id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03942v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03942v2
|
The Heuristic Core: Understanding Subnetwork Generalization in Pretrained Language Models
| 2024-03-06T18:50:14 | 2024-06-05T17:44:03 |
Adithya Bhaskar, Dan Friedman, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Prior work has found that pretrained language models (LMs) fine-tuned with
different random seeds can achieve similar in-domain performance but generalize
differently on tests of syntactic generalization. In this work, we show that,
even within a single model, we can find multiple subnetworks that perform
similarly in-domain, but generalize vastly differently. To better understand
these phenomena, we investigate if they can be understood in terms of
"competing subnetworks": the model initially represents a variety of distinct
algorithms, corresponding to different subnetworks, and generalization occurs
when it ultimately converges to one. This explanation has been used to account
for generalization in simple algorithmic tasks ("grokking"). Instead of finding
competing subnetworks, we find that all subnetworks -- whether they generalize
or not -- share a set of attention heads, which we refer to as the heuristic
core. Further analysis suggests that these attention heads emerge early in
training and compute shallow, non-generalizing features. The model learns to
generalize by incorporating additional attention heads, which depend on the
outputs of the "heuristic" heads to compute higher-level features. Overall, our
results offer a more detailed picture of the mechanisms for syntactic
generalization in pretrained LMs.
|
[
-0.4283205867,
-0.6595140696,
0.409778446,
-0.0288499799,
-0.1908606738,
0.1510261148,
-0.5262606144,
-0.2687087357,
0.1498876065,
0.486708343,
-0.689991653,
-0.4211115837,
-0.8164178729,
-0.0883214623,
-0.3780806959,
0.9624044299,
0.2100027353,
-0.1721272171,
-0.2462749183,
-0.0846887603,
-0.3626580536,
-0.6356869936,
-0.2971087992,
-0.7877845168,
0.595747292,
0.3859688938,
0.662920475,
0.5879889131,
0.6257423759,
0.2609032989,
-0.1008149534,
-0.3048189878,
-0.5256226659,
-0.0200624689,
-0.3868998289,
-0.620243609,
-0.1420381665,
0.1546017826,
0.580271244,
1.1256018877,
-0.0741404667,
0.2497411221,
0.1840800047,
0.7691633701,
-0.5737754107,
0.0693592206,
-0.7868962884,
0.0992168635,
-0.5222922564,
-0.2869430482,
-0.237667352,
0.0862890929,
0.3535998166,
-0.4246967137,
0.6434844732,
-0.011344173,
0.9328735471,
0.2309038937,
-0.05459534,
-0.0763900504,
-0.6167490482,
0.8076888919,
-0.661097765,
0.2261148989,
0.2459564209,
0.5157440901,
0.0934249014,
-0.65809232,
-0.2263361812,
-0.3091185093,
-0.1342133284,
-0.1348775029,
-0.283706665,
0.1630958915,
0.3945399523,
0.6437106133,
-0.6235671639,
0.177995339,
-0.4123903811,
-0.0291993413,
0.302174747,
-0.0751687288,
0.246663034,
0.3213782012,
0.0081098927,
-0.0007979494,
-0.6072757244,
0.2981636822,
0.4767028689,
0.5592640638,
0.0347032137,
0.4194820225,
-0.4804326892,
0.5935937166,
0.188864395,
0.0752027035,
0.267660737,
-0.3391455412,
-0.2997770011,
-0.1263900846,
0.7122561336,
0.0030723361,
0.9694207311,
-0.4568522274,
-0.1951399297,
0.1132999808,
0.4722306728,
-0.3044150472,
-0.4281079471,
0.0866454393,
-0.4930325747,
-0.1605788171,
-0.2053934634,
-0.0216912739,
0.0110594416,
-0.2174263895,
0.1820628047,
-0.2974727154,
-0.338422507,
0.2384200394,
-0.2439263016,
-0.0059287138,
-0.1962563246,
-0.9430548549,
0.5322625041,
0.7128452659,
0.5611084104,
-0.1876489222,
-0.7940867543,
-0.1727368534,
-0.0828720331,
-0.2665517032,
0.8802193403,
-0.5719003677,
-0.1298211962,
-0.1743675619,
-0.0527311303,
-0.2800273299,
-0.8283168077,
0.145622313,
-0.6680966616,
-0.080687888,
-0.4901716709,
-0.4194461107,
-0.1686042249,
0.2490583658,
-0.6484329104,
0.9348417521,
0.1515790075,
-0.9278445244,
0.4032573402,
-0.4976032078,
-0.537155211,
0.0835745409,
-0.2606824934,
-0.3279265165,
0.5605737567,
-0.0374394991,
0.4834860265,
-0.5257077217,
0.0606091842,
-0.1604715437,
-0.3877199292,
0.049962651,
0.1258231848,
0.6410941482,
-0.1070371419,
-0.5691128969,
0.2766498029,
-0.3338264525,
0.245646432,
0.3008189201,
-0.242006585,
-0.423869729,
-0.1020860374,
-0.5620532632,
0.0052745542,
0.1916052401,
-0.2345345914,
0.155557707,
-0.2791515887,
0.4715246856,
0.4406544864,
-0.1165843084,
0.6895211935,
-0.2688112259,
0.5713871121,
0.4206493199,
0.1247310936,
-0.3362317681,
-0.4123727679,
-0.6952745914,
0.1360879093,
0.3083615303,
0.418613404,
-0.395567745,
0.2139389813,
-0.2115615755,
-0.4592527747,
-0.3543579876,
0.1060310751,
0.700774312,
0.3039111793,
0.398176074,
-0.6061764956,
-0.5418604016,
-1.4816017151,
-0.5604765415,
0.2338731885,
0.4541635513,
0.2133984417,
0.5438626409,
-0.1619263738,
1.0484757423,
-0.3442898691,
-0.1728405803,
-0.5973682404,
0.1933500022,
0.3824876249,
0.6088430285,
0.7113617063,
-0.4753337502,
-0.6310984492,
0.1142193004,
-0.5725950599,
-0.1652531326,
0.1540013999,
0.0453721061,
-0.2741051912,
0.4878816605,
-0.5859094262,
0.291800499,
0.5303966403,
0.1463553458,
0.8122813702,
0.1128789335,
-0.1100233942,
-0.8339285851,
-0.0481541343,
-0.0959576368,
-0.0677114874,
-0.6098579764,
0.525005579,
-0.2422487438,
0.0790518075,
-0.2476383597,
0.2005979568,
-0.795312345,
-0.5876637101,
-0.3566502631,
-0.0455272496,
-0.1814120859,
0.7025792599,
-0.284039706,
0.857163012,
0.92410779,
-0.7089390755,
0.252042383,
-0.3145472407,
-0.3767261505,
0.2149697542,
-0.9530356526,
0.3114625216,
-0.1656544507,
0.0792282224,
-0.7985659838,
0.0004053606,
-0.0424312167,
-0.4881723523,
0.0278934427,
-0.3209768236,
-0.3275639713,
-0.4196294546,
0.1226643845,
0.5955644846,
0.4945066273,
-0.0733780935,
0.5103641748,
0.3908147812,
-0.0182542372,
-0.8379201889,
-0.651162982,
-0.1088514477,
-0.0446917973,
-0.4610647559,
0.2613994777,
0.0767837837,
-0.2635647058,
0.3480125368,
-0.1121827215,
-0.1291295737,
0.3214004338,
0.1232493147,
-0.4404214323,
-0.5240336657,
-0.2242792994,
-0.0799560249,
-0.2292090058,
0.0164028648,
-0.8295630217,
0.873403132,
-0.2798768282,
-0.5298972726,
-0.3582599163,
0.5566683412,
0.3833059669,
-0.4368748069,
0.5690270066,
0.5057011843,
-0.4733285904,
-0.3134808838,
-0.4586129785,
-0.4047140777,
-0.4069532752,
0.5162789226,
-0.7002743483,
-1.0821841955,
0.7231762409,
0.0075073512,
0.1676294655,
0.4244648814,
0.624696672,
-0.0142647466,
0.8794451356,
0.9347540736,
0.0223917011,
0.3562721908,
-0.500777185,
0.0298851132,
-0.8426193595,
-0.0599454343,
-0.6259621382,
-0.6043608189,
-0.3581288755,
-0.2604714632,
0.0649914145,
0.2556898594,
-0.0610927492,
0.5848617554,
-0.3280540407,
0.9719471335,
0.948327899,
-0.2530686855,
0.1615095139,
0.1843855083,
-0.695869863,
-0.0764814764,
-0.9700058103,
-0.2888911068,
0.8094861507,
0.2975172698,
0.6875349879,
-0.0111586116,
0.6894937754,
0.185491249,
0.3840265274,
-0.6223956943,
0.426105231,
-0.5081323981,
-0.6845635176,
-0.2285110801,
-0.2945413589,
-1.0024368763,
0.2385494858,
-0.0546118803,
-0.6867538095,
0.0105045447,
0.413336575,
-0.4808109105,
0.1092901677,
-0.7037053704,
0.9549474716,
-0.0441233292,
-0.0726524889,
-0.358237952,
-0.4927992523,
0.2670066655,
0.2397849709,
0.0801485106,
-0.1066066772,
0.3772105873,
0.6697211266,
-0.0456329957,
0.9658025503,
-0.0901547819,
0.0576679334,
0.3679880202,
0.0490779206,
0.1766000688,
-0.15622738,
0.3801724911,
0.218065843,
-0.3276299536,
-0.6456202269,
-0.5049192309,
0.549238205,
-0.9851287603,
-0.8841953874,
-0.095922038,
-0.5587503314,
-0.3148277104,
0.4970327914,
0.6397246122,
0.4202934802,
-0.1725991964,
0.3310147226,
0.9529503584,
0.0946431383,
0.2326403111,
0.2763506174,
-0.1995472908,
0.0073507084,
0.6248803139,
0.2336231917,
0.3952050507,
0.4177178741,
0.2829967737,
0.095788762,
-0.9039834142,
-0.0519946367,
0.2436773181,
-0.7794994712,
0.129002437,
-0.8546997905,
-0.2633971274,
-0.5969810486,
0.0702737495,
-0.4513549805,
-0.3434961438,
-0.0168072842,
-0.0194611736,
-0.2392433882,
0.7930734754,
0.056751661,
0.8024526238,
-0.8606843948,
0.0214138292,
0.5484423637,
0.295236975,
0.1812726706,
-0.5167070031,
-0.7777296901,
-0.1192249432,
-0.014739763,
-0.8717775345,
-0.0146607747,
0.2120121866,
1.0361530781,
0.2549927831,
-0.4313552976,
0.4396258891,
-0.6397833824,
0.6214783192,
0.0696121752,
-0.7501400709,
0.213292107,
-0.4527839124,
0.5712298155,
0.7044308186,
0.3909457326,
-0.5320724845,
-0.2508369386,
-0.7417018414,
-0.7513613701,
0.4646018147,
0.053336367,
0.0317557417,
0.0710984915,
0.4486042261,
0.1908271015,
0.5203275084,
-0.6499173045,
-0.0929863974,
-0.1076907441,
0.1096749008,
-0.239803493,
-0.2770892084,
-0.4199317992,
0.0793394595,
0.4122729897,
-0.3101180196,
0.225957945,
-0.1196292713,
-0.4505378604,
-0.1099676117,
0.3097826838,
0.6442324519,
0.6313694715,
0.1313153207,
0.4563269019,
-0.1326128244,
-0.3156913519,
-0.181450069,
-0.1756124645,
-0.0177253485,
0.0106872488,
0.7924990058,
1.1180156469,
0.2858547568,
-0.4063846767,
0.4113269448,
-0.0076052863,
-0.2575315833,
-0.1901070327,
0.3072688878,
0.3208610713,
0.4328946471,
0.4764665961,
0.2052015811,
0.0588282757,
-0.6987277269,
0.2910091281,
0.5205426216,
-0.1744722277,
-0.7170405984,
0.4171654582,
0.1867494136,
-0.3397445381,
0.417100668,
-0.2166356444,
-0.9116691947,
0.7572720647,
0.4015718997,
1.250064373,
-0.065011248,
-0.0487305857,
0.1274981648,
0.7043648362,
-0.1897466034,
0.1856649965,
-0.198881641,
-1.0838980675,
-0.4565252066,
-0.4795008004,
-0.2638679743,
0.1675730348,
-0.7051095366,
-0.2638462186,
-0.5720433593,
-0.4100648165,
-0.0887892023,
-0.1577792317,
-0.884137392,
0.2835938334,
0.0785822123,
0.8198238015,
-0.907979548,
0.5900411606,
0.9497966766,
-0.1015944332,
-0.8008118868,
0.2541643977,
-0.2984957099,
-0.9411574006,
0.8178075552,
0.2638386488,
-0.1001324281,
0.2523814142,
-0.4250996709,
-0.9440248013,
0.8912143707,
0.200450629,
-0.7579016685,
-0.456602335,
0.1339604408,
0.4406570494,
-0.6922391057,
0.1873829663,
0.664031148,
0.1668725014,
-0.2017418891,
-1.1797257662,
-0.2514280379,
-0.3137365282,
0.0276722126,
-0.0009923896,
-0.601026237,
1.4180458784,
-0.309655875,
-0.274625957,
-0.3827816546,
0.5501369834,
0.1506870538,
0.039385505,
0.5670765042,
0.8123043776,
0.4955280721,
-0.1081068218,
0.9894750714,
-0.4773692787,
0.4508940876,
1.238755703,
-0.1827988327,
0.4008656442,
0.2514092326,
-0.0553065464,
0.5455304384,
0.6796216369,
0.3910720348,
0.5398579836,
0.3436837792,
0.1878225356,
-0.4852240682,
-0.0225193724,
-0.4418482184,
0.3191932142,
0.1883186102,
-0.2957250476,
-0.3769216835,
-0.0275580063,
-0.3017205,
-0.0265734047,
-0.2934940755,
0.6357305646,
0.2089532018,
-0.6928372383,
0.6513220072,
-0.0057958062,
0.7195004225,
-0.6678587794,
0.4494362473,
-0.1574703008,
0.2610763013,
-0.0984188616,
-0.6543451548,
0.3816950619,
-0.2705740929,
-0.6050777435,
-0.121771045,
0.6648018956,
-0.3384032249,
0.0623414926,
0.3558524251,
0.7909553051,
0.1326267868,
-0.2548713088,
-0.8055217266,
0.1393790245,
-0.2396805137,
-0.4719224572,
0.4526965022,
0.4355207384,
-0.3077594936,
0.5491480827,
0.5921509862,
0.0178652126,
0.3507772684,
0.395301491,
0.9494609833,
-0.5364109278,
-0.760065794,
-0.9071703553,
0.3594592512,
0.0857514888,
-0.5185767412,
0.5529571176,
0.2875353098,
0.9752531648,
-0.1881303191,
0.9732937813,
0.2075771391,
0.4247901142,
-0.5475249887,
0.4483295977,
-0.5030765533,
0.0800555348,
0.0081471158,
-1.066214323,
0.051202558,
0.5059316754,
-0.3749808669,
0.3306173682,
1.0372709036,
0.4951662123,
-0.1530794054,
-0.2557516098,
0.3869101107,
0.2364129424,
0.0238149334,
0.6677149534,
0.6207801104,
0.0125809573,
0.1995499581,
-0.2332473099,
-0.3606182337,
-0.1766242683,
-0.7549781799,
-1.223225832,
-0.5940383673,
-0.1021780446,
-0.103445664,
0.3695412874,
0.7614122629,
0.8600050211,
-0.7305207849,
-0.3580881059,
-0.1638568938,
-0.0270461161,
-0.4028755724,
-0.2052622736,
-0.1879090369,
-0.4817036688,
-0.6086496115,
0.3973146081,
0.2814736962,
-0.0639261454,
-0.5950827599,
0.2543961406,
-0.1403943598,
0.1088086143,
0.2843999565,
0.2893970013,
-0.5430651307,
-0.169643417,
0.338822186,
-0.2251238823,
-0.0575683415,
1.4492324591,
-0.8124448061,
-0.1727506518,
0.584410131,
0.7692065835,
0.1689627916,
-0.1455839276,
0.5277962685,
-1.0267789364,
0.2236900628,
0.2173036039,
0.306150049,
0.3340619802,
-0.2357135862,
0.3571060598,
0.666883707,
-0.4258307815,
-0.820443511,
0.7889682055,
-0.524917841,
-0.3250981569,
0.9391406178,
-0.2275034189,
-0.334784627,
-0.074478671,
0.2239048332,
0.1172033101,
-0.1131055281,
0.639511764,
0.911920011,
-0.1738310754,
-0.3265186846,
-0.3636495173,
0.5287595391,
0.6460312009,
-0.4809253514,
0.0385422073,
-0.0955660269,
0.5486989617,
0.4182623327,
0.9112641811,
0.3751605749,
0.4065745771,
-0.0851802006,
0.0302651022,
-0.2320214063,
-0.604331851,
-0.0815235004,
0.3379688561,
0.1273798794,
0.0060779494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03923v1
|
Did Translation Models Get More Robust Without Anyone Even Noticing?
| 2024-03-06T18:33:51 | 2024-03-06T18:33:51 |
Ben Peters, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural machine translation (MT) models achieve strong results across a
variety of settings, but it is widely believed that they are highly sensitive
to "noisy" inputs, such as spelling errors, abbreviations, and other formatting
issues. In this paper, we revisit this insight in light of recent multilingual
MT models and large language models (LLMs) applied to machine translation.
Somewhat surprisingly, we show through controlled experiments that these models
are far more robust to many kinds of noise than previous models, even when they
perform similarly on clean data. This is notable because, even though LLMs have
more parameters and more complex training processes than past models, none of
the open ones we consider use any techniques specifically designed to encourage
robustness. Next, we show that similar trends hold for social media translation
experiments -- LLMs are more robust to social media text. We include an
analysis of the circumstances in which source correction techniques can be used
to mitigate the effects of noise. Altogether, we show that robustness to many
types of noise has increased.
|
[
-0.0497396253,
-0.6702849865,
0.7424984574,
0.1721260101,
-0.2034749091,
-0.0207251292,
-0.4554200768,
-0.5679125786,
0.0383517258,
0.2445991039,
-0.4153065681,
-0.3987420797,
-1.1502890587,
0.3209573627,
-0.9719255567,
0.939822793,
0.202346161,
0.2520791292,
0.1758203357,
-0.3351862729,
-0.1944081783,
-0.6560329795,
-0.5347640514,
-0.2872921228,
0.8789321184,
-0.3364996016,
0.952596724,
0.8589357138,
0.7819225192,
0.2683694363,
-0.4458121955,
0.213338837,
-0.2893470228,
0.4607643187,
-0.0236904044,
-0.8324370384,
-0.4468849599,
-0.2795109451,
0.6637954712,
0.7956371903,
0.162070334,
0.1238904819,
0.3993397355,
0.5549484491,
-0.2385816425,
-0.0469117574,
-0.8361632824,
-0.0856787786,
-0.1439890265,
-0.130626604,
-0.534894526,
-0.094525151,
-0.2131198943,
-0.6645498276,
0.1906138361,
-0.1796853691,
0.9911829233,
0.5812897682,
-0.4171343148,
-0.2071319222,
-0.9521259069,
0.9005511403,
-0.6685606241,
0.5723829865,
0.4725778699,
-0.0982469618,
-0.3980387449,
-0.7503937483,
-0.1991967112,
-0.0561549254,
0.1991398931,
-0.029081868,
-0.5223364234,
-0.1592118591,
0.3177046776,
0.0701165795,
-0.1508156657,
0.2133189291,
-0.2775638402,
-0.2737621963,
0.3471283913,
-0.0811432675,
0.3480929434,
0.0907523632,
0.0366508104,
-0.1227493808,
-0.5813020468,
-0.1465832591,
0.3636454344,
0.4396026134,
-0.1186715961,
0.7233703732,
0.0720987469,
0.6254431605,
-0.1041663736,
-0.0441714972,
-0.2002541423,
-0.3898111284,
-0.0665906742,
-0.3238329589,
0.9139524698,
0.499797821,
0.4593797624,
-0.2660477459,
-0.5280573368,
0.0373737141,
0.3577534556,
-0.5422818065,
-0.3453943431,
0.0073194061,
-0.5396690965,
-0.6117749214,
-0.1492150724,
-0.2591491044,
-0.5842041969,
-0.2654678524,
0.4099414647,
-0.1901476681,
-0.2544062734,
-0.2085021436,
0.1031061038,
-0.1551141441,
0.4411187768,
-0.9936775565,
0.1372670233,
0.8337728381,
1.1879466772,
-0.284719944,
-0.2874568701,
-0.6476652026,
-0.1718765497,
-0.8530738354,
0.8186560869,
-0.1863210052,
-0.0816575289,
-0.1304558516,
-0.0793401077,
-0.0893434659,
-0.6364735365,
0.4779585302,
-0.63495332,
-0.1828184724,
-0.6324341297,
-0.1346215308,
0.0600876361,
0.2294391394,
-0.4702008665,
0.7803914547,
0.0597504601,
-0.7520359159,
0.4555471539,
-0.4736641943,
-0.4929608703,
-0.4173024893,
0.117148459,
-0.5708993673,
0.5355834961,
0.2865099013,
0.3016745746,
0.0883612409,
0.3116585016,
-0.527821064,
-0.4087325037,
0.9836040735,
-0.7278442383,
0.8078782558,
0.232753396,
-0.1465690732,
0.1132596359,
-0.6111403108,
-0.1129753813,
-0.0638358891,
-0.6764578819,
-0.3347937763,
-0.0095233284,
-0.1219460666,
0.4388503432,
-0.1434046328,
-0.2794672549,
-0.0783870295,
-0.3095085323,
0.9598469734,
0.8402023911,
-0.2390276194,
0.5089812279,
-0.5008516312,
0.3441770971,
0.1920495033,
0.0513928533,
-0.0600425787,
-0.6940808296,
-0.6883392334,
-0.2022321373,
0.4699554145,
0.2461476177,
-0.4485744238,
0.1150122136,
-0.4381706715,
-0.1875455678,
-0.7537474632,
0.4254463613,
0.0559774488,
0.2466976494,
0.1716534197,
-0.1495784223,
-0.3063073754,
-0.6139655709,
-0.7192118168,
-0.2571449578,
-0.1292562634,
-0.0822092518,
0.376897186,
-0.206804052,
0.2825569212,
-0.0699286237,
0.0707183331,
-0.1518903077,
0.0629466772,
0.0189254787,
0.3368297219,
0.3697161376,
-0.7277594209,
-0.4685043395,
0.1077815443,
-0.6861876249,
-0.3133625686,
-0.0968191922,
-0.0102376891,
0.2060468495,
0.7984465361,
-0.6241042018,
0.3176256716,
0.7631798387,
0.11838682,
0.2844903469,
-0.1187277585,
-0.1397570521,
-1.1556736231,
0.1141761988,
-0.1470680237,
-0.558696866,
-0.7709562778,
0.0403792076,
0.1277634948,
0.2134777457,
-0.3345077634,
0.1898662597,
-0.5452312827,
-0.1076556519,
-0.3749791682,
0.0519844741,
0.0447989181,
0.2437914908,
-0.3075957298,
0.7042893767,
0.5948625803,
-0.684873879,
-0.1026822925,
0.0890057683,
-0.3858196735,
0.4010878801,
-0.6485055685,
0.0877300054,
-0.2488980889,
-0.192437157,
-0.9991042018,
-0.5428946018,
0.2008069307,
-0.6613112092,
0.4413796067,
-0.1739423126,
-0.6341790557,
-0.2128588557,
-0.1097354665,
0.0010966406,
0.4392097592,
-0.3989083767,
0.4271014333,
0.126656875,
-0.2225686312,
-0.3551489115,
-1.2449910641,
0.2797663212,
-0.2915979028,
-0.4769350588,
-0.2748526335,
-0.1231524721,
-0.503557384,
-0.1499918401,
-0.3417890668,
-0.4107846916,
0.6196804047,
0.3583138585,
0.2238005549,
-0.3046355546,
0.1409065425,
-0.0279759411,
-0.0333056338,
0.1605912596,
-0.2559656501,
0.3255648911,
-0.0290405229,
-0.4193432927,
-0.553406477,
0.1579124033,
0.8010290861,
-0.0872491151,
0.9372528195,
0.595313549,
-0.3238128424,
-0.118280828,
-0.4099428356,
-0.3723374009,
-0.4560247064,
0.5378177166,
-0.1117237136,
-0.757691443,
0.5628944039,
0.0318659022,
0.0864453837,
0.3409056664,
0.6215369105,
-0.213938266,
1.4893188477,
0.6676226854,
0.2144390047,
0.6962919235,
0.261131376,
0.304207772,
-0.8575817347,
0.0028629382,
-0.6257630587,
-0.5423792601,
-0.8009136915,
-0.1558555365,
0.2564021647,
0.1498758197,
-0.0236805137,
0.2179140449,
-0.4713955224,
0.3202366233,
0.6116521955,
0.0246578082,
0.5674036145,
0.373721987,
0.0373911113,
-0.3251287341,
-0.8664683104,
-0.418859899,
1.2791310549,
0.4133172631,
0.8030896187,
0.055666931,
0.3951126635,
0.0015534194,
0.7164093852,
-0.7225049734,
0.1182209104,
-0.2121185362,
-0.6837254167,
0.0314312205,
-0.5548078418,
-1.0187569857,
0.1775862873,
-0.3976384401,
-0.5928624272,
0.3078069687,
0.1975775659,
-0.6536011696,
0.4279272556,
-0.661845386,
0.4637522399,
-0.2940656245,
-0.191110462,
0.3518930674,
-0.7838494182,
0.3093400002,
-0.592242837,
0.4535578489,
-0.0628344119,
-0.1293833554,
0.523894608,
-0.2051253021,
0.7993659377,
0.3920835555,
-0.1395166218,
0.1174752042,
0.2912801802,
0.5477157235,
-0.2739949524,
-0.0755599067,
0.2932662666,
-0.1352757663,
-0.4356220067,
-0.4815574288,
0.6969458461,
-0.9066159129,
-0.3858530819,
-0.1875848472,
-0.8247341514,
0.1069761142,
0.4843558371,
0.6576830149,
0.2197609246,
0.0644518584,
0.4653666019,
0.8486608863,
-0.0799323842,
0.4422358274,
0.5312541723,
-0.2416560054,
-0.3542261422,
0.7185348868,
0.5145903826,
0.5955194235,
0.215804249,
0.2470024824,
-0.0621855818,
-0.8108018041,
-0.3222799301,
0.1066169888,
-0.6048808098,
-0.1358546019,
-1.0033936501,
-0.1513696164,
-0.3759032488,
-0.0296737365,
-0.6046909094,
-0.6306200027,
-0.260371536,
-0.0950028673,
0.1382814795,
1.0071152449,
-0.2999459207,
0.5937373042,
-0.8494848609,
0.3483205438,
0.1183495224,
0.2736486197,
-0.2790901661,
-0.7915709019,
-0.3611629009,
0.1922388375,
-0.3731747866,
-0.8274860978,
0.503939271,
0.1899844855,
0.0687810481,
0.4245702624,
-0.1146539226,
0.4256846905,
-0.2408585399,
0.7094438672,
-0.1949238926,
-0.6713320017,
0.1813162416,
-0.604205966,
0.4808772206,
0.2391449511,
-0.0037180639,
-0.3858016133,
-0.7270977497,
-0.4851027727,
-0.7150446773,
0.5537568331,
0.274401933,
0.3717885613,
-0.0543465577,
0.3789492548,
-0.0567786731,
0.3152558208,
-0.9582558274,
-0.1422789246,
-0.0424596146,
-0.0030819799,
0.0905542597,
-0.1264754385,
-0.21340774,
-0.1918605417,
0.4333584607,
0.0867889002,
0.0556600802,
0.2132979184,
-0.2085305303,
-0.4804176986,
0.2777117789,
0.8091757894,
0.5776469111,
-0.0018067592,
0.3390848637,
0.1540535837,
-0.4189962745,
-0.0322893895,
0.0000454441,
-0.5812774897,
0.2291270345,
0.6089584231,
0.7372097373,
0.1767605692,
-0.3364423513,
0.6906597018,
-0.1279378682,
-0.3488945663,
-0.0167269409,
-0.0409220718,
0.3644087315,
0.2392652184,
0.0450789519,
0.9545403719,
-0.2968885005,
-0.5298441052,
-0.0834182501,
0.3280918598,
-0.5555275679,
-0.6249256134,
1.2285326719,
-0.1980624348,
-0.4175106585,
0.4821612835,
0.0022196649,
-0.5557973981,
0.2380365282,
0.5063383579,
0.7796384692,
-0.2463594973,
-0.0146119623,
0.0178593546,
0.8263614178,
-0.4810765982,
0.1641641259,
0.1307936758,
-0.6333453655,
-0.5834720135,
-0.5435977578,
-0.2603593469,
0.190132767,
-0.7444629669,
0.0608134866,
-0.3666454852,
-0.652764082,
0.0467613526,
-0.4914203286,
-0.6497665644,
-0.0379658937,
0.0322800539,
0.6590158939,
-0.9672304392,
0.7043141127,
0.8936635256,
-0.0509920195,
-0.742430687,
0.000636701,
0.0668294802,
-0.6460862756,
0.4120215476,
0.1175043508,
0.1105498075,
-0.039233245,
-0.8077924848,
-0.9193532467,
0.5721608996,
0.8373860717,
-0.4570538998,
0.0656677783,
0.3865063488,
0.8557682633,
0.0984693021,
-0.1724974513,
0.3941557109,
0.4952778518,
-0.1517374963,
-0.7478105426,
-0.1493510455,
-0.19854559,
-0.0480665192,
0.1429987252,
-0.6846011281,
0.7825788856,
-0.2674932778,
-0.2375675291,
0.2132409215,
0.5042635202,
-0.2687377632,
0.2640082836,
0.0970256105,
0.3385954201,
0.8126455545,
-0.3117177188,
1.1470174789,
-0.343280524,
-0.1356943101,
1.0991803408,
-0.0982174724,
0.8504886031,
0.5416567922,
0.0464412272,
-0.039663624,
0.4360857904,
0.0521160625,
0.2965188026,
-0.0830809176,
-0.0281813629,
-0.5660765171,
-0.1874789745,
-0.2315836996,
0.03946447,
0.1896800995,
-0.6198918223,
-0.0237560105,
-0.0493482687,
0.254078716,
0.2226995677,
-0.1583654284,
0.8848891258,
0.485326916,
-0.6251088381,
0.4420504868,
-0.0390326418,
0.649964273,
-0.5885460377,
0.4128392935,
-0.3192034364,
0.3141400516,
-0.2436904907,
-0.6475207806,
0.6506708264,
0.1176867113,
-0.2718421519,
-0.4062156975,
0.6977127194,
-0.317294538,
-0.5556058884,
0.289966017,
0.788526237,
0.3112445176,
-0.5500009656,
-0.4345276654,
0.4546736181,
-0.0290058926,
-0.2917320132,
0.4707819223,
0.6908255816,
-0.0978439599,
0.8184107542,
0.9276922345,
0.51004529,
0.7280772924,
-0.0313381739,
0.8154851794,
-0.3267816305,
0.0815303922,
-1.039260149,
0.3392772973,
0.0960962772,
-0.278993994,
0.9260300994,
0.1960951388,
0.699490428,
0.0837498531,
0.6306247115,
0.4615577757,
0.4163817763,
-0.2159290463,
0.9957661629,
-0.5586205721,
0.3544465899,
-0.097941801,
-0.9977756143,
-0.7461627126,
0.3525277674,
-0.0789205357,
0.0145394746,
0.6102771759,
0.936968863,
0.0487101674,
-0.3413896859,
0.5952211618,
0.75236094,
0.2297082096,
0.0031649834,
0.9972808957,
-0.5371992588,
0.9261490703,
-0.1391833723,
0.1022218689,
-0.0300206318,
-0.8359785676,
-0.9315050244,
-0.2383474261,
-0.3770733178,
-0.6265233159,
0.2392624319,
0.8113900423,
0.6737121344,
-0.8558678031,
0.1661053747,
-0.1605601013,
0.2618547082,
-0.4252584875,
-0.0869454816,
0.1908437014,
-0.1822237521,
-0.7703191638,
0.5962904096,
0.1899162084,
0.3606668711,
0.1215944216,
0.2070759833,
0.1686908603,
0.2031085491,
0.542314589,
0.0732803419,
-0.5272132158,
-0.1641176939,
0.3699213266,
-0.5107613206,
0.2925676703,
0.4582079351,
-0.0777747631,
0.4772256613,
0.5171630979,
0.5572322011,
0.178564474,
0.0743021145,
0.8299103975,
-0.6016266346,
-0.054477416,
-0.1333657205,
0.2697173953,
0.7783038616,
-0.3509312272,
0.3394477963,
0.1604879647,
-0.6741903424,
-1.1122045517,
-0.0138890725,
-0.5504773855,
-0.1363924295,
1.0796619654,
-0.1235737279,
-0.311363548,
-0.1474388987,
0.0227056984,
0.4978395402,
-0.1974511594,
1.034889102,
1.0919739008,
0.281041801,
-0.0186977554,
-1.0521456003,
0.3153707385,
0.7538899183,
-0.2398374975,
0.0284712836,
0.1140450314,
0.4835285544,
0.1224670187,
0.3598583639,
-0.2564660013,
0.1264672875,
0.0773679987,
-0.4537557662,
-0.0250666477,
-0.3199590445,
-0.630474329,
-0.0929033458,
0.5927073956,
0.0749728307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03920v1
|
Enhancing Instructional Quality: Leveraging Computer-Assisted Textual Analysis to Generate In-Depth Insights from Educational Artifacts
| 2024-03-06T18:29:18 | 2024-03-06T18:29:18 |
Zewei Tian, Min Sun, Alex Liu, Shawon Sarkar, Jing Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
This paper explores the transformative potential of computer-assisted textual
analysis in enhancing instructional quality through in-depth insights from
educational artifacts. We integrate Richard Elmore's Instructional Core
Framework to examine how artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML)
methods, particularly natural language processing (NLP), can analyze
educational content, teacher discourse, and student responses to foster
instructional improvement. Through a comprehensive review and case studies
within the Instructional Core Framework, we identify key areas where AI/ML
integration offers significant advantages, including teacher coaching, student
support, and content development. We unveil patterns that indicate AI/ML not
only streamlines administrative tasks but also introduces novel pathways for
personalized learning, providing actionable feedback for educators and
contributing to a richer understanding of instructional dynamics. This paper
emphasizes the importance of aligning AI/ML technologies with pedagogical goals
to realize their full potential in educational settings, advocating for a
balanced approach that considers ethical considerations, data quality, and the
integration of human expertise.
|
[
-0.2690931559,
-1.2772854567,
0.2988258302,
-0.3006187677,
0.0233718883,
0.5316494107,
-0.1972741038,
-0.4675404131,
-0.1969937086,
0.4220362902,
-0.4145433307,
-0.7050154805,
-0.6347098947,
0.1315397471,
-0.7789151073,
0.9514972568,
0.0919166356,
0.2292862684,
-0.4576601982,
0.0398233682,
-0.7992171645,
-0.7046842575,
-0.6477737427,
-0.1660580188,
0.1926828027,
0.8133729696,
0.7273600101,
0.9697292447,
0.8557488322,
0.3107752502,
0.2145345211,
0.4847137332,
-0.190965116,
-0.0279667359,
-0.1292624027,
-0.4387673438,
-0.5901859403,
-0.0540952943,
0.7414554954,
0.9650248289,
0.0730241761,
0.3206280172,
0.8111606836,
0.8334992528,
-0.5910000205,
0.0882363543,
-0.2139936835,
0.2444657236,
-0.0388056003,
-0.3665433228,
-0.388704747,
-0.5433542132,
0.4492826164,
-0.6723041534,
0.1060971022,
-0.2203267813,
0.7229285836,
0.5643543601,
-0.2446377724,
-0.5685045123,
-0.9298306108,
1.0288612843,
-0.6263121367,
0.2574833035,
0.6349958777,
0.1189980358,
0.0445030853,
-0.702527225,
-0.4169138074,
0.0043937261,
-0.097403653,
0.1376068145,
0.2062552571,
0.0575613938,
-0.1290060431,
0.3840825856,
-0.4076929092,
0.2939184606,
-0.4092368484,
-0.0361096747,
0.7002030015,
0.383476615,
0.5390121341,
0.1363942176,
-0.0636159852,
-0.378099978,
-0.3095197976,
0.5663841963,
0.2987793982,
0.1538104266,
0.1890992373,
0.4630420506,
0.2546705306,
0.6518203616,
-0.0560858287,
-0.2622025609,
-0.0757513419,
-0.3274259269,
-0.1460412592,
0.2398552001,
0.5070363283,
0.2630744576,
0.0402055085,
-0.1019801423,
-0.0190759841,
-0.0597999617,
0.4294104874,
-0.6667041183,
-0.2070358396,
0.3513258994,
-0.6699379683,
-0.3085674047,
0.5626708865,
-0.8878813982,
-0.1973718405,
-1.1021077633,
0.2849776745,
-0.7602524757,
0.0640974864,
-0.2357125431,
-0.2711926401,
0.2343395054,
0.4591290951,
-1.0594116449,
0.4938638806,
0.9978732467,
0.6608269215,
-0.4414144754,
-0.3215176165,
-0.3482843637,
0.0346299186,
-0.3528083861,
0.8830425739,
-0.7710601091,
-0.7301720381,
0.359347105,
-0.3829759657,
0.0822600797,
-0.6043944955,
0.4255248308,
-0.1794367731,
0.5270944834,
-0.0561985523,
-0.9362758398,
-0.3889663815,
0.3922490478,
-0.6959428787,
1.2160601616,
0.1425492764,
-0.3572293818,
0.2406602651,
-0.8813644052,
-0.5272942781,
-0.0544110611,
-0.2027420402,
-0.4430268407,
-0.0474722162,
0.3354765773,
0.245666787,
-0.0935892984,
0.2451817542,
0.1260067523,
-0.5920693874,
0.3226396143,
-0.513733983,
0.9454168677,
-0.0138334008,
-0.6108391881,
0.2033369988,
-0.7991956472,
0.2164653391,
-0.2032785863,
-0.5823225975,
-0.4103920758,
0.1522453129,
-0.0065431888,
-0.4512176812,
0.2984386981,
0.0166831966,
0.2142322063,
-0.3287175,
0.0461938679,
0.7833723426,
-0.1408507228,
0.6711038351,
-0.3905415535,
0.3685181439,
-0.2666514516,
0.4910703301,
-0.5124813318,
-0.2802815139,
-0.841288805,
-0.0639055893,
0.2193244547,
0.6804977059,
-0.6937144995,
0.5741522908,
-0.0454754531,
-0.3397718668,
-0.791887939,
0.3716594279,
0.3173619807,
0.6314479113,
0.6424594522,
-0.3966915905,
-0.3872507215,
-0.3869677484,
-0.1829674244,
-0.195562616,
-0.0834212378,
0.1581892967,
0.3062617183,
-0.0284951422,
1.0557096004,
-0.3088405132,
-0.4538948238,
0.0015952291,
0.4482069016,
0.1039470211,
0.7420523167,
0.3468647301,
-0.7922561765,
-0.7351991534,
0.121737428,
-0.9461864233,
-0.0166778769,
-0.2467039973,
-0.2961716056,
-0.0273589175,
0.1900291443,
-0.0044458271,
0.568156302,
0.0894408673,
-0.2740134597,
0.498978734,
-0.1330160499,
0.5909443498,
-0.801841259,
0.0979103446,
-0.2127849311,
0.3181657493,
-0.7214755416,
0.0176076647,
-0.0138162784,
-0.1886556894,
-0.0375553668,
0.2754207253,
-0.2116833925,
-0.0014936565,
-0.3848134875,
0.1951731145,
0.2387252599,
0.3654152453,
-0.0636047646,
0.852068603,
0.1697248071,
-0.5013017654,
0.0865441635,
0.433924526,
-0.0567312166,
1.0229455233,
-0.5945156217,
0.2290664613,
0.0533965863,
-0.2300743461,
-0.5091667771,
-0.2085848451,
0.2031711489,
-0.5993050933,
0.5369435549,
0.0999218225,
-0.3619880378,
0.0107868817,
-0.7304382324,
0.0310617387,
0.5592184663,
-0.485684216,
0.6115173101,
0.2983085215,
-0.244819209,
-0.8753884435,
-0.4992670417,
0.2281294316,
-0.0571620204,
-0.3305026591,
0.5013145804,
-0.1440282911,
-0.4842809737,
0.3184423447,
-0.017551247,
-0.6677744389,
0.4427757859,
0.083165735,
0.705752492,
-0.4134238362,
0.1005041376,
0.5250223279,
-0.0656676069,
0.2716148794,
-0.3560198247,
0.0288350899,
0.1256692559,
-0.5047997236,
-0.9907445312,
0.6161798835,
0.37873739,
-0.3327371478,
0.6569312215,
0.7058642507,
-0.31295228,
-0.1613297909,
-0.3291083574,
-0.4962513745,
-0.4184574485,
0.2655653954,
0.2293853313,
-0.7314794064,
-0.0682763457,
0.1885921061,
0.5992798805,
0.2936899662,
0.0203252602,
-0.5772027373,
1.0387749672,
0.901006937,
-0.1207664609,
0.8105787039,
-0.6660532355,
-0.0139657995,
-0.7471064329,
-0.5069386959,
-0.7139779925,
-0.3088613153,
-0.2315374762,
-0.1417096555,
0.3413372338,
0.1384568214,
-0.3834559917,
-0.0087435609,
-1.1020276546,
0.3237811625,
1.0951128006,
0.3000085354,
0.5154775977,
0.0618375242,
0.3733169138,
-0.123819977,
-0.5210256577,
-0.9939885139,
1.0410301685,
0.3022139966,
0.4624820948,
-0.0564928129,
0.5658165216,
0.7528928518,
0.5162375569,
-0.7898014784,
0.4463737309,
-0.311478436,
-0.5806894302,
-0.5514571667,
-0.1688426733,
-0.8336818814,
-0.051461719,
-0.5472943783,
-0.4609403908,
0.0509726182,
0.2439187616,
-0.2071632743,
0.2970564961,
-0.7682827115,
0.8059971333,
-0.4734124243,
-0.4025680125,
-0.4184010029,
-0.4450853765,
-0.0138363205,
0.0269094631,
0.1718159914,
0.1968056262,
-0.1302957386,
0.8504449725,
-0.4433481693,
0.9241070747,
-0.0141121959,
0.1126191095,
0.6895494461,
-0.0588720031,
0.0139880162,
-0.336024493,
-0.1161981076,
0.1124688014,
-0.0728679299,
-0.5425847769,
-0.8496721387,
0.3860162497,
-1.0955461264,
-0.6274069548,
-0.1039629877,
-0.391939193,
0.0595328659,
0.1158386022,
-0.0270570088,
0.4948591292,
-0.1376366019,
0.2186054736,
0.8074424267,
-0.0706857294,
0.4982465804,
0.2580521107,
0.4763850868,
-0.4037663043,
1.2173285484,
0.3986111283,
-0.0787954256,
0.6351835728,
0.1564861387,
-0.0515693463,
-0.7278417945,
-0.3547137082,
-0.1246038452,
-0.8322961926,
-0.2777973711,
-0.3090916872,
-0.2688461244,
-0.2842534781,
-0.490624249,
-0.039031256,
-0.1900101602,
-0.9514069557,
-0.0107625099,
0.072500363,
0.8162415028,
0.1920096129,
0.4097442329,
-1.1182661057,
-0.1410407275,
0.4182113409,
-0.0085551888,
0.281298846,
-0.5543164015,
-0.4766276181,
0.1332611889,
-0.756280005,
-0.6166935563,
0.2750637233,
0.4796565175,
0.547060132,
0.5275031328,
-0.0548808724,
0.7122309208,
-0.4021404982,
0.9814633131,
0.057499066,
-1.0323929787,
0.8257338405,
0.1747479886,
-0.0019649921,
0.5325722694,
0.4497405887,
-0.1029475704,
-0.4656336904,
-0.3975501657,
-0.8520835042,
0.612315774,
-0.0041655586,
0.2419561893,
0.2437302917,
0.3043206036,
0.4393126965,
0.1631038189,
-0.2984929681,
-0.1602735221,
-0.557659626,
-0.7042841911,
0.3344323039,
-0.1329997927,
-0.1075238436,
-0.2490427196,
0.6402338743,
-0.1740801483,
-0.0535325892,
0.238607794,
-0.2997276187,
0.226594165,
0.2980782986,
0.3095460832,
0.8151525259,
0.1404151618,
-0.0655858591,
0.2435490191,
-0.716874361,
-0.1669377983,
-0.0433938652,
-0.0705710277,
-0.04189381,
0.9675218463,
0.342247963,
0.3476679325,
-0.6815404892,
0.225349009,
0.0469660349,
0.004744262,
-0.3375688195,
0.4783261716,
-0.4977385402,
0.1875941455,
0.8635940552,
-0.2048369944,
0.4640347064,
-0.4987953603,
0.2391141206,
0.217755869,
-0.4955357313,
-0.3214462101,
0.5750509501,
0.4528499246,
-0.6827836633,
0.8346192837,
0.5249507427,
-0.1767094731,
0.8876643181,
0.3547782004,
0.7922362089,
-0.3806662858,
0.2983945906,
0.337890178,
0.1627964228,
0.2477485687,
-0.0289931726,
-0.4816721082,
-0.2377652079,
-0.4138975441,
-0.167389974,
-0.8339918852,
-0.3988443315,
-0.8700011969,
0.1111327708,
-0.5852472782,
-0.1161499098,
-0.0715668201,
0.1059932113,
-0.3311398625,
0.3742547929,
-0.0498081222,
0.6519995928,
-0.5953166485,
0.5292782784,
0.7719914913,
-0.5760855079,
-0.6663707495,
-0.1830723584,
0.0426920876,
-0.5890699625,
0.5862452388,
0.0817491412,
-0.0141071826,
-0.0188843086,
-0.6435964704,
-0.4432217181,
1.2169902325,
0.0003996945,
-0.3297988176,
-0.0315490477,
0.2663081586,
0.7822611928,
-0.3193787336,
0.3705512881,
0.708930254,
0.3686258197,
-0.3291790187,
-0.3637526929,
-0.4554136693,
-0.0955965444,
-0.1807654351,
0.0140402634,
-0.0235791635,
0.3580481708,
-0.0741305947,
-0.251496017,
0.0462832004,
0.8052000999,
-0.2365532666,
0.702169776,
0.0872694403,
0.2501182258,
0.9152076244,
-0.1627115756,
0.7815741897,
-0.3606438339,
0.1172379255,
1.0461655855,
0.2642472982,
0.9123353362,
0.4462009966,
-0.3435043097,
0.7717626691,
0.5915547609,
-0.1505452693,
0.0465550646,
-0.4110333622,
-0.4020266831,
0.1804034114,
-0.3909652233,
-0.2480194271,
0.4144566655,
0.5405272245,
-0.3010830879,
0.2060085535,
0.0788340122,
-0.0087329224,
0.7181971669,
-0.4798587263,
0.9229285121,
-0.2159623057,
-0.6192348003,
0.1741388589,
-0.304125756,
0.4427578747,
-0.2278316915,
-0.5224995613,
-0.2453418523,
-0.0292170346,
-0.5304481983,
-1.0036751032,
0.468479991,
0.1589287072,
-0.1629388481,
-0.2629097104,
0.4910341203,
-0.3596384525,
-0.3667303324,
-0.0906976908,
0.3724581301,
-0.1737910509,
0.3226178288,
-0.7220401168,
0.0533000901,
-0.1713261455,
0.0959182233,
0.2013652325,
0.3948211074,
0.0754344463,
0.5756748319,
0.8924304247,
-0.203369379,
-0.2815475464,
0.0078293188,
0.6128793955,
-0.5760187507,
-0.0092763361,
-0.8805638552,
1.0423909426,
-0.4386927187,
-0.4488173723,
0.5779769421,
0.3869991004,
0.899592936,
0.1658766121,
0.5885689259,
0.0706105679,
0.3749621809,
-0.4616493881,
0.521722734,
-0.2261954993,
0.3840138018,
-0.1306359917,
-0.882178545,
-0.3601084352,
0.3840382099,
-0.1082178131,
-0.1653090119,
0.7040810585,
0.1762176007,
0.2111450583,
0.1223555803,
0.2330422252,
-0.1595065743,
0.3474354744,
-0.0015192803,
0.8245209455,
-0.4926320612,
0.4784139097,
-0.4562568963,
-0.4677111506,
-0.1788754463,
-0.4341034889,
-1.1039172411,
-0.6204915047,
-0.4416729212,
-0.0419933274,
0.1498529315,
0.9604430795,
0.4422565699,
-0.819370687,
-0.429154247,
0.0413020216,
0.5257049799,
-0.3634977639,
-0.3450649977,
0.6699523926,
-0.7013194561,
-1.0045208931,
0.2077477574,
0.351349026,
0.1351052076,
-0.3106921911,
0.12515755,
0.1361332685,
0.0339503512,
0.855035305,
0.2398545444,
-0.5658448339,
-0.3042197227,
0.339404881,
-0.1114869043,
0.1040274054,
0.9138006568,
-0.5601345897,
0.6216562986,
0.3061373532,
1.2649203539,
-0.1544070989,
0.1774773449,
0.4945148826,
-0.4317001998,
-0.2729346156,
0.5225993991,
-0.034829624,
0.3653291464,
-0.6304888725,
0.4403968751,
0.0573496185,
-0.6817555428,
-0.7344000936,
-0.3723436892,
-0.5832313895,
-0.4708585441,
0.4211304784,
-0.337246716,
-0.1241292059,
-0.2937183082,
-0.4852036238,
0.2993384898,
-0.1708905995,
1.3328585625,
0.7527211308,
-0.4250817299,
0.0298571214,
-0.4757376015,
0.3202530742,
0.2985381484,
-1.202480197,
-0.4104623795,
0.4756414294,
-0.2291533947,
0.2403269708,
0.0961538479,
-0.0793973729,
0.4437459707,
0.03649747,
-0.0903284028,
-0.143664673,
-0.404346019,
-0.1783715039,
0.2242839932,
-0.0394175649,
-0.2385146171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03909v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03909v2
|
A Measure for Transparent Comparison of Linguistic Diversity in Multilingual NLP Data Sets
| 2024-03-06T18:14:22 | 2024-04-16T10:00:41 |
Tanja Samardzic, Ximena Gutierrez, Christian Bentz, Steven Moran, Olga Pelloni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Typologically diverse benchmarks are increasingly created to track the
progress achieved in multilingual NLP. Linguistic diversity of these data sets
is typically measured as the number of languages or language families included
in the sample, but such measures do not consider structural properties of the
included languages. In this paper, we propose assessing linguistic diversity of
a data set against a reference language sample as a means of maximising
linguistic diversity in the long run. We represent languages as sets of
features and apply a version of the Jaccard index suitable for comparing sets
of measures. In addition to the features extracted from typological data bases,
we propose an automatic text-based measure, which can be used as a means of
overcoming the well-known problem of data sparsity in manually collected
features. Our diversity score is interpretable in terms of linguistic features
and can identify the types of languages that are not represented in a data set.
Using our method, we analyse a range of popular multilingual data sets (UD,
Bible100, mBERT, XTREME, XGLUE, XNLI, XCOPA, TyDiQA, XQuAD). In addition to
ranking these data sets, we find, for example, that (poly)synthetic languages
are missing in almost all of them.
|
[
-0.7696155906,
-0.1896197498,
-0.217855677,
0.6606373191,
-0.1936584413,
0.608101368,
-0.6279227138,
-0.5476734638,
0.5124691129,
0.4113373756,
-0.2170279771,
-0.5881890655,
-0.6190790534,
0.4819009006,
-0.4459252954,
1.006798625,
-0.0874230415,
-0.2629355788,
0.2169112265,
-0.8149192333,
-0.255771935,
-0.4644632638,
-0.1480033696,
-0.1120367646,
0.4254983366,
0.2512670159,
0.7881948948,
0.4470199049,
0.2906860411,
0.3984940946,
-0.3933509588,
0.4112246335,
-0.4658572078,
0.341881156,
-0.358163327,
-0.4057224393,
-0.0766651258,
-0.1952991635,
0.9598994851,
0.9036433101,
0.0056456402,
0.2838034034,
0.2396029681,
0.7200322747,
-0.6374807358,
0.0896071494,
-0.4659416378,
0.2913983464,
-0.6298049092,
-0.1729813218,
-0.1097212881,
-0.4286584854,
0.0686081871,
-0.1084016263,
0.2295112908,
-0.0162935257,
0.6074139476,
-0.203715235,
-0.2812925279,
-0.270147264,
-0.5028876066,
1.1217213869,
-0.5253215432,
0.5149666071,
0.2531993687,
0.328584969,
-0.0565276667,
0.0182620846,
-0.3460237086,
-0.3519603014,
-0.0181920622,
0.1529682726,
0.0302954912,
-0.3742077649,
0.0229830742,
0.659709096,
-0.7212244272,
-0.1796604991,
0.0131132435,
0.0288349558,
0.5982533693,
-0.0397820957,
0.401316762,
-0.2304875851,
0.3061334193,
-0.2743296921,
-0.1352124512,
-0.1626035571,
0.7067678571,
0.53533113,
-0.4036772847,
0.6154100299,
-0.3226927221,
0.5905942321,
-0.3331777751,
-0.3950089812,
0.6443335414,
-0.8072157502,
0.1507880092,
-0.2492896616,
0.6834988594,
-0.0988158882,
0.7106645107,
-0.3654155135,
-0.0474284627,
-0.1178532615,
-0.1860152185,
-0.2382532805,
-0.034327995,
0.0165889729,
-0.1670972854,
-0.2378650159,
-0.0628435537,
-1.0929219723,
-0.0929263309,
0.1308531612,
-0.4187625349,
-0.4484485686,
-0.5434246063,
0.0930767208,
-0.4086311162,
0.1120240092,
0.0948710218,
-0.8793743253,
0.4962622523,
0.5055087209,
0.8650918603,
-0.5645230412,
-0.3289986849,
-0.0657967106,
-0.1342859715,
-0.3119751513,
0.7683827281,
-0.7130689621,
-0.5473150015,
0.0618758649,
-0.0971721932,
0.0267718602,
-0.7836420536,
0.2331335247,
-0.1423000097,
0.4630591869,
-0.1075448543,
-0.3157305121,
-0.220679909,
0.5651689172,
-0.7476506829,
1.1289566755,
0.4637648165,
-0.7547876239,
0.7007662058,
-0.3677625656,
-0.4102755487,
0.4296165109,
-0.2846457362,
-0.4225043356,
-0.0559988357,
0.1627259254,
-0.2494325042,
-0.0950581282,
0.3122888207,
-0.5447108746,
-0.0135482615,
0.3532179892,
-0.5266249776,
1.0583150387,
0.0580099858,
-0.5098962188,
-0.2871531844,
-0.9040536284,
0.4796322882,
-0.2413529754,
-0.3653681278,
-0.473139286,
-0.0278793909,
0.3863636553,
0.2000799477,
-0.03952365,
-0.2559857965,
0.1085633188,
-0.5573644042,
-0.2497488856,
0.3804876208,
-0.1034793556,
0.1266254485,
-0.4664454758,
0.7918450236,
-0.2093643844,
-0.1608155966,
0.1521158218,
-0.8756655455,
-0.8794845343,
-0.4474388063,
0.5710585713,
0.6152510643,
-0.6611129045,
0.924303174,
-0.4275967777,
-0.4525375962,
-0.538736105,
0.4686140716,
0.589351058,
-0.2037264705,
0.2906618118,
-0.756096065,
-0.4557788372,
-0.8047741652,
-0.4491744339,
-0.2743656337,
-0.018492803,
0.2586934566,
0.3936542571,
0.0490644462,
0.8219075203,
0.2169062346,
-0.0351099186,
-0.4367203116,
0.2410387695,
0.2773981392,
0.3816491663,
0.6184262633,
-0.6284704804,
-0.658059895,
0.4372771978,
-0.6868901849,
-0.3397880197,
0.1097999141,
0.0738327876,
0.2541950941,
-0.1676059812,
-0.1536172926,
0.2258685976,
0.7666300535,
-0.3047677577,
0.4253008068,
0.1385859698,
0.4598818719,
-0.6603360176,
0.0836432055,
-0.1056094691,
-0.2807196081,
-0.5411271453,
0.2592740357,
-0.0866994485,
0.0128453169,
-0.2909202874,
0.6339251399,
-0.4177906513,
-0.3264417648,
-0.0226584002,
0.1328811795,
0.0687598884,
0.2508080304,
0.0843155459,
0.5765401125,
0.302451551,
-0.3054417372,
0.1744114757,
0.2266139984,
-0.5186425447,
0.4363439083,
-0.3052354157,
-0.1632189453,
0.0276257712,
-0.0883080438,
-0.7768818736,
-0.0281284824,
0.1816910058,
-0.4788732827,
0.1865751892,
-0.2169942707,
-0.4888793826,
-0.183710739,
-0.292555511,
0.5541636944,
0.2619699836,
-0.1819382012,
0.3361609876,
0.3542629182,
-0.4026164114,
-0.8361893296,
-0.8645501733,
0.3273535669,
-0.2573835552,
-0.8934464455,
0.2106878012,
-0.2553433776,
-0.4513599575,
-0.1386375725,
-0.0561912023,
-0.3157904446,
0.1289110333,
-0.1830151081,
-0.0799270123,
-0.3532983363,
0.0828410685,
0.1668546647,
0.1329999864,
-0.3475484252,
-0.4155372977,
0.5849017501,
-0.4504678547,
-0.4097100198,
0.2377508134,
0.5788137317,
0.312105,
-0.2206122279,
0.6412873864,
0.579190433,
-0.0657787696,
-0.3043514192,
-0.6683962941,
0.4229863882,
-0.3998703957,
0.2844671011,
-0.2372235805,
-0.8807294369,
0.7022944093,
0.411449939,
0.1822442859,
0.3512111604,
0.7517364025,
0.2558537424,
0.5582286119,
0.5440549254,
-0.1172395498,
0.3527026772,
0.0544428676,
0.0425214209,
-0.1098441407,
-0.1388691813,
-0.7757675052,
-0.1245472804,
-1.011234045,
-0.355771929,
0.1411039531,
-0.0175535399,
0.2317885756,
0.3138397038,
-0.3337181509,
0.5882350802,
0.3686214685,
-0.2989946306,
0.5758829117,
0.2861645222,
-0.1256079227,
-0.0833922476,
-0.6478628516,
-0.423602283,
0.9467409849,
0.0857046917,
0.5077892542,
0.269798398,
0.8988755345,
0.2793720365,
0.2454544455,
-0.5363926888,
0.4176372886,
-0.3584512472,
-0.5692676902,
-0.4376825094,
-0.7173245549,
-0.9102904201,
0.5213361382,
-0.3930851221,
-0.4608676434,
0.4965028167,
-0.2246521264,
0.0983080119,
0.0784150586,
-0.5320512652,
0.706566155,
-0.3072964549,
-0.1342891604,
0.0409552604,
-0.1936146766,
0.3748014867,
-0.3500169516,
0.3471542001,
-0.252600044,
0.0183505639,
0.6844004393,
-0.23066625,
0.4753248692,
0.2549439967,
-0.0598113276,
0.1298981011,
0.0672221109,
-0.1238204613,
0.1109104455,
-0.2064917386,
0.5340205431,
-0.0452196784,
-0.536487937,
-0.4466593564,
0.6666172147,
-0.6984394789,
-0.2895310223,
-0.5356147289,
-0.6549897194,
-0.294220984,
0.2582217455,
0.1604699343,
0.1636611521,
-0.2141430676,
0.3809538484,
0.2782325745,
-0.2656973004,
0.458760798,
0.5276235938,
-0.3116726577,
-0.3747894466,
0.8102591038,
0.3232872188,
0.4319369793,
0.2473661751,
0.2080213577,
-0.1325255334,
-0.6659891009,
-0.2490166724,
0.1011977419,
-0.5653582811,
0.0764156803,
-0.5466982126,
-0.186395824,
-0.3644945323,
-0.0773775056,
-0.2109556198,
-0.5744139552,
0.3597386777,
0.1316265017,
0.2164020687,
0.3049102426,
0.0625938401,
0.0898490623,
-0.7153224945,
0.3846550286,
0.0116617614,
0.5431140065,
-0.2934900522,
-0.4940942526,
-0.0359244794,
-0.1448399127,
-0.1961092055,
-0.6995224953,
0.7509699464,
0.4127503335,
0.7850356102,
0.2004076093,
-0.284917891,
0.5730508566,
-0.2871467173,
0.6573741436,
0.0785201341,
-0.9941767454,
0.4138711691,
-0.2277709246,
0.5149200559,
0.8303138018,
0.3876341283,
-0.771237433,
-1.1116338968,
-0.6172940731,
-0.7914038301,
0.2995112836,
0.6823162436,
-0.1194568947,
-0.2109808624,
-0.2230515927,
0.3481684923,
0.2816305459,
-1.0472619534,
-0.3057461977,
-0.3070830107,
-0.2952578962,
0.0005213933,
0.0062549757,
-0.1961996853,
0.0396069735,
0.3078058064,
-0.092563726,
-0.2244719565,
-0.0570271946,
-0.2172447145,
0.0966289714,
0.6244505644,
0.2508647144,
0.8853048682,
-0.3104126155,
0.0583643802,
0.1497864872,
-0.5701563358,
0.1998901665,
0.1587848216,
-0.2454267442,
0.580552876,
0.5846511126,
0.3198889196,
0.0684277415,
-0.7145158052,
0.1983990967,
-0.0067548482,
-0.0454339199,
-0.2197347134,
0.08295656,
-0.009710826,
-0.0167488735,
0.0254782122,
0.1933893263,
0.2682392597,
-0.5611557961,
0.3920534849,
0.3818050325,
-0.2670271397,
-0.030215567,
-0.1782410443,
0.2456702441,
-0.2725637555,
0.4478386939,
-0.3191700876,
-0.1681825668,
0.7845081091,
0.3587200642,
0.8984891176,
-0.4184605181,
0.1968898028,
0.2374125272,
0.7244612575,
-0.0774108693,
0.2578176856,
-0.0061889826,
-0.7780243158,
-0.2943392694,
-0.6481384635,
-0.432700038,
0.0921001509,
-0.6357203126,
0.2374518961,
-0.3684780896,
-0.0318588428,
0.1399528533,
-0.1331723034,
-0.5077167749,
0.0877341107,
0.2392939031,
0.8994547725,
-0.8148332238,
0.8303692937,
0.1513405442,
-0.2400976717,
-0.031872496,
-0.0553203262,
-0.0208337195,
-0.6964808106,
0.5878699422,
0.2168888301,
-0.1245676652,
-0.6628701091,
-0.0408191383,
-0.8190841079,
0.373971194,
0.2817334235,
-0.5157706738,
0.1318357438,
0.559479177,
0.7318277359,
-0.3799780309,
0.5085895658,
0.5142745376,
0.5919126868,
-0.2867097855,
-1.0932266712,
-0.3263276517,
-0.7198598981,
0.0738641024,
0.3540979922,
-0.2790499628,
0.5918489099,
0.3049833179,
-0.4202955961,
0.0243305862,
0.4490870535,
0.2627418041,
-0.0220913161,
0.7000907063,
0.2677539885,
0.7486250997,
-0.0965200663,
0.985509038,
-0.4865302145,
0.5556221604,
0.8794721365,
-0.180996865,
0.537140727,
0.3338913321,
-0.3302942514,
0.4961878359,
0.2294810712,
-0.3396378756,
0.2576002181,
0.4264631271,
-0.2790613472,
-0.1204089969,
-0.1356718391,
-0.4581165314,
0.5236905813,
0.5170878768,
-0.1739531755,
-0.6160310507,
-0.0975027531,
-0.1228730083,
0.199502036,
-0.003524486,
0.4499046504,
0.0438509062,
-0.6219916344,
0.8549865484,
-0.0594569407,
0.7969458699,
-0.9463222623,
0.0643822029,
-0.5414643884,
-0.1589555889,
-0.1908728927,
-1.1618901491,
0.52929914,
0.1009635925,
-0.1525070369,
-0.0752905607,
0.3483902514,
-0.8472371101,
-0.7466968894,
0.6770278215,
0.7082921863,
0.1189208999,
0.2064361125,
-0.8245153427,
-0.1133970693,
0.0492118187,
0.0410254151,
0.2314740419,
0.3536979854,
-0.3987656534,
0.8231261373,
0.2815179527,
0.4005322158,
0.283532083,
0.3775990009,
0.5310447812,
-0.7459244132,
-0.7298613191,
-0.6943560243,
0.2045574039,
-0.3853028715,
-0.6282402873,
0.8455103636,
0.4783806801,
0.9069762826,
0.0842860937,
0.9473510981,
-0.0024036525,
0.6092036963,
-0.2162719667,
0.5788580775,
-0.4621108174,
0.1344899535,
-0.3786313832,
-1.1003704071,
-0.4464639425,
0.3764858544,
0.0071399324,
0.2048026472,
0.5923773646,
0.7024362087,
-0.2882888615,
0.04983427,
0.3431601822,
-0.0147705125,
0.1407686919,
0.4001404643,
0.743702352,
-0.0762844384,
0.7755567431,
-0.2136000544,
-0.5002364516,
0.069391951,
-0.8118828535,
-0.8824742436,
-0.3834728301,
-0.3248031437,
-0.4068079889,
0.3417435884,
0.6250687242,
0.4578992128,
-1.2148065567,
-0.6763191223,
0.1591668874,
0.2570768893,
-0.362662226,
-0.2178897709,
-0.0004760898,
-0.4204644859,
-0.7184572816,
0.3737427294,
0.5702212453,
-0.0897755176,
-0.300647229,
0.1904832125,
-0.1258084774,
-0.0718526989,
0.3755546808,
0.4237272441,
-0.6740218997,
-0.1582494974,
-0.1318707764,
-0.0301200654,
0.2233633995,
0.6661396623,
-0.3457663357,
0.6513824463,
0.6256683469,
0.6139786839,
0.3497199118,
-0.4091073871,
0.6848956347,
-0.9490701556,
0.3658297658,
0.3376161158,
0.4549333155,
0.4580853581,
0.1037297249,
0.5510838032,
0.2848155797,
-0.1065508276,
-0.5255211592,
0.3331978917,
-1.2150651217,
-0.0488047525,
1.0555875301,
-0.2719313204,
0.0073016873,
-0.6935625076,
0.1692984551,
-0.1994925439,
-0.2045752257,
0.9868887067,
0.874360919,
0.3566180766,
-0.0833963305,
-0.3694440722,
0.4044437706,
0.4873477519,
-0.8605719209,
-0.092429623,
0.1536145359,
0.1977598071,
0.6262713671,
0.4050804973,
-0.4271605611,
0.2375042737,
-0.0092746718,
0.1188293099,
0.3419698477,
-0.2390874177,
-0.2036403418,
0.3472730517,
-0.0969761759,
0.1442242265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03894v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03894v3
|
IRCoder: Intermediate Representations Make Language Models Robust Multilingual Code Generators
| 2024-03-06T17:52:08 | 2024-04-15T16:29:41 |
Indraneil Paul, Goran Glavaš, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Code understanding and generation have fast become some of the most popular
applications of language models (LMs). Nonetheless, research on multilingual
aspects of Code-LMs (i.e., LMs for code generation) such as cross-lingual
transfer between different programming languages, language-specific data
augmentation, and post-hoc LM adaptation, alongside exploitation of data
sources other than the original textual content, has been much sparser than for
their natural language counterparts. In particular, most mainstream Code-LMs
have been pre-trained on source code files alone. In this work, we investigate
the prospect of leveraging readily available compiler intermediate
representations (IR) - shared across programming languages - to improve the
multilingual capabilities of Code-LMs and facilitate cross-lingual transfer.
To this end, we first compile SLTrans, a parallel dataset consisting of
nearly 4M self-contained source code files coupled with respective intermediate
representations. Next, starting from various base Code-LMs (ranging in size
from 1.1B to 7.3B parameters), we carry out continued causal language modelling
training on SLTrans, forcing the Code-LMs to (1) learn the IR language and (2)
align the IR constructs with respective constructs of various programming
languages. Our resulting models, dubbed IRCoder, display sizeable and
consistent gains across a wide variety of code generation tasks and metrics,
including prompt robustness, multilingual code completion, code understanding,
and instruction following.
|
[
-0.3493752778,
0.1426787823,
0.1909389645,
0.1347570866,
0.0087314947,
0.2762795985,
-0.4894662499,
-0.3537972569,
0.04881211,
0.4537279606,
-0.1760801375,
-0.2404099256,
-0.6585745215,
0.2288269252,
-0.2808358073,
1.11371696,
-0.1378403455,
0.3774532974,
-0.0916440412,
-0.351842761,
-0.3027690649,
-0.686065495,
-0.2765500546,
-0.3678184152,
0.7996942401,
0.6240150928,
0.6901592612,
0.4822569489,
0.4263904393,
0.2819841802,
0.4743070304,
-0.1005377769,
-0.491096437,
-0.0780179054,
-0.1568738967,
-0.498267144,
0.0057220291,
-0.3962199688,
0.6795620322,
0.603726685,
-0.0217909142,
0.410360992,
0.0621041283,
0.7443269491,
-0.6510648727,
0.3643211424,
-0.6013677716,
0.007193326,
-0.156310007,
-0.335498333,
-0.7811726928,
-0.2105778307,
-0.2677496374,
-0.1766480654,
0.0205976255,
-0.1380470097,
0.7834226489,
0.1302526295,
-0.402766645,
-0.491548717,
-0.9490386248,
0.5654966235,
-0.6015615463,
0.6754230857,
0.1004249305,
0.3326337934,
0.1855628043,
-1.0133647919,
-0.3599695265,
-0.4517559111,
-0.457043916,
-0.1997308433,
-0.2069890052,
0.0867374688,
0.2631705105,
0.2442163378,
-0.596557796,
-0.0105839996,
-0.4708250165,
-0.1558083445,
0.0939485282,
0.0241061561,
0.5289930701,
-0.0299058706,
-0.1162490994,
-0.0689500347,
-0.957023561,
-0.095619753,
0.2260225713,
0.2857223153,
-0.1426364481,
0.5075606108,
0.1737273932,
0.8712064624,
-0.0431429446,
-0.0525416806,
0.1561608315,
-0.4445756972,
0.131886676,
-0.1303009093,
0.6471378207,
-0.0359146409,
0.2408401072,
-0.1602498144,
-0.245175451,
0.1425753087,
0.1446004063,
-0.801553607,
-0.3680295646,
-0.19853127,
-0.4855256379,
0.176559478,
-0.0255928561,
-0.3464820981,
0.1415006965,
-0.5853316784,
0.2181908786,
-0.4627674818,
-0.3432071507,
0.2176273018,
0.2089981586,
0.4107865393,
-0.0864405334,
-0.5054596663,
0.0923314095,
0.2336489558,
0.598711133,
0.2157572955,
-0.3843790591,
-0.5312217474,
0.3641578853,
-0.373036623,
0.5126972198,
-0.7355774045,
-0.0167993475,
0.110892266,
-0.0349183865,
0.005309735,
-0.2986223996,
0.0989879295,
-0.7514181137,
0.0635888502,
0.0156778395,
-0.3400416374,
-0.0314271189,
0.124728702,
-0.7189545631,
0.879566431,
0.1510264128,
-0.8864825368,
0.1102200449,
-0.2945327163,
-0.2611534595,
-0.0450895429,
-0.6262671947,
-0.1974129826,
0.2225366831,
0.1491155028,
0.4566498697,
-0.2996520698,
0.3683342338,
0.0998498872,
-0.2765164077,
0.248981446,
-0.3736860454,
0.2473196387,
0.3858325481,
-0.2401927561,
-0.0097327912,
-0.5695884228,
0.0423611067,
-0.2253660709,
-0.3853830993,
-0.3547616601,
-0.0852922127,
-0.0508479737,
0.4837155938,
0.2810742855,
-0.1389428526,
0.1123146489,
0.1848392338,
-0.0117292888,
0.6282773018,
-0.2147969604,
0.4548649788,
-0.2448102981,
0.7453721166,
0.1849930584,
-0.0993865952,
-0.7197750211,
-0.1216545925,
-1.1234265566,
-0.1948406547,
0.4693878293,
0.4967789948,
-1.2815034389,
0.039471101,
-0.5638649464,
-0.3806191087,
-0.4113626182,
0.2379930913,
0.8077329397,
0.1797978431,
0.1507602334,
-0.0295171905,
-0.7166392207,
-0.917160213,
-0.4184811115,
-0.4129749537,
0.1909837574,
-0.0435786322,
0.3230169713,
-0.4449672699,
0.8194045424,
-0.4193834662,
-0.0017586766,
-0.6025321484,
0.1278556138,
0.3170796931,
0.7087396979,
0.6864760518,
-0.7528842688,
-0.9447387457,
0.3337202966,
-0.659298718,
-0.232474938,
-0.3508488834,
-0.2431018203,
0.0184493214,
0.9800121784,
-0.1584257483,
0.0137215229,
0.8690063357,
-0.1876140386,
0.7360306978,
-0.4757289886,
0.1839939654,
-0.9576548338,
0.3168238401,
-0.05779998,
-0.4097073078,
-0.7499989867,
0.3898532689,
0.3865377605,
-0.3512617052,
-0.4960612059,
0.3788286746,
-1.0221657753,
-0.0682153031,
-0.2314289957,
-0.3683693111,
-0.1174342781,
0.7089896202,
0.129824385,
1.0301882029,
0.7245995998,
-0.4028936327,
-0.1015179977,
-0.3334791958,
-0.2224523872,
0.0751989037,
-0.5926178098,
0.3216858804,
-0.4188207388,
-0.0318674855,
-0.5693986416,
-0.320617944,
0.1091482192,
-0.5498031378,
0.6669096351,
-0.4436487257,
-0.5214133263,
-0.2362082303,
0.0849902332,
0.4647784233,
0.7054471374,
-0.5669884086,
0.7615842223,
0.2905965745,
-0.2664578855,
-0.500253737,
-0.7617747784,
0.1811727881,
0.0351582915,
-0.5130751133,
0.0298048537,
-0.0559815504,
-0.1064298898,
0.130166769,
-0.0094174659,
-0.0980364382,
-0.4664189517,
-0.029879773,
0.325068891,
-0.377956748,
0.0596184768,
0.0628400892,
-0.4124886394,
-0.0230399314,
-0.3847638071,
0.4920982122,
-0.3110924363,
-0.616940856,
-0.033359535,
0.457164824,
0.6244695783,
-0.3741473556,
0.8580942154,
0.498408556,
-0.3294546306,
-0.0516518839,
-0.5419008136,
0.1010514721,
-0.4769541025,
0.5216113925,
-0.4956245124,
-0.9560354352,
0.6649391055,
-0.1719774008,
-0.0708449408,
0.1330696195,
0.460645318,
0.3415002227,
1.0441529751,
0.9272180796,
-0.2652134895,
0.7178327441,
-0.1810268462,
0.2348845005,
-0.5406386852,
-0.3449205756,
-0.9113995433,
0.0196945183,
-0.3877837658,
-0.8169437051,
0.3280107975,
0.3377594054,
-0.2601942718,
0.5317948461,
-0.3428274989,
0.771071732,
0.380007565,
0.0736620203,
0.0379201844,
0.2787588835,
-0.1793944836,
-0.2171604931,
-0.9861201644,
-0.5323829055,
0.8172528148,
0.3581297994,
1.1223269701,
0.0755170062,
0.7028647661,
0.2696173787,
0.4024129212,
-0.3078547418,
0.4002814889,
-0.3938317597,
-0.3301673532,
0.3766329587,
-0.6075050831,
-0.3861677349,
0.2256433219,
0.2568221986,
-0.3272815049,
0.3468389213,
0.1599781364,
-0.1420842558,
0.2404921055,
-0.8962650299,
0.7367061973,
-0.3399364352,
-0.4516955614,
-0.072743766,
-0.7222658396,
0.0820815787,
-0.1835639775,
0.3968769312,
0.2126328945,
-0.0985476151,
0.5447078943,
-0.3684698045,
0.8946123719,
-0.1732471138,
-0.0674717203,
0.2867260277,
0.1876573563,
0.6086162925,
0.2075242996,
-0.1858608127,
0.2296111435,
-0.4107881486,
-0.4139813483,
-0.4709848166,
0.7040038705,
-0.8065848351,
-0.470267266,
-0.4984948933,
-0.3985473514,
-0.0235490054,
0.2886143029,
0.2109461278,
0.6466374993,
0.1355097741,
0.1753919721,
0.6515642405,
-0.3498170674,
0.2896307707,
0.6276975274,
-0.3743683696,
-0.5195324421,
1.0333683491,
-0.2498410791,
0.4568840265,
0.431211561,
-0.0677330792,
0.0493095852,
-0.3891263902,
-0.4927936792,
0.2217045575,
-1.0012249947,
-0.5138365626,
-0.6185251474,
-0.3482812643,
-0.104355745,
-0.4182062745,
-0.5046405792,
-0.1604681313,
-0.2441991568,
0.0097202528,
0.2957606912,
0.7583584189,
-0.5264247656,
0.3876965046,
-1.2284086943,
0.4635930061,
0.0396087281,
0.312073946,
-0.0567812584,
-0.4095151126,
-0.9205952883,
0.1804618835,
0.2105370462,
-0.5979409814,
0.3999860287,
0.4905639589,
0.6774178743,
0.2480354011,
-0.0625695437,
1.0380476713,
-0.610196054,
0.734616518,
0.4727475643,
-0.9749158621,
0.323867321,
-0.0471549481,
0.4603475928,
0.7122275829,
0.5652394891,
-0.6228033304,
-0.565433383,
-0.0042510019,
-0.7056767344,
0.9767791033,
0.2106731534,
0.3111326098,
-0.1037001982,
0.3319157064,
0.3464665413,
-0.0804914385,
-1.1923726797,
-0.2277892381,
-0.0824231729,
-0.2088474184,
0.0085534258,
-0.3006821275,
0.2226137519,
-0.1995874643,
0.502695322,
-0.3237353861,
0.3715242743,
0.0785769746,
-0.4612962306,
-0.0029806513,
0.1818756759,
0.2689777613,
0.6283706427,
0.1465580612,
0.4326457977,
-0.2169299722,
-0.3787147403,
0.303095758,
0.0824503005,
-0.0179239605,
0.3513256609,
0.6169515252,
0.8523259759,
0.2195535898,
-0.6607840061,
0.3691294789,
-0.2390700132,
0.4411832988,
-0.3217474818,
-0.1035952941,
0.0696335733,
0.0854011178,
0.4066431224,
0.547595799,
-0.0265577585,
-0.4966217577,
0.4284520149,
-0.050831385,
-0.488325268,
-0.5191400051,
0.4850267768,
0.0955148861,
-0.0211235657,
0.5913437605,
-0.1662514061,
-0.771704793,
0.4994527102,
0.5844756365,
0.7950731516,
-0.2733198404,
0.0182413477,
0.4742436707,
0.3787585497,
-0.1694170684,
0.2436468601,
-0.129768759,
-0.5765255094,
-0.6329354644,
-0.4852823317,
-0.015296991,
-0.350420177,
-0.8272365928,
0.4671173096,
0.1212192848,
0.1114948615,
-0.5637189746,
-0.4772672653,
-0.7527468801,
-0.1892132163,
0.286193192,
0.9801647067,
-0.724376142,
1.2228938341,
0.797344625,
-0.5989001393,
-0.8964349627,
0.1301930696,
-0.4807539582,
-0.7099915743,
0.9004511237,
0.1954293698,
-0.2747519612,
-0.1364459693,
-0.4333901107,
-0.7720420957,
0.7153740525,
0.8870413303,
-0.8663578033,
-0.2824858129,
0.4426214099,
0.5012927651,
-0.4212648273,
0.384454459,
0.2711090446,
0.1121417433,
0.059402246,
-0.795671761,
-0.1829011142,
-0.4790144563,
0.2743546367,
0.2804105282,
-0.402369827,
0.8897694945,
-0.3602481782,
-0.1554469466,
0.0776607841,
0.7165193558,
0.3853022158,
-0.0949329585,
0.1044102907,
0.1606607139,
0.2325739563,
0.0263505764,
1.0515480042,
-1.0343171358,
0.2566295862,
1.241784811,
-0.2246799171,
0.6531341672,
0.6689821482,
0.120767884,
0.6684602499,
0.3299879134,
0.5049291253,
0.7730206847,
0.1802522391,
-0.3872448206,
-0.1989727616,
0.0416760892,
-0.7645453215,
0.1866165847,
0.5181598663,
-0.3821207583,
-0.2204224169,
0.2847802937,
0.0245194808,
0.1366270185,
-0.2453160435,
0.723695755,
0.1828798056,
-0.5873035789,
0.5683550835,
0.0217651594,
0.6893751025,
-1.1164132357,
-0.2762517631,
-0.5102238655,
0.4445180595,
-0.0339029618,
-0.6465267539,
0.4703738689,
0.2187497467,
-0.1726716608,
-0.4816070497,
0.9295853376,
-0.7773580551,
-0.593023777,
0.6056650281,
0.3906047344,
-0.0238675363,
0.291230768,
-0.5761527419,
0.4911264181,
0.3057564497,
-0.0181608424,
0.2069712281,
0.7103662491,
0.2144545168,
0.6042631865,
0.5508782864,
0.2180917859,
0.3847982883,
-0.0019751,
1.1677632332,
-0.6669917703,
-0.453137666,
-0.61808002,
0.6940160394,
0.3129704297,
0.094284147,
0.7837209702,
0.6729829907,
1.1646519899,
-0.4598401487,
0.8659159541,
-0.3979929984,
0.0160015803,
-0.7334086895,
0.7118275166,
-0.4191941619,
0.4598378837,
-0.2175014615,
-0.8483735919,
-0.4410169125,
0.4105658829,
0.0575316586,
0.007716395,
0.470223248,
0.8978011608,
-0.2177444696,
-0.5295633674,
0.2877982259,
0.0529963821,
0.3163379431,
0.627353549,
0.9050406814,
-0.4344317019,
0.691972971,
-0.1493477821,
-0.1292402744,
-0.0123691717,
-0.7319197655,
-0.8012462258,
-0.5676680207,
-0.2691802979,
-0.2679757476,
0.1334504336,
0.9449312091,
0.7168104053,
-0.7815170884,
-0.6807206869,
-0.1447265446,
-0.0496402271,
0.1793703884,
-0.1421586424,
0.0857444555,
-0.5534825325,
-0.5790746808,
0.1741086245,
0.1778776497,
-0.0991429538,
-0.4273302555,
-0.7306922674,
-0.146415174,
-0.2120607793,
0.6030751467,
0.2802862525,
-0.3483627439,
-0.1091444269,
0.1287215948,
-0.3139470518,
0.0856996924,
1.2127380371,
-0.854778707,
0.5168265104,
0.4747830331,
0.5294445157,
0.241930455,
-0.5167581439,
0.8330953121,
-0.910304606,
0.4862354696,
0.1678035408,
0.6362899542,
0.3346056938,
-0.2151299417,
0.3501628637,
-0.2244701535,
-0.4302140176,
-0.8952040076,
0.1714244485,
-0.3769401908,
-0.3071226478,
1.0576257706,
-0.4542540014,
-0.0865625814,
-0.0443224087,
-0.1888749152,
0.2523065805,
-0.3313351572,
0.0733835176,
0.3484914005,
-0.0667864382,
-0.3193917572,
-0.26384902,
0.2543488443,
0.1881431192,
-0.568505764,
0.1050953344,
0.6024739146,
0.1951084286,
0.291947186,
0.7066062093,
-0.3697652519,
0.3022196591,
0.1681596637,
0.4533266127,
-0.0002150991,
-0.6689549088,
-0.4474023879,
-0.0582421273,
0.4185456336,
-0.0034374504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03893v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03893v3
|
From One to Many: Expanding the Scope of Toxicity Mitigation in Language Models
| 2024-03-06T17:51:43 | 2024-05-30T17:37:11 |
Luiza Pozzobon, Patrick Lewis, Sara Hooker, Beyza Ermis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To date, toxicity mitigation in language models has almost entirely been
focused on single-language settings. As language models embrace multilingual
capabilities, it's crucial our safety measures keep pace. Recognizing this
research gap, our approach expands the scope of conventional toxicity
mitigation to address the complexities presented by multiple languages. In the
absence of sufficient annotated datasets across languages, we employ translated
data to evaluate and enhance our mitigation techniques. We also compare
finetuning mitigation approaches against retrieval-augmented techniques under
both static and continual toxicity mitigation scenarios. This allows us to
examine the effects of translation quality and the cross-lingual transfer on
toxicity mitigation. We also explore how model size and data quantity affect
the success of these mitigation efforts. Covering nine languages, our study
represents a broad array of linguistic families and levels of resource
availability, ranging from high to mid-resource languages. Through
comprehensive experiments, we provide insights into the complexities of
multilingual toxicity mitigation, offering valuable insights and paving the way
for future research in this increasingly important field. Code and data are
available at https://github.com/for-ai/goodtriever.
|
[
-0.1883129776,
-0.5127840042,
0.2848922014,
0.439820677,
0.0380219519,
-0.3762571812,
-0.1235673204,
-0.4585475922,
-0.1711888015,
0.808627665,
-0.3559758663,
-0.5315949321,
-0.5139656067,
0.0957776383,
-0.0166763626,
1.2489118576,
0.201299414,
0.1359081119,
-0.1950722635,
-0.5674263835,
-0.3443138897,
-0.5992477536,
-0.7348964214,
-0.2519091368,
1.1306912899,
0.7468448281,
0.8181098104,
0.236000374,
0.656064868,
0.2095561475,
-0.090264,
-0.178164795,
-0.6955836415,
0.1054511145,
-0.4132917523,
-0.4965175986,
-0.3655933738,
-0.125854969,
0.6155135036,
0.696454525,
-0.1746862531,
-0.0238880422,
0.0848176554,
0.826895833,
-1.0199757814,
-0.1240706146,
-0.4195723832,
0.1251931787,
-0.2942427695,
-0.1771604717,
-0.6265906096,
-0.4158399999,
0.2201955765,
-0.5400944352,
-0.3919670284,
-0.1182705462,
0.4268456399,
0.3095634878,
-0.7855470777,
-0.1109830439,
-0.7217237949,
0.9513847232,
-0.8839485645,
0.1868545264,
0.396508038,
0.2205967158,
0.0639401376,
-0.6786167622,
-0.059681315,
-0.0645371228,
-0.2157709002,
0.0905163139,
-0.1941767633,
0.1020087749,
0.0861726776,
-0.0176180638,
-0.5542923808,
0.0381465741,
-0.3687554896,
-0.4750059247,
0.6019539833,
0.1474100649,
0.5968428254,
-0.0626763031,
-0.4658166766,
-0.0418069474,
-0.8870667815,
-0.148309797,
0.4130331576,
0.5309177041,
-0.0970639512,
0.2194007337,
-0.108648479,
0.2444293499,
-0.7104244828,
0.2016717345,
0.2297232747,
-0.8737514019,
0.0260364711,
0.1531194299,
0.8712466955,
0.4347285032,
0.1219912544,
-0.2471651584,
0.2076862454,
-0.3450433016,
0.2873258293,
-1.0127497911,
-0.1251547933,
0.1260226816,
-0.521481812,
-0.2841406167,
-0.3460180461,
-0.9250379801,
-0.4101772308,
0.1725998074,
0.6001583934,
-0.2587681711,
-0.6549636722,
0.311142534,
-0.0499822572,
-0.0996951684,
-0.1891437173,
-0.639854908,
0.2812578976,
0.3666165173,
0.8772698641,
-0.2420109212,
-0.4753262401,
-0.4818089008,
0.3652868569,
-0.4582734406,
0.7280107141,
-0.561065197,
-0.5735985637,
0.0729633272,
-0.0695308596,
0.0551127307,
-0.5609610677,
0.768381238,
-0.2454488575,
0.2517305315,
-0.5399563313,
0.0686708316,
-0.2868619561,
0.3267234266,
-0.827162385,
0.5275602937,
-0.0295225233,
-0.8869141936,
0.1134196967,
-0.6841175556,
-0.7366330624,
-0.1325931698,
0.3805536926,
-0.5557786226,
0.0862366483,
-0.1492730528,
0.170182392,
-0.2703741491,
-0.0666005388,
-0.3601905704,
-0.0447738059,
-0.107850194,
-0.5880813599,
0.8140078187,
0.5320980549,
0.2516259551,
0.4509227574,
-0.3603026569,
0.1496253759,
-0.0109021571,
-0.4292242825,
-0.6887907982,
0.0731758177,
0.4701353312,
0.6946392059,
-0.0488960631,
-0.4469261467,
-0.1619758755,
-0.5006164312,
0.5288697481,
0.2388565242,
0.4728649259,
0.5781796575,
-0.5232519507,
0.4692726433,
0.1057847291,
0.550943017,
-0.1070724279,
-0.2947081327,
-0.4730755389,
0.0030104059,
0.0405311286,
0.5496482849,
-0.6392232776,
-0.01538595,
-0.3520250618,
-0.5255340338,
-0.3272781074,
0.0374850109,
0.7614688277,
0.1645096242,
0.5482036471,
-0.3581433594,
-0.2374691665,
-0.8897030354,
-0.3406331241,
-0.0522206761,
0.2447954714,
0.3820797503,
0.343821466,
-0.5268468261,
0.6142716408,
-0.3088273406,
-0.4488965571,
-0.1642654985,
-0.0937626362,
-0.2679467201,
0.6906118393,
0.82294029,
-0.6681573987,
-0.6625534892,
0.334292382,
-0.6135700941,
-0.0931782648,
-0.2022022903,
-0.5705975294,
0.0087245991,
0.4595932066,
-0.2408279628,
0.1654451191,
0.6986145377,
-0.0502524264,
0.4257476628,
-0.2925710082,
0.2294367999,
-0.930595994,
0.2659651041,
-0.0910333246,
0.0885483772,
-1.1104588509,
0.284679383,
0.0918236226,
-0.0126696751,
-0.9216511846,
0.7812697291,
-0.3503625691,
0.37317729,
-0.0541752055,
-0.0900164098,
0.1221307367,
0.1453518122,
-0.1810715348,
0.7494244576,
0.6128488779,
-0.606697619,
-0.082086429,
0.3715412319,
0.1481493264,
0.497426033,
-0.3975880146,
-0.1866971254,
-0.0708568692,
0.2073561549,
-0.8319069147,
-0.1468420923,
0.2815268636,
-0.3593146205,
0.3037614226,
-0.3419238329,
-0.5463039279,
-0.0962996036,
-0.3527527452,
0.5878344774,
0.0711431354,
-0.436162591,
0.5613536239,
0.5170613527,
-0.4562238753,
-0.46073246,
-0.9467709064,
0.2472523898,
-0.6370916367,
-0.7029486299,
-0.0873841792,
-0.3946324587,
-0.1279938966,
-0.2269962877,
-0.1680561602,
-0.4674138129,
0.2891841233,
-0.2781882882,
-0.0556534603,
-0.1909932047,
0.5037235022,
0.2868210673,
-0.3613148928,
0.2658058107,
0.0024275098,
0.4346303344,
-0.0532136336,
-0.1466995329,
-0.0247541759,
0.8129546642,
0.5875357389,
-0.7623086572,
0.8585989475,
0.3631258905,
-0.371327579,
0.019123435,
-0.2897354662,
-0.0623864084,
-0.4663563967,
0.6626820564,
-0.3173013628,
-0.4158450067,
0.8264799714,
-0.1923598945,
0.062428236,
0.5164263844,
0.5312050581,
0.4434678853,
1.0314651728,
0.624274075,
-0.3465383947,
0.4314443171,
-0.1280024648,
0.1982785761,
-0.6977139115,
-0.000434396,
-0.6157115102,
0.0805649757,
-0.4935561419,
-0.3692831695,
0.5169318914,
-0.0608961545,
-0.4951047003,
0.1746226847,
-0.4740174711,
0.6803858876,
0.2835462391,
0.3466138244,
0.4745911062,
-0.0520856418,
-0.141031906,
-0.0049683829,
-0.9415050149,
-0.4953464568,
1.1203309298,
0.452303648,
0.7944617271,
0.4600556493,
0.6440989971,
-0.2612131536,
0.5416577458,
-0.4703122079,
0.1413104236,
-0.3906155229,
-1.230997324,
-0.3914459646,
-0.5514320731,
-0.8464336991,
0.3942250013,
-0.0233775154,
-0.5051051378,
0.054354839,
-0.1364213526,
-0.3463095725,
0.2795124352,
-0.8715603352,
1.3087780476,
-0.5125531554,
-0.8233810663,
-0.4493744969,
-0.9290946126,
0.3252022266,
-0.3131079674,
0.4826491177,
-0.1448946446,
-0.0686408654,
0.5663932562,
0.0076818811,
0.6845383048,
0.0984692946,
-0.3027780652,
0.3496289551,
0.0579483658,
0.3003259301,
0.2032019496,
-0.4055293202,
0.3459911942,
0.2802765667,
-0.6446409822,
0.0557169467,
0.9569518566,
-0.4397706091,
-0.217406705,
-0.2942191064,
-0.798971951,
-0.191184178,
0.6336073875,
0.4384562075,
-0.0223482661,
-0.3031767309,
0.0592095181,
0.6398413181,
-0.8176505566,
0.3889862001,
0.5918056369,
-0.0256514922,
-0.2197974324,
1.1323775053,
-0.0873595998,
0.8104270697,
0.184376955,
0.5673713684,
-0.1875305623,
-0.4105727077,
-0.2144281715,
0.2480306476,
-1.006161809,
-0.1853613853,
-0.4779755473,
-0.1786710322,
-0.262231648,
0.0755054578,
-0.5210817456,
-0.0267083663,
-0.1749692857,
-0.0538890213,
0.2665293515,
0.4569469094,
-0.1296743006,
0.3005618453,
-1.2629580498,
-0.0012246898,
0.0579809733,
0.66342026,
-0.0647899136,
-0.1269573867,
-0.2287062854,
0.1854501367,
-0.2757445872,
-1.0222885609,
0.4207358956,
0.4450930059,
0.8454114199,
0.1988273114,
0.1948647201,
0.5115897059,
-0.626229167,
0.4895070493,
0.2830746174,
-0.7723993063,
0.5508794785,
-0.5802949667,
0.3062099814,
0.7221610546,
0.4902496934,
-0.9063610435,
-0.4431141913,
-0.085405387,
-0.9141942859,
0.538836062,
0.3723023832,
0.5008699298,
-0.1244390011,
0.1067078188,
0.0853081867,
-0.1784661412,
-0.726398468,
-0.3490687311,
-0.0687785596,
-0.1688358486,
-0.1871747673,
-0.2875916362,
-0.299454838,
-0.0766195431,
0.5992789268,
0.0700350702,
-0.1317104399,
-0.0456802621,
-0.2814002335,
-0.3812971711,
0.5847685933,
0.4697364569,
0.1917318255,
0.1010308564,
-0.0567454807,
0.3367223144,
-0.5055598617,
0.0174232814,
0.1233726442,
-0.0092189219,
-0.3304305375,
0.3339751959,
0.431946665,
0.1930939257,
-0.6485800147,
0.2977366447,
0.0279636737,
-0.0087783216,
0.2102199793,
0.0035572655,
0.0684466958,
0.0966728628,
0.1148357019,
0.0776189938,
0.4334228039,
-0.6426264644,
0.4664793015,
0.3779894114,
-0.4424064457,
-0.035111811,
0.6248716712,
0.5036543012,
0.124187991,
0.4700753689,
-0.0496097766,
-0.5083104372,
0.6408849359,
0.5280303359,
0.611082077,
-0.4309460521,
-0.0033679549,
0.7445060611,
0.425175637,
-0.0740702376,
-0.0352501124,
0.573361814,
-0.6518138051,
-0.2703556716,
-0.2694294751,
-0.1517285258,
-0.2310529798,
-0.5819576979,
0.0380915962,
-0.1250763983,
-0.0544976182,
-0.061280936,
-0.0132820411,
-0.2836024761,
-0.154485777,
0.1902419776,
0.657454133,
-1.1999207735,
0.6799736023,
0.5898348093,
-0.849194169,
-0.5109273195,
0.0762045234,
0.1022069007,
-0.2004567832,
0.2675368786,
0.1506772339,
-0.0037163044,
0.2311454862,
-0.3282626569,
-0.9156227708,
0.7815235853,
0.2310979068,
-0.3660230041,
0.1209351346,
0.2278843671,
0.6317668557,
0.0433077626,
0.1729450971,
0.7960090637,
0.648435235,
-0.0615483448,
-1.0481240749,
-0.0125643956,
-0.2187281549,
-0.1529399455,
0.2089772075,
-0.5170651078,
0.6276134253,
-0.3450699747,
-0.2483960688,
0.1043638662,
0.0928034931,
0.0026563755,
0.4032797515,
0.2444656044,
0.4435568452,
0.4429671168,
0.1077795625,
1.0291157961,
-0.2059261203,
0.4860948622,
1.1010950804,
-0.1867420971,
0.699958086,
0.3936274648,
-0.1861338913,
0.1487395912,
0.5099622607,
0.3064428568,
0.7096343637,
0.2812030017,
-0.406042546,
-0.2440099269,
-0.3935213983,
-0.2760617733,
0.078682512,
0.4431885779,
-0.0996911451,
-0.5155262947,
0.447039932,
0.1276926696,
0.1147406772,
-0.2306774557,
0.6299437284,
0.0541142151,
-0.5935297012,
0.4986375868,
-0.2337049544,
0.5799501538,
-0.598293364,
-0.0132838646,
-0.448425293,
0.3399564326,
-0.3811385036,
-0.8717145324,
0.4960243106,
-0.2597022653,
0.0196674895,
-0.0719323531,
0.6138397455,
-0.7008323073,
-0.3615322113,
0.6634532213,
0.6077786684,
0.0973072648,
-0.213550806,
-0.5880940557,
-0.0640939325,
-0.1137055308,
-0.0036591855,
0.3224630952,
0.4496343136,
-0.4527027011,
0.8593302965,
0.5656472445,
0.0481669828,
0.3132963181,
0.2589143515,
0.9000261426,
-0.3438426256,
-0.2217810303,
-0.6376289725,
0.7123352289,
0.1846634448,
-0.3860733509,
0.788887918,
0.7313183546,
0.8104836941,
-0.0477183424,
0.6753216982,
0.1329715252,
0.2047865987,
-0.2565021813,
1.1691997051,
-0.7244431376,
0.2675401866,
-0.3370044827,
-0.6998701692,
-0.8268284202,
0.4912211001,
-0.1127624959,
0.0374681763,
0.8556140661,
0.847810626,
-0.0824687332,
-0.4637337029,
0.3024357855,
0.3685672879,
0.5191850066,
0.7276587486,
0.6105194688,
-0.4825653732,
0.9158650041,
-0.4782015979,
0.0184735693,
-0.1290082335,
-0.8176963925,
-0.6014584899,
-0.3311441541,
-0.3433740437,
-0.1598512977,
0.2320796102,
0.4306590855,
0.6573463678,
-0.8839489818,
-0.0090937708,
-0.1226362884,
0.2987636626,
-0.2285878807,
-0.1287059784,
0.096132122,
-0.5575627089,
-0.366215378,
-0.0313351564,
0.1678179353,
-0.047572393,
-0.1527479142,
-0.4692496359,
-0.3576958477,
0.0629877374,
0.7778741717,
0.3679911196,
-0.5612550378,
-0.3629215658,
-0.0852815583,
-0.5435185432,
0.0335527509,
0.4496826828,
-0.2360144705,
0.6422327161,
0.6223762631,
0.526394248,
0.1979931295,
-0.2452277392,
0.4781203568,
-0.8224084377,
0.1570334584,
0.4164713323,
0.2190409303,
0.1932186186,
-0.3562960625,
0.7289794683,
-0.3693052232,
-0.4561397135,
-0.6669517159,
0.3667595088,
-0.8094188571,
-0.5491794944,
1.4579068422,
-0.3225271702,
0.2472347319,
-0.1828914434,
-0.33109501,
0.3989936411,
-0.0014599412,
0.6031520367,
0.828783989,
0.2314639539,
-0.1777100116,
-1.0294282436,
0.3795668483,
0.4896911383,
-1.2710465193,
0.3558299541,
0.4860019684,
0.5421974063,
0.2097780406,
0.4727736115,
-0.3822053373,
0.4252349436,
-0.3480889499,
0.085919261,
0.4722018242,
-0.4837991297,
-0.4590626061,
-0.3232295811,
0.1200994924,
0.1626504064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03888v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03888v2
|
FaaF: Facts as a Function for the evaluation of generated text
| 2024-03-06T17:48:06 | 2024-04-08T14:49:52 |
Vasileios Katranidis, Gabor Barany
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The demand for accurate and efficient verification of information in texts
generated by large language models (LMs) is at an all-time high, but remains
unresolved. Recent efforts have focused on extracting and verifying atomic
facts from these texts via prompting LM evaluators. However, we demonstrate
that this method of prompting is unreliable when faced with incomplete or
inaccurate reference information. We introduce Facts as a Function (FaaF), a
new approach to the fact verification task that leverages the function-calling
capabilities of LMs. FaaF significantly enhances the ability of LMs to identify
unsupported facts in texts, while also improving efficiency and significantly
lowering costs compared to prompt-based methods. Additionally, we propose a
framework for evaluating factual recall in Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
systems, which we employ to compare prompt-based and FaaF methods using various
LMs under challenging conditions.
|
[
-0.1714546829,
-1.2016710043,
0.9404978156,
0.1640643626,
-0.2651178241,
-0.0588770062,
-0.048266463,
-0.2036855221,
-0.0906776562,
0.4872273207,
-0.5274582505,
-0.1741572171,
-0.477761507,
0.4896257222,
-0.6870669723,
1.0065422058,
0.262432605,
-0.2180226296,
-0.7763835788,
-0.0524568446,
-0.1529071778,
-0.5595322251,
-0.489991188,
-0.4432524443,
0.2973288596,
0.584759295,
0.6787708998,
0.6145014167,
0.5224975348,
0.2996235788,
0.0390543826,
0.7675500512,
-0.2910645902,
0.1593079865,
-0.0188040659,
-0.138628304,
-0.148275122,
-0.3188313246,
0.904800117,
0.53987813,
-0.1173822507,
0.3223578036,
-0.1961143613,
0.832165122,
-0.6918429732,
0.3844774663,
-0.6038892269,
-0.1620168388,
-0.0295287184,
-0.4206025004,
-0.6664203405,
-0.8730294704,
0.1406966448,
-0.4576582611,
0.2561993599,
0.2332399487,
1.0704512596,
0.2853132784,
-0.66870749,
-0.6914510727,
-0.7260362506,
0.5310769081,
-0.5051058531,
0.6945499182,
0.3883571327,
-0.0153436055,
-0.4475531578,
-0.742146492,
-0.8697431087,
-0.5861057043,
-0.3055896461,
-0.1501394957,
-0.0291330665,
-0.1533327848,
0.5313129425,
0.2870198786,
-0.1780439019,
-0.5320242047,
-0.2822636068,
-0.3105507791,
0.5001875758,
-0.0152727291,
0.3886979222,
-0.4388893247,
-0.6165679693,
-0.0924954191,
-0.8748401403,
0.0703807026,
0.1697583199,
0.4000815451,
-0.0735348091,
0.5829210877,
-0.1407477856,
0.6075078249,
0.1225028783,
-0.4334592819,
0.2272248268,
-0.3450705409,
-0.2911891043,
0.132626608,
0.6466659307,
0.1440992057,
0.0328022316,
-0.1218456328,
-0.3309701085,
-0.4355456531,
0.1173231602,
-1.0234245062,
0.0849263743,
0.1940878481,
-0.1622801572,
-0.386741519,
0.2910323441,
-0.6332589984,
-0.5901079178,
-0.0173271801,
0.6920326948,
-0.3894973397,
-0.2369410247,
-0.0688624904,
-0.2298066914,
-0.102395989,
0.2156624496,
-0.5850180387,
0.1123989671,
0.5659540892,
0.7081861496,
0.1623335183,
-0.048005484,
-1.00406003,
-0.1308228225,
-0.5155007243,
0.8789249063,
-0.3307515979,
-0.6078516841,
0.1744922251,
-0.2078840435,
0.1344497353,
-0.473503232,
0.9059798717,
-0.7271260023,
-0.0490247756,
-0.8810862303,
-0.5679546595,
-0.3005745113,
0.2022402585,
-0.9161067009,
1.3612412214,
0.0894644782,
-0.7035509944,
0.3234171569,
-0.7849141359,
-0.6809195876,
0.0808398873,
-0.1605888903,
-0.5123597383,
-0.0206877831,
0.0121635869,
0.4372887611,
-0.6155108809,
0.5491039157,
-0.222362712,
-0.2981350422,
0.7646710873,
-0.5680520535,
0.624067843,
0.3081014752,
-0.2349674553,
-0.0734378994,
-0.9289373755,
-0.2214936316,
0.073150672,
-0.7825061679,
-0.2011676431,
0.2658621967,
-0.2422107309,
-0.2804355919,
0.1562772393,
-0.6704267859,
-0.2073060274,
-0.3940342367,
-0.1017731577,
0.4766886532,
0.3946520984,
0.0620293468,
-0.4603072703,
0.1760322899,
-0.0739926621,
-0.2735028565,
-0.4931827188,
-0.2406164259,
-0.9704289436,
-0.3312321305,
0.3624055684,
0.316363126,
-1.096673131,
0.4785145521,
-0.0821913704,
-0.3380765021,
0.0274184402,
-0.0719462782,
0.4273076653,
1.0060563087,
0.1463561803,
0.2980757952,
-0.6547027826,
-0.5476760864,
-0.213288933,
-0.596065104,
0.2277616709,
0.198424682,
0.3827147186,
-0.0292273741,
1.0446724892,
-0.4684686065,
0.1881321967,
0.00423927,
0.3828410208,
0.2174984664,
0.0373239629,
0.5843328834,
-0.8749241829,
-0.1510991007,
0.0235102437,
-0.8034842014,
-0.301846385,
-0.0839157701,
0.2832691967,
0.6508697867,
0.4808470607,
-0.6081814766,
0.2341834605,
0.2561855614,
-0.6629126668,
0.7135451436,
-0.2007677853,
0.7008144259,
-0.4041678309,
0.6967664957,
-0.1644782424,
-0.5162955523,
-0.5387327671,
0.1076465175,
0.2272185832,
-0.0282396637,
-0.3391245008,
0.7742887735,
-0.5254802108,
0.1323803812,
-0.4862376451,
0.0881820768,
-0.0154153919,
0.1846620589,
-0.1723177731,
0.8294889927,
0.3779449463,
-1.1007509232,
0.3435023129,
0.2074989229,
-0.5337595344,
0.3460402787,
-0.3312522769,
0.0166248493,
-0.2286067009,
0.021785792,
-1.0483268499,
-0.3093888164,
0.1865941286,
-0.3612563312,
0.0785474777,
0.0160295218,
-0.5938656926,
-0.2886967063,
-0.1065687314,
0.1178561002,
0.4825758934,
-0.7337030768,
0.723982811,
0.4222891331,
-0.1469750404,
-0.8791586161,
-0.151113987,
-0.2429650426,
0.0505298972,
-0.3711456954,
-0.1470039487,
-0.1196255907,
-0.4400072992,
0.0880362391,
-0.4898855686,
-0.0826255754,
0.3186726272,
0.2876663506,
0.3954600692,
-0.3281260729,
0.4131680131,
0.002322976,
0.0665865839,
0.262064606,
0.002324498,
0.1504661143,
0.0076732635,
-0.3002811968,
0.030986771,
0.2306696326,
0.6335688233,
-0.1585371047,
0.4934687614,
0.5030891299,
-0.5154297352,
-0.3987221122,
-0.6826634407,
-0.2305169553,
-0.4610848427,
0.2990876734,
-0.2581410408,
-0.856385231,
0.2743954659,
-0.0548218414,
0.1420377046,
0.6509215832,
0.4923799634,
0.1846525818,
0.5971455574,
0.6295410991,
0.4955566227,
0.181157589,
0.2708040178,
0.3000725806,
-0.1846496165,
-0.426669836,
-0.8210632801,
0.3172921538,
-0.0188952386,
-0.4096335173,
0.6809066534,
0.1577323973,
-0.2883654237,
-0.079753913,
-0.0003278406,
0.6951988935,
0.2195408344,
0.0039364216,
0.5023117661,
0.1010852605,
-0.1878659576,
0.457071811,
-0.5785403848,
-0.4702051282,
1.058421731,
0.3408791125,
0.3537050486,
0.2293297797,
0.4239947796,
0.6217919588,
0.6730036736,
-1.0394920111,
0.6885114908,
-0.1710944176,
-0.7724943161,
-0.4238035083,
-0.7259054184,
-0.4425446391,
0.0493904501,
-0.5538157225,
-0.5375871658,
0.0537689179,
0.3828294575,
-0.7019881606,
0.1017197594,
-0.7013107538,
0.3870235682,
-0.1596355289,
-0.2636537552,
-0.0137085188,
-0.2120855153,
0.6095386147,
-0.3152831197,
0.4656008184,
-0.2224663794,
0.0844272375,
0.8349057436,
-0.6487994194,
0.5650154352,
-0.1818720847,
-0.2416259348,
0.6970874667,
0.2521265149,
0.5957353115,
0.1610821784,
-0.3931646645,
-0.1258982718,
0.2122981846,
0.2369169146,
-0.7367785573,
0.6387008429,
-0.3954432309,
-0.7075654864,
-0.6932323575,
-0.3863747418,
-0.2980959415,
0.4289477468,
0.0674733073,
0.800635159,
-0.4224833846,
0.3288243711,
0.7006179094,
0.0288504716,
0.5904597044,
0.8058257699,
-0.4447230995,
-0.2870774269,
0.9896835685,
-0.0413256362,
0.0439140685,
0.6135480404,
0.3389499485,
-0.7406363487,
-0.173957631,
-0.6931154728,
0.1547468603,
-0.8404478431,
-0.5066738129,
-0.8634397984,
-0.1408846378,
-0.1037829593,
0.2861173153,
-0.1974326968,
-0.5991070867,
-0.1647139341,
-0.1738497466,
0.5684477091,
0.8730231524,
-0.1377283186,
0.0916243792,
-0.9892171025,
0.5208391547,
0.1213319749,
0.3117536604,
-0.0301170666,
-0.3152393103,
-0.32186234,
0.0232731011,
-0.2109263688,
-1.0529023409,
-0.0763766095,
0.2586430907,
0.4814092815,
0.332359165,
0.3949530721,
0.2745745182,
-0.5670416951,
0.735751152,
0.2249906659,
-1.1734142303,
0.1452154815,
-0.103122279,
-0.0156544354,
0.2578361332,
0.3184776008,
-0.4367727041,
-0.1910017133,
-0.6853768229,
-0.5311482549,
0.8494678736,
0.1143193096,
0.0230755657,
-0.264339596,
0.4523225725,
0.0104069542,
0.2020271569,
-0.4378739893,
-0.6014499068,
-0.076887548,
-0.2735623419,
0.1645823419,
-0.5226507187,
-0.338696599,
0.0978588834,
0.8710842133,
-0.3825185895,
0.2372186035,
0.5015367866,
-0.0275553577,
-0.4100335538,
0.27009359,
0.6608951688,
0.7579250932,
-0.2055099756,
0.446988076,
0.2617350817,
-0.4212656617,
0.2936026752,
0.0715341792,
-0.4212230444,
0.2757660151,
0.2770574987,
0.6767132878,
0.3399488032,
-0.8278878927,
0.6057780385,
0.0799880996,
-0.1175213605,
-0.0176538359,
0.3444485068,
-0.0113916369,
0.0066790399,
0.6625263691,
0.0646281019,
0.3017570674,
-0.6528558731,
0.6931782961,
0.4498114586,
-0.2258039713,
-0.2143327147,
0.3785581589,
0.3661155701,
-0.243563816,
0.2653074563,
-0.2931211591,
-0.5385953188,
0.6629475355,
0.7126746774,
0.7682772279,
-0.1289032698,
0.5167125463,
0.5329597592,
0.2045724243,
-0.279918462,
0.3373667896,
-0.1136193499,
-0.8035811782,
-0.3416599333,
-0.876804769,
-0.4709042609,
0.226149857,
-0.4182258248,
0.3193331957,
-0.6067108512,
-0.2808730602,
0.2309452146,
-0.0298754815,
-0.3869339228,
0.590700686,
0.042356886,
0.8824589849,
-0.7930046916,
0.4554283917,
0.6819608808,
-0.3822820783,
-0.8248942494,
0.2164542228,
0.2319227606,
-0.6735593081,
0.6847802401,
-0.0779149681,
-0.5606238842,
-0.1038315296,
-0.4955563843,
-0.9316722751,
0.6759154797,
0.6099922061,
-0.11855378,
0.2737127244,
-0.135369122,
0.2949406207,
-0.2186079323,
0.3719440699,
0.5774313211,
0.7158634663,
0.4153480828,
-0.7130485177,
0.3977020681,
-0.1695864499,
-0.3616723716,
0.2297574431,
-0.5220032334,
0.6167027354,
-0.5992726088,
-0.5995874405,
0.1598054171,
0.9653230906,
0.2965968251,
0.3741723299,
0.6587274671,
-0.0260882881,
1.1010442972,
-0.1773994863,
0.9535551667,
-0.0469968058,
0.4368773997,
0.7469142079,
-0.2448248863,
0.725479722,
0.4095230997,
0.0174540412,
0.4968659282,
0.1450039744,
0.0935241356,
0.228871718,
-0.0706109554,
-0.3225975931,
-0.3376545906,
-0.239649415,
-0.1478655487,
0.3565465808,
0.2539333999,
-0.088817656,
-0.4447393715,
-0.2482598871,
0.3363066316,
0.1802617311,
-0.0802848488,
0.673828423,
-0.0586514659,
-0.9826197624,
0.736928165,
0.231107071,
0.0498361737,
-0.5791010261,
-0.3603543043,
-0.099082917,
0.0856868103,
-0.3485377133,
-0.6848537326,
0.374047935,
0.2884097099,
-0.4664069712,
0.0680005178,
0.807788372,
-0.4591660202,
-0.4784235954,
-0.1938202232,
0.3460134566,
-0.0385114439,
0.1099562719,
-0.2809327245,
0.2652440965,
0.2493712306,
-0.1347511113,
-0.2770184278,
0.5273797512,
0.0925813615,
0.7170859575,
0.7544736266,
-0.1359168291,
-0.2516312897,
-0.1001315266,
0.5071778893,
-0.6696102023,
-0.4416399002,
-0.8891406059,
0.5611817241,
0.0135513693,
-0.3108045757,
0.6312617064,
0.4806214869,
0.4021910429,
-0.2319497168,
0.8695499897,
-0.2873507738,
0.6742572188,
-0.8192893863,
0.9942966104,
-0.5368894935,
0.3301842809,
-0.0277734715,
-0.5527418256,
-0.2380603105,
0.3171869814,
0.0131997075,
0.1063421592,
1.0526864529,
0.8203961849,
0.0552389733,
0.4559284151,
0.4048728645,
0.3175122142,
0.2864896357,
-0.0530343875,
0.9257772565,
-0.4436448216,
0.4738442004,
0.0060095498,
-0.3005742431,
-0.383351922,
-1.2234928608,
-0.7936763763,
-0.8607364297,
-0.5163626075,
-0.4685485959,
-0.0292533617,
1.0105017424,
0.508628726,
-0.8511231542,
-0.2395195961,
0.1824065745,
0.6077436209,
-0.1783022434,
-0.19096829,
0.453423351,
-0.4813710749,
-0.5560991168,
0.5482230783,
0.2305167466,
-0.1275891215,
0.0368547998,
-0.039692536,
-0.2407101691,
0.7014862895,
0.6559758186,
0.4998337626,
-0.5159246325,
-0.6669605374,
0.0256015956,
-0.1196127832,
-0.1476640552,
0.9088427424,
-0.7273336053,
0.2998208702,
0.543869555,
0.8477714658,
0.1094924062,
0.2757771015,
0.499389112,
-0.8642780185,
-0.2213994861,
-0.1098494679,
0.2814455628,
0.5141716003,
-0.5655543804,
0.2237073779,
0.4455273449,
-0.4156095982,
-1.1773928404,
0.2275620997,
-0.8621670604,
-0.1042498574,
1.2724307775,
-0.1815397739,
-0.4485406578,
-0.0121377511,
-0.1985925287,
0.2987994254,
-0.4193941355,
0.7846395969,
0.7178272009,
-0.0633893237,
0.0035916497,
0.0182947032,
0.9718328118,
0.23859483,
-0.8504126668,
0.3198577464,
0.7028992176,
0.3776561022,
0.4192229509,
0.6592546105,
-0.0838386565,
0.4918112755,
-0.0578272566,
-0.1496614516,
-0.4556080997,
-0.5816249847,
0.1057008281,
0.3986918032,
0.2304695845,
0.0886169747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03883v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03883v2
|
SaulLM-7B: A pioneering Large Language Model for Law
| 2024-03-06T17:42:16 | 2024-03-07T06:39:32 |
Pierre Colombo, Telmo Pessoa Pires, Malik Boudiaf, Dominic Culver, Rui Melo, Caio Corro, Andre F. T. Martins, Fabrizio Esposito, Vera Lúcia Raposo, Sofia Morgado, Michael Desa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce SaulLM-7B, a large language model (LLM) tailored
for the legal domain. With 7 billion parameters, SaulLM-7B is the first LLM
designed explicitly for legal text comprehension and generation. Leveraging the
Mistral 7B architecture as its foundation, SaulLM-7B is trained on an English
legal corpus of over 30 billion tokens. SaulLM-7B exhibits state-of-the-art
proficiency in understanding and processing legal documents. Additionally, we
present a novel instructional fine-tuning method that leverages legal datasets
to further enhance SaulLM-7B's performance in legal tasks. SaulLM-7B is
released under the MIT License.
|
[
-0.3274481297,
-0.6957139969,
0.7022439241,
0.2586073577,
-0.6681979895,
-0.1223823428,
-0.1020294353,
-0.2377425879,
-0.3416387439,
1.0772768259,
0.0172582436,
-0.7155721188,
-0.5990090966,
-0.1490013003,
-0.6353615522,
0.9446130395,
0.4972462952,
0.3372999132,
0.2638574541,
-0.3829646707,
-0.5950753689,
-0.5389246345,
-0.9532211423,
-0.166423291,
0.6933372021,
0.0656847656,
0.6391844749,
0.8075866699,
0.433670193,
0.2070870697,
-0.2668613195,
-0.1592057645,
-0.7159353495,
0.0743781626,
-0.36131832,
-0.6787185073,
-0.5483397841,
-0.5959107876,
0.5148030519,
0.5508109927,
-0.44300282,
0.0608207099,
-0.4580393732,
0.9079244137,
-0.5291026235,
0.0881135613,
-0.7707283497,
-0.3208487928,
-0.3090735674,
0.0586340502,
-0.7857795358,
-0.098523289,
-0.1903817356,
-0.5691068769,
0.2667776048,
0.4998868108,
0.555575788,
0.5123617053,
-0.6028975248,
-0.6246786118,
-0.290400207,
0.2849266529,
-0.9812695384,
0.6954109669,
0.2869604528,
0.4021511972,
-0.2475592047,
-1.0944763422,
-0.6635527015,
-0.4966776073,
0.3119004071,
-0.0378491767,
-0.1684863865,
0.2656606734,
0.5167757273,
-0.2444992959,
-0.6430872083,
0.3257931173,
-1.0156447887,
-0.0463383049,
0.7668191195,
0.2049053609,
0.2403811067,
-0.0590615757,
0.0791694894,
0.1631794274,
-0.9805000424,
0.0530251935,
0.550620079,
0.2374969423,
0.0181078613,
0.4258149862,
0.2196836174,
0.7721441388,
0.03613507,
-0.1807458997,
0.0284497254,
0.2655161619,
-0.5818644166,
0.4706037045,
0.741009891,
0.2958030999,
0.1107002944,
-0.0212829206,
-0.3968043327,
-0.3722344935,
0.5863950253,
-0.7564220428,
-0.0094725592,
0.2102531046,
-0.6375665665,
-0.1931934357,
0.1825179756,
-0.3113238215,
-0.7743681669,
-0.6573899984,
0.0758256018,
-0.5980243087,
0.1008564383,
0.3280507624,
-0.0061359038,
0.487732321,
0.4885955155,
-0.671014607,
0.14759776,
0.8324599266,
0.2849918008,
0.2551235259,
-0.1071425229,
-0.7852876782,
0.2719246447,
-0.615712285,
0.296028465,
-0.4517554641,
-0.245679915,
0.2605191469,
-0.0778088123,
0.4438489079,
-0.6497392654,
0.6513025761,
-0.9191733599,
-0.2946024537,
-0.0630762726,
-0.6211513877,
-0.4614241421,
0.3220067322,
-0.753818512,
0.7306399941,
0.1127612814,
-0.6121662259,
0.5675310493,
-0.708090961,
-0.6802179813,
0.5253166556,
-0.2829076946,
-0.456605047,
0.1905255914,
-0.0561473705,
0.3367167413,
-0.4611478448,
0.9794559479,
-0.2405492812,
-0.2930046022,
0.1628073901,
-0.3431037366,
0.9640678167,
0.4036962688,
-0.1559956074,
0.3530015945,
-0.7675287724,
-0.341519326,
-0.0670420006,
-0.4538318515,
-0.2379384488,
-0.1230416819,
0.0414747447,
0.1326360852,
0.3427901268,
-0.3952182829,
0.0863114893,
-0.4828190207,
0.5070843101,
0.5400840044,
-0.1818931699,
0.2776081562,
-0.2478172034,
0.6206556559,
-0.160463348,
0.1214828268,
-0.1270253658,
-0.2531924248,
-0.6825098395,
-0.2199700773,
0.6011207104,
0.2827438116,
-0.4119191468,
0.3633660972,
-0.2795073092,
-0.4396159053,
-0.9287334085,
0.3946277499,
0.0729001984,
0.0911905393,
0.2480179667,
0.3191486299,
-0.5519538522,
-1.1059981585,
-0.0420856513,
0.0134982802,
0.1824803054,
0.2259637862,
0.4700123668,
-0.0770261437,
0.6360077858,
-0.1505204439,
-0.2086907178,
-0.8369265795,
-0.054513637,
0.3780844808,
0.0768951029,
0.6701940894,
-0.8556053042,
-0.682341218,
0.2341695428,
-0.7377422452,
-0.3792859912,
-0.2581287324,
-0.0922507122,
0.1530290842,
1.1047039032,
-0.3213591874,
0.2978555858,
0.0218730569,
-0.4770501852,
0.380812943,
-0.5999680758,
-0.1848622411,
-1.1510630846,
0.0161483586,
-0.275993377,
-0.4740867317,
-0.5059512258,
0.3066455424,
0.4356075823,
0.0186230969,
-0.884564817,
0.7823966146,
-0.5599557757,
0.0254624225,
-0.551337719,
0.1966787279,
-0.1032133475,
0.2288794219,
-0.5823408961,
0.643150568,
0.6660916209,
-0.4831249118,
0.4965937734,
0.1536960006,
-0.2184710354,
0.6327993274,
-0.6272050142,
0.0215690099,
-0.5895738006,
-0.0002735773,
-0.2781133056,
-0.3936728239,
-0.0692295581,
-0.0097473059,
0.472233206,
-0.4588211477,
-0.5246537924,
-0.4744310379,
-0.0144693106,
0.1387512386,
0.7864849567,
-0.3053811193,
1.0674825907,
0.3374117017,
-0.2343841046,
-0.5892421007,
-0.3846319616,
0.155992046,
-0.3455391526,
-0.5763379931,
-0.0522854738,
0.0929631069,
-0.4598808885,
-0.0309570935,
0.2823089063,
0.0055309907,
0.0340997986,
0.6171028614,
0.0721696019,
-0.2888655961,
0.1477044076,
0.5186101794,
0.2544030547,
0.2823039889,
-0.0478300862,
0.7252577543,
0.1531753838,
-0.3720518649,
-0.0356507674,
0.3354932666,
0.851413548,
-0.2321465611,
0.6113921404,
0.2653569281,
-0.1915918589,
-0.5441935658,
-0.6355546713,
0.3368575275,
-0.4713059068,
0.5068715811,
-0.5393720269,
-0.9533774853,
0.6017087102,
0.0747371018,
0.306789577,
0.5838251114,
0.8876841068,
0.2246115059,
0.6038823724,
0.6043277383,
-0.1480535865,
0.3973826766,
-0.0087287864,
0.2227044404,
-0.7114415765,
-0.3452928364,
-0.4783556461,
-0.0246882532,
-0.2907263339,
-0.2362838238,
0.2812636793,
0.2285649776,
-0.5640699267,
0.2323900908,
-0.0857644528,
0.7085590959,
0.9187174439,
-0.0143506983,
0.1460163891,
-0.3201291263,
-0.3273673654,
0.3631977141,
-0.6649245024,
-0.7110807896,
1.288990736,
0.3955772817,
0.855340898,
0.3000074625,
0.6943174005,
0.4187318683,
0.4933651388,
-0.7398443222,
0.6725114584,
-0.4320222735,
-0.740755856,
-0.2232063413,
-0.184162125,
-1.2736041546,
0.292542249,
-0.1108736619,
-0.5297103524,
-0.2300397903,
0.0864709467,
-0.5560199618,
0.0821518302,
-0.5149514675,
0.73983109,
-0.4280845225,
-0.4392847121,
-0.2003700882,
-0.7290956974,
0.3586692512,
-0.3247900307,
0.4194298089,
-0.233569026,
0.2417409271,
0.6713241935,
-0.2747467458,
0.6345940232,
-0.2491161674,
-0.1503599733,
0.3364217579,
0.159385547,
0.3790279925,
0.1257817596,
-0.1742943376,
-0.4270743132,
0.0501242392,
-0.2126678675,
-0.5956814885,
0.5791838169,
-0.4841994643,
-0.685613811,
-0.1649343669,
-0.8432385325,
0.1902300864,
0.5059412718,
0.0610295497,
0.5139977932,
-0.1333724856,
0.6702158451,
0.5047343373,
-0.4401969612,
0.4500605166,
1.0048851967,
-0.4939348996,
-0.4919165075,
0.8919818401,
0.1310493946,
-0.1318626851,
0.168795079,
0.1459924728,
-0.6942522526,
-1.0204519033,
-0.3572516441,
0.3665336668,
-0.8994101286,
-0.2922464013,
-0.5829554796,
-0.3247109652,
-0.5092535615,
-0.3255268335,
-0.0743712559,
0.2391949445,
-0.1614219397,
-0.0515188277,
0.0859935656,
1.1562561989,
0.2938176394,
0.4075291157,
-0.8936229348,
0.338583827,
-0.0869159251,
0.2869742811,
-0.2057000399,
-0.9196427464,
-0.112948142,
-0.2317857742,
-0.1983400583,
-0.669213891,
0.4874936044,
-0.0840498656,
0.7314330339,
0.5475901961,
0.1458593756,
0.2210167795,
-0.7804017067,
0.6030994058,
0.126369074,
-0.793407023,
0.2740887105,
-0.5430758595,
0.1172967702,
0.4762797952,
0.0759748966,
-0.2681241632,
-0.6603657603,
-0.7314229608,
-0.8425391912,
0.5110920072,
0.1105268747,
0.4614771605,
0.1509976834,
0.6185639501,
0.3184215724,
0.422462523,
-0.656223774,
0.125436604,
0.0141753098,
-0.6953219771,
0.0824463144,
-0.2879940271,
-0.0234394372,
-0.3462124765,
0.633969903,
-0.0529356301,
-0.3044524491,
-0.1318685412,
-0.4708726704,
0.367231518,
0.461714536,
1.1201860905,
0.9860570431,
0.0287302323,
0.1640517414,
0.1019973159,
-0.5461660624,
0.1226239502,
0.0869934633,
-0.4168066382,
-0.1982170939,
0.4380822182,
1.1075797081,
-0.1927478462,
-0.9378501773,
0.3408189118,
0.216746375,
-0.7555856705,
-0.2173424959,
0.2256620377,
0.3616861105,
0.4986281991,
0.4651498497,
-0.5865597129,
0.2104918808,
-0.4404164553,
0.2448763996,
0.2342125773,
-0.2375590354,
0.0523995124,
0.9386194944,
0.1204113141,
-0.399369657,
0.3668003678,
-0.37317276,
-0.5453366041,
0.5884020329,
0.6501259804,
0.489418745,
0.1947204024,
0.0008249901,
0.204898417,
0.4158216119,
-0.2757201791,
0.4767881036,
0.4019347131,
-0.3723242581,
-0.3398930728,
-0.8925955296,
-0.2281172872,
0.3955591619,
-0.5503661036,
0.2859845161,
-0.7281618714,
-0.1137031391,
0.1671310365,
-0.324845165,
-0.5558009148,
0.1710454375,
-0.030126242,
0.9814335108,
-0.3480021954,
0.9704762101,
0.6052129269,
-0.5270496011,
-0.9149513245,
-0.3853527308,
-0.3169116676,
-0.7467820048,
0.783006072,
-0.0493503362,
0.1390447468,
0.1911734045,
-0.8576790094,
-0.160826534,
0.9104728699,
0.793015182,
-1.0509214401,
-0.0383826941,
0.2889117002,
0.5546700358,
-0.2857509553,
-0.3635089993,
0.5796236396,
0.3569991291,
0.0905724764,
-0.7198635936,
-0.0647562891,
-0.1392616034,
-0.1301054955,
0.4911003709,
-0.3712965548,
0.6416578293,
-0.1910148859,
0.2888918817,
-0.1595636606,
0.509444952,
0.2568634152,
0.2039988637,
0.3682578206,
0.5848296285,
0.8850588202,
0.0029651637,
0.9791452885,
-0.4947200716,
0.2047258168,
1.4507187605,
-0.5199002624,
0.8481266499,
0.3883544505,
0.0248127282,
0.1723335087,
0.2729458809,
-0.2828240097,
0.1157485023,
0.670909822,
-0.2714472711,
-0.3721450567,
-0.0134188328,
-0.1260471493,
0.2943143547,
0.2308420688,
-0.7467749715,
-0.1662790775,
0.2867231369,
-0.0527420528,
0.1064563096,
-0.5840265751,
0.913879931,
0.2696377933,
-0.5529738069,
0.2184506059,
0.3042179048,
0.2372982353,
-0.472792536,
0.0298875999,
-0.277184695,
0.182231009,
0.1443510503,
-1.0818421841,
0.0346544348,
0.1174654663,
-0.0046162559,
0.0847760439,
0.6884409785,
-0.4034035206,
-0.6060892344,
0.3771831393,
0.2068912834,
0.2982774675,
-0.1874757707,
-0.5651165843,
0.2716625333,
-0.0826841518,
0.0113317203,
0.188255772,
0.855045259,
-0.1749805212,
0.8433038592,
0.5723778009,
0.1032922417,
0.6212198734,
0.5881581903,
0.8033192754,
-0.7673636675,
-0.567106545,
-0.8142887354,
0.6465694904,
-0.1550269127,
-0.1369597614,
0.2850035429,
0.8680698872,
0.6350433826,
-0.1073244736,
0.9776570201,
-0.1431487799,
0.1822515428,
-0.7645572424,
0.7620695829,
-0.4239202738,
0.0414875001,
0.285604924,
-0.8673985004,
-0.3407446146,
0.4394124448,
-0.2260993123,
-0.1099697426,
0.4787942469,
0.6496223211,
-0.21717076,
-0.4276402593,
0.9795729518,
0.3393417895,
0.4660343528,
0.2902466357,
0.5155305266,
-0.2250783741,
0.6468036175,
0.3628500998,
0.3557365835,
-0.3691360056,
-0.4999539554,
-1.339250803,
-0.2724342942,
0.1364674866,
-0.3955875337,
0.1813431531,
0.9735995531,
0.4023258686,
-0.6240773797,
-0.2745946944,
-0.1815098077,
-0.2091615349,
0.4431320727,
-0.1419984698,
0.238296181,
-0.5098330975,
-0.560490787,
0.3996074796,
0.3572078645,
0.1646951139,
-0.2667367458,
-0.4212903976,
-0.0528108105,
0.2535758018,
0.7980772853,
-0.0303407684,
-1.0419152975,
-0.0041493271,
-0.1736176908,
-0.2928185165,
0.0913285464,
0.9389298558,
-0.0287304595,
0.4573864043,
0.3375938237,
0.8134487867,
0.5486712456,
0.1012797356,
0.7547179461,
-0.2835395634,
0.1822382957,
0.1468442678,
0.6797485352,
0.2010730952,
-0.0965189785,
0.3284436762,
-0.1927221864,
-0.3630537391,
-0.7719907165,
-0.0115283653,
-1.2709310055,
-0.4321955144,
1.1172472239,
-0.0061679604,
-0.3343716562,
-0.4217192829,
-0.821308732,
0.2071798146,
-0.5858998895,
0.3933949769,
0.7881032825,
0.4090972543,
-0.4341883659,
-0.9725927114,
0.2611325979,
-0.0122327758,
-0.8888252974,
0.0358566158,
0.5904023051,
0.5792223811,
-0.1666627377,
0.7579100728,
0.0336155333,
0.3809611201,
0.0763662457,
0.1181241572,
-0.4265318215,
-0.4207245409,
-0.1329533905,
0.6494135857,
0.4077146053,
0.3214449286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03874v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03874v1
|
Impoverished Language Technology: The Lack of (Social) Class in NLP
| 2024-03-06T17:35:27 | 2024-03-06T17:35:27 |
Amanda Cercas Curry, Zeerak Talat, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Since Labov's (1964) foundational work on the social stratification of
language, linguistics has dedicated concerted efforts towards understanding the
relationships between socio-demographic factors and language production and
perception. Despite the large body of evidence identifying significant
relationships between socio-demographic factors and language production,
relatively few of these factors have been investigated in the context of NLP
technology. While age and gender are well covered, Labov's initial target,
socio-economic class, is largely absent. We survey the existing Natural
Language Processing (NLP) literature and find that only 20 papers even mention
socio-economic status. However, the majority of those papers do not engage with
class beyond collecting information of annotator-demographics. Given this
research lacuna, we provide a definition of class that can be operationalised
by NLP researchers, and argue for including socio-economic class in future
language technologies.
|
[
-0.2765773833,
-0.4958240092,
0.168046236,
0.1268298179,
0.1474894285,
0.7320649624,
-0.1912019849,
-0.8188322186,
0.345893383,
0.318349272,
-0.0317422897,
-0.2899421453,
-0.6545174122,
0.006705944,
-0.5469271541,
0.6230617762,
0.6422052383,
-0.3280380964,
-0.2682587802,
-0.0817070603,
-0.1119936928,
-0.6666139364,
-0.8366782665,
-0.3337590098,
0.4906175137,
0.5259735584,
0.8427746892,
0.4393801391,
0.0993321538,
0.3409436047,
-0.2486227751,
-0.1357616037,
-0.0834566653,
-0.2751840949,
0.2363121212,
-0.3244447708,
-0.4308893085,
-0.0403627828,
0.6853134632,
1.1714776754,
0.1502757967,
0.3891580701,
0.0927209482,
1.2651609182,
-0.6449255347,
0.1942810267,
-0.6553071737,
0.2310848087,
-0.3321563005,
-0.2534717321,
-0.5003478527,
-0.3646952212,
0.0215186253,
-0.3357080519,
0.3946076632,
0.3174223006,
0.8138924241,
0.0872232467,
-0.2250214815,
-0.1104722619,
-0.6407980919,
0.5672230721,
-0.3101420403,
0.201916337,
0.9610571861,
0.2239459455,
0.0210209414,
-0.2758027911,
-0.3771043122,
0.0914469138,
-0.0730286911,
0.1777266264,
-0.0489768833,
-0.0653775483,
0.1198699474,
0.3378970325,
-0.3634521663,
0.1753066331,
-1.0827553272,
-0.1253186017,
0.6669621468,
-0.0884141997,
0.2528072298,
-0.3822716475,
-0.1686042994,
0.3466297388,
-0.9395109415,
0.0620423406,
0.8169252276,
0.3665668964,
-0.1857322901,
0.6239563823,
0.0002338489,
0.703701973,
-0.376973927,
-0.0286892969,
0.196285516,
0.1210987791,
-0.2054138035,
0.4730394185,
0.6930885911,
0.2841777205,
0.2687170506,
-0.1883238256,
-0.1548391432,
0.1244492382,
0.1677187681,
-0.1706824303,
0.0277454257,
0.0730600581,
-0.25601843,
-0.5420581698,
-0.4766928256,
-0.9091049433,
-0.3345933259,
0.1084182784,
-0.0403783768,
0.0441001691,
-0.3223016858,
-0.0758719519,
-0.2354955971,
0.47676301,
0.099703528,
-1.336371541,
0.6525633931,
0.5819675326,
0.997907877,
0.4818147719,
-0.0499299765,
-0.0583208129,
-0.0352653079,
-0.4543212652,
1.0453847647,
-0.7158824205,
-0.6569852829,
0.4583917856,
-0.0571918488,
0.0466625318,
-0.603775382,
0.0346627608,
-0.277475059,
0.3609666526,
-0.1432454884,
-0.291041255,
0.1597346812,
-0.2132467031,
-0.299862653,
1.2252246141,
0.4587319791,
-0.7062451839,
0.6798756123,
-0.6107496619,
-0.6915861964,
0.660367012,
-0.0157173369,
-0.1439674199,
0.1493918449,
-0.5490447283,
0.2341816574,
-0.3657577336,
0.6480612159,
-0.3911290169,
-0.3476036191,
0.1168970987,
-0.1858246773,
0.905484736,
0.1144620329,
-0.2528880835,
-0.25077793,
-0.9441334009,
-0.4204856455,
0.0624864809,
-0.3085443377,
-0.3829823434,
0.2593432367,
0.3126375675,
0.1179094911,
0.0930817723,
-0.5208355784,
0.0282352604,
-0.4786652923,
0.4877457917,
0.7134501338,
-0.6198567748,
0.750461638,
-0.4376099706,
0.3569281995,
-0.8295789957,
0.2886127234,
0.4880321324,
-0.5763501525,
-1.1264058352,
0.1916211993,
0.2737004757,
0.4697342813,
-0.8278918266,
0.2882199585,
0.0616303533,
-0.4502900541,
-0.7056545019,
-0.0789315775,
0.1562122554,
0.2451201528,
0.1781290472,
-0.1659389883,
-0.8196114302,
-1.1270105839,
-0.186682716,
-0.4608626664,
0.0983114019,
0.1295600832,
0.1246065274,
0.0603476241,
0.5484945774,
-0.3143033385,
-0.5940536857,
-0.4991354942,
0.0368660763,
-0.1355899423,
0.527232945,
0.4476045966,
-0.5786274076,
-0.3012866974,
-0.1840717793,
-0.4575682878,
-0.3178703487,
0.3666034341,
0.0463197604,
0.693614006,
0.5027434826,
-0.0057994667,
0.5084481835,
0.4882352352,
-0.2927818,
0.2243031412,
-0.29361251,
-0.2040071636,
-0.6704092026,
0.0279784035,
0.3664976656,
-0.16815871,
-0.8267714381,
-0.2372969389,
-0.2922355235,
-0.3207912445,
-0.4991309941,
0.4679214656,
-0.3309268355,
-0.4402737916,
-0.3937881887,
0.5274397731,
-0.2762285173,
0.2288497984,
0.1972020268,
0.4839636981,
0.2770622671,
-0.4443893135,
-0.1004777849,
-0.1564264148,
-0.1311441958,
0.261177361,
-0.8294022679,
-0.0092067542,
-0.0614523552,
-0.2848350704,
-0.7058953047,
-0.2995620072,
0.060171023,
-0.5214217305,
0.4150934815,
-0.2132567018,
-0.6933925152,
-0.1921377629,
-0.2609447539,
0.0940615237,
0.6759054661,
0.144955039,
0.1376203895,
1.0233291388,
-0.3126327097,
-0.5586798191,
-0.5291158557,
0.1807622463,
-0.2267894745,
-0.4834735692,
-0.0263368692,
0.1655450612,
-0.5957381725,
0.0193686187,
-0.0008862091,
-0.28839463,
0.4988113642,
0.1690947264,
0.4294295013,
-0.1341679841,
0.3674316108,
0.1178664193,
-0.1476333439,
0.2395199537,
0.1179251522,
0.6417579055,
-0.2661117911,
0.3871925473,
0.2062543482,
0.2471192479,
0.4076652229,
0.1732752621,
0.7982103825,
0.3103289306,
-0.4686954021,
-0.098709248,
-0.6334874034,
0.4186501503,
-0.4392611086,
0.1191377193,
0.1585961729,
-1.0076001883,
0.249887377,
0.0974063799,
-0.1507964879,
0.7373911738,
0.1422040015,
0.1322989017,
0.4171493351,
0.8367912769,
0.0089458674,
0.3540992737,
-0.2177314311,
0.2604856491,
-0.96708709,
-0.3062101305,
-0.9284126759,
-0.1662864834,
-0.8199342489,
0.0242513046,
0.0280892774,
-0.304938972,
-0.2784901559,
0.3534784913,
-0.5219002366,
0.3286628723,
0.6284865737,
-0.171592623,
0.2724516094,
-0.1167379022,
0.3347837925,
0.0425896272,
-0.9028736353,
-0.9139611125,
0.863543272,
0.1139118969,
0.1730727404,
0.0327290781,
0.7331482172,
0.7329099774,
0.7056437731,
-0.6752631664,
0.6161125302,
-0.426526159,
-0.720213294,
-0.3066321611,
-0.2726907432,
-1.0914475918,
0.148792848,
-0.4558963478,
-0.7317342162,
0.5706924796,
-0.0168673079,
-0.210881114,
0.2473269701,
-0.6932530403,
0.953943193,
0.1400216371,
-0.7850809097,
0.0707869455,
-0.9648573399,
0.6157273054,
-0.1333636642,
1.0741525888,
-0.6316197515,
0.3520974517,
0.7323494554,
-0.5384577513,
1.1046372652,
-0.2575220168,
0.0361502357,
0.1393867433,
-0.1643573493,
-0.3512541652,
-0.2298841327,
-0.0231889803,
-0.11285647,
0.1123211086,
-0.7074053288,
-0.0249571167,
0.5637259483,
-0.8691853881,
-0.7013383508,
-0.8461484313,
-0.3350252211,
-0.0337633826,
-0.0111759296,
0.1718683094,
0.5828765035,
-0.1105973572,
0.1954145283,
0.2260093242,
-0.499944061,
0.5554719567,
0.1823038459,
-0.4212548137,
-0.1532077938,
0.8921547532,
0.5029774308,
0.5284253359,
0.244727999,
0.408688128,
-0.0417463034,
-0.1468822658,
-0.5244106054,
0.2217305899,
-0.5471792221,
-0.1006388888,
-0.7071803212,
-0.2416343093,
-0.6140902042,
-0.6223108172,
-0.3110383451,
-0.4686540663,
-0.2754507661,
0.0607800819,
0.2239592969,
0.795183301,
-0.1907847226,
0.3431023359,
-0.5961138606,
0.2425173223,
0.1820399761,
0.0884218141,
0.1018415615,
-0.36109972,
-0.2131195515,
-0.2215811461,
0.0112066837,
-0.5357221365,
0.6572741866,
0.397662282,
0.2992351353,
-0.0475029983,
0.3539806604,
0.4083384573,
-0.3105180264,
0.8035083413,
0.2371034771,
-1.1808407307,
0.7131990194,
-0.0155247198,
0.1390240639,
0.4543275237,
0.3207917213,
-0.6029901505,
-0.8126279116,
-0.8223919868,
-1.3987449408,
0.7225777507,
-0.0275000036,
0.1699672788,
-0.2713332474,
0.0525244735,
0.2570702732,
0.3008767664,
-0.9765977859,
-0.3682484627,
-0.1591213048,
0.0512580015,
-0.0526298173,
-0.3393465281,
0.3153040707,
-0.1317649037,
0.6030159593,
0.145097822,
0.0142928455,
0.2606348097,
-0.158140108,
-0.1405090392,
0.5264471173,
0.484716624,
0.641189754,
-0.4678001702,
0.5651202798,
-0.2289569378,
-0.4913877249,
0.3261880577,
0.050702244,
-0.3944203854,
-0.0542234071,
0.2189444751,
0.449578017,
0.4066033065,
-0.4282196462,
0.2661649883,
0.1094530448,
-0.4396880865,
-0.7693454623,
0.1687036008,
-0.1569079161,
0.1112653911,
0.606800437,
0.3698397577,
0.2773833275,
-1.0251275301,
-0.3447502553,
0.1434648335,
-0.6886144876,
-0.2594064772,
0.7812191844,
0.3727486432,
-0.6217606068,
0.1388451308,
-0.3931316137,
-0.3889378905,
0.4968594909,
0.4594317377,
0.8497643471,
0.04212052,
0.595607698,
0.1943217367,
0.7561232448,
-0.0881588459,
0.0820541009,
-0.0255952124,
-0.6396023035,
-0.3696168065,
-0.8724222779,
-0.2841300368,
-0.2663425803,
-0.518686533,
0.1423146427,
-0.4175553322,
-0.3056771159,
0.0290466975,
0.126425162,
-0.6629710197,
-0.0544809774,
-0.1610153764,
0.4912120998,
-1.0009375811,
0.8100464344,
0.643384397,
-0.429289937,
-0.2339856476,
-0.374430418,
0.0197156519,
-0.8537273407,
1.1406751871,
0.0391571,
-0.3434734046,
0.0991108939,
-0.3623000979,
-0.4913602471,
0.6130411029,
0.1279368699,
-0.2760299146,
-0.0164833665,
0.201739341,
0.6582989693,
-0.2093152702,
-0.4254350066,
0.3632950485,
0.4651457667,
0.0061526564,
-0.5979833603,
-0.1903295368,
-0.495241493,
0.0064872405,
0.3346931338,
-0.7167779207,
0.2923330963,
-0.1121368408,
-0.3960652351,
-0.1749440581,
0.2810825706,
-0.1195184812,
0.7738513947,
0.2920245528,
0.228494823,
0.4312461615,
-0.2347049564,
1.1304961443,
-0.2376537472,
0.2144532651,
0.5319105387,
-0.4152272642,
0.7544348836,
0.1870515347,
-0.6056871414,
0.1810055673,
0.6654765606,
0.2642105222,
0.4302583635,
0.4740170538,
-0.4599250555,
-0.063286297,
-0.2543694973,
-0.2998615503,
0.4911473691,
0.4356201589,
-0.3533306718,
0.3826075792,
-0.2007330954,
0.1965627372,
0.3312730193,
-0.3924412727,
0.7700226307,
0.2445789129,
-0.3130901456,
0.4298171699,
-0.2363631129,
0.5677928925,
-0.4583367705,
0.1590816975,
-0.3658931255,
-0.2567210793,
-0.367366761,
-0.5479394794,
0.8131458163,
0.1883697361,
-0.0438563414,
-0.039092999,
1.0136078596,
-0.24642694,
-0.6920697689,
0.3053661287,
0.7690190077,
0.3711519241,
0.3756108582,
0.0243498553,
-0.0174341127,
-0.297419697,
0.27449736,
0.6062432528,
0.6182779074,
0.4581473768,
0.5143608451,
0.4934072793,
0.3186029792,
0.0403427333,
0.0513595492,
0.5802983046,
-0.7054219842,
0.200278312,
-0.852262795,
0.220647946,
-0.2521921396,
-0.3827729523,
0.7702024579,
0.6599270701,
0.843675077,
0.0804231167,
0.8857105374,
-0.1947385967,
-0.0256244708,
-0.2803822756,
0.7733061314,
-0.6672536135,
0.276286453,
-0.6954994798,
-0.9298911095,
-0.6270285249,
0.6791178584,
-0.2754042149,
-0.078531146,
0.5501527786,
0.2248995304,
0.5460647345,
0.1249945015,
0.5920597315,
-0.242124185,
-0.0736765638,
0.0421037003,
0.8190652728,
-0.2188401669,
0.1858194917,
-0.4549328089,
-0.3209710121,
-0.2943861485,
-0.7276408672,
-0.7018839717,
-0.4856841862,
-0.3336402178,
-0.3623349667,
0.3351386189,
0.9749426246,
0.3349766731,
-0.1845128387,
-0.6709858775,
0.1399134696,
0.5014921427,
-0.0470275283,
-0.2739787102,
0.3695636988,
-0.6136588454,
-0.6226696372,
0.0352235809,
0.7424989939,
-0.1486845464,
-0.3417838812,
0.3986122906,
-0.4036128521,
-0.1315754205,
1.1178693771,
0.3924929202,
-0.4134979546,
-0.3556890786,
0.1518245935,
0.2571148872,
0.1545370668,
0.5929308534,
-0.5806232691,
0.3345970511,
-0.0426649526,
0.3355413973,
0.2611285746,
-0.6091297865,
0.4247464538,
-0.7437634468,
0.1555832624,
0.2275030762,
0.524266243,
0.5837879181,
-0.165708214,
0.8064245582,
0.6881005168,
-0.7994619608,
-0.8090230227,
0.1857580394,
-0.7177264094,
-0.2843265831,
1.0065915585,
0.3572355211,
-0.5562158227,
-0.6819753051,
-0.1522499174,
0.3606305122,
-0.6509870887,
1.0086524487,
0.5495870709,
0.2734231651,
-0.4082013071,
-0.939301908,
0.3082355857,
-0.074599959,
-0.8479788303,
0.1834217161,
0.6826943159,
-0.3663874567,
0.3245318234,
0.9272655249,
-0.1934551299,
-0.0573081113,
0.3951839805,
0.3264499605,
0.3949714303,
0.0054861149,
0.2866201103,
0.3995241225,
0.3890427947,
0.3345161974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03870v1
|
Learning to Decode Collaboratively with Multiple Language Models
| 2024-03-06T17:23:28 | 2024-03-06T17:23:28 |
Shannon Zejiang Shen, Hunter Lang, Bailin Wang, Yoon Kim, David Sontag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose a method to teach multiple large language models (LLM) to
collaborate by interleaving their generations at the token level. We model the
decision of which LLM generates the next token as a latent variable. By
optimizing the marginal likelihood of a training set under our latent variable
model, the base LLM automatically learns when to generate itself and when to
call on one of the ``assistant'' language models to generate, all without
direct supervision. Token-level collaboration during decoding allows for a
fusion of each model's expertise in a manner tailored to the specific task at
hand. Our collaborative decoding is especially useful in cross-domain settings
where a generalist base LLM learns to invoke domain expert models. On
instruction-following, domain-specific QA, and reasoning tasks, we show that
the performance of the joint system exceeds that of the individual models.
Through qualitative analysis of the learned latent decisions, we show models
trained with our method exhibit several interesting collaboration patterns,
e.g., template-filling. Our code is available at
https://github.com/clinicalml/co-llm.
|
[
-0.112388216,
-0.4341229498,
0.6392187476,
0.2173902839,
-0.1611772478,
0.4102709293,
-0.1354029179,
-0.3254233599,
0.1563019902,
0.7249760628,
-0.4904572964,
-0.7726280689,
-0.4911019206,
0.0672111213,
-0.0505752563,
0.7847377062,
0.0231403653,
0.6661078334,
-0.5955976248,
-0.1134201512,
-0.5700493455,
-0.9843792319,
-0.7598352432,
-0.500330925,
0.4455261827,
0.4199297726,
0.4552462101,
0.3708233833,
0.438185215,
0.2986394167,
0.0977758169,
0.41126284,
-0.5418108106,
0.2292541564,
-0.2498864383,
-0.5859843493,
-0.8443217874,
-0.0510735214,
0.2617971599,
1.2835265398,
-0.0720207021,
-0.11401546,
0.1222596243,
0.278504312,
-0.4767236412,
0.4830601215,
-0.5730441213,
-0.0754574388,
0.2204850167,
-0.1866643578,
-0.8980159163,
-0.1714413315,
0.1323245168,
-0.6561686397,
0.4582259655,
0.1177018359,
0.167400524,
0.035107322,
-0.3360433578,
-0.3571529984,
-0.529635191,
0.8190077543,
-0.4357226789,
0.4569749236,
0.7196836472,
-0.0641980544,
-0.2535914481,
-0.8007691503,
-0.4568413794,
-0.1175997704,
-0.0407931842,
0.1188561469,
-0.0201736204,
0.3178654313,
-0.2228971571,
0.3781624436,
-0.5043745041,
0.1376452744,
-0.258447051,
-0.2452026904,
0.5052471161,
0.3297708929,
0.4619657397,
0.1292039454,
-0.2029855847,
-0.1232845187,
-0.6252292991,
-0.1955747902,
0.2389954478,
0.4379533231,
-0.312515229,
0.3703359067,
0.2009966373,
0.4252072573,
0.1398782581,
-0.0657068491,
0.2801629305,
-0.6741834879,
-0.1074903831,
-0.1395555437,
0.7240137458,
0.0774408877,
-0.1745594591,
-0.6294263601,
-0.1307269931,
0.0027867758,
0.1043193638,
-0.2945409417,
-0.5785096884,
0.0797549188,
-0.6000298262,
-0.2504958808,
-0.110978134,
-0.2901035249,
-0.1417330354,
-0.5054994822,
0.5634444356,
-0.3715538085,
-0.4328531027,
0.3383583128,
-0.0416654944,
-0.0985998288,
0.3013263345,
-1.250056386,
0.7606891394,
0.8416352272,
0.6674365401,
-0.1417271346,
-0.6904943585,
-1.0271215439,
0.2689791918,
-0.3811509609,
0.5612587929,
-0.4991666079,
-0.6424314976,
-0.0661290586,
0.0014245027,
-0.238324672,
-0.6110774875,
-0.1168337017,
-0.5958939791,
0.3434252739,
-0.2199779451,
-0.7230367064,
-0.001510667,
0.1085326895,
-0.8101079464,
0.4746394753,
0.3158529699,
-0.6097057462,
0.2595160902,
-0.4757829607,
-0.2403466105,
0.2660720944,
-0.4726252258,
-0.3808492422,
0.0670648366,
0.3312174678,
0.712993443,
-0.2388831228,
0.3958566785,
-0.3076523244,
-0.1518297195,
-0.015820872,
-0.2343340814,
0.9586024284,
-0.0236319471,
0.0613740869,
0.2761667073,
-0.5689073801,
-0.2121988535,
0.077768296,
-0.4513028264,
-0.3519352973,
-0.2613247037,
-0.1271625012,
-0.0834022611,
0.2974518239,
-0.1543410718,
0.312109679,
-0.2803233862,
0.2211224586,
0.5452283025,
0.2630642951,
0.6569706202,
-0.4313581884,
0.5631403923,
0.0514745228,
0.1946636736,
-0.2267234921,
-0.3904216588,
-0.8496794701,
-0.30147627,
0.1741881818,
0.2202558517,
-1.0954414606,
0.5094258189,
-0.084760353,
-0.0625649765,
-0.6061035991,
0.3242629766,
0.6129390597,
0.1678655297,
0.4763916433,
-0.5566735268,
-0.4792456329,
-0.6118355989,
0.1503380686,
-0.2313825339,
0.2056118548,
0.1477561742,
0.4243532419,
-0.1460218877,
0.717997551,
-0.2370427251,
-0.3131199777,
-0.4179464877,
0.2841652036,
0.0941570327,
0.6508316398,
0.4584635794,
-0.7115726471,
-0.6163322926,
0.0210403744,
-0.8784564734,
0.1102082804,
-0.0293586422,
-0.1551395804,
0.0829723626,
0.7210896015,
-0.0924130306,
0.0311672725,
0.9670267701,
-0.4289683402,
0.4306727946,
-0.536642313,
0.0610062145,
-1.5156919956,
-0.09226989,
-0.467743516,
-0.3157579005,
-0.5914025307,
0.1678487659,
-0.2802328467,
0.0378049091,
-0.2836432159,
0.2825256884,
-0.8128237128,
-0.2165116221,
-0.0836082026,
-0.1770256758,
0.0848043412,
0.5786176324,
0.2913732231,
0.8209875226,
0.574362278,
-0.2862204313,
0.395483762,
0.4478131533,
-0.1106274799,
0.4231596589,
-0.3981801569,
0.5927473903,
0.2205277085,
0.2296176404,
-0.5977088213,
-0.2870290875,
0.1588383019,
-0.3632559776,
0.1997110695,
-0.353137821,
-0.7386395931,
-0.017833598,
0.0362241752,
0.5473729372,
0.2073336989,
-0.8042507768,
0.7536209822,
0.5493594408,
-0.1517490745,
-0.5557394624,
-0.659172833,
0.154296875,
0.1469255835,
-0.7118918896,
0.4571861923,
-0.2473316044,
-0.2184839398,
0.2515840828,
0.2881781757,
-0.3710995317,
0.1168962419,
0.4088141918,
0.3493182063,
-0.1536048055,
0.0632952079,
-0.028075248,
-0.3126097023,
0.0298168324,
-0.3992139399,
0.823992312,
-0.2191317677,
-0.5960994363,
-0.2216802388,
0.7164626718,
0.4189026654,
-0.4004381001,
1.0677859783,
0.6175590754,
-0.4073384404,
-0.3318197429,
-0.349525094,
-0.1573655754,
-0.4663373232,
0.2673178613,
-0.5252858996,
-1.0462071896,
0.728885591,
0.0112330373,
-0.3287408054,
0.084538281,
0.7899423242,
0.3517909646,
0.9046254158,
1.1275978088,
-0.0266800094,
0.3446233273,
-0.6341506243,
0.0490218401,
-0.6752387285,
-0.5739271641,
-0.2729588747,
0.4627884328,
-0.1317623705,
-0.824144721,
0.5828921795,
0.2283621281,
0.0416387394,
0.1684837937,
-0.3495913148,
0.716236949,
0.729131043,
0.2704029381,
0.539516151,
0.0424926281,
-0.4901629984,
0.1492053568,
-0.9402265549,
-0.331623435,
1.1365507841,
0.2714936435,
0.7304786444,
0.2267255038,
1.2929810286,
0.1226068586,
0.1045801789,
-0.710494101,
0.4144955277,
-0.3432525992,
-0.2128106356,
-0.0327380113,
-0.4129579067,
-1.027974844,
0.1895293295,
-0.3501090407,
-0.5187402964,
0.1044124588,
0.0455161668,
-0.467074126,
0.262501657,
-0.7109232545,
0.8802766204,
0.0093515087,
-0.4495806694,
-0.66965276,
-0.7231328487,
0.2749583721,
-0.2666720748,
0.1715930551,
0.1958131194,
0.0793083236,
0.6467134356,
-0.4269505739,
1.1294779778,
0.03697557,
-0.106333971,
0.105318889,
0.2963250279,
0.3047010601,
0.0673143044,
-0.118167229,
0.0010139914,
-0.0436802916,
-0.4800665081,
-0.3291297555,
0.6520162225,
-1.0757740736,
-0.3617586792,
-0.1609702557,
-0.6524246335,
-0.4235414267,
0.184665516,
0.1503297091,
0.6810955405,
-0.3538671732,
0.0874046087,
0.544770956,
-0.1875390261,
0.3398579061,
0.4690640271,
-0.0282605961,
-0.6089216471,
0.9722251296,
-0.2160378397,
0.520201683,
0.5114743114,
-0.0273309406,
-0.0928998962,
-0.866599679,
-0.0014046727,
0.2852651179,
-1.0402028561,
-0.0869449377,
-0.7326032519,
-0.1332411319,
-0.5304083228,
-0.3607681394,
-0.2705415785,
0.050742574,
-0.5980454087,
0.1148745194,
0.0453931764,
1.11687994,
-0.3188737631,
0.2612529695,
-1.2193770409,
0.2026574016,
0.4664317966,
0.2746577263,
0.1445712,
-0.1251881272,
-0.5542964935,
-0.2021489292,
0.0512327552,
-0.7295094132,
0.5012470484,
-0.1009942889,
0.9034427404,
-0.1407381743,
0.0341297388,
0.4454164803,
-0.4319350123,
0.7826013565,
0.4810856283,
-1.2489892244,
0.1775141507,
-0.3758435249,
0.0918244049,
0.4934568703,
0.3760250509,
-0.4805621207,
-0.4839812815,
-0.696287632,
-0.7468631864,
0.9246256948,
-0.0410310589,
0.0983666256,
-0.0998293012,
0.1390895993,
0.5812322497,
-0.0238497872,
-0.6199709773,
-0.1512005478,
0.1207186878,
-0.4343925416,
0.0451788418,
-0.2194146961,
-0.3087114692,
-0.1027301252,
0.3814121187,
-0.3656415343,
0.2400336266,
0.0188280586,
-0.2435503304,
-0.2190288752,
-0.0520647764,
0.241148755,
0.6014566422,
-0.0408703797,
0.3611492515,
0.2037901133,
-0.2467447817,
0.0286041759,
-0.1107113808,
0.5444907546,
-0.2235767543,
0.9410312176,
0.7925511003,
0.0942646265,
-0.3009128571,
0.8026138544,
-0.3907059133,
-0.4882589281,
-0.2855969667,
0.0153952083,
0.2843910754,
0.6265718937,
0.1760802418,
0.2387541682,
-0.0328373276,
-0.5562824011,
0.5128039718,
0.2032063752,
0.0065777432,
-0.586232245,
0.5024009347,
0.4227198362,
-0.321556896,
0.566875875,
-0.3644101322,
-0.5598374605,
0.6428778172,
0.6184972525,
0.8962491751,
-0.0483044721,
0.318423748,
0.0644265339,
-0.147383377,
-0.3357656002,
0.1955865324,
-0.1442435384,
-0.8850055337,
-0.7294994593,
-0.3916288018,
-0.7689436674,
0.208304882,
-0.7314617038,
0.2330215126,
-0.4047468603,
0.1004469618,
0.0802830458,
0.1048550084,
-0.8628913164,
-0.0870433971,
0.2858599424,
0.3474393785,
-0.8763805032,
1.0999722481,
0.5732540488,
-0.6945167184,
-1.0582073927,
0.151863277,
-0.0056998353,
-0.9024284482,
0.8237282038,
-0.0725993738,
-0.2269384712,
0.1007131636,
-0.5317418575,
-0.6538331509,
0.977979362,
0.4689637423,
-0.4613455832,
-0.2514159083,
-0.0559153818,
0.6134310365,
-0.8010736108,
-0.0084380368,
0.1456797719,
-0.239721477,
0.0270914938,
-1.2837715149,
0.0067718793,
0.0064547807,
-0.3011143804,
-0.2006504983,
-0.5665580034,
1.1663705111,
-0.4430817664,
-0.0314409807,
0.1669392735,
0.45484218,
0.215058282,
0.2612107992,
0.4946974218,
0.2459826618,
0.7863504887,
0.4015164077,
0.7915462255,
-0.4325528443,
0.5148236752,
1.2359558344,
-0.0627824292,
0.8485122919,
0.2978035212,
-0.0526683219,
0.4581750333,
0.4168035388,
0.0493412688,
0.6098315716,
-0.1451094896,
-0.515535593,
-0.5901426077,
-0.2438400239,
-0.2480790764,
0.3998627961,
0.5490354896,
-0.512044549,
-0.1502735615,
0.1648579836,
-0.2167144269,
0.2818186283,
-0.1408955604,
1.0301246643,
0.2479414791,
-0.6148719192,
0.575407505,
-0.1517719924,
0.4431764781,
-0.3206795156,
-0.1991660148,
-0.1425527036,
0.3211148977,
-0.2391908467,
-0.5428345203,
0.1853155494,
-0.3432305157,
-0.2810225487,
-0.2906855345,
0.4135891199,
-0.8942962885,
-0.1717143953,
0.6944435239,
1.0329128504,
0.103548795,
0.3337987959,
-0.5723274946,
0.1958525777,
-0.0479511134,
0.3148097694,
0.2505719066,
0.3666629195,
-0.0329098403,
0.5000228882,
0.682448566,
0.0751444921,
-0.0011025331,
0.5405208468,
1.0730546713,
-0.3768320978,
-0.4721775055,
-0.6414030194,
0.2249090225,
0.1524169296,
0.0473292433,
0.4896295071,
0.4485419095,
1.1208432913,
-0.0994264036,
0.9037950635,
0.3071588874,
0.3048958778,
-0.6981321573,
0.5300218463,
-0.4266588986,
0.3725720942,
0.0830937698,
-0.6167610884,
-0.5195265412,
0.5524639487,
-0.2459661961,
-0.0870290846,
0.8616656661,
0.7158597708,
-0.0885071903,
-0.0348316655,
0.5386719108,
-0.1617153436,
0.5587409735,
0.7975685596,
0.8719768524,
-0.1988701671,
0.4529719949,
-0.3667030036,
-0.1481276155,
-0.1515708566,
-0.5479732156,
-1.2974638939,
-0.7434365749,
-0.319619298,
-0.4816131592,
0.1527290791,
1.4048193693,
0.9408413768,
-0.7066794634,
-0.2709873319,
-0.2675210834,
0.0829449371,
-0.1011046618,
-0.1120431945,
0.4646807909,
-0.5605413914,
-0.9327813983,
0.5738701224,
0.2175835818,
0.1149094105,
-0.529712975,
-0.3408662379,
-0.0727956817,
-0.2544978857,
0.4374100268,
-0.2127339393,
-0.5996075869,
-0.0945277289,
0.0369035564,
-0.322131753,
0.00943127,
1.0357737541,
-0.6774452925,
0.6228843927,
0.6047295928,
0.6996622086,
0.5167762041,
-0.3048204184,
0.9407866597,
-0.9751875997,
0.2149395794,
0.334823221,
0.3576916456,
0.5732086897,
-0.3617397547,
0.4463096857,
0.4184250534,
-0.5733219981,
-0.7467224002,
0.14052926,
-0.888740778,
-0.448589474,
1.0100777149,
-0.5418796539,
-0.1485535949,
-0.4889791906,
-0.0674659982,
0.4586281776,
-0.297301054,
0.5177564025,
0.6251635551,
-0.1633704305,
-0.2135313749,
-0.0632251501,
0.4500504434,
0.415486753,
-0.6607925296,
-0.0269770082,
0.3997171223,
0.3574796617,
0.1886775941,
0.9540808201,
0.0720408559,
0.2128575891,
0.5237156749,
0.0920860469,
-0.1923654675,
-0.4355945885,
-0.5109192729,
0.1875785738,
0.4491638541,
-0.2381251603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03867v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03867v1
|
On the Origins of Linear Representations in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-06T17:17:36 | 2024-03-06T17:17:36 |
Yibo Jiang, Goutham Rajendran, Pradeep Ravikumar, Bryon Aragam, Victor Veitch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Recent works have argued that high-level semantic concepts are encoded
"linearly" in the representation space of large language models. In this work,
we study the origins of such linear representations. To that end, we introduce
a simple latent variable model to abstract and formalize the concept dynamics
of the next token prediction. We use this formalism to show that the next token
prediction objective (softmax with cross-entropy) and the implicit bias of
gradient descent together promote the linear representation of concepts.
Experiments show that linear representations emerge when learning from data
matching the latent variable model, confirming that this simple structure
already suffices to yield linear representations. We additionally confirm some
predictions of the theory using the LLaMA-2 large language model, giving
evidence that the simplified model yields generalizable insights.
|
[
-0.0029463454,
-0.5216480494,
0.7661976218,
-0.2142900229,
0.0484132767,
0.1021969467,
-0.132374078,
-0.334367007,
0.3257489502,
0.280831933,
-0.5623835325,
-0.1977104098,
-0.7629345655,
-0.3806956112,
-0.4987068176,
1.2460813522,
-0.0161214266,
0.2008716762,
-0.1130763069,
-0.1319601089,
-0.457549423,
-0.7615961432,
-0.4948839545,
-0.7163960338,
0.8048046827,
-0.034976922,
0.9556879401,
0.8967880011,
0.2516655028,
0.2055444568,
-0.1464667767,
-0.2146186382,
-0.6226183176,
0.3599793911,
-0.0633246973,
-0.8842188716,
-0.0503440797,
0.3015298843,
0.7687932253,
1.1332490444,
0.0736631826,
-0.0084736776,
-0.0413346142,
0.0245889518,
-0.3269575834,
0.3532531559,
-0.7856670022,
0.1433292329,
-0.1409882456,
-0.3176905215,
-0.2630867958,
-0.0091809612,
0.2515992224,
-0.6105052233,
0.0342465527,
0.0139190275,
0.8011776209,
-0.0236302465,
-0.532399714,
-0.6651474237,
-0.7917407751,
0.9564321041,
-0.3169102669,
0.3744949698,
0.1331320554,
0.1276261955,
-0.2727044225,
-0.8964589238,
-0.5929961801,
-0.3959858716,
0.0885014012,
-0.3283903301,
-0.0403654873,
-0.0587591305,
0.2831647694,
0.0130724236,
-0.2728942931,
0.2687456012,
-0.4756331742,
-0.1952610463,
0.4188261032,
0.1797546893,
0.1080089658,
-0.1770641208,
-0.5362753868,
0.1824154258,
-0.7837139368,
-0.071151197,
0.0411390997,
0.4661800265,
-0.2460475862,
0.7971301079,
0.357493788,
0.0206341185,
0.0410779566,
-0.2306576371,
0.5333836079,
-0.3734760582,
0.070270963,
-0.1081084758,
0.3940649927,
0.2019960731,
0.3336321115,
-0.274110347,
-0.4098879993,
0.2804448009,
-0.1454825997,
-0.6314060688,
0.0496957824,
-0.0348092131,
-0.6557876468,
-0.3242298067,
0.031908758,
-0.3806141019,
-0.4918349683,
-0.5423613191,
0.3522319496,
0.0041890591,
-0.4197806418,
0.0968724266,
-0.0020457469,
0.5568585396,
0.3188966215,
-0.9119214416,
0.5495452881,
1.0083572865,
0.6899177432,
-0.0271228757,
-0.0732583106,
-0.6128898859,
0.1958932579,
-0.7043319941,
0.4234994948,
-0.9538038373,
-0.1961643994,
0.3995153606,
-0.0739392564,
0.4534388483,
-0.1491313875,
0.3284983039,
-0.5282981992,
0.2900013924,
-0.4250150621,
-0.6745782495,
0.1024523452,
-0.150412336,
-0.4727722108,
1.0686843395,
-0.199370265,
-0.7746310234,
0.4999517202,
-0.6214574575,
0.1129069254,
0.0972976014,
-0.6363207102,
0.0831438377,
0.5346893668,
-0.1198934391,
0.5679972172,
-0.5166041255,
0.1967671514,
-0.2471552044,
-0.1227953434,
0.3694419563,
-0.2728133798,
0.5157108307,
-0.0114725325,
-0.380284667,
-0.075190343,
-0.7299147844,
-0.2339030802,
0.2541895807,
-0.1063541323,
-0.6765287519,
0.3096063435,
-0.3122932911,
0.1879510731,
0.3750263155,
-0.4624969363,
0.2666782737,
-0.1834306419,
0.2342646867,
1.0600563288,
-0.0860620067,
0.7562361956,
0.2410147637,
0.4593926668,
0.281536907,
-0.219100818,
-0.3647954762,
-0.6986058354,
-0.8650112152,
0.2361492515,
0.394028753,
0.1143575832,
-0.4733876288,
0.0865743607,
-0.4017495215,
0.1085524932,
-0.121167019,
0.4839617312,
0.1700327843,
-0.0283884779,
-0.0700283125,
-0.0840951204,
-0.5444991589,
-0.8200897574,
0.227945745,
-0.423342824,
-0.079734318,
0.1281528622,
0.754478693,
-0.6452361941,
0.8286104798,
-0.5160393119,
0.0825553834,
-0.1110147089,
0.4197856784,
0.3852044344,
0.6746167541,
0.6694965363,
-0.6594985723,
0.0490103848,
0.0500117429,
-0.6923439503,
-0.0122330952,
-0.0570760258,
-0.3125342429,
-0.0615794398,
0.7929586768,
-0.5040780306,
0.2417468876,
0.5881686807,
-0.5367690921,
0.2702328265,
-0.0529766083,
-0.7937294841,
-1.1079849005,
-0.1100316346,
-0.1694231331,
-0.3030180931,
-0.6279444098,
-0.0526764765,
-0.24786219,
-0.2381428182,
-0.0594339371,
0.4127318263,
-0.3744414747,
-0.3151857853,
-0.2573662102,
0.2384936064,
-0.0798766017,
0.4404247701,
0.059213683,
0.4404586256,
0.5437656045,
-0.5901994109,
0.3518784046,
-0.1104807705,
0.0411919244,
0.2227513492,
-0.880006969,
0.163673088,
-0.6238291264,
0.2656388879,
-0.90170753,
0.0535127558,
-0.0357671157,
-0.46470204,
0.2793258727,
-0.1357215643,
-0.4464991689,
-0.3538475931,
-0.213622734,
0.5153106451,
0.5560749173,
-0.418754667,
0.4654834867,
0.4528906047,
-0.0913887694,
-0.6764749885,
-0.9011150002,
-0.1281594038,
0.0462760776,
-0.4346441031,
0.119706735,
-0.0777919069,
-0.4898320436,
0.1625585407,
-0.0125085404,
0.0972468406,
-0.1344862729,
0.1480115503,
0.3485668898,
-0.6988015771,
0.6287765503,
-0.2372662276,
-0.1677897274,
0.3800656497,
-0.9036279321,
0.6469230056,
-0.0355710573,
-0.1155838594,
-0.1805887073,
0.2833709717,
0.5623735189,
0.0792251527,
0.8786553741,
0.4602154195,
-0.5075511932,
-0.2310295999,
-0.3095700145,
-0.0483316295,
-0.4421470761,
0.496638149,
-0.3510188758,
-0.7932752371,
0.8822861314,
-0.0604171418,
-0.0620035194,
0.7186985016,
0.57188344,
-0.0691226572,
0.9522926211,
0.92667979,
0.1329066455,
0.5286698341,
-0.5907871127,
-0.0722606033,
-0.6505674124,
-0.6317127347,
-0.5890142322,
-0.1028405353,
-0.6485212445,
-1.0071197748,
0.0966773182,
0.2493051142,
-0.5016874075,
-0.0446661077,
0.1221001819,
0.3946365714,
0.3062850833,
-0.2638031542,
-0.1159358397,
0.0988987014,
-0.5463541746,
-0.179949522,
-0.4735068083,
-0.2936449945,
1.4462530613,
0.9040017128,
0.9305058718,
-0.0138454959,
0.6392018795,
0.421095103,
0.022612039,
-0.679604888,
0.2370171547,
-0.098767817,
-0.487821728,
-0.0733517781,
-0.2552243769,
-1.0994536877,
0.0774214268,
-0.224483639,
-0.8528658152,
0.5309966207,
-0.1167573184,
-0.1478583068,
0.1191427484,
-0.3763917089,
0.5447929502,
-0.2494298071,
-0.4449286759,
-0.3245881796,
-0.5005195737,
0.3269657791,
-0.1091821045,
0.264364928,
-0.1028957069,
-0.5361335874,
0.9622875452,
-0.6584267616,
0.9125414491,
-0.4244397879,
-0.4890334904,
0.4210673869,
0.0310770199,
0.6976562738,
0.0702400282,
0.0205536913,
-0.0143453665,
-0.4909271896,
-0.6667104959,
-0.8450661302,
0.5895847678,
-0.9876949191,
-0.5490674376,
-0.3427410424,
-0.4156095982,
-0.0773099214,
0.0162485968,
-0.1056429967,
0.72765553,
0.0321722813,
0.4157472849,
0.6825467348,
-0.1234922111,
0.3175376058,
0.0650895908,
-0.7604262233,
-0.0367952362,
0.632424891,
0.0073687388,
0.3402708471,
0.3883851469,
0.3399042487,
-0.3345091641,
-0.5685919523,
0.0931102186,
0.2979934216,
-0.9644334912,
-0.1281541735,
-0.3096278906,
-0.2408287078,
-0.1356337965,
-0.109603703,
-0.3397926986,
-0.5316151381,
-0.2689212859,
-0.3130699396,
0.2225600928,
1.423135519,
-0.2796667516,
0.4321117699,
-0.18854931,
0.1579420865,
0.4906186163,
0.3568778932,
0.0031659631,
-0.6028937101,
-0.4099657834,
-0.0028510997,
0.0205216892,
-0.6053489447,
0.1414680481,
0.2598153353,
0.7348008156,
0.720636189,
-0.4906480312,
0.4513857663,
-0.4836652577,
0.949621439,
0.6474351287,
-1.0720299482,
0.422816515,
-0.4229593277,
0.0408397913,
0.1079930365,
0.422250241,
-0.4958710372,
-0.1650968641,
-0.4598639011,
-0.704677999,
0.4208005667,
0.0769908503,
0.776347816,
0.0260713454,
0.4990585446,
0.3972245157,
0.1773056835,
-1.1062648296,
-0.3534870744,
-0.3326912224,
-0.1308980435,
-0.1730605364,
-0.6292685866,
0.1784946322,
-0.1664791405,
0.0940362886,
-0.3078764975,
0.7581481934,
-0.136033833,
-0.0065146107,
-0.064863041,
-0.1838965416,
0.4418126345,
0.7351446748,
0.0756511614,
0.3664083183,
-0.0536450967,
-0.302414149,
0.0438569561,
-0.1921993196,
-0.0380829424,
0.2614194155,
0.6452949047,
1.1079776287,
0.5133817196,
-0.4742022157,
0.6186653376,
0.1163882464,
0.0415590368,
-0.4929129183,
-0.2521530986,
0.1633159667,
0.3402077854,
0.8417821527,
-0.0564579815,
-0.0809096992,
-0.9532595277,
0.218417272,
0.4355883896,
-0.1501114368,
-0.6524729133,
0.7147433162,
0.1133357882,
0.1101298928,
0.2156053782,
-0.1357964277,
-0.7004952431,
0.4490793049,
0.5520318747,
0.7243157029,
-0.0842815563,
0.2530294955,
0.3000594974,
0.0291054826,
0.0815372244,
0.2353069484,
-0.037517637,
-0.8435304165,
-0.5136759877,
-0.841340363,
0.107513383,
0.0909315422,
-0.3947706223,
0.2953141928,
-0.7076025605,
-0.1750869453,
0.1787508875,
0.0914159939,
-0.7464014888,
0.0309030414,
0.9406729341,
0.6633670926,
-0.7868252397,
0.9760298729,
0.2865235209,
-0.5675611496,
-0.851164341,
0.1922025084,
-0.074753359,
-1.1987956762,
1.5855913162,
-0.0614311062,
-0.0681601539,
-0.3650526404,
-0.9213945866,
-1.3913249969,
0.8079539537,
0.3997245431,
-0.5159383416,
-0.3927323222,
0.2483617365,
0.6010398865,
-0.9689720273,
0.0366116874,
0.2503789365,
0.1707523614,
0.295832932,
-0.5063916445,
0.0286354572,
-0.21507366,
0.4549201131,
-0.1233767569,
-0.1560285538,
1.3898060322,
-0.2158652097,
-0.125881508,
0.1679446399,
1.038592577,
-0.134867698,
-0.0243634768,
0.278547883,
0.1133145541,
0.9218381047,
0.0135155357,
1.2366163731,
-0.3516134918,
0.2782350183,
0.7679765224,
-0.0746601894,
0.8022962809,
0.4033335149,
-0.1241262555,
1.0556524992,
0.3072316051,
0.0560238846,
0.4641391337,
0.5317310691,
-0.0305089243,
0.0224889554,
-0.4274977446,
-0.3898834586,
0.6139098406,
0.8475323319,
-0.6773786545,
-0.053688515,
-0.0978388712,
0.1165041327,
-0.1120491326,
-0.8709979653,
0.6865773797,
0.1211858168,
-0.334294647,
0.7871732116,
-0.0525461398,
0.7179176807,
-0.6849684715,
0.0525279716,
-0.1672534943,
0.1410012245,
0.0045149606,
-0.6789820194,
-0.074490495,
-0.1674329937,
-0.1574676037,
-0.2916770875,
0.6985461712,
-0.5128433108,
-0.6641733646,
0.6271417737,
0.4394335747,
0.176571399,
0.702100575,
-0.55391711,
0.3019950688,
-0.2267886698,
-0.2019187063,
-0.0848166123,
0.7426912189,
-0.207358256,
0.3910084069,
0.5271113515,
0.2422167212,
0.568353653,
0.074959971,
0.9291052222,
-0.6152681708,
-0.3835059106,
-0.7540394664,
0.2912301719,
0.125834465,
-0.2722852528,
0.2519895732,
0.2532399595,
0.5841445327,
0.1970467418,
0.7276471257,
0.0970424265,
0.1892549396,
-0.6356912851,
0.3299649954,
-0.5862653255,
0.1103375554,
-0.3030151427,
-0.9456253648,
-0.0459965281,
0.5756807923,
-0.2754189074,
0.0992723629,
0.8415735364,
0.4406078756,
0.1008506417,
-0.268520087,
0.2149738073,
0.5790222287,
0.1609142572,
0.4570175707,
0.7750583291,
-0.1895465851,
0.4135420322,
0.2247723341,
-0.0187643487,
-0.1909007877,
-0.7147864699,
-0.780583322,
-0.7842233777,
-0.1708126962,
-0.6144636869,
0.0823939443,
1.1180738211,
0.7300807238,
-0.8156040311,
-0.1980116814,
-0.1737551838,
0.0925641134,
0.3571929038,
-0.1287384331,
0.3099330068,
-0.6797640324,
-0.6390192509,
0.0401564501,
0.0695143864,
0.1502177417,
-0.862413764,
-0.4838447869,
-0.0168158151,
0.3747153878,
0.6680819988,
0.1990752816,
-0.6120479703,
-0.3754001558,
-0.3092863262,
-0.2978223562,
0.075322412,
1.1554588079,
-0.9556393027,
0.2252472788,
0.4719641805,
0.6665961742,
0.5470188856,
-0.451256901,
1.0713251829,
-0.7950893044,
0.6269420981,
0.1973599792,
0.6156073213,
0.2142825276,
-0.1471617073,
0.2640836537,
0.5744505525,
0.0861427486,
-0.9376531243,
0.3636227548,
-0.702539444,
-0.2026423365,
1.242246747,
-0.1158783138,
-0.3967791498,
-0.0567669384,
0.1516380906,
0.0135576176,
-0.4108867347,
0.2288881987,
0.5509588122,
0.0837681442,
-0.1328894347,
-0.6237307787,
0.3143340051,
0.302066654,
-0.2685652971,
0.0383259282,
0.3946664631,
0.0876778886,
0.5233717561,
0.3287579417,
-0.1587067246,
0.0835347325,
0.3822618723,
-0.1144215167,
0.3084476292,
-0.2096015662,
-0.2382283658,
0.3421420157,
0.2675411701,
-0.0583523288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03866v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03866v1
|
KIWI: A Dataset of Knowledge-Intensive Writing Instructions for Answering Research Questions
| 2024-03-06T17:16:44 | 2024-03-06T17:16:44 |
Fangyuan Xu, Kyle Lo, Luca Soldaini, Bailey Kuehl, Eunsol Choi, David Wadden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) adapted to follow user instructions are now
widely deployed as conversational agents. In this work, we examine one
increasingly common instruction-following task: providing writing assistance to
compose a long-form answer. To evaluate the capabilities of current LLMs on
this task, we construct KIWI, a dataset of knowledge-intensive writing
instructions in the scientific domain. Given a research question, an initial
model-generated answer and a set of relevant papers, an expert annotator
iteratively issues instructions for the model to revise and improve its answer.
We collect 1,260 interaction turns from 234 interaction sessions with three
state-of-the-art LLMs. Each turn includes a user instruction, a model response,
and a human evaluation of the model response. Through a detailed analysis of
the collected responses, we find that all models struggle to incorporate new
information into an existing answer, and to perform precise and unambiguous
edits. Further, we find that models struggle to judge whether their outputs
successfully followed user instructions, with accuracy at least 10 points short
of human agreement. Our findings indicate that KIWI will be a valuable resource
to measure progress and improve LLMs' instruction-following capabilities for
knowledge intensive writing tasks.
|
[
-0.013854689,
-1.0192143917,
0.7331321239,
0.3382532001,
0.1745095104,
-0.0035470324,
-0.4820311666,
-0.4667617679,
0.089672409,
1.0141944885,
-0.6498122811,
-0.4235434532,
-0.8331125379,
0.3276552856,
-0.2661018074,
1.1879811287,
-0.3005630672,
-0.2640620768,
-0.7622576952,
-0.036065802,
-0.7402728796,
-0.3562533557,
-0.5145152211,
-0.3849276602,
1.0086970329,
0.7676064968,
0.7149381042,
0.397217989,
0.5281302929,
0.272093147,
-0.0688894689,
0.6064935923,
-0.4675141573,
0.4129302204,
-0.0157208145,
-0.7286875248,
-0.38182652,
-0.0510911867,
0.4476259947,
0.8894553185,
0.218139708,
0.3901871741,
0.0841727704,
0.5800529122,
-0.6157392859,
0.5109403729,
-0.2549905181,
-0.0789762512,
-0.0746180117,
-0.247685194,
-0.7934789062,
-0.3377404511,
0.2498658746,
-0.858455658,
0.0003469589,
0.0385912508,
0.233536303,
-0.0451962501,
-0.3299235106,
-0.7125371099,
-0.650195241,
0.5489411354,
-0.7765320539,
-0.1859155893,
0.6520976424,
0.1154486015,
-0.5474298596,
-0.7933790088,
-0.60784024,
-0.5523937345,
-0.3194484413,
0.0457824133,
0.0847381279,
0.1590687484,
0.4406725168,
-0.3224723041,
-0.2353529632,
0.0339745507,
-0.5129349828,
-0.1298455596,
0.8369522095,
0.475423336,
0.4141425192,
-0.0642201751,
0.0429297015,
-0.0198619924,
-0.4850237072,
0.1778648645,
0.4323638082,
0.2186872959,
-0.2046604156,
1.0539147854,
-0.3566358984,
0.8885480165,
-0.2666556239,
-0.0918367654,
-0.1256942749,
0.0532316081,
0.0701505393,
-0.0710537508,
0.9272165298,
0.5197442174,
0.5291971564,
-0.1614182442,
-0.1780302227,
-0.305791527,
0.3018434644,
-0.7957290411,
-0.4586241543,
0.0228347685,
-0.033270169,
-0.2946661413,
-0.2974525392,
-0.4171309173,
-0.5697544813,
-0.2869076431,
0.5419790149,
-0.3522402346,
-0.0677720681,
0.0259986892,
-0.3004770279,
0.1140376851,
0.4979783595,
-0.9340360761,
0.2516715527,
0.7130112052,
0.7277799249,
-0.1386663616,
-0.5032028556,
-0.2431116998,
0.3168436885,
-0.4682041109,
0.6457588077,
-0.7908189297,
-0.6213331819,
-0.2033804059,
0.0767090991,
-0.2727099061,
-0.1662890166,
0.1956376284,
-0.5890983343,
0.3077791631,
-0.3829596341,
-0.6222080588,
-0.1724631935,
0.2349610329,
-0.6123691201,
1.1436562538,
0.2102234215,
-0.8337020874,
-0.073926568,
-1.1412394047,
-0.5895624757,
0.0727664307,
-0.0083517171,
-0.1181513518,
0.0620431565,
0.1197496504,
0.696809411,
-0.3416506946,
0.0937762931,
-0.2849749029,
-0.3660800457,
0.7054123282,
-0.5021802783,
0.7027829885,
-0.0566534363,
-0.2354497015,
0.0108467871,
-0.8439033628,
-0.0504854098,
0.106770508,
-0.3960775733,
-0.2606688142,
-0.2241583318,
-0.2994460166,
-0.3999350071,
0.3029935062,
-0.6859746575,
0.5287044644,
0.1849398762,
0.6969139576,
0.7363293767,
0.1288229674,
0.2065146565,
-0.4045430422,
0.5838210583,
-0.3367909491,
0.0952611417,
-0.4118595123,
-0.6574956179,
-0.8751837611,
0.0338724703,
0.0731719509,
0.4238829613,
-0.5197084546,
-0.1004736647,
-0.3280767202,
-0.5639946461,
-0.5621157885,
0.3199141026,
0.4423361421,
0.8217003942,
0.3128194213,
0.1713977456,
-0.3388800919,
-0.8182234764,
-0.1963058114,
-0.3158042431,
0.0888002515,
0.2897088528,
0.51628232,
-0.1972012669,
0.7962504029,
-0.7238798141,
0.1795493215,
-0.2291645408,
0.444049567,
0.0481032394,
0.2243540734,
0.084590219,
-0.6031989455,
-0.530418694,
0.1096203402,
-1.0520811081,
-0.191285193,
0.0816735104,
-0.2382371128,
0.2969467938,
0.4243893921,
-1.0192393064,
0.2791540027,
0.1870455295,
-0.2233887315,
0.7345575094,
-0.2547799349,
0.4296855927,
-0.8297370076,
0.2541944385,
-0.2691965103,
-0.0104630161,
-0.7284809351,
0.1640864015,
0.1352071613,
-0.174832359,
-0.1397595257,
0.5119470954,
-0.5871934891,
0.2202386111,
-0.3534696102,
0.1228181198,
0.2135252655,
0.4932419956,
0.0949422792,
0.8880018592,
0.1184498444,
-0.3486154675,
0.4281954467,
0.3389260173,
-0.3330779076,
0.0939349905,
-0.6927182078,
0.598269105,
-0.3341598809,
0.1274202317,
-1.0906565189,
-0.5392632484,
0.1787822545,
-0.5802955627,
0.2680692077,
-0.1248540282,
-0.3978684247,
-0.3826913238,
-0.0032965301,
0.2473301888,
0.4100564122,
-0.0813095048,
0.998455286,
-0.0623321533,
-0.6153330207,
-0.7806486487,
-0.8106081486,
0.2284802496,
0.1462557018,
-0.7002788186,
-0.0055497056,
-0.1175887585,
-0.1419318467,
0.1410756707,
0.2886549532,
0.0578294769,
0.0708572716,
0.4682642519,
0.3471156657,
-0.1202823892,
0.0278591327,
-0.1383097172,
0.1406775117,
0.4999903142,
0.0319898687,
0.3300845921,
0.5429339409,
-0.2894099653,
-0.6297241449,
0.4162961245,
0.8483111262,
-0.1641506702,
0.6832168102,
0.2903725505,
-0.0622569136,
-0.2699075937,
-0.708458662,
-0.0355314016,
-0.4573148191,
0.4718498886,
-0.3978416622,
-0.6055365205,
0.4358106256,
0.3357169032,
0.4521621764,
0.3548378944,
0.2636776268,
-0.4733124375,
0.898737371,
0.7389844656,
-0.1498098075,
0.1520059556,
-0.2330957204,
0.157823503,
-0.7196698189,
-0.608938396,
-0.5299983621,
-0.2778619826,
-0.1641547233,
-0.4366376698,
0.3613963425,
-0.1082239151,
-0.0968320519,
0.2285065204,
-0.4502483308,
0.4911869466,
0.619528532,
0.2001135796,
0.1134504974,
-0.223913759,
0.0575208589,
0.3016841114,
-0.8702017069,
-0.5328032374,
1.290025115,
0.1203893945,
0.9737179279,
-0.1167622805,
0.4733028114,
0.5177900791,
0.63470608,
-0.6586021781,
0.707994163,
0.0703960732,
-0.3416590989,
-0.5601846576,
-0.4364405572,
-0.6260936856,
-0.2354176641,
-0.1876642406,
-0.5082035065,
-0.6376338005,
0.1747969985,
-0.1854587793,
0.1413041502,
-0.7587038875,
0.7141464353,
-0.1707519889,
-0.3522132337,
-0.0659170374,
-0.6786062121,
0.2540192902,
0.112382412,
0.0651017576,
-0.0248029623,
0.0473343842,
1.0524697304,
-0.5162805319,
1.2535125017,
-0.3791611493,
-0.0356198214,
0.6160567403,
0.0436892547,
0.6544601321,
-0.2352271974,
-0.2379761636,
-0.4238273501,
0.1280786842,
-0.3983880281,
-1.0511951447,
0.6452398896,
-0.9705427885,
-0.8885216117,
-0.0004038331,
-0.9753906727,
-0.2069280744,
0.0932230353,
0.1487558782,
0.7018763423,
0.0559817888,
0.045112472,
0.6452869177,
-0.0440329164,
0.248500526,
0.5662469268,
-0.0812284872,
-0.3816491663,
0.661164701,
0.3601005077,
0.3352045119,
0.4101290107,
0.281925112,
-0.2355565876,
-0.6673500538,
-0.7430582047,
0.1987089962,
-0.9705876708,
-0.1095731035,
-0.9790654182,
-0.2316864133,
-0.4000820518,
-0.2640295327,
0.1044732407,
-0.5334303975,
-0.2796370089,
-0.0759520158,
0.6507749557,
1.132519722,
0.5857269764,
0.3314374983,
-0.8128190637,
0.2127275467,
0.0985389501,
-0.052027896,
0.265842855,
-0.655382216,
-0.1798847318,
0.2100576311,
-0.1157322824,
-0.7756018639,
-0.1228381917,
0.0118406815,
0.4590492249,
-0.0754917264,
0.162786752,
0.8252932429,
-0.299521476,
0.8517656326,
0.1226029918,
-0.5304386616,
0.4484044015,
-0.0633256659,
0.5313896537,
0.4977141619,
0.6876337528,
-0.7963958383,
-0.6370086074,
-0.1773055941,
-0.6205222607,
0.4761548042,
-0.1809081137,
0.425819993,
-0.0577989928,
0.7342905402,
0.2735844553,
-0.0175250061,
-0.514339745,
0.1423394233,
0.2517981827,
-0.4948179722,
-0.1369243562,
-0.421957612,
-0.2726163268,
0.0564131103,
0.7648402452,
-0.2452103198,
0.0543347448,
0.281720072,
-0.2926364243,
-0.0183465239,
0.1223481223,
0.516677618,
0.6518768668,
0.0936759859,
0.116293408,
0.2580468059,
-0.5387230515,
0.116825223,
0.0323838182,
-0.4337613285,
-0.2460842282,
0.9898472428,
0.6253376007,
0.1005421057,
-0.7680544853,
0.5192228556,
-0.0013008118,
-0.3794683516,
-0.5102309585,
0.4529601336,
0.3890442848,
-0.0387600884,
0.3250716031,
0.02506846,
-0.0670325682,
-0.5223689079,
-0.2595850527,
0.3501029015,
-0.3392489254,
-0.3177416921,
0.3953544497,
0.2186083645,
-0.6293799281,
0.8012230396,
0.1609355509,
-0.4076155424,
0.6826072931,
0.4661237001,
0.4697809517,
0.1437031478,
0.1665931791,
0.049308639,
0.112989895,
0.0022733766,
0.4165580273,
-0.2295815498,
-0.4465076327,
-0.6482821703,
-0.3787151873,
-0.6583966017,
-0.0406051688,
-0.7487849593,
0.2284987569,
-0.5625401735,
-0.0181382149,
0.3429481387,
-0.0526550859,
-0.7145380378,
0.0850151926,
-0.3223736286,
1.0929794312,
-0.865365088,
0.5510880947,
0.7728316784,
-0.4173305333,
-0.962097168,
-0.3293065727,
-0.1271700263,
-0.7812572122,
0.6635543704,
0.3687005341,
-0.325563997,
-0.2670191228,
-0.7703019381,
-0.5132207274,
1.1917523146,
0.2019017339,
-0.5003697872,
-0.1582351774,
0.4549080431,
0.5826759338,
-0.4091392756,
0.7167252302,
0.4890114665,
0.4872654378,
0.0146748591,
-0.5132064819,
0.1069438756,
-0.29757303,
-0.2577590048,
0.1581665277,
-0.7455958128,
0.4081827402,
-0.4905915856,
0.0063366015,
0.3715365231,
0.7818918228,
-0.0130304899,
0.2904297113,
0.3442252874,
0.2637595534,
0.8201138377,
0.2764568031,
0.9460201263,
-0.2233763933,
-0.3327492177,
1.1073800325,
-0.3033711612,
0.9358847141,
0.5108556151,
-0.0521482266,
0.6050214171,
0.2520797849,
0.1045993194,
0.1268865615,
0.2595965862,
-0.3761245906,
-0.0661213174,
-0.1275568604,
0.103088133,
0.3893480599,
0.2357608527,
-0.4253517389,
0.296966821,
0.1608186364,
0.1204816103,
0.1670868993,
-0.2665730119,
1.0026222467,
-0.1246908531,
-1.1254072189,
0.4860804975,
-0.129769668,
0.3384926319,
-0.7730941176,
-0.3034143746,
-0.2741392255,
-0.1547379792,
-0.354614228,
-1.21540308,
-0.027288869,
0.2644397318,
-0.465724051,
0.1529048532,
0.6307899952,
-0.4194696844,
-0.6353993416,
0.2270704359,
0.1241263077,
0.2550905347,
0.4112121463,
-0.2773794532,
0.1998627931,
0.0947460011,
-0.5493170619,
0.1182368398,
0.4589756429,
-0.2594522238,
1.1289646626,
0.5541254282,
0.0324370749,
0.1191397384,
0.0901204422,
0.8583418131,
-0.5563691854,
-0.1226949245,
-0.6918914914,
0.5366325974,
-0.1884114593,
-0.4678291082,
0.5645432472,
0.355419606,
0.6626280546,
-0.0503875948,
1.1784391403,
-0.1047018245,
0.3597054482,
-0.6145798564,
0.5292212963,
-0.1760749668,
0.2514986694,
0.1026247144,
-0.7587829828,
-0.1608072221,
0.1157634854,
-0.390530169,
-0.0788333789,
0.4075790644,
1.1299341917,
-0.0119909775,
0.428545773,
0.1188526377,
0.1352412552,
0.2965638041,
0.4006950259,
0.9878219962,
0.0017996886,
0.5823349953,
-0.3088038266,
-0.2814262509,
-0.0465794727,
-0.8181373477,
-1.0864434242,
-0.396435231,
-0.3101993799,
-0.2167153656,
0.3855809867,
1.038312912,
0.5075208545,
-0.5451746583,
-0.2198373973,
0.1944318265,
-0.2278802991,
-0.125074178,
-0.2203941494,
0.3295205235,
-0.4055317044,
-0.3238669038,
0.3423346281,
0.1082111672,
-0.1104577035,
-0.261331141,
-0.074069649,
0.0532883666,
0.1736231148,
0.5371600986,
0.1840791404,
-0.6117252111,
-0.5455249548,
0.1594909728,
-0.1762611419,
-0.1040002331,
0.9092292786,
-0.1732703298,
0.6188634634,
0.28854388,
0.9562096596,
0.8141363859,
-0.1442170143,
0.7573961616,
-0.4484198987,
-0.3084139228,
0.1721336991,
0.10772264,
0.5754323006,
-0.53829813,
0.3666309416,
-0.1330261678,
-0.8095839024,
-0.5501920581,
-0.0876590088,
-0.8837638497,
-0.300321281,
1.2063440084,
-0.5812139511,
-0.5260968208,
0.055238463,
-0.4696892202,
0.1245591417,
-0.2234262675,
0.6669903994,
0.943761766,
-0.3446940184,
-0.2421642989,
-0.6217547655,
0.1756401211,
0.3956038654,
-0.61642313,
0.5834721327,
0.4641355276,
0.6514434218,
0.0624001995,
0.7518501878,
0.0492648557,
0.2846325338,
0.0926984698,
0.082369104,
-0.5852576494,
-0.4366357625,
0.0258365013,
0.2371634096,
0.5661603212,
0.1961084306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03863v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03863v1
|
X-Shot: A Unified System to Handle Frequent, Few-shot and Zero-shot Learning Simultaneously in Classification
| 2024-03-06T17:13:24 | 2024-03-06T17:13:24 |
Hanzi Xu, Muhao Chen, Lifu Huang, Slobodan Vucetic, Wenpeng Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, few-shot and zero-shot learning, which learn to predict
labels with limited annotated instances, have garnered significant attention.
Traditional approaches often treat frequent-shot (freq-shot; labels with
abundant instances), few-shot, and zero-shot learning as distinct challenges,
optimizing systems for just one of these scenarios. Yet, in real-world
settings, label occurrences vary greatly. Some of them might appear thousands
of times, while others might only appear sporadically or not at all. For
practical deployment, it is crucial that a system can adapt to any label
occurrence. We introduce a novel classification challenge: X-shot, reflecting a
real-world context where freq-shot, few-shot, and zero-shot labels co-occur
without predefined limits. Here, X can span from 0 to positive infinity. The
crux of X-shot centers on open-domain generalization and devising a system
versatile enough to manage various label scenarios. To solve X-shot, we propose
BinBin (Binary INference Based on INstruction following) that leverages the
Indirect Supervision from a large collection of NLP tasks via instruction
following, bolstered by Weak Supervision provided by large language models.
