,
-0.0336077213,
-0.1730199754,
-0.1896410584,
-0.3396941125,
0.5347160101,
0.2558664382,
0.2095334083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08730v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08730v2
|
Strengthening Multimodal Large Language Model with Bootstrapped Preference Optimization
| 2024-03-13T17:29:45 | 2024-04-03T15:22:23 |
Renjie Pi, Tianyang Han, Wei Xiong, Jipeng Zhang, Runtao Liu, Rui Pan, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) excel in generating responses based
on visual inputs. However, they often suffer from a bias towards generating
responses similar to their pretraining corpus, overshadowing the importance of
visual information. We treat this bias as a "preference" for pretraining
statistics, which hinders the model's grounding in visual input. To mitigate
this issue, we propose Bootstrapped Preference Optimization (BPO), which
conducts preference learning with datasets containing negative responses
bootstrapped from the model itself. Specifically, we propose the following two
strategies: 1) using distorted image inputs to the MLLM for eliciting responses
that contain signified pretraining bias; 2) leveraging text-based LLM to
explicitly inject erroneous but common elements into the original response.
Those undesirable responses are paired with original annotated responses from
the datasets to construct the preference dataset, which is subsequently
utilized to perform preference learning. Our approach effectively suppresses
pretrained LLM bias, enabling enhanced grounding in visual inputs. Extensive
experimentation demonstrates significant performance improvements across
multiple benchmarks, advancing the state-of-the-art in multimodal
conversational systems.
|
[
-0.5945348144,
-0.6282119751,
0.5180577636,
0.2668730021,
-0.4629144371,
-0.090238452,
-0.5606719851,
-0.2509812415,
0.3512793183,
0.5264403224,
-0.5950376391,
-0.2764677107,
-0.618457675,
-0.1534564346,
0.0976423398,
1.0842117071,
0.1388810128,
0.4663178027,
-0.414624691,
-0.1281674504,
-0.4112645686,
-0.6636536717,
-0.5426035523,
-0.4849311113,
0.7325219512,
0.4944500625,
0.6229320765,
0.3598974645,
0.2147649676,
0.2864078581,
0.3281530142,
0.2695376277,
-0.6019316912,
0.3045915067,
0.182937786,
-0.3548879027,
-0.3672022521,
-0.0841065422,
0.5114181042,
0.5865507126,
0.1243723482,
0.1540213078,
-0.0004538014,
0.7514407039,
-0.8807116151,
0.3121440709,
-0.8849514723,
0.0282101054,
-0.0043604304,
-0.5938248038,
-0.6364971995,
-0.1555758268,
0.1679812521,
-0.4670879841,
0.0239124354,
0.1097271889,
0.7923100591,
0.2043235898,
-0.3012604415,
0.1444556862,
-0.4961118996,
1.02371943,
-0.5413129926,
0.4831996858,
0.6365259886,
0.0890011117,
0.0124145849,
-0.0937962309,
-0.4366565347,
-0.4198752642,
0.0170729943,
0.0281440318,
0.1498177946,
0.2010464668,
0.1104703844,
-0.0015368856,
-0.488932848,
0.2508347631,
-0.2020237595,
-0.3343271613,
0.328637898,
-0.1722977161,
-0.0169092398,
-0.0509440564,
-0.3847167194,
-0.3395859897,
-0.6568617821,
0.097288467,
0.3956769109,
0.4630132616,
-0.0116232717,
0.6897475123,
-0.0937616453,
0.7763590217,
0.1660540253,
-0.3085202277,
0.7508856058,
-0.048280701,
-0.3637520075,
0.0035550089,
0.7056931257,
0.8109715581,
0.4712903202,
-0.077852957,
-0.3859077394,
0.1178558022,
0.2760747373,
-0.9508870244,
0.0138792126,
0.4278668761,
-0.4178587198,
-0.4590241313,
-0.2265548408,
-0.8152220845,
-0.5359702706,
-0.5994223952,
0.3351265788,
-0.4400179386,
-0.1745944321,
0.0311127957,
0.0749372765,
-0.0827720091,
0.4051526785,
-1.1997033358,
-0.08620435,
0.2197132111,
0.6433557272,
-0.0707119629,
-0.2283216864,
-0.8214868307,
0.0679403841,
-0.2936457396,
0.6980511546,
-0.7070052624,
-0.1336646229,
0.0960589275,
0.0923534259,
0.2726266682,
-0.578569293,
0.3021976352,
-0.6870564222,
0.1277026385,
-0.2359794974,
-0.1530366987,
0.0704331398,
0.5256159306,
-0.5459536314,
0.864092648,
-0.1144025475,
-0.6447986364,
0.7767837048,
-0.5780652761,
-0.3594004214,
-0.2113224268,
-0.3126550913,
-0.5538565516,
0.0022065835,
0.4386989176,
0.788888216,
-0.172016114,
0.4365234375,
-0.6640797257,
-0.0148604177,
0.1620281786,
-0.389267236,
0.348867923,
0.1637268513,
-0.2750732303,
0.6378903985,
-0.988861084,
0.1424044222,
0.1484110653,
-0.4320652783,
-0.4203268886,
0.1004983559,
0.4436415136,
0.2914569676,
0.1260347068,
-0.4685927331,
0.0129556302,
-0.3320836127,
0.2675122619,
1.1993572712,
-0.2853182554,
0.5296809077,
-0.1470795721,
0.298530668,
0.3047325909,
0.0945999622,
-0.3626196682,
-0.0375304222,
-0.9553735256,
-0.4331608415,
0.0244337674,
0.1158750877,
-0.9096344113,
0.3660222292,
-0.2286636233,
-0.2440492362,
-0.4662331641,
0.2471603006,
0.37887609,
0.5742895603,
0.5863003135,
-0.3978073895,
-0.6166554689,
-1.2736642361,
0.069267571,
-0.108210288,
-0.0011843088,
0.4125487208,
0.1406187415,
-0.2666184604,
0.818615973,
-0.4869192541,
-0.1398330033,
-0.2458435893,
0.0270012021,
-0.0688040331,
0.4703969359,
0.7319971323,
-0.9343977571,
-0.35076648,
-0.1190460622,
-0.4397205114,
0.0101498375,
-0.1191118658,
-0.219304949,
0.291714251,
0.2010186166,
-0.4461431205,
0.0595394894,
0.612310648,
-0.053817112,
0.598406136,
-0.061899092,
0.2168963403,
-1.054194808,
0.0059596864,
0.2207215577,
-0.4388774335,
-0.5118803978,
-0.1398899257,
0.180719465,
-0.0737902597,
-0.412235558,
0.3717407584,
-0.4635592401,
0.1340533346,
-0.2678436041,
-0.1136506125,
-0.015712129,
0.6082912087,
0.3603689075,
0.7600500584,
0.6591775417,
-0.5644273758,
0.3941271305,
0.0348502174,
-0.2370754927,
0.4274596572,
-0.529209435,
0.1352068335,
-0.5325835943,
0.1631896347,
-1.080688715,
-0.345581919,
0.1437733918,
-0.3038397431,
0.541915834,
-0.1991514415,
-0.4110178947,
-0.1505472213,
-0.6043335199,
0.4556054771,
0.2517372966,
-0.6147201061,
0.4381611049,
0.3592570722,
-0.0567673594,
-0.9987810254,
-0.4510679245,
-0.0884906277,
-0.2042514235,
-0.4823487103,
0.0775760636,
-0.1447769254,
-0.0281051826,
-0.4751623273,
0.0887563378,
0.1228957325,
-0.1574937552,
0.2222921848,
0.5716258883,
-0.1621795297,
0.4124755859,
-0.2201771587,
-0.1758360714,
-0.0394339263,
-0.3138204813,
1.1035929918,
-0.0508257709,
-0.2925952673,
-0.1536434591,
0.1443266422,
0.90392977,
-0.3951452672,
0.7974789739,
0.7175492048,
0.0032882798,
-0.011691872,
-0.8100730181,
-0.4146475196,
-0.4788532555,
0.6673018932,
-0.2516084611,
-0.8068672419,
0.0389705375,
-0.0140195834,
-0.0644684955,
-0.1080828682,
0.8816710114,
-0.0936592668,
0.8133086562,
0.6051277518,
-0.3332350552,
0.7582352757,
0.0110729048,
0.0277677551,
-0.6183234453,
-0.2811551392,
-0.2348553389,
-0.3203698695,
-0.4703563452,
-0.4001867771,
0.388410151,
-0.3602146804,
-0.2420518994,
-0.0459256917,
-0.2171184421,
0.3721869886,
0.7249218225,
0.3599324822,
0.0511754788,
0.3353897035,
-0.1805834323,
-0.2277018577,
-0.5055744052,
-0.4986020923,
1.3884264231,
0.3286342621,
0.9914748073,
-0.2211233675,
0.4686355889,
-0.1027229056,
0.3270977139,
-0.8749403954,
0.4439157248,
0.193193689,
-0.577601254,
-0.2815173268,
-0.4499265552,
-0.6946265697,
0.4961228967,
-0.737975955,
-0.6185105443,
0.1172265857,
0.5216641426,
-0.1911940724,
0.2262389213,
-0.9558806419,
0.7676926255,
-0.4384786487,
-0.8397798538,
-0.1297391802,
-0.8205398321,
0.3492151499,
-0.1264800131,
0.259095788,
-0.0515111424,
0.1231982857,
0.480579704,
-0.2059729546,
0.8385432959,
-0.228965953,
-0.0856618881,
-0.2579012513,
-0.18843095,
0.3946655393,
0.0932595804,
-0.0042825616,
-0.0673005357,
-0.2301029116,
-0.5549909472,
-0.5653994083,
0.6146963835,
-0.8775777817,
-0.4423374832,
-0.2163608372,
-0.533813715,
-0.7045046687,
0.2515936494,
0.2316501737,
0.5399923325,
-0.1117714942,
0.403981775,
0.5212919712,
-0.2490173131,
0.442915976,
0.3312600255,
-0.4234719872,
-0.4501812458,
0.867724061,
-0.1135398597,
0.608660996,
0.4397740066,
0.083103478,
-0.2719546854,
-0.4807947874,
-0.513055563,
0.1215337589,
-0.5631325245,
-0.0779291838,
-0.6283872128,
0.1830901355,
-0.3794188797,
-0.1041056812,
-0.5555723906,
-0.1302781254,
-0.2069317698,
-0.1539845765,
0.0348132327,
0.1501018554,
0.1227727309,
0.2167409807,
-0.5349200368,
0.417478323,
0.273691386,
0.396997422,
0.1475571394,
-0.2734343112,
-0.2671083212,
0.076235041,
-0.3609317839,
-0.5592005849,
0.4795717001,
-0.0218407642,
0.2953826487,
0.7961098552,
-0.0333794281,
0.8238711357,
-0.8077373505,
0.4429425597,
0.673343122,
-0.6222079396,
0.6088805795,
-0.3748482764,
0.2664169371,
0.606934607,
0.5923543572,
-0.3166847527,
-0.0932783782,
-0.2377883643,
-0.847155273,
0.5980636477,
0.0358173847,
0.4110374153,
0.0347396284,
-0.0893255547,
0.1991639286,
0.5645287037,
-1.1337248087,
-0.3508671522,
-0.4078551233,
0.0483941324,
-0.3672514558,
-0.5307987332,
-0.3219219744,
-0.2537320554,
0.7267385125,
-0.3174260259,
0.0012569911,
-0.1142398193,
-0.1733145863,
-0.0813683495,
0.4057284892,
0.692024529,
0.6616428494,
-0.4443535507,
0.3036919832,
-0.2331170887,
-0.4371839464,
0.3141135573,
-0.1040302888,
-0.1535045803,
-0.0827351138,
0.1006455347,
1.0389994383,
0.0373330601,
-0.7885494828,
0.6108227968,
0.1249520704,
0.0627614558,
-0.1721605211,
-0.238015607,
-0.1081885695,
0.0428240038,
0.382350713,
0.4706920087,
-0.0101902317,
-0.6325932145,
0.0399197824,
0.7479449511,
-0.4278869033,
-0.1497839242,
0.4030968845,
0.3066562116,
0.008379194,
0.2193921953,
0.0799020976,
-0.5004891753,
0.2822178304,
0.6892146468,
0.5430669785,
-0.1382666379,
0.2650960982,
0.3142339885,
0.4364717901,
0.071783945,
-0.0450218134,
-0.095486939,
-1.0776789188,
-0.3492166102,
-0.6070984602,
-0.2072337866,
0.5418317318,
-0.6711934805,
0.5667141676,
-0.5282484889,
-0.3821744323,
-0.0946867988,
-0.5141730905,
-0.66241014,
0.4899635613,
0.26697281,
0.3275697231,
-0.7348223329,
0.7051312327,
0.7016683221,
-0.5374628901,
-0.4660260975,
-0.0247168671,
-0.0396294147,
-1.04769063,
0.8656511903,
0.2856023908,
-0.2265423387,
-0.1940983981,
-0.7797885537,
-0.6914227009,
0.6875696778,
0.6552115083,
-0.5242370963,
0.1077879667,
-0.0029113311,
0.2197705656,
-0.5360278487,
0.466078788,
0.1928616166,
0.3739711344,
0.100360617,
-0.8962655067,
-0.0441145785,
-0.2072110921,
0.0937653631,
0.1271100342,
-0.7618560195,
0.5488780141,
-0.2276656777,
0.1036610976,
-0.2998003662,
0.3499554992,
0.2561455071,
0.1260989755,
0.6181212068,
0.4397307634,
0.5801798105,
0.1137084141,
0.9193341136,
-0.2337169498,
0.2016178071,
1.1949886084,
-0.2492244691,
0.9635917544,
0.9846069813,
-0.0244492888,
0.2861815393,
0.67905128,
0.079291448,
0.7038043737,
0.109553054,
-0.2444069982,
-0.5602617264,
-0.1285755336,
-0.4524763525,
0.4903605878,
0.0090622967,
-0.6546859741,
-0.0603251681,
0.127729401,
0.0678851306,
-0.0031596599,
-0.2391430289,
0.6117714643,
-0.1415766925,
-0.5110743642,
0.7969571352,
-0.0518022403,
0.9292989373,
-0.7637409568,
0.1315835267,
-0.0113320043,
0.0380327553,
-0.2164022774,
-0.2395079732,
-0.1889189184,
-0.1251875609,
-0.5435535312,
-0.3427756131,
0.6503919959,
-0.6228121519,
-0.5144375563,
0.2709606886,
0.407245785,
-0.0861139297,
-0.1070485711,
-0.4752046466,
0.2388838083,
0.0290559437,
-0.2803935111,
0.5859624147,
0.1443473697,
0.1141956821,
0.7973290086,
0.8616304398,
0.1385857612,
-0.0488600507,
0.3031827807,
1.1316618919,
-0.3031269014,
-0.4329191744,
-1.1086859703,
0.5681792498,
-0.2474730015,
-0.2042363137,
0.6446353793,
0.7076247334,
0.9202926755,
-0.5033112168,
0.8628053069,
0.2938247919,
0.1567137986,
-0.8032748699,
0.7821179032,
-0.6770647168,
0.093804799,
-0.5177536011,
-1.1769099236,
-0.2189433724,
0.6707907915,
-0.5213356614,
0.1761008352,
0.690222621,
0.9317176342,
-0.1874964386,
-0.3427342176,
0.6260573268,
0.0541764498,
0.1802858561,
0.4908309877,
0.8023382425,
-0.0640591383,
0.3324088752,
-0.0618187375,
-0.4287834466,
-0.1815741807,
-0.9595550299,
-1.1901385784,
-0.5828358531,
0.0005193049,
-0.4686481357,
-0.0041017211,
1.5033665895,
1.1466014385,
-0.7928411365,
-0.3080998063,
0.2574604154,
-0.2406980395,
0.3792219162,
-0.2133224458,
0.0623798296,
-0.6874485016,
-0.7046195269,
0.2018110752,
0.399341464,
0.1139690876,
-0.3839867413,
-0.1083955392,
-0.1504075974,
-0.1068940684,
1.0282082558,
-0.0068805697,
-0.7273859978,
-0.2955351174,
-0.0841895863,
0.0548222065,
0.4188624024,
0.8058665395,
-0.7126797438,
0.7187811136,
0.065601863,
0.8069603443,
0.6808109879,
0.0408348888,
0.75756675,
-0.8038095236,
0.5904223919,
0.1787077785,
0.4116660655,
0.5918083787,
-0.1780322343,
0.131659776,
0.2541156709,
-0.3056350052,
-0.7229987383,
0.3513640165,
-1.0179978609,
-0.1696876585,
1.3317637444,
0.1685310006,
-0.1435299516,
0.0690016076,
-0.491523087,
-0.1765920669,
-0.7402616143,
0.883910954,
0.8608237505,
0.014166004,
-0.2937656641,
-0.3913909793,
0.4899836481,
0.6577332616,
-0.7030359507,
-0.0087758722,
0.8802501559,
0.1900495589,
0.2167931944,
0.7132023573,
-0.0453906357,
0.0924701467,
-0.3477864265,
0.295954138,
-0.1334168315,
-0.4774944782,
-0.1608366966,
0.2772703469,
0.2133593857,
-0.292217195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08715v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08715v3
|
SOTOPIA-$π$: Interactive Learning of Socially Intelligent Language Agents
| 2024-03-13T17:17:48 | 2024-04-25T20:23:41 |
Ruiyi Wang, Haofei Yu, Wenxin Zhang, Zhengyang Qi, Maarten Sap, Graham Neubig, Yonatan Bisk, Hao Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans learn social skills through both imitation and social interaction.
This social learning process is largely understudied by existing research on
building language agents. Motivated by this gap, we propose an interactive
learning method, SOTOPIA-$\pi$, improving the social intelligence of language
agents. This method leverages behavior cloning and self-reinforcement training
on filtered social interaction data according to large language model (LLM)
ratings. We show that our training method allows a 7B LLM to reach the social
goal completion ability of an expert model (GPT-4-based agent), while improving
the safety of language agents and maintaining general QA ability on the MMLU
benchmark. We also find that this training paradigm uncovers some difficulties
in LLM-based evaluation of social intelligence: LLM-based evaluators
overestimate the abilities of the language agents trained specifically for
social interaction.
|
[
-0.2300093621,
-1.0275593996,
0.7281752825,
0.247596994,
-0.1275873929,
0.6823556423,
-0.4423781037,
-0.4013076425,
0.7442145348,
0.2736096978,
-0.3542618454,
-0.2792423964,
-0.5062889457,
-0.0955753326,
0.0522372611,
0.8472934961,
0.3710834682,
0.2569925785,
-0.0060598706,
0.2239174545,
0.1712669581,
-0.4366356432,
-1.0584626198,
-0.2283776402,
0.620570302,
0.5410967469,
0.7007318139,
0.3457852006,
0.2529684603,
0.4885086417,
0.0056504975,
0.5104994178,
-0.7742982507,
-0.0071841297,
-0.4946092963,
-0.5906223059,
-0.5544689298,
0.3158087432,
0.678776443,
0.5846121311,
-0.2271404862,
-0.1274432391,
-0.1340817213,
0.6198515296,
-0.3588617742,
0.4589041471,
-0.653046906,
-0.1294872463,
-0.03813513,
-0.2246091366,
-0.5394612551,
-0.5784075856,
-0.1998521388,
-0.7001356483,
-0.0050339829,
-0.0654313266,
0.5410359502,
0.0176161248,
-0.1973261088,
-0.3923136294,
-0.7037288547,
0.5572068095,
-0.4459446967,
0.0421750322,
0.4690032005,
0.3766184449,
-0.4744523466,
-0.4396135807,
-0.7850229144,
-0.5312535763,
0.2789007723,
0.1465904415,
0.2150652111,
0.2161256224,
0.2623526156,
-0.0263643898,
-0.0020794568,
-0.1354074925,
-0.7600461245,
0.061510656,
0.9970729351,
-0.0099171074,
0.516233325,
-0.3325251639,
-0.2325392514,
-0.3134385645,
-0.4411060512,
0.1069611832,
0.7340932488,
0.1846528649,
0.102181606,
0.329542011,
-0.489775151,
0.1614993066,
0.2727800012,
-0.2898849249,
0.4942858219,
0.0193395484,
0.1461795866,
-0.154135704,
0.7997992635,
0.1977274716,
0.6652848125,
-0.2379300296,
-0.0426603481,
-0.1327263862,
0.4204008281,
-0.389876008,
-0.1417494863,
-0.1133470461,
-0.2195632309,
-0.6812756658,
0.2924568057,
-0.8078420758,
-0.4318581522,
-0.280336529,
0.4617726207,
-0.6251096129,
-0.6142761707,
-0.0945426896,
-0.1403936148,
0.5083687901,
0.5140038133,
-1.1261690855,
0.4851677716,
0.8061231971,
0.5821430683,
-0.2459045798,
-0.7861136198,
-0.8287918568,
0.2950149179,
-0.3151874542,
0.820723176,
-0.7386052012,
-0.6016560197,
-0.0812909976,
0.1498542726,
-0.2248713225,
-0.1361896396,
-0.0418157578,
-0.4430685639,
-0.0632041395,
-0.3248355687,
-0.5462993979,
-0.2374667525,
0.1660685092,
-0.3043009639,
0.8451265097,
0.1183163524,
-0.3261049092,
0.1405892819,
-0.5514276624,
-0.3474293053,
0.3686340749,
-0.2471902221,
-0.2120571882,
0.0324473828,
0.0083644381,
0.6157875657,
0.2176975459,
0.3154785633,
-0.8618968725,
-0.5556564927,
0.4056057334,
-0.2695552111,
0.8528353572,
0.03251433,
-0.3229719996,
0.4095014632,
-0.8238226175,
0.0853168815,
0.2346203327,
-0.2031702697,
-0.3455049396,
-0.1056555733,
-0.3861049414,
0.0830953196,
0.1562654376,
-0.6347180009,
0.3937256932,
-0.1844951361,
0.3657285273,
1.0264465809,
0.2287665159,
0.5215060115,
-0.5111418366,
0.5552041531,
-0.7222731709,
0.4542867541,
0.4530718625,
-0.512434423,
-0.7291697264,
-0.4927687943,
-0.0551034361,
0.3742836714,
-1.0577732325,
0.3237006962,
-0.3397589028,
-0.8406006694,
-0.421369046,
0.3896706998,
0.3841850162,
-0.1568116397,
0.2162068486,
-0.2565836906,
-0.2793252766,
-0.3237867355,
-0.1088920534,
-0.4234764874,
0.1203400418,
0.1850656271,
0.4789299667,
-0.2626099885,
0.5434656143,
-0.0942156911,
-0.1433371753,
-0.6094481945,
0.0301913563,
-0.1383120865,
0.3343679309,
0.3801850677,
-0.4481784403,
-0.7854973674,
-0.0199769661,
-0.7208738923,
0.0383401923,
0.019736696,
-0.1917417645,
0.0108270207,
0.7821359634,
-0.5797241926,
0.3274172246,
0.2092720121,
-0.1149077788,
0.2904057503,
-0.4520534873,
0.3535562456,
-0.8440496325,
-0.2909028828,
-0.3368721902,
-0.3246904612,
-0.7247021794,
0.0766511708,
0.1275244653,
-0.0777080357,
-0.670329392,
0.798663795,
-0.5282465816,
-0.0552703589,
-0.4028950036,
0.3485871553,
-0.3817849457,
0.9811735749,
0.0736232251,
0.5248081088,
0.407348901,
-0.4999154508,
0.6468245387,
0.0089820158,
-0.1344142556,
0.690811336,
-0.7085404992,
0.4347663522,
-0.1427922398,
-0.0515150651,
-0.907437861,
-0.4819992781,
0.4122255147,
-0.5717330575,
0.2384295464,
-0.0825243965,
-0.3170429468,
-0.0299767777,
-0.6509231925,
-0.0309175607,
0.6825313568,
-0.5523375869,
0.727609396,
0.5889866352,
-0.1935424954,
-0.1740777045,
-0.1488048881,
-0.294655472,
-0.1770852655,
-0.5628777146,
0.0697462484,
0.1014777571,
-0.2624709904,
-0.1354530752,
0.3249309063,
0.3351320922,
0.165982455,
0.3074592054,
0.1287544221,
0.2618467212,
0.1693746001,
0.1575229317,
-0.1301984638,
0.1909820735,
0.408891499,
0.60161376,
-0.4497374594,
-0.6349360943,
-0.2992038429,
-0.0989515483,
0.4257403612,
-0.1691552699,
0.6615412831,
0.5358676314,
-0.1413470507,
-0.1496522725,
-0.5299289823,
-0.0448439233,
-0.5117388368,
0.3075503409,
-0.422885716,
-0.4873119295,
0.2468190491,
-0.144060418,
-0.0917934924,
0.0949157104,
0.3385122418,
-0.231101647,
0.808870852,
0.4443029165,
0.0717337877,
0.9479730129,
-0.2228782177,
-0.0310137104,
-0.9443466663,
-0.4256389439,
-0.1564329118,
0.023848433,
-0.4999975264,
-0.5378489494,
0.2111846656,
-0.0948437229,
-0.0451906957,
0.1680225432,
-0.1137903929,
0.4939427972,
0.6362401843,
0.6392871141,
0.3260832131,
0.0941044986,
0.2439820617,
0.2517462075,
-0.3954466879,
-0.5217428207,
1.2005310059,
0.3583861887,
0.9991646409,
0.2869227529,
1.0201272964,
0.4438469708,
0.4471002519,
-0.6082246304,
0.8606387973,
0.2289220393,
-0.2793163061,
-0.8148101568,
-0.3417700529,
-0.8358025551,
0.2926279008,
-0.3101384044,
-0.7660858631,
0.0356909633,
-0.0147909494,
-0.1357224584,
0.0979199484,
-0.7827085257,
0.5131499767,
-0.371293962,
-0.5875627398,
-0.7349768877,
-0.4706299901,
0.1110970452,
0.2008157223,
0.2807201445,
-0.4211037755,
-0.0167670511,
0.4626053274,
-0.4039712846,
1.0727792978,
-0.4256744385,
0.2838805914,
0.170641914,
0.0335474722,
0.7280396819,
0.1246513203,
-0.1418140084,
-0.1555232555,
-0.0755184367,
-0.6457497478,
-0.8985445499,
0.5479029417,
-0.9254505038,
-0.872594893,
-0.5301283002,
-0.0975629315,
-0.3090703487,
-0.0307861045,
-0.1483519077,
0.0315556303,
-0.3893040121,
0.3227832913,
0.7027419806,
-0.040836595,
0.2628899515,
0.6272714138,
-0.4622007906,
-0.6386826038,
1.102014184,
0.1029016897,
0.6182411909,
0.1272628158,
0.1325035244,
-0.079102844,
-0.2119357139,
-0.2120153308,
0.5474743247,
-0.6807253361,
0.2282344997,
-0.7160339952,
-0.3791490793,
-0.317756772,
-0.2470468134,
-0.377746582,
-0.1787849218,
0.0051365788,
-0.2995461822,
0.412748754,
0.8637244701,
-0.3536942899,
0.362432003,
-0.305905968,
0.2389500886,
0.6549993753,
0.2411650121,
0.1786379218,
-0.4138197899,
0.0143714482,
0.121921137,
-0.0300555862,
-0.9674468637,
0.0864365771,
0.2204445302,
0.9509822726,
0.4117954671,
-0.0481898859,
0.4694025815,
-0.278090626,
0.3020504713,
-0.0095203072,
-0.9045974016,
0.6463519335,
-0.360085547,
-0.0098971575,
0.6484501362,
0.4973711371,
-0.4424574077,
-0.6266747117,
-0.900331974,
-0.3708070815,
0.6087223887,
0.1009313762,
0.3293714523,
-0.270588249,
0.358520329,
0.0380394422,
0.1539109796,
-0.8450349569,
0.2383953482,
-0.1013398096,
-0.2195687294,
0.0297220107,
-0.2337858379,
0.2188604176,
-0.3944197893,
0.9714949727,
-0.2071383297,
0.0369843654,
0.0900232717,
-0.3037062287,
-0.023162948,
-0.0164665096,
0.2876233459,
0.6677577496,
-0.148143515,
-0.0071344995,
0.3425872624,
-0.4108072519,
0.1947099268,
-0.1508722454,
-0.045093812,
-0.4088509679,
0.3061095476,
0.7090867162,
0.3527452946,
-0.6955595613,
0.5993019938,
-0.2001461089,
-0.0231383853,
-0.6010340452,
0.7473117709,
0.0348506868,
0.3751158416,
0.2061606348,
-0.2405834347,
0.0865758285,
-1.0037505627,
0.0550965555,
0.4967959523,
-0.4177903533,
-0.3016907871,
0.3167677522,
0.5599139929,
-0.7437583804,
0.5150470734,
-0.5506084561,
-0.5763284564,
0.5273599625,
0.2262442261,
0.6291499138,
-0.4872123003,
0.6468070149,
0.1666218191,
0.2970682681,
-0.0057758056,
0.4610423744,
-0.3675079346,
-0.6799203753,
-0.118195273,
-0.4566563964,
-0.8485231996,
-0.1109232679,
-0.4727222621,
0.4197704494,
-0.6484875679,
0.0628526583,
-0.0797417536,
0.1641326249,
-0.5168238878,
-0.177266553,
-0.1725801677,
0.4698211253,
-0.8463416696,
1.2561389208,
0.6085564494,
-0.6207217574,
-0.7590258121,
-0.1495252252,
-0.2234027237,
-0.9312538505,
0.3457216322,
0.1452544481,
-0.3783232868,
0.1461651623,
-0.5708014965,
-0.8204135299,
0.8681415319,
0.2277752608,
-0.2643584311,
-0.051611688,
-0.0387444384,
0.8014276624,
-0.2644258738,
0.4444200397,
0.4075064957,
0.1821719855,
-0.0393865034,
-0.558784008,
0.0603629015,
-0.532192111,
0.2018618733,
-0.1757698208,
-1.1055091619,
0.3836048841,
-0.4490616918,
0.0253923628,
0.1194210276,
0.8605054021,
0.4631171823,
0.1527205408,
0.646628201,
-0.1087109894,
0.9557189345,
0.0162104573,
0.8817798495,
-0.0967364684,
0.2797290981,
1.0544427633,
-0.2559072971,
0.8825013638,
0.4444652498,
-0.2396253943,
0.5198669434,
0.6463920474,
-0.0080204681,
0.4974792898,
0.2403992563,
-0.2324659377,
-0.3443050086,
0.2129226029,
-0.1571881175,
0.3308762014,
0.4660127759,
-0.0385984033,
0.2917463183,
0.2932657897,
0.014315363,
0.3142894208,
-0.1640159488,
0.9518195987,
-0.1053594127,
-0.6457303166,
0.0593740828,
-0.2899243236,
0.5084313154,
-0.5649484992,
-0.2030423433,
-0.3347688913,
0.1558104903,
-0.0405946486,
-0.6612078547,
0.0829154626,
-0.2370198816,
0.2782339156,
-0.0639498383,
0.7037298679,
-0.4813374281,
-0.3670217991,
0.5479331017,
0.3871332407,
0.6093831658,
0.0329440087,
-0.4833420515,
-0.0010239115,
-0.0036867966,
-0.3005831242,
0.3141497374,
0.6103938818,
-0.0090953056,
0.890750587,
0.6520313025,
0.1497177184,
0.1688432992,
0.1717914194,
0.7160075903,
-0.6558074355,
-0.4095828235,
-0.6988582611,
0.2689328194,
-0.6162004471,
-0.0463138409,
0.5568217039,
0.1085664183,
0.9681382775,
-0.1710966825,
0.6971591115,
-0.1898853183,
0.5330797434,
-0.5414611697,
0.6397103071,
-0.3147047162,
0.2592579126,
-0.3558870256,
-0.8711946011,
0.3572070897,
0.7822759748,
-0.4892938137,
0.2925416529,
0.5768693089,
0.7096477747,
-0.0433801934,
-0.0306760091,
0.6504011154,
0.0633894727,
0.3765508533,
0.3480516374,
1.0387380123,
-0.0840506479,
0.4976090789,
-0.559781611,
-0.6267254353,
-0.3523538113,
-0.4544209838,
-1.4146324396,
-0.5418685079,
-0.1166430414,
-0.2898520231,
0.4679659307,
1.2587110996,
0.6430105567,
-0.4775315225,
-0.2738730311,
0.0669844672,
0.3776526749,
-0.2506006658,
-0.249030292,
0.1920434386,
-0.6232281327,
-1.0311496258,
0.455547899,
0.2990989387,
0.0015168575,
-0.5605005026,
-0.3318965435,
-0.2657250464,
0.1712861359,
0.5384389758,
0.4128139913,
-0.6199537516,
-0.4354118705,
-0.0240818858,
-0.2619199753,
-0.0837918669,
0.1949026883,
-0.5236952901,
0.5388399959,
0.4546424448,
0.56725806,
0.6719305515,
-0.0126484809,
0.6064943671,
-0.2719585896,
0.1893926412,
-0.2120448351,
0.2786200643,
0.2323313951,
-0.557714045,
0.7414544821,
0.255179137,
-0.4065898657,
-0.4796923101,
0.1071511507,
-0.897857368,
-0.0685359538,
1.3951700926,
-0.2692759633,
-0.5494017005,
-0.1167434901,
-0.5050807595,
0.2823610902,
-0.6040207744,
1.1184365749,
0.6301403642,
-0.230681181,
-0.1768487543,
-0.307600826,
0.5361315012,
0.1986520588,
-1.1177846193,
-0.291454792,
0.0789409503,
0.4115974009,
0.1763671488,
0.9948852062,
-0.0109383529,
0.6573167443,
0.006205318,
0.3147443533,
-0.1055758893,
-0.505993247,
-0.1478228867,
-0.0065905903,
0.2523627877,
-0.0826820582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08694v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08694v2
|
TeaMs-RL: Teaching LLMs to Teach Themselves Better Instructions via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-03-13T16:57:57 | 2024-05-03T22:44:24 |
Shangding Gu, Alois Knoll, Ming Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) often confronts challenges
stemming from the heavy reliance on human annotators in the reinforcement
learning with human feedback (RLHF) framework, or the frequent and costly
external queries tied to the self-instruct paradigm. In this work, we pivot to
Reinforcement Learning (RL) -- but with a twist. Diverging from the typical
RLHF, which refines LLMs following instruction data training, we use RL to
directly generate the foundational instruction dataset that alone suffices for
fine-tuning. Our method, TeaMs-RL, uses a suite of textual operations and
rules, prioritizing the diversification of training datasets. It facilitates
the generation of high-quality data without excessive reliance on external
advanced models, paving the way for a single fine-tuning step and negating the
need for subsequent RLHF stages. Our findings highlight key advantages of our
approach: reduced need for human involvement and fewer model queries (only
$5.73\%$ of WizardLM's total), along with enhanced capabilities of LLMs in
crafting and comprehending complex instructions compared to strong baselines,
and substantially improved model privacy protection.
|
[
-0.2904744446,
-0.5582225323,
0.1265057623,
0.1811018139,
-0.0330792814,
0.422195375,
-0.31808725,
-0.1561919451,
-0.2235798836,
0.9206555486,
-0.8874773383,
-0.5615182519,
-0.3387109935,
0.0123149604,
-0.2523893714,
1.3490957022,
-0.0001152788,
0.0309017617,
-0.0587450154,
-0.1140624061,
-0.3642147481,
-0.4641316533,
-0.853256762,
-0.6289413571,
0.8391128182,
0.7784923911,
0.5902169347,
0.751840055,
0.1949030459,
0.2641695738,
0.2605141699,
0.6628602743,
-0.7573023438,
0.4115658402,
-0.1177974939,
-0.4061845839,
-0.2007738501,
-0.0015877238,
0.3587771058,
0.6983827353,
-0.4947048128,
0.2016331851,
0.0182760134,
1.0482641459,
-0.3999819458,
0.339309454,
-0.3685945272,
0.2880504727,
0.2333421409,
-0.3544282913,
-0.8444202542,
-0.363381356,
0.1677732319,
-0.6860641241,
0.2540954947,
0.3429100811,
0.6132441163,
0.4416262209,
-0.266843915,
-0.2224498838,
-0.7161160111,
0.8423947096,
-0.4859170914,
0.2621694803,
0.3140454292,
0.3368370831,
-0.3997425437,
-0.4371822178,
-0.0626364127,
-0.4255318046,
0.0589611977,
0.0810109675,
0.3707211018,
0.131201148,
0.2162226737,
0.1732311249,
-0.3708781302,
0.3890629709,
-0.5192539096,
-0.0408067107,
0.9500123262,
0.360455066,
0.2396692038,
0.2862965465,
-0.42188555,
-0.3412181735,
-1.0116357803,
-0.0777108297,
0.2409418225,
0.5514971614,
0.0601491891,
0.3406264782,
-0.2620272934,
0.551890254,
0.326166302,
-0.1361773163,
0.0164937191,
-0.0127594164,
-0.1401189864,
0.1100128815,
0.697139442,
0.2551966608,
0.4192016721,
-0.5021752119,
-0.5124595165,
-0.1674923003,
0.3146582544,
-0.7711905837,
-0.500385046,
-0.0211494882,
-0.2433790416,
-0.3643081486,
-0.0391813256,
-0.4416584373,
-0.518317163,
-0.4908604324,
0.338100642,
-0.3022734523,
-0.1842388362,
0.1160785109,
0.0715494007,
0.2518228292,
0.5156074762,
-1.0996618271,
0.5348382592,
0.7236292362,
0.4016612768,
-0.4144397378,
-0.4488533735,
-0.9240909815,
0.2092058957,
-0.6556606293,
0.7767218351,
-0.2906347811,
-0.6338154078,
-0.0221742205,
-0.2295577675,
0.1292820573,
-0.715298593,
-0.0047125625,
-0.5815607905,
0.4496146441,
-0.1897648275,
-0.6863711476,
0.0146115627,
0.1868824661,
-0.6322821975,
1.0382508039,
0.0347151496,
-0.2729019523,
0.4644266963,
-0.7265256643,
-0.6509645581,
0.1320800185,
-0.3066827357,
-0.44068712,
-0.1444723755,
0.2696501017,
0.5775119662,
-0.1322330087,
0.2393249869,
-0.099893719,
-0.2356899828,
0.158501938,
-0.2629264891,
0.3768397272,
0.0189206544,
-0.2759198546,
0.5295534134,
-0.5154678226,
0.0840069726,
0.0438369177,
-0.6582672596,
-0.1339184642,
0.1222204491,
-0.1491898447,
0.2642959952,
-0.0163578652,
-0.094666861,
0.3423242271,
-0.4467614889,
0.2401532978,
0.8786036372,
-0.0025949008,
0.6509585381,
-0.4115200341,
0.6224503517,
-0.2228319049,
0.3065517545,
-0.0590584874,
-0.2971042693,
-0.7700772285,
-0.064139016,
0.0929749906,
0.3840504885,
-0.9374824762,
0.0970667303,
-0.0961356461,
-0.3477119505,
-0.5403108001,
0.3719086051,
0.8057254553,
0.4414199889,
0.4671750665,
-0.1706165373,
-0.3818526864,
-0.7504277229,
-0.0993786231,
-0.0841500238,
0.1400537938,
0.2092363685,
0.3311480582,
0.040402323,
0.8036321998,
-0.3132764101,
-0.0656330585,
-0.5776768923,
0.2980392277,
-0.0768463016,
0.3594973087,
-0.0826127902,
-0.6620851159,
-0.6582040787,
-0.0816703737,
-0.5909993052,
-0.0875962749,
-0.1059562117,
-0.1351861805,
0.5460627079,
0.6319454908,
-0.264768213,
0.2045910507,
0.384783715,
-0.342320472,
0.4786369205,
-0.4344733655,
-0.0470917895,
-0.6941965818,
-0.3966579437,
-0.204881534,
-0.4412953258,
-0.4917444885,
0.0699434131,
-0.0112986416,
0.0289820135,
-0.4284089208,
0.5453957319,
-0.6153461933,
-0.1992212534,
-0.3339265585,
0.0761186182,
-0.0401874781,
0.7937556505,
0.1246746108,
0.9598152041,
0.0667439774,
-0.8330054283,
0.3743348718,
0.0879548714,
-0.1245101392,
0.273648262,
-0.4591582417,
0.1711719036,
-0.0388218276,
0.3791581988,
-0.5095801353,
-0.1347203851,
0.4305960238,
-0.2217413634,
0.487755537,
-0.2279019207,
-0.5217061639,
-0.0776786357,
-0.1748113781,
-0.0556156486,
0.5680252314,
-0.7678089738,
0.4304978251,
0.4384078085,
0.214998886,
-0.5981632471,
-0.5226833224,
-0.016240729,
-0.166328907,
-0.3309978247,
0.2157378346,
-0.076029405,
-0.1592133641,
0.1217813119,
-0.1913339049,
-0.1650324166,
0.2958956063,
0.3576132953,
0.2324806005,
-0.1024080366,
0.4361236989,
-0.1392252743,
-0.3064842224,
-0.0104399435,
-0.2784246504,
0.4687749743,
-0.1082786173,
-0.3426509202,
-0.3187659085,
0.2280861586,
0.3164532781,
-0.3329133093,
0.7833893895,
0.3602278531,
-0.0128007531,
-0.8601669073,
-0.3075911105,
-0.401319921,
-0.4687854946,
0.461391449,
-0.056096483,
-0.9495710135,
0.169074446,
-0.0794258714,
0.5249313712,
0.197591275,
0.4146247208,
-0.2189245224,
0.9613205194,
0.5216260552,
-0.1133493111,
0.5872324109,
-0.1859916598,
-0.1358726621,
-0.6735671759,
-0.3685438931,
-0.0248704851,
-0.1311262548,
-0.3676949441,
-0.5478374958,
0.2372397929,
-0.0048129982,
-0.5653166771,
0.1696880013,
-0.5295934081,
0.7166097164,
0.6273614764,
0.3334204257,
0.2874269783,
-0.0541849509,
0.0862094685,
0.1305122674,
-0.9137266278,
-0.4726207852,
1.2698596716,
0.3292571008,
1.0003507137,
0.0342184827,
1.1645535231,
0.3748027086,
0.5392682552,
-0.6323262453,
0.5990580916,
-0.0866394043,
-0.3663378954,
-0.6161844134,
-0.5789836645,
-1.0181022882,
0.3058203757,
-0.2778320312,
-0.2229796648,
-0.3708327413,
0.372941345,
-0.6104919314,
0.1692961156,
-0.8769862056,
0.7945063114,
-0.4102806747,
-0.5592357516,
-0.46692276,
-0.4694913626,
0.4829991162,
0.2374334037,
0.2186701149,
-0.0804661736,
-0.1410111785,
0.6584157944,
-0.513266027,
0.9944892526,
-0.1681594849,
-0.2859640718,
0.1711478233,
0.0534219295,
0.567157805,
0.0313571617,
0.0896458849,
-0.5890877843,
-0.2671534121,
-0.318693161,
-0.7389563322,
0.5092075467,
-0.7421579957,
-0.6193681359,
-0.2529909909,
-0.6652212739,
-0.332043767,
-0.0883893967,
-0.1062928289,
0.5755146146,
0.0205525514,
0.0240696538,
1.1354957819,
-0.4220273197,
0.2985374928,
0.6275652647,
-0.5739373565,
-0.3087517917,
1.1051242352,
0.064365454,
0.5881988406,
0.5274482369,
0.1884579211,
-0.1902921051,
-0.5103464127,
-0.4416208267,
0.1014068276,
-0.7250549197,
-0.0922012404,
-0.30187729,
-0.1536586583,
-0.1814382076,
0.0225773044,
-0.6232249737,
-0.3445186317,
-0.2851586938,
-0.0997098163,
0.3929337561,
0.9238752127,
0.0454892963,
0.1598699689,
-0.7048925757,
0.2460781038,
0.474190563,
0.3896279931,
0.0165698044,
-0.4627921283,
-0.5092824101,
-0.1366325468,
-0.1530667394,
-0.6670017838,
0.4475637674,
0.1290807724,
0.583181262,
-0.0029978731,
0.2036750764,
0.6351424456,
-0.6563776731,
0.4594523311,
0.0811685026,
-0.6036853194,
0.4459263086,
-0.2747447491,
0.1264920831,
0.5867530107,
0.0144934431,
-0.6540247202,
-0.3668076694,
-0.5784832239,
-0.9817346931,
0.9024003744,
-0.2880659401,
-0.081926465,
0.0925202072,
0.3485594392,
0.1289313585,
0.2133398801,
-0.5664232373,
-0.3294809163,
-0.0160681624,
-0.251719445,
0.0478322357,
0.0077857953,
-0.2075309902,
-0.1640038341,
0.8558117151,
-0.14230223,
0.0084266635,
0.0444751643,
-0.3097739816,
-0.1263976991,
0.115128912,
0.6882296801,
0.4932525754,
0.049254816,
-0.032627102,
0.2572701573,
-0.0241802204,
0.032011725,
-0.255533129,
0.0294958949,
-0.4029441774,
0.5338312984,
0.9636412859,
0.5969270468,
-0.8115672469,
0.2557329834,
-0.0942975357,
-0.3023401797,
-0.2251286507,
0.5387195945,
0.181763798,
0.3916286528,
0.2345781326,
-0.1561786085,
-0.0114886416,
-0.383670181,
0.4618304074,
0.1948713809,
-0.2962328494,
-0.0931332186,
0.2268053442,
0.4089129269,
-0.4828395545,
0.5528874397,
-0.3659739494,
-0.5859408975,
0.6393377781,
0.3474426866,
0.7257468104,
-0.1391724348,
0.5338768959,
0.2178944051,
0.2106806934,
-0.4867392778,
0.0279736929,
-0.1185843796,
-0.4876907766,
-0.6445659995,
-0.2878257036,
-0.8627582788,
0.0257098358,
-0.6828819513,
0.076846458,
-0.8087569475,
0.3341948986,
-0.43979761,
0.1289654225,
-0.4543793499,
0.1295524389,
0.3171025217,
0.6504691243,
-0.5921910405,
0.9859238267,
0.4644844234,
-0.5799514651,
-1.1386879683,
-0.1086560786,
-0.1380730867,
-0.9186297655,
0.9657498002,
0.1106166169,
-0.2053682208,
0.0523305312,
-0.6668671966,
-0.5686717033,
1.0453718901,
0.1837431937,
-0.6790112257,
-0.1535417289,
-0.0526917093,
0.5388123989,
-0.4280545413,
0.1218890622,
0.2770460546,
0.225143671,
0.0885043815,
-0.6823220253,
-0.0327625163,
0.0962168574,
-0.1664058268,
0.2372189611,
-0.6834538579,
0.7738801837,
-0.3018090427,
-0.3215342164,
-0.2990348041,
0.8785241842,
0.3163352013,
0.0320039392,
0.4933140576,
0.3856747746,
0.8975715637,
0.1486990899,
1.0196558237,
-0.0806295872,
0.2415546775,
1.5397306681,
-0.2003846616,
0.8682926893,
0.4123460948,
-0.1500718296,
0.4186812937,
0.6257734895,
0.0605461709,
0.5361388922,
0.5852539539,
-0.1946849823,
-0.5906216502,
0.1341878772,
-0.0902263895,
0.0574610643,
0.3969640434,
-0.1007152125,
-0.3857084215,
-0.0979836136,
-0.1202575266,
0.4307397902,
-0.4133011699,
0.8863502741,
0.0975686833,
-0.8365889788,
0.4877104163,
-0.1945962459,
0.7282484174,
-0.3930073977,
-0.1246827915,
-0.3036774397,
0.2680681348,
-0.2033190876,
-0.7292994857,
0.1332383603,
0.0138843944,
-0.1994919628,
-0.5847647786,
0.4578135014,
-0.7532405853,
-0.2044866383,
0.3331720233,
0.298283428,
0.0374420434,
0.228684634,
-0.8252307177,
-0.1391165555,
-0.0216015279,
-0.368078649,
0.465790689,
0.3812775016,
-0.1064017788,
1.0707691908,
0.5302804112,
0.0673216954,
0.270814538,
0.1999325901,
0.7446710467,
-0.644925952,
-0.2243948579,
-0.7516771555,
0.4371100068,
-0.1565503329,
-0.3290484846,
0.6101301312,
0.3713605702,
0.9213985205,
0.0096783442,
0.8722572327,
0.3278728724,
0.6467607021,
-0.6561874151,
0.6444486976,
-0.2931869626,
0.3629914522,
0.1410187483,
-0.3964983523,
-0.3688025177,
0.5736752748,
-0.4472850263,
0.0548420884,
0.5115616918,
0.7371594906,
0.1701111197,
0.0111091482,
0.2954648733,
-0.0970841572,
0.5727861524,
0.6438938975,
0.9972833991,
-0.1904530674,
0.6682665944,
-0.2501938045,
-0.0473804325,
-0.2807338834,
-0.7276890874,
-1.2680094242,
-0.2769849598,
-0.4607645273,
-0.2294394523,
0.3503049314,
1.4550340176,
0.7055020332,
-0.7211643457,
-0.4601408243,
-0.2772933245,
0.4395876825,
-0.2858179212,
-0.1444327086,
0.238595441,
-0.9008570313,
-0.484511137,
0.6087437868,
0.177808255,
-0.1625451148,
-0.5119249225,
-0.6588821411,
-0.1364208311,
-0.1595442146,
0.4876445532,
0.4928545952,
-0.7502554059,
-0.2188011408,
-0.0331274346,
-0.4215652347,
0.0020513316,
0.6032089591,
-0.759804368,
0.2209425569,
0.2065320164,
0.9297371507,
0.4428754151,
-0.223600015,
0.8308867812,
-0.582185626,
-0.265447408,
0.1902419031,
-0.0332020819,
0.3805931211,
-0.1733962446,
0.5146434307,
-0.0079361098,
-0.6585257053,
-0.8797624111,
0.2728295028,
-0.5130730271,
-0.2711745203,
1.2267873287,
-0.1248507053,
-0.3485001624,
-0.1427893788,
-0.3482066989,
0.3270633817,
-0.6530328393,
0.8730733991,
0.5027651191,
-0.2315421402,
-0.3446075618,
-0.5124643445,
0.6790980697,
0.3970710635,
-0.8872823119,
0.301502645,
0.4738892317,
0.3392136693,
-0.2366267443,
0.5274725556,
0.1824298352,
0.2274602652,
-0.2405919731,
0.225601241,
-0.3775521219,
-0.5784679055,
-0.1669333577,
0.1239134148,
0.2664895356,
-0.3337876201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08693v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08693v1
|
Do Language Models Care About Text Quality? Evaluating Web-Crawled Corpora Across 11 Languages
| 2024-03-13T16:56:33 | 2024-03-13T16:56:33 |
Rik van Noord, Taja Kuzman, Peter Rupnik, Nikola Ljubešić, Miquel Esplà-Gomis, Gema Ramírez-Sánchez, Antonio Toral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large, curated, web-crawled corpora play a vital role in training language
models (LMs). They form the lion's share of the training data in virtually all
recent LMs, such as the well-known GPT, LLaMA and XLM-RoBERTa models. However,
despite this importance, relatively little attention has been given to the
quality of these corpora. In this paper, we compare four of the currently most
relevant large, web-crawled corpora (CC100, MaCoCu, mC4 and OSCAR) across
eleven lower-resourced European languages. Our approach is two-fold: first, we
perform an intrinsic evaluation by performing a human evaluation of the quality
of samples taken from different corpora; then, we assess the practical impact
of the qualitative differences by training specific LMs on each of the corpora
and evaluating their performance on downstream tasks. We find that there are
clear differences in quality of the corpora, with MaCoCu and OSCAR obtaining
the best results. However, during the extrinsic evaluation, we actually find
that the CC100 corpus achieves the highest scores. We conclude that, in our
experiments, the quality of the web-crawled corpora does not seem to play a
significant role when training LMs.
|
[
-0.3981366158,
-0.3038451374,
0.5515691638,
0.055578243,
-0.2654108405,
0.2236013114,
-0.4889020622,
-0.7616705894,
0.053669624,
0.1539575905,
-0.181726262,
-0.6521508694,
-0.64587605,
0.43949911,
-0.780374229,
0.8479660153,
0.0801151022,
0.2704521716,
-0.3496237099,
-0.1243146732,
0.1497074664,
-0.8957682848,
-0.5108829141,
-0.1125782132,
0.7283499837,
0.0836959705,
0.7470407486,
0.5941346288,
0.724516809,
0.2734080851,
-0.3737106323,
0.2575740218,
-0.6566993594,
-0.1411814243,
-0.3749743998,
-0.4403923154,
-0.2539352477,
0.2540626526,
0.4931238592,
0.8990821838,
0.0436828807,
0.2232481837,
0.1220314577,
0.6062856317,
-0.6534932256,
-0.1525224149,
-0.597451508,
0.0319172777,
-0.0591565594,
-0.2775413692,
-0.537453115,
-0.2389449477,
0.0843785852,
-0.4630105197,
0.4700289071,
0.0140960272,
1.0873839855,
0.0568083748,
-0.2710627615,
-0.6220114827,
-0.5202900767,
0.8906530142,
-0.7050465345,
0.6085439324,
0.5611918569,
-0.1591564715,
0.0551913343,
-0.3843868375,
-0.3000876307,
-0.3023185432,
-0.0697006434,
0.164202854,
-0.2857670188,
-0.0152609386,
-0.1494517773,
0.542263031,
-0.6083645225,
0.572006464,
-0.5314239264,
-0.4407190681,
0.3998582363,
-0.0726340711,
0.328974694,
0.1664884239,
-0.2953839898,
-0.3219801784,
-0.8160430789,
0.2571520209,
0.7754206061,
0.312100172,
0.1049463525,
0.4794083238,
-0.0607313775,
0.4962464571,
-0.1268659383,
-0.2648265362,
0.1584141105,
-0.2844734192,
-0.0593557283,
-0.07993453,
0.947507143,
0.0255901087,
0.508874476,
-0.4689981639,
-0.4581232369,
0.4825280309,
0.5023400187,
-0.660808444,
-0.2191304117,
0.2112139314,
-0.40754354,
-0.310257107,
0.1318473071,
-0.2480833828,
0.027150372,
-0.3682670891,
0.2712455392,
-0.4352118373,
-0.1481378227,
0.0972381011,
-0.1304633468,
0.0216377489,
0.3682660758,
-0.8990076184,
0.4428879321,
0.7764974833,
0.719797492,
-0.5253955126,
-0.2186488509,
-0.5621659756,
-0.3162987232,
-0.7641271949,
0.9553788304,
-0.7669600248,
-0.2446510345,
0.3381647468,
0.0444429033,
-0.0330333002,
-0.6660326123,
0.7552093267,
-0.6102355123,
0.2926301658,
-0.3351962864,
-0.5138686299,
-0.121190317,
0.3403503001,
-0.7415221334,
1.0908015966,
0.2027929574,
-0.803196907,
0.5126523972,
-0.1895666867,
-0.3362644613,
-0.1099572554,
0.0633097738,
-0.1283235252,
0.2975238264,
0.0525017455,
0.623091042,
-0.0749012157,
0.093140021,
-0.3938685954,
-0.4966344535,
0.4864673018,
-0.4071675539,
0.3124733567,
0.2032609731,
-0.2076827735,
-0.1595643014,
-0.846342802,
0.1313433498,
-0.3215672672,
-0.6011584997,
-0.487647742,
0.04538868,
0.2224741876,
0.476862669,
0.2060686946,
-0.6334730983,
-0.1154105589,
-0.3913754821,
0.5520373583,
0.6643931866,
-0.35769701,
0.4590775669,
-0.1463736594,
0.6046974063,
0.0073853456,
0.0860792026,
0.1504032165,
-0.368376404,
-0.8608897328,
-0.247907877,
0.5333806872,
0.1923784465,
-0.3859364986,
0.2028599828,
-0.2591008246,
-0.7487877607,
-0.8882606626,
0.2456215471,
0.5101422668,
0.0048652817,
0.3522421718,
-0.5142008662,
-0.1314108223,
-0.899081409,
-0.1107935309,
-0.2605462968,
0.0544894747,
0.0932224989,
0.3913163245,
-0.2234054357,
0.7309402823,
0.0623887479,
-0.1146213785,
-0.2091021687,
0.0505474843,
-0.1221904457,
0.1392192245,
0.5335063338,
-0.6679048538,
-0.2335346788,
0.0377559811,
-0.4809978902,
-0.1376865357,
0.1395291984,
-0.0678271726,
0.488255471,
0.27530393,
-0.4562532604,
0.0631097332,
1.0845569372,
-0.118608281,
0.4611035883,
-0.3210581243,
0.1221100911,
-0.6435593367,
0.2842848599,
-0.0483809151,
-0.4678120613,
-0.5299281478,
0.197161749,
0.2124944925,
0.0604682229,
-0.6860403419,
0.5795612931,
-0.3976371884,
-0.4479208887,
-0.2362136841,
0.6200139523,
0.151116237,
0.3048676252,
0.2549506724,
0.8488212824,
0.1984821111,
-0.8129600883,
-0.1623911709,
-0.0128635997,
-0.4985229373,
0.256319195,
-0.5422238111,
0.228806898,
0.1311891526,
-0.0750479549,
-0.8590842485,
0.1338127106,
-0.1465537548,
-0.7224825025,
0.2416475564,
0.0120882438,
-0.5689561963,
-0.1438413858,
-0.1725432277,
0.0705962628,
0.2409215719,
-0.4926660359,
-0.0440322533,
0.4963954389,
-0.150146082,
-0.510045588,
-0.59406358,
0.0726723447,
-0.0657077208,
-0.4666835368,
0.2223946899,
-0.0845839307,
-0.3544355035,
0.0854185,
-0.1121809036,
-0.112337552,
0.3238965571,
0.0317543559,
0.1057706252,
-0.087875016,
0.1710387915,
-0.0829180181,
-0.0246358998,
-0.0787963718,
-0.2740778923,
0.7637242079,
-0.1809669286,
-0.3564923108,
-0.4395334125,
0.1950759143,
0.22806108,
-0.3713292181,
0.8024052382,
0.6832480431,
-0.1418938786,
-0.0586727671,
-0.6051586866,
-0.01434083,
-0.4265298247,
0.1327366233,
-0.2936231494,
-1.1224650145,
0.3171284199,
0.209476456,
0.1153731719,
0.6853055954,
0.6397017837,
-0.4424103796,
1.0761070251,
0.7906776667,
-0.1731849909,
0.3601776361,
-0.4306587279,
0.051562015,
-0.7782552838,
-0.0645118281,
-0.8570680022,
-0.1922005862,
-0.9204934239,
-0.2652277052,
0.1403955221,
0.1021913961,
-0.0057822065,
0.4863135219,
-0.4258799255,
0.1213205904,
0.446998477,
-0.1512884796,
0.4526195228,
0.1690790355,
-0.1042818502,
0.0745402724,
-0.7765793204,
-1.0955868959,
0.8073850274,
0.4081121683,
0.7092672586,
0.0087721748,
0.753118217,
0.2863130867,
0.3309163451,
-0.8360694647,
0.3604846597,
-0.3924317956,
-0.6092600226,
-0.1994363219,
-0.6610890031,
-1.3019812107,
0.3119906783,
0.0261424929,
-0.5160196424,
0.3123352528,
0.1830855459,
-0.1050122604,
0.218309164,
-0.4504890442,
0.6448272467,
-0.2368364334,
-0.1949071586,
-0.4572472572,
-0.258427918,
0.0411572158,
-0.1458905935,
0.6157560349,
-0.2940920591,
-0.2671691477,
0.9348903298,
-0.2453345656,
0.6251181364,
0.2185874283,
-0.3412759602,
0.344357878,
0.2844282985,
0.1900571883,
-0.1360559464,
0.0090354616,
0.3772625029,
0.43539837,
-0.6060773134,
-0.1025290489,
0.6692841649,
-0.9286674261,
-0.2956824303,
-0.5405707359,
0.0218363795,
-0.2123094052,
0.0095552802,
0.3831583261,
0.5480536819,
-0.315100193,
0.3426772058,
0.5714710951,
-0.4501559138,
0.5277855992,
0.5708792806,
0.0847738683,
-0.2619889677,
0.8881927729,
0.0398491025,
0.7162101269,
0.5349555016,
0.0896479338,
-0.1599038839,
-0.5042316914,
-0.4208226204,
0.306122303,
-0.7089953423,
-0.1634990722,
-0.8127575517,
-0.0158563871,
-0.3030489087,
-0.0224499125,
-0.591508925,
-0.3416750729,
-0.4845949411,
-0.0604605675,
0.1670194864,
0.7409182787,
-0.0997143462,
0.1324691176,
-1.0493283272,
0.1355042905,
0.0108397566,
0.2323485166,
-0.0830657259,
-0.6913912892,
-0.5000346303,
0.156167075,
-0.1471946239,
-0.5368145704,
0.5994431376,
0.2522259653,
0.5447893143,
0.4875118732,
-0.1979076564,
0.4483507276,
-0.4974385798,
0.8314217925,
-0.0012165555,
-0.7949486971,
0.2438264638,
-0.1645092815,
0.1007977203,
0.7757660151,
0.7425763011,
-0.7912884951,
-0.6328690648,
-0.6326366067,
-0.7068516612,
0.5550767779,
0.1699774563,
0.3843533993,
-0.3744647801,
0.0916700065,
0.220841825,
0.2573073506,
-0.7082653642,
0.149738878,
0.0890888199,
-0.0607019141,
-0.0663612112,
-0.2080519199,
0.1409281939,
0.3229033351,
0.6682030559,
-0.1290933043,
0.2204903364,
0.2134087086,
-0.490098089,
-0.0966471508,
0.3523163795,
0.3955626786,
0.7701063156,
-0.1824255735,
0.1534699053,
-0.0151890991,
-0.7032471895,
0.149024263,
-0.3971211612,
0.0628961399,
0.2201457471,
0.6436477304,
0.5496131778,
0.4756736755,
-0.8730099201,
0.51340729,
-0.1947591752,
0.0222189259,
-0.2582173347,
0.1823643595,
0.038903553,
-0.1530132741,
0.1336537004,
-0.096116215,
0.1934599429,
-0.9449453354,
-0.2295763344,
0.319242835,
-0.5502234101,
-0.4421446621,
0.2734850347,
0.1194646806,
-0.2319908142,
0.6779381633,
-0.3475079536,
-0.6390070319,
0.3907650411,
0.177669391,
0.4020425975,
-0.0800243989,
0.2496189624,
0.2298694551,
0.512909472,
-0.2316957712,
0.2097860873,
0.1941610575,
-0.6840216517,
-0.5768316388,
-1.0267697573,
-0.6432238817,
0.0787155256,
-0.7709109783,
0.2115325034,
-0.1748199463,
-0.1898469627,
-0.135224238,
0.2423655391,
-1.0251957178,
0.4795083702,
0.2557244897,
1.0258328915,
-0.7617366314,
0.7505105138,
0.4493883848,
-0.3929989338,
-0.5083189011,
-0.2991306186,
-0.2654462755,
-0.6377785802,
0.7339653969,
0.1927157938,
-0.1490484774,
-0.1814352274,
-0.3667795658,
-1.0553660393,
0.7286724448,
0.3587486148,
-0.808616519,
0.0315097272,
0.2059260458,
0.9467152357,
-0.1451991498,
0.3867389858,
0.3910216093,
0.2049603015,
-0.3045430183,
-1.0174927711,
-0.5263056159,
-0.1586719304,
-0.0137409829,
0.0731525272,
-0.7169246078,
0.5507449508,
-0.0323232524,
-0.4779508412,
0.1519772708,
0.437274456,
0.1279248893,
-0.0861123502,
0.3831003904,
0.5480167866,
0.789111197,
-0.1844465286,
1.4053704739,
-0.4241602123,
0.3048924804,
0.8877612352,
-0.1753596514,
1.348269701,
0.1560886055,
-0.3053995967,
0.3463878036,
1.0626837015,
0.2326212674,
0.4134080112,
0.28084445,
0.1334674805,
-0.3639062941,
0.0650647432,
-0.1897692233,
0.555942297,
0.3315116167,
-0.449101001,
0.0031692591,
-0.0378878191,
0.2375947684,
0.2127416879,
-0.219736129,
0.8472248912,
0.1909474581,
-0.6806482673,
0.6519327164,
0.2571511269,
0.5896005034,
-0.3774310946,
0.3072582483,
-0.5670111179,
0.0644861087,
-0.1970307231,
-0.6207700372,
0.0450702496,
0.4073901474,
-0.1466756463,
-0.1818334311,
0.3669672906,
-0.3917365074,
-0.5321520567,
0.5954549313,
0.5149023533,
0.5983076692,
-0.2505476773,
-0.3722012639,
0.3090957701,
-0.3547804058,
-0.2922494113,
0.6485392451,
0.5172569156,
0.0687570199,
0.6810051799,
0.8579085469,
0.2606182396,
-0.0113268057,
0.269305706,
0.7894725204,
-0.4733850658,
-0.1796149462,
-0.6876951456,
0.1789444685,
0.0191734936,
-0.51859653,
0.5768780112,
0.702614367,
1.1397809982,
0.1251413822,
0.4932950735,
0.3492428362,
0.6381454468,
-0.6220661998,
0.7027717829,
-0.473210305,
0.1023139879,
-0.316835463,
-1.2362424135,
-0.10344477,
0.718950808,
-0.2305063009,
-0.0068512564,
0.8184472919,
0.5330709219,
-0.1259552985,
-0.2625442445,
0.6018104553,
0.0848299861,
0.4104883373,
0.3019852042,
0.9231506586,
-0.3594168127,
0.7032582164,
-0.1736657917,
0.0593191832,
-0.0753774121,
-0.7380121946,
-0.7581474185,
-0.5790678859,
-0.1688138694,
-0.075276427,
0.197630167,
0.8944835663,
0.6997608542,
-0.8374530077,
-0.1621020436,
0.2009313554,
-0.340972513,
-0.079154931,
-0.1517006159,
0.519454658,
-0.7669321299,
-0.8070991635,
0.3526254296,
0.3121019602,
-0.3261236548,
-0.5072661042,
-0.0231999196,
-0.1185062155,
0.0975447968,
0.820227325,
-0.1415859014,
-0.7545186877,
-0.3055715859,
0.2689203322,
-0.5131222606,
0.2297846973,
0.6242924333,
-0.8437398076,
0.2359454036,
0.328327328,
0.5828133821,
0.3585651815,
-0.1661542058,
0.2903933525,
-0.5395502448,
-0.0570148863,
0.2658390105,
0.5976233482,
0.8213749528,
-0.1353711933,
0.6385856867,
-0.0516806468,
-0.603056848,
-0.7644053102,
-0.2253476679,
-0.8535510302,
-0.1721843183,
1.5102647543,
-0.4160414636,
-0.2512057126,
0.0760287717,
-0.1054744422,
0.1224489734,
-0.3097222447,
0.8467615843,
1.0705176592,
0.2496094257,
-0.0997567624,
-0.678045094,
0.4491292238,
0.2627677321,
-0.8124696016,
-0.1829562038,
0.365634948,
0.2727824748,
0.2998018563,
0.2965078056,
-0.3019082546,
0.2696455419,
-0.2713676691,
0.1349937916,
0.3910529017,
-0.4132199883,
-0.3188205063,
-0.0052596689,
0.3467882872,
0.2158011049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08688v1
|
Token Alignment via Character Matching for Subword Completion
| 2024-03-13T16:44:39 | 2024-03-13T16:44:39 |
Ben Athiwaratkun, Shiqi Wang, Mingyue Shang, Yuchen Tian, Zijian Wang, Sujan Kumar Gonugondla, Sanjay Krishna Gouda, Rob Kwiatowski, Ramesh Nallapati, Bing Xiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generative models, widely utilized in various applications, can often
struggle with prompts corresponding to partial tokens. This struggle stems from
tokenization, where partial tokens fall out of distribution during inference,
leading to incorrect or nonsensical outputs. This paper examines a technique to
alleviate the tokenization artifact on text completion in generative models,
maintaining performance even in regular non-subword cases. The method, termed
token alignment, involves backtracking to the last complete tokens and ensuring
the model's generation aligns with the prompt. This approach showcases marked
improvement across many partial token scenarios, including nuanced cases like
space-prefix and partial indentation, with only a minor time increase. The
technique and analysis detailed in this paper contribute to the continuous
advancement of generative models in handling partial inputs, bearing relevance
for applications like code completion and text autocompletion.
|
[
0.0345347859,
-0.58670187,
0.5781511068,
0.0326030664,
-0.467235446,
0.3786564469,
0.1280469298,
-0.1703059524,
0.2857674956,
0.3771938384,
-0.6529272199,
-0.5761188865,
-0.3690697551,
0.2978468537,
-0.4352270961,
0.9006254673,
-0.2583046854,
-0.0612699315,
-0.6085683107,
-0.1933656037,
-0.9920578003,
-0.7367109656,
-0.6737239361,
-0.40448457,
0.4939074814,
0.2206254452,
0.8141493797,
0.9506837726,
0.5877177715,
0.2256017178,
-0.3297893107,
0.2243543118,
-0.2653259039,
0.1988535821,
-0.0876185,
-0.5952926874,
-0.2267727107,
-0.1086086109,
0.571993053,
0.696860373,
-0.1214926168,
-0.0336284563,
0.0021934961,
0.3153348863,
-0.5109547377,
-0.1747457832,
-0.539414227,
0.3854219019,
-0.6445527077,
-0.2529193759,
-0.4829323888,
-0.1781526655,
-0.1547912806,
-0.7615356445,
0.6585150957,
0.2932630181,
0.9246009588,
0.3932740986,
-0.2503964007,
-0.1051813215,
-0.4597733021,
0.5531795025,
-0.7307755947,
0.303671658,
0.1717183292,
0.0730154589,
-0.3738588691,
-0.7238843441,
-0.8650557399,
-0.0530697517,
-0.3566738069,
0.2995154262,
-0.0580749363,
0.3804484308,
0.5191041827,
0.5564924479,
-0.6352511048,
0.2816015482,
-0.0042346385,
-0.5056940317,
-0.0017843865,
0.2571180165,
0.6501168609,
-0.3036837876,
-0.5018548369,
-0.0521244518,
-0.9214966893,
-0.1507093757,
0.4698439837,
0.4597762227,
-0.0659078211,
1.1437475681,
0.1165776327,
0.8393408656,
0.3226993382,
0.3267729878,
0.288487196,
-0.9451425076,
-0.3679042161,
0.067747727,
0.4857628345,
0.2001796514,
0.0275879148,
-0.1393370926,
-0.1799202114,
-0.0180227999,
0.2404394597,
-0.4224753976,
-0.1796522588,
0.2837823033,
-0.6506996751,
-0.0722309574,
-0.0087535949,
-0.6721361876,
-0.7129775286,
-0.2911362946,
0.196277678,
-0.3923490942,
-0.0968775675,
-0.2617487609,
-0.4676401317,
0.290918231,
0.1967546791,
-1.0646319389,
-0.0026230747,
0.9066388607,
1.2600497007,
-0.2974736691,
-0.0140030216,
-0.9083811045,
0.1096447557,
-0.5518631935,
0.5148720741,
-0.6931018233,
-0.4757162929,
0.0575690717,
-0.1778900325,
-0.1356044114,
-0.4807398617,
0.5851393938,
-0.5071722865,
0.2375799119,
-0.3257813156,
-0.8876331449,
0.2303915918,
0.0785785839,
-0.6593299508,
1.1547589302,
0.1300008893,
-1.0536668301,
0.5050125718,
-0.5201182961,
-0.5338484049,
0.2775993645,
-0.2828950882,
-0.4784683287,
0.4926019311,
0.3276018798,
0.1045687124,
-0.1166400909,
-0.0467410199,
-0.151620999,
-0.6477495432,
0.0917349756,
-0.1688869745,
0.5535757542,
0.0337675028,
-0.2616702318,
0.3197051883,
-0.4722481966,
-0.0997434333,
-0.1251941323,
-0.1033545732,
-0.4847980738,
-0.183665812,
0.1243292689,
0.0576479696,
0.5016561151,
-0.640597403,
0.4660969079,
-0.5106697679,
0.3689484298,
0.817984581,
-0.1954257339,
0.6256430745,
-0.0851219594,
0.7939258814,
0.2409221232,
0.1782649457,
-0.4067718089,
-0.3516576588,
-0.8650951385,
-0.6499099135,
1.1198909283,
0.5454528928,
-1.0180724859,
0.6546778679,
-0.2710472643,
-0.1789409071,
-0.548404634,
-0.0650105178,
0.5737041831,
0.5602362156,
0.296676755,
-0.5133028626,
-0.7465988994,
-0.6614323258,
-0.1913859248,
-0.2424910367,
-0.1244053394,
0.0878648683,
0.2595817447,
-0.128941074,
1.1506644487,
-0.3116741478,
-0.3173212409,
-0.1542008519,
0.3022992909,
0.2158004493,
0.7687548399,
0.4579329789,
-0.7675075531,
-0.3967951834,
0.1234905869,
-0.5355139375,
-0.3205349445,
-0.3597703278,
-0.4716956019,
0.2181814164,
0.6340545416,
-0.8389883041,
0.697693646,
0.3809377551,
-0.4907912314,
0.1954668015,
-0.1996112168,
-0.0059337616,
-1.2446709871,
0.3768309057,
-0.2904397547,
-0.5202740431,
-0.3775696456,
0.0845867991,
0.1515720934,
-0.1363695264,
0.0286608972,
0.6434974074,
-0.5814171433,
-0.1665892005,
-0.2099229544,
0.0500680208,
0.0910241455,
0.2311066538,
-0.0289470945,
1.1126925945,
0.2683057785,
-0.1878857017,
0.2399189025,
0.3637678921,
-0.035805665,
0.5319892764,
-0.69856745,
0.334967047,
-0.2418045402,
0.294077903,
-1.3329700232,
-0.0094816564,
0.4041796923,
-0.3739118576,
0.4225312173,
-0.3052121103,
-0.6766394377,
-0.2118030488,
-0.1538751274,
0.728310585,
0.5529230237,
-0.5900286436,
0.9195193052,
-0.0745411068,
-0.2308337986,
-0.584567368,
-0.4667382538,
0.2722596526,
-0.2183457166,
-0.216241762,
0.700945735,
0.0394985415,
0.1917613,
-0.0138472058,
-0.1886409223,
0.249511525,
-0.029860083,
0.1190253645,
0.4823357165,
-0.1390308142,
-0.004153105,
0.3530276716,
-0.1468638331,
-0.5822683573,
-0.3721914291,
0.8164457679,
0.6240240932,
-0.5530252457,
-0.5790103674,
0.6247688532,
0.6763248444,
-0.3023144007,
0.7448883057,
0.2258375436,
-0.4652037323,
0.2484638542,
-0.5502772927,
0.0509757698,
-0.4180921316,
0.2778084278,
-0.6159807444,
-0.5590433478,
0.7639299035,
0.1904378235,
0.1554206312,
0.4851723909,
0.3392768502,
-0.1230002418,
1.194494009,
0.7746832371,
0.0849367455,
0.9391759634,
0.190993011,
0.3233347535,
-0.9968277812,
-0.3372053504,
-0.5961862803,
-0.2099895924,
-0.3081378341,
-0.459294945,
-0.0396506153,
0.2343820632,
0.1670897901,
0.5626954436,
-0.5057825446,
0.4507131577,
0.5132531524,
-0.0772325993,
0.1619211733,
0.0801130235,
-0.6306188703,
-0.1957707107,
-0.6511707306,
-0.2394695431,
0.5723712444,
0.1519045532,
0.4435868859,
0.1288177818,
0.8285578489,
0.4400158226,
0.3031098545,
-0.6648318768,
0.2201903462,
-0.2318218052,
-0.2633466125,
-0.162673533,
-0.5675792694,
-0.7575654387,
0.0707296282,
-0.0760697126,
-0.4643878341,
0.4131518602,
0.3203473985,
-0.5959024429,
-0.1342808306,
-0.6391397715,
0.9740113616,
0.0523245372,
0.1440712512,
0.146067977,
-0.6897315383,
-0.0452355444,
-0.1669247597,
-0.257111907,
0.1907776743,
-0.1114054918,
0.5959633589,
-0.8884977698,
0.7719032764,
-0.2855995893,
-0.1247042492,
-0.0225809831,
-0.0547511354,
0.7135888338,
-0.3485606909,
0.0077812257,
0.141805321,
-0.0082767485,
-0.6891196966,
-0.8575810194,
0.3408354819,
-0.4315468371,
-0.3333112895,
-0.476162076,
-0.2849082947,
-0.0452556796,
0.3061935008,
0.6601779461,
0.3577586114,
0.0863791928,
-0.1410881281,
0.5797126889,
-0.1178901047,
0.485699147,
0.0225530732,
-0.1158541217,
-0.6002627015,
0.6262977123,
0.1333061755,
0.0798231736,
0.4813047647,
-0.0366865173,
-0.8056675792,
-0.6639698744,
-0.7105870247,
0.1840494275,
-0.8025531769,
-0.4770846665,
-0.5541543365,
-0.1525276601,
-0.5190644264,
-0.0917970091,
0.0149444165,
-0.4528620541,
-0.4911679029,
-0.2606237829,
0.2370865643,
0.3878050447,
0.3018373847,
0.3302431703,
-0.7696380615,
0.1780694276,
-0.0080322251,
0.189869836,
0.0476542823,
-0.5820546746,
-0.0726247057,
-0.0898358822,
-0.0775887445,
-0.7525231838,
0.0016714598,
0.1623933762,
0.3000017107,
0.0577430986,
-0.0645633265,
1.2193387747,
-0.6586872935,
0.9016624093,
0.5639774203,
-1.3749469519,
0.2940314412,
-0.1996454298,
0.3434389234,
0.5846318007,
-0.2171640098,
-1.053176403,
-0.2795816958,
-0.2977733314,
-1.0661554337,
0.4222490788,
0.5296863317,
0.3205250204,
-0.2536072433,
0.7633817792,
0.2712163329,
0.241758287,
-0.4045321047,
-0.1290512681,
-0.2777978778,
-0.8740001321,
0.1077569351,
-0.2301693708,
0.0426589809,
-0.0697309002,
0.5887334347,
-0.2506829202,
0.348644942,
0.2164979875,
-0.0764174834,
-0.0126667107,
-0.1961355954,
0.7766187191,
0.5553367138,
0.4831951857,
-0.0263004396,
-0.1022082865,
-0.4362657964,
0.0824660584,
0.1523089409,
-0.3097172081,
0.2833099663,
0.4080707729,
0.6552863717,
-0.0469207428,
-0.5678654909,
0.7466188669,
-0.1943907142,
0.303596735,
-0.1985621005,
-0.2641469538,
-0.3057599664,
0.1110085547,
0.5373843312,
0.2388245612,
-0.0081783962,
-0.2797049582,
0.1423812658,
0.5875419378,
-0.3750939965,
-0.1589770913,
0.7832254767,
0.1915865391,
-0.3980328143,
0.8820652962,
0.1213072836,
-0.5755417943,
0.7213739753,
0.62233603,
1.0557043552,
0.2357824892,
0.1074175388,
-0.0004124306,
0.0526249148,
-0.1526865363,
0.2353646904,
-0.246799767,
-0.5248288512,
-0.6382744312,
-0.6603996754,
-0.1991655082,
-0.2972815931,
-0.448350817,
0.200577125,
-0.3812915087,
-0.3912297785,
-0.0924182087,
-0.2372018546,
-0.5367143154,
0.1718895733,
0.0887492225,
0.9464308619,
-0.9232569933,
0.6264529228,
0.6167088747,
-0.5963432193,
-0.6817032695,
0.4001239836,
-0.3548588455,
-0.7029755712,
0.5557795763,
0.1242830604,
0.0784074515,
0.1262622178,
-0.2824499011,
-1.0496475697,
0.8122020364,
0.4685946703,
-0.6575651765,
-0.2720520496,
0.0707351491,
0.6232138872,
-0.0844879374,
0.0903869122,
0.3261722028,
0.329217881,
0.4091897309,
-0.9174721241,
0.4149768949,
-0.3235062957,
0.5517123938,
0.472644031,
-0.4986304939,
0.6049066782,
0.2852016985,
-0.457387507,
0.9653833508,
1.0217862129,
0.1762174964,
0.1524273604,
0.4396916926,
0.7182968259,
1.0135974884,
-0.2541568577,
0.9127842784,
-0.1633407027,
0.4445641637,
0.9199795127,
-0.4162510037,
0.5715022683,
0.7372506261,
-0.0190222636,
0.4063080549,
0.9831853509,
0.017195534,
0.6359986663,
0.2288375795,
-0.1580747515,
-0.2581695914,
-0.2325761467,
-0.1936759949,
0.2560243607,
0.0026546754,
-0.3722220957,
0.1052445844,
0.0651692674,
-0.1355278045,
0.0998539999,
-0.1455385834,
0.8550221324,
-0.1664198637,
-0.9289439917,
0.2839902937,
0.0389490947,
0.654861629,
-0.2698881328,
-0.2673218846,
-0.6525303721,
-0.1052072793,
-0.26930511,
-0.2709661722,
0.2652941346,
-0.0148072811,
-0.4087581336,
-0.1131882295,
0.2973415256,
-0.4603730142,
-0.5162014365,
-0.0517373681,
0.0196608473,
-0.0764122829,
0.2117962837,
-0.4531296492,
0.1162954867,
-0.195547089,
0.3041634262,
0.0143059446,
0.4793650508,
-0.1480005085,
0.0702307522,
0.582773447,
-0.0267635677,
0.3772691488,
0.2249944359,
0.592615664,
-0.5901931524,
-0.4402338266,
-1.1565742493,
0.4125771821,
-0.4276075363,
-0.4211636484,
0.6588446498,
0.739499867,
0.6657171249,
0.0763865858,
0.7720934153,
-0.2509890497,
0.2200330496,
-0.8244718909,
0.405942291,
-0.5599379539,
0.0723086596,
-0.3412701786,
-0.9709684849,
-0.5371657014,
0.4070997238,
-0.0715894178,
0.0337344408,
0.7204615474,
0.5650936961,
-0.0725363567,
-0.2493399978,
0.2924869955,
-0.1220214814,
0.3036827147,
0.144200623,
0.8629330397,
-0.4255261123,
0.2084097266,
0.2143357396,
-0.1403655261,
-0.117239438,
-0.872911334,
-0.8230318427,
-0.5266267061,
-0.4164678454,
-0.3404943049,
0.0332307778,
0.8692595363,
0.5367900133,
-0.792183578,
0.4190600812,
-0.5051256418,
0.1748008877,
-0.3202517331,
-0.2349867225,
0.4422833025,
-0.4534958005,
-0.8736874461,
0.1260212362,
0.3674286604,
0.3642277718,
0.0241387486,
0.2881474793,
-0.0152294673,
0.3049350679,
0.2064509392,
0.2686867714,
-0.8305625319,
-0.4405448437,
0.1305816621,
-0.1283100992,
0.2412920445,
1.2566559315,
-0.6887612343,
0.4606066346,
0.7034897804,
0.7979354262,
0.2761407793,
0.4510059953,
0.8307255507,
-1.4456851482,
0.0877228156,
0.1430479288,
0.5082291365,
0.6176390052,
-0.718349874,
0.2702473998,
0.3961749077,
-0.2098288834,
-0.9992514253,
0.4310499132,
-0.7534441352,
-0.0747772008,
0.7839455009,
-0.2299866378,
-0.1907927245,
-0.1607595086,
-0.505836904,
0.6613680124,
-0.1697575152,
0.7321980596,
0.8524158597,
-0.048094891,
-0.0285862852,
0.2054830492,
0.4536050856,
0.8916184306,
-0.520770967,
0.2592931986,
0.4080064595,
0.0989081115,
0.3759980798,
0.6479575634,
-0.1690961272,
0.2617864907,
-0.135824129,
0.0044235806,
0.2006849945,
-0.1355603337,
-0.5077539682,
0.0247013401,
0.0154823018,
-0.5586993694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08664v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08664v2
|
Zero-shot and Few-shot Generation Strategies for Artificial Clinical Records
| 2024-03-13T16:17:09 | 2024-03-14T15:57:59 |
Erlend Frayling, Jake Lever, Graham McDonald
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The challenge of accessing historical patient data for clinical research,
while adhering to privacy regulations, is a significant obstacle in medical
science. An innovative approach to circumvent this issue involves utilising
synthetic medical records that mirror real patient data without compromising
individual privacy. The creation of these synthetic datasets, particularly
without using actual patient data to train Large Language Models (LLMs),
presents a novel solution as gaining access to sensitive patient information to
train models is also a challenge. This study assesses the capability of the
Llama 2 LLM to create synthetic medical records that accurately reflect real
patient information, employing zero-shot and few-shot prompting strategies for
comparison against fine-tuned methodologies that do require sensitive patient
data during training. We focus on generating synthetic narratives for the
History of Present Illness section, utilising data from the MIMIC-IV dataset
for comparison. In this work introduce a novel prompting technique that
leverages a chain-of-thought approach, enhancing the model's ability to
generate more accurate and contextually relevant medical narratives without
prior fine-tuning. Our findings suggest that this chain-of-thought prompted
approach allows the zero-shot model to achieve results on par with those of
fine-tuned models, based on Rouge metrics evaluation.
|
[
0.033135172,
-0.7522486448,
0.8480417132,
-0.2202828079,
-0.2877708077,
0.1340477169,
0.1322774291,
-0.5720521212,
0.3476770818,
0.4832166135,
-0.7978500128,
-0.6094204187,
-0.1624396592,
0.3318698108,
-0.4269361794,
1.1724542379,
-0.1431225091,
0.2274781615,
0.0682369173,
-0.1722040325,
-0.5052099824,
-0.8147578835,
-0.3096237183,
-0.5023142099,
0.8746547103,
0.2838307321,
0.410695076,
0.8708648682,
0.3740099072,
0.0729672536,
0.2663549185,
0.4572488964,
-0.6539552808,
0.3897457719,
-0.0218518749,
-0.7441620827,
-0.6917120814,
-0.1223925576,
0.4827566147,
0.2939187586,
0.0076610679,
0.322106868,
-0.4316368401,
0.4190620482,
-0.6198321581,
-0.3392783701,
-0.7510982752,
0.456943661,
-0.2895796299,
-0.5751237869,
-0.4880038202,
-0.2965874076,
-0.1033494696,
-0.5898133516,
0.4490328133,
-0.0866203979,
0.7398712039,
0.1188963279,
-0.225747183,
-0.2933552265,
-0.9197345376,
0.4076639712,
-0.7445232272,
0.0032870735,
0.4338907897,
0.4215967059,
-0.1156210154,
-0.782227397,
-0.7098610401,
-0.2852592766,
0.1249209195,
0.2616833448,
-0.1639444977,
-0.1312710345,
0.3256430328,
0.2088412046,
-0.6034875512,
0.314876914,
-0.3963767588,
-0.1111735776,
0.6766408086,
0.6665145159,
0.1550819576,
-0.1066657156,
-0.3632393181,
-0.0874746144,
-1.0778359175,
-0.3319956362,
0.1939841807,
0.3070203364,
-0.2086671144,
0.7544412613,
-0.3597509563,
0.3332455754,
0.0675130934,
-0.4485269785,
0.2205267996,
-0.2705315351,
-0.1175651848,
0.3421630561,
0.8413749933,
0.4301868081,
0.2497641593,
-0.0828996748,
-0.0005967726,
0.4143820405,
0.5303922296,
-0.7402434349,
-0.0144357346,
0.4951865673,
-0.3604275584,
-0.6373696923,
-0.2618670166,
-0.6990544796,
-0.4885126948,
-0.1250884384,
0.4557751119,
-0.4255476296,
-0.1514572948,
0.0394921564,
0.0395445302,
0.2071054578,
0.2868077755,
-0.7402814627,
0.2652645707,
0.6639250517,
0.9457963109,
-0.1928018779,
-0.0579124987,
-0.5647230148,
0.4261689186,
-0.5786912441,
0.6876385808,
-0.1447163671,
-0.5127522945,
0.192822665,
-0.1934840381,
0.2779011428,
-0.631467104,
0.142406404,
-0.0728638247,
0.1194013879,
-0.1582956314,
-0.4417457879,
0.1742024124,
0.4084839523,
-0.3126660883,
0.7061827183,
0.2469870597,
-0.5146631598,
0.3921396732,
-0.2980675101,
-0.4594601691,
0.1759299189,
-0.7108277678,
-0.5483135581,
0.0834859833,
0.1897024959,
0.4242118895,
-0.2394611388,
0.2415099889,
-0.1279374212,
-0.2289970815,
0.3137113452,
-0.4436715245,
0.3665110767,
0.1121580973,
-0.2445753366,
-0.1269808412,
-0.79300946,
0.0214832015,
0.4466891885,
-0.0914507583,
-0.0776363015,
-0.3486453295,
-0.3454612195,
0.1282046884,
-0.0679261014,
-0.5040803552,
0.5362679958,
-0.519944191,
0.2001242042,
0.5034191608,
0.4494594932,
0.0668968633,
-0.8117103577,
0.8508574963,
0.1013073847,
0.2541586757,
-0.5850976706,
-0.4543357491,
-0.6700481772,
-0.1552634239,
0.1249951571,
0.698835969,
-0.5029675364,
-0.0879238248,
-0.1896233112,
-0.4735877514,
-0.8334456086,
0.0265731029,
0.537586987,
0.9390918016,
0.4336442053,
-0.3395812511,
-0.6788451672,
-0.8624247313,
0.0584378615,
-0.3291538358,
-0.1469724327,
0.526535809,
0.4675263464,
-0.3015850782,
0.7002313137,
-0.506413281,
-0.3100013435,
-0.3227129281,
0.0376941487,
0.2316587269,
0.3872692883,
0.361771971,
-0.1205412,
-0.2712660134,
0.1251250654,
-1.1204277277,
0.0616238452,
-0.5128958225,
-0.1132094786,
0.1838068962,
0.0635283664,
-0.6986821294,
0.6358525753,
0.0898623243,
0.1737123132,
0.4092952013,
-0.2994467914,
0.0937235504,
-1.0893779993,
0.2171273082,
-0.2904267609,
-0.2954128385,
-0.8916736245,
-0.1234746501,
-0.0049908622,
-0.0896280333,
-0.7111617923,
0.5893218517,
-0.2708557546,
0.2819071114,
-0.0860799924,
-0.0358395912,
0.0129998624,
0.3026341796,
0.1089835465,
0.4328748584,
0.5045928359,
-0.4461741149,
0.2552154362,
0.5076020956,
-0.0031621747,
0.5763745904,
-0.3853300214,
0.5854324102,
-0.1573106349,
0.3164793551,
-0.612142086,
-0.6170743108,
0.3837482333,
-0.4276219308,
0.4112274945,
0.0301265363,
-0.4215397239,
-0.5130851865,
-0.3641922474,
0.3841155767,
0.867939651,
-0.2615896761,
0.1000720635,
0.0976955146,
-0.0536426343,
-0.4169641137,
-0.8702828884,
0.2877714038,
-0.2652359009,
-0.2304820567,
0.3011312485,
0.1022182405,
-0.2032175064,
-0.3736933768,
-0.1183244884,
-0.0732462108,
-0.2826735675,
0.3502764702,
0.5348599553,
-0.3509402871,
0.0431135967,
0.3010696769,
-0.1281738132,
-0.0133043407,
-0.015305711,
0.4681431055,
0.3258839846,
-0.3805816472,
-0.8683850169,
0.4180631936,
0.3748151064,
0.2390985489,
0.5341593623,
0.1056867093,
-0.4573776424,
-0.4259933531,
-0.6710929871,
-0.4316763282,
-0.4122709334,
0.0261210464,
-0.0858819485,
-0.6136702895,
0.3588224649,
-0.1831144243,
-0.058020886,
0.0609111935,
0.9762975574,
-0.1619066596,
0.8368672729,
0.092800349,
0.0494749844,
-0.1073465124,
-0.2937288284,
0.2136595547,
-0.6546233892,
-0.3781193495,
-0.2244921178,
-0.1813571155,
-0.3637388051,
-0.3947550654,
0.8098222613,
-0.0170963481,
-0.2257705927,
0.0815992951,
-0.5329635143,
0.3756290078,
0.2791060507,
0.5153456926,
0.4679255784,
0.0562985614,
0.0896917507,
0.0487093702,
-0.7449292541,
-0.6382382512,
1.3300516605,
0.284496069,
0.7671580315,
-0.2267075777,
0.9235802293,
0.287612617,
0.1914919615,
-0.6904572845,
0.3674632311,
0.1247919351,
-0.5398975015,
-0.0133295618,
-0.0684466138,
-0.9598892331,
-0.1588914841,
-0.2891457975,
-0.6585303545,
0.0318536125,
0.4195849597,
-0.9772880077,
0.2402273566,
-0.3186319172,
0.3731844723,
-0.3312048018,
-0.4601475596,
0.0973765701,
-0.8510321975,
0.492351681,
-0.3207144141,
-0.1082792878,
0.0817881152,
-0.0952214301,
0.2618068457,
-0.6373693943,
1.0613356829,
0.0934977531,
-0.0198868252,
0.3881395459,
0.4396251738,
0.5657619238,
0.0958825424,
-0.067861639,
0.411970526,
0.0048038801,
-0.0849568695,
-0.4596261084,
0.5816040039,
-0.5941337943,
-0.6737914681,
-0.4932653606,
-0.5768644214,
-0.418598026,
0.000641339,
0.4132323563,
0.3954230249,
-0.2163237482,
-0.140718773,
0.2906857729,
-0.4157966375,
0.2363723367,
0.6794501543,
0.0730040446,
-0.2499263287,
0.6283647418,
0.184777528,
0.4133336842,
0.2307085693,
0.2747737467,
-0.1252598763,
-0.5012808442,
-0.6468350887,
0.5015041232,
-0.263377279,
-0.50408113,
-0.5712999701,
-0.4358816147,
-0.4192176461,
-0.2731337249,
-0.3011531532,
-0.3410081565,
-0.4688965678,
-0.2958851159,
0.5126126409,
0.7991293073,
-0.0472848006,
0.2528484762,
-0.7461159229,
0.5389729142,
-0.0029875156,
0.0501454808,
-0.00709297,
-0.4562337697,
0.0178618021,
0.0777646601,
-0.4702694714,
-0.9807477593,
0.6248546839,
0.0120494356,
0.2875653803,
0.4352490306,
0.030993754,
0.907122314,
-0.8845543265,
0.8363332748,
0.365814656,
-0.5994516611,
0.9631633759,
-0.5489555597,
0.0365622677,
0.6180903912,
0.414920181,
-0.3330922127,
-0.4288037717,
-0.6596902609,
-0.5095976591,
0.5853545666,
0.2358471155,
0.2587524951,
-0.1917827874,
0.7995147109,
0.3784494102,
0.2529628277,
-0.4855180085,
-0.1426013559,
0.0160300154,
-0.2260533869,
0.2833907902,
-0.1187372282,
-0.3137712181,
-0.114387013,
0.3615626991,
-0.1141258329,
0.0987770557,
0.6060050726,
0.3217982352,
-0.4078584611,
0.1171437576,
0.5249552131,
0.5571594238,
-0.0365007669,
0.0887968913,
0.4186962843,
-0.4467045069,
0.3285709321,
-0.6002540588,
-0.4997480214,
0.0837300047,
0.4741047621,
0.8218500614,
-0.1790341437,
-0.8276226521,
0.4900509417,
0.2964129448,
-0.2342195213,
-0.3289211392,
0.3942962885,
-0.1268655211,
0.1520561129,
0.0336451568,
-0.1990774423,
-0.0732308701,
-0.6741207242,
0.2985083759,
0.2741542161,
-0.0947554186,
-0.4475308955,
0.7796338201,
-0.124593161,
-0.5783174634,
0.658759594,
0.2175410539,
0.0869946331,
0.5176306963,
1.0043722391,
0.5632896423,
-0.445820868,
0.4429819584,
0.5096251965,
0.0329239964,
-0.2582672536,
0.2881874442,
0.0486224592,
-0.5317497849,
-0.2015619725,
-0.2966926396,
-0.5646674037,
0.4503709972,
-0.8225218058,
0.3999683857,
-0.6629256606,
-0.2429277152,
-0.1542463899,
-0.3820847571,
-0.5341718197,
0.1752346605,
0.3029928803,
0.6365932226,
-0.61617589,
0.9192442894,
-0.0324569419,
-0.4670343697,
-0.8402402997,
-0.0569544323,
0.2913467586,
-1.0991355181,
0.3736258149,
0.0682670251,
0.0142663522,
-0.2253261209,
-0.465659827,
-0.338259995,
1.1249752045,
0.5541503429,
-0.9121887684,
-0.1918624043,
0.608558476,
0.8496291041,
-0.4197088182,
-0.029419763,
0.6066837907,
0.0552402213,
0.2256680727,
-0.8410331011,
0.118549794,
-0.0737493038,
-0.2192757428,
0.0446022041,
-0.5621131659,
0.6717196107,
-0.5053874254,
-0.2608314157,
0.2377235293,
0.1790614724,
0.5540280342,
0.6688139439,
0.0348102003,
0.4084901214,
0.9037113786,
0.2366860062,
1.3829660416,
-0.1507145613,
-0.0568072274,
1.2132952213,
-0.8872505426,
0.8136123419,
0.4168547392,
-0.1521993577,
0.4724905193,
0.2885396481,
-0.1585370153,
0.4127622247,
0.2818790972,
-0.5850715637,
-0.1507804692,
-0.2908371389,
-0.3820723891,
0.3624768853,
0.1894415766,
-0.5043670535,
-0.0268758442,
-0.0845102742,
0.288626492,
-0.0506328121,
-0.0799450129,
0.9968043566,
0.2495918572,
-0.656462431,
0.7899721861,
-0.3535993397,
0.1831351072,
-0.7714360356,
-0.2527630627,
-0.2923385799,
-0.0596548989,
-0.1766681224,
-0.4408493042,
0.1312730014,
0.4807699621,
-0.0643281788,
-0.0930597857,
0.4960246384,
-0.2271897495,
-0.6568240523,
-0.0731542483,
0.6242384911,
0.2805785537,
0.2733050585,
-0.4206748605,
0.048107218,
-0.0274667293,
-0.0080381241,
0.3295659423,
0.2764235735,
-0.2809972465,
0.4938669205,
0.7848619819,
0.7095029354,
-0.1789043695,
0.2188770473,
0.6515926719,
-0.6736980081,
-0.3556785882,
-0.9760072827,
0.3077944517,
0.0122445337,
-0.5112184882,
0.4482789338,
0.6469052434,
0.5295878649,
-0.0600355119,
0.8511272669,
0.4538434446,
0.8050774336,
-0.4311230183,
0.6910303235,
-0.4500546455,
0.1529707462,
-0.0444070846,
-0.2947779894,
-0.5251808763,
0.4623262584,
0.0825518593,
-0.3793329298,
0.6186263561,
1.0457884073,
0.0928335786,
-0.1521015018,
0.3680867851,
0.5088697076,
0.2532285452,
0.6838486791,
0.7906907201,
-0.4041753411,
0.1661974192,
-0.1501228809,
-0.0952714831,
0.0105570601,
-0.739105165,
-0.9255186319,
-0.1492024511,
-0.2388271093,
-0.4679660797,
0.3655754924,
0.8759325743,
0.6513059735,
-0.752265811,
-0.0756888092,
-0.0668243542,
-0.408298701,
0.0026903923,
-0.0985541195,
0.42742607,
0.0483189858,
-0.3272127509,
0.6799505949,
0.5812939405,
0.3505582511,
-0.3167501986,
-0.1381283104,
0.1420364976,
0.2274477929,
0.3468667567,
0.4678144753,
-0.7927789688,
-0.0636351183,
-0.0421273224,
-0.1412086189,
0.367792964,
0.9554619193,
-1.1092313528,
0.560669899,
0.1414372325,
0.4482556581,
0.6825804114,
0.1426365077,
0.5435709953,
-0.6239589453,
0.2404106557,
0.5603013635,
0.0172389522,
0.2160418183,
-0.7729309797,
0.6187495589,
0.0103388997,
-0.2934674025,
-1.1597836018,
0.1260614693,
-1.0040129423,
-0.0614086352,
1.1164212227,
-0.0024560946,
-0.189005807,
-0.0293775406,
-0.3551616073,
0.3803327382,
-0.1480781138,
0.9551897049,
0.117476359,
-0.6260232925,
0.0906473473,
-0.7539083958,
0.4196603894,
0.2435051799,
-0.9166531563,
-0.1960373074,
0.4868925214,
0.1893844903,
-0.1662595719,
0.8643037081,
-0.2496878654,
0.2483846247,
0.0680827126,
-0.3242342472,
-0.2529155016,
-0.3905747235,
-0.2647714019,
0.1367683858,
-0.4377681911,
-0.0555564687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15430v1
|
Distilling Named Entity Recognition Models for Endangered Species from Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T15:38:55 | 2024-03-13T15:38:55 |
Jesse Atuhurra, Seiveright Cargill Dujohn, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Hiroyuki Shindo, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language processing (NLP) practitioners are leveraging large language
models (LLM) to create structured datasets from semi-structured and
unstructured data sources such as patents, papers, and theses, without having
domain-specific knowledge. At the same time, ecological experts are searching
for a variety of means to preserve biodiversity. To contribute to these
efforts, we focused on endangered species and through in-context learning, we
distilled knowledge from GPT-4. In effect, we created datasets for both named
entity recognition (NER) and relation extraction (RE) via a two-stage process:
1) we generated synthetic data from GPT-4 of four classes of endangered
species, 2) humans verified the factual accuracy of the synthetic data,
resulting in gold data. Eventually, our novel dataset contains a total of 3.6K
sentences, evenly divided between 1.8K NER and 1.8K RE sentences. The
constructed dataset was then used to fine-tune both general BERT and
domain-specific BERT variants, completing the knowledge distillation process
from GPT-4 to BERT, because GPT-4 is resource intensive. Experiments show that
our knowledge transfer approach is effective at creating a NER model suitable
for detecting endangered species from texts.
|
[
-0.4415341318,
-0.7613259554,
0.6044155955,
0.076119557,
-0.464317888,
0.112363033,
-0.3662543595,
-0.8048149347,
0.1608875692,
0.7078181505,
-0.2798066139,
-0.2658400834,
-0.6111165881,
0.6984479427,
-0.4646093249,
1.1877300739,
0.1283346266,
-0.4200643599,
0.1059606746,
-0.0707668737,
-0.2656169534,
-0.6396990418,
-0.6775349379,
-0.2710418105,
0.6948429942,
0.1993786693,
0.3885534108,
0.7206087708,
0.5356265903,
0.2548304796,
-0.5760720372,
0.2622875273,
-0.5641415715,
0.0905700997,
-0.4685194492,
-0.2449332923,
-0.297044158,
0.0059095016,
0.5709164739,
0.6286996007,
-0.0993262827,
0.026291186,
0.2036274076,
0.62080127,
-0.435608834,
0.2437012196,
-1.0920296907,
-0.0432462133,
-0.4062243104,
-0.3456787765,
-0.4511515498,
-0.1744261086,
0.7154909372,
-0.6421383619,
0.2192875445,
-0.001518755,
1.0080347061,
0.3762122393,
-0.4169195294,
-0.3960216343,
-0.8638367653,
0.8653495312,
-0.8482068777,
0.1688634008,
0.4322572649,
-0.1514067054,
-0.517439425,
-0.8326591849,
-0.6866770983,
-0.1376083344,
0.0230870489,
-0.1891196519,
-0.5124869347,
-0.0097188978,
0.4802041948,
0.3509567082,
-0.4237745404,
0.149781242,
-0.2839358151,
-0.0551563464,
0.7538967729,
-0.3147374094,
0.155209884,
-0.3237942755,
-0.4648428857,
0.0377148204,
-0.8453214765,
-0.2891063094,
0.378369242,
0.5813820362,
0.3857100904,
0.4577070475,
-0.0021366326,
0.7023578286,
-0.0384150185,
-0.0897986814,
0.169551,
-0.1553632915,
-0.0780072361,
0.2369325012,
0.648476243,
0.4096437991,
0.3322165608,
-0.3051295578,
-0.2763012052,
-0.2963449657,
0.188319847,
-0.7181763649,
-0.4252484441,
-0.0684814081,
-0.3756305873,
-0.1136829481,
-0.3439525962,
-0.9307180643,
-0.2970586121,
-0.4643600285,
0.4219536185,
-0.4448021054,
-0.3383013606,
0.0955858305,
-0.3276970983,
0.1232675165,
0.1477793604,
-1.0611715317,
0.2300610244,
0.6151446104,
0.953732729,
-0.1569641531,
-0.1128382757,
-0.3226657808,
0.2923446596,
-0.1318597198,
0.8533456922,
-0.575227201,
-0.3937473595,
-0.3717346191,
0.2007913738,
0.0775335431,
-0.7096982002,
0.7766321898,
-0.7176574469,
0.0504142866,
-0.486947,
-0.6690261364,
-0.5385659933,
0.2719124854,
-0.8927588463,
0.9137216806,
-0.0645929873,
-1.00852108,
0.5545781255,
-0.6868023276,
-0.3058113158,
0.274841696,
0.1333905905,
-0.4793736041,
0.0336338468,
0.293753475,
0.4005690813,
-0.3252798021,
0.1940032095,
-0.469695121,
-0.0056112483,
0.1065281332,
-0.3074105084,
0.7628992796,
0.0791299641,
-0.3215508163,
-0.4212681949,
-0.7315256,
-0.1519523263,
0.1197167784,
-0.5988218188,
-0.9617739916,
0.2796063721,
0.0151243731,
-0.002572865,
0.0757720768,
-0.6621738672,
0.2519618273,
-0.3195234835,
0.8459335566,
0.6617796421,
0.3572178185,
0.1706049293,
-0.1268774271,
0.2062850296,
-0.0973979533,
-0.1673130095,
0.1569734365,
-0.5231912732,
-0.6865035892,
-0.0954971462,
0.4060100913,
0.3313682675,
-0.5708448887,
0.5194296241,
-0.4112379551,
-0.3993433714,
-0.1511663944,
-0.1114604995,
0.0506428741,
0.6367673874,
0.5326498747,
-0.2411751747,
-0.684034586,
-0.9354801774,
-0.2600355744,
-0.3138339818,
0.0013335056,
0.2749271095,
0.7559495568,
-0.3438157737,
1.2360678911,
-0.4712770879,
-0.3388510644,
-0.1131625772,
0.4162921906,
0.1260678768,
0.4299304485,
0.6655921936,
-0.9939501286,
-0.5258285999,
0.0368531942,
-0.6933794618,
0.0474127717,
-0.0160370171,
-0.0435754918,
0.1620174944,
0.296990335,
-0.4256599545,
0.1429935247,
0.3568885624,
0.1331147105,
0.2696141899,
-0.0565108992,
-0.1054720506,
-1.2524683475,
0.2212923318,
0.1225660294,
-0.096945554,
-0.6102955341,
-0.2999253869,
-0.0705424845,
0.1585688144,
-0.1501455307,
0.2688500881,
-0.823451519,
-0.1028340682,
-0.1509023607,
0.0511389263,
-0.1907969564,
0.1902342737,
0.4516044557,
0.5974699855,
0.4071421325,
-0.5648142695,
0.269893229,
0.4442775249,
-0.21003218,
0.3599155545,
-0.5474008918,
0.199106589,
-0.0783734173,
0.2389269471,
-0.3309079707,
-0.2301353663,
0.1050699726,
-0.0449531861,
0.4813776016,
-0.5519473553,
-0.3684739172,
-0.411919266,
-0.0113681732,
0.144792065,
0.2219401449,
-0.5656173229,
0.5519772172,
0.8381836414,
-0.6767722964,
-0.686883688,
-0.6842275858,
0.561804831,
-0.5995386839,
-0.2342345268,
0.4150764346,
0.0311138555,
-0.1011735201,
0.3497680724,
-0.1157226041,
-0.2808008492,
0.2489526272,
0.0120802317,
0.341999501,
-0.1934124231,
0.3653208911,
-0.036231719,
-0.0238061007,
0.0281021614,
-0.3668119907,
0.3110932112,
-0.0547722317,
0.0036464392,
-0.1755814701,
0.2827416658,
0.439494133,
-0.2681820989,
0.7489031553,
0.2225195765,
-0.677734077,
-0.2784257829,
-0.3774474859,
-0.0971772447,
-0.3999969363,
0.3290553391,
-0.2658988833,
-1.0929425955,
0.3932304382,
-0.329182893,
0.2456575185,
0.6438603997,
0.1990922242,
0.1840760112,
0.6355131269,
0.8402836919,
-0.3161242604,
0.566585958,
-0.2592820227,
0.5043381453,
-0.8218126297,
-0.1831443459,
-0.4908554852,
-0.2797405124,
-0.5835091472,
-0.1299415529,
0.1310053468,
0.1500736922,
0.0242219511,
0.696005702,
-0.7740896344,
0.6810709834,
0.4570689499,
0.0061972542,
0.4890413582,
0.1433480978,
0.1364140958,
-0.1123941168,
-0.2785005271,
-0.9932509661,
1.2330350876,
0.2256816775,
0.4527114034,
0.0253231376,
0.9551724792,
0.3028031886,
0.5338782072,
-0.7816005945,
0.5426322818,
-0.2533613145,
-0.7849749923,
-0.4560719132,
-0.6428793669,
-0.9962701201,
0.0290748961,
-0.1710947156,
-0.7562423348,
0.4486602843,
-0.0037403642,
-0.5220803022,
0.379088074,
-0.7036078572,
0.693831265,
-0.3568861485,
-0.0523116104,
-0.0085059665,
-0.6442810297,
0.4503759146,
-0.6434757113,
-0.0389693268,
-0.3064398766,
-0.1806676984,
0.896088779,
-0.2162013501,
0.5643417239,
-0.0220220406,
-0.2088769823,
0.3578756452,
-0.1386859715,
0.5504599214,
0.052356746,
-0.3321063519,
0.1882701069,
-0.1501278281,
0.0631479174,
-0.2296810746,
0.6400668025,
-0.6265697479,
-0.4417607188,
-0.641753912,
-0.3563158512,
-0.043055933,
0.4518502057,
0.2363497317,
0.1217360869,
-0.4017863572,
0.3784874082,
0.6262943149,
-0.1854213774,
0.614010036,
0.7648354173,
0.3229273856,
-0.4317506552,
0.7688019872,
0.418125093,
0.0506218448,
0.468619138,
-0.018667968,
-0.481440872,
-0.9321342111,
-0.1403163075,
0.2097602338,
-0.5300658345,
-0.3656592369,
-1.0529266596,
-0.3288887143,
-0.0906266123,
0.2313836217,
-0.225000158,
-0.2047321051,
-0.7033148408,
-0.1993762553,
0.6340822577,
0.910744369,
-0.3184159398,
0.1407916844,
-1.0889152288,
0.2799316645,
0.4077157676,
0.2219029963,
-0.2331148237,
-0.5092067122,
-0.0208279043,
0.1849577576,
-0.2775513232,
-0.8953042626,
0.7425479293,
0.7558139563,
0.5963513851,
0.3686542213,
0.3945758343,
0.8367861509,
-0.5535115004,
0.6735521555,
-0.0752834082,
-0.8033844233,
0.4600281715,
-0.2760268748,
-0.5212783813,
0.4723173082,
0.6505154967,
-0.4946422577,
-0.2558020949,
-0.6052480936,
-1.1455191374,
0.7934154272,
0.3415710926,
0.1600717008,
-0.1619871259,
0.4425241053,
0.2427999973,
0.2236086279,
-0.9960987568,
0.0426025614,
0.1749791205,
-0.0240229741,
-0.1537824273,
-0.3596276045,
-0.0753225014,
-0.0355388857,
0.7989043593,
0.0476248488,
-0.0039002174,
0.3030604422,
-0.2541175783,
-0.0965058431,
0.4186976552,
0.2416559458,
0.3951557875,
-0.3519090414,
0.3784818947,
0.1394438446,
-0.5907943845,
0.0418562666,
0.5606659055,
-0.1752498597,
0.0251168236,
0.3552784324,
0.5552118421,
0.0335774757,
-0.5559945703,
0.151695326,
-0.1134770215,
-0.081590876,
-0.3286552131,
-0.077506341,
0.3020655811,
0.3035623133,
0.5449997783,
0.0063970489,
0.3649766147,
-0.4545768499,
0.4330564737,
0.2694897652,
0.1672089994,
-0.3396985233,
0.589074254,
0.2507776618,
0.0425211899,
0.7504727244,
-0.2462567687,
-0.5873301625,
0.4933371842,
0.4232864082,
1.0091776848,
-0.0374928489,
0.186789453,
0.601923883,
0.3148612976,
-0.431257844,
0.0064399252,
-0.0362007581,
-0.7681387067,
-0.3319756389,
-0.9827930927,
-0.4268727601,
0.505721271,
-0.6903329492,
0.1372069567,
-0.1831486374,
-0.4171380401,
0.6201638579,
0.047693368,
-0.31188187,
-0.1463964581,
0.2762895226,
0.730932653,
-1.0760009289,
0.6274911165,
0.5807833076,
-0.5525169969,
-0.9028863907,
0.1556023955,
-0.1270839125,
-0.3486854732,
0.7754178643,
0.1838826835,
0.1501108259,
0.2872132659,
-0.5280148983,
-1.1605539322,
0.8526186943,
0.6590782404,
-0.8651081324,
0.0311627034,
-0.046730116,
0.6857286692,
-0.2063422203,
-0.1593153924,
0.7937686443,
0.4479781091,
0.1313816905,
-1.0273064375,
-0.0705025718,
-0.2792652547,
0.0825165957,
0.2483316362,
-0.2695248723,
0.9035139084,
-0.1913606375,
-0.5079234838,
-0.0454690903,
0.4913668334,
0.1272217929,
0.0712115467,
0.6320367455,
0.7586653829,
0.9495640993,
-0.1251095384,
0.5276147723,
-0.0191786606,
0.4801671505,
1.3415106535,
-0.6528172493,
1.1479569674,
0.5013865829,
-0.3246407509,
0.5109289885,
1.0356146097,
-0.1898870468,
0.586514473,
0.0935931057,
-0.4855087101,
-0.1619553864,
-0.3008317947,
-0.3379752338,
0.4568926692,
0.4338123798,
-0.512075305,
-0.3555128574,
-0.072320573,
-0.0187217686,
-0.1999132335,
-0.0578458644,
0.9685297608,
0.1401343346,
-0.6628707051,
0.6172870994,
-0.2772886157,
0.555804491,
-0.4154164493,
-0.2051853985,
-0.0140710166,
0.2334963977,
-0.2404328436,
-0.9444699287,
0.3914669454,
0.349689573,
-0.3854917288,
-0.2148739249,
0.6668719053,
-0.667704463,
-0.2468562275,
0.3174208403,
0.2581036687,
0.5698370337,
-0.2160529643,
-0.5952341557,
-0.3493809104,
0.1874433905,
-0.4129837453,
0.1377303451,
0.6973068714,
-0.209937349,
0.6618408561,
0.900333941,
0.3164742291,
0.070038259,
-0.0835712552,
1.0693491697,
-0.4932033718,
-0.2654274106,
-0.96238029,
0.2802438438,
-0.3826745749,
-0.1172241271,
0.7120839357,
0.7705807686,
0.7648262382,
-0.1012819335,
0.8847262263,
-0.2545203865,
0.7262424231,
-0.2704815269,
0.6749373078,
-0.5298556089,
0.2624860108,
-0.3972404599,
-1.0059131384,
-0.377325356,
0.5736691356,
-0.3239908516,
-0.1940527111,
0.4700820744,
0.6641851664,
-0.0011424267,
-0.0762107745,
-0.0117996233,
0.227171123,
0.4160024226,
0.5073245764,
0.911246419,
-0.1106412858,
0.6380860209,
-0.1232069284,
-0.1558377892,
-0.1806145757,
-1.2862414122,
-0.5767268538,
-0.5638797283,
-0.4066206217,
0.1000435278,
0.0405856222,
0.8667222261,
0.5086869597,
-0.915938437,
0.1825827807,
-0.3253445029,
-0.065183267,
-0.0084075034,
-0.1760926545,
0.3966124654,
-0.0193688441,
-0.7051885724,
0.3657251596,
0.3868257701,
0.443446815,
0.1449915469,
0.0147376861,
-0.3154847026,
-0.081636928,
0.5495724678,
0.5833054781,
-0.7505449653,
-0.4277502894,
-0.1977622211,
0.0052592931,
-0.1779352129,
0.3782701194,
-0.5298314095,
0.4625050724,
0.2735754251,
0.5767617822,
0.3331948817,
0.0282993652,
0.5277371407,
-0.5144770741,
0.0218432322,
0.5504334569,
0.527707696,
0.5128059983,
-0.3237116337,
0.7066250443,
0.3790602982,
-0.7824501991,
-1.0644996166,
0.0563111231,
-1.0712397099,
0.0481844321,
1.1235762835,
-0.442594409,
-0.1336714923,
-0.3090867698,
-0.2508385181,
0.3602825105,
-0.4616003036,
0.8936378956,
0.6367883682,
-0.0895199925,
-0.0937116444,
-0.4482605457,
0.7278795838,
-0.102710478,
-0.9313444495,
0.3850772083,
0.5493860841,
0.5405673385,
0.3542613983,
0.4976270199,
-0.0164649971,
-0.2109413594,
-0.133551687,
0.2114850581,
0.1280619651,
-0.148969993,
-0.1679691672,
-0.0374672338,
0.0903850272,
-0.1152636707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08607v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08607v1
|
MedInsight: A Multi-Source Context Augmentation Framework for Generating Patient-Centric Medical Responses using Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T15:20:30 | 2024-03-13T15:20:30 |
Subash Neupane, Shaswata Mitra, Sudip Mittal, Noorbakhsh Amiri Golilarz, Shahram Rahimi, Amin Amirlatifi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in generating
human-like responses. However, their lack of domain-specific knowledge limits
their applicability in healthcare settings, where contextual and comprehensive
responses are vital. To address this challenge and enable the generation of
patient-centric responses that are contextually relevant and comprehensive, we
propose MedInsight:a novel retrieval augmented framework that augments LLM
inputs (prompts) with relevant background information from multiple sources.
MedInsight extracts pertinent details from the patient's medical record or
consultation transcript. It then integrates information from authoritative
medical textbooks and curated web resources based on the patient's health
history and condition. By constructing an augmented context combining the
patient's record with relevant medical knowledge, MedInsight generates
enriched, patient-specific responses tailored for healthcare applications such
as diagnosis, treatment recommendations, or patient education. Experiments on
the MTSamples dataset validate MedInsight's effectiveness in generating
contextually appropriate medical responses. Quantitative evaluation using the
Ragas metric and TruLens for answer similarity and answer correctness
demonstrates the model's efficacy. Furthermore, human evaluation studies
involving Subject Matter Expert (SMEs) confirm MedInsight's utility, with
moderate inter-rater agreement on the relevance and correctness of the
generated responses.
|
[
-0.1881655753,
-0.6083711982,
0.8960405588,
-0.0352022536,
-0.2643236518,
-0.0887955874,
-0.1894045919,
-0.504750967,
0.5280944705,
0.5332702398,
-0.7735543251,
-0.3442843556,
-0.3123583794,
0.1912070662,
-0.1683295816,
0.8916273117,
0.2034687996,
0.4691331089,
-0.4690530002,
-0.2800607383,
-0.5272614956,
-0.4818202853,
-0.4618367851,
-0.1929543018,
0.7387180924,
0.6119957566,
0.269977361,
0.1208966523,
0.7933257818,
0.2902085781,
0.2244485319,
0.5774475336,
-0.1673354954,
0.5455895662,
-0.2168675214,
-0.2001181245,
-0.2986422479,
-0.2306982577,
0.3256768286,
0.679384768,
-0.24075225,
0.2182288319,
0.0800314322,
0.5150774121,
-0.6074088812,
-0.2976421416,
-0.5127210021,
0.1297027022,
-0.0115448441,
-0.746910274,
-0.3827452958,
-0.1193841472,
0.4899830818,
-0.5971903801,
0.039611686,
-0.002192575,
0.6341121197,
0.345623672,
-0.4456782043,
-0.0699904412,
-0.2524314523,
0.6011766791,
-0.9183858633,
0.2931436896,
0.2874870002,
0.6135431528,
-0.025496386,
-1.0039505959,
-0.2342705578,
-0.1852008402,
-0.4054535925,
0.4034878016,
0.1311814785,
-0.044388853,
0.0741090029,
0.2916851938,
-0.5071851611,
-0.1145770848,
-0.2157334238,
-0.1829456836,
0.4152146876,
0.4753202498,
0.4457983971,
-0.3951162994,
-0.4439782202,
0.2028178871,
-0.6218730211,
-0.1974755079,
-0.4306280911,
0.2994515598,
-0.0687266663,
0.8642137051,
-0.1387180388,
0.9934925437,
0.2724483013,
-0.5364767313,
0.5281305313,
-0.2655056119,
-0.2731538117,
0.2047449052,
0.559646666,
0.6977368593,
-0.2638539374,
-0.2358095348,
-0.0686526448,
0.0197245628,
0.3267856836,
-1.0620808601,
0.0139179137,
0.6354861856,
-0.6147474051,
-0.3509937227,
-0.1430726498,
-0.7112272382,
-0.6779059172,
-0.4879939556,
0.3240401745,
-0.6069054604,
-0.1535773724,
0.0781020969,
-0.2078139782,
0.0375750698,
0.403785646,
-0.5506222844,
-0.1913719475,
0.4361387193,
0.6191052198,
-0.2344152629,
-0.1846442074,
-0.8069871664,
0.197039023,
-0.1287673414,
0.8202090859,
-0.6322120428,
-0.2976153493,
0.1023300961,
0.0756464899,
0.1170395389,
-0.6289236546,
0.3876878321,
-0.5089259744,
0.557341516,
-0.1222719476,
-0.6586307883,
0.1562663019,
0.4314954281,
-0.3830921948,
0.4981140494,
0.3228987753,
-0.9942571521,
0.5128890276,
-0.7030090094,
-0.6454666853,
0.5242100358,
-0.7074940801,
-0.2665852606,
0.3282651305,
0.4212464392,
0.5053964853,
-0.3351605833,
0.5154892802,
-0.1520660818,
-0.1682702601,
0.525777638,
-0.556807518,
0.4327610731,
0.2039720714,
-0.0887187496,
0.3053649664,
-0.9479081631,
0.136040628,
0.0249266624,
-0.3618462682,
-0.5011785626,
0.0612061359,
0.2561572194,
0.3819829822,
0.1964008212,
-0.6697349548,
-0.0708240569,
-0.6605060697,
0.3276605308,
0.5546746254,
0.3623588681,
0.209440276,
-0.1957502663,
0.352563709,
0.1889970303,
0.2811885476,
-0.5290464163,
-0.2643228769,
-0.1206712201,
-0.447496891,
-0.1081444919,
0.5023651123,
-1.0515781641,
0.1975019872,
-0.2621032,
-0.2171133906,
-0.7359060645,
-0.2452128083,
0.2160532624,
1.1851004362,
0.5047159791,
0.0205015857,
-0.6365315318,
-1.0456471443,
-0.4090303481,
0.1772100627,
-0.3963890076,
0.8509114981,
0.1011873856,
-0.6523373723,
0.9745833874,
-0.7491589785,
-0.2855705619,
-0.1373014003,
-0.1242571399,
0.2345772535,
0.2951602042,
0.5626524687,
-1.0067844391,
-0.3682308793,
0.1964626014,
-0.8106528521,
-0.0528400131,
0.0694307089,
-0.1124109551,
-0.1481402814,
0.2908013463,
-0.2853690088,
0.3409144878,
0.4913568199,
-0.6200903654,
0.4276457727,
-0.1182137057,
0.5640634298,
-1.8056553602,
0.5258596539,
-0.1410191357,
-0.4058738351,
-0.5854354501,
0.0835641026,
0.084115684,
-0.5122802258,
-0.4445776939,
0.7618030906,
-0.1030232608,
0.1157337874,
-0.3580033481,
0.101961948,
0.2746354043,
0.1285085231,
-0.1617757827,
1.0155749321,
0.4109354913,
-0.3683275282,
0.3568909764,
0.3759577572,
-0.4053197503,
1.1847366095,
-0.6445679069,
-0.1525510848,
-0.2886464,
0.005089303,
-0.7332109213,
-0.9372977018,
0.0387481563,
-0.5628496408,
0.2049468011,
0.1326221377,
-0.2911642492,
-0.4629779458,
-0.1141881049,
0.5173060298,
0.1905778646,
-0.6177382469,
0.8495550156,
0.3003990352,
-0.4320424199,
-0.5803539157,
-0.9629955888,
0.2828856409,
-0.054077208,
-0.5561528802,
0.4167774916,
-0.3032051623,
-0.1306427419,
0.0147839496,
0.1290158778,
-0.1797716022,
-0.115194127,
0.235650301,
0.563583374,
-0.2435690463,
0.3978329599,
0.2670914233,
0.0939282179,
0.0343192518,
-0.1285380423,
0.3723571897,
0.2415653914,
-0.6603062749,
-0.3974552751,
0.7661522627,
0.8431519866,
-0.3614955544,
0.6128778458,
0.485168159,
-0.4529728293,
0.1938380897,
-0.7740187049,
-0.7215585709,
-0.4451666176,
0.7134248614,
-0.3010931015,
-1.0846499205,
0.3975197971,
-0.1431398392,
0.1560003906,
0.331469655,
0.6118353605,
0.1210936755,
1.407615304,
0.3583663106,
0.1192464307,
0.2482520938,
0.2266891301,
0.0558435582,
-0.9873815179,
-0.558868587,
-0.2466674745,
-0.1406100988,
-0.3074150085,
-0.1238302961,
0.7621596456,
-0.5210574269,
-0.0690980852,
-0.2634270191,
-0.6868920326,
0.0719047636,
0.387660116,
0.7185667157,
0.2276612371,
0.1902256012,
-0.1695742905,
-0.279199332,
-0.7036949396,
-0.0097167967,
0.9567684531,
0.1843346208,
0.7627901435,
0.1246930435,
0.4190297127,
0.1401099414,
0.6769527793,
-0.886236012,
0.2048267126,
-0.1659686863,
-0.6332271099,
0.0833154395,
-0.6116919518,
-0.7628757358,
0.1937582344,
-0.3376103342,
-0.4247208238,
0.2890914083,
0.1449754685,
-0.7544515729,
-0.0655751377,
-0.6534565091,
0.5674725175,
-0.3329332769,
-0.472878933,
-0.0690656081,
-0.7712272406,
0.163150683,
-0.153920278,
0.0247979648,
0.1599151939,
-0.1041096449,
0.5050256848,
-0.5629063249,
0.5831528902,
-0.1979886591,
0.0868564993,
-0.0571988337,
-0.2293142676,
0.1951342374,
0.2372997105,
-0.023789268,
-0.3931227922,
0.0813346431,
-0.3166537285,
-0.6258716583,
0.9746982455,
-0.3684660494,
-0.3886710107,
-0.2133877873,
-0.6079731584,
-0.7163715363,
0.3835046589,
0.4055975378,
1.0668361187,
-0.0274862312,
0.1582186669,
0.5034856796,
-0.4508402944,
-0.0141115515,
0.8397104144,
-0.1773402691,
-0.6839807034,
0.5011135936,
-0.1570173949,
0.0478510931,
0.2954802215,
0.2594999969,
-0.2014460117,
-0.138572529,
-0.6078462601,
0.1031824425,
-0.7028198242,
-0.5517850518,
-0.5123809576,
-0.1917531192,
-0.2414872497,
-0.0803267285,
0.0206874274,
0.1221354455,
-0.2357747853,
-0.0285785459,
0.5593218207,
0.4708826244,
0.1416925043,
0.1423104256,
-0.9938658476,
0.2740236819,
0.405649066,
0.5016773343,
-0.0765853077,
-0.4218215942,
-0.3751683533,
-0.0000805347,
0.0926596895,
-1.1030448675,
0.3893745542,
0.1114565581,
0.4744227231,
0.5561860204,
0.0210177116,
0.78457129,
-0.9712206721,
0.7561674118,
0.4792962968,
-0.4100790024,
0.7758638859,
-0.0339382105,
0.4524569213,
0.8794722557,
0.0782225281,
-0.4403857291,
-0.1504536122,
-0.2962569296,
-0.9618272781,
0.429166913,
-0.2164621353,
0.1296675652,
-0.1893926859,
0.6064702868,
0.0113184052,
0.2758840621,
-0.2323539257,
-0.2431176454,
0.0082780169,
-0.5400819182,
0.0341699831,
-0.3579209149,
-0.4918262362,
-0.0989522412,
0.4385919869,
-0.366388768,
0.2347958535,
0.7941531539,
0.0080829477,
-0.1759308279,
0.3069271743,
0.5241732001,
0.8969430923,
-0.2808972001,
0.1431306899,
-0.0291668139,
-0.5406274796,
-0.1237168834,
0.421723485,
0.0329922251,
0.2132879794,
0.3311522603,
0.5654255152,
0.239159897,
-1.0101835728,
0.76312989,
-0.2577336729,
0.0842697546,
-0.1268361658,
-0.350558728,
-0.2002166808,
0.2271718681,
0.7006009817,
0.3446909785,
0.6933063269,
-0.2091383338,
0.4661631286,
0.4699716866,
-0.6648286581,
-0.033078637,
0.6140878797,
0.3319432437,
-0.0964363292,
0.3948000371,
0.3648051322,
-0.3173055649,
0.2375869453,
0.6293845773,
0.6406310797,
-0.2742475271,
0.0362388119,
0.3317825198,
-0.18126975,
0.2845287323,
0.3923633099,
0.065039441,
-0.272357583,
-0.9224047065,
-0.3584069014,
-0.2782992125,
0.263682276,
-0.7542780042,
-0.0036694005,
-0.1431245804,
-0.4735965133,
-0.0099776676,
-0.1722591072,
-0.6738632917,
0.372335434,
-0.0480848737,
1.0448863506,
-0.6391623616,
0.4069671631,
1.0664308071,
-0.4025547206,
-0.7809947133,
0.1044971421,
-0.1345923096,
-0.7652828097,
0.4360176921,
0.2779145241,
-0.124240756,
-0.2413027436,
-0.6680074334,
-0.6016619802,
1.0902379751,
0.371899128,
-0.5631990433,
-0.0081823235,
-0.130956322,
0.4937282205,
-0.4076924622,
0.2102976441,
0.2216480821,
0.2378068119,
0.1080873087,
-0.705265224,
0.1597027034,
-0.4390113354,
-0.1172709316,
-0.0223458968,
-0.2076312155,
0.5681623816,
-0.2394648045,
-0.1182278022,
0.197946161,
0.3345945477,
0.5117511749,
0.5086656809,
0.1719980985,
0.466023922,
0.6265766025,
0.1692947894,
1.3301110268,
-0.6173927784,
0.0882588923,
1.1122732162,
-0.2684406638,
0.8338578939,
0.7636594772,
0.1322760433,
0.5889179707,
0.4534448087,
0.3917602003,
0.7301697731,
-0.2830066681,
-0.6066377759,
-0.179252699,
-0.4427422285,
-0.6852878332,
0.0991777703,
0.4417229593,
-0.624546051,
-0.0603996888,
0.4572658539,
0.0165831149,
0.0492343977,
-0.2332666814,
0.9448032975,
0.1282079667,
-0.7680032253,
0.290992111,
-0.0957568064,
0.6340670586,
-0.7429562807,
-0.2012941688,
-0.3136236966,
0.2644307315,
-0.343894124,
-0.7764455676,
0.0427996553,
-0.0080028744,
-0.5145243406,
0.3462696671,
0.8648768067,
-0.4068683386,
-0.5147107244,
0.0766723305,
0.5357397199,
-0.1278517395,
-0.0862137079,
-0.716538012,
-0.1627861112,
-0.0149893118,
-0.1054723263,
0.2527356744,
0.4766074121,
0.3862248957,
0.5498914719,
0.6933946609,
0.2741600871,
-0.4289945364,
0.3312630951,
1.0394550562,
-0.2346730679,
-0.3907747567,
-0.7027337551,
0.6155338883,
-0.492773056,
-0.2629921436,
0.7274036407,
0.551553607,
0.1070264578,
-0.2130014002,
0.7441179156,
0.0998808742,
0.9666823149,
-0.2904440761,
0.7089499235,
-0.9991469383,
0.1096375287,
-0.1085348651,
-0.4342779219,
-0.482486248,
0.4467718899,
-0.1997769922,
-0.0138593027,
0.4179905653,
0.6464110613,
-0.1753920168,
-0.4041613042,
0.3754859567,
0.2353706807,
0.2191411108,
0.4844238162,
0.6297631264,
-0.2124824971,
0.1498388052,
0.0362451933,
-0.4917369485,
-0.5153693557,
-0.5765562057,
-0.7588998675,
-0.4970297813,
0.0078181596,
-0.4640053809,
0.0968934372,
1.1440093517,
0.9117811322,
-0.7951142788,
0.3538094163,
0.1542856842,
-0.4586429,
0.0595519543,
-0.337244004,
0.5401061177,
-0.4053082466,
-0.2931043208,
0.5923762321,
0.5643104315,
-0.1387676746,
-0.3682847321,
-0.0334238335,
0.0458746068,
0.0667117462,
0.8916261196,
-0.0006458133,
-0.6414045095,
-0.057978902,
0.3370946348,
-0.327603966,
0.0350141898,
0.7554118037,
-1.0038064718,
0.7712736726,
0.383058548,
0.8845405579,
-0.0695931688,
0.1558427513,
0.5041117072,
-0.8628584146,
0.1323440522,
0.5370774269,
0.4430421293,
0.5715146661,
-0.6010157466,
0.1030788869,
-0.0064183096,
-0.5535094738,
-0.7065172195,
0.3489192724,
-0.7593202591,
-0.549808383,
0.9503124356,
-0.0177586954,
-0.2190104872,
0.0400724784,
-0.6402775049,
-0.0644608065,
-0.3805784583,
0.5880073309,
0.0278006736,
-0.2058295757,
-0.0042162854,
-0.4931822717,
0.4674895406,
0.5649502873,
-0.9940732718,
-0.2818924785,
0.8093919754,
0.3296054006,
0.1517192572,
0.572679162,
-0.297629267,
0.4142086208,
-0.3962521851,
-0.238240242,
-0.0340945721,
-0.1736940593,
-0.1001169011,
0.2072670609,
0.0320822746,
-0.124118641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08604v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08604v2
|
DevBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Software Development
| 2024-03-13T15:13:44 | 2024-03-15T13:23:34 |
Bowen Li, Wenhan Wu, Ziwei Tang, Lin Shi, John Yang, Jinyang Li, Shunyu Yao, Chen Qian, Binyuan Hui, Qicheng Zhang, Zhiyin Yu, He Du, Ping Yang, Dahua Lin, Chao Peng, Kai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced their coding capabilities. However, existing benchmarks predominantly
focused on simplified or isolated aspects of programming, such as single-file
code generation or repository issue debugging, falling short of measuring the
full spectrum of challenges raised by real-world programming activities. To
this end, we propose DevBench, a comprehensive benchmark that evaluates LLMs
across various stages of the software development lifecycle, including software
design, environment setup, implementation, acceptance testing, and unit
testing. DevBench features a wide range of programming languages and domains,
high-quality data collection, and carefully designed and verified metrics for
each task. Empirical studies show that current LLMs, including GPT-4-Turbo,
fail to solve the challenges presented within DevBench. Analyses reveal that
models struggle with understanding the complex structures in the repository,
managing the compilation process, and grasping advanced programming concepts.
Our findings offer actionable insights for the future development of LLMs
toward real-world programming applications. Our benchmark is available at
https://github.com/open-compass/DevBench
|
[
-0.5216966271,
-0.3780939579,
0.4063968062,
0.3671310544,
-0.1023174897,
0.530045867,
-0.3068606853,
-0.4561322629,
-0.1674792022,
0.3513155878,
-0.6026154757,
-0.7312836051,
-0.208203733,
0.0488774702,
-0.593316257,
0.6788644195,
-0.1558180153,
-0.0616892837,
-0.2296904474,
0.0019189072,
-0.6250666976,
-0.3122778237,
-0.2942354679,
-0.1215319932,
0.2117843032,
0.4151954651,
0.5304971933,
0.6184777021,
0.7256985307,
0.2389010191,
0.1041648909,
-0.4532740116,
-0.4859731197,
0.4838267267,
-0.0489953645,
-0.3130939901,
-0.5550975204,
0.0601522923,
0.4440625608,
0.7189357877,
-0.1882231832,
0.643432796,
-0.0282366872,
0.6837601066,
-0.6495822668,
0.1341878474,
-0.3515453637,
0.1632889509,
-0.460267812,
0.2786653042,
-0.0725085512,
-0.746991396,
-0.272847563,
-0.2210931331,
0.2998172045,
-0.1443075985,
0.6127031446,
0.3069986105,
-0.2123113126,
-0.091060169,
-0.6570736766,
0.6886802316,
-0.7388291955,
0.6567122936,
-0.0559222624,
0.4829619527,
-0.3231852949,
-0.7675442696,
-0.3322689235,
-0.3346512914,
0.4154395163,
-0.0154280411,
0.121037133,
-0.0993108079,
0.4107976258,
0.5806941986,
-0.7623080015,
0.0201237202,
-0.4201259017,
-0.2210557759,
0.4338385463,
0.2609681785,
0.327244103,
0.0517248064,
-0.1960879862,
-0.0674878135,
-0.9116696715,
-0.1519649625,
0.3823502958,
0.202357471,
-0.1789327711,
0.4092757404,
-0.0309520196,
0.7943432927,
-0.5008323789,
0.1202074811,
0.3245846927,
-0.4345557392,
0.0525909029,
-0.3361827731,
0.4298366904,
0.3660595119,
0.282014221,
-0.4490765631,
-0.3242079914,
0.4397795796,
0.4131785929,
-0.8540729284,
-0.3085588515,
0.5001769662,
-0.2073836178,
-0.4704228044,
-0.1779038161,
-0.9370772839,
-0.7774176002,
-0.0647511184,
-0.2727466822,
0.0404568166,
-0.5875263214,
-0.1812662035,
-0.141202867,
0.6287474632,
0.0797002837,
-0.4640935957,
0.4350810945,
1.0984122753,
0.934648335,
-0.3881584406,
-0.3229921758,
-0.5338764787,
-0.0367238335,
-0.5943074226,
0.8778693676,
-0.3828997314,
-0.5565737486,
-0.2294519544,
-0.2147454917,
0.5206333995,
-0.8710603118,
0.2787303925,
-0.3613079488,
-0.4816631079,
-0.0824429691,
-0.5033263564,
0.223605305,
0.6368831396,
-0.6969953775,
1.1219459772,
0.5011324883,
-0.4021863043,
0.3897561133,
-0.2689339519,
-0.2214007825,
0.1520762295,
-0.3799413443,
-0.3651842177,
0.3383939266,
-0.3735030293,
0.0307426434,
-0.7747879028,
0.4879115522,
-0.6890562177,
-0.5346526504,
0.1363673359,
0.0265034884,
0.5125267506,
0.2303964496,
-0.4412309527,
0.1430422664,
-0.9161131382,
0.4489603043,
0.0226472467,
-0.4867867529,
0.2177067846,
-0.000999404,
0.0091864159,
0.2897258699,
0.1625272036,
-0.6917780042,
0.2877068818,
-0.0829382241,
0.5009083152,
0.7238370776,
-0.2018710524,
0.1966724396,
-0.0064150449,
0.9386410713,
-0.2428840101,
0.174985677,
-0.0737797543,
-0.2773502469,
-0.5555803776,
-0.1116086915,
0.5881160498,
0.4590214789,
0.0160936471,
0.2581872642,
-0.2359133512,
-0.7054108977,
-0.4947022498,
0.5121954679,
0.4714685678,
0.335418731,
0.1181652918,
-0.6690812707,
-0.542758584,
-0.7882676721,
-0.3651028275,
-0.2306665629,
-0.1718215793,
0.1074099764,
0.3412381113,
-0.2163261771,
0.8339473605,
-0.4337393343,
-0.0693370402,
-0.4299224615,
0.0592723005,
0.1734432131,
0.4004636705,
0.4699385762,
-0.6097913384,
-0.2715657055,
-0.1500053555,
-0.6802070737,
-0.3753791451,
0.1531659067,
-0.0518059358,
-0.0418804139,
0.6316102743,
-0.4296190739,
0.2916929722,
0.7855197787,
-0.233287245,
0.6720740199,
0.0181123205,
-0.1347600967,
-0.5073680878,
0.3205764294,
-0.3483274579,
-0.1367824376,
-0.2400233001,
0.3517655432,
0.4529431164,
-0.5154688358,
-0.2530726492,
0.4932148755,
-0.5411099792,
-0.7612754107,
-0.0588678159,
0.3472814858,
0.1730813235,
0.0554215759,
-0.4236686528,
1.0479962826,
0.4271060526,
-0.351391077,
0.6093182564,
-0.1035433859,
-0.5647657514,
0.4306352139,
-0.8415259123,
0.294388026,
0.2179954648,
0.1925093979,
-0.8708797097,
-0.1133118495,
-0.3193348348,
-0.2484570742,
0.0844470114,
-0.185296908,
-0.7378234267,
-0.7091923356,
-0.4769293666,
0.1842939258,
0.5785697103,
-0.2941066623,
0.4395116568,
0.3769592345,
-0.2637248635,
-0.3898308277,
-0.7316616178,
0.2148898095,
-0.0432220139,
-0.5809684396,
0.3099156618,
-0.1686149389,
-0.3630722463,
-0.0424390323,
-0.4227018654,
-0.1504808813,
0.4961079359,
0.3555827439,
0.1751297712,
-0.3170399368,
0.15523085,
-0.4271728098,
-0.3929943442,
0.1869198829,
0.0075678532,
0.4651919007,
-0.2769964933,
-0.490474999,
0.1195588261,
0.1142662913,
0.6100857854,
-0.4936527312,
0.293027252,
0.2588996291,
-0.0932430774,
-0.3949347734,
-0.6027979851,
-0.0484404191,
-0.4291163087,
0.3410424888,
-0.6183912754,
-0.569922924,
0.7671903372,
-0.5490721464,
0.2829118967,
0.0641978234,
0.3449027836,
0.3146219552,
0.8502211571,
0.7850494981,
-0.1435533613,
0.2788046896,
-0.1273765564,
0.3027768433,
-0.7795737386,
-0.0203359444,
-0.6854847074,
-0.3273380697,
-0.4303041399,
-0.4594507217,
0.1762191057,
0.4877927303,
-0.6060694456,
0.3434968293,
-0.4891514182,
0.7431055903,
0.1995030046,
-0.3909658194,
0.4475927949,
-0.4913004637,
-0.2285870463,
-0.0443946235,
-0.3549388051,
-0.4674942195,
1.1548321247,
0.3016862869,
0.7994484305,
0.3195846379,
0.7203822136,
0.2812247872,
0.6562237144,
-0.4134987891,
0.5526852608,
0.0718352124,
-0.7621740103,
0.0347896479,
-0.3457846344,
-0.6836816669,
0.3158259988,
0.3203270137,
-0.522158742,
-0.0770400092,
0.0859600604,
-0.277207762,
0.1853827536,
-0.7459731102,
1.4041935205,
-0.522881031,
-0.5433297157,
-0.2346697748,
-0.3550152481,
0.343557179,
-0.263428539,
0.3849872053,
-0.5411945581,
-0.3089689612,
0.3558194041,
-0.3967114687,
0.5562298298,
-0.2312834561,
-0.1835818142,
0.306088239,
0.5355380774,
0.4167754054,
0.0717914179,
-0.4430171847,
0.0559499599,
-0.0533061326,
-0.4042605162,
-0.3748951852,
0.9522747397,
-0.557045877,
-0.4696453512,
-0.3904983401,
-0.2598564327,
-0.4001489282,
0.2914369106,
-0.1792504042,
0.3920282423,
-0.5482062101,
0.028853137,
0.262770921,
-0.4141919613,
0.2878213525,
0.7716563344,
-0.6137616634,
-0.154222697,
0.7246440053,
-0.1194244921,
0.2741839886,
-0.3585838377,
-0.1243421957,
-0.0073089469,
-0.7928834558,
-0.5690226555,
0.0128891701,
-0.8075935245,
-0.4536543787,
-0.3239625394,
-0.0285178497,
-0.1835113168,
-0.2282711118,
-0.7291587591,
-0.2249640524,
0.1909982413,
-0.1491242051,
0.2424090654,
1.0044925213,
0.1738370806,
-0.1885270029,
-0.9590670466,
0.3655460179,
-0.0400389954,
0.8888879418,
-0.0430540293,
-0.1834174991,
0.0223462395,
-0.3929088116,
-0.5441588163,
-0.5675041676,
0.1032593697,
-0.0320561305,
0.5295250416,
-0.1055906266,
0.0284061041,
0.5630092025,
-0.2985518575,
0.8447711468,
-0.1518443972,
-0.9646744728,
0.6709264517,
-0.3317247927,
0.5918807387,
0.8635078669,
-0.0911242589,
-0.461535871,
-0.4875268638,
-0.3934367597,
-0.8716296554,
0.3541449904,
-0.085953787,
-0.0228935517,
0.0898442119,
0.2487999052,
0.1411791742,
0.328238219,
-0.6548432708,
0.065031305,
0.0925771445,
-0.0183649752,
0.0408387668,
-0.033811532,
0.033439137,
-0.1768390834,
0.2001850158,
-0.1239552572,
-0.0344965458,
-0.3214606047,
-0.297559768,
-0.082610108,
0.4246895611,
0.4753464162,
1.0347112417,
-0.3184303641,
0.1524204314,
0.1187888458,
-0.4160699248,
0.2144347578,
0.1042649224,
0.1593688577,
-0.2804347575,
0.3825515509,
0.3316432536,
0.3123116791,
-0.9931656718,
0.5384238362,
-0.0851088613,
0.1561342776,
-0.3959825337,
0.1602226347,
0.4204549193,
0.2262305468,
0.0937244073,
-0.1453143954,
0.0794071108,
-0.60062778,
0.0528796837,
0.2645608783,
-0.2723471224,
-0.3691110313,
0.6807987094,
0.4946920574,
-0.1362567395,
0.8650364876,
-0.3562363684,
-0.3797911406,
1.0317440033,
0.4577752352,
1.0863016844,
-0.0337322243,
0.0810954794,
0.3311909437,
0.2454042435,
-0.0591435507,
0.6405057311,
-0.0434331223,
-0.2976000309,
-0.4060666859,
-0.7659668326,
-0.7304110527,
-0.0920485184,
-0.3687642813,
0.2902611494,
-0.5974527001,
-0.1416919678,
-0.031480141,
0.0295769852,
-0.6616098881,
-0.2181564122,
0.2857301533,
1.1682792902,
-0.5185604095,
0.7947520614,
0.6773739457,
-0.2793824971,
-0.5483446717,
-0.1852912456,
0.2535213232,
-0.5314201713,
0.7065770626,
0.3038976789,
-0.2105343938,
0.0088235522,
-0.2875416577,
-0.8769410849,
0.9658237696,
0.4558999538,
-0.735999465,
0.1569631696,
0.2059898823,
0.6250306368,
-0.3200716078,
0.30726403,
0.8368791342,
0.6145133972,
-0.3211376965,
-0.9167032838,
0.0195039082,
-0.3433562815,
0.2841333449,
0.5324341655,
-0.5946401954,
1.0397258997,
-0.3699421585,
-0.2275957018,
0.1155420095,
0.1435392946,
0.3180089891,
0.0171843134,
0.3096092045,
0.4857396185,
0.5557083488,
-0.3499391079,
1.2248506546,
-0.7990077138,
0.250492543,
0.9718723893,
-0.7613931894,
0.9182173014,
0.2042528838,
-0.5095316172,
0.5838142037,
0.6560409665,
-0.2075852156,
0.2796855271,
0.8737509847,
-0.0753847584,
-0.0891822651,
0.003103462,
-0.624351263,
0.2130465358,
0.2121028155,
0.0312942564,
-0.436501652,
-0.1384909004,
-0.0906579494,
-0.0776232257,
-0.1280556768,
0.5701693892,
0.1849443465,
-0.6687514782,
0.6813319921,
-0.1592419297,
0.4734196961,
-0.6333054304,
0.0103912195,
-0.5613543987,
0.7028949857,
-0.0959720835,
-0.9863989949,
0.257663548,
0.2920663953,
0.0284472052,
-0.1624636799,
0.5087381601,
0.0271633416,
-0.3076919615,
0.6280453801,
0.6300880909,
0.1729101688,
-0.1371086836,
-0.7079610229,
0.7703755498,
-0.2339464575,
-0.4315045774,
0.4059380591,
0.3603566587,
0.0390451923,
0.8283239603,
0.3408790827,
0.1826127023,
0.0226637721,
0.2873846591,
1.0308754444,
-1.0358005762,
-0.3163838089,
-0.7567404509,
0.2504571378,
-0.1227404475,
-0.4446972907,
0.7205187678,
0.7991043925,
0.7914038301,
0.0582020544,
0.7652919888,
-0.2262749225,
0.573421061,
0.0132407118,
0.4154890478,
-0.3386620283,
0.4818253815,
-0.277281642,
-1.250838995,
-0.458250165,
0.2222457677,
-0.1471215039,
0.2060391158,
0.5926731825,
0.8291863203,
0.0129223466,
0.0290694907,
0.1849096417,
0.0947393328,
0.4224924147,
0.5288731456,
0.9172785878,
-0.101045765,
0.7486966252,
-0.2291318625,
-0.2314522117,
-0.0825847462,
-0.9660868645,
-0.7173182964,
-0.0850299969,
-0.3908260763,
-0.2805419862,
0.11591167,
0.4734824896,
0.5340320468,
-0.8459354639,
-0.479016155,
-0.4794826806,
0.0391098075,
-0.3266301751,
-0.1787905544,
-0.1430812776,
-0.5155329108,
-0.2157528102,
0.3955083787,
0.3771118522,
-0.0557034276,
-0.8014469743,
-0.0268870108,
0.2003751546,
-0.2901747227,
0.3103739917,
0.4182945192,
-0.4434627593,
-0.0478759781,
0.075172849,
-0.4321238697,
0.063760221,
1.0466413498,
-0.8567985296,
0.4024509192,
0.5076363087,
0.6205112934,
0.5159090757,
0.0035439634,
0.8402300477,
-0.6098182201,
0.0713435709,
0.2896519601,
0.0840449706,
0.4727631211,
0.0765683725,
1.0113941431,
-0.1197386533,
-0.636248827,
-1.1376093626,
0.254211247,
-0.5010079145,
-0.2795672119,
0.7465953231,
-0.2184420526,
-0.0341256596,
-0.2459863573,
0.1072629467,
-0.1340118349,
-0.1707362831,
0.5406114459,
0.8323004842,
-0.1086738855,
-0.2089248747,
-1.0076761246,
0.4084364474,
0.318815738,
-1.0279620886,
0.5860364437,
0.5662372708,
0.4277267456,
0.0329761058,
0.5987821817,
-0.2687096,
0.3303857446,
0.3383402526,
0.5629308224,
0.0363744386,
-0.1817305237,
-0.2762267888,
0.2489474565,
0.603286624,
0.1675303876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08593v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08593v2
|
Call Me When Necessary: LLMs can Efficiently and Faithfully Reason over Structured Environments
| 2024-03-13T14:59:07 | 2024-07-03T15:23:59 |
Sitao Cheng, Ziyuan Zhuang, Yong Xu, Fangkai Yang, Chaoyun Zhang, Xiaoting Qin, Xiang Huang, Ling Chen, Qingwei Lin, Dongmei Zhang, Saravan Rajmohan, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown potential in reasoning over
structured environments, e.g., knowledge graph and table. Such tasks typically
require multi-hop reasoning, i.e., match natural language utterance with
instances in the environment. Previous methods leverage LLMs to incrementally
build a reasoning path, where the LLMs either invoke tools or pick up schemas
by step-by-step interacting with the environment. We propose
Reasoning-Path-Editing (Readi), a novel framework where LLMs can efficiently
and faithfully reason over structured environments. In Readi, LLMs initially
generate a reasoning path given a query, and edit the path only when necessary.
We instantiate the path on structured environments and provide feedback to edit
the path if anything goes wrong. Experimental results on three KGQA and two
TableQA datasets show the effectiveness of Readi, significantly surpassing
previous LLM-based methods (by 9.1% Hit@1 on WebQSP, 12.4% on MQA-3H and 9.5%
on WTQ), comparable with state-of-the-art fine-tuned methods (67% on CWQ and
74.7% on WebQSP) and substantially boosting the vanilla LLMs (by 14.9% on CWQ).
Our code will be available on https://aka.ms/readi.
|
[
-0.0958015025,
-0.837013483,
0.9973279238,
0.4599729478,
-0.0637388751,
0.0000956212,
-0.190706268,
-0.5432040095,
-0.17003268,
0.4896833897,
-0.7778276801,
-0.6870846152,
-0.1078911796,
0.2168886214,
-0.1665363908,
0.3787582517,
-0.1901429147,
-0.0475360602,
-0.4312949777,
-0.1062623933,
-0.2738372386,
-0.227700457,
-0.4507268071,
-0.3756201863,
0.7378456593,
0.4281866848,
0.7555928826,
0.9049779177,
0.3239037693,
0.3925397694,
-0.3289875686,
0.7441340089,
-0.165701285,
0.6986094117,
-0.4353819191,
-0.3871373832,
-0.6507617831,
-0.0569129772,
0.5862627625,
0.7309075594,
-0.1410350502,
-0.0748696998,
0.0306925625,
0.5121121407,
-0.5832009315,
0.0379441231,
-0.7293492556,
0.0414087027,
-0.1739355326,
-0.4747011364,
-0.5571602583,
-0.4516747296,
-0.1194524467,
-0.8022610545,
-0.2487405092,
0.2542317212,
0.5666899681,
0.3697593808,
-0.5314602852,
-0.2593988478,
-0.7330258489,
0.6207996011,
-0.8073515892,
0.6553871632,
0.188132748,
0.2116511911,
-0.5832804441,
-0.7979639769,
-0.5659492016,
-0.1912671179,
-0.156668514,
0.0204007905,
-0.0802050531,
0.1121878624,
0.5061798692,
0.0117836017,
-0.3470252156,
-0.03157131,
-0.0927706584,
-0.060278479,
0.4692582786,
0.3336714208,
0.2485098988,
-0.1697698236,
-0.1397069097,
0.2114039809,
-0.928599298,
0.0585579276,
0.2562032342,
0.3002886176,
0.3748054206,
0.6982724071,
-0.395457536,
1.0349180698,
-0.2666420341,
-0.377577424,
-0.046694383,
-0.4950435162,
-0.1086450145,
-0.0558702461,
0.641005218,
0.3165294528,
0.3050215542,
-0.3453549743,
-0.2008385807,
-0.101363197,
0.2880871892,
-0.7940957546,
-0.2489248961,
0.5034572482,
-0.1693986952,
-0.1377983391,
-0.2499655485,
-0.3794516027,
-0.4950576723,
-0.5186184645,
0.1016328782,
-0.655363977,
0.0729202777,
0.099270612,
-0.0849664211,
0.3512620628,
0.7971329093,
-0.4063930809,
0.0862961784,
0.7957412601,
1.046402812,
0.0847225413,
-0.2579206824,
-0.7349091768,
0.4756197929,
-0.4907847643,
1.0993903875,
-0.5981073976,
-0.3400425315,
-0.1105251908,
-0.1190848798,
-0.0280756559,
-0.4101783633,
0.7795321345,
-0.4929138124,
-0.025037799,
-0.1345209628,
-0.6181312799,
0.1951998025,
0.6580191255,
-0.3244771063,
0.8808065057,
-0.1306264848,
-0.6819648743,
0.3957494795,
-0.831322968,
-0.7407224178,
-0.0951458737,
0.280790031,
-0.1549093872,
-0.3070167303,
0.4400448799,
0.1901246309,
0.2520604134,
0.2114889324,
-0.5508031845,
-0.4046935439,
0.1770231128,
-0.1979460418,
0.830062151,
0.1725392491,
-0.2192320824,
0.3376274407,
-0.7769704461,
0.5203482509,
-0.0580742434,
-0.6588589549,
-0.4448255002,
0.4198528528,
-0.2368463576,
0.400257051,
0.0477693677,
-0.7254410982,
0.5457915068,
-0.5238540769,
0.7876561284,
0.8939817548,
-0.0983066037,
0.3867537975,
-0.3217750192,
0.4662760496,
-0.1414388418,
0.1736609787,
-0.2323935032,
-0.2584808469,
-0.8044671416,
-0.3281771839,
0.069718048,
0.8452878594,
-0.6686966419,
0.3204419017,
-0.2982575595,
-0.6875048876,
-0.4431812763,
0.1246546134,
0.1938344836,
0.6311961412,
0.5424229503,
0.5898245573,
-0.5722811222,
-0.5587645173,
-0.6606737971,
-0.2321570665,
-0.1633355469,
0.6271808147,
0.3212936819,
-0.4128965139,
1.0625371933,
-0.3924459815,
-0.0663012043,
-0.1395336986,
-0.3462340832,
0.3236555159,
0.3492409587,
-0.0586840063,
-0.5127373338,
-0.2807230353,
-0.0825751126,
-0.8322111964,
-0.5816487074,
-0.200716123,
-0.5491047502,
0.0410515629,
0.7500464916,
-0.8052200079,
0.1878490746,
0.149551779,
-0.5932252407,
0.5330955982,
-0.2276351005,
0.1580055654,
-0.9814990759,
-0.0083155278,
-0.0518469885,
-0.6225160956,
-0.2233127654,
0.176401794,
-0.1151464656,
0.1525476426,
-0.3431981802,
0.5750965476,
-0.544783473,
-0.0481261909,
0.0037977742,
0.4006983638,
0.288739711,
0.2887585461,
0.0391918384,
0.6418486238,
0.4767904878,
-0.728974402,
0.4273778498,
0.556546092,
-0.4111523628,
0.5841298699,
-0.756601274,
0.4009927809,
0.1487691253,
0.6450160742,
-0.6396172047,
-0.0267470237,
0.353233546,
-0.0754728019,
-0.0847209841,
-0.313587606,
-0.5433460474,
-0.0968180299,
-0.1603249609,
0.0468289517,
0.0616583675,
-0.8524833322,
0.9823542237,
0.0555501617,
-0.0433860049,
-0.3692058027,
-0.6532466412,
0.3984544277,
-0.1703347713,
-1.0083690882,
0.5288237333,
-0.3086914122,
-0.6429047585,
-0.0181542765,
-0.1584142447,
0.0844891369,
0.1922311038,
0.4912403822,
0.2278361917,
-0.1318505257,
0.0383565836,
0.0734946728,
-0.1195845082,
0.1179748774,
-0.4908863306,
0.1907496005,
-0.3558644056,
-0.5032635331,
-0.1668682098,
0.404981941,
0.5564692616,
-0.3512160778,
0.5891501307,
0.2098376602,
-0.3778090477,
-0.4740911126,
-0.2828919888,
-0.042096138,
-0.5257794857,
0.050340917,
-0.5674183369,
-1.0465643406,
0.1522643864,
-0.4905484021,
0.4476364553,
0.0588908978,
0.3040005565,
-0.4663691223,
1.0076568127,
0.1728725731,
0.3313195705,
0.2459377646,
-0.0472257733,
0.4041110277,
-0.8774308562,
-0.4347223043,
-0.5744267702,
-0.3527258635,
-0.5041382313,
-0.4948011935,
0.5771310925,
0.2134387642,
-0.2935635448,
0.0999842361,
-0.3605731428,
0.568606019,
0.4728824198,
0.2000277787,
0.6657702327,
-0.3368287981,
-0.327683419,
0.0283737741,
-0.6560778022,
-0.6483562589,
0.5862340331,
0.1308797598,
0.7194096446,
0.2430872768,
0.636905551,
0.3019369543,
0.3530550599,
-0.8371739388,
0.7827339172,
0.2968289256,
-0.2234964222,
-0.4082871675,
-0.6214082241,
-0.7870734334,
0.5027979612,
-0.3240229189,
-0.6141825914,
0.0436234996,
0.359490484,
-0.1931894422,
0.4379268885,
-0.5584689975,
0.7760585546,
-0.2844179273,
-0.4873940349,
-0.1363663524,
-0.5479007959,
0.2967126667,
0.219025746,
0.3894036114,
-0.0134463198,
-0.1185124069,
0.2003209442,
-0.8807718754,
0.5179958344,
-0.1093170196,
-0.1387229115,
0.3022335768,
0.3859716952,
0.7692306042,
0.2448067665,
-0.2932495475,
0.0683575049,
0.2337112725,
-0.2194803804,
-0.9197144508,
0.579366684,
-0.2986505926,
-0.8119121194,
-0.4643968046,
-0.5384123921,
-0.5809626579,
0.2095365971,
-0.0797295421,
0.5116590858,
-0.066418916,
-0.0270085465,
0.5228245854,
0.017324036,
0.3350901604,
0.6546366811,
-0.4053840339,
-0.1224696636,
0.5710855126,
-0.0127921393,
0.0962260514,
0.276542455,
0.3672964871,
-0.3240671456,
-0.6080445647,
-0.515494585,
0.0118941814,
-0.7460449934,
-0.225836724,
-0.905147016,
-0.149092406,
-0.1338613182,
-0.2796375155,
-0.1400883049,
-0.3897727728,
0.0255658291,
-0.1441373825,
0.498940438,
0.6273859739,
-0.1314482391,
-0.0162451733,
-0.9736459851,
0.0840675011,
0.2968586981,
0.4166835546,
-0.3011634052,
-0.3733358383,
0.0369284935,
0.0028431609,
-0.1254949123,
-0.8586443663,
0.3097540736,
0.3900957108,
0.4294385314,
0.0781724751,
0.1298378259,
0.9235540628,
-0.6786491275,
0.3904542327,
-0.4222085178,
-1.0825303793,
0.8811383843,
-0.5250480175,
0.4610210359,
0.4860753119,
-0.0128136761,
-0.713644743,
-0.6337765455,
-0.2841734886,
-0.911462903,
0.5323720574,
0.1503835171,
-0.1266810447,
0.0186249167,
0.5765091181,
-0.2370355725,
-0.0794762596,
-0.6448169947,
0.1551643461,
-0.0435427576,
0.0755571947,
0.4756729603,
-0.1517412812,
-0.0577177182,
-0.4268299341,
0.8441336155,
-0.3731460869,
-0.0009165618,
0.5553132892,
-0.1674813479,
-0.0498226993,
0.6192048788,
0.1887344271,
1.0235335827,
-0.1623300761,
0.3403836191,
0.2849950492,
-0.1358525008,
0.1070980951,
0.0948359594,
-0.275203228,
-0.2188341767,
0.6205149293,
0.5184560418,
0.0769821033,
-0.9219850898,
0.2097883672,
-0.0802674443,
-0.1063113064,
-0.1801233888,
0.337210238,
0.3412517905,
0.5602977276,
-0.236431241,
0.2601577342,
0.1482288986,
-0.4321457446,
0.1753281355,
0.2934977412,
-0.2532675564,
-0.0049850941,
0.477791667,
0.2236375809,
-0.507171452,
1.0344389677,
-0.1998420358,
-0.5608372092,
0.2750461996,
0.668826282,
0.4962312877,
0.0011631914,
0.1439195871,
0.3373409808,
0.3415181935,
0.0841736794,
0.3017523885,
-0.056615252,
-0.9384448528,
-0.5954743624,
-0.65323174,
-0.6338295937,
-0.0634511039,
-0.1670345217,
0.0318636261,
-0.5191535354,
0.0967890322,
-0.0517092794,
-0.3405653536,
-0.3173313141,
0.1056815833,
-0.0257736705,
1.2348583937,
-0.4830322266,
0.6994579434,
0.8589932323,
0.0377320983,
-0.8942910433,
0.0049143359,
0.0702880919,
-0.3086425662,
0.304502964,
0.181773439,
-0.4650792181,
-0.0774234757,
-0.7529631853,
-0.7332274318,
1.1450529099,
0.4866328537,
-0.6868859529,
0.0970827937,
-0.1369213015,
0.4625636935,
-0.221992746,
0.1530572176,
0.5737674236,
0.7656300068,
0.1895535886,
-0.4888570905,
0.1223048791,
-0.4095038176,
-0.2245647758,
0.2212453485,
-0.4658418298,
0.4261186123,
-0.5015879273,
-0.16247572,
-0.0625304654,
0.6663585305,
0.7058730125,
0.1513239443,
0.8838790655,
0.6316315532,
1.0014646053,
-0.0952802747,
1.0363537073,
-0.1800156832,
-0.0812089145,
1.2075904608,
-0.451710552,
0.7856835127,
0.3862783015,
-0.1958688796,
0.7538362741,
0.83267802,
0.2982103825,
0.2242182642,
0.2591735125,
-0.3148508668,
-0.8734945059,
-0.1884483844,
0.0468583182,
0.4095558524,
0.2829376757,
0.0566740036,
-0.1946796328,
-0.3010226488,
0.2584724724,
0.2242756188,
-0.2292766273,
0.514180541,
0.14256531,
-0.7924663424,
0.170951128,
0.1617084891,
0.3454537094,
-0.6888530254,
-0.37296018,
-0.1742665619,
0.202443108,
-0.4098452628,
-0.9415688515,
0.6101189852,
0.1377650946,
-0.1244839728,
-0.6169483662,
0.8820281029,
-0.4053083956,
-0.4281413853,
0.4052991569,
0.711853683,
-0.0845249891,
-0.1614539325,
-0.6778562665,
-0.1579428464,
-0.1128205582,
-0.4439182281,
0.0917167813,
0.6217217445,
-0.1993900836,
1.0700173378,
1.0246473551,
0.0416598096,
-0.0599484779,
0.185544014,
0.8775135875,
-0.6873794198,
-0.5755122304,
-1.0268564224,
0.4922371507,
-0.1963181794,
-0.2267247289,
0.6483539939,
0.6044382453,
0.4537196457,
0.2752701938,
0.6160930991,
0.0216039438,
0.4230040014,
-0.8716027141,
0.512673676,
-0.4875894785,
0.3514005244,
-0.1458589137,
-0.9655352235,
-0.354457289,
0.6281262636,
-0.2164445668,
0.0471518412,
0.6968775988,
0.9077506661,
0.0900245681,
0.0221208204,
0.0483831838,
0.4743800461,
0.5016810298,
0.4218817055,
1.1183135509,
0.1865879297,
0.6255763173,
0.1277434081,
-0.1443171799,
0.3200797439,
-1.2240180969,
-0.636477232,
-0.1138350666,
-0.4149347246,
-0.6656848788,
0.2088938504,
0.8475603461,
0.6915886402,
-0.4888047278,
0.0979966298,
-0.2550386488,
0.595682621,
-0.3298658431,
-0.2247523665,
0.2362573892,
-0.3085143566,
-0.4617722929,
1.039473176,
0.638153255,
-0.434168458,
-0.2480967343,
-0.1006574854,
-0.4572899044,
0.341730535,
0.6180881858,
0.0665060878,
-0.7453042269,
-0.4252103865,
0.084627822,
-0.2177928537,
0.2493036538,
0.8890237212,
-0.8469848633,
0.4211467206,
0.5180168152,
0.4773081243,
0.3605169356,
0.0863714293,
0.6022014022,
-0.6238959432,
-0.2738138437,
0.2469516397,
0.6440138817,
0.5050799847,
-0.4753229022,
0.7206726074,
0.2917384207,
-0.6693763733,
-0.5501410961,
0.3275484741,
-1.0792027712,
-0.3183806241,
1.4402632713,
-0.2989135385,
-0.403632015,
-0.2551298141,
-0.2524139285,
-0.0221909676,
-0.1835677922,
0.4526509941,
0.5325989723,
-0.2938448489,
-0.1606519669,
-0.2560088038,
0.4879696667,
0.0689788759,
-1.2723177671,
0.2109786421,
0.8708325028,
0.3896537423,
-0.0154915564,
0.7127051353,
-0.0411030315,
-0.0603059158,
-0.1482266337,
-0.1990374923,
-0.4992981553,
-0.332405448,
0.0756794438,
0.0491250381,
0.003056387,
0.1052946299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08564v1
|
Non-discrimination Criteria for Generative Language Models
| 2024-03-13T14:19:08 | 2024-03-13T14:19:08 |
Sara Sterlie, Nina Weng, Aasa Feragen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Within recent years, generative AI, such as large language models, has
undergone rapid development. As these models become increasingly available to
the public, concerns arise about perpetuating and amplifying harmful biases in
applications. Gender stereotypes can be harmful and limiting for the
individuals they target, whether they consist of misrepresentation or
discrimination. Recognizing gender bias as a pervasive societal construct, this
paper studies how to uncover and quantify the presence of gender biases in
generative language models. In particular, we derive generative AI analogues of
three well-known non-discrimination criteria from classification, namely
independence, separation and sufficiency. To demonstrate these criteria in
action, we design prompts for each of the criteria with a focus on occupational
gender stereotype, specifically utilizing the medical test to introduce the
ground truth in the generative AI context. Our results address the presence of
occupational gender bias within such conversational language models.
|
[
-0.1863820255,
-0.7185100913,
0.575368762,
0.2826659381,
0.1966800243,
-0.2013506144,
0.0779169351,
-0.3942395151,
-0.1562672853,
0.4727623463,
-0.3694141507,
-0.5062438846,
-0.751958549,
0.3937811255,
-0.6418539882,
0.7750566602,
0.1434285343,
0.1406645328,
-0.7489177585,
-0.2758133709,
-0.571578145,
-0.6591340899,
-0.2389341742,
-0.1780635566,
0.0652008727,
0.0889326781,
0.5716042519,
0.357016921,
0.1284490675,
0.279237628,
-0.1626835465,
-0.1274783313,
-0.1658841819,
0.3530274928,
0.0739508197,
-0.8244929314,
-0.1011795402,
0.3968150318,
0.3933143616,
0.8837074637,
-0.1338320673,
0.1622654498,
-0.0490237661,
0.6237843633,
-0.6429965496,
0.3610993326,
-0.4838957191,
0.2154941112,
-0.4001725316,
0.1919660121,
-0.4910754561,
-0.5778980255,
0.0757623762,
-0.2659981847,
0.7314838171,
0.0508922972,
0.7913998365,
0.1757752001,
-0.4149558842,
-0.2039105892,
-0.6442821026,
0.8209522963,
-0.4718573689,
0.6213098764,
0.8443055153,
0.2477708608,
0.1583755016,
-0.0739597902,
-0.4801538289,
-0.6880294681,
-0.1412167996,
-0.0265286788,
-0.3501268029,
0.1745368987,
0.3785859346,
0.3555265367,
-0.3713374734,
0.2057640553,
-0.4847046733,
0.064938508,
0.3903633356,
-0.0604306012,
0.8195127845,
-0.1205009967,
0.0264860429,
0.2107578367,
-0.8335599899,
-0.5201276541,
0.7004048824,
0.1856883615,
-0.4589574337,
0.662337184,
0.028841259,
0.5046372414,
0.0562495291,
-0.0141836395,
0.3929289877,
-0.0083430316,
-0.0157280061,
-0.0365956128,
0.5661633015,
0.3499117196,
0.2070541382,
-0.328635335,
-0.1519190222,
0.4009900093,
0.3153080642,
-0.4345906675,
0.0701170415,
0.0766510591,
-0.6911349297,
-0.3985446095,
-0.3431777954,
-0.7936172485,
-0.5992450714,
-0.0033203957,
-0.1154194474,
-0.2541912496,
-0.435249418,
-0.3057942092,
-0.4925745726,
0.1523979455,
0.0501134433,
-1.187731266,
-0.0458156765,
0.5257678628,
0.7548697591,
0.0632046163,
0.0702969283,
-0.2228673846,
-0.1515958607,
-0.5948126316,
0.6012415886,
-0.716935575,
-0.6276109815,
-0.0993331298,
-0.2422605008,
-0.0024121269,
-0.975697875,
0.4899153709,
-0.1198574603,
0.5066750646,
-0.1473010182,
-0.30550161,
-0.1761808097,
0.0511149503,
-0.4754881263,
0.630274713,
0.414175272,
-0.7660452724,
0.596791327,
-0.8265924454,
-0.4809435904,
0.1798058748,
-0.8058333397,
-0.4682208598,
0.2575148642,
-0.1111785173,
-0.006789675,
-0.6936337352,
0.5139979124,
-0.3545645475,
0.1325351149,
0.0754681006,
-0.6539827585,
1.1268200874,
0.2844812572,
-0.4098286629,
0.1552300006,
-0.4094478488,
-0.3993234038,
-0.0012347864,
-0.2410162985,
-0.5042487979,
0.1425600201,
-0.1937561482,
0.1285036206,
-0.1463195384,
-0.5147584677,
-0.3165672719,
-0.2923103869,
0.2208548784,
0.896586895,
-0.4209454656,
0.2503846884,
-0.4316841066,
0.7320423722,
0.0501406342,
0.2509168088,
0.3976367116,
-0.6665512919,
-0.706310153,
-0.4020808041,
0.1468231231,
0.4971725941,
-1.0107852221,
0.7611296177,
0.1207324862,
-0.4212971926,
-0.6360911727,
0.2377395183,
0.6343989372,
0.7049637437,
0.0784289837,
-0.2551575601,
-0.6173229218,
-1.283516407,
-0.2715192437,
-0.5570299029,
-0.2529549301,
0.3409428298,
0.5033354163,
-0.2033608258,
0.968523562,
-0.200400129,
-0.2177289128,
-0.2745494545,
0.3584734797,
0.0703567564,
0.316345185,
0.844322741,
-0.6964371204,
-0.0459843576,
-0.4173509479,
-1.263474822,
-0.6459898949,
0.2221025676,
-0.1401790679,
0.1053652689,
0.3881252408,
-0.5647414327,
0.6396145225,
0.5884537101,
-0.5704652667,
0.6679447889,
-0.0288545359,
-0.0765333101,
-0.5545460582,
0.0231647305,
0.4085894525,
-0.1349383295,
-0.6188803315,
0.1341919154,
-0.2769410014,
0.0639667064,
-0.3301180899,
0.293482095,
-0.3956286013,
0.0497033671,
-0.1380178183,
-0.1502653062,
-0.117900297,
-0.1793914288,
0.1600464284,
0.7876712084,
0.7592460513,
-0.9083074927,
0.0125107886,
0.5314570069,
-0.4532341957,
0.7585896254,
-0.6937744617,
0.0993284285,
-0.7428785563,
0.268029958,
-0.5382378697,
0.1513105333,
0.3491286933,
-0.4184907675,
-0.3094260097,
-0.1861634403,
-0.3674238622,
-0.1981119365,
-0.0187817421,
0.6675818563,
0.779327035,
-0.4863716364,
0.3825750053,
0.5122392774,
0.0783219934,
-0.3161281645,
-0.7192600369,
-0.2591096163,
-0.3833660185,
-0.4164622128,
0.1675735712,
0.0887039453,
-0.7049880624,
-0.3041746616,
-0.0022437738,
-0.0169292949,
0.1716313362,
0.376237005,
0.5359441638,
0.0306862649,
0.0464500189,
-0.0433043167,
-0.1235055849,
0.0867733732,
0.1659290344,
0.4886783659,
0.2458470464,
-0.4170635045,
-0.1943281591,
0.473308742,
0.7191213369,
-0.1033720002,
0.7963237166,
0.4307436347,
-0.3991709054,
0.0943694338,
-0.545234859,
-0.2231995165,
-0.4406194091,
0.4146924615,
0.0183111243,
-0.7613848448,
0.2272031754,
0.2769221961,
0.0662139133,
0.4337531328,
0.6304437518,
0.1530907005,
1.2076320648,
0.4230238795,
-0.0336946659,
0.4804839194,
0.3030584753,
0.3865085244,
-0.8513723016,
-0.2055301517,
-0.8661934137,
0.180632636,
-0.8423085809,
-0.2948991954,
0.5617627501,
-0.1002505943,
-0.2218779624,
-0.0159137249,
-0.4034376144,
0.3826286793,
0.5203623772,
-0.1607806087,
-0.0709495619,
-0.1973229349,
-0.1474900544,
-0.0569288097,
-0.4880685806,
-0.5511022806,
0.9479988217,
0.4432614148,
0.5284759998,
0.4381343722,
0.4468185008,
0.6580310464,
0.7307376862,
-0.3319910765,
0.5011073947,
-0.5836597681,
-1.1561306715,
-0.0678446144,
-0.7298619747,
-0.8413217664,
0.3154124916,
-0.2887046337,
-0.8554560542,
0.482778728,
0.0532381944,
0.0764640048,
0.2029953599,
-0.6392588019,
0.6358212233,
-0.2885381877,
-0.1071147546,
0.0879730582,
-0.314810276,
0.6204171181,
0.1308319122,
0.352935344,
-0.564714551,
0.441008389,
0.5385574102,
-0.5002484322,
1.1049669981,
-0.46095559,
-0.1970643848,
0.1697156727,
0.0261123814,
0.1350868642,
-0.2715828419,
-0.2432408035,
0.5382370949,
-0.2778691351,
-0.3390434086,
-0.1532380283,
0.1213783249,
-0.796082437,
-0.7146354318,
-0.3811764717,
-0.2857965827,
-0.305251807,
0.2043171078,
0.417657733,
0.1197736263,
-0.4027814567,
0.1347669661,
0.5317300558,
-0.9785247445,
-0.1065404192,
0.5504984856,
-0.4286698401,
0.1678367853,
0.7609615326,
-0.0988629684,
0.485837847,
0.1299391389,
0.3107345104,
-0.458637476,
-0.3383813202,
-0.4005436003,
0.0653007776,
-0.6159669757,
0.0502111875,
-0.4950409234,
-0.2602013946,
-0.707482338,
0.1681656986,
-0.1104899198,
-0.108200103,
-0.2992868423,
-0.2951384187,
0.1274771243,
0.6236876845,
0.0321067758,
0.0332728475,
-0.4473360181,
0.8699555397,
0.3410432935,
0.2584328651,
-0.1208489984,
-0.3499085009,
0.4354335964,
-0.1264361888,
-0.3558889031,
-0.8666602373,
0.295547843,
-0.001175832,
0.8680211306,
0.545394063,
0.2826524973,
0.0284801926,
-0.2390635312,
0.8160012364,
0.4752846062,
-1.052959919,
0.5951913595,
-0.4373099804,
-0.1791650802,
0.4218064249,
0.2727508545,
-0.6953712702,
-0.7843360305,
-0.4228950441,
-0.7785226107,
0.6178616881,
0.5840824842,
0.3633796871,
-0.5940691233,
0.1754842699,
0.4038127065,
0.2878752649,
-0.7395324707,
-0.4905110002,
-0.3011509478,
-0.2795808613,
0.2819778025,
-0.2974820733,
-0.1818346232,
-0.1616996378,
0.4545354247,
0.082097508,
0.5200409889,
-0.0625697598,
-0.1348414719,
0.1794827878,
0.5449080467,
0.496545583,
0.4560946822,
-0.0296331495,
0.2550813258,
0.0456560515,
-0.2553741038,
0.4048672616,
0.0834029838,
-0.6553731561,
0.1780708581,
0.2531633973,
0.8107118607,
-0.4637623727,
-0.6422828436,
0.5236644745,
-0.0521314219,
-0.2643384933,
-0.4205983877,
0.2319907397,
-0.2324352115,
-0.0317469463,
0.0672024637,
0.0198331214,
0.2784600556,
-0.6257656217,
-0.0353726298,
0.6011947989,
-0.4624923468,
-0.1122373566,
0.9823687077,
0.3965383172,
-0.2163983881,
0.8672710657,
-0.3068937957,
-0.406550467,
0.690965414,
0.6589552164,
1.073733449,
-0.3570527136,
0.552811563,
0.2482546419,
0.3867420554,
-0.0071091005,
0.1422487795,
0.1755773127,
-0.9982879758,
0.066527687,
-0.4431058764,
-0.1309963167,
0.0293994602,
-0.6021515727,
0.1093436331,
-0.6366754174,
-0.3820345998,
0.1586757302,
-0.9710987806,
-0.4918420315,
0.1577299386,
0.2861849666,
0.4857274294,
-1.1805768013,
0.4267305434,
0.3614914417,
-0.5666869283,
-0.0401216038,
0.1250433475,
0.1885153502,
-0.9739817977,
0.8031530976,
0.230424881,
-0.1377956271,
-0.6094625592,
-0.383610785,
-0.3308289051,
0.5334547162,
0.7467198372,
-0.3627299666,
-0.1815966219,
0.3232333362,
0.3917059302,
-0.199038744,
0.511216104,
0.7222087383,
0.5584526062,
-0.2932960093,
-0.9310124516,
0.0987404361,
-0.45934847,
0.3142050207,
-0.0354258977,
-0.4735269845,
0.9913857579,
0.039004568,
-0.2967348993,
0.0559673868,
0.3920990229,
0.6012939811,
0.1604669392,
0.8486974835,
0.2828766704,
0.7336044312,
-0.1803074777,
1.1200486422,
-0.0852452442,
0.0763955563,
0.6695771217,
-0.2638480365,
0.0229638759,
0.2372840345,
-0.3939981461,
0.5725858212,
0.2215374112,
0.0089209573,
0.3159089386,
0.4825222194,
-0.6326793432,
-0.2013568282,
-0.6734169722,
-0.5614035726,
0.6325759292,
0.4331228435,
-0.8914546967,
-0.1613327563,
0.0412930846,
0.0712606013,
0.0049015395,
0.0473103859,
0.5855463147,
0.0945947692,
-0.6092511415,
0.4252224565,
0.2602847517,
0.803173244,
-0.4386609495,
-0.1895566732,
-0.2339024991,
-0.0902373269,
-0.2643990517,
-0.310390234,
0.4026115239,
0.3257202208,
-0.4921106696,
-0.2298101485,
0.5398724079,
-0.3214203119,
-0.6152276397,
0.1256076545,
0.5294664502,
0.1766447723,
0.0915743113,
-0.5882644653,
-0.1909106076,
0.120238021,
0.4196898341,
0.2305441797,
0.0351947136,
-0.2939120829,
0.6848819256,
0.4428423941,
0.0907146931,
-0.0204405133,
0.5258248448,
0.211571455,
-0.4442942441,
-0.6637595892,
-0.9118131399,
0.0733261183,
0.1507380605,
-0.2444140613,
0.7052121162,
0.4259700477,
0.3003714979,
-0.0252300985,
1.2303702831,
-0.2751365602,
0.3262570798,
-0.4911806881,
0.7214459181,
-0.3691047728,
0.2566871047,
-0.335033536,
-0.6309933662,
-0.1645531058,
0.8421850204,
-0.5367516279,
0.6775660515,
0.3142673969,
0.7016019821,
0.2581079006,
0.3181200624,
0.3192531466,
0.0724125952,
0.3950012624,
0.2901316583,
1.1736072302,
0.1110105067,
0.1611848176,
-0.0088560274,
-0.3634001613,
-0.1081214398,
-0.7937249541,
-0.848824501,
-0.4363889694,
-0.6472473145,
-0.4846075773,
0.0831291005,
0.7030916214,
0.9051524401,
-0.704649806,
-0.1148766801,
-0.3848897815,
0.4668846428,
-0.09603744,
-0.2828707099,
0.045393426,
-0.1172338724,
-0.6361385584,
0.13522695,
-0.0079123098,
0.1808163524,
-0.4623364806,
-0.0080141444,
0.1679818332,
0.0369488001,
0.5488598347,
0.2431612313,
-0.7009124756,
-0.3257449567,
-0.5211741328,
0.126573056,
0.1346650124,
0.8005127907,
-0.3958580792,
0.5844391584,
0.4900891781,
0.1565372348,
-0.0530118905,
0.0203351025,
0.9317954779,
-1.0039674044,
0.14887321,
0.1889351755,
0.3613309562,
0.5078990459,
-0.4422727823,
0.4280977249,
0.3743893504,
-0.1488205791,
-0.818911016,
0.5836680532,
-0.2256319374,
-0.3825677633,
1.1776573658,
-0.0442837253,
0.0206570886,
-0.4981511235,
-0.0192535464,
0.319339782,
-0.3069692552,
1.1028712988,
0.5478429198,
-0.326094985,
-0.1735698432,
-0.793833673,
0.4303694963,
0.4377101958,
-0.9509481788,
0.2142213434,
0.6871607304,
0.3338241279,
0.1205478609,
0.7650841475,
-0.4504312277,
0.2143179327,
0.2850649655,
0.273257792,
0.2907439768,
-0.0663865805,
-0.0565623008,
-0.0846212208,
0.3675656319,
-0.3891940117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08540v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08540v2
|
Language models scale reliably with over-training and on downstream tasks
| 2024-03-13T13:54:00 | 2024-06-14T20:21:05 |
Samir Yitzhak Gadre, Georgios Smyrnis, Vaishaal Shankar, Suchin Gururangan, Mitchell Wortsman, Rulin Shao, Jean Mercat, Alex Fang, Jeffrey Li, Sedrick Keh, Rui Xin, Marianna Nezhurina, Igor Vasiljevic, Jenia Jitsev, Luca Soldaini, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Gabriel Ilharco, Pang Wei Koh, Shuran Song, Thomas Kollar, Yair Carmon, Achal Dave, Reinhard Heckel, Niklas Muennighoff, Ludwig Schmidt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Scaling laws are useful guides for derisking expensive training runs, as they
predict performance of large models using cheaper, small-scale experiments.
However, there remain gaps between current scaling studies and how language
models are ultimately trained and evaluated. For instance, scaling is usually
studied in the compute-optimal training regime (i.e., "Chinchilla optimal"
regime). In contrast, models are often over-trained to reduce inference costs.
Moreover, scaling laws mostly predict loss on next-token prediction, but models
are usually compared on downstream task performance. To address both
shortcomings, we create a testbed of 104 models with 0.011B to 6.9B parameters
trained with various numbers of tokens on three data distributions. First, we
fit scaling laws that extrapolate in both the amount of over-training and the
number of model parameters. This enables us to predict the validation loss of a
1.4B parameter, 900B token run (i.e., 32$\times$ over-trained) and a 6.9B
parameter, 138B token run (i.e., a compute-optimal run)$\unicode{x2014}$each
from experiments that take 300$\times$ less compute. Second, we relate the
perplexity of a language model to its downstream task performance by proposing
a power law. We use this law to predict top-1 error averaged over downstream
tasks for the two aforementioned models, using experiments that take 20$\times$
less compute. Our experiments are available at
https://github.com/mlfoundations/scaling.
|
[
-0.2855993807,
-0.4569389224,
0.5057592988,
0.3205061257,
0.002213004,
-0.3026266992,
-0.432215333,
-0.2295693308,
-0.1417356133,
0.6675023437,
-0.4563455582,
0.2321485579,
-0.7730009556,
-0.1367519945,
-0.4781358838,
0.9424713254,
0.0562327653,
0.2813523412,
-0.1106381416,
-0.2203085274,
-0.2793475091,
-0.5139224529,
-0.653832376,
-0.5568239093,
0.4645896256,
0.2280602902,
0.8313981891,
0.9616777301,
0.608011961,
0.2259444743,
-0.1550582796,
-0.352086246,
-0.551615119,
-0.0319299437,
-0.0976857468,
-0.6210162044,
-0.2818815112,
0.0877689198,
0.7279180288,
0.8655168414,
-0.3057599366,
0.2598017454,
-0.1625093669,
0.6094468832,
-0.6442584991,
0.2052495629,
-0.6435517669,
-0.1678946018,
-0.1149928048,
0.0509457551,
-0.6672756076,
-0.154783234,
-0.1575439125,
-0.4011111557,
0.0437993295,
0.2200788558,
1.0155755281,
0.5099595189,
-0.3936063647,
-0.1674838513,
-0.5865585208,
0.9673910141,
-0.9606531262,
0.4908587635,
0.4211551547,
0.3421147466,
0.1198035404,
-0.772575736,
-0.4356119037,
-0.4303955138,
-0.1253682971,
-0.2356296927,
-0.4825605154,
0.0994730219,
0.6417246461,
0.4176455438,
-0.4400643408,
0.3618867695,
-0.3830216229,
-0.0479614511,
0.5532274842,
0.3054658771,
0.1971266419,
0.053790167,
-0.0976148397,
-0.1640847772,
-0.7507949471,
0.1797568649,
0.2864867747,
0.7117597461,
-0.0520015098,
0.4584697485,
-0.1093680188,
0.5406332016,
0.2601898909,
-0.1106529757,
0.3179154098,
-0.3779420853,
-0.3367862403,
-0.1158539131,
0.7392477393,
0.3272911608,
0.6688135266,
-0.265542239,
-0.2847612202,
-0.3357993364,
0.4889587164,
-1.1424028873,
-0.0460833572,
-0.0022541548,
-0.3606179059,
-0.204321906,
-0.5064687133,
-0.2685663998,
-0.4653309882,
-0.4277882278,
0.6657685041,
-0.1975464225,
-0.468878001,
0.0663630664,
-0.0023382357,
0.144447878,
0.1349853426,
-1.3089618683,
0.594887197,
0.7516592145,
0.9239591956,
0.2062729895,
-0.4106056094,
-0.5338716507,
-0.3877667189,
-0.4241940677,
0.3166489303,
-0.2926459312,
-0.0301029868,
-0.0377125517,
-0.0310990978,
-0.3735158145,
-0.4993720353,
0.3004901111,
-0.4518985748,
-0.2056602836,
-0.3848710358,
-0.7581197619,
0.0865333751,
0.0857791826,
-0.787386477,
0.7568097711,
0.1821806282,
-0.8756442666,
0.6491261721,
-0.4855348468,
-0.5520860553,
-0.1686961204,
0.0661565512,
-0.4901114702,
0.2992785275,
-0.0732596889,
0.5567331314,
-0.625064075,
0.1258054227,
-0.4007673264,
-0.3404164612,
-0.0137716969,
-0.3277043104,
0.9299364686,
0.1217310876,
-0.542362988,
0.0927578732,
-0.7426798344,
0.1555545777,
0.0726914927,
-0.3423855603,
-0.236796841,
0.0883528218,
0.0021968891,
0.0646269396,
0.0462278239,
-0.7480859756,
0.0992843881,
-0.3638993204,
0.6845160723,
0.5517835617,
-0.4010134041,
0.5511556268,
-0.1565149724,
0.5475748181,
-0.2786930799,
0.2728205919,
-0.0858278051,
-0.3781708777,
-0.639131546,
-0.1197094396,
0.2655772865,
0.4119529724,
-0.1848126352,
0.1418616176,
-0.513327539,
-0.778975904,
-0.3527765572,
0.0460816473,
0.337677002,
0.3898238242,
0.3857242763,
-0.2668824196,
-0.4242548645,
-0.8133530021,
-0.3874742389,
-0.2967133224,
-0.1759355813,
0.256036967,
0.4759312868,
0.0612812378,
0.9938604236,
-0.1113942564,
-0.0570725538,
-0.4925284386,
0.2619321346,
0.203057915,
0.5233873129,
0.5679887533,
-0.7690484524,
-0.4248929024,
0.1566075683,
-0.3105013669,
-0.196076259,
-0.1210247353,
0.4068959951,
0.1936219782,
0.6952180862,
-0.5573532581,
0.1701090187,
0.5915210247,
-0.2658702135,
0.6664397717,
-0.3405094445,
-0.0668332875,
-0.8643033504,
0.0788569227,
0.0132663939,
-0.2022776753,
-0.7965689301,
0.1032846197,
0.3564535379,
0.2458355576,
-0.1770202965,
0.5216722488,
-0.2175874263,
-0.0826501399,
-0.2593577206,
-0.312484622,
-0.1350391954,
0.5542545915,
-0.032648623,
0.7172563076,
0.6507760286,
-0.304304719,
0.0907615423,
-0.5172275901,
-0.3481784761,
0.2318364531,
-0.8689565659,
-0.1597417444,
0.109457165,
0.077822797,
-1.1259402037,
-0.1094086617,
-0.4200977981,
-0.3366728127,
0.5061073899,
-0.2680746913,
-0.6813454032,
-0.2253616899,
-0.0884140804,
0.4811395407,
0.8116668463,
-0.3759013414,
0.7497724891,
0.3872817755,
0.1891997457,
-0.5360463262,
-1.0316919088,
-0.1571906656,
-0.3694313169,
-0.4569247961,
-0.0055651846,
0.0566885136,
-0.3792614639,
-0.2370017171,
-0.0850846544,
-0.2909868658,
0.1491606385,
0.4571384192,
-0.1276254803,
-0.4596319497,
0.051109001,
-0.2020175308,
0.128490746,
0.4523024261,
-0.2791977823,
0.5540891886,
-0.2629530728,
-0.2858550251,
-0.2103104144,
-0.0837298855,
1.0180506706,
-0.1655487865,
0.9327864051,
0.3768585324,
-0.2969518602,
0.0340886973,
-0.6484876275,
-0.074176915,
-0.4473985732,
0.4279250205,
-0.5355371833,
-0.6752851605,
0.8694717884,
0.1330117136,
0.323266387,
0.5562977791,
0.6781582236,
0.2828681767,
1.1041357517,
0.8733766079,
-0.2007481903,
0.5079266429,
-0.220814243,
0.2925645113,
-0.7187134027,
0.1337574571,
-0.6311753988,
-0.0737172812,
-0.892772913,
-0.3704689145,
0.0603426658,
0.1170048043,
-0.5028016567,
0.6894651055,
-0.1029429436,
0.5192089081,
0.5345355868,
-0.1421501786,
0.1438937783,
-0.0077581671,
-0.1994449943,
0.0147217652,
-0.8570972681,
-0.2905102074,
1.3802654743,
0.6125600338,
0.8352066278,
-0.1020858586,
0.6207802296,
0.1180152223,
0.6571859717,
-0.860319376,
0.3074559271,
-0.2799955606,
-0.8676590323,
-0.7417742014,
-0.7207986712,
-0.8172364831,
0.3171643317,
0.2728723586,
-0.7730501294,
0.0560431927,
0.2335949391,
-0.3527845144,
0.6119173169,
-0.746016562,
0.9744021893,
0.0738286152,
-0.3234532475,
-0.3818223178,
-0.790841043,
0.1180754825,
-0.2501907051,
0.4549933672,
0.0184770301,
0.0119309397,
0.7209955454,
-0.7644568086,
0.8085696697,
-0.1793741137,
-0.2125740945,
0.212896049,
0.0336338021,
0.3554031551,
-0.4164919555,
-0.1013146192,
0.1915615648,
0.0144098997,
-0.5584056973,
-0.6358206272,
0.5204473138,
-0.7072964311,
-0.3807122409,
-0.0655317605,
-0.5810066462,
-0.1280622929,
0.2240384966,
0.4199253321,
0.6148481965,
0.2523459494,
0.304061234,
0.542398572,
0.2190003842,
0.4021551013,
0.4878742993,
-0.2183939964,
-0.1264207959,
0.9094076753,
0.4420615137,
0.8677043915,
0.2685664892,
0.4576331973,
-0.3006713688,
-0.6803253889,
-0.6445379853,
0.1435041428,
-0.7065498233,
0.0621422864,
-0.5194553733,
-0.1992820203,
-0.4606643617,
-0.0914031789,
-0.7018547654,
-0.4678564072,
0.0605664514,
-0.0098595368,
0.2482111007,
0.573192656,
-0.2201579511,
0.2342593074,
-0.3631026745,
-0.1317695081,
0.2131848931,
0.4009998441,
0.1629155278,
-1.0845247507,
-0.3947427869,
-0.0105245756,
-0.0067937109,
-0.5572464466,
0.2003383189,
0.2126870155,
0.4696369469,
0.3121282756,
-0.0772300065,
0.6132566333,
-0.8086855412,
0.6614052057,
0.3295631111,
-0.9620540142,
0.2087525427,
-0.2152182609,
0.3144017458,
0.5018804669,
0.4402240813,
-0.4189872742,
-0.7129687667,
-0.7281795144,
-0.8297873139,
0.5787109137,
0.241260916,
0.4748381674,
0.2277420163,
0.454815954,
0.0374130085,
0.053378582,
-0.7234243155,
-0.1753378958,
-0.2234549969,
-0.0577033497,
-0.244362399,
-0.0625519678,
0.2267826647,
-0.2479562312,
0.5033249259,
-0.1324978322,
-0.1829390675,
-0.1354023069,
0.0043937173,
-0.3665342331,
0.1694180816,
0.6006483436,
0.7666196823,
-0.2008331716,
0.0919553563,
0.2026968896,
-0.6699535251,
0.209164381,
0.0849924311,
-0.0264305845,
-0.0697226599,
0.5720666647,
0.8740673065,
0.2314454466,
-0.8659938574,
0.5308177471,
-0.1148745492,
-0.2162523717,
-0.1427689642,
0.1228892356,
0.1450284272,
0.2226378322,
0.4063997269,
-0.0055704284,
0.041930791,
-0.5336649418,
0.241867736,
0.2927158177,
-0.3984829187,
-0.2997764349,
0.7178563476,
0.002516005,
-0.2802174985,
0.5927196145,
-0.3009504974,
-0.4637444317,
0.906506598,
0.297403723,
0.6706377268,
-0.174560681,
-0.1611037105,
0.5225000978,
0.6311512589,
-0.4159629941,
-0.0601358563,
0.0030109135,
-0.585997045,
-0.7299287915,
-0.7094863653,
-0.4141794443,
0.2078202814,
-0.822427392,
0.0550989844,
-0.5030343533,
-0.3815920651,
0.2837331593,
0.1366212964,
-0.4713082016,
0.3812887967,
0.0952190682,
0.9136313796,
-0.9149813056,
0.7696630359,
0.5173074007,
-0.4231898487,
-1.0464168787,
-0.0682189688,
-0.0679124147,
-0.8324260712,
0.8287447095,
0.2233924419,
-0.0514144152,
0.0209996607,
-0.2663111985,
-1.0733224154,
0.8351165652,
0.5720394254,
-0.6337610483,
0.0178978816,
0.1732890308,
0.7366676927,
-0.3472456634,
0.4143057168,
0.625972867,
0.2567158639,
0.1530149132,
-1.5466464758,
0.178752169,
-0.0230521318,
-0.1713251472,
0.45877406,
-0.5834640861,
1.2847954035,
-0.5036657453,
-0.1198393852,
0.0147823989,
0.4424656928,
-0.0813117698,
0.2020653337,
0.736700058,
0.6638797522,
0.5332869887,
-0.0236054845,
1.2687635422,
-0.2620185614,
0.7478868365,
1.1464412212,
-0.2605518699,
0.9762813449,
0.5636538863,
-0.419603169,
0.3797986805,
0.6192594171,
-0.0391722955,
0.3483133018,
0.6167496443,
0.2792879343,
-0.2934307754,
-0.0907149762,
-0.0307596345,
0.2267752141,
0.006706411,
-0.4227110147,
-0.2475901991,
0.0485942252,
0.2273955941,
-0.0941223875,
-0.49386397,
0.4567831159,
-0.0882240161,
-0.6448276043,
0.8843973279,
-0.1115701646,
0.4138602018,
-0.5003251433,
0.3905928731,
-0.3617606163,
0.3123194575,
0.0088283243,
-0.5732137561,
0.198269546,
0.0056026797,
-0.2077515274,
-0.3208347261,
0.4371983707,
-0.2484446913,
-0.4661360085,
0.2949902713,
0.1975211203,
0.2854986489,
-0.261084944,
-0.5062986016,
-0.0112763373,
-0.1313886791,
-0.5877456069,
0.4488938153,
0.3611756563,
-0.0601781644,
0.9382839203,
0.2478568405,
0.2818718553,
0.3864874542,
0.3997940719,
0.7006172538,
-0.3065767884,
-0.3866304159,
-0.9990054965,
0.2979602814,
-0.0804500878,
-0.341594398,
0.7239902616,
0.4928409457,
0.784824729,
0.2337571234,
0.5207588673,
-0.1956475377,
0.2637615204,
-0.4029958844,
0.6396661401,
-0.8503420353,
-0.0247260332,
0.1093520001,
-0.5557150245,
-0.1823713928,
0.3402401805,
-0.4099598229,
0.3045038879,
0.5870845914,
0.7468338013,
-0.1126679927,
-0.1083592921,
0.4585142136,
0.2161422223,
0.2883388698,
0.5347117782,
0.3526198566,
-0.4217934608,
0.5309253931,
-0.2943708301,
-0.2346803248,
-0.2946436107,
-0.6530861259,
-0.9720597863,
-0.4820224643,
-0.3821783066,
-0.2481135726,
-0.1218245924,
0.6110268235,
1.07789433,
-0.7646770477,
-0.4705586731,
-0.4424496591,
-0.1778819412,
-0.397397548,
-0.2069472373,
0.179476589,
-0.8114679456,
-0.5259388089,
-0.0852426216,
0.027619414,
-0.0289843753,
-0.6542614102,
-0.0844545439,
0.0145841269,
0.4138924479,
0.327580601,
0.2420405895,
-0.7473550439,
-0.18755503,
-0.0614079013,
-0.4306564033,
-0.0724204108,
1.0933033228,
-0.3980104327,
0.3744011819,
0.4756051302,
0.7069473267,
0.4772208035,
-0.3399113715,
0.6861582398,
-0.7057036757,
-0.0778245777,
0.0494406,
0.3340943158,
0.3098355532,
-0.2324457616,
0.5330405831,
0.0247566774,
-0.6842755675,
-1.0933510065,
0.0971698016,
-0.5177337527,
-0.2484990656,
1.1163170338,
-0.4673265219,
-0.1789131761,
0.2195243686,
0.1339921802,
0.1065684259,
-0.0833078325,
0.6420977712,
1.0589433908,
-0.1597940922,
-0.1188432947,
-0.8774232268,
0.5954592824,
0.8163226843,
-0.5388101339,
0.6451749206,
0.1493114829,
0.3971500397,
0.4001381099,
0.3570772707,
0.1989031732,
0.2561830282,
0.2556588054,
-0.2017538995,
0.1509661824,
-0.1381817609,
-0.4312497973,
0.2504037321,
0.2409595102,
-0.0049891663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08495v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08495v2
|
Automatic Interactive Evaluation for Large Language Models with State Aware Patient Simulator
| 2024-03-13T13:04:58 | 2024-03-14T08:05:08 |
Yusheng Liao, Yutong Meng, Yuhao Wang, Hongcheng Liu, Yanfeng Wang, Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in
human interactions, yet their application within the medical field remains
insufficiently explored. Previous works mainly focus on the performance of
medical knowledge with examinations, which is far from the realistic scenarios,
falling short in assessing the abilities of LLMs on clinical tasks. In the
quest to enhance the application of Large Language Models (LLMs) in healthcare,
this paper introduces the Automated Interactive Evaluation (AIE) framework and
the State-Aware Patient Simulator (SAPS), targeting the gap between traditional
LLM evaluations and the nuanced demands of clinical practice. Unlike prior
methods that rely on static medical knowledge assessments, AIE and SAPS provide
a dynamic, realistic platform for assessing LLMs through multi-turn
doctor-patient simulations. This approach offers a closer approximation to real
clinical scenarios and allows for a detailed analysis of LLM behaviors in
response to complex patient interactions. Our extensive experimental validation
demonstrates the effectiveness of the AIE framework, with outcomes that align
well with human evaluations, underscoring its potential to revolutionize
medical LLM testing for improved healthcare delivery.
|
[
-0.1993461996,
-0.7300559282,
0.9848757386,
0.3595791161,
-0.1076156124,
0.1538651586,
-0.3773685098,
-0.5447849631,
0.2766560316,
0.34510535,
-0.4504744411,
-0.3859910071,
-0.5974863172,
0.1443514675,
-0.4342072904,
0.5216180682,
-0.3342413604,
0.4704746306,
-0.4394480288,
0.0577914715,
-0.2357325703,
-0.4931911826,
-0.6775880456,
-0.3928380311,
0.1446940154,
-0.0477696732,
0.5057869554,
0.3608697355,
0.6454970837,
0.4075258672,
0.1576946676,
0.0910977498,
-0.1370967627,
0.2058242708,
-0.0498206504,
-0.1911108792,
-0.5538475513,
-0.1112447307,
0.8335226774,
0.5635417104,
-0.3771546185,
0.0392333195,
-0.3137171566,
0.3162717819,
-0.521500349,
0.3693769276,
-0.3718453944,
0.1330328286,
0.1782883257,
-0.1419006586,
-0.3760491908,
-0.3805573285,
0.3270257711,
-0.4235452414,
-0.3003680408,
0.0647296757,
0.6131061912,
0.3205597401,
-0.7309676409,
-0.2001964301,
-0.82598418,
0.4531259537,
-0.9261322618,
0.6127522588,
-0.0331032872,
0.5539149642,
-0.350910455,
-0.7960252166,
-0.7224657536,
-0.8456215262,
-0.0672656447,
0.2435664386,
-0.2317964584,
0.455888629,
0.3328022361,
0.2179916799,
-0.2902263701,
0.4137613475,
-0.1323017329,
-0.1986089796,
0.6893512011,
0.596812427,
0.7737345099,
-0.2067733407,
-0.5010630488,
0.0738939568,
-0.4078299403,
0.0630724654,
-0.313282758,
-0.1188462526,
-0.3083724976,
0.595674932,
0.1128733829,
0.6474630833,
-0.1643151343,
-0.3771164417,
0.1497870088,
-0.0776554197,
-0.4061546922,
-0.0674286932,
1.0195599794,
0.4799287915,
0.0668987781,
-0.0086359531,
-0.221021831,
0.1413331479,
0.4278314412,
-0.9120372534,
-0.0318906866,
0.5588094592,
-0.3740545213,
-0.1181927025,
-0.1089816317,
-0.7100683451,
-0.6944096088,
-0.4541688859,
0.396974653,
-0.578017354,
-0.1826636344,
0.1865284294,
0.2559292912,
0.0769020915,
0.7184137106,
-0.6218323708,
0.7982283235,
0.7096357942,
0.497815609,
-0.4605770409,
-0.2707734108,
-0.7060251236,
0.1602520198,
-0.4426395893,
0.6176891327,
-0.4767172337,
-0.4308847189,
-0.1424465328,
-0.0813479871,
-0.3274129033,
-0.6258378029,
0.3855306506,
-0.3987356126,
-0.0200475883,
-0.0431979448,
-0.9070163965,
-0.0758627057,
0.3853353858,
-0.5499087572,
0.7578812242,
0.175605312,
-0.4318531752,
0.4774942994,
-1.0499360561,
-0.4614351094,
0.2471751869,
-0.5224006772,
-0.3327509761,
0.111140281,
0.2125980556,
0.4385735393,
-0.4255088866,
0.3723464012,
-0.2084821612,
-0.4366888702,
0.3664516807,
-0.2746566534,
0.5225174427,
-0.0334650166,
-0.2582415938,
0.5785025358,
-0.4933588505,
0.0692076758,
0.0300837327,
-0.3931729496,
-0.1864153743,
0.1775679588,
0.0491091944,
0.2667704225,
0.1496517807,
-0.5951244831,
0.2663146257,
-0.5765850544,
0.3191035688,
0.4153333902,
0.2965159416,
0.2934427559,
-0.1497395337,
0.9840021133,
0.0007217344,
0.5808620453,
-0.0465595797,
-0.2778668404,
-0.5566413403,
-0.6584728956,
0.3661189377,
0.7629128695,
-0.4892711043,
0.4253878593,
-0.3060866892,
-0.4467141628,
-0.8683630824,
-0.0891766399,
0.0804665014,
0.4928678572,
0.2272293568,
-0.4099985659,
-0.3393352926,
-0.9041639566,
-0.1199117303,
-0.3377683461,
-0.0222397204,
0.4968082309,
0.5656703115,
-0.4560448527,
0.7894377112,
-0.2146014422,
-0.2194866985,
-0.338981539,
-0.1223990023,
-0.1704232097,
0.3638641238,
0.4522618949,
-0.4754230678,
-0.3380656242,
0.1014465764,
-0.6999819875,
0.0507222675,
-0.1475869715,
0.1393103749,
0.0862015262,
0.5092358589,
-0.4236359,
0.4440141618,
0.6437824965,
-0.3108752966,
0.5714997649,
-0.5987263918,
0.5225253701,
-0.8488372564,
0.0644883141,
0.0208801534,
-0.3287009895,
-0.5523781776,
0.0593089983,
0.1851364076,
-0.1809605807,
-0.4500834048,
1.009224534,
-0.5276719928,
-0.2338802367,
-0.1526504755,
0.1928078383,
0.0076649804,
-0.0677140281,
0.123138696,
0.7138078213,
0.6282570958,
-0.4244274199,
0.4620599747,
0.066541709,
-0.8322950006,
0.4261367917,
-0.568316102,
-0.089523159,
0.117979154,
0.4264926314,
-0.5615294576,
-0.3550786972,
-0.0165156927,
-0.1458031386,
0.1912760735,
-0.0943599716,
-0.7084824443,
-0.5857642293,
0.0008413902,
0.3341941237,
0.607005775,
-0.1864171028,
0.9181383252,
0.5744684935,
-0.3137991726,
-0.2186911553,
-0.4548235238,
0.3483114243,
-0.1096139997,
-0.550106883,
0.0663355887,
-0.0220317803,
-0.5202267766,
-0.2138938457,
0.1991944313,
-0.2739673853,
0.3525513113,
0.2908028364,
0.5839428902,
-0.1017121077,
0.2118157744,
0.3104633391,
0.0444685556,
0.3251922429,
0.0781596825,
0.5986244082,
-0.2845967114,
-0.9560315013,
-0.8211730123,
0.3542941809,
0.9514034986,
-0.4514223635,
0.5352452993,
0.4638733864,
-0.7110990286,
0.1596618742,
-0.6869692206,
-0.4285639822,
-0.4125421941,
0.7616582513,
-0.1591906995,
-0.8058170676,
0.5254946351,
-0.4177159965,
0.133699894,
0.2739493847,
0.7634661794,
-0.1897074431,
1.321226716,
0.2639375031,
0.0741303787,
0.053344056,
0.1430970877,
0.3149130642,
-0.9501766562,
-0.488963306,
-0.2716836333,
-0.0839427188,
-0.4274214506,
-0.7016572356,
0.957147181,
-0.0509151705,
-0.1681995541,
-0.1811021268,
-0.0752397701,
0.1940840036,
0.046727553,
0.2448379546,
0.3976095915,
-0.2224665582,
-0.2642266452,
-0.2150032371,
-0.6522877812,
-0.5932448506,
0.7206809521,
0.6073338985,
0.7414094806,
-0.0187363327,
0.6256408691,
0.2765324712,
0.7339714766,
-1.0724071264,
0.6549856067,
-0.1168183684,
-0.3865282238,
-0.3193917572,
-0.3998070955,
-0.8658357859,
0.1760640442,
-0.5543062091,
-0.8126626611,
-0.2091934383,
0.2675999403,
-0.5875734687,
0.3522730768,
-0.6819653511,
0.7074047923,
-0.5768584609,
0.0236836262,
-0.5454145074,
-0.4903223813,
0.2042038143,
-0.1143287271,
0.3647188842,
-0.1934764236,
-0.2927084565,
0.5333943963,
-0.4835782945,
0.7629187703,
-0.2289256305,
-0.1908902973,
-0.0055155074,
0.412802875,
0.35783571,
0.103182286,
-0.244784534,
-0.1526888013,
0.1483444721,
-0.1886513978,
-0.8370678425,
0.7027346492,
-0.496871978,
-0.5772123933,
-0.3795980811,
-0.6024568081,
-0.6863470078,
0.2791029215,
-0.2583887279,
0.499856025,
-0.5944404006,
-0.4202408493,
0.4558508396,
-0.5532385111,
-0.0332535245,
0.940649569,
-0.5710197687,
-0.2092850506,
0.6030884981,
-0.2699152827,
0.2147483975,
0.0658467114,
0.3842073977,
-0.4367074966,
-0.5795437098,
-0.769890964,
0.3455308676,
-0.5442445874,
0.1991349906,
-0.6445436478,
-0.191069901,
-0.2417939901,
-0.2185955197,
-0.3085265458,
0.0109437937,
-0.0297701601,
0.0071828673,
0.3392528296,
1.0292149782,
0.2186077237,
0.0695359483,
-0.8694699407,
0.1721187383,
0.1612664759,
0.5893281698,
0.1711719483,
-0.3040858805,
-0.0973137766,
-0.2027307302,
0.2090021074,
-0.828540504,
0.1666695923,
0.0018869573,
0.7556310892,
0.4420277178,
-0.0971113518,
0.510494411,
-0.7723131776,
0.6614307165,
0.4478364885,
-1.0226477385,
0.4036686122,
-0.2337296158,
0.1887959689,
0.7184379101,
0.2428236902,
-0.690118134,
-0.3856475651,
-0.5037294626,
-0.7884327173,
0.3429921567,
-0.2139537036,
0.0182271972,
-0.0954611227,
0.3743069172,
-0.057283178,
0.1219234094,
-0.4438402355,
-0.0267334934,
0.526112318,
-0.4330782592,
0.2135695815,
-0.1161902919,
-0.2239595652,
-0.2447117418,
0.5675619245,
-0.0098614218,
0.2773350775,
0.284283489,
-0.1060207635,
-0.1699903756,
0.3165975809,
0.3786030412,
0.6580654979,
-0.0484710447,
-0.1711530387,
0.4732373655,
-0.4123200178,
0.1276886165,
0.2227851897,
-0.0433422513,
-0.1909527034,
0.4166812599,
0.9637534618,
0.3085651994,
-1.1580243111,
0.7457021475,
-0.2217870355,
0.0567047074,
-0.3995195329,
0.1212681308,
0.246986255,
0.1944362074,
-0.0730837137,
-0.0247606486,
0.3048466444,
-0.486828655,
0.3180682957,
0.3909744918,
-0.6958148479,
-0.0657387376,
0.5339852571,
0.3317275941,
-0.3321875632,
0.6503005624,
0.0238550305,
-0.5287233591,
0.8150089383,
0.4625339806,
0.580194056,
-0.4248960912,
0.0000208671,
0.2041366398,
0.3604465723,
0.0063901986,
0.3627179563,
0.4265570939,
-0.4236091077,
-0.7737907767,
-0.4109761417,
-0.7553443313,
0.1030743197,
-0.8152241707,
0.3898133039,
-0.5383391976,
-0.1683605909,
-0.21649988,
-0.0468825735,
-0.6985211372,
0.3876672089,
0.248187378,
1.1462198496,
-0.7260503173,
0.7769982815,
0.9440288544,
0.0314503424,
-0.9071361423,
0.1333914101,
0.0082678003,
-0.987298131,
0.3176957667,
-0.0223644283,
-0.1463377029,
-0.1916095614,
-0.0962795839,
-0.441718936,
0.9553661346,
0.5260124207,
-0.6737061143,
0.0625222251,
0.1072216034,
0.8634930849,
-0.461009264,
0.6663761735,
0.6455155015,
0.5473117232,
-0.3259537518,
-1.3125648499,
0.1282547861,
-0.2054146975,
-0.1966548264,
0.2281478345,
-0.6471156478,
0.3804064989,
-0.4908025563,
0.0567612983,
-0.0598880127,
0.5236928463,
0.3355211318,
0.2073810846,
0.9397972822,
0.2784539163,
0.9143139124,
0.0492960103,
1.3819360733,
-0.4197202623,
0.1995807439,
1.0335487127,
-0.8268366456,
0.9314460158,
0.2880213261,
-0.2678972781,
0.6302837729,
0.4459921718,
0.0052468968,
-0.0655662119,
0.5536668897,
-0.6046056747,
-0.4464081228,
-0.154560551,
-0.1570784599,
0.5851488709,
0.5072112083,
-0.2135930359,
-0.1423173845,
0.1749112457,
0.070444189,
0.1459172666,
-0.2804896832,
0.84187603,
0.1186641902,
-0.5487698317,
0.2089615911,
-0.0346074849,
0.2572789192,
-0.838083446,
-0.1272521466,
0.1143911853,
-0.0389850177,
-0.0769208074,
-0.6889562607,
0.0149590997,
0.1676972955,
-0.0071819229,
0.1044139341,
0.6957159042,
-0.4087781012,
-0.5974130034,
0.5815364122,
0.459972024,
0.2524588406,
0.1997924596,
-0.8309879303,
0.1407488585,
-0.1310949028,
-0.3051654994,
0.4446285367,
0.2121049911,
-0.2653651834,
0.9998839498,
0.4161267877,
0.4026837945,
-0.1597590894,
0.4642082453,
0.7321985364,
-0.4792993069,
-0.4915865958,
-0.7410185337,
0.3476437926,
-0.0684837326,
-0.066165939,
0.3188098073,
0.5819502473,
0.2138956636,
0.0188992675,
1.0021977425,
0.0224310365,
0.6612423658,
-0.4395917356,
0.9041622877,
-0.7086300254,
0.3071095943,
-0.2588558793,
-0.3351673186,
-0.2372456044,
0.4594531059,
-0.372305721,
0.0608533546,
0.59289819,
0.3105583787,
-0.0207505487,
-0.0530308485,
0.3309326768,
0.5488238931,
0.3576527238,
0.4998595417,
0.812042594,
-0.1190532073,
0.0514782481,
-0.1752151698,
-0.5314368606,
-0.1843953133,
-1.0029842854,
-0.7534384131,
-0.3184289038,
-0.3075096011,
-0.2660570145,
-0.0177030433,
1.4136884212,
0.6627822518,
-0.8208763599,
-0.2903501093,
0.4235422313,
-0.3764313757,
-0.1360572278,
-0.1857823879,
0.5016773939,
0.0312170479,
-0.826785624,
0.7123941779,
0.5652832389,
0.1907534748,
-0.4948206246,
-0.0289083496,
0.0979343504,
0.1787838191,
0.6081166863,
0.1131409854,
-0.6554527879,
-0.03391831,
-0.0731343701,
-0.3292156458,
0.0262225922,
0.9203643203,
-0.9339179397,
0.5274399519,
0.1327662617,
0.6954374313,
0.2252280116,
0.0510930791,
0.7201837897,
0.0339224339,
0.0695459992,
0.6147012115,
0.5150636435,
0.1970322728,
-0.3901521564,
0.0374470316,
-0.1693427116,
-0.4142480195,
-0.7499100566,
0.1257741004,
-1.111644268,
-0.1218511164,
1.0660908222,
-0.3783911467,
-0.0198160857,
-0.1244765222,
-0.1532299072,
0.1367854923,
-0.3345569372,
0.8432205915,
0.4894077778,
-0.4693776667,
0.1668835282,
-0.7921583056,
0.4108435214,
0.657669127,
-1.3324513435,
-0.05899252,
0.4851890206,
0.466391474,
-0.3040851057,
0.8568357825,
-0.3592326045,
0.3146177828,
-0.4627647698,
0.3094033599,
0.093101956,
-0.2059036344,
-0.3263602853,
-0.1728696376,
0.2389277965,
0.2249647975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08492v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08492v2
|
Rich Semantic Knowledge Enhanced Large Language Models for Few-shot Chinese Spell Checking
| 2024-03-13T12:55:43 | 2024-06-07T08:41:58 |
Ming Dong, Yujing Chen, Miao Zhang, Hao Sun, Tingting He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chinese Spell Checking (CSC) is a widely used technology, which plays a vital
role in speech to text (STT) and optical character recognition (OCR). Most of
the existing CSC approaches relying on BERT architecture achieve excellent
performance. However, limited by the scale of the foundation model, BERT-based
method does not work well in few-shot scenarios, showing certain limitations in
practical applications. In this paper, we explore using an in-context learning
method named RS-LLM (Rich Semantic based LLMs) to introduce large language
models (LLMs) as the foundation model. Besides, we study the impact of
introducing various Chinese rich semantic information in our framework. We
found that by introducing a small number of specific Chinese rich semantic
structures, LLMs achieve better performance than the BERT-based model on
few-shot CSC task. Furthermore, we conduct experiments on multiple datasets,
and the experimental results verified the superiority of our proposed
framework.
|
[
0.0463126078,
-0.7598717809,
0.5482993126,
0.0182137266,
-0.3009037077,
-0.2730823159,
-0.479323864,
-0.7468375564,
-0.0343934,
0.649702847,
-0.4629081786,
-0.7612909079,
-0.5886717439,
0.2975281775,
-0.2888908088,
0.591391027,
-0.0841920301,
0.275060147,
0.287124455,
0.0390596688,
-0.2636344731,
-0.2686644793,
-0.4648489058,
-0.3089534342,
0.4017236531,
0.5791713595,
0.5692375898,
0.5570297241,
0.4456236959,
0.2713751495,
-0.4859440625,
0.5727772117,
-0.5333162546,
-0.2060694396,
0.0219241902,
-0.559840858,
-0.291003406,
-0.3174544871,
0.9259501696,
0.7191175222,
0.1213046685,
-0.2123360485,
0.3839508593,
0.4277737439,
-0.7760619521,
-0.0813430846,
-0.9023044705,
0.2030451298,
-0.3246564567,
-0.1174989715,
-0.5756907463,
-0.1216932312,
0.2996512651,
-0.5384908915,
0.1495946646,
-0.1207039505,
0.9278790951,
-0.0181843881,
-0.5167768002,
-0.3260289431,
-0.63919276,
0.8895381689,
-1.0796884298,
0.4114832878,
0.5733093619,
0.2796536982,
-0.457139343,
-0.5465788841,
-0.7770544887,
-0.2809564769,
-0.062812604,
0.0775380731,
0.3647312224,
0.2860788107,
0.2342661768,
0.2252108008,
-0.4952861369,
0.3296203315,
-0.0833977908,
-0.4125332832,
0.2327451408,
0.2375531495,
0.3546274304,
-0.378071636,
-0.4986688197,
-0.0055594943,
-1.004955411,
0.0322553664,
-0.0775395632,
0.7204701304,
-0.1663276851,
0.5157535076,
-0.436062783,
0.8887037039,
-0.1276509613,
-0.5957947373,
-0.1474153101,
-0.351567477,
-0.2527883947,
0.2584285438,
0.3748042285,
-0.2128077149,
0.1956370026,
-0.0237906743,
-0.3358175755,
-0.0578425303,
-0.303029716,
-0.8437693119,
0.0013859244,
0.0047648638,
-0.5046661496,
0.0244503636,
0.0723777562,
-0.2666983604,
-0.5326988101,
-0.2569111586,
0.4053111076,
-0.6397377849,
0.0231887288,
0.0672023892,
0.1929551959,
0.5885847807,
0.633980751,
-0.9311697483,
-0.0090695526,
0.7615706325,
0.7821865678,
-0.1617629379,
-0.4685231447,
-0.6865774989,
0.2303552926,
-0.4105550945,
0.9751189351,
-0.3072525561,
-0.2072952241,
0.2881693244,
-0.0629847199,
0.0966632441,
-0.4745830595,
0.4733770788,
-0.6767292619,
-0.0151687684,
-0.3865108788,
-0.5921047926,
-0.0708033741,
0.5670852065,
-0.5709860921,
1.1045382023,
-0.0367630571,
-0.7300063968,
0.5705673099,
-0.2989749908,
-0.7947943211,
0.4420893788,
-0.1223805472,
-0.206598103,
-0.0934786052,
0.1659481823,
0.7480028272,
-0.0511984602,
-0.0815100372,
-0.3804908693,
-0.621555984,
0.0850722045,
-0.4180552661,
0.7796589136,
0.1646041125,
-0.3358156681,
0.0628900751,
-1.0219684839,
0.1643303186,
-0.0827988312,
-0.6341611743,
-0.5270538926,
0.0580779724,
0.1063395962,
0.3458150327,
0.2528289258,
-0.6501711011,
0.0744803548,
-0.8212329745,
0.3608469069,
0.6735226512,
-0.2664368749,
0.3738785386,
0.0848106146,
-0.0975476727,
0.0665610656,
-0.0005499102,
-0.0196386278,
-0.3390104175,
-0.8550930619,
-0.5023296475,
0.3759964406,
0.6676678658,
-0.9443360567,
0.4422272742,
-0.2292741388,
-0.2441001981,
-0.1601941139,
0.5076289177,
0.30158481,
0.3383253813,
0.230718419,
-0.3312016726,
-0.3222090304,
-0.5046362877,
-0.1893671453,
-0.1580111235,
-0.0800231025,
0.3832562268,
0.4987286329,
-0.2916951478,
0.9508545995,
-0.4114660919,
-0.6679954529,
-0.5807182193,
-0.0972243398,
0.1635498554,
0.1861497462,
0.2691873014,
-0.5006536841,
-0.6528750062,
0.1656282693,
-0.4977115393,
0.0016807745,
-0.0779171064,
-0.1791805178,
0.3304720521,
0.145916909,
-0.2319811583,
0.5618876219,
0.46067065,
-0.3525818288,
0.5627673268,
-0.2517867684,
0.2112515718,
-1.0528692007,
-0.1162342429,
0.0118729584,
-0.1800297052,
-0.7014320493,
0.1052501425,
0.4515600801,
0.0447110683,
-0.8538647294,
0.5265520811,
-0.3716551363,
-0.2013071924,
-0.5429297686,
0.5081200004,
-0.085889779,
0.4044781923,
0.3614323139,
0.4773116112,
0.3507953286,
-0.8442531228,
0.2388733178,
0.2779868841,
-0.6916550398,
0.5488860011,
-0.4536171556,
-0.1027506888,
0.1821641326,
0.2520141304,
-1.0144890547,
-0.2575654387,
-0.0934049934,
-0.3232348859,
0.2639783323,
0.0804622397,
-0.9621834159,
-0.1797727346,
-0.1133436412,
0.0575421937,
0.2078260779,
-1.058885932,
0.7670264244,
-0.1787806302,
0.1929493248,
-0.5501924157,
-1.0580750704,
0.0911914557,
0.0951023027,
-1.0261502266,
0.40661937,
0.1318214983,
-0.0381098278,
-0.1653152257,
0.12824893,
-0.4079678953,
0.2474950105,
-0.0123908725,
0.4525831938,
-0.4390944242,
0.1239958778,
0.0346250385,
0.0635505021,
-0.5103666186,
-0.1087066978,
0.2658881545,
0.0225641094,
-0.418374896,
-0.491702646,
0.2454769611,
0.3188299239,
-0.2890788615,
0.9310017824,
0.5215098262,
-0.5655022264,
-0.7317764163,
-0.6216664314,
-0.408110708,
-0.4595015943,
0.494846493,
-0.2969501317,
-1.1860710382,
0.667372942,
-0.218128562,
0.079932265,
0.3742569685,
0.5221835971,
0.0015576032,
0.7894217968,
0.7981730103,
-0.2207410187,
0.5774419308,
-0.0069940193,
0.2351363599,
-0.5411445498,
0.154421702,
-0.4444827437,
-0.0680661276,
-0.2507093549,
-0.3547517359,
0.3883382082,
0.317894727,
-0.0294811763,
0.4966476858,
-0.1716487855,
0.3954834938,
0.3584057689,
0.3426215947,
0.4562993348,
-0.0031108574,
-0.464402318,
-0.0266412031,
-0.7216522694,
-0.471744746,
0.7724443674,
0.2974917889,
0.7607373595,
0.1500151306,
0.5760724545,
-0.0600486845,
0.0907584056,
-0.9047130942,
0.6696718335,
-0.5200752616,
-0.6264302731,
-0.4420282543,
-0.2914285958,
-0.5340721607,
0.4106268883,
-0.6088439822,
-0.5177425146,
0.0717936307,
0.1384083778,
-0.583994031,
0.425734967,
-0.5849871635,
0.5722517371,
-0.4838089049,
-0.5635272264,
-0.35831514,
-0.6309395432,
0.5400951505,
-0.0754511505,
-0.0541730151,
0.1119921803,
0.1777640283,
0.4788902998,
-0.5638732314,
1.2082402706,
0.1223246455,
-0.3783612549,
0.4344657958,
-0.1266722381,
0.9259070158,
-0.33450225,
-0.2172614783,
0.3374449611,
-0.0172056276,
-0.3680962324,
-0.4057105482,
0.7550470829,
-0.6939432621,
-0.1671453863,
-0.3000601232,
-0.2668317854,
-0.2062247843,
0.3478057683,
0.1855898798,
0.3642980456,
-0.2756022513,
0.2600306273,
0.9301099777,
-0.4732388258,
0.3312918544,
0.9578239322,
0.2892224789,
-0.2266038358,
0.5960147977,
0.2334323078,
0.4215699732,
0.602476716,
0.3488205373,
0.1231645495,
-0.5730242729,
-0.4041784406,
0.1696248651,
-0.9835740328,
-0.1346147507,
-0.3560192883,
-0.2215597034,
-0.7178575993,
-0.19686535,
-0.4208408892,
0.0880802348,
-0.4270893931,
0.2511020899,
0.1907266825,
0.5999543667,
0.1323285103,
0.5726953149,
-0.8723698258,
0.354057163,
0.3294068873,
0.609562993,
0.1499247998,
-0.6274039149,
-0.5593104362,
-0.0833415836,
-0.2018488795,
-0.6257396936,
0.2996643782,
0.2933976352,
0.5656043887,
0.7879483104,
0.068733871,
0.9098500609,
-0.6182875633,
0.9752293825,
-0.1230867729,
-1.0673899651,
0.3435429931,
-0.0466467552,
0.3565532267,
0.4687006176,
-0.0232524332,
-0.8053824306,
-0.0880451277,
-0.0734343827,
-0.7004429102,
0.7751725316,
-0.0637399331,
-0.1330948025,
0.0199503824,
0.4097269177,
-0.0252656005,
-0.364831239,
-0.7400307059,
-0.0505749509,
0.1114820242,
-0.1015544981,
0.2234054804,
-0.6075771451,
0.3063610792,
0.0760115534,
0.875869751,
-0.2493778765,
-0.1192909554,
0.3080325723,
-0.4224669039,
-0.0285929479,
0.503431201,
0.7342357039,
0.1386829019,
0.0735160112,
0.1362927407,
0.6990443468,
-0.4234732091,
-0.4103469253,
-0.229309544,
-0.0508392863,
-0.1529353112,
0.7616016269,
0.6877657771,
0.5620300174,
-0.636033833,
0.5325033665,
0.2475333661,
-0.1906395853,
-0.1800218225,
-0.0962551385,
-0.0549540669,
0.2384325713,
0.2824215889,
-0.3145778477,
0.0213791318,
-0.3141207099,
0.1399532408,
0.6532862186,
-0.3049605787,
0.0059684315,
0.1549109668,
0.2804900706,
0.1994558573,
0.5857284665,
-0.0171631109,
-0.9844534993,
0.4476119578,
0.5996444821,
0.6974146962,
-0.187214151,
-0.1999243945,
0.4490567446,
0.4255321324,
-0.4844081104,
0.0061157998,
-0.419734031,
-0.9196638465,
-0.5844632387,
-0.4527707398,
-0.5149949193,
-0.014643969,
-0.1105460078,
0.7227194309,
-0.5144813061,
0.1657715142,
-0.4312938452,
0.3453916907,
-0.6094498634,
0.2839983702,
0.5765081644,
0.9099647999,
-0.8820212483,
1.2152899504,
0.3578353822,
-0.040082559,
-1.1208233833,
0.0198068302,
0.1522078663,
-0.900851965,
1.0387579203,
0.0923925042,
-0.3559183776,
-0.1964378655,
-0.7179204226,
-0.8571515083,
1.1046518087,
-0.0269498564,
-0.5807824731,
0.145602569,
0.3444103003,
0.6925770044,
-0.2150552571,
0.2829744816,
0.3968891501,
0.4444202185,
0.4142688513,
-0.9314945936,
-0.2284797132,
0.1223297119,
0.2323096842,
-0.2401340604,
-0.5090323687,
0.719617784,
-0.2176990658,
-0.5172173977,
0.3110624254,
1.0387717485,
0.3636315763,
0.1368672103,
0.5016289949,
0.3817676902,
0.614679873,
0.1217472181,
0.8068368435,
-0.3176507354,
0.2890824676,
1.0630640984,
-0.6440145969,
1.2587319613,
0.2965223789,
-0.0702066571,
0.5359486341,
0.5426475406,
-0.0141619062,
0.3791015148,
0.2539378703,
-0.3130685389,
-0.6074898243,
-0.0395415351,
-0.1594974548,
0.5492609143,
0.453235507,
-0.3439677954,
-0.4126823246,
0.0855568275,
-0.2580950856,
0.1950083375,
-0.4237954021,
0.8380332589,
0.1240297556,
-0.2731615007,
0.4717288911,
0.361738354,
1.3258297443,
-0.9004229903,
-0.1371161789,
-0.1173199862,
0.4034568071,
-0.3937696815,
-0.4773108065,
-0.0832832903,
0.0856932551,
-0.1452579647,
0.0531016737,
1.1336712837,
-0.6394676566,
-0.3355223536,
0.3249549866,
0.1551551819,
0.1338897347,
0.0559884347,
-0.5093514919,
0.0133451102,
-0.135348022,
-0.1016352102,
0.3591953218,
0.5524855852,
-0.092961207,
0.4820503592,
0.5825266838,
0.2467071265,
0.0567134954,
0.029560823,
0.593057394,
-0.6365704536,
-0.6914180517,
-0.7888374925,
0.2100298852,
0.1815573424,
-0.1475376785,
0.9426135421,
0.3031668067,
0.8788559437,
-0.0391629748,
0.6336131692,
0.2062511444,
0.6394915581,
-0.56987077,
0.9690455198,
-0.5596556664,
0.3600375354,
-0.5282183886,
-0.7323666811,
-0.6693688631,
0.6891983747,
-0.4424926341,
-0.0982791558,
0.7117798328,
0.9588736892,
0.1714259088,
0.054705251,
0.7671202421,
0.1138811633,
0.1946035922,
0.9467238784,
0.7247402072,
-0.4005839527,
0.4727295935,
-0.3404497206,
-0.294301331,
-0.4324169755,
-0.9441450834,
-1.178827405,
-0.3758193552,
-0.0946149454,
-0.5959889293,
-0.1322429031,
1.0828193426,
0.5646452904,
-0.934926331,
0.0545352623,
0.2597498596,
0.2225107998,
-0.2396629602,
-0.1809883118,
0.5783113837,
-0.2172410339,
-0.6886687279,
0.3999769688,
0.2493412793,
0.0056302333,
-0.2409594506,
-0.0976272076,
-0.2109487951,
0.0699658543,
0.9391979575,
0.2890195549,
-0.9477226734,
-0.4166894555,
0.0564776175,
-0.649222374,
-0.1990118176,
0.700872004,
-0.7511788011,
0.4432244301,
0.7565953732,
0.8336855769,
0.0383681878,
-0.3381815553,
0.1564058661,
-0.5478480458,
0.0737398788,
-0.1105503589,
0.4524537921,
0.4356757104,
-0.547937274,
0.0997912735,
0.1960407495,
-0.3037581146,
-0.5408216715,
0.0997323021,
-0.9818232059,
-0.4089609683,
1.4178994894,
-0.2703664005,
-0.3848437071,
-0.090716064,
-0.2669129074,
0.3222351372,
-0.1330893338,
0.6876185536,
0.7668097615,
0.2012605816,
0.0961479992,
-0.1755536646,
0.3630371094,
0.613587141,
-0.6290155053,
0.1049602702,
0.4720823765,
0.4211663306,
-0.0756384805,
0.2664029896,
-0.1357642859,
0.3359078467,
-0.1764197797,
0.2507799864,
0.0232804939,
-0.1512146294,
-0.3981104493,
0.1918856055,
0.0798478648,
0.1569038481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08484v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08484v1
|
Data-oriented Dynamic Fine-tuning Parameter Selection Strategy for FISH Mask based Efficient Fine-tuning
| 2024-03-13T12:50:23 | 2024-03-13T12:50:23 |
Ming Dong, Kang Xue, Bolong Zheng, Tingting He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In view of the huge number of parameters of Large language models (LLMs) ,
tuning all parameters is very costly, and accordingly fine-tuning specific
parameters is more sensible. Most of parameter efficient fine-tuning (PEFT)
concentrate on parameter selection strategies, such as additive method,
selective method and reparametrization-based method. However, there are few
methods that consider the impact of data samples on parameter selecting, such
as Fish Mask based method. Fish Mask randomly choose a part of data samples and
treat them equally during parameter selection, which is unable to dynamically
select optimal parameters for inconstant data distributions. In this work, we
adopt a data-oriented perspective, then proposing an IRD ($\mathrm{\underline
I}$terative sample-parameter $\mathrm{\underline R}$ange $\mathrm{\underline
D}$ecreasing) algorithm to search the best setting of sample-parameter pair for
FISH Mask. In each iteration, by searching the set of samples and parameters
with larger Fish information, IRD can find better sample-parameter pair in most
scale. We demonstrate the effectiveness and rationality of proposed strategy by
conducting experiments on GLUE benchmark. Experimental results show our
strategy optimizes the parameter selection and achieves preferable performance.
|
[
-0.8289417624,
-1.2100906372,
0.3363417089,
0.0324611217,
-0.7536883354,
0.1713128388,
-0.4136315286,
-0.4397661388,
0.4165042937,
0.4640528262,
-0.6201953888,
-0.4039023817,
-0.3833609223,
0.0810260475,
-0.0301194359,
0.7010816336,
-0.0580261834,
-0.2257698774,
0.0964835733,
-0.1249431893,
-0.4392143786,
0.0486175008,
-0.8808633685,
-0.1405088156,
0.7101913095,
0.6547543406,
0.4368019998,
1.3815305233,
0.6413810849,
0.2550422549,
-0.2219776809,
0.5185851455,
-0.5154111385,
0.4048592448,
-0.2716076374,
-0.5240464211,
-0.2732332349,
0.2037693709,
0.539090097,
0.5567570925,
-0.1343938112,
0.3570896685,
-0.05910955,
0.8276265264,
-0.7231326103,
0.0395158902,
-0.7289311886,
0.1599618942,
-0.7132759094,
-0.6112980247,
-0.2482878566,
-0.0894128084,
-0.1252616644,
-0.5147984028,
-0.0391961783,
0.1584352702,
0.859162271,
0.2824986875,
-0.1631558836,
-0.0008602932,
-0.8669812679,
0.8386675715,
-0.6878822446,
0.4288183451,
0.414169997,
0.1975263357,
-0.2491352707,
-0.5978153944,
-0.2877821624,
0.0369137414,
0.3229814172,
-0.1053478494,
0.3972429037,
0.0607159398,
0.2338627279,
0.3953775465,
-0.4326221347,
0.308850795,
-0.0587540939,
-0.0534916706,
0.7121816874,
0.0087104617,
0.0890629143,
0.399500221,
-0.5654548407,
-0.4047197104,
-0.6845781207,
0.0720255598,
0.6391034126,
0.573338449,
0.0466891453,
0.3796335757,
-0.5529423356,
0.9414858222,
0.519877553,
-0.3965379894,
0.1276382059,
0.0414361134,
-0.2107631862,
-0.0089272689,
0.2921367586,
0.2583280504,
0.2235608101,
0.1188863814,
-0.5087079406,
-0.0632850677,
-0.0591024607,
-0.6771377325,
-0.2336238921,
0.2494977713,
-0.5213800073,
-0.5029748082,
-0.0793085694,
-0.9365737438,
-0.1743868738,
-0.6266610026,
0.5822899342,
-0.1998058558,
-0.2852719426,
0.148196727,
0.0820965841,
0.2332359552,
0.3148095906,
-0.8748835921,
0.1862253845,
0.622241497,
0.6728504896,
-0.485235393,
-0.0175754651,
-1.0293344259,
0.3094577789,
-0.217514351,
1.2904578447,
-1.013094306,
-0.0054702121,
-0.4060869217,
-0.1251417249,
-0.2382228523,
-0.7249884009,
0.4116151631,
-0.6660158038,
-0.0150439655,
-0.0130694024,
-0.7177699804,
-0.2749722302,
0.1213030592,
-0.7189773321,
0.6011145115,
0.0728617087,
-0.6124925017,
0.5564327836,
-0.7095831633,
-0.3082486391,
0.2394910157,
-0.2681161761,
-0.7011224031,
-0.099992007,
0.2636412084,
0.518219471,
-0.2528306544,
0.3040159941,
-0.7544665337,
-0.6692063808,
0.1892412603,
-0.5164507031,
0.3360801637,
0.6440213919,
-0.5803744793,
-0.0662191436,
-0.6960955262,
0.3903457522,
-0.0263910219,
-0.578184247,
-0.2370538116,
0.1942668855,
0.1595396399,
-0.2382367849,
-0.0056196693,
-0.4161887467,
0.2054106742,
-0.2796129286,
0.2459092438,
1.0239014626,
0.2577202022,
0.2778545916,
-0.4401775897,
0.5977982283,
-0.1182816103,
0.3094203174,
0.0462602712,
-0.17676346,
-0.3478800654,
-0.7543084621,
0.7455682755,
0.4533338249,
-0.6120103002,
0.3348407745,
0.2637907267,
-0.4374613762,
-0.3080485761,
0.3180984557,
0.3905248344,
0.4191935658,
-0.0143590709,
-0.2092290074,
-0.2686550319,
-0.9461099505,
-0.5101645589,
0.1469202042,
0.1534917057,
0.409165889,
-0.0409607328,
-0.0550930537,
0.7029449344,
-0.8717424273,
-0.4304507077,
-0.059791144,
-0.2369754463,
0.5169051886,
0.540653646,
0.6536431909,
-1.1422752142,
-0.8234644532,
-0.0077639204,
-0.1695960462,
-0.1522654295,
-0.0775859728,
-0.305894196,
0.1847845912,
0.5090163946,
-0.226005584,
0.189376995,
0.4588589966,
-0.3453612626,
0.1766025871,
-0.2034815103,
0.091046378,
-0.6813830733,
0.1531257331,
0.1854071617,
-0.1761035621,
-0.391720593,
0.3024379313,
0.053657867,
0.1269664019,
-0.2978986502,
0.4592067301,
-0.4685822725,
0.3913422823,
-0.3471512496,
-0.1622973233,
-0.2104105502,
0.5512416959,
0.0242840461,
0.5314593315,
0.6581685543,
-0.5362442732,
0.4544211626,
-0.1498872489,
-0.3737049103,
0.6156898737,
-0.4173891842,
0.1985697001,
-0.1008209661,
0.0320319161,
-0.8810136318,
-0.2364184707,
0.3569538891,
-0.0808737949,
0.719550848,
-0.238627255,
-0.478490144,
0.0436550342,
-0.6144264936,
0.5178687572,
0.3056918979,
-0.5329951048,
0.2726724446,
0.6225796938,
-0.3876438439,
-0.2435810268,
-0.3854380548,
-0.0770655274,
-0.7328605056,
-0.4368929565,
0.401576072,
-0.484811455,
-0.1578065753,
-0.377201587,
-0.3789937496,
-0.0417658724,
0.0175014194,
-0.3203082681,
0.2042230219,
-0.3807193339,
-0.077440314,
0.2411512136,
-0.3672978878,
-0.431756705,
-0.1752588153,
0.6600370407,
0.0299107544,
-0.4788832068,
-0.2279788852,
0.3411616981,
0.5395663381,
-0.501920104,
0.3993935585,
0.5765773058,
-0.0664797127,
-0.4357707202,
-0.92220819,
-0.3003098667,
-0.5692468882,
0.2153856158,
-0.3088614345,
-0.575971067,
0.6485719085,
-0.3804019094,
-0.0937168151,
0.063669838,
0.2501114309,
-0.1417385787,
0.9544088244,
0.3326567113,
0.0537954494,
0.6559963822,
-0.255828172,
0.0789352804,
-0.7907279134,
-0.0775755048,
-0.3451545537,
-0.9007921815,
-0.7254056334,
-0.1983925849,
0.5752339363,
0.0710200369,
-0.1045106351,
0.0271101557,
-0.6664037704,
0.6352052689,
0.7381811142,
0.4346364737,
0.3000270724,
0.318906337,
-0.0963210911,
0.1123095378,
-0.507835269,
-0.2398922592,
1.0782982111,
0.2997516394,
0.9624480009,
-0.1356028914,
0.6270306706,
0.1626076847,
-0.3525979817,
-0.4816161692,
0.6162333488,
-0.2765436769,
-0.4341621399,
-0.5064677596,
-0.2467453331,
-0.9159085751,
0.2022640854,
-0.0882758945,
-0.6432608962,
0.626781404,
0.2442424893,
-0.2429171354,
0.4889232218,
-0.7040529847,
0.3751306534,
-0.1611561626,
-0.4094821215,
-0.1233546063,
-0.5442759991,
0.0406577662,
-0.5444873571,
0.1885708719,
-0.3453714848,
-0.3301782608,
0.6664156318,
-0.1971630454,
0.547760427,
-0.5044159889,
-0.2541992962,
0.0806222484,
0.061392948,
0.9017224312,
0.3786333203,
-0.3303787112,
-0.1045132726,
0.0860311463,
-0.2643909752,
-0.4173333943,
0.8174402714,
-0.4420099854,
-0.5878762603,
-0.1117449552,
-0.5387779474,
-0.4003878236,
0.2774584591,
0.2343760729,
0.5726008415,
0.5000914335,
0.520444572,
0.984231472,
-0.1768265367,
0.5395466685,
0.9057800174,
0.0802900121,
-0.529966712,
0.9432556033,
0.3595649004,
0.3543581665,
0.4943528175,
0.2317751199,
-0.0863313377,
-0.6414940357,
-0.3490059078,
0.3241568804,
-0.3217532933,
-0.5062584281,
-0.1239845157,
-0.1608708948,
0.0430147909,
-0.0567135438,
-0.5587946177,
-0.0855645388,
-0.1862021685,
0.2031898797,
0.5881283283,
0.0392534509,
-0.2001902014,
-0.0145974755,
-0.3654272556,
0.6970877051,
0.2873565257,
1.1026055813,
-0.2176470757,
-0.2994952798,
-0.1947053075,
0.3451754451,
-0.2555434704,
-0.5123886466,
0.1780357063,
0.4961776733,
0.6786468029,
0.5997524858,
0.4396157563,
0.8007999659,
-0.1393000335,
0.1546277255,
-0.3577607572,
-0.5438632369,
0.7459085584,
-0.6457981467,
0.1902628839,
0.5942195654,
-0.1375276297,
-0.1580872089,
-0.5460972786,
-0.5720512867,
-0.9555541873,
0.8777520657,
0.1256284267,
-0.0663667321,
0.263722986,
0.5566020012,
0.2929317355,
0.0502627976,
-0.2752205729,
-0.4232191443,
0.5090072155,
0.0830538869,
-0.0747047588,
-0.0799110383,
0.0515993424,
-0.605543673,
0.5511336923,
-0.2998456657,
0.3035050631,
0.0101655852,
0.3283567131,
-0.6473352909,
0.0137132183,
0.7438255548,
0.6662307382,
-0.4665112793,
-0.0342349783,
0.0186881293,
-0.6618403196,
0.0627207533,
0.049277436,
-0.2469142973,
-0.0478179008,
0.0482832529,
0.7046377659,
0.0731440187,
-0.6979952455,
0.2972412407,
0.22271052,
-0.2746344209,
-0.0182347503,
0.570351243,
0.0076830685,
0.5542709827,
0.4968729913,
0.1462612897,
0.0275007784,
-0.4017350674,
0.3220024407,
0.624710381,
-0.0659624934,
-0.0195037089,
0.5330684781,
-0.1055763289,
-0.3100638688,
0.484674871,
0.1677236855,
-0.0526935831,
0.7897148132,
0.422347486,
0.6885437965,
-0.4492587447,
0.2294388413,
0.0188468192,
-0.0995236263,
-0.112586461,
0.5259341598,
-0.0803440362,
-0.495670706,
-0.4765070379,
-0.6022028923,
-0.2053694129,
0.4716371596,
-0.7848165035,
0.6175580025,
-0.3424905241,
0.07264065,
-0.0113284132,
0.3269554377,
-0.3841828108,
0.2187348008,
0.0364245512,
1.0344548225,
-0.6499447823,
0.9342224002,
0.7114447355,
0.0112739103,
-0.8252210021,
0.0471876226,
-0.1156163961,
-0.812784493,
0.3960725069,
-0.320951134,
0.1244889349,
0.0995256081,
-0.7184736729,
-1.2311487198,
1.0717116594,
0.7041139603,
-0.7034472823,
0.3044042587,
0.0730221942,
0.3564085364,
-0.3315677941,
-0.0049867383,
0.5023114085,
0.7923468947,
0.4027815759,
-1.0338777304,
-0.0275572557,
-0.3543876708,
0.1803012192,
0.4943138957,
-0.887262404,
0.8068987727,
0.1100797877,
-0.1123567224,
-0.12505202,
0.2233301103,
0.4399842918,
0.3973291814,
0.7402161956,
0.2672985792,
0.5941959023,
0.2061930448,
0.5592896938,
-0.3093230128,
0.4548704922,
0.9001022577,
-0.2081623673,
0.9750266075,
0.7389609218,
-0.2122515738,
0.1205912605,
0.8778773546,
-0.4230496585,
1.0343066454,
0.2654963732,
-0.1436890811,
-0.3080273867,
0.0756085068,
-0.421617806,
0.6281683445,
0.295881778,
-0.288544476,
-0.2892341316,
0.2893990278,
-0.1517391354,
-0.0147515414,
-0.2034709901,
1.0080127716,
-0.1577367783,
-0.7446983457,
0.8544504642,
-0.0384963341,
0.7365120649,
-0.473911047,
-0.0834741294,
-0.4733644724,
0.4326914549,
-0.1879641563,
-0.7396184206,
0.0935684592,
-0.261580795,
-0.1609566063,
-0.2478963882,
0.7185271382,
-0.5437434316,
-0.321373105,
-0.1388218552,
0.1263638437,
-0.1129961088,
-0.2029008269,
-0.5691146851,
0.401027441,
0.1061094329,
-0.5623781681,
0.6044695377,
0.3205025494,
0.0537487827,
0.8673225045,
0.6384703517,
0.5836221576,
-0.3518418372,
-0.3884089887,
0.9254345894,
-0.4826515019,
-0.6173813343,
-0.8284022808,
0.3683098555,
0.085561417,
-0.0837125033,
0.3536021411,
0.6063114405,
0.8129287362,
-0.1602724791,
0.3748752773,
0.0367352031,
0.8422660828,
-0.6861231327,
0.6386258602,
-0.5564745665,
0.5815650225,
-0.6520605683,
-1.3763908148,
-0.4356462657,
0.6418232918,
-0.0223306231,
0.0775944814,
0.3602933586,
1.0057922602,
-0.3795108199,
0.0260176864,
0.1619806886,
0.0865395516,
0.2266146392,
0.3549752235,
0.4338211715,
-0.1852524132,
0.3215426803,
-0.3445319235,
-0.2229712903,
-0.3182903528,
-0.9923099875,
-0.5977047682,
-0.7226523757,
-0.7224702835,
0.2194837183,
-0.0071046813,
0.9309354424,
0.8812055588,
-0.7005759478,
-0.203328833,
0.0583237559,
-0.0411529727,
-0.3598513007,
-0.2818188369,
0.4244456887,
-0.3395255804,
-0.7211328745,
0.1858634651,
0.4509212673,
-0.0186330453,
-0.0410301462,
0.0829118565,
-0.2022024542,
0.1883703619,
0.3956291378,
0.2600976229,
-0.7459961176,
-0.3761969507,
-0.1345427632,
0.3282029033,
0.0184080154,
0.4370739162,
-0.7541697621,
0.5180168152,
0.3579772413,
0.4056523144,
0.5695494413,
-0.1613385379,
0.6778967977,
-0.5581406951,
0.0384744704,
0.0691092983,
-0.0251101572,
-0.1738668829,
-0.5966774225,
0.6058418155,
0.0814078897,
-0.4897034764,
-1.117210865,
-0.0099514052,
-1.0140185356,
-0.4116995335,
1.2346476316,
0.0558479689,
-0.0119033968,
0.0500250459,
-0.3836577237,
0.0603714399,
-0.2872364521,
0.8297790289,
0.3448319435,
-0.3213035762,
-0.3459562063,
-0.3482998908,
0.5600923896,
0.2284722626,
-0.5846025348,
-0.066973716,
0.1232392937,
0.4275282621,
-0.2630938888,
0.1722911447,
0.0070051472,
0.118716985,
-0.3810167015,
-0.6264182329,
-0.1894571036,
-0.0999239162,
-0.0017417863,
0.1505545527,
0.1883547753,
-0.2959822416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08462v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08462v1
|
Authorship Verification based on the Likelihood Ratio of Grammar Models
| 2024-03-13T12:25:47 | 2024-03-13T12:25:47 |
Andrea Nini, Oren Halvani, Lukas Graner, Valerio Gherardi, Shunichi Ishihara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Authorship Verification (AV) is the process of analyzing a set of documents
to determine whether they were written by a specific author. This problem often
arises in forensic scenarios, e.g., in cases where the documents in question
constitute evidence for a crime. Existing state-of-the-art AV methods use
computational solutions that are not supported by a plausible scientific
explanation for their functioning and that are often difficult for analysts to
interpret. To address this, we propose a method relying on calculating a
quantity we call $\lambda_G$ (LambdaG): the ratio between the likelihood of a
document given a model of the Grammar for the candidate author and the
likelihood of the same document given a model of the Grammar for a reference
population. These Grammar Models are estimated using $n$-gram language models
that are trained solely on grammatical features. Despite not needing large
amounts of data for training, LambdaG still outperforms other established AV
methods with higher computational complexity, including a fine-tuned Siamese
Transformer network. Our empirical evaluation based on four baseline methods
applied to twelve datasets shows that LambdaG leads to better results in terms
of both accuracy and AUC in eleven cases and in all twelve cases if considering
only topic-agnostic methods. The algorithm is also highly robust to important
variations in the genre of the reference population in many cross-genre
comparisons. In addition to these properties, we demonstrate how LambdaG is
easier to interpret than the current state-of-the-art. We argue that the
advantage of LambdaG over other methods is due to fact that it is compatible
with Cognitive Linguistic theories of language processing.
|
[
-0.2914760709,
-0.6453983784,
0.7613933682,
-0.0950455889,
-0.0399012752,
-0.1241887584,
-0.2204066366,
-0.3211014271,
0.0683308691,
0.3786874413,
-0.3921377361,
-0.4199994802,
-0.8860093951,
0.4768634737,
-0.5430159569,
0.7070547342,
0.4201292396,
0.1247915253,
-0.7298119068,
-0.1661637872,
-0.1810759604,
-0.7147390842,
-0.6711097956,
-0.1126378998,
0.3751827776,
-0.1285717487,
0.4542410076,
0.821773231,
0.7032152414,
0.3082004786,
-0.0590498261,
0.1688665599,
-0.2616606355,
0.0338048935,
-0.0434768349,
-0.4415468872,
-0.4807634652,
0.0930075347,
0.4601987302,
0.6831100583,
0.2614958882,
0.2980619073,
-0.0846607611,
0.5938001275,
-0.9511033297,
0.0705925822,
-0.4289062619,
-0.1881738454,
-0.3191058338,
-0.2747849226,
-0.6732011437,
-0.505918324,
-0.177910611,
-0.4824579358,
0.5536986589,
-0.1449954808,
0.5493027568,
0.1159173325,
-0.7356026769,
-0.4411126971,
-0.7748923302,
0.6785427928,
-0.732070148,
0.164006874,
0.7568078637,
0.077805303,
-0.2420536578,
-0.7596667409,
-0.6593006849,
-0.4099306464,
-0.282055527,
-0.1270265579,
-0.1327435374,
0.2019145042,
0.2689734697,
0.785938859,
-0.5796132684,
-0.2082826495,
-0.4851493835,
-0.4531309009,
0.7674917579,
-0.2124011368,
0.4585770965,
-0.1133462787,
-0.0624559335,
0.1103225872,
-0.8340537548,
0.3299604952,
0.6633125544,
0.2344110161,
0.2354370952,
0.6022405028,
0.1220529526,
0.7759032249,
0.271843642,
-0.0957958102,
0.1145706624,
-0.4612961411,
-0.1547285318,
0.0557957031,
0.8330081701,
-0.0438761897,
0.2061290145,
-0.0899885967,
0.0677834898,
0.0275860932,
0.4586884975,
-0.3036109209,
0.0302455481,
0.1481308192,
-0.3926342428,
-0.2947665155,
0.5172199011,
-0.4116322696,
-0.5327096581,
-0.3440675437,
0.3577128351,
-0.3937697411,
-0.1281019896,
-0.1602533311,
0.1060974449,
0.1948588043,
0.2743191421,
-0.9804973006,
0.1806501746,
1.1231975555,
0.7425071001,
0.1781568676,
-0.17896761,
-0.9816657305,
-0.2590633035,
-0.4935026169,
0.3802137077,
-0.4372265041,
-0.0457535759,
0.2255357057,
-0.0032205868,
-0.0543268248,
-0.2056472152,
0.8645024896,
-0.4156256914,
0.2607269287,
-0.4448774159,
-0.9692941308,
-0.2116775215,
0.0293069463,
-0.8554719687,
1.1916143894,
0.1358094811,
-0.6126827002,
0.5253072977,
-0.0457426459,
-0.2874321342,
0.2258674353,
-0.3437896967,
-0.4602354169,
0.4035334885,
0.5131605268,
0.5787332654,
-0.3961703777,
0.4082135856,
-0.202220127,
-0.1570985019,
0.3343833089,
-0.0154124498,
1.2587268353,
0.1604826301,
-0.1187753081,
-0.0849600062,
-0.8933005333,
-0.2363339365,
-0.2139813751,
-0.1670760065,
-0.3906462491,
0.1124696508,
-0.2177218497,
-0.2125551403,
0.0506158583,
-0.693688333,
0.205896467,
-0.255464077,
0.0745754838,
0.632219255,
0.0317296386,
0.4222850502,
-0.5443096161,
0.7429071069,
-0.5965729356,
-0.0869157314,
-0.2212337852,
-0.6050288081,
-0.5316979289,
-0.5784003139,
0.5226820111,
0.3216720521,
-0.4559666216,
0.8491336107,
-0.228901729,
-0.4299716353,
-0.6289128661,
0.2696883678,
0.4415982068,
0.4915771484,
0.1344566643,
-0.3072955608,
-0.6844794154,
-0.713365078,
-0.336147964,
-0.629026711,
-0.3744584322,
0.1824520826,
0.3826337457,
0.1299646348,
1.1808869839,
-0.0477475263,
-0.353615135,
-0.2086155713,
0.4294624329,
0.3493003845,
0.3979832232,
0.8639961481,
-0.4824212492,
-0.4627925456,
0.0342328921,
-1.1119776964,
-0.4796480834,
-0.1016548499,
0.1075079218,
0.2725481391,
0.9461088181,
-0.2315834463,
0.5029838085,
0.4940221906,
-0.4176881909,
0.6822761297,
-0.1186674535,
0.2695271969,
-0.7607957125,
0.2492834181,
0.1564403325,
-0.5171487331,
-0.741330564,
0.390526861,
0.0125180399,
0.1842130125,
-0.3517533839,
0.4476753175,
-0.5800326467,
0.2885221839,
-0.1527189612,
-0.2299542278,
-0.2318439186,
0.3935547769,
-0.3771713078,
0.7586966753,
0.6641725302,
-0.5636301637,
0.5027779341,
-0.0649240464,
-0.5057101846,
0.7570290565,
-0.5613822937,
0.3185375035,
-0.2902511954,
0.2433925867,
-1.1141262054,
-0.0727598146,
0.0153265726,
-0.7291251421,
0.0365506001,
-0.3320375979,
-0.4540355206,
-0.0817363337,
-0.122835353,
0.7405059934,
0.4598106444,
-0.4245827794,
1.0386273861,
0.1879756153,
-0.3551967442,
-0.6442593336,
-0.2827762961,
0.0910849944,
-0.1564038098,
-0.7101750374,
0.2544178963,
0.2979682684,
-0.4976221323,
-0.029288901,
-0.0261342414,
-0.1133383885,
-0.084262602,
0.1577019095,
0.3062649071,
-0.166446656,
0.2020189166,
-0.2120556831,
-0.0669118017,
0.2093905061,
-0.3261440694,
0.0786163062,
-0.0526053458,
-0.2778626084,
-0.3039094508,
0.3273979425,
0.6613285542,
-0.3250961006,
0.6895616651,
0.6610355377,
-0.3800152242,
-0.0523115806,
-0.7028500438,
-0.2339556366,
-0.3718807995,
0.072366409,
-0.2384669483,
-0.8237497807,
0.7475718856,
0.2644753456,
-0.0897973478,
0.6796473265,
0.523547411,
0.114036493,
0.4985278547,
0.7093518376,
-0.2136959881,
0.3841966987,
-0.011247009,
0.318860352,
-0.6713840365,
-0.058938019,
-0.8033884168,
-0.1477062106,
-0.533490181,
-0.2178247124,
0.5518701673,
-0.053262841,
0.0481277704,
0.3531550765,
-0.2517337799,
0.4687662125,
0.7729078531,
-0.0290038846,
0.4041226208,
-0.1424655914,
-0.1562731117,
0.0977900475,
-0.4335278273,
-0.613047123,
1.6161715984,
0.1518457979,
0.4544402659,
0.3975248039,
0.6320323944,
0.7877622247,
0.1511902064,
-0.6494710445,
0.5735052824,
-0.2038469017,
-0.8641464114,
-0.502998054,
-0.4544631243,
-0.8887348771,
0.3545207679,
-0.5005276799,
-0.9387072921,
0.3844130635,
0.1446408182,
-0.3883942664,
0.0456927903,
-0.3260286748,
0.5373615623,
-0.0367800966,
-0.4536004066,
0.0289796684,
-0.615421772,
0.3806891441,
-0.172716409,
0.3989636302,
0.0537768938,
0.3527905941,
0.7285268903,
-0.9051597118,
0.5943573713,
0.0026394026,
-0.1478305459,
0.4562761486,
0.1256305128,
0.533480823,
0.2561794519,
-0.2926284373,
0.2292237729,
-0.0658366978,
-0.2630257905,
-0.7827788591,
0.3424522579,
-0.6240602732,
-0.5006813407,
-0.701601088,
-0.3133534193,
-0.0374146365,
0.1605229974,
0.6709298491,
0.4641927779,
-0.4233392477,
0.613409698,
0.2183044255,
-0.0011293476,
0.2744575739,
0.0685887411,
-0.0693107098,
-0.594543159,
0.4803632498,
-0.1390955597,
0.1319064349,
0.4759985209,
0.163064748,
-0.3100922108,
-0.3208344877,
-0.2337574959,
0.3096827269,
-0.6299908161,
0.0004280514,
-0.6206740737,
-0.158351019,
-0.5460879207,
-0.294116348,
-0.1461185217,
-0.4919230342,
-0.2192513645,
-0.0454016514,
0.0597100966,
0.4115464687,
0.0018470864,
0.2802663445,
-0.3455230594,
0.3575319946,
0.4981738329,
0.0471884832,
-0.1376427859,
-0.6855293512,
-0.2256417423,
-0.0829987526,
-0.1967378706,
-0.884642303,
0.1990073025,
0.3541531265,
0.5637420416,
0.4651892781,
-0.0122618293,
0.3985296488,
-0.2665210068,
0.8380286098,
-0.1112835556,
-1.3180407286,
0.3753424883,
-0.4532532394,
-0.1038053185,
0.7334396839,
0.0724048018,
-0.4208746254,
-0.8134258986,
-0.6620936394,
-0.8621717691,
0.5990415215,
0.6774691343,
-0.0781832188,
0.176357016,
0.5432178378,
0.1856309921,
-0.0170377903,
-0.8217352033,
-0.1350784749,
0.0369666927,
-0.1148933247,
-0.3929734528,
-0.337254256,
-0.0882827938,
-0.3255903423,
0.8485862613,
-0.0912533849,
0.2069886923,
0.2881452143,
-0.1615002602,
0.0533151142,
0.1768722981,
0.6180644631,
0.833558023,
-0.3845355213,
0.290301919,
-0.1648720801,
-0.4141969979,
0.4622927606,
-0.1157083586,
-0.1947406381,
0.2326586396,
1.0479174852,
0.5102060437,
-0.3018429875,
-0.2908488512,
0.8248294592,
-0.0455900133,
-0.4815548956,
-0.5542679429,
0.0034568834,
-0.3403610289,
-0.0202434696,
0.6535286307,
-0.0589287318,
0.1718029529,
-0.4016819,
0.1707106978,
0.3582370281,
-0.11970108,
-0.1948461831,
0.6667404175,
0.1291639209,
-0.4111357331,
0.6358600259,
-0.2193362117,
-0.1725449264,
1.032869339,
0.3003821969,
1.2528343201,
-0.2654635608,
0.2701420188,
0.5843474269,
0.4888650179,
-0.3004955649,
-0.1336393207,
-0.0888985768,
-0.5545104742,
-0.5541108251,
-0.5315451026,
-0.2870798409,
0.2130688578,
-0.7133868933,
0.1807362437,
-0.3439749777,
-0.3326230645,
0.3386527002,
-0.2206664383,
-0.3743060529,
0.0764198303,
0.0256664604,
0.4946720898,
-1.1787719727,
0.4931064248,
0.6364290714,
-0.2396675795,
-0.6764323711,
-0.0613138191,
0.521632731,
-0.5096532106,
0.4788372219,
0.0255565085,
-0.0033629164,
-0.0835200101,
-0.4860451519,
-0.7360200286,
0.8272939324,
0.6782364249,
-0.3161723018,
0.2973803282,
-0.0942837223,
0.7171484828,
-0.4364593625,
0.1344392896,
0.1504587829,
0.3178626001,
0.3002146482,
-0.9186012149,
0.127375111,
-0.5380106568,
0.0698655099,
0.0838246047,
0.0338130556,
0.98519063,
0.0448602811,
-0.0810732991,
0.1044695005,
0.8109502196,
0.1301210225,
0.2257803679,
0.4204643965,
0.3678449392,
1.0154426098,
-0.0939663723,
1.1546504498,
-0.3493050635,
0.5746312141,
0.8568358421,
-0.049002327,
0.400228411,
0.4345588088,
-0.4011332393,
0.5112793446,
0.2269540578,
-0.1588983685,
0.2185910642,
0.0946763083,
-0.5036212802,
-0.3036909699,
0.0859990567,
-0.3015809357,
0.6362606287,
-0.0921559185,
-0.8096522093,
0.0344089344,
0.0434525236,
0.0181842055,
0.269015193,
-0.3004793525,
0.8507483602,
-0.0838173032,
-1.0452592373,
0.5332260132,
0.1395775527,
0.2640331686,
-0.4400545359,
0.0678903535,
-0.1465737671,
0.296202898,
-0.3958170116,
-0.3488188386,
0.2757763565,
0.0948031843,
-0.1218489483,
-0.103239961,
0.4902760684,
-0.3795225024,
-0.9872859716,
-0.194566071,
0.4117772579,
0.0648339987,
-0.1484267265,
0.1910749376,
-0.1587272435,
-0.1900540143,
0.2138532251,
-0.1704532057,
0.399717629,
-0.0957943425,
0.4284116328,
0.6152017713,
0.2237188816,
0.0604227781,
-0.143270582,
0.3207085729,
-0.3652423322,
-0.6529606581,
-1.2564839125,
0.4074347317,
0.0699971914,
-0.2343881279,
0.776787281,
0.5949675441,
0.725304544,
-0.1385895461,
1.0122563839,
-0.3114286959,
0.2000124604,
-0.6604329944,
0.5103141665,
-0.4880514741,
0.2808715999,
-0.556660831,
-0.7679175138,
-0.6512003541,
0.7173056006,
-0.2388890982,
0.2160454839,
0.9098673463,
0.8005702496,
-0.0881160125,
-0.0045438563,
0.178161785,
-0.1839220673,
0.5457851887,
0.5328285098,
0.4396407902,
-0.4179715216,
0.1538523585,
-0.0763256401,
-0.544516921,
-0.4030836821,
-1.1096712351,
-0.956253469,
-0.8895095587,
-0.3748814166,
-0.4717144668,
0.0559750162,
0.8399503231,
0.7288922668,
-0.628634572,
-0.2422139496,
-0.368512243,
0.1131798625,
-0.7344034314,
-0.147861436,
0.4577811658,
-0.2167770565,
-0.6421111822,
0.0514119938,
0.2090305537,
-0.2834525704,
-0.1928324252,
-0.0649584904,
-0.2900592089,
0.3697567284,
0.3473611772,
0.4348454773,
-0.9393942356,
-0.1963222176,
-0.1097122356,
-0.2427975833,
0.1406884938,
1.0885711908,
-0.5436244607,
0.7963217497,
0.6243031025,
0.7842615843,
0.3611209095,
0.4826669991,
0.7374338508,
-0.937977612,
-0.1426256746,
0.1317519695,
0.5388782024,
0.0936726406,
-0.6377034783,
0.5680357814,
0.3683256805,
-0.6846159697,
-0.684623003,
0.2815105319,
-1.1824611425,
-0.0107427472,
1.1612719297,
-0.2188750654,
-0.2047561705,
-0.1707838625,
0.0129045304,
0.1355221421,
-0.2287428677,
1.067245841,
1.1508448124,
0.0032195724,
-0.2743591666,
-0.1860159039,
0.4731771946,
0.3188252151,
-0.6429587603,
0.0244787,
0.7077303529,
0.0056544309,
0.2981018722,
1.025906086,
-0.2416312546,
0.5545522571,
-0.0617077611,
0.1538853347,
-0.4024140537,
-0.2801733613,
-0.4874578118,
0.509706676,
-0.0269012135,
-0.1727934629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08424v1
|
Tastle: Distract Large Language Models for Automatic Jailbreak Attack
| 2024-03-13T11:16:43 | 2024-03-13T11:16:43 |
Zeguan Xiao, Yan Yang, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant advances in recent
days. Extensive efforts have been made before the public release of LLMs to
align their behaviors with human values. The primary goal of alignment is to
ensure their helpfulness, honesty and harmlessness. However, even meticulously
aligned LLMs remain vulnerable to malicious manipulations such as jailbreaking,
leading to unintended behaviors. The jailbreak is to intentionally develop a
malicious prompt that escapes from the LLM security restrictions to produce
uncensored detrimental contents. Previous works explore different jailbreak
methods for red teaming LLMs, yet they encounter challenges regarding to
effectiveness and scalability. In this work, we propose Tastle, a novel
black-box jailbreak framework for automated red teaming of LLMs. We designed
malicious content concealing and memory reframing with an iterative
optimization algorithm to jailbreak LLMs, motivated by the research about the
distractibility and over-confidence phenomenon of LLMs. Extensive experiments
of jailbreaking both open-source and proprietary LLMs demonstrate the
superiority of our framework in terms of effectiveness, scalability and
transferability. We also evaluate the effectiveness of existing jailbreak
defense methods against our attack and highlight the crucial need to develop
more effective and practical defense strategies.
|
[
-0.1642787009,
-1.1026142836,
0.3940657377,
0.3874326944,
-0.1492015421,
0.5168883801,
-0.3918059468,
-0.6336246133,
0.5214450359,
0.7571848035,
-0.3329252601,
-0.4683285058,
-0.7687543631,
-0.0713979155,
-0.604354322,
0.9473692179,
-0.1407321841,
-0.4643105865,
0.2356042266,
-0.1873065978,
-0.8823462129,
-0.4192372262,
-0.3878919184,
-0.0949334502,
0.3431042433,
0.3639163375,
0.5022026896,
0.5487817526,
0.4001432657,
0.35972175,
-0.0274000987,
0.0234335139,
-0.5606134534,
0.4137151539,
-0.3272414804,
-0.2970696986,
-0.1421446353,
-0.1143980026,
0.2756696641,
0.0896483958,
-0.1465760469,
0.1040196642,
-0.2827057838,
0.6640797853,
-0.900011301,
-0.3175154924,
-0.8765737414,
-0.1900544912,
-0.3215003908,
0.0561692081,
-0.6734435558,
-0.2359288931,
-0.2077585161,
-0.2309025079,
-0.2179442197,
0.0884204656,
0.7262836099,
0.5579458475,
-0.0797039866,
-0.1473890245,
-0.4801239669,
0.8092107773,
-0.6404078603,
-0.0243362859,
0.4014330506,
0.2428123206,
-0.3301271796,
-0.3797723055,
-0.2323140502,
-0.5261721015,
0.189904049,
-0.2690078914,
-0.4376936853,
0.0518958829,
0.0541945733,
0.0784570798,
-0.2203914523,
0.3022490144,
-0.3514375985,
-0.1652372777,
0.5872901082,
0.16094926,
0.4987701178,
0.1902585626,
-0.6400375962,
0.3733165562,
-0.5217642188,
-0.1761807352,
0.2253483981,
0.2666711211,
-0.3098271489,
0.5235188603,
-0.0182540212,
0.6589725018,
0.2130421251,
-0.1807921529,
0.0218316577,
-0.2866879702,
-0.1974967271,
-0.0187522061,
0.9641680717,
0.2941306829,
0.377227217,
-0.5105031729,
-0.3180832565,
-0.1459504664,
0.6418794394,
-0.6957839727,
-0.1607787609,
0.6069146395,
-0.0706384331,
-0.7763761282,
-0.0869224891,
-0.6464058757,
-0.7020407319,
0.3907113075,
0.4547809362,
-0.6156047583,
-0.2163643986,
0.0683239102,
-0.0962903351,
0.0300293118,
0.2530472279,
-0.813257277,
0.3606922925,
0.6382274032,
0.9853799343,
-0.3019410372,
-0.3655154407,
-0.7533895969,
0.452955395,
-0.1291133016,
0.5000470877,
-0.2663330734,
-0.2055622637,
-0.179786399,
-0.1960984766,
0.1226219833,
-0.5790060163,
0.0827581212,
-0.6220846176,
-0.2649028897,
0.1781868041,
-0.4635549784,
-0.1527720094,
0.4466397166,
-0.8335286379,
0.6391842365,
0.1160512045,
-0.6963275671,
0.232867837,
-0.5911590457,
-0.5658252239,
0.3190633655,
0.0095904041,
-0.6046720147,
0.0551791787,
0.0295653567,
0.1851663738,
-0.1525353491,
0.4175260663,
-0.377802819,
-0.4948007762,
0.3408066034,
0.0429068692,
0.9978078604,
0.280538857,
-0.6824387312,
0.2797493637,
-0.2983714044,
0.0166518204,
0.3616156578,
-0.1653396934,
-0.5242474079,
-0.0566593707,
-0.1229275241,
0.0311427452,
0.3542627394,
-0.6884738207,
0.3049806356,
-0.3201746047,
0.6161876321,
0.6588683128,
0.0743671954,
0.4100615978,
-0.2672479451,
0.7026292086,
-0.1933966428,
0.0882866904,
-0.1841708571,
-0.1112827957,
-0.18281205,
-0.6025471091,
0.1889322549,
0.6183027029,
-0.5689442158,
0.3559793234,
0.1928343773,
-0.4518972635,
-0.6502786279,
0.4427111745,
0.5816645622,
0.3643533885,
0.3772915602,
-0.1877460629,
-0.6239001155,
-0.7752599716,
-0.5373450518,
0.1499514431,
0.2919729054,
-0.0039136736,
0.5485962629,
-0.2249999344,
0.7732490897,
-0.2601064742,
-0.4278171062,
-0.5977882743,
-0.18436113,
0.0539924353,
0.5344226956,
0.6413754821,
-0.4903652966,
-0.4330918491,
-0.3140560985,
-0.5721493959,
-0.373534441,
-0.2283530235,
0.1798529476,
0.4533802569,
0.6582497358,
-0.4448798895,
0.4935994148,
0.4987679422,
-0.673309505,
0.8823186755,
0.0635501891,
-0.0394867733,
-0.8336246014,
-0.0624633916,
0.2250359952,
-0.4155466855,
-0.6312942505,
0.4188608229,
0.1704582423,
0.0527762659,
-0.6074380279,
0.7844792604,
-0.4145815969,
0.0770838112,
-0.3527408838,
0.202933982,
-0.0886580274,
0.2299462259,
-0.3269954026,
0.9682127237,
0.1657640189,
-0.2652726471,
0.3763220608,
0.0227561742,
-0.3712685108,
0.2703054249,
-0.7274785042,
0.1167395338,
0.2613119185,
0.0382839926,
-0.8768007755,
-0.0901972428,
0.1667827666,
-0.4395621717,
0.4664118886,
-0.4036210775,
-0.5948807597,
-0.1887840927,
-0.3737919629,
0.407761544,
0.4141111374,
-0.3875880241,
0.2346283197,
0.7369586229,
-0.0079839444,
-0.8047021627,
-0.7166138887,
0.4876109362,
-0.5505678058,
-0.6196258664,
0.3734180033,
0.159278959,
-0.7331844568,
-0.2311355621,
-0.0664367601,
-0.2451496869,
0.5319438577,
0.1994801313,
0.3977436423,
0.2174316645,
-0.1710279137,
-0.3286361992,
0.0704908669,
0.259493798,
-0.3746682703,
0.6727494001,
-0.1074452624,
-0.0256116837,
-0.5210905671,
0.2268401831,
0.6206122637,
-0.213622421,
1.0201466084,
0.4283047318,
0.0066924309,
-0.4892429411,
-0.8060811758,
-0.0084233265,
-0.5359448195,
0.5486102104,
-0.0638725087,
-1.0376929045,
0.4631359279,
-0.0071472893,
0.1834739,
-0.1430952549,
0.7336517572,
-0.0567031056,
0.4230766296,
0.8554009199,
-0.4450431168,
0.7396597862,
0.0275972355,
-0.0416519418,
-0.5051219463,
-0.2099505812,
-0.3415782154,
-0.4587294459,
-0.2585343122,
-0.2556944788,
-0.0534857698,
0.0211708974,
-0.3487333357,
0.6089621782,
-0.6278566122,
0.9011799693,
0.3360461295,
0.0031701762,
0.1862093061,
-0.2342442572,
-0.2170098424,
0.0144320531,
-0.3317086995,
-0.3471617997,
1.0442657471,
0.5364874005,
0.8766192794,
0.2148280442,
1.1027464867,
0.4390940964,
0.2229441255,
-0.7735610604,
0.5015113354,
0.0019529756,
-0.6478633285,
-0.4075064063,
-0.3075677156,
-0.7965399027,
0.094890736,
-0.0455920435,
-1.2224271297,
-0.4356506765,
0.084236756,
-0.2779612541,
0.6179586649,
-0.9002129436,
0.8420761824,
-0.2740031779,
-0.7520017028,
-0.1383902133,
-0.6722803712,
0.8353031874,
-0.3029888272,
0.4634777904,
-0.1416410357,
-0.1277316362,
0.7494578362,
-0.7384036779,
1.0165374279,
-0.297005266,
-0.1452958733,
0.29044047,
0.6227266192,
0.6348300576,
-0.0371942557,
0.0111547578,
0.0144444015,
-0.2620607615,
-0.5001749396,
-0.2861839831,
0.6652376056,
-0.5667167306,
-0.876326263,
-0.0726205185,
-0.8785723448,
0.0083350092,
0.4335050881,
0.0949488506,
-0.0404391587,
0.0691085756,
-0.0014283865,
0.5975334048,
-0.2758924663,
0.6971446872,
0.4421388507,
-0.2916683555,
-0.5128177404,
0.7333233356,
-0.1805869788,
0.5209085345,
0.0719500482,
0.0196998809,
-0.0422274359,
-0.8623515368,
-0.1535336822,
0.3908106089,
-0.234495014,
-0.3152463734,
-0.3900441527,
-0.1165504009,
-0.2327242792,
-0.484706372,
-0.5225641131,
-0.4233878553,
0.1215813756,
0.0804003999,
0.5736218691,
0.7484118938,
0.1826421469,
0.3310584426,
-0.7961114645,
0.2735338807,
-0.1255779862,
0.3995216191,
-0.1105375737,
-0.6683073044,
-0.3844961822,
-0.3169876933,
-0.390517056,
-0.9763644338,
0.6604480147,
-0.3939628601,
0.4889586568,
0.1030007005,
0.3847782314,
0.5697588921,
-0.3984485567,
0.3934571147,
0.3308209777,
-0.9924296141,
0.6801308393,
-0.394992888,
0.1653753817,
0.8379451632,
-0.0354084596,
-0.2316450477,
-0.8968244791,
-0.6284979582,
-0.9219354391,
0.6117406487,
0.1323895156,
-0.1271980256,
-0.0116671417,
0.2972814143,
-0.0652955845,
0.2674942911,
-1.0510730743,
-0.302516371,
0.0315405466,
-0.1067840606,
0.1863326281,
-0.1495595127,
-0.3000663519,
0.0238324199,
0.2935485244,
0.4319554269,
-0.0499156937,
-0.0788929388,
-0.3637331128,
-0.0620534904,
0.3060113192,
0.6995171309,
0.3362615108,
-0.2014914304,
-0.0157711823,
0.1435711086,
-0.7070500255,
0.3946231902,
-0.3256776631,
-0.2453226447,
-0.1699995697,
0.3338059783,
0.3523983657,
0.1001353785,
-0.9287766218,
0.6785749197,
0.1612812877,
-0.1403541863,
-0.5089023113,
0.340455085,
0.0617139451,
0.4183728099,
0.1122711599,
-0.0740493014,
-0.3302486539,
-0.4968358576,
0.3530177772,
0.6467645764,
-0.3977437019,
-0.1421962231,
0.7379883528,
0.2889931798,
-0.6280449033,
0.55451864,
-0.2546316981,
-0.5752052665,
0.7951906919,
0.7849635482,
1.0410808325,
-0.181478709,
-0.0650371388,
0.104830049,
0.571646452,
-0.0224313438,
0.0263743941,
-0.0020909009,
-0.6518802047,
-0.6786708236,
-0.2522414625,
-0.3937108815,
0.2967937291,
-0.4844573736,
0.3776600063,
-0.8256476521,
-0.1433019787,
-0.2426304519,
0.1025275588,
-0.0096637383,
-0.2732917666,
0.181946829,
1.1062563658,
-0.4087819457,
1.1780389547,
0.4576236606,
-0.2871672511,
-0.6982824206,
-0.0226883665,
0.4284600616,
-0.8446572423,
0.7688715458,
0.262577951,
-0.1499579251,
-0.1546467543,
-0.8165860772,
-0.6148764491,
0.8991730809,
0.2687004209,
-0.5626798272,
-0.1182023361,
-0.2706573904,
0.1006679609,
-0.3517098725,
-0.118043825,
0.8806697726,
0.4738759398,
0.1153928712,
-0.8818565607,
0.342776835,
-0.1168114468,
-0.4312623739,
0.7266053557,
-0.7379098535,
0.6353658438,
-0.8533833623,
-0.0190823134,
0.0421563275,
0.2520273328,
0.7551484108,
0.0762781128,
0.2769042253,
0.6593379378,
0.4831106663,
0.1184624061,
0.8687049747,
-0.2524314225,
0.07357575,
1.3913720846,
-0.2722235918,
0.6627895832,
0.6870167851,
-0.0134843085,
0.4143547118,
-0.0221973937,
-0.3374291062,
0.5001273155,
0.4527645409,
-0.2082878947,
-0.0584166273,
0.1527444422,
-0.0149117829,
0.4346014559,
0.3732814789,
-0.2035582811,
-0.2282844782,
-0.1311591864,
0.54917413,
0.3204387724,
-0.3563681245,
0.71437639,
-0.003881169,
-0.5042453408,
0.7730628848,
0.2227285206,
0.923040688,
-0.4624280632,
0.3312590122,
-0.1460436583,
0.0951968133,
-0.3625941575,
-0.7905388474,
0.4599078,
0.3780596852,
0.0616284832,
-0.0545695126,
0.7007531524,
-0.1925741136,
0.1302666366,
0.51318115,
0.173898831,
-0.0312994458,
-0.086276412,
-0.7517361045,
0.3603519201,
0.2036185861,
-0.1639819741,
0.6566963196,
0.2625924647,
-0.0633480102,
1.0584328175,
0.488568902,
0.4039746523,
-0.0099488283,
-0.1111405417,
0.9002703428,
-1.0739463568,
-0.5369720459,
-1.3457227945,
0.4278638661,
-0.1124068201,
0.085914582,
0.7829614282,
0.3910730481,
0.5613014102,
0.2449992895,
0.6614550352,
-0.002078153,
0.3422916234,
-0.3615987897,
0.9591409564,
-0.2687363327,
0.6788520813,
-0.5707429051,
-0.5610716939,
-0.3378000855,
0.2544341981,
-0.4048314989,
-0.152061224,
0.5939224362,
0.4742831886,
0.3677107096,
-0.3429660797,
0.4098944366,
0.3087891042,
0.4487220049,
0.7649216056,
0.7610398531,
-0.1558547765,
0.8245226145,
-0.2499757558,
-0.2905369401,
-0.284593761,
-0.8624958396,
-1.1248040199,
-0.147348851,
-0.3473475575,
-0.5182641745,
0.1713009626,
0.9416167736,
0.5103166699,
-0.6103587151,
-0.418307513,
-0.0574883819,
0.3030785024,
0.0347558782,
-0.2745519876,
-0.1372110844,
-0.5908417106,
-0.4142246842,
0.5988990664,
0.493255049,
0.1307757348,
-0.1059667021,
0.1309682578,
-0.217735976,
-0.0825315043,
0.304730624,
0.6083233953,
-0.7904763818,
-0.215775907,
-0.2574082911,
-0.3034438789,
0.0132429693,
0.7004663348,
-0.9212454557,
0.2802178562,
0.0531815775,
0.7389020324,
0.2462657988,
0.2242544889,
0.6590583324,
-0.8432072997,
0.5429691672,
0.4137651622,
0.3512997627,
-0.0941442922,
-0.3573496342,
0.3704112768,
0.0092553589,
-0.5323880911,
-1.001226902,
0.2360066324,
-0.8440702558,
-0.6866065264,
1.1583551168,
-0.1496772021,
-0.4369660914,
-0.5176730156,
-0.0617685281,
-0.0849845037,
-0.6641094685,
0.9640473723,
0.5858473182,
0.1199907884,
-0.2297887355,
-0.5839809775,
0.403078407,
0.3155805469,
-0.6590804458,
0.4075443745,
0.3272536993,
0.549892962,
0.0374540463,
0.4819664359,
-0.3154993057,
0.3766522706,
-0.1061569825,
0.2586293221,
-0.7108314037,
-0.3597345948,
-0.4085048735,
0.4282736182,
0.1195575744,
-0.147175312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08391v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08391v2
|
Misinformation is not about Bad Facts: An Analysis of the Production and Consumption of Fringe Content
| 2024-03-13T10:10:07 | 2024-05-26T06:15:33 |
JooYoung Lee, Emily Booth, Hany Farid, Marian-Andrei Rizoiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
What if misinformation is not an information problem at all? To understand
the role of news publishers in potentially unintentionally propagating
misinformation, we examine how far-right and fringe online groups share and
leverage established legacy news media articles to advance their narratives.