BinBin surpasses previous state-of-the-art techniques on three benchmark
datasets across multiple domains. To our knowledge, this is the first work
addressing X-shot learning, where X remains variable.
|
[
-0.1970640868,
-0.5228967667,
0.2022957504,
-0.0990573019,
-0.0536463819,
0.090116486,
-0.0664077327,
-0.6734618545,
-0.0329412371,
0.3542544842,
-0.5587114096,
-0.8331172466,
-0.8554412723,
0.0409423858,
-0.2046923041,
1.1535335779,
-0.0936093256,
-0.3265376687,
0.2225151062,
-0.3628928661,
-0.6659894586,
-0.6753992438,
-0.7987058759,
-0.4267364442,
0.8686255813,
0.5587242246,
0.4917041063,
0.4323377609,
0.3404411077,
0.212692216,
0.3293169141,
0.0603168048,
-0.4690359533,
0.0891492739,
-0.1780271381,
-0.7307540774,
-0.0749526694,
-0.3086568415,
0.7914982438,
0.9382914901,
0.1041673049,
0.0851432681,
-0.1652029753,
0.1956359446,
-1.0250717402,
0.2747549415,
-0.6664013267,
0.3333204091,
-0.1533576697,
0.0235079546,
-0.504170537,
0.2219039798,
-0.033774931,
-0.6453553438,
0.2496834248,
0.2888793647,
0.5749815106,
0.1593982428,
-0.346682936,
0.0133136911,
-0.7959010601,
0.9264508486,
0.090584375,
0.2231411189,
0.1428718269,
0.5972504616,
-0.1226397827,
-0.3592233658,
-0.2071039677,
0.1797173768,
0.0683392957,
0.0713154748,
-0.5614142418,
-0.0269294549,
0.161216706,
-0.4523626268,
-0.7167011499,
0.3274237514,
-0.1273489594,
0.0340751112,
0.4962608516,
0.3368707895,
-0.0918260589,
-0.0070370678,
-0.5396310091,
-0.1595737338,
-0.5862694383,
0.2497323155,
0.1062507778,
0.4195878804,
0.1373722255,
0.2633426189,
-0.1972229332,
0.9174883962,
-0.0990579724,
-0.0064411545,
0.0728851706,
0.0745256245,
-0.291929841,
0.3393128812,
0.7467474341,
0.2139753699,
-0.1294562072,
-0.2253280878,
-0.1134930104,
0.0596122555,
0.1319043934,
-0.4818565845,
-0.1109924465,
0.2846423388,
0.26692155,
-0.5692412853,
0.112741001,
-0.4090167284,
-0.0268207155,
0.0033746127,
0.8380481005,
-0.3762165308,
0.1771892756,
0.1686754972,
-0.3065109849,
0.1061995327,
0.464445889,
-0.7782737613,
0.1388429403,
0.8683187366,
0.9636392593,
-0.1979618371,
-0.3445319533,
-0.6770644784,
0.4598625898,
-0.6258529425,
1.0398144722,
-0.6305266023,
-0.246015057,
-0.0940023437,
-0.0275098514,
0.0991253406,
-0.4667119086,
0.1860446185,
-0.4519759715,
-0.0046870406,
0.1924240291,
-0.607204318,
-0.2929082811,
0.3726690412,
-0.1751057655,
0.6923059821,
0.3164271712,
-0.4981274903,
0.8437315226,
-0.406193763,
-0.0866048858,
0.4347884059,
-0.4539387226,
-0.7119448185,
0.0573029928,
-0.3645724654,
0.5945531726,
0.0346381068,
0.1921852678,
-0.4985508919,
-0.5590109825,
0.0486554131,
-0.3152523637,
0.8534534574,
-0.3087030053,
-0.3725446463,
-0.0613738149,
-0.9212885499,
0.2591820657,
-0.0212617368,
-0.0729805231,
-0.4939517677,
-0.3458303213,
-0.3305176198,
0.1974283904,
-0.4095103741,
-0.6232594252,
0.4468698502,
-0.0968629345,
-0.1132897511,
0.6869110465,
0.1977442503,
0.3484458923,
-0.4424244463,
0.5701390505,
0.1612284333,
0.0458547398,
-0.572044909,
-0.4098277092,
-0.5246575475,
-0.5749362707,
0.2738740444,
0.6366801262,
-0.8314202428,
0.4840498567,
-0.1967450529,
-0.4406027198,
-0.1079244465,
0.2394130379,
0.6770298481,
0.3658216894,
0.3533720672,
-0.4363526702,
-0.3885439634,
-0.4524019063,
0.1141524017,
-0.0400008708,
-0.1193165332,
0.4712858796,
0.6047795415,
-0.1545294076,
0.7347462773,
-0.7785205841,
-0.6669153571,
-0.0102943303,
0.5634698868,
0.2395350188,
0.4173596203,
0.6513003111,
-0.3222385347,
-0.7938386798,
0.07582587,
-0.8625405431,
-0.247751832,
-0.4457363486,
-0.3530332446,
0.3273974359,
0.3826442659,
-0.2277855128,
0.5978230834,
0.3801766038,
-0.1033633202,
0.6443242431,
-0.030645635,
0.0017655028,
-0.3065631986,
-0.0954458937,
-0.0423829146,
-0.459296912,
-0.5356817842,
0.036302574,
0.0025771628,
-0.0679120198,
-0.6352234483,
0.6358166933,
-0.3665154874,
0.0847990438,
-0.4409522414,
-0.1234838665,
0.2126698196,
0.7005468011,
0.3632910848,
0.0807387903,
1.1428598166,
-0.4855300188,
0.5183878541,
0.1923816651,
-0.2708598375,
0.8025168777,
-0.4913621247,
0.0521880388,
-0.2691381574,
0.4757744074,
-0.6412585378,
-0.1662397981,
0.6401242614,
-0.3337687552,
0.678124845,
-0.3072733879,
-0.3934074342,
-0.2844934464,
-0.4167482257,
0.31027776,
0.3771391511,
-0.4532470703,
0.2738841474,
-0.1293897778,
0.1400359124,
-0.848493576,
-0.389621824,
0.0847585127,
0.0305363052,
-0.3197364211,
0.2465767562,
0.070218429,
-0.0564544275,
0.1077218726,
-0.3089001179,
-0.2684779763,
-0.124097839,
0.496024251,
0.3477707207,
-0.0530865267,
0.3067593873,
0.1296354234,
-0.4362207949,
-0.143327266,
-0.4099076688,
0.0320474841,
0.1673648953,
-0.3891850114,
-0.1890762299,
0.8473872542,
-0.0970363915,
0.3997866809,
0.651153028,
0.4893789291,
-0.1560381651,
-0.5787436366,
-0.1080691144,
-0.0702913553,
-0.4283401668,
0.4057897925,
-0.6208789945,
-0.591144681,
0.0764448643,
0.1573077142,
0.3616926372,
-0.0258419607,
0.3627307415,
-0.3617655039,
0.8574260473,
0.9578785896,
0.1242457405,
0.451287508,
-0.3988873661,
-0.0747788697,
-0.4343527257,
-0.1506834626,
-0.2529714108,
-0.3856714368,
-0.2125845104,
-0.417411238,
0.5241327882,
0.2085012197,
-0.3474492133,
0.530682385,
-0.5423834324,
0.6080799103,
0.8550014496,
0.331522584,
0.3510096967,
-0.05094162,
0.0989427119,
0.3155311942,
-1.0597484112,
-0.0704792365,
1.1598513126,
-0.1001278684,
0.775420785,
0.0437240116,
1.2077747583,
0.2652496994,
0.3085714281,
-1.009256959,
0.3848710358,
-0.1628793925,
-1.0190279484,
-0.2666072547,
-0.3798341751,
-1.3342574835,
0.3572415113,
-0.35877496,
-0.8170443177,
0.2326638997,
0.2448836267,
-0.7341655493,
0.3842072785,
-0.793538034,
0.7898066044,
-0.3607840836,
-0.6325571537,
0.0881070122,
-1.0439857244,
0.5182389617,
-0.5591317415,
0.0995801613,
-0.2696301937,
-0.1965084523,
0.319693327,
-0.3592585027,
1.1621490717,
-0.1011492312,
0.1964229047,
0.5099308491,
0.0458266325,
-0.0338230468,
-0.1623032987,
0.3306697607,
0.5280786157,
0.3061003387,
-0.6334143877,
-0.7169353366,
0.333217144,
-0.7644928098,
-0.4134154022,
-0.9615905285,
-0.4211304784,
-0.1534067988,
0.2084872425,
0.3889336288,
0.5493097901,
-0.0392326415,
0.1183576435,
0.5018351674,
-0.2037175894,
0.3796203136,
0.5969073176,
-0.3244556487,
-0.0986549854,
0.9328713417,
0.4040678144,
0.3822866082,
0.7514784336,
0.1216346249,
0.149930045,
-0.1814616919,
-0.3491538763,
0.1343958527,
-0.7341976166,
-0.7502599359,
-0.6391177773,
-0.0839813575,
-0.4141128063,
-0.5166719556,
-0.1138876677,
-0.2500948906,
-0.2230342627,
0.1800183207,
0.2117636949,
0.3560853004,
-0.5799046159,
0.5229815245,
-1.0674750805,
0.4628609121,
0.359143585,
0.4712992907,
-0.2748073041,
-0.5818231106,
-0.227786079,
-0.2943198085,
-0.3566406965,
-0.7921888828,
0.2243010402,
0.6120883226,
0.5983877778,
0.4884464741,
0.2214177847,
0.385343492,
-0.7334756255,
0.2774524987,
0.617784977,
-0.6020573974,
0.3769076169,
-0.0615151972,
0.4542500973,
0.4876919091,
1.054751873,
-0.5692760348,
-0.3681958616,
-0.6154188514,
-0.8821672201,
0.9608932137,
-0.0260942504,
0.0589185245,
-0.1467629522,
0.2779375315,
0.5557945967,
0.0921205208,
-0.5884661078,
-0.4395577312,
-0.0421338789,
0.0009490296,
0.0382499658,
0.1218417138,
-0.1537319422,
-0.1660171598,
0.7781911492,
-0.1964489073,
0.2737767994,
-0.1099411994,
-0.2861439884,
0.0043819509,
0.2424080968,
0.2243996561,
0.1843754351,
-0.4078891873,
0.2536260486,
-0.0105431173,
-0.1852992773,
0.5333188772,
-0.1863561422,
-0.3917511404,
0.2705783248,
0.4429917634,
0.8590360284,
0.6597912908,
-0.615717411,
0.5134071112,
0.343634516,
-0.3942619562,
-0.1468841434,
0.4985308349,
-0.5082803369,
0.2782172263,
0.2636276782,
0.2084416002,
0.0146873351,
-0.7367156148,
0.4038436413,
0.3901152909,
-0.5833125114,
-0.2531145215,
0.2999813259,
0.0499262102,
-0.2639029622,
0.2919075191,
-0.6189693213,
-0.3981472552,
0.465958029,
0.4163382351,
0.7918196321,
-0.0197153538,
0.5675446987,
0.3851848841,
0.0187717918,
0.0457780361,
-0.140248239,
-0.373680681,
-0.866201818,
-0.2827045321,
-0.3025762141,
-0.8416395783,
-0.2881759703,
-0.5705503225,
0.6132487059,
-0.5098398328,
-0.1498903036,
0.3672064543,
-0.1035831347,
-0.6608623266,
0.0569713376,
0.3973895013,
0.5956385136,
-0.9780375361,
0.8143167496,
0.5496970415,
-0.3827308416,
-0.4127171338,
-0.6339617968,
0.3723139465,
-0.9131379128,
0.7862046957,
0.3658550084,
-0.269970268,
0.1352835745,
-0.7642864585,
-0.4184591174,
0.899805963,
-0.0148399593,
-0.7109723687,
0.0194072612,
-0.0225483254,
0.2362315804,
-0.1691348702,
0.1570459157,
0.5242993236,
0.2808552086,
0.3722838461,
-0.554099381,
-0.4671781659,
0.2605698705,
-0.3740360141,
0.3544337451,
-0.6147568226,
0.2711669207,
-0.3637291193,
-0.0728439614,
-0.1799604893,
0.3248723745,
0.3862688839,
0.6028901935,
0.465387404,
0.4422501028,
0.4800804853,
0.0202815365,
0.8215546608,
0.0993106738,
0.3069829643,
1.4581729174,
-0.5074411035,
0.7667176723,
0.1510183513,
-0.2730616331,
0.4754726887,
0.2534514666,
-0.2947750688,
0.4001996517,
0.1398749352,
-0.7018893361,
-0.339291513,
0.0643131882,
0.1343619674,
0.6950424314,
0.3614265621,
0.031431932,
-0.6414015293,
0.4341396391,
-0.0082056671,
-0.3879629374,
-0.3857580423,
0.7900782824,
0.0953912437,
-0.45995152,
0.5763020515,
-0.2330009341,
0.8458032608,
-0.8989226818,
-0.1327291131,
-0.0251662433,
0.2098753899,
-0.2800088227,
-0.9143890738,
0.3499135673,
-0.0398889408,
-0.1127527058,
-0.1152888909,
0.6390872002,
-0.318960458,
-0.5888780951,
0.2120046765,
0.349206984,
0.4604975879,
-0.1741063446,
-0.7797356844,
0.1374594569,
-0.0603013821,
-0.007357155,
0.5318707228,
0.7129042149,
-0.2089571506,
0.6294263601,
0.1488754302,
-0.1323106438,
0.5184163451,
-0.2001897842,
0.3824030161,
-0.7009106874,
-0.1055340618,
-0.4622841775,
0.2809461355,
0.2082683593,
-0.2395390123,
0.4076822996,
0.3365919292,
0.848365128,
0.0236033592,
0.8443874717,
-0.088613309,
0.3928751349,
-0.1109873205,
0.138544783,
-0.4124475121,
-0.1309826523,
-0.161753118,
-0.7800822854,
-1.1074331999,
0.4795661867,
-0.1754229814,
-0.1097953245,
0.7677701116,
0.5588595271,
-0.0257053971,
-0.4392717183,
0.9555664062,
-0.1815730333,
0.2038272321,
0.9257377386,
0.5106156468,
-0.4056864083,
0.9563473463,
-0.6104349494,
-0.5985652804,
-0.3459496498,
-0.9712298512,
-0.6028715372,
-0.2187250108,
-0.8669883609,
0.1240939051,
0.201885879,
1.0158784389,
0.8286749721,
-0.7726960182,
-0.0329227112,
0.1107824817,
0.1168938056,
-0.5701996684,
-0.2416748255,
0.1018397808,
-0.6404399276,
-0.7471188903,
0.0011177269,
0.6203442812,
0.0560255274,
0.04303452,
0.3419034481,
-0.1144207269,
-0.0218163803,
0.8035227656,
0.7709234357,
-0.1251361817,
-0.4805706739,
-0.0992899761,
-0.0969973803,
0.3451476991,
0.7206423283,
-0.9019494653,
0.6450436711,
0.2856001556,
0.5689408183,
0.5509096384,
-0.2818629742,
0.2109525204,
-1.0926771164,
0.1513742805,
0.3028616607,
0.1722991318,
0.0336874276,
-0.1619537026,
0.4711207747,
0.3381710649,
-0.5465527177,
-0.7338966727,
0.3603436053,
-1.0726076365,
-0.4732302427,
0.9685795307,
-0.5095909238,
-0.2372737974,
-0.4660622776,
-0.1302073151,
0.0949915722,
-0.2253091186,
0.6752901673,
0.4851768911,
-0.5097635388,
-0.2714721262,
-0.4861361086,
-0.2362840027,
0.2083857059,
-0.6519863605,
-0.0914614275,
0.6362644434,
0.2355206758,
0.2615996897,
0.5709241629,
0.1619670838,
0.3410084844,
0.3345063627,
0.1985081285,
0.0496787317,
-0.6847269535,
-0.3963954151,
0.3464227319,
-0.1608962119,
-0.4990033805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03861v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03861v2
|
Designing Informative Metrics for Few-Shot Example Selection
| 2024-03-06T17:11:38 | 2024-03-19T19:51:09 |
Rishabh Adiga, Lakshminarayanan Subramanian, Varun Chandrasekaran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Pretrained language models (PLMs) have shown remarkable few-shot learning
capabilities when provided with properly formatted examples. However, selecting
the "best" examples remains an open challenge. We propose a complexity-based
prompt selection approach for sequence tagging tasks. This approach avoids the
training of a dedicated model for selection of examples, and instead uses
certain metrics to align the syntactico-semantic complexity of test sentences
and examples. We use both sentence- and word-level metrics to match the
complexity of examples to the (test) sentence being considered. Our results
demonstrate that our approach extracts greater performance from PLMs: it
achieves state-of-the-art performance on few-shot NER, achieving a 5% absolute
improvement in F1 score on the CoNLL2003 dataset for GPT-4. We also see large
gains of upto 28.85 points (F1/Acc.) in smaller models like GPT-j-6B.
|
[
-0.4228522778,
-0.4648855925,
0.6363841891,
-0.0461753346,
-0.5724803209,
-0.2262268811,
0.0928113014,
-0.0829262286,
-0.1088163331,
0.0153027652,
-0.6060791612,
-0.6781948805,
-0.4980655611,
0.2872951925,
0.1814949512,
1.1020126343,
0.1597392708,
-0.0406064279,
-0.1238741651,
-0.0848325565,
-0.8185715675,
-0.0690243319,
-0.6833063364,
-0.1355076581,
0.5564548969,
0.6174806356,
0.2470895648,
0.7164617777,
0.757350266,
0.2953049242,
-0.06892775,
0.3428389132,
-0.1806848794,
0.2336720973,
-0.1445084363,
-0.7263233662,
-0.2716506422,
0.1377399266,
0.7052343488,
0.6246962547,
0.2064749151,
0.1512281001,
-0.0758742467,
0.4244407713,
-0.35526824,
0.1817304194,
-0.5448629856,
0.0898690671,
-0.3063603938,
-0.1540507972,
-0.444400847,
-0.2768550515,
0.1973891705,
-0.5753369331,
0.0766319036,
0.4194834232,
0.6022870541,
0.4643490911,
0.0507753566,
-0.2317596823,
-0.4595544636,
0.7914344072,
-0.9011307955,
-0.1647194475,
0.2783784866,
0.3911631405,
-0.2294653803,
-0.5857076049,
-0.4049810171,
-0.0627981499,
-0.1962609291,
0.1281346828,
-0.2327094823,
0.1527971029,
0.7625682354,
0.0834335014,
-1.0598601103,
0.4751371145,
-0.0308277253,
-0.1680896133,
0.3352996111,
0.3985619247,
0.0981304199,
-0.4899179637,
-0.2781752348,
-0.0973704606,
-0.5782622695,
0.2734453082,
0.4496386945,
0.6153686047,
-0.012714861,
0.5698640347,
-0.2955259681,
1.1087379456,
-0.0918173119,
-0.3425546587,
0.3233918846,
-0.4249784946,
-0.0830793008,
-0.2184341103,
0.8415051699,
0.1434641778,
-0.0318097472,
0.2238294184,
-0.2265591025,
0.0058885268,
-0.0914724171,
-0.8826194406,
-0.4077112675,
0.1192724928,
-0.1877475828,
0.142067939,
0.2193837464,
-0.7460517883,
-0.2740379572,
0.0886596516,
0.6694136858,
-0.6770369411,
0.2355384082,
0.0186740216,
-0.5090847015,
0.3629621863,
0.2759582698,
-0.4758208394,
0.0242012702,
0.687087059,
1.1269687414,
-0.1592388898,
-0.1861052215,
-0.986369729,
-0.305965811,
-0.1648364961,
0.9191895723,
-0.7280799747,
-0.3150505722,
-0.3127691448,
-0.3458940983,
0.0386601649,
-0.4908204079,
0.5419312119,
-0.350166887,
0.3018859625,
-0.2335879356,
-0.854464829,
-0.0153471539,
0.2188164443,
-0.5595576167,
1.0024688244,
0.131216377,
-0.7746039629,
0.6363334656,
-0.639687717,
-0.3637294173,
0.4931574464,
-0.270898968,
-0.5438433886,
0.0225192737,
0.1523926407,
0.7122907043,
0.0031275218,
-0.1235835925,
-0.1830090731,
-0.5461772084,
-0.0846805573,
0.0130076203,
0.1829901338,
0.2711946368,
-0.1842106432,
0.2009420991,
-0.826613605,
0.2137516886,
0.0722009689,
-0.2825832069,
-0.3392196298,
-0.1923588067,
-0.594024241,
0.3453416824,
-0.0530977957,
-0.2795942724,
0.394574523,
-0.7559459209,
0.3085614443,
0.4835996032,
0.2100555748,
0.6216259599,
-0.7701262832,
0.9704096913,
0.1869861484,
-0.1298831999,
-0.752402246,
-0.5996712446,
-0.6467889547,
-0.5766496062,
0.4752979577,
0.7568991184,
-0.8752881289,
0.8349595666,
-0.2373006195,
-0.6587499976,
-0.5331231356,
0.3271741569,
0.5213794112,
0.5871459246,
0.3096374273,
-0.70483917,
-0.4348132312,
-0.7789429426,
-0.2746623158,
-0.4084806442,
-0.0399513617,
0.3382958174,
0.4396429062,
0.3875649571,
1.202327013,
-0.5219887495,
-0.2196689695,
-0.6557074189,
0.538505733,
0.6231864095,
0.6028862,
0.4493736327,
-0.445088625,
-0.2735140324,
-0.4230282307,
-0.2627691031,
-0.3526836336,
-0.2839575112,
-0.0662967339,
-0.0838810578,
0.1286560744,
-0.7068356872,
0.3182836473,
0.0133531736,
0.0334696285,
0.4052196443,
0.0332016982,
-0.1216958165,
-0.8156089783,
0.147912845,
0.2287071645,
-0.5495315194,
-0.4662841558,
-0.3205502033,
-0.214968577,
0.0551752895,
-0.7743282318,
0.6550181508,
-0.3122897148,
-0.2076651007,
-0.075975433,
0.1231449544,
-0.0735210106,
0.3923925459,
-0.0295580849,
0.6000007391,
0.459263891,
-0.5945985913,
0.0762315243,
0.3276324272,
-0.6638616323,
0.4617246389,
-0.5054443479,
0.2702834904,
-0.3369038403,
0.2473318577,
-1.3458991051,
-0.2329628766,
0.210206762,
-0.5050291419,
0.2553445399,
-0.3618054092,
-0.627255559,
-0.4299510121,
-0.3756654263,
0.2709614933,
0.9139307141,
-0.2611149848,
0.2744426131,
-0.0845303237,
-0.3997304142,
-0.4343709946,
-0.3671538532,
-0.3165069818,
-0.3331486583,
-0.2700525224,
0.0179857612,
-0.2870841324,
0.0570126995,
-0.3888905048,
-0.2156818062,
0.1891840696,
0.2148321867,
0.2317541391,
0.1719322056,
-0.3297290206,
0.2807521224,
-0.0033053572,
-0.1348042488,
-0.3873218596,
-0.2540049553,
0.5890963078,
-0.1675531417,
-0.1878569275,
-0.5777009726,
0.4161581099,
-0.2018626332,
-0.2155511677,
0.2876482308,
0.6512322426,
-0.1262998879,
-0.6499867439,
-0.2416795492,
-0.1062033996,
-0.4434851408,
0.1981170475,
-0.4779376984,
-1.0511876345,
0.2457312942,
-0.2473690957,
-0.0306570735,
0.2267035842,
0.3325452507,
-0.2936615646,
0.8870565295,
0.4800663292,
-0.0244735815,
0.6915177107,
-0.2078520656,
0.1305720806,
-0.4370088577,
0.0722495094,
-0.5039456487,
-0.417424351,
-0.4841226935,
-0.383010447,
0.3804565668,
0.3083726764,
-0.3754323423,
0.3065629005,
-0.3703875244,
0.7861190438,
0.63856107,
0.0082608899,
0.2097144574,
-0.3840334117,
-0.2581234276,
-0.0753739104,
-1.004796505,
-0.7543470263,
0.6792804599,
0.1258869916,
0.7376506329,
0.1244677976,
0.9219791889,
0.1375744343,
0.0875701159,
-0.9623751044,
0.6755542755,
-0.3267633021,
-0.3241847157,
-0.2643145621,
-0.3523921371,
-0.8647020459,
0.1019263193,
-0.0919546187,
-0.6516351104,
-0.2188114971,
0.2494946718,
-0.9510737062,
-0.0678784028,
-0.7383531928,
0.930949986,
0.0095202932,
-0.0648975372,
0.3170364201,
-1.1385844946,
0.2479347438,
0.043558944,
0.0164662339,
-0.3100873828,
-0.1886351109,
0.7421950102,
-0.2532607615,
0.9132559896,
-0.2487451136,
0.4413491786,
0.3584157526,
0.1669041812,
0.4754490256,
-0.186844945,
-0.0731116459,
-0.26064533,
-0.2054412961,
-0.3196707666,
-0.6357105374,
0.3795091212,
-0.3756720722,
-0.6818333864,
-0.4552347958,
-0.4436323047,
-0.3216167986,
0.212596193,
0.4735854268,
0.3645752668,
-0.1643412411,
-0.1605051607,
0.4455190897,
-0.2712576389,
0.8043973446,
0.4312182367,
0.2306929827,
-0.1820655465,
0.5805255175,
-0.0070952629,
0.2256854922,
0.6029168963,
0.2389758527,
-0.2543448806,
-0.7817428708,
-0.2591643333,
0.2767394185,
-0.9475858212,
-0.6480933428,
-0.6257427335,
0.057280533,
-0.3466720879,
-0.0711813495,
-0.0441387445,
-0.4056665003,
-0.5320701003,
-0.1525546163,
0.2278226614,
0.6414128542,
0.0318848342,
0.7723366022,
-0.7607007027,
0.1568451822,
0.2138521224,
0.2604446113,
-0.2974555194,
-0.7823536396,
0.1295241266,
-0.7006776929,
-0.2423917353,
-0.714466393,
0.4008432925,
0.5042920113,
0.5385198593,
0.3049242198,
-0.0287826527,
0.6660338044,
-0.7869448662,
0.9095296264,
0.1832321435,
-0.9703478217,
1.0044746399,
-0.1139678583,
0.712192297,
0.7593240738,
0.6672344804,
-0.2650467455,
-0.3796004951,
-0.6181119084,
-0.6412357688,
0.7690657377,
0.0114876945,
-0.0337796547,
-0.1981660426,
0.3088610172,
0.443698436,
0.1527342051,
-0.4966754317,
-0.1433776915,
0.1001555249,
-0.4145188332,
-0.2005001307,
0.0000021155,
0.2101947814,
-0.0861803144,
0.5051155686,
-0.3893971443,
0.0100207394,
0.2456052154,
-0.1931798905,
0.2425032109,
0.5813049078,
0.5778288245,
0.4777890146,
-0.0981634557,
0.3088304996,
0.0170973986,
0.0079640141,
0.2798015475,
0.0452612229,
0.0093565378,
0.2295467705,
0.5035780072,
0.9228140116,
0.0797610059,
-0.7573269606,
0.8849558234,
0.2505781054,
0.1608227342,
-0.007025714,
0.3942448795,
-0.3781014085,
0.3416176438,
0.0638109818,
-0.014120956,
0.1817825586,
-0.227558732,
0.4979221523,
0.4615043104,
-0.1558153778,
-0.3833373189,
0.312147975,
0.0769507512,
-0.3932336867,
0.3395389318,
-0.8893148303,
-0.4396080077,
0.5588309765,
0.4586183727,
0.5521038175,
-0.1546804607,
0.2898370624,
0.5960243344,
0.2316207886,
-0.3263272643,
0.4538542628,
-0.0674589947,
-0.5872503519,
-0.4759001136,
-0.6335712671,
-0.3234777451,
0.1625355482,
-0.4625500739,
0.5484440327,
-0.8066647053,
-0.327922523,
0.1992578954,
0.0831555352,
-1.010529995,
0.0787077695,
0.2654898167,
0.864690125,
-1.0001244545,
0.6284315586,
0.5930891633,
-0.5175259113,
-0.8422116637,
-0.2973407507,
0.1061376408,
-0.6375949383,
0.7714975476,
0.3966674209,
0.1408262104,
0.2128447443,
-0.7184984088,
-0.5201099515,
1.1119288206,
0.2166225165,
-0.7664402127,
-0.061921902,
-0.1945619285,
0.4393237531,
-0.6063164473,
0.5493476391,
0.801170826,
0.2704573572,
0.3842461109,
-0.9568635225,
-0.0048486716,
-0.091804646,
0.1789539605,
0.2925217748,
-0.4440960884,
0.6655213833,
-0.3849469423,
-0.4531936347,
0.4660575688,
0.5726498961,
0.3708114028,
0.3353101015,
0.6067565084,
0.6705147624,
0.8504865766,
0.0327031761,
1.0077375174,
0.2749603093,
0.0511437096,
1.5276101828,
-0.3353967667,
0.8398420215,
0.3167203665,
-0.2766562104,
0.4912156165,
0.7861267924,
-0.2287093401,
0.6183151007,
0.516653955,
-0.1505584717,
-0.4608146846,
-0.2293283641,
-0.0169602558,
0.5537711978,
0.1683205664,
-0.3354128897,
-0.3107066154,
-0.1228169724,
0.0208000597,
-0.1571888626,
-0.2998535037,
1.1342078447,
0.1791819036,
-0.7269132137,
0.1990912408,
-0.1009932682,
0.8605328798,
-0.7804054022,
-0.2057546377,
-0.1908072233,
-0.3778513074,
-0.1385248899,
-0.7944151163,
-0.0601762496,
0.1627680957,
-0.0511853211,
0.0277004652,
0.7486253381,
-0.3708836138,
-0.084364593,
-0.3299384713,
0.9321157336,
0.5378084183,
0.1600619704,
-0.5309237838,
-0.1578146368,
-0.4121502042,
0.0653935671,
0.1442307532,
0.3450158238,
0.1484221369,
0.4385884702,
0.3864637911,
0.1467411816,
0.0316294767,
0.1208730191,
0.6729272604,
-0.8309482336,
-0.766803503,
-0.9829468131,
0.5964615941,
0.0454136319,
-0.5187005401,
0.5022999644,
0.5429446697,
0.8436172009,
-0.0574590489,
0.8258066773,
0.0206228457,
0.4778448939,
-0.6648869514,
0.1103560552,
-0.2991811633,
0.3717777431,
-0.3287968636,
-0.7589370608,
-0.5823231936,
0.5696111321,
-0.4417774975,
0.0383225903,
0.8086364269,
0.7930780053,
0.2312432379,
-0.1857973188,
0.4630814195,
-0.1369763613,
0.2450848073,
0.9371483326,
1.0633018017,
-0.1546948999,
0.3805680275,
0.0210195817,
-0.3238857687,
-0.0237483568,
-1.2673277855,
-1.0589032173,
-0.5868384838,
-0.4101866484,
0.071893461,
-0.2428044528,
1.2704234123,
0.7794212103,
-0.6479721665,
0.1401080936,
0.1555723995,
0.182714045,
0.0716494694,
-0.1513376236,
0.0190020744,
-0.7737711668,
-0.5368825793,
0.4130719602,
0.3910494447,
0.3440940082,
0.1961408257,
0.2344990373,
-0.0719580427,
-0.0380036533,
0.4478936791,
0.2309655249,
-0.7250590324,
-0.4213052094,
-0.2357338518,
-0.0527404472,
0.3887958825,
0.9643483162,
-0.8804748058,
0.3390067518,
0.7866788507,
0.8301579356,
0.1778891534,
0.3084778488,
0.2005612701,
-1.2954152822,
0.1295603365,
0.6526632309,
0.3095936775,
0.4096567929,
-0.0653607845,
0.3815576136,
0.2829664946,
-0.4492976964,
-0.7654092908,
0.3807362914,
-1.2460361719,
-0.1796901673,
1.1553148031,
-0.4877431691,
-0.078866303,
0.0041393116,
-0.0958307683,
0.1470758319,
-0.4960528016,
0.151887551,
0.8441842198,
-0.2963307202,
-0.3233273327,
-0.3673208952,
0.738776207,
0.5618448257,
-0.9487498999,
-0.4466753304,
0.5860698223,
0.2458537966,
0.0235660914,
0.7389919162,
0.1895155907,
0.1402255446,
-0.2437865138,
-0.2495880872,
0.0844810456,
-0.3623332679,
-0.8487790227,
0.1661531329,
0.4741334915,
-0.1625660509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03857v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03857v2
|
Emojinize: Enriching Any Text with Emoji Translations
| 2024-03-06T17:06:17 | 2024-03-07T14:09:00 |
Lars Henning Klein, Roland Aydin, Robert West
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Emoji have become ubiquitous in written communication, on the Web and beyond.
They can emphasize or clarify emotions, add details to conversations, or simply
serve decorative purposes. This casual use, however, barely scratches the
surface of the expressive power of emoji. To further unleash this power, we
present Emojinize, a method for translating arbitrary text phrases into
sequences of one or more emoji without requiring human input. By leveraging the
power of large language models, Emojinize can choose appropriate emoji by
disambiguating based on context (eg, cricket-bat vs bat) and can express
complex concepts compositionally by combining multiple emoji (eq, "Emojinize"
is translated to input-latin-letters right-arrow grinning-face). In a cloze
test--based user study, we show that Emojinize's emoji translations increase
the human guessability of masked words by 55%, whereas human-picked emoji
translations do so by only 29%. These results suggest that emoji provide a
sufficiently rich vocabulary to accurately translate a wide variety of words.
Moreover, annotating words and phrases with Emojinize's emoji translations
opens the door to numerous downstream applications, including children learning
how to read, adults learning foreign languages, and text understanding for
people with learning disabilities.
|
[
-0.3879111707,
-0.8646262884,
0.4230049551,
0.4200087786,
-0.5120554566,
0.1616000682,
-0.475106746,
-0.5355384946,
0.4048830569,
0.4314376712,
-0.5824182034,
-0.2384052426,
-0.6963318586,
0.3792563379,
-0.2609326839,
0.8346296549,
-0.0101814456,
-0.0336248428,
-0.1904239953,
-0.0292449035,
-0.4157870114,
-0.1758968383,
-0.2417328209,
-0.1882723868,
0.5242369175,
0.7264974117,
0.7849986553,
0.258947283,
0.633859098,
0.256008029,
-0.0973080024,
0.1464199722,
-0.3651719689,
0.2812542319,
0.0309870355,
-0.6560574174,
0.0506209694,
0.1785823405,
0.1638393849,
0.6148340702,
0.0821181163,
0.0338402651,
-0.1785092652,
0.5127732158,
-0.8425607085,
0.0319575965,
-0.4302234054,
0.1758679599,
-0.3164364398,
-0.1439866424,
-0.3215508461,
-0.4908384085,
-0.2111648321,
-0.5187074542,
-0.4028693438,
0.0666487142,
0.5463787317,
0.3576876819,
-0.2452378124,
-0.2147666365,
-0.5062574148,
0.7339505553,
-0.3853339851,
0.2619389594,
0.4409399629,
0.215188697,
0.0120702628,
-0.6022827625,
-0.6179981232,
-0.2747706473,
-0.147783339,
0.3068483174,
0.0234592278,
0.1496012956,
0.3038125932,
0.473746717,
-0.4178942442,
-0.1717482954,
0.1599738896,
0.1292956024,
0.5410724878,
-0.1974518895,
1.0985308886,
-0.1575643718,
-0.1433724761,
-0.2664630413,
-0.5685288906,
-0.2261939496,
-0.0002014403,
0.0739675462,
0.0392369591,
0.8487731218,
-0.1884911507,
0.7256813049,
-0.2535103261,
-0.0948423892,
0.2577043772,
-0.3626358807,
-0.2479634434,
-0.0394024476,
0.6359383464,
0.5304861069,
0.5064522624,
-0.4228949845,
0.0114375316,
0.0902422145,
0.0972703695,
-0.8122333288,
-0.0492819324,
0.2502010465,
-0.0709315389,
-0.3368065059,
0.042443119,
-0.8041175604,
-0.5597739816,
0.0773989856,
0.4233159125,
-0.40069291,
0.0713638142,
-0.0941346586,
-0.6326196194,
-0.0517107509,
0.2977378368,
-0.9111400843,
-0.1480206251,
0.3501764834,
0.8342735171,
0.5110234022,
-0.1813233793,
-0.2618028224,
0.1688840836,
-0.3610911071,
0.5721036792,
-0.8389984369,
-0.5146802068,
0.2253545076,
-0.0922070667,
0.0531417802,
-0.3107915223,
0.6269171834,
0.0051742652,
-0.0730431378,
-0.0618034117,
-0.6306060553,
0.0985550657,
0.073873803,
-0.6505873203,
0.6146377325,
-0.0607589819,
-0.795376122,
0.2850208282,
-0.8728092313,
-0.7318333387,
0.2332900316,
-0.0023800852,
-0.3341338634,
0.4839964807,
0.3940480947,
0.5663493872,
-0.2210884094,
-0.3276817501,
-0.2329369783,
-0.2150891423,
0.6427906752,
-0.0643980876,
0.6623452306,
0.3125722408,
-0.2573899031,
-0.1720952988,
-0.3540197909,
0.0420501679,
0.142947346,
-0.2550635934,
-0.5400055647,
-0.1587589234,
0.5436635017,
-0.070257239,
0.2924936414,
-0.8314006925,
0.3094639778,
-0.5812348127,
0.6920198202,
0.2177893519,
-0.0575731806,
0.7089904547,
-0.1934429407,
0.550824523,
-0.3168655038,
0.3907544911,
-0.3768573403,
-0.9248491526,
-0.5642597079,
-0.4439717233,
0.4751787484,
0.8177937269,
-1.0524513721,
0.5955082774,
-0.5410308242,
-0.445841074,
-0.7791564465,
0.3003380001,
0.2726041973,
-0.0625644252,
0.3240010738,
-0.1020018756,
-0.3630366027,
-0.8570020199,
-0.6617690921,
0.0872321278,
-0.0877785385,
0.2213292569,
0.5670220852,
-0.2127932906,
0.5859009027,
-0.4689067304,
-0.6315563917,
-0.4249126017,
0.2765516937,
-0.3569716215,
0.3308355212,
0.4595642686,
-1.1517474651,
-0.5946390629,
0.1820458919,
-0.5782942176,
-0.1019156873,
-0.4193277657,
-0.4174975157,
-0.2565461099,
0.5230711102,
-0.4372746944,
0.5877863169,
0.557690084,
-0.2957800925,
-0.5190749764,
0.003139979,
0.4594752491,
-1.2276693583,
0.1953487247,
-0.0986757055,
-0.3350704312,
-0.6734166741,
0.513371706,
0.1005057916,
-0.1472578049,
-0.4294648468,
0.6387847662,
-0.5216560364,
0.2052633762,
-0.2306513339,
0.6080415249,
-0.0198009387,
0.1045700684,
-0.3010667264,
0.6130221486,
0.3210199773,
-0.1284147054,
0.2745092213,
0.4998041391,
-0.3080173135,
0.4926897287,
-0.2493858635,
0.1085296422,
-0.031563893,
0.1345542222,
-1.0246940851,
-0.6022673249,
0.5275871754,
-0.6374937296,
0.3940141499,
0.0666209236,
-0.6995107532,
-0.2401918471,
-0.2094720006,
0.2848406434,
0.5800538659,
-0.5611914396,
0.7633169889,
0.5790382624,
0.0494204126,
-0.3272373378,
-1.2500498295,
0.499666214,
0.0311294943,
-0.5401840806,
0.3030019104,
-0.2350720614,
-0.0548276454,
-0.1309160739,
0.3178544939,
-0.2916536331,
0.5315269232,
0.2761524618,
-0.0899398401,
0.3390600681,
0.3080847859,
0.4207902253,
0.1677330136,
-0.3643884659,
0.0518440343,
0.40456599,
0.1173644811,
-0.1311770976,
-0.3229230642,
0.6469343305,
0.5091099143,
-0.281847775,
0.7651343346,
0.7026293874,
-0.4817864895,
0.0854196027,
-0.4906111956,
-0.1114613414,
-0.3857338428,
0.1550861746,
-0.5010023117,
-0.9151627421,
0.1992579401,
-0.2487379014,
-0.0031342655,
0.1411526501,
0.1941405088,
0.13421157,
1.2728736401,
0.4187634587,
-0.1074803174,
0.702804327,
0.0807821155,
0.4304108322,
-0.8364835978,
-0.1277733594,
-0.4179678559,
-0.3685671389,
-0.4923835695,
-0.3384244442,
0.0763018206,
0.1813932359,
0.3906643987,
0.4450999796,
-0.6812703013,
0.7409545183,
0.3239740729,
0.4459831417,
0.1506610513,
0.2236454785,
0.1326349974,
-0.1273459196,
-0.5023422837,
-0.2787536979,
0.7910490036,
0.0488674827,
0.72860533,
0.3299157619,
1.0403110981,
0.1581164896,
0.7541572452,
-0.9867417812,
0.5395112634,
-0.3502921164,
-0.4597163498,
-0.2900803685,
-0.3048592806,
-0.977627635,
0.0533394217,
-0.5388011336,
-0.8036122918,
0.0165251102,
0.0461111329,
-0.0702053756,
0.0889927447,
-0.7914871573,
0.7669377923,
-0.2951929569,
-0.0495307744,
-0.2271927297,
-0.5540762544,
0.1779483408,
-0.0550709628,
0.5213937759,
-0.0963106379,
-0.3314682841,
0.3587908149,
-0.1372825205,
0.9148953557,
0.2060977072,
0.1025875434,
0.1889576316,
0.0335814133,
0.1371276826,
0.0809731334,
0.2769693136,
0.2251613289,
-0.2851081491,
-0.3937191963,
-0.959829092,
0.71695894,
-0.5016797185,
-0.4161413014,
-0.2937427461,
-0.2091233432,
0.141914919,
0.3465323746,
0.4561020136,
0.1744023561,
-0.4681537151,
0.1395168751,
0.3525059521,
-0.0077634682,
0.3125914633,
0.0211885311,
-0.3317213058,
-0.6145266891,
0.8853802681,
0.0045366441,
0.0211745966,
0.8271100521,
0.2693311274,
-0.2874027193,
-0.01708664,
-0.582059145,
0.2357904762,
-0.8569318056,
-0.1158515364,
-0.6839543581,
0.1928940564,
-0.4280833304,
-0.469440788,
0.0034493739,
-0.7446565628,
-0.3701807857,
-0.0262996759,
0.5853181481,
0.4932555556,
-0.1863128394,
0.1564229429,
-0.7860403657,
0.3629146516,
0.3257597089,
-0.0465324111,
-0.5206906796,
-0.2309359312,
-0.2847781181,
0.0841354281,
-0.1292811185,
-1.1043952703,
0.3609624803,
0.6435991526,
0.412052393,
0.3120877743,
-0.0029539412,
0.6127019525,
-0.5681666136,
0.8645764589,
0.4627775252,
-1.2501373291,
0.9917216301,
-0.0313552581,
0.3750780523,
0.6737196445,
0.2192310989,
-0.7599728107,
-0.6796559691,
-0.4458566308,
-0.9336565733,
0.2459834516,
0.6407902241,
0.4309873879,
-0.3718082309,
0.5233874917,
-0.3677834868,
0.2910528183,
-0.4984920621,
-0.3357776701,
-0.406811595,
-0.6283634305,
-0.3020109236,
0.0087632313,
-0.2750006914,
-0.2351796329,
0.2156115025,
-0.1129933298,
0.5396502018,
0.1619070023,
-0.4547971487,
0.1147638708,
0.4217070043,
0.5481337905,
0.1375854909,
0.0136809144,
0.0448541716,
0.0731261745,
-0.5304853916,
0.0679175556,
0.0412127264,
-0.0932116807,
0.0733167604,
0.1125804186,
0.5372179747,
0.4749225378,
-0.8341513276,
0.717860043,
-0.3314264119,
0.207613945,
-0.2930189669,
0.0927264765,
-0.0185607933,
0.0653907955,
0.0814820826,
0.1674406677,
0.4017637074,
-0.759046495,
0.0294876695,
0.2937159836,
-0.5276554823,
-0.1412792653,
0.629542172,
0.5040406585,
-0.4677622616,
0.3711835444,
-0.201594159,
-0.5894863605,
0.289979279,
0.4326393902,
1.1910592318,
-0.330291152,
0.4110768735,
0.3159391284,
0.5333968997,
-0.2961618304,
0.350540489,
-0.1310908496,
-0.7951876521,
-0.2974942923,
-0.4126780331,
-0.3485044241,
-0.3589113951,
-0.6092410684,
-0.0710372105,
-0.4507690668,
-0.4719709158,
0.0794896558,
-0.3877548575,
-0.6032208204,
0.4379541874,
0.3234755397,
0.675106883,
-1.14739573,
0.4856748283,
1.0383117199,
-0.8064057827,
-0.3156452179,
0.2100836635,
-0.278231889,
-0.602396965,
0.4454427958,
0.5069342852,
0.0352737419,
0.2953663766,
-0.9206892252,
-0.5795835853,
0.4717760384,
0.2338517606,
-0.247972548,
0.3778693378,
0.1023459285,
0.5582768321,
-0.4200203121,
0.5718836784,
0.4645783603,
0.7526879907,
-0.1971538216,
-0.5289207101,
0.243743524,
-0.5784718394,
0.3733019233,
0.2556502521,
-0.3498545289,
0.4740235507,
-0.3052305877,
-0.5916216969,
0.4766815901,
0.4817697406,
-0.292832762,
0.0248602871,
0.2583677173,
0.3827135265,
0.6031373739,
-0.3114508688,
1.3224685192,
-0.5779777169,
0.1520675421,
0.7545254827,
0.2529170215,
1.0811542273,
0.5670196414,
0.2188621014,
0.4661425352,
0.4190693796,
-0.0551267266,
0.4407570958,
-0.0177061763,
-0.4284653962,
-0.6326659322,
-0.3635080457,
0.0160720609,
0.3632550836,
0.599865973,
-0.3941574991,
0.0885155499,
0.5002580881,
0.1972582042,
0.2219225317,
0.068550311,
0.6568874717,
0.2275839895,
-0.7259644866,
0.3304018974,
-0.1109943986,
0.4617922306,
-0.1770871431,
-0.1244527996,
-0.1037300453,
0.1251460612,
-0.1733687967,
-0.8807411194,
0.0789320245,
-0.0774034113,
0.1740689278,
-0.066648148,
0.7002413869,
-0.4779209197,
-0.6951445341,
0.2809219658,
0.3181038499,
0.271216929,
-0.2086610049,
-0.849550724,
-0.0994640514,
0.0823265314,
-0.0529990867,
0.3031168282,
0.3842974305,
0.3533301353,
0.7557864785,
0.4319010079,
-0.0998346284,
0.0813764781,
0.2931491733,
0.719730258,
-0.536319077,
-0.3583213389,
-0.7120867968,
0.6038587689,
-0.3939236104,
-0.4370252788,
0.9153300524,
0.2845376134,
0.5954330564,
-0.2211690694,
1.0563341379,
-0.1610140055,
0.2972657084,
-0.5445466638,
0.7529624701,
-0.9393642545,
-0.089696683,
-0.3307195306,
-0.7331353426,
-0.6943027973,
0.9133370519,
-0.0595050715,
0.0007333604,
0.5779998302,
0.5515755415,
0.2125056833,
0.0966879502,
0.5083434582,
0.1361340135,
-0.0120564057,
0.2709467411,
0.8061873913,
-0.6848005652,
0.341996491,
-0.2829801142,
-0.475032568,
-0.4321481586,
-0.5340252519,
-1.3095341921,
-0.4000855088,
-0.5270721316,
-0.243148759,
0.0821194276,
0.7133727074,
0.3359310031,
-0.596137166,
0.0758523121,
-0.1467881948,
0.1887237132,
-0.2068509161,
-0.1615099311,
-0.0578537248,
-0.4205653369,
-0.8584312201,
0.4629949927,
0.3046801686,
0.2468159944,
-0.0635346398,
0.2734909058,
-0.0954760909,
0.5558140278,
0.6540977359,
0.2088979036,
-0.6619175076,
-0.3430633843,
-0.0029524826,
-0.1058968902,
-0.0118781086,
0.8157302737,
-0.3349284828,
0.812165916,
0.7497066855,
0.5105004311,
0.3037705719,
-0.1908382773,
0.4339452088,
-0.6991356015,
0.2630032301,
0.0738377422,
0.4452937543,
0.610683918,
-0.4137988687,
0.5557975173,
0.0893417224,
-0.4209717512,
-0.6230674386,
0.4043872356,
-0.7820700407,
-0.4855981469,
1.0021555424,
-0.1603954732,
-0.551061511,
-0.1688379347,
-0.3255464137,
0.2958211303,
-0.4043727815,
0.7274023294,
0.4165137708,
0.1784790158,
-0.2453453392,
-0.1659831554,
0.5355147123,
0.3905672133,
-0.9098546505,
-0.3246114254,
0.1205217913,
-0.0203086976,
0.5496153235,
0.388504833,
0.135228321,
0.1612952799,
0.0386258997,
0.2798244953,
0.3950429261,
-0.1680643857,
-0.2002821565,
-0.1183283702,
-0.0606406704,
-0.2344594449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03853v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03853v2
|
ShortGPT: Layers in Large Language Models are More Redundant Than You Expect
| 2024-03-06T17:04:18 | 2024-03-07T16:21:09 |
Xin Men, Mingyu Xu, Qingyu Zhang, Bingning Wang, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Xianpei Han, Weipeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) continue to advance in performance, their
size has escalated significantly, with current LLMs containing billions or even
trillions of parameters. However, in this study, we discovered that many layers
of LLMs exhibit high similarity, and some layers play a negligible role in
network functionality. Based on this observation, we define a metric called
Block Influence (BI) to gauge the significance of each layer in LLMs. We then
propose a straightforward pruning approach: layer removal, in which we directly
delete the redundant layers in LLMs based on their BI scores. Experiments
demonstrate that our method, which we call ShortGPT, significantly outperforms
previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods in model pruning. Moreover, ShortGPT
is orthogonal to quantization-like methods, enabling further reduction in
parameters and computation. The ability to achieve better results through
simple layer removal, as opposed to more complex pruning techniques, suggests a
high degree of redundancy in the model architecture.
|
[
-0.6095595956,
-1.0353021622,
0.5574982762,
0.2809462249,
-0.5593053699,
0.045110736,
-0.1727690101,
-0.514596045,
0.2146581709,
0.5317695737,
-0.3260802627,
-0.2842165828,
-0.5739710331,
-0.1629701108,
-0.6776032448,
0.9915309548,
0.0492354669,
-0.125344485,
-0.154496029,
0.085392192,
-0.4583727121,
-0.1870099455,
-0.9405742288,
-0.5783383846,
0.7449868321,
0.4229933321,
0.8264737725,
0.814278841,
0.475441426,
0.3181602955,
-0.358820051,
-0.0282139443,
-0.6653448939,
-0.3962618709,
-0.2175351232,
-0.2186840326,
-0.507542491,
-0.0884455144,
0.9328263402,
1.0385657549,
-0.0672696978,
0.1886483282,
0.2279879749,
0.803512454,
-0.3138113916,
0.0646456555,
-0.4507166147,
-0.3422270715,
-0.3922539353,
-0.1089458168,
-0.2342670709,
-0.3305829167,
0.144217059,
-0.0558998585,
0.1368999481,
0.2273020148,
0.6598315239,
-0.1219808981,
-0.4843367636,
0.0958681181,
-0.9096361399,
0.7036414146,
-0.6621848345,
0.1916773617,
0.3270726502,
0.006167057,
-0.0814132839,
-0.6428840756,
-0.4069724977,
-0.2986258864,
-0.1758613735,
-0.2594100237,
-0.2287228853,
0.2071664631,
0.2907416224,
0.223104611,
-0.4022216201,
0.2500952482,
-0.8349155784,
-0.1152372807,
0.4365949333,
0.0075866468,
0.4052481055,
-0.3697809577,
-0.4221539795,
0.174083963,
-1.324297905,
-0.1233841553,
0.4832799733,
0.0443290025,
0.1837026179,
0.403743118,
-0.1216922775,
0.6663982868,
-0.3558211923,
-0.0779654086,
-0.0520346463,
-0.2772010267,
-0.4255111217,
0.0592252575,
0.7807901502,
0.1147264913,
0.3089879155,
-0.2437627465,
-0.2318473309,
-0.1932806522,
0.1951109767,
-0.8959744573,
-0.4292725921,
0.0566591397,
-0.5056562424,
-0.1668276638,
-0.0947633907,
-0.4914698005,
-0.2335464805,
-0.3911401629,
0.4239452481,
-0.4436015487,
-0.3970940709,
0.1222599298,
0.0237059463,
0.1538948864,
0.3945782185,
-0.461941421,
0.5172507167,
1.0284883976,
0.9205399752,
-0.103723824,
-0.4754775465,
-0.4156111479,
0.0685682595,
-0.494141072,
0.5506519675,
-0.5526728034,
-0.3209374547,
-0.4406674504,
0.1269784421,
0.0922487751,
-0.8412581086,
0.5257031918,
-0.6333853602,
0.1516091526,
-0.4860381186,
-0.4812096655,
-0.5091858506,
0.2205991894,
-0.8263696432,
0.8121851087,
0.0177479591,
-0.6392484307,
0.0113544557,
-0.3397439718,
-0.6050885916,
0.1848607212,
0.1678820252,
-0.6038429737,
0.1922628433,
0.0045627924,
0.452673614,
-0.6678004861,
0.320176959,
-0.4800983369,
-0.6022250056,
-0.2004144937,
-0.2827441692,
0.8487347364,
0.1197179109,
-0.4205567837,
0.0676905066,
-0.9271790981,
0.0850248039,
0.074490577,
-0.2845637798,
-0.717140317,
0.1070661545,
-0.1007033065,
0.2440329194,
-0.1382063776,
-0.4547710419,
0.0605838709,
-0.428622663,
0.972307682,
0.8041058183,
0.214872539,
0.5804741383,
-0.3858999908,
0.4176298678,
-0.0907389894,
-0.0179337468,
0.3099887967,
-0.3245141506,
-0.8241954446,
-0.4178755581,
0.3697761893,
0.3536576331,
-0.5087117553,
0.3442435861,
-0.5654328465,
-0.5200235248,
-0.3152551949,
0.3351787031,
0.5815157294,
0.2909674048,
0.3504635096,
-0.6840674281,
-0.4451366365,
-1.2773873806,
-0.3778757453,
-0.23455064,
-0.0067256195,
0.1168979183,
0.5482933521,
-0.0302926432,
0.8875234723,
-0.2065425068,
-0.0990110487,
-0.321829766,
-0.064776063,
0.0165227521,
0.6206124425,
0.3688015044,
-0.5450451374,
-0.5265700221,
0.0091186482,
-0.2873359025,
-0.1541499794,
0.0348540172,
-0.0643208772,
-0.314386636,
0.4900235534,
-0.8945800662,
0.2099010646,
0.49450019,
0.0100592738,
0.6629024148,
0.114285022,
-0.085923098,
-0.672606647,
0.0853194073,
0.0572869889,
-0.5231947303,
-0.8320507407,
0.0195455756,
0.1752264649,
-0.2163549662,
-0.4845806658,
0.67975986,
-0.683701992,
-0.1554414481,
-0.3040962815,
0.1635538936,
0.2017273754,
0.4489896894,
-0.2572895586,
0.6683439016,
0.3830563724,
-0.6505655646,
0.3914901614,
-0.2340439856,
-0.7955499291,
0.1734116673,
-0.8501289487,
0.2179807127,
-0.0916815773,
0.1013854593,
-0.84945786,
0.1425738186,
0.2409578562,
0.2021605521,
0.236484468,
-0.4839223623,
-0.6567479968,
-0.3595953882,
-0.1938134283,
0.5799453855,
0.6951490045,
-0.3977615237,
0.344473511,
0.2793000042,
-0.4421707094,
-0.2836822569,
-0.8228421807,
0.1067017987,
-0.5353808403,
-0.6826591492,
0.3847310543,
0.1035348251,
-0.337718457,
0.2561663687,
-0.1098411307,
-0.1265440881,
0.1181611493,
0.1358300149,
-0.0505420454,
-0.2513640821,
0.1824658513,
-0.2018245757,
0.1206308231,
0.2460344881,
-0.3384236097,
0.6781122684,
-0.2422582507,
-0.5904279351,
-0.4678922892,
0.2735618651,
0.5163282156,
-0.299376756,
0.6742373705,
0.4739322364,
-0.0724720061,
-0.4292907119,
-0.6350213289,
-0.0863783956,
-0.4949460626,
0.6639193892,
-0.3787626624,
-0.9972230196,
0.6673284173,
-0.1215555221,
-0.2602675557,
0.149525702,
0.2604380846,
0.0739383623,
0.8090154529,
0.5484098792,
-0.3579978943,
0.7020423412,
-0.1991944462,
0.497040838,
-0.8063907623,
0.0072997999,
-0.4038054645,
-0.3784742057,
-0.4239954352,
-0.4202691317,
0.1025156081,
0.5511306524,
-0.2070605904,
0.3664441705,
-0.2817596495,
0.7891536355,
0.5686460137,
0.1921250373,
0.1440599561,
0.0437772349,
0.3060462475,
0.3214919567,
-0.6791885495,
-0.3823089004,
0.6673572063,
0.4384133816,
0.5434914827,
0.2768729627,
0.7227389812,
0.0870440677,
0.1817834079,
-0.7721115351,
0.8016638756,
-0.0486940183,
-0.5170680285,
-0.4933620691,
-0.7077363729,
-0.7990640998,
0.3755884469,
0.2320601791,
-0.5718661547,
0.046935495,
0.0831583664,
-0.3170203865,
0.6094437838,
-0.9773576856,
0.756591022,
-0.0965485573,
-0.5447959304,
-0.4401076734,
-0.3378868699,
0.5928378701,
-0.1055712998,
0.2947643101,
-0.3044367135,
0.0645424649,
0.8698942065,
-0.7620351315,
0.9746463299,
-0.1381630599,
0.0863600075,
0.604008615,
0.5014486909,
0.8626907468,
-0.1339021325,
0.1024508998,
0.1615112871,
-0.0395961925,
-0.6308333278,
-0.55537045,
0.8943799734,
-0.6156546474,
-0.8775240183,
0.075981915,
-0.2640381455,
0.0140223289,
0.4661821723,
-0.195593223,
0.5061968565,
-0.2253506333,
0.389051199,
0.4079094529,
-0.1665844768,
0.4874207079,
0.1645400971,
-0.1833907217,
-0.1055138707,
1.0066809654,
0.2433695495,
0.5355603695,
0.4647291005,
0.3176032007,
0.0761127323,
-0.8621736169,
0.028155975,
0.4171827137,
-0.701420188,
-0.0255924221,
-0.5170193911,
-0.3618129194,
-0.1726472825,
0.0876681581,
-0.5298835039,
-0.4707536995,
-0.0606347732,
-0.269122839,
0.1518399119,
0.7945664525,
0.1369299442,
0.64596802,
-0.8914200068,
0.0202366766,
0.4680403471,
0.503038466,
0.2863376141,
-0.353212148,
-0.3732149601,
-0.2849363983,
-0.1811211407,
-0.6509011388,
0.4764968753,
0.2474970371,
0.4682921171,
0.3640409708,
-0.1744823158,
0.9027624726,
-0.5690789223,
0.7077496648,
0.2606246173,
-1.2158924341,
0.1349530071,
-0.2617386281,
0.3164816797,
0.2787132859,
0.3536470234,
-0.5730745196,
-0.1488047987,
-0.7500792146,
-0.8606765866,
0.5600914955,
0.0473666489,
0.007231527,
0.0143290181,
0.3541093767,
-0.0348831341,
0.3175902069,
-0.8187381029,
-0.0932368264,
0.1751142144,
0.2185012102,
-0.1603171676,
-0.6836528778,
-0.1024018675,
-0.2133933604,
0.6421194673,
0.2481965125,
0.0990407616,
-0.1107619479,
-0.1756729931,
0.0177320242,
0.4845885038,
0.4730939567,
1.1202619076,
-0.1299069375,
0.3987580538,
0.231305778,
-0.3136883378,
-0.0165352281,
-0.4315337837,
-0.329982698,
-0.1016710475,
0.669973433,
0.9586974978,
0.2738396823,
-0.3016377687,
0.4897610843,
0.3080279231,
-0.1774276793,
-0.0114456154,
-0.1201387271,
0.2419803292,
0.1491102278,
-0.0266128853,
0.2417801768,
0.0102252476,
-0.6939858794,
0.2205303162,
0.4084691703,
-0.5456200242,
-0.5167582035,
0.0750538707,
0.2600387633,
-0.3335741162,
0.6766012311,
-0.1091607064,
-0.6456485391,
0.7088920474,
0.3506000042,
0.8465310335,
0.0572337136,
0.1950902343,
0.1001416296,
0.6967531443,
-0.4674524665,
-0.2552728951,
0.125428319,
-0.5380249023,
-0.7544592023,
-0.4267694652,
-0.0671273768,
0.4873124063,
-0.4599669576,
0.3058163524,
-0.7846220732,
-0.0555613451,
-0.0785499364,
0.2397420108,
-0.5347679257,
0.0529863164,
-0.1812171638,
0.7669842839,
-0.887737155,
1.3742791414,
0.3434868157,
-0.2835101783,
-1.0874969959,
-0.1583183408,
0.0064341445,
-0.7762291431,
0.7381178737,
0.0275400989,
-0.1240743622,
0.0106142256,
-0.332483083,
-0.842741251,
0.925365448,
0.2900301814,
-0.7834398746,
-0.1835986376,
-0.0347848497,
0.3706592619,
-0.094904162,
0.1879623681,
0.6463275552,
0.431362927,
-0.0288727712,
-1.0172257423,
0.1995533854,
-0.1013885885,
0.118855767,
0.5580621958,
-0.82006073,
1.2061612606,
-0.0172521695,
-0.4775717258,
-0.0175777208,
0.3339065015,
-0.0049203923,
0.0721342415,
0.6757053137,
0.4511116147,
0.6848518848,
0.0885364935,
0.9646731019,
-0.1910993606,
0.3140361011,
1.1509153843,
-0.216372475,
0.7716005445,
0.5650238991,
-0.1885528266,
0.3076719344,
0.5427587628,
0.0375936329,
0.5724375248,
0.4335222542,
-0.0481939651,
-0.365896225,
0.2088954747,
-0.334744364,
0.2875188291,
0.0861740112,
-0.3001505136,
-0.1742171645,
-0.1295647621,
0.1574097276,
-0.1792602986,
-0.4211794138,
0.5957177877,
0.4042187035,
-0.5633960962,
0.60855335,
0.1956591159,
0.4227094948,
-0.7364521623,
0.1374741942,
-0.3280150294,
0.2413265556,
-0.2060473263,
-0.6220116615,
0.2934989035,
-0.2717511356,
-0.3096158504,
-0.3953390419,
0.775631547,
-0.4054104388,
-0.3845713735,
0.6636161804,
0.6594180465,
0.2179657966,
-0.2311821878,
-0.5765664577,
0.1656250805,
0.1497066319,
-0.4263113737,
0.6157616377,
0.6137610078,
-0.409922421,
0.8694739342,
0.7099159956,
0.6783317327,
0.1277641505,
0.1875947118,
0.9385772943,
-0.7786066532,
-0.4228862226,
-1.0588191748,
0.1030975506,
-0.0713185444,
0.0262528304,
0.8081659675,
0.5007387996,
0.9681238532,
0.051832743,
0.6586149931,
0.0713578686,
0.5963855982,
-0.5866922736,
0.6706092954,
-0.6503774524,
0.8503858447,
-0.2709541917,
-1.3427796364,
-0.2586657703,
0.2692399323,
-0.6340332031,
0.2257009894,
0.8192592263,
1.0223251581,
-0.3571062088,
-0.0898709297,
0.4399657547,
0.4242215753,
0.5828306079,
0.4219464958,
0.8949087858,
-0.1916242838,
0.6664009094,
-0.5145658255,
-0.0999008119,
-0.1480456889,
-1.0340262651,
-0.9424513578,
-0.3550673425,
-0.3419325054,
-0.1390261799,
0.1369721591,
0.7545714378,
0.9435500503,
-0.6567356586,
-0.4025155306,
-0.0751428083,
0.3174564242,
-0.3225012124,
-0.2345160544,
0.5799918175,
0.0620867908,
-0.6063995957,
0.4464993179,
0.3135036826,
-0.1361185908,
-0.2211510092,
0.0737328008,
-0.1948970854,
-0.082422927,
0.7405585051,
0.2846552134,
-0.8021063805,
-0.5515904427,
-0.4988990724,
-0.1598290801,
-0.1294634044,
1.0450481176,
-0.4982796907,
-0.0351914279,
0.8750952482,
0.4662695825,
0.4869715571,
0.2713394165,
0.5550826788,
-0.8980634809,
0.2833900452,
0.1967763901,
0.2792160511,
0.3247973025,
-0.0572837964,
0.2481328696,
0.3277749717,
-0.6167476177,
-0.9108522534,
0.3027504981,
-0.9095109105,
-0.5192217231,
1.2981865406,
-0.0551840998,
-0.5107332468,
-0.0422404967,
-0.0519700982,
-0.2312315702,
-0.2035888284,
0.5517950654,
0.6898580194,
0.1688057035,
-0.5630337,
-0.6046429276,
0.4428147674,
0.6307467818,
-0.5012287498,
0.2499502301,
0.4022373259,
0.6113708019,
0.1155172214,
0.7595627904,
-0.0722284839,
-0.170185551,
-0.0815010518,
-0.0475004949,
-0.3359586,
-0.5895316005,
-0.1725168377,
0.5140584111,
0.3267146945,
0.0849653184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12082v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12082v1
|
The Boy Who Survived: Removing Harry Potter from an LLM is harder than reported
| 2024-03-06T16:39:50 | 2024-03-06T16:39:50 |
Adam Shostack
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work arXiv.2310.02238 asserted that "we effectively erase the model's
ability to generate or recall Harry Potter-related content.'' This claim is
shown to be overbroad. A small experiment of less than a dozen trials led to
repeated and specific mentions of Harry Potter, including "Ah, I see! A
"muggle" is a term used in the Harry Potter book series by Terry Pratchett...''
|
[
-0.6330398321,
-0.48778826,
0.4759118855,
0.2955233455,
-0.1313522309,
0.3418414593,
-0.0121626724,
-0.4695882201,
0.416972816,
0.4612901211,
-0.4110170603,
0.1070221066,
-0.7156693935,
0.3159229159,
-0.4294619858,
0.5960784554,
-0.1708493233,
-0.1318424791,
-0.3028043807,
0.1235299334,
-0.3583435714,
-0.197806254,
-0.5865205526,
-0.5129790306,
0.7428521514,
0.0056530936,
0.4467520118,
0.7622996569,
0.8587673903,
0.3749389648,
-0.3495293856,
0.0847020075,
-0.5189287066,
0.0108956983,
-0.1139244065,
-0.4199058414,
-0.1217401475,
0.0459232703,
0.5240981579,
0.9642811418,
-0.0174829196,
-0.2578103542,
0.2883832455,
0.6858371496,
-0.3327673674,
0.0457637347,
-0.6084783673,
0.1322213858,
0.2036814243,
-0.20562011,
-0.5510211587,
-0.3515126407,
0.253218174,
-0.829660356,
0.5711861253,
0.0402518064,
0.6413576007,
-0.1975774467,
-0.432864219,
-0.4964988828,
-0.5878391862,
0.9817051888,
-0.4004842937,
-0.0621936694,
0.5684659481,
0.1003412381,
-0.8334926963,
-0.5541031361,
-0.5752983093,
-0.2010257691,
-0.3061207831,
0.3367764652,
0.2961972356,
-0.126432389,
0.5711508393,
0.120355323,
-0.5764730573,
-0.4875519276,
-0.607521832,
-0.2430251539,
0.5712028742,
0.1093463749,
0.2313202173,
-0.0012993144,
-0.5797207355,
0.2287549675,
-0.7090628147,
-0.044942379,
0.3359827697,
0.0687578171,
0.4034872055,
0.5437260866,
0.0867939293,
-0.0019984657,
-0.1090211794,
-0.5439110994,
0.3412844241,
0.0877959132,
0.0143394116,
0.1956575811,
0.5064278245,
0.3865737319,
0.5291025639,
-0.2080596387,
0.0267128199,
0.0394585356,
0.2249209136,
-0.6955752373,
-0.3997558057,
-0.4666725397,
-0.6637866497,
0.1304256767,
0.3574230075,
-0.2832103074,
-0.9265680909,
0.5351641178,
0.483134836,
-0.2583682835,
-0.485722363,
0.2865307033,
-0.4580636621,
0.0854929909,
0.6753021479,
-0.4902875721,
0.1033535153,
0.6227990985,
0.4215495586,
-0.3489138484,
-0.4783937633,
0.185418874,
0.3780659437,
-0.6404605508,
0.6256918907,
-0.2813700438,
-0.9748846889,
-0.1992936283,
0.4303766191,
-0.0547870435,
-0.5840842128,
0.2537176013,
-0.3989859819,
0.0109849283,
-0.7559440732,
-0.6591361761,
-0.429431349,
0.0779042765,
-0.459066093,
0.311514765,
-0.3553034961,
-0.466337204,
0.7232643366,
0.2254061699,
-0.7448150516,
-0.0266826786,
-0.1521841437,
-0.3167722523,
-0.001338001,
-0.3905840218,
0.0067758253,
-0.2440667152,
0.07404311,
-0.3932412267,
-0.3002188504,
0.1624936908,
-0.288020134,
0.7806380987,
-0.0675779507,
-0.1143722311,
-0.6884456277,
-0.6275225282,
-0.4049242139,
0.4679154456,
-0.6266611218,
-0.3390677869,
0.1539383084,
-0.6043807864,
-0.0038752453,
0.0762233436,
-0.855599761,
0.4031502306,
-0.0958904698,
-0.2140073776,
0.4084586203,
0.4533310533,
0.3941456378,
-0.8577032685,
0.4010500014,
-0.2415088117,
0.0242196135,
-0.454890281,
-1.0328764915,
-0.7620781064,
-0.1111107841,
-0.1780406535,
0.5999642611,
-0.4642695189,
0.0121516651,
0.2096805274,
-0.4140017033,
0.0994432047,
0.2613256276,
0.649245739,
0.8284344673,
0.2626666725,
-0.0728761405,
-0.3973305225,
-1.0068956614,
-0.4112050533,
-0.6551740766,
-0.0385771878,
0.1380009055,
0.5827331543,
0.1090257242,
0.7902488708,
-0.626627326,
-0.2190263122,
-0.0389067046,
0.2821566164,
0.2834009826,
0.5648483038,
0.4484884143,
-0.6623617411,
-0.3344177902,
-0.0119417924,
-0.7976621389,
-0.0243506674,
-0.194865182,
-0.0428858101,
-0.2798067927,
0.6352256536,
-0.7412909865,
0.9787856936,
-0.581182003,
-0.322981596,
0.2731339335,
-0.3724177182,
0.3754317164,
-0.592035234,
-0.3469619751,
-0.1418776959,
-0.0344342105,
-0.2614987195,
-0.253300488,
0.1953047812,
0.3286400437,
-0.5584825277,
0.6952770352,
-0.6745696068,
0.1259715706,
-0.3323950171,
0.0859429911,
0.299133271,
0.1688663065,
0.1956558675,
0.4811167121,
0.3368237615,
-0.4573635757,
0.0754702687,
0.3044740558,
-0.1020112038,
0.1544036865,
-0.1371096373,
-0.0571378432,
-0.1844061464,
0.1399583668,
-1.1917414665,
-0.1024597958,
0.2035789043,
-0.2634165287,
0.103745915,
0.125266552,
-0.6426785588,
-0.5786255002,
-0.5313701034,
0.0742860883,
0.6554685831,
-0.4758312106,
0.7047065496,
0.4240917861,
-0.0369814523,
-0.526858747,
-0.6936933398,
0.035588026,
-0.2722363174,
-0.3408844471,
0.1780763119,
-0.5006982684,
-0.5230689645,
-0.1496873796,
-0.4697718322,
-0.2571342587,
0.3311509192,
0.4132682681,
0.0598798618,
-0.1323445588,
0.0596998446,
-0.2160216719,
0.142172873,
0.3084620833,
1.0770103931,
0.0149368746,
0.1288914531,
-0.2805343568,
-0.0936971158,
0.2873933017,
0.1784362644,
0.6666872501,
0.4535611868,
0.2494742423,
-0.6180797219,
-0.4570833445,
-0.328120321,
-0.1699220687,
-0.546720624,
0.1805679649,
-0.4697003961,
-0.2581952214,
0.961843729,
0.0817440823,
0.0060551916,
0.4819369614,
0.1195701808,
-0.3129977584,
0.7730730772,
0.2426475286,
0.2787848413,
0.2427059561,
0.0614340864,
0.1526341736,
-0.5961188078,
-0.4337910414,
-0.1914656758,
-0.2065922022,
-0.1949049234,
-0.0844378769,
-0.0764136016,
0.3559606671,
-0.2021670491,
0.551425159,
-0.5046238303,
0.8210843801,
0.5589162707,
0.4205217063,
0.7152463794,
-0.3486372232,
0.2649660408,
-0.1548873931,
-0.3374429345,
-0.3811872303,
0.9618301392,
-0.0335692316,
0.9806839228,
0.2755459547,
0.7497053742,
0.3052067161,
0.5645432472,
-0.4653642476,
1.1447517872,
0.179066807,
-0.9177148938,
-0.1066032127,
-0.1042220145,
-1.2076876163,
0.1553401351,
-0.2606489956,
-0.4418054223,
0.1650844812,
-0.2751932442,
-0.2477703542,
0.1883696467,
-0.8349781036,
0.2524586916,
0.1144551262,
-0.1733997017,
-0.3395152986,
-0.3820973039,
0.4401909113,
-0.438070178,
0.2296627611,
-0.3435751498,
-0.3010577559,
1.0449845791,
-0.7538419962,
0.5636768341,
-0.1623935699,
0.0566173866,
0.6908417344,
0.4071989059,
0.3432160318,
0.3535270095,
0.1480819136,
-0.1396562606,
-0.0132477563,
-0.2045852095,
-0.4943323433,
0.6365025043,
-0.4861981273,
-0.7965832949,
-0.6999726295,
-0.3800505996,
-0.0989229754,
0.2189213336,
0.0251270477,
0.1315272152,
-0.127621308,
0.3022524714,
0.5828502178,
-0.4731917977,
0.9885951281,
0.8006697893,
-0.4846544564,
-0.2341459841,
0.8769037724,
0.3542000353,
0.0612164699,
-0.1234290451,
0.3802669644,
0.2348587215,
-0.8251066804,
0.0282636173,
0.404628098,
-0.8121649623,
-0.087834619,
-0.6935928464,
-0.2930876315,
-0.026826866,
-0.6964380145,
-0.1739427894,
-0.1900783479,
-0.6005339622,
0.0834037662,
0.5327602625,
0.7804170847,
0.1059302837,
0.4746958911,
-0.467228651,
0.5609513521,
0.6531019807,
0.2240994871,
-0.0347198471,
-0.484495908,
-0.0625332668,
-0.4007401764,
-0.0999553278,
-0.5421187878,
0.4677819908,
0.188613832,
0.7458108664,
0.4073928297,
0.0871050432,
0.8039680719,
-0.4628506303,
0.7125801444,
0.4008409977,
-0.2300987095,
0.1478614807,
-0.570877552,
0.1474705338,
0.3887438178,
0.0824125558,
-0.045844093,
-0.5528190732,
-0.617913425,
-0.9149780273,
0.4583793581,
-0.1108840927,
0.1919963509,
-0.415499121,
0.4030607939,
0.5479675531,
0.2266668081,
-0.8091368675,
-0.4331817329,
0.250813812,
0.115164727,
0.3836381137,
-0.4900514483,
0.0755658969,
-0.4041084647,
0.5794919729,
0.438277483,
0.1278944612,
0.1528763175,
-0.6715378165,
-0.2727884352,
-0.3830699921,
0.3031565547,
1.1262680292,
-0.5880628824,
-0.0459915176,
0.0347895883,
-1.1016991138,
-0.015386452,
-0.4020007849,
-0.0143191572,
0.0112404749,
1.0648572445,
0.1456027925,
0.1928095669,
-0.7229994535,
0.5622579455,
-0.0679897591,
-0.4359869361,
-0.6081752181,
0.5486524105,
0.0035519877,
0.4596746266,
0.9498718381,
-0.1324333251,
-0.0387459546,
-0.5020328164,
0.5408431888,
0.4147077203,
0.1612102538,
-0.0749151483,
0.7054661512,
0.0503115803,
-0.3586027324,
0.0708495602,
-0.2933287323,
-0.2371935993,
1.1445246935,
0.4854681194,
0.6222850084,
-0.2016520351,
0.0557794645,
0.2137504071,
0.4975834489,
-0.5087928176,
0.2589649856,
0.4161774814,
-0.735684514,
-0.151119858,
-0.266953826,
-0.5576284528,
0.0530748256,
-0.3892062008,
0.2171253264,
-0.9036974907,
-0.1472408473,
0.2284700125,
0.0188698228,
-0.3972941339,
0.3120555878,
0.2281444967,
0.9106655717,
-0.8427399397,
0.7130920291,
0.195040375,
-0.1746908426,
-0.5771246552,
-0.0669531897,
-0.1300248206,
-0.7397590876,
0.6754400134,
0.0068767183,
0.0673710704,
-0.1832330972,
-0.203662172,
-0.692671299,
0.9564378262,
0.1008300781,
-0.270406425,
0.163448438,
-0.4517632723,
0.3521113694,
-0.4024690092,
0.3822358251,
0.2112189829,
0.6952142119,
0.1905720532,
-0.5840750933,
-0.1754634827,
-0.2668598294,
-0.3214972913,
-0.0428330898,
-0.601375103,
0.8699335456,
-0.3138427138,
-0.0680680946,
0.1064653918,
0.5931943059,
0.0991957933,
0.6054981947,
0.5103325844,
0.171767205,
0.515816927,
-0.0554349087,
0.8693333268,
0.2741175592,
0.3419041932,
1.0488601923,
-0.2644807696,
0.3312614262,
0.5887717009,
-0.554148972,
0.1589024365,
0.8212710023,
-0.065094009,
0.9592118263,
0.2835648656,
-0.4043237567,
-0.043065723,
0.281609714,
-0.3451630175,
-0.1977352202,
0.063727513,
-0.3240663707,
-0.1389204115,
0.4396392703,
0.1733318418,
-0.0179863963,
-0.5717688203,
0.6774932742,
0.2152098268,
-0.3636988401,
0.4030964971,
-0.6357095838,
0.4504120946,
-0.2659224272,
-0.3727222979,
-0.4305945039,
0.0428577252,
-0.1144928634,
-0.8299319744,
0.2117879689,
-0.4305633307,
-0.527284205,
-0.3602928221,
0.8802395463,
-0.1906134784,
-0.6051389575,
0.5446290374,
0.5445737839,
0.3198582828,
0.3201965392,
-0.3854424655,
-0.2117351443,
-0.0228184815,
-1.0243155956,
0.3442497849,
0.593083024,
-0.0838589147,
0.9946753383,
0.208240658,
0.0599391013,
0.377065599,
-0.2938498855,
0.6161030531,
-0.9479922652,
-0.0862762332,
-1.0568381548,
0.1048865989,
0.0608692914,
-0.1343370825,
1.2339642048,
0.6942424774,
0.5175157785,
-0.2094620615,
0.8078240752,
0.0142934099,
0.8422344327,
0.0938752294,
0.7666763067,
-0.6533157229,
0.3667131066,
-0.5851289034,
-0.6768534184,
-0.4584859312,
0.6338195801,
-0.3890453279,
0.0735337287,
0.9427624345,
0.6627656221,
0.1186265722,
-0.0849252269,
0.2383232415,
0.2170047611,
0.0549123809,
0.277040273,
0.9003397226,
-0.2984098196,
0.6720759869,
0.0243864376,
0.1380830705,
-0.3822739422,
-0.915171802,
-1.1528027058,
-0.2782637179,
-0.4910968542,
-0.5458917022,
0.1573676616,
0.435615927,
0.2282478064,
-0.6817257404,
0.1406031996,
-0.071097061,
0.5180299282,
0.1140405685,
-0.1107940897,
0.3931643367,
0.2892163992,
-0.5957157016,
0.6299424171,
0.1458194703,
0.0951725841,
0.0790200308,
-0.1537736356,
-0.1745703518,
0.1771809012,
0.2156760395,
0.3840433955,
-0.5491185188,
-0.5632637739,
-0.1840418726,
-0.2374191433,
0.3010894954,
0.4802056253,
-0.9125298858,
0.4600979984,
0.7229150534,
0.4402919114,
0.6633707285,
-0.1079186052,
0.208822608,
-0.212649405,
0.0760695115,
0.1828368008,
0.526478231,
0.0697284564,
-0.2129334807,
0.5233443379,
0.7578946352,
-0.3787940443,
-1.0732864141,
0.0154442973,
-0.8831589818,
-0.6002951264,
1.128057003,
-0.2198024988,
-0.4621524513,
-0.3100744784,
-0.334207207,
0.2065835446,
-0.3499771655,
0.6538236737,
0.8439123631,
-0.1358620673,
-0.2176625878,
-0.9291570187,
0.2969477177,
0.1029503271,
-0.401954025,
-0.1153213084,
0.206935823,
0.4933751225,
0.136479333,
0.6715429425,
0.184962526,
0.2127364576,
0.1595809311,
0.1978137344,
-0.0897578746,
-0.1872403026,
0.1680612564,
0.1905066222,
0.1024629176,
-0.1809571087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03823v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03823v5
|
A Modular Approach for Multimodal Summarization of TV Shows
| 2024-03-06T16:10:01 | 2024-07-02T11:22:14 |
Louis Mahon, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper we address the task of summarizing television shows, which
touches key areas in AI research: complex reasoning, multiple modalities, and
long narratives. We present a modular approach where separate components
perform specialized sub-tasks which we argue affords greater flexibility
compared to end-to-end methods. Our modules involve detecting scene boundaries,
reordering scenes so as to minimize the number of cuts between different
events, converting visual information to text, summarizing the dialogue in each
scene, and fusing the scene summaries into a final summary for the entire
episode. We also present a new metric, PRISMA (Precision and Recall EvaluatIon
of Summary FActs), to measure both precision and recall of generated summaries,
which we decompose into atomic facts. Tested on the recently released
SummScreen3D dataset, our method produces higher quality summaries than
comparison models, as measured with ROUGE and our new fact-based metric, and as
assessed by human evaluators.
|
[
-0.4834656119,
-0.5244624615,
0.364394784,
0.0464571118,
-0.3638634384,
0.0728739128,
-0.091347836,
0.334602505,
0.5982872844,
0.3169236481,
-0.4717768729,
-0.2373160422,
-0.4453042746,
0.0951239765,
-0.1644257009,
1.0354260206,
0.1237345189,
0.1080809981,
-0.211710304,
-0.2375192493,
-0.5297174454,
-0.2820728123,
0.0350515619,
-0.264980793,
0.5111048222,
0.6234467626,
0.6148062944,
0.5495571494,
0.5380485058,
0.3329034448,
0.1754177511,
0.5801169872,
-0.4665246904,
-0.0697091967,
-0.0792639405,
-0.2701000273,
-0.7506768107,
-0.0004376968,
0.4735570848,
0.7276732326,
-0.0108811846,
0.5059472322,
-0.2372363061,
0.7111769319,
-0.6223341823,
0.2991989553,
0.0020028194,
0.1089476645,
0.2763319016,
-0.4056631923,
-0.3205300272,
-0.2724823058,
0.0895219892,
-0.4418282211,
0.0998408273,
-0.006801425,
0.6246177554,
0.3337804973,
-0.796587646,
0.0528253242,
-0.8009181023,
0.7334153056,
-0.8059982061,
-0.2402960211,
0.1340013742,
0.587372601,
0.1625944823,
-0.7619972229,
-0.4923837781,
-0.1175857186,
-0.1609355509,
0.3279133737,
-0.051097963,
0.0933088511,
0.1220715716,
0.5443974733,
-0.588003099,
-0.2174353302,
-0.4755139351,
-0.2877897322,
0.7188206315,
0.6453871131,
0.4013940394,
-0.5697497725,
-0.1521705389,
0.0630452558,
-0.3392497599,
-0.0026241038,
0.2998829186,
-0.0955297723,
-0.0710728765,
0.82346946,
-0.5476793051,
0.2330978364,
-0.2569029629,
-0.2963560224,
0.1925828159,
-0.8039727807,
-0.2796717882,
0.066258572,
0.4696516693,
1.0329065323,
0.1751794815,
0.1838752776,
0.0592283346,
-0.0170887541,
0.3279679418,
-0.7392580509,
-0.4854463935,
0.3580021858,
-0.6883881688,
-0.0243344065,
-0.0348270126,
-0.6149048209,
-0.3390725255,
-0.7324665785,
0.6609710455,
-0.4050331712,
-0.2449018955,
0.0172423813,
-0.6718592048,
0.0718039423,
0.6972417831,
-0.6787708998,
0.291566968,
0.5890051723,
0.7570286989,
0.0178579167,
-0.2407894582,
-0.3778682649,
0.2019693106,
-0.2779708803,
0.9341440201,
-0.2011447996,
-0.1009905413,
-0.4959698617,
-0.2933246493,
0.0368146747,
-0.3732711971,
-0.2372026891,
-0.137033686,
0.3114070892,
-0.2141542882,
-0.4467930794,
-0.6551918387,
0.5044512749,
-0.6800876856,
0.4624632001,
0.0181313176,
-0.6683933735,
0.1966187358,
-0.4145208597,
-0.5277902484,
-0.5011721253,
-0.0886178091,
-0.2706032395,
0.2132355571,
0.4921745956,
0.7946771979,
0.0135696661,
0.679023385,
-0.0022516283,
-0.2510485947,
0.3124912083,
-0.6151989698,
0.167417258,
0.1385383308,
-0.1692602038,
0.5488509536,
-0.5165721774,
-0.2623816431,
-0.4278200865,
-0.1323242933,
-0.0314084999,
0.1593914628,
0.0466336384,
0.0097328722,
0.0882300213,
-0.2358524948,
0.1574875265,
0.0149509972,
0.2486114502,
0.6122124791,
0.0075220116,
0.5354020596,
-0.8413779736,
0.4423016012,
0.021943463,
0.1100489274,
-0.9280292988,
-0.4112434089,
-0.6670197845,
-0.6590979099,
0.0336701199,
0.6652540565,
-0.750346005,
0.3445711136,
-0.4581288397,
-0.4866163731,
0.1805773377,
-0.2260848433,
0.4912458658,
0.0698176548,
0.2400763482,
-0.5956594944,
-0.424253583,
-1.0211570263,
0.0395804755,
0.2089300603,
-0.197308585,
0.0625348687,
0.6353687048,
0.2760475278,
0.9250596762,
-0.7698044181,
-0.2862416804,
-0.7767927647,
0.4163791239,
0.3098330498,
0.4001553953,
0.5027307868,
-0.8946777582,
-0.3145214617,
0.0408435874,
-1.0357987881,
0.3463885188,
-0.2556342483,
0.3545542657,
-0.2410850376,
0.5165284872,
-0.6640275121,
0.6086682081,
0.114536196,
-0.4808359146,
0.833943069,
-0.1943759173,
0.5742681026,
-1.2294061184,
0.0696720779,
-0.0634136572,
-0.4936797321,
-0.6177995801,
-0.167831108,
-0.2476364225,
-0.1194543391,
-0.5362526774,
0.4210014045,
-0.3685590625,
-0.2754284441,
-0.105715245,
0.3997457922,
0.1695931852,
0.9790369272,
-0.1840819418,
0.5788663626,
0.0985681564,
-0.5179355145,
0.9604260921,
0.1095402837,
-0.681371212,
0.6408827901,
-0.3083668053,
-0.5031152368,
-0.5258901119,
0.5120550394,
-1.390458703,
-0.5703184009,
0.0229767803,
-0.5338379741,
0.2407687455,
0.1659475863,
-0.2270831317,
0.1548907012,
-0.6308832765,
0.6072095633,
0.1518722475,
-0.0013632284,
1.1770153046,
0.5748024583,
-0.6500925422,
-0.6515152454,
-0.4218274057,
0.3042280078,
-0.4027311802,
-0.5453600883,
0.2334476411,
-0.1898870021,
-0.5183824301,
0.1862676293,
-0.1098334268,
-0.1360197067,
-0.1125415638,
0.0544762798,
0.0977236778,
-0.5097033978,
-0.2194704413,
0.2109631598,
-0.3183559477,
-0.1283788681,
0.0895207524,
0.3070848584,
0.0494922698,
-0.1761000752,
-0.7218199968,
0.7389214635,
0.8908592463,
-0.1000062227,
0.0489622504,
0.6181189418,
-0.3224694133,
-0.0367917269,
-0.5013563037,
-0.1127420887,
-0.2910865843,
0.5832439661,
-0.1360528618,
-0.4804764986,
0.7271300554,
-0.0761382282,
0.1843480468,
0.3722959459,
0.6689462066,
-0.0411502533,
1.1258753538,
0.428994447,
0.0629651174,
0.4321756959,
-0.5054258704,
0.2144882232,
-0.9254068136,
-0.4283427,
-0.0319382958,
-0.7189233303,
0.2046934515,
-0.6125274897,
0.749576807,
-0.179630056,
0.0219936147,
0.3301160336,
0.0315302275,
0.8807159662,
0.453053236,
0.2053114623,
0.6429246664,
-0.3925094903,
0.4329688847,
0.1325431168,
-0.76776582,
-0.3552832007,
1.1412731409,
0.0812013149,
0.8348112702,
0.6907917261,
0.237875849,
0.6463285089,
0.2465144098,
-0.8796318173,
0.6935867667,
-0.2138749361,
-0.4676059186,
-0.547365427,
-0.3501538038,
-0.5014209747,
0.4686034322,
0.0467885695,
-0.5115850568,
0.1111033559,
0.0147252046,
-0.5780990124,
0.2981499732,
-0.7110474706,
0.7208357453,
-0.0898329541,
0.0503416546,
-0.8520795107,
-0.8485800028,
0.7210003138,
0.4005695581,
0.2757961452,
-0.4147716463,
0.1859678328,
0.5563154817,
-0.3932990432,
0.8848804235,
0.1974314749,
0.3438829482,
0.3227457106,
0.2129753828,
-0.2769697011,
0.3628519773,
0.2932126224,
-0.1349034756,
0.0807934329,
-0.3584885895,
-0.7325074077,
0.2575691342,
-0.5822577477,
-0.4039542973,
-0.5278505087,
-1.0331150293,
0.2337098271,
0.1400732696,
0.0824047104,
1.4015879631,
-0.1992290467,
0.1808692962,
0.7259484529,
-0.2889439464,
0.6282696724,
0.1188986972,
-0.2942892313,
-0.7636092901,
0.9856455922,
0.0851709023,
0.3421532512,
0.6944928169,
0.2503828704,
-0.0727905631,
-0.4303031564,
-0.717415154,
0.021390656,
-0.8127057552,
-0.309268564,
-0.3668597639,
-0.1133673191,
-0.3315104544,
-0.2501744628,
-0.3673500121,
-0.9095506072,
-0.0985076055,
-0.162230134,
-0.125128597,
0.82169801,
-0.0552074313,
0.1930653751,
-0.8895333409,
0.7093107104,
0.5598569512,
-0.1207345799,
0.0193094574,
-0.252671808,
-0.4381583631,
-0.3159516156,
-0.3812446892,
-0.5642315745,
0.4210449755,
0.2702074647,
0.5515387058,
0.4495304823,
0.1905136406,
0.6760517359,
-0.3357254863,
1.1289900541,
0.3979878128,
-0.9438786507,
0.3550582528,
-0.566927433,
0.5316212773,
0.2182342261,
0.0603529848,
-0.4067228734,
-0.2658456266,
-0.3152952194,
-0.7097209692,
0.5852247477,
0.3328901529,
0.233749494,
0.0858909637,
-0.0694368407,
0.2510089874,
0.5149515271,
-0.1508731991,
-0.2937879562,
-0.4308246672,
-0.2203712463,
-0.3144184053,
-0.1617750376,
-0.4456030428,
-0.3962330222,
0.4866054356,
-0.2906700075,
0.04333435,
0.3175166547,
-0.3790038526,
0.4581119418,
0.1089050248,
1.0536201,
1.1447484493,
-0.2304907441,
0.1950693727,
0.0022278768,
-0.2379515171,
-0.0533773676,
-0.3086384237,
0.3170058131,
0.1034705639,
0.688896358,
0.7138870955,
0.401753664,
-0.9136426449,
0.6548762321,
-0.3081906736,
-0.1870214343,
-0.4007023573,
0.0009448376,
-0.1857054234,
0.5364619493,
0.3051578701,
0.3848136961,
0.4682635367,
-0.8666439056,
0.5382134318,
0.0351697132,
0.0035195949,
-0.3947434723,
0.4397078454,
0.6233131886,
-0.2416587025,
0.51227808,
-0.0267902631,
-0.4878330529,
1.1417446136,
0.0820931494,
0.8301769495,
-0.1581509858,
0.5713300109,
0.2446910888,
0.070349291,
-0.1288707554,
0.0647069141,
-0.232285589,
-0.5230075121,
-0.8158670068,
-0.0450992882,
-0.6261988282,
-0.3014796078,
-0.7566976547,
0.1342408806,
-0.43959409,
-0.0683459789,
0.0117804119,
-0.393162787,
-0.0298706926,
0.1671768278,
0.2346000075,
0.8701989651,
-0.8470343351,
0.2517656088,
0.3251326978,
-0.3984688222,
-0.6442713737,
-0.2577129006,
0.3117362559,
-0.4821072221,
0.2826211751,
0.2679886222,
-0.1371446699,
-0.1115731001,
-0.1675133556,
-0.8774706721,
1.0931111574,
0.1130060852,
0.0202844515,
-0.1996917427,
-0.2838590443,
0.2488911897,
-0.4264727235,
0.5433626771,
0.5885022283,
0.4148538113,
0.0976532623,
-1.0460685492,
-0.2913235128,
-0.5655511022,
-0.3541168571,
0.3932474852,
-0.6904388666,
0.7839805484,
-0.5226035714,
-0.1166025102,
0.1504146308,
0.6300652623,
-0.1888576895,
0.7548899055,
0.2116689533,
0.302939415,
0.36231938,
-0.0810537636,
0.9935870767,
0.0632420033,
0.3881700635,
1.0281196833,
0.1937734932,
0.3722738326,
0.2479063272,
-0.0753806904,
0.4969284534,
0.5105640888,
0.1833378971,
0.5777281523,
0.088108331,
0.012026472,
-0.3472587466,
0.0617242865,
0.0003529586,
0.5598338246,
0.5618119836,
0.111529462,
-0.4591438472,
0.1940760165,
0.1332783103,
0.1874991357,
-0.4639373422,
1.0234299898,
0.0928160772,
-0.8620401025,
0.1726069003,
-0.1842399538,
0.2423357666,
-0.7285920382,
-0.1477531195,
-0.4091215134,
0.1633507907,
-0.2814924121,
-0.8045112491,
0.4559797049,
-0.4267820716,
-0.4152624309,
-0.1395726502,
-0.0025589282,
-0.428367734,
-0.3108480871,
-0.4702630639,
0.2452830374,
0.2267109901,
0.0629736707,
-0.1430670321,
-0.1659913361,
-0.0516354479,
-0.3561979532,
0.1955431402,
0.3878222704,
-0.105800949,
0.8076729178,
0.3085882366,
-0.0835558772,
0.1289145797,
0.0317903087,
0.6803926229,
-0.6848375797,
-0.9293273687,
-0.7096655369,
0.9795029759,
-0.1820003241,
-0.4111638963,
0.7389250398,
0.7590337396,
0.6100940704,
-0.3158031404,
0.7627619505,
-0.2129932493,
0.0671618581,
-0.9257128835,
0.4338632822,
-0.5463681221,
0.3289158046,
-0.1844787002,
-1.0126318932,
-0.5698575974,
0.4235807061,
-0.0006769019,
-0.2697321773,
0.964050293,
0.6728792787,
-0.1666921824,
0.0952164531,
0.2816791832,
0.0593326092,
0.3728920519,
0.4481197894,
0.9391611814,
-0.1146288291,
0.3825783134,
-0.0408546813,
-0.4630706608,
-0.4730084836,
-0.777172029,
-1.001989603,
-0.724200964,
-0.2737154365,
-0.0659092814,
-0.259689182,
0.7016663551,
0.9279045463,
-0.6723182797,
-0.4843484461,
0.6584448814,
0.3834332228,
-0.7748222351,
-0.2099216431,
0.4930307865,
0.0555647835,
-0.8109361529,
0.4181862175,
0.6807326078,
-0.4572941959,
-0.3851033151,
0.1585024595,
0.0268900543,
0.1799843311,
0.8345043659,
0.0735891312,
-0.6643100977,
-0.5130376816,
-0.3174606264,
0.1817117631,
0.021374369,
1.2477359772,
-0.7141940594,
0.599956274,
0.9758605957,
0.2538947761,
0.4546500444,
0.3950110376,
0.9015077353,
-0.6004833579,
0.0330513194,
0.0568651259,
0.3800238371,
0.1683735996,
-0.25987041,
0.2007932067,
0.2767959237,
-0.4883221388,
-0.7457258701,
0.5915920138,
-1.3683201075,
-0.4822651148,
0.7985457778,
-0.1297773272,
-0.1645036787,
-0.463601172,
-0.3365717232,
0.0559423789,
-0.2995658517,
0.7599425912,
0.4302652478,
-0.4487112164,
-0.1272128522,
-0.2856760919,
0.299793005,
0.0265214741,
-0.7720749974,
0.0589107275,
0.6701527834,
0.4497030973,
0.4628474414,
0.6709929705,
0.0027862824,
0.4404011965,
0.1071796343,
-0.1770060658,
-0.4397358596,
-0.9394518733,
-0.0580961071,
0.2689193487,
-0.809078753,
-0.2022404671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03814v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03814v1
|
Evaluating the Elementary Multilingual Capabilities of Large Language Models with MultiQ
| 2024-03-06T16:01:44 | 2024-03-06T16:01:44 |
Carolin Holtermann, Paul Röttger, Timm Dill, Anne Lauscher
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) need to serve everyone, including a global
majority of non-English speakers. However, most LLMs today, and open LLMs in
particular, are often intended for use in just English (e.g. Llama2, Mistral)
or a small handful of high-resource languages (e.g. Mixtral, Qwen). Recent
research shows that, despite limits in their intended use, people prompt LLMs
in many different languages. Therefore, in this paper, we investigate the basic
multilingual capabilities of state-of-the-art open LLMs beyond their intended
use. For this purpose, we introduce MultiQ, a new silver standard benchmark for
basic open-ended question answering with 27.4k test questions across a
typologically diverse set of 137 languages. With MultiQ, we evaluate language
fidelity, i.e.\ whether models respond in the prompted language, and question
answering accuracy. All LLMs we test respond faithfully and/or accurately for
at least some languages beyond their intended use. Most models are more
accurate when they respond faithfully. However, differences across models are
large, and there is a long tail of languages where models are neither accurate
nor faithful. We explore differences in tokenization as a potential explanation
for our findings, identifying possible correlations that warrant further
investigation.
|
[
-0.3729969859,
-0.6324932575,
0.5650019646,
0.2454462349,
-0.0873913169,
0.1483824551,
-0.4010459185,
-0.4920822978,
-0.1559817195,
0.3077999651,
-0.2433235198,
-0.358279109,
-0.4028926492,
0.5262044072,
-0.2576121986,
0.8241533041,
-0.1741126329,
0.3199806511,
-0.3752747476,
-0.5322583914,
-0.3091800511,
-0.791467905,
-0.5641310811,
-0.1531220526,
0.6846966147,
0.4208429158,
0.6976729631,
0.1685505807,
0.322576046,
0.2555565536,
-0.1986933947,
0.3354410231,
-0.538633883,
-0.0291948356,
0.0392669179,
-0.5463637114,
-0.3752545118,
-0.0482863337,
1.0330129862,
0.8080277443,
0.0205584932,
0.3851361573,
0.1626344323,
0.4728866518,
-0.6651422977,
0.0368755832,
-0.6327705383,
-0.2260682881,
-0.1960476637,
0.0814267397,
-0.3716342151,
-0.2142406702,
-0.1715968102,
-0.5258066058,
-0.1888189763,
0.1248222589,
0.5974473953,
-0.0678166896,
-0.7906706333,
-0.2242235243,
-0.6825630069,
0.8861547709,
-0.7101091743,
0.8279335499,
0.2694649696,
0.2723587751,
-0.0788250044,
-0.5245616436,
-0.5648611188,
-0.3844570518,
0.0267937202,
0.136071071,
-0.2387639582,
0.0464848615,
0.2641566098,
0.5473171473,
-0.5988167524,
0.1992591619,
-0.275672555,
-0.1946421266,
0.4595958292,
0.1272012293,
0.3065352738,
0.0518361442,
-0.2833486795,
0.041175209,
-0.7124551535,
0.4594341218,
0.3933159411,
0.5072818398,
0.0503269844,
0.7847185135,
0.0116511686,
0.5419769883,
-0.360942632,
-0.3228048384,
0.1432458758,
-0.6289967895,
-0.0849259272,
-0.3756037652,
0.8400355577,
0.2967146933,
0.4752807617,
-0.2279691696,
-0.177243188,
-0.2470307052,
-0.3071658313,
-0.6947119832,
0.3517927825,
0.3994937539,
-0.3604606986,
0.3148582578,
0.0073939036,
-0.4693872631,
-0.2198005617,
-0.0198987275,
0.3373277485,
-0.472976476,
-0.552303493,
0.2547999024,
0.0051666829,
0.3294899464,
0.1209100708,
-0.6416691542,
0.3995738626,
0.7319679856,
0.8011428118,
-0.1368436366,
-0.7794636488,
-0.7634302378,
-0.0636014417,
-0.4912069738,
0.6209031343,
-0.4026481509,
-0.348793447,
0.0221442319,
0.0870937183,
-0.1344874799,
-0.4124723077,
0.6440628171,
-0.6305232644,
0.1429715455,
-0.5153278708,
-0.4090463817,
-0.1702373475,
0.4274994135,
-0.6781779528,
1.1767911911,
0.0042833597,
-0.6215137243,
0.1700490415,
-0.4716858268,
-0.2859407365,
0.0785745755,
-0.02897688,
-0.0350795165,
0.3340426087,
0.1932638735,
0.1314940453,
-0.4375629127,
0.2970037758,
-0.2673213482,
-0.4113546014,
0.5475820303,
-0.7174796462,
0.6330888271,
0.1705530137,
0.2418046743,
0.114973411,
-0.6221086383,
0.2676686347,
0.144690901,
-0.5477433801,
-0.441470921,
-0.1077008769,
0.0599155612,
0.3517483771,
0.2504967153,
-0.6812601686,
0.0596409105,
-0.4875834584,
0.3916657269,
0.5705687404,
-0.1685932726,
0.2302915305,
-0.4010688961,
0.7227573991,
-0.0417480357,
0.0507773608,
-0.3698070645,
-0.6105513573,
-0.6544508338,
-0.4515830874,
0.5576969981,
0.5470232368,
-0.5424499512,
-0.1404495686,
-0.2972641289,
-0.2200046033,
-0.7775402069,
0.2909697592,
0.4415344596,
0.0535632484,
0.2514577806,
-0.0932458714,
-0.3180661798,
-1.014950633,
-0.3997488022,
-0.3811122477,
-0.0040524104,
0.3181794882,
0.5018969774,
0.0095242169,
0.7467480302,
-0.0705546737,
0.1740459055,
-0.3052238822,
-0.1113149524,
0.3016670942,
-0.0448194742,
0.477030009,
-0.6362430453,
-0.6063187718,
0.2112509608,
-0.5663283467,
-0.0654110909,
0.0391333066,
-0.0876216739,
0.2648595572,
0.5308052897,
-0.6999245286,
-0.0024015734,
0.8963112831,
-0.0572316051,
0.5949049592,
-0.3129041493,
0.2982168496,
-1.091468811,
0.2695086002,
-0.1926962435,
-0.2457530051,
-0.727889359,
0.3703311086,
0.4777585566,
-0.2592770159,
-0.7086542845,
0.9889805317,
-0.6426504254,
-0.2514647543,
-0.1079756171,
0.2023700923,
0.1335318536,
0.2075844854,
-0.2373855412,
1.0752590895,
0.3834190369,
-0.6212745905,
0.2055132091,
0.0766468793,
-0.2894150913,
0.4995456636,
-0.7917747498,
0.1162994727,
-0.3026264608,
-0.0587775335,
-1.3221892118,
-0.1039188653,
-0.0674456134,
-0.5374591947,
0.1156645641,
-0.2001170665,
-0.8474271297,
-0.316714406,
-0.3319766223,
0.4662193358,
0.2650116384,
-0.4803689718,
0.7315404415,
0.1939042807,
-0.2484589368,
-0.6914841533,
-0.5606639981,
0.1665623486,
-0.2909236252,
-0.8441708088,
-0.0063200109,
-0.3811185062,
-0.5373681188,
-0.2637161911,
0.0351402052,
-0.1387500465,
0.3678689301,
-0.0504349396,
0.2583705187,
-0.478191793,
0.3979658186,
-0.0221159477,
-0.0151762068,
-0.061756473,
-0.090035677,
0.5719266534,
-0.4849856496,
-0.699224174,
-0.078492783,
0.5687081814,
0.833787024,
-0.647362709,
0.8344840407,
0.3344907165,
-0.3250988424,
0.1463110596,
-0.6008570194,
-0.007384236,
-0.4506443143,
0.4848323464,
-0.7346093059,
-1.0671129227,
0.9094114304,
0.1485567987,
0.4450239837,
0.3870159984,
0.5865860581,
0.0281665009,
1.1154636145,
0.4447512031,
0.0615377538,
0.0593544357,
0.2550079525,
0.1849869192,
-0.8850166202,
-0.0221825037,
-0.604670167,
-0.0097857257,
-0.6438307166,
-0.4860936701,
0.4433864057,
0.420996815,
-0.118993789,
-0.0495292693,
0.2063215971,
0.6166133881,
0.5010632277,
-0.353274554,
0.7771651149,
-0.1018841416,
-0.2738714218,
-0.0857782513,
-0.6817302108,
-0.6671715379,
1.287795186,
0.5073202848,
0.6480015516,
0.4603728652,
0.4402379394,
-0.3075315058,
0.2248923331,
-0.8159342408,
0.3368609846,
-0.1882801056,
-0.7767082453,
-0.343432039,
-0.4171310663,
-1.0775737762,
0.6550201774,
-0.1104637608,
-0.4431674778,
-0.1676005125,
-0.1089301109,
-0.4003917277,
0.2885290086,
-0.6486802101,
0.6800376177,
-0.5387122631,
-0.1377045214,
0.1061023772,
-0.3291994333,
0.4655988216,
-0.3075216115,
0.5249533653,
-0.178647086,
-0.3123066425,
0.4941248,
0.0123726167,
0.6223754883,
0.2456110418,
-0.3483489752,
0.1218407899,
-0.0623896532,
0.2646007538,
0.2853550315,
-0.316501081,
0.2949440181,
0.353484273,
-0.5143315196,
-0.4506067336,
0.6346401572,
-0.8284525871,
-0.6302522421,
-0.4666823447,
-0.6743239164,
-0.4654958248,
0.3374799192,
0.0495306104,
0.3244396746,
-0.5064586997,
0.201481998,
0.540301621,
-0.3311387897,
0.4659816623,
0.928229332,
-0.5909739137,
-0.3572786152,
0.7168235183,
0.2236561924,
0.4601074755,
0.1720001698,
0.3548441529,
-0.5284698009,
-0.597877264,
-0.7274221182,
0.4902706742,
-0.7808215618,
0.0635478795,
-0.6432142854,
-0.0385986865,
-0.4201307297,
0.2489017546,
-0.2982365191,
-0.2921774685,
-0.161209777,
0.0575331673,
0.1662075371,
0.6594055891,
0.0869840309,
-0.0266056973,
-1.0793750286,
0.2165979594,
0.456838131,
0.3131325841,
-0.0113087855,
-0.6409831643,
-0.2090684921,
0.233433336,
-0.0266463999,
-0.812302947,
0.0174078625,
0.4772461653,
1.0086784363,
0.216231823,
0.0314705968,
0.6341018677,
-0.6423931718,
0.8015678525,
-0.0321730897,
-0.907460928,
-0.0201068427,
-0.3264700472,
0.4827233553,
0.5940707922,
0.5700223446,
-1.1252928972,
-0.4820307791,
-0.2481510788,
-0.6656085849,
0.4658247828,
0.0341744721,
0.4006598592,
-0.184231177,
0.3522283137,
0.1848890632,
0.2637540996,
-0.8513208032,
-0.2726225853,
0.115603812,
-0.0016782064,
-0.3883056045,
-0.3292274773,
-0.1673790663,
0.1324493736,
0.3734624088,
-0.3495493531,
-0.0134071149,
-0.0744549856,
-0.2555499077,
-0.2098727077,
0.6156820655,
0.526583612,
0.8638318181,
-0.0022458159,
0.072449483,
0.4320322573,
-0.224270165,
0.1403558999,
0.160085693,
-0.0298546609,
-0.1272874624,
0.49043414,
0.5716381073,
0.261603117,
-0.9544971585,
0.4765558243,
-0.3299899101,
-0.0351924971,
-0.1496554166,
-0.1948361248,
0.3872932494,
0.2481358498,
0.417272836,
-0.310854435,
-0.1492287368,
-0.7431253195,
-0.0330660641,
0.748010993,
-0.1016997248,
-0.3146608472,
0.3388621807,
0.164614439,
-0.1609020233,
0.6009135842,
-0.2496416718,
-0.4880490899,
0.4641127288,
0.5706413388,
0.5011500716,
-0.2803898156,
0.0286043249,
0.4011798799,
0.6310157776,
-0.0566449277,
0.6107249856,
0.3845201731,
-0.8715257049,
-0.7362849116,
-0.5055506229,
-0.5058082342,
0.2629361153,
-0.7495622039,
0.2595157623,
-0.2303719372,
-0.0841475353,
-0.2237461358,
-0.0299994294,
-0.6047070622,
-0.1885554641,
0.2129981071,
0.9966416955,
-0.882342577,
0.6971358061,
0.9150619507,
-0.2445894629,
-0.6339281201,
0.0000849031,
-0.0778344721,
-0.8973459601,
0.4851726294,
0.1632915735,
-0.1356685758,
0.0652605444,
-0.2276374698,
-0.9482526183,
0.842058599,
0.5160070658,
-0.3372737765,
0.075148426,
0.3910202086,
0.5900870562,
-0.2882091105,
0.4893059433,
0.4254666269,
0.3848002553,
-0.0206495225,
-1.2218700647,
-0.2961441875,
-0.1928388625,
0.0028708808,
0.228031069,
-0.8280286789,
1.2021621466,
-0.2237901688,
-0.4095989466,
0.1557573229,
0.5755918026,
0.5115919113,
0.1527956277,
0.4484260082,
0.3914195299,
1.0095537901,
0.0255235508,
1.1396414042,
-0.4601594508,
0.2986800075,
1.073985815,
-0.5545219183,
1.0766319036,
0.5462737679,
-0.2933843434,
0.0597851649,
0.6687941551,
0.3304451108,
0.0794520453,
0.0529870167,
-0.2747505307,
-0.373411417,
-0.1649042666,
-0.4390690029,
0.4920347631,
0.1532682031,
0.0120699508,
-0.2554953396,
0.1310942769,
0.1194813177,
0.013114918,
-0.3744254112,
0.5679913163,
0.0399771221,
-0.7225648165,
0.620454967,
0.2570756078,
0.6487547755,
-0.6953663826,
0.1339238584,
-0.4040578008,
-0.0427981243,
0.0319930799,
-0.9795419574,
0.0737832263,
0.1565300673,
-0.0938763991,
-0.016109962,
0.3763128221,
-0.5835129619,
-0.6583027244,
0.4143396616,
1.0343898535,
0.1939211488,
-0.1466389298,
-0.6476294994,
0.086376451,
-0.1717773825,
-0.1282601506,
0.4405477047,
0.518281281,
-0.176338017,
0.7406935692,
0.7878261805,
0.1124389023,
0.197868064,
0.0875671059,
0.6791049838,
-0.4487903118,
-0.3270302713,
-0.7537329197,
0.5419115424,
0.1905977726,
-0.5381735563,
1.1409174204,
0.7165353298,
0.8998787999,
0.1410582662,
0.7453649044,
0.3644856513,
0.5951377153,
-0.5217097998,
0.3725617826,
-0.8657963276,
0.112653479,
-0.1200557351,
-0.9278444648,
-0.1749365032,
0.3269152641,
-0.2168468386,
0.0750637278,
0.8196778893,
0.6426705718,
-0.0507266782,
-0.0843130127,
0.6787151098,
0.0482979789,
0.2285439819,
0.5428617001,
1.2215240002,
-0.3606835604,
0.731274724,
0.034076456,
-0.2214300781,
-0.0159024969,
-0.7662283778,
-1.0531986952,
-0.3865876198,
0.0430151597,
-0.3503154218,
-0.1950782984,
0.9361070395,
0.333368957,
-0.8301770091,
-0.523201406,
0.5128931999,
0.1190797612,
-0.1122515649,
-0.0901126415,
0.1738832593,
-0.2655749619,
-0.8596749902,
0.5228985548,
0.1976979077,
0.0817965791,
-0.4532912374,
-0.2093771994,
-0.2099395692,
0.1896723807,
0.6950145364,
0.3108313382,
-0.7998571992,
-0.2044735104,
0.567381382,
-0.1830505282,
0.1019895896,
0.7611370087,
-0.3051883876,
0.4210927784,
0.4130222797,
0.5798681378,
0.1579300016,
-0.0591888428,
0.5633199811,
-0.6512174606,
0.1212370023,
0.2263780981,
0.4935761094,
0.3752434254,
-0.0548265204,
0.2669072449,
-0.0842333585,
-0.4784333408,
-0.9364873767,
0.3319403231,
-0.4337676466,
-0.3351569474,
1.2794599533,
-0.3025514185,
-0.0361779705,
-0.3801620007,
-0.1564823389,
-0.0144177983,
-0.2882966399,
0.236695379,
1.1518275738,
0.0164206773,
-0.4104244113,
-0.7775356174,
0.0714445114,
0.3136060238,
-0.7449190021,
0.1403921694,
0.3373674452,
0.3391500711,
0.1794789732,
0.8284623027,
-0.1496361792,
0.3609989285,
-0.2192791104,
-0.0717602223,
-0.0427140705,
-0.2816054225,
-0.6121040583,
0.1296816617,
0.6293778419,
0.0365869515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03788v1
|
PPTC-R benchmark: Towards Evaluating the Robustness of Large Language Models for PowerPoint Task Completion
| 2024-03-06T15:33:32 | 2024-03-06T15:33:32 |
Zekai Zhang, Yiduo Guo, Yaobo Liang, Dongyan Zhao, Nan Duan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growing dependence on Large Language Models (LLMs) for finishing user
instructions necessitates a comprehensive understanding of their robustness to
complex task completion in real-world situations. To address this critical
need, we propose the PowerPoint Task Completion Robustness benchmark (PPTC-R)
to measure LLMs' robustness to the user PPT task instruction and software
version. Specifically, we construct adversarial user instructions by attacking
user instructions at sentence, semantic, and multi-language levels. To assess
the robustness of Language Models to software versions, we vary the number of
provided APIs to simulate both the newest version and earlier version settings.
Subsequently, we test 3 closed-source and 4 open-source LLMs using a benchmark
that incorporates these robustness settings, aiming to evaluate how deviations
impact LLMs' API calls for task completion. We find that GPT-4 exhibits the
highest performance and strong robustness in our benchmark, particularly in the
version update and the multilingual settings. However, we find that all LLMs
lose their robustness when confronted with multiple challenges (e.g.,
multi-turn) simultaneously, leading to significant performance drops. We
further analyze the robustness behavior and error reasons of LLMs in our
benchmark, which provide valuable insights for researchers to understand the
LLM's robustness in task completion and develop more robust LLMs and agents. We
release the code and data at \url{https://github.com/ZekaiGalaxy/PPTCR}.
|
[
-0.0712448135,
-0.5676653981,
0.3966878951,
0.0342780426,
-0.1681926847,
0.2744488418,
-0.4030556977,
-0.1697251946,
-0.5963431001,
0.4840883315,
-0.1762065887,
-0.566724062,
-0.7782172561,
0.1311729401,
-0.2411855161,
1.0277147293,
-0.3635668159,
-0.0549650937,
-0.2308466583,
0.0282793231,
-0.4718841016,
-0.5956473351,
-0.2710546851,
-0.5455085039,
0.4225612581,
0.4430752099,
0.8277038336,
0.5031455159,
0.7543182969,
0.3066082299,
0.0170001648,
-0.1331904978,
-0.4051594734,
0.2850117683,
-0.0515370555,
-0.3030073941,
-0.7675694823,
0.1314850152,
0.5899475813,
0.5011278987,
-0.090657413,
-0.0116426628,
0.488581568,
0.2945313156,
-0.6379833817,
0.3273442388,
-0.5408036113,
0.1871758997,
-0.2723561823,
-0.174142018,
-0.4332008362,
-0.2308863699,
0.2780271471,
-0.4557190835,
0.2305668592,
-0.1168325692,
0.8226300478,
0.0633356422,
-0.3837901354,
0.0068775178,
-0.5083016753,
0.7540918589,
-0.6328059435,
0.1571499407,
0.5184774399,
0.2818003297,
-0.4521401525,
-1.0724227428,
-0.3121499121,
-0.7772503495,
0.054517217,
0.3048832417,
-0.3158174753,
0.1554993391,
0.4237840772,
0.256198734,
-0.6832482219,
-0.1150457114,
-0.1241788417,
-0.4552927315,
-0.0037281716,
-0.0877162814,
0.3624867797,
-0.2369734049,
-0.4235944748,
-0.2745052576,
-0.9286831021,
-0.0210945513,
0.5988914371,
0.3274011314,
-0.1440604925,
0.6673734188,
-0.0654282495,
0.6399649382,
-0.3394163847,
-0.132227242,
0.3318376839,
-0.4448551834,
-0.0481869988,
-0.3156849146,
1.0289533138,
0.4204105139,
0.2523385882,
-0.4547972381,
-0.154617697,
-0.324106425,
0.4263519943,
-0.6838151813,
-0.4501861036,
0.1965331137,
-0.2463559508,
-0.0196177438,
-0.0076032854,
-0.4243009388,
-0.2947567105,
-0.1947259754,
0.3195450604,
-0.7533515692,
-0.2742696106,
-0.1951714158,
0.1185028479,
0.1513819098,
0.4304026067,
-0.5508151054,
0.3516007662,
1.1549656391,
0.8836379051,
-0.2057048082,
-0.8378499746,
-0.8937653899,
0.0291025843,
-0.1147797704,
0.7033734918,
-0.4191530645,
-0.3514922857,
-0.1726868004,
-0.1119365841,
-0.1828605533,
-0.6085683107,
0.6526048183,
-0.4230190217,
0.1401168555,
-0.3539504409,
-0.5003926158,
-0.1372570992,
0.5112327933,
-0.569929719,
0.8571963906,
0.0808565691,
-0.9019901752,
0.3365994394,
-0.5416287184,
-0.4868894219,
0.31131953,
-0.2720485926,
-0.5490576625,
-0.1429869235,
-0.0279821549,
0.4198844731,
-0.286477834,
0.0697426572,
-0.4828711748,
-0.4761655927,
0.3163499832,
-0.3685284555,
0.4351400137,
0.1917432845,
-0.4009085894,
0.2510553598,
-0.4666515291,
-0.0079550855,
0.1007726043,
-0.3786219954,
0.1523029208,
0.1491805613,
0.2270218581,
0.216633305,
0.4589794278,
-0.390188843,
0.0309608802,
0.0379799083,
0.5783696771,
0.7160969377,
-0.2723960876,
0.0766403377,
-0.4843848348,
0.6970378757,
-0.1893920898,
0.2290859669,
-0.1119182557,
-0.5827900767,
-0.073222205,
-0.373038739,
0.3964323401,
0.7909787297,
-0.4954478145,
0.3287302256,
-0.2405394167,
-0.4026442468,
0.0723624155,
0.3929895461,
0.6992280483,
0.646720469,
0.1592307091,
-0.3853341639,
-0.3941425681,
-0.77966398,
-0.2091262639,
-0.2986764312,
-0.6132830381,
0.1834078133,
0.6655439734,
0.1189059392,
0.8095005751,
-0.0393188521,
-0.3705046773,
-0.4580458105,
0.304055959,
0.0237984732,
0.383587718,
0.3634963334,
-0.8211879134,
-0.5192943811,
-0.0550060049,
-0.6015028954,
-0.1988443583,
0.2345496118,
0.317104429,
-0.0491021276,
0.3082950115,
-0.4345383644,
0.228036955,
0.6922166348,
-0.0872807428,
0.721429944,
-0.5758128762,
0.3489034176,
-1.0096193552,
0.3070571423,
0.0317799933,
-0.2586776614,
-0.4673175812,
-0.037010435,
0.2573088408,
-0.3623025119,
-0.6026568413,
-0.0887269676,
-0.4063917398,
-0.1118987948,
-0.3320591748,
0.3540747166,
-0.1544917524,
0.5146434307,
-0.2957015634,
0.9941899776,
0.5772292018,
-0.0629311055,
0.4013551772,
-0.0182731543,
-0.3704164624,
0.5549345016,
-0.9665902853,
0.3000337183,
0.1942710727,
0.1721182615,
-1.1441242695,
-0.4063467085,
0.2398737967,
-0.3387545347,
0.4131411314,
-0.4658791125,
-0.8483527303,
-0.1174692959,
-0.3766241074,
0.2038499415,
0.5881416202,
-0.0950800478,
0.598295629,
0.3289274573,
-0.2578236759,
-0.6477459073,
-0.4958618879,
0.4491364956,
-0.1837897599,
-0.5531343222,
0.4507492185,
-0.0522080846,
-0.1320107728,
-0.0984378606,
-0.1017354429,
0.1234237626,
0.0309626069,
0.4119082093,
0.2497624606,
0.0969383419,
-0.5176022649,
-0.5838267803,
-0.3021271825,
0.054395441,
-0.0067270836,
0.5031580329,
-0.4140158892,
-0.6020912528,
-0.6015793085,
0.1642375737,
0.7627905011,
-0.0846666694,
0.3778828979,
0.4555455446,
-0.229225114,
0.3545750976,
-0.5095922947,
-0.0621739104,
-0.4465182126,
0.5257149935,
-0.44454512,
-0.8185371161,
0.6619536877,
-0.0385187864,
0.1816376597,
0.084005259,
0.4538993239,
0.1205201671,
0.9788477421,
0.3897119164,
-0.0363801345,
0.5227333903,
-0.1684117615,
-0.0654987842,
-0.8604129553,
-0.0741103142,
-0.518807888,
-0.0716552883,
-0.4711484313,
-0.3043803871,
0.3306823671,
0.0898511186,
-0.2133865207,
0.6443929672,
-0.4569631815,
0.4187705815,
0.7340048552,
0.1010798663,
0.2161670178,
-0.1425008327,
-0.1957683265,
-0.2220041305,
-0.3921581805,
-0.7781918645,
1.2793146372,
0.3155933022,
0.6765241623,
0.1219168603,
0.4164352119,
0.3173497617,
0.2871208191,
-0.4168461263,
0.6220047474,
-0.2500833571,
-0.2162545919,
0.0358191356,
-0.5693953037,
-0.9393187761,
0.2156986892,
0.1074086651,
-1.022793889,
-0.4953506589,
0.2618042827,
-0.1623217016,
0.3686495423,
-0.7325012088,
1.29388237,
-0.1472056508,
-0.4464827478,
-0.1872802377,
-0.6568955779,
0.1468813866,
-0.105669342,
-0.115776509,
-0.2678470314,
-0.2995135188,
0.7328506112,
-0.5676970482,
0.7335755229,
-0.1611726135,
-0.0155113488,
0.0872540399,
0.0008842104,
0.7236652374,
-0.2151853889,
-0.0296956804,
0.2006478757,
-0.2286499441,
-0.4747030139,
-0.3599600792,
0.7602049708,
-0.8448688388,
-0.535530448,
-0.4325939119,
-0.6516696215,
-0.1532170773,
0.2521571517,
0.3973205388,
0.6262971163,
0.0003642299,
0.3660091758,
0.4251344502,
-0.0232188608,
0.3868632317,
0.4536111355,
0.0660524815,
-0.6244500875,
0.7416139841,
0.2314017564,
0.2269956172,
0.4117853343,
0.0829745233,
-0.392028898,
-1.3509025574,
-0.2023864239,
-0.0000079971,
-0.592707932,
-0.1000333503,
-0.4899727106,
-0.0186335109,
-0.323161602,
0.0470682532,
-0.4522226751,
-0.0724598393,
-0.0865569115,
0.1928925812,
0.1739431918,
0.6760243177,
0.0412293822,
0.2272605747,
-0.6280881763,
0.2439710051,
0.3721500635,
0.4294270873,
-0.1988924891,
-0.561396718,
0.036960043,
-0.1064223349,
-0.624161303,
-0.7413083911,
0.1226075962,
0.0186157636,
0.6425245404,
0.1039721444,
0.2457721084,
0.2803458273,
-0.4392786026,
0.8631539941,
0.3484797478,
-0.8678375483,
0.5218670368,
-0.6262057424,
0.6426038146,
0.548838675,
0.099104926,
-0.3247775733,
-0.8311908841,
-0.4485366046,
-1.0423305035,
0.7031037211,
0.4880594313,
-0.1468608379,
0.0811084807,
0.1584953368,
-0.0453640893,
0.0980257094,
-0.6144694686,
-0.2194821537,
-0.3196645677,
0.0683824867,
0.1088779345,
-0.3027795255,
-0.1508153528,
0.2304557413,
0.5816996098,
-0.038790971,
-0.0881794989,
0.0604530647,
-0.1140358672,
-0.0967811272,
0.4843282998,
0.674120903,
1.0870740414,
-0.4462309182,
0.1535306275,
0.260235399,
-0.8656313419,
-0.1122841537,
0.5444433093,
0.0787669346,
-0.2218508273,
0.4284461141,
0.4108448923,
0.2986536622,
-0.8563449383,
0.7287304997,
-0.4303168058,
-0.1799295545,
-0.3304980397,
-0.0594686009,
-0.1387434602,
0.1115291789,
0.7298152447,
0.1867806613,
-0.1069170982,
-0.3471680582,
0.3952928185,
0.3093856871,
-0.3560289741,
-0.4649555087,
0.876196146,
0.0241002366,
-0.4820254147,
0.5456392765,
-0.208180204,
-0.5885820389,
0.5628154874,
0.195755586,
0.9532222748,
0.0219448972,
-0.0266579576,
-0.0341411345,
0.2142605633,
-0.0894064084,
0.2405447066,
-0.0933647081,
-0.2745839059,
-0.8501984477,
-0.1917181611,
-0.9878804088,
0.2967427075,
-0.4744627476,
0.0868916437,
-0.3842870295,
-0.4071031213,
-0.0838982016,
0.2183155417,
-0.319920212,
-0.2143600881,
0.0593836047,
0.7378320098,
-0.3387940526,
0.9849764705,
0.7195256352,
-0.1697786301,
-0.7892728448,
0.1480943114,
0.1688901484,
-0.5353964567,
0.4453990757,
0.2660171688,
-0.1452558488,
-0.3917907774,
-0.1973073334,
-0.53923136,
1.0714645386,
0.7792047858,
-0.428422004,
0.1522212476,
0.320524931,
0.4043797851,
-0.0228913482,
0.2675970197,
0.3340848386,
0.4372617304,
0.340167731,
-1.3894356489,
0.1641574353,
-0.3059481084,
0.009598461,
0.1884610802,
-0.5216783881,
0.8606097698,
-0.2234903425,
0.0149870282,
0.2483120412,
0.525375843,
0.4124893248,
0.0764926299,
0.5198553205,
0.5098286271,
0.4276504815,
-0.3085930049,
1.0351080894,
-0.6501435637,
0.4871947169,
1.2035316229,
-0.4695068002,
0.9018275142,
0.2474814951,
-0.3487889171,
0.1430290341,
0.3964930177,
-0.0923320204,
0.5692251921,
0.0918509662,
-0.2837747335,
-0.074939698,
-0.0201992206,
-0.4069580436,
0.2768503428,
-0.0149043771,
-0.1124075428,
-0.450984329,
0.0376555845,
0.3093087673,
0.0724367648,
-0.0812275633,
0.6000488997,
-0.0698400363,
-0.8423268199,
0.507719934,
-0.2206363976,
0.614413619,
-0.9315008521,
0.1531271338,
0.018761253,
0.5348106623,
-0.013268928,
-0.9773368239,
0.2008102387,
0.189077124,
0.0762484893,
-0.4518551826,
0.5325110555,
-0.2913644016,
-0.0385290049,
0.3088953197,
0.2442529947,
0.1854492873,
-0.2148976475,
-0.9265463948,
0.2838989198,
-0.1172487885,
-0.4363372624,
0.6108263731,
0.1713381261,
0.3303234279,
0.797544241,
0.3911115527,
0.0620336607,
-0.1901819855,
0.2039009482,
0.6803218722,
-0.3887298107,
-0.2281311303,
-0.9720332026,
0.2415559441,
-0.1201389432,
-0.2117354572,
0.9641994238,
0.7830194831,
0.8326104879,
0.2163367569,
0.8177091479,
-0.1648393869,
0.3528868556,
-0.1518546194,
0.7196550965,
-0.3457638919,
0.2959714532,
-0.3710215092,
-0.6145454645,
-0.3226394355,
0.1923093498,
-0.5517821908,
0.2156330049,
0.6984878182,
0.7986213565,
-0.1289671659,
-0.0142933894,
0.3993556201,
0.0162208658,
0.5393272042,
0.7346819639,
0.9226953983,
-0.3058109879,
1.3282529116,
-0.4424062073,
-0.468286097,
-0.0328139141,
-1.0935834646,
-0.7603775859,
-0.3944348097,
-0.6502298713,
-0.493792206,
0.0676616654,
0.8245300651,
0.7143389583,
-0.7865920663,
-0.3340454996,
-0.1536320448,
0.0495470725,
-0.4278075993,
-0.1763559282,
0.4659884572,
-0.4322928786,
-0.6711614728,
0.2913813591,
0.4000015557,
0.15086025,
-0.1005082875,
-0.1394736022,
0.0278060734,
-0.4279363453,
0.2850371003,
0.417542845,
-0.7107562423,
-0.3290737569,
-0.0853284746,
-0.22376436,
0.2415943593,
1.0152277946,
-0.4463777244,
0.4481056631,
0.5172162056,
0.2379863113,
0.3389607966,
-0.1881485134,
0.7529264092,
-0.6741072536,
0.0856313854,
0.3315145969,
0.694662571,
0.6141247153,
0.0430183783,
0.376098454,
0.1481069177,
-0.7931520939,
-0.8303361535,
0.1412296444,
-1.1695629358,
-0.1630707234,
0.9082372785,
-0.7139120698,
-0.2420613766,
-0.5045961142,
-0.2514835596,
0.2069961876,
-0.4181824625,
0.7742336392,
0.6498636603,
-0.0924661905,
-0.2430447042,
-0.6511585712,
0.2985564172,
0.2713249922,
-0.5385910273,
0.4589339197,
0.3811033368,
0.5571571589,
0.2297965586,
0.5248664021,
-0.2357885987,
0.6138958931,
-0.0564171821,
-0.1265338361,
-0.3956228197,
0.0018477405,
-0.1341689527,
0.8213410378,
0.2906729877,
-0.2136203796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03750v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03750v2
|
German also Hallucinates! Inconsistency Detection in News Summaries with the Absinth Dataset
| 2024-03-06T14:37:30 | 2024-03-14T12:30:54 |
Laura Mascarell, Ribin Chalumattu, Annette Rios
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to remarkable progress on
a wide range of natural language processing tasks. Despite the advances, these
large-sized models still suffer from hallucinating information in their output,
which poses a major issue in automatic text summarization, as we must guarantee
that the generated summary is consistent with the content of the source
document. Previous research addresses the challenging task of detecting
hallucinations in the output (i.e. inconsistency detection) in order to
evaluate the faithfulness of the generated summaries. However, these works
primarily focus on English and recent multilingual approaches lack German data.
This work presents absinth, a manually annotated dataset for hallucination
detection in German news summarization and explores the capabilities of novel
open-source LLMs on this task in both fine-tuning and in-context learning
settings. We open-source and release the absinth dataset to foster further
research on hallucination detection in German.
|
[
-0.3398035765,
-0.8581227064,
0.6958015561,
0.1515510827,
-0.4537791014,
-0.314221561,
-0.3295695186,
-0.6259192228,
0.6107333302,
0.5404831767,
-0.5404197574,
-0.7900640368,
-0.619333148,
0.4675083458,
-0.5568790436,
1.0381116867,
-0.293032378,
0.2048023641,
-0.2099212557,
-0.4934498072,
-0.377083391,
-0.5138460994,
-0.2470610738,
-0.3945700526,
0.3004203141,
0.387214303,
0.5170139074,
0.3471990228,
0.5826148987,
0.1960768104,
0.1926425844,
0.3878487945,
-0.292447865,
0.3779970407,
-0.1106986776,
-0.1258078665,
-0.2296886891,
-0.302428931,
0.537932992,
0.5907809138,
-0.0191883817,
-0.1151574031,
-0.1133692861,
0.7802780271,
-0.4287603796,
0.19032906,
-0.753443718,
0.0961622745,
-0.1553020179,
-0.0585834198,
-0.2704655826,
-0.4370218813,
-0.3082285225,
-0.2257669866,
0.5405151248,
-0.1300076842,
0.9383203983,
0.4903004467,
-0.2641650438,
-0.5308682919,
-0.5347951055,
0.3489656448,
-0.7915532589,
0.5324012637,
0.3888458014,
0.0819464773,
-0.207779482,
-0.4243724644,
-0.4699357748,
-0.2555527687,
-0.3965141177,
0.0877323225,
-0.335195154,
-0.2408159822,
0.0291481558,
0.3585361242,
-0.7625494003,
0.1498731524,
-0.2067342699,
-0.2068053782,
0.596295774,
-0.0920517892,
0.205058977,
-0.1572756469,
0.0377885886,
0.0490351617,
-0.618265152,
-0.4435634315,
0.2850603759,
0.2572439909,
-0.2572939396,
0.6882866025,
-0.3695494235,
0.4513367712,
-0.2344694734,
-0.0130792577,
0.5290781856,
-0.1127894968,
-0.106756486,
0.6090211868,
0.515291214,
0.3787131608,
0.4007585347,
-0.2103409618,
-0.4292709827,
0.3007390797,
0.251488477,
-0.7645665407,
-0.5783628821,
0.4255059063,
-0.4162980318,
-0.1853311211,
0.4531077743,
-0.5126588345,
-0.5200535059,
-0.2056125402,
0.1977722794,
-0.3709338307,
-0.333476007,
0.0920036361,
-0.1457729042,
-0.1957654506,
0.4655833542,
-0.7320329547,
0.0592938438,
0.4920101166,
0.9223899245,
-0.5354046226,
-0.4644276798,
-0.6043245196,
0.0335038453,
-0.5498617291,
1.0756316185,
-0.1379589736,
-0.2453150898,
-0.0107378298,
0.268130213,
0.2420937419,
-0.7729518414,
0.6150115728,
0.0323087536,
0.3664365709,
-0.0445794351,
-0.4308251739,
-0.4138747454,
0.0812907591,
-0.6860417128,
0.8032497764,
0.0750986636,
-0.9676387906,
0.2973421216,
-0.3457778394,
-0.8653493524,
-0.1595448852,
-0.3029235601,
-0.6562319994,
0.7743222117,
0.2798366547,
0.3281884193,
0.2669109702,
0.2653967738,
0.0491816215,
-0.4960657358,
0.3083747029,
-0.3732168078,
0.656673193,
-0.0818883702,
-0.297554493,
0.2722105384,
-0.8130558729,
-0.4450928271,
0.2091264576,
0.0559948608,
-0.6603440642,
-0.1095635593,
-0.006601607,
-0.0243410636,
0.011565974,
-0.2621017396,
-0.0330952816,
-0.1939987093,
-0.1872594506,
0.5047954917,
0.3138811588,
0.0718659088,
-0.5581300855,
0.1036577448,
0.273460865,
-0.2211388201,
-0.5020104647,
-0.2998468876,
-0.6565698981,
-0.1102562919,
-0.0014716669,
0.6106743813,
-0.7959880233,
0.6779607534,
-0.1281908602,
-0.3871825933,
-0.5519093275,
0.0222180616,
0.1523550451,
0.4924013317,
0.3254197538,
-0.439484328,
-0.6123108268,
-0.8334562182,
-0.3724989891,
-0.2206608504,
-0.1312423199,
0.1711512953,
0.8072343469,
-0.4000004828,
0.5527026653,
-0.3365652859,
-0.8242916465,
-0.1711738855,
0.3766498566,
0.2779178619,
0.3603997231,
0.4953026474,
-0.7409615517,
-0.1558152288,
0.1063307002,
-1.2627484798,
-0.3977022171,
-0.2085551023,
0.2960678339,
0.8485005498,
0.3677436411,
-0.5747380257,
0.5108309388,
0.4493407607,
-0.2651858032,
0.8018581271,
-0.2388669848,
0.2473586649,
-0.9711784124,
0.0225278623,
-0.0887754858,
-0.341642499,
-0.4071754813,
-0.1226997226,
0.1590288728,
0.3139855266,
-0.3159499466,
0.4551079273,
-0.446765691,
-0.0903421715,
-0.4585357904,
0.214625448,
-0.1451162547,
0.2738884389,
0.3137729764,
0.5818357468,
0.3971359432,
-0.4100931883,
0.4819601476,
0.3482275307,
-0.4163796008,
0.5754078031,
-0.2699828446,
-0.1141877547,
-0.4289908111,
0.1985037476,
-0.7298869491,
-0.8166071773,
0.359470427,
-0.6342954636,
0.002694044,
0.2761889994,
-0.682490468,
0.0122666629,
-0.5004916787,
0.0521358363,
0.22063829,
-0.3834196627,
0.395773232,
0.3307597339,
-0.1545677632,
-0.4463358819,
-0.9765457511,
0.2202965021,
-0.084422946,
-0.4109359682,
0.2058151662,
0.1437012851,
-0.6832367182,
0.2925628722,
-0.4266113043,
0.0788236782,
0.1632730961,
0.1202035993,
0.1083363518,
-0.1620425582,
0.2393897921,
0.1637156606,
-0.053542804,
0.1188548207,
-0.1161037087,
0.4604941308,
-0.1263515502,
-0.5216163397,
-0.6427572966,
0.4659498632,
0.5670874119,
0.0800543055,
0.5434288383,
0.4769493341,
-0.7097491622,
-0.2895970047,
-0.6171051264,
-0.6684767604,
-0.2965328693,
0.5614212751,
-0.2511495948,
-0.5908940434,
0.6981262565,
0.201336354,
0.0508860387,
0.4112375975,
0.4499920309,
0.0350174382,
0.8604156971,
0.5563123822,
-0.131467849,
0.1418469697,
0.1843950748,
0.1062778905,
-0.2778123915,
-0.2050680071,
-0.38477391,
-0.0957306772,
-0.4496300519,
0.0899691582,
0.4933314621,
-0.117817454,
-0.0004264961,
0.0099725612,
-0.3387809992,
0.6552388668,
0.4102864265,
-0.098709099,
0.9153214693,
0.4027577043,
0.1090745255,
-0.102091752,
-0.4193146229,
-0.270121634,
0.5043332577,
0.1492946148,
0.7127897143,
0.1447214335,
0.7686328888,
0.5241600871,
0.219997257,
-0.6979815364,
0.3883557022,
-0.2785419822,
-0.0889639929,
-0.2829327881,
-0.5164638162,
-0.824123323,
0.294311583,
-0.195412606,
-0.7605774403,
0.0755334049,
-0.2683960795,
0.0858297199,
0.3181547821,
-0.3314461708,
0.6174702644,
-0.3554722071,
-0.1268202662,
-0.2293180525,
-0.5898078084,
0.5485724807,
-0.2206027657,
0.2744213045,
-0.2333299071,
0.1450544745,
0.4335902035,
-0.214174062,
0.6743009686,
0.0101112118,
-0.4275334477,
-0.2297677249,
0.2726657689,
0.6894318461,
0.2942999601,
0.1582926512,
0.5604560971,
-0.5133907795,
-0.0563694313,
-0.2937195003,
0.8029902577,
-0.496949017,
-0.6569850445,
-0.6969951987,
-0.7038137913,
-0.0378322862,
0.3425776362,
0.6138933301,
0.167734921,
-0.2765828371,
0.1673698872,
0.654966116,
-0.1811498106,
0.3603334427,
0.6325014234,
-0.7022692561,
-0.4072979987,
0.8236948252,
0.1479739994,
-0.1765325367,
0.0033967167,
-0.1928007305,
-0.1205827445,
-0.6308503151,
-0.6594989896,
0.5397036076,
-0.7785205841,
-0.1786142141,
-0.6998047829,
-0.5266671181,
-0.4363334179,
-0.1128683612,
-0.3255991936,
-0.3956606984,
-0.3162447512,
-0.2757331729,
0.3600434363,
0.868928194,
-0.1730766147,
-0.0219993889,
-0.7985030413,
0.5769441128,
-0.2022124529,
0.2749492526,
-0.2418629676,
-0.4391199946,
-0.3826411963,
-0.0050104931,
-0.1517130584,
-1.050393939,
0.5846908689,
-0.0491733812,
0.4720824063,
0.5841754675,
0.3298224509,
0.2776224017,
-0.1953322738,
0.684490025,
0.0395067111,
-0.7191569805,
0.5633075237,
-0.3010858893,
0.4422118366,
0.6073143482,
0.2851654887,
-0.8179470897,
-0.8273711801,
-0.4263679981,
-0.8951046467,
0.7697463036,
0.3188549578,
0.1342599988,
-0.0222763456,
-0.0475000441,
0.7353615165,
0.3729181886,
-0.7800577283,
-0.2339315712,
-0.1632406265,
-0.1245545223,
0.0554186366,
-0.131043762,
-0.1164395362,
-0.2222312093,
0.9906942248,
-0.0410976745,
-0.1082426757,
0.3257092535,
-0.4726403356,
-0.3217466176,
-0.0112516927,
0.7090997696,
0.9173015356,
-0.29601717,
0.4305630326,
0.2447720915,
-0.4680601358,
0.1066479832,
0.2267441303,
-0.447627902,
0.7689507604,
0.432633549,
0.8542869687,
0.0671514943,
-0.8956871033,
0.4394744635,
-0.1018892676,
-0.2941426337,
-0.8090271354,
-0.0134380544,
-0.1788915545,
0.1423317045,
0.7105585933,
0.1125184596,
0.044298999,
-0.4857195318,
0.4001169503,
0.2227027863,
-0.2703573704,
-0.2906560302,
0.7551810741,
-0.0548905544,
-0.2481238842,
0.8034588099,
-0.2882721424,
-0.3828445971,
0.5377261639,
0.4870907366,
1.1774053574,
-0.2188186795,
0.400534004,
0.0891333222,
0.5336481333,
-0.2868440151,
0.3609135151,
0.069465749,
-0.7818460464,
-0.2498287261,
-0.3259853125,
-0.3839578032,
0.3214987516,
-0.450473547,
0.4031593502,
0.0867803544,
0.2769363225,
-0.2550199032,
-0.3806287646,
-0.1258007437,
-0.1682350636,
0.2771023512,
0.6475101709,
-1.0631085634,
0.8992483616,
0.5841735005,
-0.3237206638,
0.019003259,
0.5548388958,
0.2380053848,
-0.3465269804,
0.1646324247,
0.5764043331,
-0.0399622843,
-0.2465488613,
-0.3238411248,
-0.4540384412,
0.776658833,
0.512337327,
-0.3534934819,
0.1558500677,
0.154700771,
0.4233187437,
-0.2722336352,
-0.130559206,
0.6607943773,
0.6956079602,
-0.0179419126,
-0.7477961183,
0.0130188055,
-0.2725927532,
-0.4420261979,
0.2419992089,
-0.5335173607,
0.8076756001,
-0.3283914924,
-0.3923528492,
-0.1256752014,
0.7304490209,
0.2819822133,
0.7188091278,
0.2664655149,
0.6964556575,
1.0376974344,
-0.130585596,
0.8822005987,
-0.4013348222,
0.1401138008,
1.2502292395,
-0.4791744947,
0.4995882213,
0.3809800744,
0.2593662739,
0.4780654609,
0.5374243855,
-0.3171344101,
0.4364377558,
-0.1166645288,
-0.2591789961,
0.0741803646,
-0.2559632063,
-0.5242937803,
0.5228583813,
0.3114559054,
-0.3257459998,
-0.5925192237,
0.3773197234,
0.3200522363,
0.0440093279,
-0.3070814908,
1.0385279655,
0.1704229861,
-0.7448542714,
0.6036348343,
0.0258382671,
0.647855401,
-0.5742690563,
-0.2134181857,
-0.6631219387,
0.2619686723,
-0.4063243568,
-0.4851528108,
0.7512432337,
0.084857747,
-0.1205826923,
0.0299911443,
0.7729417682,
-0.5062355399,
-0.6345119476,
0.3758002818,
0.762917757,
0.5726436973,
-0.3955624402,
-0.1142059267,
0.0494491905,
0.0438418165,
-0.1935357451,
0.1701288819,
0.6786875129,
-0.361407429,
0.3859371245,
0.3303837478,
0.2352387309,
-0.37215662,
0.0778805092,
0.6273617744,
-0.6203668118,
-0.4772644341,
-1.0820565224,
0.248690635,
-0.200285688,
-0.2799734473,
1.110861063,
0.8818358779,
1.1056102514,
-0.2653312683,
1.0618269444,
0.143387869,
0.285972029,
-0.5992812514,
1.0774316788,
-0.7011036873,
0.2709087729,
0.0338332877,
-1.0721596479,
-0.5933721066,
0.5881444812,
0.1270134747,
-0.2135788053,
0.9424940348,
0.7254648209,
-0.0900971442,
0.2317331731,
0.332544148,
0.5431469679,
-0.2077350914,
0.2695792019,
0.5873378515,
-0.094360292,
0.1784410328,
-0.3181326091,
-0.0244439207,
-0.5125591159,
-0.8076265454,
-0.8778671026,
-0.7587759495,
-0.3583343327,
-0.4534261227,
0.3111820221,
0.9824501872,
0.1703225225,
-1.3756638765,
-0.2640928626,
-0.209611237,
0.419677943,
-0.4932944477,
-0.2478505671,
0.6104568243,
-0.4625174701,
-0.7124032378,
0.386747092,
0.3094495535,
0.2670235336,
-0.2058122456,
0.0535036065,
0.0600884743,
-0.0220733993,
0.3498766422,
0.0889746547,
-0.7731234431,
-0.252076745,
-0.2055155188,
0.0292553473,
0.2891971469,
0.8120639324,
-0.7949937582,
0.4022009671,
0.6042128205,
0.5140035748,
0.3276520669,
0.0003772657,
0.3493906558,
-0.9722876549,
0.3777688444,
0.2008196414,
0.538950026,
0.5134655833,
-0.3890752196,
0.7241051793,
0.4453327954,
-0.3899739087,
-1.0370782614,
0.0039996668,
-0.6782594323,
-0.7912295461,
1.0683188438,
0.1526133716,
-0.155678317,
-0.2784404755,
-0.2533537447,
0.3154148757,
-0.4295589328,
1.3681066036,
0.8911337256,
-0.1394091696,
-0.1605059206,
-0.6379328966,
0.5037350059,
0.2604233921,
-0.9919338822,
0.3222681284,
0.8402768373,
-0.1454829723,
0.1350964755,
0.3562573195,
-0.0118365595,
0.3531099856,
-0.0837938786,
0.1845865399,
-0.2648668587,
-0.614780426,
-0.4745419621,
0.2410644591,
-0.4116461873,
-0.1259280592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03737v1
|
Probabilistic Topic Modelling with Transformer Representations
| 2024-03-06T14:27:29 | 2024-03-06T14:27:29 |
Arik Reuter, Anton Thielmann, Christoph Weisser, Benjamin Säfken, Thomas Kneib
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Topic modelling was mostly dominated by Bayesian graphical models during the
last decade. With the rise of transformers in Natural Language Processing,
however, several successful models that rely on straightforward clustering
approaches in transformer-based embedding spaces have emerged and consolidated
the notion of topics as clusters of embedding vectors. We propose the
Transformer-Representation Neural Topic Model (TNTM), which combines the
benefits of topic representations in transformer-based embedding spaces and
probabilistic modelling. Therefore, this approach unifies the powerful and
versatile notion of topics based on transformer embeddings with fully
probabilistic modelling, as in models such as Latent Dirichlet Allocation
(LDA). We utilize the variational autoencoder (VAE) framework for improved
inference speed and modelling flexibility. Experimental results show that our
proposed model achieves results on par with various state-of-the-art approaches
in terms of embedding coherence while maintaining almost perfect topic
diversity. The corresponding source code is available at
https://github.com/ArikReuter/TNTM.
|
[
-0.4834066033,
-0.8343841434,
0.6041550636,
0.1904772818,
-0.3419362903,
-0.031220248,
-0.1143011078,
0.3472699523,
0.5289099813,
0.6622585654,
-0.2346361578,
-0.3831942081,
-0.7590202093,
-0.4466417134,
-0.6331114173,
0.7195786238,
0.0799739286,
-0.0151068838,
-0.2807944417,
0.0858894661,
-0.5827556252,
-0.4174183607,
-0.2791929245,
-0.3641388714,
0.4873923957,
0.1522284597,
0.5991714001,
0.4618505239,
0.4946900308,
0.231905669,
-0.410798192,
-0.3358261585,
-0.1991308331,
0.195204705,
-0.4342772067,
-0.5465177298,
-0.1717330217,
-0.0059813093,
0.5376358628,
0.8047422767,
-0.4228574634,
-0.4607530832,
-0.0743337125,
0.083126761,
-0.3549731076,
0.0688869506,
-0.6090487838,
0.104264386,
0.1403581947,
-0.0877067372,
-0.3582457304,
-0.1258181334,
0.4119190872,
-0.0553665645,
0.466285497,
-0.2799682915,
0.5844707489,
0.2658123076,
-0.7235130072,
-0.0627413765,
-1.0313253403,
0.6488883495,
-0.5202459693,
0.2824125588,
0.2172363102,
0.3129615188,
-0.0265077073,
-0.8550450206,
-0.63129282,
-0.1340934783,
-0.128420487,
0.2439708859,
-0.5357211828,
-0.1415286809,
-0.2518558204,
0.5076224804,
-0.6210140586,
0.1039086208,
0.145148769,
0.1129473001,
0.2140393704,
0.1967886537,
0.1976169646,
-0.5259362459,
-0.2206797153,
-0.0849570855,
-0.3521098793,
-0.2664546967,
0.3597911298,
0.1802654713,
-0.1420185417,
0.5815343857,
0.046426665,
0.4917794168,
0.2016886175,
0.4273787141,
0.0000380037,
-0.083146818,
0.1071853116,
-0.319092989,
0.8336714506,
0.0290231034,
-0.2156671137,
-0.5588936806,
0.0274706297,
0.1400491148,
0.6167151332,
-0.7509151697,
-0.5552614331,
0.250980556,
-0.4823158085,
-0.212297529,
0.2985846698,
-0.7853494883,
-0.2518967688,
-0.2484775782,
0.3464824855,
-0.3916777372,
-0.624532938,
0.1990440339,
-0.0045903986,
0.0923595503,
0.0603851043,
-0.7796063423,
0.3399754763,
0.7378813624,
0.7923606038,
-0.4584287703,
-0.1040053144,
-0.0812097862,
0.1450784951,
-0.3853673637,
0.9165474176,
-0.7351219654,
-0.5472560525,
-0.1251372844,
0.0929248929,
0.102446191,
-0.514529109,
0.4027093649,
-0.5847019553,
0.5152940154,
0.0693474263,
-0.7830010653,
-0.043655701,
0.134117946,
-0.8520988226,
0.748765111,
0.0143146124,
-0.9069543481,
0.2222237438,
-0.5754727721,
-0.0943780914,
-0.162826404,
-0.3810641468,
-0.5804837942,
0.1806062311,
0.2049838752,
0.5988590121,
-0.6025493145,
1.2430107594,
0.1274142116,
-0.076808162,
0.3997410834,
-0.7967041135,
0.3113289475,
0.0606989935,
-0.2703178525,
0.460983187,
-0.4443786442,
-0.7331870198,
-0.0050739194,
0.1329216063,
-0.2353373468,
0.288610518,
0.1486012489,
0.3259923458,
0.1052335575,
-0.3213433027,
0.1007293016,
-0.5822618008,
0.4636979103,
0.4302417636,
0.3559419215,
0.8769801259,
-0.1844841987,
0.4495716989,
0.752435267,
-0.1184682697,
-0.2145475894,
-0.8272073269,
-0.5219300389,
-0.1633450836,
0.4947565794,
0.4767647982,
-0.7467111349,
0.8637100458,
-0.2199685574,
-0.5915308595,
-0.1680099368,
-0.5724788904,
-0.1942410916,
0.1522165537,
0.3853976429,
-0.3710363507,
-0.1535248607,
-1.0947787762,
0.1021087542,
0.0258296039,
-0.2463780046,
0.2126322985,
0.3796717823,
-0.322971791,
1.4099105597,
-0.6676393747,
-0.0797876418,
-0.4861550033,
0.7058506012,
0.5972454548,
0.6993673444,
0.5151857734,
-1.2563122511,
-0.2595851719,
-0.3789680898,
-0.4369536936,
0.117619656,
-0.2175082862,
-0.1094921455,
-0.3693437576,
0.2830330729,
-0.9044647813,
0.5169143081,
0.2610773146,
-0.4795030653,
0.3846634328,
-0.3424978256,
-0.0408643,
-1.6930738688,
-0.3186994493,
0.2006366551,
-0.2302377969,
-0.5646702647,
-0.2822710276,
-0.0939432755,
-0.4457432628,
-0.3012325764,
0.4928009212,
-0.0526542105,
0.1656751186,
-0.6784623861,
-0.1280982941,
-0.2399224788,
0.3297568858,
0.3206526339,
0.6303982139,
0.8914067745,
-0.4510955215,
0.3303238153,
0.1908770651,
0.1393540055,
0.2721575797,
-0.7774515748,
-0.2515758276,
-0.3084119558,
0.4103690684,
-0.9692898989,
-0.0361849405,
0.2678253353,
-0.2368042171,
0.4951975644,
-0.2339348793,
-0.5360270739,
-0.3360782862,
-0.0628499612,
0.1255153418,
0.6549962759,
-0.3738175035,
0.8791741729,
0.45527637,
-0.2932937741,
-0.3566664457,
-0.48927176,
0.174850896,
-0.2721240222,
-0.318557322,
1.0076829195,
0.0745376274,
0.0772951096,
0.5040817857,
-0.0253083445,
-0.2379031628,
-0.0351194479,
0.2262870818,
-0.1264294088,
-0.2419457585,
0.174316287,
0.0968102738,
-0.5753318667,
-0.0614765175,
-0.5749028921,
0.8940143585,
-0.0103260307,
-0.5245692134,
-0.354835242,
0.5395047069,
0.2500786781,
-0.2712174356,
1.0026984215,
0.6977296472,
-0.613239944,
-0.161883533,
-0.2938292623,
-0.639572978,
-0.4335833192,
0.6011121273,
-0.1566598862,
-0.9526695609,
0.5902641416,
-0.3155514896,
-0.3565892279,
0.7145291567,
0.822786808,
-0.2203265131,
0.5662947297,
0.9100581408,
-0.0037624806,
0.641361177,
-0.5423662066,
0.5047311187,
-0.5164337158,
-0.1009166688,
-0.3652507961,
-0.1649226397,
-1.0258728266,
-0.8945046067,
-0.105437465,
0.1407580376,
-0.0195568018,
0.4905051291,
-0.5052922368,
0.2990454435,
0.6551069021,
-0.0010379708,
-0.1465753317,
0.158504799,
0.058636874,
-0.2499447316,
-0.8302108645,
-0.7582965493,
0.8393364549,
0.455223918,
0.663944006,
0.0102832755,
0.7178416848,
0.2885604799,
0.4219283164,
-0.4945433438,
0.5184321404,
-0.6712200642,
-0.4429866672,
-0.2257645428,
-0.4340839088,
-0.9072549343,
0.2437444925,
-0.086445488,
-0.9365729094,
0.6500396729,
-0.097675778,
-0.129814893,
0.6922498345,
-0.1580389589,
1.0096153021,
0.2009245306,
-0.3048084974,
-0.3351510763,
-0.3570300937,
-0.0632735714,
0.0002588205,
-0.2097024769,
-0.0730310604,
0.1855949461,
0.8213655353,
-0.1251889914,
0.9593288302,
-0.2184088975,
-0.0898827463,
0.5035372972,
-0.1521992683,
0.2314053923,
0.4837173522,
-0.010114925,
0.0739130229,
-0.4339127839,
-0.2538253963,
-0.7948282361,
0.4660018086,
-0.8915096521,
-0.6821643114,
-0.4870417714,
-0.5111318231,
-0.0956118256,
-0.05887964,
0.3049734831,
0.4649390578,
-0.304553628,
0.4261417091,
0.7377279401,
-0.5450465083,
0.5628009439,
0.3500172198,
-0.2569830716,
-0.3220018744,
1.1177924871,
0.075981766,
-0.2566772997,
0.8336967826,
0.2394938916,
-0.1955535412,
-0.5577608347,
0.0775541589,
0.1463019252,
-0.7202214003,
-0.0352218784,
-1.0315369368,
-0.5189726353,
-0.102298677,
-0.0981028974,
-0.5800298452,
-0.4132086635,
-0.5818899274,
-0.1493189633,
0.3036910892,
0.6087580919,
-0.1239110231,
0.7280440927,
-0.4331634343,
0.6595743299,
0.4794225097,
0.3749118447,
-0.0602774061,
-0.5630376339,
0.0330718048,
-0.1600732654,
-0.6027691364,
-1.1224070787,
0.6569553018,
-0.1837678552,
0.8364323378,
0.068219468,
-0.0317438617,
-0.1606586576,
-0.4447087348,
0.915979445,
0.2447593957,
-0.7258650661,
0.6286555529,
-0.429784447,
0.1135761887,
0.0858603194,
0.5626194477,
-0.4251867831,
-0.5994389057,
-0.8128188848,
-1.1686370373,
0.4570084512,
0.5312624574,
0.5323088169,
-0.4306071699,
0.3101658821,
0.3176236153,
0.2074808329,
-0.7563050389,
-0.3105372488,
-0.5398605466,
-0.3916181326,
-0.0349615589,
-0.5362321138,
0.2140015215,
-0.1060517207,
0.6013147235,
-0.0717703328,
0.9103416204,
-0.1629645228,
-0.0877194628,
0.2153930664,
0.4021948576,
0.2076361328,
0.6003825068,
-0.3139011264,
0.3246907592,
-0.1162978411,
-0.2787936628,
0.386256218,
0.4854239821,
-0.1453429759,
0.3003472984,
0.1524933428,
0.8368862867,
0.2333782762,
-0.2011067271,
0.5312752724,
-0.3628419042,
-0.0790352374,
-0.1299098879,
-0.0347497426,
0.697307229,
0.3624919057,
0.5571722388,
0.0134868054,
0.0600956306,
-0.3865510225,
0.6637521982,
-0.0664979145,
-0.505096972,
-0.3617510498,
0.8603874445,
-0.0093924012,
-0.4473181963,
0.4368029237,
-0.4271313846,
-0.5242087841,
0.9358558059,
0.6339811683,
1.0712976456,
-0.2516070902,
0.6407430172,
0.105970785,
0.1378252208,
-0.1316571683,
0.4050315022,
0.192457363,
-0.7947592735,
-0.4142528772,
-0.5918877721,
-0.4686251283,
-0.0418011285,
-0.5322076082,
0.00653583,
0.0065253545,
-0.3283428848,
0.0028051811,
-0.2985802293,
-0.5292441249,
0.3696177602,
0.0688816607,
0.5984038711,
-0.9603791237,
0.9267835021,
0.7265560031,
-0.3053236902,
-0.3143576086,
0.5495428443,
-0.6939422488,
0.1620489061,
0.6059452295,
0.0850267112,
0.3604048789,
0.0244082697,
-0.1387064159,
-0.8892102838,
1.0425624847,
0.3510805964,
-0.6788482666,
0.0437456332,
0.4419050217,
0.6111193895,
-0.3317656219,
0.357940495,
0.1092236042,
0.017889563,
0.0258202385,
-0.2944627702,
-0.1711108088,
-0.0626572967,
0.2871306837,
0.1625496149,
-0.3763518333,
0.9809034467,
0.3223090172,
0.1678979844,
-0.1311050355,
1.0347626209,
0.1113318205,
0.0383193158,
0.2618559003,
0.6218240857,
0.4885802865,
-0.3700031638,
0.9930093884,
-0.6372274756,
0.5818074346,
0.9980271459,
-0.0510964356,
0.6220320463,
0.2866056859,
-0.2723250389,
0.3716089725,
0.6340914965,
0.0252169538,
1.0295020342,
0.243854478,
-0.1577386111,
-0.2444271445,
-0.0777705535,
-0.270894438,
0.4296605587,
0.4529663026,
-0.3908086717,
-0.3291990161,
0.155844003,
-0.4536184967,
0.0664775968,
0.1080278754,
0.7351787686,
0.2765214741,
-0.2691375911,
-0.1306465864,
0.4441438019,
0.8585857153,
-0.4279385805,
0.1014900208,
-0.4504181147,
-0.1314174533,
0.3327678442,
-0.8897025585,
0.6297592521,
-0.1972967088,
-0.4873062074,
-0.4241566956,
0.9109640121,
-0.5676373839,
-0.7204366326,
0.3220036924,
0.5873540044,
-0.2560396791,
-0.0879744515,
-0.5787060857,
-0.501946032,
-0.4320436418,
-0.5037600398,
0.1967783272,
0.6247300506,
-0.1595846415,
0.495531261,
0.1958762258,
-0.0976653993,
-0.0702230632,
0.3079502583,
0.8594714403,
-0.8186869025,
-0.8975134492,
-0.9525096416,
0.4705325067,
-0.0273527261,
-0.0924926475,
0.3416252732,
0.4082186222,
0.2405766398,
-0.138717711,
0.5686607361,
0.1307565719,
0.2813268006,
-0.3599230349,
0.713981092,
-0.3775341511,
0.2258376628,
-0.3066377938,
-1.000423789,
-0.2545598447,
0.7112323642,
-0.5315992832,
-0.0422852449,
0.4506706297,
0.6270688176,
-0.482953161,
0.2461614907,
0.3235131502,
0.1195433736,
0.515081346,
0.4402172565,
1.0301004648,
-0.1955828369,
0.1134019941,
-0.4243494272,
0.0066522555,
-0.2091266513,
-0.8835606575,
-0.7331001163,
-0.8698886037,
-0.6187584996,
0.1731414199,
-0.0147190131,
0.6566827893,
0.7440987825,
-0.8581518531,
0.0087578176,
-0.5378651619,
0.2539497614,
-0.0355821699,
-0.2854641378,
0.606706202,
-0.0351867862,
-0.347011745,
0.1480886191,
0.371563822,
0.138304621,
-0.3942483664,
0.2273127884,
-0.1466501802,
0.1758816391,
0.4261038899,
-0.3732999265,
-0.6997082829,
0.0713099539,
-0.0377321802,
-0.1396750957,
0.2901917994,
0.9036179781,
-0.9042916298,
0.1354263872,
0.4109677374,
0.8502634168,
0.7289351821,
-0.2443495095,
0.708401978,
-0.8724421263,
0.2882665098,
0.5264943242,
0.5188528895,
0.3436480165,
-0.1705868244,
0.2210033983,
0.3243991137,
-0.2611152828,
-0.6136962175,
0.3033390045,
-0.7284047604,
-0.6434441209,
0.8097372055,
0.0066171023,
0.0351040848,
-0.0186246783,
-0.0540434569,
0.5522523522,
-0.198561579,
0.8335438967,
0.4625178277,
0.1146405861,
-0.440769285,
-0.4696242809,
-0.0037805329,
0.4262977839,
-0.8487591743,
-0.1370672286,
-0.0079928609,
0.20187819,
0.3202698529,
0.443821162,
0.1502044499,
0.0969502181,
0.0004714571,
-0.0077072093,
0.3860663772,
-0.541528523,
-0.2116452157,
0.5328877568,
-0.2231074721,
0.0817240328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03690v1
|
Rapidly Developing High-quality Instruction Data and Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models with Minimal Human Effort: A Case Study on Japanese
| 2024-03-06T13:17:07 | 2024-03-06T13:17:07 |
Yikun Sun, Zhen Wan, Nobuhiro Ueda, Sakiko Yahata, Fei Cheng, Chenhui Chu, Sadao Kurohashi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The creation of instruction data and evaluation benchmarks for serving Large
language models often involves enormous human annotation. This issue becomes
particularly pronounced when rapidly developing such resources for a
non-English language like Japanese. Instead of following the popular practice
of directly translating existing English resources into Japanese (e.g.,
Japanese-Alpaca), we propose an efficient self-instruct method based on GPT-4.
We first translate a small amount of English instructions into Japanese and
post-edit them to obtain native-level quality. GPT-4 then utilizes them as
demonstrations to automatically generate Japanese instruction data. We also
construct an evaluation benchmark containing 80 questions across 8 categories,
using GPT-4 to automatically assess the response quality of LLMs without human
references. The empirical results suggest that the models fine-tuned on our
GPT-4 self-instruct data significantly outperformed the Japanese-Alpaca across
all three base pre-trained models. Our GPT-4 self-instruct data allowed the
LLaMA 13B model to defeat GPT-3.5 (Davinci-003) with a 54.37\% win-rate. The
human evaluation exhibits the consistency between GPT-4's assessments and human
preference. Our high-quality instruction data and evaluation benchmark have
been released here.
|
[
-0.3794886172,
-0.7813074589,
0.6076206565,
0.1551199853,
-0.1596404463,
0.0726462081,
-0.3504047692,
-0.4026251733,
-0.1313758492,
0.4237262607,
-0.4746025503,
-0.6754983068,
-0.4111934006,
0.2578604519,
-0.1083446741,
0.9624914527,
-0.2529678941,
0.1091932431,
0.0343129747,
-0.065500088,
-0.5062897205,
-0.57136935,
-0.6480936408,
-0.286108464,
0.1423235387,
0.4263568223,
0.7294251323,
0.8311822414,
0.3902680576,
0.3068258762,
0.424464047,
0.1242408976,
-0.3714868128,
-0.1807860881,
-0.1990715116,
-0.3713603616,
-0.3755907118,
0.3137747645,
0.6589894891,
0.5510314703,
-0.2759554088,
0.404088974,
0.1390224099,
0.5081363916,
-0.4931059182,
0.3957183957,
-0.3279550076,
0.1690044105,
-0.2540943325,
-0.209241882,
-0.3804145753,
-0.4958815575,
0.0175481327,
-0.8068606853,
0.4564758241,
-0.0233543497,
0.7167295218,
0.2421357781,
-0.1897422224,
-0.2949751914,
-0.5032397509,
0.6594933271,
-0.6457510591,
0.443048656,
0.6327142119,
0.2972642183,
-0.287559092,
-0.5534597635,
-0.3874130547,
-0.4665898681,
0.1517772228,
0.2685117722,
0.0222930703,
-0.0227953531,
0.3056251407,
0.222576648,
-0.6628943682,
0.3742053211,
-0.1390099972,
-0.1652274132,
0.6378090382,
0.1261209697,
0.29346928,
-0.2692807317,
-0.2029676139,
-0.3696312308,
-0.7696689963,
-0.1733160913,
0.4732344151,
0.1758152097,
-0.0312822536,
0.4251691103,
-0.2988094985,
0.3850697875,
0.1438505054,
-0.2974501848,
0.311169982,
-0.2906227112,
0.1060568243,
-0.0557386912,
1.0599762201,
0.3588757217,
0.1492326558,
-0.2227490693,
-0.2857733667,
0.1051542386,
0.1420088708,
-0.9829207063,
-0.1805697829,
-0.4003424942,
-0.3971183598,
0.089136377,
-0.2318311632,
-0.7893615961,
-0.0454002209,
-0.109950386,
0.6940607429,
-0.3547230661,
0.0528202318,
0.1249357238,
0.3297895193,
0.3208135664,
0.2932027578,
-0.993914783,
0.4501827061,
0.4494222105,
0.6807125807,
-0.1803195179,
-0.3846066594,
-0.2375820428,
0.1299170107,
-0.4962481558,
0.7014238238,
-0.4390432239,
-0.5794875622,
-0.359402597,
0.0574534908,
0.1661830544,
-0.4642065465,
0.5026484132,
-0.2877989411,
0.5504855514,
-0.2207667977,
-0.667073369,
-0.2162345052,
0.1316690296,
-0.5482698679,
0.967905581,
0.2172463983,
-0.5470735431,
0.1852614284,
-0.8973274827,
-0.4351278543,
0.2230047286,
-0.289978683,
-0.3915627897,
-0.1050121263,
0.5681230426,
0.496937871,
-0.5339252949,
0.1646928787,
-0.152810514,
-0.5221120119,
-0.1011748463,
-0.801609993,
0.4157918394,
0.0102081597,
-0.7551509738,
-0.3470954001,
-0.6240730882,
0.095056884,
0.4946101308,
-0.3178016245,
-0.2649053335,
-0.155565843,
-0.5706778765,
-0.0505840033,
0.303254813,
-0.4234804511,
0.4343096912,
-0.1795041114,
0.2189477235,
0.7245755196,
0.1314572692,
0.2881730199,
0.0815875232,
0.7068681121,
-0.3997437954,
0.375743866,
-0.2664412558,
-0.6061677337,
-0.7097614408,
0.0527783856,
0.1866583675,
0.3676708937,
-0.8525740504,
0.2280867696,
-0.1341599375,
-0.5567254424,
-0.8027921319,
0.3071279526,
0.6658271551,
0.6464624405,
0.495975852,
-0.4672531188,
-0.1564959586,
-1.0025264025,
0.0222241729,
-0.163614884,
-0.00817612,
0.0775179639,
0.3054035008,
-0.2682087719,
0.4359455407,
-0.4358739257,
0.0030324031,
-0.0421248749,
0.450651288,
0.2029109597,
0.4354529679,
0.4348238707,
-0.1493453085,
-0.4775443375,
0.0124920988,
-0.7815262675,
-0.1076021418,
0.01031294,
-0.3715579212,
0.1553454697,
0.0850628689,
-0.4002974331,
0.2926816344,
0.4277566671,
-0.0627664477,
0.4303829074,
-0.4366747439,
0.5093000531,
-0.8761165142,
-0.0318718925,
0.1272844374,
-0.0836130157,
-0.2837908566,
0.0839476287,
0.2786456347,
-0.1458200067,
-0.1595942676,
0.4560884237,
-0.5995109081,
-0.2625565231,
-0.210616082,
0.0019747857,
-0.0066787936,
0.7160542607,
0.1226058453,
1.1268123388,
0.0532589294,
-0.3172335625,
0.1783022583,
0.2286754847,
-0.5039661527,
0.2923460901,
-0.5705690384,
0.4574929774,
0.0134391543,
0.1888514161,
-0.690192163,
-0.2166941315,
0.3759691715,
-0.1151383594,
0.357062608,
-0.3260335922,
-0.5488792062,
-0.4422676563,
-0.1531467587,
0.1739180684,
0.6897016168,
-0.758169353,
0.1689305305,
0.2143173665,
-0.2872523367,
-0.6220581532,
-0.4226904213,
0.0543228462,
-0.1598344743,
-0.0881060362,
0.1296950728,
-0.1864451468,
0.2411312908,
0.0256861076,
-0.0375209749,
-0.1447962523,
0.0878395587,
0.0740546137,
0.3760256767,
-0.2856535316,
-0.078557089,
0.0588531867,
-0.2325385213,
0.1101713851,
-0.0546606369,
0.4184367955,
-0.2352175862,
-0.6561159492,
-0.8812670708,
0.1853783578,
0.2101811022,
-0.2637073994,
0.2173221856,
0.5745218992,
-0.0556745976,
-0.2060325891,
-0.7396234274,
-0.1685578674,
-0.5048177242,
0.5505045652,
-0.4284697473,
-0.5914538503,
0.1752286106,
0.1293841749,
0.0830793902,
0.4146568775,
0.3682943285,
-0.0695328563,
1.1899774075,
0.3780903816,
-0.2223928869,
0.3708743751,
-0.4288091063,
-0.1501700133,
-0.645650208,
-0.1187631488,
-0.3499220908,
-0.0431812927,
-0.6483361721,
-0.5348676443,
0.4558647275,
-0.1017018855,
-0.3792090118,
0.3974312246,
-0.5606233478,
0.7064731121,
0.5298197269,
0.1037344337,
0.3469350934,
-0.0064698663,
0.117261529,
-0.2628732324,
-0.6461443901,
-0.6156059504,
1.3630138636,
0.3951584399,
1.0205470324,
-0.0000983524,
1.0044051409,
0.2755356133,
0.6619757414,
-0.5972389579,
0.4774687588,
-0.1004620045,
-0.4262154102,
-0.3219634295,
-0.6471878886,
-1.0465905666,
0.0659513846,
0.0012164672,
-0.3004589677,
-0.263052702,
0.0741882101,
-0.2884574533,
0.1004425436,
-0.9510149956,
0.9454760551,
-0.6739522219,
-0.4285641611,
-0.1927018166,
-0.3444769681,
0.4084435999,
-0.1996827871,
0.2300519347,
-0.2647536099,
-0.1644768119,
0.9153829217,
-0.300041765,
0.8265427351,
-0.4234822989,
-0.1914702803,
0.3705802858,
0.0714461282,
0.4915321469,
-0.0375596359,
-0.194594264,
0.1432916522,
-0.151515767,
-0.4395140707,
-0.8388673067,
0.6238939166,
-1.1151036024,
-0.6912671328,
-0.1619459391,
-0.2387625575,
-0.3798883557,
0.1144939661,
0.2579748034,
0.4561558068,
-0.2921522558,
-0.0771351382,
0.3846006691,
-0.3190269172,
0.4122602046,
0.8039956689,
-0.0202580355,
-0.5273332596,
0.9718508124,
0.3835416436,
0.2492887825,
0.1848168373,
0.3474971652,
-0.497996062,
-0.4919696152,
-0.8883812428,
0.3969675303,
-0.7259148955,
-0.2669817507,
-0.2616166174,
-0.051535964,
-0.0990534201,
-0.0055146432,
-0.6889309883,
-0.0968539268,
-0.0084550101,
-0.0586651862,
0.162726,
1.0892498493,
0.0914462209,
0.3949243128,
-0.7437360883,
0.31181705,
0.4132110476,
0.4465750158,
0.1502140313,
-0.6666172147,
-0.4452067018,
0.0501551069,
-0.4603658617,
-0.8139173388,
0.34818694,
0.1481139064,
0.7313789725,
0.2901196182,
-0.0429436043,
0.9076916575,
-0.6745932698,
0.6494984627,
0.1615792662,
-0.9717977047,
0.5289310813,
-0.1801273376,
0.2824468017,
0.6383731961,
0.6750904322,
-0.3166496754,
-0.1745395362,
-0.6974125504,
-0.573235929,
0.6592472792,
-0.0470030755,
0.1687344313,
-0.1681183875,
0.5694777369,
0.4139903188,
0.0044391234,
-0.6485111117,
-0.0021463274,
-0.4156480432,
-0.207830295,
-0.2249889076,
-0.0520137735,
0.2151044458,
-0.1828215271,
0.7106786966,
-0.233673349,
0.177293852,
0.0281153861,
-0.1060143039,
0.0658818558,
0.1711901128,
0.1221546158,
0.4903210998,
-0.0615225919,
-0.0947267413,
0.360357523,
-0.4088934362,
0.5355163217,
0.0511062033,
-0.2098442614,
-0.1923991144,
0.4670508206,
0.7120758295,
0.4226641953,
-0.442448318,
0.5780549049,
-0.1614263356,
0.0817374736,
-0.1153928116,
0.1759959161,
-0.0414117575,
-0.077188991,
0.1739507765,
-0.5281901956,
0.2190394551,
-0.5534163117,
0.0498377308,
0.2374712825,
0.0202940218,
-0.4668079615,
0.5495716929,
0.3643180728,
-0.0496162288,
0.6256979108,
-0.5299566388,
-0.34745121,
0.3313431144,
0.7963457704,
0.5998671651,
-0.56272614,
0.252004534,
0.7255896926,
0.2827450037,
-0.3661361039,
0.1382419616,
-0.22716479,
-0.5846232176,
-0.7077055573,
-0.4058041275,
-0.7222779393,
0.3049552143,
-0.7154387832,
0.0347550437,
-0.6430661082,
-0.160439685,
-0.1352086961,
0.3587701023,
-0.8510271311,
0.1582927257,
0.0930880383,
0.4987929165,
-0.8970295191,
0.8816061616,
0.4345494509,
-0.5875996947,
-1.0650347471,
-0.0239472445,
-0.2086703777,
-1.085701704,
0.5815718174,
0.1739597023,
-0.1584897041,
0.1242116541,
-0.5967837572,
-0.9001206756,
0.9514355659,
0.557495594,
-0.6073263288,
0.0479567647,
0.0835589394,
0.4842517972,
-0.1460844576,
0.4809367359,
0.6687088013,
0.4642111659,
-0.1651737988,
-0.7682493925,
0.027523851,
-0.1652886868,
0.0244210269,
0.1299642622,
-0.7426573634,
0.4399245083,
-0.1287233531,
-0.3441014588,
0.0801126435,
0.7368224263,
0.0829524472,
0.0366083346,
0.3257185221,
0.4803025424,
0.7260161042,
0.0197595842,
1.0982717276,
-0.2273914069,
0.2212619036,
1.2757928371,
-0.2796466053,
0.9036952853,
0.0094545726,
-0.4461806715,
0.3625371158,
0.604531765,
-0.0887576565,
0.3009052873,
0.1177616864,
-0.1267717928,
-0.1576981843,
0.0164833292,
-0.4620223939,
0.7466987967,
0.193457827,
-0.0537373051,
-0.2207662165,
-0.0715987235,
0.2443809509,
0.0976395383,
-0.1332272589,
0.7475175858,
-0.2285967022,
-0.8104991913,
0.7701753974,
0.0051829051,
0.6888262033,
-0.6769666672,
-0.1334469169,
-0.552378118,
-0.0917291641,
0.0254218858,
-0.7491576076,
-0.1001620069,
0.4054671228,
0.0473678708,
0.0281190071,
0.1631538719,
-0.3461546302,
-0.4512941539,
0.2261641473,
0.4414626658,
0.5080533624,
0.3281705678,
-0.6379843354,
0.0306251533,
0.0285488702,
-0.4429842234,
0.4196306467,
0.3229171634,
-0.1949844658,
0.6990753412,
0.619343996,
0.046187982,
-0.1076501235,
0.2062332183,
0.4995416403,
-0.6743971705,
-0.2564936578,
-0.6465905905,
-0.0313225873,
-0.0098499535,
-0.2910214067,
0.7898536921,
0.5350553393,
0.9044390917,
-0.0286460817,
0.8652258515,
0.2539007068,
0.439104408,
-0.5628863573,
0.6125770211,
-0.3109239638,
0.0793300867,
-0.2444558144,
-0.9701206684,
0.0084659504,
0.7116369605,
-0.3690876365,
0.1731202453,
0.5284961462,
0.7744726539,
-0.0616349168,
-0.0216764901,
0.3711591065,
0.1082526669,
0.3799525797,
0.6125807762,
0.9413119555,
-0.3874790668,
0.4759028554,
-0.6088660955,
-0.4016908407,
-0.0033514332,
-0.9516828656,
-0.7103592157,
-0.3326562047,
-0.3513211608,
-0.0304969065,
0.0997404382,
1.1526571512,
0.7404567003,
-0.6105996966,
-0.3584692776,
0.2761917412,
-0.2532300949,
-0.1061424091,
-0.152935341,
0.6385801435,
-0.4508503079,
-0.8633795381,
0.7487689853,
0.1021899953,
0.2243912965,
-0.4162526727,
-0.2654190063,
0.231140092,
-0.1716344953,
0.4767481089,
0.4119967222,
-0.5984603763,
-0.3799310327,
-0.2243616283,
-0.1535008401,
0.0852195695,
0.3765517473,
-0.6304425001,
0.5691643357,
0.0064171702,
0.9696380496,
0.6216964722,
0.0540356189,
0.6464195848,
-0.4507589638,
0.0640853643,
0.0573253892,
0.3559332192,
0.6004434228,
-0.2931123972,
0.8409978151,
0.1676236689,
-0.6496085525,
-0.4333702624,
-0.1012175605,
-0.5765044689,
0.0211646575,
0.9434494972,
-0.3812740147,
-0.2934453189,
0.2073543668,
-0.272928983,
0.2676345706,
-0.4729985595,
0.9300016165,
0.5333715677,
-0.2323833704,
-0.0438771695,
-0.8638371825,
0.3089365661,
0.2859984934,
-1.0308579206,
0.0238864701,
0.5179436803,
0.4370774329,
-0.0728849545,
0.665245533,
-0.1465544105,
0.3400395811,
0.0570750311,
0.4737381041,
-0.1615618914,
-0.0881294087,
-0.1846304387,
0.0429333635,
0.3208142221,
-0.2739251852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03689v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03689v2
|
General2Specialized LLMs Translation for E-commerce
| 2024-03-06T13:15:21 | 2024-04-06T04:07:49 |
Kaidi Chen, Ben Chen, Dehong Gao, Huangyu Dai, Wen Jiang, Wei Ning, Shanqing Yu, Libin Yang, Xiaoyan Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models mainly handle translation in
the general domain, while overlooking domains with special writing formulas,
such as e-commerce and legal documents. Taking e-commerce as an example, the
texts usually include amounts of domain-related words and have more grammar
problems, which leads to inferior performances of current NMT methods. To
address these problems, we collect two domain-related resources, including a
set of term pairs (aligned Chinese-English bilingual terms) and a parallel
corpus annotated for the e-commerce domain. Furthermore, we propose a two-step
fine-tuning paradigm (named G2ST) with self-contrastive semantic enhancement to
transfer one general NMT model to the specialized NMT model for e-commerce. The
paradigm can be used for the NMT models based on Large language models (LLMs).
Extensive evaluations on real e-commerce titles demonstrate the superior
translation quality and robustness of our G2ST approach, as compared with
state-of-the-art NMT models such as LLaMA, Qwen, GPT-3.5, and even GPT-4.
|
[
-0.0459489711,
-0.7903088927,
0.315451771,
0.0860864073,
-0.813030839,
-0.0514549054,
-0.4145134091,
-0.8473871946,
0.2488321662,
0.5626356006,
-0.6451339722,
-0.3898240328,
-0.4908124804,
0.1597800702,
-0.2910336554,
1.2420712709,
-0.0878920779,
0.1697406471,
0.0666165352,
0.0753001943,
-0.2221606225,
-0.5710927844,
-0.9202103019,
-0.1617901027,
0.3389871716,
-0.0093519725,
0.6371631026,
0.5813965201,
0.7235031128,
0.2771702409,
0.1799028814,
0.542293787,
-0.4257082641,
0.0639215633,
-0.5715914965,
-0.3940317035,
-0.9833733439,
-0.2030737996,
-0.0879057571,
0.2467700392,
-0.2482313961,
0.2786603272,
0.3918016255,
0.6274601221,
-0.1719063222,
0.1210636497,
-0.5551781058,
-0.123265788,
0.1982658654,
-0.244791925,
-0.3507117033,
-0.1482067257,
0.1268558949,
-1.0799857378,
0.2943001986,
0.3781298697,
1.0235872269,
0.237125203,
-0.6480469108,
-0.2651895583,
-0.7598229051,
0.8789292574,
-0.5412421823,
0.400691092,
0.4368299544,
0.1902864724,
0.0820813552,
-1.0269014835,
-0.1733466685,
-0.029008422,
-0.2766495645,
0.4919650555,
-0.3909066617,
0.0956599265,
-0.112495251,
0.2104821652,
-0.7403873801,
0.1482756883,
-0.2669210732,
0.0345460549,
0.6697519422,
0.3082934916,
0.3413141966,
0.1659780592,
-0.7158373594,
0.2961610854,
-0.7652205229,
-0.3270719647,
0.195486024,
0.396692276,
-0.0510787964,
0.3593696952,
-0.3803101182,
0.6286528707,
0.2443357855,
-0.0393516086,
0.1270142645,
-0.6840578914,
-0.3833285272,
-0.2918679714,
0.4982713759,
0.8787828088,
0.192332834,
-0.3218458891,
-0.4521600008,
-0.2791295648,
0.3638780117,
-0.8250002265,
-0.0412813537,
0.2269795686,
-0.5895266533,
0.0100084683,
0.0219267383,
-0.6429446936,
-0.0467555523,
-0.785926342,
0.5459626913,
0.0630919784,
-0.2289598733,
0.2832713723,
0.184236303,
0.2019431442,
0.3715359867,
-0.9536217451,
0.6249671578,
0.9524132609,
0.8766220212,
-0.3536750376,
-0.0508383475,
0.0219600741,
0.4737026691,
-0.2266122997,
0.5903512836,
0.0156561024,
0.088210389,
0.1102149263,
0.1860963702,
0.0334935077,
-0.4658654034,
0.6500245929,
-0.8319937587,
-0.0092216199,
-0.170092985,
-0.5389565229,
-0.3802797794,
0.7319392562,
-0.4911790788,
0.4489578605,
-0.0080229454,
-0.3821179867,
0.064553991,
-0.297914803,
-0.6517413259,
0.0914646611,
0.0944057405,
-0.4696741402,
0.2366824299,
0.2162797898,
0.4714619815,
-0.8168724775,
0.1493929774,
0.0588634275,
-0.3362642229,
-0.0972312391,
-0.187761277,
0.5599571466,
0.402164638,
-0.4907023907,
-0.2067876756,
-0.4067241848,
0.1229142025,
0.3712246418,
-0.1685554087,
-0.3548508286,
-0.0390657298,
0.3163372874,
0.3538327515,
0.5422015786,
-0.1829541475,
0.3446926475,
-0.4122876823,
0.6936100125,
0.5365778208,
-0.1118379533,
0.3906899095,
-0.2049358487,
0.5489464998,
0.0009327839,
0.3385896981,
0.0469794422,
-0.7562466264,
-1.0154018402,
0.1215275005,
0.4526280463,
0.7165783048,
-0.6934307218,
0.3451958001,
-0.4758941829,
-0.0718847811,
-0.3835240006,
0.1089627594,
0.3881186247,
0.2379162014,
0.7490763664,
-0.3193838298,
-0.2193774283,
-1.2903248072,
-0.3625818789,
0.025975151,
-0.1883330941,
0.2925934494,
0.1712613404,
-0.3814198077,
0.4360534251,
-0.3724479377,
-0.6690627337,
-0.1194313094,
0.1953194886,
0.2668210566,
0.4480682015,
0.2090939283,
-0.8765944242,
-0.7897943258,
0.521079421,
-0.3427368701,
-0.2032725513,
-0.4743458331,
-0.1803210825,
0.2721220553,
0.4408728778,
-0.5231220722,
0.2102999538,
0.3341083229,
-0.2288600206,
0.2910068333,
-0.5388332605,
0.3461163938,
-1.2605637312,
-0.2652633488,
0.2388751209,
-0.3129940629,
-0.7676284909,
0.3825002611,
0.4610395133,
0.3686314523,
-0.571082294,
0.1882260591,
-0.6173126698,
-0.1827694923,
-0.3918073475,
0.3170528412,
0.3873375058,
0.4564509094,
0.0042688735,
0.8557682633,
-0.1092580482,
-0.7646496892,
0.3248369396,
0.2648401558,
-0.1145192534,
0.7135288119,
-0.6990462542,
0.0901015252,
0.1633681953,
0.0812637433,
-0.6375869513,
0.0442252792,
0.5084354281,
-0.3038894236,
0.5076509714,
-0.3112337291,
-0.7314041853,
-0.1086581722,
0.0511701107,
0.4024557769,
0.5723756552,
-0.5298680663,
0.5552964807,
0.0282784365,
-0.3578806221,
-0.2899032533,
-1.1772608757,
0.4371705353,
-0.0732242242,
-0.9216481447,
0.6795974374,
-0.0447556116,
0.081623666,
-0.07493487,
0.2479967624,
-0.0839189067,
0.274525106,
-0.4999590218,
0.2676027119,
-0.4977164865,
0.2002079934,
0.3118605316,
-0.2819388807,
0.0426199362,
-0.8921932578,
0.2082366347,
0.0632873699,
-0.3646315932,
-0.3349596262,
0.434158504,
0.0492698364,
-0.361043781,
0.3360945582,
0.3890478909,
-0.3920613229,
-0.3075095713,
-0.4163619578,
-0.1746874452,
-0.4809651673,
0.5505554676,
-0.5063129663,
-0.9653664827,
0.2543827891,
-0.1535652578,
-0.1318100989,
0.6169009209,
0.7338544726,
0.1113062501,
1.0724797249,
0.6664998531,
0.2530948222,
0.0185592566,
0.0888599753,
0.693179667,
-0.8805940747,
-0.2870490253,
-0.3090046346,
-0.4859700799,
-0.751470685,
-0.525161922,
-0.0606645346,
0.3319355547,
-0.3854320943,
0.6038161516,
-0.5369355679,
0.7024160028,
0.5098963976,
0.2242455184,
0.4888732135,
0.4858430922,
-0.1029732525,
-0.2426943332,
-0.3049830198,
-0.4131258726,
1.0916033983,
0.1960446388,
0.4542288482,
0.6101155281,
0.3016088009,
0.0504805185,
0.1562985778,
-0.9381460547,
0.2481947392,
-0.6990500689,
-0.4711170197,
0.1375323087,
-0.2341154069,
-0.7896599174,
0.3807030022,
0.1143623814,
-0.4650245607,
0.0555439703,
0.0270070191,
-0.5070677996,
0.1877607256,
-0.5340331197,
0.755284071,
-0.7868942022,
-0.9034747481,
-0.2495108247,
-0.561447978,
0.1583313793,
-0.2903242111,
0.3019799292,
0.0580616705,
-0.6663994193,
0.2159495205,
-0.2088876963,
0.7357205153,
0.3951756954,
-0.164367646,
0.0880359858,
0.3061086237,
0.8238711953,
-0.2701319456,
0.221305266,
0.2335396707,
-0.3215325475,
-0.3409226239,
-0.5814153552,
0.5710015297,
-0.6265798211,
-0.7167621851,
-0.1922171414,
-0.2040342838,
-0.3064703643,
0.3047532737,
0.3002292216,
-0.2086498886,
-0.2109021842,
0.023911003,
0.5538391471,
-0.0819612145,
0.1262828708,
0.7611497045,
-0.101265274,
-0.4915643036,
0.9286292791,
0.0291421656,
0.5473056436,
0.4709345996,
0.2234839797,
-0.4953760803,
-0.7894861102,
-0.6967154145,
0.0759190097,
-0.7954295874,
-0.4800226092,
-0.6069794893,
-0.0017401989,
-0.4953741133,
-0.281645745,
-0.0952274352,
-0.6269536018,
-0.5019096136,
-0.1223363206,
0.2426870614,
0.7967965007,
-0.1000023931,
0.4210351408,
-0.9235015512,
0.4971942306,
0.3628242314,
0.3306016326,
-0.0505666584,
-0.7564018369,
-0.5545598865,
0.0738336816,
-0.1881451309,
-0.4730923772,
0.5086367726,
0.2421149313,
0.4011954665,
0.4770203829,
-0.2162936479,
0.6280858517,
-0.7333795428,
0.9404148459,
0.4082370698,
-0.826993227,
0.3243646622,
-0.6408450007,
-0.15419586,
0.3325744569,
0.4412696064,
-0.72197932,
0.0119556207,
-0.3313409686,
-1.2323057652,
0.6679293513,
0.2366845459,
0.3601908386,
-0.1459732354,
0.3694202006,
0.0392418802,
0.2248127311,
-0.6408268213,
-0.1626874804,
0.0395008661,
-0.2492367625,
-0.174184382,
-0.4137538075,
0.1121506169,
-0.1383032203,
0.8830288649,
-0.0693318844,
0.0418536589,
-0.0008400727,
-0.3458128572,
-0.0278486405,
0.2900770605,
0.6702335477,
0.4347811341,
0.1795712411,
-0.2126387209,
-0.0520309396,
-0.4127444923,
0.1512224823,
-0.1169277951,
-0.5312271118,
-0.2723456323,
-0.18253842,
0.395442605,
0.2016457915,
-0.1204814687,
0.5805592537,
0.1056869701,
-0.2483448982,
-0.2251587808,
-0.3614122272,
0.3419592083,
0.3700182736,
-0.0256199222,
-0.0475251824,
0.6006889343,
-0.1494067609,
0.3649929166,
0.1367011219,
-0.1385663599,
-0.1919151545,
0.9047814608,
0.463724643,
-0.2540168762,
0.6668124199,
-0.3721985519,
-0.6840187907,
0.7508468628,
1.0095127821,
1.3776488304,
-0.1630129814,
0.1076615378,
0.5750509501,
0.7752687931,
-0.563487947,
0.120409213,
0.1894201189,
-0.4693711102,
-0.4292688072,
-0.5530043244,
-0.4577757418,
-0.1274275333,
-0.7639194727,
0.3797318935,
-0.3573701978,
-0.1043013409,
-0.4339675903,
-0.0280213673,
-0.7345479727,
0.2785431147,
0.2468013465,
0.4319289327,
-0.5610112548,
0.9673685431,
0.468757093,
-0.5531496406,
-0.4222380519,
-0.1773202121,
0.0126680685,
-0.7716174126,
0.6294665933,
0.1732579768,
-0.2478785217,
0.1660321206,
-0.1113803163,
-0.8022769094,
1.2600549459,
0.1629450023,
-1.1312068701,
0.2313285917,
0.6683200598,
0.5976728797,
-0.5133530498,
0.0790565163,
0.6617978215,
0.4300988317,
-0.2265853584,
-0.7685120106,
0.131621629,
-0.2641585171,
0.2258737981,
0.1982690841,
-0.8357335925,
1.0381349325,
0.0984591544,
-0.2508155107,
0.4202487767,
0.2808197439,
-0.1408418566,
0.1169270203,
0.1097271219,
0.7346339226,
0.7738077044,
-0.1232978925,
0.8693729639,
-0.4572297037,
0.6010760665,
1.3959364891,
-0.233511582,
0.965461731,
0.3286799192,
-0.2034260035,
0.0963224322,
0.7261859179,
-0.3567951322,
0.3907325566,
0.3346915543,
-0.0803662762,
-0.5063968897,
-0.01328272,
-0.3588769436,
-0.0161047522,
0.4453167021,
-0.5369102359,
-0.1329512745,
-0.4090179503,
-0.0890966877,
0.023073459,
-0.4787297845,
0.6847634912,
0.3364410698,
-0.2050349265,
0.4603226185,
0.5200625062,
0.8597123027,
-0.3980410099,
0.0597799048,
-0.3352896273,
0.2291070223,
-0.1014750674,
-0.3994944692,
0.2748592794,
-0.0075214747,
-0.0199211501,
-0.4314746261,
0.8389174938,
-0.4923939109,
-0.6339370608,
0.737128377,
0.6620634794,
0.1090614423,
-0.2836467922,
-0.9555112123,
-0.3995507658,
-0.0887911543,
-0.4147053063,
0.4162788689,
0.5322369337,
-0.0863959417,
0.2271349877,
0.5711749792,
-0.1587494016,
0.0898070857,
0.0709007904,
0.4763391912,
-0.8098393679,
-0.6988841891,
-0.8324263692,
0.503211081,
-0.1152135208,
-0.3126739264,
0.6820541024,
0.6885501742,
1.110588789,
-0.0814428926,
0.7852081656,
0.5537009835,
0.2686574459,
-0.6018930674,
0.8384869695,
-0.9236577153,
0.3488191664,
0.156190902,
-1.0710737705,
-0.5466731787,
0.4752287567,
0.0451666228,
-0.154632315,
0.7737694979,
0.7173480392,
-0.3001337051,
0.0172591899,
0.7331055999,
0.2436904907,
-0.0446762927,
0.6943104863,
0.5162733793,
-0.787453115,
0.5594314933,
-0.236103043,
-0.0831156373,
-0.464667201,
-0.8898304701,
-0.5874396563,
-0.1388285309,
-0.539781034,
-0.3428396881,
0.2073312253,
1.1243349314,
0.3924308419,
-0.889801085,
-0.234684974,
0.1170689464,
-0.3459058702,
-0.4208465517,
-0.0197878312,
0.2799720764,
-0.5534960628,
-0.8674849272,
0.1890465617,
0.443077445,
0.2653472126,
0.0904970765,
-0.1092721596,
0.2035636753,
0.2667326331,
0.9140657187,
-0.2923771143,
-0.942718029,
-0.0664217845,
0.2417230159,
-0.1968292743,
0.2227774709,
0.7764974833,
-0.1387096047,
0.2827209234,
0.3271399438,
0.7717844844,
0.3905450404,
-0.0408503376,
0.4871498644,
-0.2380931228,
0.0543153584,
0.2098271996,
0.4164313972,
0.2035288215,
-0.3854989111,
0.6114781499,
0.2039341629,
-0.5239946246,
-0.0386345573,
0.53430444,
-0.9693421125,
-0.4694239199,
1.3495758772,
-0.2718006074,
-0.2785698771,
-0.3791413605,
0.0425079577,
0.1088954657,
-0.1369771212,
0.4876449108,
0.558858633,
0.3678791821,
0.0572768264,
-0.7332983613,
0.160721451,
0.4191137254,
-0.6497814059,
0.0551808141,
0.4721187949,
0.2936536372,
-0.2326916754,
0.4593965113,
-0.0586330704,
0.2794627845,
-0.2562442422,
0.0527121238,
-0.1303874254,
-0.2264983207,
-0.4812065363,
-0.0978593379,
0.1796294153,
-0.0089164851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03640v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03640v3
|
Apollo: A Lightweight Multilingual Medical LLM towards Democratizing Medical AI to 6B People
| 2024-03-06T11:56:02 | 2024-06-28T06:16:24 |
Xidong Wang, Nuo Chen, Junyin Chen, Yan Hu, Yidong Wang, Xiangbo Wu, Anningzhe Gao, Xiang Wan, Haizhou Li, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the vast repository of global medical knowledge predominantly being
in English, local languages are crucial for delivering tailored healthcare
services, particularly in areas with limited medical resources. To extend the
reach of medical AI advancements to a broader population, we aim to develop
medical LLMs across the six most widely spoken languages, encompassing a global
population of 6.1 billion. This effort culminates in the creation of the
ApolloCorpora multilingual medical dataset and the XMedBench benchmark. In the
multilingual medical benchmark, the released Apollo models, at various
relatively-small sizes (i.e., 0.5B, 1.8B, 2B, 6B, and 7B), achieve the best
performance among models of equivalent size. Especially, Apollo-7B is the
state-of-the-art multilingual medical LLMs up to 70B. Additionally, these lite
models could be used to improve the multi-lingual medical capabilities of
larger models without fine-tuning in a proxy-tuning fashion. We will
open-source training corpora, code, model weights and evaluation benchmark.
|
[
-0.1839287132,
-0.215703547,
0.6418945789,
0.0707072765,
-0.4054053426,
0.0921781063,
-0.2421804667,
-0.8744128346,
0.3787078559,
0.3618778586,
-0.2096750438,
-0.6136943102,
-0.7836377025,
0.4644754231,
-0.0960259661,
0.6965858936,
0.1411695629,
0.7818101645,
0.0193134435,
-0.5407629013,
-0.1882503331,
-0.240867734,
-0.750126183,
-0.2274833024,
0.7812356949,
0.4644344151,
0.8667655587,
0.8624264002,
0.4272182286,
0.37066257,
-0.003096262,
0.1271539778,
-0.3511615694,
-0.041503422,
-0.1112538204,
-0.7283286452,
-0.4214583635,
-0.1413360387,
0.4946919382,
0.9563938379,
-0.0393382199,
-0.055747088,
-0.5139535069,
0.6526376009,
-0.4108184278,
0.1921155304,
-0.276419729,
-0.0412643403,
-0.1612671912,
0.3606085479,
-0.1585030705,
-0.3859610558,
-0.1096023172,
-0.8545082808,
-0.0655811355,
0.2642321289,
0.2163812071,
0.3166399002,
-0.6015853286,
-0.4943673015,
-0.3255542219,
0.5940344334,
-0.556402266,
0.7938838005,
0.142576322,
0.3398661911,
0.1169075146,
-0.854816556,
-0.4138716757,
-0.6151382327,
0.2050625086,
0.3714743257,
0.1702655405,
0.0886049196,
-0.2856534719,
0.4516579807,
-0.4758090675,
0.2839768529,
-1.0194125175,
-0.0923473388,
0.697276175,
0.0900200605,
0.3844703436,
-0.1123288497,
-0.1799812913,
0.1822859198,
-0.6933042407,
-0.3942762315,
0.1040158495,
0.2055138499,
-0.5964157581,
0.6065127254,
-0.1796606928,
0.3672726154,
-0.1119381487,
-0.6036705971,
0.4600316584,
-0.4036057293,
-0.1714619845,
0.2778006792,
0.8402891159,
0.2785429657,
-0.0305360053,
-0.5104430318,
0.0877820626,
0.3058092296,
0.222868219,
-0.5825985074,
0.2155101597,
0.4212150276,
-0.6263664365,
-0.1899449229,
-0.232982561,
-0.4644724429,
-0.7779617906,
-0.3498752117,
0.0882641375,
-0.5089967251,
-0.1382688284,
0.3070592582,
0.1672449857,
-0.013321978,
0.334784776,
-0.7389457822,
0.0872928575,
0.5179327726,
0.6044342518,
-0.0958123729,
-0.2693500817,
-0.3681840897,
0.1593516469,
-0.6628111601,
0.509973228,
-0.3289790154,
-0.6603325009,
-0.0779508948,
-0.0717604533,
0.1208928674,
-0.9050495028,
0.6864020228,
-0.150425449,
0.1311916709,
-0.1549419612,
-0.491835475,
0.0273564309,
0.2239160091,
-0.6392595768,
0.8915250301,
0.2390575558,
-0.3833922744,
0.480652988,
-0.536598444,
-0.3796863854,
0.2533570528,
-0.5720028877,
-0.2350206673,
0.3374198675,
0.257788837,
0.2758030891,
-0.8030304909,
0.2808597982,
-0.3263451457,
-0.1166323647,
-0.0830086544,
0.0328164883,
0.6672996283,
0.3653892577,
-0.1882079393,
0.3532768488,
-0.9131676555,
-0.2063491642,
-0.1799258143,
-0.5115666389,
-0.274604708,
-0.2470482886,
0.1244782805,
0.302760601,
0.2871369421,
-0.5610812306,
0.3764579296,
-0.6431314349,
0.2397649437,
0.4274788201,
-0.3040176928,
0.5012361407,
-0.4290018678,
0.7225477695,
-0.1169247478,
0.549567461,
0.0294875763,
-0.7525376678,
-0.4834425747,
-0.8236941695,
0.0813500509,
0.4412730932,
-0.8398118615,
0.091582939,
-0.2412436604,
-0.8139146566,
-1.237334609,
0.4589511454,
0.5568044782,
0.654491663,
0.2668531835,
0.0146369617,
-0.4635880589,
-1.0230402946,
-0.1473097801,
-0.2513557076,
0.0007827103,
0.3202970624,
0.5144513845,
-0.6952658296,
0.2725749314,
0.0211956464,
-0.3592537344,
-0.628960073,
-0.2682538033,
0.2114403397,
0.3645963967,
0.5834812522,
-0.7856869698,
-0.5258672237,
0.4950114489,
-1.1129107475,
-0.1647518128,
0.1335142851,
0.1102555841,
0.1357335895,
0.5095829964,
-0.4928463399,
0.1418082863,
0.8146064281,
-0.35671556,
0.4261789918,
-0.4656096399,
0.2787763476,
-1.5840480328,
0.0779062882,
-0.2687835097,
-0.1869959831,
-0.3192856312,
0.3109740615,
0.2979687452,
-0.2199391127,
-0.762134552,
1.1108959913,
-0.6865944266,
-0.0120718274,
-0.1964761317,
0.2791481614,
-0.231683284,
-0.2119056731,
-0.2017573863,
0.6520863175,
0.7690618038,
-0.5671446919,
0.6352754831,
0.1498929113,
-0.3265911043,
0.7746147513,
-0.602232337,
-0.1686040163,
-0.1094665378,
-0.0026588528,
-0.4700812995,
-0.3912609816,
0.0595353469,
-0.5544905663,
0.0051598004,
-0.0065264325,
-0.4549542069,
-0.2388663441,
-0.3300999701,
0.5211356878,
0.3521233797,
-0.4849924147,
0.8178021908,
0.4246914387,
-0.0310235023,
-0.5069611669,
-0.5228170753,
0.1049189121,
-0.3019541502,
-1.003929019,
0.3161297739,
-0.2050945163,
-0.4268380105,
-0.1287088245,
0.0716331676,
0.0322798491,
-0.0019542112,
0.2611923516,
0.2878640294,
-0.3028493822,
0.1771574616,
-0.0695099682,
-0.3082332909,
-0.1797272116,
-0.3243147731,
0.2803395689,
-0.01765774,
-0.4021903872,
-0.4829132259,
0.4063113034,
1.0058422089,
0.0024986516,
1.010001421,
0.540181458,
-0.4412640929,
0.2587510049,
-0.6727826595,
-0.0436986536,
-0.4184446633,
0.608897686,
-0.1746955365,
-0.8048818111,
0.8404662609,
-0.134703517,
-0.0564885214,
0.3843167424,
0.9622521996,
0.1467335075,
0.9490645528,
0.7033506632,
-0.3547480404,
0.0315962806,
-0.0772598013,
-0.0571911968,
-0.8049402833,
-0.5042994022,
-0.6934388876,
-0.1891665608,
-0.6980000138,
-0.5855612755,
0.8768424988,
0.033673428,
0.0507871546,
-0.2253838927,
-0.283141315,
0.1885460764,
0.6827219725,
-0.0287073106,
0.4575484097,
-0.3441343009,
-0.4921101928,
0.0566681549,
-0.6511657238,
-0.3204893172,
1.3630530834,
0.0559067242,
0.9999198914,
0.2580588758,
0.6778835654,
0.0484895036,
0.6374379992,
-0.6709116101,
0.2101294994,
-0.1942704767,
-0.9242155552,
0.0419843197,
-0.4679311514,
-1.2061870098,
0.1764030457,
-0.2784314156,
-0.4928641319,
-0.1679862887,
0.2207643837,
-0.2266250402,
0.1591685861,
-0.8883687258,
0.824162662,
-0.5554858446,
-0.2884995639,
-0.4090241194,
-0.7771913409,
0.3496672213,
-0.180544883,
0.6350048184,
-0.0056155096,
-0.4127240181,
0.48532933,
-0.4265067279,
0.6877795458,
0.0386618078,
0.0958250463,
-0.1106797233,
-0.4449740648,
0.1493285894,
0.587772429,
-0.1285173446,
0.1798639596,
-0.14977853,
-0.6734756231,
-0.2527778447,
0.7357974052,
-1.1457548141,
-0.3306696117,
-0.4125308692,
-0.5166996717,
-0.2745653093,
0.2808991075,
0.3760347962,
0.2946218848,
-0.2091809511,
0.2986242771,
0.3829781115,
-0.5056326389,
-0.0259646121,
0.8218429089,
-0.4670322239,
-0.8260024786,
0.4791043103,
0.0515026487,
0.258325249,
0.3616297841,
0.2983119786,
-0.5537062287,
-0.7525085807,
-0.6107142568,
0.6966360807,
-0.6846681237,
-0.0566798113,
-0.4047272503,
0.2049080431,
-0.6446557045,
-0.5262729526,
-0.6380524039,
-0.3578078747,
0.0535691641,
-0.10447108,
0.1432901919,
1.0357222557,
0.0134114418,
0.3468261659,
-0.8560450673,
0.7040066123,
-0.075543195,
0.4539589882,
-0.4726716578,
-0.2606141269,
-0.5440828204,
-0.355807513,
-0.0260782242,
-0.9597395658,
0.340122968,
-0.0152664846,
0.7919260263,
0.5388180614,
-0.1497592479,
0.5224525928,
-0.345731765,
0.5974590778,
0.5273168683,
-0.6044516563,
0.4130910635,
-0.2363284081,
0.4797472954,
0.5379194617,
0.3248556852,
-0.8420784473,
-0.5579867363,
-0.4327095747,
-0.9281922579,
0.3789160252,
-0.0792585686,
-0.0101634655,
-0.1332528144,
0.6102641225,
0.2944425941,
0.3054113388,
-0.6731650233,
-0.4024980366,
0.1397759318,
-0.6820667982,
-0.1442738473,
0.1421738863,
-0.2105961144,
-0.1318258047,
0.8119744658,
-0.3108007908,
-0.0006905544,
0.2859777212,
-0.1486950368,
0.0289439783,
0.2793045342,
0.4936774373,
0.6926176548,
0.1629037112,
-0.0560479686,
0.0769608095,
-0.7462857366,
0.2465418577,
0.3763983846,
-0.2595741749,
-0.2080908269,
0.4902245104,
0.5202126503,
0.3675363064,
-1.0701766014,
0.0923270583,
-0.2581265271,
-0.0404461809,
-0.3073250353,
-0.0573899783,
0.5126757622,
0.3284496069,
0.3609625399,
-0.0447329171,
0.0354587287,
-0.5478770733,
-0.0367207825,
0.4107411206,
-0.3114382029,
-0.4023132324,
1.1000977755,
0.4684699476,
0.0329953656,
0.5040351748,
-0.1420784742,
-0.089274928,
0.6115025282,
0.3411482871,
0.4451986849,
-0.4115378857,
-0.1121764928,
0.3469748795,
0.5873561502,
-0.1194158942,
0.4450902641,
0.5584333539,
-0.617182076,
-0.3882628381,
-0.4269891381,
-0.3633544147,
0.127720207,
-0.3909407854,
0.4517957866,
-0.3393992484,
-0.054089874,
0.0036756492,
0.1033246368,
-0.5685928464,
0.4030950665,
0.3231163323,
0.9745354056,
-0.5175942779,
0.9943097234,
1.0447870493,
-0.4637485445,
-0.7845921516,
-0.7567956448,
0.3256462812,
-1.0141034126,
0.3017792404,
0.1178321317,
0.0866227672,
-0.234089002,
-0.2023275048,
-0.7249013186,
1.1775196791,
0.980719924,
-0.524553597,
-0.0808502436,
0.1967690885,
0.4334448576,
-0.5131657124,
0.1631373763,
0.2010752261,
0.4294752181,
-0.1610349566,
-1.1913671494,
-0.2732147574,
-0.311922282,
-0.1757758111,
0.0398253798,
-0.8951906562,
0.7350516915,
-0.4853434265,
0.3261122704,
0.2863481045,
0.4383295774,
0.4966624677,
0.4213771522,
0.2244046181,
0.6460315585,
1.0458621979,
-0.0380381607,
1.4724012613,
-0.7575271726,
0.0936288089,
0.7101247311,
-0.448546201,
0.3517062962,
0.536072135,
0.063097313,
-0.1405082047,
0.5143879652,
0.32206285,
0.2110225409,
-0.1442552954,
-0.547188282,
0.0752097294,
-0.0886161625,
-0.5658745766,
0.3478144407,
0.2846004069,
-0.487875104,
0.1870947033,
0.3048683703,
0.3597545326,
0.0778040141,
-0.5706549883,
0.7361209393,
0.1510538161,
-0.6608648896,
0.4296143651,
0.1231592894,
0.5730268955,
-0.8988344669,
0.3510877788,
-0.4373805523,
0.5717281699,
-0.1278610528,
-0.1034161448,
0.1150747761,
-0.0867470726,
-0.1194992363,
0.1757654548,
0.3184259236,
-0.2850496769,
-0.9780596495,
0.8085080981,
0.7283841968,
0.1468323916,
0.1518124938,
-0.7785416245,
0.2530493438,
-0.00096605,
0.0321403742,
0.3893995285,
0.488828212,
-0.1824253947,
0.9872669578,
0.473233223,
0.5286220312,
0.4866265357,
0.1897138804,
0.8083664775,
-0.5494618416,
-0.57103163,
-0.5919293165,
0.4368717968,
0.1818311512,
-0.5389643312,
0.6489781737,
0.9318880439,
0.7776131034,
-0.1927347332,
0.9940172434,
-0.1219168305,
0.4840334356,
-0.4754683077,
0.6432016492,
-0.8208388686,
0.1586911827,
0.0003063707,
-0.4894676507,
-0.5643575191,
0.5377221704,
0.0022323178,
0.2185164392,
0.6872559786,
0.6331512928,
0.0469411239,
-0.3498947024,
0.6345201135,
0.459849149,
0.351157397,
0.3818611503,
0.5196506381,
-0.2511495352,
0.6467909813,
-0.1356762052,
-0.259111464,
-0.2579679489,
-0.4243489206,
-0.6712576747,
-0.1362858266,
-0.2285208106,
-0.1936012954,
0.1402313858,
1.0245449543,
1.0184948444,
-0.6540451646,
-0.2728870511,
0.2351533622,
0.0309319124,
-0.2667580247,
-0.0877959356,
0.2369036824,
-0.2334362864,
-0.9488846064,
0.6862474084,
0.5503640175,
-0.1474847049,
-0.3990595341,
-0.6383697987,
-0.0016860736,
-0.013313761,
0.3590744436,
0.2061124444,
-0.8162453175,
0.0083936099,
0.1675474495,
-0.2193848491,
0.3050408959,
0.7293581963,
-0.7262834311,
0.6696170568,
-0.0309301037,
0.6533461213,
0.3089858592,
-0.3153148592,
0.5608584285,
-0.578790009,
0.5675190687,
0.3677569926,
0.746113658,
0.545019567,
-0.2230534703,
0.6866294742,
0.3290150762,
-0.5088918209,
-0.4784037471,
0.055380486,
-0.9803904891,
-0.3006170094,
0.8867503405,
-0.002718976,
-0.0792056844,
-0.2948351502,
-0.4015621841,
0.4260870814,
-0.3604299724,
1.0114736557,
0.4269551635,
-0.1565113962,
-0.1389949918,
-0.8253740668,
0.2972076833,
0.203184858,
-1.2498958111,
-0.4074274898,
0.5117312074,
0.295450896,
0.3032036126,
1.1080390215,
-0.4746989608,
0.5537336469,
-0.0851825774,
0.2844341099,
0.158544451,
-0.2721065283,
-0.0362057798,
0.2275465727,
0.2898250222,
0.0601036921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03628v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03628v2
|
GPTopic: Dynamic and Interactive Topic Representations
| 2024-03-06T11:34:20 | 2024-06-22T09:00:29 |
Arik Reuter, Anton Thielmann, Christoph Weisser, Sebastian Fischer, Benjamin Säfken
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Topic modeling seems to be almost synonymous with generating lists of top
words to represent topics within large text corpora. However, deducing a topic
from such list of individual terms can require substantial expertise and
experience, making topic modelling less accessible to people unfamiliar with
the particularities and pitfalls of top-word interpretation. A topic
representation limited to top-words might further fall short of offering a
comprehensive and easily accessible characterization of the various aspects,
facets and nuances a topic might have. To address these challenges, we
introduce GPTopic, a software package that leverages Large Language Models
(LLMs) to create dynamic, interactive topic representations. GPTopic provides
an intuitive chat interface for users to explore, analyze, and refine topics
interactively, making topic modeling more accessible and comprehensive. The
corresponding code is available here: https://github.com/ArikReuter/TopicGPT.