Our findings suggest that online fringe ideologies spread through the use of
content that is consensus-based and "factually correct". We found that
Australian news publishers with both moderate and far-right political leanings
contain comparable levels of information completeness and quality; and
furthermore, that far-right Twitter users often share from moderate sources.
However, a stark difference emerges when we consider two additional factors: 1)
the narrow topic selection of articles by far-right users, suggesting that they
cherry pick only news articles that engage with their preexisting worldviews
and specific topics of concern, and 2) the difference between moderate and
far-right publishers when we examine the writing style of their articles.
Furthermore, we can identify users prone to sharing misinformation based on
their communication style. These findings have important implications for
countering online misinformation, as they highlight the powerful role that
personal biases towards specific topics and publishers' writing styles have in
amplifying fringe ideologies online.
|
[
-0.5260586739,
-0.7061673999,
0.5898626447,
0.3158710301,
-0.1870024502,
-0.0562916584,
-0.0860449374,
-0.6128213406,
0.6256580353,
0.5561274886,
-0.4964360595,
-0.1148323938,
-0.8679456711,
0.2030870169,
-0.4278352559,
1.1727888584,
0.4072893262,
-0.3540569544,
0.1139533445,
-0.273317188,
-0.1354395896,
-0.3417077363,
0.0595243089,
-0.0284298975,
0.5844795108,
0.5240923166,
1.330376029,
0.5034951568,
0.1620996445,
0.0999203697,
-0.1037810966,
0.0760586932,
-0.766992569,
-0.2711532116,
-0.6607902646,
-0.5002207756,
0.3819450438,
0.3287985623,
0.4938907623,
0.6082280278,
-0.1248518154,
0.3439128697,
0.1530818641,
0.7597606778,
-0.7380423546,
-0.5325325131,
-0.3934716582,
0.096730493,
-0.5057256222,
-0.3983332813,
-0.4146949351,
-0.5737133026,
-0.0685779452,
-0.8640679121,
0.3491452932,
0.2655874193,
0.949323535,
0.0824308619,
-0.6048383713,
-0.58491081,
-0.901579082,
0.571331203,
-0.4987232089,
0.4306781888,
0.4301245213,
-0.0310082939,
-0.1103654876,
-0.3420878053,
-0.6308809519,
0.552501142,
-0.1248199642,
0.0793058202,
-0.6617250443,
-0.1899425536,
0.2528588474,
0.2226714343,
-0.3051303923,
-0.1307317019,
-0.735280931,
-0.3033762574,
0.5834761858,
-0.1856424063,
0.3229844272,
-0.4020793438,
-0.5117365122,
0.2427375317,
-0.9099547863,
-0.1480714828,
0.7951040268,
0.2035345882,
-0.111470826,
0.6879152656,
0.0447251052,
0.5444669127,
0.5631275177,
-0.194316119,
0.1705003977,
-0.4382046759,
-0.0360717699,
0.3337597251,
0.5396980047,
0.8658236265,
-0.1274349988,
0.1207863837,
0.1142142266,
-0.3434762359,
0.3218192756,
-0.382943064,
0.0024077175,
-0.0570179932,
-0.6333985329,
-0.0968038738,
0.2849181294,
-0.9493227005,
-1.0049940348,
-0.002402148,
0.4959986806,
-0.1385100037,
-0.2605902255,
-0.0875712559,
-0.8515399694,
-0.2838810086,
0.3655183315,
-0.5868603587,
0.0854171515,
0.5089159608,
0.6445951462,
0.1923384815,
-0.0751395524,
-0.2566225231,
0.4191133082,
-0.7028076649,
0.6021922827,
-0.2727400362,
0.0762827918,
0.2761155665,
-0.0527613275,
0.2401321977,
-0.3769984543,
0.4949688613,
-0.4000060558,
0.3650784194,
-0.7132157683,
-0.4990133941,
-0.3583189845,
0.0377732776,
-0.7301719785,
0.7026156783,
0.1421916932,
-1.1794655323,
0.803052485,
-0.2137268633,
-0.3343300521,
-0.123408258,
-0.1811563224,
-0.1680218875,
0.2799744904,
0.0769387856,
0.3203545809,
0.0414782315,
0.2100324333,
-0.2297299802,
-0.4716358185,
0.4616961777,
-0.4658633769,
0.2799580693,
0.2168885767,
-0.441439569,
-0.3881964982,
-0.439897716,
-0.5420259833,
-0.1955890507,
-0.1493465751,
-0.6634213328,
0.2156418264,
-0.1091357544,
0.4382864535,
-0.1542907357,
-0.5056643486,
-0.0734808892,
0.326274991,
0.0606893934,
0.5489462018,
0.4332545102,
0.4549272358,
-0.9555463195,
-0.1172835752,
0.2652809024,
0.544728756,
0.0128916232,
-0.5356387496,
-0.5972068906,
0.1050674468,
0.0535501987,
0.4030783474,
-0.5184152126,
0.2600847185,
0.1202458441,
-0.4606473744,
-0.412091881,
0.0190559682,
-0.1204880029,
0.3021157682,
0.3795399666,
0.1635748893,
-0.3598940074,
-1.0050735474,
-0.9447336197,
0.017820159,
0.2533526123,
0.0466581695,
-0.0943286493,
-0.1229194179,
0.8996701837,
-0.2703861296,
-0.3002146184,
-0.2637940943,
0.5589131117,
0.3284775317,
0.0232448988,
0.5808749795,
-1.1271808147,
-0.2844419181,
-0.3155020475,
-0.4275928438,
-0.2085984498,
-0.4457588196,
0.1923094243,
0.2436944395,
0.2393710315,
-0.3612586558,
0.5796140432,
0.5055611134,
-0.5774501562,
0.3384922445,
0.1044312492,
0.5365813971,
-0.7860082984,
-0.1393229812,
0.1087669656,
-0.2778795958,
-0.6473254561,
-0.247858271,
-0.103947483,
0.0812077522,
-0.6278944612,
0.0170066208,
-0.3406718969,
0.1355932206,
-0.2468357682,
0.2554939389,
0.2304703444,
-0.13143529,
-0.0912845582,
0.4999854863,
0.2069773674,
-0.724137485,
-0.1415763497,
0.1057678834,
-0.3635905981,
0.4161618352,
0.0516844206,
-0.4096740186,
-0.4686140716,
0.3749961555,
-0.7079080343,
-0.3040983081,
0.7094928622,
-0.4946228266,
-0.1719357967,
-0.0645899773,
-0.5212586522,
-0.135099113,
-0.2968709469,
0.0309412293,
0.1680575609,
-0.3466541767,
0.317058444,
0.4360327423,
-0.0630637854,
-0.772590816,
-1.2361607552,
0.0213933885,
-0.3655107319,
-0.5803036094,
0.1198329628,
0.2552578449,
-0.5738537908,
0.4524770975,
-0.3509373069,
-0.1252530664,
-0.2722347081,
0.1733562946,
-0.3466945589,
-0.185080573,
0.6977174282,
0.1124443263,
0.1939944327,
-0.2007546127,
-0.1566765308,
0.2201186121,
0.3354139924,
-0.291793853,
-0.6115211248,
0.7276051044,
0.1030661613,
0.1506638229,
0.8583416939,
0.3917571604,
-0.3338081539,
-0.4845757186,
-0.9773525596,
-0.0871629119,
-0.3640149534,
-0.0056446614,
0.3645663261,
-0.4972466826,
0.1533132643,
0.0457347371,
0.1285092384,
0.7993042469,
0.0319853462,
-0.1728448272,
0.2544314563,
0.8800842762,
0.157828778,
0.4095448852,
-0.0282152146,
0.3173306286,
0.0721702427,
-0.1637512147,
-0.5004597902,
-0.181021601,
-0.4317813814,
-0.6740919352,
0.0414170995,
0.3225135505,
-0.1598088443,
0.0386168547,
-0.381098032,
0.5781579614,
0.3259260654,
-0.1257389635,
0.5860347152,
0.0252002291,
0.6025227904,
-0.0546068102,
-0.8114727736,
-0.5467771292,
0.7328181863,
0.5695336461,
1.1738607883,
0.1902027875,
0.6146660447,
1.0011204481,
0.2276234925,
-0.5221295953,
-0.1385814399,
-0.0966678187,
-0.8445696831,
-0.0231637023,
-0.2623776197,
-0.3098961413,
0.1210880578,
-0.3663647473,
-0.5945208073,
0.7236555219,
0.0349562727,
-0.336589247,
0.7085633278,
-0.4853358865,
0.3685482442,
-0.063011013,
-0.2577466071,
-0.5262691975,
-0.6680809259,
0.1688638628,
-0.1131669134,
0.7826074958,
-0.1101436093,
-0.1636030227,
0.9224110842,
0.1034618169,
0.8411974311,
-0.0392202735,
0.2017288655,
0.739761889,
0.1949101388,
0.1031495631,
0.1404665411,
0.0714327246,
0.3424455523,
0.1030942574,
-0.3318473995,
-0.2331141233,
0.1244625673,
-1.0028965473,
-0.8073803186,
-0.6891367435,
-0.2486147881,
-0.0442059785,
0.2816489637,
0.6851663589,
0.466875881,
-0.2187609226,
0.3036325574,
0.7091777325,
0.0917461216,
0.4904828966,
0.3659061491,
-0.278831929,
-0.3663865328,
0.7202785611,
0.5971926451,
0.5590757132,
0.4172248542,
0.3618297577,
-0.1564655155,
-0.2591691315,
-0.5631014705,
0.2712470591,
-1.0420567989,
-0.1757897884,
-0.4007038176,
-0.1595750004,
0.0210722405,
-0.1790903807,
-0.3810767829,
-0.3975795209,
-0.4990364611,
-0.1337125003,
0.237157166,
1.1932061911,
-0.5631558299,
0.662176609,
-1.0582523346,
0.2052993923,
0.0803759247,
0.121540226,
-0.3974610269,
-0.192150563,
-0.2859482169,
0.3671476543,
-0.724330008,
-1.2914087772,
-0.1228726953,
-0.149240464,
0.5165505409,
0.7022228241,
0.2726605237,
0.353749454,
-0.123288855,
1.0658178329,
0.3371885419,
-0.9887892604,
0.1573583186,
-0.5367609859,
-0.2876873016,
0.6837447286,
0.9504464865,
-0.9445777535,
-0.5872454643,
-0.9341712594,
-0.4324608743,
0.648335278,
-0.1355507821,
0.1520637274,
-0.1317110062,
-0.1259316206,
0.6981695294,
0.3365688622,
-0.8569204807,
-0.3420711458,
-0.5575947762,
0.1722936034,
0.0200721528,
-0.413416028,
-0.6150528789,
0.2869586349,
0.5406126976,
-0.0652657896,
0.2171519548,
0.6932470202,
-0.0960095376,
-0.5866989493,
0.3447353244,
0.3570674062,
1.1164550781,
-0.0690517053,
0.1975585818,
-0.4989684224,
-0.2612601221,
-0.1209903285,
-0.13060157,
-0.3464204073,
0.4328200221,
0.2963606715,
0.6560990214,
-0.0849982053,
-0.1487427354,
1.0654129982,
0.1230739802,
-0.2189621478,
-0.3642278612,
-0.2029335648,
0.0845369622,
0.3084243536,
0.9102109075,
0.4718821049,
0.1355050653,
-0.8495889306,
0.2621389329,
0.0572435148,
-0.3336419165,
-0.213800475,
0.3066594303,
0.3042566776,
-0.0385045595,
0.253097862,
0.0115901669,
-0.2747564912,
0.3653996289,
0.6782912612,
0.2172281891,
0.0666141137,
0.5964131951,
-0.0587454103,
0.4740952849,
-0.051134523,
-0.0004642952,
0.144504115,
-0.6575385928,
-0.2399499565,
-0.1912528425,
-0.3156690598,
0.0218010023,
-0.246034801,
0.3794488311,
-0.4113596082,
-0.3035061061,
-0.0906421095,
-0.0684410334,
-0.3331122696,
0.2844862342,
0.2781510055,
1.1055710316,
-1.0919018984,
0.1382069886,
0.2336783558,
-0.5356507301,
-0.5939065814,
0.9621071815,
0.2592074573,
-0.085274674,
0.1509901434,
0.1983943433,
0.0449908264,
-0.5752149224,
-0.4104293287,
-0.9342823029,
0.7073660493,
0.145556435,
-0.5470781326,
0.0369414426,
0.4435572624,
-0.0038840596,
-0.2447293699,
0.0848818794,
-0.0347846113,
0.5166121125,
0.127243042,
-0.8120059371,
0.0336646102,
0.4503851831,
-0.5215394497,
0.4282329977,
-0.9882611632,
0.88131392,
-0.0702927113,
-0.447183013,
-0.3922219574,
0.4499328136,
-0.3900403678,
0.5436838865,
0.3186684847,
0.2149312943,
0.7302865982,
-0.0306914598,
0.7620970011,
-0.1446439177,
0.2566156983,
0.4772934318,
0.3525906503,
0.5647271276,
0.6414259076,
0.0001022286,
0.5351108909,
0.6698939204,
0.142190367,
0.6673865318,
-0.0704985112,
-0.0044056727,
-0.1900762916,
-0.3007323146,
-0.6487076879,
0.2120397389,
0.5802382827,
-0.4485380352,
-0.4385419488,
-0.0834138095,
0.2145379633,
0.3951224685,
-0.5008385181,
0.6161265373,
0.1554404497,
-0.3842842281,
0.3764648139,
0.0158599019,
0.6944170594,
-0.5168542862,
0.1311254203,
0.1056924313,
0.1651175171,
-0.7767444253,
-1.05644238,
0.894053936,
-0.4145923555,
-0.3984619379,
-0.0572899915,
0.8875020742,
-0.2306993157,
-0.1227663755,
0.3114202023,
0.680793643,
-0.091713421,
-0.2442661971,
-0.3199096024,
0.3063935041,
0.1369284838,
0.1308551878,
0.182550475,
0.3872440159,
-0.0955724195,
0.3746948838,
0.4348133802,
0.182206288,
0.1062766537,
-0.3277441263,
0.8524355292,
-0.7797869444,
-0.6286557913,
-0.5828989744,
0.4218130112,
-0.2344486564,
-0.6165553927,
0.84935534,
0.5008835196,
0.7989864349,
0.0214887932,
1.0213407278,
-0.242732659,
0.798415482,
-0.2165044099,
0.8809748292,
-0.4801509976,
-0.1470291764,
-0.2409429997,
-0.813147068,
-0.1343319714,
0.0825570077,
-0.2409548461,
-0.2818826139,
0.6336454153,
0.5866376162,
-0.2055297941,
0.6817896962,
0.0598348081,
0.0620705076,
0.0221715812,
0.0292858053,
1.2346154451,
-0.06346903,
0.4366767704,
-0.6376258731,
-0.3803521991,
-0.3565576971,
-0.8393465877,
-0.6443358064,
-0.5128827691,
-0.1209176332,
-0.3971813619,
0.3080037236,
0.8754807115,
0.4266355932,
-0.2568470538,
0.039640855,
0.1917464733,
0.4356067777,
-0.1704451591,
-0.2420613021,
0.0520595908,
0.0125566358,
-0.3657781184,
-0.0442612357,
0.1162346005,
-0.30118379,
-0.0723391324,
0.3175757229,
-0.4131301641,
0.5503135324,
0.2894834578,
0.2894086838,
-0.6660280228,
-0.3727018237,
-0.3242516518,
-0.1848210692,
0.3041024506,
0.7171701193,
-0.5456730723,
0.244617328,
0.4453785419,
0.4250388741,
0.036782667,
0.5694877505,
0.2734755278,
-0.5367795229,
0.1245417595,
0.2564874887,
-0.1365420222,
0.6502063274,
-0.7336018085,
-0.1149946377,
0.6065818667,
-0.4845124781,
-0.3613619804,
-0.0062508848,
-0.4716005623,
-0.4627490342,
1.304017663,
0.2713435888,
-0.2244276553,
-0.3540186286,
-0.1933566779,
0.1824129075,
-0.6479670405,
0.5276927352,
0.7633751035,
-0.3829755783,
0.1782570481,
-0.5646238923,
0.6786532402,
-0.0556653701,
-0.3995839357,
0.1253159046,
0.6674835682,
0.641005218,
0.4984677136,
0.5812221169,
0.0289336983,
0.2423182875,
0.328027159,
-0.3767906725,
0.0392612964,
-0.4892191291,
-0.0671919733,
0.1319484115,
-0.2335525155,
-0.1808930039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09734v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09734v2
|
Do Large Language Models Solve ARC Visual Analogies Like People Do?
| 2024-03-13T09:48:13 | 2024-05-13T11:20:23 |
Gustaw Opiełka, Hannes Rosenbusch, Veerle Vijverberg, Claire E. Stevenson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Abstraction Reasoning Corpus (ARC) is a visual analogical reasoning test
designed for humans and machines (Chollet, 2019). We compared human and large
language model (LLM) performance on a new child-friendly set of ARC items.
Results show that both children and adults outperform most LLMs on these tasks.
Error analysis revealed a similar "fallback" solution strategy in LLMs and
young children, where part of the analogy is simply copied. In addition, we
found two other error types, one based on seemingly grasping key concepts
(e.g., Inside-Outside) and the other based on simple combinations of analogy
input matrices. On the whole, "concept" errors were more common in humans, and
"matrix" errors were more common in LLMs. This study sheds new light on LLM
reasoning ability and the extent to which we can use error analyses and
comparisons with human development to understand how LLMs solve visual
analogies.
|
[
-0.3904491365,
-0.6900753975,
0.6192706823,
0.0570104681,
-0.0660060272,
0.4059724808,
-0.248485148,
-0.6516199708,
-0.0983064845,
0.4029811025,
-0.4756048918,
-0.4414519668,
-0.52032125,
0.2849488854,
-0.6692788601,
0.199402824,
-0.4203394055,
0.0722411871,
-0.4994235933,
0.0215758756,
-0.2260861248,
-0.5113251805,
-0.8104826212,
-0.5530841351,
0.5425620079,
0.5596997738,
0.7365062833,
0.7367930412,
0.7662328482,
0.2675556242,
-0.1418222785,
0.0487513207,
-0.3606360853,
-0.1166097447,
-0.3729415834,
-0.4903893769,
-0.3490653932,
-0.1442023963,
0.4916785657,
1.0976411104,
-0.1102806404,
0.0402175188,
0.0208407138,
0.8922430277,
-0.5604906678,
0.3161797822,
-0.5374708772,
-0.0660709292,
-0.0956505984,
0.036605306,
-0.5941167474,
-0.3234655857,
0.1334387362,
-0.6255964041,
0.1209220886,
0.46061185,
0.8367056847,
0.3109955192,
-0.2478585094,
-0.3534282446,
-0.8241331577,
0.8021643758,
-0.6716867685,
0.1103417426,
0.1675635129,
0.2123016864,
-0.4538541436,
-0.6562726498,
-1.0424724817,
-0.3029577136,
-0.0314711444,
-0.194282636,
-0.5398165584,
0.1301047355,
0.3595535159,
0.0437877923,
-0.5956965685,
0.3864164352,
-0.5679357052,
-0.0438393056,
0.611913085,
0.413849175,
0.6698147058,
-0.0642612204,
-0.3392961919,
-0.3603556752,
-0.9610732794,
0.1227246076,
0.146094799,
-0.1029322892,
-0.1001437083,
0.7814096212,
-0.1857852489,
0.7530979514,
0.020236399,
-0.1069554389,
0.1068680659,
-0.0518603213,
-0.0218743347,
-0.0195252411,
0.5436452627,
0.7088745832,
0.838581562,
-0.0284342133,
-0.2617441118,
0.3921584785,
0.0995177776,
-0.4510993659,
-0.2367772758,
-0.1004868075,
-0.5057548881,
0.0670265779,
-0.0836243853,
-0.6688504219,
-0.526804626,
-0.5614880919,
0.3778550029,
-0.471889466,
-0.1005614251,
0.3358494937,
0.015203381,
0.4396163225,
0.4384827316,
-0.745680809,
0.5640221238,
0.7995757461,
0.5737681985,
-0.5541061163,
-0.7062615156,
-0.2268538028,
-0.1623675674,
-0.6464636326,
1.0814568996,
-0.4843313396,
-0.1925249547,
-0.2953383923,
-0.3232970834,
-0.2748770714,
-0.9670852423,
0.2166460454,
-0.4013909101,
-0.2119423896,
-0.1687579751,
-0.3797667325,
-0.3049313426,
0.1621514261,
-0.7144610286,
0.7664908767,
0.2192554623,
-0.6776512265,
0.3079990447,
-0.5425475836,
-0.204416737,
-0.2655289769,
-0.2743476927,
-0.254312396,
0.1819398999,
0.158985272,
0.3271023631,
-0.5626994371,
-0.0401852243,
-0.3724605143,
-0.6634463072,
0.474514246,
-0.2440624684,
0.6475996375,
0.0944729745,
-0.3401097953,
0.164642632,
-0.5358889103,
0.0069304043,
0.3088914454,
-0.2268211842,
-0.2426678985,
0.145755738,
-0.2696717083,
0.4553977549,
0.0044908412,
-0.4281258881,
0.2142315209,
-0.3123943508,
0.6653367877,
0.5776733756,
-0.1094599366,
0.2783327997,
-0.3885636628,
0.5282593369,
0.1321003586,
-0.0862252414,
-0.1421249658,
-0.6456349492,
-1.0951795578,
-0.1187690124,
0.0944734961,
0.413875699,
-0.7489740849,
0.2827100158,
-0.3799961805,
-0.401255995,
-0.2194069624,
0.1510705352,
0.4002878964,
0.5733931065,
0.1057236791,
-0.4827439189,
-0.6267911792,
-1.0704357624,
0.0201021452,
-0.5621928573,
-0.0255733617,
0.2352272719,
0.8117303252,
-0.2670706809,
1.0814825296,
-0.2623223662,
-0.028827969,
-0.3603290319,
0.2025751323,
0.0406738818,
0.0910323635,
0.4914551973,
-0.5127125382,
-0.1424486637,
0.0154853836,
-0.9459476471,
-0.1207242161,
-0.0128599629,
0.141806528,
0.1916757226,
0.6398623586,
-0.5802554488,
0.634293139,
0.5474052429,
-0.4932799041,
0.8257620335,
-0.2206718475,
-0.0403741449,
-0.5342592597,
-0.064944528,
0.0344366953,
-0.0550849177,
-0.219627738,
0.2763567567,
-0.0344928615,
0.0066293245,
-0.7303680778,
0.6091020107,
-0.4418685436,
-0.4455680251,
-0.1958346516,
0.104649432,
0.0200246423,
0.4415770471,
0.1808020175,
1.0043058395,
0.7042140961,
-0.4641720653,
0.6230120659,
-0.2049847096,
-0.514215529,
0.8495723605,
-0.8594769239,
0.1526260674,
-0.3021045625,
0.3511728644,
-1.063360095,
-0.3587573469,
0.0634858459,
-0.2442962825,
0.0384921394,
0.3956156969,
-0.5681446791,
-0.7416033149,
-0.2524413764,
0.5440061688,
0.5680242181,
-0.6086415648,
0.8599100709,
0.1181759611,
-0.1719745398,
-0.6350666881,
-0.7361824512,
0.3585900962,
-0.3273609579,
-0.8540402651,
-0.1720522642,
-0.056674473,
-0.8257317543,
0.1421827525,
0.0838303268,
-0.2416960448,
0.0964276344,
0.1717899442,
0.3259540498,
-0.4934786558,
0.0174808539,
-0.2569326162,
-0.127192378,
0.2008848786,
0.1540422738,
0.6381085515,
-0.5224230289,
-0.7558141351,
-0.5029082894,
0.3229167163,
0.7576131821,
0.1113600507,
0.6364789605,
-0.1523805112,
-0.3509466648,
-0.1589919031,
-0.3844850063,
-0.2408981174,
-0.4118484557,
0.5108705163,
-0.4145553708,
-0.445068717,
0.6354472041,
-0.0333890654,
-0.039681796,
0.4233765006,
0.637449801,
-0.5547776818,
0.7537748218,
0.2929575741,
0.1712086946,
-0.0654779375,
-0.4911468327,
0.1067462191,
-0.8709201217,
-0.1937320083,
-0.3868554235,
-0.6983508468,
-0.0264441799,
-0.4929642379,
0.0910949558,
0.312479645,
-0.5646496415,
0.3595381379,
-0.3905650377,
0.6307811737,
0.5127726197,
-0.015171933,
0.6882561445,
-0.0255136807,
-0.0766036212,
-0.2257093787,
-0.685085237,
-0.7225669026,
1.1322124004,
0.3290745914,
1.1958265305,
0.0630284995,
0.5471799374,
0.1026862115,
0.6338710785,
-0.8435778022,
0.7878568172,
-0.1447162479,
-0.5218324661,
-0.233987689,
-0.2040732056,
-1.0616022348,
0.2426945865,
-0.2257563621,
-0.9500644803,
0.3028788269,
0.1473999023,
-0.0107656,
0.5474764705,
-1.0219800472,
0.7152035236,
-0.1575326324,
0.1454229504,
-0.3025212884,
-0.657461822,
0.5446080565,
-0.210032016,
0.2091581672,
-0.1403017789,
-0.1166149303,
0.6285117269,
-0.13442114,
0.9765982628,
0.3798849881,
0.071449019,
0.6448085308,
0.2999962866,
0.2946697176,
-0.4705939889,
0.008705589,
0.2610177696,
-0.3523486555,
-0.3818631768,
-0.887442112,
0.5803402066,
-0.9032788873,
-0.6843268871,
-0.4661933184,
-0.5201799273,
0.0467042439,
-0.0431459583,
0.0871580243,
0.2768138647,
-0.0788211897,
0.2797152996,
0.6782715917,
-0.1327301413,
0.4862968922,
0.3718418777,
-0.3162710965,
0.0916275755,
0.680801034,
-0.1492828727,
0.7003416419,
0.1978015006,
0.2502441704,
-0.1569051445,
-0.5986602902,
-0.7270023823,
0.3922229409,
-0.9258027673,
0.0593346953,
-0.3525680602,
-0.3114965558,
0.1940129995,
-0.2428067625,
-0.3940983117,
-0.4268045425,
-0.1044501364,
0.0102668861,
0.1489182562,
0.7253932953,
0.1411761343,
0.1361195296,
-0.3681596816,
0.4273929,
0.6829146147,
0.1969398111,
0.4828977585,
-0.2980952561,
0.0993669108,
0.0223442428,
-0.4711128771,
-0.5718587637,
-0.0040721353,
0.1338892281,
0.4645709097,
0.3307290077,
-0.1287620366,
0.5101202726,
-0.5699207187,
0.8090311885,
0.4095884264,
-0.839843154,
0.0312922634,
-0.2329830527,
0.222920835,
0.2546557486,
0.1211554632,
-0.643981874,
-0.320907861,
-0.506306231,
-0.7222928405,
0.518502295,
0.2618273795,
0.0531201623,
0.0908520445,
0.2104454935,
0.0141269369,
-0.0835138634,
-0.6528949738,
-0.4106266797,
0.1806223392,
-0.2491353601,
-0.0189316962,
-0.0031783388,
-0.016704116,
-0.3144104183,
0.1287216842,
-0.0804058164,
0.2889894247,
-0.0396446474,
-0.1076771244,
-0.4913780689,
0.2098421454,
0.6248374581,
1.2164931297,
0.0891104713,
0.3936427236,
0.3109626472,
-0.3472398221,
0.3459582031,
-0.3144530654,
-0.0984339043,
-0.2044881731,
0.7965762019,
0.6310989857,
0.3242329061,
-1.2721381187,
0.5028615594,
-0.0882657096,
-0.2279246151,
-0.4973779619,
0.2113956958,
0.539812386,
0.1312428862,
0.5275118351,
0.283183217,
-0.1963356733,
-0.8578654528,
0.1705329418,
0.2261952311,
-0.0423967056,
-0.2094299048,
0.7171559334,
0.1536158472,
-0.7482001781,
0.7441712022,
0.126024887,
-0.3657076955,
0.9533982277,
0.4535395205,
0.703056097,
0.0853980482,
0.0865778476,
0.0852044225,
0.296148777,
-0.2787391841,
0.0471142903,
0.3581196964,
-0.949429214,
-0.8044939041,
-0.3352119327,
-0.6708884835,
-0.1376476139,
-0.4914020002,
0.2967483997,
-0.3418629467,
0.2691988051,
0.1605271995,
-0.4675951004,
-0.775780499,
0.2211398631,
0.2878277898,
0.8812843561,
-0.8829670548,
0.695369184,
0.7007960081,
-0.4021774828,
-0.9799172282,
-0.1083267406,
-0.0560474843,
-1.0429410934,
1.0910178423,
-0.0239097998,
-0.3952258527,
-0.2856987715,
-0.5868691802,
-0.8886874318,
0.8893114328,
0.5725193024,
-0.6765192747,
-0.3506992161,
0.1863977313,
0.8075786233,
-0.6780658364,
0.2960996926,
0.8874366283,
0.4576019943,
0.3234532475,
-1.1482186317,
-0.1476333141,
0.008560271,
0.0215680487,
0.0361503474,
-0.3722673655,
1.0386775732,
-0.5647832751,
-0.1517353207,
0.2580628693,
0.5955046415,
0.5024650693,
0.5663103461,
0.5550982356,
0.7627144456,
0.3823142946,
-0.0605971962,
1.3873695135,
0.0845491141,
0.2777151763,
1.0073295832,
-0.2982065976,
1.0377030373,
0.527469933,
-0.3550612926,
0.7358624935,
0.6206764579,
0.4209597707,
0.1332815588,
0.4614148438,
0.0668895245,
-0.2971436083,
0.2920856476,
-0.1763578653,
0.430121094,
0.4968815744,
-0.3878085911,
-0.2871663868,
-0.1420959979,
-0.0870842785,
0.4024693966,
-0.4372180402,
0.6761400104,
0.3924597502,
-0.6171278358,
0.8750870228,
-0.0882411972,
0.5193285942,
-0.13882339,
-0.1208354458,
-0.0859624147,
0.244035095,
-0.095845893,
-1.1180750132,
0.3135210574,
-0.0614452921,
-0.0663584992,
0.1807537228,
0.4481225312,
-0.1858619303,
-0.5772684813,
0.219667539,
0.5317141414,
0.3872179389,
0.1263658255,
-0.6760653853,
-0.0046069953,
-0.1184047163,
-0.0337050781,
0.1152343005,
0.326533407,
-0.5199156404,
1.2648458481,
0.2900310755,
0.2707950771,
0.2563299835,
-0.0628065839,
0.813361764,
-0.7708685994,
-0.1953543574,
-0.8737705946,
0.3810617626,
-0.08393538,
-0.4000063837,
0.4066615105,
0.3937011361,
0.840680778,
-0.2084427625,
0.476244241,
0.2813791037,
0.5938245654,
-0.4354827702,
0.3646831512,
-0.4031814635,
0.2171226442,
-0.4842219353,
-1.393627882,
-0.4480524361,
0.7690524459,
-0.4988261759,
-0.0528573543,
1.0954422951,
0.6578103304,
-0.1163199097,
-0.0655553415,
0.2771391571,
0.2655201852,
0.2470722795,
0.9707533717,
1.2206698656,
-0.0628525689,
0.5641207695,
-0.0606877357,
-0.1180694401,
-0.2892382443,
-0.7584956288,
-0.9479209781,
-0.3542705476,
-0.2436148524,
-0.2788877487,
0.1278239042,
0.8865373135,
0.5986061096,
-0.6370109916,
-0.3337900937,
-0.087787129,
0.2630941272,
-0.3453339636,
-0.1748745143,
0.525131762,
0.2775419354,
-0.7457399368,
0.0026295551,
0.2359420955,
-0.0035749611,
-0.6358295083,
-0.2225271314,
0.1173564941,
0.184585318,
0.4337373972,
0.3204425275,
-1.1700502634,
-0.5824389458,
-0.0340279043,
-0.2904001772,
0.3684982657,
0.9614140987,
-0.8618026972,
0.5168608427,
0.4132466316,
0.5092430115,
0.4489723444,
0.0865689516,
0.4602615237,
-0.2782331407,
0.2657905817,
0.2898913324,
0.540595293,
0.4630734324,
-0.048720073,
0.4239077866,
0.2659584582,
-0.3846311569,
-0.5573662519,
0.4692553878,
-1.0560798645,
-0.299736619,
1.1715489626,
-0.1305253953,
-0.428601861,
-0.2710444033,
-0.4244268537,
-0.3089711964,
-0.4014919698,
1.009254694,
0.8771976829,
-0.3813169599,
-0.3731903732,
-0.1926808655,
-0.0110138617,
0.1589530855,
-0.8158488274,
-0.0850903541,
0.3215060532,
0.3443640769,
0.2493923903,
0.3077368438,
0.0241448767,
0.6555661559,
0.0664939955,
0.2019048035,
0.0133343721,
-0.1516782939,
-0.1314257383,
-0.0327280052,
0.4409413934,
-0.0162034724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08377v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08377v1
|
Learning to Describe for Predicting Zero-shot Drug-Drug Interactions
| 2024-03-13T09:42:46 | 2024-03-13T09:42:46 |
Fangqi Zhu, Yongqi Zhang, Lei Chen, Bing Qin, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adverse drug-drug interactions~(DDIs) can compromise the effectiveness of
concurrent drug administration, posing a significant challenge in healthcare.
As the development of new drugs continues, the potential for unknown adverse
effects resulting from DDIs becomes a growing concern. Traditional
computational methods for DDI prediction may fail to capture interactions for
new drugs due to the lack of knowledge. In this paper, we introduce a new
problem setup as zero-shot DDI prediction that deals with the case of new
drugs. Leveraging textual information from online databases like DrugBank and
PubChem, we propose an innovative approach TextDDI with a language model-based
DDI predictor and a reinforcement learning~(RL)-based information selector,
enabling the selection of concise and pertinent text for accurate DDI
prediction on new drugs. Empirical results show the benefits of the proposed
approach on several settings including zero-shot and few-shot DDI prediction,
and the selected texts are semantically relevant. Our code and data are
available at \url{https://github.com/zhufq00/DDIs-Prediction}.
|
[
-0.0101768589,
-0.7987200618,
0.9634808302,
-0.0361645259,
0.0595660768,
0.0922647789,
0.1838084757,
-0.6209944487,
0.4101685286,
0.4717722535,
-0.6710920334,
-0.5668488145,
-0.7339823842,
0.1648207158,
-0.1267113537,
1.3758622408,
-0.2233560979,
0.1393571198,
-0.1562440544,
0.0652077347,
-0.7616776824,
-0.2464222759,
-0.6104732752,
-0.5844880939,
0.7675125599,
0.2763611078,
0.1212336048,
0.2324099094,
0.4978892207,
0.3264045715,
0.0267926157,
-0.2478521764,
-0.451484561,
0.3779500127,
-0.1681749374,
-0.3386511207,
-0.3773307204,
-0.0318781957,
0.1972911209,
0.5226121545,
-0.162138626,
-0.1899838299,
-0.5171369314,
0.4210548103,
-0.9050005674,
0.1914221346,
-0.4969316125,
0.388610214,
0.0450759307,
-0.2739051878,
-0.3529242277,
0.0770913288,
0.371958375,
-0.8691825271,
-0.241190955,
-0.1489970982,
0.896150291,
0.1232580468,
-0.5441772342,
-0.3992184699,
-0.6796568632,
0.7079382539,
-0.6877286434,
-0.0178618506,
0.2553136647,
0.6505529284,
-0.3465386331,
-0.4570216238,
-0.8258765936,
0.1399357319,
-0.1793889403,
0.1532453597,
-0.0157809332,
0.2318210602,
-0.1186572835,
0.139137581,
-0.3617676497,
0.2695305049,
-0.4909519851,
-0.0129347052,
0.5671360493,
0.5067636371,
0.4060928226,
-0.4831981957,
-0.567836225,
0.3849050403,
-0.4164004922,
-0.0744654387,
-0.073865369,
0.3839496374,
-0.2758694589,
0.5968002677,
-0.2068147808,
0.5863429904,
0.4195989072,
-0.059825182,
0.4268812537,
-0.390188694,
-0.4456160367,
0.1811840087,
1.0170907974,
0.6305695772,
0.1411957294,
-0.2458274066,
-0.0301207583,
-0.0926115885,
0.131196484,
-1.0174303055,
-0.1833359897,
0.8195227385,
-0.3408611119,
-0.8178024292,
-0.1122677699,
-1.1705293655,
-0.7695766687,
-0.1025329083,
0.7451504469,
-0.6655297279,
-0.1957296431,
-0.0038662758,
-0.2939040959,
0.201089859,
0.2013097107,
-0.817019105,
0.3213808537,
0.4228735864,
0.6985448599,
-0.3466282785,
-0.5163238049,
-0.7228731513,
0.5504992008,
-0.2607590556,
1.0887908936,
-0.3247037232,
-0.3723345101,
0.212723285,
-0.0853611827,
-0.140421167,
-0.3473023176,
0.588506639,
-0.2474714816,
0.2121443897,
0.0585648753,
-0.7047136426,
0.0114357444,
0.183769241,
-0.705850184,
0.0715790913,
-0.0096006272,
-1.0978429317,
0.6035106182,
-0.5704418421,
-0.4191456735,
0.0818538293,
-0.1760437638,
-0.7032499909,
0.0847052261,
0.0144088138,
0.5073557496,
0.2619524598,
0.487087816,
-0.5966839194,
-0.534832418,
0.6446809769,
-0.0462090112,
0.5459025502,
0.2482958883,
0.0522165,
0.3080356419,
-0.8828292489,
0.0057167234,
0.0328582227,
-0.1857046336,
-0.220622018,
-0.3364766836,
0.0608965121,
0.3316952586,
0.0199810397,
-0.8213455081,
0.0336834006,
-0.4495147467,
0.1226060763,
0.6878968477,
0.6138064265,
0.4994147122,
-0.3293972313,
0.3230076134,
0.1600620449,
0.3049314618,
-0.2013754547,
-0.4329929352,
-0.2759044468,
-0.0575928167,
0.5437757373,
0.6889287829,
-1.0202027559,
0.0596497096,
-0.2619696856,
-0.207846716,
-0.1427947581,
-0.1131309792,
0.5084659457,
0.3040381372,
0.2549881041,
-0.0112087298,
-0.6876599193,
-0.3255871832,
-0.1135850623,
-0.0851394609,
-0.2668628991,
0.445302546,
0.364002943,
-0.4716643095,
0.8190333843,
-0.8131814003,
-0.6559807062,
-0.3791932166,
0.4494113028,
0.0788014382,
0.0305168964,
0.4118454158,
-0.3965446651,
-0.4976327717,
0.0354964808,
-0.8113518357,
-0.05667625,
-0.2545500994,
-0.0790703222,
0.1526652426,
0.4124758244,
-0.4323696792,
0.4251731634,
0.4076688886,
-0.3379449546,
0.1041365638,
-0.4426846802,
0.272405535,
-1.1189937592,
-0.0885602832,
0.4483112693,
0.4489546418,
-0.9982197881,
-0.5010854602,
0.0383805409,
-0.1728279889,
-0.6289061308,
0.8692631721,
-0.2101072371,
0.3725273907,
-0.2656782269,
0.0553745441,
-0.0976777673,
0.5063881874,
0.1701517552,
0.3920612335,
0.5802450776,
-0.647141695,
0.0586640164,
0.3351043463,
-0.0765893757,
0.5084211826,
-0.4897353053,
-0.5485146046,
-0.2655113041,
0.2661806941,
-0.5895510912,
-0.3845308125,
0.3965936601,
-0.6796628237,
0.6470968723,
-0.2341786325,
0.087037541,
-0.2080879509,
-0.6157726645,
0.3453271389,
0.0936851203,
-0.2860628664,
0.5452929735,
0.7915461659,
-0.1516551673,
-0.7209630013,
-0.5621430278,
0.1452358812,
0.0177400429,
0.1137696207,
0.4279681444,
-0.1324402541,
-0.0237023085,
0.1278424561,
0.1612188965,
-0.7030973434,
-0.1445396245,
0.5461019278,
0.6829438806,
0.3209443688,
0.3005686402,
0.1173886508,
-0.3581100702,
0.0260212347,
0.1438135356,
0.033559978,
0.3314792514,
0.2323557287,
-0.5451570153,
0.3174479604,
0.4550581276,
0.0540221334,
0.628464222,
0.3547210693,
-0.2795095742,
-0.1495040506,
-0.1255085021,
0.0743611082,
-0.4217582643,
0.3672279119,
-0.359577477,
-0.3250648677,
0.0414589159,
-0.1907608211,
-0.3546396792,
0.0962035879,
0.4261398315,
0.0451810397,
0.6731449962,
0.7767133713,
0.00212884,
0.4484661818,
-0.2442954034,
0.3861902654,
-0.7513298988,
-0.5635538697,
0.0012595204,
-0.0933564603,
-0.6801831722,
-0.4850886464,
0.2858996093,
-0.075785093,
-0.2326546907,
0.3320710659,
-0.2227887958,
0.5057368875,
0.0387823842,
-0.031749852,
0.1122016907,
-0.0223644841,
-0.1740765125,
0.0538083278,
-0.400182873,
0.0430379696,
1.4812276363,
0.2089693099,
0.7643605471,
0.0680013895,
0.8000141978,
0.1124698594,
0.2725945413,
-0.6610404849,
0.3905411959,
-0.1615971625,
-0.3119158745,
-0.2090904117,
-0.6305843592,
-1.1587148905,
-0.2568898499,
-0.8115700483,
-0.69601053,
0.2378321737,
-0.4838292599,
-0.8498260379,
0.2116423994,
-0.8827438354,
0.6828554869,
-0.2450757623,
-0.2680567205,
-0.0667679831,
-0.6499212384,
0.3429531753,
-0.0495676175,
0.3999136686,
-0.2285624593,
-0.0256613083,
0.3356513977,
-0.2788264751,
0.7797635198,
-0.1375590414,
-0.1245338321,
0.1246533096,
-0.0264109299,
-0.0379599631,
0.1352177262,
-0.0490058735,
0.3538857102,
0.1763420254,
-0.3543473482,
-0.860363543,
1.0294120312,
-0.6565859318,
0.0842306241,
-0.5645171404,
-0.2129338831,
-0.1292521507,
0.1566969901,
0.2013326883,
0.2028828263,
-0.4709947407,
-0.7819796801,
0.5899429321,
-0.6087170839,
0.4788022041,
1.0185279846,
-0.2802156806,
-0.7182218432,
1.0987019539,
0.2014144063,
-0.0912811011,
0.7512324452,
0.0046403934,
-0.1892939061,
-0.5791729689,
-0.5113903284,
0.2383377701,
-0.3009213209,
-0.3963587284,
-0.6462881565,
-0.4320167303,
-0.515825808,
0.0741632804,
0.0708648264,
-0.3782628477,
-0.1563242972,
-0.3259558678,
0.4547969401,
1.0550224781,
0.0196861252,
0.0011028462,
-0.793726027,
0.2913831472,
0.2774079144,
1.0378228426,
-0.209858492,
-0.1562215388,
-0.2432869077,
-0.2003177255,
-0.3523248136,
-1.0729308128,
0.4667184353,
0.1696980447,
0.5926510692,
0.5397570133,
0.3508840501,
0.2570256889,
-0.7239053249,
0.2629925907,
0.4007541537,
-0.6268780828,
0.8717648983,
-0.2543562651,
-0.0639655814,
0.4539183378,
0.5785927176,
-0.589776814,
-0.2434097379,
-0.345181644,
-0.7659811974,
0.7031686902,
0.2368521839,
-0.1020968556,
-0.3262419701,
0.5165167451,
0.1570260972,
0.2513076365,
-0.5912852287,
-0.4083921611,
0.0383670069,
-0.3847592473,
0.1146660596,
-0.430403918,
0.1942796558,
-0.159583956,
0.7422744632,
0.0815059617,
0.2927339375,
0.0429528654,
0.1073374823,
-0.5217217207,
0.5026475787,
0.2727951109,
0.3378804624,
-0.6150382161,
-0.1894756258,
0.0623077787,
-0.4485279024,
0.2108508348,
0.3130301833,
-0.1581556201,
-0.0844970867,
0.120973289,
0.9079518914,
0.2613151371,
-1.0848751068,
0.8016741872,
-0.2288164198,
-0.2279867828,
-0.4434426129,
-0.0477894507,
-0.5038430691,
0.2543133199,
0.0142036146,
-0.0226277895,
0.338847369,
-0.6074923277,
0.6731597781,
0.2766166925,
-0.7870299816,
-0.2198625952,
0.4442031682,
0.3227956891,
-0.281100601,
0.1228254363,
-0.3705328703,
-0.170055747,
0.3078922033,
0.2008450627,
0.7371664047,
-0.2017799765,
0.7878612876,
0.6286104918,
-0.5341084599,
0.461132288,
-0.0157777984,
0.3353864551,
-0.7283934355,
-0.4051282406,
-0.428556174,
-0.4525715709,
0.1537572891,
-0.2884089947,
0.674374342,
-0.6079196334,
-0.0916673467,
0.4088049531,
0.4414774477,
-0.0551539399,
0.1482960582,
0.2481957823,
0.2704695463,
-1.0674340725,
0.8969259858,
0.4928453267,
-0.880908668,
-0.3784421682,
0.2108568698,
0.0500729382,
-0.3836753666,
0.4665776789,
0.19449687,
0.2497408837,
-0.4341679513,
-0.073706679,
-0.6972605586,
1.2311774492,
-0.0282806661,
-0.2305060476,
0.0047026468,
0.1203035191,
0.5390306115,
-0.2810196877,
0.5132094622,
0.4215835929,
0.1486475021,
0.5170961022,
-0.6071603894,
0.0559129678,
-0.429017812,
-0.1482865959,
0.3579753935,
-0.0399084166,
0.9220849276,
-0.7225885391,
-0.3392684758,
0.1949253082,
0.2221583128,
0.1072446927,
0.691108346,
0.0761600211,
0.6078525782,
0.5083500147,
0.2819834352,
1.113031745,
-0.2019680589,
0.3585608304,
1.1887774467,
-0.6379122138,
1.0447522402,
0.339117527,
-0.1832041293,
0.8320029974,
0.4686112106,
-0.222751826,
0.7608301044,
0.2508952618,
-0.5443876982,
0.2423539311,
-0.1625217944,
0.0915045068,
0.1793671548,
0.2934078276,
0.1273474842,
-0.4322021604,
0.3372535706,
-0.2495719939,
0.1547534317,
-0.0395235308,
1.2197490931,
-0.3893173039,
-0.3952833712,
0.4513004422,
0.0351985469,
0.8130465746,
-0.348410219,
-0.2884203792,
-0.0565983206,
0.3422939181,
-0.1263367981,
-0.8369101882,
0.2184758037,
-0.3678048849,
-0.4856636524,
0.2918335795,
0.7683051825,
-0.6457124352,
-0.4520859718,
0.5496243238,
0.4026733041,
-0.0488345809,
0.0525535904,
-0.6897655725,
-0.0704820678,
-0.0742392987,
0.3320323825,
0.8686363697,
0.8114561439,
0.1256384104,
0.6825459003,
0.3780573308,
0.3774844408,
-0.3267960548,
-0.1110624224,
0.5838181376,
-0.6980527639,
-0.1993323863,
-0.4770584702,
0.3997611701,
-0.3065625131,
-0.1220165864,
0.2595352829,
0.4996335506,
0.3331214786,
0.0528631322,
0.7814467549,
0.2048186511,
0.8996239901,
-0.3244820535,
0.8837646842,
-0.2155071646,
0.4172946513,
-0.2983320355,
-0.2179133892,
-0.2804965973,
0.2069091797,
-0.3690160513,
-0.1505419016,
0.8374211788,
0.5080034137,
0.3156347573,
-0.1961773038,
0.3779261708,
0.42681548,
0.1068621278,
0.835986495,
0.3588696718,
-0.7485933304,
0.6876728535,
-0.464217484,
-0.4026947021,
0.0439874232,
-0.7687581778,
-0.8860810995,
-0.4529331326,
-0.4187424481,
-0.1990318447,
0.2008400708,
0.6878631115,
0.4527710378,
-1.0927759409,
-0.0021284726,
-0.3422434628,
0.4069201946,
-0.0000878255,
-0.2551919222,
0.2127178907,
-0.3885285258,
-0.6147074103,
0.1991078109,
0.4902805388,
0.3900625408,
0.0570670031,
-0.1871874481,
-0.412429601,
0.3516716063,
0.5568150282,
0.319370091,
-0.5110772848,
0.2577070296,
-0.1786688715,
-0.0567420609,
-0.175660044,
0.9709863067,
-1.1487447023,
0.4548169374,
0.1284435838,
0.6057457924,
0.3466912508,
-0.3549853265,
0.7678154707,
-0.4321811795,
-0.042365253,
0.1484169066,
0.0823961198,
0.0270135384,
-0.5418425798,
0.1606656313,
0.068044126,
-0.3480543196,
-0.4086162448,
0.158317849,
-0.7750227451,
-0.9047804475,
0.8936986327,
-0.1525455713,
-0.4836738706,
-0.304847151,
-0.2075366378,
0.0715049282,
-0.5175974965,
1.0294058323,
0.1998603791,
-0.1066483185,
-0.3106114864,
-0.7423229814,
0.6830314994,
-0.0294131171,
-0.7801195979,
0.1172626913,
0.5778334141,
0.319850415,
-0.0308695324,
0.8635456562,
-0.0416206717,
0.0190771706,
-0.0212760922,
0.0335884616,
-0.0094877956,
-0.2286649644,
-0.2865032852,
-0.028560847,
-0.2951263189,
-0.2961966097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08375v1
|
Translating between SQL Dialects for Cloud Migration
| 2024-03-13T09:38:39 | 2024-03-13T09:38:39 |
Ran Zmigrod, Salwa Alamir, Xiaomo Liu
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Migrations of systems from on-site premises to the cloud has been a
fundamental endeavor by many industrial institutions. A crucial component of
such cloud migrations is the transition of databases to be hosted online. In
this work, we consider the difficulties of this migration for SQL databases.
While SQL is one of the prominent methods for storing database procedures,
there are a plethora of different SQL dialects (e.g., MySQL, Postgres, etc.)
which can complicate migrations when the on-premise SQL dialect differs to the
dialect hosted on the cloud. Tools exist by common cloud provides such as AWS
and Azure to aid in translating between dialects in order to mitigate the
majority of the difficulties. However, these tools do not successfully
translate $100\%$ of the code. Consequently, software engineers must manually
convert the remainder of the untranslated database. For large organizations,
this task quickly becomes intractable and so more innovative solutions are
required. We consider this challenge a novel yet vital industrial research
problem for any large corporation that is considering cloud migrations.
Furthermore, we introduce potential avenues of research to tackle this
challenge that have yielded promising preliminary results.
|
[
-0.7084817886,
-0.6605380177,
0.7164123058,
0.4440096617,
-0.2841300368,
0.0806096941,
-0.1926059872,
-0.4639441967,
0.1741241217,
0.8960707188,
-0.7481892705,
-0.1428834349,
-0.110457845,
0.2488683909,
-0.6338682175,
0.7732919455,
0.010467398,
0.1288746595,
-0.3058120608,
-0.1025571004,
-0.3282898068,
-0.9976239204,
-0.2655920982,
0.1973671168,
-0.1992642879,
0.2848649919,
0.7717837095,
0.5067240596,
0.6764722466,
0.3087475598,
-0.0125741484,
0.0327309705,
-0.2150680423,
-0.069889538,
-0.1815491319,
-0.4419837594,
-0.0547825545,
-0.8081419468,
0.2344553918,
0.9618119597,
-0.5441650152,
0.1604601741,
-0.0369514152,
1.0194606781,
-0.5066252947,
0.0387161896,
-0.870675385,
0.0923706591,
-0.2922961116,
0.1680231541,
-0.0739153102,
-0.2948946059,
-0.2369454205,
-0.4256715477,
0.2716674209,
0.0036666791,
0.6353833675,
0.0243012588,
-0.4794235229,
-0.0863837898,
-1.1789550781,
0.7420369983,
-0.6817711592,
0.4891245961,
0.0723444298,
0.5425638556,
-0.2171464413,
-0.7251956463,
-0.3727321029,
0.0433805175,
0.1183287054,
-0.164521873,
-0.1138516888,
-0.2324744612,
0.1366201192,
0.4472705424,
-0.1347452551,
0.0750211105,
-0.4942816794,
-0.0970988125,
0.8135786057,
0.226020515,
0.032614015,
0.0972369611,
-0.2089439183,
0.1025298238,
-0.7376821041,
-0.0261080861,
0.0734700337,
0.5155665278,
0.1548048109,
0.2427300513,
-0.3216592669,
0.5177658796,
-0.0746082738,
0.3632891774,
0.1449587941,
-0.7121945024,
-0.1474015415,
0.1704736352,
0.287516892,
0.1974942684,
-0.1173178107,
-0.4127086699,
-0.3638551235,
-0.1721802354,
0.506621778,
-0.5961047411,
-0.1005633995,
0.4978430867,
-0.5173743963,
0.1070249006,
0.0026540738,
-0.8929849267,
-0.688200891,
-0.2890844941,
0.2976032794,
-0.1759485453,
-0.4495799839,
0.1955589801,
0.1467575431,
0.5697156191,
0.6521989703,
-0.6516612768,
0.5022337437,
0.9454339743,
0.9697540402,
-0.1433171779,
0.1534615904,
-0.1554694921,
0.0727471858,
-0.5512683392,
0.5271200538,
0.0887207836,
-0.5636767149,
0.3742426634,
0.2199364752,
-0.0383058339,
-0.6779131889,
0.4302070141,
-0.4567929208,
0.0682351291,
-0.5418561101,
-0.2487796247,
0.0114150373,
0.082256861,
-0.5523132086,
0.64546597,
0.3857670426,
-0.0428426117,
0.0326645561,
-0.5372558832,
-0.5016505718,
0.2959016562,
-0.0971530303,
-0.2891820669,
0.3206577301,
0.3359761536,
0.107514739,
-0.8392000794,
0.0826704204,
-0.3997123241,
-0.0305873863,
0.2638718188,
0.3497593999,
1.1084353924,
0.6061284542,
-0.3740237653,
-0.2893974483,
-0.568492353,
0.224186793,
-0.1021009237,
0.1824829727,
-0.3270846009,
0.2976771593,
0.1615733057,
0.2278996855,
0.2265327573,
-0.4734658897,
0.263266772,
-0.2517323494,
0.738686502,
0.2748943269,
0.116141133,
0.5086925626,
-0.0378441773,
0.5500795841,
0.012903274,
0.5135103464,
0.1872159392,
-0.2014299929,
-0.9512547851,
-0.105246827,
0.132631585,
0.7611121535,
-0.7966556549,
0.4533034861,
-0.5842201114,
-0.5435658693,
-0.763700366,
0.285581708,
-0.0468013138,
0.0413400866,
0.6561642289,
-0.4026586115,
-0.4787331522,
-1.1093754768,
-0.2468193769,
-0.0666863471,
-0.096212171,
0.1596629769,
0.318139255,
-0.2413798869,
0.9547339678,
-0.554232955,
-0.8158294559,
-0.0868221521,
-0.1194199547,
0.2510883808,
0.4059609771,
0.6782999039,
-0.8284540176,
-0.3891490996,
0.5031195283,
-0.6063920259,
-0.1887095869,
-0.462716639,
-0.0640226603,
0.3669334948,
0.786006093,
-0.6383252144,
0.1369624138,
0.3280265629,
-0.0082511548,
0.5611981153,
0.0261898804,
0.3912190497,
-1.1176400185,
0.1446102262,
-0.3942376971,
-0.0362372212,
-0.6730365157,
0.3777331412,
0.0627001151,
-0.4207983911,
-0.6101482511,
-0.1239211485,
-0.9372746944,
-0.2334587127,
0.209470585,
-0.1955838948,
-0.150720045,
0.0363648236,
-0.1443508267,
0.7896543741,
0.4806719124,
-0.8798949122,
0.5528001189,
0.5998607874,
-0.3968901634,
0.7649168372,
-0.0937065557,
0.2925877273,
0.208968699,
0.0797415748,
-0.5852072835,
0.0911724865,
-0.2120908797,
-0.2084807605,
-0.1068563238,
-0.5983685851,
-0.3399948478,
-0.311616838,
0.0226142984,
-0.3303194046,
0.7135885954,
-0.2572606802,
0.4847370088,
0.2254826427,
-0.2963962853,
-0.2219902724,
-1.2595604658,
0.6398209929,
-0.4209149778,
-0.7699397802,
0.4822815657,
0.3087846637,
-0.5874059796,
0.1724306047,
-0.2111544162,
-0.5792789459,
0.1365131736,
-0.0205311645,
0.0424679071,
-0.5185422301,
-0.2261144817,
0.0643820167,
0.296154201,
0.3820905685,
-0.505338788,
0.1899807155,
-0.0985363498,
-0.2751739919,
-0.1098597199,
0.7773506641,
0.9053990245,
-0.3359978795,
1.3016014099,
0.3329842389,
-0.2600041926,
-0.465524435,
-0.6240907907,
-0.1083552241,
-0.4898871183,
0.511536181,
-0.4175713658,
-0.2967128456,
0.6481906176,
-0.5266045928,
0.0153367966,
0.3498421311,
0.0119364355,
-0.2568329573,
0.7317285538,
0.7481431961,
0.2920138836,
0.6237637997,
-0.1763504148,
0.3892604113,
-0.4467976391,
-0.1540389359,
-0.9219917059,
0.0320017673,
-0.3301496208,
-0.33289361,
0.6317968965,
0.1850385517,
-0.0119665377,
0.7161297798,
-0.2220002413,
0.2306636125,
-0.0679953694,
-0.0611500666,
0.2406195551,
0.4201953113,
0.3000110686,
-0.1145929992,
-0.5916815996,
-0.2282817066,
0.6483595967,
-0.0273468345,
0.3555212915,
0.7223358154,
0.7917074561,
0.5132431388,
0.1476534307,
-0.3774122894,
0.6729517579,
-0.4279492795,
-0.7320090532,
-0.2740718126,
-0.5534917712,
-0.9736663699,
0.2269412875,
-0.5388402343,
-0.4925017953,
0.4939053059,
0.0637894049,
-0.0373634063,
0.4168856144,
-0.7365914583,
0.9067370296,
-0.6744247079,
-0.4294281006,
-0.3984304368,
-0.7362065315,
-0.0736890212,
-0.4957253039,
0.7520864606,
0.2452098727,
-0.1129450276,
0.289258182,
-0.8668084145,
0.3662582338,
-0.2375525683,
0.0618827343,
0.1973188221,
0.3795771897,
0.3413413465,
-0.4814443886,
-0.4415764511,
0.5613196492,
0.286143899,
-0.4437393844,
-0.6355937123,
0.5968417525,
-0.5632842779,
-0.5546918511,
-0.4334260225,
0.1480772644,
-0.4951895773,
0.1868920028,
0.2931905687,
0.0325826295,
-0.5194522142,
0.4380461574,
0.5227562785,
0.1153299883,
0.3199313879,
0.5778040886,
-0.138909176,
-0.3916715384,
0.5966202617,
0.3057851493,
0.4779748619,
0.3469278514,
-0.1465318352,
-0.6568368673,
-0.9125204086,
-0.7564464808,
0.1405445486,
-0.7070182562,
-0.0301380605,
-0.2550545037,
0.0145395938,
-0.511204958,
-0.4588003457,
-0.540646255,
-0.7023856044,
-0.4300206304,
0.2028627247,
0.3081229627,
0.5668565035,
0.321323514,
0.1069378704,
-1.1425173283,
-0.1235200167,
-0.0186718423,
0.2567870319,
-0.3152300715,
-0.5777036548,
-0.4553954601,
0.1046241671,
-0.0288055707,
-1.233905673,
0.5438933969,
0.3535816967,
0.5276947618,
0.0773703679,
0.3897526264,
1.0185960531,
-0.3877521455,
0.7576797009,
-0.0366942436,
-1.1898149252,
0.4242123961,
-0.3273640573,
-0.349748224,
1.0289570093,
0.5463700294,
-0.8303816319,
0.084919706,
-0.5560212731,
-1.297837019,
0.5618114471,
0.3779525459,
0.0440060347,
0.5199462175,
0.4514591992,
0.0571227744,
0.6072966456,
-0.2429818064,
-0.1941679418,
-0.1267041564,
0.1657063514,
-0.3571747541,
0.4364657998,
-0.1470549256,
-0.1498391181,
0.4978262186,
0.1508629322,
0.0088435151,
0.1505285054,
-0.3860007226,
0.2226919234,
0.5454959869,
0.0784757212,
0.585080564,
-0.0321802162,
-0.0165518187,
0.2989984155,
-0.1174886823,
0.1466287524,
-0.0368935876,
-0.4742946327,
0.0771603361,
-0.0399044603,
0.6970378757,
-0.2528864741,
-0.4707796574,
0.4586787522,
0.2710553408,
-0.0540109016,
-0.6489262581,
-0.1953168511,
0.2676416636,
-0.0902952701,
0.4747191668,
0.002663939,
0.2320997119,
-0.7192513943,
0.0704159662,
0.3684999645,
-0.2261274755,
-0.1146645844,
0.5242035985,
0.5734152198,
-0.5508962274,
0.8169254065,
-0.1600036323,
-0.4816640019,
0.6875206828,
0.6049156785,
1.1713583469,
-0.1538274735,
0.0197883081,
0.2044367641,
0.5267260075,
-0.4618363976,
0.1495270729,
0.0582111217,
-0.3044313192,
0.060772147,
-0.4000155032,
-0.5517598987,
-0.1819144338,
-0.7978509068,
0.3029667735,
-0.445507586,
-0.2059213668,
-0.3542222977,
-0.4428273737,
-0.439664185,
-0.0768676475,
0.3182685673,
0.7653999329,
-1.280163765,
0.4963802993,
0.9950758815,
-0.3556289971,
-0.1462257355,
-0.1661651284,
-0.0982464924,
-0.3604527712,
0.0145416511,
-0.2827018201,
-0.229885757,
0.1665577292,
-0.4139229357,
-0.7012197971,
0.7515331507,
0.6278074384,
-0.5146457553,
0.2730289698,
0.5221304893,
0.8774102926,
-0.1425987333,
-0.0487124696,
0.5377169251,
0.3503850102,
-0.3521454334,
-0.981354475,
-0.0442921072,
-0.0961022228,
0.1810629219,
0.4521992207,
-0.5469569564,
0.9006668925,
0.0550764464,
-0.3173948526,
-0.2960068583,
0.6002904773,
-0.4181704521,
0.1689615548,
0.5661236048,
0.0203496516,
0.5062023401,
-0.0328965299,
0.8845854402,
-0.2625990808,
0.4394539297,
0.6176991463,
-0.5850246549,
1.0410068035,
0.7451472282,
-0.7074202299,
0.7031183839,
0.4468596876,
0.0753372908,
0.1780019552,
0.092062749,
-0.3895993531,
-0.5719999671,
0.032705266,
-0.6098410487,
0.1738692075,
0.452519387,
0.059724275,
0.0261291824,
-0.3620178998,
-0.0277833771,
0.3235373795,
-0.3835389912,
0.9018450975,
0.1248063222,
-0.6609645486,
0.7444045544,
0.1574653685,
0.2945940793,
-1.0660930872,
0.1771210581,
-0.4366438091,
0.272857666,
-0.5887707472,
-0.5947368741,
0.7612125874,
-0.280341655,
0.3081735969,
-0.5223090649,
0.2259882241,
-0.3621559739,
-0.265794754,
0.366224736,
0.6102145314,
0.2790660858,
-0.4764594734,
-0.6738847494,
-0.0847102627,
0.2344781309,
0.3016799986,
0.5367021561,
0.4615314901,
-0.4618570507,
0.6875087619,
0.7229300737,
0.2674926519,
0.305025816,
-0.3303844035,
0.5441765189,
-0.6224704981,
-0.8397269249,
-0.568125546,
0.2449625582,
-0.1635451764,
-0.0525376685,
0.7308983207,
0.6980562806,
0.533084929,
-0.7256577015,
0.7478293777,
-0.4051878452,
0.1687580347,
-0.6469074488,
0.8092560768,
-0.6934812069,
0.2767369747,
-0.1978891939,
-1.0344102383,
-0.1047743186,
0.443623811,
0.1070411801,
-0.4096001089,
1.0185081959,
0.8501847982,
0.1151677296,
-0.0209872946,
0.1521813124,
0.2402628511,
0.2871220708,
0.5238646269,
0.4877575934,
-0.3021685779,
0.8090344667,
-0.3675586283,
0.0106948856,
-0.2878641188,
-1.182091713,
-0.0348480903,
-0.6504732966,
-0.574952662,
-0.6131527424,
0.1095438153,
0.8764568567,
0.5476086736,
-1.2783322334,
-0.7948356271,
-0.1523158103,
-0.217391789,
-0.8354364634,
-0.0761901662,
0.0870739445,
-0.096979633,
-0.2407916784,
0.375192225,
-0.0510686077,
-0.0383093618,
-0.2727651894,
0.330450058,
0.1228834465,
-0.0003062681,
0.2835297585,
0.6676219702,
-0.3815886676,
0.0145326685,
-0.0649143755,
-0.2284332216,
0.2245309502,
0.9122377038,
-0.450748533,
0.2495021969,
0.5508950949,
1.0451073647,
0.8724318743,
0.2752378285,
0.5117381215,
-0.7386097908,
0.1175518259,
0.298446089,
0.1944564283,
0.4493307173,
-0.459100008,
0.6321777701,
0.5390324593,
-0.4110366404,
-0.955237627,
0.315238297,
-1.0906113386,
-0.2946515977,
1.1778329611,
0.2359364778,
-0.1080675796,
-0.6958390474,
-0.1998170167,
-0.035459727,
0.0605298355,
0.6420364976,
0.6334473491,
-0.3130089045,
0.0193475857,
-0.5258868337,
0.4396470487,
0.5008994341,
-1.0319969654,
0.3077485561,
0.611322701,
0.2034032792,
0.2659763694,
0.5974726677,
-0.1240240633,
0.1227580234,
0.2034712434,
0.5479696393,
-0.0069937655,
-0.0948989689,
-0.7615296841,
0.2437553555,
0.1862000823,
-0.1970587373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08370v1
|
SMART: Submodular Data Mixture Strategy for Instruction Tuning
| 2024-03-13T09:31:50 | 2024-03-13T09:31:50 |
H S V N S Kowndinya Renduchintala, Sumit Bhatia, Ganesh Ramakrishnan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Instruction Tuning involves finetuning a language model on a collection of
instruction-formatted datasets in order to enhance the generalizability of the
model to unseen tasks. Studies have shown the importance of balancing different
task proportions during finetuning, but finding the right balance remains
challenging. Unfortunately, there's currently no systematic method beyond
manual tuning or relying on practitioners' intuition. In this paper, we
introduce SMART (Submodular data Mixture strAtegy for instRuction Tuning) - a
novel data mixture strategy which makes use of a submodular function to assign
importance scores to tasks which are then used to determine the mixture
weights. Given a fine-tuning budget, SMART redistributes the budget among tasks
and selects non-redundant samples from each task. Experimental results
demonstrate that SMART significantly outperforms traditional methods such as
examples proportional mixing and equal mixing. Furthermore, SMART facilitates
the creation of data mixtures based on a few representative subsets of tasks
alone and through task pruning analysis, we reveal that in a limited budget
setting, allocating budget among a subset of representative tasks yields
superior performance compared to distributing the budget among all tasks. The
code for reproducing our results is open-sourced at
https://github.com/kowndinya-renduchintala/SMART.
|
[
-0.4597440064,
-0.8373637199,
-0.0212738048,
0.0644688457,
-0.4690057039,
0.0976403877,
-0.2143005133,
0.1166575104,
0.0870319009,
0.3359852433,
-0.802903533,
-0.2915305793,
-0.4589766562,
-0.4263963997,
-0.3715221286,
1.0744708776,
0.1987537295,
0.3057810366,
-0.5418417454,
0.0761156157,
-1.0066728592,
-0.0944363251,
-0.1637072712,
-0.481900394,
0.3784011602,
0.883230269,
0.4873145819,
1.0988329649,
0.4813929498,
0.3455572426,
0.3266415298,
0.422593832,
-0.4777803123,
0.0643673241,
-0.4235042632,
-0.699370563,
-0.5054129362,
-0.0690405965,
0.2314963937,
0.4706649482,
-0.2837919295,
0.1889065653,
-0.0204455014,
0.7642289996,
-0.8155243397,
0.113506414,
-0.5004954338,
0.0630199462,
-0.5415554643,
-0.6386303306,
-0.0900131613,
-0.2811360657,
-0.0268109217,
-0.4692339003,
0.316748023,
0.0553137846,
0.4699502587,
0.532751441,
-0.0774528831,
-0.1316410005,
-0.636300981,
1.2367274761,
-0.6587421894,
0.3362350762,
0.3656465113,
0.1901015192,
-0.0778804347,
-0.3922470808,
-0.4365189373,
0.2215086222,
0.1708643436,
0.3261467814,
0.2864938676,
0.0992789343,
0.0544658788,
0.3579871953,
-0.2344700843,
0.0971334726,
-0.5403184295,
-0.1005940214,
0.5538822412,
0.1794737726,
0.229038924,
0.1480861008,
-0.2306685895,
-0.0444953591,
-0.2916226089,
0.034277603,
0.8148002028,
0.2639973462,
0.0060474128,
0.6404336691,
-0.3340988457,
0.9174689054,
0.4373360872,
-0.5411769748,
0.1506987512,
-0.6082536578,
-0.1761304289,
0.2890018523,
0.2776409984,
0.4697526395,
0.6405887604,
0.0054159425,
-0.404376179,
-0.0115866177,
0.4471123219,
-0.7250822186,
-0.7354437113,
0.199802056,
-0.220979169,
-0.1882962137,
0.0751460865,
-0.6295714974,
-0.2673790455,
-0.7198438048,
0.4629561603,
-0.5708407164,
0.0097719701,
0.0086748861,
-0.0546010062,
0.0527962707,
0.1036955193,
-1.409285903,
0.3931046426,
1.0307826996,
0.5177314281,
-0.1603748798,
-0.1229317412,
-0.624935627,
0.0032785069,
-0.3331412971,
0.9169377685,
-0.5914614797,
-0.4083019197,
-0.4396503866,
-0.1146144643,
-0.4935948551,
-0.9427280426,
0.2802136838,
-0.2513307929,
0.1083246022,
-0.1043009609,
-0.6573783159,
-0.0574961193,
-0.036361292,
-0.5838258266,
0.9220375419,
0.3645866811,
-0.6266166568,
0.4206576049,
-0.3754357994,
-0.7955005169,
0.218853727,
-0.2583641112,
-0.579631865,
0.2435864955,
0.1645429879,
0.3774043322,
-0.2411503345,
0.2316665351,
-0.0284281112,
-0.6550512314,
0.0839537755,
-0.2943039536,
0.509349525,
0.1811989248,
-0.4235877097,
0.3033780754,
-0.4594982564,
0.4454420805,
-0.2130155265,
-0.2651988268,
-0.5240704417,
0.1911772192,
-0.0631285906,
-0.1469988674,
0.5010830164,
-0.3613524735,
0.1710320413,
-0.2839147747,
0.3765448928,
0.8093140721,
-0.1527767032,
0.6371695399,
-0.6891248226,
0.4951426685,
0.2277533561,
0.3864936829,
0.0122446595,
-0.3096052706,
-0.7681542039,
-0.5421959162,
0.8429384232,
1.0640207529,
-0.637168169,
0.7086859345,
-0.0932276696,
-0.3894378543,
-0.8348064423,
0.4694141448,
0.4884171188,
0.6009135842,
0.4805196524,
-0.3833138943,
-0.4803523421,
-1.0421682596,
-0.0485978462,
0.4342293739,
0.2548385262,
0.2417322993,
0.1700350195,
-0.1876537353,
1.0168021917,
-0.3563496768,
-0.3152543902,
-0.4596402943,
0.0338275246,
0.0315645784,
0.9905579686,
0.2262643576,
-0.8746768236,
-0.3424273431,
0.0157685932,
-0.0997926965,
-0.1872458309,
-0.1070815399,
-0.1587080061,
0.1301306039,
0.268268615,
-0.3112010658,
0.1619619727,
0.5055162311,
0.1103483886,
0.3152197599,
-0.2286199778,
0.1071801335,
-0.985337019,
-0.2103441805,
-0.2337410897,
-0.1002012119,
-0.2668011487,
-0.0030986348,
0.2288925499,
0.1698995829,
-0.4030608535,
0.1078817025,
-0.1558997482,
0.1961835325,
-0.3042725921,
-0.2310109437,
-0.0978186056,
0.4815977514,
-0.3200125098,
0.7485168576,
0.5489236116,
-0.4845155478,
0.6170466542,
-0.3083044291,
-0.5643781424,
0.6445002556,
-0.6837377548,
0.0246849302,
-0.0105802566,
-0.0964432955,
-0.7644053698,
-0.2301549762,
0.1777195483,
-0.0074899942,
0.515437007,
-0.2051762044,
-0.3754957318,
0.0160394739,
-0.2201027423,
0.5107704401,
0.5401130915,
-0.0752569512,
0.5718993545,
0.5274018645,
-0.302650243,
-0.2665851116,
-0.7842972875,
-0.5842959881,
-0.3035471141,
-0.4973702431,
0.5524831414,
-0.1418471485,
-0.2253366262,
0.199238658,
-0.633944571,
-0.0908313915,
0.2124521285,
0.0430010408,
0.2284560055,
-0.1144473329,
-0.1148538664,
0.4326586723,
-0.4234534502,
-0.3678696752,
-0.4338370562,
0.545955658,
0.2177733779,
-0.4057569504,
-0.3887008429,
0.5517812371,
0.5218511224,
-0.3313678801,
0.6272694468,
0.619446516,
-0.2460014671,
-0.5660339594,
-0.4509339929,
-0.3037406206,
-0.5155730247,
0.5290547013,
-0.1207406595,
-0.3954561055,
0.2781458795,
-0.2409791052,
0.3982864022,
-0.0267684571,
0.5044063926,
-0.192452997,
1.172441721,
0.5701721311,
-0.1058374941,
0.8238624334,
-0.3606458306,
0.4350661039,
-0.5291134715,
-0.41147089,
-0.284866631,
-0.8747956753,
-0.5814089775,
-0.5209312439,
0.289282769,
0.1905425936,
0.0975354537,
0.1166041717,
-0.5027797818,
0.7287088037,
1.0687713623,
0.1537870169,
0.0427254364,
-0.0808987319,
0.0669248998,
-0.1069854498,
-0.9412244558,
-0.1670127958,
0.8305312991,
-0.112574771,
0.978056252,
-0.2634203434,
0.8716292381,
0.28474316,
-0.1176142097,
-0.9665898085,
0.6370731592,
-0.6498142481,
-0.2577338517,
-0.1887480468,
-0.5783468485,
-0.7153247595,
0.0520273149,
-0.1349327564,
-0.2191937566,
0.0917390063,
0.4252284765,
-0.6206591129,
-0.0774803683,
-1.2232837677,
0.9141969085,
-0.47456339,
-0.15721789,
-0.3047930598,
-0.3550893962,
0.118577376,
-0.1235651001,
0.1708315611,
-0.0321762152,
-0.026971763,
0.8561187983,
-0.427819401,
0.5461540222,
-0.1560142934,
0.0095665893,
0.2518719733,
-0.0714335144,
0.4102578461,
-0.0351889879,
0.0957883373,
-0.2434921265,
0.0953205153,
-0.6769174933,
-0.7721632719,
0.9979935288,
-0.6257633567,
-0.4631000757,
-0.0560091846,
-1.1698280573,
-0.3454122841,
0.2720208466,
0.2950790226,
0.7418326139,
0.475649327,
0.5334854722,
1.1148329973,
0.1392424107,
0.2188757509,
0.2977605164,
0.5341767073,
-0.2406483442,
1.5458757877,
0.5277807117,
0.2479943037,
0.5466410518,
0.3985995948,
0.0088563394,
-0.5783054233,
-0.3909234405,
-0.279964745,
-0.3534635305,
-0.1637755185,
-0.258571744,
-0.1116072908,
-0.4006510973,
-0.1714370847,
-0.6339891553,
-0.4209137261,
-0.2269216925,
-0.0323168598,
0.2484990954,
0.1152186915,
0.1661315858,
0.2234402001,
-0.5414875746,
0.3308961093,
0.6449385881,
0.1481294036,
-0.3312751949,
-0.1202798933,
-0.5522224307,
0.2756262124,
-0.3138854504,
-0.5658008456,
0.2121396959,
0.1480321586,
0.7248786688,
0.2337399721,
0.2319287807,
1.0107294321,
-0.3308574557,
0.3543902934,
-0.1911253184,
-0.8640425801,
0.4075953364,
-0.3051720858,
0.5458981991,
0.7755422592,
0.0494619608,
0.0927173942,
-0.2979732156,
-0.5232598782,
-1.1897642612,
0.7465181947,
-0.1800152361,
-0.038475506,
0.2498968244,
-0.1224427745,
0.0478059985,
0.4474923313,
-0.0379261337,
-0.2132535875,
-0.2698180079,
-0.8463470936,
0.1109676063,
0.1938789189,
-0.3641802669,
-0.5110229254,
0.6419568658,
-0.1274507493,
0.2157092243,
-0.2172386497,
0.077705279,
-0.0865331963,
0.1722611487,
0.7597510219,
0.6914518476,
-0.1080944091,
0.1063347235,
-0.0117425714,
-0.7131846547,
-0.2506575882,
0.2531758249,
-0.3831677437,
-0.2879140973,
0.2391207516,
0.6264097691,
0.4058843851,
-0.9523934126,
0.1789142787,
0.2090312243,
-0.2453820407,
0.2766556144,
0.742277205,
0.0592219234,
0.3055430055,
0.3901037872,
0.3469362557,
-0.0584850162,
-0.5215314031,
0.1822741926,
0.2925949991,
-0.2439152449,
-0.048692964,
0.165223822,
0.192620337,
-0.3442659676,
0.571194768,
-0.1810339093,
-0.3398104906,
0.948059082,
0.4741815925,
0.6810122728,
-0.0951360837,
0.1732037663,
-0.1838692129,
0.2848201394,
-0.0224203132,
0.6271133423,
-0.2019839585,
-0.3810954094,
-0.2978727818,
-0.3431837261,
-0.4148980975,
0.0304987896,
-0.6037622094,
0.0541207381,
-0.4741472304,
0.0926859304,
-0.2401321977,
0.3097785711,
-0.4278106093,
0.3940188885,
-0.1993444562,
0.6245654225,
-0.7522367835,
0.984713912,
0.6767805815,
0.2283850908,
-0.8626462817,
0.0009582896,
-0.1348034739,
-0.5112193227,
0.2040172964,
-0.0440209545,
0.032131277,
0.0697122142,
-0.1931831092,
-0.6632066369,
1.0074045658,
0.4246397316,
-0.7693951726,
0.2188030183,
-0.1170932949,
0.2577389777,
-0.1923752874,
-0.143107757,
0.5504751205,
0.4980465472,
0.0080180494,
-0.6204108596,
-0.1858556271,
-0.3002159894,
-0.2371131182,
0.5464411974,
-0.6393682361,
1.0789853334,
-0.0891056508,
-0.115954645,
0.0433188602,
0.7021943927,
0.2259765565,
0.5022708178,
0.5819543004,
0.5917998552,
0.7376892567,
-0.2283845097,
0.7797814012,
-0.4705134928,
0.1090815738,
1.0993597507,
0.0184756126,
0.3512569964,
0.555863142,
0.1563085467,
0.3779316545,
0.5695345402,
-0.016981544,
1.0726284981,
0.2118154764,
-0.1430170536,
-0.3122870326,
-0.2192914933,
-0.2868010402,
0.2602572143,
0.3521607518,
-0.0744730979,
-0.1210438088,
0.0290432386,
-0.217666924,
0.0385638177,
-0.4727409482,
0.565038085,
-0.2096699029,
-1.0160098076,
0.3863310814,
0.1597931832,
0.6836167574,
-0.7749990225,
-0.0012060801,
-0.2864991426,
0.7086971998,
-0.3962769806,
-0.5060825944,
0.1900651455,
-0.289711535,
-0.3813238442,
-0.4099713266,
0.4709714055,
-0.7370679975,
-0.4475806653,
-0.4555108845,
0.2512599826,
-0.300775975,
0.3800568283,
-0.7314073443,
-0.0662797391,
-0.0041373847,
-0.0734023899,
0.6743093133,
0.5082739592,
-0.3450591862,
0.4906761348,
0.5618754029,
0.0522136204,
0.2203645408,
0.0563256443,
0.8036020398,
-0.2689599693,
-0.6132907271,
-0.6819007993,
0.4007647336,
0.1874084026,
-0.5467984676,
0.8757939935,
0.5852676034,
1.0770833492,
-0.1596305519,
0.5562811494,
-0.147682488,
0.2823150754,
-0.6395825148,
0.3006236851,
-0.4149197638,
0.0530298091,
-0.1484111249,
-0.7263509035,
0.1392288059,
0.6518330574,
-0.3182623386,
0.2248134464,
0.3760932684,
0.9609761834,
-0.4035404325,
0.0463121682,
0.052561827,
-0.270745486,
-0.160456866,
0.5143333077,
0.3631846011,
-0.1164066792,
0.2124972641,
-0.7378447056,
-0.3116366565,
-0.2762753069,
-0.7065683603,
-0.6920452118,
-0.3443708122,
-0.5706831813,
0.1519262344,
0.1525298655,
0.9440813065,
1.1774437428,
-0.949288547,
-0.0677756295,
-0.3371473849,
0.3145936728,
-0.9238221049,
-0.3123907149,
0.102919966,
-0.2543238997,
-0.9985906482,
0.5203206539,
0.1021984518,
-0.1283200383,
-0.2321931571,
0.0990412384,
-0.1462869644,
0.3670734465,
0.1069738716,
0.1821956187,
-0.2131620198,
0.0799535587,
0.0415257029,
-0.0973321199,
-0.5677214861,
1.0305563211,
-0.6830177903,
0.5005158186,
0.8926855922,
0.8023374081,
0.0813739076,
0.3649198711,
0.4567065835,
-0.9777959585,
0.1603654474,
0.3334524632,
0.133226037,
0.1923924536,
-0.4629554152,
0.1726192832,
0.4604402781,
-0.5276077986,
-0.6763583422,
0.0698774233,
-1.1452593803,
-0.2866072953,
0.815173924,
0.1224603057,
-0.2373210639,
-0.1081745401,
-0.3634888828,
0.1527441144,
-0.3956008554,
0.9411914349,
0.4215926528,
-0.2016562819,
0.0289049912,
-0.6347615123,
0.1991069466,
0.8967455626,
-0.6738381386,
-0.3180474639,
0.2852746248,
0.1884863824,
0.052799549,
0.282313019,
0.1861366332,
0.4494358003,
-0.1485325843,
-0.4669783711,
-0.577475369,
-0.626303494,
0.2871041298,
0.2241659611,
-0.5641425848,
-0.7685135603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08358v1
|
Log Summarisation for Defect Evolution Analysis
| 2024-03-13T09:18:46 | 2024-03-13T09:18:46 |
Rares Dolga, Ran Zmigrod, Rui Silva, Salwa Alamir, Sameena Shah
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Log analysis and monitoring are essential aspects in software maintenance and
identifying defects. In particular, the temporal nature and vast size of log
data leads to an interesting and important research question: How can logs be
summarised and monitored over time? While this has been a fundamental topic of
research in the software engineering community, work has typically focused on
heuristic-, syntax-, or static-based methods. In this work, we suggest an
online semantic-based clustering approach to error logs that dynamically
updates the log clusters to enable monitoring code error life-cycles. We also
introduce a novel metric to evaluate the performance of temporal log clusters.
We test our system and evaluation metric with an industrial dataset and find
that our solution outperforms similar systems. We hope that our work encourages
further temporal exploration in defect datasets.
|
[
-0.0363860801,
-0.4633737504,
0.527035594,
0.4241579473,
-0.3607686162,
0.4784330726,
0.263550669,
-0.6120197773,
0.3820734918,
0.0245220549,
-0.8513303399,
-0.7369531393,
-0.1082046777,
-0.0153479334,
-0.5319843292,
1.2366635799,
-0.0892844871,
-0.2803794742,
-0.3093259931,
-0.356703639,
-0.5969662666,
-0.3627535701,
-0.6086607575,
0.1389051974,
0.423951298,
0.1094268858,
0.2481832653,
0.5010219812,
0.5082125068,
0.2652647793,
-0.4221001565,
0.1834815145,
-0.3135972321,
0.2068303972,
0.3270631433,
-0.8132743239,
-0.7247420549,
-0.5633752942,
0.5024439692,
0.7321658134,
-0.2428087443,
0.260825634,
-0.0502226874,
0.607770443,
-0.3976778984,
0.5378331542,
-0.5784760118,
0.5295011401,
-0.0463189222,
-0.3713240325,
-0.153188929,
-0.4956960678,
-0.1006164327,
-0.5667970181,
0.4773975313,
-0.0177703034,
0.5832476616,
0.5155901313,
-0.054401353,
-0.2085740864,
-0.6939364076,
0.8726323247,
-1.1511534452,
0.0961102247,
-0.0729056299,
0.4737534225,
-0.2445870787,
-0.6997370124,
-0.0458282121,
-0.0231627878,
-0.4108788967,
0.2273952663,
0.1762962341,
-0.310089618,
-0.0447643735,
0.5949923992,
-0.7281240225,
0.2964524925,
-0.298694253,
-0.1385457069,
0.7339814305,
0.7455742359,
0.3590762615,
0.0358542427,
-0.0551177636,
0.1032333821,
-0.2811633348,
-0.1697684079,
0.2088614404,
-0.0695857108,
-0.050844755,
0.1524525583,
-0.3767817616,
0.8169178367,
-0.3408388197,
-0.3137588799,
0.2666526139,
-0.3868343532,
-0.0260415021,
0.2292891443,
0.3149070144,
0.6393127441,
-0.3003349602,
-0.3807671368,
-0.1553286612,
0.3672207594,
0.2739797831,
-0.51450634,
-0.466627866,
0.5711867809,
-0.5647892356,
-0.6545231938,
0.1105455086,
-1.0484477282,
-0.5399454236,
0.2447649091,
0.073214218,
-0.0935611725,
-0.4905039668,
0.1245088875,
-0.5519315004,
-0.0331253409,
0.3014107049,
-0.4841824174,
0.1745636761,
0.8670720458,
0.8929433227,
-0.3180681765,
-0.1831200421,
-0.6444666386,
0.327717483,
-0.5324372649,
0.8300612569,
-0.3947740495,
-0.6022081971,
-0.1186812297,
0.0895925239,
0.0441540591,
-0.8274906278,
0.1753234863,
-0.4605719745,
0.262594074,
0.4289756417,
-0.3975542784,
-0.2214521915,
0.2061364949,
-0.5238267779,
1.3026624918,
0.4724522233,
-0.8362213373,
0.5888059735,
-0.8196834326,
-0.2335251421,
-0.0748221949,
-0.0875145793,
-0.8858392239,
0.3435624838,
0.0232828353,
0.343413353,
0.1547169238,
0.0924187228,
-0.3508242071,
-0.2846958637,
0.2763470411,
0.105544731,
0.649248004,
0.2186857015,
-0.6086834669,
0.2620318234,
-1.1434385777,
0.0451024845,
0.0245126393,
-0.1552933007,
-0.4247168303,
0.5994814038,
-0.3558912277,
0.0291345809,
0.3448452652,
-0.6260930896,
0.1880414486,
-0.3589040637,
0.2964583337,
0.488611877,
0.578584969,
-0.0955696851,
-0.3027385175,
0.3630933464,
0.3629951179,
0.713054359,
-0.4350455701,
-0.5052781701,
-0.7840726972,
-0.0001274468,
0.0358127467,
0.693764329,
-0.0739075914,
0.5202528834,
-0.3715085685,
-0.6115032434,
-0.0812544748,
0.1430687159,
0.1873233169,
0.1495223194,
0.3636317849,
-0.5792346001,
-0.3769641519,
-0.571521759,
-0.2357725352,
-0.5027761459,
-0.269456625,
0.1483972371,
-0.0408225507,
-0.4926093519,
1.1635735035,
-1.059194684,
-0.3127489984,
0.0061867661,
0.4427691996,
0.3128932714,
0.3004163802,
0.6312000155,
-0.6581838131,
-0.3450796604,
0.3403343856,
-0.8418184519,
-0.2256034315,
-0.390466243,
0.2020738423,
0.5114277601,
0.8012184501,
-0.262930572,
0.4877994955,
0.4114665389,
-0.7285704613,
0.54174155,
-0.145524621,
0.1911670417,
-0.7536842823,
0.0324085541,
-0.3721362054,
-0.3509063423,
-0.3763438165,
-0.0198196284,
-0.1908582598,
-0.0558982231,
-0.3861472011,
0.0103795659,
-0.357401818,
-0.5341491699,
-0.0157145094,
0.1374842227,
-0.1631380022,
0.4261294305,
-0.4592386186,
0.2704102397,
0.3659737408,
-0.7758219838,
0.667609334,
0.0036927047,
-0.2911435068,
0.4623217583,
-0.5320025086,
-0.1598094702,
-0.124330841,
0.1574842632,
-0.9654200077,
-0.2352699041,
0.0212899856,
-0.6735325456,
0.2140355259,
-0.1407664269,
-0.3830885589,
-0.2796228826,
-0.5080584884,
0.1473654658,
0.5109974146,
-0.3878025413,
0.7094039321,
0.1910236627,
-0.3039134741,
-0.164348349,
-0.532674849,
-0.0315328948,
-0.715710938,
-0.7186978459,
0.2035667747,
-0.0163362063,
-0.5187352896,
0.5057918429,
-0.6251876354,
-0.2877224982,
0.4750179648,
0.2043262422,
0.2161653489,
-0.3329769969,
0.1249326617,
-0.0467544235,
-0.4341985285,
0.0603047274,
-0.3286420107,
0.3623979688,
-0.1092010215,
-0.3440878391,
-0.2992174327,
0.2715150118,
0.8241859078,
-0.0863827094,
0.6641988158,
0.4733134806,
-0.372005105,
-0.2306502312,
-0.5023898482,
0.0308549404,
-0.4210934639,
0.3942503333,
0.2483288646,
-0.7033960819,
0.8656093478,
-0.3232592344,
0.5755465031,
0.865806818,
0.0324007794,
-0.3116143942,
1.0242470503,
0.7893505096,
-0.1083418354,
0.3071317673,
-0.1002224982,
0.2103384137,
-0.4737118781,
-0.3045373261,
-0.5399175882,
-0.12397255,
-0.4781715274,
-0.2151529193,
0.7762157917,
0.3045332134,
0.1456231475,
0.1194453165,
-0.3551075459,
0.3345242143,
-0.1709420532,
-0.1039797291,
0.5134676099,
-0.0764664412,
0.2227384001,
-0.0035378933,
-0.6840034723,
-0.1935734749,
0.4049518108,
0.3061376512,
0.5901890397,
0.2256895751,
0.6337665915,
0.5566766262,
0.1063482612,
-0.3949040174,
0.29370296,
0.0537299886,
-0.3082511425,
-0.6533284783,
-0.4648357034,
-0.9218126535,
-0.0468802303,
0.2041612417,
-0.7827942371,
0.0459601581,
0.5294151902,
-0.3267640471,
0.4036714435,
-0.7531026006,
1.0737843513,
-0.2045836449,
0.2162195742,
-0.7208274007,
-0.6248232126,
0.1201724336,
-0.292827189,
0.432689786,
0.0422933735,
-0.1473720223,
0.7510023713,
-0.7970865369,
1.1500705481,
-0.31960392,
-0.0426997803,
0.3627362251,
0.1282012165,
0.6729798317,
0.008846458,
0.2144200653,
-0.0067563392,
0.3543302119,
-0.551422894,
-0.8643667102,
0.6240129471,
-0.3359428644,
-0.2971555591,
-0.5764488578,
-0.0785154998,
-0.2252102494,
-0.044505503,
-0.0827099457,
0.6997858882,
-0.0406743847,
0.0646094978,
0.5393745303,
-0.5193317533,
0.8930965662,
0.6261543036,
-0.4015306234,
0.0151330754,
1.1853371859,
0.2046646327,
0.1919121891,
0.2758978307,
0.1998563558,
0.0507292524,
-0.4590460062,
-0.3810625076,
0.1274168938,
-0.7411814332,
-0.2149218917,
-0.7190975547,
-0.0200955942,
0.165522635,
-0.3223517835,
-0.3042610586,
-0.7483379841,
-0.1104645431,
-0.1766735017,
0.7387139201,
1.0403512716,
0.1149613485,
0.3068452477,
-1.2540373802,
-0.1003593057,
0.3230535686,
0.7057039142,
0.1519806832,
0.0001548874,
-0.4380878806,
-0.3381989598,
-0.157178238,
-0.7926166654,
0.3278281391,
0.1607459784,
0.7113573551,
0.0986811146,
0.1251896918,
0.6733037233,
-0.3280771077,
1.2921528816,
0.0859348476,
-0.7605667114,
0.7648715973,
-0.366792053,
0.3681913614,
0.1372899711,
0.1169309691,
-0.8805338144,
-0.7555000186,
-0.9148496985,
-1.1802151203,
0.5179848075,
-0.039313484,
-0.3319088817,
0.3050279915,
0.2174527049,
0.1106422395,
-0.0083639687,
-0.2598528862,
-0.1958116442,
-0.0816690326,
-0.0937383771,
-0.015119113,
-0.2181014568,
-0.0034127978,
-0.0288838651,
0.6693037748,
-0.1799793094,
0.2897687852,
0.0672181249,
-0.3659991622,
-0.0358666889,
0.1633752286,
0.716588974,
1.231223464,
-0.291577369,
-0.074568592,
0.7745198607,
-0.4288828969,
-0.1208165959,
-0.3875268996,
0.1458894908,
0.4854305685,
0.5162104368,
0.5353240371,
0.268987596,
-0.7415744066,
0.248783052,
0.0820342228,
0.2784315348,
-0.6497934461,
0.1518936306,
0.0614446402,
0.2265859246,
0.5753871799,
-0.217072174,
0.2789014876,
-0.3434327245,
0.1417020261,
-0.1356825233,
-0.4798289835,
-0.2565446794,
0.3666804433,
0.1565409601,
-0.2503909767,
0.4751260281,
-0.1980265081,
-0.4113575816,
1.0024032593,
0.2820577025,
0.9059103727,
-0.224616766,
0.1618510187,
0.1931804866,
0.1869102716,
0.2485707253,
0.077171661,
0.1640014201,
0.060285151,
-0.6470258236,
-0.5875154734,
-0.2989397943,
-0.1632216424,
-0.519372642,
0.321505487,
-0.2084284574,
0.1816720665,
-0.1739740521,
-0.3440456986,
-0.0711761788,
0.3095051944,
-0.4588747919,
0.7461328506,
-0.9601371288,
0.1370478719,
0.469822526,
-0.0910106003,
-0.2290330529,
-0.0051860032,
0.1756575257,
-0.3738025427,
0.440151006,
0.0039919601,
0.0712266862,
-0.0651882663,
-0.1307886243,
-0.6956563592,
1.1832475662,
-0.2833018899,
-0.3592348397,
-0.0315899104,
-0.1520401239,
0.7445389032,
-0.1377691776,
0.014095312,
0.4080688059,
0.3194734454,
-0.3435868919,
-0.8992419243,
-0.3026377261,
-0.2487699091,
0.1360417306,
0.7395352125,
-0.7087099552,
0.3037904799,
0.0562615655,
-0.4229565859,
-0.3757373095,
0.5736322403,
-0.2487413436,
0.5193933845,
0.7239964604,
0.6412082911,
0.7247372866,
-0.2033944577,
1.0135253668,
-0.3777399063,
0.4362935126,
0.8270785809,
0.1135358289,
0.6434043646,
0.086356394,
-0.4629587233,
0.8575335145,
0.8179285526,
-0.0092105353,
0.3756834865,
0.2406606525,
-0.4282586575,
0.0192132629,
0.0068056234,
-0.5341996551,
-0.0971726403,
0.4766498208,
0.0701370314,
-0.3834337294,
-0.3173536956,
-0.0133432206,
-0.2684786618,
-0.3723496795,
1.0939912796,
-0.0579461344,
-0.4694704115,
0.2584612668,
-0.0730151087,
0.4241124392,
-0.6233741641,
-0.0329262316,
-0.491063565,
0.3003068268,
-0.7017692327,
-0.4350963831,
1.064936161,
0.0169757586,
-0.0586159639,
0.1689055264,
0.4130973816,
0.0709966645,
-0.3995499015,
0.2214306444,
0.1716778427,
0.2257573903,
0.3987670243,
-0.1148174554,
0.1646772921,
-0.01362193,
0.0543939136,
0.2364171445,
0.3772613406,
-0.4622105062,
0.682493031,
0.2881436348,
-0.143805027,
0.4612143934,
-0.1567808688,
0.9323874712,
-0.8319767118,
-0.7764856815,
-0.8724345565,
1.0840265751,
-0.4062646031,
-0.2475391924,
0.6771615744,
0.8041683435,
0.7641450763,
-0.1990596652,
0.7952927947,
-0.0382738784,
0.6862949133,
-0.5652744174,
0.4567278326,
-0.4898951352,
0.3500228524,
-0.3315294385,
-1.0451178551,
-0.4518176019,
0.3393443823,
0.2717238963,
-0.3878927827,
0.9196282625,
0.7773734331,
0.0794768259,
0.1073563397,
0.0472253524,
0.4707995355,
0.422222048,
0.3305806816,
0.8990401626,
-0.1868610829,
0.6277390122,
-0.0324326567,
-0.437261939,
-0.4239152074,
-1.2047239542,
-0.5699868798,
-0.5557540655,
-0.7001083493,
-0.3925913572,
0.0876834318,
0.5364999771,
0.3017186224,
-1.0097529888,
-0.2448402941,
-0.1695532352,
-0.0379075482,
-0.5846937895,
-0.2262234241,
0.3000039756,
-0.7939284444,
-0.2015360892,
0.3614268899,
0.5944213867,
-0.0417723693,
-0.4340600967,
0.0407107882,
0.2955573499,
-0.3593240082,
0.7123386264,
0.4038290679,
-0.3725949824,
-0.3315980136,
0.0500786528,
0.2737190425,
-0.035405837,
0.9034081101,
-0.4671333432,
0.3999666274,
0.6484220624,
0.6498047113,
0.8688882589,
-0.2984324396,
0.5117123723,
-0.7601079941,
0.025278667,
0.0637345761,
0.1906028241,
0.1839939952,
-0.5340988636,
0.8237344027,
0.6137726307,
-0.4847370386,
-0.9710845351,
0.1136066467,
-0.8716022372,
-0.381932646,
0.8394104838,
-0.2107253522,
-0.0987996757,
-0.4603725076,
-0.0496921875,
0.1747903973,
0.0263720118,
1.1173434258,
0.5742314458,
-0.5497533679,
0.1941914111,
-0.3618826568,
0.4704284668,
0.247383371,
-1.323045969,
0.007398841,
0.6652264595,
0.3933130205,
0.5221687555,
0.3060287833,
-0.4267897904,
0.3417053819,
0.141791895,
-0.3071595132,
0.2151450664,
-0.2981953025,
-0.5446409583,
0.0679830834,
0.2472834587,
-0.1815143377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08345v1
|
From human experts to machines: An LLM supported approach to ontology and knowledge graph construction
| 2024-03-13T08:50:15 | 2024-03-13T08:50:15 |
Vamsi Krishna Kommineni, Birgitta König-Ries, Sheeba Samuel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The conventional process of building Ontologies and Knowledge Graphs (KGs)
heavily relies on human domain experts to define entities and relationship
types, establish hierarchies, maintain relevance to the domain, fill the ABox
(or populate with instances), and ensure data quality (including amongst others
accuracy and completeness). On the other hand, Large Language Models (LLMs)
have recently gained popularity for their ability to understand and generate
human-like natural language, offering promising ways to automate aspects of
this process. This work explores the (semi-)automatic construction of KGs
facilitated by open-source LLMs. Our pipeline involves formulating competency
questions (CQs), developing an ontology (TBox) based on these CQs, constructing
KGs using the developed ontology, and evaluating the resultant KG with minimal
to no involvement of human experts. We showcase the feasibility of our
semi-automated pipeline by creating a KG on deep learning methodologies by
exploiting scholarly publications. To evaluate the answers generated via
Retrieval-Augmented-Generation (RAG) as well as the KG concepts automatically
extracted using LLMs, we design a judge LLM, which rates the generated content
based on ground truth. Our findings suggest that employing LLMs could
potentially reduce the human effort involved in the construction of KGs,
although a human-in-the-loop approach is recommended to evaluate automatically
generated KGs.
|
[
-0.5632551312,
-0.4909086525,
0.7750368118,
-0.5580686331,
0.2177356184,
0.3355711997,
-0.0815040767,
-0.4217107892,
0.0181975141,
0.9815284014,
-0.3470868468,
-0.7091093063,
-0.446077913,
0.2421365231,
-0.1293781102,
0.6497300863,
-0.1217662022,
-0.1595811248,
-0.4120351374,
0.0831099078,
-0.128056854,
-0.3524604738,
-0.3668276072,
-0.5783675909,
0.4177577198,
0.5375877619,
0.8929526806,
0.8020732403,
0.1663869768,
0.3647862077,
0.1062160954,
0.587071538,
-0.4383198917,
0.0503588244,
-0.3906564713,
-0.4144885242,
-0.6415049434,
0.1851138175,
0.4012479484,
0.8845917583,
0.0190721303,
0.2323521376,
0.0783832744,
0.8057787418,
-0.3349304199,
0.348958075,
-0.7524155378,
0.2936345041,
-0.1597612053,
-0.2061057389,
-0.215749532,
-0.1720739901,
0.0615736879,
-0.8246012926,
0.0399513245,
0.3723495007,
0.6329979897,
0.3351760507,
-0.4508824944,
-0.6319944859,
-0.4181801379,
0.7181804776,
-0.7312716246,
0.5120779276,
0.3894539177,
0.4228236377,
-0.4135355949,
-0.8626764417,
-0.6355828047,
-0.2952819169,
-0.2096079737,
0.1350299269,
0.1259872317,
0.1042766273,
0.0585170723,
0.0697411746,
-0.449496001,
0.3458642662,
-0.214612931,
-0.3580121398,
0.7526255846,
0.4370506406,
0.2183711678,
-0.5056408048,
-0.1221946701,
0.2885580063,
-0.8492131233,
-0.4321554005,
0.4448031485,
0.4098502398,
0.3955947161,
0.9337949753,
-0.3605329692,
0.7687498331,
-0.1736601442,
-0.3945426941,
-0.1094733626,
-0.1798715889,
-0.1749404669,
-0.0056382143,
0.9222843647,
0.1231084839,
0.5279278755,
-0.6833568811,
-0.1917268336,
-0.0430929959,
0.4859275222,
-0.3385263383,
-0.3984012902,
0.2012179196,
-0.2331644893,
-0.4680383503,
-0.1299595833,
-0.344609499,
-0.5081782937,
-0.5948435664,
0.3233509958,
-0.3676787615,
-0.0083354963,
-0.1294190437,
0.0759506077,
-0.0978592411,
0.4103490114,
-0.4496531487,
0.1454320103,
0.4102676809,
0.37718606,
0.0651474744,
-0.1346215308,
-0.1907192171,
0.6540489793,
-0.4532485604,
0.7492512465,
-0.2115418911,
-0.3582523465,
-0.0676344484,
-0.2367179245,
0.3963906467,
-0.5215681791,
0.4827225804,
-1.0798910856,
0.2201026082,
-0.1656489968,
-0.9173470736,
-0.0603211187,
0.6704750061,
-0.416010797,
0.9228903055,
0.3300447762,
-0.8423207402,
0.3723111749,
-0.7780528069,
-0.3222818077,
0.3252559304,
-0.3587871194,
-0.1168796048,
-0.4444394708,
0.1023082435,
0.7159217,
-0.5754489899,
0.0876075551,
-0.3020955026,
0.2658148706,
0.1926011145,
0.2013427466,
0.7405508161,
0.3534777164,
-0.0826557949,
-0.1763825566,
-0.7187718749,
0.3632126153,
-0.0493805967,
-0.5029186606,
-0.0676681623,
0.1637804359,
-0.5424436331,
0.2384075224,
0.186709404,
-0.3720810115,
0.3744512498,
-0.3792504072,
0.4349628687,
0.7659007311,
-0.1906248182,
0.3880306482,
-0.1211509854,
0.4044381976,
-0.2860338986,
-0.0877053514,
0.1601136625,
-0.6087963581,
-0.686611712,
-0.1164419055,
0.4787826836,
0.634116888,
-1.0136058331,
0.6618282795,
-0.3380956352,
-0.618539989,
-0.5287342668,
0.6837902665,
0.4332300127,
0.9531667233,
0.2620798051,
-0.3637723923,
-0.5350885391,
-0.5745167732,
0.0206887778,
-0.48655954,
-0.2648207247,
0.541701436,
0.330204308,
-0.3369214535,
1.5225485563,
-0.7981379628,
-0.5824338198,
-0.0459670015,
0.0137550216,
-0.0626920387,
0.1087005287,
0.1678657383,
-0.6941233277,
-0.5351732969,
0.3211501241,
-1.1561120749,
-0.2684452832,
0.4839273691,
-0.1991200596,
0.3395707905,
0.5127516985,
-0.5889846087,
0.2242162675,
0.0983586535,
-0.262886703,
0.5909808278,
-0.1630698889,
-0.02730898,
-1.1599740982,
0.2699193954,
-0.1908130944,
-0.4322556555,
-0.4538729191,
0.074677825,
-0.1898561269,
0.0148355626,
-0.3311446011,
0.6620745659,
-0.3246999681,
-0.2712296844,
-0.1623543501,
0.6067870855,
-0.0216611996,
0.3842572272,
-0.0702110082,
0.3706694245,
0.219555065,
-0.7081233263,
0.5355727077,
0.564858675,
-0.3256755769,
0.4241831005,
-0.5375817418,
0.2704862058,
0.1446221024,
0.0602230653,
-0.8168486953,
-0.4635584354,
0.4527329803,
-0.6988294721,
0.235531345,
-0.4109928906,
-0.9854680896,
-0.57686764,
0.1192401052,
-0.1721434146,
0.7229632735,
-0.3041510582,
0.5720126629,
0.850710094,
-0.0996204093,
-0.4362303019,
-0.6723510623,
0.4037009478,
0.219285503,
-1.1342440844,
0.3176291585,
0.1402940005,
-0.4103536606,
0.3457299471,
0.1613168418,
-0.0743862987,
0.1337858886,
0.1121068075,
0.1068220586,
-0.0254726447,
0.3413224816,
-0.0773596466,
-0.2020728886,
0.1346360743,
-0.7876048684,
0.2415558696,
0.2243163735,
-0.4064442813,
-0.2295290977,
-0.0993065089,
0.3907483518,
-0.0957482308,
0.515103519,
0.3572523296,
-0.1731446236,
-0.3727924824,
-0.5594971776,
-0.1401708722,
-0.475537926,
0.1360211372,
-0.2276504487,
-1.0423090458,
0.3803550005,
-0.2658146918,
0.1378475726,
0.5229663253,
0.7322140336,
-0.2623117566,
0.9580314755,
0.4619238675,
0.152024731,
-0.1967919618,
-0.3051540256,
0.1082071587,
-0.5841844678,
-0.3469263613,
-0.488697648,
-0.0753233358,
-0.5091469884,
-0.5692723393,
0.6032334566,
0.0471011102,
-0.2572920024,
0.1190054938,
-0.4850946069,
0.1709997803,
0.4400823116,
0.035513293,
0.5618525147,
-0.0362475477,
-0.3323949277,
0.1883814484,
-0.9998812079,
-0.9224101901,
1.2634340525,
0.1829843372,
0.6619330049,
-0.0545281135,
0.5911056995,
0.6395949721,
0.5325088501,
-0.7930796742,
0.822763443,
-0.1023565158,
-0.7087711692,
-0.5256508589,
-0.5951801538,
-0.8559165001,
-0.1234747395,
-0.4334588051,
-0.330195576,
-0.423738122,
0.2612128258,
-0.1825653166,
0.4971212149,
-0.4242141247,
0.5974130034,
-0.1140127555,
-0.3971488476,
-0.0308768842,
-0.9355324507,
0.2519293427,
-0.3088228703,
0.3247210979,
0.0031756086,
-0.2149628401,
0.7697979808,
-0.7728854418,
1.085963726,
-0.2296384126,
-0.3199578226,
0.7646489143,
0.0078613162,
0.6096761227,
0.0166184623,
-0.3712674677,
0.0002809782,
-0.4672015607,
-0.3853023052,
-0.610746026,
0.396666497,
-1.0674935579,
-0.5874191523,
0.1756415367,
-0.5967986584,
-0.381398946,
0.4824834168,
-0.1070846394,
0.1902911067,
-0.1107528657,
-0.2365993112,
0.6859143376,
-0.0871107131,
-0.0951351598,
0.6768342853,
-0.27394104,
-0.5304098129,
0.7804738283,
0.5514511466,
0.1761141121,
0.360181123,
0.2646802366,
-0.28343454,
-0.589074254,
-0.6502809525,
0.0384491198,
-0.8026810884,
-0.3023132086,
-0.818049252,
-0.286028862,
-0.7090688944,
-0.1910742819,
-0.2119162977,
-0.442594558,
-0.2107047141,
0.0188468229,
0.4557469785,
1.1440098286,
0.0380145498,
0.0327141248,
-1.1809612513,
0.1987278014,
0.6626630425,
0.2503350377,
0.1134525016,
-0.4220954776,
-0.4913673401,
0.0126778688,
-0.3678208292,
-0.5189238787,
0.3039222062,
-0.1451466978,
0.7227030396,
0.3597251177,
0.3298132718,
0.2856063843,
-0.56571877,
0.6553806663,
0.0489217266,
-0.7796128988,
0.3757029474,
-0.4780531824,
-0.2030499578,
0.4114150703,
0.4972355664,
-0.1617774814,
-0.4620975256,
-0.523769021,
-0.683036983,
0.6471389532,
0.273272872,
-0.1128016934,
0.1034389287,
0.6078236699,
0.2292455584,
0.2139355242,
-0.3731990457,
-0.0266582854,
-0.037624646,
-0.2248279899,
0.2008828968,
-0.0401772745,
-0.3334682584,
0.1001906469,
0.6816099882,
-0.3753740191,
-0.1671853513,
0.1620557457,
-0.2457748502,
-0.0774977729,
0.187150538,
-0.1618690938,
0.6256453395,
-0.0584214479,
0.2016119808,
0.2724824548,
-0.0507945977,
0.1398125142,
-0.0295169838,
-0.285551697,
-0.4837816954,
0.382126987,
0.4417905509,
-0.1483762413,
-0.7737717032,
0.1748230457,
0.4145503044,
-0.4159530103,
-0.3556566834,
0.1725434512,
0.3757903874,
0.3269283473,
0.2797698975,
-0.2226072997,
-0.2395316213,
-0.4033199549,
0.2301694602,
0.3757477403,
-0.3923696578,
-0.2168985605,
0.6237546206,
0.40117383,
-0.269665122,
0.7841937542,
-0.5091018081,
-0.6727150083,
0.3553607464,
0.1036468148,
0.4441350996,
0.0045174318,
0.1192535758,
0.0518586338,
0.2083687931,
0.0634366646,
0.1527399868,
-0.0395166092,
-0.987349391,
-0.696803689,
-0.6135242581,
-0.6056537628,
-0.460327059,
-0.2065528035,
0.3557367623,
-0.2169922888,
-0.1450488567,
-0.0193694886,
0.3197827637,
-0.5368044376,
0.4650833309,
0.1867588609,
0.9004514813,
-0.6941743493,
0.8114441037,
1.0870848894,
-0.4210612774,
-0.8835765123,
-0.2152294964,
-0.1532476395,
-0.9226936102,
0.9839357138,
-0.1834314615,
-0.1232304871,
0.2602052093,
-0.5397585034,
-0.6338438392,
1.4435092211,
0.3258993328,
-0.1576338261,
-0.2333780527,
0.4663291574,
0.6506800056,
-0.2403964847,
0.0280082226,
0.2044281811,
0.7042868733,
0.2616260946,
-0.7747053504,
0.1286419779,
0.0415438749,
-0.3368263841,
0.2438719571,
-0.5725331306,
0.6575363874,
-0.2916315794,
-0.0974145606,
0.0148996124,
0.6851231456,
0.2952134609,
0.233794868,
0.5592994094,
0.9172205925,
0.9149156213,
0.3464391828,
0.968444705,
-0.6291696429,
0.1691812873,
0.7295960784,
-0.4656980336,
0.4405133724,
0.2801524997,
-0.5315734744,
0.4481856227,
0.4636665285,
-0.0740695298,
0.1941480637,
0.3823663294,
-0.0576195419,
-0.5521798134,
-0.2614025772,
-0.1551727951,
0.461060673,
0.4096060395,
-0.369395107,
-0.2315095216,
-0.2370962799,
0.0737492666,
0.1372203082,
-0.4352762997,
0.8216785789,
0.1766717732,
-0.7011408806,
0.2436139733,
0.0122074978,
0.2987686098,
-0.5941528678,
0.1440425813,
0.1441957802,
-0.0634388477,
-0.4184276164,
-1.1755383015,
0.337303251,
0.1205553934,
-0.2878603041,
-0.3032346964,
1.0046139956,
-0.2300274372,
-0.4909375608,
0.3273027539,
0.8911948204,
0.2201334089,
0.1518691927,
-0.4752213657,
-0.532517612,
-0.1479826868,
-0.4268910289,
0.4067575634,
0.7113019824,
-0.0760287568,
0.8241303563,
0.6405453086,
-0.0790465027,
-0.111252293,
-0.1066111922,
1.1414390802,
-0.4307684004,
-0.2667780519,
-0.6530661583,
0.4983611107,
-0.0477697812,
0.0601758435,
0.816776216,
0.4661932886,
0.7990736365,
0.1922426373,
1.2098425627,
-0.3907674849,
0.6864094138,
-0.6267107725,
1.1082055569,
-0.7033489347,
0.3141640723,
-0.2773720324,
-0.5035811067,
-0.3656983376,
0.0755291432,
-0.2370483428,
-0.0428832062,
0.1764809489,
0.9041407108,
0.0825694874,
-0.2513093352,
0.3397781551,
0.1841307729,
0.3020917177,
0.2643864453,
0.7443420291,
0.0216144156,
0.9439584017,
0.0260910224,
-0.2234830856,
-0.0579636469,
-0.9961339831,
-0.9751807451,
-0.2883161008,
-0.1949554384,
-0.4708665013,
-0.0773352459,
0.89068681,
0.630123198,
-0.5519814491,
-0.2558022141,
-0.138323769,
0.3170567751,
0.3749510348,
-0.176421538,
0.4889597893,
-0.509980619,
-0.4593547583,
0.298288554,
0.2193583697,
-0.2344163805,
-0.6485227942,
-0.4274408221,
-0.0134791629,
-0.0795377567,
0.7201858759,
0.1528463662,
-0.5621013641,
-0.2139151543,
0.1588085741,
-0.19642663,
0.0062802681,
0.6223941445,
-1.0707843304,
0.5680068731,
0.6260386109,
0.7415204644,
0.2015823275,
-0.1896730065,
0.6172146201,
-0.6582710743,
-0.342535913,
0.2642126381,
0.1606201977,
0.4172935784,
-0.1489325464,
0.8782394528,
0.4958261847,
-0.7159898281,
-0.7392692566,
0.3035266995,
-0.62022084,
-0.253064543,
1.0486898422,
-0.2095120698,
-0.167170018,
-0.5648465157,
-0.1464093924,
0.494784236,
-0.0196467973,
0.9278817177,
0.4949806035,
-0.3379183114,
0.3684632182,
-0.4780869782,
0.2231862247,
0.047232978,
-0.8655478954,
-0.057411015,
0.3183970451,
0.3374048769,
0.4013055563,
0.7067649961,
-0.0830139965,
-0.1873656213,
-0.113356337,
0.4586647749,
-0.4324400425,
-0.0187044311,
0.5940590501,
0.4661687315,
0.2771464586,
0.390612781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08332v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08332v1
|
Autoregressive Score Generation for Multi-trait Essay Scoring
| 2024-03-13T08:34:53 | 2024-03-13T08:34:53 |
Heejin Do, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, encoder-only pre-trained models such as BERT have been successfully
applied in automated essay scoring (AES) to predict a single overall score.
However, studies have yet to explore these models in multi-trait AES, possibly
due to the inefficiency of replicating BERT-based models for each trait.
Breaking away from the existing sole use of encoder, we propose an
autoregressive prediction of multi-trait scores (ArTS), incorporating a
decoding process by leveraging the pre-trained T5. Unlike prior regression or
classification methods, we redefine AES as a score-generation task, allowing a
single model to predict multiple scores. During decoding, the subsequent trait
prediction can benefit by conditioning on the preceding trait scores.
Experimental results proved the efficacy of ArTS, showing over 5% average
improvements in both prompts and traits.
|
[
-0.3985398114,
-0.623811543,
0.4832656682,
0.3873291016,
0.0450716801,
0.1085492596,
0.0146526229,
-0.6598275304,
0.5785343647,
0.3743252158,
-0.6557358503,
-0.5052922368,
-0.7557393909,
0.2687820792,
-0.3628039956,
1.0244972706,
-0.0701774955,
0.0515070781,
-0.2558546066,
-0.1175920516,
-0.265932858,
-0.5616190434,
-0.7840659618,
-0.1070997864,
0.6984186172,
0.436119169,
0.1405692846,
0.360640794,
0.6290355325,
0.2902188599,
0.6569507718,
0.2091753632,
-0.2259369344,
0.5439649224,
0.456913203,
-0.3443217278,
-0.5599056482,
0.3519414961,
0.5732771158,
0.3735704422,
0.1419069469,
0.2944055498,
0.2271950394,
0.4839517176,
-0.6802651882,
0.2063155174,
-0.339260906,
0.2523055971,
0.0804021806,
-0.1333143413,
-0.6749218702,
-0.9124869108,
-0.1056364775,
-0.4369984269,
0.3449538052,
-0.0261714272,
0.5658126473,
0.2143173218,
-0.4683614075,
0.0538819954,
-0.5621755123,
1.0603474379,
-0.4332726896,
-0.0157466326,
0.5216633081,
0.2641355991,
0.1626121998,
-0.5225598216,
-0.3489693701,
-0.0626441389,
-0.1106282622,
0.3381489813,
0.1694440842,
0.3046135306,
0.1576218456,
0.477730751,
-0.4120155275,
-0.101984933,
-0.373365283,
-0.2984394431,
0.9336072803,
0.2656235397,
0.0017621275,
-0.0641227216,
-0.1285983473,
-0.275715977,
-0.3424531221,
0.5006082058,
0.4194526374,
0.097276561,
0.2529300451,
0.2830532193,
0.2226025164,
0.5034821033,
0.4579757154,
-0.0372526012,
0.3280569017,
0.0329684205,
0.0554246716,
-0.1505030692,
0.9697930217,
0.3398833275,
0.1158703342,
0.019349141,
-0.2675041258,
0.2738294601,
0.3463270068,
-0.727227509,
-0.5105707049,
0.0453607067,
-0.7876788378,
-0.5590199828,
-0.0610656552,
-1.0324116945,
-0.1053873077,
-0.1613564491,
0.5894318223,
-0.6766901016,
-0.0310071614,
-0.1064133197,
-0.2319769263,
0.4047070742,
0.2989725471,
-0.7933166623,
0.1441290826,
-0.0332745649,
0.6114873886,
-0.1810534745,
-0.6633215547,
-0.5634133816,
-0.1337122917,
-0.5001110435,
0.9853401184,
-0.8448768258,
-0.5276899338,
-0.030650869,
-0.0771598518,
-0.3395735323,
0.1498948634,
0.7930980921,
-0.2074666619,
0.2514344752,
-0.4749042988,
-0.7750402093,
-0.2832971513,
0.2228569239,
-1.0330181122,
1.0074423552,
0.0303062312,
-0.4206819236,
0.5875453353,
-0.8512725234,
-0.6206169128,
-0.3129685819,
-0.0731384978,
-0.7786158919,
0.3780441284,
0.5802128315,
0.5528225303,
0.0869091079,
-0.0555960722,
-0.7489441037,
-0.3246890903,
0.165517047,
-0.5258927941,
0.2839675844,
0.0746210963,
-0.2720708847,
-0.1879807115,
-0.7145303488,
0.4757010043,
-0.2043858767,
-0.4880300462,
0.0601602159,
-0.0211331267,
-0.0425369479,
0.3117299974,
0.1692838669,
-0.8260868192,
0.2163728476,
0.0328736268,
0.044235874,
0.9038532972,
0.0221831501,
0.2284450233,
-0.8307740092,
0.7200641036,
-0.2324461341,
0.2438952476,
-0.4638396204,
-0.5036779642,
-0.7887849212,
-0.4936723411,
0.0301682521,
0.2611694634,
-0.4593864083,
0.6029570699,
0.1694919169,
-0.5778120756,
-1.1113250256,
-0.1697234362,
0.4474305212,
0.1812764257,
0.7607703805,
-0.2090464234,
-0.467033416,
-0.683681488,
-0.5680377483,
-0.1372502297,
0.2976197004,
0.0424493961,
0.4040965736,
0.1416568011,
0.7374091148,
-0.7436554432,
-0.5031379461,
-0.3217148483,
0.8964451551,
-0.1447409391,
0.7319238186,
0.9024746418,
-0.4129622281,
-0.7325763106,
-0.6414296627,
-0.5445885062,
-0.1317412108,
-0.0067323502,
-0.0796402469,
0.3232640028,
0.351675123,
-0.2953723073,
0.702111125,
0.6722207665,
-0.3861055374,
0.8257302046,
-0.0886119157,
0.8438820839,
-0.9892813563,
-0.1064813137,
0.054962799,
-0.0937726572,
-0.3681395948,
-0.1457016021,
-0.1664651632,
-0.0646250099,
0.2898757756,
0.3147485852,
-0.3481641412,
0.1129030138,
-0.2349999845,
-0.9027073383,
0.6172780991,
0.606490016,
0.181227982,
0.5821077228,
0.6029753089,
-0.3948248327,
0.237312898,
0.161626935,
-0.3247017264,
0.4550184011,
-0.6036396623,
0.3264200687,
-0.4447260797,
0.240034461,
-1.2176386118,
-0.1181915626,
-0.4092067182,
-0.6873867512,
0.5317937136,
0.1213304326,
-0.0094551323,
-0.5130609274,
-0.5990271568,
0.3462183475,
0.5231648684,
-0.4849518836,
1.1098980904,
0.1050839499,
-0.2787443697,
-0.4718392193,
-0.8108644485,
-0.2630755901,
-0.2201508135,
-0.4871381819,
0.266222775,
-0.4950165451,
0.2168315202,
0.1236037165,
0.2627551854,
-0.121275574,
-0.0126331532,
0.1358386725,
0.2070397735,
-0.1951126903,
0.3443152606,
0.2077786624,
0.0980096981,
0.2370695919,
-0.3301297426,
0.0433291718,
0.0023830179,
-0.5734038353,
-0.3061294854,
1.2134175301,
0.9575669169,
-0.5331191421,
0.8345891237,
0.6907530427,
-0.2025025338,
-0.4108837247,
-0.9187800884,
-0.3287642002,
-0.4326882064,
0.1824775487,
-0.600313127,
-0.549478054,
0.5023262501,
0.1124502197,
0.3225073516,
0.5286925435,
0.127953425,
-0.5452408195,
1.3878092766,
0.7967247367,
-0.2062404603,
0.5382916927,
-0.3294482231,
0.1367403716,
-0.5118083358,
-0.1774553657,
-0.6214933395,
-0.5264394879,
-0.43925035,
-0.0474731699,
0.7379527688,
-0.2438042015,
-0.2079435587,
-0.1643098593,
-0.5335934758,
0.5098866224,
0.745859921,
0.2270859331,
-0.0250328369,
-0.0624478348,
-0.3520397842,
-0.1925596595,
-0.4089511633,
-0.1784971207,
1.5861576796,
0.0946657211,
0.8610501289,
0.050479956,
1.0500847101,
0.607722044,
0.5325706601,
-0.601700902,
0.1704356223,
-0.638153553,
-0.4401969016,
-0.4732572436,
-0.093850702,
-0.5561178923,
0.0073029972,
-0.4590848386,
-0.4987935424,
0.2943284214,
0.3846177161,
-0.6712918878,
0.1543233842,
-0.6965671778,
0.9012066722,
-0.3760999441,
-0.4613978267,
-0.1725239605,
-0.3979538381,
0.3522769511,
-0.2271536887,
0.0077659283,
0.0637022853,
0.6013032794,
0.8233780265,
-0.194677949,
0.9572353959,
-0.2840752304,
0.2281209081,
0.3267851174,
-0.0409653075,
0.5631418228,
-0.2717912197,
-0.6363378167,
-0.238271594,
-0.0756976306,
-0.3269803226,
-0.5797712207,
0.6604087353,
-1.0351029634,
-0.3419911861,
-0.4232167602,
-0.1051296368,
-0.2929961085,
-0.1681667715,
0.5957857966,
0.5926756263,
-0.4461416006,
-0.0583415814,
0.7935827971,
-0.0537623279,
0.8047689199,
0.5371295214,
0.1925019026,
-0.6100652218,
0.778768003,
0.0054094703,
0.0835782364,
0.3896133602,
0.187286526,
-0.4755522311,
-0.1908571124,
-0.116372481,
-0.1315274537,
-0.8184250593,
-0.3561024964,
-0.7423666716,
-0.1708457619,
-0.7293587327,
-0.5405036807,
-0.2987961769,
-0.2365393788,
-0.3691239655,
-0.3579282761,
0.4150725901,
0.9788310528,
-0.3524197936,
0.0096748676,
-0.9337890744,
0.2672462761,
0.4037717283,
0.5160424113,
-0.0498306677,
-0.5733805895,
-0.2422357202,
-0.2188172191,
-0.5265017152,
-0.8832694292,
0.5369594097,
0.7190210819,
0.6335138083,
0.6225935221,
0.2214495987,
0.6745024323,
-0.4099233449,
0.6937311888,
0.3016664386,
-0.9078695774,
0.6123937368,
0.0425853282,
0.4247945547,
0.8199783564,
0.5372196436,
-0.1778557152,
-0.7391651869,
-0.4126477838,
-0.5133671761,
0.6401888728,
-0.2753556669,
0.1073185503,
-0.0271349791,
0.1432663649,
0.6441653371,
0.0860211924,
-0.9642837644,
-0.0407907479,
-0.8167473674,
-0.6677418947,
-0.3900551498,
-0.4007918537,
0.2331453115,
-0.6200072169,
0.7965943217,
-0.2215743512,
0.6115589142,
0.1775738746,
0.0328948721,
-0.3376111686,
0.1890538335,
0.245582208,
-0.1371678263,
-0.257474333,
-0.2511204183,
-0.1375260651,
-0.5294933915,
0.2897365987,
0.292204529,
-0.0123226605,
-0.0193418302,
0.6020694971,
0.9041900039,
-0.1489787251,
-0.0497894771,
0.6665697694,
-0.1902432293,
-0.4729043543,
-0.7791813016,
-0.0426797904,
-0.4077566266,
0.1153624058,
0.4353336394,
0.3275763094,
0.2290026546,
-0.482111901,
0.3390087783,
0.252500087,
-0.2952471673,
-0.2891283333,
0.6772380471,
0.4962408245,
0.1758847088,
0.6544352174,
-0.288662672,
-0.6246134043,
0.7686852813,
0.376175344,
1.2953951359,
-0.7426361442,
0.2708365023,
0.6465969086,
0.2845959067,
-0.1205195338,
0.7338954806,
-0.0139279244,
-0.7355292439,
-0.5896220207,
-1.1592601538,
-0.1253579855,
0.1701288968,
-0.736379087,
0.1436745077,
-0.0947400406,
-0.3254389167,
-0.1053715646,
-0.0152583001,
-0.8009389639,
0.5236177444,
0.1477884799,
0.6284490824,
-1.2764769793,
0.8301629424,
0.8418774009,
-0.5825715661,
-1.0310301781,
0.2306393236,
-0.1886251569,
-0.4501706958,
0.6600276828,
0.3863401413,
-0.3604641557,
0.062840417,
-0.2534230053,
-1.0038722754,
0.8817956448,
0.2174703479,
-0.1640661955,
-0.0897931978,
0.0419018753,
0.5577130914,
-0.626234591,
0.7284273505,
0.4728586078,
0.6586230993,
-0.0133619262,
-0.588147223,
-0.3028938472,
-0.5133755803,
-0.3401509523,
0.1780628264,
-0.5886985064,
1.20005548,
-0.3463744223,
0.0123087717,
-0.0074057127,
0.6873657107,
-0.3596040308,
0.1210702434,
0.3280636668,
0.6997553706,
0.631732583,
-0.0781610534,
0.8790347576,
-0.5331121683,
0.0802608579,
0.7677457333,
-0.0870015472,
0.6476641893,
0.032591667,
-0.0310402494,
0.9143570065,
0.4997995496,
-0.0764972195,
0.6905316114,
-0.0088488329,
-0.4610230029,
-0.603392601,
0.2037581503,
-0.1752808839,
1.0585708618,
0.4164516926,
-0.7000850439,
0.0852299035,
0.2682987452,
-0.3602552712,
0.2672134638,
-0.4384668171,
0.8811055422,
-0.115860045,
-1.2983622551,
0.2636729777,
-0.0550316758,
0.6458780766,
-0.7195760012,
-0.3983834088,
-0.3213298023,
0.2041383982,
-0.0403234735,
-0.6661003828,
0.2631988823,
-0.1641517878,
-0.5373506546,
-0.5087451339,
0.7617029548,
-0.7031010389,
-0.900300622,
0.3667536974,
0.4602375329,
-0.0360905416,
0.1458668858,
-0.3829179704,
-0.2260624915,
-0.1999291778,
-0.3072577715,
0.1758150011,
0.3562084436,
0.1711068451,
0.4798119664,
0.3566298783,
-0.0741491541,
0.1246382445,
0.0404727533,
0.617942512,
-0.7414626479,
-0.7617021799,
-0.6197340488,
0.4025162756,
-0.0511209033,
-0.289943397,
0.4226749241,
0.359693408,
0.4794154167,
-0.2599358261,
1.3322987556,
0.0217458773,
0.7753842473,
-0.5300046802,
0.7612107992,
-0.5775606632,
-0.1601148546,
-0.3620708883,
-0.5084471107,
0.1104475334,
0.5955448151,
-0.2456010729,
0.2299235612,
1.074603796,
0.4546673894,
0.2698269486,
0.2357394248,
0.2587825954,
-0.1471750885,
0.1099947989,
0.9454953074,
0.7340456843,
-0.3278384209,
0.4294944406,
-0.2996157706,
-0.31765154,
-0.1611271054,
-0.8828657269,
-0.9188684821,
-0.7117280364,
-0.1617879719,
-0.1592635363,
0.1577926874,
0.725572288,
0.3877344131,
-0.8522786498,
-0.0315313153,
0.2484450042,
-0.2203888893,
-0.6829519272,
-0.2683085501,
0.3876965046,
-0.7052552104,
-0.6869796515,
0.3420428634,
0.0004004413,
-0.0030321893,
-0.3653485477,
0.0551443808,
-0.1356031299,
0.3427292109,
0.4971526861,
0.1783389151,
-0.3313176632,
-0.5084975362,
-0.0186314248,
-0.1632709801,
-0.0202298574,
0.8503509164,
-0.8814396858,
0.305072993,
0.3598792255,
0.4147420824,
0.2921183109,
0.1332869679,
0.9333341718,
-0.6757170558,
-0.3666349351,
0.5466476083,
0.6149457097,
0.2541730404,
-0.5408211946,
0.0264575779,
0.1379965991,
-0.6266412735,
-0.2027394027,
0.3211041093,
-0.4658411443,
-0.3120990396,
0.720760107,
-0.5190160871,
-0.0308320243,
-0.205522418,
0.1875372976,
0.1834844947,
-0.5634667277,
1.2553648949,
0.8043494821,
-0.440066278,
-0.2904799879,
-0.0234632231,
0.8287196159,
0.5254589915,
-0.803371191,
-0.1880262345,
0.7317331433,
0.1339372396,
-0.0343330465,
0.7311108708,
0.034722656,
0.4815954268,
0.2073708773,
0.4578366876,
-0.1087197438,
-0.4782668352,
-0.1690270603,
0.497700423,
0.2035216838,
-0.4040507674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08319v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08319v2
|
Knowledge Conflicts for LLMs: A Survey
| 2024-03-13T08:02:23 | 2024-06-22T08:31:40 |
Rongwu Xu, Zehan Qi, Zhijiang Guo, Cunxiang Wang, Hongru Wang, Yue Zhang, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This survey provides an in-depth analysis of knowledge conflicts for large
language models (LLMs), highlighting the complex challenges they encounter when
blending contextual and parametric knowledge. Our focus is on three categories
of knowledge conflicts: context-memory, inter-context, and intra-memory
conflict. These conflicts can significantly impact the trustworthiness and
performance of LLMs, especially in real-world applications where noise and
misinformation are common. By categorizing these conflicts, exploring the
causes, examining the behaviors of LLMs under such conflicts, and reviewing
available solutions, this survey aims to shed light on strategies for improving
the robustness of LLMs, thereby serving as a valuable resource for advancing
research in this evolving area.
|
[
-0.5132268667,
-0.7296679616,
0.8325101137,
0.2311392725,
-0.0150036216,
0.2993062437,
-0.2607908547,
-0.766143918,
-0.2344789356,
0.6822198629,
-0.2498934716,
-0.3668453395,
-0.8115566373,
-0.2275803834,
-0.4694226384,
0.5997823477,
-0.4259638786,
0.1740861982,
-0.6693663597,
-0.4133130014,
-0.5321809649,
-0.8558452129,
-0.6523702145,
-0.308671385,
0.4942463934,
0.3335352838,
0.4675042033,
0.0942067802,
0.6547933817,
0.3393488526,
-0.2727604806,
0.2832171023,
-0.4113120735,
0.666087091,
-0.2269082516,
-0.394092679,
-0.2457998544,
-0.0447875261,
0.5886873603,
0.4859713614,
-0.1369693726,
0.2310422808,
0.1090680361,
0.5856835246,
-0.7395685315,
0.1171350926,
-0.6400126219,
-0.0642181709,
-0.4576519728,
-0.174442485,
0.0700023249,
-0.592435658,
0.3868847191,
-0.3340562582,
-0.1190553233,
0.1943045259,
0.8430222869,
0.3706422448,
-0.6698132753,
-0.5182572007,
-0.7900537848,
0.7761795521,
-0.7456873655,
0.4467788935,
0.5229300857,
0.2101728022,
-0.1592706591,
-0.5322502255,
-0.4898443222,
0.0624115244,
0.0885596797,
-0.0770542175,
-0.2357201725,
-0.2468851507,
0.2871035635,
0.1605843902,
-0.4061899185,
0.3535474241,
-0.4008518457,
-0.2122413069,
0.5078608394,
0.3782028258,
0.3837994635,
0.0858301967,
-0.1804384887,
0.0304861497,
-1.1039179564,
0.0383891165,
0.4356512725,
-0.2124873996,
0.0431150161,
0.4639828205,
-0.0523389429,
0.9761629105,
-0.2355257869,
-0.3585895002,
-0.1732105762,
-0.2752539814,
0.0587435924,
0.0707691684,
0.9103478789,
0.5669331551,
0.0916530192,
-0.0234392788,
-0.2960290611,
-0.2110651433,
0.0091433935,
-0.413495183,
0.2382278442,
0.2832053602,
-0.316780746,
-0.1466132402,
-0.1438185573,
-0.7550950646,
-0.6445469856,
-0.2916096449,
0.3975766599,
-0.407373786,
-0.3842650056,
-0.0195723325,
-0.1132799461,
0.137010321,
0.3471363485,
-0.5851809382,
0.0463536046,
0.6124177575,
0.5684219003,
-0.1396610737,
-0.3373329937,
-0.1101175472,
0.509100914,
-0.2477905899,
0.77130723,
-0.5091019273,
-0.4222434759,
0.2946952581,
-0.3527513444,
-0.2597048879,
-0.9104325175,
0.2731829584,
-0.6782109737,
0.4164296389,
-0.6626272202,
-0.7780182958,
-0.1031806618,
0.5877712369,
-0.642888844,
1.2096951008,
0.1947247535,
-0.8124652505,
0.3685048223,
-0.3857837319,
-0.1560394913,
-0.0655379519,
-0.4916859269,
-0.1224284992,
0.009758451,
-0.177074194,
0.5852409005,
-0.7834942937,
0.5342288017,
-0.2259388268,
-0.2023992985,
0.3746947348,
-0.1532200277,
0.46640715,
0.4043544531,
-0.1954844743,
0.1794462204,
-0.7529815435,
-0.3329237401,
0.109066762,
-0.4645525813,
-0.6166058183,
0.1712037623,
-0.4299814999,
0.410469383,
0.6797186136,
-0.377596885,
0.111949034,
0.1828723103,
0.3834968805,
0.6449130774,
0.2028810233,
0.3013212681,
-0.5671357512,
0.5250354409,
0.5618428588,
0.298296392,
0.1894226819,
-0.5527901053,
-0.7853948474,
0.4114944041,
-0.0114112301,
0.4741488397,
-0.757737577,
0.1197131276,
-0.0914528593,
-0.3570868671,
-0.164407596,
0.2471477091,
0.3182474077,
0.6462777853,
0.2543083727,
0.1109924093,
-0.4129504859,
-0.8664124608,
-0.3843047321,
-0.315392226,
0.2714816332,
0.418607831,
0.2162651718,
-0.3108610213,
1.0455771685,
-0.3621595502,
-0.2861216962,
-0.0793636218,
0.1969637424,
-0.2795405686,
0.339230597,
0.6379995346,
-0.6372647882,
-0.4871070087,
0.0550197847,
-0.7694174647,
-0.0496636033,
0.2930704355,
0.2156006396,
0.4020384848,
1.037274003,
-0.6065930128,
0.1083103493,
0.7113136053,
-0.2412180603,
0.4631944597,
0.0512058027,
0.1691389978,
-1.1786404848,
-0.2275212407,
0.1140865088,
0.1695340127,
-0.4220455885,
0.0078076073,
0.1307998747,
0.2702571154,
-0.6513896585,
0.6523201466,
-0.5442542434,
0.1219673529,
0.1469388753,
0.2547732294,
-0.1817195266,
0.0547787286,
0.0023946087,
0.8473090529,
0.6286737323,
-0.7385960221,
0.407296896,
0.0454125479,
-0.622580111,
0.4829999208,
-0.2721449733,
-0.051136706,
-0.141048044,
0.0372219495,
-0.8580234051,
-0.3216700852,
0.256764859,
-0.117579788,
0.2673726678,
-0.0515667461,
-0.7169982195,
-0.0700817332,
-0.1396036148,
0.7016304731,
0.4181410968,
-0.2875223756,
0.4983674586,
0.4827091098,
-0.1913493425,
-0.7196743488,
-0.5867982507,
0.0389022753,
-0.5502187014,
-0.516955018,
0.108621031,
-0.065599978,
-0.6429676414,
0.2057736963,
-0.1623601764,
-0.3599351645,
-0.2019028366,
0.0924765468,
0.074985154,
-0.3202578425,
0.1597059965,
-0.0981905088,
0.2962249219,
0.2316041589,
0.0571772568,
0.6015794873,
-0.2050825208,
-0.6000076532,
-0.0219575875,
0.2106835991,
0.7691444755,
0.0112113282,
0.8622463346,
0.5369465947,
-0.3146351576,
-0.0472197905,
-1.2151045799,
0.0771929622,
-0.4791089892,
0.327390641,
-0.2806379199,
-1.472053051,
0.8346812129,
-0.3539480865,
-0.1057249829,
0.2731256485,
0.5110228658,
-0.1045871079,
0.8133754134,
0.4970058203,
-0.395704627,
0.4132253826,
0.1595564187,
0.2817497849,
-0.8274044991,
-0.6511617899,
-0.5206443667,
-0.2621119022,
-0.2779687643,
-0.47725299,
0.3516373932,
0.1997259408,
-0.3019465208,
0.4376859963,
-0.1578980982,
0.422521621,
0.2265902311,
-0.4036265314,
0.3987573385,
-0.3131673932,
-0.2717190981,
-0.1376087517,
-0.8712348938,
-0.5747380257,
0.9707816243,
0.4487394392,
0.7981442809,
0.567364037,
0.6481066346,
-0.1798877716,
0.2005663514,
-0.5847555399,
0.639473021,
0.1565222591,
-0.6852559447,
-0.2682073712,
-0.5748310089,
-0.9441529512,
0.0760050267,
-0.0570532121,
-1.0024143457,
0.1963280439,
-0.094259575,
-0.2505357862,
0.548669517,
-0.4749436378,
0.6770484447,
-0.4080211818,
-0.2363158911,
-0.1106618941,
-0.5344603658,
0.8311108947,
-0.2847031355,
0.2891723216,
-0.1723197103,
0.0006118083,
0.8879685998,
-0.1470160633,
0.6966642737,
0.0738155395,
-0.5524532199,
0.4104643464,
0.2106258422,
0.4069841504,
0.0358789377,
0.1196044832,
0.1949726045,
0.3846050799,
-0.0751307756,
-0.3789950311,
0.806681335,
-0.8512579203,
-0.7684444785,
-0.4871569872,
-0.796113193,
-0.8399884701,
0.0960176587,
0.3523619175,
0.2065278739,
-0.2319699228,
0.3029782772,
1.2633183002,
-0.3196072578,
0.5450055599,
0.7387305498,
-0.3914197385,
0.0239412673,
0.8832708597,
0.2816183567,
0.291870892,
0.2459503263,
0.0358094014,
-0.2396391332,
-0.7337470651,
0.0741127506,
0.1548102945,
-0.7569662929,
-0.3227888346,
-0.5262389183,
-0.3505608737,
-0.4436379671,
0.1190736145,
-0.3804337382,
-0.1530293077,
-0.407548815,
0.2752901316,
0.3331455588,
1.1304728985,
0.195671618,
0.438940078,
-1.0424615145,
0.0938433781,
0.3566589952,
0.409132272,
-0.0716522634,
-0.4525406957,
-0.3606351316,
-0.3941236734,
-0.3506390452,
-1.0827639103,
0.1259352863,
-0.2959890366,
0.8116641045,
0.6328682303,
0.0732634217,
0.7692031264,
-0.1047645062,
1.0470106602,
0.2624240518,
-0.7804566026,
0.1912707239,
-0.4812155664,
0.102161251,
0.4855763614,
0.6482416391,
-0.6232531667,
-0.5817652941,
-0.552416563,
-0.892306149,
0.5582207441,
-0.2335981727,
-0.2795079648,
0.0058579445,
0.3303127587,
-0.341625154,
0.2408062965,
-0.5494949818,
-0.1939101815,
0.365029186,
-0.123547174,
0.059375342,
-0.5276755095,
-0.6084285975,
-0.3751663566,
0.5196368694,
0.1592268497,
-0.0330688842,
-0.0677487031,
-0.2149428874,
-0.2954922915,
0.2992240489,
0.9103412032,
1.0287582874,
-0.0081870491,
0.3516447246,
0.4183381796,
-0.2701981664,
0.2214349955,
-0.225545153,
0.0457004718,
-0.3077363074,
0.3662928939,
0.6902612448,
0.4201569855,
-0.8604527116,
0.6105447412,
-0.2462141365,
-0.4413073957,
-0.2946295738,
0.0472001918,
0.5098381639,
0.3450008333,
0.1558072567,
0.1254588366,
-0.1417708248,
-0.5066916943,
-0.0382920355,
0.5478207469,
-0.3707001507,
0.0756854862,
0.3227911294,
-0.0445104577,
-0.019398557,
0.3575596511,
-0.0312942304,
-0.5233935714,
0.4076005816,
0.4348621368,
0.5017733574,
-0.220756188,
0.0034564009,
-0.0463372581,
0.2857065201,
-0.2490205765,
0.1156847253,
0.0174652115,
-0.9625974298,
-0.2465230078,
-0.5631694198,
-0.6709761024,
0.6027611494,
-0.6387618184,
0.0419881642,
-0.4209069908,
-0.2961196303,
-0.5072408319,
-0.0025878628,
-0.5781177878,
-0.078307569,
0.0563126802,
0.8162638545,
-0.6042433381,
0.9197970033,
0.8551484346,
-0.2543703616,
-0.7901073098,
0.0974687636,
0.1032367945,
-0.6678432226,
0.8434976339,
-0.4420719743,
-0.208793357,
-0.4134128094,
-0.4527266324,
-1.0504635572,
1.1814191341,
0.3606978953,
-0.4964565933,
0.0274933353,
0.355445683,
0.3884807527,
-0.2696914077,
-0.0954116508,
0.7290390134,
0.7131684422,
-0.0253580976,
-1.0087552071,
-0.0715176761,
0.0824634805,
0.1096957847,
0.1364506036,
-1.0919728279,
1.0078475475,
0.391872853,
-0.1610850543,
-0.0842521265,
0.552560389,
0.5206157565,
0.4126409292,
0.34356758,
0.7018729448,
0.6259596944,
-0.2036095411,
0.5686511397,
-0.6138255,
0.1272065192,
1.2110021114,
-0.4872047901,
0.6998972297,
0.7323299646,
-0.3157375753,
0.4541016221,
0.7265477777,
0.2892311513,
0.0291694477,
0.0996055603,
-0.5165521502,
-0.092883788,
0.0050016139,
-0.6937211752,
0.4158838987,
0.59448874,
-0.1285766214,
-0.3643470407,
-0.2699632049,
0.1936329007,
-0.0224994887,
0.0034713384,
0.8040630221,
-0.0373149626,
-0.7423377633,
0.2585683167,
0.0516248271,
0.8493543863,
-0.7388828397,
0.1903365254,
-0.0244418085,
0.0477058813,
-0.2617384791,
-1.0036029816,
0.3441356719,
-0.2658679783,
-0.1634057015,
-0.2678054273,
0.8493093848,
-0.7102791071,
-0.0350854099,
0.5174786448,
0.9430853128,
0.022107074,
-0.0692910478,
-0.5558239222,
0.555795908,
-0.2700051069,
-0.2970339656,
0.8189313412,
0.5769851208,
-0.1894842237,
0.8002291322,
0.4036997259,
0.1572341621,
0.4176284969,
0.0451978035,
0.9169808626,
-0.5967854261,
-0.003655747,
-0.8397592902,
0.1335816532,
-0.0768558085,
-0.3532207608,
1.0775741339,
0.6172720194,
0.7490364909,
-0.0612136796,
0.7666585445,
0.0665654391,
0.5197250247,
-0.508084178,
0.9105400443,
-0.5285287499,
0.4019686282,
-0.27816993,
-0.8608524203,
-0.1609676927,
0.3314774632,
-0.33705163,
0.0025966316,
0.7752450705,
0.6852838397,
0.0938785449,
0.0360237248,
0.5239328742,
0.1256769001,
0.1541801095,
0.707149744,
1.4395265579,
-0.2714671493,
0.4704143703,
-0.2169167846,
0.1374542713,
-0.1212459803,
-0.9969224334,
-0.7903886437,
-0.929908812,
-0.3881003857,
-0.1862452179,
-0.0823912919,
0.6827721,
0.5077950358,
-0.7103124261,
-0.6206626892,
0.1511518806,
0.46428743,
0.2789031565,
-0.244600445,
-0.0538247675,
-0.5307401419,
-0.6625362635,
0.3861929178,
0.1198509857,
0.185362339,
-0.3972561359,
-0.2012072355,
-0.1686710566,
0.084687598,
0.7734963298,
0.4677868187,
-0.8481150866,
-0.304509908,
-0.2836749852,
-0.1368059814,
-0.3341552615,
1.2227180004,
-0.5154566765,
0.1001137793,
0.502471149,
0.6039389968,
0.3002728522,
-0.2094997019,
0.4462040961,
-0.7607228756,
0.0430229418,
0.1406164914,
0.5056112409,
0.1407619715,
-0.5403955579,
0.2022328377,
0.1546885818,
-0.784316361,
-0.8903087974,
0.251714617,
-0.9330996871,
-0.4561375976,
1.4241429567,
0.0594687089,
0.2191515267,
-0.3730371296,
-0.003600128,
0.2009126693,
-0.1685888469,
0.5962384939,
1.2566504478,
-0.4132219255,
-0.1645745188,
-0.7234483361,
0.912322998,
0.2900729775,
-0.6697922945,
-0.0293386113,
0.6862645149,
0.5142761469,
0.1083537191,
0.5268664956,
-0.3635829985,
-0.1631143391,
-0.4004161656,
-0.1753431559,
0.0037268857,
-0.3988473415,
-0.3019910753,
0.4652399123,
0.3503852487,
0.3907297254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09733v1
|
OverleafCopilot: Empowering Academic Writing in Overleaf with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T07:52:31 | 2024-03-13T07:52:31 |
Haomin Wen, Zhenjie Wei, Yan Lin, Jiyuan Wang, Yuxuan Liang, Huaiyu Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has facilitated a
variety of applications from different domains. In this technical report, we
explore the integration of LLMs and the popular academic writing tool,
Overleaf, to enhance the efficiency and quality of academic writing. To achieve
the above goal, there are three challenges: i) including seamless interaction
between Overleaf and LLMs, ii) establishing reliable communication with the LLM
provider, and iii) ensuring user privacy. To address these challenges, we
present OverleafCopilot, the first-ever tool (i.e., a browser extension) that
seamlessly integrates LLMs and Overleaf, enabling researchers to leverage the
power of LLMs while writing papers. Specifically, we first propose an effective
framework to bridge LLMs and Overleaf. Then, we developed PromptGenius, a
website for researchers to easily find and share high-quality up-to-date
prompts. Thirdly, we propose an agent command system to help researchers
quickly build their customizable agents. OverleafCopilot
(https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/overleaf-copilot/eoadabdpninlhkkbhngoddfjianhlghb
) has been on the Chrome Extension Store, which now serves thousands of
researchers. Additionally, the code of PromptGenius is released at
https://github.com/wenhaomin/ChatGPT-PromptGenius. We believe our work has the
potential to revolutionize academic writing practices, empowering researchers
to produce higher-quality papers in less time.
|
[
-0.3826117516,
-0.6191868782,
0.8856220245,
0.1542941481,
0.2580287158,
0.7449838519,
-0.2983534932,
-0.6831700206,
0.3165002763,
0.5697118044,
-0.5656628609,
-0.7653603554,
-0.2327957302,
-0.0211601593,
-0.3974242508,
0.8746780753,
-0.3087045252,
-0.1123464033,
-0.7332583666,
-0.0363623872,
0.000220575,
-0.5457756519,
-0.5286082625,
-0.1212827563,
1.0433939695,
0.4333594143,
0.5035734773,
0.2748726904,
0.6148188114,
0.3342204094,
0.1267225742,
0.1858265847,
-0.5667573214,
0.3454156518,
-0.2845894992,
-0.4836394787,
-0.6434409022,
-0.0345993303,
0.5718880296,
0.4684313238,
-0.0229848865,
0.0641165376,
0.1916874945,
0.4525321126,
-0.5800533891,
0.0404307358,
-0.050784152,
-0.2088751048,
-0.4190213978,
-0.4263697267,
-0.2734839618,
-0.8660162687,
-0.0038519392,
-0.9007480145,
0.000797421,
0.4034993649,
0.4763189256,
0.0751419514,
-0.3374095559,
-0.5757657886,
-0.4760141373,
0.7029322386,
-0.5042186379,
0.1186887175,
0.0614365637,
0.4842113554,
-0.4180503488,
-1.054820776,
-0.6183606386,
-0.4045573473,
0.0050643929,
0.3430142403,
-0.2774671018,
0.1333007216,
0.2185067683,
0.2097000629,
-0.7977016568,
0.4422718585,
-0.2258599848,
0.0904596373,
0.5678616762,
0.3879744709,
0.2702693641,
0.2053738832,
0.0347290225,
-0.007888875,
-0.5632981062,
0.0559918247,
0.6315639019,
0.2800235152,
0.1155569628,
0.5458232164,
0.1407512873,
0.4307429492,
-0.3307893574,
0.0826577172,
0.0502515808,
0.0480786189,
0.0086932853,
0.0616133921,
0.7639713287,
0.3668770194,
0.0791984424,
-0.1355348378,
0.0675371811,
0.0358824059,
0.23051548,
-0.7249782085,
0.0763243958,
0.6309131384,
-0.2052149624,
-0.2330414057,
-0.1092037633,
-0.8445397615,
-0.948577106,
-0.3734358549,
0.1109751761,
-0.4083066583,
-0.1578001231,
-0.017060915,
-0.2432692796,
0.0728849694,
0.570289731,
-0.7760503292,
0.5987749696,
1.1023749113,
1.0797784328,
-0.3750819862,
-0.5227344036,
-0.3926907182,
0.0370330364,
-0.1892080754,
0.6189951897,
-0.3414518535,
-0.5877335668,
0.4589483142,
-0.1056624427,
0.0041681523,
0.036282111,
0.5274512768,
-0.49276793,
0.3261458874,
-0.2820313871,
-0.8730027676,
-0.0594981462,
0.2963934243,
-0.6878051162,
0.795915544,
0.2188046575,
-0.5715548396,
0.0045097047,
-0.8771479726,
-0.2743110657,
0.2992874086,
-0.1245903671,
-0.2390565276,
-0.0283031277,
-0.2584284246,
0.3455324769,
-0.4928419292,
0.2767303586,
-0.3965742886,
-0.0564425401,
0.469042629,
-0.0789146796,
0.8524512053,
0.1968856752,
0.0434586741,
0.409827739,
-0.7735401988,
0.0694554448,
-0.080697,
-0.0692001209,
0.0030168162,
-0.2231644094,
0.4913921356,
-0.2961513996,
0.5122118592,
-0.8651501536,
0.6422616839,
0.0942148715,
0.5552306175,
0.3644573987,
-0.2409714907,
0.2827908993,
-0.5371931195,
0.8997353911,
-0.9705042839,
0.1761577129,
-0.1791181713,
-0.2784497142,
-0.5144593716,
-0.4420132637,
0.4500071108,
0.5574526787,
-0.4522068799,
0.4451564848,
-0.2895044088,
-0.7301228642,
-0.4940487146,
0.0943211019,
0.0979206413,
0.1498145014,
0.171846211,
-0.0373954363,
-0.3952509165,
-0.3805001378,
-0.0885735825,
0.074209787,
-0.2292716503,
-0.0732680336,
0.5759199262,
-0.1927195489,
1.1882398129,
-0.6551111937,
-0.6002240777,
-0.6752979159,
0.5131982565,
0.0581827909,
0.4318163097,
0.7181229591,
-0.5684664845,
-0.8031057715,
0.120091252,
-0.4967499673,
-0.4838642478,
-0.2788153291,
-0.0720710829,
0.3609013259,
0.8141092062,
-0.5679633617,
0.1433344781,
0.6475273371,
-0.2292644978,
0.5018487573,
-0.3138435185,
0.0395789109,
-0.9494189024,
0.5130461454,
0.1602131426,
-0.3538310826,
-0.5035297275,
0.168768689,
0.0779114068,
-0.2574530542,
-0.1965722144,
0.7176139951,
-0.4874223471,
0.1870340705,
-0.4039038122,
0.326605171,
0.221122697,
0.3794921339,
-0.0126956599,
0.6258758903,
0.5380740166,
0.072870262,
0.4294694662,
0.1834721714,
-0.174044624,
0.5433781743,
-0.7486412525,
0.0240842476,
-0.1523721963,
0.3884115815,
-0.8882285357,
-0.4550212026,
0.0870028287,
-0.5198159218,
0.3997152746,
0.1462808847,
-0.625849247,
-0.1875956208,
-0.6228746772,
-0.0893348828,
0.4941006005,
-0.3811706007,
0.8606973886,
0.2843815088,
-0.4461005628,
-0.0820126757,
-0.5342754722,
0.2420909554,
-0.1224606037,
-0.4848066568,
0.4415249527,
-0.0604373664,
-0.1990686655,
0.0544183515,
0.2820384502,
0.0514517166,
-0.107350193,
0.4796153903,
0.157826975,
0.1433854103,
0.1292160451,
0.0832755193,
-0.0261407699,
0.1543955952,
-0.2106975317,
0.3871234357,
0.0667884573,
-0.3850788474,
-0.3795287013,
0.6156414151,
0.7109407187,
-0.2806871831,
0.5740709305,
0.4209547937,
0.0095339883,
-0.3685487807,
-0.476265192,
-0.0180497002,
-0.5182226896,
0.0910791904,
-0.149669528,
-0.8455185294,
0.5397183895,
-0.1839072704,
0.422570169,
0.146158874,
0.1688434482,
-0.1637049615,
0.6290696263,
0.8426389098,
0.0564780906,
0.5978696346,
-0.4213513732,
0.0401908979,
-0.9076769948,
-0.2695070803,
-0.8084167242,
-0.319748491,
-0.5993430018,
-0.2665686011,
0.2950187325,
-0.2725914419,
0.0389820524,
0.1127642244,
-0.2852795422,
0.4789928794,
0.9565396905,
-0.233432889,
0.1404438019,
-0.1891397536,
0.1226359457,
-0.154983893,
-0.7173128128,
-0.6797407269,
0.9620533586,
0.4549895227,
0.9426400661,
0.0930589363,
0.5855340958,
0.3662308156,
0.3873676956,
-0.6207328439,
0.5574784875,
-0.1228371188,
-0.5328641534,
-0.4280764163,
-0.1444758028,
-1.015194416,
0.06982743,
-0.2474701107,
-0.9385406971,
0.2205619216,
0.1703909636,
-0.5266590714,
0.0906276032,
-0.388754487,
0.9394851327,
-0.4810535014,
-0.7776020765,
-0.1240378246,
-0.6188510656,
-0.0418418273,
-0.0800121874,
0.0610187799,
0.1047541574,
0.0144448876,
0.6992805004,
-0.4182071984,
1.0088182688,
0.2065740228,
-0.0528002307,
0.4007925391,
0.0776333064,
0.445648104,
-0.1020676643,
-0.0998503193,
0.1438018382,
0.1033549979,
-0.1642548591,
-0.7234065533,
1.0551942587,
-0.6529277563,
-0.3779653907,
-0.9398519993,
-0.5194195509,
-0.0549116544,
0.2792448699,
0.0900334865,
0.7401987314,
-0.4136572182,
0.382186234,
0.3540773392,
-0.2681264877,
0.3918090761,
0.7188550234,
-0.6241334081,
-0.479041338,
0.9893912673,
0.2757030725,
0.2426265478,
0.4302899837,
0.0747546032,
-0.5147976875,
-0.6252654791,
-0.1247917265,
0.2087834775,
-0.7945096493,
0.1029943004,
-0.7609600425,
-0.1839049608,
-0.5781996846,
-0.7339669466,
-0.0083579961,
-0.5660552382,
-0.476924479,
-0.0626746789,
0.5694617033,
0.5901503563,
-0.1233276278,
0.8047824502,
-0.635032475,
-0.0205134898,
0.0169320572,
0.1583940387,
-0.0479589477,
-0.198411718,
-0.1359364986,
-0.4338234663,
-0.5954340696,
-0.5528745055,
0.5385833979,
-0.0866136029,
0.4110591412,
0.2419945896,
0.104996331,
0.260497123,
-0.4139333367,
0.7278100252,
0.1739867479,
-0.9814238548,
0.1227856204,
-0.5570830107,
0.3640576005,
0.7428508401,
0.7053220868,
-0.7473213673,
-0.7363430858,
-0.3689394891,
-0.9191564322,
0.3766642809,
0.0958680138,
-0.2450053245,
0.3588777781,
-0.0070049269,
0.3885323405,
0.4522657394,
-0.4091954231,
0.0393983647,
-0.1468280852,
-0.3981378675,
-0.4125344157,
-0.1394570768,
-0.1648289263,
-0.0479199365,
0.5159977674,
-0.0953967273,
-0.2971986234,
0.183799848,
0.0704604164,
-0.074546352,
0.2924700081,
0.5557273626,
0.9703146219,
-0.4702754915,
0.0307244901,
-0.1177383289,
-0.4403539896,
-0.2685931921,
0.3454717696,
-0.2520278692,
0.0375990272,
0.7544910312,
0.6656585932,
-0.0563449264,
-0.6768079996,
0.2836704552,
-0.0780902281,
-0.1733518541,
-0.5579964519,
0.1590980738,
0.0630564094,
0.295430094,
0.4184295535,
-0.3199612796,
0.2784254551,
-0.6736476421,
-0.2623707354,
0.5033919811,
-0.2076146305,
-0.2232954502,
0.7290455699,
0.5854743123,
-0.4532053173,
0.1711978018,
-0.100676626,
-0.5883470774,
0.5074368715,
0.3697331548,
0.9221622944,
0.043908041,
0.4055098891,
-0.042670384,
0.2050704509,
0.0242703818,
0.4225566685,
0.0731635466,
0.0205245242,
-0.3905717432,
-0.4517958462,
-0.9758813381,
-0.0291329697,
-0.4105960429,
0.2972244918,
-0.5122033954,
-0.2881661355,
0.2029650211,
0.281205982,
-0.2963146567,
-0.1514418423,
-0.1375736594,
1.1018449068,
-0.6497958899,
0.6582608819,
0.714872241,
-0.2756072283,
-0.2790914476,
-0.2752133012,
0.2356859148,
-0.3259908855,
0.2590227723,
0.2209421694,
-0.3095719814,
0.2036263347,
-0.6304334998,
-0.5189028978,
1.0965210199,
0.047758963,
-0.9343219995,
0.2018181533,
0.265506655,
0.8360417485,
-0.2074929029,
0.4554838538,
0.3513460159,
0.602048099,
0.3004413247,
-0.7296236753,
0.0800034106,
-0.0715355501,
-0.223532781,
0.3657132387,
-0.6733621359,
0.7021023631,
0.1264767796,
-0.1923693269,
0.3016998768,
0.5864450336,
-0.0093333172,
0.5949223042,
-0.0268961452,
0.2580391467,
0.9268628359,
-0.0521249734,
1.0609918833,
-0.3161308765,
0.1702951044,
1.1668493748,
-0.6613541245,
0.6984025836,
0.5551365614,
-0.0462574512,
0.4552049041,
0.2508982718,
-0.0676300898,
0.2785778642,
0.4150713086,
-0.317694813,
0.1438695192,
-0.389146328,
-0.3712280095,
-0.1625484377,
0.2785956562,
-0.0736538395,
-0.2492716014,
0.1664869189,
0.2218604833,
0.4446946681,
-0.2000019848,
0.5430799127,
0.1643641889,
-0.6861670017,
0.1301004291,
-0.0902325809,
0.3781865239,
-0.9646075368,
0.1461347193,
-0.2184340358,
0.0705239102,
-0.2583430707,
-1.0984810591,
0.1120411605,
0.1395623982,
0.0722901747,
-0.4686408043,
0.3930515051,
-0.4546771944,
-0.5189336538,
0.2380672842,
0.3152372837,
-0.0126265706,
0.0645630732,
-0.2205689996,
0.6108263731,
-0.3339721859,
-0.2709648609,
0.1767279804,
0.4715904295,
-0.0042553321,
0.883782208,
0.6217674613,
0.4061261117,
-0.0939956531,
0.1140305325,
0.8295191526,
-0.5531487465,
-0.6260506511,
-0.6793314219,
0.5078874826,
-0.4798503518,
-0.3835980594,
1.0951564312,
0.6216540337,
0.2893119156,
0.0574479029,
1.1373765469,
-0.2311159521,
0.690328598,
-0.3573458791,
0.7845352888,
-0.6024109125,
-0.0800043717,
-0.1107882559,
-0.9450585246,
-0.5402758718,
0.1049938053,
-0.5027178526,
-0.3557925522,
0.9967830181,
0.6097240448,
0.0119869206,
-0.1405454874,
0.2327251881,
-0.0235650875,
0.6895438433,
0.3527063131,
0.7114036679,
0.2374363691,
0.4604562223,
-0.0155840944,
-0.4828281999,
-0.3765578568,
-1.0464400053,
-1.2790261507,
-0.4911573231,
-0.3605337739,
-0.1448661387,
0.1672116518,
0.8653591871,
0.2974675298,
-0.6928752661,
-0.411875993,
-0.3199921548,
-0.0610525496,
0.1399464011,
-0.1887305528,
0.4118447304,
-0.1691351384,
-0.8891672492,
0.2039593458,
0.2457540333,
0.1480609775,
-0.7302710414,
0.0040538777,
0.0642468631,
0.1196706221,
0.3255199492,
0.7114087343,
-0.3269163668,
0.1192027405,
0.0900483727,
-0.1896163672,
-0.1759366542,
1.0004585981,
-0.3416872919,
0.3392120302,
0.6706598997,
0.5516013503,
0.4057272375,
0.1789585203,
0.7509091496,
-0.3489534259,
-0.0141220726,
0.3014449179,
0.2499646246,
0.3638958037,
-0.2929901779,
0.4010698795,
-0.3584091663,
-0.9156329632,
-0.954513967,
0.1587643772,
-1.0447238684,
-0.4935250282,
1.04674685,
-0.1735449731,
-0.2775122523,
0.000569763,
-0.7262874246,
0.0543375202,
-0.6591368318,
0.8399900198,
0.6748864651,
-0.0839110315,
-0.0382475741,
-0.594999671,
0.6078909039,
0.1682281345,
-1.0736103058,
0.1054052263,
0.6249035597,
-0.1065525338,
0.5207915306,
0.5025162101,
0.4963105321,
0.1868404597,
-0.03737114,
0.318833828,
-0.4762201607,
-0.5332868695,
-0.3371381164,
0.3662039042,
0.1066948324,
-0.0336847492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08314v1
|
Is Context Helpful for Chat Translation Evaluation?
| 2024-03-13T07:49:50 | 2024-03-13T07:49:50 |
Sweta Agrawal, Amin Farajian, Patrick Fernandes, Ricardo Rei, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the recent success of automatic metrics for assessing translation
quality, their application in evaluating the quality of machine-translated
chats has been limited. Unlike more structured texts like news, chat
conversations are often unstructured, short, and heavily reliant on contextual
information. This poses questions about the reliability of existing
sentence-level metrics in this domain as well as the role of context in
assessing the translation quality. Motivated by this, we conduct a
meta-evaluation of existing sentence-level automatic metrics, primarily
designed for structured domains such as news, to assess the quality of
machine-translated chats. We find that reference-free metrics lag behind
reference-based ones, especially when evaluating translation quality in
out-of-English settings. We then investigate how incorporating conversational
contextual information in these metrics affects their performance. Our findings
show that augmenting neural learned metrics with contextual information helps
improve correlation with human judgments in the reference-free scenario and
when evaluating translations in out-of-English settings. Finally, we propose a
new evaluation metric, Context-MQM, that utilizes bilingual context with a
large language model (LLM) and further validate that adding context helps even
for LLM-based evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.2502507269,
-0.6469222307,
0.4254468977,
0.4540867507,
-0.5804661512,
-0.0651733726,
-0.5132751465,
-0.5049408674,
0.1662086099,
0.0938058048,
-0.2704140842,
-0.3589816988,
-0.4913883209,
0.1117759869,
-0.434600085,
1.0515210629,
0.2039600313,
0.3098924756,
-0.6225513816,
-0.403553009,
-0.9546087384,
-0.6920518279,
-0.5580341816,
-0.2329445332,
0.3272190094,
0.3989201188,
0.8837329149,
0.3273283541,
0.5751142502,
0.3028256893,
-0.0825794116,
0.4214464426,
-0.4412362874,
0.1630037576,
-0.1383937001,
-0.476767391,
-0.5541772842,
0.1125026122,
0.6427785158,
0.8112173676,
0.0483489633,
0.1633474827,
0.3950009048,
0.6894922853,
-0.5287303925,
0.2280062586,
-0.5002841949,
0.027283961,
0.0937401876,
-0.6934635043,
-0.4164847434,
-0.0455474779,
0.3740845323,
-0.3142271638,
-0.0915023759,
0.0520918556,
0.7211490273,
0.3308731914,
-0.822285831,
-0.286559701,
-0.7402099371,
0.724799931,
-0.6727837324,
0.5420579314,
0.3572633564,
0.4340121448,
-0.2543110847,
-0.3497673273,
-0.3012045622,
-0.2130961269,
-0.425273478,
0.2846134007,
-0.1290408969,
-0.1781184673,
-0.2686659992,
0.3244995475,
-0.2294053137,
-0.0728528276,
-0.3852653503,
-0.20827429,
0.5783349872,
0.3151423931,
0.5567412376,
-0.4158179462,
-0.3487111628,
-0.0642524064,
-0.458437562,
0.1827651858,
0.0688985512,
0.2506841421,
-0.2406388819,
0.306209296,
-0.1918950975,
0.745675087,
-0.2467807382,
-0.3907744586,
0.4087360203,
-0.8166887164,
-0.069116056,
-0.3440970182,
0.8601579666,
0.9569431543,
0.06547153,
-0.2949911654,
0.0404448509,
-0.284085393,
0.2202791125,
-0.6953197122,
0.1724202037,
0.0212640185,
-0.5248572826,
-0.0642360747,
0.0512588285,
-0.4678111374,
0.0380158462,
-0.2885319293,
0.1621964127,
-0.394502759,
0.0400320813,
-0.1852626801,
-0.2491959482,
0.1719067842,
0.5419619083,
-0.6605549455,
0.0005614494,
0.4552798569,
0.8350952268,
-0.3893541694,
-0.2346580029,
-0.6095373631,
-0.1731521189,
-0.5615506172,
0.5850585699,
-0.4659186602,
-0.4392938614,
-0.1517196447,
-0.0647243112,
-0.1634792686,
-0.3853088915,
0.7596630454,
-0.4465401471,
0.5596082807,
-0.0325384736,
-0.4167374671,
-0.0939773545,
0.2846175134,
-0.3113000393,
0.8579102755,
0.1094843075,
-0.6502226591,
0.512963593,
-0.5335179567,
-0.6441982388,
0.0927838236,
-0.0815869644,
0.0075252173,
0.2763743699,
0.1921394467,
0.3096883595,
-0.2710730731,
0.284224391,
-0.0371647365,
-0.5994520187,
0.5753115416,
-0.6202360392,
0.3340442479,
0.334769249,
-0.0363249816,
0.0809069127,
-0.3609021008,
0.2724899352,
-0.4764640927,
-0.4657509029,
-0.4677621126,
0.074576728,
-0.072617054,
0.4134423733,
0.0391196385,
-0.3000030518,
-0.2983098626,
-0.5261501074,
0.5552943945,
0.104631573,
0.03143185,
0.7144119143,
-0.1735513806,
0.2150276452,
0.0988727659,
0.1201838553,
-0.3936575651,
-0.558156848,
-0.8627228141,
-0.0575105548,
0.3276272416,
0.5932480097,
-0.6450881362,
0.7812442183,
-0.5001318455,
-0.3723777533,
-0.3281756341,
0.202434361,
0.5076611638,
0.6111539602,
0.3668062985,
-0.6072093844,
-0.4007813931,
-0.8085132837,
-0.3081748188,
-0.0554930344,
-0.2411662489,
0.6158304811,
0.3631443083,
-0.3050180972,
1.0338834524,
-0.0979801044,
-0.3799239099,
-0.109142907,
0.0465408564,
0.1097942218,
0.4746723473,
0.5491114855,
-0.5998398662,
-0.5385158062,
-0.1475238055,
-0.6362606287,
-0.1149926931,
-0.1700328588,
-0.3600691259,
0.0858317912,
0.4365849793,
-0.5262328386,
0.3892429173,
0.7318480015,
-0.4441618323,
0.2796904147,
-0.3090693951,
0.6036878824,
-1.2267072201,
0.1719938368,
-0.2241396606,
-0.4836294353,
-0.6619977951,
-0.1356184036,
0.1548138112,
-0.0052020419,
-0.7059365511,
0.6964043975,
-0.2528888285,
-0.2584845126,
-0.3732029796,
0.6687705517,
0.2443894446,
0.3790545166,
-0.0746957436,
1.1070977449,
0.0947765708,
-0.621088028,
0.1681813449,
0.4192034006,
-0.6325966716,
0.8432196975,
-0.3819339275,
0.1394236535,
-0.0173295103,
0.4954755008,
-1.0587309599,
-0.0571495406,
0.1356713176,
-0.7941682935,
0.2130956203,
0.08812657,
-0.4037256539,
-0.0073046549,
0.0612511933,
0.3586749136,
0.3024154305,
-0.3313234448,
0.0544863008,
0.3770478666,
0.1700166911,
-0.5385301113,
-0.8345671892,
0.4425777793,
-0.1878483146,
-0.7127395272,
0.3890423179,
-0.1007738486,
-0.1387454271,
-0.1136811823,
-0.2138805389,
-0.1694221646,
0.3905715346,
0.0295472797,
0.0328212492,
-0.1261598468,
0.2923973203,
0.0004516327,
-0.1476559937,
0.0394927189,
-0.2033872604,
0.3197968006,
-0.3965271115,
-0.2510866821,
-0.4875004888,
0.2444610894,
0.546549499,
0.0534705743,
0.8842813373,
0.5166901946,
-0.1045140475,
0.127094239,
-0.4666498899,
-0.1605218947,
-0.3691115677,
0.4440669417,
-0.2588617504,
-0.9427267313,
0.4459002316,
0.1759037226,
-0.1426070482,
0.4205185771,
0.4224558175,
-0.3376053274,
1.0374110937,
0.3946314752,
-0.0674950257,
0.6549915671,
0.0866756886,
0.2727064192,
-1.0527052879,
-0.0066282614,
-0.3211930096,
-0.4372843206,
-0.41967085,
-0.5850563049,
0.5442221165,
0.250259012,
0.2234424502,
0.3980583251,
-0.0315205231,
0.5267763734,
0.3045352697,
0.0702505484,
0.5302897692,
-0.2068151385,
-0.1051046923,
-0.1996995807,
-0.6906687021,
-0.6927628517,
0.8117525578,
0.3359200358,
0.2918223143,
-0.0446439609,
0.2980934978,
0.2311131358,
0.6764692068,
-0.852208674,
0.2300903499,
-0.0497504473,
-0.5835801959,
-0.2351081371,
-0.6985147595,
-0.8553459644,
0.6098609567,
-0.1526374668,
-0.6922987103,
-0.052927494,
-0.0449282601,
-0.2557215989,
-0.1343028992,
-0.7918317318,
0.8630462885,
-0.4150066674,
-0.1380593181,
-0.3043079972,
-0.5590258241,
0.3367349505,
-0.0621449612,
0.4247832,
-0.2880345881,
-0.1765353531,
0.7140051723,
-0.3402690589,
0.6119738221,
0.1734932065,
0.0051929406,
0.3243946731,
0.0742193535,
-0.0483456776,
0.3542265296,
0.0138580808,
0.4132563472,
0.2851307094,
-0.3319870532,
-0.9390454292,
0.6503961682,
-0.7742850184,
-0.5873842835,
0.0269696899,
-0.6161330342,
-0.3931930065,
0.069541432,
0.1242173761,
0.3453077078,
-0.3836928904,
0.8246582747,
0.1161775365,
-0.296715498,
0.3512465656,
0.607405901,
0.0655920357,
-0.4889104664,
0.5162477493,
-0.1539315432,
0.3897885084,
0.4880835712,
0.1904767007,
-0.1686136574,
-0.1485610604,
-0.6569505334,
-0.1661300063,
-0.8745701313,
-0.3811732829,
-0.432492882,
-0.1172183007,
-0.0492168516,
0.0046520755,
-0.4483471811,
-0.3867333233,
-0.077436015,
0.0141918128,
-0.0819429904,
0.1016986668,
0.1611730307,
0.4228424132,
-1.1498106718,
-0.154668346,
0.1338554919,
0.2039622813,
-0.0946777388,
-0.7176037431,
-0.5410280824,
0.4317729771,
-0.2752991319,
-0.8683099151,
0.4451793432,
0.3093106151,
0.6030014753,
0.2173963934,
-0.098518461,
0.740005672,
-0.5492333174,
0.925347209,
0.1439915597,
-1.0265573263,
0.4268900454,
-0.2489551455,
0.406224221,
0.7758074999,
0.0872189924,
-0.9721176624,
-0.5585032105,
-0.3321641684,
-0.6145442724,
0.5040231347,
0.4859538078,
0.6884141564,
-0.1745073348,
0.5236405134,
-0.2089109123,
0.4200706184,
-0.6457791328,
-0.2805140316,
-0.1309976727,
0.1215897575,
-0.427269578,
-0.2190320194,
-0.1188452616,
-0.4730308056,
0.222912401,
-0.0996719897,
0.325964272,
0.2540372312,
-0.3604601324,
-0.0120674651,
0.4436330497,
0.6618167758,
0.758926034,
-0.1778705865,
-0.0998086855,
0.5369843245,
-0.0646253973,
0.0010667945,
-0.4490911365,
0.0191047154,
0.2013039142,
0.3738429546,
0.7948606014,
0.63786906,
-0.5120829344,
0.8020840287,
-0.2914513946,
0.0673274398,
-0.0939179808,
0.0810688287,
0.0702346414,
0.075280495,
0.2798098028,
0.1783382446,
0.1040416285,
-0.7474295497,
0.2670567334,
0.545107305,
-0.7388979793,
-0.286295414,
0.3348639905,
0.7438266873,
-0.3874903619,
0.5752997398,
-0.0173195899,
-0.5654324293,
0.4054734707,
0.4473452866,
0.7822592258,
-0.1914856881,
-0.0416641682,
0.4440662563,
0.2233504653,
0.2472778261,
-0.1525090784,
-0.3904608786,
-0.8668512702,
-0.6156806946,
-0.4686415195,
-0.5197664499,
-0.0450695083,
-0.3564004004,
0.2058689296,
0.1114745066,
-0.3446644843,
-0.4763168395,
-0.0098042162,
-0.7220267653,
0.1850257516,
0.0466772579,
0.8008242249,
-0.6847573519,
0.7592483163,
0.4516092539,
-0.2299916595,
-0.3048870265,
-0.0229059886,
-0.2167620659,
-0.4199241102,
0.6925317645,
0.3430962265,
-0.2169052511,
-0.2728567123,
-0.0835469738,
-1.0538400412,
1.0480792522,
0.2728326321,
-0.1555498093,
0.1245782673,
0.1022217795,
0.9840948582,
-0.5386924148,
0.6814691424,
0.5127258301,
0.3446027637,
-0.0383848138,
-1.2756689787,
-0.0731520876,
-0.4516057074,
0.03503526,
0.0327415504,
-0.6605088711,
0.3828190267,
0.0987866595,
-0.4399258494,
-0.061297629,
0.6489656568,
-0.3426225185,
0.1149243712,
0.5324625373,
0.1190332249,
0.5441125035,
-0.151979804,
0.9933615923,
-0.7141154408,
0.1498002708,
1.263146162,
0.0844385549,
1.0622282028,
0.5638164878,
0.1885378808,
0.5769135952,
0.4887056351,
0.3484110832,
0.3463068902,
-0.0199717842,
0.0544210859,
-0.0777839348,
-0.0351370387,
-0.2539651394,
0.6705390811,
0.5716725588,
-0.4511032403,
-0.3191922605,
0.0229583047,
0.0263376739,
-0.0219455939,
0.1889725626,
0.8330802917,
0.232135579,
-1.0555977821,
0.5976624489,
0.2555475235,
0.5515760779,
-0.2442879528,
0.2326306701,
-0.5122172236,
0.1380314827,
-0.220082894,
-0.6311399937,
0.8209526539,
-0.1354272366,
0.0078475084,
-0.3882487118,
0.4649166763,
-0.5326400995,
0.0204955228,
0.372032702,
0.9155443907,
0.2651560009,
-0.1121517792,
-0.6182799935,
-0.1349906474,
-0.3639021218,
-0.1747848392,
0.3885543644,
0.40289253,
-0.0913177505,
0.5693674684,
0.7194734812,
-0.2324488759,
-0.3422406912,
0.0143130273,
0.6093912125,
-0.6048362255,
-0.547778964,
-0.9796991944,
0.3735571504,
-0.1105084419,
-0.494497925,
0.9413253069,
0.5094262958,
0.8835636377,
0.1523031443,
0.3786115348,
0.2167411745,
0.3269541264,
-0.3986981213,
0.8269695044,
-0.6122277975,
0.2350353152,
-0.2210894376,
-0.9776731133,
-0.2835566998,
0.5407110453,
-0.4096876085,
-0.1226586029,
0.9165580273,
0.4336477816,
-0.073676236,
-0.095075354,
0.5679860115,
-0.1887364239,
0.2840797305,
0.5423367023,
0.9999883175,
-0.6543593407,
0.7600367665,
-0.0226073582,
-0.2556525171,
-0.3699057698,
-1.1060960293,
-0.9106994867,
-0.6487619281,
-0.1400958747,
-0.2647524476,
-0.1158085689,
0.7975203991,
0.9203687906,
-0.6252683997,
-0.4351643622,
0.1780119985,
0.1557156891,
-0.0949115381,
-0.2445125729,
0.1331133395,
-0.8417874575,
-0.766292274,
0.6447869539,
0.369022429,
-0.1126651317,
-0.1066857725,
-0.1868360937,
0.0558377802,
0.0655646771,
0.8524787426,
-0.0829704106,
-0.6342074871,
-0.4108943045,
-0.0358500667,
-0.5228254795,
0.3116878569,
0.7330310345,
-0.6102166772,
0.5618627667,
0.6786652207,
0.5914897323,
0.3380675614,
0.2127684802,
1.0312372446,
-0.9390138984,
0.3425267935,
-0.0069078845,
0.3752389848,
0.4903307259,
-0.3461746275,
0.4647049606,
0.1769003719,
-0.4829667211,
-0.5772362351,
-0.0705383793,
-0.4764442444,
-0.0792353898,
1.2272156477,
-0.2144194394,
-0.2781373262,
0.016882509,
-0.263772577,
0.1799879968,
-0.2170199007,
0.7883847952,
0.9942653179,
-0.0723647624,
-0.0508008227,
-0.806864202,
0.6507620811,
0.6470093727,
-0.8441039324,
-0.3179364204,
0.397521019,
0.193537876,
0.3032594025,
0.6711563468,
-0.0955166221,
0.319460839,
-0.4609642029,
-0.359744817,
0.2138383836,
-0.2310793996,
-0.1172941402,
-0.3126440644,
-0.0936546549,
-0.1638434976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08312v1
|
StreamingDialogue: Prolonged Dialogue Learning via Long Context Compression with Minimal Losses
| 2024-03-13T07:44:14 | 2024-03-13T07:44:14 |
Jia-Nan Li, Quan Tu, Cunli Mao, Zhengtao Yu, Ji-Rong Wen, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Standard Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle with handling dialogues with
long contexts due to efficiency and consistency issues. According to our
observation, dialogue contexts are highly structured, and the special token of
\textit{End-of-Utterance} (EoU) in dialogues has the potential to aggregate
information. We refer to the EoU tokens as ``conversational attention sinks''
(conv-attn sinks). Accordingly, we introduce StreamingDialogue, which
compresses long dialogue history into conv-attn sinks with minimal losses, and
thus reduces computational complexity quadratically with the number of sinks
(i.e., the number of utterances). Current LLMs already demonstrate the ability
to handle long context window, e.g., a window size of 200k or more. To this
end, by compressing utterances into EoUs, our method has the potential to
handle more than 200k of utterances, resulting in a prolonged dialogue
learning. In order to minimize information losses from reconstruction after
compression, we design two learning strategies of short-memory reconstruction
(SMR) and long-memory reactivation (LMR). Our method outperforms strong
baselines in dialogue tasks and achieves a 4 $\times$ speedup while reducing
memory usage by 18 $\times$ compared to dense attention recomputation.
|
[
-0.3874741793,
-0.9028910398,
0.5709739923,
-0.0662551522,
-0.5475516915,
0.290219903,
-0.4909715652,
-0.2613425553,
0.4471982419,
0.6197150946,
-0.6671584249,
-0.1550140232,
-0.5145728588,
-0.0195056032,
-0.2446046919,
0.788403213,
0.1922300756,
-0.1237158552,
-0.3342206776,
-0.227738291,
-0.4488338828,
-0.501911521,
-1.1767703295,
-0.2041012645,
0.517773211,
0.3305466771,
0.3242764771,
0.3264949024,
0.0623428412,
0.3746238649,
-0.251658529,
0.1985258758,
-1.2584700584,
0.3761028051,
0.3988126516,
-0.3531214893,
-0.0853195414,
-0.3369365335,
0.6416361332,
0.7811922431,
-0.3096805811,
0.1108374521,
0.3356384039,
0.7557599545,
-0.5897572041,
0.487454921,
-0.3822681606,
0.0327282026,
-0.025557138,
-0.6801977754,
-0.6219215989,
-0.12197759,
0.3755072653,
-0.5078449249,
0.0367495641,
0.1346104443,
0.4906803966,
0.6491052508,
-0.4551544785,
-0.0475340523,
-0.8326135278,
0.895767808,
-0.5869321823,
0.4857906103,
0.4007358849,
0.2719358206,
-0.1532561034,
-0.6464055777,
-0.3545345366,
-0.0448501222,
0.0999425724,
0.2989392281,
-0.0505353846,
0.3728078604,
0.4392870665,
0.2319805473,
-0.4343566895,
0.0338294059,
-0.4585323036,
-0.340662688,
0.2242092341,
0.2162910998,
-0.0213172231,
0.0203458313,
-0.4393599331,
0.206336543,
-0.8810109496,
0.2511748672,
0.1062038243,
0.0791643932,
-0.0508565903,
0.12525855,
-0.255045861,
0.5669082403,
-0.0640360788,
-0.4263469577,
0.0417175367,
-0.0408524573,
-0.3807154298,
0.1924327016,
0.6028416753,
0.4043464065,
-0.041283492,
0.0379458927,
-0.0060619097,
-0.1977673918,
0.1095736325,
-1.0130733252,
-0.1158293188,
0.1560993195,
-0.3503944278,
-0.074148573,
-0.6049879193,
-0.5537244678,
-0.1378289312,
-0.5753674507,
0.2538403869,
-0.238427788,
0.056489937,
0.0289688874,
0.0191267822,
0.1079505533,
0.6794033647,
-0.6636282206,
0.4809078872,
0.5283443332,
0.8987178802,
-0.2014725655,
0.1656421125,
-0.9170440435,
0.1775048077,
0.0636185482,
0.6477951407,
-0.4734918177,
-0.5843182802,
0.1285289079,
0.0326248929,
0.0862204134,
-0.5103800297,
0.4801851511,
-0.4140253067,
0.2902165949,
-0.0366604775,
-0.9050622582,
-0.4257494509,
0.0319742188,
-0.6179997921,
0.6780412793,
0.0125660319,
-0.4582801163,
0.0076493914,
-0.4010580778,
-0.3452955484,
0.1921585649,
-0.239597097,
-0.2760144472,
0.1336262971,
0.0955267847,
0.4952034652,
-0.2319245338,
0.1611233056,
-0.2018416077,
-0.4669429064,
0.0842793807,
-0.6546736956,
0.5591663718,
0.1803235859,
-0.2243646979,
-0.0670300126,
-0.3650079668,
-0.1956557781,
-0.111108765,
-0.4270133376,
-0.2337732911,
0.2841506898,
-0.0678234026,
-0.1167496517,
-0.164884761,
-0.5557714105,
0.0143559044,
-0.308880806,
0.8407633901,
0.8021800518,
-0.01669994,
0.3627040088,
-0.2418757677,
0.4470119774,
0.0742871761,
-0.0501166135,
-0.5403855443,
-0.2693215311,
-1.0626422167,
-0.4187018871,
0.1332487911,
0.4777591825,
-0.9014465213,
0.1854412109,
-0.6423433423,
0.0281858183,
-0.2048532814,
0.3674832284,
0.365038842,
0.7066076398,
0.2940470278,
-0.3992110789,
-0.4906686544,
-0.7723816633,
0.16211088,
-0.1197432056,
-0.0334047414,
0.7972996235,
0.0109807989,
-0.2225936353,
0.7901538014,
-0.6109467149,
-0.217501685,
-0.4465068579,
0.1829467416,
0.1748722196,
0.3231520057,
0.2940433025,
-0.617631197,
-0.442094326,
-0.4000205994,
-0.5970597267,
0.0876997635,
-0.3386498392,
-0.0739034191,
0.2843738794,
0.7436215878,
-0.8016043305,
0.4345411658,
0.6549289823,
0.0875191018,
0.2211519331,
-0.0003655712,
0.0663347393,
-1.1089327335,
-0.269333154,
-0.1626213342,
-0.8709836006,
-0.7002527118,
-0.2827774286,
-0.1386959553,
-0.5287847519,
-0.6998186111,
0.6398937106,
-0.4609097242,
0.1952136457,
-0.2940494716,
0.2636318207,
-0.0841351151,
0.9748846292,
0.3010756373,
0.7386883497,
0.3670574725,
-0.7268971801,
0.4200628102,
0.051352784,
-0.363071084,
0.2056944966,
-0.5854690671,
0.3758400679,
-0.3372647166,
0.8324763775,
-1.094438076,
-0.1359077096,
0.0573596954,
-0.3462779522,
0.5964593887,
-0.2368689924,
0.0203980599,
-0.0470775701,
-0.3445796072,
0.7055984735,
0.6953148246,
-0.6368908286,
0.7044073939,
0.4222638309,
-0.6129190326,
-0.5042135715,
-0.3726098239,
0.0886768922,
-0.3585468531,
-0.5229548216,
0.2202773541,
-0.1957895756,
0.0386518873,
-0.3512717187,
-0.1579754204,
0.0052098935,
-0.0940020159,
0.3118956089,
0.1767435968,
-0.0745766684,
0.1955584288,
0.0231650956,
-0.1771157533,
-0.0764701292,
-0.2283448577,
0.6718300581,
0.1403850615,
-0.0135542583,
-0.5635390282,
0.5102387667,
0.4581044614,
0.23514916,
0.6183709502,
0.3734264672,
-0.2703502774,
-0.0626167879,
-0.7233195305,
-0.2731320262,
-0.4924416244,
0.3144802153,
-0.2092097998,
-1.4017385244,
0.4806280434,
-0.2883323729,
0.1920040548,
0.0189508554,
0.3293523192,
-0.3845667541,
0.7450247407,
0.4309729934,
-0.4422891736,
0.7830886245,
-0.460916996,
0.2909033,
-0.9870447516,
0.1064159796,
-0.2060503364,
-0.3366372883,
-0.2493352294,
-0.6849202514,
0.373627305,
-0.0502220429,
-0.1511256695,
0.138186574,
-0.0302810837,
0.5559253693,
0.2778763175,
0.4100913703,
0.0720931366,
0.1220800281,
0.3789629638,
-0.0884420425,
-0.6718502641,
-0.1982147396,
0.877571404,
0.4200722873,
0.8455631733,
0.1744456738,
0.8560785055,
0.3640038669,
0.0133553855,
-1.1605631113,
0.7206814289,
0.079607293,
-0.2026447505,
-0.4378880262,
-0.6549502015,
-1.0547300577,
0.0339088552,
0.2257244885,
-0.8564363718,
-0.1438927501,
0.315618068,
-0.6588824391,
0.0521269217,
-0.7313681245,
0.4291404784,
0.0322278142,
-0.6294330359,
-0.5644040108,
-0.716491282,
0.2477386445,
0.1816992611,
0.1770716757,
-0.0728079975,
-0.0270467885,
0.6292225122,
-0.4668823183,
0.965354383,
-0.2619521022,
0.0881331265,
0.3968533278,
0.1305693239,
0.5285156369,
0.2775536776,
0.5330008864,
-0.114981778,
-0.2538684905,
-0.500631392,
-0.6918506026,
0.6471309662,
-0.6068694592,
-0.6304828525,
-0.2725159228,
-0.2354646027,
-0.1857686043,
-0.1604422033,
0.1414697766,
1.0759135485,
-0.2525893748,
0.4989670813,
1.057464838,
-0.2232666314,
0.6847398281,
0.2274801582,
-0.1492914557,
-0.3489089012,
0.9562020898,
-0.0640353635,
0.4047637284,
0.4394668639,
0.0342269428,
-0.2831307054,
-0.4523003101,
-0.3112963736,
0.2150614411,
-0.6551064849,
-0.360147655,
-0.5835771561,
-0.3164952099,
-0.1057086214,
-0.1466619819,
-0.3577739,
-0.3544372618,
-0.3155251443,
-0.1097368523,
0.1909745783,
0.2032143623,
0.2247983366,
0.3250081241,
-0.9795826077,
0.4064959586,
0.541449666,
0.049015414,
-0.0166691393,
-0.6929981112,
-0.3385842741,
0.0849217772,
-0.2575322688,
-0.5708618164,
0.4207072556,
0.5826495886,
0.4481666088,
0.7030810714,
0.0097194053,
0.8944201469,
-0.5652628541,
0.9533587694,
0.4005051553,
-0.7997375727,
0.2867943645,
-0.3726787865,
0.6342172027,
0.5790246725,
0.3479315639,
-0.7065722942,
-0.2573872805,
-0.5187442899,
-1.0318226814,
0.4292934239,
0.2334848344,
0.4205605686,
-0.044730708,
0.2355956584,
0.1291053593,
0.2206796557,
-0.4720235169,
-0.0917769894,
0.0325286947,
-0.027691368,
-0.4238660038,
-0.4728765786,
-0.2001937628,
-0.3127565086,
0.7100511789,
-0.3188939393,
0.6111108661,
0.2282360345,
-0.5000104308,
0.2865223587,
0.1911385357,
0.8396834135,
0.3987925947,
-0.2274498045,
0.0115892105,
0.2130418867,
-0.4094416201,
0.0384835042,
-0.1444210857,
-0.0326421149,
0.0411282293,
0.2338579744,
1.1711616516,
0.6645099521,
-0.7963413596,
0.3659632802,
-0.3498501182,
-0.1209645048,
-0.6988956928,
-0.1403294951,
0.1515641361,
0.0922747105,
0.3374310434,
-0.1183049232,
0.3441522717,
-0.6905205846,
0.0388655216,
0.2190333754,
-0.3505047262,
-0.0339769982,
0.3054323196,
0.8366818428,
-0.2133868933,
0.8290855885,
-0.0715813041,
-0.5827830434,
0.1727384627,
0.2585995495,
0.9021393657,
-0.1178347766,
-0.0000846994,
0.3809675574,
-0.3024834692,
0.0152632557,
-0.0220155884,
-0.6607493162,
-0.5695642233,
-0.7205321193,
-0.5456818342,
-0.4021010101,
0.2431594878,
-0.6408805847,
-0.0288475677,
-0.370677352,
-0.2369283587,
-0.3040038049,
-0.0919677243,
-0.596793294,
-0.0454105809,
0.4156938195,
0.7815952301,
-0.4081988633,
0.7308551073,
0.1424653679,
0.0632136315,
-0.4567030966,
-0.2759766281,
0.2273919731,
-0.6094689965,
0.519973278,
0.5359460711,
-0.5034647584,
0.1687532961,
-0.6505427957,
-0.8406591415,
0.9887895584,
0.2592055798,
-0.9397190213,
-0.0867943168,
-0.1135511175,
0.2832599878,
-0.3716455996,
0.3356034458,
0.5774520636,
0.0248328242,
0.2097981721,
-0.8423653245,
-0.21515432,
-0.0579337552,
-0.0063531683,
0.4019689858,
-0.8698517084,
0.2630300224,
0.0114102932,
-0.3880080283,
0.1105186716,
0.7127131224,
-0.0674782544,
0.2710878551,
0.6024827957,
0.6444007158,
0.6502090693,
-0.1925968826,
0.9237456322,
-0.1670714766,
0.294894129,
1.2853373289,
-0.0713817328,
0.9965798855,
0.7523896694,
-0.0118328203,
0.3827439249,
0.7101070285,
0.589945972,
0.6233303547,
0.2919867933,
-0.6550279856,
-0.4134711325,
-0.2340982556,
-0.0422770567,
0.3838580251,
0.60687536,
-0.1273468733,
0.0452639237,
0.2713974416,
0.1523133367,
-0.2119856328,
-0.3184036314,
1.078856349,
0.3692856431,
-0.7257542014,
0.8342084885,
-0.6727903485,
0.6083759665,
-0.5953111649,
0.0642094389,
-0.4221955836,
0.088752225,
0.0380195044,
-0.3352934122,
0.0158314221,
-0.2194920927,
0.0060229762,
-0.3516573012,
0.4515263736,
-0.6414914727,
-0.1568985432,
0.2436586767,
0.4159249961,
0.3544196486,
0.0464617684,
-0.4951025844,
0.2483274788,
0.1868249625,
-0.460403651,
0.3736358285,
0.0769298151,
0.3524117172,
0.9315120578,
0.4809521437,
-0.1629266292,
0.0044981535,
0.2435454875,
1.0341155529,
-0.6630630493,
-0.4462408423,
-0.6011819243,
0.4990535378,
-0.2654663324,
-0.0487259217,
0.3511233926,
0.7004548907,
0.8080644011,
0.0949429646,
0.6987258792,
0.1781636178,
0.4621347189,
-0.8656730056,
0.3202416599,
-0.4743511975,
0.0464464314,
0.1049915105,
-0.9183471799,
0.0708696991,
0.4916425943,
0.0028470517,
-0.2393962592,
0.8712816238,
0.6443905234,
-0.050331831,
0.0855648294,
0.3887557983,
0.1491621435,
0.3699499965,
0.9311215281,
0.9256786108,
-0.2738150656,
0.5762883425,
-0.1579492688,
-0.1861735731,
-0.4259171784,
-0.7165272236,
-0.9925311208,
-0.5090628266,
-0.4009845853,
-0.1801141053,
0.144090876,
1.0306705236,
0.9281459451,
-0.4866263866,
-0.4447311461,
0.0654637069,
-0.1396816373,
-0.0106962174,
-0.1856007576,
0.161597997,
-0.4203535914,
-0.8508472443,
0.5324947834,
0.4054347873,
0.0554943606,
-0.2240378559,
-0.3366759419,
0.0195886642,
0.178154394,
0.8860833645,
0.4799339771,
-0.6424891949,
-0.4124170542,
-0.2087874413,
0.065889746,
0.2196460962,
1.0961279869,
-0.9349224567,
0.6172770262,
0.5259016752,
0.7390087843,
1.036932826,
0.1191910431,
0.6971936226,
-0.6356852055,
0.4900046885,
0.3280814886,
0.557258904,
0.2661787271,
-0.2365968525,
0.3802865148,
0.0945867077,
-0.8005107045,
-0.7697427273,
0.3115321994,
-1.3427494764,
-0.2026848495,
1.1042164564,
-0.2768285871,
-0.2490897626,
-0.2059198767,
-0.4365965724,
0.2734222412,
-0.7857548594,
0.6923906207,
0.6934625506,
-0.3103466928,
-0.5344834924,
-0.728417635,
0.7357506156,
0.5125054121,
-0.5619537234,
0.1507696807,
0.7363274693,
0.1231261939,
-0.0178725366,
0.7322456241,
0.3359608352,
0.2856357396,
-0.2033700198,
-0.4562476575,
0.0466135368,
-0.4021757543,
-0.2138869464,
0.0067703039,
-0.1778513193,
-0.0072010229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08305v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08305v1
|
Towards Personalized Evaluation of Large Language Models with An Anonymous Crowd-Sourcing Platform
| 2024-03-13T07:31:20 | 2024-03-13T07:31:20 |
Mingyue Cheng, Hao Zhang, Jiqian Yang, Qi Liu, Li Li, Xin Huang, Liwei Song, Zhi Li, Zhenya Huang, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language model evaluation plays a pivotal role in the enhancement of
its capacity. Previously, numerous methods for evaluating large language models
have been proposed in this area. Despite their effectiveness, these existing
works mainly focus on assessing objective questions, overlooking the capability
to evaluate subjective questions which is extremely common for large language
models. Additionally, these methods predominantly utilize centralized datasets
for evaluation, with question banks concentrated within the evaluation
platforms themselves. Moreover, the evaluation processes employed by these
platforms often overlook personalized factors, neglecting to consider the
individual characteristics of both the evaluators and the models being
evaluated. To address these limitations, we propose a novel anonymous
crowd-sourcing evaluation platform, BingJian, for large language models that
employs a competitive scoring mechanism where users participate in ranking
models based on their performance. This platform stands out not only for its
support of centralized evaluations to assess the general capabilities of models
but also for offering an open evaluation gateway. Through this gateway, users
have the opportunity to submit their questions, testing the models on a
personalized and potentially broader range of capabilities. Furthermore, our
platform introduces personalized evaluation scenarios, leveraging various forms
of human-computer interaction to assess large language models in a manner that
accounts for individual user preferences and contexts. The demonstration of
BingJian can be accessed at https://github.com/Mingyue-Cheng/Bingjian.
|
[
-0.3903467953,
-0.6051298976,
0.4586083293,
0.4799205661,
-0.0915288329,
0.3223644197,
-0.8421447277,
-0.3326977789,
0.2011836469,
0.6450811028,
-0.3482718766,
-0.7161106467,
-0.2573255897,
0.0145823574,
-0.3759843409,
0.9330300093,
0.2344630957,
0.0684269518,
-0.1883781105,
-0.4094982147,
-0.3622871935,
-0.4116640687,
-0.7342290878,
0.1172693148,
0.3848695457,
0.3237501383,
0.5697479248,
0.4019652903,
0.3260258734,
0.4220406413,
0.1032643914,
-0.0493879505,
-0.5947163105,
0.3246691525,
-0.5093994141,
-0.1425962597,
-0.2032132,
0.0447574407,
0.7148430347,
0.8308057189,
-0.2312067002,
0.7504954338,
0.139365539,
0.5415395498,
-0.7419406176,
0.1902482212,
-0.7609364986,
-0.1766947061,
-0.3902976513,
0.1050116792,
-0.5709162951,
-0.565077126,
0.3078877926,
-0.3809792399,
-0.0037731181,
0.1494996548,
0.6485384703,
-0.168181926,
-0.254904449,
-0.2527675629,
-0.6419620514,
0.6642224193,
-0.5775732398,
0.3347526491,
0.4569358528,
0.7192198038,
0.1762750298,
-0.745208323,
-0.3178817332,
-0.8086542487,
-0.0379246511,
0.0586769953,
-0.3933946788,
-0.1162728146,
-0.2055945545,
0.2127408087,
-0.8707607388,
0.255055666,
-0.259131968,
-0.1825793982,
0.6192781329,
0.1833738983,
0.2513872087,
-0.1627776325,
-0.2764947712,
0.2025505453,
-0.1836037636,
0.099791646,
0.6825788617,
0.5237852931,
-0.0285004713,
0.3603509068,
-0.5298550725,
0.8809423447,
0.2519235611,
0.2791313529,
0.2362205386,
-0.1458247155,
-0.1176634952,
-0.0832996666,
0.8815088272,
0.0201080032,
0.1028000042,
-0.328979224,
-0.2371764183,
-0.4321638644,
0.0979671404,
-0.820720315,
-0.1810965836,
0.2358308882,
-0.8006972075,
-0.6446985006,
0.228044495,
-0.8255278468,
-0.7434549928,
-0.1659064591,
0.3948706686,
0.0849435851,
-0.3301842511,
0.084981218,
-0.0331463479,
-0.2221743166,
0.4709079862,
-0.8095128536,
0.5701532364,
0.7162854671,
0.9227902293,
-0.1695400178,
-0.2648312151,
-1.106064558,
-0.0974431038,
-0.3076947033,
0.5677517056,
-1.0382676125,
-0.1269291341,
0.0307759382,
-0.0510803461,
0.1785886139,
-0.6933375001,
0.4057975113,
-0.7164940834,
0.2903173566,
-0.2937991619,
-0.2827287316,
-0.1343756169,
0.2897147834,
-0.6687676311,
0.7083899975,
0.1008495241,
-0.5611471534,
0.1886575371,
-0.7743184566,
-0.1273967624,
0.6685110927,
-0.1446590573,
-0.0139767528,
0.0280025527,
0.1796548814,
0.552965939,
-0.4767608047,
0.623229444,
-0.73454386,
-0.3681276441,
0.3299996257,
-0.4531199336,
0.9370750189,
0.3319621682,
-0.6026149392,
0.6711227298,
-0.8272894621,
0.0850705877,
0.1106970757,
-0.4303662479,
-0.6153547168,
-0.1812709868,
0.4836067259,
0.02888822,
0.5613709688,
-0.4654977918,
0.1826209575,
-0.4033512771,
0.3391545713,
1.2439988852,
-0.1442389041,
0.2571166456,
0.089725852,
0.6470341086,
-0.4174245,
0.1980058104,
-0.0467606373,
-0.3825352192,
-0.6955009103,
-0.0385045484,
0.4480959475,
0.3023276031,
-0.372889787,
0.5658451319,
-0.3120695651,
-0.7959153056,
-0.677906394,
0.4000265002,
0.405847311,
0.2230750471,
0.0162050352,
-0.3414381444,
-0.4451300502,
-0.8664817214,
-0.3431505263,
-0.2232858986,
-0.2314549834,
0.6602225304,
0.3456236422,
0.0073293871,
0.8382217288,
-0.4931288362,
-0.2260908037,
-0.3410383761,
0.0181018896,
0.1338806599,
0.3383384943,
0.3632720709,
-0.6987352371,
-0.7428774238,
0.4187465906,
-0.4771362841,
-0.3657939434,
-0.0486870706,
-0.2277799994,
-0.148650527,
0.3311715722,
-0.3897272348,
-0.0834851637,
0.9553678632,
-0.4526780844,
0.8368245363,
-0.0622517616,
0.1444709003,
-1.0543295145,
0.5680546165,
-0.0204510503,
-0.4093294442,
-0.3340983093,
0.4625450075,
-0.1342636049,
-0.430547893,
-0.2368295342,
1.0086764097,
-0.2729427814,
-0.2114955485,
-0.1145010591,
0.6140657067,
-0.1145406365,
0.2961959541,
-0.136896044,
0.5689390302,
0.5098376274,
-0.2111082971,
0.6482796669,
0.0884135589,
-0.7409095764,
0.3234714568,
-0.8636507392,
0.4222350121,
0.1586319357,
0.3577103317,
-0.8888580799,
-0.3117448986,
0.2534546852,
-0.4293853939,
-0.0573940091,
-0.2368385196,
-0.2725511789,
-0.2218289971,
-0.3253238797,
0.2039214522,
0.2858044803,
-0.7748154998,
0.2503296137,
0.4438528419,
-0.2834101915,
-0.5807790756,
-0.3759818375,
0.5528032184,
-0.2606936097,
-0.8788756132,
0.0632946342,
-0.202496171,
-0.5311620831,
0.0621142723,
0.2588686943,
-0.083770521,
0.2045099437,
0.1285084039,
0.1023593396,
-0.2652610838,
0.1755094081,
0.0079496568,
-0.0591916479,
-0.1334497184,
-0.595605433,
0.7799146771,
-0.4875983,
-0.2407188118,
-0.3612285554,
0.144788608,
0.4820521772,
-0.8020499945,
0.6626284122,
0.8674889803,
-0.3235456645,
-0.3740486205,
-0.8465447426,
0.0951682255,
-0.5506504774,
0.6075935364,
-0.1753420979,
-1.1930346489,
0.4559844434,
-0.0439854749,
-0.049456995,
0.257640928,
1.0563929081,
0.4166334569,
1.0430939198,
0.4959249794,
-0.3192592263,
0.1888988167,
0.0750186965,
-0.0283767842,
-0.676163435,
-0.2081372589,
-0.7169248462,
-0.2244029492,
-0.4599091113,
-0.3948476613,
0.280157268,
-0.1339760721,
-0.30656299,
0.1582134217,
-0.3654162884,
0.4901376367,
0.5545938015,
-0.0342328437,
0.4028466642,
-0.148107484,
-0.1388481557,
0.1442198753,
-0.2674926221,
-0.6435480118,
0.9874470234,
0.3415389657,
0.6839575171,
0.1555936635,
0.5613332391,
0.5086312294,
0.4468924999,
-0.6323388815,
0.6567923427,
-0.1952279359,
-0.7208153605,
-0.4922191501,
-0.6340606809,
-0.9985687733,
0.3992037177,
0.0042119073,
-1.04251194,
-0.0469961949,
-0.0771724433,
-0.4268966913,
0.2264017761,
-0.7501935363,
1.1001501083,
-0.3333517313,
-0.3705907166,
-0.364671737,
-0.4319739044,
0.5903390646,
-0.1949409992,
0.149149552,
-0.0041720965,
-0.1160320342,
0.6424684525,
-0.4445702434,
0.8258309364,
-0.4126771688,
0.2070722133,
0.1682387441,
0.3133164942,
0.5832856297,
0.2606570423,
-0.3880385458,
0.3066589236,
-0.2624790072,
-0.2190520018,
-0.6851650476,
1.2226576805,
-0.6623846292,
-0.6804847717,
-0.0105806645,
-0.0972110033,
-0.4437968731,
0.4147745967,
-0.057556279,
0.2849602699,
-0.3817285001,
0.4255083501,
0.085077852,
-0.5898962617,
0.2140201628,
0.6333332062,
-0.589269042,
-0.4886128604,
0.9868696332,
-0.1630594879,
0.0400598645,
0.2637257278,
0.70860219,
-0.2355059981,
-0.5059505701,
-0.6714212298,
-0.0000960307,
-0.7124390006,
0.0925895423,
-0.5947485566,
0.215127781,
-0.4437533021,
-0.091284588,
-0.472181797,
-0.166617915,
0.1273840368,
-0.1189860031,
-0.0995132923,
0.5854782462,
0.130772531,
-0.1666608155,
-0.8209758997,
0.0150301596,
0.430313617,
0.6713922024,
0.4690153301,
-0.3963322341,
-0.2508616745,
-0.1084501669,
-0.0142084239,
-0.5847837329,
0.1618456095,
0.0907867327,
0.5274367332,
0.7130483389,
0.0073353988,
0.7075300217,
-0.3951815367,
0.757417798,
0.0373449214,
-1.3025619984,
0.3541297317,
-0.4652543962,
0.0992005989,
0.847200036,
0.2356985211,
-0.8642439842,
-0.3970338702,
-0.2175740004,
-0.6637252569,
0.7306845784,
0.1527211815,
0.3959388137,
0.2609700561,
0.1058695912,
0.3802615702,
0.2962547839,
-0.8645705581,
-0.0029604211,
-0.0095026642,
-0.0755971074,
-0.1459451616,
-0.0523281209,
0.0579870977,
-0.1574190408,
0.5661736727,
-0.0235765502,
-0.3849947751,
-0.2131469399,
-0.0849465728,
-0.1399298012,
0.1901930869,
0.3161443174,
0.7551175356,
-0.2087780684,
-0.164444074,
0.0848027542,
-0.3763965666,
-0.09734191,
0.1323194057,
-0.2774623334,
0.0316293277,
0.2657163739,
0.7965441942,
0.1373399645,
-1.1006456614,
0.7131071091,
-0.1646375507,
0.1507317275,
-0.4860733747,
-0.1701776832,
0.2623166442,
0.308347851,
0.3399212658,
0.1255806834,
0.3582837284,
-0.3361826539,
-0.0408306681,
0.321359694,
-0.5775766969,
-0.4156251848,
0.6981527209,
0.4489326775,
-0.2785491943,
0.6014249921,
-0.2669989169,
-0.3247016966,
0.3118683696,
0.2886927426,
1.2824760675,
-0.4163987935,
0.5057277083,
0.3265243173,
0.3462621272,
0.2216119468,
-0.248355642,
-0.1875974983,
-0.3673822582,
-0.3061555624,
-0.8090043068,
-0.3596743345,
0.5470166206,
-0.5009902716,
0.5617629886,
-0.5270909667,
0.0930567905,
-0.0997171402,
-0.0567312166,
-0.4644704759,
0.0203815419,
0.312476337,
0.8437585235,
-0.4020145535,
0.6117638946,
0.7229114771,
-0.2461592704,
-0.6301429272,
0.1388469934,
-0.1108149067,
-0.7048597336,
0.7179579139,
0.3170843422,
-0.1142011136,
-0.2239557803,
-0.4774330556,
-0.8558690548,
0.7556730509,
0.4801781178,
-0.5418651104,
0.129365921,
0.0161830392,
0.6498543024,
-0.2853989601,
0.3771694005,
0.2273104042,
0.7150776386,
-0.2251169086,
-0.9967204928,
0.2596927285,
-0.5347157717,
-0.0297683291,
-0.1480475515,
-0.9262353182,
0.6504276991,
-0.1489613652,
-0.1285911351,
0.2322626561,
0.39762941,
0.1886980981,
0.3078273237,
0.7491432428,
0.1460989714,
0.8579064608,
0.3486699462,
1.0159034729,
-0.4043196738,
0.4718976021,
1.1971555948,
-0.4602939785,
0.9963728189,
-0.0619688854,
-0.177743718,
0.5187430382,
0.5557370782,
-0.2294293642,
0.3185172379,
0.5303214192,
-0.1801586598,
-0.4066640437,
-0.0882117227,
-0.2194488794,
0.8526157737,
-0.0183622148,
-0.3678258955,
-0.2633538246,
0.0594957471,
0.028512273,
0.2071776986,
-0.318616271,
0.4460442066,
-0.2256243676,
-0.6231959462,
0.4230860174,
0.6085675359,
0.5247458816,
-0.7955934405,
0.145738706,
-0.2242545336,
0.1118496656,
-0.17985484,
-0.302410394,
0.0473487079,
0.2790793478,
0.1820477545,
-0.169803977,
0.7831431031,
-0.3613847196,
-0.5393455625,
0.3100158274,
0.3543676734,
0.1554535627,
-0.4726555347,
-0.8019334674,
0.2359138876,
-0.1087809056,
-0.5188131928,
0.4726738036,
0.0607133396,
-0.2233091593,
0.8425806761,
0.8093025088,
0.0280361939,
-0.2557671666,
0.3905425668,
0.772108376,
-0.435444206,
-0.7602022886,
-0.8734354973,
0.2753338814,
-0.1621957123,
-0.5478444099,
1.0287774801,
0.8967034221,
0.828448534,
-0.1922299117,
1.147628665,
0.0208372138,
0.5453463793,
-0.1827836186,
1.1234984398,
-0.5231080651,
0.2837487459,
-0.5982548594,
-0.969260633,
-0.0905811265,
0.335344404,
-0.390089184,
0.2350133657,
0.289629072,
0.5654088855,
-0.0453699753,
-0.1078261212,
0.4542475939,
0.4815294445,
0.516509831,
0.3095678687,
0.8967418075,
0.0983660668,
0.7599079609,
-0.240732491,
-0.538387537,
-0.3071994185,
-0.6343111396,
-0.9953058958,
-0.7705236673,
-0.090222545,
-0.2825546265,
0.0019146268,
1.2383493185,
0.812658608,
-0.8342375159,
-0.6383209229,
0.155592829,
-0.0274525397,
-0.041073665,
-0.349768579,
0.4879471064,
-0.2181750834,
-0.9719852805,
0.4977183938,
0.5393424034,
-0.6002579331,
-0.856362164,
-0.0147713656,
0.1789868772,
-0.009695773,
0.5679855347,
0.063943617,
-0.7392050028,
-0.1281414479,
0.1122686416,
-0.0355154239,
-0.4392805696,
0.8023669124,
-0.8452330232,
0.7916107178,
0.3130346835,
0.8188056946,
0.3515021205,
0.1930084974,
0.4819092155,
-0.4240733683,
0.0487001538,
0.3654003739,
0.1441777796,
0.3959343135,
-0.3966319561,
0.2403775901,
0.1542426944,
-0.4234339893,
-0.9093014598,
-0.0738648027,
-0.9209215641,
-0.2813077271,
1.3178120852,
-0.4890722632,
0.0293375403,
-0.0671593994,
-0.3355960548,
-0.2035954297,
-0.4338710308,
1.1397451162,
0.8625907898,
0.3100842237,
0.345299542,
-0.6710042357,
0.0976087451,
0.2433226109,
-0.8349934816,
0.3321873844,
0.431545645,
0.3459011316,
0.0095133716,
0.5656767488,
-0.0686274916,
0.1477413625,
-0.171301648,
-0.1558700204,
-0.2075915039,
-0.0857911408,
-0.3707589209,
0.4766886532,
0.0858721659,
-0.0371741839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08295v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08295v4
|
Gemma: Open Models Based on Gemini Research and Technology
| 2024-03-13T06:59:16 | 2024-04-16T12:52:47 |
Gemma Team, Thomas Mesnard, Cassidy Hardin, Robert Dadashi, Surya Bhupatiraju, Shreya Pathak, Laurent Sifre, Morgane Rivière, Mihir Sanjay Kale, Juliette Love, Pouya Tafti, Léonard Hussenot, Pier Giuseppe Sessa, Aakanksha Chowdhery, Adam Roberts, Aditya Barua, Alex Botev, Alex Castro-Ros, Ambrose Slone, Amélie Héliou, Andrea Tacchetti, Anna Bulanova, Antonia Paterson, Beth Tsai, Bobak Shahriari, Charline Le Lan, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Clément Crepy, Daniel Cer, Daphne Ippolito, David Reid, Elena Buchatskaya, Eric Ni, Eric Noland, Geng Yan, George Tucker, George-Christian Muraru, Grigory Rozhdestvenskiy, Henryk Michalewski, Ian Tenney, Ivan Grishchenko, Jacob Austin, James Keeling, Jane Labanowski, Jean-Baptiste Lespiau, Jeff Stanway, Jenny Brennan, Jeremy Chen, Johan Ferret, Justin Chiu, Justin Mao-Jones, Katherine Lee, Kathy Yu, Katie Millican, Lars Lowe Sjoesund, Lisa Lee, Lucas Dixon, Machel Reid, Maciej Mikuła, Mateo Wirth, Michael Sharman, Nikolai Chinaev, Nithum Thain, Olivier Bachem, Oscar Chang, Oscar Wahltinez, Paige Bailey, Paul Michel, Petko Yotov, Rahma Chaabouni, Ramona Comanescu, Reena Jana, Rohan Anil, Ross McIlroy, Ruibo Liu, Ryan Mullins, Samuel L Smith, Sebastian Borgeaud, Sertan Girgin, Sholto Douglas, Shree Pandya, Siamak Shakeri, Soham De, Ted Klimenko, Tom Hennigan, Vlad Feinberg, Wojciech Stokowiec, Yu-hui Chen, Zafarali Ahmed, Zhitao Gong, Tris Warkentin, Ludovic Peran, Minh Giang, Clément Farabet, Oriol Vinyals, Jeff Dean, Koray Kavukcuoglu, Demis Hassabis, Zoubin Ghahramani, Douglas Eck, Joelle Barral, Fernando Pereira, Eli Collins, Armand Joulin, Noah Fiedel, Evan Senter, Alek Andreev, Kathleen Kenealy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This work introduces Gemma, a family of lightweight, state-of-the art open
models built from the research and technology used to create Gemini models.
Gemma models demonstrate strong performance across academic benchmarks for
language understanding, reasoning, and safety. We release two sizes of models
(2 billion and 7 billion parameters), and provide both pretrained and
fine-tuned checkpoints. Gemma outperforms similarly sized open models on 11 out
of 18 text-based tasks, and we present comprehensive evaluations of safety and
responsibility aspects of the models, alongside a detailed description of model
development. We believe the responsible release of LLMs is critical for
improving the safety of frontier models, and for enabling the next wave of LLM
innovations.
|
[
-0.0859769508,
-0.8411915302,
0.466278553,
0.3799551129,
0.0474115424,
-0.3956613839,
-0.0542802401,
-0.6518769264,
0.2533850074,
0.618226707,
-0.3858692944,
-0.5242087841,
-0.8522760868,
-0.1017470434,
-0.6736705303,
0.9222488999,
-0.1172209457,
0.4544223845,
-0.1819925904,
0.0738075525,
-0.2441624105,
-0.4235136509,
-0.8215600848,
-0.2544161379,
0.6302111745,
0.3289716542,
1.2974010706,
0.6571369171,
0.9458072186,
0.1783382744,
-0.527494967,
0.1711486429,
-0.5990710855,
-0.1970108896,
-0.2929242253,
-0.4842399657,
-0.6968173385,
0.21121189,
0.5206025243,
0.5796724558,
-0.1302369088,
0.3469463289,
0.1365334094,
0.3686240911,
-0.951392591,
0.2035673559,
-0.4311151505,
0.1122254878,
-0.3793343008,
-0.0491772965,
-0.6935644746,
-0.2542995214,
-0.1495925784,
-0.7489106655,
0.1866742969,
0.0828209296,
0.8223996758,
0.2760224044,
-0.4786919057,
-0.3425995409,
-0.7852200866,
0.7264328599,
-0.430939436,
0.1298750192,
0.1153922901,
0.4605444074,
-0.5406635404,
-1.3106514215,
-0.2629651725,
-0.3412593603,
0.1367269158,
0.1111098081,
0.0013105787,
0.0377426334,
-0.3072510362,
0.5764663219,
-0.2432848066,
0.2981821299,
-0.6412833333,
-0.0029242826,
0.5228191614,
0.6038917899,
0.2906633615,
0.3354818821,
-0.4967666268,
0.074805893,
-1.13798666,
-0.2213784903,
0.2239225656,
0.363191843,
-0.4150049984,
1.0294786692,
-0.0341777503,
0.615147233,
0.065324232,
-0.1612107307,
-0.206107229,
-0.2445805371,
-0.3887860775,
-0.1170085296,
0.8895049691,
0.0502013452,
0.0730478317,
-0.2650160491,
0.0619117208,
-0.0570357405,
0.5730435252,
-0.9508724809,
-0.1202237681,
0.3802489638,
-0.8426682353,
-0.6154447198,
0.0744778886,
-0.4563502073,
-0.4664047658,
-0.0456790254,
0.7497366071,
-0.3347717524,
-0.4688756168,
0.6484958529,
0.0776431859,
0.1704598218,
0.4902387857,
-1.1908324957,
0.4811166823,
0.791375041,
0.9033567905,
-0.149352327,
-0.3201024234,
-0.4733177125,
0.1516919881,
-0.6594769955,
0.3378844261,
-0.4139093459,
-0.8983057141,
-0.0529613569,
-0.0656353459,
-0.1224060282,
-0.4402241111,
0.5859071612,
-0.5256683826,
0.1181313396,
-0.1345309317,
-0.2661766708,
-0.0198922958,
0.1783447415,
-0.6600653529,
1.1900829077,
0.0750260949,
-0.989582479,
0.4016851187,
-0.8963152766,
0.0102674151,
0.0275949556,
-0.044151213,
-0.215119943,
0.2543022931,
0.0359511152,
0.4384394288,
-0.5772053003,
0.3598736823,
-0.2871191502,
-0.3086036146,
0.1933561116,
-0.3891364634,
1.0198594332,
0.5668718815,
-0.1774350703,
0.4836167693,
-0.5158806443,
-0.2668057382,
0.1838105023,
-0.3784959316,
0.151808545,
0.0326630324,
0.1277098209,
0.1418390721,
0.6480162144,
-0.6764013767,
-0.1068735197,
-0.070749402,
0.3287094533,
0.3826233447,
-0.2872328758,
0.2516909838,
-0.4258842766,
0.5310422778,
0.2199407816,
0.7163065672,
-0.160403356,
-0.9198963642,
-0.7467275262,
-0.6496869326,
0.2625949681,
0.2195799202,
-0.3543775976,
0.2382726073,
-0.0350307114,
-0.8253469467,
-0.6714743376,
-0.157191366,
0.5338288546,
0.3735940158,
0.351498872,
-0.41254282,
-0.0245258287,
-0.7049139142,
-0.077256687,
-0.3991158009,
0.0557910874,
0.1726873666,
0.5260975957,
-0.3280075788,
0.9753315449,
-0.46701473,
-0.0657157749,
-0.3141993284,
0.0316797011,
0.0611516237,
0.4219361246,
0.6685877442,
-0.793219924,
-0.0415878668,
0.0035633771,
-1.0756891966,
0.3934890032,
0.2177018672,
-0.1275354326,
0.0010777494,
0.4885616601,
-0.9296187758,
0.5319648385,
0.6777466536,
-0.5863493681,
0.6709141731,
-0.3671030998,
-0.0342428163,
-1.283921957,
0.0866212994,
-0.0222550128,
-0.1308593005,
-0.5012875199,
0.7776296139,
0.2031290829,
-0.2953438461,
-1.0453773737,
0.8059388399,
-0.5151006579,
-0.158734262,
-0.0895866603,
0.1112087891,
0.0378232375,
-0.0897884965,
0.098507762,
0.8543031216,
0.7963795066,
-0.7228527665,
0.1829864383,
0.4379107058,
-0.3765286803,
-0.0924430341,
-0.8701338768,
-0.1093476638,
-0.1651100665,
-0.133318156,
-0.7240273356,
-0.3971025646,
0.1052594185,
-0.5617594123,
0.3177985251,
-0.0926726609,
-0.5908138752,
-0.2528321743,
-0.1037501916,
0.2745327652,
0.5072875619,
-0.8371207714,
0.7976204753,
0.5737271309,
-0.0304042175,
-0.668620646,
-0.5375062227,
0.0938611552,
-0.1671805084,
-1.01973629,
0.4861186147,
0.0801833048,
-0.6059743762,
0.0911943316,
0.1853937507,
-0.1907638013,
0.2534386516,
0.508387804,
0.4695799351,
-0.3011745811,
0.0234549847,
-0.170445472,
-0.1783518046,
0.2021413296,
-0.1388158798,
0.4702890217,
-0.2770755291,
-0.3171280921,
-0.3815645278,
-0.1116201282,
0.6889505982,
-0.2145352215,
1.4284236431,
0.5550285578,
-0.4058595002,
-0.0765739903,
-0.1581044048,
0.0347158909,
-0.5407699943,
0.1944417357,
-0.4748832583,
-0.9305838346,
0.4115401804,
0.0784460083,
0.3829334676,
0.5613724589,
0.9162504673,
0.3176155388,
0.7378911376,
0.9125381708,
-0.021733908,
0.1409247965,
-0.1377293617,
0.1491038054,
-0.6102430224,
-0.5458242893,
-0.8826534152,
0.2503267825,
-0.3549922705,
-0.7646611333,
0.4980299771,
0.2874472141,
-0.3462250531,
0.3920482695,
-0.4571230412,
0.3226812482,
0.6120744348,
0.1459293664,
0.4493834376,
-0.4881186783,
-0.4260438979,
0.2686519921,
-0.6601734757,
-0.9273633361,
1.4168587923,
0.679969728,
1.1609144211,
0.3847246468,
0.6077723503,
0.0450705215,
0.6777614355,
-0.7409002185,
0.6229976416,
-0.1167877465,
-1.2033792734,
-0.2035992742,
-0.4199780524,
-0.8126761913,
0.13858217,
-0.4328150749,
-0.6260724664,
-0.2317404151,
0.1661579013,
-0.1150557771,
0.5369544625,
-0.3352307379,
0.7295070887,
0.0749213025,
-0.5426049232,
-0.4649388492,
-0.460054785,
0.8762235641,
-0.0295225661,
-0.0282156095,
-0.0564627722,
0.0243077371,
0.5096278191,
-0.6019488573,
0.7939022183,
0.0866221562,
-0.136932835,
0.6952909231,
0.2612879574,
0.418800205,
0.1451933533,
-0.2668198347,
0.3239807785,
0.0648978949,
-0.3377708495,
-0.1555999368,
0.6584116817,
-0.987857759,
-0.5666536689,
-0.2504944205,
-0.4971738756,
0.0579941757,
0.0345067568,
0.3254565001,
0.588037312,
-0.5620325208,
0.1560364515,
0.7430300117,
-0.4370401204,
0.5120608211,
0.5044013262,
-0.6660320163,
-0.2895022333,
0.3970912099,
-0.2770146728,
0.3785364926,
0.4282312989,
0.0163445082,
-0.2079807967,
-0.9508964419,
-0.5410323739,
0.2217692733,
-0.5382487178,
0.2239189446,
-0.6462672949,
-0.400783807,
-0.3251750171,
-0.1934819072,
-0.7340504527,
-0.7533146143,
-0.6265597343,
-0.0816530287,
0.2024883479,
1.2060592175,
0.0719974712,
0.5017319322,
-0.9798443913,
0.3744631112,
0.0444592312,
0.2751415074,
-0.2185634822,
-0.4323885441,
-0.4862686396,
-0.1057273075,
-0.8861669302,
-0.3528502285,
0.365863502,
-0.2991229296,
0.4323014915,
0.6355885267,
-0.1453077495,
0.6105044484,
-0.3746967018,
1.1739848852,
0.4570569694,
-0.9029935598,
0.2770653963,
-0.684943676,
-0.0815237164,
0.3521320224,
0.6197885871,
-0.0673661605,
-0.3049204051,
-0.5918672085,
-0.4818534553,
0.3606468141,
0.33248353,
0.0751750022,
-0.4469495118,
0.5387136936,
0.1563848853,
-0.0665926635,
-0.5934433937,
-0.1518785208,
0.0057500992,
-0.2870188057,
-0.1929886043,
-0.2946663797,
-0.0999113247,
0.1828053743,
0.7485574484,
-0.1270895302,
0.3472283483,
0.1433807164,
0.1130841896,
-0.2667358518,
-0.1100548059,
0.4663609862,
0.6674665809,
-0.3087815046,
-0.2096356601,
0.0088819051,
-0.9568687081,
0.0081009008,
-0.2139156014,
-0.0083907805,
-0.1340573877,
0.3555809259,
0.2675273716,
0.1331412792,
-0.6946796179,
0.6194489002,
-0.2509058416,
-0.1254757047,
-0.6664610505,
0.5255969763,
0.2649691105,
0.1437299252,
-0.0475530215,
0.2405147702,
-0.0061803507,
-0.7163913846,
0.031323541,
0.5272657275,
-0.6365970373,
-0.3693451285,
1.3775475025,
0.3243836164,
-0.2189119011,
0.5603742003,
0.2279829532,
0.3784292042,
0.7693930864,
0.5794120431,
0.8212881088,
-0.0420838408,
0.1758668274,
0.2486681938,
0.3570871055,
-0.6162068844,
0.4636521637,
0.4039958715,
-0.8387393355,
-0.3544881046,
-0.7586791515,
-0.9106093049,
-0.0474127829,
-0.8997008801,
0.6676872969,
-0.842571497,
-0.4736354947,
-0.1205968782,
-0.139119491,
-0.4621912241,
0.4181891978,
-0.0466044582,
1.7859088182,
-0.4298441708,
0.8885216117,
0.5220580697,
-0.41575104,
-0.7260750532,
-0.1996210665,
0.249692142,
-0.8480907679,
0.727560699,
0.201151967,
-0.3862910867,
-0.1343494058,
-0.4891454279,
-1.0364826918,
1.478710413,
0.4596520066,
-0.3643916249,
-0.2730206251,
0.0824002922,
0.4054437876,
-0.6762884259,
0.4549411237,
0.1298720986,
0.1899738014,
0.2321148068,
-1.0642222166,
-0.3161904216,
-0.193056047,
-0.1727888286,
0.4308313429,
-1.0309692621,
1.2532263994,
-0.5370559096,
-0.072149843,
0.7395535111,
0.623339653,
0.5103406906,
0.2914547622,
-0.1235937923,
0.7120399475,
0.5763355494,
-0.0443088375,
1.2882804871,
-0.5432722569,
0.2060542107,
0.9965624809,
-0.5038288236,
0.8995063901,
0.1611682773,
0.0447159708,
0.3956175148,
0.6662269235,
0.4223919809,
0.4103705585,
0.0411849655,
-0.5724158883,
-0.0214651898,
-0.2045338005,
-0.0788821802,
0.431609422,
0.5330981612,
-0.6417922974,
-0.0329078808,
-0.4164505005,
0.3842280209,
-0.0900889412,
-0.7366290092,
0.4919798672,
0.2129141539,
-0.5576241016,
0.3193995357,
0.5023745894,
0.3062057495,
-0.6461235285,
0.1839997917,
0.0837610066,
0.3071590066,
-0.2310558707,
-0.7072507739,
0.4298457503,
0.0248931963,
0.1437579393,
-0.1045335159,
0.6998920441,
0.1471521109,
-0.4634884596,
0.6335785389,
0.3507063389,
0.3602901101,
0.2575309277,
-0.3237070739,
-0.0678534284,
-0.3269807398,
-0.2936413288,
0.3283305168,
0.3019037843,
-0.0291660707,
1.1227781773,
0.450111568,
0.1345019937,
0.3207945824,
-0.1391250044,
0.9349305034,
-0.8917164207,
-0.2658191919,
-0.6866251826,
0.760667026,
0.2687756717,
-0.7634414434,
0.6980732083,
0.6176803708,
0.5935114622,
-0.1211335734,
0.5227116942,
0.0669739544,
0.3090350926,
-0.8329947591,
0.6991404295,
-0.3177159727,
0.1917875111,
-0.0341809802,
-0.8660970926,
-0.3903354108,
0.0585748814,
-0.1288684905,
0.0507893115,
0.7443602681,
1.1136717796,
-0.0978544354,
0.3230295777,
0.5004234314,
0.1253128797,
0.3246277571,
0.4829225242,
0.8925021291,
-0.3861848414,
0.3847339153,
0.1837050468,
-0.3560145497,
-0.2428841293,
-0.7505483627,
-1.3129023314,
-0.2813096941,
-0.164833039,
-0.3625589013,
0.1467250884,
0.6665982604,
0.919143796,
-0.4231106639,
-0.1297345608,
-0.2742953598,
-0.2556813359,
0.0603435338,
-0.2058181316,
0.0907823592,
-0.4590351284,
-0.5830408931,
0.7442468405,
0.4799430072,
0.1193224117,
-0.5030974746,
-0.3413411081,
0.2908752859,
0.4787383676,
0.4368587136,
-0.0300774071,
-0.4861877263,
-0.3254263699,
-0.1673638374,
-0.2865617871,
-0.09047658,
0.7259044647,
-0.663556993,
0.1025099158,
0.2931168377,
0.4358939826,
0.7351854444,
-0.1743975729,
0.6325557232,
-0.2419116944,
0.3052767813,
0.0511109643,
0.7375897765,
0.118390955,
-0.4993255436,
0.844569087,
-0.2630999982,
-0.6821947694,
-0.5448023677,
0.4147124887,
-0.8704747558,
-0.3779394627,
0.8189455271,
-0.4187488556,
-0.1942706555,
-0.049592901,
0.0381143913,
0.0766005218,
0.0945816189,
1.0552486181,
0.5687840581,
0.0890775323,
-0.0471182615,
-0.5558212996,
0.1858095378,
0.186523512,
-0.9250324965,
-0.1769539863,
0.2970415354,
0.4087632298,
0.2584232092,
0.5635331869,
-0.9241049886,
0.4271330833,
0.4263165891,
0.2737442553,
-0.2081554532,
-0.9450488091,
-0.2498214841,
0.3776305318,
0.5684666634,
-0.1839556247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08293v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08293v3
|
Generative Pretrained Structured Transformers: Unsupervised Syntactic Language Models at Scale
| 2024-03-13T06:54:47 | 2024-06-17T16:22:52 |
Xiang Hu, Pengyu Ji, Qingyang Zhu, Wei Wu, Kewei Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A syntactic language model (SLM) incrementally generates a sentence with its
syntactic tree in a left-to-right manner. We present Generative Pretrained
Structured Transformers (GPST), an unsupervised SLM at scale capable of being
pre-trained from scratch on raw texts with high parallelism. GPST circumvents
the limitations of previous SLMs such as relying on gold trees and sequential
training. It consists of two components, a usual SLM supervised by a
uni-directional language modeling loss, and an additional composition model,
which induces syntactic parse trees and computes constituent representations,
supervised by a bi-directional language modeling loss. We propose a
representation surrogate to enable joint parallel training of the two models in
a hard-EM fashion. We pre-train GPST on OpenWebText, a corpus with $9$ billion
tokens, and demonstrate the superiority of GPST over GPT-2 with a comparable
size in numerous tasks covering both language understanding and language
generation. Meanwhile, GPST also significantly outperforms existing
unsupervised SLMs on left-to-right grammar induction, while holding a
substantial acceleration on training.
|
[
-0.1216493249,
-0.5353391171,
0.6778991222,
0.302916199,
-0.3675897121,
0.0793201625,
-0.5550926924,
0.0485850275,
0.2394647747,
0.5043213964,
-0.5248666406,
-0.4423285425,
-0.4884713888,
-0.052881632,
-0.7014206648,
1.3739864826,
-0.0654133409,
-0.1259244084,
-0.3133297861,
0.0199674033,
-0.2054819018,
-0.6555529833,
-0.2629411817,
-0.2927246094,
0.1649639159,
0.1373928934,
0.8687687516,
0.4586676657,
0.3172260225,
0.4094598889,
0.2396520525,
-0.1939417869,
-0.259282887,
-0.021231344,
-0.14607732,
-0.3046324253,
-0.5015435815,
0.1258741319,
0.8494659662,
0.9153263569,
-0.5652429461,
0.2177412361,
0.0804740191,
0.4705174267,
-0.2049604803,
0.4043735266,
-0.6629244089,
0.0228055026,
-0.4010563791,
0.0575746559,
-0.6018968821,
-0.0516449697,
-0.0147247277,
-0.6768379807,
0.4148096144,
-0.2336735129,
0.7312074304,
0.3194603324,
-0.2988378406,
0.1360279471,
-0.9382368326,
0.4179552197,
-0.4930564165,
0.3968515396,
-0.1098056585,
0.329690218,
-0.0214705206,
-1.3250031471,
-0.3901486993,
-0.2611585557,
-0.300909698,
0.2544801831,
-0.2069308907,
0.2296977341,
0.3018600941,
0.3790060282,
-0.9444258213,
0.0459336713,
-0.1414988637,
0.0381176434,
0.2229962498,
-0.059864305,
0.2705492675,
0.0251974538,
-0.5024271607,
-0.1939765215,
-0.7618566155,
-0.4492339492,
0.3036501408,
0.3979537487,
-0.0034515373,
0.4741265178,
0.0260456707,
0.5462422967,
0.0698172152,
0.2566610277,
0.1904609501,
-0.3889683187,
-0.3421399891,
0.0562337935,
0.9259403348,
-0.1277619153,
0.4798510969,
-0.3624244928,
-0.3183974028,
0.1772668809,
0.6000877619,
-0.8324170709,
-0.3591309786,
-0.3437400758,
-0.2430871874,
0.0121143116,
0.2095310092,
-0.4198895693,
0.1542691588,
-0.3182221055,
0.3357436955,
-0.1014386639,
-0.4287244678,
0.341278404,
0.1861218214,
-0.0105311144,
0.0961983874,
-1.1226978302,
0.3107987642,
0.5381595492,
0.6574338675,
0.0781514645,
-0.3649303019,
-0.2599916458,
0.2369440049,
-0.1374397874,
0.8057729602,
-0.3948969543,
-0.1998684853,
0.1553485096,
0.0671437755,
-0.3505109549,
-0.3541733623,
0.4765871167,
-0.4482604265,
0.3987555504,
0.2373897135,
-0.253018707,
0.1332079321,
0.1679053307,
-0.5121665597,
1.1887688637,
0.5697303414,
-0.8537418842,
0.3546910584,
-0.5465298891,
-0.5439870954,
0.5174940825,
-0.3559291661,
-0.5136768222,
0.3061632216,
0.193050921,
0.3159040809,
-0.2463812828,
0.5810329914,
0.0882807374,
-0.2903149426,
-0.1812196523,
-0.423640132,
0.4425744414,
-0.1337836683,
-0.3514134586,
0.4050948024,
-0.6675970554,
0.1239468008,
0.3865358829,
-0.297055006,
-0.1645538807,
0.0209866129,
0.135414198,
0.1407096982,
0.3272582293,
-0.5764625669,
0.2665324509,
-0.3734716475,
0.6397283077,
0.5453567505,
-0.4000692368,
0.4273630679,
0.2012637556,
0.6265659332,
-0.0539209023,
0.0294661168,
-0.271348685,
-0.1555600166,
-0.8694217801,
0.0272330232,
0.1846752167,
0.3062618077,
-0.8083268404,
0.6324794888,
-0.6938685179,
-0.321834147,
-0.4181275666,
-0.0735894889,
0.2814189792,
0.3223394454,
0.5210911632,
-0.3645149767,
-0.5097603798,
-0.9501137137,
-0.3759324551,
-0.2426161766,
-0.2647539079,
-0.2735508084,
0.2824623287,
-0.2300950736,
0.9064236879,
-0.3834548593,
-0.2831526101,
-0.5555253625,
0.3506041765,
0.0285512209,
0.4679161906,
0.32462731,
-0.6404669881,
-0.545220077,
-0.0086004678,
-0.4485524595,
-0.1344278306,
-0.2500445843,
0.1803859472,
0.1575043797,
0.6737218499,
-1.1448534727,
0.3233094215,
0.6325442791,
-0.2041306794,
0.4902822077,
-0.4974000454,
-0.423366487,
-1.2037141323,
-0.0556602813,
-0.1578858197,
-0.570055306,
-0.6104151011,
0.1236507297,
0.1743850112,
-0.2701362073,
-0.2505148053,
-0.0765317604,
-0.5442788005,
-0.3893907666,
-0.1252046376,
0.0923533514,
-0.1450076103,
0.6025191545,
0.1630958617,
0.9988811612,
0.3027079105,
0.0012415349,
0.1593650579,
0.1208800972,
-0.5458514094,
-0.0113954637,
-0.6630185843,
0.3132915199,
-0.1983936876,
0.5124668479,
-0.6165744662,
-0.0327009335,
-0.1476461142,
-0.0562725179,
0.4534101188,
-0.1643089503,
-0.8297371268,
-0.4492467046,
-0.0332270823,
0.5439571142,
0.5337509513,
-0.5409609079,
0.4866713285,
0.1614215076,
-0.2754792571,
-0.1780830473,
-0.6376317739,
0.0774077997,
-0.0483768024,
-0.3540871143,
0.4378807247,
0.2819083333,
0.1276796013,
0.1033146381,
-0.0836825743,
0.3042683005,
-0.0802856386,
0.2189572155,
0.0694441721,
-0.4216957688,
0.2361580878,
-0.0274027549,
-0.4307230115,
0.1949421763,
-0.8375537395,
0.8989021182,
-0.5073511004,
-0.4626572728,
-0.2169782668,
0.2796162069,
0.4855616391,
-0.4583560228,
0.6581695676,
0.6195616126,
-0.1672136337,
-0.2737434506,
-0.172375083,
-0.0211879481,
-0.4828553796,
0.6421069503,
-0.2792980075,
-0.9040048718,
0.1392581016,
-0.154870078,
-0.0750193372,
0.5517043471,
0.5948318839,
0.1446487308,
1.0293385983,
0.7499608397,
-0.0075515718,
0.513641119,
-0.1922396272,
0.4194538295,
-0.4778549075,
-0.1299913824,
-0.4371271431,
-0.0313309841,
-0.8096401095,
-0.5211718082,
0.3669667244,
0.1246205643,
-0.4865320623,
0.6614314914,
-0.5027651787,
0.5791348815,
0.5801099539,
-0.1775046587,
0.293507725,
0.1318546832,
-0.1637728363,
0.0658761188,
-0.692944169,
-0.6268915534,
0.9476329684,
0.2946245968,
0.7056331038,
-0.0518917143,
0.4733783305,
-0.0181043334,
0.5154871345,
-0.6472076774,
0.6325002313,
-0.4757355452,
-0.290925771,
-0.2827528715,
-0.2722014189,
-0.670797646,
0.2173506916,
0.023333678,
-0.5025972128,
-0.3968746066,
0.1122956052,
-0.2087281048,
0.354315877,
-0.8080405593,
1.0323330164,
-0.1849200577,
-0.1001432464,
-0.0532746874,
-0.8047423959,
0.0481075682,
-0.1117626727,
-0.2735418379,
0.1796941906,
0.2145390809,
0.5674404502,
-0.5899242163,
0.7839461565,
-0.1973621696,
-0.0498626456,
0.3063372076,
0.0470068678,
0.6555401087,
0.0349882618,
0.3119982183,
0.1413765848,
-0.2931383252,
-0.357663542,
-0.7075638175,
0.5953454375,
-0.6182416081,
-0.8318853974,
-0.353526026,
-0.7012807727,
-0.2029744536,
0.3843703866,
0.2223017812,
0.3298102319,
-0.2129190415,
0.1628965884,
0.263397038,
0.0240484681,
0.5475058556,
0.2270754129,
-0.1661633104,
-0.0676076561,
0.646797061,
-0.0901754797,
0.3167158365,
0.5594723225,
0.0391739868,
-0.4710472226,
-0.6602010727,
-0.6361171007,
0.116283752,
-0.4409382641,
-0.2042323649,
-0.5918636918,
-0.4474258721,
-0.3729605079,
0.096582517,
-0.6485082507,
-0.5259398222,
-0.1225773096,
-0.4177811146,
0.0376915038,
0.9201415777,
0.189103812,
0.6766488552,
-0.5971477628,
0.0362397917,
0.2557671666,
0.3095148504,
-0.3513334692,
-0.3724477887,
-0.3005957901,
-0.0020880634,
-0.3514707386,
-0.4677371681,
0.4261640012,
0.0830696523,
0.1053360403,
0.4004947841,
-0.186872974,
0.7221476436,
-0.8219463229,
0.6681542993,
0.2700552046,
-0.75891608,
0.2014705539,
-0.4463930428,
0.4856546521,
0.5526384115,
0.2017773986,
-0.4156723022,
-0.444013834,
-0.5363930464,
-0.6383985281,
0.7862911224,
0.1928559244,
0.3007813394,
-0.1163186058,
0.2889308631,
0.1714470387,
0.2209737748,
-1.0200668573,
0.0409870856,
-0.6661835909,
-0.3164878488,
-0.4339821637,
-0.2087113261,
0.1921384633,
-0.2035878152,
0.4535863996,
-0.1298832595,
0.2433306873,
-0.0253298134,
-0.2776599228,
-0.0316201337,
0.4655836225,
0.4836966395,
0.4291192889,
-0.1248476356,
0.5435557961,
-0.1815460324,
-0.5054249167,
0.0689490959,
0.442486763,
-0.2391295284,
0.0357059874,
0.434371233,
0.9084857702,
0.1828148663,
-0.4026235342,
0.6427739263,
0.0525840521,
-0.2063243687,
-0.3044778705,
-0.4040926695,
0.2693678141,
0.0065044072,
0.1570636481,
0.0248405263,
-0.2227122337,
-0.4794791341,
0.1772485971,
0.4192861617,
-0.3108616173,
-0.7669118047,
0.6760001779,
0.1065437198,
-0.2241574526,
0.8925105929,
-0.1892886907,
-0.7736960053,
0.230481714,
1.0151731968,
0.9939444661,
-0.2538254857,
0.4619874358,
0.1734096557,
0.5205706954,
-0.2386897206,
-0.12218301,
-0.212839216,
-0.6401159763,
-0.5896912217,
-0.7999275923,
0.0001404406,
0.329814285,
-0.665700078,
0.0015017893,
-0.3219847083,
0.0124647534,
-0.131344229,
-0.1319572479,
-0.5738781691,
-0.0878629312,
-0.0867789984,
0.6942027807,
-0.8996829987,
1.1401107311,
0.9236771464,
-0.4628868699,
-0.8698562384,
0.2645579875,
-0.4457950592,
-0.8149113059,
0.603581965,
0.4383403063,
-0.0762535334,
0.3202159703,
-0.2235705853,
-0.6027752161,
0.9463127255,
0.6926410198,
-0.7116031647,
-0.3995110691,
0.6646190882,
0.7435517907,
-0.3052942157,
0.226277858,
0.6266514659,
0.1748203635,
-0.167228803,
-0.9634201527,
0.1422231644,
0.0057873642,
0.2810132205,
0.6667888165,
-0.4002149701,
1.0180599689,
-0.0663691685,
-0.6583160162,
0.1168432087,
0.5792279243,
-0.0990871787,
-0.191247955,
0.5808581114,
0.952553153,
0.2465012074,
-0.1930420846,
0.889990449,
-0.2622694373,
0.5531833172,
1.2506506443,
-0.3307036161,
0.6209538579,
0.4385100603,
-0.2507784665,
0.6741476655,
0.3757821321,
0.2042969167,
0.5193696618,
0.2673741579,
-0.4909592867,
-0.4562533796,
-0.1098688617,
-0.3526200056,
0.5363352895,
0.2218687236,
-0.2486878335,
-0.6605588794,
0.0029593413,
-0.1684443504,
0.4555425942,
-0.1561632156,
0.6750599742,
0.0177364945,
-0.65211308,
0.3382290304,
0.1619542688,
0.3393612504,
-0.664405942,
0.1789926142,
-0.2976593375,
0.3633335531,
0.0136591792,
-0.5630024076,
0.3911534846,
0.0154390112,
-0.046290528,
-0.8449184895,
0.7280911207,
-0.7762365937,
-0.4754952788,
0.2560422719,
0.5204740763,
0.1231022403,
-0.4031360447,
-0.4943742752,
-0.255823195,
-0.2682112753,
-0.4276773334,
0.3666416705,
0.468262285,
-0.4376213253,
0.385755688,
0.5150969028,
0.0190005619,
0.037830472,
0.4162988365,
1.0950843096,
-0.6261587143,
-0.4152100682,
-0.7092215419,
0.3055777252,
0.2273603529,
0.0660818741,
0.6396410465,
0.7339537144,
1.0958682299,
-0.2598218918,
0.5091943741,
0.023367539,
0.2837264836,
-0.4751203358,
0.6504668593,
-0.270247668,
-0.0472969301,
0.1435143352,
-1.0995094776,
-0.3448980451,
0.4804986715,
-0.1815967709,
0.1827476025,
0.8377805352,
0.5939708352,
-0.2036309987,
0.0202389527,
0.2555582523,
0.2285717875,
0.2750639021,
0.6278296113,
0.7503492832,
-0.2927116752,
0.5960068703,
-0.0353000052,
0.003389409,
0.2038366646,
-0.7641043663,
-0.9765391946,
-0.6326758265,
-0.1057131514,
-0.0253993087,
-0.0735793635,
0.7321441174,
0.6799798012,
-0.5018054247,
-0.1170680523,
-0.7912402153,
-0.2583349347,
0.0175149571,
-0.195523262,
0.4718446732,
-0.5098407269,
-0.7259757519,
0.5495117903,
0.3796011508,
0.1471036524,
-0.4966535568,
0.1209317222,
-0.1028951705,
-0.3692017794,
0.7050293684,
0.0943784192,
-0.5172791481,
-0.3106561601,
-0.3167459667,
-0.1352949739,
0.0816631094,
1.1827971935,
-0.9282306433,
0.206602037,
0.217430234,
0.5670098662,
0.8256835938,
0.2495995909,
0.6249396205,
-1.1915156841,
0.4672694504,
0.2924624979,
0.2784696817,
0.3325622678,
-0.0601120703,
0.2492115796,
0.276186794,
-0.3086979091,
-0.6923456192,
0.3118405044,
-0.9112117887,
-0.0646711588,
0.9330571294,
-0.2437608093,
0.0926666781,
0.1193351448,
0.2121304721,
0.3727730811,
-0.0838821232,
0.3374047577,
0.4394610524,
0.2480190694,
-0.1085774377,
-0.4117132127,
0.5061667562,
0.5961778164,
-0.8843300343,
0.3647709191,
0.2224646807,
0.110640347,
0.2246668488,
0.5517423153,
-0.3704445064,
-0.1138994694,
0.020293681,
0.3213158548,
-0.2766087055,
-0.6087046266,
-0.326069206,
0.1801426858,
0.0238750391,
-0.2205328643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08281v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08281v4
|
Mastering Text, Code and Math Simultaneously via Fusing Highly Specialized Language Models
| 2024-03-13T06:18:48 | 2024-03-26T09:29:51 |
Ning Ding, Yulin Chen, Ganqu Cui, Xingtai Lv, Weilin Zhao, Ruobing Xie, Bowen Zhou, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Underlying data distributions of natural language, programming code, and
mathematical symbols vary vastly, presenting a complex challenge for large
language models (LLMs) that strive to achieve high performance across all three
domains simultaneously. Achieving a very high level of proficiency for an LLM
within a specific domain often requires extensive training with relevant
corpora, which is typically accompanied by a sacrifice in performance in other
domains. In this paper, we propose to fuse models that are already
highly-specialized directly. The proposed fusing framework, UltraFuser,
consists of three distinct specialists that are already sufficiently trained on
language, coding, and mathematics. A token-level gating mechanism is introduced
to blend the specialists' outputs. A two-stage training strategy accompanied by
balanced sampling is designed to ensure stability. To effectively train the
fused model, we further construct a high-quality supervised instruction tuning
dataset, UltraChat 2, which includes text, code, and mathematical content. This
dataset comprises approximately 300,000 instructions and covers a wide range of
topics in each domain. Experiments show that our model could simultaneously
achieve mastery of the three crucial domains.
|
[
-0.2208449841,
-0.9465474486,
0.2887514234,
0.3358404934,
-0.0583402924,
0.579578042,
-0.1877296567,
-0.3626526594,
-0.2977328897,
0.858727932,
-0.4048340321,
-0.4111932814,
-0.4111324847,
-0.2229209989,
-0.5109977722,
1.2452853918,
-0.0556108989,
0.0459868014,
-0.3918626606,
0.077393055,
-0.709613204,
-0.7895331383,
-0.3355712891,
-0.7319182754,
-0.0173664801,
0.3941998482,
0.7869563103,
0.6609137654,
0.5252171755,
0.2664364576,
0.2678146064,
0.4362203479,
-0.8373429179,
-0.122784026,
-0.2986389995,
-0.5605596304,
-0.4082612991,
-0.1124236584,
0.5322605968,
0.8616650701,
-0.0520468429,
-0.1865320206,
0.2035430223,
0.4619480968,
-0.4061484337,
0.0485549755,
-0.8449907899,
-0.118826285,
-0.0237931572,
-0.1838004142,
-0.5333912373,
-0.1247355714,
-0.2098073065,
-0.6302827597,
0.2594542503,
-0.0634230152,
0.8648511767,
0.1594512761,
-0.4411614239,
0.0471675992,
-0.92922014,
0.8671921492,
-0.4869415462,
0.2598487437,
0.3135401607,
-0.0073209065,
0.184182778,
-0.411340028,
-0.4499401152,
0.2860732675,
-0.1056410074,
0.1046932489,
-0.2242015302,
-0.0351890624,
0.0951921418,
0.3170819283,
-0.5596601367,
0.3035007417,
-0.2701173425,
-0.1914658099,
0.5367618799,
0.3810707331,
0.4591244161,
0.1597450823,
-0.4119785726,
-0.1895512342,
-0.6936030984,
-0.2905143201,
0.306178689,
0.0659396127,
-0.1940671355,
0.6969668865,
0.191196546,
0.6505560279,
-0.2512477934,
-0.0013145787,
-0.0422025695,
-0.5112231374,
-0.3601516783,
-0.2751426101,
0.7913622856,
0.1715336442,
0.4542136788,
-0.2544278204,
-0.2988199592,
0.4305401146,
0.3076294065,
-0.5494166613,
-0.5957802534,
0.0298700929,
-0.0841769725,
-0.3457085788,
0.0226346347,
-0.7153432369,
-0.0986711979,
-0.451148361,
0.3299825191,
-0.4580380023,
-0.3145616353,
0.2431099564,
0.1153150126,
-0.0032657143,
-0.09425807,
-1.327688098,
0.3502604365,
0.9290353656,
0.6098791361,
-0.3963268697,
-0.429698348,
-0.2842844427,
0.5588579774,
-0.5313825011,
0.752916038,
-0.9574109316,
-0.3852826655,
0.143682003,
-0.2773210704,
-0.3357074857,
-0.485645473,
0.4348415434,
-0.655305326,
-0.1083555594,
0.2421489954,
-0.8008636236,
0.0493672639,
-0.0711941123,
-0.5441021919,
1.2407587767,
0.5113414526,
-0.5648784637,
0.0210360084,
-0.3821666241,
-0.5472405553,
0.2377034724,
-0.1692688465,
-0.4147067964,
0.1707713902,
0.3011409342,
0.4917339683,
-0.2893218398,
0.4128119349,
-0.09177728,
-0.5638158917,
0.2407300323,
-0.446949482,
0.6635972857,
-0.061497353,
-0.1899517626,
0.1081095561,
-0.5739178658,
0.0541557074,
-0.0405606553,
-0.3251003921,
-0.4334332049,
-0.2863762975,
0.305280894,
0.1594731212,
0.2380529195,
-0.1569708139,
0.4011977613,
-0.4706496894,
0.3777316213,
0.7903628945,
-0.1386639476,
0.5614777207,
-0.193039,
0.4773487747,
0.0017099282,
-0.0675698593,
-0.4357624352,
-0.3197136223,
-0.9898661375,
-0.2724101841,
0.3580738902,
0.7248407006,
-0.7641846538,
0.6302887201,
-0.3517003953,
-0.3297388256,
-0.650988698,
0.5870120525,
0.6418630481,
0.3087987006,
0.3562165201,
-0.005917381,
-0.4296713471,
-0.8085922599,
-0.237162292,
0.1224845946,
-0.1040782779,
0.1753227264,
0.4335457981,
-0.3836384416,
0.7519496083,
-0.7183772326,
-0.4687467515,
-0.3261200786,
0.229732275,
0.1736734211,
0.6830738187,
0.2725324333,
-0.78676337,
-0.5629960299,
0.3845272362,
-0.8888928294,
-0.0478632823,
-0.2658471763,
-0.3844507337,
0.1285120994,
0.6073525548,
-0.1313148588,
0.1457467824,
0.6008319855,
-0.0882368311,
0.3947169483,
-0.3011457622,
0.0325430408,
-1.0811094046,
-0.0699043497,
-0.1386438459,
-0.1290315986,
-0.6699565053,
0.4147149026,
0.298930347,
-0.1986488402,
-0.2304838598,
0.446282804,
-0.5371872783,
0.3005859852,
-0.464787066,
-0.0381735004,
-0.1834516525,
0.6579342484,
-0.0893148631,
0.922286272,
0.8181927204,
-0.5498759151,
0.4980755448,
0.2489239722,
-0.1818722636,
0.4704067111,
-0.7401793003,
0.219413504,
0.2893033624,
-0.0579210036,
-0.8005382419,
-0.3548771739,
-0.4707137048,
-0.3185205162,
0.2994586229,
-0.17510131,
-0.756000638,
-0.4282618165,
-0.0055524982,
0.4895796776,
0.6297236681,
-0.3494092822,
0.6696573496,
0.6085830331,
-0.1568777114,
-0.3729632497,
-0.6832497716,
0.0602635331,
0.084931381,
-0.6188416481,
0.4006206989,
-0.0234005861,
0.1481731683,
0.0202308316,
-0.074249059,
-0.1829668432,
0.0850808397,
0.1948944926,
0.7241305113,
0.0283417236,
-0.1031406596,
0.2879871726,
-0.4245069921,
-0.0929985866,
-0.616532743,
0.7837197185,
0.0946857333,
-0.6221873164,
-0.2850813568,
0.5743587613,
0.4431584179,
-0.4888893962,
0.7700472474,
0.5465003848,
-0.3990281522,
-0.383880198,
-0.6024502516,
-0.0700415,
-0.469848603,
0.4946691096,
-0.499892205,
-1.1893856525,
0.4403738678,
-0.115364328,
0.3908425868,
0.3068057001,
0.6623312235,
0.001171171,
1.3957656622,
1.2238241434,
-0.2858896255,
0.2010602653,
-0.4501315653,
0.4124496281,
-0.7083474398,
-0.3917538524,
-0.4950807691,
-0.0510976277,
-0.2514657676,
-0.4729250968,
0.5785520077,
0.1192620546,
0.0514856391,
0.3754537106,
-0.4389986992,
0.9737507105,
0.459608674,
-0.1296792775,
0.3231596947,
0.5205452442,
-0.3405819535,
0.0172867011,
-0.7496117949,
-0.4285763204,
1.0822257996,
0.1488221735,
1.0272352695,
0.0031989927,
0.506824553,
-0.0813141689,
-0.0417586602,
-0.4033289552,
0.4094076753,
-0.5277205706,
-0.4947814941,
-0.0757679045,
-0.6150689721,
-0.6681963205,
0.1619924903,
-0.3494752645,
-0.4830058515,
-0.2459116131,
0.0523142219,
-0.3003933728,
0.400411576,
-0.6026974916,
0.640655756,
-0.104425095,
-0.5956553817,
-0.4069399238,
-0.6095553041,
0.5652210712,
-0.4686357081,
0.3915487826,
-0.0248763375,
0.0663708523,
0.6488478184,
-0.0222557634,
0.8335928321,
0.468475014,
-0.2301864177,
0.0093819769,
0.4171711206,
0.1843991429,
0.1346954405,
0.0295014195,
0.1295218766,
-0.1919209212,
-0.6352545619,
-0.553589344,
1.0041458607,
-0.9505791068,
-0.3808259964,
-0.2319873422,
-0.850669384,
-0.4666954577,
0.3108313382,
0.0698997229,
0.4989973605,
-0.118606478,
0.0548626818,
1.0021529198,
0.1932440847,
0.4105693996,
0.3640053868,
-0.0539650954,
-0.4467022419,
1.1135536432,
-0.3074676096,
0.5442408919,
0.5025374889,
-0.1830085069,
-0.1131721437,
-0.3755053878,
-0.4938370883,
0.3048509061,
-0.6035978794,
-0.3386321962,
-0.9031823874,
-0.4443822801,
-0.4776805043,
-0.4475471079,
-0.2120734155,
-0.1009079814,
-0.3143803775,
-0.0096505936,
0.2533723712,
0.7249373198,
0.1408174187,
0.5162056684,
-1.0707205534,
0.4687230885,
0.3637520671,
0.4319980145,
-0.1150423214,
-0.3896243274,
-0.5064565539,
0.2357645035,
-0.3240332901,
-0.6076753736,
0.2638700604,
0.2035857141,
0.5763759017,
0.2808856368,
-0.3750213981,
0.8390667439,
-0.4162564874,
0.7127928138,
0.2806247771,
-1.0880943537,
0.3736953437,
-0.4219402373,
0.2198781967,
0.6019935608,
0.3434860408,
-0.4721269608,
-0.607452035,
-0.5105822086,
-0.7981292605,
0.8186379671,
0.2420019358,
0.5043942928,
0.20983845,
0.1409645826,
0.128875494,
0.0572112128,
-0.5969136357,
-0.1529224813,
0.0619149096,
-0.4127546251,
-0.0070656724,
-0.1575746238,
-0.394859612,
-0.5109347105,
0.7114772797,
-0.325607866,
0.1067879871,
-0.4701739848,
-0.2737753987,
0.0253732353,
-0.0390788503,
0.1384737641,
0.7915150523,
0.3656107187,
0.2801338434,
0.0202938002,
-0.4748519063,
0.0896206498,
-0.0021761819,
-0.0870038271,
-0.3506987393,
0.7003289461,
0.7641282678,
0.6360343099,
-0.7092148662,
0.3980327547,
0.2427537888,
-0.2722367942,
0.2576415539,
0.3854696453,
0.2778645158,
-0.2386061847,
0.3435014784,
0.137768954,
-0.2441361099,
-0.5597615838,
0.3394194543,
0.423681438,
-0.2071073055,
-0.2151990384,
0.6567796469,
0.2666956484,
-0.068465963,
0.8619812727,
0.0652431846,
-0.7375261188,
0.4997196496,
0.9484173059,
0.549092412,
-0.2032517344,
0.1641892493,
0.0420283712,
0.2031777352,
-0.1399098635,
0.1279865801,
0.0031650357,
-0.5940388441,
-0.4936885238,
-0.8182230592,
-0.2554292083,
-0.196279943,
-0.4251761734,
0.3573891819,
-0.2640696466,
0.2461647242,
0.0440458171,
-0.0469984449,
-0.4916574359,
0.0874529257,
-0.1516243815,
0.6188008785,
-1.1420166492,
0.9143301845,
0.7149648666,
-0.3488931954,
-0.8812299967,
-0.2595846355,
-0.1689185947,
-0.8994145393,
0.1473320574,
-0.0094550671,
-0.1357800066,
0.2480378747,
-0.5506449938,
-0.5028780699,
0.684964776,
0.429453671,
-0.5907915831,
-0.1880685389,
0.3350420296,
0.4212997258,
-0.4636635184,
0.2429374903,
0.8841782212,
0.0721775517,
0.2648357749,
-0.954503119,
-0.3659859598,
-0.3357296288,
0.070130989,
0.4484633207,
-0.6721903682,
0.8146588802,
-0.0391536504,
-0.1808383614,
-0.1576685607,
0.7645361423,
0.2416041791,
-0.0776810423,
0.1741079092,
0.6046878695,
0.7123252749,
-0.171857506,
0.6291526556,
-0.5152662992,
0.4616405368,
0.817048192,
-0.3870054483,
0.5870921016,
0.1733749211,
-0.1733800769,
0.4255884886,
0.3465768695,
-0.1774759591,
0.296168983,
-0.0748932585,
-0.3671235442,
-0.5554413199,
-0.0984375477,
-0.3526607752,
0.4245889783,
0.3474316299,
-0.0058940356,
-0.1066140458,
0.1304391921,
0.1258538961,
0.399436295,
-0.1020490378,
0.9699397683,
0.0210240223,
-0.6615545154,
0.6899445057,
0.1561658233,
0.740398109,
-0.6474030614,
-0.0559457876,
-0.2480527312,
0.2989627421,
-0.1829820275,
-0.8887875676,
0.2924601436,
0.1330585927,
-0.1462863535,
-0.2472635806,
0.4798036218,
-0.6760334373,
-0.9022633433,
0.2595633864,
0.4255549908,
0.0678325072,
0.1985946149,
-0.5442588329,
0.2282545418,
0.045281779,
0.3652248383,
0.3280909956,
0.3895847201,
-0.1853723526,
0.6191325188,
0.9220781326,
0.0511304811,
0.0979061276,
0.3762640655,
1.2927430868,
-0.4174311459,
-0.4816280305,
-0.9948282242,
0.2508064508,
-0.1568459421,
-0.2557485402,
0.6792823672,
0.9281115532,
0.9162207842,
0.0144022591,
0.8098341227,
0.2688586712,
0.0875473619,
-0.5760958791,
0.7156733871,
-0.4458613396,
0.2817535698,
-0.288941443,
-1.0009042025,
-0.3293114007,
0.379720211,
0.2317672372,
0.0388306975,
0.6754230261,
0.7402600646,
-0.4352542758,
0.1165394336,
0.3392771482,
-0.0079914927,
0.4777562022,
0.9777368307,
0.3610926569,
-0.317661196,
0.5629367232,
-0.1492237598,
-0.5808368921,
-0.130837664,
-0.5784983635,
-1.2132424116,
-0.5100395679,
-0.2004291266,
-0.0622870848,
-0.0287254043,
0.5890907049,
0.8623583913,
-0.6826129556,
-0.3828003109,
-0.1127244607,
0.0641627386,
-0.3409760594,
-0.2046519369,
0.2864966691,
-0.432290107,
-0.8503761888,
0.3532232642,
0.373895824,
-0.0214426666,
-0.3830873966,
0.2227275372,
-0.0018134874,
0.2913639545,
0.4778097272,
-0.0490083247,
-0.4513631761,
0.2275623232,
0.2572791576,
-0.3266380727,
-0.152288124,
1.1220264435,
-0.7215595245,
0.3633114696,
0.3032981157,
0.7692614198,
0.4609366655,
-0.0192280859,
0.6125236154,
-0.7860935926,
0.0937138945,
0.1590650231,
0.1037470475,
0.3808479905,
-0.4295503497,
0.3775448501,
0.238615647,
-0.4845046401,
-0.9403911829,
0.2674663663,
-0.6754589081,
-0.3444875479,
1.0228478909,
0.0994796902,
-0.0069451965,
-0.1637395173,
-0.1295136362,
0.3235145807,
-0.0237283744,
0.4973036647,
0.808514595,
-0.0943320692,
0.0409592986,
-0.4768390059,
0.3093036711,
0.6265877485,
-0.85069561,
0.3858839273,
0.3915249705,
0.1419362575,
0.1341138929,
0.4738511741,
-0.2484552413,
0.2052905858,
-0.0842539892,
0.0220508426,
-0.2683161497,
-0.6867446303,
-0.3438726962,
0.255569607,
-0.3532693684,
0.2780691981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08272v1
|
RECIPE4U: Student-ChatGPT Interaction Dataset in EFL Writing Education
| 2024-03-13T05:51:57 | 2024-03-13T05:51:57 |
Jieun Han, Haneul Yoo, Junho Myung, Minsun Kim, Tak Yeon Lee, So-Yeon Ahn, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The integration of generative AI in education is expanding, yet empirical
analyses of large-scale and real-world interactions between students and AI
systems still remain limited. Addressing this gap, we present RECIPE4U (RECIPE
for University), a dataset sourced from a semester-long experiment with 212
college students in English as Foreign Language (EFL) writing courses. During
the study, students engaged in dialogues with ChatGPT to revise their essays.