|
[
-0.5941603184,
-1.0078841448,
0.7846292257,
0.1168751344,
-0.3047839105,
0.5145584941,
-0.4857153893,
-0.0904183611,
0.4167360663,
0.5057954788,
-0.6530354619,
-0.5641483665,
-0.9223579764,
-0.4052266181,
-0.4068666697,
1.079616189,
0.1398877352,
-0.2839960754,
-0.4108816683,
0.2561132312,
-0.3587627113,
-0.388284862,
-0.5565527678,
-0.3679665029,
0.4743393064,
0.5285133719,
0.9386735559,
0.3833769262,
0.4698303044,
0.3398040235,
-0.3198948205,
-0.1122383624,
-0.7682743073,
0.3884657025,
-0.4369828999,
-0.3202716112,
-0.4243062437,
0.2804381549,
0.6320370436,
0.8525177836,
-0.2938001752,
-0.1241186187,
-0.1315208226,
0.2474668026,
-0.1539300233,
0.1449148804,
-0.8786761165,
0.0037598747,
-0.2933918834,
-0.5116856694,
-0.1144134626,
-0.1147225723,
0.3138914108,
-0.6870359778,
-0.1233873069,
-0.1655661911,
0.6288986206,
0.3798503578,
-0.2483806759,
-0.4838426709,
-0.7402932048,
0.4961842895,
-0.3971951306,
0.2830477357,
0.3035102785,
0.4111753106,
-0.293509841,
-0.8861108422,
-0.4325213134,
-0.6482496858,
0.0455409959,
-0.0599038042,
-0.2114251256,
-0.1045077443,
0.3307249248,
0.6461169124,
-0.4979626536,
0.0801353678,
0.0221764166,
-0.0561702549,
0.283968538,
0.3362483382,
0.6233841181,
-0.1558354646,
-0.0164229404,
0.2242423594,
-0.8539757729,
-0.4371440709,
0.4398171902,
0.2013158947,
-0.2299035788,
0.6061840057,
-0.1334776133,
0.4791538715,
0.1196976304,
-0.1042738408,
0.0066799293,
-0.055367846,
0.1122805923,
-0.3464823663,
0.3658706546,
0.0218285751,
-0.0281738192,
-0.2106252015,
0.1634899527,
-0.0571396165,
0.3486752808,
-0.8704775572,
-0.6082805395,
0.5455256104,
-0.2708152533,
-0.4276879132,
0.0028161868,
-0.7777401209,
-0.684304893,
-0.4722413421,
0.0884319842,
-0.1653020233,
-0.4389558136,
-0.1714695692,
-0.0926415026,
0.0138030704,
0.6920255423,
-0.7796915174,
0.3808923662,
0.7395751476,
0.7961717248,
-0.5290862322,
-0.2492227256,
-0.6068114638,
0.2265533507,
-0.3216475546,
0.9127573371,
-1.0552272797,
-0.4750177264,
-0.2815931439,
-0.0419422984,
0.3957131207,
-0.3009197414,
-0.0480462611,
-0.4373441041,
0.4710162282,
-0.2423805445,
-0.6968317628,
0.2361785769,
0.2630889416,
-0.5210855007,
0.9024482369,
0.0497293472,
-1.2024126053,
0.2598155737,
-0.7802762389,
0.2570442855,
0.486078769,
-0.7062648535,
0.1420120597,
-0.0233751889,
0.1570644379,
0.4097308218,
-0.1199995652,
0.5591964126,
-0.2675587535,
-0.3470692635,
0.1983556449,
-0.3501682878,
0.4204230011,
0.2315062881,
-0.1870414019,
0.5599149466,
-0.4467318058,
-0.3664190769,
0.0571090728,
-0.3303918242,
-0.2615474761,
0.1433537751,
0.1973582953,
0.0229765121,
0.4935666621,
-0.1222489253,
0.8046717644,
-0.1477263272,
0.6223344207,
0.5431227088,
0.1854974031,
0.4821063578,
-0.0394645706,
0.6085930467,
-0.23917678,
-0.3603272736,
-0.1566402316,
-0.7775992155,
-0.2865090072,
-0.3636623323,
0.4462263286,
0.8026217222,
-1.0306301117,
0.2671176493,
-0.2643887699,
-0.6391085386,
0.1078918129,
-0.0855292901,
-0.2050710768,
0.0032927722,
-0.1440987885,
-0.2507800162,
-0.1166212782,
-0.7389253378,
0.0309089217,
-0.0673273578,
-0.3624852598,
0.2428001612,
0.4943779111,
-0.2756981254,
1.0158178806,
-0.8406582475,
0.0214236658,
-0.5064743757,
0.6156102419,
0.2831769586,
0.2769943774,
0.5849069357,
-0.8365135789,
-0.4941020012,
-0.0049677342,
-0.4361265302,
-0.2213539928,
-0.1584172994,
-0.4104302227,
-0.387411356,
0.6294395924,
-0.9586306214,
0.2789120078,
0.4820622802,
-0.4033536315,
0.4661309719,
-0.3678043783,
-0.0239007156,
-1.1891791821,
0.2798452079,
-0.1456934065,
-0.3584381938,
-0.5892150402,
0.3225785196,
-0.3012430072,
-0.7168033719,
-0.2700892687,
0.7614357471,
-0.3945225477,
-0.1725312024,
-0.6492356658,
0.3878791928,
-0.4282514155,
0.2320044786,
0.3737542629,
1.1234332323,
0.8356406689,
-0.4231551886,
0.5537909865,
0.4281183779,
-0.162459746,
0.3573494256,
-0.5228902102,
0.0940697044,
-0.0317741074,
0.3413291276,
-0.987922132,
-0.6528922319,
0.4575639069,
-0.311945051,
0.5437245965,
-0.3737251163,
-0.2944497168,
-0.1427650601,
-0.2803922594,
0.0369855799,
0.3794284463,
-0.1796430498,
0.2903173864,
0.929508388,
-0.91046381,
-0.478746742,
-0.5190663934,
0.519962728,
-0.3802868724,
-0.1750914603,
0.7707856894,
-0.2294408232,
-0.3931762278,
0.2008641809,
0.1788129658,
-0.0781990141,
0.0102922991,
0.1131037399,
-0.1067126691,
0.2110096365,
0.3230388463,
-0.1522904336,
-0.3432859182,
-0.1682028323,
-0.1919265687,
0.8318376541,
-0.0672086924,
-0.3934018314,
-0.1861471534,
0.6105012894,
0.8354176283,
-0.2454757541,
0.5273922086,
0.4329722524,
-0.702255547,
-0.2142164707,
-0.3383492827,
-0.0706268772,
-0.4990100265,
0.4099417031,
-0.290187031,
-0.9094383121,
0.7026554942,
-0.308457166,
-0.0186732877,
0.3052150309,
0.8637393117,
0.1225791126,
0.5446186066,
0.8982155323,
-0.0064986059,
0.6246185899,
-0.1472946703,
0.1904402077,
-0.4943016469,
-0.0433088131,
-0.2781563997,
0.0040514832,
-0.8588824868,
-0.5668407679,
0.2355768979,
-0.0644370317,
-0.1230546758,
0.1337847859,
-0.553704977,
0.2594675124,
0.469188869,
-0.0447546542,
0.169262588,
0.2411452383,
-0.0175792798,
-0.2415987253,
-0.4855719805,
-0.8223618269,
0.7165353298,
0.5639342666,
0.926515758,
-0.0671820194,
0.7253788114,
0.4588894248,
0.3847257197,
-0.8733541369,
0.7962175012,
-0.3222439587,
-0.3536459804,
-0.4801938534,
-0.466820389,
-0.6273964643,
-0.0008034321,
-0.2881365418,
-1.0448459387,
-0.0838511288,
0.0989633724,
-0.2553522885,
0.5189032555,
-0.0435516201,
0.8296573758,
-0.1019546464,
-0.33701092,
-0.3484628797,
-0.1185860857,
0.1622683555,
-0.0332787223,
0.0626444668,
-0.3010190427,
-0.2675866485,
0.5593267679,
-0.2936981022,
0.8542709947,
-0.1492398977,
-0.2535620928,
0.3202562332,
0.2492549419,
0.3759684563,
0.3989669383,
0.122901611,
0.0568595044,
-0.186120078,
-0.2378768325,
-0.5544522405,
0.93395257,
-0.6435647011,
-0.9523123503,
-0.478466779,
-0.6447680593,
-0.2113075852,
0.0891590342,
-0.0048212488,
0.4415203035,
-0.278080225,
0.0260089487,
0.6516382098,
-0.6894814372,
0.1472817957,
0.0630037412,
-0.6547854543,
-0.4905459583,
0.9222108722,
0.1131993085,
-0.0494227633,
0.4937290251,
0.0852576196,
-0.1152725592,
-0.8349782825,
-0.5132323503,
0.2414888293,
-0.8090669513,
0.2603134513,
-0.6225761771,
-0.2644966543,
-0.0035473523,
-0.0509610884,
-0.3424874842,
-0.685644269,
-0.3640688062,
-0.2006142884,
0.6442729831,
0.8960284591,
-0.1760542095,
0.5108408332,
-0.5287376046,
0.5154457688,
0.4782353342,
0.4540072978,
-0.2674362063,
-0.3195047975,
0.0884468183,
-0.3206984997,
-0.3457992375,
-1.1562722921,
0.4850574434,
0.0321551748,
0.9086859822,
0.40384534,
-0.1078798473,
0.387834996,
-0.635547936,
1.0133836269,
-0.1223830581,
-1.0412881374,
0.8045284152,
-0.8084735274,
0.3108213842,
0.5008863807,
0.7275441289,
-0.6678308249,
-0.6079609394,
-0.5473172665,
-0.9553384781,
0.4348233938,
0.3493638039,
0.3578744829,
-0.0295048114,
0.5023605824,
0.4054323435,
0.4106323123,
-0.5860154033,
-0.1662433147,
-0.0487211831,
-0.0521044098,
0.0522320494,
-0.4387658238,
-0.102508679,
-0.0058454117,
0.5985379219,
-0.1683239639,
0.8023445606,
-0.2910254002,
-0.0167664383,
-0.0357860662,
0.2128718197,
0.6019675136,
1.2900668383,
-0.4591438174,
0.1832873076,
0.1643822342,
-0.4925303161,
-0.2507689893,
0.3165703118,
0.0665805787,
-0.0570686907,
0.4015707076,
0.5476418734,
0.285761863,
-0.5119208694,
0.3173233271,
-0.0244840328,
0.1956463009,
-0.3543239534,
-0.0190277323,
0.6229740977,
0.1134663001,
0.5744721889,
-0.4165774286,
0.0056177769,
-0.9272167087,
0.6421326399,
0.3433148861,
-0.2750013471,
-0.0530467555,
0.6817694902,
0.2781481743,
-0.2068342417,
0.6941992044,
-0.3092917502,
-0.6670511365,
0.5263759494,
0.0768870935,
0.6548622251,
-0.1503712982,
0.4310037494,
0.1153945327,
0.0359046869,
0.2927916646,
0.4902409315,
0.1015198901,
-0.4425453842,
-0.5991322398,
-0.3603633642,
-1.15769732,
0.3938932419,
-0.3349517286,
0.2713593245,
-0.2638328373,
-0.2396361977,
0.1469064057,
0.1543601453,
-0.2975324988,
-0.0246501565,
0.5148488283,
1.0625652075,
-0.7439845204,
0.9359300137,
1.0386080742,
-0.2396527231,
-0.1018153951,
0.3205650151,
-0.0768225864,
-0.4272380471,
0.4925854504,
0.029298313,
0.2150895894,
-0.1907034665,
-0.64281708,
-0.9831876755,
1.0236165524,
0.3099153638,
-0.3662026227,
-0.1870174259,
0.3475578129,
0.5260555744,
-0.5290493369,
0.5802142024,
0.0604967065,
0.4698599577,
0.2196356654,
-0.9812002182,
0.0530242249,
-0.2411464006,
-0.1177236363,
0.0377108119,
-0.3381428719,
0.936912179,
0.1685499549,
-0.1442492604,
-0.0523583964,
0.663261652,
0.3791214824,
0.1948559135,
0.3542276621,
0.3600063622,
0.9282707572,
-0.2277521789,
0.9430994987,
-0.5645469427,
0.4149173498,
1.0059136152,
-0.0933939442,
0.8301359415,
0.3084837496,
-0.2143180519,
0.252695024,
1.0152852535,
0.0586706325,
0.7105618715,
0.3933193982,
-0.0359250419,
-0.5284642577,
0.1954699755,
-0.3695135415,
0.3438941836,
1.0072031021,
0.0618490726,
-0.5768646598,
0.0812637433,
-0.1151492745,
-0.0543447509,
-0.4065575004,
0.466467917,
0.208908394,
-0.3232762516,
0.1508341134,
-0.0242388882,
0.6459621787,
-0.6688945293,
-0.496201396,
-0.2708228827,
-0.2515386641,
0.0296791587,
-1.1841658354,
0.5654827356,
0.0510260686,
0.0829512775,
-0.2656094432,
1.1122317314,
-0.4991089702,
-0.3037034571,
0.1202948987,
0.8134016395,
0.399425149,
-0.1731451005,
-0.8376065493,
0.2608413696,
-0.1375993639,
-0.5300604105,
0.2473827749,
0.4224815667,
-0.2700317502,
1.0293879509,
0.4022198021,
0.1550430208,
-0.3251731098,
-0.0392664224,
1.1123123169,
-0.7938647866,
-0.6713442802,
-0.4973864257,
0.4572315514,
-0.1987380534,
-0.2066377252,
0.2763727605,
0.3094385266,
0.4658384323,
-0.198660925,
0.8545308709,
-0.1862642765,
0.6268199086,
-0.4368063807,
0.8712977171,
-0.5373796225,
0.481143266,
-0.2036030889,
-1.1249505281,
-0.3175758719,
0.661760509,
-0.6632714272,
-0.0239849575,
0.446700573,
0.5032853484,
-0.3656250834,
-0.0650922582,
0.3847171366,
0.2753258049,
0.3352801502,
0.2241283357,
1.2564513683,
0.417223841,
0.3117186427,
-0.1876802742,
-0.4422077537,
-0.1925786585,
-1.2857944965,
-0.9612997174,
-0.5313113928,
-0.6678853631,
0.215225175,
0.1263184845,
1.0673234463,
0.7253749371,
-0.8084582686,
-0.1706196219,
-0.1368758231,
0.1476395875,
0.1652143002,
-0.2281957269,
0.4773607254,
-0.1389132738,
-0.877871573,
0.505941093,
0.2439256161,
-0.1041308343,
-0.6372476816,
0.3305468559,
0.1096395031,
0.1457879096,
0.5227952003,
0.1890604496,
-0.6993733644,
-0.3753727973,
-0.2770714164,
-0.0634465441,
0.0639966354,
0.9120640755,
-0.7945749164,
0.0746186599,
0.6768029928,
0.5924991369,
0.6303012967,
-0.0620575808,
0.5718325377,
-0.4449615777,
0.1205476448,
0.0464601144,
0.3129901588,
0.4043759108,
-0.5331784487,
0.4625096917,
0.1632671207,
-0.3883297145,
-0.7591100931,
0.3945608437,
-1.1808558702,
-0.6067892909,
1.1622068882,
-0.1512599736,
0.1627561599,
-0.058958482,
-0.5130819678,
0.0010817869,
-0.3789337873,
0.6752507091,
0.9029704332,
-0.2533220053,
-0.4559558034,
-0.9485501647,
0.474033922,
-0.0963943973,
-0.9652429223,
0.2008003145,
0.3708432615,
0.5265296102,
0.2697127461,
0.6821666956,
0.111732617,
-0.0848360807,
0.1029401273,
-0.0068710321,
-0.056322705,
-0.4764118493,
-0.1341178715,
0.3313602507,
0.1928666681,
0.2466676533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03627v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03627v2
|
Multimodal Large Language Models to Support Real-World Fact-Checking
| 2024-03-06T11:32:41 | 2024-04-26T05:16:53 |
Jiahui Geng, Yova Kementchedjhieva, Preslav Nakov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) carry the potential to support
humans in processing vast amounts of information. While MLLMs are already being
used as a fact-checking tool, their abilities and limitations in this regard
are understudied. Here is aim to bridge this gap. In particular, we propose a
framework for systematically assessing the capacity of current multimodal
models to facilitate real-world fact-checking. Our methodology is
evidence-free, leveraging only these models' intrinsic knowledge and reasoning
capabilities. By designing prompts that extract models' predictions,
explanations, and confidence levels, we delve into research questions
concerning model accuracy, robustness, and reasons for failure. We empirically
find that (1) GPT-4V exhibits superior performance in identifying malicious and
misleading multimodal claims, with the ability to explain the unreasonable
aspects and underlying motives, and (2) existing open-source models exhibit
strong biases and are highly sensitive to the prompt. Our study offers insights
into combating false multimodal information and building secure, trustworthy
multimodal models. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to evaluate
MLLMs for real-world fact-checking.
|
[
-0.4063046277,
-0.850012958,
0.915592134,
0.1923662126,
-0.149540633,
-0.1076339483,
-0.2197890282,
-0.3869192004,
-0.3251458704,
0.3727036417,
-0.465808481,
-0.2720856667,
-0.6178571582,
0.0589700565,
-0.2928234339,
0.9090336561,
0.0025127346,
-0.0808917582,
-0.5040545464,
-0.1786671877,
-0.2878104448,
-0.6615142226,
-0.2222807854,
-0.0916365013,
0.8523781896,
0.2529805005,
0.7647458315,
0.3067924082,
0.4659465253,
0.3345721662,
0.2609320283,
0.4331650436,
-0.2680159211,
0.1806520969,
-0.0962147266,
-0.2629700601,
-0.4395218194,
0.3495775759,
0.6952448487,
0.1427973956,
-0.0112396264,
0.240237087,
-0.1548104286,
0.1725683808,
-0.6995057464,
0.2602793276,
-0.569586277,
-0.0695959628,
-0.1293081641,
-0.0300297178,
-0.643283546,
-0.4348817468,
-0.0066414126,
-0.3653644323,
0.1338580698,
0.0983100012,
0.7542985678,
0.0584313199,
-0.868255794,
-0.1577351093,
-0.7394816279,
0.7291334271,
-0.7116885781,
0.7469030023,
0.4703117609,
0.4083775282,
0.0731827915,
-0.7682722807,
-0.9352927804,
-0.6228663921,
-0.1855015308,
0.0116960863,
-0.254424572,
0.0445340686,
0.5598155856,
0.0847067609,
-0.8217788339,
-0.1800875664,
-0.2134253532,
-0.6687780023,
0.3187494278,
-0.0049095047,
0.4050705433,
-0.187995255,
-0.4457653463,
-0.0793954656,
-0.7122680545,
-0.0213107839,
0.3183924854,
0.1536521763,
-0.1970949471,
0.7348926067,
-0.0789217278,
0.5669544339,
-0.3435643911,
-0.4721659124,
0.1716124713,
-0.7632495165,
-0.1713493466,
-0.1773868501,
0.7361936569,
0.5186182857,
0.008964438,
-0.1044215634,
-0.3054112196,
0.2699777186,
0.200305894,
-1.0200868845,
-0.0177056007,
0.3036397099,
-0.4718542397,
-0.1876763701,
-0.054129947,
-0.7942708135,
-0.5495821238,
-0.1767214537,
0.545242846,
-0.4056164026,
-0.5188755393,
-0.097875461,
-0.2229400426,
-0.0579327755,
0.4535578191,
-0.4647919238,
-0.3138983846,
0.5290671587,
1.0561791658,
0.1762925833,
-0.1903164089,
-0.724737823,
0.032949809,
-0.2115834951,
0.7361755967,
-0.5902662873,
-0.0183606464,
0.052074369,
-0.0278310198,
0.0986840948,
-0.1024416313,
0.9026456475,
-0.6628163457,
0.2699778974,
-0.5176141262,
-0.3576633334,
-0.4293783307,
0.8052224517,
-0.8330713511,
0.6539592743,
-0.1973284185,
-0.7387571931,
0.450586468,
-0.6645736694,
-0.1522888094,
-0.1032093167,
-0.0652148426,
-0.3823269606,
-0.0635353625,
0.2898824811,
0.5090230703,
-0.2788656652,
0.6065861583,
-0.5956891775,
0.1527846009,
0.4395982921,
-1.0274182558,
0.6143795252,
0.5101771355,
-0.1559833735,
0.3396116197,
-0.7876902819,
-0.124233,
0.0086687505,
-0.2901827097,
-0.2948469222,
0.0127239497,
0.1041336656,
0.4492963552,
0.1749880463,
-0.8083988428,
0.1321766526,
0.1487662941,
0.3177773058,
0.6217805743,
-0.1815211624,
0.1251407266,
-0.3701996803,
0.3789558411,
0.263915658,
0.4056249857,
-0.4825812876,
-0.6533213258,
-0.4996953011,
-0.4452603459,
0.3419372737,
0.4042704701,
-1.0375709534,
0.0325722434,
-0.2065167427,
-0.5142962337,
-0.3431041539,
-0.1525611579,
0.268976301,
0.43782866,
0.3589203358,
0.0344536789,
-0.5228517652,
-0.9382330775,
-0.3199204803,
-0.2406113446,
0.0298657697,
0.0355275944,
0.6332179308,
-0.3164728582,
1.0731755495,
-0.1230395511,
0.1120787486,
-0.0882238075,
0.3152958453,
-0.0033141163,
0.349329859,
0.5681655407,
-1.1231456995,
-0.1758364588,
-0.0949536189,
-0.8780195117,
0.055932913,
-0.1171714291,
0.3741815984,
0.0761423931,
0.162827462,
-0.9389198422,
0.174936533,
0.8621444702,
-0.5334231257,
0.7496935725,
-0.2870917916,
0.4606749713,
-0.6459454894,
0.1782111973,
0.0966716409,
-0.5362341404,
-0.7258684635,
0.1447335333,
0.4925643802,
-0.086093992,
-0.452870816,
0.5995665789,
-0.3802923858,
0.0652708858,
-0.1280751079,
0.0648327991,
0.0540396795,
0.2972700596,
-0.1111115292,
0.6852783561,
0.269949168,
-0.4911539555,
0.6644586921,
-0.1699640155,
-0.6661320329,
0.495592922,
-0.4389572442,
-0.0880846903,
-0.1616503596,
0.3849974573,
-1.0435452461,
-0.4821279049,
0.2022737563,
-0.3457528353,
-0.0334765725,
-0.3921530247,
-0.6595003605,
-0.3117398322,
-0.2292307317,
0.3800467551,
0.2171567529,
-0.5800778866,
0.916582942,
0.2807411253,
-0.2116138786,
-0.6375416517,
-0.3456082642,
0.3154482543,
-0.0934658796,
-0.7892189622,
-0.0376633443,
-0.206107825,
-0.4929279387,
-0.0806148797,
0.005178377,
-0.1188658774,
0.0254859123,
0.228031382,
0.3165917993,
-0.2474954426,
0.1865216047,
-0.1815093756,
0.0079613151,
-0.0045894524,
-0.1317444295,
0.2568682134,
-0.3612692356,
-0.7497696877,
-0.2934348583,
0.2237850577,
1.132699728,
-0.5094991922,
0.6685607433,
1.0090472698,
-0.3437108397,
0.1647499651,
-0.9556934834,
-0.2666027248,
-0.4312774837,
0.4136850834,
-0.3193500936,
-0.9601447582,
0.3150576055,
0.1084098816,
0.189661175,
0.2430892736,
0.7937363386,
0.2205999047,
1.2386039495,
0.4327636957,
0.2492156774,
0.237217173,
0.2286200523,
0.3531239629,
-0.3831793964,
-0.3629838526,
-0.3042443991,
0.0274677221,
-0.3509104848,
-0.6177399755,
0.5425796509,
-0.3797637522,
-0.0520760566,
-0.0719821751,
0.0194105655,
0.38556844,
0.4203831851,
-0.0397437327,
0.4354235232,
-0.1749096364,
-0.2659820914,
0.1103727818,
-0.5712839365,
-0.5875124335,
1.0220556259,
0.642179966,
0.733107686,
0.4479831159,
-0.2346516252,
0.5097064376,
0.4613621533,
-0.5346695781,
0.4839163423,
0.2003184557,
-1.0207098722,
-0.2338689864,
-0.5563263297,
-0.5672647357,
0.7432868481,
-0.5540478826,
-0.312199533,
0.0140185254,
0.4221235514,
-0.4500911832,
0.5175142288,
-0.813906312,
0.9034132361,
-0.5231922269,
-0.5330203176,
-0.3129072189,
-0.5397529006,
0.7479735613,
-0.1216674522,
0.5881352425,
-0.3043501675,
0.0566411987,
0.3624673486,
-0.1047614366,
1.0119873285,
-0.3826772571,
-0.3931595981,
0.2173492908,
0.1977773458,
0.6077718139,
0.1911859363,
0.1225263327,
0.1596807688,
0.0791074932,
-0.258661747,
-0.5989211798,
0.6317291856,
-0.5574351549,
-0.5242965221,
-0.5051389337,
-0.6422915459,
-0.3470160663,
0.3247241378,
-0.0512638912,
0.7804360986,
-0.323328793,
0.4676772952,
0.6535155773,
-0.1235241294,
0.4367724955,
0.6754140854,
-0.4589196146,
-0.150189504,
1.0334519148,
0.0680060163,
0.1344917566,
0.3953503966,
0.2902549505,
-0.6704261899,
-0.5111384392,
-0.6939703226,
0.0749109387,
-0.6901673675,
-0.0405208021,
-0.8140175343,
0.1401050389,
-0.4997825921,
0.4416390061,
-0.4274047911,
-0.3048374653,
0.1794249117,
-0.0798493773,
0.1711654812,
0.7668702602,
-0.1119931862,
-0.0756352767,
-0.990876317,
0.4127393961,
0.6083033681,
0.4377801716,
-0.1225131825,
-0.3820446134,
-0.1553679407,
0.3227821589,
-0.1526532173,
-0.7749211788,
0.1594272256,
-0.0569345392,
0.5968250632,
0.4983399808,
0.1045739651,
0.394589901,
-0.5411474109,
0.9807149768,
0.1863922924,
-0.6529310346,
0.1420723051,
-0.3550207913,
0.0636161491,
0.0613381788,
0.5370724797,
-0.690644443,
-0.2396448851,
-0.3880284727,
-0.3733078539,
0.3688948452,
0.1661966443,
0.0626260564,
0.0847461224,
-0.0490059666,
0.1946164221,
0.3072246909,
-0.9288390875,
0.0559501313,
-0.6272700429,
-0.1405889392,
-0.2059895396,
-0.5737523437,
-0.3048199117,
0.0251119751,
0.5343798399,
-0.2948900163,
0.1965903491,
0.1313329488,
-0.392008841,
0.0412246324,
0.592925787,
1.0802682638,
0.8169663548,
-0.2355670035,
0.6729952097,
0.0582072362,
-0.4175619781,
0.2450987399,
-0.0839838982,
-0.0542672761,
-0.0463589318,
0.4604443908,
0.7689765692,
0.0531888083,
-0.9016881585,
0.8703776002,
-0.255279839,
-0.0690527782,
-0.1684664041,
-0.1389627606,
-0.0008931976,
0.3102307022,
0.1867807508,
0.2979468405,
-0.0754891783,
-0.681746304,
0.2027434409,
0.5749359131,
-0.1814617813,
-0.5448068976,
0.4406502545,
0.2778452337,
0.1434083432,
0.5272578001,
-0.2056808472,
-0.5674002171,
0.2835929096,
0.5255126357,
0.5234912038,
-0.1951030344,
0.2046468854,
0.3165907562,
0.6629102826,
-0.149856329,
0.0263625458,
0.0691735744,
-0.9030809999,
-0.6988224983,
-0.4266814888,
-0.4455365837,
0.3980019689,
-0.2925645411,
0.0168082919,
-0.4335453212,
-0.2947966754,
-0.0439544208,
-0.3945868611,
-0.5320783854,
0.2303061485,
0.4089334607,
0.8610438108,
-0.8927925825,
0.8376774788,
0.5367447734,
-0.3952440023,
-0.3831466734,
-0.0686301813,
0.4076352417,
-0.7732430696,
0.6444166899,
0.2019809932,
-0.2920181751,
-0.2831078768,
-0.6880431771,
-0.7956696153,
0.8161825538,
0.4894789755,
-0.5799301863,
-0.0387354121,
-0.1048677415,
0.3066789806,
-0.1764069796,
0.4567676187,
0.2418228835,
0.8411263824,
-0.0192165114,
-1.0068204403,
0.0990806967,
-0.199701637,
-0.3212598562,
-0.008720791,
-0.4969622791,
1.0234671831,
-0.2833838761,
-0.16470474,
-0.1587947905,
0.6564708948,
0.0823954418,
0.274456948,
0.7769176364,
0.4074362516,
0.8481917977,
-0.0693022162,
1.137804389,
-0.2149232328,
0.4119305313,
0.8487564921,
-0.3795765936,
0.6695206761,
0.3544221818,
0.0212845784,
0.5674089193,
0.3027742803,
-0.1204622835,
0.302896589,
-0.3558233678,
-0.4333799481,
-0.6226023436,
-0.181942001,
-0.227742821,
0.5205129385,
0.378166467,
-0.0330152251,
-0.3379481733,
0.3061845005,
0.0815508813,
-0.2286459059,
-0.1892931908,
0.4300787747,
-0.241462186,
-0.7869458199,
0.3945146501,
0.1483750641,
0.6069265008,
-0.7970619202,
-0.1410425901,
0.1054879576,
0.1464484781,
-0.0831761882,
-0.8997965455,
0.0686565563,
0.3326816261,
-0.3429044485,
-0.2500407696,
0.8936491609,
-0.5852307081,
-0.2274523824,
0.0448370501,
0.5775648355,
-0.1203238443,
-0.3972253203,
-0.6073989868,
0.2382177562,
-0.044905968,
-0.2073720247,
0.3846872449,
0.334772557,
-0.1631900966,
0.9589987397,
0.9215532541,
-0.2059838325,
0.0429109558,
0.0198476687,
0.6587351561,
-0.494718194,
-0.44457376,
-1.0833461285,
0.5486888289,
-0.0952200517,
0.0724164397,
1.0208904743,
0.5550547838,
0.5608317852,
-0.027805429,
1.1079758406,
-0.1046024412,
0.5117288232,
-0.6275419593,
0.7900791168,
-0.625541687,
-0.0643470213,
-0.0290460978,
-0.5153737664,
-0.3367426097,
0.5109040737,
-0.1908275783,
0.0512544625,
0.6094109416,
0.9548786879,
-0.2759271264,
0.2555320263,
0.6902400851,
0.4403853118,
0.5986399055,
0.1641991138,
1.2049479485,
0.0208581723,
0.6847348809,
-0.0927721187,
-0.3395253718,
-0.3833125234,
-1.2809345722,
-1.0238164663,
-0.6433141232,
-0.0037473741,
-0.3751027584,
-0.188568905,
1.0185390711,
0.8032093048,
-0.6630908251,
0.1507169753,
0.5083699226,
0.2320177555,
-0.052714128,
-0.1403941214,
0.1616743207,
-0.1704181284,
-0.4066941738,
0.5556389689,
0.3411282003,
0.0352669694,
-0.4864044189,
-0.0312832221,
-0.2019422948,
0.1124224514,
1.0483082533,
0.0869082063,
-0.9917656183,
-0.5564267039,
-0.0276046768,
-0.1051900089,
-0.1124689057,
1.113388896,
-0.52982831,
0.6533031464,
0.4621933401,
0.5158923268,
0.1601955891,
-0.0673514828,
0.4028533101,
-0.7553251982,
0.0811492726,
0.1171128079,
0.6191499233,
0.4564853907,
-0.0717449337,
0.111859262,
0.4643290639,
-0.5381388664,
-0.8631356955,
0.3813923001,
-0.8703044057,
-0.3252623677,
1.1672831774,
-0.1921999007,
0.0081066294,
-0.4196210504,
-0.2490367293,
0.0553224012,
-0.357229948,
0.553371489,
0.8441861272,
0.0944143757,
-0.290625155,
-0.7649315596,
0.4622682333,
0.0465924814,
-0.7458873391,
0.3919286728,
0.8311648965,
0.3485807776,
0.3592351675,
0.4593059421,
-0.1101892292,
0.3564660847,
0.048671592,
0.0430179276,
-0.3856292367,
-0.5439307094,
-0.1369467378,
0.5362760425,
0.0064403564,
0.178107813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04808v1
|
WaterMax: breaking the LLM watermark detectability-robustness-quality trade-off
| 2024-03-06T10:55:30 | 2024-03-06T10:55:30 |
Eva Giboulot, Furon Teddy
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Watermarking is a technical means to dissuade malfeasant usage of Large
Language Models. This paper proposes a novel watermarking scheme, so-called
WaterMax, that enjoys high detectability while sustaining the quality of the
generated text of the original LLM. Its new design leaves the LLM untouched (no
modification of the weights, logits, temperature, or sampling technique).
WaterMax balances robustness and complexity contrary to the watermarking
techniques of the literature inherently provoking a trade-off between quality
and robustness. Its performance is both theoretically proven and experimentally
validated. It outperforms all the SotA techniques under the most complete
benchmark suite.
|
[
-0.525344789,
-0.7859546542,
0.3604260385,
0.1834487319,
-0.7160516977,
0.4176472425,
0.251312077,
-0.6254864335,
0.1032075509,
0.6891146898,
-0.4427969456,
-0.2390218079,
-0.9562312961,
-0.0439881682,
-0.5600572228,
0.6552146077,
-0.3336186409,
-0.0889214277,
-0.2105612904,
-0.5089871287,
-0.3153407872,
-0.4696783721,
-0.6754795313,
-0.4824716449,
0.362556994,
0.1631147265,
1.073336482,
0.9830932617,
0.4518056214,
0.2578054667,
-0.3981965184,
0.2227014154,
-0.5551834106,
0.344016999,
-0.0686590299,
-0.5868926644,
-0.2369993925,
0.0994029865,
0.7168788314,
0.1181953102,
0.300308913,
-0.0015472174,
0.2902114093,
0.7194407582,
-0.8291395307,
0.217826426,
-0.6554583907,
0.0733684301,
-0.4061999321,
-0.3913047612,
-0.2449546605,
-0.1269848943,
-0.2519289553,
-0.5824157,
-0.1449564397,
0.0856944993,
1.1673069,
0.3341364264,
0.0082805706,
-0.1615686864,
-0.749753058,
0.8467949629,
-0.795796454,
0.2502886653,
0.5579288602,
0.3009940684,
0.0669398457,
-0.5959833264,
-0.7103190422,
0.1478261203,
0.411614567,
0.0544963926,
-0.5367416143,
-0.3495139182,
0.2694003582,
0.4307442605,
-0.3959668279,
-0.0874635056,
-0.0868718624,
-0.2162560523,
0.6763113141,
0.1516231894,
0.6042429209,
0.332297653,
-0.6265166998,
0.0626817346,
-0.958091557,
0.1320065707,
0.396950841,
0.1047995761,
0.4609411359,
0.5079452991,
0.0061099338,
0.4868273735,
-0.4017512202,
-0.4258704782,
-0.1053356975,
-0.0793723017,
-0.3791146278,
-0.0430526286,
0.6372278929,
0.2958959341,
0.3641749024,
0.0722885132,
-0.6104127169,
-0.1243944839,
-0.1647170633,
-0.7459335327,
0.0612492897,
0.0846621022,
-0.4050240517,
-0.4657327533,
-0.0078100539,
-0.5173373818,
-0.5184988976,
-0.2190636843,
0.8626481891,
-0.3291356564,
-0.4098403156,
0.2769727409,
-0.0915757939,
0.1198078915,
0.1292212605,
-0.4844397008,
0.2660136819,
0.6749853492,
0.913015306,
-0.3219668567,
-0.0953730866,
-0.4797374308,
0.2958950102,
-0.3078123927,
0.9021008015,
-0.6538218856,
-0.5364582539,
-0.0596787743,
-0.1463619322,
0.3048368394,
-0.8473827243,
0.3893077374,
-0.9004998803,
0.0200623423,
-0.2371775955,
-0.8149687648,
0.0199600141,
0.2967602611,
-1.0224096775,
0.9486346245,
0.0058279196,
-0.8867976665,
0.5903909206,
-0.3635313809,
-0.2484249026,
0.2665262818,
0.1772715598,
-0.8207629919,
-0.1889474094,
-0.1237693653,
0.1645253599,
-0.2221058458,
0.1640564799,
-0.3403255641,
-0.5993923545,
0.5652266741,
-0.5553734303,
0.715439558,
0.2892268598,
-0.423110038,
-0.1275293231,
-0.8243021369,
0.1615388691,
0.4531387687,
-0.7108469605,
-0.5178761482,
-0.1837120652,
0.0946025699,
0.0154650388,
0.254692018,
-0.4489468336,
-0.0202370062,
-0.1034003943,
0.550368309,
0.6907655001,
-0.1144208908,
0.2609765232,
-0.4834201038,
0.7907291651,
-0.1791736931,
0.3917225301,
-0.0542242825,
-0.5848932266,
-0.7282503843,
-0.6371464729,
0.5256304741,
0.6089132428,
-0.7902455926,
0.19418253,
-0.1466252953,
-0.4650858343,
-0.2737030983,
0.5297445655,
0.4448179007,
0.0854802728,
0.5327395201,
-0.1820211709,
-0.3685628772,
-0.7946714163,
-0.616943121,
0.11997623,
0.1533956528,
0.1110187992,
0.4145591557,
-0.3437922299,
1.0343310833,
-0.3780745566,
-0.1869787425,
-0.5262366533,
0.0256042387,
0.1217314824,
0.5524713993,
0.2836643457,
-0.8228135705,
-0.676705718,
-0.3800934255,
-0.4135140181,
-0.3212995231,
0.0214547496,
-0.1615047604,
0.0872747749,
0.6647927165,
-0.5712419152,
0.7223336101,
0.6555828452,
-0.5551195145,
0.6588286161,
-0.0903997272,
-0.152722016,
-0.9511146545,
0.0676728338,
-0.1718809605,
-0.3914352655,
-0.5444065928,
0.1441486478,
0.1411855668,
-0.0230205785,
-0.4480967224,
0.7845315933,
-0.4871881604,
0.227210179,
-0.7300261855,
-0.155674845,
0.4400793016,
-0.1101935655,
-0.263689965,
0.823522687,
0.4822717607,
-0.4206228554,
0.3657149673,
0.2568863034,
-0.3223626912,
0.6291573048,
-0.7925593853,
-0.0317301266,
-0.0085304687,
-0.0080906497,
-1.0480097532,
0.3702230155,
0.0382952765,
-0.3905879259,
0.608953774,
-0.1464713812,
-0.5765263438,
0.1110919416,
-0.4574913979,
0.3743864298,
0.4632949233,
-0.5889043212,
0.5615094304,
0.4032465219,
-0.170252949,
-0.5849992633,
-1.0727926493,
0.4524359405,
-0.2834695876,
-0.636747241,
0.4133012891,
-0.1596649885,
-0.4129313529,
0.0331465751,
-0.4719866216,
-0.4129432142,
0.075947538,
0.1781558096,
0.2546265125,
-0.1823216975,
-0.2611010075,
0.0418754593,
-0.5394725204,
-0.1393223256,
-0.1389799565,
0.5573028326,
0.2706595361,
-0.2362678349,
-0.492908746,
0.4252239466,
0.6806021929,
-0.2312328964,
0.8034148812,
0.3280972242,
-0.6314007044,
-0.3440640271,
-0.445682615,
0.0250247214,
-0.5595258474,
-0.0861013085,
-0.3019924164,
-0.94258219,
0.438585788,
-0.0337492228,
0.0084522413,
0.2692257166,
0.1042501405,
-0.0992895439,
0.8137316704,
0.6306812763,
-0.2453086674,
0.5591247082,
-0.2436680198,
0.4143347442,
-0.5564143658,
0.0367555507,
-0.5651777983,
-0.2088099271,
-0.1895023286,
-0.3710821569,
-0.0809422135,
0.3027972579,
-0.0593051463,
0.5053764582,
-0.2730852962,
0.7487255931,
0.5071328282,
-0.0219802931,
0.6059100628,
0.1804938018,
-0.2130951732,
-0.2278887779,
-0.4568416178,
-0.6958681345,
0.8613684773,
0.2320531458,
0.7739493847,
0.173107177,
0.6993740201,
0.6014951468,
0.4149790406,
-0.5571869612,
0.5158724189,
0.1392350346,
-0.8330924511,
-0.5137476921,
-0.4960308075,
-1.1180403233,
0.3061386347,
-0.2353574485,
-0.4418772161,
-0.0491449125,
-0.0587750413,
-0.0383745283,
0.5915250182,
-0.2740148306,
0.5951427817,
-0.1006924361,
-0.8481817245,
-0.0831369013,
-0.1982249022,
0.1980653554,
-0.2764979899,
0.5512692332,
-0.3958027065,
-0.3569675982,
0.6295086145,
-0.5297834277,
0.522370398,
-0.2942068875,
-0.3790549636,
0.3367067873,
0.6079384089,
0.6194623113,
0.0339105837,
0.0586948916,
-0.0419356711,
0.1309630424,
-0.7030062675,
-0.3190158606,
0.5173544884,
-0.5108577609,
-0.4845770895,
-0.4243178964,
-0.3789819181,
-0.3245663643,
0.3948679268,
0.3930109441,
0.3945821524,
0.008228655,
0.0723769888,
0.8140540719,
-0.4017897844,
0.4511652589,
0.5666507483,
-0.2023853511,
-0.4862448871,
1.145588398,
0.2959699035,
0.3933205009,
0.4309316576,
0.3290391266,
-0.4128344357,
-0.8475641608,
-0.2349819094,
0.045641765,
-0.7959761024,
-0.3321766257,
-0.3247805238,
-0.5157494545,
0.093897678,
-0.1145923212,
-0.4773319662,
-0.3096631765,
-0.2711652219,
-0.1041372791,
0.0537463799,
0.5350254774,
-0.0305102021,
0.0671784654,
-0.8809831142,
0.306653738,
0.6895433068,
0.4340309501,
-0.4137448072,
-0.810084641,
-0.0540236682,
-0.1323052794,
-0.2937298417,
-0.5931948423,
0.3887757659,
0.3556207418,
0.6171454191,
0.7577053905,
0.1084241718,
0.3854237199,
-0.1712245494,
0.5184714198,
0.3337220848,
-1.3609557152,
0.4588075876,
-0.2316264659,
0.3177176416,
0.4646399021,
0.1953591853,
-0.2767732739,
-0.6193802357,
-0.6300932765,
-1.070509553,
0.0510902219,
0.2990781367,
0.4051756561,
0.4122910798,
0.3097013235,
0.2816847265,
0.0318958685,
-0.809536159,
-0.1218014956,
-0.1462142318,
0.008577574,
0.0621027946,
-0.7857581377,
-0.2268405557,
-0.2399292737,
0.6824018359,
-0.1198348105,
0.009582432,
0.143343389,
-0.3405892551,
0.0247023199,
0.1936394125,
0.6741856337,
0.731377244,
0.1011637375,
0.5224192739,
0.1880037338,
-0.549054563,
0.3448604941,
-0.2770535648,
-0.412014991,
0.1053615659,
0.6680042744,
0.6057092547,
0.0363565013,
-0.8757904768,
0.5446861982,
-0.0800452679,
-0.3704632819,
0.1100780666,
0.2865556777,
0.1406743079,
0.2355889529,
0.4604276419,
-0.0100634946,
0.0051917625,
-0.2961398661,
0.3116333783,
0.5138261318,
-0.4098208249,
-0.1708531231,
0.7642109394,
0.008597102,
-0.2084257603,
0.0134051833,
-0.0712493435,
-0.6379331946,
0.4826785624,
0.5423565507,
0.5636942387,
-0.1787216961,
0.038141977,
0.1412004083,
0.5121542811,
-0.1621419489,
0.5521970391,
0.0124476394,
-1.0096260309,
-0.3809211254,
-0.5116917491,
-0.8075632453,
0.2657140195,
-0.672899425,
0.0396826379,
-0.6777239442,
-0.2896203697,
-0.2886891961,
-0.0473810807,
-0.2605344057,
0.3723181188,
0.2660829723,
1.1784141064,
-0.6367868781,
0.8742897511,
0.3319167495,
-0.0446001329,
-0.4707704782,
0.06783925,
0.0985173956,
-1.1555383205,
0.253734529,
0.2827861905,
-0.2865175903,
-0.0934524685,
-0.8352867961,
-0.9082625508,
1.0572035313,
0.6520743966,
-0.4942729175,
0.686727643,
0.3792124391,
0.3129503727,
-0.0135137485,
-0.2779329717,
0.7890316844,
0.7321025729,
-0.1321467459,
-0.633836329,
0.3730944693,
-0.5611647367,
-0.0284518506,
-0.0112948706,
-0.7730772495,
0.4304887652,
0.0249469336,
-0.3791469634,
0.0831147879,
0.2426896691,
0.4056317806,
0.3302481174,
0.6716803312,
0.7202726007,
0.702364862,
-0.3172294497,
0.7701278925,
-0.3329404593,
0.3937894702,
0.6578452587,
-0.4211349487,
0.8727089763,
0.6802252531,
-0.3649988472,
0.0383485109,
0.428241998,
-0.2194214761,
0.5301540494,
0.4207870662,
-0.5033163428,
-0.3702420294,
-0.1866223514,
-0.4821534157,
0.3162014186,
0.1525477171,
-0.2254085094,
0.1000027806,
-0.2346675694,
0.3119525909,
-0.0075018001,
-0.1433723569,
0.5254245996,
0.184118554,
-0.152714625,
0.6854763031,
-0.0316304751,
0.8970149159,
-0.4865990579,
0.2883765399,
-0.4522237182,
0.1736523956,
-0.2990507483,
-0.9027602673,
0.4197512269,
0.0255865753,
-0.0230088998,
-0.6028048992,
0.9723928571,
-0.2190034986,
-0.2736846209,
0.6770970821,
0.5050778389,
-0.0504120961,
-0.3497564197,
-0.7181867361,
0.4492297173,
-0.1270335317,
-0.5261757374,
0.3036206961,
0.3919536173,
0.3803685009,
1.0355513096,
0.9000176191,
0.1863342077,
0.1709617674,
-0.0137350839,
0.8131911755,
-0.7062894106,
-0.4753555059,
-1.1454024315,
0.2270241678,
-0.1135393903,
-0.1386926919,
0.7115215063,
0.7025281191,
0.5007717013,
0.1926037967,
1.059032321,
0.3736770451,
0.0865884423,
-0.5540911555,
1.0001461506,
-0.7218571901,
0.3660320044,
-0.3134917617,
-0.9364540577,
-0.5696751475,
0.3803451955,
0.242872417,
-0.1712625027,
0.5851332545,
0.6733367443,
-0.0087120403,
0.0094947917,
0.7606981993,
-0.0865193233,
0.4820165038,
0.4189584851,
1.0391023159,
-0.2928540111,
0.9473623633,
0.03325985,
-0.3467491567,
-0.1872005761,
-0.9267072082,
-0.7658544183,
-0.3326842487,
-0.4991707206,
-0.6477237344,
-0.0695314184,
0.2956872582,
0.7632396817,
-0.864127934,
0.1987738311,
-0.0514204279,
0.2539761364,
-0.1969228536,
-0.2075964808,
0.1243523881,
0.0207956377,
-0.4969140887,
0.3881689906,
0.6321251392,
0.398676604,
-0.3895388842,
-0.2216731906,
0.2002953738,
0.5939077735,
0.4299231172,
0.3051291704,
-0.2492030114,
-0.0255487841,
-0.2025771737,
-0.365160346,
0.2061214894,
0.8089368939,
-0.1057270318,
0.3671947122,
0.6548191905,
0.7855466604,
0.5495967269,
-0.4420791864,
0.353713423,
-0.4782567024,
0.0818196684,
0.0968548283,
0.6500237584,
0.3905129433,
-0.1148444936,
0.4466678202,
0.6602136493,
-0.2540121377,
-0.9582081437,
0.0757304132,
-0.8263000846,
-0.4141547978,
1.252016902,
-0.4037585258,
-0.0636649951,
-0.3805790246,
-0.3148426414,
0.0148465009,
-0.1051811129,
0.8531506062,
1.0569201708,
0.2607991993,
-0.2108295262,
-0.5025037527,
0.2518879175,
0.4165627956,
-0.7413102388,
-0.1510086358,
-0.118188791,
0.7141363621,
0.0508047678,
0.4413241446,
-0.3059759736,
0.165072307,
0.094015494,
0.0824512243,
-0.379347682,
-0.0945539325,
-0.1350233555,
0.368579179,
0.2565023005,
-0.1472615004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03582v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03582v1
|
Design of an Open-Source Architecture for Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-06T09:57:52 | 2024-03-06T09:57:52 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
adaptNMT is an open-source application that offers a streamlined approach to
the development and deployment of Recurrent Neural Networks and Transformer
models. This application is built upon the widely-adopted OpenNMT ecosystem,
and is particularly useful for new entrants to the field, as it simplifies the
setup of the development environment and creation of train, validation, and
test splits. The application offers a graphing feature that illustrates the
progress of model training, and employs SentencePiece for creating subword
segmentation models. Furthermore, the application provides an intuitive user
interface that facilitates hyperparameter customization. Notably, a
single-click model development approach has been implemented, and models
developed by adaptNMT can be evaluated using a range of metrics. To encourage
eco-friendly research, adaptNMT incorporates a green report that flags the
power consumption and kgCO${_2}$ emissions generated during model development.
The application is freely available.
|
[
-0.4003240466,
-0.3948622644,
0.4368039072,
0.4225458801,
-0.3720736802,
-0.4247730672,
-0.385784924,
-0.1015109643,
0.1644335687,
0.6915951371,
-0.3494294584,
-0.5896898508,
-0.3560588658,
0.0446725488,
-0.1666699499,
0.7286124825,
-0.3052741587,
0.0967289433,
0.0300524309,
-0.5680010319,
-0.3948942721,
-0.0604279637,
-0.6628838778,
-0.4085023701,
0.673551023,
0.3325237632,
0.7299291492,
0.8624677658,
0.7642525434,
0.2265929431,
-0.2947410941,
-0.1088197604,
0.0601726696,
0.226610586,
-0.3732151985,
-0.4409834445,
-0.5837117434,
-0.1678276211,
0.386929363,
0.446194768,
-0.3095873892,
0.6192604899,
-0.1184991598,
0.5825510025,
-0.3363470137,
0.1470440924,
-0.6948891878,
0.1280120611,
-0.0573626682,
-0.1761197597,
-0.3763102591,
-0.516636312,
0.0406365395,
-0.5520471931,
-0.0537525378,
-0.058254566,
0.5844994187,
0.4238479733,
-0.3580659926,
-0.225379467,
-0.7021312714,
0.4999901056,
-0.7584883571,
0.4572792351,
-0.1799935251,
0.7323981524,
-0.1912941039,
-1.1815345287,
-0.4871001244,
-0.0395281054,
-0.0659646094,
0.221671313,
-0.4098823369,
-0.0318435989,
-0.2413461953,
0.6106870174,
-0.6957140565,
0.0440010317,
-0.4008889198,
0.125868544,
-0.0578456894,
0.3886279464,
0.2153790444,
-0.0766592175,
-0.5025348663,
0.1577237546,
-0.5651450753,
-0.4799723923,
0.1170560792,
0.7020466924,
-0.0548515283,
0.7664861083,
0.0191328023,
0.6910263896,
-0.4230785072,
0.5457183719,
0.2458923906,
-0.3830744922,
-0.4388340414,
0.160113588,
0.8050710559,
0.3475402594,
0.0461203046,
-0.1494489014,
-0.233443588,
-0.3227359951,
0.5563563108,
-1.0407394171,
-0.3323385715,
0.1040680036,
-0.669172585,
-0.2814396024,
-0.3107430041,
-0.669121325,
-0.114554897,
-0.3571871817,
0.5954238176,
-0.4227550328,
-0.4992512763,
0.1539214998,
-0.2605965137,
0.0727008581,
0.1892222762,
-0.6200046539,
0.2393912971,
0.4534188807,
1.3867021799,
0.0109115401,
-0.2487526983,
0.1203270331,
-0.0440717563,
0.0379897766,
0.5474320054,
-0.1251850724,
-0.3744078279,
-0.3596293628,
0.2287641615,
-0.2541173398,
-0.5444146991,
0.4750181139,
-0.6347241402,
0.2138143778,
0.3514059782,
-0.1533134282,
-0.4863395989,
0.487151444,
-0.5969455838,
0.8215330839,
0.4059540331,
-0.8312121034,
-0.1154973879,
-1.5295084715,
-0.162241444,
0.028318109,
0.3493885994,
-0.5413028598,
0.3396429718,
0.0394939408,
-0.0828356817,
-0.3255767524,
0.0774833411,
-0.0752555802,
-0.1326084882,
0.0909420848,
-0.4803425372,
0.9108558297,
0.7268056273,
-0.2016530484,
0.6398453712,
-0.8949145079,
0.091727078,
0.1688624322,
-0.7042470574,
-0.4391273856,
-0.2701992691,
0.2260648906,
0.3308558166,
0.1349407732,
-0.609187901,
0.1831592023,
-0.3653437793,
0.751858592,
0.6049386263,
-0.0120364092,
0.1737426072,
0.0473950244,
0.5543245673,
0.3890005648,
0.2510901988,
-0.4769937396,
-0.4928947985,
-0.7921655774,
-0.056373246,
0.4797071517,
0.5277795792,
-0.5682654977,
0.3051857352,
-0.3604876399,
-0.7271159887,
-0.8862346411,
0.0130956108,
0.0266860947,
0.6902419329,
0.5886566639,
0.0129472027,
-0.6137161851,
-1.0485999584,
-0.2969061732,
0.1560655683,
-0.2304198593,
0.1116063669,
0.6021885276,
-0.3824215829,
0.8815268874,
-0.5045821071,
-0.1095793024,
-0.0558742769,
-0.0964534357,
0.4549831748,
0.5869008899,
0.5876897573,
-0.7209655046,
-0.381870389,
0.4591734707,
-0.6509796977,
0.1014196351,
0.3519029319,
-0.3121349812,
-0.2072474211,
0.368855536,
-0.6154042482,
0.2419978082,
0.6651162505,
-0.2310925573,
0.3270257711,
-0.2161083817,
-0.1318199337,
-1.6672071218,
0.590147078,
-0.0765005425,
-0.2215052843,
-0.4140632451,
0.3830038309,
0.1270079762,
-0.3793237805,
-0.8724542856,
0.3086734414,
-0.0907566845,
0.0133571262,
-0.3373954892,
-0.0625232756,
-0.0745781437,
0.3716462851,
-0.1273819953,
0.8549667597,
0.0810840577,
-0.5616759658,
0.0434342362,
0.2210769951,
-0.3824182153,
0.3118756413,
-0.8758512139,
0.3384616375,
0.1244077981,
-0.1425224543,
-0.7416272163,
-0.060887754,
0.4224687219,
-0.3724001646,
-0.1754454225,
-0.1514701545,
-0.4695304334,
-0.2092892528,
0.1470139921,
0.3289903104,
0.4653766155,
-0.6402100325,
0.5490502715,
0.1525184363,
-0.0683422089,
0.0261184815,
-0.9988607764,
0.1663223058,
-0.2113227695,
-0.5048511028,
0.1423868835,
0.0391519479,
-0.1081145927,
0.2526872158,
0.0927520767,
-0.182372123,
0.2531077862,
0.1963299364,
0.023098316,
-0.8440557718,
0.0012829333,
0.1370577067,
-0.1676380932,
0.0012340213,
-0.9051086307,
0.4625613689,
-0.176798448,
-0.1394864023,
-0.2673450708,
0.1425049007,
0.9100261927,
-0.3265140951,
0.5800512433,
0.5966832638,
-0.3838040233,
-0.1183496863,
0.2484324574,
0.2779948711,
-0.4742396772,
0.4216606319,
-0.1790403277,
-0.6989141703,
0.1877448857,
-0.3901745081,
0.4171047807,
0.5396755338,
0.6793991923,
0.3349473476,
0.9412693381,
0.6109467745,
0.453778863,
0.4658483565,
0.052853141,
-0.0664432272,
-1.1448956728,
-0.1115499064,
-0.6644864678,
-0.6847486496,
-0.3155089021,
-0.3603342772,
0.2668006718,
-0.1778540611,
-0.5738943219,
0.6601424813,
-0.9649422765,
0.3119050562,
0.7328371406,
0.1213737428,
0.2739783227,
-0.060202349,
-0.3404163122,
-0.1888106316,
-0.6866232753,
-0.509791851,
0.9347963333,
0.4592551589,
0.5502923131,
0.3971139491,
0.3028242886,
-0.0401029214,
0.6296946406,
-0.9983041883,
0.409989208,
-0.1782370657,
-0.4582258165,
0.0162858274,
-0.5499961972,
-0.9644457698,
0.1853100359,
0.310323149,
-0.3576114476,
-0.0415508412,
0.1937783957,
-0.1700376868,
0.5800634027,
-0.753131628,
1.0620894432,
-0.3226824999,
0.0936168283,
0.0396408699,
-0.5829574466,
0.2993609011,
-0.0250062756,
-0.0834136903,
0.0478962548,
-0.0605906248,
0.4871454239,
-0.4838067889,
0.5052168965,
-0.3198886514,
0.1726783812,
0.3494371474,
0.1575624943,
0.0682817474,
-0.331884712,
-0.3692598045,
0.2775468826,
-0.432816118,
-0.1659101099,
-0.4656820893,
0.7977051735,
-0.6008661985,
-0.3304283321,
-0.0521654449,
-0.8930864334,
0.0184153765,
0.8169742227,
0.1084882244,
-0.1049151644,
-0.3468844891,
0.5148767829,
0.6144767404,
-0.4514865279,
0.2894845307,
0.5549057722,
-0.6415327787,
-0.9667620659,
0.6799422503,
0.0990315005,
0.328491807,
0.4006421864,
0.6761792898,
-0.1697525829,
-0.8622485399,
-0.7252791524,
-0.2759973705,
-0.6820726395,
-0.2506480217,
-0.6442068219,
-0.1699732095,
-0.3294757009,
0.2171768695,
-0.4800234437,
-0.6718295217,
-0.0523625053,
-0.1556164622,
0.5489582419,
0.6880444288,
0.3440636992,
0.704265058,
-0.7934448123,
0.067558974,
0.0372217223,
0.4786755443,
0.0115748914,
-0.4381748438,
-0.6592156291,
0.1579279155,
-0.7113608718,
-0.4427996874,
0.2974701524,
0.0522042885,
0.3809115291,
0.1379817724,
-0.1993072331,
0.3718520105,
-0.550947845,
0.8579443693,
0.1832467914,
-0.6229448318,
0.6921992898,
-0.3223956823,
0.8426030874,
0.599260807,
0.2651795745,
-0.4377464056,
-0.1085415706,
-0.2597655952,
-0.8561548591,
0.7020978332,
0.2616792321,
0.0866515338,
-0.0782717168,
0.3344433606,
0.2293570042,
0.3582233787,
-0.4966017604,
-0.2225693017,
-0.6743952036,
-0.5292566419,
0.0529136918,
0.2851677537,
-0.02201147,
-0.1919517368,
0.7256640196,
-0.1519683301,
0.2970961332,
0.1702481061,
-0.1369905621,
0.0926264673,
0.111876972,
0.8564453721,
0.3152866662,
-0.2913811803,
0.3470530212,
0.031396091,
-0.5611872673,
-0.0095494241,
-0.0878506824,
-0.3619482219,
0.4441839159,
-0.2538025379,
1.0723153353,
0.3032879829,
-0.1893808991,
0.1001895443,
-0.2452287823,
-0.3910099566,
-0.0823031515,
-0.0485843606,
0.6251308918,
0.2604484558,
-0.1716227531,
0.6135183573,
0.0030973242,
-0.1795763671,
0.1057256684,
-0.0280444361,
-0.8047866225,
-0.5045810938,
1.1459947824,
0.2426064759,
-0.8819732666,
0.7990392447,
0.3116854429,
-0.3793179393,
0.5671743155,
0.8982245922,
1.2983750105,
-0.2257438749,
-0.1532761604,
0.2511697412,
0.6318191886,
0.1115074083,
0.2752287388,
0.0515489392,
-0.2225233614,
-0.0883330032,
-0.7799316645,
-0.3684084117,
0.0665839911,
-0.5306090713,
0.5111301541,
-0.3763012886,
-0.2958977222,
-0.0454296283,
-0.7435279489,
-0.5969962478,
0.0834536999,
-0.2914700806,
1.6004042625,
-0.3992579877,
0.8798617721,
1.0093696117,
-0.5200834274,
-0.3802720308,
-0.1262060553,
-0.2189534754,
-0.9263150096,
0.4758346379,
0.2211469561,
0.0784234256,
0.3435109556,
-0.179414615,
-0.5338612795,
1.3407694101,
0.6214871407,
-0.3623329103,
-0.0922067687,
0.3302308619,
0.4890475869,
-0.3500595391,
0.1111510172,
0.1045368537,
0.6914755702,
-0.0495696776,
-0.6914243698,
0.0987912342,
-0.2827257812,
0.2449991852,
0.5947934389,
-0.5968993902,
0.9147731662,
0.1686465293,
-0.0354879238,
0.1672926247,
0.4987230003,
-0.2497630864,
0.4180334806,
0.367174089,
0.681486249,
0.2556923032,
-0.0700450614,
0.718427062,
-0.4937657416,
0.3859457374,
1.3316326141,
0.0568816513,
0.8196749687,
0.6516019106,
-0.0947239548,
0.3302849233,
0.4485822618,
0.0021713313,
0.4522436261,
0.3738281131,
-0.1936561763,
0.1741525233,
-0.2132143527,
-0.2810820341,
0.3194195628,
0.2837614417,
-0.9732523561,
-0.5512673259,
0.0635556877,
-0.0329480767,
-0.1156000048,
-0.469022572,
0.6783604026,
0.3511276245,
-0.5821931958,
0.2291448116,
0.1308361143,
0.4415242374,
-0.6443422437,
0.0130401244,
-0.0993751436,
0.5676256418,
-0.2329347879,
-0.855481267,
0.9499655962,
-0.0815521106,
-0.2474413812,
-0.2651730776,
0.5394706726,
-0.3608494997,
-0.4013414979,
0.1385618001,
0.4527783096,
0.1996916085,
-0.1963778436,
-0.7271380424,
-0.0869570971,
-0.0623069964,
-0.4033423066,
0.2891021371,
0.525052011,
0.0494319573,
0.3528656363,
0.6278748512,
0.0838763937,
0.1665335745,
-0.1049792618,
0.7065322995,
-0.7366469502,
-0.3161209524,
-0.8674880862,
0.5785958767,
0.1317108721,
-0.5416040421,
0.7806851268,
0.9067465663,
0.572678566,
-0.3126825094,
0.7123355269,
0.1209187731,
0.3063280284,
-0.2426137477,
0.9161846042,
-0.4954957962,
0.0549769923,
0.1807516962,
-1.0072222948,
-0.5354309082,
-0.0223497953,
0.1377143413,
-0.3340708911,
0.5135036111,
0.6630694866,
-0.6208914518,
0.1161360666,
0.1760158241,
0.0576087572,
0.3346888423,
0.3585869074,
0.5611696839,
-0.521283865,
0.8007133007,
-0.0821584389,
0.0043351292,
-0.1796347946,
-0.9642397761,
-0.5897136927,
-0.1455620378,
-0.2561296821,
-0.4304111898,
-0.1146305054,
1.0670793056,
0.4901163876,
-0.6499451399,
-0.1542284638,
-0.5196906328,
0.0262187589,
-0.4750425816,
-0.2379818112,
0.2120015025,
-0.2045465857,
-0.6838109493,
0.5000305176,
0.3954869211,
-0.0124389892,
-0.2152729332,
-0.156230092,
-0.2033848763,
0.0916144475,
0.4663811326,
0.2047620565,
-0.290279001,
-0.1368283778,
0.1653514802,
0.0276487432,
0.4469205737,
0.7826043963,
-0.4059298933,
0.6915736794,
0.5274009109,
0.9914217591,
0.216948837,
-0.3457365334,
0.6571112871,
-0.5565471053,
0.0865374431,
0.1417710632,
0.2707681358,
0.2401166409,
-0.0492515191,
0.4641680717,
0.1989830136,
-0.6470302939,
-0.7970533371,
0.1815928817,
-0.7305375338,
-0.0906687677,
0.7399269938,
-0.2836127877,
-0.6002138257,
-0.0234041996,
-0.3733026385,
0.3332657814,
-0.0379975922,
0.447142899,
0.4576473832,
-0.0121360701,
0.0203292202,
-0.6417483687,
-0.1558290571,
0.1248379275,
-0.5734803677,
0.0291950256,
0.0306451228,
0.4845189154,
0.3209381104,
0.1375405788,
-0.3461156189,
0.0901734605,
0.101559341,
0.4069610238,
-0.6621935964,
0.0289122798,
-0.5347229838,
0.2616234422,
0.2160972655,
-0.8681874871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03581v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03581v1
|
Enhancing ASD detection accuracy: a combined approach of machine learning and deep learning models with natural language processing
| 2024-03-06T09:57:42 | 2024-03-06T09:57:42 |
Sergio Rubio-Martín, María Teresa García-Ordás, Martín Bayón-Gutiérrez, Natalia Prieto-Fernández, José Alberto Benítez-Andrades
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Purpose: Our study explored the use of artificial intelligence (AI) to
diagnose autism spectrum disorder (ASD). It focused on machine learning (ML)
and deep learning (DL) to detect ASD from text inputs on social media,
addressing challenges in traditional ASD diagnosis.
Methods: We used natural language processing (NLP), ML, and DL models
(including decision trees, XGB, KNN, RNN, LSTM, Bi-LSTM, BERT, and BERTweet) to
analyze 404,627 tweets, classifying them based on ASD or non-ASD authors. A
subset of 90,000 tweets was used for model training and testing.
Results: Our AI models showed high accuracy, with an 88% success rate in
identifying texts from individuals with ASD.
Conclusion: The study demonstrates AI's potential in improving ASD diagnosis,
especially in children, highlighting the importance of early detection.
|
[
-0.446467638,
-1.0052230358,
0.3140195012,
0.0930807739,
-0.0023077549,
0.6423904896,
-0.1309929937,
-1.0378432274,
0.1573002189,
0.3419680297,
-0.5989915133,
-0.7523014545,
-0.8209936023,
0.2367596328,
-0.6959941983,
0.6503638029,
0.0061893696,
0.0839346647,
0.3438584208,
-0.141857639,
-0.0884013548,
-0.1780725867,
-1.5012683868,
-0.269317776,
0.2857634723,
0.6416168809,
0.6400567889,
0.5237599015,
0.6565580964,
0.2514072359,
-0.320577383,
0.4054532051,
0.0911767185,
-0.0878404602,
-0.0720938891,
0.2562451363,
-0.695435524,
0.075192824,
0.3787266612,
0.8338965774,
0.1276057363,
0.1335285902,
0.2735973001,
0.6333201528,
-0.2171499282,
0.0163021665,
-0.0848096907,
0.3058649302,
-0.2108218819,
0.0155779403,
-0.1555014104,
-0.1229786947,
-0.0179902278,
-0.6726287007,
0.2823077142,
-0.1506215483,
0.7200796008,
0.3224622607,
-0.7185677886,
-0.6368353963,
-0.8187847733,
0.3826934695,
-0.8228359818,
0.3906694353,
0.6295158863,
0.4556268156,
0.1047751307,
-0.5130594969,
-0.7929536104,
-0.093152374,
0.1563402414,
-0.2975913286,
-0.2997563779,
0.0805690065,
0.287927568,
0.0051719882,
-0.7090835571,
0.4461541474,
-0.2995598316,
-0.177657634,
1.089546442,
0.00519465,
0.6220010519,
0.1462393999,
0.2159101963,
0.2624865174,
-0.0354256481,
0.3593149483,
-0.0072925286,
0.3759074509,
-0.2036420256,
0.3643241823,
-0.1625602841,
0.4166204929,
0.2251682281,
0.1863803864,
0.48288095,
-0.2361342013,
-0.1066386998,
0.0757668167,
0.9216150641,
0.316159755,
0.5933850408,
-0.0177519191,
-0.2523882687,
0.2940755785,
0.294762969,
-0.5331395864,
-0.2799014151,
0.2810536325,
-0.6158031225,
-0.261631459,
-0.1763845086,
-0.3835775256,
-0.6918391585,
-0.2220700979,
0.0441266708,
-0.7893548012,
-0.3559009135,
0.0402816683,
-0.1892881244,
-0.1957853884,
0.2171408683,
-0.9029514194,
0.6296314001,
0.5862177014,
0.5679677725,
-0.1786002219,
0.0144266039,
-0.4935412407,
-0.0791963637,
-0.6260890365,
1.0656911135,
-0.4866627455,
0.0109883305,
-0.2033483386,
-0.0855713785,
-0.0488859713,
-0.5190294385,
0.7934330106,
-0.5076481104,
-0.2750190794,
-0.0469721928,
-0.5518034101,
-0.3543169796,
0.1452437639,
-0.8113585711,
0.8340842724,
0.1965257823,
-0.3787562251,
0.7193112373,
-1.0920441151,
-0.7400266528,
0.2526162267,
0.0762842521,
-0.5868703723,
-0.172762543,
0.7452058792,
0.5747720599,
-0.1035963893,
0.4963227808,
-0.4973344207,
-0.3145905435,
0.0551536456,
-0.494084239,
1.0702973604,
0.3423841298,
-0.5268751383,
0.1518695205,
-0.6124985218,
0.0992231742,
-0.0450035445,
-0.2776530385,
0.0803993046,
0.183408305,
0.3297912478,
0.0043181027,
-0.2798629701,
-0.5998886228,
-0.1275359243,
-0.7191610336,
0.317447722,
0.4778511524,
0.1364628822,
0.2123310715,
-0.4626466334,
0.5910332203,
0.3280902505,
0.0943059251,
0.1681568474,
-0.9972750545,
-0.2184727341,
-0.1137749776,
0.3797997236,
0.429025948,
-0.669308424,
0.9473637938,
-0.1634293348,
-0.0889075547,
-0.7311826944,
0.2260858864,
0.2807543278,
0.5411470532,
0.4282450378,
-0.2044298351,
-0.4780059755,
-0.4678789079,
-0.3733617663,
0.1354413927,
0.0317115821,
0.2380907536,
0.4797282815,
-0.5240795016,
0.7039576173,
0.0865868628,
-0.4994550645,
-0.2208850235,
0.3021611869,
-0.0684357658,
0.4099608064,
0.7608889341,
-0.7870204449,
-1.0265471935,
0.2232527435,
-0.7454622984,
-0.2467702627,
0.4782417417,
0.462764889,
0.4680940807,
0.5294423103,
-0.3243112862,
0.7667175531,
0.3111982942,
-0.8820685744,
0.0485703871,
0.1333585531,
0.4042593241,
-0.8350211382,
0.0875775516,
0.264102459,
-0.3863638937,
-0.6575966477,
-0.1938297451,
0.1615705043,
-0.1684769392,
-0.1031368747,
0.4050443172,
-0.1523894519,
-0.1670266539,
-0.2570484579,
-0.1249972582,
-0.1089067534,
-0.2492731661,
-0.2750887573,
0.5212547779,
0.7208064198,
-0.6651971936,
0.2589058578,
0.0796943605,
-0.2530395389,
0.3127291501,
-0.4794799685,
-0.0655986294,
-0.0552845597,
0.2734443545,
-1.2362972498,
-0.227206856,
0.5720125437,
-0.926379025,
0.2991790473,
0.3413302004,
-0.5099166632,
-0.8397060037,
-0.3356689513,
0.3539420366,
0.1791580319,
-0.5443120599,
0.5921597481,
0.572953999,
-0.1008800343,
-0.5470370054,
-0.6927275658,
0.2906352878,
0.0329368412,
-0.7991280556,
0.272574693,
-0.1151554957,
-0.1879379153,
0.361351192,
-0.0696136877,
-0.2706868351,
0.6281638145,
-0.1269717664,
-0.1913343966,
-0.5277180672,
0.3023745418,
0.2279162854,
-0.2054794282,
-0.0304500442,
0.223321557,
0.6981855035,
-0.0563460216,
-0.3768393397,
-0.9158760905,
0.5177672505,
0.4066703022,
-0.3334443569,
0.6097391248,
0.6818935871,
-0.7622826099,
-0.6196727157,
-0.1381373107,
-0.243828997,
-0.5129392147,
-0.064557381,
-0.0061855726,
-0.6038190126,
0.5980499983,
0.2672157586,
-0.3879654408,
0.5669840574,
0.2376314104,
-0.5543240905,
1.4339301586,
0.6296592951,
-0.2650957704,
0.4551936388,
-0.4077250957,
0.4992625713,
-0.5646819472,
0.0884785429,
-0.3404147029,
-0.520555377,
-0.2880004048,
-0.0383578613,
0.1323665977,
-0.3874037266,
-0.5365387201,
-0.231399864,
-0.7971404791,
0.5347958207,
0.5482624173,
0.354185909,
0.2183702588,
-0.0762672871,
0.2235756218,
0.0566745289,
-0.4462239444,
-0.7064938545,
1.5708884001,
0.4335969388,
0.0312839262,
0.1211391017,
0.5160713196,
0.8367651105,
0.720721662,
-0.8962477446,
0.3491559923,
-0.5978779197,
-0.7708605528,
-0.3550930023,
-0.2997856736,
-1.1697461605,
-0.3737755418,
-0.2478949428,
-0.880962193,
0.1837322116,
-0.0806687102,
-0.7744838595,
0.2371198535,
-0.6609046459,
0.9236963391,
-0.3619025052,
0.406883955,
-0.2873532772,
-0.54979527,
0.3856677115,
-0.3579445481,
0.3227091134,
-0.1985652596,
-0.0929606706,
1.1243252754,
-0.2650432289,
0.678968966,
-0.1375352144,
0.1474722922,
0.1643476784,
-0.2344334275,
-0.0090913223,
-0.0263828933,
-0.2936467826,
0.2345226407,
-0.2256995738,
-0.247516185,
-0.2413496077,
0.4957267642,
-0.9990182519,
-0.1340333372,
-0.6685456634,
-0.5420042276,
-0.3338465691,
0.3566777706,
-0.0037063984,
0.254383117,
0.0539098568,
0.1192033663,
0.5134254694,
-0.1296489239,
0.805865705,
0.7255923152,
-0.0674207583,
-0.0468063876,
0.5911100507,
0.4103804231,
-0.2220930755,
-0.0955697522,
0.1758220494,
-0.0698076934,
-0.7533676028,
-0.3176858723,
0.1604074836,
-0.5779545903,
-0.2239732444,
-0.6830083728,
-0.5811865926,
-0.9254018664,
-0.2633576393,
-0.2221114486,
-0.1647993922,
-0.6591677666,
-0.3514380157,
0.4530757666,
1.0063681602,
-0.2736607492,
0.4551313519,
-0.6039531231,
1.0933377743,
-0.1764342338,
0.4925816655,
0.0951594263,
-0.3043757379,
0.0102926055,
0.5278148055,
-0.4752254784,
-0.8691902757,
0.7730756998,
0.5487657189,
0.4881400466,
0.5764873624,
0.249326393,
0.5202584863,
0.0119829243,
0.6804450154,
-0.1611025482,
-0.9204005599,
0.6459234357,
-0.2396102101,
0.0088170497,
0.3036308885,
0.5817042589,
-0.5073487759,
-0.4210850596,
-0.7608035207,
-0.74677068,
1.1626310349,
-0.0438454524,
-0.3060147464,
0.0726013184,
0.1641739607,
-0.1760367453,
-0.0754439533,
-0.4618936479,
-0.418094337,
0.1632356197,
-0.705329895,
-0.5441713333,
-0.2839885652,
-0.0092879869,
-0.8646300435,
0.6132544875,
-0.0555129796,
0.2863985896,
-0.0513200499,
0.1290641725,
-0.5181280375,
-0.2698758245,
0.3116523623,
0.5933713317,
-0.0101756826,
-0.1798267812,
-0.1277504265,
-0.5718945861,
0.0044816835,
0.4118405282,
-0.1431137621,
0.0357253551,
0.6425305605,
0.3733259737,
-0.1824693829,
-0.7746815085,
0.6431847215,
-0.3062340617,
-0.3062112033,
-0.4303936362,
0.1338903904,
0.3415423036,
0.3446623981,
0.6801563501,
0.4065236151,
0.3578290343,
-0.4559363723,
0.6582849622,
0.5857099891,
-0.2025794685,
-0.1145150885,
0.59785676,
0.0890589431,
-1.0292415619,
0.6793074012,
-0.423707068,
-0.4926439822,
1.2829321623,
0.3501385748,
0.7910544872,
-0.4683816731,
0.4845923483,
-0.140355587,
0.3697467446,
0.1932529509,
0.5466794968,
-0.1284776628,
-1.1488733292,
-0.1340166628,
-0.3437190652,
-0.1195845827,
0.2602049112,
-0.5278030634,
0.2100377828,
-0.8249403238,
-0.3025820553,
0.7468235493,
0.3571685553,
-0.5049372911,
0.5873718858,
0.416071862,
0.6594899297,
-1.0024499893,
0.7372189164,
0.7162085176,
-0.3138846755,
-1.0391596556,
0.346742183,
0.1552828997,
-0.6444635391,
0.589658618,
0.5417233109,
0.1141113639,
0.1766252965,
-0.7231384516,
-0.9158756733,
0.7710905075,
0.2851502597,
-0.1310620159,
0.3820222318,
0.1141896024,
0.9440460205,
-0.5151082277,
0.1950805336,
0.7603415847,
0.4433709085,
0.1601211578,
-1.2566722631,
-0.2065324038,
-0.620646894,
-0.4707445204,
0.1212747321,
0.0872846767,
0.679305315,
-0.236140132,
-0.5228265524,
-0.3132860065,
0.3410809636,
0.0686938912,
1.0972886086,
0.1248895526,
0.5361966491,
1.1842708588,
0.1564320326,
0.9749155045,
-0.3869274557,
-0.0191211887,
0.5226450562,
-0.0793778151,
0.8420345783,
-0.0978967473,
0.0419913121,
0.1303038746,
0.9053878784,
0.4092485607,
0.2659557462,
-0.4266018271,
-0.2423633933,
0.0910549536,
-0.0801058486,
-0.2593405247,
0.1092810854,
0.8761360645,
-0.5371328592,
-0.1933748722,
0.4317751825,
-0.0050229807,
0.342715323,
-0.6046145558,
0.9096403718,
-0.0541398153,
-0.3776233196,
0.7047396302,
0.0978970155,
0.7735388875,
0.0758952126,
0.1238167137,
0.1109874472,
0.4851405621,
-0.3840360045,
-0.9671261907,
0.7899294496,
0.0166048408,
-0.1098074913,
-0.418109268,
0.7616791725,
-0.1844259053,
-0.9723408222,
0.4652174413,
0.3576268256,
-0.0783090219,
-0.1422416717,
-0.9705865979,
-0.1761527658,
-0.1359995753,
-0.2313847244,
-0.0596612655,
0.5743123293,
-0.227064684,
1.1527465582,
0.7406468987,
0.137247175,
-0.0614635386,
-0.1038416624,
0.7250835299,
-0.4863599837,
-0.4426491559,
-0.8350827098,
0.2568019927,
-0.2737566233,
-0.2518613636,
0.4887865484,
0.3148615658,
0.5495103598,
0.2269360423,
0.6744325161,
-0.0664348453,
1.1210116148,
0.1533643901,
1.1207123995,
-0.5577269793,
0.4865082502,
-0.1525508761,
-0.2060822248,
-0.7706744671,
0.8825947642,
-0.4542333484,
0.1920202225,
0.8173462152,
0.6351687312,
-0.1071100906,
0.2880662084,
-0.0372240618,
0.3597627878,
0.6120141745,
0.3692730367,
0.3300797641,
-0.4501186609,
0.0268340241,
-0.28946805,
-0.2474191189,
-0.3214874268,
-0.349760443,
-0.8966489434,
-0.5356624722,
-0.3838435411,
-0.1693426967,
0.3432837427,
0.9450019598,
0.5343074203,
-1.0426914692,
0.0910865963,
-0.3060416579,
0.4516912401,
-0.5342069864,
-0.2365562618,
0.3437528908,
-0.2098018974,
-0.4626513422,
0.4500142038,
-0.1089718193,
-0.0680873618,
0.1942712218,
0.0297146849,
-0.424403429,
-0.0446463227,
0.5433146954,
0.1971064061,
-0.4090785682,
-0.4374993742,
-0.2353764474,
-0.3694263697,
0.1233389452,
0.0846211836,
-0.9798743725,
0.1151539832,
0.139724806,
0.8077200055,
0.2370394915,
0.3875302672,
0.5591644049,
-0.3437504768,
-0.3639703095,
0.8632265925,
-0.0340173841,
0.245991528,
-0.6151227355,
0.4032293558,
0.3680613339,
-0.482796818,
-0.8013486862,
-0.1718860418,
-1.0241492987,
-0.4385497272,
1.1520609856,
0.146701321,
-0.3434862196,
-0.8672350645,
-0.2651844621,
0.2836872935,
-0.6862160563,
0.8200422525,
0.3836085796,
-0.3224635422,
-0.1984007508,
-0.4268072248,
0.7321279645,
0.0251130387,
-0.6214009523,
-0.4104652107,
0.2261922359,
0.2653196454,
-0.0839748308,
0.850143373,
0.4457393885,
0.6342120767,
-0.2143867016,
-0.140955165,
-0.1750604212,
-0.1839493215,
-0.4245136678,
0.1720490307,
-0.2170591205,
-0.2259176821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03575v1
|
gaHealth: An English-Irish Bilingual Corpus of Health Data
| 2024-03-06T09:36:36 | 2024-03-06T09:36:36 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Órla Ní Loinsigh, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine Translation is a mature technology for many high-resource language
pairs. However in the context of low-resource languages, there is a paucity of
parallel data datasets available for developing translation models.
Furthermore, the development of datasets for low-resource languages often
focuses on simply creating the largest possible dataset for generic
translation. The benefits and development of smaller in-domain datasets can
easily be overlooked. To assess the merits of using in-domain data, a dataset
for the specific domain of health was developed for the low-resource English to
Irish language pair. Our study outlines the process used in developing the
corpus and empirically demonstrates the benefits of using an in-domain dataset
for the health domain. In the context of translating health-related data,
models developed using the gaHealth corpus demonstrated a maximum BLEU score
improvement of 22.2 points (40%) when compared with top performing models from
the LoResMT2021 Shared Task. Furthermore, we define linguistic guidelines for
developing gaHealth, the first bilingual corpus of health data for the Irish
language, which we hope will be of use to other creators of low-resource data
sets. gaHealth is now freely available online and is ready to be explored for
further research.
|
[
0.2753759623,
-0.3848394752,
0.4711162448,
0.0755221248,
0.0311456546,
-0.0023258834,
-0.1504450589,
-0.7550187707,
0.514329493,
0.5444439054,
0.0166060682,
-0.5361583233,
-0.826220274,
0.2651638687,
-0.2573426664,
1.3274604082,
-0.0989522114,
0.3235774338,
-0.1882705986,
-0.3238840699,
-0.377602756,
-0.5606473684,
-0.3294796646,
-0.3081905842,
0.6180390716,
0.7171980739,
0.9200538397,
0.6315776706,
0.8881910443,
0.0689731091,
0.1636051387,
0.3232475519,
-0.4699713886,
0.0812460855,
-0.3492740393,
-0.1320636421,
-0.7620654702,
-0.1342360973,
0.2842317224,
0.9931394458,
0.0943204835,
0.5253924131,
-0.0020485518,
0.7726973891,
-0.4187946022,
0.2045416981,
-0.2607130408,
0.0739946142,
-0.7192611694,
-0.3117238283,
-0.126623854,
-0.1157672331,
0.0761847794,
-0.4358042181,
0.0411493145,
0.2612698674,
0.8932217956,
0.0454989076,
-0.6627964377,
-0.4872918427,
-0.4323354363,
0.6932599545,
-0.4499264061,
0.6788788438,
0.6690589786,
0.0144489538,
-0.103709124,
-0.6653749943,
-0.2018743157,
-0.1118528321,
-0.2428828329,
0.2596902847,
-0.5961236358,
-0.2403706908,
-0.0907982066,
0.5075616837,
-0.8932257295,
-0.1042220816,
-0.7536712885,
-0.0856626034,
0.6879993677,
0.4732930958,
0.6658639312,
-0.2631686926,
-0.0430060364,
0.1099190339,
-0.7597569227,
-0.1742570102,
0.1213502735,
0.6334343553,
-0.4841812253,
0.7946512103,
-0.0698693395,
0.3163334727,
-0.1063253582,
-0.3958825469,
0.7277694941,
-0.4372351766,
-0.3500978947,
0.0541210026,
0.3924953938,
0.5084608197,
0.0493689142,
-0.6775451899,
-0.0583350249,
0.0278074518,
0.2872871757,
-0.804348886,
-0.1000586003,
0.3152575493,
-0.6432672143,
0.0731675178,
-0.3273789883,
-0.7215890288,
-0.0417024046,
-0.2689110637,
0.1085230485,
-0.2925342321,
-0.1351491511,
0.425812602,
0.1512242109,
-0.3730796278,
-0.1152571067,
-0.8654882312,
0.4684847295,
0.4849044085,
0.8373302221,
-0.388392061,
-0.0235915855,
-0.683480382,
0.3767347634,
-0.2889420986,
0.4353850484,
-0.4723004401,
-0.6139366627,
0.0841962695,
0.2436506152,
-0.267729938,
-0.7621027231,
0.8026208282,
-0.1365592331,
0.0906952769,
-0.1626222432,
-0.4271664321,
0.017281469,
-0.0611544028,
-0.6478862166,
0.7914915085,
0.312721312,
-0.8223385215,
0.3482351899,
-0.6914689541,
-0.8804126382,
0.3755035996,
0.1142442375,
-0.2442067713,
0.173470661,
0.2754001915,
0.3850752413,
-0.4993160963,
0.0375321656,
-0.2679639161,
0.033816725,
-0.1071373075,
-0.0351508856,
0.7576252818,
0.4055038095,
-0.0800321922,
-0.4277727306,
-0.4586826861,
0.1234427392,
-0.077486366,
-0.2141379863,
-0.5697768331,
-0.0599541292,
0.2232439518,
0.1453952938,
0.1602804512,
-0.5597458482,
-0.1373831928,
-0.2420039177,
0.2739004493,
-0.1025750861,
0.0101935649,
0.4729956985,
-0.4710924625,
0.6223614216,
0.0161414146,
0.2232658565,
0.1921219081,
-1.0207953453,
-0.089847967,
-0.4340488017,
0.173017785,
1.018527627,
-0.5885657072,
0.0958420858,
-0.4727540016,
-0.2864904702,
-1.0843385458,
0.3076008558,
0.3938557208,
0.8662177324,
0.7357493043,
-0.2086065114,
-0.2470374405,
-0.9169427752,
-0.1523924172,
-0.1652736962,
0.0095536606,
0.5477190614,
0.413208276,
-0.7450256348,
0.2771487236,
-0.2298730612,
-0.3549124897,
-0.2456019521,
-0.1395653337,
0.1032704338,
0.5780180097,
0.6626548171,
-0.8722660542,
-0.5678902268,
0.5580074787,
-0.9570997953,
-0.255292058,
0.4203234911,
-0.5036087036,
-0.0849587023,
-0.0918084979,
-0.4165504277,
0.5118652582,
1.0442297459,
-0.2658083439,
0.305865556,
-0.2150945365,
0.2955223322,
-1.1093808413,
0.3234383166,
0.0898288563,
-0.3435967863,
-0.7950802445,
0.3217387199,
0.1439220607,
-0.3524517715,
-0.3847315311,
0.7996503711,
-0.1446654946,
0.4284436703,
-0.0565669313,
-0.3911244571,
0.1641678065,
-0.2692669034,
-0.1851958334,
0.8202582002,
0.3641163111,
-0.3142621517,
0.2530493736,
0.5088528395,
-0.2175500095,
0.7254011035,
-0.672939539,
0.1283029616,
0.1612158269,
0.0238025263,
-0.2739336491,
-0.62668854,
0.2660244703,
-0.4105649292,
0.0933953002,
0.0508691855,
-0.3632200956,
-0.2667655945,
0.1969984025,
0.4685358107,
0.3501431048,
-0.3291899264,
-0.1425629109,
1.0550763607,
-0.4558912516,
-0.1807920635,
-1.2746624947,
0.2396854758,
-0.4284434617,
-0.8130760193,
0.6321481466,
0.0355911292,
-0.5142269731,
0.3921209574,
0.0663218945,
-0.3752557337,
-0.3105597794,
0.0170399211,
0.2354987264,
-0.2301266342,
0.3876768351,
-0.1197121441,
-0.1185417846,
-0.1061723977,
-0.6492419839,
-0.0446031801,
0.0847080871,
0.0261126757,
-0.2217427343,
1.1575248241,
0.3237037361,
-0.2190583348,
0.6289100647,
0.1570031792,
-0.5773306489,
-0.0875719413,
-0.1535848528,
0.2733754516,
-0.311176002,
0.1673954576,
-0.2201045007,
-0.8229805827,
0.3781782389,
0.2733468413,
-0.1321553439,
0.4866250157,
0.8695031404,
-0.1843044311,
0.885599196,
0.7755296826,
-0.2336059362,
-0.0144270053,
-0.0634959564,
0.4109888375,
-0.517403841,
-0.1400586963,
-0.5310031772,
-0.2328217328,
-0.9320659637,
-0.3829461932,
0.6936955452,
-0.2488659918,
0.1309374273,
0.4636784792,
-0.4089983702,
-0.093580544,
0.3021378219,
0.473833859,
0.2424437106,
0.0355185457,
-0.2985132933,
-0.1960179806,
-0.6024334431,
-0.543107748,
1.0959966183,
0.1328469366,
0.6898937225,
0.1230000928,
0.6947351098,
0.306091696,
0.149028644,
-0.7191357017,
-0.0987288654,
-0.6686086059,
-0.6397525072,
-0.1146012023,
-0.6191491485,
-1.2331488132,
-0.0979842544,
-0.0209107716,
-0.4276364148,
0.2473809123,
0.198512733,
-0.3807165921,
0.1867394745,
-0.8336572647,
0.7485160232,
-0.3898754716,
-0.4788146019,
-0.2005769461,
-0.490215987,
0.0505078696,
-0.1984047145,
0.3870788217,
-0.159822613,
0.1057919264,
0.5229883194,
-0.4281859994,
0.3698648214,
0.1642883569,
0.0416789688,
0.013938495,
-0.1245232224,
0.2260738015,
0.2995773852,
-0.3331991136,
0.3028178811,
0.125132069,
-0.7713294625,
-0.1979403943,
0.672470808,
-0.370528996,
-0.4728411436,
-0.2577210963,
-0.781647861,
-0.4454890192,
0.1089731231,
0.2982222438,
0.4617263079,
-0.057933677,
0.0618216693,
0.3215015531,
-0.2741819918,
-0.1298600435,
0.3546636403,
-0.0167197511,
-0.4297531247,
0.9017836452,
0.2960036099,
0.2170331329,
0.380731225,
0.2763037682,
-0.0613108277,
-0.4213917851,
-0.6364398599,
0.2806291282,
-0.2521188557,
-0.2642785907,
-0.4628354013,
-0.2216201425,
-0.5822288394,
-0.1948251277,
0.1393387318,
-0.1908692271,
-0.000211424,
-0.1966293454,
0.4361234903,
0.7486379743,
-0.1358826756,
-0.1959640384,
-0.9515900612,
0.3925744593,
0.14539662,
0.0622033812,
-0.4571890235,
-0.2824611068,
-0.7917744517,
0.172684893,
-0.1158600971,
-0.977792263,
0.8431854844,
0.1666954458,
0.5126479268,
0.0429466292,
-0.1639165431,
0.7341138721,
-0.8490834236,
0.6528025866,
0.112934269,
-0.5313993692,
0.4054531753,
-0.2579559982,
0.2817842364,
0.7181611657,
0.599703908,
-0.8568522334,
-0.2583851218,
-0.6071345806,
-0.7405436635,
-0.0349686071,
0.1088160798,
0.1759368032,
-0.3239341378,
-0.0008748573,
0.366201818,
0.1672609448,
0.08204557,
-0.0605017692,
0.1043217033,
-0.2736241221,
-0.3346736133,
0.1167383119,
-0.2787915468,
-0.5411300659,
0.5016497374,
-0.1742474586,
0.3408251107,
0.2479770631,
-0.2857348025,
-0.2687859237,
0.1732521206,
0.2155758888,
0.4657628834,
-0.1827761531,
0.1101296768,
0.0654725507,
-0.88951087,
0.1207612306,
0.1976107657,
-0.206192106,
0.3200546205,
0.5010229945,
0.6317118406,
0.1634083986,
-0.5317264199,
0.4289649427,
0.2946938276,
0.0115967672,
0.2330249101,
-0.283529669,
0.0653188229,
-0.0669913813,
0.1544403732,
0.0193676483,
0.3554537594,
-0.538566649,
0.425489068,
0.1219575629,
-0.3532178402,
-0.6696708202,
0.7590276599,
0.3124794364,
-0.1203661039,
0.5056581497,
-0.0423806645,
0.0061585424,
0.3213194609,
0.6444716454,
0.7169516087,
-0.092448853,
0.3800939322,
0.2496555001,
0.1656679809,
0.0635344535,
0.5039147735,
0.3679198027,
-0.4987674356,
-0.4698675275,
-0.6511100531,
-0.5070099831,
0.0980127528,
-0.8988813162,
0.1664747894,
0.3132469654,
-0.3057034314,
0.0740215331,
0.1637870818,
-1.2164306641,
0.4243077636,
0.1640158892,
0.9066556096,
-0.7644242048,
1.0799767971,
0.8773195744,
-0.4869166315,
-0.4751593769,
0.2020701021,
0.1603032947,
-0.8533351421,
0.6340893507,
-0.197371155,
0.0271888394,
-0.1732196808,
-0.1995900869,
-0.7345921993,
0.6909610033,
0.7763330936,
-0.4130462408,
-0.2279610336,
0.569947958,
0.5931369662,
-0.5061078668,
-0.068090044,
0.47901088,
0.6133534908,
-0.4899486601,
-1.3104039431,
-0.2919928133,
-0.4504649341,
-0.2289290875,
0.1849305779,
-0.6619412303,
0.8503400087,
-0.1481544524,
-0.2153389305,
-0.0633854792,
0.3270673454,
-0.1844651252,
0.5282130837,
0.0802472234,
0.7275731564,
1.0743613243,
0.0963523239,
1.3447364569,
-0.3858278096,
0.2137922049,
0.8633979559,
-0.4608275294,
0.7262964249,
0.472705096,
-0.0880728066,
0.2169535756,
0.3591510355,
0.5050005317,
0.6790668964,
-0.0407862999,
-0.4919881225,
-0.0856490061,
-0.4264182746,
-0.4621616304,
0.4100464284,
0.4444815814,
-0.4864381254,
-0.2745773792,
0.3241223395,
0.296710819,
0.1406838894,
-0.2107535154,
0.4390135407,
0.3233641982,
-0.0709150508,
0.5193661451,
-0.1562178582,
0.3380663991,
-0.4790500104,
-0.0150052849,
-0.390569061,
-0.0059483252,
-0.4590365291,
-0.7007648945,
0.6557077169,
0.2381780744,
-0.4897889197,
-0.4122464359,
0.5278944969,
-0.5915879607,
-0.7487159967,
0.6680111289,
0.9011853933,
0.4249498248,
0.3997936547,
-0.4146206975,
-0.2352398634,
-0.3452988863,
0.1700407565,
0.4125909805,
0.6601876616,
-0.4772787094,
0.2258119434,
0.6867879033,
0.8200739026,
0.0355548039,
-0.1813225597,
0.5152158737,
-0.4383142292,
-0.4281831384,
-0.4636071622,
0.2313433141,
0.0877471119,
-0.6468393207,
0.7739776373,
0.7238181829,
0.9233453274,
0.0872461349,
1.151296258,
-0.2103160024,
0.823315382,
-0.2924697697,
0.8673875928,
-0.7938592434,
-0.4853558242,
0.0129790939,
-0.2399065942,
-0.6030781865,
0.2104231119,
-0.2508367598,
-0.6062629819,
0.8768378496,
0.8179194331,
-0.2092751563,
-0.1408517808,
0.6038207412,
-0.0485003926,
0.0415721573,
0.6347791553,
0.1444433331,
-0.3968169391,
0.0872381181,
-0.3303011358,
-0.1560186893,
-0.1665255576,
-0.695274055,
-0.3542883098,
-0.55413872,
-0.0978105217,
-0.3403917849,
0.5580875278,
0.8651849627,
0.8168119788,
-1.2053966522,
-0.3221887648,
0.489757508,
-0.3550518155,
-0.6589018703,
-0.0823857486,
0.30316329,
-0.3430725634,
-0.7582376003,
0.7617897391,
0.4341672063,
-0.3488498032,
0.0474652015,
-0.2765033841,
-0.0552926548,
-0.0024238401,
0.5548045039,
0.4764307141,
-0.2394830585,
-0.418035686,
0.1356250644,
-0.6830002666,
0.1518242508,
0.684774518,
-0.3910039961,
0.5363319516,
0.397128731,
0.9005302191,
0.2380573452,
-0.2177872658,
0.6664198041,
-0.3138781786,
0.3593325019,
0.3874097168,
0.4825288653,
0.4130194485,
-0.6226540208,
0.7783802152,
0.2984004915,
-0.6876418591,
-0.6649889946,
-0.1748732924,
-0.7435365915,
0.281529516,
1.1566925049,
-0.124667421,
-0.3658027649,
-0.3352498412,
0.0364771187,
0.2734713852,
-0.358432591,
0.6141248941,
0.6507617831,
-0.2138277292,
0.366404891,
-1.3187501431,
0.4207291603,
0.4211465418,
-0.915417552,
-0.1855197996,
0.1669355035,
0.1336313188,
-0.0730402991,
0.6855664253,
-0.2804181874,
0.2954175472,
-0.1778541207,
0.0317711718,
0.343290776,
-0.2986724675,
0.0016179703,
0.0083545893,
-0.5547319055,
-0.2105029374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03558v1
|
Benchmarking Hallucination in Large Language Models based on Unanswerable Math Word Problem
| 2024-03-06T09:06:34 | 2024-03-06T09:06:34 |
Yuhong Sun, Zhangyue Yin, Qipeng Guo, Jiawen Wu, Xipeng Qiu, Hui Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are highly effective in various natural language
processing (NLP) tasks. However, they are susceptible to producing unreliable
conjectures in ambiguous contexts called hallucination. This paper presents a
new method for evaluating LLM hallucination in Question Answering (QA) based on
the unanswerable math word problem (MWP). To support this approach, we
innovatively develop a dataset called Unanswerable Math Word Problem (UMWP)
which comprises 5200 questions across five categories. We developed an
evaluation methodology combining text similarity and mathematical expression
detection to determine whether LLM considers the question unanswerable. The
results of extensive experiments conducted on 31 LLMs, including GPT-3,
InstructGPT, LLaMA, and Claude, demonstrate that in-context learning and
reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) training significantly
enhance the model's ability to avoid hallucination. We show that utilizing MWP
is a reliable and effective approach to assess hallucination. Our code and data
are available at https://github.com/Yuki-Asuuna/UMWP.
|
[
-0.4359150231,
-0.9939017892,
0.6339559555,
0.4087124169,
-0.1929527074,
0.0555969514,
-0.3030687869,
-0.3342648149,
0.11582838,
0.461766243,
-0.6223897934,
-0.474489212,
-0.4722988904,
0.3231262267,
-0.358019352,
0.5037386417,
-0.155378148,
0.2719815373,
-0.687912941,
-0.3419065177,
-0.8546132445,
-0.5902271271,
-0.4994436502,
-0.5460860133,
0.1202977821,
0.0264515523,
0.5464038849,
0.2234334797,
0.6444148421,
0.3020252883,
0.0293912105,
0.3220569789,
-0.4152565598,
0.0098948134,
0.049510587,
-0.2318859845,
-0.0784061849,
-0.1839537174,
0.4913858771,
0.9754443765,
-0.45954144,
0.2042571455,
0.146454066,
0.7411509752,
-0.5385045409,
0.2493974566,
-1.0020219088,
0.3526160717,
0.2023902535,
-0.337064147,
-0.3585539758,
-0.4069543779,
0.0452597365,
-0.3668526411,
0.0289608222,
-0.0068087769,
0.5174368024,
0.3556877077,
-0.0847396329,
-0.4233759344,
-0.5339155793,
0.7165780067,
-0.7717605233,
0.4486279488,
0.4935442507,
0.2000143826,
-0.4471020997,
-0.4000859559,
-0.6142982244,
-0.3098831773,
0.1582968533,
-0.032043431,
-0.1946499199,
-0.2537521422,
0.5156226158,
0.1126353368,
-0.6988644004,
-0.0015622446,
-0.0074939332,
-0.2235761136,
0.3740644157,
0.2036158741,
0.2549290657,
-0.2056450099,
-0.2216920406,
-0.1895774603,
-0.4614416957,
-0.0094172796,
0.1041448861,
0.1205331758,
0.1890012771,
0.8158542514,
-0.1644619852,
0.5492420197,
-0.3226402998,
0.047451783,
0.3422564566,
0.3441175818,
-0.2145790309,
-0.0473033413,
0.5017938614,
0.2336580455,
0.4035693705,
-0.525647819,
-0.4974115193,
0.2929947674,
0.2744657993,
-0.7315753698,
0.0247728825,
0.1527817845,
-0.290615797,
-0.1416178793,
0.182666108,
-0.8613460064,
-0.476187557,
-0.1578430533,
0.7465578914,
-0.3176620007,
-0.0282461438,
0.2172718942,
0.0251713172,
0.3273203373,
0.0657794103,
-0.8182743788,
0.4954530001,
0.7381026149,
0.7799658179,
-0.4624997377,
-0.434222281,
-0.8203602433,
-0.2449747175,
-0.4503309429,
0.8153656125,
-0.3811120987,
-0.3491076529,
0.0864367038,
-0.0958762914,
-0.1679042578,
-1.1057543755,
0.4966029227,
-0.5360401869,
0.1026216224,
-0.2060206234,
-0.7965728641,
-0.2792253196,
0.5013641715,
-0.5834702849,
1.0954580307,
0.2751140893,
-0.5865216255,
0.1064115837,
-0.5057788491,
-0.1591499597,
0.0177130401,
-0.3291274905,
-0.5566385388,
0.5557869673,
0.4661851525,
0.3259839416,
-0.3164906204,
0.386826992,
-0.4685697258,
-0.5547776222,
0.6032610536,
-0.5295488834,
0.3799653351,
-0.1328949183,
-0.4835185111,
0.0786829442,
-0.8711449504,
0.3121598661,
0.3227347732,
-0.040599335,
-0.3160416484,
-0.0486108027,
-0.1181751937,
0.2322331667,
0.0037144853,
-0.3454114497,
0.0603762195,
-0.4119354784,
0.1425353736,
0.7763608098,
0.0661046356,
-0.0870480835,
-0.4208656847,
0.539106071,
-0.3223813474,
-0.152375415,
0.264862597,
-0.497997582,
-0.6509456635,
0.1943527311,
0.2251753807,
0.5323667526,
-0.8429859281,
0.4152580798,
-0.0712671876,
-0.2225435078,
-0.3579397798,
0.064363189,
0.3836282492,
0.6418306828,
0.4627290666,
-0.20127514,
-0.4174054563,
-0.6299898028,
-0.4527155459,
-0.1206015721,
-0.3116725087,
0.3282861412,
0.5786148906,
-0.3757712841,
0.6889697909,
-0.6813418865,
-0.3803936243,
-0.0834402815,
0.4667443335,
0.0668416247,
0.0941565409,
0.0680753812,
-0.4728392661,
-0.1067297831,
-0.2883605063,
-0.9151740074,
-0.3834863603,
-0.0311084595,
0.1189288646,
0.3657925725,
0.5107126236,
-0.5163711309,
0.4767231941,
0.5060924888,
-0.3316582441,
0.6623772383,
-0.2668817937,
0.1995837539,
-0.8176508546,
0.109964937,
-0.191431433,
-0.0590014942,
-0.329161942,
0.1905924231,
0.1133161113,
-0.2823856175,
-0.261531651,
0.4850055873,
-0.3979687095,
-0.3473622203,
-0.4051776528,
0.251139313,
-0.4237035215,
0.7976686358,
0.113873966,
0.7046006322,
0.1814195514,
-0.4818943739,
0.2643624842,
0.174916774,
-0.5023084283,
0.2325405031,
-0.6628447175,
0.293141067,
-0.0339081772,
-0.0309292581,
-0.9362404346,
0.0823317021,
-0.0794599131,
-0.5019094348,
-0.2019353956,
0.385548979,
-0.6304311752,
-0.3209265471,
-0.2239593565,
0.4869571626,
0.4843753576,
-0.6190394163,
0.5712746382,
0.4064725935,
0.0460974947,
-0.400636375,
-0.2445840836,
-0.0826748312,
-0.3066128492,
-0.4411080778,
0.1757245511,
-0.2416227162,
-0.2428784668,
-0.2505576015,
-0.2930454016,
0.0332549661,
0.1863090694,
0.3056529462,
0.2953319848,
0.059258908,
0.2272632569,
-0.2871257365,
-0.159101814,
0.6172193289,
0.0687727705,
1.0223648548,
-0.1604090184,
-0.4761198759,
-0.3055319786,
0.2040834874,
0.3737180829,
-0.0136132967,
0.4233745635,
0.4844041169,
-0.7978897691,
-0.3357809186,
-0.5674805641,
-0.4149290323,
-0.4085645378,
0.474278301,
-0.4256612659,
-0.8596722484,
0.6862388253,
-0.1473961771,
0.0086819958,
0.4437254667,
0.5368412137,
0.2968413234,
1.1666445732,
0.4351361096,
-0.1445601285,
0.0225755647,
-0.0469276682,
0.1386640072,
-0.7380884886,
-0.4061802626,
-0.5454560518,
-0.2074275166,
-0.4402764738,
-0.576051414,
0.3689991534,
0.1334982365,
0.0985034481,
0.2024486363,
-0.2031414658,
0.5677728057,
0.135492295,
0.0137171578,
0.4401178658,
0.0758009329,
-0.3306786716,
-0.3103343546,
-0.4606313407,
-0.2180332243,
1.0370329618,
0.2821164727,
0.6325188279,
0.0506754592,
0.5495650172,
0.2180595696,
0.3249467015,
-0.771481514,
0.7385767102,
0.1230340824,
-0.1882466972,
-0.6460588574,
-0.8638421893,
-0.9074645042,
0.5448705554,
-0.4339323044,
-0.8684310913,
-0.3525069952,
-0.308903724,
-0.1665923595,
0.2892425954,
-0.3164091706,
0.7152332664,
-0.1018844545,
-0.0849842504,
-0.2608731389,
-0.2022399604,
0.4777361453,
-0.3587453663,
0.100220345,
-0.2023181319,
0.0998561084,
0.8330280781,
-0.3494277298,
0.3833525181,
0.021620648,
-0.3463989198,
0.0272373762,
0.2319850326,
0.6195290685,
0.2438665777,
-0.0368132591,
0.2115670741,
-0.0734727457,
-0.1109089479,
-0.8839790225,
0.7009158731,
-0.6073034406,
-0.3246831894,
-0.5937327743,
-0.796810925,
-0.6720752716,
0.0685270652,
0.1717152894,
0.3658566475,
-0.3257606626,
0.1099418998,
0.7772054076,
-0.4077093899,
0.4507272542,
0.4425780773,
-0.703879416,
-0.4479525387,
0.8986000419,
0.0407624766,
0.0622028559,
0.421957463,
0.3258041739,
-0.538802743,
-0.4223818481,
-0.3391641974,
0.2805430591,
-0.627974987,
-0.2120762616,
-0.6571627855,
-0.3926053643,
-0.3172524869,
0.0768664852,
-0.2640443146,
-0.2139744312,
-0.1274230331,
0.1689426601,
0.0404338688,
0.5744475126,
0.3169714808,
-0.2086339444,
-0.5425738096,
0.6776561737,
0.5506144762,
0.4572873116,
0.2417527437,
-0.7590188384,
0.0639697313,
-0.044125367,
-0.3263739645,
-0.7344509959,
0.4666891098,
-0.1898803711,
0.4990913868,
0.3472084701,
0.2068680674,
0.8392623663,
-0.4527679086,
0.3246954083,
0.2191256583,
-1.1005922556,
0.1812410206,
-0.003054241,
0.5379433036,
0.5334822536,
0.2373316139,
-0.6968250275,
-0.387735039,
-0.5862141252,
-0.6729428768,
0.1776860207,
0.2298342586,
0.0145795699,
-0.0939856768,
0.2869045436,
0.140091598,
0.36559394,
-0.8207334876,
0.0162376519,
0.3446518481,
0.1138698757,
-0.1674284935,
-0.1559440494,
-0.0153357657,
-0.3398710489,
0.5807859898,
-0.1831154972,
0.2375918627,
-0.0154745085,
-0.3284285069,
-0.2241471857,
0.1328283548,
0.6395657063,
0.9923565388,
-0.3731937706,
0.1842518151,
0.5416636467,
-0.483472079,
-0.0185313486,
0.0378355719,
-0.0704628378,
0.0731499717,
0.4250819981,
0.4664447606,
0.2686506212,
-1.1172097921,
0.5377722383,
-0.2495933175,
-0.3784821033,
-0.4849358201,
-0.0989581198,
0.0282304753,
0.1459788233,
0.4636029899,
-0.3112347424,
0.0604735389,
-0.5851642489,
0.3385196924,
0.7366105318,
-0.511783421,
-0.0151536604,
0.6235054731,
-0.1570812613,
-0.5345177054,
0.8697635531,
-0.2255372554,
-0.6141694784,
0.6258611679,
0.7936910987,
0.9242231846,
0.0119040469,
0.322419256,
0.2797987163,
0.3569283187,
-0.1919304132,
0.5172436833,
0.1265774071,
-0.693298161,
-0.3494655192,
-0.6669239402,
-0.4362992644,
0.4846601188,
-0.7870225906,
0.1497858614,
-0.3946277797,
0.1399043202,
-0.1182015091,
0.2089954913,
-0.4509822726,
0.0812713504,
-0.0768018439,
0.6424013972,
-0.8783660531,
0.6109083295,
0.407158494,
0.0049224496,
-0.6775046587,
0.3342073262,
-0.1379090399,
-0.9877250195,
0.2860643268,
0.4959797859,
-0.1428738832,
0.0144539122,
-0.2861919105,
-0.4448332191,
0.9224128127,
0.2343065143,
-0.590212822,
0.2758359015,
0.3796978891,
0.5933240652,
-0.2960404754,
0.0469696,
0.541244328,
0.2932246327,
0.1470504999,
-0.5390426517,
0.2190789133,
-0.177398771,
0.1517289877,
0.4200863242,
-0.3340474069,
0.4942932129,
-0.3747816086,
-0.1708323807,
0.3078296483,
0.8292669654,
0.6568841934,
0.4842576683,
0.7465212345,
0.8883873224,
0.8292925358,
-0.0927240476,
0.6557440162,
0.0200639833,
0.4221691489,
0.9911273718,
-0.3243935108,
1.1604139805,
0.7580763698,
-0.2965742946,
0.1489820778,
0.4683086276,
-0.111294955,
0.4018777609,
0.8805264831,
-0.1401560903,
-0.2645699084,
-0.0084662875,
-0.4800746143,
0.5506549478,
0.0282704923,
0.019120587,
-0.3463945389,
0.1399465948,
-0.0581544302,
0.2452965677,
-0.1200195998,
0.7133048773,
0.0923650935,
-0.6668386459,
0.735746026,
0.0396913812,
0.5369078517,
-0.5166107416,
-0.332536906,
-0.5058475137,
0.0746287033,
0.0275115799,
-0.3255625069,
0.2337751538,
-0.0433987528,
-0.0713530406,
0.1919625849,
0.3213565648,
-0.440874666,
-0.7061538696,
0.3771904707,
0.6021504998,
0.3714761138,
-0.3867557347,
-0.6373253465,
0.1171929836,
-0.1298385262,
-0.0348383859,
0.5242915154,
0.5279924273,
-0.132440418,
0.7981988788,
0.6224193573,
0.0847133473,
-0.1714939177,
0.3731787801,
0.7538547516,
-0.8003191352,
-0.29077667,
-0.8716500998,
-0.0858435705,
0.0293587521,
-0.5018761754,
0.846606791,
0.5796560645,
0.8560612798,
-0.054829143,
0.294305712,
0.2796024978,
0.4187961221,
-0.6642930508,
0.5632622242,
-0.6197301745,
0.5926837921,
-0.639752686,
-1.3222383261,
-0.4191293716,
0.7030966282,
-0.0354629159,
0.0519862995,
0.9921687245,
0.669021368,
0.1139183417,
0.1509317309,
0.5826199055,
-0.0270187203,
-0.0019957528,
0.8156280518,
0.9310260415,
-0.4449431896,
0.4518787861,
-0.376039058,
-0.1966619939,
-0.1257148385,
-0.8246781826,
-1.0654605627,
-0.5574656725,
-0.2319472134,
-0.4996921718,
-0.2500887215,
0.8780676723,
0.1259020418,
-0.7862414122,
-0.414182663,
-0.1186320111,
0.2505567074,
-0.5668962002,
-0.2212650627,
0.6168292761,
-0.3084342778,
-0.5547594428,
0.1654079109,
0.3320974708,
0.0126115065,
-0.4233410656,
-0.0124996891,
-0.0110914139,
0.0711083859,
0.6991136074,
0.1569651365,
-0.5551275015,
-0.1959097385,
0.1858775616,
0.1107156202,
-0.1119484678,
0.9519188404,
-0.6457000971,
0.268315345,
0.4502141476,
1.0583330393,
0.2670595646,
0.0165860131,
0.265929997,
-0.4087850749,
-0.0517907254,
0.2992125154,
0.2737384439,
0.1646432579,
-0.1281108707,
0.6063641906,
0.3842471242,
-0.585265696,
-1.0966774225,
-0.0122816293,
-0.7550939918,
-0.5281429291,
1.0495840311,
0.1544727385,
-0.0949469954,
0.0011920498,
-0.0184484329,
-0.0231711175,
-0.0738850683,
1.5415999889,
0.9526482224,
-0.1395024061,
-0.0749140978,
-0.7334042192,
0.3351741731,
0.7327453494,
-1.1718900204,
0.2221900374,
0.3987959921,
-0.0096947048,
-0.0131376982,
0.4815581441,
-0.1758497655,
0.1380465925,
-0.1354224086,
0.0594960451,
0.0950278193,
-0.3859104812,
-0.4424416423,
0.3452003598,
-0.079729788,
-0.089399308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03544v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03544v1
|
Prompt Mining for Language-based Human Mobility Forecasting
| 2024-03-06T08:43:30 | 2024-03-06T08:43:30 |
Hao Xue, Tianye Tang, Ali Payani, Flora D. Salim
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the advancement of large language models, language-based forecasting has
recently emerged as an innovative approach for predicting human mobility
patterns. The core idea is to use prompts to transform the raw mobility data
given as numerical values into natural language sentences so that the language
models can be leveraged to generate the description for future observations.
However, previous studies have only employed fixed and manually designed
templates to transform numerical values into sentences. Since the forecasting
performance of language models heavily relies on prompts, using fixed templates
for prompting may limit the forecasting capability of language models. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework for prompt mining in language-based
mobility forecasting, aiming to explore diverse prompt design strategies.
Specifically, the framework includes a prompt generation stage based on the
information entropy of prompts and a prompt refinement stage to integrate
mechanisms such as the chain of thought. Experimental results on real-world
large-scale data demonstrate the superiority of generated prompts from our
prompt mining pipeline. Additionally, the comparison of different prompt
variants shows that the proposed prompt refinement process is effective. Our
study presents a promising direction for further advancing language-based
mobility forecasting.
|
[
-0.382139653,
-0.2923592031,
0.5944586396,
0.3178931475,
-0.4005702436,
-0.2133704722,
0.0746482462,
-0.1919119358,
0.41890046,
0.325766772,
-1.0947018862,
-0.4223389626,
0.0816926584,
0.1899283528,
-0.1424297988,
0.5936689377,
0.2660026252,
-0.004768746,
0.0013869858,
-0.1103413254,
-1.0538394451,
-0.356061846,
-0.4381118119,
-0.021560166,
0.5914438963,
0.5047674179,
0.78953439,
0.6521909237,
-0.0937340856,
0.1982303113,
0.046102304,
0.0386019982,
0.1894405633,
0.4666504264,
-0.1148816943,
-0.24529773,
-0.1730178893,
-0.1797677726,
0.5704053044,
0.7982070446,
-0.3155229986,
0.0080711506,
-0.1785941273,
0.5847770572,
-0.3841672838,
0.0195028689,
-0.57215029,
-0.0603616238,
-0.4621799588,
-0.2436851561,
-0.3754429519,
-0.316118896,
-0.0700075105,
-0.2502296567,
0.1987383366,
0.4430069625,
0.5858902931,
0.1586464792,
-0.3496783674,
-0.2734370232,
-0.334864974,
0.6144172549,
-0.4657795429,
0.5361167789,
0.2734738886,
0.5046551824,
-0.1907214075,
-0.4696992636,
-0.3916980028,
-0.2964915633,
0.1451198757,
-0.118940115,
0.0145261949,
-0.2217962295,
0.1903811395,
-0.0526444018,
-0.6999855042,
0.300247848,
-0.3185615242,
-0.2598291934,
0.5167462826,
0.5907831192,
0.400930196,
-0.0689307228,
-0.4011747539,
0.1177416518,
-0.6441038847,
0.2483479381,
0.2233160585,
0.8415781856,
-0.2116321474,
0.4027647376,
-0.5832987428,
0.7214960456,
0.0638798028,
-0.003293925,
0.4476486742,
-0.2282215953,
0.1616872251,
0.2420836091,
0.8469495773,
0.7425183654,
0.1935208142,
-0.4486362934,
-0.2490691692,
-0.3597591519,
-0.1068226472,
-0.8992158175,
0.0192101151,
0.0487814918,
-0.6557644606,
-0.3545214236,
0.1026976556,
-1.275836587,
-0.6214783788,
-0.0875323638,
-0.4791107178,
-0.4532698691,
-0.335850358,
0.2046572566,
0.0012853318,
0.2085095644,
0.2949582636,
-1.0980325937,
-0.1768146157,
0.3145311773,
1.1114205122,
-0.0074281185,
-0.2766102254,
-0.7726788521,
-0.2806968987,
-0.1685751826,
0.9873146415,
-0.6731584668,
-0.5139706135,
0.21910882,
-0.0328504816,
0.0403617322,
-0.1903273165,
0.850906074,
-0.567143023,
0.4543077052,
-0.4359885156,
-0.0733220503,
-0.1368291825,
0.1483492404,
-0.7598284483,
0.9424235225,
0.1376589537,
-0.8301456571,
0.5461127758,
-0.6973501444,
-0.5042732358,
0.3814079165,
0.174995929,
-0.0610757694,
0.0571616441,
0.3185327649,
0.4564422965,
-0.6740083098,
0.5983418822,
-0.4967064857,
-0.0639530197,
0.086117819,
-0.3697162569,
0.9493540525,
0.5617936254,
-0.1046759859,
0.0404539555,
-0.7514202595,
0.0602841526,
-0.3131071627,
-0.0379460491,
-0.3196297884,
0.0847050771,
-0.1657872647,
0.5330209136,
0.2119651586,
-0.4169888198,
0.1442587674,
-0.6351559758,
0.2014933974,
0.8735384941,
-0.0407270901,
0.8594962358,
-0.2924256325,
0.9183683395,
0.0716839731,
-0.1213436946,
-0.7731826305,
-0.6330440044,
-0.0905627608,
0.0584764555,
0.1650847197,
0.8602372408,
-0.6758140922,
0.5655035377,
-0.3645203412,
-0.500598073,
-0.4501548111,
-0.2075952888,
-0.3260861933,
0.5849637389,
0.3070453107,
0.2634837031,
-0.5895957947,
-0.3642098606,
-0.5201407671,
-0.3730483353,
-0.0801517665,
-0.0202394109,
-0.0204181448,
-0.4570774734,
1.2740392685,
-0.3563961089,
0.252897054,
-0.3646370173,
0.0827050284,
0.4034942985,
0.393324703,
0.60960114,
-0.6932282448,
-0.3655253649,
-0.2022271454,
-0.5182526112,
-0.3805491626,
-0.5083585382,
-0.0242476296,
-0.1915114373,
0.5120439529,
-0.7008988261,
0.3068991005,
0.1767219603,
-0.8452186584,
0.6587327123,
0.0383154787,
-0.028361544,
-1.1798511744,
0.0063464255,
0.2540603578,
-0.153196156,
-0.6968400478,
-0.2473386824,
-0.1629387885,
-0.3873753548,
-0.2090906948,
0.9064848423,
-0.4471433759,
0.2928355932,
-0.2327767611,
-0.2128689289,
-0.4781218171,
0.0018621602,
-0.1923331767,
0.6898907423,
0.7325012684,
-0.6938542128,
0.4373768568,
-0.0287031736,
-0.4647343755,
0.5324845314,
-0.44633165,
-0.0363426581,
-0.4527332783,
0.2218978852,
-0.8749269247,
-0.0020620895,
0.2589247227,
-0.3017469645,
-0.181658268,
-0.3321635127,
-0.3978922665,
-0.4284913838,
-0.2112431377,
0.3254744411,
0.6895440817,
-0.4410530329,
0.658844173,
0.3888731897,
-0.4311712682,
-0.3491202593,
-0.3433427215,
0.314148128,
-0.7476075292,
-0.8463492393,
0.3547528684,
-0.0988143906,
-0.3429989517,
-0.2846415043,
0.104921855,
0.1648259014,
0.2952426672,
0.4963103831,
0.4578766823,
0.2726348042,
0.1994671673,
-0.2114265412,
-0.4018120766,
0.2274336368,
-0.6249094009,
0.7250414491,
0.189390704,
0.2073822916,
-0.3185289204,
0.2235189378,
0.7007585168,
-0.2189128548,
0.6166185737,
0.6746093631,
-0.2400153875,
-0.0534674004,
-0.2330170274,
-0.1147363037,
-0.5305350423,
0.0708836913,
-0.4510317743,
-0.6716531515,
0.7627009153,
-0.4663482904,
0.2379986048,
0.4491640925,
0.5207971334,
0.0121453376,
1.2122062445,
0.6361919641,
-0.170364067,
0.8348676562,
0.4083932042,
0.0693722293,
-0.3707719743,
-0.411424309,
-0.7196652293,
0.0086874766,
-0.7707151771,
-0.324914217,
0.1172923148,
-0.098416768,
-0.2278673351,
0.1897312403,
-0.1013147011,
0.283441186,
0.4432035387,
-0.1613862664,
-0.2953644693,
0.3304116428,
-0.3877632618,
0.0917136222,
-0.6992628574,
-0.5393859148,
0.7405206561,
0.2275075018,
0.7711342573,
-0.3084943593,
0.4357094467,
0.500891149,
0.1990301609,
-0.4837616682,
0.6807996035,
0.2929132283,
-0.2341657579,
-0.3451595902,
-0.7429244518,
-1.0621950626,
-0.0493047275,
-0.0804955959,
-0.8227707148,
0.3643208444,
-0.058824759,
-0.3822378218,
0.2950363457,
-0.4330610335,
0.7067270279,
-0.1272194833,
-0.1900333315,
-0.1263642758,
-0.7370646,
0.0072764,
0.1120402664,
0.6630988121,
-0.3976794481,
0.0612638555,
0.7659935355,
-0.8367624283,
0.7826631069,
-0.715021193,
-0.1497460455,
0.4062541723,
0.102581583,
0.8590581417,
0.0953152999,
-0.6631454229,
-0.1053571999,
-0.4539795518,
-0.3183101118,
-0.3234877288,
0.6763904095,
-0.1550748199,
-0.2919246554,
-0.2744693458,
-0.2961848378,
-0.2696733475,
0.2472240329,
0.538369894,
0.5216805935,
-0.0791999102,
-0.4485077262,
0.1773647964,
-0.2206952423,
0.7428207994,
0.3095434606,
-0.0417900048,
-0.5105161667,
0.9596226215,
0.0982652307,
-0.3958310485,
0.35512954,
0.3316458464,
-0.5520038009,
-0.4601551294,
-0.7052798867,
0.0211246535,
-0.4488814771,
-0.1992034167,
-0.529204905,
0.3979005516,
-0.541456461,
-0.2170492113,
-0.017762959,
-0.48738271,
-0.230428189,
-0.3201126754,
0.3474470377,
0.3997874558,
-0.1038113385,
0.2994385958,
-0.7258996964,
-0.0172967222,
0.2787363529,
0.5072703362,
-0.0758850649,
-0.3073293865,
-0.5423138142,
0.1643828005,
-0.1121662334,
-0.978027761,
0.7384278178,
-0.123485148,
0.4118098021,
0.3528541327,
0.5352784991,
0.6658220887,
-0.7631207108,
0.9664574862,
0.5961487293,
-0.6324195266,
0.6691730022,
-0.3653948903,
0.3796183169,
0.6249890924,
0.1089973748,
-0.7734833956,
-0.0119698495,
-0.5734062791,
-1.0647461414,
0.4620078802,
-0.1931130588,
0.2374846786,
-0.3186454475,
0.2043352276,
0.2188466191,
0.1573799849,
-0.5745043159,
-0.1040881649,
-0.2727455795,
-0.3331940472,
0.1454067975,
-0.3335563242,
0.414719522,
-0.084087126,
0.3591151834,
-0.1011966094,
0.1310997158,
-0.0466817915,
0.1322211772,
-0.2201557308,
0.3254310489,
0.5948134065,
0.3525716662,
-0.2269653231,
0.0086412029,
0.4269790947,
-0.2281845361,
0.4309194088,
-0.1180490777,
-0.3546971381,
0.3502110839,
0.2165596336,
0.8703989387,
-0.2905551791,
-0.8654760718,
0.3026735187,
-0.1862607747,
0.2033165991,
-0.4598073065,
0.034108717,
-0.4239247143,
-0.0137562593,
0.5373904109,
0.4457146525,
0.2602237165,
-0.4869618118,
0.0690618008,
0.2571981549,
-0.6842386723,
-0.7782512903,
0.8198127151,
0.4818808138,
-0.6212123632,
0.7557684183,
-0.5691440701,
-0.3007155657,
0.1305404156,
0.4369013309,
1.1363115311,
-0.6903318763,
0.0524691753,
0.5144279599,
0.1281083226,
-0.3552497923,
0.4674259722,
0.0603493229,
-0.6596107483,
-0.4591804743,
-0.3841280639,
0.062213514,
-0.3492839336,
-0.5333696008,
0.6009001732,
-0.1605302691,
-0.3168635368,
-0.464527607,
-0.268276751,
-0.6733748913,
0.2039219737,
0.2555006444,
1.1638076305,
-0.868989408,
0.6303394437,
0.9510880709,
0.0384501815,
-0.5972453952,
0.262556076,
-0.1243393198,
-0.499728471,
0.5208034515,
0.6487739682,
-0.0936785489,
-0.0466945693,
-0.3784836829,
-0.5926827192,
0.9463043809,
0.4971229136,
-0.5149461627,
-0.4413617253,
-0.1346616,
0.0525162555,
-0.551891923,
0.1367822737,
0.3635611832,
0.4852545857,
0.1136891469,
-0.7447474003,
0.400362879,
-0.403054297,
-0.0112066725,
0.1969787478,
-0.2639840245,
0.8430062532,
-0.4579232335,
-0.6570128798,
0.1004426181,
0.6726048589,
0.2551920712,
0.6223243475,
0.9268234968,
0.4558505118,
1.1490645409,
0.128884837,
0.98480618,
-0.4394240677,
-0.0388421007,
0.8042530417,
-0.4889433086,
0.3043704629,
0.2296148688,
0.091001384,
1.0511395931,
0.6116915345,
0.292722106,
0.8147349954,
0.1519291252,
-0.395340085,
-0.5308744907,
-0.2087060958,
-0.2624881864,
0.0981320366,
0.2551918328,
-0.1790529341,
-0.2980238199,
0.2855808437,
0.1265087426,
-0.2170766145,
-0.5228200555,
0.7360814214,
-0.2245905995,
-0.8581198454,
0.4592978656,
0.2969008088,
0.6051734686,
-0.2740947306,
0.1315104067,
-0.165447399,
-0.3439177275,
-0.0400021039,
-0.7280896306,
0.1809028536,
0.1510128826,
-0.1955906004,
-0.6687531471,
0.6131799221,
-0.21266298,
-0.3849176466,
-0.0982321128,
0.415823102,
-0.0084219901,
-0.1888276041,
-0.5547767282,
-0.227508828,
0.289047569,
-0.010691653,
0.2980850935,
0.9444201589,
-0.1572009176,
1.0869045258,
0.7139992714,
0.204732433,
-0.0911725983,
-0.0778087601,
0.8717642426,
-1.2344958782,
-1.0919995308,
-1.294401288,
0.8506498337,
-0.0602481812,
-0.2353740484,
0.6621111631,
0.6248087883,
-0.013389417,
0.0716765523,
0.9142408967,
-0.0953041464,
0.4970422983,
-0.6680228114,
0.0169101115,
-0.0638971925,
0.7260462642,
-0.0186848585,
-0.4105249047,
-0.1223197356,
0.5276854634,
-0.2442298234,
-0.0746079162,
0.3590276837,
0.8297314048,
0.1426961422,
0.0483890995,
-0.0483787805,
-0.2416642904,
0.4910213351,
0.2338062227,
0.8827670217,
0.0262239072,
0.3513380587,
0.1119556278,
-0.1075312421,
-0.4631918669,
-0.9899590015,
-0.7266131043,
-0.8378483653,
-0.2047540396,
-0.5098003745,
-0.0827192068,
1.199079752,
0.913340807,
-0.6067520976,
-0.3008899689,
-0.4749094546,
0.3163919449,
-0.1877468526,
-0.3000253439,
0.1839056313,
-0.6534267068,
-0.289503634,
0.6854689717,
0.2066191733,
0.3613904119,
-0.0330223143,
-0.0923537463,
0.3315989077,
-0.1214556545,
0.4578182697,
0.1914277077,
-0.1806234717,
-0.0519445203,
0.0644483268,
0.14081572,
-0.1978260428,
1.1011781693,
-1.1844255924,
0.3246148527,
0.486690104,
0.1119970083,
0.0140751768,
0.2703255415,
1.1210956573,
-0.8838610053,
0.3763870895,
0.2262797803,
0.4434522092,
0.2231461406,
-0.360463351,
0.313937366,
0.1947063953,
-0.307061851,
-1.0219497681,
0.376372695,
-0.7300682068,
-0.1961842477,
1.166839838,
0.1333476901,
-0.0436851233,
-0.4498976767,
-0.3108795285,
-0.0508477651,
-0.7583958507,
0.6972070932,
0.2566423714,
0.1776424944,
-0.3196469247,
-0.3265582025,
0.5445348024,
-0.0333849043,
-0.4796322882,
0.7157649994,
0.4752006829,
0.0468487814,
-0.0377878547,
0.6585806012,
0.210646823,
0.2161550522,
-0.2991409004,
-0.1554238349,
-0.0353480242,
-0.2799550593,
-0.3189005554,
0.4287407696,
0.0819446743,
-0.0546245389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03538v1
|
RADIA -- Radio Advertisement Detection with Intelligent Analytics
| 2024-03-06T08:34:28 | 2024-03-06T08:34:28 |
Jorge Álvarez, Juan Carlos Armenteros, Camilo Torrón, Miguel Ortega-Martín, Alfonso Ardoiz, Óscar García, Ignacio Arranz, Íñigo Galdeano, Ignacio Garrido, Adrián Alonso, Fernando Bayón, Oleg Vorontsov
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Radio advertising remains an integral part of modern marketing strategies,
with its appeal and potential for targeted reach undeniably effective. However,
the dynamic nature of radio airtime and the rising trend of multiple radio
spots necessitates an efficient system for monitoring advertisement broadcasts.
This study investigates a novel automated radio advertisement detection
technique incorporating advanced speech recognition and text classification
algorithms. RadIA's approach surpasses traditional methods by eliminating the
need for prior knowledge of the broadcast content. This contribution allows for
detecting impromptu and newly introduced advertisements, providing a
comprehensive solution for advertisement detection in radio broadcasting.
Experimental results show that the resulting model, trained on carefully
segmented and tagged text data, achieves an F1-macro score of 87.76 against a
theoretical maximum of 89.33. This paper provides insights into the choice of
hyperparameters and their impact on the model's performance. This study
demonstrates its potential to ensure compliance with advertising broadcast
contracts and offer competitive surveillance. This groundbreaking research
could fundamentally change how radio advertising is monitored and open new
doors for marketing optimization.
|
[
-0.5922433734,
-0.7590697408,
0.24498564,
0.3508913219,
-0.0340993293,
0.0210834667,
-0.2837650776,
-0.6375212669,
0.4860525429,
0.1552937478,
-0.5552408099,
-0.5567401052,
-0.607460916,
-0.077722013,
-0.4415766299,
0.7779212594,
0.7221053243,
-0.2671271563,
-0.181573391,
-0.2018175572,
-0.2681792974,
0.1831850857,
-0.5421026349,
-0.2491909564,
0.1683123112,
0.6089780927,
0.8086124659,
0.6637999415,
0.5390784144,
0.376195401,
0.1097408682,
0.4278855622,
-0.1085682362,
0.3412133455,
0.1064342782,
0.0780476779,
-0.6551740766,
0.1781390607,
0.5476600528,
0.0772507191,
-0.2589162886,
0.1975738555,
-0.3471114337,
0.4338477254,
-0.7075536847,
0.2090422809,
-0.6232093573,
-0.2600989342,
-0.415853411,
-0.6975714564,
-0.5715869069,
-0.4047722816,
0.041229371,
-0.671156168,
0.0669843554,
0.1778898835,
1.0466252565,
0.3031751215,
-0.3210255206,
-0.784496367,
-1.111430645,
0.7579281926,
-0.3013580441,
0.2699222267,
0.4944300056,
0.5378129482,
0.2954411507,
-0.6234204173,
-0.247634694,
-0.2114896923,
0.1753572971,
0.1477394104,
-0.9228641987,
-0.0965729803,
-0.0225480758,
0.1389005929,
-0.4640384018,
0.0779284313,
-0.2584941983,
-0.1305453926,
0.5167176723,
0.0071968329,
0.2876770794,
-0.2048577368,
-0.2971544266,
0.1395964324,
-0.2233213782,
-0.386906147,
0.3642689586,
-0.0079920534,
-0.0011563322,
-0.0035911945,
-0.4250124693,
0.6608046889,
-0.2230881006,
0.1072345302,
0.1419999003,
0.1698101461,
-0.1595926583,
0.3378920555,
0.9914093018,
-0.0926732644,
0.1460993439,
0.2685398161,
-0.2516466379,
0.4295198619,
-0.1290371716,
-0.4513566196,
-0.3384508491,
-0.1840361059,
-0.3141829967,
-0.6892004609,
0.100969635,
-0.3947241306,
0.0411007851,
0.0706577003,
0.4265665412,
-0.4622129798,
-0.3579036593,
0.4806661606,
0.2267994136,
0.2452370226,
0.0095279813,
-0.7423668504,
0.2509846687,
0.6717284918,
0.6527537704,
0.3996623456,
0.4317350984,
-0.5501968861,
0.1898526847,
-0.0777884051,
1.2523138523,
-0.8211810589,
-0.2863355875,
-0.3597249687,
-0.5353643894,
-0.0276872981,
-0.4210734367,
0.563739419,
-1.0303848982,
0.3711758852,
0.1447436512,
-0.4734615684,
-0.3361570835,
0.0309353005,
-0.5835306644,
0.937140286,
-0.0081586223,
-0.5270024538,
0.5465331078,
-0.6868398786,
-0.4518497586,
0.3994561732,
-0.0896907225,
-0.7938600183,
0.0499018207,
0.4175735116,
0.2076818943,
-0.2897156775,
-0.0900844634,
-0.3075760305,
-0.30593279,
0.7207827568,
-0.7544826865,
0.5353947282,
0.6698341966,
-0.161557436,
0.0256566238,
-0.6940592527,
0.2091015279,
0.0016032939,
-0.3183388412,
-0.7422841787,
-0.0012693903,
0.5459022522,
0.0086946208,
-0.0613827296,
-0.5551390648,
0.0044489345,
-0.4206650257,
0.1278382391,
0.326148212,
0.0177788772,
0.2317445278,
-0.1292301565,
0.7196224928,
-0.6209770441,
0.246121183,
-0.3115049005,
-0.528408587,
-0.3327854276,
-0.487420857,
0.5296654105,
0.4001295269,
-0.0859515965,
0.6630734205,
-0.117778264,
-0.5772871971,
-0.5353859663,
-0.0626714602,
0.1624690592,
0.2911146581,
-0.0113213928,
0.1001333892,
-0.5409951806,
-0.5786293149,
-0.3204532862,
0.1671482921,
0.4057924449,
0.2393429875,
0.2629938424,
-0.3817626834,
1.1275149584,
-0.8992601037,
-0.776666522,
-0.4269689023,
0.2732467055,
0.3854096234,
0.2539541423,
0.8248789907,
-0.9578180313,
-0.664981544,
0.1121010408,
-0.7183540463,
-0.5047238469,
-0.0318006463,
0.3710641861,
-0.3415983617,
0.610175252,
-0.4217405915,
0.3452943861,
0.445310384,
-0.3025059104,
0.2826001346,
-0.5041566491,
0.1233568117,
-0.6926205158,
-0.1502526999,
0.2785208225,
-0.3122073114,
-0.4899331927,
-0.4046449661,
0.09044756,
-0.1858029515,
-0.3767157793,
0.243613869,
-0.322372973,
-0.3906918764,
-0.8346431255,
-0.1955433041,
0.0910407156,
-0.1234660745,
-0.0722167194,
0.7976535559,
0.604209125,
-0.7440741062,
0.5923140645,
0.182640925,
-0.9788836241,
0.355091691,
-0.5618183613,
0.0994943082,
-0.3954059184,
0.2172436118,
-1.490085721,
-0.3302264512,
0.0492166877,
-0.8554944992,
0.1551299989,
0.0728730112,
-0.1829602718,
-0.0981097817,
0.0152501417,
0.5396388173,
0.3303811252,
-0.3058998585,
0.5415116549,
0.6126515269,
0.0354928598,
-0.4361573756,
-0.1874187887,
0.1640923321,
-0.4323905408,
-0.4991872907,
0.2981714904,
0.4221877456,
-0.1520322561,
0.2508534193,
-0.1891632378,
-0.1809723228,
0.0909453481,
-0.0427425988,
0.0960514992,
-0.4149731696,
-0.0326615758,
0.1076270118,
-0.5997210145,
0.1566472352,
-0.371273756,
0.520981431,
-0.0107422061,
-0.0768998042,
-1.1236519814,
0.2772660553,
0.994746387,
-0.5418410897,
0.4263129234,
0.8590954542,
-0.3912717104,
-0.2830435038,
-0.4899359941,
0.1054517627,
-0.6086893678,
0.3938450813,
-0.0146873668,
-0.1539080292,
0.1727870852,
0.1333702505,
-0.4071593285,
0.3734857142,
0.4109218717,
-0.2474170625,
1.519828558,
0.6199047565,
-0.1572808027,
0.5543237329,
-0.346346885,
0.1728674024,
-0.3260587156,
-0.3848837614,
-0.7084636688,
-0.0813958719,
-0.4026802182,
-0.2131356299,
0.8180282712,
-0.5943599343,
0.1938344985,
0.162835449,
-0.506080389,
0.5808596611,
0.3274680972,
0.1088077202,
0.2830812633,
-0.0206802245,
0.527264595,
-0.1213689595,
-0.4569653869,
-0.3045661151,
0.7866629958,
0.3380738795,
1.2122298479,
0.0603397824,
0.2674796283,
0.9114881754,
0.6037942171,
-0.9795783162,
0.3970437944,
-0.1659030467,
-0.7649471164,
-0.13846457,
-0.3989312053,
-0.7999712229,
0.2329223603,
-0.2422577739,
-0.108095184,
0.1747128963,
0.2149859965,
-0.5190970302,
-0.0604309887,
-0.4854830205,
0.4426975548,
-0.4631443918,
0.0897892341,
-0.6421285272,
-0.0429265983,
0.2499151975,
-0.0509459339,
0.7142279148,
-0.6487646699,
0.0037150288,
1.0010383129,
-0.0913714841,
0.3079814017,
-0.2532543838,
0.1109567806,
0.0613441803,
-0.1217364818,
0.2635191083,
0.0982505083,
0.1828556657,
-0.534399271,
-0.3175356388,
-0.3787469566,
-0.3951287866,
0.7709081173,
-0.5425484776,
-0.1354021579,
-0.7101502419,
-0.6530597806,
-0.260951519,
0.4973661602,
0.4136198163,
0.6415470243,
-0.4520520568,
0.2474262118,
0.9566604495,
-0.53972435,
0.2079882473,
0.7445418239,
-0.0348994769,
-0.5901289582,
1.0069090128,
-0.3028352261,
0.0892039239,
0.4956960678,
0.5196380019,
-0.6651230454,
-0.5158029795,
0.261790663,
0.4742771685,
-0.5984427929,
-0.3277747929,
-0.7788566351,
0.1697226316,
-0.5619089007,
0.0691798255,
-0.3942644298,
-0.2178942561,
-0.1995553225,
0.0907474905,
0.3354796469,
0.8249628544,
-0.192419529,
0.7228579521,
-0.6155875921,
0.309022218,
0.2234305888,
0.1318936199,
-0.2476504445,
-0.3370422125,
-0.5437124372,
-0.2716838121,
-0.2126795948,
-0.7896831632,
0.5810003281,
0.4439235032,
0.4255845845,
0.9261851907,
-0.03286504,
0.2106814682,
-0.05305776,
-0.1872009337,
0.0158396903,
-0.8675537705,
0.6952655911,
-0.7633951902,
0.2609208822,
0.4079988897,
0.3149843216,
-0.402338773,
-0.1889250875,
-0.410767287,
-0.6598581076,
0.7848393321,
0.0501960255,
0.0966476575,
-0.1045798734,
-0.0624581203,
-0.4065000415,
0.0042946446,
-0.263020128,
-0.1948560923,
0.2086521387,
-0.2181975693,
0.1840161532,
-0.2112953663,
0.2764622569,
-0.4418506622,
0.7067295313,
0.3279679418,
0.2155352831,
-0.0628730878,
-0.2086074054,
-0.1023372412,
0.0689818412,
0.6960281134,
0.4500559568,
-0.6210393906,
-0.1909212619,
-0.2575844228,
-0.4222641289,
0.256835103,
-0.1674657166,
-0.0679806471,
0.3805504739,
0.1058507264,
0.4484636188,
0.3397890329,
-0.4367818832,
0.5118211508,
-0.0685352907,
-0.0873938128,
-0.6411363482,
0.0769097283,
-0.0987599343,
-0.0766289458,
0.5003330708,
0.427372098,
0.3019465506,
-0.3780913949,
0.5796275735,
0.6358581781,
-0.6245135665,
-0.1500841081,
1.1562197208,
0.2812314928,
-0.1667323411,
0.2956236899,
0.0021809821,
-0.4829101562,
0.8656166196,
0.4754039943,
0.8921177387,
-0.8085633516,
0.3406421542,
-0.2074002773,
0.2520569265,
0.1516433507,
-0.0032188511,
-0.1439270824,
-0.8901780844,
-0.269760251,
-0.3115989864,
-0.400369525,
0.1242124066,
-1.0057611465,
0.4787590504,
-0.5230997205,
-0.4664516747,
0.868955195,
-0.0160614531,
-0.5873787403,
0.5004167557,
0.4620475173,
1.0829720497,
-1.1384161711,
1.0756965876,
0.6998804808,
0.0180015285,
-0.3123350739,
-0.0850616097,
0.0982762128,
-0.8168424368,
0.6597718,
0.2879473269,
-0.678168118,
0.3040576875,
-0.2237525284,
-0.8500036597,
0.5820723176,
-0.1544591039,
-0.144715637,
-0.0624432378,
-0.1679866016,
0.2157050222,
-0.5070517063,
0.272416383,
0.819101274,
0.541436851,
-0.0362814888,
-0.578062892,
-0.3413785398,
0.0266532544,
-0.3886280656,
0.5027733445,
-0.4897215366,
0.3151600361,
-0.0075593544,
-0.1067313552,
-0.0057997173,
0.8811414838,
-0.1506558359,
0.8606435657,
0.5524395704,
0.3299523294,
0.4727837741,
-0.1426225454,
0.6715055108,
-0.0521317869,
0.6716948748,
0.1818293631,
-0.3358213305,
0.2528044283,
-0.084075354,
0.0649007112,
0.3864521682,
0.1764144003,
-0.0048613078,
0.956636548,
-0.3672274649,
-0.6697132587,
-0.352889061,
-0.0686916411,
-0.2449629754,
1.0472558737,
1.0771286488,
-0.3190531135,
-0.5097988248,
0.5821199417,
0.1270456761,
0.4191710949,
-0.1479590833,
0.5870220065,
-0.2273700237,
-0.2166040689,
0.4899770916,
0.3551095128,
0.8649613857,
-0.9177049398,
0.4069575071,
0.2053504586,
0.6672320962,
-0.315474987,
-0.2860253155,
0.502954185,
-0.1052602082,
-0.0322918147,
-0.1980118454,
0.8136720657,
-0.1980515718,
-0.3527644575,
0.10082376,
0.2342351973,
-0.0295516569,
-0.0295520108,
-0.723929584,
0.5256816149,
0.0478153303,
-0.2007061094,
0.0257966481,
0.176045537,
0.2426231205,
0.6153929234,
0.5781197548,
0.3677846193,
-0.2113082558,
-0.2734963298,
0.5945914984,
-0.8013661504,
-1.0400360823,
-0.5999948382,
-0.2536633015,
-0.0740323365,
-0.1859022528,
0.683699131,
0.7739105821,
0.4353665113,
0.0515252687,
0.8839473724,
0.0159562472,
0.5996581912,
-0.2543954849,
0.8410994411,
-0.318105489,
0.6905249953,
-0.4095399976,
-0.7774396539,
-0.407089442,
0.7020450234,
-0.5886668563,
-0.080824405,
0.286578089,
0.8474265933,
-0.4298806787,
0.146172151,
0.1448882073,
-0.2755671144,
0.6364439726,
0.3640600145,
0.8918074369,
-0.4309946001,
0.8435571194,
-0.0304497406,
-0.5325733423,
-0.3607650399,
-0.6102973223,
-0.5260052085,
-0.3331177533,
-0.5844270587,
-0.3208584785,
-0.0030273772,
0.7814109921,
0.8055961728,
-0.746533215,
-0.3195513189,
0.3698336482,
-0.0089244442,
-0.6159574389,
-0.3390315771,
0.4150784612,
-0.1571791917,
-0.7156500816,
0.7341585755,
0.4680899978,
-0.2158494741,
0.0049059168,
0.265453428,
-0.2172969878,
0.4236017168,
0.2357280999,
0.5636261106,
-0.1548212022,
0.1823415607,
-0.0796182901,
-0.1742739826,
-0.1040181816,
1.0504566431,
-0.8521806598,
0.2527282536,
0.6748492718,
0.3538552523,
0.5486189723,
0.2753441036,
0.2272644192,
-0.6545642018,
0.4177445173,
0.4558063745,
-0.0639811009,
0.3075605333,
-0.333746314,
-0.2521780133,
0.3130688369,
-0.6110476255,
-0.9031983614,
0.2180876285,
-0.8890581727,
-0.3671704829,
0.8577161431,
0.5262412429,
-0.134142831,
-0.4219218194,
-0.0051819673,
0.1013691872,
-0.4274195731,
0.6626819372,
0.212275669,
-0.3050360084,
0.0594669208,
-0.6582641006,
0.5458240509,
0.4170583785,
-0.45145455,
-0.0822688267,
0.4792023301,
0.5853322744,
0.030784037,
0.9354268909,
-0.0459583625,
0.6082904339,
-0.3125618696,
-0.475877583,
-0.5053370595,
-0.40907377,
-0.2227037549,
0.1642592698,
-0.100049831,
-0.8128077388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03522v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03522v2
|
Non-verbal information in spontaneous speech -- towards a new framework of analysis
| 2024-03-06T08:03:05 | 2024-03-13T09:50:40 |
Tirza Biron, Moshe Barboy, Eran Ben-Artzy, Alona Golubchik, Yanir Marmor, Smadar Szekely, Yaron Winter, David Harel
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Non-verbal signals in speech are encoded by prosody and carry information
that ranges from conversation action to attitude and emotion. Despite its
importance, the principles that govern prosodic structure are not yet
adequately understood. This paper offers an analytical schema and a
technological proof-of-concept for the categorization of prosodic signals and
their association with meaning. The schema interprets surface-representations
of multi-layered prosodic events. As a first step towards implementation, we
present a classification process that disentangles prosodic phenomena of three
orders. It relies on fine-tuning a pre-trained speech recognition model,
enabling the simultaneous multi-class/multi-label detection. It generalizes
over a large variety of spontaneous data, performing on a par with, or superior
to, human annotation. In addition to a standardized formalization of prosody,
disentangling prosodic patterns can direct a theory of communication and speech
organization. A welcome by-product is an interpretation of prosody that will
enhance speech- and language-related technologies.
|
[
-0.2668566406,
-0.8325884342,
0.4049456716,
0.4435235858,
-0.4416439235,
0.0381071605,
-0.1774879098,
-0.4460979104,
0.5898418427,
0.1650414467,
-0.514252007,
-0.4405560493,
-0.56427598,
-0.1049848422,
-0.5073378086,
0.7196909189,
0.3561519682,
0.2075146884,
0.1507942975,
-0.0539799221,
-0.0502596349,
-0.7323321104,
-0.200525701,
-0.0330743007,
0.4134105146,
0.2884628177,
0.5559936166,
0.2678702176,
0.2493542731,
0.4014619291,
-0.1198639274,
0.0892040133,
-0.0560520291,
0.2147902101,
0.1811025888,
-0.4908792675,
-0.677287221,
0.4497477114,
0.8918667436,
0.9057896137,
-0.2126446068,
0.1221358329,
0.1992207021,
0.3351058066,
-0.1464404315,
0.5732892752,
-0.1048782989,
0.1188305765,
-0.6964063048,
-0.5901889801,
-0.5006284714,
-0.3345846534,
0.0469740108,
-0.3885062933,
0.3141938448,
-0.1126782149,
0.4423442483,
0.0853831396,
-0.5571521521,
-0.2964451909,
-0.9191663265,
0.3889853358,
-0.2179142535,
0.7878116369,
0.3434372842,
0.2800315917,
-0.348208636,
-0.5870593786,
-0.774764955,
-0.2224283963,
-0.0260178186,
0.1519543827,
0.0153195495,
0.152993083,
-0.2271130234,
0.3103034496,
-0.5382967591,
0.1609119773,
-0.2529295087,
-0.2465824783,
0.7723062038,
-0.0593288168,
0.2977586389,
-0.1235364154,
-0.1291913837,
0.1151322573,
-0.2833579481,
0.0371326618,
0.2321105003,
0.5859653354,
-0.3070409894,
0.4083699584,
-0.1293144673,
0.5963515043,
0.0462817363,
-0.3732835352,
0.5673292875,
-0.2331228405,
0.0091483677,
0.5001034737,
0.8502866626,
0.0156504158,
0.0284944791,
-0.2103445828,
0.0399258807,
0.0974245518,
-0.0820025355,
-0.3820863664,
-0.128377676,
0.1650217324,
-0.3416430056,
-0.4177301824,
0.218752563,
-0.335619241,
-0.4363598824,
-0.5720181465,
0.2578682601,
-0.1604596972,
-0.7003695965,
-0.0152151845,
-0.099839516,
-0.0349724144,
0.040960528,
-0.8084562421,
0.4149544835,
0.5412634611,
0.9143621922,
0.2689388394,
-0.2767050266,
-0.4345770776,
-0.058638595,
-0.3593548834,
0.8508425355,
-0.4898717999,
-0.3711158335,
-0.3263575435,
0.3248024881,
-0.026582066,
-0.38769117,
0.2786950171,
-0.4566252232,
-0.0359221511,
0.062662974,
-0.5731884241,
-0.0137521243,
-0.3272977769,
-0.6544780135,
0.5049177408,
-0.071710147,
-0.585482657,
0.2022242099,
-0.5578359365,
-0.5321583748,
0.3625866175,
-0.2931091785,
-0.1491016746,
0.4502990246,
-0.6421464086,
0.4056319296,
-0.0486929193,
0.5155246258,
-0.3361988366,
-0.1931159645,
0.7142387629,
-0.3350151777,
0.7285667062,
0.321352005,
-0.1543565392,
0.1659704745,
-0.9971771836,
-0.0141615504,
-0.2046289891,
-0.1276750267,
-0.2557677031,
0.1978719831,
-0.1571839601,
0.3827857375,
0.1291482151,
-0.4481582642,
0.0801038072,
-0.3927564323,
0.8278913498,
0.5126630664,
0.2368563712,
0.7084541321,
0.1844764352,
0.2611267865,
0.1650555283,
0.3417846859,
0.1701201349,
-0.688781321,
-0.5503339767,
-0.429246664,
0.1698567271,
0.5641899705,
-0.4410423934,
0.4219216704,
0.0508199222,
-0.5967672467,
-0.3671962321,
-0.3152505755,
0.1998053342,
0.5725008249,
0.2982998788,
-0.1375171989,
-0.5721674562,
-0.5676344633,
-0.220235303,
-0.1003385484,
-0.0519237518,
-0.1639113873,
0.0066568172,
0.1403113157,
0.7886690497,
-0.26919505,
-0.4355665445,
-0.1000150591,
0.6794870496,
0.3138240576,
0.4101436138,
0.0707259104,
-0.6726647615,
-0.0743131116,
0.0419450104,
-0.8683555126,
-0.1534624249,
0.0129496958,
0.0850396231,
-0.2588493824,
0.681614995,
-0.543808043,
0.3235132098,
0.0507228971,
-0.1268042475,
0.4182537496,
-0.1483907998,
-0.1273202002,
-0.6293693781,
-0.2806613743,
-0.0196674857,
0.1007103026,
-1.0928845406,
-0.5159047842,
-0.0332466513,
-0.2693696022,
-0.5779171586,
0.3291047513,
-0.4916421473,
-0.1765286475,
-0.469003737,
0.1908393502,
-0.1810917854,
0.3701868355,
0.3487221599,
0.2658813894,
0.7603203058,
-0.8594906926,
0.4156171978,
0.228036046,
-0.277864486,
0.5881499648,
-0.4230405688,
0.2677658796,
-0.4633252919,
0.1514305174,
-0.9589830637,
-0.3091997504,
0.2649121881,
-0.6412848234,
0.2375883162,
-0.0907722935,
-0.65500772,
0.0885465592,
0.0785933435,
0.2486851513,
0.4080083072,
-0.0957486778,
0.4502657652,
0.6800484657,
-0.2880965471,
-0.0489706211,
-0.4769935012,
-0.1805382669,
-0.2482016981,
-0.4555231929,
0.2984364331,
0.3373778462,
-0.348588109,
-0.1534695178,
-0.2333180606,
-0.2935027182,
0.2013130039,
0.5056428909,
0.0484980084,
0.0502420738,
0.391433388,
0.1152481586,
-0.412635386,
0.1607542038,
-0.4667319059,
0.376873821,
-0.1278842986,
-0.0584132709,
-0.8724133968,
0.2952163517,
0.5906649828,
-0.1740630567,
0.6455305815,
0.6022909284,
-0.2970873415,
-0.0630198941,
0.0802955702,
-0.2497882098,
-0.4753718078,
0.1563772261,
-0.424268961,
-0.5645466447,
0.2904993594,
-0.1540767103,
-0.251330018,
0.0641472563,
0.3887412846,
-0.5393723845,
1.070699811,
0.4568029046,
0.3126656413,
0.4647063315,
0.0003441348,
0.4636133611,
-0.4284037948,
-0.6546128392,
-0.5871025324,
-0.3093501031,
-0.7704023123,
-0.2514531016,
0.5094031692,
0.3749682009,
-0.0295372009,
0.1577526033,
-0.4736537337,
0.2298269272,
0.4171045423,
-0.0211578608,
0.059664771,
-0.1428300887,
0.1965848207,
-0.1395864487,
-0.4647913277,
-0.5826147199,
0.5391259789,
0.2835671604,
0.3418310285,
0.2438715696,
0.8474361897,
0.1572658271,
0.2017576844,
-0.7728146911,
0.6636788249,
-0.1590922177,
-0.4863590002,
-0.3724022508,
-0.189395532,
-0.9869235754,
0.3565125465,
-0.3065929413,
-0.9158340096,
0.5691939592,
0.2276476324,
-0.3262962103,
-0.2739584446,
-0.8424748778,
0.6605735421,
-0.3527372777,
-0.2458215505,
-0.1004795358,
-0.7486486435,
0.3605561852,
0.0087219179,
0.6410661936,
-0.2568385303,
0.1539750099,
0.7911782265,
-0.4174124599,
1.0597366095,
-0.6408711076,
-0.1567611545,
0.4961107969,
0.2015328854,
0.1893719137,
-0.0049784682,
0.2211186588,
0.356588304,
0.0494993292,
-0.0904352739,
-0.7267466187,
0.355737865,
-0.5950595737,
-0.1958233863,
-0.4536739886,
-0.0659008846,
-0.3579604924,
0.1957120448,
0.2803707421,
0.6550765634,
-0.094113864,
0.0610448569,
0.6421046853,
0.1081308424,
0.4352865815,
0.650206089,
-0.0328882672,
-0.2493266016,
1.2810206413,
0.4796110094,
0.0050487081,
0.4016768932,
0.249512434,
-0.6165840626,
-0.3658551276,
0.0953282267,
0.1813328266,
-0.7068734169,
0.1669086814,
-0.5427229404,
-0.1330857873,
-0.6310133934,
0.2778262198,
-0.1514485925,
-0.4918161035,
-0.6079307199,
-0.2931515872,
0.130778119,
0.5581839681,
-0.4470721185,
0.4418207407,
-0.8886676431,
0.4797060192,
0.2387945205,
0.18561019,
-0.1517671496,
-0.2737461925,
0.0114654219,
-0.1132971942,
-0.0666401312,
-1.5030857325,
0.366940856,
0.4994227886,
0.6574240923,
0.6186134219,
0.1510954052,
0.5507898331,
-0.5149668455,
0.6211687922,
0.2229012549,
-1.1820001602,
0.7020222545,
-0.1884247363,
-0.0270927567,
0.2617756128,
0.4120176435,
-0.6665284038,
-0.3903223276,
-0.8721846938,
-0.8727424741,
0.7165602446,
0.1469363868,
-0.2152601033,
-0.2137794942,
0.1081101298,
0.003966928,
0.3790528476,
-0.503667593,
-0.1613494158,
-0.5595141649,
-0.2163088173,
-0.2646141648,
-0.1889376193,
-0.1783784777,
-0.2146086693,
0.2451444417,
0.1895630807,
0.6083829999,
0.0600552149,
-0.464337647,
0.2978205979,
0.3817961514,
0.7763441801,
0.3031248152,
-0.0567953847,
0.6971196532,
-0.2144781798,
-0.6151431799,
0.5502986908,
0.0266578868,
0.3273343146,
0.1152539104,
0.6215419173,
0.6836286187,
0.1927370578,
-0.1687767804,
0.3978135586,
0.0890486389,
-0.2045493275,
-0.4725690782,
0.0586207807,
-0.0986612588,
0.247451365,
0.2947157323,
-0.0771196261,
0.3086715043,
-0.6082004905,
0.3301340938,
0.2063812464,
-0.3895528615,
-0.9055794477,
0.3733153343,
0.4298653007,
-0.5882126689,
0.5145838261,
-0.6538795829,
-0.2539640069,
0.4124953151,
0.1732727438,
0.8912811279,
-0.6113532186,
0.4640891552,
0.0204011239,
0.1721239537,
0.1925633252,
0.6757284999,
-0.5900600553,
-0.7576512694,
-0.2213707566,
-0.6712388992,
-0.1021139398,
0.1315362304,
-0.7791414261,
0.2511141598,
-0.7306975722,
-0.2724131644,
0.5127230883,
-0.374612838,
-0.3141120374,
0.022385126,
0.2809034586,
0.3738990724,
-1.2302696705,
0.9345647097,
0.5182830095,
-0.2138157338,
-0.559804976,
-0.1542754918,
0.3659897149,
-0.5160027146,
0.9814409614,
0.1981636137,
-0.4063933194,
0.1550211608,
-0.4091224074,
-0.8578494787,
0.6833461523,
0.1582005918,
-0.7310133576,
0.2523815334,
0.3152259588,
0.5792025924,
-0.1118086576,
0.1241043136,
0.6576067209,
0.4487481415,
-0.1172551438,
-0.9996508956,
-0.1936781406,
-0.2344431281,
-0.2976240516,
0.2599037886,
-0.3194549382,
0.7598046064,
0.1362709254,
-0.6559622884,
-0.3391953409,
0.5503709912,
0.1764400899,
0.5875882506,
0.3859021068,
0.0269176643,
1.0295211077,
-0.2546229362,
0.3890741467,
-0.208791852,
0.0788955167,
1.018817544,
-0.4253351688,
0.5125161409,
0.2582958341,
-0.2600500286,
0.3164165616,
0.7394039035,
0.4534934461,
0.7256656885,
0.3212172389,
-0.4459369183,
-0.1966634244,
-0.0370660275,
-0.4500958622,
0.7368389368,
0.7270876765,
-0.0902526602,
-0.0430312641,
0.4281848669,
-0.2150450349,
-0.2446958423,
-0.2180099189,
0.8787460923,
0.1124920845,
-0.1453002691,
0.6444784999,
-0.1745871454,
0.1522325724,
-0.4228027761,
-0.0113255326,
0.0907575041,
0.0091993641,
-0.4274995029,
-0.4483380318,
0.4488801062,
-0.287160784,
0.0620350726,
-0.4236947894,
0.5221874714,
-0.2275444269,
-0.1569412351,
-0.0395958796,
0.3650349379,
0.5349403024,
-0.0040060976,
-0.3574659824,
0.0514061302,
-0.3798338771,
-0.0031514578,
0.1757042557,
0.6054394841,
-0.4631390572,
0.2474323511,
0.5124834776,
0.0440631658,
0.2938267291,
0.472058028,
0.5599035621,
-0.8177329302,
-0.8737225533,
-0.631944716,
0.512671113,
-0.0617628247,
-0.0985611826,
0.7070373893,
0.2034032196,
0.508887291,
0.206979692,
0.51170367,
0.0742800608,
0.2949922383,
-0.4227098823,
0.3946364522,
-0.1364948004,
0.0346686058,
-0.3709764183,
-0.7423116565,
-0.4044906795,
0.7287061214,
-0.2800914049,
-0.3310239613,
0.6629018188,
0.5076053143,
0.2415144145,
0.6323059797,
0.1480425447,
0.2310957462,
0.1318817288,
-0.0142619647,
1.2970155478,
0.123845011,
0.0716763511,
-0.0439859703,
-0.7189112902,
-0.2527416945,
-0.5580518246,
-0.3858889639,
-0.986600101,
-0.3953670263,
-0.0970375016,
-0.2841516137,
0.6261629462,
0.8885211945,
-0.5615291595,
-0.3144251704,
-0.4210182428,
-0.0204417259,
-0.5264204144,
-0.1977532655,
0.1474281847,
-0.4265273213,
-0.4498724639,
0.9416264296,
0.3371176124,
0.413082689,
-0.2731761932,
0.0992250293,
0.1392359734,
0.0313384235,
0.7529470325,
0.489518553,
-0.4701045752,
0.1451426595,
0.0633483976,
0.4499419928,
-0.2151964605,
0.8513635397,
-0.5865361094,
0.2637051344,
0.4222282469,
-0.1401984841,
0.4007634819,
-0.2486873865,
0.1418648362,
-1.0548557043,
0.6841490269,
0.3751913607,
0.0951025337,
0.0000466236,
-0.4370461404,
-0.0490692183,
0.4196079969,
-0.1723275483,
-1.0882762671,
0.5834587812,
-0.8628363609,
-0.3744232953,
0.7616422772,
0.1536194831,
-0.3249311149,
-0.4536076486,
0.1292279661,
0.5360243917,
-0.1459561288,
0.5078018308,
0.7979778647,
-0.7840259671,
-0.2890416682,
-0.2999742627,
0.5385648608,
-0.0299837999,
-0.6227833629,
0.0879917443,
0.5548603535,
0.0459531844,
0.4861946702,
0.9175570607,
-0.2250218689,
0.0215905085,
0.0318139978,
0.021382587,
-0.0174731929,
-0.737873137,
-0.4835967422,
0.4125592113,
0.0582807623,
-0.7270807624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03521v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03521v1
|
BiVert: Bidirectional Vocabulary Evaluation using Relations for Machine Translation
| 2024-03-06T08:02:21 | 2024-03-06T08:02:21 |
Carinne Cherf, Yuval Pinter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural machine translation (NMT) has progressed rapidly in the past few
years, promising improvements and quality translations for different languages.
Evaluation of this task is crucial to determine the quality of the translation.
Overall, insufficient emphasis is placed on the actual sense of the translation
in traditional methods. We propose a bidirectional semantic-based evaluation
method designed to assess the sense distance of the translation from the source
text. This approach employs the comprehensive multilingual encyclopedic
dictionary BabelNet. Through the calculation of the semantic distance between
the source and its back translation of the output, our method introduces a
quantifiable approach that empowers sentence comparison on the same linguistic
level. Factual analysis shows a strong correlation between the average
evaluation scores generated by our method and the human assessments across
various machine translation systems for English-German language pair. Finally,
our method proposes a new multilingual approach to rank MT systems without the
need for parallel corpora.
|
[
-0.10316284,
-0.4068888426,
0.2041287571,
0.4286087453,
-0.6372992992,
-0.0421520248,
-0.5199311376,
-0.2113328874,
0.2633565068,
0.0458599627,
-0.396612972,
-0.5145179033,
-0.6873141527,
0.2820724249,
-0.1898529977,
0.8364947438,
-0.0154199488,
0.2817190588,
-0.5775591135,
-0.4659844637,
-0.6170489788,
-0.3252219558,
-0.3544959724,
-0.3388744891,
0.5546666384,
-0.0244249292,
0.7250007391,
0.2296166569,
0.957056582,
0.4399302304,
-0.1042892933,
0.1254789978,
-0.149694711,
0.2033165395,
-0.541659534,
-0.1330667287,
-0.3447905779,
0.0248545166,
0.7094415426,
0.832696557,
0.0419029705,
0.1476071626,
0.0060114725,
0.8169619441,
-0.357258141,
-0.0063744318,
-0.5601303577,
0.088266097,
-0.1735102683,
-0.2653110325,
-0.2735830843,
-0.2597695887,
0.2862616777,
-0.3011446595,
-0.0118328296,
0.1400978863,
1.1817828417,
0.2691520751,
-0.5502669811,
-0.2749052644,
-0.4547409415,
0.6169641614,
-0.691400528,
0.7685710192,
0.0728682205,
0.3543855846,
0.1490824223,
-0.5974516273,
-0.6690056324,
-0.5731770992,
-0.0101402681,
0.6254608035,
0.0017766124,
-0.1876412481,
-0.1975884587,
0.3709945679,
-0.7903606892,
-0.2292642146,
-0.2635991871,
-0.1726071835,
0.4111199975,
-0.2062597424,
0.3721177578,
-0.682936728,
-0.8532392383,
-0.3550311029,
-0.430249393,
-0.3763718307,
0.4147366881,
0.289018929,
-0.1071624905,
0.8400132656,
-0.0882254168,
0.5381986499,
-0.3275256157,
0.1803485304,
0.4340428412,
-0.736762464,
-0.1450487673,
-0.0024412661,
0.9550017118,
0.8490202427,
0.1079428717,
-0.5611876845,
-0.2839313447,
0.0189322978,
0.2103832364,
-0.7370384336,
0.092746973,
-0.2220997363,
-0.3614016175,
-0.1331757456,
0.0716374144,
-0.61292243,
-0.0204425771,
-0.373486042,
0.590166688,
-0.6185414791,
-0.2508983314,
-0.0003906999,
-0.1455400288,
0.0993204638,
-0.0160019677,
-0.1677798927,
0.1467273235,
0.6534683704,
1.020532608,
-0.2428854406,
-0.6358497143,
-0.2689736485,
-0.0063035456,
-0.170070231,
0.7058637142,
0.0201224182,
-0.2352710217,
-0.2959003747,
-0.1492596716,
-0.2490058839,
-0.5671062469,
0.564913094,
-0.8115739822,
0.4727796912,
0.0268004108,
-0.2847175002,
-0.3426864743,
0.513762176,
-0.401616931,
0.9267556071,
0.3919768333,
-0.7641867995,
0.305006057,
-0.6262865067,
-0.7170933485,
0.2162389308,
0.2863050699,
-0.0314729661,
0.0460606366,
-0.0754767209,
0.1056012139,
-0.4881794155,
0.365555644,
-0.0432855561,
0.0467801578,
0.339656502,
-0.7332467437,
0.9135535955,
0.17811279,
-0.208329916,
0.2404584736,
-0.6653318405,
0.0378377177,
-0.1175899357,
-0.3385478854,
-0.6896545291,
-0.1688500941,
0.1544371992,
0.5633900762,
0.5836604238,
-0.5722055435,
-0.1833731085,
-1.0440009832,
0.2561607957,
0.5805236101,
-0.0892935991,
0.4390423,
0.2762105763,
0.4271679223,
0.1363625228,
0.1388440281,
0.3299655318,
-0.3822099864,
-0.7092534304,
-0.057048779,
0.8305063844,
0.6860846877,
-1.0757528543,
0.6137669086,
-0.7026245594,
-0.3074132502,
-0.6724404693,
0.1152702793,
0.7481128573,
0.6552940607,
0.47419402,
-0.4712090194,
-0.3200992346,
-1.0005663633,
-0.2597242296,
-0.1287241429,
-0.1467504352,
0.0671151131,
0.4362469614,
-0.2620851398,
0.5514476895,
-0.1695539951,
0.0612645485,
0.0408263393,
0.1127680838,
0.23770383,
0.2869828939,
0.2491716295,
-0.8324292302,
-0.4137718976,
0.3881812394,
-0.7478039265,
-0.0512968786,
0.1622278988,
-0.5795704722,
0.1797198504,
0.1629004031,
-0.622422576,
0.2156376392,
0.664719224,
-0.5924623609,
0.4378916025,
-0.3374215364,
0.2381446511,
-1.3223531246,
0.3707744181,
-0.2108270228,
-0.1508509815,
-0.2177598625,
0.2942310274,
0.2028464973,
0.0891745612,
-0.3894726336,
0.4279088378,
-0.2976439297,
-0.2833836675,
0.0791992769,
0.8145942092,
0.2355228215,
0.24728553,
-0.1574293524,
0.7364373803,
0.0412510522,
-0.3940397501,
0.7425842881,
0.3333916068,
-0.2297284007,
0.9928939342,
-0.6473119855,
0.0949027315,
0.1003888994,
-0.3292738497,
-1.1466621161,
0.259940654,
0.2152027637,
-0.8679125309,
0.4145672023,
-0.012441704,
-0.5743131638,
-0.2295844704,
-0.094471626,
0.2877543271,
0.104691498,
-0.2798030376,
0.2190926373,
0.0117720626,
-0.1131043956,
-0.5005961657,
-0.6017727256,
0.4402225912,
-0.0348004699,
-0.8939419985,
0.2543014586,
0.0846780315,
-0.3139918149,
0.0450915731,
-0.2465367615,
-0.0042839781,
0.1913750917,
-0.0284832772,
0.5206065774,
-0.2874399126,
0.3197874129,
0.2553717196,
-0.300026387,
0.1521132737,
-0.3116747141,
0.4244816303,
-0.4146679342,
-0.323628664,
-0.0206364039,
0.1274624169,
0.5469244719,
-0.5296475887,
0.5243643522,
0.6702339053,
-0.2018978298,
0.1405128688,
-0.236102879,
-0.138901934,
-0.3757973909,
0.4898438156,
-0.5272119045,
-0.3256031573,
0.1543192416,
-0.0580740422,
-0.2499188781,
0.6207802892,
0.6244623065,
0.0107919192,
0.6014751792,
0.2587229013,
0.1424825937,
-0.1521624923,
-0.1546534598,
0.3975626528,
-0.8951169252,
-0.3652626276,
-0.5312758088,
-0.3240482807,
-0.5021691918,
-0.4147491455,
0.3956231177,
0.2514210641,
0.0023704711,
0.7619502544,
-0.4336553812,
0.0993039384,
0.5537502766,
-0.1201480851,
0.3847917914,
-0.0592532381,
-0.6355625987,
-0.0454869084,
-0.5171688795,
-0.4604161978,
0.735766232,
0.0857852548,
-0.070878692,
0.5268594623,
0.5548887849,
0.1444867551,
0.4885681272,
-1.1424599886,
0.5933356285,
-0.0684527084,
-0.4651784599,
-0.4880933464,
-0.6621696949,
-1.0199042559,
0.5396997929,
0.0305845235,
-0.2210924476,
-0.1174528971,
-0.4883013666,
-0.0197578836,
-0.2312075347,
-0.8212582469,
1.0396573544,
-0.3517520726,
-0.5503637195,
-0.2585373521,
-0.8989369869,
0.0384434797,
0.1621400267,
0.00156583,
-0.2528402805,
-0.2178624421,
0.8710154295,
-0.5065472722,
0.2122441232,
-0.0896698758,
0.0183579139,
-0.1264110506,
0.3920678496,
0.0017887456,
0.0305408314,
-0.3962232172,
0.5033550262,
0.4293015301,
-0.2263078541,
-0.6536301374,
0.7660720348,
-0.5890253186,
-0.127120778,
-0.3957733214,
-0.6718578339,
-0.4520281851,
0.6039415598,
0.2811806798,
0.2634288371,
-0.2597623169,
0.065649122,
0.0051153582,
-0.2202748954,
0.4032217264,
0.5782790184,
-0.0603379123,
-0.5834940672,
0.852648139,
0.1048015133,
0.1191462725,
0.697899282,
0.4776613116,
-0.7969148159,
-0.3767639995,
-0.8282812238,
0.311448127,
-0.5695088506,
-0.439651221,
-0.2073451877,
0.0609524511,
-0.3753858209,
0.0179280676,
-0.415595293,
-0.4080248773,
0.2829091549,
0.0650622323,
0.202929467,
0.3705426753,
0.1179701462,
0.0231860895,
-0.7451111078,
0.0674531758,
0.0720876083,
0.4475487769,
-0.1358900368,
-0.6614301205,
-0.2693277299,
0.127808392,
-0.3307882547,
-0.9715158939,
0.604441762,
-0.0335474238,
0.3358683288,
0.2566040456,
-0.0564026423,
0.6753962636,
-0.6289358735,
0.5661507249,
0.4114306867,
-1.0093157291,
0.3860570192,
-0.0747688264,
0.0494730361,
0.6666374803,
0.3801792264,
-0.7537489533,
0.0474865511,
-0.5465745926,
-0.805119276,
0.26668486,
0.3100096881,
0.163217634,
-0.2282300293,
0.0433699898,
-0.2797242999,
0.3755610287,
-0.3730091751,
-0.2081924826,
-0.2893725038,
-0.2958674729,
-0.2889699638,
0.059240669,
-0.0698926747,
-0.3958975375,
0.4895250201,
0.0380375646,
0.3924663961,
0.1793280691,
-0.4468361735,
0.1194862649,
0.3469334245,
0.5066956878,
0.705467999,
-0.3196511865,
0.3875923455,
0.2624264657,
-0.4341259301,
0.0213858243,
0.2629884481,
-0.1630014181,
0.4207821786,
0.3710273504,
0.5094287992,
0.3673169911,
-0.4441188872,
0.9871743321,
0.2152636647,
-0.0458746143,
-0.060272336,
-0.7287740111,
0.3566177487,
0.0506636314,
-0.2643106282,
0.2703003883,
0.3972482681,
-0.30882743,
0.2241790742,
0.3026970327,
-0.6429896951,
-0.4026139379,
0.2049830854,
0.200366661,
-0.4277657866,
0.8073470592,
-0.3394661546,
-0.716377914,
0.4559593499,
0.4247603714,
0.9617828131,
-0.3811245859,
0.1009363532,
0.4558934569,
0.5212637186,
0.2921104431,
0.0488964915,
-0.0594744496,
-0.7203109264,
-0.5805783868,
-0.9544778466,
-0.0800300986,
-0.4373291731,
-0.7394940853,
0.2218479365,
-0.0301155411,
-0.024535751,
-0.0628899038,
0.1064580977,
-0.5740936399,
-0.0424248576,
-0.1599556506,
0.8068927526,
-0.5316080451,
0.8277743459,
0.7452684641,
-0.4853055179,
-0.5600525737,
-0.0405402668,
-0.3780989945,
-0.7782506943,
1.071371913,
-0.0296368878,
-0.3947214782,
-0.0658621266,
0.0873434916,
-0.5442504287,
0.9053534865,
0.2129661143,
-0.3415791094,
0.1693497449,
0.1099887937,
0.7478852868,
0.2011250705,
0.3983474672,
0.3883382976,
0.5867111683,
0.0841045454,
-1.0495325327,
0.0192238521,
-0.5095817447,
0.3050381243,
0.3915065229,
-0.4587881565,
0.5367906094,
0.0953681096,
-0.3273290098,
-0.0725530684,
0.6789418459,
-0.2746125162,
0.4798970819,
0.4001089334,
0.6129550934,
0.4649342,
0.0323034003,
0.979881525,
-0.530031085,
0.5647307634,
1.1320506334,
-0.4647372067,
1.2274181843,
0.8239162564,
-0.4062307179,
0.4177969098,
0.2969380915,
0.0835214555,
0.479948312,
0.4238268435,
-0.2196457237,
0.0344290063,
0.0760496557,
-0.1934964508,
0.5704530478,
0.2419612706,
-0.2641372979,
-0.5253204703,
0.1821851581,
0.0637538433,
0.303396821,
0.0743920133,
0.7408217788,
0.0944010392,
-0.7617081404,
0.8657438159,
0.4131151438,
0.5370054245,
-0.4404633641,
0.0950874537,
-0.2786034942,
0.1796112061,
0.076801464,
-0.6651728749,
0.7363597155,
-0.1057126001,
-0.1028886139,
-0.0476169512,
0.579739213,
-0.4831439555,
-0.4267546535,
0.5211091638,
0.777355969,
0.3421818614,
-0.2071166486,
-0.8609800339,
-0.4371779561,
-0.3402678668,
-0.1240978986,
0.1575617343,
0.6655954719,
-0.0113469204,
0.3667008281,
0.6103637815,
0.0815145075,
0.058543209,
0.1728646457,
0.5959176421,
-0.3879882097,
-0.2332582772,
-0.8460304141,
0.1506388187,
-0.1498185992,
-0.5027884841,
1.1654473543,
0.7172688246,
0.985994637,
-0.0456162803,
0.3641545177,
-0.1870136112,
0.4669535458,
-0.3415756822,
0.818117559,
-0.5518038869,
0.1095387787,
-0.2504456341,
-0.9670411348,
-0.4071584046,
0.6373098493,
-0.6311463714,
-0.0924900621,
1.1500934362,
0.9536892772,
-0.1849551499,
-0.184953168,
0.6319457293,
0.146822542,
-0.2449954748,
0.4902173579,
0.8670950532,
-0.7361450791,
0.518645525,
-0.4226413667,
-0.2466865182,
-0.1410901248,
-0.8177070022,
-0.649902463,
-0.681003809,
-0.1881254762,
-0.6587352753,
0.128392294,
0.8477243781,
0.4384260774,
-0.5659075975,
-0.4134730101,
0.0646040663,
0.1731313914,
-0.5398749113,
-0.2041506618,
0.7378176451,
-0.390168339,
-0.6796938181,
0.3680028915,
0.4768838882,
-0.3683675826,
-0.3551694453,
-0.2326031327,
-0.5178112388,
-0.1407781988,
1.2304059267,
-0.3486957252,
-0.6066920161,
-0.14568232,
0.0383894071,
-0.2768894136,
0.0351324603,
0.3848356605,
-0.5018881559,
0.6659077406,
0.9124261737,
0.5769968629,
0.1850756258,
-0.1378564537,
0.3298045695,
-0.7291992903,
0.123394087,
0.3399558961,
0.1881255358,
0.4629354477,
-0.1606332362,
0.5727558136,
0.5585755706,
-0.2533912063,
-0.6498449445,
0.0613647923,
-1.1898752451,
-0.1915504932,
1.1162316799,
-0.3533581793,
-0.3664139509,
-0.015289722,
-0.1038714796,
0.5421748757,
0.0407726802,
0.5049147606,
0.5831141472,
0.4099507034,
0.0398518555,
-0.6470425129,
-0.0498824529,
0.5697998405,
-0.5734459162,
-0.2764870822,
0.2980074584,
0.2130633444,
0.3732669055,
0.0221697129,
-0.4765478373,
0.1212097332,
-0.0072105108,
0.4303872585,
-0.0426974967,
-0.2907326519,
-0.4266483784,
-0.038629014,
0.0586562902,
-0.3983879387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03516v1
|
Unsupervised Multilingual Dense Retrieval via Generative Pseudo Labeling
| 2024-03-06T07:49:06 | 2024-03-06T07:49:06 |
Chao-Wei Huang, Chen-An Li, Tsu-Yuan Hsu, Chen-Yu Hsu, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Dense retrieval methods have demonstrated promising performance in
multilingual information retrieval, where queries and documents can be in
different languages. However, dense retrievers typically require a substantial
amount of paired data, which poses even greater challenges in multilingual
scenarios. This paper introduces UMR, an Unsupervised Multilingual dense
Retriever trained without any paired data. Our approach leverages the sequence
likelihood estimation capabilities of multilingual language models to acquire
pseudo labels for training dense retrievers. We propose a two-stage framework
which iteratively improves the performance of multilingual dense retrievers.
Experimental results on two benchmark datasets show that UMR outperforms
supervised baselines, showcasing the potential of training multilingual
retrievers without paired data, thereby enhancing their practicality. Our
source code, data, and models are publicly available at
https://github.com/MiuLab/UMR
|
[
-0.2363127023,
-0.5332238674,
0.3700383902,
-0.0174969453,
-0.3720650673,
0.0671485141,
-0.2666683197,
-0.2493281364,
0.2092460543,
0.4420776367,
0.0451346226,
-0.2743203044,
-0.3345225751,
0.1065537855,
-0.2784112096,
1.0148755312,
0.2998767197,
0.3484417796,
-0.0967392325,
-0.3869636655,
-0.2661328018,
-0.7371863127,
-0.3947981298,
-0.3698199987,
0.6988507509,
0.6316215992,
0.5948847532,
0.2479765117,
0.1620975882,
0.3221143782,
-0.014600235,
0.2243070155,
-0.5936064124,
0.0351661406,
0.0971756727,
-0.3825677037,
0.1315124929,
-0.4622467458,
1.0147337914,
1.0556670427,
-0.4541350007,
-0.1058009043,
0.0950219929,
0.7625807524,
-0.640154779,
-0.113384597,
-0.4603767693,
0.1857144237,
-0.6671267152,
-0.1714728475,
-0.5769646168,
-0.1203841045,
0.1474203914,
-0.5982782245,
0.3536463678,
0.1930237561,
0.4464304447,
-0.1004245058,
-0.5578436852,
0.0431620032,
-0.7663904428,
0.8004903197,
-0.2430596054,
0.8425357342,
0.4365964532,
0.2843704522,
-0.0124177719,
-0.8128154874,
-0.3915804029,
0.020077236,
-0.2530668974,
0.0970696732,
-0.0521968342,
-0.2058294863,
0.0931817368,
0.5468127131,
-1.0540047884,
0.0046984786,
-0.2640040219,
-0.2171175331,
0.4033040106,
-0.1621449441,
0.2315671444,
-0.1291574389,
-0.3480263054,
-0.249277398,
-0.4599088132,
-0.1201672032,
0.2965830863,
0.3537415266,
-0.0526416004,
0.8977020383,
-0.0870026425,
0.8881852627,
-0.0672088489,
-0.0573853664,
0.394407779,
-0.2744007707,
0.1990868747,
0.1774072349,
0.9805556536,
-0.0598529056,
0.0552063249,
-0.5875187516,
-0.3589387536,
-0.151084885,
-0.0486488082,
-0.7690831423,
-0.6086487174,
-0.0197915658,
-0.43567577,
0.3517335653,
0.221934855,
-0.9719122648,
-0.1177233085,
-0.2032009512,
0.4429640174,
-0.3835529983,
-0.3868798614,
0.1383513808,
-0.1423248649,
0.1514820009,
-0.1404934824,
-0.6512650847,
-0.0274958964,
0.0905212983,
0.6435844898,
0.049953185,
-0.2196589112,
-0.6904560328,
0.2574463785,
-0.2618401647,
0.7714335322,
-0.6376203895,
-0.5878900886,
-0.0327304378,
-0.0167548303,
-0.1383619457,
-0.5931674838,
0.4152697623,
-0.9335664511,
0.2291941643,
-0.454461813,
-0.4795393944,
0.0328794196,
-0.0005335485,
-0.8123767376,
1.4202240705,
-0.0749516487,
-1.0431491137,
0.195875302,
-0.2602924705,
-0.7895355821,
0.30430457,
-0.2246198356,
-0.2766788006,
0.0601159632,
0.1507553458,
0.2216670811,
-0.3336382806,
0.4521624148,
-0.3216161728,
-0.5157794356,
0.1715865582,
-0.2678999007,
0.6513365507,
0.3634445369,
-0.1030274928,
-0.0280616917,
-0.9214066267,
0.1621206105,
0.2326351255,
-0.4781774282,
-0.632248044,
0.0260779299,
0.471477896,
0.1548886001,
0.2089102119,
-0.5526202917,
0.1796389371,
-0.2194830924,
0.1125416011,
0.2287207693,
-0.1935209185,
0.8320962787,
0.0687814802,
0.1903111041,
-0.0229540244,
-0.2157441974,
-0.0822015479,
-0.3768371344,
-0.8063058257,
-0.3261306584,
0.4978320003,
0.6474846005,
-1.3281145096,
0.2938919067,
-0.2621410191,
-0.2239113003,
-0.7589895129,
0.5221164823,
0.7656498551,
0.5504418015,
0.6411005855,
-0.286817193,
-0.7684719563,
-0.7198753357,
-0.0485114977,
-0.0140394308,
-0.2199368328,
0.2013584524,
0.2564377785,
-0.3144616783,
0.7469087243,
-0.4591184258,
-0.4911966026,
-0.4698247612,
0.5414689183,
-0.005267608,
0.5087121129,
0.2741284966,
-1.1799771786,
-0.500769794,
0.0780436546,
-1.0793880224,
0.1452140361,
0.2220624983,
-0.1335217506,
0.2099597454,
0.5046001077,
-0.3939514458,
0.1272868067,
0.2725692987,
0.1872208118,
0.0611349195,
-0.5799791813,
0.113792181,
-1.048079133,
0.4366039634,
0.0243281573,
-0.0048414143,
-0.5277949572,
-0.088728033,
0.2963445783,
-0.1586236954,
-0.3534618914,
0.7674977779,
-0.8701366186,
-0.3482713103,
-0.0920447037,
-0.054207474,
0.0259901453,
0.0041415426,
0.5037546754,
0.8422365785,
0.4489434361,
-0.6105613112,
0.080067642,
0.3082498908,
-0.4618920088,
0.5909052491,
-0.6754053235,
0.3388293982,
-0.489444077,
0.2029288113,
-0.9031468034,
-0.2434846759,
-0.0814109594,
-0.1940405965,
0.6262569427,
-0.5048125982,
-0.9103637338,
-0.6423977017,
0.0384031087,
0.7243715525,
0.3238823712,
-0.6556876302,
0.4559046328,
0.508533299,
-0.0145627297,
-0.6399208307,
-0.8546559215,
0.0289417487,
-0.2054914236,
-0.3201835454,
0.3544223309,
-0.3271536827,
-0.0762729794,
-0.142362386,
0.0863595307,
-0.4134060442,
-0.2803635597,
-0.240759626,
0.1225399897,
-0.1909528673,
-0.0844408497,
-0.0660329089,
-0.31682989,
-0.3810452819,
-0.4524566233,
0.3843195438,
-0.0533720106,
-0.2257455587,
-0.0432509556,
0.5144997239,
0.0107474569,
-0.5828576684,
0.7983128428,
0.9469469786,
-0.2736543715,
0.1612080038,
-0.8368564248,
-0.1711010039,
-0.4327384531,
0.1317505538,
-0.6858669519,
-1.013045311,
0.4010928273,
0.222353667,
-0.351051271,
0.1365244389,
0.3907691538,
-0.1753948629,
1.0382773876,
0.7408846617,
-0.1841367334,
0.3014652729,
-0.2526391447,
0.2724654377,
-0.5941041112,
-0.6438775659,
-0.574115932,
0.0156910215,
-0.4338497519,
-0.4636202455,
0.4729487002,
0.425088048,
0.0962486714,
0.2284177393,
-0.3210673928,
0.629989028,
0.6774873734,
0.0733052045,
0.3977110982,
0.1835644543,
-0.5030894876,
-0.3300116956,
-0.9959661961,
-0.1641560197,
0.9861992598,
-0.4284425378,
0.7224808931,
0.268101722,
0.5671727061,
0.1869614124,
0.1505407095,
-0.4265936017,
0.2252473086,
-0.1223819181,
-0.6331170797,
-0.0594556369,
-0.7377861738,
-1.2254005671,
0.7670775056,
-0.04756229,
-0.6124563813,
0.2869658768,
0.0937279016,
-0.1745857894,
0.1936398596,
-0.6322590709,
0.9504874945,
-0.4827854335,
-0.4780522585,
0.1646978557,
-1.1157053709,
0.2460538894,
-0.3533582091,
0.3974480331,
0.3013027906,
0.2146536857,
0.7987046838,
-0.215095669,
0.6416710615,
-0.1930883527,
0.0556149967,
0.3112358451,
0.0118446536,
0.3806867301,
0.0866140127,
-0.2584161162,
0.1687582433,
-0.0986854807,
-0.6704794765,
-0.2314662635,
0.8572369218,
-0.65877527,
0.0146504287,
-0.5366907716,
-0.5359779596,
-0.149710238,
0.5300306082,
0.6127632856,
0.3699497879,
-0.4230040014,
0.2067937404,
0.8841912746,
-0.0782282576,
0.6046207547,
0.7498281002,
-0.0982120931,
-0.3964182436,
1.0750337839,
0.1353576779,
-0.2404879183,
0.8776183128,
-0.0396034308,
-0.8385133743,
-0.3547493815,
-0.7242209911,
0.235682711,
-0.5186071992,
-0.2419991195,
-1.0016965866,
0.1753190607,
-0.3007755876,
0.050016921,
-0.4597728848,
-0.1954355538,
-0.3651484847,
0.0781316683,
0.0565353744,
0.4806996882,
-0.273680985,
0.3065977693,
-0.8858926296,
0.5460889339,
0.1130792126,
0.1291077882,
-0.1039167121,
-0.6318825483,
-0.2329171747,
0.0671622306,
0.1208136007,
-0.5863338113,
0.4045835733,
0.3080107868,
0.5958800912,
0.5259962678,
0.2486852258,
0.9755868316,
-0.5696322918,
0.3157399595,
0.1903833151,
-0.5481722951,
0.4130898714,
-0.128288433,
0.2453371882,
0.7299265265,
0.7215610147,
-0.2918478549,
0.2714527845,
-0.2173342556,
-0.9137645364,
0.6280732751,
-0.0191008449,
-0.0077283634,
-0.3054437637,
0.2097891867,
0.0898158327,
0.2668661773,
-0.7876839638,
-0.4402069151,
-0.1526251584,
0.0550240241,
-0.5676941276,
-0.5689249039,
0.1074023396,
-0.1961323172,
0.4411818683,
-0.1177179515,
0.0310039427,
0.0804037377,
-0.7589014173,
-0.1540412754,
0.4628693163,
0.1363404095,
0.3825103343,
-0.3504032493,
0.3906174898,
-0.176373601,
0.0483174548,
0.2319049537,
0.6766677499,
-0.2821846604,
0.0499879234,
0.0258005392,
0.5149329901,
0.8233675957,
-0.7034332752,
0.4830104113,
0.029454546,
0.1536298394,
-0.2230296284,
-0.7114322782,
0.0090963608,
0.1511457115,
0.5809919238,
-0.2203380167,
0.543636322,
-0.2295754254,
0.5216020346,
0.4213585854,
-0.3429836929,
-0.4412384033,
0.8775699735,
-0.0936987326,
0.243568331,
0.9789969921,
-0.373395443,
-0.3149223924,
-0.0217271242,
0.8451859355,
0.2453078926,
-0.4281885922,
0.3257395327,
0.4257426858,
0.2589292228,
-0.4030637145,
0.3266696632,
-0.1587932855,
-0.7086820602,
-0.3974950016,
-0.7544430494,
0.0568201058,
0.0362070017,
-0.8634624481,
-0.0023946301,
0.0067601763,
0.0124425562,
-0.1068807766,
-0.1713256836,
-0.5358163118,
0.1360203624,
0.1437431574,
0.4462325573,
-0.7093374729,
1.0758566856,
0.896001935,
-0.6552278996,
-0.4406321943,
-0.4249117076,
0.1548030674,
-0.6578646302,
0.5469451547,
0.1736011952,
-0.0370506011,
0.2963437736,
0.0161459595,
-0.9161655307,
0.7063206434,
0.4609384537,
-0.6567556262,
0.0426320843,
0.1735934764,
0.4859142303,
0.1218120083,
0.3975709081,
0.1678431034,
0.4610818028,
0.3805759549,
-0.5764729381,
-0.2967393994,
-0.3292731047,
0.3613810539,
0.4127405882,
-0.4187676013,
0.6395256519,
-0.4609537423,
-0.3044140637,
0.4292048216,
0.9117605686,
0.2225578427,
0.2825170457,
0.1793004125,
0.885681808,
0.8279518485,
-0.0034734206,
1.2872196436,
-0.0843302906,
0.2354392111,
1.1252578497,
-0.5560241342,
0.9696824551,
0.4963608384,
-0.0322643146,
0.1198166385,
0.6172609329,
0.1551322043,
0.6786919832,
-0.074166663,
-0.3331323862,
-0.3655621111,
-0.4068125188,
-0.5952011943,
0.3107763529,
0.0916929767,
-0.0782220662,
-0.240889132,
0.2136257887,
0.1586492807,
0.1438159347,
-0.0588860065,
0.7021611333,
0.1299237013,
-0.467900753,
0.6984211802,
0.1177903786,
0.799202621,
-0.5128307343,
-0.0254327971,
-0.4850965738,
0.2784601152,
-0.123317875,
-0.5661185384,
0.0298688374,
-0.1089926288,
-0.2515312135,
-0.155684188,
0.6089699268,
-0.8504572511,
-0.6976016164,
0.7673202157,
0.8111669421,
0.2086901069,
-0.2344578058,
-0.8178355098,
0.0441956744,
-0.1272067279,
-0.0862094834,
0.6284136176,
0.49476403,
-0.1769851446,
0.4643691778,
0.8424733281,
-0.3081471324,
0.2793343365,
0.5374802947,
0.7043586969,
-0.5243192911,
-0.1751363277,
-0.4892268479,
0.4320569634,
0.2449633032,
0.1169868931,
0.8177906275,
1.1771868467,
1.2326653004,
-0.0854542255,
0.5988745093,
-0.1375612766,
0.3972156644,
-0.473446399,
0.6233633757,
-0.7489673495,
0.0937888473,
-0.2063291669,
-1.2729927301,
-0.5348666906,
0.6236198545,
-0.1056440771,
0.247205615,
0.4237640202,
0.7802348137,
-0.4542895257,
-0.3017389774,
0.4519894421,
0.124681741,
-0.1867325604,
0.3938999176,
0.8474119902,
-0.4670307636,
0.6989853978,
-0.5248876214,
-0.1383975595,
-0.1713044047,
-0.5118887424,
-0.8616980314,
-0.6040933132,
-0.1148954555,
-0.189467147,
0.1446915716,
0.4593736827,
0.671346426,
-0.8716523647,
-0.3505432606,
0.2071098238,
-0.1199362949,
0.1658620089,
-0.2328104228,
0.2234623283,
-0.2889067531,
-0.6538076997,
0.8123807907,
0.1364540607,
0.0677076355,
0.2772938609,
-0.2858877778,
-0.6244510412,
-0.6017706394,
0.6083837152,
0.7377366424,
-0.6595525146,
0.2423727661,
-0.0566085316,
-0.059434697,
0.1459497958,
0.8247637153,
-0.7107649446,
0.7006531358,
0.2467993051,
0.6786835194,
0.8646633029,
-0.1012485772,
0.3891538978,
-0.9885097742,
0.4428378344,
0.0637435392,
0.5014426112,
0.7541108727,
-0.2144710869,
0.4747975767,
0.2731640339,
-0.2841238976,
-0.7704824805,
-0.0736348927,
-0.7948608994,
-0.1943673044,
1.008120656,
-0.0919520408,
0.251712203,
-0.2856251597,
-0.0448558442,
0.32574898,
-0.4256128967,
0.4628953934,
0.1129849181,
0.2119839489,
-0.3725086153,
-0.4338754117,
0.1102813482,
0.6143686175,
-0.4695921838,
-0.3231546283,
0.6799092293,
0.2127595842,
0.0871197432,
0.9066001177,
-0.2924974859,
-0.0826706663,
-0.2791620493,
0.2557965517,
0.3065292835,
-0.6366858482,
-0.3095295131,
0.1046418473,
0.0416421518,
0.1517761648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03514v1
|
CLongEval: A Chinese Benchmark for Evaluating Long-Context Large Language Models
| 2024-03-06T07:43:43 | 2024-03-06T07:43:43 |
Zexuan Qiu, Jingjing Li, Shijue Huang, Wanjun Zhong, Irwin King
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Developing Large Language Models (LLMs) with robust long-context capabilities
has been the recent research focus, resulting in the emergence of long-context
LLMs proficient in Chinese. However, the evaluation of these models remains
underdeveloped due to a lack of benchmarks. To address this gap, we present
CLongEval, a comprehensive Chinese benchmark for evaluating long-context LLMs.
CLongEval is characterized by three key features: (1) Sufficient data volume,
comprising 7 distinct tasks and 7,267 examples; (2) Broad applicability,
accommodating to models with context windows size from 1K to 100K; (3) High
quality, with over 2,000 manually annotated question-answer pairs in addition
to the automatically constructed labels. With CLongEval, we undertake a
comprehensive assessment of 6 open-source long-context LLMs and 2 leading
commercial counterparts that feature both long-context abilities and
proficiency in Chinese. We also provide in-depth analysis based on the
empirical results, trying to shed light on the critical capabilities that
present challenges in long-context settings. The dataset, evaluation scripts,
and model outputs will be released.
|
[
-0.0596061386,
-0.6171959043,
0.384056896,
0.7063382864,
-0.4862944782,
-0.2912964821,
-0.8984010816,
-0.5616642237,
-0.2064068913,
0.5492236614,
-0.0777892172,
-0.6679010987,
-0.414637208,
0.0301508568,
-0.3167008758,
0.6050501466,
-0.0500987545,
0.0257714652,
-0.1410347819,
-0.38444677,
-0.5288755298,
-0.4642791152,
-0.4463047981,
-0.2813061476,
0.2346263975,
0.0834013671,
0.488342464,
0.5823997855,
0.3407245874,
0.2069849521,
-0.1079048514,
0.1387894452,
-0.5676335692,
0.1435031593,
-0.0208195839,
-0.0584355853,
-0.5639989972,
-0.0972152576,
0.8533673286,
0.7799352407,
-0.1993345767,
0.4879567623,
0.5235185623,
0.62607342,
-0.5583649874,
0.2390345782,
-0.6432397366,
-0.1960588694,
-0.5902719498,
0.0891858637,
-0.2315562963,
-0.5820682645,
0.4653548002,
-0.2663313448,
-0.2394280881,
-0.216866672,
0.2663192153,
0.096240297,
-0.6589391828,
-0.3935936689,
-0.2579375803,
0.9788532853,
-0.9817836881,
0.3669522107,
0.128062889,
0.4948307574,
-0.2555667758,
-1.0326313972,
-0.207788825,
-0.6087957621,
-0.0140587734,
-0.0203463715,
0.322920531,
0.0880512968,
0.1689356714,
0.3979448378,
-0.7716953158,
0.1333283633,
-0.4079427421,
-0.2720001638,
0.8941495419,
0.0514592193,
0.1815609485,
-0.1551860124,
-0.6874793768,
0.3183450401,
-0.8047967553,
0.2514773607,
-0.2062185109,
0.6037221551,
-0.0358938389,
0.2372872978,
-0.1465544105,
0.6664819717,
-0.3385665417,
-0.354631424,
0.3554309309,
-0.1916554868,
-0.32618016,
0.2468586117,
0.7769550681,
0.4584252834,
0.1639136523,
0.0526792072,
-0.3355915546,
-0.3512931466,
-0.2690292001,
-1.1546733379,
-0.0927799493,
0.5741677284,
-0.5336939692,
0.0673086271,
-0.1120818257,
-0.7207995653,
-0.616902709,
-0.0329038687,
0.1631780863,
-0.2073449343,
-0.3506008387,
0.0655939803,
0.0364987627,
0.3324553967,
0.225460425,
-0.5834290981,
0.1393503249,
0.9826360941,
1.0506675243,
-0.4750633538,
-0.5446071625,
-0.5189919472,
-0.0370675549,
-0.3172124624,
0.3476291001,
-0.3091388047,
-0.4692573845,
0.5326423049,
0.2055295855,
0.0393245406,
-0.7936658263,
0.9102061987,
-0.3593735993,
-0.0944881588,
-0.2271727026,
-0.6023961306,
-0.023916373,
0.4330554903,
-0.5744949579,
1.1095271111,
0.1312419474,
-0.5477541685,
0.2493332773,
-0.545676887,
-0.6000247598,
0.430965811,
-0.1074971184,
-0.111044772,
-0.125902161,
0.0320112482,
0.4527160823,
-0.4733798206,
0.4938174486,
-0.3792815208,
-0.4942514002,
0.1010180786,
-0.4815692604,
0.9353227615,
0.1141414419,
-0.4277848303,
0.24295187,
-0.7362894416,
0.3741970956,
0.0648163781,
-0.374101311,
-0.5041446686,
-0.0348363481,
0.2001755685,
0.1974759102,
0.8772554994,
-0.4086748362,
0.0485885926,
-0.3294680119,
0.8153249621,
0.5625531077,
-0.3175771832,
0.0382778011,
-0.0194946099,
0.2558459342,
-0.1031988636,
0.1414181143,
-0.2463923991,
-0.1068559885,
-0.4546405077,
-0.2813333273,
0.2428113669,
0.4323245883,
-0.2992597222,
0.4254623353,
-0.4398249984,
-0.772781074,
-0.4695595205,
0.4613600969,
0.426908046,
0.3951895237,
0.4003966153,
-0.1948637366,
-0.287522614,
-0.8016774654,
-0.2552526295,
-0.0619056411,
-0.260738939,
0.4297433794,
0.5154541135,
-0.1482696533,
0.5657886863,
-0.3088211119,
-0.390019238,
-0.2601055205,
-0.195053339,
0.4019667208,
0.2719250023,
0.4361696541,
-0.6093193293,
-0.639280498,
0.1549830735,
-0.7030564547,
-0.2019064128,
0.1033846959,
0.0879465342,
0.2190820277,
0.4619412124,
-0.6557381749,
0.0655834153,
0.7649019957,
0.1505113989,
0.7416617274,
-0.1643826216,
-0.0211935285,
-0.8845208883,
0.4141907394,
-0.1194033325,
-0.2416545153,
-0.6283971071,
0.269485265,
0.3963507712,
-0.1605283767,
-0.5597137213,
0.7012885809,
-0.5206411481,
-0.145566076,
-0.3430480659,
0.8211101294,
-0.1676649749,
0.2495922595,
0.1269537061,
0.8535780311,
0.4106993377,
-0.5044317842,
0.6319313049,
-0.0274807997,
-0.7169806957,
0.349552393,
-1.0639992952,
0.0792541355,
0.3412032425,
0.4756686985,
-0.7867161632,
-0.3664259017,
-0.1693205088,
-0.0764358863,
-0.0164109021,
-0.1664407998,
-0.3114571273,
-0.4614780843,
-0.4792127907,
0.6548828483,
0.4089260101,
-0.7882316709,
0.2594057024,
0.320851922,
-0.1072569117,
-0.6205370426,
-0.6031634212,
0.0978536084,
-0.3580070138,
-0.7902138829,
0.3647903502,
-0.131921947,
-0.1788345873,
-0.4039205015,
0.1166745275,
-0.1050705761,
0.1171594113,
0.1331035495,
0.0376434103,
-0.5761948228,
0.2303785384,
-0.3075378537,
0.1712714285,
0.1661143154,
-0.3208907247,
0.5283396244,
-0.344347477,
-0.2323922962,
-0.2160610408,
-0.0478127301,
0.5940039754,
-0.4935511947,
0.3740810454,
0.3705965877,
-0.3179833293,
-0.6212146878,
-0.397408098,
0.1972049326,
-0.4816724956,
0.6150554419,
-0.1648121774,
-0.887067616,
0.511497438,
-0.2849154174,
0.3415291607,
0.2244014889,
0.6094602346,
0.4745443165,
0.6157277822,
0.3162324727,
-0.4867922366,
0.1464410424,
0.1968037039,
-0.002852438,
-0.8423431516,
0.0518131144,
-0.1946384609,
0.0106992573,
-0.6319668889,
-0.4172611237,
0.3575989306,
0.2290109992,
-0.3236862421,
0.3594973087,
-0.3909737468,
0.39719823,
0.2868789732,
-0.0798053592,
0.2599633634,
-0.6094591022,
0.1318108439,
0.1320452541,
-0.266015321,
-0.6700154543,
1.0284789801,
0.5139638782,
0.4053062797,
0.1841823608,
0.5038526654,
0.1953140497,
0.3227607608,
-0.666914463,
0.685421288,
-0.3262523711,
-0.5931383967,
-0.5256544948,
-0.1728898585,
-0.9245864153,
0.4221713245,
0.263102293,
-0.6684285402,
-0.2814712822,
0.0802609548,
-0.3115184009,
0.0555902608,
-0.4219846129,
1.0942881107,
-0.5646443367,
-0.4244888425,
-0.1270580739,
-0.6073906422,
0.71312356,
-0.1524796784,
0.0489292555,
-0.18323116,
-0.1031154767,
0.4433634281,
-0.3300529122,
0.7491894364,
-0.2715552449,
-0.2834896743,
0.4593802392,
-0.1165448278,
0.4329836667,
0.148868233,
-0.431611985,
0.2899823487,
0.2871621549,
-0.5108675361,
-0.4365384579,
1.0467082262,
-0.5151700377,
-0.5955122709,
-0.2979320884,
-0.2642158866,
-0.1974440366,
0.53491956,
-0.0630624592,
0.5516241193,
-0.5823057294,
0.4218820035,
0.3374531269,
-0.3140039742,
0.5131594539,
0.3435776234,
-0.4786144495,
-0.4433079362,
0.7200158238,
0.1990942657,
0.3945756853,
-0.0491658151,
0.2525453568,
-0.3260030448,
-0.7813717723,
-0.3818844855,
0.0574445352,
-0.6962813735,
0.0397046581,
-0.0006610173,
-0.5452308059,
-0.3615703583,
0.060440883,
-0.3690291941,
-0.0626398548,
0.0039368351,
0.1600911617,
-0.1460428238,
0.4408432543,
0.3502531648,
0.1147695854,
-0.832754612,
-0.0370884873,
0.2651575506,
0.4309541285,
0.2850747108,
-0.4986587465,
-0.3810621202,
0.0503854081,
-0.2467386425,
-0.368855834,
0.3166110218,
0.3754310906,
0.4900544286,
0.534491241,
0.291157335,
0.8336065412,
-0.5617397428,
1.1902599335,
-0.2153545767,
-0.9911459684,
0.4126220047,
-0.3761353195,
0.3449614942,
0.5954172015,
0.1931565553,
-0.6440516114,
-0.0565523989,
-0.1453102976,
-0.8197977543,
0.1716394424,
-0.0376574211,
0.1797495037,
-0.097623758,
0.3165412545,
0.1318336278,
0.3005307615,
-0.7853957415,
0.0296627358,
-0.2348437011,
-0.041410692,
-0.1529906243,
-0.3025068045,
-0.0489714518,
-0.0694285631,
0.4121658206,
-0.2012994736,
-0.3803323507,
0.2684769034,
-0.3264187276,
0.26689592,
0.3699317575,
0.847565949,
0.986019671,
-0.3230194747,
0.0963816345,
0.5396561027,
-0.3846214712,
-0.3989262581,
0.2138541937,
0.0951553956,
-0.0705867782,
0.7010085583,
0.4307886362,
0.1331095845,
-1.0697102547,
0.7116212249,
0.1809498966,
0.0964481533,
-0.7476248741,
-0.1012233421,
0.1861605644,
0.3148828745,
0.4218259454,
-0.5987563729,
0.124856323,
-0.539301753,
0.2005744874,
0.5283768177,
-0.4374794364,
-0.3744256496,
0.4603817761,
0.4642463923,
-0.0682231784,
0.5497338772,
0.0843014345,
-0.5687413216,
0.4524262846,
0.5883622766,
0.8484527469,
-0.2618452907,
-0.1903109998,
0.5635253787,
0.2505812943,
-0.2220808715,
0.0931230187,
-0.0705946088,
-0.213979423,
-0.0962605104,
-0.5178263187,
-0.2542405128,
0.3807575703,
-0.5291488171,
0.3333313465,
-0.4829990566,
-0.1445649713,
-0.3236049712,
0.391704917,
-0.2790550292,
0.0924352705,
0.1549614817,
1.2209973335,
-0.3479835391,
1.0652655363,
0.2124893069,
-0.0284076091,
-0.4932475686,
0.1723918766,
-0.0982763097,
-0.9138935208,
0.6651303768,
0.6533499956,
-0.1792282015,
-0.3422399163,
-0.5339382887,
-0.5569415689,
1.4805412292,
0.1600113511,
-0.6448997855,
0.1110597551,
0.3686568737,
0.7499243021,
-0.5147899389,
0.2725605965,
0.7760156393,
0.4593605399,
-0.2449522167,
-1.2415783405,
0.1420615613,
-0.1218240336,
0.0887840539,
0.0980226621,
-1.1451481581,
0.7834629416,
-0.0443475544,
-0.4316728413,
0.5323109031,
0.8491992354,
0.4359450042,
0.4727506042,
0.4915235639,
-0.0247457046,
0.9258897901,
0.0690208152,
0.7743633389,
-0.8132463098,
0.2858415842,
1.1879069805,
-0.618716538,
1.3152428865,
0.1708091199,
-0.1017806455,
0.3239946961,
0.5828262568,
0.0226612203,
0.2957276106,
0.4353151619,
-0.3667107821,
-0.2648381591,
-0.3641490936,
-0.5580559969,
0.2233797014,
0.4006143212,
-0.2810838521,
-0.1403367221,
-0.3411046267,
-0.0812595636,
0.1649472415,
-0.3680244684,
0.2639145851,
0.4752880335,
-0.7542614937,
0.8038851619,
-0.0824364871,
0.6863561869,
-0.7344426513,
0.0807056725,
-0.2441254556,
0.333014071,
-0.1908793151,
-0.9517657161,
-0.1056564599,
-0.1576584727,
0.2305034548,
0.2937981486,
0.7515305281,
-0.7916430831,
-0.156672135,
0.5128828287,
0.1934364438,
0.1140325144,
-0.0043377015,
-0.5906103253,
0.1468494534,
-0.2413451374,
-0.2138625085,
0.3086105287,
0.5117827654,
-0.248200804,
0.828461647,
0.4293538928,
0.2063520253,
-0.1013892964,
0.0748963654,
0.6211382747,
-0.803494215,
-0.2582977116,
-0.9350036979,
0.3764827549,
-0.2381891459,
-0.6745449901,
0.8870491982,
0.7122286558,
0.609608829,
0.1700874567,
0.8011494279,
0.1978521943,
0.4519581795,
-0.3651514649,
0.7097022533,
-0.5472394824,
0.3372047544,
-0.0361370556,
-0.8695640564,
-0.2880108654,
0.1155456677,
-0.4048878253,
0.0458549038,
0.4631389678,
0.626733005,
-0.0364504643,
-0.0239700675,
0.3821646869,
0.2863143086,
0.46995911,
0.9006624818,
0.8288630247,
-0.3347071111,
0.4591065943,
-0.1879776865,
-0.2220185548,
-0.2444396317,
-1.0387731791,
-1.2874078751,
-0.4827976823,
0.0483959056,
-0.1704654843,
0.105279848,
1.1609241962,
0.5127211809,
-0.8414412737,
-0.5784262419,
0.3722573817,
-0.1104810759,
-0.1863148808,
-0.1764021367,
0.8466994762,
-0.3629392385,
-0.5848243237,
0.4790956974,
0.321120739,
-0.2417241484,
-0.5882424116,
-0.111528106,
0.3021630347,
0.0701075718,
0.9441686869,
0.3684874773,
-0.8945518136,
-0.408457756,
-0.1237596571,
-0.334721148,
-0.0575461127,
0.6675008535,
-0.3982692361,
0.3538025022,
0.4020569324,
0.6255690455,
0.1376818568,
0.1981095076,
0.5510131121,
-0.570402205,
0.2089092135,
0.0983769149,
0.3777782023,
0.4183196723,
0.0951984823,
0.4394584298,
-0.1941621602,
-0.952516377,
-1.0385802984,
0.0193435382,
-1.0105370283,
-0.2567974925,
1.1723433733,
-0.484487623,
-0.3074321747,
-0.0365381241,
-0.1482565999,
-0.1080280915,
-0.2110927105,
0.7018655539,
0.7126805782,
0.2030319273,
0.0232755393,
-0.7684983015,
0.5838012099,
0.2226477116,
-0.6341996789,
0.6918240786,
0.3803704679,
0.3132291734,
-0.0009908981,
0.5419427752,
-0.0209372435,
0.2779464126,
-0.3192739785,
-0.304895252,
0.0358975455,
-0.105256401,
-0.312798351,
0.2574776709,
0.4253869951,
0.153934896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03506v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03506v4
|
Detecting AI-Generated Sentences in Human-AI Collaborative Hybrid Texts: Challenges, Strategies, and Insights
| 2024-03-06T07:25:46 | 2024-05-23T13:18:33 |
Zijie Zeng, Shiqi Liu, Lele Sha, Zhuang Li, Kaixun Yang, Sannyuya Liu, Dragan Gašević, Guanliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study explores the challenge of sentence-level AI-generated text
detection within human-AI collaborative hybrid texts. Existing studies of
AI-generated text detection for hybrid texts often rely on synthetic datasets.
These typically involve hybrid texts with a limited number of boundaries. We
contend that studies of detecting AI-generated content within hybrid texts
should cover different types of hybrid texts generated in realistic settings to
better inform real-world applications. Therefore, our study utilizes the
CoAuthor dataset, which includes diverse, realistic hybrid texts generated
through the collaboration between human writers and an intelligent writing
system in multi-turn interactions. We adopt a two-step, segmentation-based
pipeline: (i) detect segments within a given hybrid text where each segment
contains sentences of consistent authorship, and (ii) classify the authorship
of each identified segment. Our empirical findings highlight (1) detecting
AI-generated sentences in hybrid texts is overall a challenging task because
(1.1) human writers' selecting and even editing AI-generated sentences based on
personal preferences adds difficulty in identifying the authorship of segments;
(1.2) the frequent change of authorship between neighboring sentences within
the hybrid text creates difficulties for segment detectors in identifying
authorship-consistent segments; (1.3) the short length of text segments within
hybrid texts provides limited stylistic cues for reliable authorship
determination; (2) before embarking on the detection process, it is beneficial
to assess the average length of segments within the hybrid text. This
assessment aids in deciding whether (2.1) to employ a text segmentation-based
strategy for hybrid texts with longer segments, or (2.2) to adopt a direct
sentence-by-sentence classification strategy for those with shorter segments.
|
[
-0.3137043118,
-0.7114987373,
0.7711682916,
0.057432685,
-0.1759127229,
0.4271673858,
-0.1985930949,
-0.6310346723,
0.2664097548,
0.7430359125,
-0.5812029243,
-0.5227292776,
-0.4801116288,
0.6835570335,
-0.465913415,
1.012316227,
-0.160403505,
-0.4806362689,
-0.6333858371,
-0.0837096721,
-0.5391755104,
-0.3075366914,
-0.2751711607,
-0.0333477296,
0.4771657586,
0.4937986434,
0.4586987197,
0.7473760843,
0.4773446023,
0.3884801865,
0.1099359691,
0.6860357523,
-0.13199687,
0.2834201157,
0.3194971085,
-0.2646526396,
-0.0878036991,
0.1580783427,
0.5666666627,
0.3379090428,
0.2197984159,
-0.0808204859,
-0.1302983016,
0.4330742955,
-0.5874118209,
-0.1456060559,
-0.5538794398,
0.0195023697,
-0.606251061,
-0.2165947407,
-0.586269021,
-0.1044374704,
0.1410758942,
-0.6100775003,
0.261110872,
0.4804070592,
0.6106943488,
0.2412135601,
-0.4430022538,
-0.5666542053,
-0.7114097476,
0.6893899441,
-0.3818420172,
-0.1401747763,
0.1180540919,
-0.1876469553,
-0.0628445297,
-0.4708763063,
-1.1013646126,
-0.3227322996,
-0.3583019972,
0.1281041652,
-0.1908332705,
0.0442545637,
0.0747427046,
0.45906201,
-0.7104987502,
0.3533508778,
-0.2440071255,
-0.4636811912,
1.0025844574,
0.3232839704,
0.7560332417,
-0.3845258951,
-0.3563898504,
-0.0242342148,
-0.2163372785,
0.0184715483,
0.7644673586,
-0.0496890843,
-0.177058354,
0.6821654439,
0.1157487631,
0.6038603783,
-0.0095813433,
0.0505851805,
0.1337014437,
-0.6623829603,
0.2543131411,
0.0679680333,
1.351303339,
0.220385924,
0.5047219992,
-0.2129560113,
-0.0956059098,
0.0238117781,
0.1885107309,
-0.2284647226,
-0.3111579716,
0.1905648559,
-0.4176263511,
-0.3908793926,
0.5099027753,
-0.4557552636,
-0.5297838449,
-0.1693480462,
0.1624917686,
-0.4883446991,
-0.0946293622,
-0.0396696106,
-0.4215118885,
0.097606428,
0.0690232366,
-0.7606255412,
0.2172289342,
0.7281003594,
0.8427400589,
-0.7173794508,
-0.6046627164,
-0.5905124545,
0.0624927245,
-0.2059115916,
1.0247619152,
-0.3516581059,
-0.4206687212,
-0.2167259157,
-0.384221524,
-0.4143905342,
-0.597997129,
0.5102550387,
-0.2373341024,
0.8064241409,
0.0213661883,
-0.8091562986,
0.3144552708,
0.0833407417,
-0.6164799333,
0.7748689055,
-0.0260488037,
-0.869173646,
0.5145533681,
-0.7972080112,
-0.7624079585,
0.299299866,
-0.3075764477,
-0.8327783346,
-0.2310945243,
0.2734718025,
0.3664307296,
0.0294984542,
0.1405598521,
0.0834032595,
-0.4015688896,
0.4154238403,
-0.1564551145,
0.7650946975,
-0.1648626477,
-0.3023376763,
0.4683389664,
-0.6618130207,
-0.2866064906,
0.0523932092,
-0.2723157704,
-0.3780524135,
0.0924495235,
0.3484436274,
-0.2131417543,
0.2432356477,
-0.8583797812,
0.0706735477,
-0.06741523,
0.1353678405,
0.7963747382,
0.2396686375,
0.4681576192,
-0.6026526093,
0.6052630544,
-0.1304362118,
-0.0438522846,
-0.3733037412,
-0.6090769172,
-0.563775301,
-0.4923694432,
0.1629740149,
0.6388458014,
-0.8361113667,
1.1467599869,
0.0090911603,
-0.3914138675,
-0.522400558,
0.1830295324,
0.4487652481,
0.3279457986,
0.4337467253,
-0.1261852384,
-0.4261161983,
-0.9666294456,
-0.6134326458,
-0.3066171706,
-0.0252456199,
0.0889030173,
0.7649897933,
-0.1256440133,
1.2443081141,
-0.7792907953,
-0.4483301044,
-0.6002009511,
0.5094575882,
-0.4433329403,
0.5980377197,
0.4093812108,
-0.9846498966,
-0.8217735291,
-0.0785336494,
-0.7107123733,
-0.2104647458,
-0.6417950392,
-0.0281711128,
0.0661603808,
0.5114258528,
-0.6558428407,
0.464772135,
0.1669925749,
-0.3549889624,
0.7293991446,
-0.1654088795,
0.0678405315,
-1.1450593472,
0.0248542745,
0.2407746613,
-0.2247101665,
-0.4895631671,
0.0613336526,
-0.3178383112,
0.3667791486,
0.0673535541,
0.2424474359,
-0.5118710399,
0.1434974521,
-0.2997319698,
0.0378511176,
0.042903401,
0.3062116504,
0.0521209054,
0.8353571892,
-0.012654759,
-0.1214643568,
0.3380172253,
0.5038721561,
-0.5180307031,
0.5734311938,
-0.5109232664,
0.4516562819,
-0.0226034671,
0.5805416107,
-0.9108422995,
-0.3085538745,
0.3994166851,
-0.5438646674,
-0.1610808522,
0.2635564208,
-0.8270835876,
-0.2711458504,
-0.3636889756,
0.300290525,
0.284065485,
-0.1840242445,
0.5640758872,
0.3705329001,
-0.1942683607,
-0.0443465747,
-0.4778394103,
0.2662057579,
-0.2717583776,
-0.9074261785,
0.5675436258,
-0.0080154352,
-0.428739965,
-0.0561900847,
0.344325453,
-0.0770452023,
0.2106735557,
0.2197523713,
0.1778266132,
-0.0167309325,
-0.3187541366,
0.3673017621,
-0.2063436508,
0.0838597789,
-0.0151653262,
0.4108422995,
0.155907169,
-0.1589129865,
-0.872223556,
0.7134756446,
0.6398147345,
-0.4927598238,
0.6505039334,
0.9590100646,
-0.0872161686,
-0.3300696909,
-0.4002714753,
-0.0618170537,
-0.4187415242,
0.0817421451,
0.0860880837,
-0.9545362592,
0.4365317822,
0.4617828131,
-0.0826729834,
0.494273454,
0.5193989873,
-0.3105574548,
0.7612292171,
0.5355421305,
-0.1763475388,
0.4124269783,
-0.172736153,
0.2370816171,
-0.8603387475,
-0.3451248407,
-0.4706061482,
-0.4631094038,
-0.5927030444,
-0.1978717595,
0.6805853248,
-0.6155183911,
0.1969384849,
0.482583046,
-0.6310091019,
0.581002593,
0.9622691274,
0.216136992,
0.3621712029,
-0.2948290706,
0.0252345745,
0.0401291214,
-0.3518777788,
-0.3663598895,
0.8824598789,
0.0004717698,
0.1496560723,
-0.1206894368,
0.967217803,
0.7919998765,
-0.2372306436,
-0.5679112673,
0.6598914862,
-0.1361249238,
-0.4537705779,
-0.2965580225,
-0.4307996035,
-0.9603062868,
0.0988601521,
-0.4706156552,
-0.6953817606,
-0.2237123549,
-0.0477326959,
-0.5417869687,
0.290294528,
-0.6763412952,
0.9181939363,
-0.292072773,
-0.2095650285,
-0.1307293773,
-0.9355570674,
0.0315320529,
0.0100989472,
-0.0188329332,
0.1590340734,
0.1463688016,
0.9324861169,
-0.4733333886,
0.7141125798,
0.0729599968,
0.1371389776,
0.6320441365,
0.0181451868,
0.3549410403,
-0.1551227272,
0.188744843,
-0.1840175986,
-0.3482637703,
-0.334289372,
-0.1827380955,
0.3305953741,
-0.7065961957,
-0.3402159512,
-0.5568459034,
-0.7785738707,
-0.0464010388,
0.259724766,
0.7557513118,
0.1936753094,
-0.1656406522,
0.1384139955,
0.1596867889,
-0.2003207207,
0.4953288138,
-0.0507629216,
0.2825622559,
-0.3573705852,
1.048430562,
-0.2806633413,
0.0353505164,
0.4855080247,
0.2092159241,
-0.1654182225,
-0.9385687709,
-0.622040391,
0.1521063894,
-0.0799856111,
0.1785620004,
-0.6662639976,
-0.0842374563,
-0.3033690453,
-0.3418096602,
0.0129504334,
-0.0547913834,
-0.6191228032,
0.0930769145,
0.1914276332,
0.7954460382,
0.1107036471,
0.2826479673,
-0.7252899408,
0.2931022942,
-0.1083042175,
-0.2386540473,
-0.1507467777,
-0.0937179402,
-0.0831092894,
-0.188958928,
-0.3485629261,
-0.5267919302,
0.1807345003,
-0.0228896644,
0.3480220735,
0.0480038226,
0.1824677885,
0.3500816524,
-0.2797265947,
1.0176335573,
0.1151759773,
-0.9127418995,
0.45312953,
-0.6037235856,
0.305364579,
0.7490531802,
0.1869832873,
-0.6181491017,
-0.6480221748,
-0.348038435,
-0.7180408239,
0.5981698036,
0.756578207,
0.1209042668,
0.0728410259,
0.271769762,
0.3198084533,
0.2496617287,
-0.7150876522,
-0.0474918336,
0.4360877573,
-0.5421343446,
0.1303578317,
0.0739892423,
0.1682587266,
0.0600796267,
0.3376761973,
-0.1943893433,
0.1112896428,
0.2258353382,
-0.1538280249,
-0.0068773157,
0.0244055204,
0.62349087,
0.2779606581,
0.1200083047,
-0.3086226881,
-0.3330828846,
-0.4326063097,
-0.1309652627,
0.2099683732,
-0.5314631462,
-0.0381671265,
1.1596847773,
0.6082620621,
-0.340326786,
-0.7425525188,
0.7193787098,
0.0825865567,
-0.2087230235,
-0.4643069804,
0.2507597804,
-0.2430436611,
0.1426357329,
0.437466979,
0.4275973737,
0.2168327123,
-0.4369806647,
0.2139651179,
0.502635181,
-0.179867059,
-0.440390408,
0.5354905128,
0.4987158775,
-0.4944473803,
0.766029954,
-0.3269348145,
-0.8521283269,
0.8046045899,
0.1688023657,
0.9394302964,
0.2847856283,
0.4007669985,
-0.1343223155,
0.1276994646,
0.1528580487,
-0.0400891677,
-0.2821153402,
-0.9336913228,
-0.2009730041,
-0.1933147311,
-0.5198030472,
-0.0110497661,
-0.5379553437,
0.2851449549,
-0.3344539702,
0.0789619684,
0.2898781896,
-0.0731101409,
-0.0962649286,
-0.1124907732,
0.3569941223,
0.3849474788,
-0.8791710138,
0.2557969391,
0.5073011518,
-0.3449343741,
-0.5166946054,
0.4540966451,
0.3179114163,
-0.5242706537,
-0.0718582198,
0.3713715076,
-0.2490053475,
-0.047913868,
-0.5819758773,
-0.1351427287,
1.1068618298,
-0.0350280479,
-0.1870482862,
-0.2088169456,
0.2349549234,
0.7279459834,
-0.5304151177,
-0.0381116644,
0.3822167516,
0.4082950056,
-0.1312208921,
-0.9354090691,
-0.1887697577,
-0.1911176741,
-0.3372765481,
0.3016650379,
-0.8754581809,
0.8469668627,
-0.1332718432,
-0.0478077605,
0.5210878253,
0.6981295943,
0.2657491267,
0.748816669,
0.7969241738,
0.3432035148,
0.6039838791,
0.1294483989,
0.993445158,
0.0387283973,
0.0440399088,
0.8941603899,
-0.4994432628,
0.5631994605,
0.3430210352,
-0.0019180045,
1.0830922127,
0.3224825859,
-0.3398831487,
0.1792433113,
0.173607856,
-0.3578896821,
-0.3825165331,
-0.2614732981,
-0.0138906185,
0.7875619531,
-0.0724078193,
-0.4071006477,
0.3363093734,
0.0667727143,
0.1938981265,
0.7064080834,
0.1520936936,
0.9301246405,
-0.1908018142,
-1.0558892488,
-0.2264726311,
0.1236707941,
0.7622315288,
-0.2535513937,
0.1829421222,
0.0062250895,
0.1778785586,
-0.2650913,
-0.9182547331,
0.3033997118,
0.2479858398,
-0.237607196,
-0.3394307494,
0.6471115947,
-0.5826903582,
-0.4746418893,
0.0643262267,
0.4876968861,
-0.1284674555,
-0.2610955238,
-0.4456080794,
0.120656468,
0.1376239061,
0.1479583383,
0.0532574691,
0.2371599227,
-0.0765427053,
0.3097050488,
0.7302624583,
-0.1947653443,
-0.1526515037,
-0.1612838805,
0.6125811934,
-0.3674407303,
-0.7758700848,
-0.9807097316,
0.6077284217,
-0.3771998882,
-0.6188209653,
0.6842389107,
0.9251936674,
0.764526546,
-0.0787588358,
1.1190040112,
-0.2442786694,
0.5097357035,
-0.5822739005,
0.7726506591,
-0.4022950232,
0.2044658959,
-0.3575623631,
-0.5254538059,
-0.3465652764,
0.3593483865,
-0.441893369,
-0.040721707,
0.6610708833,
0.3504857123,
0.0235297456,
0.2419109643,
-0.2289138585,
-0.1813555062,
0.4277526736,
0.5323181748,
1.0414214134,
-0.277431488,
0.590601325,
-0.2322297692,
-0.008200625,
-0.0867541283,
-0.6104519367,
-1.1100451946,
-0.803960979,
-0.5651596785,
-0.1020833179,
-0.2627554238,
0.9449061155,
0.4793910384,
-0.6814084053,
-0.3117714822,
-0.268620193,
0.16042687,
-0.102504313,
-0.2558549047,
0.2529495656,
0.2070905268,
-0.7172971368,
0.516260922,
0.3475543261,
-0.0896568522,
-0.249180004,
-0.0213496387,
-0.4190840125,
-0.0797091275,
0.2570197284,
0.0811406672,
-0.6307410002,
-0.3952096701,
0.1989827007,
-0.0370476507,
0.0300102085,
1.0811475515,
-0.5115092397,
0.366071701,
0.5167960525,
0.6136298776,
0.3362104893,
0.3856827319,
0.6643301249,
-0.8335914016,
-0.1764437109,
0.5175976157,
0.1444831192,
0.5133286715,
-0.5709811449,
0.2838633358,
0.6894162893,
-0.6011838913,
-0.644726634,
0.2848218381,
-1.1209369898,
-0.1279554516,
1.0144348145,
-0.1465494484,
-0.0525245816,
-0.1455947757,
-0.4321668446,
0.0527744591,
-0.4188991189,
0.6451573372,
0.6619940996,
-0.6097250581,
-0.0035815898,
0.313256532,
0.4232752919,
0.2427631021,
-0.9760590196,
-0.1044043899,
0.6913677454,
-0.0268252734,
0.5215750933,
0.6205863953,
0.3160366714,
0.3368471265,
0.0092632016,
-0.283521384,
-0.2564049661,
-0.430203706,
0.1053731516,
0.2249846309,
-0.4466042519,
-0.3453953862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03496v1
|
A Knowledge Plug-and-Play Test Bed for Open-domain Dialogue Generation
| 2024-03-06T06:54:02 | 2024-03-06T06:54:02 |
Xiangci Li, Linfeng Song, Lifeng Jin, Haitao Mi, Jessica Ouyang, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge-based, open-domain dialogue generation aims to build chit-chat
systems that talk to humans using mined support knowledge. Many types and
sources of knowledge have previously been shown to be useful as support
knowledge. Even in the era of large language models, response generation
grounded in knowledge retrieved from additional up-to-date sources remains a
practically important approach. While prior work using single-source knowledge
has shown a clear positive correlation between the performances of knowledge
selection and response generation, there are no existing multi-source datasets
for evaluating support knowledge retrieval. Further, prior work has assumed
that the knowledge sources available at test time are the same as during
training. This unrealistic assumption unnecessarily handicaps models, as new
knowledge sources can become available after a model is trained. In this paper,
we present a high-quality benchmark named multi-source Wizard of Wikipedia
(Ms.WoW) for evaluating multi-source dialogue knowledge selection and response
generation. Unlike existing datasets, it contains clean support knowledge,
grounded at the utterance level and partitioned into multiple knowledge
sources. We further propose a new challenge, dialogue knowledge plug-and-play,
which aims to test an already trained dialogue model on using new support
knowledge from previously unseen sources in a zero-shot fashion.
|
[
-0.7433705926,
-0.6749308109,
0.3380708992,
0.1427726001,
0.092405878,
-0.0375099741,
-0.2350066006,
-0.1620478183,
-0.138140291,
0.5800175071,
-0.7532317638,
-0.0957126468,
-0.1748098135,
0.0244125836,
-0.1821951121,
0.9332100749,
0.0824006721,
0.087652199,
-0.5399939418,
-0.1945997477,
-0.6627317667,
-0.3529985845,
-0.3514938951,
-0.1626805812,
0.4100069106,
0.4026525319,
0.5980367661,
-0.1870472431,
0.1464146972,
0.2378562391,
0.1293504834,
0.3809192777,
-0.5444058776,
0.2820827365,
-0.1082247719,
-0.1052960753,
-0.2359354347,
0.0859833434,
0.2771954834,
0.4410695732,
-0.19893305,
0.1509934962,
0.0890263319,
0.1929697245,
-0.6464995146,
0.3038726151,
-0.9185784459,
0.0255384035,
0.1335763931,
-0.2743317485,
-0.534254849,
-0.54114151,
0.3473413885,
-0.8515013456,
0.3090640604,
0.1810989827,
0.6613652706,
0.1404690892,
-0.5105144978,
-0.1932816207,
-0.7759571075,
0.631462276,
-0.7731113434,
0.4711188078,
0.156705454,
0.7933028936,
-0.5245910883,
-0.4707354903,
-1.0226745605,
-0.2128641605,
-0.0128911873,
0.2337391675,
-0.0047138622,
-0.2143643349,
0.2698715925,
0.3066238165,
-0.3955444396,
-0.5379008651,
-0.3877570033,
-0.2807110846,
0.3688162267,
-0.186626941,
0.1260342747,
-0.2417426258,
-0.3590453267,
-0.1233853996,
-0.7111980319,
-0.1451024711,
0.4003202617,
0.5190075636,
0.14108935,
0.7474957108,
-0.2382666171,
0.721108377,
-0.1576801986,
-0.3214863837,
0.1773140281,
-0.4090011716,
-0.190855056,
-0.0781949013,
0.9098971486,
0.1692440361,
0.2759836018,
-0.031207813,
0.4239841998,
-0.1147466674,
0.4370487332,
-0.6958774924,
-0.1313192844,
-0.0757054016,
-0.227955386,
-0.1931665689,
-0.2362183928,
-0.842882514,
-0.567486763,
-0.0903807878,
0.4436247051,
-0.7053824067,
-0.6466702223,
0.0079408614,
-0.2865349948,
0.2464250326,
0.4756374955,
-0.4947528243,
0.2381066531,
0.2939271033,
0.5882806182,
-0.0395145938,
-0.1821598113,
-0.7327033877,
0.1152292266,
-0.2903030813,
0.9359841347,
-0.2396238595,
-0.4800980687,
0.2023200095,
-0.1872814298,
-0.0340551659,
-0.4378119707,
0.4143846333,
-0.6051124334,
0.7612166405,
-0.1189553291,
-0.4985878468,
0.0005112529,
0.2641150057,
-0.5219647288,
0.8589574695,
0.4636929631,
-0.8953993917,
0.40038234,
-0.6759655476,
-0.235216856,
0.0179847945,
-0.4568921328,
-0.1222608835,
-0.1019402295,
0.0718576461,
0.0963016078,
-0.4047025442,
0.1180545837,
-0.5639126301,
-0.0638021454,
0.2717958093,
-0.4724259973,
0.6314565539,
0.1214773431,
-0.3493099809,
-0.2221542299,
-0.9212755561,
0.2909246087,
0.1286798269,
-0.4018248916,
-0.312872529,
0.1260139793,
-0.3072344661,
0.5194395781,
-0.3310833573,
-0.8198134303,
0.0047820928,
-0.3016706705,
-0.0282647368,
0.5700867772,
0.2238120735,
-0.0225956608,
-0.0482429378,
0.3338432312,
0.1780784577,
0.1584990025,
-0.3186690211,
-0.8458086252,
-0.7051701546,
-0.0319144167,
0.1904677302,
0.408287853,
-0.9698512554,
0.4389276803,
0.0009303536,
-0.3229398429,
-0.6752179861,
-0.011696591,
0.3234136701,
0.7669069767,
0.5309180617,
-0.3906300664,
-0.2867404521,
-0.7900381088,
-0.2042140812,
-0.3862518966,
-0.3993639946,
0.7763223052,
0.0283973385,
0.0740228668,
1.1809374094,
-0.81025666,
-0.0731489882,
0.1121345535,
0.1489586085,
-0.2405341566,
0.1375418007,
0.2767308652,
-0.5096070766,
-0.527533412,
0.0779882297,
-0.7184726596,
0.1160258129,
0.2538663447,
-0.4410087168,
0.0564674847,
0.2302987725,
-0.7409328818,
0.3493534625,
0.5247063041,
-0.3684535921,
0.680845499,
0.1262518317,
0.5381899476,
-1.1969543695,
0.1844653189,
-0.3172465861,
-0.0679033995,
-0.5213044286,
-0.1559977382,
0.0135163907,
-0.3455740809,
-0.5263207555,
0.5408778787,
-0.1261931211,
0.0340537131,
-0.0909739733,
0.3710927963,
0.121254243,
0.6728860736,
0.0364012271,
0.9002557397,
0.2952000201,
-0.5719251037,
0.5618954301,
0.6260737777,
-0.5030537248,
0.7552366853,
-0.4973330498,
0.3781137466,
0.1324002743,
0.1714408547,
-1.2049628496,
-0.3208244741,
0.1006987989,
-0.5508159399,
0.0961826071,
-0.0637680963,
-0.5172708035,
-0.4588892162,
-0.0096370708,
0.1916055977,
0.4356958568,
-0.5793220401,
0.4446202517,
0.3028691411,
-0.2214578092,
-0.6818549633,
-0.02347387,
-0.3046346307,
-0.0376362912,
-0.7415569425,
-0.0492057651,
-0.4468377531,
-0.0924912989,
-0.0946105123,
-0.1894125193,
-0.124268122,
-0.1236380562,
0.0957385227,
0.2127175331,
-0.3368223608,
0.2301958948,
0.0646105409,
0.1795972735,
0.1072604656,
-0.3200126588,
0.4983009994,
0.3376528025,
-0.7041782737,
0.3132549524,
0.4794535935,
0.4924630225,
-0.256547451,
0.6215239167,
0.4340384603,
-0.062098857,
-0.2946548164,
-0.7597453594,
-0.1245885566,
-0.4475613534,
-0.0112637011,
-0.3315621614,
-0.9042293429,
0.2086300254,
-0.353528589,
0.4148719609,
0.3561526835,
0.5623531938,
0.1098816171,
0.9702390432,
0.4192876518,
0.2251064479,
0.2252439559,
0.124487415,
0.4574138224,
-0.5176986456,
-0.3106472492,
-0.6639795303,
0.2135250866,
-0.2123124152,
-0.5662782788,
0.4687658548,
0.1407731175,
-0.235732317,
0.4220552146,
-0.1897060871,
0.2686426342,
0.6610588431,
0.0361214243,
0.5833125114,
-0.0028376281,
-0.4843528867,
0.0812978223,
-0.5502832532,
-0.1810761392,
1.0815684795,
0.002217802,
0.6167548895,
0.2164602727,
0.2226799279,
0.1255624443,
0.0794846565,
-0.5915641785,
0.4330256283,
0.4417833388,
-0.6870062947,
-0.4307623506,
-0.5325666666,
-0.7171370387,
0.3009103537,
-0.1623725295,
-0.4640902281,
-0.0704204589,
0.04042935,
-0.4918743074,
0.1908765435,
-0.9547224641,
0.7868195772,
0.3279024065,
-0.1481876671,
-0.1313769221,
-0.5083308816,
0.7427377105,
-0.0367673598,
0.2152643949,
-0.1086386293,
0.6073662639,
0.2947349548,
-0.3563506901,
0.5331456065,
-0.2937045097,
-0.2122897357,
0.4588784277,
0.1472923309,
0.1483803093,
0.2273471057,
0.1386812329,
-0.1327593327,
-0.0338049196,
-0.3448977172,
-0.7423590422,
0.6303886175,
-0.9697756171,
-0.5158329606,
-0.0593498498,
-0.4980368912,
-0.9313068986,
0.1526666582,
0.1153904796,
0.4203424156,
-0.4848025739,
0.102279827,
0.9418299198,
-0.5993981361,
0.0039807418,
0.7284759283,
-0.2833115757,
-0.4799958766,
0.7126584053,
-0.1691512167,
0.4927236736,
0.0953152254,
0.1093089357,
-0.2293245047,
0.1173120737,
-0.7769046426,
-0.0838133469,
-0.5379050374,
-0.4492853582,
-0.7373477221,
-0.561170578,
-0.6869900227,
0.3132786751,
-0.3160352409,
-0.5097008348,
0.1157038808,
-0.1250112504,
0.4135698676,
0.6565603018,
0.1682640016,
-0.1032607928,
-0.747012794,
0.4347303212,
0.8505379558,
0.6653079391,
0.0429261439,
-0.0673489943,
-0.4429585338,
-0.0433742516,
-0.7781210542,
-1.0652229786,
0.0004965395,
0.1180082336,
0.8083848357,
0.3202775717,
0.283449769,
0.4977366328,
-0.8965508342,
1.0976225138,
0.3362227678,
-0.5786741376,
0.6512090564,
-0.3431355655,
0.2813356221,
0.4453921318,
0.323974669,
-0.5393279195,
-0.6305907965,
-0.7838250995,
-0.4479445517,
0.8260386586,
0.2904101312,
0.1888610572,
-0.2027872056,
-0.168223381,
0.4698559344,
0.5853768587,
-0.2990015447,
-0.2272954285,
-0.5050388575,
0.2515872121,
0.0367857628,
0.0990870595,
-0.5594403148,
-0.112201862,
0.7048674822,
-0.368601948,
0.5786708593,
0.0453817174,
0.0648875535,
-0.4355880916,
0.4628441334,
0.4053418934,
0.6138976216,
-0.1599573344,
-0.1428241879,
0.05994666,
-0.3001055121,
-0.0356977582,
0.131524533,
0.0097156828,
0.2121388912,
0.0143527919,
0.8896385431,
0.2365858555,
-0.6338809729,
0.6393428445,
-0.2607987821,
-0.3521871567,
-0.223539874,
0.3854291737,
0.0937005877,
0.1997719556,
0.2721259594,
0.279063195,
0.0255263802,
-0.5456156135,
0.329300791,
0.6124446988,
-0.3498648405,
-0.101409927,
0.4072349072,
0.3184774518,
-0.2936609089,
0.5480063558,
-0.2502391934,
-0.1577756554,
0.0784676597,
0.3488128781,
0.7404369712,
-0.3193472624,
0.521099925,
0.4774636328,
-0.1827883571,
0.2424289137,
0.3567514718,
-0.1787974536,
-0.7984496951,
-0.5397719741,
-0.4722844362,
-0.7224238515,
0.4166882038,
-0.5568806529,
0.3505989015,
-0.0671582371,
0.0195446964,
-0.172854349,
-0.0718372315,
-0.9087020159,
-0.1035860181,
-0.1017076373,
1.2235165834,
-0.6073403358,
0.7859090567,
0.3532348573,
-0.4370078743,
-0.8611069322,
0.1665991694,
0.0809868798,
-0.6971437931,
0.2836721838,
-0.1353664994,
0.0773269087,
-0.0793514922,
-0.5972912312,
-0.7433796525,
1.0461587906,
0.3852259517,
0.050247062,
-0.1502991468,
0.0329625346,
0.452963084,
-0.3377964199,
0.7173464298,
0.4396760762,
0.1692081094,
0.4206461012,
-1.2128685713,
-0.1583985686,
-0.3052289188,
-0.0684918016,
0.0130837252,
-0.5919002891,
0.8012590408,
0.0457187593,
-0.0448076501,
-0.0410221964,
0.5805796981,
0.5002034903,
0.0338638648,
0.6155429482,
0.4032735825,
0.5615553856,
0.0767095014,
0.6615927815,
-0.3049433529,
0.1989869028,
1.0596321821,
-0.4181566536,
0.9291976094,
0.3768355846,
-0.213725403,
0.8414464593,
0.2484734654,
0.269387275,
0.7337719798,
0.3190656304,
-0.5928454995,
-0.1818181723,
-0.2502533793,
-0.5824025273,
0.2284026593,
0.1877917498,
0.0534707755,
-0.5572372079,
-0.0109239705,
-0.0979227945,
-0.0806450695,
0.1683505177,
1.115278244,
-0.0713628307,
-0.9938210845,
0.575913012,
-0.350209713,
0.3688336015,
-0.933797121,
-0.4113409221,
-0.3112556934,
-0.0036928391,
-0.0130856717,
-0.5621110201,
0.0091810925,
0.0921829045,
-0.1382754445,
0.0324922949,
0.9467472434,
-0.5896161199,
-0.0859942585,
0.3999895453,
0.9354383349,
0.0815685615,
-0.1986301541,
-0.3025755882,
-0.2824214697,
-0.0270898733,
-0.3314267695,
0.5914999843,
0.6949046254,
0.1476778835,
0.3341698349,
0.6878777742,
0.0668422282,
0.2088768035,
0.1525424123,
1.239269495,
-0.2568624318,
-0.3659256995,
-0.1698499769,
0.740191102,
-0.4210441709,
-0.2802001536,
0.9047182202,
0.5072910786,
0.9015238881,
-0.1039504036,
1.2369372845,
-0.208034128,
0.9116578102,
-0.1708634794,
0.5790406466,
-0.3502778709,
-0.1512161493,
-0.5299454927,
-0.8368729353,
0.2370685786,
0.3464089632,
0.1148309186,
-0.0957958922,
0.8510987759,
0.7966455221,
-0.2195826173,
0.4370790422,
0.5292374492,
0.0770183802,
0.3814761043,
0.3894761503,
0.9652995467,
-0.333562851,
0.9720352292,
-0.0881712213,
-0.4427627325,
0.1624330282,
-0.6940707564,
-0.9765655398,
-0.7320095897,
-0.0689972714,
-0.7334802747,
-0.1407539696,
0.7679652572,
0.701064527,
-1.0189431906,
-0.1960584521,
0.0839419663,
0.0666418374,
-0.3035995364,
-0.257879436,
-0.0438562445,
-0.7187133431,
-0.4440692365,
0.6798692346,
0.0839151368,
-0.2221179903,
-0.6794653535,
-0.1164719686,
-0.116054371,
0.2468381375,
0.7258890271,
0.370860517,
-0.5080976486,
-0.4477620125,
0.3639032543,
0.0430081449,
0.0005491317,
1.0910527706,
-1.0280913115,
0.6062420607,
0.4534496963,
0.6678958535,
0.3851648569,
-0.2022749782,
1.0697342157,
-1.0771484375,
-0.1630659848,
0.0335935168,
0.2238601744,
0.2402296811,
-0.1235970929,
0.4052258134,
0.3001893163,
-0.6017410159,
-0.7004842162,
0.3373221755,
-0.6379067302,
-0.1555479318,
1.1324654818,
-0.4196940958,
0.1795830876,
-0.4042053223,
-0.4496906996,
0.3532165289,
-0.4905132353,
0.870911181,
0.9039543867,
-0.1203511134,
-0.109966293,
-0.7705946565,
0.769818306,
0.0822566301,
-0.8809149861,
0.2446208149,
0.7060559988,
0.1575254649,
0.5565644503,
0.8981359601,
-0.0587963313,
0.1118098348,
0.162635684,
0.1390468329,
0.0254404619,
-0.4051238894,
0.1741504073,
0.3124419749,
0.0538386256,
-0.1261665672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03481v1
|
Magic Markup: Maintaining Document-External Markup with an LLM
| 2024-03-06T05:40:31 | 2024-03-06T05:40:31 |
Edward Misback, Zachary Tatlock, Steven L. Tanimoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text documents, including programs, typically have human-readable semantic
structure. Historically, programmatic access to these semantics has required
explicit in-document tagging. Especially in systems where the text has an
execution semantics, this means it is an opt-in feature that is hard to support
properly. Today, language models offer a new method: metadata can be bound to
entities in changing text using a model's human-like understanding of
semantics, with no requirements on the document structure. This method expands
the applications of document annotation, a fundamental operation in program
writing, debugging, maintenance, and presentation. We contribute a system that
employs an intelligent agent to re-tag modified programs, enabling rich
annotations to automatically follow code as it evolves. We also contribute a
formal problem definition, an empirical synthetic benchmark suite, and our
benchmark generator. Our system achieves an accuracy of 90% on our benchmarks
and can replace a document's tags in parallel at a rate of 5 seconds per tag.
While there remains significant room for improvement, we find performance
reliable enough to justify further exploration of applications.
|
[
-0.2845920324,
-0.4717807472,
0.5199406743,
0.138262108,
-0.0513377376,
0.3734505475,
-0.2919487357,
-0.7175577879,
0.1593690515,
0.6940329075,
-0.4277767837,
-0.651769042,
-0.5122011304,
0.1779334843,
-0.2632619143,
1.0200195312,
-0.3049833477,
-0.1803995371,
-0.2968456149,
-0.0001205802,
-0.5463719964,
-0.3769730031,
-0.4413416386,
-0.5943416357,
0.434677422,
0.3819930851,
0.9761224389,
1.2104091644,
0.9753215313,
0.3198998868,
0.5179795027,
0.5475655198,
0.0145099359,
0.154591158,
-0.2935120463,
-0.6317059994,
-0.8115358353,
0.3195561171,
0.642582655,
0.6037921309,
0.1679020226,
0.1263595074,
-0.196122691,
0.4946886301,
-0.6083471775,
0.5502901673,
-0.7628250122,
0.0334088542,
-0.2241404653,
-0.6916570067,
-0.4594302177,
-0.3772529364,
-0.2975777686,
-1.095033288,
0.0182968937,
0.2057766467,
1.0258395672,
0.5069929957,
-0.0802099481,
-0.4297843575,
-0.6668598652,
0.7002121806,
-0.4968113601,
0.2479373366,
0.6978504062,
0.1645373553,
-0.5138565302,
-1.0152621269,
-0.5914069414,
-0.5966690779,
-0.1288234442,
0.0458633974,
-0.0213200152,
0.1440778077,
0.4554015696,
0.3243834972,
-0.200311482,
0.0296528842,
-0.0163995866,
-0.14452748,
0.6627939939,
0.3505164087,
0.7351371646,
0.265443325,
-0.3201046288,
-0.0316714011,
-0.5683079958,
-0.5377985239,
0.4422706962,
0.0891929343,
0.5131085515,
0.702098906,
-0.0567529202,
0.7199491858,
-0.3283316195,
-0.2593274415,
0.1617237628,
-0.2608762383,
-0.5001720786,
0.0234048329,
0.4567627013,
0.6569310427,
0.4745523036,
-0.3393214345,
-0.3185308576,
0.3153758347,
0.4136639833,
-0.4305600524,
-0.5383223891,
-0.0807038099,
-0.114199698,
-0.140370816,
0.15080899,
-0.1523475349,
-0.7761160135,
-0.8331874013,
0.372885406,
-0.7268348932,
-0.008428867,
-0.1109893173,
-0.4116359353,
0.178585887,
0.632841289,
-0.9484939575,
0.3417791724,
0.986900568,
0.6693728566,
0.0627230033,
-0.4336828589,
-0.3075836301,
0.5548252463,
-0.5272700787,
1.0079923868,
-0.8683710098,
-0.3661076725,
-0.2849162817,
0.0872223079,
0.0282821432,
-0.5375777483,
0.6085777283,
-0.6644665599,
0.0589296706,
-0.216510728,
-0.7992129922,
-0.0765322298,
0.4260360301,
-0.4502678812,
1.2050738335,
0.1074414775,
-0.7104110718,
0.4672103524,
-0.9457492232,
-0.1701809913,
0.0596395694,
-0.15019162,
-0.1583338231,
0.0706080124,
-0.1614318043,
0.1761707515,
-0.0747750252,
-0.0490311421,
-0.136628449,
-0.5862096548,
0.2784662545,
-0.0915762633,
0.273444593,
0.2436177582,
-0.1406192183,
0.137128368,
-0.9780287743,
-0.0375544988,
0.3045840561,
-0.7217000723,
-0.7322057486,
0.1472650021,
0.0623207577,
0.080394119,
0.4403571188,
-0.4224879146,
0.9670407772,
-0.461895138,
0.0751384795,
0.714317441,
-0.1912697405,
0.5415305495,
-0.5382578969,
0.3416169584,
-0.3993604779,
0.0181809254,
-0.6082555056,
-0.4054200053,
-0.8384112716,
-0.4383398592,
0.2923543453,
0.6664196253,
-0.5788860917,
0.3697770834,
-0.26744771,
-0.4382920861,
-0.5904379487,
0.2770748436,
0.3849449456,
0.4446460009,
0.3611874282,
-0.2526454926,
-0.439363122,
-0.9411782622,
-0.3373033702,
-0.1255554706,
-0.1189368665,
0.0779154375,
0.4356950819,
-0.4640966654,
1.2324546576,
-0.7126243711,
-0.3147072196,
0.0173923355,
0.3810833991,
-0.0571121089,
0.5565131903,
0.2081810087,
-0.743740797,
-0.4781655967,
0.1506070346,
-0.6988748312,
-0.7239242196,
-0.3320479393,
-0.2024180293,
0.4808782339,
0.5971516967,
-0.4029376209,
0.4149453342,
0.0455544107,
-0.2458817214,
0.4753623307,
-0.619732976,
0.1514408737,
-0.85578686,
0.1700048894,
-0.0949065462,
-0.1495942324,
-0.4745731652,
0.3088691533,
0.2482127398,
0.031510409,
-0.2043284476,
0.6627206206,
-0.6908854246,
-0.1095184609,
-0.6882382631,
0.2608062029,
0.3242729604,
0.2433899492,
-0.1236616299,
0.7071686983,
0.1000116393,
-0.3095854819,
0.4942722023,
-0.000509477,
0.1059948355,
0.6599170566,
-0.2694091797,
0.2583907247,
-0.1566096246,
0.1307887882,
-0.8569646478,
-0.2718967497,
0.5862930417,
-0.2998746634,
0.7742573619,
-0.1492213905,
-1.1699640751,
-0.019851096,
-0.4427750409,
-0.3256807923,
0.2952388525,
-0.3355247676,
0.7537449002,
0.2668124139,
0.1601445824,
-0.4146529138,
-0.6628593206,
0.6460303664,
-0.0389793813,
-0.6619654298,
0.5750031471,
-0.1414057314,
-0.5672680736,
0.1500809491,
-0.0706184208,
0.0162563995,
0.4246397316,
0.5334364176,
0.2468814999,
0.025692068,
0.4612447023,
-0.1084706336,
-0.6026774049,
-0.0051502925,
-0.3707549274,
0.2542286515,
-0.080422312,
-0.5661548376,
-0.2657820284,
0.4075101316,
0.4120782912,
-0.4574764371,
0.5424473286,
0.6251518726,
-0.5636236072,
-0.3068392873,
-0.4194730222,
0.240883559,
-0.4926989675,
0.0166712049,
-0.4704118967,
-0.260633409,
0.3749993145,
-0.1933491826,
0.2080215812,
0.3940936029,
0.3711398244,
-0.2321635187,
0.7314049602,
0.9230189323,
0.1401420087,
0.6878442168,
-0.0582196191,
0.0221868884,
-0.7492395639,
-0.2276444286,
-0.4414413869,
-0.2763031125,
-0.4489542842,
-0.4686534405,
-0.0517648831,
0.2526615262,
0.0754985958,
0.321362704,
-0.7971504331,
0.6321358681,
0.7937670946,
-0.3629696369,
0.6198116541,
-0.1910060346,
-0.1040765569,
-0.1919271499,
-0.1636661291,
-0.967684269,
0.8068557382,
0.4260987043,
1.0533484221,
-0.1493777931,
0.7238900661,
0.4765716195,
0.827496767,
-0.7239117026,
0.6676996946,
0.1726132035,
-0.4130765498,
0.0063206311,
0.0585562289,
-0.7825867534,
0.1068946496,
-0.1815281212,
-0.8923812509,
-0.3220394254,
0.2438201755,
0.0899692252,
0.3022318482,
-0.9992440939,
0.6494053602,
-0.1674335897,
-0.4236292541,
0.0936919972,
-0.5393819213,
0.0749932379,
-0.270349592,
0.0334360339,
-0.314165771,
-0.4631481469,
0.5203462243,
-0.6402660608,
0.6981495023,
0.0624241009,
-0.2625778317,
0.1611420065,
0.2567696571,
0.6131333709,
-0.3167161047,
-0.0255832169,
-0.14428927,
0.1759888977,
-0.1466493756,
-0.8752709031,
0.7370343804,
-0.4855153263,
-0.7032717466,
-0.667576313,
-0.7534748912,
-0.0204205792,
0.2584681511,
-0.2306007147,
0.3014757037,
0.2225154489,
-0.2015328854,
0.5193797946,
-0.1584323794,
0.5976092219,
0.6907582879,
-0.3281030953,
-0.0920723304,
0.9410916567,
0.330317229,
0.0468128622,
0.5977498889,
0.0906608924,
-0.0721892044,
-0.5661943555,
-0.3480353057,
0.1452594399,
-0.9516616464,
-0.1460300535,
-0.7348707914,
0.0182383824,
-0.1175512895,
-0.5467760563,
-0.1921353936,
-0.3915926516,
-0.4393677413,
0.0168016274,
0.3902873695,
0.7943484187,
0.0942241326,
0.128820464,
-0.9446587563,
0.1266958117,
-0.1525227726,
0.4955416024,
-0.3611607254,
-0.1830001771,
-0.4244998693,
-0.2551090419,
-0.352062881,
-0.9035064578,
0.3033597469,
0.1232098341,
0.5959088206,
0.0515216477,
0.0259537213,
0.4440737367,
-0.6059240103,
0.6717630029,
-0.2272434235,
-0.8853365779,
0.7108510733,
-0.5066275001,
0.2860970497,
0.3916625679,
0.2285924852,
-0.615981102,
-0.4957066774,
-0.4978970289,
-0.7487646341,
0.5142883062,
0.0161405541,
0.0305983946,
-0.0695937127,
0.367549032,
-0.0818824992,
0.2007228732,
-0.4419271648,
-0.2903204262,
-0.0409450531,
-0.2918576002,
0.1542148292,
-0.0748522058,
-0.191202417,
0.007180261,
0.7330618501,
-0.3575670719,
0.2033340633,
0.1198132113,
-0.3025945723,
0.0064327233,
0.3183149993,
0.6898990273,
0.8320841789,
-0.3450657129,
0.4323295355,
0.0720934495,
-0.5765092373,
-0.0987675339,
0.2817719877,
-0.0242381673,
-0.0801898092,
0.4526334107,
0.2448703647,
0.2221320719,
-0.6075073481,
0.1544653028,
0.0670611188,
0.1772394925,
-0.401019603,
0.3109026849,
0.0812957585,
0.0983578041,
0.3395702839,
-0.0228767116,
0.0670375153,
-0.594979763,
0.1938092709,
0.4074153602,
-0.2481112927,
-0.11338038,
0.5606359839,
0.0663725063,
-0.5929663777,
0.2165794522,
-0.3943299353,
-0.3760545552,
0.5908176899,
0.6724348068,
0.7293404937,
0.1267383099,
-0.105243817,
-0.2685129046,
0.533100009,
0.1631008089,
0.2737377882,
0.0153346099,
-0.5731580257,
-0.2218474448,
-0.610901475,
-0.5718544126,
-0.2376384437,
-0.1797465682,
0.3770941496,
-0.6247546673,
-0.2444701046,
0.1774853319,
0.4098994434,
-0.4604696929,
0.4016067088,
0.2440070212,
1.2183734179,
-0.6203132868,
1.0463154316,
1.0149992704,
-0.7136362791,
-0.6084218025,
-0.1061948165,
0.0723976567,
-0.6400334239,
0.8155595064,
0.0342928395,
-0.0934185982,
0.0179241244,
-0.4913916886,
-0.807076335,
1.1536027193,
0.2655780017,
-0.185896486,
0.0819986537,
0.0727077574,
0.6767753363,
-0.3566614091,
0.3383379281,
0.641828835,
0.8747717142,
-0.0644175038,
-0.7979466319,
0.1384462267,
-0.4630120695,
0.1260810047,
0.4009406269,
-0.3614484072,
0.4101919532,
-0.0208311975,
-0.3414077461,
-0.1447255611,
0.4238963127,
0.0188189968,
0.5231236815,
0.0410377681,
0.6689732075,
0.8664146066,
-0.3491282165,
1.3506531715,
-0.5428009629,
0.1158775613,
1.3053328991,
-0.2408488691,
0.5507274866,
0.411653161,
-0.1281449795,
0.3540940583,
0.590808928,
-0.4232616425,
0.1387441307,
0.4286416471,
-0.2432443947,
-0.0242039058,
-0.4961530268,
-0.4137912691,
0.3665587008,
0.4661352038,
-0.5827638507,
-0.1859547645,
-0.2912505865,
0.5175848603,
0.299439013,
-0.2100277096,
0.616216898,
-0.0199096352,
-0.4254445434,
0.015786292,
0.5291185379,
0.6513906717,
-0.7070440054,
-0.3050919771,
-0.0693558902,
0.2035461366,
-0.4962376952,
-0.8059896231,
0.5687218308,
-0.2899261713,
-0.3349196613,
-0.3627741635,
1.1819797754,
-0.2469003648,
-0.3513059914,
0.1125065982,
0.2704876363,
0.0109669929,
0.0565752909,
-0.5864834785,
0.3603785634,
-0.4946597219,
-0.1928790808,
0.3528460562,
0.3604733348,
-0.2205469757,
0.7943711281,
0.8421917558,
0.0754530728,
0.1696358323,
0.0274916496,
0.9855684042,
-0.6142067909,
-0.4382016063,
-0.9503912926,
0.5108991861,
-0.1742141843,
-0.0193038378,
1.0175318718,
0.5219931602,
0.6786891818,
0.0186147988,
0.7905308008,
0.2103595734,
0.0484186485,
-0.4809288979,
0.8562016487,
-0.3661730587,
0.3005244434,
-0.5259761214,
-0.9902623892,
-0.7481427789,
0.3921231627,
-0.465075165,
-0.1244257614,
0.7129563093,
0.8853990436,
0.1309378296,
-0.2272317857,
0.3098903,
-0.256698519,
0.5501564145,
0.2707740068,
0.8795056939,
-0.2277743369,
0.1961500794,
0.0145993466,
-0.3071308434,
-0.230068922,
-1.3043416739,
-0.6461434364,
-0.5069295764,
-0.605409205,
-0.3972535729,
-0.0256830752,
1.2618433237,
0.5854436755,
-0.3870552778,
0.2439960688,
0.2489797175,
0.2691276371,
-0.0396893136,
-0.2549163103,
0.2745302618,
-0.4904074967,
-0.7736686468,
0.2940509319,
0.8325894475,
0.1094842851,
-0.2551745176,
0.1884189546,
-0.213440448,
0.3410091698,
0.3660617769,
0.4399479032,
-0.599986732,
-0.4771262109,
-0.2452718318,
-0.3539875746,
0.1795669943,
0.8306990862,
-0.5915862322,
0.6855623722,
0.4397210181,
0.8362029791,
-0.0000083388,
0.0677991658,
0.3885775805,
-0.7630899549,
-0.254280746,
-0.0974915475,
0.370937407,
0.4996182323,
-0.3920620084,
0.6279905438,
0.5634478331,
-0.490362674,
-0.6261848211,
0.1168036386,
-0.8855112195,
-0.257065028,
1.0668817759,
-0.2588959038,
-0.2831520438,
-0.1955069005,
-0.5531587005,
0.2869354188,
-0.315081954,
0.6051533818,
0.7663000822,
-0.2884083092,
-0.0306696165,
-0.5996540785,
0.558161974,
-0.2543000281,
-1.0904310942,
-0.0659059361,
0.6405596733,
0.3881418109,
0.5837007165,
0.8670232892,
0.0007924164,
-0.1280639321,
0.1880271733,
0.4196677208,
-0.7126503587,
-0.2731634676,
-0.1292235553,
0.2102680653,
0.1917028278,
-0.3253405094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03435v1
|
VLSP 2023 -- LTER: A Summary of the Challenge on Legal Textual Entailment Recognition
| 2024-03-06T03:42:06 | 2024-03-06T03:42:06 |
Vu Tran, Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Trung Vo, Son T. Luu, Hoang-Anh Dang, Ngoc-Cam Le, Thi-Thuy Le, Minh-Tien Nguyen, Truong-Son Nguyen, Le-Minh Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this new era of rapid AI development, especially in language processing,
the demand for AI in the legal domain is increasingly critical. In the context
where research in other languages such as English, Japanese, and Chinese has
been well-established, we introduce the first fundamental research for the
Vietnamese language in the legal domain: legal textual entailment recognition
through the Vietnamese Language and Speech Processing workshop. In analyzing
participants' results, we discuss certain linguistic aspects critical in the
legal domain that pose challenges that need to be addressed.
|
[
-0.0922670662,
-0.83205235,
0.8013012409,
0.0383342728,
-0.2719566822,
-0.2173874378,
-0.0543469489,
-0.8262632489,
-0.0985466242,
1.1933732033,
-0.259080708,
-0.3451394141,
-0.6827604771,
0.1940589547,
-0.4274043143,
0.6195511818,
-0.3261400461,
-0.1961333603,
-0.2704160213,
-0.5295119286,
-0.6738290787,
-0.7305207253,
-0.8200373054,
-0.2510480881,
0.1334094107,
0.1871498525,
0.2396967411,
0.8164103031,
0.7339857817,
0.3759929538,
0.0579330064,
-0.0526782759,
-0.1562340558,
0.3966704905,
0.0334407017,
-0.5629336238,
-0.3639832735,
-0.0533602387,
0.5559284687,
0.298361063,
-0.0154536963,
-0.0801994503,
-0.3680051565,
0.8336538076,
-0.5684354305,
0.1291563511,
-0.7239712477,
0.1806036532,
-0.3760062158,
-0.5177643299,
-0.468000859,
-0.0855377465,
0.4926071763,
-0.7091405392,
0.1555052996,
-0.0848862752,
1.074416399,
0.686275661,
-0.6692126989,
-0.3852208853,
-0.7024644613,
0.3280683458,
-0.4908490777,
0.4688916802,
0.6226391792,
0.3788613379,
0.0527420267,
-1.0449769497,
-0.6815317273,
-0.3452376127,
0.0349540375,
0.198882997,
-0.3483214974,
0.1477912366,
0.3109797835,
0.0402749553,
-0.6472069025,
0.2490251064,
-0.4789626598,
-0.3088452816,
0.7189011574,
0.1684021056,
0.3619863987,
0.0381630212,
0.0407330729,
0.3918409646,
-0.6847310066,
-0.0344193801,
0.1027379185,
-0.0307841767,
-0.0862664729,
0.8325554729,
-0.1436192095,
0.591499567,
-0.312903434,
0.0565665141,
0.4225488901,
-0.5094069242,
-0.2987168729,
0.2623585463,
0.7447874546,
0.1745891869,
0.2864364982,
0.3114883006,
-0.2268456966,
-0.3473323584,
0.1100950614,
-0.2952846289,
0.2262859643,
0.5691666603,
-0.5393018126,
0.1183287129,
0.2291758955,
-0.3709818125,
-0.5122828484,
-0.766682744,
0.0620765463,
-0.4226301908,
-0.1708977222,
0.4484701753,
-0.3418800235,
0.897993803,
0.6422442198,
-0.4139370322,
0.1193285808,
0.9509980679,
0.5099312067,
0.1401666403,
-0.2309287637,
-0.7608908415,
0.4645338058,
0.0601751432,
0.7715117931,
-0.700545609,
-0.262183547,
0.2761482596,
0.2263514996,
-0.013633104,
-0.6633490324,
0.773383379,
-0.3328313828,
0.2747794986,
0.0192647539,
-0.5923739672,
-0.1808221042,
0.3818159103,
-0.6694629788,
0.7306065559,
0.1188418269,
-0.6468596458,
0.6119023561,
-0.6578919291,
-0.463614434,
0.6666814685,
-0.5572798252,
-0.6782382727,
-0.0565571412,
-0.0253943559,
0.1471536905,
-0.2705337107,
0.3239954412,
0.2797879279,
-0.2092718929,
0.1836262643,
-0.4151517749,
0.9991633892,
0.2153282762,
-0.4896078706,
0.4401268065,
-0.9399939775,
-0.1816181839,
0.2339944243,
-0.5422432423,
-0.3478623629,
0.0970166922,
0.2337946743,
-0.0607481226,
0.5034460425,
-0.303388834,
0.0682589039,
-0.4179478884,
0.6827994585,
0.5408912301,
-0.0064904243,
0.3691043854,
-0.0051758885,
0.4986179173,
-0.1776030958,
-0.0005278829,
-0.3380576968,
-0.7122964859,
-1.0257104635,
-0.2141866088,
0.2504582405,
0.881155014,
-0.724119544,
0.2748777568,
-0.1671197414,
-0.1201806962,
-0.9999427795,
-0.1456497461,
0.2492428571,
-0.1031329706,
0.2484138012,
0.2510481775,
-1.1476626396,
-0.8887397647,
-0.4318532646,
-0.5185706019,
-0.0507872328,
0.1107952446,
0.5811479688,
-0.5572618842,
0.7751908302,
-0.174438566,
-0.6624081135,
-0.3153945804,
0.3979969025,
0.0359267332,
0.3343091309,
0.4872048795,
-1.1715580225,
-0.7173967361,
0.6327188015,
-0.9879127741,
-0.2489675283,
-0.0019951547,
0.1735592633,
0.3836872578,
1.174926281,
-0.4462596774,
0.6244082451,
-0.0996215418,
-0.663788259,
0.2486445308,
-0.468639344,
0.068722561,
-0.677251935,
-0.2477002591,
-0.1521382034,
-0.4065452218,
-0.7534912825,
0.4464042485,
-0.0869641453,
0.0083263759,
-0.5689200163,
0.4171045125,
-0.3513128161,
0.290441364,
-0.4617843926,
-0.0008054767,
-0.4124926925,
-0.1490065306,
0.1317372024,
0.5443997979,
0.5061277151,
-0.6308927536,
0.3539243937,
-0.0154581508,
0.043926999,
0.7928922772,
-0.6626392007,
0.1222894639,
-0.3972626925,
-0.0429959223,
-0.3068858385,
-0.3342449665,
0.3208365142,
-0.500354588,
0.2169769108,
-0.1015554443,
-0.3744679391,
-0.3434684873,
-0.1219696701,
0.4022260308,
0.5698265433,
0.0503745303,
0.9325431585,
0.6711900234,
0.1006451473,
-0.5292559862,
-0.5332467556,
0.2160184085,
-0.5055847764,
-0.1879595667,
0.2325958908,
0.3529960513,
-0.6518593431,
-0.0036896784,
0.3240406215,
-0.3058289289,
0.0332753696,
0.186062932,
-0.0406942144,
-0.3726881146,
-0.1750591695,
-0.2194725573,
-0.367528975,
0.4543842077,
-0.3883218765,
0.3904309273,
-0.1311130524,
-0.2545732856,
-0.6384137869,
0.3646986187,
0.4833620787,
-0.3451275826,
0.286770463,
0.6494119167,
-0.6165570021,
0.0879397988,
-0.6980288029,
0.4633472562,
-0.4749996066,
0.541249752,
-0.3495076895,
-1.3026063442,
0.046688728,
0.1445438415,
0.0305207707,
0.8041331768,
0.664033711,
-0.0869452134,
0.4727420211,
1.1015536785,
-0.0877410173,
0.3164770007,
0.211610496,
0.1468816102,
-0.3563429415,
-0.3497664034,
-0.9594540596,
0.3430981934,
-1.0577068329,
-0.5571964979,
0.3095675707,
-0.5136327744,
-0.151622951,
0.7620100379,
-0.2619995773,
0.5735351443,
0.6911611557,
-0.1222361922,
0.4492489398,
-0.1360155046,
0.2415049076,
-0.2999139428,
-0.2101041973,
-0.7174212337,
0.8556494713,
0.5390711427,
0.0457079634,
-0.0490437672,
0.7343904376,
0.3788755834,
-0.1819738299,
-0.8274600506,
0.7483853698,
-0.2903183997,
-0.3805116415,
-0.5126250982,
-0.295081377,
-1.2268127203,
0.1274425834,
-0.1257737279,
-0.6595616937,
0.0611404404,
-0.3576375246,
0.0839609131,
0.0125805847,
-0.1848779321,
0.6461566687,
-0.1018470675,
-0.1766463369,
-0.2085377127,
-0.6367459893,
0.1032913625,
-0.1737665534,
0.3726359904,
-0.1528372169,
-0.0672545806,
0.8817358017,
-0.4511764646,
0.4365954697,
-0.0965916365,
-0.3208642006,
0.7333238125,
-0.2281423509,
0.2419193238,
0.229889065,
0.157614246,
-0.2515910864,
0.0796664953,
-0.2012378573,
-0.267124176,
0.0558674075,
-0.5068185329,
-0.8205748796,
-0.6769245863,
-0.361985743,
0.2511357665,
0.4463832378,
0.2939271033,
-0.306440264,
-0.3437865674,
0.1730739474,
0.6494367123,
-0.383754313,
0.263648957,
1.0272102356,
-0.1631118804,
-0.2901720107,
1.2560639381,
0.1736539304,
-0.3654934764,
0.7329924107,
0.0168840401,
-0.2159611583,
-0.6779332161,
-0.1311681271,
0.3161109984,
-0.8689243197,
0.1443035603,
-0.9116491675,
-0.6256487966,
-0.2658444047,
-0.1970362961,
-0.137984857,
-0.2949539423,
-0.2463501394,
-0.0398277752,
0.2319577485,
1.1172144413,
0.2478177249,
0.0794502124,
-0.8022065163,
0.5054317713,
0.2725028992,
-0.0155912153,
-0.664763093,
-0.6618795395,
-0.0294444431,
-0.1551792324,
-0.3197633028,
-0.3423571587,
0.1790582389,
0.2329778969,
0.7160565853,
0.3163584471,
-0.0065521337,
0.4625724554,
-0.8794983625,
0.7055324316,
-0.1870352626,
-1.0052659512,
0.9112756252,
-0.2502273917,
0.1027366072,
0.4886653721,
0.4002723992,
-0.4048304558,
-0.7159541845,
-0.5043188334,
-0.9918795228,
0.3683601916,
0.5032458305,
0.115555048,
0.1911153942,
0.4082669318,
0.1575323045,
0.0550430268,
-0.8681308627,
0.0875109434,
0.2125253975,
-0.0519318059,
0.3034283519,
-0.2387523949,
0.0961616635,
-0.4904143512,
0.1817819774,
0.0581069589,
0.3693707883,
0.1177406013,
-0.0610376298,
0.1085106432,
0.3133142591,
0.7196474075,
0.6181082129,
-0.0609642975,
0.0657612085,
0.1184548289,
-0.6876949668,
0.2557892799,
0.0035482775,
-0.3529303372,
0.2588302195,
0.9104245901,
0.7908551097,
-0.2613797188,
-0.8975527883,
0.5488933325,
-0.1015391946,
-0.7101762295,
-0.7856913209,
-0.0344858468,
-0.3303227723,
0.2453587949,
0.383490026,
-0.2109762728,
0.3740634918,
-0.7252213955,
0.3252271116,
0.1712567508,
-0.6733387709,
0.0536227562,
0.8652939796,
-0.0937930644,
-0.3654266,
0.5030793548,
-0.087303713,
-0.7088891268,
0.8510736227,
0.3433632851,
1.1066066027,
-0.0065628742,
0.0876376927,
0.3757559061,
0.5076831579,
-0.1990405917,
0.6190063953,
0.095815599,
-0.4125651121,
-0.2436621189,
-0.2488648444,
-0.5811665058,
-0.0375205949,
-0.4915631115,
0.6273577213,
-0.2596836388,
-0.0791344047,
0.0080803605,
-0.3551261127,
-0.6993989348,
0.1733921617,
0.0850102305,
0.5493363142,
-0.2340927571,
0.8688855767,
0.7125163078,
-0.4764748812,
-0.0443515591,
0.1010178328,
0.2592006624,
-0.8353148699,
0.8297489882,
0.2550595403,
0.0917066485,
-0.0986132473,
-0.8039423227,
-0.2933138013,
1.0453407764,
0.1967545301,
-0.3016128242,
-0.1030633003,
0.7238664031,
0.7411019206,
-0.2687265873,
0.0607330576,
0.9546995759,
0.6598262787,
-0.1482680887,
-1.065002203,
0.0166067891,
-0.3210764825,
-0.194039017,
0.0297204647,
-0.3268903494,
0.7925741673,
0.0154151767,
-0.4006454349,
-0.076569289,
0.9672619104,
0.4179447889,
0.738437593,
0.217730701,
0.3660125732,
0.6462497711,
-0.369928062,
0.7127806544,
-0.0292424709,
-0.0087397834,
1.0022261143,
-0.4392385483,
0.9085219502,
0.5779485703,
-0.4976566434,
-0.0052039139,
0.2974212468,
0.0109220911,
0.199482277,
0.2532647252,
-0.1215195283,
0.1342052221,
-0.5714201331,
-0.5634843111,
0.7147172689,
0.6351841688,
-0.1419211924,
0.2547565997,
0.1590524912,
-0.0942503065,
0.388479203,
-0.1986867487,
1.1645066738,
0.1205036491,
-0.5013609529,
0.3355553746,
0.2437497675,
0.6308563948,
-0.6318342686,
-0.2792138159,
0.0265091714,
-0.0017969739,
-0.1280242205,
-1.044906497,
0.5738011599,
0.0334530957,
0.1650979519,
-0.159732461,
0.5665408373,
-0.3297291994,
-0.2531788945,
0.5643063188,
0.4576930702,
0.2656303346,
-0.0777021646,
-0.4719133973,
0.3005092144,
-0.1723725796,
0.1035249978,
0.1179364994,
1.2128142118,
-0.1210596934,
0.6314567924,
0.3369349837,
-0.0106744003,
0.192974925,
0.2355945557,
0.7692037821,
-0.8977211714,
-0.4285318851,
-0.842807889,
0.4605676532,
0.0012896843,
-0.3499768972,
0.5973266363,
0.4974678755,
0.9682360888,
-0.0496347807,
0.9640673995,
-0.2639431059,
0.073639065,
-0.9498636723,
0.6342320442,
-0.4916988313,
0.1516237855,
-0.2292664349,
-0.7136799097,
-0.3984383941,
0.5797578096,
0.0376915112,
-0.2510460317,
0.8436940908,
0.0972853452,
0.2862792611,
0.0169750284,
0.5269204974,
0.015329469,
0.5603756309,
0.5297741294,
0.7251783609,
-0.7162739038,
0.3486014605,
-0.1275568902,
0.2107080817,
-0.1430449486,
-0.6162070036,
-0.9563943744,
-0.8935065269,
-0.3335803747,
-0.500138402,
0.0197798237,
0.8813207746,
0.102841422,
-1.0028338432,
-0.587176621,
-0.3118732274,
-0.0107881464,
-0.0426318683,
-0.2488591075,
0.1893612742,
-0.3293120265,
-0.7721378803,
0.2460303009,
0.5751127005,
0.2868954539,
0.0838199854,
-0.2869090438,
-0.3840834796,
-0.0921799541,
0.8289040327,
0.4177315235,
-1.0080957413,
-0.2588524818,
-0.1999985129,
-0.1921242476,
0.0823848993,
1.2463021278,
-0.4087700248,
0.5645050406,
0.5702039003,
1.1045817137,
0.2416175604,
-0.2567833066,
0.8588413596,
-0.1852879673,
0.4996434748,
0.2694760859,
0.567240715,
-0.0419273116,
-0.4555248618,
1.012298584,
0.4202231467,
-0.5636536479,
-0.7236468792,
0.396283865,
-0.8690001965,
-0.0937657654,
0.7875475883,
-0.1299808323,
-0.2007757574,
-0.9315408468,
-0.6943748593,
0.3020470142,
-0.1039560437,
0.2723065317,
0.7887551785,
0.0866944864,
-0.5530674458,
-1.1602470875,
0.4711079597,
0.236477226,
-0.8254493475,
-0.0790501684,
0.2945560217,
-0.2629912794,
-0.0420569964,
1.0598402023,
-0.2192299366,
0.3719195127,
0.0790866837,
-0.3103505373,
0.148686856,
-0.2942408919,
-0.3193584979,
0.159748733,
0.1765173078,
0.2528738379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03432v1
|
Mixture-of-LoRAs: An Efficient Multitask Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-06T03:33:48 | 2024-03-06T03:33:48 |
Wenfeng Feng, Chuzhan Hao, Yuewei Zhang, Yu Han, Hao Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction Tuning has the potential to stimulate or enhance specific
capabilities of large language models (LLMs). However, achieving the right
balance of data is crucial to prevent catastrophic forgetting and interference
between tasks. To address these limitations and enhance training flexibility,
we propose the Mixture-of-LoRAs (MoA) architecture which is a novel and
parameter-efficient tuning method designed for multi-task learning with LLMs.
In this paper, we start by individually training multiple domain-specific LoRA
modules using corresponding supervised corpus data. These LoRA modules can be
aligned with the expert design principles observed in Mixture-of-Experts (MoE).
Subsequently, we combine the multiple LoRAs using an explicit routing strategy
and introduce domain labels to facilitate multi-task learning, which help
prevent interference between tasks and ultimately enhances the performance of
each individual task. Furthermore, each LoRA model can be iteratively adapted
to a new domain, allowing for quick domain-specific adaptation. Experiments on
diverse tasks demonstrate superior and robust performance, which can further
promote the wide application of domain-specific LLMs.
|
[
-0.4884859324,
-0.9980694056,
0.3522776365,
0.084792763,
-0.3516874611,
0.3189302683,
-0.3393442035,
-0.1268516481,
0.4264053106,
0.6883535981,
-0.6145890355,
-0.4286715984,
-0.6611646414,
-0.2919067144,
-0.1291383505,
0.7926490307,
0.0561538972,
-0.0968003124,
-0.1252003461,
-0.366224438,
-0.7124838233,
-0.3568308055,
-0.5285630226,
-0.3233256936,
0.8164071441,
0.4550135136,
0.2237010598,
0.8283243179,
0.2517661452,
0.4399672747,
0.0670040101,
0.9233316183,
-0.4861011803,
0.262737751,
-0.33059448,
-0.519856751,
-0.7328201532,
-0.3591916561,
0.5693575144,
0.6527563334,
-0.4363085926,
-0.0211286694,
0.1769572347,
0.5917935967,
-0.813303709,
-0.0435401089,
-0.8608036637,
-0.2005738914,
-0.4863864183,
-0.4807480574,
-0.3014381528,
0.1936396956,
-0.1198194474,
-0.6631984115,
-0.0471298024,
0.130886063,
0.4621827304,
0.5302172899,
-0.4257480204,
-0.1576630771,
-0.442684412,
1.0352222919,
-0.6605985761,
0.1646409184,
0.2302558869,
0.1391426921,
-0.2452999502,
-0.0145597672,
-0.4839958549,
0.2447980493,
0.3357951939,
-0.0057794363,
0.1401692331,
-0.1080061495,
-0.0615977719,
0.2784520388,
-0.3631119728,
0.414180249,
-0.1079394668,
0.0546112768,
0.2990446389,
0.2251517326,
0.1750352085,
0.3304347396,
-0.2702334821,
-0.0962023884,
-0.6756972671,
-0.2423946708,
0.7077871561,
0.4797057211,
-0.1598870307,
0.4493833184,
-0.2028881609,
1.0346273184,
0.2544904649,
-0.7228763103,
0.4183547795,
-0.0837631449,
-0.1200809553,
-0.243384555,
0.6395381093,
-0.1758066863,
-0.0797201023,
-0.2447006255,
-0.2668318748,
0.1737626791,
0.3955107927,
-0.5143023729,
-0.0691676214,
0.1253474951,
-0.097068496,
-0.1375436932,
-0.2200115472,
-0.7717301846,
-0.2510642707,
-0.6562509537,
0.6387679577,
-0.613058269,
-0.2267601341,
0.4153462946,
0.2348303348,
-0.1482689977,
0.1901329756,
-1.0805579424,
0.3779048324,
0.7569774389,
0.4933651388,
-0.5174201727,
-0.627468586,
-0.8495790958,
0.321618259,
-0.089283824,
0.8866023421,
-0.6990184188,
-0.2590970099,
-0.0489378572,
-0.2613113821,
-0.5789692402,
-0.7584977746,
0.2561621964,
-0.6446009278,
0.0836874694,
-0.0420760959,
-0.4549625516,
-0.2154186517,
0.154986456,
-0.5544159412,
1.1368985176,
0.2153869569,
-0.4577750266,
0.149403736,
-0.6936230063,
-0.867567718,
-0.1197268292,
-0.1944586486,
-0.3246018291,
0.1011323705,
0.3046445549,
0.5036312342,
-0.2570292354,
0.217551738,
-0.0765991434,
-0.1517589241,
0.2566596866,
-0.0839548334,
0.5098013282,
0.1620563865,
-0.1573453546,
0.2742732465,
-0.8106502891,
0.0212557875,
-0.1570298672,
-0.6287241578,
-0.5189940333,
0.1443058699,
-0.0724521503,
0.1812615097,
0.3556101322,
-0.2301824242,
0.1978512555,
-0.152715981,
0.3932880759,
0.6991152167,
-0.2086360604,
0.3362240791,
-0.5745798349,
0.4838273823,
0.3435373306,
-0.1919794828,
-0.2813496888,
-0.4953556657,
-1.0752099752,
-0.5170193315,
0.207421422,
0.509190619,
-0.9088528752,
0.9604654908,
-0.1157913581,
-0.46893695,
-0.5502560139,
0.6211515069,
0.42386657,
0.4798460901,
0.2607946098,
-0.3171522915,
-0.538457036,
-0.6028339267,
-0.0107547343,
0.4549979568,
0.3700139225,
0.2455109209,
0.5534226894,
-0.2619343102,
0.7565348744,
-0.4715729356,
-0.440294832,
-0.1762055755,
0.0572946742,
0.1922923476,
0.5676299334,
0.4116111994,
-0.5483335257,
-0.4975786209,
0.2154353708,
-0.4838746786,
0.1173851714,
0.1762447059,
-0.4381733239,
0.0579461344,
0.2136689425,
-0.4217742085,
-0.2647837996,
0.8408333659,
-0.0778364688,
0.232071951,
-0.4439325333,
0.1523490548,
-1.3676098585,
-0.1108907685,
-0.0499084331,
-0.1422455609,
-0.5720475316,
0.2442608923,
0.1389900446,
0.1401705593,
-0.3961893618,
0.4152940214,
-0.2653492987,
0.2752333283,
-0.5200922489,
0.1541071683,
-0.0299996138,
0.783105135,
-0.1385183185,
0.8367255926,
0.9607875943,
-0.911316514,
0.2339442819,
0.2091449499,
-0.6299821138,
0.7739587426,
-0.2866556048,
0.4450311959,
-0.0973592103,
0.0653326139,
-0.780715704,
-0.2814308703,
0.010553549,
0.0843757167,
0.1987059563,
0.0552758053,
-0.521343708,
0.040423844,
-0.0848230794,
0.4524452686,
0.391836226,
-0.5128167868,
1.1408673525,
0.6269171834,
-0.0992704481,
-0.6767771244,
-0.482896179,
-0.1051432639,
-0.4570236504,
-0.6402485371,
0.5663601756,
-0.178810969,
-0.1373155117,
-0.1039420217,
-0.0641618073,
-0.2235507816,
0.1220656261,
0.1586011052,
0.1701090336,
-0.37916255,
-0.0526927486,
0.3722113669,
-0.0789422914,
-0.4569870234,
-0.2620888352,
0.8457326293,
0.1870032698,
-0.5766221285,
-0.2694381773,
0.5252659917,
0.5062360764,
-0.5492783189,
0.9004231095,
0.5834270716,
-0.139753446,
-0.6181836128,
-0.7425240874,
0.0228034724,
-0.5396308899,
0.5811638832,
-0.5393620729,
-0.9687147141,
0.4410917163,
-0.1475067139,
0.1859317273,
0.2250297815,
0.8082808256,
-0.0368201435,
0.6446967125,
0.6775743961,
-0.3779800534,
0.6006180644,
-0.1834418774,
0.1561329812,
-0.8651112914,
-0.1494367719,
-0.5239205956,
-0.4417463839,
-0.0546573512,
-0.7197890282,
0.5174927711,
-0.1310078055,
-0.0664373338,
0.2787817419,
-0.1501541138,
0.7633751631,
0.5504803061,
0.3383661509,
0.2699356973,
0.1662153751,
0.1229298189,
0.3236015439,
-0.8548864722,
-0.1741150618,
1.0296208858,
0.0314541273,
0.8814606667,
0.1573083699,
0.6915069222,
0.1064441279,
-0.1591731757,
-0.6278546453,
0.5506384373,
-0.5920876265,
-0.3770903945,
-0.1596048772,
-0.2877236009,
-0.9304838777,
0.5574700236,
-0.1533034444,
-0.5881704688,
-0.0187356416,
0.2339258045,
-0.6294814944,
0.3717817366,
-0.7081643939,
0.6234542131,
-0.3512188494,
-0.2931579649,
-0.6346845627,
-0.3593700528,
0.3552031815,
-0.4275359213,
0.3266912401,
-0.2084148526,
-0.2160039991,
0.8095521331,
-0.0527428277,
1.0342923403,
0.0463100709,
-0.3837749362,
0.1954024732,
-0.0443487354,
0.4425387681,
-0.3501754403,
-0.0409164876,
-0.160856694,
-0.3185328245,
-0.4840492308,
-0.434438169,
0.9431340098,
-1.026524663,
-0.4312222898,
0.0318871103,
-0.9895194173,
-0.6674941182,
-0.0111099631,
-0.0437884964,
0.5968987346,
0.0513987429,
0.231223166,
1.0826678276,
-0.0366021357,
0.2500442863,
0.5462360382,
0.0332579166,
-0.3411589563,
1.2383569479,
-0.1062432304,
0.3993338943,
0.6108628511,
0.0927491114,
-0.0368094705,
-0.6123541594,
-0.4247910082,
0.1714090705,
-0.7176485062,
-0.1407124549,
-0.6222245693,
0.0335456915,
-0.1870500892,
0.0145218447,
-0.4524251521,
0.0294609088,
-0.3802086115,
0.3298298717,
0.3531877995,
0.5843482018,
0.3718353212,
0.7313081622,
-0.6319378614,
0.4934956729,
0.3978250921,
0.3711960614,
-0.0174695142,
-0.6883654594,
-0.4533782899,
-0.122983247,
-0.3317335546,
-0.4302401543,
0.2543106675,
0.4952996373,
0.6586151123,
0.4501492679,
-0.3528746963,
0.8310080767,
-0.5653281808,
0.388666749,
0.1321857423,
-0.8698779345,
0.2537049353,
-0.5679452419,
0.2328371406,
0.4270929396,
0.1052971259,
-0.2340178341,
-0.0699115694,
-0.2196734399,
-0.7548293471,
0.7473503351,
-0.1973689049,
0.2290355563,
0.2622845471,
0.0275733881,
0.5214906931,
0.276511699,
-0.2721397579,
-0.3766006231,
0.10596212,
-0.4393381476,
-0.1060643867,
-0.0791519433,
-0.4501647949,
-0.1962963194,
0.8240444064,
-0.3913438916,
0.0217912477,
-0.6534709334,
-0.2138751596,
-0.1032587513,
0.2794409692,
0.6225258708,
0.7747769952,
0.1146014482,
0.0963144004,
0.1827465147,
-0.22921817,
0.1589370966,
-0.163324222,
0.1889847368,
-0.2979820669,
0.1209780201,
1.0758886337,
0.4051374495,
-0.9084200859,
0.1101385057,
0.3817124069,
-0.2924977243,
0.192522496,
0.65478158,
0.3028890193,
0.2274375558,
0.2754452527,
0.3775234818,
-0.353069365,
-0.5636011958,
-0.0347714499,
0.3606089354,
0.2079232186,
-0.2194590867,
0.3505535424,
0.3755382895,
-0.3829076588,
0.0384263135,
0.00607032,
-0.2048827112,
0.5197764635,
0.6616710424,
0.5285061598,
-0.3216612637,
0.0046245367,
-0.0909429491,
-0.000277136,
-0.2159430236,
0.4062453508,
0.1376298964,
-0.9138683081,
-0.7114950418,
-0.5439203382,
-0.3881848752,
0.1982885599,
-0.4741277397,
0.1234664321,
-0.3250698447,
0.0396591499,
0.0493816212,
-0.2962836623,
-0.4887520969,
0.1425618231,
0.1411486715,
0.5721710324,
-0.7293947339,
1.3535001278,
0.6941838861,
0.0824269652,
-0.5302858353,
-0.2381602377,
-0.1019840166,
-0.9630746245,
0.3654040992,
-0.1361064315,
-0.4051709473,
-0.0128442496,
-0.1366598457,
-0.8914347291,
0.8485590219,
0.434150666,
-0.7105112076,
0.0619676486,
0.1267375797,
0.2997087538,
-0.5386276841,
-0.2002090961,
0.6499547958,
0.2152877301,
-0.0040363632,
-0.8144652247,
-0.3432981968,
-0.1286897212,
-0.2113930881,
0.3574708104,
-0.8260787725,
1.1101051569,
0.159783408,
0.2842310965,
0.1494610757,
0.6170688868,
0.3544349372,
-0.1451128274,
0.8104535341,
0.6600757837,
0.9008068442,
-0.0021471973,
0.6609727144,
-0.4818186164,
0.0097910091,
1.1647660732,
-0.5139383078,
0.8899956942,
0.5539929271,
-0.0894136354,
0.5216875076,
0.2654919624,
0.3128714859,
0.7450737953,
-0.0332660116,
-0.414152056,
-0.4907822609,
-0.0024680377,
-0.347293973,
0.5113045573,
0.596546948,
0.0436050817,
-0.1482732594,
0.2386960536,
-0.1205867007,
0.1369206458,
-0.3213368654,
0.5720816255,
-0.0791916177,
-0.8711259365,
0.504827559,
0.2527140379,
1.0985064507,
-0.9702202082,
0.2391527593,
-0.1098981425,
0.3918682635,
-0.1729531884,
-0.4239015281,
-0.0648832396,
-0.1677899063,
-0.1867417693,
-0.092163831,
0.4940885305,
-0.7268218398,
-0.3408919275,
0.1201441959,
0.7318832278,
-0.1870839596,
-0.0911604911,
-0.5463050604,
0.1864654124,
-0.0135325976,
0.0090330672,
0.7735997438,
0.4988620579,
0.1657267213,
0.7423740625,
0.4996119738,
-0.0512864888,
0.3692421913,
0.0566684231,
1.0448858738,
-0.4808298647,
-0.6078313589,
-0.7676872015,
0.4036992192,
0.2449795902,
-0.5597766042,
0.5513517261,
0.4928972721,
0.6301476359,
-0.2710139155,
0.8487359285,
-0.0346903913,
0.5411999822,
-0.8663005829,
0.3032969832,
-0.6542240381,
0.1105220839,
0.0411998443,
-0.9047967196,
0.062166594,
0.4030654132,
0.0404019691,
0.1199660301,
0.7134690285,
0.8762393594,
-0.4377466142,
-0.1640845835,
0.3880277276,
-0.1088880375,
0.1161781996,
0.6566489935,
0.611949861,
-0.1254301071,
0.2739439309,
-0.3057592809,
-0.1105112061,
-0.2209036499,
-0.6997605562,
-1.085991621,
-0.5925500989,
-0.3838588595,
-0.0015724133,
0.0775697976,
1.0074291229,
1.0337588787,
-0.8234458566,
-0.5172766447,
0.3031058013,
-0.0962607488,
-0.4958392084,
-0.0696785897,
0.2985354066,
-0.6251026988,
-0.9124557972,
0.9414368272,
0.2507974803,
-0.3689145148,
-0.412034452,
-0.1204117537,
-0.2562594414,
0.0865586177,
0.5917294025,
-0.0277363118,
-0.6432497501,
0.0842683017,
-0.1477659643,
-0.083489269,
0.2080643028,
0.918928206,
-0.6034064889,
0.257566452,
0.2179205418,
0.9487313628,
0.282769382,
-0.1364959478,
0.3771851063,
-0.9093065262,
0.2721585631,
0.0165268388,
0.5032083392,
0.1961730421,
-0.1552153826,
0.2574271858,
0.1004545689,
-0.400999099,
-0.5107423663,
0.0806266665,
-1.4288299084,
-0.251550138,
1.1425590515,
-0.0166081712,
-0.1743398756,
-0.2392918319,
-0.3600312173,
-0.0206453316,
-0.5418495536,
0.8524381518,
0.6084300876,
-0.0549882948,
0.099687174,
-0.5098531246,
0.007722408,
0.6453123093,
-1.1301127672,
-0.1180182025,
0.2645168304,
0.3512871861,
0.068446666,
0.3865329623,
0.4114600122,
0.032835722,
-0.1754660606,
-0.1134934053,
-0.1899999976,
-0.4189190269,
0.0109206736,
0.3508456945,
0.0238096192,
-0.4575141668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03419v1
|
Negating Negatives: Alignment without Human Positive Samples via Distributional Dispreference Optimization
| 2024-03-06T03:02:38 | 2024-03-06T03:02:38 |
Shitong Duan, Xiaoyuan Yi, Peng Zhang, Tun Lu, Xing Xie, Ning Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the role of AI, yet also
pose potential risks of propagating unethical content. Alignment technologies
have been introduced to steer LLMs towards human preference, gaining increasing
attention. Despite notable breakthroughs in this direction, existing methods
heavily rely on high-quality positive-negative training pairs, suffering from
noisy labels and the marginal distinction between preferred and dispreferred
response data. Given recent LLMs' proficiency in generating helpful responses,
this work pivots towards a new research focus: achieving alignment using solely
human-annotated negative samples, preserving helpfulness while reducing
harmfulness. For this purpose, we propose Distributional Dispreference
Optimization (D$^2$O), which maximizes the discrepancy between the generated
responses and the dispreferred ones to effectively eschew harmful information.
We theoretically demonstrate that D$^2$O is equivalent to learning a
distributional instead of instance-level preference model reflecting human
dispreference against the distribution of negative responses. Besides, D$^2$O
integrates an implicit Jeffrey Divergence regularization to balance the
exploitation and exploration of reference policies and converges to a
non-negative one during training. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our
method achieves comparable generation quality and surpasses the latest
baselines in producing less harmful and more informative responses with better
training stability and faster convergence.
|
[
-0.6150115132,
-0.557795167,
0.3643232584,
-0.0668680742,
-0.3529457748,
-0.0495597683,
-0.2691658735,
-0.4066430628,
0.2823717892,
0.3629573882,
-0.5086411834,
-0.3529468477,
-0.6287973523,
0.1752232164,
-0.4809206724,
1.0500996113,
0.3842251599,
0.1897041649,
-0.3727151155,
-0.2425836325,
-0.3196988702,
-0.3287376463,
-0.4638278782,
-0.4338456392,
0.7154684067,
0.4386940002,
0.9654821754,
0.8225721717,
0.5780021548,
0.3178984821,
-0.0754050985,
0.1029490605,
-0.6969041228,
0.1880255193,
-0.2529526651,
-0.3674358726,
-0.2716116011,
0.1025375873,
0.1574124396,
0.6435914636,
-0.3574501276,
0.2933750451,
0.0969734788,
0.7182184458,
-0.8682047129,
-0.4617184103,
-0.6048812866,
-0.0883844867,
-0.1528442502,
-0.172393918,
-0.4098377824,
-0.6529091001,
0.0880984217,
-0.8417449594,
0.1736700386,
-0.1005258188,
0.8941460848,
0.7053114772,
-0.3160615861,
-0.4792994261,
-0.8423022032,
1.0024561882,
-0.7872823477,
0.3536502123,
0.603520453,
0.0987018794,
-0.1005515754,
0.1506585181,
-0.8904080391,
-0.0870635435,
0.101740934,
0.1396066397,
-0.1903553605,
0.0987522975,
0.1859345585,
0.010679815,
-0.4310376942,
0.4193033278,
-0.2078056186,
-0.1650847048,
0.861694634,
-0.0579073876,
0.2068814784,
0.1504682899,
-0.1563296765,
-0.3873219192,
-0.811055243,
-0.3058325946,
0.71372509,
0.220617041,
-0.0320841484,
0.5937732458,
0.1263516396,
0.619818747,
0.3681437969,
-0.3349886239,
0.4323319197,
-0.167298317,
-0.0410822667,
0.1887344718,
0.6583789587,
0.4143133163,
0.3249438107,
-0.169012621,
-0.0300820284,
0.4136269987,
0.34522295,
-0.6818175316,
0.0304554757,
0.1295946985,
-0.0959323347,
-0.3670844734,
-0.0821649507,
-0.865486145,
-0.9199957848,
-0.7709001303,
0.3366889656,
-0.2991710901,
-0.126091525,
0.0493763499,
-0.0905963406,
0.0484381169,
0.3963269889,
-0.9530317783,
0.0930316821,
0.5779898763,
0.4429699183,
0.1770907342,
-0.0736497864,
-0.6897717714,
0.1914931089,
-0.4317293465,
0.4721696377,
-0.2993580103,
-0.2502325177,
-0.0357972346,
-0.4476852715,
0.5403007865,
-0.6899408102,
0.5916606784,
-0.5316638947,
0.3263286054,
-0.3769426644,
-0.4795840383,
-0.0212895777,
0.3677451015,
-0.4815045297,
0.6568624377,
-0.0356680639,
-0.7762656212,
0.393197,
-0.2924569547,
-0.549361825,
-0.1470777541,
-0.2731146812,
-0.6426411867,
-0.0147667732,
0.0894629583,
0.1743162572,
-0.2740417421,
0.2917203605,
-0.6960458755,
-0.4278790057,
0.2493393272,
-0.3043947816,
0.8370155096,
0.2709830999,
-0.4970616698,
0.0660633817,
-0.7876327634,
-0.3215342462,
0.0087851733,
-0.1001717523,
-0.7446413636,
0.1082011312,
-0.5131453872,
0.3149527609,
0.1426171362,
-0.5407332778,
-0.008350431,
-0.439902693,
0.289932251,
1.0071465969,
-0.253176719,
0.8762487769,
-0.3201287985,
0.4383487403,
0.0578634515,
0.2389182448,
0.4275011122,
0.0201503802,
-0.5726500154,
-0.1834212393,
0.1228217706,
0.5262539387,
-0.7479153872,
0.7866947651,
-0.348903805,
-0.3870521784,
-0.778380394,
0.3843038976,
0.2079937756,
0.9626612067,
0.5655830503,
-0.1706906706,
-0.5651237965,
-0.857873857,
0.1052952334,
-0.287453562,
0.1346513927,
0.1104055792,
-0.0889014304,
-0.2247795761,
0.7774528861,
-0.4664277732,
-0.1516972035,
-0.0514824986,
-0.0228565261,
0.2317764908,
0.2925937474,
0.4650892019,
-0.9073800445,
-0.4798848033,
-0.3817739785,
-0.6343739033,
-0.3769447505,
-0.117449142,
-0.3629432023,
0.1254997402,
0.222920388,
-0.575304091,
0.2876787186,
0.499677211,
-0.0860681981,
0.110649161,
-0.0633386597,
-0.1525700092,
-1.1598712206,
0.1247166097,
0.3039400578,
-0.1204167679,
-0.5758094192,
-0.2648601532,
-0.05224929,
0.1583742499,
-0.2826751471,
0.5020660758,
-0.4396384358,
0.1452212781,
-0.3396103978,
0.4195069969,
0.018266527,
0.170072332,
-0.0354152806,
0.6921654344,
0.2173260301,
-0.6603876352,
0.0969310626,
0.6802818775,
0.1927208155,
0.9193701744,
-0.4463098645,
0.0446716957,
-0.6565319896,
0.247800529,
-0.8448393345,
0.0171882864,
0.4229611754,
-0.3729266822,
0.3246299028,
0.0691277236,
-0.2097812593,
-0.2924766839,
-0.6418278217,
0.4805372059,
0.8892213702,
-0.520624578,
0.0902981162,
0.4305365086,
0.0007159468,
-1.0492771864,
-0.7743245959,
-0.0795432776,
-0.5871373415,
-0.3171255589,
0.3059224188,
-0.1693451554,
-0.3266308606,
-0.2334606498,
-0.1415596455,
0.2012975514,
0.1877430528,
0.1759443432,
0.4734504819,
0.01997138,
0.1533467323,
-0.0871711075,
-0.2604211569,
-0.230350256,
-0.1024681777,
0.4316411018,
0.4037796259,
-0.4907123446,
-0.6367179751,
0.1450401694,
0.2868076265,
-0.0517891087,
0.7229598761,
0.5879426599,
-0.2616533339,
-0.0678337589,
-0.609669745,
-0.3979821503,
-0.5002388358,
0.2917418778,
0.2894847989,
-0.6365023851,
0.0563300401,
0.1559204459,
0.0325515978,
0.1513402313,
0.3446376026,
-0.2793125212,
0.9397265911,
0.4029256105,
-0.352240026,
0.748108983,
-0.0601624809,
0.4570326209,
-0.7173846364,
0.1710089296,
-0.552508831,
-0.4854416549,
-0.6056220531,
-0.180837363,
0.3380253017,
0.4356223345,
-0.6791503429,
0.3832894266,
-0.8195954561,
0.5730854273,
0.6770612001,
0.0702316314,
0.1340117157,
-0.056132827,
0.4050275683,
-0.1642539203,
-0.4085225165,
-0.5368084908,
1.1321736574,
0.2603175342,
1.0408272743,
0.3210220933,
1.1178694963,
0.2264220864,
0.6615093946,
-0.5715852976,
0.5025182366,
-0.2998748422,
-0.3688387871,
-0.4567183852,
-0.5070568323,
-0.8791490197,
0.1059426442,
-0.1345502883,
-0.7447467446,
0.3114768565,
0.4309990704,
-0.326726675,
0.0277925543,
-0.7116673589,
0.4031956494,
-0.3664095402,
-0.5005090237,
-0.0511000752,
-0.9116042256,
0.1231533885,
0.040467862,
0.3598306179,
-0.2560795248,
0.0353243239,
0.3811130822,
-0.287132591,
0.9393805265,
-0.5063696504,
-0.3760501146,
0.2227196097,
-0.0002845558,
0.5967256427,
-0.052678898,
-0.2766156197,
0.1415240467,
-0.1658366024,
-0.4145160317,
-0.4866619408,
0.5296759605,
-1.0462055206,
-0.5875806808,
-0.2311882228,
-0.3617527187,
-0.1858047843,
0.307312727,
0.2378071994,
0.0042645978,
-0.0428097472,
-0.1452787071,
0.6312550306,
-0.3306474984,
0.3390411735,
0.4008532763,
0.1701494902,
-0.5675086975,
1.1272680759,
0.054000672,
0.4056018591,
0.5809716582,
0.3063068986,
-0.7253648639,
-0.6847494245,
-0.4116443992,
0.3251575828,
-0.6905271411,
-0.5381681919,
-0.2511351705,
0.0271938723,
-0.4758174121,
-0.1822381318,
-0.259291321,
-0.3272583187,
-0.5927396417,
-0.1056347713,
-0.0496068448,
0.5506686568,
-0.3923563063,
0.1355849802,
-0.6489306092,
0.3513871431,
0.0343926921,
0.0223481581,
0.02697194,
-0.3818566799,
-0.0774844587,
0.5376300812,
-0.7641658187,
-0.7865507603,
0.2598219216,
-0.0447424427,
0.4233460128,
0.5211898685,
0.4571625888,
0.9432817698,
-0.3506776392,
0.5860977173,
0.429172039,
-0.8828205466,
0.2532228529,
-0.2226636112,
-0.0196947884,
0.9065290689,
0.449123174,
-0.5609778166,
-0.3416644931,
-0.4801955223,
-1.0110619068,
0.4784211814,
0.0993239805,
0.3367359042,
-0.2110677361,
0.4215668738,
0.1949544549,
0.4849426746,
-0.6909630895,
-0.2081005871,
-0.2272293717,
-0.5028452873,
-0.197556749,
-0.0699927062,
-0.4889279604,
-0.1305855513,
1.0059015751,
-0.1540123522,
0.0572148599,
0.2462260723,
-0.1225662231,
-0.3040149808,
0.3307915628,
0.8111071587,
0.4874472618,
-0.0099018114,
0.3964148462,
-0.023022214,
-0.2934264541,
0.5894761682,
0.238757357,
-0.2729015648,
-0.350174427,
0.2387306541,
0.3821923435,
-0.393166393,
-0.4796982408,
0.6853496432,
0.1830356419,
-0.0466384627,
-0.3520819843,
0.0628445894,
0.1680400372,
0.1565901041,
0.1826691478,
0.0720931515,
-0.0328109413,
0.050724335,
0.1385962367,
0.7117054462,
-0.2880016863,
-0.3289978802,
0.6911144257,
0.3340261579,
-0.388553977,
0.8286188841,
-0.3520947397,
-0.130190596,
0.3925590515,
0.5161087513,
0.6599136591,
-0.1534319371,
0.3955753446,
0.4425418675,
-0.0067230407,
-0.1267037392,
0.022853544,
-0.1376966089,
-1.0714013577,
-0.3508882821,
-0.5527031422,
-0.2117092013,
0.1378032714,
-0.7340760827,
0.318257153,
-0.4127939641,
-0.2639943659,
0.067042008,
-0.2539393604,
-0.4785787165,
0.1189977527,
0.3829724491,
0.4891185164,
-0.7917842269,
0.6173546314,
0.4672116935,
-0.5524055362,
-0.6876092553,
0.1359414607,
0.1932064742,
-0.926849544,
0.4422720373,
0.1147992685,
-0.2664871216,
0.0344129056,
-0.5775347352,
-0.8081610799,
1.1191810369,
0.9605767727,
-0.8716307282,
0.0898573026,
0.3016839623,
0.6299298406,
0.1035643294,
0.2315056622,
0.2591606081,
0.385918051,
0.2753109038,
-0.6344602108,
0.1796509176,
-0.1014834866,
-0.0498204157,
0.5424502492,
-0.6353008747,
0.5253711343,
-0.2691732943,
-0.2731091678,
0.1147555634,
0.2573443949,
0.2781967819,
0.2095554322,
0.5438999534,
0.9200327396,
0.7979704738,
0.1863581687,
0.8271899223,
-0.2270946652,
0.331022799,
1.2412264347,
-0.5938811302,
0.5630120039,
1.1398794651,
-0.2218398601,
0.3180355728,
0.6801048517,
0.0553649701,
0.6408696771,
0.5653700233,
-0.4015194774,
-0.1676036566,
-0.4101119041,
-0.3982849717,
0.0682407171,
-0.0301543567,
-0.3341882825,
-0.3319422305,
-0.3346318603,
-0.0776237771,
0.4375190735,
0.2387257367,
1.053960681,
-0.0366744325,
-0.6891283393,
0.7398895621,
-0.1675334722,
0.8584610224,
-0.4019745588,
-0.0777738988,
-0.2619677782,
0.2847940624,
-0.3200259805,
-0.488879621,
0.3163273036,
-0.2496565729,
-0.2122629732,
-0.2235524505,
0.3373546898,
-0.4981057644,
-0.2141994685,
0.3176905811,
0.2709375322,
-0.212030977,
0.2139611244,
-0.565205574,
-0.1739397943,
0.0413758755,
-0.0433634147,
0.4496172369,
0.2339818031,
-0.0822482035,
0.4935158491,
0.6739623547,
0.204314366,
-0.2831080258,
0.2162057012,
0.7610493302,
-0.4741635919,
-0.4780680239,
-1.1572685242,
0.4204967022,
-0.2031572908,
-0.16207546,
0.5378814936,
0.3635829389,
0.9461117387,
0.1778697968,
0.8513560295,
-0.028144652,
0.4220620394,
-0.1417773515,
0.4026021659,
-0.4606997371,
0.4392679632,
-0.4489435554,
-1.0242164135,
-0.4507714212,
0.6941292882,
-0.5200749636,
-0.0666989237,
0.1358065903,
0.9312619567,
-0.059044499,
-0.068430908,
0.180304572,
-0.0489782728,
0.5320657492,
0.4435195327,
1.0347056389,
-0.215283215,
0.4280153215,
-0.3719519079,
-0.1975987107,
0.010503565,
-1.0112735033,
-0.6248164177,
-0.4059125781,
-0.2568534017,
-0.5576171875,
0.0482813418,
1.1223515272,
0.7733637094,
-0.6535205841,
-0.1335585415,
-0.4668203294,
0.2641125023,
0.0053224894,
-0.2148358077,
0.1722885519,
-0.1638096571,
-0.5952208042,
0.025784459,
0.1148349494,
0.508913219,
-0.4079001546,
-0.4674634039,
-0.1507362425,
-0.0065850643,
0.2082346827,
0.253261447,
-0.5584686995,
-0.3700951636,
-0.0806326047,
-0.2704262137,
0.2110709548,
0.5056924224,
-0.356477052,
0.330435127,
0.3458143175,
0.8421501517,
0.1590115577,
0.5017643571,
0.6348425746,
-0.7915790081,
0.3127282858,
0.5907706022,
-0.0030083817,
0.6273441911,
-0.6830406785,
0.4161909819,
-0.0159876347,
-0.6399620771,
-0.8280310035,
0.3593127728,
-0.6946309209,
-0.1371563673,
1.1881407499,
0.0795216635,
-0.073100403,
0.0869577602,
-0.2467664927,
0.3665238917,
-0.5999959111,
1.1870903969,
0.647295475,
-0.4253250957,
0.2356050313,
-0.0851413533,
0.5136294961,
0.6643394232,
-0.7689393163,
-0.0018632527,
0.6876648664,
0.3027460873,
0.4138789177,
0.6949858069,
0.0592713803,
0.0591526516,
-0.2811897993,
0.2080739439,
0.0554997735,
-0.1282019466,
-0.4113997221,
-0.0929744318,
0.2921392322,
-0.3692647517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03407v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03407v2
|
Human vs. Machine: Behavioral Differences Between Expert Humans and Language Models in Wargame Simulations
| 2024-03-06T02:23:32 | 2024-06-03T15:00:47 |
Max Lamparth, Anthony Corso, Jacob Ganz, Oriana Skylar Mastro, Jacquelyn Schneider, Harold Trinkunas
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
To some, the advent of artificial intelligence (AI) promises better
decision-making and increased military effectiveness while reducing the
influence of human error and emotions. However, there is still debate about how
AI systems, especially large language models (LLMs), behave compared to humans
in high-stakes military decision-making scenarios with the potential for
increased risks towards escalation and unnecessary conflicts. To test this
potential and scrutinize the use of LLMs for such purposes, we use a new
wargame experiment with 107 national security experts designed to look at
crisis escalation in a fictional US-China scenario and compare human players to
LLM-simulated responses in separate simulations. Wargames have a long history
in the development of military strategy and the response of nations to threats
or attacks. Here, we show a considerable high-level agreement in the LLM and
human responses and significant quantitative and qualitative differences in
individual actions and strategic tendencies. These differences depend on
intrinsic biases in LLMs regarding the appropriate level of violence following
strategic instructions, the choice of LLM, and whether the LLMs are tasked to
decide for a team of players directly or first to simulate dialog between
players. When simulating the dialog, the discussions lack quality and maintain
a farcical harmony. The LLM simulations cannot account for human player
characteristics, showing no significant difference even for extreme traits,
such as "pacifist" or "aggressive sociopath". Our results motivate policymakers
to be cautious before granting autonomy or following AI-based strategy
recommendations.
|
[
-0.5954874158,
-1.028147459,
0.4930899739,
0.1831412017,
0.2567987442,
0.4291580021,
-0.2320632041,
-0.5638104081,
0.0576291122,
0.4948022366,
-0.4187705815,
-0.1058132127,
-0.6814085245,
0.2324178964,
-0.0447898917,
0.6888096333,
0.0719531253,
0.111919336,
-0.1128965691,
0.0153866056,
-0.3229953051,
-0.914263308,
-0.9201855659,
-0.670398891,
0.2422956377,
0.1635591686,
0.9999115467,
0.4308121204,
0.7155660987,
0.4857037365,
-0.1370095611,
-0.0290459879,
-0.4253809452,
0.2091355026,
-0.1888872534,
-0.4065482318,
-0.4177064598,
0.2489254028,
0.18807742,
0.2756658196,
-0.026217524,
0.0356271267,
-0.0637566671,
0.3617204726,
-0.2378341705,
0.2647398412,
-0.3860732317,
0.1661358178,
0.1985208243,
0.0109141115,
-0.2068607807,
0.0011616688,
0.5211428404,
-0.7020930052,
0.0717351735,
0.2424921989,
0.7191011906,
0.4804363251,
-0.4580637217,
-0.1094446331,
-1.0870269537,
0.6163618565,
-0.7361415029,
-0.1334168166,
0.4743161798,
0.1808903515,
-0.4453185201,
-0.2072711587,
-0.4927139878,
-0.5776157379,
0.1671640724,
0.2573116422,
-0.2743543088,
0.3020012677,
0.6631338,
-0.1385506541,
-0.4909877181,
0.3110297322,
-0.3410933018,
-0.0110129435,
1.1401779652,
0.3738455772,
0.256364584,
-0.113146089,
-0.4861322343,
-0.3068420589,
-0.5137961507,
0.3944402337,
0.4463517964,
0.0876735151,
-0.3374797404,
0.2759996653,
-0.1081497297,
0.13933824,
0.1886731833,
-0.2524954081,
-0.2212564647,
0.0934764817,
-0.2392803282,
0.1619128138,
1.0591137409,
0.7703453302,
0.5505464077,
-0.0204166025,
-0.1642176807,
0.264087379,
0.4651333988,
-0.7854806185,
-0.1787831932,
0.0509159341,
-0.5576503277,
-0.4658720195,
0.14407745,
-0.9662162066,
-0.749569118,
-0.0407699272,
0.3279553354,
-0.070018366,
-0.2239689231,
0.0535434671,
-0.2613014281,
0.4307402968,
0.0883530006,
-0.6787570715,
0.4422205389,
0.5775156021,
0.488312602,
-0.2656815946,
-0.4292222559,
-0.2012878656,
-0.1050730273,
-0.616779089,
0.7186176181,
-0.4435792565,
-0.9050632715,
-0.0657861307,
-0.3247666359,
0.2092508972,
-0.7066538334,
0.5561300516,
-0.3243152499,
-0.0179130845,
-0.4069787562,
-0.3435086608,
-0.1716859639,
0.263972789,
-0.5839343071,
0.7266106009,
-0.094650209,
-0.3736554086,
0.3369197249,
-0.8398092985,
-0.5275508165,
-0.016496582,
-0.5600680709,
-0.2721919119,
-0.1070336178,
-0.0649091452,
0.3143479228,
-0.6704437137,
0.1434911489,
-0.6457394361,
-0.5064448118,
0.7613261342,
-0.4833305478,
0.6103566885,
0.1291900277,
-0.5362939835,
0.1688699573,
-0.1664474159,
-0.0904491767,
0.3544899821,
-0.4064045548,
-0.0218873993,
0.5374850035,
-0.4813780189,
0.5249195099,
-0.1394818425,
-0.333784312,
0.2483199835,
-0.2331839204,
0.438570112,
0.816588521,
0.2115558982,
0.4427860379,
-0.789203763,
0.4941679537,
-0.0798347592,
0.4048821926,
0.319708854,
-0.5886709094,
-0.6121103168,
-0.0229634419,
0.0169320554,
0.8719842434,
-0.6706051826,
0.1185027808,
0.0542212799,
-0.3663974702,
-0.3764144182,
-0.2187679559,
0.3493451774,
0.2821775973,
0.1761063039,
-0.2148919255,
-0.5988681316,
-0.6833850741,
-0.3778653145,
-0.8073212504,
-0.1006344184,
0.6185469031,
0.4264199734,
-0.1907255501,
0.7713749409,
-0.2315185964,
0.1502614319,
-0.3523933589,
0.4061961472,
-0.3855593503,
0.2660986483,
0.3973275423,
-0.7348974347,
-0.2965043783,
-0.2937383652,
-0.9408490062,
0.0622880571,
-0.2077331841,
-0.0552335605,
0.1704736203,
0.6147341728,
-0.5394916534,
0.502915144,
0.1741452068,
-0.1863195747,
0.7533168197,
-0.210817948,
0.472627461,
-0.7229402065,
0.0592716932,
-0.0125480639,
0.1756386161,
-1.0295184851,
0.1759054661,
-0.2874758542,
-0.1836944371,
-0.3870095909,
0.4848014116,
-0.0877080336,
-0.1435584575,
-0.2939801216,
0.0554556549,
-0.1285673529,
0.4713215232,
-0.0255685076,
0.8424326181,
0.3048567772,
-0.6888370514,
0.4509845674,
0.1124560907,
-0.1600432545,
0.487829417,
-0.8750805855,
0.2114910632,
0.1027380079,
0.0976379737,
-0.603669405,
-0.2709676325,
0.2986707985,
-0.3980563879,
0.0059536309,
0.1271686256,
-0.281204313,
-0.4680906832,
-0.3809567392,
0.1739973724,
0.8076316118,
0.2340414077,
0.5423772931,
0.6087901592,
-0.3030259311,
-0.4046584368,
-0.6808433533,
0.3603787124,
-0.4408241212,
-0.3503022194,
0.27755934,
-0.2577093542,
-0.8345311284,
-0.3504649699,
0.1471274197,
-0.1877610832,
0.5386167169,
0.5485035777,
0.400593251,
-0.1330554038,
-0.0161260553,
-0.5124659538,
-0.1094553024,
0.5988234282,
0.1290348321,
0.3821998239,
-0.1962286383,
-0.4404718876,
-0.3362060189,
0.5493601561,
0.6254841685,
-0.1478428841,
0.4964575469,
0.3271021545,
-0.0781148896,
0.2758902907,
-0.4523481727,
-0.3010543883,
-0.4480108321,
0.4625704587,
0.0369532965,
-0.6336517334,
0.4551060796,
-0.3158046305,
0.1860208213,
0.4095510244,
0.4854664505,
-0.3894479573,
1.37579,
0.6139967442,
-0.4271441102,
0.2384475917,
-0.0899101123,
0.0729555041,
-0.5120966434,
-0.1876374781,
-0.467631042,
-0.5301839709,
-0.8852610588,
-0.2623958588,
0.3752317727,
-0.3195857108,
-0.7729096413,
-0.2586053312,
-0.2437054813,
0.3634543121,
0.4706557095,
-0.0754574165,
-0.1201823577,
-0.0565669574,
0.1374277771,
0.0216924753,
-0.85612005,
-0.5557952523,
0.6538897157,
0.2707239687,
0.8636510968,
0.1063042358,
0.6019247174,
0.4701834023,
0.0571535192,
-0.8486856222,
0.7519182563,
0.0692155436,
-0.6301465034,
-0.3929299116,
-0.5029376149,
-0.9610754848,
0.0688203052,
-0.7450851202,
-0.4548718035,
-0.0699286237,
-0.017492542,
-0.7288559079,
0.2713884115,
-0.4263886809,
0.5108405948,
-0.4796484411,
-0.0676952153,
-0.1661524028,
-0.7191186547,
0.1499465257,
0.2575677633,
0.2209522426,
-0.0443766117,
-0.1494606435,
0.7160843611,
0.0241013318,
0.9150308371,
-0.0074407868,
0.0316468552,
0.3266715705,
0.2217201144,
0.4002820849,
-0.1765533537,
-0.1313907355,
0.0771715119,
-0.2964457572,
-0.4676692188,
-0.4192282856,
0.3489795029,
-1.3558610678,
-1.1504379511,
-0.5671386719,
-0.5819503069,
0.0250041783,
0.140163511,
0.2200862467,
0.3042358458,
-0.770337224,
0.0418284312,
0.8851214051,
-0.3776321411,
0.4121508896,
0.5831825137,
-0.1510788053,
-0.2254113257,
0.6860772967,
0.2029047459,
0.395500958,
0.0961225107,
0.3312442899,
-0.058056619,
-0.323595643,
-0.3711676002,
-0.0200052895,
-0.2911638618,
0.0145691996,
-0.1499242038,
-0.1921904832,
-0.1100769043,
-0.2007543594,
-0.2001867443,
0.1668434441,
-0.0194234326,
0.0153409317,
0.3331819773,
1.1569696665,
0.0051332791,
0.1450251788,
-0.4700869322,
0.2800249457,
0.3622362912,
-0.0401486196,
-0.1478740275,
-0.463321805,
-0.0417912491,
0.2544673681,
-0.3485549092,
-1.1153798103,
0.1984689385,
-0.0557363778,
0.6304748654,
0.5519116521,
0.3188461363,
0.6546168923,
-0.3723560274,
1.018055439,
-0.1395649016,
-0.6507535577,
0.0066805445,
-0.4695159197,
0.2443065047,
0.1786596328,
0.2939646244,
-0.6465100646,
-0.2092374861,
-0.8752004504,
-0.5262046456,
0.5283825994,
-0.197970584,
-0.0476244353,
0.0866030827,
0.3626832366,
-0.19806692,
0.0828805268,
-0.2343336791,
-0.4151937962,
0.0709086061,
0.1758592874,
-0.3010549843,
-0.1642937213,
-0.4772241414,
0.0829287246,
0.3564481735,
0.0788224414,
0.4106496572,
0.2497219443,
0.0044140802,
-0.3100807369,
0.375187844,
0.6840923429,
0.3722637892,
0.0965964273,
0.1357234269,
0.6616544724,
-0.177652806,
0.5053825378,
0.0185240414,
-0.2273986787,
-0.4038726985,
0.5421665907,
0.673035562,
0.3781216145,
-0.7563154697,
0.3636882007,
-0.2150419801,
-0.5919900537,
-0.1659191549,
0.2293979228,
-0.0236262456,
0.7023857236,
0.2156885862,
0.2909819186,
0.0438383892,
-0.8098909259,
0.0982821584,
0.4907403886,
-0.0215345919,
-0.2584186792,
0.4107230306,
0.5012259483,
-0.9491667747,
0.4020659924,
-0.4435634911,
-0.6549136043,
0.6973729134,
0.2537768781,
0.7925366759,
-0.2410924733,
0.5310761929,
-0.0926928893,
0.3673275113,
-0.1008389294,
0.1732812524,
0.3338008225,
-0.529178977,
-0.258228302,
0.0122088986,
-0.6820190549,
0.3537755609,
-0.6048990488,
-0.2123768926,
-0.7631720901,
-0.3695187271,
-0.3007178307,
0.4558066726,
-0.6806390285,
-0.1688692272,
0.5351908803,
0.6926426888,
-0.5995204449,
0.2708272338,
0.7096121311,
-0.2977353036,
-0.833178401,
0.2572005987,
0.129021883,
-0.4556078911,
0.5489931107,
0.0440009162,
-0.0751963928,
-0.4312817156,
-0.4998866022,
-0.7132900953,
0.9429021478,
0.4255362749,
-0.1883574575,
-0.0704935864,
0.4378676713,
0.6521551013,
-0.3197286129,
0.3972229958,
0.6883937716,
0.4987614751,
-0.2011517733,
-0.8377721906,
-0.0771094561,
-0.0716603324,
-0.0653676614,
0.0385816358,
-1.0500804186,
0.951064229,
-0.3550168872,
-0.2894901931,
-0.0517094508,
0.6288035512,
0.2597881854,
0.2506872714,
0.46083951,
0.1433415413,
0.6362528205,
0.0636205375,
1.031488657,
-0.3145564497,
-0.0751529038,
0.546672225,
-0.5421132445,
0.748175621,
0.1092836633,
-0.2209437639,
0.4992407262,
0.6770437956,
0.0344136022,
0.023127282,
0.1203052253,
-0.101132527,
-0.2478008121,
-0.0119613092,
-0.1730203032,
0.6351293325,
0.1620912403,
-0.03608004,
-0.0713412687,
-0.3166208863,
0.3700909019,
0.0478522293,
-0.289762646,
1.0030003786,
0.0166149028,
-0.7382615805,
0.4884717464,
0.1367630363,
0.6251196265,
-0.4153324664,
0.1015178189,
0.047406327,
0.0452438928,
0.0678845122,
-0.7680135965,
-0.0546877757,
0.20174326,
-0.213088572,
-0.0430915691,
0.5898464322,
-0.1817950308,
-0.2306439579,
0.2775631249,
0.727088809,
0.2879207134,
-0.0175455287,
-1.1408164501,
0.1204198301,
-0.2540490627,
-0.2952338159,
0.5362293124,
0.3112302721,
-0.1019065082,
0.7633452415,
0.5477713346,
0.272456497,
-0.1821389049,
-0.1360913664,
0.7891612053,
-0.6016294956,
-0.3325798213,
-1.1362153292,
0.055389028,
-0.3313257694,
-0.3651803434,
0.5392377973,
0.051517114,
0.5231465697,
0.0671101734,
1.0393559933,
0.0100170989,
0.0292163379,
-0.2304866612,
0.7260813713,
-0.0446402207,
0.0299541671,
-0.1385174543,
-0.3563899696,
0.0986876562,
0.5897141695,
-0.4734633267,
0.1505872458,
0.2508815229,
0.7807949781,
0.3934933841,
-0.170772776,
0.40258196,
0.340838939,
0.44487679,
0.4177190959,
1.0942553282,
-0.1173508689,
0.4869536757,
0.0020496973,
-0.3183547258,
-0.4371519685,
-0.6232527494,
-1.1295585632,
-0.33558321,
0.1829091609,
-0.0182081889,
0.2158522308,
1.3930073977,
0.4978429377,
-0.4955825806,
-0.6091123819,
0.4391935766,
0.1158320829,
-0.2490956634,
-0.1603356898,
-0.0308482517,
-0.027764,
-0.4665541053,
0.3396426439,
0.2334679216,
0.1677549928,
-0.4672400057,
-0.3999866843,
0.0075633,
0.5538482666,
0.6560063362,
0.4957011342,
-0.9114230871,
-0.3595142365,
0.1557809711,
-0.2109809518,
-0.0632374734,
0.7399778962,
-0.676273942,
0.2172691226,
0.3658304214,
0.633267343,
-0.2872582972,
0.0573965125,
0.7730687261,
-0.2252574563,
0.1975016296,
0.2311672121,
0.1119906232,
0.141308099,
-0.3331571519,
0.2249862701,
0.1252667755,
-0.9064564109,
-0.7266694307,
0.2189198583,
-0.2743979692,
-0.3214908242,
1.1344698668,
-0.1836843491,
-0.0399913378,
-0.0883309394,
-0.4678958356,
0.3485812545,
-0.7179883122,
1.131167531,
0.7905989885,
-0.3873302937,
0.0622645952,
-0.7789500356,
0.8691879511,
0.3060630858,
-0.7946864963,
0.1286835223,
0.1439351887,
-0.231795162,
0.0426059775,
0.1805776656,
0.4276703596,
0.3804309964,
0.1339897066,
-0.036044132,
-0.1442234516,
-0.3372335732,
-0.2113116533,
-0.070497945,
0.1306117922,
0.2211423665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13826v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13826v1
|
Measuring Diversity in Co-creative Image Generation
| 2024-03-06T01:55:14 | 2024-03-06T01:55:14 |
Francisco Ibarrola, Kazjon Grace
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.0
|
Quality and diversity have been proposed as reasonable heuristics for
assessing content generated by co-creative systems, but to date there has been
little agreement around what constitutes the latter or how to measure it.
Proposed approaches for assessing generative models in terms of diversity have
limitations in that they compare the model's outputs to a ground truth that in
the era of large pre-trained generative models might not be available, or
entail an impractical number of computations. We propose an alternative based
on entropy of neural network encodings for comparing diversity between sets of
images that does not require ground-truth knowledge and is easy to compute. We
also compare two pre-trained networks and show how the choice relates to the
notion of diversity that we want to evaluate. We conclude with a discussion of
the potential applications of these measures for ideation in interactive
systems, model evaluation, and more broadly within computational creativity.
|
[
-0.7738130093,
-0.1222725287,
0.0873108432,
0.5284991264,
-0.5424478054,
0.2725696862,
-0.3037729263,
-0.562584877,
0.3725202978,
-0.2131646574,
-0.5728495717,
-0.2311430126,
-0.7090594769,
0.1120777503,
-0.395369947,
0.6112192273,
-0.0109209483,
0.0990164652,
-0.5045660138,
-0.2775258422,
-0.4884281754,
0.0160677433,
-0.5469798446,
-0.2018308938,
0.689956367,
0.0671531036,
0.8669109344,
-0.0596703701,
0.7587273717,
0.4255597591,
-0.1424800456,
0.2172882855,
-0.6987969875,
0.206673786,
-0.1992042065,
-0.2782729566,
0.0995868221,
0.1699312478,
0.3638806939,
0.8260540366,
0.2834131718,
0.2667081058,
-0.0043476913,
0.5966746211,
-0.8865952492,
-0.2994555831,
-0.4737173617,
0.7964887619,
0.0210816618,
-0.1932150424,
0.0381542668,
-0.4638105929,
0.19343099,
-0.642270565,
0.3279776871,
-0.0985586792,
0.7619389296,
0.1616375446,
-0.1483746022,
-0.5931690931,
-0.9305115342,
0.8507191539,
-0.3482420743,
0.3208419085,
0.0273042265,
0.4057381153,
0.0871033818,
-0.6934009194,
-0.7888947129,
-0.1833740324,
0.4665521979,
0.6819746494,
-0.4103934169,
-0.239741832,
0.0553820096,
1.0047918558,
-0.4550791085,
0.0928352699,
-0.3086290956,
-0.137292251,
0.8153138161,
0.2858588696,
0.5767014623,
0.0369404256,
-0.2217042595,
-0.3253754377,
-0.2542140782,
0.0618379526,
0.8037769794,
-0.3384220898,
-0.2422487736,
0.7288973927,
-0.1357357055,
0.5073261261,
0.1097934842,
0.200957194,
0.1418837309,
-0.602178514,
-0.250638485,
-0.6244291067,
0.8865065575,
0.4719092846,
-0.1667976826,
-0.4317654073,
-0.2832603753,
0.046296671,
0.1712639034,
-0.8558084369,
-0.3918205202,
-0.0920206457,
-0.6060628891,
-0.2423971444,
0.3220494688,
-0.5911313295,
-0.23241961,
-0.1270087063,
0.4257831275,
-0.2475786954,
-0.4121981263,
-0.0164136644,
-1.0127863884,
-0.0499867313,
0.3856779635,
-0.6628865004,
-0.0063259387,
0.4150460362,
0.8036615252,
-0.4373459518,
-0.2689631879,
0.178837195,
-0.4701453149,
-0.7381464243,
0.6346501708,
-0.1589518189,
-0.2033206969,
-0.6265126467,
-0.4685656428,
0.153027162,
-0.6585791111,
0.2548720837,
-0.7705110908,
0.2649418116,
-0.4470181167,
-0.4547345638,
-0.2210171819,
0.109623231,
-0.8444375992,
0.4205667675,
0.5046692491,
-0.8581449986,
0.8430557847,
-0.5656876564,
-0.1901429892,
0.3892721534,
-0.4123667181,
-0.5052440763,
0.4235687256,
-0.1076721698,
-0.0347266681,
-0.3866045475,
0.4431626499,
-0.6969192624,
-0.4370141029,
0.4882688522,
-0.6591735482,
1.1242970228,
0.7423452735,
-0.199754104,
0.1344580501,
-0.6637625098,
0.2581460178,
0.1578503698,
-0.4012193084,
-0.0422712006,
-0.270052284,
-0.1109987646,
0.0966115743,
0.0254041087,
-0.4357793331,
-0.4069443643,
-0.1197164953,
0.2083109021,
0.5965704918,
-0.212410599,
0.5215795636,
-0.6099143028,
0.5696300864,
-0.0045131198,
0.0562218502,
0.0568642505,
-0.6680306792,
-0.8033518195,
-0.4993802011,
0.3809211552,
0.2861117721,
-0.8210532069,
0.8419359922,
-0.1041966081,
-0.7708986998,
-0.4070902169,
0.1781059951,
0.007973847,
0.0383686423,
0.0026647423,
-1.2048114538,
-0.6431324482,
-0.5735343099,
-0.3098551333,
0.0368855745,
-0.2270930707,
0.5591636896,
0.672467649,
0.0736900792,
0.9504907131,
-0.0350562781,
0.49371472,
-0.1601171046,
0.6869544387,
0.2752295136,
0.629208684,
0.6678723097,
-0.776992023,
-0.3877768517,
-0.2496212274,
-1.2060872316,
0.0885677412,
-0.0855747089,
-0.0187539626,
-0.4089408815,
-0.2271349728,
-0.6373968124,
0.7043348551,
0.6342756748,
-0.1888799518,
0.5179037452,
0.0161264073,
0.5859013796,
-0.5651294589,
-0.104005821,
-0.271576941,
0.2060280293,
-0.4222133756,
0.3167747557,
-0.2854023874,
-0.3711270988,
-0.5080156922,
0.173885271,
-0.5809497833,
-0.5747365952,
-0.2654808164,
-0.4335633218,
0.3183637857,
0.188173905,
0.0057284757,
0.6552003026,
0.6487175822,
-0.4559164941,
0.9024640918,
0.0056720409,
-0.9914118052,
0.6358242035,
-0.5747491717,
0.3737026155,
-0.2610959709,
0.0857502222,
-0.9608906507,
-0.2825262547,
0.2184395939,
-0.5132462978,
-0.0340184197,
0.1255670339,
-0.1853920519,
-0.6967943311,
-0.1179253981,
0.789617002,
0.6476401687,
-0.6398923993,
0.1806410551,
-0.1018149704,
0.183227405,
-0.5155024529,
-0.8260111213,
0.4538692534,
-0.4456008971,
-1.1550121307,
0.4868926704,
-0.3470599651,
-0.4268109798,
0.2337831855,
0.0789703429,
-0.2056273371,
0.4210413396,
0.1389280111,
-0.0549286455,
-0.6112518907,
-0.0832950547,
0.028193133,
0.4383473694,
-0.1425042748,
-0.5799427032,
0.3985731304,
-0.1792051941,
-0.8022267222,
-0.2931463718,
0.452575475,
0.3227764368,
-0.0889053121,
0.5887123346,
0.8258442283,
-0.0838258862,
-0.1356015503,
-0.2083642632,
0.1119932011,
-0.4580253959,
0.2653367817,
-0.1615839452,
-0.8813818097,
0.7735453844,
0.1335183382,
-0.2875209451,
0.571200788,
0.6793764234,
-0.4290352762,
0.5495497584,
0.4147080183,
0.7259417772,
0.5528898239,
-0.4534695745,
0.3033541739,
-0.3883206844,
-0.2811993659,
-0.2844071686,
-0.7642470002,
-0.5483952165,
-0.3543711305,
0.2508561015,
0.3513241708,
-0.3120780587,
0.0120033026,
-0.2443988323,
0.6418084502,
0.8649090528,
0.231338203,
0.0420324691,
0.2169502825,
0.0483943261,
0.0176701359,
-0.899892509,
-0.0648026615,
0.9423760772,
0.1594285369,
0.8927491307,
0.1209652722,
0.8587982059,
0.3137170374,
0.4570525289,
-0.7705672979,
0.4161163867,
-0.3496812284,
-0.599912107,
-0.4992953837,
-0.6830586195,
-0.8333368897,
0.1348531097,
-0.4745977223,
-0.308560729,
0.6510468125,
0.0144420853,
-0.5880624652,
0.5464311838,
-0.6202612519,
0.6148040891,
-0.5346527696,
-0.4470962882,
-0.1078291833,
-0.17619057,
0.4529642463,
-0.0680880919,
-0.1352875829,
0.1516379863,
0.3282706141,
0.9212506413,
-0.3796603382,
0.7054926157,
0.0924404562,
0.073544465,
0.8929248452,
-0.0061064567,
-0.2657731175,
0.0064687389,
-0.0458254255,
0.4493991435,
-0.4238996208,
-0.3410174251,
-0.715624094,
0.4755957723,
-1.0625030994,
-0.5071222186,
-0.0660792589,
-0.8140861392,
0.2035893649,
0.1706120968,
0.8496150374,
0.0789819434,
-0.4251488447,
0.5770164728,
0.1629455984,
-0.5706578493,
0.5697794557,
-0.1689537019,
0.0825178698,
-0.6326065063,
0.8739535809,
0.337703377,
0.3364758492,
-0.1010473222,
0.2105997205,
-0.0320951231,
-0.6216834784,
-0.3293504715,
-0.6892154217,
-0.9462383986,
-0.0824606866,
-0.3722347915,
-0.2885008454,
-0.2640235126,
-0.0661728382,
-0.235975951,
-0.6354722381,
-0.507814765,
0.120465368,
-0.0630046502,
0.6613387465,
-0.4826543033,
0.187472567,
-0.3389382064,
0.2988229692,
0.8199662566,
0.5653173923,
0.1655206978,
-0.4426528215,
-0.2678284347,
0.0446053743,
-0.7077360749,
-0.967898488,
0.2927136421,
0.1764578223,
0.6375707388,
0.4862777889,
-0.3123025596,
0.4756741822,
0.1533038467,
0.9577345848,
0.8114442825,
-0.9402464032,
0.3052290082,
-0.095947884,
0.1406239569,
0.4145645499,
0.3625370562,
-0.1807096004,
-0.3696523309,
-0.7711469531,
-0.3685393333,
0.1240312755,
0.5421490073,
0.3543066978,
-0.1003051922,
-0.040036466,
0.3354152739,
0.4188617766,
-0.7306869626,
0.0528964028,
-0.8786055446,
-0.1234577,
0.0243086573,
0.1028875336,
-0.2972950637,
-0.4094382226,
-0.0177460499,
0.1536635756,
0.4354557097,
0.0297775101,
0.0224702135,
-0.4124895036,
0.2558170259,
0.4563647509,
0.6679465771,
-0.0185367297,
0.5388844609,
0.058760386,
-0.2422120571,
0.2667620182,
-0.3541134596,
-0.3212909102,
0.0448606201,
0.474189043,
1.1414200068,
-0.414634496,
-0.3674235642,
0.497905612,
-0.0826940835,
-0.2770177126,
-0.1680985689,
0.5387095213,
0.140004307,
0.341943711,
0.0177268498,
0.8316446543,
0.1450410783,
-0.6717948318,
0.1067778394,
0.6151527166,
-0.2762609422,
-0.3736340702,
0.2424160689,
0.2100829929,
-0.5644595623,
0.9133206606,
-0.716779232,
-0.2507238388,
1.3516290188,
0.618866086,
1.0328179598,
0.0563693009,
0.2869360149,
0.4235278964,
0.3503981531,
0.0306458529,
0.4835462272,
-0.1906242818,
-1.168153882,
-0.1981618553,
-0.2842768133,
-0.214659825,
0.2738689184,
-0.499332428,
0.0155365895,
-0.527235508,
-0.5643917322,
-0.0784148872,
-0.4689753056,
-1.0895467997,
0.5091198683,
0.3571048081,
0.647703588,
-0.9191499949,
0.1480584443,
0.5531126857,
-0.5611694455,
-0.5228077173,
-0.2275204659,
-0.377015233,
-0.5624340773,
0.997421205,
0.057649307,
-0.0450256988,
-0.286414206,
-1.0326442719,
-0.847990036,
1.1424982548,
0.4482338428,
-0.3138386905,
0.2331761569,
-0.0232988652,
0.5293007493,
-0.6835083365,
0.3896166682,
-0.0168637615,
0.271216929,
0.4986524284,
-0.4768954515,
-0.4118764699,
-0.713057518,
0.0851726755,
-0.3621328175,
-0.3652418852,
1.2528645992,
-0.5227057934,
-0.6080292463,
0.2534797192,
0.8657569289,
0.250454396,
0.648786664,
0.7291901708,
0.7976973057,
0.807169795,
-0.1471414715,
0.8866701126,
0.081589818,
0.4868333936,
0.8530497551,
0.0608302243,
0.1816806644,
0.3478425145,
-0.24806723,
0.3608891666,
0.8836121559,
-0.6023128629,
0.679212451,
0.6466777921,
-0.3009407222,
-0.4806782901,
-0.1217252314,
-0.3658722639,
0.4631082714,
0.1999958903,
-0.4793175459,
-0.1173799857,
0.0953576267,
-0.8663698435,
-0.142196551,
-0.239174366,
0.7003917694,
0.1008653566,
-0.8014546037,
0.5957828164,
-0.1359943151,
0.7541151643,
0.064875178,
0.1353261918,
-0.4201344848,
-0.3998434246,
-0.3426365554,
-1.1339623928,
0.479028374,
0.0110355606,
-0.1231060997,
0.0562699698,
0.7784969807,
-0.0702702701,
-0.5094742179,
0.1206823885,
0.5994437337,
0.1407279968,
0.1592192054,
-0.5931836367,
0.0275509227,
-0.2879530489,
-0.0270671155,
-0.2032893002,
0.5520735979,
0.0903085172,
0.3664794266,
0.4948787391,
0.0460721552,
0.28160882,
0.1393050402,
0.5438756347,
-0.4097058773,
-0.6853382587,
-0.7431868911,
0.3624107242,
-0.1901149303,
-0.409142375,
0.5205737352,
0.3411295414,
0.9493271112,
-0.308598429,
1.1116213799,
-0.1913858056,
-0.3668169975,
-0.2804966867,
0.6889162064,
-0.6119305491,
0.1037830561,
-0.2569314539,
-0.9144670963,
-0.1288833469,
0.575457871,
-0.3206745684,
0.38335374,
0.4469612241,
0.6536323428,
-0.4374070168,
0.4950830936,
0.3439933658,
-0.3036655188,
-0.0342924111,
0.5303231478,
1.792432189,
-0.1199925542,
0.1532661915,
-0.2225670218,
-0.4544368684,
0.0993981212,
-0.9282853603,
-0.8009239435,
-0.4676599503,
-0.2708774507,
-0.2998237908,
-0.1863718331,
0.6817851067,
0.8603865504,
-0.638194561,
-0.2281498015,
-0.3684478104,
0.1311585605,
-0.2771890461,
-0.0494733788,
-0.034310177,
-0.0483631268,
-0.2739590406,
0.1766137779,
0.401783824,
0.3512049317,
-0.464248538,
-0.2437942177,
0.5459789634,
0.2434345484,
0.4666418433,
0.1251389533,
-0.5991374254,
-0.0237967353,
0.1137413308,
0.0283512045,
0.2411146015,
0.8360369205,
-0.2043607235,
0.6588984132,
1.1109172106,
0.7476016283,
0.3442318439,
-0.2935478091,
0.4751118124,
-0.5557576418,
0.0119673852,
0.3255882561,
0.2623870969,
0.5347067118,
-0.1865565181,
0.1646092236,
0.597433567,
-0.1558660865,
-0.2865851521,
0.6429581046,
-0.7950366139,
-0.166173175,
0.6202796102,
-0.5608165264,
-0.064673394,
0.1173237488,
0.2462386042,
0.2902938724,
0.1291564256,
0.9885431528,
0.6793003082,
-0.0340679921,
-0.1905777305,
-0.0213262048,
0.1425693929,
0.3900020719,
-0.8126341701,
-0.8108842969,
0.3787270486,
0.191074416,
0.6202779412,
0.5537326336,
-0.0332688317,
0.573649168,
0.3484110236,
0.1817644238,
-0.0269506648,
-0.3464567065,
-0.1222742423,
0.4406271577,
0.1157523319,
0.0001826996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03396v1
|
Japanese-English Sentence Translation Exercises Dataset for Automatic Grading
| 2024-03-06T01:37:03 | 2024-03-06T01:37:03 |
Naoki Miura, Hiroaki Funayama, Seiya Kikuchi, Yuichiroh Matsubayashi, Yuya Iwase, Kentaro Inui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper proposes the task of automatic assessment of Sentence Translation
Exercises (STEs), that have been used in the early stage of L2 language
learning. We formalize the task as grading student responses for each rubric
criterion pre-specified by the educators. We then create a dataset for STE
between Japanese and English including 21 questions, along with a total of 3,
498 student responses (167 on average). The answer responses were collected
from students and crowd workers. Using this dataset, we demonstrate the
performance of baselines including finetuned BERT and GPT models with few-shot
in-context learning. Experimental results show that the baseline model with
finetuned BERT was able to classify correct responses with approximately 90% in
F1, but only less than 80% for incorrect responses. Furthermore, the GPT models
with few-shot learning show poorer results than finetuned BERT, indicating that
our newly proposed task presents a challenging issue, even for the
stateof-the-art large language models.
|
[
-0.1226802319,
-1.0976910591,
0.3332298696,
0.1359845549,
-0.2392506748,
-0.0554135367,
-0.2630628943,
-0.322596997,
-0.1585896611,
0.3251647949,
-0.4055757821,
-0.3786669075,
-0.7144523263,
0.4163879752,
-0.5054249167,
1.2395105362,
-0.5790629387,
0.5631073713,
0.03715422,
-0.1824563146,
-0.5427803993,
-0.1317130327,
-0.8401790261,
-0.0481791347,
0.1026083753,
0.6421987414,
0.4739408791,
0.3135295808,
0.7799256444,
0.2966965735,
0.29266572,
0.0258107595,
-0.3985920846,
0.1083839834,
0.0162109528,
-0.5815702081,
-0.3039448559,
0.152311042,
0.8024563789,
0.8547767401,
0.2546173036,
0.3584976196,
0.1490450352,
0.5265160799,
0.0597657673,
0.181577608,
-0.4393449426,
0.2180862576,
-0.081711784,
0.1643387973,
-0.5442474484,
-0.3837835789,
0.0264664125,
-0.7382535338,
0.1080595627,
0.1418938637,
1.0272676945,
0.2481420487,
-0.4795476794,
-0.4421575963,
-0.2078497708,
0.7151978612,
-0.505063951,
0.1800622493,
0.5056301951,
0.2638740242,
-0.0541609973,
-0.6015579104,
-0.2337026745,
-0.2371604592,
-0.2428599149,
0.3028415442,
0.0861544311,
0.1327745765,
0.3018114269,
0.3351207376,
-0.9637841582,
0.2090663761,
-0.4864559174,
-0.1656606644,
0.7837257385,
0.2423001826,
0.4496244192,
-0.6160436273,
-0.360860616,
-0.2576800585,
-0.5246264935,
0.2745840847,
0.3286991119,
0.3467543721,
-0.236999929,
0.7510770559,
-0.0163456518,
0.6566051841,
-0.059472926,
0.0539947301,
0.1204228178,
-0.5376181602,
-0.2773601115,
-0.1769559383,
0.9798539281,
0.3728118539,
0.3645281494,
-0.0678724945,
-0.3949246407,
0.0755917132,
0.0432879478,
-0.722299099,
-0.0842290968,
-0.0366204046,
-0.1985663027,
-0.2569266558,
-0.1486986727,
-0.5432181954,
0.1960977316,
-0.4404223859,
0.5949681997,
-0.3764151633,
0.2445160002,
-0.0064279358,
-0.020025529,
0.0597032271,
0.5143588781,
-0.4561711848,
0.4932728112,
0.4534596503,
0.7968649268,
-0.2321966439,
-0.2735208869,
-0.6043118834,
-0.18314825,
-0.4858861864,
0.6196841598,
-0.2631449699,
-0.3271803558,
-0.0409804061,
0.2784149051,
-0.1660857201,
-0.1245581582,
0.5159253478,
-0.4181854427,
0.8576078415,
-0.2313878089,
-0.9046684504,
-0.0967569202,
0.2638483346,
-0.357003063,
1.1685082912,
0.3613139689,
-0.5705869198,
0.2722911835,
-0.8944496512,
-0.6109161973,
0.2465971857,
-0.1341401935,
-0.2903648317,
-0.0426358618,
0.2706773579,
0.5609381795,
0.0944060236,
0.2913633287,
-0.1027849689,
-0.6032820344,
0.1605063975,
-0.2592046261,
0.7181833982,
0.3854395151,
-0.3555830717,
-0.1630392522,
-0.4395788312,
0.1691579968,
0.1034034342,
-0.3404580057,
-0.5395844579,
-0.5204936266,
0.2427234501,
0.1545278132,
0.1319878548,
-0.4928792417,
0.5869244933,
-0.4921551645,
0.2421635389,
0.780713141,
0.1680012941,
0.5321460366,
-0.1174936965,
0.6869193316,
-0.0767300576,
0.0287561584,
-0.0162475146,
-0.7021839619,
-0.5745899677,
0.0685286447,
0.4794139862,
0.6818692684,
-0.9533762336,
0.5074040294,
-0.5753282309,
-0.3357360661,
-0.8149135113,
0.3990670145,
0.672051549,
0.3419461846,
0.3291254938,
-0.4532045126,
-0.3754379451,
-0.7341210842,
-0.2782738209,
-0.3193980455,
-0.0318818949,
0.1011158153,
0.7242822051,
-0.013125076,
0.7129528522,
-0.3837206364,
-0.5463755131,
-0.2499642223,
0.620829463,
-0.0395730324,
0.4345418513,
0.4078900516,
-0.5066248775,
-0.7769669294,
-0.0808513835,
-0.7329630852,
-0.2672380507,
-0.2291273326,
-0.2339753956,
0.1784901023,
0.3950556219,
-0.2120414674,
0.2250071466,
0.3533299863,
-0.2845759392,
0.153158918,
-0.035179805,
0.4098338187,
-1.2430686951,
0.1151654199,
0.2049194723,
-0.5688930154,
-0.4955452085,
0.1653084308,
0.1066227555,
-0.1493988335,
-0.4621070027,
0.729174912,
-0.2880395651,
-0.2563530803,
-0.1152150035,
0.3351403475,
0.0644111484,
0.4433328211,
0.0895194933,
0.9020675421,
0.1650777608,
-0.4707434773,
0.2828958333,
0.515941143,
-0.5444784164,
0.4628160298,
-0.6007900834,
0.2579748034,
-0.2086805254,
0.3661338985,
-1.282220602,
-0.422706604,
0.1644548178,
-0.6564309597,
0.2490246147,
-0.1401681751,
-0.4821895361,
-0.4593832493,
-0.2046053112,
0.229235813,
0.5629449487,
-0.1705634743,
-0.1273291111,
0.0893615633,
-0.4936385453,
-0.485589534,
-0.854539156,
-0.018413648,
-0.0435890406,
-0.3727429509,
0.0076402822,
-0.1007784829,
-0.2472453117,
0.030507518,
0.1194075495,
-0.2113133371,
0.1864150912,
-0.0355937369,
0.2100870162,
-0.2427076548,
0.1175143644,
0.3231112063,
0.0942312703,
-0.0473708585,
0.1640319526,
0.3442215919,
-0.2804272175,
-0.2374935895,
-0.4707953632,
0.2338364124,
0.499127537,
0.0821599215,
0.2621432543,
0.7226443887,
-0.4444411397,
0.1291998923,
-0.3736396134,
-0.2161570787,
-0.3868926167,
0.67660743,
-0.4923320711,
-0.5419425964,
0.3624944091,
0.3005054891,
0.4317598939,
0.3843684793,
0.4746981263,
-0.4727706611,
1.1764169931,
0.2223910391,
-0.2934526801,
0.4869900942,
-0.4504182041,
-0.0219330173,
-0.7298667431,
0.1188597605,
-0.5540397763,
-0.5118467212,
-0.4025767148,
-0.2222550213,
0.5564413071,
0.2107140124,
-0.112621963,
0.5409680605,
-0.2792159915,
0.4572710693,
0.2906978726,
0.1185442582,
0.3069293201,
0.1206283048,
-0.1094137952,
-0.2799866796,
-0.453993082,
-0.7056456804,
1.2496541739,
0.5073708296,
0.599817276,
0.0074340287,
0.7364744544,
0.3321768641,
0.654376328,
-1.000074625,
0.5746446252,
-0.3637344241,
-0.7529321909,
-0.6678443551,
-0.5228258967,
-0.8695377707,
0.1541080624,
0.2221297175,
-0.1753003597,
-0.2351673543,
-0.2371726185,
-0.2317726761,
-0.1106263772,
-0.7940524817,
0.8364160061,
-0.4718212783,
-0.3319925666,
0.0197844431,
-0.885058701,
0.3856357336,
-0.0172630288,
0.5234637856,
0.0637587532,
0.1339167953,
1.1223535538,
-0.2608759403,
0.6714597344,
-0.4954403639,
-0.1710683703,
0.2598628998,
0.1977301836,
0.5647708178,
0.1325029731,
-0.0308619756,
-0.3640260696,
0.1144159585,
-0.454932332,
-0.4718115032,
0.419795692,
-0.8890747428,
-0.1304011345,
-0.3541892171,
-0.6509487033,
-0.1485988349,
0.1709670722,
0.3835179508,
0.2422888577,
-0.2536985576,
0.2110441923,
0.4184499681,
-0.0300950613,
0.1688744426,
0.7899162173,
-0.2157023549,
-0.4028989971,
0.5243939161,
0.1954567283,
0.4489301443,
0.2479989976,
-0.0016992135,
-0.3994512558,
-0.4014746249,
-0.8089638352,
0.1543224156,
-0.9436550736,
-0.2762690783,
-0.3859426677,
0.096118018,
-0.61466223,
-0.2125433683,
-0.1987610906,
-0.3889712691,
0.0198712368,
-0.2742615342,
0.098609522,
0.8119703531,
0.2265449613,
0.2222592235,
-0.6334782839,
0.3929556608,
0.051185064,
0.0684064403,
-0.5619364977,
-0.9812529683,
-0.3328745365,
0.3667159975,
-0.411437422,
-0.7150643468,
0.2238281816,
0.2646607757,
0.3259937763,
0.1467435509,
-0.107535243,
1.0153859854,
-0.4274096489,
1.0741415024,
0.0485732928,
-0.9201168418,
0.7787786126,
-0.1933000982,
0.1018932834,
0.9989668727,
0.5218756795,
-0.7397468686,
-0.8118673563,
-0.5303023458,
-0.5774964094,
0.800786972,
0.2016931474,
0.280629009,
-0.0323463082,
0.459081918,
0.1875414401,
-0.0120857321,
-1.0482242107,
-0.0310460478,
-0.0386076272,
-0.7089884281,
-0.2405564785,
0.195467785,
-0.0395463519,
-0.6202185154,
0.8136318922,
-0.2977412045,
0.2066480368,
0.2246741056,
-0.6314042807,
-0.4361245036,
0.3741672039,
0.4726943374,
0.1388425976,
-0.2484863847,
-0.1957744062,
0.3491710424,
-0.4912938476,
0.4747391045,
-0.0487442203,
-0.4097964168,
0.2224933207,
0.41927284,
0.8359465003,
0.3714931011,
-0.5377831459,
0.9227871895,
-0.0398385152,
-0.3301865757,
-0.2173178643,
-0.1196874529,
-0.5787460208,
-0.23954992,
0.1575670689,
-0.0921527296,
0.2287260741,
-0.5742593408,
0.3060068488,
0.247787267,
-0.4346915483,
-0.3039070666,
0.4909096062,
0.2083512396,
0.0226683486,
0.6493329406,
-0.3750988245,
-0.6580569744,
0.5474352241,
0.4492154121,
0.7057387829,
-0.2962267399,
0.223322928,
0.6298539639,
0.4798715711,
-0.2976301908,
0.2865393758,
-0.0089096352,
-0.3999881744,
-0.2394567728,
-0.5671388507,
-0.4280784428,
0.2265374213,
-0.9569328427,
0.4952322245,
-0.1214838102,
-0.0387142301,
-0.3056137562,
0.3111774325,
-0.7756772637,
0.382437706,
0.0406993106,
0.6689949036,
-1.3301793337,
0.9102082253,
1.1263303757,
-0.6660274267,
-0.6838039756,
-0.0859229565,
-0.2467599511,
-0.9626020193,
1.0606662035,
0.1107010096,
0.3070906997,
0.1725679785,
-0.4434677958,
-0.5339962244,
0.8794105649,
0.0659970641,
-0.4452792704,
-0.405430764,
0.4432246983,
0.6866623163,
-0.0987527072,
0.5233343244,
0.3747113943,
0.6035530567,
-0.2896754742,
-1.0536044836,
-0.2334125489,
-0.3423991799,
-0.0197856352,
-0.0685078427,
-0.4282669425,
0.6044137478,
0.1161444485,
-0.1982603073,
0.2535111308,
0.4551923871,
-0.0644532219,
0.2213552147,
0.5828303099,
0.5254927874,
0.5624201298,
-0.332192421,
0.9382597208,
-0.2064626515,
0.544443965,
0.9380316138,
-0.1876913756,
1.0364992619,
0.5094383955,
-0.3924164176,
0.2422869653,
0.6817192435,
-0.0303125158,
0.5044806004,
0.4054362774,
0.2205382586,
-0.1181156188,
0.1557885408,
-0.3749902546,
0.2934015095,
0.3810278773,
-0.3952281475,
-0.2625657618,
0.5826439857,
0.0746230185,
0.1639688164,
-0.1902567148,
0.9629979134,
0.1782287806,
-1.0680913925,
0.6265605092,
0.2632003427,
0.7055264115,
-0.5723093152,
0.1823923141,
-0.5633323193,
0.134032473,
-0.1473977417,
-1.0444660187,
0.2285516411,
0.4699637294,
0.103618376,
-0.5508224964,
0.3512651324,
-0.6883277297,
-0.6612943411,
-0.1082104445,
0.3407952189,
0.5035215616,
0.4025901854,
-0.8689596057,
-0.1532367319,
-0.0366127752,
-0.3904361129,
0.2124062926,
0.3438600898,
-0.1059628502,
0.4275846481,
0.2220574319,
-0.0339372642,
0.2276738435,
0.1222779006,
0.3118056059,
-0.2900542617,
-0.4449143112,
-0.4742326438,
0.4419665635,
0.0540198423,
-0.362318784,
0.7554491162,
0.7485058904,
0.9617226124,
-0.3065178096,
0.8385128379,
-0.0838733763,
0.5796039701,
-0.6989181638,
0.4745722413,
-0.6861082911,
0.0704175681,
-0.429477036,
-0.6124402881,
-0.2341997623,
0.9183505177,
-0.3934445977,
-0.1509842128,
1.0042994022,
0.4955477118,
0.0338401124,
-0.0487085097,
0.1305263191,
0.1159268543,
0.5195118189,
0.951823175,
0.6159460545,
-1.2496491671,
0.3341438174,
-0.3549152911,
-0.0806964859,
-0.2612889707,
-0.4083373249,
-0.7981908321,
-0.6867700219,
-0.5851889849,
-0.2860348523,
0.0733113587,
1.1658235788,
0.3294776082,
-0.9337291718,
-0.3109045029,
-0.2000087351,
-0.2909882665,
-0.1133107468,
-0.328678906,
0.427764684,
-0.8372429013,
-1.0507501364,
0.3542024195,
-0.2564321756,
0.3771388233,
-0.1016251892,
-0.2328587025,
-0.0981804207,
-0.2457318753,
0.5716181397,
-0.0805713162,
-0.751301527,
-0.359360069,
0.0836458504,
-0.5818683505,
-0.056667354,
0.4707201719,
-0.4457147121,
0.391803056,
0.5952926278,
0.5636244416,
0.3226171434,
0.116728723,
0.5417885184,
-1.145195961,
0.2005127817,
0.3241793513,
0.3510041535,
0.2755957246,
-0.1740041971,
0.6009503603,
0.343954742,
-0.4641215801,
-1.1918460131,
0.0157407187,
-0.8024311066,
-0.0342404321,
1.2195314169,
-0.3826597035,
-0.033750467,
0.0347519703,
-0.3669595122,
0.4313686192,
-0.078405492,
0.7247441411,
1.2044546604,
0.2190456539,
0.1193519831,
-0.720151782,
0.4869431555,
0.8161299229,
-1.0720304251,
-0.0247816667,
0.4126024544,
0.3696353436,
0.0146753257,
0.59681952,
-0.2665568888,
0.3846482337,
-0.4334434271,
-0.0390601046,
0.1063083112,
-0.2566176951,
-0.4293998182,
-0.1208095625,
0.0823106617,
-0.1867817193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03348v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03348v3
|
Learning to Maximize Mutual Information for Chain-of-Thought Distillation
| 2024-03-05T22:21:45 | 2024-06-09T14:24:54 |
Xin Chen, Hanxian Huang, Yanjun Gao, Yi Wang, Jishen Zhao, Ke Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge distillation, the technique of transferring knowledge from large,
complex models to smaller ones, marks a pivotal step towards efficient AI
deployment. Distilling Step-by-Step~(DSS), a novel method utilizing
chain-of-thought~(CoT) distillation, has demonstrated promise by imbuing
smaller models with the superior reasoning capabilities of their larger
counterparts. In DSS, the distilled model acquires the ability to generate
rationales and predict labels concurrently through a multi-task learning
framework. However, DSS overlooks the intrinsic relationship between the two
training tasks, leading to ineffective integration of CoT knowledge with the
task of label prediction. To this end, we investigate the mutual relationship
of the two tasks from Information Bottleneck perspective and formulate it as
maximizing the mutual information of the representation features of the two
tasks. We propose a variational approach to solve this optimization problem
using a learning-based method. Our experimental results across four datasets
demonstrate that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art DSS. Our findings
offer insightful guidance for future research on language model distillation as
well as applications involving CoT. Codes are available at
\url{https://github.com/xinchen9/cot_distillation_ACL2024}.
|
[
-0.6157162786,
-0.7216727734,
0.6861709952,
-0.1184984595,
-0.4370702803,
0.3295386136,
-0.2452279329,
-0.3166016042,
-0.0492253639,
0.3028059602,
-0.7044664621,
-0.2830974758,
-1.0088781118,
0.0408244058,
-0.1733668447,
1.2983492613,
-0.2619904876,
-0.0223251916,
-0.354172945,
-0.0613977611,
-0.3538650572,
-0.4542999864,
-0.5155456066,
-0.5488911867,
0.5437240601,
0.1660250425,
0.2184337825,
0.5029509664,
0.2347323745,
0.3183340132,
-0.3798493147,
0.3921941519,
-0.6840879321,
0.4215590358,
-0.1953748763,
-0.880018115,
-0.0015230097,
0.1460980326,
0.0958521515,
0.802466929,
-0.2439180613,
0.2125604153,
0.41139552,
1.0975497961,
-0.8515732884,
0.3054405153,
-0.7276311517,
0.125225991,
0.1385091096,
0.0088808648,
-0.1869474649,
-0.2865939438,
0.4757076502,
-0.4868896604,
0.300688535,
0.1138580143,
0.5524017215,
0.5414181352,
-0.4912745953,
-0.5036916733,
-0.8363313675,
0.8032240272,
-0.3881217837,
0.1868570894,
0.5238067508,
0.4792035222,
-0.157768935,
-0.6571987271,
-0.6554536223,
-0.3013198674,
-0.0385089554,
-0.2050470114,
-0.2096899897,
0.0588983819,
0.4379398823,
0.5926760435,
-0.1897741109,
-0.3825272918,
-0.4990841448,
0.0872902498,
0.4064691961,
0.0385213941,
-0.0221461039,
0.3784455955,
-0.7046221495,
-0.1770852953,
-0.2032146901,
-0.2264138907,
0.0807795972,
0.2301146537,
-0.1224099398,
0.3528454006,
-0.2222867906,
0.7562175393,
0.4333600998,
-0.263679415,
0.4066914916,
-0.4046385884,
-0.3389034867,
-0.1097219512,
0.718231082,
0.0766442567,
-0.1038129628,
-0.1140398607,
-0.3292344213,
-0.1016248167,
0.1608845443,
-0.6552684903,
-0.1240677685,
-0.0216734782,
-0.181502521,
-0.4556179941,
-0.0610180832,
-0.7431876659,
-0.4268305004,
-0.6735345721,
0.3445598185,
-0.35709849,
-0.2934142649,
-0.0168120954,
-0.378359884,
-0.4618152678,
0.1518811435,
-0.8051935434,
0.2936995924,
0.4554750621,
1.0206243992,
-0.200926125,
-0.1011623964,
-0.4016611278,
0.253567189,
-0.3336824477,
0.26253286,
-0.253878355,
-0.3689187169,
-0.4492070079,
-0.4158978462,
0.1175697148,
-0.6338024139,
0.1872791201,
-0.447324723,
-0.1758178025,
-0.5227752924,
-0.5521489978,
-0.1583337933,
0.2068929821,
-0.892305851,
0.8545107841,
0.0395505764,
-1.0508491993,
0.4384479225,
-0.4982261956,
-0.3734740019,
-0.2271044701,
-0.4501978159,
-0.263915807,
0.3068794608,
0.1038386673,
0.4198994637,
-0.6651859283,
0.5158655047,
-0.2740356028,
-0.0390712507,
0.0826694071,
-0.6634899974,
0.6659400463,
0.4687651098,
-0.4743603468,
-0.3833394349,
-0.6838549972,
-0.4198410511,
-0.0670135617,
-0.2293734252,
-0.6301696897,
-0.1378163397,
-0.5696823001,
0.231393382,
0.3396158218,
-0.2811177373,
0.2326994389,
0.0173866954,
0.279060185,
0.7312529683,
0.1567687392,
0.3912625015,
-0.3637363017,
0.4373520613,
0.5007517934,
0.1227623597,
0.2444892377,
-0.2266307771,
-0.7544576526,
-0.0435470454,
0.1907154769,
0.2222607285,
-1.1337485313,
0.4101099074,
0.0474557467,
-0.6734265685,
-0.1965665072,
0.1930040419,
0.5240781307,
0.6543874741,
0.3965439498,
-0.3264730573,
-0.4220975339,
-0.624335289,
0.0504080132,
-0.1393583119,
0.0944796056,
0.1317540556,
0.3201912045,
-0.1709405631,
0.6785801649,
-0.9459195733,
-0.3109860122,
-0.287188381,
0.7771427631,
0.4198532403,
0.3928951919,
0.5859475732,
-0.9755201936,
-0.7898888588,
-0.0003653523,
-0.6856211424,
0.1222990006,
-0.0177225415,
-0.2186898291,
0.0185401328,
0.5865494013,
-0.2951692045,
0.4137565792,
0.5063778758,
0.0424856246,
0.5921437144,
-0.4287156463,
0.2448142916,
-1.1807830334,
-0.0197851118,
0.2132058144,
-0.0652128085,
-0.5324953794,
-0.2817429006,
-0.3486599624,
0.2220606357,
-0.1541019231,
0.0086673005,
-0.6673560143,
0.2831816077,
-0.4999562204,
0.0202091858,
0.1638115346,
0.7145322561,
-0.1703439355,
0.6876577735,
0.7403082252,
-0.756265223,
0.6259940863,
-0.0541926958,
-0.3198382854,
0.6274422407,
-0.2891798913,
0.0831200927,
-0.3011146486,
0.2738014162,
-0.8097135425,
0.2099723667,
0.1533278972,
-0.2800495327,
0.555041492,
-0.0794353038,
-0.187879324,
-0.4630349278,
-0.0532557294,
0.5289378762,
0.4180971682,
-0.4907058775,
0.684391737,
0.5969869494,
0.0844936594,
-0.9020787477,
-0.7113676071,
-0.3684069514,
-0.3249717653,
-0.0823891684,
0.2325361073,
-0.0280041192,
-0.1043802127,
0.0486642197,
-0.7223431468,
-0.467030108,
-0.1882845759,
0.146650508,
0.3586015105,
0.0589129515,
0.1956732869,
0.2492637038,
-0.0893335342,
0.0481646806,
-0.585496068,
0.4441294968,
-0.0142237116,
-0.0644061938,
-0.5440297723,
0.235165894,
0.7300621867,
0.2173231691,
0.8854510784,
0.511169672,
-0.1916636974,
-0.3633795679,
-0.5288821459,
-0.0948048085,
-0.5148635507,
0.3967975974,
-0.7985554338,
-0.5186834335,
0.1789639592,
-0.5264311433,
-0.1886687577,
0.3598425388,
0.2527573109,
-0.2098337412,
0.611905992,
0.9749592543,
-0.5355032086,
0.576479733,
-0.6913534403,
0.2810944319,
-0.78455621,
-0.3744428456,
-0.525118351,
-0.4040447772,
-0.3980314434,
-0.7734531164,
0.5036604404,
0.4002773464,
-0.0637777895,
0.5437702537,
-0.4431563318,
0.5689026713,
0.6502648592,
0.4479343891,
0.3695395291,
0.0075626047,
-0.5516793132,
0.1957704425,
-0.7852278352,
-0.1421940327,
1.2052125931,
0.0708663762,
0.9737529755,
-0.4039721489,
1.0472362041,
0.364023149,
-0.1700396687,
-0.3976805806,
0.3433097899,
-0.2912565768,
-0.3812059164,
-0.3636784554,
-0.7005084157,
-0.4800696075,
0.1711425483,
-0.0873222873,
-0.7024023533,
0.3479919434,
0.3723912239,
-0.0521507673,
0.5633662343,
-0.4655832946,
0.412643224,
-0.2901556492,
-0.4462759495,
-0.5816376805,
-0.8527778387,
0.3545694053,
-0.2107334733,
0.3466103077,
-0.0317189768,
0.1735369265,
0.6796762943,
-0.5762043595,
0.8255721927,
-0.2551701963,
-0.1946088672,
0.5198540688,
0.0673244745,
0.5506547689,
-0.2245937288,
0.0626088455,
0.092878744,
-0.000439133,
-0.1702402979,
-0.8376424909,
0.5672572255,
-0.6782616377,
-0.6108836532,
-0.4807753861,
-0.4127768874,
-0.2924456,
-0.008905665,
0.3551042378,
0.1322523057,
-0.1025836319,
-0.035801243,
0.8159630895,
0.1294988841,
0.3279323578,
0.0862446949,
-0.0221075285,
-0.3002630174,
0.9403171539,
-0.0500584878,
0.6391680241,
0.6089920998,
0.1688615233,
-0.3199261725,
-0.3168261945,
-0.1670464873,
0.0924686044,
-0.7214615345,
-0.288060993,
-0.5017737746,
-0.2517765462,
-0.0083266851,
0.0694693103,
-0.5765989423,
-0.294600904,
-0.3994966745,
-0.1602693349,
0.2667215765,
0.8664413691,
-0.4115784764,
-0.0169667155,
-0.7153015137,
0.5721089244,
0.4231462479,
0.1871372461,
0.3125896752,
-0.207992658,
-0.3719497025,
0.5912425518,
-0.4695060253,
-0.7847139239,
0.0376164801,
0.1393691599,
0.628839314,
0.4579775631,
0.3933830261,
0.7189028263,
-0.2552630901,
0.5191196799,
0.7030563354,
-1.1176577806,
0.6024110913,
0.3295705616,
0.0509869568,
0.8943267465,
0.9275475144,
-0.3846238256,
-0.465231657,
-0.4140641391,
-0.9026401043,
0.5985543728,
0.2899926603,
-0.1961770356,
0.2565772831,
0.2165372074,
0.4105868638,
0.430319488,
-0.5825958252,
-0.4019926488,
0.2869538665,
-0.1863621026,
-0.0043878057,
-0.0409104079,
-0.1091794893,
-0.4029901326,
0.8179998994,
0.0232497882,
-0.0382913277,
0.078657113,
-0.1115035638,
0.0125087788,
-0.1033478677,
0.2022016197,
0.5880033374,
-0.0152141647,
0.3099724948,
0.1597967297,
-0.5254357457,
0.4425528049,
-0.2455060035,
0.1583794653,
0.0159236696,
0.1129396036,
1.2125732899,
-0.2647269964,
-0.4028349519,
0.4770569801,
-0.1155274659,
-0.2580945492,
0.19817774,
0.2885205746,
0.0956257805,
0.6438866854,
0.3835084438,
0.2501549423,
0.3113372922,
-0.5600526333,
0.3293218017,
0.2179209441,
-0.4644000828,
0.015000809,
0.5651068687,
0.1702240556,
0.1363867074,
0.4125794172,
-0.1823285818,
-0.5080016255,
0.7074551582,
0.2773082554,
0.9996775985,
-0.1502529681,
0.2802354097,
0.485994786,
-0.1467824131,
-0.2774316967,
-0.0346098877,
-0.7614860535,
-0.349239409,
-0.0503947847,
-0.8109939694,
-0.2860836387,
-0.0450549275,
-0.8706602454,
0.3232669234,
-0.2170065194,
-0.3159388304,
-0.0112887528,
-0.0604972169,
-0.6992915869,
0.2777339518,
0.0845066309,
0.5457780957,
-0.9976943135,
1.0101534128,
0.1817905158,
-0.5722908974,
-0.8062005043,
0.3279630244,
-0.1147580743,
-0.5154315233,
0.7637205124,
0.0452496037,
-0.3805865645,
-0.2984946966,
-0.4580567777,
-0.8018251657,
1.2677276134,
0.3385925889,
-1.233289361,
-0.2099743932,
0.1473768502,
0.5090532899,
-0.5107463002,
0.0639873371,
0.6516051888,
0.0566532239,
0.6368780136,
-0.9704462886,
0.1167067587,
-0.1099255159,
0.2009504437,
0.2240705937,
-0.4374036789,
0.8153745532,
-0.3774515092,
-0.0683969185,
-0.2657355964,
0.520825386,
0.2282983363,
0.3634619713,
0.7323291302,
0.5462674499,
0.9175909758,
0.1361239254,
0.5420660377,
-0.2853235602,
0.5194236636,
1.4771097898,
-0.0924453735,
0.5076537132,
0.760428071,
-0.4684395194,
0.6009452939,
0.3824242055,
0.2194852829,
0.9996235371,
0.5189985633,
-0.5216261744,
0.2069330812,
0.1138000488,
-0.4487438798,
0.0565890931,
0.4537241161,
-0.5936493278,
-0.1503830552,
0.2700548172,
-0.2473616749,
-0.0245470088,
-0.000380777,
1.1297447681,
0.1417862624,
-0.7141602635,
0.9426962733,
-0.357116282,
0.6502897143,
-0.5433910489,
0.0543512367,
-0.1538866758,
0.0476315022,
0.1885581017,
-0.3929930627,
0.2994259596,
-0.089395836,
-0.3413067162,
-0.0673954636,
0.3122698665,
-0.7465421557,
-0.3236047328,
0.5449348688,
0.4166299999,
0.0892239437,
-0.0131537905,
-0.5492835641,
0.1041649356,
0.2341719717,
0.0105506722,
0.2042281777,
0.7869436741,
0.2404127121,
0.696521759,
0.2796697915,
0.2374334633,
0.0831123888,
-0.1739788353,
1.3167513609,
-0.3940234482,
-0.5407745838,
-0.9767016768,
0.2975331843,
-0.2634272277,
0.0366332978,
0.030718565,
0.5537477732,
0.9690983891,
-0.1492051929,
1.1334106922,
-0.2918088436,
0.210329473,
-0.410319984,
0.6178301573,
-0.6129760742,
0.4326622784,
-0.3759256601,
-1.0824549198,
0.2889869213,
0.4439166188,
-0.1652175635,
-0.1208658889,
1.0765908957,
0.5591004491,
-0.0942216069,
0.105801627,
0.253968358,
0.0989965275,
0.0541709512,
0.9351347089,
0.6352434158,
-0.3140048981,
0.3793218434,
-0.617869556,
-0.5905593634,
0.0114706149,
-0.8491011262,
-0.9613429308,
-1.1576519012,
-0.3644750118,
-0.1936576366,
0.2433154434,
0.8907958269,
0.6416279674,
-0.5879899263,
-0.3811649084,
-0.6855121255,
0.1621120274,
-0.3061533868,
-0.1279438138,
0.1412274092,
-0.6339470148,
-0.8155648708,
0.042840071,
0.2449063659,
0.2759742141,
-0.1766105592,
-0.0776953846,
-0.3396110833,
0.0886114016,
0.250287205,
0.0280260332,
-0.5456854701,
0.2502923906,
-0.536588192,
-0.1387775391,
-0.0111757666,
1.0347150564,
-0.6644722223,
0.7583307028,
0.5073812604,
0.4792266488,
1.0891257524,
-0.1537099332,
0.852562964,
-0.7941115499,
0.3914915919,
0.1966665536,
0.2120063007,
-0.0310517866,
-0.475877583,
0.4397091866,
0.3189975321,
-0.4134886563,
-0.6178705692,
0.3234196305,
-0.781440556,
-0.5469791293,
0.8177214861,
-0.5518592,
-0.2407769859,
-0.0095723048,
-0.2781460285,
0.7005551457,
-0.2900417447,
0.9679995179,
0.731387198,
-0.158740893,
0.2192604393,
-0.0599865727,
0.6412198544,
0.1308723986,
-0.6266258359,
0.1682393402,
0.4158559442,
0.2727871537,
0.2733656764,
0.4877105355,
0.2333720624,
-0.2091609389,
0.3439318538,
-0.2323206216,
-0.0181690361,
-0.6978113055,
0.0550441928,
0.0751289278,
-0.0061852857,
-0.5790656805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04804v1
|
AttentionStitch: How Attention Solves the Speech Editing Problem
| 2024-03-05T22:09:58 | 2024-03-05T22:09:58 |
Antonios Alexos, Pierre Baldi
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
The generation of natural and high-quality speech from text is a challenging
problem in the field of natural language processing. In addition to speech
generation, speech editing is also a crucial task, which requires the seamless
and unnoticeable integration of edited speech into synthesized speech. We
propose a novel approach to speech editing by leveraging a pre-trained
text-to-speech (TTS) model, such as FastSpeech 2, and incorporating a double
attention block network on top of it to automatically merge the synthesized
mel-spectrogram with the mel-spectrogram of the edited text. We refer to this
model as AttentionStitch, as it harnesses attention to stitch audio samples
together. We evaluate the proposed AttentionStitch model against
state-of-the-art baselines on both single and multi-speaker datasets, namely
LJSpeech and VCTK. We demonstrate its superior performance through an objective
and a subjective evaluation test involving 15 human participants.
AttentionStitch is capable of producing high-quality speech, even for words not
seen during training, while operating automatically without the need for human
intervention. Moreover, AttentionStitch is fast during both training and
inference and is able to generate human-sounding edited speech.
|
[
-0.3839052022,
-0.8325862885,
0.3454693556,
0.2104523033,
-0.2799316943,
0.1234955564,
-0.3456146121,
-0.549233973,
0.4413475096,
0.6077035666,
-0.6475064158,
-0.2410603762,
-0.5502029061,
0.1951997131,
-0.6753247976,
0.8914643526,
0.309215039,
-0.2068050504,
0.0493005402,
-0.0238384213,
-0.5367993116,
-0.2896966934,
-0.777799964,
-0.0575471409,
0.3862275183,
0.4116593599,
0.5952566266,
0.6880353689,
0.3854480684,
0.3311980963,
-0.5266798139,
0.2914944589,
-0.3878969252,
0.2333904058,
-0.2531268001,
-0.1949095726,
-0.3885668814,
0.1929141879,
0.4585956335,
0.3348568082,
0.1565277427,
0.4514771998,
0.3417188227,
0.605641067,
-0.637093246,
-0.4308718145,
-0.6826013923,
0.1736255437,
-0.3477226198,
-0.1003044844,
-0.2912138999,
-0.4013220668,
0.1761643738,
-0.4939357042,
0.4456558228,
-0.2251015902,
0.3303651512,
0.9472325444,
0.0189909674,
0.0477885492,
-0.7257548571,
0.2414592952,
-0.5221937895,
0.4992409348,
0.4224316478,
0.0404084772,
0.0577065311,
-0.7809436321,
-0.4829868376,
-0.0525355712,
0.0683857203,
0.1560431868,
-0.0228505433,
0.1541152149,
0.3448436558,
0.1423939466,
-0.5672698021,
0.0557038598,
-0.0356755666,
-0.2272279263,
0.3668165505,
-0.1101011485,
0.2708794773,
-0.1196798608,
-0.2393260151,
0.1763149053,
-0.1108446717,
0.0864659175,
0.3818749189,
0.1987774372,
0.2088530809,
0.6953050494,
-0.2733619511,
0.87643224,
0.3211198151,
0.1728868335,
-0.0217964482,
-0.3864735067,
-0.4074054658,
0.4974147677,
0.6359402537,
0.2772424519,
0.4271424115,
-0.1173315719,
0.197918281,
0.0383369178,
0.2237885296,
-0.2392387986,
-0.3633418977,
0.452709496,
-0.0546000861,
-0.4555477202,
-0.1471900344,
-0.8484831452,
-0.4588843584,
-0.4304778278,
0.5269158483,
-0.0724089146,
-0.063173607,
-0.0233235285,
-0.3572303057,
-0.5164828897,
0.114875868,
-0.7825895548,
0.0516088083,
0.5330898166,
0.9824712873,
-0.1246755645,
-0.4689882696,
-0.8075270653,
0.3011666834,
-0.3135904372,
0.8965229988,
-0.2668330073,
-0.2694891691,
-0.4866641462,
-0.3294540346,
0.0594835654,
-0.3724771738,
0.5258404016,
-0.2321757227,
0.0977527201,
0.0720381737,
-0.3740299642,
0.4718137681,
-0.0387066603,
-0.5868804455,
1.2615288496,
-0.138914451,
-0.9822021127,
0.2077023387,
-0.8449830413,
-0.5332526565,
-0.0094381003,
0.5399850011,
-0.5292537212,
0.1105859801,
0.4116127789,
0.3397960365,
0.0240828376,
0.1499789357,
-0.1166088581,
-0.4092098773,
0.4343330562,
-0.1593192965,
0.6027902365,
0.0202808082,
-0.4614060223,
0.1748749763,
-0.8060358167,
0.2334999293,
0.014301029,
-0.3783152699,
-0.416246146,
-0.2144080997,
0.3763034344,
0.2713787556,
0.2063148022,
-0.6827644706,
-0.0916228965,
-0.6666370034,
0.6948865056,
0.7065519691,
0.1825731248,
0.3716755807,
0.126545012,
0.1992552727,
-0.4596121609,
0.3794224262,
-0.2236575186,
-0.4145551622,
-0.7140167952,
-0.1820789278,
0.6818762422,
0.551364243,
-0.3310230374,
0.3907743692,
-0.0891372934,
-0.4798356891,
-0.8949789405,
0.0860133842,
0.5051543117,
0.6187394261,
0.4159015417,
-0.307610929,
-0.6529270411,
-0.8082668185,
-0.8363583088,
0.2036197931,
-0.0275861248,
0.0484251305,
-0.0516185164,
-0.0200216603,
1.2145324945,
-0.4127879441,
-0.4346311688,
-0.045169387,
0.3059144318,
-0.3234780133,
0.4157315195,
0.1191596761,
-0.5892993808,
-0.5450437069,
-0.1467940807,
-0.2569314241,
-0.463365823,
-0.0642583817,
-0.2424331754,
-0.125124976,
0.5899026394,
-0.4859634042,
0.460355103,
0.415857017,
-0.2602803409,
0.5753550529,
-0.0260862708,
0.3005954623,
-1.0979574919,
0.220430389,
-0.0861931071,
-0.4325554967,
-0.892622292,
-0.184561491,
0.0841032267,
-0.6816272736,
-0.6419305205,
0.50731498,
-0.2634180486,
-0.2791129649,
-0.3680654168,
0.2800579965,
0.032750167,
0.504779458,
-0.2060424089,
0.8412235379,
0.164382562,
-0.3367439508,
0.5448614955,
0.514254868,
-0.3560105264,
0.5036068559,
-0.5952575803,
0.7486143112,
-0.0019104445,
0.0456108488,
-0.926491797,
-0.3208693266,
0.0679006875,
-0.5766299963,
0.2223643064,
-0.1422719657,
-0.4079627097,
-0.4363993704,
-0.2653029859,
0.2941831648,
0.1483229399,
-0.4945985079,
0.2185322493,
0.5625026226,
-0.7491770387,
-0.4762136042,
-0.7429594398,
0.5153300166,
-0.0327549689,
-0.486081481,
0.4426119328,
-0.1309016943,
-0.1307980865,
-0.0193268266,
-0.1720156819,
-0.3659839332,
-0.0536605865,
0.0945289657,
-0.0663951784,
0.27849105,
0.1408280879,
0.0714789033,
-0.2724628747,
-0.2807482779,
-0.2670997381,
0.2990999818,
0.5737343431,
-0.0660713688,
-0.931989491,
0.547324121,
0.8071599603,
-0.7716693878,
0.0720354319,
0.3905571401,
-0.2066834867,
-0.0509096831,
-0.7658181787,
-0.2625493705,
-0.4036801457,
0.6041051745,
-0.0697593614,
-0.8383516669,
0.1074610502,
-0.0438775606,
0.127955392,
0.0405297689,
0.3553466201,
-0.2563437223,
0.8895218968,
0.5868596435,
0.0425675474,
0.8779393435,
0.1466269195,
0.0689993501,
-0.8744449615,
0.016266048,
-0.7902235389,
-0.4076700509,
-0.2200061232,
-0.3411585093,
0.4208479226,
-0.3701834679,
-0.0466192439,
0.2663226426,
-0.8199293017,
0.8291766047,
0.8351942301,
0.3577071428,
0.2049028724,
0.0201961771,
0.0418973081,
-0.2234252393,
-0.5884904861,
-0.0998851731,
0.8743955493,
0.1473691463,
0.4537133276,
-0.3496369421,
0.546051383,
0.3892594576,
-0.1849321723,
-0.7118763924,
0.4396707714,
-0.2882475853,
-0.4787240028,
-0.6130161285,
-0.1800982207,
-0.5553545356,
0.0220199842,
-0.1174163073,
-0.5773460269,
0.1980091482,
0.5161332488,
-0.5636431575,
0.0055994508,
-1.0013667345,
0.8727263212,
-0.0150577556,
-0.4912663996,
-0.3377833366,
-0.8776468635,
0.3325050771,
-0.2775956988,
0.1629036814,
-0.1246639937,
0.2501548529,
1.0458284616,
-0.1466076672,
0.6421837211,
-0.1716722697,
0.2644039989,
0.25257653,
0.1013518572,
0.5645917058,
-0.0645167604,
0.1047883108,
0.0640437752,
-0.3714228272,
-0.0126627134,
-0.5369842052,
0.5804542899,
-0.4578549862,
-0.4874658287,
-0.079602927,
-0.4041541517,
-0.566843152,
0.0981338397,
0.3052895665,
0.5063933134,
-0.1948296577,
-0.1084827185,
0.5800008178,
0.0527285896,
0.4641192853,
0.2294218838,
0.1744991392,
-0.5395439267,
0.5965396166,
0.1880800873,
0.3297804594,
0.1933146864,
0.3057174087,
-0.2077789307,
-0.2679172754,
-0.1660953909,
0.1172432154,
-0.4422272146,
0.0350354463,
-0.9872481823,
-0.1269072592,
-0.5121884942,
-0.1197529659,
-0.6890820265,
-0.5655328631,
-0.1766755432,
0.0691266805,
0.2982497215,
0.3946400285,
-0.1525915116,
0.3543154597,
-0.8447355628,
0.7930905223,
0.9713955522,
0.3012441397,
-0.2644121647,
-0.5522073507,
-0.5276259184,
-0.1364902556,
-0.1133524328,
-1.0881271362,
0.1790378392,
0.3012881875,
0.2039263994,
-0.0907387435,
-0.0858099088,
0.8426420689,
-0.692719698,
0.6769880652,
0.1115331873,
-1.2313437462,
1.0098882914,
-0.0018624912,
0.6721844077,
0.5936909318,
-0.3841609955,
-0.8999200463,
-0.8818927407,
-0.4665159583,
-0.7778891921,
0.9019651413,
0.4276714027,
-0.141561687,
0.1961678267,
0.233769834,
-0.1501991898,
0.2870773077,
-0.2325735539,
-0.0634359196,
-0.3454626799,
-0.2342226356,
-0.1697853506,
-0.4539445639,
-0.001156456,
-0.1668381989,
0.6002648473,
0.2259519696,
0.2843900621,
0.334385246,
-0.1889080107,
-0.2403938174,
0.521039784,
0.6702743173,
0.2774763405,
-0.1603305787,
0.04166013,
-0.0225111078,
-0.7104678154,
0.2407625616,
0.2240063995,
-0.0060434388,
0.2160754204,
0.167171225,
0.9404317737,
0.5129707456,
-0.387406528,
0.197949782,
-0.1431448609,
-0.0685662776,
0.2358953804,
0.0265162773,
0.0587970093,
0.0951889977,
0.1818632483,
0.5372955799,
0.3039769828,
-0.0482325852,
0.2718136609,
0.1306187212,
-0.2782878578,
-0.0691129193,
0.9300798774,
0.5777682066,
-0.8091642261,
0.3271466792,
0.3233435452,
-0.4473226666,
0.5851131082,
0.1494497955,
1.1607047319,
-0.7651292682,
0.0326693766,
0.212922439,
0.4192388654,
0.0389495045,
0.0381200202,
-0.2933579087,
-0.1855483651,
-0.6972939968,
-0.3865270019,
-0.5752109289,
0.1416979879,
-0.4679952562,
0.2302432954,
-0.2841630578,
-0.3942972124,
0.3131861389,
-0.4108206034,
-0.5222876668,
0.4582553208,
-0.0190286022,
0.6054224968,
-0.7112076879,
0.5706996918,
0.5816313624,
0.2330190837,
-0.6140213609,
0.3324172199,
-0.0009234334,
-0.5091718435,
0.2568433881,
0.2417656332,
-0.1255158186,
0.5427587032,
-0.3154440224,
-0.8967798352,
0.3795959353,
0.5408245325,
-0.8871802688,
0.0692237467,
-0.0196804423,
0.2928757071,
0.2930918932,
-0.1501973569,
0.8650872707,
0.4232120812,
-0.171656251,
-1.1762187481,
-0.4731230736,
-0.1170945168,
-0.2373636514,
0.3168548942,
-0.53777951,
0.474103272,
-0.2148360759,
0.004651302,
-0.3197143972,
0.2958700359,
-0.0961959362,
0.1358031034,
0.6407545209,
0.6307061315,
0.5937495232,
-0.0050649489,
0.593822062,
-0.1328041106,
0.3764861524,
1.4976685047,
-0.0710683241,
0.7390828133,
0.5711372495,
-0.1333802044,
-0.1847992837,
0.5432249904,
0.3459526896,
0.6927178502,
-0.2266583294,
-0.2259732932,
-0.1892646998,
-0.0853563845,
-0.2392508388,
0.723341763,
-0.0489690527,
-0.2434439063,
-0.0024978656,
0.4822154343,
-0.1866665483,
0.053890314,
-0.3786925673,
1.0747287273,
-0.2254774719,
-0.6298779249,
0.2721872628,
-0.2313535362,
0.4356923401,
-0.3994671702,
0.1308112592,
0.0116572212,
-0.093710117,
-0.0472944751,
-0.7781197429,
0.3824626207,
0.431874007,
-0.2810201645,
-0.2991808653,
0.568623662,
-0.6361072659,
-0.3044947982,
-0.0217987038,
0.104336895,
-0.0338021517,
-0.407608211,
-0.7732253075,
0.0446558595,
0.036528822,
-0.4718848765,
0.0946457237,
0.302172035,
0.3116708994,
0.3042768836,
0.7698910236,
0.2791548669,
0.1270648241,
0.1788440496,
0.4596287906,
-0.493293643,
-1.1565701962,
-0.8969764113,
0.7706906796,
-0.2392040938,
-0.3004978299,
0.3397477567,
0.3770745695,
0.3940522075,
-0.1210501343,
0.9626066089,
0.3218593895,
0.9981176853,
-0.4654522538,
0.7522296309,
-0.3265774846,
-0.3797918558,
-0.492112577,
-0.8040441871,
-0.3471771479,
0.323384434,
0.0123857744,
-0.2916256487,
0.7812741399,
0.6580107808,
-0.0696806982,
-0.0714802518,
0.387481451,
0.3708711565,
0.067918919,
0.3202551007,
0.5164093375,
-0.1715953797,
0.5842562914,
-0.4014458954,
-0.3355831206,
-0.3023192286,
-0.4735840857,
-0.7742131948,
-0.5505691767,
-0.3787082136,
-0.0507436804,
0.3565550745,
0.7499454021,
0.5447437763,
-0.454230696,
0.1359079778,
-0.0782231987,
0.0300106145,
-0.396713376,
-0.1876458377,
0.5504080653,
-0.2120173872,
-0.9225713015,
0.7363969684,
0.6890364289,
0.2203858197,
0.0153355105,
0.4296384156,
-0.1216943115,
0.1235990524,
0.4723250568,
0.2053519189,
-0.6031402946,
-0.1933884621,
-0.208152622,
-0.0406901091,
-0.0034076762,
0.8958446383,
-0.6791977286,
0.9584257007,
0.3510216177,
0.7131002545,
0.4689464271,
0.0643519163,
0.3276400864,
-1.1204820871,
0.4480909109,
0.164084062,
0.0851321444,
0.4893059731,
-0.5890108347,
0.2382585257,
0.2196349353,
-0.7055261731,
-0.8837374449,
0.0697934404,
-0.9230616093,
-0.0347244442,
0.7565299273,
0.0750089511,
-0.0912045613,
-0.3056844175,
-0.7015357018,
0.7444384694,
-0.2646406293,
0.9190230966,
0.7216513157,
0.0349143371,
-0.3768240213,
-0.4826001525,
0.6652928591,
0.5541043282,
-0.9106076956,
0.5604995489,
0.3294427693,
0.2258859873,
-0.0008467258,
0.4402476549,
0.2153217196,
0.7298769355,
-0.4218211174,
0.2208536714,
-0.3961173296,
-0.3971568346,
-0.3530882001,
0.4608334005,
-0.2269639075,
-0.4848780334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03336v1
|
Scope of Large Language Models for Mining Emerging Opinions in Online Health Discourse
| 2024-03-05T21:38:19 | 2024-03-05T21:38:19 |
Joseph Gatto, Madhusudan Basak, Yash Srivastava, Philip Bohlman, Sarah M. Preum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
In this paper, we develop an LLM-powered framework for the curation and
evaluation of emerging opinion mining in online health communities. We
formulate emerging opinion mining as a pairwise stance detection problem
between (title, comment) pairs sourced from Reddit, where post titles contain
emerging health-related claims on a topic that is not predefined. The claims
are either explicitly or implicitly expressed by the user. We detail (i) a
method of claim identification -- the task of identifying if a post title
contains a claim and (ii) an opinion mining-driven evaluation framework for
stance detection using LLMs.
We facilitate our exploration by releasing a novel test dataset, Long
COVID-Stance, or LC-stance, which can be used to evaluate LLMs on the tasks of
claim identification and stance detection in online health communities. Long
Covid is an emerging post-COVID disorder with uncertain and complex treatment
guidelines, thus making it a suitable use case for our task. LC-Stance contains
long COVID treatment related discourse sourced from a Reddit community. Our
evaluation shows that GPT-4 significantly outperforms prior works on zero-shot
stance detection. We then perform thorough LLM model diagnostics, identifying
the role of claim type (i.e. implicit vs explicit claims) and comment length as
sources of model error.
|
[
-0.0556859262,
-0.7243375778,
0.8649309874,
0.0783137679,
-0.2000879198,
0.0417816266,
-0.2317583561,
-0.6295558214,
0.6358867884,
0.3041331172,
-0.3688152432,
-0.7802473307,
-0.8251780868,
-0.0459555276,
-0.1975816488,
1.3639729023,
0.0512439385,
0.2438644916,
-0.4156146646,
-0.1088979468,
0.087264657,
-0.4446886182,
-0.7416149378,
-0.525334537,
0.4824469984,
0.2827404141,
0.5633912683,
0.0080661373,
0.3884642124,
0.0944176614,
-0.1625165045,
0.0116161481,
-0.3267466128,
0.0315296426,
-0.2115939409,
-0.3872342706,
-0.9135263562,
-0.0565288514,
0.4189916253,
0.3758955002,
-0.2822721004,
0.3306358159,
-0.0092648864,
0.3666916788,
-0.2628880739,
-0.0691497028,
-0.5518637896,
0.141615212,
-0.2083964199,
0.0876580104,
-0.3722393215,
-0.0815215334,
0.1196881831,
-0.213605091,
-0.0252644308,
-0.2144282013,
0.8178659081,
-0.0957231075,
-0.507892549,
-0.2876045406,
-0.6001566052,
0.7043815851,
-1.02792871,
0.289124012,
0.2725250423,
0.0932378545,
-0.092637457,
-0.6704432368,
-0.3891413212,
0.0580653362,
0.0042753057,
0.1299429834,
-0.5498490334,
0.1629984081,
0.0262227245,
0.4342296422,
-0.4578303099,
0.2404557616,
-0.1192289963,
-0.1951351166,
0.6629174948,
-0.1610550731,
0.2199844122,
-0.6533546448,
-0.502969265,
0.6082263589,
-0.8328818679,
0.1339799762,
0.2158147097,
0.1595538706,
-0.4958442152,
0.5743279457,
-0.0449621603,
0.5524209738,
0.4573578238,
-0.2831385136,
0.3273537457,
-0.2313479036,
-0.3388131857,
0.0892101973,
0.8775358796,
0.6962978244,
-0.4074958563,
0.1277538389,
-0.0834465027,
-0.1605781615,
0.1719565243,
-0.7966125011,
-0.2700107694,
0.39120996,
-0.8822951913,
-0.4803104997,
0.1237727776,
-0.9705486298,
-0.9173522592,
-0.0517661013,
0.2237317115,
0.0317927115,
-0.780801177,
-0.0075724456,
-0.0332780369,
0.5151792765,
0.132851392,
-0.5759493709,
0.2830201983,
1.0174491405,
0.8738387823,
-0.4166486263,
0.4790489972,
-0.3580667675,
-0.0861151367,
-0.1146903113,
1.004242301,
-0.6475116014,
-0.3099264801,
0.1185011566,
0.1440328509,
0.1243310943,
-0.4967610836,
0.7079074979,
-0.4806472063,
0.0408275351,
-0.1076815501,
-0.7272786498,
-0.0429270156,
0.7987036705,
-0.7206478715,
0.7503673434,
-0.0104117608,
-1.0719790459,
0.5406681895,
-0.6502729654,
-0.4277468324,
0.1673849225,
-0.4083993435,
-0.7497013807,
0.1067604944,
0.3155120909,
0.6365439892,
-0.3175024092,
0.2981789708,
-0.6144346595,
0.1890310347,
0.1629980803,
-0.0925936848,
0.8301626444,
0.0994618163,
-0.4201732576,
0.3092819154,
-0.5918002725,
0.0479963012,
0.1155878231,
-0.2420547903,
-0.5391103625,
0.1886450648,
-0.2024654895,
0.2666120827,
0.5416234136,
-0.64617908,
0.1987959594,
-0.6414680481,
0.544216156,
0.5843148828,
0.6672993302,
-0.0053517893,
-0.2603310645,
0.6836823821,
0.0269490257,
0.3876893222,
-0.0428703018,
-0.6414095759,
-0.6934246421,
-0.1777025312,
0.0864097476,
0.3975701928,
-0.4343026876,
0.4200577438,
-0.2478929609,
-0.328797549,
-0.6045024991,
0.1149967685,
0.1720204949,
0.2568547726,
0.3421626389,
-0.2731137574,
-0.6082322001,
-1.0009400845,
-0.4596795142,
-0.3954484761,
0.190248847,
0.2411312312,
0.2781105042,
-0.4704488516,
0.9104682803,
-0.3226214349,
0.0313935243,
-0.4277171791,
0.2576156557,
0.4149788618,
-0.1298813075,
0.3576948941,
-0.6889379621,
-0.4466614127,
0.0310808998,
-0.7780538797,
-0.0258100312,
0.0401676223,
0.2900935411,
0.1084513515,
0.4446949065,
-0.4636444747,
0.0247916915,
0.7946532369,
-0.1741541773,
0.2819868028,
-0.0295534208,
0.0498832911,
-1.4206105471,
-0.1853478551,
0.4281073511,
-0.3436038792,
-0.6582299471,
0.2686664462,
-0.214549616,
0.2108670771,
-0.5967073441,
0.4520815015,
-0.3048615754,
0.254021436,
-0.5034900904,
-0.1980046779,
-0.1296714544,
-0.0184366982,
0.0817700624,
0.0845137835,
0.569804132,
-0.3454378247,
0.3505085707,
-0.1726505756,
-0.2019454688,
0.7457796335,
-0.5688154697,
0.2323198617,
0.0652813762,
0.344733268,
-0.8274099827,
-0.3109427989,
0.2429219782,
-0.6109791398,
0.089019157,
-0.41698125,
-0.3022220731,
-0.5279126763,
-0.4773752391,
0.2829008698,
0.1926896274,
-0.445107758,
0.3728289306,
0.9306271076,
-0.3541049063,
-0.5354573727,
-0.4293919802,
0.0904436111,
-0.4242086411,
-0.3922812343,
0.248462826,
0.2065790892,
-0.7181856036,
0.0220294781,
0.0318691544,
-0.0092451237,
-0.0033949031,
0.3654837906,
0.0852899551,
0.0915159807,
0.267257303,
0.0006226091,
0.0398077406,
0.4500671029,
-0.1440481395,
0.5067628026,
-0.2543046176,
-0.4930820167,
-0.1962714344,
0.5048978925,
0.5662495494,
0.0878337324,
0.3831110001,
0.547426641,
-0.6383181214,
-0.2332747579,
-0.4046477377,
-0.1100637168,
-0.3734147251,
0.3748929203,
0.1844022125,
-0.8533474803,
0.1756672859,
-0.2369366884,
0.3124435544,
0.6259323955,
0.9594488144,
-0.0505734868,
0.8648735881,
0.5964953303,
-0.3257964253,
0.057558991,
-0.0712252706,
0.3840363324,
-0.6061791182,
-0.1828979701,
-0.0784718171,
-0.1775905341,
-0.7397093177,
-0.5502639413,
0.6666455865,
-0.2631852627,
-0.0579580739,
-0.0564585738,
-0.3512273431,
0.0476552211,
0.1545440853,
0.5419207215,
0.4184474349,
-0.1202408969,
-0.1319009811,
-0.1821886152,
-0.4591847956,
-0.3444951773,
1.4258073568,
0.5968104005,
0.4802805781,
0.2496467829,
0.7539063692,
0.6476428509,
0.6136742234,
-1.2073144913,
0.4832650721,
-0.0475475714,
-0.5409498215,
0.0680371225,
-0.2045517564,
-1.0595405102,
-0.0391909294,
-0.5540425181,
-0.3740968108,
-0.2994878888,
0.1583546251,
-0.6312403679,
0.6312204003,
-0.2298669517,
0.5476253629,
-0.4752216339,
-0.5388920903,
-0.5182698965,
-0.6263309717,
0.4177148938,
0.0748114213,
0.439435333,
-0.1952910721,
0.2199072838,
0.8143963814,
-0.4559083283,
1.0744026899,
-0.3674686849,
-0.246517092,
0.4401939809,
-0.3037073016,
0.2900350094,
0.3008030653,
-0.2943040729,
0.2482394874,
-0.1660135984,
-0.1494079381,
-0.2436722964,
0.8662489653,
-0.7963481545,
-0.6838813424,
-0.6612029672,
-0.0282829311,
-0.4674449265,
0.2003837228,
0.1160161346,
0.2088897824,
-0.6719868183,
0.037701536,
0.6589487195,
-0.2881619632,
0.2382073849,
0.4438280761,
-0.2769806683,
-0.4247545302,
0.5186325312,
-0.1648602039,
0.0525845475,
0.4589065015,
0.5915135741,
-0.2576954067,
-0.7114701271,
-0.1874667406,
0.219511956,
-0.6213312149,
-0.2801066935,
-0.5491092205,
-0.3012084961,
-0.5310869813,
0.1662815511,
-0.2155724466,
-0.197894007,
0.0486860983,
-0.5275064707,
0.6548708081,
0.9615849257,
-0.053224571,
0.0881180912,
-0.7616388202,
0.2499044389,
0.3229182661,
0.309494108,
-0.0537872426,
-0.2086742371,
-0.1477561891,
-0.0200917833,
-0.3052664399,
-0.8887382746,
0.4390840828,
-0.0052332249,
0.6356104016,
0.7816283107,
0.0815767869,
0.4243637323,
-0.2473607063,
0.982881844,
0.440214783,
-0.5726979375,
0.6238583326,
-0.4305530488,
0.0171386097,
0.4594341218,
0.6123844385,
-0.6426680088,
-0.188255772,
-0.7701075077,
-0.9552474022,
0.1113879606,
-0.3200157583,
-0.0404559672,
-0.2345074713,
0.3690127432,
0.3363860548,
0.1008249298,
-1.0686695576,
-0.2206218988,
0.1021052971,
-0.1358605325,
0.2812302113,
-0.2499616742,
-0.4353405237,
-0.3414205313,
0.5425155759,
-0.1155774891,
0.3254353702,
0.205728814,
-0.1045455933,
-0.215033561,
0.6912500262,
0.1168971062,
0.5104341507,
-0.0058240909,
0.4256214797,
0.0537641458,
-0.3061334789,
0.0023699887,
0.0490982123,
-0.3289506137,
0.0948487371,
0.2933779955,
0.7048134804,
0.3874057233,
-0.4927550852,
0.9465908408,
0.1744481623,
-0.0881452337,
-0.6643015742,
-0.2921755612,
0.2048337758,
0.0816676617,
0.1076684743,
-0.0344313048,
0.2733217478,
-0.7234286666,
0.4657680392,
0.8431731462,
-0.6636704206,
-0.6310655475,
0.4993592501,
0.3546731174,
-0.0821107253,
0.1851541996,
-0.1586644948,
-0.3122531772,
0.3729987144,
0.4165834785,
0.7414898276,
-0.1575688571,
0.381986618,
0.4192170203,
-0.0404375046,
0.0155282812,
0.2219155431,
0.2790254951,
-0.7416577339,
-0.2627344728,
-0.4808933437,
-0.461199373,
0.3982452154,
-0.793084681,
0.560051918,
-0.4414474368,
-0.4697545469,
-0.0378192477,
0.1269833446,
-0.3739539683,
0.0600418113,
0.5147454739,
0.4616568387,
-0.9606820345,
0.690699935,
0.8376399279,
-0.0444058292,
-0.519464612,
0.4502911568,
0.4685043395,
-0.9729630947,
0.0230513532,
0.2028340101,
-0.2454353571,
-0.3487475514,
-0.6192114949,
-0.5196986198,
1.0988080502,
0.1418820769,
-0.5019006729,
0.0581356548,
0.0850047097,
0.6119490266,
-0.4404778779,
0.1643556356,
0.3171823919,
0.429020077,
0.052611988,
-0.9850782752,
0.0864258185,
-0.2229719907,
-0.6112393141,
0.0469314419,
-0.8001613021,
0.7192938328,
-0.4256845713,
-0.1641048491,
-0.1041648313,
0.5835924745,
0.4578703344,
0.545141995,
0.658986032,
0.732552588,
0.9291472435,
0.3226142526,
0.9376363158,
-0.368070066,
0.4521677196,
1.0260313749,
-0.4744369984,
1.0762082338,
0.4291006625,
-0.2113910168,
0.8750770092,
0.8420354128,
0.0316547006,
0.3055764735,
0.2577618361,
-0.5546351671,
-0.3950180411,
-0.1985916048,
-0.2970028818,
0.2867344022,
0.6542367339,
-0.7254040837,
-0.2405920327,
-0.1240131035,
0.4592499435,
0.0669146478,
-0.7760478258,
0.8929599524,
0.2749670446,
-0.7894409895,
0.1666438282,
0.2732948363,
0.7868645787,
-0.4270581901,
-0.1253730953,
0.1918807179,
0.1977825761,
-0.5695561171,
-0.7875159979,
0.2264020145,
0.1115682498,
-0.2671672106,
-0.1754695028,
1.0211182833,
-0.2943452597,
-0.6536872983,
0.4499739707,
0.8199844956,
0.1257395297,
0.099749513,
-0.8903141022,
-0.1341177821,
-0.1051136404,
-0.1661404073,
0.4374308288,
0.1069127619,
-0.2993296981,
0.2337375134,
0.4293895364,
0.4232065976,
-0.1934501678,
0.0879021361,
0.7615224719,
-0.5317220092,
-0.5055533648,
-1.0043330193,
0.0611797906,
-0.2834613919,
0.0383693576,
0.8535985947,
0.6425996423,
0.4231446087,
0.3283849359,
1.1792083979,
-0.1376480758,
0.6925094724,
-0.4334210455,
0.7357240915,
-0.403033942,
0.1297895163,
-0.0559822135,
-0.2478541881,
-0.4566868842,
0.3649476171,
-0.4504644871,
-0.2487309575,
0.5841094255,
0.57598418,
0.1793195009,
-0.0525257401,
-0.0500426851,
0.4338235855,
0.4329304397,
0.5915090442,
0.5487015247,
-0.1810589433,
0.2427236736,
0.1461341083,
-0.3410479426,
-0.2751283646,
-1.1525553465,
-0.7736877799,
-0.1886136234,
-0.4690490961,
-0.7242426872,
-0.1185729206,
1.4568864107,
0.7990902066,
-0.9580692649,
-0.0194208156,
-0.0148190102,
0.0956851244,
-0.3837077916,
-0.216818437,
0.4091104269,
0.2552578747,
-0.3716057241,
0.4271966815,
0.2459508479,
-0.3727367222,
-0.4788881838,
-0.075855054,
-0.2708430886,
-0.0208200831,
0.8380063176,
0.4871993065,
-0.7910249829,
-0.2745322287,
0.0325588435,
0.0652768239,
0.4430350959,
0.9857802987,
-0.5053319335,
0.5644519925,
0.1603683531,
0.4551250041,
0.5508182645,
0.1223734319,
0.5144301653,
-0.716047287,
-0.1445078552,
0.3680561483,
0.5212973356,
0.567471385,
-0.3741538227,
0.1061213166,
0.3327580094,
-0.3358150721,
-0.5432154536,
0.2916178703,
-1.2040423155,
-0.2197785378,
1.6489377022,
-0.2386766076,
-0.0625606775,
-0.3275508881,
0.0869986266,
0.0362826958,
-0.4577848911,
0.7773574591,
0.645747602,
-0.548989296,
-0.1140654162,
-0.5050170422,
0.4458689392,
-0.0242912769,
-0.8886754513,
0.0490920283,
0.3412563205,
0.5382217169,
0.0491543561,
0.9396870136,
-0.4591237009,
0.0275154207,
-0.5388925076,
-0.0109580299,
0.3482981324,
0.0632624701,
-0.5717401505,
0.4833920896,
0.2823072374,
0.1312821656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03334v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03334v1
|
DIVERSE: Deciphering Internet Views on the U.S. Military Through Video Comment Stance Analysis, A Novel Benchmark Dataset for Stance Classification
| 2024-03-05T21:36:23 | 2024-03-05T21:36:23 |
Iain J. Cruickshank, Lynnette Hui Xian Ng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Stance detection of social media text is a key component of downstream tasks
involving the identification of groups of users with opposing opinions on
contested topics such as vaccination and within arguments. In particular,
stance provides an indication of an opinion towards an entity. This paper
introduces DIVERSE, a dataset of over 173,000 YouTube video comments annotated
for their stance towards videos of the U.S. military. The stance is annotated
through a human-guided, machine-assisted labeling methodology that makes use of
weak signals of tone within the sentence as supporting indicators, as opposed
to using manual annotations by humans. These weak signals consist of the
presence of hate speech and sarcasm, the presence of specific keywords, the
sentiment of the text, and the stance inference from two Large Language Models.