RECIPE4U includes comprehensive records of these interactions, including
conversation logs, students' intent, students' self-rated satisfaction, and
students' essay edit histories. In particular, we annotate the students'
utterances in RECIPE4U with 13 intention labels based on our coding schemes. We
establish baseline results for two subtasks in task-oriented dialogue systems
within educational contexts: intent detection and satisfaction estimation. As a
foundational step, we explore student-ChatGPT interaction patterns through
RECIPE4U and analyze them by focusing on students' dialogue, essay data
statistics, and students' essay edits. We further illustrate potential
applications of RECIPE4U dataset for enhancing the incorporation of LLMs in
educational frameworks. RECIPE4U is publicly available at
https://zeunie.github.io/RECIPE4U/.
|
[
-0.0817775428,
-0.9600275755,
0.5614626408,
0.1517578512,
0.4887302816,
0.0882500187,
-0.0560836084,
-0.3594290018,
0.2371228188,
0.4262267649,
-0.722166121,
-0.6348589063,
-0.1331727654,
0.2175337374,
-0.3985840082,
1.1575642824,
-0.2226909548,
0.1168247163,
-0.7002308965,
0.266793251,
-0.4938001931,
-0.6835976243,
-0.8934628963,
-0.2702450156,
0.6758899093,
0.8038845658,
0.1391439736,
0.1877645999,
0.488824755,
0.2879612148,
0.4467271864,
-0.1202448681,
-0.7868078947,
0.2335005105,
0.132386595,
-0.4041649997,
-0.5549833775,
0.3656354845,
0.5781418085,
0.557488203,
-0.1377812475,
0.019192636,
0.3590764701,
0.3330700994,
-0.2839562595,
0.4601973593,
-0.2077241838,
0.4043746293,
-0.2693656385,
-0.1150141731,
-0.6354064345,
-0.3155288994,
0.0566668101,
-0.783441782,
0.1969362199,
-0.142003417,
0.3797784746,
0.1275104731,
-0.125640437,
-0.4228774905,
-0.5963041186,
0.7442184687,
-0.8478525281,
0.3994745016,
0.4111491442,
0.1898563504,
-0.6597905159,
-0.9943336248,
-0.7717328072,
0.1358973831,
-0.2143900096,
0.5154762864,
0.0989968553,
0.3073731661,
0.0956692919,
0.3273915648,
-0.4762463272,
0.0791547149,
-0.2264739722,
-0.1302316636,
0.3869873285,
0.4316469729,
0.637927711,
0.1212156191,
-0.2307667881,
0.0483609512,
-0.734804213,
0.2326501608,
0.6189192533,
0.0135620143,
-0.0413470268,
0.6923492551,
-0.0071853427,
0.7192215919,
-0.2238646448,
-0.0903713331,
0.1228185445,
-0.5301180482,
-0.2476080954,
0.08578825,
0.8319026828,
0.4516293108,
0.0706384778,
0.0651681498,
-0.137241438,
0.076331757,
0.1230742112,
-0.8955124617,
-0.5264777541,
0.2566184998,
0.2076190859,
-0.3274643421,
-0.008394829,
-0.7334589362,
-0.1300500631,
-0.3516344428,
0.2944404483,
-0.3474785089,
-0.1322273314,
-0.0644864738,
-0.2019557655,
0.5802237988,
0.3112102151,
-0.9776751399,
0.4794831276,
0.9313465357,
0.666204989,
-0.3367100954,
-0.7828953862,
-0.4870198965,
0.2783229053,
-0.2355392575,
0.6649096608,
-0.7363795638,
-0.4741905928,
0.2143045366,
-0.0726924986,
-0.3455879092,
-0.3055982888,
0.6790660024,
-0.0790223852,
0.3805544972,
-0.2176724225,
-1.0747054815,
0.0297570545,
0.356019944,
-0.6719840169,
1.0671019554,
0.0252660904,
-0.3280183077,
0.1538822651,
-0.8160117865,
-0.5794534683,
0.1515003592,
-0.6178231835,
-0.4193935394,
-0.2481450289,
-0.0572381839,
0.5836859941,
-0.1190198213,
0.3742019534,
0.0118524283,
-0.473500073,
0.4795692861,
-0.4447548687,
0.397356391,
0.0490125306,
-0.1875490695,
0.1064402834,
-0.5853664875,
-0.1511959881,
0.1417535543,
-0.6012710929,
0.0716415942,
-0.1644478291,
0.1509187818,
-0.2748711407,
0.1495388448,
-0.4360093176,
0.2305362523,
-0.1574519724,
0.5813934803,
0.7379040718,
0.0362402238,
0.2374096662,
-0.4089753926,
0.4961726367,
0.0768203661,
0.1185917407,
-0.3809438944,
-0.7815408111,
-0.8783587813,
0.0170735978,
0.0777039975,
0.3677497506,
-0.5375548601,
0.1330964118,
0.0201935116,
-0.1934992522,
-0.5575330853,
0.1779888421,
0.3495716155,
0.4803470075,
0.1874953955,
-0.059294045,
-0.6847479343,
-0.5842455626,
-0.3312178254,
-0.0649391487,
-0.0714120939,
0.2647273839,
0.2767574489,
-0.2043852806,
0.9715244174,
-0.4715847373,
-0.3848515451,
-0.6507927179,
0.1482429504,
0.1692340374,
0.6657033563,
0.4609203935,
-0.5348741412,
-0.7748860717,
-0.076724343,
-0.9071927071,
-0.2042151093,
-0.2922897637,
-0.4323406816,
0.1652965546,
0.4434816539,
-0.4985997081,
0.413035661,
0.4305526614,
-0.380363971,
0.5339040756,
0.153408587,
0.3919569254,
-1.0868711472,
-0.3417454064,
0.1911531538,
0.0093162963,
-0.8596676588,
-0.1875651032,
-0.1142357215,
-0.120772168,
-0.3631762266,
0.4316735268,
-0.2823892534,
-0.0434338525,
0.1306807697,
0.0941879526,
0.224750489,
0.6126626134,
-0.0212792698,
0.8473622799,
0.2246493846,
0.0299734641,
0.2457401007,
0.2417494506,
-0.2640731335,
0.6077221632,
-0.5254552364,
0.24863787,
0.310418129,
0.3281279504,
-1.0821754932,
-0.5617769361,
0.5377703309,
-0.3599155843,
0.0478080995,
-0.1246840134,
-0.2130644172,
0.0205893815,
-0.3010256588,
0.4121322632,
0.2657343745,
-0.5682575703,
0.810729146,
0.1753070801,
-0.2492800802,
-0.2315138727,
-0.4308239818,
0.3215990365,
-0.1307234913,
-0.3605417907,
0.284943372,
-0.4614481628,
-0.145177722,
0.1071068794,
0.2016188055,
-0.1416714638,
-0.1674713939,
0.3666518331,
0.3640619516,
-0.2612041533,
-0.18111597,
0.2159680128,
0.1263272017,
0.2728566229,
-0.0896848962,
0.4509177208,
-0.1254719198,
-0.3064101636,
-0.8143213391,
0.1943422258,
0.4677481949,
0.1210589707,
0.5359926224,
0.3771800101,
-0.2218242139,
-0.229216069,
-0.5034223795,
-0.2536900938,
-0.4851046205,
0.0808681548,
-0.5810950994,
-0.5909875631,
0.3262298405,
0.0404514819,
0.3647128344,
0.0310000908,
0.2194788903,
-0.3444149196,
0.4058788121,
0.2175936997,
-0.0732570514,
0.3690427244,
-0.3311166763,
0.2484965175,
-0.8158589602,
-0.4291986227,
-0.201883167,
-0.3663079441,
-0.1750259846,
-0.3704854548,
0.3202430308,
-0.3135155439,
-0.0396766365,
-0.0570169315,
-0.1667853296,
0.8181966543,
0.5047000051,
-0.0102440929,
0.3325645626,
-0.0360168479,
-0.112804696,
-0.2403207719,
-0.683917284,
-0.32139346,
1.0790165663,
0.0487425253,
0.5780077577,
0.2608456016,
0.840585649,
0.5146536231,
0.4294337332,
-0.8885299563,
0.7481625676,
0.1762806177,
-0.2226902843,
-0.4186284542,
-0.3751820326,
-0.9003524184,
0.001201884,
-0.1777227521,
-0.3954569399,
-0.3544184268,
0.1223922446,
-0.109314844,
0.0774923712,
-1.0142438412,
1.091850996,
-0.2913151085,
-0.7542278171,
0.2714691162,
-0.3527719378,
0.0916442052,
-0.0597923659,
0.1345396489,
0.2250381708,
0.5259523392,
0.9131057858,
-0.4741058946,
1.32754457,
0.1321692616,
-0.0715061873,
0.3958129883,
0.0031518426,
0.4709437191,
-0.0124138407,
-0.1503151506,
0.1624723822,
-0.0357075408,
-0.390684098,
-0.6020114422,
1.124140501,
-0.8815233111,
-0.8514519334,
-0.6398465037,
-0.459739387,
-0.0367337875,
0.1115093231,
0.0212931689,
0.345610857,
-0.5529927015,
-0.0513680503,
0.2960836589,
-0.0690750033,
0.349758625,
0.4391326606,
-0.3279412687,
-0.1120797694,
1.1950519085,
0.1306936294,
0.1316900998,
0.0781930462,
0.3089250624,
-0.0383209065,
-0.1411925107,
-0.6647874117,
0.0876385793,
-0.7002649307,
0.031104587,
-0.5828526616,
-0.4448101819,
-0.5252603889,
-0.4993826449,
-0.1667113304,
-0.1554271728,
-0.3830076754,
-0.3767300546,
0.1963994801,
1.0535025597,
0.208372429,
0.2268719375,
-0.409864068,
-0.2296233177,
0.1644631624,
0.1831276268,
0.0192960538,
-0.2766763568,
-0.1692720354,
-0.0547733903,
-0.4789815843,
-0.7793108821,
0.2726589441,
0.5386118293,
0.4881445169,
0.4341385961,
-0.1651870608,
0.413413167,
-0.5531166792,
0.977697134,
0.1756542474,
-0.7825773358,
0.5622954369,
-0.2532364726,
0.1905042082,
0.274879396,
0.5057918429,
-0.7376587987,
-0.5864539146,
-0.3530701399,
-0.7772716284,
0.6505527496,
0.3744263053,
0.1509724855,
0.0498925485,
0.5693252683,
0.3878686726,
0.0126956347,
-0.6817813516,
-0.2148790658,
-0.2983512282,
-0.753505826,
0.0119578624,
-0.2083010226,
-0.166274026,
-0.4086357057,
0.7624627948,
0.1341543049,
-0.01783517,
-0.0801578015,
0.1708948463,
0.0845391005,
0.1978639513,
0.2757587135,
0.5228390098,
-0.0552180335,
0.1363398135,
-0.1297666728,
-0.7757701874,
0.1106842384,
0.0049934024,
-0.0247095861,
-0.2399989963,
0.3637654483,
0.4975923598,
0.3779895604,
-0.6665537953,
0.4613771439,
-0.4990954697,
-0.1642581373,
-0.7446184754,
0.4004017413,
0.1139842048,
0.0193926543,
0.0837757662,
-0.3940776885,
0.4172147214,
-0.5651251674,
0.114861913,
0.0467423834,
-0.2026667446,
-0.5970907211,
0.4554784,
0.6316542029,
-0.4153171182,
0.7955722809,
0.0049313726,
-0.2800836265,
0.5625383854,
0.7857199311,
0.6963462234,
-0.3275086582,
0.5277776718,
0.2093187422,
0.0878124014,
0.2163078934,
0.1274419427,
0.0304937121,
-0.9523214102,
-0.1384112537,
-0.6122152805,
-0.7999883294,
0.399315834,
-0.3686166704,
0.2706993222,
-0.3163307309,
0.1862347424,
0.1970469803,
-0.3384863138,
-0.8474546075,
0.0586646125,
-0.3179545701,
0.1028596014,
-0.9150485396,
0.7308004498,
0.9395794868,
-0.3827237487,
-0.8054875135,
-0.0467487089,
0.4367030263,
-0.4691556692,
0.490678221,
0.397159636,
-0.0330080651,
0.2467057705,
-0.3137819767,
-0.3794372976,
0.8035954237,
0.0263860729,
-0.6334782839,
0.1967547387,
0.8023887873,
0.4814482331,
-0.4160577953,
0.2170830667,
0.8352121711,
0.3418383002,
0.2767444551,
-0.2553710043,
-0.2060780674,
-0.5104127526,
-0.4523047507,
0.0778126121,
-0.5012292266,
0.4160929024,
-0.153817296,
-0.1138254702,
-0.0865288302,
0.5951080918,
0.0345298462,
0.7632675767,
0.0706663877,
0.7105126381,
0.5774821639,
-0.3559601009,
0.6237614751,
-0.174575001,
0.0755421519,
1.3233623505,
-0.4470015466,
0.7429767847,
0.6715424061,
-0.2323933989,
0.4076863229,
0.7815582156,
0.0751598775,
0.1615102291,
0.1965347379,
-0.6167890429,
0.0430574007,
-0.0797222406,
-0.1535301954,
0.3132322431,
0.5822041631,
-0.1821715534,
0.3468288779,
0.0526696853,
0.2725164294,
-0.0852187276,
0.0823149532,
1.0161622763,
-0.0622874275,
-0.8775404096,
0.2567941546,
-0.2828534544,
0.272503227,
-0.2631931305,
-0.6050693393,
-0.6847321391,
-0.1227920055,
-0.3665833175,
-1.0290929079,
-0.1465992481,
-0.0052255327,
0.0271771196,
-0.0140650878,
0.4678685367,
-0.6793165207,
-0.7498970032,
0.0042792493,
0.5074204206,
0.4631018341,
0.5395615697,
-0.268943429,
0.3299666643,
0.04995206,
-0.3137679398,
0.3331208229,
0.5560231209,
0.331882745,
0.2288269997,
0.6988570094,
-0.0785395652,
0.0457116514,
0.3052850366,
0.8085906506,
-0.4962152839,
-0.2072033882,
-0.6901496649,
0.3978306949,
-0.0580402464,
-0.3299081624,
0.7564604282,
0.7917770147,
1.214556098,
-0.1143125668,
1.2485582829,
-0.0042210231,
-0.0265780017,
-0.6251081228,
0.4377752542,
-0.3699862957,
0.5648765564,
-0.1713661999,
-0.9737387896,
-0.1352851391,
0.5890274644,
-0.3272070885,
-0.0166190322,
0.5840061307,
0.6991679072,
-0.1387735009,
0.4323177934,
0.6111344695,
0.2965600789,
0.6751599908,
0.420499444,
0.883250773,
-0.2395842373,
0.1705468446,
-0.2067355067,
-0.4356618822,
-0.2001310736,
-0.5963576436,
-1.0730575323,
-0.5829966068,
-0.1113183722,
-0.0061917761,
0.3429312408,
0.8604421616,
-0.0109557146,
-0.6834706068,
-0.5499798059,
-0.2629418373,
0.012760371,
-0.119983986,
-0.2960700691,
0.1951993257,
-0.5318660736,
-1.00831604,
0.4405632317,
0.2192890793,
0.1026320234,
-0.1825268418,
-0.3032383919,
-0.0555932261,
0.2720150352,
0.6600446105,
0.1656029075,
-0.6085454822,
-0.1809108406,
-0.0550444834,
0.1449163258,
0.2006714344,
0.9183798432,
-0.2573923171,
0.6464303136,
0.1436857879,
0.7627549171,
0.4055989087,
-0.0955119058,
0.5988667011,
-0.7125842571,
-0.2408687174,
-0.0322995149,
0.328243345,
0.4172393382,
-0.4624715149,
0.6416186094,
0.3647662699,
-0.8960012794,
-0.5244071484,
-0.0917933434,
-0.8389772177,
-0.0433372222,
1.0968458652,
-0.5645172596,
-0.0307249539,
-0.013394244,
-0.3117159009,
0.2309011668,
-0.6336160898,
0.7577505708,
0.7921184301,
-0.6469751596,
-0.1623094082,
-0.8274690509,
0.641043067,
0.4234226942,
-1.2288767099,
-0.0863704979,
0.8254972696,
0.2080602199,
-0.1412607431,
0.683765769,
0.2510902286,
0.0908522457,
-0.1623829156,
0.2261791378,
0.0638097078,
-0.5735114813,
0.3487920165,
-0.0443954878,
0.0672848672,
0.0802429244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14683v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14683v1
|
A Moral Imperative: The Need for Continual Superalignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T05:44:50 | 2024-03-13T05:44:50 |
Gokul Puthumanaillam, Manav Vora, Pranay Thangeda, Melkior Ornik
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper examines the challenges associated with achieving life-long
superalignment in AI systems, particularly large language models (LLMs).
Superalignment is a theoretical framework that aspires to ensure that
superintelligent AI systems act in accordance with human values and goals.
Despite its promising vision, we argue that achieving superalignment requires
substantial changes in the current LLM architectures due to their inherent
limitations in comprehending and adapting to the dynamic nature of these human
ethics and evolving global scenarios. We dissect the challenges of encoding an
ever-changing spectrum of human values into LLMs, highlighting the
discrepancies between static AI models and the dynamic nature of human
societies. To illustrate these challenges, we analyze two distinct examples:
one demonstrates a qualitative shift in human values, while the other presents
a quantifiable change. Through these examples, we illustrate how LLMs,
constrained by their training data, fail to align with contemporary human
values and scenarios. The paper concludes by exploring potential strategies to
address and possibly mitigate these alignment discrepancies, suggesting a path
forward in the pursuit of more adaptable and responsive AI systems.
|
[
0.0003084672,
-0.1644494236,
0.6187559366,
-0.2972798347,
-0.0393287316,
0.2533598542,
0.0160921775,
-0.5238939524,
-0.2365844846,
0.3479436636,
-0.6668296456,
0.0711210817,
-0.5495752096,
-0.0384058766,
-0.2166066617,
1.2163863182,
0.2431476414,
0.2157303095,
-0.371889174,
-0.648635447,
-0.5648953319,
-0.6550748944,
-0.5908610821,
-0.5844717026,
0.260856539,
0.4197923839,
1.4130661488,
0.8467684388,
0.4935801029,
0.2446205169,
-0.0814106464,
0.1469804049,
-0.6745783091,
0.3809991479,
-0.368186295,
-0.5871893167,
-0.2853965759,
0.1740002632,
0.8340848088,
0.5349938273,
-0.2285064012,
0.1674363017,
-0.1071886122,
0.8811004162,
-0.373519212,
-0.059516903,
-0.4058398008,
-0.149994418,
-0.2603285611,
0.2016879469,
0.1026457623,
-0.4613259733,
0.1352574974,
-0.7692016959,
-0.2220436782,
0.0539745763,
1.2470836639,
0.7235720158,
-0.1528032124,
-0.0294222515,
-0.8690184355,
0.9994748831,
-0.6831778884,
0.6017006636,
0.1484334469,
0.1592364162,
-0.296959728,
-0.3614787757,
-0.7428723574,
-0.2181728333,
0.2484814972,
-0.0769217908,
0.1715656221,
-0.2467692196,
0.1570392996,
0.1301124096,
-0.3459065855,
0.3784536421,
-0.1905225515,
0.0122471889,
0.7505884171,
0.5778440237,
0.5218948126,
0.2386702746,
-0.2538079917,
-0.182150051,
-1.1839040518,
0.0985321924,
0.4071733952,
0.1019138992,
-0.1222929731,
0.2073028684,
0.3588832617,
0.2047847807,
0.2486538887,
-0.1562885493,
-0.0898805857,
-0.273683846,
-0.0438918769,
0.2113643587,
0.4347377121,
0.6634073853,
0.6809054017,
0.0803992376,
-0.172614038,
0.1621024311,
0.5128389597,
-0.3269942403,
0.1441327035,
0.2548282146,
-0.215832442,
-0.1150391921,
-0.057102941,
-0.2765326202,
-0.6764031649,
-0.7755711675,
-0.082848385,
-0.5440702438,
-0.2280399203,
0.3144437671,
0.2302925438,
0.7375205159,
0.2513008416,
-1.2018575668,
-0.2025156915,
0.9690196514,
0.7190843821,
0.2256969959,
-0.3240416944,
-0.0960959494,
0.5109812617,
-0.6594638228,
0.5070154667,
-0.976565361,
-0.4608362913,
-0.0836249292,
0.0726598948,
-0.0406586751,
-0.5722675323,
0.3455476463,
-0.5009401441,
-0.0102659427,
-0.3825240135,
-0.5403091908,
0.0603929646,
0.2377792299,
-0.3793625236,
0.9448141456,
0.0943692252,
-0.3939177692,
0.2524134517,
-0.5360224247,
-0.305516541,
0.4668385386,
-0.5099616051,
-0.3978482485,
0.283767283,
-0.0672176629,
0.3971576691,
-0.4410642385,
0.7094869614,
-0.32794258,
-0.5946906805,
0.2655720115,
-0.5954170227,
1.0064842701,
-0.0360213518,
-0.4487651587,
0.0479422025,
-0.5369276404,
-0.2227192223,
0.1570755094,
-0.4569649696,
-0.3386111856,
0.4810510278,
-0.2428783178,
0.2516416013,
0.463927418,
-0.3784409165,
0.5149081945,
-0.454988867,
0.8070214987,
1.3172869682,
-0.5476592779,
0.2640027404,
-0.6382915974,
0.5059883595,
-0.4335336685,
0.3633375764,
0.1899010837,
-0.0648476556,
-0.9395961761,
0.2536494136,
-0.0780376568,
0.8223817348,
-0.4238113761,
0.5884822011,
-0.7232316136,
-0.2519555688,
-0.8186113238,
0.0828855038,
0.4272688627,
0.1118458584,
0.3428825736,
-0.0457465239,
-0.4242432714,
-0.7904075384,
-0.2145031095,
-0.434836328,
0.1761950552,
0.1923827529,
0.536950469,
-0.4084714055,
0.7364934683,
0.0090095764,
-0.0564530641,
-0.1355365962,
-0.1328133345,
-0.0283230096,
0.7679716349,
0.2294702977,
-1.0180661678,
-0.0153664937,
0.1288389266,
-1.0299313068,
0.216742143,
-0.4786654711,
0.0644557178,
0.3871099651,
1.1831669807,
-0.6727589369,
0.1300228983,
0.4606648088,
-0.0781030506,
0.915440321,
-0.2079543322,
-0.1176246703,
-0.8542169929,
0.1454425305,
-0.0852945745,
-0.1072257459,
-0.4266946316,
0.3776544631,
-0.178191632,
0.0399760827,
-0.5726549625,
0.5132389069,
-0.2833536863,
0.1290273964,
0.0322962627,
0.0992554873,
-0.1846500635,
-0.0652498454,
-0.3988825679,
0.9628177881,
0.4660479724,
-0.7315835953,
0.5298351049,
0.2297012508,
-0.1793614626,
1.1381487846,
-0.7377248406,
0.2577470243,
-0.3089980185,
0.5992610455,
-0.6770321131,
-0.3276728392,
0.1155482456,
-0.3143281043,
0.3942925334,
0.0420542136,
-0.3960930109,
-0.1321674436,
-0.1748648882,
0.8134368658,
0.2644374967,
-0.2805514336,
0.5186777115,
0.4991827905,
-0.3539382815,
-0.660004735,
-0.6162992716,
0.4935607612,
-0.3669705689,
-0.7567418814,
0.486792624,
-0.1216692701,
-0.2405796945,
-0.0308619291,
-0.2382948101,
0.7611284852,
0.218994543,
0.3592618406,
0.4113468528,
-0.2887743115,
0.421628803,
-0.3673312664,
-0.6505954862,
-0.0119591625,
-0.6918399334,
0.4713798165,
-0.5512481332,
-0.3381799459,
-0.809855938,
0.4296892881,
1.1558804512,
-0.2193453014,
0.9287721515,
0.3333185613,
-0.4166025817,
0.3987575173,
-0.6379339695,
0.2599208653,
-0.4914880395,
0.2061616033,
0.1219984815,
-1.2609555721,
0.2889250517,
-0.045292519,
0.3092069626,
0.378085345,
0.4172179401,
-0.458894074,
1.3638863564,
0.9311172366,
-0.3237956762,
0.4741503596,
-0.1651989222,
0.4638355374,
-0.9501282573,
-0.2901975513,
-0.4660779238,
-0.5030429363,
-0.7246178389,
-0.1942913532,
0.414704442,
-0.0151842833,
-0.8605564833,
0.0126459654,
-0.4116067588,
0.6739299893,
0.4319660068,
-0.3247401714,
-0.0046193404,
-0.3160057068,
-0.0386446863,
-0.0081456769,
-0.5286021233,
-1.0051441193,
0.6994965076,
0.2354581654,
0.7445856333,
0.3135744929,
0.4007219076,
0.0762780905,
0.3187392354,
-0.586789012,
0.7594099641,
-0.4857817292,
-0.484156847,
-0.5592408776,
-0.1557373255,
-1.033822298,
-0.1193934605,
-0.1275395751,
-0.8942351341,
0.1594001055,
0.1674557775,
-0.7901932001,
0.1764133573,
-0.2200754881,
0.7086338401,
-0.5059267282,
-0.4855968952,
-0.3417170048,
-1.0626959801,
0.1051208079,
0.1713522077,
0.2608081102,
-0.3764904141,
-0.0389235094,
0.4855514765,
-0.3194755912,
0.9512753487,
0.0883952677,
-0.3562543094,
-0.0516823977,
0.0767983645,
0.4580180049,
-0.0152128655,
-0.0656120181,
0.0914645791,
0.1105275452,
-0.6300116777,
-0.3993721604,
0.8067122698,
-0.9950547218,
-1.1600593328,
-0.5144622922,
-0.8532438874,
-0.2801795602,
0.1790706813,
0.0330485515,
0.3696850538,
-0.2222519815,
0.2588320971,
0.8017120957,
-0.1952141225,
0.4924916923,
0.1514587402,
0.14257285,
-0.1822099984,
1.0587694645,
0.2486150861,
0.4438682199,
0.0005150791,
0.2596698403,
-0.5519670248,
-0.4137610495,
-0.6504536271,
0.5025481582,
-0.466807574,
-0.0187409837,
-0.1015665531,
-0.2333618701,
-0.5852150321,
-0.7083204389,
-0.3567579389,
-0.2233874053,
-0.5620580912,
0.0047425372,
0.116402328,
0.897998631,
-0.2321320176,
0.1273768544,
-1.0418968201,
0.1214836836,
0.2867624462,
0.3739144206,
-0.109953098,
-0.6069142818,
-0.2364083529,
0.3003159761,
-0.2217395008,
-0.266736865,
-0.0635068491,
0.212788254,
0.6049295664,
0.4809688628,
0.0720590353,
0.9744451642,
-0.5874630809,
0.9102227092,
0.2083625942,
-0.9356297255,
0.3772038817,
-0.4098551273,
0.4288129807,
0.6982857585,
0.5798767805,
-1.0366517305,
-0.2829249203,
-0.5250823498,
-1.0487473011,
0.5336663127,
-0.1675780118,
0.5493297577,
0.0998501852,
0.662257731,
-0.204518944,
-0.0354204476,
-0.6350462437,
0.0272338744,
-0.0622368641,
-0.2983745635,
-0.129263252,
0.0281073581,
-0.3084296584,
-0.2074229121,
0.8130906224,
-0.1652629822,
-0.1261528283,
0.0622166879,
-0.0568372346,
-0.1189967394,
0.2574543953,
0.8185591102,
0.765350461,
0.1346570402,
0.020394519,
0.0676665455,
-0.3312181532,
0.703653276,
-0.18014431,
-0.0790865347,
-0.7401009798,
0.2943675518,
0.5504118204,
0.1557432264,
-0.5847660303,
0.3307157159,
0.1964390576,
0.0942206532,
-0.3088948131,
0.2680440545,
0.256942153,
0.4590214491,
0.202989921,
-0.0144022079,
-0.6069073677,
-0.7654637694,
0.0405464992,
0.5269091129,
-0.5731831193,
-0.1688404977,
0.670353651,
0.1760370135,
-0.6352609396,
0.8833717108,
-0.2923171222,
-0.5839604735,
0.5013440847,
0.5422518253,
0.6466782093,
-0.5934346914,
0.09181346,
-0.1525871158,
0.3933616877,
-0.4565258026,
0.1052991152,
0.2701116204,
-1.022664547,
-0.4255269766,
-0.5278522968,
-0.3482742906,
0.1117304564,
-0.5425782204,
-0.0649198219,
-0.7120879292,
-0.1433593929,
-0.2747148275,
-0.2577534914,
-0.3374064267,
0.1746608317,
0.3280208409,
0.4817536175,
-0.7362758517,
0.607609272,
0.8568813801,
-0.2250720561,
-0.7275701761,
0.326936543,
0.3699370325,
-0.9524314404,
0.397908628,
0.369250834,
-0.6928936839,
0.1716992557,
-0.9344160557,
-0.9883883595,
0.9772642851,
0.8297472596,
-0.6009242535,
-0.3086847067,
0.3077214956,
0.6300792694,
-0.3213767707,
-0.3803285956,
0.9702294469,
0.5706202984,
-0.1717970669,
-0.7574308515,
0.1732178181,
-0.2194774151,
0.1422016323,
0.3537096083,
-1.1808590889,
0.528609395,
-0.3888272345,
-0.6491341591,
0.1196736544,
0.4316635132,
0.3859449029,
-0.0478517935,
0.4723673761,
0.8486093283,
0.7859125137,
-0.0228111707,
0.8674244881,
-0.3628696799,
0.2457312047,
0.7629551291,
-0.5203577876,
0.6425821781,
0.4074647427,
-0.2024041414,
0.6259813905,
0.5388926268,
0.0456361622,
-0.0286757722,
0.2311028838,
-0.2443368435,
-0.7202329636,
-0.5817753077,
-0.6037839055,
0.5996365547,
0.787883997,
0.2463261187,
0.0287763514,
-0.2993597984,
0.2393179238,
0.0302690156,
-0.3066319227,
0.4177386165,
0.1726088226,
-0.7645036578,
0.7115868926,
-0.2760229111,
0.4764394164,
-0.3762590885,
0.0134311672,
-0.2568472624,
0.2666038871,
-0.1543313563,
-0.7077758908,
0.3528020382,
-0.2274206877,
-0.0905447081,
-0.5657845736,
0.2544442117,
-0.0007982925,
-0.5596910119,
0.2355761826,
0.2062797844,
0.10169027,
0.4375346899,
-0.9649740458,
0.2240537405,
-0.1501843631,
0.0851176903,
0.2904236913,
0.3697672188,
-0.2948604226,
1.0099012852,
0.8477039933,
-0.0436903499,
-0.2340599298,
0.1316928566,
0.7220399976,
-0.8428969383,
-0.5737424493,
-1.1352620125,
0.481005758,
0.2536939383,
-0.6820421815,
0.2026211023,
0.1246302426,
0.8802131414,
0.5427219868,
0.682810545,
0.1744039655,
-0.1632365286,
-0.6614050865,
0.6438729763,
-0.7436665893,
0.4697603583,
-0.0130510377,
-0.621463418,
-0.5508188009,
0.7086874247,
-0.2239839733,
-0.0027034045,
0.354835391,
0.839885354,
0.2315083593,
0.0321434215,
0.3451300859,
0.2997255623,
0.4721328914,
0.7145426273,
1.2104642391,
-0.0480748005,
0.5534347892,
0.5665727854,
-0.0104103386,
-0.4317343831,
-0.9358468056,
-0.1876808405,
-0.4926516116,
-0.3143136203,
-0.2097212374,
0.4206390977,
1.0231556892,
0.8402301073,
-0.7075772285,
-0.2413156629,
-0.2561715841,
0.1130622923,
-0.1354759634,
-0.1714104116,
0.2300047278,
-0.2818108499,
-0.6191129088,
0.3544808924,
0.6766613722,
0.2932834029,
-0.5894209146,
-0.1023940295,
-0.4116153717,
0.307405293,
0.3032699525,
0.5998896956,
-0.9130961299,
-1.0372726917,
-0.1550550759,
-0.2429512739,
0.2054853439,
0.9255396128,
-0.5598287582,
0.1387450099,
0.0526902713,
0.9081276059,
-0.2276245952,
0.074625805,
0.8147138357,
-0.5038565993,
-0.233932972,
0.3918334544,
0.292227596,
0.5994781852,
-0.4586668015,
0.2949740291,
0.3087456822,
-1.0154175758,
-0.7899910808,
0.7405621409,
-0.4885582924,
-0.2210492492,
0.9018115401,
-0.1735661626,
0.0276979879,
-0.6193832755,
-0.0306050908,
0.3073622584,
-0.2141274959,
0.847499311,
0.8826083541,
-0.3922798038,
0.0074883914,
-0.5531086922,
0.3385112882,
0.8320274353,
-0.6514327526,
0.3941283822,
0.5766256452,
0.1726033092,
0.3535478711,
0.3633146286,
-0.0581301339,
0.3062006235,
-0.2190429419,
-0.1846593618,
0.2691194415,
-0.5385165215,
-0.5646823645,
-0.0974796414,
-0.0981346667,
0.0798972994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15426v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15426v1
|
A Three-Phases SFT Hybrid Model Integrated Strong Prior Module and Data Overlap Estimation in the Eduation Context
| 2024-03-13T05:38:39 | 2024-03-13T05:38:39 |
Zhangquan Chen, Chunjiang Liu, Haobin Duan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
In this paper, we propose an end-to-end prior-based three-phases supervised
fine-tuned model, which is proved more competitive than traditional fine-tuning
method. More specifically, our model realizes the structural disassembly and
incremental guided output of educational knowledge. To this end, we robustify
data classification of three types via a sampler and overlap estimation neural
network, and inject the preprocessing datasets into pre-trained model in three
batches for LORA fine-tuning. Then, we design a prior module couples system
prompt, vector databases, and abstract syntax tree task segmentation. Finally,
the compression method and regularization constraint are applied to the
prior-based fine-tuned model, followed by text filter at the output end to
obtain incremental guided results. Our model represents the first research
effort to truly embody the tutor role with the features of abundant educational
knowledge, step-by-step incremental guided outputs and non-disclosure of
answers. Extensive experiments report that our model also achieves
state-of-the-art in code abilities compared to open-source models, reaching an
impressive 75.10% on the HumanEval (@pass 1) benchmark. Additionally, our model
maintains strong conversational capabilities, with the 13B quantized version
achieving scores of 56.34, 50.60, and 45.27 respectively on the MMLU, C-Eval,
and AGIEval (5 shot) dialogue evaluation benchmarks.
|
[
-0.3527755439,
-1.3164402246,
0.5122784972,
-0.0834723338,
-0.1391158253,
0.1515122205,
-0.1584193558,
-0.444514811,
-0.1675108075,
0.4865999222,
-0.5007984638,
-0.5923585892,
-0.4010846019,
-0.1263317764,
-0.5394833684,
0.7875409722,
-0.1334857047,
0.0409510508,
-0.1239185631,
0.3718954623,
-0.5462218523,
-0.2295115441,
-0.5466023684,
-0.2773918211,
0.0399006233,
0.5219674706,
0.2992313504,
0.4179724753,
0.3022319078,
0.3275151551,
-0.3796734512,
0.1909788102,
-0.3935856223,
-0.3642852604,
-0.1197372079,
-0.6317567229,
-0.68080616,
0.0597430579,
0.6079399586,
0.8509114981,
-0.1770025641,
-0.1067566872,
0.5010756254,
0.5903621316,
-0.5185828805,
0.01909131,
-0.5518464446,
0.0940946564,
0.085628204,
-0.2361045033,
-0.3248026967,
-0.4139072299,
0.2641486526,
-0.7214896083,
0.1515032649,
-0.4574013352,
0.6570329666,
0.4715293944,
-0.6470376849,
0.2978686094,
-0.6154873967,
0.5802812576,
-0.7793798447,
0.4054258466,
0.4295607209,
0.3222095072,
-0.2674017549,
-0.7360082269,
-0.6886268854,
0.0062619438,
0.0471739471,
0.4092131555,
0.1022418588,
0.4535854459,
0.0880850703,
0.4858961403,
-0.337805599,
0.317699939,
-0.7280066013,
0.0415582843,
0.2029023916,
0.1571970135,
-0.0832928568,
-0.2097848356,
-0.6299370527,
0.1200047284,
-0.5802636743,
0.1667953283,
0.7273693085,
0.3192570806,
-0.1860814095,
0.5570219755,
-0.4200861752,
0.9945361614,
0.2255500555,
0.0234733745,
0.057908684,
-0.5248464942,
-0.2763086855,
-0.2184609771,
0.7658570409,
0.0842644647,
0.4000811279,
0.2776655257,
-0.0252998378,
0.2286983579,
0.1851002127,
-0.6798633933,
-0.2854085863,
0.2559148371,
-0.1327732652,
-0.2410328835,
0.0928051919,
-0.5289312601,
0.0582066216,
-0.7797160149,
0.7033491135,
-0.7988268137,
-0.4662176967,
0.5408897996,
0.3743173778,
-0.1537222564,
0.3977569044,
-0.7228809595,
0.6204977632,
0.8224173784,
0.8895648122,
-0.3819700181,
-0.4405333996,
-0.2333062887,
0.0056623416,
-0.1584795564,
0.5812759995,
-0.582088232,
-0.1460483074,
-0.0878311545,
0.0252705216,
-0.440906316,
-0.2467972189,
0.3607318103,
-0.3006132543,
0.5434111357,
0.3871898949,
-0.7576723099,
-0.4162282348,
0.1127948239,
-0.3931917846,
1.230787158,
0.4655036032,
-0.6497055888,
0.2753256857,
-0.637855351,
-0.3403286338,
0.087825194,
-0.145739764,
-0.2012432814,
-0.3473656178,
0.2746204138,
0.6623159647,
0.1047875658,
0.7074326277,
-0.1530939937,
-0.8290707469,
-0.1822054833,
-0.2891412675,
0.6980948448,
-0.1546506733,
-0.2971264422,
0.3229373097,
-0.9318454266,
-0.0692838356,
-0.321113497,
-0.3099324703,
-0.5293110609,
-0.3246357143,
-0.0462453701,
0.2083695978,
0.439652741,
-0.4962170124,
0.1416993886,
-0.5420265794,
0.603785634,
0.8887506127,
0.0655598044,
0.2313685566,
-0.1852342784,
0.6982944012,
0.3282742798,
0.377017796,
-0.3573058844,
-0.4131884277,
-0.7260941863,
-0.296010375,
0.4049931169,
0.4164087474,
-0.6795568466,
0.7582820058,
-0.104484342,
-0.2542773485,
-0.3158851266,
0.002799609,
0.2081382275,
0.6470614076,
0.3998133242,
-0.0028987068,
-0.5010975003,
-0.9170539379,
0.1294997782,
-0.0318130702,
0.1388679445,
0.0051773828,
0.7370838523,
-0.059017878,
1.0572500229,
-0.5832411647,
-0.4345756471,
0.1053935513,
0.0363764875,
0.4323196709,
0.8850515485,
0.3783713281,
-0.7390397191,
-0.4613039792,
0.137896806,
-0.5566748381,
0.1481758952,
0.0611228719,
-0.4370546341,
-0.2860119045,
0.4131712317,
-0.3053747118,
0.2891532481,
0.4130482376,
-0.3255343735,
0.3946111798,
-0.0031045268,
0.3030796945,
-1.3149294853,
-0.234023124,
0.0758803338,
-0.2122682929,
-0.4947228432,
0.0358110443,
0.2112876922,
0.0404434763,
-0.2356736958,
0.2111460716,
-0.2209710032,
0.224614948,
-0.2026005983,
0.2983958125,
-0.0385109708,
0.8498421907,
-0.0139832683,
0.8059031963,
0.4994682074,
-0.4736379385,
-0.0266619511,
0.2643112242,
-0.4787903726,
0.9224808216,
-0.9314146638,
0.0766072199,
0.2544475496,
0.0790531039,
-0.9226477146,
-0.1677147746,
0.0935303643,
-0.1706026345,
0.2334883809,
-0.3913472295,
-0.4088835418,
-0.5669813156,
-0.2967796028,
0.3384201527,
0.1821081787,
-0.5308841467,
0.6356128454,
0.0945026726,
-0.3044995368,
-0.4805774391,
-0.3375899196,
-0.4183884263,
-0.1293928027,
-0.6957166791,
0.436988622,
-0.194811061,
0.3082191944,
-0.0133292694,
-0.1644034237,
-0.3950726688,
0.0902747437,
0.2814264297,
0.4777005017,
-0.4010280371,
-0.214802146,
0.5229216218,
0.1267744005,
-0.1497057378,
-0.3372710943,
0.5181500316,
-0.1233243421,
-0.6097260714,
-0.5949375033,
0.0559844337,
0.3777855337,
-0.1392229199,
0.4791112244,
0.5996654034,
-0.6123821139,
-0.1659693122,
-0.5422138572,
-0.139871642,
-0.533991456,
0.4888571799,
-0.39336586,
-1.2246161699,
0.4217748344,
0.0864337236,
0.0238726847,
0.1974131167,
0.0453572348,
0.1917033643,
0.9416377544,
0.9468153119,
0.2665895224,
0.8093422055,
-0.4454681873,
-0.1359181553,
-1.0107785463,
-0.2408547997,
-0.0999527201,
-0.2287636399,
-0.0587550849,
-0.145843938,
0.45511204,
0.5801962018,
-0.3575210571,
0.430221498,
-0.5934294462,
0.514764905,
0.5638945699,
0.5956546068,
0.3806652725,
-0.0460640676,
0.0250373371,
0.0466215461,
-0.6080989838,
-0.204793185,
1.2274035215,
0.3371374905,
0.4419380426,
-0.0182069484,
0.6406626701,
0.1678001136,
-0.0078549786,
-0.5557848811,
0.5020896792,
0.0479529053,
-0.4359157979,
-0.2720492184,
-0.4062632322,
-0.5801508427,
0.3653693199,
-0.0519604422,
-0.9489265084,
0.0721005127,
-0.0097860266,
-0.7156433463,
0.0879710615,
-0.9654819369,
0.7484573126,
0.0044279401,
-0.7357705235,
-0.2652041018,
-0.4467390478,
0.7198280096,
-0.4404814243,
-0.0304150768,
-0.0001472361,
0.2582339942,
1.0500047207,
-0.4859511256,
1.0106827021,
-0.169282794,
-0.1603095531,
0.345264852,
-0.0923655033,
0.4928202927,
-0.1531769484,
0.066446729,
0.0036006614,
0.3171337247,
-0.254848063,
-0.6194365025,
0.7466073036,
-0.6920790672,
-0.5339509249,
0.0737267435,
-0.5159268379,
-0.3804960549,
0.2357958406,
0.0008468829,
0.5410277247,
-0.0222040452,
0.1144285426,
0.5289877653,
-0.0133153377,
0.1658866256,
0.7995507717,
-0.1310116649,
-0.4804466665,
0.8149466515,
0.1117899567,
0.3805948496,
0.3127467334,
0.1394806653,
-0.0760991052,
-0.5113918185,
-0.2571666241,
0.0831358433,
-0.5626622438,
-0.265150547,
-0.834328115,
-0.2996305227,
-0.4380518496,
-0.3320575356,
-0.3692010939,
-0.4394882619,
-0.3859528005,
-0.3181115091,
0.5857014656,
1.106066823,
-0.0059992885,
0.8484134078,
-0.3580832779,
0.2044622153,
0.1318994164,
0.6116378307,
-0.0447051562,
-0.698846221,
-0.4536503553,
0.1111617759,
-0.3304386437,
-0.7855154276,
-0.0053435704,
0.1480079442,
0.4914274514,
0.4925042093,
-0.1553511322,
0.7337160707,
-0.2140460908,
0.8254033327,
0.1783264428,
-0.8626419306,
0.6234670877,
-0.6754592657,
0.1551059186,
0.592795074,
0.2242430896,
0.1014220789,
-0.292461127,
-0.6528632641,
-0.9576895237,
0.8959082961,
0.0948725268,
-0.2038864642,
0.1837327629,
0.2532037795,
0.4045545161,
0.3715124726,
-0.608361423,
-0.1030524597,
-0.1465956867,
-0.4716669321,
0.2548433542,
-0.2129262984,
-0.0101701748,
-0.5214137435,
0.6548229456,
-0.3088252842,
-0.0527986586,
-0.1415980756,
0.0770144612,
-0.0279595237,
0.3031756878,
0.3980305493,
0.6528411508,
-0.3934320509,
-0.2244449854,
0.0872938409,
-0.7382246256,
-0.0179022811,
0.6233662367,
-0.1339218915,
-0.3023754954,
0.1813947856,
0.7054818273,
0.6114781499,
-0.2938669324,
0.6610996723,
0.279963702,
-0.3201040328,
-0.2993934155,
0.2693401277,
-0.3542387486,
0.3906367421,
0.2574494779,
0.0152479429,
0.2063676715,
-0.0896926224,
0.3352251351,
0.2732152641,
-0.3293733299,
-0.3694244921,
0.9288225174,
0.3266508877,
0.0364634879,
0.2059376687,
0.3626360595,
-0.5938248038,
0.6908129454,
0.5621464252,
0.6271183491,
-0.202998966,
0.2992052138,
0.4440217316,
0.1915608943,
-0.2686208487,
0.5443766713,
-0.392918855,
-0.582162559,
-0.4922406077,
-0.581281662,
-0.2982294559,
0.1431915313,
-0.8807113171,
0.5216273069,
-0.49645105,
-0.0349925943,
-0.0975315049,
0.004566276,
-0.6431293488,
0.3074807227,
-0.2559053004,
0.8646127582,
-0.8495151401,
0.7962543964,
0.6246185899,
-0.4775017202,
-0.9335932732,
-0.3531179428,
-0.2413678169,
-0.5426982641,
0.2422450781,
0.2674871087,
-0.117438972,
0.4288611412,
-0.5645138025,
-0.7966323495,
1.1888383627,
0.291059345,
-0.8097102642,
-0.2102615088,
-0.0883606374,
0.4847272038,
-0.3024975061,
0.5190219879,
0.801545918,
0.1202048138,
-0.0050014644,
-0.8428381681,
-0.2584706247,
-0.3667913377,
-0.2250834554,
0.2646608949,
-0.5888411999,
0.9381235242,
-0.0687565207,
-0.1514283419,
0.1850786656,
0.7403354049,
0.1430524439,
0.1560217887,
0.6181444526,
0.3799602985,
0.6648056507,
-0.1331515461,
0.6044464707,
-0.6392690539,
0.264339745,
1.3495585918,
0.0346975476,
0.9032835364,
0.3843601048,
-0.3940445781,
0.5029700994,
0.8219149709,
0.054548908,
0.4263854325,
-0.1598569006,
-0.0561023317,
-0.2504931092,
-0.0738155916,
-0.7109298706,
0.2372590303,
0.3962920606,
-0.1628325731,
0.1362406164,
0.1822719872,
-0.2981539369,
0.1868856102,
-0.1137900651,
0.4316956997,
-0.0052731778,
-0.5836896896,
0.5571882725,
-0.1819405854,
1.0008388758,
-0.7421085835,
-0.1694260091,
-0.1915487498,
0.0790332556,
-0.3953680396,
-0.9423928857,
-0.1988417953,
-0.1930863112,
0.0075718951,
0.0479801968,
0.4369298518,
-0.7830406427,
-0.3026368022,
0.2138929814,
0.4734373391,
0.0911046937,
-0.0235072151,
-0.3250329196,
-0.1955730021,
-0.0091859521,
-0.2904482484,
0.032621067,
0.4078227282,
0.0386891067,
0.3761288822,
0.5902352929,
-0.024626404,
0.1175085828,
0.2999800146,
0.9939540029,
-0.3786926568,
-0.760061264,
-0.5619937181,
0.57403332,
-0.015690282,
-0.5850588083,
0.4891366065,
0.5615255237,
0.9837162495,
0.1927832812,
0.7515872121,
0.1641481668,
0.4647895396,
-0.7704094052,
0.3649931252,
-0.6216984391,
0.2420774549,
-0.7533236146,
-0.8860960603,
0.1629754752,
0.5321380496,
-0.3740028441,
0.1906884164,
0.6459078789,
0.5914911628,
-0.3728838563,
0.5281366706,
0.3395340443,
0.2112623155,
-0.050430011,
0.7123932242,
1.0167384148,
-0.6040250063,
0.2650035322,
-0.5089744925,
-0.3626592457,
0.04170008,
-0.3152444959,
-1.1600140333,
-0.6591109633,
-0.364272505,
-0.0806235895,
0.0128890062,
0.8075742126,
0.7966220379,
-0.650411725,
-0.009776419,
-0.270406127,
-0.1044722497,
-0.2833326757,
-0.2881117165,
0.3759253323,
0.182292968,
-0.9147227407,
0.6521157026,
0.0474697798,
0.3117270172,
-0.3904912174,
0.1635208428,
-0.2942149937,
-0.2132161707,
0.5589234829,
-0.1120376438,
-0.6457800269,
-0.2642233968,
0.0289326701,
0.0733763501,
-0.0568059087,
0.6255061626,
-1.0035598278,
0.4558088779,
0.10499461,
0.4852970243,
0.4257460237,
0.2697481513,
0.7505893111,
-0.5774392486,
0.2871078849,
-0.0010311999,
0.4909086227,
0.2943435609,
-0.7689205408,
0.7418856621,
0.0390810333,
-0.3789490163,
-0.7693887353,
0.083286114,
-0.9332587123,
-0.2302941531,
0.9912817478,
-0.0780777633,
0.0864284486,
-0.1440675557,
-0.3250406981,
0.3876901567,
-0.3958213329,
0.6359016895,
0.5904316902,
-0.0885890052,
-0.0596911386,
-0.6167834997,
0.1541389376,
0.4822103679,
-0.8134951591,
-0.2845338583,
0.6060406566,
0.2452471852,
-0.1765869558,
0.5397961736,
0.0710401461,
0.119088605,
-0.0558883697,
-0.0673693046,
-0.4794559181,
-0.5870313048,
-0.2380898893,
0.2201833129,
-0.3763350248,
-0.2978825271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08258v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08258v2
|
Skipformer: A Skip-and-Recover Strategy for Efficient Speech Recognition
| 2024-03-13T05:20:45 | 2024-05-21T02:06:26 |
Wenjing Zhu, Sining Sun, Changhao Shan, Peng Fan, Qing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Conformer-based attention models have become the de facto backbone model for
Automatic Speech Recognition tasks. A blank symbol is usually introduced to
align the input and output sequences for CTC or RNN-T models. Unfortunately,
the long input length overloads computational budget and memory consumption
quadratically by attention mechanism. In this work, we propose a
"Skip-and-Recover" Conformer architecture, named Skipformer, to squeeze
sequence input length dynamically and inhomogeneously. Skipformer uses an
intermediate CTC output as criteria to split frames into three groups: crucial,
skipping and ignoring. The crucial group feeds into next conformer blocks and
its output joint with skipping group by original temporal order as the final
encoder output. Experiments show that our model reduces the input sequence
length by 31 times on Aishell-1 and 22 times on Librispeech corpus. Meanwhile,
the model can achieve better recognition accuracy and faster inference speed
than recent baseline models. Our code is open-sourced and available online.
|
[
-0.2308389097,
-0.3873102963,
0.5016863346,
0.1003907844,
-0.1782617122,
-0.0656512231,
0.0562184826,
-0.3274984658,
0.0233045947,
0.1393472254,
-0.3114680946,
0.0937241018,
-0.8887650371,
-0.0351148732,
-0.5621282458,
0.5834197998,
0.0177361965,
-0.0080699585,
0.4036641717,
-0.0895055756,
-0.6719871163,
-0.1110027656,
-0.9241402149,
-0.0496148616,
0.5602319837,
0.268189311,
0.3857531548,
1.1047121286,
0.1923049986,
0.2839997411,
-0.4992160499,
-0.2641940713,
-0.5541126728,
0.0989320576,
0.273686856,
-0.0581699088,
-0.5379250646,
-0.0249892529,
0.8070985675,
0.4888375401,
-0.1360357553,
0.1867710948,
0.044743944,
0.5978364348,
-0.842074275,
0.1156186759,
-0.5752872229,
-0.1504145861,
-0.1826056093,
0.1938762069,
-0.4830556512,
-0.6138994694,
0.0694118962,
-0.2255099118,
0.2652365565,
-0.2363324761,
0.5687875748,
0.5572465658,
0.0700481087,
-0.1142808199,
-0.881544292,
0.4136294127,
-0.6653165817,
1.0769358873,
0.3079837263,
0.5456001163,
0.1269594282,
-0.5863723755,
-0.6622127295,
-0.050665766,
0.1086389497,
0.1465414912,
-0.2323412001,
-0.0455286093,
0.2754054964,
0.3307361007,
-0.7035129666,
0.0275497977,
-0.743070662,
-0.3622227609,
0.2290263623,
-0.0913686454,
0.1313024759,
0.1407240331,
-0.0203044862,
0.0934456438,
-0.5027793646,
0.2566430271,
0.0727462918,
0.2818448842,
-0.0962352455,
0.3813370764,
0.0281845946,
1.015378356,
0.7168300748,
-0.0816856176,
0.0635881498,
-0.1474395096,
-0.3340002894,
0.4153255522,
0.3502523303,
-0.1578181535,
0.2006490976,
-0.2169124186,
-0.1094739735,
0.084955819,
0.3221539557,
-0.7127796412,
-0.3442786932,
0.2910604179,
-0.3763943315,
0.0456416383,
-0.0416422375,
-0.4652764797,
0.0206256155,
-0.2696447968,
0.3363646269,
-0.5993043184,
0.2567664385,
-0.0283092931,
-0.1460084468,
0.2713846266,
0.4925269186,
-0.5775029659,
0.4736355543,
0.352117002,
1.0687568188,
-0.3871650696,
0.1792047471,
-1.2296175957,
0.211843729,
-0.0287158825,
0.49433887,
-0.4772816598,
-0.5820612311,
-0.4773924351,
0.0363014378,
-0.2212317884,
-0.4811033309,
0.3372315764,
-0.7583335638,
0.2846131027,
0.1791199595,
-0.6921057701,
-0.3506665528,
0.0460599624,
-1.0566140413,
0.4519394636,
-0.0873977393,
-0.4661198556,
0.3056543469,
-0.5962097049,
-0.1820857376,
0.1357482523,
0.1681642979,
-0.5367160439,
0.0434800833,
0.2287723422,
0.1844272316,
-0.0343027897,
-0.0034052914,
-0.428268373,
-0.4967663884,
0.0263111964,
-0.535987258,
0.6467852592,
0.1062871888,
-0.2160479575,
0.1424205899,
-1.1150912046,
-0.1071979702,
-0.0045927106,
-0.8210065365,
-0.1968516856,
-0.0531782433,
0.3849804401,
0.3640878797,
-0.0397689305,
-0.7568114996,
-0.1212998629,
-0.5171518922,
0.535816431,
0.667502284,
-0.0796469226,
0.727147162,
-0.2693532705,
0.3964820802,
-0.0117484955,
0.0549603589,
-0.3005311191,
0.0134708723,
-0.7616112828,
-0.7269564867,
0.5117078424,
0.6371839046,
-0.0732509568,
0.5040083528,
-0.3002050519,
-0.3583771586,
-0.6177309752,
-0.0945501924,
0.3945893645,
0.6252528429,
0.4065805972,
-0.2406950146,
-0.5351204872,
-0.6820864677,
-0.2522636354,
-0.0353837609,
-0.2833531797,
0.1451982409,
0.069318682,
-0.0459551662,
1.0390403271,
-0.3615855873,
-0.3714728653,
-0.2877447009,
-0.3402931392,
0.3480377793,
0.5587276816,
0.1077487394,
-0.7800127864,
-0.3190903962,
-0.2802571654,
-0.0851203874,
0.1148901582,
-0.0210640356,
0.1408342868,
0.1354501843,
0.271376431,
-0.3322712779,
0.6566773653,
0.3143075705,
-0.0316296071,
0.1635364443,
0.2099742591,
-0.1829919368,
-0.7527825236,
0.285274148,
-0.2596637905,
-0.4811875224,
-0.7291412354,
-0.5555645227,
0.2334372848,
-0.1946652085,
-0.5624742508,
0.720593214,
-0.5344848037,
0.0739509538,
-0.3003034294,
0.0210233144,
-0.2468833923,
0.4972331822,
0.1996646971,
0.7718153596,
0.3417465091,
-0.9073673487,
-0.1932630241,
0.3733912408,
0.2188854665,
0.1913646162,
-0.9320143461,
0.4941415489,
-0.3170587718,
0.2300369889,
-1.0886632204,
-0.2791317701,
0.1930937171,
-0.5732235312,
0.5663233995,
-0.2691575289,
-0.0307374466,
-0.3647949398,
-0.1317951083,
0.7353745103,
0.6460658312,
-0.5814223886,
0.8891751766,
0.4276277721,
-0.2392458618,
-0.2726221383,
-0.5259830356,
-0.3408671618,
-0.1102681309,
-0.2829970419,
0.2850168347,
-0.1752024144,
0.0923849717,
-0.2411088049,
-0.5065562129,
-0.2089280933,
-0.3128229082,
0.4338562191,
0.236162439,
-0.0718879104,
-0.0677833483,
-0.0319270864,
0.0277083702,
-0.4008843601,
-0.5726633668,
0.4820975065,
0.0250067338,
-0.0907443166,
-0.5753259063,
0.2435930669,
0.5940095186,
-0.3069107234,
0.2168108225,
0.320015192,
-0.5408214927,
0.1670438796,
-0.7969373465,
0.0150454659,
-0.4396087229,
0.4092054963,
-0.0934022591,
-0.9026106,
0.2695837617,
0.2098615319,
0.3780952692,
0.27085796,
0.4789988101,
0.0948845223,
0.5307211876,
0.6101261377,
-0.1793244332,
0.5156607628,
-0.048818998,
0.0720665976,
-0.8389211893,
-0.1072730422,
-0.3290239573,
-0.4129605889,
0.0645432621,
-0.4889221191,
0.3883383572,
-0.0146951592,
-0.1812785566,
0.4527593851,
-0.4472015202,
0.3778547645,
0.2484725863,
0.0099114366,
0.1283724308,
-0.2805174887,
0.0678630769,
-0.0275733601,
-0.6399676204,
-0.2899974883,
0.6817462444,
0.4130633175,
0.8044994473,
0.0828181505,
0.8689302802,
0.2540627122,
0.197923705,
-0.9718484879,
0.4208091795,
-0.2371217459,
-0.301954031,
-0.4093638062,
-0.2115265727,
-0.7047329545,
0.0195060968,
0.3702235222,
-0.6774237156,
0.4618824124,
0.549739182,
-0.6693488955,
0.1653520465,
-0.3141659498,
0.5072728992,
0.1636710912,
-0.2634563148,
-0.0281487573,
-0.8225374222,
0.5165117979,
-0.2413042933,
0.074616313,
0.1117332354,
0.0189573877,
0.8441520333,
-0.317266345,
0.6288627386,
-0.2981685102,
0.0989618823,
0.1308012158,
0.2643856108,
0.3659368753,
-0.0887940079,
0.1484009922,
0.057040371,
-0.3318268061,
-0.1304531544,
-0.4600874186,
0.3563301265,
-0.3864339888,
-0.3278556168,
-0.1846535355,
-0.5646401048,
-0.240282163,
0.3400653899,
0.2696829438,
0.5352930427,
-0.497020334,
-0.0325799026,
0.7654404044,
0.1765146703,
0.8982320428,
0.6481368542,
0.2548274696,
-0.7379270792,
0.6215593815,
0.1495961994,
0.2396035939,
0.472247541,
-0.04309728,
-0.4427323937,
-0.3475477397,
-0.2985267639,
0.3542335331,
-0.357874155,
-0.1398022771,
-0.9583092332,
-0.4257756472,
-0.5806367397,
0.0008614921,
-0.4842185974,
-0.6747874022,
-0.356097579,
0.0769224018,
0.1337370872,
0.4410218,
-0.1825344414,
0.4885875881,
-1.0457863808,
0.4473448694,
0.4304212034,
0.2834179103,
0.2210120708,
-0.8290052414,
-0.0991893038,
-0.397975117,
-0.3034224808,
-0.9129507542,
0.4771924615,
0.3736206591,
0.4638094902,
0.5069856644,
-0.2145195305,
0.8703558445,
-0.8985753059,
0.2582591474,
0.1666013449,
-1.0597171783,
0.4826797247,
-0.0092016384,
0.6999251842,
0.3744314909,
0.2496230751,
-0.5064783096,
-0.3142358661,
-0.4724211693,
-0.8311169744,
0.8346013427,
0.2175645679,
-0.3946035504,
0.0410476401,
0.25938797,
0.1172896251,
-0.0814559013,
-0.5192629099,
0.1114237458,
-0.2479191869,
-0.3922450542,
-0.0029166644,
-0.236712575,
0.1074494794,
-0.053512916,
0.6051511168,
0.1101201996,
0.3066339791,
0.2627142668,
-0.429777503,
0.2052703053,
0.3223437667,
0.5703193545,
0.1498280913,
-0.1185805649,
-0.1209182739,
0.1179435477,
-0.7334901094,
0.2971198857,
0.3608756065,
-0.2556531429,
0.16113244,
0.1365689784,
0.7674664259,
0.2001895756,
-0.4822846055,
0.2007141709,
-0.1817808598,
-0.1096513867,
-0.5226162076,
0.077810064,
-0.0325993411,
0.2254505605,
0.1968216151,
0.4604787529,
0.5243700147,
0.0241116732,
0.4866301119,
0.1562402397,
-0.650737524,
-0.3272258043,
1.0293626785,
0.0527267344,
-0.5497577786,
0.5487392545,
0.2836956978,
-0.2597858608,
0.4683609307,
0.40214324,
1.1378349066,
-0.6073105931,
-0.3606591225,
0.4191525578,
-0.0051259827,
-0.2570387125,
0.1859060079,
-0.3745498061,
-0.3419647515,
-0.2627950907,
-0.5707264543,
-0.0633633733,
0.1304601729,
-0.7401847243,
0.3525144458,
-0.5656663179,
-0.1045318097,
0.0865141079,
-0.7179093361,
-0.6115435362,
0.2045847923,
0.429811269,
0.9860032797,
-0.319407016,
0.9373856187,
0.1749473065,
-0.1261397302,
-0.7818120122,
0.3142951429,
0.2966795862,
-0.528044045,
0.7948598862,
0.4345436096,
-0.3251840472,
0.0716219544,
-0.2472174764,
-1.1710665226,
0.7897068262,
0.0426123627,
-0.956897974,
-0.4100548625,
-0.4308615029,
0.0421282575,
-0.241061151,
0.0083947768,
0.6079674363,
0.3859514892,
0.2492457032,
-1.0152513981,
0.0090556899,
-0.1547168642,
0.2056876421,
0.2147345245,
-0.4900946021,
0.6431204081,
-0.3646995723,
-0.2881437838,
0.1691357195,
0.7509938478,
0.4572229981,
0.0106096836,
0.8826655149,
0.3206380904,
0.4694371819,
0.127223596,
0.5730135441,
-0.0126423398,
0.0153505746,
1.1823331118,
-0.2867775857,
0.8246557713,
0.2726451755,
0.030234484,
0.1832517982,
0.342884928,
0.0348542742,
0.6965426803,
0.2437672317,
0.1138384119,
-0.1890969872,
0.4089581668,
-0.0613967106,
0.6831122041,
0.2157702893,
-0.3053486347,
-0.196517244,
0.2171653211,
0.0294672903,
-0.2194127738,
-0.407841295,
0.9114152193,
-0.107931219,
-0.4321451783,
0.7455274463,
-0.2009180039,
0.5550590754,
-0.5944805741,
-0.1550746262,
-0.1395383179,
0.4152792692,
0.1324881613,
-0.2415125221,
0.5218402147,
-0.008676854,
-0.6187946796,
-0.0560324565,
0.5286666751,
-0.663575232,
-0.4598444998,
0.1112440452,
0.1096246764,
0.0634809136,
0.0218271893,
-0.3688131571,
0.190641135,
-0.1607112437,
-0.0506354049,
-0.047565978,
0.081097357,
-0.0553505197,
0.4922844768,
0.4053775072,
0.0174064189,
0.3446345329,
0.0567202494,
0.8340047002,
-0.6848341823,
-0.9373500347,
-0.8014170527,
0.5804818273,
0.0694722086,
0.0307368655,
0.4213196039,
0.8022126555,
0.5347355008,
-0.2385817468,
0.7259945869,
0.0225558039,
0.885492444,
-0.4570668638,
0.7832291126,
-0.4716719389,
-0.0303711668,
-0.2824592292,
-0.5940029621,
-0.3385124803,
0.4579658508,
-0.0008098389,
0.0371205062,
0.3286471069,
0.4348292649,
-0.2472722977,
0.0317300931,
0.2782123089,
0.3667531013,
0.3979747295,
0.7492041588,
0.4765998423,
-0.4382009804,
0.5793046355,
0.1646155864,
-0.4641045332,
-0.0188872181,
-0.5098885894,
-0.7062873244,
-0.4376590848,
-0.3303856552,
-0.4229657948,
0.2179113328,
0.7039714456,
0.7976076007,
-0.904976666,
-0.1724134386,
0.0191193633,
-0.1042061001,
-0.2910537124,
-0.2419224381,
0.3010922074,
-0.1820736527,
-0.8755124807,
0.6110736728,
0.6398025155,
0.3906769454,
0.0956938341,
-0.0080962926,
-0.0397990979,
0.1679360867,
0.3390626609,
0.6536638141,
-0.8664320111,
-0.0124913706,
0.2393196225,
0.2038329244,
0.0707974434,
0.9458941221,
-1.1430761814,
0.2875083685,
0.4140152037,
0.7946658134,
0.5001605749,
-0.0418916084,
0.665951252,
-0.4618059695,
0.1851216406,
0.524790287,
0.4353982806,
0.1903490573,
-0.4832333326,
0.2651630342,
0.2314368188,
-0.5370396972,
-0.6602289081,
0.2412996739,
-1.2791616917,
0.021564886,
0.8488016129,
-0.0029494474,
-0.2773829401,
-0.260920763,
-0.2430936545,
0.4166665971,
-0.6692945957,
0.7181425691,
0.3640237749,
-0.2956466377,
-0.3934993744,
-0.0744368583,
0.4608074725,
0.0885244161,
-0.3614107668,
0.1836463213,
0.6857228875,
0.5702161789,
0.1648447365,
0.918204546,
-0.374650985,
0.6117986441,
-0.1722612232,
-0.0645707324,
-0.3069155514,
-0.4600160122,
-0.6873578429,
0.3641823232,
-0.4282686412,
-0.6160680056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08229v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08229v1
|
Boosting Disfluency Detection with Large Language Model as Disfluency Generator
| 2024-03-13T04:14:33 | 2024-03-13T04:14:33 |
Zhenrong Cheng, Jiayan Guo, Hao Sun, Yan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current disfluency detection methods heavily rely on costly and scarce
human-annotated data. To tackle this issue, some approaches employ heuristic or
statistical features to generate disfluent sentences, partially improving
detection performance. However, these sentences often deviate from real-life
scenarios, constraining overall model enhancement. In this study, we propose a
lightweight data augmentation approach for disfluency detection, utilizing the
superior generative and semantic understanding capabilities of large language
model (LLM) to generate disfluent sentences as augmentation data. We leverage
LLM to generate diverse and more realistic sentences guided by specific
prompts, without the need for fine-tuning the LLM. Subsequently, we apply an
uncertainty-aware data filtering approach to improve the quality of the
generated sentences, utilized in training a small detection model for improved
performance. Experiments using enhanced data yielded state-of-the-art results.
The results showed that using a small amount of LLM-generated enhanced data can
significantly improve performance, thereby further enhancing
cost-effectiveness.
|
[
-0.3339956403,
-1.0295759439,
0.6011871696,
0.1023403257,
-0.2372936457,
0.0632686391,
-0.1241469979,
-0.7224538326,
0.1276500523,
0.2646605372,
-0.749619782,
-0.3125591576,
-0.7065806985,
0.1974949539,
-0.4107448161,
0.8155582547,
0.1449600756,
0.0245001297,
-0.1087052375,
0.039701581,
-0.4344758093,
-0.2219874412,
-0.5265433788,
-0.3712619245,
0.187531516,
0.5927419066,
0.912340939,
0.5341537595,
0.4285362065,
0.443513006,
-0.3577189445,
0.280143261,
-0.4070564806,
0.1979489923,
-0.00276985,
-0.3681818247,
-0.5347203612,
-0.4898165166,
0.5389527082,
0.5943889618,
-0.1504791379,
-0.2193726301,
0.0340212472,
0.6286051869,
-0.4671927094,
0.089957647,
-0.8807961345,
0.2548595071,
-0.2205083072,
0.2946376801,
-0.1370337605,
-0.0862500668,
-0.2701489627,
-0.5456081629,
0.3889443874,
-0.0144871771,
0.7074905038,
0.5066996217,
-0.2234024704,
-0.1751474589,
-0.4919238389,
0.457483232,
-0.9154817462,
0.2456994653,
0.4256357551,
0.1605364978,
-0.3479047418,
-0.5010480881,
-0.9990192056,
-0.4451209009,
-0.1589034051,
-0.050199572,
-0.2245441824,
0.1473844796,
0.5871711969,
0.705221653,
-0.433933109,
0.63072294,
0.0180344936,
-0.3872434795,
0.5883456469,
0.2493969202,
0.3608425558,
-0.3054697514,
-0.4195774198,
-0.3007290065,
-0.4461405873,
-0.3646734953,
0.493429333,
0.259318471,
0.014312054,
0.5473905206,
-0.6095121503,
0.6809809804,
-0.0525089093,
-0.3087617755,
0.370490104,
-0.3660066426,
-0.1278775632,
0.1272757947,
0.5951422453,
0.239518106,
0.0614978336,
-0.09092094,
-0.5145332813,
0.2220040709,
0.1445802152,
-0.9377458096,
-0.2376612723,
0.1316561848,
-0.2596467137,
-0.5552039742,
-0.0830513164,
-0.9673274159,
-0.842408061,
-0.3266358972,
0.2898067832,
-0.6734223962,
-0.3926330209,
0.2373376191,
-0.0043967292,
-0.1956739128,
0.2667624652,
-0.8349342942,
0.0043383832,
0.4431418478,
0.8129585385,
-0.1844747365,
0.1187153757,
-0.719271183,
-0.0056618871,
-0.1707498729,
0.6330556273,
-0.1522179097,
-0.1172928065,
0.1041118354,
-0.0877965465,
0.5657501817,
-0.7102595568,
0.9136190414,
-0.1415312141,
-0.0143054044,
0.0521449633,
-0.4332525134,
0.1663393825,
0.1927262694,
-0.838475883,
1.0413807631,
0.4881911576,
-0.8579378128,
0.7148293257,
-0.3698856533,
-0.6324999332,
0.4642933905,
-0.0515748449,
-0.8544865251,
0.1955592185,
0.6370158792,
0.5921810865,
-0.1039628908,
0.5968567133,
-0.7108550668,
-0.2975473106,
0.311450243,
-0.707321763,
0.5857852101,
0.1505337507,
-0.2549644411,
-0.1033469588,
-1.0825328827,
-0.4158843458,
0.1317465752,
-0.2879810333,
-0.3304975033,
-0.0494587943,
0.2820177674,
0.1787607521,
0.1471252441,
-0.710552752,
0.1802572906,
-0.55964607,
0.1457993388,
0.697586596,
-0.0856099203,
0.197046712,
-0.2257187665,
0.3194008172,
0.2656480372,
0.0667105466,
-0.0102466149,
-0.1767031252,
-0.6544499993,
-0.5782117844,
0.0765828788,
0.3333356082,
-1.212174058,
0.6774986982,
-0.2024774253,
-0.0918124765,
-0.4855215251,
0.2856594622,
0.213639915,
0.951748848,
0.4614443481,
0.0065523302,
-0.6252232194,
-0.8697071075,
-0.0313871577,
-0.2164906114,
-0.150616467,
-0.0883244723,
0.4584316909,
-0.3053967953,
0.8253822327,
-0.7781887054,
-0.4922537506,
-0.2893110812,
0.2054813355,
-0.1136824787,
0.4983412325,
0.4548732638,
-0.910353899,
-0.1120692194,
-0.1002058163,
-0.579839766,
-0.3612214923,
-0.2795147896,
0.1752786636,
0.3089326024,
0.5271094441,
-0.5871352553,
0.4834632277,
0.4584878385,
-0.3697894216,
0.6050661206,
-0.2785089314,
0.171199888,
-1.3093217611,
-0.1400730461,
0.1094908416,
-0.551056385,
-0.4817737341,
-0.108218275,
0.1016532481,
-0.0233938657,
-0.2591482699,
0.0593970418,
-0.4092026353,
-0.0776208639,
-0.4129784703,
0.2507390082,
0.0920901746,
0.0400582924,
0.0368727259,
0.5657038689,
0.4913400114,
-0.4067246616,
0.5205976963,
0.2886700332,
-0.5516518354,
0.573130846,
-0.6215721369,
-0.3114467859,
-0.1839762479,
0.2545552552,
-1.1974629164,
-0.5640691519,
0.1828029603,
-0.1863079369,
0.3753030598,
-0.1409434229,
-0.8786434531,
-0.4777001441,
-0.3764918745,
0.0678798407,
0.4580843747,
-0.7617263198,
0.115845345,
0.1629508138,
-0.268404305,
-0.4832268655,
-0.891490221,
0.1966503859,
-0.4641214907,
-0.7089992762,
0.6949278712,
-0.0979643241,
-0.16720061,
-0.2579434812,
-0.1674904674,
-0.1832330078,
0.4328680336,
0.2246781886,
0.4930797815,
-0.1435183436,
0.5532303452,
0.2096283138,
-0.0362033173,
-0.1548532695,
0.1442943066,
0.4967457652,
0.1306131482,
-0.5074291825,
-0.4499251544,
0.2390075773,
0.5086494088,
0.0863604471,
0.6526980996,
0.8884404898,
-0.5732260942,
-0.2757438421,
-0.54755193,
-0.5036562085,
-0.5422780514,
0.6874448061,
-0.2017305195,
-0.95236063,
0.4592378139,
-0.2109291404,
-0.2710627913,
0.2010054737,
0.5566966534,
-0.0493933447,
1.0451351404,
0.4571201503,
-0.3884503543,
0.7868783474,
0.1849336326,
0.0886445642,
-0.6161553264,
0.1341077387,
-0.2921913862,
-0.2028489858,
-0.3550484478,
-0.4696103632,
0.302955091,
0.2851960957,
0.1478258669,
0.139902845,
-0.6057489514,
0.2744950652,
-0.0084923739,
0.5822142363,
0.5755435824,
0.1397300959,
0.3378946781,
-0.1476348042,
-0.4429258108,
-0.3841060996,
0.7701055408,
0.4447986484,
0.8997593522,
0.1745645702,
0.4768278599,
0.362978071,
0.1570320278,
-0.6419650316,
0.3138298392,
-0.1314453632,
-0.2647266984,
-0.2747615278,
-0.7033052444,
-0.7065317631,
0.2589873075,
-0.5597729683,
-0.7654033899,
0.182740286,
0.278601408,
-0.1582676172,
0.2592404485,
-0.5798652172,
0.6046115756,
-0.1583822668,
-0.2746411562,
-0.2093477398,
-0.2874623239,
0.7260967493,
-0.156527102,
0.0731776729,
-0.0406821519,
0.0648591146,
0.3951420486,
-0.6321761608,
0.848287046,
-0.245320946,
-0.369441241,
0.0530183055,
-0.1312208027,
0.8352308273,
0.298422128,
-0.0969422013,
-0.2010893822,
-0.5104442239,
-0.1253702641,
-0.5533279777,
0.6292344928,
-0.3250367343,
-0.4977146387,
-0.1264294386,
-0.9150961041,
-0.3488997519,
-0.0528196432,
0.1889851838,
0.4116882682,
-0.144941166,
0.1556093246,
0.9093652964,
-0.2437102944,
0.6466100216,
0.4410420358,
-0.1597948521,
-0.1362614185,
0.7710857987,
-0.0503986031,
0.3616875112,
0.2517764568,
0.1415660381,
-0.4277241826,
-0.8215282559,
-0.6288006902,
-0.0486266911,
-0.5350424647,
-0.4422045946,
-0.6879162788,
0.2070067227,
-0.6106110811,
0.127684623,
-0.1739691198,
-0.5049266815,
-0.2547211349,
-0.3233181536,
0.8239580989,
0.4108592868,
-0.051404696,
0.4829646945,
-0.5513708591,
0.7706454396,
0.2817230225,
0.2619277239,
-0.1984383315,
-0.6024034619,
-0.0872746259,
0.2411494553,
-0.3074959219,
-0.7880650759,
0.4464712739,
0.1849299818,
0.3416850269,
0.3406283855,
0.335031122,
0.9060297012,
-0.2477019429,
0.607583344,
0.3297552466,
-0.9013268352,
0.6763320565,
-0.1081876159,
0.1358316094,
0.5525258183,
0.0552956462,
-0.1472875476,
-0.5841193199,
-0.4161833525,
-1.0685740709,
0.9143076539,
0.1361736208,
0.1110847592,
0.2173247784,
0.281072557,
0.0258063097,
0.1004316285,
-0.804844439,
-0.0045086863,
-0.0061908527,
-0.4171631932,
0.0116667943,
-0.1382648796,
-0.0404773802,
-0.2004825771,
0.6365947127,
-0.285787791,
-0.0535213761,
0.1816651374,
-0.5498875976,
-0.1568912268,
0.2398867011,
0.4543094337,
0.2157163769,
-0.0389383659,
-0.1144196317,
0.323923856,
-0.4553466737,
0.1550933868,
0.4778556228,
-0.0722434744,
0.1509989947,
0.3802758455,
0.9563177824,
-0.1136395261,
-0.9097124934,
0.6673079133,
-0.0167598519,
-0.044160895,
-0.1683186144,
0.0582189448,
0.0774453431,
0.3031662703,
0.2988097668,
-0.2071845829,
0.4821045101,
-0.3808731735,
0.5137767792,
0.5059189796,
-0.2363188863,
0.0887350664,
0.4950714707,
0.0027120954,
-0.080061987,
0.6117363572,
-0.1509430259,
-0.4486691356,
0.5885366201,
0.7014409304,
0.4913425744,
-0.2330548018,
0.2694500685,
0.0473517887,
0.265735954,
-0.1746865809,
0.1435876787,
-0.0678955466,
-0.7648532391,
-0.5809291005,
-0.6655296683,
-0.1095735356,
0.4618309438,
-0.6801507473,
0.2593495846,
-0.2646485269,
-0.0287283771,
0.0763315111,
-0.2376369089,
-0.4127069116,
0.2687041759,
0.3322989643,
0.5796094537,
-1.1749300957,
0.7195271254,
0.5183282495,
-0.6005626321,
-0.6071779728,
0.2958541512,
-0.0726315379,
-0.6963990927,
0.6095288396,
0.3301845491,
0.0598247498,
-0.3353200555,
-0.3410633802,
-0.4373927116,
1.0396802425,
0.8659589291,
-0.8675842285,
0.0983492061,
0.2277302444,
0.6100703478,
-0.1710405648,
0.1579620093,
0.509552598,
0.3344204724,
0.0789990351,
-0.5569814444,
0.3687475026,
0.0096681323,
0.1698208302,
0.2000049353,
-0.2692852616,
0.7373185158,
0.0069973702,
-0.2210366577,
-0.0653524175,
0.6528921723,
0.2182053775,
0.3281063437,
0.7441946864,
0.8326882124,
0.861286521,
-0.0746153072,
1.1513798237,
0.023884315,
0.2336461842,
1.0956838131,
-0.2730670571,
0.5107185841,
0.4319428802,
-0.1387189776,
0.4262748957,
0.5030853152,
-0.0810712576,
0.2428802848,
0.346188128,
-0.547311008,
-0.3429138362,
-0.2043846846,
-0.2186018229,
0.3778297007,
0.4478455782,
-0.4917048216,
-0.27373752,
0.4061784744,
-0.0403905995,
0.1399530321,
-0.2778665423,
0.8949430585,
-0.1882181913,
-0.3327150941,
0.7383500338,
-0.1315184385,
1.008310914,
-0.3224515021,
-0.1859544963,
-0.2717444897,
0.3421576023,
-0.3982766569,
-0.7384461761,
0.3329302967,
0.0760021582,
-0.2908077538,
-0.1230981722,
1.0764137506,
-0.5801426172,
-0.5451549292,
0.1348434687,
0.3793956935,
0.0281130448,
-0.2729012668,
-0.6476359367,
0.163509652,
-0.0485284925,
-0.1329285204,
0.6168810129,
0.5905349851,
-0.0643499121,
0.6027423143,
0.5677965283,
0.1830891669,
-0.2142689079,
0.2967213094,
1.09316504,
-0.0434405878,
-0.3042135239,
-0.9833674431,
0.6147400141,
-0.5646095276,
-0.2233145982,
0.477412194,
0.2378300279,
0.6883080006,
-0.1420577914,
0.6671777368,
-0.2702552974,
0.4020993412,
-0.5244423747,
0.6382353306,
-0.5694584846,
0.3282568455,
-0.4446947575,
-0.7130334973,
-0.2260470837,
0.6871170402,
-0.0026807582,
-0.0305269193,
0.3230210245,
1.062522769,
-0.2193561643,
-0.0996531025,
0.5368617773,
0.3317478001,
0.2599796653,
0.4002896845,
0.6942968965,
-0.3620724082,
0.5647432208,
-0.2972750366,
-0.2858156562,
-0.2870518267,
-0.8621758223,
-0.6850178242,
-0.4850159287,
-0.5157099962,
-0.261441201,
-0.097034514,
0.6866359711,
0.6970831752,
-0.6581048369,
0.4718208015,
-0.5468800068,
0.12819013,
-0.1555286199,
-0.3236099184,
0.1642484367,
-0.5056948662,
-0.7718191743,
0.5622614026,
0.0060442765,
0.2258457392,
-0.3216046691,
0.1341939121,
-0.0191230588,
-0.3480477035,
0.6521057487,
-0.1377151161,
-0.4847579896,
-0.3851109743,
-0.4461917579,
-0.0545695126,
0.0199576747,
0.6738057733,
-0.8454173207,
0.4850854576,
0.3469102979,
0.8428080678,
0.3945582211,
0.0781651884,
0.4708147645,
-1.1752940416,
0.3630886376,
0.322832495,
0.5522129536,
0.6926630735,
-0.8059806228,
0.3145465255,
0.3927387595,
-0.3748841286,
-1.1136137247,
0.4346086979,
-0.8223384619,
-0.5071031451,
1.0527582169,
-0.3176534772,
0.0441980734,
-0.161849007,
-0.3622487485,
0.4863354862,
-0.4956287146,
0.9889551997,
0.5830067992,
-0.0784602612,
-0.1979305148,
-0.3135355413,
0.5486534834,
0.5347849131,
-1.0465252399,
0.3419355452,
0.8830792308,
0.1754900664,
0.0608742237,
0.1663797498,
0.0172235798,
0.0799197257,
0.1226219162,
0.1114416718,
-0.2672344744,
0.0184851587,
-0.5150093436,
0.0705389529,
0.010666362,
-0.1358804703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08217v1
|
Research on the Application of Deep Learning-based BERT Model in Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-13T03:31:26 | 2024-03-13T03:31:26 |
Yichao Wu, Zhengyu Jin, Chenxi Shi, Penghao Liang, Tong Zhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper explores the application of deep learning techniques, particularly
focusing on BERT models, in sentiment analysis. It begins by introducing the
fundamental concept of sentiment analysis and how deep learning methods are
utilized in this domain. Subsequently, it delves into the architecture and
characteristics of BERT models. Through detailed explanation, it elucidates the
application effects and optimization strategies of BERT models in sentiment
analysis, supported by experimental validation. The experimental findings
indicate that BERT models exhibit robust performance in sentiment analysis
tasks, with notable enhancements post fine-tuning. Lastly, the paper concludes
by summarizing the potential applications of BERT models in sentiment analysis
and suggests directions for future research and practical implementations.
|
[
-0.5270705223,
-0.749303937,
0.3720936179,
0.3616694808,
-0.503970921,
0.0036642887,
-0.3399350643,
-0.5147638917,
-0.0842107907,
0.2327613086,
-0.9020678997,
-0.4956201315,
-0.3888424635,
-0.4411297739,
-0.2434557974,
0.9252594113,
0.25219208,
0.6993082762,
0.0673560351,
0.0225513186,
-0.5081430674,
-0.5426746011,
-0.6682661772,
-0.2829682231,
0.6370882988,
0.1775654405,
0.667378366,
-0.3147314787,
0.8385232091,
0.2755815089,
-0.2283825427,
-0.1197018921,
-0.3690793216,
0.2500743866,
0.1540093273,
-0.32910344,
-0.396710217,
0.2455954105,
0.6321412921,
0.8584748507,
0.244045943,
-0.0103032254,
0.2104101032,
0.6660327911,
-0.3299471736,
0.0933367088,
-0.624864161,
0.4032776356,
0.0777783394,
0.1499696374,
-0.3993032575,
-0.7510789633,
0.6249334812,
0.1060092747,
0.2868677974,
-0.314743489,
0.9356160164,
0.0495403558,
-0.0802301094,
-0.4686906338,
-0.6358281374,
1.2250478268,
-1.2645637989,
0.3596056402,
-0.2982545495,
0.2986211777,
0.193988502,
-0.5187396407,
-0.5368844867,
-0.2975244522,
0.1330195814,
0.2350609452,
0.2301922739,
0.172815606,
-0.2589139044,
0.742462635,
-0.3380678892,
0.3112262487,
-0.0148018273,
0.2178361416,
0.5927146077,
0.2547423542,
-0.1928851306,
-0.2888374627,
-0.4542523324,
-0.164363414,
-0.0463590547,
0.3995895386,
0.2537856698,
0.7837238312,
0.1207534447,
0.1972103715,
-0.020901259,
0.526853919,
-0.1532566547,
0.3969088495,
0.4492846429,
0.211228326,
-0.6868934035,
-0.3460710943,
0.5429981351,
0.3661119044,
0.297221601,
0.1706012189,
-0.2941637933,
-0.0395803228,
0.4689434171,
-0.748088479,
-0.2406573743,
0.2268105596,
-1.2050628662,
-0.8642630577,
-0.2573486269,
-0.8734193444,
-0.4869530201,
-0.3982456923,
0.3270356059,
-0.4908464551,
-0.4250461459,
0.1207091883,
-0.2399316281,
0.6051930785,
0.3561205864,
-0.5743531585,
0.2285555154,
0.916292727,
0.6181026101,
0.0688705221,
-0.0564539246,
0.1189192981,
-0.7067582011,
-0.490727216,
0.4610212743,
-0.5572826266,
-0.346796155,
0.4038728476,
-0.2416744679,
0.2339074165,
-0.2749455273,
0.8447349668,
-0.8848642707,
-0.1580730528,
-0.4523925185,
-0.9721804857,
-0.693872273,
0.5376996994,
-0.487608552,
0.6215015054,
-0.246803537,
-0.520431459,
0.4747086167,
-0.7811866403,
-0.5868343115,
-0.2375289649,
0.3550952077,
-0.6443656087,
0.9484421611,
0.3715575635,
1.0539833307,
0.1735117882,
0.1176132038,
-0.687539041,
-0.2777495086,
0.5670647621,
-0.3898611963,
1.1471062899,
0.6121266484,
-0.1459456235,
-0.1391167492,
-0.3614310622,
0.2031313479,
0.0106759258,
-0.1817420423,
-0.4479424655,
0.313398689,
0.2131788284,
-0.1429706514,
0.4628301561,
-0.662112534,
0.2241735458,
-0.488191098,
0.2428327203,
0.7584820986,
0.0331619382,
0.3135212064,
0.1803195328,
0.1118696854,
-0.0459901243,
0.4572714567,
0.1258620024,
-0.3966760635,
-0.9257537723,
-0.1628612578,
0.8549765348,
0.2838925123,
-0.1188002825,
0.651671946,
0.0195914079,
-0.6086426973,
-0.7653993964,
-0.0513450615,
-0.1666983515,
0.4368560612,
0.1708469391,
-0.4532354474,
-0.6542189717,
-0.8968049288,
-0.3035149276,
0.0344287269,
0.4273654819,
0.3174111247,
0.2267891616,
-0.3834224343,
0.8809388876,
-0.4185341001,
-0.0999484211,
-0.384996593,
0.6876420975,
0.5151959062,
0.4337626994,
0.7932940125,
-0.6537483931,
-0.3582340181,
-0.2163827419,
-0.8017981052,
0.4082864821,
-0.1197502464,
-0.0487938225,
0.106631726,
0.0413630754,
-0.265376091,
0.2222346067,
0.4643887281,
0.1124325916,
0.3390673101,
0.1413334757,
-0.1983257383,
-0.6412738562,
-0.166331023,
0.2524207532,
-0.1237470731,
-0.6097692847,
0.2859168053,
-0.1314025968,
-0.2438854724,
-0.2701034546,
0.0500343256,
0.0004106243,
0.0582914986,
-0.4927917421,
-0.4272425175,
-0.0128101287,
0.3750315905,
0.1690474004,
0.2701127529,
0.6296703219,
-0.3522510827,
0.4193001688,
-0.0703663081,
-0.6097662449,
0.0786959678,
-0.4782464802,
0.0356782898,
-0.1320046484,
-0.2042521387,
-1.4550118446,
0.1851208955,
0.0988980234,
-0.7686554193,
0.4221903384,
0.2113673538,
-0.5033547878,
-0.5857673287,
-0.7035967112,
-0.1448284686,
0.8916019797,
-0.6509938836,
0.5819664001,
0.1747373044,
-0.2834566236,
-0.6205741167,
-0.761095643,
-0.0274819192,
-0.1981405318,
-0.4244362414,
-0.0030891616,
-0.0304299984,
-0.2115414292,
0.0500367358,
0.3408845067,
-0.2528157234,
0.3039845228,
0.0048440476,
0.1093879566,
-0.2997719347,
0.3851665258,
0.2102129906,
0.2654718459,
0.3325926363,
0.1016609371,
0.4090161324,
-0.4412732124,
0.0147108985,
-0.6127803326,
0.5156727433,
0.4314469099,
-0.026998302,
0.5297239423,
0.8630864024,
-0.2330414206,
-0.2768335342,
-0.7441905737,
-0.2233617902,
-0.4643139839,
0.4797194898,
-0.0070254221,
-0.5707058907,
0.460873574,
-0.4760684669,
-0.0039198287,
0.4586037099,
0.7101038098,
-0.9316592216,
1.0571624041,
0.9039668441,
-0.7091807127,
0.7488968968,
-0.4395800531,
0.4653664827,
-0.7063819766,
0.0591272786,
-0.433519125,
-0.6631116271,
-0.4002928138,
0.0864392594,
-0.0415544324,
0.0568651184,
-0.2788755298,
-0.2901120782,
-0.6396722794,
-0.0414396189,
0.6829717755,
0.3915137053,
-0.3117289245,
0.1526125222,
-0.2203692943,
-0.3005836308,
-0.3380655944,
-0.423343569,
0.9961469173,
0.8598614335,
0.9485445619,
-0.3069719672,
0.7653613687,
0.8484569788,
0.21081236,
-1.11619699,
0.543263495,
-0.4636789858,
-0.6248418093,
-0.296941191,
-0.0334185325,
-0.519055903,
-0.0078390175,
-0.0146880057,
-0.2663428485,
0.5007527471,
-0.0455379374,
-0.3857923448,
0.1681200564,
-0.717857182,
0.5862541795,
-0.5430877805,
0.0428287312,
-0.4209801257,
-0.6967417598,
0.2013233602,
0.2846593857,
0.0948157832,
-0.0602811985,
0.4722264707,
0.7213687897,
-0.1478904635,
1.4586088657,
-0.8471876979,
-0.2114194334,
0.4485978782,
-0.2061860859,
0.3857980669,
0.0678911433,
-0.4220485091,
0.3425016701,
-0.6240521073,
-0.1748905629,
-0.4582187533,
0.8177343011,
-0.9207822084,
-0.2840544283,
-0.2692855,
-0.6097897887,
-0.4251060188,
0.0156123051,
-0.2245703638,
0.1376702338,
-0.2978401184,
0.1890704632,
0.8330395818,
-0.2105694264,
0.7345322967,
0.0421301723,
-0.1012330204,
-0.431230545,
0.8140363693,
0.0570390597,
-0.1579864472,
0.3778424263,
0.3722594082,
-0.1992544532,
-0.7294777632,
-0.1451612115,
-0.0178433824,
-0.6599263549,
-0.2895642221,
-0.3354924321,
-0.1652483046,
-0.4608084559,
-0.3474646509,
-0.2853908539,
-0.3225682378,
-0.2836697698,
-0.129802376,
0.4025684893,
0.5450811386,
-0.1020902619,
0.3558020294,
-0.6981265545,
0.2479671985,
0.7826170325,
0.4839226007,
0.4552393556,
-0.075050272,
-0.2474761903,
0.2280961126,
-0.3736239672,
-0.7514827251,
0.5415862799,
0.1145748273,
0.5452142358,
0.4954151511,
-0.1248566583,
0.4697359502,
-0.2275268286,
1.0003731251,
0.0395249613,
-1.214471817,
0.7251288891,
-0.2960262299,
-0.1708485037,
0.5413216352,
0.3099826574,
-0.0663943291,
-0.1494974345,
-0.2579587996,
-0.571765542,
0.3292078674,
-0.0319093987,
0.669906795,
0.1949140131,
0.537733376,
0.2037555575,
0.4014589787,
-0.687274456,
-0.0959946439,
-0.4396081269,
-0.4245227575,
0.0320223868,
-0.7141574025,
0.1313212812,
-0.6408917904,
0.6993505955,
-0.012457964,
0.6351203918,
0.1217600554,
-0.0408388339,
-0.0038949631,
0.1713642925,
0.3229752779,
0.1251564473,
-0.6074883938,
-0.4542809427,
0.2973094583,
-0.1141503155,
-0.4294031262,
0.1167932451,
-0.013522693,
0.1809950322,
0.3640788496,
0.5212901831,
-0.0485327505,
-0.4234313965,
0.5611922145,
-0.0680526346,
-0.1172557324,
-0.3964543939,
-0.1823001951,
0.1202343479,
0.5720880628,
0.3955450356,
0.2521647811,
0.590736866,
-0.6560322046,
-0.185251087,
0.9430015683,
-0.8442789912,
-0.0930342525,
0.0639091879,
0.2711074054,
0.0502563566,
0.9088514447,
0.1074517593,
-0.6995758414,
0.704067409,
0.0514328219,
0.9359225631,
-0.0788353011,
0.0448775627,
-0.1766047031,
0.1325266808,
0.4127661586,
0.8751938939,
-0.0406798162,
-0.752505064,
-0.4949188828,
-0.7079039216,
-0.4911503196,
0.1447220594,
-0.8159617782,
0.1243246719,
-0.5186436176,
-0.4690572917,
0.1783123016,
0.2597400546,
-0.8496445417,
0.7315961123,
0.5804592967,
0.9451913238,
-0.8392757177,
0.9216278195,
0.6756029725,
-0.186622411,
-0.5400798917,
0.0250688065,
-0.4053792357,
-0.8614477515,
1.004585743,
0.1685736179,
-0.0345235169,
-0.3355940878,
-1.0246129036,
-0.3006874621,
0.6053965092,
-0.1645067185,
-0.3908411562,
0.1703360528,
0.0074072666,
0.8861108422,
-0.5026614666,
-0.1161915138,
0.37566486,
0.5105122924,
-0.2098749578,
-0.3543556631,
-0.3323449492,
-0.2336721867,
0.1916422546,
-0.114827469,
-0.7314416766,
1.1330605745,
-0.0182082057,
0.5234784484,
0.3305923939,
0.9525914192,
-0.2335110158,
0.1621380299,
0.3326386213,
0.718711853,
0.6473586559,
-0.0682606474,
0.7617374659,
0.0339683332,
0.8529614806,
0.7193980813,
-0.3828334808,
0.9219636321,
0.3453422189,
-0.0764888003,
0.8025094271,
0.5660401583,
-0.5419594646,
1.1268599033,
0.1856233478,
-0.1900084764,
-0.2245064825,
0.0222433358,
-0.4692383707,
0.3917928338,
0.668605268,
-0.8632156849,
-0.0295157582,
0.3232933581,
-0.2235180736,
-0.2162014842,
-0.6931052804,
0.8117405176,
0.0257215369,
-0.1449470818,
0.1380886585,
-0.0708994567,
0.8829551935,
-0.3918213844,
-0.0744914189,
0.0039802641,
0.5427445173,
-0.0127787273,
-0.9095262885,
0.23038432,
-0.2208380252,
-0.2620494962,
-0.2584425211,
1.1151641607,
0.2726280391,
-0.8479406834,
0.4472986758,
0.3520830572,
-0.2024711519,
-0.1277645379,
-0.9724089503,
0.0980861783,
0.0676277652,
-0.4390355945,
0.0110957483,
0.6851809621,
0.4255027473,
0.3338478506,
0.505910635,
-0.0176513456,
0.0830805972,
0.4255613685,
1.0076762438,
-0.9602224827,
-0.2123811245,
-1.0208859444,
0.6190455556,
-0.2095052898,
-0.0809898973,
0.8437582254,
0.2972273529,
0.5742868185,
-0.573030293,
1.1537593603,
-0.0330765694,
0.907740891,
-0.2973812222,
0.8241160512,
-0.359595269,
-0.1425573081,
-0.5177853703,
-0.4364641607,
-0.6646952629,
0.8408661485,
-0.5098930597,
0.2214558125,
0.235148266,
0.2333983183,
0.1622974277,
0.4053630531,
0.0903043672,
0.2255269736,
0.1671214253,
0.130463779,
1.1093894243,
-0.4622834623,
0.0551116392,
-0.6264129877,
0.0829888657,
-0.6774144769,
-0.8635338545,
-1.1710323095,
-0.3128730953,
-0.0749769881,
-0.0333845392,
0.137727946,
0.5534893274,
0.8034134507,
-0.9763051271,
-0.1048175767,
-0.0890750811,
-0.034045741,
-0.5392311811,
-0.3271269202,
0.3794139922,
-1.0806291103,
-0.6593931317,
0.0509522408,
-0.232693553,
-0.048547186,
-0.4585004449,
0.2034007758,
-0.1448689699,
0.2821163237,
0.8075307012,
-0.2375986278,
-0.6646689177,
-0.2534125149,
-0.0079960311,
0.0890280232,
-0.0141943935,
0.9368740916,
-1.0208156109,
0.3901157081,
0.6778655648,
0.7568051815,
0.2854836583,
-0.0755594298,
0.4793464243,
-0.8946759701,
-0.1421571076,
0.5552310348,
0.478049159,
0.25366202,
-0.4955235124,
0.211495772,
-0.23861821,
-0.5573458672,
-0.6772310138,
-0.1006550342,
-1.2365641594,
-0.6202200055,
0.5740341544,
-0.1472823471,
0.080665648,
0.1919047087,
-0.2740575373,
0.2431120276,
-0.5823795795,
1.047593832,
0.7653591633,
-0.3073294163,
-0.2005052865,
-0.3341844082,
0.2302893847,
0.6322717667,
-0.3397437036,
-0.1572474539,
0.0416052341,
0.0169252157,
0.1798011512,
0.0150102451,
0.0378197618,
-0.0722961649,
-0.3036148846,
0.2770925462,
0.1398288906,
-0.1029510945,
-0.6755313277,
0.5775838494,
0.3183387816,
-0.4736655653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08213v1
|
Can Large Language Models Identify Authorship?
| 2024-03-13T03:22:02 | 2024-03-13T03:22:02 |
Baixiang Huang, Canyu Chen, Kai Shu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ability to accurately identify authorship is crucial for verifying
content authenticity and mitigating misinformation. Large Language Models
(LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional capacity for reasoning and
problem-solving. However, their potential in authorship analysis, encompassing
authorship verification and attribution, remains underexplored. This paper
conducts a comprehensive evaluation of LLMs in these critical tasks.
Traditional studies have depended on hand-crafted stylistic features, whereas
state-of-the-art approaches leverage text embeddings from pre-trained language
models. These methods, which typically require fine-tuning on labeled data,
often suffer from performance degradation in cross-domain applications and
provide limited explainability. This work seeks to address three research
questions: (1) Can LLMs perform zero-shot, end-to-end authorship verification
effectively? (2) Are LLMs capable of accurately attributing authorship among
multiple candidates authors (e.g., 10 and 20)? (3) How can LLMs provide
explainability in authorship analysis, particularly through the role of
linguistic features? Moreover, we investigate the integration of explicit
linguistic features to guide LLMs in their reasoning processes. Our extensive
assessment demonstrates LLMs' proficiency in both tasks without the need for
domain-specific fine-tuning, providing insights into their decision-making via
a detailed analysis of linguistic features. This establishes a new benchmark
for future research on LLM-based authorship analysis. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/baixianghuang/authorship-llm.
|
[
-0.0931059867,
-0.7424179316,
1.0982035398,
0.1329275668,
0.0062574418,
0.13885732,
-0.6463847756,
-0.5078503489,
0.0181058571,
0.7203373909,
-0.3168638349,
-0.439355135,
-0.878018558,
0.4032042623,
-0.4787191451,
0.6641281843,
-0.1315081269,
-0.1434468776,
-0.632825017,
-0.0185959246,
-0.360204041,
-0.4075971246,
-0.5026760101,
-0.3144465387,
0.8871263266,
0.2005861998,
0.4042934477,
0.7095313668,
0.2998732626,
0.3456262052,
-0.1608942598,
0.1554964483,
-0.5740280747,
0.0269800443,
-0.1356141269,
-0.3533104956,
-0.5125392079,
0.0798303708,
0.6889321208,
0.6807286143,
0.1484662443,
0.4339892864,
0.0605154373,
0.2240366191,
-0.7160550356,
0.1487294734,
-0.7007027268,
-0.3446894586,
-0.2512536645,
-0.3612135351,
-0.7681978941,
-0.6084829569,
-0.0844593272,
-0.3572129011,
-0.0195545461,
0.036299739,
0.5956825614,
0.1939890832,
-0.6134485006,
-0.535874486,
-0.5425998569,
0.9670990705,
-0.8018113375,
0.0671290681,
0.1911125034,
0.0578557402,
-0.0182007253,
-0.3554990292,
-0.615182519,
-0.2718281746,
-0.289411217,
-0.2053393275,
0.1006578729,
-0.2073566765,
0.1416451335,
0.443924129,
-0.6083935499,
0.5656011701,
-0.0182630289,
-0.170732975,
0.7598518133,
-0.0175112803,
0.5329329371,
-0.0489565134,
-0.294033885,
0.2124271542,
-0.7597686648,
0.0214603245,
0.6754412055,
0.3424664438,
-0.1580995023,
0.6620917916,
0.0580693223,
0.6583926082,
-0.16570279,
-0.0383342765,
0.0023846626,
-0.0782927275,
-0.0489636697,
0.1521953642,
0.8669518232,
-0.0596099794,
0.617911458,
-0.2740780711,
-0.1277564913,
-0.3570451736,
0.1003944874,
-0.5405883789,
0.0571506284,
0.3588075042,
-0.3371840715,
-0.337939173,
0.2929077148,
-0.281701535,
-0.6574887633,
-0.3699770272,
0.430320859,
-0.070152469,
-0.4377990961,
0.1116797701,
0.0056321369,
0.4438993335,
0.3166550398,
-0.7583317757,
0.1799563318,
1.0669515133,
0.608524859,
-0.3031714857,
-0.5936604142,
-0.5060018301,
0.0892837793,
-0.5395310521,
0.4708184302,
-0.4766881764,
0.3321098983,
0.1821631342,
0.0286340863,
-0.2037131786,
-0.3712638617,
0.3100908399,
-0.6106801033,
0.1082114503,
-0.4122731984,
-0.7807862759,
0.0313436948,
0.1821448654,
-0.608671546,
0.6874114275,
-0.0753696039,
-0.4944508076,
0.3103897274,
-0.3340837359,
-0.3978177309,
0.1725420952,
-0.1022332162,
-0.3692176044,
0.2261961997,
0.1774228811,
0.9409404397,
-0.5260962248,
0.4397270381,
-0.2964829206,
-0.3459331989,
0.6721464992,
-0.1227422059,
1.0104236603,
-0.0623665564,
-0.0763540789,
0.0417500436,
-0.6968221664,
0.0204803385,
0.307397753,
-0.0953981727,
-0.1272892505,
-0.1378294379,
0.0293965694,
-0.1761684418,
0.4739501774,
-0.5739706755,
0.1241024435,
-0.0726922005,
0.2352016866,
0.6688848138,
-0.0980374217,
0.2451882809,
-0.2654493749,
0.685939908,
-0.6852667332,
-0.152802214,
-0.3766745329,
-0.4697676897,
-0.3532730639,
-0.6084456444,
0.4224895239,
0.5811282396,
-0.4567920268,
0.6060250401,
-0.3831093013,
-0.5040723085,
-0.3383193612,
0.4282472432,
0.6502816081,
0.1791509986,
0.1927038282,
-0.0745142177,
-0.3059401214,
-0.7113405466,
-0.6456933022,
-0.0410528369,
-0.1780053377,
0.2460215539,
0.676689744,
0.3018324375,
0.7298566699,
-0.487698555,
-0.1228623912,
-0.4721882939,
0.2675344944,
0.3213712871,
0.2653870881,
0.4632571936,
-0.4695541263,
-0.6133478284,
0.1458290368,
-1.0593029261,
-0.4825673103,
-0.309163034,
0.0701448023,
-0.0918995589,
0.6881859303,
-0.6771950126,
0.2429248542,
0.38976565,
-0.4116888046,
0.6960002184,
-0.1533001661,
0.2038993984,
-0.6163333654,
0.3298982084,
-0.0385961793,
-0.1575934738,
-0.5458235145,
0.2689772844,
0.0884408429,
0.0964514762,
-0.1672813594,
0.6041274667,
-0.8559784293,
-0.0873789713,
-0.1783760041,
0.1802320182,
-0.0911002904,
0.491019249,
-0.1590158492,
0.3551334143,
0.4768105745,
-0.1651354134,
0.4990998209,
0.1100834906,
-0.7256527543,
0.5729788542,
-0.7484269142,
0.164001748,
-0.0740243718,
0.165566355,
-1.1555280685,
-0.3616181314,
-0.093616046,
-0.6039737463,
0.4245362878,
-0.3773612678,
-0.8675958514,
0.0238680709,
-0.2238723636,
0.3349647522,
0.3197087944,
-0.2649287581,
0.6691649556,
0.0779170245,
-0.5233759284,
-0.5594789386,
-0.4428289831,
0.3213179708,
-0.2359071374,
-0.5632477403,
0.2371363044,
0.2355326265,
-0.3945266604,
-0.1032712758,
0.3640345335,
-0.1054033339,
0.2530091703,
0.0818923637,
0.1954826713,
-0.1437388361,
-0.0476175956,
-0.0801043212,
-0.1711919457,
0.1366622597,
-0.0084927278,
0.1950665116,
0.2180776,
-0.380250603,
-0.4053995907,
0.2529524267,
0.7526106238,
-0.4217518568,
0.9153100252,
0.5037750602,
-0.3092981279,
-0.3601230979,
-0.7333622575,
-0.0418589413,
-0.3651458323,
0.2431511879,
-0.0975258872,
-0.8952700496,
0.7098605037,
0.1405845881,
0.0040769135,
0.4732694626,
0.6361095309,
0.0183874834,
0.4360004663,
0.6245111823,
0.029445868,
0.0576857589,
-0.0514032766,
0.3135189414,
-0.770188868,
-0.2450573146,
-0.6357122064,
-0.2297818661,
-0.4407568872,
-0.2906780839,
0.1691188812,
-0.2383128405,
-0.2001920193,
0.3442168534,
-0.3064474761,
0.6380623579,
0.2550300062,
-0.1490655243,
0.3147258759,
-0.3108277619,
0.1742776632,
0.0946071967,
-0.1937050223,
-0.7507258654,
1.146758914,
0.353518486,
0.6558848023,
0.3093144298,
0.437509656,
0.4581061304,
0.1091387346,
-0.5118970871,
0.6332458854,
-0.1735482514,
-0.6774947643,
-0.5661916137,
-0.3388479054,
-0.6157149673,
0.2157845348,
-0.3222101331,
-0.9570819736,
-0.0329968259,
-0.0416525602,
-0.3128063381,
0.2857915461,
-0.5034512877,
0.8805940747,
-0.4085253775,
-0.5011863708,
0.0298653599,
-0.5528207421,
0.2618912756,
-0.4098248184,
0.2282032818,
-0.1500507742,
0.0440915301,
0.6650406718,
-0.1835254729,
0.9312186837,
-0.121783413,
-0.5637797713,
0.0153555274,
0.1333996356,
0.3983691335,
-0.0257203151,
-0.3600902259,
0.2406247556,
-0.106434688,
-0.2389089018,
-0.6440179944,
0.8442909718,
-0.5344375372,
-0.3934423625,
-0.2264146358,
-0.3213171363,
-0.1700018942,
0.208923474,
0.1403184831,
0.3911426961,
-0.0889719576,
0.5329291821,
0.4887700975,
-0.5487197638,
0.2240223587,
0.2343426794,
-0.1382728964,
-0.2833108008,
0.8701195717,
0.0594797991,
0.2190177888,
0.5177958012,
0.2512944043,
-0.1214456558,
-0.6763216853,
-0.5007454157,
0.5104125738,
-0.5836097002,
0.1449335963,
-0.6141465306,
-0.0217933971,
-0.2695487142,
-0.4313696325,
-0.2837140262,
-0.2744911313,
-0.239202857,
0.0730239376,
0.0428661481,
0.7656506896,
0.3685615659,
0.3963025212,
-0.347986877,
0.3256925941,
0.1890698224,
0.260874927,
0.3295112848,
-0.6902489662,
-0.3062708676,
-0.2405861169,
-0.049540475,
-0.7135491371,
0.0469443388,
0.0625564009,
0.691793263,
0.2962676287,
-0.1914875209,
0.3562553227,
-0.4160913229,
0.9139122367,
-0.0762275681,
-1.0509451628,
0.2591503561,
-0.4813184738,
0.117610082,
0.3841381669,
0.3807335496,
-0.312283814,
-0.4808888137,
-0.2675115764,
-0.70888412,
0.6215561032,
0.2792360187,
0.1092724577,
0.3000718653,
0.5482217669,
0.3406009674,
0.1251496673,
-0.8136895299,
-0.0176012311,
0.4020706713,
-0.1431923658,
-0.301159054,
-0.5403240919,
0.0479210578,
-0.1321149766,
0.6118913293,
-0.1636285931,
0.0646101311,
-0.1194016486,
-0.2883057892,
0.0489723943,
0.328976512,
0.563751936,
1.0029379129,
-0.0215801578,
0.0111217238,
0.1115897521,
0.0729535818,
0.0000676964,
0.0005131406,
0.0859625116,
-0.1364161521,
1.197406292,
0.4629440904,
0.0864772946,
-0.4853353798,
0.9063450098,
0.2260924429,
-0.2348023802,
-0.3972564042,
-0.0977512598,
0.2657536566,
0.2721875906,
0.4247741699,
-0.4636403918,
-0.0916983858,
-0.5271548033,
-0.1268843263,
0.4473258257,
-0.1301980466,
-0.4266142249,
0.5411043763,
0.0451568551,
-0.1193246022,
0.4096677303,
0.0848773867,
-0.4552823007,
0.8479801416,
0.2949181199,
1.0605906248,
-0.0888372585,
0.0682804361,
0.1396597326,
0.406041652,
-0.026840141,
0.0668192208,
-0.0827328488,
-0.6835101843,
-0.8300242424,
-0.5325989127,
-0.5312859416,
-0.0220002569,
-0.5231268406,
0.3095275164,
-0.3302468657,
0.1158091649,
0.4357436597,
-0.1614281535,
-0.44044137,
0.0175401382,
0.316619128,
0.3386126757,
-1.0408549309,
0.3819252253,
0.5260766149,
-0.0624006167,
-0.4594474137,
-0.0995633677,
0.3065499663,
-0.8454959989,
0.6087859869,
0.2120306641,
-0.2283679992,
-0.1291255504,
-0.8033138514,
-0.5000935793,
1.0048900843,
0.6974008679,
-0.269628197,
0.118566379,
0.2650770843,
0.552123487,
-0.4339758754,
0.3772665858,
0.1089821011,
0.5368634462,
0.1418144554,
-1.0406934023,
0.1970657259,
-0.0258095805,
-0.1384005249,
0.0548422486,
-0.4168201983,
0.7633081079,
-0.2884305716,
0.0981557295,
0.1444424391,
0.357152015,
0.1601327956,
0.2238424867,
0.3601733148,
0.2926495671,
0.7054780722,
-0.0489129536,
0.8965786099,
-0.2453346103,
0.3823626637,
1.1024433374,
-0.5261105299,
0.6799040437,
0.4116778076,
-0.1413397491,
0.5568035841,
0.0985961929,
-0.2113945633,
0.1509565264,
0.456925869,
-0.0364264324,
-0.47152403,
-0.0870378613,
-0.0681039095,
0.6467592716,
0.0096589746,
-0.6403024793,
0.0723839924,
0.0151371388,
0.2252155095,
0.2244344056,
0.0187023357,
0.7433201075,
0.185974285,
-0.5829008818,
0.3714117408,
-0.0246144384,
0.5445137024,
-0.5599614978,
-0.0038575456,
0.1412038207,
0.215967387,
-0.385384053,
-0.912729919,
0.0376485996,
0.2526966035,
-0.0391987786,
-0.5441758037,
0.5728574395,
-0.3775371015,
-0.4882887602,
0.2083563954,
0.6110372543,
0.2366530597,
-0.1845563799,
-0.0673072189,
0.2000644356,
-0.1157679111,
-0.2687344849,
0.0750640705,
0.6859188676,
-0.0253955591,
0.6590279341,
0.6394354105,
0.3745350838,
-0.2222288251,
0.0966288298,
0.3720836341,
-0.7010064721,
-0.1097214296,
-1.2171456814,
0.488255322,
-0.1095542535,
-0.3238746524,
0.8430459499,
0.5690171719,
0.7052494884,
-0.2062155753,
0.7647162676,
-0.1382637471,
0.3962439001,
-0.6076844931,
0.9537383914,
-0.7259739041,
0.2601854503,
-0.5127328634,
-0.8528105021,
-0.5307075381,
0.2680258155,
-0.345426023,
0.2862683237,
0.6066262722,
0.5818541646,
0.0157386083,
-0.1220833883,
0.4354343712,
0.1969995648,
0.3908839822,
0.4079938531,
0.9591696262,
-0.191136688,
0.256621331,
-0.0328193717,
-0.3450056314,
-0.2397254556,
-1.2261385918,
-1.1116609573,
-0.5229225755,
-0.5042709112,
0.1199413836,
-0.0942162648,
0.6344450116,
0.4588954151,
-0.5727980137,
-0.289781183,
0.3704219759,
0.2231921852,
-0.2149830312,
-0.1228509322,
0.4684233069,
-0.0097652841,
-0.5283502936,
0.1298312247,
0.2696232796,
-0.3686149716,
-0.3543493748,
0.0115789473,
-0.1662237495,
0.2029049098,
0.582277596,
0.040272247,
-0.9936727285,
-0.2084807903,
0.0219400413,
-0.0719549507,
-0.2440150231,
0.8371385336,
-0.2306262702,
0.4363603294,
0.4107709527,
0.6668246388,
0.122299552,
0.0286215171,
0.4894246757,
-0.5129455924,
-0.4444457591,
0.096897766,
0.4441365004,
0.3647634089,
-0.5612582564,
0.392587781,
-0.0111541776,
-0.8461198211,
-0.8140445948,
-0.0467107967,
-1.0831593275,
-0.1783581674,
1.271709919,
-0.3028200567,
0.000367311,
-0.046486415,
0.0241795536,
0.1050947234,
-0.071646221,
0.5587261915,
1.0495114326,
0.1085487306,
-0.2922998071,
-0.599922657,
0.1649676412,
0.3075249493,
-0.7183135748,
0.4803843498,
0.4798724055,
0.2630230188,
0.1006777659,
0.5292612314,
-0.2793130875,
0.1332884431,
-0.4135378599,
0.1831430942,
-0.3303863406,
-0.3559513092,
-0.2405864596,
0.2455158234,
0.2403401732,
0.127882123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08211v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08211v2
|
Large Language Models are Contrastive Reasoners
| 2024-03-13T03:15:05 | 2024-05-22T21:06:37 |
Liang Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prompting methods play a crucial role in enhancing the capabilities of
pre-trained large language models (LLMs). We explore how contrastive prompting
(CP) significantly improves the ability of large language models to perform
complex reasoning. We demonstrate that LLMs are decent contrastive reasoners by
simply adding "Let's give a correct and a wrong answer." before LLMs provide
answers. Experiments on various large language models show that zero-shot
contrastive prompting improves performance on a range of arithmetic,
commonsense, and symbolic reasoning tasks without any hand-crafted few-shot
examples, such as increasing the accuracy on GSM8K from 35.9% to 88.8% and
AQUA-RAT from 41.3% to 62.2% with the state-of-the-art GPT-4 model. Our method
not only surpasses zero-shot CoT and few-shot CoT in most arithmetic and
commonsense reasoning tasks but also can seamlessly integrate with existing
prompting methods, resulting in improved or comparable results when compared to
state-of-the-art methods. Our code is available at
https://github.com/yao8839836/cp
|
[
-0.4031760097,
-0.7715035081,
0.9124549031,
0.194893837,
-0.3369125128,
-0.2443207055,
-0.3546441197,
-0.2272127867,
-0.2440447211,
0.3331350982,
-0.3453771174,
-0.3554351032,
-0.5959526896,
0.1917292476,
-0.2397856414,
0.7877885103,
0.0975766107,
0.3447982967,
0.0204596855,
0.0583085418,
-0.4881663918,
-0.3894906938,
-0.9486922026,
-0.5428193212,
0.9625477791,
0.4903428853,
0.5706146359,
0.3812565804,
0.0414454564,
0.3597580791,
-0.299954325,
0.1360632926,
-0.5138121247,
0.2281145751,
-0.3835731745,
-0.7366138697,
-0.0734725371,
0.0111973565,
0.2453430742,
0.671790123,
0.0523555167,
-0.2317647636,
0.0846206099,
0.6326212883,
-0.8071346879,
0.1177228615,
-0.7075355053,
-0.2334198505,
0.1352794617,
-0.4001165628,
-0.6486715674,
-0.3758512139,
0.1162584648,
-0.5341076255,
0.2236747593,
-0.1335798055,
0.7126016617,
0.2011368722,
-0.3774836659,
-0.1766391993,
-0.4522979856,
0.9699484706,
-0.8312795162,
0.2033239454,
0.3587082326,
0.2519649565,
-0.0325610675,
-0.4739387929,
-0.926779747,
-0.4359043241,
-0.1016834378,
0.2031154782,
-0.2310203463,
0.1721930802,
0.5127224922,
0.3417645991,
-0.3590314388,
0.1764560789,
-0.3799806237,
-0.0716370791,
0.2331810296,
0.1541207731,
0.2111649215,
0.0628146604,
-0.042625282,
-0.033296451,
-1.1319158077,
0.081803441,
0.2670739889,
0.2918123007,
-0.3691591322,
0.4597014487,
-0.2661136687,
1.0794657469,
0.3783699572,
0.1572060436,
-0.13232252,
-0.281457752,
-0.1808793247,
-0.1281671077,
0.5519654751,
0.4532616436,
0.5396733284,
0.3351002932,
-0.2679930925,
0.0617964417,
-0.1400512755,
-1.0378316641,
-0.6005702019,
0.3461063206,
-0.1750404686,
-0.1993553489,
-0.2953761518,
-0.5276648998,
-0.560739398,
-0.6757663488,
0.5775678754,
-0.5576640964,
-0.1520420015,
0.4187321365,
-0.2100032568,
0.5742074847,
0.8278498054,
-1.0800588131,
-0.1426975876,
0.7927702665,
0.6597564816,
0.214331612,
-0.3166621327,
-0.861184001,
-0.1837538481,
-0.7692395449,
1.0116209984,
-0.691434443,
-0.2402323782,
0.0947857499,
-0.2509101033,
0.0031307531,
-0.8424925208,
0.6291229129,
-0.5561009049,
0.3572121859,
-0.747094512,
-0.3626654148,
-0.222084254,
0.7163108587,
-0.4732375443,
0.6759492159,
-0.0996281281,
-0.6172878146,
0.1542343199,
-0.4884890616,
-0.2462064475,
0.1484221816,
-0.2348866016,
-0.0217389446,
0.1031888053,
0.7284058332,
0.5411682725,
-0.3102248609,
0.2511617243,
-0.2708053887,
-0.4750794172,
0.315848887,
-0.5297139287,
0.8097810149,
0.120280996,
-0.259524852,
0.2909211516,
-0.4929548502,
-0.0205876008,
0.3041836321,
-0.3529008031,
-0.1053221449,
-0.3064139485,
-0.5128480196,
0.3711354136,
0.1089924574,
-0.3601102531,
0.0995522067,
-0.4592176676,
0.4383476675,
0.7507647276,
-0.0789719075,
0.2894359827,
-0.538280189,
0.4912611842,
0.18323493,
-0.1831937283,
-0.8312399983,
-0.3532918096,
-0.9211347103,
-0.4155896306,
0.2296455652,
0.5413725376,
-1.0054972172,
0.2580964565,
0.0746566504,
-0.4127951264,
-0.4364706278,
-0.0199876279,
0.6023355126,
0.9149754047,
0.4170626998,
0.3247332871,
-0.3433919549,
-0.601864934,
-0.0793964192,
-0.1067237705,
-0.2040058672,
0.3160660565,
0.2439709306,
0.2845166028,
0.4629727304,
-0.3981895447,
0.2583871186,
-0.4770000875,
0.1998135746,
0.4811606109,
0.3046940863,
0.3794283867,
-0.6899263263,
-0.6625551581,
-0.141355589,
-0.6623288393,
-0.4735860527,
-0.1248397231,
0.0469125733,
0.1352998167,
0.5801997185,
-0.7633394599,
0.0071450868,
0.6266346574,
-0.3781056106,
0.8883913755,
-0.2726620436,
0.4028528035,
-0.8613653183,
0.1593601257,
-0.0909582451,
-0.1669140011,
-0.6981561184,
0.211817354,
0.0290054623,
-0.1944242567,
-0.6637913585,
0.6527469158,
-0.4010376632,
0.2913485169,
-0.3923404813,
0.3852441013,
0.3382621109,
0.2360236943,
0.0139897093,
0.8999701738,
0.8912468553,
-0.9080817699,
0.3948943019,
0.0417828038,
-0.2271508127,
0.8684390783,
-0.9679986835,
-0.0204848815,
-0.2466875464,
0.4712075591,
-1.2384077311,
-0.2884876728,
0.1635097712,
-0.4597305059,
0.3310958147,
-0.1620722413,
-0.2700061202,
-0.3213913441,
-0.432090044,
0.4355744123,
0.4261700213,
-1.0457755327,
0.4736444056,
-0.2517238557,
-0.4027114213,
-0.7426638603,
-0.4971636832,
0.0898699686,
0.0339062922,
-0.5059166551,
0.0499960817,
-0.4055700004,
-0.3343906105,
-0.2784456015,
-0.0042773462,
0.0167147312,
-0.0528480075,
-0.0506543927,
0.7115806937,
-0.4269095361,
0.1585656404,
-0.1761334091,
-0.356500417,
0.1013656855,
-0.161674872,
0.8997654915,
-0.1479198784,
-0.4139452279,
-0.8001217842,
0.1642041653,
0.3897268772,
-0.2776816785,
0.5773935318,
0.2135849595,
-0.0818313584,
-0.0203752574,
-0.8301661611,
-0.3813467622,
-0.5077548623,
0.0734473318,
-0.4832636416,
-1.1913262606,
0.3246641755,
-0.0048197974,
0.0736436769,
0.3135185242,
0.6519932747,
0.0173051301,
1.1442519426,
0.1801807731,
0.081991531,
0.4800576568,
0.0747638196,
0.4411337674,
-0.7223604321,
-0.119622089,
-0.695055902,
-0.067061767,
-0.2632631063,
-0.5342752337,
0.1325405091,
0.3337182105,
-0.4596057832,
-0.1781622022,
-0.5418613553,
1.0767573118,
0.3048535883,
0.1072167978,
0.1137078255,
-0.1848372817,
-0.1215784401,
-0.0570932701,
-0.5720325708,
-0.4026510119,
0.7904891968,
0.0911781043,
0.7499935627,
0.0225713607,
0.8055039644,
-0.2785080671,
0.4065101147,
-1.0692833662,
0.6496816278,
-0.0809496045,
-0.4685437679,
-0.3008494079,
-0.5368654728,
-0.9582247138,
0.4749399126,
-0.1760812253,
-0.5471379757,
0.194904685,
0.5582478642,
-0.6194782853,
0.1161175221,
-0.8165097833,
0.6035001278,
-0.148123309,
-0.5435208082,
-0.2937602103,
-0.3673784137,
0.4665412903,
0.0910751373,
-0.0758685023,
0.023290664,
-0.1447242498,
0.3206470907,
-0.3343317509,
0.9117413759,
-0.1936968863,
-0.2778009474,
0.2944884002,
0.3505833745,
0.7447801828,
-0.2813988328,
-0.4115225077,
-0.1051343307,
-0.3167280257,
-0.5640207529,
-0.7856605053,
0.8373286128,
-0.3884323239,
-0.9714118838,
-0.206976369,
-0.4725037217,
-0.2424865961,
0.2568151951,
0.3868779242,
0.3643861711,
0.175337404,
0.2957779169,
1.0590851307,
-0.3939628899,
0.4430288076,
0.6767876148,
-0.1026708931,
-0.3631515801,
0.7194296718,
-0.1247140542,
0.5683010817,
0.5020638108,
0.6443101168,
-0.411829859,
-0.5821404457,
-0.3801027536,
0.4482516944,
-1.0161088705,
-0.2422884703,
-0.7178913951,
-0.081773892,
-0.3130054772,
-0.642724812,
-0.0885267109,
-0.312245518,
-0.1152788177,
-0.2195303142,
0.0961536989,
0.7778977752,
-0.0779608339,
0.2154362351,
-0.8414264321,
0.3014145494,
0.7662497163,
0.1292816103,
0.2361349314,
-0.7423445582,
0.2130051553,
-0.1817715317,
-0.2483722866,
-0.6890557408,
0.200897187,
-0.1530749649,
0.5876944661,
0.4787233472,
0.0549681224,
0.7651637793,
-0.470453769,
1.1530721188,
0.5051980615,
-1.1264425516,
0.4331416786,
-0.5752201676,
0.6644461751,
0.4478821456,
0.3730543852,
-0.4851262271,
-0.2748336792,
-0.4027805924,
-0.7035615444,
0.7104208469,
-0.1252892613,
0.4053373933,
-0.122108914,
0.3261398971,
-0.102578342,
-0.0362145938,
-0.9436352253,
0.0000621951,
-0.1917069703,
-0.0151202353,
0.0454641469,
-0.4790310264,
-0.2137555033,
-0.1502917111,
0.7647650838,
-0.3020577729,
-0.0201122947,
0.2042548954,
0.140672043,
-0.187798664,
0.653287828,
0.8034463525,
0.824380517,
0.109917827,
0.4688792229,
0.4555579722,
0.1326954365,
0.0384959094,
0.0803204924,
-0.1117869243,
-0.2342734635,
0.5222581029,
0.643292129,
0.2373316288,
-0.6357547641,
0.7660837173,
0.019842051,
-0.3723852336,
0.1924285889,
0.1716957986,
0.357832253,
0.2627823055,
0.0792205408,
-0.2382322699,
0.0532700904,
-0.4360204935,
-0.1446885318,
0.3364821672,
-0.2549807727,
-0.1369908601,
0.4249038696,
0.2683372498,
-0.1614960283,
0.5409443378,
-0.0804603547,
-0.747772634,
0.4851522744,
0.9539042711,
0.4929344654,
-0.5839022398,
0.2232073396,
0.743611753,
0.0591950007,
-0.2627042234,
0.3438407779,
-0.2765392959,
-0.7623494864,
-0.7356063128,
-0.3239064515,
-0.6313474178,
0.3386156261,
-0.3443816006,
0.286703974,
-0.6063625216,
0.4639881849,
0.228634432,
-0.200695768,
-0.4164406359,
0.3314457238,
0.2970026135,
0.9918708205,
-0.743783772,
0.6263289452,
0.4139885902,
-0.3744643629,
-1.1300358772,
0.0736828819,
0.0903361067,
-0.9363012314,
0.6909990311,
0.4314973056,
-0.3073999584,
-0.1691344678,
-0.9867022038,
-0.4635337591,
0.6268960834,
0.6167737246,
-0.8878987432,
0.3098062575,
-0.0958292186,
0.5685644746,
-0.2201509476,
0.4177133441,
0.3871849775,
0.6140363216,
0.7126286626,
-0.6161034107,
0.3047142029,
-0.1708537489,
-0.1305286884,
0.256688267,
-0.3997142017,
1.0512537956,
-0.6748635769,
-0.032410562,
0.134824872,
0.296561569,
0.884783864,
0.3548252881,
0.6014274955,
0.388933301,
0.851797998,
-0.1416310519,
1.2070945501,
-0.1992786974,
-0.0802590027,
1.2255105972,
-0.4196382463,
0.9863190651,
0.4061094224,
0.0931527838,
0.490732044,
0.4162612259,
0.118079558,
0.2185048312,
0.1979042292,
-0.6068072915,
-0.7693403363,
-0.102557376,
-0.2570251226,
0.1455543488,
0.3913204372,
-0.2431959808,
-0.3811805844,
-0.3077944219,
0.2191861123,
0.2625203133,
-0.4101948738,
0.7314680219,
0.3164699376,
-1.1830031872,
0.9219604731,
-0.308349967,
0.6337915659,
-0.6069386601,
-0.2457511872,
-0.2071954608,
0.0994546637,
-0.3175878823,
-1.0575180054,
0.0607443415,
-0.0596601926,
-0.1007316634,
-0.1455180049,
0.6573237777,
-0.5408530831,
0.0339559391,
0.1796321124,
0.3827835023,
0.0760040805,
-0.2212034315,
-0.8457491398,
-0.1203211099,
0.0718116835,
-0.0382841937,
0.121072419,
0.6977205873,
-0.0073915701,
0.6825371385,
0.9567130804,
0.0566469692,
-0.3278689384,
0.4628113806,
1.0097434521,
-0.8698897362,
-0.4305931926,
-1.1116250753,
0.6148317456,
-0.1253810823,
-0.095225893,
0.577111125,
0.30202654,
0.5637578964,
-0.1040955335,
0.6822772622,
0.1996940821,
0.48428455,
-0.6778724194,
0.3752140403,
-0.3470640779,
0.40223822,
0.0591631681,
-0.8151317835,
-0.657373786,
0.5838845968,
-0.7218791246,
0.1482758075,
0.7373757362,
1.1547974348,
0.0736397952,
0.0503360778,
0.804095149,
0.3504326642,
0.4799550474,
0.598423779,
1.2643678188,
0.1049000099,
0.665404439,
0.0676731989,
-0.2903282046,
-0.2553358674,
-0.9867082238,
-1.1241515875,
-0.179107219,
-0.146414414,
-0.5042991638,
-0.0170192309,
0.9608437419,
0.6691333652,
-0.8801817298,
0.0949117169,
-0.2351549864,
0.1438783705,
0.0661351904,
-0.2232994139,
0.170770213,
-0.6723418236,
-0.7867196798,
0.4202310741,
0.3834446967,
0.1066587195,
-0.0163521804,
-0.2142296731,
-0.0461014472,
0.452890873,
0.7318021059,
0.3528034091,
-0.7891324162,
-0.2866043746,
-0.2337783277,
-0.2103842497,
0.147853896,
0.9013412595,
-0.7973370552,
0.5510402918,
0.6919444799,
0.4462109208,
0.3519924879,
-0.0290196277,
0.6410397291,
-0.4366044402,
0.1340553761,
0.3369893134,
0.5948157907,
0.6784486175,
-0.3891755342,
0.2384020984,
-0.0062926435,
-0.6902995706,
-0.5126345754,
0.4549989998,
-0.9395591021,
-0.3402674496,
1.2258685827,
-0.309891969,
-0.185069859,
-0.1292234361,
-0.6831111312,
-0.0170422737,
-0.5281073451,
0.7960739136,
0.743439734,
-0.1488854289,
-0.6402058601,
-0.1454737186,
0.3774933815,
0.7643903494,
-0.9954379797,
0.3149867058,
0.6852988601,
0.3572191298,
0.160943225,
0.7160738111,
-0.2502828538,
0.6876215935,
0.0016897727,
-0.2609171271,
-0.061302565,
-0.1972827315,
-0.7842927575,
0.1068912968,
0.3979839087,
0.156922251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13002v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13002v3
|
AutoTRIZ: Artificial Ideation with TRIZ and Large Language Models
| 2024-03-13T02:53:36 | 2024-05-23T02:19:12 |
Shuo Jiang, Jianxi Luo
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.1
|
Researchers and innovators have made enormous efforts in developing ideation
methods, such as morphological analysis and design-by-analogy, to aid
engineering design ideation for problem solving and innovation. Among these,
the Theory of Inventive Problem Solving (TRIZ) stands out as one of the most
well-known approaches, widely applied for systematic innovation. However, the
complexity of TRIZ resources and concepts, coupled with its reliance on users'
knowledge, experience, and reasoning capabilities, limits its practicality.
Therefore, we explore the recent advances of large language models (LLMs) for a
generative approach to bridge this gap. This paper proposes AutoTRIZ, an
artificial ideation tool that uses LLMs to automate and enhance the TRIZ
methodology. By leveraging the broad knowledge and advanced reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, AutoTRIZ offers a novel approach for design automation
and interpretable ideation with artificial intelligence. AutoTRIZ takes a
problem statement from the user as its initial input, and automatically
generates a solution report after the reasoning process. We demonstrate and
evaluate the effectiveness of AutoTRIZ through consistency experiments in
contradiction detection, and a case study comparing solutions generated by
AutoTRIZ with the experts' analyses from the textbook. Moreover, the proposed
LLM-based framework holds the potential for extension to automate other
knowledge-based ideation methods, including SCAMPER, Design Heuristics, and
Design-by-Analogy, paving the way for a new era of artificial ideation for
design innovation.
|
[
-0.4981327653,
-0.8953151107,
0.8094066381,
0.2004696876,
-0.2331128716,
0.437615633,
-0.1198712587,
-0.4482063949,
0.0678371713,
0.2284750342,
-0.485699445,
-0.4724542201,
-0.1759519428,
0.1828138083,
-0.6466879249,
0.3722379208,
-0.6137793064,
-0.3483117223,
-0.1827361733,
0.2301304638,
-0.5451326966,
-0.2124218345,
-0.4169723988,
-0.3788161278,
0.0764283016,
0.5621648431,
0.7080075145,
0.7090854645,
0.3750438988,
0.4255874157,
0.1038830578,
0.2090598196,
0.1498793066,
0.0514424518,
0.0215225909,
-0.529574573,
-0.2835967541,
-0.0893153176,
0.5891016722,
0.4322296977,
-0.2998155057,
0.2572621405,
0.0407710001,
0.493424207,
-0.3798648715,
0.2979045808,
-0.6349787712,
0.3148538172,
-0.1992174387,
-0.1727412194,
-0.1570061743,
-0.5529164672,
-0.0519180596,
-0.5609918833,
0.1339408308,
0.2320379615,
0.6610425711,
0.6946537495,
0.3425832093,
-0.5974622369,
-1.0626844168,
0.5005012751,
-1.2045453787,
0.2330499887,
-0.2207700908,
0.4381562173,
-0.5327810645,
-0.4785625935,
-1.1375377178,
-0.3325273395,
0.0576523617,
0.0356683396,
-0.3480284512,
0.0471861884,
0.2245377153,
0.2790455222,
-0.6771892309,
0.1831152439,
-0.0072772885,
0.0641436279,
0.791665554,
0.396512717,
0.5092713237,
-0.1477689147,
-0.4736915827,
0.0790548101,
-0.5584102869,
-0.0582856312,
0.1704577953,
0.0187858418,
-0.0643707216,
0.5741773844,
-0.4150575101,
0.8520061374,
0.0797680542,
0.2681469917,
0.3532679081,
-0.3025536239,
-0.3230362833,
-0.0273509696,
1.0213292837,
-0.1508499682,
0.3858200908,
-0.3014532924,
-0.2312718332,
0.0018456762,
0.1928759664,
-0.407433629,
-0.2632103264,
0.2990334332,
-0.3107260466,
-0.1789401323,
-0.0609479137,
-0.6687093973,
-0.220868662,
-0.5013021231,
0.585472405,
-0.2039004713,
-0.2441386431,
0.4698995948,
-0.0501696579,
0.2784594297,
0.1971964389,
-0.5154085755,
-0.0133719724,
0.41456303,
0.6777525544,
-0.1166564301,
-0.3327920437,
0.2774665356,
0.2892145216,
-0.7162051797,
1.1607444286,
-0.2548414469,
-0.4210092127,
-0.2421616614,
-0.4079014957,
0.205232054,
-0.5507301092,
0.1444489956,
-0.3177895546,
0.0149597563,
0.1661159545,
-0.3552753925,
-0.2441208959,
-0.0283767059,
-0.7154377103,
0.8567840457,
0.1297961771,
-0.5401549935,
0.3056336343,
-0.9337682128,
-0.3482564688,
0.6224381328,
-0.6854841113,
-0.6191142797,
0.0959778577,
-0.1057160497,
-0.0271746758,
-0.6045445204,
0.4652155638,
-0.426987648,
-0.11568553,
0.3437428772,
-0.2522572577,
0.9413843751,
0.3532387912,
-0.5676296353,
0.1546015739,
-0.5241157413,
0.4515767992,
0.3783068359,
-0.038476564,
-0.0292185098,
-0.0295138061,
-0.3590980768,
0.4787212312,
0.2054007947,
-0.6446604133,
0.2360435277,
-0.5391044021,
0.4831296802,
0.4088553786,
0.0316247158,
0.3821542859,
-0.3907185495,
0.471593678,
-0.4023770988,
0.3338357508,
0.2531402111,
-0.3248237669,
-1.1253424883,
0.0704244301,
0.1095022708,
0.5984579921,
-0.8899025917,
0.4283408225,
0.0972347409,
-0.6102740169,
-0.4585412145,
0.414332211,
0.2880770266,
0.3773317635,
0.1957561374,
-0.1965485513,
-0.575062573,
-1.138594985,
-0.5423223972,
-0.1542956233,
-0.2051507682,
0.1646376252,
0.5725240111,
-0.1458983719,
1.5043808222,
-0.5881848931,
-0.3589891493,
-0.4074988067,
0.7395839691,
0.243352443,
0.3072496951,
0.5574358702,
-0.7315347195,
-0.6322834492,
-0.2977015376,
-0.8705542088,
-0.4025369287,
-0.2160295546,
-0.1746479124,
0.0766255483,
0.5153144598,
-0.8073459268,
0.619610846,
-0.0256425887,
-0.1533713639,
0.6248475313,
-0.1107717678,
-0.172972098,
-1.1304211617,
0.0006636879,
-0.055036664,
0.3030127883,
-0.3966860473,
-0.2853556871,
0.0048326347,
-0.0468742065,
-0.3638525307,
0.7439044714,
-0.4528536499,
-0.0482957512,
-0.4780936539,
0.1034832373,
0.0641039982,
0.2966469228,
-0.0190088153,
0.8562960029,
0.126020968,
-0.5702852011,
1.0044057369,
0.4471156597,
-0.4265010357,
0.3350495696,
-0.7410272956,
0.2451003343,
-0.0390982144,
0.1531479061,
-0.9597610831,
-0.1928337514,
0.4780022502,
-0.4566851556,
-0.0502931029,
0.1541678011,
-0.9608605504,
-0.8296095133,
-0.0125751644,
0.5385246873,
0.2114467174,
-0.3721431792,
0.8530661464,
0.4344355166,
-0.6284393668,
-0.2182995528,
-0.6463586092,
0.4424141645,
-0.3247055113,
-0.4904669225,
0.6356995106,
-0.4307616055,
-0.4797611833,
0.297885716,
0.1603986621,
-0.2375741601,
0.0290261339,
-0.0069572371,
0.3514221311,
0.0781476051,
0.2564711869,
-0.1232156605,
-0.1964167953,
0.3362650573,
-0.4340682924,
0.509085834,
-0.4098944962,
-0.4697677195,
-0.4328728318,
0.3615947366,
0.4907690883,
-0.4364898205,
0.2945249975,
0.3298749328,
-0.4642839432,
-0.8651069403,
-0.5674058199,
0.1793114245,
-0.5579581261,
0.2123792171,
-0.3692302108,
-0.418094486,
0.4747093618,
-0.2237150371,
0.3188336194,
0.3528603017,
0.8482813835,
-0.3763902485,
0.792683661,
0.8842653036,
0.1139394492,
0.567530036,
-0.327085346,
0.5063133836,
-0.6230254173,
-0.3070835471,
-0.4996902049,
-0.2557196319,
-0.1431906223,
-0.2187254578,
0.4727706015,
-0.2264396697,
-0.308796823,
0.4454515278,
-0.4795355499,
0.428825289,
0.4221319556,
-0.1161254048,
0.3682736158,
-0.1924183518,
-0.3576387465,
0.3818491101,
-1.184464097,
-0.3734803498,
0.8782277107,
0.1231397912,
0.8987852335,
-0.1565212011,
0.6822793484,
0.3998049498,
0.4395117164,
-0.8322526813,
0.5304294229,
0.2688381076,
-0.5224478245,
-0.5264151096,
-0.2315389365,
-0.5760679841,
-0.2580785453,
-0.1659159064,
-0.4257154167,
0.1728597879,
0.2563663423,
-0.7881340981,
0.3389748335,
-0.6521212459,
0.6265902519,
-0.6995707154,
-0.2420908362,
-0.0960300267,
-0.4476276338,
0.020122122,
-0.3545169234,
0.514493227,
0.1160835922,
0.2716427147,
0.7894933224,
-0.1027515903,
0.7387056947,
0.1874475777,
-0.4830415547,
0.861715734,
0.2963431478,
0.3540341556,
-0.0750377998,
0.0640276447,
-0.0508051254,
-0.4384522736,
0.0590373725,
-0.8630827069,
0.3287279606,
-0.425218761,
-0.7605912089,
-0.1657258272,
-0.9786467552,
-0.1232058704,
0.2960196137,
0.1733253151,
0.275142014,
-0.0789675266,
-0.1471960396,
0.5000615716,
-0.245406732,
0.7193846703,
0.6713738441,
-0.0220594816,
-0.3047176003,
0.7885458469,
0.0630487353,
0.087035656,
0.0294133313,
0.0828577355,
-0.3553850651,
-0.6087722182,
-0.8214323521,
0.2491768003,
-0.6314795017,
-0.3819707334,
-0.3210991323,
-0.5390139222,
-0.1043015942,
-0.1474431306,
-0.522593081,
-0.3059152663,
0.0303113721,
0.2444376051,
0.1341141611,
0.9095142484,
-0.1434662342,
0.059783265,
-0.5906177759,
0.5401016474,
0.3930235803,
0.6683064103,
0.1432505697,
-0.330101639,
-0.4784737229,
0.0101317028,
-0.2419458628,
-0.7562261224,
0.4496008754,
-0.1378831267,
0.792388916,
0.2250056267,
0.1035277173,
0.2529325783,
-0.5322396755,
0.22179088,
0.0231516119,
-0.9768335819,
0.4572520852,
-0.2078302354,
0.2380751222,
0.2947118878,
0.1649012864,
-0.4535725415,
-0.3468306065,
-0.6520567536,
-0.754314363,
0.2617689073,
0.3262227774,
-0.2312077135,
0.2735112011,
0.3943755925,
0.1293784976,
0.346576184,
-0.700281024,
0.0175598208,
-0.0130618783,
-0.6597732306,
0.0972478092,
-0.0454034805,
-0.163388893,
-0.2591388226,
0.4886834323,
0.0775626749,
0.4917186797,
0.0456108116,
-0.1524166614,
-0.4248648286,
0.3943403363,
0.3583288789,
0.6884996295,
0.1431995034,
0.1732489169,
0.3432429135,
-0.0679030716,
0.3416877091,
0.1210601479,
-0.3993883431,
0.0160162188,
-0.000627344,
0.3223593533,
-0.1504326612,
-0.5495105982,
0.0002045852,
0.1131832078,
-0.2865147591,
-0.778701961,
0.2911629677,
0.1455105841,
0.5540488958,
0.4188299179,
-0.2709032297,
0.1399126351,
-0.2582754791,
0.2386422306,
0.7070040107,
0.0410102233,
-0.011624746,
0.5275993943,
0.1962822527,
-0.8216627836,
0.3058578074,
-0.2325438559,
-0.7482298613,
0.9211054444,
0.6690506935,
1.054852128,
-0.2838403881,
0.1564253569,
0.0242053457,
0.2792951465,
0.0732740983,
0.3021956682,
-0.0552872829,
-0.8047306538,
-0.3539780974,
-0.5899758935,
-0.4829067588,
0.2192172259,
-0.1387527436,
0.3385246992,
-0.3972216845,
-0.0914691165,
0.0491354391,
-0.0660964623,
-0.5777084827,
0.2134637237,
0.3832788467,
0.7230130434,
-0.7795028687,
0.4864065051,
0.7247301936,
-0.3947958052,
-0.8212023973,
0.0525558032,
-0.0573579408,
-0.5634926558,
0.6913801432,
-0.1953193694,
-0.6175700426,
0.4024370015,
-0.6730210781,
-1.049274683,
1.0690722466,
0.0352537185,
-0.5883646011,
-0.3677909374,
0.5743860602,
0.3549389541,
-0.5970135331,
0.0117363138,
0.5245862007,
0.5035071373,
-0.0032368752,
-1.1052417755,
0.0138178272,
-0.4538947344,
-0.0955685824,
0.339951843,
-0.5862646699,
0.8395118117,
-0.3173845708,
-0.3498579562,
0.0794199705,
0.5572578311,
0.1997939199,
0.2642707825,
0.5044152737,
0.6905812621,
0.3010647595,
0.1908157021,
0.4794246554,
-0.37155056,
0.3819429874,
0.9621674418,
-0.0194919258,
0.429353416,
0.288826555,
-0.127529785,
0.6764435768,
0.3900205791,
-0.3194886148,
0.2943840623,
0.4154453576,
-0.2171990871,
-0.3697903454,
0.1051106527,
-0.2865908146,
0.6102483273,
0.5684781075,
-0.1881332099,
-0.4878761768,
0.099842228,
-0.0793312863,
0.0407255366,
-0.1197450161,
0.6101884246,
0.2840572298,
-0.29948318,
0.7071942687,
0.0292456597,
0.2657175362,
-0.1913829744,
-0.3040623963,
0.0418705866,
0.1589907855,
-0.0710252747,
-1.0239573717,
0.3788251877,
0.112194106,
-0.0090328762,
-0.134901017,
0.6823061705,
-0.2686287165,
-0.564711988,
0.0512383319,
0.8678233027,
-0.041994065,
0.1070251316,
-0.7881793976,
-0.1724928468,
-0.2595303357,
0.2009472996,
-0.3299768269,
0.6310908794,
-0.1193117946,
1.202469945,
0.4099134803,
0.1517895311,
-0.1794431061,
-0.1754625291,
1.0086253881,
-0.7099354267,
-0.660553515,
-0.9182145596,
0.2402128577,
0.081430383,
0.1170463338,
0.6545516849,
0.4633164704,
0.9069202542,
0.0569905527,
1.2018988132,
-0.1273306459,
0.5500515699,
-0.3716561794,
0.878917098,
-0.3370268941,
0.2411984056,
-0.4745319486,
-0.9029028416,
-0.3185654283,
0.6698609591,
-0.5182614923,
0.025064528,
0.5800021291,
0.3987039626,
0.0574819259,
-0.0446340889,
-0.1333058029,
0.4585596621,
0.3783380389,
0.8701763153,
1.1623940468,
0.154308483,
0.5933871865,
-0.1324944049,
-0.4525525272,
-0.2549702823,
-0.8686986566,
-0.8349146247,
-0.6116006374,
-0.0023855618,
0.0317808203,
-0.0191355888,
1.0866059065,
0.2066363543,
-0.5319265723,
-0.4289756715,
-0.6689173579,
0.0170487501,
0.219231993,
-0.1657018661,
0.2661232352,
-0.3932561278,
-0.3812092841,
0.2458963692,
0.2689523995,
0.2506650686,
-0.4764570892,
0.2021680325,
0.0963253528,
0.3569231927,
0.2623797655,
0.51533705,
-0.6593873501,
-0.1879704744,
0.0598236769,
-0.0377175547,
0.1269740313,
0.7611306906,
-1.1244982481,
0.4545201361,
0.2413423806,
0.4676852226,
0.1570797265,
0.1277218759,
0.8149924278,
-0.0167537443,
0.1302021444,
0.5019232631,
0.1243568957,
0.1133755445,
-0.223571077,
0.1473762542,
0.2122611552,
-0.3031721711,
-0.5624122024,
0.6755475402,
-0.3804893494,
-0.412967056,
0.9952018857,
0.1531932652,
-0.2800142765,
-0.4002275467,
-0.2060197145,
0.653539598,
0.0056306352,
1.5768760443,
0.5485773087,
-0.4940643311,
-0.1037006825,
-0.6714124084,
0.7350350618,
0.4947903156,
-1.106038332,
0.2078606188,
0.1236843765,
0.2214650214,
0.2164619416,
0.2665219307,
-0.0601676181,
0.2686710656,
-0.1261715591,
0.4215232134,
-0.3716287613,
-0.6774827242,
0.1381426454,
-0.0446646847,
0.1956573725,
-0.0204637256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08198v1
|
Validating and Exploring Large Geographic Corpora
| 2024-03-13T02:46:17 | 2024-03-13T02:46:17 |
Jonathan Dunn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper investigates the impact of corpus creation decisions on large
multi-lingual geographic web corpora. Beginning with a 427 billion word corpus
derived from the Common Crawl, three methods are used to improve the quality of
sub-corpora representing specific language-country pairs like New Zealand
English: (i) the agreement of independent language identification systems, (ii)
hash-based deduplication, and (iii) location-specific outlier detection. The
impact of each of these steps is then evaluated at the language level and the
country level by using corpus similarity measures to compare each resulting
corpus with baseline data sets. The goal is to understand the impact of
upstream data cleaning decisions on downstream corpora with a specific focus on
under-represented languages and populations. The evaluation shows that the
validity of sub-corpora is improved with each stage of cleaning but that this
improvement is unevenly distributed across languages and populations. This
result shows how standard corpus creation techniques can accidentally exclude
under-represented populations.
|
[
-0.8731857538,
-0.4635198414,
0.5987690687,
0.1382502317,
-0.0941270739,
0.3170249164,
-0.6029217839,
-0.5552828908,
0.3508372307,
0.5661332011,
-0.1600178331,
-0.80040133,
-0.4631435275,
0.6125948429,
-0.5556727052,
0.8265758157,
0.0338777862,
-0.2010750771,
-0.042265676,
-0.1423785537,
-0.44955796,
-0.6068456769,
-0.4948982596,
0.0938505232,
0.4999313653,
0.7729071379,
0.9386842251,
0.478790462,
0.4829004407,
0.3342814744,
-0.2986107767,
0.557723105,
-0.6651954651,
-0.0475139283,
-0.3221462667,
-0.4258902967,
0.0129223717,
-0.113735415,
0.7301707268,
1.0176883936,
-0.0654269382,
0.1855276674,
-0.0299232882,
0.5612393022,
-0.7561833262,
-0.126413092,
-0.6521704793,
-0.2486404777,
-0.4092960358,
-0.1704410762,
-0.256391108,
-0.4050933123,
0.1070553809,
-0.7683770657,
0.4866043925,
0.1589015275,
0.7508978844,
0.0498778969,
-0.4642767608,
-0.530143559,
-0.5982853174,
0.8159543276,
-0.3555809557,
0.3297260106,
0.6438949704,
0.0510527641,
-0.4481072724,
-0.4084743261,
-0.3446264565,
0.1231172383,
-0.3474180102,
0.0623190627,
-0.3887057602,
-0.4364231229,
0.1443031579,
0.0920034647,
-0.6762558222,
0.4489371479,
-0.9751794338,
-0.2315769494,
0.5438347459,
-0.1104645357,
0.4933070242,
-0.3234606683,
-0.1909624636,
-0.1213083938,
-1.191316247,
-0.1131872311,
0.8912190795,
0.6080727577,
0.0351539999,
0.5406522155,
-0.3295626342,
0.301425755,
-0.0949145332,
0.1482296139,
0.4367910922,
-0.2398506254,
-0.010304004,
0.3134916723,
0.5377433896,
0.3195513189,
0.5676586628,
-0.2648436427,
-0.0423300602,
0.09665218,
0.3796263337,
-0.3693034351,
-0.0593608953,
0.4582588673,
-0.3295325041,
0.0122942813,
0.247202605,
-0.9302845001,
-0.3765202165,
-0.53074646,
-0.149297297,
-0.591676116,
-0.550583303,
0.2875410318,
-0.3842429221,
-0.019407073,
0.3627465367,
-0.8907555938,
0.1902040541,
1.0248359442,
0.7712844014,
-0.1983801872,
-0.4910351336,
-0.3158308566,
-0.0080496268,
-0.7472807169,
0.9728910327,
-0.4285663068,
-0.3928129971,
0.2765730321,
0.0787445381,
0.0700831339,
-0.9172830582,
0.3479492664,
-0.9521259069,
0.1578316987,
-0.4761982858,
-0.2745612562,
-0.4963817596,
0.4178268313,
-0.8765000105,
1.1354250908,
0.3292192817,
-0.5613355637,
0.6157878637,
-0.6122290492,
-0.4260180295,
0.183921814,
0.2081802636,
-0.0472518243,
0.188755706,
0.3142715394,
0.0796905607,
-0.1216032207,
0.2244729102,
-0.1051373482,
-0.5432140231,
-0.0595419034,
-0.0877665952,
1.1027326584,
0.4617688358,
-0.4659750164,
-0.1020276919,
-0.9461198449,
0.2609399557,
-0.3713796735,
-0.3614462614,
-0.7353538871,
-0.1338772029,
0.0577590428,
-0.0747454986,
0.1933327466,
-0.6353678107,
0.1011696383,
-0.1553008854,
0.3739638329,
0.2813135087,
0.1435855776,
0.4153805673,
-0.0706458092,
0.6142879725,
-0.0381822735,
0.2110403925,
-0.0127873132,
-0.4600895643,
-0.4361775219,
-0.5486495495,
0.7181578279,
0.4222980142,
-0.4190561473,
0.36747697,
-0.6797133684,
-0.6775197387,
-0.3618102074,
0.0964953229,
0.1341494322,
0.0549524575,
0.5433966517,
-0.3888911307,
-0.8588953614,
-0.7004206181,
0.411742866,
-0.1928955913,
-0.1637147218,
-0.227318719,
0.6004500985,
-0.7008018494,
1.2023376226,
-0.2999326587,
-0.1499441117,
-0.0067074001,
0.2881444395,
-0.1315182596,
0.2988849878,
0.5566139817,
-0.8837622404,
-0.2826625705,
-0.1319464296,
-0.5448530912,
-0.3441126347,
0.1664783359,
-0.4254159033,
0.4910899699,
0.6617559195,
-0.5534753799,
0.3662900031,
0.6669380069,
-0.1418462843,
0.4959568679,
-0.3965996802,
0.4752122164,
-0.4990482628,
0.0426219702,
-0.2104523778,
0.0224379171,
-0.2052515745,
0.3329031169,
0.1890995055,
-0.005265181,
-0.5106807947,
0.0790348202,
-0.6404859424,
-0.3704510629,
-0.171100229,
0.5058096051,
-0.0032346556,
-0.040931806,
0.0551362559,
0.7326828241,
0.1763642281,
-0.5143568516,
0.0861264169,
0.3318144083,
-0.6809397936,
0.3672641218,
-0.424962312,
-0.0058805109,
-0.2798870504,
0.3798077106,
-1.2082071304,
-0.0178073589,
-0.2841160297,
-0.4101050198,
-0.0086677372,
-0.1501735449,
-0.7269052267,
-0.2061555833,
-0.3384105265,
0.4189091325,
0.2719298601,
-0.7689502239,
0.1373202056,
0.5583172441,
-0.1576936543,
-0.4949391782,
-0.7664528489,
0.3758169711,
-0.5354121923,
-0.7113143802,
0.1717610657,
0.1427546889,
-0.5832223892,
0.0814204663,
0.3115630448,
0.0546824746,
0.0909745693,
0.1464865655,
0.0345373377,
-0.1501467526,
0.1676599085,
-0.2667453885,
0.0336992927,
0.0165008307,
-0.2396878749,
0.7498215437,
-0.0374394655,
-0.2907349467,
0.2459363937,
0.5652529001,
0.4655460119,
-0.4992398024,
0.5008069873,
0.5110580325,
-0.2788254917,
-0.0539394394,
-0.5474143624,
0.2706941366,
-0.4246044159,
0.1288746148,
-0.2938997447,
-0.799336791,
0.6704773903,
-0.0954268053,
-0.0230354872,
0.647533536,
0.3460517526,
-0.0004699242,
0.6619989872,
0.5934683084,
-0.0979842246,
0.0111235417,
-0.3492551446,
0.3285779357,
-0.6512719989,
-0.0908589885,
-0.7271993756,
-0.2568880022,
-1.2764658928,
-0.4381884038,
0.3434570432,
0.1769785285,
-0.4499880075,
0.5500049591,
-0.3584525287,
0.4545672834,
0.9966853857,
-0.2977895439,
0.3254190087,
0.2292035967,
-0.1760770082,
0.0816083923,
-0.6340476871,
-0.8074980378,
1.0439509153,
-0.0484903865,
0.4334784746,
0.5176648498,
0.9265127778,
0.27023229,
0.255636543,
-0.5721306801,
0.3276267052,
-0.2613620162,
-0.6892839074,
-0.5066178441,
-0.3299206197,
-1.421661377,
0.3058674932,
-0.2531606257,
-0.5209530592,
0.2304613143,
-0.3676829338,
-0.4076356888,
0.2102102637,
-0.8767369986,
0.4736974835,
-0.1788024604,
-0.0987072811,
-0.2266864926,
-0.4654455483,
0.1076704785,
-0.3894533813,
0.6935938597,
0.0837534145,
-0.1002259329,
0.4731472433,
-0.3971599638,
0.7613912225,
-0.1017371342,
-0.3139567077,
0.7064413428,
0.1140088812,
0.0539612509,
-0.1030218899,
-0.1551053673,
0.6327930093,
0.1330781579,
-0.3289431334,
-0.3819375336,
0.6866754293,
-0.7788125277,
-0.4161586463,
-0.2574958205,
-0.2870930731,
-0.1369156539,
0.3173194528,
0.2477185577,
0.450910002,
-0.1223995611,
0.2391104102,
0.4950305521,
-0.576910913,
0.3729529977,
0.5974849463,
-0.1415159851,
-0.539590776,
0.5965992808,
0.2252903283,
0.0322245657,
0.3517716229,
0.1532067508,
-0.4655514956,
-0.5042848587,
-0.3877375722,
0.1501174271,
-0.7292705178,
-0.2484143227,
-0.4277653396,
0.3768647015,
-0.69964993,
-0.1754518896,
-0.0846004188,
-0.2152531892,
-0.0204497501,
-0.1197759286,
0.2483004332,
0.8550907373,
-0.431915313,
0.3048945665,
-0.900785327,
0.0688721836,
-0.2836086154,
0.1076198593,
-0.250913471,
-0.0923507512,
-0.3061668575,
0.0136168087,
-0.0013116216,
-0.5794969797,
0.4557671547,
-0.2159614414,
0.3657171726,
0.2293839902,
0.0682047457,
0.9569451809,
-0.6693010926,
0.8842942715,
-0.0434108712,
-0.722158432,
0.3112926185,
-0.3798618615,
0.5919555426,
0.7313975096,
0.709207356,
-0.6844005585,
-0.6060894728,
-0.64858073,
-1.1455332041,
-0.0503937304,
-0.1073924899,
-0.0052482998,
-0.387114495,
0.2600145936,
0.1384508908,
-0.0380099863,
-0.1361489147,
0.0195921212,
0.2628440559,
-0.1474700421,
-0.1257172674,
-0.2230831087,
-0.0627031103,
0.147432372,
0.755969882,
-0.0434388891,
-0.1670131087,
0.2189949453,
-0.3284140825,
-0.1484120339,
0.3249690831,
0.5625658631,
0.9570007324,
0.0433537737,
0.3962406814,
0.1268630624,
-0.6689248681,
-0.0306952689,
-0.0888832659,
-0.3037377596,
0.1792521477,
0.5161659122,
0.0322859213,
0.370028764,
-0.8545448184,
0.2102805376,
-0.046070911,
-0.2664756477,
-0.5343679786,
-0.3766206503,
0.0775889084,
0.1598384827,
0.468775928,
-0.0281425826,
0.2058636248,
-0.4881133735,
0.3014057875,
0.2973036766,
0.1216233373,
-0.0382094458,
0.3023317754,
-0.1285686046,
0.0306251831,
0.9701276422,
-0.4711988568,
-0.674918294,
0.6322857141,
0.2101033777,
0.2583650649,
0.045198679,
0.1399582773,
0.7362865806,
0.523781538,
-0.080880031,
0.1751751304,
0.1525434554,
-0.7114580274,
-0.5294037461,
-0.4438560009,
-0.4223327041,
0.1459638178,
-0.5753701329,
0.4870606065,
-0.1120759696,
-0.1876869202,
0.0787853971,
0.2797860205,
-0.6801216602,
0.4268112481,
0.3031055033,
0.8470108509,
-0.8308796883,
0.2748062313,
0.6175227761,
-0.3659702539,
-0.65847224,
-0.1179543063,
0.1590360105,
-0.7717880011,
0.8564934134,
0.2024537176,
-0.3094772398,
-0.4012596607,
-0.4345183074,
-1.4509986639,
0.7465740442,
0.0243338626,
-0.5542837381,
0.3849176764,
0.3665909171,
0.8562358022,
-0.0057297647,
0.2770897448,
0.4874916673,
0.6102505326,
-0.2168973386,
-1.0021519661,
0.0486633144,
0.0272440333,
-0.0579172708,
0.4051535428,
-0.4589896202,
0.7968243361,
-0.269079864,
-0.4979903698,
0.0025955993,
0.5285861492,
0.3379807472,
-0.0210047793,
0.8701655865,
0.5760439038,
1.1228761673,
-0.0234857704,
0.8317217827,
-0.3956763446,
0.1879797727,
1.0819859505,
-0.4488283694,
1.0736972094,
0.3115873635,
-0.0872712508,
0.7124387026,
0.8191301227,
-0.1759159863,
0.4067669809,
0.6482542753,
-0.0465601124,
0.1817470342,
-0.0530733354,
-0.1978379935,
1.0348954201,
0.2955657244,
-0.0440088511,
-0.5015177727,
-0.0518322624,
0.1773318201,
0.2602746189,
-0.3452009857,
0.4252923429,
-0.4750738442,
-1.1337391138,
0.4839115441,
0.0206630677,
0.8233883381,
-0.3023701906,
0.0923940837,
-0.2066921294,
0.0900214612,
-0.5867747068,
-0.7290587425,
0.4822055995,
0.3080913126,
-0.2200645208,
-0.2681134641,
0.4934263229,
-0.5119017363,
-0.2145665437,
0.5134489536,
0.574388206,
0.4674216807,
-0.1217362583,
-0.0192324761,
0.169413954,
-0.1807295829,
-0.1661520451,
0.2351778001,
0.7296646237,
-0.5253824592,
0.095183976,
0.9131561518,
0.2444971949,
0.0540982783,
0.4962459803,
0.2909039855,
-0.5197363496,
-0.498634696,
-0.6256911159,
0.1494945735,
-0.1688379347,
-0.2171135545,
0.9490277767,
1.0812791586,
1.1961855888,
0.1849205941,
0.8502064943,
-0.0765988529,
0.6284160614,
-0.3587712049,
0.5108555555,
-0.2714283466,
0.041554004,
-0.1330294758,
-0.7353457808,
-0.3667178452,
0.3440128267,
-0.4070543945,
-0.1520467699,
0.7662112713,
0.8584460616,
-0.037508674,
0.1403306872,
0.2359520793,
-0.1734668612,
0.3149130344,
0.1787264496,
0.9406998754,
-0.2919294238,
0.6598968506,
-0.2035185099,
-0.29730317,
0.1623744816,
-1.0252574682,
-0.2501377165,
-0.5966129899,
-0.353639096,
-0.2488604933,
-0.2362592816,
0.6649711728,
0.5488985181,
-0.8557946682,
-0.1645877957,
0.1132798046,
-0.157577917,
-0.1986532211,
-0.312969327,
0.4466588795,
-0.5431296825,
-0.883972466,
0.4884569049,
-0.0391639955,
-0.2908334732,
-0.3543319404,
0.3402325809,
-0.1830387712,
-0.330170691,
0.8640204668,
0.1978880763,
-0.4116127789,
-0.4036677182,
0.0358815119,
-0.154449299,
0.0192378145,
0.8277007341,
-0.65558213,
0.1946605742,
0.362770766,
0.4506364167,
0.509531498,
0.1803385168,
0.4182229638,
-0.7770012021,
-0.0450953469,
-0.1024336442,
0.5009927154,
0.7244921327,
-0.4623976648,
0.7746657133,
-0.0894042403,
-0.6257784367,
-0.4846116602,
-0.0514978468,
-0.6861115098,
-0.496404171,
1.6943870783,
-0.0626226664,
-0.2071704268,
-0.419668138,
-0.1688281149,
0.1920845658,
-0.2176338881,
0.9043015242,
0.8776578903,
-0.0163865108,
0.5546392202,
-0.5543738008,
0.2401602417,
0.1972287595,
-0.6490280032,
-0.0210637599,
0.9146193862,
0.5167044401,
0.8416634202,
0.5720130205,
-0.3136989772,
0.0602917187,
-0.1180124059,
0.0956222862,
0.221490711,
-0.2433370948,
-0.1608528048,
0.3873234093,
-0.2535519898,
-0.138957426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08196v1
|
SpeechColab Leaderboard: An Open-Source Platform for Automatic Speech Recognition Evaluation
| 2024-03-13T02:41:53 | 2024-03-13T02:41:53 |
Jiayu Du, Jinpeng Li, Guoguo Chen, Wei-Qiang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
In the wake of the surging tide of deep learning over the past decade,
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) has garnered substantial attention, leading
to the emergence of numerous publicly accessible ASR systems that are actively
being integrated into our daily lives. Nonetheless, the impartial and
replicable evaluation of these ASR systems encounters challenges due to various
crucial subtleties. In this paper we introduce the SpeechColab Leaderboard, a
general-purpose, open-source platform designed for ASR evaluation. With this
platform: (i) We report a comprehensive benchmark, unveiling the current
state-of-the-art panorama for ASR systems, covering both open-source models and
industrial commercial services. (ii) We quantize how distinct nuances in the
scoring pipeline influence the final benchmark outcomes. These include nuances
related to capitalization, punctuation, interjection, contraction, synonym
usage, compound words, etc. These issues have gained prominence in the context
of the transition towards an End-to-End future. (iii) We propose a practical
modification to the conventional Token-Error-Rate (TER) evaluation metric, with
inspirations from Kolmogorov complexity and Normalized Information Distance
(NID). This adaptation, called modified-TER (mTER), achieves proper
normalization and symmetrical treatment of reference and hypothesis. By
leveraging this platform as a large-scale testing ground, this study
demonstrates the robustness and backward compatibility of mTER when compared to
TER. The SpeechColab Leaderboard is accessible at
https://github.com/SpeechColab/Leaderboard
|
[
-0.2215327322,
-0.5527870655,
0.0396814309,
0.6642587185,
-0.1399420202,
0.4384649098,
-0.4620298445,
-0.3110404015,
0.0570374094,
0.0679230615,
-0.018150948,
-0.6582712531,
-0.7084505558,
-0.0923888236,
-0.4747917354,
0.8690128326,
-0.0495826118,
0.1240582019,
-0.1222539619,
-0.2994692624,
-0.6015649438,
-0.497826308,
-0.6922927499,
-0.4670127928,
0.3904655278,
0.3147905469,
0.4110042453,
0.5192880034,
0.8573896289,
0.273866564,
-0.1369385868,
-0.2781847715,
-0.1447773129,
0.2407729626,
0.0385161601,
-0.0677900687,
-0.6657787561,
0.0175272692,
0.7629973888,
0.8039880991,
-0.325076133,
0.4326811135,
0.4120113254,
0.4710608721,
-0.6957271099,
0.3901500702,
-0.4401372671,
0.0849038437,
-0.2665697932,
-0.1904141456,
-0.2711013258,
-0.6521713138,
0.1205078587,
-0.2115663886,
0.0613493584,
-0.1246528104,
0.3603393734,
0.4399496317,
-0.0945114642,
-0.4921268225,
-0.752332449,
0.4985166788,
-0.2889020145,
0.6606166363,
0.1834916621,
0.8366554379,
0.0564946085,
-0.9938083887,
-0.3795550466,
-0.3671894073,
0.3745217025,
0.2318690866,
-0.5578229427,
-0.1062402278,
0.0176011417,
0.4882936478,
-0.6989046335,
0.3143007457,
-0.4755433798,
-0.1779481322,
0.2718062699,
0.0494613051,
0.0683218166,
0.0702230632,
-0.0852933004,
-0.1817907244,
-0.3362251222,
0.324151963,
0.234262079,
0.5032895803,
-0.0838851184,
0.4665498734,
-0.2577353418,
0.4752794504,
0.0877964199,
0.3978965878,
0.5947560668,
0.1210664213,
-0.3492147326,
0.5434398055,
0.9640955329,
0.398950398,
-0.0241631046,
-0.4125757217,
-0.0417050123,
0.4052458704,
0.1549565941,
-0.8050041199,
-0.5092693567,
0.3009985685,
-0.3232257664,
-0.3130094409,
0.191720292,
-0.6793260574,
-0.4183031023,
-0.1272889972,
0.5072339773,
-0.3795744181,
-0.0186813511,
0.0154877575,
-0.1419183016,
0.3008777201,
0.3484388888,
-0.5044007301,
0.4943937957,
0.8607546091,
1.0919305086,
-0.2947429717,
-0.3101317585,
-0.9509866834,
-0.1983485371,
-0.355299592,
0.7836589813,
-0.5666965842,
-0.5422891378,
-0.2941384614,
-0.2943985164,
-0.1177357361,
-0.8186447024,
0.7194955945,
-0.3325141966,
0.1078839749,
-0.1125492379,
-0.46789819,
0.0801160336,
0.2429210991,
-0.5391466022,
0.7555193305,
-0.3491027951,
-0.4381963611,
0.3974350095,
-1.0376114845,
-0.4406381547,
0.2574310005,
-0.1945742965,
-0.3852467239,
-0.0385043472,
0.0730060413,
0.1280755848,
-0.3387284577,
0.1963630617,
-0.083464101,
-0.4807099104,
0.3126870394,
-0.4458789527,
0.8553743958,
0.2920899987,
-0.4403275549,
0.4111816287,
-0.8822543621,
0.2027902603,
-0.3424867392,
-0.4696811736,
0.0321578644,
-0.1135261506,
0.2493368983,
-0.0493451916,
0.0664647073,
-0.6133866906,
-0.2529335022,
-0.1874027699,
0.7308084965,
0.7893132567,
-0.1773860604,
0.2142982483,
-0.2046615034,
0.50365448,
-0.194223702,
0.2829235792,
0.0396328829,
-0.5999577641,
-0.6394062638,
-0.4897934198,
0.6659040451,
0.6372378469,
-0.1251052022,
0.8612314463,
-0.4885671735,
-0.6618465185,
-0.9989489913,
-0.0623873249,
0.3936341107,
0.6410680413,
0.4554432034,
-0.3975557089,
-0.572431922,
-0.571703136,
-0.2386667579,
-0.1443655491,
-0.2810847163,
0.1278684735,
0.2707523406,
-0.2466880381,
0.8299114704,
-0.1116226837,
-0.6900214553,
-0.0477714799,
0.2484263331,
0.2553848028,
0.6549270153,
0.1878781766,
-0.6270272732,
-0.6565262675,
0.0863330662,
-0.5965023637,
-0.1911594272,
0.2891893387,
0.2874998748,
-0.0659996122,
0.5063668489,
-0.3136935532,
0.3423010707,
0.5915262103,
-0.2120840549,
0.5813400745,
-0.2520287335,
0.3001268208,
-0.6865939498,
0.3937704265,
-0.3034420609,
-0.065709278,
-0.4581935704,
-0.0028736526,
-0.0846269652,
-0.1288813204,
-0.2531564832,
0.4836426675,
0.0174251925,
-0.228965655,
-0.1090529859,
0.2069675773,
-0.1334764659,
0.0078368578,
-0.3675419688,
0.7278338075,
0.6493062973,
-0.4410307705,
0.47511518,
0.2738166153,
-0.5420449972,
0.769600451,
-0.8926719427,
0.3162657917,
0.0950631872,
0.0871839747,
-0.8296085596,
0.0589126833,
0.1616003811,
-0.7833359241,
0.0728183687,
-0.0176193714,
-0.5799461007,
-0.3370456398,
-0.2303817421,
0.1639443189,
0.6401836872,
-0.5604932308,
0.4104560018,
0.4864590466,
-0.1964541823,
-0.4284273982,
-0.7326554656,
0.4122472703,
-0.1937417537,
-0.4182962477,
0.2533340156,
-0.3550851345,
-0.3689435124,
-0.089187853,
-0.2050970644,
0.0174717139,
0.0201295335,
0.491140008,
-0.0048366562,
-0.2826472521,
-0.0886723697,
-0.1293149889,
-0.316960305,
-0.0717025325,
-0.2486654222,
0.60446316,
-0.6772735715,
-0.2743563056,
-0.6867531538,
0.0117537612,
0.5584781766,
-0.3990026712,
0.2015230507,
0.7352235317,
-0.3727769554,
0.036304269,
-0.5526291728,
0.0778477192,
-0.4255364239,
0.1792536676,
-0.4467611313,
-0.7411587238,
0.5384805202,
0.0771967098,
-0.1084180102,
0.222192198,
0.5858545303,
-0.2502236962,
0.6205102801,
0.4907322824,
-0.0423446186,
0.2457949519,
-0.1904093176,
0.1235970035,
-0.9493122697,
-0.4392310083,
-0.6633909345,
-0.4822562933,
-0.6024492383,
-0.4967122078,
0.3437526524,
-0.0828802884,
-0.2413575798,
0.2452981621,
-0.6402437687,
0.41226843,
0.7062942386,
-0.0185228847,
0.4344602525,
-0.1634492725,
0.0105921021,
-0.211278379,
-0.3875510395,
-0.4691080153,
1.0175973177,
0.2002493292,
0.5591591001,
0.0643656552,
0.5324969888,
0.7168646455,
0.2092218399,
-0.7926388383,
0.4348717034,
-0.4192022979,
-0.1852663606,
-0.1735326648,
-0.364883244,
-0.8238119483,
0.1900495589,
-0.0185806975,
-0.7409052253,
0.3243621588,
0.1045093536,
-0.4128769934,
0.0537376963,
-0.5891799331,
0.948492229,
-0.2202674299,
-0.0508069135,
-0.1271558106,
-0.5797420144,
-0.2306680232,
-0.0477027148,
0.0384112634,
0.1237715781,
0.1880939901,
0.8999764919,
-0.1252650619,
0.6142501235,
-0.3229023814,
0.4032977223,
0.1368392259,
0.0896808058,
0.0743817091,
-0.2650282979,
-0.334340483,
0.3852538168,
-0.1923667789,
-0.1234875619,
-0.5255868435,
0.7630332708,
-0.7408718467,
-0.073952727,
-0.4698834121,
-0.2516799867,
-0.2543659806,
0.3248223364,
0.1789414287,
0.4754996598,
-0.5783984065,
0.731603384,
0.3593263924,
-0.1564279199,
0.2619404793,
0.2945517302,
-0.1797069609,
-0.7214013934,
0.8833379149,
0.1963908225,
-0.2091653198,
0.3385255039,
0.2474339902,
-0.2983409762,
-0.7277530432,
-0.3131194115,
-0.2496555746,
-0.6360782981,
-0.046889592,
-0.6454597116,
-0.2381415218,
-0.5052740574,
-0.1614972949,
-0.4363636672,
-0.5061871409,
-0.1574821472,
-0.277479738,
0.0708090067,
0.3420065641,
-0.280641675,
0.4197223783,
-0.1772498637,
0.2808320224,
0.2709214091,
0.6157747507,
-0.2120617479,
-0.6649725437,
0.0767900273,
-0.01845585,
-0.2596929371,
-0.3565818667,
0.1262777001,
0.4958291352,
0.548861444,
0.2522870898,
0.0545991622,
0.7985790372,
-0.5977059007,
0.5223712921,
0.213657245,
-1.1093987226,
0.5376889706,
0.0265814736,
0.2086841613,
0.6520783901,
0.130403176,
-0.5806677938,
-0.4135825336,
-0.3550775647,
-0.8498805761,
0.3144122362,
0.2953977883,
-0.1377526671,
0.133001864,
-0.0416985042,
0.2795650363,
0.5067757368,
-0.3702817857,
-0.0930678844,
-0.5887738466,
-0.3229593337,
-0.2134652138,
0.0736260861,
-0.0570056885,
-0.1749252826,
0.5337380767,
0.0856500939,
0.114465639,
0.1070457399,
-0.3732760251,
0.1260585189,
0.4079641998,
0.2692244351,
0.610893786,
-0.4994188547,
0.0458609834,
-0.0569841899,
-0.5702933073,
-0.1297652274,
0.4489763081,
-0.2677643001,
-0.0191162527,
0.2153702676,
0.9090448022,
0.1193130016,
-0.6940059066,
0.5438166857,
-0.0891102031,
-0.0384815559,
-0.3462949395,
-0.0773336589,
-0.1521000564,
0.4659505188,
0.5108718872,
0.2416362762,
0.4854336083,
-0.5276840925,
0.3746767938,
0.3349097967,
-0.826343298,
-0.3314599693,
0.7913658619,
0.1652895808,
-0.6563655734,
0.5522305965,
-0.2220712155,
-0.3301277459,
0.4216338098,
0.2304574847,
1.0988497734,
-0.4670225978,
0.3033433259,
0.1036426127,
0.4478994608,
0.1523579955,
0.1345578432,
-0.2654537857,
-0.3847498596,
-0.1093170568,
-0.7344434857,
-0.6751695275,
-0.0290945116,
-0.8180887103,
0.3887837231,
-0.7692062855,
-0.3656107187,
0.1704341322,
-0.110605523,
-0.4956061542,
0.2139975876,
0.1429500729,
0.8227468729,
-0.4112477601,
0.590134263,
0.6412745118,
-0.341530025,
-0.2167333961,
-0.0645122603,
-0.0693362281,
-0.6308454871,
0.5790838003,
0.3993689716,
-0.3454391658,
0.0218726806,
-0.111412853,
-0.3784070909,
1.1533116102,
0.3765178025,
-0.3993406594,
0.0557450168,
0.1896491498,
0.8322705626,
-0.2231503427,
0.2330563068,
0.4201256633,
0.4066254795,
0.2570731342,
-1.2529686689,
-0.1119985282,
-0.3755207956,
-0.1070096716,
-0.2226093858,
-0.5565228462,
0.6391658783,
-0.201283589,
-0.1243096516,
0.0748241022,
0.4501775503,
0.2028862536,
0.5656446218,
0.2365316898,
0.4665758908,
0.8328172565,
-0.2179188281,
0.5070354939,
-0.2007333785,
0.1946822703,
1.355219245,
-0.3132974505,
1.0882630348,
0.3704825342,
-0.1119082645,
0.5293872356,
0.2226810008,
-0.3418136835,
0.6608893871,
0.1891518682,
0.018462969,
0.1123698205,
-0.0111004421,
-0.4928857088,
0.7041336298,
0.1901719719,
-0.2715367675,
-0.2127266079,
0.1675467342,
-0.1741645485,
0.0438849032,
-0.2670301497,
0.83201617,
0.0928952694,
-0.1026057079,
0.4637434781,
-0.1204154938,
0.5495973825,
-0.4831068814,
0.1408866048,
-0.0013891478,
0.4943473041,
-0.2289200276,
-0.6938465238,
0.3918648958,
0.2212019861,
-0.0055126073,
-0.2197557837,
0.3139039874,
-0.1545592248,
-0.483615607,
0.3931539655,
0.3075465262,
0.2146282196,
-0.3225670159,
-0.667190969,
0.493400842,
-0.3643064797,
0.1382369846,
0.1500662863,
0.2249618024,
0.1572506577,
0.7730567455,
0.7039234042,
0.2611211538,
0.1621763259,
0.252658844,
0.5988391638,
-0.4682535827,
-0.8642414212,
-0.7131279707,
0.4968694746,
-0.1383264065,
-0.1742146611,
0.7016903162,
0.8687600493,
0.6509885192,
0.214029789,
0.8108451366,
-0.1767445058,
0.4683573544,
-0.0319608524,
0.99387604,
-0.200436458,
0.2364526689,
-0.4221480191,
-0.8768686652,
-0.7188154459,
0.7230608463,
-0.3918754756,
-0.1746458709,
0.5040758252,
0.5063304901,
-0.0450266898,
0.1371748149,
0.265188098,
0.4770912826,
0.5005589724,
0.2546426952,
0.7153539658,
-0.6091589332,
0.8801432252,
-0.1448278874,
-0.6059342027,
-0.3295337856,
-0.7337806225,
-0.546192944,
-0.6886641383,
-0.5593165159,
-0.3444238007,
0.5726110339,
0.964192152,
0.400433749,
-0.9666913748,
-0.5049760938,
-0.0670455992,
-0.1732416004,
-0.3239385784,
-0.2127340883,
0.363209933,
-0.1446859241,
-0.6177245975,
0.3999896049,
0.4602928162,
-0.2698279619,
0.0303371437,
-0.0523677729,
0.2282989621,
-0.3361248076,
0.611113131,
0.3595715463,
-0.5589069724,
-0.2344644666,
0.0594641343,
0.0990154073,
0.2973382175,
0.5401863456,
-0.8228423595,
0.6213929653,
0.2942990363,
0.6855955124,
0.333414197,
-0.083732374,
0.3090199232,
-0.3040747941,
-0.0985450223,
0.4972241223,
0.1961124837,
0.5883748531,
0.2153238803,
0.3978140652,
0.173900798,
-0.6065037251,
-1.2126100063,
-0.101448819,
-0.9720580578,
0.216071263,
0.7976606488,
-0.017300725,
0.0223838147,
0.1121168137,
-0.096287556,
0.2268478721,
-0.5925077796,
1.0691436529,
0.4004304111,
-0.1808431745,
-0.0460337736,
-0.3349449039,
0.1844816655,
0.017444687,
-0.6226394176,
0.1144411564,
0.4613108337,
0.388840884,
0.2727491558,
0.7223612666,
-0.2385995537,
0.3400068879,
-0.0053918432,
0.0577742085,
-0.1640385091,
-0.402839452,
-0.6029043198,
0.3152398169,
0.0469220914,
-0.5212690234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09732v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09732v4
|
PET-SQL: A Prompt-Enhanced Two-Round Refinement of Text-to-SQL with Cross-consistency
| 2024-03-13T02:32:41 | 2024-06-02T02:58:53 |
Zhishuai Li, Xiang Wang, Jingjing Zhao, Sun Yang, Guoqing Du, Xiaoru Hu, Bin Zhang, Yuxiao Ye, Ziyue Li, Rui Zhao, Hangyu Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in Text-to-SQL (Text2SQL) emphasize stimulating the large
language models (LLM) on in-context learning, achieving significant results.
Nevertheless, they face challenges when dealing with verbose database
information and complex user intentions. This paper presents a two-stage
framework to enhance the performance of current LLM-based natural language to
SQL systems. We first introduce a novel prompt representation, called
reference-enhanced representation, which includes schema information and
randomly sampled cell values from tables to instruct LLMs in generating SQL
queries. Then, in the first stage, question-SQL pairs are retrieved as few-shot
demonstrations, prompting the LLM to generate a preliminary SQL (PreSQL). After
that, the mentioned entities in PreSQL are parsed to conduct schema linking,
which can significantly compact the useful information. In the second stage,
with the linked schema, we simplify the prompt's schema information and
instruct the LLM to produce the final SQL. Finally, as the post-refinement
module, we propose using cross-consistency across different LLMs rather than
self-consistency within a particular LLM. Our methods achieve new SOTA results
on the Spider benchmark, with an execution accuracy of 87.6%.
|
[
-0.1610030532,
-0.8110296726,
0.6070507765,
0.0154663604,
-0.4496003389,
0.0308191571,
-0.440948844,
-0.3678438067,
0.073116973,
0.5823370814,
-0.6283839345,
-0.5003672242,
0.0089786509,
0.5458093882,
-0.0322303101,
0.9095446467,
0.2644661069,
0.3611523211,
-0.1700443178,
-0.0827625766,
-0.3047652245,
-0.4248276651,
-0.5283309817,
-0.2123692185,
0.3500796258,
0.5258334279,
0.6871884465,
0.4998678863,
0.2621801496,
0.0842348039,
-0.0532864518,
0.4604811966,
-0.4967924058,
0.4217023253,
-0.7130481005,
-0.4770419896,
-0.4407582879,
-0.3611722887,
0.7429556847,
0.4931566417,
-0.2150927931,
-0.4120248258,
0.1986772567,
0.6970387697,
-0.4424422681,
0.0766531006,
-0.856841743,
-0.1624111533,
-0.2541047931,
-0.2773350775,
-0.6684547067,
-0.3596298099,
-0.0348788723,
-0.8767869473,
0.1220836341,
0.2327249646,
0.9726290703,
0.122785069,
-0.4013268054,
-0.1571183056,
-0.4699466527,
0.5233178139,
-0.4656027555,
0.4773275256,
0.3372407258,
0.5164684057,
-0.669878006,
-0.8058861494,
-0.5900914073,
-0.4431657195,
-0.3654177189,
-0.2519744635,
0.3671615422,
0.0303439926,
0.3336648941,
0.2390531749,
-0.4734197259,
-0.0022763561,
-0.0033154795,
-0.1366252899,
0.5921694636,
0.2776979804,
-0.0754088014,
-0.034355551,
-0.4433270395,
0.0792413577,
-1.0718055964,
-0.1066432744,
0.027339384,
0.7036859989,
0.3213379383,
0.7263448238,
-0.3267910779,
0.5627843738,
0.4638946652,
0.2671432495,
0.1457675695,
-0.8019861579,
0.0177501105,
-0.1011264026,
0.9004692435,
0.367387861,
0.1947009116,
-0.1242477745,
-0.1279179752,
-0.1261108667,
0.1607732177,
-0.8386805058,
-0.0434470959,
0.3387706578,
-0.295784086,
-0.1260567904,
-0.3315560222,
-0.6617466211,
-0.7000450492,
-0.3009799123,
0.4266610444,
-0.6912226081,
-0.2692538202,
-0.0498245172,
0.1224187464,
0.4684233963,
0.5859838128,
-0.831885159,
0.520363152,
0.7618988156,
0.5287532806,
-0.2401145548,
-0.1564133316,
-0.6707342863,
0.3782509267,
-0.5392562747,
0.8421620131,
-0.6354649663,
-0.386879921,
-0.146335125,
0.1908053458,
0.3759867549,
-0.5528824329,
0.2810829878,
-0.3713856637,
0.5109071732,
-0.6371411085,
-0.620041132,
0.1750136912,
0.3083518445,
-0.4335128665,
1.6006239653,
0.114297837,
-0.5779477358,
0.5785667896,
-0.3740991056,
-0.4078980386,
0.1271632761,
-0.546200633,
-0.4481846988,
-0.0206369385,
-0.091702655,
0.3416306078,
-0.4968174994,
0.3062846959,
-0.206066668,
-0.5704619884,
-0.0933492705,
0.3325549662,
0.4654637277,
-0.0133839538,
-0.2040199935,
0.1002441198,
-0.977173388,
0.1524838358,
0.0136508765,
-0.2285186052,
-0.2295881808,
-0.0217353906,
-0.1157742068,
0.2781374753,
0.3085345328,
-0.5221905112,
0.3973720074,
-0.4600870907,
0.3239619434,
0.2421314865,
-0.0063195615,
0.5580641031,
0.0192510169,
0.1286727637,
-0.0539706834,
-0.0374737941,
-0.4259338975,
-0.2873038054,
-0.6045837402,
-0.0983460173,
0.2195851803,
0.4975284934,
-0.6376720071,
0.6205285192,
0.0255908445,
-0.4670206308,
-0.1288720071,
-0.3069938421,
0.3536223173,
0.5920280814,
0.5475122333,
-0.4336256385,
-0.6199911237,
-0.82139045,
-0.3807846606,
-0.1539790332,
-0.184028998,
0.4623472691,
0.24339059,
0.0942994431,
1.1177176237,
-0.1692838073,
-0.1852135062,
-0.0896576419,
0.062141452,
0.1138668433,
0.6488286257,
0.2511660457,
-0.2873703539,
-0.6896317601,
0.0526201166,
-0.5404638648,
-0.1430987269,
-0.1860377938,
-0.411283195,
0.4426178038,
0.6071414948,
-0.7436086535,
0.3556646705,
-0.1673504263,
-0.5364221334,
0.9309835434,
-0.2266905308,
0.2241545916,
-1.1023151875,
0.1634347737,
-0.236178413,
-0.4111442864,
-0.6506821513,
-0.2652009428,
0.2200093716,
-0.1501020342,
-0.2623640597,
0.4187991917,
-0.7246741652,
-0.2919389307,
-0.2253636122,
0.2915067971,
0.2563474476,
0.2821251154,
0.5281505585,
1.0651391745,
0.6334421039,
-0.6532685757,
0.1894377917,
0.2737748921,
0.1255489439,
0.9839573503,
-0.6370021701,
0.2300168872,
-0.0346575119,
0.5550937057,
-0.9980962276,
-0.0405650325,
0.2138636559,
-0.4035495222,
0.4298967719,
-0.037964575,
-0.505012393,
0.07818342,
-0.3981117308,
-0.0065739756,
0.4343270361,
-0.3711820245,
0.8018913865,
-0.1504973471,
-0.1322944909,
-0.5622679591,
-0.606913805,
0.3101780117,
0.1048714593,
-0.5305822492,
0.6647686958,
0.2934139073,
0.0529301092,
-0.088899307,
-0.0496470965,
-0.1285194308,
-0.3089238107,
-0.1967945397,
0.1930928379,
-0.3138668537,
0.5013917089,
-0.1583996415,
-0.1472972035,
-0.1493935734,
-0.2948789895,
0.6431847811,
-0.0510326996,
-0.094522357,
-0.5436089039,
0.539268434,
0.2527608871,
-0.2638631463,
0.6652628779,
0.3717727065,
-0.2907125056,
-0.2255782038,
-0.4002422392,
-0.6882593632,
-0.4280459881,
0.450483501,
-0.7536036372,
-0.7146254182,
0.4647665024,
-0.3569022417,
0.0624843054,
0.4029950202,
0.3784896731,
-0.1928925663,
0.7165423632,
0.6369791031,
0.7724365592,
0.5227541924,
0.3133685291,
-0.0450063273,
-0.7953177691,
-0.6470400691,
-0.7332050204,
0.258659631,
-0.3731737137,
-0.7352921367,
0.0678193048,
0.3445960581,
-0.4882847369,
0.5179671049,
-0.5588316917,
0.6248041391,
0.2695697546,
0.1099456251,
0.3630506992,
0.2372938395,
-0.4404461086,
-0.2506195009,
-0.3642448783,
-0.6346861124,
1.0498107672,
0.1093353927,
0.7423339486,
-0.0778163671,
0.5236572623,
0.0924227685,
-0.1085683778,
-0.4655302465,
0.7382876277,
-0.0117054153,
-0.4932231009,
-0.3210033774,
-0.1822882742,
-0.7450606227,
0.4366576374,
-0.4385531843,
-0.8226604462,
0.20914644,
0.1595892757,
-0.2820883095,
-0.0593331344,
-0.5090215206,
0.7610092163,
-0.1875943989,
-1.1041153669,
-0.4281283319,
-0.8437143564,
0.1950603873,
0.0141736288,
-0.3562786579,
-0.1793179214,
-0.4095675349,
0.3269736767,
-0.9120053053,
0.543082118,
-0.1858342886,
-0.050480172,
0.2623361051,
0.0710213333,
1.0886369944,
0.0921556801,
-0.4536511004,
-0.0881114826,
-0.0116544347,
-0.2808002532,
-0.8480575085,
0.2812254131,
-0.1348800361,
-0.5851345062,
-0.5186578631,
-0.156007871,
-0.4945757091,
0.2435308546,
-0.0085340068,
0.2819758952,
-0.2710151076,
0.2324997336,
0.7545747161,
-0.2883662581,
0.1097288504,
0.9150229692,
-0.2907992303,
-0.3489537835,
0.4860537946,
-0.1697569489,
0.3804670274,
0.381113559,
0.0994304046,
-0.9246602654,
-0.2977196276,
-0.5721969604,
0.3437008262,
-0.4888179302,
-0.0796098262,
-0.5813202858,
0.1171175912,
-0.3144326508,
-0.109688513,
-0.4635960758,
-0.5512477756,
-0.3326377273,
0.1949635148,
0.6408684254,
0.5647479296,
0.1491339505,
0.2931168973,
-0.5680857897,
0.0337639824,
-0.0467088446,
0.474098146,
-0.4179986417,
-0.4054358304,
-0.0059690932,
-0.2570975721,
0.087520197,
-1.1633462906,
-0.1723022461,
0.3912873566,
0.3869479895,
0.1114875823,
0.0601221062,
0.6805807352,
-0.6437398791,
0.8599209785,
0.3191605806,
-0.8406941891,
0.8197050095,
-0.4225406349,
0.0388467722,
0.9497195482,
0.2243506312,
-0.5183594823,
-0.1402751356,
-0.5268706083,
-0.7972552776,
0.9024854898,
0.0659323633,
-0.2595070004,
0.1432525665,
0.5941152573,
0.2865816951,
0.3090713322,
-0.5228843093,
-0.0739835501,
-0.0541288555,
-0.0816492811,
0.2350532264,
-0.4099796116,
0.1115790606,
-0.2559509277,
0.5925723314,
-0.3465596437,
0.06213535,
0.2629361153,
0.2367518693,
0.1297284961,
0.3655212224,
0.3225545883,
0.6035794616,
-0.3031791747,
0.1068657339,
0.4028116465,
-0.3318119943,
0.1429418772,
0.0485402159,
-0.2295829505,
0.2044783384,
-0.1150217429,
0.5383397341,
0.1080653816,
-0.6632816792,
0.4390982091,
-0.0939277858,
0.1930928677,
0.0054652314,
-0.0403192192,
0.1134608537,
0.0008461238,
0.2750667036,
-0.1357459277,
0.2168837041,
-0.7225506902,
0.5641744137,
0.486215055,
-0.2483960539,
-0.1582825482,
0.5055187345,
0.378525883,
-0.346008569,
0.4472112358,
-0.3842015862,
-0.3098822236,
0.267786473,
0.7339330316,
0.7802776098,
-0.3737901747,
-0.0252431817,
0.6230109334,
0.0677445009,
-0.1181212142,
0.8803873062,
-0.3071331978,
-0.2989947796,
-0.3702738881,
-0.4173108339,
-0.5824434757,
-0.1551952958,
-0.4290887117,
0.7665959001,
-0.5490345955,
-0.114224501,
-0.2129889429,
0.2010769695,
-0.1732207984,
0.261051327,
-0.3560337722,
1.041723609,
-0.5779209137,
1.0625135899,
0.7711302638,
-0.4566173851,
-0.8590209484,
-0.0711893588,
-0.2046432793,
-0.5040495396,
0.320164144,
0.0995686948,
-0.0959394425,
-0.1225248128,
-0.2373360097,
-0.7509555817,
0.9585615993,
0.2951359153,
-1.0418915749,
-0.0861349106,
0.37471807,
0.6633095145,
-0.5241162777,
0.7189315557,
0.7295104265,
0.2992275059,
0.3445897102,
-0.9802032709,
0.4016819298,
-0.0145792663,
0.0753952712,
0.1795140654,
-0.5797258615,
0.708362937,
-0.3529906869,
-0.2871475816,
-0.060362909,
0.6842064261,
0.693897903,
0.155676052,
0.4653887749,
0.3231106699,
1.0520812273,
-0.2374665737,
0.7077602744,
-0.348885864,
0.1303652674,
1.4183834791,
-0.7103672028,
1.1387298107,
0.5987443924,
-0.4057052433,
0.6462650299,
0.7413432002,
0.0178312771,
0.5195649266,
0.2803228199,
-0.2321265787,
-0.4151097238,
-0.4197779596,
-0.6823014617,
0.1846940517,
0.4108401835,
-0.2904082537,
-0.4908803701,
-0.4365847409,
0.0220361836,
0.2566250265,
-0.0293362401,
0.772541225,
-0.059220843,
-0.6693791747,
0.6289811134,
-0.1452331245,
0.5619173646,
-0.7130329609,
-0.2480954677,
-0.2296813875,
0.0469712019,
-0.3120671809,
-0.8768427372,
0.4025329649,
-0.0035443134,
-0.186282903,
0.043339815,
0.863910675,
-0.7863330841,
0.0171297714,
0.0448345318,
0.1258972734,
0.4698158801,
-0.2723411024,
-0.6632992625,
0.0456283167,
-0.0473988429,
-0.1644578129,
0.1103506237,
0.6218344569,
-0.1343137175,
0.4714093804,
0.4611294866,
0.0102223307,
-0.1107315198,
0.1630397886,
0.8933728337,
-0.7657842636,
-0.6682162285,
-0.813906014,
0.4895344973,
-0.4614542127,
-0.2068217546,
0.6694325209,
0.972132206,
0.3668903112,
0.0874336585,
0.461677134,
-0.107808575,
0.6924712062,
-0.495783776,
0.3770548701,
-0.5578212142,
0.3753780723,
0.1104902998,
-0.9612146616,
-0.082940802,
0.4870618582,
-0.0533275865,
0.0876422748,
1.0184745789,
1.2118053436,
0.3177713156,
0.1073849723,
0.1366636008,
0.0680572465,
0.0783753917,
0.6194040775,
0.8663101792,
-0.4749353528,
0.4681058526,
0.1275539696,
-0.1369142383,
-0.3053124547,
-0.9125115275,
-0.776634872,
-0.4613395631,
-0.3964787722,
-0.787083149,
0.4096177518,
0.9433876872,
0.8066339493,
-0.8422335386,
-0.023709869,
-0.3923095167,
-0.2014023811,
-0.0014594434,
-0.2121804804,
0.4618622363,
-0.737482965,
-0.5295661092,
0.5089190006,
0.5536885858,
-0.1011135951,
-0.3586120009,
-0.1493441314,
-0.2430405021,
0.1901283562,
0.4516447783,
0.257003665,
-0.6929167509,
-0.0773952603,
-0.0063577392,
-0.6363930702,
0.3610732853,
0.7307524085,
-1.0405400991,
0.3804450333,
0.6739957333,
0.4049729109,
0.5884070396,
0.2725896835,
0.8210063577,
-0.88082093,
0.0375346951,
0.4170107543,
0.1414363831,
0.3816922009,
-0.6464779973,
0.676930666,
0.2674513757,
-0.3980075419,
-0.7456995249,
0.3969984949,
-0.9125435352,
-0.2622761428,
1.1912261248,
0.0295359734,
-0.3181720972,
-0.3262711763,
-0.4418305755,
0.1554481089,
-0.6086127162,
0.3762059212,
0.4609363079,
-0.2596617639,
-0.1894104779,
0.0275844671,
1.0659631491,
0.6740835905,
-1.0302460194,
0.4342075288,
0.6574754715,
0.4180811346,
-0.1014600918,
0.8645223379,
-0.3515090048,
0.3698050976,
0.166197896,
0.2017316222,
0.0239216853,
-0.263979733,
-0.3287492692,
0.0811717808,
0.0262818467,
-0.0480570123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08192v1
|
MoleculeQA: A Dataset to Evaluate Factual Accuracy in Molecular Comprehension
| 2024-03-13T02:26:16 | 2024-03-13T02:26:16 |
Xingyu Lu, He Cao, Zijing Liu, Shengyuan Bai, Leqing Chen, Yuan Yao, Hai-Tao Zheng, Yu Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.BM
|
Large language models are playing an increasingly significant role in
molecular research, yet existing models often generate erroneous information,
posing challenges to accurate molecular comprehension. Traditional evaluation
metrics for generated content fail to assess a model's accuracy in molecular
understanding. To rectify the absence of factual evaluation, we present
MoleculeQA, a novel question answering (QA) dataset which possesses 62K QA
pairs over 23K molecules. Each QA pair, composed of a manual question, a
positive option and three negative options, has consistent semantics with a
molecular description from authoritative molecular corpus. MoleculeQA is not
only the first benchmark for molecular factual bias evaluation but also the
largest QA dataset for molecular research. A comprehensive evaluation on
MoleculeQA for existing molecular LLMs exposes their deficiencies in specific
areas and pinpoints several particularly crucial factors for molecular
understanding.
|
[
-0.3018663228,
-0.8065914512,
0.7664875984,
-0.0760194883,
-0.1440274864,
0.3752334416,
0.2137720883,
-0.1177543402,
0.0141226659,
0.4059409797,
-0.5823047161,
-0.4753771722,
-0.3553080559,
0.3868964911,
-0.5367434621,
0.9105651379,
0.1646436155,
0.4692439735,
-0.7006642818,
-0.3279656768,
-0.0658299774,
-0.2600239813,
-0.3205442727,
0.051582545,
0.6116207838,
0.6050948501,
0.6929123402,
0.414481312,
0.7070321441,
0.2901623845,
-0.2805829942,
0.1144671217,
-0.7532585859,
-0.175629884,
-0.3458438516,
-0.5275349021,
-0.5132482648,
0.1514621824,
0.6676074266,
0.8435862064,
-0.0418110192,
0.3849263191,
-0.4214731157,
0.8280674815,
-0.5645624399,
-0.1807636917,
-0.7009584308,
0.0972741917,
0.0327418856,
-0.0021473833,
-0.1979313344,
-0.4257177413,
0.495531857,
-0.782350719,
0.4199303985,
0.0767250806,
0.8489753008,
0.332347393,
-0.8953383565,
-0.4609662592,
-0.3953229189,
0.4161386788,
-0.6064832211,
0.4421495497,
0.089007467,
0.4876414835,
-0.3343254626,
-0.6594682932,
-0.8730739951,
-0.4971539378,
0.2253838032,
0.2137844414,
-0.0581671633,
0.1691825688,
0.1273894608,
0.6531971693,
-0.9070900679,
-0.5059660077,
-0.6596069932,
-0.3557653129,
0.3060290217,
0.0312792957,
0.4402472377,
-0.4116584957,
-0.5363419652,
0.0105353389,
-0.6714323759,
-0.0563206822,
0.2632262111,
0.0649626553,
0.2399447858,
0.9932565689,
-0.2667876184,
0.6018446088,
0.0796434507,
0.2128065228,
0.1082662046,
-0.6313800216,
-0.4152256548,
0.292802006,
0.383400768,
0.2982133925,
0.2138605565,
-0.2324642092,
0.171484679,
-0.0299782064,
0.3739321232,
-0.8066781163,
-0.4083768129,
0.7649006844,
-0.1629476398,
-0.2497440726,
0.2585870326,
-0.9121286273,
-0.4884684682,
-0.1574296206,
0.6953412294,
-0.3462027013,
-0.0166485328,
0.16326195,
-0.6031171679,
0.0767955035,
0.1592268646,
-0.397219032,
0.1336428076,
0.5964919329,
0.7598563433,
-0.2099190503,
0.0029177095,
-0.3692728281,
-0.0128462268,
-0.4372827113,
0.7636658549,
-0.5459535122,
-0.3881719112,
-0.5083867311,
0.0447596684,
0.0594757162,
-0.8622474074,
0.3873864412,
-0.7453337312,
0.2267428488,
-0.5361828208,
-0.9437304735,
-0.4396626949,
0.1611226946,
-0.8917213678,
0.5890825391,
0.4636280239,
-0.5095486045,
0.657354176,
-0.4351657033,
0.1711981595,
0.080199115,
-0.1283749938,
-0.2942159176,
-0.1786512285,
0.1482897252,
0.1534989327,
-0.2229571193,
0.3219577074,
-0.4277692735,
-0.0847537145,
0.7655097246,
-0.4066728652,
0.8644453287,
0.0116064819,
-0.1943697184,
-0.0101767387,
-1.0562077761,
0.1345322728,
-0.2077755183,
-0.3637180626,
0.1747358441,
-0.4701029956,
-0.1985505968,
0.3186631799,
0.1799200773,
-0.6532332897,
0.1973698139,
-0.3071703017,
0.366055578,
0.6744393706,
0.3537145555,
0.3877897561,
-0.4031049311,
0.8239046335,
0.2111518979,
-0.2013774365,
0.2182722688,
-0.6274535656,
-0.8141162395,
-0.2789751589,
0.6128528118,
0.5246379375,
-0.6456246972,
0.2820335925,
-0.3245640397,
-0.5552226305,
-0.5169259906,
0.3753143549,
0.4566518068,
0.7510420084,
0.5117826462,
-0.3061020672,
-0.5151933432,
-1.0542144775,
-0.3090284765,
-0.3284582794,
-0.1436326355,
0.4223467112,
0.8005543351,
-0.1898179203,
0.8721485734,
-0.1812840253,
0.1299765706,
-0.0154422848,
-0.0399161205,
0.0355400033,
0.2722448409,
0.1378812194,
-0.8483117223,
-0.015717743,
-0.3905726969,
-0.564738512,
0.1558274031,
-0.1775553524,
-0.6481946111,
0.0148489298,
0.3078799546,
-0.7284316421,
0.2138159871,
0.4657410085,
-0.6875867844,
0.5004508495,
0.2064511329,
0.2288730294,
-0.7631120086,
0.408665359,
0.0243233312,
-0.2792165577,
-0.5425770879,
-0.0353753045,
0.0300090965,
0.1246515214,
-0.6151115298,
0.5840574503,
-0.1740907133,
-0.0245094579,
0.0085740546,
0.2706229389,
0.4265644848,
0.3070092797,
-0.1276887804,
1.0220094919,
0.1507782191,
-0.4984955192,
0.6138350368,
0.7240546942,
-0.4805816412,
0.4415361583,
-0.7627651691,
0.1253973544,
-0.0631718412,
0.4247238934,
-1.074716568,
-0.4252061546,
0.3888994455,
-0.6528728604,
-0.0350083597,
-0.2324363291,
-0.0488393866,
-0.3030588329,
-0.0874261335,
0.4200105071,
0.2251711488,
-0.4054051936,
0.3000707626,
0.3881990016,
0.0115222167,
-0.6940097213,
-0.6841159463,
-0.0057988092,
-0.1527923197,
-0.6380870342,
-0.0498348698,
-0.0684856176,
-0.3339936137,
0.1140338704,
-0.6463285685,
-0.3649284542,
-0.0852213278,
0.1259870231,
0.3059327602,
-0.4305371344,
0.2128543109,
-0.2825109959,
0.1067669019,
0.3796266317,
-0.2062538862,
0.1717676371,
-0.1865189672,
0.0516506173,
-0.20952712,
-0.0005499467,
0.5682846904,
-0.0247705169,
0.7125712633,
0.3371087313,
-0.2064311653,
-0.0682524294,
-0.1064556018,
-0.1666134,
-0.458075434,
0.4799011648,
-0.3589366078,
-0.8810926676,
0.3462237418,
0.1856038719,
-0.3514539897,
0.5313450694,
0.5428287387,
-0.2516528666,
0.5647964478,
0.1198447198,
0.2946749032,
-0.3379310369,
-0.1119799316,
0.2135394067,
-0.7397414446,
-0.514904201,
-0.3587933779,
-0.1693635732,
-0.549844563,
-0.8077796698,
0.4976602495,
0.193793118,
-0.414693296,
0.1052622274,
-0.1723346114,
0.5259603262,
0.6474041343,
0.4070648849,
0.2211403102,
-0.0439202264,
-0.0224166457,
0.491606921,
-0.8360734582,
-0.7817949057,
1.4219776392,
0.170517087,
0.2806779444,
0.4112970531,
0.1215866506,
0.3164966404,
-0.1467018574,
-0.8877572417,
0.5735937357,
0.1739330888,
-1.1940475702,
-0.4153931737,
-0.9319613576,
-0.8334155679,
-0.0944469869,
-0.3725014925,
-0.4399594367,
0.3900433481,
0.2811402678,
-0.6755443215,
0.1241523847,
-0.5635011792,
1.1571041346,
-0.0397357792,
-0.1929996014,
-0.0456272848,
-0.8249393106,
0.6713325977,
-0.1593430936,
-0.2462517768,
-0.297552228,
-0.0815825239,
0.811022222,
-0.4227059186,
0.089642182,
0.0402717851,
-0.0584745593,
0.4963623285,
0.2673572898,
-0.1037954539,
0.3346492052,
-0.080088079,
0.0412836,
0.5670545697,
-0.9045073986,
-0.8657383919,
0.3585112095,
-0.5342095494,
-0.4198480248,
-0.4240160584,
-0.2607380152,
-0.5968993902,
-0.0128891608,
0.1738458574,
0.5227395296,
-0.3341668248,
0.1514213085,
0.8369752765,
-0.3909012675,
-0.2174687684,
0.3907115757,
-0.2427906692,
-0.4151889682,
1.06072855,
-0.1767949313,
0.4331288934,
0.5005285144,
-0.0661380813,
-0.5298278332,
-0.5402516723,
-0.7055066824,
-0.053805396,
-0.9151431918,
-0.1824082285,
-0.5698245168,
-0.1739118844,
-0.2125079781,
0.2643495798,
-0.2223333269,
-0.9153072238,
-0.0407985933,
-0.3922192156,
0.4464128017,
0.7426450849,
-0.0641463324,
-0.0566378385,
-0.9896347523,
0.9417638779,
0.5750169754,
0.1430881023,
-0.3617276251,
-0.586357832,
-0.1381615847,
0.3354192972,
-0.1250546873,
-1.0561659336,
-0.0213314071,
0.4670354128,
0.4102613032,
0.2559142709,
-0.2786574364,
0.4477787912,
-0.2674301267,
0.8350358605,
-0.3899515867,
-1.114918828,
0.3573565781,
-0.2547467053,
0.2787217796,
0.8522203565,
0.6394689679,
-0.5102946758,
-0.1735442132,
-0.6688866019,
-0.754602015,
0.3831721246,
0.5310564041,
-0.345589608,
0.0712647513,
0.6357679367,
0.0735760853,
0.3739508688,
-0.3197204769,
-0.3901127279,
-0.3076087236,
-0.3379146755,
-0.1266082376,
-0.2274201363,
-0.2043156177,
-0.2864618003,
0.9024357796,
-0.0310453512,
0.3873034418,
0.4958499372,
-0.3409214318,
0.0418252274,
0.1684209704,
0.5473224521,
0.9089584351,
-0.6034367085,
0.1640524268,
0.09318766,
-0.6706241965,
0.3997836113,
-0.2293103337,
0.0538608916,
-0.1365368664,
0.3948669434,
0.4095678926,
-0.255079478,
-1.0679975748,
0.3591424525,
-0.0930793136,
-0.1381371319,
0.1720547378,
0.2498953044,
0.1550800204,
0.0171341095,
0.2325695455,
0.2257067859,
0.6320189834,
-0.7536596656,
0.6462001204,
0.2855333388,
-0.5032207966,
-0.0149685312,
0.4058906436,
0.1394773573,
0.3649966419,
0.8185629249,
-0.2477640212,
-0.713016212,
1.0823789835,
-0.0761393756,
0.5283061862,
-0.0569343008,
0.6080312729,
0.4825759232,
0.3808947504,
0.486962527,
0.528455615,
0.1924737543,
-0.8314808607,
-0.1662360132,
-0.6559506059,
-0.6186290383,
0.1668561101,
-0.5706838369,
-0.0875569582,
-0.4716718197,
0.1449720711,
0.2971771359,
0.1600262523,
-0.3706102073,
0.6421211958,
0.0979487821,
1.1130344868,
-0.5397934318,
0.5797886848,
0.5685847402,
-0.397716105,
-0.6619861126,
-0.1423014104,
0.2379428744,
-0.710480392,
0.554784894,
0.1676364243,
-0.061585214,
-0.0445390344,
-0.5890299082,
-0.8591307998,
0.7626847625,
0.3566426933,
-0.6160211563,
0.2073333859,
0.5577636361,
0.5369336009,
-0.0281016827,
0.3258611858,
1.0208687782,
0.6584216356,
0.1755552143,
-0.5587499142,
0.1773423702,
-0.5027140379,
-0.3066197932,
-0.1395172179,
-0.569118917,
0.3878984749,
-0.1611454487,
-0.2687578499,
0.2987384796,
0.6222795248,
0.4087047279,
0.4353211522,
0.3084526956,
0.5600600839,
1.0828968287,
-0.1869576573,
0.8616966605,
-0.2604257464,
0.1364457309,
1.0711256266,
-0.0153304907,
0.6356514692,
0.4438482225,
-0.4158206582,
0.2771620154,
0.9413009882,
-0.0767382756,
0.2020228356,
0.6955194473,
-0.4396855831,
-0.5098212361,
0.1147125289,
-0.2495943904,
0.6164842248,
0.4395726919,
-0.0206598938,
0.0370959118,
-0.2023414075,
-0.3295250833,
0.0055381958,
-0.3003462851,
0.7207722068,
-0.0145577956,
-0.3905214667,
0.508726716,
-0.1033485606,
0.1045675054,
-0.2443751544,
-0.2267855108,
-0.3118987381,
-0.2015914768,
-0.2144730687,
-0.8297835588,
0.1900252551,
-0.0299644731,
-0.1914406568,
0.5117777586,
0.268922776,
-0.5593186021,
-0.6299905181,
-0.1604293883,
0.5299426317,
0.2868057489,
-0.2466815412,
-0.8479341269,
-0.3691760898,
0.0277236495,
-0.1577361226,
-0.2787354589,
0.535759151,
0.4188401103,
0.8932648301,
0.4846846461,
-0.207280308,
0.3350588083,
-0.4279832244,
0.653832674,
-0.9403085709,
0.0819352865,
-0.5986798406,
0.351703316,
0.0591814965,
-0.5343811512,
0.8319500089,
0.8817647696,
0.7505136132,
-0.0618351363,
0.8198391795,
0.1831624806,
0.6217653751,
-0.916369915,
0.5896757245,
-0.4661482275,
0.1913044304,
0.0989573747,
-0.9468276501,
-0.0670415461,
0.3626323342,
-0.0228818152,
0.3286776245,
0.7958993912,
0.97412467,
-0.1470833272,
0.2888566256,
0.2327059507,
0.6524754167,
0.1093806848,
0.7100031972,
1.1394580603,
-0.623034358,
0.3866257071,
-0.212714538,
0.1432427615,
-0.1686998159,
-0.6392176747,
-0.9379184842,
-0.5637199283,
-0.2507459819,
-0.7631475329,
0.2904846072,
0.9926981926,
0.6832072735,
-1.1571284533,
-0.0806875452,
-0.4012843668,
0.1320684254,
0.3307819664,
-0.2795764506,
0.3374976516,
-0.0460683145,
-0.6584350467,
0.7101106644,
0.201836437,
0.1797939092,
-0.3844363093,
0.0730121508,
-0.2756215036,
0.4116777778,
0.3753085136,
0.3758300245,
-0.4712745249,
0.0108237518,
0.092184253,
-0.2355877012,
0.3153615296,
0.5785142779,
-0.809769094,
0.5296913385,
0.4349696338,
0.7913621664,
0.1710782945,
0.2430574149,
0.8571614027,
-0.4157049656,
-0.2571774423,
0.4472773671,
0.0653480068,
0.4233113825,
-0.4915364981,
0.4122281075,
0.271993041,
-0.6627269387,
-0.5575498343,
0.0770691335,
-1.4185433388,
-0.5411277413,
1.0856055021,
0.0354712531,
-0.4249687493,
-0.2549754977,
-0.2251513451,
0.1572619528,
-0.4699491262,
0.7213249803,
0.9113429189,
0.0724288151,
0.0261115115,
-0.5173255205,
0.7944664359,
0.7632384896,
-0.8612323403,
-0.1000924855,
0.7451084256,
0.1248372346,
-0.1327358335,
0.247201696,
0.1106022075,
0.6716920733,
0.1080153212,
-0.1791827828,
0.1649724543,
-0.6972939372,
-0.408254981,
0.0408186316,
-0.0987347066,
0.0483015738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08189v1
|
Embedded Translations for Low-resource Automated Glossing
| 2024-03-13T02:23:13 | 2024-03-13T02:23:13 |
Changbing Yang, Garrett Nicolai, Miikka Silfverberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate automatic interlinear glossing in low-resource settings. We
augment a hard-attentional neural model with embedded translation information
extracted from interlinear glossed text. After encoding these translations
using large language models, specifically BERT and T5, we introduce a
character-level decoder for generating glossed output. Aided by these
enhancements, our model demonstrates an average improvement of 3.97\%-points
over the previous state of the art on datasets from the SIGMORPHON 2023 Shared
Task on Interlinear Glossing. In a simulated ultra low-resource setting,
trained on as few as 100 sentences, our system achieves an average 9.78\%-point
improvement over the plain hard-attentional baseline. These results highlight
the critical role of translation information in boosting the system's
performance, especially in processing and interpreting modest data sources. Our
findings suggest a promising avenue for the documentation and preservation of
languages, with our experiments on shared task datasets indicating significant
advancements over the existing state of the art.
|
[
-0.3817275167,
-0.4910133779,
0.598541379,
0.4163662195,
-0.3263361752,
0.0864526704,
-0.5989657044,
-0.7129414678,
0.3993892372,
0.4539710879,
-0.2605903149,
-0.3514425159,
-0.7763743997,
-0.0387115069,
-0.5082423091,
0.9835335016,
-0.0183114037,
0.0202304162,
-0.1845452785,
-0.0777319893,
-0.0294643287,
-0.51854527,
-0.5502508283,
-0.1330899894,
0.5657944083,
0.4808633924,
0.986156106,
0.6852706075,
0.5986610651,
0.1708197296,
-0.0682193339,
0.2960213125,
-0.4022415578,
-0.0176558644,
-0.1907573044,
-0.2915571332,
-0.8014063239,
-0.0932152793,
0.5272771716,
0.7469486594,
0.0941115022,
0.1403958648,
0.3371137083,
0.3767262101,
-0.6870532036,
0.4205940068,
-0.6068168283,
-0.1092042103,
-0.3235711753,
-0.1532764584,
-0.3228305578,
-0.2594675124,
0.1457692236,
-0.722458601,
0.1644105613,
-0.0862174854,
0.9383408427,
0.6439297199,
0.0111776106,
-0.4761831462,
-0.7661170959,
0.6739777923,
-0.8816376925,
0.1226029247,
0.5818997622,
0.062241897,
0.2154730111,
-0.7962590456,
-0.4658447206,
-0.2519876659,
-0.279317379,
0.3542681336,
-0.157345593,
0.3362852037,
0.1483478993,
0.5358784199,
-0.0509413742,
0.2065655738,
-0.3534400463,
0.0688469186,
0.554867208,
0.07984896,
0.3045797944,
-0.1113383546,
-0.0247260556,
-0.1609927565,
-0.4897537827,
-0.2844109833,
-0.0333555825,
0.5452955961,
-0.132113561,
0.5497050285,
-0.1943282783,
0.3239575624,
0.1402058452,
0.0734549537,
0.1233955026,
-0.5156985521,
-0.0207829773,
0.0882888064,
0.7940804958,
0.2859217525,
0.3377394974,
-0.4273337126,
-0.5883901119,
-0.2497663945,
0.2979591787,
-0.633336544,
-0.1466573775,
0.0254904311,
-0.2609356642,
0.0946960449,
-0.2114399076,
-0.4299503863,
-0.2926283777,
-0.2877159417,
0.3536976278,
-0.6277263761,
0.1339449286,
-0.1979614049,
0.2149345279,
0.0365688764,
0.5251561403,
-1.245367527,
0.5070726275,
0.526604712,
1.1182187796,
-0.1971521974,
-0.0271745101,
-0.6105595827,
0.2579550445,
-0.3127371073,
0.6705209017,
-0.2862995863,
-0.2223679423,
0.0229380168,
0.0226895455,
-0.0420473218,
-0.6875684261,
0.4378373623,
-0.5856181383,
-0.0597321913,
-0.0667976514,
-0.4541259706,
-0.0154890353,
-0.1102662086,
-0.7098807096,
1.0457248688,
0.122510165,
-0.2854930162,
0.270365417,
-0.9056155682,
-0.4780753851,
0.3570018709,
0.0486108139,
-0.1624715775,
0.390437007,
0.3879671395,
0.3513742387,
-0.3420704603,
0.1081987321,
-0.1704116464,
-0.4692213535,
0.0548824668,
-0.3475824296,
0.3863133192,
0.2803459167,
-0.4320346713,
0.1134381965,
-0.3382527828,
0.2103103101,
-0.1645568311,
-0.5600520968,
-0.4890447259,
-0.1270966083,
0.3880844712,
0.1451093405,
0.8506222963,
-0.4797771573,
0.1915986985,
-0.5542638302,
0.1587357074,
0.6547243595,
-0.2791503966,
0.6587513089,
-0.047410585,
0.5201793313,
0.0137772765,
0.2736413181,
0.1301164776,
-0.4257741868,
-1.0612059832,
-0.1460017562,
0.6285223961,
0.618712604,
-0.9490877986,
0.3666996062,
-0.45594576,
-0.1264291406,
-0.968421936,
0.2128060013,
0.5693627,
0.1654348224,
0.6444715261,
-0.2371260971,
-0.0780857131,
-1.1991649866,
0.0838712007,
0.1938615888,
-0.1497959942,
0.5107412338,
0.1750968844,
-0.2789131999,
0.7121046185,
-0.3093844652,
-0.31180197,
-0.1811074615,
0.3141349256,
0.1493207067,
0.5764065385,
0.4270785749,
-0.6822004318,
-0.9052314162,
0.1450856924,
-0.7977589965,
-0.2794217467,
-0.0097103538,
-0.1186486632,
0.3395884037,
0.6609999537,
-0.0958716571,
0.276771158,
0.7255267501,
-0.1192341596,
-0.0714045539,
-0.6131544709,
0.0098422477,
-1.0324773788,
0.2181221098,
-0.1088617891,
-0.3224821389,
-0.513406992,
-0.0193571299,
0.0771431178,
0.0100818714,
-0.279841572,
0.5518666506,
-0.6733759046,
-0.5091004372,
-0.5153244138,
0.2721715271,
-0.261243403,
0.5605433583,
0.0021657448,
1.2661972046,
0.2210705578,
-0.5266425014,
0.1429660469,
0.3619436324,
-0.4130941033,
0.2962945104,
-0.6452565193,
0.1472088397,
-0.0268128198,
-0.0728562847,
-0.6675222516,
-0.4739603996,
0.1383174509,
-0.1841953993,
0.2471408844,
-0.0611563213,
-0.7869052291,
0.0248394385,
-0.0122193778,
0.1761531234,
0.5522645712,
-0.4962793589,
0.3268490732,
0.6971485019,
-0.4184525907,
-0.3903287351,
-0.8135957122,
0.4245651662,
0.0339516774,
-0.5009903312,
0.6784502864,
-0.0517742001,
-0.2634449601,
0.15133439,
0.0591998398,
-0.2697904408,
0.3022303581,
0.1882927269,
0.0350451842,
-0.3067853749,
0.3774439394,
0.2051989585,
-0.0359022506,
-0.2868649364,
-0.3937197924,
0.4514136016,
-0.4764073491,
-0.0496341586,
-0.434396714,
0.5166019201,
0.6431218982,
-0.1021518409,
0.8674502373,
0.5795186162,
-0.4272761345,
0.0161955804,
-0.2485878468,
-0.1747068912,
-0.4689987302,
0.1682644486,
-0.4043688774,
-0.6656850576,
0.5579961538,
-0.0880262107,
0.029037796,
0.3997805417,
0.2564501464,
-0.4029311538,
1.1293047667,
0.9449785352,
0.2350924611,
0.833306849,
-0.2398758978,
-0.0673001185,
-0.9879664183,
0.0518430844,
0.0796733126,
-0.4866838157,
-0.5796589851,
-0.6448562145,
0.736010313,
0.2594860196,
0.1993898302,
0.3825368583,
-0.4680588841,
0.493611306,
0.8574430346,
0.3211440742,
0.2476929128,
-0.1414479166,
0.1276948601,
-0.079375051,
-0.7474839091,
-0.712903738,
0.8772132397,
0.1184755787,
0.8031945229,
0.125460878,
0.6851842999,
0.5341180563,
0.3481030464,
-1.0035136938,
0.5083870888,
-0.7328138351,
-0.3256121278,
-0.41071105,
-0.131089434,
-0.7505335808,
0.0669435188,
-0.2200663686,
-0.5211185813,
0.2969022691,
0.3716978431,
-0.5159321427,
-0.0974486694,
-0.8343074918,
0.7402508259,
-0.4162651896,
-0.4374774396,
-0.2889363766,
-0.6639302969,
0.138906166,
-0.2458766401,
-0.0870273411,
-0.0640491918,
-0.2918355465,
0.7303054333,
-0.400793016,
0.7556904554,
-0.1587875485,
-0.2789717317,
-0.030858703,
-0.1882759929,
0.5273012519,
-0.1093431488,
-0.1551163942,
0.2298919559,
-0.1285540462,
-0.5475441217,
-0.5144227743,
0.6714719534,
-0.7448070645,
-0.5324494839,
-0.3292514086,
-0.874851048,
-0.3093207479,
0.1684261858,
0.1360249668,
0.2644037902,
-0.1053515747,
0.2177258879,
0.7660599351,
-0.177555725,
0.5355961919,
0.3979094326,
0.0616863668,
-0.4050243199,
0.8243924975,
0.2334150523,
0.574368,
0.4032020569,
-0.1019580662,
-0.0996485502,
-0.7291365266,
-0.6041887403,
0.3461534679,
-0.7930790186,
-0.0313332491,
-0.8152458072,
-0.2064021528,
-0.3355362117,
-0.246896103,
-0.4878871441,
-0.6619708538,
-0.4472339153,
0.1893437058,
0.3633483052,
0.966447413,
-0.3199904561,
0.7451028824,
-0.8745368719,
0.2752160728,
0.1426851749,
0.1776339859,
-0.1461305171,
-0.4258991182,
-0.9193076491,
0.0602342747,
0.1587242633,
-0.4663436711,
0.6042680144,
0.3682011366,
0.4837532043,
0.1622792929,
0.1273091733,
0.6876237392,
-0.5558612943,
0.6286919713,
-0.2128016055,
-1.1683598757,
0.4297763109,
-0.295112133,
0.6927953362,
0.8066887856,
0.2359057367,
-0.5898953676,
-0.6258552074,
-0.457018286,
-1.0968363285,
1.1357152462,
0.0566393659,
0.1288608015,
0.0327335857,
0.3186602294,
-0.0180631764,
0.1837883592,
-0.6343175173,
-0.050767716,
-0.0342274718,
-0.4497720003,
-0.135277465,
-0.2216974497,
-0.181012243,
-0.096035555,
0.8277057409,
-0.4441603422,
0.306111306,
0.0054270979,
-0.4910373092,
0.0539968126,
0.183154121,
0.5713199973,
0.3854712248,
-0.4017443061,
0.3341350853,
0.2044447809,
-0.518963933,
-0.1978336871,
0.3864644468,
-0.2462990731,
-0.0845198557,
0.1523148715,
0.8178858161,
0.3831236362,
-0.5789386034,
0.4227671623,
-0.0572125167,
0.2953938842,
-0.2680414319,
-0.1189250425,
0.1280008852,
0.2337017059,
0.2859047949,
0.1324088573,
0.1445104331,
-0.4827699363,
0.2670522928,
0.2820329368,
-0.5700334311,
-0.4142777026,
0.7046448588,
0.4521824121,
0.041918505,
0.5012925863,
-0.1813274324,
-0.3297861218,
0.4129710197,
0.3811832368,
0.8698819876,
-0.0129198031,
0.0248996876,
0.2291154861,
0.3784241378,
0.0938727707,
0.1280316114,
-0.3371077776,
-0.3932753503,
-0.3056774139,
-0.7673230171,
-0.559689045,
0.1551677138,
-0.5937843919,
0.0925595164,
-0.373100996,
-0.078897424,
0.0148602473,
-0.2629454434,
-0.3867801428,
0.0946778506,
0.556778729,
0.6663573384,
-0.6362691522,
0.9728737473,
0.5493184924,
-0.6727784872,
-0.2780924439,
0.5795564055,
-0.4990016818,
-0.8420452476,
0.9414845705,
-0.0324153341,
-0.3471057415,
0.1092688665,
-0.5535924435,
-1.3048324585,
0.9998391271,
0.4164734781,
-0.4309728444,
-0.2834977806,
0.1673092395,
0.6811036468,
-0.2755950391,
0.1478274763,
0.5013729334,
0.4291006327,
-0.2299864292,
-1.3335659504,
0.1101676971,
-0.3134436011,
0.1609988958,
0.1681440473,
-0.5470722914,
1.0483082533,
-0.0254114792,
-0.6424073577,
0.1083616987,
0.7045075297,
-0.4179053605,
-0.0237157922,
0.4326966405,
0.2646404505,
0.7090289593,
-0.0526724234,
1.2093094587,
-0.7753933668,
0.1343648881,
1.3347457647,
-0.089927651,
0.8014041781,
0.5631706119,
0.2359041423,
0.3296117187,
0.4893865883,
0.2734125555,
0.8061708212,
-0.0630850494,
-0.5497331619,
-0.2946993411,
-0.5174199343,
-0.0951069668,
0.4234249294,
0.7633747458,
-0.5644835234,
-0.1983940005,
0.2530488372,
-0.0535607636,
0.0509004556,
-0.343493104,
1.0281985998,
0.0833896846,
-0.7531281114,
0.850975275,
-0.042788323,
0.9252230525,
-0.5084576607,
-0.1319398731,
-0.2613732219,
0.4097208679,
-0.1408831775,
-0.8618513942,
0.3568765521,
0.1635155976,
-0.252517432,
-0.5863768458,
0.4788640738,
-0.6558837891,
-0.15092659,
0.4658712149,
0.5266798735,
0.328543067,
0.0069405069,
-0.6377813816,
-0.2128221989,
-0.1125545576,
0.0580471866,
0.2052011043,
0.3288449049,
-0.193817243,
0.3289759457,
0.3487170935,
0.1189813763,
0.3496191502,
0.0657685399,
0.9006747603,
-0.634322226,
-0.4543385506,
-0.401111722,
0.2534107268,
-0.2599217594,
-0.1136195883,
0.713252008,
0.5831615925,
0.7222344875,
-0.1670698225,
0.9507524967,
-0.0994789228,
0.3024570942,
-0.668266952,
0.8543706536,
-0.5846529007,
0.1487698406,
0.1157958582,
-0.7760011554,
-0.1738725752,
0.3810108304,
-0.433978498,
-0.4322136939,
0.6399385333,
0.5650743246,
-0.4404779673,
-0.3853075206,
0.3815602362,
0.1749568731,
0.1782210767,
0.5042359829,
0.7028733492,
-0.5629697442,
0.6395933628,
-0.4478808045,
-0.253978163,
-0.453489393,
-0.546141386,
-0.5501989126,
-0.6792879701,
-0.1526963115,
-0.219600305,
0.2109228671,
0.9718180895,
0.6988253593,
-0.9840406179,
-0.2898765802,
-0.1766802073,
-0.2322597206,
-0.1221090555,
-0.2416581213,
0.2064502835,
-0.6282684803,
-1.2673381567,
0.7317274809,
0.3375577033,
0.2883611917,
-0.2657681108,
-0.0002373896,
-0.3243315518,
0.2640790045,
0.62834692,
0.2343451828,
-0.8029154539,
-0.302908808,
-0.0644780025,
-0.5562558174,
0.2625039518,
0.4649393559,
-0.6973713636,
0.418120265,
0.3964334428,
0.630189538,
0.7544214129,
0.0313466266,
0.746676147,
-0.9162406921,
0.2297931314,
0.5344339609,
0.3636561036,
0.5639677644,
-0.461055547,
0.658156693,
-0.0685038418,
-0.4195950031,
-0.6455834508,
0.0559424125,
-1.0919708014,
-0.0953115076,
1.0264815092,
-0.3698723912,
-0.3471941948,
0.0095492871,
0.0445940942,
0.3594867587,
-0.5568399429,
0.8227325678,
0.6176396012,
-0.256313622,
0.0351799168,
-0.5964378119,
0.6888104081,
0.4427797496,
-1.1099529266,
0.2029266208,
0.5420703292,
-0.0453354716,
0.533084929,
0.6215211749,
0.0141565241,
0.2548316419,
-0.0114996489,
0.3340395689,
0.2220094204,
-0.2344378531,
-0.3981261253,
-0.1214912087,
-0.0094454605,
-0.1881486028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08187v1
|
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) for the Diagnosis of pronunciation of Speech Sound Disorders in Korean children
| 2024-03-13T02:20:05 | 2024-03-13T02:20:05 |
Taekyung Ahn, Yeonjung Hong, Younggon Im, Do Hyung Kim, Dayoung Kang, Joo Won Jeong, Jae Won Kim, Min Jung Kim, Ah-ra Cho, Dae-Hyun Jang, Hosung Nam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7
|
This study presents a model of automatic speech recognition (ASR) designed to
diagnose pronunciation issues in children with speech sound disorders (SSDs) to
replace manual transcriptions in clinical procedures. Since ASR models trained
for general purposes primarily predict input speech into real words, employing
a well-known high-performance ASR model for evaluating pronunciation in
children with SSDs is impractical. We fine-tuned the wav2vec 2.0 XLS-R model to
recognize speech as pronounced rather than as existing words. The model was
fine-tuned with a speech dataset from 137 children with inadequate speech
production pronouncing 73 Korean words selected for actual clinical diagnosis.
The model's predictions of the pronunciations of the words matched the human
annotations with about 90% accuracy. While the model still requires improvement
in recognizing unclear pronunciation, this study demonstrates that ASR models
can streamline complex pronunciation error diagnostic procedures in clinical
fields.
|
[
0.0770209581,
-0.2721503973,
0.2133480757,
0.0569825582,
-0.2682414949,
0.1190012544,
-0.1040065289,
-0.5104701519,
-0.0729764998,
0.5083475113,
-0.33514902,
-0.3504238427,
-0.7184525132,
0.1105835661,
-0.3836283088,
0.4771116376,
-0.0898611471,
0.6578096747,
0.1641224027,
-0.0148974694,
-0.4460375011,
-0.258967638,
-1.2333635092,
-0.4097117484,
0.1129064187,
0.55422616,
0.7127436996,
1.1472723484,
0.5780925751,
0.3566842079,
-0.2853006721,
-0.0670791715,
-0.2072001249,
0.263431251,
0.0874180719,
0.0400097407,
-0.5643571615,
-0.0945215151,
0.5399031043,
0.9364007115,
-0.2447062284,
-0.0339446962,
0.0506176203,
0.5501952171,
-0.0762318969,
-0.0076505537,
-0.221720174,
0.3030949831,
-0.0661257878,
0.0233544335,
-0.0311734062,
-0.2659528553,
0.348334372,
-0.5764659643,
0.5402888656,
-0.2879507244,
0.6147934794,
0.5098215342,
-0.4008103013,
-0.7280355096,
-1.0899074078,
0.4043856561,
-0.5299457312,
0.6819405556,
0.5576971173,
0.4852593839,
-0.0322107412,
-0.522582531,
-0.4917010069,
-0.2085157931,
0.14996925,
0.1405982971,
-0.1979470551,
0.3539249301,
0.3812243342,
0.1177862361,
-0.9717698097,
0.2466106713,
-0.739292562,
-0.409830302,
0.7131766677,
0.1936671883,
0.6128258705,
-0.31935063,
-0.1016747728,
-0.0808965042,
-0.2840676606,
0.3203033209,
0.2355152965,
0.7656449676,
-0.0188822411,
0.3961354196,
-0.3871713281,
0.5376065373,
0.2400141507,
-0.4284757078,
0.3448374867,
-0.0782654509,
-0.1548304409,
0.6354926825,
0.556578517,
0.1111199036,
0.2369900346,
-0.0477973334,
-0.3968250453,
0.3832966685,
0.2206926942,
-0.5007913709,
-0.6269900203,
0.1562719643,
-0.7208355665,
-0.2069467604,
-0.009866111,
-0.445535928,
-0.3995049894,
-0.6873627305,
0.795250535,
-0.3323706985,
-0.4270347357,
0.0865131468,
-0.3620240092,
-0.3217442036,
-0.1425212175,
-0.6052784324,
0.5519108176,
0.1731662899,
0.400126785,
-0.0165759921,
0.1061785147,
-0.4614038765,
-0.0258547068,
-0.3941931427,
0.8729425669,
-0.5717970133,
-0.9264214039,
-0.1243613809,
0.1605076045,
-0.3450343609,
-0.9977737665,
0.6526042819,
-0.0842684209,
-0.4124323428,
-0.2210890651,
-0.626870513,
0.0075982832,
-0.5246638656,
-0.4870467782,
0.6916683316,
0.3035672307,
-0.1130650342,
0.6265585423,
-0.5279074311,
-0.5604429245,
0.2499923557,
0.0358821079,
-0.3248718977,
0.0029664959,
0.0044018142,
0.2460027784,
0.0208140817,
0.0989829674,
0.1625243723,
-0.3278132975,
0.0665147677,
-0.4547996819,
0.532874167,
0.5037585497,
0.0179106519,
0.0693867058,
-1.1237714291,
0.5199046731,
-0.097540088,
-0.4831872284,
-0.1908313781,
-0.0916453004,
0.0852858871,
0.2687820494,
0.0843284577,
-0.4684481025,
-0.1294927597,
-0.5848090053,
0.3157593906,
-0.0073358216,
0.048203703,
0.1839422584,
-0.3106245995,
0.6303070784,
0.1514468193,
0.1520963758,
0.0235284846,
-0.4277684689,
-0.6647168994,
-0.4550697505,
0.4602658153,
0.7226760387,
-0.5065531135,
0.4176474512,
-0.068465203,
-0.4382089674,
-0.9659562707,
-0.1213301867,
0.7742460966,
0.7590554357,
0.3779570758,
-0.1667082608,
-1.0247405767,
-0.7053781748,
-0.2234333605,
-0.1854049861,
-0.1907436252,
0.4307021797,
0.1527823806,
-0.4552664459,
0.4720221162,
-0.0147467609,
-0.5001752377,
-0.0056706551,
0.1620337516,
-0.1121226847,
0.4654556513,
-0.0974072292,
-0.6766991615,
-0.6765756011,
0.1253262758,
-0.536241889,
-0.3598114848,
0.5841530561,
0.6016606092,
0.196016565,
0.7817252278,
-0.4063370228,
0.579194963,
0.3955649734,
-0.5473683476,
0.5441253781,
-0.3853490055,
0.2251323313,
-0.476688832,
-0.0914085954,
-0.1498257816,
-0.2760249376,
-0.8189408183,
-0.3665445745,
0.0556357354,
-0.342187494,
-0.1556617171,
0.2849187553,
-0.3285205364,
-0.0455746539,
-0.4702307284,
0.1786718667,
0.0014667467,
-0.3624823987,
0.0691783205,
0.6624520421,
0.7042283416,
-0.8260556459,
0.5437355638,
0.1265951693,
-0.0985609889,
0.6157740355,
-0.8165488839,
0.0434198231,
0.0441510826,
0.0593897589,
-1.0476257801,
-0.4156967402,
0.1494951248,
-0.8438870907,
0.7234150171,
-0.2431532741,
-0.0849367008,
-0.8115063906,
0.3751107752,
0.3237128556,
0.4993352592,
-0.6010434628,
0.4339594245,
0.6714672446,
-0.4432553947,
-0.1667956859,
-0.369236201,
-0.1220938563,
-0.1607290208,
-0.5114471316,
0.3752219677,
0.1438582093,
-0.1976837218,
0.0820925012,
-0.2112805396,
-0.5298150778,
-0.2243417203,
0.2363249809,
0.0979796126,
-0.5927290916,
0.2115579844,
0.0994920433,
-0.4312362969,
-0.2658821642,
0.0592445284,
0.3594129682,
0.0776766986,
-0.1311399043,
-0.7938162684,
0.1551149637,
0.4566103816,
0.2604557872,
-0.0448174216,
0.4466533661,
-0.8489025235,
-0.1036188155,
-0.5604239702,
-0.0348029882,
-0.4988740385,
0.3593598008,
-0.6278984547,
-0.3004286587,
0.6625243425,
-0.0656547546,
-0.7479708195,
0.4430306256,
0.1949587315,
-0.403796643,
1.4231811762,
0.3147982955,
0.1437955946,
-0.0717529282,
-0.0036585985,
0.2303310335,
-0.9160370827,
-0.1778361052,
-0.6795226932,
-0.0473058596,
-0.5187650919,
-0.2247036994,
0.2883681655,
0.1779960841,
-0.1293248683,
0.0820130929,
-0.835136354,
0.5046389103,
0.3294570446,
0.0227444079,
0.1543198824,
-0.2763094902,
-0.1711470336,
-0.4289492667,
-0.5789955854,
-0.6805659533,
0.9542376995,
0.267896533,
0.3645111918,
-0.1005951986,
0.3977855146,
0.4124502242,
-0.1436356008,
-1.1301621199,
0.2276527286,
-0.8122968674,
-0.2926015854,
-0.6076218486,
-0.2467246652,
-0.992696166,
0.0764740705,
0.1211469099,
-0.6307656169,
0.3984382153,
0.230185464,
-0.8778591156,
-0.1094712541,
-0.6090813279,
0.761577189,
-0.1690314114,
0.4009878039,
-0.1299034953,
-0.5862661004,
0.2104238123,
0.0114380373,
0.1078782976,
0.0787595063,
0.2120130658,
0.9261551499,
-0.5292093158,
0.373355031,
-0.645739913,
0.1782042384,
0.1182047278,
-0.1273331195,
0.3388910294,
-0.3247027099,
-0.0477770083,
-0.0203396622,
0.1241263747,
0.1593350321,
-0.4681650698,
0.5551252365,
-0.8733960986,
-0.0976435468,
-0.4328277111,
-0.2407047302,
-0.4046345651,
0.0323552974,
0.4289879799,
0.6687782407,
-0.208549723,
-0.0564352609,
0.7728870511,
-0.1674160808,
0.13425982,
0.7382262349,
0.0886466727,
-0.4270605743,
1.0921651125,
0.6649340391,
0.0729584545,
-0.3540032804,
0.2464055419,
-0.4386155307,
-0.6137499213,
-0.4734531045,
0.1835155189,
-0.6002629995,
-0.0266168416,
-0.6247546077,
-0.7970102429,
-0.6288838983,
-0.0982935727,
-0.5690735579,
-0.4506081641,
-0.5417745709,
-0.0650103614,
0.3187215328,
0.9902654886,
-0.4381576777,
0.3253823817,
-0.5901771188,
0.9286994338,
0.1893298328,
0.3663252592,
0.0130848084,
-1.1486028433,
-0.0570818186,
0.2379315346,
-0.2408359498,
-0.5029430389,
0.8292046189,
0.4080206454,
0.2499711365,
0.5869464278,
0.1471758932,
1.2492182255,
-0.7031548023,
0.6843633652,
0.059332978,
-0.9116333127,
0.6437789798,
-0.2222596854,
0.0609906167,
0.273951441,
0.262965858,
-0.7620270252,
-0.2516463399,
-0.7309706807,
-0.8993242383,
0.8270721436,
-0.1969019026,
-0.3036733568,
0.1288138926,
0.3287038505,
0.1723539978,
-0.1037351266,
0.1673347354,
-0.2952868342,
-0.1760273725,
-0.4915733933,
-0.0769776776,
-0.480573684,
-0.0149196219,
-0.6716482043,
0.7850930691,
0.2385416478,
0.3414215147,
0.3885871768,
-0.0148651898,
-0.6296895146,
-0.0475331843,
0.4537101686,
0.3794780076,
0.1045816839,
-0.0697446838,
0.0645658076,
-0.7731159329,
0.2560734451,
0.455663383,
-0.0552994721,
0.3096143007,
-0.1082386672,
0.9291434288,
0.2747802734,
-0.6742989421,
0.5270151496,
-0.2434848845,
-0.3979394138,
-0.6390231848,
0.2531397939,
0.1013254598,
0.4724495709,
0.3650485873,
0.1770759374,
0.4313423932,
-0.2675007582,
0.3678153157,
0.3660921454,
-0.7577244043,
-0.360222578,
0.762064755,
0.1337711662,
-0.8317402601,
0.8011783957,
-0.2390464395,
-0.6343639493,
0.8529402614,
0.698895812,
0.6904013753,
-0.7406514287,
0.1944244355,
0.3447805941,
0.0121430028,
-0.4708012044,
0.5318660736,
0.1500405222,
-0.7315986156,
0.1052013487,
-0.4270728827,
-0.2158055454,
0.5234178901,
-1.015332818,
0.4914880693,
-0.2522709668,
-0.3747254014,
0.3012928069,
0.0788298994,
-0.457403779,
0.7319391966,
0.3458096385,
0.1687324643,
-0.692003727,
0.7649930716,
0.6125526428,
-0.159209609,
-0.881957531,
0.064492777,
0.1535906792,
-0.6120244861,
0.761248827,
0.0450578034,
-0.1837700456,
0.3575500548,
-0.1828238219,
-1.1682447195,
0.8274639845,
-0.0011726014,
-0.6372807622,
0.3159885108,
0.1946262121,
0.7637594342,
-0.2564334869,
0.0680839345,
0.8029152155,
0.4194972515,
0.1056886464,
-1.6165089607,
-0.2290941477,
-0.243106693,
0.0686203465,
-0.0657741278,
-0.1842600256,
0.5563628078,
-0.4676153064,
-0.4921012223,
0.223562479,
0.3625976443,
0.3998998106,
0.7515599728,
0.4022546113,
0.4169516563,
1.1340857744,
0.0455337875,
0.7410857677,
-0.3854293525,
-0.1163778454,
0.7267948389,
-0.2181975991,
0.8702425361,
-0.0011471998,
-0.1994524598,
-0.2362757772,
0.6014524698,
0.2131645381,
0.5518328547,
0.139412865,
-0.2868175209,
-0.0255137458,
-0.2165440917,
-0.2968885601,
0.5858588815,
0.8647560477,
-0.3424962163,
0.3718910515,
0.2585067451,
-0.081088379,
0.252068907,
-0.48552531,
0.9521881342,
0.1515135616,
-0.3047875762,
0.8221141696,
-0.0973735824,
0.4832149148,
-0.3568806946,
0.0321210586,
0.3394051492,
0.3089165986,
-0.2449782938,
-0.3277424574,
0.4722224176,
-0.0276257657,
-0.5933107734,
0.0037102995,
0.8220240474,
-0.6514752507,
-0.5927115083,
0.1978538632,
0.247887969,
0.4659825265,
0.1674886346,
-0.5245355368,
0.1408863664,
-0.1969704628,
0.1102893203,
0.1213048622,
0.5359507799,
-0.0294958893,
0.6682415605,
0.4904535711,
0.5620974302,
0.1066652462,
0.4495282173,
0.2851528227,
-0.4994911849,
-0.3562603295,
-0.4275535643,
0.4333805442,
0.1635827124,
-0.3525669575,
0.2658570707,
0.4147294164,
0.5917726755,
-0.1645751297,
0.9191387892,
0.2693549991,
1.3539150953,
-0.2880990505,
1.0518317223,
-0.4942143857,
-0.0155974505,
-0.199411884,
-0.2522619069,
-0.4054326117,
1.0518680811,
-0.0423270389,
0.1175242588,
0.6360344291,
0.8622818589,
-0.0497356132,
0.2564892471,
0.5100423098,
0.5120717883,
-0.0972395167,
-0.0209119264,
0.6278265715,
-0.5498769879,
0.3386370242,
-0.3177594244,
-0.0899164677,
-0.4266827106,
-0.2083756924,
-0.2873131633,
-0.5039563775,
-0.5750729442,
-0.216900602,
0.5764749646,
1.0184415579,
0.5741176605,
-0.9080309272,
-0.1785214096,
0.0511410274,
-0.1351653636,
-0.6149777174,
-0.2563023269,
0.449994117,
-0.0664105639,
-0.5759016275,
0.9206995964,
-0.0096914954,
0.2458650917,
0.140953809,
-0.1677081138,
0.5866810083,
-0.0304908529,
0.3755841851,
0.4971011281,
-0.7467018366,
-0.2432929873,
-0.214548409,
-0.2392511815,
0.0771497115,
0.4966427088,
-0.7377750278,
0.6714497209,
0.2307914943,
0.2031565309,
-0.0809674785,
0.2072091103,
0.495736599,
-0.2677728236,
-0.0803873464,
0.5494148731,
0.0764845908,
0.4873673618,
-0.390291661,
0.2064720988,
0.2184638083,
-0.6532042027,
-1.1632971764,
-0.094906792,
-0.5804454088,
0.1214111149,
1.1886070967,
0.0181737337,
0.0777569339,
-0.8785416484,
-0.2871749401,
0.5450581908,
-0.5564020872,
0.7011562586,
0.3821439445,
-0.3476181328,
0.1299518496,
-0.6901022196,
0.8573053479,
-0.075378947,
0.085422039,
0.0165301748,
0.3879632652,
0.3979602158,
-0.1822865009,
0.6043865085,
-0.1826036721,
0.5061354041,
0.286536485,
0.0864988267,
0.0965405107,
-0.3543102741,
-0.6724562049,
-0.247163102,
0.0866835117,
-0.2981531918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08174v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08174v1
|
Rethinking Loss Functions for Fact Verification
| 2024-03-13T01:56:32 | 2024-03-13T01:56:32 |
Yuta Mukobara, Yutaro Shigeto, Masashi Shimbo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore loss functions for fact verification in the FEVER shared task.