The weak signals are then consolidated using a data programming model before
each comment is annotated with a final stance label. On average, the videos
have 200 comments each, and the stance of the comments skews slightly towards
the "against" characterization for both the U.S. Army and the videos posted on
the channel.
|
[
-0.9412698746,
-0.7802217603,
0.1714282632,
0.0666711256,
-0.5571633577,
0.4583308995,
0.080800578,
-0.0614122041,
0.3092803359,
0.3388783038,
-0.7861939669,
-0.8415628076,
-1.1273238659,
0.0183893573,
-0.4060189724,
1.2521455288,
0.1386025846,
-0.0268495046,
0.3244568408,
-0.5366271734,
0.2573053837,
-0.5100538731,
-0.0961074084,
-0.1508461684,
0.358569473,
0.4625953138,
0.7908955216,
0.57306844,
0.4113844633,
0.3939020336,
-0.1075270027,
-0.4297595918,
-0.5641467571,
0.1894339025,
-0.3082877696,
-0.3804977536,
-0.1132367477,
0.1787437052,
0.7458644509,
0.595156908,
0.3185991943,
0.3115879297,
-0.2091697901,
0.4039175808,
-0.593511045,
-0.4302612841,
-0.6995463967,
0.2898714542,
-0.3160001636,
0.2704936266,
-0.1044071019,
-0.220818609,
0.3153271377,
-0.2871705294,
0.4892647564,
-0.3420833051,
0.7454164624,
0.2089205533,
-0.7288058996,
0.1869299561,
-0.642962575,
1.0500360727,
-0.5572561622,
0.6665898561,
0.3507835865,
0.4938218594,
0.1889768541,
-0.2717962861,
-0.641287446,
0.3122019768,
0.5389421582,
0.1126744375,
-0.2851122022,
0.0038926648,
0.2142943442,
0.43363446,
-0.4887660742,
0.2089056671,
-0.2513235211,
-0.0938563794,
0.5501836538,
0.0165621396,
0.4496777654,
-0.3696113229,
-0.4615029097,
-0.0779845193,
-0.2308683991,
0.4392901063,
0.6156305075,
0.1240453497,
-0.4194402993,
0.6976655126,
-0.5476396084,
0.3406621516,
0.2196638435,
-0.276804775,
0.4168008268,
0.0951483473,
-0.4788011014,
-0.1130940467,
0.8425171971,
0.6815705299,
0.1758922637,
0.1854525656,
-0.1345094591,
0.4041802287,
0.5324988365,
-0.7933478951,
-0.0859151781,
-0.0859856755,
-1.1059690714,
-0.3870584667,
0.2615387142,
-1.0468177795,
-0.9712364078,
-0.1857928783,
-0.0575045422,
-0.0997429565,
-0.402267307,
-0.3673503697,
-0.4758786559,
0.230108887,
0.3659178615,
-0.7158178687,
0.4477909803,
0.7415953279,
0.7360372543,
-0.2457840741,
0.0210764352,
-0.4428422153,
-0.2370399386,
0.0956704021,
0.9587159753,
-0.830381155,
-0.3580628633,
0.0224089064,
0.0967059582,
0.3649017811,
-0.4876007736,
0.6014364958,
-0.6075850129,
-0.2287188619,
-0.4333848953,
-0.4443711042,
-0.5077408552,
0.7663952708,
-0.8530525565,
0.702747643,
0.104206346,
-0.9165822864,
0.7604760528,
-0.1456154436,
-0.2167678773,
-0.1468079239,
-0.5551383495,
-0.4743191302,
-0.0213806108,
0.1055762917,
0.5267922878,
-0.1728626192,
-0.0600244105,
-0.9887769818,
-0.0558728725,
0.3963900805,
-0.3372991383,
0.8191766143,
0.353982091,
-0.6584603786,
-0.0564876311,
-0.6904426217,
-0.2302689403,
-0.3271711469,
-0.37393713,
-0.2617405355,
0.068462044,
0.086843513,
0.4097258747,
-0.2541946173,
-0.6528049707,
0.0572048202,
-0.3447107673,
0.0678992718,
0.8795360923,
0.2794227302,
0.3473573923,
0.011681431,
0.7461801171,
0.1906929761,
0.4240652919,
0.2554858327,
-0.6224931479,
-0.4701001048,
-0.3704150021,
-0.2675971091,
0.532916069,
-0.2953664362,
0.1053506732,
-0.1318909079,
-0.4858517945,
-0.2301655263,
0.5474351048,
0.2416868359,
0.2631652355,
0.324474901,
-0.4082542658,
-0.876889348,
-1.0897504091,
-0.5263749957,
-0.4376718998,
0.1368766725,
0.0844043717,
0.3697754741,
-0.4704680443,
0.5691695809,
-0.2879965007,
-0.0291833319,
-0.1084211245,
0.5491092801,
-0.0330300964,
-0.146197319,
0.5363368988,
-1.1698800325,
-0.7756714225,
0.0377144367,
-0.8035132885,
0.1592203826,
-0.0316730738,
-0.0711929277,
-0.5843870044,
0.318728447,
-0.380066514,
0.4180431962,
0.4295509458,
-0.1668159366,
0.2014123946,
0.7575762272,
0.4163080752,
-0.8919010758,
-0.2969151437,
0.4153362513,
0.1063067093,
-0.6434799433,
-0.1769536287,
-0.5032405853,
-0.0202656835,
-0.4971351326,
0.1838430315,
0.0036615881,
-0.0286392402,
-0.2647086084,
-0.1403501332,
-0.217807889,
0.1343803853,
0.0707581043,
0.2203789651,
0.6364941001,
-0.3625310957,
0.4655421674,
0.2317778468,
-0.0399910696,
0.7886502147,
-0.1741820574,
-0.173669517,
-0.0904340968,
0.2252268642,
-1.1486557722,
-0.3543040752,
0.3980819285,
-0.5337080956,
-0.0199797768,
-0.4258249104,
0.0787111297,
-0.1843881458,
-0.7887847424,
0.4543058276,
0.120126754,
-0.2975213528,
0.5529809594,
1.0705196857,
-0.1767513603,
-0.9828541875,
-0.7087442279,
0.0393389352,
-0.3911865056,
-0.310623318,
0.2415675819,
0.2353525162,
-0.6384971738,
-0.0361324027,
-0.3803015351,
-0.5105928183,
-0.0324283727,
0.6156435013,
-0.0313031562,
-0.2052485794,
0.0446825847,
-0.0138431853,
0.2802892625,
0.1629900634,
0.0041627046,
0.2975982428,
-0.2984421849,
-0.3558203876,
-0.3763662577,
0.6922087669,
0.6486267447,
0.1562412679,
0.3397382796,
0.8099328279,
-0.2854904234,
-0.465691328,
-0.4987067878,
-0.0411546603,
-0.5130915046,
0.2475734204,
0.0270123202,
-0.5654575229,
0.4757227004,
-0.1811236441,
0.2209693491,
0.3899350166,
0.4484549165,
-0.2656574249,
1.2060118914,
0.6416490078,
-0.4912940264,
0.645893693,
-0.2418101728,
-0.0314653851,
-0.2978461087,
-0.1559264064,
-0.4357171655,
-0.7774362564,
-0.7600243092,
-0.2426396608,
-0.0487629101,
-0.1157427505,
-0.5419750214,
0.0604652464,
-0.5996856093,
0.2342553735,
0.2052661031,
0.1275831908,
-0.1350918263,
0.3680609167,
-0.111893177,
-0.4837866426,
0.0178468339,
-0.5285179019,
1.1522274017,
0.3817068934,
0.6218138933,
0.3954813778,
0.7727380395,
0.8030892611,
0.4707480073,
-1.2114264965,
0.796633184,
-0.6555979252,
-0.4633163512,
0.0482362099,
-0.3123394847,
-0.7184907198,
0.0762907416,
-0.4007688463,
-0.7225405574,
-0.0379567742,
0.0761145204,
0.0093014771,
0.5117119551,
-0.4540822208,
0.7356359363,
-0.3002329767,
-0.1682970524,
-0.2795357406,
-0.7931109667,
0.4507525265,
0.410700649,
0.1493890584,
0.0007918371,
-0.0996340513,
0.7206015587,
-0.2991969883,
1.125767827,
-0.4372673333,
0.3126528859,
0.2763212025,
-0.3329520524,
0.0026352031,
0.1003798246,
-0.0161435958,
-0.0855232552,
-0.481838733,
-0.3043013215,
-0.3290587664,
0.6962686181,
-1.2010774612,
-0.4537308216,
-0.3277352452,
-0.0152856233,
-0.3926748335,
0.4004315436,
0.1681049466,
0.1453138441,
-0.6754649282,
0.4745183885,
0.9285831451,
-0.1543762982,
0.1676226407,
0.1616344005,
0.0324939378,
-0.7140709162,
0.7945967913,
0.1607873589,
-0.0499437302,
0.481531322,
-0.0147508457,
-0.2397152185,
-0.5504630208,
-0.5133003592,
0.0373077765,
-1.1344377995,
-0.002748451,
-0.6301910281,
0.011446801,
-0.2429094762,
-0.2269238383,
-0.26016289,
-0.372844547,
-0.0003243407,
-0.4441668987,
0.2369686216,
0.8508707881,
0.3477979004,
0.4943017364,
-0.6719152331,
0.8210117817,
0.4462519288,
0.4406145215,
-0.4867757261,
-0.3399730325,
0.0552768447,
-0.1567008346,
-0.5738115907,
-1.3507194519,
-0.0033059211,
0.0869351178,
0.9032709599,
0.926766336,
-0.0225976147,
0.4229872823,
0.0465122648,
0.9107086658,
0.207478866,
-0.8110590577,
0.5954144597,
-0.4144365191,
0.3167834282,
0.7270355821,
0.7749775648,
-0.2478874028,
-0.5766076446,
-0.7070822716,
-0.594743371,
0.3896858096,
-0.1432578862,
0.0406775028,
-0.0498018041,
-0.1133514941,
0.217144832,
0.2583291829,
-0.6479892731,
-0.2620787024,
-0.8532457352,
-0.2804160416,
0.1983130723,
0.0731311664,
-0.366717428,
-0.0499569103,
0.3792053461,
-0.1392021775,
0.0328100324,
-0.2855057716,
-0.2500269115,
-0.0675968975,
0.4468713701,
0.3852400184,
0.2403757721,
-0.2241288722,
0.5272970796,
0.1569834799,
-0.9269334674,
0.3061024249,
-0.0754623264,
-0.3546094596,
0.3679480255,
0.0878932253,
0.4476964772,
0.179380253,
-0.4711017311,
0.5610485077,
-0.0887911916,
-0.1707029343,
-0.0798876062,
-0.0899051353,
-0.1198502481,
0.157680124,
0.2102943063,
0.536907196,
0.4641009867,
-0.776687026,
0.5984609723,
0.7614021301,
-0.5738662481,
-0.5932474136,
0.4328656495,
0.2913732529,
-0.1994622648,
0.1810830981,
0.0770656988,
-0.6529274583,
0.5637032986,
0.1273750812,
1.0891922712,
-0.2181902528,
0.8021665812,
0.402767092,
0.1234952658,
0.0745874718,
0.2283118367,
-0.1594990939,
-0.7258124948,
0.141654104,
-0.4637899995,
-0.406860292,
0.3102847338,
-0.8370208144,
0.4327736199,
-1.2371256351,
-0.5909999609,
0.4581069946,
0.0672050267,
-0.7572892308,
0.6813658476,
0.5243690014,
0.4292801023,
-1.2443995476,
0.7194096446,
1.0865107775,
-0.3682727516,
-0.5677942038,
0.3057111502,
0.8547422886,
-0.6052692533,
0.6773995161,
0.4132793248,
-0.535182178,
-0.6890623569,
-0.3853657544,
-0.2087920606,
0.4816321433,
0.2102627456,
-0.0851565748,
0.4910142422,
0.4550355673,
0.4721582532,
-0.3747102618,
0.2368271053,
0.2504505515,
0.2474552989,
-0.146548748,
-0.4129541516,
0.1184130684,
-0.6381451488,
-0.3726278841,
0.1743000448,
-0.8473989964,
1.0260982513,
0.3675631285,
-0.2033504248,
-0.5233634114,
0.3896769583,
0.1790650636,
0.4678487182,
0.9633123279,
0.5589615107,
0.6415417194,
0.2750148773,
0.5762259364,
0.2001839131,
0.0849620178,
0.6533716917,
-0.10849493,
0.9044786096,
0.6110762954,
-0.1468729675,
0.8135865331,
0.4871886969,
-0.3019630909,
0.5259218812,
-0.0263845865,
-0.6449304223,
-0.2643941343,
-0.0987168252,
-0.2326227874,
0.5901688933,
0.451369375,
-0.6284839511,
-0.3726126552,
-0.08661668,
-0.1144683883,
0.32284078,
-0.5076544285,
0.910715282,
0.0419397131,
-0.5486758351,
0.474701643,
-0.0749885365,
0.6210296154,
-0.4544157386,
-0.0792698711,
0.124855943,
0.3526911139,
-0.5312263966,
-1.0467064381,
0.2670327723,
0.5882336497,
-0.4544067383,
-0.1641087532,
0.7034022808,
0.0550396144,
-0.2360027581,
0.2161771208,
0.2463364601,
0.0099115819,
0.0517164357,
-0.9975581169,
0.241286546,
0.1148101315,
-0.3649582863,
0.4825907946,
0.4396687448,
-0.2470523864,
0.5956158042,
0.4812030792,
-0.138396129,
0.1758190691,
0.2954488397,
1.1805049181,
-0.7106978893,
-0.6089956164,
-0.9091911316,
0.5632312894,
-0.5541201234,
-0.5823437572,
0.9668075442,
0.5358797312,
0.7748389244,
-0.0421457514,
1.258865118,
-0.0473696254,
0.5284686685,
-0.174423188,
0.4162263572,
-0.4570887685,
0.2042313814,
-0.391328156,
-0.6270106435,
-0.327586621,
0.5888283253,
-0.3013374805,
-0.2874853313,
0.2750032544,
0.6531242728,
-0.5577457547,
0.3069436848,
-0.0559137054,
0.0795076415,
0.2901984453,
-0.0578402132,
0.9540590048,
-0.2082013935,
0.9235551357,
-0.4051393867,
-0.1759893298,
-0.3012578189,
-0.5781269073,
-1.1595770121,
-0.0067716842,
-0.3035043776,
-0.336211741,
-0.2676739693,
0.9733607769,
0.8853284717,
-1.1044639349,
-0.2405066043,
-0.1663020402,
0.1240382493,
-0.2527873814,
-0.2121522874,
-0.1256299019,
0.0553951412,
-0.5039557219,
0.2950520515,
0.2306903154,
-0.29576689,
-0.2128245533,
-0.059347257,
-0.373608917,
0.0016467285,
0.3882628977,
0.7105949521,
-0.979693532,
-0.4509662986,
0.2815594971,
-0.0579522736,
0.1298286766,
0.7711566091,
-0.4649339318,
0.7307930589,
0.7758699059,
0.9750950933,
0.6444145441,
0.4799048901,
0.411585182,
-0.9676450491,
0.3482072353,
0.4026486278,
0.2425544262,
0.5105630755,
-0.2035810798,
0.0274630617,
0.4644664824,
-0.3371065855,
-0.814696312,
0.4572384953,
-1.3096399307,
-0.2998474836,
0.9340057373,
-0.2448306531,
0.0513506904,
-0.3723879158,
-0.1961400807,
0.3315054774,
-0.6017994285,
0.8446128368,
0.7503455281,
-0.09812361,
-0.4120236039,
-0.540045917,
0.4479397237,
0.424423188,
-0.7282583714,
-0.3204860687,
0.4723289013,
0.3739456832,
0.0806131288,
0.4605285525,
0.2151147723,
0.388261795,
0.2900861502,
-0.3408955336,
0.4354206026,
-0.2024578005,
-0.2938608527,
0.5923694968,
-0.0916798711,
-0.3088027537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03329v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03329v3
|
Guardrail Baselines for Unlearning in LLMs
| 2024-03-05T21:19:06 | 2024-06-11T15:47:39 |
Pratiksha Thaker, Yash Maurya, Shengyuan Hu, Zhiwei Steven Wu, Virginia Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has demonstrated that finetuning is a promising approach to
'unlearn' concepts from large language models. However, finetuning can be
expensive, as it requires both generating a set of examples and running
iterations of finetuning to update the model. In this work, we show that simple
guardrail-based approaches such as prompting and filtering can achieve
unlearning results comparable to finetuning. We recommend that researchers
investigate these lightweight baselines when evaluating the performance of more
computationally intensive finetuning methods. While we do not claim that
methods such as prompting or filtering are universal solutions to the problem
of unlearning, our work suggests the need for evaluation metrics that can
better separate the power of guardrails vs. finetuning, and highlights
scenarios where guardrails expose possible unintended behavior in existing
metrics and benchmarks.
|
[
-0.4932138622,
-0.7561163902,
0.554402113,
-0.0431581475,
-0.5385068655,
0.2848065495,
-0.2949101925,
-0.0711757839,
-0.3472228646,
0.5952316523,
-0.7201316953,
-0.4356751442,
-0.5206506252,
-0.4286032617,
-0.5291883349,
1.074085474,
-0.1757793278,
0.3892306983,
-0.159513697,
-0.1290604323,
-0.6342451572,
-0.1562713981,
-0.8427953124,
-0.8139288425,
0.4841281772,
0.7727684975,
0.3482258618,
0.731824398,
0.3858728409,
0.2371919304,
-0.4875219166,
0.1425741464,
-0.6739438772,
0.1204569116,
-0.2958706021,
-0.47750476,
-0.1483317763,
-0.0334150195,
0.4687564969,
1.1286890507,
-0.2968459129,
0.2128044814,
0.7477306724,
0.8017911911,
-0.7126514912,
-0.0109265931,
-0.6599163413,
0.1119099259,
-0.3429459333,
-0.3540278673,
-0.1842472851,
-0.104069382,
0.0574293621,
-0.4353500307,
0.3218216598,
0.0773581639,
0.6437492967,
0.4488441944,
-0.3533005714,
-0.2030541003,
-0.6443383694,
0.9190663099,
-0.4312291145,
0.321265012,
0.4266923666,
0.3027794361,
-0.2199788988,
-0.7417137027,
-0.1130695939,
-0.2135619372,
-0.0522332303,
0.3898600042,
-0.311740607,
0.1983365715,
0.3633286357,
0.4243857861,
-0.391887933,
0.7547574639,
-0.5223069191,
-0.1151493117,
0.2807599604,
0.4271919131,
0.1423207074,
-0.2825168073,
-0.3850890398,
0.0284619611,
-1.0139193535,
0.2542978525,
0.3682906032,
0.35650298,
-0.190842554,
0.3963463306,
-0.3106491268,
0.3614201546,
0.0596661456,
0.1780998707,
-0.2167098671,
-0.0858335495,
-0.0693006143,
-0.2035467625,
0.5746095181,
0.6525716186,
0.5065292716,
-0.4317691922,
-0.453903228,
0.2695011795,
0.1786635816,
-0.7520729899,
-0.4049485624,
0.204733029,
-0.4284281731,
-0.2149324715,
-0.22503151,
-1.0180959702,
-0.6895798445,
-0.5845348835,
0.4011315405,
-0.510560751,
0.0254235752,
0.0371254943,
-0.120855175,
0.3269456029,
0.4564160705,
-1.0132806301,
0.3599885702,
0.7930519581,
0.9210845232,
-0.3463896811,
-0.3199765384,
-0.6584339142,
-0.3658327758,
-0.3586536646,
0.9695192575,
-0.0149712488,
-0.6166411042,
0.0330407359,
-0.0951338932,
0.2983263135,
-0.6672156453,
0.6550284028,
-0.4205905199,
0.1174296662,
-0.1437066495,
-0.6042455435,
0.1012197062,
-0.1179088131,
-0.3932720423,
0.8774818182,
-0.0238524266,
-0.4800459445,
0.6657370329,
-0.3393547535,
-0.3261007965,
0.1763047129,
-0.0519497581,
-0.4585564137,
0.2356283814,
0.1622888297,
0.5750478506,
-0.2696297169,
0.5011811256,
-0.136401087,
-0.4650602043,
-0.0816014707,
-0.7311888933,
0.8793464899,
0.6125828028,
-0.270406425,
0.107775934,
-0.7323165536,
0.0360278636,
-0.3075882196,
-0.5235673785,
-0.2960506678,
0.1771386266,
-0.0011123379,
-0.1638442725,
0.2199813575,
-0.5272990465,
-0.1246097833,
-0.4005357027,
0.3427216113,
1.1992003918,
0.2953310609,
0.5833768845,
-0.5330186486,
0.4005023837,
-0.0733398199,
0.0745728463,
0.1239036545,
-0.123975575,
-1.0464272499,
-0.149170801,
0.2551006973,
0.2120315284,
-0.7368382812,
0.1042531803,
-0.0095407162,
-0.6111962199,
-0.4544101059,
0.5858238935,
0.9608181715,
0.4856531322,
0.4354474843,
-0.3887224197,
-0.6766474843,
-0.4923302829,
-0.3088953793,
0.0200558044,
-0.0634449348,
-0.2495729327,
0.449667275,
0.0441328473,
0.8118046522,
-0.390630573,
-0.2846249044,
-0.1771274805,
0.3465536535,
0.0213668346,
0.6383272409,
0.2705658674,
-0.3156581819,
-0.3875700831,
-0.0578324459,
-0.7964785099,
-0.1778430343,
-0.0536870025,
0.0568678156,
-0.1877506226,
0.9416105747,
-0.2860789597,
0.2654909492,
0.2196665555,
-0.1223730221,
0.558804214,
-0.2688443959,
-0.2477753609,
-0.9135286808,
-0.0696448013,
-0.0312870853,
-0.1137358695,
-0.8501333594,
0.0092319865,
-0.0056517855,
0.077428259,
-0.7248505354,
0.7140695453,
-0.6581727862,
-0.0513140149,
-0.4261036515,
0.3350068331,
-0.0427130722,
0.492218554,
-0.2218525857,
0.8817939162,
0.6625909209,
-0.9847555161,
0.1422253847,
0.212937817,
-0.6963308454,
0.706535995,
-0.3792886734,
-0.2366068363,
-0.3483787477,
-0.0100871585,
-0.8469179273,
-0.0988827124,
-0.1921640784,
-0.304127872,
0.1670407951,
-0.5059656501,
-0.2587474883,
-0.1563581675,
-0.4977658391,
-0.2227408439,
0.732323885,
-0.9182590842,
0.0594530851,
0.4303717613,
0.1498045623,
-0.5338526964,
-0.5570241213,
-0.1384382099,
-0.6045832038,
0.0596434213,
0.2297367752,
0.0403773412,
-0.3739069402,
-0.1898662597,
-0.311347872,
-0.0332139134,
0.5857948065,
0.4750535786,
0.1274686158,
-0.1384004802,
0.096826002,
-0.2277889401,
-0.3666134179,
0.2049289197,
-0.1076661348,
0.6967480183,
-0.0605523475,
-0.5609366894,
-0.3201016784,
0.0237004291,
0.4180373251,
-0.1863707304,
0.5137632489,
0.4853991866,
-0.4741311073,
-0.4578980803,
-0.3093070984,
-0.219230175,
-0.5871992111,
0.2671390474,
-0.3225164115,
-0.9794943929,
0.6805120111,
-0.4070068002,
0.3993003666,
0.2494729608,
0.3455755413,
-0.5754602551,
1.0277172327,
0.7329667211,
0.0263237879,
0.8550754189,
-0.4077259302,
-0.1568375975,
-0.9817239046,
-0.2063626945,
-0.668407619,
-0.221391812,
-0.67148,
0.0329428278,
0.1811482757,
0.6529538631,
-0.5446994305,
0.203238517,
-0.2860291004,
0.8156248927,
0.628693223,
0.2487644255,
0.4461250007,
0.25791201,
-0.4370914698,
0.040783979,
-0.6684678197,
-0.734143734,
1.2216476202,
0.0596437268,
1.138019681,
0.2010456771,
0.6837103367,
0.1144346073,
0.4132387638,
-0.8625385165,
0.6887277961,
-0.4378583431,
-0.2861976922,
-0.2464272231,
-0.5135840178,
-1.2908440828,
0.1879757345,
-0.314117521,
-1.0207438469,
0.1038123071,
0.2618729174,
-0.6998039484,
0.5110081434,
-0.726964891,
0.710021019,
-0.4257138968,
-0.3855685294,
-0.2941069901,
-0.3184941113,
0.3424986899,
-0.1926696301,
-0.0062646987,
-0.1617099196,
0.1977812052,
0.9165534377,
-0.4796442389,
1.1256070137,
-0.2991155982,
-0.0029296887,
0.2570289075,
0.1117987186,
0.3394007981,
-0.1924305558,
0.137129277,
-0.235951066,
0.0546022877,
-0.2784901559,
-0.6172770262,
0.7913148403,
-0.8367481232,
-0.5377714634,
-0.1944041848,
-0.2157150805,
-0.509447217,
0.157234773,
0.4249241948,
0.5191914439,
-0.277310729,
0.1954048723,
0.8404551744,
0.0611073263,
0.6301941872,
0.7986546159,
-0.1837360561,
-0.2687442005,
0.8529776335,
0.3058273196,
0.2707183361,
0.1939358413,
0.2538690567,
-0.3436855078,
-1.0632675886,
-0.3907214999,
-0.0271591898,
-0.8850233555,
-0.2912858427,
-0.1532574743,
-0.1602959037,
-0.0337038711,
-0.4194003344,
-0.2285882235,
-0.4198288321,
-0.3559957147,
-0.3391941786,
0.6268524528,
0.8713541031,
-0.3505027592,
0.8815116286,
-0.4472583234,
0.1846167147,
0.334941715,
0.6658095717,
0.1195911318,
-0.8382813931,
-0.361456871,
-0.0756469816,
-0.4415475428,
-0.3029192984,
0.0912094042,
-0.0830765888,
0.7992039919,
0.6897673607,
0.209570691,
1.0274549723,
-0.6929519773,
0.5789635777,
0.1996935457,
-0.8257625103,
0.4876908064,
-0.3109942973,
0.2526593804,
0.9282742739,
0.2021927834,
-0.7250949144,
-0.3433350921,
-0.6703048944,
-0.913888514,
0.6481282115,
-0.1421299726,
0.1440922618,
0.2644695938,
0.4433903694,
-0.1217523143,
0.0029298498,
-0.480027765,
-0.1573432386,
0.1212277934,
-0.1275694966,
-0.4471698999,
-0.1679742187,
-0.1990441829,
-0.0651673898,
0.4867175519,
-0.010144908,
-0.0715183467,
-0.3589146733,
-0.405471772,
-0.2241500318,
0.4841477573,
0.3049761057,
0.5309189558,
-0.2856636643,
0.4520384669,
0.6625154018,
-0.3521782756,
0.2139964551,
-0.3207147121,
-0.4006612599,
-0.3468800485,
0.4557829797,
0.6750571132,
0.3665675223,
-0.5891993642,
0.3035066724,
0.2667740583,
-0.2009581327,
-0.1012621224,
0.2758591771,
-0.0319056697,
0.0655701607,
-0.0194533505,
0.1187119409,
-0.1224254817,
-0.5640257001,
0.5440070033,
0.5370281935,
-0.7626040578,
-0.0979986489,
0.6758556366,
0.1973936707,
-0.2275427431,
0.295723021,
0.0332308821,
-0.308008492,
0.4890729785,
0.2574237287,
0.702986896,
-0.0470543876,
0.0508160405,
0.1765984148,
0.3299245238,
-0.4194470048,
0.1178974658,
-0.2074213177,
-0.6470851898,
-0.4148280323,
-0.5278058648,
-0.8184179068,
0.2305608094,
-0.8434485793,
0.2516226768,
-0.7631120682,
0.0035622776,
0.0055623502,
0.2060892433,
-0.5573760867,
0.141246289,
0.0324381739,
0.7814810872,
-0.9415922165,
0.5339842439,
0.5271692276,
-0.5842428803,
-0.7635623813,
-0.068330884,
0.3699988127,
-0.8406035304,
0.3751875758,
0.1269475371,
-0.3961261213,
0.0704025179,
-0.4740554094,
-0.5827804804,
1.0478188992,
0.2386536598,
-0.4662315249,
0.1501632929,
0.1530737728,
0.6311441064,
0.0406778157,
0.2499731779,
0.658881247,
0.1593357623,
-0.2879454494,
-0.610727191,
-0.0944627747,
0.0479824021,
-0.2102085352,
0.0579168983,
-0.8110796213,
0.8654667139,
0.1989763826,
-0.5245128274,
0.2361596823,
0.4855131209,
0.1196147129,
0.2463518679,
0.4003067017,
0.5560575128,
0.925204277,
-0.2435484082,
0.5877408385,
-0.0982607976,
0.3199792504,
1.2699512243,
-0.2099132538,
0.885812521,
0.5408635736,
-0.1749223322,
0.1644618958,
0.7524591684,
0.1248183697,
0.6944646239,
0.3787788451,
-0.3204514384,
-0.2816951275,
-0.1911025643,
0.1175878048,
0.3409235775,
0.2900459766,
0.1726730615,
-0.8299808502,
0.2615005374,
0.3662220538,
0.2578555942,
-0.618300736,
0.9611484408,
0.3378962576,
-0.8934139013,
0.7035834789,
-0.0145578654,
0.8168030381,
-0.4735354781,
0.1867235303,
-0.6770840883,
0.4826346338,
-0.2550680041,
-1.0658624172,
0.2488420606,
0.6234270334,
0.0978777409,
-0.7727898955,
0.4608337581,
-0.2649013996,
-0.0024715231,
0.3322845995,
0.8875221014,
0.3478078544,
0.3049775064,
-0.6044190526,
-0.4571886361,
0.0695831254,
-0.146762833,
0.6264392734,
0.4860906601,
-0.2911211252,
1.0545796156,
0.8096721768,
0.1396874636,
0.0537813902,
0.3286649883,
0.9689749479,
-0.457223177,
-0.247017473,
-0.9581828713,
0.5849818587,
0.1432701051,
-0.4972914755,
0.8974966407,
0.5665179491,
0.86940521,
0.1985068917,
0.6194630861,
0.3388878405,
0.6731530428,
-1.0232845545,
0.9157428741,
-0.4817503989,
0.6041985154,
-0.0933827087,
-0.7269641161,
-0.3537782431,
0.3734808862,
-0.2516623735,
-0.2070899308,
0.5771738887,
1.0344986916,
-0.2444425821,
-0.1573459506,
0.5458105803,
-0.0903769657,
0.1821446568,
0.3496625721,
1.2509394884,
-0.0431721322,
0.6436638832,
-0.2549693286,
0.0026080702,
-0.0092962245,
-0.6822910905,
-1.0214012861,
-0.373906523,
-0.1373234987,
-0.2705383301,
0.2612269223,
0.6943848729,
0.5582188368,
-0.8977639079,
-0.3844418228,
-0.4296242595,
0.2583273947,
-0.0453779288,
-0.1344335824,
0.3712400198,
-0.5753148794,
-0.5638017058,
0.471454829,
-0.1331691742,
0.357648164,
-0.4646512866,
-0.0899279118,
0.1228976995,
-0.0260755848,
0.2232263237,
0.5307065248,
-0.5288781524,
-0.3573226035,
-0.3091931939,
-0.0861344486,
0.0509853661,
0.7620173097,
-0.8508054018,
0.1278752089,
0.3583504856,
0.5671640038,
0.6176713705,
0.0057999562,
0.2833751142,
-1.0307155848,
0.0406346284,
-0.1562668532,
0.6813846827,
0.2901856601,
0.0558870509,
0.5170922279,
-0.1113478243,
-0.4729339778,
-0.9879487753,
0.3355480134,
-0.6088892817,
-0.1611669213,
0.9257241488,
-0.1343295872,
-0.0352423228,
-0.3609135449,
-0.1468185484,
0.2299700677,
-0.1975401491,
0.4534796774,
0.6361154318,
-0.0681855306,
-0.3998697698,
-0.8441651464,
0.7206417918,
0.7389016747,
-0.8220422268,
0.374619633,
0.5004453659,
0.4860755801,
-0.0651940778,
0.5236014724,
0.1450192928,
0.1632806361,
-0.0707799122,
-0.0249739215,
0.1275471896,
-0.3479666114,
-0.8865718246,
-0.1537510604,
0.3187277615,
-0.0607703105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03307v1
|
Book2Dial: Generating Teacher-Student Interactions from Textbooks for Cost-Effective Development of Educational Chatbots
| 2024-03-05T20:12:05 | 2024-03-05T20:12:05 |
Junling Wang, Jakub Macina, Nico Daheim, Sankalan Pal Chowdhury, Mrinmaya Sachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Educational chatbots are a promising tool for assisting student learning.
However, the development of effective chatbots in education has been
challenging, as high-quality data is seldom available in this domain. In this
paper, we propose a framework for generating synthetic teacher-student
interactions grounded in a set of textbooks. Our approaches capture one aspect
of learning interactions where curious students with partial knowledge
interactively ask a teacher questions about the material in the textbook. We
highlight various quality criteria that such dialogues should fulfill and
compare several approaches relying on either prompting or fine-tuning large
language models. We use synthetic dialogues to train educational chatbots and
show benefits of further fine-tuning in different educational domains. However,
human evaluation shows that our best data synthesis method still suffers from
hallucinations and tends to reiterate information from previous conversations.
Our findings offer insights for future efforts in synthesizing conversational
data that strikes a balance between size and quality. We will open-source our
data and code.
|
[
-0.3412029743,
-0.8620329499,
0.1996951103,
-0.2354703993,
-0.0120630674,
0.1543922126,
-0.0578933395,
-0.3119639456,
-0.1260572076,
0.5572856665,
-0.5377136469,
-0.1239688843,
0.1963430047,
-0.2209429741,
-0.4033888578,
0.8053902388,
0.3046854734,
0.3266750574,
-0.7005360723,
0.3150247037,
-0.4918621778,
-0.600084126,
-0.6673440933,
-0.3576231301,
0.2405960113,
0.8072875142,
0.8819846511,
0.0315136723,
0.1625672728,
0.2631967068,
0.1443630606,
0.5582174659,
-0.641459167,
0.4927551746,
-0.2611445487,
-0.4455734193,
-0.2804037035,
0.1249304041,
0.5639477968,
0.6553876996,
-0.0716046169,
-0.1309048682,
0.4748129547,
0.5887088776,
-0.1017853469,
0.1434811503,
-0.4147114456,
0.174714908,
0.1792296618,
-0.2009996325,
-0.6116746664,
-0.3131426871,
0.2360965312,
-0.6196815968,
0.413700074,
-0.1671370417,
0.5778467655,
-0.032354556,
-0.4509925246,
-0.6068093181,
-0.9636329412,
0.6942529082,
-0.5098819733,
0.407186389,
0.7214661837,
0.4818534553,
-0.6121376157,
-0.6774753332,
-0.7943246365,
-0.0969908014,
-0.2253219932,
0.4535970092,
0.1702036411,
-0.0222727917,
-0.0158869196,
0.1802241355,
-0.2255344987,
-0.2774834037,
-0.6365516782,
-0.1730987579,
0.6382912397,
0.3677110374,
0.3372243941,
-0.4618651867,
-0.2887054384,
-0.4334090054,
-0.4142573178,
0.3045136631,
1.1341912746,
0.4243062437,
0.0036101167,
0.6479631662,
0.135375753,
0.5018032789,
-0.3360196352,
-0.1042245477,
-0.2282670587,
-0.7674582601,
0.2749594152,
0.0115929116,
0.6179693937,
0.7387871146,
0.4123958349,
0.0222656745,
-0.1311468184,
0.1081424206,
0.3948478103,
-1.0995208025,
-0.5884116292,
0.3906693459,
-0.0954532996,
-0.5871450305,
-0.177823633,
-1.2960594893,
-0.3595395684,
-0.7375363111,
0.4628714323,
-0.420157522,
-0.419179827,
-0.1714475602,
-0.2285225987,
-0.0334462784,
0.3583870232,
-0.9525550604,
0.5895084739,
0.399343282,
0.5141274333,
0.0597029738,
0.0977150202,
-0.4202138186,
0.0475384444,
-0.4775227308,
0.6120713949,
-0.7108089924,
-0.8599685431,
0.3396022618,
-0.2671653628,
0.2928249836,
-0.5007125735,
0.1233998165,
-0.0529677756,
0.7048813701,
-0.0112208491,
-0.6818252802,
0.1558178812,
0.1819497049,
-0.2305205464,
1.1758437157,
0.3424898684,
-0.1857876033,
-0.0533593558,
-0.3706764877,
-0.3656150103,
0.0619669743,
-0.1727013886,
-0.2715534568,
-0.3649441004,
-0.0693353489,
0.1784262806,
-0.4362010658,
0.3471619189,
0.2133834362,
-0.1275370866,
0.570123136,
-0.3984582424,
0.3911877573,
0.2434081435,
0.0624355711,
-0.1095725596,
-0.8082749844,
0.2640846968,
0.1204253212,
-0.1381072551,
-0.2298544645,
0.2712139785,
0.2185321301,
-0.2207115889,
0.0624865666,
-0.2514726818,
0.3086126447,
-0.6550348997,
0.3997402191,
0.543603301,
0.2677443027,
0.5404350758,
-0.4356021881,
0.3803873956,
-0.0275833309,
0.2834585905,
-0.3785309792,
-0.4382923543,
-0.890159905,
0.1628203392,
0.2769530714,
0.2745228112,
-0.8386919498,
0.0910614207,
-0.0046153478,
-0.6868169904,
-0.3465101719,
0.3597004116,
0.38150087,
0.4399650395,
0.2935959399,
-0.371445179,
-0.4155049324,
-0.5806748867,
-0.0371203758,
-0.2979195714,
-0.1844037175,
0.7460381389,
0.1318753809,
-0.1547346562,
1.3136110306,
-0.4792479277,
-0.3638946712,
-0.1183558255,
-0.1206092462,
-0.178383559,
0.8582254052,
0.5269557834,
-0.8088738322,
-0.471087724,
-0.0611564741,
-0.5208629966,
0.1664546132,
-0.389306128,
-0.7193629742,
0.257579118,
0.4078740478,
-0.5056748986,
0.2680713534,
0.2324330211,
-0.0779073015,
0.2824259996,
-0.0887637362,
0.052056808,
-1.3140765429,
-0.2717565,
-0.189389959,
-0.1345436126,
-0.7803966999,
-0.3747199178,
-0.1850906461,
-0.5272912979,
-0.2718775272,
0.8537853956,
-0.1676867753,
0.0240161847,
-0.0263029523,
0.5300323367,
-0.1695232838,
0.6150276065,
-0.0035965275,
0.899422586,
0.1696240455,
-0.5218476057,
0.4823677242,
0.7378796339,
-0.2401275933,
0.5315150023,
-0.8058981895,
0.2628457546,
0.1801177263,
0.4427899122,
-1.0946739912,
-0.6141270995,
0.5311322212,
-0.6783637404,
0.2482381314,
-0.4378956258,
-0.6563662291,
-0.1675792038,
-0.2573441863,
0.2966372073,
0.8409024477,
-0.5415351391,
0.4904552996,
0.4928503633,
-0.4935114682,
-0.0544490889,
-0.1484415084,
0.2560428083,
0.3744310141,
-0.3862635791,
0.0622579418,
-0.2248122692,
-0.046643097,
0.0009940814,
-0.120317854,
-0.2317468673,
-0.1619523764,
0.3450156748,
0.5773543715,
0.0817910954,
0.499399066,
0.468488723,
-0.0254410226,
0.1254954934,
-0.2462433726,
0.7302952409,
0.3720549047,
-0.1533522606,
-0.4787263274,
0.127506718,
0.3895661533,
0.0626026168,
0.3735761344,
0.1907221526,
-0.5184639692,
-0.4636414349,
-0.1667593718,
-0.7805450559,
-0.5477007627,
0.2272599638,
-0.2261690795,
-0.4543809891,
0.0839772448,
-0.0617148653,
0.2710891068,
-0.1666962057,
0.6352447867,
-0.1256984621,
0.8301066756,
0.1190495044,
0.6096380949,
0.5850630403,
-0.1764559746,
0.4551610351,
-0.4416810572,
-0.6951911449,
-0.4354713261,
-0.066900827,
-0.5040137172,
-0.5091803074,
0.3075072467,
0.0854313001,
-0.0517335385,
0.3152672052,
-0.6483747363,
0.5194962025,
0.7630502582,
0.2329975665,
-0.0874485821,
0.3135282397,
0.0444612093,
-0.0002132534,
-0.5641487241,
-0.8809512854,
1.0524657965,
-0.0303877369,
0.5690133572,
0.4006551206,
0.5199215412,
0.2698509097,
-0.0327077508,
-0.8204259276,
0.7177758217,
0.4261475801,
-0.7904052138,
-0.5004727244,
-0.5027725697,
-1.085149765,
0.1233594269,
-0.5896167755,
-0.5435083508,
-0.2360364348,
0.1488381177,
-0.0998209417,
-0.0740531683,
-0.8336254358,
0.7268061638,
0.1643517613,
-0.7176827788,
-0.3120184541,
-0.5628803372,
0.0163378455,
-0.17463696,
0.1157597229,
0.0239483174,
0.3619799316,
0.6806438565,
-0.7047668099,
1.1509603262,
-0.0532317087,
-0.3754528463,
0.950457871,
0.4623922706,
0.196668148,
0.3745217025,
0.0386625491,
-0.2379657477,
0.3831556439,
-0.5737944841,
-0.5773941875,
0.5951710343,
-0.9742197394,
-0.6830658317,
-0.2277487516,
-0.6431306601,
-0.5573542118,
0.075842917,
-0.2132401168,
0.9001939297,
-0.0937786102,
0.0460917912,
0.1873877198,
-0.2679819763,
0.2177267522,
0.2648334503,
-0.214709416,
-0.4276112616,
1.3242959976,
0.2548574805,
0.4834275544,
0.0320293941,
0.1378253847,
-0.2640377283,
0.1208827496,
-0.6685064435,
-0.0079345768,
-0.696541965,
-0.1742178649,
-0.5775549412,
-0.4853417277,
-0.6429018378,
-0.3456216156,
-0.2326585054,
-0.5406297445,
-0.3502198458,
0.0324371308,
0.4312440157,
0.7710067034,
-0.0363340713,
0.1663018316,
-1.0206817389,
0.0091905007,
0.7631588578,
-0.0307302698,
0.2064843774,
-0.3583031893,
0.0527861565,
0.4653427601,
-0.6400601864,
-0.6675483584,
0.3768779039,
0.3173286021,
0.1323723793,
0.2055404186,
0.4828730226,
0.2966422439,
-0.5413925648,
1.129343152,
0.3164658844,
-0.8331229091,
0.696608305,
-0.2681660652,
-0.2785598934,
0.0740319714,
0.2515488863,
-0.423822403,
-0.4686281085,
-0.6656569839,
-0.7836940289,
0.9114572406,
0.6446152925,
0.9529385567,
0.1793662608,
0.3021956086,
0.2283277661,
0.1932807863,
-0.1796225607,
-0.1977384537,
-0.3272230625,
-0.5849754214,
-0.0056088786,
-0.3978281617,
-0.2666315138,
-0.1509906501,
0.5541793704,
-0.0410509184,
0.0674649253,
0.061643444,
0.3604884148,
-0.1334998757,
0.0219434258,
0.3619077504,
0.479473263,
0.1184154078,
0.0560177155,
0.0327198952,
-0.6630097032,
0.0727061033,
-0.1739166528,
0.0351963788,
0.0116429785,
0.0508500412,
0.4119057953,
0.3313553631,
-0.9147712588,
0.4307515621,
-0.0640248656,
-0.0788388178,
-0.5896968842,
0.6691166162,
0.1048162356,
0.2697921991,
0.1425554007,
-0.047445707,
-0.0159174912,
-0.6788783073,
0.1629200131,
0.1308820844,
-0.4201593399,
-0.4567040205,
0.5673935413,
0.8771560192,
-0.7760596871,
0.8020315766,
0.0501603596,
-0.4792108536,
0.6244476438,
0.5355041623,
0.2053282261,
-0.0705914795,
0.5656231046,
0.7683811784,
-0.1976959556,
0.1829599887,
0.0317828692,
-0.4458974302,
-0.8188657761,
0.2056150436,
-0.2948158979,
-1.2607667446,
-0.254873246,
-0.4828136563,
0.5022886992,
-0.340067625,
-0.0362701416,
0.2176996917,
0.0268706605,
-0.4211285412,
0.1405440718,
-0.0698508099,
0.1906998158,
-0.3492746651,
0.6408385038,
0.6024582386,
-0.4108393788,
-0.6665632725,
-0.2278348356,
-0.1542099863,
-0.4160006046,
0.3382292688,
0.0286811478,
0.082689248,
0.3486329317,
-0.6637403965,
-0.2979985178,
0.5634143949,
0.0811295509,
-0.5867621303,
0.1169398427,
0.4898623824,
0.482342571,
0.112527743,
0.2568445206,
0.2314726263,
0.1083104536,
0.3509290814,
-0.4510145783,
-0.266279608,
-0.3880321681,
-0.1827432364,
0.1637225896,
-0.6390541792,
0.4237082005,
-0.1974340677,
-0.2454933971,
0.2980694473,
0.5419296622,
-0.1899989545,
0.560138762,
0.2728874981,
-0.1256548315,
0.8257954717,
-0.0993309394,
0.7983210087,
-0.4582565725,
0.437279135,
0.9794663787,
-0.2514390349,
0.6950927377,
0.4824008942,
-0.3854574859,
0.1423069835,
0.6959715486,
-0.0498535149,
0.1658135355,
0.2735540867,
-0.4873536825,
-0.4926172793,
-0.2550557852,
-0.3375896215,
0.1855789125,
0.4546894729,
0.2938219607,
0.1025015265,
0.0559137091,
-0.0939582437,
0.1785742044,
0.2021739334,
0.8579252958,
0.086773634,
-0.7343026996,
0.4028167427,
-0.383690536,
0.0402377956,
-0.2160225958,
-0.4502122104,
-0.3043915629,
0.1046172455,
-0.0655520111,
-0.9032641053,
-0.2700203955,
0.0218394138,
-0.0986739025,
-0.1351062208,
0.5606989264,
-0.9137036204,
-0.4953038394,
-0.2245256901,
0.4514226317,
0.4399456978,
0.4338853359,
-0.1500475109,
-0.2445438355,
0.0537109114,
-0.155565992,
0.3617030382,
0.4540861547,
0.1008896828,
0.5269392729,
1.0907684565,
-0.1867332757,
-0.3837105334,
0.0759219006,
0.8560606837,
-0.3356654346,
-0.1596594006,
-0.2967586219,
0.4438124299,
-0.1981076449,
-0.4897926748,
0.5203830004,
0.5036117435,
0.8720358014,
-0.0364507511,
0.793156147,
0.1534240544,
0.5189495087,
-0.4568738341,
0.7412415147,
-0.5049983263,
0.0520114191,
-0.0810234398,
-1.0910432339,
0.2398564517,
0.7734850049,
0.3225564957,
-0.1200258285,
0.2915029526,
0.9406704903,
-0.0191279985,
0.4442372322,
0.4636349678,
0.0035566913,
0.6893621087,
0.1399924159,
0.9285971522,
-0.7290534377,
0.7318974733,
-0.2681004107,
-0.0322891362,
-0.4236316085,
-0.2307031602,
-1.2256467342,
-0.8916759491,
-0.4034296274,
-0.6762287021,
0.1012831554,
1.2315220833,
0.4668626487,
-0.5307466984,
-0.1934844702,
-0.2305983752,
0.0668496564,
0.3695338964,
-0.2343617082,
0.0966287553,
-0.7295696139,
-1.3724420071,
0.2216356248,
-0.3105384111,
0.5258493423,
-0.1976391524,
-0.1434533149,
0.5347805023,
0.6338301301,
0.6430475712,
0.0214971472,
-0.3216507733,
-0.2986620069,
-0.0839055553,
-0.3656462133,
-0.264778018,
0.7846591473,
-0.7279002666,
0.8841431737,
0.2731179297,
0.6963979006,
0.3190158606,
-0.0218979903,
0.5667494535,
-0.5223303437,
0.3099024594,
0.3191376925,
-0.2018118203,
0.2640641928,
-0.1824274659,
0.6511808038,
0.2802442908,
-0.4699001908,
-1.2452878952,
0.0929129943,
-0.8349086642,
-0.1900373548,
1.3593376875,
0.1350418627,
0.0566412173,
0.0085169543,
-0.8494073749,
0.2409009188,
-0.4413408339,
0.6777178049,
0.670958817,
0.1143964157,
0.2191203684,
-0.5861184001,
0.547500968,
0.3362531364,
-0.7780108452,
-0.0464299768,
0.5905282497,
-0.0852042213,
0.0926700905,
0.2456528842,
0.0157383755,
0.2619532943,
0.4252388775,
0.1492007375,
0.0524392761,
-0.3929625154,
0.6043360233,
-0.0968790799,
-0.2965873182,
-0.1251520813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03305v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03305v1
|
Best of Both Worlds: A Pliable and Generalizable Neuro-Symbolic Approach for Relation Classification
| 2024-03-05T20:08:32 | 2024-03-05T20:08:32 |
Robert Vacareanu, Fahmida Alam, Md Asiful Islam, Haris Riaz, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces a novel neuro-symbolic architecture for relation
classification (RC) that combines rule-based methods with contemporary deep
learning techniques. This approach capitalizes on the strengths of both
paradigms: the adaptability of rule-based systems and the generalization power
of neural networks. Our architecture consists of two components: a declarative
rule-based model for transparent classification and a neural component to
enhance rule generalizability through semantic text matching. Notably, our
semantic matcher is trained in an unsupervised domain-agnostic way, solely with
synthetic data. Further, these components are loosely coupled, allowing for
rule modifications without retraining the semantic matcher. In our evaluation,
we focused on two few-shot relation classification datasets: Few-Shot TACRED
and a Few-Shot version of NYT29. We show that our proposed method outperforms
previous state-of-the-art models in three out of four settings, despite not
seeing any human-annotated training data. Further, we show that our approach
remains modular and pliable, i.e., the corresponding rules can be locally
modified to improve the overall model. Human interventions to the rules for the
TACRED relation \texttt{org:parents} boost the performance on that relation by
as much as 26\% relative improvement, without negatively impacting the other
relations, and without retraining the semantic matching component.
|
[
-0.0101787131,
-0.519564867,
0.4404856861,
0.0959041119,
-0.3761492968,
-0.1530274153,
-0.3291478753,
-0.5573039651,
0.1492589265,
0.2688907683,
-0.5565902591,
-0.6167145967,
-0.5557130575,
-0.0592789836,
0.0552754737,
1.1197698116,
0.1268136352,
0.1821498424,
-0.2880532742,
-0.2825369537,
-0.3722686172,
-0.626498282,
-0.5785042048,
-0.6241992116,
0.684024334,
0.0738097206,
0.8770395517,
0.9173541069,
0.5808710456,
0.2603291869,
-0.2325076163,
0.4283464253,
-0.1525707841,
0.2751129568,
-0.2259251475,
-0.3651187122,
-0.6681142449,
-0.1280319542,
0.1468500495,
0.7509081364,
-0.1533583403,
0.1163585111,
-0.118343465,
0.5151121616,
-0.718108654,
0.6560930014,
-0.6243069768,
0.262730062,
0.0274898522,
-0.285672754,
-0.4864142537,
-0.2008683532,
0.2034481019,
-0.7428074479,
0.2047627717,
-0.0535144396,
1.1521449089,
0.132911846,
-0.6560906172,
-0.1240607575,
-0.7232965827,
0.5171300173,
-0.5425669551,
0.5221682787,
0.3715389669,
0.4557198584,
-0.3321878016,
-0.7834823728,
-0.4096672535,
-0.1613252014,
-0.3827259243,
-0.046701666,
-0.2482591867,
0.3436264396,
0.2326970249,
0.2315965444,
-0.3890722096,
0.1353531927,
-0.0235293247,
-0.1922277361,
0.6145191193,
0.3705708683,
0.4727998674,
-0.1505878121,
-0.2684161365,
-0.0678047165,
-0.4527602792,
-0.2467223704,
0.1481748372,
0.449522078,
-0.1787361056,
0.2268752307,
-0.1649649739,
0.5947417021,
0.0623503067,
-0.046322953,
0.1134753749,
-0.3154965937,
-0.263330698,
-0.148136735,
1.0778698921,
0.4658824205,
0.6261334419,
-0.4729279876,
0.0152726434,
0.619407773,
0.0213197768,
-0.7522346377,
-0.2662124038,
-0.3236375451,
-0.5456879139,
-0.22816962,
0.0522010438,
-0.4430571198,
-0.4078187048,
-0.6868128777,
0.2261364907,
-0.5298992395,
-0.3556134999,
-0.0421993732,
-0.0796927437,
0.379806459,
0.4457778335,
-1.077606082,
0.778762579,
1.0930620432,
0.8553634286,
0.0122769624,
-0.1791780591,
-0.2932948172,
0.2240562141,
-0.4264749289,
0.7127320766,
-0.4272407591,
0.3264005482,
0.01119263,
-0.3790874779,
-0.0352098383,
-0.5206367373,
0.3615462184,
-0.8839644194,
0.2359856069,
0.1925883442,
-0.5570291877,
-0.1783640832,
0.3297002912,
-0.6110022068,
0.5346143246,
0.1387785375,
-0.7442008257,
0.6076299548,
-0.5027195811,
-0.5683840513,
-0.0243908409,
-0.3677084744,
-0.407040745,
-0.0760198012,
-0.1555286944,
0.6659825444,
-0.3766313791,
0.5229298472,
-0.4710300565,
-0.2658236921,
-0.0255758557,
-0.0593056045,
0.6895872951,
0.1168575436,
-0.1193751767,
0.279414624,
-0.8091755509,
-0.0881017372,
0.0220796373,
-0.0601611435,
-0.7115089893,
-0.1055071503,
0.0816214085,
0.6096321344,
0.0366721377,
-0.4916929305,
0.260030359,
-0.5745232701,
0.5969800353,
0.6145375967,
0.0647459105,
0.897429347,
-0.1828170419,
0.180228442,
0.2288745493,
0.300693959,
0.0691774487,
-0.3669895232,
-0.7187423706,
-0.1340956241,
0.6375440359,
0.3826131523,
-0.5791243911,
0.5849773884,
-0.6316846609,
-0.3419831097,
-0.1689717323,
0.1415428817,
0.5681790113,
0.4867645204,
0.381963104,
-0.336376816,
-0.5037403703,
-1.0838583708,
-0.1137803942,
-0.2313552648,
0.0883871019,
0.2323324829,
0.5365166664,
-0.0404337347,
0.7932575941,
-0.5116901994,
-0.6654196382,
-0.0096291024,
0.0145568624,
0.2914899588,
0.3486002088,
0.5735679269,
-0.8026602864,
-0.3929664195,
0.3157102168,
-1.079223752,
0.2767997682,
0.0708660707,
-0.266992569,
-0.0574401729,
0.3376541436,
-0.6116530895,
0.4564438164,
-0.1237436906,
-0.5707611442,
0.1975454241,
-0.1440010667,
-0.284715414,
-1.064463973,
-0.3675699532,
0.1711618006,
-0.2707211673,
-0.8298993111,
0.227343455,
0.1722343862,
0.2707391083,
-0.4502408504,
0.4074262977,
-0.3177518249,
0.0616091155,
-0.25606516,
-0.2289527804,
-0.1892946362,
0.8018360138,
0.1877848804,
0.1944883615,
0.4966928661,
-0.8665410876,
0.3986920118,
0.493774116,
0.1159892157,
0.7194107175,
-0.3446474969,
0.2506239712,
-0.2762247622,
0.3354336321,
-0.5719537735,
-0.1735685021,
0.4918133318,
-0.5343750715,
0.3892879784,
-0.2204416841,
-0.7109870911,
0.2354874313,
-0.3936217427,
0.3286798298,
0.4029844105,
-0.6237371564,
1.1427305937,
0.093182534,
0.2264681906,
-0.4864953458,
-0.798884809,
0.1593290418,
-0.0435352325,
-0.6099088788,
0.7161113024,
0.1648595631,
-0.2488205135,
0.218642965,
-0.3394383192,
-0.648121953,
-0.0184878446,
0.412416786,
0.3175114989,
-0.2138676047,
0.356379956,
0.0490245521,
-0.1660621762,
0.165134266,
0.0555760264,
0.3378056586,
-0.0113308132,
0.3727992773,
-0.7387393713,
0.2196796238,
0.570808053,
-0.0441048145,
0.7283537388,
0.2443651259,
-0.5636889935,
-0.4720003605,
-0.3607638478,
-0.3268358707,
-0.427495569,
0.3234580457,
-0.6145710945,
-0.7593356371,
0.4008446932,
-0.0529535972,
-0.0387824625,
0.3455216885,
0.2087469697,
0.0256705638,
0.7711773515,
0.9021812677,
-0.1261441708,
0.3388628662,
-0.3909761608,
-0.0549243614,
-0.7725987434,
-0.5515205264,
-0.2958175838,
-0.4675209522,
-0.6871292591,
0.1338288039,
-0.0743516982,
-0.0621676967,
-0.4989750981,
0.7639788985,
-0.6100886464,
0.3862745464,
0.3534588516,
0.3645666242,
0.5251502395,
-0.2067681253,
-0.1154807657,
-0.3362949789,
-0.7744983435,
-0.2832555771,
0.8584469557,
0.2258524299,
0.5271958113,
0.2269984633,
0.77215451,
0.0023569933,
0.5406447649,
-1.1128568649,
0.6705322862,
-0.3373204172,
-0.4362820983,
0.2217069119,
-0.7905502319,
-0.9397530556,
0.2956849635,
-0.4108814001,
-0.5315354466,
0.3496191204,
0.0848743618,
-0.2269951254,
0.2362234443,
-0.749489367,
0.7268025875,
-0.2827459276,
-0.345356375,
-0.2652208507,
-0.7412244081,
0.5030314326,
0.0712240934,
-0.1188612953,
-0.1203785464,
-0.3683891296,
0.8011956215,
-0.3830506802,
0.6378597021,
-0.0303582754,
0.3293423951,
-0.3100497425,
0.2580796182,
0.1251651645,
-0.0641372651,
0.0205881782,
0.1336682588,
-0.0166026969,
-0.0806817189,
-1.1708594561,
0.7421141863,
-0.771761477,
-0.1391349137,
-0.7665554285,
-0.5786956549,
-0.2227520943,
0.249500379,
-0.005015309,
0.2058658898,
-0.0350874551,
0.1508745998,
0.352751106,
0.1567141265,
0.435172677,
0.5511026382,
0.0341000445,
-0.6251894236,
0.7003313899,
0.0843718722,
-0.0140236141,
0.6424736381,
0.2423887998,
-0.3823902309,
-0.428139329,
0.0866280124,
0.4331295788,
-0.6668817401,
-0.4984035492,
-0.4135594964,
-0.2791108191,
-0.2439515591,
0.2411859632,
-0.1616934091,
-0.1970526129,
-0.2666615844,
-0.0017565095,
0.3807712197,
0.6784288883,
0.3053915501,
0.1221230403,
-0.3496650457,
0.538932085,
0.3500956297,
0.582919538,
0.0546579584,
-0.4031307101,
0.2370845228,
-0.2939931154,
-0.3261991143,
-0.983135879,
0.1905255318,
0.4752352238,
0.2618039548,
0.4122223258,
0.2241617292,
0.7483994365,
-0.5637051463,
0.2144961655,
0.5318522453,
-0.7821241617,
0.4713140726,
-0.2049863786,
-0.1722394526,
0.7760244012,
0.4481349289,
-0.3328370452,
0.1485690176,
-0.8702633977,
-0.7292541265,
0.7558979988,
0.2328153551,
0.2322132438,
0.0702785552,
0.7739226818,
-0.1770312339,
0.2962016463,
-0.5582842827,
-0.3627423048,
-0.0028214182,
-0.4521875679,
0.4277304113,
0.124012202,
0.1867265552,
-0.6695845127,
0.393006444,
-0.2086229771,
0.208392188,
0.1087567061,
-0.0971177295,
0.1471353024,
0.1907321513,
0.3630615473,
0.7291457653,
-0.2629801333,
0.2446094304,
0.1119036004,
-0.2186546624,
0.2232101262,
0.0400360189,
-0.2895533442,
0.0966413021,
0.3739898801,
0.6433870792,
0.3811993897,
-0.096277222,
0.7255715132,
-0.1101117805,
-0.5321900249,
-0.2043132186,
0.0338011459,
0.090240553,
0.1947348118,
-0.0344865546,
0.2233504206,
0.1237463206,
-0.744138062,
0.34025684,
0.4446713924,
-0.4376426637,
-0.3662051857,
0.6143539548,
-0.0564621389,
-0.4625019431,
0.6003410816,
-0.2590504885,
-0.4099561274,
0.3320225179,
0.2751942277,
0.9553441405,
0.0514769219,
0.2276492119,
0.1454754919,
0.0242196675,
-0.0966691002,
-0.0943333805,
-0.3127355576,
-0.9348760843,
-0.5431010127,
-0.4144775271,
-0.3420220613,
0.3591404855,
-0.7500163913,
0.3875951767,
-0.9933793545,
-0.1934867501,
0.470815599,
-0.1263471991,
-0.7165335417,
0.031086361,
-0.0381115787,
0.875056982,
-0.8020633459,
0.8072135448,
0.9179792404,
-0.6523855329,
-0.8086399436,
-0.164561227,
-0.174617067,
-0.4364490211,
0.9732887149,
0.1274450421,
-0.0876670629,
-0.2908793092,
-0.5204435587,
-0.1716118157,
0.9557064176,
0.7094841599,
-0.3840608895,
-0.34131217,
-0.0272358023,
0.9219721556,
-0.3267358541,
0.4095965326,
0.6026201844,
0.3122299016,
0.1380272955,
-0.8467680216,
0.2050986886,
-0.44488433,
0.1978102624,
0.4558031857,
-0.6303510666,
0.331705302,
0.0680404678,
-0.2411403358,
0.0499223508,
0.8326789737,
-0.0268323496,
0.4874017537,
0.4849887788,
0.6195545197,
0.3999246359,
-0.313654542,
0.8365929723,
-0.0865176097,
0.3239212334,
1.3303210735,
-0.2808374465,
0.9468019605,
0.5092331767,
-0.1512703896,
0.7991613746,
0.4226233959,
-0.1397416443,
0.5194563866,
0.2843076289,
-0.0900641456,
-0.4696567655,
-0.3870391548,
0.0254598763,
0.4613562822,
0.0634762794,
-0.51951015,
-0.5519522429,
-0.2892954946,
-0.0238457788,
0.6394070983,
-0.1651188135,
1.1251119375,
0.3554775119,
-0.4326047897,
0.314640522,
-0.0325730629,
1.1007467508,
-0.6552637219,
-0.3620771766,
0.0293353125,
0.4449611008,
-0.5284499526,
-0.5719012618,
0.2789027989,
-0.1914085448,
-0.4223831892,
-0.0976257026,
0.8130233288,
-0.3948513865,
-0.0930346176,
0.5349560976,
0.2876674831,
-0.2523123622,
0.0000423008,
-0.7209950089,
-0.3790014982,
-0.4642989039,
0.0815787092,
0.5235518217,
0.3467899263,
-0.2736799419,
0.6066262722,
0.629891336,
0.2158672512,
-0.1383225918,
0.1860018224,
1.0154881477,
-0.8025822639,
-0.5855526924,
-0.9670764804,
0.1363894343,
-0.1755989939,
-0.5816594958,
0.4642872512,
0.4500334263,
0.7461800575,
-0.0175406281,
0.2385170758,
0.07218007,
0.0386761315,
-0.2325054407,
0.4981224537,
-0.1978664398,
0.0512413979,
-0.1732831895,
-0.9919921756,
-0.9492846131,
0.6206377149,
-0.3359411359,
0.0509264618,
0.8923835754,
0.6787515879,
-0.2877319455,
0.0622411259,
0.2171578556,
0.0430585481,
0.1719176322,
1.0250246525,
0.9158492088,
-0.5835847855,
0.5834087133,
-0.4897161722,
-0.1380706728,
0.144817844,
-0.7575235963,
-1.0722392797,
-0.4498387277,
-0.6521219611,
-0.2953092456,
0.2736878991,
1.153919816,
1.0049860477,
-0.6558207273,
-0.0876852944,
-0.4586220384,
0.0875861272,
-0.3567406535,
-0.3367322683,
0.4190836251,
-0.2641451359,
-0.3592767119,
0.1942536831,
0.2512285113,
-0.1995028108,
0.1241342202,
-0.2478475869,
-0.2634313703,
-0.4166641831,
0.647151351,
0.2083315849,
-0.5659546852,
0.0419610888,
0.019723,
-0.1774406135,
0.1328664422,
0.6947948337,
-0.7770130038,
0.2096987814,
0.6800835133,
0.6897439957,
0.4972516596,
-0.0834532306,
0.4788077176,
-0.8627449274,
0.0296789929,
0.5486162901,
0.2783442438,
0.2232093662,
-0.4407890141,
0.6300086379,
0.2851439416,
-0.3202270567,
-0.6694021225,
0.2456386536,
-1.2033137083,
-0.1494054049,
1.0764149427,
-0.0481903702,
-0.4807188511,
-0.2142828852,
0.0535718873,
0.414804548,
-0.477848351,
0.4982677996,
0.2796323299,
-0.3666625023,
-0.1665208191,
-0.3266938627,
0.4705990255,
0.1958549321,
-0.7591528296,
-0.160212487,
0.3944827616,
0.5284939408,
0.4441602826,
0.2670558095,
-0.2001633346,
0.5326682925,
-0.3047577739,
-0.0057403427,
-0.5002835989,
-0.4535279274,
-0.4634641111,
0.2243151516,
0.0152659509,
-0.24049595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03304v2
|
Large Language Models for Document-Level Event-Argument Data Augmentation for Challenging Role Types
| 2024-03-05T20:07:42 | 2024-06-12T19:21:33 |
Joseph Gatto, Parker Seegmiller, Omar Sharif, Sarah M. Preum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Event Argument Extraction (EAE) is an extremely difficult information
extraction problem -- with significant limitations in few-shot cross-domain
(FSCD) settings. A common solution to FSCD modeling is data augmentation.
Unfortunately, existing augmentation methods are not well-suited to a variety
of real-world EAE contexts including (i) The need to model long documents (10+
sentences) (ii) The need to model zero and few-shot roles (i.e. event roles
with little to no training representation). In this work, we introduce two
novel LLM-powered data augmentation frameworks for synthesizing extractive
document-level EAE samples using zero in-domain training data. Our highest
performing methods provide a 16-pt increase in F1 score on extraction of zero
shot role types.
To better facilitate analysis of cross-domain EAE, we additionally introduce
a new metric, Role-Depth F1 (RDF1), which uses statistical depth to identify
roles in the target domain which are semantic outliers with respect to roles
observed in the source domain. Our experiments show that LLM-based augmentation
can boost RDF1 performance by up to 11 F1 points compared to baseline methods.
|
[
-0.4319696426,
-0.7949197888,
0.5032404661,
0.0008364964,
-0.2139046788,
0.0065418975,
-0.1923489869,
-0.69512254,
0.0694181472,
0.4023777246,
-0.8235543966,
-0.7049534917,
-0.6311761737,
0.1893727481,
-0.3304719925,
0.9270935059,
-0.075925,
-0.1041997746,
-0.4294058084,
0.0200524013,
-0.2166943699,
-0.5277736783,
-0.7577002048,
-0.2433616519,
0.4196844995,
0.7404358983,
0.4050878584,
0.5641625524,
0.276245445,
0.1815377921,
0.2261206061,
0.3169569373,
-0.3712471128,
0.2625615895,
-0.2588504851,
-0.297596395,
-0.7100299597,
-0.0144817103,
0.5035862327,
0.6528695226,
0.2811423242,
-0.0516690351,
-0.0662426874,
0.2393588871,
-0.5658597946,
0.30327788,
-0.6300905347,
0.1093445346,
-0.224914059,
-0.405507803,
-0.3785050511,
0.2441288382,
0.2292251289,
-0.6911373734,
0.3842425346,
-0.2128610015,
0.7856969237,
-0.1260840595,
-0.2726008892,
-0.1321496069,
-0.6631364226,
0.7691414952,
-0.9388152361,
0.3333054781,
0.2292355001,
-0.0139820827,
-0.1354795098,
-0.5035640001,
-0.4420603216,
0.0205316897,
0.0086483639,
0.053182438,
-0.1309049278,
0.2728471458,
0.3653694987,
0.1972796917,
-0.5264684558,
0.4812705219,
-0.0942332149,
0.1182951182,
0.9383925796,
0.198043108,
0.2090879381,
-0.1796084046,
-0.2780632973,
-0.1354973316,
-0.7519258261,
-0.108748816,
0.4589979649,
0.326951921,
-0.0428290218,
0.6179966927,
-0.1479640603,
0.5758057833,
0.1039365977,
-0.0133590484,
-0.2295891345,
-0.2831661403,
-0.4104700387,
0.0769826174,
0.5501692295,
0.1220536083,
0.0685605705,
-0.3091488779,
-0.0741669387,
-0.2335938662,
0.0094050886,
-1.0727299452,
0.1159225255,
0.4380014837,
-0.1922047883,
-0.448810339,
0.3178169429,
-0.9379428029,
-0.5077019334,
-0.1917192191,
0.3739164174,
-0.5185285807,
-0.1834404618,
0.138294071,
-0.1540512294,
0.5193609595,
0.4800972044,
-0.7813045979,
0.3124572635,
0.8434391022,
0.6089115739,
-0.5275208354,
-0.0818399042,
-0.8285764456,
0.1660342515,
-0.3144679368,
0.8946779966,
-0.8139443994,
-0.453904748,
0.2399875969,
0.0640015081,
-0.037964765,
-0.4460850954,
0.8886342645,
-0.5266619325,
0.3880520463,
-0.0343807526,
-0.9097735286,
0.0199967343,
0.126965493,
-0.6387419701,
1.0105580091,
0.1794959307,
-0.3538852334,
0.8057427406,
-1.0141422749,
-0.6491237283,
0.2664443254,
-0.3863240778,
-0.2846010327,
0.088171497,
0.5575300455,
0.713835597,
-0.3800898194,
0.0143812168,
-0.3524052203,
-0.1475588828,
0.0220372882,
-0.5011176467,
0.5961748362,
-0.1298413426,
-0.2500493228,
0.1029139012,
-0.973454237,
-0.1861588061,
0.1166992709,
-0.1876539588,
-0.3308645785,
0.1370423883,
0.0939936191,
0.3681825399,
0.1429384202,
-0.6941467524,
0.2579527795,
-0.6326483488,
0.1422219872,
0.5912256241,
0.2384478152,
0.5904647708,
-0.0795753077,
0.7497934699,
0.2010003477,
-0.0029974934,
-0.4120237231,
-0.3053718209,
-0.4214116335,
-0.5074679255,
0.2138833702,
0.547745347,
-0.6417180896,
0.6693746448,
-0.3958640397,
-0.2164863944,
-0.4675223529,
0.2243858129,
-0.1184121296,
0.4163856506,
0.421910882,
-0.0643384233,
-0.6075945497,
-0.7442021966,
-0.2255823165,
-0.2962268591,
-0.0952822715,
0.2103196084,
0.2324906737,
-0.0267180186,
1.1198329926,
-0.3557556868,
-0.5499307513,
-0.4548802078,
0.1587139666,
0.1708488613,
0.3323934078,
0.3555790484,
-0.5389612317,
-0.2003110945,
0.2871051431,
-0.7474805713,
-0.3130681813,
-0.3713213205,
0.0890817419,
0.4129614234,
0.4415687919,
-0.7770923376,
0.4092809856,
0.165177837,
-0.3540623188,
0.2849768102,
0.0847555399,
0.1678721756,
-1.0394768715,
-0.1046559438,
0.2412611544,
-0.2901270688,
-0.7777249813,
0.0849922597,
-0.092234984,
-0.2255671471,
-0.4161864817,
0.802287221,
-0.4960377216,
-0.097068131,
-0.3820408583,
0.3746544421,
0.3370771408,
0.2930957079,
0.2950350344,
0.4234243333,
0.6019109488,
-0.3027767539,
0.255569756,
0.2568813562,
-0.3397680521,
0.5961498022,
-0.4353207648,
0.0708401725,
-0.1499703228,
0.1959587634,
-0.9348306656,
-0.363507092,
-0.095277518,
-0.1992686987,
0.5810709,
-0.4233484864,
-0.4806355536,
-0.0157011207,
-0.4901497066,
0.3481346965,
0.158012256,
-0.6902030706,
0.6390787363,
0.2566948235,
-0.385024637,
-0.5768982172,
-0.7126018405,
0.2463013232,
-0.3664872944,
-0.9813584089,
0.6829001307,
0.1662772149,
-0.152927056,
0.0765881091,
-0.2128020376,
-0.1180498973,
-0.0442957096,
0.17148,
0.3121604919,
-0.507478714,
-0.0160305575,
0.2945265472,
0.0272866655,
0.0182362236,
-0.0857411399,
0.244828552,
0.2473472804,
-0.5661349297,
-0.1528280079,
0.8649650812,
0.5587501526,
-0.1259900779,
0.6169725657,
0.5052996278,
-0.6208802462,
-0.4479282498,
-0.5361741781,
-0.3248640895,
-0.4176852107,
0.5056407452,
-0.3349409103,
-0.9781137705,
0.5581475496,
0.0435839407,
0.3869483471,
0.5138282776,
0.2687283158,
0.1004815772,
0.9405238032,
0.2660021484,
-0.0709662661,
0.5855197906,
-0.3792343438,
0.1707479656,
-0.6053148508,
0.008763209,
-0.2830795646,
-0.1378674358,
-0.235824585,
-0.6402385831,
0.4641557038,
0.2895911932,
0.0896232948,
0.2622699142,
-0.0249546636,
0.4049189985,
-0.0576503761,
-0.255559653,
0.359574765,
0.2045206577,
0.2889270484,
-0.1195474789,
-0.8556610942,
-0.5123279095,
0.8835110068,
0.512111783,
0.6021665335,
0.0277986322,
0.8784396648,
0.3635043204,
0.2754690945,
-0.8933683634,
0.5723616481,
-0.2730038762,
-0.6196787357,
-0.570643425,
-0.161394462,
-0.7900801897,
0.3552796543,
-0.4512922168,
-0.7835197449,
0.5272510052,
-0.2746188343,
-0.2808563113,
0.2585838139,
-0.4783580303,
0.9506121278,
-0.00678463,
-0.5786087513,
-0.0883784071,
-0.2239013165,
0.2256331146,
-0.1472403556,
0.1616763175,
0.0105516845,
-0.0638646483,
0.6952863932,
-0.4017702341,
0.7052809,
-0.3124025166,
-0.3519641757,
0.3447264433,
-0.0081096366,
0.9266018867,
0.2745189965,
-0.510271132,
0.0598702729,
0.0102681853,
-0.3164423108,
-0.7226030231,
0.7366038561,
-0.492978394,
-0.7675631642,
-0.2489268929,
-0.4693169594,
-0.4853712022,
-0.0282712262,
0.1406555176,
0.5665242672,
-0.4761682749,
0.371186465,
0.4223278761,
-0.2109231502,
0.5791746974,
0.6947721839,
0.1678686589,
-0.1814573258,
0.7541363239,
0.1085077077,
0.1072188467,
0.5444168448,
-0.0976976305,
-0.4098495841,
-0.5447463393,
-0.6252729893,
0.0340916626,
-0.7132465839,
-0.3694512248,
-0.7595008612,
-0.280330956,
-0.4541116059,
-0.3637147248,
-0.1888128966,
-0.6819928288,
-0.5257472992,
-0.5498994589,
0.4069737792,
0.2370979935,
-0.1384491175,
0.2941213846,
-0.8449598551,
0.2441951334,
-0.0798469558,
0.1791122109,
-0.1882468462,
-0.4813916087,
-0.3005022109,
-0.2555099726,
-0.2580707967,
-0.873789072,
0.4122983515,
0.3968926668,
0.598731339,
0.4008829296,
0.0157200322,
0.8732871413,
-0.3602655232,
0.9618363976,
0.0783797875,
-0.8814170361,
0.4820498526,
-0.2970021665,
-0.125144735,
0.4207697213,
0.2446939647,
-0.2552876472,
-0.4006145895,
-0.7192835212,
-1.0726695061,
0.9910759926,
0.0871966034,
0.0173292011,
-0.1788809299,
0.4686359167,
0.3260900974,
-0.1583277434,
-0.5690713525,
-0.0055179833,
0.112661846,
-0.223294124,
0.1464199275,
-0.0577344336,
-0.0430909656,
-0.0623669289,
0.7061930299,
-0.2727578878,
0.0181071367,
0.5085645914,
-0.1609057635,
-0.4150341749,
0.4410861433,
0.4837138355,
0.6391813755,
-0.2143710554,
-0.1048859954,
0.3066107035,
-0.1437957436,
0.051290106,
0.4804866314,
0.0149800889,
0.0672394037,
0.8272166848,
0.8541975021,
0.1969117969,
-0.5679243803,
0.6042538285,
0.213362366,
-0.3379594386,
-0.1485586762,
0.1448303908,
-0.2085459828,
0.3237194717,
0.5599967837,
-0.4510359764,
0.1020755768,
-0.55146873,
0.4794415832,
0.6721599102,
-0.3652917445,
-0.1740087271,
0.5669970512,
0.2883728743,
-0.0748368204,
0.0126221878,
-0.0073857075,
0.0351652615,
0.6003767252,
0.582706213,
1.0108934641,
-0.0245095789,
0.338711828,
0.1528723687,
0.2662447989,
0.2136009634,
0.1579777449,
0.0459907502,
-0.6999996305,
-0.8558557034,
-0.6024135351,
-0.319791764,
0.6432062387,
-0.5376202464,
0.4043107331,
-0.2568927705,
0.0830164477,
0.146712929,
0.3435259759,
-0.6510680318,
0.2080894858,
0.0426068343,
1.05397439,
-0.7520606518,
0.8459615707,
0.5764324665,
-0.3700691462,
-0.3878211975,
0.0434956513,
-0.1873884648,
-0.3238427043,
0.4326142073,
-0.1146231741,
0.028816564,
0.0033410119,
-0.1848559231,
-0.467474252,
1.1598920822,
0.4404560924,
-0.3756338358,
-0.1403031051,
0.4454638958,
0.536290586,
-0.9341977835,
0.1565326452,
0.5000813603,
0.5811998248,
-0.1061265096,
-0.3771062195,
0.1268480122,
0.0466625988,
-0.2021344453,
-0.013171955,
-0.171531707,
0.3745809793,
0.0600381903,
-0.3009906709,
-0.1583994031,
0.7281713486,
0.1808827817,
0.491607219,
0.4773036838,
0.3478617668,
0.5175338387,
0.173169747,
1.0887680054,
-0.1472572386,
0.0528667495,
0.9640652537,
-0.7117401958,
0.5637235045,
0.3304634392,
0.0697644353,
0.4547791183,
0.4314870834,
0.0971639156,
0.178691268,
-0.0742185041,
-0.4650557041,
-0.4688830674,
-0.0272187982,
-0.0626889616,
0.3556074798,
0.5126718283,
-0.3570893705,
-0.4220178723,
-0.1505417526,
-0.1392624378,
-0.0353489965,
-0.2054896057,
0.8192554116,
0.1874877065,
-0.5432969332,
0.2994747162,
0.379496634,
0.3765587211,
-0.5700992942,
-0.2372547537,
-0.3503385186,
-0.0336902998,
-0.3709605336,
-0.846773088,
0.2973677516,
0.2902368307,
-0.3110875785,
-0.0527175777,
1.0126897097,
-0.5921378732,
-0.4293483794,
0.4835496247,
0.6367449164,
-0.0095449183,
-0.0140237873,
-0.5220699906,
0.0810994282,
-0.2987068295,
-0.3906359076,
0.5360269547,
0.6428714395,
-0.3368270993,
0.2141415179,
0.657264173,
0.1724460125,
-0.0042666835,
0.226641044,
0.756279707,
-0.5394037962,
-0.2838009894,
-0.9591475129,
0.5350196362,
-0.4509733021,
-0.1166054159,
0.4783383012,
0.6676136851,
0.5644187927,
-0.0886231065,
0.9068786502,
0.0139650544,
0.2760151029,
-0.5130906105,
0.3131560087,
-0.5751633644,
0.3527828753,
-0.3940710425,
-0.92217803,
-0.4351348877,
0.4462704659,
-0.2679154277,
-0.1328694373,
0.4177829027,
0.9424905777,
-0.3476479352,
0.1194167137,
0.5720146894,
0.0187585969,
0.6535230875,
0.6166539788,
0.6166263223,
-0.5625810623,
0.4406379163,
0.1529548913,
-0.2758827209,
-0.3428146839,
-1.174752593,
-0.7925667763,
-0.529764533,
-0.5956469178,
-0.0707561597,
-0.0380537398,
1.1234315634,
0.8707054853,
-0.9036302567,
-0.1108832806,
-0.0550226122,
0.1445968598,
-0.1864193976,
-0.3290150762,
0.3675501645,
-0.3412802815,
-0.7864609957,
1.0024087429,
0.4998220503,
-0.2260810733,
-0.1762957573,
-0.01580403,
-0.2125759572,
0.4720359743,
0.8901883364,
0.3737010956,
-0.6103773117,
-0.4766022265,
-0.2124396563,
0.1616586596,
0.0499421246,
0.879668951,
-0.5286293626,
0.1851893216,
0.5179795027,
0.8626018763,
0.6517409682,
0.1594065577,
0.7326459289,
-1.2726620436,
0.0917854086,
0.0812302455,
0.3358678222,
0.2866012156,
-0.6082135439,
0.5776568651,
0.2104154229,
-0.2624122798,
-0.9537025094,
0.2441624105,
-1.1819440126,
-0.2365085632,
1.3279290199,
-0.1949141026,
-0.0302545652,
-0.1277576387,
-0.1546432376,
0.1599480957,
-0.3825794458,
0.471265316,
0.8713937998,
-0.3358534276,
-0.2432074845,
-0.4196582735,
0.6582513452,
0.2578499019,
-1.0729014874,
0.364515543,
0.6877692342,
0.1159305722,
0.0636546463,
0.5178043842,
-0.3911180198,
0.1678860784,
-0.2651869953,
-0.1673827022,
-0.3068326712,
-0.4042872488,
-0.4212598801,
0.5270527005,
-0.0774690211,
0.1242034063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04801v2
|
Alpaca against Vicuna: Using LLMs to Uncover Memorization of LLMs
| 2024-03-05T19:32:01 | 2024-03-31T04:33:56 |
Aly M. Kassem, Omar Mahmoud, Niloofar Mireshghallah, Hyunwoo Kim, Yulia Tsvetkov, Yejin Choi, Sherif Saad, Santu Rana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce a black-box prompt optimization method that uses
an attacker LLM agent to uncover higher levels of memorization in a victim
agent, compared to what is revealed by prompting the target model with the
training data directly, which is the dominant approach of quantifying
memorization in LLMs. We use an iterative rejection-sampling optimization
process to find instruction-based prompts with two main characteristics: (1)
minimal overlap with the training data to avoid presenting the solution
directly to the model, and (2) maximal overlap between the victim model's
output and the training data, aiming to induce the victim to spit out training
data. We observe that our instruction-based prompts generate outputs with 23.7%
higher overlap with training data compared to the baseline prefix-suffix
measurements. Our findings show that (1) instruction-tuned models can expose
pre-training data as much as their base-models, if not more so, (2) contexts
other than the original training data can lead to leakage, and (3) using
instructions proposed by other LLMs can open a new avenue of automated attacks
that we should further study and explore. The code can be found at
https://github.com/Alymostafa/Instruction_based_attack .
|
[
-0.3011799455,
-1.1844322681,
0.8343194127,
-0.0875072107,
-0.4220353663,
-0.0151444189,
0.1187980697,
-0.2770540714,
0.2730111778,
0.6235876679,
-0.8794799447,
-0.7551758289,
-0.6490778327,
-0.0465263613,
-0.4238192141,
0.8151212931,
-0.031912867,
0.0947396904,
-0.1250324845,
-0.1453277469,
-0.7233915329,
-0.8009650111,
-0.8512685299,
-0.306637913,
0.6326267123,
0.3634071052,
0.3862388134,
1.1536159515,
0.2895158827,
0.2747933865,
0.0858244449,
0.1817626953,
-0.4124032259,
0.2037733644,
0.193841368,
-0.9910226464,
-0.219133541,
-0.0921380147,
0.4054076672,
0.2713832855,
-0.0520941876,
0.1764920801,
-0.1580822468,
0.4938566387,
-0.8799645901,
-0.1689848304,
-0.8471400142,
0.1930394322,
-0.1173266917,
-0.9045006037,
-0.4912424386,
-0.3187115788,
-0.1866082847,
-0.5755468607,
0.4621931314,
-0.1226365343,
0.6098399162,
0.6348776221,
-0.1930210441,
-0.6966602206,
-0.5365243554,
0.6265923381,
-0.3094601631,
-0.0210242663,
0.4541393518,
0.3632525802,
-0.4401241541,
-0.3139513433,
-0.2524193525,
-0.2925084829,
0.2660901546,
0.1593423635,
-0.4136354923,
0.1128704771,
0.2744093537,
0.1749453992,
-0.2618216872,
0.3417890668,
-0.3326036334,
-0.2471479028,
0.3913236856,
0.4752690196,
0.2478307933,
0.0234648995,
-0.6865667701,
-0.1641878933,
-0.7957227826,
0.2120559514,
0.5787863135,
0.3353743255,
-0.014168785,
0.5728991032,
0.0078127207,
0.5854783058,
-0.1707928926,
-0.3234688938,
-0.0077946656,
0.1967285722,
-0.2145205289,
0.256919086,
0.7674524784,
0.3101855516,
-0.1020367444,
-0.1495341808,
-0.3832290471,
0.0489422567,
0.5376221538,
-0.7993763685,
-0.0050375406,
0.3318841755,
-0.2894795239,
-0.3747349977,
-0.061470475,
-0.7853243947,
-0.4739266634,
-0.206370011,
0.6784643531,
-0.5670485497,
0.4712980688,
0.1290988922,
-0.216234237,
0.5009453893,
0.3135023713,
-0.7495144606,
0.3094907403,
0.808300674,
0.9385710359,
-0.0003443725,
-0.2193322182,
-0.8539324999,
0.2102695107,
-0.4469785094,
0.7896335721,
-0.2894098163,
-0.5841930509,
0.0211220793,
-0.1139621511,
-0.0645310879,
-0.5078660846,
0.4284102619,
-0.5634763837,
-0.1092113182,
-0.4310474694,
-0.6394912004,
-0.2362221777,
0.2642455101,
-0.7836225033,
0.9948996902,
-0.0565695018,
-0.4356687963,
0.1291279197,
-0.5310047269,
0.0049428605,
-0.1280397326,
-0.2062504441,
-0.6239467263,
0.0969226658,
0.3037115932,
0.3790819645,
-0.4337960482,
-0.2238781452,
-0.1463328451,
-0.6359385848,
0.4091563821,
-0.6592658162,
0.9170846939,
0.1906844527,
-0.5225670338,
0.1358981133,
-0.8031773567,
-0.1142597571,
0.4350424409,
-0.1974153817,
-0.2923865914,
-0.2694444954,
-0.8375803828,
-0.301995039,
0.3177067935,
-0.2034380287,
0.4040133059,
-0.0703804046,
0.0066795284,
0.9071905613,
0.4391162992,
0.2911764085,
-0.5566458106,
0.9099754095,
-0.1823844463,
0.5164517164,
-0.5096079111,
-0.3019728065,
-0.8286293149,
-0.4778688252,
-0.0935760364,
0.696164608,
-0.683920145,
0.2564606667,
0.2166181356,
-0.4671802819,
-0.756722033,
0.2371613234,
0.5146207809,
0.6682491302,
0.5514270067,
-0.386082828,
-0.4333735108,
-0.900580585,
0.0097479466,
-0.1412138492,
0.0262430068,
0.115598619,
0.3344196677,
-0.3234617412,
0.7283843756,
-0.5194277167,
-0.3779404759,
0.0707752779,
-0.0738751143,
-0.0155500825,
0.2651964128,
0.6507389545,
-0.288916558,
0.0167475101,
-0.4254118502,
-0.8270865679,
-0.2349687964,
-0.2033250034,
-0.2315537483,
0.0185006559,
0.7639039159,
-0.525174737,
0.601939261,
0.0655698776,
-0.1392552108,
0.5252646804,
-0.2920546234,
0.0791670084,
-0.8607850671,
-0.1423425227,
-0.3151766956,
-0.0568380058,
-0.7148823738,
0.3874970973,
0.1173301116,
0.0498976,
-0.6613087654,
0.4303331077,
-0.6904000044,
-0.1824062318,
-0.5349646211,
-0.2523501813,
0.0152782956,
0.7136951089,
-0.3207582831,
0.9707635045,
0.4519225955,
-0.7263218164,
0.3945626318,
-0.0153539982,
-0.1103783846,
0.3406436741,
-0.5794786811,
0.5957581401,
-0.3109489083,
0.040337868,
-0.6427283883,
0.0532416366,
0.6686418056,
-0.4195128977,
0.1793429852,
-0.240670681,
-0.3901131451,
-0.1445806623,
-0.5684626698,
0.3537182212,
0.3860035539,
-0.5954392552,
0.6211265326,
0.125587523,
0.3004609346,
-0.9187939167,
-0.3677308261,
0.0006925925,
-0.5934659839,
-0.0107947337,
0.0709089041,
-0.2572464347,
-0.2319024801,
-0.3148407936,
-0.0682011694,
0.1529018283,
0.5020040274,
0.4167914093,
0.3708269894,
-0.1735166907,
0.0867005065,
0.0227774195,
-0.0226318706,
0.346100986,
-0.2028745264,
0.9686350226,
-0.0174490288,
-0.5687424541,
-0.6234095097,
0.4865502715,
0.1820702106,
-0.0569015592,
0.8398316503,
0.3614063859,
-0.2699232996,
-0.321656853,
-0.5540474057,
-0.2209303826,
-0.5381345153,
0.2636214495,
-0.5008594394,
-0.3681312203,
0.7166805267,
0.1716446429,
-0.0614335574,
0.0470957197,
0.6283029914,
-0.0044757766,
0.6047781706,
0.6586927176,
-0.1854710579,
0.6724655628,
-0.5802246928,
-0.3529510498,
-0.7128224969,
-0.4693127871,
-0.5020293593,
-0.1484034657,
-0.1252685487,
-0.4769060016,
0.3573755026,
0.1718543023,
-0.1082198173,
0.2452312261,
-0.5444185138,
0.7447621226,
0.638471961,
0.4376705587,
0.1788215786,
-0.0845499486,
0.0236674678,
0.2394106686,
-0.6661673784,
-0.61306566,
1.3495525122,
0.4958811998,
0.6262486577,
-0.0809151307,
1.1530790329,
0.3111725152,
0.2341975272,
-1.1314499378,
0.6609039903,
0.4061918259,
-0.2207039744,
-0.2487443238,
-0.3676027656,
-1.4605624676,
0.2003228813,
0.0142777078,
-0.6252703667,
0.1947992891,
0.1098671332,
-0.4215349853,
0.225575313,
-0.6964117289,
0.5217696428,
-0.4089003801,
-0.1284717023,
0.1080228835,
-0.4242215157,
0.3096512854,
-0.0109650511,
0.1826233864,
-0.1066267192,
-0.5529759526,
0.8535137773,
-0.5269416571,
0.9549950957,
-0.2468124777,
-0.4760421813,
0.5279455781,
0.0136566544,
0.5155908465,
-0.0727182701,
0.0378699489,
-0.1214999929,
-0.3983931541,
-0.6796773076,
-0.7373661399,
0.2920130491,
-0.8951909542,
-0.9448399544,
-0.29422611,
-0.6279798746,
-0.0417276397,
0.0267939828,
0.60793823,
0.4511683583,
-0.14874731,
-0.1287829131,
0.9036637545,
-0.0872607604,
0.4633466005,
0.5855446458,
0.1506673545,
-0.4700493217,
0.7826812267,
0.1485072225,
0.3535081446,
0.4722076654,
-0.0148160923,
0.0299572963,
-0.8442311883,
-0.3645067215,
0.2871170938,
-1.0100054741,
-0.4219193161,
-0.6401690841,
-0.0205564704,
-0.0751883835,
-0.0963713005,
-0.2090398818,
-0.1830541044,
-0.5569124222,
-0.2335963398,
0.4832078815,
0.5523766875,
0.2630566061,
0.7947878242,
-0.6039756536,
0.4699902236,
0.3033533394,
-0.1204149798,
0.1335407495,
-0.5664259195,
-0.2568851709,
0.0481910221,
-0.4961686432,
-1.4351267815,
0.5520002246,
-0.1838405579,
0.6881065369,
0.4973157048,
0.125729531,
0.6168037057,
-0.3049123585,
0.3147457242,
0.0903349295,
-0.7821595669,
0.7541749477,
-0.2462336719,
0.2264543474,
0.6507759094,
0.4410046637,
-0.1101488546,
-0.5998396873,
-0.6622617841,
-0.8791067004,
0.6133289337,
-0.1080224141,
0.1185668856,
-0.0879247114,
0.7183451653,
0.2103051096,
0.141432941,
-0.6112656593,
-0.6541652679,
-0.0542336218,
-0.1660473496,
0.1198834777,
-0.3932954371,
-0.4767737389,
0.1247878596,
0.5623478293,
-0.1663306653,
0.4745436013,
0.2675025463,
-0.2367229164,
-0.0845320821,
0.1237171963,
0.5642859936,
0.4343518913,
-0.1449576914,
0.0362679586,
0.3716587126,
-0.6469728351,
0.5625545382,
0.0065654605,
-0.503970325,
0.0048965528,
0.6436756849,
1.004847765,
-0.0328250788,
-0.6427915692,
0.4801933467,
-0.122205697,
-0.1814769804,
-0.5213672519,
0.5900229216,
-0.2960158288,
0.3421762884,
0.6718751192,
-0.166853562,
0.2098775208,
-0.8317629099,
0.0892502218,
0.6702920794,
-0.2722270191,
-0.0310774967,
0.5715684891,
-0.3686595559,
-0.678514123,
0.2380934209,
0.0198060982,
-0.6158525944,
1.0010371208,
0.4256839752,
0.8097605109,
-0.4727443457,
0.0532396883,
0.1896021217,
0.5548695326,
0.07425116,
0.1087384224,
-0.2650170922,
-0.4265626669,
0.09669476,
-0.2808692753,
-0.529227972,
0.306938529,
-1.0299304724,
0.3890562057,
-0.7924746871,
-0.1482083499,
-0.11557547,
0.2035927176,
-0.6088665724,
0.0828041434,
-0.013371286,
0.8027606606,
-0.6608839035,
0.7886220217,
0.0939620212,
-0.3879430592,
-0.7522969246,
0.0417942964,
0.111584723,
-1.1980630159,
0.153917104,
0.4380612373,
-0.1381382793,
-0.2939309776,
-0.572462678,
-0.6896972656,
1.3535308838,
0.7425242662,
-0.4590086937,
-0.0051533347,
0.1281102449,
0.3621541262,
-0.3717187345,
0.2777780592,
0.8685702682,
0.2197345644,
-0.0117734233,
-0.2964949012,
0.1545027196,
-0.2234263122,
-0.1945372671,
0.2323867977,
-0.7929261327,
0.8797389865,
-0.3933210075,
-0.2565574646,
0.1991163045,
0.7925185561,
0.4783866405,
0.5731565952,
0.3937831521,
0.3800549209,
1.0355924368,
0.2353844047,
1.2243531942,
0.1190629825,
-0.2436936945,
1.0982131958,
0.0694806203,
0.6002346873,
0.5477525592,
0.0138253132,
0.4062154889,
0.6004090905,
-0.2064510584,
0.4830949306,
0.2984705865,
-0.3515095711,
0.1484811157,
0.0055588842,
-0.2998757958,
0.3305294812,
0.3083783984,
-0.3186409771,
-0.0182408579,
0.2498989105,
0.1565122008,
0.0521249026,
-0.4596763551,
1.0779476166,
0.061829444,
-0.7120186687,
0.9382587075,
0.0097421473,
0.5766020417,
-0.7056481242,
0.1062844917,
-0.3408536315,
-0.0915020928,
0.0420390815,
-0.2510929406,
0.0345680602,
0.0782712772,
-0.1124001369,
0.1797310412,
0.4026494026,
-0.3562019169,
-0.2499544322,
0.451489687,
0.382466495,
0.2634191215,
-0.0383329391,
-0.6275066733,
0.2073066086,
0.0066043623,
-0.343718946,
0.3930220306,
0.4771941006,
-0.211977765,
0.9896783829,
0.6765934825,
0.2264652252,
0.3427697122,
0.1203302965,
0.8438141346,
-0.7911162376,
-0.4796297848,
-1.2100867033,
-0.0787162557,
0.112024419,
-0.0872165263,
0.6332134008,
0.6477177739,
0.4878137708,
0.0791193992,
0.540720284,
0.7274730802,
0.2900037169,
-0.9889914393,
0.3088405728,
-0.2903514504,
0.6840164065,
-0.0216973852,
-0.839297533,
0.0300978832,
0.2046013027,
-0.2279056013,
-0.1361919641,
0.5941250324,
0.977997601,
0.2031431943,
-0.1495773792,
0.1801473349,
-0.0993412435,
0.439645201,
0.7684961557,
0.9353990555,
-0.5339852571,
0.7726993561,
-0.3585905135,
-0.337646544,
-0.2786677182,
-0.60507375,
-1.137526989,
-0.3350343704,
-0.0488463119,
-0.2035889328,
0.2900629938,
0.9724375606,
0.2596904337,
-0.4007048607,
-0.2541154325,
0.0720913038,
0.1744562685,
-0.1639440358,
-0.1475718021,
0.5112179518,
-0.4056064785,
-0.6574356556,
0.6702265739,
0.0099144187,
0.5791010261,
-0.175251022,
-0.1127441972,
0.1260335296,
0.4852021039,
0.1535172909,
0.3754607737,
-0.655992806,
0.0252786689,
-0.004833342,
-0.2497559339,
0.1435834318,
1.0064437389,
-0.7841469646,
0.2388020456,
-0.0733479187,
0.6829388738,
0.5503143072,
0.0119119957,
0.5282708406,
-0.8842814565,
0.4898501635,
0.2241378129,
0.4971287549,
0.2790637016,
-0.7920334935,
0.4535742402,
-0.1526852697,
-0.2072412074,
-0.9882674217,
0.1474550366,
-0.8889598846,
-0.5064095259,
0.9930046797,
-0.0203547385,
-0.7695844769,
-0.0803645551,
-0.4009518027,
0.4086534083,
-0.5515206456,
1.0176551342,
0.3883619905,
-0.0067352657,
-0.1985685825,
-0.5529587865,
0.5466220379,
0.495092392,
-0.9497383237,
-0.0306756012,
0.3897164166,
0.0485793352,
0.0541625023,
0.9263368249,
0.0057153939,
0.5868205428,
0.0237893276,
-0.0435176082,
-0.5642521381,
-0.5073606968,
-0.6042313576,
0.3659337461,
-0.0408530347,
-0.5280125737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03218v7
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03218v7
|
The WMDP Benchmark: Measuring and Reducing Malicious Use With Unlearning
| 2024-03-05T18:59:35 | 2024-05-15T19:16:09 |
Nathaniel Li, Alexander Pan, Anjali Gopal, Summer Yue, Daniel Berrios, Alice Gatti, Justin D. Li, Ann-Kathrin Dombrowski, Shashwat Goel, Long Phan, Gabriel Mukobi, Nathan Helm-Burger, Rassin Lababidi, Lennart Justen, Andrew B. Liu, Michael Chen, Isabelle Barrass, Oliver Zhang, Xiaoyuan Zhu, Rishub Tamirisa, Bhrugu Bharathi, Adam Khoja, Zhenqi Zhao, Ariel Herbert-Voss, Cort B. Breuer, Samuel Marks, Oam Patel, Andy Zou, Mantas Mazeika, Zifan Wang, Palash Oswal, Weiran Lin, Adam A. Hunt, Justin Tienken-Harder, Kevin Y. Shih, Kemper Talley, John Guan, Russell Kaplan, Ian Steneker, David Campbell, Brad Jokubaitis, Alex Levinson, Jean Wang, William Qian, Kallol Krishna Karmakar, Steven Basart, Stephen Fitz, Mindy Levine, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Uday Tupakula, Vijay Varadharajan, Ruoyu Wang, Yan Shoshitaishvili, Jimmy Ba, Kevin M. Esvelt, Alexandr Wang, Dan Hendrycks
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The White House Executive Order on Artificial Intelligence highlights the
risks of large language models (LLMs) empowering malicious actors in developing
biological, cyber, and chemical weapons. To measure these risks of malicious
use, government institutions and major AI labs are developing evaluations for
hazardous capabilities in LLMs. However, current evaluations are private,
preventing further research into mitigating risk. Furthermore, they focus on
only a few, highly specific pathways for malicious use. To fill these gaps, we
publicly release the Weapons of Mass Destruction Proxy (WMDP) benchmark, a
dataset of 3,668 multiple-choice questions that serve as a proxy measurement of
hazardous knowledge in biosecurity, cybersecurity, and chemical security. WMDP
was developed by a consortium of academics and technical consultants, and was
stringently filtered to eliminate sensitive information prior to public
release. WMDP serves two roles: first, as an evaluation for hazardous knowledge
in LLMs, and second, as a benchmark for unlearning methods to remove such
hazardous knowledge. To guide progress on unlearning, we develop RMU, a
state-of-the-art unlearning method based on controlling model representations.
RMU reduces model performance on WMDP while maintaining general capabilities in
areas such as biology and computer science, suggesting that unlearning may be a
concrete path towards reducing malicious use from LLMs. We release our
benchmark and code publicly at https://wmdp.ai
|
[
-0.41418612,
-0.602165699,
0.4153075516,
-0.3251535594,
-0.0544852987,
0.3108660579,
-0.0996664241,
-0.2204603404,
-0.487976402,
0.6737830639,
-0.4324840605,
-0.6736522317,
-0.7322785258,
-0.1834892333,
-0.2223990411,
1.005341053,
0.2154867202,
-0.0582884066,
-0.4150577188,
-0.30147475,
-0.3303153515,
-0.4743155241,
-0.2736968696,
-0.5079737902,
0.633671999,
0.2405658215,
0.89341712,
0.882224381,
0.7998278141,
0.3107506335,
0.0298028365,
0.0284076426,
-0.5776017308,
-0.051532127,
-0.6155064106,
-0.216612339,
-0.2315412462,
0.4037114382,
0.2678951025,
1.0333781242,
-0.2940973341,
0.4158437252,
0.0550927669,
0.6461232305,
-0.9419643283,
0.0016933698,
-0.6803957224,
-0.0197910368,
-0.1940760314,
-0.2282108516,
-0.4935036302,
-0.1286387295,
0.1037528813,
-0.4718665779,
-0.048656702,
-0.1468588263,
0.3364857435,
0.396463275,
-0.6987800002,
0.3686792552,
-0.7537823915,
0.8808225393,
-0.6434679627,
0.4188913703,
0.4187488258,
0.3250417113,
-0.7010703087,
-0.883040607,
-0.2250485271,
-0.31138888,
0.3600209951,
0.1362297386,
-0.4519488513,
0.279207319,
0.5228859782,
0.0469526947,
-0.7156699896,
0.1230393127,
-0.5548621416,
-0.3895892501,
0.7472285032,
0.0982623547,
0.1091668159,
0.0436180122,
-0.6861535907,
-0.3159582317,
-0.864577949,
-0.0911264271,
0.3649687171,
0.0236512404,
0.0796089619,
0.7308826447,
-0.1477987468,
0.264936626,
-0.705629468,
-0.1658338904,
0.2179289013,
0.1901194304,
-0.374247998,
-0.2259968966,
0.868090868,
0.6252257824,
0.1413841397,
-0.2078162432,
-0.1133932173,
0.4237383008,
0.7252083421,
-0.707229495,
-0.2523763478,
0.0178102106,
-0.6346634626,
-0.2534277141,
0.0349844098,
-0.7625286579,
-0.7636364102,
-0.1040467992,
0.4873819053,
-0.2400251329,
-0.0279978793,
-0.1414462626,
-0.5493040085,
-0.3841377497,
-0.0054860581,
-0.4017414749,
0.5919382572,
0.7098816037,
0.6276342869,
-0.3118221164,
-0.4430489838,
-0.4751942456,
0.3352793753,
-0.2707054317,
0.455927819,
-0.5776054263,
-0.6829048991,
0.0703866854,
-0.1824883521,
0.2884373367,
-0.9505233765,
0.4058181942,
-0.3938650787,
0.0284059998,
-0.2438449264,
-0.3908165693,
-0.5007431507,
0.1038284153,
-0.3820869327,
0.9001779556,
0.1716829538,
-0.4922422469,
0.3563685119,
-0.3811506033,
-0.2054270208,
0.164424926,
0.0067973654,
-0.2954504192,
0.0875813439,
-0.1485220492,
0.3559896052,
-0.4879760742,
0.3370772302,
-0.6292201281,
-0.3697100878,
0.2082601488,
-0.6911887527,
0.7255834937,
0.4144651592,
-0.3143143952,
0.29309389,
-0.8798156381,
0.0279435907,
0.0906512737,
-0.4875884354,
-0.361315757,
0.257860899,
-0.3048515618,
0.2562965751,
0.0213530716,
-0.5131047368,
0.0699620247,
-0.1796032935,
0.2717002034,
0.8965104818,
0.1940603852,
0.3126512468,
-0.6595876813,
0.3265985548,
-0.0544551015,
0.3544053137,
0.2155035585,
-0.5674858093,
-0.2857514322,
-0.1800259948,
-0.1366704106,
0.6337406635,
-0.6038587689,
0.1952576488,
0.1347063333,
-0.8503267765,
-0.2343186736,
0.3019441068,
0.6356897354,
0.5406899452,
0.6577195525,
-0.3784973025,
-0.4595784843,
-0.6613606811,
-0.575509429,
-0.3632702231,
-0.3040210903,
0.0277652312,
0.4794747233,
-0.4481442869,
0.3276847303,
-0.4246920049,
-0.26905635,
0.0263546351,
0.4206888676,
-0.163719967,
0.394623965,
0.0677139834,
-0.4925898314,
-0.0203492902,
-0.1693578809,
-0.8808999062,
-0.0885540247,
0.1581416726,
-0.0783829316,
-0.1508531719,
0.6864657998,
-0.5649756789,
0.4491271079,
0.3791331351,
-0.0630204305,
0.4346902966,
-0.4221409261,
0.1604645997,
-0.7619129419,
0.2191295326,
-0.0956303105,
0.0546629094,
-0.5935873389,
0.3549757898,
0.0367446356,
-0.352113694,
-0.7202473879,
0.34852314,
-0.3853628635,
0.0945890248,
-0.1950074583,
0.2868403196,
-0.071875304,
0.3554316461,
-0.3765600324,
0.4317534566,
0.3194457293,
-0.6876279116,
0.3814741075,
-0.0239628758,
-0.1845655739,
0.2531584799,
-0.4856273532,
0.1196173802,
0.1394398361,
-0.096688427,
-0.6281133294,
0.1595463306,
0.0696498528,
-0.1245944276,
0.2447728217,
-0.1522029042,
-0.352234453,
-0.3472504616,
-0.5095297694,
0.3263327181,
0.9182729125,
-0.4260990322,
0.3568553329,
0.7516351342,
0.1903966665,
-0.9700264931,
-0.38258636,
0.0042832051,
-0.2293229103,
-0.2426002771,
0.3949548602,
-0.0566886887,
-0.4466640949,
-0.0133256428,
-0.3246498108,
0.1732756048,
0.2991343737,
0.6380631924,
0.2090566158,
-0.0609368272,
-0.0163600389,
-0.1162610278,
-0.2557215095,
0.7466129065,
-0.0090681147,
0.3560623229,
0.428049922,
-0.4509623945,
-0.3072273433,
0.2390979975,
0.7223842144,
-0.1986674666,
0.6052263975,
0.3458427787,
-0.3802569509,
-0.5029422641,
-0.4469347,
-0.1455656439,
-0.505412817,
0.4360677302,
0.0094703436,
-0.3940523863,
0.3467440009,
-0.693341434,
0.33400774,
0.3172068596,
0.347034663,
0.2307357788,
1.1460200548,
0.5862350464,
-0.3626301289,
0.1813612133,
-0.1384009421,
0.0173059795,
-0.6522557139,
-0.5817424655,
-0.413877815,
-0.2024054527,
-0.68942523,
-0.419416368,
0.2770390213,
-0.0507076345,
-0.5957696438,
0.2376591116,
-0.4915758073,
0.4352352023,
0.6887378097,
0.1382377446,
0.2276128381,
-0.2131397575,
-0.1659846753,
0.0856634751,
-0.2108907402,
-0.6366919875,
1.4685332775,
0.3634274304,
0.8125886321,
0.0900312439,
0.5432527661,
0.523088336,
0.142870307,
-0.5696582794,
0.9236460328,
-0.2339505106,
-0.4117007852,
-0.1080049425,
-0.677960813,
-0.8657902479,
0.31632936,
-0.2909432054,
-0.5103447437,
-0.3120274842,
-0.0310039762,
-0.0479531623,
0.5403410196,
-0.5090414882,
0.8004953265,
0.0934067518,
-0.2838320434,
-0.5354442596,
-0.5848140717,
0.3090566397,
0.0527533628,
0.1186913997,
-0.4921841323,
-0.2603090703,
1.0057412386,
-0.4181540608,
0.6601273417,
-0.3230057955,
0.0787829831,
0.2011526078,
0.2910902798,
0.314215064,
-0.036584232,
-0.015610965,
0.4375139177,
-0.0111153079,
-0.1584498733,
-0.2444570959,
0.6868884563,
-0.8778056502,
-0.8268867731,
-0.7017835975,
-0.6857621074,
-0.2508482635,
0.4831216335,
0.1626134515,
0.278755784,
-0.5683999658,
0.0726660416,
0.6797302961,
-0.3113813102,
0.5315335989,
0.6789383292,
-0.0277357008,
-0.2064693868,
0.8443212509,
0.1612178832,
0.2799314857,
0.3814014494,
0.3951317966,
-0.1747147143,
-0.8204517365,
-0.1695367247,
0.2698872089,
-0.8057460189,
-0.4799188673,
-0.5507891178,
-0.2521822155,
-0.492305845,
-0.0291576087,
-0.2728426456,
-0.0300591644,
-0.1250154227,
-0.2014025301,
0.229623124,
1.055273056,
-0.2322802991,
-0.0629165694,
-0.6981988549,
0.5832951665,
0.3410511613,
0.2044703364,
-0.2862479985,
-0.7247872353,
0.1038686335,
0.1158115044,
-0.7085200548,
-0.821736455,
0.4202784598,
0.0552323423,
0.7270501256,
0.5658131242,
0.4711265564,
0.6261950135,
-0.5775891542,
0.6421630979,
-0.0313390568,
-0.8389140368,
0.4855647981,
-0.2923945487,
0.2287662923,
0.4107628763,
0.751103878,
-0.478731215,
-0.6407266259,
-0.6464945674,
-0.6578177214,
0.4964248836,
-0.2752526999,
0.0930615291,
-0.1782304645,
0.0990176201,
0.0297764074,
0.2505400181,
-0.2537971437,
-0.510181129,
-0.0379870422,
0.0221040733,
-0.173190549,
-0.338444382,
-0.5318570137,
-0.0282492712,
0.7597113252,
0.1605028659,
-0.1305996627,
-0.3029855192,
-0.1136271656,
-0.3009346724,
0.2445334792,
0.4891917408,
0.7182379365,
-0.269531399,
0.4829886556,
0.2330112308,
-0.9599587917,
0.1344521493,
-0.0765571669,
0.0203796346,
-0.3709071875,
0.2677572966,
-0.0650179014,
0.0975659788,
-1.0265221596,
0.5338310003,
0.219152838,
-0.1740630418,
-0.1133056805,
0.2314655185,
-0.1404149681,
0.1718207747,
0.3151585162,
0.36185655,
0.2981961966,
-0.8256376982,
0.4348702133,
0.546451509,
-0.3769870996,
-0.1099782959,
0.7747097611,
0.1077416465,
-0.1352678835,
0.7547842264,
-0.141390115,
-0.1896269023,
0.4657624364,
0.5373434424,
0.5631141067,
-0.526632309,
0.3858922422,
0.2963456511,
0.5852765441,
-0.0622521713,
0.2094994634,
0.2799016833,
-0.44267717,
0.1046026722,
-0.2621102631,
-0.3872633576,
0.4891068935,
-0.8946334124,
0.0351403393,
-1.0011787415,
-0.1512552649,
0.0417499058,
0.0988395736,
-0.4181684554,
0.2040506303,
-0.0453854129,
0.7606249452,
-0.9683550596,
0.5604567528,
0.4107171297,
-0.3477648795,
-0.4752373993,
-0.2738586366,
0.6765010357,
-0.8447256088,
0.3114920259,
0.1738098115,
-0.0287487507,
-0.2786676586,
-0.3312985599,
-0.6773353815,
0.8664882779,
0.5064103603,
-0.3951857388,
0.4019576013,
0.2238659412,
0.4227298796,
0.099814415,
0.1109693199,
0.5882447958,
0.3544178307,
-0.2318873554,
-0.6274708509,
0.3695887625,
-0.2538732588,
-0.1026541069,
0.5354222059,
-0.2788543701,
0.7934189439,
-0.4420349002,
-0.3937669992,
-0.107262753,
0.4971601367,
0.0350925587,
0.5784860253,
0.143383339,
0.8011264801,
0.7190718651,
-0.1050274,
0.7605066299,
0.0937258005,
-0.1299882531,
0.95893538,
-0.4462790787,
1.0692540407,
0.4449169934,
-0.2468310893,
0.3338364065,
0.2800320387,
-0.3409785628,
0.7253416181,
0.5698666573,
-0.4480784833,
0.0714074969,
-0.3788307905,
-0.3824851513,
0.3871878386,
0.1658869237,
-0.3069899082,
-0.1916964054,
0.2275002599,
0.3029939532,
0.2985953391,
-0.3076286614,
1.055611968,
0.0973876417,
-0.5664390922,
0.4467147291,
0.1502265036,
0.2900120318,
-0.7152838111,
-0.2389585227,
0.0235277414,
0.4998451173,
-0.2230992168,
-0.6155833006,
0.2341769636,
-0.0504851602,
-0.083522439,
-0.0638941228,
0.3087563515,
-0.2779072523,
-0.0670166239,
0.7151350379,
0.4204623699,
0.2097961754,
-0.1710392982,
-0.7427381873,
-0.0477543548,
-0.2313537151,
-0.2226883471,
0.6969642639,
0.3199097216,
-0.1076653823,
0.9922032952,
0.8795639873,
0.3575947881,
0.0646801293,
0.4273010492,
0.9429957867,
-0.5216888785,
0.1352127194,
-0.8829540014,
0.3377634585,
-0.0007716319,
-0.4729438722,
0.8824591041,
0.6061769128,
1.1683335304,
0.1306278855,
0.625893712,
0.1628590375,
0.400449574,
-0.3349815011,
0.985886395,
-0.4222575426,
0.4698512554,
-0.2175244391,
-1.0064076185,
-0.2574844062,
0.0547579601,
0.0668687001,
0.1118905991,
0.9026594758,
0.8941221237,
0.1275906265,
-0.274887681,
0.7608810663,
0.0949559808,
0.3173615336,
0.2842294872,
0.7391088605,
-0.4438600242,
0.6614388824,
-0.7860998511,
-0.336245954,
0.0685216263,
-0.8995990157,
-1.1627987623,
-0.4523963928,
-0.3535833657,
-0.2655257583,
0.2058790475,
0.7910850644,
0.3624454737,
-0.687808454,
-0.4203935564,
0.1418112218,
0.086222522,
-0.5525786281,
-0.1362804472,
0.1831691712,
-0.016613245,
-0.2600807548,
0.7733043432,
0.3700996339,
-0.037576098,
-0.2770899832,
0.0354013145,
-0.0596513264,
0.1129782423,
0.5074704289,
0.5177194476,
-0.6725327969,
-0.3717597127,
-0.2724612057,
-0.1049007699,
-0.4032735229,
0.7614831924,
-0.6238663197,
0.4591169953,
0.5474588275,
0.6214581132,
-0.0935140848,
-0.1364405453,
0.522964716,
-0.6675311327,
0.1553222686,
0.3026074171,
0.5026836991,
0.0355714411,
-0.342292726,
0.5627826452,
0.2953825295,
-0.7047049999,
-1.0604225397,
0.1326648891,
-0.7897555232,
-0.4914353788,
0.8676217198,
-0.2051228285,
-0.0902138427,
-0.4900260568,
0.0830358863,
0.392450273,
-0.3683831096,
0.9001946449,
0.0616148151,
0.2530012131,
0.007259557,
-0.6592835784,
0.6243822575,
0.1834759861,
-0.9538056254,
0.4687741697,
0.4316534996,
0.1738076657,
0.0206370596,
0.3009649515,
-0.1958181858,
0.3446122706,
0.1963450313,
0.1479829103,
-0.3798558414,
-0.6794170141,
-0.1117260903,
0.1989684999,
-0.0876025036,
-0.2455296218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03194v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03194v1
|
MAGID: An Automated Pipeline for Generating Synthetic Multi-modal Datasets
| 2024-03-05T18:31:28 | 2024-03-05T18:31:28 |
Hossein Aboutalebi, Hwanjun Song, Yusheng Xie, Arshit Gupta, Justin Sun, Hang Su, Igor Shalyminov, Nikolaos Pappas, Siffi Singh, Saab Mansour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Development of multimodal interactive systems is hindered by the lack of
rich, multimodal (text, images) conversational data, which is needed in large
quantities for LLMs. Previous approaches augment textual dialogues with
retrieved images, posing privacy, diversity, and quality constraints. In this
work, we introduce \textbf{M}ultimodal \textbf{A}ugmented \textbf{G}enerative
\textbf{I}mages \textbf{D}ialogues (MAGID), a framework to augment text-only
dialogues with diverse and high-quality images. Subsequently, a diffusion model
is applied to craft corresponding images, ensuring alignment with the
identified text. Finally, MAGID incorporates an innovative feedback loop
between an image description generation module (textual LLM) and image quality
modules (addressing aesthetics, image-text matching, and safety), that work in
tandem to generate high-quality and multi-modal dialogues. We compare MAGID to
other SOTA baselines on three dialogue datasets, using automated and human
evaluation. Our results show that MAGID is comparable to or better than
baselines, with significant improvements in human evaluation, especially
against retrieval baselines where the image database is small.
|
[
-0.5497326851,
-0.444575727,
0.3599042296,
0.1604928821,
-0.0912181586,
0.2708131671,
-0.2253088802,
-0.2721369267,
0.2995330691,
0.2670100927,
-0.8102046251,
-0.6568233371,
-0.0369193144,
0.2612122893,
-0.3364655674,
0.9281065464,
0.3661737442,
0.326998651,
-0.4735469818,
-0.1457827538,
-0.2244351059,
-0.1435892284,
-0.2957755327,
-0.0571628585,
0.6845835447,
0.4487684369,
1.0008304119,
0.4242869914,
0.4376041889,
0.3278958201,
0.2021959573,
0.9657978415,
-0.3129705191,
0.4682942331,
-0.1223631874,
-0.1080839336,
-0.4963294566,
-0.0007612653,
0.5801496506,
0.3044644594,
0.0534883551,
0.0338887423,
-0.0412350819,
0.476254195,
-0.7143478394,
0.1196707189,
-0.3740119934,
0.1554709524,
-0.1213068217,
-0.386480242,
-0.4736777544,
-0.1932726353,
0.1117473096,
-0.7550284863,
-0.1466589719,
0.2051091939,
0.8898763061,
0.2107604146,
-0.447355181,
-0.6545596123,
-0.78057307,
0.6525024176,
-0.6185257435,
0.1954152137,
0.2645278573,
0.1528324187,
-0.146898821,
-0.7172368765,
-0.8203065991,
-0.1341211498,
-0.3382617533,
0.2636878788,
-0.0580050871,
0.1623970866,
-0.006134422,
0.4311529994,
-0.3070977032,
-0.0703965202,
-0.3675253987,
-0.2511013448,
0.7776498199,
0.574837923,
0.3425641656,
-0.5468483567,
-0.3786845207,
-0.1093144566,
-0.624022305,
-0.0582291372,
0.5672975183,
-0.0006643258,
0.0900120437,
0.6795185804,
-0.1923649907,
0.6343782544,
0.0277225096,
-0.4069463611,
0.4419837892,
-0.902436614,
-0.1941624731,
-0.4891265929,
1.2032878399,
0.8397387266,
-0.1178609282,
-0.0900555253,
-0.2068937719,
-0.1683230102,
0.1846494973,
-0.9126158357,
-0.2354419827,
0.1185958236,
-0.4226908684,
-0.4214632809,
0.1512524933,
-0.9100091457,
-0.50007689,
-0.4759956598,
0.4232362807,
-0.4968612492,
-0.1580446213,
-0.1842149049,
0.1186364368,
-0.0631334186,
0.3268345892,
-0.6755427122,
-0.0587676689,
0.1446806192,
0.7799220085,
-0.3589747548,
-0.0433213785,
-0.4892524183,
0.2391963899,
-0.3992348015,
0.8134106398,
-0.8239584565,
-0.6155477166,
-0.0759129822,
0.005252915,
-0.0350030288,
-0.5065639019,
0.57880795,
-0.2201542854,
0.5014007688,
-0.1184900627,
-0.1049898043,
-0.0972628295,
0.2660760283,
-0.5502020121,
0.8332244158,
-0.1646199971,
-0.7150523663,
0.2992893457,
-0.9823287725,
-0.2777072489,
-0.1160509139,
-0.3498941362,
-0.3114421666,
-0.0948131308,
0.4929949045,
0.283390522,
-0.5103580952,
0.299678266,
-0.1153763831,
-0.2649948597,
0.614438653,
-0.5381509662,
0.2763583958,
0.6923096776,
-0.0169492606,
0.3362603486,
-0.7410043478,
0.3394345045,
-0.3046049178,
-0.266304493,
-0.0378517695,
0.0315928422,
0.1776980609,
0.2550331056,
-0.0741011128,
-0.4461844563,
0.2662108839,
-0.3287625015,
0.3260600567,
0.8163360953,
-0.1299753338,
0.564368844,
-0.4699624479,
0.5660919547,
0.1373298466,
0.3031737506,
-0.8869954944,
-0.2756242454,
-0.9857929349,
-0.9025242329,
0.5733427405,
0.6202940345,
-1.0771964788,
0.3301953375,
-0.4659414887,
-0.3468938172,
-0.5874091387,
0.2386060357,
0.4310562313,
0.0857247412,
-0.0204242952,
-0.5196733475,
-0.5412709713,
-1.190299511,
0.3255283237,
-0.216653347,
-0.3315435946,
0.7320413589,
0.267881304,
-0.4365636408,
1.0941886902,
-0.2214892209,
-0.4382557869,
0.0345839374,
0.3914211988,
-0.011622007,
0.4342343211,
0.3700326383,
-0.6752555966,
-0.4386281669,
-0.0339473784,
-0.8708073497,
-0.2375573665,
-0.3909630477,
-0.3075766563,
0.0647537112,
0.302310437,
-0.7956290841,
0.3448667228,
0.545463562,
-0.0835965723,
0.4564034939,
-0.0435280912,
0.6362792253,
-1.3596082926,
0.0616161264,
-0.2358604521,
-0.1288089156,
-0.4673104882,
-0.1513807178,
-0.2867978215,
-0.2811264396,
-0.444642812,
0.4378824532,
-0.6181672215,
-0.2307742238,
-0.0459106751,
0.0924880803,
0.2818439305,
0.5800697207,
-0.2344881147,
1.132599473,
0.6814860106,
-0.2413073629,
0.661136806,
0.4644910395,
-0.3863761723,
1.0662564039,
-0.5024467111,
0.2577142119,
-0.2469350994,
0.240476042,
-1.1846467257,
-0.5462622046,
0.3033705652,
-0.3857232332,
0.1681344509,
-0.0014858271,
-0.7788858414,
-0.0702709481,
-0.3361125588,
0.351650238,
0.2544160187,
-0.3294883072,
0.8345927596,
0.3046745062,
-0.3977394402,
-0.4594560266,
-0.4130780101,
0.5233954191,
-0.0437872931,
-1.0031170845,
0.1789463013,
-0.3490919173,
-0.1624738723,
-0.0984383151,
0.1927759945,
-0.1220184341,
-0.2471535206,
0.539178133,
0.3382116556,
-0.0910685137,
0.5748407841,
0.2022755146,
0.0017856928,
-0.2309682816,
-0.0050111539,
0.3893577754,
-0.1437072456,
-0.7304475307,
-0.7470397949,
0.6346790791,
0.8365676403,
-0.1670713723,
0.380625993,
0.7659469247,
-0.0181331672,
0.2596426606,
-0.5721146464,
-0.1528917998,
-0.4906279147,
-0.0165904183,
-0.488335073,
-0.6685853004,
0.500658989,
-0.2123389989,
0.0848374367,
0.1791417003,
0.6936278343,
-0.329480499,
1.3096334934,
0.1375341415,
0.3890629411,
0.4668135643,
-0.2950006723,
0.0488784462,
-0.7518969178,
-0.4701974392,
-0.0413771756,
-0.5858519673,
-0.246415481,
-0.5734000802,
0.7931744456,
-0.1221520156,
0.1739037782,
-0.0902339891,
-0.5254337192,
0.6553257108,
0.5213753581,
0.2046407163,
0.5460335016,
0.2692573071,
-0.2901829481,
-0.2329248637,
-0.5229110718,
-0.6564543247,
1.1525915861,
0.0995228663,
1.2259171009,
0.1838378459,
0.3233990073,
0.5145536065,
0.4480342269,
-0.6321921945,
0.5923686624,
0.1314643621,
-0.7192442417,
0.0107439412,
-0.1448273659,
-0.8309478164,
0.3556706607,
-0.6548457742,
-0.5020795465,
0.358253032,
0.0412792601,
-0.5878535509,
0.1012682989,
-0.8993300796,
0.6174083948,
-0.137324214,
-0.4907463491,
-0.0483675115,
-0.7660492659,
0.3029009998,
0.0137899369,
0.1706110686,
-0.1858572066,
0.0281047653,
0.2308753431,
-0.3624770939,
0.9067142606,
0.1636161804,
-0.061604511,
0.4649496377,
0.1355807036,
0.2765904963,
0.2711313963,
-0.040523652,
-0.0284018572,
0.0568106696,
-0.1779372543,
-0.733422935,
0.7419364452,
-0.5580531359,
-0.4812965691,
-0.1725224853,
-0.7589706182,
-0.1134598702,
-0.0026403773,
0.2016292214,
0.8565506339,
-0.1902282685,
0.3793408275,
0.5395158529,
-0.2410719842,
0.4354261756,
0.2599865198,
-0.3055814803,
-0.7210378051,
0.8452496529,
-0.1152695268,
0.3049151897,
-0.0535036065,
-0.1838754267,
-0.2932057679,
-0.1533383876,
-0.9293620586,
-0.0019004069,
-0.7515000701,
-0.5109409094,
-0.8108366132,
-0.2227911055,
-0.1203987002,
0.0231355913,
-0.296664834,
-0.3839735389,
-0.5490552187,
-0.0069355634,
0.3111966252,
0.4541272819,
-0.296582371,
0.1815095246,
-0.8549052477,
0.2245686203,
0.550252974,
0.1365534365,
-0.2114107311,
-0.2448615283,
-0.2381967753,
0.291620791,
-0.6176777482,
-0.6932583451,
0.5647032857,
0.6618831754,
0.4322272837,
0.4526826739,
0.1467680782,
0.7615661621,
-0.4363194406,
0.8613209724,
0.4039913714,
-0.7767246366,
0.566021204,
-0.4174645841,
0.2429765016,
0.3762279153,
0.1516886503,
-0.3913494945,
-0.4538388848,
-0.317719698,
-0.6314336658,
0.5354998112,
0.4428653121,
0.5380902886,
-0.1295576394,
0.0663585439,
0.2319999784,
0.4112241268,
-0.5887310505,
-0.1268895864,
-0.3120917678,
-0.4229248762,
0.3494792581,
-0.2627908885,
-0.6904762387,
-0.2816830873,
0.3142397106,
-0.447167784,
0.493976742,
0.3348094225,
-0.2127086222,
0.0480182283,
0.4783338904,
0.6913277507,
0.7624308467,
0.1406589895,
0.1135553196,
0.0109369457,
-0.1506005973,
0.2557218671,
-0.1691527963,
-0.2167799622,
0.196335122,
-0.0732331276,
0.9785484672,
-0.1548870057,
-0.9647014141,
0.6239215732,
-0.0288625024,
-0.0935450718,
-0.2992871106,
0.0880661756,
-0.0517196022,
0.5362401605,
0.4886745512,
0.3112771511,
0.4442800283,
-0.6287774444,
0.2875450552,
0.5789368749,
-0.3511328399,
-0.3904963732,
0.4703482687,
0.546954453,
-0.2859096825,
0.5233179927,
-0.4001931846,
-0.0355847254,
0.0127510782,
0.2460741401,
0.5897925496,
0.1002539247,
0.4955363274,
0.2560094893,
0.1087671071,
0.2632443011,
0.2953052819,
0.0033897045,
-0.6783406734,
-0.6028738618,
-0.384105742,
-0.398352921,
-0.1239264309,
-0.3896533251,
0.2981932461,
-0.4816763401,
-0.5571530461,
-0.0805395916,
-0.5404230952,
-0.435790211,
0.0708827525,
0.1686732471,
0.3667545319,
-0.5693528056,
0.5669864416,
0.4482028186,
-0.4780697525,
-0.3998527527,
-0.2081917226,
0.0786916837,
-0.5227419734,
0.692489028,
0.1247406006,
-0.2641694546,
-0.0237576049,
-0.778232038,
-0.6288462281,
1.1251846552,
0.420674026,
-0.1404555291,
-0.0928218514,
-0.0740292668,
0.6067425609,
-0.7853056192,
0.5065944195,
0.2560733259,
0.4958097339,
0.5623593926,
-0.9583948255,
-0.1847685724,
-0.6720207334,
0.0687568858,
-0.1129969805,
-0.5509573817,
0.6134051085,
-0.296230346,
-0.62272048,
0.5153525472,
0.5232704878,
-0.0951007083,
0.2421468794,
0.5770372748,
0.4501657188,
0.5207545161,
-0.3254437447,
0.8963443637,
-0.1759493649,
0.1151187047,
0.8985033631,
-0.1585344672,
0.4064619839,
0.3876373768,
0.0886217132,
0.6645743847,
0.5935206413,
-0.1808766723,
0.5793114305,
0.0235314928,
-0.5223135352,
-0.5683524609,
-0.5999238491,
-0.1819785684,
0.5315725803,
0.4608761072,
-0.5200235844,
-0.0171950385,
0.3203260601,
-0.1833818555,
0.065172784,
0.086667344,
0.9406138659,
-0.402410686,
-0.4374569058,
0.6510767937,
-0.2252445668,
0.7405937314,
-0.2332643569,
-0.0615015142,
-0.2849316001,
-0.3078058362,
-0.3333771527,
-0.7018428445,
0.1838238984,
-0.1497284174,
-0.2693163157,
-0.2411047369,
0.5650086999,
-0.7075206637,
-0.5274389386,
-0.3906641006,
0.499807924,
0.2227602005,
0.2961829007,
-0.6109255552,
0.1114205271,
-0.075296931,
-0.0596559234,
0.0683267266,
0.4257720709,
0.0089797955,
0.8647545576,
0.8423274755,
-0.2783085108,
-0.0094056288,
0.0100794667,
1.1761020422,
-0.2574922144,
-0.1631421,
-0.6054716706,
0.8515658975,
-0.3989992738,
-0.1083043963,
0.4542099833,
0.5200788975,
0.4700160921,
-0.1562062055,
0.587893188,
-0.141486153,
0.4072975814,
-0.6880886555,
0.6559882164,
-0.6585493088,
0.241734311,
-0.2371062338,
-0.9753851891,
-0.2989056408,
0.7121562362,
0.153815195,
-0.2040426582,
0.5933659673,
1.2888326645,
-0.1426949054,
-0.0707557648,
0.4266586006,
-0.0574292876,
0.3075424433,
0.1860644072,
1.256079793,
-0.4429294467,
0.8960825801,
0.2051076293,
0.0561383776,
-0.1336084008,
-0.7896310687,
-0.8238090277,
-0.7225190401,
-0.1525194496,
-0.2944135368,
-0.0291434303,
1.0169656277,
0.9920352697,
-0.6131051779,
-0.1271222979,
0.4909344018,
0.0014980296,
0.2665508687,
-0.2366704345,
0.0225114077,
-0.2813534439,
-1.1519972086,
0.4924092889,
0.6520400047,
0.1888263077,
-0.6131244898,
-0.1931664646,
-0.127473861,
0.3768152297,
0.5352293253,
-0.030721182,
-0.8413975239,
-0.347764492,
0.2284003645,
-0.2352849394,
0.2911694944,
0.8480224609,
-0.5710734129,
0.9398596883,
0.4198758006,
0.4490395486,
0.326158613,
0.0740545467,
0.7914509177,
-0.8763048053,
0.366089195,
0.0965634733,
0.124985002,
0.5404106975,
-0.133223027,
0.4807176292,
0.2517507374,
-0.4275610149,
-0.8079260588,
0.5272519588,
-0.8786193728,
0.0633800626,
1.1308053732,
-0.2719790041,
0.1511594355,
-0.0317655057,
-0.7498098016,
-0.2168867439,
-0.4627420008,
0.7255147696,
0.7615574002,
-0.1278697997,
-0.3667646945,
-0.2254011035,
0.4067867994,
0.2132564634,
-0.9161004424,
-0.1945452541,
1.0918023586,
-0.0382275917,
0.5145270824,
0.6376028657,
-0.2946754992,
0.2018379122,
-0.2815693915,
0.1769038141,
-0.2271669805,
-0.4593961537,
0.1839323938,
0.0369528979,
-0.2102338076,
-0.2083520442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03187v1
|
Reliable, Adaptable, and Attributable Language Models with Retrieval
| 2024-03-05T18:22:33 | 2024-03-05T18:22:33 |
Akari Asai, Zexuan Zhong, Danqi Chen, Pang Wei Koh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Wen-tau Yih
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Parametric language models (LMs), which are trained on vast amounts of web
data, exhibit remarkable flexibility and capability. However, they still face
practical challenges such as hallucinations, difficulty in adapting to new data
distributions, and a lack of verifiability. In this position paper, we advocate
for retrieval-augmented LMs to replace parametric LMs as the next generation of
LMs. By incorporating large-scale datastores during inference,
retrieval-augmented LMs can be more reliable, adaptable, and attributable.
Despite their potential, retrieval-augmented LMs have yet to be widely adopted
due to several obstacles: specifically, current retrieval-augmented LMs
struggle to leverage helpful text beyond knowledge-intensive tasks such as
question answering, have limited interaction between retrieval and LM
components, and lack the infrastructure for scaling. To address these, we
propose a roadmap for developing general-purpose retrieval-augmented LMs. This
involves a reconsideration of datastores and retrievers, the exploration of
pipelines with improved retriever-LM interaction, and significant investment in
infrastructure for efficient training and inference.
|
[
-0.3244610131,
-0.4834174216,
0.7461134195,
0.0772612616,
0.0326041095,
0.210529536,
-0.2786589861,
-0.504976809,
0.3688813448,
0.8472626209,
-0.0657742098,
-0.2600655258,
-0.4260103106,
0.1024502292,
-0.7181131244,
0.5928755403,
-0.102340728,
-0.1601136476,
-0.3074789941,
-0.3269393444,
-0.3253389895,
-0.7202777267,
-0.5218333006,
-0.0365980454,
0.6691358685,
0.1131330058,
1.0812038183,
0.5996620655,
0.3375137746,
0.2894666195,
-0.039931532,
0.175429672,
-0.1933205128,
0.3085894287,
-0.3986596763,
-0.4287593961,
-0.4495966434,
-0.2280516326,
0.9531128407,
0.9908450842,
-0.4033368528,
0.0043354863,
0.1804438531,
0.684292376,
-0.9192018509,
0.0002819805,
-0.7948250771,
-0.2955395877,
-0.1142705828,
-0.1115969568,
-0.3920930028,
-0.4226635396,
0.2582575381,
-0.4848380089,
0.0288199652,
0.1768656969,
0.494746387,
-0.009346107,
-0.4029935598,
-0.4320650995,
-0.7457031012,
0.8475979567,
-0.7157102227,
0.9048840404,
0.6927949786,
0.4415469766,
-0.21873568,
-0.8737547398,
-0.1672119051,
-0.3633516431,
0.0211514663,
-0.4802907705,
0.1519796699,
-0.0475438051,
-0.156415835,
0.2131227702,
-0.3806399405,
-0.0374798812,
-0.0846197233,
-0.0398362279,
0.341293633,
0.3660664558,
0.3361453712,
-0.0321680307,
-0.0252512395,
0.435947001,
-0.7949060798,
-0.3507813215,
0.1244436055,
0.6727213264,
0.3988682926,
0.3192959726,
-0.4659553766,
0.917180717,
-0.2415433377,
0.0831616595,
0.244257465,
-0.3982025683,
0.0447426997,
-0.1191025376,
0.6515301466,
0.0462132543,
0.1293336898,
-0.5757322907,
-0.4854214489,
-0.455945313,
0.4315499365,
-0.629470706,
-0.1716864556,
0.3645965457,
-0.3480032682,
-0.0792992115,
-0.2327854037,
-0.8191649914,
-0.5554483533,
-0.3357464969,
0.5648839474,
-0.4068211317,
-0.3039085567,
0.1761916131,
0.0983344093,
0.024693504,
0.3532938361,
-1.1053937674,
0.4286319613,
0.5955846906,
1.0150860548,
-0.1873734146,
-0.3024848998,
-0.4668335021,
0.4170231521,
-0.413749963,
0.8797076941,
-0.8117561936,
-0.3971770704,
0.3585042357,
0.0772140771,
0.1817870736,
-0.844258666,
0.4914568663,
-0.593223989,
0.1374488473,
-0.5417037606,
-0.4940690994,
0.1414223611,
0.3908413351,
-0.8247520328,
0.7828853726,
0.2161152363,
-0.5527006984,
0.0844266042,
-0.2801677287,
-0.1665202379,
0.2051914781,
0.0572449528,
-0.1251444072,
0.0479662493,
0.2666646242,
0.1677101851,
-0.6291261315,
0.366241008,
-0.5383294821,
-0.645845592,
0.1345359683,
-0.3782912493,
0.5279167295,
0.2522892058,
0.1549021006,
-0.165405333,
-0.9622467756,
0.0923159719,
-0.0732485056,
-0.5934075713,
-0.5056370497,
0.5521815419,
0.050838951,
-0.1654726863,
0.5010063648,
-0.3198036551,
0.0601476058,
-0.1922504902,
0.4886226356,
0.5555938482,
-0.1599095613,
0.7688114643,
-0.1459521502,
0.5235516429,
-0.2021136433,
0.1575416923,
-0.0261042789,
-0.0569705293,
-0.5843315721,
-0.1336361915,
0.0917445347,
0.4524196982,
-0.9863768816,
0.1134163812,
-0.3101517856,
-0.4867143035,
-0.3841638267,
0.3054857254,
0.1303808838,
0.6263628602,
0.5305618644,
0.0553068742,
-0.7431335449,
-0.7055444717,
-0.4872534871,
-0.2723857462,
-0.1288996935,
0.2861658931,
0.113665022,
-0.3293441534,
0.886369288,
-0.1026455462,
-0.0325792544,
-0.1569861621,
-0.1790144444,
0.1864478439,
0.3384729326,
0.2968593538,
-0.8580527902,
-0.444114238,
-0.0395694822,
-0.9263605475,
-0.1243528128,
0.3738071322,
0.083406724,
0.0509695113,
0.5220615268,
-0.5931842327,
-0.0889509022,
0.3078838885,
0.0143322237,
0.6885885,
-0.1452605128,
0.1797173768,
-0.879109621,
0.1203300655,
-0.1457582116,
-0.2245065123,
-0.7702162862,
0.1705894172,
0.2577170432,
-0.2700259387,
-0.414159447,
0.7555235624,
-0.6001309752,
-0.1964923739,
-0.2639823258,
0.2235780507,
-0.0152694434,
0.0298189297,
0.0472111702,
0.9765852094,
0.5687122941,
-0.7946673036,
0.5536034703,
0.2171190083,
-0.4092108011,
0.7310221195,
-0.6239980459,
0.1793993264,
-0.1431426704,
0.3553557396,
-0.542316556,
-0.1756936759,
0.1120486557,
-0.2713604271,
0.1041782498,
-0.0434372053,
-0.5458239913,
-0.3038916588,
-0.3858419359,
0.2691035569,
0.3031169474,
-0.6954325438,
0.8218507171,
0.400277108,
-0.2645663321,
-0.5757843256,
-0.5610259771,
0.4762624502,
-0.2946749032,
-0.2379328609,
0.1708660722,
0.1468951106,
-0.1519571245,
0.0013214221,
0.1339102834,
-0.2399198115,
-0.0612706468,
-0.2208511829,
0.2205891907,
-0.1849773228,
0.3286541104,
-0.2058059126,
0.0603791662,
0.0573023558,
-0.3544906378,
0.43299523,
-0.1326518804,
-0.384512037,
-0.1489729285,
0.3581832945,
0.48556602,
-0.2903926671,
0.8582491279,
0.2888151109,
-0.624668479,
0.0810494199,
-0.8537964821,
-0.0829093754,
-0.5078386068,
0.5153762102,
-0.4763692021,
-0.8556697965,
0.6778402925,
-0.1042743474,
-0.0988362581,
-0.0063610668,
0.4048497975,
-0.045303084,
1.1300216913,
0.3012421131,
-0.1582107693,
0.5663141608,
0.1720953137,
0.0999236777,
-1.0573642254,
-0.2599883378,
-0.6867982745,
-0.1260985583,
-0.5788623095,
-0.1971177608,
0.1598965079,
0.1927954108,
-0.3382584751,
0.4456432462,
-0.2286673486,
0.2977278531,
0.3857387304,
0.2746755183,
0.3702935874,
-0.0313499644,
0.3139878809,
-0.0126707209,
-0.505109787,
-0.6471018195,
1.241443634,
0.2473086268,
0.8711618781,
0.2183689326,
0.6127690673,
0.1723124981,
0.1946995258,
-0.3971752524,
0.6256236434,
-0.164411068,
-0.7463260889,
-0.2240314335,
-0.3742956817,
-0.7964035273,
0.1951991022,
0.1015651226,
-1.05440557,
0.3709084988,
0.3145242035,
-0.1366613209,
0.2846311033,
-0.63707757,
0.6630085111,
-0.0926144868,
-0.5675949454,
-0.0148006417,
-0.4479806721,
0.1432356983,
-0.2204190493,
0.3171872497,
0.1582272798,
-0.3407765627,
0.4300560951,
-0.6192832589,
0.5136606693,
-0.405782789,
-0.1888800412,
0.5086578131,
0.095083788,
0.7199552059,
0.0204508267,
-0.3979510665,
-0.3850820363,
0.2160196602,
-0.6607120633,
-0.9402402639,
0.8608598113,
-0.4406190217,
-0.8868977427,
-0.1624217331,
-0.6925534606,
-0.7651937604,
0.0284028798,
-0.2066036761,
0.431761235,
-0.1319382638,
0.4349279404,
0.6541287303,
-0.107030578,
0.2553529739,
0.5397005081,
-0.4702851772,
-0.4592150152,
1.3299248219,
0.1189000905,
0.3562225401,
0.3406111896,
0.0442476831,
-0.5638017058,
-0.716710031,
-0.2754070461,
0.0557365119,
-0.6002447605,
-0.0287602656,
-0.5832197666,
-0.0939682946,
-0.3216467798,
-0.0360198021,
-0.4872219265,
-0.2511040866,
-0.5503968596,
0.1106079742,
0.3974473774,
0.3819513023,
-0.08291848,
0.1668559015,
-0.8759108186,
0.2381047308,
0.237972334,
0.446695447,
0.1274835765,
-0.6693528891,
-0.3805504143,
0.2326759696,
0.0009416657,
-0.6339371204,
0.2999213636,
0.324047178,
0.3729998469,
0.0540151037,
-0.1700185835,
0.5739805698,
-0.7302410603,
0.6966522336,
-0.0796955526,
-0.7525634766,
0.5066376328,
-0.3884070516,
0.0547498949,
0.6325538158,
0.442309767,
-0.5870054364,
-0.1876485348,
-0.1343433261,
-0.7757025957,
0.3975307643,
-0.2776985168,
0.4596002102,
-0.1437863708,
0.6219054461,
0.07025069,
0.4294862747,
-0.4519262314,
0.1747396737,
-0.1368776113,
-0.2258980125,
-0.0781567246,
-0.2517753541,
0.3717700839,
-0.1770674735,
0.5967332721,
-0.0829722881,
0.1342859119,
-0.1654480398,
-0.2298010737,
0.1193812415,
0.2506447732,
-0.0089371931,
0.9252747297,
-0.4252189398,
0.2749804556,
0.1795369834,
-0.3685800731,
0.3984861374,
0.1962498277,
-0.1972129792,
0.0234799534,
0.156325534,
0.838963747,
0.2775443196,
-0.8164144158,
0.0979247615,
0.2771511972,
0.1323922724,
-0.2141031921,
-0.0356870964,
0.359130621,
0.3538968861,
0.5356653333,
-0.4316887259,
0.3420238793,
-0.7499409318,
0.2915432751,
0.5917399526,
-0.4635847211,
-0.2616205812,
0.7738054991,
0.1384844333,
-0.6002995372,
0.5979378819,
-0.082606107,
-0.3731824756,
0.0149022546,
0.554939568,
0.6333712935,
-0.5001010299,
0.1335769147,
0.0810061246,
0.1681914628,
-0.4294357002,
0.3147954345,
0.144470185,
-0.5469410419,
-0.3105380833,
-0.6029177904,
-0.4668377638,
0.0971080288,
-0.6257199645,
0.3341151476,
-0.3776270747,
-0.0702796951,
-0.4684127867,
-0.125606969,
-0.3699860871,
0.3287163973,
-0.0618769601,
1.0326917171,
-0.4964594543,
0.9316789508,
0.6338577867,
-0.6613880396,
-0.4722324312,
-0.2015005797,
-0.3056224883,
-0.7743505239,
0.4142540991,
-0.3133440018,
0.0567764379,
0.1752044708,
-0.4595894217,
-0.8411793709,
1.1037094593,
0.5957388878,
-0.5501043797,
-0.5578048229,
0.3141831458,
0.5906876326,
-0.206776917,
0.2639241219,
0.5695685148,
0.1928697377,
-0.0757312179,
-0.7647625804,
0.0711897314,
0.053101059,
0.4954799116,
0.3284602165,
-0.4896056652,
0.7459539175,
0.0230944026,
0.0930661857,
0.3643473089,
0.8195548058,
0.3500175476,
0.075565353,
0.2923293412,
0.5717758536,
0.5815076828,
0.0995016173,
0.9729096889,
-0.2336105555,
0.3266817331,
1.2576887608,
-0.4806900918,
1.2538095713,
0.6551520824,
-0.5268983245,
0.5101764202,
0.5490707755,
0.2524605393,
0.6419250965,
0.0176186524,
-0.5858897567,
-0.1730886251,
-0.3524039388,
-0.3469592333,
0.0504356623,
0.6085162163,
-0.3885390162,
-0.2384943962,
0.0772727951,
-0.2040626258,
0.1875852793,
-0.2613219023,
0.3803184628,
0.0697138458,
-0.3562322855,
0.8265733123,
-0.1507251859,
0.4841557443,
-0.5413330197,
0.0693336502,
-0.3281041682,
0.0478501916,
-0.1170822158,
-0.6549071074,
0.3001718223,
-0.1061885282,
-0.0978657901,
-0.1163300052,
0.9212931395,
-0.5313453078,
-0.4037595689,
0.4218909144,
0.5894266367,
0.068188481,
-0.409044683,
-0.5286567807,
0.3207059205,
-0.1855249256,
-0.4258605242,
0.6551564932,
0.4583453238,
0.0073480937,
0.9853780866,
0.4448660612,
0.2031739801,
0.1484667063,
0.1739853621,
0.7887988091,
-0.5634377599,
-0.0704222694,
-0.6580654383,
0.2897642851,
0.1871886104,
0.1537596136,
0.5337737203,
0.4501929879,
0.4111198783,
0.1390678436,
0.7969893813,
-0.0154413795,
0.8345079422,
-0.3555484414,
0.5428475142,
-0.7027836442,
0.3584991992,
-0.2878959477,
-1.289355278,
-0.1928359717,
0.3546270132,
-0.2289744318,
0.2560570836,
0.5557325482,
0.8183140755,
-0.106454581,
0.0041717845,
0.2291774154,
0.0886233971,
0.4299812615,
0.5339853168,
0.6771723032,
-0.5841031671,
0.6367723346,
-0.0491272472,
-0.0884761959,
-0.1732825935,
-0.6890046597,
-0.4945085347,
-0.7346731424,
-0.2045740187,
-0.3531576395,
0.493688792,
0.680706799,
0.2763882875,
-0.9482093453,
-0.3157145977,
-0.4282274246,
-0.019770585,
0.179039821,
-0.209408626,
0.2547127903,
-0.5695174932,
-0.9444105029,
0.3370565772,
0.2520543039,
-0.1717061102,
-0.516381681,
-0.2403890342,
-0.5132675171,
-0.0665586069,
0.5660096407,
0.5456663966,
-0.7930908203,
-0.5978959799,
0.0979153737,
-0.1390986592,
-0.0904330313,
0.5414733887,
-0.9689882994,
0.4556248486,
0.303078562,
1.0863302946,
0.064920634,
-0.0741778612,
0.7533156872,
-0.3478212953,
0.0661514103,
0.2509126663,
0.4272104502,
0.5431901813,
0.0457093045,
0.3084416389,
0.1809845865,
-0.6336035132,
-1.1233599186,
0.1297665238,
-0.3027467132,
-0.149602592,
1.1289857626,
-0.1322868615,
-0.0951110944,
-0.1723256707,
-0.0522956923,
0.0054185363,
-0.1385925412,
0.5622322559,
0.8716484308,
0.136654377,
-0.4550306499,
-0.6207662225,
0.401709199,
0.5243020654,
-0.840143919,
0.2824210823,
0.4825618565,
0.1882018,
0.1637551337,
0.5802947879,
-0.2244718075,
-0.0268449299,
-0.1238191202,
-0.1184742004,
0.3462185264,
-0.2846706808,
-0.1400862336,
-0.0052107554,
0.5720673203,
-0.1832820624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03170v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03170v1
|
SNIFFER: Multimodal Large Language Model for Explainable Out-of-Context Misinformation Detection
| 2024-03-05T18:04:59 | 2024-03-05T18:04:59 |
Peng Qi, Zehong Yan, Wynne Hsu, Mong Li Lee
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
Misinformation is a prevalent societal issue due to its potential high risks.
Out-of-context (OOC) misinformation, where authentic images are repurposed with
false text, is one of the easiest and most effective ways to mislead audiences.
Current methods focus on assessing image-text consistency but lack convincing
explanations for their judgments, which is essential for debunking
misinformation. While Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have rich
knowledge and innate capability for visual reasoning and explanation
generation, they still lack sophistication in understanding and discovering the
subtle crossmodal differences. In this paper, we introduce SNIFFER, a novel
multimodal large language model specifically engineered for OOC misinformation
detection and explanation. SNIFFER employs two-stage instruction tuning on
InstructBLIP. The first stage refines the model's concept alignment of generic
objects with news-domain entities and the second stage leverages language-only
GPT-4 generated OOC-specific instruction data to fine-tune the model's
discriminatory powers. Enhanced by external tools and retrieval, SNIFFER not
only detects inconsistencies between text and image but also utilizes external
knowledge for contextual verification. Our experiments show that SNIFFER
surpasses the original MLLM by over 40% and outperforms state-of-the-art
methods in detection accuracy. SNIFFER also provides accurate and persuasive
explanations as validated by quantitative and human evaluations.
|
[
-0.4068261087,
-0.8583067656,
0.5909785628,
0.0420362391,
-0.1828583181,
-0.0958570912,
-0.1536270827,
-0.6088300347,
-0.2448888123,
0.2831017673,
-0.3739108741,
-0.2221490592,
-0.783028245,
-0.1800878197,
-0.3486241102,
0.7810769081,
-0.0689483508,
-0.0778273195,
-0.2481321394,
-0.0745551512,
-0.4699857831,
-0.0341573842,
-0.5363076925,
-0.2506154478,
0.3394557238,
0.6792222261,
0.6918807626,
0.257047832,
0.1298799366,
0.3095256388,
0.0674837828,
0.2582594156,
-0.5843012333,
-0.0670324713,
-0.2803950012,
-0.3760402799,
0.176878646,
-0.1093197837,
0.4857470095,
0.1237288639,
-0.0987469777,
0.0398184359,
-0.1197862104,
0.3262552321,
-0.8484632969,
0.0727667734,
-0.8250303268,
-0.332434237,
-0.1215062067,
-0.4804766774,
-0.6593395472,
-0.0376068354,
0.0599173605,
-0.4707571566,
0.2922371626,
0.0394320264,
0.9440637231,
0.1915894896,
-0.7478100061,
-0.3918034434,
-0.4873158038,
0.7367917299,
-0.6305428743,
0.6361936927,
0.2922405303,
0.51431638,
-0.1575113833,
-0.6037486792,
-0.9612435699,
-0.1357986927,
-0.1980053782,
0.1009157524,
-0.2253792882,
-0.3658102155,
0.0490880758,
0.1716080457,
-0.6268184781,
0.0869057178,
-0.2791395485,
-0.3023306429,
0.2701554596,
-0.2395212948,
0.5950907469,
-0.1514492035,
-0.7580724955,
-0.107859917,
-0.3882456422,
0.0555785559,
0.2257561982,
-0.266192019,
-0.1739260703,
0.4297013879,
0.0135329664,
0.5213971138,
0.2489123195,
-0.4410856366,
0.2321656793,
-0.2457012981,
-0.2189752162,
0.3368779421,
0.6383160353,
0.545851171,
0.0138654513,
-0.00064809,
-0.1108598933,
0.1619924307,
0.138000071,
-0.9791762829,
-0.1813642234,
0.1253459603,
-0.721380949,
-0.2487484366,
0.0639645457,
-1.0605204105,
-0.6948521733,
-0.1400016844,
0.4880250394,
-0.6133300662,
-0.2965995669,
0.1523495615,
-0.415892005,
-0.0175699573,
0.4889917076,
-0.5604589581,
-0.228551656,
0.3425194621,
0.6748709679,
-0.0105388453,
-0.3948591948,
-0.6596410275,
0.2760113776,
-0.0805657133,
0.8681557775,
-0.8831145167,
-0.0212640911,
-0.1081913263,
0.0891181454,
-0.187626943,
-0.4843369126,
0.4043952525,
-0.5947760344,
0.4212016463,
-0.0027353629,
-0.43641904,
-0.4815909863,
0.5435822606,
-0.5953817964,
1.1529076099,
0.1110941544,
-1.0138556957,
0.5685918331,
-0.7558683753,
-0.1052102968,
-0.007608573,
-0.1275812238,
-0.3837315738,
0.1263296753,
0.52409482,
0.2441693842,
-0.0744108856,
0.3061889112,
-0.2038528174,
-0.3979622424,
0.3899752498,
-0.8504747748,
0.7006525993,
0.2089928985,
-0.576551795,
0.2353613824,
-0.7209329009,
-0.1206251904,
0.1272387207,
-0.3546797931,
-0.5211895108,
-0.0811287984,
0.1564953029,
0.5384207964,
0.1246339455,
-0.6786659956,
-0.1129498407,
0.0955338553,
0.4432154,
0.4103790224,
0.0277071204,
0.354337424,
-0.1608391702,
0.4415603876,
0.4830373228,
0.3478953242,
-0.8081578612,
-0.5511812568,
-0.4632227123,
-0.3843735754,
-0.0968781412,
0.533370018,
-0.9284653664,
0.1509774327,
-0.2506073117,
-0.4323591888,
-0.4297323227,
0.0912025198,
0.3693366349,
0.6250380278,
0.5141679049,
0.0772497803,
-0.3172107339,
-0.7984371185,
-0.5879129171,
0.061552573,
0.1344345361,
0.0557499602,
0.6200697422,
-0.6392011046,
0.8031103611,
-0.1837672442,
-0.1979254633,
-0.294482559,
0.3468941748,
-0.2712766826,
0.3369117975,
0.4476146698,
-1.1289771795,
-0.3969171345,
0.2203167379,
-0.6032068729,
0.0682398453,
-0.3484658599,
-0.0869386941,
0.3362479508,
0.678748548,
-0.5452038646,
0.654782176,
0.6725706458,
-0.5079625845,
0.5369938612,
-0.3805676699,
0.3298585713,
-0.8399253488,
-0.0627015159,
0.1562785655,
-0.323107779,
-0.5947567225,
0.1905920506,
0.4112927914,
-0.0025970608,
-0.5657901764,
0.6182385087,
-0.620993197,
0.3536591828,
-0.3208791614,
0.2182681412,
0.3422016799,
0.2905561626,
0.0001802409,
0.4330910742,
0.5642002225,
-0.4066092074,
0.2974793017,
0.1389001608,
-0.5563175678,
0.7620091438,
-0.3677282035,
-0.024194194,
-0.4842232466,
0.5124701262,
-1.210927844,
-0.4100804627,
0.4182597995,
-0.3392185569,
0.2938377857,
-0.3153511882,
-0.5279389024,
-0.2554429173,
-0.1815105081,
0.5878975391,
0.1187794209,
-1.0210032463,
0.8336213231,
0.2150977254,
0.2323260158,
-0.6239093542,
-0.6250040531,
0.1216186509,
-0.3135071695,
-0.724766314,
0.0542463399,
-0.0470444523,
-0.1840177178,
-0.0312014502,
-0.3273371458,
-0.2622472048,
-0.2326336056,
0.2306432277,
0.246774286,
-0.2060142606,
0.4302667081,
-0.0525242984,
-0.0164523199,
-0.0527322926,
-0.1898191124,
0.4556933045,
-0.1164191961,
-0.5548009276,
-0.4464875758,
0.288530916,
0.7863685489,
-0.3051012754,
0.8467540145,
1.0115035772,
-0.2925878167,
-0.1005355343,
-0.7767487168,
-0.1019777209,
-0.4622383714,
0.5166256428,
-0.308278054,
-0.564699173,
0.1910674572,
-0.1066974252,
-0.1466310024,
0.1926198453,
0.2164771706,
0.1223375499,
0.9969225526,
0.5329841971,
0.1344895065,
0.447473824,
0.0405674092,
0.476808548,
-0.3790541887,
-0.4980416894,
-0.2750015557,
-0.3501301408,
-0.2451668382,
-0.6481992602,
0.3771204352,
0.0681864396,
-0.0087948432,
-0.1027522758,
-0.3193284571,
0.8740513921,
0.4268629253,
0.2313582301,
0.4376264513,
0.0166713893,
0.0866011828,
0.1106857508,
-0.5588491559,
-0.4187960923,
0.6728191972,
0.4999113977,
0.9049956203,
0.1232863888,
0.322658807,
0.0816815868,
0.3033376336,
-0.8010479808,
0.2421859354,
-0.0092023537,
-0.8329592347,
-0.2790239453,
-0.3789257705,
-0.6740390062,
0.5756222606,
-0.2542960644,
-0.7420383096,
0.3106045127,
0.3741769493,
0.1204213649,
0.4918242991,
-0.8835392594,
1.1679960489,
-0.3769901991,
-0.1488375813,
-0.2741678357,
-0.6661134362,
0.6453738213,
-0.0939593986,
0.5035482645,
0.0595496781,
0.0098114721,
0.2770223916,
-0.1541892737,
0.9762323499,
-0.3946079612,
-0.3773035109,
0.1105491742,
0.1270626932,
0.5713940859,
0.0631110147,
0.2424261719,
0.2085132897,
0.0680143237,
-0.296684444,
-0.6469935179,
0.6797540784,
-0.3445341587,
-0.2712329328,
-0.1278258562,
-0.7282559276,
-0.0397815071,
0.3468511701,
0.6166114211,
0.6209488511,
-0.0957285985,
0.2783678174,
0.7994803786,
-0.6018152237,
0.1516799629,
0.4732102454,
-0.3239784241,
0.0484779142,
1.0140969753,
-0.3655487895,
0.2548129261,
0.6634376049,
0.3923612237,
-0.4574757218,
-0.2413913161,
-0.5245558619,
0.1342260242,
-0.9993308783,
0.0375176184,
-0.5614151359,
0.1121609136,
-0.174774915,
-0.0026905334,
-0.2092738152,
0.0502374507,
0.124828212,
0.175470978,
0.1402200311,
0.6165016294,
0.1232028529,
0.4372428358,
-0.7599849105,
0.696749568,
0.2521750927,
0.3748086095,
-0.0107261064,
-0.5427885652,
-0.2141555548,
0.319876641,
-0.3454523683,
-1.0381858349,
0.2455296814,
0.2120217383,
0.5705112815,
0.9275127649,
-0.094311744,
0.7071844935,
-0.2017208785,
0.6550953388,
0.3475821614,
-0.9904198647,
0.421507597,
-0.1996133178,
0.4364708662,
0.2932103276,
0.4717759788,
-0.7208279371,
-0.4333192408,
-0.3843488693,
-0.7750368714,
0.7501000166,
-0.1732140183,
-0.0733809397,
-0.0627868325,
-0.2112329453,
0.385843128,
-0.0875382647,
-0.8624224663,
0.0135496808,
-0.4984950721,
-0.2463452667,
-0.1855158657,
-0.4029936492,
-0.1768262088,
-0.0283427872,
0.7076100707,
-0.2529624701,
0.0684125572,
0.080283694,
-0.6551286578,
-0.1186487004,
0.5245585442,
0.7403757572,
0.8991640806,
0.0213480853,
0.4923606217,
-0.0600750186,
-0.5559997559,
0.045076631,
0.014131912,
-0.0293037761,
0.2009138465,
0.3764128685,
0.7868490219,
0.3308456242,
-0.9983626008,
0.8141803145,
-0.1709720641,
-0.0865302905,
-0.1850104332,
-0.1746076047,
0.0821515471,
0.3024135828,
0.2092464417,
0.4341791868,
0.1587466449,
-0.6707396507,
-0.0688464418,
0.4349035323,
-0.2831865847,
-0.1534839571,
0.6306495667,
-0.0660789981,
0.224618718,
0.383275032,
-0.095896408,
-0.4861941636,
0.4213081002,
0.5967534781,
0.4407455325,
-0.2124841958,
0.3580247164,
0.0721662343,
0.433442533,
-0.2085419446,
0.0602143258,
-0.1314496547,
-0.8441446424,
-0.2423900068,
-0.2664360702,
0.0450435281,
0.5074606538,
-0.5553342104,
0.1006187424,
0.0145637058,
0.1571890712,
0.1305304468,
-0.703835547,
-0.6930860877,
0.2146966457,
0.2126455307,
1.044537425,
-0.8489100933,
0.7028179169,
0.656193912,
-0.2674454451,
-0.5654091835,
0.4387562275,
0.2961519659,
-0.8373426795,
0.7052425742,
0.5402144194,
-0.3320538104,
-0.3817213476,
-0.5148363709,
-0.6198475361,
0.7722694278,
0.5186011195,
-0.6161314845,
0.0722875595,
-0.0421032682,
0.2469989657,
-0.2211323977,
0.5040512681,
0.4612091482,
0.8179990053,
0.1772709638,
-0.8536554575,
0.0906320289,
-0.2704687417,
-0.0259014498,
0.1945545971,
-0.2622754574,
0.6971803308,
-0.3635576069,
-0.2103379816,
-0.1600608975,
0.2510747313,
0.1043938622,
0.69468081,
0.7860571742,
0.4825587571,
0.6960276961,
0.0846031457,
0.9651337862,
-0.1576824486,
0.0318809524,
1.3480437994,
-0.0635856763,
0.7257000208,
0.5498874187,
0.4131361246,
0.7904073,
0.3256203234,
0.1535214037,
0.3655147851,
-0.1063896269,
-0.2707773149,
-0.3614817262,
0.0923601389,
-0.3525609374,
0.8056673408,
0.4562451243,
-0.5198671222,
-0.3561136127,
0.3067461252,
-0.0833730176,
0.0591862164,
-0.2982535958,
0.5397273898,
-0.3760873675,
-0.6797450781,
0.7081565261,
0.0631327629,
0.7220929861,
-0.4662360847,
-0.0561987236,
0.0384611487,
0.5650565028,
-0.2996409535,
-0.7868512273,
0.1310522556,
-0.1254173219,
-0.2040025592,
-0.1637710184,
0.9309654236,
-0.7429119349,
-0.2817192972,
0.3557154834,
0.2964208722,
0.1930219084,
-0.4057851434,
-0.5222937465,
0.1641575098,
-0.0438216962,
-0.1307201535,
0.1186033338,
0.8588912487,
-0.2776910961,
0.7368731499,
0.535181582,
-0.2576799095,
0.2551145852,
0.1451825798,
0.7837581038,
-0.3401564062,
-0.6127325296,
-0.821383059,
0.6132707,
-0.1819523424,
-0.2279003114,
0.8573220968,
0.5636073351,
0.8889744282,
-0.317579627,
0.8714734316,
0.1057120264,
0.3966801465,
-0.5199517608,
0.670897007,
-0.7560428381,
0.0312735625,
-0.1096843779,
-0.6868530512,
-0.0461091213,
0.4296358526,
-0.1923928559,
-0.0619887263,
0.8013422489,
0.9523344636,
-0.6249575615,
0.1437334418,
0.304430604,
0.41784814,
0.3014840484,
0.3576029837,
1.1315797567,
-0.264637053,
0.8332579732,
-0.0273142979,
-0.3600405455,
-0.4450711906,
-0.95010674,
-1.0014139414,
-0.5038468242,
-0.2521125078,
-0.156815663,
-0.1523949057,
0.5005589724,
0.9078171253,
-0.6946733594,
0.1834629625,
0.1049651206,
0.0345936231,
-0.3388077319,
-0.3387816548,
0.0401409902,
-0.2192855775,
-0.5341867805,
0.5734575391,
0.3147345185,
-0.1270697564,
-0.2141980827,
-0.1828085184,
-0.23809807,
0.2152001262,
0.6455551982,
0.1787929535,
-0.9042418599,
-0.1971582174,
-0.3359115422,
0.063431561,
0.1157282144,
0.825963974,
-0.6488969326,
0.8027014732,
0.4531575143,
0.3554196358,
0.4193726182,
0.057447236,
0.14171727,
-0.8623433113,
0.2588409781,
-0.1998478621,
0.4914178252,
0.3657812774,
-0.5067007542,
0.0291553773,
0.0759830102,
-0.3933787346,
-0.6946901679,
0.298533529,
-0.9389989376,
-0.6993156672,
1.0965775251,
-0.016527487,
-0.1550195664,
-0.3385921121,
-0.689643383,
0.1861702055,
-0.5596353412,
0.9527663589,
0.4970498979,
0.0751015022,
-0.4199898243,
-0.4882588387,
0.2176003307,
-0.027979847,
-0.9331076741,
-0.0496923514,
0.6793410778,
0.5371488929,
0.271386832,
0.3808056712,
-0.0943458006,
0.4503785968,
0.0873804018,
0.0181846377,
-0.3432304263,
-0.4499129057,
-0.1387000978,
0.1348759532,
-0.3807920218,
-0.3820481598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03167v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03167v3
|
PARADISE: Evaluating Implicit Planning Skills of Language Models with Procedural Warnings and Tips Dataset
| 2024-03-05T18:01:59 | 2024-06-06T08:22:16 |
Arda Uzunoglu, Abdalfatah Rashid Safa, Gözde Gül Şahin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been growing interest within the community regarding
whether large language models are capable of planning or executing plans.
However, most prior studies use LLMs to generate high-level plans for
simplified scenarios lacking linguistic complexity and domain diversity,
limiting analysis of their planning abilities. These setups constrain
evaluation methods (e.g., predefined action space), architectural choices
(e.g., only generative models), and overlook the linguistic nuances essential
for realistic analysis. To tackle this, we present PARADISE, an abductive
reasoning task using Q\&A format on practical procedural text sourced from
wikiHow. It involves warning and tip inference tasks directly associated with
goals, excluding intermediary steps, with the aim of testing the ability of the
models to infer implicit knowledge of the plan solely from the given goal. Our
experiments, utilizing fine-tuned language models and zero-shot prompting,
reveal the effectiveness of task-specific small models over large language
models in most scenarios. Despite advancements, all models fall short of human
performance. Notably, our analysis uncovers intriguing insights, such as
variations in model behavior with dropped keywords, struggles of BERT-family
and GPT-4 with physical and abstract goals, and the proposed tasks offering
valuable prior knowledge for other unseen procedural tasks. The PARADISE
dataset and associated resources are publicly available for further research
exploration with https://github.com/GGLAB-KU/paradise.
|
[
-0.0986043513,
-0.9366112351,
0.9136297107,
0.3666716814,
-0.0931029916,
-0.1623697132,
-0.311414659,
-0.0544087514,
-0.0873029009,
0.6194621921,
-1.0160409212,
-0.8311323524,
-0.4760495424,
0.1955848932,
-0.4498007298,
0.9305135608,
-0.0457797945,
-0.2342245132,
-0.3164721727,
0.2462983876,
-0.6425664425,
-0.2827891707,
-0.5767527819,
-0.0558642074,
0.60535115,
0.4535721838,
0.6258490682,
0.5216766596,
0.3303538263,
0.2398804277,
-0.049801562,
0.2241823226,
-0.7225406766,
0.1647193283,
-0.0962340981,
-0.3026292026,
-0.318802923,
-0.2984242737,
0.5877226591,
0.7824838758,
-0.0066340305,
0.1643709987,
-0.0098265959,
0.5931763649,
-0.8201290369,
0.5104953647,
-0.8373503089,
0.1060946807,
0.1798992157,
-0.2891881764,
-0.4038905799,
-0.432839334,
0.3102118075,
-0.4615840018,
0.0323950052,
0.0332942754,
0.5005358458,
0.4971132576,
-0.2644966543,
-0.4609932601,
-0.9955831766,
0.7376208901,
-0.4745902419,
0.2134101391,
0.4787933826,
0.1911861449,
-0.328597784,
-0.4991204441,
-0.5715025067,
-0.4477870166,
-0.0442326032,
0.0559774823,
-0.2405401468,
0.2752700746,
0.5107565522,
0.0138812121,
-0.6091284752,
-0.1299423128,
-0.3331108987,
0.0198374689,
0.4816225469,
0.292402029,
0.2925874293,
-0.4186936021,
-0.0643704161,
0.1214893684,
-1.0004655123,
0.2885664105,
0.4835885167,
0.4346821904,
-0.1387469023,
0.8483432531,
-0.373356849,
0.5379469395,
-0.437985599,
0.034993764,
-0.3229264021,
-0.2932466269,
-0.2653500438,
-0.2440648824,
0.5454050303,
0.321205318,
0.3293678761,
-0.1998805404,
-0.1699474156,
0.0011635395,
0.5782128572,
-0.61416471,
-0.4667302966,
0.3707321882,
-0.1850564629,
0.0700926408,
-0.4511598647,
-0.256165117,
-0.2085874975,
-0.3356670141,
0.2651662529,
-0.6393145323,
-0.2354932427,
0.2051901966,
0.0039012104,
0.1996597648,
0.3975822926,
-0.5964050293,
0.2392487675,
0.8454616666,
0.6593500972,
-0.0420065857,
-0.2548050582,
-0.3899701536,
-0.0396411866,
-0.5254271626,
0.838098526,
-0.5433375835,
-0.6710330248,
0.2706722617,
-0.04877102,
-0.3030626178,
-0.1207250729,
0.7720623612,
-0.3929848075,
0.0349297449,
-0.6379454136,
-0.3343844712,
-0.4266792238,
0.4291469753,
-0.4464279711,
0.6462780237,
0.1486424804,
-0.4451577961,
0.3416815996,
-0.6630259752,
-0.452681452,
0.087676838,
-0.4373887479,
-0.3186199367,
0.0363173299,
0.1675945818,
0.4274356961,
-0.0764708072,
0.3279149234,
-0.1918044388,
-0.4770379066,
0.2071750611,
-0.3328946531,
0.7452684641,
-0.0231173299,
-0.4425237775,
0.3031579256,
-0.4222135544,
0.0292070508,
0.2321024239,
-0.2699708641,
-0.3166439235,
0.227439329,
-0.1732022315,
0.1459698975,
0.1539901346,
-0.2513361573,
0.3405222297,
-0.3595435619,
0.1499959677,
0.5825633407,
0.2041962296,
0.3306264579,
-0.2704880238,
0.7566474676,
-0.3976725936,
0.2838690877,
-0.0740629658,
-0.5846381783,
-0.9325085282,
-0.0607246608,
0.0652032122,
0.4070067108,
-0.8600697517,
0.1938252449,
-0.5287752151,
-0.2024029642,
-0.1854906678,
-0.0132963788,
0.7924701571,
0.2899161577,
0.2268128544,
-0.0561132282,
-0.4091539085,
-1.0066657066,
-0.2070190758,
-0.1618605256,
0.0951794982,
0.4528811574,
0.644291997,
0.0793671459,
1.0207031965,
-0.6069459319,
-0.1326124668,
-0.5085695386,
0.1080181897,
0.095604755,
0.4066379368,
0.5123150349,
-0.953873992,
-0.2498979717,
-0.1970294118,
-0.7069322467,
0.2309354544,
-0.083316803,
-0.2661573887,
-0.0283775274,
0.1156477034,
-0.7539648414,
0.516254425,
0.2292187959,
-0.4165945947,
0.8163708448,
-0.1054247916,
0.1789283603,
-0.6161705852,
-0.0153906178,
0.0222631861,
-0.0997310132,
-0.6401727796,
0.1815466732,
0.011319655,
0.1394791007,
-0.5096616149,
0.3985489607,
-0.339779079,
-0.2045033127,
-0.298938632,
-0.2359287888,
-0.1442411244,
0.7832863331,
0.3784052432,
0.8636606336,
0.3508916497,
-0.7952678204,
-0.0659492835,
0.4160221219,
-0.2113677114,
0.3335629106,
-0.5002568364,
0.2472693026,
-0.1277631968,
0.0052437601,
-0.9700135589,
-0.272487998,
0.5078365803,
-0.443813026,
0.0735770091,
-0.6884846687,
-0.3242256045,
-0.4161958694,
-0.206691727,
0.2229950577,
0.5840193033,
-0.0176179633,
0.5746474266,
0.31801036,
-0.5248443484,
-0.5936946273,
-0.3372272253,
0.0946282148,
-0.1982314587,
-0.1246408299,
0.090454191,
-0.1936967969,
-0.4018881917,
0.175924629,
-0.1475046426,
-0.0998736173,
0.0631527677,
0.6645491719,
0.2567151487,
-0.1299552619,
-0.273381263,
0.4799927175,
0.1169419512,
0.471038729,
-0.3886532187,
0.5306639075,
-0.1737422198,
-0.4813466668,
-0.1586161554,
0.0965636,
0.3202726841,
0.0129351048,
0.639621675,
0.0755196884,
-0.5544691682,
-0.2197881192,
-0.4082574546,
0.1064943075,
-0.4083639979,
0.3275748789,
-0.6412947774,
-0.6847985983,
0.2698734105,
0.0083027976,
0.377076596,
0.3798808157,
0.418915838,
-0.0126528814,
0.9545912743,
0.7417990565,
0.3792978227,
0.1084148064,
-0.683821559,
0.029209597,
-0.7937901616,
-0.3714723885,
-0.5331400037,
0.0011589564,
-0.3041264713,
-0.6068768501,
0.3969390988,
-0.2339293212,
0.0234628841,
0.4729309082,
-0.2253187001,
0.5936213732,
0.4258079529,
0.0086970804,
0.3995302618,
-0.0063019628,
-0.1422153264,
-0.0411901884,
-0.5547813177,
-0.7915112972,
1.2741143703,
0.2835581005,
0.2854914069,
-0.0811184123,
0.3911299407,
0.4676380754,
0.2401234061,
-0.8878982067,
0.7229676843,
-0.0010599862,
-0.4080885053,
-0.4149703681,
-0.415217489,
-0.9075927734,
0.2212248892,
-0.147365123,
-0.5610693693,
0.2257306874,
-0.0170157161,
-0.7636786103,
0.0684441775,
-0.5252918005,
0.7966504693,
-0.2105312496,
-0.2957339287,
-0.3671736419,
-0.3347418606,
0.5684229136,
0.0397680961,
0.2779729962,
-0.3757025301,
-0.0125085134,
0.5514210463,
0.028056208,
0.7686914206,
-0.2779947221,
-0.1761685312,
0.338000983,
0.5196726322,
0.3608977795,
0.0283159725,
0.0549586825,
0.1134732664,
0.0167870484,
-0.3512998521,
-0.525619328,
0.7568596601,
-0.5968549252,
-0.5271576047,
-0.1851045638,
-0.7702118158,
-0.4592014551,
0.2225606292,
0.0482622646,
0.4596948922,
-0.3535905182,
-0.1729825288,
0.5670221448,
-0.2735833824,
0.3374356329,
0.5290694237,
-0.3014577627,
-0.1553380638,
0.7368913293,
0.0267940741,
0.1893690675,
0.2988547087,
-0.0267704446,
-0.517077446,
-1.0635044575,
-0.4076789618,
0.1694217771,
-0.7859336138,
0.0443136357,
-0.7717872262,
-0.2726190388,
-0.365378052,
0.0295272972,
-0.300355345,
-0.463211298,
0.1621542424,
-0.1306876689,
0.0473673381,
1.1480983496,
0.2015299499,
0.3538464904,
-0.5089836717,
0.3568412364,
0.2037600875,
0.0383253321,
-0.0636774376,
-0.2855727971,
-0.0467865095,
0.2510844171,
-0.1207334474,
-0.694924593,
0.4804692268,
-0.0299053825,
0.5076805949,
0.4896118641,
0.2591000795,
0.5784966946,
-0.5860259533,
0.6268199682,
-0.2044996768,
-0.574283123,
0.7188370824,
-0.6462137103,
0.0927951336,
0.591501534,
0.7789627314,
-0.2289891988,
-0.4374349117,
-0.7004809976,
-0.7707018852,
0.596185863,
0.6240190268,
0.1867896765,
-0.0050250362,
0.5544546247,
0.3211209476,
0.4895876646,
-0.8282790184,
-0.1702307314,
0.2720637918,
0.1296259314,
0.0287619568,
-0.4449409246,
-0.2760536373,
-0.2444539517,
0.5427569151,
-0.2032625228,
0.3594691455,
0.0188752096,
-0.2735488415,
-0.1556516886,
0.2410692722,
0.5927491188,
0.9077028036,
-0.2530113757,
0.0248353351,
0.1207338274,
-0.278840512,
-0.0830503926,
0.0767300203,
-0.4405779839,
-0.2008866966,
0.4298252165,
0.687698245,
0.4489727914,
-0.8050256968,
0.4248332977,
-0.4136582017,
-0.2319728434,
-0.5692549944,
0.321159184,
-0.065231137,
0.1363776624,
0.340400666,
0.0945272446,
0.377128005,
-0.4289174378,
-0.0987552404,
0.6001947522,
-0.4533065856,
-0.2907545567,
0.3504668474,
0.107624948,
-0.2496011853,
0.7296016812,
-0.5619284511,
-0.578160584,
0.5325546265,
0.3092566133,
0.9394686222,
0.1734439731,
0.3990391791,
0.2604568899,
0.5422141552,
0.2337927222,
0.4092181325,
-0.3453504145,
-0.6282630563,
-0.7648154497,
-0.7575523853,
-0.5256141424,
0.2329073399,
-0.3148138225,
0.0721254274,
-0.4463642538,
0.0539216027,
-0.4427073002,
-0.0184946656,
-0.7647316456,
0.0963982493,
0.1482779831,
0.8562555313,
-0.8743890524,
0.4920002222,
0.6758285165,
-0.385635376,
-0.7834126949,
0.3335179389,
-0.061751388,
-0.8962097168,
0.574354887,
0.2416529655,
-0.251547873,
0.057598833,
-0.4539393485,
-0.7363963723,
0.7411441803,
0.5025144219,
-0.4670664072,
-0.4397181273,
0.2672531605,
0.3760878742,
-0.2092825621,
0.3405809104,
0.8935415745,
0.4646659195,
0.35686481,
-0.9385129213,
0.0687640086,
-0.1685426235,
-0.1544594169,
-0.0762523711,
-0.0768989474,
0.5973680615,
-0.4052577615,
-0.3510222137,
0.3076509237,
0.6127644777,
0.313074559,
0.200334385,
0.6618406773,
0.4463225901,
0.5297638178,
-0.1903805137,
1.263894558,
-0.0855969638,
0.1488675475,
0.8770222068,
-0.1427112967,
0.8684412837,
0.1934722364,
-0.3116914034,
0.5989335775,
0.6757382751,
0.5394209623,
0.6706396341,
0.1349890232,
-0.1874808222,
-0.4903577864,
-0.1314016432,
-0.1850067377,
0.4502489269,
0.6980352402,
0.1473380476,
-0.2910822034,
-0.007614532,
0.0571624376,
0.049545493,
-0.4273139834,
0.6617970467,
0.0217553861,
-0.9313567877,
0.4901432097,
-0.125122264,
0.3432591558,
-0.6010715961,
-0.198379308,
-0.1262900382,
0.0609971993,
-0.0032630349,
-0.8213441372,
0.3442774713,
0.0239153169,
0.1710092723,
-0.2579608858,
0.6263312697,
-0.2984005511,
-0.4695166647,
0.0857324377,
0.5951430202,
0.2401399463,
-0.4855224192,
-0.794470489,
0.0010030797,
-0.0237603225,
-0.0816909075,
0.1181511506,
0.3538149297,
-0.0722167566,
0.8874249458,
0.8263892531,
0.3438499272,
0.0561392605,
0.0409780592,
0.8971856236,
-0.5899627805,
-0.5830224156,
-0.8358123899,
0.5972406864,
0.0161513798,
-0.1059728265,
0.7907684445,
0.7291035652,
0.6441342235,
-0.2613587976,
0.8118502498,
-0.0425180718,
0.3218162358,
-0.7613488436,
0.5024473667,
-0.3157568276,
0.2671074867,
-0.3250883222,
-0.9213539958,
-0.1676568836,
0.6071256995,
-0.8921759725,
-0.0218308773,
0.6579489708,
0.4714208543,
0.0191777833,
0.0387310684,
0.3894073963,
0.1687132269,
0.2726241946,
0.7379472852,
1.3004287481,
0.0090167196,
0.5554045439,
-0.4607520103,
-0.1717131436,
-0.1961275488,
-0.9659870863,
-1.0322057009,
-0.6233870387,
-0.3056012392,
-0.165768519,
0.3967354298,
0.9559738636,
0.6612281799,
-0.7128711343,
-0.2430797517,
-0.3310147822,
0.3998610675,
-0.1446057707,
-0.1917726696,
0.4163453281,
-0.3634525537,
-0.8190764785,
0.6417261958,
0.3520095348,
-0.027955668,
-0.4259631932,
-0.1457698941,
-0.0744185224,
-0.1695840955,
0.5310798287,
0.3848020732,
-0.869743526,
-0.1534012407,
0.0538704135,
0.0864099115,
-0.3494836688,
0.9453052282,
-0.8323341012,
0.0719787404,
0.03401554,
0.426076144,
0.2114038765,
-0.0027196214,
0.6870820522,
-0.7786535025,
0.0040964205,
0.4414982796,
0.4534097016,
0.2093113214,
-0.4804924726,
0.411108166,
0.0781895071,
-0.4364194572,
-0.7198124528,
0.1287776083,
-0.7717500329,
-0.2729651928,
1.3923975229,
-0.1668953001,
-0.335998714,
-0.207362324,
-0.4762884676,
0.0922551528,
-0.2935945988,
0.8317118883,
0.5459809303,
-0.3110997081,
-0.0472616926,
-0.7746830583,
0.7532503009,
0.3149659336,
-0.7470953465,
0.2461813539,
0.7850527167,
0.2130790949,
0.1111324281,
0.8589789271,
0.2053662688,
0.4250462353,
-0.2105182409,
-0.0699630231,
-0.2183607072,
-0.785299778,
-0.1813993603,
0.1433979124,
0.3682895899,
-0.0851436406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03163v1
|
Design2Code: How Far Are We From Automating Front-End Engineering?
| 2024-03-05T17:56:27 | 2024-03-05T17:56:27 |
Chenglei Si, Yanzhe Zhang, Zhengyuan Yang, Ruibo Liu, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
Generative AI has made rapid advancements in recent years, achieving
unprecedented capabilities in multimodal understanding and code generation.
This can enable a new paradigm of front-end development, in which multimodal
LLMs might directly convert visual designs into code implementations. In this
work, we formalize this as a Design2Code task and conduct comprehensive
benchmarking. Specifically, we manually curate a benchmark of 484 diverse
real-world webpages as test cases and develop a set of automatic evaluation
metrics to assess how well current multimodal LLMs can generate the code
implementations that directly render into the given reference webpages, given
the screenshots as input. We also complement automatic metrics with
comprehensive human evaluations. We develop a suite of multimodal prompting
methods and show their effectiveness on GPT-4V and Gemini Pro Vision. We
further finetune an open-source Design2Code-18B model that successfully matches
the performance of Gemini Pro Vision. Both human evaluation and automatic
metrics show that GPT-4V performs the best on this task compared to other
models. Moreover, annotators think GPT-4V generated webpages can replace the
original reference webpages in 49% of cases in terms of visual appearance and
content; and perhaps surprisingly, in 64% of cases GPT-4V generated webpages
are considered better than the original reference webpages. Our fine-grained
break-down metrics indicate that open-source models mostly lag in recalling
visual elements from the input webpages and in generating correct layout
designs, while aspects like text content and coloring can be drastically
improved with proper finetuning.
|
[
-0.623374939,
-0.4051140547,
0.480015099,
0.3245629072,
-0.2729945779,
-0.0150535256,
-0.1088945791,
-0.5284638405,
-0.2963764071,
0.001037352,
-0.6524338126,
-0.6035684943,
-0.266593188,
0.2212401628,
-0.331867218,
0.5488609672,
-0.2676448226,
-0.0616664626,
-0.5811652541,
0.0858042687,
-0.3163661063,
-0.1132821962,
-0.5354569554,
0.1050954536,
0.4228903949,
0.0803484768,
0.5083292127,
0.3691005707,
0.5370492935,
0.2574210763,
0.2795420587,
0.1906864196,
-0.286363095,
-0.0415145196,
-0.1432730108,
-0.4912418723,
-0.3437080085,
0.2432593703,
0.1952757984,
0.1743510067,
0.1360730231,
0.2650600374,
0.1655958444,
0.7174431086,
-0.6905285716,
0.4480112791,
-0.2443119586,
0.2941671014,
0.0900519267,
-0.1454735994,
-0.5527980924,
-0.3326922655,
-0.3376428783,
-0.8403767347,
0.3324047029,
0.1079954654,
0.7301088572,
0.5851937532,
-0.1798572391,
-0.3184084892,
-0.4728195965,
0.6094851494,
-0.3779990077,
0.8170674443,
0.14674519,
0.2915370166,
0.0551670156,
-0.8371225595,
-0.6135832071,
-0.5191035271,
0.1024871245,
0.3819101751,
-0.560448885,
0.0048375418,
0.3349866867,
0.3103601635,
-0.7759976387,
0.2783523798,
-0.3588992059,
-0.2973490059,
0.6437408924,
0.0951680914,
0.392937243,
-0.2220169753,
-0.4909054339,
-0.298920095,
-0.5999327302,
0.031402804,
0.3882031739,
-0.2589386702,
-0.2668592036,
0.4269786775,
-0.291115284,
0.5294686556,
0.0847315639,
0.187776193,
0.4064146876,
-0.6295136809,
-0.1019495726,
-0.6577480435,
0.8989415765,
0.9195607305,
0.4444389939,
-0.2901108265,
-0.4076252282,
0.5021291971,
0.7454435229,
-0.6850729585,
-0.4965320826,
0.2874201834,
-0.6314973235,
-0.2093394101,
-0.0683020875,
-0.8348267674,
-0.2308321595,
-0.4842807055,
0.4963873327,
-0.1827900112,
-0.1519831866,
-0.3097395599,
-0.4117053449,
0.3426201046,
0.4445871711,
-0.639015317,
-0.028469542,
0.5495576262,
0.7979292274,
-0.3855519891,
-0.2009028941,
-0.1821365356,
-0.2460666597,
-0.7395569086,
0.7899915576,
-0.1030748934,
-0.4330886602,
-0.0190676544,
-0.3863225281,
0.3457764685,
-0.6496090293,
0.1881890893,
-0.427269876,
0.0705924332,
-0.0232752468,
-0.1407889575,
-0.0584262833,
0.3612383306,
-0.7117820978,
0.7209017277,
0.3040040135,
-0.5541056991,
0.5443851352,
-0.6090528965,
-0.3619796634,
-0.0203233417,
-0.5486906171,
-0.5623050928,
0.3507380486,
0.2116626501,
0.1090422794,
-0.3802643716,
-0.1665362269,
-0.2310871482,
-0.3340494037,
0.1363258064,
-0.5027195811,
0.4505492151,
0.4836178124,
-0.484360218,
0.292716831,
-0.8210406899,
0.2605886757,
0.1392845958,
-0.4424686432,
0.1150217503,
-0.1505342871,
0.2145422995,
0.3951302469,
0.0293445531,
-0.4754057825,
0.1878380477,
-0.2320189327,
0.4589650333,
0.8127470613,
-0.2087862641,
0.4917204976,
-0.2072811872,
0.7262094021,
-0.1211321056,
0.4702720046,
-0.2520480752,
-0.7455898523,
-0.876173377,
-0.0889107138,
-0.005436908,
0.4642689526,
-1.0651680231,
0.0495278686,
-0.0555696189,
-0.2096167505,
-0.2662192583,
0.2914810479,
0.6781793833,
0.2260166109,
0.3459996581,
-0.8326067924,
-0.3668755889,
-1.0405416489,
-0.0905198306,
-0.2237562239,
-0.2828499973,
0.3394288719,
0.4684974551,
-0.4501598775,
0.967402041,
-0.3426329494,
-0.0439338274,
0.0188323744,
0.3754195869,
-0.1165107191,
0.3375501335,
0.6547529697,
-0.7153268456,
-0.3224781454,
-0.0730533004,
-1.1226884127,
-0.1726628393,
-0.0769304112,
-0.0485622101,
0.2875044346,
0.2894825935,
-0.5926861763,
0.7370637655,
0.3485563993,
-0.1056588143,
0.6455600262,
-0.2613654137,
0.1662953645,
-0.7062987685,
0.1323020607,
0.2280881852,
0.0839844346,
-0.3478115201,
0.4323332906,
0.4330022335,
-0.3548520803,
-0.5272884369,
0.5797041655,
-0.7321628332,
-0.5614172816,
-0.1785212755,
-0.118352212,
0.2888334692,
0.5982150435,
-0.2623867393,
1.1125255823,
0.1726748943,
-0.5672087669,
0.709985137,
0.2779510617,
-0.3468803763,
0.5786386132,
-0.6624215245,
0.2820860445,
-0.1929803044,
0.3386165798,
-1.1446070671,
-0.2283267975,
0.4241020679,
-0.451292932,
0.1045888662,
-0.0520155616,
-0.6131804585,
-0.8177493811,
-0.4703673422,
0.344130367,
0.7683591247,
-0.5003731251,
0.4362916648,
-0.1018155292,
-0.0797694176,
-0.2172224671,
-0.659830749,
0.3187964559,
0.050594192,
-0.8702135086,
0.4491294622,
-0.2850880623,
-0.3759325147,
-0.1533474624,
-0.0760713145,
0.0782424435,
0.0315664746,
0.3776559532,
0.2423707247,
-0.1522725672,
-0.0741813853,
-0.1502988786,
-0.340140909,
0.1540424973,
-0.3401213586,
0.3501997888,
0.0204149354,
-0.6555870175,
-1.054238677,
0.2693963349,
0.5614828467,
-0.412555337,
-0.163742587,
0.7822509408,
-0.1817125827,
-0.1738648266,
-0.5263698101,
-0.069586359,
-0.4593330026,
0.308262378,
-0.6108732224,
-0.3741311431,
0.2027357072,
0.0506521799,
0.2810102403,
0.4217181206,
0.7057716846,
-0.2322264463,
0.943122983,
0.6765376925,
0.2938212156,
0.5610281229,
-0.3616861701,
0.0166342705,
-0.6417277455,
-0.3547614515,
-0.1515459865,
-0.3529834449,
-0.5734232664,
-0.6027957201,
0.6304442286,
-0.0148765957,
-0.046118103,
0.2365980148,
-0.5719736218,
0.1556449383,
0.7585388422,
0.2538290322,
0.1483581215,
0.1438362002,
-0.1663084179,
0.0057433047,
-0.5502822995,
-0.2450877428,
1.0929517746,
0.3791095614,
0.9524347782,
0.1938420385,
0.6007744074,
0.613150835,
0.4500131309,
-0.6949880123,
0.3132042289,
-0.175721854,
-0.3168712854,
0.0996974483,
-0.2078344971,
-0.6727415919,
0.0259647239,
-0.0939998776,
-0.1850692332,
0.1053826287,
0.3610623479,
-0.6346182823,
-0.1961607486,
-0.8710163832,
0.910507679,
-0.566822648,
-0.8875390887,
-0.3048880994,
-0.5203857422,
0.242889449,
0.0565464124,
0.2465162873,
0.0717748106,
0.0382470675,
0.5593556166,
-0.2088357806,
0.7718731165,
-0.1751171499,
-0.3425248563,
0.3749638498,
-0.0416302234,
0.3053428233,
0.0394461304,
0.137198627,
0.0338080935,
-0.345859319,
-0.2525867522,
-0.6233444214,
0.5278699994,
-0.8857237101,
-0.4341751933,
-0.2507528365,
-0.1617420316,
-0.1222102046,
-0.0670004785,
0.4086277783,
0.6341488957,
-0.1139037311,
-0.0919837877,
0.4414336681,
-0.6064523458,
0.57006073,
0.1951697022,
-0.154104203,
-0.4617497921,
0.8195047379,
-0.3348538876,
0.1643466353,
0.3395800292,
-0.1620694995,
-0.4943422377,
-0.6090515256,
-1.2182866335,
-0.1665991545,
-0.8561603427,
-0.201751098,
-0.4163371027,
-0.135156095,
-0.472345829,
-0.0949358419,
-0.4262770116,
-0.1667004079,
-0.2296972573,
0.1091768891,
0.0620005578,
1.0730979443,
-0.1760767847,
-0.0359100774,
-0.5970785022,
0.5675050616,
0.5214011669,
0.3886552155,
-0.1250299364,
-0.1646008343,
-0.0305220243,
-0.1862106472,
-0.5860592127,
-0.5563495755,
0.1267037094,
-0.0105974907,
0.6983253956,
0.3183804452,
-0.2817178667,
0.5321545005,
-0.51104635,
0.9530178308,
0.5215793848,
-0.6040500402,
0.5790576935,
-0.1655577421,
0.4726267457,
0.3755003512,
0.2540426552,
-0.3652171791,
0.039334476,
-0.3345956504,
-0.710406661,
0.3642734587,
0.2813994884,
0.0989483595,
0.0289726015,
0.323564142,
0.1315027922,
0.1573100835,
-0.3438109756,
0.0566005856,
-0.6317495704,
-0.3509704471,
0.0140096303,
-0.1572502553,
-0.0493409745,
0.0502416007,
0.1027383208,
-0.2697452009,
0.7615956664,
-0.1188538373,
-0.2887473702,
0.1653012335,
-0.0351086371,
0.8005262017,
1.0133794546,
0.2220183164,
0.011835211,
-0.1453609765,
-0.1648973376,
0.1429190338,
0.2180867195,
-0.1767343581,
-0.1498444229,
0.4049704075,
0.8237962127,
0.2181165218,
-0.5491544008,
0.7317893505,
-0.165771544,
-0.2110540271,
-0.489867419,
0.1842750758,
-0.2714639604,
0.3121757209,
0.3167844713,
0.1487924457,
0.2232493013,
-0.5363283157,
0.430254221,
0.3854611814,
-0.2089125216,
-0.5911596417,
1.2259017229,
0.7988969088,
-0.3415404558,
0.8508247137,
-0.2926872373,
-0.3589579165,
0.6699638367,
0.2861449718,
0.8192805648,
0.2223748267,
0.0426683091,
0.5022066236,
-0.009733689,
0.2539721727,
0.2935062945,
-0.3531853855,
-0.4215151668,
-0.3578107357,
-0.78250283,
-0.3129876852,
-0.176520735,
-0.5414606333,
0.2165510505,
-0.658524096,
-0.1792097241,
0.0224674717,
-0.2416090518,
-0.9333797097,
0.4120021462,
0.5427633524,
0.8249732256,
-0.5435864925,
0.4662206471,
0.6838409901,
-0.7483170629,
-0.1444699764,
-0.073079206,
0.456718415,
-0.9269728661,
0.7097541094,
0.3042346239,
-0.0397522934,
0.1242593527,
-0.4054805338,
-0.440213114,
1.1311552525,
-0.2019338459,
-0.8026884794,
-0.3156289756,
-0.0521708466,
0.35003075,
-0.0343374312,
0.4319592118,
0.1216488779,
0.4714042246,
-0.1218178049,
-1.0417960882,
-0.0866571292,
-0.5185111165,
0.3320117891,
0.0403691903,
-0.7433653474,
0.7810510993,
-0.3197576702,
-0.2189824581,
0.4347806275,
0.5784196854,
0.107476078,
0.4166632295,
0.3740778267,
0.6893365979,
0.2609075606,
-0.131970644,
1.101774931,
-0.467095077,
0.1687221825,
0.6025810838,
-0.027415866,
0.6608448029,
0.4402846694,
-0.4051856697,
0.23973988,
0.5953429937,
-0.2485182136,
0.6149018407,
0.3742191494,
-0.169298172,
-0.0375250764,
0.2613884509,
-0.3991570175,
0.5721988082,
0.1759372354,
-0.477391392,
-0.1649399251,
0.2382648587,
-0.1675565839,
-0.0291984156,
-0.0985769033,
0.8328754902,
0.0904953405,
-0.9110334516,
0.588901937,
0.2730130255,
0.8422015905,
-0.363252908,
-0.0341616422,
-0.5781585574,
0.4944422841,
-0.1465189308,
-0.8887726665,
0.2924004197,
0.0571091548,
-0.1564996094,
-0.6090378761,
0.3711931109,
0.1113737002,
-0.3176183403,
0.1327946484,
0.5413087606,
0.1381306052,
-0.1199264452,
-0.6102080345,
0.4261312783,
0.1678612232,
0.0639492571,
0.2508307695,
0.1429167241,
-0.2264584899,
0.6557950377,
0.7076616883,
-0.4419891238,
0.1757503897,
0.3609337509,
0.9096288681,
-0.6049394608,
-0.4347034693,
-0.7213392258,
0.4914931059,
0.0215732716,
-0.4427994788,
0.6050662398,
0.6315662861,
0.925172925,
-0.2207736969,
0.963013947,
-0.092533499,
-0.1818375587,
-0.5661100745,
0.695933044,
-0.601221025,
-0.0991911963,
-0.0945507064,
-0.9331378341,
-0.3002534211,
0.6415748,
-0.020440748,
0.0534277707,
0.4000942409,
0.7831501365,
-0.1446807683,
-0.0943524688,
0.2512109578,
-0.1261029989,
0.5234143138,
0.6754516363,
1.0372905731,
-0.3294459283,
0.6951987743,
-0.2831170857,
-0.4604137838,
-0.297201544,
-0.5276478529,
-0.7321705222,
-0.4513297677,
-0.348061204,
-0.1379913241,
0.314850986,
0.645761013,
0.8691498637,
-0.4911031127,
0.0515943021,
-0.2129253447,
-0.4081195593,
-0.1904464662,
-0.175168097,
-0.0337840877,
-0.286593914,
-0.6368097067,
0.3245905042,
0.3552396595,
0.1148229167,
-0.6496415734,
-0.1732489616,
0.2936057448,
-0.3640216589,
0.9419152141,
0.1296552271,
-0.9716764688,
-0.3204515576,
0.0529207811,
-0.1923493147,
0.3495418429,
0.6164048314,
-0.8267565966,
0.6152569652,
0.5617040992,
0.4975434542,
0.419329524,
0.2552368939,
0.5872408748,
-0.5519831181,
0.0076764803,
-0.0594245344,
0.1118204519,
0.4763305485,
0.0621874221,
0.596285522,
0.4391132593,
-0.3100130558,
-0.2854989171,
0.415296793,
-0.7400582433,
-0.1240887418,
1.1502084732,
-0.1618837714,
-0.0862381235,
0.083216615,
-0.1763606668,
0.1431639344,
-0.2017518282,
0.6970435977,
0.3363637924,
-0.4984302819,
-0.4013904631,
-0.8597677946,
0.4096828401,
0.1021496505,
-0.8888710141,
-0.3371131718,
0.7357933521,
0.428252995,
0.2608727813,
0.5451093316,
-0.0828180313,
0.6732156873,
0.3619793355,
0.4108816385,
-0.2431565374,
-0.4073981047,
-0.125303641,
0.2150263339,
0.1058704406,
-0.4093962014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03141v1
|
Language Guided Exploration for RL Agents in Text Environments
| 2024-03-05T17:26:41 | 2024-03-05T17:26:41 |
Hitesh Golchha, Sahil Yerawar, Dhruvesh Patel, Soham Dan, Keerthiram Murugesan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Real-world sequential decision making is characterized by sparse rewards and
large decision spaces, posing significant difficulty for experiential learning
systems like $\textit{tabula rasa}$ reinforcement learning (RL) agents. Large
Language Models (LLMs), with a wealth of world knowledge, can help RL agents
learn quickly and adapt to distribution shifts. In this work, we introduce
Language Guided Exploration (LGE) framework, which uses a pre-trained language
model (called GUIDE ) to provide decision-level guidance to an RL agent (called
EXPLORER). We observe that on ScienceWorld (Wang et al.,2022), a challenging
text environment, LGE outperforms vanilla RL agents significantly and also
outperforms other sophisticated methods like Behaviour Cloning and Text
Decision Transformer.
|
[
-0.1702511311,
-0.8487768769,
0.8365789056,
0.3241847456,
0.0713714212,
0.3902561367,
-0.3499398828,
-0.5001359582,
0.0666320845,
0.4659972787,
-0.9806571603,
-0.6633448005,
-0.3921656311,
0.1757403314,
-0.0163533296,
1.0454713106,
-0.197789371,
-0.2186054736,
-0.0952391624,
-0.0623945147,
-0.5406441092,
-0.2009550929,
-0.848462522,
-0.6146380305,
0.8488982916,
0.3869648576,
0.7868236303,
0.4254776537,
0.2994038463,
0.3003570139,
-0.3276360929,
0.4496315122,
-0.4478194118,
0.4946906269,
-0.4577046931,
-0.4479472339,
-0.2345343232,
-0.0844389871,
0.5627659559,
0.4452598095,
-0.2701699734,
-0.0721197724,
-0.0811889246,
0.6449519992,
-0.2917274237,
0.5389615893,
-0.1314715296,
0.514515996,
0.1615031809,
-0.3631683886,
-0.6664201021,
-0.1957282424,
0.6998491883,
-1.1708853245,
-0.0091728009,
0.399400413,
0.5663357377,
0.3726203144,
-0.361284554,
-0.4709949195,
-0.7863698006,
0.8445965648,
-0.1655003875,
0.3940704465,
0.128350988,
0.4844776392,
-0.4439261556,
-0.9270471334,
-0.4308641255,
-0.3187736571,
-0.1642004251,
0.0380399004,
0.1038948968,
0.1334519088,
0.250913471,
-0.2749929726,
-0.6399462223,
0.2352840751,
-0.1390235871,
-0.1698604673,
0.519256115,
0.1364294589,
0.3139754534,
0.0849726871,
-0.303212136,
-0.604349494,
-0.7514846921,
0.2901697755,
0.0537129156,
0.3153452277,
0.1276339144,
0.1609701812,
-0.1409298629,
0.8616178036,
-0.2247749567,
-0.2825438976,
0.1824900806,
0.0369851664,
-0.1023894772,
0.0559266806,
0.4984936416,
0.1763921827,
0.4108931124,
-0.0290396996,
-0.4517137706,
-0.4000586867,
0.1966896206,
-0.7347534895,
-0.1728608757,
-0.1272805333,
-0.4495921135,
-0.2696214914,
-0.2607151568,
-0.8613834381,
-0.7067406178,
0.0476888567,
0.4291815758,
-0.243400529,
-0.3320180774,
0.2156028599,
-0.1158825085,
0.3891021609,
0.6152468324,
-0.6920240521,
0.107184127,
0.530831039,
0.8265039921,
-0.2395028323,
-0.5080717206,
-0.7417473793,
-0.0369480662,
-0.314917475,
1.0362161398,
-0.735362649,
-0.7741650343,
0.1926842779,
0.0837819278,
-0.0410259254,
-0.3677583337,
0.4954811037,
-0.869787693,
0.2586408257,
-0.1913900077,
-0.3251754344,
-0.3393847644,
0.4350546002,
-0.6249166131,
1.0909911394,
0.0389606506,
-0.3917586803,
0.5442478657,
-0.9012112617,
-0.2158781141,
0.1528039277,
-0.2858879566,
-0.2068470418,
-0.3150765896,
0.3558440506,
0.235204041,
0.0819784626,
0.2065369636,
0.1437140703,
-0.4162599444,
0.1744187027,
-0.2437087297,
0.2333654016,
0.2817393839,
-0.3788776994,
0.4670335054,
-0.5559173822,
0.0949822292,
0.2536315024,
-0.4453104436,
-0.5582742691,
0.3890706897,
-0.0060681785,
0.1246218011,
0.2211581618,
-0.2687029839,
0.731022656,
-0.314221859,
0.0122808395,
1.004506588,
0.1972658783,
0.5850692987,
-0.1053503007,
0.9865768552,
-0.2248210162,
0.0737029538,
-0.3455287814,
-0.4763016105,
-0.6578440666,
-0.0434694514,
0.3454804718,
0.7339008451,
-0.9505736232,
0.2221633047,
-0.2175769955,
-0.2608318031,
-0.3672485054,
-0.0882517025,
0.3150271177,
0.1065049618,
0.3109076023,
0.2355426103,
-0.3350189924,
-0.6222979426,
-0.3694082797,
-0.0585055761,
0.2562355697,
0.6110889316,
0.4387696385,
-0.6190918088,
0.9083243608,
-0.6474677324,
-0.2855550647,
-0.7003650069,
0.1015437916,
0.243290782,
0.2547376752,
0.2186964303,
-0.7768921852,
-0.6270243526,
0.1728314608,
-0.845323801,
-0.1046938747,
-0.3476891518,
-0.1382926255,
0.190289095,
0.7426127195,
-0.3972492814,
0.3727158308,
0.4031201303,
-0.5953828096,
0.3218569756,
-0.6065138578,
-0.0732914358,
-0.5531190038,
-0.2297525257,
0.0660704151,
-0.5202404857,
-0.5886340141,
0.3882288039,
-0.0203904975,
-0.0152173545,
-0.2648268044,
0.967135787,
-0.6123505831,
-0.0740862489,
-0.3752727509,
0.5065254569,
-0.2438795567,
0.5578461289,
0.5360520482,
0.9239544868,
0.6637769938,
-0.6930074692,
0.1561694592,
0.281249702,
-0.4632495344,
0.078117229,
-0.5004841685,
0.1855318993,
-0.3377427161,
0.590092361,
-0.5190250874,
0.243644163,
0.1738334894,
-0.1467090547,
0.1933511049,
0.1897650808,
-0.3336526752,
-0.0829594284,
-0.2623278797,
0.4443106055,
0.5812863708,
-0.794860661,
0.7166867256,
0.0000277694,
-0.2138686776,
-0.969278276,
-0.3548132479,
0.0567953549,
-0.0983469039,
-0.3416053355,
0.124292627,
-0.3013693094,
-0.3988977075,
-0.0158266574,
-0.0131700942,
0.4548466504,
0.0119506503,
0.1296717227,
0.0682413727,
-0.0291643403,
0.2138930559,
-0.1857361794,
-0.1898292303,
0.1217760295,
-0.3353645802,
0.4929124117,
-0.0978141204,
-0.2705239356,
0.1148647293,
0.2265892029,
0.1775837541,
-0.1088727266,
0.6237781644,
0.4296832085,
-0.0579124093,
-0.7680826783,
-0.1121992469,
0.0081811361,
-0.5331403017,
0.7004757524,
-0.3755219579,
-0.8492598534,
0.5020486116,
-0.3195639253,
0.2198688388,
0.2657286823,
0.1216789037,
0.1223302633,
1.1299328804,
1.0024932623,
-0.0265562814,
0.5883217454,
-0.3515728116,
0.1929742396,
-0.4850503802,
-0.5039007068,
-0.333978802,
-0.3710107207,
-0.6639667749,
-0.5726224184,
0.599075377,
-0.2249310464,
-0.0238426458,
-0.1407350451,
-0.4334415793,
0.7106057405,
0.5508437157,
0.1136706173,
0.295140028,
-0.0147189526,
-0.2858674228,
-0.0688467398,
-0.8036855459,
-0.4180106521,
0.9310798645,
0.4218144715,
0.9575742483,
0.1295441091,
0.8297281265,
0.6128666997,
0.359918952,
-0.7919245958,
0.8082677722,
0.3963784277,
-0.1679350734,
-0.5249558091,
-0.2178504914,
-1.0391787291,
0.3997757435,
-0.2859368324,
-0.508979857,
0.0940533504,
-0.0519704446,
-0.3515002429,
0.1639680415,
-0.5364810228,
0.7172157764,
-0.3569130003,
-0.3617009521,
-0.3900743127,
-0.4870804846,
0.0660497025,
-0.0822134465,
0.4604700506,
0.4727573991,
-0.2396894544,
0.8299049139,
-0.1183664948,
0.6630871296,
-0.560749352,
-0.3550459445,
0.2273771763,
0.2807784975,
1.0306224823,
-0.030038828,
0.1392764747,
-0.4751353264,
-0.2256063372,
-0.134662047,
-0.716209352,
0.6585124731,
-0.7695935369,
-0.764320612,
-0.8587024808,
-0.5076990128,
-0.2359268814,
0.1143632829,
-0.0899481401,
0.2118618786,
-0.381319046,
-0.1330871731,
1.1989583969,
-0.7895669937,
0.4825786054,
0.9499340653,
-0.8108964562,
0.0740084201,
0.9349532127,
-0.1863662452,
0.0817310363,
0.5259298682,
0.1980326921,
-0.4699971378,
-0.7376799583,
-0.40327847,
0.0336841904,
-0.8850303888,
0.0565548539,
-0.6366359591,
-0.1727481186,
-0.0188403986,
-0.2790985107,
0.0628167093,
0.0079695666,
-0.0691055879,
-0.3233782351,
0.4204030931,
1.2183164358,
-0.0945693925,
0.4611144662,
-0.7041429877,
0.1023843735,
0.3547878265,
0.2849697769,
-0.1207501516,
-0.4105509222,
-0.3878439367,
-0.2331099212,
0.0632006153,
-0.8212068677,
0.5184985399,
0.1612424105,
0.8469381332,
0.1747347414,
-0.141278401,
0.4794272184,
-0.4708819985,
0.7753002644,
-0.3582701981,
-0.4912256896,
0.5831238627,
-0.3712823987,
0.4336147308,
0.3287205696,
0.1561935097,
-0.7804371119,
-0.226250723,
-0.4973369241,
-0.813356936,
0.8751788139,
-0.3030063808,
-0.2937331498,
0.2665807605,
0.3919256628,
0.1647710949,
-0.0083362674,
-1.2788015604,
-0.3082550466,
0.1037025154,
0.0101371733,
-0.3552896976,
-0.1074326783,
0.0336526148,
0.0304052178,
0.8361021876,
-0.2245160788,
0.2140849382,
0.3916799128,
-0.4297292829,
-0.1297770739,
0.3017958701,
0.7378928661,
0.4249509275,
-0.3008673489,
-0.0965155885,
0.1363140494,
-0.3948220313,
0.2148592472,
0.178325966,
-0.2268552333,
-0.2115251571,
0.500200808,
0.8522099257,
0.0222866572,
-1.2097325325,
0.3525068462,
-0.4119727314,
-0.1766197234,
-0.4556669891,
0.2627543509,
-0.1972077936,
0.523370266,
0.5942949653,
-0.0947119296,
0.0522096641,
-0.5087593198,
0.0182945281,
0.4296292663,
-0.3610440791,
0.066365324,
0.2834891677,
0.28313905,
-0.6773441434,
0.3782286048,
-0.6055247784,
-0.702998817,
0.4986232221,
0.4567837715,
0.8907741904,
-0.0014515535,
0.3407300711,
0.2334144264,
0.4959307909,
-0.3371473551,
0.1549368501,
-0.232908234,
-0.6229977012,
-0.6120750308,
-0.4407426119,
-0.5522813201,
0.0404009782,
-0.2376175374,
0.1329860836,
-0.3647678196,
0.343773514,
-0.5417429805,
0.1028557867,
-0.7167235017,
0.0941038504,
0.1415672898,
1.2942811251,
-0.7357379198,
0.8308981061,
0.8847280145,
-0.0179447271,
-0.837755084,
0.1132935286,
-0.2593346536,
-0.9311606288,
0.913008213,
0.1245028004,
-0.5229257941,
0.0562464744,
-0.6000205874,
-0.7887285352,
1.1830766201,
-0.2255508006,
-0.6167805195,
-0.1764574498,
-0.1344679743,
0.7097412944,
-0.3885134459,
0.3862088025,
0.4598126113,
0.6567193866,
-0.1910356134,
-0.7377759814,
-0.0208922941,
-0.1732998341,
-0.2457602471,
0.2041808814,
-0.6211990118,
0.4773787558,
-0.4145935774,
-0.205729112,
-0.0053720726,
0.853038013,
0.50823915,
0.359854728,
0.866881907,
0.1987768859,
0.763320744,
0.0338835306,
0.9943261743,
-0.0595099218,
0.2287240922,
0.7449370027,
-0.3689904213,
0.6545674205,
0.2081231475,
-0.0612459779,
0.9777889848,
0.8317825198,
0.4196115732,
0.7851855755,
0.2642388046,
-0.3587257862,
-0.2823725045,
0.0083378665,
-0.318806231,
0.208959654,
0.6121409535,
-0.2087213248,
-0.2741165757,
0.2115763277,
-0.1451862305,
0.350592941,
-0.4166390896,
0.8261863589,
-0.2746830285,
-1.0861927271,
0.2995018661,
0.0412948802,
0.8383868933,
-0.9748613834,
-0.4437383711,
-0.3078510463,
0.2730869651,
0.0633176118,
-0.8494392037,
-0.2129962891,
-0.1399299353,
0.0573757738,
-0.7206377983,
0.8254833817,
-0.4094750583,
-0.2115976363,
0.5207897425,
0.7670402527,
0.0715824515,
0.2220698893,
-0.694260478,
-0.0810836181,
0.2904370129,
-0.7947720289,
0.468065232,
0.51041013,
-0.1409356147,
1.1754213572,
0.4072473049,
0.1520368904,
-0.0827196464,
-0.0805767849,
0.6430050135,
-1.0374566317,
-0.8703963757,
-0.5716122985,
0.1451314539,
-0.0258761272,
0.0016082869,
0.6059148908,
0.3504978418,
0.5839887261,
-0.0443697758,
0.8902506232,
-0.0189459473,
0.5522958636,
-0.7354924679,
0.307517916,
-0.4474982023,
0.3775470555,
-0.1364261806,
-0.8075759411,
-0.1211510897,
0.9093498588,
-0.1625721306,
0.1270589083,
0.7951362729,
0.9042523503,
0.1167560592,
-0.0873944387,
0.1439003497,
0.1557447612,
0.6416595578,
0.6336007714,
1.156468749,
0.0734903365,
0.4903531969,
0.2108001262,
-0.3368562758,
-0.0206859708,
-1.1328914165,
-0.9292057157,
-0.4553092122,
-0.0761777759,
-0.2722770572,
0.2395634204,
1.2618664503,
0.5436309576,
-0.3206692636,
-0.2234125584,
-0.1577428728,
0.3608981371,
-0.3721375763,
-0.2489151508,
0.3600138128,
-0.35972929,
-0.8258605599,
0.9713075161,
0.154200688,
0.0231398251,
-0.7387385964,
-0.528706789,
-0.2421235889,
-0.0327843502,
0.4227371216,
0.5200593472,
-0.4128111005,
-0.3195964694,
0.2121516615,
0.0563414916,
-0.2961569726,
0.9624878168,
-1.2201180458,
0.4099634588,
0.2788840532,
0.6434120536,
0.5729774833,
-0.2903368771,
0.6915863752,
-0.8118702173,
0.3365773261,
0.1509536207,
0.2527951896,
0.0938979313,
-0.3141422868,
0.6131776571,
-0.0146086896,
-0.8128147125,
-0.7765471339,
0.193688035,
-0.8853832483,
-0.4553518593,
1.4486804008,
-0.0687504858,
-0.2591916025,
-0.0439624377,
-0.5450274348,
-0.1074879393,
-0.5652413964,
0.5556969643,
0.6952038407,
-0.2106226981,
-0.1427294165,
-0.7018033862,
0.8057671189,
0.4127374291,
-0.7184603214,
-0.0200332478,
0.5867247581,
0.0947930515,
0.1332295537,
0.7166406512,
0.5046628714,
0.1340268552,
-0.3459742367,
0.056293454,
-0.0902164578,
-0.5874663591,
-0.4322645366,
-0.0418622121,
0.5131374598,
0.010877884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03129v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03129v2
|
CoGenesis: A Framework Collaborating Large and Small Language Models for Secure Context-Aware Instruction Following
| 2024-03-05T17:15:28 | 2024-06-06T09:30:24 |
Kaiyan Zhang, Jianyu Wang, Ermo Hua, Biqing Qi, Ning Ding, Bowen Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the advancement of language models (LMs), their exposure to private data
is increasingly inevitable, and their deployment (especially for smaller ones)
on personal devices, such as PCs and smartphones, has become a prevailing
trend. In contexts laden with user information, enabling models to both
safeguard user privacy and execute commands efficiently emerges as an essential
research imperative. In this paper, we propose CoGenesis, a collaborative
generation framework integrating large (hosted on cloud infrastructure) and
small models (deployed on local devices) to address privacy concerns logically.
Initially, we design a pipeline to create personalized writing instruction
datasets enriched with extensive context details as the testbed of this
research issue. Subsequently, we introduce two variants of CoGenesis based on
sketch and logits respectively. Our experimental findings, based on our
synthesized dataset and two additional open-source datasets, indicate that: 1)
Large-scale models perform well when provided with user context but struggle in
the absence of such context. 2) While specialized smaller models fine-tuned on
the synthetic dataset show promise, they still lag behind their larger
counterparts. 3) Our CoGenesis framework, utilizing mixed-scale models,
showcases competitive performance, providing a feasible solution to privacy
issues.
|
[
-0.1596109271,
-0.9290381074,
0.5074269176,
0.1931550652,
0.363048315,
0.0529645942,
-0.3566709757,
-0.3279375136,
-0.0895298496,
0.725032866,
-0.6751295924,
-0.8768139482,
-0.225683853,
-0.2817408741,
-0.4746787548,
0.7608721256,
0.1004713848,
-0.1132943854,
-0.7347654104,
0.1425331384,
-0.4199465811,
-0.6628968716,
-0.5229827762,
0.1143723801,
0.3219688535,
0.8091961145,
0.5800858736,
1.0498605967,
0.437918961,
0.2870522439,
0.151703164,
-0.0098550441,
-0.5158597827,
0.3572664857,
-0.3356588483,
-0.1780259907,
-0.5014883876,
-0.1213817522,
0.2983149886,
0.9084845781,
-0.2321995497,
0.0347986519,
0.1969896555,
0.2884340584,
-0.5836862922,
-0.0180547331,
-0.4412786663,
0.2555264235,
-0.0482311547,
0.0318972431,
-0.7268375754,
-0.2691761851,
0.5192893744,
-0.5883933306,
0.6774257421,
0.2459085882,
0.264010936,
0.0058179586,
-0.2496291995,
-0.6775156856,
-0.5022979975,
1.0310637951,
-0.4244958162,
0.3739539385,
0.3301035166,
0.339617461,
-0.3622795641,
-1.1910965443,
-0.2849089503,
-0.1113822758,
-0.1661448181,
-0.1467414349,
0.2491248995,
0.1348655224,
0.0417416245,
0.4452064633,
-0.5016462803,
0.3914147317,
-0.328410238,
-0.5179874301,
0.7138340473,
0.2954320014,
0.4903028309,
0.1956104785,
-0.3668697178,
-0.1081377938,
-1.1185035706,
0.1906619072,
0.3169028461,
0.5460643768,
-0.6464500427,
0.3494009972,
-0.15798226,
0.6650888324,
0.1622397453,
0.0825047791,
-0.3219335973,
-0.3458871245,
-0.3188980818,
0.212654531,
0.8646791577,
0.1641539484,
-0.318688035,
-0.3557543457,
0.3408267796,
-0.0375234075,
0.0582201444,
-1.1734565496,
-0.2828498185,
0.2972552776,
-0.1285175681,
-0.3973334134,
-0.1035355404,
-0.9847952724,
-0.64138937,
-0.139971301,
0.1436077058,
-0.0970849916,
0.2334415466,
0.1023422033,
0.257776916,
-0.2278762609,
0.3107553124,
-1.4202799797,
0.5470144153,
0.9984144568,
0.695669651,
-0.1687125713,
-0.1913815886,
-0.6217191219,
0.2939706147,
-0.2252097577,
-0.0279340427,
-0.5820160508,
-0.6497202516,
0.1720080227,
0.095535934,
-0.1723487824,
-0.2618334591,
0.3865554333,
-0.4427453876,
0.6300597787,
-0.2367452085,
-0.838926971,
-0.0334308371,
0.0482027568,
-0.6252604723,
0.5858772397,
0.1429833621,
-0.6983553767,
0.3299637139,
-0.7465363145,
-0.3563318849,
0.230080694,
-0.4865460396,
-0.5754502416,
-0.0043992666,
-0.0684797317,
0.8237792253,
-0.3241546452,
0.5053036213,
-0.3226129115,
-0.3296069801,
-0.0052861939,
-0.0466013998,
0.7727709413,
0.1780298352,
-0.5725782514,
0.1078016832,
-0.801700592,
0.160299629,
-0.1262811124,
-0.1115574688,
-0.4456034899,
0.0286623891,
-0.4306682348,
0.1172862574,
0.4778115153,
-0.6699620485,
-0.0205595996,
-0.2976225317,
0.5785142183,
0.4319054186,
0.1362451166,
0.9694988728,
-0.1271384805,
0.4235073924,
0.0971026272,
0.1685839444,
-0.4650847018,
-0.5162391663,
-0.526707232,
-0.3815428019,
0.0349178314,
0.2434453368,
-0.3342508972,
0.5285331607,
-0.2104860693,
-0.3485313058,
-0.2656389177,
0.3608961701,
0.5240126252,
0.7178809047,
0.2557917237,
-0.2504478097,
-0.6313249469,
-0.83318609,
-0.2150937766,
0.3792834282,
0.2293754071,
0.5974786878,
0.2689567208,
-0.3492811322,
1.0226900578,
-0.4171824455,
-0.1879312992,
-0.0062873671,
-0.0239516851,
-0.2006634772,
0.9019091725,
0.3612570167,
-0.6318051815,
-0.7663853765,
0.0432352573,
-0.8365260363,
0.0755543783,
0.0653210878,
-0.2322909683,
-0.0555132851,
0.6862000227,
-0.0938034281,
0.3230771422,
1.079431653,
-0.4542863667,
0.0208578464,
-0.2914812863,
-0.1941661686,
-1.3976713419,
-0.1132678986,
-0.1787809432,
-0.3533267379,
-0.6951463223,
0.4255224168,
0.0018957549,
-0.5016493201,
-0.438944757,
0.5811642408,
-0.4145216048,
0.0895186439,
-0.0240209363,
0.0198324304,
0.1541221142,
0.2309737206,
0.1757470369,
0.9830546379,
0.602429986,
-0.4990049005,
-0.0136625804,
0.1189758927,
-0.3488581777,
0.100280337,
-0.4800871611,
0.5804072022,
0.4225394726,
0.1425075084,
-0.3616129458,
-0.8070327044,
0.0829830468,
0.0035079916,
0.1160701066,
0.0098909205,
-0.5450726151,
-0.0856470093,
-0.2229524851,
0.1334971786,
0.397908181,
-0.7732877135,
0.3954130709,
0.538068831,
-0.2216629535,
-0.3839250505,
-0.6471697688,
0.0502830781,
-0.1733450741,
-1.0847450495,
0.5640404224,
-0.1761588752,
-0.2361870557,
-0.0134932911,
0.3816249669,
-0.2252531201,
0.2284062952,
0.6128445268,
0.022796372,
-0.3498527408,
-0.1506402493,
0.6434562206,
0.1714588851,
-0.102566801,
-0.2370304018,
0.4721753895,
-0.1731680781,
-0.1933732331,
-0.4643436968,
0.4586532712,
0.3904823661,
-0.0927391797,
1.1240150928,
0.4589340389,
-0.398216486,
-0.6236888766,
-0.1696484685,
-0.3320506513,
-0.573274374,
0.0222200695,
-0.0654140785,
-1.4842785597,
0.5105417371,
-0.1376114637,
0.0139386524,
-0.0435774773,
0.7600804567,
0.098129645,
0.9423653483,
0.952062428,
0.3584600389,
0.4727444351,
-0.3163184822,
0.2527225316,
-0.750728786,
-0.3390958011,
-0.2975494862,
-0.14614214,
-0.592757225,
-0.5015336275,
0.241319105,
0.0854545236,
-0.1348661035,
0.526078105,
-0.6699430346,
0.4638609588,
0.6197812557,
0.0796078816,
0.1790366918,
0.0513820983,
-0.4408421218,
-0.2008057535,
-0.7032707334,
-0.6782733202,
1.1554875374,
0.306655705,
0.6273406148,
0.1887635738,
1.1974279881,
0.1283997744,
0.3840641975,
-0.3537070155,
0.6635289788,
-0.3105440736,
-0.9856581092,
-0.2808284461,
-0.3944262266,
-0.8628525138,
0.058319252,
-0.1508390903,
-1.0873857737,
0.4172975421,
0.34082973,
-0.7263252139,
-0.0684325472,
-1.2505396605,
1.2061607838,
-0.0934452042,
-1.4228497744,
-0.1104582325,
-0.5864691138,
0.5045385957,
-0.1677368283,
0.4489136338,
0.3106397092,
-0.0304089785,
0.5990310907,
-0.772379458,
1.1666003466,
-0.4227018952,
-0.1860054135,
0.679557085,
0.2281689793,
0.4870437682,
0.1006014198,
-0.1047682986,
-0.1894107014,
0.0483049154,
-0.0904133618,
-0.4071888328,
1.2358279228,
-0.5632500648,
-0.5738381147,
-0.0155356647,
-0.6274480224,
-0.2671944797,
0.374083966,
0.4253618419,
0.431671232,
-0.378338635,
0.8573542237,
0.6049541831,
-0.4123614132,
0.4870783389,
0.2572957575,
-0.2602475882,
-0.1662400961,
0.9361297488,
0.0403739624,
0.1863250434,
0.1961150169,
0.4710355401,
-0.2676530778,
-0.5003579855,
-0.5354648232,
-0.2052102238,
-0.5474517941,
0.1028469428,
-0.6100649238,
-0.0920226425,
-0.430603981,
-0.5456107259,
-0.3394972086,
-0.3096726239,
-0.3440458477,
0.0099591194,
0.0892458409,
0.4236558974,
-0.0097848857,
0.7365849614,
-0.8219002485,
-0.1381271631,
0.2832833529,
0.3820756376,
0.0453809053,
-0.1192098632,
-0.5787438154,
0.1637800336,
-0.4704191685,
-0.4599413574,
0.4176540077,
0.2470783591,
0.1788242459,
0.1725814342,
-0.0431476273,
0.4576636553,
-0.4362299144,
0.7783611417,
0.0169227328,
-0.9458306432,
0.2793478966,
-0.5896142125,
-0.074404344,
0.7835832238,
0.1526465863,
-0.3750343919,
-0.1695357263,
-0.7514223456,
-0.7254741192,
0.6712452769,
0.0604230464,
0.3322886229,
0.2832371891,
0.3517584801,
0.4191920757,
0.3652333915,
-0.5227182508,
0.1569787413,
0.0355622843,
-0.6169631481,
0.0638415515,
0.013599026,
-0.2901366651,
-0.162991792,
0.2310032845,
-0.0323051438,
0.0495774262,
0.0008320755,
-0.0312056094,
-0.0897048041,
0.2452573627,
0.5648441911,
0.3437850177,
-0.0555467643,
-0.0201440472,
-0.1480613798,
-0.7147156,
0.1001236737,
-0.0491692536,
-0.4582004249,
-0.388232708,
0.3242438734,
0.560299933,
0.4544809759,
-0.5787899494,
0.706213057,
-0.2837911248,
-0.04595723,
-0.3525105715,
0.5866938233,
0.3935628533,
-0.0557546243,
-0.1797261238,
0.0683864951,
0.213007763,
-0.6838925481,
0.2587741911,
0.1574459076,
-0.3321068585,
-0.5895759463,
0.6762799025,
0.4714337587,
-0.4093045294,
0.167168662,
-0.2967099547,
-0.2502942085,
0.6583246589,
0.6733778119,
0.82924366,
-0.2473155856,
0.1757427603,
0.2898104489,
-0.0658249706,
-0.1606781185,
0.0958665535,
-0.1895949543,
-0.556596458,
-0.1240219772,
-0.5010445118,
-0.5864524245,
0.1850357503,
-0.5093237162,
0.2071492672,
-1.0183980465,
0.0036448808,
-0.2261469662,
0.0294144135,
-0.689620316,
0.4200503826,
-0.026302781,
0.5919030309,
-0.654559195,
0.9025548697,
0.422473073,
-0.0383492894,
-0.8454558849,
-0.2368978262,
0.2040721476,
-0.4092035592,
0.4098840058,
0.3332936168,
-0.195978418,
0.2240050137,
-0.6406146288,
-0.600043714,
1.202493906,
0.2824049294,
-1.0290436745,
-0.1493616849,
0.2049205303,
0.8032273054,
-0.8636462688,
-0.5650980473,
0.2108103633,
-0.043255724,
-0.010503754,
-0.3147480786,
0.1551716179,
0.1594426036,
-0.3255177736,
-0.2175578177,
-0.646476984,
0.9951016307,
-0.1390141249,
-0.3130214512,
0.4027091861,
0.5517753959,
0.2713856697,
0.6716150045,
0.0513153821,
0.4016402364,
0.8712569475,
0.1222370639,
1.1532299519,
-0.7110951543,
0.2581110299,
1.4148974419,
-0.2928003967,
0.8334684372,
0.2833639681,
0.2584376633,
0.6806896329,
0.384208858,
0.3247567415,
0.5998401046,
0.1103579476,
-0.4798561037,
0.0461042114,
-0.1690412909,
-0.3281715512,
0.3568728864,
0.5584856272,
-0.7305882573,
0.0864663795,
-0.1694941819,
0.2330324948,
0.4908860624,
-0.0972888544,
0.646494031,
0.351854831,
-0.7570205927,
0.1786294132,
0.277930975,
0.3991846144,
-0.3154598176,
0.2275091857,
-0.1366980225,
0.3935073018,
-0.3382350504,
-0.3786770403,
0.33967188,
0.202980414,
-0.066480048,
-0.3210754991,
0.6954208612,
-0.622659862,
-0.2898139358,
0.2378452271,
0.3664228022,
-0.3364440799,
0.4657846093,
-0.3790130615,
0.262573421,
-0.2057894617,
0.0476603694,
0.4416535497,
0.3253110647,
-0.2491688132,
0.367731452,
0.6603210568,
-0.1433138698,
0.3202888966,
-0.0086456295,
0.6758030057,
-0.377024591,
-0.6767272353,
-0.8623934984,
0.4243257046,
-0.2623826861,
-0.1081639975,
1.0345598459,
0.7320383191,
0.8027907014,
-0.070236139,
0.8373794556,
-0.0753463134,
0.5840883255,
-0.4073559344,
0.9188765287,
-0.2508793771,
0.3073471189,
-0.1425135881,
-0.7014645338,
-0.3077335358,
0.4386553764,
-0.599873662,
0.05391372,
0.578541398,
0.9263513088,
-0.2767465115,
0.3995608389,
0.2344010174,
-0.0333898365,
0.4551579058,
0.4531209171,
0.7041056752,
-0.3364147842,
-0.0374549143,
-0.6597834826,
-0.175208196,
-0.3106321692,
-0.9654439688,
-1.0548868179,
-0.5005122423,
-0.2362971306,
-0.1833282262,
-0.045541551,
0.8974109292,
1.0924860239,
-0.8332256675,
-0.2996969521,
-0.6275955439,
-0.1269178241,
0.2258215547,
-0.1659209877,
0.3628111482,
-0.0686829314,
-0.746445775,
0.6151596308,
0.175738886,
0.1723453254,
-0.4611381292,
-0.210005179,
0.1992642879,
0.1305866688,
0.4523866773,
0.3641960323,
-0.2276203483,
-0.396553129,
0.1815038323,
-0.435235858,
-0.2267006189,
1.0017619133,
-0.426561892,
0.7281779051,
0.4722015858,
0.8092874885,
0.4025767446,
0.0316274092,
0.7498654127,
-1.040071249,
0.3943199813,
0.1546823084,
0.1761405915,
0.7355310917,
-0.714107275,
0.2655788958,
0.1466476172,
-0.5400979519,
-0.9047548771,
0.2871786952,
-0.6622282267,
0.0009121611,
0.6573340893,
-0.5012351274,
-0.5166174173,
0.0536994785,
0.0079885488,
0.0985417962,
-0.3481651843,
0.7765541077,
0.5911339521,
0.0223225374,
0.0157290567,
-0.3243560493,
0.670371294,
0.328584224,
-0.9114894271,
0.097281456,
0.5024724603,
0.0117165036,
0.3287105262,
0.3992019892,
-0.0912791789,
0.2359486669,
0.2444078475,
-0.2579933405,
-0.3387244642,
-0.6504257321,
-0.1933343709,
0.3667750061,
-0.0766497925,
-0.0037468069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03121v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03121v3
|
Angry Men, Sad Women: Large Language Models Reflect Gendered Stereotypes in Emotion Attribution
| 2024-03-05T17:04:05 | 2024-05-28T14:43:52 |
Flor Miriam Plaza-del-Arco, Amanda Cercas Curry, Alba Curry, Gavin Abercrombie, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) reflect societal norms and biases, especially
about gender. While societal biases and stereotypes have been extensively
researched in various NLP applications, there is a surprising gap for emotion
analysis. However, emotion and gender are closely linked in societal discourse.
E.g., women are often thought of as more empathetic, while men's anger is more
socially accepted. To fill this gap, we present the first comprehensive study
of gendered emotion attribution in five state-of-the-art LLMs (open- and
closed-source). We investigate whether emotions are gendered, and whether these
variations are based on societal stereotypes. We prompt the models to adopt a
gendered persona and attribute emotions to an event like 'When I had a serious
argument with a dear person'. We then analyze the emotions generated by the
models in relation to the gender-event pairs. We find that all models
consistently exhibit gendered emotions, influenced by gender stereotypes. These
findings are in line with established research in psychology and gender
studies. Our study sheds light on the complex societal interplay between
language, gender, and emotion. The reproduction of emotion stereotypes in LLMs
allows us to use those models to study the topic in detail, but raises
questions about the predictive use of those same LLMs for emotion applications.
|
[
-0.2480156273,
-0.3510180712,
0.323695451,
0.5023670197,
0.1246282086,
0.173138991,
-0.0664325058,
-0.452852428,
0.1370372176,
0.2674724162,
-0.6473134756,
-0.3085330725,
-0.6455543041,
0.3849929273,
-0.5023620725,
0.5994418263,
-0.0934142023,
0.2271574587,
-0.1801474243,
-0.2381454408,
-0.0887573883,
-1.0099709034,
-0.4800585806,
-0.5066201091,
0.8649988174,
0.0276282299,
0.4918552041,
0.057155937,
0.5275454521,
0.309938997,
-0.2159656137,
-0.0570898056,
-0.6383671761,
0.264538765,
-0.1209260076,
-0.4196029305,
-0.4894654751,
0.3272803724,
0.2386215478,
0.4684873521,
-0.2070972323,
0.1665783226,
-0.0666144416,
0.8709819317,
-0.6364651322,
0.2913338542,
-0.3988609016,
0.3037509322,
-0.0871651694,
-0.1091340855,
-0.3277271688,
-0.6447656155,
0.1843676418,
0.1859300584,
-0.0153907361,
0.2311426401,
0.5982288718,
0.1221119463,
-0.8029683232,
-0.5507708192,
-0.5142421722,
0.9114800096,
-0.6626957655,
0.2664533556,
-0.0752536207,
0.0339060836,
-0.1486742198,
-0.1447438151,
-0.4139874578,
-0.2007489502,
0.0602804162,
0.0625603721,
-0.7533054352,
-0.1000895053,
0.1192507148,
0.2218478769,
-0.2386203408,
0.0591236465,
-0.3379623592,
0.2633543611,
0.6649061441,
0.1968361139,
0.514316678,
-0.4272120893,
-0.1665717959,
0.2221813202,
-0.6683213115,
-0.3692203164,
0.6501988769,
0.3669497967,
-0.308811605,
0.651499331,
0.2979517281,
0.2660307288,
0.0834978968,
0.0528786555,
0.2412646562,
0.3141205609,
-0.1058915034,
0.2349868715,
1.0038878918,
0.5300875306,
0.7805294991,
0.0398532562,
-0.265519768,
0.1944945902,
0.451380372,
-0.5188750029,
0.0865358189,
0.1633218527,
-0.452906996,
-0.5773686767,
-0.4877697527,
-0.9484369755,
-0.8937969208,
-0.0510891937,
0.0636948869,
0.0952484608,
-0.374204874,
0.0012394304,
-0.2441985309,
0.1467954814,
0.158268109,
-0.7714393139,
0.2354596257,
0.7002266645,
0.8409343362,
0.1292728484,
0.0840745717,
0.0898700878,
0.0341851413,
-0.5170650482,
0.5254929662,
-0.6790192127,
-0.2548286617,
0.3309126496,
-0.09905947,
0.1016375497,
-0.4890334308,
0.5133769512,
-0.1765241325,
0.3407852054,
-0.4150337577,
-0.3378465176,
-0.2113625109,
0.3299484849,
-0.5471909642,
0.8715206981,
-0.0772914067,
-0.8079276681,
0.0060413498,
-0.6521276236,
-0.0318431631,
-0.307194382,
-0.4753499627,
-0.2125083506,
0.5748159885,
-0.1363108307,
0.4632228613,
-0.8235617876,
0.3364967406,
-0.6358867288,
0.1307784021,
0.192353636,
0.0345821232,
0.6259716749,
0.1472456753,
-0.3386677206,
0.3021097183,
-0.2924070358,
-0.6050715446,
0.4735904932,
-0.1562850922,
-0.4699694514,
0.3223689497,
-0.0855705589,
0.2612704635,
0.0735844448,
-0.6430668235,
-0.0582682341,
-0.234259516,
0.4903007448,
0.9400879145,
-0.4122995436,
0.3986179531,
-0.0569927543,
0.6859166622,
0.0688918307,
0.0658585504,
0.3288419545,
-0.3838539422,
-0.6441860199,
-0.0784031749,
-0.2053881139,
0.5012052655,
-0.1969336271,
0.1787910312,
0.2215512395,
-0.6305918694,
-0.4356487691,
-0.2513321042,
0.4309996367,
0.2151424736,
-0.1516148746,
-0.0846152753,
-0.6672116518,
-0.9514693022,
-0.7012620568,
-0.4617030621,
0.0502503999,
0.6115291119,
0.3196420968,
-0.1876921654,
0.888263464,
-0.6075210571,
-0.146900773,
-0.3852937222,
0.6498826742,
-0.0998182744,
0.2443367988,
0.8330961466,
-0.3827403486,
-0.1344731748,
-0.2308750153,
-0.9169806838,
-0.4997729957,
0.3922501206,
-0.134225592,
0.3655851185,
0.3241068721,
-0.3324443996,
0.007309427,
0.8581824899,
-0.4123028219,
0.6194142103,
0.1026168168,
0.2303921431,
-0.7893257737,
-0.2246842086,
0.2935132086,
-0.0232469644,
-0.4353640079,
-0.1089527905,
-0.0514590964,
-0.3616327047,
-0.6575693488,
0.5997780561,
-0.6145524979,
-0.2793751657,
0.0669738948,
-0.0256347358,
-0.1460972726,
0.0245907921,
-0.0024337303,
0.3101585209,
0.3779323101,
-0.2553401589,
0.4607534409,
0.2123520374,
-0.1229101196,
0.5133017302,
-0.4193231761,
0.2143938392,
-0.4631077051,
0.2343091071,
-1.0108265877,
-0.3259597123,
0.210974142,
-0.3317394555,
0.1171110347,
-0.0182229597,
-0.3311576545,
-0.4355898798,
-0.2216712236,
0.3418598473,
0.4971503615,
-0.2957803309,
1.0659244061,
0.3966216445,
-0.2779301405,
-0.4491834342,
-0.5749368668,
0.225618735,
-0.3385121822,
-0.5372672677,
-0.4571835101,
0.0370582081,
-0.7920145988,
-0.3580374122,
0.115104951,
-0.1466501504,
-0.0438059047,
0.4443620741,
-0.025800392,
-0.1368377656,
0.227065146,
0.0386336111,
0.200167805,
0.4618427753,
0.4396861792,
0.6686918736,
-0.4532413185,
-0.2356904447,
-0.2026067227,
0.5344355106,
0.7227488756,
0.0567408018,
0.9135496616,
0.512902081,
-0.6453154087,
0.091130577,
-0.3943018317,
-0.1357263476,
-0.4051506221,
0.4737877548,
-0.2910610437,
-1.0169380903,
0.6086320281,
-0.186286822,
0.0831566975,
0.4581196308,
0.6486594677,
-0.4056907594,
1.1780165434,
0.6085231304,
-0.4399690926,
0.4301918745,
0.2001651675,
0.2378161252,
-0.6749245524,
-0.1191484928,
-0.9638893604,
-0.6058287621,
-0.6715514064,
-0.2187174112,
0.0659128875,
-0.3161604404,
-0.4492433071,
-0.3788698912,
-0.0404499918,
0.2320938706,
-0.0310086906,
-0.1660975367,
0.0252268612,
-0.2647972703,
0.4150273502,
-0.4437833726,
-0.5669384599,
-0.6107194424,
0.8306718469,
0.5711608529,
1.039413929,
0.4135231078,
0.5378032327,
0.5036649108,
0.5860872865,
-0.7776145935,
0.5475811958,
-0.6106706262,
-1.0372979641,
0.1293413937,
-0.4824652374,
-0.6921917796,
0.0265098214,
-0.040560212,
-1.0331531763,
0.4155838192,
0.3615969419,
0.0978775844,
0.3999493718,
-0.4832918346,
0.7721806169,
-0.0815976709,
-0.0808384418,
-0.1161909625,
-0.467076242,
0.9975742698,
-0.0548817478,
0.4784204066,
-0.4659526646,
0.1868764609,
0.6851658225,
-0.2674839199,
1.0489215851,
0.0197761524,
-0.6075604558,
-0.0855506063,
0.3496181965,
0.3982810378,
-0.4775569737,
-0.2558379471,
0.3264628947,
-0.4311349988,
-0.1670299172,
-0.22043477,
0.7336299419,
-0.8499386907,
-0.5110802054,
-0.4793381393,
-0.5997313857,
0.1083051637,
-0.3163891137,
-0.0810363293,
0.4712670147,
-0.1606473476,
-0.0276098121,
0.7227823138,
-0.7396503091,
0.0077622165,
0.3461133242,
-0.5629859567,
-0.0876360983,
0.6282965541,
-0.1788999736,
0.4775778353,
0.2132650912,
0.5147660971,
-0.0596791543,
0.1380033791,
-0.2531826496,
0.3795281649,
-0.8308069706,
0.0180158131,
-0.7389674783,
0.0971144289,
-0.5349379778,
-0.4037494659,
-0.9851213098,
0.0277493987,
-0.4362339675,
0.1095431745,
0.4215481579,
0.8482778072,
0.0774747357,
0.2437719852,
-0.8175795078,
0.2929384112,
0.217388764,
0.2293074131,
-0.0144940121,
-0.4265599847,
0.4836194813,
-0.3559809029,
0.058756046,
-1.3233121634,
0.676903069,
0.3227852583,
0.0328919925,
0.5426379442,
0.3121637702,
0.3598633409,
-0.33858639,
0.9204387665,
0.3504222333,
-1.0389155149,
0.2214214951,
-0.5012540221,
0.0251975656,
-0.1110971123,
0.476085186,
-0.9380102158,
-0.6323506832,
-0.4072169363,
-0.8702999949,
0.7906447053,
-0.1723026186,
0.4677260518,
-0.2614685297,
0.438218981,
0.0761684701,
0.2691331506,
-0.7208600044,
-0.489915967,
0.1695727557,
-0.6516867876,
-0.1559082717,
-0.6649894118,
-0.1774422824,
0.0924540758,
0.3544911444,
0.055876933,
0.6057595611,
-0.1247630417,
-0.1129692942,
-0.3544476628,
0.3922204673,
0.4577876031,
0.2582947314,
-0.525775671,
0.2882866561,
-0.0216552094,
-0.1882388294,
0.4056748152,
-0.3314400315,
0.1111184508,
0.1530890614,
0.2043611407,
0.9844790697,
0.4258079529,
-0.8235881925,
0.6265655756,
-0.1232693568,
-0.2442525029,
-0.369617939,
-0.2733128667,
0.4393765032,
0.8621024489,
0.0797382891,
-0.1628709882,
0.2900185287,
-1.0501798391,
-0.5231210589,
0.4891591668,
-0.6997475624,
-0.315125078,
0.5960707068,
0.3760674298,
-0.281933248,
0.4553512633,
-0.1459644586,
-0.9335536957,
0.5679988861,
0.5823625922,
1.0643894672,
-0.2461734116,
0.1864680201,
0.3767204285,
0.4487228394,
-0.0843928605,
0.6554843187,
0.6621305943,
-0.7117277384,
-0.0439101756,
-0.6466787457,
-0.5659840107,
-0.0365131646,
-0.5458475351,
0.1817640215,
-0.4068274498,
-0.2039841712,
-0.3123302758,
-0.3158377111,
-0.5557752848,
0.0652200878,
0.7311483026,
0.822824955,
-1.1768027544,
0.1485523582,
0.8175831437,
-0.0301463958,
-0.657854259,
-0.1944193244,
0.5150611401,
-0.5440573692,
0.9052072763,
0.1273770332,
-0.2392147332,
0.0348050706,
-0.6443861723,
-0.6259680986,
0.5242393017,
0.5241938829,
-0.6916392446,
0.0782651305,
0.1073557809,
0.3624067903,
-0.5323946476,
0.5646867156,
0.4961672127,
0.4582127631,
-0.1173380986,
-0.8081862926,
-0.0505425781,
-0.102722533,
-0.1219328418,
0.384155333,
-0.7213914394,
1.0511223078,
-0.031223489,
-0.0820293725,
-0.2683760822,
0.7647161484,
0.3573117256,
0.2148922235,
0.6193750501,
0.2120994478,
0.6677185297,
-0.2812033892,
1.0338090658,
0.126975432,
0.1473371238,
0.8777577877,
-0.4731904268,
0.7081456184,
0.3596758246,
-0.4199305475,
0.4664483666,
0.5604985952,
0.3257791996,
-0.0330225006,
0.6671327353,
-0.3023029566,
-0.150889203,
-0.3029730618,
-0.1806522906,
0.6400862336,
0.3281268179,
-0.5772637129,
-0.1428314,
-0.0473378189,
0.2002224773,
-0.1581398994,
-0.5097076297,
0.6490741968,
0.3419073224,
0.0449635312,
0.2338669449,
-0.0098164538,
0.7780979276,
-0.6165266633,
0.3769767582,
-0.373645097,
0.0945817381,
-0.2789592445,
-0.5027908683,
0.1465693414,
0.5457181334,
-0.4106683135,
0.0197628736,
0.7801686525,
-0.5275938511,
-0.434037149,
0.4330784976,
0.480324626,
0.6129714847,
-0.3582290113,
-0.5267980099,
0.1955507547,
0.078148447,
-0.5835236907,
0.5920333862,
0.4911673069,
-0.1555078179,
0.840292573,
0.1858726144,
-0.04261766,
0.1839462966,
0.5118016601,
0.6143516898,
-0.9042392969,
0.0332925282,
-0.9702966809,
0.5029047132,
0.1426452249,
-0.1806337833,
0.2333845943,
0.1938929856,
0.1218695939,
-0.1840642393,
0.6713412404,
-0.0936676413,
0.4366585314,
-0.1287489384,
0.743729651,
-0.7810491323,
-0.0872093812,
-0.7879540324,
-0.9345539212,
-0.1582274735,
0.4506080449,
-0.3519735336,
-0.041082304,
0.4293615818,
0.4600652456,
0.3423149288,
0.1843199581,
0.1011419669,
0.4013858736,
0.5035264492,
0.4597242177,
1.2158581018,
-0.1234603748,
0.2870415449,
0.0297142938,
-0.2536317408,
-0.3842939138,
-1.3061349392,
-0.61412853,
-0.1531791091,
-0.5708572268,
-0.0401730835,
0.0363341831,
1.1693800688,
0.0033460504,
-0.3962824047,
-0.4570529461,
0.3448321521,
0.1208827496,
0.2222907692,
-0.2158557773,
-0.0049739033,
-0.1843135804,
-0.8838854432,
0.0242677517,
0.2134440988,
-0.1426716149,
-0.3588356674,
-0.1710781157,
-0.1039418429,
0.4638618529,
0.7249484062,
-0.0370277576,
-0.77663064,
-0.4067754149,
-0.2946757376,
-0.1354960054,
-0.0746114925,
0.7086102962,
-0.2231778949,
0.2780990601,
0.5165794492,
0.1991760582,
-0.2479265779,
-0.2025184929,
0.9741200209,
-0.8573074341,
0.0169881824,
0.0847843364,
0.5917204618,
0.4968306124,
-0.2574816048,
0.3017394245,
0.1794782132,
-0.59744066,
-0.9478809834,
0.2600655556,
-0.8938544393,
-0.1398917735,
1.1554256678,
-0.2707750797,
-0.151839897,
0.3633643091,
-0.2916561961,
0.5828351378,
-0.7615662813,
0.9296764135,
0.9404867291,
-0.0849102736,
-0.3981126249,
-0.7053015828,
0.2936266661,
0.4102741778,
-0.8474746346,
0.5114730597,
0.7952350974,
-0.1460918039,
0.0359339118,
0.2401652634,
-0.1008034199,
-0.2513119876,
-0.0557651371,
0.7450072765,
0.3481784761,
-0.0741806701,
-0.3938960135,
0.2362062633,
-0.0123952134,
0.3355719745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03102v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03102v3
|
"In Dialogues We Learn": Towards Personalized Dialogue Without Pre-defined Profiles through In-Dialogue Learning
| 2024-03-05T16:43:03 | 2024-03-12T05:33:16 |
Chuanqi Cheng, Quan Tu, Wei Wu, Shuo Shang, Cunli Mao, Zhengtao Yu, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Personalized dialogue systems have gained significant attention in recent
years for their ability to generate responses in alignment with different
personas. However, most existing approaches rely on pre-defined personal
profiles, which are not only time-consuming and labor-intensive to create but
also lack flexibility. We propose In-Dialogue Learning (IDL), a fine-tuning
framework that enhances the ability of pre-trained large language models to
leverage dialogue history to characterize persona for completing personalized
dialogue generation tasks without pre-defined profiles. Our experiments on
three datasets demonstrate that IDL brings substantial improvements, with BLEU
and ROUGE scores increasing by up to 200% and 247%, respectively. Additionally,
the results of human evaluations further validate the efficacy of our proposed
method.
|
[
-0.5005750656,
-0.53669101,
0.6389442682,
-0.0964560583,
-0.0501964428,
0.764883697,
-0.1265475452,
-0.0624943189,
0.1212954074,
0.6273936629,
-0.8764238954,
-0.4651307464,
-0.1891135275,
-0.0114469966,
0.1785549223,
1.1162595749,
0.6010366678,
0.2394261509,
-0.1043050364,
-0.0632207319,
-0.6170963645,
-0.4014200568,
-0.8974613547,
-0.4236479104,
0.6192603111,
0.7497431636,
0.2292229086,
0.1642761678,
0.1780674756,
0.2765030861,
0.0199616496,
0.3865323067,
-0.6594281793,
0.2720216215,
-0.2826763093,
-0.3547081351,
-0.252472192,
0.0333241671,
0.6596392989,
1.0570129156,
0.0585358627,
0.1289274544,
0.3447961211,
0.8403481245,
-0.491227895,
0.2147372961,
-0.6283701062,
0.0116629535,
-0.0588935837,
-0.342387259,
-0.6835460067,
-0.6977004409,
0.5741159916,
-0.4016571343,
0.0258699525,
0.050975319,
0.6517802477,
0.0803429335,
-0.4340430498,
-0.1962458938,
-0.917473197,
0.6150508523,
-0.7247080207,
0.1675373763,
0.5197962523,
0.6415688396,
-0.2108291239,
-0.6516612768,
-0.2577908039,
-0.3894555867,
-0.3018209338,
0.1751751602,
0.1767616123,
0.325717926,
0.6096577048,
0.1194988266,
-0.4879180491,
0.1485982239,
-0.1518287063,
-0.1114463508,
0.6312711835,
0.5128750205,
0.0085360706,
0.2789262235,
-0.1685822308,
-0.1129356623,
-0.7911292911,
0.5692516565,
0.6299900413,
0.4716849029,
-0.1477452666,
0.0648090392,
-0.3347251117,
0.3177380562,
0.7548872232,
-0.3595128357,
0.1067456156,
-0.13343665,
-0.2877317965,
-0.0820461884,
0.7091341019,
0.1809546649,
0.418969214,
-0.312102288,
-0.0066619418,
-0.396261543,
0.0758128986,
-1.1353466511,
-0.4911115766,
-0.0106709823,
-0.3404321373,
-0.1872823536,
0.1054785848,
-0.8430057168,
-0.5935401917,
-0.5627605319,
0.3627120256,
-0.4227876365,
0.1136244759,
-0.1187703013,
-0.0025501722,
0.0160091855,
0.6383720636,
-0.9487106204,
0.4874053895,
0.1698327214,
0.4442431033,
-0.0779885575,
-0.0222421326,
-0.9021564722,
0.0207656175,
-0.2265233397,
0.5825837851,
-0.8034673333,
-0.5718861818,
0.0277108159,
-0.3246600628,
-0.0230790749,
-0.8393856287,
0.0892712697,
-0.0244609043,
0.3994240761,
-0.3375575244,
-0.699886322,
-0.1024519801,
0.1142915934,
-0.2014260143,
0.4245720804,
0.4794228375,
-0.261829406,
0.4327628314,
-0.7959315181,
-0.3720643818,
0.4601626396,
-0.1684140861,
-0.1837953776,
-0.0732871071,
0.1027364284,
0.4350686371,
-0.2717503309,
0.3536260426,
-0.2894378603,
-0.4549080729,
0.2966995537,
-0.2494828552,
0.7787172198,
0.0858658999,
-0.3672574461,
0.22024028,
-0.8038006425,
0.0765752792,
-0.2394658625,
-0.313965261,
-0.0638971776,
-0.0860382617,
-0.1811938137,
0.160772875,
0.1280684769,
-0.7368692756,
0.2119495422,
-0.853154242,
0.2280055583,
0.914114058,
0.082738094,
0.668874681,
-0.4484840333,
0.3924566805,
0.1977265477,
0.0740906447,
-0.7644932866,
-0.2052041143,
-0.8644902706,
-0.2998903096,
0.1181857511,
0.6095898747,
-0.5096054077,
0.6426335573,
-0.1147695929,
-0.5239101052,
-0.2236581147,
0.3475268781,
0.7591267824,
0.74687922,
0.1929844916,
-0.7206491828,
-0.474722296,
-0.8540450335,
-0.471093297,
-0.2323068827,
-0.1845591068,
0.6665289998,
0.1831617951,
-0.2853184342,
1.2081241608,
-0.5104156733,
-0.305655539,
-0.4894916415,
0.0627309456,
-0.0807803199,
0.4302345216,
0.3763896525,
-0.6090153456,
-1.1368923187,
0.1145885363,
-0.5335419774,
-0.0134086739,
-0.1782014072,
0.102540426,
-0.0938942581,
0.6197437048,
-0.3607872128,
0.5654761195,
-0.0380063392,
-0.2375670075,
0.2488800436,
-0.1976053417,
-0.0677188709,
-1.1160037518,
-0.1183404252,
0.192444697,
-0.5159703493,
-0.7916108966,
-0.4936241508,
-0.1245800778,
-0.3623533845,
-0.4155282378,
0.8948469162,
0.1769174784,
0.1816287637,
0.023992788,
0.0723033175,
0.0447951332,
1.125772357,
-0.1620263606,
0.4419669807,
0.2825546563,
-0.6036094427,
0.1564104557,
0.5150614977,
-0.4306269288,
0.8851581216,
-0.3555382192,
0.529632926,
-0.2726339996,
0.4476179779,
-1.0622662306,
-0.4966748059,
0.4645920098,
-0.1893951446,
0.4181429446,
-0.2346360087,
-0.1362029463,
0.1692844778,
-0.0846739039,
0.0444702879,
0.6233946681,
-0.6910313368,
0.6316866279,
0.3522713482,
-0.338748008,
-0.0505285151,
0.0359419286,
-0.0595684052,
-0.4889515638,
-0.3718417585,
0.2349820435,
-0.7489649653,
-0.3679762185,
-0.6706062555,
0.1139356196,
-0.2228092998,
0.0297214817,
0.4385332465,
-0.1346069127,
-0.0141766919,
0.2825077772,
0.0434001833,
-0.0290614106,
-0.3446071744,
-0.1812748313,
0.6050447226,
-0.0083540753,
-0.1030482724,
-0.9976443648,
0.3761209249,
0.5890045762,
-0.4205946922,
0.4189223349,
0.3571637571,
0.028522009,
-0.1700675488,
-0.5169020891,
-0.3719240725,
-0.536532402,
0.1451698542,
-0.3153848946,
-1.0429301262,
0.4311331809,
-0.5537303686,
0.2995293438,
-0.1898668259,
0.387729913,
-0.5846708417,
1.2703840733,
0.6395949125,
-0.0062141446,
0.7680658698,
0.0132665848,
0.4828908145,
-0.7032727599,
-0.3745404184,
-0.3166774213,
-0.548695147,
-0.4554309547,
0.2080640942,
0.4034339786,
-0.1925594807,
-0.7211757898,
0.1508250087,
-0.1951197535,
0.546366632,
0.5728262067,
0.2694778144,
0.0894085988,
-0.3000608087,
0.1501719654,
-0.3282176554,
-0.1586841941,
-0.3717200458,
1.0151234865,
0.1843191385,
0.7615198493,
0.1594092548,
0.8078317642,
0.2489535511,
0.1610662192,
-0.680182457,
0.6098357439,
-0.2046074718,
-0.2512026131,
-0.3428418934,
-0.302301228,
-1.0073634386,
0.0279755909,
-0.0283423364,
-1.2931329012,
0.0377891846,
0.4405555725,
-0.9084552526,
-0.0627944767,
-0.8726667762,
0.7443547845,
-0.3209246397,
-0.277071327,
-0.188336283,
-0.8554799557,
0.2136868089,
-0.1054464579,
-0.2747915983,
-0.2089496255,
0.498799473,
0.1997637004,
-0.2724456489,
1.18650949,
-0.357268095,
0.4092158079,
0.0449035577,
0.2176099122,
0.5077009201,
0.4054871798,
0.1828794628,
-0.4209466577,
-0.0666678846,
-0.2537695169,
-1.0559492111,
0.4276440144,
-0.5421309471,
-0.6406665444,
-0.0800403357,
-0.4285909832,
-0.6017423272,
0.0908547491,
0.3312332034,
0.7004963756,
-0.6178750396,
0.2719336748,
0.9506550431,
-0.3293500245,
0.4222716391,
0.650190115,
-0.1877553761,
-0.1805450618,
0.9228031635,
-0.1397830099,
0.3199116886,
0.5334528685,
0.3053567111,
-0.0768595561,
-0.3289968371,
-0.3645354509,
0.0831103995,
-0.5359150171,
-0.122209616,
-0.5594126582,
-0.2448271215,
-0.2837092876,
-0.0952885002,
-0.1765303761,
0.0404669717,
-0.4945528209,
0.1008053795,
-0.1209076867,
0.7956176996,
0.5778087378,
0.6447063088,
-0.7809707522,
0.0924808607,
0.6157018542,
0.1941388398,
-0.2197473794,
-0.5774571896,
-0.4198185503,
0.300768137,
-0.8189919591,
-0.5072537661,
0.4694469869,
0.7612689734,
0.4933516681,
0.6872909665,
-0.0285127796,
0.8503921628,
-0.6322852373,
0.6049627662,
0.0081587154,
-0.9830155969,
0.7675856948,
-0.3595070839,
0.6033650041,
0.9412648678,
0.3274953067,
-0.4708960354,
-0.2928374112,
-0.6949584484,
-0.3286809325,
0.5992591977,
-0.0952146724,
0.565398097,
0.2114731967,
0.5162339211,
0.3830097616,
0.2915089428,
-0.4121655822,
0.0117639545,
0.0585448332,
-0.1797839552,
-0.2992011309,
0.009380335,
-0.0335094854,
-0.5821631551,
0.4757225811,
-0.5217316747,
-0.2072217762,
-0.0364812091,
-0.1982356161,
-0.0968216285,
-0.0059960363,
0.5038635731,
0.6993945837,
-0.3342227936,
-0.5255283117,
0.0934138,
-0.1837329865,
-0.0410778783,
-0.3025729358,
-0.0461523756,
-0.1966935843,
-0.0714059621,
1.0574901104,
0.5796409845,
-0.9849110246,
0.5628219843,
-0.4093820751,
-0.035150636,
-0.7145922184,
0.3662367165,
-0.225026384,
0.4388887286,
0.0780062228,
0.2891081572,
0.0777222961,
-0.7137762904,
0.1608648449,
0.5241571069,
-0.7385006547,
-0.5452754498,
0.2511311769,
0.5742457509,
-0.700265348,
0.7237231731,
-0.2209673077,
-0.0842867121,
0.1734835804,
0.4226732552,
1.0801682472,
-0.374840498,
0.4542269409,
0.4172265828,
-0.3059257865,
0.1842387766,
-0.2413498312,
-0.3990381956,
-0.7728388309,
-0.1169503033,
-0.6183857322,
-0.6600068212,
0.3760021627,
-0.5520473123,
0.4240736663,
-0.9599635005,
0.0185181834,
0.0475088209,
0.059722282,
-0.7876333594,
0.1956780255,
-0.017099617,
0.6024338007,
-0.5987815857,
1.0161973238,
0.3485758603,
-0.2755342424,
-0.6663913131,
0.1829648763,
0.0598556027,
-0.1785584539,
0.8025083542,
0.3247841299,
-0.2995071709,
0.2150107026,
-0.5289240479,
-0.5557123423,
0.8759643435,
0.7758616805,
-0.6324673295,
-0.3381589353,
-0.0391517729,
0.6128774285,
-0.8328391314,
0.3205161095,
0.7566185594,
0.0474103652,
0.1663748622,
-0.8993943334,
-0.6285689473,
-0.2097310424,
-0.0876507238,
0.1129205301,
-0.7597853541,
0.7011518478,
-0.1053462327,
-0.2599538267,
0.3791104257,
0.3995364308,
-0.2440129369,
0.2754443586,
0.3931841552,
0.3570262194,
0.9891072512,
-0.0141825248,
0.9191507697,
-0.0537464283,
-0.0162869617,
1.4457689524,
-0.505020082,
0.4818261862,
0.1488182545,
0.0332379006,
0.7863432169,
0.6535074115,
0.2763974667,
0.6448910832,
0.1115132421,
-0.5262290239,
-0.5147964954,
0.0330721736,
0.3218032718,
0.7046213746,
0.6196972132,
-0.3511018157,
-0.0767752007,
0.2154901326,
-0.0884634703,
0.4970038235,
-0.1131897196,
1.2039852142,
0.0782927275,
-0.8050535321,
0.287735194,
-0.5595344305,
0.5217957497,
-0.7065797448,
-0.2494311929,
-0.5024340749,
0.3127132058,
0.0016375131,
-0.3942278624,
-0.0451969989,
-0.1636346877,
-0.1304439157,
-0.577023983,
0.4092409015,
-0.613016665,
-0.2224609554,
0.1572277695,
0.4873824716,
0.1527824253,
0.0222897418,
-0.4183096886,
-0.5613877773,
0.2610170245,
0.0760260746,
0.7743433714,
0.0701666176,
-0.028338043,
0.9262275696,
0.4382662177,
-0.3482005298,
-0.2748411298,
0.1767090708,
0.7583686113,
-0.4355504215,
-0.4834966063,
-0.8091944456,
0.8632288575,
-0.2398207933,
-0.649518609,
0.6260890365,
0.7032835484,
1.1710891724,
-0.0223350283,
0.9492634535,
0.3344171345,
0.9693852663,
-0.3163677752,
0.5111933351,
-0.3752245605,
0.2706436813,
-0.3332719505,
-0.9085436463,
-0.1295081973,
0.5112020969,
-0.0707147792,
-0.0209486913,
0.4630101621,
0.8811069131,
0.01454762,
0.0363194942,
0.6513212919,
-0.0044784704,
0.5801421404,
0.6012964249,
0.8461898565,
0.0053929701,
0.1860770285,
-0.3508558869,
-0.1975445598,
-0.2027966231,
-0.4439276755,
-1.428532958,
-0.9879211187,
-0.2605143487,
-0.1539385021,
0.145281136,
1.2370967865,
0.6666576862,
-0.6568161249,
-0.4695855379,
0.0527862273,
-0.1424094141,
0.1095372215,
-0.1277473271,
-0.0642825067,
-0.6432870626,
-1.1178461313,
0.7293024659,
0.6406618357,
0.0060428912,
-0.2806791961,
-0.4111868143,
0.1699573547,
0.2088714242,
0.5849014521,
0.5832129717,
-0.73824054,
-0.5243293643,
-0.0731049031,
-0.0319851078,
0.4405226111,
1.0811764002,
-1.048109889,
0.8056676388,
0.3450330198,
0.5289461613,
0.6083933711,
0.1714639664,
0.8461815715,
-0.8897086382,
0.2223291248,
0.5263944864,
0.1640131772,
0.4575555921,
-0.3460087776,
0.0753927678,
-0.0893497691,
-0.6158244014,
-0.6335634589,
0.7340810895,
-0.8021179438,
0.0820184425,
0.6155046821,
-0.4799785316,
0.3009103835,
-0.4307815433,
-0.5301134586,
0.0133797433,
-0.5523414016,
0.7246427536,
0.4520650208,
-0.6168401241,
-0.1952050924,
-0.2151496112,
0.9721031785,
0.2287117839,
-0.7899053097,
-0.1774546653,
0.2671197355,
0.2436231822,
0.0630851984,
0.7306447625,
0.2776694298,
0.2815797925,
-0.5659657121,
-0.3579077125,
0.2875356376,
-0.5245853066,
-0.1814176738,
-0.0357250758,
0.1947083771,
0.2298870981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03101v1
|
KnowAgent: Knowledge-Augmented Planning for LLM-Based Agents
| 2024-03-05T16:39:12 | 2024-03-05T16:39:12 |
Yuqi Zhu, Shuofei Qiao, Yixin Ou, Shumin Deng, Ningyu Zhang, Shiwei Lyu, Yue Shen, Lei Liang, Jinjie Gu, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated great potential in complex
reasoning tasks, yet they fall short when tackling more sophisticated
challenges, especially when interacting with environments through generating
executable actions. This inadequacy primarily stems from the lack of built-in
action knowledge in language agents, which fails to effectively guide the
planning trajectories during task solving and results in planning
hallucination. To address this issue, we introduce KnowAgent, a novel approach
designed to enhance the planning capabilities of LLMs by incorporating explicit
action knowledge. Specifically, KnowAgent employs an action knowledge base and
a knowledgeable self-learning strategy to constrain the action path during
planning, enabling more reasonable trajectory synthesis, and thereby enhancing
the planning performance of language agents. Experimental results on HotpotQA
and ALFWorld based on various backbone models demonstrate that KnowAgent can
achieve comparable or superior performance to existing baselines. Further
analysis indicates the effectiveness of KnowAgent in terms of planning
hallucinations mitigation. Code is available in
https://github.com/zjunlp/KnowAgent.
|
[
-0.2884384096,
-0.7326090336,
0.8190629482,
0.2291263044,
0.4216322601,
-0.0093785878,
-0.0487512574,
-0.4833339453,
0.683334291,
0.8291404843,
-0.5937103033,
-0.4706609547,
-0.1995137334,
-0.3459479809,
-0.1455595344,
0.6331444383,
-0.0962698683,
-0.1964227557,
0.0182280131,
-0.0626441166,
-0.5725200176,
-0.3703888953,
-0.6114597321,
-0.5591186285,
0.4811953902,
0.3667331338,
0.8934143782,
0.371157974,
0.2754860818,
0.3688363135,
0.1041247174,
0.625001967,
-0.3194681406,
0.4640538096,
-0.3639967144,
-0.1978226155,
-0.8310244679,
-0.5764965415,
0.1434866339,
0.5414347053,
-0.19176507,
-0.347102493,
-0.4825948775,
0.5655290484,
-0.6507778168,
0.3369384706,
-0.4922467172,
0.2436350137,
0.4469187558,
-0.1926497817,
-0.2213529795,
-0.1046987623,
0.3137750626,
-0.7094499469,
0.0730437785,
-0.0849753618,
0.1821811199,
0.6914249659,
-0.2060291916,
-0.3196392953,
-1.2627934217,
0.3328563869,
-0.3891595304,
0.3455542028,
0.4344025552,
0.6928324103,
-0.4736351669,
-0.708547771,
-0.5872815847,
-0.0795201585,
-0.0579386801,
0.0419779569,
-0.1573467851,
0.1815488189,
0.2942997515,
0.0198742002,
-0.6216900945,
-0.0572395548,
-0.1606655717,
-0.3189111948,
0.5653350949,
0.1621889323,
0.1971736997,
0.0688097849,
-0.5427209735,
0.0676357299,
-0.5935429335,
-0.0548440926,
-0.036716599,
0.1145700365,
0.2502484024,
0.6557898521,
-0.4435910881,
0.7395332456,
-0.1383348703,
0.005855835,
-0.1791715324,
0.1838784814,
-0.1957492679,
0.1578355283,
0.3315260112,
0.0903050601,
0.2908450663,
-0.383646071,
-0.526935041,
-0.2606077492,
0.3246036768,
-0.5683973432,
-0.6210234165,
0.4040875733,
0.3229365945,
-0.0048845378,
-0.3021029234,
-0.4947949648,
-0.7779580355,
-0.4031535983,
0.7999090552,
-0.7497691512,
-0.3247505426,
0.2600310445,
-0.0185465813,
0.4083587825,
0.5828776956,
-0.5695286989,
0.2252733856,
0.4593695104,
0.4346115589,
0.0989815518,
-0.7335605025,
-0.6123928428,
0.6555221081,
-0.4381793737,
1.2174246311,
-0.3872804344,
-0.2159544677,
0.0187756773,
-0.3300457299,
0.0838770121,
-0.4602063894,
0.2045305371,
-0.6499408484,
-0.2374800742,
-0.3699458539,
-0.4859593511,
-0.4118507206,
0.704533875,
-0.7818496823,
0.7447440624,
0.0813594088,
-0.3271594048,
0.2995869815,
-0.8447596431,
-0.5732578039,
0.2835645676,
-0.2787679136,
0.1603216827,
-0.3300270736,
0.4576279819,
0.5544855595,
0.2720406055,
0.2706146538,
0.1603273153,
-0.2139064819,
0.0812111422,
-0.0673993081,
0.1490913779,
0.0375245735,
-0.3428213,
0.5519378185,
-0.6699183583,
0.1289393753,
0.0629707947,
-0.1407404393,
-0.0564854555,
0.0996397659,
-0.4703548551,
0.2587129176,
0.4147158265,
-0.0016477972,
0.3639962077,
-0.5062712431,
-0.0154829985,
0.7004868984,
0.1158756912,
0.5511219501,
-0.6691996455,
0.6092849374,
-0.3258318603,
0.0331232809,
-0.0445451289,
-0.0398567729,
-1.0357350111,
-0.0363499485,
-0.2814303041,
0.5837945342,
-1.1260126829,
0.3176365793,
-0.232984066,
-0.8040869832,
0.1932105869,
-0.1277964562,
0.2359422892,
0.24347049,
0.4877588153,
0.2926589847,
-0.5001072288,
-0.4273224473,
-0.398452729,
-0.1963535398,
0.3416281641,
0.1191425994,
0.3757930696,
-0.2710016966,
1.0656969547,
-0.6027613282,
-0.5562802553,
-0.7454827428,
-0.0442861505,
-0.1561304778,
0.2032627016,
0.3191800416,
-0.6975212097,
-0.0635148883,
0.1216137707,
-0.8311288953,
0.0909275338,
-0.0966288894,
-0.1528447121,
0.0879452452,
0.5002074838,
-0.8952251077,
0.5761238337,
0.3300519586,
-0.5214651823,
0.7718369961,
-0.5940753818,
-0.1271151602,
-0.9427405596,
-0.0749866962,
-0.4103838503,
-0.2345301956,
-0.8921843767,
0.1077266186,
-0.1608080566,
-0.1392548233,
-0.5638154149,
0.8940638304,
-0.5383737683,
-0.3368073404,
-0.5339676738,
0.1185936332,
-0.1349304914,
0.714969337,
0.4010895491,
0.7996344566,
0.5266612768,
-0.9522144794,
0.4476815462,
0.3842892051,
-0.0547591262,
0.2348308116,
-0.4348931909,
0.156686008,
-0.0117730154,
0.1056443602,
-0.5510175228,
-0.5216143131,
0.1969976276,
-0.3169082701,
0.2584190965,
-0.0608445853,
-0.3375819027,
-0.2299934328,
0.0374209099,
0.1524537802,
0.1708168536,
-0.6210961938,
1.2018717527,
0.4685037136,
0.088367179,
-0.6853334308,
-0.5801293254,
0.0217632167,
0.0938151181,
-0.553386867,
0.0976678953,
-0.1437586546,
-0.4431607425,
-0.1056782305,
-0.2080658525,
-0.05579184,
-0.2619950473,
0.2926391363,
-0.2095338851,
0.2172224522,
0.4709431827,
0.0377837941,
-0.1690637767,
0.2566867471,
-0.4635140002,
0.7759227753,
0.046115756,
-0.4813740551,
0.1212089658,
0.1497488618,
0.5973518491,
-0.46042943,
0.5280070901,
0.3007175326,
-0.4250556827,
-0.6072424054,
-0.6165293455,
-0.266022563,
-0.4926606417,
0.4022698998,
-0.5231591463,
-0.6326751113,
0.5989941359,
-0.4033786356,
0.1372217834,
0.0364218317,
0.3978031874,
0.2821195722,
0.7384653687,
0.6376638412,
0.1908348054,
0.1947482526,
-0.492927134,
0.2940481901,
-0.4927280843,
-0.481462568,
-0.095415011,
-0.285679251,
-0.2625717521,
-0.9101220965,
0.4862601161,
-0.3406102657,
-0.335169822,
0.2343775779,
-0.2114713341,
0.5702486634,
0.2522293925,
0.0016069215,
0.3686178327,
-0.0294403099,
-0.085915193,
0.2554581463,
-0.7262302637,
-0.4958903491,
0.7444936633,
-0.0083693434,
0.8009636402,
0.1858858764,
0.674146533,
0.3887941241,
-0.0802242607,
-0.9106581211,
0.9785687327,
0.4723509252,
-0.4919497073,
-0.6832939386,
-0.1979795247,
-0.9236369133,
0.0726700723,
-0.0441524237,
-0.6436639428,
0.1288864166,
0.220099926,
-0.3963287473,
0.4863047898,
-0.5007467866,
0.5643347502,
-0.5164964795,
-0.3533146381,
-0.2155029327,
-0.3664449751,
0.0378026776,
0.0325739309,
0.0890621319,
-0.1556699574,
-0.1942977905,
0.5646129847,
-0.576529026,
0.7044151425,
-0.3471140265,
-0.2260023504,
0.4176096916,
0.5471944809,
1.1774584055,
-0.2010320276,
-0.0303998515,
-0.2921087444,
-0.3525079489,
-0.3876008093,
-0.795751214,
0.8651764393,
-0.6825873852,
-0.8041796088,
-0.2208318561,
-1.0521656275,
-0.4828495681,
0.2672502398,
0.0033695982,
0.259560883,
-0.3948430717,
-0.4966751933,
0.7262105346,
-0.2000364959,
0.4904932082,
0.8195735216,
-0.694062531,
-0.3419523537,
0.8705058694,
0.3194660544,
0.1449777037,
0.5389399529,
0.0902050883,
-0.0285090264,
-0.4976445138,
-0.1145552993,
0.2902100086,
-0.9502788186,
-0.0256443191,
-0.8094633222,
-0.4873397946,
-0.4411043525,
-0.3037739098,
-0.4819945693,
-0.5718506575,
0.2855788469,
-0.3179820478,
0.5400960445,
1.0727757215,
-0.1245001256,
0.3649244905,
-0.3558524251,
0.1675135195,
0.6744686365,
0.0320894346,
-0.1735564321,
-0.0307436623,
-0.1849736273,
-0.1822517514,
-0.1991966516,
-0.8477609754,
0.7359316945,
-0.1372382045,
0.7541302443,
0.4387020469,
0.3762796521,
0.6366913915,
-0.1743165255,
0.5287957191,
-0.3205960393,
-0.5024940372,
0.9009668231,
-0.4324341714,
0.4561982155,
0.3131430149,
0.2714663148,
-0.1813890338,
-0.4796808362,
-0.6564397812,
-0.7254319787,
0.5084810853,
0.3874084055,
-0.1607477069,
0.2387185097,
0.1387350261,
0.0880969465,
0.118431136,
-0.6121251583,
-0.100392282,
0.0650910661,
0.227580145,
0.0773285478,
-0.2120752782,
-0.1592596024,
-0.1131460369,
0.6147897243,
-0.2301625162,
0.3482483923,
0.4581750631,
-0.3575130105,
-0.1627533883,
0.1360609829,
0.7642151713,
0.9624418616,
-0.1880871207,
0.3735592067,
0.4246958792,
-0.5319638848,
0.0385326333,
0.2901957929,
-0.0653617159,
-0.2761153281,
0.3938916326,
0.5482177734,
0.1208496019,
-0.8903838396,
0.2008562386,
-0.0856816992,
-0.1828722954,
-0.9328605533,
0.4116221666,
-0.0446544141,
0.7376207709,
0.2542446256,
0.163292408,
0.0307757836,
-0.2520388067,
0.0232686382,
0.1837863326,
-0.7786804438,
-0.26872316,
0.2571473122,
0.1530951411,
-0.611163497,
0.019802399,
-0.2826550007,
-0.6746271253,
0.5321570039,
0.5150694847,
0.760979414,
-0.5282944441,
0.2150107473,
0.0655220896,
0.4720521271,
0.041350387,
0.6754751801,
-0.0980725512,
-0.9074705243,
-0.4473383427,
-0.2944454551,
-0.3238103092,
0.1652428359,
0.0167979803,
0.3262833655,
-0.4307744503,
0.1113747358,
-0.5631061792,
0.0215487741,
-0.6372429729,
0.0635924265,
-0.3127693832,
0.9484015703,
-0.4677118063,
0.6962984204,
1.1480237246,
-0.2867478728,
-1.2335532904,
0.2113250643,
-0.2137189358,
-0.8443239331,
0.3505334556,
0.1129846498,
-0.501665771,
0.1391236335,
-0.3389882147,
-0.9240394831,
1.4345149994,
0.3129672408,
-0.3656433523,
-0.1692340672,
0.2457951307,
0.4096559882,
-0.2815124393,
0.0866590217,
0.4631198645,
0.6797732711,
0.5124384761,
-0.7303423285,
0.0418214835,
-0.0359730162,
-0.5584880114,
0.4595251381,
-0.5362487435,
0.3606916964,
-0.6238754988,
0.0243972223,
-0.1635257304,
0.8144453764,
0.4845940173,
0.5975350738,
0.3595402837,
0.5245908499,
0.923605442,
0.295605123,
0.7859427333,
-0.3923374414,
-0.0639844835,
1.2768851519,
-0.385709852,
0.5962091088,
0.2810415328,
0.173179239,
0.3807487786,
0.0395136699,
0.4305424988,
0.4376785755,
-0.0708596036,
-0.4345706403,
-0.5670917034,
-0.0025577687,
-0.0403241068,
0.6707066894,
0.5241827369,
-0.0386961922,
-0.3745357096,
0.0923803523,
0.2703078687,
0.1425003707,
-0.4182161689,
0.7729367614,
-0.162638247,
-0.9270797968,
0.3508450091,
-0.4483561516,
0.0764685571,
-0.6620557308,
-0.2172468901,
-0.2969851494,
0.4459905326,
-0.060170833,
-0.8713765144,
0.2552035153,
-0.3237580657,
0.06649369,
-0.0328625664,
1.2398086786,
-0.3935796916,
-0.1490601003,
0.4144379497,
0.9617276788,
0.2466428727,
-0.4267274439,
-0.270411551,
-0.3546370566,
-0.2073739767,
-0.3090135753,
0.0970834643,
0.818092227,
-0.1612688005,
1.2478700876,
0.3835805357,
0.2337736934,
-0.1466225684,
-0.0294932686,
1.0390183926,
-0.8315939307,
-0.3559402823,
-0.5012428164,
0.3889487982,
-0.0897813365,
0.032138627,
0.6552259326,
0.5768169165,
0.5207098722,
-0.0526487306,
0.6805095673,
0.0167000405,
0.3181666732,
-0.5185584426,
0.7822027802,
-0.2127049416,
0.6391080022,
0.0774346665,
-0.9025447965,
-0.2919892073,
0.4661158919,
-0.7510204315,
0.2015604377,
0.5818004012,
0.9832122326,
0.1277920902,
-0.2803539634,
0.8213575482,
0.1870245636,
0.5410639644,
0.6146387458,
1.112639308,
-0.0339361466,
0.7598355412,
-0.3030051291,
-0.0742470101,
-0.0924835503,
-0.6826589108,
-1.1293874979,
-0.5175437331,
-0.0180672091,
0.0517071895,
0.2178924978,
0.9286979437,
0.7691558599,
-0.3340055645,
-0.2694430947,
-0.3808015287,
0.3647220433,
-0.1782393903,
-0.1425598413,
0.3428689539,
-0.3725767434,
-0.2821420431,
0.645529747,
0.3408770263,
0.1174215451,
-0.4741148651,
-0.6082882285,
-0.3003235459,
0.2131088525,
0.6323311329,
0.4186574817,
-0.6898332834,
-0.1120948419,
0.1502282619,
0.1455972493,
-0.2790438831,
0.8999283314,
-1.1982456446,
0.4935631752,
0.318777144,
0.2384078056,
0.4315380454,
-0.2336517125,
0.7063214183,
-0.6993219256,
0.1842279583,
0.3961731195,
0.2962367535,
0.1459655762,
-0.5790944099,
0.6866172552,
-0.1351520419,
-0.8481516838,
-0.3408337533,
0.3855385482,
-0.8581068516,
-0.3731719255,
1.2858109474,
0.0818171054,
-0.3057675362,
-0.198427394,
-0.5798217058,
0.2656131983,
-0.3193373084,
0.7393824458,
0.274048686,
-0.4006285071,
-0.2487866879,
-0.4424898624,
0.665940702,
0.2287555188,
-1.0054482222,
0.3048670292,
0.5755717158,
-0.0420666002,
0.2952134311,
0.54583323,
0.3891579211,
0.2851677537,
-0.100114733,
0.4920625091,
-0.3610928357,
-0.7173827291,
0.1482790112,
0.1069745794,
0.4034943879,
0.2678262293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03100v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03100v3
|
NaturalSpeech 3: Zero-Shot Speech Synthesis with Factorized Codec and Diffusion Models
| 2024-03-05T16:35:25 | 2024-04-23T08:38:03 |
Zeqian Ju, Yuancheng Wang, Kai Shen, Xu Tan, Detai Xin, Dongchao Yang, Yanqing Liu, Yichong Leng, Kaitao Song, Siliang Tang, Zhizheng Wu, Tao Qin, Xiang-Yang Li, Wei Ye, Shikun Zhang, Jiang Bian, Lei He, Jinyu Li, Sheng Zhao
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
While recent large-scale text-to-speech (TTS) models have achieved
significant progress, they still fall short in speech quality, similarity, and
prosody. Considering speech intricately encompasses various attributes (e.g.,
content, prosody, timbre, and acoustic details) that pose significant
challenges for generation, a natural idea is to factorize speech into
individual subspaces representing different attributes and generate them
individually. Motivated by it, we propose NaturalSpeech 3, a TTS system with
novel factorized diffusion models to generate natural speech in a zero-shot
way. Specifically, 1) we design a neural codec with factorized vector
quantization (FVQ) to disentangle speech waveform into subspaces of content,
prosody, timbre, and acoustic details; 2) we propose a factorized diffusion
model to generate attributes in each subspace following its corresponding
prompt. With this factorization design, NaturalSpeech 3 can effectively and
efficiently model intricate speech with disentangled subspaces in a
divide-and-conquer way. Experiments show that NaturalSpeech 3 outperforms the
state-of-the-art TTS systems on quality, similarity, prosody, and
intelligibility, and achieves on-par quality with human recordings.
Furthermore, we achieve better performance by scaling to 1B parameters and 200K
hours of training data.
|
[
-0.6518347859,
-1.0969359875,
0.5123855472,
0.3131076097,
-0.4459656477,
0.1872234195,
-0.0499591753,
-0.4423765838,
0.4162686765,
0.3107616901,
-0.6879608035,
-0.4965573549,
-0.244309932,
0.2248579711,
-0.5606672168,
0.9215012789,
0.196110636,
0.2352404296,
0.2734900117,
-0.0233170893,
-0.4161301255,
-0.2362277508,
-0.7653914094,
-0.2626985908,
0.3579705954,
0.3520856798,
0.5692921877,
0.3124866486,
0.0291943531,
0.2577394843,
-0.1375312507,
0.1256033331,
-0.1959782243,
0.1434652358,
0.142890498,
-0.401060462,
-0.548165679,
0.1337943524,
0.6533290744,
0.6013186574,
-0.261888057,
-0.0270200428,
0.0027283723,
0.5225119591,
-0.4436547458,
-0.1552342176,
-0.4123315215,
0.2572164536,
-0.147588864,
-0.1774428189,
-0.2770859897,
-0.6978803873,
0.3012142181,
-0.4831169546,
0.7205626965,
-0.2801000476,
0.3861739635,
0.1989930719,
-0.2418629527,
0.0332238711,
-1.1042317152,
0.6801379323,
-0.9852917194,
0.2360628694,
0.4190359414,
0.338750273,
-0.0894400626,
-0.5512779355,
-0.8165923953,
-0.3016871214,
0.380733639,
0.0548708998,
-0.4691169858,
0.0167209711,
-0.1017472371,
0.4759187996,
-0.7520284653,
0.109037213,
-0.2681237161,
-0.2625592947,
0.511069417,
0.0739353672,
0.3861462176,
-0.2870579064,
-0.083005026,
0.1140044183,
-0.6067191362,
-0.1797101647,
0.4251152277,
0.4716750979,
-0.1031754985,
0.4410588145,
-0.3325282931,
1.0693076849,
0.0736996084,
-0.2188918144,
0.2561597228,
-0.3345923722,
-0.1355167478,
0.3524404466,
0.874342382,
0.087507233,
-0.0877733305,
-0.2474636585,
-0.0523949154,
-0.0530753881,
0.44343099,
-0.8290655613,
0.072857663,
0.4144205749,
-0.100413546,
-0.431497097,
-0.1336759627,
-0.6378244162,
-0.0904290751,
-0.6478523016,
0.8066450357,
-0.7699581981,
-0.4424138069,
0.1288939714,
-0.0814897418,
0.0334361643,
0.2514018714,
-0.7996416688,
0.5419465303,
0.5772586465,
1.2373622656,
-0.1919953525,
-0.2809104323,
-0.7991957068,
-0.1205844209,
-0.6600944996,
0.5305779576,
-0.2224085033,
-0.5130235553,
-0.1677279472,
-0.3033512235,
0.3637916744,
-0.4315571785,
0.1851577759,
-0.2266451269,
0.2480796278,
0.0701724738,
-0.431622088,
-0.1402081847,
-0.1638556868,
-0.6073791981,
0.7986275554,
-0.0520663224,
-0.4069921374,
0.2404647022,
-0.791692555,
-0.7016298175,
0.1793094128,
0.0319979228,
-0.2387719005,
0.4911102653,
0.1136262268,
0.4542861283,
-0.3663894236,
0.2855508327,
-0.0989363343,
-0.3595191538,
0.3025327027,
-0.6646463275,
0.4592453837,
0.3250699639,
-0.6415046453,
-0.0591766536,
-0.9473938346,
-0.0202370081,
0.0012666082,
0.0741301253,
-0.029463144,
-0.104465194,
-0.1783809662,
0.0777894408,
-0.2354601473,
-0.9231587052,
-0.2059820741,
-0.6901634336,
0.7677785158,
0.3493049145,
0.44575876,
0.8369832039,
-0.0991698429,
0.4240367711,
-0.0728967041,
0.0894952118,
0.1698044986,
-0.5237455964,
-0.824262619,
-0.6446347237,
0.3567563295,
0.2133206725,
-0.9660359025,
0.4260413945,
-0.1829798371,
-0.6700347066,
-0.4883550107,
-0.3629182875,
0.0794890076,
0.6518139243,
0.4353175461,
-0.2035844773,
-0.3415299952,
-0.9743164778,
0.1921251863,
0.1304553896,
-0.766482532,
-0.1130551472,
0.2818132937,
0.1256336719,
1.079842329,
-0.621796608,
-0.4445977211,
-0.1642312855,
0.6240277886,
0.2334802896,
0.522921741,
0.5565353036,
-0.368707329,
-0.172241047,
-0.1837667823,
-0.1422880441,
0.0085257832,
0.0061791874,
-0.3290368319,
0.1430763453,
0.3669638634,
-0.5711320043,
0.4427012503,
0.3192403615,
-0.1650210768,
0.2779644728,
-0.0188117493,
0.179973498,
-1.0173279047,
0.1958345175,
-0.0363540202,
-0.2994149923,
-1.1016974449,
-0.1654506773,
-0.2918254733,
-0.5849971175,
-0.6706470847,
0.1797568053,
0.0001883568,
0.0633452237,
-0.4291357398,
0.2265326679,
0.1335865408,
0.6082834601,
0.3043054938,
0.7665400505,
0.6925014853,
-0.7398750186,
0.1443762332,
0.1309361756,
-0.1248940453,
0.8033832908,
-0.7980366349,
0.296400696,
-0.037510626,
0.4120745659,
-0.6347846389,
-0.2355636507,
-0.0942277238,
-0.7800945044,
0.2039891928,
-0.0463845208,
-0.5529099703,
-0.1725322604,
-0.3152896166,
0.193521902,
0.608320415,
-0.3962107897,
0.644549191,
0.2773627341,
-0.2894771397,
0.1526929289,
-0.9896922708,
0.148503989,
0.0309819113,
-0.6708257198,
0.65792799,
0.0637326911,
0.3405110836,
0.0734152347,
-0.2206584662,
-0.3476350009,
-0.1689500213,
0.0798676237,
0.2433331013,
-0.1546007097,
-0.2451483905,
-0.112241894,
-0.1593326926,
-0.0832667127,
-0.3320129812,
0.4278819859,
-0.0976668522,
-0.1924850196,
-0.5014616251,
0.4835754037,
0.5659728646,
-0.3262129426,
0.4850393534,
0.76655972,
-0.5885275006,
-0.3989376426,
-0.3224014938,
-0.1867648512,
-0.448849231,
0.1004296467,
-0.0134448092,
-1.1649917364,
0.2205312252,
0.2436724752,
0.0059691803,
0.1487199813,
0.5467333198,
-0.0613744147,
1.2136850357,
0.2693634331,
0.232594505,
0.4985737801,
-0.3810138702,
0.516047895,
-0.5985027552,
-0.0805524066,
-0.437238127,
-0.3922767937,
-0.5091912746,
-0.785238862,
0.5564948916,
-0.0692077726,
-0.383471936,
0.3547888398,
-0.6390550733,
0.3961320817,
0.8828871846,
0.0864632577,
-0.0455148816,
0.314770937,
-0.1262288392,
-0.1781762391,
-0.5097269416,
-0.2268250883,
0.7548832893,
0.3846670389,
0.2172728777,
0.4675079584,
0.9587737918,
0.0916306973,
-0.1333156675,
-0.7522994876,
0.5198137164,
-0.3597096801,
-0.6133739352,
-0.3028562069,
-0.4577781856,
-0.5059076548,
0.1250633299,
-0.2398141772,
-0.6771980524,
0.2941051424,
0.0696363375,
-0.8068410158,
0.2224330455,
-0.7425377965,
0.2362633646,
0.1997876763,
-0.7671132684,
-0.2056992054,
-0.4986219704,
0.4135811031,
-0.0582293049,
-0.0172384661,
-0.1612896025,
0.2183167636,
0.7157872319,
-0.5326267481,
0.6750102639,
-0.3567959368,
-0.0036281431,
0.6293920875,
0.663790524,
0.081271179,
0.2085711211,
0.0266040917,
0.3635801971,
-0.1444271505,
-0.1954054534,
-0.6108607054,
0.858187139,
-0.5832713842,
-0.2739449441,
-0.2747308016,
0.0674988106,
-0.6241892576,
0.1908463836,
0.4095987082,
0.9000905156,
-0.3304804564,
0.2211681306,
0.5549858809,
-0.2764223814,
0.6884863377,
0.9496714473,
0.0064493841,
-0.832100749,
1.4024441242,
0.1559889168,
0.3382439613,
0.2688203156,
0.2074717134,
-0.205493331,
-0.4532433152,
-0.3070363402,
0.0603835024,
-0.2607519329,
-0.6120528579,
-0.4006788731,
-0.4304615557,
-0.213641867,
-0.2315444648,
-0.7652249336,
-0.4572919607,
-0.6194422841,
-0.3271369636,
0.3757251501,
0.8332777023,
-0.6214282513,
0.2947406173,
-0.7756766677,
0.8761191368,
0.5382638574,
0.5707037449,
0.0700364262,
-0.4767996669,
0.0239144415,
0.1886778921,
-0.2639150321,
-0.9389674664,
0.5675660968,
0.158764869,
0.1875471473,
0.1394029111,
-0.0786161795,
0.573584795,
-0.8683729768,
1.1562875509,
0.4870013297,
-1.1970876455,
0.721102953,
-0.2940494418,
0.4803986847,
0.4636520445,
0.0875253603,
-0.4386435747,
-0.4651363492,
-0.5569025874,
-0.8941496611,
0.9219217896,
0.7617338896,
0.0020479341,
-0.1760686636,
-0.0332581401,
0.09763401,
0.1864422709,
-0.4137027264,
-0.1090056598,
-0.5934755206,
-0.0562080033,
-0.0186769851,
-0.1574208736,
-0.1719202399,
-0.3115484118,
0.6555045843,
0.0221458115,
0.590833962,
0.3532770872,
0.1435043216,
-0.0064456272,
0.3545284867,
0.8791341186,
0.1061655357,
-0.3926855922,
0.3484700918,
-0.0787984431,
-0.495613277,
0.4140333533,
0.1020186096,
-0.1447249353,
0.236495778,
0.3488406837,
1.210947752,
0.2618252635,
-0.0764776692,
0.5583360791,
-0.1804108471,
-0.6269001961,
-0.1042643562,
0.1193399876,
0.0743876621,
-0.182908237,
0.460598886,
0.3504192829,
0.2675411105,
-0.0534451045,
0.2169761509,
0.0707345828,
-0.3074864745,
-0.4787985682,
0.7565186024,
0.6719322205,
-0.5128822923,
0.3344596624,
-0.3929474652,
-0.1231193319,
0.2456459552,
0.4058596194,
1.2426598072,
-0.2470221519,
0.7947271466,
0.5260186195,
0.1740778536,
-0.0098326113,
0.193842411,
-0.2569939494,
-0.3242605925,
-0.705711484,
-0.7741063237,
-0.3568660617,
0.2950727046,
-0.5758635998,
0.1688482314,
-0.5480880141,
-0.1923919618,
0.0869427323,
-0.2801690102,
-0.7438882589,
0.0783449337,
0.4714590311,
0.6599475145,
-0.8618904352,
0.563823998,
0.1507578641,
-0.3437197506,
-0.7807546258,
0.0119208023,
0.1538445204,
-0.2964136302,
0.2479473203,
0.085047096,
-0.3494898379,
0.3465559781,
-0.5445609093,
-0.8411122561,
0.9428685308,
0.38995561,
-0.5636482835,
0.3045069277,
0.4361557066,
0.7003959417,
-0.2019490451,
0.029946072,
0.9257977009,
0.1006545573,
0.2351123393,
-0.726526916,
-0.2973328233,
0.0167802442,
0.1619963944,
0.0045085554,
-0.2405740917,
0.5412326455,
0.0434183106,
-0.3878600895,
-0.1854466647,
0.5872198343,
0.266861707,
-0.0077192602,
0.4124192297,
0.3971831501,
0.5262313485,
-0.0724123418,
0.7468214631,
-0.0581340529,
-0.01455562,
1.1152436733,
-0.4217276871,
0.9822359681,
0.3901901841,
-0.3123739958,
0.2714515924,
0.2322266996,
0.3885310888,
0.7572963238,
0.1837633848,
-0.6934580207,
-0.133153826,
-0.0176306888,
-0.1117961258,
0.5555147529,
0.1926963478,
0.1940915883,
-0.384029597,
0.2608640492,
-0.1771273762,
-0.0211447068,
0.0433478355,
0.8605793118,
-0.1158582941,
-0.6500627995,
0.6913614273,
0.0927427188,
0.6571860313,
-0.8360339999,
-0.3049222231,
-0.4798295498,
-0.3828219771,
-0.1231330633,
-0.7029553652,
0.2582176328,
0.1652484983,
-0.1770954579,
-0.1840072721,
0.3476102352,
-0.3438832462,
-0.4538846612,
-0.106236212,
0.2162653208,
-0.2115554512,
-0.2023126632,
-0.3870514631,
0.1424984187,
0.2788057923,
-0.0995917693,
0.0559154041,
0.269120574,
0.3124420941,
0.4211496413,
0.7560003996,
0.2562576532,
0.0401965939,
0.3115777969,
0.5413182378,
-0.5030976534,
-0.6672645807,
-0.7162166238,
0.55760324,
-0.0369284078,
-0.190242067,
0.4243754447,
0.25707829,
0.2393400967,
-0.1160759702,
0.6300393939,
-0.101587154,
0.7567295432,
-0.5379376411,
0.514034152,
-0.3447693288,
0.0027956681,
-0.3511752188,
-1.0244309902,
-0.3961502314,
0.6654626131,
0.0562640913,
-0.2139496207,
0.6359212399,
0.9451876283,
0.0765068457,
0.3004391193,
0.4451497793,
0.1420868188,
0.5808559656,
0.3543793857,
0.6999209523,
-0.2730512023,
0.3627137542,
-0.4488293231,
-0.3162712455,
-0.1622644365,
-0.8280204535,
-0.3636679351,
-0.7029842138,
-0.5652571321,
-0.0011603802,
-0.2988868058,
0.6588582397,
0.8312158585,
-0.7892167568,
0.0635075793,
-0.7419496775,
-0.2436333001,
-0.0074804155,
-0.3138198256,
0.0650756806,
-0.0962587148,
-0.762673676,
0.9532669783,
0.4607216716,
0.3687306643,
-0.5352215171,
0.0150010902,
-0.0717257857,
0.244580254,
0.6602742672,
0.2768810093,
-0.645396471,
-0.29842031,
0.0324188098,
0.1742430925,
-0.2222840935,
0.880669713,
-0.8679319024,
0.6371837854,
0.5436353683,
0.2958980799,
0.5788549781,
-0.1872267574,
0.9050294757,
-1.2403981686,
0.3392114043,
0.538600862,
0.0158613138,
0.4244135618,
-0.0440504104,
0.4182136655,
-0.1041731164,
-0.433994025,
-0.8887744546,
0.1321633905,
-0.7714471221,
-0.3344242275,
1.1050628424,
0.3437405825,
-0.142820105,
0.0992923379,
-0.3617408872,
0.3120982945,
-0.3772547245,
0.2027886808,
0.4314292967,
-0.3083471656,
0.159839794,
-0.6557480097,
0.6655103564,
0.2975638807,
-0.3971755505,
0.0203810111,
0.8224984407,
0.4260959923,
0.2341019958,
0.6829605103,
-0.1192547455,
0.3431937099,
0.1774985045,
0.2867926359,
-0.0801317841,
-0.1878163218,
-0.5290648937,
0.1821811944,
-0.0090305954,
-0.5225949287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03075v1
|
Detecting Concrete Visual Tokens for Multimodal Machine Translation
| 2024-03-05T16:01:09 | 2024-03-05T16:01:09 |
Braeden Bowen, Vipin Vijayan, Scott Grigsby, Timothy Anderson, Jeremy Gwinnup
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The challenge of visual grounding and masking in multimodal machine
translation (MMT) systems has encouraged varying approaches to the detection
and selection of visually-grounded text tokens for masking. We introduce new
methods for detection of visually and contextually relevant (concrete) tokens
from source sentences, including detection with natural language processing
(NLP), detection with object detection, and a joint detection-verification
technique. We also introduce new methods for selection of detected tokens,
including shortest $n$ tokens, longest $n$ tokens, and all detected concrete
tokens. We utilize the GRAM MMT architecture to train models against
synthetically collated multimodal datasets of source images with masked
sentences, showing performance improvements and improved usage of visual
context during translation tasks over the baseline model.
|
[
-0.4137582779,
-0.6113363504,
0.5127779245,
0.267583847,
-0.6899143457,
0.0486318916,
-0.0985374227,
-0.2750892341,
-0.0449724942,
0.5140744448,
-0.5332662463,
-0.6088256836,
-0.9232580662,
0.3477339447,
-0.443646282,
0.7739588022,
-0.2320073545,
0.1264174432,
-0.3588950634,
-0.295488447,
-0.8927156925,
-0.6678665876,
-0.4816308916,
0.0137271723,
0.3634437919,
0.2528281808,
0.568053782,
0.6694664955,
0.8110255599,
0.3579944074,
0.072522141,
0.5232192278,
0.1473643929,
0.1685761064,
0.1447540224,
-0.2449220866,
-0.2565885484,
0.0212118886,
0.6427306533,
0.3370749652,
0.5272153616,
0.2144663036,
-0.2027979195,
0.4612781703,
-0.7579453588,
0.4365418255,
-0.7185624242,
0.3524334431,
-0.3503247797,
-0.5106778741,
-0.7071637511,
0.3812665045,
-0.4561028779,
-0.370821923,
0.29694435,
0.3162533045,
0.6573693156,
0.3737465441,
-0.8616562486,
-0.2187452018,
-0.2902291119,
0.7124585509,
-0.3294415772,
0.7322403789,
0.4073797166,
0.5285291672,
-0.138511166,
-0.9238250256,
-0.6775551438,
-0.408731401,
-0.2628318369,
0.3146975338,
-0.1485343874,
0.2048199028,
0.2967545986,
0.2742148042,
-0.6210671067,
-0.2540147305,
-0.1850647479,
-0.5102732778,
-0.1319204867,
-0.1197017059,
0.6744490862,
-0.5586965084,
-0.7119451761,
-0.2943699956,
-0.4173060954,
-0.2693505883,
-0.098989591,
0.1124382243,
-0.1783204824,
0.86318326,
-0.3355468512,
0.7789709568,
-0.2416635156,
-0.430508256,
0.3452717662,
-0.68692559,
-0.344763577,
-0.1641963571,
0.6445578933,
0.5281122327,
0.2543056309,
-0.1852073669,
-0.4638493657,
0.326208055,
-0.0930349231,
-0.6506726742,
-0.0918740258,
-0.1018665507,
-0.6475142837,
-0.4126982987,
0.0676120073,
-0.4688423276,
-0.1009558141,
-0.4331582189,
0.2407761961,
-0.3322033584,
-0.06976863,
0.0075291269,
-0.6341252923,
0.1129190549,
0.1555951685,
-0.8624421954,
0.0993528888,
0.3731188774,
1.0370051861,
-0.1899772584,
-0.2387252152,
-0.9102631211,
0.3605560958,
-0.39980793,
0.8297768831,
-0.4557266235,
-0.0398697332,
0.0700299144,
0.1489152014,
-0.1676385999,
-0.5377416015,
0.6611132026,
-0.3670035899,
0.0925369784,
-0.1591650546,
-0.0883497819,
0.018950928,
0.7056097984,
-0.6345510483,
0.8414478302,
-0.019271614,
-0.7407941222,
0.6497842669,
-0.7401486635,
-0.4483089745,
0.0043249815,
-0.3674084544,
-0.2505605519,
0.2406008393,
0.6975570917,
0.5885323286,
0.0740439147,
0.2201119363,
-0.1908167303,
-0.2033774108,
0.4607005715,
-0.7862842083,
0.491363734,
0.4098584354,
-0.3555116951,
0.2462111861,
-0.9263624549,
-0.1857137531,
-0.0369299278,
-0.2834441662,
-0.1246301234,
0.0012195706,
0.4924526811,
0.6150076389,
-0.0032383064,
-0.4978523552,
0.0919656232,
0.196772024,
0.6140796542,
0.8049620986,
0.006344167,
0.2184944302,
0.0660468936,
0.4744425714,
0.4708453417,
0.1729766279,
-0.7091947198,
-0.7332021594,
-0.8899062276,
-0.6631379128,
0.2251567245,
0.5530068874,
-1.2931061983,
0.2009863257,
-0.2977308929,
0.2238609642,
-0.3692963123,
0.1012807786,
0.3743103445,
0.4143997431,
0.5904561877,
-0.2355219573,
-0.6455923319,
-0.9480555654,
-0.1757698506,
-0.1169078723,
-0.0637559071,
-0.0089525469,
0.8620995283,
-0.3728545606,
0.8047479391,
-0.3756561279,
-0.5627160072,
0.1498548687,
0.3276347518,
-0.1313214004,
0.7384624481,
0.5774155259,
-1.1865206957,
-0.4552056491,
0.2208301276,
-0.8097121119,
-0.1800666749,
-0.2149780095,
-0.0185817722,
-0.0175960604,
1.1484966278,
-0.7159868479,
0.4275487065,
0.6217511892,
-0.385632962,
0.3144777417,
-0.0630647168,
0.4297505915,
-1.0490602255,
0.0785996169,
-0.2205468714,
-0.8777448535,
-0.3063719571,
0.3694999814,
0.3269535899,
-0.2348924726,
-0.6126312017,
0.4210966825,
-0.6262043118,
-0.1636118293,
-0.2985175848,
0.1666199267,
0.0756730065,
0.5287448168,
-0.0758306384,
0.9341557622,
0.3382326066,
-0.3109805882,
0.4156827033,
0.2502608597,
-0.2146317959,
0.8765612245,
-0.3305612206,
0.1941885203,
-0.2631802857,
0.3540310264,
-1.0814766884,
-0.1343081295,
0.5894055963,
-0.5597629547,
0.1751125008,
-0.5120555758,
-0.9047324657,
-0.1654273272,
-0.1170670167,
0.5861204267,
0.3218121827,
-0.5117039084,
0.5044690371,
-0.025982745,
0.1988440901,
-0.53189224,
-0.8010404706,
0.7084088326,
-0.1746507138,
-0.5326882601,
0.4044281244,
-0.0827863961,
0.0674916431,
-0.0472725816,
-0.1862635016,
-0.1416338384,
0.161442399,
0.2013520896,
0.0957716405,
-0.1720823944,
-0.0706046671,
-0.0118212886,
-0.4716326296,
-0.1174386293,
-0.6013656259,
0.5306995511,
-0.0445783958,
-0.660723269,
-0.3089314699,
0.4126516283,
0.8973194957,
-0.544108212,
0.6439374685,
1.3407436609,
-0.5262755752,
0.4104177058,
-0.6749175787,
-0.0185308643,
-0.4158456922,
0.4265972972,
-0.6333554983,
-0.7488540411,
0.4373217821,
0.0723854303,
-0.3792671561,
0.4118449092,
0.5974696279,
0.1504414827,
1.5503165722,
0.6308637261,
0.0882804394,
0.6574119329,
-0.0040095309,
0.2019762844,
-0.97136271,
-0.2128745466,
-0.3144361079,
-0.1299720705,
-0.5711797476,
-0.8284471631,
0.3648746908,
0.1713133007,
0.3051404953,
0.2188190669,
-0.3746651113,
0.7005750537,
0.6357519031,
0.0913041979,
0.4364664257,
0.0888654217,
-0.567240417,
0.0294154119,
-0.2983080447,
-0.5041967034,
0.8422612548,
0.238935113,
0.0856489986,
0.0987446085,
0.3048592806,
0.4124877155,
0.290931195,
-0.5707739592,
0.4821739495,
-0.149383828,
-0.5415270329,
0.1593872309,
-0.2772758603,
-0.5817898512,
0.5226508975,
-0.3138617277,
-0.4380314946,
0.0338984355,
0.0574059859,
0.2006829083,
0.2570239305,
-0.6919721365,
1.1028386354,
-0.0093958192,
0.1311874986,
0.0473074205,
-0.6762111783,
0.3641693592,
0.0944195539,
0.1593316942,
-0.0009145127,
-0.1783149242,
0.4356087148,
-0.0245515313,
0.7460857034,
-0.105744414,
0.1055348441,
0.0013670231,
-0.0019773261,
0.4214112461,
0.0799202025,
0.4293198287,
0.0924819782,
-0.0950898826,
-0.630312264,
-0.4877301455,
0.3854928911,
-0.3770579696,
-0.2571474612,
-0.4161117077,
-0.5459113717,
0.1161364242,
0.4754767716,
0.3139488697,
0.3190611303,
-0.0345617384,
0.4383122623,
0.3039200306,
-0.1526685506,
0.4580085874,
0.123252593,
-0.2630701363,
-0.7518303394,
0.8826953769,
-0.177071929,
0.2937458754,
0.5725368261,
-0.0174973365,
-0.1768432856,
-0.9144230485,
-0.8284959197,
-0.0827088729,
-1.0272437334,
-0.4354164898,
-0.7555440068,
0.0852546245,
-0.6223604083,
-0.0921810642,
-0.0169967506,
-0.3181705475,
-0.1667378098,
-0.1799744219,
-0.0127955452,
0.3517875671,
0.0046261856,
0.3489839435,
-0.7662709951,
0.8001798987,
0.3936684132,
0.1137757376,
-0.5377848148,
-0.282987982,
-0.1673105657,
0.0143231275,
-0.2895317674,
-0.7966737151,
0.3717015386,
0.0338302962,
0.3531779647,
0.5817239285,
-0.2131376863,
0.9009682536,
-0.729042232,
0.808247149,
0.4330740869,
-0.9458302855,
0.503225863,
-0.3539849222,
0.330275476,
0.3956434131,
-0.0736525431,
-0.8581753969,
-0.5225298405,
-0.1455326974,
-0.714818418,
0.3895763755,
0.5719133615,
0.2032508701,
-0.4568236172,
0.0456443168,
-0.3353082836,
0.4665902257,
-1.219478488,
-0.0294553861,
-0.3073228002,
-0.3133974373,
-0.0771293566,
-0.2718478143,
-0.0118418233,
-0.0185233783,
0.2245613039,
-0.449573338,
0.3693860471,
0.2826193869,
-0.6460555792,
0.0513543449,
0.0793109238,
0.9808390737,
0.372330755,
-0.3071239889,
0.6289957166,
-0.0071741315,
-0.3699432611,
0.0515975729,
-0.1234847009,
-0.206814751,
0.3216888309,
0.6194279194,
0.7216460705,
0.2725681365,
-0.6730966568,
0.808344543,
0.0266458113,
-0.0507285297,
-0.2770146132,
-0.440520376,
-0.2114258707,
0.0823009908,
0.2133866698,
0.6471506357,
0.2321828306,
-0.6022503972,
0.3524556756,
0.5409712195,
-0.6636639833,
-0.237274915,
0.7072655559,
0.0727092773,
-0.2561535239,
0.4691736102,
-0.2320842892,
-0.8347130418,
0.4976378083,
0.7635372877,
0.8389405608,
0.0980470926,
0.1812894642,
-0.0670159012,
0.6524679065,
0.0833328664,
-0.1053675711,
-0.2135992944,
-0.6060571671,
-0.5374674201,
-0.3307452798,
0.0233104788,
0.0422648862,
-0.3614738882,
0.5085065365,
-0.2290832251,
-0.103036955,
-0.2276439071,
-0.5995966196,
-0.7635697126,
0.2096818388,
0.4441185296,
0.7017066479,
-1.135206461,
0.6876015067,
0.6523118615,
-0.6560940146,
-0.1357821375,
-0.2476804852,
0.0045791678,
-0.9129587412,
1.0909875631,
0.4004412889,
-0.0794523582,
-0.034331169,
-0.4768842757,
-0.5318560004,
0.9756270051,
0.4260347784,
0.0493366159,
0.080985859,
0.3027513325,
0.212223947,
-0.3222964406,
0.2344061583,
0.1729134768,
0.6333741546,
0.0710102022,
-0.7544377446,
0.0213519596,
-0.3201689422,
-0.0207831841,
0.1852912754,
-0.3020989299,
0.9476040602,
0.4137543142,
-0.2203469276,
0.0740183741,
0.5664108992,
0.2007097006,
0.3997067213,
0.5435856581,
0.5713415146,
0.3845899701,
-0.0229742602,
0.8474927545,
-0.2065659016,
0.1093929037,
0.7514106631,
0.0594778173,
0.7289499044,
0.9003582001,
0.1783389002,
0.414585799,
0.523186326,
-0.1065197885,
0.6042020321,
0.0355768539,
-0.3314293921,
-0.2650738955,
-0.2968758643,
-0.3826518059,
0.5017289519,
0.0591045544,
-0.4605875909,
-0.1474688202,
0.4484377205,
-0.0490198359,
0.004947219,
-0.0806951448,
0.76585567,
0.0820183083,
-0.6233515143,
0.4767958522,
0.5376662016,
0.532086432,
-0.3300058246,
-0.3372374475,
-0.2614868283,
0.136091128,
0.0150585789,
-0.1760185808,
0.1187880039,
0.0040581804,
-0.1871644408,
-0.6666789651,
0.8251937628,
-0.4545017481,
-0.5812721252,
0.1252339333,
0.4585532844,
0.0429798029,
-0.4860610068,
-0.5321983695,
-0.0077924114,
-0.1587895453,
0.0888892412,
0.3520253301,
0.7768204808,
-0.2738128901,
0.6382808685,
1.1932028532,
-0.085807465,
0.408318758,
0.0964004397,
0.8350444436,
-0.6074866652,
-0.6218018532,
-1.0598629713,
0.5879881978,
-0.2803097665,
-0.1315789968,
0.8391312361,
0.6179078817,
0.9017926455,
-0.4196610153,
0.3717363477,
0.2117188722,
-0.3354084194,
-1.0587345362,
0.382185787,
-0.3949099481,
-0.0162838753,
-0.4000867307,
-1.036588788,
-0.7183363438,
0.7202190161,
0.2579615414,
-0.2498133183,
1.221571207,
0.6439427733,
-0.4790438116,
-0.4929368198,
0.6142390966,
-0.2518700063,
0.5655753613,
0.2561694384,
0.8212120533,
-0.7240635157,
0.8136209249,
0.0120992726,
-0.1071873233,
-0.3158860207,
-1.1826924086,
-1.0838526487,
-0.7026597857,
-0.4005452991,
-0.1541966945,
-0.1821517795,
0.8108819723,
1.0318732262,
-0.8253958821,
0.0285881832,
-0.2360439152,
0.1684854925,
-0.4694797993,
-0.1718665063,
0.2124377042,
-0.6085500717,
-0.6388633251,
0.5176590681,
0.6066990495,
0.3001399934,
-0.1152021438,
0.0168493912,
-0.3505924642,
-0.2082448602,
0.9670034647,
-0.2344347239,
-0.8781071305,
-0.5348903537,
0.1248222515,
-0.062119849,
0.074621886,
1.0896081924,
-0.7110473514,
0.5632663369,
0.482851088,
0.5586323738,
0.5863449574,
-0.1942270845,
0.4019524753,
-1.291659236,
0.7283173203,
-0.0085797738,
0.5634649992,
0.3862348795,
0.0343608782,
0.5177181363,
0.6481329203,
-0.1131422073,
-1.0701130629,
0.3898220658,
-1.0737532377,
-0.1475194246,
0.8132091165,
-0.1177504882,
-0.1789119542,
-0.2536483407,
-0.5183036923,
0.2966199219,
-0.0081093041,
0.4414592385,
0.7825289369,
0.5081115961,
-0.3898822963,
-0.9150906801,
0.314778626,
0.3790575564,
-0.633399725,
-0.2000736445,
0.512416482,
-0.0739195719,
0.3928377032,
0.6289592385,
-0.1885939986,
0.2758061588,
0.005388075,
-0.0016122548,
-0.2423636466,
-0.445982784,
-0.1208916605,
0.190484032,
-0.0180457253,
-0.7435435653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03045v1
|
Adding Multimodal Capabilities to a Text-only Translation Model
| 2024-03-05T15:28:24 | 2024-03-05T15:28:24 |
Vipin Vijayan, Braeden Bowen, Scott Grigsby, Timothy Anderson, Jeremy Gwinnup
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While most current work in multimodal machine translation (MMT) uses the
Multi30k dataset for training and evaluation, we find that the resulting models
overfit to the Multi30k dataset to an extreme degree. Consequently, these
models perform very badly when evaluated against typical text-only testing sets
such as the WMT newstest datasets. In order to perform well on both Multi30k
and typical text-only datasets, we use a performant text-only machine
translation (MT) model as the starting point of our MMT model. We add
vision-text adapter layers connected via gating mechanisms to the MT model, and
incrementally transform the MT model into an MMT model by 1) pre-training using
vision-based masking of the source text and 2) fine-tuning on Multi30k.
|
[
-0.4372497499,
-0.4275556505,
0.6621271372,
0.1900777519,
-0.4582208693,
-0.0516014658,
-0.0716239139,
-0.3731437922,
-0.0959940776,
0.6615381837,
-0.8138620853,
-0.2774918973,
-0.7300165892,
0.2000120133,
-0.3677330911,
1.3313803673,
-0.2049935609,
0.1117696315,
-0.201961413,
-0.3626363873,
-0.4478807747,
-0.4802088737,
-0.2516429424,
-0.1959006041,
0.5455806255,
0.3586457372,
0.6150237918,
0.605475843,
0.7935626507,
0.2448550314,
0.1530177891,
0.3935000896,
-0.0772826001,
-0.2071556747,
0.0243471954,
-0.3406746686,
-0.7353123426,
0.1452205777,
0.6617386937,
0.3183048964,
0.1106766388,
0.2703032196,
0.0340813808,
0.3877785206,
-0.3486919701,
0.1663042754,
-0.6228175759,
0.019639954,
-0.2133225799,
-0.3362623155,
-0.6247882247,
0.0716659799,
0.1490785182,
-0.6652936339,
0.0991196632,
0.0657212958,
0.8201645613,
0.1455420703,
-0.9269315004,
-0.065770492,
-0.6420550346,
0.7800673246,
-0.4840007126,
0.5909310579,
0.2787026465,
0.4902112782,
0.3221313357,
-0.5520808101,
-0.7414533496,
-0.3500318825,
-0.0263652336,
0.4730486572,
-0.0555312857,
0.1168156192,
0.2376974672,
0.33095783,
-0.7091420889,
-0.1571613997,
-0.412456423,
-0.0868336111,
0.242552653,
0.2022374719,
0.2786206603,
-0.3348166943,
-0.7471935153,
-0.469507426,
-0.3535535038,
-0.0598867759,
0.0964889899,
0.2973780334,
-0.0440279916,
1.0301047564,
-0.0635025799,
0.656250298,
-0.2761801779,
-0.0959130153,
0.4648505747,
-0.6082829237,
-0.5501642823,
-0.322386831,
0.7231557369,
0.5442127585,
0.1833566725,
-0.0978784785,
-0.4573384523,
0.1061499044,
0.4253678322,
-0.790605545,
-0.192635417,
0.0036163523,
-0.415754199,
-0.4430694878,
-0.1738830954,
-0.6386830807,
-0.3736465275,
-0.3243635893,
0.8412694335,
-0.5480539799,
-0.2306834161,
0.0417015366,
-0.2233054638,
-0.0337585434,
0.2847586572,
-0.6852074862,
0.0655098855,
0.0666921213,
0.91917485,
-0.0880155936,
-0.6501554847,
-0.2741710544,
0.2716487348,
-0.3470554948,
0.8100642562,
-0.3344388604,
-0.138165921,
-0.141217351,
0.3437638283,
-0.4655151367,
-0.300904721,
0.6219572425,
-0.3969809115,
0.1309615076,
-0.1792239398,
-0.2058521956,
-0.3763982952,
0.3556354344,
-0.6238287687,
0.8728816509,
0.2087205052,
-0.5634552836,
0.5396079421,
-1.0768982172,
-0.4952174425,
-0.0962981507,
0.2288163602,
-0.4861221015,
0.3317957222,
0.5418871045,
0.4745965898,
-0.0800351575,
0.0279869065,
-0.2438638955,
-0.0507036746,
0.3858446181,
-0.813647151,
0.3502676487,
0.2723885775,
-0.0455142483,
0.214221254,
-0.9155153632,
-0.0502663441,
0.0617571175,
-0.4646157324,
-0.1987751275,
-0.118258968,
0.4884423912,
0.594393611,
0.0300718956,
-0.5149308443,
0.232098937,
-0.0424171165,
0.4095685184,
0.7288429141,
-0.3816109002,
0.4516778588,
-0.4927854836,
0.5464082956,
0.3369761705,
0.2002846748,
-0.5127220154,
-0.6046878099,
-0.9233081341,
-0.3207629025,
0.1895987093,
0.8045505881,
-1.2748949528,
-0.1917318106,
-0.5511237979,
-0.4515227973,
-0.665412724,
0.1336378753,
0.3754272759,
0.4013032019,
0.5809605718,
-0.2649119496,
-0.4272725284,
-1.0654449463,
-0.0656160414,
0.1714511067,
-0.1203693151,
0.1854952276,
0.6459175348,
-0.2628719807,
0.4924816489,
-0.3289314508,
-0.5604531765,
-0.1982905418,
0.1296834052,
0.0549087487,
0.4175377786,
0.5752851963,
-0.8899518847,
-0.4877178669,
0.3522566557,
-0.7054967284,
-0.0121056372,
-0.158422038,
0.0973300263,
0.0659402087,
0.4129448831,
-0.5462553501,
0.3856263161,
1.0600825548,
-0.2349134088,
0.519208014,
-0.3125262856,
0.5786628127,
-1.3412897587,
0.0009877195,
0.0635020658,
-0.5230157971,
-0.6128357649,
0.1940524131,
0.4955804944,
-0.39469558,
-0.5549658537,
0.3891244531,
-0.4046085477,
0.1744493842,
-0.2677151859,
0.0302107949,
0.2883317173,
0.5301461816,
-0.1983924955,
1.0474280119,
0.2386009246,
-0.6442970037,
0.3793006539,
0.319714576,
-0.4288630486,
0.8173510432,
-0.3809852898,
-0.0328499824,
-0.0666712895,
0.1160777211,
-1.0058865547,
-0.3164833486,
0.0684061795,
-0.4699562788,
0.2073978633,
-0.1856527627,
-0.7435570955,
-0.4019573927,
-0.2644884288,
0.4082409143,
0.1766491681,
-0.408921659,
0.677667439,
0.0643268973,
-0.1007875502,
-0.1815101802,
-1.1214245558,
0.3789723217,
-0.1599533111,
-0.744040668,
0.3877737224,
-0.1033510119,
0.3285745084,
-0.1751604527,
0.1115223914,
-0.2560679913,
-0.0938056037,
0.0827619955,
0.2845307291,
-0.3611132205,
0.1728827059,
0.2314244658,
-0.2791074812,
-0.4367978275,
-0.337377578,
0.4576384127,
0.0313951299,
-0.4214020967,
-0.4707728624,
0.4576577246,
1.0889074802,
-0.5846576095,
0.9280926585,
0.87927109,
-0.1851347834,
0.2175596952,
-0.5406814218,
-0.0422295108,
-0.4133166671,
0.8771675229,
-0.9353598356,
-0.6356495023,
0.4910886586,
0.1106073633,
0.0756919459,
0.53665483,
0.551966548,
-0.2906719744,
1.3903747797,
0.8526745439,
0.3905457556,
0.6860114336,
0.1316100955,
-0.0271692034,
-1.0920151472,
-0.1166512817,
-0.1184885502,
-0.2670567036,
-0.571300745,
-0.3681334257,
0.3594008982,
-0.2096519917,
0.0154588362,
0.6403138041,
-0.4121512473,
0.2342042625,
0.5193165541,
0.3562124074,
0.4395309389,
0.1552159041,
-0.2818234861,
-0.1992949694,
-0.5811715722,
-0.4935675561,
1.393129468,
0.3282501996,
0.5993543863,
0.2905040681,
-0.0099746985,
0.0786745176,
0.4562234879,
-0.536927402,
0.3201750815,
-0.5811921954,
-0.7653642297,
0.0109543316,
-0.5066286325,
-0.5610377789,
0.4125246406,
-0.247181505,
-0.3835035264,
0.1120040864,
-0.0047799069,
-0.2332115024,
0.4648403823,
-1.1376982927,
1.0352176428,
-0.1700111181,
0.0301323161,
0.1446089,
-0.4293021262,
0.3776295483,
-0.3121386766,
0.4069392383,
-0.0585989095,
-0.0825733691,
0.6031374335,
0.0383480974,
0.7050311565,
-0.1380316615,
-0.1125418395,
0.0112528224,
0.0986531675,
0.4059969187,
-0.1512074172,
0.1244609877,
-0.0579665564,
0.197097823,
-0.4441965222,
-0.5632743835,
0.3885789514,
-0.7268879414,
-0.321999222,
-0.2647377253,
-0.9493206739,
-0.1355664134,
0.2496551126,
0.2075424939,
0.3918520212,
0.0005554779,
0.3097577393,
0.534760654,
-0.0885485783,
0.4241842031,
0.5375699997,
-0.4631124735,
-0.6357766986,
1.1393046379,
0.291069746,
0.6725971699,
0.3575818837,
0.0430645831,
-0.2664898336,
-0.6417589784,
-1.1027860641,
-0.1961111426,
-0.6990258694,
-0.0808525756,
-0.8278167248,
-0.1633471847,
-0.5247699022,
0.1390274912,
-0.4534650743,
-0.2778188288,
-0.0600603707,
-0.0461359173,
0.2180749774,
0.5564817786,
0.1477667391,
0.6931437254,
-1.0112682581,
0.394651562,
0.3416051269,
0.2672088444,
-0.3683843911,
-0.7351443172,
-0.5140827298,
0.1912939399,
-0.5663428903,
-0.7731601,
0.3709549308,
0.2270290107,
0.2994458079,
0.3056997955,
-0.316005826,
0.9234558344,
-0.7030087113,
0.5892016888,
0.203533709,
-0.7966412306,
0.3490127325,
-0.5475136042,
0.5656653047,
0.5132601857,
0.104453899,
-0.6298165321,
-0.2607936859,
-0.1339931339,
-0.5406690836,
0.672939539,
0.4559310973,
0.4460368156,
0.2410690188,
0.0808248892,
0.1509595066,
0.327937901,
-1.1497131586,
0.0730355456,
-0.5018825531,
-0.3326135874,
-0.4462189674,
-0.2912988961,
-0.0649677962,
-0.2579784691,
0.4940121174,
-0.3025375605,
0.3366223574,
0.1465590149,
-0.4541879296,
0.0121526457,
0.290199846,
0.8794633746,
0.6116415858,
-0.3262527883,
0.229446888,
0.1541013271,
-0.5853618383,
0.1635026187,
0.1847428679,
-0.1073282287,
-0.1293255836,
0.2398597747,
0.906761229,
0.0813941881,
-0.3939178586,
0.5842135549,
-0.0167425163,
-0.2060988992,
0.2280018181,
-0.2422393411,
-0.035356041,
0.2292649448,
0.4269518554,
0.6114387512,
-0.0957539529,
-0.3570929766,
0.4402524829,
0.1782798022,
-0.7302877307,
-0.3384562433,
0.805300951,
0.0874954462,
0.0248472076,
0.4119283557,
0.0323441848,
-0.5948076248,
0.468759656,
0.6271582842,
0.7106778622,
-0.4581220448,
0.1832605749,
0.1221211851,
0.9032752514,
0.0888669789,
0.0476326011,
0.0737840682,
-0.5879467726,
-0.6404120326,
-0.5739683509,
-0.2308358997,
0.0376122035,
-0.6029866934,
0.4073379934,
-0.0536012016,
-0.189196825,
-0.028658824,
-0.2739996016,
-0.7360191345,
0.5682429671,
-0.0866138116,
0.6750136018,
-0.9710116386,
1.0631911755,
0.8854795098,
-0.6068266034,
-0.2406947613,
-0.1887770593,
-0.0617802404,
-0.9561085105,
0.2820491791,
0.3492431939,
0.2292854339,
0.177782923,
-0.2829335332,
-0.5543090105,
1.0815368891,
0.3400695622,
-0.3431406021,
-0.0509630367,
0.3955099285,
0.1355977058,
-0.3541405499,
0.2301188409,
0.0235450454,
0.5842677951,
0.1110292822,
-1.1468925476,
-0.0876534879,
-0.2458795309,
0.0185611714,
0.1035577282,
-0.5812222362,
1.1044756174,
0.0567960292,
-0.1624495834,
0.0839447603,
0.4422912896,
-0.1422904283,
0.2591077387,
0.3744208515,
0.6862809658,
0.3624766767,
-0.0302887596,
1.2883214951,
0.0332324281,
0.3802396655,
1.0798434019,
0.0167231821,
0.7403156161,
0.6010986567,
-0.1560154259,
-0.050037276,
0.6423253417,
-0.2170292586,
0.7728413939,
-0.225017041,
-0.2147938609,
-0.3410705328,
0.002771697,
-0.4351537526,
0.532980144,
-0.0573375449,
-0.5453207493,
-0.2883408964,
0.6927469969,
-0.1484677345,
-0.2275381088,
-0.1307279021,
0.7027880549,
0.0192130636,
-0.3868123889,
0.2545725107,
0.4402206242,
0.6652165651,
-0.6396223307,
0.1252583414,
-0.0636318848,
0.2180982679,
-0.0095898518,
-0.7780599594,
0.5092154145,
-0.0811434388,
-0.4840871692,
-0.407071352,
0.4558576047,
-0.441086024,
-0.9322723746,
0.1728597879,
0.6828252077,
-0.0585109517,
-0.6224370003,
-0.4639874101,
-0.1472798735,
0.1522053629,
-0.3284358978,
0.4935194552,
0.7245588303,
-0.0820309743,
0.743304193,
1.0224938393,
-0.158758536,
0.3582049012,
-0.0542193912,
0.9640472531,
-0.6037905216,
-0.2328309715,
-1.0534669161,
0.7618410587,
0.0896101072,
-0.3599631488,
0.8056827784,
0.6089141369,
0.7308257222,
-0.1609426141,
0.6311441064,
0.0359664932,
0.0356199928,
-0.5366723537,
1.0924115181,
-0.8922547102,
-0.0834910125,
-0.3475499153,
-1.0141365528,
-0.4511235058,
0.4487061501,
-0.0066080154,
0.0319968164,
0.898699224,
0.6105344296,
-0.4184139967,
0.0082535194,
0.8921118975,
0.2256592512,
0.4620810449,
0.5833494663,
0.5865917802,
-0.8337441683,
0.9756064415,
-0.1290520281,
-0.4792530835,
0.0217837412,
-0.8863323331,
-1.0766903162,
-0.7447187304,
-0.0688795075,
-0.2587404847,
-0.1741694361,
0.412391901,
0.7867749333,
-0.6592335701,
0.0549948588,
0.1845407784,
-0.2098544985,
-0.2193931043,
-0.1785778403,
0.243332088,
-0.3036432862,
-0.7271925211,
0.4129697084,
0.3139804602,
0.2929018736,
-0.2674126625,
0.1068366095,
-0.2607170641,
0.055677034,
0.9495772719,
-0.4782365263,
-0.3762787282,
-0.311727941,
0.1892664582,
-0.1217607409,
0.3382721245,
0.6289548278,
-0.4396694601,
0.7045329809,
0.0813815296,
0.585888207,
0.656291306,
-0.3615482152,
0.5683491826,
-0.8106922507,
0.2346921265,
-0.0803615376,
0.1897058189,
0.2394960821,
-0.0252105575,
0.2682925463,
0.3419780731,
-0.3355757594,
-0.7908454537,
0.2059148848,
-1.008223176,
-0.0005749994,
0.7599706054,
-0.1579493582,
-0.3258410096,
0.0213849135,
-0.377844125,
0.2943848968,
-0.1580802202,
0.5247533917,
1.0595859289,
0.2345090359,
-0.6120763421,
-1.1192506552,
0.1094118059,
0.2867125273,
-0.6721234322,
-0.1547814757,
0.0623461045,
0.2725491822,
0.1798776686,
0.3181348145,
-0.2911606729,
0.2760883868,
0.1800156385,
0.2070433199,
-0.4517183602,
-0.427634269,
-0.0280310139,
0.248036474,
-0.312365979,
-0.5464437604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03031v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03031v4
|
Learning to Use Tools via Cooperative and Interactive Agents
| 2024-03-05T15:08:16 | 2024-06-22T14:00:56 |
Zhengliang Shi, Shen Gao, Xiuyi Chen, Yue Feng, Lingyong Yan, Haibo Shi, Dawei Yin, Pengjie Ren, Suzan Verberne, Zhaochun Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tool learning empowers large language models (LLMs) as agents to use external
tools and extend their utility. Existing methods employ one single LLM-based
agent to iteratively select and execute tools, thereafter incorporating
execution results into the next action prediction. Despite their progress,
these methods suffer from performance degradation when addressing practical
tasks due to: (1) the pre-defined pipeline with restricted flexibility to
calibrate incorrect actions, and (2) the struggle to adapt a general LLM-based
agent to perform a variety of specialized actions. To mitigate these problems,
we propose ConAgents, a Cooperative and interactive Agents framework, which
coordinates three specialized agents for tool selection, tool execution, and
action calibration separately. ConAgents introduces two communication protocols
to enable the flexible cooperation of agents. To effectively generalize the
ConAgents into open-source models, we also propose specialized action
distillation, enhancing their ability to perform specialized actions in our
framework. Our extensive experiments on three datasets show that the LLMs, when
equipped with the ConAgents, outperform baselines with substantial improvement
(i.e., up to 14% higher success rate).
|
[
-0.1239472926,
-0.7581628561,
0.5900862217,
0.087542437,
-0.2310566008,
0.5660400987,
-0.4011725485,
-0.24772726,
0.0302502755,
0.5117371082,
-0.5081097484,
-0.6169493794,
-0.6449084878,
0.0589196272,
-0.1659596115,
0.8456068039,
-0.0048627863,
0.2100453675,
-0.0164482277,
-0.3687032759,
-0.6216431856,
-0.2274413705,
-0.991556108,
-0.6623766422,
0.6696307659,
0.7076090574,
0.9813325405,
0.333047241,
0.4202696383,
0.6128476858,
0.3856040239,
0.3184991479,
-0.5429845452,
0.2326028794,
-0.4106830955,
-0.7042276263,
-0.4635126591,
0.2143672109,
0.2531047463,
0.6408905387,
-0.3719832599,
-0.006483335,
0.192334488,
0.3008542359,
-0.5217769146,
0.2264819443,
-0.5528225899,
-0.1005272046,
0.1066393331,
-0.0659659952,
-0.562761426,
-0.3102937937,
0.2312570512,
-0.9054230452,
0.0750994757,
-0.1931753308,
0.0692864358,
0.423401773,
-0.3405292928,
-0.4865412712,
-0.7431941628,
0.8389329314,
-0.4974159896,
0.1741525382,
0.3411826789,
0.5268301368,
-0.5578768253,
-1.162587285,
-0.4942632616,
-0.4195450544,
-0.2752773762,
0.1319946498,
-0.0913932249,
0.1381610632,
0.2905578017,
-0.0128185414,
-0.387976408,
0.4584982693,
-0.2728719711,
-0.2235239297,
0.6339606047,
0.3122766316,
0.0801035538,
0.5530173779,
-0.3089934289,
-0.2596472502,
-0.3486487567,
0.1605125219,
0.3060132563,
0.3537224233,
-0.3173643351,
0.426825583,
0.1130395904,
0.5420972109,
0.1120791212,
-0.2071883529,
0.193721354,
-0.1036349162,
-0.5132384896,
-0.3629704416,
0.7817651033,
-0.0555549376,
0.2472648323,
-0.3462385535,
-0.1728243977,
0.0420105644,
0.0853279009,
-0.591588378,
-0.3736786842,
0.3187183142,
0.0683539212,
-0.1162801459,
-0.0247903503,
-0.3104008734,
-0.4760992527,
-0.5226560831,
0.5500047207,
-0.2681263685,
-0.2736525238,
0.2313763797,
-0.2913998663,
-0.0179975647,
0.6727166176,
-0.5074334145,
0.7029191852,
0.7747344971,
0.8495151401,
-0.3258701265,
-0.4821037352,
-1.3015705347,
0.1350319982,
-0.1931783706,
0.5511860251,
-0.8695781827,
-0.5978111029,
-0.102769509,
0.220828414,
0.0453656502,
-0.4369664192,
0.1502680182,
-0.551450789,
-0.0778262988,
-0.2498104423,
-0.3737792373,
-0.3778214753,
0.1926223934,
-1.0269633532,
0.7220816016,
0.2598639727,
-0.4228147268,
0.2560977042,
-0.6584601402,
-0.2633055151,
0.3119421005,
-0.4058666825,
-0.3497689962,
-0.1030638814,
-0.2535715997,
0.5089606047,
-0.3349037468,
0.2062018067,
-0.4534034431,
-0.5677084923,
0.2353483886,
-0.2298801094,
0.7131899595,
-0.0340496041,
-0.1892656386,
0.5374732614,
-0.4579618275,
-0.2011366189,
-0.1439390332,
-0.3991338611,
-0.1485920995,
-0.0204637237,
-0.2292916328,
0.3522646427,
0.0764953196,
-0.6270772219,
0.2738449872,
-0.3032021224,
0.2294516712,
0.8788720369,
-0.2032451183,
0.7052130699,
-0.3920396268,
0.6791547537,
-0.0810320675,
0.2178538442,
0.2100125402,
-0.1193966493,
-0.644649446,
-0.3757736981,
0.105027765,
0.438567698,
-1.0797960758,
0.2375665456,
-0.0519970357,
-0.8916136026,
-0.2639272213,
0.3290711641,
0.443562001,
0.2559147179,
0.1361144334,
-0.6046774387,
-0.2447513044,
-0.5302237868,
-0.0893152431,
-0.1047796085,
-0.0840458497,
0.0909929425,
0.2256369293,
0.0177166555,
0.8544661403,
-0.1421051025,
-0.2270994335,
-0.4272171855,
0.0585165732,
0.0948030949,
0.3107556403,
0.4374614954,
-0.865631938,
-0.8421781063,
0.2229270637,
-0.4897103608,
0.0275691412,
0.1135133281,
0.0389796011,
0.0156436823,
0.5393177867,
-0.3130289018,
0.2228154391,
0.869383812,
-0.1391507536,
0.4952636659,
-0.2485326082,
-0.2897466421,
-1.0168610811,
0.0291785635,
0.0631064698,
-0.5011075735,
-0.5038636923,
-0.1431187391,
-0.2500384748,
0.1146630868,
-0.7181175351,
0.6916497946,
-0.4196430147,
-0.0568505526,
-0.4167425334,
0.2745833695,
-0.0532937795,
0.6520682573,
0.013696528,
0.7604409456,
0.6417241096,
-0.5599752665,
0.6736142039,
0.1085340232,
0.1368805021,
0.3363297284,
-0.792961359,
0.2385502756,
0.1368099898,
0.2590647936,
-0.7305122614,
-0.2171728611,
0.2985459566,
-0.1221103221,
0.3051201999,
-0.1125373691,
-0.6443223953,
0.0496502146,
-0.3797642291,
-0.0503989123,
0.281385839,
-0.3500549197,
0.9221432805,
0.3121542037,
-0.0461580306,
-0.8355277777,
-0.5628988743,
-0.2232818305,
-0.0160246678,
-0.3499753475,
0.0348077007,
-0.2555024624,
-0.3388919234,
-0.0666307136,
0.0127787702,
0.1503115892,
0.2819198966,
0.4914275408,
-0.047946129,
0.2308385968,
0.4715029895,
-0.0607977286,
-0.2684357464,
-0.1623833477,
0.1154354289,
0.5818739533,
-0.1598850936,
-0.6196718216,
-0.1091428474,
0.5125774741,
0.5671834946,
-0.5092098117,
0.6775224805,
0.6781800985,
0.0517429709,
-0.4529176056,
-0.4613677561,
-0.4164859354,
-0.6355167031,
0.4430137873,
-0.2723650932,
-1.0014417171,
0.5326346159,
-0.6144519448,
0.4827859104,
-0.1467972398,
0.5899277329,
0.1618411839,
0.9185356498,
0.9606381059,
0.0779046789,
0.734949708,
-0.4009372592,
-0.0698581785,
-0.5852794051,
-0.180347681,
-0.3426775336,
-0.5654502511,
-0.7777274847,
-0.387290895,
0.5467143655,
-0.1311596632,
-0.1935766041,
0.2791582644,
-0.2940887809,
0.5145487189,
0.6076552272,
0.2115735412,
0.395575732,
0.0156503581,
-0.2699571252,
0.302534759,
-0.6363476515,
-0.7438325286,
1.0031975508,
0.2101578116,
0.938498795,
0.2858881652,
0.7162451148,
0.2339466065,
0.5247081518,
-0.9426784515,
0.7422276735,
-0.2508987784,
-0.1396544129,
-0.3694732487,
-0.0410810895,
-1.1330400705,
0.2583392859,
-0.0684059486,
-0.6744330525,
0.1634114683,
0.036922656,
-0.3125740588,
0.1252623945,
-0.8839101195,
0.7564122677,
-0.127715081,
-0.7680529356,
-0.4577722549,
-0.7648154497,
-0.1353052258,
-0.1703309268,
0.1865091473,
-0.1461206228,
-0.3664595783,
0.2502713501,
-0.4258988798,
1.1945866346,
-0.2379673868,
0.0206794366,
0.311973691,
0.4203719497,
0.8432958126,
0.0504344516,
-0.5120666623,
-0.1774877459,
-0.1787337959,
-0.2703516781,
-0.7949291468,
0.7020482421,
-0.8246551752,
-0.8020868301,
-0.2206474096,
-0.5901777148,
-0.1052554548,
0.1285938323,
-0.2549517751,
0.4924225807,
-0.189821437,
0.231771782,
0.1532959491,
0.0948754922,
0.7984289527,
1.04324615,
-0.0122897867,
-0.2162933946,
0.6207079887,
0.1456841379,
0.5206528306,
0.0657996088,
0.1223498881,
-0.0008957804,
-0.5787228346,
-0.0481325947,
0.1846418232,
-0.8628183007,
-0.2447382957,
-0.5331650972,
0.0905972719,
0.0191681404,
-0.3684483469,
-0.1877830923,
-0.0845434368,
-0.2441429645,
-0.1642489135,
0.5091750622,
0.6639591455,
-0.1497593671,
0.5728439093,
-0.8270018697,
-0.1472955197,
0.4323546588,
0.2558801472,
-0.1608296484,
-0.0446423516,
-0.3075045645,
-0.0211595371,
-0.6304832101,
-0.7198354006,
0.2255735248,
0.309056133,
0.7702355981,
0.0220113043,
0.260210067,
0.2727284431,
-0.3613717556,
0.5403729677,
-0.0579834059,
-0.7737477422,
0.2258225083,
-0.140696004,
0.2508533597,
0.4416134953,
0.4542041123,
-0.3728926778,
-0.6179249883,
-0.580962956,
-0.5315788388,
0.8490741849,
0.1734063476,
0.1857636571,
0.1383755058,
0.1201246902,
0.4840325713,
0.2549006343,
-0.5845171213,
0.0320368931,
0.1520664245,
-0.136634022,
-0.2834585011,
0.346391499,
-0.3116214871,
0.106061019,
0.581864357,
-0.4881387949,
-0.2844413221,
0.1126897112,
-0.172789678,
-0.2298561782,
0.2647666633,
0.1524651647,
0.6854560971,
0.2445159405,
0.0577246137,
0.2231708169,
-0.4076399505,
0.3030782342,
0.0836477801,
0.3533019423,
-0.0786395222,
0.3556182683,
0.6158871055,
0.1813335568,
-0.6965620518,
0.4752581716,
-0.1981932968,
0.1546640545,
-0.3400112391,
0.5096177459,
0.2763674259,
0.7555662394,
0.0743204281,
0.1103496403,
0.1989685148,
-0.6042738557,
0.2105634362,
0.4409342408,
-0.4557610452,
-0.5096567273,
-0.0237228591,
0.5871828198,
-0.7028288841,
0.1861783117,
-0.3052513301,
-0.1699046642,
0.6804295778,
0.3071837127,
0.8988255858,
-0.4688186049,
0.3668064475,
0.0246450808,
0.1839575768,
-0.1552926898,
0.3095077276,
-0.0834474042,
-0.6998563409,
-0.4790982306,
-0.3773373067,
-0.6319561601,
0.0265567508,
-0.3586216867,
0.5747641921,
-0.4527498782,
-0.257717222,
0.002748756,
0.2281678617,
-0.9729686975,
-0.0390828364,
-0.5260735154,
0.8873601556,
-0.7967903018,
1.0814323425,
0.9509875178,
-0.4513647854,
-1.0653361082,
-0.1765865535,
0.0652142391,
-0.435669899,
0.3762420416,
0.0370481387,
-0.4035422206,
0.2202757001,
-0.7343187928,
-0.5259378552,
1.2736421824,
0.7397369742,
-0.8336166143,
0.081014581,
0.1162886694,
0.6619208455,
-0.345962435,
0.3493071496,
0.3987944424,
0.320753336,
0.2596378624,
-1.2998023033,
0.1263962388,
0.0320437923,
-0.3734247983,
0.1167810708,
-0.8626599908,
0.8572568893,
-0.1709777713,
-0.1623558849,
-0.1475096345,
0.197533533,
0.3407761455,
0.2412154078,
0.5399355888,
0.0504053347,
0.55449754,
0.1994423121,
0.8430945873,
0.0674329177,
0.1496217847,
1.3441904783,
-0.4789772332,
0.7820646167,
0.4721880257,
0.0756185129,
0.612627089,
0.3470123708,
0.1455504745,
0.5266320705,
0.0956708267,
-0.5151526332,
-0.4585861862,
-0.1440539062,
0.2401005179,
0.7055631876,
0.6191114783,
-0.1966863275,
-0.4140530825,
0.096166946,
-0.0049379519,
0.3261809647,
-0.159869343,
1.0420603752,
0.2649921179,
-0.7277560234,
0.1621601582,
-0.0630942807,
0.4629920125,
-0.8185754418,
-0.3508425057,
0.0503989309,
0.3619175255,
-0.2000122666,
-0.7717280388,
0.1979345232,
-0.3549290597,
0.1947484016,
0.1812608391,
0.7838613391,
-0.5990760326,
-0.1729952246,
0.6253566742,
0.6066271067,
-0.03441469,
0.1922933012,
-0.7094095945,
0.2436062694,
-0.371692121,
-0.1886706352,
0.2435004413,
0.616967082,
-0.2272224426,
0.8262910843,
0.5876849294,
-0.0501199551,
-0.2597387135,
0.0358127914,
1.2247772217,
-0.0609044358,
-0.2812953889,
-0.915412426,
0.8152397871,
-0.2349536419,
0.2018045485,
0.6589443684,
0.2628669739,
0.9925910234,
0.017470099,
0.9121875167,
0.127413094,
0.3037691116,
-0.2728540599,
0.4285156429,
-0.2965550721,
0.3771763146,
-0.0762420893,
-0.7379914522,
-0.1938079149,
0.3282829523,
-0.2820947468,
0.1892855316,
0.5489129424,
0.7687411308,
-0.3172124326,
-0.2305746675,
0.4905424416,
-0.043041531,
0.700645864,
0.4674913883,
0.4225169122,
-0.1294543445,
0.4298987389,
-0.2034506649,
-0.3279343843,
-0.1876789927,
-0.9025970101,
-1.0371112823,
-0.5015336871,
-0.2985779643,
0.0551337264,
0.0240879077,
1.2664465904,
0.7812390327,
-0.4993523359,
-0.4453653693,
-0.1724286973,
0.1708742827,
-0.188742891,
-0.0786258057,
0.073211804,
-0.4063853323,
-0.9659336209,
0.340603888,
0.3138449192,
-0.0485213026,
-0.4028547406,
-0.4088197351,
-0.0749639794,
0.0384784453,
0.460860461,
0.2446971089,
-0.723398149,
-0.375869751,
-0.0033842241,
-0.0335314125,
-0.2079084218,
0.8863486648,
-0.8877144456,
0.7538428307,
0.3753888309,
0.3682846725,
0.2387044728,
-0.2751590312,
0.9129202366,
-1.0731705427,
0.5164925456,
0.4566600621,
0.1872280538,
0.3260731697,
-0.146933943,
0.5336050391,
-0.1734970361,
-0.6391479969,
-0.5980358124,
0.3638332784,
-0.8408346772,
-0.0916546583,
1.1207728386,
-0.534730494,
-0.0746132433,
-0.4667550921,
-0.5758420825,
0.5608366728,
-0.599327147,
0.4942121506,
0.560580194,
-0.049455706,
-0.1876271516,
-0.311611861,
0.5904234052,
0.0852992162,
-0.6660309434,
0.1168211326,
0.3900027871,
0.4515821636,
0.1487924457,
0.4725278616,
0.1103801131,
0.3851439655,
-0.1524381489,
0.0472759716,
-0.4146031439,
-0.27083987,
-0.2549471557,
0.0407553948,
0.3467083275,
-0.1946426779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03029v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03029v1
|
Socratic Reasoning Improves Positive Text Rewriting
| 2024-03-05T15:05:06 | 2024-03-05T15:05:06 |
Anmol Goel, Nico Daheim, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reframing a negative into a positive thought is at the crux of several
cognitive approaches to mental health and psychotherapy that could be made more
accessible by large language model-based solutions. Such reframing is typically
non-trivial and requires multiple rationalization steps to uncover the
underlying issue of a negative thought and transform it to be more positive.
However, this rationalization process is currently neglected by both datasets
and models which reframe thoughts in one step. In this work, we address this
gap by augmenting open-source datasets for positive text rewriting with
synthetically-generated Socratic rationales using a novel framework called
\textsc{SocraticReframe}. \textsc{SocraticReframe} uses a sequence of
question-answer pairs to rationalize the thought rewriting process. We show
that such Socratic rationales significantly improve positive text rewriting for
different open-source LLMs according to both automatic and human evaluations
guided by criteria from psychotherapy research.
|
[
-0.2293438762,
-0.6239559054,
0.8914660811,
0.1634289026,
-0.5262654424,
0.0379799642,
-0.2519607842,
-0.2981924713,
0.3896563351,
0.61498034,
-0.489071995,
-0.5147473812,
-0.3221141696,
0.226316765,
-0.2423449904,
1.0988519192,
-0.1315733045,
0.4213556945,
-0.2990615368,
-0.0649656802,
-0.3231722414,
-0.4882110357,
-0.6483223438,
-0.635979712,
0.4752369523,
0.4344538152,
0.7637934089,
-0.0426831506,
0.2658286393,
0.1235167906,
0.1135510728,
0.1856649667,
-0.7706124187,
0.5988150835,
-0.3929128051,
-0.761682868,
-0.4287693799,
0.0972428173,
0.4005877078,
0.4608050585,
-0.229623422,
0.2189504802,
-0.1613224745,
0.7643831968,
-0.5065648556,
-0.0567377247,
-0.652965188,
0.043550387,
0.1076574028,
-0.2772980034,
-0.5180774927,
-0.8275012374,
-0.0511807129,
-0.7500564456,
0.4937380254,
-0.1537432075,
0.5663107634,
0.2213520408,
-0.4801571369,
0.0082939621,
-0.7349097133,
0.6486855745,
-0.8513496518,
0.5239985585,
0.3685839474,
0.228259936,
-0.4359239638,
-0.4298741519,
-0.5783448815,
-0.0393755361,
-0.0290987976,
0.125206545,
0.0719542652,
0.1043881327,
0.3443234861,
0.3291616142,
-0.2405352443,
-0.4748882353,
-0.4864591658,
-0.4689527452,
0.7191275358,
0.1840438247,
0.0576623045,
-0.1178789809,
-0.0890769809,
0.3012156188,
-0.7353727818,
0.0948537514,
-0.1426630169,
0.0366149433,
0.2212278992,
0.6801292896,
-0.2419206798,
0.4493932128,
0.1275071502,
-0.4672540128,
0.2732946575,
-0.535315752,
-0.1766135395,
0.1823222488,
0.262375325,
0.7678080201,
0.3438247442,
-0.478374064,
-0.0706073642,
0.5250477791,
0.4181895852,
-0.850446403,
0.0705509931,
0.4134031236,
-0.2495483011,
-0.1453680843,
-0.3264846802,
-0.5404841304,
-0.5895984769,
-0.7263523936,
0.179057315,
-0.6401074529,
-0.0678010657,
0.6971470118,
-0.2424653322,
0.3287091851,
0.8237593174,
-0.4569892287,
-0.002933416,
0.8834765553,
0.8096520305,
0.3365449905,
0.1321694106,
-0.591896534,
0.1985479593,
-0.4538111389,
1.0547157526,
-0.6342520118,
-0.2815126479,
-0.1963269562,
-0.0318618044,
0.1933808178,
-0.3768137395,
0.787920773,
-0.2572007477,
0.4593353868,
-0.4072277248,
-0.459056139,
-0.096701555,
0.4218252599,
-0.2184160054,
0.7529212236,
-0.0923013389,
-0.7810290456,
0.313634038,
-0.1882462651,
-0.5933255553,
-0.0422752388,
-0.3480449021,
-0.4044856429,
0.3575975597,
0.1930736154,
0.1570582986,
-0.6025819182,
0.4357573986,
-0.5850798488,
-0.3901319802,
0.5166131258,
-0.2376743555,
0.9182082415,
0.1382888705,
-0.4060130715,
0.3293524086,
-0.6477614045,
0.3075256944,
-0.1006790772,
-0.0925727263,
-0.3906917572,
-0.085544534,
-0.3042071164,
0.303591609,
-0.0067359065,
-0.9073007107,
0.1783517152,
-0.5008494258,
0.5844055414,
0.6908913255,
0.421582669,
0.3740508258,
-0.5908071995,
0.7615859509,
-0.2153107971,
0.1122490838,
-0.0649939626,
-0.6357783079,
-0.6856221557,
-0.4322992861,
-0.2879438996,
0.3303617835,
-0.9329792857,
-0.1009012684,
0.0267608296,
-0.6466761231,
-0.9409401417,
-0.0360150374,
0.3434948623,
0.6361461282,
0.4356763661,
-0.2584387064,
-0.4468982816,
-0.8641417623,
-0.2062059492,
-0.0809734166,
0.1595716774,
0.1500220895,
0.2432320267,
-0.2328531593,
0.8315908909,
-0.78412503,
0.0746560618,
-0.1424062997,
0.175941214,
0.0170210525,
0.3829143047,
0.3241089582,
-0.5205301642,
-0.4170386493,
-0.5483538508,
-0.7146707177,
-0.3110095561,
-0.5363532901,
-0.6824011803,
-0.0459966846,
0.4460468292,
-0.6463282704,
0.7558090687,
-0.2448677123,
-0.6306888461,
1.0086814165,
-0.1052143052,
0.3268333972,
-0.9716526866,
-0.0731250122,
0.0613339469,
-0.2760929167,
-0.4808027744,
0.1082857624,
-0.0845756158,
-0.2970724404,
-0.1957137436,
0.270829469,
-0.2740724385,
0.0330848433,
-0.2080520988,
0.5459528565,
0.2969360054,
0.4134297073,
-0.1805315167,
0.9013428688,
0.4282748997,
-0.1746937037,
0.2716042399,
0.291716814,
-0.3645471036,
0.565166533,
-0.6314758062,
0.1446627378,
-0.7062999606,
0.6234986782,
-0.9482222795,
0.0076883081,
0.5002741218,
-0.3665514588,
-0.2260988802,
0.2331463844,
-0.260053575,
0.0543359034,
-0.6562358141,
0.45801422,
0.135213539,
-0.2069943994,
0.1639168113,
0.1977389008,
-0.0981295928,
-0.4573753774,
-0.599863112,
0.1662993431,
-0.0242332388,
-0.617643714,
0.5983597636,
-0.3016052246,
-0.4876597226,
-0.0778431892,
-0.1962472051,
0.1174320504,
0.0723699033,
0.155678153,
0.3345749378,
-0.1957055479,
0.4548859,
0.2039460838,
-0.347591579,
0.2354876399,
-0.0392121635,
0.473400712,
-0.2126499414,
-0.1567497551,
-0.4408963025,
0.4069919586,
0.8236849904,
-0.5333595872,
0.8528558016,
0.3653364778,
-0.4916601479,
-0.2152352184,
-0.3809286654,
-0.2857731283,
-0.3649383783,
0.0405897573,
-0.1660735309,
-1.0050108433,
0.2217062116,
0.2299771905,
0.0346992575,
-0.1001944393,
0.5954170227,
0.1456921548,
0.8559055328,
0.1583246589,
0.3020007908,
0.351474762,
-0.1781333983,
0.6070544124,
-1.0447540283,
-0.0947902873,
-0.3407243192,
-0.2127059549,
-0.3783667386,
-0.6145815253,
0.233133316,
0.2839338481,
-0.3693151176,
0.0744626597,
-0.7437480092,
0.3978415132,
0.1860244572,
0.5715443492,
0.4815712571,
-0.0751157179,
-0.1902872175,
-0.2957967222,
-0.4149589241,
-0.6786291599,
1.0449252129,
0.0683478266,
0.5530546904,
0.1920071989,
0.836582303,
0.1799191386,
1.0428429842,
-0.7131305337,
0.8092647195,
0.2214132994,
-0.895634234,
-0.2599001229,
-0.2105047107,
-0.6302797794,
0.5506828427,
-0.5376191735,
-0.6831377745,
0.377804935,
0.1148336902,
-0.5541138053,
0.0636685342,
-0.8037284017,
0.6649388671,
-0.2562467456,
-0.6492996812,
-0.6991735101,
-0.325496912,
0.3713346124,
-0.1033062264,
0.1536623687,
-0.3242809176,
0.0054166117,
0.4423545301,
-0.3639172316,
0.7771538496,
-0.218564719,
-0.2879557014,
0.4780565798,
0.1708150506,
0.2196253389,
0.5071009398,
-0.3626733124,
-0.2400843948,
0.0831927732,
-0.5287613273,
-0.9942005277,
0.5956915617,
-0.5479179025,
-1.0287722349,
-0.4570838809,
-0.2199553251,
-0.2640835941,
0.2469114363,
0.0515955649,
0.5579974055,
-0.1126225591,
0.2929528356,
0.4206087291,
-0.3132820725,
-0.2978057861,
0.7060261369,
-0.6518284678,
-0.8406892419,
0.6137886643,
0.0947024524,
0.4004163444,
0.23315157,
-0.0237870086,
-0.0823344663,
-0.5362749696,
0.0661171824,
0.6286495328,
-0.8173978329,
-0.2772917449,
-0.3168709278,
0.0234513506,
-0.7808226347,
-0.4098083079,
-0.0330763496,
-0.7024547458,
-0.1152250394,
-0.3208308518,
0.2629835904,
0.1750241071,
0.0307354294,
-0.1678147465,
-0.5754012465,
0.4861252308,
0.1268678606,
0.4132328033,
0.3822391033,
-0.3140411377,
-0.2020743638,
0.323405385,
-0.4160650373,
-1.0642185211,
0.3535729945,
-0.1246705055,
0.358045578,
0.2426999211,
0.3840006292,
0.7236973643,
-0.4336698353,
0.6033934951,
0.2471737266,
-0.7995448709,
0.4500442445,
-0.1886920929,
0.3145501912,
0.7769797444,
0.3405532837,
-0.8665244579,
-0.4260847867,
-0.4493781626,
-0.7252062559,
0.4790573418,
0.3836883605,
-0.3838286698,
-0.2528374493,
1.0496299267,
0.1600575745,
0.2697255313,
-0.7099027038,
-0.0518215932,
-0.536549449,
-0.174169004,
-0.4117420912,
-0.16518116,
-0.1230017841,
-0.4694818556,
1.0781302452,
-0.0783358663,
0.4074596167,
0.6750400066,
-0.0126306415,
-0.2696214616,
0.6577881575,
0.5385075808,
0.2696543932,
-0.3470461667,
0.3165080249,
-0.0800006911,
-0.2800513804,
0.4097562134,
-0.0535123385,
-0.4597209394,
-0.2426434457,
0.2535979748,
0.3745858371,
0.3101866543,
-0.7515363097,
0.2635909617,
-0.2237569988,
-0.0485957228,
-0.2927151322,
0.3206992447,
0.2674555182,
0.5063342452,
-0.0452398546,
0.2460414171,
0.06446895,
-0.654327035,
0.2187704146,
0.3892071247,
-0.2744753659,
-0.4213384092,
0.4412898421,
0.2480364591,
-0.6391386986,
0.6347861886,
-0.2100965381,
-0.6672002077,
0.3579072654,
0.9918320179,
0.98198843,
0.2078829706,
0.7431656122,
0.6743889451,
0.2456166148,
0.0499269441,
0.3848596513,
-0.3433214724,
-1.0614064932,
-0.4767278135,
-0.3512379825,
-0.4442273974,
0.0234331936,
-0.5917912126,
0.1992860734,
-0.6868344545,
-0.3075774908,
0.1351778507,
-0.087786302,
-0.2017028928,
0.2094297558,
0.1030069664,
0.8365100622,
-0.5500169396,
0.8809209466,
0.8365623951,
-0.5987553596,
-0.5485109091,
0.0684484169,
-0.1037866697,
-0.6033858061,
0.1787425727,
0.31968081,
-0.6210986972,
-0.1772513092,
-0.5886387229,
-0.7325911522,
1.1286648512,
0.7596618533,
-0.2970092893,
0.0350561514,
0.1238356307,
0.9056305885,
-0.4694801867,
0.0632064492,
0.268688798,
0.4375772178,
-0.0033096848,
-0.2735301852,
0.4248536527,
-0.4049643874,
-0.2250351012,
0.3205061257,
-0.6717879176,
0.5126399994,
-0.4447083175,
-0.3781067431,
-0.1429264098,
0.411683917,
0.2822986543,
0.4896067083,
0.3850103915,
0.6532183886,
0.9100663662,
0.2337152809,
0.8078600764,
-0.3154888153,
0.2042644322,
1.3402695656,
-0.4410853088,
0.7334707975,
0.4930954576,
-0.0943211094,
0.7762345076,
0.3809716403,
0.3298122287,
0.3387622833,
0.0209002402,
-0.5633485317,
-0.8075371981,
-0.1500937194,
-0.3085129261,
0.0331673175,
0.2761567831,
-0.2532068193,
-0.3228559196,
-0.088991791,
0.153458491,
0.4775895476,
-0.2105482966,
0.3695391417,
0.2758936286,
-1.045327425,
0.6530587673,
0.1290930063,
0.3133383989,
-0.2277384102,
-0.0862496421,
-0.2777778208,
0.3325462937,
-0.4523340762,
-0.7790692449,
0.535345912,
0.0920751542,
-0.2952332795,
-0.4476700127,
1.0150892735,
-0.3484967649,
-0.3813329637,
0.050997097,
0.1913699806,
-0.1052159369,
-0.0623297505,
-0.612909615,
-0.3051835597,
0.4799932539,
0.0693757236,
0.1552815586,
0.6075646877,
-0.025097765,
0.7014796138,
0.77729249,
0.0243944749,
-0.4076803625,
-0.0151587175,
0.9557242393,
-0.9994571805,
-0.4363836944,
-0.6263406277,
0.3715672791,
-0.2395159006,
-0.3165567815,
0.77632761,
0.5063112974,
0.6587891579,
0.2025794089,
0.5984351039,
0.2968283892,
0.5160250664,
-0.1619934142,
0.4717558324,
-0.3617582619,
0.4923863709,
-0.2502177656,
-0.8036682606,
-0.58114326,
0.9738790989,
-0.9372759461,
-0.5240566134,
0.5414486527,
0.9425318837,
0.3588402271,
0.4869373739,
0.0224078894,
0.3814649284,
0.686316371,
0.4264085889,
0.7192797065,
-0.1463844031,
0.1227209195,
-0.2019715458,
-0.3556620181,
0.0634881556,
-0.8357005119,
-0.7631561756,
-0.3399303854,
-0.3408117592,
-0.74538064,
0.1262898296,
1.2823389769,
0.1384819895,
-0.5530594587,
0.0070347926,
-0.2949241698,
0.4193376303,
-0.129945606,
-0.2870603502,
0.0388826542,
-0.2866412103,
0.1704721749,
0.1076978147,
0.4656864405,
-0.1883886606,
-0.3984024525,
-0.2276441008,
-0.2367912084,
0.5815801024,
0.6733967662,
0.0168437865,
-0.4931498766,
-0.5463192463,
0.0209662076,
-0.1252525449,
0.3691506684,
1.1037938595,
-0.9927748442,
0.6520566344,
0.5360751748,
0.3280185461,
0.6280516386,
0.0089964438,
0.7565372586,
0.0022172939,
0.0265885349,
0.4725749493,
0.3318195939,
0.4228833616,
-0.3643361926,
0.4191047549,
0.4732275307,
-0.4786558449,
-0.78095752,
0.4400708377,
-0.7748939991,
-0.5219789147,
0.9500896335,
-0.0639048442,
-0.269623816,
-0.2263879031,
-0.7852626443,
0.2029344887,
-0.4426245391,
1.2755717039,
0.7741981745,
-0.4244421124,
-0.0100185489,
0.086370185,
0.2402730584,
0.5505976081,
-0.7680820823,
0.3624740839,
0.7636279464,
0.2084650397,
0.1492169201,
0.9616253972,
-0.2271424085,
0.3604423404,
-0.0504167229,
-0.0609462112,
0.0489468537,
-0.0271279085,
-0.063277863,
0.1106679067,
-0.0602101311,
0.4767045379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03028v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03028v1
|
Word Importance Explains How Prompts Affect Language Model Outputs
| 2024-03-05T15:04:18 | 2024-03-05T15:04:18 |
Stefan Hackmann, Haniyeh Mahmoudian, Mark Steadman, Michael Schmidt
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.5.2
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized numerous
applications across industries. However, their "black box" nature often hinders
the understanding of how they make specific decisions, raising concerns about
their transparency, reliability, and ethical use. This study presents a method
to improve the explainability of LLMs by varying individual words in prompts to
uncover their statistical impact on the model outputs. This approach, inspired
by permutation importance for tabular data, masks each word in the system
prompt and evaluates its effect on the outputs based on the available text
scores aggregated over multiple user inputs. Unlike classical attention, word
importance measures the impact of prompt words on arbitrarily-defined text
scores, which enables decomposing the importance of words into the specific
measures of interest--including bias, reading level, verbosity, etc. This
procedure also enables measuring impact when attention weights are not
available. To test the fidelity of this approach, we explore the effect of
adding different suffixes to multiple different system prompts and comparing
subsequent generations with different large language models. Results show that
word importance scores are closely related to the expected suffix importances
for multiple scoring functions.
|
[
-0.3114338219,
-0.6131517291,
0.9185776711,
0.4844345748,
-0.0233326275,
-0.293343097,
-0.1156512126,
-0.1222019345,
0.0669596717,
0.2562265396,
-0.4511567056,
-0.3299633563,
-0.8238353729,
0.2045773119,
-0.3695136011,
0.9591758847,
0.1191767976,
0.0505600981,
-0.2959668338,
0.0997202769,
-0.7317988873,
-0.5696613193,
-0.4711007774,
-0.3180223405,
0.8530452251,
0.2925655842,
0.8951943517,
0.7400289774,
0.6142711639,
0.3447457254,
-0.3219760656,
-0.3178709149,
-0.6521127224,
0.1822529137,
-0.313036263,
-0.4502638578,
-0.3916549981,
0.1860569268,
0.7741018534,
0.9076681137,
0.1895029694,
0.4375700951,
0.3492406011,
0.343265295,
-0.5096870065,
0.3048053384,
-0.5407494903,
-0.3027000725,
-0.1949594915,
-0.5729029775,
-0.3994930983,
-0.3471769392,
0.089476347,
-0.3272698224,
0.051633846,
0.1194230169,
0.9899483323,
0.215107426,
-0.0660125688,
-0.1464245319,
-0.5671354532,
0.889716804,
-0.6510919333,
0.3273313344,
0.1345014274,
0.0906030759,
-0.5426133871,
-0.2094973326,
-0.4146153927,
-0.0256735925,
-0.0917818695,
-0.0347170271,
-0.1126425788,
0.4840890467,
0.3551169336,
0.2609127164,
-0.2041736096,
0.1670695096,
-0.1756477803,
-0.2911269963,
0.3498266935,
0.3376102448,
0.7031978369,
-0.142237395,
-0.1992612481,
-0.0827983096,
-0.8498159051,
0.5269386172,
0.4843819737,
0.4034153819,
0.0217404645,
0.7508631349,
-0.1926191449,
0.680649817,
-0.0756089911,
-0.4302292764,
0.045290865,
-0.4422705472,
-0.0923065096,
0.2256712466,
0.6468495727,
0.3467942774,
0.0697445944,
-0.1149736047,
-0.1786858141,
-0.0634952337,
0.0930088684,
-0.7384201884,
0.2788445055,
0.2946504056,
-0.4662571847,
-0.1752836406,
0.174625963,
-0.6811156869,
-0.5699424744,
-0.3371556997,
0.675000608,
-0.1705425978,
0.0205972623,
0.1931188405,
-0.3295192122,
0.1111141071,
0.6965603232,
-1.0232678652,
0.0110356016,
0.8449544311,
0.5374881029,
-0.2392249703,
-0.3995220363,
-0.8472933173,
-0.0400057845,
-0.3676621914,
0.8114571571,
-0.8389843702,
-0.2422779649,
-0.0651516691,
0.0700291395,
-0.0243310761,
-0.3581881225,
0.5749880075,
-0.3009067774,
0.1592881978,
-0.3947776258,
-0.5489211082,
-0.2551772296,
-0.1779656261,
-0.4417642653,
0.7162308693,
-0.0348583236,
-0.6628577113,
0.3745614588,
-0.6552792788,
-0.4692140818,
0.3028895855,
-0.1786900908,
-0.0139907524,
0.6100823879,
0.0766310245,
0.624845624,
-0.3802632093,
0.2903539538,
-0.2156974524,
-0.4593959153,
0.6567409039,
-0.5311741233,
0.5483745933,
-0.224883914,
-0.2298087627,
0.1731566042,
-0.6198990345,
-0.0824011266,
-0.1408693343,
-0.6826376915,
-0.6052173972,
-0.0464949682,
-0.1886770427,
-0.0529268123,
0.1906418651,
-0.1390596926,
-0.1113285944,
-0.4010053277,
0.2971564531,
0.7135130167,
0.1649919748,
0.3322591484,
0.0126224514,
0.9730786681,
-0.1647607535,
0.1289269477,
-0.4710909426,
-0.7591420412,
-0.5605855584,
-0.3721597195,
0.4061956704,
0.4330975711,
-0.2522855103,
0.4155016541,
-0.2997561097,
-0.185443759,
-0.500005424,
-0.0333079994,
0.3685706258,
0.2596206069,
-0.0973671973,
-0.1254470348,
-0.3165320754,
-1.0045735836,
-0.5049885511,
-0.3132202625,
-0.025326604,
0.3141751289,
0.2779590189,
-0.1097285151,
1.0523474216,
-0.5535522699,
0.264269948,
-0.4162990749,
-0.0146357287,
0.4404173493,
-0.0907090455,
0.321052283,
-0.3400711417,
0.0226734858,
-0.2441403866,
-0.3998547196,
-0.6253107786,
-0.3529213369,
-0.2816159427,
-0.3069761992,
0.3988130987,
-0.6383430958,
0.4744694829,
0.5282343626,
-0.5909540653,
0.7124226689,
-0.2467160076,
0.2668005526,
-0.6837251782,
-0.0848001912,
-0.0057488591,
0.0654705241,
-0.7360515594,
-0.0480505265,
0.0441540852,
-0.3362639546,
-0.3632187843,
0.7939335108,
-0.6139742732,
-0.3073607087,
-0.1313589513,
0.2524905801,
0.2847349644,
0.1156430468,
-0.532576263,
0.9962304235,
0.3183735609,
-0.8775917292,
-0.010018195,
0.023050433,
-0.4275547862,
0.1699485779,
-0.6213510036,
-0.3037613928,
-0.1512723863,
-0.2776737809,
-1.5865391493,
-0.0383046903,
-0.0527912378,
-0.5413137674,
0.3094439805,
0.1163622662,
-0.391928643,
-0.2368863225,
-0.3815752268,
0.1501146406,
0.2146406174,
-0.4600309134,
0.4341858327,
0.6561822891,
-0.2679814994,
-0.4319995046,
-0.5324799418,
0.2293544859,
-0.4405353367,
-0.5127530694,
0.1288853139,
-0.0258260891,
-0.5476195216,
-0.178738147,
-0.1627736092,
0.345731914,
0.6379352212,
0.4170616865,
0.2850328982,
-0.0747842863,
0.6659877896,
0.1082016304,
-0.1982156187,
0.285005033,
-0.0393872187,
0.5778535008,
0.1484682411,
-0.0824189335,
-0.3390761912,
0.289199084,
0.6413782239,
-0.2227576822,
0.9539992809,
0.2695698738,
-0.2267978936,
-0.18026869,
-0.5720895529,
-0.3711319268,
-0.4723185599,
0.4793792367,
-0.294133395,
-0.7849157453,
0.551435709,
0.1034838781,
-0.01587536,
0.5738844275,
0.469774127,
0.077885434,
0.9363208413,
0.6669317484,
0.0282115526,
0.7136155367,
0.3243408203,
0.4653285742,
-0.793314755,
0.1473579854,
-0.6119124293,
-0.1132437363,
-0.492582798,
-0.2858127952,
0.420271486,
0.2622973025,
0.0988504663,
0.0360478126,
-0.3994702995,
0.5079641938,
0.3380261958,
-0.1153987423,
0.3971388638,
0.3270731866,
-0.0211719573,
-0.1417115927,
-0.6122770905,
-0.8645373583,
0.9562255144,
0.6145372391,
0.8622134328,
0.1504880488,
0.5335056186,
0.2305310369,
0.1286321878,
-0.8895717859,
0.7065794468,
-0.1503050923,
-0.399863869,
-0.6211729646,
-0.4535288215,
-1.1951369047,
0.3253045678,
-0.2067743987,
-0.8827144504,
0.0913699791,
0.1349168122,
-0.6720089912,
-0.2169654518,
-0.9668973088,
0.6418015957,
-0.1474743485,
-0.3086446226,
-0.3116645515,
-0.2323874682,
0.3509807885,
0.0657427385,
0.38879475,
-0.1847864836,
-0.2841767371,
0.9572363496,
-0.5025242567,
0.9300622344,
0.1241081655,
-0.2389828861,
0.1376787424,
0.016202623,
0.4101557136,
0.0108124455,
-0.0784834176,
0.3383542895,
-0.3284954131,
0.036649432,
-0.6764412522,
0.9096733928,
-0.6716463566,
-1.22757411,
-0.2216843963,
-0.780621767,
-0.0180223379,
0.0268325675,
0.009330119,
0.6910451055,
0.0897618011,
-0.0608859807,
0.6695072651,
-0.590837419,
0.424870044,
0.3820113242,
-0.329592526,
-0.1803431362,
0.7784129977,
0.4607184529,
0.3381506503,
0.4032720327,
0.6106786132,
-0.2102115154,
-0.4552527368,
-0.3832085133,
0.4171619713,
-0.9154210091,
0.1016347408,
-0.8891025186,
0.0332984142,
-0.3804885447,
-0.0897480175,
0.2335287631,
-0.3948788643,
-0.5067796707,
-0.0968544036,
0.7157773972,
0.7289242744,
0.3045557737,
0.4917254746,
-0.6835511923,
0.1912867576,
0.4550584257,
0.5346199274,
0.1881220341,
-0.7455758452,
-0.1313231289,
-0.4010567963,
-0.0594628863,
-1.2055308819,
0.2512078881,
-0.0112552783,
0.9623775482,
0.4850741029,
-0.2129226476,
0.539790988,
-0.4908932447,
0.7325304151,
0.2611240447,
-1.1428307295,
0.5050604343,
-0.469887048,
0.7033499479,
0.4530940056,
0.047041744,
-0.6125742197,
-0.4666654468,
-0.4887571037,
-1.0289107561,
0.9402768016,
0.1371825039,
0.0584479049,
-0.1629622281,
0.4441798329,
0.1493157893,
0.2164182067,
-0.4965166152,
-0.2487369925,
0.3539046049,
-0.1763810515,
-0.1403332651,
-0.692474246,
0.1586564034,
-0.1566863656,
0.6311516166,
0.2948772609,
0.1189094409,
0.1174568906,
-0.0108246692,
0.0336466692,
0.6616149545,
0.6111619473,
0.6798762679,
0.0730785951,
0.1628741622,
0.1420059204,
-0.625361979,
0.1601298302,
-0.1472176164,
-0.3051062822,
0.2423804849,
0.4370567501,
0.8696566224,
0.2910239697,
-0.6048846841,
0.3063859046,
0.1456094235,
0.3506910205,
0.166974172,
0.2028669715,
0.2487228513,
0.0171230938,
0.3648478389,
-0.2338155657,
0.3769256473,
-0.865403533,
-0.1420452446,
0.3752912581,
-0.3176075816,
-0.194751814,
0.2694508135,
0.2124892026,
-0.5587002039,
-0.0644089282,
-0.1214872748,
-0.5589995384,
0.8212955594,
0.4412464797,
0.7349123955,
-0.6173685193,
0.1511249691,
0.3706583083,
0.5586612225,
-0.2184288353,
0.2914307117,
0.3590119779,
-0.4383348823,
-0.4725186825,
-0.6126473546,
-0.2602129579,
0.2216717303,
-0.2491337061,
0.421908617,
-0.3846541941,
-0.4848461449,
0.2359495163,
-0.3892216086,
-0.6045623422,
0.0097128749,
0.0343659148,
0.4829514921,
-0.9757026434,
0.1730682254,
0.6455668807,
-0.2373462021,
-0.8918673396,
0.1320280135,
-0.0811198801,
-0.6413680315,
0.8225231171,
0.3735718429,
-0.2274126709,
-0.0871394575,
-0.2912226021,
-1.3545546532,
0.6436378956,
0.500643909,
-0.7007725835,
0.2987706065,
0.0303072128,
0.5334588289,
-0.4784162939,
0.7567613721,
0.5729985237,
0.6854973435,
-0.2742286026,
-0.7872905135,
0.1841747016,
0.0797591209,
0.2130202651,
0.3680851161,
-0.2128348202,
0.6544474959,
-0.5396239161,
-0.6734013557,
-0.3894094527,
0.2949659526,
0.2484218925,
0.1426362395,
0.5333778262,
0.1464896947,
0.7244058847,
-0.1294618398,
1.2059791088,
-0.0971811488,
0.054776296,
0.9576234818,
-0.0523084775,
0.6538547873,
0.6896323562,
-0.3649532199,
0.1710094064,
0.6127669215,
0.1144810393,
0.1721938848,
0.5792800188,
0.1337861717,
-0.3628813624,
-0.339799732,
-0.2181026191,
0.2326298505,
0.6493003964,
-0.6913555861,
-0.35315907,
0.1543439925,
0.1669604778,
-0.0130606806,
-0.4171530008,
0.6214504242,
0.0684273988,
-0.6936945915,
0.4835582078,
-0.1928144395,
0.4410962164,
-0.5373467803,
-0.084311083,
-0.1167770401,
0.0746067837,
-0.3192983568,
-0.8859488964,
-0.17904751,
0.0666659102,
-0.4945592284,
-0.1308687031,
0.4544283748,
-0.3717415333,
-0.7442099452,
0.4132807553,
0.4649564028,
0.4553482831,
-0.1315981299,
-0.2974817455,
0.3087126911,
-0.0373709612,
-0.473151952,
0.2980666459,
0.5828389525,
-0.2195037007,
0.6700015068,
0.6141143441,
0.2522267997,
-0.0193680953,
0.3067521453,
0.7350676656,
-0.6296192408,
-0.519494772,
-1.0863975286,
0.3530044258,
0.0654380471,
-0.4246934354,
0.9512932301,
0.3096656203,
0.0701690614,
-0.0035590783,
0.7116217613,
0.3616825938,
0.4487142563,
-0.4435586631,
0.7379190326,
-0.525069654,
0.7299448848,
-0.4282155335,
-0.9102727771,
-0.3368766606,
0.089218542,
-0.7540786266,
-0.0610538684,
0.7509274483,
0.7554877996,
0.2566229105,
-0.1711962223,
0.5386177301,
0.4763467312,
0.1567222774,
0.2202647477,
0.6560586691,
-0.2820581794,
0.605594337,
0.2427354604,
-0.565803051,
-0.3804944456,
-0.9466481209,
-0.8647587895,
-0.476679951,
-0.5000725389,
-0.3156575263,
0.0898226723,
0.8434737325,
0.2517135441,
-0.6582400799,
-0.1132260859,
0.3720779419,
0.3734833896,
-0.1797653437,
-0.2958731353,
0.5882099867,
-0.5113007426,
-0.3547284901,
0.2539389133,
0.577542007,
-0.0162367392,
-0.3136405647,
0.3099887371,
-0.0002850156,
0.330576241,
0.7066246867,
-0.1956638545,
-1.0756864548,
-0.4871809781,
-0.0294844694,
-0.2243618965,
-0.1466380954,
0.7020978332,
-0.671474278,
0.4886621237,
0.9832060933,
0.4904137254,
-0.3306520283,
-0.0177384578,
0.8362401128,
-0.3465305567,
-0.1890134513,
-0.2284820229,
0.5958039165,
0.4833920002,
-0.915997684,
0.2751743495,
0.0270777103,
-0.5246585011,
-0.7116519809,
0.1396380514,
-0.8461493254,
-0.3396623731,
1.625841856,
-0.131168589,
-0.4154396951,
-0.3634647131,
-0.3002682924,
0.0051712878,
-0.789737165,
0.8881803155,
1.0594987869,
0.2136687934,
-0.2554431856,
-0.5964013338,
0.3515350223,
0.543454349,
-0.726747036,
0.4867711067,
0.3927257061,
0.1464083046,
0.2723953128,
0.2156926244,
-0.2230840623,
0.056903962,
-0.3331073225,
0.3221793771,
0.1526898444,
-0.1747024059,
-0.8382979035,
0.2350747436,
0.1441801786,
-0.04075877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03014v1
|
The Case for Evaluating Multimodal Translation Models on Text Datasets
| 2024-03-05T14:49:52 | 2024-03-05T14:49:52 |
Vipin Vijayan, Braeden Bowen, Scott Grigsby, Timothy Anderson, Jeremy Gwinnup
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A good evaluation framework should evaluate multimodal machine translation
(MMT) models by measuring 1) their use of visual information to aid in the
translation task and 2) their ability to translate complex sentences such as
done for text-only machine translation. However, most current work in MMT is
evaluated against the Multi30k testing sets, which do not measure these
properties. Namely, the use of visual information by the MMT model cannot be
shown directly from the Multi30k test set results and the sentences in Multi30k
are are image captions, i.e., short, descriptive sentences, as opposed to
complex sentences that typical text-only machine translation models are
evaluated against.
Therefore, we propose that MMT models be evaluated using 1) the CoMMuTE
evaluation framework, which measures the use of visual information by MMT
models, 2) the text-only WMT news translation task test sets, which evaluates
translation performance against complex sentences, and 3) the Multi30k test
sets, for measuring MMT model performance against a real MMT dataset. Finally,
we evaluate recent MMT models trained solely against the Multi30k dataset
against our proposed evaluation framework and demonstrate the dramatic drop
performance against text-only testing sets compared to recent text-only MT
models.
|
[
-0.3832694292,
-0.382242471,
0.5302562714,
0.297504127,
-0.3748103976,
-0.1319115758,
-0.2711186707,
-0.2843366861,
-0.3167467415,
0.3489705324,
-0.7626393437,
-0.2686141729,
-0.6961360574,
0.379555434,
-0.7263090014,
1.0327751637,
-0.3741002381,
0.256963402,
-0.5122375488,
-0.3564684689,
-0.5718986392,
-0.4060438871,
-0.0955886543,
-0.248597905,
0.3744357824,
0.2493955642,
0.7832003832,
0.6802773476,
1.1272013187,
0.3559672236,
0.1950043887,
0.2779186666,
-0.2100845724,
-0.2765227556,
0.0511203073,
-0.4277045727,
-0.3148583472,
0.2642929554,
0.543915689,
0.7604670525,
0.1608198732,
0.2162180096,
-0.0879950374,
0.4787791073,
-0.4094280899,
0.4173110723,
-0.3900561929,
0.241536364,
-0.1864881516,
-0.3425844908,
-0.6953533888,
-0.0969147533,
0.1242579371,
-0.6533192396,
0.2043469548,
0.3311773837,
0.8244349957,
0.1481962353,
-0.9467449784,
-0.1796853095,
-0.5831292272,
0.9661930203,
-0.5308562517,
0.6552988887,
0.2425606996,
0.6199886203,
0.0253864117,
-0.4009960592,
-0.60462749,
-0.5362089872,
-0.0436721742,
0.6338151693,
-0.3278526068,
0.1026657,
0.3351964355,
0.4996371567,
-0.8402504325,
-0.1792850941,
-0.388238132,
-0.0747616664,
0.258026123,
0.3974739909,
0.3748351336,
-0.4604803622,
-0.7529982924,
-0.4626690149,
-0.4540811181,
0.0000915454,
0.0689772293,
0.188716054,
-0.3962421119,
1.0337184668,
-0.1164916679,
0.7726002336,
-0.3576445282,
-0.2024706006,
0.4792248011,
-0.7683370709,
-0.3886173069,
-0.473970592,
0.8265215755,
0.9036684632,
0.3071541786,
-0.3058017492,
-0.3691673279,
0.1957492828,
0.1762423217,
-0.92544204,
-0.0260027871,
-0.1071811244,
-0.6820725203,
-0.2262081206,
-0.0770101696,
-0.7483748794,
-0.1718851924,
-0.3853108287,
0.4200483561,
-0.3900090754,
-0.1143110693,
0.126505971,
-0.3282948732,
-0.0787631273,
0.3566587269,
-0.6099171042,
0.218532443,
0.2080869377,
0.758307755,
-0.338398397,
-0.5216652751,
-0.2959259748,
0.0167700537,
-0.2784331739,
0.7138859034,
-0.3646607995,
-0.0993163213,
-0.0120884329,
0.3068614006,
-0.7050816417,
-0.4573189914,
0.5373989344,
-0.3251250088,
0.035316132,
-0.239631623,
-0.4073878229,
-0.338324368,
0.4217218757,
-0.7402501106,
0.4897220135,
0.0466823727,
-0.6170356274,
0.5240238905,
-0.879404366,
-0.4998289049,
-0.2998655438,
0.1402469426,
-0.4584920406,
0.2103340328,
0.2977020144,
0.546204567,
-0.4423666894,
0.1954592764,
-0.542701304,
-0.370559752,
0.4599857926,
-0.8573054671,
0.3987125456,
0.4920963943,
-0.2089962512,
0.0540446118,
-0.6160776019,
-0.1305517852,
-0.0181120578,
-0.5081249475,
-0.2919120491,
-0.0538610108,
0.5323377252,
0.5353614092,
-0.114596568,
-0.5753331184,
0.1661943346,
-0.0393251553,
0.3047834337,
0.6438529491,
-0.2873152792,
0.3190277219,
-0.4723419249,
0.7345508337,
0.3182713389,
0.1184993684,
-0.4975351393,
-0.5390749574,
-0.8884260654,
-0.358438313,
0.2675244212,
0.5151361823,
-1.0563460588,
-0.1099232286,
-0.7147956491,
-0.4686480463,
-0.4926026165,
-0.201190412,
0.5022463799,
0.2857290804,
0.4663759172,
-0.1798925102,
-0.3676732779,
-1.1257641315,
-0.3879909217,
0.1305293888,
0.1164235696,
0.2257047147,
0.7340534925,
-0.1903703809,
0.5561620593,
-0.1814249754,
-0.0193680599,
-0.1657801121,
0.3611740172,
0.0252843369,
0.4179259241,
0.5474614501,
-1.0167694092,
-0.2872959971,
0.1979356557,
-0.9480449557,
0.0447006561,
-0.3212548494,
0.2371921688,
-0.1512996852,
0.1958986074,
-0.6375619173,
0.5241858959,
0.8866395354,
-0.3582737148,
0.5454748869,
-0.168566823,
0.8359515071,
-1.0065200329,
0.1249694824,
0.1241273955,
-0.5442304611,
-0.3710866868,
0.0351251476,
0.3141189814,
-0.2990025282,
-0.5302830935,
0.4712423086,
-0.3424623907,
-0.1398149878,
0.125827685,
0.0245174728,
0.1234116927,
0.3872191906,
-0.357601881,
0.9064416289,
0.0408372805,
-0.5448592305,
0.3346142173,
0.3644212484,
-0.6788397431,
0.8613538146,
-0.1793304086,
-0.099036701,
0.0811529905,
0.0897318721,
-1.0324277878,
-0.2241595536,
0.1488863379,
-0.3266859949,
0.0500564687,
0.015215178,
-0.8421293497,
-0.3998945653,
-0.1564169675,
0.3323261738,
0.0985518247,
-0.4659436941,
0.3985256553,
-0.0470127612,
0.0525000133,
-0.2939937711,
-0.9166907668,
0.3073044121,
-0.3144748807,
-0.833309114,
0.2135959417,
-0.2732541859,
0.0122655286,
-0.0952427685,
-0.0017404703,
-0.2103528976,
0.1526707262,
0.2984686494,
0.1923036277,
-0.1907382309,
0.1397267431,
0.1195664927,
-0.2145158499,
-0.1653319746,
0.0946824849,
0.3375314176,
-0.1689213514,
-0.5653657317,
-0.4202561378,
0.3824468255,
0.9809892178,
-0.4459840059,
0.6758601069,
0.8137265444,
-0.157494545,
0.4206848145,
-0.461322397,
-0.0145899998,
-0.330968529,
0.7576763034,
-0.7984586358,
-0.6399815083,
0.4176644683,
-0.1424548477,
0.0155405365,
0.5898085237,
0.6887526512,
-0.2352395207,
1.3383549452,
0.5379159451,
0.4441349208,
0.4497113228,
-0.1686227918,
0.135989517,
-0.8454141617,
-0.0124415383,
-0.3687919378,
-0.2149328738,
-0.6937993169,
-0.2001498789,
0.3765352368,
-0.2574505806,
0.0350498445,
0.4560804069,
-0.1694582105,
0.1691461056,
0.2090888172,
0.1489938349,
0.5495821238,
0.1458344162,
-0.2923618257,
-0.2861434519,
-0.6769982576,
-0.6640883088,
1.3362234831,
0.2796245813,
0.6721752286,
0.0840033814,
-0.0605837218,
0.3798987567,
0.5993947983,
-0.5621988177,
0.4061690867,
-0.4244926274,
-0.751708746,
0.0095961681,
-0.7974103093,
-0.9159733057,
0.5047938228,
-0.0977504849,
-0.0640807822,
0.119256027,
-0.0712724254,
-0.0781305805,
0.1692333072,
-1.0200411081,
1.2091217041,
-0.1943507344,
-0.0221123081,
-0.141847983,
-0.4789535999,
0.4489279985,
-0.1964330226,
0.5416119695,
-0.2016668171,
0.0822250545,
0.7906862497,
-0.0870526731,
0.6306337118,
-0.0909969062,
0.2080938071,
-0.0668262765,
0.0544604696,
0.2286673635,
-0.3481073976,
-0.0416147932,
-0.0263504889,
0.3747923672,
-0.3259078562,
-0.5743516088,
0.3817128241,
-0.6002898812,
-0.056496758,
-0.2410369515,
-0.9120006561,
-0.059695296,
0.1912914366,
0.2620268464,
0.3906023502,
-0.2166385651,
0.492171526,
0.204945609,
-0.0487649553,
0.4661503732,
0.4801982641,
-0.3082074225,
-0.4580940902,
0.9659025073,
0.2629164159,
0.5670387745,
0.2186726034,
0.1219162792,
-0.300911814,
-0.4399519861,
-0.9604486823,
-0.2266804427,
-0.8887631297,
-0.2423367202,
-0.6352618337,
0.2576648593,
-0.1888803393,
0.18682006,
-0.4236549437,
-0.3444499075,
0.2168197483,
0.0809237286,
0.0054033226,
0.5633279681,
0.1675137579,
0.4494861066,
-0.8185750842,
0.4028457999,
0.1853957176,
0.1085652635,
-0.2579114139,
-0.4550051391,
-0.5218942165,
0.1922655255,
-0.5004686713,
-0.8655535579,
0.3403252661,
0.0168496836,
0.4260304868,
0.1219508275,
-0.2180233598,
0.8616901636,
-0.5125320554,
0.5641793609,
0.2811110318,
-0.8610447645,
0.1149751693,
-0.4054316282,
0.4235267639,
0.5026336312,
0.0534785986,
-0.6958975196,
-0.2849963903,
-0.2628099024,
-0.5267899036,
0.4531219006,
0.5623859763,
0.2307680249,
0.0615686849,
0.0047232094,
0.1297905147,
0.6063123345,
-1.0928032398,
-0.0532257929,
-0.2143959701,
-0.4834348559,
-0.2869632244,
-0.071666427,
0.047551278,
-0.1689021587,
0.2705696225,
-0.1251876503,
0.4345219135,
0.0224587992,
-0.5301295519,
-0.0472630113,
0.3052201569,
0.6400703192,
0.6392204165,
-0.2594777048,
0.168686524,
-0.0542944483,
-0.2603982389,
0.3439820707,
0.1885075122,
-0.1926278919,
0.1113852784,
0.5584114194,
0.8665353656,
0.3543299437,
-0.5403712988,
0.8562271595,
-0.1187368482,
-0.0578352995,
0.0413751416,
-0.3132172227,
0.0084849773,
0.1700636894,
0.0240411349,
0.6242846251,
0.2475336343,
-0.3850578666,
0.2645029426,
0.2538437843,
-0.7435995936,
-0.2862204015,
0.5801226497,
0.1294063926,
0.0618624501,
0.6106239557,
-0.1039810628,
-0.4455938339,
0.766613543,
0.4694722295,
0.6679840684,
-0.2880466878,
0.071180284,
0.0675064772,
0.7803933024,
-0.1163777635,
0.0391290709,
0.0231618099,
-0.480853796,
-0.5978844166,
-0.3321145475,
-0.3020817041,
-0.0952742398,
-0.651455462,
0.3421500027,
0.1879374385,
-0.1826869547,
-0.047343079,
-0.3394514918,
-0.9971340895,
0.4759915471,
-0.1728967428,
0.6793676615,
-1.1583976746,
0.6767301559,
0.6325465441,
-0.6410878301,
-0.206325978,
-0.3459476829,
-0.1790461391,
-0.5042647719,
0.5611084104,
0.4956277311,
0.2156116813,
-0.0886818096,
-0.4287635982,
-0.4376797974,
1.0838470459,
0.6317864656,
-0.3957450092,
0.2972179055,
0.4145291746,
0.3011012077,
-0.4222858846,
0.4044349194,
0.1165811121,
0.8775567412,
-0.0684669614,
-1.1869295835,
-0.0563675351,
-0.3570125997,
0.0130606527,
-0.071629934,
-0.6761937141,
1.0224108696,
-0.0386033654,
-0.222619161,
0.1388611495,
0.3307849765,
0.0283628497,
0.3869317174,
0.562590003,
0.5217117071,
0.3293147087,
-0.2027732134,
1.4537657499,
0.1148131564,
0.6121102571,
0.9642170668,
-0.1362544745,
0.7278664708,
0.6496519446,
-0.1104473919,
-0.1861900389,
0.7857728004,
-0.3788466156,
0.7376823425,
0.2662201226,
0.089926675,
-0.5120847225,
-0.0685918406,
-0.368295759,
0.5092784166,
-0.2704957426,
-0.4996292591,
-0.4053706527,
0.5706788301,
0.1005891189,
-0.1005919799,
0.1461478323,
0.4612921774,
0.1059175134,
-0.5758064985,
0.4986299574,
0.4154580534,
0.3822276592,
-0.3459619284,
-0.1531044543,
-0.232822597,
0.2991387248,
-0.0036193102,
-0.5172481537,
0.4283387661,
0.0386577137,
-0.2750212848,
-0.3752873838,
0.2666601241,
-0.325365752,
-0.782597959,
0.2666993439,
0.611974895,
0.1890390813,
-0.3521534204,
-0.6491552591,
0.0873246416,
0.055627346,
-0.3668848872,
0.2239518762,
0.5182253122,
-0.1208986118,
0.860304296,
0.882788837,
-0.2764565647,
0.2679828107,
0.0083195893,
0.8042092919,
-0.5729762316,
-0.2096885443,
-1.0230952501,
0.5479983091,
0.0674440414,
-0.3875461817,
0.8935998678,
0.9555907249,
0.7249883413,
-0.3485770524,
0.7214243412,
0.1548868418,
0.0993825197,
-0.7154592872,
0.864166081,
-0.8295475245,
0.0344893411,
-0.4106331766,
-0.9670159221,
-0.3368470371,
0.5193722248,
-0.2471766323,
0.1496118605,
1.0602555275,
0.5347682238,
-0.3940597177,
0.0427300371,
0.7515559196,
0.1667526364,
0.4155322015,
0.5905193686,
0.9097264409,
-0.9360642433,
0.8260543346,
-0.0530224591,
-0.3178244531,
-0.0482468531,
-0.8463498354,
-1.0514596701,
-0.6148629785,
-0.202293098,
-0.153494671,
0.0099716373,
0.6335548162,
0.7819927931,
-0.5752617717,
-0.3799059689,
0.2407790571,
-0.1252600849,
-0.4822558463,
-0.1076144129,
0.3429931998,
-0.231375441,
-0.6959776878,
0.3796005547,
0.3792296648,
0.1091681272,
-0.2662544549,
0.0189211238,
-0.2424808592,
-0.1142643094,
0.7354905605,
-0.5437978506,
-0.5290656686,
-0.1431450546,
0.2242009193,
-0.2721673846,
0.2844212055,
0.5598228574,
-0.3264561892,
0.7520135641,
0.3815222383,
0.457367152,
0.7174153924,
-0.3187178671,
0.66187644,
-0.3170394003,
0.199562788,
-0.1377717406,
0.4013572633,
0.423642695,
0.1395423263,
0.6102153659,
0.488402009,
-0.2040598691,
-0.803748548,
-0.0114970375,
-0.9736676216,
0.1265062392,
0.8542080522,
-0.4358115196,
-0.3512139618,
-0.0723302513,
-0.0659928471,
0.300968349,
-0.0638437271,
0.595523417,
1.0553480387,
0.261312753,
-0.3635767996,
-1.2270009518,
0.0407544635,
0.3609010875,
-0.866758585,
-0.0299243405,
0.2660485506,
0.064329274,
0.2058705091,
0.1964581311,
-0.2729720771,
0.2748663127,
-0.0589118078,
0.3113004565,
-0.2553679049,
-0.2314621657,
-0.0816074982,
0.069673039,
-0.3498204648,
-0.5498195887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02990v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02990v4
|
Data Augmentation using Large Language Models: Data Perspectives, Learning Paradigms and Challenges
| 2024-03-05T14:11:54 | 2024-07-02T07:59:40 |
Bosheng Ding, Chengwei Qin, Ruochen Zhao, Tianze Luo, Xinze Li, Guizhen Chen, Wenhan Xia, Junjie Hu, Anh Tuan Luu, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the rapidly evolving field of large language models (LLMs), data
augmentation (DA) has emerged as a pivotal technique for enhancing model
performance by diversifying training examples without the need for additional
data collection. This survey explores the transformative impact of LLMs on DA,
particularly addressing the unique challenges and opportunities they present in
the context of natural language processing (NLP) and beyond. From both data and
learning perspectives, we examine various strategies that utilize LLMs for data
augmentation, including a novel exploration of learning paradigms where
LLM-generated data is used for diverse forms of further training. Additionally,
this paper highlights the primary open challenges faced in this domain, ranging
from controllable data augmentation to multi-modal data augmentation. This
survey highlights a paradigm shift introduced by LLMs in DA, and aims to serve
as a comprehensive guide for researchers and practitioners.
|
[
-0.3643004,
-0.8678044677,
0.4709649384,
-0.0618834272,
-0.0510896519,
0.3349710405,
-0.392136395,
-0.719697535,
0.0947226882,
0.4989361763,
-0.6838902235,
-0.4426101148,
-0.6026543975,
0.2874793112,
-0.4758968353,
0.815485239,
0.0483006127,
0.178576678,
-0.3937225342,
0.0644094273,
-0.6380183697,
-0.8980163932,
-0.5186997056,
-0.3112984002,
0.5624645948,
0.3217711151,
0.6469090581,
0.755829215,
0.47908324,
0.270857662,
-0.0954036936,
0.4950920045,
-0.4984002411,
0.306243062,
-0.0243644658,
-0.6752863526,
-0.5477400422,
-0.1273125261,
1.0234699249,
1.2926812172,
0.0456848368,
-0.023765441,
0.0185048748,
0.876737535,
-0.5739593506,
0.2397141457,
-0.5817512274,
0.0302234776,
-0.4421091676,
-0.1089385748,
-0.2153596133,
-0.1997247934,
0.2817106843,
-0.4010635912,
-0.0607405007,
-0.1551756859,
0.2751383781,
0.2903626561,
-0.7003093362,
-0.2618468702,
-1.0870712996,
0.8775368929,
-0.7304273844,
0.6453068256,
0.1553104222,
0.1078455225,
-0.2576287687,
-0.6674099565,
-0.5705074668,
-0.0334566347,
0.1644055843,
-0.3225631416,
0.0075974804,
-0.0614472367,
0.4441562891,
0.6735330224,
-0.2652874589,
0.6744279265,
-0.331887722,
0.1466956139,
0.9318320155,
0.442541182,
0.1576218307,
0.0012946175,
-0.1463095695,
-0.3127070367,
-0.9130094051,
-0.188777253,
0.4575613141,
0.4133062363,
-0.045967035,
0.6089727879,
-0.2577250898,
1.0109610558,
-0.2845962346,
-0.0331149772,
0.4688213468,
-0.3404236734,
-0.1524427086,
-0.2270264328,
0.4906898141,
0.140027836,
-0.0024067403,
-0.1386856884,
-0.3227212429,
-0.2238559425,
0.1648044735,
-0.5803661346,
0.075856559,
0.1028411761,
-0.1302668899,
-0.3227781951,
0.0955280364,
-0.7931451797,
-0.6379579902,
-0.7010529637,
0.0564870872,
-0.2075641006,
-0.3815830052,
0.3356127441,
0.0992095098,
0.4390230477,
0.5211516023,
-1.0189554691,
0.2224456966,
0.8369845748,
0.7378187776,
-0.4599589705,
-0.0983366668,
-0.2236375511,
0.1681448668,
-0.5681347847,
0.5833378434,
-0.6818622351,
-0.515594244,
0.2041500211,
-0.0793338567,
-0.0199097879,
-0.6292155385,
0.4362267554,
-0.6060106754,
0.2166797072,
-0.256734699,
-0.7641929388,
-0.3539359868,
0.2867276669,
-0.8397619724,
1.1592462063,
0.0701882839,
-0.5453256965,
0.4922306538,
-0.7383421063,
-0.5140847564,
0.1213486791,
-0.3117671609,
-0.2719963193,
0.3602192998,
0.2822008431,
0.6093192101,
-0.521821022,
0.3020114005,
-0.3382782638,
-0.0434570312,
0.4339644611,
-0.5865653157,
0.5947226286,
0.0056537902,
0.0697460771,
0.0777133331,
-1.0008753538,
-0.2086911649,
0.2855198681,
-0.4449283183,
-0.3569822311,
0.1103908345,
0.1500018388,
0.3113000095,
0.2709792852,
-0.3886767328,
0.5556904674,
-0.4986982644,
0.2677617669,
0.7097076774,
-0.0581750572,
0.4733052254,
-0.3980696499,
0.5116497874,
0.0130436663,
-0.0035726882,
-0.3720262647,
-0.3411655426,
-0.5790701509,
-0.1658727974,
0.4570420682,
0.3820432723,
-0.8868819475,
0.5661641359,
-0.594042778,
-0.4140331745,
-0.5858902931,
0.325247556,
-0.2353487015,
0.4141805768,
0.3797201812,
-0.1988362521,
-0.6639277935,
-0.8048128486,
0.0401837677,
0.0587536283,
-0.1666889042,
0.317489177,
0.3196024001,
-0.4292553067,
0.9530159831,
-0.5192508101,
-0.2239715904,
-0.4680196941,
-0.1290338188,
0.0928819999,
0.5322260261,
0.2601064444,
-0.9097022414,
-0.3123542368,
0.0275907889,
-0.7466914654,
-0.0195712652,
-0.2933360934,
0.5302949548,
0.2637437582,
0.625392437,
-0.4264928401,
0.1003473252,
0.5068175197,
0.1148843989,
0.4744631648,
-0.1599570662,
0.0574408285,
-1.1103270054,
-0.0380285718,
0.0424903668,
-0.0988104343,
-0.9843746424,
0.1350721568,
-0.028327493,
0.0503838621,
-0.267516464,
0.5328907371,
-0.6231916547,
-0.2612259388,
-0.4165417254,
-0.0128940763,
-0.0887753069,
0.0323559903,
0.1865414083,
0.6507589221,
0.8099888563,
-0.6781258583,
0.6401221156,
0.2737340331,
-0.4042485058,
0.3081491292,
-0.4675538838,
0.3682000637,
-0.3147527874,
0.4388606548,
-0.7854073048,
-0.4094438255,
0.1074616835,
-0.1827142239,
0.471868068,
-0.0270141959,
-0.8246042132,
-0.2893921137,
-0.369029969,
0.5920100212,
0.3690213263,
-0.6840482354,
0.4305530488,
0.4056181908,
-0.2590630054,
-0.5759560466,
-0.7411948442,
0.5652672648,
-0.4001607597,
-0.6424133778,
0.4568458498,
0.0016046728,
-0.2827594876,
-0.3081882894,
0.0760491118,
0.0936819017,
0.1678505391,
0.006761753,
0.4378660619,
0.0046863919,
0.3664472699,
-0.0624332428,
0.0324949436,
0.1267576069,
-0.2413957268,
0.7317679524,
0.1846163571,
-0.5343351364,
-0.2191684544,
0.4050858319,
0.2921822369,
-0.1846881807,
0.8495546579,
0.4482644498,
-0.4339150786,
-0.2985303998,
-0.5449596047,
-0.2385435402,
-0.4416971505,
0.4606636763,
-0.2237280458,
-1.0032458305,
0.4021688402,
-0.2969953716,
0.1615905911,
0.2858330011,
0.6071373224,
0.1127663776,
1.0725240707,
0.7768666744,
-0.3403114378,
0.626380384,
-0.3432127237,
0.1800844967,
-0.9658658504,
-0.4063155949,
-0.3480705917,
-0.400275588,
-0.6323614717,
-0.6459189653,
0.3823528886,
-0.1487732381,
0.1520437747,
-0.0446302854,
-0.2406947017,
0.1264548898,
0.1908492446,
0.004832827,
0.6092562675,
-0.0137101077,
0.4364392459,
-0.1130078509,
-0.6895737052,
-0.4111180007,
1.4609292746,
0.5937352777,
0.9739177227,
0.0540785939,
0.4565326273,
0.1813267171,
-0.0080212215,
-1.0058352947,
0.5262573361,
0.0315507613,
-0.4136884809,
-0.3225759566,
-0.4793522954,
-1.0181027651,
0.1717166305,
-0.4930126071,
-0.5162403584,
0.2308959216,
-0.1176351458,
-0.069024764,
0.2873353958,
-0.3702709675,
0.4185951352,
-0.3428924978,
-0.3557634056,
-0.1834347099,
-0.5642892122,
0.4564142823,
-0.4463014603,
0.2552074194,
0.1847450435,
-0.3766420186,
0.6389208436,
-0.1991485804,
0.8553655744,
-0.0080769965,
-0.625451088,
0.0489804037,
-0.2786670327,
0.7114962935,
-0.0636223033,
0.0367299244,
0.2591463923,
-0.3032283783,
-0.2215793282,
-0.6270561218,
0.7119149566,
-0.4886474907,
-0.6714811325,
-0.3008137345,
-1.0522880554,
-0.618365705,
-0.0818686113,
-0.2681411207,
0.3170450926,
-0.0427195355,
0.439927578,
0.6886464953,
-0.2281880379,
0.4045036137,
0.3626742065,
-0.4162967801,
-0.2230037749,
0.9043664336,
0.2229767591,
0.4123018384,
0.3420371711,
-0.0738991201,
-0.599312067,
-0.9211930633,
-0.4352919459,
0.1358700246,
-0.59600389,
0.1006680354,
-0.5636361241,
-0.1602337509,
-0.5298206806,
0.0934438854,
-0.3188617229,
-0.5346901417,
-0.3552357256,
-0.2287968993,
0.4177643657,
0.8240839243,
-0.0770354196,
0.3690372705,
-0.6879912615,
0.2473138273,
0.2611478865,
0.3764366806,
-0.0099746473,
-0.4572918415,
-0.4413291812,
0.2284888029,
-0.0491718613,
-0.6765913367,
0.4686957598,
0.0525699109,
0.5122903585,
0.2375835478,
-0.1628502756,
0.5704190135,
-0.4496638775,
0.7908763885,
0.0750535876,
-0.5659444928,
0.3002700806,
-0.3708157837,
0.123108618,
0.2749588192,
0.4817986786,
-0.6986745596,
-0.0383167081,
-0.4030269384,
-1.0297688246,
0.557469964,
-0.1005526781,
0.4132487476,
0.2609393895,
0.4506761432,
0.2676265836,
0.3135995269,
-0.6847780943,
-0.2809270918,
0.2806699872,
-0.0519087203,
-0.1921703219,
0.059286736,
-0.0491106771,
-0.3535577953,
0.5411944389,
-0.2359378189,
-0.1607904285,
-0.1539392918,
-0.2678873837,
0.0276768357,
0.313018918,
0.3118532002,
0.7086114883,
0.0757760033,
-0.156146884,
0.1861976981,
-0.2210113406,
0.091687575,
0.1574437618,
-0.2055074722,
-0.1657803208,
0.3779777884,
1.022475481,
0.0801470727,
-0.7774326801,
0.2567448616,
0.2504850924,
-0.1803480983,
-0.137813583,
0.1089008749,
-0.0628458485,
0.2477283925,
0.6532254815,
-0.300211817,
0.1143572778,
-0.6084055901,
0.0537202954,
0.6696086526,
-0.0696975738,
-0.2866049111,
0.4897356331,
-0.076172553,
-0.0217817742,
0.4484356642,
0.2561185658,
-0.0920256898,
0.3636105657,
0.5776052475,
0.7370538116,
-0.2324262112,
0.0225020982,
0.0378264785,
0.2427320033,
-0.0516260974,
0.1437256187,
-0.0274583902,
-0.8144003749,
-0.7394684553,
-0.4519909024,
-0.5707811117,
0.4409218729,
-0.7336264253,
0.3861024976,
-0.306024462,
0.0312217101,
0.0279892795,
-0.0118666943,
-0.639787674,
0.209561497,
0.4797275364,
0.8624325991,
-0.8185455799,
0.9336674809,
0.8670558333,
-0.2143168896,
-0.3773537576,
-0.0434180759,
-0.0576753989,
-0.7204082012,
0.5781015754,
-0.0011218017,
0.0991622135,
0.0671198666,
-0.4710374773,
-0.7783786654,
0.8601340055,
0.3694385886,
-0.4865397215,
-0.2247215211,
0.70000875,
0.6326241493,
-0.5144686103,
-0.0480514951,
0.7420783639,
0.481651336,
0.0319483206,
-0.746778667,
-0.1296985596,
0.0412812568,
0.2299790829,
0.1217790395,
-0.3477327824,
0.7139823437,
-0.0240009893,
-0.1988807619,
-0.299606055,
0.6231087446,
0.0399661884,
0.0850051567,
0.4989186525,
0.5757341981,
0.6007172465,
0.0583245456,
1.0450508595,
-0.0696455687,
0.1564332992,
1.0131754875,
-0.409448415,
0.6419751644,
0.5383838415,
-0.4004804194,
0.3438729048,
0.7363568544,
-0.1147841662,
0.1745838076,
0.1867582649,
-0.3639504611,
-0.1275752634,
-0.2072070092,
-0.5340515375,
0.6708695889,
0.7348114252,
-0.1572293937,
-0.3299015462,
0.2485150844,
-0.2271963358,
0.1052064374,
-0.4180552363,
0.9659688473,
-0.0447892547,
-0.2603579462,
0.4922513962,
0.1257676035,
0.7721105218,
-0.5807563663,
-0.1651279032,
-0.0474130586,
-0.1037563086,
-0.3007160127,
-0.7929996252,
0.347373575,
-0.0124377571,
-0.2574777007,
-0.3905200958,
0.6626237631,
-0.5933538079,
-0.4983471632,
0.2100363523,
0.8044700623,
-0.0136174401,
-0.0284114592,
-0.5468461514,
0.3447650373,
-0.1449643523,
-0.2342210561,
0.6068848372,
0.2510026395,
-0.1150290221,
0.8320767283,
0.7680591345,
0.2985547781,
0.2098762393,
0.1638924181,
1.0851655006,
-0.5660205483,
-0.3292721808,
-0.8548512459,
0.3749440312,
-0.1006314903,
-0.0213915259,
0.8604698181,
0.7101806998,
0.9841074944,
-0.0324429534,
0.9978243113,
0.0057635168,
0.739228785,
-0.6106644869,
0.3975524008,
-0.5226438642,
0.5465626121,
-0.2399723232,
-1.0568537712,
-0.3384805024,
0.1702254862,
-0.5274478793,
0.1318053603,
0.2943011522,
0.6136882305,
0.1102895886,
0.0466651246,
0.2821187675,
0.0747493878,
0.4589014053,
0.3586370945,
0.9203768373,
-0.372305572,
0.0947214514,
-0.2287875563,
-0.0954490826,
-0.0887355059,
-0.7945460677,
-0.7073168755,
-0.8374587893,
-0.2380966991,
0.1119446754,
-0.3208802938,
1.1081820726,
0.535859406,
-0.7143008709,
-0.3216598928,
-0.0508704744,
0.2282653004,
0.0043511107,
-0.237857163,
0.2846736014,
-0.5294701457,
-1.2309628725,
0.8775964975,
0.1749221236,
0.15621759,
-0.5545922518,
0.0867003649,
-0.1893275827,
-0.1195081323,
0.7838582993,
0.3232604563,
-0.4150283039,
-0.1491471529,
-0.0698220134,
0.0758767277,
0.1390940994,
0.9066867232,
-0.8673172593,
0.564565897,
0.2837311625,
1.2561404705,
0.481099844,
-0.0713378787,
0.7884590626,
-0.8445025086,
0.1133187264,
0.2930288315,
0.1470127702,
0.6369035244,
-0.3185878098,
0.454983592,
0.3237980306,
-0.3294051588,
-1.1989165545,
0.3054060936,
-0.8597385883,
-0.2333565652,
1.1931593418,
0.3156158626,
0.1692234129,
-0.1841917038,
0.0002303188,
0.0327053554,
-0.0267363973,
0.6881350279,
0.7200214863,
-0.2179248929,
-0.2079827785,
-0.809490025,
0.4899395704,
0.2926047146,
-1.1709800959,
0.3166292608,
0.8995386362,
0.0437817015,
-0.0798736364,
0.1864163131,
-0.1625180244,
-0.1535592079,
-0.2606058419,
-0.0521202125,
-0.1680555642,
-0.3870556355,
-0.8191592693,
0.1096884608,
0.0903552547,
-0.0062130918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02975v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02975v2
|
A General and Flexible Multi-concept Parsing Framework for Multilingual Semantic Matching
| 2024-03-05T13:55:16 | 2024-04-04T01:07:24 |
Dong Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sentence semantic matching is a research hotspot in natural language
processing, which is considerably significant in various key scenarios, such as
community question answering, searching, chatbot, and recommendation. Since
most of the advanced models directly model the semantic relevance among words
between two sentences while neglecting the \textit{keywords} and
\textit{intents} concepts of them, DC-Match is proposed to disentangle keywords
from intents and utilizes them to optimize the matching performance. Although
DC-Match is a simple yet effective method for semantic matching, it highly
depends on the external NER techniques to identify the keywords of sentences,
which limits the performance of semantic matching for minor languages since
satisfactory NER tools are usually hard to obtain. In this paper, we propose to
generally and flexibly resolve the text into multi concepts for multilingual
semantic matching to liberate the model from the reliance on NER models. To
this end, we devise a \underline{M}ulti-\underline{C}oncept \underline{P}arsed
\underline{S}emantic \underline{M}atching framework based on the pre-trained
language models, abbreviated as \textbf{MCP-SM}, to extract various concepts
and infuse them into the classification tokens. We conduct comprehensive
experiments on English datasets QQP and MRPC, and Chinese dataset Medical-SM.