While the cross-entropy loss is a standard objective for training verdict
predictors, it fails to capture the heterogeneity among the FEVER verdict
classes. In this paper, we develop two task-specific objectives tailored to
FEVER. Experimental results confirm that the proposed objective functions
outperform the standard cross-entropy. Performance is further improved when
these objectives are combined with simple class weighting, which effectively
overcomes the imbalance in the training data. The souce code is available at
https://github.com/yuta-mukobara/RLF-KGAT
|
[
0.020637108,
-0.2529647946,
0.6831227541,
0.287448585,
-0.2902988195,
-0.1802907586,
-0.094862543,
-0.2863882482,
0.1993930191,
0.3040502071,
-0.7043110132,
-0.2935293913,
-0.9348734617,
0.0235313978,
-0.5451183915,
1.412150383,
-0.2100422084,
0.0155809997,
-0.7777209282,
-0.2551772594,
-0.3346305788,
-0.5071824789,
-0.3145463169,
-0.9476246834,
0.7171123028,
0.6514840126,
0.772360146,
0.4128575325,
0.5171299577,
0.1287407428,
0.4477990568,
0.0234664157,
-0.721845746,
0.0817296356,
-0.151266858,
-0.8247974515,
0.1615884155,
0.089858979,
0.3490920663,
0.3050836921,
-0.2283373922,
0.2237611413,
0.0168112013,
0.5707201958,
-1.0659036636,
0.2207072228,
-0.3249314725,
0.4954014719,
-0.2230641097,
-0.5047237277,
-0.5044063926,
-0.2595895827,
0.2233649939,
-0.430180043,
0.488197118,
0.1332015246,
0.9996748567,
0.5189335346,
-0.6294198036,
-0.0651480407,
-0.7409650087,
0.8445794582,
-0.1373140365,
0.6574440002,
0.2719568312,
0.1025385261,
-0.0376098491,
-0.5692196488,
-0.3090353012,
0.0213212054,
-0.1267290264,
0.1427462548,
-0.0470972471,
-0.2361010909,
-0.0123592354,
0.322471112,
-0.3077236712,
-0.6892248988,
-0.2935971022,
-0.5874858499,
0.9646966457,
0.4053575695,
0.2405829281,
0.1333850175,
-0.4667671323,
0.0837844461,
-0.6369667649,
0.2508351803,
0.0984722525,
0.2206481695,
-0.3841569424,
0.4654035866,
-0.2215007097,
0.5424138308,
0.1631840169,
-0.4718858004,
0.3814611435,
-0.2073465288,
-0.2058705539,
0.3603325784,
0.2182454318,
0.7395541072,
-0.0787589997,
-0.3427363038,
-0.2173040658,
-0.4974880815,
0.0794050843,
-0.9084710479,
-0.3079389334,
-0.015201088,
-0.6518501639,
-0.4263722003,
-0.0225496776,
-0.4725985825,
-0.7847257257,
-0.2662334442,
0.8171430826,
-0.4131939709,
-0.1470740736,
0.2384626716,
-0.564119637,
0.1378454119,
0.3213468492,
-0.4744904041,
0.2034105361,
0.6038346887,
0.7975647449,
-0.0785535872,
-0.314448297,
-0.8004744649,
-0.2006848902,
0.0100989146,
0.7188293338,
-0.7447758913,
-0.1794317514,
-0.066050142,
-0.321810931,
-0.3827338517,
-0.2013377845,
0.6103700399,
-0.399862051,
0.1771507561,
-0.6177127361,
-0.3631045222,
-0.4502441287,
0.2414222956,
-0.286714375,
0.7127572298,
-0.0219695941,
-1.2566407919,
0.7148061395,
-0.2148089409,
-0.8927858472,
-0.3442282081,
-0.058320906,
-0.9313728213,
0.1954998672,
-0.1587622911,
0.5756636262,
-0.5473622084,
0.2895159423,
-0.4946817458,
-0.5352290273,
0.2057507336,
-0.0533645414,
0.7360266447,
0.4337769747,
-0.4491590261,
0.1067363173,
-0.6938661337,
0.0011367264,
0.1065295562,
-0.4482530653,
-0.4209624231,
0.1667013168,
-0.0883921459,
-0.3417413235,
-0.0975945815,
-0.8666824102,
0.0810840279,
-0.002967495,
0.0139190461,
0.2242264897,
0.018017821,
0.2054125667,
-0.6967157722,
0.3852695227,
0.024028033,
0.3291765749,
0.5558702946,
-0.4392537177,
-0.5106883049,
-0.6354227662,
0.4199028909,
0.8025918603,
-0.832834065,
0.0685242116,
0.1610423923,
-0.6866176128,
-0.2219001055,
-0.1294151694,
0.2674233019,
0.3946837187,
0.363765806,
-0.0778550059,
-0.9982966781,
-0.7060761452,
-0.5755668879,
-0.0758110881,
0.2269628793,
0.0317425616,
0.3831732869,
-0.3808115721,
0.9000344872,
-0.5378780961,
-0.325607419,
-0.5293482542,
0.1507792026,
0.3056710362,
0.4745212495,
0.6978519559,
-0.8820232749,
-0.3143463731,
-0.2022787929,
-0.7730987668,
-0.2612988949,
-0.0355145149,
0.2494138777,
0.1788549274,
0.4087715447,
-0.3511353135,
0.9276322722,
0.4899522364,
-0.5600909591,
0.5137565732,
0.0531606525,
0.5053403378,
-0.4498742521,
-0.1013407186,
0.0210327283,
-0.4004360437,
-0.7207834125,
0.0032015331,
-0.0042135078,
0.1376842856,
-0.4865854084,
0.2364130169,
-0.2268950939,
0.0843593627,
-0.3583768606,
-0.5421756506,
0.0548138916,
0.2978008389,
0.0319330618,
0.3159671724,
0.9408802986,
-0.7601703405,
0.4497349262,
-0.3124981225,
-0.0406071022,
0.5559190512,
-0.6776903868,
-0.3419617116,
-0.4533089995,
0.2476399392,
-0.6134922504,
-0.1223494932,
0.7642025352,
-0.4249825776,
0.3836836219,
-0.1349688023,
0.0028022076,
-0.1351982653,
-0.4536587298,
0.622813046,
0.3609694839,
-0.3225729167,
0.9300438166,
0.3388779759,
0.3750762343,
-0.899926424,
-0.6786907315,
-0.2469407469,
-0.362282902,
-0.620066762,
0.3986263275,
0.0414519683,
-0.3877148926,
0.0849588588,
-0.4389759898,
0.1199935004,
0.1629690975,
0.5348902941,
0.0340085998,
-0.1156291068,
0.3458127379,
-0.1661123335,
0.1761112809,
0.2049943656,
-0.2867925167,
0.4555454552,
-0.1309189647,
-0.3262600005,
-0.288367182,
0.4264498353,
0.169102475,
-0.0774905905,
0.8057528734,
0.7762046456,
-0.487377733,
-0.1104318798,
-0.5353489518,
-0.1568077654,
-0.3864686489,
0.3030391932,
-0.6679649353,
-0.6748649478,
0.680280149,
0.3551292121,
0.1430342346,
0.8189406991,
0.6447418332,
0.0197139811,
0.5646707416,
0.9895385504,
0.1739755571,
0.3483592868,
-0.0847940296,
0.2286955714,
-0.4206276238,
-0.6615076661,
-0.5861347914,
-0.3031981885,
-0.0805749819,
-0.4428162575,
0.6239219904,
-0.1282933205,
0.0327920727,
-0.0252980422,
-0.3748542964,
0.4059699774,
0.8247899413,
0.5210592151,
0.0625183359,
-0.0672125667,
0.0553905629,
0.2715884447,
-0.972156167,
0.0172320101,
1.2731144428,
0.3352197707,
1.0227597952,
-0.1258357614,
1.4991413355,
0.6174051762,
0.4822083712,
-0.7485297918,
0.3297637403,
-0.1709919423,
-0.7905241847,
-0.6577677131,
-0.6251242757,
-0.8106976151,
0.2363282889,
-0.2770240009,
-0.5284253955,
0.5348000526,
0.3943935931,
-0.4584892094,
0.3821749985,
-0.5483742356,
0.9008966088,
0.0646704659,
-0.468229413,
-0.439971149,
-0.6323043108,
0.6217781901,
0.107948333,
0.2449290901,
-0.168190971,
0.1785450429,
1.1500166655,
-0.7685441375,
0.9073739052,
-0.4082768261,
0.0957456157,
0.5736082792,
-0.1531392187,
0.2703968883,
0.3736118674,
-0.4279310107,
0.095356673,
0.4148621559,
-0.3200992942,
-0.2880866528,
0.368729502,
-0.8618308902,
-0.8013668656,
-0.9597588778,
-0.5585295558,
0.0539578684,
0.1247759089,
0.6441640854,
0.6577996612,
0.0190153215,
0.3117130101,
0.8543838859,
-0.0970291942,
0.0617213026,
0.4408752918,
-0.1185853258,
-0.1806176007,
1.0145506859,
0.0135367103,
-0.0247651897,
0.5863763094,
0.6456836462,
-0.0111581404,
-0.6194106936,
-0.3014566302,
0.0066173086,
-0.8751155734,
-0.5953606963,
-0.6473956108,
-0.1512228847,
-0.7542245388,
0.1372168213,
-0.1881815344,
-0.2107439488,
-0.1454908401,
0.1479149014,
0.4246912003,
0.4645101726,
-0.7366747856,
0.0759916902,
-0.8326382637,
0.3519428074,
0.2050757855,
0.3206322193,
-0.4067165554,
-0.6678501368,
-0.4285320938,
0.1696301997,
-0.127956897,
-0.8964527845,
0.0755396932,
0.5366330743,
0.8172567487,
0.3060131967,
0.6938700676,
0.3763560355,
-0.0557267293,
0.4237844944,
0.4678244889,
-1.0783638954,
0.3036701977,
0.2652133405,
-0.0055264425,
0.5533435941,
0.3859803975,
-0.6370045543,
-0.4228040576,
-0.4471685588,
-0.2588899136,
1.0268219709,
0.1139098704,
-0.2013887316,
0.3693872988,
0.3736997843,
0.2711502612,
-0.0220262762,
-0.6314251423,
-0.5287975669,
-0.6122413278,
-0.3198288977,
-0.0480150282,
-0.337634027,
-0.4326832592,
-0.3549180925,
0.9356412888,
-0.0307763368,
0.2416519225,
0.7825417519,
-0.0585455783,
-0.5458279252,
0.0621127635,
0.6622496247,
0.3693046272,
-0.4485845566,
0.4451738596,
0.1938139349,
-0.5746719837,
0.2801787257,
0.1858183593,
-0.2153986692,
0.0683593452,
0.7984759808,
0.5957975984,
0.0247499812,
-0.4519768953,
0.712377727,
-0.3601301908,
-0.5118578672,
0.1414494216,
0.2575538456,
-0.1704165339,
0.5404794216,
0.3396684229,
0.4728564024,
0.6847234964,
-0.9272783995,
0.505579114,
0.3302191496,
-0.3934447765,
-0.1760369092,
0.5619017482,
0.2117814124,
0.0870012343,
0.3576737046,
-0.4245218039,
-1.0008378029,
0.7309289575,
0.3283830881,
0.8567150831,
-0.1074751467,
0.3894155324,
0.1588625461,
0.3238970339,
-0.1942605376,
0.5640953183,
0.0530690253,
-0.7349966168,
-0.0899393782,
-0.6041757464,
-0.3946654201,
-0.4367744327,
-0.4857320786,
0.2745556831,
-0.3379893899,
-0.2414857,
0.1194738224,
0.0688954368,
-0.8283819556,
0.4942052364,
0.1275510192,
0.6790939569,
-1.0445226431,
0.7126001716,
0.6874375343,
-0.2749033868,
-0.8392474055,
0.1697648913,
0.194359526,
-1.0385907888,
0.8402251601,
0.0662253872,
-0.1753641069,
-0.6394180655,
-0.5592694283,
-1.0538563728,
0.7540239692,
0.3938585818,
-0.3551503122,
0.1708755791,
-0.0165125765,
0.1122217998,
-0.4223650992,
-0.1241966784,
0.4696565866,
0.5901885629,
0.6176211238,
-0.9326679111,
0.2279703021,
-0.0026995444,
-0.5512334108,
0.2400733978,
-0.5775213838,
1.0327590704,
-0.7780357599,
-0.2236030847,
-0.323702991,
0.8850609064,
-0.0553341694,
1.3515245914,
0.7671138644,
0.4587132931,
0.7312406898,
-0.2596530318,
1.1085474491,
-0.00473643,
0.4628371,
1.0400457382,
-0.2385986894,
0.2980205119,
0.5814126134,
-0.0701857805,
0.208111763,
0.5587128997,
-0.0303543527,
0.8068249226,
0.5806729198,
0.0034227828,
-0.6703867912,
-0.1961906105,
-0.452126652,
0.3969351351,
0.056471765,
-0.1288178563,
-0.1759058982,
0.3220273554,
0.0759896711,
-0.2135389596,
-0.4500154257,
0.3828515112,
-0.0990102366,
-0.7959590554,
0.6894165874,
0.1950210631,
0.5662036538,
-0.2498762459,
0.1618479639,
-0.1399412751,
0.3463301361,
-0.648183167,
-0.6717363,
0.6699389219,
-0.4060046971,
-0.2624804676,
-0.0098258732,
1.0372899771,
-0.469879359,
-0.5446562767,
-0.1432444304,
0.2193944007,
0.1890781373,
-0.2610439062,
-0.4209998846,
0.467700392,
0.3094719648,
-0.1252572387,
-0.1741068065,
0.5331710577,
0.0784117505,
0.8819370866,
0.0111345211,
-0.133122623,
0.0206457227,
-0.0411883257,
0.5179196,
-0.5443596244,
-0.2230782807,
-0.843599081,
0.1206497997,
0.0787873119,
-0.257743299,
0.6178792119,
0.6868200898,
0.5875486135,
-0.3505068123,
0.7525433302,
-0.4759777784,
0.398994118,
-0.5379300117,
0.632032156,
-0.9219735861,
0.0881938711,
0.0248546768,
-0.4279650152,
-0.5308780074,
0.3263500631,
-0.23207739,
-0.1722461581,
0.7533100843,
0.6369054317,
0.0541741736,
0.1232587621,
0.384804219,
-0.2431370169,
0.2121328264,
0.7228773832,
0.8301736712,
-0.7240260839,
0.634713769,
-0.5599022508,
-0.5141254067,
-0.8287394643,
-0.8094028831,
-1.1598978043,
-0.5059170723,
-1.0080189705,
-0.3643077612,
0.5109601617,
1.1425216198,
0.9490857124,
-0.8926736712,
-0.0356631987,
0.3913498819,
0.636749506,
-0.6111623049,
-0.134171471,
0.263913095,
-0.4369702041,
-0.3636237085,
-0.0132301319,
0.014430495,
-0.1533361226,
0.2555964589,
-0.3651746511,
-0.2649246752,
0.2725865543,
0.4465227723,
0.2687796652,
-0.472517252,
-0.6179062128,
-0.2934936881,
-0.0903605297,
-0.2432760894,
1.1126073599,
-0.7365115285,
-0.0027023093,
0.8003041148,
0.7026543021,
0.36762622,
-0.4268421829,
0.6695810556,
-0.6957443953,
-0.2100269198,
0.1376701742,
0.613499701,
0.0851624832,
-0.5714997649,
0.5651659966,
0.667884171,
-0.3446949422,
-1.1101214886,
0.072488822,
-0.9221524,
-0.2089671344,
0.9570812583,
-0.135490194,
-0.3747837543,
-0.1192775369,
-0.0881863162,
0.5458099246,
-0.4365412891,
1.0153326988,
0.5387369394,
-0.2638826072,
-0.1487438828,
0.1589077413,
0.826045692,
0.5633762479,
-0.5776423216,
0.1778889745,
0.3027425706,
0.6006155014,
0.2796643376,
0.4867676795,
0.322519213,
0.6753916144,
0.0804491341,
0.2136717439,
-0.1468195468,
-0.5859994888,
0.161151275,
0.398187995,
-0.0314648896,
-0.3863883615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08167v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08167v2
|
MolBind: Multimodal Alignment of Language, Molecules, and Proteins
| 2024-03-13T01:38:42 | 2024-04-03T01:00:53 |
Teng Xiao, Chao Cui, Huaisheng Zhu, Vasant G. Honavar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.QM
|
Recent advancements in biology and chemistry have leveraged multi-modal
learning, integrating molecules and their natural language descriptions to
enhance drug discovery. However, current pre-training frameworks are limited to
two modalities, and designing a unified network to process different modalities
(e.g., natural language, 2D molecular graphs, 3D molecular conformations, and
3D proteins) remains challenging due to inherent gaps among them. In this work,
we propose MolBind, a framework that trains encoders for multiple modalities
through contrastive learning, mapping all modalities to a shared feature space
for multi-modal semantic alignment. To facilitate effective pre-training of
MolBind on multiple modalities, we also build and collect a high-quality
dataset with four modalities, MolBind-M4, including graph-language,
conformation-language, graph-conformation, and conformation-protein paired
data. MolBind shows superior zero-shot learning performance across a wide range
of tasks, demonstrating its strong capability of capturing the underlying
semantics of multiple modalities.
|
[
-0.2224429101,
-0.3719359934,
0.1246375442,
-0.0889724419,
-0.1544306725,
0.0271455739,
-0.034512233,
-0.1723938435,
0.4745240808,
0.1493260115,
-0.4737461805,
-0.4016828239,
-0.5630625486,
0.0723968223,
0.1248971224,
1.0659172535,
-0.1165596619,
0.4467482865,
-0.2194814235,
-0.6115481257,
-0.1968036443,
-0.0564549565,
0.0334860981,
-0.4304202199,
0.8791467547,
0.083481662,
0.4712090194,
0.5257765055,
0.9128108621,
0.2467259467,
0.4034653008,
0.2574526072,
-0.5199784636,
0.2308469713,
-0.3552437723,
-0.2796011269,
-0.5757679939,
0.0042818761,
0.3543967009,
0.7779145837,
0.0145327318,
-0.0667893365,
-0.1726228893,
0.541670084,
-0.9036847353,
0.1933339536,
-0.3219999373,
0.1772783995,
-0.4897193313,
-0.2916179001,
0.0199444219,
0.0605407842,
0.1221130565,
-0.9360466599,
0.2506425083,
0.0484151952,
1.1105023623,
0.3006007671,
-1.0484399796,
-0.3081899583,
0.0839795992,
0.5667455196,
-0.5100309253,
0.6787157059,
0.0635239929,
0.3586167097,
-0.1226702034,
-0.412420392,
-0.6474567652,
0.0099751903,
-0.2408389747,
0.4660868049,
0.4129030406,
0.3849495947,
-0.0804640949,
0.4840344191,
-0.8176404834,
-0.0990502238,
-0.5290983319,
-0.6316187382,
0.0842640325,
0.0995276123,
0.1409415901,
-0.2548155189,
-0.5651053786,
-0.2190015465,
-0.5426798463,
-0.2724713087,
0.2192108929,
0.4550823867,
-0.1072409377,
0.6875559688,
-0.0138198156,
0.8183936477,
0.1595786065,
-0.2438959628,
0.8123316765,
-0.9225607514,
-0.3298163414,
0.0950188637,
0.9190123677,
0.3437088132,
-0.4303030968,
0.0892005637,
-0.079394199,
0.2169521451,
0.0298626386,
-1.0315239429,
-0.3370904326,
0.2158361077,
-0.4557124376,
-0.1714507937,
0.0074797245,
-0.8912060857,
-0.6589714289,
-0.2588754892,
0.6444223523,
-0.7864426374,
-0.2782275379,
0.2689368725,
-0.3261018991,
0.2565906048,
0.1016352922,
-1.0685352087,
-0.2007369995,
0.2574559152,
0.734623909,
-0.2116033137,
-0.3805607557,
-0.5281992555,
0.7533611655,
-0.1521642357,
0.5575642586,
-0.7656630874,
-0.2648003995,
-0.1411814094,
-0.0451154485,
-0.2319178283,
-0.3895322978,
0.0842738524,
-0.3753527701,
0.3097023666,
-0.1582689583,
-0.4001753628,
-0.3217259943,
0.4989824891,
-0.6847664714,
0.3269163072,
-0.0121298991,
-0.6754230857,
0.4906845093,
-0.9375685453,
-0.580804944,
-0.0504216701,
-0.7680258751,
-0.0583422333,
0.2114475369,
0.2329636216,
0.247817412,
-0.1660207957,
0.1925180852,
-0.1973260045,
-0.0347373709,
0.2305934429,
-0.2977648377,
0.6185887456,
0.3512307703,
-0.070071198,
0.1323164999,
-0.7568843365,
-0.0368030071,
-0.479703486,
-0.5352363586,
-0.0094453236,
-0.5629903674,
0.1022768095,
0.2947680354,
0.2560244203,
-0.5555024147,
0.2937479317,
-0.2587664723,
0.4258143902,
0.6588477492,
-0.0957973078,
0.5917375684,
-0.2016182542,
0.4642191827,
0.6642846465,
-0.1302860081,
-0.4563030303,
-0.0554599836,
-0.6305471063,
-0.6402075887,
0.390178144,
0.2352302074,
-0.8859207034,
0.2081477046,
-0.5461187959,
-0.2628952265,
-0.5608767867,
0.358061254,
0.6685663462,
0.4596562386,
0.5056073666,
-0.5632302165,
-0.3833811283,
-1.1048419476,
0.0997390896,
0.0795269459,
0.0747424364,
0.3055830896,
0.5428863168,
-0.8189988732,
0.677603662,
-0.3080275059,
-0.7217374444,
0.0627234578,
0.4099366963,
0.1840907037,
0.6879858971,
0.3402605355,
-1.0069563389,
-0.270391047,
0.3454827666,
-0.8672928214,
-0.0446782745,
-0.1232794672,
-0.5173416734,
-0.1335283816,
0.4887455404,
-0.3886113465,
0.0040426096,
0.8165491819,
-0.1113015935,
0.1154175401,
-0.0889939144,
0.4533007443,
-1.305331111,
0.2630032599,
-0.0655254945,
0.0558470823,
-0.4484654367,
-0.1214469597,
0.2080518007,
-0.2498583496,
-0.4382195473,
0.4946942031,
-0.7089208364,
0.2932324708,
0.0423958674,
-0.0244194269,
0.3661507666,
0.649035573,
-0.1281475872,
0.694842577,
0.641040206,
-0.4169139564,
0.3592621088,
0.4396047294,
-0.1301127821,
0.8917348981,
-0.3553703725,
-0.2837426364,
-0.1465772986,
0.1988997757,
-0.7267076969,
-0.6565967202,
0.3373261392,
-0.4153023958,
0.5836828351,
0.1799777001,
0.0052207028,
0.1151870713,
-0.4169220924,
0.8297900558,
-0.1045360938,
-0.2949708402,
1.1126055717,
0.3679274321,
0.2469459921,
-0.738224268,
-0.7914906144,
-0.221983254,
0.1766312569,
-0.5648347139,
0.3979979455,
-0.0379864275,
0.2138068527,
0.0635378212,
-0.4120793045,
-0.2181294411,
-0.3548190892,
0.5571924448,
0.0811597779,
-0.3267905414,
0.4118575454,
-0.0719641447,
-0.2113171816,
-0.5017486215,
-0.3033476472,
0.4009875953,
-0.2358695865,
-0.5757676363,
-0.1099269465,
0.3515358865,
0.6313567758,
-0.4394555092,
0.5455268621,
0.6533594131,
-0.1571701765,
0.3217763603,
-0.255926162,
-0.1126250327,
-0.4744923115,
0.5243062973,
-0.4011985064,
-0.7476320863,
0.1668914258,
-0.1548173875,
-0.1355442703,
0.0574772246,
0.460369736,
-0.1341597587,
0.8481162786,
0.7625678778,
0.2053595036,
0.4927736223,
-0.1517035365,
0.5833582878,
-0.8965517879,
-0.4680128694,
-0.0143697904,
-0.6729504466,
-0.219204843,
-0.6641230583,
0.4884884953,
0.1275762022,
-0.2613047957,
0.3153114021,
-0.2750254869,
0.5480600595,
0.5135037303,
0.2173898667,
-0.068731539,
0.1399430633,
-0.4049615562,
-0.1596691757,
-0.43326509,
-0.1050243899,
1.1015322208,
-0.1642018557,
1.0442838669,
0.3653141856,
0.5421974063,
-0.0468018651,
0.1968041211,
-0.630630374,
0.4036124051,
-0.0374034829,
-0.830006063,
0.0029435612,
-0.4604069591,
-0.8108806014,
0.449270606,
-0.5852825642,
-0.170922935,
0.5919649005,
0.2157535404,
-0.3356328309,
0.022020245,
-0.7385401726,
1.0899055004,
-0.6175884604,
-0.437151134,
-0.1579324603,
-0.9948390126,
0.278147161,
-0.1500875801,
0.09078563,
-0.1641276628,
-0.2297026366,
0.5303635597,
-0.2037587613,
0.7274541855,
-0.0085878568,
0.0626550019,
-0.2517468333,
0.2143517137,
-0.2942610383,
-0.11328426,
0.0863450617,
0.1724309176,
0.0560038276,
-0.6129579544,
-0.5378909707,
0.6584460139,
-0.5740291476,
-0.2743525803,
-0.5415590405,
-0.7664500475,
-0.3029487431,
0.5440084934,
0.3958679438,
0.7545486689,
-0.015846299,
0.4942625165,
0.6312947273,
-0.0587118901,
0.13947317,
0.4293672144,
-0.2217215002,
-0.7040266991,
1.1994042397,
-0.0306888334,
0.3123546541,
0.7973923683,
-0.0532645099,
-0.1183803156,
-0.4215530157,
-0.1790565252,
0.3614245057,
-0.7504903078,
-0.4641738534,
-0.5758536458,
-0.0052711153,
-0.6242945194,
-0.5315030217,
-0.3121158481,
-0.2438857555,
0.0555122718,
-0.1754627526,
-0.0029736748,
0.1353349835,
-0.4071660936,
0.109895736,
-0.9606164694,
0.4961188436,
0.2770425677,
0.2352018207,
-0.528749764,
-0.1241699159,
-0.4287859797,
0.2746308148,
-0.4299255311,
-0.7126592994,
0.2353601605,
0.7183033228,
0.7104867697,
0.7640274167,
-0.2631925344,
0.7819857001,
-0.3069339097,
0.6820007563,
0.7944872379,
-0.7126279473,
0.5315434337,
-0.2810592949,
0.3732869923,
0.8642419577,
0.5760322213,
-0.5725821257,
-0.0182147846,
-0.0838703886,
-0.8575444221,
0.2179161161,
-0.0645538345,
-0.0578581057,
-0.0525857955,
-0.1369043291,
0.513066411,
0.6303057075,
-0.8029337525,
-0.0725095421,
-0.7185320258,
-0.6913425326,
-0.0639187992,
0.0556462146,
-0.72640872,
-0.1740663648,
0.5965204835,
-0.4999719858,
0.2763909996,
-0.0814320296,
-0.5901378393,
0.2436214983,
0.241272375,
0.6015210152,
0.5495396852,
-0.2836320698,
0.5562692285,
-0.3881211281,
-0.5251717567,
0.2541615963,
0.0903600082,
0.1813206077,
-0.2686931789,
0.5284175277,
0.8295295238,
0.2119407654,
-0.9049525261,
0.6985331178,
0.1885533929,
-0.1852578521,
0.3622714281,
0.0259940606,
-0.011780316,
0.3136033714,
-0.0991821066,
0.3691875339,
0.1457471102,
-0.6227823496,
0.1484424174,
0.4018608928,
-0.5324628949,
-0.4305709898,
0.615953207,
0.4534481764,
0.1124885455,
0.5699036121,
0.0523632467,
-0.3727277815,
0.2217083573,
0.4161137938,
0.6304286718,
-0.0643812045,
0.1296911538,
0.2225567251,
-0.0872170851,
0.3579301536,
0.075428836,
-0.1605378687,
-0.9660953879,
0.1514758319,
-0.6776961088,
-0.1400565654,
-0.2565269172,
-0.5635951161,
0.3008811176,
-0.2684919536,
-0.090190798,
0.1324900836,
-0.266913563,
-0.6042781472,
-0.0713870302,
0.1183488965,
0.618791461,
-0.7927716374,
0.8381804228,
0.8606084585,
-0.9469301701,
-0.3124404848,
-0.2117576897,
0.3436637521,
-0.7198546529,
0.9034208655,
0.5270678401,
-0.3591244817,
-0.2687257826,
-0.4794254005,
-0.7812387347,
1.2277849913,
0.2842644751,
-0.4918108582,
0.0565647297,
0.0088707004,
0.4309155345,
-0.4683304131,
0.1973056197,
0.2688361704,
0.4447843134,
0.1775311977,
-0.7777276039,
-0.1441372037,
-0.639373064,
-0.1609383821,
0.3663340211,
-0.5563542247,
1.0276577473,
0.0107326796,
-0.256175518,
-0.2802421153,
0.4686429501,
0.140192315,
0.0091680307,
0.1639166176,
0.5969293118,
0.75510782,
-0.0687252656,
0.6593547463,
-0.2766416073,
-0.0342195965,
1.0018384457,
-0.5356897116,
0.501596272,
0.8529615402,
0.1919538826,
0.4298907518,
0.4250683188,
-0.1047727838,
0.9191448092,
0.0355148278,
-0.2336299717,
-0.3842253387,
-0.2583849132,
-0.5599964857,
0.3218631446,
0.5198193789,
-0.0069798799,
-0.4349932075,
0.5178272128,
-0.3702557683,
-0.0775078982,
-0.1003184095,
0.5495237708,
-0.1799881756,
-0.0789952651,
0.4096474051,
-0.3863762021,
0.9301614165,
-0.9560992718,
-0.1231224984,
-0.292334795,
0.2590809166,
-0.2621099353,
-0.4640446603,
-0.1996186972,
-0.7337393761,
-0.3368016481,
-0.0650255829,
0.2602008581,
-0.7360172868,
-0.2252064645,
0.2872098386,
0.3219473958,
-0.0305051077,
0.4287754893,
-0.5343155265,
0.0236827694,
0.0394794047,
-0.0694198608,
0.4489973187,
0.6063568592,
0.2631572783,
0.5729799271,
0.4419879317,
-0.0648735017,
0.1431505829,
-0.1751072556,
0.9902621508,
-0.6886204481,
-0.1710353792,
-0.5076950788,
0.4970588386,
-0.1723027676,
-0.4374094903,
0.5642722249,
0.8679380417,
0.9780377746,
-0.056544926,
0.6677615047,
-0.2459885925,
0.1119755283,
-0.6398441792,
0.4345204532,
-0.7758902311,
-0.0069133178,
0.2983016372,
-0.7771092057,
-0.4350722432,
0.7691977024,
0.0644212887,
-0.107034184,
0.9623582959,
1.3946968317,
-0.3590216637,
-0.2206861377,
0.2618915439,
0.1901091337,
0.6293093562,
0.7558420897,
0.5185563564,
-0.465382129,
0.6031759381,
-0.030964883,
-0.1505088955,
-0.3473257422,
-0.8987366557,
-0.8098534942,
-0.6652349234,
-0.1901439875,
-0.2481202334,
-0.1094194725,
1.0738116503,
0.8121144176,
-0.985447228,
-0.2058786154,
0.1775970012,
-0.2348914593,
-0.1410423517,
-0.1400063187,
0.2250214517,
-0.3625082374,
-0.6425269246,
0.5694338679,
0.7230429649,
0.1391929686,
-0.113798961,
-0.2665714622,
-0.562446177,
-0.0876501426,
0.2872961164,
0.4559849501,
-0.5347636342,
-0.1106019095,
-0.058016438,
-0.5642030835,
0.2454238981,
1.0174987316,
-0.6059841514,
0.9755116105,
0.6709799767,
0.8254129291,
0.3275743127,
-0.2306362689,
0.8978300691,
-0.6316132545,
0.3760431409,
0.268332541,
0.431951791,
0.3379183114,
0.0246245619,
0.6023029685,
0.2465580106,
-0.3983462453,
-0.6604142189,
0.4189290702,
-1.2677807808,
-0.3632619977,
0.8862832785,
0.169209376,
-0.2660452425,
-0.0888302922,
-0.3492160439,
0.1783789545,
-0.3472321928,
0.4055394232,
0.6244773865,
-0.2278961688,
0.1107051075,
-0.3101037741,
0.3597440422,
0.3658902943,
-0.5778260827,
-0.184723556,
0.9420513511,
0.0669164956,
0.5121780634,
0.6297198534,
-0.258428365,
0.1148620322,
0.2158063948,
0.2345683724,
-0.4132715762,
-0.4698810577,
-0.3125598133,
0.2456253171,
-0.4194737673,
-0.3256365955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08140v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08140v2
|
BAGEL: Bootstrapping Agents by Guiding Exploration with Language
| 2024-03-12T23:59:15 | 2024-06-09T01:12:26 |
Shikhar Murty, Christopher Manning, Peter Shaw, Mandar Joshi, Kenton Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Following natural language instructions by executing actions in digital
environments (e.g. web-browsers and REST APIs) is a challenging task for
language model (LM) agents. Unfortunately, LM agents often fail to generalize
to new environments without human demonstrations. This work presents BAGEL, a
method for bootstrapping LM agents without human supervision. BAGEL converts a
seed set of randomly explored trajectories or synthetic instructions, into
demonstrations, via round-trips between two noisy LM components: an LM labeler
which converts a trajectory into a synthetic instruction, and a zero-shot LM
agent which maps the synthetic instruction into a refined trajectory. By
performing these round-trips iteratively, BAGEL quickly converts the initial
distribution of trajectories towards those that are well-described by natural
language. We use BAGEL demonstrations to adapt a zero shot LM agent at test
time via in-context learning over retrieved demonstrations, and find
improvements of over 2-13% absolute on ToolQA and MiniWob++, with up to 13x
reduction in execution failures.
|
[
-0.2410789579,
-0.7254480124,
0.6106992364,
0.1693786532,
0.3211829066,
0.4211930335,
-0.3683663309,
-0.4005680382,
0.1317397505,
0.2834222317,
-0.6447546482,
-0.6448145509,
-0.2745325565,
-0.2488764524,
-0.5624918938,
1.1986461878,
-0.162994802,
-0.1319578141,
-0.1122338176,
0.398458004,
-0.2925633192,
-0.1224722788,
-0.689422369,
-0.4317935109,
0.6069401503,
0.4375438392,
0.4734452367,
0.4248357117,
-0.0626302734,
0.2719151974,
0.287231952,
0.1818316132,
-0.4609389603,
0.1137918159,
-0.2996821105,
-0.4749005139,
-0.1066513211,
-0.0664568469,
0.4282154143,
0.8208838701,
-0.1381769329,
0.1176870465,
-0.0284806695,
0.5488726497,
-0.7396768332,
0.2120536715,
-0.3778597713,
-0.1204237789,
0.1886997521,
-0.2842669189,
-0.5262507796,
-0.3596434295,
0.0029069399,
-0.8308538198,
0.3490259647,
0.3341761529,
0.7493106723,
-0.0654704273,
-0.1699802279,
-0.6402541399,
-1.1190491915,
0.8339750767,
-0.389637202,
0.1471922398,
0.6079572439,
0.6765260696,
-0.4261802733,
-0.6975389719,
-0.5663401484,
-0.3482824862,
-0.1985870749,
-0.2846138477,
-0.116836369,
-0.1270847619,
0.0890663043,
-0.166997388,
-0.5525987744,
0.0471074358,
-0.44937554,
-0.3191373944,
0.7080373168,
0.0054707369,
0.37063694,
0.2273804098,
-0.4031536281,
-0.6896364689,
-0.5497727394,
0.3466373086,
0.2827118933,
0.5134378076,
-0.1877606064,
0.0662557185,
-0.1889131814,
0.7930358052,
0.0505615734,
-0.0172561184,
0.1289278567,
-0.1232161745,
-0.0920396224,
0.1803520173,
0.5778499842,
0.2687909305,
0.176760152,
-0.4299746156,
-0.5527507067,
-0.2062602937,
0.4810902774,
-0.8233217001,
-0.3882979155,
0.3038018942,
0.0345690437,
-0.3694421351,
-0.0594541244,
-0.9243180752,
-0.545466125,
-0.0355354659,
0.6212435961,
-0.4724850953,
-0.0320589207,
0.0702042356,
-0.289758414,
0.4867449403,
0.3754788041,
-0.9769768715,
0.7171950936,
0.5432312489,
0.8791944385,
0.1626750082,
-0.2388194501,
-0.7712145448,
0.3667463362,
-0.6023845673,
1.0331757069,
-0.6179136038,
-0.4404040873,
0.2457096875,
0.1071087271,
-0.0660795569,
-0.4096359909,
0.3856006563,
-0.3270640671,
0.2828193009,
-0.1134358421,
-0.4682717919,
-0.4099777043,
0.3899517059,
-0.3257838786,
0.750099957,
0.1428699791,
-0.1183544621,
0.1813924909,
-1.1390867233,
-0.6306304336,
0.1157860532,
-0.2999130189,
0.053249523,
-0.121608898,
0.4476954341,
0.3335132003,
0.1671496481,
-0.2316883206,
-0.0390861705,
-0.6818253398,
0.1315061748,
-0.045342017,
0.5922470689,
-0.1266514212,
-0.5320563912,
0.2060975283,
-0.7849187255,
0.1599248946,
0.4415595531,
-0.2092059404,
-0.4264467061,
0.128529951,
0.2517289221,
-0.0394770801,
-0.0997475833,
-0.3398392797,
0.759254396,
-0.6419680715,
0.1422901899,
0.8605036139,
0.0984418914,
0.872627914,
-0.5940023065,
0.7719962597,
-0.3696803749,
-0.0946717933,
-0.5890620947,
-0.3387849033,
-1.0034946203,
-0.1122102141,
0.2807776928,
0.4566511214,
-0.7418965697,
0.1736148149,
-0.3394002914,
-0.4353822172,
-0.6804633737,
0.1860275865,
0.1715887934,
0.1473679543,
0.3436903656,
0.0780054331,
-0.3587181568,
-0.8121237755,
-0.0722637996,
-0.1329532862,
-0.4430100322,
-0.0768346712,
0.4033221006,
-0.2624550462,
0.7387428284,
-0.2820973396,
-0.09801092,
-0.4407009184,
0.544831872,
-0.0675181448,
0.4817557931,
0.5168219209,
-0.3625577986,
-0.4636726081,
0.1688883007,
-0.3201610744,
-0.2427919358,
-0.5496686697,
-0.175864011,
0.1611526161,
0.2678549588,
-0.4232003391,
0.5304690003,
0.4217272699,
-0.1162527204,
0.4509509206,
-0.1705861092,
0.1120020598,
-0.7165402174,
-0.0532385707,
-0.1271490902,
-0.6083424091,
-0.7688128948,
0.2123339176,
0.0553318597,
-0.0688708127,
-0.3924388587,
0.9285356998,
-0.6128556728,
-0.0489255674,
-0.5194606781,
0.3587699533,
0.0822095945,
0.654509902,
0.0712548122,
0.7321285605,
0.7261583805,
-0.8368102312,
0.2610524595,
-0.080908522,
-0.2029661238,
0.2652522922,
-0.4399628043,
0.5286911726,
-0.1069637015,
0.3140608966,
-0.8853790164,
-0.0709766597,
0.5079184175,
-0.3473587036,
0.2939976454,
-0.151149556,
-0.5839425921,
-0.0771960989,
-0.4708503783,
0.0181455612,
0.672909677,
-0.4944234192,
0.4175333381,
-0.1158071682,
0.152781561,
-0.281768471,
-0.532410562,
0.1095447168,
0.028676223,
-0.2870703042,
0.2624263167,
-0.3629232049,
-0.3673763573,
-0.2051659673,
0.0024101345,
0.0503997579,
-0.0084957555,
0.3583470285,
-0.0802273601,
0.0430500954,
0.2635273039,
-0.0609736741,
0.0990443826,
0.0661762208,
-0.3412982821,
0.7574238777,
-0.1188048124,
-0.3725806773,
-0.5170520544,
0.4013784826,
0.3279235959,
0.1595876813,
0.6101513505,
0.715177536,
-0.490159601,
-0.6571859717,
-0.2760996521,
-0.5204547048,
-0.5463761091,
0.0625809655,
-0.271163553,
-0.2937677503,
0.2529968321,
-0.2114750445,
0.2370795459,
-0.1512579471,
0.2641668618,
-0.4647130668,
0.665096879,
0.8061202765,
0.029478278,
0.2451685518,
-0.3773424029,
0.3914090693,
-0.3365273476,
-0.1766388416,
-0.3945004642,
-0.7809257507,
-0.3701551259,
-0.4730340242,
0.334058553,
-0.0046342658,
0.0227181315,
0.4098505378,
-0.2963531017,
0.6853910685,
0.6303023696,
-0.132161513,
0.1709254086,
0.1317064315,
-0.2454022467,
0.1827940047,
-0.7355791926,
-0.7173063755,
0.9457222819,
0.1499259025,
0.884544611,
0.0344762802,
0.907107532,
0.5962343216,
0.3908183575,
-0.7540401816,
0.6454987526,
0.6775550246,
-0.565246582,
-0.3018824458,
-0.1159936637,
-1.0145425797,
-0.0343909003,
-0.0477370508,
-1.0973303318,
-0.1154052243,
0.2031627893,
-0.3863452375,
0.2177585661,
-0.8238222599,
0.8416876197,
-0.3708589077,
-0.4319018722,
-0.1012031585,
-0.4942896366,
0.1475466043,
0.1594627351,
0.624830842,
0.1560164243,
-0.1265626699,
0.525397718,
-0.2368409187,
1.0412782431,
-0.2474142462,
-0.3375531733,
0.2397756875,
0.64661479,
0.8458194733,
-0.3080658913,
0.2226363271,
-0.17638807,
0.0997307003,
-0.6756203771,
-1.1628439426,
0.6951096058,
-0.4363318384,
-0.551733017,
-0.3430595696,
-0.5191020966,
-0.2431122214,
-0.0178716406,
-0.1315486133,
0.2200461626,
-0.1624168158,
-0.0858346224,
0.1345310807,
-0.1783925146,
0.8415265679,
0.7147196531,
-0.8334389925,
0.1482126713,
0.8780290484,
-0.1640120894,
0.3928364813,
0.5740568638,
0.1899232417,
-0.1980974823,
-0.3556818664,
-0.685223043,
-0.1007367224,
-0.6312462687,
0.1282130778,
-0.4488167763,
-0.0562978275,
-0.3300918639,
-0.5380306244,
-0.4480517507,
-0.4687632024,
0.101823099,
-0.1310350597,
0.1025130302,
0.7849244475,
-0.0211360864,
0.5365674496,
-0.6015236378,
-0.1215730906,
0.1902110279,
-0.0955634788,
0.0492175743,
-0.395516187,
-0.4030625224,
0.171488896,
-0.4512951672,
-1.0547187328,
0.3867759407,
0.1072249785,
0.3484480381,
0.5883295536,
0.1601669192,
0.804219842,
-0.5217746496,
0.7547870278,
-0.0703489557,
-0.8533248305,
0.749900043,
-0.3949148059,
0.3381348848,
0.2592445314,
0.5745840669,
-0.6727581024,
-0.4148271084,
-0.3819784522,
-0.6124583483,
0.4751013517,
0.2712922394,
0.2525883317,
0.2328485399,
0.0246412326,
0.2111427635,
0.1940151751,
-0.8683602214,
-0.027399255,
0.0003983007,
0.0412509553,
-0.0274509694,
0.2098125666,
-0.3435586095,
-0.3240994513,
0.7959184647,
-0.2058610469,
0.3027710915,
0.0667723194,
-0.3184818029,
-0.1524550468,
0.4733626842,
0.8641302586,
0.724821806,
-0.2628040314,
0.353450954,
-0.0061753765,
0.0253507551,
0.2445644289,
-0.0497305356,
-0.394639492,
0.0358737707,
0.5714857578,
0.7237740159,
0.416154176,
-0.9833517075,
0.5313199162,
0.0202605035,
-0.0162282251,
-0.4418187737,
0.231905967,
0.1655113548,
0.2062208056,
0.4811654389,
-0.0494579189,
0.0709571391,
-0.6370179057,
0.224943921,
0.3232325613,
-0.3760693669,
-0.480812043,
0.31220451,
0.1965640783,
-0.9176750779,
0.1864009351,
-0.8506800532,
-0.2924858928,
0.2657340169,
0.6997262239,
0.950971365,
-0.1128338054,
0.4989266992,
0.2267640978,
0.6731649041,
0.2183556706,
-0.1843557209,
-0.3746033907,
-0.6243882179,
-0.1440955698,
-0.5825500488,
-0.2598390579,
0.2855725288,
-0.3135781288,
0.2411001176,
-0.5881388783,
0.3274947107,
-0.2855664492,
-0.1827697903,
-0.6944109201,
-0.2233408988,
0.1491276622,
0.7731021047,
-0.741299808,
0.6984992027,
0.7967867851,
-0.4342551529,
-0.4957410693,
0.4603076875,
0.0543716997,
-0.8649734259,
0.4843269885,
0.3388156593,
-0.3905781209,
-0.0810134858,
-0.7810806632,
-0.3134349883,
0.9827910066,
0.1888078153,
-0.600271821,
-0.2094686627,
0.107637167,
0.4246317148,
-0.4344546497,
0.3728331923,
0.1698427349,
0.547015667,
0.0822720751,
-0.6632884741,
0.039481815,
-0.0737299323,
-0.1806119531,
-0.0162038077,
-0.4701145589,
0.2853962481,
-0.3040279746,
-0.4695696831,
0.0380076095,
0.5235167742,
-0.028258305,
0.4265632927,
0.5412572622,
0.0991830528,
0.6537743211,
0.1925071925,
1.126319766,
-0.1928650737,
0.1825278699,
1.1478629112,
-0.3668256998,
0.9019601941,
0.6792547107,
-0.0794628859,
1.0041233301,
0.4989881814,
0.2961086631,
0.5191229582,
0.4550319314,
-0.4407917261,
-0.282494396,
-0.0514494255,
0.063562192,
0.457339406,
0.3032630682,
-0.1932614446,
-0.499347508,
0.0796294138,
0.1626457274,
0.5028511882,
-0.142121926,
0.526876986,
-0.1792129427,
-0.5189445019,
0.8330466151,
0.1256880462,
0.3790725768,
-0.6655718088,
-0.4329677522,
-0.2141394019,
0.0608014315,
0.086078383,
-0.2840144634,
0.1256479919,
-0.0060140677,
0.1165317595,
-0.591658473,
0.673075676,
-0.4068993032,
-0.7257759571,
0.3922576904,
0.4288643599,
0.3793068826,
0.0694615692,
-0.3503017128,
0.0842792317,
-0.0947796926,
-0.3403437734,
0.379157424,
0.0477057584,
0.1198451966,
0.9643591046,
0.5110313892,
0.0152424965,
0.120661974,
-0.089152351,
0.7370821238,
-0.6054281592,
-0.3243961334,
-0.7852886915,
0.5687350631,
-0.2562842369,
0.27976951,
0.5743234754,
0.5129516721,
1.1061245203,
-0.3019185066,
0.9117813706,
-0.0352309085,
0.3382061422,
-0.692279458,
0.8353154659,
-0.4549638927,
0.37437886,
0.1282828152,
-0.760517478,
-0.0124473963,
0.7987342477,
-0.249794066,
0.0636579692,
0.8116605878,
1.0718294382,
-0.322490871,
-0.2314008176,
0.4612543881,
0.0803377032,
0.4955505729,
0.6261702776,
0.743198812,
-0.3328503668,
0.6212778687,
-0.3553318083,
-0.2405759543,
-0.0150872311,
-0.8781346083,
-1.0762190819,
-0.5719682574,
-0.3042354286,
-0.0883266851,
0.2979959249,
1.2251983881,
1.0883911848,
-0.8657068014,
-0.5361508131,
-0.0570149682,
0.1584293842,
-0.5030616522,
-0.3164185584,
-0.0627723038,
-0.7123122215,
-0.956928432,
0.9979451299,
0.1634870768,
0.033358831,
-0.6147170067,
-0.2391759604,
-0.2501330972,
0.1892029196,
0.2865783572,
0.4612646401,
-0.6853986382,
-0.4670575261,
-0.1095471382,
0.1109062135,
0.0650681034,
0.8016297221,
-0.8881343007,
0.5900872946,
0.0708354115,
0.8669109344,
0.671171248,
-0.211192593,
0.7458337545,
-1.1503680944,
0.1712460965,
0.1950308084,
-0.053603299,
0.3387029767,
-0.0599780008,
0.3537915647,
0.2138768584,
-0.4005521238,
-0.763513267,
0.2928566337,
-0.8557223678,
-0.2831617594,
1.3578492403,
-0.0094341943,
-0.4580526352,
0.2062454224,
-0.3383116126,
-0.0659490898,
-0.5910770893,
1.0176770687,
0.7038470507,
-0.0820812732,
-0.2942733169,
-0.8532912731,
0.4212433696,
0.1228875071,
-0.8404259086,
0.0565746836,
0.2765509188,
0.2487620711,
0.3200140893,
0.5896293521,
0.4046208262,
-0.0639241412,
-0.0478828438,
0.3993221819,
-0.0028437062,
-0.3879099488,
-0.1684441715,
0.0549890324,
0.0013473413,
-0.5864068866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08137v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08137v1
|
From Paper to Card: Transforming Design Implications with Generative AI
| 2024-03-12T23:47:28 | 2024-03-12T23:47:28 |
Donghoon Shin, Lucy Lu Wang, Gary Hsieh
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7
|
Communicating design implications is common within the HCI community when
publishing academic papers, yet these papers are rarely read and used by
designers. One solution is to use design cards as a form of translational
resource that communicates valuable insights from papers in a more digestible
and accessible format to assist in design processes. However, creating design
cards can be time-consuming, and authors may lack the resources/know-how to
produce cards. Through an iterative design process, we built a system that
helps create design cards from academic papers using an LLM and text-to-image
model. Our evaluation with designers (N=21) and authors of selected papers
(N=12) revealed that designers perceived the design implications from our
design cards as more inspiring and generative, compared to reading original
paper texts, and the authors viewed our system as an effective way of
communicating their design implications. We also propose future enhancements
for AI-generated design cards.
|
[
-0.1886930764,
-0.2977147996,
0.7414101362,
0.155073002,
-0.6565499902,
0.0263631679,
-0.0186886545,
-0.7878499627,
0.3667730689,
0.1824360937,
-0.3640022576,
-0.5174043179,
-0.5051401854,
0.0201484524,
-0.3004285097,
1.0912326574,
-0.4413794577,
-0.3204441965,
-0.7274441719,
0.2218738496,
-0.53549546,
-0.0553999357,
-0.6760746837,
-0.5068551898,
0.6961836815,
0.4234836102,
0.6533172131,
0.6937940121,
0.7230209708,
0.2261554003,
-0.0006854081,
0.05302459,
-0.2334368825,
0.0319404304,
-0.013229249,
-0.6142250299,
-0.648355186,
0.1979281604,
0.3351602554,
0.3703846931,
0.0394494832,
0.3924973607,
0.3002947271,
0.8367656469,
-0.4023334384,
0.466276437,
-0.1095803231,
0.216442436,
-0.49023211,
-0.5251316428,
-0.7751922607,
-0.2542344928,
-0.3825946748,
-0.946554184,
-0.0216526203,
-0.1408919394,
0.65651232,
0.2784609795,
0.0920861959,
-0.5980395079,
-1.1608383656,
0.2135737687,
-0.5122201443,
0.12102741,
-0.0867527351,
0.3785399795,
-0.1081698537,
-0.7123482823,
-0.6760169268,
0.2068939209,
-0.3032470047,
0.5014529824,
-0.0562245809,
0.0345943049,
0.1795903444,
0.3584256768,
-0.3341826797,
-0.0615871437,
-0.2640138268,
0.3244661987,
1.0291856527,
0.2268257439,
0.3288873434,
0.0052260156,
0.0553029366,
-0.4444313347,
-0.4854103327,
-0.0357618667,
0.4093982279,
0.0536387973,
-0.3834341168,
0.4894731939,
0.3093456626,
0.5970969796,
0.0945719555,
-0.1026699543,
0.1476693153,
-0.0448557101,
-0.0188163016,
-0.1372799128,
0.6254374981,
0.2586062849,
-0.3106683791,
-0.2983155549,
-0.16739133,
-0.00334194,
0.5738833547,
-0.6626195908,
-0.1947474629,
0.3349181414,
-1.0606642962,
-0.2876626849,
0.2289983481,
-1.0480420589,
-0.5003902316,
-0.6572668552,
0.0941199362,
0.240714848,
-0.4107899368,
-0.303973794,
-0.5086377263,
0.2102144957,
0.6594253182,
-0.8365542293,
-0.3861571252,
0.5168483853,
0.598741293,
-0.4612164795,
0.1136492565,
-0.2428992689,
0.5155315399,
-0.6204388738,
1.0149679184,
-0.40145123,
-0.9964434505,
0.1944043934,
-0.4357786477,
0.3118700981,
-0.5384928584,
0.8622356653,
-0.2801644206,
-0.0934612826,
-0.1675869524,
-0.1459230632,
0.2973901927,
0.2266789824,
-0.8045618534,
0.4082889557,
-0.1235854179,
-0.6581498384,
0.4404769838,
-0.9151794314,
-0.6540770531,
0.4590802789,
-0.7384821177,
-0.7152071595,
0.5949826241,
-0.0128079085,
0.146963343,
-0.5120489001,
0.2806496918,
-0.2810693979,
-0.2181041092,
0.068440631,
-0.2987161875,
0.6409993768,
0.4278972447,
-0.1894044876,
0.2416106462,
-0.7644428611,
0.074950628,
0.1383599043,
-0.8592233658,
-0.0599327534,
0.168045789,
0.4251517653,
0.1359863132,
0.0774090737,
-0.3980222046,
0.1843394935,
0.0950469077,
0.3862404823,
0.6432106495,
-0.275686115,
0.7573356628,
-0.6468529701,
0.5002583265,
-0.1880599856,
0.3004205823,
-0.2643893957,
-0.6372981668,
-0.7796759605,
-0.0686493739,
0.0928880647,
0.3296025097,
-0.8561195731,
0.3002955317,
-0.4204856455,
-0.6192070842,
-0.6061285138,
-0.046570316,
0.0350332707,
0.3239208758,
0.172719419,
-0.133546412,
-0.1458238363,
-0.7186772227,
-0.1998770684,
-0.5406846404,
-0.3586709499,
0.3975527585,
0.4655645192,
-0.4797125459,
0.5504404306,
-0.4200067222,
-0.5417374372,
0.0238481518,
0.6434419751,
0.1824318171,
0.5178869963,
0.2898589671,
-0.7933164835,
-0.6538211107,
0.212515533,
-1.040623188,
-0.0103873005,
-0.9285658002,
-0.4150111377,
0.1567549407,
0.4798011482,
-0.6431636214,
1.0068683624,
0.0888183564,
-0.1041432247,
0.1854646057,
-0.3298162818,
0.0532221347,
-0.9760500789,
0.5077419281,
-0.1535753459,
0.4413060546,
-0.3902099133,
0.2915447056,
0.0154343527,
-0.473472625,
0.0434894711,
0.8677463531,
-0.6734113097,
0.0402863659,
-0.3328727782,
-0.1006876305,
0.4405499399,
0.1726073921,
0.3370880485,
0.6785937548,
0.0467588566,
-0.3372887075,
-0.0262438152,
0.5076096654,
-0.1745991707,
0.9922677875,
-0.6524682045,
0.2098095715,
-0.5898087621,
0.168235302,
-0.8886570334,
-0.08804176,
0.5086835027,
-0.3753243685,
0.6047356725,
0.1610570401,
-0.6975845695,
-0.6945998669,
-0.1206791922,
0.4497493207,
0.4941738844,
-0.8645979166,
1.1314038038,
0.3568983972,
-0.043084573,
0.1098942533,
-0.8469939232,
0.401197046,
-0.2419674248,
-0.6282706857,
1.0074913502,
-0.3773943186,
-0.3653444648,
0.1673165709,
0.1438916177,
0.2493576258,
-0.0540521666,
0.5438449383,
0.2941089869,
0.0004519753,
0.4138220847,
0.1472610086,
-0.2537250519,
0.1677052528,
-0.1348931044,
-0.0730183497,
0.1490686685,
-0.3470995724,
-0.7583159804,
0.8835330009,
0.6075110435,
-0.2195501924,
0.428850472,
0.4520669281,
-0.3443455994,
-0.062658757,
-0.4052992165,
0.1504153311,
-0.4245688021,
-0.3638155162,
-0.6220832467,
-0.0956491679,
0.4624008238,
-0.2435921282,
0.574619472,
0.5703678727,
0.2575074732,
-0.5301927328,
0.9219884872,
0.7284042239,
0.1280828565,
0.6527069211,
-0.2558152378,
0.2240094095,
-0.8512460589,
-0.5116081834,
-0.671246767,
-0.5060837865,
-0.5555784106,
-0.2092221826,
0.419323802,
-0.0322635062,
0.0354792774,
0.0161602367,
-0.8468008637,
0.2538518906,
0.650462985,
0.216172561,
0.3520422876,
0.4375970662,
0.3436471224,
0.0478706397,
-0.5308906436,
-0.6514670849,
0.8434179425,
0.3875508308,
1.054697752,
0.0431127399,
1.1137230396,
0.3903497458,
1.1352887154,
-0.6492946148,
0.264246583,
-0.3324730098,
-0.3704289794,
-0.0498567708,
0.0133764287,
-0.7372432351,
-0.1348247975,
-0.6609218717,
-0.3401120305,
0.49064219,
0.0531809703,
-0.2758768201,
0.3174588382,
-0.5407939553,
0.4949827492,
-0.5125125647,
-0.7496932745,
-0.2368469387,
-0.3746371865,
0.0787782148,
-0.0208572429,
0.2178128064,
0.3150947392,
0.2587455511,
0.8053313494,
-0.3303010166,
0.9443476796,
0.1742821336,
-0.304862231,
0.6954966187,
-0.2679458261,
0.4442843199,
0.1736752987,
-0.4556728601,
0.2741097212,
-0.1451916546,
-0.3072474003,
-0.6389292479,
0.3492379487,
-0.7865210772,
-0.8397300243,
-0.2153392881,
-0.5037250519,
0.2706054151,
0.185665518,
0.2950999141,
0.1582405716,
-0.2437187433,
-0.0784280896,
0.2441198081,
-0.2696557045,
0.5144348741,
0.0428781696,
0.1229029223,
-0.372426331,
0.6029130816,
-0.1257341355,
-0.2477735877,
0.5224026442,
0.2490970492,
-0.4128480256,
-0.487262547,
-0.839621067,
0.306555599,
-0.7068766356,
-0.1107521802,
-0.0793890432,
-0.317083329,
-0.4543645382,
-0.4564805925,
-0.0534924492,
0.0014384874,
-0.8207191229,
0.2138954401,
-0.1464398205,
0.9629783034,
-0.3051353395,
0.366787672,
-0.7174431682,
0.0651896223,
0.3710276186,
0.4086068571,
0.0318947583,
-0.2829830647,
-0.0151463393,
0.0688564032,
-0.5856118798,
-0.7875733972,
0.1601717919,
0.0164714996,
0.6703469157,
0.6921164989,
0.0332085565,
0.6884268522,
-0.4938182831,
0.3278400004,
0.4241599739,
-0.5666925311,
0.744034946,
-0.4305257797,
0.283645004,
0.4704577327,
0.303873837,
-0.3978078067,
0.105157733,
-0.7845854759,
-0.5514051318,
0.1812985688,
0.0586086884,
0.310760349,
0.02609496,
0.8689691424,
0.190304786,
0.1065355912,
-0.5116483569,
-0.1651416272,
-0.165106684,
-0.1627545059,
0.0399989523,
-0.5110397935,
-0.3504212797,
-0.1272783279,
0.2794117928,
-0.1032596156,
0.7413962483,
-0.0676674694,
0.520663321,
-0.1557832658,
0.1889068633,
0.6869981885,
0.6175694466,
0.2607728541,
0.0558815636,
-0.5063591003,
-0.0187053885,
-0.0366327241,
0.1484328061,
-0.499125123,
-0.0026619062,
0.4373268783,
0.6438318491,
-0.6147322059,
-0.1852067858,
0.1666374505,
-0.2008842975,
-0.3173144162,
-0.4003794193,
-0.1545285434,
0.1239019185,
0.1645490378,
0.080139868,
0.039358791,
0.090879634,
-0.6739584804,
0.1636403352,
0.3463023901,
0.0177494138,
-0.2458520085,
1.2208366394,
0.7951487303,
-0.9261357188,
0.7204847336,
-0.0445035435,
0.1274088472,
0.6024577618,
0.7571436167,
0.9026237726,
0.0669429526,
0.6466587186,
0.4526199698,
-0.1109781787,
0.1016663313,
0.1796948314,
-0.5128117204,
-0.1472223103,
-0.0738536939,
-0.2324497104,
-0.3394513428,
0.0360664316,
-0.8389405608,
0.2530114949,
-0.4459989965,
-0.3331764638,
-0.0254177563,
-0.2758151293,
-0.647585094,
0.1795925349,
0.2640050054,
0.7051542997,
-0.7736135125,
0.4093421102,
0.8752022386,
-0.7694435716,
-0.3937223256,
0.1795859933,
-0.0339387469,
-0.6811799407,
0.5938336253,
-0.0039742892,
0.1578180492,
-0.2123456597,
-0.4054742157,
-0.4357095063,
1.1132190228,
-0.090694353,
-0.7178719044,
-0.0732845366,
0.5211277008,
0.8208707571,
-0.3816740811,
0.142549783,
0.1521454155,
0.476852864,
0.341740787,
-0.276293695,
0.0320094749,
-0.6759991646,
0.0852535143,
0.0869872272,
-0.4426519275,
0.5191857219,
-0.3444769084,
-0.5849041939,
0.1769853383,
0.7720664144,
0.2106647938,
0.5182338953,
0.1193891391,
0.4555531442,
0.8581016064,
0.0790196732,
0.9723217487,
-0.1915700287,
-0.4225124717,
1.0351940393,
0.193873778,
0.7971847653,
0.8564273119,
0.127877906,
0.4962450266,
0.5974271894,
0.0281434078,
0.3860572278,
0.4454829395,
-0.4556129873,
-0.2123490721,
-0.4877788126,
-0.4177291393,
0.2675054371,
0.6028375626,
-0.3506550491,
-0.1861168891,
0.007558025,
-0.191630289,
0.356395483,
-0.1606274098,
0.7094202638,
0.1208647043,
-0.8039447069,
0.0426014923,
-0.1365234405,
0.3576718867,
0.0719420984,
-0.4624011219,
-0.3829122484,
0.2301798016,
-0.2427813709,
-1.0913348198,
0.7633529902,
-0.2423250824,
-0.2730437517,
-0.7715465426,
0.5832815766,
-0.1631905288,
-0.681519866,
0.1150678843,
0.565110743,
0.2172035277,
0.1989056468,
-0.7469208241,
0.4645614922,
-0.1353434175,
0.2844351828,
0.0247713272,
0.3416169584,
-0.1989843547,
0.3992833495,
0.3499900699,
0.0955141485,
-0.4017138481,
-0.0080741066,
0.6451957822,
-0.2591739297,
-0.3605079949,
-0.5456532836,
0.847374022,
-0.2781222165,
-0.3371387124,
0.0811468735,
0.5296073556,
0.6551860571,
-0.1903897375,
1.0614198446,
-0.1832213402,
-0.147120744,
-0.3381953537,
0.9629959464,
-0.724075675,
0.2610406578,
-0.1323830336,
-0.6599953771,
-0.5596709251,
0.6173463464,
-0.1924674213,
-0.2050769776,
0.3861761987,
0.39203915,
0.2861602604,
-0.0116051491,
0.1586687416,
-0.446070224,
0.8932796717,
0.4530898631,
0.5581700802,
-0.499029547,
0.6039330959,
-0.2662929595,
-0.2898512185,
-0.0478025191,
-1.0837013721,
-1.1818832159,
-0.9235756397,
-0.5347473025,
-0.2955884039,
-0.0416149236,
0.2166294008,
0.6094302535,
-0.3885621727,
-0.2311460227,
-0.2534846365,
0.1857342273,
0.0676930174,
-0.1466240883,
0.5335761309,
-0.0252648145,
-0.5568751693,
-0.1504758745,
0.2313958555,
0.452250272,
-0.0209674947,
0.0148775242,
0.4561678171,
-0.2200750262,
0.7057386637,
0.498803854,
-0.5517557859,
-0.2056135386,
-0.1695686281,
-0.0856148526,
0.3710548282,
0.9708380103,
-0.3861169219,
0.4608413279,
0.7643533945,
0.9736654162,
0.4797598124,
0.0473311059,
0.6230761409,
-0.0491748378,
-0.1938414574,
-0.0639445037,
0.0520442203,
0.1999683529,
-0.5420805216,
0.5962033272,
0.0705655292,
-0.4375990033,
-0.3502936065,
0.2705916762,
-0.8403795362,
-0.1678693295,
0.9364019632,
0.0179399531,
-0.3705970645,
0.2294028103,
-0.273614943,
0.1842577904,
-0.2183762342,
1.2916778326,
0.4042042196,
-0.3600558341,
-0.1403831691,
-0.3881308138,
0.4680117369,
0.0103475703,
-1.5960690975,
-0.0663326904,
0.2371907979,
-0.2321923226,
0.6665154696,
0.8484359384,
-0.2182020843,
0.2273263335,
0.3828509152,
0.337238729,
0.1477107853,
-0.4677746892,
0.1273927391,
-0.140506044,
0.3186523914,
-0.2471016049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08115v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08115v2
|
Legally Binding but Unfair? Towards Assessing Fairness of Privacy Policies
| 2024-03-12T22:53:32 | 2024-05-08T14:47:39 |
Vincent Freiberger, Erik Buchmann
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, K.4.m
|
Privacy policies are expected to inform data subjects about their data
protection rights and should explain the data controller's data management
practices. Privacy policies only fulfill their purpose, if they are correctly
interpreted, understood, and trusted by the data subject. This implies that a
privacy policy is written in a fair way, e.g., it does not use polarizing
terms, does not require a certain education, or does not assume a particular
social background. We outline our approach to assessing fairness in privacy
policies. We identify from fundamental legal sources and fairness research, how
the dimensions informational fairness, representational fairness and ethics /
morality are related to privacy policies. We propose options to automatically
assess policies in these fairness dimensions, based on text statistics,
linguistic methods and artificial intelligence. We conduct initial experiments
with German privacy policies to provide evidence that our approach is
applicable. Our experiments indicate that there are issues in all three
dimensions of fairness. This is important, as future privacy policies may be
used in a corpus for legal artificial intelligence models.
|
[
-0.3988328576,
-0.6022464037,
0.7037926316,
0.3819153011,
-0.0623929948,
-0.3968497813,
-0.1626965404,
-0.432523191,
-0.2599616647,
0.4565678537,
-0.348544538,
-0.4149125814,
-0.5761796236,
-0.1530015916,
-0.0587854311,
1.1924874783,
0.175939694,
0.6201590896,
-0.6041787267,
-0.3274398148,
-0.3413516879,
-0.5183880925,
-0.3126224279,
-0.2010327429,
0.3084461391,
0.0744107962,
1.0791227818,
0.6415402293,
0.5790112019,
0.3803070486,
-0.441211015,
-0.5835315585,
-0.3386290669,
-0.3868376017,
-0.5528623462,
-0.5452924967,
-0.5698263049,
0.4601447284,
0.5497252345,
0.8855534792,
-0.3344521224,
0.3698541522,
0.0578710996,
0.8299787045,
-0.7710476518,
-0.0826574638,
-0.1911275536,
0.6402930617,
-0.1125943065,
0.0128268497,
-0.2192599475,
-0.8556329012,
-0.0979131833,
-0.0429732464,
0.2565567195,
0.1729184836,
0.6156672239,
0.2435776144,
-0.7601754665,
-0.2372594029,
-0.5615122318,
0.726221621,
-0.5664215684,
0.6417965889,
0.5483999848,
0.4730224609,
-0.1164325848,
-0.5868195891,
-0.6973351836,
-0.264277637,
-0.1979039758,
0.0607439503,
-0.2452905327,
0.2523266077,
0.7652378082,
0.2441261709,
-0.4020041227,
0.2023861408,
-0.5008999705,
-0.386631757,
0.9140210152,
0.0704459623,
0.0139482347,
-0.2091132998,
0.1108219698,
0.1523643136,
-0.312094152,
0.4280751348,
1.2213983536,
0.0314748809,
-0.1955073625,
0.528434515,
-0.1416688412,
0.5826968551,
0.2150032967,
-0.0609595105,
0.4856255352,
0.0233623907,
0.0265307911,
0.1721107662,
0.582618773,
0.7425612211,
0.3025552034,
-0.5312994123,
-0.1584793925,
-0.2015034854,
0.2520366013,
-0.5072603822,
0.3202869594,
0.4108504951,
-0.9917316437,
-0.4585337639,
0.4169656634,
-0.7827999592,
-0.5438575745,
-0.4242755175,
0.1771576852,
0.3642848432,
0.1041579098,
0.176459983,
-0.1699474901,
0.3380100429,
0.0823976919,
-0.7407331467,
0.521625638,
0.6666525602,
0.1035796255,
0.1084808707,
-0.2294805348,
-0.4931724966,
0.1505005807,
-0.098919481,
0.2022969276,
-0.433009088,
-0.1651996523,
0.2039010525,
0.2631638348,
0.4642173052,
-0.2424236238,
0.6645370722,
-0.5738245845,
0.7795645595,
-0.3782963753,
-0.6655282974,
-0.4797860682,
0.0392713472,
-0.8724240661,
0.2118480802,
0.0408367813,
-0.8465938568,
0.8870218396,
-0.829945147,
-0.661811471,
-0.1668697298,
-0.3323076665,
-0.2857574821,
0.0987078995,
-0.146185711,
0.3659236133,
-0.1117808893,
0.6935309768,
-0.7885474563,
-0.0205966793,
0.5204197764,
-0.6464654803,
1.3040779829,
0.3438945711,
-0.7315694094,
-0.2184666395,
-0.6610018611,
0.188820228,
-0.0346129648,
-0.0444810428,
0.2674494982,
0.0902439803,
0.0738168657,
0.3659952283,
0.6213954091,
-0.5792937875,
-0.2484692186,
-0.2321825325,
0.2343576103,
1.0912678242,
-0.4107033014,
0.9322943687,
-0.2641710639,
0.5883845091,
-0.1323814541,
0.7023581862,
0.7886992693,
-0.3260666132,
-0.0555029251,
0.24402906,
0.75286448,
0.6850116849,
0.0357822925,
0.6844446063,
-0.1945938915,
-0.0619675703,
-0.567915976,
-0.0931486934,
0.3610783219,
0.4462573528,
-0.1450255662,
-0.4356268048,
-0.0288506337,
-1.1622405052,
-0.6186482906,
-0.1398349255,
0.2785601616,
0.6719294786,
0.5671404004,
0.1358904392,
1.1363455057,
-0.2333800346,
-0.2385109663,
0.1494425684,
-0.3127010465,
0.136746645,
0.3303847313,
0.6124488711,
-1.3752539158,
-0.1224687025,
-0.1060898006,
-1.0988395214,
-0.0696446747,
0.2965525389,
0.1076454744,
0.2606366575,
0.0547726452,
-0.1916272789,
0.8185688257,
0.1313239038,
-0.8396871686,
-0.0689153373,
-0.4039561152,
0.4364357591,
-0.1583753526,
0.0322883353,
-0.2087323219,
-0.6893337369,
-0.4597261548,
0.0255439673,
0.0049910895,
-0.1587868035,
-0.8348213434,
0.6384884119,
0.0916057006,
-0.5253152251,
-0.2900276184,
-0.0975138322,
-0.0322510004,
0.4597153664,
-0.4272695482,
0.2867923379,
0.3240772784,
-0.5618109703,
0.1114357561,
0.0502521098,
0.0345527753,
1.0200942755,
-0.1585635245,
0.1087859794,
-0.4456363618,
0.3047419488,
-0.0486975387,
-0.2300114632,
0.623683989,
-0.4773752093,
-0.2682272792,
-0.0672015473,
-0.5261137486,
-0.258335799,
-0.2058362812,
0.5505163074,
0.5406150222,
-0.4445437789,
0.8880655766,
1.0143415928,
0.0331262946,
-0.5858139396,
-0.7748967409,
-0.0072288406,
-0.6625739336,
-0.5120443106,
0.3033166528,
-0.0301828254,
-0.5491960049,
0.4205265641,
0.0532188155,
-0.4462461174,
0.1986784339,
0.4042613804,
-0.1812847704,
0.321403712,
-0.382766515,
0.098480314,
-0.2011137158,
0.297198385,
-0.1987567097,
0.1989243925,
-0.3877578974,
-0.3533361852,
-0.7837613821,
0.3382202983,
0.170645833,
0.1337693185,
0.284466058,
0.3242937624,
-0.5475850701,
0.2851015031,
-0.6369462609,
0.1125571579,
-0.4211719632,
-0.1702345014,
-0.2007195354,
-0.6317206621,
0.8627949953,
0.2746633291,
0.0915751159,
0.4022071064,
0.5299388766,
-0.0769459382,
1.1783913374,
0.9492223859,
-0.0341835096,
0.2043323368,
0.211158812,
0.3540831506,
0.0410847925,
-0.3945665658,
-0.7001993656,
-0.364792645,
-1.2785826921,
0.3544949293,
0.0733472332,
0.1168834269,
-0.3597763777,
-0.0453447774,
-0.3572521806,
0.6267793775,
0.689137578,
0.3691627085,
0.365219444,
-0.1256537884,
0.1734559834,
-0.0331786945,
-0.4765179753,
-0.6329400539,
1.1310675144,
0.4756399095,
0.5710994005,
0.2230584323,
0.7913452983,
0.7420853376,
-0.0110370694,
-0.372525543,
0.5057166815,
-0.4048380852,
-0.6295199394,
-0.189731881,
-0.7472345829,
-0.9388155937,
-0.1119929254,
-0.0880112275,
-0.7733408809,
0.6084271073,
0.2203145176,
-0.0261417013,
0.2088637352,
-0.7907027602,
0.8462897539,
-0.4991350174,
-0.5581872463,
-0.3833975494,
-0.8687076569,
0.2574725151,
0.0483144373,
0.5440207124,
-0.3232395649,
-0.0095276022,
0.8004235625,
-0.4354242384,
0.4038650393,
-0.8012762666,
0.0354780816,
0.1069697291,
-0.1077214703,
0.1115988046,
-0.0061612171,
-0.2500014007,
0.4916594028,
0.2086717635,
-0.4871511757,
-0.784303844,
0.5832742453,
-0.5096399784,
-0.2562033236,
-0.6282516718,
-0.4120744467,
-0.0892850086,
0.3556140363,
-0.0620102473,
-0.012696987,
-0.3865499794,
-0.0179189388,
0.3650218844,
-0.1403731257,
0.1525746733,
0.6754161119,
-0.285269469,
-0.1880306304,
0.9148227572,
0.3148505986,
-0.2499637753,
-0.2436317652,
0.3033919036,
-0.6346040964,
-0.1643636525,
-0.1686965227,
-0.13292256,
-0.9475404024,
-0.0205310937,
-0.4405567944,
-0.0501445644,
-0.5125293732,
-0.0893649682,
0.1108088344,
-0.7069586515,
0.1689230204,
-0.024606647,
0.4510556757,
0.665800333,
-0.769687593,
0.1362143755,
-0.2141398042,
0.6851525307,
0.0654317513,
0.6349347234,
-0.3776654303,
-0.3158868253,
0.3509902954,
0.04409419,
-0.1584342122,
-0.693400383,
-0.191174984,
-0.1476913989,
0.5336396694,
0.2446134686,
-0.1854815334,
0.1567655951,
-0.8593102694,
0.5606523156,
0.0533308536,
-0.9739264846,
0.331712991,
-0.0519308448,
-0.3722829223,
1.0030544996,
0.3553613424,
-0.2063598633,
-0.5353319645,
-1.2413722277,
-0.5961765051,
0.6303723454,
0.1914793253,
0.2458206564,
0.4726346433,
0.4746409059,
0.1601325274,
0.6087240577,
-0.9173363447,
-0.3594589829,
-0.0940392613,
-0.336283952,
0.2860254347,
0.175983116,
-0.3393573463,
-0.1528353542,
0.3642328978,
0.2542161942,
0.1561640501,
-0.3048473597,
0.0424577557,
0.2082520574,
0.3763795495,
0.3032739162,
0.930567205,
-0.2304665446,
-0.1917571276,
0.1001872346,
-0.3192504048,
0.3229012489,
0.5451090932,
-0.6210656166,
-0.0997276679,
-0.2693794668,
0.3562372327,
-0.1669362932,
-0.3764109015,
1.0219479799,
-0.4429888725,
-0.4126914442,
-0.489125371,
0.1776059419,
-0.4345601201,
0.1726659834,
-0.2231695354,
-0.0373886451,
0.6758582592,
-0.3944338858,
0.4389498234,
0.3322803676,
-0.5201326609,
0.182785973,
0.7829737663,
0.1315624118,
-0.5606529713,
0.2621830106,
-0.518007338,
-0.3405310512,
0.5154922009,
-0.0392222553,
0.625231266,
0.1057911068,
0.1433530748,
-0.2854644954,
0.1872103214,
-0.196571663,
0.4335364699,
-0.0783971176,
-0.358281225,
-0.0280718375,
-0.2251596004,
-0.3575999737,
-0.3363670111,
-1.046230793,
0.1386382133,
-0.6020103693,
-0.325512886,
-0.0820809975,
0.2265422046,
-1.1223891973,
0.3843443394,
-0.1893938631,
0.7582654953,
-0.7934138179,
0.2359577864,
0.2665559053,
-0.4255456626,
-0.4014790356,
0.1214782372,
0.1870901138,
-0.8796692491,
0.3564822376,
0.0617139451,
0.0493785441,
-0.4442035854,
-0.7700583339,
-0.2746994793,
0.677642107,
0.7659409642,
-0.5202738047,
0.047281187,
0.6270714402,
0.4266641736,
0.0693350956,
0.1122197658,
0.7547722459,
0.7470033765,
-0.4474301934,
-0.9300596118,
-0.1015060693,
0.0478749238,
-0.3262471259,
-0.0149405459,
-0.5488401651,
0.3323250115,
-0.0641985759,
-0.0580507852,
-0.3148553967,
0.788079381,
0.0165283848,
0.745034337,
0.6438184381,
0.6576982141,
1.1051471233,
-0.0318232402,
1.3203910589,
-0.4410945773,
0.4684134722,
1.0400096178,
-0.5883535743,
0.2519529462,
0.4137643576,
-0.2009373605,
0.2557812333,
0.6161932945,
-0.2188640237,
0.6132318974,
0.3891393244,
-0.1311545074,
0.2587396502,
-0.4366072416,
-0.3115873337,
0.4699516296,
-0.1718031913,
-0.197422415,
-0.3238992989,
0.4323928654,
0.0321280137,
0.4120027125,
-0.568252027,
0.8186440468,
0.0441466048,
-0.4316790104,
-0.4178265333,
0.4542938471,
0.3477695584,
-0.2031511813,
-0.0351268537,
-0.0713822395,
0.0707309991,
-0.4493683577,
-1.2283068895,
0.2584093213,
0.432710737,
-0.2865706682,
-0.4105358422,
0.5290507674,
0.0161734037,
-0.3581950665,
0.2910799086,
0.326939106,
0.409268558,
0.4444798529,
-1.2289936543,
-0.15410842,
-0.0712371394,
-0.1326032579,
0.3581466675,
0.4861571193,
-0.1668245643,
0.5286431313,
0.2897526026,
0.1774786115,
0.1828375608,
0.2796995342,
0.3821360767,
-0.8555212021,
-0.8638013005,
-0.6006193161,
0.4837759733,
-0.2447156608,
-0.164425388,
0.5563236475,
0.5770135522,
0.912645936,
0.6119036674,
0.7415730953,
-0.4417648613,
0.4442356825,
-0.8623982072,
0.6984726191,
-0.4501426816,
-0.0125999907,
0.1441805363,
-1.0151869059,
-0.2158138007,
0.6826899648,
-0.5474254489,
0.6493859291,
0.2583549917,
0.5452134013,
-0.0889609382,
0.1533608735,
0.0352055356,
-0.0738845244,
0.2245607227,
0.2045624107,
0.472867012,
-0.4258897305,
0.306381166,
-0.4598959684,
-0.2582856417,
0.3514517546,
-1.0700235367,
-0.5496558547,
-0.1295832843,
-0.0955273136,
-0.6541463733,
0.0319880769,
0.5743299127,
0.5209076405,
-0.5902438164,
-0.1626101732,
0.018495271,
0.4474335015,
0.1084433571,
-0.3128377497,
0.3440885842,
-0.0874745622,
-0.5054667592,
-0.1936157644,
-0.058558289,
-0.0492774472,
-0.1925756186,
-0.1745265573,
0.3467740119,
-0.2856708169,
0.1856802106,
0.4072796404,
-0.3416362405,
-0.320010066,
-0.6083787084,
-0.3363975883,
0.124597162,
0.9078651071,
-0.3997449279,
0.2543463111,
0.4929911792,
0.5986087322,
0.0996173173,
-0.1074568778,
0.4414467216,
-0.2058004439,
0.4875176251,
0.6377476454,
0.3109959662,
-0.0762245953,
-0.5744550824,
0.3542291522,
-0.2704078853,
-0.6732470989,
-0.9550139904,
0.1535056531,
-0.6618500948,
-0.2826251388,
0.7210725546,
0.0807604119,
-0.4778725505,
-0.1735330522,
0.112135984,
-0.2246752083,
-0.328771472,
0.8115628958,
0.4592624307,
-0.1054628938,
0.4364887774,
-1.0215892792,
0.5560442805,
0.1796939075,
-0.8299920559,
-0.1178990081,
0.5443045497,
0.0956782922,
-0.1029425114,
0.9222860336,
-0.5099122524,
0.5227175951,
-0.5299757719,
-0.1486271024,
0.3995850384,
-0.3093464077,
-0.7900674939,
0.0430667847,
-0.1289601326,
0.2049880475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08111v1
|
AI-Assisted Causal Pathway Diagram for Human-Centered Design
| 2024-03-12T22:36:27 | 2024-03-12T22:36:27 |
Ruican Zhong, Donghoon Shin, Rosemary Meza, Predrag Klasnja, Lucas Colusso, Gary Hsieh
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7
|
This paper explores the integration of causal pathway diagrams (CPD) into
human-centered design (HCD), investigating how these diagrams can enhance the
early stages of the design process. A dedicated CPD plugin for the online
collaborative whiteboard platform Miro was developed to streamline diagram
creation and offer real-time AI-driven guidance. Through a user study with
designers (N=20), we found that CPD's branching and its emphasis on causal
connections supported both divergent and convergent processes during design.
CPD can also facilitate communication among stakeholders. Additionally, we
found our plugin significantly reduces designers' cognitive workload and
increases their creativity during brainstorming, highlighting the implications
of AI-assisted tools in supporting creative work and evidence-based designs.
|
[
-0.6191241741,
-0.6098791957,
0.7352333069,
0.4275619388,
-0.7501698732,
-0.0034830626,
0.2842775881,
-0.6387952566,
0.256983012,
0.2560567856,
-0.9259778261,
-0.5423125029,
-0.2892961204,
-0.0482962765,
0.1695481092,
0.6084797382,
-0.0398818068,
0.2126485109,
-0.1954586059,
0.1971710026,
-0.9531480074,
-0.0979408026,
-0.9803950787,
-0.3157145977,
1.0161926746,
0.6732100248,
0.7288523316,
0.4614325464,
0.5958117247,
0.1663931608,
-0.0422446989,
-0.0617924184,
-0.144778043,
0.2127540112,
-0.2062363178,
-0.152955249,
-0.7143775225,
0.051392924,
-0.1156594977,
0.9299790263,
-0.152586937,
0.2431459278,
0.3661779165,
0.9031370282,
-0.5506107807,
0.4286352694,
0.1674792618,
0.258336097,
-0.3026362956,
-0.2061742395,
-0.4766017199,
-0.2900630832,
0.2015104592,
-0.991209209,
-0.0908838362,
0.031526573,
0.340284586,
0.5314275026,
-0.439984411,
-0.3225394189,
-0.9242694378,
0.2225921601,
-0.6202225089,
0.2060651928,
0.0418559127,
0.3875029981,
-0.2598440349,
-0.6467027068,
-0.2372504771,
0.1113839075,
-0.2961828113,
0.0374864563,
0.0106034055,
0.4902310073,
0.3923006356,
-0.2118807137,
-0.5294569731,
0.3680069745,
-0.4582945108,
-0.0884311646,
0.9002378583,
0.3333990574,
0.5857717395,
-0.0931345448,
-0.2937190235,
0.0248462558,
-0.7743883729,
-0.0187943261,
0.1072697788,
0.1546824574,
-0.2210170329,
0.416970998,
0.025083065,
0.7263199091,
0.0192680359,
0.0351506956,
-0.1350399256,
-0.1704954207,
-0.0946785957,
0.1019712985,
0.6382263899,
0.4679181278,
0.0677312762,
-0.1892875731,
0.1986463666,
-0.1139477193,
0.593940556,
-0.6304312348,
-0.5354396105,
0.1705482304,
-0.6145351529,
-0.1877126843,
0.238721922,
-0.6001111269,
-0.4370743632,
-0.9113895893,
0.3354946375,
-0.0184730366,
-0.0608285442,
-0.2094381899,
-0.4498616457,
0.0727429241,
0.6200493574,
-0.4844164252,
0.0842766389,
0.7149157524,
0.9068844318,
-0.1782194972,
-0.0768893212,
-0.2470145226,
0.3046900928,
-0.4694562256,
0.8333874941,
-0.128318578,
-0.6987926364,
-0.3294955492,
-0.2874767184,
0.2744446397,
-0.4132029414,
0.9482854605,
-0.4695739746,
0.218846038,
-0.4528910816,
-0.396987319,
-0.2946066856,
-0.1473505795,
-0.8089986444,
0.175441131,
0.0136564476,
-0.9816765189,
0.7246193886,
-0.9686121941,
-0.7200892568,
0.270719558,
-0.5782641768,
-0.4774140418,
-0.0223957505,
0.0730424672,
0.432176441,
-0.3713798225,
0.5005597472,
-0.5464111567,
-0.4321578145,
-0.1900385618,
-0.1227513477,
1.3163048029,
0.3766769767,
-0.560346663,
0.687402606,
-0.7868378758,
-0.1558279097,
-0.0970976204,
-0.0754926652,
-0.3092448413,
0.2149564028,
0.1816503555,
0.6326435804,
-0.1928969473,
-0.1487297565,
0.1985536516,
0.1405746937,
0.2403407544,
1.1779714823,
0.3102618456,
0.4693693817,
-0.5602785945,
0.6051923037,
-0.0626032725,
0.4786297977,
-0.0560931712,
-1.1703318357,
-0.7027239799,
-0.2356568277,
-0.3466629088,
0.3393956423,
-0.4909218252,
0.9104840159,
0.2179716825,
-0.5932146907,
-0.3958656788,
-0.0399554893,
0.1528506726,
0.7609516978,
0.1055228934,
-0.5078189969,
-0.3246301413,
-0.7900428176,
0.2068492621,
-0.4186179638,
-0.4245518446,
0.4618657827,
0.1908894777,
-0.2941898704,
0.8405140638,
-0.7830042839,
-0.4971921146,
-0.0059058219,
0.7051259875,
0.1669927537,
0.6535716057,
0.5742061734,
-0.7415410876,
-0.7759928703,
-0.3104940057,
-0.7265190482,
-0.380009383,
-0.49510023,
-0.6965213418,
-0.0984974802,
0.3825866282,
-0.6546444893,
0.8078325987,
-0.0979560614,
-0.7968723774,
0.6117004752,
-0.2884403467,
0.3596045375,
-0.9505868554,
0.543084681,
-0.2377308756,
0.3568468094,
-0.7248674631,
-0.0200402699,
-0.0606293753,
-0.3242450953,
-0.4981475472,
0.2585417926,
-0.2035742849,
0.0254873391,
-0.0842082947,
0.1138176098,
0.1472211182,
0.6753691435,
-0.0782773271,
0.4797536135,
0.5262329578,
-0.63759619,
0.0694848001,
0.4443474412,
0.0188990682,
0.9609337449,
-0.8238810897,
0.2397862226,
-0.290889889,
0.2633644938,
-0.8647229075,
-0.1461903453,
0.5105959773,
-0.3281735182,
0.1002114937,
0.0853105932,
-0.4451083839,
-0.536557436,
-0.3687241375,
0.6011919379,
0.4110896289,
-0.6086864471,
0.5503860712,
0.382540971,
-0.0765993893,
0.1631025374,
-0.5697594285,
0.0217200946,
-0.3545360863,
-1.1922364235,
0.5711137056,
-0.561691761,
-0.4144825637,
-0.132737413,
0.4412467182,
0.0044335076,
0.4684002995,
0.6720543504,
0.5942783356,
-0.1603767872,
0.011300249,
0.1022273675,
-0.3512113392,
0.4646529555,
-0.2198705375,
0.3207519054,
0.4859599471,
-0.7601925135,
-1.3983768225,
0.6521365643,
1.1644564867,
0.1094758213,
0.7449153662,
0.6272614598,
-0.4443507791,
0.1501369476,
-0.2259123474,
-0.0595690459,
-0.4197788537,
-0.4199541509,
0.0292300582,
-0.700514555,
0.6564577222,
-0.1388855875,
0.1860146523,
0.5363563299,
0.3968276978,
-0.2083745599,
1.3955239058,
0.7903186679,
-0.2629300356,
0.5351485014,
-0.2140304595,
0.223136723,
-1.0363222361,
-0.4936524332,
-0.4758565128,
-0.5018949509,
-0.4578229189,
-0.2043422014,
0.5298879147,
0.3670873046,
-0.6115777493,
0.0089463051,
-0.805768013,
0.0650768206,
0.7146804333,
0.1827990562,
0.3012303412,
-0.4819782078,
-0.2086627036,
-0.1551089436,
-0.8051960468,
-0.2525428236,
0.8687211275,
0.1222185269,
0.8282845616,
0.034680672,
0.6994494796,
0.5532011986,
0.723249495,
-0.5961611867,
0.2176572978,
0.464075774,
-0.6195006967,
-0.2861877978,
-0.0206268374,
-0.7813168764,
0.0610788688,
-0.5425959229,
-0.7487311363,
0.5427972078,
0.3773237467,
-0.4831446111,
0.1409450471,
-1.0519076586,
0.7517171502,
-0.316355139,
-0.7347301245,
-0.5899637938,
-0.6821542978,
0.5762789845,
-0.2075715512,
0.1683171839,
0.0999018699,
0.515525341,
0.9254542589,
-0.6527576447,
0.8228676915,
-0.1043455452,
0.1566276401,
0.5354505777,
0.0033347122,
0.4954073429,
0.0118281627,
0.0947399735,
-0.1178312898,
-0.5073563457,
-0.2983474135,
-0.59541291,
0.6161230803,
-0.6236603856,
-0.7609912753,
-0.1268712729,
-0.1911684126,
0.2020759881,
0.3401642442,
0.0685030371,
0.2017636299,
-0.2508886755,
-0.058409892,
0.0506896637,
-0.1957178861,
0.3718099594,
0.0906465948,
0.0999855474,
-0.4033207297,
0.3294712305,
-0.1830490828,
0.2334810197,
-0.0214825962,
0.2777007818,
-0.0812279955,
-0.1143048778,
-0.4821975827,
0.0979291275,
-0.6723748446,
-0.0141064115,
-0.1660172045,
-0.220774129,
-0.5143305063,
-0.7721036077,
-0.0353228673,
-0.4720154405,
-0.83373034,
-0.1022939831,
0.1312480569,
1.1398177147,
-0.2627058923,
-0.0404696763,
-0.6241974235,
0.2703360021,
0.4432215989,
0.2763092816,
0.5859478712,
0.1863577068,
-0.2503259182,
-0.1565020829,
-0.7262373567,
-0.86317873,
0.2058038563,
-0.3310878873,
0.6102759242,
1.0571755171,
0.1831487864,
0.7553616762,
-0.6500620246,
0.6918521523,
0.5321806073,
-0.54921031,
0.8000785112,
-0.3826763332,
0.3139865994,
0.2545740306,
0.7547745705,
-0.6501870155,
-0.1088934988,
-0.7664496899,
-0.7722767591,
0.4667401612,
0.2312306613,
-0.6283810139,
0.093646355,
0.3955239654,
-0.0241207965,
-0.2464386225,
-0.1102927476,
-0.2712007761,
0.0474894457,
-0.1012705639,
0.2410939634,
-0.0122021651,
-0.3471798301,
-0.4849738479,
0.3457497656,
0.0550315082,
0.3066676855,
0.3661598265,
0.2180589736,
-0.4226101041,
-0.0197942406,
0.7264596224,
0.88008672,
0.0075233663,
0.0881942436,
-0.2903203368,
-0.123243399,
-0.0850135535,
0.0266391356,
-0.2104565948,
-0.4487167299,
0.603094995,
0.484434247,
0.0523849949,
-0.3357816041,
0.2753202021,
-0.2851255834,
-0.0448250286,
-0.0041826558,
0.3163587153,
0.0901578143,
0.5160478354,
0.3759797812,
0.1677369773,
0.4326741397,
-0.4077237248,
0.6090300679,
0.4271988869,
-0.399132818,
-0.4053287804,
1.3306567669,
0.5915822983,
-1.0586760044,
0.7664285302,
0.0308821052,
-0.3649774194,
0.7670964599,
0.3812270164,
1.1198816299,
0.1378211677,
0.3915257156,
0.4556839764,
-0.0824481398,
0.3669470549,
0.0456352197,
-0.5629716516,
-0.0868555531,
-0.3355687261,
-0.0614401028,
-0.5177627802,
-0.4385235012,
-0.724747777,
0.5850763917,
-0.5462213159,
-0.2656327188,
-0.0624688864,
-0.1774170101,
-0.558136344,
0.0426589586,
0.2253400534,
0.5920356512,
-0.7808927894,
0.2765079737,
0.4444971383,
-0.7296795845,
-0.6292976141,
-0.1434615552,
0.4414502382,
-0.3198657334,
0.7340952754,
-0.1284579784,
-0.2215752602,
-0.0348299704,
-0.4404402673,
-0.5351643562,
1.6504638195,
-0.0507665873,
-0.2599070668,
0.0571404174,
0.1071482077,
0.6354616284,
-0.409680903,
0.1614200324,
0.0622938164,
0.3855533898,
0.3112886846,
-0.5416387916,
0.3748908639,
-0.2740053535,
-0.1958069503,
-0.0294862576,
-0.5964587927,
0.6757780313,
-0.5643301606,
-0.4908589423,
-0.026556043,
0.5757502913,
0.4388841391,
0.355245024,
0.4350211322,
0.4434840083,
0.7065133452,
0.2629173398,
0.738622129,
-0.5862202644,
0.0814610571,
0.8568053246,
0.2458552867,
0.5226795673,
0.5618296266,
0.1349368244,
0.6520940661,
0.5677062273,
0.3861798346,
0.5520890355,
0.1380075961,
-0.2993224561,
-0.1063734367,
-0.2396901697,
-0.217201367,
-0.3225624859,
0.1536486298,
-0.1953439116,
-0.0637580231,
-0.1536820084,
-0.0645883232,
-0.1528804153,
-0.0980306491,
0.610827446,
0.1355066597,
-0.7546047568,
0.1764876395,
-0.2606653571,
0.2483832389,
-0.1178502589,
-0.3924437463,
-0.2065498084,
0.1055870876,
-0.146127373,
-0.9163455963,
0.419620961,
-0.277760148,
0.2589643896,
-0.4722196758,
0.6228026748,
-0.0451817587,
-0.208942011,
0.3598871231,
0.4190081954,
-0.2917984128,
0.0132081006,
-0.7324709296,
0.0317719243,
-0.261071831,
0.1715695411,
-0.0065431236,
0.5279203057,
-0.2513391078,
0.8148482442,
0.7147606611,
-0.3086306751,
-0.2729764581,
0.4124521613,
1.024113059,
-0.7599485517,
-0.5816460848,
-0.7397950888,
0.9842352271,
-0.1711989194,
-0.375410825,
0.398712337,
0.4080414772,
0.7346704602,
-0.0694133565,
0.3866046667,
-0.0947922319,
-0.0476072878,
-0.3890379369,
1.1136636734,
-0.4745174646,
0.1447551996,
-0.6766496301,
-0.5718000531,
-0.8745221496,
0.639611125,
0.1866337508,
-0.3052058816,
0.7316269875,
0.6048951149,
0.0377310812,
0.1279517859,
-0.0102510378,
-0.1225155741,
0.9882878661,
0.3826146424,
0.8252267241,
0.0334526561,
0.0302816555,
-0.568721056,
-0.4495837092,
-0.3827929199,
-0.7829080224,
-0.9922865629,
-0.849046886,
-0.355210036,
0.0409553908,
-0.270487994,
0.7461476326,
0.8476081491,
-0.3943408728,
-0.3401653469,
-0.6020198464,
0.5923923254,
-0.0006398926,
-0.2678412795,
0.5486577749,
-0.145839259,
-0.1334762871,
-0.1010544747,
0.5439103246,
0.0629471689,
-0.5276275873,
-0.3109840751,
-0.2026625872,
-0.1409671158,
0.760961175,
0.1251428276,
-0.4335492253,
-0.4312128425,
-0.175586164,
0.0310693718,
0.1007904634,
1.3578393459,
-0.5705726147,
0.4690268934,
0.92581141,
0.329723835,
0.2923025787,
0.1347630173,
0.8184575438,
-0.0154417222,
0.1013103724,
0.0576541908,
0.2721492648,
0.0561600737,
-0.5754027367,
0.5488884449,
0.4674602747,
-0.7557208538,
-0.2404755056,
0.0950100273,
-1.0264861584,
-0.2676090598,
0.4824712873,
0.072869502,
-0.2277038097,
-0.3555480242,
-0.6025570631,
0.2682652175,
-0.17698735,
1.1074274778,
0.5060655475,
-0.9595153928,
0.2395940423,
-0.2985623181,
0.4784153998,
-0.0806671679,
-1.0731180906,
-0.1079960316,
0.7659239769,
-0.1049687788,
0.3030958176,
0.7973837256,
0.1333474964,
0.400754869,
-0.1582452953,
-0.0318993963,
0.2082932144,
-0.5850299001,
0.036637146,
-0.1438288391,
0.2828528881,
0.0001392322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08103v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08103v2
|
Contextual Clarity: Generating Sentences with Transformer Models using Context-Reverso Data
| 2024-03-12T22:23:08 | 2024-03-14T10:47:32 |
Ruslan Musaev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the age of information abundance, the ability to provide users with
contextually relevant and concise information is crucial. Keyword in Context
(KIC) generation is a task that plays a vital role in and generation
applications, such as search engines, personal assistants, and content
summarization. In this paper, we present a novel approach to generating
unambiguous and brief sentence-contexts for given keywords using the T5
transformer model, leveraging data obtained from the Context-Reverso API. The
code is available at https://github.com/Rusamus/word2context/tree/main .
|
[
-0.1586705148,
-0.3874458969,
0.5218043327,
0.0486169942,
-0.5505700111,
-0.3237253129,
-0.1932108849,
-0.1048382893,
-0.094235234,
0.7294741869,
-0.8210053444,
-0.7331702709,
-0.3170162141,
0.1349266022,
-0.6960505247,
1.1222612858,
0.2160089165,
-0.4773921072,
-0.1172150597,
-0.3071222305,
-0.8744361997,
0.0721933246,
-0.3041767776,
-0.3760615885,
0.2423844039,
0.9588677287,
0.5311600566,
0.2134683728,
0.1493680328,
0.2146605998,
0.045920115,
-0.0112899328,
-0.5404632092,
0.6113066673,
-0.357336551,
-0.3813627958,
0.0741302744,
-0.4137351215,
0.492357105,
0.8407317996,
0.0510810353,
0.140981704,
0.1755617559,
0.4535143077,
-0.6990911365,
0.0208149459,
-1.3018097878,
-0.1102753803,
-0.0356388055,
-0.2509401143,
-0.5510246158,
-0.0312076081,
0.2129151672,
-0.5371128917,
0.5998610258,
-0.0617833585,
1.158906579,
0.2210898697,
-0.7514876127,
-0.4785420299,
-0.7375094891,
0.5877918601,
-0.8564991355,
0.4032033086,
0.0731864795,
0.3161261082,
-0.0425493717,
-1.3104203939,
-0.7597306967,
0.1022731736,
-0.3040109873,
0.2721392214,
0.1222019345,
-0.0136622535,
0.0503025539,
0.2680178583,
-0.3317472041,
-0.2869648635,
-0.4430899322,
-0.0043618064,
0.3705041707,
0.2534749508,
0.1734363884,
-0.5750650167,
-0.1381785572,
0.0978476107,
-0.7988443375,
0.142541334,
0.2442424893,
0.3929134309,
-0.0490579419,
0.7130717039,
-0.3336595595,
0.4355269372,
-0.0169138871,
-0.2136841267,
0.105059959,
-0.6882271171,
-0.1034428999,
0.0950109214,
0.6626930237,
0.6009864807,
0.0058577866,
-0.6347584128,
-0.3233263195,
0.1815750599,
0.6168945432,
-1.1179456711,
-0.1996180266,
0.2277819663,
-0.5074176788,
-0.6964352727,
0.2487163991,
-0.6715572476,
0.1022754759,
0.0318558514,
0.3816519678,
-0.1390558481,
0.0684325919,
-0.0997129232,
-0.2782563865,
0.4507258534,
-0.220651269,
-0.716234386,
0.0152061991,
0.4651923478,
0.7424048185,
0.1029237434,
0.0081268046,
-0.2346805781,
0.308870852,
-0.2097401172,
0.5477671623,
-0.5962913632,
-0.8882586956,
0.1281145513,
0.1015479192,
0.163855508,
-0.3457698822,
0.8058266044,
-0.5568511486,
0.6280884743,
-0.070102036,
-0.4626924098,
-0.1645391434,
0.1727812737,
-0.4273985326,
0.7275034785,
0.0748128518,
-0.7990548015,
0.53197366,
-0.9055342674,
-0.7970574498,
0.2520595789,
-0.2377786338,
-0.6052197218,
0.315294385,
0.1567647308,
0.3543777764,
-0.1606242657,
0.518845737,
-0.1390450895,
-0.0375187211,
0.2691214979,
-0.3326099813,
0.3736344278,
0.4352909923,
-0.3683326542,
0.1239759326,
-0.625048399,
0.0475388505,
0.1444907635,
-0.1672643274,
-0.2234576195,
0.0960916579,
0.3400216699,
0.2371978462,
0.2073099166,
-0.4508721232,
0.2013198137,
-0.5574777126,
0.8574776649,
0.2548414767,
0.2528958023,
0.5149425864,
0.0977102369,
0.3093364239,
0.2426162958,
-0.0513607152,
-0.7104190588,
-0.4190315604,
-0.5797393918,
0.27227211,
0.4256833792,
0.2760323584,
-0.8797932863,
0.5704851747,
-0.7090570331,
-0.2878543437,
-0.3822316229,
-0.046513591,
0.2360024154,
1.1075359583,
0.1645157486,
0.0260737576,
-0.570713222,
-1.0632369518,
-0.3610310256,
0.1276478469,
-0.209070012,
0.6421981454,
0.424156934,
-0.4369445741,
1.4918620586,
-0.7891551256,
-0.1900599301,
-0.4756402373,
0.3051987588,
0.0846299082,
0.3533990383,
0.3179787993,
-1.2935539484,
-0.2706466019,
-0.2294805944,
-0.4959897101,
-0.3429562449,
-0.1253557056,
-0.0950195938,
0.1309286356,
0.7430062294,
-0.5899438262,
0.414142549,
0.3831607699,
-0.4574857056,
0.0167639777,
-0.0877162293,
0.0458252728,
-2.0162134171,
0.7565712929,
-0.4426029623,
-0.2917089462,
-0.8833397031,
-0.113155663,
0.1220550537,
-0.3534106314,
-0.314694196,
0.4379154146,
-0.2129602432,
0.061603602,
-0.4739557505,
0.4010935724,
0.2270292789,
0.2321480662,
-0.0910123363,
0.6953881979,
0.1793713719,
-0.5729164481,
-0.0965358242,
0.2769104242,
-0.234149307,
0.2765091658,
-0.7942653894,
0.0122089367,
-0.2118289024,
0.3627539575,
-1.3557680845,
-0.5806865692,
-0.1017481312,
-0.5762341022,
0.047814142,
0.0380098224,
-0.5339241624,
-0.294356823,
-0.1542216539,
0.7170228362,
0.594491601,
-0.5904734731,
0.5393310189,
0.3237987161,
0.0753484294,
-0.4564112723,
-0.6630933285,
0.3137117922,
-0.4644607604,
-0.6546037793,
0.7685167789,
0.1133885011,
0.0837512985,
0.1198970675,
-0.0708664358,
0.0362305157,
0.2584086359,
0.3842786551,
0.0941573456,
0.1399492472,
0.3381635249,
0.3045332134,
0.0849307254,
-0.1073983088,
-0.3034051061,
0.6375947595,
-0.0565280542,
0.0675475746,
-0.2198062241,
0.3017917573,
0.5399489403,
-0.0399751551,
0.5189511776,
0.5161989927,
-0.3620787263,
-0.2306187749,
-0.1966188997,
-0.4159604609,
-0.4614023864,
0.2523885369,
-0.509791851,
-0.8480766416,
0.6404861808,
-0.2884202302,
0.2072474062,
0.6224027276,
0.35991624,
0.0427780412,
1.0598931313,
0.7344073057,
0.1528145075,
0.4275465608,
-0.0830327719,
0.6555284262,
-0.7031223178,
-0.2933056355,
-0.3923354447,
-0.4737719595,
-0.8012480736,
0.2543502748,
0.4247922003,
0.4650580883,
0.0682620853,
0.4975164235,
-0.6489111185,
0.3707380295,
0.506421268,
-0.1184599623,
0.2509563565,
-0.1886452138,
-0.1239990667,
0.1189116687,
-0.6746093035,
-0.6868451834,
1.0490672588,
0.0512323603,
0.5085489154,
0.0319973156,
0.6088843346,
0.0441930257,
0.1495630592,
-0.8694786429,
0.5349931121,
-0.2447802424,
-0.4874891341,
-0.0152917178,
-0.2035038024,
-1.2273521423,
-0.0002618118,
-0.2360450029,
-0.7148795724,
-0.0765586123,
0.1445027888,
-0.4040764868,
0.041742295,
-0.6829769015,
1.1276152134,
0.2323332131,
-0.1045453325,
-0.0372166187,
-1.1512613297,
0.3020015657,
0.0113971056,
-0.1009455323,
0.1190060303,
-0.1937610954,
0.5567079186,
-0.5738384724,
0.669849515,
-0.1322970539,
0.110461697,
0.4918805063,
-0.0300369319,
0.4792038798,
0.2902069092,
0.4453526437,
-0.1057221666,
-0.2237902135,
0.009256592,
-0.5335358977,
0.681274116,
-0.3342117667,
-0.2523714006,
0.2259757966,
-0.6677324772,
-0.198284179,
0.5420550108,
0.7512543201,
0.4707703888,
-0.1946873963,
0.6035482883,
0.424035579,
0.0262671616,
0.7640191913,
0.3615970314,
-0.0752101168,
-0.4833894074,
0.5925861001,
-0.0241514537,
0.0219830628,
0.4682562053,
0.2694405913,
-0.5596597791,
-0.265960902,
-0.294213742,
-0.007275267,
-0.5305294394,
-0.3313287795,
-0.6926546693,
-0.0963323638,
-0.711812079,
-0.3407344818,
-0.1216325238,
-0.4938182831,
-0.3145194948,
0.0320554152,
0.0452820957,
0.7008314133,
0.4490157664,
0.6645380259,
-0.7039192319,
0.4444756806,
0.1858877391,
0.0097865732,
-0.310338676,
-0.4929204881,
-0.0436660163,
0.0620632283,
-0.5671060681,
-0.96553725,
0.3887971342,
0.139853254,
0.1128157601,
0.4982567728,
0.1953558475,
0.5641780496,
-0.4681092203,
1.1605042219,
0.2068894953,
-1.1462901831,
0.9398190379,
-0.1874804199,
0.8424906731,
0.7993232608,
-0.1080334559,
-0.8314039111,
-0.3304065466,
-0.9658446312,
-1.3958660364,
0.5475296974,
0.4938309193,
0.2257854044,
0.0588014759,
0.4860556126,
0.1733483225,
0.5569387078,
-0.7151876688,
-0.0792594403,
-0.5831022263,
-0.7104398608,
-0.007682893,
-0.2274855077,
-0.1295083761,
0.3240840435,
0.606795907,
-0.4289152324,
0.0911340564,
0.2623241246,
-0.2477430999,
0.213444829,
0.629755199,
1.0640007257,
0.2831475735,
0.0569814891,
0.3319246769,
0.2228771448,
-0.4701904356,
-0.251830101,
-0.0918831378,
-0.5418900847,
0.2437732071,
0.2913243771,
0.8398413062,
0.3708257973,
-0.7341207266,
0.6684181094,
-0.0993153751,
-0.1173971072,
-0.2935629785,
-0.0434336737,
0.1481094956,
0.1483183354,
0.297093302,
0.0435225554,
0.3600513935,
-0.4535578787,
0.15202941,
0.4749470651,
-0.1559449285,
-0.4939343929,
0.7800693512,
0.3375966847,
-0.1928679496,
0.8419852257,
-0.0832671896,
-0.4563633204,
0.4214445949,
0.6897435188,
1.2904651165,
0.0706696957,
-0.1769129485,
0.3460096121,
0.0364596061,
0.0922318771,
0.2296229601,
-0.5879049897,
-0.7704450488,
-0.0853719339,
-0.3542021811,
-0.0248384122,
0.2756153047,
-0.6016097069,
0.3783374131,
-0.035074167,
-0.2556520402,
-0.1598480195,
-0.237791568,
-0.5813218951,
0.3315303028,
0.0370242335,
0.7825401425,
-0.8569020629,
0.8367384076,
0.6755886674,
-0.3438687325,
-0.8641693592,
0.2723387182,
-0.5574192405,
-0.4928537309,
0.5611852407,
0.4890531301,
-0.1657560021,
-0.0272258278,
-0.7781200409,
-0.4779880941,
1.5398589373,
0.0752184242,
-0.4194533825,
-0.4002366662,
0.5070679784,
0.4992977381,
-0.7256227732,
0.0744182467,
0.3891689777,
0.4292518795,
0.3175472021,
-0.76507622,
0.0894728154,
-0.1362124383,
0.435205251,
0.1535477638,
-0.4065463245,
0.5110710263,
-0.2425231934,
-0.7147591114,
0.0890253261,
0.8130824566,
0.0059972932,
0.378349036,
0.5806578398,
0.6974256039,
0.4203337729,
-0.1444716007,
0.7083220482,
-0.8606311679,
0.5553981662,
1.2668261528,
-0.0423805602,
0.7322660089,
0.6862656474,
0.4726726115,
0.3827299476,
0.3583738208,
0.1254138499,
0.9281061888,
-0.2562316656,
-0.3471433818,
-0.0697938204,
-0.3437132835,
-0.1139351428,
0.5161750317,
0.2514593303,
-0.7125678062,
-0.381244123,
-0.0818433613,
0.067301333,
0.0539903268,
-0.2511534691,
0.928494513,
0.1508049071,
-0.8784494996,
0.1626271456,
0.1248185039,
0.6853649616,
-0.4532658458,
0.050411094,
-0.2424117178,
0.211162895,
-0.3967694044,
-1.0142698288,
0.5490037799,
-0.0778722614,
-0.3100202978,
-0.210851565,
0.9457199574,
-0.7608411908,
-0.3062163889,
-0.1827427745,
0.1333892792,
-0.0801158473,
0.0628793091,
-0.4042826295,
-0.131981805,
0.0333976261,
-0.1030668765,
-0.4065362513,
0.4182573557,
0.1038214564,
0.454962492,
0.2850063741,
-0.3822490275,
-0.092957899,
0.2745000422,
0.6201854348,
-0.7342128158,
-0.4796453714,
-0.7688820958,
0.6597386003,
-0.1317903399,
-0.6213729978,
0.5756981373,
0.6993851066,
0.7902969122,
-0.1550426185,
0.7873094678,
-0.3342352211,
0.2854588628,
-0.2192118615,
0.7261840701,
-0.6489097476,
-0.005825242,
0.0256679207,
-0.7734822631,
-0.2328495532,
0.1625441313,
-0.0995916426,
0.1488008946,
0.6237851977,
0.8589461446,
-0.2184723616,
0.1097591817,
0.2742346823,
0.1978808641,
0.4856400788,
0.3899661005,
0.3022347987,
-0.9086247683,
0.7073025703,
-0.2033471614,
0.3447865546,
-0.2653081417,
-0.8085821271,
-0.7516052127,
-0.9930140972,
-0.0969868824,
-0.5743683577,
-0.2257246226,
0.6604909301,
0.5336580873,
-0.7425203323,
0.032079,
-0.7175528407,
-0.0256566089,
0.1665252,
-0.3324210644,
0.2104793787,
-0.5497742891,
-0.7265007496,
0.3640364707,
0.013708394,
0.0585783795,
-0.0569275804,
0.0553767569,
0.1711665392,
0.1102243736,
0.6708819866,
0.03860569,
-0.7436796427,
-0.5026887059,
-0.0717818886,
-0.1786696017,
-0.0328357629,
1.1151739359,
-0.9460270405,
0.4486118257,
0.8044722676,
0.4133052528,
0.4206944704,
0.2473783493,
0.5033656955,
-0.9947574735,
-0.0858746096,
0.1455049068,
0.3086080551,
0.4072601199,
-0.1714803725,
0.4943223298,
0.343537271,
-0.4554113448,
-0.8835365176,
0.5151364207,
-1.0863603354,
-0.4094204009,
1.1378432512,
0.2804790735,
-0.2586334646,
0.1579172164,
-0.1620356888,
0.5650171041,
-0.2865612209,
0.7526048422,
0.4498480856,
0.1907989383,
0.0334147476,
-0.2247996628,
0.4513541162,
0.4698028564,
-0.7378389239,
-0.0485712327,
0.3217297494,
0.5217248797,
0.2289188355,
0.1817636639,
-0.0726399273,
-0.0294218808,
0.0091632651,
0.198574096,
0.1100491509,
-0.3636688292,
-0.2162236124,
0.5713047981,
-0.184280023,
-0.2347423583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09728v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09728v1
|
Simulating Weighted Automata over Sequences and Trees with Transformers
| 2024-03-12T21:54:34 | 2024-03-12T21:54:34 |
Michael Rizvi, Maude Lizaire, Clara Lacroce, Guillaume Rabusseau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CC
|
Transformers are ubiquitous models in the natural language processing (NLP)
community and have shown impressive empirical successes in the past few years.
However, little is understood about how they reason and the limits of their
computational capabilities. These models do not process data sequentially, and
yet outperform sequential neural models such as RNNs. Recent work has shown
that these models can compactly simulate the sequential reasoning abilities of
deterministic finite automata (DFAs). This leads to the following question: can
transformers simulate the reasoning of more complex finite state machines? In
this work, we show that transformers can simulate weighted finite automata
(WFAs), a class of models which subsumes DFAs, as well as weighted tree
automata (WTA), a generalization of weighted automata to tree structured
inputs. We prove these claims formally and provide upper bounds on the sizes of
the transformer models needed as a function of the number of states the target
automata. Empirically, we perform synthetic experiments showing that
transformers are able to learn these compact solutions via standard
gradient-based training.
|
[
-0.3921232522,
-0.6637603641,
0.7734860182,
0.147042349,
0.1136442721,
0.1366177797,
-0.0823737904,
-0.3071647584,
-0.0154245151,
0.1051375419,
-0.6749439836,
0.0403518118,
-0.5166913867,
0.381021589,
-0.8914811611,
0.6865393519,
-0.1064706445,
-0.0668099448,
-0.1691776961,
-0.1806035191,
-0.231965512,
-0.3633155823,
-0.5305619836,
-0.6794926524,
0.4169992208,
-0.0072570918,
0.905375421,
0.3480445743,
0.4386411011,
0.5277586579,
0.0544860475,
-0.1656527966,
-0.0430494025,
0.1233293116,
0.0075890846,
-0.7536844611,
-0.0422966294,
0.2999875844,
0.6753717065,
0.708427012,
-0.3811560869,
0.2731497884,
-0.3049054444,
0.4242688417,
-0.4421673119,
0.1244952902,
-0.5687173009,
0.381704092,
0.1477220207,
-0.1859813631,
-0.7730561495,
-0.2746078968,
0.0613578111,
-0.6258215308,
0.1638402939,
-0.0236607213,
0.7663086653,
0.8305640221,
-0.459328115,
-0.119988367,
-1.3317419291,
0.8477274776,
-0.7793243527,
0.244363144,
0.0596696958,
0.5125871301,
-0.1935133487,
-0.8776606917,
-0.7759726644,
-0.2086078227,
-0.4781256616,
0.0341202542,
-0.6379144788,
0.1976061314,
0.8704749942,
0.4100926816,
-0.4549563825,
0.1288589835,
0.050698746,
0.1378410012,
0.4962192178,
0.2177171856,
0.1415686011,
-0.1052088663,
-0.2956947684,
-0.4433553517,
-0.0975319296,
0.1153148934,
0.2803635001,
-0.0608882494,
-0.089425765,
0.5794752836,
-0.0399848968,
0.7502751946,
0.2548352778,
-0.199512288,
0.0482631549,
0.024341587,
-0.6497991681,
-0.2759171128,
0.8510250449,
0.0354119092,
0.6695114374,
-0.2620509267,
-0.2243018746,
0.2312733531,
0.3402270675,
-0.8959553242,
-0.0838806257,
0.2521297932,
-0.5780726075,
-0.2198597342,
-0.1991401315,
-0.4518983364,
0.0246299766,
-0.5066602826,
0.5394134521,
-0.3636414409,
-0.0909571648,
0.2666952312,
-0.2762500346,
0.4003059566,
0.1616912484,
-0.929948926,
0.6994553208,
0.6671661735,
0.5984094739,
0.130313009,
-0.1915960759,
-0.3621806502,
-0.2527550757,
-0.2769845426,
0.4639043212,
-0.5265726447,
-0.2745344341,
-0.1042385101,
-0.3167832792,
-0.1726738214,
-0.3694030941,
0.3218334317,
-0.5328646302,
0.2771945298,
-0.0769121796,
-0.4502128363,
-0.1606843323,
0.0932863206,
-0.7923668027,
0.9746312499,
0.4069615006,
-0.8350045085,
0.4345851839,
-0.5277250409,
-0.7917521,
-0.2512173057,
-0.0763339475,
-0.3285260797,
0.3849598765,
0.0059651616,
0.317085892,
-0.5039083362,
0.5147118568,
-0.2393815964,
-0.545632422,
0.126950264,
-0.6534442306,
0.8278279901,
0.3352227807,
-0.6135095954,
0.10251946,
-0.5370443463,
-0.0971317291,
0.2479851097,
0.0308920778,
-0.3214331269,
0.1826410443,
-0.1733954847,
0.3777435124,
-0.0235240981,
-0.7898167372,
0.5258159041,
-0.3545539081,
0.4687697291,
0.4566985369,
-0.2065771371,
0.7393653393,
-0.3375036716,
0.5457493663,
-0.0310762338,
0.2059109062,
0.0816266015,
-0.4934912622,
-0.8232658505,
-0.1302478611,
0.4307614267,
0.5000827312,
-0.8158242106,
0.4592064619,
-0.255653888,
-0.5414993763,
-0.396281153,
-0.4836181104,
-0.0736011788,
0.3960174918,
0.4702615142,
-0.2716650963,
-0.606972158,
-0.8572428226,
-0.1570612341,
-0.1728451997,
-0.3860363662,
0.024922939,
0.5952605009,
0.00036296,
1.3647624254,
-0.4819415808,
-0.2307507396,
-0.1974178553,
0.3618491888,
0.2015123218,
0.3779834807,
0.6169244647,
-0.6823545694,
-0.2216161191,
-0.4035740793,
-0.6739241481,
0.2031219602,
-0.527674675,
0.2845726609,
-0.0565222874,
0.3912290037,
-0.9371241927,
0.4685178101,
0.6188934445,
-0.2796005607,
0.3560771048,
-0.1762896031,
-0.1426475048,
-0.9938911796,
0.1361898482,
0.0020725196,
-0.4153937101,
-0.4806570709,
0.0594059564,
-0.3118178844,
-0.0216732547,
-0.0090401527,
0.4017121494,
-0.0710703954,
-0.356684953,
-0.3502677679,
-0.2513162196,
-0.117480211,
0.7125185728,
0.0576198697,
0.7559530139,
0.5335066319,
-0.5388765931,
0.1550642103,
0.0317354128,
-0.3575284779,
0.4547879696,
-0.8567367792,
-0.3867420852,
-0.3362608552,
0.7402158976,
-0.6705770493,
0.1409391016,
-0.2516809702,
-0.236439243,
0.1467105001,
0.0131324027,
-0.7136361003,
-0.627631247,
0.0073498245,
0.4366998076,
1.0175030231,
-0.4860910177,
1.1832660437,
0.2213946581,
0.5032118559,
-0.627335608,
-0.6307653785,
-0.1682953537,
-0.2088716477,
-0.1721763015,
0.44288221,
-0.0989001542,
-0.366509527,
0.0402569771,
-0.0432501771,
0.0552547351,
0.5575293303,
0.4261161685,
-0.2317835093,
-0.0218657311,
0.0582995266,
-0.1635832042,
-0.177317366,
0.13237378,
-0.5418376327,
0.7179021239,
-0.259080857,
-0.5272275805,
-0.6179945469,
0.256111443,
0.691175282,
-0.3269819915,
0.7181097865,
0.6559843421,
-0.6727320552,
-0.4337012172,
-0.1784337312,
-0.5031788349,
-0.5227857828,
0.1027319059,
-0.5096488595,
-0.7208923101,
0.4062075913,
-0.1057593301,
0.5943551064,
0.6762008071,
0.6642096639,
-0.1845029742,
1.230764389,
0.6308355927,
-0.0980798602,
0.319709301,
-0.5302339196,
0.1767231673,
-0.4648722112,
-0.0070602633,
-0.5877274275,
-0.825302124,
-0.6287496686,
-0.6161864996,
0.1702806056,
-0.2225289196,
-0.4128135741,
0.6235385537,
-0.3193969131,
0.3638924956,
0.5956285596,
-0.2873538136,
0.3417482078,
-0.097628437,
-0.3577762246,
0.2256490886,
-0.7149989605,
-0.3032787144,
0.4758783579,
0.3803982139,
0.6460587978,
-0.2215531915,
0.532089293,
0.2608329058,
0.6971213222,
-1.0041334629,
0.5338275433,
-0.2617104948,
-0.575438261,
-0.4020014703,
-0.7348457575,
-0.9549096227,
0.1323135644,
-0.0924346894,
-0.3529169559,
0.1826927513,
0.054551471,
-0.4038924575,
0.7108269334,
-0.3555312753,
0.5237965584,
0.1369849294,
0.3493334949,
-0.335906595,
-0.475363642,
0.4185596704,
0.0398894958,
0.1968822926,
-0.1113356575,
0.1362768263,
0.5205132961,
-0.6351524591,
0.820096314,
-0.3357904255,
-0.3732757568,
0.5295510292,
0.3359935582,
0.3779357672,
-0.1099385619,
-0.1021430343,
-0.0696840137,
-0.1493074745,
-0.2893844247,
-0.8666009307,
0.3206008971,
-0.5666052699,
-0.4298256636,
-0.4366146624,
-0.7211678028,
-0.2802933753,
0.0129948258,
-0.0124006411,
0.4168848693,
-0.0140934326,
0.0721425042,
0.3764221072,
0.0747799054,
0.8028506041,
0.4459162652,
-0.0540173016,
0.0293578487,
0.4644772708,
0.1098259389,
0.1732131541,
0.6081333756,
0.3299481869,
-0.1212854013,
-0.3309977353,
-0.5369275808,
-0.1191006601,
-0.4242593944,
-0.2987918556,
-0.630500257,
-0.2572361827,
0.2034903169,
-0.0374775529,
-0.2929106057,
-0.8283728957,
0.1679520458,
-0.243575722,
0.5217702985,
0.8517374396,
0.0846664757,
0.4111178815,
-0.5015733838,
0.3474033475,
0.5807908773,
0.60312289,
0.5268531442,
-0.375364691,
0.0773749501,
0.0009135857,
-0.1006876901,
-0.5723521113,
0.1929049343,
0.1247509792,
0.3032106161,
0.1744384766,
-0.0093342764,
0.6317752004,
-0.9717278481,
0.5728501081,
-0.0154014342,
-0.8006547689,
-0.1328357458,
-0.1769418269,
0.3532244861,
0.5575321913,
0.5309233665,
-0.3767630458,
-0.4361808896,
-0.8078300357,
-0.3142577112,
0.3598102927,
0.3969082236,
0.2041825801,
-0.1179327071,
0.2787957191,
-0.2756416798,
-0.0232939404,
-0.6586524844,
-0.348834157,
-0.1309252381,
-0.6263180971,
0.0386722907,
0.2077010274,
0.0955759138,
-0.1977071315,
0.4932130277,
-0.2132485509,
0.0785436332,
0.3026805818,
0.0180086438,
-0.2218340188,
-0.0265876055,
0.3821272552,
0.0059742816,
0.113126494,
0.1927892715,
0.3247103989,
-0.4088808596,
0.4769492745,
0.0263095219,
-0.5526044369,
0.0282775071,
0.280087173,
0.6408810616,
0.4763764143,
-0.6985828876,
0.3623532951,
-0.4421550333,
-0.3381801844,
-0.340873301,
0.0180413201,
0.3236257732,
0.1572619975,
0.5546731353,
0.4519964755,
0.0287912209,
-0.5037229657,
0.5619779825,
0.5817826986,
-0.4442048073,
-0.277097553,
0.8218875527,
0.0375857018,
-0.4164427221,
0.6352673769,
-0.2284460515,
-0.4713645577,
0.8255562186,
0.4240318537,
0.7911710143,
-0.0258071795,
0.1372750551,
0.6144381166,
0.4602482319,
-0.2451096624,
0.1255219132,
-0.1896629333,
-0.6312007308,
-0.7988189459,
-1.0387564898,
-0.3675290644,
-0.1950983405,
-0.4500552714,
0.0351970792,
-0.5898344517,
-0.3680909574,
-0.0285983607,
-0.094784297,
-0.7019244432,
0.2099094987,
0.1078551561,
1.2408618927,
-0.8816084862,
0.8201113939,
0.1327675283,
-0.272572875,
-1.0157353878,
0.1343892664,
-0.3508313,
-0.5887490511,
0.4568453729,
0.197847113,
-0.1232866645,
0.232754752,
-0.3076638579,
-0.9555830956,
1.0161044598,
0.3372919261,
-0.4612162709,
-0.2960760295,
0.1458611339,
0.7367540598,
-0.0941835046,
0.5316309333,
0.7138569355,
0.5178931355,
0.0160255693,
-0.9755433798,
-0.0224691164,
0.0334022678,
-0.154303208,
0.235082984,
-0.6033601761,
0.9353585839,
-0.2914610505,
-0.3470754325,
0.2701137364,
0.8734571934,
0.1122487187,
-0.1687104404,
1.0280774832,
0.9956598878,
0.481993109,
-0.1639325619,
1.3671678305,
-0.1724824458,
0.3533053398,
0.9973033071,
-0.5429452062,
0.7255465388,
0.1962328702,
-0.4642256498,
1.0933469534,
0.3302953541,
-0.226614356,
0.0099033806,
0.4699357748,
-0.1472200453,
-0.2819102705,
-0.0493134148,
0.0856183618,
0.7836324573,
0.0888742059,
-0.0993007049,
-0.3673201501,
-0.0347961783,
-0.1687826067,
0.2782752514,
-0.2336328477,
0.7066682577,
0.0839879662,
-0.6752021909,
0.4898376763,
0.357960254,
0.7702605724,
-0.6641403437,
-0.0182209872,
0.0396989472,
0.0506282225,
-0.1749492586,
-0.4808497727,
0.5085820556,
0.0586593747,
-0.1602829397,
-0.5414429903,
0.4157709777,
-0.2930208743,
-0.6464980841,
0.1553772688,
0.2463700175,
-0.0752225295,
0.1123741418,
-0.4268551171,
-0.5043340325,
-0.4163905084,
-0.3809110224,
0.2049511671,
0.2872050703,
-0.1973578185,
0.8255331516,
0.5338512063,
-0.1543444544,
0.1030666232,
0.3495773077,
0.5257293582,
-0.4274713695,
-0.2768649757,
-0.9100302458,
0.3193078041,
0.01237363,
0.1216439828,
0.6828644276,
0.54586941,
0.7104857564,
-0.2218480557,
0.431384176,
-0.2447256893,
0.2020686269,
-0.3171040118,
0.5606509447,
-0.5019470453,
-0.3004213572,
-0.0474896431,
-0.7829598784,
-0.1883965284,
0.645209074,
0.0107806427,
0.2805695236,
0.5609964132,
0.166831702,
-0.1360833645,
0.2012197822,
0.2391135097,
0.2557436526,
0.2780646384,
0.697611928,
0.5932838321,
-0.4901633859,
0.4213245213,
-0.4362764955,
-0.1129763648,
0.1571594775,
-0.8478551507,
-0.7627133131,
-0.6627907753,
0.0774009004,
-0.0527129956,
-0.6893717051,
0.7950175405,
0.7488345504,
-0.7913493514,
-0.115293324,
-0.3974303603,
0.3284008801,
-0.4299943745,
-0.2032954544,
0.0822302774,
-0.301148355,
-0.9227083921,
0.3795666397,
0.0575456433,
0.3081282377,
-0.6691505313,
0.1394377947,
-0.1531500071,
0.4043075442,
0.6505768895,
0.1662050635,
-0.4817119241,
-0.2346325517,
0.0205112267,
-0.1224277169,
-0.1783496439,
1.1543263197,
-1.4754152298,
-0.1066764593,
0.4821363688,
0.5651556253,
0.3591404259,
0.1336136162,
0.732303381,
-0.8758733869,
0.3286960423,
0.4437725842,
0.6387700438,
0.13708435,
0.0136329606,
0.4361475408,
0.0878039151,
-0.2284305096,
-0.7112799287,
0.6772591472,
-0.6591085792,
-0.2836821079,
0.783339262,
0.0749081299,
-0.0216999948,
0.0617345013,
0.1612881124,
0.3102225661,
0.1322937161,
0.6603743434,
0.3410098851,
0.1084478199,
0.2265451401,
-0.3626128435,
0.7614602447,
0.5938627124,
-0.7067236304,
0.1179944575,
0.0477790572,
0.22359474,
0.3500876427,
0.4762433171,
-0.0252455883,
0.1294589788,
-0.0334246755,
-0.0328377523,
0.1126461998,
-0.5543066859,
-0.3755836189,
0.3109216988,
-0.0633830801,
0.2723931968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08081v1
|
Mechanics of Next Token Prediction with Self-Attention
| 2024-03-12T21:15:38 | 2024-03-12T21:15:38 |
Yingcong Li, Yixiao Huang, M. Emrullah Ildiz, Ankit Singh Rawat, Samet Oymak
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC
|
Transformer-based language models are trained on large datasets to predict
the next token given an input sequence. Despite this simple training objective,
they have led to revolutionary advances in natural language processing.
Underlying this success is the self-attention mechanism. In this work, we ask:
$\textit{What}$ $\textit{does}$ $\textit{a}$ $\textit{single}$
$\textit{self-attention}$ $\textit{layer}$ $\textit{learn}$ $\textit{from}$
$\textit{next-token}$ $\textit{prediction?}$ We show that training
self-attention with gradient descent learns an automaton which generates the
next token in two distinct steps: $\textbf{(1)}$ $\textbf{Hard}$
$\textbf{retrieval:}$ Given input sequence, self-attention precisely selects
the $\textit{high-priority}$ $\textit{input}$ $\textit{tokens}$ associated with
the last input token. $\textbf{(2)}$ $\textbf{Soft}$ $\textbf{composition:}$ It
then creates a convex combination of the high-priority tokens from which the
next token can be sampled. Under suitable conditions, we rigorously
characterize these mechanics through a directed graph over tokens extracted
from the training data. We prove that gradient descent implicitly discovers the
strongly-connected components (SCC) of this graph and self-attention learns to
retrieve the tokens that belong to the highest-priority SCC available in the
context window. Our theory relies on decomposing the model weights into a
directional component and a finite component that correspond to hard retrieval
and soft composition steps respectively. This also formalizes a related
implicit bias formula conjectured in [Tarzanagh et al. 2023]. We hope that
these findings shed light on how self-attention processes sequential data and
pave the path toward demystifying more complex architectures.
|
[
-0.2322288305,
-0.4798718989,
0.632481277,
0.0381618813,
-0.0029935851,
0.0387263373,
0.0021008295,
-0.3629474938,
0.2579084337,
0.4510556757,
-1.0219253302,
-0.3236807287,
-0.5009159446,
0.1020946875,
-0.6030623317,
1.2099840641,
-0.0303798635,
-0.1954660714,
-0.229382053,
-0.0502767488,
-0.5383219719,
-0.6571928263,
-0.6775160432,
-0.2809025943,
0.7328578234,
0.2586160004,
0.4939748645,
1.1427849531,
0.5464513898,
0.4183870852,
0.0636433363,
-0.6231374741,
-0.4857282043,
0.3447610736,
-0.1558014303,
-0.5266996622,
-0.3160946071,
0.1831346601,
0.6789318323,
0.7037647963,
0.1425047219,
0.2537586093,
0.1994587034,
0.5980784297,
-0.4040691555,
0.353715837,
-0.5206474066,
0.4217913151,
-0.3286868036,
-0.1424099505,
-0.2361172587,
0.2961292863,
0.1034647748,
-0.358717829,
0.4873414636,
0.0515172482,
0.4819058776,
0.6664529443,
-0.3886891007,
-0.0239699781,
-0.6268321276,
0.6169036031,
-0.2889100611,
0.4700359702,
0.2796589434,
0.2632161975,
-0.0443694666,
-1.0844087601,
-0.4624269009,
-0.20403862,
-0.0464942195,
0.27025792,
0.0894135609,
0.2684946358,
0.2376753539,
0.343318224,
-0.5353189111,
0.2053871155,
-0.3775424361,
-0.3592769206,
0.3323401809,
0.3378653526,
0.0373213515,
-0.2253948897,
-0.8177967072,
-0.1346232444,
-0.5123721361,
0.0840708539,
0.2382964939,
0.2417630106,
-0.0756187439,
0.5601618886,
-0.2164937407,
0.4118660986,
0.5293198824,
0.1524722576,
0.3373122215,
-0.4326432347,
-0.2033167183,
0.1040572971,
0.8844385147,
-0.0156924892,
0.2389653921,
-0.2396686226,
-0.3073788285,
-0.0994788259,
0.3978014588,
-0.624486506,
-0.2261092812,
0.2842124104,
-0.6405307055,
-0.3780899644,
-0.0898825005,
-0.392940551,
-0.0607264899,
-0.5213151574,
0.3608798683,
-0.1012184694,
-0.2076559812,
-0.0698072761,
0.3308296204,
0.1774941683,
-0.0969941765,
-1.1072095633,
0.2877017558,
0.7508247495,
0.9060236812,
-0.37488693,
-0.6089516878,
-0.7400467992,
0.1065309644,
-0.1858603805,
0.9148654938,
-0.4306555688,
-0.0863383338,
-0.0423617922,
0.0724984258,
-0.2278394997,
-0.2102981359,
0.5046354532,
-0.4875499308,
0.3017393649,
-0.2213384956,
-0.5275204778,
-0.048295524,
0.011466925,
-0.7189508677,
1.0840237141,
-0.0397711657,
-0.8450452089,
0.275442034,
-0.6673581004,
-0.7817429304,
-0.0122706117,
-0.195514366,
-0.3532671332,
0.1740106195,
-0.0174833667,
0.7027567029,
-0.1278903186,
0.118010655,
-0.5383925438,
-0.2658613324,
0.2170172036,
-0.5220355392,
0.4903182983,
0.0130258584,
-0.8016405702,
0.2003657371,
-0.6478725672,
-0.2376810759,
0.0881137624,
-0.0327681229,
0.1367155164,
-0.0716858655,
-0.2971127331,
0.7246179581,
0.358512193,
-0.4021650851,
0.0213543568,
-0.6153044105,
0.4337497354,
1.3158265352,
-0.1440558434,
0.6492069364,
0.3072541654,
0.6057240367,
0.0329570808,
0.4043045938,
-0.4267970026,
-0.1297504008,
-0.8062395453,
0.1929606646,
0.2673701346,
0.1492712796,
-0.3622648716,
0.3362982571,
-0.0316613466,
-0.0219562463,
-0.2910697162,
0.0802876577,
0.5836766362,
0.797598362,
0.3641085625,
-0.4017696977,
-0.4056990445,
-0.8599013686,
-0.1674079895,
-0.3060885966,
0.263153702,
0.3271766305,
0.2636500299,
-0.0641694292,
0.9129948616,
-0.5066946149,
-0.5606161952,
-0.1099399775,
0.2577125728,
0.2397381961,
0.4520919919,
0.4357350171,
-0.5048999786,
-0.4449925721,
-0.146157667,
-0.6746239662,
0.0511996634,
-0.0795090869,
-0.2498085499,
0.2820094526,
0.9480357766,
-0.5183329582,
0.3909021914,
0.4225245118,
-0.2724992931,
0.4255478382,
0.0264075994,
-0.463396281,
-0.9538468122,
0.135280177,
-0.0985172763,
-0.181053713,
-0.4974637628,
-0.2269022763,
-0.1524986327,
0.0198299866,
-0.4351743162,
0.6971588135,
-0.553055346,
-0.4862551689,
-0.4757470489,
-0.0419190899,
-0.3306420147,
0.9727793336,
-0.0195324123,
0.7243512273,
0.7631049752,
-0.6852852106,
0.265599668,
0.038515728,
0.0841445252,
0.2754389048,
-0.8786417842,
0.3504808843,
-0.3133010864,
0.2230669111,
-1.3135700226,
-0.0490422323,
0.2730100751,
-0.5588368773,
0.4714874327,
-0.2265952379,
-0.3686216176,
-0.8104057908,
-0.0933034942,
0.5797047019,
0.1513621509,
-0.6313957572,
0.7633880973,
0.417912066,
-0.2054110467,
-0.9108624458,
-0.6156777143,
0.0184892714,
0.1842951775,
-0.3401805758,
0.1121455431,
-0.2287052721,
0.2267976999,
0.1044896841,
-0.2084315866,
0.1646667272,
0.2145687789,
0.3656679988,
0.1488774866,
-0.0389103293,
0.2377720624,
-0.0112830075,
-0.5992389917,
0.4711280167,
-0.8667872548,
0.7501055002,
-0.1082615331,
-0.451782167,
-0.5512608886,
0.1214206591,
0.7005793452,
-0.4899819791,
0.3739554584,
0.9384146333,
-0.1902854145,
0.0928255916,
-0.5644798279,
-0.5065933466,
-0.5245003104,
0.5205065608,
-0.60271734,
-0.7548671961,
0.7705403566,
0.2495952547,
-0.1139256582,
0.8436638713,
0.7242897153,
-0.1780929118,
1.3839172125,
0.6775635481,
-0.4134795368,
0.7820968032,
-0.4777829051,
0.0551273003,
-0.7872371674,
-0.4268844128,
-0.3639913201,
-0.4870329797,
-0.5990129709,
-0.1444679499,
0.3660056293,
-0.3409195244,
-0.2976903617,
0.3665175736,
-0.5073863268,
0.426461488,
0.7335272431,
-0.1584740132,
-0.0856889635,
0.0380755998,
-0.5330058932,
0.0224669315,
-0.795661509,
0.1605357379,
1.146427393,
0.5081314445,
0.7268626094,
-0.3403520584,
0.8183113933,
0.2021462917,
0.197232455,
-0.7802132368,
0.5284177065,
-0.0111732753,
-0.6206111908,
-0.4106164873,
-0.2735475302,
-1.0906835794,
0.0740968809,
0.1022861674,
-0.6022198796,
0.2119928896,
0.224574998,
-0.3556014001,
0.0753399655,
-0.5168013573,
1.078594923,
-0.3129831851,
-0.5435195565,
-0.2998075485,
-1.1139154434,
0.2012686282,
0.1491281539,
-0.062495511,
-0.0747587308,
0.1371275187,
0.7327606082,
-0.3131496012,
1.065692544,
-0.1858967692,
-0.140724346,
0.3717012703,
0.1608026326,
0.5913837552,
-0.0018633658,
0.2399992496,
0.0013754229,
-0.5226411223,
-0.3080089986,
-0.639357686,
0.5864166617,
-0.7743756175,
-0.6629744768,
-0.3938804269,
-0.1919473559,
-0.0305440277,
0.4355211258,
0.1878882498,
0.7334397435,
0.1042246297,
0.0972390994,
0.4935307205,
0.4116567075,
0.7869039178,
0.3238344789,
0.0876210779,
-0.3509092033,
0.9531021118,
0.1130601317,
0.0723909512,
0.3566572964,
0.1893971264,
-0.7555580735,
-0.3285607696,
-0.2840381563,
0.3801850379,
-0.7489128113,
-0.3979341984,
-1.0104739666,
-0.3675627112,
-0.4850868881,
0.2123979479,
-0.5437515378,
-0.4035617709,
-0.5012015104,
-0.3692280948,
-0.0255190711,
0.9468653798,
-0.120738633,
0.0513112135,
-0.5578967929,
0.2689374089,
0.503045857,
0.5968565345,
0.2467451543,
-0.5697396994,
-0.5163459778,
-0.345282495,
-0.1474794596,
-0.5196820498,
0.1715476364,
0.0042616837,
0.7318013906,
0.5300587416,
-0.1568498313,
0.4208699167,
-0.7523674369,
0.5261488557,
0.3200102448,
-0.8534541726,
0.4445112646,
-0.2583880424,
0.2338538021,
0.6824899316,
0.1576108634,
-0.5650286674,
-0.4779191315,
-0.8004611731,
-0.7306428552,
0.9863448739,
0.0625430495,
0.2105956227,
-0.2686236799,
0.5712135434,
0.1282663196,
0.2462446988,
-0.8444561362,
-0.4941243529,
-0.3043459058,
-0.3397096992,
-0.1145096496,
-0.3726678491,
0.1457872391,
-0.1629340202,
0.4172971249,
-0.4531408846,
0.6318465471,
0.2491540164,
0.0249584671,
-0.2105534524,
-0.378626883,
0.4650264382,
0.2338566631,
0.1059980243,
0.0749153718,
-0.0707550496,
-0.4559841752,
0.1348527223,
0.1366703957,
-0.0545815863,
-0.2392710447,
0.3435619473,
1.0953549147,
0.3092873991,
-0.2061818987,
0.71175915,
-0.0729294792,
-0.1702836603,
-0.3498827517,
-0.0534588061,
-0.3769288361,
0.3272306025,
0.5984081626,
0.1599980891,
0.4770367444,
-0.3860876262,
0.3329241574,
0.4405135512,
-0.7062794566,
-0.683032155,
1.039704442,
0.2066802979,
-0.1632236689,
0.3283994496,
-0.025962444,
-0.9078245163,
0.7430514097,
0.5000336766,
1.378187418,
-0.3408135772,
0.1792185754,
0.4081680477,
0.0832282156,
0.0021344647,
0.0096289665,
-0.4005135,
-0.4423562586,
-0.6729176641,
-0.5464570522,
-0.080450356,
-0.1196428388,
-0.4312990606,
0.1477882862,
-0.4379388392,
-0.2107718289,
-0.2646485865,
-0.0708069801,
-0.8174765706,
0.410325259,
0.2281670272,
0.387650162,
-0.6687730551,
0.496462822,
0.4748076797,
-0.360054493,
-0.9082418084,
0.3419902623,
-0.2185181528,
-0.979614079,
0.9183338284,
0.4626306593,
-0.3205385208,
0.2095188648,
-0.3755258918,
-1.5608736277,
0.9679374695,
0.2801576555,
-0.4336482584,
-0.2467005402,
0.0235874299,
0.5353668928,
-0.2368279397,
0.3748659194,
0.2490896434,
0.2920050323,
0.1407399178,
-0.6484541297,
0.0932699963,
-0.1788320243,
-0.1567586511,
0.0799567327,
-1.0402251482,
1.0571258068,
-0.2486369163,
-0.34528777,
-0.1569389254,
1.1782324314,
-0.259688437,
0.1391734928,
0.6430086493,
0.4792549312,
0.5388432741,
0.1390081942,
1.2245475054,
-0.7572427392,
0.5403510928,
1.1278426647,
-0.0733050629,
0.4974083006,
0.3580672443,
-0.2190720141,
0.7796136141,
0.5722162127,
0.1864486486,
0.620864749,
-0.0886554867,
0.0564740971,
-0.2018690407,
-0.0656595603,
-0.2577174306,
0.6739945412,
0.0185106993,
-0.4418279529,
0.0655582026,
0.1129873991,
-0.3058417141,
-0.2487121969,
-0.3871946335,
0.9656215906,
-0.0470258258,
-0.9007231593,
0.453592509,
-0.2721471786,
0.2751183808,
-0.2527347505,
0.2231601775,
-0.2728071511,
0.1960385144,
0.0343360528,
-0.8523265719,
0.0194692556,
-0.4545786083,
-0.2431395799,
-0.173088789,
0.8662000895,
-0.4030044675,
-0.4213706851,
0.4472358525,
0.3792655468,
-0.0911965966,
-0.0721588656,
-0.8374621272,
-0.1609688848,
-0.1861840487,
-0.5065883398,
0.1886915416,
0.4037227631,
0.170730561,
0.8578640819,
0.6003072858,
-0.2923150957,
0.3039696515,
0.3173044622,
0.9843627214,
-0.6223703027,
-0.7538121343,
-0.8629139662,
0.3840547502,
0.1233039945,
-0.2861783803,
0.4916026592,
0.4559651017,
0.7673484087,
0.1240251288,
0.5476602316,
0.3276741803,
0.2993653715,
-0.556452632,
0.2830631733,
-0.6108947396,
-0.1921837777,
-0.1910282522,
-0.9473811388,
-0.1468820572,
0.4868941903,
-0.2778555155,
0.3442074955,
0.8663046956,
0.4322697222,
-0.0323719792,
-0.3241185248,
0.1396711618,
0.4610311091,
0.086717248,
0.4414200187,
0.5216193199,
-0.378090173,
0.7070025206,
-0.2257110924,
0.0822403431,
-0.356808275,
-0.5104526281,
-1.0559419394,
-0.7703700662,
-0.0446036384,
-0.4317131639,
-0.0892955065,
0.7466244102,
0.7518296838,
-0.6903762817,
0.0542862639,
-0.5990169644,
0.0914262533,
-0.1110915467,
-0.2851696014,
0.4769379497,
-0.8440058827,
-0.8345804214,
0.2659756839,
0.5102247,
0.1940483153,
-0.6631168723,
0.0165513605,
0.0974160656,
-0.2036682516,
0.5230717659,
0.4044123292,
-0.5885882974,
-0.2607601285,
0.27657184,
-0.3123090565,
0.174209699,
1.0390371084,
-1.0453727245,
0.3552343845,
0.3022091091,
0.8143588901,
0.9678282142,
-0.0342226662,
0.6242383122,
-0.790948987,
0.1341079473,
0.1661208421,
0.4610656202,
0.1491557509,
-0.6682630777,
0.4431509078,
0.4944388568,
-0.5366060734,
-0.5687061548,
0.4131718278,
-0.6856681108,
0.0318929106,
1.0343536139,
0.0937593654,
-0.6272962689,
0.0090471385,
-0.1103790626,
0.3624551594,
-0.3185046017,
0.7764901519,
0.4509747326,
-0.1866124719,
-0.2116448134,
-0.0942637548,
0.5228464007,
0.9442796111,
-0.3656406999,
0.1850859076,
0.1766685098,
0.160251379,
0.1896673739,
0.6479299664,
0.0131807253,
0.3444222808,
-0.2567294538,
0.0209501404,
-0.1176293865,
-0.7596953511,
-0.4925099909,
0.1671291739,
-0.1779048741,
-0.3395701945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09727v1
|
Investigating the performance of Retrieval-Augmented Generation and fine-tuning for the development of AI-driven knowledge-based systems
| 2024-03-12T21:06:31 | 2024-03-12T21:06:31 |
Robert Lakatos, Peter Pollner, Andras Hajdu, Tamas Joo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The development of generative large language models (G-LLM) opened up new
opportunities for the development of new types of knowledge-based systems
similar to ChatGPT, Bing, or Gemini. Fine-tuning (FN) and Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) are the techniques that can be used to implement domain
adaptation for the development of G-LLM-based knowledge systems. In our study,
using ROUGE, BLEU, METEOR scores, and cosine similarity, we compare and examine
the performance of RAG and FN for the GPT-J-6B, OPT-6.7B, LlaMA, LlaMA-2
language models. Based on measurements shown on different datasets, we
demonstrate that RAG-based constructions are more efficient than models
produced with FN. We point out that connecting RAG and FN is not trivial,
because connecting FN models with RAG can cause a decrease in performance.