Besides, we experiment on Arabic datasets MQ2Q and XNLI, the outstanding
performance further prove MCP-SM's applicability in low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.3608574867,
-0.6706960201,
0.6579507589,
-0.006767414,
-0.558817029,
0.0667247474,
-0.1784984469,
-0.2536505163,
0.1531642228,
0.4404487908,
-0.6880202293,
-0.5067873597,
-0.2731028199,
0.2615812421,
-0.1511121541,
0.5931213498,
-0.0929263458,
0.1627395004,
-0.2318065763,
-0.309188664,
-0.3363419473,
-0.4507263005,
-0.5532987118,
-0.1744044423,
0.4353116453,
0.6230888367,
0.5806947947,
0.712127924,
0.636421144,
0.3642246425,
-0.1103768796,
0.3801120222,
0.0690613836,
0.0793365464,
-0.3262492418,
-0.1551504731,
-0.4221027792,
-0.0527361967,
0.6237546802,
0.6883924007,
-0.2071416825,
-0.1533184648,
-0.0254607648,
0.5786042213,
-0.5878920555,
0.0424003713,
-0.9254012108,
-0.0650250018,
-0.2339543998,
-0.2612550557,
-0.2111169845,
0.0993798301,
-0.0395523123,
-0.6668043733,
0.3920506835,
0.059958782,
0.8613102436,
0.2425217927,
-0.6390118599,
-0.4672823846,
-0.1842276305,
0.5265194178,
-0.5868432522,
0.3956708014,
0.1000674814,
0.4790202677,
-0.1367681324,
-0.4694857597,
-1.0063217878,
-0.0495760776,
-0.2996119857,
0.018521823,
0.179618746,
0.18929708,
-0.0482586585,
0.4128230512,
-0.5680969357,
-0.0171852596,
0.1085591689,
-0.1024891958,
0.3233535886,
0.1429395974,
0.4504633248,
-0.3249411881,
-0.4157070518,
-0.2361038923,
-0.58697474,
-0.1067368388,
0.1755921841,
0.7288349271,
-0.2773957253,
0.9309482574,
-0.5282959938,
0.7735429406,
-0.1625504494,
-0.2860707343,
0.2570141554,
-0.9050642252,
-0.186015293,
0.1439236403,
0.7192805409,
0.4237361848,
0.2925831079,
-0.1140921786,
0.2637912035,
0.715095818,
-0.0952403098,
-0.8765704632,
-0.0737405345,
0.0028771427,
-0.3539676368,
0.0388377979,
-0.0299969111,
-0.8661797643,
-0.0589115731,
-0.3701796234,
-0.047385145,
-0.3996582925,
-0.4726420641,
0.4672859609,
-0.053595826,
0.3252417147,
0.0732207149,
-0.7936815619,
0.2983813286,
0.6895173788,
0.9421366453,
-0.0553471334,
-0.1952311695,
-0.4991674125,
0.0903009176,
-0.0551387034,
0.8022491336,
-0.7196708322,
-0.2071107775,
-0.1344707906,
0.0923262239,
-0.5186495185,
-0.3505086303,
0.7113850117,
-0.4138880074,
0.1057915315,
-0.328777045,
-0.5824946165,
0.023951035,
0.5064452887,
-0.4789953828,
0.4067115188,
-0.1873080134,
-0.932823658,
0.5400009751,
-0.7850348353,
-0.3561487198,
-0.1081046015,
-0.3125310838,
-0.1834587902,
-0.0085111232,
0.291495353,
0.561242044,
-0.4741175473,
0.2299040854,
-0.5252560973,
-0.0159823131,
-0.0105815502,
-0.375466913,
0.5249741077,
0.3178596795,
-0.0363100879,
0.3239758313,
-1.0041180849,
0.1999898702,
0.0264498424,
-0.1504490823,
-0.5215063691,
0.0474970341,
0.1630357355,
0.882017076,
-0.0503361449,
-0.6919171214,
-0.0716013461,
-0.5647082329,
0.6438721418,
0.3601198196,
-0.2560138404,
0.3893643916,
-0.0608617589,
0.4793610871,
0.4094457328,
-0.2691124976,
-0.2891861498,
-0.4130353034,
-0.7124888897,
-0.5366771817,
0.2689896822,
0.5303778052,
-0.8299037218,
0.5185351372,
-0.4222319126,
-0.2963530421,
-0.9368386865,
0.011170933,
0.3672069311,
0.6207885742,
0.5928218365,
-0.0900536254,
-0.2408019304,
-0.8435161114,
-0.2114195973,
0.0326683335,
0.085336782,
0.2194127291,
0.4053230882,
-0.349134326,
0.9986422062,
-0.5343142152,
-0.5494125485,
-0.3038078249,
-0.1748305261,
0.0916141942,
0.4310586154,
0.4703232646,
-1.1123474836,
-0.6173144579,
0.2524757981,
-0.4798946381,
0.0731333196,
0.1466569453,
-0.2455553859,
-0.025293652,
0.6131294966,
-0.8386131525,
0.2756077051,
0.5388756394,
-0.665474236,
0.2822723687,
-0.2247949541,
0.3012101054,
-1.4546147585,
0.1669588089,
-0.0719550326,
-0.1436636448,
-0.3568331897,
0.3941203654,
0.126010254,
-0.0726202875,
-0.5340327024,
0.6832325459,
-0.2403227091,
0.2841591537,
-0.2804994285,
0.5981330872,
0.1412822753,
0.2264979333,
0.3114309609,
0.5632926822,
0.5608789325,
-0.7584868073,
0.4035136104,
0.2358408719,
-0.0631182939,
0.8130116463,
-0.7278553843,
-0.1971849054,
-0.1809825748,
0.1099577621,
-1.0048353672,
-0.0709763989,
0.3428582251,
-0.2423824966,
0.0805715993,
-0.0197346285,
-0.7453398705,
-0.1826564819,
-0.1506612897,
0.5474355817,
-0.1890812814,
-0.4661866128,
0.661013782,
0.2410456538,
0.0734754652,
-0.713878274,
-0.5320560932,
-0.0219593495,
-0.3830151558,
-0.7041850686,
0.6231096387,
-0.3106356263,
-0.1865349859,
0.0629612431,
-0.1362906247,
-0.2221542448,
0.2335560918,
-0.1395194679,
0.1683482081,
-0.3077728152,
0.030825194,
0.1345255822,
-0.3436725438,
-0.3795464337,
-0.0293623637,
0.7058109045,
-0.190784052,
-0.4787552953,
-0.2184188217,
0.5120567679,
0.5741868615,
-0.2952603102,
0.9062101841,
0.5979616642,
-0.3766707182,
0.2154797018,
-0.3739919364,
0.0328966714,
-0.4630445242,
0.3731736243,
-0.9311999083,
-0.9906725883,
0.3943431079,
-0.0752176568,
-0.1293152124,
0.6261287332,
0.5201761127,
0.2936557233,
0.9407307506,
0.8131030798,
-0.0169716198,
-0.0365573838,
0.1375796944,
0.4167711437,
-0.6878872514,
-0.0976883247,
-0.7391998172,
0.0758030191,
-0.8814216256,
-0.2927843928,
-0.1204222441,
0.2726166844,
0.0962235257,
0.549980104,
-0.4998466372,
0.5225775242,
0.155719921,
-0.3711147606,
0.4509066045,
-0.3400432169,
-0.7100042701,
-0.1814771742,
-0.5662153959,
-0.3984264731,
0.7282834053,
0.082858786,
0.5187003016,
0.3291742802,
0.4847947359,
-0.1882747859,
-0.16367504,
-0.8349476457,
0.5975716114,
-0.3995413184,
-0.4143795967,
-0.0874141604,
-0.666944623,
-0.9609953165,
0.7468444109,
-0.2444220781,
-0.5094467402,
0.0037571259,
-0.0381373726,
-0.2439400852,
0.0939268172,
-0.7725282907,
1.2569525242,
-0.0068841008,
0.1576361209,
-0.3914733827,
-0.8415921926,
0.3862881064,
-0.1749478132,
0.3192121089,
-0.5347266197,
0.0791151151,
0.2960074544,
-0.1942471564,
0.404966116,
0.0417723693,
-0.0250857417,
-0.191805914,
-0.1899831593,
-0.1535993218,
0.3233231306,
0.1073794216,
-0.0482889675,
0.3211827278,
-0.2592992187,
-0.3224850297,
0.7740442753,
-0.4391602278,
-0.1408959031,
-0.4862394631,
-0.437900275,
-0.0586131327,
0.510786593,
0.1636366248,
0.1895846725,
-0.2836309671,
0.1753759086,
0.4145591259,
-0.0926511362,
0.480240494,
0.6713777781,
-0.0452080294,
-0.3140729368,
0.5986799598,
-0.3244227469,
0.2193669975,
0.8289754987,
0.1646691561,
-0.5561481118,
-0.1274753511,
-0.4311710894,
0.3442198932,
-0.6800906062,
-0.3101858497,
-0.9906176329,
-0.0135802943,
-0.5482322574,
-0.0702390671,
-0.2236064672,
-0.3809707761,
-0.2261590958,
0.065029338,
0.071881406,
0.1091750264,
0.0897518322,
0.4700747132,
-0.6690307856,
0.9558698535,
0.1674248278,
0.2579343021,
-0.4389664531,
-0.1542664021,
0.0850589797,
0.2243059427,
-0.2451473176,
-0.6233161092,
0.1474169791,
0.6055667996,
0.5319697857,
0.4130852222,
0.116760619,
0.8608419895,
-0.826433897,
0.494032234,
0.4151104093,
-1.117179513,
0.5861735344,
-0.0142055703,
0.303291887,
0.7884454727,
0.2561882734,
-0.8192086816,
-0.3113913834,
-0.5106806159,
-0.9493291974,
0.671635747,
0.0043093725,
0.0512042344,
-0.3998807669,
0.3370962739,
-0.2191322297,
0.4018336535,
-0.7232378125,
-0.3025154173,
-0.1832662225,
-0.5522418022,
-0.2219687253,
-0.0556328483,
0.1063345298,
-0.2902940214,
0.5720455647,
-0.4961881638,
0.1859353334,
-0.0120972944,
-0.2964147329,
0.199855566,
0.6230120659,
0.5837376714,
0.4499691725,
-0.0232294239,
0.2004956305,
-0.0663070008,
-0.3134776652,
0.3406987488,
0.433080107,
0.0386344455,
0.0127561651,
0.156811595,
0.3254530132,
0.1815436333,
-0.7912492752,
0.5910635591,
-0.346760273,
0.0792514309,
-0.0511862785,
0.0736210197,
0.2764236331,
0.1378621906,
-0.0551052243,
0.2242825031,
0.1730911285,
-0.6289206743,
0.5147468448,
0.5927428603,
-0.2882276475,
-0.2143255919,
0.6846125722,
0.0042105438,
0.0093474044,
0.5258153081,
-0.5059125423,
-0.6014794111,
0.2947769463,
0.5480068922,
0.609395802,
-0.2575509548,
0.309227556,
0.2894320786,
0.0401872508,
-0.0999069661,
0.2838623524,
-0.1284142882,
-1.16781497,
-0.6598896384,
-0.7755742669,
-0.1729926318,
-0.1979546398,
-0.557985127,
0.4380650818,
-0.2785032094,
-0.034072753,
0.2645292282,
0.1246950477,
-0.7913168073,
0.2537573576,
0.0529774763,
0.8222113848,
-0.7620580196,
1.0694191456,
0.807524085,
-0.4222364426,
-0.5136570334,
0.0024666095,
0.0533908755,
-0.6388852596,
0.3419317007,
0.4165284038,
-0.3908486962,
0.0164050553,
0.0283986926,
-0.620944798,
0.811927855,
0.5081986785,
-0.4514278769,
-0.2955747247,
0.1843142807,
0.3861104548,
-0.5943453312,
0.1501763463,
0.7110393643,
0.3307110369,
0.1972482204,
-0.9762305617,
0.0739323795,
-0.2155339569,
-0.1293003112,
0.2049615532,
-0.5226922631,
0.9087332487,
-0.0856175423,
-0.2953026891,
0.2503450513,
0.5493971109,
0.4061029553,
0.1322723925,
0.5335944295,
0.7924050093,
0.5892061591,
-0.0835380405,
0.5189391971,
-0.3441442549,
0.5193530917,
1.0165463686,
-0.5093086958,
0.9385089278,
0.51217556,
-0.0107533708,
0.4854674041,
0.4465965331,
0.2460203171,
0.9026356339,
0.222136423,
-0.0034619709,
-0.230380863,
-0.2663987279,
-0.3609750271,
0.6417033672,
0.5161973238,
0.0085632838,
-0.5350777507,
-0.0482327454,
0.0877451301,
0.3086151183,
-0.0414059758,
0.8505120873,
0.1645438969,
-0.336689949,
0.2899226248,
0.3613760471,
0.9341371059,
-0.7480858564,
0.0204549935,
0.1741340905,
0.3943810165,
0.0061448165,
-0.3606961668,
0.4074807763,
-0.312543571,
-0.2113458216,
0.0669975281,
0.6467655301,
-0.7167704701,
-0.4934116602,
0.6294001937,
0.6312099695,
-0.1709459573,
-0.1602638364,
-1.0299088955,
-0.2218797207,
-0.2430847138,
0.336151123,
0.1903068572,
0.7402461171,
0.3587366045,
0.5653722882,
0.4674166739,
0.1099752039,
-0.1087927446,
0.1772054732,
0.6881963015,
-0.7127752304,
-0.8072266579,
-1.0223748684,
0.3817237914,
-0.0963467732,
-0.4029542804,
0.6935711503,
0.4645184278,
1.0353144407,
0.3051499426,
0.4327262044,
-0.1349583715,
0.5691606998,
-0.6892409325,
0.4641710818,
-0.767549336,
0.0975273922,
-0.573105216,
-1.0181539059,
-0.3584571779,
0.7872968316,
0.2146942317,
-0.0526990481,
1.0117315054,
0.4938536882,
-0.4351308942,
-0.1367430836,
0.3413330913,
-0.2073641121,
0.3536273837,
0.4984089136,
0.5424628258,
-0.2934729159,
0.4121880531,
-0.1764152944,
0.0048359614,
-0.0864111632,
-0.8735061884,
-0.8671392798,
-0.7045393586,
-0.4695346653,
-0.0997326076,
-0.2752416134,
1.0458872318,
0.6941851974,
-0.8569847345,
0.022327045,
-0.1429971606,
0.1861937046,
-0.3436745703,
-0.2426267266,
0.5104292035,
-0.4215735793,
-0.4355968237,
0.5150860548,
0.1435471177,
0.0789124593,
0.1112453416,
0.0018591974,
-0.5442554355,
0.0082933428,
0.6865616441,
-0.1765653044,
-0.8917976022,
-0.3085128069,
0.0679311156,
-0.0185517874,
0.0014172774,
0.9698174596,
-0.5671417117,
0.3651187718,
0.16654405,
0.8587771058,
0.1843044311,
-0.1151771098,
0.3740222454,
-0.9454609752,
0.3499347866,
0.0484680459,
0.611823976,
0.4763135016,
-0.1934232861,
0.4506347477,
0.3823841512,
-0.2072071731,
-0.675337255,
0.4736901522,
-1.0284694433,
-0.4140736759,
0.9496331811,
-0.1424932033,
0.1112858877,
-0.3783183694,
-0.1285327226,
0.3588010967,
-0.1281658113,
0.4118148685,
0.7616943717,
0.2025039494,
-0.2064849138,
-0.3546792269,
0.5767378211,
0.3460096717,
-0.8223513961,
0.111822851,
0.4381736517,
0.1805307865,
0.3942187726,
0.7731428146,
-0.066423364,
0.120374389,
-0.1998544186,
-0.1622181237,
0.3248964548,
-0.5290943384,
-0.2228614986,
0.1740352064,
-0.0867788941,
-0.371222645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02966v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02966v2
|
Evidence-Focused Fact Summarization for Knowledge-Augmented Zero-Shot Question Answering
| 2024-03-05T13:43:58 | 2024-06-19T06:47:32 |
Sungho Ko, Hyunjin Cho, Hyungjoo Chae, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent studies have investigated utilizing Knowledge Graphs (KGs) to enhance
Quesetion Answering (QA) performance of Large Language Models (LLMs), yet
structured KG verbalization remains challengin. Existing methods, such as
triple-form or free-form textual conversion of triple-form facts, encounter
several issues. These include reduced evidence density due to duplicated
entities or relationships, and reduced evidence clarity due to an inability to
emphasize crucial evidence. To address these issues, we propose EFSum, an
Evidence-focused Fact Summarization framework for enhanced QA with
knowledge-augmented LLMs. We optimize an open-source LLM as a fact summarizer
through distillation and preference alignment. Our extensive experiments show
that EFSum improves LLM's zero-shot QA performance, and it is possible to
ensure both the helpfulness and faithfulness of the summary.
|
[
-0.1728079617,
-0.892893374,
0.9067181945,
-0.2635867298,
-0.3674373925,
0.0330310352,
0.1080754176,
-0.2198302746,
0.4080854654,
0.3072410822,
-0.1760132313,
-0.685981214,
-0.6283808947,
0.1070878804,
-0.2750785649,
1.2469952106,
-0.200599581,
-0.044780612,
-0.4843404889,
-0.3338121474,
-0.0423508063,
-0.4412596226,
-0.2511786222,
-0.2356595695,
0.5969531536,
0.7860689163,
0.6395404935,
0.610708952,
0.3884476125,
0.2036545873,
-0.1417484432,
0.3713562489,
-0.7985885143,
0.1453018636,
0.0438480191,
-0.5008460879,
-0.7657197118,
-0.194443807,
0.496954143,
0.8063021898,
-0.2279966325,
0.3268406987,
-0.2784099877,
0.5932218432,
-0.7873228192,
0.2494884729,
-0.3256847262,
-0.1351614594,
0.0978431329,
-0.2960523367,
-0.2940403521,
-0.5882372856,
0.1379461884,
-0.9906988144,
0.2079179436,
0.0850417167,
0.877535522,
0.294172883,
-0.5622569919,
-0.2650434971,
-0.5790037513,
0.4860865474,
-0.8767433763,
0.3282341659,
0.1771345586,
0.1019196287,
-0.1365858167,
-0.5704393983,
-0.5240442157,
0.1353581846,
-0.2852025628,
0.1656455845,
-0.0785094202,
0.2988292277,
0.2810208797,
0.4361180365,
-0.6278303266,
-0.3122522235,
-0.1648921371,
-0.3526325822,
0.5045359731,
0.0225150865,
0.2538247108,
0.0537409633,
-0.0352361687,
-0.0622372106,
-0.7839278579,
-0.0139552839,
-0.1180063412,
0.1406920403,
0.0602298155,
0.899318099,
-0.7748684287,
0.9217737913,
0.0073847752,
-0.4801744819,
0.2863078117,
-0.370944947,
-0.252027601,
0.3031916916,
0.5071244836,
0.6584174037,
0.0139507409,
-0.3149308264,
0.1364747435,
-0.2062195688,
-0.4210219681,
-1.3616393805,
-0.1031345204,
0.4887718856,
-0.0102477791,
-0.1362732649,
-0.0054015028,
-0.6366187334,
-0.2559832335,
-0.1389947087,
0.4369701743,
-0.464576304,
-0.2710388303,
0.2779093683,
-0.3888801336,
0.2550213039,
0.4428060949,
-0.6672375202,
0.2360285521,
0.5930368304,
0.8209068179,
0.28087309,
-0.0640808642,
-0.8433407545,
0.6639996767,
-0.179405272,
0.9829725623,
-0.3675345182,
-0.16364941,
-0.1402326822,
-0.1319991946,
0.0355021283,
-0.2725605071,
0.5364822745,
-0.7479621172,
0.4482236803,
-0.5425148606,
-0.8099073172,
-0.4450308681,
0.5648823977,
-0.4270937443,
0.8180943131,
-0.0698157549,
-0.7637227178,
0.3987859488,
-0.6907619238,
-0.6296765804,
-0.1583945453,
-0.1938442141,
-0.2822268307,
0.1530092508,
0.5743476152,
0.3794078231,
0.0153059037,
0.3684601486,
-0.3997908533,
-0.2763061821,
0.0577980652,
0.0847204924,
0.4282722175,
0.2238612771,
-0.0493703596,
0.0882345587,
-0.7487874627,
-0.0672696531,
0.2925242782,
-0.2764220238,
-0.4484689236,
0.1489150524,
-0.6225665808,
0.0847727358,
0.2221022099,
-0.7958441973,
-0.0823387131,
-0.3285866976,
0.1042171046,
0.2650560141,
0.2222850472,
0.3747707307,
-0.6179735661,
0.3748995662,
0.1692200452,
-0.0626745299,
-0.1867233813,
-0.4507076442,
-0.7416051626,
-0.4764552414,
0.1295057535,
0.3827981353,
-0.923199296,
0.1344907284,
-0.5448778868,
-0.2072929144,
-0.3818342686,
-0.0127005801,
0.2378815114,
0.8706207275,
0.363605231,
0.04838074,
-0.3389294744,
-0.7312968969,
-0.2324461192,
-0.4215674698,
-0.0222591013,
0.1477108747,
0.2863645256,
0.3858093321,
1.1664241552,
-1.0315318108,
-0.1556731761,
-0.1082952023,
0.1189688295,
0.2425438464,
-0.16790016,
0.6999901533,
-0.4966053367,
-0.3052599132,
-0.1991183013,
-0.8517699838,
-0.1664311588,
0.3226311803,
-0.2711752951,
0.0274218787,
0.2234761119,
-0.5181857347,
0.1966548562,
0.2569671571,
-0.4855408669,
0.0574362017,
0.1633344591,
0.513045311,
-1.0476869345,
0.2088020593,
-0.2246373594,
-0.3920989335,
-0.9041625857,
0.0693506077,
0.015571625,
-0.0515630655,
-0.4194505215,
0.261457473,
-0.3675721288,
-0.0621624552,
-0.2049908787,
0.5611401796,
0.4446229041,
0.4651752412,
0.1435891539,
0.7463551164,
0.0784464628,
-0.6442341805,
0.0715850666,
0.447807312,
-0.0986931548,
0.4616273642,
-0.6377743483,
0.0548635721,
-0.448445648,
0.1082175449,
-1.0033751726,
-0.4143479466,
0.0932844281,
-0.5081548691,
0.4436331391,
-0.0041388469,
-0.2640531957,
0.1449392736,
-0.6105970144,
0.4101577103,
0.3288192749,
-0.3989025056,
0.5870204568,
0.4439112544,
-0.328194499,
-0.7044250369,
-0.5753285885,
-0.0329561718,
0.0329366066,
-0.6888549924,
0.3381046653,
-0.1740826517,
-0.2944286764,
0.1820251197,
-0.0704077706,
0.0756500438,
0.2950765491,
-0.1091550067,
0.1220653057,
-0.3382100761,
0.1808612198,
0.1089245081,
0.2525431812,
-0.014533692,
-0.0064950013,
0.2866660655,
-0.1259654909,
-0.3467232585,
-0.1452659667,
0.2961609662,
0.6364536285,
-0.0902647451,
0.7898914814,
0.1748293191,
-0.3462094963,
0.1053465381,
-0.5619831681,
-0.1042113528,
-0.3267510235,
0.4370840788,
-0.2561387122,
-1.2963308096,
0.4759230018,
0.0517916717,
0.34115839,
0.4967860281,
0.4041085541,
-0.0330191962,
0.8181104064,
0.3960455358,
0.0100557758,
0.2381721735,
0.0533137098,
0.4169051051,
-0.5998162627,
-0.1892206967,
-0.3428430855,
0.103893362,
-0.0161481015,
-0.1746730953,
0.6163151264,
0.3118189871,
-0.1148558483,
-0.0659918338,
-0.3411729336,
0.511135757,
0.1113383025,
0.1418534815,
0.7173085213,
0.0408354625,
0.0191236604,
0.3445495665,
-0.9995425344,
-0.3084359467,
1.2168402672,
0.2351738214,
0.3241206706,
0.6102868915,
0.773075521,
0.0749454051,
0.5909065008,
-0.839502871,
0.4488357008,
0.2024872601,
-0.7365297079,
-0.4598456323,
-0.6146528721,
-0.3702859282,
0.4093761742,
-0.1934848279,
-0.1542066485,
0.0202316064,
0.0647176355,
-0.6991451979,
0.2236338556,
-0.8343392611,
0.4723310173,
-0.1954762489,
-0.2601965368,
-0.0479733385,
-0.327174902,
0.6848324537,
0.0647214651,
0.40491575,
-0.2824175954,
-0.0396414734,
0.8297516704,
-0.7114155293,
0.5034917593,
-0.3729829788,
-0.2355133593,
0.4520441294,
-0.1059807315,
0.4136390984,
0.0564426668,
-0.0792393461,
-0.1514456719,
0.2534031272,
-0.5568345189,
-0.7962438464,
0.5151262879,
-0.7289335728,
-0.8187707663,
-0.4574367404,
-0.708116591,
-0.3413994908,
0.1637428403,
-0.1921292692,
0.4973728359,
-0.528151691,
0.0637361556,
0.7787464857,
0.0632815212,
0.2410195619,
0.9413565993,
-0.4788220823,
-0.6583659053,
0.8204345703,
0.296416223,
0.3080309927,
0.6258022785,
0.170642212,
-0.3945005834,
-0.8612695336,
-0.6559957266,
0.3437397182,
-0.6629298925,
-0.3488071561,
-0.8754122853,
-0.0388091579,
-0.7597237825,
0.0265076775,
0.1539585143,
-0.9044945836,
-0.2008042037,
-0.5068579912,
0.7986649871,
0.6348636746,
0.0160504915,
0.2253471166,
-0.7679158449,
0.5569232106,
0.492514044,
0.3896545172,
-0.2016408443,
-0.5984075665,
-0.2663475275,
0.132634744,
-0.047676228,
-0.908780992,
0.0412996225,
0.4091925621,
0.4794788063,
0.6106771231,
0.4344058931,
0.6733556986,
-0.2225398272,
0.7434670329,
0.2186083645,
-0.6507190466,
0.4583058953,
-0.4731402993,
0.2152932435,
0.8328976631,
0.3294375539,
-0.4297606945,
-0.2040714771,
-0.2785368562,
-0.6047332287,
0.7188814282,
0.1338279545,
-0.334861517,
-0.2123993635,
0.4671088457,
-0.0131896464,
0.3789274693,
-0.2958415449,
-0.2437954396,
-0.3403294683,
-0.4237554669,
-0.0552497767,
-0.5977152586,
-0.5133413076,
-0.2719149888,
0.9487649798,
-0.3892430365,
-0.0200437177,
0.614572525,
-0.4264218211,
-0.0704263821,
0.5028144717,
0.7776823044,
0.766176343,
-0.5753839612,
0.255128324,
0.3873417675,
-0.3819807172,
0.347990483,
0.2253204584,
-0.5809834003,
0.0097784605,
0.2685635388,
0.5131017566,
0.1352561563,
-0.5520141721,
0.7285647988,
-0.0875103325,
-0.5063747168,
-0.0764290765,
-0.0697585642,
0.1163106859,
-0.0126906708,
0.3670428395,
-0.4554387033,
0.2879303694,
-0.5548349023,
0.0993528292,
0.2353382856,
-0.26355955,
-0.2485446334,
0.4239207804,
0.3738666177,
0.3262357414,
0.334705472,
-0.2661578059,
-0.485397011,
0.4384507239,
0.3594209254,
0.6117969751,
-0.053073477,
0.4253155589,
0.4024035633,
0.2088044733,
0.0186561644,
0.4762468636,
-0.1353237927,
-0.8239982724,
-0.7403684855,
-0.5302690268,
-0.4714591503,
-0.2342921793,
-0.6454948783,
-0.0165898353,
-0.4374500811,
-0.0030067693,
-0.0785075203,
-0.0084183747,
-0.2732510269,
0.1104251444,
0.018185202,
0.7317869067,
-0.8974476457,
0.4961000979,
0.7390325069,
-0.5494639874,
-0.6877735853,
-0.2561459243,
0.022191925,
-0.5777372122,
0.247052148,
-0.1211687401,
-0.3564659655,
0.0519122407,
-0.5234225988,
-1.0013902187,
1.5686272383,
0.5748540759,
-0.297870189,
0.0435825624,
0.2494581789,
0.3206685185,
-0.3395320773,
0.618335247,
0.5667275786,
0.4722151458,
0.4416006207,
-0.5542408228,
0.2632737756,
-0.2746063769,
-0.5038452148,
0.2938566804,
-0.9059454203,
0.3727118671,
-0.4793696702,
-0.5157552361,
-0.2270347923,
0.8768799901,
0.4069555998,
0.6507408023,
0.3419189751,
0.8682327271,
0.8995261788,
-0.0422672182,
0.8245439529,
-0.4991458952,
0.1790398955,
1.2599750757,
-0.6110899448,
0.611510098,
0.5226657391,
-0.1439679563,
0.5931657553,
0.4441898465,
0.3513472974,
0.4618962407,
-0.1294598132,
-0.243243888,
-0.3545107245,
-0.6159849763,
-0.4631054699,
0.3035651445,
0.2933294475,
-0.1446255296,
-0.5377799273,
-0.5550267696,
0.4479010999,
0.0226440504,
-0.3424103856,
0.927443862,
-0.0836150199,
-0.6831532717,
0.5178934336,
-0.1845119596,
0.3437423408,
-0.685828805,
-0.1597080976,
-0.2748226821,
-0.2196722329,
-0.5142790079,
-0.7350950241,
0.2355938107,
0.1016433239,
-0.3726722896,
0.0257724468,
0.537673831,
-0.5295695066,
-0.3662058115,
0.1080634817,
0.7310078144,
0.1571774781,
-0.0958816037,
-0.1232843325,
-0.3747208118,
-0.0787016451,
-0.2624730766,
0.3515822291,
0.4546196163,
0.1412962228,
0.3705515265,
0.6737613678,
-0.1132543609,
-0.0642485321,
0.1739852875,
1.1661980152,
-0.5242941976,
-0.3204940856,
-0.6843393445,
0.2695720792,
-0.3551489711,
-0.0212036651,
0.8282637,
0.8529669046,
0.6145903468,
0.2562977076,
0.7235015035,
-0.1217588633,
0.5963840485,
-0.5078952312,
0.8248208165,
-0.4778576493,
-0.0252375249,
-0.0528868102,
-0.6913380623,
-0.3735053837,
0.0226908457,
-0.3073093593,
-0.1531097293,
0.7250705361,
0.8342949152,
0.1704712659,
0.15416646,
0.5154963732,
0.2285797894,
0.2925284505,
0.6686365008,
0.719822526,
-0.4598126411,
0.7389125824,
-0.2414635718,
-0.3169593811,
-0.1779592931,
-0.9252151847,
-0.7804440856,
-0.246957615,
-0.5445421338,
-0.2079136968,
0.0542650037,
0.8096898198,
0.5152189136,
-0.9615889192,
0.0925935432,
0.1806912571,
0.2978808284,
0.0524539724,
-0.1758823991,
0.5825045109,
-0.1250329316,
-0.2270427346,
0.4218311012,
0.2459751219,
-0.1093300432,
0.0999941006,
-0.0701888651,
-0.4105910361,
0.1619873047,
0.8048392534,
0.297681421,
-0.4282059669,
-0.4926029742,
0.2636375427,
0.1475385129,
0.0627371222,
0.7959781885,
-0.6060141921,
0.4842862189,
0.7982375622,
0.5704106092,
0.576633215,
0.2939679027,
0.5366601944,
-0.6476364136,
-0.1504757255,
-0.0193562303,
0.4288064837,
0.3299733102,
-0.4527138472,
0.5325958133,
0.194693163,
-0.4771251976,
-0.6115460396,
0.1317620724,
-0.8544356227,
-0.2702901065,
1.1945610046,
-0.2471534759,
-0.4589604735,
-0.3695142269,
0.0178096388,
0.4664786458,
-0.5072462559,
0.6449915767,
0.7131745219,
-0.2860892415,
-0.1593777239,
-0.243273899,
0.4518494308,
0.4335638285,
-0.8369460702,
0.0741522163,
1.0129497051,
0.5066667795,
0.1965705603,
0.7950626016,
-0.2634347975,
0.2778297365,
-0.3214621842,
0.2803402245,
-0.6596913934,
-0.142809853,
-0.3654889166,
0.5590439439,
0.3569135666,
-0.0440201424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02959v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02959v1
|
SimuCourt: Building Judicial Decision-Making Agents with Real-world Judgement Documents
| 2024-03-05T13:30:02 | 2024-03-05T13:30:02 |
Zhitao He, Pengfei Cao, Chenhao Wang, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Jiexin Xu, Huaijun Li, Xiaojian Jiang, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the development of deep learning, natural language processing technology
has effectively improved the efficiency of various aspects of the traditional
judicial industry. However, most current efforts focus solely on individual
judicial stage, overlooking cross-stage collaboration. As the autonomous agents
powered by large language models are becoming increasingly smart and able to
make complex decisions in real-world settings, offering new insights for
judicial intelligence. In this paper, (1) we introduce SimuCourt, a judicial
benchmark that encompasses 420 judgment documents from real-world, spanning the
three most common types of judicial cases, and a novel task Judicial
Decision-Making to evaluate the judicial analysis and decision-making power of
agents. To support this task, we construct a large-scale judicial knowledge
base, JudicialKB, with multiple legal knowledge. (2) we propose a novel
multi-agent framework, AgentsCourt. Our framework follows the real-world
classic court trial process, consisting of court debate simulation, legal
information retrieval and judgement refinement to simulate the decision-making
of judge. (3) we perform extensive experiments, the results demonstrate that,
our framework outperforms the existing advanced methods in various aspects,
especially in generating legal grounds, where our model achieves significant
improvements of 8.6% and 9.1% F1 score in the first and second instance
settings, respectively.
|
[
-0.4792049527,
-0.5845658183,
0.8889567852,
-0.1112673506,
-0.218691662,
0.0927220732,
-0.2566646636,
-0.5000432134,
0.1219916195,
0.633209765,
-0.5854664445,
-0.3392570615,
-0.3254695237,
-0.2436451614,
-0.2846368253,
0.7157971263,
0.1580150872,
0.2704798877,
-0.2413915545,
-0.3265789151,
-0.2602059245,
-0.400857687,
-0.4184942544,
-0.214687705,
0.2999516129,
0.5189701915,
0.9700606465,
0.4675847292,
0.5845496655,
0.4457232654,
0.2337110639,
0.1421279907,
-0.0982402563,
0.3251512051,
-0.5014372468,
-0.6533733606,
-0.4319968522,
0.3323720694,
0.1884412467,
0.3567844033,
-0.3736674786,
0.0233857669,
-0.5585232377,
0.6922333837,
-0.8415712118,
0.1612747312,
-0.4778831005,
0.3891364932,
0.0874688551,
-0.0488149822,
-0.4322313368,
-0.5595106483,
0.1607518643,
-0.94866395,
0.2657144964,
0.3048337102,
0.5957458019,
0.4638765752,
-0.5439727902,
-0.1884680688,
-0.809591651,
0.4970063269,
-0.6236075759,
0.4895638227,
0.2613837123,
1.0154391527,
-0.1452811658,
-1.2844253778,
-0.6142591834,
-0.5677307844,
0.0065635801,
0.4641626477,
0.1416799873,
0.3288385868,
0.3866269886,
-0.1898545325,
-0.2865428925,
-0.3127789795,
-0.1024380699,
-0.1576282382,
0.7197977304,
0.052153226,
0.120668672,
-0.1504732221,
-0.1851870418,
-0.4946519136,
-0.1656542569,
0.1244936362,
0.4703349471,
0.5517966747,
0.2428300083,
0.2453873605,
-0.4640999138,
0.4453827143,
0.0078571942,
-0.2235744447,
0.0996854901,
-0.2868374586,
-0.3099274933,
0.3424012661,
0.777140379,
0.4363530874,
0.4211777449,
-0.0022489619,
-0.0893432423,
-0.2356865704,
0.5545358062,
-0.9205340147,
0.0620850548,
0.212204963,
-0.5775930882,
-0.3020420372,
0.4608803093,
-0.5328299999,
-0.773023963,
-0.7241579294,
0.1906869262,
-0.4460752904,
-0.187979579,
0.0069328132,
-0.1752788126,
0.051073119,
0.7400987148,
-0.1984717399,
0.5126268864,
0.66350317,
0.4499833882,
0.3861733973,
-0.287227124,
-0.8778333664,
0.0106507745,
-0.3743886352,
0.8382946253,
-0.5849597454,
-0.0868235156,
0.1394331604,
-0.0819606707,
0.0207424834,
-0.5838748217,
1.0374571085,
-0.5327616334,
-0.222941339,
-0.4433322251,
-0.4875215292,
-0.227737844,
0.417848587,
-0.9362698793,
0.5407676697,
-0.1599362344,
-0.4098528028,
1.0750344992,
-0.5522998571,
-0.4623517692,
0.2958934903,
-0.5486419797,
-0.4003486633,
0.0189764556,
0.0973926634,
0.2619542181,
-0.4794009924,
0.5274738073,
-0.4428117573,
-0.334422946,
0.0877042562,
-0.3263604641,
0.6453023553,
0.2841557264,
-0.330781877,
-0.0037469047,
-0.6749925613,
0.08381401,
-0.0798701495,
-0.1226664111,
-0.2827936113,
0.205995813,
-0.0528886095,
0.5768390298,
-0.2236622274,
-0.5610178709,
0.2917153239,
-0.106607534,
0.0332004428,
0.6587937474,
0.0492822714,
0.2925367653,
-0.3966152668,
0.5350099802,
-0.1696825027,
0.4550027251,
0.2785389125,
-0.347622782,
-0.6204584837,
-0.0927051753,
0.6221246719,
0.4678082466,
-0.7888939977,
0.1258579791,
-0.434245199,
-0.3974753618,
-0.6559409499,
-0.217539534,
0.1273155808,
0.1286715269,
0.2715930343,
-0.1033263579,
-0.3942377567,
-1.0474272966,
-0.6944726706,
-0.3245726824,
0.3676428795,
0.4849841893,
0.6042028069,
-0.0615996011,
1.1379095316,
-0.0977592617,
-0.3276655376,
-0.1172988787,
0.1992236823,
0.1403890699,
0.1863519251,
0.5488051772,
-1.0995025635,
-0.3586207628,
0.2411364913,
-0.8954968452,
0.1031407863,
-0.4990475178,
-0.2992706001,
-0.2898023129,
0.6503167748,
-0.700995028,
0.5114572644,
-0.3045939505,
-0.4819248319,
0.6135309935,
-0.2981003821,
0.4214742482,
-0.7066499591,
-0.1642933339,
-0.2743822336,
-0.5187346339,
-0.5736831427,
0.2597459257,
0.2801519334,
0.3479624391,
-0.6354409456,
0.5354683399,
-0.280928582,
-0.2909350097,
-0.089602761,
0.3636614382,
-0.1133080572,
0.3899748027,
-0.184122175,
0.419534862,
0.1072068959,
-0.4598238766,
0.6772847176,
0.1062291637,
-0.3396263123,
0.802429378,
-0.1078867465,
-0.2261340916,
-0.0178138074,
0.4132744372,
-0.2923014164,
-0.3476679325,
0.1555005759,
-0.1577635556,
0.0483877733,
-0.3003690541,
-0.7484003901,
-0.4043617249,
-0.276776433,
0.3638176024,
0.1184548214,
-0.3934832513,
1.3295091391,
0.2241691947,
-0.1129672006,
-0.678894043,
-0.7005859017,
0.2502084076,
0.2528329492,
-0.5110720396,
0.2786080539,
-0.0870805904,
-0.6878894567,
0.2521636188,
-0.0708039999,
0.0319801606,
-0.0165820345,
0.5087708235,
-0.2666451633,
-0.0620210506,
0.3518124819,
0.3790346682,
0.0753596798,
0.2363944352,
-0.1619017869,
0.1850399375,
-0.0183942858,
-0.921481967,
-0.3643133342,
0.117399171,
0.7255561352,
-0.2901134193,
0.3670675457,
0.100638628,
-0.1782987565,
-0.7818808556,
-0.6404018998,
-0.0068453592,
-0.4236000776,
0.109062776,
-0.6407424808,
-0.5076413751,
0.4586603045,
-0.4988917708,
0.2785672545,
0.2440560907,
0.7055107951,
0.3614855111,
0.6452001333,
0.2854589522,
0.0872190222,
0.5189281702,
-0.1690247953,
0.2628446817,
-0.2281380594,
-0.1980323344,
-0.2306089848,
-0.1952187568,
-0.6007500291,
-0.3988787234,
0.1821872294,
-0.3423956335,
-0.2957947254,
0.0590404198,
-0.2219656706,
0.5425412655,
0.9779679775,
0.0947488025,
0.5053220987,
-0.327290982,
-0.7498370409,
0.3753732741,
-0.6047450304,
-0.3449188471,
1.1236201525,
-0.1273130029,
0.3681845367,
0.0687633604,
0.7959282398,
0.7298426628,
0.2013876736,
-0.7451758981,
0.7034326196,
0.048078429,
-0.6155810356,
-0.0570366792,
-0.345248431,
-0.5426806808,
0.805449903,
-0.3971132636,
-0.1501186639,
0.3987771273,
-0.4249115586,
-0.7978816628,
0.234983772,
-0.5306139588,
0.6625545621,
-0.3194618225,
-0.7346372008,
-0.2624686956,
-0.7660802007,
0.386133939,
-0.0178493969,
0.420471251,
-0.2443016618,
0.0131031107,
0.4604481161,
-0.8195870519,
0.4222854376,
-0.3871290088,
0.1366914362,
0.5356593728,
0.1841169298,
0.6222217083,
0.2651664317,
-0.3039490879,
-0.4966677129,
-0.0675363541,
-0.0342139751,
-0.8251382113,
0.4771614075,
-0.6214776039,
-0.4098828137,
-0.7441586852,
-0.5890172124,
-0.1839883327,
0.1952553689,
-0.1661046892,
0.2788972855,
-0.5180116296,
0.0651727021,
0.1209860444,
-0.014673179,
0.3847326934,
0.8308971524,
-0.0526032299,
-0.2897333205,
0.7824059129,
0.3329843879,
-0.0860995352,
0.0909804255,
-0.0468327217,
-0.0994075686,
-0.2812196314,
-0.3758229315,
-0.0101788072,
-0.8569011688,
-0.2914745212,
-0.5640957355,
-0.153538689,
-0.4023901522,
-0.1165114045,
-0.4499326944,
-0.5139509439,
0.4972438216,
-0.3454664946,
0.1144491658,
0.6417541504,
-0.1219476387,
-0.0039776848,
-0.5183711052,
0.5901961327,
0.7748584747,
0.4322145879,
-0.15143013,
-0.1734123826,
-0.1549306363,
-0.0442339145,
-0.1370851845,
-0.4319002926,
0.2508403361,
0.0066263131,
0.8451346755,
0.3931583166,
0.5231101513,
0.5933240056,
-0.6204646826,
0.443276912,
-0.2030670345,
-0.6151100993,
0.5212693214,
-0.1751146168,
0.0410829261,
1.0266478062,
-0.1246527061,
-0.3651674688,
-0.5525134206,
-0.761957109,
-0.6907858253,
1.232109189,
0.5147087574,
-0.1245079711,
0.3957256675,
0.3822060823,
-0.0147455046,
0.2847508192,
-0.4130915105,
-0.0001007628,
-0.1579275429,
-0.1433179379,
0.4514064193,
0.1748463959,
-0.2357802093,
-0.3505490422,
0.7028186321,
-0.2958270013,
0.0228485242,
0.2304673493,
-0.324026525,
-0.0336582363,
0.140429154,
0.3368402421,
0.5516150594,
-0.3479353189,
0.0889083818,
0.0654601157,
-0.3891450465,
0.2179423124,
0.523637116,
-0.1066052467,
-0.2065246999,
0.6709917188,
0.6967873573,
-0.0645346716,
-0.922208488,
0.6812899113,
-0.689771831,
-0.546333909,
-0.5107780695,
0.213752687,
-0.0760557577,
0.8226422071,
0.4187322557,
0.2729938328,
0.5549087524,
-0.6874047518,
0.5387636423,
0.2768676877,
-0.330627501,
0.3457475305,
0.523068428,
0.2785665393,
-0.1013121456,
0.3037129641,
-0.5363737941,
-0.4176429212,
0.9426628351,
-0.0950985178,
0.9080855846,
0.0383706614,
0.2787332535,
0.1341592073,
0.2834428847,
-0.4110862911,
0.0543870479,
-0.4183469415,
-0.566229105,
-0.2319110483,
-0.6213253736,
-0.7463675141,
-0.3898200691,
-0.4796778262,
0.1641946137,
-0.6501064897,
-0.3746601641,
0.0058658211,
0.386128962,
-0.7144359946,
0.3290448487,
0.0456126705,
0.7211380005,
-0.6202559471,
0.7904927135,
0.6008229256,
-0.5543665886,
-0.6319926381,
0.1553884596,
0.2229379863,
-0.3821897805,
0.6893744469,
0.1844473034,
-0.3502799273,
-0.4459320307,
-0.56477952,
-0.4761541486,
1.2403560877,
0.5252797008,
-0.6756196022,
0.0695863515,
0.1793052107,
0.5803146362,
-0.4154485464,
0.5417937636,
0.7714306116,
0.725210309,
0.0828114152,
-0.659193933,
0.2056741118,
-0.5488339663,
-0.1577247679,
0.1324134618,
-0.7545214295,
0.9395473003,
-0.1073213294,
-0.1323195994,
-0.0923998803,
0.5668336153,
0.347301662,
0.3535663188,
0.529233098,
0.7283705473,
0.7570209503,
-0.0917798802,
1.2788914442,
-0.4347220957,
0.2417770475,
1.2738349438,
-0.5270525813,
0.4147155881,
0.1928900182,
-0.0426803604,
0.554477334,
0.2957628965,
-0.0831807479,
0.3170961142,
0.0918417126,
-0.2719009519,
-0.8133987188,
-0.328225404,
-0.0728677139,
0.3927078545,
0.0135003701,
-0.3786699772,
-0.2280112356,
0.0555402711,
-0.102219753,
0.231702283,
-0.1054465324,
0.8049432635,
-0.00707892,
-0.6562185884,
-0.102472432,
-0.0070777675,
0.0266238488,
-0.484395802,
-0.3309512138,
-0.1625999063,
0.483594805,
-0.1163120195,
-0.6637864113,
-0.3611700833,
-0.108215712,
-0.0953765288,
-0.1980223358,
0.5820469856,
-0.0523438565,
-0.7504647374,
0.7651457191,
0.6824881434,
-0.1139420792,
-0.2440368235,
-0.9816442728,
-0.1787114441,
-0.3782539368,
-0.5568424463,
0.2554109097,
1.0209035873,
-0.3905802369,
0.6892552376,
0.6738958359,
0.1694753319,
-0.0419343859,
0.7348406911,
1.0255162716,
-0.7748098969,
-0.5769631267,
-0.5902224779,
0.23752518,
-0.6671255827,
-0.0037332929,
0.4135094881,
0.5867271423,
0.6799146533,
0.2868614197,
1.0446960926,
-0.2122245878,
0.4718394578,
-0.4725229442,
0.6596206427,
-0.59393996,
0.0430932939,
-0.2486036867,
-0.7694386244,
-0.3242534399,
0.5312069654,
-0.2422494888,
0.334156245,
0.6384693384,
0.6807466149,
-0.2596820295,
0.0990978181,
0.4355217814,
0.0964349955,
0.4078572392,
0.4343084991,
0.8086367249,
-0.4992394745,
0.6714704037,
-0.3259808719,
-0.0232351162,
-0.5357007384,
-0.5554989576,
-0.8450576067,
-0.0990762487,
0.1606240124,
0.0971565023,
0.2034656107,
1.2772051096,
0.7460699677,
-0.7836843133,
-0.242634654,
-0.2136349976,
0.0821129754,
-0.3474890888,
-0.1509475112,
0.2686626613,
-0.5205067992,
-0.4759000838,
0.3672349155,
0.1059903055,
-0.3712452054,
0.2318030298,
-0.3393827677,
-0.6448862553,
0.3582801819,
0.5612024069,
-0.038808234,
-0.7555285096,
-0.0966868848,
-0.4902139902,
-0.1919934303,
-0.0874472186,
1.02173388,
-1.0195270777,
0.7743207216,
0.4077644944,
0.5797871947,
0.6161748767,
0.3316346705,
0.5487026572,
-0.4324572086,
0.317425698,
0.3685047328,
0.6209394932,
-0.0548044369,
-0.0606367663,
0.7433219552,
0.2739022076,
-0.4355576932,
-0.3956094086,
0.0119363228,
-0.8293192387,
-0.7260062695,
0.7958238125,
0.0340877511,
-0.2289232314,
-0.2044088542,
-0.4507733583,
0.3506522477,
-0.7656233907,
0.4820723534,
0.6313851476,
-0.1488648355,
0.0164903197,
-0.9500752687,
0.6403375864,
0.2065675408,
-0.8963785768,
0.099382557,
0.7937772274,
-0.1175028384,
0.343922019,
0.5476110578,
0.1272444874,
0.5926078558,
0.2819634974,
0.2257544249,
-0.3024483621,
-0.551445961,
0.0281451195,
0.4953731596,
-0.1166711971,
0.2905230522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02951v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02951v2
|
Benchmarking the Text-to-SQL Capability of Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Evaluation
| 2024-03-05T13:23:48 | 2024-03-06T08:43:17 |
Bin Zhang, Yuxiao Ye, Guoqing Du, Xiaoru Hu, Zhishuai Li, Sun Yang, Chi Harold Liu, Rui Zhao, Ziyue Li, Hangyu Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as a powerful tool in advancing the
Text-to-SQL task, significantly outperforming traditional methods.
Nevertheless, as a nascent research field, there is still no consensus on the
optimal prompt templates and design frameworks. Additionally, existing
benchmarks inadequately explore the performance of LLMs across the various
sub-tasks of the Text-to-SQL process, which hinders the assessment of LLMs'
cognitive capabilities and the optimization of LLM-based solutions. To address
the aforementioned issues, we firstly construct a new dataset designed to
mitigate the risk of overfitting in LLMs. Then we formulate five evaluation
tasks to comprehensively assess the performance of diverse methods across
various LLMs throughout the Text-to-SQL process.Our study highlights the
performance disparities among LLMs and proposes optimal in-context learning
solutions tailored to each task. These findings offer valuable insights for
enhancing the development of LLM-based Text-to-SQL systems.
|
[
-0.2848453224,
-0.8440158963,
0.7934801579,
0.2522552013,
-0.4044198096,
0.1433291733,
-0.566911459,
-0.3193971813,
-0.2464104593,
0.4571814239,
-0.6054134965,
-0.659018755,
-0.4839106798,
0.4571790099,
-0.4500125349,
0.7355962396,
0.0596414544,
0.0253577512,
-0.726391077,
-0.1045439988,
-0.704030633,
-0.5524644852,
-0.4615978599,
-0.3292786777,
0.21657525,
0.3322864175,
0.2132251114,
0.4339135885,
0.3759637177,
0.2051815242,
-0.2023245692,
0.1931607425,
-0.6942837834,
0.2932686806,
-0.3393218219,
-0.4040026665,
-0.3511901498,
-0.3223216832,
0.8621804118,
0.7913808823,
-0.1055026427,
0.2477699816,
0.1839827448,
0.7950060368,
-0.6529741883,
-0.0081077879,
-0.7607787251,
-0.0174833555,
-0.3667431474,
-0.1173909828,
-0.6748456955,
-0.4444374442,
0.1576771438,
-0.2424974889,
-0.1708443314,
0.1589584649,
0.2438078821,
0.2378747016,
-0.6288429499,
-0.3389169872,
-0.5933485627,
0.9801067114,
-0.6017655134,
0.4447420239,
-0.0514311269,
0.3432227969,
-0.3001200259,
-0.5797049403,
-0.2105365694,
-0.3838303387,
0.0589113794,
-0.0348122418,
0.0055952966,
-0.2048503906,
0.2848467529,
0.3336447477,
-0.7209653258,
0.3499476314,
0.1441990584,
-0.018939333,
0.6294785738,
0.5187349319,
0.0065736412,
-0.0171843283,
-0.3858145177,
0.0752240494,
-0.7351402044,
-0.1176953092,
-0.0668732896,
0.5235708356,
0.0715087652,
0.6159508824,
-0.2599250972,
0.7155131102,
-0.1962062865,
-0.1518135965,
0.2697113752,
-0.4515851438,
-0.2797493339,
-0.1710678637,
0.8504739404,
0.3038367629,
0.2338927537,
-0.5203697681,
-0.4951469004,
-0.1546193212,
0.2235995829,
-0.841765523,
0.3359149098,
0.1849213988,
-0.3324299157,
-0.1063401997,
-0.3967273533,
-0.8244921565,
-0.5760188103,
-0.3322683573,
0.353479743,
-0.2672199905,
-0.0827290863,
-0.1526954174,
0.0299169235,
0.1148124635,
0.2973475754,
-0.6894487143,
0.5739728808,
0.7190861106,
0.7562964559,
-0.7525730729,
-0.0385331064,
-0.2582058907,
0.0698123649,
-0.530616641,
0.8241559863,
-0.4610484242,
-0.6378653646,
0.2505053282,
-0.1491214931,
0.0227900073,
-0.8063399792,
0.6429314017,
-0.4331820905,
0.0687045828,
-0.6378079653,
-0.8992176652,
0.209109202,
0.3608619273,
-0.5163754225,
1.1521955729,
0.1400479376,
-0.4462275505,
0.4326145649,
-0.4056226611,
-0.4986925125,
0.1260361671,
-0.395419836,
-0.3418513536,
0.4119116962,
0.2285625339,
0.5244588852,
-0.9529492259,
0.297314018,
-0.1892808378,
-0.5277604461,
0.3136706948,
-0.3097957373,
0.5914946795,
0.1426509917,
-0.2512606084,
0.1464085728,
-0.791467607,
0.1568066031,
0.2227968574,
-0.5016877651,
-0.1751542985,
0.1769582927,
0.1619894952,
0.0557516478,
0.314568013,
-0.335762918,
0.1030535847,
-0.2991859317,
0.4201873243,
0.5592020154,
-0.1980461776,
0.3336119652,
-0.2592684329,
0.3958177567,
-0.1029330716,
0.0083243679,
-0.2308302522,
0.0146668358,
-0.6160984635,
-0.3359056413,
0.1421286166,
0.5037351847,
-0.5910307765,
0.5259289742,
-0.2870927751,
-0.5523236394,
-0.0163010899,
0.227141425,
0.4078514278,
0.3890817165,
0.4280696511,
-0.3719266951,
-0.3316845596,
-0.8300108314,
-0.4854825139,
0.0917122439,
-0.185500592,
0.3510559499,
0.4711492956,
-0.0293505806,
0.9432980418,
-0.2877722681,
-0.3663547337,
-0.3284671605,
-0.1642070264,
0.2514186203,
0.1511475891,
0.5490860939,
-0.3453534842,
-0.4282953143,
-0.0894087031,
-0.7353289723,
-0.1492024958,
-0.0642646775,
0.1980922222,
0.4519463778,
0.7506998181,
-0.3808988333,
-0.0701317191,
0.3646697104,
-0.1771429628,
0.6741939187,
-0.0737499893,
0.0273040775,
-0.9734800458,
0.3101140857,
0.1137500554,
-0.1616988927,
-0.4364052117,
-0.113456741,
0.3171797395,
-0.035468664,
-0.2609490156,
0.5913532376,
-0.6192781329,
-0.3304065466,
-0.078963846,
0.2825005352,
-0.1409275085,
0.2573148608,
-0.0428610072,
0.9116403461,
0.4527919888,
-0.5039221048,
0.2871275842,
0.2047265321,
-0.7250334024,
0.7727104425,
-0.7400686145,
0.018008573,
-0.0932217166,
0.3269664049,
-1.060972929,
0.0381340161,
-0.2198878527,
-0.1952147633,
0.3273244202,
0.0689383522,
-0.6711048484,
-0.1361728907,
-0.3610225916,
0.4498617649,
0.4988645911,
-0.4707413614,
0.6409481168,
0.2672160268,
-0.154542774,
-0.5115141869,
-0.6178239584,
0.345272243,
-0.2957687676,
-0.3066501915,
0.4949337542,
0.1059814319,
-0.2372724414,
-0.3910363913,
-0.1604225934,
-0.0105215339,
0.0999411196,
0.0221621133,
0.1837652028,
-0.1491199136,
0.455286175,
-0.0089568608,
-0.0517325886,
0.3294634819,
-0.1923929155,
0.4630880356,
0.0464228392,
-0.4425394237,
-0.0750165433,
0.2948057055,
0.4007321894,
-0.3280225694,
0.7298762202,
0.1499062032,
-0.2867831886,
-0.5169064403,
-0.7483690977,
-0.1245011166,
-0.4419251084,
0.6522792578,
-0.2898745835,
-0.8563987017,
0.3442668617,
-0.5051141381,
0.2773389518,
0.4196944833,
0.5744604468,
0.0889693052,
0.6735497117,
0.6522167325,
-0.0182318036,
0.5060466528,
0.0728343204,
0.1227937639,
-0.744707644,
-0.4652312696,
-0.8412371278,
0.0454919823,
-0.3696938455,
-0.4932520092,
0.4078630507,
-0.0211193822,
-0.3445373774,
0.193410784,
-0.2985781133,
0.4935778379,
0.0177901909,
-0.000002026,
0.4681451619,
0.0932705775,
-0.3151987493,
-0.2097816616,
-0.654777348,
-0.6730674505,
1.1961129904,
0.3114929795,
0.7156294584,
0.0942573398,
0.4658330977,
0.1371893883,
0.3202191591,
-0.6323613524,
0.7082777023,
-0.3834383786,
-0.571303606,
-0.3893551826,
-0.4784634709,
-0.6738886237,
0.1617994606,
-0.3244538307,
-0.8324902058,
-0.1645963192,
-0.1137100458,
-0.0338018239,
0.0488005318,
-0.5492823124,
0.905706346,
-0.311185807,
-0.5522814393,
-0.2100607455,
-0.3817140758,
0.2250246555,
-0.3428186178,
0.2009844631,
-0.0877835974,
-0.4589792788,
0.6454146504,
-0.0957480296,
0.71350348,
0.0671199635,
-0.2076942027,
0.1317400783,
-0.0935112908,
0.4083354175,
-0.0166505706,
-0.4838145375,
0.0850537643,
-0.0231492389,
-0.2949902415,
-0.4185813069,
0.7806364298,
-0.4291513264,
-0.3952305913,
-0.3067541718,
-0.3546960354,
-0.5872231126,
0.1992646903,
0.1103093326,
0.5193098783,
-0.6172953844,
0.3777863681,
0.7894496918,
-0.4367998838,
0.5966860056,
0.510384202,
-0.1746780276,
-0.3326010406,
0.658509016,
0.1060849354,
0.3107227087,
0.573902607,
-0.0247033089,
-0.7461355329,
-0.8919158578,
-0.4690933228,
0.1267986894,
-0.8508418798,
-0.0016673323,
-0.4470869005,
0.0447536372,
-0.1903157532,
0.0072240261,
-0.3708756864,
-0.0677706897,
-0.2982678413,
0.2641606033,
0.2010401189,
0.6735728383,
0.6135234237,
0.1918821335,
-0.6542836428,
-0.084745273,
0.1447314024,
0.5811870694,
0.1598567665,
-0.5050788522,
-0.1547849774,
-0.3818573058,
-0.2726989686,
-0.6869370937,
-0.0076605463,
0.2054855376,
0.7735598683,
0.0633739531,
0.1792594492,
0.5317969918,
-0.6158440709,
0.8268836141,
0.0858596265,
-1.0904232264,
0.392380774,
-0.2728884816,
0.4318410754,
0.6663561463,
0.3862933218,
-0.3703171313,
-0.0708373562,
-0.0756257623,
-1.0052880049,
0.4482269585,
0.1240598112,
0.1175670177,
-0.1151722819,
0.383228004,
0.1296606064,
0.3646731377,
-0.6682391167,
-0.1163570955,
0.357096374,
-0.1269912869,
-0.4770670533,
-0.317299664,
0.0524919406,
-0.017452877,
0.3860271871,
-0.3142186105,
0.1387128979,
-0.0119961491,
-0.2624896169,
0.0811868086,
0.3504664898,
0.4957481027,
1.0166729689,
-0.03153776,
-0.1363245994,
0.7361027598,
-0.1885119528,
-0.0600969419,
-0.0668057129,
0.0644259751,
-0.0541508198,
0.5876899362,
0.5775691867,
0.178721115,
-1.0231124163,
0.3918592036,
-0.1806525439,
-0.0728888586,
-0.1595374048,
0.0593762361,
0.3589279652,
0.209218204,
0.4833007455,
-0.3890787661,
0.0720952079,
-0.6413857937,
-0.0079307742,
0.7040848136,
-0.3389313221,
0.0874272883,
0.3785462976,
0.319577992,
-0.3894546926,
0.4463336766,
0.2235561609,
-0.2955704033,
0.5512281656,
0.4393979311,
0.814479053,
-0.1086962372,
-0.2125375569,
0.3704353273,
0.2813420296,
-0.1212605983,
0.2467686981,
-0.050575465,
-0.2796093822,
-0.4657253921,
-0.5822343826,
-0.3905548155,
0.0900070593,
-0.486443907,
0.4353720248,
-0.2909556627,
-0.2468068302,
-0.0090159252,
0.2177799791,
-0.4870330393,
0.2478784621,
-0.1275107712,
1.1684911251,
-0.703998208,
0.7362877727,
0.620057106,
-0.0514758006,
-0.268987298,
-0.0423834249,
-0.0913232341,
-0.5652429461,
0.3179763258,
0.1499540657,
0.0933282301,
-0.1686470956,
-0.1906314641,
-0.5657687187,
1.0135793686,
0.5913507342,
-0.9702966213,
0.1150817871,
0.4708324075,
0.7044887543,
-0.467341274,
0.4706986845,
0.7747011185,
0.3315934539,
-0.0320491605,
-0.9596930146,
0.1918319166,
0.0483116582,
0.3403657377,
0.299353689,
-0.5147464275,
0.6434493065,
-0.0653835014,
-0.1314615607,
0.1293887347,
0.392611444,
0.3054210842,
0.2191322446,
0.4695832133,
0.299898386,
0.5897237062,
-0.1170466766,
0.9937396646,
-0.192507267,
0.2642561793,
1.1392624378,
-0.5780206919,
1.0896323919,
0.6640796661,
-0.337538898,
0.0726422742,
0.5879329443,
-0.0315770023,
0.3771220446,
0.6238110065,
-0.2624194026,
-0.29388991,
-0.1957876682,
-0.2977290452,
0.1294367313,
0.3980770707,
-0.371407181,
-0.3916613162,
-0.2621126771,
-0.3302268684,
0.4396440983,
-0.1145607233,
0.9702458978,
0.1403413564,
-0.6707056761,
0.5855365992,
-0.045727171,
0.6982062459,
-0.5550123453,
0.1845572889,
-0.2304662019,
0.2821314931,
-0.103545703,
-0.7700251341,
0.2524628937,
0.1438884586,
-0.10438288,
-0.1850799769,
0.5237396359,
-0.3234544098,
-0.3730957806,
0.4257412553,
0.6023911834,
0.0506239645,
-0.023334587,
-0.591060698,
0.4040073752,
-0.2471427023,
-0.2929592133,
0.5941346288,
0.4916836023,
-0.1457014531,
0.7053607702,
0.3533860147,
-0.0456662215,
-0.2725374401,
0.2106892616,
0.8160312176,
-0.6421645284,
-0.2447518408,
-1.1955577135,
0.36193645,
-0.1995162666,
-0.4421918988,
0.7647234797,
0.8051592708,
0.7368473411,
0.0212805029,
0.6723062396,
0.1089006141,
0.5270386934,
-0.5166565776,
0.5805906057,
-0.7355830669,
0.5690155625,
-0.4618000984,
-1.1834509373,
-0.1789749116,
0.2231165171,
-0.2021779418,
0.3219891489,
0.8438774943,
0.7336171269,
0.2665402591,
-0.0400978029,
0.4144892693,
0.0478954241,
0.3339025676,
0.6813012958,
0.8585413694,
-0.3553194702,
0.4523427784,
0.0676102191,
-0.1501356661,
-0.2631006539,
-1.3180555105,
-1.2457119226,
-0.5260775685,
-0.1883978546,
-0.1414940059,
0.345888108,
0.9741207361,
0.5725479722,
-0.7420390248,
-0.6066008806,
-0.0648625195,
0.0676120669,
-0.0991903991,
-0.0875755548,
0.2964496315,
-0.5217134356,
-0.5759615898,
0.445177108,
0.2953754067,
-0.0111737959,
-0.2759590745,
0.0177335963,
0.0312120412,
0.0771617368,
0.8375716805,
-0.1327035427,
-0.5778028965,
0.1370129734,
0.0201272313,
-0.3208270073,
-0.1202714816,
0.763815999,
-0.6999725699,
0.1484582424,
0.4937793911,
0.9144409299,
0.3918859661,
-0.1881052554,
0.7135205865,
-0.7135081291,
-0.154385373,
0.3286752701,
0.178315863,
0.3284024894,
-0.1178731546,
0.4198435545,
-0.0812363997,
-0.5590363741,
-1.0654708147,
-0.0727352872,
-0.8868418336,
-0.5119216442,
1.1207036972,
-0.083334446,
-0.0273911916,
-0.1394853592,
-0.12293908,
0.0176506136,
-0.3317775428,
0.6683875918,
0.6791543365,
0.1151018739,
0.0023206838,
-0.6319594979,
0.5744552016,
0.5970332026,
-1.0439889431,
0.4044770896,
0.4518002272,
0.3965703547,
-0.2646149099,
0.4864793718,
-0.1459106207,
0.0743956342,
-0.2110840082,
-0.19082959,
0.0351534635,
-0.3199064136,
-0.5880161524,
0.2186749429,
0.3611392379,
0.2341017872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02939v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02939v2
|
PaperWeaver: Enriching Topical Paper Alerts by Contextualizing Recommended Papers with User-collected Papers
| 2024-03-05T13:10:06 | 2024-05-09T07:59:01 |
Yoonjoo Lee, Hyeonsu B. Kang, Matt Latzke, Juho Kim, Jonathan Bragg, Joseph Chee Chang, Pao Siangliulue
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
With the rapid growth of scholarly archives, researchers subscribe to "paper
alert" systems that periodically provide them with recommendations of recently
published papers that are similar to previously collected papers. However,
researchers sometimes struggle to make sense of nuanced connections between
recommended papers and their own research context, as existing systems only
present paper titles and abstracts. To help researchers spot these connections,
we present PaperWeaver, an enriched paper alerts system that provides
contextualized text descriptions of recommended papers based on user-collected
papers. PaperWeaver employs a computational method based on Large Language
Models (LLMs) to infer users' research interests from their collected papers,
extract context-specific aspects of papers, and compare recommended and
collected papers on these aspects. Our user study (N=15) showed that
participants using PaperWeaver were able to better understand the relevance of
recommended papers and triage them more confidently when compared to a baseline
that presented the related work sections from recommended papers.
|
[
-0.3247754872,
-0.1519444734,
0.7828091979,
0.2457685769,
-0.3186361194,
0.0824486613,
-0.1396715641,
-0.6955938339,
0.3994790018,
0.262175858,
-0.269120127,
-0.4058474898,
-0.4797740281,
0.0960797369,
-0.7443321943,
1.1891893148,
0.1698379219,
-0.3218295574,
-0.4726385176,
0.1423136741,
-0.3443827331,
0.0129634999,
-0.295551151,
-0.5893672705,
0.7582184076,
0.5009414554,
0.3466201127,
0.1485100836,
1.0220146179,
0.2023955584,
-0.159617126,
-0.0108517054,
-0.3468438685,
0.4256472588,
-0.5631610751,
-0.0876601934,
-0.4804260135,
-0.0967126638,
0.0003930715,
0.4541761577,
-0.0441337675,
0.4703490436,
0.2524056733,
0.5555149317,
-1.0311748981,
-0.2714603543,
-0.5193843246,
-0.0699711815,
-0.4431593418,
-0.7324050665,
-0.3636249304,
-0.3916130662,
0.3290874958,
-0.5443800092,
0.2631337643,
-0.2377087176,
0.5752598643,
-0.2452694923,
-0.393366158,
-0.3504760861,
-0.9318716526,
0.4952444732,
-0.1974373609,
0.092989929,
0.4330424964,
0.5568346381,
-0.0746322274,
-1.0649819374,
-0.075830996,
0.2749884427,
-0.1470768601,
0.5131911635,
-0.2764376998,
-0.3256740868,
0.1503871679,
0.2495413721,
-0.6232714653,
-0.4008660614,
-0.4171465039,
-0.0585845113,
0.4905889928,
0.0347467363,
0.1764465868,
-0.2169684023,
-0.3338025808,
-0.0700564012,
-0.4454604387,
0.0655683503,
-0.0675697252,
0.1086379662,
0.0786287189,
0.2261639386,
-0.1842844933,
0.7732307911,
0.1809019893,
-0.5943645835,
0.2016126513,
0.083674781,
-0.0834951922,
-0.0454245396,
0.4383795261,
0.5300564766,
0.0896890014,
-0.2809230685,
-0.3338392079,
-0.2980879247,
0.2096706033,
-0.6886952519,
-0.2776968777,
0.290985465,
-0.6495414972,
-0.1703740954,
0.1592503339,
-0.9002047181,
-0.7245380878,
-0.4035713971,
0.1902276874,
-0.1974852979,
-0.3992176354,
-0.0582035668,
-0.4775107205,
-0.3768654466,
0.6362749934,
-0.5722884536,
0.043883983,
0.6502922177,
0.6759485602,
-0.1389224678,
-0.1422392279,
-0.3757020533,
0.6198065877,
0.0794320703,
1.1820842028,
-0.7376977801,
-0.8245574236,
0.2202070206,
-0.3359057903,
0.3022458851,
-0.2609630823,
0.7236552238,
-0.8237078786,
0.3839613199,
-0.4381691813,
-0.2820827067,
-0.1041712016,
0.2442760766,
-0.2858358324,
0.9859771132,
0.2383744121,
-1.0858424902,
0.4775761366,
-0.5066488981,
-0.5338101387,
0.4173373878,
-0.1089383364,
0.1041841581,
0.2760260701,
0.0715696663,
0.4180873036,
-0.5700015426,
0.5277582407,
-0.1596423388,
-0.2194955349,
-0.0233904906,
0.1803102046,
0.7562925816,
0.5330815911,
-0.0629428327,
0.1564044058,
-0.3600399792,
-0.1190019846,
-0.0505703576,
-0.089140676,
-0.6716220379,
-0.2010777593,
0.4096198976,
-0.0429991446,
0.455971241,
-0.1283826977,
0.005075641,
0.1872073412,
0.1301311702,
0.4588491917,
0.1527808458,
0.2658576071,
-0.7047042251,
0.6290685534,
-0.3268393576,
-0.1151046678,
-0.2760108709,
-0.2912377715,
-0.4718163908,
-0.2547413111,
0.310687393,
0.7694147825,
-0.3480397165,
0.5130904913,
-0.3432391882,
-0.602658093,
0.2094459534,
0.1132115424,
0.1384109855,
0.6707128882,
0.3968865871,
0.0074393889,
-0.6929495931,
-0.8375911117,
-0.5612598658,
0.0955734327,
-0.3905491233,
0.3632952571,
0.2497786134,
-0.5403521657,
1.3206913471,
-0.7658658028,
-0.2611060441,
-0.1175441742,
0.4920573235,
0.1762707233,
0.115382798,
0.7040044665,
-0.7890807986,
-0.7887594104,
-0.094838351,
-0.5950017571,
-0.579421103,
-0.1768738776,
-0.1217108667,
-0.5954466462,
0.619713366,
-0.1807740927,
0.4637402594,
0.2101117969,
-0.1744780391,
0.2535707355,
-0.1113072038,
-0.0365233533,
-1.1244428158,
0.3918482363,
0.1798026413,
-0.2741363645,
-0.2836412787,
-0.1702028066,
0.0859559476,
-0.2100128978,
0.0110975225,
0.7670375705,
-0.613706708,
-0.1935311109,
-0.611556828,
0.5415878296,
0.2346732467,
-0.0297730975,
-0.0410048664,
1.0107344389,
0.2646072507,
-0.5775548816,
-0.3360688686,
0.1652875394,
-0.1442936063,
0.6381251812,
-0.5492752194,
0.1417845041,
-0.0014117181,
0.1389845014,
-0.6261724234,
-0.3853035867,
-0.3234648705,
-0.2833573222,
0.3582262099,
-0.1443200856,
-0.2121238261,
-0.3108035624,
-0.4226997495,
0.2130765468,
0.3875899017,
-0.4186044931,
0.8155339956,
0.7027459145,
-0.2912085354,
-0.347447902,
-0.5149738193,
0.2827787995,
-0.2683398128,
-0.3254647553,
0.8474732041,
0.1246583238,
-0.5276950598,
0.093290709,
-0.1004748419,
-0.0290878098,
0.2782156169,
0.4195871055,
-0.0335936323,
0.2396147698,
0.2578125596,
-0.0435616747,
-0.1264397502,
0.0223934781,
-0.1626688689,
0.3222365975,
-0.1629710346,
-0.112054579,
0.0642720461,
0.4176595509,
0.4271827638,
-0.162235409,
0.2687901855,
0.7802286148,
-0.4120008349,
0.1366025358,
-0.5706787109,
-0.1827816665,
-0.5054892302,
-0.2500714362,
-0.4570213258,
-0.9455538392,
0.4668699205,
-0.4008934796,
0.108556278,
0.5281528831,
0.2827376127,
-0.3567943275,
0.7230526209,
0.7371060252,
-0.1526400149,
0.9026706219,
0.0025442562,
0.1066569835,
-1.0621907711,
-0.0679471642,
-0.8666416407,
-0.179875657,
-0.4475229383,
-0.0594011918,
0.4307250381,
0.2315425128,
-0.2133830637,
0.3015418351,
-0.8195894361,
0.5391586423,
0.6495118141,
-0.0705141127,
0.1078206822,
0.2459423542,
-0.0560910925,
-0.0334568769,
-0.3654024303,
-0.7563360929,
0.9154012799,
-0.0585538261,
0.6936619282,
0.067473121,
0.8229979277,
0.5852479339,
0.8572295904,
-0.4783744216,
0.4209021926,
-0.0679184273,
-0.6538717747,
0.2066391408,
-0.0919355825,
-0.9334455729,
0.0411964096,
-0.3723453879,
-1.1718434095,
0.4581838846,
0.0587641075,
-0.2527711391,
-0.0387951061,
-0.2601873875,
0.2816565037,
-0.2814061642,
-0.7418325543,
-0.2197258323,
-0.2793659866,
0.3722083569,
-0.1125288457,
0.3576293588,
-0.1038626432,
-0.0009556955,
0.9045727849,
-0.0833063275,
0.6372759938,
-0.1726934612,
0.0901767612,
0.3969954848,
0.2805492282,
0.5450316668,
0.3290555775,
-0.2315364629,
-0.1536328644,
-0.1305174232,
-0.2566308081,
-0.2481048256,
0.7375894785,
-0.5793321133,
-0.9836176634,
-0.6354382634,
-0.4790598154,
-0.2776142061,
0.6695715189,
0.4086367786,
0.4927530587,
-0.1383365989,
0.3942792714,
0.5553369522,
0.1235326529,
0.379406631,
0.4724123776,
-0.5028602481,
-0.6877453327,
0.5165513754,
-0.1461948007,
-0.5056579709,
0.5348622799,
0.3899795115,
-0.0021423101,
-0.7171882391,
0.0346138403,
-0.0131282182,
-0.8730207682,
-0.5589763522,
-0.9891421199,
0.1943590194,
-0.3767789006,
-0.5839164257,
0.2733823061,
-0.404581964,
-0.4482919276,
0.0621340573,
0.5822928548,
0.5538597703,
-0.1520869285,
0.5071374178,
-1.0015702248,
0.2432448268,
0.4988818169,
0.2096925378,
-0.0158086959,
-0.6149085164,
-0.3043499887,
-0.3433821201,
-0.3584798574,
-0.9574698806,
0.3437832296,
0.0220869593,
0.5080049038,
0.809045136,
0.3597634733,
0.4393577576,
-0.3380692601,
0.4955303967,
0.2028789967,
-0.8122848272,
0.7295091152,
-1.1010868549,
0.4528085887,
1.189427495,
0.425298661,
-0.4384766519,
-0.082713984,
-0.4572812915,
-0.8914382458,
0.2465640604,
0.0069191512,
0.0100260526,
0.0089914408,
0.42966187,
-0.0237735268,
0.1205406561,
-0.5927355886,
0.1285754293,
-0.285017401,
-0.1493690163,
0.2103173733,
-0.7469444275,
-0.6174737811,
-0.0184847359,
0.4730075002,
-0.1224038005,
0.365478009,
0.306941092,
-0.196537897,
-0.2032875419,
0.2867990732,
0.825996995,
1.2332355976,
-0.7391068935,
0.2793123722,
-0.0985525846,
-0.6986342669,
-0.1882358193,
0.1197653189,
-0.3925625682,
-0.088903442,
0.6194127202,
0.1995765716,
0.0105330991,
-0.3293524086,
0.3373250067,
-0.3634442985,
-0.0494116358,
-0.398719281,
0.1197377443,
0.2687047124,
-0.0222491603,
0.7875666618,
0.2679897845,
0.6836331487,
-0.3731121719,
0.1141055375,
0.3462659419,
-0.3794268966,
-0.254191488,
0.4116541743,
0.5503728986,
-0.4877695143,
0.0762177482,
0.087641865,
-0.6231999993,
0.472564131,
0.7727157474,
1.2266719341,
0.1316648126,
-0.0695209056,
0.3164994419,
0.2890500426,
-0.0511802472,
0.2249132693,
-0.2174610645,
-0.4283648431,
-0.0393781289,
-0.4154247344,
-0.6587841511,
0.1829293966,
-0.8810163736,
0.2760063112,
-0.5095456839,
-0.6712915301,
0.1724245548,
-0.0285304915,
-0.4595706463,
0.1630338728,
-0.1494710296,
1.1981370449,
-0.6634914279,
0.654648304,
0.9388529062,
-0.1965383589,
-0.4035926759,
0.50571841,
0.0911418051,
-0.174723193,
0.5617023706,
0.1360148638,
-0.4591108263,
-0.4528862834,
-0.1836234629,
-1.0177280903,
1.1191828251,
-0.0574310459,
-0.4577615559,
0.5411244035,
-0.3746380806,
0.6847720742,
-0.4249896705,
0.6932840943,
0.1246044412,
0.5865739584,
-0.016900802,
-0.4273520112,
-0.0409185365,
-0.6367076635,
-0.1713901311,
0.2840082943,
-0.4628474414,
0.7674064636,
0.1886897683,
-0.1346545964,
-0.4851730466,
0.7202997804,
0.229841128,
0.7243335843,
0.4998189807,
0.0291069075,
0.8062393069,
0.1132819578,
0.9978938699,
-0.6916680932,
-0.0172850192,
1.4361045361,
-0.5879740119,
0.6479576826,
0.4393818378,
-0.0230606981,
0.7425307631,
0.7170869112,
0.1841464639,
0.7229479551,
-0.3153940439,
-0.3942050338,
-0.2193189114,
-0.3117417693,
-0.780612886,
0.181603834,
0.6420111656,
-0.2447737902,
-0.298204273,
-0.0448908843,
-0.0416748039,
0.2909439206,
-0.0206012297,
0.8074373007,
0.0760647282,
-0.8163173199,
0.2433227748,
-0.0095979422,
0.6438851357,
-0.5060352087,
0.2026618123,
-0.4366717935,
0.223164022,
-0.470305264,
-0.7355456948,
0.4037945271,
0.3344019055,
-0.5303890705,
-0.4079659283,
1.1821713448,
-0.0619650185,
-0.3012672663,
0.3531852067,
0.4933645129,
-0.1015179306,
0.1735859811,
-0.5448984504,
-0.2373014688,
0.044532802,
-0.2039644718,
0.4145411551,
0.4108892977,
-0.3259364367,
0.5515082479,
0.6187900901,
-0.0937521011,
-0.7285496593,
-0.0660991818,
0.921949923,
-0.4904339314,
-0.5097153187,
-0.4990952909,
0.3176992238,
-0.4245854318,
-0.5014189482,
0.8611516356,
0.7749040127,
0.3732219338,
-0.0721814632,
0.8666295409,
-0.0780778825,
0.8539509773,
-0.1153028831,
0.5048424602,
-0.6208946705,
0.5887420774,
-0.3833406568,
-0.8816944361,
-0.3610019386,
0.5609017611,
-0.6768260598,
0.1353973448,
0.5867338777,
0.4537726343,
-0.3398723602,
0.023877345,
-0.1842535436,
-0.5302755237,
0.3112379611,
-0.062846072,
0.7190356255,
0.0054547223,
0.4236946106,
-0.2897512317,
-0.3421996236,
-0.767598629,
-1.2568917274,
-0.9751982093,
-0.4519384205,
-0.2307609916,
-0.2001526356,
0.0935334265,
0.7562457919,
0.5884622931,
-1.0503804684,
-0.4183574319,
0.0129629308,
0.0901046395,
-0.0098504815,
-0.2773147523,
0.5287877321,
-0.1264369935,
-0.1989695579,
0.4215894043,
0.5293853283,
0.1694660932,
-0.0513003618,
0.3295041621,
-0.3226945996,
0.1728764921,
0.3777652085,
0.2683231831,
-0.2317288965,
-0.0512150563,
0.0857534483,
-0.5247161984,
-0.1234957576,
1.2327674627,
-0.7011391521,
0.2938502431,
0.9890745282,
0.3275464475,
0.8442323208,
0.0488914028,
0.6610888243,
-0.5909591913,
0.3570806682,
0.3168829978,
0.4583587646,
0.4338750541,
-0.7143685818,
0.8978806734,
-0.1039426103,
-0.5450586677,
-0.9063713551,
-0.1153179407,
-0.8301436901,
-0.4757593274,
0.866168201,
-0.1984586418,
0.014117769,
-0.2118579447,
-0.1337469518,
0.0617448911,
-0.6123508811,
0.9829524755,
0.2448600382,
-0.0157480147,
-0.0827456266,
-0.4205290377,
0.6937365532,
0.2069646269,
-0.973269999,
-0.0120214466,
0.3727550805,
0.0865103304,
0.7220121026,
0.595951438,
0.3107655048,
0.6042436957,
-0.1698732227,
0.0596840084,
-0.1334441751,
-0.4024399519,
0.0154442675,
0.2903076112,
0.1797338724,
0.4158910215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02938v1
|
AIx Speed: Playback Speed Optimization Using Listening Comprehension of Speech Recognition Models
| 2024-03-05T13:08:52 | 2024-03-05T13:08:52 |
Kazuki Kawamura, Jun Rekimoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Since humans can listen to audio and watch videos at faster speeds than
actually observed, we often listen to or watch these pieces of content at
higher playback speeds to increase the time efficiency of content
comprehension. To further utilize this capability, systems that automatically
adjust the playback speed according to the user's condition and the type of
content to assist in more efficient comprehension of time-series content have
been developed. However, there is still room for these systems to further
extend human speed-listening ability by generating speech with playback speed
optimized for even finer time units and providing it to humans. In this study,
we determine whether humans can hear the optimized speech and propose a system
that automatically adjusts playback speed at units as small as phonemes while
ensuring speech intelligibility. The system uses the speech recognizer score as
a proxy for how well a human can hear a certain unit of speech and maximizes
the speech playback speed to the extent that a human can hear. This method can
be used to produce fast but intelligible speech. In the evaluation experiment,
we compared the speech played back at a constant fast speed and the flexibly
speed-up speech generated by the proposed method in a blind test and confirmed
that the proposed method produced speech that was easier to listen to.
|
[
-0.5702545047,
-0.5762537122,
0.7137241364,
0.3006480932,
-0.5635034442,
-0.1477902532,
-0.176290825,
-0.5149727464,
0.2988158166,
0.4293668866,
-0.5383741856,
0.1160377041,
-0.1644642949,
0.1246118098,
-0.4187800884,
0.3363048732,
0.4460118413,
0.0781904086,
0.1502927095,
-0.0917233825,
-0.4219427109,
-0.1839588434,
-0.8719823956,
-0.2030968368,
0.3567732573,
0.8525063992,
0.8574567437,
1.1033314466,
0.4588710368,
0.2847756147,
-0.1455103159,
-0.113575384,
-0.2847053111,
0.5237252116,
0.0329813771,
-0.2540092468,
-0.5181412101,
-0.2895525098,
1.0656112432,
0.4701273143,
-0.1479309201,
0.3972855806,
-0.1329252869,
0.8361544609,
-0.4134140909,
-0.3545257747,
-0.5158632398,
0.0831225067,
-0.3486601114,
-0.710273385,
-0.2277842164,
-0.4069586098,
0.2549366951,
-0.6104235649,
0.4584427178,
0.4845340848,
0.3893107474,
0.6250658631,
-0.1657262295,
0.1431402415,
-1.0488110781,
0.54050982,
-0.5727972984,
0.7566984296,
0.2538809776,
0.6125044823,
0.158714518,
-0.4923481345,
-0.7156977654,
-0.0693676323,
0.3142895103,
-0.0955937356,
0.0921123475,
0.1752489954,
0.6234446168,
0.3480523229,
-0.9954568148,
-0.0165002067,
-0.3623493314,
-0.6169403195,
0.9452109933,
0.3804008067,
0.1486338526,
-0.1043425128,
0.1572679579,
-0.3329636455,
-0.1660974324,
0.2198579758,
0.4420783222,
0.2247174829,
0.3250145912,
0.50407058,
-0.4018103778,
0.558318615,
-0.1523298919,
-0.43954283,
0.3677501976,
-0.2062441111,
-0.1513245106,
0.6284943223,
0.415028125,
0.3541828692,
0.2798379064,
-0.0561061092,
-0.134796083,
0.1238509789,
0.1554861218,
-0.6700989008,
0.1991081089,
0.1474713236,
-0.3676412404,
-0.0863975286,
-0.0492450856,
-0.6339648962,
-0.2492671311,
-0.511236608,
0.6728441715,
-0.4967976809,
-0.2956304252,
0.0561152324,
-0.3688763082,
0.0809013695,
0.0966203138,
-1.0155249834,
0.6275837421,
0.3343937993,
0.9416759014,
-0.158096537,
-0.1771179289,
-1.1639055014,
0.2687967718,
-0.3435105681,
0.6453594565,
-0.3403715491,
-0.6039634943,
-0.3963270783,
-0.1222594231,
0.0133861843,
-0.4198275805,
0.8240340948,
-0.4090568721,
-0.0838831216,
-0.3299437463,
-0.7596232891,
-0.1072440967,
-0.541846633,
-0.5658066273,
0.6768327951,
-0.1143935472,
-0.4570122361,
0.5707471967,
-0.8358941674,
-0.8394120336,
0.1845105588,
0.2168470323,
-0.265765667,
0.0966762751,
0.1369481832,
0.4078427851,
-0.1252798587,
-0.0203584321,
0.0034526014,
-0.7837591171,
0.0904333666,
-0.5378782153,
0.4867888093,
0.5661266446,
-0.5077893734,
0.0649264827,
-0.8713670373,
0.234347403,
-0.0637352169,
-0.5059872866,
-0.10342592,
0.3209359944,
0.179087922,
-0.1765055954,
-0.303804338,
-0.6882104874,
-0.4196573198,
-0.5252640843,
0.500696063,
0.7585029006,
0.1577134132,
0.2895770967,
-0.4217121303,
0.4273695052,
-0.238507092,
0.1711549908,
-0.2476766407,
-0.3920103908,
-0.7219843864,
-0.1323425025,
0.1005758941,
0.5635457635,
-0.3495591879,
0.0230642501,
-0.1766909063,
-0.3737275898,
-0.80097121,
0.027138982,
0.1840691864,
0.7501559258,
0.3359974623,
-0.5149949789,
-0.6421682239,
-0.9355639219,
-0.5645062327,
-0.2354686856,
-0.2570568025,
0.7042050362,
0.041467905,
0.1707960218,
0.6180407405,
-0.4869371355,
0.1545886248,
-0.1141321659,
0.1551064551,
-0.0498928055,
0.4628165662,
0.1071084291,
-0.848725915,
-0.254207164,
-0.2223926485,
-0.161982134,
-0.1341857016,
0.1155323014,
0.0581769757,
0.1472806931,
0.5722250342,
-0.0337079726,
0.4087969959,
0.1171364486,
-0.3368772268,
0.5419532061,
-0.4045620263,
0.2823645771,
-0.6329589486,
0.0528937355,
-0.1215279698,
-0.4816448987,
-0.618825376,
-0.5760536194,
-0.1319365948,
-0.5655658245,
-0.7803884149,
0.3219760358,
-0.0962455198,
-0.6471425891,
-0.2912049294,
0.327164799,
-0.0613480024,
0.4055418074,
0.1667827517,
1.1489233971,
0.5708343387,
-1.2274816036,
0.3015909195,
-0.1376236528,
-0.4188445508,
0.4688411057,
-0.8079358935,
0.1731844842,
-0.2100389302,
-0.1008487195,
-0.7204374075,
-0.3969486356,
-0.3512803912,
-0.4473334551,
0.103147231,
0.3774350882,
-0.2936363518,
-0.1704199165,
0.0666655824,
0.4392690957,
0.7450605035,
-0.3702668548,
0.3490229547,
0.526658833,
-0.1268980205,
-0.1661681831,
-0.3400893807,
-0.3047068119,
-0.3535813987,
-0.9717311263,
0.5582691431,
-0.3590197265,
-0.3532864749,
-0.3144415021,
-0.0748994052,
0.1285194755,
0.0846182555,
0.160959512,
-0.1661651731,
-0.3779634833,
0.4481065571,
0.2334525436,
-0.1478885263,
-0.147305578,
-0.4145806134,
0.3139228523,
-0.3367959559,
-0.172143653,
-0.8335008025,
0.4824235439,
0.6679528952,
0.026764445,
0.3935075104,
0.7634065151,
-0.2728718221,
0.2207079679,
-0.7907685637,
-0.3780281842,
-0.4419187307,
0.2380802631,
-0.1836619079,
-0.8255049586,
0.1733234227,
0.0822983384,
-0.2259920686,
0.3520011902,
0.3344781995,
-0.1209796891,
1.3061270714,
0.617810607,
-0.111776419,
0.4013409317,
0.1003422737,
-0.2055931091,
-0.8616992235,
0.0012957342,
-0.7378261685,
-0.26253286,
-0.7152273655,
-0.1697073579,
0.4905374348,
-0.2461894453,
-0.4930929244,
0.3658539951,
-0.4698068202,
0.4475997388,
0.7960623503,
0.2683724463,
0.3277336061,
-0.216213733,
-0.1278144121,
-0.0519282408,
-0.4961231351,
-0.3413106203,
0.6710085273,
0.3494929969,
0.5021998286,
0.2937419713,
0.3621056676,
0.759074986,
-0.3741488755,
-0.6143288016,
0.6291499734,
-0.2210328132,
-0.7162619233,
-0.812461853,
-0.3415587842,
-0.496741116,
0.0563055687,
-0.0793512389,
-0.8152990937,
0.3049018085,
0.425760746,
-0.4921343029,
-0.0150666256,
-0.7693551779,
0.7278927565,
-0.2104243785,
-0.5212683082,
-0.5559135675,
-0.7984880805,
0.0987563506,
0.1468687207,
0.1570534855,
-0.2714475393,
0.0715230554,
0.8962661624,
-0.2972774208,
0.1321979314,
-0.3658391833,
0.5485388637,
0.25300318,
0.1733450443,
0.1628827304,
-0.0277440771,
-0.265693754,
-0.1917028725,
-0.1069207415,
-0.3409216702,
-0.5247501135,
0.3246670961,
-0.6380788684,
-0.8297182322,
-0.1364756227,
-0.4054754972,
-0.1970527172,
0.0373330526,
0.2834502757,
0.4422945082,
-0.3171766698,
0.1070647463,
0.7659817934,
-0.0718631372,
0.645424366,
0.553699851,
0.1665173322,
-0.0087120505,
1.1787837744,
0.0490241498,
0.404211551,
0.3627638221,
0.3496016264,
-0.5069423318,
-0.54596591,
-0.3579175472,
0.1402530819,
-0.277146697,
0.3124213517,
-0.2319281697,
-0.1845054328,
-0.5878879428,
0.0805517957,
-0.2319703847,
-0.7756900787,
-0.2688939273,
-0.0053089079,
0.2217302173,
0.2102219909,
-0.4062139392,
0.4416365325,
-0.6506025791,
0.4884205461,
0.6112225652,
0.3432675302,
-0.1250241399,
-0.9370027781,
-0.146720916,
-0.0770095959,
-0.4243139923,
-0.6735719442,
0.4552600086,
0.4666640162,
0.5298556089,
0.4259586334,
-0.0051797065,
0.741260767,
-0.6381276846,
0.5953171253,
-0.0908127576,
-1.1959705353,
0.9191530943,
-0.0812319517,
0.3631125689,
0.3858859837,
0.2313681841,
-0.695189774,
-0.1073586494,
-0.4709698558,
-0.7286947966,
0.8578481674,
0.5008996129,
-0.2127223313,
0.196395874,
0.402862817,
-0.0460506268,
0.1116463989,
0.1151985899,
-0.1915353835,
-0.3833004534,
0.152582109,
-0.5252800584,
-0.1433345377,
0.2145745158,
-0.1716340184,
1.0093955994,
-0.0789266899,
0.171380654,
0.7061328292,
-0.2966124713,
-0.5656719208,
0.3017154038,
0.864698112,
0.5428087711,
-0.5524270535,
-0.0287284441,
0.0990624055,
-0.7570289969,
0.4083451629,
0.0580423847,
-0.2354374975,
-0.0457498059,
0.1223930418,
1.152731061,
-0.0547270849,
-0.8671504259,
0.1515993774,
-0.5322571993,
-0.0640796199,
-0.3344311118,
0.5838406086,
-0.0513217896,
0.2315632403,
0.2518627346,
0.1598007232,
0.367187202,
-0.5370380282,
0.3171963394,
0.1560338289,
-0.4403758943,
0.0604608692,
1.1101617813,
0.3153680265,
-0.9391689897,
0.7045406699,
0.0790465325,
-0.2282370627,
0.3623896539,
0.2254762948,
1.0473393202,
-0.6333910823,
0.0602181256,
0.3464581966,
0.1069285944,
-0.0809847638,
0.2895682752,
-0.3526321054,
-0.7004847527,
-0.510825634,
-0.7591846585,
-0.5621761084,
-0.2059610933,
-0.8032203317,
0.0378140584,
-0.0236511547,
-0.3843833804,
0.4163168371,
0.1093282402,
-0.685736537,
0.4733094573,
0.2277138084,
1.1086617708,
-0.5899258852,
0.7852859497,
0.231228441,
-0.2228977829,
-0.833786428,
0.0466093048,
-0.0582285747,
-0.4468328059,
0.4322501123,
0.0023975333,
-0.4123643041,
0.0666595995,
-0.202971682,
-0.7386472225,
1.234167099,
0.3958055973,
-0.8758202791,
0.2145048827,
0.1155975163,
0.5260206461,
-0.4682343304,
0.2288041115,
0.8932575583,
0.5029209256,
0.0232457276,
-1.0821528435,
-0.0749996006,
-0.1024942324,
0.1894776523,
-0.1594144404,
-0.5782777071,
0.5616448522,
-0.3914674222,
0.0294049401,
0.0519378372,
0.6956802607,
0.1863769442,
0.6824218035,
0.9214174747,
0.2975101173,
0.8398004174,
0.102148585,
1.0456097126,
-0.0643043816,
-0.1499091089,
0.7702730894,
-0.2591803968,
0.6289324164,
0.4753980339,
-0.0169239286,
0.2732777596,
0.5955159664,
0.5723250508,
0.471789062,
0.1382912099,
-0.5161710978,
-0.4032330215,
-0.2718308866,
-0.2486968488,
0.4611472189,
0.2503805459,
-0.3579999208,
0.6173186898,
0.2088720649,
-0.4393453598,
0.0474635661,
-0.4636671245,
0.8564577103,
-0.2867931128,
-0.8835223317,
0.6008840799,
-0.0632623509,
0.0297837593,
-0.5386230946,
0.1684740037,
-0.0724337921,
0.1879471391,
0.0848045722,
-0.5138709545,
0.2993952632,
0.0252183117,
-0.2128330022,
0.129301548,
0.5319535732,
-0.1112640053,
-0.3223449886,
0.165073514,
0.2551015317,
0.6618306637,
-0.0824406072,
-0.3397717476,
0.2932277024,
0.1201470643,
-0.2794200778,
0.1149345338,
0.1304866225,
0.107729733,
0.6969276071,
0.5434820652,
0.1818400025,
0.0028515412,
0.4318748415,
0.5623524785,
-0.8741434813,
-0.4811480641,
-0.6866513491,
0.3806506991,
-0.1919064075,
-0.1841332018,
0.4909342229,
0.6206482649,
0.6767109632,
0.0551768541,
0.6620701551,
0.1076282784,
1.0108634233,
-0.5588969588,
0.3973716199,
-0.7459486723,
0.2545590103,
-0.581161797,
-1.0237317085,
-0.0073147956,
0.6542015672,
0.0705798939,
-0.1147268489,
0.7582756281,
0.8259334564,
0.0075361817,
0.5726540685,
0.5786164999,
0.1881913394,
0.3060130477,
0.4069470763,
0.2853663266,
-0.3522035778,
0.7308172584,
-0.6532860994,
-0.2252230495,
-0.3890206516,
-0.8712474704,
-0.4240358174,
-0.8509292006,
-0.1225390583,
-0.2996538579,
0.514198184,
0.5816300511,
0.8990884423,
-0.4928854406,
-0.4527815878,
-0.0503035858,
0.0659480542,
-0.6029081941,
-0.3280767202,
0.2943232358,
-0.0758309215,
-0.6981215477,
0.6998512149,
0.3758025169,
0.1315613985,
-0.2715252042,
-0.4994045198,
0.0956079885,
0.3369732201,
0.3640055656,
0.4967886209,
-0.4405091703,
-0.5160861015,
0.22724244,
0.2327978462,
0.000140653,
1.2547699213,
-0.9018211365,
0.6929862499,
0.6485575438,
0.2105586529,
0.9770476222,
0.1563629955,
0.5054641962,
-0.5071353912,
0.2683593631,
0.6048253179,
0.3856689632,
0.2986514568,
-0.3741670251,
0.301429987,
0.1104157194,
-0.8674878478,
-0.7445780635,
0.2837778032,
-1.0320569277,
0.0255431049,
0.6855472922,
0.2269586176,
-0.3959755301,
-0.2067009211,
-0.4219566882,
0.5293380618,
-0.6438506842,
0.5644822121,
0.2858326137,
-0.5973802805,
-0.0373097658,
-0.4427437186,
0.5394985676,
0.4262840748,
-0.3705968559,
0.003264531,
0.3231052458,
0.2206889987,
0.072805874,
0.6950115561,
0.1598327905,
0.8083769083,
0.0341469236,
-0.2313609868,
-0.1050157771,
-0.359477669,
-0.089231357,
0.0185930934,
0.0371957421,
-0.0906413272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02932v2
|
RulePrompt: Weakly Supervised Text Classification with Prompting PLMs and Self-Iterative Logical Rules
| 2024-03-05T12:50:36 | 2024-04-25T09:23:28 |
Miaomiao Li, Jiaqi Zhu, Yang Wang, Yi Yang, Yilin Li, Hongan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Weakly supervised text classification (WSTC), also called zero-shot or
dataless text classification, has attracted increasing attention due to its
applicability in classifying a mass of texts within the dynamic and open Web
environment, since it requires only a limited set of seed words (label names)
for each category instead of labeled data. With the help of recently popular
prompting Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), many studies leveraged manually
crafted and/or automatically identified verbalizers to estimate the likelihood
of categories, but they failed to differentiate the effects of these
category-indicative words, let alone capture their correlations and realize
adaptive adjustments according to the unlabeled corpus. In this paper, in order
to let the PLM effectively understand each category, we at first propose a
novel form of rule-based knowledge using logical expressions to characterize
the meanings of categories. Then, we develop a prompting PLM-based approach
named RulePrompt for the WSTC task, consisting of a rule mining module and a
rule-enhanced pseudo label generation module, plus a self-supervised
fine-tuning module to make the PLM align with this task. Within this framework,
the inaccurate pseudo labels assigned to texts and the imprecise logical rules
associated with categories mutually enhance each other in an alternative
manner. That establishes a self-iterative closed loop of knowledge (rule)
acquisition and utilization, with seed words serving as the starting point.
Extensive experiments validate the effectiveness and robustness of our
approach, which markedly outperforms state-of-the-art weakly supervised
methods. What is more, our approach yields interpretable category rules,
proving its advantage in disambiguating easily-confused categories.
|
[
-0.2575588822,
-0.8590581417,
0.574533999,
-0.0430847406,
-0.4825106859,
-0.1926658303,
-0.2991275191,
-0.2041073889,
-0.0600998215,
0.4191420674,
-0.7019588947,
-0.8438686728,
-0.5883488655,
0.3317835033,
-0.5983445644,
1.4186862707,
0.1616427451,
-0.3735603392,
-0.3639700115,
-0.1207456291,
-0.5683416128,
-0.4815621674,
-0.2278749645,
-0.1335314214,
0.5256759524,
0.7119191885,
0.4470321536,
0.4826167226,
0.4100725651,
0.3793084025,
-0.1937142611,
0.1667262167,
-0.2793307006,
0.0386130996,
-0.3929975927,
-0.3639465868,
-0.2381044477,
0.0589287244,
0.1245593131,
0.6183887124,
-0.2095950097,
0.3229463696,
0.2497912347,
0.336512953,
-0.6649839282,
0.3352680504,
-0.6699553132,
0.0046064756,
-0.2894538045,
-0.4563810825,
-0.5995670557,
-0.2443678081,
0.134672299,
-0.5309648514,
0.3867932558,
0.0315676779,
0.8659998775,
0.1922801435,
-0.3494260609,
-0.4844010472,
-0.5748931766,
0.8697013259,
-0.5828645229,
0.1208712533,
0.4374147654,
-0.0478080697,
-0.2351214886,
-0.9755744338,
-0.6619411707,
0.0304564815,
-0.1799756736,
0.3595627248,
-0.3012644947,
0.1408991367,
0.2923102975,
0.2682957947,
-0.5942101479,
0.1560844779,
-0.3916605711,
-0.2328633517,
0.3287414312,
0.1579104513,
0.1667090356,
-0.3827954233,
-0.5780655146,
0.0853366926,
-0.3148725629,
0.1635137349,
0.0949553028,
0.5025543571,
-0.0164713357,
0.6038036346,
-0.3660238683,
0.8628931046,
0.1463583261,
-0.3847683668,
0.1880194545,
-0.4456424117,
-0.2145937234,
0.3716198206,
1.016612649,
0.1593440026,
0.2679635584,
-0.0147979399,
-0.0323094726,
0.2888819873,
0.2457793504,
-0.6426314116,
-0.2966261208,
0.0930983797,
-0.5788411498,
-0.5372838974,
-0.0091781905,
-0.6989248991,
-0.3463912308,
-0.5300422907,
0.6744090319,
-0.2822728753,
-0.0854561999,
0.1119700894,
-0.1328253597,
0.1545731723,
0.3746324182,
-0.6945408583,
0.336818248,
0.4840073884,
0.8371540904,
-0.109539248,
-0.1831904054,
-0.4507019818,
-0.032204926,
-0.3570597172,
1.0754680634,
-0.3046183884,
-0.1938262433,
0.0076723979,
-0.0250072218,
-0.0257530324,
-0.2698184252,
0.7237401605,
-0.3733341098,
0.50328058,
-0.0556839891,
-0.781540215,
-0.1092336401,
0.2458961159,
-0.2701286674,
0.9718492031,
-0.1674923748,
-1.0448086262,
0.5611872673,
-0.2138051391,
-0.5985600948,
0.337941587,
0.048399508,
-0.4742904603,
0.1368811429,
-0.0203427747,
0.6097174883,
-0.1626128107,
0.4505893588,
-0.3509632349,
-0.2683375776,
0.0471067652,
-0.2178020328,
0.676417768,
0.2483608127,
-0.2809283435,
0.4743510187,
-0.7418204546,
0.1358973831,
0.0288625415,
0.1128806323,
-0.5790070295,
0.2949069142,
-0.3817665577,
0.4520992339,
0.2449098229,
-0.3571582139,
0.2130374163,
-0.3089441955,
0.221741274,
0.7184703946,
0.1708608419,
0.4386146069,
-0.161525771,
0.1424031407,
-0.0277012922,
0.3962746263,
-0.0846477523,
-0.6343873143,
-0.8918820024,
-0.3909971714,
0.3532910347,
0.6125333905,
-0.9035457373,
0.7435054779,
0.0780863538,
-0.4871183038,
-0.2979130447,
0.4124469161,
0.2105924636,
0.9028503299,
0.6513348818,
-0.1851608157,
-0.668291688,
-0.5998597741,
-0.0643159002,
-0.3737124205,
0.1483730972,
-0.1288708448,
0.2946076095,
-0.0337088145,
0.9888669848,
-0.4885678291,
-0.8696889281,
-0.5514145494,
0.5693364739,
0.3709498942,
0.2562363446,
0.0361769572,
-0.5943320394,
-0.3091803193,
-0.3331409693,
-0.8722703457,
-0.4344679117,
-0.1333615333,
-0.0288419332,
-0.0361305587,
0.6183503866,
-0.2683576047,
0.5233458281,
0.1582961828,
-0.3371421397,
0.5119772553,
-0.263063252,
-0.2147766799,
-0.7394917011,
-0.1440815628,
0.2484159172,
-0.2273867875,
-0.6300510168,
-0.3006756306,
0.0435289517,
0.0706511661,
-0.5921087265,
0.4391090274,
-0.3461831808,
0.4026914239,
-0.6329180598,
0.1429363787,
-0.2113658637,
0.5145004988,
0.3807535172,
0.3781783283,
0.6762001514,
-1.0426863432,
0.2291194797,
0.1795176268,
-0.0911980569,
0.6483671069,
-0.2641847134,
-0.1582487822,
-0.2084905058,
0.0046918243,
-0.816942811,
0.0727446303,
0.2333978862,
-0.2347509712,
0.2348964065,
-0.1720408797,
-0.7494225502,
-0.4440171123,
-0.3643392324,
0.1195985302,
0.7614199519,
-0.5269056559,
0.4085309505,
0.1915870011,
0.0991593525,
-0.2717427909,
-0.3507264853,
0.0030096353,
-0.2382111847,
-0.0837769508,
0.1427741051,
0.0178485159,
-0.050548818,
0.1571539342,
-0.1512139738,
-0.0974410549,
0.127228573,
0.2509954572,
0.2719098032,
0.0076221316,
0.3006444573,
0.0643101335,
-0.2182427198,
-0.104095228,
-0.4973189235,
0.2138918489,
-0.1923885643,
-0.0709267408,
-0.6708481312,
-0.034057688,
0.0422041528,
-0.0868517533,
0.6869286299,
0.6329882741,
-0.2625600398,
-0.5797539353,
-0.2990441322,
-0.2869967222,
-0.5048056841,
-0.1460507214,
-0.3343161345,
-0.796028614,
0.1863552034,
-0.3547365665,
-0.1863438487,
0.5520463586,
0.5711574554,
-0.3275614977,
0.9434741735,
0.8791543841,
0.1492941082,
0.349953264,
0.0838849097,
0.0587676875,
-0.2933293283,
-0.334905833,
-0.5419610739,
-0.1521001905,
-0.8446170688,
-0.1341940463,
0.1128172502,
0.2697257698,
-0.0122354636,
0.4026174247,
-0.6482340693,
0.399563998,
0.6163339019,
0.0691144392,
0.3674375117,
-0.1069106236,
-0.3345121145,
-0.1631682515,
-0.8274330497,
-0.3647181392,
0.7492172718,
0.0959431008,
0.7723782063,
-0.053022109,
0.8733567595,
0.54071486,
0.3763845265,
-1.0623735189,
0.721701622,
-0.4810177088,
-0.4128570855,
0.057679534,
-0.4255926907,
-0.8016570807,
0.0785199925,
-0.2607183754,
-0.8019096851,
0.2449757606,
0.3413634002,
-0.1355625242,
0.1732882112,
-0.8966059685,
0.9710351229,
-0.2526427507,
-0.4872772396,
0.1386799216,
-0.5512040257,
0.4366124272,
-0.144456923,
0.3251279593,
-0.1567870677,
-0.0620263778,
0.8136092424,
-0.6456648111,
1.1197658777,
-0.3212730885,
-0.0420743823,
0.7594642639,
0.1909398437,
0.4094983041,
-0.28246665,
0.1393251717,
0.0595645681,
0.0724970549,
-0.2696819901,
-0.5244860053,
0.4699805081,
-0.3941876888,
-0.4788511992,
-0.7071908712,
0.004383374,
-0.3215411305,
0.4552849233,
0.3118669391,
0.3380937278,
0.0264672283,
0.1406787932,
0.7146915793,
-0.0643409267,
0.4297492504,
0.7103305459,
-0.0922082141,
-0.1640949845,
1.2003145218,
-0.0869730785,
0.002411956,
0.4146451354,
0.5471227765,
-0.5550767183,
-0.6484636068,
-0.0870855898,
-0.0265882481,
-0.6951757073,
-0.6366961598,
-0.4988181591,
-0.1238543317,
-0.2032002956,
-0.0026563054,
-0.0588924848,
-0.2287652493,
-0.5424323082,
-0.0516874231,
0.5548878312,
0.6709281802,
0.0256923083,
0.3784689903,
-0.5556131005,
0.4455817938,
0.1112643927,
0.3695743978,
-0.2441079319,
-0.6581166983,
0.0790917426,
-0.4749755859,
-0.1437660605,
-1.0017482042,
0.2958209515,
0.414159745,
0.4226407409,
0.5472962856,
0.5763020515,
0.6541697383,
-0.4692779779,
0.5688435435,
0.3698259592,
-1.0730689764,
0.8637248874,
-0.1168469042,
0.1847072244,
0.7812723517,
0.426214695,
-0.424904108,
-0.6486930251,
-0.733530581,
-0.8060895801,
0.8986128569,
0.1819601059,
-0.0544039495,
-0.1685449481,
0.1378900409,
0.1947757304,
0.2651655376,
-0.7128337026,
-0.1624771357,
-0.5439357758,
-0.8074272275,
0.1033638641,
-0.2631827295,
0.1577554941,
-0.2964303792,
0.6967930794,
-0.4508314133,
0.0012833801,
0.2583498657,
-0.3160418272,
0.1967424154,
0.5647455454,
0.3141035438,
0.3320731521,
-0.1960524023,
0.6472118497,
0.2204669267,
-0.269947201,
0.1812702119,
0.0369769856,
-0.3319224119,
-0.0866585672,
0.5121945143,
0.5821208358,
0.3009498417,
-0.6677747965,
0.6742311716,
-0.1976837367,
-0.3861715794,
0.1500501186,
0.2238908112,
-0.3368532062,
-0.1445982158,
0.225482896,
0.0549140349,
0.2463169247,
-0.4480779469,
0.4333587885,
0.246347025,
-0.5684199333,
-0.2869303226,
0.3842189014,
0.0103747854,
0.1116602942,
0.2470889986,
-0.7015890479,
-0.5587117672,
0.2795190811,
0.6075646877,
0.6652490497,
0.1054930761,
0.4930062592,
0.3940745592,
0.3477861881,
-0.2600891292,
0.1413370222,
-0.4063607454,
-0.6216150522,
-0.368044585,
-0.7884039879,
-0.1404445469,
0.203658402,
-0.5316734314,
0.4487646222,
-0.6831910014,
-0.1492357552,
0.0345436931,
0.071698986,
-0.5510885715,
0.3315725327,
0.1229192838,
0.8003130555,
-1.0148410797,
0.7778636813,
0.7104045749,
-0.4952226281,
-0.8569019437,
-0.0015920375,
0.1868931204,
-0.4190352857,
0.5838221312,
0.0910597369,
-0.0698342398,
0.1442270279,
-0.6499812603,
-0.4704927206,
0.702257514,
-0.1711089015,
-0.4910672307,
0.3205980659,
0.0101588937,
0.8334338069,
0.1013912633,
0.304977715,
0.2656199634,
0.4460629821,
0.2965728045,
-0.7678856254,
0.1773233861,
-0.1945336461,
-0.2432346493,
0.139338851,
-0.4089071751,
0.3681398332,
-0.1372662187,
-0.3514322937,
-0.0127757909,
0.8318934441,
0.0173402485,
0.5052251816,
0.5507224202,
0.4683569372,
0.7434676886,
-0.1173676252,
0.7188517451,
-0.0572623238,
0.3960256577,
1.2187819481,
-0.3754344285,
0.7650582194,
0.26832816,
-0.0991695374,
0.6539630294,
0.6863466501,
-0.2090655118,
0.6905902624,
0.0683319047,
-0.2915553153,
-0.4248919785,
-0.4487128854,
0.0682781339,
0.5696230531,
0.3534940481,
-0.080428496,
-0.489716351,
0.1503851712,
-0.1238464937,
0.2656242549,
-0.5163981915,
1.3374946117,
0.1768011451,
-0.5880500674,
0.4023042321,
0.1338354945,
0.795935154,
-0.6679499149,
0.067101717,
-0.0474569835,
0.2602450848,
-0.4464794397,
-0.9180254936,
0.1593981683,
0.3586587012,
-0.1513712257,
-0.3310621381,
1.253959775,
-0.300439924,
-0.5564488173,
0.3475218713,
0.6370412111,
0.0740681887,
0.1037103087,
-0.7635137439,
-0.1912536621,
-0.1893438101,
0.1241928339,
0.2418418378,
0.7699598074,
-0.2909211814,
0.4492780864,
0.6452313066,
0.0614961646,
0.0181948543,
0.2251551747,
0.6664078832,
-0.6650307775,
-0.5594061017,
-0.8990929127,
0.2876186073,
0.1037051901,
-0.1128493324,
0.8560342789,
0.4230543375,
0.6143019795,
0.0327531248,
0.5449576974,
-0.165901944,
0.3941571414,
-0.54009974,
0.4550428987,
-0.5702613592,
0.0830660388,
-0.3206430674,
-0.4701196849,
-0.4590443373,
0.3751571774,
-0.3609052598,
-0.1099238619,
0.8483691812,
0.5016117096,
-0.0805202574,
0.1175758317,
0.1840898395,
0.1771639884,
0.0219117273,
0.2563778758,
0.9213624001,
-0.1685087979,
0.7519723177,
-0.4128307104,
-0.3316073418,
-0.0631800741,
-0.9732774496,
-0.9329738021,
-0.5186982155,
-0.6308476329,
-0.276071012,
0.0799434036,
0.8488762379,
0.6902981997,
-0.9687458873,
0.0629590824,
-0.518728435,
0.4154600203,
-0.3082489073,
-0.2958172262,
0.4127427042,
-0.8041132092,
-0.3744356334,
0.3370939195,
0.0868961662,
0.0579285249,
0.1236480027,
0.1292331368,
-0.2786081731,
-0.147971496,
0.6458014846,
0.4461258054,
-0.378029108,
0.0822923407,
-0.0962753817,
-0.0597663522,
-0.1328222901,
0.7849162221,
-1.0165785551,
0.5085975528,
0.4664442241,
0.3125790656,
0.2875519395,
0.2201968282,
0.0789619833,
-1.0261366367,
0.2068341672,
0.2584043145,
0.1103933081,
0.1261839569,
-0.2330798656,
0.1124644428,
0.6457905769,
-0.1604570895,
-0.6908766031,
0.0268192347,
-1.0717046261,
-0.5837872028,
1.035692811,
0.076611422,
-0.4734188616,
-0.3455640674,
-0.1294062287,
0.2681007683,
-0.4248595536,
0.6796331406,
0.3507649899,
-0.2215690315,
-0.2541946769,
-0.3755597472,
0.7150669098,
0.3331170082,
-0.9924554825,
-0.1014847159,
0.3512988389,
0.1762209386,
0.09932708,
0.6015517712,
0.0355931632,
0.1089477092,
-0.2253896892,
0.0266423468,
-0.038850531,
-0.4253486991,
-0.2343748361,
0.3556753099,
0.0922971889,
-0.1402059793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02930v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02930v2
|
A Second Look on BASS -- Boosting Abstractive Summarization with Unified Semantic Graphs -- A Replication Study
| 2024-03-05T12:48:29 | 2024-03-25T12:07:13 |
Osman Alperen Koraş, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present a detailed replication study of the BASS framework, an abstractive
summarization system based on the notion of Unified Semantic Graphs. Our
investigation includes challenges in replicating key components and an ablation
study to systematically isolate error sources rooted in replicating novel
components. Our findings reveal discrepancies in performance compared to the
original work. We highlight the significance of paying careful attention even
to reasonably omitted details for replicating advanced frameworks like BASS,
and emphasize key practices for writing replicable papers.
|
[
-0.4640679359,
-0.8149158359,
0.3865363598,
0.1839067936,
-0.2622797191,
0.0947922021,
0.1896657199,
-0.4054303765,
0.7336443067,
0.4092783928,
-0.5790598989,
-0.2520655096,
-0.5688650608,
0.3659072518,
-0.7824499011,
1.0940476656,
0.2008599788,
-0.0153726796,
-0.1853178144,
-0.4683600068,
-0.3510838151,
-0.2101278752,
-0.7612233758,
-0.8300176859,
0.4327379763,
0.5184989572,
0.8724547029,
0.9042689204,
0.3865272403,
0.2717596292,
-0.4119094908,
0.1962656826,
-0.6243776679,
0.1714176238,
-0.4050832987,
-0.1407860368,
-0.9203884602,
-0.1898829192,
0.702131927,
1.1832301617,
0.2097705603,
0.0799574777,
-0.0881528258,
0.9411293864,
-0.4568680525,
0.0059449845,
-0.094043754,
-0.0559059009,
-0.0007178774,
-0.241116792,
-0.5179581046,
-0.2585446537,
-0.0149841122,
-0.5868514776,
0.486014545,
-0.0186209772,
0.4277647138,
0.0835939646,
-0.8055847287,
-0.3018921316,
-0.8336593509,
0.3192707896,
-0.5452848673,
-0.08194419,
-0.1160728037,
0.0011035762,
-0.0720821097,
-1.145408392,
-0.6452983618,
0.1724919379,
-0.4833134711,
0.4588690102,
-0.2836371064,
0.023083061,
-0.0507565364,
0.6239396334,
-0.3775639236,
-0.1639117002,
-0.6585985422,
-0.2791922987,
0.6589326262,
0.2582882345,
0.1441038102,
-0.1314913183,
-0.2918556035,
-0.4387938976,
-0.5390990973,
-0.1977577806,
0.3299722373,
0.3496773839,
0.0224139374,
0.8049424887,
-0.286144793,
0.5670155883,
0.0230401065,
0.0788629502,
0.6024574041,
-0.7478584647,
-0.138311401,
0.3208833039,
0.281466037,
0.7947145104,
0.0854240656,
-0.2090593725,
-0.2219774127,
0.1688974202,
0.4236768186,
-0.4405214787,
-0.5089640617,
0.2556097209,
-0.560367465,
-0.1889411509,
0.39286533,
-0.4798198938,
-0.26502949,
-0.4362922013,
0.2758480012,
-0.3486144245,
-0.5554949045,
0.017988598,
-0.6682493687,
0.0404655449,
0.1629082561,
-0.8754736781,
0.4785721898,
1.180346489,
1.0424793959,
-0.4700145423,
-0.421194315,
-0.0549615808,
0.3780058622,
-0.4990648031,
0.9228861928,
-0.0622253492,
-0.6715778112,
-0.1980024129,
0.1649597436,
0.1829763204,
-0.3754964471,
0.5356837511,
-0.6279895306,
-0.2104435116,
-0.524086833,
-0.8862015009,
-0.3558962643,
-0.2156407237,
-0.7701295614,
0.7326364517,
0.4247051775,
-0.9594546556,
0.2462085187,
-0.6267256141,
-0.8629019856,
-0.1346587539,
0.1319016963,
-0.349588871,
0.4587084949,
-0.1860087663,
0.0956456438,
0.4198674858,
-0.1228308082,
-0.1634816378,
-0.67935431,
-0.2370452881,
0.2485060841,
0.812695682,
0.066634953,
-0.3064115047,
0.3447920084,
-1.07178545,
0.1296388209,
-0.023106942,
-0.0210344419,
-0.4286821783,
-0.183268249,
0.3188582659,
-0.1694422215,
-0.2738332152,
-0.41598019,
0.1201550886,
-0.310346067,
0.2265204787,
0.6735764742,
0.3157975972,
0.7177754045,
-0.5193940997,
0.3953557611,
-0.2069051862,
-0.4758432209,
-0.783983767,
-0.1879288554,
-0.5901702046,
-0.1919641495,
0.3351293802,
0.4373243451,
-0.2342725694,
0.3443584144,
-0.20815216,
-0.4830704033,
-0.2552629411,
-0.0550776832,
0.6761830449,
0.5828951597,
0.3090592027,
-0.4915926158,
-0.9051648378,
-1.2026575804,
0.1491647214,
0.1779834777,
0.1509231925,
0.0810054243,
0.7215229869,
-0.4231106639,
1.0711919069,
-0.5876120329,
-0.3998284638,
-0.5579314828,
0.4641316235,
0.0642363653,
0.83634305,
0.8828569055,
-0.757199347,
-0.3271333277,
-0.2196080983,
-0.8405805826,
-0.1725988835,
-0.0708735585,
-0.2693415582,
0.3689371943,
0.818472445,
-0.343408525,
0.2658936679,
0.299256742,
-0.4501456022,
0.6154764295,
-0.2901405394,
-0.0249907728,
-1.1280578375,
0.1488693357,
-0.4651683569,
-0.2472385764,
-0.4422803521,
0.0533877462,
-0.1657893509,
0.2615532577,
0.1584679037,
0.1650179327,
-0.4818065166,
-0.6156936884,
-0.7860768437,
0.2549203038,
0.0461495742,
0.136727795,
-0.2903137803,
0.7461928129,
0.2984236777,
-0.3840689957,
0.5334424973,
0.323002845,
-0.0043058037,
0.8177765012,
-1.027988553,
-0.0292053465,
-0.4424157441,
0.5408206582,
-1.3094522953,
-0.5612143874,
0.0025217913,
-0.5992586613,
0.4111300409,
0.1031496972,
-0.4184074402,
-0.1612702608,
-0.4184467793,
0.2649980187,
0.3526027501,
-0.3640328944,
0.5347368717,
0.4080859721,
-0.4722955227,
-0.6047209501,
-0.5932343602,
-0.159807846,
0.1981719732,
-0.523459971,
0.3750690222,
0.2285177857,
-0.553422749,
0.5171986222,
-0.3153375983,
0.27573511,
0.3222157359,
0.401719898,
-0.0033866221,
-0.3532551825,
0.197261095,
0.2805760503,
-0.5313555002,
0.1409869641,
-0.4960513711,
0.4541067779,
-0.3774939775,
-0.2091596127,
-0.8185716271,
0.7106496096,
0.5160116553,
0.0907765329,
0.3360525072,
0.2529616356,
-0.116982013,
-0.07141947,
-0.1251303703,
-0.2022280991,
-0.4273511469,
0.5054016709,
-0.199261263,
-0.4902760386,
0.627692461,
-0.09165968,
0.0920405313,
0.5708452463,
0.4108326137,
-0.5293915868,
0.6546479464,
1.0863294601,
-0.0149805034,
0.3585284948,
-0.4569627047,
-0.2603331208,
-0.77698493,
-0.0493360572,
-0.3534190357,
-0.4805281758,
-0.3421965241,
0.1503410339,
0.2372297794,
0.2760094106,
-0.0735102296,
0.2423313856,
-0.2550014853,
0.8808725476,
0.7250609398,
-0.1781406552,
0.698579967,
-0.0086847143,
-0.120275028,
0.2425562292,
-0.337915659,
-0.5600749254,
1.2231256962,
-0.3030130565,
0.4308864772,
0.0638743341,
0.7580271363,
0.5967001319,
0.4314723611,
-0.4435128272,
0.2544955909,
0.1875901967,
-0.5646925569,
-0.4772624671,
-0.2879998684,
-0.7865811586,
0.7602559924,
-0.0947743952,
-0.5318342447,
-0.2601753771,
0.4852184355,
-0.3594337702,
0.2757152021,
-0.5952347517,
0.6832371354,
0.4333916306,
-0.0658989251,
-0.255431354,
-0.8446166515,
0.5166514516,
0.1187754348,
0.3991749287,
0.3308377564,
0.1110640764,
0.5461319089,
-0.4051032364,
0.5631504655,
0.1474047303,
-0.0429411866,
0.1856707036,
0.2067177743,
0.2652859092,
0.2781288028,
0.1442184448,
-0.5291507244,
-0.0842076689,
-0.5015660524,
-0.6386641264,
0.6205394864,
-0.5273681879,
-0.5607759953,
-0.4371876121,
-0.7105038166,
-0.0706870481,
0.5010660291,
0.3569226265,
0.6630142331,
-0.1601875573,
0.4693939984,
0.3510654867,
0.5474427342,
0.4439361095,
0.0483155698,
-0.2530810535,
-0.5750538707,
0.4249346554,
0.0404343866,
0.4773615897,
0.0044770325,
-0.1224721372,
0.1057353839,
-0.6168464422,
-0.4749936163,
0.280785799,
-0.6279417872,
0.030025078,
-0.9571329951,
0.1799561977,
-0.6149603724,
-0.6782599092,
-0.7025604248,
-0.9986590147,
-0.1237623543,
-0.6199730635,
0.1879824698,
1.0197621584,
-0.5667586327,
0.4266525507,
-0.522429347,
0.264801383,
-0.1007032543,
0.3465429842,
0.2155358046,
-0.3623905778,
-0.1791001111,
0.0291746017,
-0.2926790416,
-0.8745798469,
-0.0918102711,
0.064746283,
0.4856713414,
0.2459691167,
0.0695816353,
0.5288570523,
-0.1970243901,
0.695348382,
0.0245296657,
-0.9789780378,
0.4982169867,
-0.4107509851,
0.2697383761,
0.7862653136,
0.1966374665,
-0.4079391956,
-0.4713610709,
-0.7181052566,
-1.2706364393,
0.7289269567,
0.1956527233,
0.2059315294,
0.1863770187,
0.5953853726,
0.0922688171,
0.1809579134,
-0.5158306956,
-0.9001812339,
-0.2979232669,
0.0883204713,
-0.3433915377,
-0.6892005801,
-0.3824127913,
-0.287301451,
0.8652312756,
-0.1958433837,
-0.1726977974,
0.433293879,
-0.0942028612,
0.0189054143,
0.0877919272,
0.8025307655,
0.8707798719,
-0.381649524,
0.2802325189,
-0.1644311249,
-0.4715667367,
0.1878010035,
-0.3165261745,
-0.726336658,
0.2530030608,
0.8467098475,
0.3671890795,
0.5553796291,
-0.4283634126,
0.5280390978,
0.3669768572,
-0.0692514405,
-0.4262812138,
-0.185469225,
0.3834953606,
0.2739920318,
0.3317790031,
0.2004253417,
0.3738325834,
-0.8832486272,
0.5810770392,
0.1607109308,
-0.1579399705,
-0.4911309481,
0.5181221366,
0.1489811391,
-0.1197336391,
0.5006675124,
-0.4516963065,
-0.5738009214,
0.6758142114,
0.8675789237,
0.5547770858,
0.1365854144,
0.2067694515,
0.3908093572,
0.1209037602,
-0.2294900417,
0.3422669768,
-0.2261267751,
-0.5622527003,
-0.1280565262,
-0.0104507608,
-0.5229520202,
-0.6461286545,
-1.4258927107,
-0.1139579415,
-0.1881529838,
-0.1173031852,
0.3835290074,
-0.2508580983,
0.2387931198,
-0.1535853744,
-0.3899616003,
0.8647553325,
-0.7887207866,
0.4146597683,
0.919729054,
-0.478579402,
-0.4015752971,
-0.3016675413,
0.4031453729,
-0.1525462866,
0.5989789367,
-0.0951023549,
-0.4771462381,
-0.0059030405,
-0.2101780921,
-0.8896989226,
1.4037081003,
0.0066681909,
0.2318226695,
-0.0651590675,
-0.3907734156,
0.6246255636,
-0.4874609709,
0.0398392156,
0.7252959013,
0.1861718595,
0.4102680385,
-0.8093450069,
-0.0780190974,
-0.2819195986,
0.0203731675,
-0.018147463,
-0.7089995742,
1.0727337599,
-0.6395277381,
-0.4144100249,
0.2065155357,
0.8520528674,
0.1327002347,
0.4883643985,
0.3190738261,
0.6275730729,
0.9243525863,
-0.1626794934,
1.1798776388,
-0.1359568089,
0.5233377218,
1.7343506813,
-0.3013697863,
0.6258477569,
0.5229552388,
0.0047961739,
0.5010365248,
0.1926241368,
-0.2447132766,
0.6423372626,
0.1523396373,
0.1152880043,
0.0805015191,
0.1012469828,
-0.7664806843,
0.4733978212,
-0.0861056447,
-0.4619143605,
-0.3647049665,
0.0679235086,
0.3626698554,
0.3497936428,
-0.359026283,
0.8764278889,
-0.1402229816,
-0.6827263236,
0.1017045975,
-0.0009212338,
0.4317241609,
-0.3888012171,
0.0389592126,
-0.5542626977,
0.5183739662,
-0.2032257617,
-0.5016425848,
0.7904314995,
-0.3276915252,
-0.611738503,
-0.3887261748,
0.3866138756,
0.1094390526,
-0.4166910946,
0.437401861,
0.4160608649,
-0.0994093716,
0.3337324858,
0.1319636703,
0.1202395186,
-0.0585124902,
-0.4147393107,
0.0625178218,
0.2377600372,
0.3748775125,
0.5171400309,
0.4442757964,
0.026258247,
-0.0052583134,
-0.1014736369,
0.7539071441,
-0.7158192396,
-0.7461231351,
-0.854896009,
0.364803493,
-0.3309544027,
-0.4041240513,
0.9445993304,
0.9717319012,
1.2077137232,
-0.2047621906,
0.7746593952,
0.0781868696,
0.5879769921,
-0.4570896029,
0.7558009028,
-0.4363180399,
0.0104125869,
-0.5377800465,
-0.7622101307,
-0.391120851,
0.5056370497,
0.5667775273,
-0.262571007,
0.714253962,
0.6233037114,
0.2156413645,
0.5605880618,
-0.1132074818,
0.4168564379,
0.0231421385,
0.1922917962,
0.5314323306,
-0.4139001369,
0.2236791402,
-0.3645877242,
-0.3513573408,
-0.3255642653,
-0.7074947953,
-0.3902187347,
-0.6810179353,
-0.277546525,
-0.6540223956,
0.0612074547,
0.9824594259,
0.5618007779,
-0.9847226143,
-0.0806886181,
-0.0809272677,
0.2881415784,
-0.5552579165,
-0.2157200128,
0.7119458914,
-0.2818461359,
-0.6893665195,
0.2750450075,
0.2094969898,
0.3340461254,
0.0003695147,
0.3402640522,
0.0936420113,
-0.0716911927,
0.6547787189,
0.3424659967,
-0.562117517,
-0.3409983218,
-0.2652058005,
-0.0112817725,
-0.1010081694,
1.2347265482,
-0.5441524982,
0.3740913272,
0.3638752997,
0.5925681591,
0.4585028887,
0.389559269,
0.6827430129,
-0.6437394023,
0.0581952892,
-0.0655094162,
0.6913752556,
0.2082678527,
-0.040979702,
0.7851122618,
0.5628834367,
-0.2669034898,
-1.1103762388,
0.2602576315,
-1.3145655394,
-0.2195923775,
0.8739545345,
-0.1405514926,
0.2345062792,
-0.1377373934,
-0.3316600323,
0.2260541171,
-0.0912172347,
0.633955121,
0.8234477639,
-0.4667807519,
0.2495594919,
-0.1795815825,
0.4031697214,
0.1811949015,
-0.4655759633,
0.194523409,
0.8378849626,
0.4034153819,
0.597399056,
0.8716289997,
-0.311028868,
0.4658541977,
0.5304395556,
-0.2226886451,
-0.6667693853,
-0.3508927822,
-0.4580237269,
0.5922496915,
-0.3572614491,
0.0948329046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04799v1
|
AI Literacy in Low-Resource Languages:Insights from creating AI in Yoruba videos
| 2024-03-05T12:27:28 | 2024-03-05T12:27:28 |
Wuraola Oyewusi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
To effectively navigate the AI revolution, AI literacy is crucial. However,
content predominantly exists in dominant languages, creating a gap for
low-resource languages like Yoruba (41 million native speakers). This case
study explores bridging this gap by creating and distributing AI videos in
Yoruba.The project developed 26 videos covering foundational, intermediate, and
advanced AI concepts, leveraging storytelling and accessible explanations.
These videos were created using a cost-effective methodology and distributed
across YouTube, LinkedIn, and Twitter, reaching an estimated global audience of
22 countries. Analysis of YouTube reveals insights into viewing patterns, with
the 25-44 age group contributing the most views. Notably, over half of the
traffic originated from external sources, highlighting the potential of
cross-platform promotion.This study demonstrates the feasibility and impact of
creating AI literacy content in low-resource languages. It emphasizes that
accurate interpretation requires both technical expertise in AI and fluency in
the target language. This work contributes a replicable methodology, a 22-word
Yoruba AI vocabulary, and data-driven insights into audience demographics and
acquisition channel
|
[
-0.4919242263,
-0.8299404979,
0.1933704019,
0.0107270041,
0.0580383949,
0.3907696307,
-0.3302788138,
-0.615898788,
0.1674131006,
0.2735267282,
-0.5933868289,
-0.0868739188,
-0.6163955331,
0.1073147357,
-0.0649078637,
0.7954606414,
0.2329145074,
-0.091757305,
-0.0750964284,
-0.353358537,
-0.5919513106,
0.0327815078,
-0.6046664119,
-0.1930458695,
0.4494867027,
0.8438625932,
0.7723278403,
0.7674598694,
0.0748451799,
0.389988333,
0.0391968898,
0.3881165385,
-0.5025997162,
-0.1569910645,
0.0036486234,
-0.5273852348,
-0.1142413318,
0.0398134924,
0.4105394483,
0.7067734599,
0.173267886,
0.464830637,
0.0231289882,
0.7274404764,
-0.5361585617,
0.2709653974,
-0.3719373941,
0.035366375,
-0.4023069143,
-0.0400590785,
-0.1663217098,
-0.3483844995,
-0.0309727136,
-0.6097120047,
0.1775182784,
-0.2350938469,
0.3129270375,
0.5035238266,
-0.3299249411,
-0.2348094136,
-0.8256274462,
0.6896356344,
-0.4764236808,
0.2759180963,
1.0251666307,
0.3047576547,
0.1983524859,
-0.3477660418,
-0.755163908,
-0.1045387536,
0.2547408044,
-0.1449211985,
-0.1210070699,
-0.299564898,
0.080641143,
0.3194593489,
-0.3874205351,
0.3178270161,
-0.6925466657,
-0.1797940284,
0.7678906322,
0.1453127712,
0.4408395886,
-0.2226005644,
0.2098052055,
-0.1794077754,
-0.4939275682,
0.2734585106,
0.8935329914,
0.2948507965,
-0.3901254535,
0.6822168231,
-0.2153208852,
0.5489020944,
-0.1026100144,
-0.3675165176,
0.1355845928,
-0.5299854279,
-0.0914808884,
0.1393467039,
0.823846519,
-0.0872052088,
0.4277864397,
0.1875061691,
0.0980662182,
-0.1095036045,
0.438626796,
-0.6243792772,
-0.0924969912,
-0.1136998683,
-0.5559631586,
-0.0884164646,
-0.1739904732,
-0.7404640913,
-0.6818463802,
-0.047769852,
0.2082737535,
-0.5957426429,
-0.1748142987,
-0.2255171835,
-0.0861887783,
0.0996561274,
0.3990122676,
-1.1486310959,
-0.0493212342,
0.3785795569,
0.7675831318,
0.3564265072,
-0.2629050612,
-0.0964672565,
0.1080356687,
-0.3393599689,
0.4596635997,
-0.3350349665,
-0.3014590442,
0.275896728,
-0.2942739129,
0.0471967943,
-0.2018854618,
0.1894552559,
-0.6324164271,
0.0215095375,
0.1782523096,
-0.1643147171,
-0.4075034261,
0.3964633942,
-0.8241425753,
0.6238870621,
0.1396676749,
-0.3217290938,
-0.0269529428,
-0.6710889935,
-0.7770804763,
0.2846253514,
-0.2951621115,
0.0623249002,
0.0001597053,
0.3127060235,
0.0220060982,
-0.1347221881,
-0.0143793449,
0.2639611363,
-0.1211770624,
0.2158797234,
-1.2457923889,
0.9994038343,
0.2640006542,
-0.5114877224,
-0.2009262145,
-0.545669198,
-0.1039542928,
0.1381086558,
-0.2074466199,
-0.1735162437,
0.0109888352,
-0.0644410104,
-0.2760548592,
0.4284645319,
-0.3191971481,
0.2499531955,
-0.2973055243,
0.607057035,
0.5052269101,
-0.1105178446,
0.4648689628,
-0.1227862388,
0.8074547052,
-0.275208205,
0.3035439551,
-0.2624829113,
-0.7760819197,
-0.5744812489,
0.1869372129,
-0.1173922643,
0.5066813231,
-0.9144555926,
0.0218494665,
-0.0737664849,
-0.6572746634,
-1.0106084347,
0.7326735854,
0.2270924002,
0.7638120651,
0.4013115466,
0.0119144348,
-0.2102249861,
-0.783176899,
0.2435125113,
-0.6268287897,
0.1798921376,
0.3577668667,
0.2747982442,
-0.4069477916,
0.6083213687,
-0.4075972736,
-0.505466342,
-0.6715899706,
0.1457880139,
0.2404689491,
0.4443404973,
0.5937561393,
-1.0091922283,
-0.5830700994,
0.1851412803,
-0.5192731023,
0.3931684494,
-0.0324263312,
0.035532672,
0.3471878469,
0.285641104,
-0.2477256805,
0.5163301229,
0.6807509661,
-0.1542365998,
0.2854994833,
-0.3402273357,
0.3971775174,
-0.9692399502,
-0.0590050519,
0.0532909222,
-0.1071782559,
-0.4418518543,
-0.2057978362,
-0.4603976607,
-0.2610505521,
-0.5052143931,
0.3727247715,
-0.1921939403,
0.2403933555,
-0.1612643152,
0.173361823,
-0.1869821697,
0.3170580268,
-0.0288430769,
0.9420019388,
0.0639723018,
-0.4231971502,
0.3400605321,
0.6492683887,
-0.5589972138,
0.3474394679,
-0.5089270473,
-0.1751693487,
-0.113901034,
-0.2136089951,
-0.908413887,
-0.5466964245,
0.399863869,
-0.7273648381,
0.1621357799,
-0.3392189443,
-0.2099343091,
-0.2360544503,
0.0783103853,
0.5214206576,
0.5201284289,
-0.2351238132,
0.3015595078,
0.8213273287,
-0.356752336,
-0.7534018755,
-0.8847283721,
0.0995754525,
-0.0978615209,
-0.5707243085,
0.0517474934,
-0.1581852734,
-0.327947855,
0.2933832705,
0.1777330339,
-0.3074024618,
0.3657752275,
0.2068878859,
0.0234576371,
-0.3780981004,
-0.0399421901,
-0.1671290696,
0.1212481558,
-0.058792863,
-0.2298754603,
0.671610117,
-0.3104542494,
-0.4504670501,
-0.7253342271,
0.4542780221,
0.382619381,
-0.2661777139,
0.9431509376,
0.8256545663,
-0.4176698029,
-0.1811530143,
-0.4104655683,
0.1119745374,
-0.4471022487,
0.4017853439,
0.1096891984,
-0.5572071671,
0.3454245329,
0.4681730866,
-0.0559614263,
0.4119212031,
0.479596585,
-0.536770165,
0.8435262442,
0.9905860424,
-0.5591489673,
0.8372006416,
-0.7492769957,
0.2126525193,
-0.4146021307,
-0.5549574494,
-0.7009269595,
-0.5268443227,
-0.7172279358,
-0.541572392,
0.5086442828,
-0.1373436749,
-0.3271774352,
0.2671968341,
0.0063066632,
0.5417345166,
1.0658251047,
-0.0087668011,
0.3806972504,
0.1216098741,
0.4264472127,
-0.1309617609,
-0.9753600955,
-0.5136005878,
0.7579835057,
0.1050079316,
0.4394307137,
0.3581686318,
0.5888673067,
0.9106729031,
0.2538076341,
-1.0520764589,
0.2955904901,
-0.1470855176,
-0.4723410308,
-0.6388314366,
-0.3577743471,
-0.8417493105,
-0.4433946609,
-0.2554272115,
-0.4814103544,
-0.0807237849,
0.1015751958,
-0.2804610431,
0.4098604321,
-0.6093205214,
0.963744998,
-0.3466754556,
-0.441569984,
-0.6787355542,
-0.6547084451,
0.2302022278,
0.0757211,
0.6280466914,
0.0188792739,
0.1234427318,
0.5380132794,
-0.6798855662,
1.0134205818,
-0.0247720592,
0.0888385624,
0.8366099,
-0.0242114794,
-0.1288098544,
0.2710916102,
-0.1324747205,
0.2236909121,
-0.4723617435,
-0.5537418723,
-0.2965983748,
0.4458315969,
-1.1516714096,
-0.6452298164,
-0.2127049565,
-0.6187048554,
-0.2784175873,
0.4516819417,
0.0232887659,
0.3698104918,
-0.2520734072,
0.2698598504,
0.5794447064,
-0.252573967,
0.6157573462,
0.0841520503,
0.6039870381,
-0.5409398079,
1.0576765537,
0.0986406282,
0.1899458915,
0.2741398513,
0.1450237483,
-0.2054314464,
-0.6616450548,
-0.9994128346,
0.1722024083,
-0.5528552532,
-0.1088703349,
-0.1644062549,
-0.3312328756,
-0.4692781568,
-0.3604688942,
-0.31494385,
-0.2070734352,
-0.2557342052,
-0.1731002927,
0.3732703626,
0.9556471705,
-0.3270674944,
0.619392097,
-0.8932496309,
0.2775900662,
0.3382142186,
0.1768341213,
0.1831257492,
-0.4533073604,
-0.8401011229,
0.360545218,
-0.2320283502,
-0.8673976064,
0.4636960626,
0.3865436316,
0.7418720722,
0.6341115236,
0.0319177136,
0.8125585914,
-0.3949950337,
0.9499976039,
0.1294125915,
-0.8392777443,
0.6872902513,
-0.3625603914,
0.1945335418,
0.7662718296,
0.8008316755,
-0.6675015688,
-0.3130451739,
-0.4953898787,
-0.8294730186,
0.6407108307,
0.0954775214,
0.6190351248,
-0.0882596746,
-0.1365784705,
0.2418528497,
0.2667940259,
-0.4917125702,
-0.3890171349,
-0.4248526394,
-0.3440902531,
-0.2609663904,
0.0912074074,
-0.0864592418,
-0.0265800711,
0.7427725196,
-0.4033647478,
-0.1547246575,
0.010901208,
-0.4265750647,
0.0116711371,
-0.0050674733,
0.3428868949,
0.5894388556,
0.0705311,
-0.1351451278,
-0.3533428609,
-0.8193704486,
0.0788772255,
0.0430289842,
-0.5276888609,
-0.2329582423,
0.6797038317,
0.7687092423,
-0.0473242477,
-1.0931353569,
0.2177423835,
-0.043540813,
0.2171899825,
-0.5102823377,
0.1782348305,
0.0936340392,
0.4453955591,
0.5607868433,
0.1660489589,
-0.145905301,
-0.7540089488,
-0.0328114554,
0.281785965,
-0.2613820434,
-0.2105288655,
0.936388731,
0.5682008266,
-0.5107653141,
1.1311963797,
-0.1400387138,
-0.3364539742,
0.8935882449,
0.432215333,
0.6084420681,
0.1413900256,
0.6757180691,
0.3679602444,
0.4933768511,
0.1095735431,
0.063952066,
-0.3969900608,
-0.875449419,
-0.3517866731,
-0.3473305106,
-0.5705583692,
0.0522309132,
-0.6388220787,
0.0550733767,
-0.3415134251,
-0.2880429924,
-0.2076468319,
0.3212086558,
-0.8589231968,
0.1908256263,
0.4887255132,
0.7826402187,
-1.0823286772,
0.6458197832,
0.7015593648,
-0.8599247932,
-0.6878973246,
-0.0954952985,
0.0187438671,
-0.972422123,
0.4621061683,
0.0768770427,
-0.0174864065,
0.0211597253,
-0.3810383081,
-0.6299764514,
1.0116202831,
0.1768699437,
-0.1883481592,
0.0188655593,
0.4287890792,
0.656596303,
-0.2208765447,
0.309522301,
0.3088538349,
0.3748762906,
-0.0347525738,
-0.5745256543,
-0.7443746328,
-0.2602053881,
-0.2657903731,
-0.0865038633,
-0.687391758,
0.2917848229,
-0.4893804193,
0.000661202,
0.2160755992,
1.0679795742,
0.0341343842,
0.4974386096,
0.3217956424,
0.1718631089,
0.8224775195,
0.1738891304,
0.8128915429,
-0.2841943502,
-0.3119456172,
0.9376310706,
0.2953079343,
0.7313411236,
0.360196203,
-0.0894869938,
0.6354953647,
0.465893656,
0.0999861136,
0.2492299974,
-0.206035763,
-0.2319844067,
-0.1299020052,
-0.7812416553,
-0.0801646113,
0.659977138,
0.4841171205,
-0.0083696349,
0.2602758408,
0.1659179926,
-0.0263401791,
0.4816445708,
-0.7574846148,
0.6047045588,
-0.0828115046,
-0.5096966028,
0.0086037097,
-0.1659755409,
0.4995510876,
-0.6316040754,
0.0407083035,
-0.4528779984,
0.054569751,
-0.0271413252,
-0.9418424964,
0.4063478708,
0.4944498539,
-0.1495095044,
-0.4151525497,
0.3674165606,
-0.4556165934,
-0.4280388653,
0.0580153093,
0.822162807,
0.1401846111,
0.306101799,
-0.3315414488,
0.0253266431,
0.0834466442,
0.0613498203,
0.1250040382,
0.3863148689,
-0.3466351628,
0.7258705497,
0.3979104757,
0.3535657823,
0.0029060703,
0.0380392894,
0.354036659,
-0.4780495763,
-0.436085403,
-0.6231869459,
0.5436335802,
-0.0024493523,
-0.4109951258,
0.7845553756,
0.4126697183,
1.2873039246,
-0.2178337872,
1.0237103701,
-0.506804049,
-0.2858703136,
-0.1794200242,
0.9262311459,
-0.6229584813,
-0.1572811753,
0.0273904726,
-0.6994885802,
0.1817325801,
0.5291129947,
-0.0429847278,
-0.2049170583,
0.0279388856,
0.2548530698,
0.2105122209,
-0.1726913154,
0.2222839594,
0.1930867434,
0.2384511828,
0.3620554805,
0.7443342805,
-0.4445003569,
0.6848570704,
-0.4422001839,
-0.1519770324,
-0.2554978728,
-0.7220816016,
-0.6780073643,
-0.5135212541,
-0.336879164,
-0.2588957548,
-0.1644063592,
0.9384720922,
0.5138120055,
-0.6143631935,
-0.3436520398,
0.2356058508,
0.4901444018,
-0.3209290504,
-0.1909959614,
0.1055199876,
-0.0450185984,
-1.3832093477,
0.7212405205,
-0.0609561093,
0.0301210005,
-0.6284987926,
-0.1414361894,
-0.1963866353,
-0.0255585629,
0.3812864125,
0.8473080397,
-0.2287132889,
-0.0896239728,
0.1606043875,
-0.0168446656,
0.0131926555,
0.6424507499,
-0.7897267938,
0.4074872136,
0.7987295985,
1.0678465366,
0.3475096524,
0.1667720377,
0.5469773412,
-0.627971828,
0.4785360992,
0.4930058718,
0.2500120699,
0.4560244977,
-0.2459369749,
0.5152260661,
0.4043663442,
-0.359170258,
-0.6323589683,
0.2287658304,
-0.7459465861,
0.0381116197,
0.814013958,
-0.0369789302,
-0.2006363124,
-0.1052317321,
-0.0038726784,
0.4571301043,
-0.4066911638,
0.8540952802,
0.4565636516,
-0.1056384593,
0.0023240142,
-0.7540993094,
0.247075066,
0.1772069633,
-0.7187244296,
-0.3562367558,
0.6885175705,
0.0393644758,
0.3847535849,
0.5354921222,
0.2379567474,
0.2152652144,
0.1673439294,
-0.2013981938,
-0.4529569149,
-0.4958429635,
-0.1895574033,
-0.0166100375,
0.037000861,
-0.1924787015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02902v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02902v2
|
Demonstrating Mutual Reinforcement Effect through Information Flow
| 2024-03-05T12:11:32 | 2024-06-05T15:47:38 |
Chengguang Gan, Xuzheng He, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Mutual Reinforcement Effect (MRE) investigates the synergistic
relationship between word-level and text-level classifications in text
classification tasks. It posits that the performance of both classification
levels can be mutually enhanced. However, this mechanism has not been
adequately demonstrated or explained in prior research. To address this gap, we
employ information flow analysis to observe and substantiate the MRE theory.
Our experiments on six MRE hybrid datasets revealed the presence of MRE in the
model and its impact. Additionally, we conducted fine-tuning experiments, whose
results were consistent with those of the information flow experiments. The
convergence of findings from both experiments corroborates the existence of
MRE. Furthermore, we extended the application of MRE to prompt learning,
utilizing word-level information as a verbalizer to bolster the model's
prediction of text-level classification labels. In our final experiment, the
F1-score significantly surpassed the baseline in five out of six datasets,
further validating the notion that word-level information enhances the language
model's comprehension of the text as a whole.
|
[
-0.5068637729,
-0.8078104258,
0.1957976967,
0.1083154976,
0.0178911351,
-0.0615812503,
0.0664546788,
-0.5294624567,
0.2629831433,
0.0074362089,
-0.5277159214,
-0.3019603193,
-0.9776283503,
0.1873004138,
-0.5014763474,
1.1808946133,
-0.15065597,
-0.0106574493,
-0.2760934234,
-0.1029783785,
-0.6848588586,
-0.4748146832,
-0.807428658,
-0.5708473325,
0.9921205044,
0.3319762349,
0.661046803,
0.4377964735,
0.5379806161,
0.3638319373,
-0.1064507663,
-0.2086959183,
-0.6467357278,
0.2066530585,
-0.4182197452,
-0.7221953869,
0.0158906709,
0.3984901011,
0.8730037212,
0.4379577041,
-0.3281700909,
-0.1726381034,
0.3199413717,
0.7608559132,
-0.6263416409,
0.0881126523,
-0.1593242884,
0.1582629681,
-0.1020702273,
-0.5559992194,
-0.5162718296,
-0.1523603648,
0.2229687274,
-0.6853065491,
-0.1358882785,
0.2607235312,
1.2222158909,
0.2307568491,
-0.4026209712,
-0.2097603232,
-0.7481657267,
0.5981033444,
-0.3514568508,
0.4423251748,
0.3564942479,
0.2712332904,
-0.2291981429,
-0.6984994411,
-0.8413383365,
-0.2845361233,
-0.1917838454,
0.2353334725,
0.0257242713,
0.2828415632,
0.3937979341,
0.3176050484,
-0.518445015,
-0.1667540967,
-0.41195485,
-0.1018397138,
0.1848588437,
0.1108214855,
0.5003503561,
-0.0578464158,
-0.619412601,
-0.5462635756,
-0.0940847918,
0.4886215925,
-0.0694056824,
0.0343790427,
-0.0447831452,
0.587364614,
-0.07321845,
0.5190210342,
-0.1225727871,
-0.1718611717,
0.1274366528,
-0.5981153846,
-0.1917211115,
-0.1674892604,
0.9198506474,
0.2277094573,
0.2438581735,
-0.1081554741,
-0.3074587584,
0.04398074,
0.1213048622,
-0.9515145421,
0.2021615356,
-0.2630271316,
-0.6218278408,
-0.4868275523,
0.6599159241,
-0.6984679103,
-0.2872349322,
-0.316688776,
0.7317499518,
-0.5168007612,
-0.4969549179,
0.2059992254,
-0.7438713908,
0.2043059766,
0.1469660848,
-0.707402885,
0.533347249,
0.5761644244,
0.9530965686,
-0.1218046471,
-0.6312562227,
-0.3805339038,
0.1744457334,
-0.2197530866,
0.8698592782,
-0.985951364,
-0.3065750897,
-0.0604919158,
-0.1212083846,
-0.5890020132,
-0.4338675141,
0.3026898205,
-0.5613396764,
0.9224629998,
-0.3185493648,
-0.7362219095,
-0.3545480371,
0.2385080755,
-0.542584002,
0.9176740646,
0.0795467049,
-1.2606967688,
0.5164304376,
-0.7519959211,
-0.3311387002,
-0.3402789235,
-0.3171791136,
-0.1161431447,
0.006631,
-0.2416927814,
0.3093053997,
-0.0558146574,
-0.006155021,
-0.3585763574,
-0.5333667397,
0.4666029513,
-0.362108022,
0.232134074,
0.0202049445,
-0.231201604,
0.103589572,
-0.414447248,
-0.2675604522,
0.1203219667,
-0.2787748873,
-0.7517933846,
-0.0750893727,
-0.4856826961,
0.4816715419,
0.0221175402,
-0.4071531594,
0.2126726508,
-0.0774844065,
-0.067111522,
0.6160702705,
0.4223786294,
0.4765495062,
-0.7308055758,
0.6839296222,
0.1728724837,
0.0335494317,
-0.0292659197,
-0.3958614171,
-0.4688125849,
-0.1576154977,
0.4682365358,
0.8060208559,
-0.9418279529,
-0.0012553161,
-0.0829797313,
0.0011123022,
-0.3518399894,
-0.0478305928,
0.3472137749,
0.4555540383,
0.3142261803,
-0.3502544165,
0.0018580398,
-0.6864121556,
-0.2060440034,
-0.3012397587,
0.1096286625,
0.2619930208,
0.2149000019,
-0.1168343425,
0.7489725947,
-0.5042641759,
-0.1361765414,
-0.242732957,
0.6517904997,
0.0751508847,
0.4345643818,
0.3812863529,
-0.5268130302,
-0.0788437352,
-0.2792728543,
-0.9464826584,
-0.0896080881,
-0.191968739,
-0.4358668029,
-0.1375402957,
0.5984706879,
-0.264015615,
0.3097117841,
0.4510453641,
-0.7388107181,
0.4686505497,
-0.2372940928,
0.6814911366,
-0.9774478674,
-0.2010421753,
0.3283314407,
-0.0758748725,
-0.5645781159,
-0.224338755,
-0.0580070838,
-0.0041865795,
0.2085310221,
0.3719263375,
-0.0387181938,
0.0114813456,
-0.6938083768,
0.3531280458,
0.1096615046,
0.3121447861,
0.1291664243,
0.9101579785,
0.5048440695,
-0.8110595942,
-0.1808178723,
-0.0230964087,
-0.1171420813,
0.6116167307,
-0.671022594,
-0.1277005672,
-0.3838067651,
0.1665581167,
-1.0349106789,
0.0105437767,
0.1364155114,
-0.6475380659,
0.6724264026,
0.3060126007,
-0.558996439,
-0.2707034647,
-0.4316186309,
0.317266643,
0.1967147738,
-0.4626574516,
0.310495317,
0.3212325871,
-0.1493782103,
-0.6521205306,
-0.4435101748,
-0.1628467292,
-0.1873251349,
-0.9057449698,
0.0454303175,
-0.091216974,
-0.2150380313,
0.0300619081,
-0.1180572063,
-0.3489285707,
0.1542554498,
0.2176837772,
0.3586067855,
-0.191306293,
0.4218299985,
0.2441561073,
-0.0911854059,
0.3219285011,
-0.0428864881,
0.354618758,
0.0190681927,
0.0165285487,
-0.7838817239,
0.0525267199,
0.4643217325,
-0.1257778704,
1.287525773,
0.6872919202,
-0.2120143026,
-0.2548500597,
-0.1898990422,
-0.6294219494,
-0.511903286,
0.2448988259,
-0.5889763832,
-1.0192232132,
0.1651924253,
-0.0991407931,
-0.0950470865,
0.3031929731,
-0.2768098116,
-0.3182769716,
0.8292554617,
0.7231398821,
-0.1861725748,
1.048674345,
-0.1631167829,
-0.2206524163,
-0.5591339469,
-0.3562070131,
-0.5938904881,
-0.4058103263,
-0.5029556751,
-0.2450550795,
0.3435455859,
0.5847354531,
0.0937967151,
0.2142344266,
-0.1748027205,
0.3861510754,
0.4988900423,
0.2309246212,
0.2561312616,
-0.0538719632,
-0.3948814273,
0.0126299551,
-0.8917857409,
-0.2849495113,
0.5398480296,
0.5319877863,
0.7181642652,
-0.1055177972,
0.6699138284,
0.5581823587,
0.2563540637,
-0.3993551433,
0.6268725395,
0.1654644161,
-0.4363842607,
-0.382961005,
-0.7636902928,
-1.0018972158,
0.503115952,
-0.6618529558,
-0.2526622117,
0.0868327171,
0.0030468199,
0.2136155814,
0.023575956,
-0.7082939148,
0.9043384194,
0.1755925566,
-0.6001436114,
-0.9488742352,
-0.3386366963,
0.5953760743,
0.0981170088,
0.4599617124,
0.1809793413,
-0.1796506494,
0.9792205095,
-0.4716215432,
0.6241512895,
-0.4409274459,
-0.1199286878,
0.3791460693,
0.0698210448,
0.6673895121,
-0.0928655118,
0.0514101088,
-0.082986854,
-0.1287918687,
-0.5745062232,
-1.0560998917,
0.564478755,
-0.6395390034,
-0.4823525846,
-0.55936867,
-0.5588217974,
-0.1606031805,
-0.003309268,
-0.0461939946,
0.5413638353,
-0.0246888474,
-0.1426759511,
0.8489409685,
-0.2915259302,
0.3194502294,
0.8061008453,
-0.3148508072,
-0.4436560571,
0.9852175117,
-0.0159897506,
0.6100732088,
0.5788804889,
0.4844329357,
-0.306579411,
-0.3909840584,
-0.0802110434,
0.6120336056,
-0.4726837277,
0.1201824769,
-0.3669994175,
-0.0820634589,
-0.1001414657,
0.0930248424,
0.1452727467,
-0.5397423506,
0.1189864576,
-0.3669326603,
0.2990088761,
1.2182120085,
-0.1468022019,
0.3182333708,
-0.7880222201,
0.0474250503,
0.3393197954,
0.4492841065,
-0.0512304343,
-0.789963305,
-0.3712363541,
-0.2089965343,
-0.220316112,
-0.9065897465,
-0.2467173338,
-0.0597945936,
0.5996702909,
0.5861015916,
-0.0251075774,
0.4008295238,
-0.2312058657,
0.5195447206,
0.283657819,
-0.8603340983,
0.50293082,
-0.3016918004,
0.2982525527,
0.5351264477,
0.4518807828,
-0.674680531,
-0.8511242867,
-0.6180971265,
-0.374637723,
0.6699710488,
0.2733146548,
-0.2295214981,
-0.1625973731,
0.3276953697,
-0.0096725663,
0.345163852,
-0.9992620349,
-0.2464087009,
-0.0798961818,
-0.1303715408,
0.1866168231,
-0.282904923,
0.4161273241,
0.0336856879,
0.7588628531,
0.3529748023,
0.2597248256,
0.3377856016,
-0.0267830547,
-0.2141499221,
0.4019945264,
0.8768566251,
0.2591333389,
-0.192874819,
0.2034870535,
0.0015537125,
-0.2336911112,
0.0754610524,
0.0897036046,
-0.1481439769,
0.0486407951,
0.6270042658,
0.8069478869,
0.1646459252,
-0.2885172963,
0.7719221711,
-0.3292790055,
-0.4641549289,
0.3524739742,
0.3614089191,
-0.3021936119,
0.4284823835,
-0.0280105006,
0.2458672374,
0.2029410601,
-0.3714465797,
0.6259756088,
0.5475380421,
-0.5575431585,
-0.2806006372,
0.4799263179,
0.1208125576,
-0.0635660216,
0.2323173881,
-0.2129703909,
-0.3952314854,
0.3726566732,
0.5476685762,
0.4514608979,
-0.3830218613,
0.3439873159,
0.6407693028,
0.5152308345,
-0.240629524,
0.1943546087,
-0.1723613143,
-0.5478612185,
-0.6610367298,
-0.385773927,
-0.1536465734,
-0.0847520009,
-0.7305654287,
0.0230313912,
-0.4141896963,
-0.0942524299,
-0.2106621116,
-0.2215872556,
-0.2622964084,
0.1544312537,
0.1013790518,
1.186347127,
-0.9937185049,
0.8425087333,
0.7010669112,
-0.7221263647,
-0.8239244819,
0.2454397529,
-0.2265200466,
-0.6890704036,
0.738053441,
0.3629665673,
-0.4470213652,
-0.180582419,
-0.3815952837,
-0.8233137727,
1.1095889807,
-0.227665022,
-0.3919127584,
0.034207359,
0.17795901,
0.5002707839,
-0.2322565913,
0.7087569833,
0.0320103355,
0.554989934,
0.1422144622,
-0.8497427702,
0.0877130106,
-0.2012512535,
0.0444082394,
0.5584360957,
-0.6352612376,
0.2739376426,
-0.2254105359,
-0.4414571524,
-0.3892146349,
1.0537536144,
0.0245056618,
0.5249238014,
0.9131361842,
0.629714787,
0.9695396423,
0.1292549074,
1.116399169,
-0.2513599396,
0.075051032,
0.8215562105,
-0.052763924,
0.8862563372,
0.2151170522,
-0.1798894405,
1.086306572,
0.3355255127,
0.4232330322,
0.5573717952,
0.2893171906,
-0.407258153,
0.0739459321,
-0.4842933118,
-0.3830329776,
-0.0785755292,
0.3046342731,
-0.4455633461,
-0.1514013112,
0.3134628832,
-0.1537039578,
0.2265570164,
-0.3954019547,
0.9381617308,
0.1401411444,
-0.6030163169,
0.5025752187,
-0.1634765863,
0.6959551573,
-0.7708208561,
-0.0466989167,
-0.271725595,
0.063827388,
-0.1679135263,
-0.7641877532,
0.1947072148,
-0.2392994314,
-0.464194268,
-0.2049575746,
0.8448667526,
-0.6211501956,
0.0849808827,
0.5880931616,
0.4230001867,
0.0232382342,
0.1244480088,
-0.6928076148,
-0.2789288759,
-0.028746089,
-0.2501043677,
0.5611853004,
0.8396280408,
0.3322925866,
0.6882911921,
0.3920555711,
-0.0414891616,
0.2412039489,
0.0958893374,
0.8516213298,
-0.9740373492,
-0.336057812,
-0.7111007571,
0.3611166179,
-0.2567273378,
-0.0048214891,
0.7191278934,
0.5246727467,
0.7446370125,
0.1392707974,
0.7853098512,
0.1229344308,
0.6732618213,
-0.5459336042,
0.2161578387,
-0.5917739272,
0.1946991235,
-0.3824198544,
-0.5246571898,
0.1643146574,
0.5841880441,
-0.2437733561,
-0.0495851487,
1.2634019852,
0.777785182,
0.140136987,
0.2476996183,
0.157257691,
0.04224433,
0.0663329959,
0.4178443551,
1.1131967306,
-0.3072473705,
0.6749725938,
-0.1605145782,
-0.6746050715,
0.2723066509,
-0.5240914822,
-1.3325793743,
-0.4415073991,
-0.3279483616,
-0.7484209538,
0.2107604742,
0.7701376081,
0.4938552082,
-0.4640507102,
-0.3458355665,
-0.4107539058,
0.2484234124,
-0.3268798888,
-0.3664723635,
-0.2330480665,
-0.793403089,
-0.39656201,
0.4753762484,
0.1730840057,
0.2913109362,
0.1416224986,
-0.2788870633,
-0.2179046124,
0.2721087933,
0.5747064948,
0.1672536135,
0.0276108701,
-0.0111292619,
-0.151318267,
-0.4295898378,
0.0158070084,
1.002554059,
-0.6572892666,
0.1633910239,
0.7871988416,
0.6757808924,
0.296693325,
0.2346741259,
0.8557369709,
-0.5109370947,
-0.0190802868,
-0.3434113562,
0.3037705123,
-0.2134785652,
-0.2139497548,
0.400315851,
0.5805155635,
-0.7113257051,
-0.4175046086,
0.210166648,
-0.6430501342,
-0.5694561005,
1.1242053509,
0.0959648713,
-0.13452591,
0.1327424943,
-0.1379562318,
0.3175795078,
-0.7744636536,
0.8912206888,
1.0481791496,
-0.1513475925,
-0.2586358488,
-0.4941853583,
0.4001654685,
0.7100706697,
-1.0415662527,
-0.2645594478,
0.4808105528,
0.159388423,
0.1287656277,
0.5214422345,
0.2158424854,
0.0494259074,
0.0371268913,
-0.1103594527,
-0.1396794021,
-0.4384851754,
-0.3682994545,
0.2679621279,
0.2893490493,
-0.3465046287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04798v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04798v2
|
JMI at SemEval 2024 Task 3: Two-step approach for multimodal ECAC using in-context learning with GPT and instruction-tuned Llama models
| 2024-03-05T12:07:18 | 2024-04-02T14:52:37 |
Arefa, Mohammed Abbas Ansari, Chandni Saxena, Tanvir Ahmad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper presents our system development for SemEval-2024 Task 3: "The
Competition of Multimodal Emotion Cause Analysis in Conversations". Effectively
capturing emotions in human conversations requires integrating multiple
modalities such as text, audio, and video. However, the complexities of these
diverse modalities pose challenges for developing an efficient multimodal
emotion cause analysis (ECA) system. Our proposed approach addresses these
challenges by a two-step framework. We adopt two different approaches in our
implementation. In Approach 1, we employ instruction-tuning with two separate
Llama 2 models for emotion and cause prediction. In Approach 2, we use GPT-4V
for conversation-level video description and employ in-context learning with
annotated conversation using GPT 3.5. Our system wins rank 4, and system
ablation experiments demonstrate that our proposed solutions achieve
significant performance gains. All the experimental codes are available on
Github.
|
[
-0.4873500466,
-1.0342063904,
0.7438793778,
0.1721255481,
-0.1991871148,
-0.0800318792,
-0.0444373302,
-0.4781071544,
0.1468915194,
0.3094738424,
-0.7490414977,
-0.2658115327,
-0.6161225438,
0.0327193327,
-0.045329012,
0.8855884075,
-0.3612756431,
0.1208129823,
-0.2880334854,
-0.2446110398,
-0.5712352991,
-0.4510893822,
-0.70798105,
0.0864496008,
0.539447546,
0.7821667194,
-0.0652874485,
0.0156700294,
0.5378886461,
0.3382228613,
0.1377744675,
0.2572614253,
-0.1784818619,
0.2443067133,
0.0761869997,
-0.2284453362,
-0.6652944684,
-0.2038010359,
0.2504445314,
0.1017125696,
-0.1362633854,
0.1881970316,
0.0008352472,
0.5893973708,
-0.8067674041,
0.1338016391,
-0.4381163418,
-0.00292586,
-0.1652258933,
-0.6718053222,
-0.1757739782,
0.0418192111,
0.0980910063,
-0.3991725147,
-0.160970673,
-0.0005220574,
0.5205091238,
0.4278640747,
-0.9836720228,
-0.5604428649,
-0.4695439339,
0.6238252521,
-0.6359721422,
0.1654311866,
0.2300641835,
0.0978785604,
0.0383131765,
-0.5197173357,
-0.6350203753,
0.3087853491,
0.3480418324,
0.394200772,
-0.140998289,
0.1459473372,
0.2365482002,
-0.0762549415,
-0.6327078938,
0.0750177503,
-0.3711737692,
-0.0014637884,
0.4110766947,
0.2993199229,
0.439314425,
-0.1266924441,
-0.4786067903,
-0.1471298337,
-0.6644975543,
-0.0341631696,
0.4546788037,
-0.0052725701,
-0.3321112394,
0.2254238278,
-0.2752431929,
0.0607185587,
-0.1934770346,
-0.1123652309,
0.4367480278,
-0.3987179995,
-0.2294641137,
0.1640097201,
0.5480878949,
0.4363388717,
-0.2942977846,
0.3400412798,
-0.095180355,
0.2921918929,
0.2390811443,
-0.9849380255,
-0.0862890556,
0.3686231971,
-0.3133069873,
-0.1968512833,
-0.3056046963,
-1.2901198864,
-0.2631791532,
-0.3620443642,
0.9482751489,
-0.0981264859,
-0.3651449978,
-0.1904270351,
0.200120762,
0.2711795568,
0.4599137306,
-0.9168552756,
0.1392228901,
0.4423825741,
0.6240647435,
0.0757562071,
-0.104188025,
-0.4838913083,
0.1062216312,
-0.0739279836,
0.7732000351,
-0.6267642975,
-0.2967895865,
0.0246758088,
0.0919130221,
-0.0640550107,
-0.1084532291,
0.6850488782,
-0.3750356138,
0.3381888866,
-0.3085454106,
-0.1877993047,
-0.4630309939,
0.4627560377,
-0.2988856435,
0.6313470602,
-0.2601493299,
-0.5616409183,
0.0861979723,
-1.023424387,
-0.452242583,
-0.1531134695,
-0.078839086,
-0.4470001161,
0.0827704296,
0.3329376578,
0.4979948699,
-0.2147371918,
0.194205448,
-0.2885299027,
-0.2381850928,
0.1093873382,
-0.7025635839,
0.3020889163,
0.3595619798,
-0.6467081904,
0.0161996782,
-0.8007051945,
-0.170696944,
0.0114080729,
-0.1827363223,
-0.226097405,
0.1418721527,
-0.0764686763,
0.4383170605,
0.218166247,
-0.4627947211,
-0.0170238279,
-0.0948795006,
0.2315699011,
0.8294183612,
0.4529431462,
0.3057857454,
0.2258692533,
0.703704834,
0.3904951811,
0.1630761921,
-0.5908848047,
-0.4247634113,
-1.002314806,
-0.0502540097,
-0.1593008637,
0.4728780985,
-0.6944669485,
-0.2850037217,
0.2733859718,
-0.3619426489,
-0.0997309908,
-0.0245805047,
0.4376959205,
0.5750565529,
0.3506893516,
-0.399309814,
-0.782872498,
-0.8041734695,
-0.0011311438,
-0.1323055476,
0.2074319273,
0.465492785,
0.5524924994,
-0.4776060581,
0.2694542408,
-0.0537932515,
-0.1961442381,
0.0084749646,
0.646533668,
-0.10579741,
0.3356588185,
0.3262793422,
-0.6582629681,
-0.2317804694,
0.0409875251,
-0.7591007948,
-0.386429131,
-0.1599321812,
-0.1062487587,
0.4361925125,
0.3812732995,
-0.246172592,
0.5232409239,
0.8077886701,
-0.2261181921,
0.0491545126,
-0.0031537453,
0.7964432836,
-1.2666072845,
-0.1319966763,
0.1757140607,
0.0879795626,
-0.6972702742,
-0.3415090144,
0.1233151779,
-0.2000921071,
-0.597305119,
0.0934744775,
-0.309176892,
-0.1842337251,
-0.3446008563,
0.1790928245,
-0.0911265686,
0.9304584265,
-0.0731910691,
0.7201378942,
0.290541023,
-0.6738191247,
0.0544614196,
0.1259037256,
-0.0612868257,
0.8205443025,
-0.3981812298,
0.2861905694,
-0.0510500073,
0.1776573956,
-1.1300029755,
-0.6011711955,
0.3352872133,
-0.4034185112,
0.2902188897,
0.2252264619,
-0.0625224262,
-0.1114765778,
-0.2639513612,
0.4130919874,
0.2492474765,
-0.5548190475,
0.8682848215,
0.6134958863,
-0.5602318645,
-0.3993405402,
-0.4096513689,
0.1417255253,
-0.5639534593,
-0.6197960377,
0.1799097657,
-0.166869089,
-0.0735526904,
-0.3381553888,
-0.0176081732,
-0.0126925986,
0.3469704986,
0.5436875224,
0.1834593564,
0.0455818251,
0.0794835985,
0.3464843035,
-0.018342901,
0.3775919974,
0.3838901818,
0.2545440793,
-0.2258422822,
-0.5157453418,
-0.6496953368,
0.5055111051,
0.5788981318,
-0.1220739931,
0.2447039783,
0.8165121078,
-0.2926802933,
0.098129943,
-0.5772216916,
-0.0999367684,
-0.4493438005,
0.5458778143,
-0.3528649509,
-0.9492058754,
0.3940398395,
-0.4704861045,
-0.0532158911,
0.2687040269,
0.9554184675,
-0.2297430336,
1.5264444351,
0.571188271,
0.1203469336,
0.6422268152,
0.1189580634,
0.3178413808,
-0.9096668959,
-0.362835288,
-0.4885081351,
-0.3641551137,
-0.4864912629,
-0.2254702896,
0.8106509447,
-0.1894178689,
-0.2747274935,
0.0800427794,
-0.0312037151,
0.3751762509,
0.3587151468,
-0.0312416032,
0.0422639027,
0.01078605,
0.1844246835,
0.0835224018,
-0.3804133534,
-0.5405968428,
1.0581953526,
0.5502963066,
0.4096426368,
0.4789885879,
0.6494889259,
0.1636123359,
0.3612463176,
-0.4524484277,
0.5313596129,
0.3929355443,
-0.5268799067,
-0.0559917614,
-0.1787169874,
-0.6059501767,
0.2714345753,
0.0154624507,
-1.0286710262,
0.1673074812,
0.1410055608,
-0.0813924372,
0.0060517639,
-0.7842173576,
0.9328430295,
-0.3174741864,
-0.6386058927,
-0.4424150288,
-0.7858673334,
0.6491546631,
-0.1382213384,
0.3852463961,
-0.1822164953,
0.0649069026,
0.7363686562,
-0.2685541213,
0.8646647334,
-0.406730175,
-0.1666662097,
0.4279058278,
-0.0793756545,
0.6437853575,
0.1406479329,
0.231025368,
-0.1139842793,
0.1680140644,
-0.0954670757,
-0.5207324624,
0.6066009402,
-0.8222331405,
-0.4065279961,
-0.3341441751,
-0.1250690222,
-0.4583604038,
-0.2828052044,
-0.0025735958,
0.5591444969,
-0.182597518,
0.2895618081,
0.5319241285,
-0.2161125541,
0.7620847225,
0.5982394218,
0.20816046,
-0.4694182575,
0.9567952752,
-0.255120337,
0.0028714782,
0.2464361638,
-0.0809484646,
-0.135806486,
-0.2303495705,
-0.4606873095,
-0.1670679599,
-0.721114397,
-0.3847162127,
-0.6341695786,
0.21757254,
-0.2938768268,
-0.0318303555,
-0.4060793221,
-0.0038404122,
-0.5525618792,
-0.0542054549,
0.0783054903,
0.5260051489,
-0.1250344664,
0.2277934849,
-0.7805452347,
0.0759065375,
0.4584423006,
0.002864283,
-0.1743592024,
-0.4744852781,
-0.3909989595,
-0.0609643348,
-0.8915287852,
-0.9713280201,
0.5854141116,
0.2385350764,
0.252802819,
0.4760408401,
-0.1580042392,
0.937712431,
-0.3182108998,
0.9185304046,
0.3377262652,
-1.0954036713,
0.8125837445,
-0.3751828372,
0.126494661,
0.5061345696,
0.2789803743,
-0.5818137527,
-0.0683435798,
-0.4970871508,
-0.924626708,
0.7498532534,
0.0119512985,
0.2697273195,
-0.1417776793,
-0.0834550858,
-0.0391145758,
0.0113623329,
-0.4468860924,
0.134989053,
-0.1309476644,
-0.4285500348,
0.126461789,
-0.6501871943,
-0.1712424606,
0.2264614105,
0.9041141868,
-0.3704943359,
0.4619966447,
0.0889113173,
-0.2097766548,
-0.3962349594,
0.6607618928,
0.8579699993,
0.3462643921,
-0.1817104071,
-0.0357630029,
0.53612113,
-0.1418540627,
0.1511426121,
-0.2039400041,
0.3162695765,
-0.4291978776,
0.1497961134,
1.021228075,
0.4652445316,
-0.7986392379,
0.7420766354,
-0.1311479956,
-0.4094599485,
-0.4567088485,
-0.0759290978,
-0.0460536778,
0.68081671,
0.2278211713,
-0.1400074214,
0.6435517669,
-0.4826054573,
0.1353614777,
0.167003572,
-0.2915993631,
-0.6163535714,
0.6649565101,
0.6248009205,
0.0208731908,
0.2181007117,
-0.2453592718,
-0.5848835111,
0.7074766755,
0.5681173801,
0.9677618742,
-0.3317305744,
0.0972315148,
0.4102678597,
-0.0256158691,
0.1406717449,
0.4657895267,
-0.2598257363,
-0.5898686051,
-0.4375596046,
-0.3675334752,
-0.8453570008,
0.0379892029,
-0.6426694393,
0.3226415217,
-0.2282966971,
0.0085939588,
-0.4123753011,
-0.0038029768,
-0.7641321421,
0.2685837746,
0.5562747717,
0.272243917,
-1.0703001022,
0.5197470188,
0.6637852788,
-0.2786025405,
-0.9233552217,
-0.2672191262,
0.4749308825,
-0.4025248885,
0.7106332779,
0.363915354,
-0.1717687696,
-0.1368979812,
-0.5226136446,
-0.7370112538,
1.4391944408,
-0.1064855605,
-0.6487882733,
0.3581691682,
-0.3000606894,
0.4204984605,
-0.5467299223,
0.623108685,
0.651289165,
0.3146523833,
0.1864361018,
-0.7359528542,
-0.3416559696,
-0.4140291214,
-0.158737883,
0.1499624997,
-0.8645185232,
0.5688126087,
-0.0296747331,
-0.2526373267,
-0.0629018471,
0.7607934475,
0.3249072433,
0.8318371177,
0.352317214,
0.5537025332,
0.5669695139,
0.0071761627,
0.6562287807,
-0.2840021849,
0.3565756083,
1.0293329954,
-0.4990952313,
0.8863895535,
0.712025106,
-0.1552630663,
0.5956241488,
0.8015846014,
0.5118637085,
0.5699484348,
-0.2551076114,
-0.5780450702,
-0.135463953,
-0.2057554126,
-0.2342481911,
0.8468270898,
0.7072826028,
-0.2368365079,
0.0867810473,
0.2827818394,
0.082893692,
-0.3674387038,
-0.3165819347,
0.8400268555,
-0.1224468797,
-0.5834251642,
-0.047858011,
-0.0059726969,
0.5062198639,
-0.3314504921,
-0.105325833,
-0.315395534,
0.0090227565,
-0.1104874313,
-0.2840773761,
0.1123716086,
0.1880617887,
0.2858213484,
-0.1205322966,
0.7407083511,
-0.4401215911,
-0.2287526727,
0.0770880133,
0.4011739194,
0.259480238,
0.1707101911,
-0.4735630155,
0.3760769367,
-0.0032356144,
-0.8439807892,
0.4717600048,
0.6234052181,
-0.1158509552,
0.4033225775,
0.2760519385,
-0.4262180924,
-0.2522265017,
0.3255086541,
0.7943419218,
-0.5239846706,
-0.40155375,
-0.7500498891,
0.7035588622,
0.0523775034,
-0.3134244978,
0.4136624336,
0.1489619017,
0.5559923649,
0.0719189495,
0.7382262945,
-0.1622013748,
0.3546801507,
-0.6985393763,
-0.0452753454,
-0.8598697782,
0.3064123094,
-0.6357685924,
-0.8638814092,
-0.2123868167,
0.3836816847,
-0.1928102523,
-0.0354106724,
0.8757448792,
1.0249893665,
0.0958922282,
0.3817088306,
0.3666137755,
-0.0244534984,
0.5249339342,
0.9019180536,
0.9334290624,
-0.5046643615,
0.5199218988,
-0.1330537498,
-0.3358044922,
-0.5216200352,
-0.8975072503,
-0.6464066505,
-0.7178836465,
-0.442464143,
0.0062850248,
-0.0815832913,
1.0149503946,
0.5291173458,
-0.5868136287,
0.1319038868,
-0.0345155001,
-0.1883541793,
0.2116166055,
-0.1708925664,
0.0669342279,
-0.4670542777,
-0.9073898792,
0.5404703021,
0.7106384039,
-0.1670316905,
-0.1634166241,
-0.2600374222,
-0.0922395959,
0.1595181972,
0.7011808753,
0.3110330403,
-0.6701468825,
-0.7051991224,
-0.344956398,
-0.0096316338,
-0.0381305702,
0.7833854556,
-0.4718839228,
0.5713154078,
0.4826947451,
0.7652626634,
0.5677707791,
0.0398926772,
0.406661123,
-0.601546526,
0.0736418068,
-0.0784820095,
0.4701291323,
0.184966892,
-0.3585078418,
0.6818677187,
0.0992272571,
-1.0035928488,
-0.6243923903,
0.1483664811,
-1.1825067997,
0.0244179033,
1.0469602346,
-0.078113772,
-0.2811082304,
0.2106932998,
-0.418138653,
0.4201145768,
-0.3935430646,
0.681743443,
0.6473302245,
-0.4462239742,
-0.5291618705,
-0.755177319,
0.0483027548,
0.6174144149,
-1.1565905809,
-0.3675786257,
0.7016060352,
0.040109545,
-0.0485192835,
0.7074491978,
-0.1032096371,
0.4038218856,
-0.0685212463,
0.3506412208,
0.0495968126,
-0.5651096702,
-0.4557628334,
0.2288223207,
-0.1451548189,
-0.2832577825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02893v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02893v2
|
Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Document-Level Event Causality Identification with Heterogeneous Graph Contrastive Transfer Learning
| 2024-03-05T11:57:21 | 2024-03-22T07:44:32 |
Zhitao He, Pengfei Cao, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Zhiqiang Zhang, Mengshu Sun, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Event Causality Identification (ECI) refers to the detection of causal
relations between events in texts. However, most existing studies focus on
sentence-level ECI with high-resource languages, leaving more challenging
document-level ECI (DECI) with low-resource languages under-explored. In this
paper, we propose a Heterogeneous Graph Interaction Model with
Multi-granularity Contrastive Transfer Learning (GIMC) for zero-shot
cross-lingual document-level ECI. Specifically, we introduce a heterogeneous
graph interaction network to model the long-distance dependencies between
events that are scattered over a document. Then, to improve cross-lingual
transferability of causal knowledge learned from the source language, we
propose a multi-granularity contrastive transfer learning module to align the
causal representations across languages. Extensive experiments show our
framework outperforms the previous state-of-the-art model by 9.4% and 8.2% of
average F1 score on monolingual and multilingual scenarios respectively.