Furthermore, we outline a simple RAG-based architecture which, on average,
outperforms the FN models by 16% in terms of the ROGUE score, 15% in the case
of the BLEU score, and 53% based on the cosine similarity. This shows the
significant advantage of RAG over FN in terms of hallucination, which is not
offset by the fact that the average 8% better METEOR score of FN models
indicates greater creativity compared to RAG.
|
[
-0.5740559697,
-0.8254179358,
0.415671885,
-0.0824235082,
-0.1230286285,
0.233208254,
-0.3463158309,
-0.6151282191,
-0.0378153361,
0.5082168579,
-0.1444582194,
-0.2704446614,
-0.3513711095,
0.0607118383,
-0.4546797872,
0.9971995354,
0.2551251948,
-0.2679107785,
-0.0013129612,
-0.0985227004,
-0.475322336,
-0.4033508301,
-0.8351634145,
-0.3498821855,
0.5029931068,
0.1387040466,
0.942373991,
0.5607045293,
0.6429296732,
0.2571024895,
-0.1759114116,
0.5300630927,
-0.6692399383,
0.0071484544,
-0.5942303538,
-0.328206569,
-0.457065016,
-0.1465248913,
0.2953752577,
0.3240537643,
-0.0076721539,
0.3187038898,
0.1183987334,
0.9140626192,
-0.672134757,
0.1690190583,
-0.8771089315,
-0.3691677153,
-0.2102297097,
-0.3955421448,
-0.488822192,
-0.3111896813,
-0.017140422,
-0.8130200505,
0.4172294438,
0.3705104291,
0.9611983895,
0.5348428488,
-0.0574804656,
-0.4935348332,
-0.9153802991,
0.72894454,
-0.5782893896,
0.4938185811,
0.2354074568,
0.3052307069,
-0.3707222939,
-0.4586138129,
-0.5419316292,
-0.2930027246,
-0.1061453074,
0.1576955318,
0.0522342511,
-0.0835524574,
0.3087038994,
0.5577865243,
-0.680647552,
0.2564389706,
-0.3670765162,
-0.0529535487,
0.9532778859,
0.2171675414,
-0.0859120712,
-0.3030854464,
-0.1377561241,
-0.1461770982,
-0.8795827031,
-0.3171929121,
0.19105196,
0.4658610523,
0.0228899606,
0.6063337326,
-0.3227109611,
0.8521969914,
0.3081333041,
-0.1861253232,
0.0462197214,
-0.2099179178,
-0.3236543238,
-0.4690624774,
0.5942633748,
0.3602349758,
0.546109736,
-0.4718375206,
-0.4854216576,
0.1031447873,
0.3897278905,
-0.5811774731,
-0.2742286921,
-0.2192526013,
-0.4565294981,
-0.2309659719,
-0.2860555947,
-0.3990570605,
-0.4961974025,
-0.7362581491,
0.7789569497,
-0.5557324886,
-0.1432905495,
-0.0269463956,
-0.2816325724,
0.4057474732,
0.4330078065,
-0.7558279634,
0.3207473457,
0.9033823013,
0.7040629983,
-0.3150669038,
-0.1671073139,
-0.4173802435,
-0.0274778511,
-0.5678893924,
0.7326310277,
-0.4585309625,
-0.4486210346,
-0.138832584,
-0.3734925389,
-0.1832081228,
-0.9684774876,
0.4274304211,
-0.9382250309,
-0.0715795234,
-0.1144004911,
-0.6729058027,
-0.2833963931,
0.1912761927,
-0.5639901161,
0.9216961861,
0.4433524013,
-0.4616530538,
0.4439989924,
-0.5217128396,
-0.3916013837,
0.1329597235,
-0.1160349995,
-0.1510332525,
0.4573312402,
0.0137959542,
0.4416861534,
-0.6942933798,
0.1793656796,
-0.093668133,
-0.6646335125,
-0.0992631018,
-0.3553331792,
0.2435931563,
0.3925772607,
-0.3185981512,
-0.1941936165,
-0.8849748969,
0.112798661,
-0.0089740194,
-0.5854599476,
-0.4764053524,
0.1098912433,
-0.0519012623,
-0.0283571221,
0.1708186865,
-0.0450490601,
0.2078439891,
-0.556368947,
-0.1269833744,
0.6990246773,
-0.1110685691,
0.3798508048,
-0.671561718,
0.2750349939,
-0.137211144,
-0.0677161887,
0.0499858782,
-0.3658964634,
-0.9432177544,
0.0086483676,
0.4798055887,
0.523912549,
-0.9686428308,
0.1867205501,
-0.3071587086,
-0.581833005,
-0.53515625,
0.0153830843,
0.5994744897,
0.479562223,
0.4854616225,
-0.2892763019,
-0.2771775424,
-0.877117455,
-0.5423947573,
-0.0128679639,
0.0703246146,
0.7398460507,
0.4263293147,
-0.1244063824,
0.5700260997,
-0.3491362333,
-0.039180968,
-0.0449118726,
-0.007038095,
0.3017270565,
0.2952525914,
0.7192761898,
-0.7863835096,
-0.7259859443,
0.4264397919,
-0.5546486378,
0.0175128523,
0.0657712892,
0.0478329398,
0.636393249,
0.2431892008,
-0.5496789217,
0.5988735557,
0.4823407233,
-0.3418652415,
0.8025147319,
-0.2417575121,
0.333596617,
-1.0261898041,
0.2711572051,
-0.1358635575,
-0.1141862869,
-0.650203824,
0.3583732843,
-0.1015385017,
0.1716523618,
-0.2609052956,
0.8171429634,
-0.430744946,
-0.1805811673,
-0.3335102499,
0.2033668607,
-0.0465791598,
0.4831678569,
-0.257570833,
1.169424057,
0.3620226085,
-1.0378547907,
0.0927173346,
0.1088887528,
-0.5456436872,
0.3866022825,
-0.5080778599,
0.2615847588,
-0.016659895,
-0.2854207754,
-0.4180996418,
-0.2713976502,
-0.0564582534,
-0.3734256625,
0.3946478069,
-0.1636825055,
-0.4201655686,
-0.185022071,
0.0521196164,
0.3656421602,
0.6350227594,
-0.6280480623,
0.5614631772,
0.1638677865,
0.0043955529,
-0.4380161464,
-0.2714698911,
-0.0901098847,
-0.3603392839,
-0.5687344074,
0.4631981254,
-0.0469398983,
-0.4102485776,
-0.0038461443,
-0.0164466761,
0.3098198175,
0.2492373586,
0.1147823632,
0.0880347937,
-0.4142787457,
0.2045162171,
0.0118480027,
0.0338056907,
-0.3063655198,
-0.2099633813,
0.7378988266,
-0.0103714745,
-0.3025050461,
-0.0555483066,
-0.0092280395,
0.4737550914,
-0.2921542823,
0.7863547206,
0.3611825109,
-0.1836553663,
-0.3912760317,
-0.736489594,
-0.0385021009,
-0.4836700857,
0.2131196111,
-0.6221182942,
-0.9822853804,
0.5935434699,
-0.2234778255,
-0.026606774,
0.7244739532,
0.517336905,
0.0748651326,
0.7008948326,
0.5097634196,
-0.2259274423,
0.392359972,
-0.3895380795,
0.0061044958,
-0.9791953564,
-0.0728783011,
-0.5458602905,
-0.3388896286,
-0.8922151923,
-0.5666877627,
0.3577427566,
0.406291157,
-0.4257793128,
0.188086167,
-0.4397937655,
0.4440220296,
0.6524526477,
-0.0479827076,
0.3625181615,
0.1068674326,
-0.1150786132,
0.2920852304,
-0.7758805752,
-0.4130653143,
1.2053303719,
-0.0537449606,
0.8144441843,
0.2574176192,
0.7015218735,
0.2754712403,
0.3819821477,
-0.6587460637,
0.5145830512,
-0.6916264892,
-0.454914093,
-0.3063426018,
-0.5180996656,
-0.9180344343,
0.1468263865,
-0.2230128646,
-0.6219347715,
0.1251892149,
0.1700796038,
-0.2943014503,
0.1232582927,
-0.7188233137,
0.4185864627,
-0.1526747644,
-0.3921498954,
-0.533704102,
-0.1633711308,
0.2027778178,
-0.1767378598,
0.229233712,
0.0912005156,
0.3029024005,
0.5432018638,
-0.1293640584,
0.3423424065,
-0.1813426912,
-0.0285640229,
0.4249162972,
0.2211374938,
0.54079175,
0.0062024435,
-0.4840399027,
-0.1385638565,
-0.3091432452,
-0.0245696455,
-0.7557605505,
0.8629034162,
-0.8605301976,
-0.976023674,
-0.0381434634,
-0.7212175727,
-0.178596735,
0.2730616331,
0.0514444336,
0.5812010765,
-0.2208180726,
0.2319250256,
0.6076847315,
-0.3135146499,
0.2591760457,
0.607647419,
-0.4122921526,
-0.3050887585,
1.0231224298,
0.2498186827,
0.3893550336,
0.4639331698,
0.1381933838,
-0.0823716447,
-0.6531176567,
-0.6106172204,
0.2220155746,
-0.3015754223,
-0.4905350804,
-0.2382737398,
-0.457498312,
-0.2753287256,
-0.0739171356,
-0.2701195478,
-0.577444911,
-0.2345217764,
0.2497833222,
0.6604950428,
1.0098274946,
-0.0888630375,
0.1591672599,
-0.6221852303,
0.5133107901,
0.0916325599,
0.5080673695,
0.1631835252,
-0.6725564599,
-0.5429473519,
0.1111517996,
-0.3991906941,
-0.489446044,
0.2318137288,
0.3090343773,
0.4109965861,
0.068543002,
-0.1677323431,
0.7829141021,
-0.4936101139,
0.6092206836,
-0.4002081454,
-0.6444113851,
0.4415056407,
-0.6049478054,
0.1462498009,
0.4315155447,
0.1532949507,
-0.2719449401,
-0.3263305724,
-0.60044384,
-0.5859029889,
0.7646489143,
0.0689980313,
-0.1426355839,
0.0822562128,
0.8474957943,
0.1853450537,
0.1416473389,
-0.1166795269,
-0.2969019413,
0.093687959,
-0.0356722511,
-0.4024638832,
-0.016994413,
0.0346305072,
-0.0838522166,
0.6358028054,
-0.1697731167,
0.1238796934,
0.0695847645,
-0.1399300247,
-0.0403893553,
0.1265908182,
0.5807638764,
0.5450136065,
-0.0004315762,
-0.147597611,
0.2436428517,
-0.4477277994,
-0.0319230594,
0.148605898,
-0.5781205297,
-0.2203276157,
0.2171269059,
1.0434687138,
-0.1186107323,
-0.2365256399,
0.0015507437,
0.1364623606,
-0.0407719016,
0.03036258,
0.7757860422,
0.0076261484,
0.482281208,
0.3026681244,
0.2431603074,
0.2405165434,
-0.6095253825,
0.0222621318,
0.549536705,
0.1408477575,
-0.2515289187,
0.4651016593,
-0.0444831364,
-0.6179969907,
0.531311512,
-0.320800215,
-0.3386435509,
0.5871450305,
0.5898150802,
0.602304101,
-0.2635161281,
0.1425225586,
0.4693010747,
0.1082070246,
-0.1234918013,
0.3896863163,
0.0418180004,
-0.6726031303,
-0.5054712892,
-1.049146533,
-0.2530281544,
0.2639834583,
-0.5692327023,
0.1387452185,
-0.2499375641,
-0.1472454667,
-0.1247280538,
0.244218275,
-1.0142674446,
0.5003288984,
-0.2286420316,
0.9793634415,
-0.4465585947,
0.5870016217,
0.7412207127,
-0.2428373843,
-1.2260581255,
0.0452246293,
-0.2400768399,
-0.6193827987,
0.55531919,
-0.1978342384,
-0.1613472104,
0.1365956068,
-0.130359903,
-1.0800023079,
1.2281202078,
0.3097753525,
-0.6626003981,
-0.1828522682,
0.2171705663,
0.9356768727,
-0.2373266816,
0.0923615992,
0.7147843838,
0.3772363663,
-0.0731590986,
-1.3876835108,
-0.1879698932,
0.0111357784,
0.1094422862,
0.3500165641,
-0.9542192817,
0.7889306545,
-0.2162283212,
-0.2507822812,
0.3819951415,
0.4338670373,
0.3801938891,
0.2671772242,
0.2114890665,
0.7335891724,
0.722334981,
-0.1953520775,
1.1356822252,
-0.4357785583,
0.3325004578,
0.9960567355,
-0.0609877706,
0.9449144006,
0.2016552687,
-0.1162298992,
0.4887382388,
0.2080600262,
0.0157445408,
0.5402566791,
0.2669301927,
-0.030487055,
-0.0731550232,
0.0136104794,
-0.394565016,
0.6276065111,
0.5490609407,
-0.2704697251,
-0.0248605479,
-0.1646970958,
-0.2264756411,
0.14311032,
-0.5644283295,
1.0884736776,
0.1947501004,
-0.9897174239,
0.9000990987,
-0.0344623029,
0.532001853,
-0.202497825,
0.0378904045,
-0.4169791937,
0.2913312018,
-0.1755063981,
-0.6597982645,
0.4723328054,
0.1135519445,
-0.338580519,
0.1632263809,
0.9415554404,
-0.1495838761,
-0.4044773281,
0.3739593625,
0.6582468152,
0.1393642426,
0.1336385459,
-0.4020520449,
0.1099337116,
-0.1090977639,
-0.3069624305,
0.3610311151,
0.5967417955,
-0.1975478679,
0.7002296448,
0.5091855526,
0.2119290531,
0.1208533421,
0.2664787173,
0.9189050794,
-0.6613189578,
-0.025471691,
-0.6722697616,
0.3517587185,
0.1808735877,
-0.1906451434,
0.7147773504,
0.7269040346,
0.9705294967,
-0.2437534183,
0.7291546464,
-0.2013814747,
0.7973636985,
-0.654135108,
0.8685864806,
-0.7856832147,
0.1717151999,
-0.3139861524,
-1.1610754728,
-0.1637574285,
0.3666394055,
-0.3020510674,
0.2571271062,
0.2954705656,
1.0787039995,
-0.111322023,
-0.1052689105,
0.3888033032,
0.2086286098,
0.3192344606,
0.449326396,
0.8299174905,
-0.5859717727,
0.1791242361,
-0.0617056154,
-0.0574060939,
-0.2635266781,
-0.5073855519,
-0.8759994507,
-0.5500839949,
0.0269959345,
-0.2045936733,
0.4135633111,
0.4477852881,
0.4107737839,
-0.8058030605,
-0.135233596,
-0.0939832181,
0.1193774417,
-0.0035887521,
-0.2235181034,
0.4564070404,
-0.4411612451,
-0.6370531917,
0.5098122954,
0.2219443172,
-0.1275068671,
-0.1373251826,
-0.2993641794,
-0.0280061997,
0.1579094231,
0.747181654,
0.100964874,
-0.7356932759,
-0.607956171,
0.2211616635,
0.0198915619,
-0.1116147935,
0.4706622362,
-1.096944809,
0.1843523234,
0.4517726302,
0.6659553647,
0.4215810597,
0.2312188298,
0.4875591397,
-0.439419806,
-0.1095654443,
0.1015182287,
0.0495095775,
0.3602510095,
-0.2580870986,
0.6428922415,
-0.0332793258,
-0.9823269248,
-0.5892060995,
0.2383758575,
-0.6152339578,
0.06190091,
1.1987037659,
0.2318628877,
0.0471848883,
-0.0815492719,
-0.2785231471,
0.2722193003,
-0.1693514735,
1.0311142206,
0.4176202714,
-0.2495151311,
0.1541628689,
-0.3559902012,
0.8034816384,
0.3877797723,
-0.5874528885,
-0.0320847332,
0.4682137072,
0.2091265023,
0.4776789546,
0.4277715683,
0.1210973561,
0.4573314786,
-0.0712279528,
-0.227270022,
-0.1201404855,
-0.5722828507,
-0.0677725747,
0.0914836898,
0.4019100666,
0.3158735037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08059v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08059v2
|
FluoroSAM: A Language-aligned Foundation Model for X-ray Image Segmentation
| 2024-03-12T20:11:38 | 2024-03-28T00:59:37 |
Benjamin D. Killeen, Liam J. Wang, Han Zhang, Mehran Armand, Russell H. Taylor, Dave Dreizin, Greg Osgood, Mathias Unberath
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Automated X-ray image segmentation would accelerate research and development
in diagnostic and interventional precision medicine. Prior efforts have
contributed task-specific models capable of solving specific image analysis
problems, but the utility of these models is restricted to their particular
task domain, and expanding to broader use requires additional data, labels, and
retraining efforts. Recently, foundation models (FMs) -- machine learning
models trained on large amounts of highly variable data thus enabling broad
applicability -- have emerged as promising tools for automated image analysis.
Existing FMs for medical image analysis focus on scenarios and modalities where
objects are clearly defined by visually apparent boundaries, such as surgical
tool segmentation in endoscopy. X-ray imaging, by contrast, does not generally
offer such clearly delineated boundaries or structure priors. During X-ray
image formation, complex 3D structures are projected in transmission onto the
imaging plane, resulting in overlapping features of varying opacity and shape.
To pave the way toward an FM for comprehensive and automated analysis of
arbitrary medical X-ray images, we develop FluoroSAM, a language-aligned
variant of the Segment-Anything Model, trained from scratch on 1.6M synthetic
X-ray images. FluoroSAM is trained on data including masks for 128 organ types
and 464 non-anatomical objects, such as tools and implants. In real X-ray
images of cadaveric specimens, FluoroSAM is able to segment bony anatomical
structures based on text-only prompting with 0.51 and 0.79 DICE with
point-based refinement, outperforming competing SAM variants for all
structures. FluoroSAM is also capable of zero-shot generalization to segmenting
classes beyond the training set thanks to its language alignment, which we
demonstrate for full lung segmentation on real chest X-rays.
|
[
-0.2903705239,
-0.7469477654,
0.3258619606,
-0.0446089916,
-0.5078145266,
-0.0993764475,
0.1275349408,
-0.5642564893,
0.1221642196,
0.5086811781,
-0.3723216951,
-0.4352519214,
-0.5736026168,
0.1702158898,
-0.7258876562,
0.8168604374,
-0.0576495603,
0.2665888965,
0.0842596442,
-0.2686100006,
-0.1983541846,
-0.0202754047,
-0.6904301643,
-0.2576551735,
0.2520336509,
0.1509113461,
1.1520453691,
1.2165278196,
0.5621480346,
0.3428768516,
0.2660940588,
-0.2733992636,
-0.1830097288,
-0.313776195,
-0.0248812996,
-0.4753861725,
-0.2042291164,
-0.210382551,
0.6173914671,
0.9721668959,
0.0235616583,
-0.2804814279,
-0.6721106768,
0.6252048612,
-0.4423955083,
-0.1728583723,
-0.33710289,
0.3523977697,
-0.1420853585,
-0.1186072379,
0.2106656134,
-0.2692774534,
0.6130948663,
-0.530864954,
0.1608092934,
-0.2128787935,
1.1536002159,
0.2685281932,
-0.3533012271,
-0.3493293822,
-0.1871542633,
0.6872220635,
-0.1309436858,
0.6317991018,
0.0582713746,
0.5549182296,
0.0092596682,
-0.8350723982,
0.0528381318,
-0.0871505737,
-0.1954834461,
-0.2847841382,
-0.1358109415,
0.2584688365,
-0.2400779128,
0.790931344,
-0.7594988942,
-0.0887475386,
-0.5265890956,
-0.0830444694,
0.7169448137,
0.0620860718,
0.4836504459,
-0.1354707479,
-0.8626947403,
-0.0796054378,
-0.6507780552,
-0.332177341,
-0.26642856,
-0.1594787687,
-0.044161167,
0.1439219117,
-0.1057664379,
1.1174645424,
0.0975073576,
-0.318241924,
0.1060617492,
0.0113991806,
-0.8569275737,
0.255631566,
0.7869371176,
0.0108065242,
0.1293841451,
0.1646499634,
-0.3083305955,
0.0802878067,
0.0359741747,
-0.7817872167,
-0.3953240216,
0.2999284267,
-0.5756220222,
-0.7553489208,
0.1718073487,
-0.3515443504,
-0.2871296704,
-0.1571971625,
0.5043697357,
-0.5809492469,
-0.1322057098,
0.4665347338,
-0.0162508991,
0.0683367178,
0.2250274867,
-0.7747420073,
0.4447362721,
0.5380094051,
0.9592333436,
0.0089325691,
0.1297041327,
-0.5153374672,
0.0632988736,
-0.5282648802,
0.8181726933,
-0.7297521234,
-0.7089130878,
-0.3180978,
0.2181173563,
-0.0906461999,
-0.5921177864,
0.1192661822,
-0.3333256841,
0.2301175296,
0.0028976281,
-0.4444986582,
-0.3912493587,
0.3635031581,
-0.8136854768,
0.5218040943,
0.5871335864,
-0.2548777461,
0.4487366676,
-0.6262272,
-0.4576259553,
-0.1376321018,
-0.8826566339,
-0.361913085,
0.0153887486,
0.2430345565,
0.448658824,
-0.5401634574,
0.50172472,
-0.020791132,
-0.201754868,
0.2887058258,
-0.2634951472,
0.8392229676,
0.2161309272,
-0.4790860116,
0.3657619357,
-0.8518851995,
0.0024709895,
0.2080406994,
-0.002465504,
-0.2021090537,
-0.3033190072,
0.1019938886,
0.2533181608,
-0.0261157025,
-0.6462132931,
0.1754569262,
-0.4426686168,
0.2501296401,
0.4641901851,
-0.0631484315,
0.1872979552,
-0.5493738651,
0.7877376676,
-0.0271418449,
0.1838892847,
-0.4292059541,
-0.474958092,
-0.546384871,
-0.7264829278,
0.4628332555,
0.4280338585,
-0.1477297843,
0.2835895419,
-0.1326438934,
-0.4278999865,
-0.4191369712,
-0.0669053048,
0.4297898114,
0.6525313258,
0.1284795105,
-0.5334811211,
-0.7757514119,
-1.0154676437,
0.3319512904,
0.0966766253,
-0.0050303815,
0.007051805,
0.3113518059,
-0.3147318363,
0.8848467469,
-0.9072506428,
-0.5975788832,
0.1866360903,
0.0095101045,
-0.0077778529,
0.6495345235,
0.7473662496,
-1.1707005501,
-0.7161207795,
0.4329359233,
-0.7707361579,
-0.1274838299,
-0.2029387504,
-0.1979042888,
0.0348011218,
0.5622417331,
-0.1704643816,
0.3443146646,
0.3134209514,
-0.0569927581,
0.3041300774,
0.1398666501,
0.1957960576,
-0.7278952003,
0.4142952263,
0.1722639799,
-0.4588695168,
-0.6206665635,
0.17732355,
0.1020618379,
-0.2325109094,
-0.3764460087,
0.7132803798,
-0.5262097716,
-0.0868404508,
-0.2530448735,
-0.1627912223,
0.2043702602,
0.1438479871,
0.7442160845,
0.4356583357,
0.6575533748,
-0.1722357273,
0.0134175094,
0.18052876,
-0.3769325912,
0.7772889137,
-0.6465112567,
-0.0377257913,
0.2831445932,
0.0955116153,
-0.7525702715,
-0.4260005951,
0.2062674165,
-0.1568730772,
0.3692408502,
-0.0799386352,
0.0256083868,
0.060988605,
-0.3020952046,
0.4521886408,
0.3939261138,
-0.4166531265,
0.4321054816,
0.4079988599,
0.0571068712,
-0.5292105675,
-0.5913484693,
-0.1732754707,
-0.0004398665,
-0.9327809215,
0.7500910759,
0.0327174142,
-0.3305648565,
0.173606053,
-0.293807745,
-0.6498376131,
0.0700990632,
0.2912645936,
0.181336686,
-0.4596660733,
-0.1105184108,
0.272626549,
-0.3911213279,
-0.0813756362,
-0.3864944279,
0.2662486434,
-0.1458598077,
-0.2367966622,
-0.2503373325,
0.3585287035,
0.5963683724,
-0.1087955758,
0.1086375415,
0.3840658069,
-0.7780719995,
0.1870015562,
-0.3784970045,
0.1265817136,
-0.4713078141,
0.469596982,
-0.3582921028,
-0.7271081805,
0.1608576477,
0.2018245608,
0.1962897182,
0.2816501856,
0.3222051561,
0.02985809,
1.261729002,
0.7039815187,
0.1153438017,
0.3957244456,
-0.3505323529,
-0.1116258428,
-0.5408550501,
-0.1492056996,
-0.3057539165,
-0.17381832,
0.0376079977,
-0.2127876133,
0.4012417197,
-0.1403297782,
0.2024667859,
-0.0299754124,
-0.679975152,
0.5664148331,
-0.0911162719,
-0.0693752468,
0.1801185757,
0.1630739719,
0.0314187519,
0.2926667035,
-0.508264482,
-0.3756332397,
0.9235841632,
0.2836934924,
0.5684213638,
-0.3150635362,
0.7767098546,
0.3060048819,
0.4433188736,
-0.8842983842,
0.3306973875,
-0.3406829834,
-0.9263819456,
-0.1834255904,
-0.0802650303,
-1.1681690216,
0.4078771472,
0.0652794018,
-0.4587281644,
0.4393803179,
0.1199209541,
-0.7877787352,
0.1736227274,
-0.4861095846,
0.9072003961,
-0.4303330183,
0.0616404042,
-0.0307403449,
-0.8885744214,
0.4193956256,
-0.4138807058,
0.3481912315,
-0.0887102261,
-0.1802044362,
0.6056412458,
-0.7150188684,
0.7228414416,
-0.0853185877,
-0.350418061,
0.0679900348,
0.0995990559,
-0.1505599618,
0.0517271347,
-0.0948822498,
0.0382170714,
0.5830016732,
-0.3106522262,
-0.5970612168,
0.5348131061,
-0.5075013638,
-0.5058079958,
-0.4123653769,
-0.4469161034,
0.0350058898,
0.3996353447,
0.359538734,
0.6307486892,
-0.4484039247,
0.2063105106,
0.5578788519,
0.2131346762,
-0.1396006346,
0.2998965085,
-0.358931154,
-0.6513076425,
0.9481588602,
0.2651589513,
0.0196873117,
0.7478681803,
0.4037296176,
-0.0708707348,
-0.5315879583,
-0.6391119957,
0.1363876015,
-0.7528802752,
-0.3588793278,
-0.4485804737,
-0.050986845,
-0.0834417418,
-0.8660514355,
-0.1435665935,
-0.4611495733,
-0.2073227614,
0.0871977061,
0.1437581927,
0.3314827085,
-0.1937307417,
0.4616415203,
-0.9899587631,
0.2830568254,
0.0185219608,
0.1738852561,
-0.3039371073,
-0.1161396578,
-0.2922544181,
-0.2602600753,
-0.0177899953,
-0.8665120006,
0.1886027157,
0.326960206,
0.345104903,
0.905203104,
-0.2752653658,
0.7455129623,
-0.0148852114,
0.3359996974,
0.2442976683,
-0.8639621139,
0.4941169322,
-0.2349856645,
0.1259144992,
0.5182036757,
0.3291301429,
-0.4549974799,
0.0011668653,
-0.6389914751,
-0.4746085703,
0.6245859265,
-0.0063589755,
-0.336210072,
-0.2821030319,
0.3567552269,
0.5315626264,
0.2732979953,
-0.3700451553,
0.1278259009,
-0.1486390382,
-0.6097388864,
0.4888433218,
0.0979407057,
-0.4180054665,
-0.1842308044,
0.6169012785,
-0.2491363883,
0.0700496957,
0.3671712875,
-0.5259396434,
-0.2701417506,
-0.1461018175,
0.6011039615,
0.4946008921,
-0.1516065001,
-0.0101827113,
-0.1663466096,
-0.612891376,
0.4584764242,
0.2118490189,
-0.0127268294,
-0.062602669,
0.2462005615,
0.4370520413,
0.3797419071,
-0.81862396,
0.34962672,
-0.0315177068,
-0.3660755455,
-0.2606226504,
0.5053405762,
-0.2870995402,
0.0825332999,
0.3664705753,
0.2089630812,
0.2123859227,
-0.2607960701,
0.5254804492,
0.4350968599,
-0.6662675142,
-0.2578027844,
0.3463697731,
0.2756829262,
0.0602780245,
0.5466658473,
0.1550508738,
-0.2095923573,
0.9460554719,
0.3254733384,
0.8434732556,
-0.4401299655,
0.2169816047,
0.0188901126,
0.2089018822,
0.1825343519,
0.3620244265,
-0.1771060675,
-0.5309595466,
-0.0375870392,
-0.5024733543,
-0.1019007191,
0.1312913001,
-0.5904149413,
0.4849061668,
-0.8897702098,
-0.037363328,
0.1451987773,
-0.0337751731,
-0.1858526319,
1.0308870077,
0.0064910059,
1.1599664688,
-0.7260392904,
0.8244358301,
0.7664208412,
-0.2711587846,
-0.303953886,
-0.2514756024,
0.2515979409,
-0.9122769237,
0.1153973415,
0.5273811817,
-0.0789111331,
0.1616284996,
-0.1794048697,
-0.9120816588,
1.1171478033,
0.3967548609,
-0.4332152903,
-0.1092685014,
0.1199998409,
0.2591161132,
-0.6401279569,
-0.0670095235,
0.8496713638,
0.3773851693,
0.0535958707,
-0.6325598359,
0.3128843009,
-0.2942230999,
-0.1528788805,
0.5766797066,
-0.4100289941,
0.6481484175,
-0.1535578817,
-0.2303764969,
0.3174146116,
0.5457181334,
0.1822163016,
0.1370951682,
0.8186046481,
0.4147466719,
0.7316807508,
-0.1681970358,
0.7940921783,
-0.3133198619,
-0.0095531773,
0.4239443839,
-0.2011346817,
0.1902298778,
0.3321297467,
-0.0175121259,
0.5321499109,
0.8285954595,
-0.3268012106,
0.4761331379,
-0.0940981731,
-0.182082504,
-0.1937663704,
0.0699842349,
-0.4931718111,
0.5401300192,
0.7756183743,
-0.5968509316,
-0.1890808195,
0.1249439493,
0.0417082496,
-0.383405894,
-0.1866726875,
0.490519464,
0.1191876978,
-0.3638687432,
0.7865008116,
0.1821438372,
0.4771220386,
-1.0152899027,
-0.0134156989,
0.0028742927,
-0.0127536114,
-0.6417109966,
-0.460729599,
0.6890308857,
-0.2923808694,
0.0246431194,
0.4457548261,
0.5642724037,
-0.2243383229,
-0.4634672105,
-0.0098037152,
0.0083653182,
0.1126294211,
-0.0007949747,
-0.821213007,
0.3596090674,
0.1730973721,
-0.0659602955,
0.334703207,
0.176779747,
-0.4616167545,
0.4503495693,
0.4444188178,
-0.2846046388,
-0.2446412146,
-0.3541376591,
0.7160619497,
-0.4083811045,
-0.6542099714,
-0.5796935558,
0.5487734675,
-0.0449247994,
-0.3166187406,
0.0477606207,
0.571906209,
0.8347619772,
0.0641772225,
0.7766327262,
-0.109870255,
-0.1172953993,
-0.5953552723,
0.5829761624,
-0.8535983562,
-0.0642920434,
-0.248251915,
-0.4847110808,
-0.7267204523,
1.0262000561,
-0.1618172973,
0.0996838212,
0.7441735268,
0.769569695,
-0.3616301715,
0.0465144925,
0.4006007612,
-0.2000518888,
0.2831074595,
0.1954892576,
0.4145232141,
-0.261725843,
0.5656500459,
-0.4874307811,
-0.5603827238,
-0.351023376,
-0.4736905992,
-0.5849475861,
-0.5543860793,
-0.6889514923,
0.0524528101,
0.0355353765,
0.8170136809,
1.1249165535,
-0.6422765851,
-0.3812844157,
-0.0851375759,
0.010527283,
-0.3214036822,
-0.1738466024,
0.6817352772,
-0.0536937714,
-0.7018698454,
0.5659480095,
0.6838267446,
0.1244212762,
-0.3400779068,
-0.0046716146,
-0.0107967481,
0.2033135891,
0.2762454152,
0.6737825871,
-0.5929031968,
-0.0491835512,
0.1232605875,
-0.0315183438,
0.5715233684,
0.7478755713,
-0.7239441872,
0.6557925344,
0.3959414363,
0.4785634577,
0.1690596193,
-0.1275355965,
0.7742154598,
-0.5860936642,
0.1419324726,
0.1057913601,
0.5905074477,
0.400714457,
-0.5245440602,
0.5958623886,
0.1196510792,
-0.2535153627,
-0.9166437387,
0.2373139411,
-0.6218290925,
-0.4727428854,
0.6299585104,
-0.0574914664,
-0.6010245085,
-0.1997286379,
-0.5088711381,
0.1949757636,
-0.0056176656,
0.5996147394,
0.2976252735,
-0.3116085231,
-0.2200339139,
0.1037583426,
0.4716084301,
0.3932072222,
-0.7764703631,
-0.4128340483,
0.5227546692,
0.5674192309,
0.2561924458,
0.8506421447,
-0.5582291484,
0.8035665751,
-0.2327019125,
-0.1380084306,
-0.2253244817,
-0.3209797144,
-0.6088237762,
0.4965206385,
-0.0579890124,
-0.4093140066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08058v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08058v2
|
CHAI: Clustered Head Attention for Efficient LLM Inference
| 2024-03-12T20:10:04 | 2024-04-27T22:45:39 |
Saurabh Agarwal, Bilge Acun, Basil Hosmer, Mostafa Elhoushi, Yejin Lee, Shivaram Venkataraman, Dimitris Papailiopoulos, Carole-Jean Wu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) with hundreds of billions of parameters have
transformed the field of machine learning. However, serving these models at
inference time is both compute and memory intensive, where a single request can
require multiple GPUs and tens of Gigabytes of memory. Multi-Head Attention is
one of the key components of LLMs, which can account for over 50% of LLMs
memory and compute requirement. We observe that there is a high amount of
redundancy across heads on which tokens they pay attention to. Based on this
insight, we propose Clustered Head Attention (CHAI). CHAI combines heads with a
high amount of correlation for self-attention at runtime, thus reducing both
memory and compute. In our experiments, we show that CHAI is able to reduce the
memory requirements for storing K,V cache by up to 21.4% and inference time
latency by up to 1.73x without any fine-tuning required. CHAI achieves this
with a maximum 3.2% deviation in accuracy across 3 different models (i.e.
OPT-66B, LLAMA-7B, LLAMA-33B) and 5 different evaluation datasets.
|
[
-0.4154320657,
-0.7908408642,
0.654948175,
0.5634787679,
-0.1975105405,
-0.1234793663,
-0.3434219658,
-0.3670587838,
0.2723067403,
0.5182946324,
-0.6155771613,
-0.4200830162,
-0.5386146307,
-0.2388042063,
-0.3454392254,
0.6640025377,
0.4447562397,
-0.1381150186,
-0.394823283,
-0.1856930405,
-0.51241225,
-0.3465701938,
-0.8970784545,
-0.2626330853,
1.0189985037,
0.3017132878,
0.3900537789,
0.9296703339,
0.6214918494,
0.2792414129,
0.0009090467,
0.3352648914,
-0.6694177389,
0.0742260814,
-0.1311037391,
-0.4929628968,
-0.7083668709,
-0.1263926029,
0.6014741659,
0.6798586249,
-0.1534668356,
0.0744099021,
-0.0289765354,
0.8128175139,
-1.3077998161,
0.0910438895,
-0.8086985946,
-0.1067844629,
-0.3114588559,
-0.0696395561,
-0.4820911586,
0.1141665429,
0.1122141406,
-0.4793901145,
0.3775528669,
0.0376070365,
0.5260082483,
0.7070026398,
-0.1680140793,
0.3370782733,
-0.3948886096,
1.2868003845,
-0.6750166416,
0.4999818206,
0.3528981209,
0.166941151,
-0.0227091312,
-0.5292873979,
-0.6182764173,
0.1722447723,
-0.0471346192,
0.403339684,
-0.0913835242,
0.0050343559,
0.1133870184,
0.2366372198,
-0.4433082044,
0.1991620213,
0.0354386643,
-0.035569597,
0.5740381479,
0.1673911959,
-0.0702953562,
0.3259415329,
-0.1907480359,
-0.1603026092,
-0.6358742714,
-0.5129575133,
-0.0478978194,
0.3887059689,
-0.2290726602,
0.2375653088,
-0.2696113586,
1.0673689842,
0.3164055943,
-0.3128792048,
0.0645454898,
-0.3188664317,
-0.429748714,
-0.0173717085,
0.8194546103,
0.222548306,
0.3560289741,
-0.3488878012,
0.0557435416,
0.2549468279,
0.4830523729,
-0.6870920658,
-0.0963043123,
0.5617007017,
-0.2639343143,
-0.1700869501,
-0.1870063692,
-0.8733859658,
-0.379497081,
-0.3354972005,
-0.1849419922,
-0.213360697,
0.0097588934,
0.0187876504,
0.1097412482,
0.492751509,
0.3888578415,
-0.870665133,
0.2051426619,
0.6905342937,
0.8949267864,
-0.7773011327,
-0.4264679253,
-0.748940289,
0.6514160037,
-0.0937022492,
0.9656974673,
-0.6452719569,
-0.3301223516,
-0.2669728994,
-0.1523987949,
-0.40726161,
-0.6288536191,
0.3954697847,
-0.5881839395,
-0.3433939517,
-0.1624810845,
-0.4469417334,
-0.1725506037,
0.0495284274,
-0.6101514697,
0.8722755313,
-0.0078654615,
-0.9126925468,
-0.0200870782,
-0.2561268508,
-0.5837902427,
-0.0133847101,
-0.2372364998,
-0.6799275875,
0.1964025199,
0.5582532883,
0.6913305521,
-0.5933562517,
0.2498693764,
-0.704642117,
-0.3422348201,
0.053660538,
-0.054286629,
0.4704957604,
0.2699227929,
-0.3626238704,
0.1827867329,
-0.7638434768,
-0.0201044343,
0.0411687084,
0.1030758619,
-0.419839114,
0.1203744188,
0.1187805012,
-0.0053790826,
0.2764276862,
-0.3169095516,
-0.1227609143,
-0.1673181802,
0.5217968225,
0.5993064046,
-0.0043079285,
0.199300915,
-0.1281114221,
0.2863523364,
0.4198870659,
-0.1747843772,
-0.1503060013,
-0.2469219118,
-1.1419414282,
-0.5363098383,
0.0856993198,
0.4871122539,
-0.1673369408,
0.5376449227,
-0.2651744783,
-0.5147365928,
-0.6356812716,
0.1618835926,
0.5312954783,
0.5505891442,
0.1598200947,
-0.1369556636,
-0.4872736633,
-1.201113224,
-0.2239866406,
0.0207945183,
0.049675677,
0.5049184561,
0.2591062784,
-0.4084465802,
0.9798529148,
-0.5243692398,
-0.2856475413,
-0.1826523244,
-0.0643247738,
0.0579292066,
0.3660895824,
0.3763908446,
-0.5823919177,
-0.5012708902,
0.2344978303,
-0.6535109282,
-0.3830326796,
-0.26933375,
-0.3989008069,
0.0485129505,
0.4418399036,
-0.6402793527,
0.2104804665,
0.4417279363,
0.1560127139,
0.2589874566,
0.1244627982,
0.0392203629,
-0.9242629409,
0.2015624046,
0.290961951,
-0.3230810165,
-0.5564882755,
0.1673117578,
0.2617479563,
0.1123112515,
-0.4960879385,
0.7206779718,
-0.5927547812,
-0.2239994109,
-0.4515986443,
0.4593808949,
-0.1750743538,
0.8713591695,
0.2319393903,
1.1365771294,
0.7156024575,
-1.0326445103,
0.0513636582,
0.0559391826,
-0.0534439459,
0.7365515232,
-0.8532499671,
0.4829975665,
-0.0033416501,
0.1147250459,
-0.9028074741,
-0.3665736914,
-0.0358926207,
-0.2082601488,
0.2814594209,
0.2551451921,
-0.1908435225,
-0.2745928764,
-0.2625307441,
0.640832901,
0.2186360061,
-0.6261950731,
0.5814814568,
0.9248414636,
0.0230207555,
-0.5892266035,
-0.8834519386,
-0.0831857026,
-0.4201926887,
-0.3876142204,
0.3345037699,
0.0506515987,
-0.2346850485,
-0.1203621626,
-0.1171013191,
-0.201928407,
-0.1676580757,
0.162804544,
0.1021955386,
-0.0828599408,
0.0628112927,
-0.0981071889,
-0.2947990894,
-0.2366167009,
-0.4165861905,
0.569026947,
-0.0938107073,
-0.3837949932,
-0.6748531461,
0.5320740342,
0.8707177043,
-0.4605335891,
0.7107260227,
0.6684828997,
-0.402553767,
-0.0392281339,
-1.0577274561,
-0.134300828,
-0.4218076766,
0.5127230883,
-0.4286638498,
-1.009732604,
0.6065523028,
0.0864824876,
0.0081366124,
0.4655973613,
0.9972838163,
-0.042067118,
0.8496040106,
0.3193119466,
-0.6868951321,
0.387655288,
-0.0710916221,
0.2370014191,
-1.0008420944,
-0.0370484181,
-0.3922882378,
-0.3258264363,
-0.3413252532,
-0.5998144746,
0.3627233505,
-0.2466295958,
-0.1934562773,
0.1696144044,
-0.458108604,
0.560182333,
0.6518447995,
0.2952004373,
0.1104724035,
0.0506051667,
0.2691661119,
-0.0147561869,
-0.7697669864,
-0.1356852502,
0.8926589489,
0.1921908855,
0.8789573908,
-0.1806456149,
0.420969218,
0.2431228012,
-0.0233935174,
-0.7493340969,
0.6668784022,
-0.1098037511,
-0.1895959824,
-0.2442269176,
-0.3995836675,
-1.0768591166,
0.435138166,
0.2767575979,
-0.6638894677,
0.04365905,
0.3522327542,
-0.4736204743,
0.1152963266,
-0.7930530906,
0.7287530303,
0.0613250472,
-0.6502703428,
-0.7251662016,
-0.5993267298,
0.6230156422,
-0.2200845182,
0.0109041743,
0.0389204137,
-0.2051568478,
0.7420671582,
-0.2704895139,
1.1892375946,
0.0984889194,
0.0330456868,
0.5256931186,
-0.3405707777,
0.7567403316,
-0.042565573,
0.187833786,
0.328540951,
-0.1993646622,
-0.6605303884,
-0.6372139454,
1.1189147234,
-0.8540104628,
-0.6811552048,
-0.302189678,
-0.8022209406,
-0.3638092279,
0.1740708798,
-0.162654236,
0.0355758779,
0.0815485939,
0.1214909479,
0.856297493,
0.0132275,
0.4347516298,
0.2664444745,
0.1320159882,
-0.5302449465,
0.8715030551,
-0.1098191142,
0.2517319024,
0.4682210386,
0.1165851951,
-0.1575297415,
-0.5981401205,
-0.1648802459,
0.7509461641,
-0.3841784298,
-0.1721012443,
-1.0727277994,
-0.1691980362,
-0.5471256971,
0.0305720568,
-0.6777711511,
-0.2787888348,
-0.2549862266,
0.2940728366,
0.3334827125,
0.286352545,
0.3645885587,
0.9681255817,
-0.6402739882,
0.3722554445,
0.4139266014,
0.2501926422,
0.360357523,
-0.4020923674,
-0.4346106946,
-0.280372262,
-0.1979209036,
-0.6454265714,
0.4404819906,
0.0875251815,
0.5825685859,
0.7500986457,
-0.0908452347,
1.2173193693,
-0.4872781932,
0.3995313644,
0.0569820143,
-0.786899507,
0.5015713573,
-0.4688851237,
0.7045306563,
0.571947515,
0.0702277869,
-0.433825016,
-0.4907424152,
-0.4012820125,
-0.5845731497,
0.7594866753,
0.057310909,
-0.3830076456,
-0.1890438944,
0.494656831,
-0.0811369643,
0.2085875571,
-0.5418689251,
-0.3352789581,
0.3932170868,
-0.1226196289,
-0.0936513394,
-0.4069624841,
-0.0247694608,
-0.2157485336,
0.7656647563,
-0.1722595245,
0.4537321627,
0.0946038738,
-0.1550057977,
0.1010521054,
-0.1367240101,
0.5629072785,
0.5592013597,
0.0298093986,
0.3563517928,
0.3716857433,
-0.54382658,
-0.1730238795,
-0.4413262606,
-0.0993608236,
-0.3597042859,
0.4208943546,
0.9064849615,
0.2849163413,
-0.6621932983,
0.1589401215,
0.0598549098,
0.1248277575,
-0.2356116474,
0.170703277,
0.3636614084,
0.1595453173,
-0.0976614282,
-0.0753355771,
0.0293511637,
-0.1466285586,
0.2477114052,
0.6401618719,
-0.317198813,
-0.1775417924,
0.6288447976,
0.1714602262,
-0.0449818037,
0.5035000443,
0.1126500592,
-0.2633953691,
0.5106128454,
0.5698009729,
1.171041131,
-0.4207790494,
-0.2800214291,
0.490003556,
0.1176894829,
0.0447678417,
-0.0701635703,
-0.1654974371,
-0.6757630706,
-0.5472843051,
-0.5953092575,
-0.4005513787,
0.32953462,
-0.6546945572,
0.197290048,
-0.3193514645,
-0.1631815583,
-0.0123456866,
-0.1518690884,
-0.4592737556,
0.2364011556,
0.1182423308,
0.5369000435,
-0.741093874,
1.0953257084,
0.4720543325,
0.119960621,
-0.1255867183,
0.0359187089,
-0.0822731629,
-0.9312666059,
0.4077352583,
0.2851902246,
-0.5620234609,
0.1838806272,
-0.476166904,
-0.9927844405,
0.898697257,
0.3972764313,
-0.9567089677,
0.0985026881,
-0.0297712442,
0.2067769915,
-0.5666925311,
0.416636616,
0.9058876038,
0.464240253,
0.221716851,
-0.5111044049,
-0.2233639657,
-0.0404209942,
0.2242100388,
0.0756126493,
-1.2227703333,
0.7025541067,
-0.2753053606,
-0.33940956,
-0.3083765507,
1.1153151989,
0.617615819,
0.3180105686,
0.6984373927,
0.7819415927,
0.7958935499,
0.112597324,
1.1511056423,
-0.5118740797,
0.2250347435,
1.2780123949,
-0.3454524875,
0.8697775602,
0.8427708149,
-0.3418664336,
0.0538198762,
0.9000255466,
0.2606037259,
0.6310817599,
0.0532479696,
-0.3378495574,
-0.6159554124,
-0.1568910927,
-0.12377242,
0.3414392769,
0.3651240468,
0.0143793942,
-0.0476735495,
-0.1458157748,
-0.006416176,
-0.0777776241,
-0.3079114854,
0.5912578702,
0.2133568674,
-0.8896487951,
0.5261695981,
-0.143046096,
0.5586649776,
-0.5522610545,
0.2513847649,
-0.328902334,
0.6202153563,
-0.0587201752,
-0.140806064,
0.3992049396,
-0.1759607792,
-0.4454221725,
0.20501329,
0.651337266,
-0.5595337152,
-0.690040648,
0.402574569,
0.4216392338,
0.2348693758,
-0.4321950078,
-0.5836885571,
0.3475752175,
-0.0237164497,
-0.3569928408,
0.4918110073,
0.256257236,
-0.2161833495,
0.9926441908,
0.4578213096,
0.0785100833,
0.2415215224,
0.2635165453,
0.8248005509,
-0.7373806834,
-0.6773129106,
-1.113083601,
0.013118648,
-0.1446092576,
-0.0293311924,
0.7374073863,
0.5801984668,
0.5501667857,
-0.2386149168,
0.8623231053,
0.3093705177,
0.5253099799,
-0.4428594708,
0.5763295293,
-0.5712149143,
0.0553660989,
-0.1412917376,
-1.0897269249,
-0.5300804973,
0.67917943,
-0.1496840268,
0.215889141,
0.8818738461,
0.8032942414,
-0.2262658775,
-0.0965255946,
0.4146644771,
0.2033520639,
0.1547176838,
0.8281403184,
0.3762138486,
-0.1956391931,
0.1201888248,
-0.1698996425,
-0.277828455,
-0.0316458717,
-0.7832509875,
-1.1420869827,
-0.3285116255,
-0.7176747322,
0.0464033298,
0.0353709012,
0.5240744352,
0.9671932459,
-1.0867393017,
-0.5000223517,
-0.2170081586,
-0.0521215573,
-0.4475772381,
-0.1825170815,
0.637116313,
-0.7210963964,
-1.1007294655,
0.3771108091,
0.5473872423,
-0.2817957699,
-0.4373513162,
0.0208504889,
-0.3336145282,
0.0464242958,
0.6853099465,
0.0753882974,
-1.0631024837,
-0.1821983606,
-0.0961243138,
-0.1876547486,
0.0619741008,
0.8496384621,
-0.8236183524,
0.3058633208,
0.2851810157,
1.1415243149,
0.9674986601,
0.0212506745,
0.5402817726,
-0.6418245435,
0.4309960008,
-0.0067742849,
0.2670815885,
0.1778055131,
-0.4605827928,
0.6558771729,
0.4859392941,
-0.6263196468,
-0.6661100388,
0.0940790847,
-1.5454728603,
-0.0337914787,
1.1691104174,
-0.0638370067,
-0.7325633168,
0.1249105111,
-0.0138654448,
0.3248595595,
-0.3393980861,
0.78637743,
0.7033059597,
-0.2450399548,
-0.529031992,
-0.5719398856,
0.0586763769,
0.8079323769,
-0.8072363138,
0.4441979825,
0.1831285954,
-0.1546170115,
0.1089060307,
0.5212785006,
0.0598625392,
0.086308144,
0.0467266887,
0.2487151176,
0.1286001205,
-0.4181382954,
-0.1362291873,
0.170929864,
-0.3336193562,
-0.5080474019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08053v1
|
Generating Clarification Questions for Disambiguating Contracts
| 2024-03-12T19:57:39 | 2024-03-12T19:57:39 |
Anmol Singhal, Chirag Jain, Preethu Rose Anish, Arkajyoti Chakraborty, Smita Ghaisas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Enterprises frequently enter into commercial contracts that can serve as
vital sources of project-specific requirements. Contractual clauses are
obligatory, and the requirements derived from contracts can detail the
downstream implementation activities that non-legal stakeholders, including
requirement analysts, engineers, and delivery personnel, need to conduct.
However, comprehending contracts is cognitively demanding and error-prone for
such stakeholders due to the extensive use of Legalese and the inherent
complexity of contract language. Furthermore, contracts often contain
ambiguously worded clauses to ensure comprehensive coverage. In contrast,
non-legal stakeholders require a detailed and unambiguous comprehension of
contractual clauses to craft actionable requirements. In this work, we
introduce a novel legal NLP task that involves generating clarification
questions for contracts. These questions aim to identify contract ambiguities
on a document level, thereby assisting non-legal stakeholders in obtaining the
necessary details for eliciting requirements. This task is challenged by three
core issues: (1) data availability, (2) the length and unstructured nature of
contracts, and (3) the complexity of legal text. To address these issues, we
propose ConRAP, a retrieval-augmented prompting framework for generating
clarification questions to disambiguate contractual text. Experiments conducted
on contracts sourced from the publicly available CUAD dataset show that ConRAP
with ChatGPT can detect ambiguities with an F2 score of 0.87. 70% of the
generated clarification questions are deemed useful by human evaluators.
|
[
-0.5424076319,
-0.8795919418,
0.6571461558,
0.1791827679,
-0.5304874182,
-0.0168800354,
0.0320396796,
-0.6104985476,
0.2653557956,
0.7876878977,
-0.5367693901,
-0.5001295805,
-0.6002956629,
-0.0461133346,
-0.2893578112,
0.9509171247,
-0.0967166722,
-0.6383184195,
-0.1329416037,
-0.3013852537,
-0.6913146377,
-0.2951198518,
-0.4411822557,
-0.3317660689,
0.3754796982,
0.7893404961,
0.8847807646,
0.1336065084,
0.1603284925,
0.3059799373,
-0.2600670457,
0.4753838778,
0.1410256922,
0.3098395765,
-0.3269655704,
-0.3546917737,
-0.0039029957,
-0.0648185685,
0.1425042897,
0.9113807678,
-0.3043574989,
0.5120145679,
0.047722131,
0.8287444711,
-0.7646353245,
0.1126686037,
-0.8842394352,
-0.0698767453,
-0.0482137725,
-0.4165003002,
-0.3262441456,
-0.1296718419,
0.1891051829,
-0.8191531897,
0.3299896121,
0.1317961067,
1.3424758911,
0.5376340151,
-0.8010621667,
-0.929743886,
-0.3073536158,
0.3086607754,
-0.3765388131,
0.2884349823,
0.4135345519,
0.1379616708,
-0.2316886932,
-0.925540626,
-0.4301469326,
-0.390280515,
-0.4068589807,
0.2347427756,
-0.3307430744,
0.2600107491,
0.5327563286,
0.1162145659,
-0.4915551245,
-0.1166135073,
-0.5295494795,
-0.0780075267,
0.6706435084,
-0.1809454709,
0.2274381518,
-0.3471767902,
-0.2062204927,
0.4892685115,
-0.509781003,
0.261733681,
0.671901226,
-0.0958530679,
-0.0681456476,
0.6822589636,
-0.2504243553,
0.5637337565,
0.3016121686,
0.3341726363,
0.290225029,
-0.1754310131,
-0.2196199894,
0.1987613589,
0.3116516173,
0.2249879092,
0.2060088813,
-0.2178144306,
0.0173189566,
-0.1948197931,
0.3618382812,
-0.156757459,
-0.0570328385,
0.8444082141,
-0.0738861337,
0.2181121856,
-0.0006158293,
-0.4869385362,
-0.4600870907,
-0.6792055368,
0.0723477453,
-0.326874584,
-0.2016778141,
0.364665091,
-0.3939412236,
0.3910741508,
0.2763600349,
-0.8252592683,
-0.2042023987,
0.5584641695,
0.4178308547,
0.7273808122,
-0.0263233427,
-0.5732952356,
0.2610611618,
-0.1598071307,
0.435902983,
-0.2646571398,
-0.2371204495,
0.1242083758,
-0.2448482215,
-0.0359868072,
-0.4794967771,
0.3938765526,
-0.4124622345,
0.0351439416,
-0.0375796296,
-0.4137035906,
-0.0868921801,
0.5778645277,
-0.579154551,
0.708093524,
0.145529747,
-0.8360963464,
0.6707837582,
-0.6588037014,
-0.2499084026,
0.6424767971,
-0.6517462134,
-0.5811192989,
0.1416576356,
0.0278815422,
0.1601990908,
-0.3384830058,
0.4631048143,
0.1788138002,
0.0706371367,
0.5059119463,
-0.0022768383,
0.8166312575,
0.4332300425,
-0.3911306262,
-0.0104846377,
-0.7144791484,
0.1712828428,
-0.2550899684,
-0.476395607,
-0.179575339,
-0.1850923151,
-0.4056508243,
0.1083069667,
0.4899117649,
-0.3255066872,
-0.1534083188,
-0.3789077699,
0.5731163025,
0.308935374,
0.6131375432,
0.3418750763,
-0.2154334635,
0.7696982622,
-0.0544042177,
0.1880061477,
-0.0156735331,
-0.5599405169,
-0.6448948979,
-0.1799622178,
0.4777673781,
0.4637210369,
-0.9533101916,
0.1347436607,
0.0961215347,
-0.4383315444,
-0.8047445416,
0.2708107233,
0.4722079635,
0.3194431961,
0.3854745924,
0.3825689256,
-0.6734804511,
-1.0466173887,
-0.4321510792,
-0.3552666306,
-0.0032743742,
0.1528683752,
0.5313791037,
0.0009056478,
0.87332654,
-0.4543291628,
-0.1580097377,
-0.3817137182,
0.377248913,
0.3436179161,
0.3429656029,
0.3807436526,
-1.2334359884,
-0.481020242,
0.1199051291,
-0.5041739941,
-0.0859940425,
-0.5340114832,
-0.1763088852,
-0.0389356539,
0.7790142894,
-0.9311825037,
0.2950861752,
0.060947407,
-0.56987077,
0.555600822,
-0.631436944,
-0.0746445134,
-0.7925210595,
0.4208411872,
-0.2214853913,
-0.3243469298,
-0.4636969566,
0.4085865021,
0.0305993129,
0.0101776719,
-0.5874361992,
0.0983718634,
-0.5837932825,
0.2569319308,
0.0655334219,
0.4865827858,
0.3341773748,
0.3310264945,
-0.2346587032,
0.3422454,
0.2485063225,
-1.0238829851,
0.19358325,
0.5508186817,
-0.2724427879,
0.6381353736,
-0.538195312,
-0.0671633258,
-0.3301937878,
-0.074029848,
-0.4501146972,
-0.151407674,
0.3532891273,
-0.4063498378,
0.0403788239,
-0.6015490294,
-0.5777177811,
-0.2774323523,
0.0645175576,
0.3008834124,
0.3255200982,
-0.2097715288,
0.4083461463,
0.6002531648,
0.2226154953,
-0.8765118718,
-0.791834712,
0.1133795455,
-0.4205972552,
-0.5623525977,
0.1708905697,
0.3350542188,
-0.2657875419,
-0.0142147671,
-0.2227314711,
-0.2064640969,
0.4666772187,
0.4669685066,
-0.1850968599,
0.2001802623,
0.1923657954,
0.2082930207,
-0.1317953318,
0.4284374714,
-0.1060239449,
0.2393393666,
0.1365258396,
-0.297845304,
0.0792693645,
0.5422535539,
0.3733641207,
-0.4937264025,
0.1049592122,
0.2258116007,
-0.4166834056,
-0.5641069412,
-0.4120381176,
0.322474122,
-0.490105629,
0.0174444877,
-0.5523000956,
-0.803722024,
0.5106741786,
-0.2715682387,
0.1137113273,
0.2976641357,
0.512339592,
-0.1891777366,
0.3342834711,
0.3954388499,
0.6552060246,
0.1083895862,
-0.2470796406,
0.1578919291,
-0.4324012995,
-0.5919956565,
-0.6649758816,
-0.2805612087,
-0.7810682654,
-0.2000892609,
0.3183302283,
0.0748090893,
0.1961225718,
0.509822309,
-0.5634790659,
0.465875715,
0.6240796447,
0.1331638992,
0.2558221817,
-0.3652566075,
-0.3853688538,
0.2741887569,
-0.4229479432,
-0.6366546154,
0.5385859609,
0.1657695472,
0.2070489675,
0.3699222207,
0.8131042719,
0.3969939351,
-0.2628159225,
-0.4943342507,
0.4848953187,
0.0390828848,
-0.987254262,
-0.304420054,
-0.2636060417,
-1.6207891703,
0.2114251405,
-0.3276785612,
-0.5453326106,
0.4821562171,
0.3606216609,
-0.4183833003,
-0.2111424804,
-0.6667595506,
1.0001779795,
-0.0707575306,
-0.2347376496,
-0.2262604982,
-0.8576055765,
0.1594095528,
-0.1134230793,
0.3272897899,
-0.4112271965,
-0.2528247833,
0.2971000671,
-0.7134832144,
0.511625886,
-0.4749285877,
-0.0434972905,
0.8826307058,
0.0314891711,
0.2739282548,
0.5143615007,
-0.2040142268,
-0.4329308867,
0.3581180274,
-0.4013424516,
-0.5507717729,
0.3464392424,
-0.3267337382,
-0.5891568065,
-0.3341869712,
-0.5523073077,
-0.3409554958,
0.1993764043,
0.1663214117,
-0.0148019632,
0.1525773704,
0.0359656513,
0.38447088,
-0.2295400947,
0.2041006684,
0.701693356,
0.1038288176,
-0.0084429011,
0.3881770074,
0.3435201347,
0.0209893901,
0.2001060545,
-0.0937304646,
-0.5934803486,
-0.7658661604,
-0.2745929658,
0.3384613097,
-0.9127447605,
-0.3271416128,
-0.313392967,
-0.0374221168,
-0.0706324354,
-0.2607761621,
0.1341658831,
-0.5103572607,
-0.1989508718,
-0.3524204493,
0.374402076,
0.6236552596,
0.1143353656,
-0.0295507889,
-0.801692009,
0.4638864398,
-0.0704698712,
0.127816692,
-0.6501389742,
-0.2503462136,
-0.3415875435,
-0.0178158097,
-0.3500354588,
-1.0610021353,
0.1153787896,
-0.0483661816,
0.6022858024,
-0.0021018484,
0.6171584725,
0.6267234087,
-0.2734255493,
0.7869740129,
0.1657336205,
-1.0662610531,
0.6978812814,
-0.1518697143,
0.2835467458,
0.9370028377,
0.2663497925,
-0.4262143672,
-0.8557460904,
-1.088226676,
-1.3282760382,
0.3880242705,
0.4421499372,
0.1944081336,
-0.1681742221,
0.9367097616,
0.0477424599,
0.524636507,
-0.4617576897,
-0.1921188086,
0.2485016286,
-0.0781224146,
0.4187974632,
-0.2323674709,
-0.1323772669,
0.2618685961,
0.5928145051,
0.0801559612,
-0.2362080961,
0.4469884038,
-0.3105891943,
0.2567222416,
0.6896703243,
0.4394708574,
1.0144096613,
-0.0557440892,
0.3999351263,
0.1593026966,
-0.2512308955,
0.2296379209,
0.0911819637,
-0.3926073015,
0.594943285,
0.0324501656,
0.4234223068,
-0.1106395721,
-0.7300374508,
0.4018357098,
0.2357681394,
-0.7122511864,
-0.7182546258,
-0.1910999715,
0.0743290409,
0.3492791355,
0.1794573069,
-0.1706743836,
0.1481609643,
-0.1822624654,
0.4853326976,
0.3556632698,
-0.1890940964,
0.2012313157,
0.6699543595,
0.2761041522,
0.0165896229,
0.5418503284,
-0.3716855943,
-0.0782165304,
0.6643669605,
0.0577028953,
0.5758826137,
0.372372061,
0.4249153435,
0.3274027407,
0.4901915491,
0.1724328995,
0.540866971,
-0.0900621042,
-0.2860940993,
-0.5857881904,
-0.1116505861,
-0.5397663116,
0.1032184139,
-0.7292460799,
0.5866678357,
-0.5525058508,
-0.3607249856,
0.1706440896,
0.0072685652,
-0.7023278475,
0.272020191,
-0.0419070125,
0.8826602101,
-0.5244578719,
0.6931883097,
0.8627444506,
-1.0476058722,
-0.8968041539,
-0.0841417611,
-0.420594126,
-0.4198236763,
0.4614669681,
-0.0395466052,
0.0614558496,
-0.1118675172,
-0.5603436828,
-0.2680737376,
1.180126071,
0.8010507226,
-0.5533548594,
-0.3580174446,
0.7019043565,
0.5307229757,
0.2237685472,
0.0454952791,
0.5088226795,
0.607005775,
0.0219234619,
-0.675147593,
0.3813950121,
-0.1667290628,
-0.4713202119,
0.3313146532,
-0.3100125194,
0.409430474,
-0.0890470967,
-0.3256383836,
-0.1469624937,
0.4599219859,
0.3724766672,
0.7311953902,
0.5563778281,
0.2704147995,
1.0564424992,
-0.0105289621,
0.8473005295,
-0.4452005625,
0.1767670512,
1.2417765856,
0.1676728427,
0.5682540536,
1.0192507505,
0.036630895,
0.4008549154,
0.5816986561,
-0.0523065664,
-0.0436828509,
0.8128407001,
-0.0010254583,
-0.3586140573,
-0.2758704126,
-0.2510322332,
0.2359893769,
0.3707948327,
-0.229323864,
-0.3647740185,
-0.2185024768,
0.1190054044,
0.4813575447,
-0.1309200078,
0.7220230103,
0.2550635338,
-0.9711965322,
0.3975889683,
0.2641136646,
0.1635749936,
-0.815577507,
-0.1150049269,
-0.1323678344,
0.0447661281,
-0.5684699416,
-0.9244930744,
0.6730142236,
0.0893151909,
-0.02889302,
-0.2113847882,
0.1486429423,
-0.5123932362,
-0.0798218027,
0.1563611776,
0.3850517571,
0.330098331,
-0.2025383413,
-1.1328303814,
-0.2788498998,
0.1556435972,
0.1174352318,
-0.0757919773,
1.0434401035,
-0.1004673019,
0.5507063866,
0.3951096535,
0.0225547049,
0.2989893556,
-0.0135534583,
0.6766009331,
-0.347296387,
-0.5614645481,
-0.5788394213,
1.0375330448,
-0.0924377739,
-0.4634135067,
0.7194090486,
0.6816458702,
0.6215485334,
-0.0716730878,
0.6626190543,
-0.2917010486,
0.3106645942,
-0.8358337879,
0.3519459069,
-0.4703579545,
0.5809851885,
0.0319556259,
-0.5180124044,
-0.4076798856,
0.2086932212,
-0.0794565156,
-0.3763303757,
0.7616959214,
0.4983173609,
-0.0386395268,
-0.2524709702,
0.1279321909,
-0.1382400542,
0.3876338601,
0.5300032496,
0.7739165425,
-0.5135083795,
1.109478116,
-0.0967336446,
0.1614536941,
-0.1391988397,
-0.8958328962,
-0.5682110786,
-0.7678601146,
-0.9728780985,
-0.6706452966,
-0.1073620021,
0.8797664046,
0.3652453721,
-0.6158269048,
-0.1384563446,
-0.3879210651,
0.3551732302,
-0.0856842026,
-0.1560135335,
0.2772178948,
-0.8540396094,
-0.5446563959,
0.1319683492,
-0.0386456959,
0.0389140472,
0.0662458837,
-0.1257338971,
-0.5223366022,
0.2902023494,
-0.0166846216,
0.4249365628,
-0.5337684751,
-0.1838345677,
-0.5620080233,
0.0044360207,
-0.198699832,
1.0093535185,
-0.1831919104,
0.3886161447,
0.4640685022,
0.57725209,
0.6375493407,
0.1224945709,
0.4260607064,
-1.2489670515,
0.3108800948,
0.3039425313,
0.44039011,
0.0917617455,
-0.5680966377,
0.6185569763,
-0.2052426487,
-0.5128865838,
-0.5527411103,
0.4927915931,
-1.04804039,
-0.4117377996,
1.0505424738,
-0.1566931754,
-0.0769627392,
-0.8224183917,
-0.4309013784,
0.2055352777,
-0.283504039,
0.5998165011,
0.5336483717,
-0.0030159527,
-0.0274509843,
-0.6759742498,
0.7629188299,
0.4398293793,
-0.5777313709,
0.1272251606,
0.5697956085,
0.0137132248,
0.3195390999,
0.5741580725,
-0.0584050156,
0.3663387895,
-0.0053672618,
-0.0389714353,
-0.2084382772,
0.1925466806,
0.1067810431,
0.5506529212,
0.5083245039,
-0.4962329268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08046v1
|
Big City Bias: Evaluating the Impact of Metropolitan Size on Computational Job Market Abilities of Language Models
| 2024-03-12T19:40:18 | 2024-03-12T19:40:18 |
Charlie Campanella, Rob van der Goot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a useful technology for job
matching, for both candidates and employers. Job matching is often based on a
particular geographic location, such as a city or region. However, LLMs have
known biases, commonly derived from their training data. In this work, we aim
to quantify the metropolitan size bias encoded within large language models,
evaluating zero-shot salary, employer presence, and commute duration
predictions in 384 of the United States' metropolitan regions. Across all
benchmarks, we observe negative correlations between the metropolitan size and
the performance of the LLMS, indicating that smaller regions are indeed
underrepresented. More concretely, the smallest 10 metropolitan regions show
upwards of 300% worse benchmark performance than the largest 10.
|
[
-0.529902935,
-0.5576279163,
1.0704817772,
0.0711362287,
0.1490393877,
-0.1968745589,
-0.2355964929,
-0.7191742659,
0.4165382385,
0.4311651886,
-0.3653464615,
-0.33211869,
-0.5830572844,
0.0193737447,
-0.4009879529,
0.390186429,
0.3746640086,
0.3843844235,
-0.2803383768,
0.1789633483,
-0.6101384759,
-0.6261703968,
-0.413089633,
-0.5254104137,
0.2642325461,
0.4902411401,
0.8623444438,
0.9483591318,
0.3988620043,
0.2567276657,
-0.0211492013,
-0.4062086046,
-0.4462367594,
-0.1460217088,
-0.211820364,
-0.6412858367,
-0.2995806634,
0.1315468401,
0.6051288843,
1.109592557,
-0.1627427936,
0.3014786541,
-0.2464933097,
0.5931764841,
-0.7445514202,
-0.0158148166,
-0.8175997734,
-0.0030055528,
-0.4838601351,
-0.1032519713,
-0.093884103,
-0.4573576748,
0.1657548845,
-0.1782329381,
0.4317064285,
0.2765053213,
0.58022964,
0.3194274008,
-0.6827150583,
-0.1126268357,
-0.8225328326,
0.9964838028,
-0.5035430193,
0.3528415859,
0.6091811061,
0.5698324442,
-0.106328994,
0.0342262499,
-0.40627262,
0.019613754,
-0.1241080761,
-0.0482505299,
-0.1664318591,
0.0906841382,
0.5695691109,
0.4475554526,
-0.45904544,
0.5687429905,
-0.588532269,
0.1316661239,
0.5459189415,
0.5196734667,
0.0440383814,
0.1873404235,
0.1341357231,
0.0422506556,
-0.8933467269,
-0.1868231744,
0.4313426018,
0.2496558577,
-0.0851455852,
0.5870607495,
-0.3230979145,
0.6145328879,
-0.0181610323,
-0.2247458845,
0.208948195,
-0.2882030308,
-0.3783740699,
0.0848842934,
0.7559507489,
0.3756451905,
0.3040694594,
-0.1292827427,
-0.1670197099,
-0.1991804689,
0.2603678703,
-0.6439520717,
0.1699301898,
0.229121685,
-0.3538490832,
0.0488942116,
-0.2240215689,
-0.8596009612,
-0.7922832966,
-0.2598950267,
-0.1388730109,
0.3716868162,
0.0856495351,
0.0676879585,
-0.3465892076,
0.2930615544,
0.1897480786,
-1.075761199,
0.1125801578,
0.6241663694,
0.7473495007,
0.0712695494,
-0.4006865323,
-0.1275388747,
0.0898442864,
-0.5525560975,
0.7508947253,
-0.617521286,
-0.3411562443,
0.1495915502,
-0.2444145083,
-0.0925469697,
-0.9880453348,
0.3085758388,
-0.3576613963,
-0.1975976378,
-0.4043734372,
-0.0680819228,
0.1458564848,
0.2884922624,
-0.6079250574,
0.884452045,
0.2440255582,
-0.6546766162,
0.5763475895,
-0.6458102465,
-0.3690857589,
-0.2344469279,
-0.3200291097,
-0.2959116101,
0.3614620268,
0.3869029284,
0.3409984112,
-0.5853771567,
0.18105115,
-0.6781333685,
-0.6558428407,
0.4290356934,
-0.2738989294,
0.7874723077,
0.1373835504,
-0.33987692,
-0.24045147,
-0.609446466,
-0.4440751672,
0.0556927435,
-0.210249871,
-0.4253728986,
-0.0180636998,
-0.3223433197,
0.3787483871,
0.1884119958,
-0.9745876193,
0.1994310617,
-0.5453976393,
0.2484859526,
0.5797470808,
-0.208960712,
0.8808499575,
-0.3009031713,
0.7485347986,
0.0519538745,
0.0819540098,
0.3032213449,
-0.1139817834,
-0.5445720553,
-0.2516931593,
0.0371883921,
0.3012210429,
-0.7188808918,
-0.0133922314,
-0.5503026843,
-0.6807787418,
-0.3509141207,
-0.1824471951,
-0.1616279781,
0.1243149415,
0.0279341303,
0.0702373013,
-0.8653758168,
-1.283218503,
-0.2663095593,
0.368573904,
-0.351313442,
0.2757665515,
0.6255544424,
-0.2400780767,
1.1575739384,
-0.6344726086,
-0.4207163751,
-0.1898422241,
-0.4790471196,
0.6653181911,
0.1366741359,
0.7555249929,
-0.1002863199,
-0.5344361663,
-0.2842867076,
-0.372767061,
-0.3912096024,
0.1500300467,
-0.0348873511,
-0.0309053641,
0.5285204649,
-0.583798945,
0.4180680215,
1.0123630762,
-0.36120525,
0.7794751525,
-0.0763103738,
-0.0428093299,
-0.8414618969,
0.0968534052,
0.415052861,
-0.1821061522,
-0.4879193306,
-0.3309666812,
-0.3961306512,
-0.3843220174,
-0.1473084837,
0.6595540643,
-0.5018804073,
-0.7725667357,
-0.3591487706,
0.2787326574,
-0.2022735924,
0.1263802946,
0.1479549557,
0.8281292915,
0.3355983794,
-0.3217048347,
0.0810997188,
-0.0070202751,
-0.8317129016,
0.5262337327,
-0.5661399961,
-0.065924786,
-0.1523476243,
0.7866061926,
-0.6779444814,
-0.0929053873,
-0.3930284381,
-0.1045714393,
-0.3045736253,
-0.1887264401,
-0.75404495,
-0.6363572478,
-0.1727565229,
0.4956602156,
0.2616280615,
-0.3944320977,
0.0975121707,
0.6005086303,
-0.1504509747,
-0.4803001285,
-1.2426228523,
0.150570035,
-0.174476549,
-0.3444377184,
-0.013349372,
0.0205660481,
-0.5858845115,
-0.4285283387,
0.3323534727,
-0.5414391756,
0.1393929869,
0.3741728663,
0.178532809,
0.0892403275,
-0.2750760615,
-0.3084375858,
-0.1099580899,
0.2478870898,
-0.1176940799,
0.5483527184,
0.3701034784,
-0.3172911406,
-0.0823102072,
0.1831531674,
0.8865430355,
0.0391353257,
0.9261177778,
0.4681329727,
-0.2287505716,
-0.143750295,
-0.502440989,
-0.2124837637,
-0.4508147538,
0.374896735,
-0.1057440937,
-1.017124176,
0.5163143277,
0.2255315632,
-0.0100227529,
0.4491697252,
0.7267190218,
0.1873134077,
1.0136816502,
0.5615079999,
-0.2853985429,
0.4819341004,
-0.0547161624,
0.4056373239,
-0.710450232,
0.0549651794,
-0.8810958266,
-0.5941486955,
-0.6699929833,
-0.4861417115,
0.5160061121,
-0.2887066901,
-0.5002643466,
0.1257849932,
-0.3697899282,
0.6828347445,
0.8637571931,
-0.3532812595,
0.0619063862,
0.0716020465,
-0.0004292432,
-0.165419966,
-0.7952646613,
-0.1869582683,
1.2266685963,
0.5996512771,
0.4965053797,
0.2597174942,
0.2849856317,
0.1407442242,
0.1898522824,
-0.634860754,
0.3283312917,
-0.2223933786,
-0.9257321358,
-0.2179164439,
-0.5420969725,
-1.1194148064,
0.2684336305,
-0.4595244229,
-0.9510458708,
0.4447321892,
-0.1055790558,
-0.3125190139,
0.276594162,
-0.5106400251,
0.5640630722,
0.0956309438,
-0.0051089912,
-0.3196079731,
0.0073095975,
0.3956840634,
-0.4034372866,
0.751101017,
-0.2555342317,
0.1460781842,
0.4761174321,
-0.4467581511,
0.8154257536,
-0.1754036099,
-0.0450071804,
-0.0623344257,
0.1124467775,
0.4949920774,
-0.3360242844,
-0.5621637702,
0.818791151,
0.2187358141,
-0.5538962483,
-0.2444772124,
0.8180797696,
-0.7779678106,
-0.2282708138,
-0.3321640491,
-0.8528641462,
-0.4202310741,
0.2505405843,
0.3208532929,
0.4778530598,
0.0098871607,
0.219205901,
0.2152175456,
-0.3274470568,
0.4309788942,
0.6954798102,
-0.4110470414,
-0.3111491203,
0.4472869635,
0.4413160682,
-0.0514499061,
0.1251166314,
0.2521920502,
-0.3690609038,
-0.5453670621,
-0.0821125656,
0.2050126344,
-0.3761312068,
-0.0489220396,
-0.2191817313,
-0.0319508128,
-0.4877167046,
-0.4477716088,
-0.5058287978,
-0.0597795956,
0.1694662273,
0.0996920243,
-0.3333414197,
1.1641361713,
-0.0013488169,
0.4582667947,
-0.4122974873,
-0.1855685413,
0.0824655443,
0.6084487438,
0.1440758109,
-0.3433193266,
-0.9855437279,
0.252009362,
-0.1536387503,
-0.451230675,
0.3589231372,
-0.4184372723,
0.4682092667,
0.3033615351,
-0.0904488117,
0.6209641695,
-0.5063091516,
0.9451489449,
0.2630729973,
-0.5612418652,
0.2151615769,
-0.6882575154,
0.8544620275,
0.4701354206,
0.2069944888,
-0.4495576024,
-0.4766130745,
-0.4632992744,
-0.3744519651,
0.6511699557,
0.0655913055,
0.05517691,
-0.3146519959,
0.3161506951,
-0.1186008006,
0.3443953991,
-0.6748664379,
-0.4573372006,
0.3673335016,
0.023383446,
-0.2669793963,
-0.5929551125,
0.0003699319,
-0.2532056272,
0.3671815097,
0.1356457025,
0.439458698,
0.0548343025,
0.1472753137,
-0.19748649,
0.3372077346,
0.8654552102,
0.913954258,
-0.1374654621,
0.2230415195,
0.4821798801,
-0.3661541343,
-0.0673507452,
-0.1636942923,
-0.1947534531,
0.157473892,
0.4478980899,
0.4155849516,
-0.0225275066,
-0.7840423584,
0.6697958708,
0.0307294708,
-0.396838069,
-0.6709456444,
-0.2256368995,
-0.0375264324,
0.4404064417,
0.5347759724,
-0.1200517491,
0.1537607908,
-0.6995026469,
-0.3415630162,
0.5321646333,
-0.5831394196,
-0.1000394821,
0.5127605796,
0.1842324734,
0.1039161608,
0.5202477574,
-0.1161779985,
-0.6009127498,
0.7137820721,
0.5163424015,
0.6621382833,
0.0121763153,
-0.3703590631,
0.4964663982,
0.5125496387,
-0.151489079,
-0.2556730211,
0.4669478238,
-0.7598928213,
-0.6584255099,
-0.5872280002,
-0.2266848236,
0.1871053129,
-0.2875409424,
0.2282010168,
-0.5776507854,
-0.4161943495,
-0.1567134857,
0.0873026773,
-0.8879646659,
0.2673555315,
0.4507213235,
0.798964262,
-0.8905496597,
0.8005594015,
0.8323561549,
0.0257025026,
-0.574185729,
0.1152965873,
0.2518496215,
-0.7134982944,
0.7086518407,
0.137818858,
0.1412445009,
-0.3768227398,
-0.3379333019,
-1.1171113253,
1.1056990623,
0.5575039983,
-0.8236672282,
0.0147670712,
0.6933544278,
0.5255078077,
-0.4818936586,
0.6439759135,
0.7343984246,
0.2553901076,
-0.1406798214,
-1.4654427767,
-0.1569226682,
0.4166126847,
0.135888651,
0.1786946803,
-0.5706439018,
0.7373739481,
0.1295104027,
-0.0458861366,
-0.3264557123,
0.0443400778,
0.0915605873,
0.2661621869,
0.3679512143,
0.7370895147,
0.6284966469,
-0.10822054,
1.1889103651,
-0.4861958623,
0.5165593624,
1.0185114145,
-0.1996190846,
0.7842050791,
0.2246401012,
-0.3271031678,
0.6214843988,
0.4387073219,
-0.0582336523,
0.2395479381,
0.4078756571,
0.0421946347,
-0.1524011493,
-0.3483575583,
-0.0856163278,
0.6320652366,
0.0880846679,
-0.191772446,
-0.3619128466,
-0.0618830472,
0.0521401763,
0.0912797228,
-0.6598415375,
0.4771305919,
0.0996923745,
-0.4741805792,
0.3347083032,
0.0503292084,
0.6893181801,
-0.2801214457,
0.1716733128,
-0.3439132869,
0.2378021777,
-0.3320421875,
-0.8880749941,
0.6299260855,
-0.1256352812,
-0.5384287238,
-0.1115189642,
0.5038274527,
-0.3491539657,
-0.2371421754,
0.2480772138,
0.2414764911,
0.2365804762,
-0.4305505753,
-0.5995081067,
0.328379333,
-0.0752732977,
-0.0268653743,
0.6197367311,
0.2765473723,
0.1406394392,
0.8343300819,
0.6133446097,
0.215695411,
-0.228681162,
0.085312739,
0.2838279307,
-0.6802386045,
-0.6040303707,
-0.9769600034,
0.095580861,
-0.1480797827,
0.0520600416,
0.9385609031,
0.725320518,
0.503408134,
0.0780873746,
0.7558526993,
0.1421161145,
0.7652483582,
-0.2312306613,
0.4203610718,
-0.3660571873,
0.4708647132,
-0.1122446805,
-1.3421177864,
-0.0628657788,
0.4274124503,
-1.1182612181,
0.2976064682,
0.7488180399,
0.7913174629,
-0.0870239735,
-0.4166508913,
0.6524185538,
0.3083431423,
0.1323370934,
0.4512044489,
0.5776547194,
-0.1006921083,
0.4192506671,
-0.2521649003,
-0.0326121785,
-0.5433751941,
-0.698749423,
-0.916184783,
-0.1562272012,
-0.115489468,
-0.4327087104,
-0.3466513455,
0.6183344126,
0.8874791861,
-0.4270775914,
-0.5364929438,
0.1855750829,
0.0768056735,
0.1651692986,
-0.2875524461,
0.0201841779,
0.171906352,
-0.7195143104,
0.4117292762,
0.2541529834,
-0.020679161,
-0.6122984886,
0.2265587747,
0.0544727072,
0.2717802823,
0.6735665798,
-0.02808097,
-0.4352046549,
-0.3457418382,
-0.1722327471,
-0.5956385136,
-0.1414838284,
0.7697865963,
-0.5294671059,
0.193753913,
0.2201918215,
0.3055423498,
0.4468087256,
0.0356174894,
0.7844952941,
-0.7861609459,
0.2697826624,
-0.2415436804,
0.3997121155,
0.2821736336,
-0.1627518535,
0.5293289423,
0.153947562,
-0.9917343855,
-0.4594536126,
0.0859978944,
-0.5669918656,
-0.5116245747,
1.4149032831,
0.4805727303,
-0.165842399,
-0.2493233383,
0.1313765049,
-0.3135452867,
-0.3166463971,
0.7884203196,
0.6355376244,
0.2054799497,
-0.0726679116,
-1.2163459063,
0.1270642728,
0.1563039869,
-0.4021160603,
0.1847200245,
0.8775419593,
0.4003848732,
0.0413983688,
0.8052894473,
0.2715173364,
0.1533271819,
0.3018615842,
0.263941586,
0.1050729826,
0.115699701,
-0.492636174,
-0.0005077686,
0.4532365799,
0.1136164293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08043v1
|
Authorship Style Transfer with Policy Optimization
| 2024-03-12T19:34:54 | 2024-03-12T19:34:54 |
Shuai Liu, Shantanu Agarwal, Jonathan May
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Authorship style transfer aims to rewrite a given text into a specified
target while preserving the original meaning in the source. Existing approaches
rely on the availability of a large number of target style exemplars for model
training. However, these overlook cases where a limited number of target style
examples are available. The development of parameter-efficient transfer
learning techniques and policy optimization (PO) approaches suggest lightweight
PO is a feasible approach to low-resource style transfer. In this work, we
propose a simple two step tune-and-optimize technique for low-resource textual
style transfer. We apply our technique to authorship transfer as well as a
larger-data native language style task and in both cases find it outperforms
state-of-the-art baseline models.
|
[
0.0178751554,
-0.5604320765,
0.5696820021,
0.1094162315,
-0.2283598781,
-0.1028979868,
-0.6036405563,
-0.3368233442,
0.3547914624,
0.8651559353,
-0.7245104909,
0.0213344768,
-0.5578176975,
0.2134687603,
0.0163732227,
1.3053199053,
-0.143084392,
-0.4570382237,
-0.1149745956,
0.0961606652,
-0.3679624498,
0.1175310686,
-0.967920661,
-0.2449510545,
0.4621434212,
0.8183766007,
0.6450104713,
0.7015177608,
0.6828854084,
0.1938071698,
-0.0091857789,
0.2172180414,
-0.8234114647,
-0.05178532,
-0.3524284959,
-0.2739234865,
-0.6542574763,
0.0564991161,
0.4618337154,
0.5594328642,
-0.0116598113,
0.4216162264,
0.1229375005,
0.6838546991,
-1.0878257751,
-0.0362991951,
-0.625680387,
-0.1395261288,
-0.0879523307,
-0.4042556286,
-0.7449247837,
-0.6898467541,
0.199830085,
-0.9441443682,
0.0115093449,
0.1619457155,
0.5371479392,
-0.0448738746,
-0.3954634368,
-0.1666385084,
-0.704292655,
1.1249930859,
-0.5302669406,
-0.1757443547,
0.4187503457,
0.0991836339,
0.2525421083,
-0.6201736927,
-0.5554193258,
-0.1989529431,
-0.2922036946,
-0.0294783413,
-0.0012064135,
-0.0842081085,
0.0322441161,
0.0987383276,
-0.4442151785,
0.1207042485,
-0.4654360116,
-0.1601418108,
0.9616973996,
-0.140430674,
0.1234459728,
-0.2020356506,
-0.5480149984,
-0.2903234661,
-0.4334118664,
0.2874211371,
0.4549263716,
0.5417205691,
-0.1201634482,
0.1046028137,
-0.1920038909,
0.5093668103,
0.0947851688,
-0.4921165407,
0.0064740754,
-0.7260277867,
0.20044294,
0.1828774363,
0.7067447901,
0.3686181307,
0.4378243089,
-0.2465298474,
-0.244057402,
-0.4707479477,
0.3948622942,
-0.6493329406,
0.0081273122,
-0.4330633283,
-0.581327498,
-0.5567498803,
0.0628191307,
-1.0844804049,
-0.3115179837,
-0.7387899756,
0.6630455852,
-0.3530309796,
-0.1566836536,
0.0721167102,
-0.0654273927,
0.4450833499,
0.5071963668,
-1.1688952446,
0.3356421888,
0.5843292475,
0.8373883963,
-0.4636615813,
-0.1615513116,
-0.8644136786,
0.2878361046,
-0.5509796739,
0.4002050161,
-0.3874517679,
-0.3770784438,
0.06631919,
0.0186203476,
-0.2066650838,
0.0403314643,
0.4884717166,
-0.1476777345,
0.0836282521,
-0.4457945526,
-0.1847429574,
0.2877169847,
-0.3524369597,
-0.5345767736,
0.9152254462,
0.3343359232,
-0.2513130903,
0.3926149011,
-0.6690089107,
-0.9508572817,
-0.1531583369,
0.4424499571,
-0.4933065772,
0.1565364301,
0.122076273,
0.477306515,
-0.2426178008,
-0.0811594129,
-0.2303619832,
-0.5710579157,
-0.0704113767,
0.1380969584,
0.829852283,
0.500582695,
-0.2439842671,
-0.1308498383,
-0.6093146205,
0.0140417274,
0.1384870261,
-0.2683170736,
-0.5350604653,
-0.3376464248,
0.3597944677,
-0.1520035714,
0.4985198081,
-0.5145716667,
0.7336025238,
-0.0257361811,
0.4517267942,
0.7488543391,
0.0968223065,
0.9977716804,
-0.5718501806,
0.6006373167,
-1.0972127914,
0.2761606872,
0.2644875646,
-0.178704083,
-0.3580230474,
-0.2392995358,
0.0389727876,
0.7391049266,
-0.8162570596,
0.2949304581,
-0.3981318474,
-0.4829326272,
-0.5478917956,
0.4654408693,
0.5349407196,
0.5167860389,
0.4292760789,
-0.1554161012,
-0.1916315109,
-0.9071247578,
-0.7028028369,
-0.0711280182,
0.2102090865,
0.1206087396,
0.4607827961,
0.4368642271,
0.7273845673,
-0.6144037843,
-0.4178186953,
-0.6149637699,
0.4320652485,
-0.0119839115,
0.9152195454,
0.9181234837,
-0.6039357781,
-0.7756622434,
0.2032898813,
-0.418405503,
-0.2278885841,
-0.5216805935,
-0.5290660858,
0.0953005031,
0.8683030009,
-0.157098636,
0.1596503854,
0.374060601,
-0.2246402651,
0.4628552198,
-0.1395325661,
0.3015793264,
-1.211224556,
0.2904197574,
-0.0872247964,
-0.1770534962,
-0.5809826255,
-0.0081355469,
-0.0048417319,
-0.3594348431,
-0.3599230051,
0.6980028749,
-0.6930616498,
0.1194575951,
-0.134580642,
-0.1423587501,
0.150000453,
0.6854166389,
-0.0493523926,
0.8268865943,
0.4006015658,
-0.1861918718,
0.1419899762,
0.2821211219,
-0.3219008148,
1.1358253956,
-0.4977460206,
0.6768687963,
-0.3070263863,
0.0148351798,
-1.0547133684,
0.0179070774,
0.1169812605,
0.0630005971,
0.8405818343,
-0.5751578212,
-0.5025357008,
0.1171677187,
-0.4190695882,
0.2675932348,
0.7532842159,
-0.2291701585,
0.4727626741,
-0.0468421206,
-0.4930060208,
-0.3625549972,
-0.5507669449,
0.0333113261,
-0.4001339674,
-0.3997787535,
0.8843061924,
0.2588346601,
-0.0574959181,
0.0343945101,
-0.0419807956,
-0.1541674137,
0.031275738,
-0.4920728207,
0.217938602,
-0.1647050679,
-0.2196231484,
0.3876880705,
0.1349965483,
-0.2045574635,
-0.0860642716,
-0.0256209727,
0.130350396,
0.1181531474,
-0.7631886005,
0.3502001762,
0.6322240233,
-0.3054120839,
0.832867682,
0.7375004888,
0.0847411603,
-0.6291097999,
-0.3166363239,
-0.3951865733,
-0.4684277773,
0.2397954762,
-0.2651980221,
-0.5069091916,
0.0382251814,
-0.156504944,
0.2424026281,
0.2818433344,
0.00851057,
0.0632006228,
0.2917779684,
1.0040102005,
-0.2032379806,
0.9988113046,
-0.2875157595,
0.0108616725,
-0.7335594296,
0.0178554803,
-0.6765398979,
-0.6373060346,
-0.5820822716,
-0.1748288572,
0.4057501256,
0.0170274302,
-0.127257973,
0.94777596,
-0.5720655918,
0.5556345582,
0.7222046256,
0.2160258591,
0.2516939938,
0.1219071075,
0.3213372827,
-0.0779511705,
-0.4711907506,
-0.4188266397,
1.139616847,
-0.1345914155,
0.9682943821,
0.2970051765,
0.8893403411,
0.479667902,
0.0151371099,
-0.7213465571,
0.5573288798,
-0.5682099462,
-0.2393254936,
-0.7569466829,
-0.4246121049,
-0.7886114717,
0.0907430872,
-0.5151190162,
-0.8153649569,
0.5270933509,
0.244340688,
-0.0589223914,
0.2773015201,
-0.6023523808,
0.9286495447,
-0.0404259749,
-0.6683039665,
-0.0324380063,
-0.7270792127,
0.2741097212,
-0.1484296322,
0.146315068,
-0.0669933781,
-0.1641833037,
0.9073550105,
-0.3983824849,
0.6678850651,
-0.1129245162,
-0.1575691253,
0.1514802128,
0.2983727753,
1.0070816278,
-0.3355694711,
-0.2496926636,
-0.2455971092,
-0.0136735691,
-0.4900143445,
-0.5863419771,
0.39453879,
-0.6502600908,
-0.1201201901,
-0.0327098519,
-0.4886936545,
-0.3049203753,
0.3061618805,
0.5871529579,
0.3758803904,
-0.0736487508,
0.5348596573,
0.4760884941,
0.0416053608,
0.4241341949,
0.3817526996,
0.4328541756,
-0.1709436476,
0.9284695983,
0.1074459404,
0.6190975904,
0.5920834541,
0.4455878139,
-0.2091739774,
-0.4241477251,
-0.4634367526,
0.1939366311,
-0.4458884597,
0.076431118,
-0.1873855442,
0.1521372348,
-0.5879319906,
-0.8760076165,
-0.4255604148,
-0.3600234389,
-0.3173453808,
0.452791512,
0.5813689232,
0.2779403627,
0.1331264377,
0.6648811698,
-0.2369795889,
0.4036537111,
0.3159739673,
0.1461287886,
-0.3392010331,
-0.8824201226,
-0.0640049949,
-0.4289587438,
-0.1931524426,
-0.8789077401,
0.1046467796,
0.6602976322,
0.403365612,
0.3948308825,
0.594184339,
0.365827322,
-0.3451190889,
0.3152168691,
0.098893553,
-0.9490859509,
0.7355536819,
-0.4463861585,
0.0603731163,
1.2073124647,
0.2220062017,
-0.3636376858,
-0.0408957861,
-0.3279796541,
-0.6384942532,
0.9191724062,
0.2803639174,
0.2310046852,
0.5364508629,
0.5851909518,
0.2617896795,
0.2544065416,
-0.4328171611,
0.0391763188,
0.0777560696,
0.003479823,
-0.1090230346,
-0.0009396113,
-0.0608802028,
-0.0626768619,
0.6625685692,
-0.461060375,
0.1479590833,
0.1810045093,
-0.1032905579,
-0.0873810798,
0.4717415273,
0.633629024,
0.6834893823,
-0.2515570223,
-0.1916481107,
0.0085216034,
-0.5018047094,
0.2072407752,
-0.011778255,
-0.4381330609,
-0.1189873666,
0.6008269191,
0.8504370451,
0.402100265,
-0.1550346315,
0.7099881768,
0.4171567857,
-0.4533943832,
-0.0631531402,
0.069950141,
-0.3141321242,
-0.0988006741,
0.1220050156,
0.2346258312,
0.2565031946,
-0.6482617259,
0.0584652685,
0.3965986371,
-0.1870452017,
-0.2692767978,
0.7434751987,
0.2485253066,
-0.2178105414,
0.2770039737,
-0.2737809718,
-0.0653010979,
0.5303202271,
0.5472519398,
0.9026939273,
-0.0646651611,
0.3655697703,
0.3370221853,
0.5279420614,
-0.3875360489,
0.2292972654,
-0.1879943609,
-0.4591087103,
-0.6842169166,
-0.6641222835,
-0.5923487544,
-0.1091742963,
-1.0480070114,
0.5856007934,
-0.6658023596,
0.051883027,
-0.0077039702,
0.0423911959,
-0.594522059,
-0.2492614537,
-0.1496806145,
0.5146205425,
-1.140157342,
0.5877473354,
0.6837664247,
-0.2831202745,
-0.7670266032,
-0.0506371036,
0.2105813175,
-0.8702731729,
0.321900934,
-0.2331929207,
-0.3709564805,
0.1810162961,
-0.6660138369,
-0.9112103581,
0.9287640452,
0.7317204475,
-0.4828426242,
-0.056561593,
-0.3866399229,
0.3213213384,
-0.1957836896,
-0.4949352145,
0.5509309173,
0.5589149594,
0.281363517,
-1.1201382875,
0.3514226377,
0.0302692167,
0.0601227768,
0.3128718436,
-0.6483947635,
0.9173569679,
-0.1978737563,
0.0336955339,
0.2492960542,
0.521101892,
-0.0974743143,
0.2116819322,
0.5340397954,
0.2595266104,
0.5016541481,
0.1308382303,
1.131457448,
-0.1155199334,
0.3117398024,
0.9503245354,
-0.3356812596,
0.7697802186,
0.5552772284,
-0.256826967,
0.618548274,
0.0916440189,
-0.1392569095,
0.6397929788,
0.2138028145,
0.0259517394,
-0.098396033,
-0.3735951483,
-0.1601924151,
0.7071384192,
-0.356208533,
-0.307988584,
0.1095541492,
0.0497558862,
0.6422556043,
0.3395364881,
-0.4028658569,
0.9603039622,
-0.1126921847,
-0.8612099886,
0.3845231533,
-0.0370591022,
0.7387183905,
-0.7272859812,
-0.1900613904,
-0.2168530375,
-0.0284755584,
-0.1630617827,
-0.4408955574,
0.1093575358,
-0.2346943915,
-0.0326562598,
-0.9458270669,
0.7848450541,
-0.5197275281,
-0.5501519442,
-0.1126885861,
0.3919506371,
0.1935303956,
0.0085420739,
-0.3964222074,
-0.3231389225,
-0.1694744676,
-0.2127098739,
0.5740807652,
0.4632515609,
-0.1830122769,
0.2852097452,
0.7493684292,
0.608979702,
-0.3993588686,
-0.219633922,
0.3211739659,
-0.3381488323,
-0.8540905714,
-0.590908587,
0.1305115819,
-0.1220950857,
-0.5776508451,
0.4962326288,
0.229492873,
0.6661292911,
-0.2209479958,
0.6777760983,
-0.2938695848,
0.2285966575,
-0.8996434808,
0.9146994352,
-0.841917038,
-0.1493922174,
-0.8646932244,
-1.0894976854,
0.1208165362,
0.6107575297,
-0.3064542413,
0.1303521693,
0.7153437138,
0.5947787166,
-0.0638130233,
-0.2602956295,
0.1612402201,
-0.5226995349,
-0.1360052973,
0.5432313681,
0.2235694677,
-0.0818222687,
0.7517131567,
-0.6827418208,
-0.3487890363,
-0.4287518263,
-1.2546175718,
-0.4745232761,
-0.5741683841,
-0.5333822966,
-0.1225784421,
0.1095652133,
0.8838843107,
1.0540633202,
-0.4568639696,
-0.3133073747,
0.080808796,
0.0289285742,
-0.7636879086,
-0.2879287899,
0.616689682,
-0.3533562422,
-0.8057910204,
0.3615007401,
0.0431301035,
-0.1894608885,
0.0503925793,
0.0386718884,
-0.0366242044,
-0.0048838281,
0.55510813,
0.3243868351,
-0.4411017299,
-0.3005704582,
-0.0839221179,
-0.2078429163,
-0.2410675734,
1.1671674252,
-0.2555772662,
0.4063384533,
0.5699050426,
0.7929711938,
0.352014333,
0.3384310901,
0.494974494,
-0.975935936,
-0.0035005072,
0.1686303914,
0.2459990382,
0.1232410446,
-0.6426083446,
0.5831198096,
0.3676304817,
-0.402361095,
-0.5933899879,
0.1216555014,
-1.2922152281,
-0.4259293675,
1.2280753851,
-0.0170224104,
-0.1149946153,
0.1354168504,
-0.3648390472,
-0.0260278378,
-0.6210308671,
0.4036888182,
0.434882462,
-0.2926599979,
-0.2303724885,
-0.6427856088,
0.7922263145,
0.4786287546,
-0.791929543,
0.0223018266,
0.2606698871,
0.1810389161,
0.140961796,
0.8412999511,
0.1277279854,
0.3449427783,
-0.0212619249,
0.0562256053,
-0.1631470025,
-0.5518357754,
-0.0118337842,
0.1219300404,
-0.0107089635,
-0.2267002016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08035v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08035v1
|
Harnessing Artificial Intelligence to Combat Online Hate: Exploring the Challenges and Opportunities of Large Language Models in Hate Speech Detection
| 2024-03-12T19:12:28 | 2024-03-12T19:12:28 |
Tharindu Kumarage, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Joshua Garland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) excel in many diverse applications beyond
language generation, e.g., translation, summarization, and sentiment analysis.
One intriguing application is in text classification. This becomes pertinent in
the realm of identifying hateful or toxic speech -- a domain fraught with
challenges and ethical dilemmas. In our study, we have two objectives: firstly,
to offer a literature review revolving around LLMs as classifiers, emphasizing
their role in detecting and classifying hateful or toxic content. Subsequently,
we explore the efficacy of several LLMs in classifying hate speech: identifying
which LLMs excel in this task as well as their underlying attributes and
training. Providing insight into the factors that contribute to an LLM
proficiency (or lack thereof) in discerning hateful content. By combining a
comprehensive literature review with an empirical analysis, our paper strives
to shed light on the capabilities and constraints of LLMs in the crucial domain
of hate speech detection.
|
[
-0.3737672567,
-0.8261954188,
0.429243207,
-0.1897992939,
-0.0120084845,
0.3316911757,
-0.289095521,
-0.8412766457,
-0.0334876291,
0.533392787,
-0.3561202884,
-0.403747499,
-0.9347973466,
0.1428033412,
-0.7574475408,
1.1027573347,
0.3130944073,
0.2439385355,
-0.1211184934,
-0.1204894334,
0.025214199,
-0.8405175805,
-0.8447442055,
-0.3678028584,
1.0013834238,
0.1836346686,
0.5216715336,
0.5136335492,
0.630817771,
0.3736815155,
-0.1729626358,
0.045485314,
-0.6437072158,
0.2846784592,
-0.0382734723,
-0.449957341,
-0.0452351086,
0.1340692192,
0.3647002578,
0.2650342584,
-0.0104746325,
0.0457897447,
-0.082425341,
0.3030949831,
-0.3963272572,
-0.311668843,
-0.9836767912,
0.1213070825,
-0.3874304593,
-0.0349204428,
-0.418458879,
-0.5023534298,
0.0145945419,
-0.3233256638,
-0.0294466875,
0.1535927057,
0.4433735311,
0.3573606312,
-0.4238898754,
-0.6963348389,
-0.9313727021,
0.9973704219,
-0.75973171,
0.3146553338,
0.2671770751,
0.1718320698,
0.0675992519,
-0.4244537354,
-0.7179479003,
-0.3613762259,
0.18483527,
-0.1370320469,
-0.2908748388,
0.1406341195,
0.1437722147,
0.3432860672,
-0.4773250222,
0.8909416795,
-0.3698267937,
-0.3440736234,
1.0090925694,
0.3319399655,
0.4975430667,
-0.0116355708,
-0.1543585956,
0.3056142628,
-0.4141530991,
-0.2640793025,
0.7022917271,
0.3786811233,
0.1663554907,
0.4365319014,
0.250231564,
0.4464676082,
-0.3069589436,
-0.4211139381,
0.2118687481,
0.3188369274,
-0.0871421769,
0.2151117772,
0.8290913105,
0.3247712255,
0.5475943685,
-0.0858689696,
-0.2343293726,
0.4801443517,
0.6446422338,
-0.8623836637,
0.1008626968,
0.1347634345,
-0.4900939763,
-0.6030938625,
-0.3133571744,
-0.8163982034,
-0.9814463258,
-0.2660342753,
0.2289071828,
-0.121328108,
-0.2270012796,
-0.3111220598,
-0.2269847095,
0.1367124766,
0.4607012868,
-0.6775951982,
0.4030242264,
0.7686584592,
0.737514317,
-0.548330307,
-0.0623483434,
-0.3969720304,
-0.0981761441,
-0.1425131708,
0.4717788398,
-0.7160767913,
-0.1122288033,
0.3854613602,
-0.3404728174,
0.2414171994,
-0.788567245,
0.7986952662,
-0.8372945189,
-0.0243981928,
0.2077652961,
-0.7140968442,
-0.3470258117,
0.4036987424,
-0.44680655,
0.7290219069,
0.0123023959,
-0.6882466674,
0.0114075663,
-0.5687597394,
-0.5359791517,
0.265239656,
-0.058226984,
-0.6062932611,
0.101883471,
-0.322144866,
0.5239017606,
-0.363129884,
0.0206214283,
-0.5781545043,
-0.1268001795,
0.5213141441,
-0.2843468785,
0.8398720026,
0.5490567088,
-0.4343141913,
0.3502175808,
-0.6063504815,
-0.3307216763,
0.4666240215,
-0.2322679907,
-0.5641893148,
0.316093415,
0.4453586042,
0.2276770025,
-0.0663501248,
-0.7213340998,
-0.3580708206,
-0.2982184887,
0.4787412584,
1.0194981098,
-0.33928895,
0.0590368733,
-0.4697580636,
0.6972963214,
-0.1010385677,
0.1308852583,
0.3917112052,
-0.5000712872,
-0.64395684,
-0.1962251514,
-0.0604777783,
0.7081475258,
-0.3434325457,
0.3002603054,
0.1773619652,
-0.6865867972,
-0.3160191774,
0.233160004,
0.2817315757,
0.3635008633,
0.2454330772,
0.0340641551,
-0.8670645952,
-0.8091508746,
-0.4032921791,
-0.2413421422,
0.0538845249,
0.4309738874,
0.4289629161,
-0.4281467795,
0.7045829892,
-0.1815873832,
-0.3034351468,
-0.4076981544,
0.0974014625,
-0.2042650282,
-0.0083762938,
0.6066193581,
-1.0640068054,
-0.6568936706,
-0.0929573104,
-0.6577142477,
-0.4417795837,
0.2047555745,
0.150273338,
0.0439960398,
0.5444313288,
-0.1219211295,
0.2316593528,
0.4280374646,
-0.1647014767,
0.570045352,
0.4414045811,
0.2105448097,
-0.7411916256,
-0.1801977307,
0.2309902161,
-0.2190939486,
-1.0438454151,
0.1516872495,
-0.3572774231,
0.0692616999,
-0.67770046,
0.3225975335,
0.0607024282,
0.1973095536,
-0.5578383803,
0.2369729131,
-0.5722193718,
0.069549419,
-0.0801773444,
0.3875868917,
0.1909031272,
-0.6604714394,
0.6029050946,
0.1496406496,
-0.3496553898,
0.6934463978,
-0.2357869446,
0.0576792657,
-0.1245403215,
-0.0554316379,
-0.7188795805,
-0.2001852989,
0.3530910611,
-0.4334513545,
0.0668093339,
-0.0194675811,
-0.5863157511,
-0.513638258,
-0.3080000281,
0.5574603677,
0.5177559853,
-0.2979592383,
0.6055569649,
1.0157103539,
-0.3223499358,
-0.3762514293,
-0.6868450642,
0.1340096593,
-0.7314061522,
-0.2444041967,
0.3070245385,
-0.2791208923,
-0.7719022036,
-0.3195185065,
0.2194364071,
-0.1799978018,
0.3444399536,
0.4362721145,
0.1278816313,
0.0170450415,
0.1474072635,
-0.3166568279,
0.2517546713,
0.45722121,
-0.0910073146,
0.575386703,
0.2211993784,
-0.114690505,
-0.4487536252,
0.2606815696,
0.7910358906,
0.0704411417,
0.6403077245,
0.5738275051,
-0.4120305479,
-0.4601206481,
-0.7426419258,
0.1792202592,
-0.4497723877,
0.5285177231,
0.3076162338,
-1.2938703299,
0.4248766005,
0.2228497118,
0.0482271053,
0.5347931981,
0.8213813901,
0.0171433967,
1.0646016598,
0.5806575418,
-0.4884446859,
0.5899157524,
0.1994539946,
0.3326931298,
-0.5050502419,
-0.2702827156,
-0.7656053901,
-0.168667227,
-0.538262248,
-0.2059046626,
0.4443801343,
-0.4164197445,
-0.4836484492,
-0.127585873,
-0.5630045533,
0.4736990333,
0.1911012083,
-0.0874639601,
0.2437380403,
0.2190803289,
0.2849204242,
-0.1579952985,
-0.4143854976,
-0.5292240977,
0.9902517796,
0.71447891,
0.6124378443,
0.1398644894,
0.3656447828,
0.7165958285,
0.6129860878,
-1.0861612558,
0.6439252496,
-0.2377651036,
-0.8365314007,
-0.1481651217,
-0.5349805355,
-0.70454669,
0.1426729113,
-0.1460666358,
-0.7469139099,
-0.4599821568,
-0.0060235355,
-0.2564519346,
0.7005429864,
-0.295222044,
0.5657374859,
-0.609796226,
-0.216587171,
-0.5710201263,
-0.311917007,
0.3970815241,
-0.4097850323,
0.7314577699,
-0.1309336126,
-0.2164758891,
1.0293852091,
-0.1708171517,
0.9076445699,
-0.0402344018,
-0.3195074797,
0.2843817472,
0.0379411317,
0.1799369454,
-0.6095679402,
-0.3304947019,
0.3975220323,
-0.4085744917,
-0.042825792,
-0.1732525676,
0.6013255715,
-0.825286746,
-0.6274290085,
-0.4678066969,
-0.6245852113,
-0.1601586044,
0.2055432945,
-0.0545394979,
0.060836494,
-0.3310928643,
0.0442301407,
0.7774837613,
-0.5067234635,
0.2212341428,
0.4435901344,
-0.525587678,
-0.3207655549,
1.2102451324,
0.1369846463,
0.2515820563,
0.2610016167,
0.3334938288,
-0.316126734,
-1.0710098743,
-0.3082542121,
0.183021754,
-0.7473344803,
-0.2181355059,
-0.8128702044,
-0.4754915535,
-0.4302619994,
-0.1474284381,
-0.0431343503,
0.0470410176,
-0.4001246691,
0.0888560489,
0.4489139915,
1.3439332247,
0.0054295179,
0.3998589516,
-0.587187767,
0.2671620548,
0.3555945754,
0.2551186979,
0.2057276815,
-0.9397224188,
-0.168402791,
-0.1171523631,
-0.302726984,
-0.9878414869,
0.5841296315,
-0.1397587955,
0.5297155976,
0.5205234885,
0.1136807874,
0.33972615,
-0.5083419085,
0.6978062987,
0.0879907981,
-0.6990064979,
0.3631971776,
-0.2727786005,
-0.3175379336,
0.248217538,
1.038664937,
-0.6375570893,
-0.7072129846,
-0.4702735543,
-0.6585109234,
0.8115595579,
0.1518704891,
0.1822144687,
-0.0234410837,
0.0763165429,
0.0515591502,
0.3116942942,
-0.9945048094,
-0.4668954611,
0.0384372137,
-0.2928782105,
0.0105695873,
-0.4871867895,
-0.1211157143,
-0.2145799994,
0.8577848673,
0.2388796508,
-0.0672723353,
-0.2757769227,
-0.2806986272,
-0.1441225111,
0.2554017305,
0.5031724572,
0.3143884838,
0.1490572989,
-0.0160496756,
0.3169695139,
-0.4165295362,
0.1983844936,
-0.0964795277,
-0.2395706028,
-0.1610336304,
0.3133682013,
0.4805163145,
-0.0317539796,
-0.9931921363,
0.5872631073,
0.0580743849,
-0.2672602534,
-0.6138055921,
0.1273671687,
-0.0891739577,
0.306709677,
0.3625586033,
-0.3439748585,
0.2278292179,
-0.4238147438,
0.0693261623,
0.665214479,
-0.1665515006,
0.0064718276,
0.4850959182,
0.2130859345,
-0.6676671505,
0.4793918729,
-0.2425555289,
-1.1664532423,
0.6079590321,
0.590272665,
0.6724776626,
-0.4212468565,
0.1714427173,
0.154087171,
0.2311170548,
0.4267936647,
-0.2271119505,
0.1271565855,
-0.9562785625,
-0.0964418426,
-1.0170974731,
-0.5200196505,
0.5587439537,
-0.3191828728,
0.0927167386,
-0.8590195775,
-0.0096706338,
0.3570743501,
-0.107188113,
-0.3192537725,
0.1017983928,
0.8984856606,
0.63072294,
-0.7805648446,
0.4137678742,
0.4781160951,
-0.1819153726,
-0.4529896677,
-0.0894753039,
0.5312424898,
-0.739233315,
0.7398108244,
0.3962993622,
-0.2424295396,
0.0254729241,
-0.7212288976,
-0.4745406508,
0.3565450907,
0.048542466,
-0.6114218831,
0.1072793528,
0.4076653123,
0.7401684523,
-0.5408071876,
0.3277541399,
0.5855523348,
0.411082238,
0.0310822167,
-0.8555675745,
-0.1331904829,
-0.2074725181,
-0.0745669976,
0.1824804097,
-0.6004306078,
0.6575815678,
0.055873815,
-0.1514794379,
-0.0720030814,
0.4733147025,
-0.0747765452,
0.3298232555,
0.6793264747,
0.5848443508,
0.6404033303,
0.1774531752,
0.7927773595,
0.1085311323,
-0.0144833317,
0.7969742417,
-0.3881718814,
0.7143669128,
0.0098159192,
-0.2639839649,
0.6022298932,
0.5185969472,
-0.2695216835,
0.0239578206,
0.649569571,
-0.5488965511,
-0.3467029631,
-0.549439311,
-0.0622588955,
0.5119128227,
0.6524020433,
-0.4479826391,
-0.1245102584,
0.4090627134,
0.0531300753,
0.4525094628,
-0.8124850392,
0.7776717544,
0.0665477812,
-0.2581052482,
0.34047544,
0.1710289419,
1.0622469187,
-0.4658467174,
0.2332925349,
0.4088985324,
0.2706700563,
-0.3752070665,
-0.7201154232,
0.5216668248,
0.4955994487,
-0.1706240922,
-0.311897248,
0.6823902726,
-0.2299610674,
-0.2011771947,
0.605047822,
0.2026791126,
0.3079863787,
-0.208482787,
-0.9261575937,
0.5629411936,
0.0343494117,
-0.0281508062,
0.4972443283,
0.1637941003,
0.0383604839,
0.8737877607,
0.6426635385,
0.1903690398,
0.0575038046,
0.2613272071,
0.819064796,
-0.6640708447,
-0.4162740111,
-1.119566679,
0.1209424436,
-0.1280517876,
-0.2765112221,
0.7531958222,
0.5662238598,
1.1380149126,
0.2191530764,
0.9864390492,
-0.1398171932,
0.9190215468,
-0.1736207902,
0.8356506824,
-0.6147868633,
0.0948882326,
-0.294300288,
-0.5630546212,
-0.6221146584,
0.6093928814,
-0.5451509953,
0.0387303084,
0.4431446791,
0.9068105817,
0.296780616,
0.2179852128,
0.4927099347,
0.5477648973,
0.5013441443,
0.300137341,
1.2625294924,
-0.1094914973,
0.672973454,
-0.0485875607,
-0.20068717,
-0.2818659842,
-0.6374348998,
-1.1476052999,
-0.354881376,
-0.2067715824,
-0.4184233546,
0.0576203279,
1.136046648,
0.4382288754,
-0.949745357,
-0.4275818169,
0.1912333071,
0.3147735894,
0.3239215016,
-0.2834132612,
-0.2454880923,
-0.2243865877,
-0.8698475957,
0.3199415207,
0.2315795273,
-0.1099732593,
-0.3580058217,
-0.2249981612,
-0.3095537126,
0.1466629654,
0.9458900094,
0.2337970883,
-0.9604526162,
-0.1757910103,
-0.5409817696,
-0.2664714754,
-0.1705548465,
0.8965324759,
-0.5080013275,
0.0108205061,
0.2432665974,
1.1312676668,
0.0097942054,
-0.245716095,
0.186966598,
-0.2013555616,
-0.044419568,
0.7698523402,
0.172751233,
0.3366165459,
-0.3490558565,
0.278029263,
0.4104900062,
-0.8766408563,
-1.1037095785,
0.3522185683,
-0.7951402664,
-0.3525316119,
1.2757884264,
0.2161143422,
-0.1179257184,
-0.4238004386,
-0.2562302649,
0.2215596735,
-0.3353366554,
0.8365854621,
0.646048069,
-0.0189116355,
-0.0658284426,
-0.5319938064,
0.6043335199,
0.3346609473,
-0.8801391721,
0.210738793,
0.7498944998,
0.1782784164,
0.1766460091,
0.417658627,
0.025173679,
0.0776003972,
-0.3481306732,
-0.0239453483,
0.1006399989,
-0.378708899,
-0.5238536,
0.3259087503,
0.1105775014,
0.3596463799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08011v1
|
Gujarati-English Code-Switching Speech Recognition using ensemble prediction of spoken language
| 2024-03-12T18:21:20 | 2024-03-12T18:21:20 |
Yash Sharma, Basil Abraham, Preethi Jyothi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
An important and difficult task in code-switched speech recognition is to
recognize the language, as lots of words in two languages can sound similar,
especially in some accents. We focus on improving performance of end-to-end
Automatic Speech Recognition models by conditioning transformer layers on
language ID of words and character in the output in an per layer supervised
manner. To this end, we propose two methods of introducing language specific
parameters and explainability in the multi-head attention mechanism, and
implement a Temporal Loss that helps maintain continuity in input alignment.
Despite being unable to reduce WER significantly, our method shows promise in
predicting the correct language from just spoken data. We introduce
regularization in the language prediction by dropping LID in the sequence,
which helps align long repeated output sequences.
|
[
-0.3348345459,
-0.4462284446,
0.1378190815,
0.1740573496,
-0.2272192985,
0.2736986578,
-0.4301019013,
-0.4398418963,
-0.0918798894,
0.4743706286,
-0.488094151,
-0.0896885619,
-0.5735848546,
0.0927665755,
-0.4703219235,
0.938174367,
0.0556491055,
0.2287542075,
0.0620971732,
0.0883601606,
-0.5426655412,
-0.4099552035,
-0.9700448513,
-0.5953008533,
0.3974577188,
0.4102096558,
0.4373401999,
0.5098536611,
0.369969517,
0.2918435037,
-0.0461711101,
-0.2235564739,
-0.3709090054,
-0.0626607314,
0.052995801,
-0.6363825798,
-0.0289379451,
-0.2875742018,
0.7953372598,
0.6159718037,
-0.2264866382,
-0.0988014415,
0.0131499209,
0.4163377583,
-0.4381511509,
0.4194465578,
-0.7621605396,
0.161781624,
-0.38168329,
-0.3775405884,
-0.6509382725,
-0.0933568105,
-0.0667706579,
-0.2067459524,
0.1808943301,
-0.0332093649,
0.7578395009,
0.4371691644,
-0.2348291278,
0.0601523742,
-0.9798890948,
0.9148803949,
-0.4394554198,
0.6906483173,
0.5781113505,
0.6169015169,
0.3668667376,
-0.3999198973,
-0.5652893782,
-0.1251801401,
-0.1500413716,
0.4196461439,
-0.0239243675,
0.108158797,
-0.0048466027,
0.230251357,
-0.5131581426,
-0.0447325073,
-0.5152813792,
-0.4668257833,
0.7044752836,
-0.1356450617,
0.3214603066,
0.3221922517,
0.010162333,
-0.1136836559,
-0.4178188145,
0.2397252768,
0.330188334,
0.4134243727,
-0.0726164207,
0.2073449045,
-0.0510978512,
0.5803697705,
0.5032508373,
-0.2765645385,
0.3640555441,
0.0054832017,
-0.2648160458,
0.3584271073,
0.4155608118,
0.1986665428,
0.2422674447,
-0.3837434351,
-0.0429874361,
0.2537302673,
0.0088372901,
-0.4625658393,
-0.0215549041,
0.1544152051,
-0.3430929184,
-0.1431203932,
-0.0463039242,
-0.6200914979,
0.0089182453,
-0.2570106685,
0.2143122554,
-0.5606883168,
-0.2519449592,
0.0410201624,
-0.1256527901,
0.47603935,
0.0702910051,
-0.8966119885,
0.494286567,
0.3066701889,
0.651919663,
-0.365637064,
-0.3838392496,
-0.6495234966,
0.3966688216,
-0.230250746,
0.6284713745,
-0.8425511718,
-0.3533265591,
-0.0662808716,
0.0921675712,
-0.3342599869,
-0.3288323879,
0.3876934648,
-0.4108341038,
0.3718225956,
0.3065356612,
-0.2780357003,
-0.2432214171,
-0.0448488854,
-0.5338594317,
0.7527610064,
-0.1278672218,
-0.5295799971,
0.2815390229,
-0.3774397373,
-0.6631602049,
0.1752079725,
0.0155955106,
-0.6329789162,
-0.0317417346,
0.3807986975,
0.3836764693,
-0.0476487838,
0.1663237065,
0.2197156996,
-0.4275740683,
0.1159761623,
-0.3262651861,
0.6711672544,
0.3486907184,
-0.158449471,
-0.0308120344,
-0.8933560252,
0.2235568166,
-0.0950793102,
-0.3149416745,
-0.1585447788,
0.2099680305,
0.4365231097,
0.1348968744,
0.1061742678,
-0.4528457224,
0.187188223,
-0.4620998502,
0.4603360295,
0.3890295923,
-0.1721100807,
0.5462054014,
-0.1648988426,
0.854013443,
0.1936718374,
0.0279088411,
-0.0279821754,
-0.5574734211,
-0.6984707713,
-0.1440142542,
0.3950786889,
0.8927440047,
-0.6940329671,
0.3047804832,
-0.0650803372,
-0.3701548874,
-0.6221082807,
-0.1168334708,
0.8874652386,
0.2524467409,
0.2437630147,
-0.5702044368,
-0.855484724,
-0.8326802254,
-0.336815834,
-0.2638160288,
0.0077537033,
0.3135278225,
0.0606434084,
-0.3703638017,
0.7942192554,
-0.3371085823,
-0.1687358916,
-0.4848974645,
0.2537024319,
0.1806275249,
0.4809456468,
0.2485800385,
-0.8349413872,
-0.6332527399,
0.4070425034,
-0.0557378754,
-0.1604756862,
-0.3266457021,
0.0836345702,
0.2697009742,
0.6487460136,
-0.1467309594,
0.3235440254,
0.8029236794,
0.078684181,
0.3249786496,
0.1699793339,
0.2888964117,
-1.0998840332,
-0.2201914191,
-0.1405871063,
-0.181039378,
-0.8553456664,
-0.2313349992,
0.0732166246,
-0.2382929623,
-0.4463613927,
0.4193226099,
-0.5759527087,
-0.1379097998,
-0.1485654265,
-0.3368102014,
-0.2426715642,
0.7460351586,
0.4051112533,
0.979909122,
0.9253755212,
-0.6296665072,
0.1731516272,
0.1952336282,
-0.1716143638,
0.3156101406,
-0.4869123995,
0.3702394366,
-0.1655980647,
0.2185585946,
-1.107622385,
-0.1932918727,
-0.0259502307,
-0.8435138464,
0.7669406533,
-0.3818292916,
0.1360153705,
-0.2256357372,
-0.0133066066,
0.6103750467,
0.5985530019,
-0.3611879647,
0.576690197,
0.5160380006,
-0.2512572408,
-0.4304564595,
-1.119882226,
0.2051460445,
-0.2489181012,
-0.4852594733,
0.5634021759,
0.0651012063,
-0.0793315321,
-0.1597347707,
-0.0049102791,
-0.5826241374,
-0.3092372417,
0.1415023059,
-0.0144533971,
-0.1003681868,
0.2482164204,
0.1199333891,
-0.3098122478,
-0.1740941256,
-0.3843425214,
0.6308476329,
-0.1062832102,
-0.1549249142,
-0.5260357261,
0.4485010505,
0.4452463388,
-0.5449802876,
0.5246273875,
0.7061129212,
-0.4321188629,
-0.0255822856,
-0.4168730676,
0.057244733,
-0.4018100202,
0.6158174872,
-0.6149380207,
-0.6520769596,
0.7029429674,
0.0771692172,
-0.2537741363,
0.4002709687,
0.7059797645,
0.0388576649,
1.1996186972,
0.732260406,
-0.4180686474,
0.6075156331,
-0.0514538698,
0.575481236,
-0.710717082,
-0.0759293362,
-0.6160127521,
0.0304699335,
-0.6851122975,
-0.2772481441,
0.2720165551,
-0.0932082236,
0.1735116839,
0.5450015664,
-0.6367526054,
0.5353173018,
0.4387268126,
0.1733248383,
0.0546117276,
-0.1328605264,
0.0494818874,
0.1122071445,
-0.5138607025,
-0.030847311,
0.8609877825,
0.2134347558,
0.9985294342,
-0.0488935858,
0.8973340392,
0.1198724881,
-0.3919464648,
-0.8195317984,
0.320034951,
-0.1367805004,
-0.2617659271,
-0.4813968837,
-0.2295541167,
-0.9208313227,
-0.1272904426,
0.2304995209,
-0.6011467576,
0.2321221679,
0.2812798917,
-0.2530260384,
-0.0439551808,
-1.0214511156,
0.3200280368,
-0.1149884164,
-0.0556991585,
-0.2748456299,
-0.8429760933,
0.2825613022,
0.030656714,
0.1648345441,
0.345587492,
0.0792863071,
0.6301508546,
-0.2233626842,
0.7816332579,
-0.0118244914,
0.1573166698,
0.1542751044,
-0.2040858567,
0.3361617625,
-0.1102461666,
0.0232109539,
0.2707998753,
-0.0791086107,
-0.3280754089,
-0.4419172406,
0.4737804234,
-0.7960467935,
-0.4633812308,
-0.3302974701,
-0.6061612964,
-0.4583651721,
0.0228723437,
0.5282965302,
0.452911377,
-0.0532519296,
0.0666176602,
0.6886758804,
-0.0606431551,
0.5111272335,
0.2586427033,
-0.1738350391,
-0.292937845,
0.9801990986,
0.1571610123,
0.3462284803,
0.7239924669,
0.2516273558,
-0.2020673901,
-0.5432356,
-0.3205305338,
-0.1044841856,
-0.4534668922,
-0.0182082392,
-0.5294268131,
-0.5311546922,
-0.6598927379,
-0.252746731,
-0.2241442502,
-0.5524057746,
0.1212686449,
0.1046277359,
0.2732633352,
0.3776009083,
0.100296773,
0.353069365,
-0.7062492967,
0.2083673179,
0.503254056,
0.4644070268,
-0.4103165567,
-0.8381294012,
-0.5186440945,
-0.1333594918,
0.0034846109,
-0.9844577312,
0.4706218541,
0.6134326458,
0.6209641695,
0.5000366569,
-0.3895623684,
0.6247531772,
-0.6326767206,
0.5813863873,
0.2422605455,
-1.1371934414,
0.6383678317,
-0.2373227775,
0.597415626,
0.3096830249,
0.0715333819,
-0.7319710851,
-0.5127348304,
-0.3814394474,
-0.594274044,
0.9073912501,
0.2291392088,
-0.1488707513,
0.0724702179,
-0.0074591357,
0.1002001911,
0.0299640708,
-0.6005749702,
-0.2521683276,
-0.316100508,
-0.1519420445,
-0.145335719,
-0.1087699011,
0.1539894491,
-0.3827449083,
0.7461482882,
-0.0644120574,
0.5873480439,
-0.1497641802,
-0.1836107969,
-0.2562924922,
0.5403752923,
0.6460215449,
0.4453548193,
-0.1817112267,
-0.0763256773,
0.3429236412,
-0.6171315312,
0.034297768,
-0.0086848447,
-0.1076078564,
0.0945840627,
0.2760248184,
0.9871909618,
0.0586784706,
-0.4835959375,
0.1744653434,
0.0525684245,
-0.1348610669,
-0.4601304829,
0.0144569594,
0.0951985493,
-0.0631977096,
0.283144027,
0.3258189559,
0.3416008353,
-0.7601004839,
0.2528668642,
0.2398454845,
-0.3869018555,
-0.12545605,
0.4967515767,
0.3695510328,
-0.5187373161,
0.3352987766,
-0.1097010076,
-0.7622414827,
0.9422886372,
0.698333919,
1.2268643379,
-0.8583616614,
-0.1155302376,
0.3739506006,
0.2185005695,
0.033894103,
0.1242119595,
-0.1437811702,
-0.7460116148,
-0.5084251165,
-0.3042429686,
-0.5428315997,
-0.0765853822,
-1.0072458982,
0.5067365766,
-0.2882035971,
0.1181864142,
-0.0108439317,
-0.2531084716,
-0.5481340289,
0.4500501752,
0.3852516711,
0.4217844307,
-0.9462214112,
1.2229633331,
0.5289761424,
-0.4830954969,
-0.6318503022,
0.2348974794,
0.0219304189,
-1.0639748573,
0.4080379605,
0.1861505508,
-0.4467899501,
-0.036273919,
-0.4875663817,
-0.9906706214,
0.7948369384,
0.0380256474,
-0.9417809248,
0.0977063254,
-0.0001833551,
0.4350941479,
-0.3448171616,
0.3475397527,
0.7897879481,
0.3679507077,
0.1429452598,
-1.1315114498,
-0.4568662643,
-0.3638568521,
0.2397296429,
0.4377985895,
-0.7557301521,
0.8298230171,
-0.2132278234,
-0.3618329465,
-0.2746969461,
0.5335166454,
-0.1761584729,
0.3837354183,
0.5685379505,
0.3914400935,
0.5177695155,
-0.0156773645,
0.8733412623,
-0.4988477826,
0.225820452,
1.0431468487,
-0.2428616732,
0.8686709404,
0.5723052025,
-0.4561694562,
0.3460587561,
0.5072109699,
0.0583936349,
0.8603973389,
0.0105179083,
-0.0584745109,
-0.1299579442,
0.0683392659,
-0.4654067159,
0.7609203458,
0.326001972,
-0.1609324813,
0.1232556254,
0.2116277814,
-0.1097249389,
0.0182953421,
-0.4126387537,
0.8407674432,
-0.3167610765,
-0.8532147408,
0.7015618682,
-0.0279709417,
0.8338732719,
-0.5493116379,
-0.1118174419,
-0.1834422797,
0.1533070058,
-0.3302274942,
-0.4952306449,
0.4851385653,
-0.1667328626,
-0.4354535341,
-0.270058006,
0.6565241814,
-0.91868186,
-0.6953887939,
0.1925633103,
0.0371431559,
0.3745797873,
0.1435875893,
-0.5070279837,
0.011439709,
0.0919427201,
0.0266494323,
0.3222542703,
0.1509036273,
-0.1502997875,
0.5966810584,
0.3361611664,
0.104349941,
0.3258136213,
0.4480600655,
0.5466374755,
-0.5094870925,
-0.6537749767,
-0.4581011236,
0.2448525429,
0.0197480768,
-0.298101306,
0.3805651367,
0.5809087157,
0.9372375607,
-0.2551722825,
1.1196341515,
-0.0358443521,
0.7218174934,
-0.6024408937,
0.6007473469,
-0.3450530767,
0.1172034517,
-0.2109594494,
-0.706137538,
-0.2814725339,
0.5376551151,
-0.1015241966,
0.2108662724,
0.9583257437,
0.9721106887,
0.0493308976,
-0.2791646123,
0.6258109808,
0.1662620753,
0.1015454456,
0.8992907405,
0.3820702136,
-0.5426715612,
0.8041405082,
-0.2067425698,
-0.3205808401,
-0.2258779854,
-0.570982337,
-0.7331741452,
-0.8503311276,
-0.4785526097,
-0.0996338874,
0.4222829342,
0.5093861222,
0.7146836519,
-1.1845235825,
-0.4028451741,
-0.1889668405,
-0.0279760044,
-0.6642294526,
-0.2302076668,
0.1420072466,
-0.4077042639,
-0.9656253457,
0.3300488293,
0.4492438436,
-0.2690906227,
-0.1991662383,
-0.2600201666,
-0.2778070271,
0.1462260485,
0.3733978868,
0.5016388297,
-0.8875863552,
-0.292399019,
-0.1617196649,
-0.1128202006,
0.1255271137,
0.8651012778,
-0.7155964375,
0.526304245,
0.603890717,
0.7824829817,
0.5794625878,
-0.1350721419,
0.7450074553,
-0.7573066354,
0.3131797314,
0.3640315235,
0.4507189691,
0.2503314018,
-0.4743060768,
0.456728816,
0.0396178961,
-0.5883659124,
-0.5924896002,
0.3351143897,
-1.2078611851,
0.0364874154,
1.134734869,
0.0292545371,
-0.204243958,
-0.393989414,
-0.4840541184,
0.4654968381,
-0.4587180316,
0.7571423054,
0.76099962,
-0.2402136922,
-0.7618801594,
-0.0358523279,
0.5262717605,
0.5680850744,
-0.6897270679,
-0.1834207028,
0.1941896826,
0.0802128315,
0.1676165909,
0.5605173111,
-0.0142276036,
0.5459635854,
0.0417240486,
0.4204083681,
0.0996446237,
-0.3394299448,
-0.6363411546,
-0.2177648246,
-0.013644753,
-0.7729132175
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.