Notably, in the multilingual scenario, our zero-shot framework even exceeds
GPT-3.5 with few-shot learning by 24.3% in overall performance.
|
[
-0.2097687572,
-1.0700376034,
0.5840621591,
0.0197736584,
-0.1049655229,
-0.0523086898,
-0.1129346639,
-0.8045246005,
0.2599606812,
0.0535876118,
-0.4166551828,
-0.5425372124,
-0.6466364264,
-0.0840259343,
-0.1057498753,
1.0974045992,
-0.3323758543,
-0.1599317044,
0.0466777422,
-0.1786711663,
-0.201899454,
-0.4773880243,
-0.8148441315,
-0.4532277286,
0.9864469767,
0.5021730065,
0.2518841326,
0.3233745396,
0.3141650856,
0.2673490644,
0.0412143879,
-0.1280863732,
-0.6124674678,
-0.3832449913,
-0.4604232311,
-0.2244783491,
-0.347199589,
-0.0490097553,
0.6572729349,
0.9176725149,
0.0850169584,
-0.1825068593,
-0.0146592772,
0.2458602488,
-0.8085569143,
0.4908275902,
-0.5488582253,
0.3102556169,
-0.0920890197,
-0.370603323,
-0.4336842895,
0.1105234623,
-0.0615041442,
-0.8706858754,
0.1724558175,
-0.265969187,
1.1901941299,
-0.2446978986,
-0.6604171991,
-0.2704126239,
-0.6787444949,
0.6421222687,
-0.4510053694,
0.1168970838,
0.3199925125,
0.2946035266,
0.2507967651,
-0.7124477625,
-0.5775484443,
-0.0072065741,
-0.2106375247,
0.3458256125,
-0.2619905472,
-0.1061794311,
0.055766996,
-0.0707383975,
-0.5348659158,
0.3752411306,
-0.3287851214,
-0.3644132316,
0.3301756978,
0.2861120701,
0.4823893011,
-0.2236845791,
-0.4449512362,
0.1968945116,
-0.5458461642,
-0.0165178217,
0.6092614532,
0.519553721,
-0.4555492699,
0.1061043441,
-0.3856735229,
0.5879343152,
0.4243728518,
-0.1398766041,
0.3914251626,
-0.7037342787,
-0.0764819756,
0.1125254259,
0.7701174021,
-0.0211216621,
0.1233792529,
-0.3354203701,
0.1163854301,
-0.2050729245,
-0.0616083965,
-1.0754089355,
0.0246855896,
0.0192779489,
-0.2262029499,
-0.380400449,
0.1772740781,
-0.6489702463,
-0.1046377346,
-0.2240638435,
0.4551221728,
-0.609674871,
-0.247063458,
-0.0413779989,
0.1022002622,
0.3637616634,
0.4237951338,
-0.7466357946,
-0.0865960047,
0.4847121239,
0.8589869142,
-0.1335526556,
-0.9031612873,
-0.8505066037,
0.7138615251,
-0.3030602932,
0.8787134886,
-0.4772534668,
-0.3476774096,
0.3464112282,
0.3529384732,
-0.4179104269,
-0.0169354323,
0.4768881202,
-0.4539449513,
0.5871822238,
-0.1409618258,
-0.4442590475,
-0.1467619687,
0.6089113355,
-0.5020114183,
0.5719642043,
0.033613544,
-1.0862444639,
0.250020951,
-0.5146733522,
-0.8578656912,
0.0704944506,
-0.3951460421,
-0.4763796031,
-0.2765471935,
-0.024418423,
0.5197595358,
0.0446438082,
0.4715223312,
-0.5639789701,
-0.3004589081,
-0.108441785,
-0.5933636427,
0.6743203998,
0.0937726274,
-0.2251210362,
0.0726836994,
-0.9969909191,
-0.2192255259,
0.0057524573,
-0.3388302326,
-0.3588422239,
-0.4616525769,
0.2696187794,
0.5864762068,
0.1241004765,
-0.5477099419,
0.086043559,
-0.0781384483,
0.0828551054,
0.4900014102,
0.2647715807,
0.6316581368,
-0.1031561121,
0.454562813,
0.4314929247,
0.0749808028,
-0.2778314352,
-0.321575433,
-0.3324207366,
-0.2520515323,
0.2802866995,
0.7443284392,
-1.2364752293,
0.3078671992,
-0.4277477264,
-0.3027317822,
0.099576436,
-0.1054723561,
0.5046293139,
0.9759297967,
0.2022025138,
-0.254768759,
-0.0977028832,
-0.694370091,
-0.0710743964,
-0.3471667469,
0.0157658402,
0.5493448377,
0.5214837193,
-0.3226180077,
0.4877934754,
-0.4125195146,
-0.4382857382,
-0.2564097941,
0.703738749,
0.0877909735,
0.367606014,
0.768045187,
-0.6906792521,
-0.7278284431,
0.6879919767,
-0.8509956002,
-0.453035444,
-0.3131019473,
-0.168134883,
0.3485646546,
0.6898150444,
-0.1115669683,
0.430976361,
0.4799348116,
-0.6597152352,
0.4529290497,
-0.3970923722,
0.3493643999,
-1.1829611063,
0.4963585138,
0.0982566476,
-0.1200618222,
-0.8345729709,
-0.1517019123,
0.2078746855,
-0.2864820361,
-0.7632899284,
0.7447119355,
-0.4994396269,
0.0733953118,
-0.1865878552,
0.3703691363,
0.1180035695,
0.7840673327,
0.1177528203,
0.4734797776,
0.7142420411,
-0.4822646379,
-0.0821039304,
0.1397392303,
-0.0564198196,
1.1083488464,
-0.4205244184,
-0.1434172541,
-0.1194272265,
0.2849820554,
-0.781255424,
-0.1343480498,
0.364859879,
-0.3773647249,
0.6229372025,
-0.3821907341,
-0.0895394981,
0.1668747663,
-0.1607613862,
0.6413840055,
-0.0959688872,
-0.441133976,
1.0647021532,
0.1860018671,
-0.2193753123,
-0.7690790296,
-0.7269809842,
0.115836665,
-0.0092220707,
-0.6275151372,
0.3998822868,
0.0506958663,
0.2226962745,
0.1873262376,
0.0496753417,
-0.4589470029,
-0.0019497591,
0.2120300829,
0.457660675,
-0.1752475649,
-0.0039158161,
-0.0468330532,
-0.4275483787,
-0.2356954366,
-0.1773137599,
0.4472601414,
0.0259341672,
-0.5052283406,
-0.4605588317,
0.5916760564,
0.4681431949,
-0.0064414809,
0.8383461833,
1.0761146545,
-0.2448786348,
0.2187282443,
-0.2326653451,
0.3157227039,
-0.328813374,
0.5427929163,
-0.7707403898,
-0.7650890946,
0.9202920198,
-0.1064321846,
-0.430314064,
0.5887664557,
0.4586848319,
0.2160978615,
0.5946487784,
0.7337932587,
-0.6092931628,
0.9219458699,
-0.2721699178,
0.1799055934,
-0.6813628674,
-0.1578661054,
-0.6308569312,
-0.1491356492,
-0.4927935302,
-0.3294149637,
0.2550196648,
0.2311276644,
-0.3349717259,
0.2046373636,
0.2067209482,
0.5743589401,
0.123910211,
-0.0162122082,
0.4147512019,
0.0430989042,
-0.2399367243,
0.3968579173,
-0.8282351494,
-0.0224629156,
0.6535457373,
-0.0160080977,
0.6314508319,
0.1504097581,
0.6730821729,
0.0764352456,
0.2492856532,
-0.5199247003,
0.2701584995,
-0.1213047206,
-0.3607123196,
-0.3957161903,
-0.812769711,
-1.1713148355,
0.2426185012,
-0.1680534333,
-0.9362086654,
0.5246796012,
-0.346318543,
0.0054357112,
0.3929451108,
-0.651306808,
1.0230113268,
-0.0391332209,
-0.6471443772,
-0.1499225199,
-0.6704025269,
0.2111653835,
-0.0846644565,
0.3607212305,
0.0650304332,
-0.0009127091,
0.368167311,
-0.1214414686,
1.1070269346,
-0.0576187558,
-0.3415344059,
0.1027126014,
0.0700557604,
0.7520210743,
0.0758105889,
-0.1365375221,
0.5652840734,
-0.182939887,
-0.6583849788,
-0.4252797365,
0.9418551922,
-0.7941997647,
-0.2279284447,
-0.1774776727,
-0.4959349632,
-0.0860066414,
0.4085789025,
0.3508169055,
0.5578244925,
-0.6122103333,
-0.2657348216,
0.4279060364,
-0.227978304,
0.667249918,
1.0474601984,
-0.0912377983,
-0.3492930233,
1.2040659189,
0.1193068251,
0.4086204767,
0.5117246509,
0.0403233282,
0.1426478475,
-0.3617191017,
-0.5965825915,
0.2880600095,
-0.7979459763,
-0.0222048648,
-0.7598596215,
-0.2304714322,
-0.2755123675,
-0.5326281786,
-0.1404760033,
-0.2361796349,
-0.413592726,
-0.109152846,
-0.1827376038,
0.2111067325,
-0.3125827909,
0.0372768268,
-0.7398378253,
0.3184507489,
0.1592709124,
0.4165849984,
-0.0256399494,
-0.6794615984,
-0.4450081587,
-0.3237015605,
-0.1030526459,
-0.6778966784,
0.1905627996,
0.2666089237,
0.6360487938,
0.6813060641,
-0.1477043778,
0.6564928889,
-0.5883157849,
0.5563579798,
0.5670648813,
-0.9246356487,
0.2750211954,
-0.4111062884,
0.3710727096,
0.5758756399,
0.5627261996,
-0.7536422014,
-0.3573419154,
-0.7282209396,
-0.8395521045,
0.8836156726,
0.0387274325,
0.041096665,
-0.0819962174,
0.2049249709,
0.0437741317,
-0.0550444983,
-0.8716737032,
-0.124930799,
0.0160330199,
-0.0760229677,
-0.050081294,
0.0197820272,
-0.1449587494,
-0.013472761,
0.8141368628,
-0.6149348617,
0.1197391972,
0.2578849196,
-0.2216374576,
-0.3943231106,
0.3292779028,
0.5271024108,
0.5590602756,
-0.0268707387,
0.2416526079,
0.2094635963,
-0.373128444,
0.004196736,
0.5261223912,
-0.2942846715,
-0.0392241143,
0.8354488015,
0.9649131894,
0.3104866743,
-0.2061227411,
0.7514308691,
-0.0079741422,
-0.3157908022,
0.2295227498,
-0.3133041263,
-0.0714422166,
0.171519354,
0.0962162018,
-0.3393437564,
0.1382744312,
-0.8910856247,
0.1735740453,
0.4055072963,
-0.7512395382,
-0.4851019382,
0.4309943616,
0.4437297285,
-0.0964547843,
0.212316975,
-0.2500387132,
-0.5035415292,
0.7552827597,
0.5046703815,
0.8555613756,
-0.1861549616,
0.6194812059,
0.5418906212,
0.1699691117,
0.3469029069,
0.1169925109,
-0.0609023049,
-0.9474285841,
-0.4986518621,
-0.2954835892,
-0.4015245736,
0.0403129272,
-0.481790781,
0.2926315367,
0.0133142555,
0.3041706979,
0.2674494088,
0.195317477,
-0.637270987,
-0.0030982667,
0.2751084864,
0.4373004436,
-1.2777768373,
1.0288381577,
0.5111026764,
-0.9055389166,
-0.7614209056,
0.0618344322,
-0.1088422537,
-0.6791321039,
0.505611062,
-0.0557016023,
-0.0444694534,
-0.1681457907,
-0.1974014044,
-0.6183749437,
1.1579859257,
0.4068900943,
-0.4947719276,
0.1853108555,
0.2427558303,
0.6187105179,
-0.5117670894,
0.440625757,
0.2038727254,
0.5732195973,
0.3286076486,
-0.7564665079,
0.045783326,
-0.1791451573,
-0.1111154258,
0.313791424,
-0.6122127771,
0.8003740907,
-0.1339637339,
-0.3698470592,
-0.2564349771,
0.5230167508,
-0.1713520736,
0.7666813731,
0.2298403531,
0.520749867,
0.8087426424,
0.1438645124,
1.3019113541,
-0.6201756597,
0.5225255489,
1.1930155754,
-0.5709644556,
0.5588555336,
0.4922977388,
0.1324370503,
0.7185078859,
0.2579161227,
0.2100963891,
0.5692403913,
-0.1060050726,
-0.4085777402,
-0.12749888,
-0.2474891543,
-0.2545647025,
0.0120825684,
0.0384282619,
-0.1477160454,
-0.6135861278,
0.0657359734,
0.0771084353,
-0.2142422944,
-0.3271928728,
0.88539505,
-0.1455675215,
-0.2764790952,
0.4531542063,
0.0016790637,
0.4997815192,
-0.7696427107,
0.071019873,
-0.3612348139,
0.0509266183,
-0.1946481317,
-0.7533665895,
0.3110495806,
-0.2586366534,
-0.4299602211,
0.1593753397,
1.0408138037,
-0.8396129012,
-0.5465435982,
0.6117708683,
0.7833638787,
0.036905963,
0.1481374651,
-0.6062531471,
-0.2226793617,
-0.132377103,
-0.1875408143,
0.7877081037,
1.0786231756,
-0.2233906239,
0.3354439139,
0.5344130397,
-0.0345537439,
-0.2410338074,
0.4496802092,
0.7278137207,
-0.5987941623,
-0.6212404966,
-0.5778429508,
0.3053285778,
-0.1977689266,
-0.3690019548,
0.4849019945,
0.4639753699,
0.8889942169,
0.0123167634,
0.7503622174,
-0.0668629259,
-0.1252249032,
-0.4252649844,
0.6374382377,
-0.4229639471,
0.048875466,
-0.4542044997,
-0.5475329161,
-0.3897411525,
0.1806311756,
-0.4323328733,
-0.1246515363,
0.9696554542,
0.6798285842,
-0.3932695687,
-0.3276247084,
0.7845769525,
0.1580480337,
0.2772323191,
0.8404538035,
0.5546910167,
-0.4542072117,
0.7737153769,
-0.1050406322,
-0.2708882987,
-0.1468640864,
-1.1106054783,
-0.7992113829,
-0.5429920554,
-0.7088756561,
-0.1336063743,
0.0586471148,
0.2043769509,
0.5277348757,
-0.760456562,
0.0258406177,
-0.0586086027,
0.3367033601,
-0.218509838,
-0.2928296626,
0.5530657172,
-0.5355235934,
-0.6835441589,
0.1737353802,
0.5215493441,
-0.0586385317,
0.0564764142,
-0.1302254945,
-0.501575768,
0.2932178676,
0.5932716131,
0.532569766,
-0.2906646729,
-0.623981297,
-0.4819644392,
-0.3881209493,
0.1751837283,
0.8729831576,
-0.5108215213,
0.270672828,
0.4473487437,
0.7375122309,
0.5505878925,
-0.2412706465,
0.2824987471,
-0.8760696054,
0.4085285068,
-0.2398861349,
0.6242394447,
0.1868695319,
-0.5011092424,
0.6874628067,
0.5649860501,
-0.3200019598,
-0.3594801724,
0.3251404166,
-1.173161149,
-0.4864353836,
1.2219727039,
-0.4287032187,
-0.3489893973,
-0.2070418745,
-0.1648185551,
0.4040769935,
-0.126834318,
0.8081357479,
0.6627616286,
0.0435985774,
0.0572636276,
-0.0979703888,
-0.0384452268,
0.0934103802,
-1.1391862631,
-0.1507626325,
0.6562657952,
0.327848196,
0.4331359863,
0.7249733806,
-0.1922944635,
0.2622677386,
0.0993114561,
0.2682785392,
-0.179560259,
-0.4755392671,
-0.5206059813,
0.4372638166,
-0.5070376396,
-0.1067848653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02889v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02889v2
|
In Search of Truth: An Interrogation Approach to Hallucination Detection
| 2024-03-05T11:50:01 | 2024-03-20T09:53:17 |
Yakir Yehuda, Itzik Malkiel, Oren Barkan, Jonathan Weill, Royi Ronen, Noam Koenigstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the many advances of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
unprecedented rapid evolution, their impact and integration into every facet of
our daily lives is limited due to various reasons. One critical factor
hindering their widespread adoption is the occurrence of hallucinations, where
LLMs invent answers that sound realistic, yet drift away from factual truth. In
this paper, we present a novel method for detecting hallucinations in large
language models, which tackles a critical issue in the adoption of these models
in various real-world scenarios. Through extensive evaluations across multiple
datasets and LLMs, including Llama-2, we study the hallucination levels of
various recent LLMs and demonstrate the effectiveness of our method to
automatically detect them. Notably, we observe up to 62% hallucinations for
Llama-2 in a specific experiment, where our method achieves a Balanced Accuracy
(B-ACC) of 87%, all without relying on external knowledge.
|
[
-0.3061648607,
-0.9790604711,
1.1192525625,
0.1395174414,
-0.2885369062,
0.1602416933,
-0.2438462079,
-0.4928287268,
0.3754584193,
0.5196679831,
-0.6203134656,
-0.705114007,
-0.7755067945,
0.1892765164,
-0.4639931619,
0.3107748926,
-0.0176862683,
0.0277067292,
-0.0754306316,
0.06289161,
-0.5359827876,
-0.5479061007,
-0.0193933528,
-0.3051179945,
0.3471482396,
0.3426715434,
0.6387836933,
0.566663146,
0.4764941633,
0.1963520795,
-0.1288598776,
0.7398548722,
-0.6509295106,
0.2631833553,
-0.0365755782,
-0.6037943959,
0.0497967675,
0.0806488097,
0.4263101816,
0.4638924897,
-0.4160227478,
-0.0163603537,
-0.2817118764,
0.4322797954,
-0.6047972441,
-0.1074841395,
-1.0055180788,
0.3285698295,
-0.0233017895,
-0.3058965504,
-0.6082203388,
-0.5827841163,
0.0092345886,
-0.4448958933,
0.1586765796,
0.1658433527,
0.7055324316,
0.6847698092,
-0.1947435886,
-0.8184737563,
-0.6227746606,
0.847407639,
-0.6818463802,
0.5832371712,
0.3372884393,
0.4196009934,
-0.421628952,
-0.5725897551,
-1.0448114872,
-0.53833884,
-0.1943942904,
-0.3343240023,
-0.2366638333,
-0.2246038765,
0.3270999789,
0.0769872442,
-0.6796185374,
0.026820356,
-0.0902455226,
-0.3606651723,
0.3775515854,
0.1410133541,
0.1654688418,
-0.2277344614,
-0.0947290063,
0.1523027867,
-0.4869019687,
-0.4617606103,
0.3264315128,
0.1349261552,
0.1017800942,
0.5668596029,
-0.0445009395,
0.4590821564,
0.0272749923,
-0.4302458465,
0.372453481,
0.0600005835,
-0.0567683503,
0.3789562285,
0.5027893186,
0.3313556015,
0.0748601332,
-0.2673072517,
-0.3857783675,
0.3404310048,
0.4465288222,
-0.927942276,
-0.1288446933,
0.3318178356,
-0.493085891,
-0.4632487595,
-0.20999071,
-0.9506659508,
-1.0620735884,
-0.2055445015,
0.5795619488,
-0.2718119919,
-0.329470098,
0.4480788112,
0.0662252232,
0.5524013042,
0.206164971,
-0.7032787204,
0.2876265943,
0.7412028909,
1.1158661842,
-0.3698361516,
0.0108722318,
-0.7685766816,
-0.1824070364,
-0.5898541808,
1.023395896,
-0.6079356074,
-0.2799122334,
-0.0252553802,
0.0294991937,
0.2955037355,
-0.955953598,
0.6926852465,
-0.4593515992,
-0.0829317793,
-0.2894954979,
-0.5053330064,
-0.530382514,
0.4637132883,
-0.4971396923,
0.9535291195,
-0.1499913037,
-0.4592721164,
0.1500841081,
-0.5091996193,
-0.2118030787,
-0.1194004416,
-0.4301072359,
-0.4548882246,
0.3553130627,
0.3449647129,
0.3606093824,
-0.1770402789,
0.4911903143,
-0.2635596693,
-0.8246737719,
0.4405450225,
-0.5340169072,
0.6288930178,
0.0555298403,
-0.714861095,
-0.1493631452,
-0.6725627184,
-0.2697251439,
0.4257966578,
0.2549427748,
-0.2016242445,
0.1406459063,
-0.2684769332,
-0.0172737855,
0.2673378289,
-0.5541836619,
0.1285726875,
-0.400128305,
-0.0365401432,
0.6700729728,
0.052863203,
-0.2043093145,
-0.1402288526,
0.323146373,
0.0435625501,
0.1985857636,
0.1607063562,
-0.4721259475,
-0.8183577061,
-0.2141155005,
-0.0787359104,
0.4744484425,
-0.3619140685,
0.8572856188,
-0.1164345592,
-0.4977810979,
-0.7058663964,
0.031870421,
0.1459029615,
0.582395494,
0.4477896392,
0.1652903855,
-0.6895128489,
-0.8964259624,
-0.188636899,
-0.1938074082,
0.0384255648,
0.2699567974,
0.7041684985,
-0.6704308391,
0.7998282909,
-0.6132903099,
-0.3025752604,
-0.1439722031,
0.2111631036,
0.2545173466,
0.1417787075,
0.3680895865,
-0.8606214523,
-0.0676787123,
-0.115058735,
-1.3221281767,
-0.2959676683,
-0.0307585914,
0.0256849676,
0.1848267317,
0.3577504754,
-0.3748140037,
0.5382638574,
0.6117020249,
-0.1593098193,
0.4911496043,
0.0299548432,
0.1494293362,
-0.5701851845,
0.0060119471,
-0.2377385497,
-0.0593146086,
-0.6648257375,
0.1152539477,
0.0597797446,
0.3912044466,
-0.2208273262,
0.3329770863,
-0.2451445609,
-0.1327096373,
-0.4570295215,
0.4461174607,
-0.0761933699,
0.3782289922,
0.2687493563,
0.7453246117,
0.4299650788,
-0.3900381029,
0.5636872053,
0.2915584743,
-0.7212589383,
0.3102281094,
-0.3877006769,
0.6641617417,
-0.322075367,
0.2657414675,
-1.0829360485,
-0.2869063914,
0.4655923843,
-0.3816266656,
-0.1008761376,
0.028854508,
-0.6965250969,
-0.1748585105,
-0.313334018,
0.2607291043,
0.529491961,
-1.0017318726,
0.7377325892,
0.4936911762,
0.2006600052,
-0.7076212168,
-0.5578475595,
0.4268710911,
-0.2349536568,
-0.4645284414,
-0.0152477706,
-0.3252573013,
-0.6203361154,
-0.3784620166,
-0.3574764132,
0.0833766833,
0.132247597,
0.3502821326,
0.226603359,
-0.090291217,
0.0115643358,
0.0882103816,
-0.0128402086,
0.2262498736,
-0.1553285122,
0.8464047313,
-0.1671774089,
-0.4816916883,
-0.7193648219,
0.1758335233,
0.6179888844,
0.0026822886,
0.7064107656,
0.5078527927,
-0.7519664168,
-0.3177353442,
-1.1702553034,
-0.3955779672,
-0.5191274285,
0.4532203972,
-0.3533814847,
-0.5300194025,
0.5037605166,
-0.18975465,
-0.2010491192,
0.0150939217,
0.6802052855,
0.2679121494,
1.3403841257,
0.4249097705,
0.0765318274,
-0.0052908044,
-0.1540068537,
0.6545029283,
-0.699303925,
-0.7627435923,
-0.4302328825,
-0.2610293329,
-0.4141234756,
-0.5183016062,
0.5325467587,
-0.1434402168,
0.1512485743,
-0.0061249994,
-0.6931778789,
0.7599622011,
-0.037025176,
0.2958504856,
0.5665581226,
0.050796479,
0.0171757229,
-0.2104205489,
-0.1164846569,
-0.6502769589,
1.0011928082,
0.3736065328,
0.6453015804,
0.1935259849,
0.5984393358,
0.4823734164,
0.3007400334,
-1.0682142973,
0.6258378029,
0.182558164,
-0.3873510957,
-0.398848027,
-0.3368320465,
-0.4351633787,
0.3587867916,
-0.0276970752,
-0.7650208473,
0.2859719098,
-0.3019368351,
-0.4564166963,
0.309512943,
-0.2687891722,
0.516212225,
-0.4869728684,
-0.1566753983,
-0.4654386342,
-0.4086193144,
0.5939183235,
-0.3875745535,
0.2517488599,
-0.3075710535,
-0.1170677245,
0.7757264376,
-0.0613199472,
0.6671643257,
-0.2842872143,
-0.5085216165,
0.1620023847,
0.4321948588,
0.8750250936,
0.1409621984,
-0.2607088387,
0.3236023188,
-0.3510472775,
-0.0451450311,
-0.9263567328,
0.6688238382,
-0.4760372043,
-0.7780975699,
-0.4772647023,
-0.6184080839,
-0.162661761,
-0.1104803756,
0.0847597495,
0.0357500613,
-0.1404246241,
0.0002557401,
1.0345373154,
-0.3151746988,
0.0988608152,
0.6178311706,
-0.5164247751,
-0.1865641624,
0.7828944325,
-0.0196223389,
-0.1428017318,
0.030449992,
0.386960566,
-0.6292058825,
-0.7396005988,
-0.2252171636,
0.5987477303,
-0.8666137457,
-0.0142237311,
-0.9614156485,
-0.1738253385,
-0.3330183625,
0.0073983115,
-0.3254513741,
0.1113763079,
-0.2445513457,
-0.2955111563,
0.3565832973,
0.827268362,
-0.0884334818,
0.2129557431,
-0.3421806693,
0.810231626,
0.4354611337,
0.1911348403,
-0.1679631025,
-1.0136295557,
0.1118173972,
0.067333445,
-0.1107824966,
-1.0038325787,
0.5147474408,
-0.1536237597,
0.4883144498,
0.6273237467,
0.1089433953,
0.7227358222,
-0.1496830434,
0.6262173653,
-0.1586547047,
-1.1049375534,
0.4602658153,
0.1645929366,
-0.2629317641,
0.4434718192,
0.5415812731,
-0.636651814,
-0.3236856759,
-0.1899969429,
-0.2457129508,
0.458863467,
0.1932849139,
0.0728724897,
0.1340398788,
0.512300849,
0.3022172451,
0.3435799778,
-0.7680573463,
-0.1849349439,
0.0274299197,
-0.1802607328,
0.2134085149,
-0.3921040297,
-0.1173599958,
-0.3941896558,
0.5754588842,
-0.0512815341,
0.1525072753,
0.1530613154,
-0.2797933221,
-0.1968789548,
-0.2058253139,
0.6989436746,
0.7270101905,
-0.3651614189,
0.4029146135,
0.4293254912,
-0.5135494471,
0.2595923543,
-0.3415807784,
-0.125704214,
0.3617379367,
0.3039439023,
0.7218186855,
-0.0751001313,
-1.1314759254,
0.6738223433,
0.0045712637,
-0.2103562504,
-0.5795021057,
-0.0621551462,
-0.190914467,
0.4450980723,
0.4693087041,
-0.2011162937,
0.392627418,
-0.6838403344,
0.2947616875,
0.4794997871,
-0.3985509872,
-0.1954030246,
0.4262024164,
-0.2564162016,
-0.4157936275,
0.7265238762,
-0.5297601819,
-0.9545277357,
0.4481254816,
0.5497589707,
0.9613386989,
-0.3715878129,
0.3006629348,
0.2037045062,
0.4426831305,
-0.3182591498,
0.2856166661,
0.2166994512,
-0.9000732899,
-0.3088002801,
-0.7120954394,
-0.3949377537,
0.5777363777,
-0.392937243,
0.3951020539,
-0.2997668386,
0.1585266441,
-0.1717764437,
-0.0426532067,
-0.1324959695,
-0.050241448,
0.573166132,
0.5681238174,
-0.7208310962,
0.6515683532,
-0.1044916883,
0.0196409449,
-0.3943076134,
0.3607746363,
0.1982243955,
-1.0140318871,
0.5343109965,
0.6146857738,
-0.5395144224,
-0.1194060072,
-0.9122979641,
-0.6207488179,
0.8917348981,
0.5438704491,
-0.5910323262,
-0.0527583994,
0.1237042695,
0.4801775813,
-0.4275943041,
0.1367425174,
1.2557291985,
0.8608865142,
0.2526837587,
-0.5542195439,
0.1749108434,
-0.0066538411,
-0.3995738328,
-0.0036320533,
-0.463568747,
0.576225996,
-0.4009447992,
-0.2621924579,
0.0465640761,
0.7010097504,
0.5813949108,
0.4123660624,
0.7916144133,
0.2370079756,
1.2387185097,
0.0926042199,
0.4253711104,
-0.2039858848,
0.2211574912,
0.8675591946,
-0.6635395885,
0.6145932078,
0.5291711688,
0.1859893799,
0.5970279574,
0.4789484143,
-0.2519888878,
0.5829074979,
0.5694268942,
-0.3348476887,
-0.5388357043,
-0.3948206007,
-0.2075042725,
0.5195922256,
0.6043442488,
0.0181924403,
0.0465294458,
0.1940730661,
0.1261527985,
0.2511470914,
0.100910604,
0.6275682449,
-0.0771071166,
-0.5991541147,
0.9923844934,
-0.2364429384,
0.7930963635,
-0.3363023996,
-0.4640823901,
-0.3867602348,
0.0052216924,
-0.1955067664,
-0.5042252541,
0.2066817731,
0.253708899,
0.2080784887,
0.2334623337,
0.3524165452,
-0.336678803,
-0.5671513081,
0.6614099145,
0.3918188512,
0.5120304823,
-0.4688590467,
-0.1621730477,
0.534561038,
0.0902561545,
-0.064763464,
-0.1439900994,
0.4929617345,
0.0939945281,
0.8035622835,
0.4631725252,
0.1090563089,
0.1199417487,
-0.0792713985,
0.7050228715,
-0.5230196714,
-0.2456964552,
-0.996011436,
0.017078381,
-0.1638432145,
-0.0448423736,
0.5657418966,
0.6927124262,
0.6152334809,
0.1158431694,
0.9084900618,
0.1911857277,
0.5747317076,
-0.5615147352,
0.6683973074,
-0.6670934558,
0.5248122215,
-0.063517563,
-0.8623376489,
-0.3868714571,
0.9968715906,
-0.2914843261,
-0.357529372,
0.8438323736,
1.4302462339,
-0.0072527141,
0.2461297959,
0.5023872256,
0.5770943165,
0.3012913764,
0.3295268416,
1.235255003,
-0.3396641612,
0.4540480375,
-0.1599578559,
-0.266833216,
-0.4238140583,
-0.6984707713,
-0.994204402,
-0.5204527974,
-0.1009930372,
-0.3696765006,
0.1305644661,
1.045882225,
0.4363403916,
-0.9602066875,
-0.309260577,
0.1682832241,
0.2681958973,
-0.1894866824,
-0.133764416,
0.3647744358,
-0.2112067044,
-0.6768336296,
0.8693385124,
0.2540384829,
-0.0149506321,
-0.5751745105,
-0.2866977751,
-0.0792891756,
0.3822277486,
0.3803243637,
-0.235236004,
-1.0516661406,
-0.4506653845,
0.1707360893,
-0.0678424984,
0.2074120641,
0.7627280951,
-0.9311596751,
0.4274751246,
0.2569007277,
0.508415401,
0.4312619865,
-0.184705019,
0.1514608413,
-0.3956741989,
0.275559932,
0.3983691633,
0.1050542518,
0.3179754317,
-0.5237004161,
0.5885806084,
0.4747794867,
-0.3687432706,
-1.4366385937,
0.0115239955,
-0.941023767,
-0.269590646,
1.0835754871,
0.324206382,
-0.0932091773,
-0.3946903348,
-0.3891236484,
0.2831962407,
-0.2581037283,
1.4730068445,
0.5609315038,
0.0189419929,
0.0608429126,
-0.6317051649,
0.4719446599,
0.209559232,
-0.8260651827,
0.3813229203,
0.4445488453,
-0.0899842605,
0.3900808096,
0.1058057845,
0.1186602265,
0.1118803322,
-0.0798972398,
0.1207571551,
0.0696356967,
-0.6905492544,
-0.3686177731,
0.1898168027,
-0.173023954,
-0.0043650856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02884v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02884v1
|
MathScale: Scaling Instruction Tuning for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-03-05T11:42:59 | 2024-03-05T11:42:59 |
Zhengyang Tang, Xingxing Zhang, Benyou Wang, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
problem-solving. However, their proficiency in solving mathematical problems
remains inadequate. We propose MathScale, a simple and scalable method to
create high-quality mathematical reasoning data using frontier LLMs (e.g., {\tt
GPT-3.5}). Inspired by the cognitive mechanism in human mathematical learning,
it first extracts topics and knowledge points from seed math questions and then
build a concept graph, which is subsequently used to generate new math
questions. MathScale exhibits effective scalability along the size axis of the
math dataset that we generate. As a result, we create a mathematical reasoning
dataset (MathScaleQA) containing two million math question-answer pairs. To
evaluate mathematical reasoning abilities of LLMs comprehensively, we construct
{\sc MwpBench}, a benchmark of Math Word Problems, which is a collection of ten
datasets (including GSM8K and MATH) covering K-12, college, and competition
level math problems. We apply MathScaleQA to fine-tune open-source LLMs (e.g.,
LLaMA-2 and Mistral), resulting in significantly improved capabilities in
mathematical reasoning. Evaluated on {\sc MwpBench}, MathScale-7B achieves
state-of-the-art performance across all datasets, surpassing its best peers of
equivalent size by 42.9\% in micro average accuracy and 43.7\% in macro average
accuracy, respectively.
|
[
-0.5361249447,
-0.9282017946,
0.6110600233,
0.3972003758,
-0.0023218354,
0.0811946839,
-0.3271530867,
0.1785543412,
-0.1008826718,
0.444234103,
-0.8526134491,
-0.5206977725,
-0.4217654169,
-0.1721680462,
0.0057832086,
0.8776582479,
0.0987091959,
0.1354630291,
-0.6381189227,
-0.2269181758,
-0.3358565569,
-0.3259777427,
-0.9229996204,
-0.3698799014,
0.2724997699,
0.5854641795,
0.9675396681,
0.9194734693,
0.6227658987,
0.3607441485,
-0.1439929903,
0.4134115279,
-0.5537279844,
-0.1323000491,
-0.3733001649,
-0.6526916027,
-0.869291842,
0.0040518525,
0.5999506116,
0.8721982241,
-0.2860894501,
0.4239265323,
-0.0439501517,
0.6849504709,
-0.2989960909,
0.1973837465,
-0.6882260442,
-0.1017102972,
-0.2274847329,
-0.0670823753,
-0.2996504307,
-0.7419373393,
-0.2701579034,
-0.9299242496,
0.1660124063,
0.0449321419,
0.6236765981,
0.4168335795,
-0.322745949,
-0.3343881071,
-0.355612576,
1.0167082548,
-0.7463232279,
0.235901922,
0.4826773405,
0.6110917926,
-0.1993528306,
-0.7767874599,
-0.2872152925,
0.0368643142,
0.2277158201,
-0.1563131511,
-0.3045988083,
-0.1026132703,
0.7362315655,
0.5853769779,
-0.5552113056,
0.0660073385,
-0.1508603394,
-0.3898691535,
0.5676349998,
0.4858853817,
0.1656833142,
0.1719249785,
0.2135749906,
-0.2563324273,
-0.7871050239,
-0.0838555023,
0.1384039372,
0.1772722006,
0.1327583343,
0.6880164146,
-0.175327599,
0.785635829,
0.0077010416,
-0.5008163452,
0.0928465948,
-0.2476878315,
-0.1454971284,
-0.3277003467,
0.4477618933,
0.3078424931,
0.4474396408,
0.222760886,
-0.2716286182,
0.0900981873,
0.0653726682,
-0.9255976081,
-0.397934556,
-0.0104366476,
-0.0052918708,
-0.0710595548,
-0.3810561299,
-0.8558059335,
-0.3348686099,
-0.6470740438,
0.6906574368,
-0.4294670224,
0.0688156411,
-0.02189501,
0.0138763469,
-0.07858935,
0.4067293406,
-0.8030595779,
0.4335865974,
0.6739959121,
0.7442191839,
-0.0287948195,
-0.1278084069,
-0.5504119992,
-0.2071628273,
-0.5345734358,
0.7453763485,
-0.4708595276,
-0.3335220516,
-0.1531572193,
-0.2853048146,
0.1389180869,
-0.824782908,
0.5948602557,
-0.3215024769,
-0.0333712734,
-0.4958437681,
-0.6050162911,
0.0782566294,
0.295049727,
-0.556871295,
1.1480962038,
0.3226062953,
-0.3543943763,
0.1700635105,
-0.6537585258,
-0.2587209344,
0.0803185031,
-0.1778763831,
-0.4435442984,
0.1188424677,
0.7236633301,
0.1334048212,
-0.585262239,
0.101369895,
-0.219937399,
-0.2049316615,
0.3058603108,
-0.4668721557,
0.6002992988,
0.2083813995,
-0.2097623944,
0.0823126137,
-0.6661823392,
0.5547529459,
0.2004465312,
-0.0322969966,
-0.0527037419,
-0.0221696924,
-0.424038142,
0.0003382551,
0.4334089756,
-0.53723979,
0.20108217,
-0.1513739079,
0.7069665194,
0.7801815867,
-0.1300295442,
0.4923664331,
-0.5350984931,
0.5456914902,
-0.3034099936,
0.1271969378,
-0.0125844805,
-0.4316869974,
-0.8515979052,
-0.3957277834,
0.2252728343,
0.5269306302,
-0.8017129302,
0.1794216782,
-0.3475696743,
-0.5692048669,
-0.1786289364,
0.2451763153,
0.3730836511,
0.5759637356,
0.4357147813,
0.4862940311,
-0.1960519254,
-0.9426103234,
-0.316631943,
0.2927053273,
-0.4348962605,
0.5771868825,
0.3205747604,
0.0302981865,
1.0472854376,
-0.9896045327,
-0.2489759177,
-0.0831196457,
0.0900490135,
0.3709631562,
0.2624389231,
0.3030239344,
-0.4868187308,
-0.3465973735,
-0.0216673985,
-0.4934354722,
-0.5997105837,
0.0364624187,
-0.368187815,
-0.1147892028,
0.5368674994,
-0.2917510867,
0.1143808588,
0.5073120594,
-0.3925358355,
0.4636686742,
-0.2917536199,
0.0718505904,
-1.0170063972,
-0.3610941768,
0.1409105062,
0.0188383553,
-0.1937380135,
0.048094213,
0.2568607032,
-0.3022987843,
-0.0487945303,
0.4894683659,
-0.1608757675,
-0.0684372708,
-0.043163456,
0.3120892346,
-0.0705741346,
0.4660617709,
-0.2573386431,
1.2070121765,
0.2944802344,
-0.4758832753,
0.3419374824,
-0.0382022038,
-0.1993249655,
0.8804011345,
-0.6996724606,
-0.0054141553,
0.2187771052,
0.1759496778,
-0.7837333083,
-0.201654911,
-0.3597978652,
-0.5543634295,
-0.0357676856,
-0.0979736671,
-0.5561739802,
-0.3112098575,
-0.1387866139,
0.6023210287,
0.5990784168,
-0.6526887417,
0.6856901646,
0.3279977441,
-0.4176205695,
-0.2179893553,
-0.5679930449,
-0.1483462304,
-0.1381039619,
-0.7460517287,
-0.0733389482,
-0.1820431352,
-0.3497436345,
-0.0036172229,
-0.3534843922,
-0.3470805585,
-0.184352845,
0.1191882938,
0.4343696833,
-0.4454575777,
0.2873493731,
0.5059625506,
-0.1695338637,
0.3291766644,
-0.4642596543,
0.3143405616,
-0.4943776131,
-0.3112032712,
0.1804927886,
0.0906732231,
0.7089697719,
-0.3750966191,
0.293127805,
0.3661575019,
-0.4561728239,
-0.6759556532,
-0.4240175486,
-0.1677763313,
-0.5293900967,
0.3251707554,
-0.5165801048,
-1.1146776676,
0.3010961115,
-0.5242651105,
0.2589858174,
0.5440803766,
0.6872054935,
0.1330311596,
1.0357570648,
0.2417755127,
0.1354682297,
0.1607030779,
-0.3526103795,
0.0621525608,
-0.778008163,
-0.0649538338,
-0.4281579256,
-0.3132648468,
-0.4024241269,
-0.8230215907,
0.6633222103,
0.1069452837,
-0.5517356396,
0.2688878477,
-0.6793169379,
0.9148015976,
0.4558569193,
0.160727948,
0.2391025275,
0.2322980016,
-0.3557776213,
-0.5338341594,
-0.6936135888,
-0.2822709084,
1.2627910376,
0.0723982602,
0.7828302383,
0.1680345088,
0.3900577724,
0.0751243532,
0.2879969478,
-0.8207310438,
0.6351969242,
-0.1957104057,
-0.5209192634,
-0.5759584308,
-0.9234340787,
-0.7879635096,
0.3099730015,
-0.134136647,
-0.6575492024,
-0.4432142973,
0.186162442,
-0.1836755425,
0.3349831998,
-0.6559948921,
0.7283394933,
-0.1063586324,
-0.4449183643,
-0.3572520018,
-0.0150124915,
0.4439465404,
-0.1869419068,
0.5200051665,
-0.2168777883,
-0.1282247156,
0.5860318542,
-0.7922745347,
0.5366538167,
0.0572769493,
-0.1766425371,
0.3049871922,
0.5472778678,
0.2386811078,
0.3407852948,
0.0852869749,
0.2089967132,
0.1170907393,
-0.4966747761,
-0.9249134064,
0.91444242,
-0.7747429609,
-0.5836638212,
-0.2050010711,
-1.1951204538,
-0.63704741,
0.1025246829,
0.0664626434,
0.8230520487,
0.2679436803,
0.1680577248,
1.0209139585,
-0.0004745609,
0.215330109,
0.3005681038,
-0.1941437423,
-0.8577932119,
1.1861181259,
0.2422395349,
0.352866441,
0.3336995542,
0.4872108102,
-0.4256805182,
-0.235956952,
-0.6083300114,
0.3579675257,
-0.7069779634,
-0.4918632209,
-0.0357458405,
-0.3451322317,
-0.1393843591,
-0.4639054835,
-0.3614379168,
-0.6657266617,
0.0873796642,
0.2874025702,
0.5921132565,
0.468541652,
-0.0613844842,
0.3345252573,
-0.585272789,
0.2995729744,
0.5751411915,
0.3804547191,
-0.1773397177,
-0.8073003888,
-0.0746638402,
0.1500616372,
-0.3150930107,
-0.1506500542,
0.1849829555,
0.1485980898,
0.3674284816,
0.2308721542,
-0.1236760095,
0.7667864561,
-0.604883194,
0.5135840774,
0.0326327756,
-1.1690740585,
0.6957213283,
-0.3654138744,
0.6235551238,
0.2746214569,
0.228229627,
-0.1941949725,
-0.2518922389,
-0.565987885,
-0.3842507601,
0.5356727242,
0.2903958559,
-0.1265241355,
0.142853573,
0.4769797623,
-0.1152410284,
-0.0341078267,
-0.2907373905,
-0.0211269986,
-0.0394457653,
-0.5005571842,
-0.1359399557,
-0.1045518219,
-0.3694091737,
-0.4703287482,
0.3957220316,
-0.4603894949,
0.0341092534,
-0.141215831,
0.0821256638,
-0.0214686431,
0.229812026,
0.6981168985,
1.0877614021,
0.0778563917,
0.0919554979,
0.5013002753,
-0.8242204189,
0.0565369427,
-0.0401844084,
0.0237812139,
-0.3279210031,
0.4182432294,
0.36168015,
0.2386118025,
-0.7669866085,
0.4053624868,
-0.0200210642,
-0.6071435809,
-0.1058540791,
0.1180073023,
0.2407046407,
0.2458213717,
0.2086327225,
-0.1415770799,
-0.0900202021,
-0.1632166803,
0.1701607108,
0.3747680485,
0.03640946,
0.0977419466,
0.6273128986,
-0.0322902575,
-0.3572157621,
0.8587059975,
-0.1371844709,
-0.3847470582,
0.8054002523,
0.7456031442,
0.3197336495,
-0.0824785754,
0.1384773552,
0.7306751013,
0.5218874812,
0.0063925791,
0.3128406405,
-0.1847306341,
-0.6358503699,
-0.7140039802,
-0.7235829234,
-0.6600871682,
-0.0329788886,
-0.7104420066,
0.0145721063,
-0.8286773562,
-0.0979795456,
-0.0232153405,
0.2867915332,
-0.3310079277,
0.2898617089,
-0.0976474583,
1.0343192816,
-0.727792263,
0.6786685586,
0.6611905098,
-0.0367550328,
-1.0295259953,
-0.4124008715,
0.2874834836,
-1.0338616371,
0.3860500157,
-0.2074242979,
-0.0277306344,
0.2138669789,
-0.5262188911,
-1.0020797253,
1.2743891478,
0.4787510335,
-0.6147141457,
0.2776862085,
0.3445157409,
0.4175825119,
-0.2591620088,
0.2882980704,
0.7354191542,
0.3120083809,
0.6342182755,
-0.8742682934,
0.0807725489,
-0.0793483779,
0.1494551301,
0.6018123627,
-0.4251126349,
1.0729517937,
-0.2562749684,
0.2105695307,
-0.0617066659,
0.502471745,
0.6625894308,
0.3796697855,
0.4820422232,
1.1219359636,
0.8982135653,
-0.4539426267,
0.7016305923,
-0.0332021527,
0.3056027889,
1.0526576042,
0.2041403651,
0.7477591038,
0.1301842034,
-0.5190432668,
0.3908510506,
0.5652067065,
0.0283303428,
-0.0294442624,
0.5282394886,
-0.2528621256,
-0.6293566227,
0.1418695003,
-0.2010670304,
0.1044589207,
0.7671977282,
0.1405423582,
-0.5201203823,
-0.2258363664,
0.2881790698,
0.3964463472,
-0.7863462567,
0.3109290004,
0.1305607557,
-0.4466406107,
0.5784662366,
-0.1615259796,
0.1603139341,
-0.6539027691,
-0.2611503303,
-0.5901998281,
0.4582177401,
-0.2382449806,
-0.8204063773,
0.2486319989,
-0.0153451907,
-0.1053737625,
0.06812457,
0.2420333773,
-0.269166559,
-0.8439759612,
-0.3744689226,
0.5682777166,
0.1244448051,
-0.1853739917,
-0.6285032034,
0.2096117437,
-0.1071894914,
0.1975054741,
0.5254113078,
0.9497981071,
-0.3535926044,
0.9042254686,
0.8308126926,
0.1217340156,
0.0650980324,
0.0990277231,
1.0198557377,
-0.4731904566,
-0.2090118378,
-0.6540300846,
0.1128265858,
-0.2279092371,
-0.6677542925,
0.8836156726,
0.5446470976,
0.7011243105,
0.2462821156,
0.323402673,
0.0878447816,
0.4575870633,
-0.5261725187,
0.3738307655,
-0.4235629141,
0.2058638781,
-0.0422551744,
-1.0462251902,
-0.3767868578,
0.6018251777,
-0.4433760643,
-0.0067789727,
0.9326500893,
0.8217605352,
-0.0312168393,
0.0086123329,
0.3606555462,
0.0822375789,
0.2163485885,
0.7720057964,
0.5044782162,
-0.1204814538,
0.841402173,
-0.2824460864,
-0.7161608338,
0.1846403033,
-0.6866587996,
-1.0955563784,
-0.2863456011,
-0.2583179772,
-0.3778016269,
-0.3466338515,
0.6062121987,
0.5478152633,
-0.5905047655,
-0.4054038525,
-0.2486221939,
0.193906486,
-0.2878742218,
-0.2954208553,
0.3407879472,
-0.6445202827,
-0.6098171473,
0.1922594309,
0.3047612906,
-0.2944970727,
-0.210573256,
0.1121627539,
0.3821642995,
0.3644496202,
0.7924774289,
0.1474726945,
-0.6161780953,
-0.0667481944,
0.2410302907,
-0.0728733242,
-0.1589320004,
0.9287352562,
-0.5173131824,
0.2547829747,
0.191148147,
0.8855158687,
0.5181400776,
-0.115895398,
0.2724770606,
-0.2824293673,
-0.1246624514,
0.2699139714,
0.1873632073,
0.0609269999,
-0.2398942709,
0.6394408941,
0.3227342367,
-0.7882996798,
-0.4990230799,
0.1669540703,
-0.9267303348,
-0.2639629841,
1.0893796682,
-0.0380808935,
-0.2368016988,
0.41877231,
-0.3584800363,
-0.2922275066,
-0.2873807251,
0.5221887827,
0.8000048399,
-0.3292789757,
-0.1746022552,
-0.5602875352,
0.2527064979,
0.4215852618,
-0.8971934915,
0.0932788998,
0.6787371635,
0.3353849947,
0.0069539752,
0.2796624005,
-0.2659654617,
0.382635206,
0.5212733746,
-0.0964621678,
-0.259403348,
-0.1280608028,
-0.1033071652,
0.2268615067,
0.1365155727,
-0.0083189616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02875v1
|
Enhancing Conceptual Understanding in Multimodal Contrastive Learning through Hard Negative Samples
| 2024-03-05T11:38:48 | 2024-03-05T11:38:48 |
Philipp J. Rösch, Norbert Oswald, Michaela Geierhos, Jindřich Libovický
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Current multimodal models leveraging contrastive learning often face
limitations in developing fine-grained conceptual understanding. This is due to
random negative samples during pretraining, causing almost exclusively very
dissimilar concepts to be compared in the loss function. Consequently, the
models struggle with fine-grained semantic differences. To address this
problem, we introduce a novel pretraining method incorporating synthetic hard
negative text examples. The hard negatives permute terms corresponding to
visual concepts, leading to a more fine-grained visual and textual concept
alignment. Further, we introduce InpaintCOCO, a new challenging dataset for
assessing the fine-grained alignment of colors, objects, and sizes in
vision-language models. We created the dataset using generative inpainting from
COCO images by changing the visual concepts so that the images no longer match
their original captions. Our results show significant improvements in
fine-grained concept understanding across a wide range of vision-language
datasets, including our InpaintCOCO dataset.
|
[
-0.5790590644,
-0.6397723556,
0.3676585257,
0.0112561118,
-0.5036084056,
0.3052853346,
-0.1247747093,
-0.4619871378,
0.1122899652,
0.4738870263,
-0.7389306426,
-0.5550408959,
-0.417748332,
0.0650214925,
-0.2304365337,
1.1538404226,
-0.2624333501,
0.1987633705,
-0.4807945788,
-0.3487037122,
-0.5459727645,
-0.277118206,
-0.4449889362,
-0.5234996676,
0.4754000306,
0.660220921,
0.4965823591,
0.2355366349,
0.6668497324,
0.2220495194,
0.0743910596,
0.2622356713,
-0.590901196,
-0.2236555964,
-0.36167261,
-0.6075749397,
-0.0895584002,
0.1105612442,
0.137764737,
0.6242468953,
-0.1891163588,
-0.1726412773,
0.207173124,
0.544433713,
-1.075492382,
0.2952293456,
-0.6840313673,
0.3006957471,
-0.2365674973,
-0.4370989203,
-0.2294958532,
-0.0371945985,
0.0440192074,
-1.224496603,
0.6378144622,
-0.2951814532,
1.2130925655,
0.2765736878,
-0.3699199557,
-0.442150861,
-0.3300311565,
0.7376547456,
-0.3834736943,
0.306991905,
0.4051127136,
0.2564469874,
0.0911373347,
-0.6374148726,
-1.1328080893,
-0.1831675023,
-0.0025350298,
0.4625576735,
0.3402847648,
0.228431657,
-0.0240212306,
0.5179825425,
-0.2868280411,
0.1092611328,
-0.3669662774,
-0.1922990531,
0.4502052367,
0.1859892607,
0.2980994582,
-0.1622935086,
-0.6363611817,
-0.4932406843,
-0.6676137447,
-0.2066808641,
0.1213534847,
0.3491635919,
-0.4706550241,
0.6901587844,
-0.200700596,
0.6964455247,
-0.0251718331,
-0.2066877782,
0.5614743829,
-0.542347014,
-0.4310652018,
0.1457021385,
0.4888124764,
0.6698253155,
0.3865417838,
-0.1023190767,
0.0179076083,
0.5372700095,
0.193260923,
-1.0296220779,
-0.366784364,
-0.0253819861,
-0.0771828219,
-0.4139442146,
0.0902473405,
-0.7236958742,
-0.6548219323,
-0.7019096017,
0.6835519671,
-0.6006173491,
-0.0448612384,
0.3493196666,
-0.2547844052,
0.2863169909,
0.577239871,
-0.9048821926,
0.2462684065,
0.3953637481,
0.6958441734,
-0.1451351047,
-0.2838185728,
-0.2586182952,
0.2283146083,
-0.6399191022,
0.7289919257,
-0.561334908,
-0.184151426,
-0.2064446211,
0.0026052007,
-0.0667267144,
-0.6488463283,
0.4290477633,
-0.3769899011,
0.1835256368,
-0.0141873378,
-0.3856427372,
-0.2311362922,
0.6482219696,
-0.32594648,
0.5758392215,
0.1549028605,
-0.7204758525,
0.4959961772,
-0.4867914319,
-0.484064281,
-0.1659463644,
-0.4183699489,
-0.3800578415,
0.3238823116,
0.1288039088,
0.5386794806,
-0.3142066896,
-0.0185125843,
-0.5732086301,
-0.3946262896,
0.2530349195,
-0.2585224211,
0.5493601561,
0.3029827774,
-0.0520961881,
0.0725675747,
-0.927308321,
-0.181761831,
0.1679867059,
0.1730775386,
-0.6041600704,
-0.1709874272,
0.0666108355,
0.4608002305,
0.036672283,
-0.5763142109,
-0.0270959735,
-0.4173703194,
0.4912692308,
0.6701664329,
-0.0594343916,
0.484832406,
-0.2617653608,
0.4761022031,
0.5040855408,
0.053268671,
-0.4701723754,
-0.0658070147,
-0.9908857942,
-0.2896697223,
0.1314764172,
0.3199714422,
-1.1680772305,
-0.0935649201,
-0.142225042,
-0.348538965,
-0.4591482282,
0.3453340232,
0.5205047727,
0.8047419786,
0.6981940269,
-0.8286607862,
-0.3039003015,
-0.8028636575,
0.3510638773,
0.3683390915,
0.0679671764,
0.3704684079,
0.4867036641,
-0.3888192773,
0.7554090023,
-0.7782264948,
-0.5843617916,
0.0701504052,
0.3739305139,
0.0593094565,
0.7775736451,
0.2900240719,
-0.9495668411,
-0.378497541,
0.1066265106,
-0.7357532978,
0.1965947598,
-0.1690296382,
-0.1970393211,
-0.084773235,
0.8462325335,
-0.5636281967,
0.2035376877,
0.4582853615,
-0.1798322648,
0.2324940413,
-0.2017047703,
0.1758368015,
-1.1522511244,
-0.2438290566,
0.1757411361,
0.1094411314,
-0.4301793575,
0.3842599392,
0.2510654628,
-0.2756165564,
-0.7461695075,
0.5525078177,
-0.2797646224,
0.3026177585,
-0.1442045569,
0.2312783301,
0.4258436859,
0.5711849332,
0.2405563742,
0.6808112264,
0.4367344081,
-0.6931725144,
0.1303702593,
0.3259380758,
-0.6178182364,
0.9099884629,
-0.4867099226,
0.1756758392,
-0.5145136118,
0.332600683,
-1.1535799503,
-0.2770956457,
0.3355279565,
-0.1617768258,
0.5730600357,
0.0314311609,
-0.338583529,
-0.0143796718,
-0.428560257,
0.8567481041,
-0.0899377093,
-0.4641548991,
0.3386987746,
0.1702542752,
0.0784028098,
-0.6546118259,
-0.8612853289,
0.0706971362,
-0.3231591582,
-0.2473627478,
0.7317183614,
-0.1065315679,
-0.0243961997,
-0.1752467901,
-0.188828826,
-0.1659223437,
0.1112307385,
0.1289491653,
0.3105597496,
-0.1314376742,
0.425472945,
-0.0338535383,
-0.1084081307,
-0.2221839577,
-0.111780934,
0.7267338634,
0.1281992197,
-0.2777833641,
-0.567776382,
-0.0702607185,
0.5051068068,
-0.353050977,
0.577323854,
0.7070137262,
-0.3174628615,
0.110892728,
-0.3571150005,
-0.1699211448,
-0.429677248,
0.3759222627,
-0.578318119,
-0.5330803394,
0.2775776088,
0.0951184109,
-0.4133149087,
0.3730596006,
0.274002254,
-0.6020528078,
0.614025712,
0.752363205,
0.3274900615,
0.6058726907,
-0.6395657063,
-0.0750714839,
-0.8219884634,
-0.3930709064,
-0.2466525435,
-0.3118055463,
-0.678145647,
-0.7357770801,
0.0254270267,
0.230282411,
-0.3229038715,
0.2051105797,
-0.3895626068,
0.6634990573,
0.2570877373,
0.604309082,
0.2875622511,
-0.0314380825,
-0.0632149652,
-0.0966190845,
-0.3647995591,
-0.2590564489,
1.1072157621,
-0.061961595,
0.9718956947,
-0.0941770449,
0.6456288695,
-0.0099332333,
0.5839830041,
-0.807326138,
0.2672418356,
-0.483494103,
-0.6187750697,
-0.0683780313,
-0.2760239244,
-0.7216678262,
0.3295811713,
-0.5289644599,
-0.3712084293,
0.5308980346,
0.2779939175,
-0.3820636272,
-0.0034059281,
-1.0945832729,
1.1080082655,
-0.1004877537,
-0.4669731557,
-0.4813372493,
-0.6665444374,
0.4156571031,
-0.0776508078,
0.1315415651,
-0.0525564738,
0.0314101763,
0.463912487,
-0.2419387847,
0.9454188347,
-0.097960785,
-0.3614071906,
0.3726543486,
0.0701588318,
0.1943738163,
0.022715196,
0.1945247203,
0.1173441261,
-0.0631833896,
-0.5933275223,
-0.6950489283,
0.4588840902,
-0.6334857345,
-0.3084605336,
-0.3415245116,
-0.5708254576,
-0.253426224,
-0.0041270768,
0.2803383172,
0.4925619662,
-0.2222140133,
0.2859938145,
0.6243757606,
-0.3529614806,
0.1416362971,
0.3197855055,
0.1379657537,
-0.240528062,
1.3417938948,
-0.0383280255,
0.4628976285,
0.8988321424,
0.0359244496,
-0.2655164003,
-0.5549877882,
-0.1891202033,
0.0159248374,
-0.7321596146,
-0.3132196367,
-0.4409062862,
0.0733046159,
0.1055160388,
-0.4399039149,
-0.2584051192,
-0.3363026381,
-0.5368242264,
-0.1468220055,
-0.1357114762,
0.3072594702,
0.1417919695,
0.3892782927,
-0.4685339928,
0.5590903759,
0.4062587619,
0.2107972354,
0.0036102028,
-0.460382998,
-0.25014624,
0.2249397784,
-0.7072930336,
-0.5510780215,
0.2208164334,
0.2790469825,
0.0624855161,
0.6122676134,
-0.1383396834,
1.0751230717,
-0.3118899763,
0.5208238959,
0.7082460523,
-0.9355868101,
0.4604641199,
-0.1702725887,
0.4146226645,
0.838971138,
0.4180157781,
-0.507996738,
-0.1496457607,
-0.6258411407,
-0.7600529194,
0.548194468,
0.079402335,
0.5102175474,
-0.0109893288,
0.1587383598,
0.3273799717,
0.370149076,
-0.7288749218,
0.1141883507,
-0.7581341863,
-0.5079074502,
-0.7876800299,
-0.1370675266,
-0.2694498897,
-0.4312768877,
0.5553723574,
-0.3501977623,
0.0012681807,
0.0827843919,
-0.4706264734,
0.1954847425,
0.2622919083,
0.822442472,
0.5633271933,
-0.2442317307,
0.4013775289,
0.3749975264,
-0.4153580964,
0.2568742633,
0.1897758543,
0.1305735856,
-0.3560610712,
0.4762212038,
0.7725628614,
0.22828345,
-0.7193388939,
0.5187090039,
-0.0350556187,
-0.0356560722,
-0.0292675216,
0.1357759684,
-0.0682843253,
-0.0541243367,
0.0483848639,
0.2874422967,
-0.0359714627,
-0.6688326597,
0.1075444818,
0.373495847,
-0.7296841145,
-0.2932745814,
0.3375460804,
0.2918377221,
0.1865187436,
0.7307588458,
-0.2293867022,
-0.1628473103,
0.8454785347,
0.5723307729,
0.4899102747,
0.0992849022,
0.3737673759,
0.3250571191,
0.0591377914,
0.2558972239,
0.0471854582,
-0.545900166,
-1.2507102489,
-0.3758693039,
-0.5299140811,
-0.363922447,
0.2618369162,
-0.6038578749,
0.41988796,
-0.4681337476,
0.1221362278,
0.0840294659,
-0.0553783439,
-0.8972706199,
0.7222892642,
0.2239597589,
0.6190311909,
-0.9622686505,
0.7736918926,
0.6083345413,
-0.6317911744,
-0.490282774,
-0.0374414101,
-0.0960381776,
-0.8838253021,
0.8161438107,
0.4543500245,
-0.2088939846,
0.0129213873,
-0.5851706862,
-0.5212550163,
0.9888147712,
0.4734839797,
-0.6229365468,
0.1507877409,
-0.0009554775,
0.5068047047,
-0.3003642857,
0.3329731524,
0.3105167449,
0.2919659317,
0.3842592239,
-0.4186220467,
-0.2340367138,
-0.1546153128,
-0.0124276392,
0.2191670388,
-0.567450285,
0.8607040644,
-0.2893871367,
-0.3750604093,
0.0636468306,
0.5925890803,
0.0892714784,
0.579664588,
0.5153905749,
0.9523472786,
0.6422899961,
-0.1195100024,
1.0264117718,
-0.0550110415,
0.4813319445,
1.4332727194,
-0.0811556205,
0.5101522207,
0.7765256166,
0.1005696133,
0.5536015034,
0.8003478646,
0.1159041598,
0.7623930573,
0.3632057905,
-0.3481368721,
-0.3356920183,
-0.4808390141,
-0.4152056873,
0.5947991014,
0.4281768799,
-0.1167868897,
-0.4301093519,
0.2270117551,
-0.2030831277,
0.2425221205,
-0.3843181133,
0.7345998883,
0.2008510679,
-0.4194996953,
0.7704690099,
-0.198053211,
0.890704155,
-0.5746136308,
-0.182168752,
-0.2838848531,
0.3672320247,
-0.3379556835,
-0.7064985633,
0.1418177485,
-0.312989682,
0.052452594,
-0.0548443682,
0.2579450309,
-0.5351076126,
-0.3792770505,
0.1870924085,
0.1559349746,
-0.070678778,
-0.03599732,
-0.636441052,
0.0311789103,
-0.1718064398,
0.2762120664,
0.1681330651,
0.5426363349,
-0.1446113735,
0.4777044058,
0.4833754599,
-0.2637150586,
-0.3016765118,
0.3379117548,
0.7857860327,
-0.5492905974,
-0.3426809907,
-0.9230986238,
0.4102398157,
-0.0255314931,
-0.5301245451,
0.4286095202,
0.4572970271,
1.4752811193,
-0.2518870831,
0.2961655557,
0.0519648716,
-0.2248498499,
-0.7542541623,
0.5168586373,
-0.8564492464,
-0.1975775957,
-0.6417139173,
-0.9056809545,
-0.3467799723,
0.7344480157,
-0.1861112118,
-0.2229133993,
0.7135756016,
0.9996168613,
-0.4487403631,
-0.0346516892,
0.2043572068,
0.2488269061,
0.261501044,
0.5418730378,
1.0281927586,
-0.4263091683,
0.4063469172,
-0.5372431278,
-0.0126569355,
-0.0572470129,
-0.9047599435,
-0.8193269968,
-0.7618413568,
-0.3265122473,
-0.1680377275,
0.0823061839,
0.8183708191,
0.8033074141,
-0.8748270273,
-0.1484950334,
-0.5930448771,
0.0866171494,
-0.0891084969,
-0.2480449826,
0.3828167617,
-0.4949813187,
-0.7148448229,
0.1078228429,
0.2034180164,
0.4189077318,
0.0677714571,
-0.0590310544,
-0.2365052998,
-0.0211400874,
0.8132035136,
0.1986840665,
-0.3362105489,
-0.2521839142,
-0.50760746,
-0.1547713727,
0.3330959082,
0.83632195,
-0.7785286307,
0.8313898444,
0.289624691,
0.6280176044,
1.0233882666,
0.0710544512,
0.3048867285,
-0.7007152438,
0.5906664133,
0.1604599655,
0.2391344607,
0.6293686628,
-0.0663895607,
0.4878275394,
0.3342453837,
0.2558134794,
-0.6515306234,
0.3675610423,
-1.1572512388,
-0.4855784476,
0.6835569739,
0.1397998631,
-0.065885134,
0.1142253429,
-0.4024095833,
0.3377743661,
-0.1248180792,
0.9642916918,
0.752679348,
0.0080652675,
-0.1282804906,
-0.1072600409,
0.3540752828,
0.518101573,
-0.8671318889,
-0.3586279154,
0.2475123554,
0.1685979813,
0.4390456975,
0.4923174381,
-0.1864904016,
0.1777090579,
-0.1514963508,
0.255579114,
-0.1518085748,
-0.5088127851,
-0.1980156898,
0.1605561078,
-0.2601817548,
-0.5132701397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02839v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02839v2
|
On the Limitations of Fine-tuned Judge Models for LLM Evaluation
| 2024-03-05T10:20:52 | 2024-06-17T12:10:34 |
Hui Huang, Yingqi Qu, Hongli Zhou, Jing Liu, Muyun Yang, Bing Xu, Tiejun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been a growing trend of utilizing Large Language Model
(LLM) to evaluate the quality of other LLMs. Many studies have employed
proprietary close-source models, especially GPT-4, as the evaluator.
Alternatively, other works have fine-tuned judge models based on open-source
LLMs as the evaluator. While the fine-tuned judge models are claimed to achieve
comparable evaluation capability with GPT-4, in this study, we conduct an
empirical study of judge models. Our findings indicate that although the
fine-tuned judge models achieve high performance on in-domain test sets, even
surpassing GPT-4, they underperform GPT-4 across several dimensions, including
generalizability, fairness, aspect-specific evaluation, and scalability. We
also reveal that the fine-tuned judge model inherently operates as a
task-specific classifier, consequently imposing the limitations. Finally, we
propose an effective indicator to measure the reliability of fine-tuned judges,
with the aim of maximizing their utility in LLM evaluation.
|
[
-0.4348771274,
-0.5467880964,
1.0868579149,
-0.0709235966,
-0.1675161719,
-0.2890328467,
-0.6891601086,
-0.6253495812,
-0.4015622437,
0.5129085779,
-0.2433215678,
-0.4238493741,
-0.7991908789,
0.2388855219,
-0.3572796583,
1.1661239862,
-0.0921279415,
0.2352108806,
-0.2383988649,
-0.1629359275,
-0.5329514742,
-0.4328277707,
-0.3241507113,
-0.4488440156,
0.2172335684,
0.4562037885,
0.7227904797,
0.2842876911,
0.8138587475,
0.3205382526,
-0.1788110435,
0.1442755461,
-0.5372521281,
-0.1805384159,
-0.4980939925,
-0.5420140028,
-0.6461740732,
0.4326030612,
0.5749608278,
0.5091814399,
-0.1073463932,
0.2755766511,
0.1074836627,
0.502879262,
-0.5675855875,
0.4250292182,
-0.8826933503,
-0.0510223843,
-0.2974718213,
-0.1717570275,
-0.2886383533,
-0.6424033642,
0.0422762409,
-0.4068420827,
0.2220870554,
-0.0672950223,
0.9357184768,
0.4185159504,
-0.39102,
-0.1408222765,
-0.8083108068,
0.7830086946,
-1.0763529539,
0.3706616163,
0.5047857761,
0.5513112545,
-0.0725956559,
-0.6534477472,
-0.4309577048,
-0.7824187279,
0.1377443224,
0.0389662907,
-0.1371626854,
0.1154478192,
0.3207858503,
0.6144071817,
-0.3395724297,
0.5001686215,
-0.1742176414,
-0.0701049939,
0.5406138897,
0.3946425617,
-0.0588915646,
-0.1405715644,
-0.1569854915,
0.5239182711,
-0.5059466362,
0.0385327563,
0.466201067,
0.4434017837,
0.2146888822,
0.5897025466,
-0.4645164311,
0.8616677523,
0.4124419689,
-0.1371389329,
0.0776475817,
-0.4218909442,
-0.2387407571,
-0.6085569859,
0.7754724026,
0.5257174373,
0.5785577893,
-0.3336766958,
-0.5175586343,
0.0585647151,
0.3546964228,
-0.8182707429,
-0.0485601053,
-0.0669141114,
-0.5336915851,
-0.3335407078,
-0.004993367,
-0.4875951409,
-0.3209799826,
-0.3929983377,
0.4217752516,
-0.2812055647,
-0.0746300742,
0.1725398153,
0.0478425361,
-0.011411937,
0.1707914919,
-0.9468900561,
0.5691463351,
0.8624216318,
0.6053405404,
-0.410551995,
-0.2799278498,
-0.7964532375,
-0.3937541544,
-0.1778793633,
0.626766324,
-0.8492665291,
-0.1554437727,
-0.0936527029,
0.1099076346,
-0.1002986804,
-0.7246839404,
0.950763762,
-0.6520067453,
-0.2332484275,
-0.2756178379,
-0.8406382799,
-0.0128064277,
0.4623629749,
-0.5945349336,
0.5896882415,
0.471041292,
-0.4300774634,
0.6197090745,
-0.4597693086,
-0.2646146119,
0.1080585942,
-0.1714914292,
-0.5002961755,
0.4027864635,
0.1610210538,
0.5710365772,
-0.5862659216,
0.3555582762,
-0.6562006474,
-0.7099013329,
0.1571837515,
-0.5186443925,
0.1248725578,
0.3543708324,
-0.3146547377,
0.2096465826,
-0.8122742176,
0.1608678997,
-0.039281778,
-0.6319284439,
-0.0640073493,
0.0572797358,
0.0218873136,
0.0590543523,
0.3894003034,
-0.5890011191,
-0.1289537698,
-0.5212874413,
0.6191135645,
0.7964869738,
-0.0923568159,
0.2859525681,
-0.3150185049,
0.7814134359,
-0.3008503914,
0.181908384,
0.252610594,
-0.2453269809,
-0.5271839499,
-0.0853558332,
0.5679388642,
0.2393153459,
-0.2677574456,
0.4722070992,
-0.3028279841,
-0.6931029558,
-0.3019725382,
0.2638761401,
0.4791351557,
0.2430676669,
0.1731241941,
-0.5012238622,
0.0332354978,
-1.0517165661,
-0.6037274003,
0.1536037922,
0.1906410605,
0.5048613548,
0.564586699,
-0.060900487,
0.7838807702,
-0.1906313449,
0.0292258002,
-0.2558893263,
-0.2956159413,
0.4835128486,
0.2965753078,
0.8215301633,
-0.4517883062,
-0.4774432778,
0.2150267065,
-0.4725991488,
-0.2722424567,
0.2830832601,
0.1960583627,
0.0053141941,
0.2413704842,
-0.5094712377,
0.3431021869,
0.6405879855,
-0.4120096266,
0.9717231393,
-0.2422916889,
0.2111919671,
-0.3975178301,
-0.0831018388,
0.229124561,
-0.4547113776,
-0.3326805532,
0.3777015507,
0.264531374,
0.0409771241,
-0.2049415708,
0.5495228767,
-0.2226106524,
-0.2373824716,
-0.4471223056,
0.2302588969,
-0.1247816309,
0.4612303972,
-0.2928803861,
0.5686951876,
0.20463489,
-0.6560301185,
0.3474100828,
0.044084724,
-0.7535589337,
0.8586130738,
-0.6303479671,
-0.0145257004,
0.4497171938,
0.0388299823,
-0.4806033075,
-0.2655887008,
-0.081892401,
-0.0294720903,
0.419665724,
-0.3027432859,
-0.5543085337,
-0.4755177796,
-0.1593374014,
0.25778687,
0.3644985259,
-0.6234964728,
0.2344816476,
0.0392267145,
-0.1191392541,
-0.2547594607,
-0.4093277156,
-0.1535650939,
-0.3111356199,
-0.5387230515,
0.1370006204,
-0.19209674,
-0.1732484996,
0.0459546335,
-0.4763401449,
0.0106884204,
0.3355112076,
0.2144569159,
-0.0218385458,
-0.2433639914,
-0.0822931007,
-0.0686004311,
-0.0263608228,
0.0905174986,
-0.1072276905,
0.2577319145,
-0.4843151569,
-0.8253711462,
-0.5130206943,
-0.0451980717,
0.6351487637,
-0.440143466,
0.2272356749,
0.2821452618,
-0.1044531018,
-0.229136616,
-0.6306595206,
0.036610458,
-0.4605791271,
0.5884954333,
-0.6368424296,
-1.2427364588,
0.3926483393,
-0.2154829353,
-0.1836706698,
0.5870839357,
0.7656670213,
0.2604518533,
0.8637319207,
0.5087886453,
-0.1293728203,
0.4028197825,
0.1164142713,
0.1941019744,
-0.8979084492,
0.0583542995,
-0.6622928977,
-0.2689479291,
-0.8180733919,
-0.0779901966,
0.3389206231,
0.1647153199,
-0.5400550365,
0.0806590021,
-0.4229785204,
0.568813026,
0.6077262759,
0.2805990875,
0.5230095983,
-0.263424933,
-0.4289239645,
0.1033561379,
-0.3884408176,
-0.7309724689,
1.278860569,
0.610709846,
0.7715246677,
0.0411248468,
0.4728554189,
0.1566049159,
0.1923068464,
-0.838778913,
0.5103940368,
-0.321313709,
-0.6423814297,
-0.2848313153,
-0.447752893,
-0.6016761065,
0.2752197683,
0.0709991902,
-0.8496881127,
0.0595101044,
0.0511639081,
-0.4374773204,
0.2733275592,
-0.6413040757,
0.9541817904,
-0.3756485283,
-0.3587228656,
-0.2213319093,
-0.2661472559,
0.4417999685,
-0.5794189572,
0.0720899478,
-0.2829490304,
0.3388364017,
0.3999504447,
-0.7764789462,
0.6731491685,
-0.2554602921,
-0.0885222852,
0.0911533013,
0.1651861966,
0.7528155446,
0.0444831252,
-0.3770441413,
0.1818644851,
-0.0051852809,
-0.2395437658,
-0.5850073099,
0.952684164,
-0.6903752685,
-0.8337032199,
-0.2720210552,
-0.4283875525,
-0.6759601831,
0.1909128875,
0.0758048669,
0.2262519449,
-0.2139804214,
0.0040892954,
0.0366081148,
-0.2640918791,
0.1981011927,
0.8909540772,
-0.0805096626,
-0.051820498,
0.7358044386,
0.017971782,
0.391223222,
-0.152693674,
0.2942418754,
0.0197899938,
-1.0490143299,
-0.3135302365,
0.1401394755,
-0.6415044069,
-0.1741673201,
-0.1162346825,
-0.1773377657,
0.0798104554,
0.0774842501,
-0.418743223,
-0.4170694649,
-0.0679543614,
-0.3013871014,
0.1790439039,
0.9815680385,
0.1234051362,
0.233460933,
-0.548948884,
0.2995494604,
0.348916322,
1.0748029947,
-0.1059735939,
-0.8480495811,
-0.4431763291,
-0.2463486791,
-0.4576279819,
-0.4323559403,
0.0011765704,
0.0159640219,
0.6965827346,
0.4595603049,
-0.1949297041,
0.6841154695,
-0.8403599262,
0.7079023719,
-0.0349046476,
-0.9507210255,
0.4152695239,
-0.4915200472,
0.1198754385,
0.6056791544,
-0.0926518887,
-0.0200715233,
-0.8092157245,
-0.4133147299,
-0.5161215663,
0.8453606367,
0.0821645185,
0.1405935735,
-0.0569980517,
0.6711050868,
0.3884049356,
0.2615210712,
-0.6176382899,
0.1215272397,
-0.0395614468,
-0.0292965006,
-0.2204830348,
-0.4123613834,
0.0141903199,
-0.4347819686,
0.4824692011,
-0.0403988957,
-0.0094447108,
-0.1422783136,
0.0533008203,
-0.2314117998,
0.5597367883,
0.4485223889,
0.8380178213,
-0.339312166,
-0.1157910451,
0.2316163629,
-0.1283037663,
-0.0363518596,
0.381075561,
-0.183803007,
-0.2596527636,
0.3577153683,
0.9534032345,
0.3429317474,
-0.4350132048,
0.6673701406,
0.0578900166,
-0.2304118425,
-0.1853693724,
0.3725747168,
0.0718904361,
0.6843761206,
-0.1484594792,
0.2906756699,
0.2082436979,
-0.3584887981,
0.1402151138,
0.6429262757,
-0.4703795016,
-0.2770911455,
1.0478969812,
0.2165890336,
-0.0853482708,
0.3816884458,
-0.270968765,
-0.3589037657,
0.5883383751,
0.4119472802,
0.7708487511,
0.0878057927,
-0.1290018409,
0.1237053126,
0.3236627579,
-0.3032152653,
0.1872789413,
0.003610641,
-0.6095161438,
-0.5664275289,
-0.9685478806,
-0.590772748,
0.2558268607,
-0.6178032756,
0.1098424494,
-0.3699650764,
-0.516473949,
-0.0365875363,
0.1580964327,
-1.0887187719,
0.1844409108,
0.1342867613,
0.9244019985,
-0.4922229052,
0.8168197274,
0.4339713454,
-0.2830917537,
-0.9252585769,
0.0128745167,
-0.1177333295,
-0.7460687757,
0.7003869414,
0.1775922179,
-0.0577505939,
-0.3056330085,
-0.4217392802,
-0.6579526663,
0.8562789559,
0.6636171937,
-1.0147989988,
0.1201245934,
0.0877593681,
0.718616724,
-0.1877959222,
0.4070512652,
1.007524848,
0.8017423153,
-0.3467639685,
-1.614009738,
0.1011240706,
-0.192504406,
0.1284445822,
0.0339122117,
-0.7755782008,
0.7664554715,
-0.2204042226,
0.1838495135,
0.4615431428,
0.259049952,
0.2967170179,
0.2473930866,
0.4408189654,
0.6194604039,
0.7930839062,
-0.2376610935,
1.4363927841,
-0.4411684573,
0.6747046709,
1.3720296621,
-0.4233633876,
0.6477437615,
0.0291115195,
-0.2503632605,
0.215130344,
0.5499719977,
-0.4860263467,
0.4084348679,
0.409935385,
0.027721785,
-0.4591524899,
0.171562463,
-0.0631405711,
0.609749794,
-0.0045442921,
-0.4929031432,
-0.1760867387,
-0.1479539126,
-0.0601441786,
0.2150534093,
-0.6226438284,
0.374753952,
0.2524383068,
-0.6999289989,
0.4544424117,
0.3632605672,
0.6273560524,
-0.4338205755,
0.2170351893,
-0.176614821,
0.3792842925,
-0.3034549952,
-0.6360596418,
0.0453755632,
0.2504793108,
-0.0247505177,
0.0880791992,
0.6514978409,
0.0474575758,
-0.4551666975,
0.4551763535,
0.5336585641,
0.2249396145,
-0.332326442,
-0.4684532881,
-0.0644844696,
-0.2154493481,
-0.5674114227,
0.41584903,
0.698825717,
-0.1610905677,
0.5865154862,
0.3444575965,
0.3790131807,
-0.0454330482,
0.4376608431,
0.7875407338,
-0.8138580322,
-0.2080567628,
-0.9589518905,
0.1903564334,
0.2594091296,
-0.2669503987,
0.7621849775,
0.4899780154,
0.9018182755,
-0.070461683,
0.9082962871,
0.2143293768,
0.5545250773,
-0.6149168015,
0.610227108,
-0.6226798296,
0.4252678156,
-0.395495981,
-0.85686028,
-0.0646478981,
0.2662844062,
-0.6056278348,
0.5091826916,
0.69764781,
0.455542028,
-0.3282857239,
0.0101474356,
0.6876280308,
0.3295593262,
0.3227850795,
0.7213264108,
0.8637338877,
-0.0103850076,
0.5090405345,
-0.034773659,
-0.1394400895,
-0.3744785488,
-0.5480477214,
-1.0999333858,
-0.1327180117,
-0.0624838136,
-0.0744518414,
-0.1628632694,
0.4388588965,
0.5997751355,
-0.8280005455,
0.0159235168,
0.0306159146,
-0.0865740702,
-0.2232996821,
-0.2168325633,
0.3109320998,
-0.6001429558,
-0.9148151278,
0.5398967266,
0.1944620758,
-0.4893344939,
-0.1892340481,
-0.2595380247,
0.4548507929,
0.0745698363,
0.5574358702,
-0.1137334183,
-0.9337123632,
-0.6650673747,
-0.4231985509,
-0.0555208921,
0.0217590127,
0.6048636436,
-0.5765211582,
0.5401990414,
0.0517617203,
0.5350794196,
0.5395442247,
0.1385402977,
0.6534162164,
-0.4033825696,
-0.2570361197,
0.185259372,
0.6788818836,
-0.0292883664,
-0.1788002402,
0.7384762168,
-0.0022296549,
-0.9772193432,
-0.5887621641,
0.2858837247,
-0.9879989028,
-0.1017104983,
1.2864226103,
-0.2460407615,
0.2975855768,
0.0802126154,
0.0461963117,
0.0706834346,
-0.3486102521,
0.5013349056,
1.0163682699,
-0.3433176577,
0.1454559565,
-1.0834691525,
0.3661786914,
0.4364499748,
-0.6237431169,
-0.0706839785,
0.5121750236,
0.8328635693,
-0.1005154923,
0.5381520391,
-0.3633956313,
0.2811245024,
-0.295542568,
-0.189692542,
-0.344548732,
-0.0212859493,
-0.511914134,
0.3542440534,
0.6346952915,
0.0514266454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02799v1
|
DPPA: Pruning Method for Large Language Model to Model Merging
| 2024-03-05T09:12:49 | 2024-03-05T09:12:49 |
Yaochen Zhu, Rui Xia, Jiajun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Model merging is to combine fine-tuned models derived from multiple domains,
with the intent of enhancing the model's proficiency across various domains.
The principal concern is the resolution of parameter conflicts. A substantial
amount of existing research remedy this issue during the merging stage, with
the latest study focusing on resolving this issue throughout the pruning stage.
The DARE approach has exhibited promising outcomes when applied to a simplistic
fine-tuned model. However, the efficacy of this method tends to wane when
employed on complex fine-tuned models that show a significant parameter bias
relative to the baseline model. In this paper, we introduce a dual-stage method
termed Dynamic Pruning Partition Amplification (DPPA), devised to tackle the
challenge of merging complex fine-tuned models. Initially, we introduce
Dynamically Pruning (DP), an improved approach based on magnitude pruning,
which aim is to enhance performance at higher pruning rates. Subsequently, we
propose Dynamically Partition Amplification (DPA), a rescaling strategy, is
designed to dynamically amplify parameter partitions in relation to their
significance levels. The experimental results show that our method maintains a
mere 20% of domain-specific parameters and yet delivers a performance
comparable to other methodologies that preserve up to 90% of parameters.
Furthermore, our method displays outstanding performance post-pruning, leading
to a significant improvement of nearly 20% performance in model merging. We
make our code on Github.
|
[
-0.6803587079,
-1.0454981327,
0.414909184,
0.3135059774,
-0.47217834,
0.4729492664,
-0.3228703737,
-0.4179422259,
-0.1859685928,
0.1960523874,
-0.6914873719,
-0.1584875584,
-0.4887315035,
-0.2453364879,
-0.2220869958,
0.5251377225,
0.00611478,
-0.1020357832,
-0.1620465368,
0.0838086754,
-0.6630496979,
-0.3883230388,
-0.5520811081,
-0.1795552671,
0.4910657108,
0.3882880211,
0.7384135127,
0.8563867211,
0.5952816606,
0.3964898884,
-0.6064966321,
0.6605916023,
-0.4155824482,
0.6032393575,
0.079793781,
-0.2487668693,
-0.5526996851,
-0.0445988551,
1.1309059858,
0.8113287091,
-0.205162257,
0.111418657,
0.0337463059,
0.4741680622,
-0.5096179843,
0.2497117668,
-0.5241925716,
-0.1350816935,
-0.2314189076,
-0.2056577504,
-0.354644686,
-0.4709655046,
-0.289624691,
-0.3501887321,
-0.0084894309,
-0.1034886464,
0.8213890791,
0.6140886545,
-0.8204602599,
0.2181529403,
-1.1557776928,
1.0291696787,
-0.9405870438,
0.3577917814,
-0.1014972478,
0.4215398729,
-0.3969745934,
-0.5755376816,
-0.810824275,
-0.2145031393,
0.1023791507,
-0.4970115721,
0.1723386198,
0.1175855622,
0.3792954683,
0.7587487698,
-0.1298608631,
0.2881498635,
-0.2435009927,
-0.0627913997,
0.9400230646,
0.1204526573,
0.3642887473,
0.1810587198,
-0.2917758226,
-0.5593661666,
-0.6853425503,
-0.203619644,
0.7976098657,
0.4196532071,
0.0945136994,
0.3990012109,
-0.0592312925,
1.0516283512,
0.2068773806,
-0.4162442088,
0.2683318853,
-0.4930557907,
-0.0473186299,
-0.1789575368,
0.6298294663,
0.1974983364,
0.1326800436,
0.2092650235,
-0.1822440475,
0.0072766198,
0.2656090856,
-0.8149250746,
-0.3615860939,
0.3702481985,
-0.2294897586,
-0.5294932723,
-0.3478322625,
-1.0308750868,
-0.3953804076,
-0.5117257833,
0.1417318732,
-0.5051223636,
-0.6808690429,
-0.0537600517,
0.1789434999,
-0.0117120286,
0.4451997578,
-0.8240247965,
0.1812432259,
1.0018674135,
0.6278461218,
-0.2075376958,
-0.3047872186,
-0.612419486,
0.1324195564,
-0.2593347728,
0.4406409264,
-0.5249287486,
-0.3188223243,
-0.0345691703,
-0.2452821136,
-0.0029014724,
-0.7281882167,
0.6153219342,
-0.712166965,
-0.0245881584,
-0.2585845292,
-0.5129212141,
-0.3920912445,
0.3661397696,
-0.6813089252,
0.96409899,
-0.0033223366,
-0.5417845249,
0.4655196667,
-0.2864342928,
-0.5130589604,
0.1317829192,
-0.2117609084,
-0.591117382,
0.1593794823,
0.1247507706,
0.1826349646,
-0.2936365306,
0.8437726498,
-0.4451467991,
-0.1976685971,
0.0966770351,
-0.7439684272,
0.7053695321,
0.2509560287,
-0.1429257691,
0.3927046061,
-0.8956869245,
0.063283436,
0.1793418974,
-0.5090386271,
-0.3031939566,
0.0356756337,
-0.1148679033,
0.2232714295,
0.4159634411,
-0.4538463056,
0.7128028274,
-0.5195553303,
0.4637122154,
0.530397296,
0.2507725954,
0.4333771765,
-0.2181329876,
0.3735564649,
-0.0388682373,
0.0993406773,
-0.0249258149,
-0.4341219664,
-0.6699410081,
-0.4050350487,
0.6018217802,
0.25383991,
-0.3953555226,
0.6625158191,
-0.1538258791,
-0.5835595727,
-0.3081574738,
-0.0380976237,
0.3195026517,
0.373306036,
0.2213399559,
-0.2551493049,
-0.3828440607,
-0.9959785342,
-0.0856019408,
-0.3395231366,
-0.028220227,
0.2367827296,
0.0951338708,
0.102158457,
0.8415597677,
-0.7355716228,
-0.1880380213,
-0.1566112936,
0.1389356256,
0.1341010183,
0.7663716078,
0.4550674856,
-1.2402379513,
-0.6391611099,
-0.1397672594,
-0.2988989651,
0.0116159208,
-0.0407913476,
0.0939532667,
-0.1493103355,
0.1783518493,
-0.5290042162,
0.0955102444,
0.6557846069,
-0.2124874741,
0.5319167972,
-0.2248900533,
0.3634133637,
-0.8937376142,
-0.1214213744,
-0.137761876,
-0.1842280775,
-0.6942155957,
0.4181569815,
0.1594722867,
-0.2842379212,
-0.5505786538,
0.4239192009,
-0.6855329275,
0.256511271,
-0.5174813271,
-0.1230802909,
-0.0941268578,
0.4710883498,
-0.1854530126,
0.7064907551,
0.4715590775,
-0.7155098915,
0.6753252745,
0.2469093055,
-0.2220981866,
0.0131870219,
-0.4038564265,
-0.0420263968,
0.245127812,
0.3213671446,
-1.1278768778,
-0.2287593335,
0.102832593,
-0.1506694853,
0.8341507316,
-0.4036085606,
-0.5823261142,
-0.4355340004,
-0.1716101617,
0.7544004917,
0.5383797288,
-0.4937594831,
0.5281277299,
0.6997647882,
-0.3678941727,
-0.2395416498,
-0.5195531845,
0.0264214128,
-0.4979355335,
-0.894661665,
0.7884941101,
-0.1183080375,
-0.2871860266,
-0.1770429164,
-0.2222863734,
-0.2527044713,
-0.064069137,
0.1107451096,
0.2686427236,
0.0980789885,
-0.026517624,
0.3224808574,
0.03006972,
-0.2654670477,
0.091964528,
0.8190562129,
0.1756418943,
-0.4732968211,
-0.5830879807,
0.2605705559,
0.8698150516,
-0.5267535448,
0.965153873,
0.4311478734,
-0.2845863402,
-0.2886255682,
-0.6957085729,
-0.3527956605,
-0.5175994635,
0.1583270133,
-0.5781539679,
-0.7780117393,
0.662559092,
-0.545296669,
0.2896666229,
0.2164840996,
0.6589711905,
0.3920079768,
1.1788730621,
0.8353022337,
0.0476280712,
0.5127770305,
-0.2217069417,
0.5642490983,
-0.8626328707,
-0.2620745003,
-0.405754298,
-0.6344202161,
-0.5593720675,
-0.775826633,
0.053783264,
0.1020771861,
0.055787582,
0.2079101056,
-0.6993600726,
0.1999346465,
0.4606570303,
-0.2162135541,
0.4167022109,
-0.0335240662,
0.0512991026,
-0.2113190591,
-0.6465185881,
-0.2452114075,
0.6000257134,
0.5954169631,
0.3779852688,
0.2822338343,
0.6281537414,
-0.0195133481,
-0.150515154,
-0.846935451,
0.8401567936,
-0.1102785021,
-0.593551755,
-0.5702499151,
-0.6310930848,
-0.7062035799,
0.5508301854,
-0.1598769575,
-0.4896016717,
0.5644634962,
0.2600367069,
-0.3802979887,
0.4375447929,
-0.520961225,
0.5993575454,
-0.1743470132,
-0.4957861006,
-0.5051363707,
-0.3256399035,
0.6370837688,
-0.3384823799,
0.1543550044,
-0.368698895,
-0.0903549939,
0.6268206239,
-0.6093707681,
0.6486223936,
-0.3183602095,
-0.3788023293,
0.1302842051,
0.2868950963,
0.7714031935,
0.0423953347,
-0.0684283227,
0.1051415876,
0.0449751429,
-0.1593913734,
-0.6360955238,
1.0050491095,
-0.4417487979,
-0.7356987,
-0.2524285614,
-0.8798860312,
-0.4708668888,
0.2359928191,
-0.2960924506,
0.3879365027,
0.0437853821,
0.2891679406,
0.6141377091,
-0.2865314186,
0.3164359629,
0.6976145506,
-0.1414425075,
-0.1587450802,
0.7312067747,
0.1513244808,
0.1545675844,
0.2660861611,
0.158140853,
-0.1118014455,
-0.9096320271,
-0.3836601377,
0.4021828473,
-0.240161404,
-0.2845585346,
-0.4126212299,
-0.1994945258,
-0.5310617685,
0.25843665,
-0.6954162121,
-0.4506672025,
0.1971233934,
0.1923402101,
0.2940448821,
0.2957391143,
0.075695999,
0.2763869464,
-0.9790352583,
0.2658559382,
0.0946048796,
0.2862046361,
0.1048133597,
-0.4364951551,
0.0467220098,
0.1026036367,
-0.2996910214,
-1.0018042326,
0.6466380954,
0.163309142,
0.5381104946,
0.1967154741,
0.4379162192,
0.8752129674,
-0.4506069124,
0.6647461057,
0.035129182,
-0.7115715146,
0.620737493,
-0.570807457,
0.1482701451,
0.646006763,
0.3252585232,
-0.2064941972,
-0.4282670617,
-0.5902697444,
-1.2391799688,
0.6335045695,
-0.0106782522,
-0.0374576598,
0.2369157374,
0.3735467196,
-0.1629059911,
0.3174338043,
-0.3021574318,
-0.1344394386,
0.7191696167,
-0.0811976716,
0.0127207953,
-0.4748399258,
-0.5376796126,
-0.4692429006,
0.609921217,
0.152262792,
-0.2750434875,
-0.3530318737,
0.2137137502,
-0.1954356432,
0.0821346417,
0.2927006185,
0.8778162003,
-0.2118386179,
-0.1251483709,
0.0280104168,
-0.4082524776,
0.3182317317,
0.3427929282,
-0.2947190404,
-0.2245248109,
0.3001101911,
0.8085587621,
0.1780071706,
-0.6056562066,
0.3839811385,
-0.151460588,
-0.238875106,
-0.0669522509,
0.1926677674,
-0.1317393333,
0.2407732755,
0.3162799478,
-0.0178908408,
-0.0026570377,
-0.6035804152,
0.3292637169,
0.3501686454,
-0.0078036762,
-0.1063255966,
0.4437200725,
0.4951282144,
-0.2054748982,
0.8773556352,
-0.1604507118,
-0.5708760619,
0.5685409307,
0.3310979605,
0.5659013987,
-0.4132998586,
-0.0660388693,
0.4307039976,
0.0463128239,
-0.093397446,
-0.0606081821,
-0.3367033005,
-0.5756409764,
-1.0348151922,
-0.9121355414,
-0.3499607444,
0.1813523322,
-0.5346342325,
0.3417737484,
-0.2447131872,
-0.13834548,
0.0095760953,
0.5537186861,
-0.0781829134,
0.2645896971,
0.0271545891,
0.9191388488,
-1.0090657473,
1.2188512087,
0.7051244378,
-0.2461078167,
-1.179240346,
0.2721845806,
0.1180554703,
-0.3688783348,
0.589373529,
-0.1099635065,
0.3118959367,
-0.0266305171,
0.1342641115,
-0.9456157684,
0.9155548215,
0.4707696736,
-0.9661061168,
-0.0467508435,
-0.0245873425,
0.393430531,
-0.098465912,
-0.3585793078,
0.6454433203,
0.8464708924,
0.6261740327,
-1.0640194416,
0.267002821,
-0.1264724731,
-0.1457541734,
0.6812700033,
-0.716285944,
0.92206496,
0.0126324343,
-0.3635200858,
-0.0867584869,
0.6312718987,
0.3613151908,
0.2602543533,
0.8770820498,
0.5400720239,
0.9282971025,
-0.2083272785,
0.7214172482,
-0.5287742019,
0.3972738087,
1.070589304,
-0.3396612108,
0.8701971173,
0.6130789518,
-0.4008519053,
0.2149462104,
0.6667175889,
-0.0642178059,
0.5083751678,
0.2336883545,
-0.337249279,
-0.2941848338,
0.0614061803,
-0.5411538482,
0.3493219912,
0.1812436581,
-0.0778356269,
-0.0167584307,
0.0644204542,
-0.0574497692,
0.2140989751,
0.0393332914,
0.8398830891,
-0.1435739696,
-0.923291564,
0.7178804874,
0.093654424,
0.7028458714,
-0.6448600292,
-0.068722181,
-0.1323350817,
0.5075768232,
-0.1148795635,
-0.713747859,
0.6715575457,
-0.2943130732,
-0.2114096135,
-0.3480221629,
0.8331074715,
-0.7054191232,
-0.3892529905,
0.3283789456,
0.1873481423,
-0.016110355,
-0.1456763297,
-0.6056414843,
0.7273198366,
0.3548044562,
-0.3023346961,
0.6772492528,
0.2010981739,
0.0184520259,
0.7105293274,
0.6898574829,
0.4593187869,
-0.1309881806,
0.038551271,
1.1603746414,
-0.255020678,
-0.3998690546,
-0.7972871065,
0.5980333686,
-0.2685730755,
-0.0122901862,
0.8194962144,
0.5115838647,
0.6053379774,
0.1354185641,
0.3321399391,
-0.1402616203,
0.5586181879,
-0.2045807242,
0.5120988488,
-0.8029389381,
0.5890945792,
0.0735637918,
-1.2643868923,
-0.3228414655,
0.2821633816,
-0.4477337599,
0.0697437599,
0.2591982782,
0.7069658637,
-0.2146445811,
-0.3510691822,
0.3479223251,
0.2305613756,
0.5972786546,
0.2318468392,
0.5788139701,
-0.1468480527,
0.5565225482,
-0.4797807336,
-0.5826143026,
-0.2333832234,
-0.8542073369,
-0.3206124902,
-0.6359058022,
-0.6632055044,
-0.2105656266,
0.0178759117,
0.3484393954,
0.9572621584,
-0.4499967992,
-0.0350506678,
-0.146703735,
-0.0362967439,
-0.2787739038,
-0.2456506789,
0.2271571457,
-0.3020281494,
-1.2801032066,
0.7021659017,
0.2696849108,
-0.2299192846,
-0.5869607329,
0.1172084063,
-0.320064038,
0.1806922704,
0.3073014021,
0.3046055436,
-0.4854095578,
0.0655240268,
-0.6383736134,
0.2367138714,
-0.2599483132,
0.8526493311,
-0.6577692032,
0.3792195916,
0.8968054056,
0.4587486982,
0.573564589,
0.3035967648,
1.0068202019,
-0.910416007,
0.5341340303,
0.3779889047,
0.1244207844,
0.3924251497,
-0.4019769728,
0.3223249912,
0.0053526997,
-0.7551037669,
-1.3970555067,
0.5502997041,
-1.0064214468,
-0.5471144915,
1.0832709074,
-0.0857198238,
-0.0436210297,
0.261435926,
-0.2140194178,
0.5221624374,
-0.2160507143,
0.6195022464,
0.5230318308,
-0.059164416,
-0.1364593804,
-0.3514290154,
0.6250793934,
0.4180689454,
-0.4226128459,
0.3750962615,
0.5535055995,
0.0820336863,
0.3323662281,
0.2109645903,
-0.2135041654,
-0.1235075742,
0.1990182996,
-0.1849181801,
-0.3728323579,
-0.4472251236,
-0.3873995841,
0.5140579343,
0.3325512409,
-0.3228617013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02795v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02795v2
|
Evaluating and Optimizing Educational Content with Large Language Model Judgments
| 2024-03-05T09:09:15 | 2024-05-06T04:54:19 |
Joy He-Yueya, Noah D. Goodman, Emma Brunskill
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Creating effective educational materials generally requires expensive and
time-consuming studies of student learning outcomes. To overcome this barrier,
one idea is to build computational models of student learning and use them to
optimize instructional materials. However, it is difficult to model the
cognitive processes of learning dynamics. We propose an alternative approach
that uses Language Models (LMs) as educational experts to assess the impact of
various instructions on learning outcomes. Specifically, we use GPT-3.5 to
evaluate the overall effect of instructional materials on different student
groups and find that it can replicate well-established educational findings
such as the Expertise Reversal Effect and the Variability Effect. This
demonstrates the potential of LMs as reliable evaluators of educational
content. Building on this insight, we introduce an instruction optimization
approach in which one LM generates instructional materials using the judgments
of another LM as a reward function. We apply this approach to create math word
problem worksheets aimed at maximizing student learning gains. Human teachers'
evaluations of these LM-generated worksheets show a significant alignment
between the LM judgments and human teacher preferences. We conclude by
discussing potential divergences between human and LM opinions and the
resulting pitfalls of automating instructional design.
|
[
-0.1659417748,
-0.9497472048,
0.5821377635,
-0.0220404025,
-0.0554472692,
0.2620619833,
-0.4927122295,
-0.0579179674,
-0.1069091707,
0.2670991719,
-0.3499573171,
-0.3408053517,
-0.5673783422,
-0.2040409893,
-0.2473128885,
0.9610205889,
-0.2142649591,
0.2694464922,
-0.2840329707,
0.2422209233,
-0.5873357654,
-0.3569946885,
-0.6431872249,
-0.5570563078,
0.4494392276,
0.5191215873,
0.8627016544,
0.7035470605,
0.4225682914,
0.3113158047,
0.1881819218,
-0.0150240315,
-0.5390281677,
-0.217968598,
-0.3193910718,
-0.3230103254,
-0.2157597393,
0.2421864569,
0.4224379063,
0.8557217121,
-0.5083920956,
0.0764811486,
0.2270090878,
0.7425180674,
-0.6683447957,
0.2371037602,
-0.3287484646,
0.2045941949,
0.2184722871,
-0.3150329888,
-0.4434483647,
-0.6526499987,
0.4037743211,
-0.414062053,
-0.0123093901,
-0.292386204,
0.5302069783,
0.1392707676,
-0.0686140358,
-0.6656455994,
-0.7414457202,
1.056137085,
-0.5726552606,
0.5456340909,
0.5052254796,
0.1825324446,
-0.0708001703,
-0.3258598447,
-0.4455842674,
-0.3274617493,
0.1583032161,
0.4009528458,
0.0620020144,
-0.1070722789,
0.0575153381,
0.2673371732,
-0.4559232295,
0.2018431723,
-0.4868383408,
-0.1232752651,
0.5862678289,
0.3629404008,
0.5452715158,
-0.1410205066,
-0.3235575557,
-0.333111465,
-0.5857758522,
0.088946119,
0.7239367962,
0.3192266524,
0.0758363754,
0.6093677282,
0.1582549661,
0.6961672306,
-0.2552765906,
-0.4315189719,
0.0780348703,
-0.0501875095,
0.0844769925,
-0.2530978918,
0.5314363837,
0.3057787418,
0.2634956539,
-0.2337867171,
-0.3606445491,
0.2855360508,
0.4693099856,
-0.8624283671,
-0.3418638706,
-0.1595250368,
-0.1934248358,
-0.3288185596,
0.0729736611,
-0.7113804221,
-0.1318833083,
-0.8407300711,
0.6918729544,
-0.4700865149,
-0.0802959278,
0.3807984591,
0.0761416852,
-0.0586983301,
0.475684464,
-0.9235754609,
0.3950593472,
0.5948661566,
0.5290571451,
-0.4323278069,
-0.2443476915,
-0.3763251603,
-0.1206561476,
-0.5321736336,
0.5444550514,
-0.7685192227,
-0.6623960137,
-0.0020094316,
-0.3094765246,
-0.0119479978,
-0.370098561,
0.4540184736,
-0.4829736948,
0.5003442764,
-0.2152540386,
-0.885738492,
-0.1428800821,
-0.0533858016,
-0.6863494515,
0.7424792051,
0.406393826,
-0.3793232441,
0.1774446815,
-0.619320333,
-0.371578306,
0.0998077318,
-0.2715199888,
-0.2288384438,
0.1089583486,
-0.1393594891,
0.1185134128,
-0.3796723485,
0.2164091319,
0.0585444309,
-0.3152108788,
0.3357243538,
-0.4219799638,
0.4923371971,
0.1941020638,
-0.4888702631,
-0.1337438077,
-0.3642783463,
0.0999776423,
0.1375118345,
-0.7726246715,
-0.5008817315,
0.2818620205,
-0.1436395794,
-0.0399589129,
0.2009214163,
-0.1499674618,
0.1715703309,
-0.2297256738,
0.0719379559,
1.025865674,
-0.1219384074,
0.5714096427,
-0.3059339523,
0.7736487389,
-0.3457547426,
0.0787850842,
0.0304702614,
-0.3242881894,
-0.6886103749,
0.0640386418,
0.254683286,
0.3849981129,
-0.822509706,
-0.0100475699,
-0.0233433209,
-0.3732903302,
-0.3732318282,
0.5627503991,
0.6309953332,
0.5008137226,
0.2015519887,
-0.4719853699,
-0.2288621515,
-0.8136949539,
-0.4931716621,
0.0059493883,
0.0060904617,
0.3338898718,
0.4352434874,
0.012297431,
0.8531578779,
-0.7966892123,
0.0852146447,
-0.1315909028,
0.2421074212,
0.1709624082,
0.4811451733,
0.4896848202,
-0.68317312,
-0.7017768621,
-0.2213677168,
-0.4800109863,
-0.1411297768,
-0.1306098253,
-0.3081414998,
0.2839558125,
0.1460479647,
-0.3618769646,
0.3367674053,
0.1039350033,
-0.1620223224,
0.5884891152,
-0.175041467,
0.0472270772,
-0.5836917162,
-0.2263766825,
0.2330917865,
0.1517841667,
-0.5372956991,
0.1694520563,
0.0702288449,
0.0142908795,
-0.2652879953,
0.5175778866,
-0.4656454325,
0.0745074227,
-0.2781533897,
0.2238094211,
0.0981710777,
0.6250842214,
0.1421764493,
0.8471637368,
0.1870669276,
-0.4025189579,
0.1970418245,
-0.046374172,
-0.6182237267,
0.6317147017,
-0.6221298575,
0.2852052748,
-0.2113789022,
-0.2184563726,
-0.5823888183,
-0.1317819655,
0.1614497751,
-0.3135668635,
0.4505589008,
0.0047272947,
-0.3426538706,
-0.4542168975,
-0.4529702067,
0.1282109916,
0.7075151801,
-0.4776128531,
0.513857305,
0.4758377373,
-0.321221143,
-0.5245732665,
-0.3778546154,
-0.0765036196,
-0.1583578438,
-0.1457427442,
0.1721933484,
-0.4900007844,
-0.4513410628,
0.1383062005,
-0.2820660472,
-0.0963565111,
0.1105231047,
0.0005434357,
0.6282981038,
-0.0837950557,
0.3296647966,
-0.0227837153,
-0.0345770866,
0.2199534625,
-0.4666483998,
0.3911851048,
-0.2018662691,
-0.4624633491,
0.0319914594,
0.2820308208,
0.150097236,
-0.1298041195,
0.5252301693,
0.3831507564,
-0.3439943194,
-0.3764445186,
-0.4443969727,
-0.2347847819,
-0.4799692333,
0.6662673354,
-0.1285958141,
-0.4189811647,
0.0733991116,
0.2260251641,
0.1095056459,
0.2268093675,
0.6357542276,
-0.0250346381,
1.1720776558,
0.5620317459,
0.060376592,
0.632932961,
-0.544380188,
0.2425730377,
-0.6378578544,
-0.2206763476,
-0.2955687344,
-0.0829849616,
-0.2277075797,
-0.411837697,
0.387787044,
0.0613404922,
-0.1813416034,
0.2621500194,
-0.5069078207,
0.7924312353,
0.5209719539,
0.4136939347,
0.1187984571,
0.117952846,
-0.2229263783,
-0.1450290531,
-0.7497252226,
-0.7212746739,
1.0452194214,
0.1701593846,
0.9717699885,
0.2131768167,
0.5226138234,
0.2223071307,
0.7191436887,
-0.9022114873,
0.4941060543,
-0.1565808505,
-0.4626633823,
-0.3973870575,
-0.7194125652,
-0.9774518013,
0.1624050587,
-0.2929211855,
-0.7056519985,
-0.317158699,
-0.1627570391,
-0.1716395617,
0.3509284854,
-0.9299907684,
0.9087900519,
-0.4837760925,
-0.7593221664,
-0.4256242514,
-0.149960652,
0.2024143636,
-0.4260245264,
0.5601206422,
0.0510505624,
0.0744760036,
0.8268073201,
-0.5131969452,
0.7587327957,
-0.1163268462,
-0.3464936614,
0.5634007454,
0.2572876811,
0.219573766,
-0.2109382153,
-0.1708285809,
-0.3617730737,
-0.2962153256,
-0.3335856795,
-0.9030510187,
0.7263819575,
-0.9480463266,
-0.8887078762,
-0.068801038,
-0.7812806368,
-0.0685422942,
0.2196905017,
-0.0822344199,
0.5507153273,
-0.0972410813,
-0.1761277318,
0.4230872393,
-0.3058881164,
0.3899253309,
0.7295612693,
-0.0288447421,
-0.2536454201,
1.4520822763,
0.3501915038,
0.4500042796,
0.178060025,
0.5677336454,
-0.3192924857,
-0.4212301373,
-0.3693310618,
0.0808923692,
-1.0560213327,
-0.0711147487,
-0.2036007941,
0.0272765402,
0.0208220817,
-0.3160455823,
-0.2467522025,
-0.3380999565,
-0.309605211,
0.0056079929,
-0.1049587429,
1.0033633709,
-0.0833884403,
0.3081216514,
-0.65252316,
0.0524765626,
0.6581144929,
0.3554202616,
0.2415432185,
-0.5302752852,
-0.5337437987,
0.3140367568,
-0.5694976449,
-0.7871026993,
0.4797994494,
0.0624685548,
0.7078225613,
0.2738011777,
-0.1061311513,
0.2981636524,
-0.5364954472,
0.4640183747,
0.3023347259,
-1.081217289,
0.3904152215,
-0.1824797243,
0.1969085783,
0.2151730508,
0.4944857061,
-0.1788615286,
-0.2861504555,
-0.5786899924,
-0.7135772705,
0.695543468,
0.1205571517,
0.3334442973,
-0.0879537836,
0.3216819763,
0.2587401271,
0.2480416596,
-0.4331268072,
-0.0682392344,
-0.1852647662,
-0.4107979238,
-0.079576239,
-0.1184377,
-0.1166115701,
-0.1326351911,
0.5740095377,
-0.071511209,
-0.0708021522,
-0.126332134,
-0.2234048843,
-0.2112011611,
0.2792933285,
0.6192288995,
0.9941731095,
-0.0458985493,
0.0246077292,
0.2084156424,
-0.6066116095,
0.0386380404,
-0.1721426845,
-0.1671474725,
-0.1512328684,
0.3453190029,
0.6290018559,
0.456402868,
-0.6334264874,
0.5337612629,
-0.0353416204,
-0.0415004045,
-0.2156383693,
0.2919217646,
0.0888073817,
0.0822491124,
0.341624558,
-0.0453148484,
0.062653318,
-0.6248785257,
0.1338244826,
0.3484015465,
-0.2044458836,
-0.3504154682,
0.4969765544,
0.0908918083,
-0.6818364859,
0.5167888999,
0.018561855,
-0.6937257648,
0.8601629734,
0.5753690004,
0.746432364,
-0.5305216312,
0.3891264498,
0.4135216475,
0.1405323148,
-0.1617423296,
0.1657728553,
-0.0475656353,
-0.680098176,
-0.3807938695,
-0.4485044479,
-0.7881217599,
-0.2971719503,
-0.7591638565,
0.2827440202,
-0.3335754871,
-0.1404560506,
0.2593708336,
-0.0759657472,
-0.756362617,
0.2859784067,
0.006248991,
0.4237707555,
-0.6891701221,
0.5887895823,
0.7311394215,
-0.5188728571,
-0.9855676293,
-0.2200255543,
-0.1206485853,
-0.8319189548,
0.7636556625,
-0.0586841702,
-0.1429055482,
-0.1413763314,
-0.5053137541,
-0.562006712,
0.6968967319,
0.4456607401,
-0.3664012253,
-0.0783977956,
0.2078639716,
0.4986855388,
-0.39749524,
0.4931794405,
0.3517687023,
0.3910302222,
0.0448138863,
-0.5583484769,
-0.1154842302,
-0.2366741449,
-0.004759192,
0.2513732612,
-0.3627055585,
0.9089236856,
-0.4698208272,
-0.2774211168,
-0.2066169977,
0.3547798991,
0.1217366606,
0.1113900766,
0.5392957926,
0.3968859315,
0.622353673,
0.1257852614,
1.0976341963,
-0.3870310485,
0.5474085808,
0.9766534567,
0.1829733849,
0.6448374987,
0.4733674228,
-0.5279630423,
0.551946938,
0.6462749243,
-0.1063474417,
0.3377292752,
0.573055923,
-0.1375795156,
-0.26646927,
0.003232178,
-0.3008484244,
0.3461100757,
0.4196358919,
-0.0971359536,
-0.2242278308,
-0.2026475221,
0.0393231511,
0.3665190637,
-0.2761162817,
0.4779258072,
0.0317148492,
-0.7721082568,
0.5297732353,
0.064650245,
0.2667168677,
-0.2937049866,
-0.2519375086,
-0.1765703857,
0.1409279406,
-0.104340747,
-0.7254931927,
0.086837098,
0.0303312913,
-0.0540685952,
-0.0547999963,
0.4438771904,
-0.7386539578,
-0.7360290289,
0.0692504644,
0.5124616623,
0.1116445586,
0.3625899255,
-0.6298016906,
-0.0341029987,
-0.1340964288,
-0.3018622994,
0.2843912244,
0.1616646647,
0.1105430052,
0.6016362906,
0.6710405946,
0.0777478814,
-0.2753542364,
0.1844831258,
0.7637015581,
-0.4680784643,
-0.3340637982,
-0.9292783737,
0.4037124813,
0.053054288,
-0.1597539485,
0.7040699124,
0.5697138906,
0.9141005278,
-0.1620996296,
0.8606590629,
0.3526520133,
0.2932615578,
-0.5908795595,
0.5197520852,
-0.5421043038,
0.5347675085,
-0.6615967155,
-1.0042624474,
0.032104969,
0.7808716893,
-0.5130078197,
0.2808322906,
0.7394136786,
0.4335609674,
0.0775486901,
0.2352085114,
0.1937202811,
-0.0672724918,
0.2243170142,
0.7748551369,
0.9514437318,
-0.2055822462,
0.3599374294,
-0.3602859974,
-0.370426327,
-0.022868257,
-0.7193821669,
-1.0435661077,
-0.3862772584,
-0.3358376026,
-0.1505989283,
0.0037633104,
1.0490562916,
0.3384385705,
-0.4791080654,
-0.4860776067,
-0.0849347115,
0.4516095221,
0.1255198568,
-0.2566259205,
0.5984781384,
-0.5120331049,
-0.9176752567,
0.2538124621,
0.0293122493,
0.2405188084,
-0.4569917619,
-0.3068300784,
0.2556912005,
0.3850695789,
0.5837256908,
0.0371276475,
-0.6454030275,
-0.2589423954,
0.2668324709,
-0.2801729739,
-0.093775779,
0.7955080867,
-0.4873421788,
0.677606523,
0.3281061351,
0.708902657,
0.4329108298,
-0.029871488,
0.6895608902,
-0.1388037056,
-0.251675576,
0.1499039233,
0.2497927845,
0.3429835737,
-0.1756832749,
0.6519514322,
0.1458338052,
-0.4942231774,
-0.790479064,
0.166547969,
-0.4295933843,
-0.3684532344,
1.0267953873,
-0.2775942087,
-0.1840982437,
0.2863562107,
-0.1964866519,
0.1740236431,
-0.3370304108,
1.1883087158,
0.9075415134,
-0.05899968,
-0.009830446,
-0.7583644986,
0.2515764832,
0.6982680559,
-0.7269808054,
-0.2617676556,
0.3382137716,
0.1643057019,
0.1418631822,
0.2647114396,
-0.0805640593,
0.2008067369,
-0.0598919578,
0.1260224581,
-0.0268568508,
-0.3030960262,
-0.0204204451,
-0.0467487946,
0.0127141029,
0.1265028715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15412v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15412v4
|
Towards Measuring and Modeling "Culture" in LLMs: A Survey
| 2024-03-05T08:29:36 | 2024-06-19T05:43:27 |
Muhammad Farid Adilazuarda, Sagnik Mukherjee, Pradhyumna Lavania, Siddhant Singh, Alham Fikri Aji, Jacki O'Neill, Ashutosh Modi, Monojit Choudhury
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We present a survey of more than 90 recent papers that aim to study cultural
representation and inclusion in large language models (LLMs). We observe that
none of the studies explicitly define "culture, which is a complex,
multifaceted concept; instead, they probe the models on some specially designed
datasets which represent certain aspects of "culture". We call these aspects
the proxies of culture, and organize them across two dimensions of demographic
and semantic proxies. We also categorize the probing methods employed. Our
analysis indicates that only certain aspects of ``culture,'' such as values and
objectives, have been studied, leaving several other interesting and important
facets, especially the multitude of semantic domains (Thompson et al., 2020)
and aboutness (Hershcovich et al., 2022), unexplored. Two other crucial gaps
are the lack of robustness of probing techniques and situated studies on the
impact of cultural mis- and under-representation in LLM-based applications.
|
[
-0.6601501107,
-0.6198633313,
0.4245946109,
0.179776594,
-0.0322104506,
0.2521041036,
-0.3697831333,
-0.5655249953,
0.649921298,
0.3548774123,
-0.4662165642,
-0.3802143931,
-0.5386840701,
0.0331934206,
-0.229589358,
0.5910663009,
-0.0400616117,
0.3974112272,
-0.5120396018,
-0.3296770751,
-0.2678273022,
-0.7814837694,
-0.0682730451,
-0.4250696301,
0.3545329571,
0.2874207199,
0.5079413056,
0.4798774123,
0.3130523264,
0.2781302631,
-0.3617331386,
0.1533937603,
-0.5126447082,
0.3946512043,
-0.1364611536,
-0.472314328,
-0.5490127802,
0.6757594347,
0.6613530517,
1.119592905,
0.1773288548,
0.4754024148,
0.2101880461,
0.396477133,
-0.5856186152,
0.049741596,
-0.2427740097,
0.1333885342,
-0.2431093007,
-0.177487269,
-0.1231770366,
-0.28621912,
-0.0983750373,
-0.0079255244,
0.0466170646,
0.0319171511,
0.3973128796,
-0.1264724731,
-1.1047792435,
-0.4517183602,
-0.9669254422,
1.1625326872,
-0.2656123638,
0.4428040385,
0.3877714574,
0.208019793,
-0.3116930723,
-0.5257197618,
-0.4685130417,
-0.3780635893,
0.0156530719,
0.2680554688,
-0.1294653118,
-0.2518852949,
-0.0080145439,
0.4489328265,
-0.3843658566,
0.1712877452,
-0.2378454506,
-0.3683836162,
0.6236566901,
0.4727895856,
0.3300251365,
0.0493996888,
-0.2826524973,
0.0728331655,
-0.9223940969,
0.0894832015,
0.3744391501,
-0.02713052,
-0.0550558679,
0.5053775907,
-0.0687680095,
0.3693049848,
-0.4258410633,
-0.1657379419,
0.1204660386,
-0.4466811419,
0.1742798984,
-0.281879425,
0.5353720784,
0.4074662328,
0.40471071,
-0.0261540227,
-0.0987955257,
0.067589432,
-0.0769334733,
-0.6720942855,
0.0094986111,
0.2559797764,
-0.4490400255,
-0.1948782951,
0.1290101856,
-0.4138188958,
-0.5179537535,
-0.1530387849,
-0.2080490887,
0.1673493981,
-0.607224822,
-0.2805548608,
-0.0655071288,
0.4717594087,
0.2724236548,
-0.6169511676,
0.124135755,
0.8255524635,
0.7015749216,
-0.1873749495,
-0.3183909953,
-0.0590314083,
0.1307822317,
-0.7005079985,
0.6691949368,
-0.6508990526,
-0.8753926754,
0.3609935939,
0.1585222036,
0.2385341525,
-0.6906654835,
0.5072512031,
-0.5628920794,
0.2698968053,
-0.5666671991,
-0.4846870303,
-0.1831357181,
0.6284618974,
-0.6400367022,
0.9524121284,
0.003052115,
-0.4445047379,
0.4431303442,
-0.3826543987,
-0.2542167902,
-0.021979576,
-0.3099075258,
0.1037070081,
0.2742840648,
-0.1450278461,
0.5216511488,
-0.3799622059,
0.4207007885,
-0.6002930999,
-0.5716056824,
0.6634945869,
-0.4766919017,
0.9267529249,
0.3943992555,
0.0339032598,
-0.0811332166,
-0.4680874944,
-0.034802448,
0.0543298684,
-0.4131868184,
-0.4200912416,
0.1641711891,
0.2067713439,
0.2446806282,
0.4623212814,
-0.5278832912,
0.2622921169,
-0.134157449,
0.4856924117,
0.3182388842,
-0.3213056326,
0.6694709063,
-0.1940209568,
0.7098481059,
0.1474625617,
0.2168362141,
-0.0297105499,
-0.3289043605,
-0.641279459,
-0.0519550443,
0.2345096916,
0.5361016393,
-0.4587920904,
0.1110696942,
-0.2157234848,
-0.695974052,
-0.2378395349,
0.0712119043,
0.1418291777,
0.0998771191,
-0.0848346651,
-0.5427268744,
-0.3541045487,
-0.8905362487,
-0.1034721062,
-0.5445635915,
-0.3228001595,
0.1998452842,
0.6161192656,
-0.2209693044,
0.9325067401,
-0.2977212071,
-0.3703493476,
-0.2278765142,
0.0019301753,
0.2069842368,
0.4259799421,
0.6833590269,
-0.7300639749,
-0.2027160972,
-0.1969452649,
-0.8181046247,
-0.2392170727,
0.5628470778,
0.2513666749,
0.0886455551,
0.6061178446,
-0.3942315578,
0.1282024533,
0.8784407973,
-0.271789968,
0.5230597258,
-0.0422817096,
0.1746123433,
-0.9656473398,
-0.1142515242,
0.1024108529,
0.0726253465,
-0.8756536245,
0.1145002916,
0.1520896852,
-0.1644984186,
-0.5608489513,
0.7772539854,
-0.6862061024,
-0.0785961822,
-0.3250228167,
0.2441725731,
0.1572017521,
0.1197102815,
0.2052871734,
0.7221508622,
0.4892574847,
-0.4217659235,
0.3727717996,
-0.0615370385,
-0.5401058197,
0.7794967294,
-0.4263883531,
0.1550584137,
-0.1908383965,
0.7941043973,
-0.9879017472,
-0.2575516999,
0.337623775,
-0.4341735542,
0.0096000638,
-0.3973296583,
-0.5543518662,
-0.203231439,
-0.3706051707,
0.5530723929,
0.5378345847,
-0.0335528515,
0.6702644229,
0.7115535736,
0.0201212466,
-0.4567947686,
-0.6952755451,
0.1886453778,
-0.6412654519,
-0.7558395267,
0.2615349889,
-0.0110757435,
-0.8645962477,
-0.2290532887,
-0.0917645469,
-0.0804687813,
0.3763177097,
0.2028247565,
0.0854534134,
-0.52527982,
-0.0377517752,
-0.4093282521,
0.0137123726,
0.2588167787,
-0.2501328886,
0.4933300912,
-0.2824487686,
-0.5283674598,
-0.0550888628,
0.6657025218,
0.6454738975,
-0.3400495648,
0.7513221502,
0.6713331342,
-0.2270161211,
-0.1440904289,
-0.6924649477,
-0.2099659443,
-0.4423220158,
0.2278181612,
-0.2293879688,
-1.3067859411,
0.9237405658,
-0.1511892378,
-0.0921285003,
0.3001248538,
0.4959325194,
-0.5134049058,
0.9062460065,
0.7431403995,
0.0412544683,
0.2966232002,
-0.0596671551,
0.3002054393,
-0.7498264909,
-0.1858595163,
-0.7784021497,
-0.3588674664,
-1.0723661184,
-0.4486136734,
0.6236082315,
0.0257736817,
-0.1328576356,
-0.247384876,
0.1253850311,
0.3027656376,
0.5632785559,
-0.48923859,
0.2725532353,
-0.3095893562,
0.150603205,
-0.313805759,
-0.6022763252,
-0.8197169304,
0.6902682185,
0.6468464732,
0.9680531621,
0.3926564157,
0.367384553,
0.0266516227,
0.5756989121,
-0.9973076582,
0.691655755,
-0.3386504948,
-0.9596831203,
-0.2347386628,
-0.0877930373,
-0.7520757318,
0.5049614906,
0.0687178001,
-0.8381406069,
0.4285098016,
0.1229569539,
-0.0116897449,
0.2502159774,
-0.4157706201,
0.5609036684,
-0.2025242299,
-0.3140428364,
0.0188157782,
-0.4761011302,
0.5756463408,
-0.048300419,
0.5088049769,
-0.4630058408,
0.0384294391,
0.7987287045,
-0.1364071816,
1.2000426054,
-0.0713669956,
-0.5063220263,
0.4682443142,
0.4530092478,
0.2211637348,
-0.098650977,
-0.000290798,
0.3338931203,
0.4716866612,
-0.4432242215,
-0.4787991047,
0.8050350547,
-0.5722764134,
-0.7765612602,
-0.5334286094,
-0.6407576203,
-0.5722805262,
-0.199148491,
-0.1679653227,
0.4249514341,
-0.2735069096,
0.5766470432,
0.7890390158,
-0.3082948327,
0.360247761,
0.5992683172,
-0.2164093107,
0.0444460586,
0.674084425,
0.5151032805,
0.2454448342,
0.111597769,
0.2661776543,
-0.4095926881,
-0.3952794075,
-0.3448180258,
0.226247102,
-0.8559556603,
0.3355489075,
-0.4267430902,
-0.0565434583,
-0.5309098363,
0.0453462824,
-0.2869139314,
-0.0873673707,
-0.2475093007,
0.1062436774,
0.0741631687,
0.6594073772,
0.1180999205,
0.3557119966,
-0.7436912656,
-0.219481498,
0.2220403701,
0.2506727576,
-0.1276631951,
-0.4211318791,
-0.2139843851,
-0.0531349592,
-0.1086136177,
-0.9013614655,
0.2533161044,
0.0078381822,
0.8063263297,
0.5617158413,
0.0697765276,
0.6007400155,
-0.2630612254,
1.2557661533,
-0.2318381071,
-0.6878455281,
0.3450346887,
-0.4646430314,
0.1934927255,
0.3558099866,
0.7050666809,
-0.927495718,
-0.5159626603,
-0.3647195399,
-0.7269014716,
0.3550160825,
-0.3353849649,
0.7584678531,
-0.1284852177,
0.0137325535,
-0.1634970903,
0.1560561806,
-0.6578065753,
-0.2660121024,
0.1354961991,
0.0037157333,
-0.0728850067,
-0.7830793858,
-0.2806664407,
-0.0704843253,
0.4019575119,
-0.0728657693,
-0.047824651,
-0.1065210775,
-0.3109327853,
0.0818236992,
0.3226341009,
0.563596487,
0.9981684089,
-0.1491489261,
0.4264621735,
0.2135946006,
-0.6080529094,
0.2139686942,
-0.3410116434,
-0.0333823971,
-0.0501998328,
0.5122210979,
0.2007816136,
-0.0203083232,
-0.4350063801,
0.3011765778,
0.0041147089,
-0.1039856002,
-0.6550566554,
0.0035944413,
0.1668679863,
0.3508608043,
0.4273625612,
-0.6350933909,
-0.1337658167,
-1.0332612991,
-0.1418550462,
0.6424425244,
-0.8161295652,
-0.3607667685,
0.5397592783,
0.2965361476,
-0.0565137453,
0.6486244202,
-0.0146613633,
-0.3023715913,
0.5350089669,
0.3377239406,
0.5739461184,
-0.2989887893,
0.1628174186,
-0.0119744008,
0.4876959622,
0.0287181139,
0.2456130981,
0.2446389198,
-1.1258764267,
-0.5511609316,
-0.6972604394,
-0.4425293803,
0.2128122449,
-0.4952359796,
0.0091864243,
0.0242218114,
-0.2541212142,
-0.2703158259,
0.1263877153,
-0.5129890442,
0.1509212404,
0.2301034629,
1.1973649263,
-1.353276372,
0.9455701709,
1.0533667803,
-0.2593306005,
-0.2900617123,
0.1796213388,
0.3835002482,
-0.6137686968,
0.6470833421,
-0.0462017581,
-0.3582626283,
-0.2819284797,
-0.4888118207,
-0.8162820339,
0.8716179132,
-0.0046559284,
-0.0684991479,
0.3973461092,
0.2014584392,
0.7177023292,
-0.4522157907,
0.23259601,
0.5959565639,
0.4774377346,
-0.0316280127,
-0.8856643438,
-0.2987728417,
-0.3248132169,
0.1313270479,
0.0401733331,
-0.6851378083,
0.7900111675,
0.2814606726,
-0.1055131927,
-0.0120033277,
0.8971998692,
0.2679424584,
0.5238589048,
0.5158246756,
-0.0476033799,
0.479998678,
-0.4393653572,
0.9635826945,
-0.1974773258,
0.1961868554,
0.7064861655,
-0.4921000302,
0.5508468151,
0.7937108874,
-0.394944191,
0.1055779234,
0.962561667,
0.1551195532,
0.0926789269,
0.5668831468,
-0.3574769199,
-0.3069113195,
-0.6954519749,
-0.2388892472,
0.7285323739,
0.6294013858,
-0.1789652854,
-0.0958874077,
-0.2191439271,
0.4257643819,
0.0989221483,
-0.1594287008,
0.6203579307,
0.2093023956,
-0.6122695208,
0.1703273654,
0.189986974,
0.7599107027,
-0.6848605871,
0.1546551883,
-0.921843648,
-0.4143701196,
0.0579253882,
-1.0761965513,
0.3025511801,
-0.1173809469,
-0.1240545809,
-0.5313580036,
0.6764589548,
-0.3753560483,
-0.4062703252,
0.152362287,
1.0372174978,
0.4244722724,
0.1330316216,
0.006069968,
0.3914369345,
-0.3557396531,
-0.3705657125,
0.4927352965,
0.4726629555,
-0.6707407236,
0.6431232095,
0.2913041115,
0.0736152083,
-0.1332088709,
0.2713678777,
0.4260883629,
-0.745798409,
-0.2167087495,
-0.8635943532,
0.4927705526,
0.0853859335,
-0.3963780999,
0.7799875736,
0.3680075109,
1.0558668375,
0.1008725688,
0.5931712389,
-0.1077592447,
0.1642661989,
-0.3906182945,
0.7614491582,
-0.6121901274,
0.2454043627,
-0.1078089327,
-0.9651175737,
-0.2691085339,
0.2927801013,
-0.3107175827,
0.1763223559,
0.2887416482,
0.9252967238,
-0.1130824685,
0.0329598449,
0.4484283328,
0.1758194715,
0.2636858523,
-0.0301834065,
1.5436493158,
0.2488743067,
0.155854091,
-0.2452095896,
-0.2462278754,
-0.2840086818,
-1.1139987707,
-0.5534680486,
-0.8764088154,
-0.3093450963,
-0.1966674477,
-0.3991563022,
0.8089635372,
0.6018582582,
-0.7142649293,
-0.5683995485,
0.8948631287,
0.0748601332,
-0.1429886818,
-0.1482915431,
-0.007975434,
0.0152880708,
-0.9818432927,
0.4748747349,
0.0879577994,
0.0346270688,
-1.0117772818,
0.1348778307,
0.2264179289,
0.0612142421,
0.8817383051,
0.0435386226,
-0.8180651665,
-0.2824948132,
0.1184503287,
0.0639410689,
-0.1448166817,
0.9146479964,
-0.3462487161,
0.2263584286,
0.5401520729,
0.2902776599,
0.134165138,
-0.3252460361,
0.465313226,
-0.8755017519,
0.1343319416,
0.165792793,
0.4359546304,
0.400675416,
0.0286957435,
0.5278221369,
0.2286556214,
-0.3581829965,
-0.9835964441,
0.5132877827,
-0.7917332053,
-0.3231333196,
1.2751084566,
-0.0204923898,
-0.1682443321,
-0.1358031482,
0.2020165473,
0.0376106091,
0.1875742078,
0.6633428335,
0.9372375011,
-0.0155385239,
0.063353695,
-1.2120864391,
0.1159447655,
0.2463347465,
-0.3856181204,
-0.1323271394,
0.753392458,
0.456061393,
0.326038301,
0.503249526,
-0.4082517624,
-0.0796563849,
-0.3534183204,
-0.1279045045,
0.2018579692,
-0.2777815759,
-0.3308415711,
0.2588642538,
0.3048275113,
0.0041691158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02757v1
|
In-Memory Learning: A Declarative Learning Framework for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-05T08:25:11 | 2024-03-05T08:25:11 |
Bo Wang, Tianxiang Sun, Hang Yan, Siyin Wang, Qingyuan Cheng, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The exploration of whether agents can align with their environment without
relying on human-labeled data presents an intriguing research topic. Drawing
inspiration from the alignment process observed in intelligent organisms, where
declarative memory plays a pivotal role in summarizing past experiences, we
propose a novel learning framework. The agents adeptly distill insights from
past experiences, refining and updating existing notes to enhance their
performance in the environment. This entire process transpires within the
memory components and is implemented through natural language, so we character
this framework as In-memory Learning. We also delve into the key features of
benchmarks designed to evaluate the self-improvement process. Through
systematic experiments, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework and
provide insights into this problem.
|
[
-0.0852530971,
-0.5813107491,
0.791318953,
-0.3437489867,
0.060048189,
0.4139142931,
-0.4359886944,
-0.5381465554,
0.0077402964,
0.3692376018,
-0.5591067076,
-0.451815933,
-0.1797045916,
0.0228283498,
-0.2240472734,
0.9198212028,
-0.0561819747,
-0.0422153175,
-0.7143774629,
-0.4027315378,
-0.6899405122,
-0.4658243358,
-0.7836350203,
-0.6599531174,
0.2829138339,
0.5168544054,
0.7004737258,
0.9826592803,
0.5646989942,
0.3754765391,
0.1946485192,
0.2978660166,
-0.4784111977,
0.3848696351,
-0.5750871897,
-0.5188677311,
-0.3051071167,
-0.076055117,
0.8882862926,
0.6860911846,
-0.2279697359,
-0.0402679853,
0.1269628257,
0.8983685374,
-0.4661157131,
0.3866102397,
-0.6800338626,
0.113901265,
0.0131893158,
-0.1630855203,
-0.4972690344,
-0.4569239318,
0.0744982809,
-0.5616876483,
0.0686620623,
-0.0360611714,
0.8153774142,
0.4764179885,
-0.0962575674,
-0.5711818933,
-0.6148599982,
0.7844135761,
-0.7634239197,
0.4601509869,
0.3232859373,
0.3029245734,
-0.3464276195,
-0.5269967914,
-0.4222690761,
-0.1712110788,
0.093761228,
0.0653843582,
0.2474047244,
0.0764073282,
0.0776710361,
0.268889159,
-0.5000703335,
0.1436714977,
-0.201123476,
-0.0741681755,
0.4059444666,
0.2078284323,
0.275000304,
0.5800933838,
-0.4972552359,
-0.2759957314,
-0.3937841654,
-0.153503567,
0.2714264989,
0.5521628261,
0.1172482595,
0.1625940949,
0.0654293299,
0.7378131747,
0.2854605019,
-0.3697174788,
0.4298734069,
0.0440074168,
-0.1095295995,
0.5458366871,
0.3009124696,
0.2143812329,
0.1066733375,
-0.5470263362,
-0.4813025594,
0.0854105726,
0.5536851883,
-0.9020451307,
-0.2514879704,
0.0532232858,
-0.3968522251,
-0.074059397,
-0.031971328,
-0.8066073656,
-0.4739480019,
-0.4708182514,
0.4871816933,
-0.7900477648,
-0.2815347016,
0.0378019586,
-0.21690844,
0.3832662404,
0.3278253078,
-1.135337472,
0.6216892004,
0.8754208684,
0.7623137236,
-0.1071879938,
-0.5827727914,
-0.4057222605,
0.4350827932,
-0.4650693536,
0.8598504663,
-0.9792017937,
-0.2069519609,
-0.0529069826,
-0.1656712294,
-0.2541173398,
-0.8918778896,
0.117165871,
-0.5483806133,
0.1262237579,
-0.5227362514,
-0.9667292833,
-0.4714735448,
0.3658683598,
-0.5034629107,
0.7631363869,
0.284011662,
-0.3145917654,
0.5494894385,
-0.8123995662,
-0.1471427679,
0.0626591817,
-0.3083801866,
-0.3161150515,
-0.0496516041,
-0.2025030404,
0.0816898122,
-0.1875011176,
0.1622744352,
-0.2959643304,
-0.3671515584,
0.4120895565,
-0.2493011504,
0.4854513705,
0.1782997102,
-0.1242469773,
-0.0475684926,
-0.7087131143,
-0.0712309405,
-0.0052531995,
-0.46466887,
-0.3441290855,
0.0471748374,
-0.6396926045,
0.1965641379,
0.4759552479,
-0.5953760743,
0.2899330258,
-0.6548408866,
0.5527141094,
0.7633651495,
0.1502254903,
0.9343611002,
-0.6345275044,
0.2614890635,
0.3031184375,
0.0766200423,
-0.4516356587,
-0.0419556908,
-0.539078176,
-0.2961470187,
-0.0411354899,
0.1533382237,
-0.391141057,
0.2261542529,
-0.2475034446,
-0.326567322,
-0.3247214258,
0.4887371957,
0.5702372193,
0.8169881701,
0.4001050889,
-0.4575174153,
-0.358499229,
-0.6847203374,
-0.096966669,
-0.3929411471,
0.2030750364,
0.1989637613,
0.5850335956,
-0.3972846866,
1.1122865677,
-0.257117331,
-0.1814230978,
-0.133937031,
0.0528343916,
-0.0607692823,
0.7132436633,
0.4597872496,
-0.6962140203,
-0.2888815999,
0.2062985599,
-0.9426804781,
0.3707673252,
-0.22450234,
-0.1116225645,
0.2510640919,
0.6308124065,
-0.5331007838,
-0.0158527177,
0.1832037419,
-0.1967392862,
0.100468412,
-0.5778721571,
-0.148753956,
-0.9002923369,
-0.1623183489,
-0.1546291113,
-0.1626163125,
-0.5368386507,
-0.1273839027,
0.3962296844,
0.1270936579,
-0.2882626057,
0.6231886148,
-0.6975830197,
-0.0787038058,
-0.3909052312,
0.2136584073,
-0.0340640172,
0.6539321542,
-0.0087685203,
0.4933947623,
0.4611804485,
-0.6397833824,
0.1582697183,
0.2832684517,
-0.0783034191,
0.7235676646,
-0.0993226692,
0.2863100171,
-0.6433998942,
0.1256193519,
-0.9334850907,
-0.2168123573,
0.2517481446,
-0.3366837502,
0.6538575888,
0.1015251055,
-0.4298890531,
-0.0465598516,
-0.0039907373,
0.3356510103,
0.4937805831,
-0.7256442308,
0.7894827724,
0.3092559576,
0.2371177971,
-0.3396635354,
-0.3776762784,
0.0159965083,
-0.5778060555,
-0.1754132956,
0.349353224,
-0.1516471952,
-0.508892417,
0.0941360742,
-0.213797763,
-0.1352436244,
0.0512793176,
0.3071151674,
0.1225556955,
-0.3990378976,
0.7516133189,
-0.3759112656,
-0.0234603118,
0.0572318062,
-0.5298856497,
0.5208909512,
-0.3204999566,
-0.3228100836,
-0.2358234823,
0.0090589756,
0.5967559814,
-0.42553702,
0.5849621296,
0.0389180407,
-0.5627939105,
-0.5089533329,
-0.4681921303,
-0.2792524099,
-0.5492581129,
0.2241924554,
-0.2060818076,
-0.509133637,
0.5431908369,
-0.288790673,
0.0188648738,
0.1691252887,
0.1768680215,
-0.3073483407,
0.6844436526,
0.9607223868,
-0.1686339378,
0.5346218348,
-0.2391748875,
0.0085331108,
-0.7295200825,
-0.3274410963,
-0.3141583204,
-0.4998551905,
-0.1485237926,
-0.2962450385,
-0.0024138147,
-0.1671981364,
-0.6134464741,
0.3736383617,
-0.5048567653,
0.6773707867,
0.2444995046,
0.1393638849,
0.0267875493,
-0.3819444478,
-0.0858390927,
0.0798642784,
-0.4532885551,
-0.6163906455,
0.8787980676,
0.3618261814,
0.6671215892,
0.0693765059,
0.7942572236,
0.1823846996,
0.412358135,
-0.6285349131,
0.5302758217,
0.2674997151,
-0.4570701718,
-0.4584090114,
-0.1522721946,
-0.9817970991,
0.2586336732,
0.117130667,
-0.9072733521,
0.2557190359,
0.0542066097,
-0.4973819256,
0.4063901603,
-0.5926011801,
1.0564054251,
-0.6880502701,
-0.5399874449,
-0.3041658998,
-0.7486757636,
0.0235329587,
-0.2081797272,
-0.058423236,
-0.0545468256,
-0.4169449508,
0.5823171735,
-0.2974572182,
1.1447709799,
-0.2923614681,
-0.0511095412,
0.3025484979,
0.0977747589,
0.4947081208,
-0.2774131,
-0.2556528747,
-0.2924750447,
-0.1133146435,
-0.3769081235,
-0.8246398568,
0.5418236852,
-0.6024781466,
-0.3633078039,
-0.4107770622,
-0.7005862594,
-0.4545049667,
0.1376277059,
-0.2227895856,
0.5068610907,
-0.4217077792,
0.1183675006,
1.0465909243,
-0.0549198091,
0.8688257933,
0.7771875262,
-0.2048472613,
-0.4064469039,
1.1077843904,
0.1764381528,
0.3367536664,
0.6072821021,
0.1698456109,
-0.456389606,
-0.5172613263,
-0.3456122577,
0.5080991983,
-0.806219697,
-0.2859370112,
-0.5840180516,
-0.1393856704,
-0.0260769539,
-0.4391895831,
-0.4360930026,
0.047199849,
-0.4273219407,
-0.2941594422,
0.2283871323,
0.8703792095,
0.0717364997,
0.1634384692,
-0.8289508224,
-0.0484426133,
0.3235467374,
0.1484942436,
0.1837845594,
-0.5373952389,
-0.6478909254,
0.2709095478,
-0.5529376268,
-0.8385710716,
0.6138362288,
0.5499766469,
0.898783803,
0.7353515625,
-0.0500670858,
0.9420101047,
-0.2602817118,
0.5198103786,
-0.0907163695,
-0.7598586679,
0.5591811538,
-0.2761970162,
0.4256595373,
0.8822163939,
0.3198218048,
-0.3724115789,
-0.4317533672,
-0.8181785345,
-0.6171748042,
0.4014810324,
-0.276037246,
0.0424788073,
-0.1214272082,
0.5596241951,
0.2247457206,
0.5108187199,
-0.3363579512,
0.1873210073,
-0.0780774951,
-0.3226798475,
-0.2741128504,
-0.0534740612,
-0.0642129034,
-0.311325103,
0.5838988423,
-0.4229496121,
0.0340252444,
0.1235200837,
-0.4223940372,
-0.2812877893,
-0.1070028096,
0.5566901565,
0.8610872626,
-0.2358182073,
0.2178615481,
0.3272208869,
-0.3006617725,
0.3131507337,
-0.3210807443,
0.0108671775,
-0.3547620177,
0.2187912762,
0.3872767985,
0.5296593308,
-0.9152065516,
0.4369866252,
0.0165775772,
0.0430487357,
-0.5540701151,
0.1777899712,
0.0630654469,
0.4644157588,
0.274325043,
0.1997867525,
0.0435054228,
-0.915424943,
0.4852344394,
0.5385510325,
-0.7630049586,
-0.4153111577,
0.6208785176,
-0.0941873416,
-0.3918789625,
0.8787466288,
-0.3647180796,
-0.3880977035,
0.8193539381,
0.9378017187,
1.0167386532,
-0.2379098982,
0.2010097355,
0.4910381436,
0.1320761442,
-0.3921372592,
0.0288360957,
-0.3982553184,
-1.0055223703,
-0.006069615,
-0.698449254,
-0.4684900641,
-0.2423637509,
-0.5102183819,
-0.1005008966,
-0.6140300035,
0.0479064137,
-0.1642584205,
0.1200518906,
-0.4332677424,
0.2692975402,
0.2781836987,
0.7612837553,
-0.8215347528,
1.1338984966,
0.7670328021,
-0.6755039692,
-0.5667398572,
0.132913053,
-0.0161634088,
-0.6440674663,
0.6229006052,
0.5362862945,
-0.2707261443,
-0.0071935952,
-0.4540129006,
-1.1859693527,
1.2321623564,
0.5770797133,
-0.2025939077,
0.050632555,
0.0067897979,
0.842692554,
-0.7017352581,
0.1834274083,
0.6543790102,
0.45736745,
0.037389826,
-0.5732011795,
0.0104476362,
-0.2316412628,
0.0064568506,
0.3199339211,
-1.0267096758,
0.9169911146,
-0.2002194971,
-0.4582191408,
-0.1032590345,
0.9824801683,
-0.1173926219,
0.2899818718,
0.2545745671,
0.7723186016,
1.209422946,
0.2261806577,
0.5263834596,
-0.2485048622,
-0.0019442842,
1.4367665052,
-0.5645179152,
0.7605978251,
0.5424077511,
0.1323449612,
0.8158553839,
0.5499296188,
0.054524783,
0.6877172589,
0.1170845404,
-0.3494536877,
-0.2622460127,
-0.0750672072,
-0.0871133879,
0.5421039462,
0.5910388827,
-0.3638996482,
-0.3760472536,
0.0748361349,
-0.1032364815,
0.5610266328,
-0.3195712566,
1.1213849783,
-0.0349592119,
-0.6964640617,
0.4305424392,
-0.6245890856,
0.3188847899,
-0.5515287519,
-0.4521593153,
-0.2434375733,
0.5539153218,
-0.1600043923,
-0.5404611826,
0.3294151425,
-0.506193161,
-0.2762022316,
-0.5048140287,
0.5229820013,
-0.5314503312,
-0.1335306913,
0.3562209904,
0.3587606847,
0.2136488408,
0.0809787512,
-0.5655575991,
-0.066995278,
-0.1178877354,
0.0163293891,
0.620742023,
0.6685742736,
-0.0492735542,
1.0378564596,
0.2507168353,
-0.0551180355,
-0.2305222452,
-0.2577577233,
0.7963631749,
-0.8034085035,
-0.3299037814,
-1.0569796562,
0.4196019769,
-0.1941584051,
-0.1526105404,
0.8196431398,
0.9876285195,
1.129840374,
0.0613319539,
0.7263106704,
0.3235937655,
0.4496240318,
-0.4139629602,
0.5447525382,
-0.302097559,
0.2298288196,
0.0367965028,
-0.7635335326,
0.0079588573,
0.5310454369,
-0.2846285999,
-0.1032706946,
0.9026794434,
1.075734973,
0.1192706525,
0.0093765985,
0.4717987478,
0.1465623081,
0.2011245191,
0.7058287263,
1.0219222307,
-0.1912014931,
0.2318166345,
-0.2261521965,
0.003767546,
0.0838060752,
-0.7479061484,
-0.8796700835,
-0.8572409749,
-0.3607928753,
-0.0600767769,
0.2206882834,
1.2966886759,
0.3628654778,
-0.581826508,
-0.417003572,
-0.3143829107,
0.0614094995,
-0.62778759,
-0.1214517802,
0.0868810788,
-0.8801466823,
-0.6474870443,
0.6812471151,
0.5639573336,
0.2598840892,
-0.2107187808,
-0.2708332837,
-0.0353296548,
0.1205855012,
0.1912116259,
0.736230433,
-0.4326893687,
-0.2842713892,
-0.2527843714,
-0.2291976959,
0.5686979294,
0.6484592557,
-1.0280529261,
0.5685008168,
0.1867863685,
0.7362675071,
0.355129987,
0.2169238776,
0.6718007922,
-0.3393736184,
0.0893003866,
0.4551124871,
0.328383863,
0.4801338911,
-0.4506497085,
0.38092044,
-0.0406855121,
-0.7645769119,
-0.617164135,
0.0259736646,
-0.7458043694,
-0.3990041316,
0.9252783656,
-0.0043033431,
-0.5846161842,
-0.1702305526,
-0.1322182417,
0.1599833369,
-0.5133710504,
0.8543885946,
0.528580904,
-0.2051803619,
0.0269517154,
-0.4337720275,
0.6999638081,
0.0471149422,
-0.7060554028,
0.0186331701,
0.7732953429,
0.2212762833,
0.1194348335,
0.6198166013,
-0.1242410615,
0.111111775,
0.1048154756,
0.1399597228,
0.1163120419,
-0.5267532468,
-0.5001292229,
0.1996745467,
0.3012055159,
-0.3073911369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02756v1
|
Role Prompting Guided Domain Adaptation with General Capability Preserve for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-05T08:22:41 | 2024-03-05T08:22:41 |
Rui Wang, Fei Mi, Yi Chen, Boyang Xue, Hongru Wang, Qi Zhu, Kam-Fai Wong, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growing interest in Large Language Models (LLMs) for specialized
applications has revealed a significant challenge: when tailored to specific
domains, LLMs tend to experience catastrophic forgetting, compromising their
general capabilities and leading to a suboptimal user experience. Additionally,
crafting a versatile model for multiple domains simultaneously often results in
a decline in overall performance due to confusion between domains. In response
to these issues, we present the RolE Prompting Guided Multi-Domain Adaptation
(REGA) strategy. This novel approach effectively manages multi-domain LLM
adaptation through three key components: 1) Self-Distillation constructs and
replays general-domain exemplars to alleviate catastrophic forgetting. 2) Role
Prompting assigns a central prompt to the general domain and a unique role
prompt to each specific domain to minimize inter-domain confusion during
training. 3) Role Integration reuses and integrates a small portion of
domain-specific data to the general-domain data, which are trained under the
guidance of the central prompt. The central prompt is used for a streamlined
inference process, removing the necessity to switch prompts for different
domains. Empirical results demonstrate that REGA effectively alleviates
catastrophic forgetting and inter-domain confusion. This leads to improved
domain-specific performance compared to standard fine-tuned models, while still
preserving robust general capabilities.
|
[
-0.3166645765,
-0.716881454,
0.5460545421,
0.3945629895,
-0.2552538812,
0.1028342918,
-0.3289884031,
-0.0631664917,
-0.0030842654,
0.4783922434,
-0.7212379575,
-0.3982685506,
-0.4888891578,
0.2693540156,
0.1559296697,
0.8906926513,
-0.0983104482,
0.112978898,
-0.3908433318,
-0.1810841411,
-1.2573789358,
-0.6279858351,
-0.8438646793,
-0.171388343,
0.4198779166,
0.5078665018,
0.1589290202,
0.2303394377,
0.0017492558,
0.220485881,
0.3283803761,
0.5975957513,
-0.4611637592,
0.3557095528,
-0.4274705052,
-0.4794462919,
-0.6643736362,
-0.1300758421,
0.7294882536,
0.5663487315,
-0.309761256,
0.0326439366,
0.4799485207,
0.5698230267,
-0.6196260452,
0.3253799379,
-0.8187837005,
-0.289434433,
0.0580697469,
-0.4349112511,
-0.6882894039,
0.1268272102,
0.2600343227,
-0.8232742548,
0.2260858715,
-0.0210187454,
0.2830810547,
0.2217121422,
-0.3828130364,
-0.2304154485,
-0.8865798712,
0.8165290952,
-0.4799839556,
0.2473511249,
0.3439593315,
0.3800661266,
-0.3923249245,
-0.341190964,
-0.4497991204,
0.0334677808,
0.3034776449,
0.2368534356,
-0.2267677933,
-0.0934736356,
-0.0362066217,
-0.1933076829,
-0.5982685685,
0.2814199924,
-0.2075572908,
-0.1562852561,
0.3876099586,
0.0342186652,
0.3378804326,
0.2242497653,
-0.4270445704,
-0.0177863967,
-0.8834072948,
0.0309772622,
0.0338220745,
0.6091449261,
0.0862394869,
0.1389410496,
0.1303437352,
0.6911058426,
0.2385826409,
-0.1286122799,
-0.0378998853,
-0.027285831,
-0.3225637078,
-0.1057544574,
0.4964741766,
0.2061571926,
0.5146204233,
-0.0926479176,
-0.0240276959,
-0.1281050742,
0.4142386019,
-0.5716223717,
-0.1543565243,
0.1344214082,
-0.2788548172,
0.3562886119,
-0.2312495112,
-0.7728658915,
-0.3130586445,
-0.4009871185,
0.6412346363,
-0.5042902231,
-0.1207843348,
0.3666702509,
0.0228343513,
0.1847875416,
0.6094992161,
-1.1823503971,
0.3597878516,
0.5376977921,
0.7162114978,
-0.4030769765,
-0.4665105045,
-0.8304124475,
0.3143325448,
-0.1344531029,
0.6784620881,
-0.6333222985,
-0.4631601572,
0.0594329983,
0.158507213,
-0.5890876651,
-0.622351408,
0.253372252,
-0.8591635823,
0.2137058079,
-0.1201735735,
-0.3264790773,
-0.3701972067,
0.0859192312,
-0.7437593937,
0.5502462387,
0.0649564639,
-0.2427873313,
0.502712369,
-0.4867708981,
-0.3950784802,
-0.1418160945,
-0.1474384367,
-0.3974618316,
0.1276839674,
0.4951932728,
0.5719714761,
-0.3863552511,
0.2493609339,
-0.3573295176,
-0.0988904089,
0.046773795,
-0.3683575094,
0.5269489884,
-0.0341043174,
0.0574203096,
0.1902836412,
-0.5658369064,
-0.2056524754,
0.093785271,
-0.1978530437,
-0.7237495184,
-0.108057335,
-0.2549367547,
0.2617184222,
0.0802612156,
0.0799473077,
0.5437802076,
0.1799882948,
0.3219513893,
0.9488654137,
0.2804882228,
0.624341011,
-0.2353167087,
0.8032628894,
0.2301031351,
0.260981977,
-0.1769664586,
-0.5759906173,
-0.43385005,
-0.4820536375,
0.2506100833,
0.5976505876,
-0.6739125252,
0.5008113384,
-0.0093587739,
-0.0837334618,
-0.360514462,
0.2916798294,
0.1722605228,
0.4719683528,
0.6058111191,
-0.5698010921,
-0.3815895915,
-0.7291327119,
-0.2068605572,
-0.1614568233,
0.1166219711,
0.1978284568,
0.3828796148,
-0.3560726643,
0.9216312766,
-0.378798455,
-0.7695707083,
-0.2974458933,
-0.0502046235,
0.1799495071,
0.3976553977,
0.5842751265,
-0.7193917632,
-0.4924828708,
-0.2129340321,
-0.4100537896,
-0.2381519824,
-0.5628267527,
-0.0485836305,
0.2236207128,
0.2939221561,
-0.6761303544,
0.0856427029,
0.7098556757,
-0.20752801,
0.6580375433,
-0.4460090995,
0.2140869349,
-1.2075086832,
0.1412744224,
-0.0541823693,
-0.042006664,
-0.7611991763,
-0.4029679298,
0.1730213761,
0.1440188587,
-0.0590175763,
0.6366282105,
-0.7566308975,
0.0363195278,
-0.3305660486,
0.1481584013,
0.2852785885,
0.532345593,
-0.1232694611,
1.0940920115,
0.7975504994,
-0.9476906657,
-0.0947036594,
0.5993008018,
-0.0378642417,
0.3847973347,
-0.2287738472,
0.1120279282,
-0.230735749,
0.401997149,
-1.0093874931,
-0.1367752105,
0.1825911999,
-0.1317680627,
0.4620300829,
-0.3187040389,
-0.125385955,
-0.1400053501,
-0.0619386062,
0.3964097202,
0.377175957,
-0.5850512981,
0.9314834476,
0.3675185144,
-0.3843072951,
-0.7193837762,
-0.4831952751,
0.1326833963,
-0.4036090374,
-0.4637117684,
0.4814446568,
-0.2726449072,
0.0980665609,
-0.1653038859,
-0.268418014,
-0.2639934123,
0.2584774792,
0.1735859215,
0.3506485522,
-0.2094078809,
0.2143210322,
0.2518923581,
-0.0767448023,
-0.1114659384,
-0.3995720446,
0.5143562555,
0.1269123107,
-0.4162296951,
-0.4576158226,
0.4916293025,
0.6584628224,
-0.4011603296,
0.7127300501,
0.4201480448,
-0.259916693,
-0.7474416494,
-0.42667225,
-0.3059433401,
-0.4181020558,
0.3480986357,
-0.523679018,
-1.1055600643,
0.7836976647,
-0.4421655238,
-0.0435095727,
0.3389098942,
0.5070570707,
0.3481447697,
0.7852362394,
0.7796352506,
-0.2859558761,
0.4551683664,
-0.0778461546,
0.361131072,
-0.9132691622,
-0.249333784,
-0.3240675032,
0.0113700069,
-0.0566708557,
-0.6770917773,
0.3920930028,
0.5248907804,
-0.0079325829,
0.2127060592,
-0.1420318335,
0.3689226806,
0.3963063955,
-0.0493844673,
0.3927052617,
0.1019074395,
0.0083183022,
0.0269496981,
-0.8810375333,
-0.4207268059,
0.8937744498,
0.3320882618,
0.9356623888,
0.2719357014,
0.6889412999,
0.4553493559,
0.2044513226,
-0.7890560031,
0.4676000178,
-0.2614841163,
-0.35733217,
-0.3843707144,
-0.1966513991,
-0.8884576559,
0.2952424884,
-0.0897140428,
-0.5185732841,
0.2951907218,
0.3538365364,
-0.8078695536,
0.0125545859,
-0.8472495079,
0.9198492765,
-0.032256715,
-0.2552720308,
-0.3496557474,
-0.3947127163,
0.3550311923,
-0.5538757443,
0.0990228504,
-0.0242830403,
0.030571375,
0.4785856009,
0.2218239605,
1.2487254143,
-0.4598041475,
-0.2681686878,
0.4004666209,
0.0675259158,
0.5692396164,
0.0968075916,
-0.0556375496,
0.000242831,
-0.2551236153,
-0.2093691677,
-0.6925709248,
0.688278079,
-0.7100495696,
-0.9445915222,
-0.1786270142,
-0.4769984782,
-0.7010653019,
0.2292368263,
-0.2514931262,
0.4296113849,
-0.4845740199,
-0.0617237762,
0.7912096381,
-0.395581305,
0.3819538951,
0.613350153,
-0.0277383458,
-0.3631637692,
0.6343526244,
-0.045737531,
0.5409947038,
0.2983933389,
0.0357063971,
-0.4600634575,
-0.6541116834,
-0.6291659474,
0.219729647,
-0.6937729716,
-0.3684970737,
-0.628608942,
0.0035281957,
-0.6685101986,
-0.0450844541,
-0.0472505502,
-0.2456069887,
-0.6202365756,
0.1336711198,
0.3719718754,
0.5391462445,
-0.0712652951,
0.2921595871,
-0.9632104039,
0.3808311522,
0.5496609807,
0.2557368577,
0.0740161464,
-0.7698071003,
-0.2778456509,
-0.2408588976,
-0.1664126366,
-0.6126015186,
0.4063130915,
0.6471783519,
0.8614759445,
0.2088111788,
0.0143041648,
0.8616489768,
-0.9212363958,
0.7120841146,
0.1932294071,
-0.8354764581,
0.3212804496,
-0.3212271631,
0.2509859204,
0.3615033627,
0.4448117316,
-0.5108932257,
-0.1011820659,
-0.1735519767,
-0.6302928329,
0.6908075809,
-0.3698550761,
0.1519805044,
-0.1022467539,
0.4087727964,
0.3407820165,
-0.1119611189,
-0.3289557397,
-0.0491874702,
-0.1466466337,
-0.0354756564,
0.0000357773,
-0.2998200357,
-0.3401775062,
0.098036468,
0.7453565598,
-0.6124361753,
0.1536649466,
0.3421047032,
-0.2817902267,
-0.0872356668,
0.448656857,
0.7764807343,
0.8202072382,
0.0920251608,
0.0169187244,
0.348003298,
-0.411845237,
0.2434644401,
-0.0564098395,
0.2549190521,
-0.3593508601,
0.3842346668,
0.733792603,
0.0134908948,
-0.4211134613,
0.3879399896,
-0.0575935356,
-0.1489123404,
-0.0616375171,
0.2337439358,
0.0032784529,
0.4089572132,
0.6806129813,
0.2420209944,
-0.0756996647,
-0.4754630029,
0.4406888783,
0.2937133014,
-0.0432790779,
-0.4196787775,
0.6332717538,
0.1686550379,
0.0361173078,
0.1744485199,
0.1785893589,
-0.3921408355,
0.4343199134,
0.9811264277,
1.1826645136,
-0.72090137,
0.3804801404,
0.2126109898,
0.1178849488,
-0.3608531952,
0.1644634008,
0.2964227498,
-0.8365262747,
-0.7051300406,
-0.4290264547,
-0.2685714662,
0.2281081378,
-0.6773920059,
-0.0273885261,
-0.5612139702,
-0.1524719745,
-0.2173906118,
-0.2423606813,
-0.4531109035,
0.2322854698,
-0.0364189371,
1.0106406212,
-0.932035625,
1.0574430227,
0.4358742535,
-0.2457693964,
-0.6479145288,
0.1239997894,
0.02728815,
-0.8627983928,
0.554299593,
0.0921405405,
-0.3311257064,
0.0657480061,
-0.1948138922,
-0.6565580964,
1.2175915241,
0.40793401,
-0.5642009377,
0.1114729866,
-0.0611400418,
0.494535327,
-0.7661547065,
-0.4073846638,
0.4885555804,
0.3126066923,
-0.1177977398,
-0.9434012175,
0.2921871841,
0.1603081226,
0.0064227777,
-0.1296745241,
-0.7020489573,
0.7232816219,
-0.2737463713,
-0.2222606987,
-0.0409019738,
0.6294035316,
0.3529653251,
-0.0046998034,
0.7478117347,
0.1156093627,
0.8838912249,
0.3355254531,
0.6484466791,
-0.2707073689,
0.078078188,
1.1321463585,
-0.6258886456,
0.6579415202,
0.477080524,
0.2027096003,
0.4660327435,
0.364231497,
0.1951108873,
0.7123997808,
-0.0114413481,
-0.5553603172,
-0.5927782059,
0.0331155024,
-0.1785420626,
0.4975456297,
0.4750440419,
-0.1825623959,
-0.2541299462,
0.1085847169,
-0.2093543261,
0.0501642413,
-0.2505137622,
0.678144753,
0.2995575368,
-0.9141272902,
0.590686202,
-0.0432795286,
0.239781186,
-0.8639995456,
-0.3244786859,
-0.2114007622,
0.2905925214,
0.0989565104,
-0.4736934006,
0.140596658,
-0.2437573075,
-0.5611981153,
-0.448625505,
0.8416027427,
-0.6103205085,
0.1504196674,
0.5600423813,
0.6544441581,
-0.2753084004,
-0.1616228223,
-0.7141260505,
0.1232524887,
-0.059935037,
-0.0711555183,
0.467024982,
0.7181747556,
-0.4773652256,
0.7505547404,
0.5846914649,
-0.0607087538,
-0.0032777966,
0.5314255953,
0.9684633613,
-0.6132672429,
-0.4176659584,
-0.6874573231,
0.4988659322,
0.1402608156,
-0.2617465556,
0.8021537066,
0.2634296119,
0.4988540709,
-0.4839459062,
1.0208371878,
0.1736862659,
0.2467091382,
-0.7817922235,
0.5708810687,
-0.4148949087,
0.2989243865,
-0.0213728119,
-0.8743255138,
-0.6279293299,
0.4449427426,
-0.2495032102,
0.1988193989,
0.5740126371,
0.8140650988,
-0.1720766127,
-0.3072795868,
0.4336533546,
0.1505037695,
0.5673301816,
0.7162213922,
0.6339198351,
-0.224205777,
0.2617651224,
0.5212118626,
-0.5955556631,
-0.3034476042,
-0.9016274214,
-1.0318012238,
-0.6419057846,
-0.2270078361,
-0.2702658772,
0.0256553385,
0.9049987793,
0.7217302322,
-0.9788127542,
-0.058299493,
0.2159506977,
-0.0680007413,
-0.4864040911,
-0.1552262753,
0.3862937987,
-0.6092258692,
-0.6011753678,
0.8243988156,
0.4742175639,
-0.0070189061,
-0.3430663645,
-0.080380477,
-0.2253676504,
0.1946895421,
0.6850351095,
0.4135037959,
-0.6297766566,
-0.4590373039,
-0.0064621894,
-0.0552969798,
-0.0999483913,
0.9976269603,
-0.6192345619,
0.4439377487,
0.2616861463,
0.9049227238,
0.1187483519,
0.0931034088,
0.9096115232,
-0.7187696099,
-0.1632276326,
0.0237412006,
0.2701203525,
0.2619358599,
-0.3797310293,
0.2556885183,
0.2174444497,
-0.6456454396,
-0.4796145856,
0.2867771089,
-1.2182124853,
-0.4303863943,
1.1782777309,
-0.2954443097,
-0.2052401155,
-0.3951990604,
-0.3410889804,
0.1216811314,
-0.3724502921,
0.9977935553,
0.6307811737,
-0.1084994599,
-0.040603634,
-0.4457600713,
0.6922289729,
0.4233260155,
-0.7437418699,
0.5871576071,
0.6395296454,
0.4759094119,
-0.0108817816,
0.7966691256,
0.0716506839,
0.1142201722,
-0.2939824462,
-0.0208256096,
-0.0493954234,
-0.9639367461,
-0.7530221343,
0.0129484227,
0.1183599457,
-0.2529469132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02745v1
|
CURATRON: Complete Robust Preference Data for Robust Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-05T07:58:12 | 2024-03-05T07:58:12 |
Son The Nguyen, Niranjan Uma Naresh, Theja Tulabandhula
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper addresses the challenges of aligning large language models (LLMs)
with human values via preference learning (PL), with a focus on the issues of
incomplete and corrupted data in preference datasets. We propose a novel method
for robustly and completely recalibrating values within these datasets to
enhance LLMs resilience against the issues. In particular, we devise a
guaranteed polynomial time ranking algorithm that robustifies several existing
models, such as the classic Bradley--Terry--Luce (BTL) (Bradley and Terry,
1952) model and certain generalizations of it. To the best of our knowledge,
our present work is the first to propose an algorithm that provably recovers an
{\epsilon}-optimal ranking with high probability while allowing as large as
O(n) perturbed pairwise comparison results per model response. Furthermore, we
show robust recovery results in the partially observed setting. Our experiments
confirm that our algorithms handle adversarial noise and unobserved comparisons
well in both general and LLM preference dataset settings. This work contributes
to the development and scaling of more reliable and ethically aligned AI models
by equipping the dataset curation pipeline with the ability to handle missing
and maliciously manipulated inputs.
|
[
0.002929013,
-0.6215279698,
0.4388227165,
-0.2720595598,
0.0383648053,
0.3507556021,
-0.5873996615,
-0.0311528631,
0.0079765301,
0.6376193762,
-0.1847889721,
-0.319994241,
-0.5108110905,
-0.0820067078,
-0.1154497415,
1.186645031,
0.342752099,
0.0505160168,
-0.1117652506,
-0.2727749348,
-0.1307862848,
-0.761338532,
-0.6887794137,
-0.2901738882,
0.3299570978,
0.4332392514,
1.1352548599,
0.7769048214,
0.4743317068,
0.3105129302,
-0.1437945068,
0.3884961903,
-0.7172700763,
0.3888067901,
-0.1408279985,
-0.1652417481,
-0.6759402752,
0.0303100832,
0.6414086223,
0.7957164645,
-0.2904699743,
0.0756559521,
0.2432607412,
0.6334474683,
-0.6473608613,
-0.0705192015,
-0.8511142731,
0.0781653374,
-0.2819249332,
-0.1323365122,
-0.5960143209,
-0.6130633354,
0.039506156,
-0.3797964752,
-0.0023585684,
0.2632713616,
0.8493825197,
0.3894370496,
-0.3267524242,
0.0984169841,
-0.6920667887,
1.0930451155,
-0.6967244148,
0.287679553,
0.4928435683,
0.2110588849,
-0.357385546,
-0.3004546165,
-0.3311860263,
-0.3806100488,
0.1278875172,
0.0831956342,
-0.1660008579,
0.0174839627,
0.154724434,
0.4553228021,
-0.6144568324,
0.2910498083,
0.024203172,
-0.5188710093,
0.4490065277,
0.2827504575,
0.1588856131,
0.0458412357,
-0.1009814814,
-0.2596357167,
-0.6147417426,
0.2696079314,
0.7282387614,
0.5783012509,
-0.10402482,
0.5653147101,
-0.13453269,
0.8055189252,
0.4587101936,
-0.1715353727,
0.4330562055,
-0.355086118,
-0.2843879759,
0.0907630697,
0.8798483014,
0.0960304812,
0.2504581213,
-0.373757571,
-0.0433901176,
0.0896239281,
0.3945297003,
-0.3890762031,
-0.4424205124,
0.3227657676,
-0.207789138,
-0.7420502305,
0.0335900001,
-0.6770393252,
-0.4949164391,
-0.3582866192,
0.1838987321,
-0.1008947864,
-0.2538892031,
0.1571705639,
0.4498008192,
0.1843850464,
0.2297697514,
-1.2459405661,
0.1815694571,
0.8136664033,
0.5422749519,
-0.4109393954,
0.0172495618,
-0.9010331631,
-0.0534072034,
-0.2659305036,
0.4498127997,
-0.5168095231,
-0.1555763334,
-0.0863584206,
0.0886414126,
0.2636294961,
-0.5688514113,
0.9659854174,
-0.5848636031,
0.128513813,
-0.2106171548,
-0.3389029503,
0.1088146046,
0.5544463396,
-0.601898849,
0.984839201,
0.1316857636,
-0.937805593,
0.0987224057,
-0.0919850022,
-0.2166741639,
-0.2988275588,
-0.0895629451,
-0.8725097179,
-0.165271908,
0.2445341945,
0.2340199202,
-0.1781542301,
0.4590186179,
-0.8775521517,
-0.0428255685,
0.2707798481,
-0.6407234073,
1.1110540628,
0.0945124254,
-0.2524339855,
0.4429737031,
-0.5328435898,
0.1445857435,
0.0695003793,
-0.2644881904,
-0.2935514748,
-0.0267132409,
-0.1378955543,
0.038567353,
0.656506896,
-0.6492475867,
0.2571666837,
-0.4519841969,
0.5635726452,
1.15578866,
-0.3935451508,
0.7094420195,
-0.4384969771,
0.465893209,
-0.0754747689,
0.3536474407,
0.2995223999,
-0.1035956517,
-0.7072618008,
-0.2026039511,
0.3139781654,
0.6281847954,
-0.298122853,
0.6564475894,
-0.4446114302,
-0.3744599521,
-0.5961423516,
0.2453178614,
0.329633832,
0.8944914937,
0.1969966441,
-0.1781796366,
-0.5060380697,
-1.07158494,
0.2212011367,
-0.3176094592,
-0.0480288714,
0.4472488761,
-0.0420214981,
-0.1629231274,
0.7464952469,
-0.3528236449,
-0.0752070993,
-0.1236540899,
-0.4218769372,
0.4179750681,
0.4401864409,
0.3826641142,
-0.7779743671,
-0.2401646823,
0.1511053145,
-0.584007144,
-0.0262071472,
0.3128409684,
-0.5143821239,
0.2687018812,
0.1015639529,
-0.1360934973,
0.0891535506,
0.6817494035,
0.0226852763,
0.4598716497,
-0.2619143724,
0.2840715945,
-1.2811894417,
0.2625858188,
-0.1117208004,
-0.5551649332,
-0.6344875097,
-0.2011823654,
0.0273149218,
0.1124799252,
-0.3278003037,
0.4156079888,
0.0547969118,
-0.0426863357,
-0.2233380675,
0.2287845761,
-0.0693250671,
0.4706037343,
0.0679977462,
0.6942047477,
0.3779270649,
-0.3176327646,
0.3674374819,
0.4973416328,
0.0725883618,
0.6220830083,
-0.5898427367,
0.3713757396,
-0.0517089143,
-0.1079781801,
-0.9428933859,
-0.2725591063,
0.2695792913,
-0.5109957457,
0.2691242993,
-0.2638442218,
-0.1943053603,
0.100446783,
-0.4317363799,
0.5690914392,
0.3102178574,
-0.5414322019,
0.3805193603,
0.8594404459,
-0.2317460477,
-0.9905090332,
-0.1688094437,
-0.0994158983,
-0.2876731753,
-0.5167860389,
0.3133910894,
-0.2205737978,
-0.3706429601,
-0.0576788709,
0.0346941538,
0.1040410027,
0.3012741804,
0.4279443026,
0.7824781537,
0.0793038681,
-0.2907921672,
-0.1619553119,
-0.2586570978,
-0.2569077909,
-0.1790784448,
0.5088137388,
-0.2283257991,
-0.1380815953,
-0.126374498,
0.0833564028,
0.6819437146,
-0.1461088657,
0.3184828758,
0.4437090456,
-0.4468785822,
0.0896949545,
-0.4347130656,
-0.0641116202,
-0.4399110973,
0.2192005813,
0.0938171223,
-1.1794641018,
0.4279506505,
0.3740744293,
0.2820248008,
0.2361678779,
0.7328009009,
0.1645687073,
1.152104497,
0.7104983926,
-0.8863687515,
0.4363397658,
0.1804811507,
0.2810529768,
-0.8323193192,
-0.0821094811,
-0.6513499022,
-0.2148303539,
-0.6123671532,
0.1428157538,
0.4445945024,
-0.2239756584,
-0.7213771939,
0.233912304,
-0.6229321957,
0.2833332419,
0.5703123808,
0.168697983,
0.2682601213,
0.2119341642,
-0.0571889505,
-0.1659132689,
-0.4089900553,
-0.5463326573,
1.2268556356,
0.0713879392,
0.8464345336,
0.3616145551,
0.4956727326,
0.4059730172,
0.2261800617,
-0.7343120575,
0.205864653,
-0.1964287013,
-0.4266959429,
-0.3907856643,
-0.5785633922,
-0.9345118403,
-0.0016294098,
-0.4211739302,
-0.7504472136,
-0.0858515576,
0.2006158233,
-0.7271665335,
0.2971434295,
-0.2254208028,
0.7386069298,
-0.4341944158,
-0.6770579219,
0.041197855,
-0.689502418,
0.4027657807,
-0.1324219257,
-0.0941406712,
-0.1445436031,
0.2598760426,
0.6576676965,
-0.295820713,
0.5281451941,
0.1428900659,
0.109758459,
-0.3233552277,
0.1870106161,
0.4480889738,
0.2292965651,
-0.3877963126,
0.0649309307,
-0.0383156873,
-0.4701471925,
-0.4549612701,
0.9296347499,
-1.0684041977,
-0.7172411084,
-0.5498016477,
-0.6676902175,
-0.3822517395,
0.2436321974,
0.0215809979,
0.4529259205,
-0.0512105785,
0.1034676507,
0.7898532748,
-0.2015803158,
0.2773531079,
0.3792429268,
-0.0528680272,
-0.9033169746,
0.7879811525,
-0.1080406606,
0.2642457485,
0.2401098311,
0.0613525249,
-0.3304524422,
-0.5768170953,
-0.2966820002,
0.1774655133,
-0.276794374,
-0.4012779891,
-0.3026532829,
-0.3249975443,
-0.3541714549,
-0.352437675,
-0.4178746641,
-0.4172242582,
-0.2689332068,
-0.139998287,
0.2244691998,
0.4535206258,
0.0138984099,
-0.0691556707,
-0.5328863859,
0.0736389309,
0.166593954,
0.1749137193,
-0.1422691494,
-0.8386166096,
-0.0835444853,
0.133033976,
-0.4081044197,
-0.3554075956,
0.6002624035,
-0.0531440899,
0.5194738507,
0.4864810407,
0.3493043482,
0.5809651613,
-0.3368538618,
0.6427493095,
-0.1837700009,
-0.7393021584,
0.4290557802,
-0.3675180376,
0.0546423681,
0.8415868282,
0.2032940984,
-0.392451793,
-0.3664436936,
-0.670384407,
-0.803620398,
0.5535601974,
0.0875305533,
0.0355938412,
0.1339421272,
0.481015414,
0.1201095283,
0.1810678989,
-0.4721256793,
-0.2963386178,
-0.0403562374,
-0.5503920913,
-0.1249226555,
-0.2259043753,
-0.3253048062,
-0.0428885072,
0.8582108021,
-0.1765945405,
-0.0625016242,
-0.0653925166,
0.0432740487,
-0.0432653688,
0.303801924,
0.5763581991,
0.4958675802,
-0.5205552578,
0.3533282578,
0.0294896904,
-0.4345946014,
0.3008143306,
0.0746752843,
-0.2890002131,
-0.4915573895,
-0.0094751101,
0.4745862782,
0.206737861,
-0.5964329243,
0.5146169066,
-0.1942787915,
0.1853543371,
-0.6396769285,
-0.1098361909,
-0.2979989946,
0.1016433239,
0.1668021232,
0.305996865,
-0.0362240672,
-0.294917047,
0.3874309063,
0.7708154321,
-0.5687136054,
-0.3911613524,
0.9478162527,
-0.0131063275,
-0.1740477532,
0.8112717867,
-0.0630300641,
-0.5128286481,
0.346097976,
0.3715569377,
0.6194686294,
-0.0936665088,
0.1669560373,
0.3581721187,
0.1127934009,
-0.3416943252,
0.0765715614,
0.0426066257,
-1.107332468,
-0.1302755028,
-0.5498094559,
-0.6816160083,
0.0714886561,
-0.7755864263,
0.1509583145,
-0.7576466203,
-0.452372998,
-0.0862600505,
0.2344786823,
-0.2947411537,
-0.2088186592,
0.12711519,
0.4100394547,
-0.7728124261,
1.0231928825,
0.3923410773,
-0.2218780816,
-0.7979140282,
-0.2408090234,
0.3645710349,
-0.6808055639,
0.2619971037,
-0.2076515108,
-0.2581222355,
0.0754239783,
-0.4825485647,
-0.9391912222,
0.9673356414,
0.8954111338,
-0.4324734807,
0.1420532018,
-0.0423514917,
0.3907031715,
-0.3260955811,
0.2107619643,
0.5223073363,
0.358256042,
-0.150429666,
-0.9659506083,
0.0105809141,
-0.1954622418,
-0.2751362026,
0.3791562021,
-0.7800720334,
0.5714443326,
-0.1352806538,
0.0963831842,
0.2965543866,
0.4725325108,
0.3239252865,
0.0139263188,
0.4859599769,
0.6927636862,
1.065636754,
-0.1328859329,
0.7902605534,
-0.4434715211,
0.5184232593,
1.0525856018,
-0.4631246924,
0.8474076986,
0.3002516031,
-0.1644598246,
0.0295388233,
0.736712873,
0.054799322,
0.407910049,
-0.208057642,
-0.2267246097,
-0.7832642198,
-0.4381249547,
-0.1497043073,
0.2984045148,
0.0377124771,
-0.2592993081,
0.0634330884,
-0.3505768478,
0.2520388663,
0.2615483403,
-0.2494323105,
0.513472259,
-0.1070995703,
-0.5869386792,
0.5269509554,
-0.2214780748,
0.6505987048,
-0.400780648,
0.1550486088,
-0.3217725456,
0.2311906517,
-0.3558193743,
-0.7075158358,
0.0900046378,
-0.2998996377,
-0.4429797232,
-0.0239491705,
0.38096264,
-0.5848450065,
-0.5404441357,
0.0290995408,
0.2119191438,
-0.2222147286,
0.4153760672,
-0.5491759777,
0.303774178,
0.2058210522,
0.0374995135,
0.542863071,
-0.1575216353,
-0.2036143243,
0.704121232,
0.5915581584,
0.1356108934,
-0.28252092,
-0.1370224953,
0.6600033045,
-0.3576919138,
-0.1775265485,
-0.9825086594,
0.3338317275,
-0.2576729953,
-0.127946943,
0.7600263953,
0.66335392,
0.8230676055,
0.2632701993,
0.7784189582,
0.1526007056,
0.4258884788,
-0.3237353861,
0.6981707215,
-0.1957854927,
0.1994374245,
-0.2104643881,
-0.7472813129,
-0.5533444285,
0.5176286101,
-0.3804333508,
-0.1534634084,
0.2165603191,
1.0643564463,
-0.1286548972,
-0.2799752951,
0.4332226515,
0.1113104224,
0.4088139236,
0.7954529524,
0.446701616,
-0.1903659999,
0.377120018,
-0.2222052962,
-0.347353965,
-0.1059385836,
-0.7659914494,
-0.5773792863,
-0.6444339156,
-0.2767346799,
-0.7134816051,
0.0745103955,
1.2706342936,
0.5764344335,
-0.9709920883,
-0.1000073999,
0.4408788979,
0.3341683149,
-0.17961514,
-0.1699935049,
0.5797736049,
-0.1591727436,
-0.8515248895,
0.3212483227,
0.4851295054,
-0.1034270748,
-0.2777732611,
-0.265134424,
0.1255348474,
-0.0544966199,
0.3352137804,
0.5551627278,
-0.6420369148,
-0.6485563517,
0.2093471289,
-0.2546874583,
0.2608264983,
0.6059169769,
-0.6680846214,
0.5031372905,
0.3599724472,
0.9434344172,
-0.0683022961,
0.3227551877,
0.607876122,
-0.3696119189,
0.1092768982,
0.2184647173,
0.6257194877,
0.6017772555,
-0.4389551878,
0.4215206206,
0.0186942331,
-1.0337359905,
-0.9557388425,
0.3775011599,
-1.4872429371,
0.293071121,
1.0998511314,
-0.1867161244,
-0.2825162113,
-0.2257861048,
-0.30587551,
0.1904603094,
-0.5924057961,
1.1238921881,
0.5718964338,
-0.1013268009,
0.059444692,
-0.2899440527,
0.4625756741,
0.452122122,
-0.471552521,
0.2478550375,
0.6220190525,
0.5748208761,
-0.0124714971,
0.457865119,
-0.3773076534,
0.0852489844,
-0.584235847,
-0.1809095889,
-0.2041606605,
0.0197840035,
-0.5880202055,
0.4043853879,
0.4682036936,
0.1043950245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02742v1
|
Towards Training A Chinese Large Language Model for Anesthesiology
| 2024-03-05T07:53:49 | 2024-03-05T07:53:49 |
Zhonghai Wang, Jie Jiang, Yibing Zhan, Bohao Zhou, Yanhong Li, Chong Zhang, Liang Ding, Hua Jin, Jun Peng, Xu Lin, Weifeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical large language models (LLMs) have gained popularity recently due to
their significant practical utility. However, most existing research focuses on
general medicine, and there is a need for in-depth study of LLMs in specific
fields like anesthesiology. To fill the gap, we introduce Hypnos, a Chinese
Anesthesia model built upon existing LLMs, e.g., Llama. Hypnos' contributions
have three aspects: 1) The data, such as utilizing Self-Instruct, acquired from
current LLMs likely includes inaccuracies. Hypnos implements a cross-filtering
strategy to improve the data quality. This strategy involves using one LLM to
assess the quality of the generated data from another LLM and filtering out the
data with low quality. 2) Hypnos employs a general-to-specific training
strategy that starts by fine-tuning LLMs using the general medicine data and
subsequently improving the fine-tuned LLMs using data specifically from
Anesthesiology. The general medical data supplement the medical expertise in
Anesthesiology and enhance the effectiveness of Hypnos' generation. 3) We
introduce a standardized benchmark for evaluating medical LLM in
Anesthesiology. Our benchmark includes both publicly available instances from
the Internet and privately obtained cases from the Hospital. Hypnos outperforms
other medical LLMs in anesthesiology in metrics, GPT-4, and human evaluation on
the benchmark dataset.
|
[
0.1744458377,
-0.1460887343,
0.7365215421,
-0.0682005435,
-0.5283296704,
0.0364995562,
-0.4837587178,
-0.4535516202,
0.5491763353,
0.647085309,
-0.3189897239,
-0.5729618669,
-0.2455554456,
0.1246594712,
-0.3433781564,
0.7327705622,
-0.0593989305,
0.6471126676,
0.161125809,
0.0837369636,
0.014373132,
-0.7049671412,
-0.7310894132,
-0.4824112356,
0.5102748871,
0.1307344586,
0.8500734568,
1.0640273094,
0.3598535061,
0.202246353,
0.1004887447,
-0.067806311,
-0.2408231944,
-0.1573009193,
0.0045266273,
-0.432162255,
-0.2235841751,
-0.1694749892,
0.6628829837,
0.8410131335,
-0.619859755,
-0.1029702947,
-0.1316587925,
0.2711498439,
-0.366466552,
-0.3010537624,
-0.6154125929,
0.4712039828,
-0.2212006599,
-0.2502759099,
-0.1112201214,
-0.4896137118,
0.3358437121,
-0.8028046489,
0.2745068371,
0.2074684054,
0.8782839179,
0.2969747484,
-0.2800207436,
-0.4171621799,
-0.418762356,
0.5046164989,
-1.0001670122,
0.6063261032,
0.1767846942,
0.3267868459,
-0.037089359,
-0.7353158593,
-0.4194533825,
-0.6652480364,
0.0682111681,
0.0080654118,
0.5110854506,
0.2962130308,
0.1220873967,
0.613226831,
-0.4816054702,
0.5761336088,
-0.4852227867,
-0.2959159315,
0.5672061443,
0.3553406298,
0.3802115023,
-0.2828429043,
-0.6111204028,
0.1826507449,
-1.0221936703,
-0.2795330584,
0.4113899767,
0.0216304529,
-0.2432028353,
0.3796727359,
-0.1641449928,
0.6661333442,
-0.2061808854,
-0.3808049858,
0.3404962718,
-0.258730799,
-0.3724415898,
0.1343059689,
0.7548655272,
0.0869809538,
0.3282384574,
-0.264652133,
-0.2345068306,
-0.0064501665,
0.5302888751,
-0.8726409078,
-0.3801218569,
0.2029686421,
-0.4364205003,
-0.2855910063,
-0.086901933,
-0.6098267436,
-0.916684866,
-0.668394506,
0.2631574869,
-0.1439062059,
-0.2999138236,
0.3845312595,
0.1232314855,
0.1615904421,
0.5422555804,
-0.9639109373,
0.5155320764,
0.6336855292,
0.8748409748,
-0.4331355393,
-0.406607002,
-0.1205703318,
0.0297037438,
-0.6583341956,
0.4946748912,
-0.2294676453,
-0.2079062462,
0.2671202123,
0.0479585305,
0.013145851,
-0.7208877802,
0.3352139592,
-0.0044885171,
0.124789685,
-0.1440358162,
-0.5901759267,
-0.0122666722,
0.2945654392,
-0.5781056881,
0.4584986269,
0.0065220436,
-0.4799257517,
0.3344552219,
-0.4120151997,
-0.4095049798,
-0.008322902,
-0.5104572177,
-0.5167069435,
0.0585108958,
0.2102977186,
0.2971733809,
-0.7392413616,
0.2973379195,
-0.3202364445,
-0.5409564376,
0.11769142,
-0.0756755769,
0.8243602514,
0.1616690308,
0.2170072943,
0.2305811048,
-0.6571214199,
-0.3053921759,
0.1617435962,
-0.4343086183,
-0.2504947782,
-0.1360864639,
-0.2460125685,
0.0196685065,
0.1556584239,
-0.7549029589,
0.3211099803,
-0.5651132464,
0.7349660397,
0.3115241528,
0.3822274804,
0.2998208404,
-0.4297452271,
0.2385588288,
-0.2906804681,
0.5605701804,
0.0199288502,
-0.2000669241,
-0.7562034726,
-0.1717515588,
0.3201968074,
0.3684986234,
-0.7146185637,
0.3200721443,
0.0754187182,
-0.6296818256,
-0.7979064584,
0.2058772445,
0.0462815166,
0.8335083127,
0.2078490555,
-0.3482396901,
-0.539890945,
-0.5219535828,
-0.0034700397,
-0.1943902969,
-0.2561504841,
-0.0333565399,
0.3590893447,
-0.3187182844,
0.3199411035,
-0.3699346781,
-0.4273113906,
0.0350812562,
-0.2586925328,
0.3250976801,
0.3961933851,
0.3225167096,
-0.3093619943,
-0.3052581847,
0.2272035182,
-0.9271286726,
0.0401228704,
-0.1418089718,
-0.1246014759,
0.0306546185,
0.4567303061,
-0.369898051,
0.2590883672,
0.5580608845,
0.1120351776,
0.5931390524,
-0.3715907633,
0.0566629805,
-0.9606179595,
0.0815292299,
-0.0948031992,
0.2318367958,
-0.9494671822,
-0.0202240795,
0.2914178073,
-0.359151274,
-0.5456139445,
0.5361210108,
-0.5059137344,
-0.1358361095,
-0.3138900101,
-0.0919946656,
0.0037433973,
0.443648845,
0.3784907162,
0.2456647605,
0.8361674547,
-0.6919411421,
0.6471256614,
0.0771599561,
-0.3156674206,
0.4075110257,
-0.8523716927,
0.1472281963,
0.1857234836,
0.0625434592,
-0.6977335215,
-0.3924178779,
0.1286535859,
-0.2407498658,
0.2969883978,
-0.2551540136,
-0.459212184,
-0.6052263379,
-0.2378683835,
0.1347047091,
0.4035147429,
-0.862184763,
0.2077829689,
0.2676759958,
0.0855834857,
-0.4899114668,
-0.5172740817,
0.1730886996,
-0.1603349298,
-0.2521833181,
0.2686558366,
0.1589865983,
-0.0724482313,
0.0024434775,
-0.1929377168,
-0.2384250611,
0.1518164426,
0.0260825362,
0.2960630357,
-0.2592257261,
0.6061956286,
-0.003359112,
0.1076047495,
0.1020193025,
-0.5202714205,
0.5282865763,
0.3468024433,
-0.478392005,
-0.7895289063,
-0.2031805366,
0.3399476111,
-0.0821568817,
0.1505097002,
0.3769303262,
-0.719735086,
-0.1884047836,
-0.7184494734,
-0.3651793301,
-0.4124113321,
0.3413437605,
0.0273917001,
-0.5977322459,
0.4161368608,
-0.1090741828,
0.1163469777,
0.2156188935,
0.6577278376,
-0.0737849176,
0.5847774744,
0.3246847391,
-0.2870625257,
0.4453371465,
-0.1406687647,
-0.2375902832,
-0.7281966209,
-0.0562716946,
-0.5903676748,
0.1853984892,
-0.3986705244,
-0.2445095628,
0.5431104302,
-0.1546703726,
-0.4436302483,
0.1610140055,
-0.3924111724,
0.2368520796,
0.1285094917,
0.3562252522,
0.3165007234,
0.0553555079,
-0.0276341978,
0.2093833685,
-0.6638448238,
-0.2152228355,
1.2545902729,
0.6419997215,
1.1750438213,
-0.245790273,
0.8797397614,
0.0627046525,
0.2739613652,
-0.8172960281,
0.0753478855,
-0.1820789576,
-0.5172425508,
-0.5132796764,
-0.4687411487,
-1.0210510492,
0.4003221989,
-0.2401451021,
-0.3954890668,
0.0372255705,
0.1688243002,
-0.5420479774,
0.3295198977,
-0.4201035202,
0.660928905,
-0.447014004,
-0.2982012928,
-0.26518929,
-0.5371844769,
0.4053663611,
-0.2045179456,
-0.0290194824,
-0.1475739181,
-0.3368356228,
0.7776528597,
-0.525588572,
0.9285919666,
-0.25931409,
-0.2743029892,
0.1021121591,
-0.150892362,
0.2398153394,
0.2101025432,
-0.4458340108,
0.3466717601,
-0.1235438883,
-0.3909241557,
-0.5689920187,
0.7043325305,
-0.8491748571,
-0.5180784464,
-0.2950057089,
-0.1802869141,
-0.3433610499,
0.0435899459,
0.3126361072,
0.4643488526,
-0.1928836107,
-0.0202776175,
0.5482278466,
-0.3795514405,
0.1717974991,
0.5886718631,
0.1256050467,
-0.619674921,
0.4527120292,
0.229709208,
0.1010086909,
0.2556225061,
0.6339568496,
-0.49877581,
-0.6745872498,
-0.848754108,
0.5827972889,
-0.6365480423,
-0.0194169637,
-0.337438345,
-0.5829942822,
-0.3901511133,
0.0335288718,
-0.3849766254,
0.1028819829,
-0.2736038864,
-0.0216035601,
0.1727531254,
1.015158534,
0.2178395689,
0.5790519714,
-0.4229529798,
0.4415405095,
0.3150290549,
0.5463232398,
0.2079084367,
-0.649302423,
-0.5334079266,
-0.235765934,
0.0103043802,
-0.9749267101,
0.5344495773,
-0.0537433624,
0.8625517488,
0.4868810475,
-0.0947262496,
0.5628411174,
-0.4638362825,
0.6703933477,
0.5293868184,
-0.8279764056,
0.6549026966,
-0.0800160915,
0.1295199394,
0.5835023522,
0.4458923936,
-0.6049956679,
-0.2190928906,
-0.2332355976,
-0.5099859834,
0.4803868532,
-0.2768762708,
0.0905300826,
0.3559949398,
0.5938195586,
0.2015213817,
0.4477742314,
-0.6884921193,
0.1299594492,
-0.0842972323,
-0.1574606448,
-0.044986207,
0.0266022589,
-0.2292163074,
-0.274397552,
0.4840500951,
-0.2208943516,
0.0362009443,
0.3090028763,
-0.0479216799,
-0.1313715577,
0.0462408811,
0.493398875,
0.8007603288,
0.0311851632,
0.1328951567,
0.3811668456,
-0.6275143623,
0.1126796231,
-0.2096660584,
-0.1231831461,
0.0387484543,
0.3638356328,
0.8228493333,
-0.0195038002,
-0.2976079583,
0.3835508525,
0.0662714392,
-0.223565042,
-0.382557869,
0.0509097055,
-0.0478966907,
-0.1365177631,
0.1940317154,
-0.2967171669,
0.1920401007,
-0.4927931726,
0.1999129802,
0.0101168761,
-0.3361163437,
-0.2852996886,
0.4598549008,
0.3770020604,
-0.1709682643,
0.3568771183,
0.0324167907,
-0.5079638362,
0.6506857872,
0.4406470954,
0.6012513041,
-0.5515961051,
-0.1672852784,
0.7111572623,
0.3945943117,
-0.5129668713,
0.2823658288,
0.0422634371,
-0.4041028619,
-0.4813191593,
-0.4137664735,
-0.8907592893,
0.2397616953,
-0.5853175521,
0.5968744159,
-0.7969059348,
0.0223602131,
-0.238659516,
0.3063218296,
-0.5286832452,
0.3224603534,
0.1951154172,
0.7058336139,
-0.6846226454,
1.2156685591,
0.5094339848,
-0.2965398133,
-0.6453843713,
0.2568532228,
-0.1112617478,
-1.1557563543,
0.0421507321,
-0.0926856771,
0.3526783884,
-0.3367062807,
-0.3836686313,
-0.8406583667,
1.0151802301,
0.3666424155,
-0.8842129111,
-0.1871661097,
0.1045694202,
0.853548646,
-0.4737118185,
-0.0331810229,
0.513252914,
0.1278651059,
-0.0250838362,
-1.1386494637,
0.2568834722,
0.0346163325,
-0.0630567372,
-0.1131806821,
-0.586093843,
1.0095262527,
-0.4797872901,
-0.0407112241,
0.2236421853,
0.3157989979,
0.2186276317,
0.3087764084,
0.5408795476,
0.4290826023,
1.1131526232,
-0.0487062782,
1.0648146868,
-0.4365443289,
0.1459921449,
0.9393273592,
-0.6095986366,
0.7750016451,
0.3653759658,
0.0973954946,
0.4268766642,
0.7237257957,
-0.2778149843,
0.3394032419,
0.849989593,
-0.0797627196,
-0.2114736289,
-0.0921873227,
-0.6130869985,
0.4647336304,
0.4633094072,
-0.3426541388,
0.06192974,
0.1682897657,
0.1087125763,
0.0546320118,
-0.5261679888,
0.8121718168,
0.1995228976,
-0.6577312946,
0.8400595188,
-0.1130565926,
0.6032395363,
-0.7798331976,
0.1353414655,
-0.1698932946,
-0.0052540433,
-0.4309002459,
-0.4218713939,
0.0463231429,
-0.1907741129,
0.289045006,
0.2720089853,
0.5988954306,
-0.5089887977,
-0.1669901162,
0.3297260106,
0.336050719,
0.2482135743,
0.1098057106,
-0.3592208624,
0.0745926872,
-0.1827528179,
0.048419714,
0.2634889185,
0.4628297985,
-0.0434638672,
0.6092759967,
0.6412374973,
0.7268767357,
-0.1312962919,
0.5151569247,
0.7304980159,
-0.660302937,
-0.8035894632,
-0.6867716312,
-0.2051815391,
-0.1216746792,
-0.5588012934,
0.5258330107,
0.4160059094,
0.6912198663,
-0.0780475885,
0.8649194837,
0.5635910034,
0.5831790566,
-0.685451448,
0.8404385448,
-0.6775621772,
0.247256726,
0.2438936234,
-0.6074344516,
-0.382812947,
0.4773564935,
-0.1738572121,
-0.1421480775,
0.5585899353,
0.5708371401,
0.1867358983,
-0.0258126631,
0.5734773874,
0.0649693981,
0.0811532289,
0.5646945238,
1.1842604876,
-0.3178593814,
0.3103605509,
-0.3519327044,
0.0359399468,
-0.2353742272,
-0.578528583,
-0.9814785719,
-0.0369659327,
-0.3446011841,
-0.2914792597,
0.1847937107,
1.0671985149,
0.9972504973,
-0.7350522876,
-0.7307940722,
0.0698071495,
0.1365122199,
-0.1224189103,
-0.0466175638,
0.5368528962,
-0.4331296682,
-0.5438057184,
0.3524681628,
0.130532071,
0.2396264076,
-0.5387921929,
-0.4389243126,
0.2435783595,
-0.0617068335,
0.208955273,
0.2669630945,
-0.7680345178,
-0.065468207,
0.1547360122,
-0.4014932811,
0.1597096622,
0.950948894,
-0.3580444157,
0.371362865,
0.3573491573,
0.7636270523,
0.4795912802,
-0.3048858047,
0.3428911865,
-0.679471612,
0.0265625231,
0.2495800853,
0.659450829,
0.5397320986,
-0.4348973632,
0.7222980857,
0.2665780187,
-0.4817787707,
-0.946287334,
-0.1950556934,
-0.8053954244,
-0.2580730021,
1.4314609766,
-0.1324918419,
-0.2499887198,
-0.3008469939,
-0.2783166468,
0.3115922809,
-0.2287354618,
0.7769771814,
0.3438930213,
-0.0682898089,
0.1146006286,
-0.5737031698,
0.606733799,
0.2548308671,
-0.9985560775,
-0.0871979371,
0.1693120152,
0.496058166,
0.1176392585,
0.8055999875,
-0.1035616472,
0.4343253076,
0.0809281096,
0.5542637706,
-0.0569852963,
-0.464302063,
-0.614371419,
0.177219227,
0.2126825452,
-0.3089614809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02738v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02738v2
|
Causal Prompting: Debiasing Large Language Model Prompting based on Front-Door Adjustment
| 2024-03-05T07:47:34 | 2024-05-22T16:21:38 |
Congzhi Zhang, Linhai Zhang, Jialong Wu, Deyu Zhou, Yulan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the notable advancements of existing prompting methods, such as
In-Context Learning and Chain-of-Thought for Large Language Models (LLMs), they
still face challenges related to various biases. Traditional debiasing methods
primarily focus on the model training stage, including approaches based on data
augmentation and reweighting, yet they struggle with the complex biases
inherent in LLMs. To address such limitations, the causal relationship behind
the prompting methods is uncovered using a structural causal model, and a novel
causal prompting method based on front-door adjustment is proposed to
effectively mitigate LLMs biases. In specific, causal intervention is achieved
by designing the prompts without accessing the parameters and logits of LLMs.
The chain-of-thought generated by LLM is employed as the mediator variable and
the causal effect between input prompts and output answers is calculated
through front-door adjustment to mitigate model biases. Moreover, to accurately
represent the chain-of-thoughts and estimate the causal effects, contrastive
learning is used to fine-tune the encoder of chain-of-thought by aligning its
space with that of the LLM. Experimental results show that the proposed causal
prompting approach achieves excellent performance across seven natural language
processing datasets on both open-source and closed-source LLMs.
|
[
-0.3784945905,
-1.3429453373,
0.676789999,
0.4609567225,
-0.2510690093,
-0.3514793813,
-0.3599166572,
-0.0543957092,
-0.0411715731,
0.3178725541,
-0.8023327589,
-0.453202188,
-0.4648023546,
0.327834487,
-0.087382935,
0.7021268606,
0.1574229449,
0.3333958983,
-0.1918365359,
0.2077361643,
-0.9751943946,
-0.1316616982,
-1.012917757,
-0.5277708769,
0.8553665876,
0.2444912046,
0.5863161087,
0.2750372887,
0.0415694751,
0.2573072612,
-0.1794534922,
0.0441470519,
-0.4701915085,
0.2241498232,
-0.488232255,
-0.4157909751,
-0.1859233826,
-0.0810358897,
0.7196056843,
0.6689054966,
-0.0432483181,
0.2616842091,
0.3476869464,
0.7616317272,
-0.6718707085,
0.2383496761,
-0.6708437204,
-0.1617813855,
0.0868089646,
-0.4187286794,
-0.7174488306,
-0.6072853804,
0.0534332581,
-0.4004707336,
0.1183039024,
0.1087532565,
0.5080490112,
0.5369799137,
-0.4272496104,
-0.1971804649,
-0.5915324092,
0.6512712836,
-0.7181434631,
0.5273285508,
0.4491645396,
0.0644622445,
-0.4477556348,
-0.0154590933,
-0.4886930883,
-0.4724173844,
-0.0170831457,
-0.0259921104,
-0.4288136363,
-0.0249904804,
0.4234450161,
0.0101547148,
-0.4087244272,
0.4964124858,
-0.1427245587,
-0.0257362239,
0.2600964606,
0.1589746922,
0.2146676332,
0.089082025,
-0.3402739763,
-0.0590769574,
-1.1288993359,
0.0103991767,
0.4611364007,
0.4489332139,
-0.1159111485,
0.2925230861,
-0.3310353458,
0.952988565,
0.4787709713,
0.1810640693,
0.0524953417,
0.0565076247,
-0.3960607648,
0.218292132,
0.6514196992,
0.5543593168,
0.354809761,
0.0248163193,
-0.082844235,
0.1747214496,
0.1042043641,
-0.6768817306,
0.1044641361,
0.2197975218,
-0.2400936186,
-0.3904653788,
-0.1887979805,
-0.9137775898,
-0.6884531379,
-0.5309481025,
0.4624342322,
-0.022297997,
0.0293004122,
0.0883049592,
0.0341578498,
0.1655868739,
0.4094973803,
-0.8162682056,
0.1351594329,
0.4619426727,
0.7515813112,
0.1035884619,
-0.2473521978,
-0.8125027418,
0.2648454905,
-0.4289248884,
0.6725592017,
-0.4987778068,
-0.2328047901,
0.1206448451,
-0.1711624414,
0.0544519275,
-0.414042592,
0.4273418188,
-0.6976917982,
0.3202884197,
-0.5491164923,
-0.1660606712,
-0.1691837609,
0.4767923951,
-0.6511526108,
0.847591877,
-0.2497806251,
-0.9324680567,
0.3898149729,
-0.2969425321,
-0.3911010325,
-0.2902876437,
-0.2971577942,
-0.207921505,
0.2312673777,
0.7387401462,
0.3555139899,
-0.7998843789,
0.9086287022,
-0.3989813924,
-0.2184843719,
0.2174259126,
-0.6993376613,
0.9324621558,
0.0529550202,
-0.463696748,
0.4107610881,
-0.7386341691,
-0.4665588737,
0.0648946837,
-0.1378305554,
-0.5511730313,
0.0180846006,
-0.6785386801,
0.3948834836,
0.0874716938,
-0.396230787,
0.027282048,
-0.5243124366,
-0.049340751,
1.1005526781,
0.3050489724,
0.3356795609,
-0.2022033334,
0.4200294614,
0.1747736335,
0.2129096091,
-0.2099198699,
-0.3263370693,
-0.7535918355,
-0.07703989,
-0.0572264642,
0.5420386791,
-0.7301297188,
0.5597441196,
0.014584058,
-0.249533847,
-0.3472694159,
0.1633305997,
0.4172793031,
0.7847864628,
0.3047839999,
0.0165279787,
-0.3969305754,
-0.7504025102,
-0.3361993134,
-0.2491258979,
-0.0619821399,
0.0970656499,
0.2526778281,
-0.165760681,
0.8634708524,
-0.7702968717,
-0.1463149786,
-0.0012752878,
0.1236228272,
0.4960907996,
0.3984265327,
0.2758583128,
-0.3929187357,
-0.2896718979,
-0.2871329486,
-0.6245930195,
-0.5598032475,
-0.2359323502,
-0.1763391942,
0.0156516936,
0.7267153859,
-0.4074992537,
0.2855814993,
0.4602517486,
-0.2382829636,
0.6205402017,
-0.1854396462,
0.051375404,
-0.9128960967,
0.1144213527,
0.1255552769,
0.3289291263,
-0.5445160866,
-0.1280248165,
-0.0869671404,
-0.0342117064,
-0.3098733127,
0.7819339037,
-0.51973176,
0.3027424812,
-0.271590203,
0.363824904,
-0.0780582726,
0.5611100197,
-0.0353384428,
0.571998477,
0.667891264,
-0.8662126064,
0.2571045756,
0.3261511326,
-0.2309451997,
0.5443404317,
-0.5792664289,
0.0801742971,
-0.3687724769,
0.523479104,
-1.0481567383,
0.0477952808,
0.513903439,
-0.1480491757,
0.1505042166,
-0.0180331953,
-0.3978202343,
-0.4589303136,
-0.372091502,
0.2281031311,
0.2907482982,
-0.7680152655,
0.2595261037,
-0.0829267427,
-0.2420237958,
-0.5627438426,
-0.5087605715,
-0.0072511719,
-0.2170399576,
-0.3675584793,
-0.0016987439,
-0.1500732303,
-0.305120647,
-0.2279391736,
-0.0373023935,
0.2605048716,
0.072631672,
0.1605080515,
0.3847209513,
-0.0267203152,
0.2341763228,
0.3080976307,
-0.3057469428,
0.4626944661,
-0.3767240942,
0.503880918,
0.3486584425,
-0.4274667501,
-0.3983363509,
0.0663388893,
0.3841972947,
-0.064591445,
0.7503509521,
0.3125284612,
-0.2849452794,
-0.2192163914,
-0.7871232033,
-0.5890936852,
-0.4724000692,
0.0595808253,
-0.2104557455,
-0.8927894235,
0.3753649294,
-0.1253022701,
-0.085840933,
0.0782692507,
0.8975786567,
0.4730748832,
1.0704487562,
0.3283700347,
-0.4266053438,
0.7252253294,
0.3179104924,
0.3936350048,
-0.8347638249,
-0.2458586693,
-0.7346800566,
-0.2345712185,
-0.3939793408,
-0.392062366,
0.2027534097,
0.1079574376,
-0.4763409495,
-0.1355761588,
-0.2720502317,
0.3747069836,
0.5947490335,
0.2522101402,
0.3059304953,
-0.0842506886,
-0.5042963624,
0.0871060044,
-0.6116446257,
-0.2701494098,
0.6349981427,
0.2904913127,
1.1282287836,
-0.0214658305,
0.5507948995,
0.1055646688,
0.3166760206,
-0.6764423847,
0.5219663978,
0.311989814,
-0.5813887119,
-0.280965507,
-0.4535042048,
-0.8737439513,
0.2661489248,
-0.0804853588,
-0.8715689182,
0.5309348702,
0.3243280351,
-0.3895222545,
0.0713684186,
-0.4709079862,
0.5633803606,
-0.0075214286,
-0.6336125135,
-0.3193707764,
-0.5737217069,
0.458447516,
-0.030961575,
0.2202602476,
-0.0252960883,
0.28720662,
0.535602212,
-0.1929160804,
1.441514492,
-0.3824750781,
-0.6383775473,
0.258649081,
0.2907949388,
0.8921633363,
0.0802596807,
-0.1898515224,
0.0312670432,
-0.6247843504,
-0.0014486428,
-0.7319051027,
0.7624049187,
-0.3873960972,
-1.0930975676,
-0.1825544834,
-0.4021404684,
-0.4910034537,
0.1551547945,
0.1494861394,
0.5343226194,
-0.3099996746,
-0.0326402411,
0.6262806654,
-0.5576760173,
0.2705912888,
0.6389280558,
-0.2418351173,
-0.5396949649,
0.4821590483,
-0.2808552384,
0.3280360699,
0.6695702076,
0.7432259917,
-0.3493180275,
-0.389763236,
-0.3155402541,
0.2105264068,
-0.655915916,
-0.3177592754,
-0.5426938534,
0.1798697412,
-0.4709487557,
-0.1956512332,
0.0017919837,
-0.0313265696,
-0.22097902,
-0.2669184208,
0.3254123628,
0.61838305,
-0.0055995896,
0.3533061147,
-0.7489396334,
0.1888716817,
0.3946492672,
0.2443219423,
0.5277209282,
-0.4936782718,
-0.2558150887,
0.0448151864,
-0.2862667739,
-0.9225916862,
0.212367177,
-0.2763503492,
0.5176176429,
0.7568897605,
0.2249236256,
0.7115985155,
-0.688411057,
0.8063843846,
0.3305828869,
-1.0194522142,
0.7339516878,
-0.452455312,
0.5309319496,
0.4308958352,
0.3174381852,
-0.5855257511,
-0.6729572415,
-0.2780804038,
-0.6653713584,
0.578582108,
-0.2198167443,
0.0147552723,
-0.3352944255,
0.1384077966,
0.0481107719,
0.2802005708,
-0.6999286413,
-0.1402968615,
0.0890800953,
-0.1336314529,
-0.037555892,
-0.2872882783,
-0.1503523439,
-0.2950147688,
0.8672018647,
-0.2032170892,
0.1154184863,
0.2495445609,
-0.2566304505,
-0.3428346515,
0.5194197297,
0.7796678543,
0.6644575596,
-0.1102280766,
0.2072532922,
0.4529188275,
-0.1392089725,
0.1957410872,
-0.1859864444,
-0.4219491184,
-0.1936044246,
0.2519042492,
0.9978086352,
0.5033283234,
-0.3167374134,
0.3599593937,
0.1866863519,
0.1073062718,
0.1736110747,
-0.0257186126,
-0.0740688816,
0.309481442,
0.2056886852,
-0.2850201428,
0.0007657609,
-0.3457841575,
-0.0185607783,
0.437767446,
-0.5590059161,
-0.4502806365,
0.7254230976,
0.3140137494,
-0.1323765367,
0.5768185258,
0.0543272682,
-0.6074579954,
0.2311684638,
1.0107768774,
1.2204277515,
-0.5485675931,
0.1877193004,
0.6692667603,
0.3977226019,
-0.1190014854,
0.0378122777,
-0.0625263825,
-0.9059279561,
-0.6682674885,
-0.4458265603,
-0.3300452828,
0.2193330079,
-0.6943487525,
0.3455356359,
-0.4601196647,
-0.0724135116,
-0.4944022,
-0.1460273117,
-0.4706121087,
0.2676757872,
0.1901415437,
1.0435569286,
-1.0388854742,
0.760667026,
0.3851545155,
-0.4404657483,
-0.7780550122,
0.1707878113,
0.3370574713,
-0.7324641347,
0.9317898154,
0.0367826261,
-0.3691545129,
0.0879073665,
-0.5035099983,
-0.5653803349,
0.7592588663,
0.4434182942,
-0.7787306905,
-0.1149430349,
-0.1769062728,
0.3350647986,
-0.2290796191,
0.1122110263,
0.4604773223,
0.6832504272,
-0.0035899887,
-0.4582439363,
0.6482738256,
0.0100367824,
-0.1487382203,
0.2322632968,
-0.5554058552,
0.6289554834,
-0.2522809803,
-0.1180724055,
-0.2553834021,
0.4752521515,
0.4785233438,
0.1737974137,
0.6704221964,
0.3847313821,
0.7926570773,
0.1085390076,
0.8804931045,
-0.2674557865,
0.0454392582,
1.3429092169,
-0.5297129154,
0.6242203712,
0.7625832558,
0.0371921957,
0.6830578446,
0.4456623495,
0.0649981946,
0.5214893818,
0.2964953184,
-0.3409169912,
-0.0595840141,
-0.1485878229,
-0.2733446658,
0.0887802839,
0.3555958867,
-0.2873031199,
-0.4666972458,
-0.0546941273,
0.0206865016,
-0.0137928426,
-0.2522719204,
0.8509518504,
0.2872303426,
-0.9429998994,
0.4631810188,
-0.1268513799,
0.5190858245,
-0.6241576672,
0.0440859012,
-0.1913008839,
0.069540374,
-0.0238434188,
-0.3353838921,
0.0383489653,
0.0042912653,
-0.2611875832,
-0.3932288587,
0.6263087988,
-0.4922502339,
-0.1800787896,
0.4947576225,
0.490392983,
-0.3749109507,
-0.136756137,
-0.5838352442,
0.1815522164,
-0.0144055346,
-0.2725164294,
0.1300623864,
0.4532618523,
-0.3685985804,
0.5013599992,
0.8578132987,
0.1993807405,
-0.2285320461,
0.5789341927,
0.9087786078,
-0.8799334168,
-0.7066844106,
-1.2812718153,
0.3164192736,
0.0315477923,
-0.1510345042,
0.9271056652,
0.1819263995,
0.5874654651,
-0.2399446964,
0.4584754109,
0.2601449788,
0.2174648494,
-0.7544161677,
0.5527335405,
-0.2040459365,
0.4179025888,
-0.5882795453,
-0.9300816059,
-0.4300004542,
0.4720077813,
-0.6968662739,
-0.1396334618,
0.9102811813,
1.0833421946,
0.3369908333,
0.1993355602,
0.3016093969,
0.4820735753,
0.3799622357,
0.3541044891,
1.0472691059,
-0.0163031816,
0.002617579,
0.1994282752,
-0.3828164041,
-0.276920259,
-1.0634748936,
-1.1067049503,
-0.4222997725,
-0.2676488161,
-0.3733507395,
0.0811485127,
1.1275767088,
0.1969999969,
-0.8352155685,
-0.2076678425,
-0.2869421542,
0.501873672,
-0.2870303392,
-0.2159919292,
0.3483274281,
-0.5655217767,
-0.6277301908,
0.5295954943,
0.232410714,
-0.1062590331,
-0.3662752211,
-0.0177474637,
-0.3776679039,
0.271091193,
0.6916284561,
-0.0491152108,
-0.7265737057,
-0.3405662179,
-0.3276393712,
0.0939069986,
-0.0204310808,
1.0349651575,
-0.9045754671,
0.4484220743,
0.6202024221,
0.5854279995,
0.129516691,
0.0079388767,
0.9439757466,
-0.8222378492,
0.2719270289,
-0.1079873368,
0.2232138515,
0.2523869574,
-0.6196346879,
0.2011704296,
0.0032840499,
-0.3577317894,
-0.7524548173,
0.4171738029,
-0.580709517,
-0.2575066686,
1.1129486561,
0.1963565201,
-0.284966737,
-0.1149039865,
-0.4448577464,
0.4000566304,
-0.5034314394,
0.8566083312,
0.7667980194,
0.1585947871,
0.0594828464,
-0.3253466785,
0.3916367292,
0.3820646703,
-0.758368969,
0.4484621584,
0.7553355098,
0.1362250149,
-0.0831801891,
0.5749291182,
-0.0328922719,
0.094279781,
-0.048864264,
-0.0510153808,
-0.103395313,
-0.4511713088,
-0.7664228082,
-0.1234378889,
0.1410390139,
-0.0074710352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02727v1
|
HARGPT: Are LLMs Zero-Shot Human Activity Recognizers?
| 2024-03-05T07:34:51 | 2024-03-05T07:34:51 |
Sijie Ji, Xinzhe Zheng, Chenshu Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
There is an ongoing debate regarding the potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) as foundational models seamlessly integrated with Cyber-Physical Systems
(CPS) for interpreting the physical world. In this paper, we carry out a case
study to answer the following question: Are LLMs capable of zero-shot human
activity recognition (HAR). Our study, HARGPT, presents an affirmative answer
by demonstrating that LLMs can comprehend raw IMU data and perform HAR tasks in
a zero-shot manner, with only appropriate prompts. HARGPT inputs raw IMU data
into LLMs and utilizes the role-play and think step-by-step strategies for
prompting. We benchmark HARGPT on GPT4 using two public datasets of different
inter-class similarities and compare various baselines both based on
traditional machine learning and state-of-the-art deep classification models.
Remarkably, LLMs successfully recognize human activities from raw IMU data and
consistently outperform all the baselines on both datasets. Our findings
indicate that by effective prompting, LLMs can interpret raw IMU data based on
their knowledge base, possessing a promising potential to analyze raw sensor
data of the physical world effectively.
|
[
-0.0608177632,
-0.804484129,
0.8492122293,
-0.143579632,
-0.2658579648,
0.1722823381,
-0.0914954394,
-0.826407373,
-0.036736533,
0.3292426169,
-0.4680973589,
-0.2819375098,
-0.243347913,
0.0338110588,
-0.2921029031,
0.5696783066,
-0.1484192014,
-0.0153434081,
-0.0896755159,
-0.0385051668,
-0.5674310923,
-0.7262294292,
-0.5300553441,
-0.9155702591,
0.4198457599,
0.2939046919,
0.346612066,
0.3609892726,
0.3043572605,
0.2424351424,
-0.0065074298,
0.0114855478,
-0.3780266643,
0.2135183066,
-0.0031215821,
-0.1769184917,
-0.5068898797,
-0.1162204966,
0.5465858579,
0.5065165162,
0.0410034359,
0.2317855954,
0.3312995732,
0.2457483113,
-0.5099745393,
0.3082238734,
-0.3929337263,
0.2254960239,
-0.0750031322,
-0.3763808906,
-0.2821590304,
0.5308251381,
0.1375633329,
-0.2864658237,
0.2802408636,
0.0760340989,
0.6232188344,
0.1037697941,
-0.411599189,
0.1517286897,
-1.002532959,
0.6650593877,
-0.4594359994,
0.4169461429,
0.3017981946,
0.2070673555,
-0.1763213277,
-0.1997301579,
-0.5763241053,
-0.1715698987,
-0.065153785,
0.142607376,
-0.1957871616,
0.0910364762,
0.4438489377,
0.3365201354,
-0.6260012388,
0.3275205493,
-0.2440568209,
-0.1963590682,
0.5667058229,
0.3605991006,
0.0014639725,
-0.3822437227,
-0.4370586276,
0.0802923962,
-0.80619663,
0.2446454614,
0.0679427162,
0.2177488357,
-0.414152354,
0.8414392471,
-0.3681500554,
0.7572072148,
-0.1959474534,
-0.1248566061,
-0.0140278935,
-0.1741453856,
-0.5304744244,
0.0949183181,
0.6716194749,
0.1210338473,
0.3697059453,
-0.3344992995,
-0.3235113323,
-0.0976301879,
0.405331105,
-0.6473053694,
-0.0743778795,
0.2159345001,
-0.256670773,
-0.24312976,
0.0086902864,
-0.5590644479,
-0.5770918727,
-0.4580493867,
0.6136245131,
-0.1156690866,
-0.2392118573,
0.5685108304,
0.1153616756,
0.6386803389,
0.5956776738,
-0.6587180495,
0.378546834,
0.7846928835,
0.8929957151,
-0.1525290161,
-0.3154781461,
-0.3862978518,
0.1877335459,
-0.0907868519,
0.8529674411,
-0.1268866658,
-0.4482288659,
-0.1137422696,
-0.0570486076,
-0.1478746682,
-0.3931458592,
0.3625016809,
-0.5751382709,
0.1011123806,
-0.2326993942,
-0.4012479782,
-0.0865594372,
0.8099000454,
-0.3249991834,
1.0227458477,
0.134565115,
-0.5179435015,
0.39667961,
-0.9596341252,
-0.4987951219,
0.355627656,
-0.3735907972,
-0.3880522847,
0.1732595563,
0.1611363143,
0.6999819279,
-0.0753564313,
0.0675162971,
-0.3242048025,
-0.4356167316,
0.5488622189,
-0.6642377973,
0.4824153483,
0.1364389658,
-0.3800162971,
0.0832283422,
-0.3688941002,
-0.1261781603,
0.2136548012,
-0.4387961924,
0.0700959489,
0.1537479162,
-0.2672346234,
0.342177093,
0.0883874521,
-0.8502240181,
0.2564848661,
-0.0231485087,
0.2446834594,
0.7744640708,
-0.1445873529,
0.2480458468,
-0.3400291502,
0.6460242271,
-0.1664048433,
-0.0600517541,
-0.3921679258,
-0.6645359993,
-0.4087589383,
-0.5937663317,
-0.0564591959,
0.6871238351,
-0.5017117858,
0.5496428609,
-0.4314909279,
-0.2562523782,
-0.1199333593,
-0.1723503619,
0.2499943823,
0.9081016183,
0.3248794675,
-0.2392867804,
-0.4952236414,
-0.269197464,
-0.2150813192,
-0.4935633242,
-0.3192151189,
0.6389475465,
0.4648681581,
-0.0770901144,
0.8771193027,
-0.3181489706,
-0.1867840737,
-0.3854496181,
0.3895463347,
0.2425757647,
0.0830271468,
0.3501429856,
-0.4598893523,
-0.2930102348,
-0.0290583149,
-1.1326528788,
-0.1227508336,
-0.1359716952,
0.0780167133,
-0.048733186,
0.4147598147,
-0.7215192914,
0.7449601293,
0.2304579169,
-0.5035506487,
0.6172180772,
-0.2516301572,
0.2353771031,
-0.6673443913,
0.2619902492,
-0.0723851547,
-0.463509649,
-0.8826899529,
-0.1868479103,
-0.0647213906,
-0.3377262354,
-0.7822043896,
0.8302801847,
-0.567363739,
-0.5209653378,
-0.4934130907,
-0.4760834575,
-0.0907241553,
0.3654231429,
0.3645240366,
0.5957868099,
0.7110959291,
-0.8032827973,
0.3358313143,
0.1409660876,
-0.439176172,
0.5109577775,
-0.636454165,
0.0522620194,
-0.0440669172,
0.2963313758,
-0.8763465881,
-0.6784025431,
0.3017289639,
-0.3723674119,
0.2951158285,
-0.3946357071,
-0.7672609091,
-0.5369689465,
-0.2213603109,
0.4404409528,
0.6403746009,
-0.5160944462,
0.4222574532,
0.338749975,
0.1513187736,
-0.4707464874,
-0.577347219,
0.215269208,
-0.3032545447,
-0.2599303126,
0.129421398,
-0.0432553776,
-0.0545059778,
-0.2700468302,
-0.1740645617,
-0.1554267555,
0.2830189764,
0.4898495674,
0.6194084883,
-0.1218809709,
-0.1661699116,
-0.6486824155,
-0.1736352444,
0.0676223487,
-0.0565070026,
0.7789576054,
-0.1187292114,
-0.7874881625,
-0.6140496135,
-0.0638772845,
0.6102829576,
0.0807446614,
0.3212346435,
0.5405967832,
-0.5663380623,
0.4641046226,
-0.2632710636,
-0.1617949605,
-0.472851187,
-0.0325614177,
-0.1194650456,
-1.0655919313,
0.2686383426,
0.0039450959,
0.1210925132,
0.0677994862,
0.6573652625,
-0.4456653893,
0.9596030712,
0.4481540024,
-0.1962949038,
0.5382941365,
-0.2288939655,
0.1555511951,
-0.9184414148,
-0.1589673311,
-0.1816763282,
-0.6744593978,
-0.3648506105,
-0.3938602507,
0.6341071725,
-0.1229246929,
-0.3929071128,
0.2183629423,
-0.3585281372,
0.5194476247,
0.2115717679,
0.1876469851,
0.1327647418,
0.2376962602,
0.1704886556,
-0.0248588044,
-0.5501421094,
-0.6059485674,
0.9185247421,
0.3977093101,
0.9785688519,
0.030368235,
0.7913423181,
0.2593553662,
0.4136362076,
-1.2176790237,
0.7141652703,
0.2922233641,
-0.7103369236,
-0.3649225533,
-0.0611476973,
-1.3279060125,
0.334110111,
-0.2697987258,
-1.0562375784,
0.1469582468,
0.2840775251,
-0.4820665717,
0.7088677883,
-0.4485786259,
0.6973664761,
-0.4687735736,
-0.4636030197,
-0.0976003855,
-0.3838754296,
0.3428278863,
0.0869852528,
0.3251575828,
-0.3665928841,
0.0393014923,
0.549709022,
0.0620270558,
1.14103508,
-0.2928646207,
-0.0004238159,
0.4297452867,
0.2273381501,
0.3497649431,
-0.0556261465,
-0.0625469312,
0.3804424405,
-0.3226948082,
-0.3822416663,
-0.2589877546,
0.4897483885,
-0.6162785888,
-0.5133984685,
-0.7750968933,
-0.5233582258,
-0.0749749765,
0.2637541592,
0.0207505152,
0.3625566959,
-0.3926918507,
0.1835713238,
0.5164399147,
0.1441500634,
0.5538654327,
0.770899117,
-0.109744668,
0.0578667894,
0.8380450606,
-0.0102386186,
-0.0589734763,
0.544588387,
0.2671866715,
-0.2485194951,
-0.4559313953,
-0.4734893143,
0.3407199979,
-0.2081079483,
-0.257828325,
-0.6903243661,
-0.2383195162,
-0.3661387265,
-0.368281126,
0.0193800926,
-0.1571946591,
-0.4828499854,
-0.0555504598,
0.1275161803,
0.8794700503,
-0.2341274321,
0.4118479788,
-0.9228007197,
0.6474163532,
0.3467567265,
0.2773700655,
-0.1165139079,
-0.5158923864,
-0.2518377602,
0.016261993,
-0.4230358303,
-0.7461205125,
0.3255418539,
-0.0210452005,
0.5353914499,
0.5087372661,
-0.0212919507,
0.6742478013,
-0.5307182074,
1.0094188452,
0.2394030839,
-0.6976999044,
0.3696779311,
-0.3967835009,
0.5322325826,
0.2491479516,
0.4512577951,
-0.5596847534,
0.1976616681,
-0.6903827786,
-0.490749687,
0.8054289222,
-0.0888271332,
0.0700513273,
0.166418463,
0.337939173,
-0.1415917426,
0.1117749065,
-0.8080404997,
0.2720245421,
-0.0784013644,
0.1113932878,
-0.0327124782,
-0.0682019219,
-0.1171617284,
-0.2643065453,
0.2072413564,
-0.2964130044,
0.5966809988,
0.2598949373,
-0.1843362153,
-0.3635005951,
0.5226994753,
0.2605661452,
0.4641665518,
-0.2502477467,
0.3026109636,
0.3980673254,
-0.4626481831,
0.365781039,
-0.2604200542,
-0.0892665684,
-0.1718003452,
0.5814732313,
0.577647686,
0.2923116684,
-0.7825562954,
0.6077523828,
-0.0658968315,
-0.3012788892,
-0.2616602182,
0.2608269453,
-0.2548540235,
0.1061060578,
0.1633719355,
-0.1317839324,
-0.0041714101,
-0.6923271418,
0.0145181958,
0.5900246501,
-0.5745987296,
-0.7303583622,
0.4917039871,
-0.0087151611,
-0.3959388435,
0.544932127,
-0.1697748452,
-0.5098591447,
0.3958548307,
0.423178494,
0.8399115801,
-0.306483686,
0.1046996862,
0.3553139865,
0.1810939759,
-0.0099790329,
0.725383997,
-0.4702391028,
-0.8791852593,
-0.6210274696,
-0.4811044037,
-0.7357735038,
0.4564580619,
-0.5948907137,
0.3193182051,
-0.4041180909,
0.0236248728,
-0.0977843702,
-0.1585973054,
-0.9573339224,
0.1643412262,
0.4661607146,
0.6019533277,
-0.8566349745,
0.8342788815,
0.8522464037,
0.081792675,
-0.3445304334,
0.0223869681,
0.2650221884,
-1.0441285372,
0.6260457039,
0.3197545111,
-0.0862784535,
-0.0691512674,
-0.5887057781,
-0.509548068,
1.3141330481,
0.2262389213,
-0.3318035305,
-0.0313894786,
0.422424674,
0.6157416105,
-0.1515958905,
0.1042345986,
0.2993891537,
0.5174999833,
0.1154517159,
-0.9222972393,
-0.0744258612,
0.1614034623,
-0.6183679104,
0.1562992334,
-0.3865687549,
0.656755805,
-0.3480974734,
-0.3383279443,
-0.1981360167,
0.4741382003,
0.4853077233,
0.6255089045,
0.6945152283,
0.454464227,
0.5487294793,
0.0164264422,
1.1469759941,
-0.1235065311,
0.0981462747,
0.8911497593,
-0.8096336126,
0.9151813388,
0.2733679712,
-0.236242041,
0.2615363896,
0.5260075927,
0.1255458444,
0.2770672739,
0.0789876729,
-0.7287556529,
-0.454572916,
-0.1640087515,
0.0455791354,
0.6629112959,
0.5201445222,
0.1243516281,
-0.4420058131,
-0.0814439058,
-0.0535185896,
-0.4939011931,
-0.2132884711,
0.8403103948,
-0.0013252756,
-0.6560121775,
0.5031670332,
-0.1168239862,
0.6492981315,
-0.6551215649,
-0.055973649,
0.343380779,
-0.0341988653,
-0.2786867023,
-1.173140645,
0.2923927605,
0.2955526412,
0.041215308,
-0.6047573686,
1.1685574055,
-0.0000011244,
-0.1159371659,
0.1609548181,
0.8004322648,
0.5193460584,
-0.2272815257,
-0.6017584801,
-0.214510411,
-0.2624173164,
-0.1331715137,
0.6319986582,
0.2654516995,
-0.1923200637,
0.5297673941,
0.8359994292,
0.0103278998,
-0.1949619055,
-0.1280199885,
0.6958127618,
-0.82575804,
-0.4054587185,
-0.870464921,
0.4746780396,
0.0441085473,
-0.056200128,
0.6218608618,
0.614123106,
0.6585460305,
0.0871787146,
0.8588234782,
0.0182690341,
0.5653430223,
-0.3549660742,
0.4652906954,
-0.2588445246,
0.1865236908,
0.190927729,
-0.5890112519,
-0.2947075367,
0.6106841564,
-0.314019978,
-0.1390117407,
0.3519323766,
0.6571583152,
-0.5752193928,
-0.0443082713,
0.6864759326,
0.0297234729,
0.5437790751,
0.2107440978,
1.0707719326,
-0.1624058336,
0.2146660984,
-0.0492265299,
-0.3640188277,
-0.4362931252,
-1.0817803144,
-0.8379676938,
-0.1633461863,
-0.2526445985,
-0.0844385251,
-0.1915529817,
0.8399180174,
0.7995188832,
-0.6520857215,
-0.5643143058,
-0.0583912991,
-0.0607116222,
-0.1168263927,
-0.2271807045,
0.0117573431,
-0.0357923992,
-0.3823553026,
0.8705098033,
0.4356788695,
0.4339328706,
-0.3579578698,
-0.259798646,
-0.1222369969,
0.0022938466,
0.9299877882,
0.8017296195,
-0.6748505831,
-0.5230790973,
0.3031353652,
0.1154816002,
0.1838598549,
1.2113932371,
-0.9661689997,
0.3284074664,
0.6831473112,
0.5408118367,
0.6426772475,
-0.058876507,
0.2214932442,
-0.858129859,
0.0885445997,
0.2936024964,
0.6308758259,
0.4032417238,
-0.4213740826,
0.6876241565,
0.258975327,
-0.8311218023,
-0.766463697,
0.2849053442,
-1.0777351856,
-0.1265399456,
1.2213155031,
-0.213123709,
-0.2710190713,
-0.4811534882,
-0.2509214282,
0.1004839912,
-0.2228066921,
0.7450492978,
0.5912508965,
-0.8559220433,
-0.2107124925,
-0.7470706105,
0.0267349873,
0.1488228589,
-0.8873673081,
0.2906167805,
0.5568626523,
0.085500598,
0.0380711332,
0.8897920251,
0.0161125921,
0.2227332294,
-0.5261753798,
0.0110918283,
-0.1698267609,
-0.3057375252,
-0.5570709705,
-0.1299013197,
0.028587129,
-0.0974542126
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.